id sid tid token lemma pos pipe-0093 1 1 open open ADJ pipe-0093 1 2 to to ADP pipe-0093 1 3 what what PRON pipe-0093 1 4 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 2 1 a a DET pipe-0093 2 2 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 2 3 evaluation evaluation NOUN pipe-0093 2 4 of of ADP pipe-0093 2 5 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 2 6 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 2 7 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 2 8 – – PUNCT pipe-0093 2 9 in in ADP pipe-0093 2 10 the the DET pipe-0093 2 11 library library NOUN pipe-0093 2 12 with with ADP pipe-0093 2 13 the the DET pipe-0093 2 14 lead lead NOUN pipe-0093 2 15 pipe pipe NOUN pipe-0093 2 16 skip skip NOUN pipe-0093 2 17 to to ADP pipe-0093 2 18 main main ADJ pipe-0093 2 19 content content NOUN pipe-0093 2 20 open open ADJ pipe-0093 2 21 menu menu NOUN pipe-0093 2 22 home home ADV pipe-0093 2 23 about about ADP pipe-0093 2 24 awards award NOUN pipe-0093 2 25 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 2 26 good good ADJ pipe-0093 2 27 words word NOUN pipe-0093 2 28 contact contact NOUN pipe-0093 2 29 editorial editorial NOUN pipe-0093 2 30 board board NOUN pipe-0093 2 31 denisse denisse PROPN pipe-0093 2 32 solis solis PROPN pipe-0093 2 33 ian ian PROPN pipe-0093 2 34 beilin beilin PROPN pipe-0093 2 35 ikumi ikumi PROPN pipe-0093 2 36 crocoll crocoll PROPN pipe-0093 2 37 jaena jaena PROPN pipe-0093 2 38 rae rae PROPN pipe-0093 2 39 cabrera cabrera PROPN pipe-0093 2 40 kellee kellee PROPN pipe-0093 2 41 warren warren PROPN pipe-0093 2 42 nicole nicole PROPN pipe-0093 2 43 cooke cooke PROPN pipe-0093 2 44 ryan ryan PROPN pipe-0093 2 45 randall randall PROPN pipe-0093 2 46 emeritus emeritus NOUN pipe-0093 2 47 announcements announcement NOUN pipe-0093 2 48 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 2 49 archives archive NOUN pipe-0093 2 50 conduct conduct VERB pipe-0093 2 51 submission submission NOUN pipe-0093 2 52 guidelines guideline NOUN pipe-0093 2 53 lead lead VERB pipe-0093 2 54 pipe pipe NOUN pipe-0093 2 55 publication publication NOUN pipe-0093 2 56 process process NOUN pipe-0093 2 57 style style NOUN pipe-0093 2 58 guide guide NOUN pipe-0093 2 59 search search NOUN pipe-0093 2 60 home home ADV pipe-0093 2 61 about about ADP pipe-0093 2 62 awards award NOUN pipe-0093 2 63 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 2 64 good good ADJ pipe-0093 2 65 words word NOUN pipe-0093 2 66 contact contact NOUN pipe-0093 2 67 editorial editorial NOUN pipe-0093 2 68 board board NOUN pipe-0093 2 69 denisse denisse PROPN pipe-0093 2 70 solis solis PROPN pipe-0093 2 71 ian ian PROPN pipe-0093 2 72 beilin beilin PROPN pipe-0093 2 73 ikumi ikumi PROPN pipe-0093 2 74 crocoll crocoll PROPN pipe-0093 2 75 jaena jaena PROPN pipe-0093 2 76 rae rae PROPN pipe-0093 2 77 cabrera cabrera PROPN pipe-0093 2 78 kellee kellee PROPN pipe-0093 2 79 warren warren PROPN pipe-0093 2 80 nicole nicole PROPN pipe-0093 2 81 cooke cooke PROPN pipe-0093 2 82 ryan ryan PROPN pipe-0093 2 83 randall randall PROPN pipe-0093 2 84 emeritus emeritus NOUN pipe-0093 2 85 announcements announcement NOUN pipe-0093 2 86 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 2 87 archives archive NOUN pipe-0093 2 88 conduct conduct VERB pipe-0093 2 89 submission submission NOUN pipe-0093 2 90 guidelines guideline NOUN pipe-0093 2 91 lead lead VERB pipe-0093 2 92 pipe pipe NOUN pipe-0093 2 93 publication publication NOUN pipe-0093 2 94 process process NOUN pipe-0093 2 95 style style NOUN pipe-0093 2 96 guide guide NOUN pipe-0093 2 97 search search NOUN pipe-0093 2 98 2020 2020 NUM pipe-0093 2 99 19 19 NUM pipe-0093 2 100 feb feb PROPN pipe-0093 2 101 ian ian PROPN pipe-0093 2 102 mcdermott mcdermott PROPN pipe-0093 2 103 /0 /0 PROPN pipe-0093 2 104 comments comment VERB pipe-0093 2 105 open open ADJ pipe-0093 2 106 to to ADP pipe-0093 2 107 what what PRON pipe-0093 2 108 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 3 1 a a DET pipe-0093 3 2 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 3 3 evaluation evaluation NOUN pipe-0093 3 4 of of ADP pipe-0093 3 5 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 3 6 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 3 7 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 3 8 in in ADP pipe-0093 3 9 brief brief NOUN pipe-0093 3 10 this this DET pipe-0093 3 11 selective selective ADJ pipe-0093 3 12 literature literature NOUN pipe-0093 3 13 review review NOUN pipe-0093 3 14 evaluates evaluate VERB pipe-0093 3 15 open open ADJ pipe-0093 3 16 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 3 17 resources resource NOUN pipe-0093 3 18 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 3 19 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 3 20 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 3 21 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 3 22 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 3 23 through through ADP pipe-0093 3 24 the the DET pipe-0093 3 25 lens lens NOUN pipe-0093 3 26 of of ADP pipe-0093 3 27 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 3 28 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 3 29 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 4 1 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 4 2 have have VERB pipe-0093 4 3 radical radical ADJ pipe-0093 4 4 potential potential NOUN pipe-0093 4 5 as as ADP pipe-0093 4 6 transformative transformative ADJ pipe-0093 4 7 tools tool NOUN pipe-0093 4 8 for for ADP pipe-0093 4 9 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 4 10 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 4 11 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 4 12 they they PRON pipe-0093 4 13 can can AUX pipe-0093 4 14 serve serve VERB pipe-0093 4 15 as as ADP pipe-0093 4 16 a a DET pipe-0093 4 17 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 4 18 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 4 19 free free ADJ pipe-0093 4 20 version version NOUN pipe-0093 4 21 of of ADP pipe-0093 4 22 the the DET pipe-0093 4 23 status status NOUN pipe-0093 4 24 quo quo NOUN pipe-0093 4 25 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 4 26 inclined incline VERB pipe-0093 4 27 toward toward ADP pipe-0093 4 28 propagating propagate VERB pipe-0093 4 29 austerity austerity NOUN pipe-0093 4 30 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 5 1 this this DET pipe-0093 5 2 review review NOUN pipe-0093 5 3 analyzes analyze VERB pipe-0093 5 4 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 5 5 published publish VERB pipe-0093 5 6 since since SCONJ pipe-0093 5 7 2008 2008 NUM pipe-0093 5 8 with with ADP pipe-0093 5 9 regard regard NOUN pipe-0093 5 10 to to ADP pipe-0093 5 11 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 5 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 5 13 access access NOUN pipe-0093 5 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 5 15 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 5 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 5 17 commercialization commercialization NOUN pipe-0093 5 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 5 19 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 5 20 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 5 21 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 6 1 these these DET pipe-0093 6 2 criteria criterion NOUN pipe-0093 6 3 are be AUX pipe-0093 6 4 used use VERB pipe-0093 6 5 to to PART pipe-0093 6 6 make make VERB pipe-0093 6 7 explicit explicit ADJ pipe-0093 6 8 subjects subject NOUN pipe-0093 6 9 indirectly indirectly ADV pipe-0093 6 10 addressed address VERB pipe-0093 6 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 6 12 if if SCONJ pipe-0093 6 13 not not PART pipe-0093 6 14 ignored ignore VERB pipe-0093 6 15 completely completely ADV pipe-0093 6 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 6 17 in in ADP pipe-0093 6 18 the the DET pipe-0093 6 19 existing exist VERB pipe-0093 6 20 literature literature NOUN pipe-0093 6 21 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 7 1 typically typically ADV pipe-0093 7 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 7 3 ample ample ADJ pipe-0093 7 4 attention attention NOUN pipe-0093 7 5 is be AUX pipe-0093 7 6 paid pay VERB pipe-0093 7 7 to to ADP pipe-0093 7 8 a a DET pipe-0093 7 9 study study NOUN pipe-0093 7 10 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 7 11 design design NOUN pipe-0093 7 12 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 7 13 methodology methodology NOUN pipe-0093 7 14 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 7 15 the the DET pipe-0093 7 16 underlying underlying ADJ pipe-0093 7 17 institutional institutional ADJ pipe-0093 7 18 infrastructure infrastructure NOUN pipe-0093 7 19 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 7 20 decision decision NOUN pipe-0093 7 21 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 7 22 making make VERB pipe-0093 7 23 process process NOUN pipe-0093 7 24 is be AUX pipe-0093 7 25 unexamined unexamined ADJ pipe-0093 7 26 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 8 1 what what PRON pipe-0093 8 2 emerges emerge VERB pipe-0093 8 3 is be AUX pipe-0093 8 4 an an DET pipe-0093 8 5 incomplete incomplete ADJ pipe-0093 8 6 picture picture NOUN pipe-0093 8 7 of of ADP pipe-0093 8 8 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 8 9 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 8 10 are be AUX pipe-0093 8 11 adopted adopt VERB pipe-0093 8 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 8 13 developed develop VERB pipe-0093 8 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 8 15 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 8 16 sustained sustain VERB pipe-0093 8 17 in in ADP pipe-0093 8 18 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 8 19 education education NOUN pipe-0093 8 20 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 9 1 measurables measurable NOUN pipe-0093 9 2 like like ADP pipe-0093 9 3 student student NOUN pipe-0093 9 4 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 9 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 9 6 while while SCONJ pipe-0093 9 7 important important ADJ pipe-0093 9 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 9 9 are be AUX pipe-0093 9 10 too too ADV pipe-0093 9 11 often often ADV pipe-0093 9 12 foregrounded foreground VERB pipe-0093 9 13 to to PART pipe-0093 9 14 appeal appeal VERB pipe-0093 9 15 to to ADP pipe-0093 9 16 administrators administrator NOUN pipe-0093 9 17 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 9 18 funding funding NOUN pipe-0093 9 19 organizations organization NOUN pipe-0093 9 20 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 10 1 the the DET pipe-0093 10 2 review review NOUN pipe-0093 10 3 concludes conclude VERB pipe-0093 10 4 with with ADP pipe-0093 10 5 suggestions suggestion NOUN pipe-0093 10 6 for for ADP pipe-0093 10 7 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 10 8 to to PART pipe-0093 10 9 utilize utilize VERB pipe-0093 10 10 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 10 11 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 10 12 for for ADP pipe-0093 10 13 future future ADJ pipe-0093 10 14 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 10 15 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 10 16 grassroots grassroot NOUN pipe-0093 10 17 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 10 18 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 10 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 11 1 by by ADP pipe-0093 11 2 ian ian PROPN pipe-0093 11 3 mcdermott mcdermott PROPN pipe-0093 11 4 introduction introduction PROPN pipe-0093 11 5 open open VERB pipe-0093 11 6 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 11 7 resources resource NOUN pipe-0093 11 8 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 11 9 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 11 10 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 11 11 are be AUX pipe-0093 11 12 misunderstood misunderstood NOUN pipe-0093 11 13 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 11 14 underutilized underutilize VERB pipe-0093 11 15 in in ADP pipe-0093 11 16 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 11 17 education education NOUN pipe-0093 11 18 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 11 19 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 11 20 ed ed NOUN pipe-0093 11 21 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 11 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 12 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 12 2 part part NOUN pipe-0093 12 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 12 4 this this DET pipe-0093 12 5 situation situation NOUN pipe-0093 12 6 can can AUX pipe-0093 12 7 be be AUX pipe-0093 12 8 traced trace VERB pipe-0093 12 9 to to ADP pipe-0093 12 10 definitions definition NOUN pipe-0093 12 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 13 1 what what PRON pipe-0093 13 2 are be AUX pipe-0093 13 3 oer oer ADJ pipe-0093 13 4 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 14 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 14 2 2002 2002 NUM pipe-0093 14 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 14 4 the the DET pipe-0093 14 5 united united PROPN pipe-0093 14 6 nations nations PROPN pipe-0093 14 7 educational educational PROPN pipe-0093 14 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 14 9 scientific scientific ADJ pipe-0093 14 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 14 11 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 14 12 cultural cultural ADJ pipe-0093 14 13 organization organization NOUN pipe-0093 14 14 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 14 15 unesco unesco PROPN pipe-0093 14 16 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 14 17 coined coin VERB pipe-0093 14 18 the the DET pipe-0093 14 19 term term NOUN pipe-0093 14 20 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 14 21 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 14 22 2002 2002 NUM pipe-0093 14 23 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 14 24 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 14 25 defined define VERB pipe-0093 14 26 them they PRON pipe-0093 14 27 as as ADP pipe-0093 14 28 non non ADJ pipe-0093 14 29 - - ADJ pipe-0093 14 30 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 14 31 learning learning NOUN pipe-0093 14 32 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 14 33 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 15 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 15 2 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 15 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 15 4 unesco unesco PROPN pipe-0093 15 5 refined refine VERB pipe-0093 15 6 their their PRON pipe-0093 15 7 definition definition NOUN pipe-0093 15 8 to to PART pipe-0093 15 9 include include VERB pipe-0093 15 10 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 15 11 any any DET pipe-0093 15 12 type type NOUN pipe-0093 15 13 of of ADP pipe-0093 15 14 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 15 15 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 15 16 that that PRON pipe-0093 15 17 are be AUX pipe-0093 15 18 in in ADP pipe-0093 15 19 the the DET pipe-0093 15 20 public public ADJ pipe-0093 15 21 domain domain NOUN pipe-0093 15 22 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 15 23 introduced introduce VERB pipe-0093 15 24 with with ADP pipe-0093 15 25 an an DET pipe-0093 15 26 open open ADJ pipe-0093 15 27 license license NOUN pipe-0093 15 28 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 15 29 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 15 30 unesco unesco PROPN pipe-0093 15 31 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 15 32 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 15 33 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 15 34 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 16 1 these these DET pipe-0093 16 2 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 16 3 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 16 4 encompass encompass VERB pipe-0093 16 5 everything everything PRON pipe-0093 16 6 from from ADP pipe-0093 16 7 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 16 8 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 16 9 curricula curricula NOUN pipe-0093 16 10 to to PART pipe-0093 16 11 lecture lecture VERB pipe-0093 16 12 notes note NOUN pipe-0093 16 13 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 16 14 animation animation NOUN pipe-0093 16 15 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 17 1 the the DET pipe-0093 17 2 william william PROPN pipe-0093 17 3 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 17 4 flora flora PROPN pipe-0093 17 5 hewlett hewlett PROPN pipe-0093 17 6 foundation foundation PROPN pipe-0093 17 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 17 8 a a DET pipe-0093 17 9 charitable charitable ADJ pipe-0093 17 10 foundation foundation NOUN pipe-0093 17 11 that that PRON pipe-0093 17 12 supports support VERB pipe-0093 17 13 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 17 14 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 17 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 17 16 states states PROPN pipe-0093 17 17 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 17 18 are be AUX pipe-0093 17 19 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 17 20 high high ADJ pipe-0093 17 21 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 17 22 quality quality NOUN pipe-0093 17 23 teaching teaching NOUN pipe-0093 17 24 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 17 25 learning learning NOUN pipe-0093 17 26 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 17 27 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 17 28 research research NOUN pipe-0093 17 29 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 17 30 that that PRON pipe-0093 17 31 are be AUX pipe-0093 17 32 free free ADJ pipe-0093 17 33 for for ADP pipe-0093 17 34 people people NOUN pipe-0093 17 35 everywhere everywhere ADV pipe-0093 17 36 to to PART pipe-0093 17 37 use use VERB pipe-0093 17 38 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 17 39 repurpose repurpose NOUN pipe-0093 17 40 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 17 41 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 17 42 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 17 43 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 17 44 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 18 1 david david PROPN pipe-0093 18 2 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 18 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 18 4 founder founder NOUN pipe-0093 18 5 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 18 6 chief chief ADJ pipe-0093 18 7 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 18 8 officer officer NOUN pipe-0093 18 9 at at ADP pipe-0093 18 10 lumen luman NOUN pipe-0093 18 11 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 18 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 18 13 argues argue VERB pipe-0093 18 14 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 18 15 it it PRON pipe-0093 18 16 is be AUX pipe-0093 18 17 flexible flexible ADJ pipe-0093 18 18 licensing licensing NOUN pipe-0093 18 19 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 18 20 permissions permission NOUN pipe-0093 18 21 in in ADP pipe-0093 18 22 opposition opposition NOUN pipe-0093 18 23 to to ADP pipe-0093 18 24 conventional conventional ADJ pipe-0093 18 25 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 18 26 restrictive restrictive ADJ pipe-0093 18 27 copyright copyright NOUN pipe-0093 18 28 that that PRON pipe-0093 18 29 are be AUX pipe-0093 18 30 central central ADJ pipe-0093 18 31 to to PART pipe-0093 18 32 oer oer VERB pipe-0093 18 33 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 19 1 wiley wiley NOUN pipe-0093 19 2 cites cite VERB pipe-0093 19 3 the the DET pipe-0093 19 4 5 5 NUM pipe-0093 19 5 rs rs NOUN pipe-0093 19 6 of of ADP pipe-0093 19 7 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 19 8 as as ADP pipe-0093 19 9 the the DET pipe-0093 19 10 most most ADV pipe-0093 19 11 important important ADJ pipe-0093 19 12 features feature NOUN pipe-0093 19 13 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 19 14 the the DET pipe-0093 19 15 ability ability NOUN pipe-0093 19 16 to to PART pipe-0093 19 17 retain retain VERB pipe-0093 19 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 19 19 reuse reuse VERB pipe-0093 19 20 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 19 21 revise revise NOUN pipe-0093 19 22 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 19 23 remix remix NOUN pipe-0093 19 24 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 19 25 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 19 26 redistribute redistribute VERB pipe-0093 19 27 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 19 28 hilton hilton PROPN pipe-0093 19 29 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 19 30 wiley wiley NOUN pipe-0093 19 31 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 19 32 stein stein PROPN pipe-0093 19 33 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 19 34 johnson johnson PROPN pipe-0093 19 35 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 19 36 2010 2010 NUM pipe-0093 19 37 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 19 38 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 19 39 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 19 40 bliss bliss PROPN pipe-0093 19 41 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 19 42 mcewen mcewen PROPN pipe-0093 19 43 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 19 44 2014 2014 NUM pipe-0093 19 45 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 19 46 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 20 1 these these DET pipe-0093 20 2 definitions definition NOUN pipe-0093 20 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 20 4 while while SCONJ pipe-0093 20 5 useful useful ADJ pipe-0093 20 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 20 7 hint hint NOUN pipe-0093 20 8 at at ADP pipe-0093 20 9 the the DET pipe-0093 20 10 motivations motivation NOUN pipe-0093 20 11 of of ADP pipe-0093 20 12 the the DET pipe-0093 20 13 organizations organization NOUN pipe-0093 20 14 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 20 15 individuals individual NOUN pipe-0093 20 16 behind behind ADP pipe-0093 20 17 them they PRON pipe-0093 20 18 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 21 1 as as ADP pipe-0093 21 2 an an DET pipe-0093 21 3 international international ADJ pipe-0093 21 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 21 5 aspirational aspirational ADJ pipe-0093 21 6 organization organization NOUN pipe-0093 21 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 21 8 unesco unesco PROPN pipe-0093 21 9 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 21 10 broad broad ADJ pipe-0093 21 11 definition definition NOUN pipe-0093 21 12 is be AUX pipe-0093 21 13 inclusive inclusive ADJ pipe-0093 21 14 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 21 15 emphasizes emphasize VERB pipe-0093 21 16 the the DET pipe-0093 21 17 public public ADJ pipe-0093 21 18 domain domain NOUN pipe-0093 21 19 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 21 20 open open ADJ pipe-0093 21 21 licenses license NOUN pipe-0093 21 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 22 1 the the DET pipe-0093 22 2 hewlett hewlett PROPN pipe-0093 22 3 foundation foundation PROPN pipe-0093 22 4 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 22 5 definition definition NOUN pipe-0093 22 6 signals signal VERB pipe-0093 22 7 an an DET pipe-0093 22 8 interesting interesting ADJ pipe-0093 22 9 shift shift NOUN pipe-0093 22 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 22 11 emphasizing emphasize VERB pipe-0093 22 12 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 22 13 high high ADJ pipe-0093 22 14 quality quality NOUN pipe-0093 22 15 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 22 16 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 22 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 22 18 which which PRON pipe-0093 22 19 is be AUX pipe-0093 22 20 not not PART pipe-0093 22 21 surprising surprising ADJ pipe-0093 22 22 since since SCONJ pipe-0093 22 23 hewlett hewlett PROPN pipe-0093 22 24 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 22 25 as as ADP pipe-0093 22 26 an an DET pipe-0093 22 27 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 22 28 funder funder NOUN pipe-0093 22 29 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 22 30 has have VERB pipe-0093 22 31 a a DET pipe-0093 22 32 financial financial ADJ pipe-0093 22 33 stake stake NOUN pipe-0093 22 34 in in ADP pipe-0093 22 35 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 22 36 development development NOUN pipe-0093 22 37 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 23 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 23 2 2019 2019 NUM pipe-0093 23 3 hewlett hewlett PROPN pipe-0093 23 4 granted grant VERB pipe-0093 23 5 nearly nearly ADV pipe-0093 23 6 $ $ SYM pipe-0093 23 7 8 8 NUM pipe-0093 23 8 million million NUM pipe-0093 23 9 to to PART pipe-0093 23 10 18 18 NUM pipe-0093 23 11 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 23 12 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 23 13 at at ADP pipe-0093 23 14 universities university NOUN pipe-0093 23 15 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 23 16 organizations organization NOUN pipe-0093 23 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 23 18 including include VERB pipe-0093 23 19 the the DET pipe-0093 23 20 university university PROPN pipe-0093 23 21 of of ADP pipe-0093 23 22 california california PROPN pipe-0093 23 23 at at ADP pipe-0093 23 24 berkeley berkeley PROPN pipe-0093 23 25 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 23 26 university university PROPN pipe-0093 23 27 of of ADP pipe-0093 23 28 cape cape PROPN pipe-0093 23 29 town town NOUN pipe-0093 23 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 23 31 creative creative ADJ pipe-0093 23 32 commons common NOUN pipe-0093 23 33 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 23 34 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 23 35 the the DET pipe-0093 23 36 wiki wiki ADJ pipe-0093 23 37 education education NOUN pipe-0093 23 38 foundation foundation NOUN pipe-0093 23 39 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 23 40 hewlett hewlett PROPN pipe-0093 23 41 foundation foundation PROPN pipe-0093 23 42 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 23 43 grants grant NOUN pipe-0093 23 44 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 23 45 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 24 1 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 24 2 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 24 3 5 5 NUM pipe-0093 24 4 rs rs NOUN pipe-0093 24 5 model model NOUN pipe-0093 24 6 is be AUX pipe-0093 24 7 arguably arguably ADV pipe-0093 24 8 the the DET pipe-0093 24 9 preeminent preeminent ADJ pipe-0093 24 10 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 24 11 definition definition NOUN pipe-0093 24 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 25 1 it it PRON pipe-0093 25 2 is be AUX pipe-0093 25 3 clear clear ADJ pipe-0093 25 4 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 25 5 concise concise ADJ pipe-0093 25 6 while while SCONJ pipe-0093 25 7 articulating articulate VERB pipe-0093 25 8 a a DET pipe-0093 25 9 broad broad ADJ pipe-0093 25 10 set set NOUN pipe-0093 25 11 of of ADP pipe-0093 25 12 practices practice NOUN pipe-0093 25 13 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 26 1 one one NUM pipe-0093 26 2 critique critique NOUN pipe-0093 26 3 points point VERB pipe-0093 26 4 out out ADP pipe-0093 26 5 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 26 6 several several ADJ pipe-0093 26 7 of of ADP pipe-0093 26 8 the the DET pipe-0093 26 9 5 5 NUM pipe-0093 26 10 rs rs NOUN pipe-0093 26 11 require require VERB pipe-0093 26 12 access access NOUN pipe-0093 26 13 to to ADP pipe-0093 26 14 technology technology NOUN pipe-0093 26 15 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 26 16 the the DET pipe-0093 26 17 requisite requisite ADJ pipe-0093 26 18 skills skill NOUN pipe-0093 26 19 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 26 20 lambert lambert NOUN pipe-0093 26 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 26 22 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 26 23 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 26 24 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 27 1 like like ADP pipe-0093 27 2 the the DET pipe-0093 27 3 hewlett hewlett PROPN pipe-0093 27 4 foundation foundation PROPN pipe-0093 27 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 27 6 wiley wiley NOUN pipe-0093 27 7 has have VERB pipe-0093 27 8 a a DET pipe-0093 27 9 vested vested ADJ pipe-0093 27 10 interest interest NOUN pipe-0093 27 11 in in ADP pipe-0093 27 12 the the DET pipe-0093 27 13 success success NOUN pipe-0093 27 14 of of ADP pipe-0093 27 15 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 27 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 28 1 lumen luman NOUN pipe-0093 28 2 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 28 3 is be AUX pipe-0093 28 4 a a DET pipe-0093 28 5 company company NOUN pipe-0093 28 6 that that PRON pipe-0093 28 7 provides provide VERB pipe-0093 28 8 a a DET pipe-0093 28 9 suite suite NOUN pipe-0093 28 10 of of ADP pipe-0093 28 11 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 28 12 technology technology NOUN pipe-0093 28 13 products product NOUN pipe-0093 28 14 that that PRON pipe-0093 28 15 colleges college NOUN pipe-0093 28 16 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 28 17 universities university NOUN pipe-0093 28 18 pay pay VERB pipe-0093 28 19 to to ADP pipe-0093 28 20 use use VERB pipe-0093 28 21 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 28 22 lumen lumen PROPN pipe-0093 28 23 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 28 24 candela candela PROPN pipe-0093 28 25 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 28 26 waymaker waymaker NOUN pipe-0093 28 27 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 28 28 ohm ohm PROPN pipe-0093 28 29 provide provide VERB pipe-0093 28 30 the the DET pipe-0093 28 31 infrastructure infrastructure NOUN pipe-0093 28 32 for for ADP pipe-0093 28 33 many many ADJ pipe-0093 28 34 instructors instructor NOUN pipe-0093 28 35 teaching teach VERB pipe-0093 28 36 with with ADP pipe-0093 28 37 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 28 38 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 29 1 while while SCONJ pipe-0093 29 2 their their PRON pipe-0093 29 3 products product NOUN pipe-0093 29 4 are be AUX pipe-0093 29 5 often often ADV pipe-0093 29 6 less less ADV pipe-0093 29 7 expensive expensive ADJ pipe-0093 29 8 than than ADP pipe-0093 29 9 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 29 10 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 29 11 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 29 12 platforms platform NOUN pipe-0093 29 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 29 14 some some PRON pipe-0093 29 15 argue argue VERB pipe-0093 29 16 their their PRON pipe-0093 29 17 business business NOUN pipe-0093 29 18 model model NOUN pipe-0093 29 19 betrays betray VERB pipe-0093 29 20 the the DET pipe-0093 29 21 ethos ethos NOUN pipe-0093 29 22 of of ADP pipe-0093 29 23 open open ADJ pipe-0093 29 24 access access NOUN pipe-0093 29 25 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 29 26 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 29 27 downes downe NOUN pipe-0093 29 28 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 29 29 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 29 30 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 29 31 see see VERB pipe-0093 29 32 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 29 33 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 29 34 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 29 35 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 29 36 for for ADP pipe-0093 29 37 counterpoint counterpoint NOUN pipe-0093 29 38 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 29 39 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 30 1 critically critically ADV pipe-0093 30 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 30 3 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 30 4 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 30 5 initial initial ADJ pipe-0093 30 6 definition definition NOUN pipe-0093 30 7 of of ADP pipe-0093 30 8 2007 2007 NUM pipe-0093 30 9 only only ADV pipe-0093 30 10 included include VERB pipe-0093 30 11 4 4 NUM pipe-0093 30 12 rs r NOUN pipe-0093 30 13 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 30 14 wiley wiley NOUN pipe-0093 30 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 30 16 2007 2007 NUM pipe-0093 30 17 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 30 18 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 31 1 he he PRON pipe-0093 31 2 added add VERB pipe-0093 31 3 retain retain VERB pipe-0093 31 4 as as ADP pipe-0093 31 5 the the DET pipe-0093 31 6 fifth fifth ADJ pipe-0093 31 7 r r NOUN pipe-0093 31 8 in in ADP pipe-0093 31 9 2014 2014 NUM pipe-0093 31 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 32 1 as as ADP pipe-0093 32 2 a a DET pipe-0093 32 3 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 32 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 32 5 creators creator NOUN pipe-0093 32 6 of of ADP pipe-0093 32 7 any any DET pipe-0093 32 8 work work NOUN pipe-0093 32 9 should should AUX pipe-0093 32 10 retain retain VERB pipe-0093 32 11 certain certain ADJ pipe-0093 32 12 rights right NOUN pipe-0093 32 13 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 33 1 coincidentally coincidentally ADV pipe-0093 33 2 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 33 3 not not PART pipe-0093 33 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 33 5 the the DET pipe-0093 33 6 right right NOUN pipe-0093 33 7 to to PART pipe-0093 33 8 retain retain VERB pipe-0093 33 9 is be AUX pipe-0093 33 10 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 33 11 to to ADP pipe-0093 33 12 the the DET pipe-0093 33 13 lumen luman NOUN pipe-0093 33 14 business business NOUN pipe-0093 33 15 model model NOUN pipe-0093 33 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 34 1 it it PRON pipe-0093 34 2 enables enable VERB pipe-0093 34 3 lumen luman NOUN pipe-0093 34 4 to to PART pipe-0093 34 5 monetize monetize VERB pipe-0093 34 6 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 34 7 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 34 8 by by ADP pipe-0093 34 9 packaging package VERB pipe-0093 34 10 them they PRON pipe-0093 34 11 in in ADP pipe-0093 34 12 a a DET pipe-0093 34 13 proprietary proprietary ADJ pipe-0093 34 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 34 15 fee fee NOUN pipe-0093 34 16 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 34 17 based base VERB pipe-0093 34 18 system system NOUN pipe-0093 34 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 35 1 these these DET pipe-0093 35 2 definitions definition NOUN pipe-0093 35 3 vary vary VERB pipe-0093 35 4 enough enough ADV pipe-0093 35 5 to to PART pipe-0093 35 6 preclude preclude VERB pipe-0093 35 7 a a DET pipe-0093 35 8 shared share VERB pipe-0093 35 9 understanding understanding NOUN pipe-0093 35 10 of of ADP pipe-0093 35 11 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 35 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 36 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 36 2 fact fact NOUN pipe-0093 36 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 36 4 a a DET pipe-0093 36 5 majority majority NOUN pipe-0093 36 6 of of ADP pipe-0093 36 7 college college NOUN pipe-0093 36 8 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 36 9 university university NOUN pipe-0093 36 10 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 36 11 are be AUX pipe-0093 36 12 not not PART pipe-0093 36 13 familiar familiar ADJ pipe-0093 36 14 with with ADP pipe-0093 36 15 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 36 16 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 36 17 seaman seaman PROPN pipe-0093 36 18 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 36 19 seaman seaman PROPN pipe-0093 36 20 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 36 21 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 36 22 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 36 23 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 36 24 16 16 NUM pipe-0093 36 25 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 36 26 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 37 1 current current ADJ pipe-0093 37 2 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 37 3 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 37 4 varies vary VERB pipe-0093 37 5 depending depend VERB pipe-0093 37 6 on on ADP pipe-0093 37 7 the the DET pipe-0093 37 8 practitioner practitioner NOUN pipe-0093 37 9 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 37 10 affiliation affiliation NOUN pipe-0093 37 11 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 37 12 e.g. e.g. ADV pipe-0093 37 13 professor professor NOUN pipe-0093 37 14 at at ADP pipe-0093 37 15 a a DET pipe-0093 37 16 public public ADJ pipe-0093 37 17 university university NOUN pipe-0093 37 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 37 19 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 37 20 librarian librarian NOUN pipe-0093 37 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 37 22 lumen luman NOUN pipe-0093 37 23 employee employee NOUN pipe-0093 37 24 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 37 25 adjunct adjunct ADJ pipe-0093 37 26 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 37 27 member member NOUN pipe-0093 37 28 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 37 29 student student NOUN pipe-0093 37 30 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 37 31 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 38 1 beyond beyond ADP pipe-0093 38 2 sharing share VERB pipe-0093 38 3 resources resource NOUN pipe-0093 38 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 38 5 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 38 6 ed ed PROPN pipe-0093 38 7 lacks lack VERB pipe-0093 38 8 a a DET pipe-0093 38 9 common common ADJ pipe-0093 38 10 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 38 11 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 38 12 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 38 13 existing exist VERB pipe-0093 38 14 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 38 15 practices practice NOUN pipe-0093 38 16 lack lack VERB pipe-0093 38 17 an an DET pipe-0093 38 18 explicit explicit ADJ pipe-0093 38 19 social social ADJ pipe-0093 38 20 justice justice NOUN pipe-0093 38 21 mission mission NOUN pipe-0093 38 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 39 1 this this DET pipe-0093 39 2 situation situation NOUN pipe-0093 39 3 presents present VERB pipe-0093 39 4 an an DET pipe-0093 39 5 excellent excellent ADJ pipe-0093 39 6 opportunity opportunity NOUN pipe-0093 39 7 to to PART pipe-0093 39 8 define define VERB pipe-0093 39 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 39 10 develop develop VERB pipe-0093 39 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 39 12 implement implement ADJ pipe-0093 39 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 39 14 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 39 15 advocate advocate VERB pipe-0093 39 16 for for ADP pipe-0093 39 17 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 39 18 in in ADP pipe-0093 39 19 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 39 20 ways way NOUN pipe-0093 39 21 that that PRON pipe-0093 39 22 address address VERB pipe-0093 39 23 social social ADJ pipe-0093 39 24 justice justice NOUN pipe-0093 39 25 issues issue NOUN pipe-0093 39 26 facing face VERB pipe-0093 39 27 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 39 28 ed ed NOUN pipe-0093 39 29 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 39 30 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 39 31 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 39 32 access access NOUN pipe-0093 39 33 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 39 34 pedagogical pedagogical ADJ pipe-0093 39 35 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 39 36 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 39 37 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 39 38 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 39 39 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 39 40 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 40 1 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 40 2 that that PRON pipe-0093 40 3 assess assess VERB pipe-0093 40 4 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 40 5 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 40 6 impact impact NOUN pipe-0093 40 7 on on ADP pipe-0093 40 8 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 40 9 ed ed PROPN pipe-0093 40 10 tend tend VERB pipe-0093 40 11 to to PART pipe-0093 40 12 focus focus VERB pipe-0093 40 13 on on ADP pipe-0093 40 14 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 40 15 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 40 16 perceptions perception NOUN pipe-0093 40 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 41 1 when when SCONJ pipe-0093 41 2 compared compare VERB pipe-0093 41 3 to to ADP pipe-0093 41 4 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 41 5 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 41 6 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 41 7 learning learning NOUN pipe-0093 41 8 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 41 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 41 10 these these DET pipe-0093 41 11 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 41 12 measure measure VERB pipe-0093 41 13 whether whether SCONJ pipe-0093 41 14 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 41 15 are be AUX pipe-0093 41 16 effective effective ADJ pipe-0093 41 17 at at ADP pipe-0093 41 18 producing produce VERB pipe-0093 41 19 positive positive ADJ pipe-0093 41 20 student student NOUN pipe-0093 41 21 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 41 22 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 41 23 if if SCONJ pipe-0093 41 24 they they PRON pipe-0093 41 25 are be AUX pipe-0093 41 26 perceived perceive VERB pipe-0093 41 27 favorably favorably ADV pipe-0093 41 28 by by ADP pipe-0093 41 29 students student NOUN pipe-0093 41 30 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 41 31 instructors instructor NOUN pipe-0093 41 32 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 42 1 to to PART pipe-0093 42 2 develop develop VERB pipe-0093 42 3 a a DET pipe-0093 42 4 social social ADJ pipe-0093 42 5 justice justice NOUN pipe-0093 42 6 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 42 7 oriented orient VERB pipe-0093 42 8 analysis analysis NOUN pipe-0093 42 9 of of ADP pipe-0093 42 10 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 42 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 42 12 i i PRON pipe-0093 42 13 am be AUX pipe-0093 42 14 going go VERB pipe-0093 42 15 to to PART pipe-0093 42 16 use use VERB pipe-0093 42 17 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 42 18 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 42 19 as as ADP pipe-0093 42 20 a a DET pipe-0093 42 21 theoretical theoretical ADJ pipe-0093 42 22 lens lens NOUN pipe-0093 42 23 to to PART pipe-0093 42 24 review review VERB pipe-0093 42 25 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 42 26 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 42 27 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 42 28 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 43 1 listed list VERB pipe-0093 43 2 below below ADV pipe-0093 43 3 are be AUX pipe-0093 43 4 criteria criterion NOUN pipe-0093 43 5 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 43 6 examples example NOUN pipe-0093 43 7 for for ADP pipe-0093 43 8 evaluating evaluate VERB pipe-0093 43 9 these these DET pipe-0093 43 10 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 43 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 44 1 this this DET pipe-0093 44 2 literature literature NOUN pipe-0093 44 3 review review NOUN pipe-0093 44 4 examines examine VERB pipe-0093 44 5 oer oer VERB pipe-0093 44 6 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 44 7 case case NOUN pipe-0093 44 8 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 44 9 based base VERB pipe-0093 44 10 on on ADP pipe-0093 44 11 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 44 12 they they PRON pipe-0093 44 13 address address VERB pipe-0093 44 14 the the DET pipe-0093 44 15 below below ADJ pipe-0093 44 16 criteria criterion NOUN pipe-0093 44 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 45 1 subsequent subsequent ADJ pipe-0093 45 2 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 45 3 should should AUX pipe-0093 45 4 be be AUX pipe-0093 45 5 judged judge VERB pipe-0093 45 6 for for ADP pipe-0093 45 7 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 45 8 well well ADV pipe-0093 45 9 they they PRON pipe-0093 45 10 remedy remedy VERB pipe-0093 45 11 them they PRON pipe-0093 45 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 46 1 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 46 2 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 46 3 criteria criterion NOUN pipe-0093 46 4 1 1 NUM pipe-0093 46 5 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 46 6 cost cost PROPN pipe-0093 46 7 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 46 8 access access PROPN pipe-0093 46 9 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 46 10 adoption adoption NOUN pipe-0093 46 11 eliminates eliminate VERB pipe-0093 46 12 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 46 13 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 46 14 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 46 15 democratizes democratize VERB pipe-0093 46 16 access access NOUN pipe-0093 46 17 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 46 18 online online ADJ pipe-0093 46 19 books book NOUN pipe-0093 46 20 are be AUX pipe-0093 46 21 available available ADJ pipe-0093 46 22 in in ADP pipe-0093 46 23 multiple multiple ADJ pipe-0093 46 24 formats format NOUN pipe-0093 46 25 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 46 26 accessible accessible ADJ pipe-0093 46 27 for for ADP pipe-0093 46 28 all all DET pipe-0093 46 29 learners learner NOUN pipe-0093 46 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 46 31 including include VERB pipe-0093 46 32 formats format NOUN pipe-0093 46 33 that that PRON pipe-0093 46 34 do do AUX pipe-0093 46 35 not not PART pipe-0093 46 36 rely rely VERB pipe-0093 46 37 on on ADP pipe-0093 46 38 consistent consistent ADJ pipe-0093 46 39 internet internet NOUN pipe-0093 46 40 access access NOUN pipe-0093 46 41 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 46 42 e.g. e.g. ADV pipe-0093 46 43 pdf pdf NOUN pipe-0093 46 44 download download NOUN pipe-0093 46 45 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 46 46 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 46 47 acknowledges acknowledge VERB pipe-0093 46 48 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 46 49 high high ADJ pipe-0093 46 50 priced price VERB pipe-0093 46 51 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 46 52 are be AUX pipe-0093 46 53 a a DET pipe-0093 46 54 barrier barrier NOUN pipe-0093 46 55 to to ADP pipe-0093 46 56 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 46 57 because because SCONJ pipe-0093 46 58 many many ADJ pipe-0093 46 59 students student NOUN pipe-0093 46 60 do do AUX pipe-0093 46 61 not not PART pipe-0093 46 62 purchase purchase VERB pipe-0093 46 63 expensive expensive ADJ pipe-0093 46 64 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 46 65 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 46 66 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 46 67 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 46 68 access access NOUN pipe-0093 46 69 to to ADP pipe-0093 46 70 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 46 71 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 46 72 learning learning NOUN pipe-0093 46 73 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 46 74 are be AUX pipe-0093 46 75 connected connect VERB pipe-0093 46 76 to to ADP pipe-0093 46 77 students student NOUN pipe-0093 46 78 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 46 79 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 46 80 course course NOUN pipe-0093 46 81 grade grade NOUN pipe-0093 46 82 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 46 83 enrollment enrollment NOUN pipe-0093 46 84 intensity intensity NOUN pipe-0093 46 85 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 46 86 withdrawal withdrawal NOUN pipe-0093 46 87 rates rate NOUN pipe-0093 46 88 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 46 89 etc etc X pipe-0093 46 90 . . NOUN pipe-0093 46 91 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 46 92 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 46 93 criteria criterion NOUN pipe-0093 46 94 2 2 NUM pipe-0093 46 95 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 46 96 pedagogical pedagogical ADJ pipe-0093 46 97 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 46 98 replacing replace VERB pipe-0093 46 99 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 46 100 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 46 101 with with ADP pipe-0093 46 102 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 46 103 is be AUX pipe-0093 46 104 a a DET pipe-0093 46 105 pedagogical pedagogical ADJ pipe-0093 46 106 decision decision NOUN pipe-0093 46 107 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 46 108 beyond beyond ADP pipe-0093 46 109 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 46 110 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 46 111 access access NOUN pipe-0093 46 112 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 46 113 details detail NOUN pipe-0093 46 114 are be AUX pipe-0093 46 115 provided provide VERB pipe-0093 46 116 about about ADP pipe-0093 46 117 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 46 118 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 46 119 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 46 120 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 46 121 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 46 122 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 46 123 are be AUX pipe-0093 46 124 making make VERB pipe-0093 46 125 pedagogical pedagogical ADJ pipe-0093 46 126 decisions decision NOUN pipe-0093 46 127 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 46 128 are be AUX pipe-0093 46 129 transparent transparent ADJ pipe-0093 46 130 about about ADP pipe-0093 46 131 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 46 132 adopted adopt VERB pipe-0093 46 133 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 46 134 including include VERB pipe-0093 46 135 relevant relevant ADJ pipe-0093 46 136 software software NOUN pipe-0093 46 137 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 46 138 e.g. e.g. ADV pipe-0093 46 139 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 46 140 management management NOUN pipe-0093 46 141 software software NOUN pipe-0093 46 142 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 46 143 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 46 144 open open ADJ pipe-0093 46 145 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 46 146 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 46 147 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 46 148 is be AUX pipe-0093 46 149 used use VERB pipe-0093 46 150 to to PART pipe-0093 46 151 involve involve VERB pipe-0093 46 152 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 46 153 reflect reflect VERB pipe-0093 46 154 students student NOUN pipe-0093 46 155 ’ ’ PART pipe-0093 46 156 voices voice NOUN pipe-0093 46 157 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 47 1 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 47 2 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 47 3 criteria criterion NOUN pipe-0093 47 4 3 3 NUM pipe-0093 47 5 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 47 6 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 47 7 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 47 8 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 47 9 required require VERB pipe-0093 47 10 for for ADP pipe-0093 47 11 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 47 12 initiative initiative PROPN pipe-0093 47 13 is be AUX pipe-0093 47 14 described describe VERB pipe-0093 47 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 47 16 including include VERB pipe-0093 47 17 work work NOUN pipe-0093 47 18 done do VERB pipe-0093 47 19 by by ADP pipe-0093 47 20 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 47 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 47 22 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 47 23 technologists technologist NOUN pipe-0093 47 24 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 47 25 graduate graduate NOUN pipe-0093 47 26 assistants assistant NOUN pipe-0093 47 27 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 47 28 librarians librarian NOUN pipe-0093 47 29 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 47 30 undergraduate undergraduate NOUN pipe-0093 47 31 students student NOUN pipe-0093 47 32 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 47 33 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 47 34 others other NOUN pipe-0093 47 35 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 47 36 price price NOUN pipe-0093 47 37 of of ADP pipe-0093 47 38 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 47 39 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 47 40 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 47 41 funding funding NOUN pipe-0093 47 42 sources source NOUN pipe-0093 47 43 included include VERB pipe-0093 47 44 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 48 1 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 48 2 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 48 3 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 48 4 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 48 5 has have AUX pipe-0093 48 6 been be AUX pipe-0093 48 7 used use VERB pipe-0093 48 8 to to PART pipe-0093 48 9 analyze analyze VERB pipe-0093 48 10 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 48 11 reimagine reimagine VERB pipe-0093 48 12 education education NOUN pipe-0093 48 13 for for ADP pipe-0093 48 14 over over ADP pipe-0093 48 15 50 50 NUM pipe-0093 48 16 years year NOUN pipe-0093 48 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 49 1 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 49 2 have have VERB pipe-0093 49 3 this this DET pipe-0093 49 4 potential potential NOUN pipe-0093 49 5 when when SCONJ pipe-0093 49 6 put put VERB pipe-0093 49 7 into into ADP pipe-0093 49 8 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 49 9 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 49 10 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 49 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 50 1 for for ADP pipe-0093 50 2 this this DET pipe-0093 50 3 review review NOUN pipe-0093 50 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 50 5 i i PRON pipe-0093 50 6 define define VERB pipe-0093 50 7 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 50 8 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 50 9 via via ADP pipe-0093 50 10 two two NUM pipe-0093 50 11 foundational foundational ADJ pipe-0093 50 12 texts text NOUN pipe-0093 50 13 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 50 14 paulo paulo PROPN pipe-0093 50 15 freire freire NOUN pipe-0093 50 16 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 50 17 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 50 18 of of ADP pipe-0093 50 19 the the DET pipe-0093 50 20 oppressed oppress VERB pipe-0093 50 21 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 50 22 1968 1968 NUM pipe-0093 50 23 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 50 24 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 50 25 bell bell PROPN pipe-0093 50 26 hooks hooks PROPN pipe-0093 50 27 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 50 28 teaching teaching NOUN pipe-0093 50 29 to to PART pipe-0093 50 30 transgress transgress NOUN pipe-0093 50 31 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 50 32 education education NOUN pipe-0093 50 33 as as ADP pipe-0093 50 34 the the DET pipe-0093 50 35 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 50 36 of of ADP pipe-0093 50 37 freedom freedom NOUN pipe-0093 50 38 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 50 39 1994 1994 NUM pipe-0093 50 40 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 50 41 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 51 1 brazilian brazilian ADJ pipe-0093 51 2 educator educator NOUN pipe-0093 51 3 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 51 4 theorist theorist NOUN pipe-0093 51 5 freire freire PROPN pipe-0093 51 6 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 51 7 1968 1968 NUM pipe-0093 51 8 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 51 9 argues argue VERB pipe-0093 51 10 for for ADP pipe-0093 51 11 liberatory liberatory ADJ pipe-0093 51 12 education education NOUN pipe-0093 51 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 51 14 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 51 15 [ [ X pipe-0093 51 16 w]here w]here ADJ pipe-0093 51 17 knowledge knowledge NOUN pipe-0093 51 18 emerges emerge VERB pipe-0093 51 19 only only ADV pipe-0093 51 20 through through ADP pipe-0093 51 21 invention invention NOUN pipe-0093 51 22 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 51 23 re re NOUN pipe-0093 51 24 - - NOUN pipe-0093 51 25 invention invention NOUN pipe-0093 51 26 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 51 27 through through ADP pipe-0093 51 28 the the DET pipe-0093 51 29 restless restless NOUN pipe-0093 51 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 51 31 impatient impatient ADJ pipe-0093 51 32 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 51 33 continuing continue VERB pipe-0093 51 34 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 51 35 hopeful hopeful ADJ pipe-0093 51 36 human human ADJ pipe-0093 51 37 inquiry inquiry NOUN pipe-0093 51 38 human human ADJ pipe-0093 51 39 beings being NOUN pipe-0093 51 40 pursue pursue VERB pipe-0093 51 41 in in ADP pipe-0093 51 42 the the DET pipe-0093 51 43 world world NOUN pipe-0093 51 44 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 51 45 with with ADP pipe-0093 51 46 the the DET pipe-0093 51 47 world world NOUN pipe-0093 51 48 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 51 49 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 51 50 with with ADP pipe-0093 51 51 each each DET pipe-0093 51 52 other other ADJ pipe-0093 51 53 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 51 54 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 51 55 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 51 56 72 72 NUM pipe-0093 51 57 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 51 58 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 52 1 teachers teacher NOUN pipe-0093 52 2 minimize minimize VERB pipe-0093 52 3 their their PRON pipe-0093 52 4 authoritative authoritative ADJ pipe-0093 52 5 role role NOUN pipe-0093 52 6 through through ADP pipe-0093 52 7 a a DET pipe-0093 52 8 reconciliation reconciliation NOUN pipe-0093 52 9 of of ADP pipe-0093 52 10 the the DET pipe-0093 52 11 teacher teacher NOUN pipe-0093 52 12 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 52 13 student student NOUN pipe-0093 52 14 contradiction contradiction NOUN pipe-0093 52 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 52 16 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 52 17 so so SCONJ pipe-0093 52 18 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 52 19 both both PRON pipe-0093 52 20 are be AUX pipe-0093 52 21 simultaneously simultaneously ADV pipe-0093 52 22 teachers teacher NOUN pipe-0093 52 23 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 52 24 students student NOUN pipe-0093 52 25 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 52 26 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 52 27 freire freire NOUN pipe-0093 52 28 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 52 29 1968 1968 NUM pipe-0093 52 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 52 31 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 52 32 72 72 NUM pipe-0093 52 33 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 52 34 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 53 1 this this DET pipe-0093 53 2 model model NOUN pipe-0093 53 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 53 4 education education NOUN pipe-0093 53 5 combats combat VERB pipe-0093 53 6 what what DET pipe-0093 53 7 freire freire NOUN pipe-0093 53 8 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 53 9 1968 1968 NUM pipe-0093 53 10 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 53 11 termed term VERB pipe-0093 53 12 the the DET pipe-0093 53 13 banking banking NOUN pipe-0093 53 14 concept concept NOUN pipe-0093 53 15 of of ADP pipe-0093 53 16 education education NOUN pipe-0093 53 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 53 18 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 53 19 in in ADP pipe-0093 53 20 which which PRON pipe-0093 53 21 the the DET pipe-0093 53 22 students student NOUN pipe-0093 53 23 are be AUX pipe-0093 53 24 the the DET pipe-0093 53 25 depositories depository NOUN pipe-0093 53 26 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 53 27 the the DET pipe-0093 53 28 teacher teacher NOUN pipe-0093 53 29 is be AUX pipe-0093 53 30 the the DET pipe-0093 53 31 depositor depositor NOUN pipe-0093 53 32 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 53 33 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 53 34 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 53 35 72 72 NUM pipe-0093 53 36 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 53 37 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 54 1 for for ADP pipe-0093 54 2 freire freire NOUN pipe-0093 54 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 54 4 education education NOUN pipe-0093 54 5 is be AUX pipe-0093 54 6 one one NUM pipe-0093 54 7 site site NOUN pipe-0093 54 8 in in ADP pipe-0093 54 9 the the DET pipe-0093 54 10 struggle struggle NOUN pipe-0093 54 11 against against ADP pipe-0093 54 12 larger large ADJ pipe-0093 54 13 forces force NOUN pipe-0093 54 14 of of ADP pipe-0093 54 15 oppression oppression NOUN pipe-0093 54 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 55 1 leveling level VERB pipe-0093 55 2 hierarchy hierarchy NOUN pipe-0093 55 3 as as ADV pipe-0093 55 4 much much ADV pipe-0093 55 5 as as ADP pipe-0093 55 6 possible possible ADJ pipe-0093 55 7 in in ADP pipe-0093 55 8 the the DET pipe-0093 55 9 student student NOUN pipe-0093 55 10 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 55 11 teacher teacher NOUN pipe-0093 55 12 relationship relationship NOUN pipe-0093 55 13 is be AUX pipe-0093 55 14 fundamental fundamental ADJ pipe-0093 55 15 to to ADP pipe-0093 55 16 the the DET pipe-0093 55 17 struggle struggle NOUN pipe-0093 55 18 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 56 1 though though SCONJ pipe-0093 56 2 his his PRON pipe-0093 56 3 ideas idea NOUN pipe-0093 56 4 have have AUX pipe-0093 56 5 influenced influence VERB pipe-0093 56 6 educators educator NOUN pipe-0093 56 7 throughout throughout ADP pipe-0093 56 8 the the DET pipe-0093 56 9 world world NOUN pipe-0093 56 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 56 11 freire freire PROPN pipe-0093 56 12 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 56 13 early early ADJ pipe-0093 56 14 writings writing NOUN pipe-0093 56 15 emerged emerge VERB pipe-0093 56 16 from from ADP pipe-0093 56 17 his his PRON pipe-0093 56 18 experience experience NOUN pipe-0093 56 19 teaching teach VERB pipe-0093 56 20 the the DET pipe-0093 56 21 illiterate illiterate ADJ pipe-0093 56 22 poor poor ADJ pipe-0093 56 23 in in ADP pipe-0093 56 24 brazil brazil PROPN pipe-0093 56 25 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 56 26 to to PART pipe-0093 56 27 read read VERB pipe-0093 56 28 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 57 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 57 2 the the DET pipe-0093 57 3 united united PROPN pipe-0093 57 4 states states PROPN pipe-0093 57 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 57 6 feminist feminist ADJ pipe-0093 57 7 educator educator NOUN pipe-0093 57 8 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 57 9 author author NOUN pipe-0093 57 10 bell bell PROPN pipe-0093 57 11 hooks hooks PROPN pipe-0093 57 12 has have AUX pipe-0093 57 13 explored explore VERB pipe-0093 57 14 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 57 15 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 57 16 for for ADP pipe-0093 57 17 decades decade NOUN pipe-0093 57 18 in in ADP pipe-0093 57 19 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 57 20 ed ed NOUN pipe-0093 57 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 57 22 as as SCONJ pipe-0093 57 23 it it PRON pipe-0093 57 24 intersects intersect VERB pipe-0093 57 25 with with ADP pipe-0093 57 26 race race NOUN pipe-0093 57 27 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 57 28 gender gender NOUN pipe-0093 57 29 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 57 30 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 57 31 class class NOUN pipe-0093 57 32 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 58 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 58 2 teaching teaching NOUN pipe-0093 58 3 to to ADP pipe-0093 58 4 transgress transgress NOUN pipe-0093 58 5 hooks hook NOUN pipe-0093 58 6 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 58 7 1994 1994 NUM pipe-0093 58 8 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 58 9 contrasts contrast VERB pipe-0093 58 10 her her PRON pipe-0093 58 11 ecstatic ecstatic ADJ pipe-0093 58 12 experience experience NOUN pipe-0093 58 13 of of ADP pipe-0093 58 14 education education NOUN pipe-0093 58 15 as as ADP pipe-0093 58 16 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 58 17 the the DET pipe-0093 58 18 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 58 19 of of ADP pipe-0093 58 20 freedom freedom NOUN pipe-0093 58 21 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 58 22 when when SCONJ pipe-0093 58 23 she she PRON pipe-0093 58 24 was be AUX pipe-0093 58 25 a a DET pipe-0093 58 26 child child NOUN pipe-0093 58 27 in in ADP pipe-0093 58 28 all all PRON pipe-0093 58 29 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 58 30 black black ADJ pipe-0093 58 31 schools school NOUN pipe-0093 58 32 in in ADP pipe-0093 58 33 the the DET pipe-0093 58 34 south south NOUN pipe-0093 58 35 with with ADP pipe-0093 58 36 the the DET pipe-0093 58 37 oppressive oppressive ADJ pipe-0093 58 38 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 58 39 racist racist ADJ pipe-0093 58 40 schools school NOUN pipe-0093 58 41 she she PRON pipe-0093 58 42 attended attend VERB pipe-0093 58 43 during during ADP pipe-0093 58 44 integration integration NOUN pipe-0093 58 45 that that PRON pipe-0093 58 46 strove strove VERB pipe-0093 58 47 to to PART pipe-0093 58 48 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 58 49 reinforce reinforce VERB pipe-0093 58 50 domination domination NOUN pipe-0093 58 51 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 58 52 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 58 53 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 58 54 4 4 NUM pipe-0093 58 55 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 58 56 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 59 1 for for ADP pipe-0093 59 2 hooks hook NOUN pipe-0093 59 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 59 4 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 59 5 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 59 6 means mean VERB pipe-0093 59 7 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 59 8 creating create VERB pipe-0093 59 9 [ [ X pipe-0093 59 10 a a X pipe-0093 59 11 ] ] X pipe-0093 59 12 democratic democratic ADJ pipe-0093 59 13 setting setting NOUN pipe-0093 59 14 where where SCONJ pipe-0093 59 15 everyone everyone PRON pipe-0093 59 16 feels feel VERB pipe-0093 59 17 a a DET pipe-0093 59 18 responsibility responsibility NOUN pipe-0093 59 19 to to PART pipe-0093 59 20 contribute contribute VERB pipe-0093 59 21 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 59 22 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 59 23 1994 1994 NUM pipe-0093 59 24 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 59 25 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 59 26 39 39 NUM pipe-0093 59 27 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 59 28 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 60 1 this this DET pipe-0093 60 2 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 60 3 requires require VERB pipe-0093 60 4 a a DET pipe-0093 60 5 desire desire NOUN pipe-0093 60 6 to to PART pipe-0093 60 7 transgress transgress VERB pipe-0093 60 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 60 9 to to PART pipe-0093 60 10 empower empower VERB pipe-0093 60 11 the the DET pipe-0093 60 12 oppressed oppress VERB pipe-0093 60 13 through through ADP pipe-0093 60 14 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 60 15 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 60 16 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 60 17 students student NOUN pipe-0093 60 18 of of ADP pipe-0093 60 19 color color NOUN pipe-0093 60 20 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 60 21 queer queer ADJ pipe-0093 60 22 students student NOUN pipe-0093 60 23 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 60 24 poor poor ADJ pipe-0093 60 25 students student NOUN pipe-0093 60 26 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 61 1 more more ADV pipe-0093 61 2 recently recently ADV pipe-0093 61 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 61 4 classroom classroom NOUN pipe-0093 61 5 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 61 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 61 7 librarians librarian NOUN pipe-0093 61 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 61 9 instructional instructional ADJ pipe-0093 61 10 designers designer NOUN pipe-0093 61 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 61 12 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 61 13 others other NOUN pipe-0093 61 14 in in ADP pipe-0093 61 15 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 61 16 education education NOUN pipe-0093 61 17 have have AUX pipe-0093 61 18 examined examine VERB pipe-0093 61 19 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 61 20 with with ADP pipe-0093 61 21 a a DET pipe-0093 61 22 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 61 23 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 61 24 perspective perspective NOUN pipe-0093 61 25 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 61 26 e.g. e.g. ADV pipe-0093 61 27 darder darder NOUN pipe-0093 61 28 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 61 29 torres torre NOUN pipe-0093 61 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 61 31 baltodano baltodano NOUN pipe-0093 61 32 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 61 33 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 61 34 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 61 35 accardi accardi NOUN pipe-0093 61 36 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 61 37 drabinski drabinski NOUN pipe-0093 61 38 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 61 39 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 61 40 kumbier kumbier NOUN pipe-0093 61 41 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 61 42 2010 2010 NUM pipe-0093 61 43 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 61 44 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 62 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 62 2 her her PRON pipe-0093 62 3 analysis analysis NOUN pipe-0093 62 4 of of ADP pipe-0093 62 5 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 62 6 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 62 7 the the DET pipe-0093 62 8 open open ADJ pipe-0093 62 9 access access NOUN pipe-0093 62 10 movement movement NOUN pipe-0093 62 11 in in ADP pipe-0093 62 12 libraries library NOUN pipe-0093 62 13 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 62 14 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 62 15 education education NOUN pipe-0093 62 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 62 17 crissinger crissinger NOUN pipe-0093 62 18 warns warn VERB pipe-0093 62 19 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 62 20 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 62 21 openness openness NOUN pipe-0093 62 22 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 62 23 when when SCONJ pipe-0093 62 24 disconnected disconnect VERB pipe-0093 62 25 from from ADP pipe-0093 62 26 its its PRON pipe-0093 62 27 political political ADJ pipe-0093 62 28 underpinnings underpinning NOUN pipe-0093 62 29 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 62 30 could could AUX pipe-0093 62 31 become become VERB pipe-0093 62 32 as as ADV pipe-0093 62 33 exploitative exploitative ADJ pipe-0093 62 34 as as ADP pipe-0093 62 35 the the DET pipe-0093 62 36 traditional traditional ADJ pipe-0093 62 37 system system NOUN pipe-0093 62 38 it it PRON pipe-0093 62 39 had have AUX pipe-0093 62 40 replaced replace VERB pipe-0093 62 41 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 62 42 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 62 43 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 62 44 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 62 45 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 63 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 63 2 analyzing analyze VERB pipe-0093 63 3 key key ADJ pipe-0093 63 4 texts text NOUN pipe-0093 63 5 of of ADP pipe-0093 63 6 open open ADJ pipe-0093 63 7 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 63 8 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 63 9 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 63 10 oep oep NOUN pipe-0093 63 11 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 63 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 63 13 lambert lambert NOUN pipe-0093 63 14 finds find VERB pipe-0093 63 15 little little ADJ pipe-0093 63 16 explicit explicit ADJ pipe-0093 63 17 social social ADJ pipe-0093 63 18 justice justice NOUN pipe-0093 63 19 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 63 20 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 63 21 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 63 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 64 1 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 64 2 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 64 3 must must AUX pipe-0093 64 4 be be AUX pipe-0093 64 5 a a DET pipe-0093 64 6 part part NOUN pipe-0093 64 7 of of ADP pipe-0093 64 8 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 64 9 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 64 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 65 1 if if SCONJ pipe-0093 65 2 students student NOUN pipe-0093 65 3 can can AUX pipe-0093 65 4 not not PART pipe-0093 65 5 afford afford VERB pipe-0093 65 6 a a DET pipe-0093 65 7 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 65 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 65 9 they they PRON pipe-0093 65 10 are be AUX pipe-0093 65 11 already already ADV pipe-0093 65 12 oppressed oppress VERB pipe-0093 65 13 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 66 1 faced face VERB pipe-0093 66 2 with with ADP pipe-0093 66 3 this this DET pipe-0093 66 4 contradiction contradiction NOUN pipe-0093 66 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 66 6 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 66 7 can can AUX pipe-0093 66 8 we we PRON pipe-0093 66 9 possibly possibly ADV pipe-0093 66 10 create create VERB pipe-0093 66 11 the the DET pipe-0093 66 12 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 66 13 democratic democratic ADJ pipe-0093 66 14 setting setting NOUN pipe-0093 66 15 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 66 16 hooks hook NOUN pipe-0093 66 17 strives strive VERB pipe-0093 66 18 for for ADP pipe-0093 66 19 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 67 1 replacing replace VERB pipe-0093 67 2 an an DET pipe-0093 67 3 expensive expensive ADJ pipe-0093 67 4 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 67 5 with with ADP pipe-0093 67 6 a a DET pipe-0093 67 7 free free ADJ pipe-0093 67 8 one one NOUN pipe-0093 67 9 is be AUX pipe-0093 67 10 not not PART pipe-0093 67 11 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 67 12 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 67 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 67 14 because because SCONJ pipe-0093 67 15 expensive expensive ADJ pipe-0093 67 16 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 67 17 are be AUX pipe-0093 67 18 one one NUM pipe-0093 67 19 symptom symptom NOUN pipe-0093 67 20 of of ADP pipe-0093 67 21 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 67 22 ed ed PROPN pipe-0093 67 23 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 67 24 disease disease PROPN pipe-0093 67 25 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 68 1 eliminating eliminate VERB pipe-0093 68 2 expensive expensive ADJ pipe-0093 68 3 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 68 4 is be AUX pipe-0093 68 5 a a DET pipe-0093 68 6 first first ADJ pipe-0093 68 7 step step NOUN pipe-0093 68 8 toward toward ADP pipe-0093 68 9 confronting confront VERB pipe-0093 68 10 the the DET pipe-0093 68 11 contradictions contradiction NOUN pipe-0093 68 12 students student NOUN pipe-0093 68 13 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 68 14 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 68 15 face face NOUN pipe-0093 68 16 in in ADP pipe-0093 68 17 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 68 18 ed ed NOUN pipe-0093 68 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 69 1 for for ADP pipe-0093 69 2 example example NOUN pipe-0093 69 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 69 4 five five NUM pipe-0093 69 5 publishers publisher NOUN pipe-0093 69 6 control control VERB pipe-0093 69 7 80 80 NUM pipe-0093 69 8 % % NOUN pipe-0093 69 9 of of ADP pipe-0093 69 10 the the DET pipe-0093 69 11 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 69 12 market market NOUN pipe-0093 69 13 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 69 14 senack senack NOUN pipe-0093 69 15 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 69 16 donoghue donoghue NOUN pipe-0093 69 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 69 18 2016 2016 NUM pipe-0093 69 19 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 69 20 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 69 21 4 4 NUM pipe-0093 69 22 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 69 23 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 69 24 over over ADP pipe-0093 69 25 70 70 NUM pipe-0093 69 26 % % NOUN pipe-0093 69 27 of of ADP pipe-0093 69 28 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 69 29 members member NOUN pipe-0093 69 30 hold hold VERB pipe-0093 69 31 contingent contingent NOUN pipe-0093 69 32 positions position NOUN pipe-0093 69 33 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 69 34 american american PROPN pipe-0093 69 35 association association PROPN pipe-0093 69 36 of of ADP pipe-0093 69 37 university university NOUN pipe-0093 69 38 professors professor NOUN pipe-0093 69 39 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 69 40 n.d n.d PROPN pipe-0093 69 41 . . PROPN pipe-0093 69 42 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 69 43 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 70 1 can can AUX pipe-0093 70 2 the the DET pipe-0093 70 3 strategic strategic ADJ pipe-0093 70 4 use use NOUN pipe-0093 70 5 of of ADP pipe-0093 70 6 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 70 7 effect effect NOUN pipe-0093 70 8 the the DET pipe-0093 70 9 kind kind NOUN pipe-0093 70 10 of of ADP pipe-0093 70 11 change change NOUN pipe-0093 70 12 in in ADP pipe-0093 70 13 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 70 14 education education NOUN pipe-0093 70 15 that that PRON pipe-0093 70 16 places place VERB pipe-0093 70 17 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 70 18 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 70 19 at at ADP pipe-0093 70 20 its its PRON pipe-0093 70 21 center center NOUN pipe-0093 70 22 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 70 23 eschews eschew VERB pipe-0093 70 24 the the DET pipe-0093 70 25 austerity austerity NOUN pipe-0093 70 26 mindset mindset NOUN pipe-0093 70 27 that that PRON pipe-0093 70 28 currently currently ADV pipe-0093 70 29 governs govern VERB pipe-0093 70 30 the the DET pipe-0093 70 31 field field NOUN pipe-0093 70 32 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 71 1 background background NOUN pipe-0093 71 2 some some DET pipe-0093 71 3 broader broad ADJ pipe-0093 71 4 context context NOUN pipe-0093 71 5 on on ADP pipe-0093 71 6 the the DET pipe-0093 71 7 unaffordability unaffordability NOUN pipe-0093 71 8 of of ADP pipe-0093 71 9 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 71 10 education education NOUN pipe-0093 71 11 is be AUX pipe-0093 71 12 necessary necessary ADJ pipe-0093 71 13 to to PART pipe-0093 71 14 understand understand VERB pipe-0093 71 15 why why SCONJ pipe-0093 71 16 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 71 17 are be AUX pipe-0093 71 18 a a DET pipe-0093 71 19 pressing press VERB pipe-0093 71 20 topic topic NOUN pipe-0093 71 21 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 72 1 first first ADV pipe-0093 72 2 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 72 3 foremost foremost ADV pipe-0093 72 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 72 5 the the DET pipe-0093 72 6 price price NOUN pipe-0093 72 7 of of ADP pipe-0093 72 8 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 72 9 education education NOUN pipe-0093 72 10 continues continue VERB pipe-0093 72 11 to to PART pipe-0093 72 12 increase increase VERB pipe-0093 72 13 as as SCONJ pipe-0093 72 14 the the DET pipe-0093 72 15 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 72 16 burden burden NOUN pipe-0093 72 17 has have AUX pipe-0093 72 18 been be AUX pipe-0093 72 19 shifted shift VERB pipe-0093 72 20 to to ADP pipe-0093 72 21 students student NOUN pipe-0093 72 22 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 72 23 their their PRON pipe-0093 72 24 families family NOUN pipe-0093 72 25 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 73 1 according accord VERB pipe-0093 73 2 to to ADP pipe-0093 73 3 the the DET pipe-0093 73 4 state state NOUN pipe-0093 73 5 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 73 6 education education NOUN pipe-0093 73 7 executive executive NOUN pipe-0093 73 8 officers officer NOUN pipe-0093 73 9 association association PROPN pipe-0093 73 10 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 73 11 sheeo sheeo PROPN pipe-0093 73 12 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 73 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 73 14 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 73 15 was be AUX pipe-0093 73 16 the the DET pipe-0093 73 17 first first ADJ pipe-0093 73 18 year year NOUN pipe-0093 73 19 a a DET pipe-0093 73 20 majority majority NOUN pipe-0093 73 21 of of ADP pipe-0093 73 22 states state NOUN pipe-0093 73 23 relied rely VERB pipe-0093 73 24 on on ADP pipe-0093 73 25 tuition tuition NOUN pipe-0093 73 26 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 73 27 fees fee NOUN pipe-0093 73 28 more more ADJ pipe-0093 73 29 than than ADP pipe-0093 73 30 state state NOUN pipe-0093 73 31 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 73 32 local local ADJ pipe-0093 73 33 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 73 34 appropriations appropriation NOUN pipe-0093 73 35 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 73 36 sheeo sheeo NOUN pipe-0093 73 37 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 73 38 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 73 39 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 73 40 pp pp PROPN pipe-0093 73 41 . . PROPN pipe-0093 74 1 8 8 NUM pipe-0093 74 2 - - SYM pipe-0093 74 3 9 9 NUM pipe-0093 74 4 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 74 5 to to PART pipe-0093 74 6 fund fund VERB pipe-0093 74 7 public public ADJ pipe-0093 74 8 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 74 9 education education NOUN pipe-0093 74 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 75 1 nationwide nationwide ADV pipe-0093 75 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 75 3 spending spend VERB pipe-0093 75 4 per per ADP pipe-0093 75 5 student student NOUN pipe-0093 75 6 by by ADP pipe-0093 75 7 public public ADJ pipe-0093 75 8 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 75 9 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 75 10 institutions institution NOUN pipe-0093 75 11 has have AUX pipe-0093 75 12 decreased decrease VERB pipe-0093 75 13 by by ADP pipe-0093 75 14 8 8 NUM pipe-0093 75 15 % % NOUN pipe-0093 75 16 since since SCONJ pipe-0093 75 17 1992 1992 NUM pipe-0093 75 18 while while SCONJ pipe-0093 75 19 per per ADP pipe-0093 75 20 student student NOUN pipe-0093 75 21 tuition tuition NOUN pipe-0093 75 22 has have AUX pipe-0093 75 23 increased increase VERB pipe-0093 75 24 96 96 NUM pipe-0093 75 25 % % NOUN pipe-0093 75 26 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 75 27 sheeo sheeo NOUN pipe-0093 75 28 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 75 29 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 75 30 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 75 31 brownstein brownstein NOUN pipe-0093 75 32 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 75 33 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 75 34 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 75 35 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 76 1 student student NOUN pipe-0093 76 2 debt debt NOUN pipe-0093 76 3 now now ADV pipe-0093 76 4 exceeds exceed VERB pipe-0093 76 5 individual individual ADJ pipe-0093 76 6 credit credit NOUN pipe-0093 76 7 card card NOUN pipe-0093 76 8 debt debt NOUN pipe-0093 76 9 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 76 10 johnson johnson PROPN pipe-0093 76 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 76 12 2019 2019 NUM pipe-0093 76 13 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 76 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 77 1 focusing focus VERB pipe-0093 77 2 on on ADP pipe-0093 77 3 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 77 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 77 5 the the DET pipe-0093 77 6 bureau bureau NOUN pipe-0093 77 7 of of ADP pipe-0093 77 8 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 77 9 statistics statistic NOUN pipe-0093 77 10 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 77 11 bls bls PROPN pipe-0093 77 12 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 77 13 reports report VERB pipe-0093 77 14 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 77 15 the the DET pipe-0093 77 16 price price NOUN pipe-0093 77 17 of of ADP pipe-0093 77 18 college college NOUN pipe-0093 77 19 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 77 20 has have AUX pipe-0093 77 21 increased increase VERB pipe-0093 77 22 88 88 NUM pipe-0093 77 23 % % NOUN pipe-0093 77 24 between between ADP pipe-0093 77 25 2006 2006 NUM pipe-0093 77 26 - - SYM pipe-0093 77 27 2016 2016 NUM pipe-0093 77 28 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 77 29 far far ADV pipe-0093 77 30 outpacing outpace VERB pipe-0093 77 31 tuition tuition NOUN pipe-0093 77 32 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 77 33 fees fee NOUN pipe-0093 77 34 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 77 35 college college NOUN pipe-0093 77 36 housing housing NOUN pipe-0093 77 37 during during ADP pipe-0093 77 38 the the DET pipe-0093 77 39 same same ADJ pipe-0093 77 40 period period NOUN pipe-0093 77 41 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 77 42 2016 2016 NUM pipe-0093 77 43 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 77 44 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 77 45 a a DET pipe-0093 77 46 similar similar ADJ pipe-0093 77 47 study study NOUN pipe-0093 77 48 by by ADP pipe-0093 77 49 the the DET pipe-0093 77 50 u.s u.s PROPN pipe-0093 77 51 . . PROPN pipe-0093 77 52 government government NOUN pipe-0093 77 53 accountability accountability NOUN pipe-0093 77 54 office office PROPN pipe-0093 77 55 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 77 56 gao gao PROPN pipe-0093 77 57 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 77 58 reached reach VERB pipe-0093 77 59 similar similar ADJ pipe-0093 77 60 results result NOUN pipe-0093 77 61 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 77 62 2013 2013 NUM pipe-0093 77 63 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 77 64 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 77 65 6 6 NUM pipe-0093 77 66 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 77 67 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 78 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 78 2 some some DET pipe-0093 78 3 cases case NOUN pipe-0093 78 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 78 5 the the DET pipe-0093 78 6 price price NOUN pipe-0093 78 7 of of ADP pipe-0093 78 8 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 78 9 is be AUX pipe-0093 78 10 greater great ADJ pipe-0093 78 11 than than ADP pipe-0093 78 12 the the DET pipe-0093 78 13 price price NOUN pipe-0093 78 14 of of ADP pipe-0093 78 15 tuition tuition NOUN pipe-0093 78 16 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 78 17 fischer fischer PROPN pipe-0093 78 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 78 19 hilton hilton PROPN pipe-0093 78 20 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 78 21 robinson robinson NOUN pipe-0093 78 22 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 78 23 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 78 24 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 78 25 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 78 26 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 78 27 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 78 28 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 78 29 160 160 NUM pipe-0093 78 30 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 78 31 goodwin goodwin NOUN pipe-0093 78 32 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 78 33 2011 2011 NUM pipe-0093 78 34 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 78 35 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 78 36 15 15 NUM pipe-0093 78 37 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 78 38 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 79 1 65 65 NUM pipe-0093 79 2 % % NOUN pipe-0093 79 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 79 4 surveyed survey VERB pipe-0093 79 5 students student NOUN pipe-0093 79 6 admitted admit VERB pipe-0093 79 7 high high ADJ pipe-0093 79 8 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 79 9 prevented prevent VERB pipe-0093 79 10 them they PRON pipe-0093 79 11 from from ADP pipe-0093 79 12 buying buy VERB pipe-0093 79 13 a a DET pipe-0093 79 14 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 79 15 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 79 16 senack senack NOUN pipe-0093 79 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 79 18 2014 2014 NUM pipe-0093 79 19 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 79 20 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 79 21 11 11 NUM pipe-0093 79 22 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 79 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 80 1 students student NOUN pipe-0093 80 2 specifically specifically ADV pipe-0093 80 3 cite cite VERB pipe-0093 80 4 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 80 5 prices price NOUN pipe-0093 80 6 as as ADP pipe-0093 80 7 an an DET pipe-0093 80 8 impediment impediment NOUN pipe-0093 80 9 preventing prevent VERB pipe-0093 80 10 them they PRON pipe-0093 80 11 from from ADP pipe-0093 80 12 passing pass VERB pipe-0093 80 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 80 14 completing complete VERB pipe-0093 80 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 80 16 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 80 17 even even ADV pipe-0093 80 18 enrolling enrol VERB pipe-0093 80 19 in in ADP pipe-0093 80 20 classes class NOUN pipe-0093 80 21 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 80 22 florida florida PROPN pipe-0093 80 23 virtual virtual ADJ pipe-0093 80 24 campus campus NOUN pipe-0093 80 25 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 80 26 2019 2019 NUM pipe-0093 80 27 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 80 28 pp pp PROPN pipe-0093 80 29 . . PROPN pipe-0093 81 1 31 31 NUM pipe-0093 81 2 - - SYM pipe-0093 81 3 32 32 NUM pipe-0093 81 4 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 81 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 82 1 therefore therefore ADV pipe-0093 82 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 82 3 reducing reduce VERB pipe-0093 82 4 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 82 5 eliminating eliminate VERB pipe-0093 82 6 the the DET pipe-0093 82 7 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 82 8 of of ADP pipe-0093 82 9 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 82 10 is be AUX pipe-0093 82 11 one one NUM pipe-0093 82 12 step step NOUN pipe-0093 82 13 toward toward ADP pipe-0093 82 14 lowering lower VERB pipe-0093 82 15 the the DET pipe-0093 82 16 barriers barrier NOUN pipe-0093 82 17 to to ADP pipe-0093 82 18 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 82 19 education education NOUN pipe-0093 82 20 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 83 1 scope scope NOUN pipe-0093 83 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 83 3 methods method NOUN pipe-0093 83 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 83 5 objectives objective VERB pipe-0093 83 6 this this DET pipe-0093 83 7 review review NOUN pipe-0093 83 8 is be AUX pipe-0093 83 9 limited limit VERB pipe-0093 83 10 to to PART pipe-0093 83 11 oer oer VERB pipe-0093 83 12 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 83 13 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 83 14 in in ADP pipe-0093 83 15 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 83 16 education education NOUN pipe-0093 83 17 published publish VERB pipe-0093 83 18 in in ADP pipe-0093 83 19 north north PROPN pipe-0093 83 20 america america PROPN pipe-0093 83 21 between between ADP pipe-0093 83 22 2008 2008 NUM pipe-0093 83 23 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 83 24 2019 2019 NUM pipe-0093 83 25 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 84 1 books book NOUN pipe-0093 84 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 84 3 news news NOUN pipe-0093 84 4 articles article NOUN pipe-0093 84 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 84 6 reports report NOUN pipe-0093 84 7 issued issue VERB pipe-0093 84 8 by by ADP pipe-0093 84 9 governmental governmental ADJ pipe-0093 84 10 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 84 11 non non ADJ pipe-0093 84 12 - - ADJ pipe-0093 84 13 profit profit ADJ pipe-0093 84 14 organizations organization NOUN pipe-0093 84 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 84 16 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 84 17 blogs blog NOUN pipe-0093 84 18 are be AUX pipe-0093 84 19 included include VERB pipe-0093 84 20 as as ADP pipe-0093 84 21 secondary secondary ADJ pipe-0093 84 22 sources source NOUN pipe-0093 84 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 85 1 the the DET pipe-0093 85 2 body body NOUN pipe-0093 85 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 85 4 literature literature NOUN pipe-0093 85 5 on on ADP pipe-0093 85 6 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 85 7 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 85 8 is be AUX pipe-0093 85 9 not not PART pipe-0093 85 10 voluminous voluminous ADJ pipe-0093 85 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 85 12 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 85 13 it it PRON pipe-0093 85 14 is be AUX pipe-0093 85 15 growing grow VERB pipe-0093 85 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 86 1 a a DET pipe-0093 86 2 comprehensive comprehensive ADJ pipe-0093 86 3 article article NOUN pipe-0093 86 4 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 86 5 length length NOUN pipe-0093 86 6 review review NOUN pipe-0093 86 7 is be AUX pipe-0093 86 8 not not PART pipe-0093 86 9 possible possible ADJ pipe-0093 86 10 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 86 11 desirable desirable ADJ pipe-0093 86 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 87 1 as as ADV pipe-0093 87 2 much much ADV pipe-0093 87 3 as as ADP pipe-0093 87 4 possible possible ADJ pipe-0093 87 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 87 6 the the DET pipe-0093 87 7 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 87 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 87 9 reports report NOUN pipe-0093 87 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 87 11 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 87 12 articles article NOUN pipe-0093 87 13 selected select VERB pipe-0093 87 14 for for ADP pipe-0093 87 15 this this DET pipe-0093 87 16 review review NOUN pipe-0093 87 17 are be AUX pipe-0093 87 18 published publish VERB pipe-0093 87 19 in in ADP pipe-0093 87 20 open open ADJ pipe-0093 87 21 access access NOUN pipe-0093 87 22 journals journal NOUN pipe-0093 87 23 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 87 24 websites website NOUN pipe-0093 87 25 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 87 26 though though SCONJ pipe-0093 87 27 articles article NOUN pipe-0093 87 28 from from ADP pipe-0093 87 29 the the DET pipe-0093 87 30 following follow VERB pipe-0093 87 31 databases database NOUN pipe-0093 87 32 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 87 33 search search NOUN pipe-0093 87 34 engines engine NOUN pipe-0093 87 35 were be AUX pipe-0093 87 36 used use VERB pipe-0093 87 37 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 87 38 education education NOUN pipe-0093 87 39 resources resource NOUN pipe-0093 87 40 information information NOUN pipe-0093 87 41 center center NOUN pipe-0093 87 42 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 87 43 eric eric PROPN pipe-0093 87 44 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 87 45 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 87 46 library library NOUN pipe-0093 87 47 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 87 48 information information NOUN pipe-0093 87 49 science science NOUN pipe-0093 87 50 source source NOUN pipe-0093 87 51 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 87 52 ebscohost ebscohost NOUN pipe-0093 87 53 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 87 54 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 87 55 education education NOUN pipe-0093 87 56 source source NOUN pipe-0093 87 57 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 87 58 ebscohost ebscohost NOUN pipe-0093 87 59 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 87 60 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 87 61 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 87 62 google google PROPN pipe-0093 87 63 scholar scholar PROPN pipe-0093 87 64 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 88 1 the the DET pipe-0093 88 2 open open ADJ pipe-0093 88 3 education education NOUN pipe-0093 88 4 group group NOUN pipe-0093 88 5 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 88 6 the the DET pipe-0093 88 7 review review NOUN pipe-0093 88 8 project project NOUN pipe-0093 88 9 is be AUX pipe-0093 88 10 an an DET pipe-0093 88 11 indispensable indispensable ADJ pipe-0093 88 12 resource resource NOUN pipe-0093 88 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 88 14 which which PRON pipe-0093 88 15 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 88 16 provides provide VERB pipe-0093 88 17 a a DET pipe-0093 88 18 summary summary NOUN pipe-0093 88 19 of of ADP pipe-0093 88 20 all all DET pipe-0093 88 21 known know VERB pipe-0093 88 22 empirical empirical ADJ pipe-0093 88 23 research research NOUN pipe-0093 88 24 on on ADP pipe-0093 88 25 the the DET pipe-0093 88 26 impacts impact NOUN pipe-0093 88 27 of of ADP pipe-0093 88 28 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 88 29 adoption adoption NOUN pipe-0093 88 30 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 88 31 including include VERB pipe-0093 88 32 our our PRON pipe-0093 88 33 own own ADJ pipe-0093 88 34 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 88 35 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 89 1 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 89 2 open open ADJ pipe-0093 89 3 education education NOUN pipe-0093 89 4 group group NOUN pipe-0093 89 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 89 6 2019 2019 NUM pipe-0093 89 7 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 89 8 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 90 1 to to ADP pipe-0093 90 2 date date NOUN pipe-0093 90 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 90 4 this this DET pipe-0093 90 5 ongoing ongoing ADJ pipe-0093 90 6 literature literature NOUN pipe-0093 90 7 review review NOUN pipe-0093 90 8 includes include VERB pipe-0093 90 9 48 48 NUM pipe-0093 90 10 peer peer NOUN pipe-0093 90 11 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 90 12 reviewed review VERB pipe-0093 90 13 articles article NOUN pipe-0093 90 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 90 15 theses these VERB pipe-0093 90 16 / / SYM pipe-0093 90 17 dissertations dissertation NOUN pipe-0093 90 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 90 19 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 90 20 white white ADJ pipe-0093 90 21 papers paper NOUN pipe-0093 90 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 91 1 the the DET pipe-0093 91 2 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 91 3 were be AUX pipe-0093 91 4 chosen choose VERB pipe-0093 91 5 as as ADP pipe-0093 91 6 a a DET pipe-0093 91 7 representative representative ADJ pipe-0093 91 8 sample sample NOUN pipe-0093 91 9 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 91 10 for for ADP pipe-0093 91 11 their their PRON pipe-0093 91 12 ability ability NOUN pipe-0093 91 13 to to PART pipe-0093 91 14 meet meet VERB pipe-0093 91 15 the the DET pipe-0093 91 16 criteria criterion NOUN pipe-0093 91 17 discussed discuss VERB pipe-0093 91 18 above above ADV pipe-0093 91 19 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 91 20 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 91 21 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 91 22 access access NOUN pipe-0093 91 23 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 91 24 pedagogical pedagogical ADJ pipe-0093 91 25 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 91 26 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 91 27 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 91 28 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 91 29 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 91 30 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 92 1 past past ADJ pipe-0093 92 2 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 92 3 current current ADJ pipe-0093 92 4 literature literature NOUN pipe-0093 92 5 reviews review NOUN pipe-0093 92 6 on on ADP pipe-0093 92 7 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 92 8 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 92 9 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 92 10 hilton hilton PROPN pipe-0093 92 11 iii iii PROPN pipe-0093 92 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 92 13 2016 2016 NUM pipe-0093 92 14 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 92 15 abri abri PROPN pipe-0093 92 16 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 92 17 dabbagh dabbagh NOUN pipe-0093 92 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 92 19 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 92 20 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 92 21 hilton hilton PROPN pipe-0093 92 22 iii iii PROPN pipe-0093 92 23 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 92 24 2019 2019 NUM pipe-0093 92 25 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 92 26 emphasize emphasize VERB pipe-0093 92 27 quantitative quantitative ADJ pipe-0093 92 28 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 92 29 qualitative qualitative ADJ pipe-0093 92 30 data datum NOUN pipe-0093 92 31 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 92 32 survey survey NOUN pipe-0093 92 33 design design NOUN pipe-0093 92 34 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 93 1 following follow VERB pipe-0093 93 2 crissinger crissinger NOUN pipe-0093 93 3 ’s ’s X pipe-0093 93 4 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 93 5 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 93 6 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 93 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 93 8 lambert lambert PROPN pipe-0093 93 9 ’s ’s X pipe-0093 93 10 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 93 11 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 93 12 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 93 13 analyses analysis NOUN pipe-0093 93 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 93 15 the the DET pipe-0093 93 16 objective objective NOUN pipe-0093 93 17 for for ADP pipe-0093 93 18 this this DET pipe-0093 93 19 study study NOUN pipe-0093 93 20 is be AUX pipe-0093 93 21 to to PART pipe-0093 93 22 search search VERB pipe-0093 93 23 for for ADP pipe-0093 93 24 evidence evidence NOUN pipe-0093 93 25 of of ADP pipe-0093 93 26 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 93 27 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 93 28 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 93 29 social social ADJ pipe-0093 93 30 justice justice NOUN pipe-0093 93 31 in in ADP pipe-0093 93 32 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 93 33 efficacy efficacy PROPN pipe-0093 93 34 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 93 35 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 94 1 analysis analysis NOUN pipe-0093 94 2 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 94 3 commentary commentary NOUN pipe-0093 94 4 this this DET pipe-0093 94 5 section section NOUN pipe-0093 94 6 organizes organize VERB pipe-0093 94 7 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 94 8 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 94 9 case case NOUN pipe-0093 94 10 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 94 11 into into ADP pipe-0093 94 12 three three NUM pipe-0093 94 13 subsections subsection NOUN pipe-0093 94 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 95 1 these these DET pipe-0093 95 2 subsections subsection NOUN pipe-0093 95 3 are be AUX pipe-0093 95 4 organized organize VERB pipe-0093 95 5 in in ADP pipe-0093 95 6 descending descend VERB pipe-0093 95 7 order order NOUN pipe-0093 95 8 by by ADP pipe-0093 95 9 the the DET pipe-0093 95 10 frequency frequency NOUN pipe-0093 95 11 with with ADP pipe-0093 95 12 which which PRON pipe-0093 95 13 they they PRON pipe-0093 95 14 are be AUX pipe-0093 95 15 addressed address VERB pipe-0093 95 16 in in ADP pipe-0093 95 17 the the DET pipe-0093 95 18 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 95 19 under under ADP pipe-0093 95 20 review review NOUN pipe-0093 95 21 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 96 1 1 1 NUM pipe-0093 96 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 97 1 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 97 2 reduction reduction NOUN pipe-0093 97 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 97 4 increased increase VERB pipe-0093 97 5 access access NOUN pipe-0093 97 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 97 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 97 8 student student NOUN pipe-0093 97 9 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 97 10 every every DET pipe-0093 97 11 study study NOUN pipe-0093 97 12 addresses address VERB pipe-0093 97 13 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 97 14 oer oer ADJ pipe-0093 97 15 help help NOUN pipe-0093 97 16 reduce reduce VERB pipe-0093 97 17 the the DET pipe-0093 97 18 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 97 19 of of ADP pipe-0093 97 20 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 97 21 education education NOUN pipe-0093 97 22 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 97 23 increases increase VERB pipe-0093 97 24 access access NOUN pipe-0093 97 25 to to ADP pipe-0093 97 26 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 97 27 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 97 28 learning learning NOUN pipe-0093 97 29 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 97 30 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 98 1 the the DET pipe-0093 98 2 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 98 3 measure measure VERB pipe-0093 98 4 student student NOUN pipe-0093 98 5 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 98 6 in in ADP pipe-0093 98 7 classes class NOUN pipe-0093 98 8 using use VERB pipe-0093 98 9 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 98 10 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 98 11 test test NOUN pipe-0093 98 12 group group NOUN pipe-0093 98 13 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 98 14 compared compare VERB pipe-0093 98 15 with with ADP pipe-0093 98 16 classes class NOUN pipe-0093 98 17 using use VERB pipe-0093 98 18 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 98 19 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 98 20 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 98 21 control control NOUN pipe-0093 98 22 group group NOUN pipe-0093 98 23 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 98 24 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 98 25 student student NOUN pipe-0093 98 26 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 98 27 include include VERB pipe-0093 98 28 a a DET pipe-0093 98 29 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 98 30 b b PROPN pipe-0093 98 31 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 98 32 c c PRON pipe-0093 98 33 grades grade NOUN pipe-0093 98 34 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 98 35 d d PROPN pipe-0093 98 36 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 98 37 f f INTJ pipe-0093 98 38 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 98 39 withdrawal withdrawal NOUN pipe-0093 98 40 rates rate NOUN pipe-0093 98 41 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 98 42 enrollment enrollment NOUN pipe-0093 98 43 intensity intensity NOUN pipe-0093 98 44 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 98 45 final final ADJ pipe-0093 98 46 exam exam NOUN pipe-0093 98 47 grades grade NOUN pipe-0093 98 48 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 98 49 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 98 50 others other NOUN pipe-0093 98 51 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 99 1 often often ADV pipe-0093 99 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 99 3 student student NOUN pipe-0093 99 4 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 99 5 are be AUX pipe-0093 99 6 similar similar ADJ pipe-0093 99 7 across across ADP pipe-0093 99 8 the the DET pipe-0093 99 9 test test NOUN pipe-0093 99 10 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 99 11 control control NOUN pipe-0093 99 12 groups group NOUN pipe-0093 99 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 99 14 though though SCONJ pipe-0093 99 15 some some DET pipe-0093 99 16 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 99 17 present present VERB pipe-0093 99 18 a a DET pipe-0093 99 19 case case NOUN pipe-0093 99 20 for for ADP pipe-0093 99 21 correlation correlation NOUN pipe-0093 99 22 between between ADP pipe-0093 99 23 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 99 24 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 99 25 access access NOUN pipe-0093 99 26 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 99 27 improved improved ADJ pipe-0093 99 28 student student NOUN pipe-0093 99 29 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 99 30 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 100 1 2 2 NUM pipe-0093 100 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 100 3 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 100 4 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 100 5 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 100 6 some some DET pipe-0093 100 7 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 100 8 provide provide VERB pipe-0093 100 9 details detail NOUN pipe-0093 100 10 about about ADP pipe-0093 100 11 the the DET pipe-0093 100 12 pedagogical pedagogical ADJ pipe-0093 100 13 decisions decision NOUN pipe-0093 100 14 made make VERB pipe-0093 100 15 with with ADP pipe-0093 100 16 regard regard NOUN pipe-0093 100 17 to to ADP pipe-0093 100 18 oer oer VERB pipe-0093 100 19 adoption adoption NOUN pipe-0093 100 20 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 101 1 for for ADP pipe-0093 101 2 example example NOUN pipe-0093 101 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 101 4 which which PRON pipe-0093 101 5 oer oer VERB pipe-0093 101 6 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 101 7 replaced replace VERB pipe-0093 101 8 the the DET pipe-0093 101 9 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 101 10 option option NOUN pipe-0093 101 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 102 1 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 102 2 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 102 3 rarely rarely ADV pipe-0093 102 4 name name VERB pipe-0093 102 5 the the DET pipe-0093 102 6 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 102 7 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 102 8 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 103 1 even even ADV pipe-0093 103 2 fewer few ADJ pipe-0093 103 3 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 103 4 discuss discuss VERB pipe-0093 103 5 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 103 6 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 103 7 intersect intersect ADJ pipe-0093 103 8 with with ADP pipe-0093 103 9 pedagogical pedagogical ADJ pipe-0093 103 10 theories theory NOUN pipe-0093 103 11 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 103 12 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 103 13 / / SYM pipe-0093 103 14 student student NOUN pipe-0093 103 15 / / SYM pipe-0093 103 16 staff staff NOUN pipe-0093 103 17 collaborations collaboration NOUN pipe-0093 103 18 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 104 1 3 3 NUM pipe-0093 104 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 104 3 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 104 4 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 104 5 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 104 6 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 104 7 rarest rare ADJ pipe-0093 104 8 of of ADP pipe-0093 104 9 all all PRON pipe-0093 104 10 is be AUX pipe-0093 104 11 the the DET pipe-0093 104 12 study study NOUN pipe-0093 104 13 that that PRON pipe-0093 104 14 provides provide VERB pipe-0093 104 15 details detail NOUN pipe-0093 104 16 about about ADP pipe-0093 104 17 the the DET pipe-0093 104 18 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 104 19 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 104 20 required require VERB pipe-0093 104 21 for for ADP pipe-0093 104 22 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 104 23 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 104 24 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 105 1 adopting adopt VERB pipe-0093 105 2 an an DET pipe-0093 105 3 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 105 4 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 105 5 may may AUX pipe-0093 105 6 require require VERB pipe-0093 105 7 a a DET pipe-0093 105 8 significant significant ADJ pipe-0093 105 9 amount amount NOUN pipe-0093 105 10 of of ADP pipe-0093 105 11 work work NOUN pipe-0093 105 12 for for ADP pipe-0093 105 13 a a DET pipe-0093 105 14 single single ADJ pipe-0093 105 15 professor professor NOUN pipe-0093 105 16 teaching teach VERB pipe-0093 105 17 a a DET pipe-0093 105 18 single single ADJ pipe-0093 105 19 section section NOUN pipe-0093 105 20 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 106 1 the the DET pipe-0093 106 2 number number NOUN pipe-0093 106 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 106 4 people people NOUN pipe-0093 106 5 only only ADV pipe-0093 106 6 increases increase VERB pipe-0093 106 7 for for ADP pipe-0093 106 8 large large ADJ pipe-0093 106 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 106 10 multi multi ADJ pipe-0093 106 11 - - ADJ pipe-0093 106 12 section section ADJ pipe-0093 106 13 courses course NOUN pipe-0093 106 14 reliant reliant ADJ pipe-0093 106 15 on on ADP pipe-0093 106 16 course course NOUN pipe-0093 106 17 management management NOUN pipe-0093 106 18 software software NOUN pipe-0093 106 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 107 1 very very ADV pipe-0093 107 2 few few ADJ pipe-0093 107 3 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 107 4 detail detail VERB pipe-0093 107 5 the the DET pipe-0093 107 6 personnel personnel NOUN pipe-0093 107 7 involved involve VERB pipe-0093 107 8 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 107 9 the the DET pipe-0093 107 10 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 107 11 required require VERB pipe-0093 107 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 108 1 some some DET pipe-0093 108 2 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 108 3 are be AUX pipe-0093 108 4 discussed discuss VERB pipe-0093 108 5 in in ADP pipe-0093 108 6 more more ADJ pipe-0093 108 7 than than ADP pipe-0093 108 8 one one NUM pipe-0093 108 9 subsection subsection NOUN pipe-0093 108 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 108 11 though though SCONJ pipe-0093 108 12 each each DET pipe-0093 108 13 subsection subsection NOUN pipe-0093 108 14 foregrounds foreground VERB pipe-0093 108 15 one one NUM pipe-0093 108 16 of of ADP pipe-0093 108 17 the the DET pipe-0093 108 18 above above ADJ pipe-0093 108 19 topics topic NOUN pipe-0093 108 20 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 109 1 while while SCONJ pipe-0093 109 2 i i PRON pipe-0093 109 3 use use VERB pipe-0093 109 4 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 109 5 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 109 6 as as ADP pipe-0093 109 7 a a DET pipe-0093 109 8 lens lens NOUN pipe-0093 109 9 to to PART pipe-0093 109 10 analyze analyze VERB pipe-0093 109 11 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 109 12 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 109 13 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 109 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 109 15 i i PRON pipe-0093 109 16 am be AUX pipe-0093 109 17 not not PART pipe-0093 109 18 primarily primarily ADV pipe-0093 109 19 concerned concerned ADJ pipe-0093 109 20 with with ADP pipe-0093 109 21 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 109 22 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 109 23 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 109 24 is be AUX pipe-0093 109 25 used use VERB pipe-0093 109 26 in in ADP pipe-0093 109 27 specific specific ADJ pipe-0093 109 28 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 109 29 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 109 30 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 109 31 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 109 32 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 109 33 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 110 1 the the DET pipe-0093 110 2 below below ADJ pipe-0093 110 3 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 110 4 do do AUX pipe-0093 110 5 not not PART pipe-0093 110 6 provide provide VERB pipe-0093 110 7 such such ADJ pipe-0093 110 8 granular granular ADJ pipe-0093 110 9 detail detail NOUN pipe-0093 110 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 111 1 instead instead ADV pipe-0093 111 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 111 3 i i PRON pipe-0093 111 4 am be AUX pipe-0093 111 5 analyzing analyze VERB pipe-0093 111 6 these these DET pipe-0093 111 7 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 111 8 for for ADP pipe-0093 111 9 evidence evidence NOUN pipe-0093 111 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 111 11 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 111 12 lack lack NOUN pipe-0093 111 13 thereof thereof ADV pipe-0093 111 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 111 15 of of ADP pipe-0093 111 16 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 111 17 approaches approach NOUN pipe-0093 111 18 to to PART pipe-0093 111 19 oer oer VERB pipe-0093 111 20 adoption adoption NOUN pipe-0093 111 21 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 111 22 survey survey NOUN pipe-0093 111 23 design design NOUN pipe-0093 111 24 as as SCONJ pipe-0093 111 25 it it PRON pipe-0093 111 26 relates relate VERB pipe-0093 111 27 to to PART pipe-0093 111 28 cost cost VERB pipe-0093 111 29 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 111 30 access access NOUN pipe-0093 111 31 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 111 32 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 111 33 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 111 34 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 111 35 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 111 36 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 111 37 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 112 1 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 112 2 reduction reduction NOUN pipe-0093 112 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 112 4 increased increase VERB pipe-0093 112 5 access access NOUN pipe-0093 112 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 112 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 112 8 student student NOUN pipe-0093 112 9 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 112 10 many many ADJ pipe-0093 112 11 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 112 12 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 112 13 identify identify VERB pipe-0093 112 14 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 112 15 reduction reduction NOUN pipe-0093 112 16 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 112 17 increased increase VERB pipe-0093 112 18 access access NOUN pipe-0093 112 19 as as ADP pipe-0093 112 20 the the DET pipe-0093 112 21 initial initial ADJ pipe-0093 112 22 motivation motivation NOUN pipe-0093 112 23 for for ADP pipe-0093 112 24 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 112 25 adoption adoption NOUN pipe-0093 112 26 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 113 1 the the DET pipe-0093 113 2 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 113 3 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 113 4 investigators investigator NOUN pipe-0093 113 5 then then ADV pipe-0093 113 6 track track VERB pipe-0093 113 7 student student NOUN pipe-0093 113 8 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 113 9 for for ADP pipe-0093 113 10 test test NOUN pipe-0093 113 11 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 113 12 control control NOUN pipe-0093 113 13 groups group NOUN pipe-0093 113 14 across across ADP pipe-0093 113 15 a a DET pipe-0093 113 16 variety variety NOUN pipe-0093 113 17 of of ADP pipe-0093 113 18 metrics metric NOUN pipe-0093 113 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 114 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 114 2 nearly you ADV pipe-0093 114 3 all all PRON pipe-0093 114 4 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 114 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 114 6 student student NOUN pipe-0093 114 7 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 114 8 are be AUX pipe-0093 114 9 the the DET pipe-0093 114 10 same same ADJ pipe-0093 114 11 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 114 12 better well ADJ pipe-0093 114 13 in in ADP pipe-0093 114 14 classes class NOUN pipe-0093 114 15 taught teach VERB pipe-0093 114 16 with with ADP pipe-0093 114 17 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 114 18 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 115 1 the the DET pipe-0093 115 2 university university PROPN pipe-0093 115 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 115 4 california california PROPN pipe-0093 115 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 115 6 davis davis PROPN pipe-0093 115 7 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 115 8 uc uc PROPN pipe-0093 115 9 davis davis PROPN pipe-0093 115 10 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 115 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 115 12 created create VERB pipe-0093 115 13 the the DET pipe-0093 115 14 stemwiki stemwiki ADJ pipe-0093 115 15 hyperlibrary hyperlibrary NOUN pipe-0093 115 16 to to PART pipe-0093 115 17 provide provide VERB pipe-0093 115 18 students student NOUN pipe-0093 115 19 with with ADP pipe-0093 115 20 a a DET pipe-0093 115 21 no no DET pipe-0093 115 22 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 115 23 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 115 24 replacement replacement NOUN pipe-0093 115 25 for for ADP pipe-0093 115 26 existing exist VERB pipe-0093 115 27 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 115 28 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 115 29 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 115 30 allen allen PROPN pipe-0093 115 31 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 115 32 guzman guzman PROPN pipe-0093 115 33 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 115 34 alvarez alvarez PROPN pipe-0093 115 35 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 115 36 molinaro molinaro NOUN pipe-0093 115 37 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 115 38 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 115 39 larsen larsen PROPN pipe-0093 115 40 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 115 41 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 115 42 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 115 43 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 115 44 3 3 NUM pipe-0093 115 45 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 115 46 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 116 1 chemwiki chemwiki ADJ pipe-0093 116 2 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 116 3 part part NOUN pipe-0093 116 4 of of ADP pipe-0093 116 5 the the DET pipe-0093 116 6 hyperlibrary hyperlibrary NOUN pipe-0093 116 7 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 116 8 was be AUX pipe-0093 116 9 used use VERB pipe-0093 116 10 as as ADP pipe-0093 116 11 the the DET pipe-0093 116 12 exclusive exclusive ADJ pipe-0093 116 13 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 116 14 in in ADP pipe-0093 116 15 seven seven NUM pipe-0093 116 16 chemistry chemistry NOUN pipe-0093 116 17 classes class NOUN pipe-0093 116 18 at at ADP pipe-0093 116 19 uc uc PROPN pipe-0093 116 20 davis davis PROPN pipe-0093 116 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 116 22 purdue purdue PROPN pipe-0093 116 23 university university PROPN pipe-0093 116 24 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 116 25 sacramento sacramento PROPN pipe-0093 116 26 city city PROPN pipe-0093 116 27 college college NOUN pipe-0093 116 28 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 116 29 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 116 30 howard howard PROPN pipe-0093 116 31 university university PROPN pipe-0093 116 32 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 117 1 allen allen PROPN pipe-0093 117 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 117 3 et et PROPN pipe-0093 117 4 al al PROPN pipe-0093 117 5 . . PROPN pipe-0093 117 6 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 117 7 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 117 8 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 117 9 claim claim VERB pipe-0093 117 10 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 117 11 chemwiki chemwiki ADJ pipe-0093 117 12 implementation implementation NOUN pipe-0093 117 13 saved save VERB pipe-0093 117 14 students student NOUN pipe-0093 117 15 approximately approximately ADV pipe-0093 117 16 $ $ SYM pipe-0093 117 17 500,000 500,000 NUM pipe-0093 117 18 dollars dollar NOUN pipe-0093 117 19 in in ADP pipe-0093 117 20 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 117 21 expenditures expenditure NOUN pipe-0093 117 22 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 117 23 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 117 24 3 3 NUM pipe-0093 117 25 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 117 26 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 117 27 though though SCONJ pipe-0093 117 28 the the DET pipe-0093 117 29 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 117 30 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 117 31 replaced replace VERB pipe-0093 117 32 by by ADP pipe-0093 117 33 chemwiki chemwiki NOUN pipe-0093 117 34 is be AUX pipe-0093 117 35 not not PART pipe-0093 117 36 mentioned mention VERB pipe-0093 117 37 by by ADP pipe-0093 117 38 name name NOUN pipe-0093 117 39 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 118 1 it it PRON pipe-0093 118 2 is be AUX pipe-0093 118 3 not not PART pipe-0093 118 4 clear clear ADJ pipe-0093 118 5 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 118 6 the the DET pipe-0093 118 7 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 118 8 arrived arrive VERB pipe-0093 118 9 at at ADP pipe-0093 118 10 this this DET pipe-0093 118 11 figure figure NOUN pipe-0093 118 12 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 118 13 perhaps perhaps ADV pipe-0093 118 14 it it PRON pipe-0093 118 15 is be AUX pipe-0093 118 16 based base VERB pipe-0093 118 17 on on ADP pipe-0093 118 18 an an DET pipe-0093 118 19 estimate estimate NOUN pipe-0093 118 20 assuming assume VERB pipe-0093 118 21 all all DET pipe-0093 118 22 students student NOUN pipe-0093 118 23 purchased purchase VERB pipe-0093 118 24 the the DET pipe-0093 118 25 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 118 26 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 118 27 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 119 1 all all DET pipe-0093 119 2 available available ADJ pipe-0093 119 3 research research NOUN pipe-0093 119 4 indicates indicate VERB pipe-0093 119 5 many many ADJ pipe-0093 119 6 students student NOUN pipe-0093 119 7 do do AUX pipe-0093 119 8 not not PART pipe-0093 119 9 purchase purchase VERB pipe-0093 119 10 expensive expensive ADJ pipe-0093 119 11 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 119 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 120 1 such such ADJ pipe-0093 120 2 opacity opacity NOUN pipe-0093 120 3 is be AUX pipe-0093 120 4 not not PART pipe-0093 120 5 helpful helpful ADJ pipe-0093 120 6 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 121 1 for for SCONJ pipe-0093 121 2 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 121 3 to to PART pipe-0093 121 4 flourish flourish VERB pipe-0093 121 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 121 6 it it PRON pipe-0093 121 7 is be AUX pipe-0093 121 8 important important ADJ pipe-0093 121 9 to to PART pipe-0093 121 10 name name VERB pipe-0093 121 11 the the DET pipe-0093 121 12 resources resource NOUN pipe-0093 121 13 being be AUX pipe-0093 121 14 replaced replace VERB pipe-0093 121 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 121 16 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 121 17 their their PRON pipe-0093 121 18 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 121 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 122 1 readers reader NOUN pipe-0093 122 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 122 3 especially especially ADV pipe-0093 122 4 those those PRON pipe-0093 122 5 considering consider VERB pipe-0093 122 6 adopting adopt VERB pipe-0093 122 7 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 122 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 122 9 deserve deserve VERB pipe-0093 122 10 to to PART pipe-0093 122 11 know know VERB pipe-0093 122 12 these these DET pipe-0093 122 13 details detail NOUN pipe-0093 122 14 to to PART pipe-0093 122 15 help help VERB pipe-0093 122 16 them they PRON pipe-0093 122 17 make make VERB pipe-0093 122 18 informed informed ADJ pipe-0093 122 19 decisions decision NOUN pipe-0093 122 20 at at ADP pipe-0093 122 21 their their PRON pipe-0093 122 22 own own ADJ pipe-0093 122 23 institutions institution NOUN pipe-0093 122 24 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 123 1 the the DET pipe-0093 123 2 virginia virginia PROPN pipe-0093 123 3 state state PROPN pipe-0093 123 4 university university PROPN pipe-0093 123 5 school school NOUN pipe-0093 123 6 of of ADP pipe-0093 123 7 business business NOUN pipe-0093 123 8 turned turn VERB pipe-0093 123 9 to to PART pipe-0093 123 10 oer oer VERB pipe-0093 123 11 in in ADP pipe-0093 123 12 hopes hope NOUN pipe-0093 123 13 of of ADP pipe-0093 123 14 reducing reduce VERB pipe-0093 123 15 inequality inequality NOUN pipe-0093 123 16 in in ADP pipe-0093 123 17 the the DET pipe-0093 123 18 classroom classroom NOUN pipe-0093 123 19 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 123 20 improving improve VERB pipe-0093 123 21 student student NOUN pipe-0093 123 22 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 123 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 124 1 prior prior ADV pipe-0093 124 2 to to ADP pipe-0093 124 3 this this DET pipe-0093 124 4 study study NOUN pipe-0093 124 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 124 6 only only ADV pipe-0093 124 7 47 47 NUM pipe-0093 124 8 % % NOUN pipe-0093 124 9 of of ADP pipe-0093 124 10 vsu vsu NOUN pipe-0093 124 11 students student NOUN pipe-0093 124 12 purchased purchase VERB pipe-0093 124 13 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 124 14 for for ADP pipe-0093 124 15 their their PRON pipe-0093 124 16 courses course NOUN pipe-0093 124 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 125 1 students student NOUN pipe-0093 125 2 cited cite VERB pipe-0093 125 3 affordability affordability NOUN pipe-0093 125 4 as as ADP pipe-0093 125 5 the the DET pipe-0093 125 6 primary primary ADJ pipe-0093 125 7 barrier barrier NOUN pipe-0093 125 8 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 125 9 many many ADJ pipe-0093 125 10 vsu vsu NOUN pipe-0093 125 11 students student NOUN pipe-0093 125 12 struggle struggle VERB pipe-0093 125 13 financially financially ADV pipe-0093 125 14 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 125 15 work work VERB pipe-0093 125 16 at at ADV pipe-0093 125 17 least least ADV pipe-0093 125 18 one one NUM pipe-0093 125 19 job job NOUN pipe-0093 125 20 in in ADP pipe-0093 125 21 addition addition NOUN pipe-0093 125 22 to to ADP pipe-0093 125 23 their their PRON pipe-0093 125 24 full full ADJ pipe-0093 125 25 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 125 26 time time NOUN pipe-0093 125 27 courseload courseload NOUN pipe-0093 125 28 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 125 29 feldstein feldstein PROPN pipe-0093 125 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 125 31 hilton hilton PROPN pipe-0093 125 32 iii iii PROPN pipe-0093 125 33 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 125 34 hudson hudson PROPN pipe-0093 125 35 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 125 36 martin martin PROPN pipe-0093 125 37 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 125 38 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 125 39 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 125 40 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 125 41 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 125 42 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 125 43 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 125 44 1 1 NUM pipe-0093 125 45 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 125 46 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 126 1 vsu vsu PROPN pipe-0093 126 2 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 126 3 investigated investigate VERB pipe-0093 126 4 ebook ebook NOUN pipe-0093 126 5 alternatives alternative NOUN pipe-0093 126 6 in in ADP pipe-0093 126 7 order order NOUN pipe-0093 126 8 to to PART pipe-0093 126 9 lower lower VERB pipe-0093 126 10 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 126 11 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 126 12 ensure ensure VERB pipe-0093 126 13 students student NOUN pipe-0093 126 14 would would AUX pipe-0093 126 15 have have VERB pipe-0093 126 16 ongoing ongoing ADJ pipe-0093 126 17 access access NOUN pipe-0093 126 18 to to ADP pipe-0093 126 19 course course NOUN pipe-0093 126 20 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 126 21 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 127 1 they they PRON pipe-0093 127 2 contracted contract VERB pipe-0093 127 3 flat flat ADJ pipe-0093 127 4 world world NOUN pipe-0093 127 5 knowledge knowledge NOUN pipe-0093 127 6 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 127 7 fwk fwk NOUN pipe-0093 127 8 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 127 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 127 10 then then ADV pipe-0093 127 11 an an DET pipe-0093 127 12 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 127 13 provider provider NOUN pipe-0093 127 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 127 15 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 127 16 paid pay VERB pipe-0093 127 17 for for ADP pipe-0093 127 18 per per ADP pipe-0093 127 19 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 127 20 student student NOUN pipe-0093 127 21 seat seat NOUN pipe-0093 127 22 licenses license NOUN pipe-0093 127 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 128 1 vsu vsu PROPN pipe-0093 128 2 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 128 3 purposely purposely ADV pipe-0093 128 4 avoided avoid VERB pipe-0093 128 5 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 128 6 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 128 7 proprietary proprietary ADJ pipe-0093 128 8 platforms platform NOUN pipe-0093 128 9 that that PRON pipe-0093 128 10 would would AUX pipe-0093 128 11 restrict restrict VERB pipe-0093 128 12 access access NOUN pipe-0093 128 13 for for ADP pipe-0093 128 14 students student NOUN pipe-0093 128 15 without without ADP pipe-0093 128 16 regular regular ADJ pipe-0093 128 17 internet internet NOUN pipe-0093 128 18 access access NOUN pipe-0093 128 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 129 1 therefore therefore ADV pipe-0093 129 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 129 3 students student NOUN pipe-0093 129 4 could could AUX pipe-0093 129 5 read read VERB pipe-0093 129 6 the the DET pipe-0093 129 7 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 129 8 online online ADV pipe-0093 129 9 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 129 10 download download VERB pipe-0093 129 11 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 129 12 retain retain VERB pipe-0093 129 13 all all DET pipe-0093 129 14 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 129 15 in in ADP pipe-0093 129 16 several several ADJ pipe-0093 129 17 formats format NOUN pipe-0093 129 18 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 129 19 feldstein feldstein PROPN pipe-0093 129 20 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 129 21 et et PROPN pipe-0093 129 22 al al PROPN pipe-0093 129 23 . . PROPN pipe-0093 129 24 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 129 25 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 129 26 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 129 27 pp pp PROPN pipe-0093 129 28 . . PROPN pipe-0093 130 1 1 1 NUM pipe-0093 130 2 - - SYM pipe-0093 130 3 2 2 NUM pipe-0093 130 4 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 130 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 131 1 however however ADV pipe-0093 131 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 131 3 working work VERB pipe-0093 131 4 with with ADP pipe-0093 131 5 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 131 6 entities entity NOUN pipe-0093 131 7 on on ADP pipe-0093 131 8 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 131 9 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 131 10 has have VERB pipe-0093 131 11 considerable considerable ADJ pipe-0093 131 12 drawbacks drawback NOUN pipe-0093 131 13 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 132 1 one one NUM pipe-0093 132 2 year year NOUN pipe-0093 132 3 after after ADP pipe-0093 132 4 the the DET pipe-0093 132 5 vsu vsu NOUN pipe-0093 132 6 study study NOUN pipe-0093 132 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 132 8 fwk fwk NOUN pipe-0093 132 9 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 132 10 evolved evolve VERB pipe-0093 132 11 from from ADP pipe-0093 132 12 open open ADJ pipe-0093 132 13 education education NOUN pipe-0093 132 14 resources resource NOUN pipe-0093 132 15 to to ADP pipe-0093 132 16 fair fair ADJ pipe-0093 132 17 pricing pricing NOUN pipe-0093 132 18 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 132 19 according accord VERB pipe-0093 132 20 to to ADP pipe-0093 132 21 their their PRON pipe-0093 132 22 website website NOUN pipe-0093 132 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 133 1 this this PRON pipe-0093 133 2 means mean VERB pipe-0093 133 3 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 133 4 the the DET pipe-0093 133 5 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 133 6 vsu vsu NOUN pipe-0093 133 7 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 133 8 had have AUX pipe-0093 133 9 hoped hope VERB pipe-0093 133 10 to to PART pipe-0093 133 11 make make VERB pipe-0093 133 12 available available ADJ pipe-0093 133 13 for for ADP pipe-0093 133 14 free free ADJ pipe-0093 133 15 were be AUX pipe-0093 133 16 now now ADV pipe-0093 133 17 subject subject ADJ pipe-0093 133 18 to to ADP pipe-0093 133 19 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 133 20 fair fair ADJ pipe-0093 133 21 pricing pricing NOUN pipe-0093 133 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 133 23 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 134 1 fwk fwk PROPN pipe-0093 134 2 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 134 3 vsu vsu VERB pipe-0093 134 4 students student NOUN pipe-0093 134 5 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 134 6 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 134 7 may may AUX pipe-0093 134 8 have have VERB pipe-0093 134 9 divergent divergent ADJ pipe-0093 134 10 ideas idea NOUN pipe-0093 134 11 of of ADP pipe-0093 134 12 what what PRON pipe-0093 134 13 ’s ’ VERB pipe-0093 134 14 a a DET pipe-0093 134 15 fair fair ADJ pipe-0093 134 16 price price NOUN pipe-0093 134 17 for for ADP pipe-0093 134 18 a a DET pipe-0093 134 19 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 134 20 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 135 1 at at ADP pipe-0093 135 2 the the DET pipe-0093 135 3 time time NOUN pipe-0093 135 4 of of ADP pipe-0093 135 5 this this DET pipe-0093 135 6 writing writing NOUN pipe-0093 135 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 135 8 the the DET pipe-0093 135 9 fwk fwk NOUN pipe-0093 135 10 website website NOUN pipe-0093 135 11 lists list VERB pipe-0093 135 12 most most ADJ pipe-0093 135 13 e e NOUN pipe-0093 135 14 - - NOUN pipe-0093 135 15 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 135 16 between between ADP pipe-0093 135 17 $ $ SYM pipe-0093 135 18 25-$30 25-$30 NUM pipe-0093 135 19 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 135 20 most most ADJ pipe-0093 135 21 print print NOUN pipe-0093 135 22 copies copy NOUN pipe-0093 135 23 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 135 24 ebook ebook NOUN pipe-0093 135 25 included include VERB pipe-0093 135 26 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 135 27 list list NOUN pipe-0093 135 28 for for ADP pipe-0093 135 29 $ $ SYM pipe-0093 135 30 55 55 NUM pipe-0093 135 31 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 136 1 this this DET pipe-0093 136 2 price price NOUN pipe-0093 136 3 is be AUX pipe-0093 136 4 much much ADV pipe-0093 136 5 lower low ADJ pipe-0093 136 6 than than ADP pipe-0093 136 7 many many ADJ pipe-0093 136 8 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 136 9 alternatives alternative NOUN pipe-0093 136 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 136 11 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 136 12 it it PRON pipe-0093 136 13 is be AUX pipe-0093 136 14 a a DET pipe-0093 136 15 lot lot NOUN pipe-0093 136 16 more more ADJ pipe-0093 136 17 than than ADP pipe-0093 136 18 free free ADJ pipe-0093 136 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 137 1 the the DET pipe-0093 137 2 percentage percentage NOUN pipe-0093 137 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 137 4 african african ADJ pipe-0093 137 5 american american PROPN pipe-0093 137 6 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 137 7 latinx latinx PROPN pipe-0093 137 8 students student NOUN pipe-0093 137 9 that that PRON pipe-0093 137 10 receive receive VERB pipe-0093 137 11 a a DET pipe-0093 137 12 bachelor bachelor NOUN pipe-0093 137 13 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 137 14 degree degree NOUN pipe-0093 137 15 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 137 16 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 137 17 lags lag NOUN pipe-0093 137 18 far far ADV pipe-0093 137 19 behind behind ADP pipe-0093 137 20 white white ADJ pipe-0093 137 21 students student NOUN pipe-0093 137 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 138 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 138 2 a a DET pipe-0093 138 3 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 138 4 study study NOUN pipe-0093 138 5 at at ADP pipe-0093 138 6 the the DET pipe-0093 138 7 university university PROPN pipe-0093 138 8 of of ADP pipe-0093 138 9 georgia georgia PROPN pipe-0093 138 10 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 138 11 uga uga PROPN pipe-0093 138 12 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 138 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 138 14 colvard colvard NOUN pipe-0093 138 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 138 16 watson watson NOUN pipe-0093 138 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 138 18 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 138 19 park park NOUN pipe-0093 138 20 sought seek VERB pipe-0093 138 21 to to PART pipe-0093 138 22 address address VERB pipe-0093 138 23 the the DET pipe-0093 138 24 attainment attainment ADJ pipe-0093 138 25 gap gap NOUN pipe-0093 138 26 through through ADP pipe-0093 138 27 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 138 28 adoption adoption NOUN pipe-0093 138 29 in in ADP pipe-0093 138 30 eight eight NUM pipe-0093 138 31 general general ADJ pipe-0093 138 32 education education NOUN pipe-0093 138 33 courses course NOUN pipe-0093 138 34 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 139 1 the the DET pipe-0093 139 2 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 139 3 point point VERB pipe-0093 139 4 to to ADP pipe-0093 139 5 the the DET pipe-0093 139 6 connection connection NOUN pipe-0093 139 7 between between ADP pipe-0093 139 8 public public ADJ pipe-0093 139 9 disinvestment disinvestment NOUN pipe-0093 139 10 in in ADP pipe-0093 139 11 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 139 12 education education NOUN pipe-0093 139 13 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 139 14 rising rise VERB pipe-0093 139 15 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 139 16 for for ADP pipe-0093 139 17 students student NOUN pipe-0093 139 18 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 140 1 they they PRON pipe-0093 140 2 argue argue VERB pipe-0093 140 3 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 140 4 shifting shift VERB pipe-0093 140 5 the the DET pipe-0093 140 6 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 140 7 burden burden NOUN pipe-0093 140 8 away away ADV pipe-0093 140 9 from from ADP pipe-0093 140 10 taxpayers taxpayer NOUN pipe-0093 140 11 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 140 12 onto onto ADP pipe-0093 140 13 students student NOUN pipe-0093 140 14 exacerbates exacerbate VERB pipe-0093 140 15 ethnic ethnic ADJ pipe-0093 140 16 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 140 17 racial racial ADJ pipe-0093 140 18 disparities disparity NOUN pipe-0093 140 19 in in ADP pipe-0093 140 20 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 140 21 attainment attainment NOUN pipe-0093 140 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 141 1 students student NOUN pipe-0093 141 2 saved save VERB pipe-0093 141 3 over over ADP pipe-0093 141 4 3 3 NUM pipe-0093 141 5 million million NUM pipe-0093 141 6 dollars dollar NOUN pipe-0093 141 7 as as ADP pipe-0093 141 8 a a DET pipe-0093 141 9 result result NOUN pipe-0093 141 10 of of ADP pipe-0093 141 11 these these DET pipe-0093 141 12 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 141 13 adoptions adoption NOUN pipe-0093 141 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 142 1 cleverly cleverly ADV pipe-0093 142 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 142 3 this this DET pipe-0093 142 4 study study NOUN pipe-0093 142 5 disambiguated disambiguate VERB pipe-0093 142 6 student student NOUN pipe-0093 142 7 data datum NOUN pipe-0093 142 8 in in ADP pipe-0093 142 9 order order NOUN pipe-0093 142 10 to to PART pipe-0093 142 11 determine determine VERB pipe-0093 142 12 if if SCONJ pipe-0093 142 13 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 142 14 have have VERB pipe-0093 142 15 a a DET pipe-0093 142 16 greater great ADJ pipe-0093 142 17 impact impact NOUN pipe-0093 142 18 on on ADP pipe-0093 142 19 students student NOUN pipe-0093 142 20 eligible eligible ADJ pipe-0093 142 21 for for ADP pipe-0093 142 22 pell pell PROPN pipe-0093 142 23 grants grant NOUN pipe-0093 142 24 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 142 25 part part NOUN pipe-0093 142 26 time time NOUN pipe-0093 142 27 students student NOUN pipe-0093 142 28 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 142 29 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 142 30 non non ADJ pipe-0093 142 31 - - ADJ pipe-0093 142 32 white white ADJ pipe-0093 142 33 students student NOUN pipe-0093 142 34 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 142 35 colvard colvard NOUN pipe-0093 142 36 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 142 37 watson watson NOUN pipe-0093 142 38 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 142 39 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 142 40 park park PROPN pipe-0093 142 41 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 142 42 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 142 43 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 142 44 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 142 45 264 264 NUM pipe-0093 142 46 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 142 47 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 143 1 the the DET pipe-0093 143 2 results result NOUN pipe-0093 143 3 are be AUX pipe-0093 143 4 promising promise VERB pipe-0093 143 5 as as ADP pipe-0093 143 6 the the DET pipe-0093 143 7 percentage percentage NOUN pipe-0093 143 8 of of ADP pipe-0093 143 9 students student NOUN pipe-0093 143 10 receiving receive VERB pipe-0093 143 11 grades grade NOUN pipe-0093 143 12 a a DET pipe-0093 143 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 143 14 a- a- X pipe-0093 143 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 143 16 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 143 17 b+ b+ ADP pipe-0093 143 18 in in ADP pipe-0093 143 19 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 143 20 test test NOUN pipe-0093 143 21 courses course NOUN pipe-0093 143 22 increased increase VERB pipe-0093 143 23 dramatically dramatically ADV pipe-0093 143 24 for for ADP pipe-0093 143 25 all all DET pipe-0093 143 26 three three NUM pipe-0093 143 27 populations population NOUN pipe-0093 143 28 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 143 29 colvard colvard NOUN pipe-0093 143 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 143 31 et et PROPN pipe-0093 143 32 al al PROPN pipe-0093 143 33 . . PROPN pipe-0093 143 34 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 143 35 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 143 36 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 143 37 pp pp PROPN pipe-0093 143 38 . . PROPN pipe-0093 144 1 269 269 NUM pipe-0093 144 2 - - NUM pipe-0093 144 3 271 271 NUM pipe-0093 144 4 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 144 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 145 1 the the DET pipe-0093 145 2 last last ADJ pipe-0093 145 3 study study NOUN pipe-0093 145 4 in in ADP pipe-0093 145 5 this this DET pipe-0093 145 6 subsection subsection NOUN pipe-0093 145 7 presents present VERB pipe-0093 145 8 a a DET pipe-0093 145 9 convincing convincing ADJ pipe-0093 145 10 argument argument NOUN pipe-0093 145 11 for for ADP pipe-0093 145 12 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 145 13 reduction reduction NOUN pipe-0093 145 14 as as ADP pipe-0093 145 15 a a DET pipe-0093 145 16 contributor contributor NOUN pipe-0093 145 17 to to ADP pipe-0093 145 18 student student NOUN pipe-0093 145 19 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 145 20 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 146 1 fischer fischer PROPN pipe-0093 146 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 146 3 hilton hilton PROPN pipe-0093 146 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 146 5 robinson robinson NOUN pipe-0093 146 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 146 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 146 8 wiley wiley NOUN pipe-0093 146 9 designed design VERB pipe-0093 146 10 the the DET pipe-0093 146 11 largest large ADJ pipe-0093 146 12 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 146 13 study study NOUN pipe-0093 146 14 upon upon SCONJ pipe-0093 146 15 its its PRON pipe-0093 146 16 publication publication NOUN pipe-0093 146 17 in in ADP pipe-0093 146 18 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 146 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 147 1 it it PRON pipe-0093 147 2 is be AUX pipe-0093 147 3 a a DET pipe-0093 147 4 quasi quasi ADJ pipe-0093 147 5 - - ADJ pipe-0093 147 6 experimental experimental ADJ pipe-0093 147 7 study study NOUN pipe-0093 147 8 that that PRON pipe-0093 147 9 analyzed analyze VERB pipe-0093 147 10 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 147 11 results result NOUN pipe-0093 147 12 across across ADP pipe-0093 147 13 four four NUM pipe-0093 147 14 four four NUM pipe-0093 147 15 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 147 16 year year NOUN pipe-0093 147 17 colleges college NOUN pipe-0093 147 18 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 147 19 six six NUM pipe-0093 147 20 community community NOUN pipe-0093 147 21 colleges college NOUN pipe-0093 147 22 for for ADP pipe-0093 147 23 approximately approximately ADV pipe-0093 147 24 16,000 16,000 NUM pipe-0093 147 25 students student NOUN pipe-0093 147 26 in in ADP pipe-0093 147 27 fifteen fifteen NUM pipe-0093 147 28 undergraduate undergraduate ADJ pipe-0093 147 29 courses course NOUN pipe-0093 147 30 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 147 31 approx approx PROPN pipe-0093 147 32 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 148 1 5,000 5,000 NUM pipe-0093 148 2 in in ADP pipe-0093 148 3 the the DET pipe-0093 148 4 test test NOUN pipe-0093 148 5 group group NOUN pipe-0093 148 6 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 148 7 11,000 11,000 NUM pipe-0093 148 8 in in ADP pipe-0093 148 9 the the DET pipe-0093 148 10 control control NOUN pipe-0093 148 11 group group NOUN pipe-0093 148 12 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 148 13 fischer fischer PROPN pipe-0093 148 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 148 15 hilton hilton PROPN pipe-0093 148 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 148 17 robinson robinson NOUN pipe-0093 148 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 148 19 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 148 20 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 148 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 148 22 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 148 23 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 148 24 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 148 25 164 164 NUM pipe-0093 148 26 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 148 27 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 149 1 the the DET pipe-0093 149 2 study study NOUN pipe-0093 149 3 measured measure VERB pipe-0093 149 4 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 149 5 in in ADP pipe-0093 149 6 four four NUM pipe-0093 149 7 categories category NOUN pipe-0093 149 8 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 149 9 course course NOUN pipe-0093 149 10 completion completion NOUN pipe-0093 149 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 149 12 passing pass VERB pipe-0093 149 13 courses course NOUN pipe-0093 149 14 with with ADP pipe-0093 149 15 at at ADP pipe-0093 149 16 least least ADJ pipe-0093 149 17 a a DET pipe-0093 149 18 cgrade cgrade NOUN pipe-0093 149 19 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 149 20 credit credit NOUN pipe-0093 149 21 hours hour NOUN pipe-0093 149 22 during during ADP pipe-0093 149 23 the the DET pipe-0093 149 24 semester semester NOUN pipe-0093 149 25 tested test VERB pipe-0093 149 26 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 149 27 enrollment enrollment NOUN pipe-0093 149 28 intensity intensity NOUN pipe-0093 149 29 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 149 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 149 31 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 149 32 credit credit NOUN pipe-0093 149 33 hours hour NOUN pipe-0093 149 34 in in ADP pipe-0093 149 35 the the DET pipe-0093 149 36 following following ADJ pipe-0093 149 37 semester semester NOUN pipe-0093 149 38 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 150 1 fischer fischer ADV pipe-0093 150 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 150 3 et et PROPN pipe-0093 150 4 al al PROPN pipe-0093 150 5 . . PROPN pipe-0093 150 6 claim claim VERB pipe-0093 150 7 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 150 8 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 150 9 is be AUX pipe-0093 150 10 more more ADV pipe-0093 150 11 impactful impactful ADJ pipe-0093 150 12 on on ADP pipe-0093 150 13 student student NOUN pipe-0093 150 14 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 150 15 than than ADP pipe-0093 150 16 instructional instructional ADJ pipe-0093 150 17 design design NOUN pipe-0093 150 18 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 150 19 mode mode NOUN pipe-0093 150 20 of of ADP pipe-0093 150 21 delivery delivery NOUN pipe-0093 150 22 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 150 23 fischer fischer NOUN pipe-0093 150 24 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 150 25 et et PROPN pipe-0093 150 26 al al PROPN pipe-0093 150 27 . . PROPN pipe-0093 150 28 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 150 29 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 150 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 150 31 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 150 32 169 169 NUM pipe-0093 150 33 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 150 34 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 151 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 151 2 this this DET pipe-0093 151 3 study study NOUN pipe-0093 151 4 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 151 5 others other NOUN pipe-0093 151 6 like like ADP pipe-0093 151 7 it it PRON pipe-0093 151 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 151 9 student student NOUN pipe-0093 151 10 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 151 11 are be AUX pipe-0093 151 12 similar similar ADJ pipe-0093 151 13 when when SCONJ pipe-0093 151 14 using use VERB pipe-0093 151 15 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 151 16 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 151 17 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 151 18 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 151 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 152 1 however however ADV pipe-0093 152 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 152 3 the the DET pipe-0093 152 4 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 152 5 see see VERB pipe-0093 152 6 a a DET pipe-0093 152 7 correlation correlation NOUN pipe-0093 152 8 between between ADP pipe-0093 152 9 saving save VERB pipe-0093 152 10 money money NOUN pipe-0093 152 11 on on ADP pipe-0093 152 12 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 152 13 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 152 14 enrollment enrollment NOUN pipe-0093 152 15 intensity intensity NOUN pipe-0093 152 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 153 1 the the DET pipe-0093 153 2 test test NOUN pipe-0093 153 3 group group NOUN pipe-0093 153 4 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 153 5 those those PRON pipe-0093 153 6 using use VERB pipe-0093 153 7 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 153 8 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 153 9 enrolled enrol VERB pipe-0093 153 10 in in ADP pipe-0093 153 11 more more ADJ pipe-0093 153 12 credits credit NOUN pipe-0093 153 13 in in ADP pipe-0093 153 14 the the DET pipe-0093 153 15 surveyed survey VERB pipe-0093 153 16 semester semester NOUN pipe-0093 153 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 153 18 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 153 19 the the DET pipe-0093 153 20 following follow VERB pipe-0093 153 21 semester semester NOUN pipe-0093 153 22 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 153 23 than than ADP pipe-0093 153 24 the the DET pipe-0093 153 25 control control NOUN pipe-0093 153 26 group group NOUN pipe-0093 153 27 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 153 28 fischer fischer NOUN pipe-0093 153 29 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 153 30 et et PROPN pipe-0093 153 31 al al PROPN pipe-0093 153 32 . . PROPN pipe-0093 153 33 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 153 34 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 153 35 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 153 36 pp pp PROPN pipe-0093 153 37 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 154 1 167 167 NUM pipe-0093 154 2 - - SYM pipe-0093 154 3 168 168 NUM pipe-0093 154 4 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 154 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 155 1 their their PRON pipe-0093 155 2 argument argument NOUN pipe-0093 155 3 is be AUX pipe-0093 155 4 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 155 5 students student NOUN pipe-0093 155 6 use use VERB pipe-0093 155 7 their their PRON pipe-0093 155 8 savings saving NOUN pipe-0093 155 9 to to PART pipe-0093 155 10 enroll enroll VERB pipe-0093 155 11 in in ADP pipe-0093 155 12 more more ADJ pipe-0093 155 13 classes class NOUN pipe-0093 155 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 156 1 causation causation NOUN pipe-0093 156 2 is be AUX pipe-0093 156 3 impossible impossible ADJ pipe-0093 156 4 to to PART pipe-0093 156 5 prove prove VERB pipe-0093 156 6 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 156 7 this this DET pipe-0093 156 8 hypothesis hypothesis NOUN pipe-0093 156 9 is be AUX pipe-0093 156 10 provocative provocative ADJ pipe-0093 156 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 157 1 the the DET pipe-0093 157 2 refrain refrain ADJ pipe-0093 157 3 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 157 4 student student NOUN pipe-0093 157 5 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 157 6 are be AUX pipe-0093 157 7 the the DET pipe-0093 157 8 same same ADJ pipe-0093 157 9 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 157 10 better well ADJ pipe-0093 157 11 when when SCONJ pipe-0093 157 12 using use VERB pipe-0093 157 13 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 157 14 is be AUX pipe-0093 157 15 increasingly increasingly ADV pipe-0093 157 16 common common ADJ pipe-0093 157 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 158 1 this this DET pipe-0093 158 2 argument argument NOUN pipe-0093 158 3 is be AUX pipe-0093 158 4 used use VERB pipe-0093 158 5 to to PART pipe-0093 158 6 encourage encourage VERB pipe-0093 158 7 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 158 8 adoption adoption NOUN pipe-0093 158 9 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 159 1 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 159 2 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 159 3 need need NOUN pipe-0093 159 4 practitioners practitioner NOUN pipe-0093 159 5 committed commit VERB pipe-0093 159 6 to to ADP pipe-0093 159 7 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 159 8 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 159 9 to to PART pipe-0093 159 10 move move VERB pipe-0093 159 11 beyond beyond ADP pipe-0093 159 12 a a DET pipe-0093 159 13 free free ADJ pipe-0093 159 14 version version NOUN pipe-0093 159 15 of of ADP pipe-0093 159 16 the the DET pipe-0093 159 17 status status NOUN pipe-0093 159 18 quo quo NOUN pipe-0093 159 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 160 1 fischer fischer PROPN pipe-0093 160 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 160 3 et et PROPN pipe-0093 160 4 al al PROPN pipe-0093 160 5 . . PROPN pipe-0093 160 6 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 160 7 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 160 8 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 160 9 admit admit VERB pipe-0093 160 10 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 160 11 future future ADJ pipe-0093 160 12 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 160 13 should should AUX pipe-0093 160 14 analyze analyze VERB pipe-0093 160 15 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 160 16 quality quality NOUN pipe-0093 160 17 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 160 18 teacher teacher NOUN pipe-0093 160 19 effects effect NOUN pipe-0093 160 20 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 160 21 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 160 22 170 170 NUM pipe-0093 160 23 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 160 24 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 161 1 they they PRON pipe-0093 161 2 do do AUX pipe-0093 161 3 not not PART pipe-0093 161 4 provide provide VERB pipe-0093 161 5 any any DET pipe-0093 161 6 details detail NOUN pipe-0093 161 7 about about ADP pipe-0093 161 8 the the DET pipe-0093 161 9 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 161 10 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 161 11 used use VERB pipe-0093 161 12 in in ADP pipe-0093 161 13 their their PRON pipe-0093 161 14 study study NOUN pipe-0093 161 15 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 162 1 this this DET pipe-0093 162 2 omission omission NOUN pipe-0093 162 3 is be AUX pipe-0093 162 4 too too ADV pipe-0093 162 5 common common ADJ pipe-0093 162 6 in in ADP pipe-0093 162 7 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 162 8 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 162 9 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 162 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 163 1 these these DET pipe-0093 163 2 issues issue NOUN pipe-0093 163 3 are be AUX pipe-0093 163 4 taken take VERB pipe-0093 163 5 up up ADP pipe-0093 163 6 in in ADP pipe-0093 163 7 the the DET pipe-0093 163 8 following follow VERB pipe-0093 163 9 subsections subsection NOUN pipe-0093 163 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 164 1 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 164 2 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 164 3 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 164 4 the the DET pipe-0093 164 5 fact fact NOUN pipe-0093 164 6 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 164 7 the the DET pipe-0093 164 8 vast vast ADJ pipe-0093 164 9 majority majority NOUN pipe-0093 164 10 of of ADP pipe-0093 164 11 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 164 12 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 164 13 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 164 14 show show VERB pipe-0093 164 15 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 164 16 student student NOUN pipe-0093 164 17 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 164 18 are be AUX pipe-0093 164 19 the the DET pipe-0093 164 20 same same ADJ pipe-0093 164 21 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 164 22 better well ADJ pipe-0093 164 23 when when SCONJ pipe-0093 164 24 using use VERB pipe-0093 164 25 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 164 26 is be AUX pipe-0093 164 27 promising promise VERB pipe-0093 164 28 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 165 1 however however ADV pipe-0093 165 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 165 3 most most ADJ pipe-0093 165 4 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 165 5 lack lack VERB pipe-0093 165 6 an an DET pipe-0093 165 7 in in ADP pipe-0093 165 8 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 165 9 depth depth NOUN pipe-0093 165 10 analysis analysis NOUN pipe-0093 165 11 of of ADP pipe-0093 165 12 the the DET pipe-0093 165 13 pedagogical pedagogical ADJ pipe-0093 165 14 choices choice NOUN pipe-0093 165 15 driving drive VERB pipe-0093 165 16 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 165 17 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 165 18 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 166 1 this this DET pipe-0093 166 2 section section NOUN pipe-0093 166 3 examines examine VERB pipe-0093 166 4 case case NOUN pipe-0093 166 5 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 166 6 for for ADP pipe-0093 166 7 evidence evidence NOUN pipe-0093 166 8 of of ADP pipe-0093 166 9 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 166 10 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 166 11 with with ADP pipe-0093 166 12 regard regard NOUN pipe-0093 166 13 to to ADP pipe-0093 166 14 oer oer VERB pipe-0093 166 15 adoption adoption NOUN pipe-0093 166 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 167 1 though though SCONJ pipe-0093 167 2 never never ADV pipe-0093 167 3 specifically specifically ADV pipe-0093 167 4 mentioned mention VERB pipe-0093 167 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 167 6 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 167 7 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 167 8 is be AUX pipe-0093 167 9 at at ADP pipe-0093 167 10 the the DET pipe-0093 167 11 center center NOUN pipe-0093 167 12 of of ADP pipe-0093 167 13 the the DET pipe-0093 167 14 uc uc PROPN pipe-0093 167 15 davis davis PROPN pipe-0093 167 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 167 17 chemwiki chemwiki ADJ pipe-0093 167 18 study study NOUN pipe-0093 167 19 discussed discuss VERB pipe-0093 167 20 above above ADV pipe-0093 167 21 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 168 1 allen allen PROPN pipe-0093 168 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 168 3 et et PROPN pipe-0093 168 4 al al PROPN pipe-0093 168 5 . . PROPN pipe-0093 168 6 stress stress VERB pipe-0093 168 7 the the DET pipe-0093 168 8 importance importance NOUN pipe-0093 168 9 of of ADP pipe-0093 168 10 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 168 11 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 168 12 student student NOUN pipe-0093 168 13 engagement engagement NOUN pipe-0093 168 14 in in ADP pipe-0093 168 15 authoring author VERB pipe-0093 168 16 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 168 17 reviewing review VERB pipe-0093 168 18 chemwiki chemwiki ADJ pipe-0093 168 19 teaching teaching NOUN pipe-0093 168 20 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 168 21 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 169 1 as as SCONJ pipe-0093 169 2 the the DET pipe-0093 169 3 name name NOUN pipe-0093 169 4 suggests suggest VERB pipe-0093 169 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 169 6 chemwiki chemwiki PROPN pipe-0093 169 7 utilizes utilize VERB pipe-0093 169 8 a a DET pipe-0093 169 9 model model NOUN pipe-0093 169 10 similar similar ADJ pipe-0093 169 11 to to ADP pipe-0093 169 12 wikipedia wikipedia PROPN pipe-0093 169 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 169 14 a a DET pipe-0093 169 15 comparison comparison NOUN pipe-0093 169 16 the the DET pipe-0093 169 17 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 169 18 embrace embrace VERB pipe-0093 169 19 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 169 20 allen allen PROPN pipe-0093 169 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 169 22 et et PROPN pipe-0093 169 23 al al PROPN pipe-0093 169 24 . . PROPN pipe-0093 169 25 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 169 26 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 169 27 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 169 28 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 169 29 2 2 NUM pipe-0093 169 30 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 169 31 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 170 1 teaching teach VERB pipe-0093 170 2 modules module NOUN pipe-0093 170 3 are be AUX pipe-0093 170 4 created create VERB pipe-0093 170 5 by by ADP pipe-0093 170 6 many many ADJ pipe-0093 170 7 instructors instructor NOUN pipe-0093 170 8 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 170 9 can can AUX pipe-0093 170 10 be be AUX pipe-0093 170 11 hyperlinked hyperlinke VERB pipe-0093 170 12 within within ADP pipe-0093 170 13 each each DET pipe-0093 170 14 course course NOUN pipe-0093 170 15 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 170 16 instance instance NOUN pipe-0093 170 17 of of ADP pipe-0093 170 18 chemwiki chemwiki PROPN pipe-0093 170 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 171 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 171 2 other other ADJ pipe-0093 171 3 words word NOUN pipe-0093 171 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 171 5 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 171 6 is be AUX pipe-0093 171 7 distributed distribute VERB pipe-0093 171 8 horizontally horizontally ADV pipe-0093 171 9 in in ADP pipe-0093 171 10 an an DET pipe-0093 171 11 effort effort NOUN pipe-0093 171 12 to to PART pipe-0093 171 13 draw draw VERB pipe-0093 171 14 on on ADP pipe-0093 171 15 collective collective ADJ pipe-0093 171 16 expertise expertise NOUN pipe-0093 171 17 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 171 18 avoid avoid VERB pipe-0093 171 19 the the DET pipe-0093 171 20 centralization centralization NOUN pipe-0093 171 21 of of ADP pipe-0093 171 22 expertise expertise NOUN pipe-0093 171 23 used use VERB pipe-0093 171 24 in in ADP pipe-0093 171 25 authoring author VERB pipe-0093 171 26 traditional traditional ADJ pipe-0093 171 27 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 171 28 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 172 1 colvard colvard NOUN pipe-0093 172 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 172 3 et et PROPN pipe-0093 172 4 al al PROPN pipe-0093 172 5 . . PROPN pipe-0093 172 6 argue argue VERB pipe-0093 172 7 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 172 8 their their PRON pipe-0093 172 9 study study NOUN pipe-0093 172 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 172 11 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 172 12 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 172 13 by by ADP pipe-0093 172 14 extension extension NOUN pipe-0093 172 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 172 16 addresses address VERB pipe-0093 172 17 all all DET pipe-0093 172 18 three three NUM pipe-0093 172 19 of of ADP pipe-0093 172 20 the the DET pipe-0093 172 21 great great ADJ pipe-0093 172 22 challenges challenge NOUN pipe-0093 172 23 facing face VERB pipe-0093 172 24 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 172 25 education education NOUN pipe-0093 172 26 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 172 27 affordability affordability NOUN pipe-0093 172 28 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 172 29 retention retention NOUN pipe-0093 172 30 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 172 31 completion completion NOUN pipe-0093 172 32 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 172 33 quality quality NOUN pipe-0093 172 34 of of ADP pipe-0093 172 35 student student NOUN pipe-0093 172 36 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 172 37 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 172 38 colvard colvard NOUN pipe-0093 172 39 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 172 40 et et PROPN pipe-0093 172 41 al al PROPN pipe-0093 172 42 . . PROPN pipe-0093 172 43 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 172 44 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 172 45 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 172 46 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 172 47 273 273 NUM pipe-0093 172 48 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 172 49 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 173 1 quality quality NOUN pipe-0093 173 2 of of ADP pipe-0093 173 3 student student NOUN pipe-0093 173 4 learning learning NOUN pipe-0093 173 5 is be AUX pipe-0093 173 6 measured measure VERB pipe-0093 173 7 by by ADP pipe-0093 173 8 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 173 9 performance performance NOUN pipe-0093 173 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 173 11 which which PRON pipe-0093 173 12 improved improve VERB pipe-0093 173 13 in in ADP pipe-0093 173 14 the the DET pipe-0093 173 15 test test NOUN pipe-0093 173 16 group group NOUN pipe-0093 173 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 174 1 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 174 2 the the DET pipe-0093 174 3 study study NOUN pipe-0093 174 4 reveals reveal VERB pipe-0093 174 5 little little ADJ pipe-0093 174 6 about about ADP pipe-0093 174 7 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 174 8 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 175 1 most most ADJ pipe-0093 175 2 of of ADP pipe-0093 175 3 the the DET pipe-0093 175 4 classes class NOUN pipe-0093 175 5 adopted adopt VERB pipe-0093 175 6 openstax openstax NOUN pipe-0093 175 7 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 175 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 175 9 a a DET pipe-0093 175 10 major major ADJ pipe-0093 175 11 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 175 12 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 175 13 publisher publisher NOUN pipe-0093 175 14 based base VERB pipe-0093 175 15 out out ADP pipe-0093 175 16 of of ADP pipe-0093 175 17 rice rice PROPN pipe-0093 175 18 university university PROPN pipe-0093 175 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 176 1 uga uga PROPN pipe-0093 176 2 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 176 3 center center NOUN pipe-0093 176 4 for for ADP pipe-0093 176 5 teaching teaching NOUN pipe-0093 176 6 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 176 7 learning learning NOUN pipe-0093 176 8 assisted assist VERB pipe-0093 176 9 with with ADP pipe-0093 176 10 some some DET pipe-0093 176 11 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 176 12 adoptions adoption NOUN pipe-0093 176 13 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 176 14 no no DET pipe-0093 176 15 further further ADJ pipe-0093 176 16 details detail NOUN pipe-0093 176 17 are be AUX pipe-0093 176 18 provided provide VERB pipe-0093 176 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 177 1 as as ADP pipe-0093 177 2 a a DET pipe-0093 177 3 result result NOUN pipe-0093 177 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 177 5 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 177 6 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 177 7 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 177 8 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 177 9 are be AUX pipe-0093 177 10 hinted hint VERB pipe-0093 177 11 at at ADP pipe-0093 177 12 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 177 13 never never ADV pipe-0093 177 14 discussed discuss VERB pipe-0093 177 15 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 178 1 one one NUM pipe-0093 178 2 study study NOUN pipe-0093 178 3 can can AUX pipe-0093 178 4 not not PART pipe-0093 178 5 cover cover VERB pipe-0093 178 6 all all DET pipe-0093 178 7 topics topic NOUN pipe-0093 178 8 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 178 9 this this DET pipe-0093 178 10 one one NOUN pipe-0093 178 11 does do VERB pipe-0093 178 12 a a DET pipe-0093 178 13 remarkable remarkable ADJ pipe-0093 178 14 job job NOUN pipe-0093 178 15 of of ADP pipe-0093 178 16 situating situate VERB pipe-0093 178 17 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 178 18 in in ADP pipe-0093 178 19 a a DET pipe-0093 178 20 social social ADJ pipe-0093 178 21 justice justice NOUN pipe-0093 178 22 context context NOUN pipe-0093 178 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 179 1 perhaps perhaps ADV pipe-0093 179 2 a a DET pipe-0093 179 3 future future ADJ pipe-0093 179 4 study study NOUN pipe-0093 179 5 could could AUX pipe-0093 179 6 widen widen VERB pipe-0093 179 7 the the DET pipe-0093 179 8 aperture aperture NOUN pipe-0093 179 9 of of ADP pipe-0093 179 10 social social ADJ pipe-0093 179 11 justice justice NOUN pipe-0093 179 12 to to PART pipe-0093 179 13 better well ADJ pipe-0093 179 14 account account NOUN pipe-0093 179 15 for for ADP pipe-0093 179 16 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 179 17 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 179 18 the the DET pipe-0093 179 19 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 179 20 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 179 21 required require VERB pipe-0093 179 22 to to PART pipe-0093 179 23 adopt adopt VERB pipe-0093 179 24 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 179 25 at at ADP pipe-0093 179 26 a a DET pipe-0093 179 27 large large ADJ pipe-0093 179 28 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 179 29 public public ADJ pipe-0093 179 30 university university NOUN pipe-0093 179 31 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 180 1 hendricks hendrick NOUN pipe-0093 180 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 180 3 reinsberg reinsberg PROPN pipe-0093 180 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 180 5 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 180 6 rieger rieger PROPN pipe-0093 180 7 acknowledge acknowledge VERB pipe-0093 180 8 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 180 9 most most ADJ pipe-0093 180 10 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 180 11 ignore ignore VERB pipe-0093 180 12 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 180 13 by by ADP pipe-0093 180 14 providing provide VERB pipe-0093 180 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 180 16 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 180 17 a a DET pipe-0093 180 18 very very ADV pipe-0093 180 19 specific specific ADJ pipe-0093 180 20 description description NOUN pipe-0093 180 21 of of ADP pipe-0093 180 22 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 180 23 the the DET pipe-0093 180 24 open open ADJ pipe-0093 180 25 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 180 26 used use VERB pipe-0093 180 27 in in ADP pipe-0093 180 28 the the DET pipe-0093 180 29 course course NOUN pipe-0093 180 30 we we PRON pipe-0093 180 31 are be AUX pipe-0093 180 32 studying study VERB pipe-0093 180 33 has have AUX pipe-0093 180 34 been be AUX pipe-0093 180 35 adapted adapt VERB pipe-0093 180 36 to to PART pipe-0093 180 37 fit fit VERB pipe-0093 180 38 into into ADP pipe-0093 180 39 that that DET pipe-0093 180 40 course course NOUN pipe-0093 180 41 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 180 42 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 180 43 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 180 44 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 180 45 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 180 46 82 82 NUM pipe-0093 180 47 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 180 48 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 181 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 181 2 this this DET pipe-0093 181 3 study study NOUN pipe-0093 181 4 at at ADP pipe-0093 181 5 the the DET pipe-0093 181 6 university university PROPN pipe-0093 181 7 of of ADP pipe-0093 181 8 british british PROPN pipe-0093 181 9 columbia columbia PROPN pipe-0093 181 10 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 181 11 ubc ubc PROPN pipe-0093 181 12 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 181 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 181 14 the the DET pipe-0093 181 15 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 181 16 adopted adopt VERB pipe-0093 181 17 an an DET pipe-0093 181 18 openstax openstax NOUN pipe-0093 181 19 physics physics NOUN pipe-0093 181 20 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 181 21 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 181 22 edited edit VERB pipe-0093 181 23 out out ADP pipe-0093 181 24 sections section NOUN pipe-0093 181 25 of of ADP pipe-0093 181 26 the the DET pipe-0093 181 27 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 181 28 that that PRON pipe-0093 181 29 were be AUX pipe-0093 181 30 not not PART pipe-0093 181 31 relevant relevant ADJ pipe-0093 181 32 to to ADP pipe-0093 181 33 the the DET pipe-0093 181 34 course course NOUN pipe-0093 181 35 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 181 36 hendricks hendrick NOUN pipe-0093 181 37 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 181 38 reinsberg reinsberg PROPN pipe-0093 181 39 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 181 40 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 181 41 rieger rieger PROPN pipe-0093 181 42 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 181 43 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 181 44 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 181 45 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 181 46 90 90 NUM pipe-0093 181 47 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 181 48 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 182 1 professors professor NOUN pipe-0093 182 2 also also ADV pipe-0093 182 3 stopped stop VERB pipe-0093 182 4 using use VERB pipe-0093 182 5 a a DET pipe-0093 182 6 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 182 7 software software NOUN pipe-0093 182 8 package package NOUN pipe-0093 182 9 for for ADP pipe-0093 182 10 homework homework NOUN pipe-0093 182 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 183 1 instead instead ADV pipe-0093 183 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 183 3 they they PRON pipe-0093 183 4 added add VERB pipe-0093 183 5 the the DET pipe-0093 183 6 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 183 7 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 183 8 review review VERB pipe-0093 183 9 questions question NOUN pipe-0093 183 10 to to ADP pipe-0093 183 11 the the DET pipe-0093 183 12 course course NOUN pipe-0093 183 13 website website NOUN pipe-0093 183 14 in in ADP pipe-0093 183 15 an an DET pipe-0093 183 16 attempt attempt NOUN pipe-0093 183 17 to to PART pipe-0093 183 18 reduce reduce VERB pipe-0093 183 19 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 183 20 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 183 21 simplify simplify PROPN pipe-0093 183 22 administration administration NOUN pipe-0093 183 23 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 183 24 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 183 25 simplify simplify VERB pipe-0093 183 26 students student NOUN pipe-0093 183 27 ’ ’ PART pipe-0093 183 28 experience experience NOUN pipe-0093 183 29 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 183 30 hendricks hendrick NOUN pipe-0093 183 31 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 183 32 et et PROPN pipe-0093 183 33 al al PROPN pipe-0093 183 34 . . PROPN pipe-0093 183 35 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 183 36 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 183 37 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 183 38 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 183 39 83 83 NUM pipe-0093 183 40 - - SYM pipe-0093 183 41 84 84 NUM pipe-0093 183 42 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 183 43 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 184 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 184 2 this this DET pipe-0093 184 3 instance instance NOUN pipe-0093 184 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 184 5 getting getting AUX pipe-0093 184 6 rid rid VERB pipe-0093 184 7 of of ADP pipe-0093 184 8 the the DET pipe-0093 184 9 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 184 10 homework homework NOUN pipe-0093 184 11 system system NOUN pipe-0093 184 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 184 13 rather rather ADV pipe-0093 184 14 than than ADP pipe-0093 184 15 the the DET pipe-0093 184 16 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 184 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 184 18 generated generate VERB pipe-0093 184 19 the the DET pipe-0093 184 20 greatest great ADJ pipe-0093 184 21 savings saving NOUN pipe-0093 184 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 185 1 hendricks hendrick NOUN pipe-0093 185 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 185 3 et et PROPN pipe-0093 185 4 al al PROPN pipe-0093 185 5 . . PROPN pipe-0093 185 6 found find VERB pipe-0093 185 7 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 185 8 students student NOUN pipe-0093 185 9 ’ ’ PART pipe-0093 185 10 problem problem NOUN pipe-0093 185 11 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 185 12 solving solve VERB pipe-0093 185 13 abilities ability NOUN pipe-0093 185 14 were be AUX pipe-0093 185 15 slightly slightly ADV pipe-0093 185 16 negatively negatively ADV pipe-0093 185 17 impacted impact VERB pipe-0093 185 18 by by ADP pipe-0093 185 19 the the DET pipe-0093 185 20 new new ADJ pipe-0093 185 21 homework homework NOUN pipe-0093 185 22 system system NOUN pipe-0093 185 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 186 1 the the DET pipe-0093 186 2 previous previous ADJ pipe-0093 186 3 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 186 4 system system NOUN pipe-0093 186 5 provided provide VERB pipe-0093 186 6 hints hint NOUN pipe-0093 186 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 186 8 tutorials tutorial NOUN pipe-0093 186 9 as as SCONJ pipe-0093 186 10 students student NOUN pipe-0093 186 11 completed complete VERB pipe-0093 186 12 their their PRON pipe-0093 186 13 homework homework NOUN pipe-0093 186 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 186 15 whereas whereas SCONJ pipe-0093 186 16 the the DET pipe-0093 186 17 new new ADJ pipe-0093 186 18 system system NOUN pipe-0093 186 19 simply simply ADV pipe-0093 186 20 provided provide VERB pipe-0093 186 21 correct correct ADJ pipe-0093 186 22 / / SYM pipe-0093 186 23 incorrect incorrect ADJ pipe-0093 186 24 feedback feedback NOUN pipe-0093 186 25 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 187 1 however however ADV pipe-0093 187 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 187 3 their their PRON pipe-0093 187 4 transparency transparency NOUN pipe-0093 187 5 demonstrates demonstrate VERB pipe-0093 187 6 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 187 7 moving move VERB pipe-0093 187 8 away away ADV pipe-0093 187 9 from from ADP pipe-0093 187 10 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 187 11 entities entity NOUN pipe-0093 187 12 in in ADP pipe-0093 187 13 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 187 14 education education NOUN pipe-0093 187 15 may may AUX pipe-0093 187 16 not not PART pipe-0093 187 17 be be AUX pipe-0093 187 18 painless painless ADJ pipe-0093 187 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 188 1 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 188 2 pedagogies pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 188 3 are be AUX pipe-0093 188 4 necessarily necessarily ADV pipe-0093 188 5 difficult difficult ADJ pipe-0093 188 6 because because SCONJ pipe-0093 188 7 the the DET pipe-0093 188 8 intention intention NOUN pipe-0093 188 9 is be AUX pipe-0093 188 10 to to PART pipe-0093 188 11 leave leave VERB pipe-0093 188 12 behind behind ADV pipe-0093 188 13 pre pre ADJ pipe-0093 188 14 - - ADJ pipe-0093 188 15 existing existing ADJ pipe-0093 188 16 approaches approach NOUN pipe-0093 188 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 189 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 189 2 this this DET pipe-0093 189 3 regard regard NOUN pipe-0093 189 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 189 5 the the DET pipe-0093 189 6 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 189 7 show show VERB pipe-0093 189 8 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 189 9 there there PRON pipe-0093 189 10 is be VERB pipe-0093 189 11 much much ADV pipe-0093 189 12 more more ADJ pipe-0093 189 13 to to PART pipe-0093 189 14 student student VERB pipe-0093 189 15 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 189 16 than than ADP pipe-0093 189 17 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 189 18 the the DET pipe-0093 189 19 same same ADJ pipe-0093 189 20 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 189 21 better well ADJ pipe-0093 189 22 results result NOUN pipe-0093 189 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 189 24 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 190 1 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 190 2 approaches approach NOUN pipe-0093 190 3 factored factor VERB pipe-0093 190 4 into into ADP pipe-0093 190 5 the the DET pipe-0093 190 6 decision decision NOUN pipe-0093 190 7 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 190 8 making make VERB pipe-0093 190 9 process process NOUN pipe-0093 190 10 in in ADP pipe-0093 190 11 the the DET pipe-0093 190 12 virginia virginia PROPN pipe-0093 190 13 state state PROPN pipe-0093 190 14 university university PROPN pipe-0093 190 15 study study NOUN pipe-0093 190 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 191 1 feldstein feldstein PROPN pipe-0093 191 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 191 3 et et PROPN pipe-0093 191 4 al al PROPN pipe-0093 191 5 . . PROPN pipe-0093 191 6 do do AUX pipe-0093 191 7 not not PART pipe-0093 191 8 provide provide VERB pipe-0093 191 9 details detail NOUN pipe-0093 191 10 on on ADP pipe-0093 191 11 pedagogical pedagogical ADJ pipe-0093 191 12 methods method NOUN pipe-0093 191 13 used use VERB pipe-0093 191 14 in in ADP pipe-0093 191 15 the the DET pipe-0093 191 16 courses course NOUN pipe-0093 191 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 191 18 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 191 19 vsu vsu NOUN pipe-0093 191 20 business business NOUN pipe-0093 191 21 school school NOUN pipe-0093 191 22 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 191 23 identified identify VERB pipe-0093 191 24 the the DET pipe-0093 191 25 value value NOUN pipe-0093 191 26 in in ADP pipe-0093 191 27 adopting adopt VERB pipe-0093 191 28 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 191 29 with with ADP pipe-0093 191 30 creative creative ADJ pipe-0093 191 31 commons common NOUN pipe-0093 191 32 licenses license NOUN pipe-0093 191 33 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 192 1 this this DET pipe-0093 192 2 way way NOUN pipe-0093 192 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 192 4 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 192 5 are be AUX pipe-0093 192 6 relatively relatively ADV pipe-0093 192 7 easy easy ADJ pipe-0093 192 8 to to PART pipe-0093 192 9 revise revise VERB pipe-0093 192 10 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 192 11 remix remix NOUN pipe-0093 192 12 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 192 13 their their PRON pipe-0093 192 14 teaching teaching NOUN pipe-0093 192 15 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 192 16 can can AUX pipe-0093 192 17 reflect reflect VERB pipe-0093 192 18 current current ADJ pipe-0093 192 19 events event NOUN pipe-0093 192 20 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 192 21 different different ADJ pipe-0093 192 22 points point NOUN pipe-0093 192 23 of of ADP pipe-0093 192 24 view view NOUN pipe-0093 192 25 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 192 26 feldstein feldstein PROPN pipe-0093 192 27 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 192 28 et et PROPN pipe-0093 192 29 al al PROPN pipe-0093 192 30 . . PROPN pipe-0093 192 31 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 192 32 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 192 33 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 192 34 pp pp PROPN pipe-0093 192 35 . . PROPN pipe-0093 193 1 1 1 NUM pipe-0093 193 2 - - SYM pipe-0093 193 3 2 2 NUM pipe-0093 193 4 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 193 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 194 1 as as SCONJ pipe-0093 194 2 one one NUM pipe-0093 194 3 professor professor NOUN pipe-0093 194 4 put put VERB pipe-0093 194 5 it it PRON pipe-0093 194 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 194 7 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 194 8 since since SCONJ pipe-0093 194 9 students student NOUN pipe-0093 194 10 now now ADV pipe-0093 194 11 had have VERB pipe-0093 194 12 permanent permanent ADJ pipe-0093 194 13 access access NOUN pipe-0093 194 14 to to ADP pipe-0093 194 15 content content NOUN pipe-0093 194 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 194 17 the the DET pipe-0093 194 18 value value NOUN pipe-0093 194 19 was be AUX pipe-0093 194 20 in in ADP pipe-0093 194 21 the the DET pipe-0093 194 22 information information NOUN pipe-0093 194 23 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 194 24 not not PART pipe-0093 194 25 in in ADP pipe-0093 194 26 the the DET pipe-0093 194 27 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 194 28 as as ADP pipe-0093 194 29 a a DET pipe-0093 194 30 commodity commodity NOUN pipe-0093 194 31 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 194 32 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 194 33 feldstein feldstein PROPN pipe-0093 194 34 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 194 35 et et PROPN pipe-0093 194 36 al al PROPN pipe-0093 194 37 . . PROPN pipe-0093 194 38 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 194 39 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 194 40 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 194 41 p. p. PROPN pipe-0093 194 42 8) 8) NUM pipe-0093 194 43 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 195 1 pawlyshyn pawlyshyn PROPN pipe-0093 195 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 195 3 braddlee braddlee PROPN pipe-0093 195 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 195 5 casper casper ADV pipe-0093 195 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 195 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 195 8 miller miller PROPN pipe-0093 195 9 document document NOUN pipe-0093 195 10 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 195 11 adoption adoption NOUN pipe-0093 195 12 for for ADP pipe-0093 195 13 ten ten NUM pipe-0093 195 14 high high ADJ pipe-0093 195 15 enrollment enrollment NOUN pipe-0093 195 16 courses course NOUN pipe-0093 195 17 at at ADP pipe-0093 195 18 seven seven NUM pipe-0093 195 19 institutions institution NOUN pipe-0093 195 20 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 195 21 part part NOUN pipe-0093 195 22 of of ADP pipe-0093 195 23 the the DET pipe-0093 195 24 project project PROPN pipe-0093 195 25 kaleidoscope kaleidoscope PROPN pipe-0093 195 26 open open ADJ pipe-0093 195 27 course course NOUN pipe-0093 195 28 initiative initiative NOUN pipe-0093 195 29 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 195 30 koci koci PROPN pipe-0093 195 31 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 195 32 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 196 1 their their PRON pipe-0093 196 2 writing writing NOUN pipe-0093 196 3 is be AUX pipe-0093 196 4 reflective reflective ADJ pipe-0093 196 5 to to ADP pipe-0093 196 6 an an DET pipe-0093 196 7 extent extent NOUN pipe-0093 196 8 rarely rarely ADV pipe-0093 196 9 found find VERB pipe-0093 196 10 in in ADP pipe-0093 196 11 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 196 12 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 196 13 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 196 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 197 1 they they PRON pipe-0093 197 2 dedicate dedicate VERB pipe-0093 197 3 just just ADV pipe-0093 197 4 as as ADV pipe-0093 197 5 much much ADJ pipe-0093 197 6 space space NOUN pipe-0093 197 7 to to ADP pipe-0093 197 8 pedagogical pedagogical ADJ pipe-0093 197 9 decision decision NOUN pipe-0093 197 10 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 197 11 making making NOUN pipe-0093 197 12 as as ADP pipe-0093 197 13 to to ADP pipe-0093 197 14 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 197 15 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 197 16 student student NOUN pipe-0093 197 17 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 197 18 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 198 1 this this DET pipe-0093 198 2 fact fact NOUN pipe-0093 198 3 may may AUX pipe-0093 198 4 be be AUX pipe-0093 198 5 connected connect VERB pipe-0093 198 6 to to ADP pipe-0093 198 7 the the DET pipe-0093 198 8 project project NOUN pipe-0093 198 9 design design NOUN pipe-0093 198 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 199 1 participants participant NOUN pipe-0093 199 2 collaborated collaborate VERB pipe-0093 199 3 across across ADP pipe-0093 199 4 institutions institution NOUN pipe-0093 199 5 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 199 6 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 199 7 held hold VERB pipe-0093 199 8 weekly weekly ADJ pipe-0093 199 9 skype skype NOUN pipe-0093 199 10 calls call NOUN pipe-0093 199 11 ! ! PUNCT pipe-0093 199 12 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 199 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 199 14 which which PRON pipe-0093 199 15 surfaced surface VERB pipe-0093 199 16 important important ADJ pipe-0093 199 17 differences difference NOUN pipe-0093 199 18 at at ADP pipe-0093 199 19 the the DET pipe-0093 199 20 respective respective ADJ pipe-0093 199 21 institutions institution NOUN pipe-0093 199 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 200 1 for for ADP pipe-0093 200 2 example example NOUN pipe-0093 200 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 200 4 student student NOUN pipe-0093 200 5 populations population NOUN pipe-0093 200 6 varied vary VERB pipe-0093 200 7 from from ADP pipe-0093 200 8 remedial remedial ADJ pipe-0093 200 9 to to ADP pipe-0093 200 10 college college NOUN pipe-0093 200 11 entry entry NOUN pipe-0093 200 12 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 200 13 pawlyshyn pawlyshyn PROPN pipe-0093 200 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 200 15 braddlee braddlee NOUN pipe-0093 200 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 200 17 casper casper ADV pipe-0093 200 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 200 19 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 200 20 miller miller PROPN pipe-0093 200 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 200 22 2013 2013 NUM pipe-0093 200 23 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 200 24 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 201 1 consequently consequently ADV pipe-0093 201 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 201 3 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 201 4 developed develop VERB pipe-0093 201 5 targets target NOUN pipe-0093 201 6 for for ADP pipe-0093 201 7 their their PRON pipe-0093 201 8 specific specific ADJ pipe-0093 201 9 student student NOUN pipe-0093 201 10 populations population NOUN pipe-0093 201 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 202 1 for for SCONJ pipe-0093 202 2 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 202 3 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 202 4 to to PART pipe-0093 202 5 succeed succeed VERB pipe-0093 202 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 202 7 the the DET pipe-0093 202 8 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 202 9 make make VERB pipe-0093 202 10 the the DET pipe-0093 202 11 following follow VERB pipe-0093 202 12 recommendation recommendation NOUN pipe-0093 202 13 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 202 14 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 202 15 introduce introduce VERB pipe-0093 202 16 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 202 17 facilitate facilitate VERB pipe-0093 202 18 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 202 19 efforts effort NOUN pipe-0093 202 20 through through ADP pipe-0093 202 21 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 202 22 initiative initiative NOUN pipe-0093 202 23 rather rather ADV pipe-0093 202 24 than than ADP pipe-0093 202 25 making make VERB pipe-0093 202 26 a a DET pipe-0093 202 27 top top ADJ pipe-0093 202 28 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 202 29 down down ADP pipe-0093 202 30 institutional institutional ADJ pipe-0093 202 31 directive directive NOUN pipe-0093 202 32 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 203 1 eventually eventually ADV pipe-0093 203 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 203 3 institutional institutional ADJ pipe-0093 203 4 policy policy NOUN pipe-0093 203 5 must must AUX pipe-0093 203 6 support support VERB pipe-0093 203 7 emergent emergent ADJ pipe-0093 203 8 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 203 9 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 203 10 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 203 11 pawlyshyn pawlyshyn INTJ pipe-0093 203 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 203 13 et et PROPN pipe-0093 203 14 al al PROPN pipe-0093 203 15 . . PROPN pipe-0093 203 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 203 17 2013 2013 NUM pipe-0093 203 18 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 203 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 204 1 even even ADV pipe-0093 204 2 when when SCONJ pipe-0093 204 3 documenting document VERB pipe-0093 204 4 koci koci PROPN pipe-0093 204 5 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 204 6 shortcomings shortcoming NOUN pipe-0093 204 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 204 8 pawlyshyn pawlyshyn VERB pipe-0093 204 9 et et PROPN pipe-0093 204 10 al al PROPN pipe-0093 204 11 . . PROPN pipe-0093 205 1 provide provide VERB pipe-0093 205 2 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 205 3 reflections reflection NOUN pipe-0093 205 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 206 1 some some DET pipe-0093 206 2 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 206 3 resisted resist VERB pipe-0093 206 4 koci koci NOUN pipe-0093 206 5 based base VERB pipe-0093 206 6 on on ADP pipe-0093 206 7 perceived perceive VERB pipe-0093 206 8 limitations limitation NOUN pipe-0093 206 9 to to ADP pipe-0093 206 10 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 206 11 freedom freedom NOUN pipe-0093 206 12 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 206 13 of of ADP pipe-0093 206 14 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 206 15 corporate corporate ADJ pipe-0093 206 16 interference interference NOUN pipe-0093 206 17 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 206 18 since since SCONJ pipe-0093 206 19 koci koci PROPN pipe-0093 206 20 used use VERB pipe-0093 206 21 lumen luman NOUN pipe-0093 206 22 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 206 23 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 206 24 received receive VERB pipe-0093 206 25 funding funding NOUN pipe-0093 206 26 from from ADP pipe-0093 206 27 the the DET pipe-0093 206 28 bill bill NOUN pipe-0093 206 29 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 206 30 melinda melinda PROPN pipe-0093 206 31 gates gate NOUN pipe-0093 206 32 foundation foundation NOUN pipe-0093 206 33 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 206 34 the the DET pipe-0093 206 35 hewlett hewlett PROPN pipe-0093 206 36 foundation foundation PROPN pipe-0093 206 37 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 206 38 pawlyshyn pawlyshyn INTJ pipe-0093 206 39 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 206 40 et et PROPN pipe-0093 206 41 al al PROPN pipe-0093 206 42 . . PROPN pipe-0093 206 43 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 206 44 2013 2013 NUM pipe-0093 206 45 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 206 46 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 207 1 the the DET pipe-0093 207 2 following follow VERB pipe-0093 207 3 section section NOUN pipe-0093 207 4 examines examine VERB pipe-0093 207 5 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 207 6 decisions decision NOUN pipe-0093 207 7 regarding regard VERB pipe-0093 207 8 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 207 9 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 207 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 207 11 which which PRON pipe-0093 207 12 can can AUX pipe-0093 207 13 include include VERB pipe-0093 207 14 collaborating collaborate VERB pipe-0093 207 15 with with ADP pipe-0093 207 16 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 207 17 vendors vendor NOUN pipe-0093 207 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 207 19 is be AUX pipe-0093 207 20 discussed discuss VERB pipe-0093 207 21 in in ADP pipe-0093 207 22 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 207 23 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 207 24 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 207 25 — — PUNCT pipe-0093 207 26 when when SCONJ pipe-0093 207 27 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 207 28 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 207 29 is be AUX pipe-0093 207 30 discussed discuss VERB pipe-0093 207 31 at at ADV pipe-0093 207 32 all all ADV pipe-0093 207 33 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 208 1 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 208 2 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 208 3 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 208 4 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 208 5 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 208 6 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 208 7 is be AUX pipe-0093 208 8 rarely rarely ADV pipe-0093 208 9 covered cover VERB pipe-0093 208 10 in in ADP pipe-0093 208 11 these these DET pipe-0093 208 12 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 208 13 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 209 1 this this PRON pipe-0093 209 2 is be AUX pipe-0093 209 3 understandable understandable ADJ pipe-0093 209 4 insofar insofar ADV pipe-0093 209 5 as as ADP pipe-0093 209 6 the the DET pipe-0093 209 7 focus focus NOUN pipe-0093 209 8 of of ADP pipe-0093 209 9 most most ADJ pipe-0093 209 10 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 209 11 is be AUX pipe-0093 209 12 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 209 13 savings saving NOUN pipe-0093 209 14 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 209 15 student student NOUN pipe-0093 209 16 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 209 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 210 1 however however ADV pipe-0093 210 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 210 3 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 210 4 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 210 5 is be AUX pipe-0093 210 6 central central ADJ pipe-0093 210 7 to to ADP pipe-0093 210 8 any any DET pipe-0093 210 9 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 210 10 initiative initiative PROPN pipe-0093 210 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 211 1 who who PRON pipe-0093 211 2 is be AUX pipe-0093 211 3 doing do VERB pipe-0093 211 4 the the DET pipe-0093 211 5 work work NOUN pipe-0093 211 6 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 212 1 are be AUX pipe-0093 212 2 they they PRON pipe-0093 212 3 getting getting AUX pipe-0093 212 4 paid pay VERB pipe-0093 212 5 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 213 1 is be AUX pipe-0093 213 2 this this DET pipe-0093 213 3 work work NOUN pipe-0093 213 4 acknowledged acknowledge VERB pipe-0093 213 5 for for ADP pipe-0093 213 6 promotion promotion NOUN pipe-0093 213 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 213 8 tenure tenure NOUN pipe-0093 213 9 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 214 1 based base VERB pipe-0093 214 2 on on ADP pipe-0093 214 3 the the DET pipe-0093 214 4 available available ADJ pipe-0093 214 5 literature literature NOUN pipe-0093 214 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 214 7 it it PRON pipe-0093 214 8 is be AUX pipe-0093 214 9 difficult difficult ADJ pipe-0093 214 10 to to PART pipe-0093 214 11 answer answer VERB pipe-0093 214 12 these these DET pipe-0093 214 13 questions question NOUN pipe-0093 214 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 215 1 calling call VERB pipe-0093 215 2 attention attention NOUN pipe-0093 215 3 to to ADP pipe-0093 215 4 the the DET pipe-0093 215 5 matter matter NOUN pipe-0093 215 6 will will AUX pipe-0093 215 7 hopefully hopefully ADV pipe-0093 215 8 help help VERB pipe-0093 215 9 remedy remedy VERB pipe-0093 215 10 this this DET pipe-0093 215 11 glaring glare VERB pipe-0093 215 12 omission omission NOUN pipe-0093 215 13 in in ADP pipe-0093 215 14 the the DET pipe-0093 215 15 literature literature NOUN pipe-0093 215 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 216 1 hendricks hendrick NOUN pipe-0093 216 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 216 3 et et PROPN pipe-0093 216 4 al al PROPN pipe-0093 216 5 . . PROPN pipe-0093 216 6 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 216 7 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 216 8 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 216 9 acknowledge acknowledge VERB pipe-0093 216 10 the the DET pipe-0093 216 11 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 216 12 of of ADP pipe-0093 216 13 adopting adopt VERB pipe-0093 216 14 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 216 15 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 216 16 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 216 17 the the DET pipe-0093 216 18 literature literature NOUN pipe-0093 216 19 on on ADP pipe-0093 216 20 open open ADJ pipe-0093 216 21 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 216 22 related relate VERB pipe-0093 216 23 to to AUX pipe-0093 216 24 cost cost VERB pipe-0093 216 25 focuses focus NOUN pipe-0093 216 26 on on ADP pipe-0093 216 27 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 216 28 savings saving NOUN pipe-0093 216 29 to to ADP pipe-0093 216 30 students student NOUN pipe-0093 216 31 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 216 32 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 216 33 it it PRON pipe-0093 216 34 ’s ’ VERB pipe-0093 216 35 important important ADJ pipe-0093 216 36 to to PART pipe-0093 216 37 keep keep VERB pipe-0093 216 38 in in ADP pipe-0093 216 39 mind mind NOUN pipe-0093 216 40 the the DET pipe-0093 216 41 possible possible ADJ pipe-0093 216 42 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 216 43 for for ADP pipe-0093 216 44 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 216 45 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 216 46 institutions institution NOUN pipe-0093 216 47 in in ADP pipe-0093 216 48 terms term NOUN pipe-0093 216 49 of of ADP pipe-0093 216 50 time time NOUN pipe-0093 216 51 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 216 52 support support NOUN pipe-0093 216 53 when when SCONJ pipe-0093 216 54 using use VERB pipe-0093 216 55 open open ADJ pipe-0093 216 56 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 216 57 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 216 58 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 216 59 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 216 60 94 94 NUM pipe-0093 216 61 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 216 62 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 217 1 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 217 2 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 217 3 graduate graduate NOUN pipe-0093 217 4 assistants assistant NOUN pipe-0093 217 5 worked work VERB pipe-0093 217 6 together together ADV pipe-0093 217 7 during during ADP pipe-0093 217 8 the the DET pipe-0093 217 9 summer summer NOUN pipe-0093 217 10 months month NOUN pipe-0093 217 11 to to PART pipe-0093 217 12 prepare prepare VERB pipe-0093 217 13 the the DET pipe-0093 217 14 course course NOUN pipe-0093 217 15 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 218 1 the the DET pipe-0093 218 2 latter latter ADJ pipe-0093 218 3 were be AUX pipe-0093 218 4 paid pay VERB pipe-0093 218 5 with with ADP pipe-0093 218 6 a a DET pipe-0093 218 7 teaching teaching NOUN pipe-0093 218 8 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 218 9 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 218 10 grant grant NOUN pipe-0093 218 11 of of ADP pipe-0093 218 12 c$20,000 c$20,000 PROPN pipe-0093 218 13 from from ADP pipe-0093 218 14 university university PROPN pipe-0093 218 15 of of ADP pipe-0093 218 16 british british PROPN pipe-0093 218 17 columbia columbia PROPN pipe-0093 218 18 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 219 1 ensuring ensure VERB pipe-0093 219 2 fair fair ADJ pipe-0093 219 3 compensation compensation NOUN pipe-0093 219 4 for for ADP pipe-0093 219 5 graduate graduate NOUN pipe-0093 219 6 assistants assistant NOUN pipe-0093 219 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 219 8 contingent contingent NOUN pipe-0093 219 9 workers worker NOUN pipe-0093 219 10 is be AUX pipe-0093 219 11 crucial crucial ADJ pipe-0093 219 12 from from ADP pipe-0093 219 13 a a DET pipe-0093 219 14 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 219 15 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 219 16 perspective perspective NOUN pipe-0093 219 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 220 1 however however ADV pipe-0093 220 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 220 3 there there PRON pipe-0093 220 4 is be VERB pipe-0093 220 5 no no DET pipe-0093 220 6 indication indication NOUN pipe-0093 220 7 the the DET pipe-0093 220 8 grant grant NOUN pipe-0093 220 9 covered cover VERB pipe-0093 220 10 the the DET pipe-0093 220 11 time time NOUN pipe-0093 220 12 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 220 13 effort effort NOUN pipe-0093 220 14 spent spend VERB pipe-0093 220 15 by by ADP pipe-0093 220 16 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 220 17 planning plan VERB pipe-0093 220 18 the the DET pipe-0093 220 19 project project NOUN pipe-0093 220 20 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 220 21 securing secure VERB pipe-0093 220 22 funds fund NOUN pipe-0093 220 23 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 220 24 selecting selecting NOUN pipe-0093 220 25 materials material NOUN pipe-0093 220 26 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 220 27 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 220 28 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 220 29 new new ADJ pipe-0093 220 30 systems system NOUN pipe-0093 220 31 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 221 1 are be AUX pipe-0093 221 2 these these DET pipe-0093 221 3 tasks task NOUN pipe-0093 221 4 considered consider VERB pipe-0093 221 5 part part NOUN pipe-0093 221 6 of of ADP pipe-0093 221 7 their their PRON pipe-0093 221 8 job job NOUN pipe-0093 221 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 221 10 were be AUX pipe-0093 221 11 they they PRON pipe-0093 221 12 paid pay VERB pipe-0093 221 13 a a DET pipe-0093 221 14 stipend stipend NOUN pipe-0093 221 15 for for ADP pipe-0093 221 16 extra extra ADJ pipe-0093 221 17 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 221 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 221 19 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 221 20 given give VERB pipe-0093 221 21 course course NOUN pipe-0093 221 22 release release NOUN pipe-0093 221 23 time time NOUN pipe-0093 221 24 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 221 25 to to PART pipe-0093 221 26 name name VERB pipe-0093 221 27 a a DET pipe-0093 221 28 few few ADJ pipe-0093 221 29 payment payment NOUN pipe-0093 221 30 options option NOUN pipe-0093 221 31 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 222 1 transparency transparency NOUN pipe-0093 222 2 on on ADP pipe-0093 222 3 the the DET pipe-0093 222 4 working work VERB pipe-0093 222 5 conditions condition NOUN pipe-0093 222 6 of of ADP pipe-0093 222 7 all all DET pipe-0093 222 8 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 222 9 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 222 10 staff staff NOUN pipe-0093 222 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 222 12 contingent contingent NOUN pipe-0093 222 13 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 222 14 full full ADJ pipe-0093 222 15 time time NOUN pipe-0093 222 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 222 17 is be AUX pipe-0093 222 18 necessary necessary ADJ pipe-0093 222 19 as as SCONJ pipe-0093 222 20 we we PRON pipe-0093 222 21 use use VERB pipe-0093 222 22 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 222 23 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 222 24 to to PART pipe-0093 222 25 implement implement VERB pipe-0093 222 26 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 222 27 document document NOUN pipe-0093 222 28 just just ADV pipe-0093 222 29 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 222 30 practices practice NOUN pipe-0093 222 31 for for ADP pipe-0093 222 32 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 222 33 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 222 34 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 223 1 pawlyshyn pawlyshyn PROPN pipe-0093 223 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 223 3 et et PROPN pipe-0093 223 4 al al PROPN pipe-0093 223 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 223 6 directly directly ADV pipe-0093 223 7 address address VERB pipe-0093 223 8 payment payment NOUN pipe-0093 223 9 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 223 10 incentives incentive NOUN pipe-0093 223 11 in in ADP pipe-0093 223 12 a a DET pipe-0093 223 13 section section NOUN pipe-0093 223 14 called call VERB pipe-0093 223 15 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 223 16 motivations motivation NOUN pipe-0093 223 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 223 18 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 224 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 224 2 addition addition NOUN pipe-0093 224 3 to to ADP pipe-0093 224 4 a a DET pipe-0093 224 5 small small ADJ pipe-0093 224 6 stipend stipend NOUN pipe-0093 224 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 224 8 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 224 9 participants participant NOUN pipe-0093 224 10 received receive VERB pipe-0093 224 11 travel travel NOUN pipe-0093 224 12 funds fund NOUN pipe-0093 224 13 to to PART pipe-0093 224 14 attend attend VERB pipe-0093 224 15 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 224 16 conferences conference NOUN pipe-0093 224 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 225 1 the the DET pipe-0093 225 2 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 225 3 claim claim VERB pipe-0093 225 4 this this PRON pipe-0093 225 5 was be AUX pipe-0093 225 6 an an DET pipe-0093 225 7 even even ADV pipe-0093 225 8 greater great ADJ pipe-0093 225 9 motivator motivator NOUN pipe-0093 225 10 than than ADP pipe-0093 225 11 the the DET pipe-0093 225 12 stipend stipend NOUN pipe-0093 225 13 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 225 14 they they PRON pipe-0093 225 15 make make VERB pipe-0093 225 16 explicit explicit ADJ pipe-0093 225 17 recommendations recommendation NOUN pipe-0093 225 18 for for ADP pipe-0093 225 19 other other ADJ pipe-0093 225 20 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 225 21 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 225 22 to to PART pipe-0093 225 23 allocate allocate VERB pipe-0093 225 24 funds fund NOUN pipe-0093 225 25 for for ADP pipe-0093 225 26 conference conference NOUN pipe-0093 225 27 attendance attendance NOUN pipe-0093 225 28 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 225 29 pawlyshyn pawlyshyn PROPN pipe-0093 225 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 225 31 et et PROPN pipe-0093 225 32 al al PROPN pipe-0093 225 33 . . PROPN pipe-0093 225 34 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 225 35 2013 2013 NUM pipe-0093 225 36 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 225 37 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 226 1 though though SCONJ pipe-0093 226 2 the the DET pipe-0093 226 3 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 226 4 do do AUX pipe-0093 226 5 not not PART pipe-0093 226 6 explain explain VERB pipe-0093 226 7 why why SCONJ pipe-0093 226 8 professional professional ADJ pipe-0093 226 9 development development NOUN pipe-0093 226 10 funds fund NOUN pipe-0093 226 11 were be AUX pipe-0093 226 12 so so ADV pipe-0093 226 13 popular popular ADJ pipe-0093 226 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 226 15 the the DET pipe-0093 226 16 implication implication NOUN pipe-0093 226 17 is be AUX pipe-0093 226 18 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 226 19 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 226 20 relished relish VERB pipe-0093 226 21 the the DET pipe-0093 226 22 opportunity opportunity NOUN pipe-0093 226 23 to to PART pipe-0093 226 24 share share VERB pipe-0093 226 25 their their PRON pipe-0093 226 26 work work NOUN pipe-0093 226 27 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 226 28 learn learn VERB pipe-0093 226 29 from from ADP pipe-0093 226 30 others other NOUN pipe-0093 226 31 in in ADP pipe-0093 226 32 a a DET pipe-0093 226 33 community community NOUN pipe-0093 226 34 of of ADP pipe-0093 226 35 practice practice NOUN pipe-0093 226 36 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 227 1 one one NUM pipe-0093 227 2 shortcoming shortcoming NOUN pipe-0093 227 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 227 4 their their PRON pipe-0093 227 5 report report NOUN pipe-0093 227 6 is be AUX pipe-0093 227 7 it it PRON pipe-0093 227 8 does do AUX pipe-0093 227 9 not not PART pipe-0093 227 10 include include VERB pipe-0093 227 11 any any DET pipe-0093 227 12 information information NOUN pipe-0093 227 13 about about ADP pipe-0093 227 14 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 227 15 lumen luman NOUN pipe-0093 227 16 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 227 17 was be AUX pipe-0093 227 18 involved involve VERB pipe-0093 227 19 in in ADP pipe-0093 227 20 koci koci PROPN pipe-0093 227 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 227 22 especially especially ADV pipe-0093 227 23 with with ADP pipe-0093 227 24 regard regard NOUN pipe-0093 227 25 to to ADP pipe-0093 227 26 myopenmath myopenmath NOUN pipe-0093 227 27 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 227 28 mom mom NOUN pipe-0093 227 29 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 227 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 227 31 a a DET pipe-0093 227 32 free free ADJ pipe-0093 227 33 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 227 34 online online ADJ pipe-0093 227 35 course course NOUN pipe-0093 227 36 management management NOUN pipe-0093 227 37 system system NOUN pipe-0093 227 38 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 228 1 it it PRON pipe-0093 228 2 would would AUX pipe-0093 228 3 be be AUX pipe-0093 228 4 helpful helpful ADJ pipe-0093 228 5 to to PART pipe-0093 228 6 know know VERB pipe-0093 228 7 if if SCONJ pipe-0093 228 8 koci koci PROPN pipe-0093 228 9 used use VERB pipe-0093 228 10 the the DET pipe-0093 228 11 free free ADJ pipe-0093 228 12 version version NOUN pipe-0093 228 13 of of ADP pipe-0093 228 14 mom mom NOUN pipe-0093 228 15 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 228 16 the the DET pipe-0093 228 17 lumen luman NOUN pipe-0093 228 18 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 228 19 supported support VERB pipe-0093 228 20 version version NOUN pipe-0093 228 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 228 22 lumen luman NOUN pipe-0093 228 23 ohm ohm PROPN pipe-0093 228 24 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 229 1 each each DET pipe-0093 229 2 option option NOUN pipe-0093 229 3 presents present VERB pipe-0093 229 4 distinct distinct ADJ pipe-0093 229 5 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 229 6 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 229 7 maintenance maintenance NOUN pipe-0093 229 8 issues issue NOUN pipe-0093 229 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 229 10 namely namely ADV pipe-0093 229 11 vendor vendor NOUN pipe-0093 229 12 fees fee NOUN pipe-0093 229 13 versus versus ADP pipe-0093 229 14 local local ADJ pipe-0093 229 15 maintenance maintenance NOUN pipe-0093 229 16 expenses expense NOUN pipe-0093 229 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 230 1 allen allen PROPN pipe-0093 230 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 230 3 et et PROPN pipe-0093 230 4 al al PROPN pipe-0093 230 5 . . PROPN pipe-0093 230 6 contrast contrast VERB pipe-0093 230 7 the the DET pipe-0093 230 8 commercial commercial ADJ pipe-0093 230 9 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 230 10 publishing publishing NOUN pipe-0093 230 11 process process NOUN pipe-0093 230 12 – – PUNCT pipe-0093 230 13 a a DET pipe-0093 230 14 small small ADJ pipe-0093 230 15 group group NOUN pipe-0093 230 16 of of ADP pipe-0093 230 17 experts expert NOUN pipe-0093 230 18 deciding decide VERB pipe-0093 230 19 on on ADP pipe-0093 230 20 relevant relevant ADJ pipe-0093 230 21 content content NOUN pipe-0093 230 22 – – PUNCT pipe-0093 230 23 with with ADP pipe-0093 230 24 the the DET pipe-0093 230 25 horizontal horizontal ADJ pipe-0093 230 26 crowdsourcing crowdsourcing NOUN pipe-0093 230 27 of of ADP pipe-0093 230 28 chemwiki chemwiki NOUN pipe-0093 230 29 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 231 1 the the DET pipe-0093 231 2 infrastructure infrastructure NOUN pipe-0093 231 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 231 4 chemwiki chemwiki NOUN pipe-0093 231 5 is be AUX pipe-0093 231 6 developed develop VERB pipe-0093 231 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 231 8 maintained maintain VERB pipe-0093 231 9 by by ADP pipe-0093 231 10 professors professor NOUN pipe-0093 231 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 231 12 research research NOUN pipe-0093 231 13 assistants assistant NOUN pipe-0093 231 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 231 15 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 231 16 students student NOUN pipe-0093 231 17 who who PRON pipe-0093 231 18 regularly regularly ADV pipe-0093 231 19 review review VERB pipe-0093 231 20 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 231 21 update update VERB pipe-0093 231 22 content content NOUN pipe-0093 231 23 for for ADP pipe-0093 231 24 difficulty difficulty NOUN pipe-0093 231 25 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 231 26 allen allen PROPN pipe-0093 231 27 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 231 28 et et PROPN pipe-0093 231 29 al al PROPN pipe-0093 231 30 . . PROPN pipe-0093 231 31 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 231 32 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 231 33 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 231 34 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 231 35 3 3 NUM pipe-0093 231 36 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 231 37 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 232 1 the the DET pipe-0093 232 2 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 232 3 do do AUX pipe-0093 232 4 not not PART pipe-0093 232 5 discuss discuss VERB pipe-0093 232 6 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 232 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 232 8 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 232 9 if if SCONJ pipe-0093 232 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 232 11 in in ADP pipe-0093 232 12 the the DET pipe-0093 232 13 case case NOUN pipe-0093 232 14 of of ADP pipe-0093 232 15 students student NOUN pipe-0093 232 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 232 17 this this DET pipe-0093 232 18 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 232 19 is be AUX pipe-0093 232 20 compensated compensate VERB pipe-0093 232 21 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 232 22 otherwise otherwise ADV pipe-0093 232 23 supported support VERB pipe-0093 232 24 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 233 1 the the DET pipe-0093 233 2 final final ADJ pipe-0093 233 3 example example NOUN pipe-0093 233 4 in in ADP pipe-0093 233 5 this this DET pipe-0093 233 6 subsection subsection NOUN pipe-0093 233 7 examines examine VERB pipe-0093 233 8 a a DET pipe-0093 233 9 study study NOUN pipe-0093 233 10 that that PRON pipe-0093 233 11 looks look VERB pipe-0093 233 12 to to PART pipe-0093 233 13 oer oer VERB pipe-0093 233 14 as as ADP pipe-0093 233 15 an an DET pipe-0093 233 16 institutional institutional ADJ pipe-0093 233 17 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 233 18 saving saving NOUN pipe-0093 233 19 measure measure NOUN pipe-0093 233 20 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 234 1 bowen bowen PROPN pipe-0093 234 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 234 3 chingos chingos PROPN pipe-0093 234 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 234 5 lack lack NOUN pipe-0093 234 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 234 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 234 8 nygren nygren PROPN pipe-0093 234 9 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 234 10 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 234 11 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 234 12 examine examine VERB pipe-0093 234 13 an an DET pipe-0093 234 14 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 234 15 hybrid hybrid ADJ pipe-0093 234 16 learning learning NOUN pipe-0093 234 17 environment environment NOUN pipe-0093 234 18 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 234 19 a a DET pipe-0093 234 20 mix mix NOUN pipe-0093 234 21 of of ADP pipe-0093 234 22 in in ADP pipe-0093 234 23 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 234 24 person person NOUN pipe-0093 234 25 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 234 26 online online ADV pipe-0093 234 27 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 234 28 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 235 1 published publish VERB pipe-0093 235 2 by by ADP pipe-0093 235 3 ithaka ithaka PROPN pipe-0093 235 4 s+r s+r PROPN pipe-0093 235 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 235 6 a a DET pipe-0093 235 7 consulting consult VERB pipe-0093 235 8 non non NOUN pipe-0093 235 9 - - NOUN pipe-0093 235 10 profit profit NOUN pipe-0093 235 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 235 12 the the DET pipe-0093 235 13 study study NOUN pipe-0093 235 14 tested test VERB pipe-0093 235 15 traditional traditional ADJ pipe-0093 235 16 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 235 17 hybrid hybrid ADJ pipe-0093 235 18 classes class NOUN pipe-0093 235 19 for for ADP pipe-0093 235 20 a a DET pipe-0093 235 21 basic basic ADJ pipe-0093 235 22 statistics statistic NOUN pipe-0093 235 23 course course NOUN pipe-0093 235 24 designed design VERB pipe-0093 235 25 at at ADP pipe-0093 235 26 carnegie carnegie PROPN pipe-0093 235 27 mellon mellon NOUN pipe-0093 235 28 university university PROPN pipe-0093 235 29 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 235 30 taught teach VERB pipe-0093 235 31 at at ADP pipe-0093 235 32 six six NUM pipe-0093 235 33 public public ADJ pipe-0093 235 34 universities university NOUN pipe-0093 235 35 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 236 1 like like ADP pipe-0093 236 2 most most ADJ pipe-0093 236 3 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 236 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 236 5 bowen bowen PROPN pipe-0093 236 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 236 7 et et PROPN pipe-0093 236 8 al al PROPN pipe-0093 236 9 . . PROPN pipe-0093 236 10 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 236 11 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 236 12 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 236 13 found find VERB pipe-0093 236 14 the the DET pipe-0093 236 15 hybrid hybrid ADJ pipe-0093 236 16 format format NOUN pipe-0093 236 17 produced produce VERB pipe-0093 236 18 the the DET pipe-0093 236 19 same same ADJ pipe-0093 236 20 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 236 21 better well ADJ pipe-0093 236 22 results result NOUN pipe-0093 236 23 than than ADP pipe-0093 236 24 traditional traditional ADJ pipe-0093 236 25 classroom classroom NOUN pipe-0093 236 26 instruction instruction NOUN pipe-0093 236 27 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 236 28 pp pp PROPN pipe-0093 236 29 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 237 1 18 18 NUM pipe-0093 237 2 - - SYM pipe-0093 237 3 21 21 NUM pipe-0093 237 4 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 237 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 238 1 unlike unlike ADP pipe-0093 238 2 most most ADJ pipe-0093 238 3 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 238 4 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 238 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 238 6 bowen bowen PROPN pipe-0093 238 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 238 8 et et PROPN pipe-0093 238 9 al al PROPN pipe-0093 238 10 . . PROPN pipe-0093 238 11 also also ADV pipe-0093 238 12 tested test VERB pipe-0093 238 13 whether whether SCONJ pipe-0093 238 14 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 238 15 not not PART pipe-0093 238 16 the the DET pipe-0093 238 17 oer oer ADJ pipe-0093 238 18 / / SYM pipe-0093 238 19 hybrid hybrid ADJ pipe-0093 238 20 method method NOUN pipe-0093 238 21 can can AUX pipe-0093 238 22 lower lower VERB pipe-0093 238 23 instructor instructor NOUN pipe-0093 238 24 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 238 25 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 239 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 239 2 their their PRON pipe-0093 239 3 model model NOUN pipe-0093 239 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 239 5 the the DET pipe-0093 239 6 hybrid hybrid ADJ pipe-0093 239 7 course course NOUN pipe-0093 239 8 would would AUX pipe-0093 239 9 be be AUX pipe-0093 239 10 supervised supervise VERB pipe-0093 239 11 by by ADP pipe-0093 239 12 tenure tenure NOUN pipe-0093 239 13 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 239 14 track track NOUN pipe-0093 239 15 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 239 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 239 17 with with ADP pipe-0093 239 18 in in ADP pipe-0093 239 19 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 239 20 person person NOUN pipe-0093 239 21 sections section NOUN pipe-0093 239 22 led lead VERB pipe-0093 239 23 by by ADP pipe-0093 239 24 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 239 25 teaching teaching NOUN pipe-0093 239 26 assistants assistant NOUN pipe-0093 239 27 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 239 28 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 239 29 administrative administrative ADJ pipe-0093 239 30 work work NOUN pipe-0093 239 31 handled handle VERB pipe-0093 239 32 by by ADP pipe-0093 239 33 a a DET pipe-0093 239 34 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 239 35 part part ADJ pipe-0093 239 36 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 239 37 time time NOUN pipe-0093 239 38 instructor instructor NOUN pipe-0093 239 39 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 239 40 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 239 41 bowen bowen PROPN pipe-0093 239 42 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 239 43 et et PROPN pipe-0093 239 44 al al PROPN pipe-0093 239 45 . . PROPN pipe-0093 239 46 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 239 47 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 239 48 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 239 49 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 239 50 25 25 NUM pipe-0093 239 51 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 239 52 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 240 1 admittedly admittedly ADV pipe-0093 240 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 240 3 this this PRON pipe-0093 240 4 is be AUX pipe-0093 240 5 one one NUM pipe-0093 240 6 line line NOUN pipe-0093 240 7 of of ADP pipe-0093 240 8 inquiry inquiry NOUN pipe-0093 240 9 in in ADP pipe-0093 240 10 a a DET pipe-0093 240 11 lengthy lengthy ADJ pipe-0093 240 12 report report NOUN pipe-0093 240 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 240 14 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 240 15 using use VERB pipe-0093 240 16 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 240 17 as as ADP pipe-0093 240 18 a a DET pipe-0093 240 19 way way NOUN pipe-0093 240 20 to to PART pipe-0093 240 21 lower lower VERB pipe-0093 240 22 operating operating NOUN pipe-0093 240 23 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 240 24 is be AUX pipe-0093 240 25 anathema anathema NOUN pipe-0093 240 26 to to ADP pipe-0093 240 27 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 240 28 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 240 29 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 240 30 social social ADJ pipe-0093 240 31 justice justice NOUN pipe-0093 240 32 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 241 1 the the DET pipe-0093 241 2 authors author NOUN pipe-0093 241 3 estimate estimate VERB pipe-0093 241 4 large large ADJ pipe-0093 241 5 scale scale NOUN pipe-0093 241 6 implementation implementation NOUN pipe-0093 241 7 could could AUX pipe-0093 241 8 reduce reduce VERB pipe-0093 241 9 instructor instructor NOUN pipe-0093 241 10 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 241 11 36%-57 36%-57 NUM pipe-0093 241 12 % % NOUN pipe-0093 241 13 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 241 14 bowen bowen PROPN pipe-0093 241 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 241 16 et et PROPN pipe-0093 241 17 al al PROPN pipe-0093 241 18 . . PROPN pipe-0093 241 19 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 241 20 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 241 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 241 22 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 241 23 26 26 NUM pipe-0093 241 24 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 241 25 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 242 1 they they PRON pipe-0093 242 2 do do AUX pipe-0093 242 3 not not PART pipe-0093 242 4 include include VERB pipe-0093 242 5 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 242 6 they they PRON pipe-0093 242 7 reach reach VERB pipe-0093 242 8 these these DET pipe-0093 242 9 numbers number NOUN pipe-0093 242 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 242 11 likely likely ADJ pipe-0093 242 12 because because SCONJ pipe-0093 242 13 they they PRON pipe-0093 242 14 would would AUX pipe-0093 242 15 be be AUX pipe-0093 242 16 perceived perceive VERB pipe-0093 242 17 as as ADP pipe-0093 242 18 controversial controversial ADJ pipe-0093 242 19 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 242 20 if if SCONJ pipe-0093 242 21 not not PART pipe-0093 242 22 incendiary incendiary ADJ pipe-0093 242 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 243 1 conclusion conclusion NOUN pipe-0093 243 2 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 243 3 future future ADJ pipe-0093 243 4 considerations consideration NOUN pipe-0093 243 5 oer oer VERB pipe-0093 243 6 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 243 7 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 243 8 are be AUX pipe-0093 243 9 just just ADV pipe-0093 243 10 as as ADP pipe-0093 243 11 revealing reveal VERB pipe-0093 243 12 for for ADP pipe-0093 243 13 what what PRON pipe-0093 243 14 they they PRON pipe-0093 243 15 omit omit VERB pipe-0093 243 16 as as ADP pipe-0093 243 17 for for ADP pipe-0093 243 18 what what PRON pipe-0093 243 19 they they PRON pipe-0093 243 20 include include VERB pipe-0093 243 21 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 244 1 it it PRON pipe-0093 244 2 is be AUX pipe-0093 244 3 challenging challenge VERB pipe-0093 244 4 to to PART pipe-0093 244 5 design design VERB pipe-0093 244 6 a a DET pipe-0093 244 7 methodologically methodologically ADV pipe-0093 244 8 sound sound ADJ pipe-0093 244 9 study study NOUN pipe-0093 244 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 244 11 especially especially ADV pipe-0093 244 12 under under ADP pipe-0093 244 13 tight tight ADJ pipe-0093 244 14 timelines timeline NOUN pipe-0093 244 15 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 244 16 tight(er tight(er NOUN pipe-0093 244 17 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 244 18 budgets budget NOUN pipe-0093 244 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 245 1 given give VERB pipe-0093 245 2 this this DET pipe-0093 245 3 reality reality NOUN pipe-0093 245 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 245 5 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 245 6 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 245 7 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 245 8 tell tell VERB pipe-0093 245 9 the the DET pipe-0093 245 10 tidiest tidy ADJ pipe-0093 245 11 story story NOUN pipe-0093 245 12 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 245 13 saving save VERB pipe-0093 245 14 students student NOUN pipe-0093 245 15 money money NOUN pipe-0093 245 16 is be AUX pipe-0093 245 17 good good ADJ pipe-0093 245 18 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 245 19 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 245 20 may may AUX pipe-0093 245 21 improve improve VERB pipe-0093 245 22 student student NOUN pipe-0093 245 23 learning learning NOUN pipe-0093 245 24 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 246 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 246 2 this this DET pipe-0093 246 3 respect respect NOUN pipe-0093 246 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 246 5 these these DET pipe-0093 246 6 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 246 7 conform conform VERB pipe-0093 246 8 to to ADP pipe-0093 246 9 the the DET pipe-0093 246 10 logics logic NOUN pipe-0093 246 11 of of ADP pipe-0093 246 12 funders funder NOUN pipe-0093 246 13 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 246 14 administrators administrator NOUN pipe-0093 246 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 246 16 not not PART pipe-0093 246 17 students student NOUN pipe-0093 246 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 246 19 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 246 20 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 246 21 librarians librarian NOUN pipe-0093 246 22 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 246 23 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 246 24 staff staff NOUN pipe-0093 246 25 working work VERB pipe-0093 246 26 at at ADP pipe-0093 246 27 colleges college NOUN pipe-0093 246 28 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 246 29 universities university NOUN pipe-0093 246 30 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 247 1 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 247 2 this this DET pipe-0093 247 3 story story NOUN pipe-0093 247 4 elides elide VERB pipe-0093 247 5 an an DET pipe-0093 247 6 inconvenient inconvenient ADJ pipe-0093 247 7 truth truth NOUN pipe-0093 247 8 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 247 9 if if SCONJ pipe-0093 247 10 students student NOUN pipe-0093 247 11 are be AUX pipe-0093 247 12 not not PART pipe-0093 247 13 buying buy VERB pipe-0093 247 14 expensive expensive ADJ pipe-0093 247 15 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 247 16 to to PART pipe-0093 247 17 begin begin VERB pipe-0093 247 18 with with ADP pipe-0093 247 19 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 247 20 florida florida PROPN pipe-0093 247 21 virtual virtual ADJ pipe-0093 247 22 campus campus NOUN pipe-0093 247 23 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 247 24 2019 2019 NUM pipe-0093 247 25 ; ; PUNCT pipe-0093 247 26 feldstein feldstein PROPN pipe-0093 247 27 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 247 28 et et PROPN pipe-0093 247 29 al al PROPN pipe-0093 247 30 . . PROPN pipe-0093 247 31 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 247 32 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 247 33 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 247 34 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 247 35 are be AUX pipe-0093 247 36 they they PRON pipe-0093 247 37 saving save VERB pipe-0093 247 38 money money NOUN pipe-0093 247 39 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 247 40 are be AUX pipe-0093 247 41 they they PRON pipe-0093 247 42 not not PART pipe-0093 247 43 spending spend VERB pipe-0093 247 44 money money NOUN pipe-0093 247 45 they they PRON pipe-0093 247 46 do do AUX pipe-0093 247 47 not not PART pipe-0093 247 48 have have VERB pipe-0093 247 49 in in ADP pipe-0093 247 50 the the DET pipe-0093 247 51 first first ADJ pipe-0093 247 52 place place NOUN pipe-0093 247 53 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 248 1 this this PRON pipe-0093 248 2 is be AUX pipe-0093 248 3 not not PART pipe-0093 248 4 to to PART pipe-0093 248 5 say say VERB pipe-0093 248 6 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 248 7 well well ADV pipe-0093 248 8 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 248 9 designed design VERB pipe-0093 248 10 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 248 11 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 248 12 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 248 13 are be AUX pipe-0093 248 14 irrelevant irrelevant ADJ pipe-0093 248 15 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 249 1 the the DET pipe-0093 249 2 above above ADJ pipe-0093 249 3 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 249 4 are be AUX pipe-0093 249 5 valuable valuable ADJ pipe-0093 249 6 for for ADP pipe-0093 249 7 their their PRON pipe-0093 249 8 analysis analysis NOUN pipe-0093 249 9 of of ADP pipe-0093 249 10 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 249 11 advocacy advocacy NOUN pipe-0093 249 12 for for ADP pipe-0093 249 13 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 249 14 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 249 15 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 250 1 but but CCONJ pipe-0093 250 2 the the DET pipe-0093 250 3 desire desire NOUN pipe-0093 250 4 to to PART pipe-0093 250 5 quantify you VERB pipe-0093 250 6 all all DET pipe-0093 250 7 aspects aspect NOUN pipe-0093 250 8 of of ADP pipe-0093 250 9 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 250 10 ed ed NOUN pipe-0093 250 11 is be AUX pipe-0093 250 12 reflected reflect VERB pipe-0093 250 13 in in ADP pipe-0093 250 14 the the DET pipe-0093 250 15 literature literature NOUN pipe-0093 250 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 251 1 the the DET pipe-0093 251 2 statistics statistic NOUN pipe-0093 251 3 are be AUX pipe-0093 251 4 given give VERB pipe-0093 251 5 primacy primacy NOUN pipe-0093 251 6 over over ADP pipe-0093 251 7 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 251 8 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 252 1 can can AUX pipe-0093 252 2 an an DET pipe-0093 252 3 education education NOUN pipe-0093 252 4 committed commit VERB pipe-0093 252 5 to to ADP pipe-0093 252 6 measuring measure VERB pipe-0093 252 7 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 252 8 student student NOUN pipe-0093 252 9 success success NOUN pipe-0093 252 10 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 252 11 ever ever ADV pipe-0093 252 12 be be AUX pipe-0093 252 13 liberatory liberatory ADJ pipe-0093 252 14 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 253 1 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 253 2 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 253 3 does do AUX pipe-0093 253 4 not not PART pipe-0093 253 5 reduce reduce VERB pipe-0093 253 6 students student NOUN pipe-0093 253 7 to to ADP pipe-0093 253 8 their their PRON pipe-0093 253 9 letter letter NOUN pipe-0093 253 10 grades grade NOUN pipe-0093 253 11 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 253 12 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 253 13 many many ADJ pipe-0093 253 14 dollars dollar NOUN pipe-0093 253 15 they they PRON pipe-0093 253 16 saved save VERB pipe-0093 253 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 254 1 rather rather ADV pipe-0093 254 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 254 3 students student NOUN pipe-0093 254 4 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 254 5 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 254 6 engage engage NOUN pipe-0093 254 7 in in ADP pipe-0093 254 8 dialog dialog NOUN pipe-0093 254 9 about about ADP pipe-0093 254 10 defining define VERB pipe-0093 254 11 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 254 12 success success NOUN pipe-0093 254 13 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 255 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 255 2 contrast contrast NOUN pipe-0093 255 3 to to ADP pipe-0093 255 4 the the DET pipe-0093 255 5 above above ADJ pipe-0093 255 6 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 255 7 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 255 8 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 255 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 255 10 qualitative qualitative ADJ pipe-0093 255 11 approaches approach NOUN pipe-0093 255 12 used use VERB pipe-0093 255 13 in in ADP pipe-0093 255 14 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 255 15 perception perception NOUN pipe-0093 255 16 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 255 17 could could AUX pipe-0093 255 18 be be AUX pipe-0093 255 19 incorporated incorporate VERB pipe-0093 255 20 more more ADV pipe-0093 255 21 often often ADV pipe-0093 255 22 to to PART pipe-0093 255 23 center center VERB pipe-0093 255 24 students student NOUN pipe-0093 255 25 ’ ’ PART pipe-0093 255 26 voices voice NOUN pipe-0093 255 27 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 256 1 action action NOUN pipe-0093 256 2 research research NOUN pipe-0093 256 3 is be AUX pipe-0093 256 4 another another DET pipe-0093 256 5 approach approach NOUN pipe-0093 256 6 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 257 1 according accord VERB pipe-0093 257 2 to to ADP pipe-0093 257 3 sagor sagor NOUN pipe-0093 257 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 257 5 action action NOUN pipe-0093 257 6 research research NOUN pipe-0093 257 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 257 8 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 257 9 is be AUX pipe-0093 257 10 a a DET pipe-0093 257 11 disciplined discipline VERB pipe-0093 257 12 process process NOUN pipe-0093 257 13 of of ADP pipe-0093 257 14 inquiry inquiry NOUN pipe-0093 257 15 conducted conduct VERB pipe-0093 257 16 by by ADP pipe-0093 257 17 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 257 18 for for ADP pipe-0093 257 19 those those PRON pipe-0093 257 20 taking take VERB pipe-0093 257 21 the the DET pipe-0093 257 22 action action NOUN pipe-0093 257 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 258 1 the the DET pipe-0093 258 2 primary primary ADJ pipe-0093 258 3 reason reason NOUN pipe-0093 258 4 for for ADP pipe-0093 258 5 engaging engage VERB pipe-0093 258 6 in in ADP pipe-0093 258 7 action action NOUN pipe-0093 258 8 research research NOUN pipe-0093 258 9 is be AUX pipe-0093 258 10 to to PART pipe-0093 258 11 assist assist VERB pipe-0093 258 12 the the DET pipe-0093 258 13 ‘ ' PUNCT pipe-0093 258 14 actor actor NOUN pipe-0093 258 15 ’ ' PUNCT pipe-0093 258 16 in in ADP pipe-0093 258 17 improving improve VERB pipe-0093 258 18 and/or and/or CCONJ pipe-0093 258 19 refining refine VERB pipe-0093 258 20 his his PRON pipe-0093 258 21 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 258 22 her her PRON pipe-0093 258 23 actions action NOUN pipe-0093 258 24 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 258 25 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 258 26 sagor sagor PROPN pipe-0093 258 27 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 258 28 2000 2000 NUM pipe-0093 258 29 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 258 30 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 259 1 action action NOUN pipe-0093 259 2 research research NOUN pipe-0093 259 3 on on ADP pipe-0093 259 4 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 259 5 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 259 6 would would AUX pipe-0093 259 7 be be AUX pipe-0093 259 8 a a DET pipe-0093 259 9 welcome welcome ADJ pipe-0093 259 10 addition addition NOUN pipe-0093 259 11 to to ADP pipe-0093 259 12 the the DET pipe-0093 259 13 literature literature NOUN pipe-0093 259 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 259 15 as as SCONJ pipe-0093 259 16 the the DET pipe-0093 259 17 method method NOUN pipe-0093 259 18 aligns align VERB pipe-0093 259 19 nicely nicely ADV pipe-0093 259 20 with with ADP pipe-0093 259 21 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 259 22 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 259 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 260 1 bowen bowen PROPN pipe-0093 260 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 260 3 et et PROPN pipe-0093 260 4 al al PROPN pipe-0093 260 5 . . PROPN pipe-0093 260 6 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 260 7 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 260 8 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 260 9 seem seem VERB pipe-0093 260 10 to to PART pipe-0093 260 11 accept accept VERB pipe-0093 260 12 the the DET pipe-0093 260 13 divestment divestment NOUN pipe-0093 260 14 of of ADP pipe-0093 260 15 public public ADJ pipe-0093 260 16 funds fund NOUN pipe-0093 260 17 for for ADP pipe-0093 260 18 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 260 19 education education NOUN pipe-0093 260 20 as as ADP pipe-0093 260 21 a a DET pipe-0093 260 22 permanent permanent ADJ pipe-0093 260 23 reality reality NOUN pipe-0093 260 24 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 260 25 instead instead ADV pipe-0093 260 26 of of ADP pipe-0093 260 27 an an DET pipe-0093 260 28 ongoing ongoing ADJ pipe-0093 260 29 struggle struggle NOUN pipe-0093 260 30 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 260 31 pp pp NOUN pipe-0093 260 32 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 261 1 4 4 NUM pipe-0093 261 2 - - SYM pipe-0093 261 3 6 6 NUM pipe-0093 261 4 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 262 1 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 263 1 their their PRON pipe-0093 263 2 solutions solution NOUN pipe-0093 263 3 address address VERB pipe-0093 263 4 the the DET pipe-0093 263 5 perspective perspective NOUN pipe-0093 263 6 of of ADP pipe-0093 263 7 administration administration NOUN pipe-0093 263 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 263 9 not not PART pipe-0093 263 10 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 263 11 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 263 12 students student NOUN pipe-0093 263 13 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 264 1 moreover moreover ADV pipe-0093 264 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 264 3 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 264 4 are be AUX pipe-0093 264 5 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 264 6 being be AUX pipe-0093 264 7 commercialized commercialize VERB pipe-0093 264 8 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 265 1 david david PROPN pipe-0093 265 2 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 265 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 265 4 a a DET pipe-0093 265 5 co co NOUN pipe-0093 265 6 - - NOUN pipe-0093 265 7 author author NOUN pipe-0093 265 8 on on ADP pipe-0093 265 9 several several ADJ pipe-0093 265 10 above above ADJ pipe-0093 265 11 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 265 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 265 13 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 265 14 many many ADJ pipe-0093 265 15 others other NOUN pipe-0093 265 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 265 17 is be AUX pipe-0093 265 18 the the DET pipe-0093 265 19 chief chief ADJ pipe-0093 265 20 academic academic ADJ pipe-0093 265 21 officer officer NOUN pipe-0093 265 22 at at ADP pipe-0093 265 23 lumen luman NOUN pipe-0093 265 24 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 265 25 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 266 1 a a DET pipe-0093 266 2 deeper deep ADJ pipe-0093 266 3 investigation investigation NOUN pipe-0093 266 4 into into ADP pipe-0093 266 5 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 266 6 open open ADJ pipe-0093 266 7 washing washing NOUN pipe-0093 266 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 266 9 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 266 10 or or CCONJ pipe-0093 266 11 proprietary proprietary ADJ pipe-0093 266 12 practices practice NOUN pipe-0093 266 13 disguised disguise VERB pipe-0093 266 14 as as ADP pipe-0093 266 15 open open ADJ pipe-0093 266 16 access access NOUN pipe-0093 266 17 / / SYM pipe-0093 266 18 licensing licensing NOUN pipe-0093 266 19 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 266 20 as as SCONJ pipe-0093 266 21 defined define VERB pipe-0093 266 22 by by ADP pipe-0093 266 23 watters watter NOUN pipe-0093 266 24 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 266 25 2014 2014 NUM pipe-0093 266 26 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 266 27 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 266 28 in in ADP pipe-0093 266 29 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 266 30 initiatives initiative NOUN pipe-0093 266 31 is be AUX pipe-0093 266 32 needed need VERB pipe-0093 266 33 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 267 1 alternative alternative ADJ pipe-0093 267 2 perspectives perspective NOUN pipe-0093 267 3 abound abound VERB pipe-0093 267 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 268 1 brier brier ADV pipe-0093 268 2 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 268 3 fabricant fabricant ADJ pipe-0093 268 4 decry decry VERB pipe-0093 268 5 austerity austerity NOUN pipe-0093 268 6 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 268 7 commercialization commercialization NOUN pipe-0093 268 8 in in ADP pipe-0093 268 9 their their PRON pipe-0093 268 10 full full ADV pipe-0093 268 11 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 268 12 throated throate VERB pipe-0093 268 13 defense defense NOUN pipe-0093 268 14 of of ADP pipe-0093 268 15 public public ADJ pipe-0093 268 16 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 268 17 education education NOUN pipe-0093 268 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 268 19 austerity austerity NOUN pipe-0093 268 20 blues blue NOUN pipe-0093 268 21 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 268 22 fighting fight VERB pipe-0093 268 23 for for ADP pipe-0093 268 24 the the DET pipe-0093 268 25 soul soul NOUN pipe-0093 268 26 of of ADP pipe-0093 268 27 public public ADJ pipe-0093 268 28 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 268 29 education education NOUN pipe-0093 268 30 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 268 31 2016 2016 NUM pipe-0093 268 32 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 268 33 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 269 1 winn winn PROPN pipe-0093 269 2 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 269 3 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 269 4 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 269 5 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 269 6 marxist marxist ADJ pipe-0093 269 7 analysis analysis NOUN pipe-0093 269 8 of of ADP pipe-0093 269 9 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 269 10 in in ADP pipe-0093 269 11 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 269 12 education education NOUN pipe-0093 269 13 cautions caution VERB pipe-0093 269 14 against against ADP pipe-0093 269 15 administrators administrator NOUN pipe-0093 269 16 ’ ’ PART pipe-0093 269 17 attempts attempt NOUN pipe-0093 269 18 to to PART pipe-0093 269 19 exploit exploit VERB pipe-0093 269 20 oer oer VERB pipe-0093 269 21 for for ADP pipe-0093 269 22 surplus surplus NOUN pipe-0093 269 23 value value NOUN pipe-0093 269 24 in in ADP pipe-0093 269 25 the the DET pipe-0093 269 26 form form NOUN pipe-0093 269 27 of of ADP pipe-0093 269 28 increased increase VERB pipe-0093 269 29 enrollment enrollment NOUN pipe-0093 269 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 269 31 lower low ADJ pipe-0093 269 32 teaching teaching NOUN pipe-0093 269 33 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 269 34 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 269 35 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 269 36 cultural cultural ADJ pipe-0093 269 37 prestige prestige NOUN pipe-0093 269 38 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 269 39 pp pp NOUN pipe-0093 269 40 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 270 1 143 143 NUM pipe-0093 270 2 - - NUM pipe-0093 270 3 144 144 NUM pipe-0093 270 4 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 270 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 271 1 farrow farrow NOUN pipe-0093 271 2 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 271 3 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 271 4 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 271 5 criticizes criticize VERB pipe-0093 271 6 the the DET pipe-0093 271 7 austerity austerity NOUN pipe-0093 271 8 mindset mindset NOUN pipe-0093 271 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 271 10 obsessed obsess VERB pipe-0093 271 11 with with ADP pipe-0093 271 12 efficiencies efficiency NOUN pipe-0093 271 13 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 271 14 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 271 15 promote promote VERB pipe-0093 271 16 the the DET pipe-0093 271 17 idea idea NOUN pipe-0093 271 18 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 271 19 technological technological ADJ pipe-0093 271 20 innovation innovation NOUN pipe-0093 271 21 can can AUX pipe-0093 271 22 offer offer VERB pipe-0093 271 23 neat neat ADJ pipe-0093 271 24 solutions solution NOUN pipe-0093 271 25 to to ADP pipe-0093 271 26 challenges challenge NOUN pipe-0093 271 27 faced face VERB pipe-0093 271 28 by by ADP pipe-0093 271 29 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 271 30 institutions institution NOUN pipe-0093 271 31 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 271 32 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 271 33 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 271 34 131 131 NUM pipe-0093 271 35 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 271 36 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 272 1 as as ADP pipe-0093 272 2 the the DET pipe-0093 272 3 title title NOUN pipe-0093 272 4 of of ADP pipe-0093 272 5 this this DET pipe-0093 272 6 article article NOUN pipe-0093 272 7 asks ask VERB pipe-0093 272 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 272 9 open open ADJ pipe-0093 272 10 to to ADP pipe-0093 272 11 what what PRON pipe-0093 272 12 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 273 1 a a DET pipe-0093 273 2 free free ADJ pipe-0093 273 3 version version NOUN pipe-0093 273 4 of of ADP pipe-0093 273 5 the the DET pipe-0093 273 6 status status NOUN pipe-0093 273 7 quo quo NOUN pipe-0093 273 8 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 274 1 the the DET pipe-0093 274 2 above above ADJ pipe-0093 274 3 analysis analysis NOUN pipe-0093 274 4 shows show VERB pipe-0093 274 5 that that SCONJ pipe-0093 274 6 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 274 7 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 274 8 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 274 9 would would AUX pipe-0093 274 10 benefit benefit VERB pipe-0093 274 11 from from ADP pipe-0093 274 12 greater great ADJ pipe-0093 274 13 transparency transparency NOUN pipe-0093 274 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 275 1 this this DET pipe-0093 275 2 transparency transparency NOUN pipe-0093 275 3 applies apply VERB pipe-0093 275 4 to to ADP pipe-0093 275 5 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 275 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 275 7 technology technology NOUN pipe-0093 275 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 275 9 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 275 10 the the DET pipe-0093 275 11 financial financial ADJ pipe-0093 275 12 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 275 13 emotional emotional ADJ pipe-0093 275 14 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 275 15 for for ADP pipe-0093 275 16 students student NOUN pipe-0093 275 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 275 18 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 275 19 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 275 20 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 275 21 staff staff NOUN pipe-0093 275 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 276 1 it it PRON pipe-0093 276 2 is be AUX pipe-0093 276 3 one one NUM pipe-0093 276 4 thing thing NOUN pipe-0093 276 5 to to PART pipe-0093 276 6 use use VERB pipe-0093 276 7 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 276 8 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 276 9 to to PART pipe-0093 276 10 diagnose diagnose VERB pipe-0093 276 11 the the DET pipe-0093 276 12 problem problem NOUN pipe-0093 276 13 with with ADP pipe-0093 276 14 the the DET pipe-0093 276 15 above above ADJ pipe-0093 276 16 studies study NOUN pipe-0093 276 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 277 1 it it PRON pipe-0093 277 2 is be AUX pipe-0093 277 3 a a DET pipe-0093 277 4 far far ADV pipe-0093 277 5 more more ADV pipe-0093 277 6 important important ADJ pipe-0093 277 7 challenge challenge NOUN pipe-0093 277 8 to to PART pipe-0093 277 9 address address VERB pipe-0093 277 10 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 277 11 ed ed PROPN pipe-0093 277 12 ’s ’s PART pipe-0093 277 13 contradictions contradiction NOUN pipe-0093 277 14 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 277 15 power power NOUN pipe-0093 277 16 struggles struggle NOUN pipe-0093 277 17 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 277 18 teacher teacher NOUN pipe-0093 277 19 / / SYM pipe-0093 277 20 student student NOUN pipe-0093 277 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 277 22 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 277 23 / / SYM pipe-0093 277 24 administrator administrator NOUN pipe-0093 277 25 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 277 26 proprietary proprietary ADJ pipe-0093 277 27 / / SYM pipe-0093 277 28 open open ADJ pipe-0093 277 29 access access NOUN pipe-0093 277 30 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 277 31 banking bank VERB pipe-0093 277 32 education education NOUN pipe-0093 277 33 / / SYM pipe-0093 277 34 open open ADJ pipe-0093 277 35 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 277 36 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 278 1 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 278 2 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 278 3 opens open VERB pipe-0093 278 4 the the DET pipe-0093 278 5 door door NOUN pipe-0093 278 6 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 279 1 acknowledgements acknowledgement NOUN pipe-0093 279 2 i i PRON pipe-0093 279 3 would would AUX pipe-0093 279 4 like like VERB pipe-0093 279 5 to to PART pipe-0093 279 6 thank thank VERB pipe-0093 279 7 peer peer NOUN pipe-0093 279 8 reviewers reviewer NOUN pipe-0093 279 9 ryan ryan PROPN pipe-0093 279 10 randall randall PROPN pipe-0093 279 11 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 279 12 nicole nicole PROPN pipe-0093 279 13 williams williams PROPN pipe-0093 279 14 for for ADP pipe-0093 279 15 their their PRON pipe-0093 279 16 insightful insightful ADJ pipe-0093 279 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 279 18 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 279 19 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 279 20 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 279 21 encouraging encourage VERB pipe-0093 279 22 comments comment NOUN pipe-0093 279 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 280 1 thank thank VERB pipe-0093 280 2 you you PRON pipe-0093 280 3 to to ADP pipe-0093 280 4 ian ian PROPN pipe-0093 280 5 beilin beilin PROPN pipe-0093 280 6 for for ADP pipe-0093 280 7 serving serve VERB pipe-0093 280 8 as as ADP pipe-0093 280 9 publishing publish VERB pipe-0093 280 10 editor editor NOUN pipe-0093 280 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 281 1 a a DET pipe-0093 281 2 very very ADV pipe-0093 281 3 special special ADJ pipe-0093 281 4 thank thank VERB pipe-0093 281 5 you you PRON pipe-0093 281 6 to to ADP pipe-0093 281 7 professor professor PROPN pipe-0093 281 8 maria maria PROPN pipe-0093 281 9 jerskey jerskey PROPN pipe-0093 281 10 at at ADP pipe-0093 281 11 laguardia laguardia PROPN pipe-0093 281 12 community community NOUN pipe-0093 281 13 college college NOUN pipe-0093 281 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 281 15 who who PRON pipe-0093 281 16 runs run VERB pipe-0093 281 17 the the DET pipe-0093 281 18 literacy literacy NOUN pipe-0093 281 19 brokers broker NOUN pipe-0093 281 20 writing write VERB pipe-0093 281 21 group group NOUN pipe-0093 281 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 282 1 i i PRON pipe-0093 282 2 never never ADV pipe-0093 282 3 would would AUX pipe-0093 282 4 have have AUX pipe-0093 282 5 finished finish VERB pipe-0093 282 6 this this DET pipe-0093 282 7 article article NOUN pipe-0093 282 8 without without ADP pipe-0093 282 9 her her PRON pipe-0093 282 10 guidance guidance NOUN pipe-0093 282 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 282 12 along along ADP pipe-0093 282 13 with with ADP pipe-0093 282 14 other other ADJ pipe-0093 282 15 laguardia laguardia NOUN pipe-0093 282 16 colleagues colleague NOUN pipe-0093 282 17 who who PRON pipe-0093 282 18 participate participate VERB pipe-0093 282 19 in in ADP pipe-0093 282 20 the the DET pipe-0093 282 21 writing writing NOUN pipe-0093 282 22 group group NOUN pipe-0093 282 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 283 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 283 2 particular particular ADJ pipe-0093 283 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 283 4 many many ADJ pipe-0093 283 5 thanks thank NOUN pipe-0093 283 6 to to ADP pipe-0093 283 7 professors professor NOUN pipe-0093 283 8 dominique dominique NOUN pipe-0093 283 9 zino zino PROPN pipe-0093 283 10 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 283 11 derek derek NOUN pipe-0093 283 12 stadler stadl ADJ pipe-0093 283 13 for for ADP pipe-0093 283 14 their their PRON pipe-0093 283 15 invaluable invaluable ADJ pipe-0093 283 16 feedback feedback NOUN pipe-0093 283 17 on on ADP pipe-0093 283 18 multiple multiple ADJ pipe-0093 283 19 drafts draft NOUN pipe-0093 283 20 of of ADP pipe-0093 283 21 this this DET pipe-0093 283 22 article article NOUN pipe-0093 283 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 284 1 references reference NOUN pipe-0093 284 2 abri abri PROPN pipe-0093 284 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 284 4 m.a m.a PROPN pipe-0093 284 5 . . PROPN pipe-0093 284 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 284 7 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 284 8 dabbagh dabbagh PROPN pipe-0093 284 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 284 10 n. n. PROPN pipe-0093 284 11 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 284 12 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 284 13 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 284 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 285 1 open open VERB pipe-0093 285 2 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 285 3 resources resource NOUN pipe-0093 285 4 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 285 5 a a DET pipe-0093 285 6 literature literature NOUN pipe-0093 285 7 review review NOUN pipe-0093 285 8 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 286 1 journal journal PROPN pipe-0093 286 2 of of ADP pipe-0093 286 3 mason mason PROPN pipe-0093 286 4 graduate graduate PROPN pipe-0093 286 5 research research PROPN pipe-0093 286 6 6(1 6(1 NUM pipe-0093 286 7 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 286 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 286 9 83 83 NUM pipe-0093 286 10 - - SYM pipe-0093 286 11 104 104 NUM pipe-0093 286 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 287 1 doi doi NOUN pipe-0093 287 2 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 287 3 https://doi.org/10.13021/g8jmgr.v6i1.2386 https://doi.org/10.13021/g8jmgr.v6i1.2386 X pipe-0093 287 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 288 1 accardi accardi PROPN pipe-0093 288 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 288 3 m. m. PROPN pipe-0093 288 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 288 5 drabinski drabinski PROPN pipe-0093 288 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 288 7 e. e. PROPN pipe-0093 288 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 288 9 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 288 10 kumbier kumbier PROPN pipe-0093 288 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 288 12 a a DET pipe-0093 288 13 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 288 14 eds ed NOUN pipe-0093 288 15 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 288 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 289 1 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 289 2 2010 2010 NUM pipe-0093 289 3 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 289 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 290 1 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 290 2 library library NOUN pipe-0093 290 3 instruction instruction NOUN pipe-0093 290 4 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 290 5 theories theory NOUN pipe-0093 290 6 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 290 7 methods method NOUN pipe-0093 290 8 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 291 1 duluth duluth PROPN pipe-0093 291 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 291 3 mn mn PROPN pipe-0093 291 4 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 291 5 library library PROPN pipe-0093 291 6 juice juice PROPN pipe-0093 291 7 press press PROPN pipe-0093 291 8 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 292 1 allen allen PROPN pipe-0093 292 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 292 3 g. g. PROPN pipe-0093 292 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 292 5 guzman guzman PROPN pipe-0093 292 6 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 292 7 alvarez alvarez PROPN pipe-0093 292 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 292 9 a. a. NOUN pipe-0093 292 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 292 11 molinaro molinaro NOUN pipe-0093 292 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 292 13 m. m. PROPN pipe-0093 292 14 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 292 15 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 292 16 larsen larsen PROPN pipe-0093 292 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 292 18 d. d. PROPN pipe-0093 292 19 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 292 20 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 292 21 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 292 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 293 1 assessing assess VERB pipe-0093 293 2 the the DET pipe-0093 293 3 impact impact NOUN pipe-0093 293 4 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 293 5 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 293 6 of of ADP pipe-0093 293 7 the the DET pipe-0093 293 8 open open ADJ pipe-0093 293 9 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 293 10 access access NOUN pipe-0093 293 11 chemwiki chemwiki ADJ pipe-0093 293 12 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 293 13 project project NOUN pipe-0093 293 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 294 1 educause educause NOUN pipe-0093 294 2 learning learning PROPN pipe-0093 294 3 initiative initiative NOUN pipe-0093 294 4 brief brief NOUN pipe-0093 294 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 295 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 295 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 295 3 https://library.educause.edu/resources/2015/1/assessing-the-impact-and-efficacy-of-the-openaccess-chemwiki-textbook-project https://library.educause.edu/resources/2015/1/assessing-the-impact-and-efficacy-of-the-openaccess-chemwiki-textbook-project PROPN pipe-0093 295 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 296 1 american american PROPN pipe-0093 296 2 association association PROPN pipe-0093 296 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 296 4 university university NOUN pipe-0093 296 5 professors professor NOUN pipe-0093 296 6 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 297 1 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 297 2 n.d n.d PROPN pipe-0093 297 3 . . PROPN pipe-0093 297 4 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 297 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 298 1 background background NOUN pipe-0093 298 2 facts fact NOUN pipe-0093 298 3 on on ADP pipe-0093 298 4 contingent contingent ADJ pipe-0093 298 5 faculty faculty NOUN pipe-0093 298 6 positions position NOUN pipe-0093 298 7 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 299 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 299 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 299 3 https://www.aaup.org/issues/contingency/background-facts https://www.aaup.org/issues/contingency/background-fact NOUN pipe-0093 299 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 300 1 bowen bowen PROPN pipe-0093 300 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 300 3 w. w. PROPN pipe-0093 300 4 g. g. PROPN pipe-0093 300 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 300 6 chingos chingos PROPN pipe-0093 300 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 300 8 m. m. PROPN pipe-0093 300 9 m. m. PROPN pipe-0093 300 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 300 11 lack lack NOUN pipe-0093 300 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 300 13 k. k. PROPN pipe-0093 300 14 a. a. NOUN pipe-0093 300 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 300 16 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 300 17 nygren nygren PROPN pipe-0093 300 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 300 19 t. t. PROPN pipe-0093 300 20 i. i. PROPN pipe-0093 300 21 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 300 22 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 300 23 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 300 24 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 301 1 interactive interactive ADJ pipe-0093 301 2 learning learning NOUN pipe-0093 301 3 online online ADV pipe-0093 301 4 at at ADP pipe-0093 301 5 public public ADJ pipe-0093 301 6 universities university NOUN pipe-0093 301 7 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 301 8 evidence evidence NOUN pipe-0093 301 9 from from ADP pipe-0093 301 10 randomized randomized ADJ pipe-0093 301 11 trials trial NOUN pipe-0093 301 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 302 1 ithaka ithaka PROPN pipe-0093 302 2 s+r s+r PROPN pipe-0093 302 3 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 303 1 https://doi.org/10.18665/sr.22464 https://doi.org/10.18665/sr.22464 PROPN pipe-0093 303 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 304 1 brownstein brownstein PROPN pipe-0093 304 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 304 3 r. r. PROPN pipe-0093 304 4 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 304 5 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 304 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 304 7 may may AUX pipe-0093 304 8 3 3 NUM pipe-0093 304 9 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 304 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 305 1 american american PROPN pipe-0093 305 2 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 305 3 education education NOUN pipe-0093 305 4 hits hit VERB pipe-0093 305 5 a a DET pipe-0093 305 6 dangerous dangerous ADJ pipe-0093 305 7 milestone milestone NOUN pipe-0093 305 8 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 306 1 the the DET pipe-0093 306 2 atlantic atlantic PROPN pipe-0093 306 3 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 307 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 307 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 307 3 https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/05/american-higher-education-hits-a-dangerous-milestone/559457/. https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/05/american-higher-education-hits-a-dangerous-milestone/559457/. PROPN pipe-0093 307 4 bureau bureau NOUN pipe-0093 307 5 of of ADP pipe-0093 307 6 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 307 7 statistics statistic NOUN pipe-0093 307 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 307 9 u.s u.s PROPN pipe-0093 307 10 . . PROPN pipe-0093 307 11 department department NOUN pipe-0093 307 12 of of ADP pipe-0093 307 13 labor labor NOUN pipe-0093 307 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 308 1 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 308 2 2016 2016 NUM pipe-0093 308 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 308 4 august august PROPN pipe-0093 308 5 30 30 NUM pipe-0093 308 6 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 308 7 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 309 1 college college NOUN pipe-0093 309 2 tuition tuition NOUN pipe-0093 309 3 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 309 4 fees fee NOUN pipe-0093 309 5 increase increase VERB pipe-0093 309 6 63 63 NUM pipe-0093 309 7 percent percent NOUN pipe-0093 309 8 since since SCONJ pipe-0093 309 9 january january PROPN pipe-0093 309 10 2006 2006 NUM pipe-0093 309 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 310 1 ted ted PROPN pipe-0093 310 2 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 310 3 the the DET pipe-0093 310 4 economics economic NOUN pipe-0093 310 5 daily daily ADV pipe-0093 310 6 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 311 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 311 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 311 3 https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2016/college-tuition-and-fees-increase-63-percent-since-january-2006.htm https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2016/college-tuition-and-fees-increase-63-percent-since-january-2006.htm PROPN pipe-0093 311 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 312 1 colvard colvard PROPN pipe-0093 312 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 312 3 n. n. PROPN pipe-0093 312 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 312 5 watson watson PROPN pipe-0093 312 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 312 7 e. e. PROPN pipe-0093 312 8 c. c. PROPN pipe-0093 312 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 312 10 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 312 11 hyojin hyojin PROPN pipe-0093 312 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 312 13 p. p. NOUN pipe-0093 312 14 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 312 15 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 312 16 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 312 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 313 1 the the DET pipe-0093 313 2 impact impact NOUN pipe-0093 313 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 313 4 open open ADJ pipe-0093 313 5 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 313 6 resources resource NOUN pipe-0093 313 7 on on ADP pipe-0093 313 8 various various ADJ pipe-0093 313 9 student student NOUN pipe-0093 313 10 success success NOUN pipe-0093 313 11 metrics metric NOUN pipe-0093 313 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 314 1 international international ADJ pipe-0093 314 2 journal journal NOUN pipe-0093 314 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 314 4 teaching teaching NOUN pipe-0093 314 5 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 314 6 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 314 7 in in ADP pipe-0093 314 8 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 314 9 education education NOUN pipe-0093 314 10 30(2 30(2 NUM pipe-0093 314 11 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 314 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 314 13 262 262 NUM pipe-0093 314 14 - - SYM pipe-0093 314 15 276 276 NUM pipe-0093 314 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 315 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 315 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 315 3 http://www.isetl.org/ijtlhe/pdf/ijtlhe3386.pdf http://www.isetl.org/ijtlhe/pdf/ijtlhe3386.pdf PROPN pipe-0093 315 4 . . PROPN pipe-0093 315 5 crissinger crissinger PROPN pipe-0093 315 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 315 7 s. s. PROPN pipe-0093 315 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 315 9 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 315 10 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 315 11 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 315 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 316 1 a a DET pipe-0093 316 2 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 316 3 take take NOUN pipe-0093 316 4 on on ADP pipe-0093 316 5 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 316 6 practices practice NOUN pipe-0093 316 7 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 316 8 interrogating interrogate VERB pipe-0093 316 9 commercialization commercialization NOUN pipe-0093 316 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 316 11 colonialism colonialism NOUN pipe-0093 316 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 316 13 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 316 14 content content NOUN pipe-0093 316 15 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 317 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 317 2 the the DET pipe-0093 317 3 library library NOUN pipe-0093 317 4 with with ADP pipe-0093 317 5 a a DET pipe-0093 317 6 lead lead ADJ pipe-0093 317 7 pipe pipe NOUN pipe-0093 317 8 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 318 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 318 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 318 3 https://www.inthelibrarywiththeleadpipe.org/2015/a-critical-take-on-oer-practices-interrogating-commercialization-colonialism-and-content/. https://www.inthelibrarywiththeleadpipe.org/2015/a-critical-take-on-oer-practices-interrogating-commercialization-colonialism-and-content/. NOUN pipe-0093 318 4 downes downe NOUN pipe-0093 318 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 318 6 j. j. PROPN pipe-0093 318 7 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 318 8 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 318 9 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 318 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 319 1 if if SCONJ pipe-0093 319 2 we we PRON pipe-0093 319 3 talked talk VERB pipe-0093 319 4 about about ADP pipe-0093 319 5 the the DET pipe-0093 319 6 internet internet NOUN pipe-0093 319 7 like like SCONJ pipe-0093 319 8 we we PRON pipe-0093 319 9 talk talk VERB pipe-0093 319 10 about about ADP pipe-0093 319 11 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 319 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 320 1 half half DET pipe-0093 320 2 an an DET pipe-0093 320 3 hour hour NOUN pipe-0093 320 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 321 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 321 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 321 3 https://halfanhour.blogspot.com/2017/11/if-we-talked-about-internet-like-we.html https://halfanhour.blogspot.com/2017/11/if-we-talked-about-internet-like-we.html NOUN pipe-0093 321 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 322 1 farrow farrow PROPN pipe-0093 322 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 322 3 r. r. PROPN pipe-0093 322 4 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 322 5 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 322 6 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 322 7 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 323 1 open open ADJ pipe-0093 323 2 education education NOUN pipe-0093 323 3 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 323 4 critical critical ADJ pipe-0093 323 5 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN pipe-0093 323 6 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 324 1 learning learning NOUN pipe-0093 324 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 324 3 media medium NOUN pipe-0093 324 4 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 324 5 technology technology NOUN pipe-0093 324 6 42 42 NUM pipe-0093 324 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 324 8 130 130 NUM pipe-0093 324 9 - - SYM pipe-0093 324 10 146 146 NUM pipe-0093 324 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 325 1 http://oro.open.ac.uk/id/eprint/46662 http://oro.open.ac.uk/id/eprint/46662 NOUN pipe-0093 325 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 326 1 feldstein feldstein PROPN pipe-0093 326 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 326 3 a. a. PROPN pipe-0093 326 4 martin martin PROPN pipe-0093 326 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 326 6 m. m. PROPN pipe-0093 326 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 326 8 hudson hudson PROPN pipe-0093 326 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 326 10 a. a. NOUN pipe-0093 326 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 326 12 warren warren PROPN pipe-0093 326 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 326 14 k. k. PROPN pipe-0093 326 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 326 16 hilton hilton PROPN pipe-0093 326 17 iii iii PROPN pipe-0093 326 18 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 326 19 j. j. PROPN pipe-0093 326 20 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 326 21 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 326 22 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 326 23 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 326 24 d. d. PROPN pipe-0093 326 25 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 326 26 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 326 27 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 326 28 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 327 1 open open ADJ pipe-0093 327 2 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 327 3 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 327 4 increased increase VERB pipe-0093 327 5 student student NOUN pipe-0093 327 6 access access NOUN pipe-0093 327 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 327 8 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 327 9 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 328 1 european european PROPN pipe-0093 328 2 journal journal PROPN pipe-0093 328 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 328 4 open open PROPN pipe-0093 328 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 328 6 distance distance NOUN pipe-0093 328 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 328 8 e e NOUN pipe-0093 328 9 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 328 10 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 328 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 328 12 2 2 NUM pipe-0093 328 13 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 329 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 329 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 329 3 https://www.eurodl.org/. https://www.eurodl.org/. PROPN pipe-0093 329 4 fischer fischer PROPN pipe-0093 329 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 329 6 l. l. PROPN pipe-0093 329 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 329 8 hilton hilton PROPN pipe-0093 329 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 329 10 j. j. PROPN pipe-0093 329 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 329 12 robinson robinson PROPN pipe-0093 329 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 329 14 t.j t.j PROPN pipe-0093 329 15 . . PROPN pipe-0093 329 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 329 17 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 329 18 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 329 19 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 329 20 d. d. PROPN pipe-0093 329 21 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 329 22 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 329 23 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 329 24 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 330 1 a a DET pipe-0093 330 2 multi multi ADJ pipe-0093 330 3 - - ADJ pipe-0093 330 4 institutional institutional ADJ pipe-0093 330 5 study study NOUN pipe-0093 330 6 of of ADP pipe-0093 330 7 the the DET pipe-0093 330 8 impact impact NOUN pipe-0093 330 9 of of ADP pipe-0093 330 10 open open ADJ pipe-0093 330 11 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 330 12 adoption adoption NOUN pipe-0093 330 13 on on ADP pipe-0093 330 14 the the DET pipe-0093 330 15 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 330 16 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 330 17 of of ADP pipe-0093 330 18 post post ADJ pipe-0093 330 19 - - ADJ pipe-0093 330 20 secondary secondary ADJ pipe-0093 330 21 students student NOUN pipe-0093 330 22 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 331 1 journal journal PROPN pipe-0093 331 2 of of ADP pipe-0093 331 3 computing compute VERB pipe-0093 331 4 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 331 5 education education NOUN pipe-0093 331 6 27(3 27(3 NUM pipe-0093 331 7 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 331 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 331 9 159 159 NUM pipe-0093 331 10 - - SYM pipe-0093 331 11 172 172 NUM pipe-0093 331 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 332 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/s12528-015-9101-x https://doi.org/10.1007/s12528-015-9101-x PROPN pipe-0093 332 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 333 1 florida florida PROPN pipe-0093 333 2 virtual virtual ADJ pipe-0093 333 3 campus campus PROPN pipe-0093 333 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 334 1 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 334 2 2019 2019 NUM pipe-0093 334 3 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 334 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 335 1 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 335 2 florida florida PROPN pipe-0093 335 3 student student NOUN pipe-0093 335 4 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 335 5 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 335 6 course course NOUN pipe-0093 335 7 material material NOUN pipe-0093 335 8 survey survey NOUN pipe-0093 335 9 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 335 10 results result NOUN pipe-0093 335 11 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 335 12 findings finding NOUN pipe-0093 335 13 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 336 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 336 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 336 3 https://dlss.flvc.org/colleges-and-universities/research/textbooks https://dlss.flvc.org/colleges-and-universities/research/textbook NOUN pipe-0093 336 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 337 1 goodwin goodwin NOUN pipe-0093 337 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 337 3 m. m. PROPN pipe-0093 337 4 a. a. PROPN pipe-0093 337 5 l. l. PROPN pipe-0093 337 6 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 337 7 2011 2011 NUM pipe-0093 337 8 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 337 9 the the DET pipe-0093 337 10 open open ADJ pipe-0093 337 11 course course NOUN pipe-0093 337 12 library library NOUN pipe-0093 337 13 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 337 14 using use VERB pipe-0093 337 15 open open ADJ pipe-0093 337 16 education education NOUN pipe-0093 337 17 resources resource NOUN pipe-0093 337 18 to to PART pipe-0093 337 19 improve improve VERB pipe-0093 337 20 community community NOUN pipe-0093 337 21 college college NOUN pipe-0093 337 22 access access NOUN pipe-0093 337 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 338 1 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 338 2 unpublished unpublished ADJ pipe-0093 338 3 doctoral doctoral ADJ pipe-0093 338 4 dissertation dissertation NOUN pipe-0093 338 5 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 338 6 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 339 1 pullman pullman NOUN pipe-0093 339 2 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 339 3 washington washington PROPN pipe-0093 339 4 state state PROPN pipe-0093 339 5 university university PROPN pipe-0093 339 6 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 339 7 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 339 8 from from ADP pipe-0093 339 9 http://hdl.handle.ne/2376/3497 http://hdl.handle.ne/2376/3497 PROPN pipe-0093 339 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 340 1 hendricks hendrick NOUN pipe-0093 340 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 340 3 c. c. PROPN pipe-0093 340 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 340 5 reinsberg reinsberg PROPN pipe-0093 340 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 340 7 s. s. PROPN pipe-0093 340 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 340 9 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 340 10 rieger rieger PROPN pipe-0093 340 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 340 12 g. g. PROPN pipe-0093 340 13 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 340 14 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 340 15 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 340 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 341 1 the the DET pipe-0093 341 2 adoption adoption NOUN pipe-0093 341 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 341 4 an an DET pipe-0093 341 5 open open ADJ pipe-0093 341 6 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 341 7 in in ADP pipe-0093 341 8 a a DET pipe-0093 341 9 large large ADJ pipe-0093 341 10 physics physics NOUN pipe-0093 341 11 course course NOUN pipe-0093 341 12 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 341 13 an an DET pipe-0093 341 14 analysis analysis NOUN pipe-0093 341 15 of of ADP pipe-0093 341 16 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 341 17 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 341 18 outcomes outcome NOUN pipe-0093 341 19 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 341 20 use use NOUN pipe-0093 341 21 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 341 22 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 341 23 perceptions perception NOUN pipe-0093 341 24 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 342 1 the the DET pipe-0093 342 2 international international ADJ pipe-0093 342 3 review review NOUN pipe-0093 342 4 of of ADP pipe-0093 342 5 research research NOUN pipe-0093 342 6 in in ADP pipe-0093 342 7 open open ADJ pipe-0093 342 8 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 342 9 distributed distribute VERB pipe-0093 342 10 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 342 11 18(4 18(4 NUM pipe-0093 342 12 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 342 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 342 14 78 78 NUM pipe-0093 342 15 - - SYM pipe-0093 342 16 99 99 NUM pipe-0093 342 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 343 1 http://dx.doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v18i4.3006 http://dx.doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v18i4.3006 NOUN pipe-0093 343 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 344 1 hilton hilton PROPN pipe-0093 344 2 iii iii PROPN pipe-0093 344 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 344 4 j. j. PROPN pipe-0093 344 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 344 6 fischer fischer PROPN pipe-0093 344 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 344 8 l. l. PROPN pipe-0093 344 9 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 344 10 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 344 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 344 12 d. d. PROPN pipe-0093 344 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 344 14 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 344 15 william william PROPN pipe-0093 344 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 344 17 l. l. PROPN pipe-0093 344 18 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 344 19 2016 2016 NUM pipe-0093 344 20 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 344 21 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 345 1 maintaining maintain VERB pipe-0093 345 2 momentum momentum NOUN pipe-0093 345 3 toward toward ADP pipe-0093 345 4 graduation graduation NOUN pipe-0093 345 5 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 345 6 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 345 7 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 345 8 the the DET pipe-0093 345 9 course course NOUN pipe-0093 345 10 throughput throughput NOUN pipe-0093 345 11 rate rate NOUN pipe-0093 345 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 346 1 the the DET pipe-0093 346 2 international international ADJ pipe-0093 346 3 review review NOUN pipe-0093 346 4 of of ADP pipe-0093 346 5 research research NOUN pipe-0093 346 6 in in ADP pipe-0093 346 7 open open ADJ pipe-0093 346 8 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 346 9 distributed distribute VERB pipe-0093 346 10 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 346 11 17(6 17(6 NUM pipe-0093 346 12 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 346 13 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 346 14 18 18 NUM pipe-0093 346 15 - - SYM pipe-0093 346 16 27 27 NUM pipe-0093 346 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 347 1 http://dx.doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v17i6.2686 http://dx.doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v17i6.2686 PROPN pipe-0093 347 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 348 1 hilton hilton PROPN pipe-0093 348 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 348 3 j. j. PROPN pipe-0093 348 4 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 348 5 2019 2019 NUM pipe-0093 348 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 348 7 august august PROPN pipe-0093 348 8 6 6 NUM pipe-0093 348 9 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 348 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 349 1 open open VERB pipe-0093 349 2 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 349 3 resources resource NOUN pipe-0093 349 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 349 5 student student NOUN pipe-0093 349 6 efficacy efficacy NOUN pipe-0093 349 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 349 8 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 349 9 user user NOUN pipe-0093 349 10 perceptions perception NOUN pipe-0093 349 11 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 349 12 a a DET pipe-0093 349 13 synthesis synthesis NOUN pipe-0093 349 14 of of ADP pipe-0093 349 15 research research NOUN pipe-0093 349 16 published publish VERB pipe-0093 349 17 between between ADP pipe-0093 349 18 2015 2015 NUM pipe-0093 349 19 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 349 20 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 349 21 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 350 1 educational educational ADJ pipe-0093 350 2 technology technology NOUN pipe-0093 350 3 research research NOUN pipe-0093 350 4 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 350 5 development development NOUN pipe-0093 350 6 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 351 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/s11423-019-09700-4 https://doi.org/10.1007/s11423-019-09700-4 NUM pipe-0093 351 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 352 1 johnson johnson PROPN pipe-0093 352 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 352 3 d. d. PROPN pipe-0093 352 4 m. m. PROPN pipe-0093 352 5 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 352 6 2019 2019 NUM pipe-0093 352 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 352 8 september september PROPN pipe-0093 352 9 23 23 NUM pipe-0093 352 10 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 352 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 353 1 what what PRON pipe-0093 353 2 will will AUX pipe-0093 353 3 it it PRON pipe-0093 353 4 take take VERB pipe-0093 353 5 to to PART pipe-0093 353 6 solve solve VERB pipe-0093 353 7 the the DET pipe-0093 353 8 student student NOUN pipe-0093 353 9 debt debt NOUN pipe-0093 353 10 crisis crisis NOUN pipe-0093 353 11 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 354 1 harvard harvard PROPN pipe-0093 354 2 business business PROPN pipe-0093 354 3 review review PROPN pipe-0093 354 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 355 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 355 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 355 3 https://hbr.org/. https://hbr.org/. PROPN pipe-0093 355 4 lambert lambert PROPN pipe-0093 355 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 355 6 s. s. PROPN pipe-0093 355 7 r. r. PROPN pipe-0093 355 8 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 355 9 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 355 10 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 355 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 356 1 changing change VERB pipe-0093 356 2 our our PRON pipe-0093 356 3 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 356 4 dis)course dis)course NOUN pipe-0093 356 5 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 356 6 a a DET pipe-0093 356 7 distinctive distinctive ADJ pipe-0093 356 8 social social ADJ pipe-0093 356 9 justice justice NOUN pipe-0093 356 10 aligned align VERB pipe-0093 356 11 definition definition NOUN pipe-0093 356 12 of of ADP pipe-0093 356 13 open open ADJ pipe-0093 356 14 education education NOUN pipe-0093 356 15 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 357 1 journal journal NOUN pipe-0093 357 2 of of ADP pipe-0093 357 3 learning learn VERB pipe-0093 357 4 for for ADP pipe-0093 357 5 development development NOUN pipe-0093 357 6 5(3 5(3 NUM pipe-0093 357 7 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 357 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 357 9 225 225 NUM pipe-0093 357 10 - - SYM pipe-0093 357 11 244 244 NUM pipe-0093 357 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 357 13 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 357 14 from from ADP pipe-0093 357 15 https://jl4d.org/index.php/ejl4d/article/view/290/334 https://jl4d.org/index.php/ejl4d/article/view/290/334 NOUN pipe-0093 357 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 358 1 paulsen paulsen PROPN pipe-0093 358 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 358 3 m. m. PROPN pipe-0093 358 4 b. b. PROPN pipe-0093 358 5 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 358 6 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 358 7 st st PROPN pipe-0093 358 8 . . PROPN pipe-0093 358 9 john john PROPN pipe-0093 358 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 358 11 e. e. PROPN pipe-0093 358 12 p. p. PROPN pipe-0093 358 13 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 358 14 2002 2002 NUM pipe-0093 358 15 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 358 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 359 1 social social ADJ pipe-0093 359 2 class class NOUN pipe-0093 359 3 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 359 4 college college NOUN pipe-0093 359 5 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 359 6 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 359 7 examining examine VERB pipe-0093 359 8 the the DET pipe-0093 359 9 financial financial ADJ pipe-0093 359 10 nexus nexus NOUN pipe-0093 359 11 between between ADP pipe-0093 359 12 college college NOUN pipe-0093 359 13 choice choice NOUN pipe-0093 359 14 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 359 15 persistence persistence NOUN pipe-0093 359 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 360 1 the the DET pipe-0093 360 2 journal journal NOUN pipe-0093 360 3 of of ADP pipe-0093 360 4 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 360 5 education education NOUN pipe-0093 360 6 73(2 73(2 NUM pipe-0093 360 7 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 360 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 360 9 189–236 189–236 NUM pipe-0093 360 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 361 1 https://doi.org/10.1080/00221546.2002.11777141 https://doi.org/10.1080/00221546.2002.11777141 PROPN pipe-0093 361 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 362 1 pawlyshyn pawlyshyn PROPN pipe-0093 362 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 362 3 n. n. PROPN pipe-0093 362 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 362 5 braddlee braddlee PROPN pipe-0093 362 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 362 7 d. d. PROPN pipe-0093 362 8 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 362 9 casper casper PROPN pipe-0093 362 10 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 362 11 l. l. PROPN pipe-0093 362 12 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 362 13 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 362 14 miller miller PROPN pipe-0093 362 15 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 362 16 h. h. PROPN pipe-0093 362 17 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 362 18 2013 2013 NUM pipe-0093 362 19 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 362 20 november november PROPN pipe-0093 362 21 4 4 NUM pipe-0093 362 22 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 362 23 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 363 1 adopting adopt VERB pipe-0093 363 2 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 363 3 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 363 4 a a DET pipe-0093 363 5 case case NOUN pipe-0093 363 6 study study NOUN pipe-0093 363 7 of of ADP pipe-0093 363 8 cross cross ADJ pipe-0093 363 9 - - ADJ pipe-0093 363 10 institutional institutional ADJ pipe-0093 363 11 collaboration collaboration NOUN pipe-0093 363 12 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 363 13 innovation innovation NOUN pipe-0093 363 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 364 1 educause educause NOUN pipe-0093 364 2 review review PROPN pipe-0093 364 3 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 365 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 365 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 365 3 http://er.educause.edu/articles/2013/11/adopting-oer-a-case-study-of-crossinstitutional-collaboration-and-innovation http://er.educause.edu/articles/2013/11/adopting-oer-a-case-study-of-crossinstitutional-collaboration-and-innovation PROPN pipe-0093 365 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 366 1 sagor sagor PROPN pipe-0093 366 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 366 3 r. r. PROPN pipe-0093 366 4 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 366 5 2000 2000 NUM pipe-0093 366 6 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 366 7 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 367 1 what what PRON pipe-0093 367 2 is be AUX pipe-0093 367 3 action action NOUN pipe-0093 367 4 research research NOUN pipe-0093 367 5 ? ? PUNCT pipe-0093 368 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 368 2 r. r. PROPN pipe-0093 368 3 sagor sagor PROPN pipe-0093 368 4 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 368 5 author author NOUN pipe-0093 368 6 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 368 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 368 8 guiding guide VERB pipe-0093 368 9 school school NOUN pipe-0093 368 10 improvement improvement NOUN pipe-0093 368 11 with with ADP pipe-0093 368 12 action action NOUN pipe-0093 368 13 research research NOUN pipe-0093 368 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 369 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 369 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 369 3 http://www.ascd.org/publications/books/100047/chapters/what-is-action-research%c2%a2.aspx http://www.ascd.org/publications/books/100047/chapters/what-is-action-research%c2%a2.aspx PROPN pipe-0093 369 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 370 1 senack senack PROPN pipe-0093 370 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 370 3 e. e. PROPN pipe-0093 370 4 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 370 5 2014 2014 NUM pipe-0093 370 6 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 370 7 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 371 1 fixing fix VERB pipe-0093 371 2 the the DET pipe-0093 371 3 broken broken ADJ pipe-0093 371 4 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 371 5 market market NOUN pipe-0093 371 6 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 371 7 how how SCONJ pipe-0093 371 8 students student NOUN pipe-0093 371 9 respond respond VERB pipe-0093 371 10 to to ADP pipe-0093 371 11 high high ADJ pipe-0093 371 12 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 371 13 costs cost NOUN pipe-0093 371 14 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 371 15 demand demand NOUN pipe-0093 371 16 alternatives alternative NOUN pipe-0093 371 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 372 1 the the DET pipe-0093 372 2 student student NOUN pipe-0093 372 3 public public ADJ pipe-0093 372 4 interest interest NOUN pipe-0093 372 5 research research NOUN pipe-0093 372 6 groups group NOUN pipe-0093 372 7 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 373 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 373 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 373 3 https://uspirg.org/reports/usp/fixing-broken-textbook-market https://uspirg.org/reports/usp/fixing-broken-textbook-market PROPN pipe-0093 373 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 374 1 senack senack PROPN pipe-0093 374 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 374 3 e. e. PROPN pipe-0093 374 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 374 5 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 374 6 donoghue donoghue PROPN pipe-0093 374 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 374 8 r. r. PROPN pipe-0093 374 9 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 374 10 2016 2016 NUM pipe-0093 374 11 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 374 12 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 375 1 covering cover VERB pipe-0093 375 2 the the DET pipe-0093 375 3 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 375 4 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 375 5 why why SCONJ pipe-0093 375 6 we we PRON pipe-0093 375 7 can can AUX pipe-0093 375 8 no no ADV pipe-0093 375 9 longer long ADV pipe-0093 375 10 afford afford VERB pipe-0093 375 11 to to PART pipe-0093 375 12 ignore ignore VERB pipe-0093 375 13 high high ADJ pipe-0093 375 14 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 375 15 prices price NOUN pipe-0093 375 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 376 1 the the DET pipe-0093 376 2 student student NOUN pipe-0093 376 3 public public ADJ pipe-0093 376 4 interest interest NOUN pipe-0093 376 5 research research NOUN pipe-0093 376 6 groups group NOUN pipe-0093 376 7 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 377 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 377 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 377 3 https://studentpirgs.org/2016/02/03/covering-cost/. https://studentpirgs.org/2016/02/03/covering-cost/. NOUN pipe-0093 377 4 state state NOUN pipe-0093 377 5 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 377 6 education education NOUN pipe-0093 377 7 executive executive NOUN pipe-0093 377 8 officers officer NOUN pipe-0093 377 9 association association PROPN pipe-0093 377 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 378 1 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 378 2 2018 2018 NUM pipe-0093 378 3 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 378 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 379 1 state state NOUN pipe-0093 379 2 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 379 3 education education NOUN pipe-0093 379 4 finance finance NOUN pipe-0093 379 5 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 379 6 shef shef NOUN pipe-0093 379 7 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 379 8 fiscal fiscal ADJ pipe-0093 379 9 year year NOUN pipe-0093 379 10 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 379 11 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 380 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 380 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 380 3 https://sheeomain.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/sheeo_shef_fy2017_final-1.pdf https://sheeomain.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/sheeo_shef_fy2017_final-1.pdf PROPN pipe-0093 380 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 381 1 unesco unesco PROPN pipe-0093 381 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 382 1 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 382 2 2002 2002 NUM pipe-0093 382 3 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 382 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 383 1 forum forum NOUN pipe-0093 383 2 on on ADP pipe-0093 383 3 the the DET pipe-0093 383 4 impact impact NOUN pipe-0093 383 5 of of ADP pipe-0093 383 6 open open ADJ pipe-0093 383 7 courseware courseware NOUN pipe-0093 383 8 for for ADP pipe-0093 383 9 higher high ADJ pipe-0093 383 10 education education NOUN pipe-0093 383 11 in in ADP pipe-0093 383 12 developing develop VERB pipe-0093 383 13 countries country NOUN pipe-0093 383 14 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 383 15 final final ADJ pipe-0093 383 16 report report NOUN pipe-0093 383 17 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 384 1 paris paris PROPN pipe-0093 384 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 385 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 385 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 385 3 http://www.unesco.org:80/iiep/eng/focus/opensrc/pdf/oerforumfinalreport.pdf http://www.unesco.org:80/iiep/eng/focus/opensrc/pdf/oerforumfinalreport.pdf NOUN pipe-0093 385 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 386 1 unesco unesco PROPN pipe-0093 386 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 387 1 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 387 2 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 387 3 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 387 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 388 1 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 388 2 paris paris PROPN pipe-0093 388 3 oer oer PROPN pipe-0093 388 4 declaration declaration PROPN pipe-0093 388 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 389 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 389 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 389 3 http://www.unesco.org/new/fileadmin/multimedia/hq/ci/wpfd2009/english_declaration.html http://www.unesco.org/new/fileadmin/multimedia/hq/ci/wpfd2009/english_declaration.html PROPN pipe-0093 389 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 390 1 u.s u.s PROPN pipe-0093 390 2 . . PROPN pipe-0093 390 3 government government NOUN pipe-0093 390 4 accountability accountability NOUN pipe-0093 390 5 office office NOUN pipe-0093 390 6 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 391 1 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 391 2 2013 2013 NUM pipe-0093 391 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 391 4 june june PROPN pipe-0093 391 5 6 6 NUM pipe-0093 391 6 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 391 7 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 392 1 college college NOUN pipe-0093 392 2 textbooks textbook NOUN pipe-0093 392 3 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 392 4 students student NOUN pipe-0093 392 5 have have VERB pipe-0093 392 6 greater great ADJ pipe-0093 392 7 access access NOUN pipe-0093 392 8 to to ADP pipe-0093 392 9 textbook textbook NOUN pipe-0093 392 10 information information NOUN pipe-0093 392 11 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 392 12 gao-13 gao-13 NOUN pipe-0093 392 13 - - PUNCT pipe-0093 392 14 368 368 NUM pipe-0093 392 15 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 392 16 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 393 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 393 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 393 3 https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-13-368 https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-13-368 PROPN pipe-0093 393 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 394 1 watters watter NOUN pipe-0093 394 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 394 3 a. a. NOUN pipe-0093 394 4 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 394 5 2014 2014 NUM pipe-0093 394 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 394 7 august august PROPN pipe-0093 394 8 16 16 NUM pipe-0093 394 9 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 394 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 395 1 from from ADP pipe-0093 395 2 “ " PUNCT pipe-0093 395 3 open open ADJ pipe-0093 395 4 ” " PUNCT pipe-0093 395 5 to to ADP pipe-0093 395 6 justice justice PROPN pipe-0093 395 7 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 396 1 hack hack NOUN pipe-0093 396 2 education education PROPN pipe-0093 396 3 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 397 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 397 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 397 3 http://hackeducation.com/2014/11/16/from-open-to-justice http://hackeducation.com/2014/11/16/from-open-to-justice PROPN pipe-0093 397 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 397 5 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 397 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 397 7 david david PROPN pipe-0093 397 8 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 398 1 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 398 2 2007 2007 NUM pipe-0093 398 3 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 398 4 august august PROPN pipe-0093 398 5 8) 8) PROPN pipe-0093 398 6 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 399 1 open open ADJ pipe-0093 399 2 education education NOUN pipe-0093 399 3 license license NOUN pipe-0093 399 4 draft draft NOUN pipe-0093 399 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 400 1 iterating iterate VERB pipe-0093 400 2 toward toward ADP pipe-0093 400 3 openness openness NOUN pipe-0093 400 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 401 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 401 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 401 3 https://opencontent.org/blog/archives/355 https://opencontent.org/blog/archives/355 NOUN pipe-0093 401 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 402 1 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 402 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 402 3 d. d. PROPN pipe-0093 402 4 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 402 5 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 402 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 402 7 november november PROPN pipe-0093 402 8 8) 8) NUM pipe-0093 402 9 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 403 1 if if SCONJ pipe-0093 403 2 we we PRON pipe-0093 403 3 talked talk VERB pipe-0093 403 4 about about ADP pipe-0093 403 5 the the DET pipe-0093 403 6 internet internet NOUN pipe-0093 403 7 like like SCONJ pipe-0093 403 8 we we PRON pipe-0093 403 9 talk talk VERB pipe-0093 403 10 about about ADP pipe-0093 403 11 oer oer NOUN pipe-0093 403 12 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 403 13 the the DET pipe-0093 403 14 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 403 15 trap trap NOUN pipe-0093 403 16 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 403 17 inclusive inclusive ADJ pipe-0093 403 18 access access NOUN pipe-0093 403 19 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 404 1 iterating iterate VERB pipe-0093 404 2 toward toward ADP pipe-0093 404 3 openness openness NOUN pipe-0093 404 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 405 1 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 405 2 from from ADP pipe-0093 405 3 https://opencontent.org/blog/archives/5219 https://opencontent.org/blog/archives/5219 NOUN pipe-0093 405 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 406 1 wiley wiley PROPN pipe-0093 406 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 406 3 d. d. PROPN pipe-0093 406 4 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 406 5 2017 2017 NUM pipe-0093 406 6 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 406 7 november november PROPN pipe-0093 406 8 13 13 NUM pipe-0093 406 9 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 406 10 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 407 1 more more ADV pipe-0093 407 2 on on ADP pipe-0093 407 3 the the DET pipe-0093 407 4 cost cost NOUN pipe-0093 407 5 trap trap NOUN pipe-0093 407 6 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 407 7 inclusive inclusive ADJ pipe-0093 407 8 access access NOUN pipe-0093 407 9 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 408 1 iterating iterate VERB pipe-0093 408 2 toward toward ADP pipe-0093 408 3 openness openness NOUN pipe-0093 408 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 409 1 https://opencontent.org/blog/archives/5244 https://opencontent.org/blog/archives/5244 PROPN pipe-0093 409 2 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 410 1 william william PROPN pipe-0093 410 2 and and CCONJ pipe-0093 410 3 flora flora PROPN pipe-0093 410 4 hewlett hewlett PROPN pipe-0093 410 5 foundation foundation PROPN pipe-0093 410 6 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 411 1 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 411 2 2020 2020 NUM pipe-0093 411 3 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 411 4 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 412 1 hewlett hewlett PROPN pipe-0093 412 2 foundation foundation PROPN pipe-0093 412 3 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 412 4 grants grant NOUN pipe-0093 412 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 412 6 retrieved retrieve VERB pipe-0093 412 7 from from ADP pipe-0093 412 8 https://hewlett.org/grants/?sort=date&grant_strategies=31557¤t_page=1 https://hewlett.org/grants/?sort=date&grant_strategies=31557¤t_page=1 PROPN pipe-0093 412 9 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 413 1 winn winn PROPN pipe-0093 413 2 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 413 3 j. j. PROPN pipe-0093 413 4 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 413 5 2012 2012 NUM pipe-0093 413 6 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 413 7 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 414 1 open open ADJ pipe-0093 414 2 education education NOUN pipe-0093 414 3 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 414 4 from from ADP pipe-0093 414 5 the the DET pipe-0093 414 6 freedom freedom NOUN pipe-0093 414 7 of of ADP pipe-0093 414 8 things thing NOUN pipe-0093 414 9 to to ADP pipe-0093 414 10 the the DET pipe-0093 414 11 freedom freedom NOUN pipe-0093 414 12 of of ADP pipe-0093 414 13 people people NOUN pipe-0093 414 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 415 1 in in ADP pipe-0093 415 2 m. m. PROPN pipe-0093 415 3 neary neary PROPN pipe-0093 415 4 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 415 5 h. h. PROPN pipe-0093 415 6 stevenson stevenson PROPN pipe-0093 415 7 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 415 8 & & CCONJ pipe-0093 415 9 l. l. PROPN pipe-0093 415 10 bell bell PROPN pipe-0093 415 11 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 415 12 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 415 13 eds ed NOUN pipe-0093 415 14 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 415 15 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 415 16 , , PUNCT pipe-0093 415 17 towards towards ADP pipe-0093 415 18 teaching teaching NOUN pipe-0093 415 19 in in ADP pipe-0093 415 20 public public NOUN pipe-0093 415 21 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 415 22 reshaping reshape VERB pipe-0093 415 23 the the DET pipe-0093 415 24 modern modern ADJ pipe-0093 415 25 university university NOUN pipe-0093 415 26 ( ( PUNCT pipe-0093 415 27 pp pp PROPN pipe-0093 415 28 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 416 1 133 133 NUM pipe-0093 416 2 - - SYM pipe-0093 416 3 147 147 NUM pipe-0093 416 4 ) ) PUNCT pipe-0093 416 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 417 1 london london PROPN pipe-0093 417 2 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 417 3 continuum continuum PROPN pipe-0093 417 4 international international PROPN pipe-0093 417 5 publishing publishing NOUN pipe-0093 417 6 group group NOUN pipe-0093 417 7 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 418 1 teaching teach VERB pipe-0093 418 2 with with ADP pipe-0093 418 3 care care NOUN pipe-0093 418 4 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 418 5 a a DET pipe-0093 418 6 relational relational ADJ pipe-0093 418 7 approach approach NOUN pipe-0093 418 8 to to ADP pipe-0093 418 9 individual individual ADJ pipe-0093 418 10 research research NOUN pipe-0093 418 11 consultations consultation NOUN pipe-0093 418 12 communicating communicate VERB pipe-0093 418 13 with with ADP pipe-0093 418 14 information information NOUN pipe-0093 418 15 : : PUNCT pipe-0093 418 16 creating create VERB pipe-0093 418 17 inclusive inclusive ADJ pipe-0093 418 18 learning learning NOUN pipe-0093 418 19 environments environment NOUN pipe-0093 418 20 for for ADP pipe-0093 418 21 students student NOUN pipe-0093 418 22 with with ADP pipe-0093 418 23 asd asd NOUN pipe-0093 418 24 this this DET pipe-0093 418 25 work work NOUN pipe-0093 418 26 is be AUX pipe-0093 418 27 licensed license VERB pipe-0093 418 28 under under ADP pipe-0093 418 29 a a DET pipe-0093 418 30 cc cc PROPN pipe-0093 418 31 attribution attribution NOUN pipe-0093 418 32 4.0 4.0 NUM pipe-0093 418 33 license license NOUN pipe-0093 418 34 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 419 1 issn issn ADJ pipe-0093 419 2 1944 1944 NUM pipe-0093 419 3 - - SYM pipe-0093 419 4 6195 6195 NUM pipe-0093 419 5 . . PUNCT pipe-0093 420 1 about about ADP pipe-0093 420 2 this this DET pipe-0093 420 3 journal journal NOUN pipe-0093 420 4 | | NOUN pipe-0093 420 5 archives archive VERB pipe-0093 420 6 | | NOUN pipe-0093 420 7 submissions submission NOUN pipe-0093 420 8 | | NOUN pipe-0093 420 9 conduct conduct NOUN