id sid tid token lemma pos 47429882s7j 1 1 this this DET 47429882s7j 1 2 dissertation dissertation NOUN 47429882s7j 1 3 attempts attempt VERB 47429882s7j 1 4 to to PART 47429882s7j 1 5 address address VERB 47429882s7j 1 6 a a DET 47429882s7j 1 7 perennial perennial ADJ 47429882s7j 1 8 problem problem NOUN 47429882s7j 1 9 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 1 10 i.e. i.e. X 47429882s7j 1 11 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 1 12 the the DET 47429882s7j 1 13 original original ADJ 47429882s7j 1 14 understanding understanding NOUN 47429882s7j 1 15 of of ADP 47429882s7j 1 16 the the DET 47429882s7j 1 17 religious religious ADJ 47429882s7j 1 18 liberty liberty NOUN 47429882s7j 1 19 provisions provision NOUN 47429882s7j 1 20 . . PUNCT 47429882s7j 2 1 to to PART 47429882s7j 2 2 do do VERB 47429882s7j 2 3 so so ADV 47429882s7j 2 4 the the DET 47429882s7j 2 5 author author NOUN 47429882s7j 2 6 employs employ VERB 47429882s7j 2 7 traditional traditional ADJ 47429882s7j 2 8 primary primary ADJ 47429882s7j 2 9 source source NOUN 47429882s7j 2 10 materials material NOUN 47429882s7j 2 11 as as ADV 47429882s7j 2 12 well well ADV 47429882s7j 2 13 as as ADP 47429882s7j 2 14 cases case NOUN 47429882s7j 2 15 interpreting interpret VERB 47429882s7j 2 16 the the DET 47429882s7j 2 17 provisions provision NOUN 47429882s7j 2 18 from from ADP 47429882s7j 2 19 1776 1776 NUM 47429882s7j 2 20 to to ADP 47429882s7j 2 21 1900 1900 NUM 47429882s7j 2 22 . . PUNCT 47429882s7j 3 1 the the DET 47429882s7j 3 2 thesis thesis NOUN 47429882s7j 3 3 of of ADP 47429882s7j 3 4 this this DET 47429882s7j 3 5 study study NOUN 47429882s7j 3 6 is be AUX 47429882s7j 3 7 that that SCONJ 47429882s7j 3 8 the the DET 47429882s7j 3 9 religious religious ADJ 47429882s7j 3 10 freedom freedom NOUN 47429882s7j 3 11 provisions provision NOUN 47429882s7j 3 12 were be AUX 47429882s7j 3 13 understood understand VERB 47429882s7j 3 14 to to PART 47429882s7j 3 15 embody embody VERB 47429882s7j 3 16 a a DET 47429882s7j 3 17 consensus consensus NOUN 47429882s7j 3 18 in in ADP 47429882s7j 3 19 favor favor NOUN 47429882s7j 3 20 of of ADP 47429882s7j 3 21 liberty liberty NOUN 47429882s7j 3 22 of of ADP 47429882s7j 3 23 conscience conscience NOUN 47429882s7j 3 24 which which PRON 47429882s7j 3 25 held hold VERB 47429882s7j 3 26 that that PRON 47429882s7j 3 27 : : PUNCT 47429882s7j 3 28 ( ( PUNCT 47429882s7j 3 29 1 1 X 47429882s7j 3 30 ) ) PUNCT 47429882s7j 3 31 civil civil ADJ 47429882s7j 3 32 rulers ruler NOUN 47429882s7j 3 33 had have VERB 47429882s7j 3 34 no no DET 47429882s7j 3 35 authority authority NOUN 47429882s7j 3 36 to to PART 47429882s7j 3 37 define define VERB 47429882s7j 3 38 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 3 39 compel compel ADJ 47429882s7j 3 40 observance observance NOUN 47429882s7j 3 41 or or CCONJ 47429882s7j 3 42 punish punish VERB 47429882s7j 3 43 the the DET 47429882s7j 3 44 breach breach NOUN 47429882s7j 3 45 of of ADP 47429882s7j 3 46 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 3 47 religious religious ADJ 47429882s7j 3 48 duties duty NOUN 47429882s7j 3 49 ; ; PUNCT 47429882s7j 3 50 and and CCONJ 47429882s7j 3 51 ( ( PUNCT 47429882s7j 3 52 2 2 X 47429882s7j 3 53 ) ) PUNCT 47429882s7j 3 54 the the DET 47429882s7j 3 55 individual individual NOUN 47429882s7j 3 56 must must AUX 47429882s7j 3 57 be be AUX 47429882s7j 3 58 left leave VERB 47429882s7j 3 59 free free ADJ 47429882s7j 3 60 to to PART 47429882s7j 3 61 define define VERB 47429882s7j 3 62 and and CCONJ 47429882s7j 3 63 observe observe VERB 47429882s7j 3 64 his his PRON 47429882s7j 3 65 religious religious ADJ 47429882s7j 3 66 duties duty NOUN 47429882s7j 3 67 so so ADV 47429882s7j 3 68 long long ADV 47429882s7j 3 69 as as SCONJ 47429882s7j 3 70 he he PRON 47429882s7j 3 71 did do AUX 47429882s7j 3 72 not not PART 47429882s7j 3 73 threaten threaten VERB 47429882s7j 3 74 the the DET 47429882s7j 3 75 civil civil ADJ 47429882s7j 3 76 order order NOUN 47429882s7j 3 77 . . PUNCT 47429882s7j 4 1 the the DET 47429882s7j 4 2 author author NOUN 47429882s7j 4 3 argues argue VERB 47429882s7j 4 4 that that SCONJ 47429882s7j 4 5 the the DET 47429882s7j 4 6 americans americans PROPN 47429882s7j 4 7 who who PRON 47429882s7j 4 8 ratified ratify VERB 47429882s7j 4 9 the the DET 47429882s7j 4 10 first first ADJ 47429882s7j 4 11 amendment amendment NOUN 47429882s7j 4 12 conceived conceive VERB 47429882s7j 4 13 of of ADP 47429882s7j 4 14 liberty liberty NOUN 47429882s7j 4 15 of of ADP 47429882s7j 4 16 conscience conscience NOUN 47429882s7j 4 17 and and CCONJ 47429882s7j 4 18 understood understand VERB 47429882s7j 4 19 the the DET 47429882s7j 4 20 religious religious ADJ 47429882s7j 4 21 liberty liberty NOUN 47429882s7j 4 22 provisions provision NOUN 47429882s7j 4 23 primarily primarily ADV 47429882s7j 4 24 in in ADP 47429882s7j 4 25 terms term NOUN 47429882s7j 4 26 of of ADP 47429882s7j 4 27 a a DET 47429882s7j 4 28 set set NOUN 47429882s7j 4 29 of of ADP 47429882s7j 4 30 beliefs belief NOUN 47429882s7j 4 31 and and CCONJ 47429882s7j 4 32 concepts concept NOUN 47429882s7j 4 33 expressed express VERB 47429882s7j 4 34 in in ADP 47429882s7j 4 35 terms term NOUN 47429882s7j 4 36 of of ADP 47429882s7j 4 37 a a DET 47429882s7j 4 38 religious religious ADJ 47429882s7j 4 39 strain strain NOUN 47429882s7j 4 40 of of ADP 47429882s7j 4 41 discourse discourse NOUN 47429882s7j 4 42 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 4 43 and and CCONJ 47429882s7j 4 44 based base VERB 47429882s7j 4 45 on on ADP 47429882s7j 4 46 a a DET 47429882s7j 4 47 new new ADJ 47429882s7j 4 48 understanding understanding NOUN 47429882s7j 4 49 of of ADP 47429882s7j 4 50 scripture scripture NOUN 47429882s7j 4 51 that that PRON 47429882s7j 4 52 had have AUX 47429882s7j 4 53 been be AUX 47429882s7j 4 54 worked work VERB 47429882s7j 4 55 out out ADP 47429882s7j 4 56 over over ADP 47429882s7j 4 57 hundreds hundred NOUN 47429882s7j 4 58 of of ADP 47429882s7j 4 59 years year NOUN 47429882s7j 4 60 prior prior ADV 47429882s7j 4 61 to to ADP 47429882s7j 4 62 the the DET 47429882s7j 4 63 revolution revolution NOUN 47429882s7j 4 64 . . PUNCT 47429882s7j 5 1 at at ADP 47429882s7j 5 2 the the DET 47429882s7j 5 3 same same ADJ 47429882s7j 5 4 time time NOUN 47429882s7j 5 5 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 5 6 however however ADV 47429882s7j 5 7 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 5 8 this this DET 47429882s7j 5 9 religious religious ADJ 47429882s7j 5 10 understanding understanding NOUN 47429882s7j 5 11 of of ADP 47429882s7j 5 12 liberty liberty NOUN 47429882s7j 5 13 of of ADP 47429882s7j 5 14 conscience conscience NOUN 47429882s7j 5 15 overlapped overlap VERB 47429882s7j 5 16 with with ADP 47429882s7j 5 17 a a DET 47429882s7j 5 18 more more ADV 47429882s7j 5 19 rationalistic rationalistic ADJ 47429882s7j 5 20 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 5 21 natural natural ADJ 47429882s7j 5 22 law law NOUN 47429882s7j 5 23 and and CCONJ 47429882s7j 5 24 natural natural ADJ 47429882s7j 5 25 rights right NOUN 47429882s7j 5 26 notion notion NOUN 47429882s7j 5 27 of of ADP 47429882s7j 5 28 liberty liberty NOUN 47429882s7j 5 29 of of ADP 47429882s7j 5 30 conscience conscience NOUN 47429882s7j 5 31 . . PUNCT 47429882s7j 6 1 the the DET 47429882s7j 6 2 convergence convergence NOUN 47429882s7j 6 3 of of ADP 47429882s7j 6 4 these these DET 47429882s7j 6 5 two two NUM 47429882s7j 6 6 strains strain NOUN 47429882s7j 6 7 of of ADP 47429882s7j 6 8 discourse discourse NOUN 47429882s7j 6 9 around around ADP 47429882s7j 6 10 the the DET 47429882s7j 6 11 shared share VERB 47429882s7j 6 12 concept concept NOUN 47429882s7j 6 13 of of ADP 47429882s7j 6 14 liberty liberty NOUN 47429882s7j 6 15 of of ADP 47429882s7j 6 16 conscience conscience NOUN 47429882s7j 6 17 made make VERB 47429882s7j 6 18 possible possible ADJ 47429882s7j 6 19 the the DET 47429882s7j 6 20 consensus consensus NOUN 47429882s7j 6 21 principle principle NOUN 47429882s7j 6 22 that that SCONJ 47429882s7j 6 23 the the DET 47429882s7j 6 24 religious religious ADJ 47429882s7j 6 25 liberty liberty NOUN 47429882s7j 6 26 provisions provision NOUN 47429882s7j 6 27 were be AUX 47429882s7j 6 28 understood understand VERB 47429882s7j 6 29 to to PART 47429882s7j 6 30 embody embody VERB 47429882s7j 6 31 by by ADP 47429882s7j 6 32 the the DET 47429882s7j 6 33 americans americans PROPN 47429882s7j 6 34 who who PRON 47429882s7j 6 35 ratified ratify VERB 47429882s7j 6 36 them they PRON 47429882s7j 6 37 . . PUNCT 47429882s7j 7 1 the the DET 47429882s7j 7 2 author author NOUN 47429882s7j 7 3 further far ADV 47429882s7j 7 4 argues argue VERB 47429882s7j 7 5 that that SCONJ 47429882s7j 7 6 the the DET 47429882s7j 7 7 case case NOUN 47429882s7j 7 8 law law NOUN 47429882s7j 7 9 interpreting interpret VERB 47429882s7j 7 10 the the DET 47429882s7j 7 11 religious religious ADJ 47429882s7j 7 12 liberty liberty NOUN 47429882s7j 7 13 provisions provision NOUN 47429882s7j 7 14 throughout throughout ADP 47429882s7j 7 15 the the DET 47429882s7j 7 16 nineteenth nineteenth ADJ 47429882s7j 7 17 century century NOUN 47429882s7j 7 18 evidence evidence NOUN 47429882s7j 7 19 the the DET 47429882s7j 7 20 consensus consensus NOUN 47429882s7j 7 21 posited posit VERB 47429882s7j 7 22 by by ADP 47429882s7j 7 23 this this DET 47429882s7j 7 24 study study NOUN 47429882s7j 7 25 because because SCONJ 47429882s7j 7 26 they they PRON 47429882s7j 7 27 show show VERB 47429882s7j 7 28 courts court NOUN 47429882s7j 7 29 struggling struggle VERB 47429882s7j 7 30 to to PART 47429882s7j 7 31 distinguish distinguish VERB 47429882s7j 7 32 religious religious ADJ 47429882s7j 7 33 and and CCONJ 47429882s7j 7 34 civil civil ADJ 47429882s7j 7 35 duties duty NOUN 47429882s7j 7 36 as as SCONJ 47429882s7j 7 37 the the DET 47429882s7j 7 38 courts court NOUN 47429882s7j 7 39 interpret interpret VERB 47429882s7j 7 40 the the DET 47429882s7j 7 41 provisions provision NOUN 47429882s7j 7 42 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 7 43 and and CCONJ 47429882s7j 7 44 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 7 45 in in ADP 47429882s7j 7 46 this this DET 47429882s7j 7 47 process process NOUN 47429882s7j 7 48 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 7 49 show show VERB 47429882s7j 7 50 a a DET 47429882s7j 7 51 gradual gradual ADJ 47429882s7j 7 52 unfolding unfolding NOUN 47429882s7j 7 53 of of ADP 47429882s7j 7 54 the the DET 47429882s7j 7 55 implications implication NOUN 47429882s7j 7 56 of of ADP 47429882s7j 7 57 the the DET 47429882s7j 7 58 consensus consensus NOUN 47429882s7j 7 59 the the DET 47429882s7j 7 60 provisions provision NOUN 47429882s7j 7 61 were be AUX 47429882s7j 7 62 understood understand VERB 47429882s7j 7 63 to to PART 47429882s7j 7 64 embody embody VERB 47429882s7j 7 65 . . PUNCT 47429882s7j 8 1 finally finally ADV 47429882s7j 8 2 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 8 3 the the DET 47429882s7j 8 4 author author NOUN 47429882s7j 8 5 also also ADV 47429882s7j 8 6 argues argue VERB 47429882s7j 8 7 that that SCONJ 47429882s7j 8 8 this this DET 47429882s7j 8 9 process process NOUN 47429882s7j 8 10 of of ADP 47429882s7j 8 11 interpretation interpretation NOUN 47429882s7j 8 12 also also ADV 47429882s7j 8 13 demonstrates demonstrate VERB 47429882s7j 8 14 the the DET 47429882s7j 8 15 preeminent preeminent ADJ 47429882s7j 8 16 influence influence NOUN 47429882s7j 8 17 of of ADP 47429882s7j 8 18 the the DET 47429882s7j 8 19 protestant protestant ADJ 47429882s7j 8 20 christian christian ADJ 47429882s7j 8 21 culture culture NOUN 47429882s7j 8 22 that that PRON 47429882s7j 8 23 engendered engender VERB 47429882s7j 8 24 them they PRON 47429882s7j 8 25 and and CCONJ 47429882s7j 8 26 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 8 27 in in ADP 47429882s7j 8 28 so so ADV 47429882s7j 8 29 doing do VERB 47429882s7j 8 30 , , PUNCT 47429882s7j 8 31 testifies testify VERB 47429882s7j 8 32 to to ADP 47429882s7j 8 33 the the DET 47429882s7j 8 34 preeminent preeminent ADJ 47429882s7j 8 35 influence influence NOUN 47429882s7j 8 36 of of ADP 47429882s7j 8 37 the the DET 47429882s7j 8 38 religious religious ADJ 47429882s7j 8 39 strain strain NOUN 47429882s7j 8 40 of of ADP 47429882s7j 8 41 discourse discourse NOUN 47429882s7j 8 42 in in ADP 47429882s7j 8 43 the the DET 47429882s7j 8 44 understanding understanding NOUN 47429882s7j 8 45 of of ADP 47429882s7j 8 46 the the DET 47429882s7j 8 47 religious religious ADJ 47429882s7j 8 48 liberty liberty NOUN 47429882s7j 8 49 provisions provision NOUN 47429882s7j 8 50 at at ADP 47429882s7j 8 51 the the DET 47429882s7j 8 52 time time NOUN 47429882s7j 8 53 they they PRON 47429882s7j 8 54 were be AUX 47429882s7j 8 55 ratified ratify VERB 47429882s7j 8 56 . . PUNCT