id sid tid token lemma pos crl-14716 1 1 college college NOUN crl-14716 1 2 and and CCONJ crl-14716 1 3 research research NOUN crl-14716 1 4 libraries librarie VERB crl-14716 1 5 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 1 6 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 1 7 : : PUNCT crl-14716 1 8 the the DET crl-14716 1 9 views view NOUN crl-14716 1 10 of of ADP crl-14716 1 11 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 1 12 , , PUNCT crl-14716 1 13 special special ADJ crl-14716 1 14 , , PUNCT crl-14716 1 15 and and CCONJ crl-14716 1 16 public public ADJ crl-14716 1 17 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 1 18 roma roma PROPN crl-14716 1 19 m. m. NOUN crl-14716 1 20 harris harris PROPN crl-14716 1 21 this this DET crl-14716 1 22 study study NOUN crl-14716 1 23 identifies identify VERB crl-14716 1 24 the the DET crl-14716 1 25 positions position NOUN crl-14716 1 26 taken take VERB crl-14716 1 27 by by ADP crl-14716 1 28 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 1 29 , , PUNCT crl-14716 1 30 special special ADJ crl-14716 1 31 , , PUNCT crl-14716 1 32 and and CCONJ crl-14716 1 33 public public ADJ crl-14716 1 34 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 1 35 with with ADP crl-14716 1 36 respect respect NOUN crl-14716 1 37 to to ADP crl-14716 1 38 the the DET crl-14716 1 39 role role NOUN crl-14716 1 40 of of ADP crl-14716 1 41 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 1 42 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 1 43 in in ADP crl-14716 1 44 the the DET crl-14716 1 45 delivery delivery NOUN crl-14716 1 46 of of ADP crl-14716 1 47 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 1 48 services service NOUN crl-14716 1 49 . . PUNCT crl-14716 2 1 using use VERB crl-14716 2 2 a a DET crl-14716 2 3 series series NOUN crl-14716 2 4 of of ADP crl-14716 2 5 statements statement NOUN crl-14716 2 6 derived derive VERB crl-14716 2 7 from from ADP crl-14716 2 8 articles article NOUN crl-14716 2 9 relevant relevant ADJ crl-14716 2 10 to to ADP crl-14716 2 11 the the DET crl-14716 2 12 information information NOUN crl-14716 2 13 - - PUNCT crl-14716 2 14 versus versus NOUN crl-14716 2 15 - - PUNCT crl-14716 2 16 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 2 17 debate debate NOUN crl-14716 2 18 , , PUNCT crl-14716 2 19 the the DET crl-14716 2 20 author author NOUN crl-14716 2 21 asked ask VERB crl-14716 2 22 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 2 23 to to PART crl-14716 2 24 indicate indicate VERB crl-14716 2 25 the the DET crl-14716 2 26 degree degree NOUN crl-14716 2 27 to to PART crl-14716 2 28 which which PRON crl-14716 2 29 they they PRON crl-14716 2 30 agreed agree VERB crl-14716 2 31 or or CCONJ crl-14716 2 32 disagreed disagree VERB crl-14716 2 33 with with ADP crl-14716 2 34 various various ADJ crl-14716 2 35 positions position NOUN crl-14716 2 36 represented represent VERB crl-14716 2 37 in in ADP crl-14716 2 38 this this DET crl-14716 2 39 debate debate NOUN crl-14716 2 40 . . PUNCT crl-14716 3 1 ti1e ti1e PROPN crl-14716 3 2 results result NOUN crl-14716 3 3 revealed reveal VERB crl-14716 3 4 that that SCONJ crl-14716 3 5 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 3 6 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 3 7 tend tend VERB crl-14716 3 8 to to PART crl-14716 3 9 favor favor VERB crl-14716 3 10 positions position NOUN crl-14716 3 11 that that PRON crl-14716 3 12 stress stress VERB crl-14716 3 13 user user NOUN crl-14716 3 14 independence independence NOUN crl-14716 3 15 , , PUNCT crl-14716 3 16 whereas whereas SCONJ crl-14716 3 17 special special ADJ crl-14716 3 18 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 3 19 view view VERB crl-14716 3 20 information information NOUN crl-14716 3 21 delivery delivery NOUN crl-14716 3 22 as as ADP crl-14716 3 23 the the DET crl-14716 3 24 key key ADJ crl-14716 3 25 function function NOUN crl-14716 3 26 of of ADP crl-14716 3 27 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 3 28 service service NOUN crl-14716 3 29 . . PUNCT crl-14716 4 1 public public ADJ crl-14716 4 2 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 4 3 fall fall VERB crl-14716 4 4 somewhere somewhere ADV crl-14716 4 5 between between ADP crl-14716 4 6 these these DET crl-14716 4 7 two two NUM crl-14716 4 8 positions position NOUN crl-14716 4 9 . . PUNCT crl-14716 5 1 the the DET crl-14716 5 2 results result NOUN crl-14716 5 3 also also ADV crl-14716 5 4 indicate indicate VERB crl-14716 5 5 that that SCONJ crl-14716 5 6 the the DET crl-14716 5 7 practice practice NOUN crl-14716 5 8 of of ADP crl-14716 5 9 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 5 10 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 5 11 is be AUX crl-14716 5 12 largely largely ADV crl-14716 5 13 unregulated unregulated ADJ crl-14716 5 14 in in ADP crl-14716 5 15 terms term NOUN crl-14716 5 16 of of ADP crl-14716 5 17 both both DET crl-14716 5 18 library library NOUN crl-14716 5 19 policy policy NOUN crl-14716 5 20 and and CCONJ crl-14716 5 21 professional professional ADJ crl-14716 5 22 training training NOUN crl-14716 5 23 in in ADP crl-14716 5 24 instructional instructional ADJ crl-14716 5 25 techniques technique NOUN crl-14716 5 26 . . PUNCT crl-14716 6 1 ven ven ADJ crl-14716 6 2 though though SCONJ crl-14716 6 3 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 6 4 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 6 5 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 6 6 or or CCONJ crl-14716 6 7 user user NOUN crl-14716 6 8 education education NOUN crl-14716 6 9 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 6 10 seems seem VERB crl-14716 6 11 to to PART crl-14716 6 12 be be AUX crl-14716 6 13 a a DET crl-14716 6 14 fact fact NOUN crl-14716 6 15 in in ADP crl-14716 6 16 most most ADV crl-14716 6 17 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 6 18 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 6 19 , , PUNCT crl-14716 6 20 some some PRON crl-14716 6 21 believe believe VERB crl-14716 6 22 that that SCONJ crl-14716 6 23 it it PRON crl-14716 6 24 should should AUX crl-14716 6 25 not not PART crl-14716 6 26 be be AUX crl-14716 6 27 . . PUNCT crl-14716 7 1 for for ADP crl-14716 7 2 instance instance NOUN crl-14716 7 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 7 4 tom tom PROPN crl-14716 7 5 eadie eadie PROPN crl-14716 7 6 argued argue VERB crl-14716 7 7 recently recently ADV crl-14716 7 8 that that SCONJ crl-14716 7 9 user user NOUN crl-14716 7 10 education education NOUN crl-14716 7 11 is be AUX crl-14716 7 12 , , PUNCT crl-14716 7 13 essentially essentially ADV crl-14716 7 14 , , PUNCT crl-14716 7 15 useless useless ADJ crl-14716 7 16 when when SCONJ crl-14716 7 17 it it PRON crl-14716 7 18 is be AUX crl-14716 7 19 " " PUNCT crl-14716 7 20 aimed aim VERB crl-14716 7 21 at at ADP crl-14716 7 22 groups group NOUN crl-14716 7 23 of of ADP crl-14716 7 24 library library NOUN crl-14716 7 25 users user NOUN crl-14716 7 26 , , PUNCT crl-14716 7 27 delivered deliver VERB crl-14716 7 28 on on ADP crl-14716 7 29 schedule schedule NOUN crl-14716 7 30 and and CCONJ crl-14716 7 31 in in ADP crl-14716 7 32 anticipation anticipation NOUN crl-14716 7 33 of of ADP crl-14716 7 34 questions question NOUN crl-14716 7 35 that that PRON crl-14716 7 36 have have AUX crl-14716 7 37 not not PART crl-14716 7 38 yet yet ADV crl-14716 7 39 been be AUX crl-14716 7 40 asked ask VERB crl-14716 7 41 , , PUNCT crl-14716 7 42 rather rather ADV crl-14716 7 43 than than ADP crl-14716 7 44 on on ADP crl-14716 7 45 demand demand NOUN crl-14716 7 46 at at ADP crl-14716 7 47 pointof pointof PROPN crl-14716 7 48 - - PUNCT crl-14716 7 49 service service PROPN crl-14716 7 50 . . PUNCT crl-14716 7 51 "1 "1 PUNCT crl-14716 8 1 others other NOUN crl-14716 8 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 8 3 too too ADV crl-14716 8 4 , , PUNCT crl-14716 8 5 have have AUX crl-14716 8 6 been be AUX crl-14716 8 7 critical critical ADJ crl-14716 8 8 of of ADP crl-14716 8 9 user user NOUN crl-14716 8 10 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 8 11 , , PUNCT crl-14716 8 12 claiming claim VERB crl-14716 8 13 among among ADP crl-14716 8 14 other other ADJ crl-14716 8 15 things thing NOUN crl-14716 8 16 that that PRON crl-14716 8 17 it it PRON crl-14716 8 18 stifles stifle VERB crl-14716 8 19 creativity creativity NOUN crl-14716 8 20 . . PUNCT crl-14716 9 1 mona mona PROPN crl-14716 9 2 mccormick mccormick PROPN crl-14716 9 3 noted note VERB crl-14716 9 4 , , PUNCT crl-14716 9 5 for for ADP crl-14716 9 6 example example NOUN crl-14716 9 7 , , PUNCT crl-14716 9 8 that that SCONJ crl-14716 9 9 " " PUNCT crl-14716 9 10 if if SCONJ crl-14716 9 11 library library NOUN crl-14716 9 12 education education NOUN crl-14716 9 13 focuses focus VERB crl-14716 9 14 only only ADV crl-14716 9 15 on on ADP crl-14716 9 16 how how SCONJ crl-14716 9 17 to to PART crl-14716 9 18 locate locate VERB crl-14716 9 19 information information NOUN crl-14716 9 20 and and CCONJ crl-14716 9 21 on on ADP crl-14716 9 22 the the DET crl-14716 9 23 particulars particular NOUN crl-14716 9 24 of of ADP crl-14716 9 25 a a DET crl-14716 9 26 certain certain ADJ crl-14716 9 27 index index NOUN crl-14716 9 28 ... ... PUNCT crl-14716 9 29 it it PRON crl-14716 9 30 will will AUX crl-14716 9 31 soon soon ADV crl-14716 9 32 bore bore VERB crl-14716 9 33 the the DET crl-14716 9 34 student student NOUN crl-14716 9 35 who who PRON crl-14716 9 36 does do AUX crl-14716 9 37 experience experience VERB crl-14716 9 38 the the DET crl-14716 9 39 challenge challenge NOUN crl-14716 9 40 and and CCONJ crl-14716 9 41 creativity creativity NOUN crl-14716 9 42 of of ADP crl-14716 9 43 using use VERB crl-14716 9 44 information information NOUN crl-14716 9 45 critically critically ADV crl-14716 9 46 . . PUNCT crl-14716 10 1 "2 "2 PUNCT crl-14716 10 2 instead instead ADV crl-14716 10 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 10 4 she she PRON crl-14716 10 5 argued argue VERB crl-14716 10 6 , , PUNCT crl-14716 10 7 the the DET crl-14716 10 8 search search NOUN crl-14716 10 9 for for ADP crl-14716 10 10 information information NOUN crl-14716 10 11 should should AUX crl-14716 10 12 lead lead VERB crl-14716 10 13 students student NOUN crl-14716 10 14 to to ADP crl-14716 10 15 a a DET crl-14716 10 16 critical critical ADJ crl-14716 10 17 approach approach NOUN crl-14716 10 18 to to ADP crl-14716 10 19 information information NOUN crl-14716 10 20 . . PUNCT crl-14716 11 1 mary mary PROPN crl-14716 11 2 huston huston PROPN crl-14716 11 3 suggested suggest VERB crl-14716 11 4 that that SCONJ crl-14716 11 5 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 11 6 should should AUX crl-14716 11 7 empower empower VERB crl-14716 11 8 library library NOUN crl-14716 11 9 users user NOUN crl-14716 11 10 to to PART crl-14716 11 11 operate operate VERB crl-14716 11 12 from from ADP crl-14716 11 13 their their PRON crl-14716 11 14 own own ADJ crl-14716 11 15 domain domain NOUN crl-14716 11 16 of of ADP crl-14716 11 17 experience experience NOUN crl-14716 11 18 rather rather ADV crl-14716 11 19 than than ADP crl-14716 11 20 from from ADP crl-14716 11 21 that that PRON crl-14716 11 22 of of ADP crl-14716 11 23 the the DET crl-14716 11 24 librarian.3 librarian.3 PROPN crl-14716 11 25 extending extend VERB crl-14716 11 26 this this DET crl-14716 11 27 point point NOUN crl-14716 11 28 further far ADV crl-14716 11 29 , , PUNCT crl-14716 11 30 willie willie NOUN crl-14716 11 31 parson parson NOUN crl-14716 11 32 claimed claim VERB crl-14716 11 33 that that SCONJ crl-14716 11 34 " " PUNCT crl-14716 11 35 it it PRON crl-14716 11 36 is be AUX crl-14716 11 37 the the DET crl-14716 11 38 failure failure NOUN crl-14716 11 39 to to PART crl-14716 11 40 be be AUX crl-14716 11 41 concerned concern VERB crl-14716 11 42 with with ADP crl-14716 11 43 the the DET crl-14716 11 44 critical critical ADJ crl-14716 11 45 treatment treatment NOUN crl-14716 11 46 of of ADP crl-14716 11 47 information information NOUN crl-14716 11 48 that that PRON crl-14716 11 49 calls call VERB crl-14716 11 50 into into ADP crl-14716 11 51 question question NOUN crl-14716 11 52 the the DET crl-14716 11 53 notion notion NOUN crl-14716 11 54 of of ADP crl-14716 11 55 the the DET crl-14716 11 56 library library NOUN crl-14716 11 57 as as ADP crl-14716 11 58 the the DET crl-14716 11 59 center center NOUN crl-14716 11 60 of of ADP crl-14716 11 61 the the DET crl-14716 11 62 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 11 63 environment environment NOUN crl-14716 11 64 . . PUNCT crl-14716 12 1 effective effective ADJ crl-14716 12 2 pedagogy pedagogy NOUN crl-14716 12 3 makes make VERB crl-14716 12 4 the the DET crl-14716 12 5 issue issue NOUN crl-14716 12 6 of of ADP crl-14716 12 7 critical critical ADJ crl-14716 12 8 thinking thinking NOUN crl-14716 12 9 a a DET crl-14716 12 10 priority priority NOUN crl-14716 12 11 of of ADP crl-14716 12 12 the the DET crl-14716 12 13 first first ADJ crl-14716 12 14 magnitude magnitude NOUN crl-14716 12 15 . . PUNCT crl-14716 12 16 " " PUNCT crl-14716 13 1 4 4 NUM crl-14716 13 2 criticism criticism NOUN crl-14716 13 3 of of ADP crl-14716 13 4 user user NOUN crl-14716 13 5 education education NOUN crl-14716 13 6 is be AUX crl-14716 13 7 not not PART crl-14716 13 8 limited limit VERB crl-14716 13 9 merely merely ADV crl-14716 13 10 to to ADP crl-14716 13 11 methods method NOUN crl-14716 13 12 of of ADP crl-14716 13 13 delivery delivery NOUN crl-14716 13 14 and and CCONJ crl-14716 13 15 their their PRON crl-14716 13 16 impact impact NOUN crl-14716 13 17 on on ADP crl-14716 13 18 users user NOUN crl-14716 13 19 . . PUNCT crl-14716 14 1 rather rather ADV crl-14716 14 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 14 3 the the DET crl-14716 14 4 very very ADJ crl-14716 14 5 role role NOUN crl-14716 14 6 of of ADP crl-14716 14 7 user user NOUN crl-14716 14 8 education education NOUN crl-14716 14 9 in in ADP crl-14716 14 10 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-14716 14 11 has have AUX crl-14716 14 12 been be AUX crl-14716 14 13 challenged challenge VERB crl-14716 14 14 . . PUNCT crl-14716 15 1 thus thus ADV crl-14716 15 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 15 3 not not PART crl-14716 15 4 only only ADV crl-14716 15 5 roma roma PROPN crl-14716 15 6 m. m. NOUN crl-14716 15 7 harris harris PROPN crl-14716 15 8 is be AUX crl-14716 15 9 associate associate ADJ crl-14716 15 10 professor professor NOUN crl-14716 15 11 at at ADP crl-14716 15 12 the the DET crl-14716 15 13 school school NOUN crl-14716 15 14 of of ADP crl-14716 15 15 library library NOUN crl-14716 15 16 and and CCONJ crl-14716 15 17 information information NOUN crl-14716 15 18 science science NOUN crl-14716 15 19 at at ADP crl-14716 15 20 the the DET crl-14716 15 21 university university PROPN crl-14716 15 22 of of ADP crl-14716 15 23 western western PROPN crl-14716 15 24 ontario ontario PROPN crl-14716 15 25 at at ADP crl-14716 15 26 london london PROPN crl-14716 15 27 , , PUNCT crl-14716 15 28 ontario ontario PROPN crl-14716 15 29 , , PUNCT crl-14716 15 30 canada canada PROPN crl-14716 15 31 n6 n6 PROPN crl-14716 15 32 g g PROPN crl-14716 15 33 1h1 1h1 NUM crl-14716 15 34 . . PUNCT crl-14716 16 1 the the DET crl-14716 16 2 autlwr autlwr PROPN crl-14716 16 3 would would AUX crl-14716 16 4 like like VERB crl-14716 16 5 to to PART crl-14716 16 6 thank thank VERB crl-14716 16 7 patricia patricia PROPN crl-14716 16 8 dewdney dewdney NOUN crl-14716 16 9 for for ADP crl-14716 16 10 suggesting suggest VERB crl-14716 16 11 the the DET crl-14716 16 12 idea idea NOUN crl-14716 16 13 for for ADP crl-14716 16 14 this this DET crl-14716 16 15 paper paper NOUN crl-14716 16 16 and and CCONJ crl-14716 16 17 for for ADP crl-14716 16 18 commenting comment VERB crl-14716 16 19 on on ADP crl-14716 16 20 an an DET crl-14716 16 21 earlier early ADJ crl-14716 16 22 draft draft NOUN crl-14716 16 23 of of ADP crl-14716 16 24 the the DET crl-14716 16 25 manuscript manuscript NOUN crl-14716 16 26 . . PUNCT crl-14716 17 1 249 249 NUM crl-14716 17 2 250 250 NUM crl-14716 17 3 college college PROPN crl-14716 17 4 & & CCONJ crl-14716 17 5 research research PROPN crl-14716 17 6 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 17 7 did do AUX crl-14716 17 8 eadie eadie VERB crl-14716 17 9 , , PUNCT crl-14716 17 10 a a DET crl-14716 17 11 former former ADJ crl-14716 17 12 user user NOUN crl-14716 17 13 education education NOUN crl-14716 17 14 librarian librarian PROPN crl-14716 17 15 , , PUNCT crl-14716 17 16 suggest suggest VERB crl-14716 17 17 that that SCONJ crl-14716 17 18 he he PRON crl-14716 17 19 was be AUX crl-14716 17 20 not not PART crl-14716 17 21 sure sure ADJ crl-14716 17 22 that that PRON crl-14716 17 23 librarians librarian VERB crl-14716 17 24 " " PUNCT crl-14716 17 25 should should AUX crl-14716 17 26 be be AUX crl-14716 17 27 ' ' PUNCT crl-14716 17 28 educating educate VERB crl-14716 17 29 ' ' PUNCT crl-14716 17 30 students student NOUN crl-14716 17 31 " " PUNCT crl-14716 17 32 at at ADP crl-14716 17 33 alj alj NOUN crl-14716 17 34 , , PUNCT crl-14716 17 35 s s PRON crl-14716 17 36 but but CCONJ crl-14716 17 37 pauline pauline PROPN crl-14716 17 38 wilson wilson NOUN crl-14716 17 39 went go VERB crl-14716 17 40 so so ADV crl-14716 17 41 far far ADV crl-14716 17 42 as as SCONJ crl-14716 17 43 to to PART crl-14716 17 44 argue argue VERB crl-14716 17 45 that that SCONJ crl-14716 17 46 by by ADP crl-14716 17 47 assuming assume VERB crl-14716 17 48 teaching teaching NOUN crl-14716 17 49 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-14716 17 50 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 17 51 are be AUX crl-14716 17 52 promoting promote VERB crl-14716 17 53 a a DET crl-14716 17 54 fiction fiction NOUN crl-14716 17 55 about about ADP crl-14716 17 56 their their PRON crl-14716 17 57 occupational occupational ADJ crl-14716 17 58 roles.6 roles.6 NOUN crl-14716 17 59 in in ADP crl-14716 17 60 spite spite NOUN crl-14716 17 61 of of ADP crl-14716 17 62 such such ADJ crl-14716 17 63 doubts doubt NOUN crl-14716 17 64 , , PUNCT crl-14716 17 65 some some PRON crl-14716 17 66 appear appear VERB crl-14716 17 67 to to PART crl-14716 17 68 be be AUX crl-14716 17 69 completely completely ADV crl-14716 17 70 confident confident ADJ crl-14716 17 71 about about ADP crl-14716 17 72 the the DET crl-14716 17 73 centrality centrality NOUN crl-14716 17 74 of of ADP crl-14716 17 75 teaching teaching NOUN crl-14716 17 76 's 's PART crl-14716 17 77 role role NOUN crl-14716 17 78 in in ADP crl-14716 17 79 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-14716 17 80 . . PUNCT crl-14716 18 1 indeed indeed ADV crl-14716 18 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 18 3 charles charles PROPN crl-14716 18 4 d. d. PROPN crl-14716 18 5 patterson patterson PROPN crl-14716 18 6 and and CCONJ crl-14716 18 7 donna donna PROPN crl-14716 18 8 w. w. PROPN crl-14716 18 9 howell howell PROPN crl-14716 18 10 claimed claim VERB crl-14716 18 11 that that SCONJ crl-14716 18 12 " " PUNCT crl-14716 18 13 the the DET crl-14716 18 14 librarian librarian NOUN crl-14716 18 15 is be AUX crl-14716 18 16 a a DET crl-14716 18 17 teacher teacher NOUN crl-14716 18 18 . . PUNCT crl-14716 19 1 whether whether SCONJ crl-14716 19 2 assisting assist VERB crl-14716 19 3 individual individual ADJ crl-14716 19 4 library library NOUN crl-14716 19 5 patrons patron NOUN crl-14716 19 6 in in ADP crl-14716 19 7 locating locate VERB crl-14716 19 8 information information NOUN crl-14716 19 9 and and CCONJ crl-14716 19 10 thus thus ADV crl-14716 19 11 informally informally ADV crl-14716 19 12 teaching teach VERB crl-14716 19 13 or or CCONJ crl-14716 19 14 formally formally ADV crl-14716 19 15 lecturing lecture VERB crl-14716 19 16 to to ADP crl-14716 19 17 a a DET crl-14716 19 18 class class NOUN crl-14716 19 19 and and CCONJ crl-14716 19 20 teaching teach VERB crl-14716 19 21 the the DET crl-14716 19 22 specificity specificity NOUN crl-14716 19 23 of of ADP crl-14716 19 24 the the DET crl-14716 19 25 structure structure NOUN crl-14716 19 26 and and CCONJ crl-14716 19 27 organization organization NOUN crl-14716 19 28 of of ADP crl-14716 19 29 a a DET crl-14716 19 30 given give VERB crl-14716 19 31 literature literature NOUN crl-14716 19 32 , , PUNCT crl-14716 19 33 the the DET crl-14716 19 34 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 19 35 librarian librarian NOUN crl-14716 19 36 is be AUX crl-14716 19 37 , , PUNCT crl-14716 19 38 in in ADP crl-14716 19 39 each each DET crl-14716 19 40 situation situation NOUN crl-14716 19 41 , , PUNCT crl-14716 19 42 teaching teaching NOUN crl-14716 19 43 . . PUNCT crl-14716 19 44 " " PUNCT crl-14716 20 1 7 7 NUM crl-14716 20 2 the the DET crl-14716 20 3 disagreement disagreement NOUN crl-14716 20 4 and and CCONJ crl-14716 20 5 confusion confusion NOUN crl-14716 20 6 in in ADP crl-14716 20 7 the the DET crl-14716 20 8 field field NOUN crl-14716 20 9 over over ADP crl-14716 20 10 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 20 11 - - PUNCT crl-14716 20 12 versus versus ADP crl-14716 20 13 - - PUNCT crl-14716 20 14 information information NOUN crl-14716 20 15 delivery delivery NOUN crl-14716 20 16 have have AUX crl-14716 20 17 presented present VERB crl-14716 20 18 problems problem NOUN crl-14716 20 19 not not PART crl-14716 20 20 only only ADV crl-14716 20 21 for for ADP crl-14716 20 22 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 20 23 who who PRON crl-14716 20 24 wish wish VERB crl-14716 20 25 to to PART crl-14716 20 26 define define VERB crl-14716 20 27 their their PRON crl-14716 20 28 roles role NOUN crl-14716 20 29 but but CCONJ crl-14716 20 30 also also ADV crl-14716 20 31 , , PUNCT crl-14716 20 32 and and CCONJ crl-14716 20 33 perhaps perhaps ADV crl-14716 20 34 more more ADV crl-14716 20 35 importantly importantly ADV crl-14716 20 36 , , PUNCT crl-14716 20 37 for for ADP crl-14716 20 38 the the DET crl-14716 20 39 users user NOUN crl-14716 20 40 of of ADP crl-14716 20 41 library library NOUN crl-14716 20 42 services service NOUN crl-14716 20 43 . . PUNCT crl-14716 21 1 as as SCONJ crl-14716 21 2 anne anne PROPN crl-14716 21 3 f. f. PROPN crl-14716 21 4 roberts roberts PROPN crl-14716 21 5 pointed point VERB crl-14716 21 6 out out ADP crl-14716 21 7 , , PUNCT crl-14716 21 8 information information NOUN crl-14716 22 1 [ [ X crl-14716 22 2 and and CCONJ crl-14716 22 3 ] ] X crl-14716 22 4 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 22 5 have have AUX crl-14716 22 6 [ [ X crl-14716 22 7 often often ADV crl-14716 22 8 ] ] PUNCT crl-14716 22 9 been be AUX crl-14716 22 10 at at ADP crl-14716 22 11 cross cross NOUN crl-14716 22 12 purposes purpose NOUN crl-14716 22 13 with with ADP crl-14716 22 14 each each DET crl-14716 22 15 other other ADJ crl-14716 22 16 since since SCONJ crl-14716 22 17 each each DET crl-14716 22 18 term term NOUN crl-14716 22 19 has have AUX crl-14716 22 20 been be AUX crl-14716 22 21 joined join VERB crl-14716 22 22 with with ADP crl-14716 22 23 a a DET crl-14716 22 24 conflicting conflicting ADJ crl-14716 22 25 view view NOUN crl-14716 22 26 as as ADP crl-14716 22 27 to to ADP crl-14716 22 28 the the DET crl-14716 22 29 amount amount NOUN crl-14716 22 30 of of ADP crl-14716 22 31 assistance assistance NOUN crl-14716 22 32 to to PART crl-14716 22 33 be be AUX crl-14716 22 34 offered offer VERB crl-14716 22 35 in in ADP crl-14716 22 36 each each DET crl-14716 22 37 case case NOUN crl-14716 22 38 . . PUNCT crl-14716 23 1 information information NOUN crl-14716 23 2 has have AUX crl-14716 23 3 been be AUX crl-14716 23 4 associated associate VERB crl-14716 23 5 with with ADP crl-14716 23 6 giving give VERB crl-14716 23 7 the the DET crl-14716 23 8 greatest great ADJ crl-14716 23 9 amount amount NOUN crl-14716 23 10 of of ADP crl-14716 23 11 service service NOUN crl-14716 23 12 , , PUNCT crl-14716 23 13 while while SCONJ crl-14716 23 14 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 23 15 limited limit VERB crl-14716 23 16 the the DET crl-14716 23 17 service service NOUN crl-14716 23 18 to to ADP crl-14716 23 19 pointing point VERB crl-14716 23 20 the the DET crl-14716 23 21 way way NOUN crl-14716 23 22 for for ADP crl-14716 23 23 users user NOUN crl-14716 23 24 ... ... PUNCT crl-14716 23 25 if if SCONJ crl-14716 23 26 all all DET crl-14716 23 27 this this DET crl-14716 23 28 confuses confuse NOUN crl-14716 23 29 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 23 30 and and CCONJ crl-14716 23 31 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 23 32 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 23 33 it it PRON crl-14716 23 34 certainly certainly ADV crl-14716 23 35 confuses confuse VERB crl-14716 23 36 the the DET crl-14716 23 37 users user NOUN crl-14716 23 38 . . PUNCT crl-14716 24 1 users user NOUN crl-14716 24 2 want want VERB crl-14716 24 3 answers answer NOUN crl-14716 24 4 , , PUNCT crl-14716 24 5 not not PART crl-14716 24 6 instruction.8 instruction.8 PROPN crl-14716 24 7 of of ADP crl-14716 24 8 course course NOUN crl-14716 24 9 , , PUNCT crl-14716 24 10 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 24 11 and and CCONJ crl-14716 24 12 information information NOUN crl-14716 24 13 delivery delivery NOUN crl-14716 24 14 need need AUX crl-14716 24 15 not not PART crl-14716 24 16 be be AUX crl-14716 24 17 considered consider VERB crl-14716 24 18 mutually mutually ADV crl-14716 24 19 exclusive exclusive ADJ crl-14716 24 20 . . PUNCT crl-14716 25 1 in in ADP crl-14716 25 2 fact fact NOUN crl-14716 25 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 25 4 according accord VERB crl-14716 25 5 to to ADP crl-14716 25 6 brian brian PROPN crl-14716 25 7 nielsen nielsen PROPN crl-14716 25 8 , , PUNCT crl-14716 25 9 " " PUNCT crl-14716 25 10 the the DET crl-14716 25 11 present present ADJ crl-14716 25 12 competition competition NOUN crl-14716 25 13 between between ADP crl-14716 25 14 those those PRON crl-14716 25 15 who who PRON crl-14716 25 16 advocate advocate VERB crl-14716 25 17 the the DET crl-14716 25 18 intermediary intermediary ADJ crl-14716 25 19 role role NOUN crl-14716 25 20 and and CCONJ crl-14716 25 21 those those PRON crl-14716 25 22 who who PRON crl-14716 25 23 advocate advocate VERB crl-14716 25 24 the the DET crl-14716 25 25 teaching teaching NOUN crl-14716 25 26 role role NOUN crl-14716 25 27 is be AUX crl-14716 25 28 unfortunate unfortunate ADJ crl-14716 25 29 and and CCONJ crl-14716 25 30 unnecessary unnecessary ADJ crl-14716 25 31 . . PUNCT crl-14716 25 32 "9 "9 PUNCT crl-14716 26 1 nevertheless nevertheless ADV crl-14716 26 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 26 3 although although SCONJ crl-14716 26 4 information information NOUN crl-14716 26 5 and and CCONJ crl-14716 26 6 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 26 7 can can AUX crl-14716 26 8 be be AUX crl-14716 26 9 , , PUNCT crl-14716 26 10 and and CCONJ crl-14716 26 11 often often ADV crl-14716 26 12 are be AUX crl-14716 26 13 , , PUNCT crl-14716 26 14 integrated integrate VERB crl-14716 26 15 into into ADP crl-14716 26 16 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 26 17 service service NOUN crl-14716 26 18 , , PUNCT crl-14716 26 19 the the DET crl-14716 26 20 literature literature NOUN crl-14716 26 21 suggests suggest VERB crl-14716 26 22 that that SCONJ crl-14716 26 23 very very ADV crl-14716 26 24 different different ADJ crl-14716 26 25 points point NOUN crl-14716 26 26 of of ADP crl-14716 26 27 view view NOUN crl-14716 26 28 exist exist VERB crl-14716 26 29 in in ADP crl-14716 26 30 the the DET crl-14716 26 31 field field NOUN crl-14716 26 32 over over ADP crl-14716 26 33 what what PRON crl-14716 26 34 should should AUX crl-14716 26 35 be be AUX crl-14716 26 36 emphasized emphasize VERB crl-14716 26 37 in in ADP crl-14716 26 38 service service NOUN crl-14716 26 39 delivery delivery NOUN crl-14716 26 40 . . PUNCT crl-14716 27 1 given give VERB crl-14716 27 2 the the DET crl-14716 27 3 level level NOUN crl-14716 27 4 of of ADP crl-14716 27 5 disagreement disagreement NOUN crl-14716 27 6 in in ADP crl-14716 27 7 the the DET crl-14716 27 8 literature literature NOUN crl-14716 27 9 over over ADP crl-14716 27 10 the the DET crl-14716 27 11 role role NOUN crl-14716 27 12 and and CCONJ crl-14716 27 13 value value NOUN crl-14716 27 14 of of ADP crl-14716 27 15 inmay1992 inmay1992 PROPN crl-14716 27 16 struction struction NOUN crl-14716 27 17 in in ADP crl-14716 27 18 library library NOUN crl-14716 27 19 work work NOUN crl-14716 27 20 , , PUNCT crl-14716 27 21 it it PRON crl-14716 27 22 seems seem VERB crl-14716 27 23 timely timely ADJ crl-14716 27 24 to to PART crl-14716 27 25 consider consider VERB crl-14716 27 26 the the DET crl-14716 27 27 differences difference NOUN crl-14716 27 28 in in ADP crl-14716 27 29 perspective perspective NOUN crl-14716 27 30 among among ADP crl-14716 27 31 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 27 32 who who PRON crl-14716 27 33 work work VERB crl-14716 27 34 in in ADP crl-14716 27 35 special special ADJ crl-14716 27 36 , , PUNCT crl-14716 27 37 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 27 38 , , PUNCT crl-14716 27 39 and and CCONJ crl-14716 27 40 public public ADJ crl-14716 27 41 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 27 42 . . PUNCT crl-14716 28 1 in in ADP crl-14716 28 2 other other ADJ crl-14716 28 3 words word NOUN crl-14716 28 4 , , PUNCT crl-14716 28 5 it it PRON crl-14716 28 6 may may AUX crl-14716 28 7 be be AUX crl-14716 28 8 useful useful ADJ crl-14716 28 9 to to PART crl-14716 28 10 examine examine VERB crl-14716 28 11 the the DET crl-14716 28 12 values value NOUN crl-14716 28 13 that that PRON crl-14716 28 14 inform inform VERB crl-14716 28 15 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 28 16 ' ' PART crl-14716 28 17 positions position NOUN crl-14716 28 18 on on ADP crl-14716 28 19 this this DET crl-14716 28 20 issue issue NOUN crl-14716 28 21 and and CCONJ crl-14716 28 22 how how SCONJ crl-14716 28 23 these these PRON crl-14716 28 24 vary vary VERB crl-14716 28 25 from from ADP crl-14716 28 26 setting set VERB crl-14716 28 27 to to ADP crl-14716 28 28 setting set VERB crl-14716 28 29 . . PUNCT crl-14716 29 1 in in ADP crl-14716 29 2 an an DET crl-14716 29 3 earlier early ADJ crl-14716 29 4 study study NOUN crl-14716 29 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 29 6 the the DET crl-14716 29 7 author author NOUN crl-14716 29 8 surveyed survey VERB crl-14716 29 9 public public ADJ crl-14716 29 10 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 29 11 as as ADP crl-14716 29 12 to to ADP crl-14716 29 13 their their PRON crl-14716 29 14 views view NOUN crl-14716 29 15 about about ADP crl-14716 29 16 the the DET crl-14716 29 17 role role NOUN crl-14716 29 18 of of ADP crl-14716 29 19 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 29 20 in in ADP crl-14716 29 21 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 29 22 work work NOUN crl-14716 29 23 . . PUNCT crl-14716 30 1 10 10 NUM crl-14716 30 2 the the DET crl-14716 30 3 results result NOUN crl-14716 30 4 revealed reveal VERB crl-14716 30 5 that that SCONJ crl-14716 30 6 the the DET crl-14716 30 7 majority majority NOUN crl-14716 30 8 of of ADP crl-14716 30 9 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 30 10 saw see VERB crl-14716 30 11 user user NOUN crl-14716 30 12 education education NOUN crl-14716 30 13 as as ADP crl-14716 30 14 desirable desirable ADJ crl-14716 30 15 , , PUNCT crl-14716 30 16 even even ADV crl-14716 30 17 when when SCONJ crl-14716 30 18 it it PRON crl-14716 30 19 is be AUX crl-14716 30 20 not not PART crl-14716 30 21 requested request VERB crl-14716 30 22 by by ADP crl-14716 30 23 library library NOUN crl-14716 30 24 patrons patron NOUN crl-14716 30 25 . . PUNCT crl-14716 31 1 the the DET crl-14716 31 2 disagreement disagreement NOUN crl-14716 31 3 and and CCONJ crl-14716 31 4 confusion confusion NOUN crl-14716 31 5 in in ADP crl-14716 31 6 the the DET crl-14716 31 7 field field NOUN crl-14716 31 8 over over ADP crl-14716 31 9 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 31 10 - - PUNCT crl-14716 31 11 versus versus ADP crl-14716 31 12 - - PUNCT crl-14716 31 13 information information NOUN crl-14716 31 14 delivery delivery NOUN crl-14716 31 15 have have AUX crl-14716 31 16 presented present VERB crl-14716 31 17 problems problem NOUN crl-14716 31 18 not not PART crl-14716 31 19 only only ADV crl-14716 31 20 for for ADP crl-14716 31 21 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 31 22 ... ... PUNCT crl-14716 31 23 but but CCONJ crl-14716 31 24 for for ADP crl-14716 31 25 the the DET crl-14716 31 26 users user NOUN crl-14716 31 27 of of ADP crl-14716 31 28 library library NOUN crl-14716 31 29 services service NOUN crl-14716 31 30 . . PUNCT crl-14716 32 1 however however ADV crl-14716 32 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 32 3 the the DET crl-14716 32 4 findings finding NOUN crl-14716 32 5 also also ADV crl-14716 32 6 indicated indicate VERB crl-14716 32 7 that that SCONJ crl-14716 32 8 little little ADJ crl-14716 32 9 consensus consensus NOUN crl-14716 32 10 exists exist VERB crl-14716 32 11 within within ADP crl-14716 32 12 the the DET crl-14716 32 13 public public ADJ crl-14716 32 14 library library NOUN crl-14716 32 15 community community NOUN crl-14716 32 16 about about ADP crl-14716 32 17 the the DET crl-14716 32 18 values value NOUN crl-14716 32 19 that that PRON crl-14716 32 20 underlie underlie VERB crl-14716 32 21 the the DET crl-14716 32 22 conflict conflict NOUN crl-14716 32 23 sometimes sometimes ADV crl-14716 32 24 referred refer VERB crl-14716 32 25 to to ADP crl-14716 32 26 as as ADP crl-14716 32 27 the the DET crl-14716 32 28 " " PUNCT crl-14716 32 29 informationversus informationversus NOUN crl-14716 32 30 - - PUNCT crl-14716 32 31 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 32 32 debate debate NOUN crl-14716 32 33 . . PUNCT crl-14716 32 34 " " PUNCT crl-14716 33 1 11 11 NUM crl-14716 33 2 the the DET crl-14716 33 3 public public ADJ crl-14716 33 4 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 33 5 included include VERB crl-14716 33 6 in in ADP crl-14716 33 7 the the DET crl-14716 33 8 sample sample NOUN crl-14716 33 9 did do AUX crl-14716 33 10 not not PART crl-14716 33 11 agree agree VERB crl-14716 33 12 on on ADP crl-14716 33 13 the the DET crl-14716 33 14 extent extent NOUN crl-14716 33 15 to to PART crl-14716 33 16 which which PRON crl-14716 33 17 a a DET crl-14716 33 18 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 33 19 librarian librarian NOUN crl-14716 33 20 's 's PART crl-14716 33 21 role role NOUN crl-14716 33 22 is be AUX crl-14716 33 23 to to PART crl-14716 33 24 deliver deliver VERB crl-14716 33 25 information information NOUN crl-14716 33 26 or or CCONJ crl-14716 33 27 to to PART crl-14716 33 28 teach teach VERB crl-14716 33 29 patrons patron NOUN crl-14716 33 30 how how SCONJ crl-14716 33 31 to to PART crl-14716 33 32 find find VERB crl-14716 33 33 it it PRON crl-14716 33 34 for for ADP crl-14716 33 35 themselves themselves PRON crl-14716 33 36 . . PUNCT crl-14716 34 1 they they PRON crl-14716 34 2 were be AUX crl-14716 34 3 also also ADV crl-14716 34 4 divided divide VERB crl-14716 34 5 over over ADP crl-14716 34 6 such such ADJ crl-14716 34 7 questions question NOUN crl-14716 34 8 as as ADP crl-14716 34 9 to to ADP crl-14716 34 10 whether whether SCONJ crl-14716 34 11 the the DET crl-14716 34 12 teaching teaching NOUN crl-14716 34 13 function function NOUN crl-14716 34 14 of of ADP crl-14716 34 15 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 34 16 work work NOUN crl-14716 34 17 is be AUX crl-14716 34 18 as as ADV crl-14716 34 19 important important ADJ crl-14716 34 20 as as ADP crl-14716 34 21 information information NOUN crl-14716 34 22 provision provision NOUN crl-14716 34 23 , , PUNCT crl-14716 34 24 and and CCONJ crl-14716 34 25 whether whether SCONJ crl-14716 34 26 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 34 27 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 34 28 perform perform VERB crl-14716 34 29 work work NOUN crl-14716 34 30 similar similar ADJ crl-14716 34 31 to to ADP crl-14716 34 32 that that PRON crl-14716 34 33 of of ADP crl-14716 34 34 teachers teacher NOUN crl-14716 34 35 . . PUNCT crl-14716 35 1 overall overall ADV crl-14716 35 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 35 3 these these DET crl-14716 35 4 results result NOUN crl-14716 35 5 suggest suggest VERB crl-14716 35 6 that that SCONJ crl-14716 35 7 while while SCONJ crl-14716 35 8 public public ADJ crl-14716 35 9 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 35 10 generally generally ADV crl-14716 35 11 favor favor VERB crl-14716 35 12 the the DET crl-14716 35 13 idea idea NOUN crl-14716 35 14 of of ADP crl-14716 35 15 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 35 16 , , PUNCT crl-14716 35 17 they they PRON crl-14716 35 18 do do AUX crl-14716 35 19 not not PART crl-14716 35 20 agree agree VERB crl-14716 35 21 with with ADP crl-14716 35 22 one one NUM crl-14716 35 23 another another DET crl-14716 35 24 about about ADP crl-14716 35 25 the the DET crl-14716 35 26 extent extent NOUN crl-14716 35 27 to to PART crl-14716 35 28 which which PRON crl-14716 35 29 it it PRON crl-14716 35 30 should should AUX crl-14716 35 31 be be AUX crl-14716 35 32 highlighted highlight VERB crl-14716 35 33 in in ADP crl-14716 35 34 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 35 35 service service NOUN crl-14716 35 36 . . PUNCT crl-14716 36 1 what what PRON crl-14716 36 2 remains remain VERB crl-14716 36 3 unclear unclear ADJ crl-14716 36 4 , , PUNCT crl-14716 36 5 however however ADV crl-14716 36 6 , , PUNCT crl-14716 36 7 is be AUX crl-14716 36 8 where where SCONJ crl-14716 36 9 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 36 10 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 36 11 and and CCONJ crl-14716 36 12 special special ADJ crl-14716 36 13 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 36 14 see see VERB crl-14716 36 15 themselves themselves PRON crl-14716 36 16 in in ADP crl-14716 36 17 this this DET crl-14716 36 18 debate debate NOUN crl-14716 36 19 and and CCONJ crl-14716 36 20 to to ADP crl-14716 36 21 what what DET crl-14716 36 22 extent extent NOUN crl-14716 36 23 different different ADJ crl-14716 36 24 types type NOUN crl-14716 36 25 of of ADP crl-14716 36 26 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 36 27 hold hold VERB crl-14716 36 28 different different ADJ crl-14716 36 29 views view NOUN crl-14716 36 30 about about ADP crl-14716 36 31 user user NOUN crl-14716 36 32 education education NOUN crl-14716 36 33 . . PUNCT crl-14716 37 1 the the DET crl-14716 37 2 study study NOUN crl-14716 37 3 reported report VERB crl-14716 37 4 here here ADV crl-14716 37 5 was be AUX crl-14716 37 6 undertaken undertake VERB crl-14716 37 7 in in ADP crl-14716 37 8 order order NOUN crl-14716 37 9 to to PART crl-14716 37 10 identify identify VERB crl-14716 37 11 the the DET crl-14716 37 12 positions position NOUN crl-14716 37 13 on on ADP crl-14716 37 14 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 37 15 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 37 16 that that PRON crl-14716 37 17 exist exist VERB crl-14716 37 18 among among ADP crl-14716 37 19 these these DET crl-14716 37 20 three three NUM crl-14716 37 21 major major ADJ crl-14716 37 22 groups group NOUN crl-14716 37 23 within within ADP crl-14716 37 24 the the DET crl-14716 37 25 library library NOUN crl-14716 37 26 community community NOUN crl-14716 37 27 . . PUNCT crl-14716 38 1 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 38 2 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 38 3 251 251 NUM crl-14716 38 4 tablet tablet NOUN crl-14716 38 5 survey survey NOUN crl-14716 38 6 response response NOUN crl-14716 38 7 rates rate NOUN crl-14716 38 8 mailed mail VERB crl-14716 38 9 out out ADP crl-14716 38 10 returned return VERB crl-14716 38 11 , , PUNCT crl-14716 38 12 wrong wrong ADJ crl-14716 38 13 address address NOUN crl-14716 38 14 returned return VERB crl-14716 38 15 , , PUNCT crl-14716 38 16 useable useable ADJ crl-14716 38 17 response response NOUN crl-14716 38 18 rate rate NOUN crl-14716 38 19 method method NOUN crl-14716 38 20 the the DET crl-14716 38 21 same same ADJ crl-14716 38 22 methodology methodology NOUN crl-14716 38 23 used use VERB crl-14716 38 24 in in ADP crl-14716 38 25 earlier early ADJ crl-14716 38 26 research research NOUN crl-14716 38 27 was be AUX crl-14716 38 28 employed employ VERB crl-14716 38 29 in in ADP crl-14716 38 30 the the DET crl-14716 38 31 present present ADJ crl-14716 38 32 investigation investigation NOUN crl-14716 38 33 . . PUNCT crl-14716 39 1 in in ADP crl-14716 39 2 the the DET crl-14716 39 3 original original ADJ crl-14716 39 4 study study NOUN crl-14716 39 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 39 6 a a DET crl-14716 39 7 three three NUM crl-14716 39 8 - - PUNCT crl-14716 39 9 page page NOUN crl-14716 39 10 questionnaire questionnaire NOUN crl-14716 39 11 was be AUX crl-14716 39 12 sent send VERB crl-14716 39 13 to to ADP crl-14716 39 14 a a DET crl-14716 39 15 random random ADJ crl-14716 39 16 sample sample NOUN crl-14716 39 17 of of ADP crl-14716 39 18 members member NOUN crl-14716 39 19 of of ADP crl-14716 39 20 the the DET crl-14716 39 21 canadian canadian ADJ crl-14716 39 22 association association PROPN crl-14716 39 23 of of ADP crl-14716 39 24 public public ADJ crl-14716 39 25 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 39 26 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 39 27 capl capl NOUN crl-14716 39 28 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 39 29 . . PUNCT crl-14716 40 1 in in ADP crl-14716 40 2 this this DET crl-14716 40 3 study study NOUN crl-14716 40 4 , , PUNCT crl-14716 40 5 a a DET crl-14716 40 6 questionnaire questionnaire NOUN crl-14716 40 7 with with ADP crl-14716 40 8 minor minor ADJ crl-14716 40 9 modifications modification NOUN crl-14716 40 10 for for ADP crl-14716 40 11 each each DET crl-14716 40 12 group group NOUN crl-14716 40 13 of of ADP crl-14716 40 14 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 40 15 was be AUX crl-14716 40 16 sent send VERB crl-14716 40 17 to to ADP crl-14716 40 18 random random ADJ crl-14716 40 19 samples sample NOUN crl-14716 40 20 of of ADP crl-14716 40 21 members member NOUN crl-14716 40 22 of of ADP crl-14716 40 23 the the DET crl-14716 40 24 canadian canadian ADJ crl-14716 40 25 association association PROPN crl-14716 40 26 of of ADP crl-14716 40 27 college college PROPN crl-14716 40 28 and and CCONJ crl-14716 40 29 university university NOUN crl-14716 40 30 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 40 31 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 40 32 cacul cacul PROPN crl-14716 40 33 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 40 34 and and CCONJ crl-14716 40 35 the the DET crl-14716 40 36 canadian canadian ADJ crl-14716 40 37 association association PROPN crl-14716 40 38 of of ADP crl-14716 40 39 special special ADJ crl-14716 40 40 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 40 41 and and CCONJ crl-14716 40 42 information information NOUN crl-14716 40 43 services service NOUN crl-14716 40 44 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 40 45 caslis caslis PROPN crl-14716 40 46 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 40 47 . . PUNCT crl-14716 41 1 the the DET crl-14716 41 2 questionnaire questionnaire NOUN crl-14716 41 3 responses response NOUN crl-14716 41 4 from from ADP crl-14716 41 5 all all DET crl-14716 41 6 three three NUM crl-14716 41 7 groups group NOUN crl-14716 41 8 were be AUX crl-14716 41 9 then then ADV crl-14716 41 10 compared compare VERB crl-14716 41 11 . . PUNCT crl-14716 42 1 12 12 NUM crl-14716 42 2 sample sample NOUN crl-14716 42 3 in in ADP crl-14716 42 4 the the DET crl-14716 42 5 original original ADJ crl-14716 42 6 study study NOUN crl-14716 42 7 , , PUNCT crl-14716 42 8 the the DET crl-14716 42 9 names name NOUN crl-14716 42 10 of of ADP crl-14716 42 11 310 310 NUM crl-14716 42 12 capl capl NOUN crl-14716 42 13 members member NOUN crl-14716 42 14 were be AUX crl-14716 42 15 randomly randomly ADV crl-14716 42 16 selected select VERB crl-14716 42 17 from from ADP crl-14716 42 18 the the DET crl-14716 42 19 1987 1987 NUM crl-14716 42 20 canadian canadian ADJ crl-14716 42 21 library library NOUN crl-14716 42 22 association association PROPN crl-14716 42 23 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 42 24 cla cla PROPN crl-14716 42 25 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 42 26 membership membership NOUN crl-14716 42 27 directory directory NOUN crl-14716 42 28 . . PUNCT crl-14716 43 1 the the DET crl-14716 43 2 sample sample NOUN crl-14716 43 3 excluded exclude VERB crl-14716 43 4 students student NOUN crl-14716 43 5 and and CCONJ crl-14716 43 6 retired retire VERB crl-14716 43 7 association association NOUN crl-14716 43 8 members member NOUN crl-14716 43 9 to to PART crl-14716 43 10 ensure ensure VERB crl-14716 43 11 that that SCONJ crl-14716 43 12 only only ADV crl-14716 43 13 practicing practice VERB crl-14716 43 14 librarians librarians PROPN crl-14716 43 15 were be AUX crl-14716 43 16 included include VERB crl-14716 43 17 in in ADP crl-14716 43 18 the the DET crl-14716 43 19 study study NOUN crl-14716 43 20 . . PUNCT crl-14716 44 1 in in ADP crl-14716 44 2 the the DET crl-14716 44 3 present present ADJ crl-14716 44 4 study study NOUN crl-14716 44 5 the the DET crl-14716 44 6 same same ADJ crl-14716 44 7 procedure procedure NOUN crl-14716 44 8 was be AUX crl-14716 44 9 used use VERB crl-14716 44 10 to to PART crl-14716 44 11 select select VERB crl-14716 44 12 249 249 NUM crl-14716 44 13 cas cas ADJ crl-14716 44 14 lis lis ADJ crl-14716 44 15 members member NOUN crl-14716 44 16 and and CCONJ crl-14716 44 17 250 250 NUM crl-14716 44 18 cacul cacul PROPN crl-14716 44 19 members member NOUN crl-14716 44 20 from from ADP crl-14716 44 21 the the DET crl-14716 44 22 listings listing NOUN crl-14716 44 23 in in ADP crl-14716 44 24 the the DET crl-14716 44 25 cla cla PROPN crl-14716 44 26 directory directory NOUN crl-14716 44 27 . . PUNCT crl-14716 45 1 see see VERB crl-14716 45 2 table table NOUN crl-14716 45 3 1 1 NUM crl-14716 45 4 for for ADP crl-14716 45 5 response response NOUN crl-14716 45 6 rates rate NOUN crl-14716 45 7 . . PUNCT crl-14716 46 1 questionnaire questionnaire NOUN crl-14716 46 2 . . PUNCT crl-14716 47 1 the the DET crl-14716 47 2 questionnaire questionnaire NOUN crl-14716 47 3 used use VERB crl-14716 47 4 in in ADP crl-14716 47 5 the the DET crl-14716 47 6 original original ADJ crl-14716 47 7 study study NOUN crl-14716 47 8 included include VERB crl-14716 47 9 questions question NOUN crl-14716 47 10 about about ADP crl-14716 47 11 the the DET crl-14716 47 12 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 47 13 ' ' PART crl-14716 47 14 work work NOUN crl-14716 47 15 setting setting NOUN crl-14716 47 16 , , PUNCT crl-14716 47 17 several several ADJ crl-14716 47 18 openended openende VERB crl-14716 47 19 questions question NOUN crl-14716 47 20 about about ADP crl-14716 47 21 their their PRON crl-14716 47 22 understanding understanding NOUN crl-14716 47 23 of of ADP crl-14716 47 24 user user NOUN crl-14716 47 25 education education NOUN crl-14716 47 26 or or CCONJ crl-14716 47 27 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 47 28 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 47 29 , , PUNCT crl-14716 47 30 their their PRON crl-14716 47 31 experience experience NOUN crl-14716 47 32 and and CCONJ crl-14716 47 33 training training NOUN crl-14716 47 34 in in ADP crl-14716 47 35 user user NOUN crl-14716 47 36 education education NOUN crl-14716 47 37 , , PUNCT crl-14716 47 38 and and CCONJ crl-14716 47 39 their their PRON crl-14716 47 40 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 47 41 ' ' PART crl-14716 47 42 instructional instructional ADJ crl-14716 47 43 policy policy NOUN crl-14716 47 44 . . PUNCT crl-14716 48 1 the the DET crl-14716 48 2 questionnaire questionnaire NOUN crl-14716 48 3 also also ADV crl-14716 48 4 included include VERB crl-14716 48 5 a a DET crl-14716 48 6 set set NOUN crl-14716 48 7 of of ADP crl-14716 48 8 statements statement NOUN crl-14716 48 9 derived derive VERB crl-14716 48 10 from from ADP crl-14716 48 11 articles article NOUN crl-14716 48 12 type type NOUN crl-14716 48 13 of of ADP crl-14716 48 14 librarian librarian ADJ crl-14716 48 15 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 48 16 public public ADJ crl-14716 48 17 special special ADJ crl-14716 48 18 250 250 NUM crl-14716 48 19 310 310 NUM crl-14716 48 20 249 249 NUM crl-14716 48 21 13 13 NUM crl-14716 48 22 28 28 NUM crl-14716 48 23 33 33 NUM crl-14716 48 24 91 91 NUM crl-14716 48 25 120 120 NUM crl-14716 48 26 77 77 NUM crl-14716 48 27 38 38 NUM crl-14716 48 28 % % NOUN crl-14716 48 29 43 43 NUM crl-14716 48 30 % % NOUN crl-14716 48 31 36 36 NUM crl-14716 48 32 % % NOUN crl-14716 48 33 about about ADP crl-14716 48 34 the the DET crl-14716 48 35 information information NOUN crl-14716 48 36 - - PUNCT crl-14716 48 37 versus versus NOUN crl-14716 48 38 - - PUNCT crl-14716 48 39 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 48 40 debate debate NOUN crl-14716 48 41 with with ADP crl-14716 48 42 which which PRON crl-14716 48 43 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 48 44 were be AUX crl-14716 48 45 asked ask VERB crl-14716 48 46 to to PART crl-14716 48 47 agree agree VERB crl-14716 48 48 or or CCONJ crl-14716 48 49 disagree disagree VERB crl-14716 48 50 using use VERB crl-14716 48 51 a a DET crl-14716 48 52 7 7 NUM crl-14716 48 53 - - PUNCT crl-14716 48 54 point point NOUN crl-14716 48 55 scale scale NOUN crl-14716 48 56 in in ADP crl-14716 48 57 which which PRON crl-14716 48 58 a a DET crl-14716 48 59 score score NOUN crl-14716 48 60 of of ADP crl-14716 48 61 " " PUNCT crl-14716 48 62 7 7 NUM crl-14716 48 63 " " PUNCT crl-14716 48 64 indicated indicate VERB crl-14716 48 65 strong strong ADJ crl-14716 48 66 agreement agreement NOUN crl-14716 48 67 and and CCONJ crl-14716 48 68 a a DET crl-14716 48 69 score score NOUN crl-14716 48 70 of of ADP crl-14716 48 71 " " PUNCT crl-14716 48 72 1 1 NUM crl-14716 48 73 " " PUNCT crl-14716 48 74 indicated indicate VERB crl-14716 48 75 strong strong ADJ crl-14716 48 76 disagreement disagreement NOUN crl-14716 48 77 . . PUNCT crl-14716 49 1 each each PRON crl-14716 49 2 of of ADP crl-14716 49 3 these these DET crl-14716 49 4 statements statement NOUN crl-14716 49 5 was be AUX crl-14716 49 6 created create VERB crl-14716 49 7 in in ADP crl-14716 49 8 order order NOUN crl-14716 49 9 to to PART crl-14716 49 10 express express VERB crl-14716 49 11 the the DET crl-14716 49 12 different different ADJ crl-14716 49 13 points point NOUN crl-14716 49 14 of of ADP crl-14716 49 15 view view NOUN crl-14716 49 16 expressed express VERB crl-14716 49 17 in in ADP crl-14716 49 18 the the DET crl-14716 49 19 debate debate NOUN crl-14716 49 20 . . PUNCT crl-14716 50 1 for for ADP crl-14716 50 2 instance instance NOUN crl-14716 50 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 50 4 one one NUM crl-14716 50 5 of of ADP crl-14716 50 6 the the DET crl-14716 50 7 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 50 8 - - PUNCT crl-14716 50 9 oriented orient VERB crl-14716 50 10 statements statement NOUN crl-14716 50 11 declares declare VERB crl-14716 50 12 that that SCONJ crl-14716 50 13 " " PUNCT crl-14716 50 14 the the DET crl-14716 50 15 primary primary ADJ crl-14716 50 16 goal goal NOUN crl-14716 50 17 of of ADP crl-14716 50 18 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 50 19 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 50 20 in in ADP crl-14716 50 21 public public ADJ crl-14716 50 22 [ [ X crl-14716 50 23 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 50 24 or or CCONJ crl-14716 50 25 special special ADJ crl-14716 50 26 ] ] PUNCT crl-14716 50 27 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 50 28 should should AUX crl-14716 50 29 be be AUX crl-14716 50 30 to to PART crl-14716 50 31 help help VERB crl-14716 50 32 people people NOUN crl-14716 50 33 become become VERB crl-14716 50 34 independent independent ADJ crl-14716 50 35 users user NOUN crl-14716 50 36 of of ADP crl-14716 50 37 the the DET crl-14716 50 38 library library NOUN crl-14716 50 39 . . PUNCT crl-14716 50 40 " " PUNCT crl-14716 51 1 the the DET crl-14716 51 2 type type NOUN crl-14716 51 3 of of ADP crl-14716 51 4 library library NOUN crl-14716 51 5 identified identify VERB crl-14716 51 6 in in ADP crl-14716 51 7 each each PRON crl-14716 51 8 of of ADP crl-14716 51 9 these these DET crl-14716 51 10 statements statement NOUN crl-14716 51 11 was be AUX crl-14716 51 12 specific specific ADJ crl-14716 51 13 to to ADP crl-14716 51 14 the the DET crl-14716 51 15 particular particular ADJ crl-14716 51 16 respondent respondent NOUN crl-14716 51 17 group group NOUN crl-14716 51 18 . . PUNCT crl-14716 52 1 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 52 2 librarians librarians PROPN crl-14716 52 3 were be AUX crl-14716 52 4 asked ask VERB crl-14716 52 5 to to PART crl-14716 52 6 indicate indicate VERB crl-14716 52 7 the the DET crl-14716 52 8 degree degree NOUN crl-14716 52 9 to to PART crl-14716 52 10 which which PRON crl-14716 52 11 they they PRON crl-14716 52 12 agreed agree VERB crl-14716 52 13 or or CCONJ crl-14716 52 14 disagreed disagree VERB crl-14716 52 15 with with ADP crl-14716 52 16 each each DET crl-14716 52 17 statement statement NOUN crl-14716 52 18 vis vi VERB crl-14716 52 19 - - PUNCT crl-14716 52 20 a a DET crl-14716 52 21 - - PUNCT crl-14716 52 22 vis vis X crl-14716 52 23 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 52 24 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 52 25 and and CCONJ crl-14716 52 26 special special ADJ crl-14716 52 27 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 52 28 with with ADP crl-14716 52 29 respect respect NOUN crl-14716 52 30 to to ADP crl-14716 52 31 special special ADJ crl-14716 52 32 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 52 33 . . PUNCT crl-14716 53 1 results result NOUN crl-14716 53 2 respondent respondent VERB crl-14716 53 3 characteristics characteristic VERB crl-14716 53 4 the the DET crl-14716 53 5 level level NOUN crl-14716 53 6 of of ADP crl-14716 53 7 experience experience NOUN crl-14716 53 8 and and CCONJ crl-14716 53 9 professional professional ADJ crl-14716 53 10 training training NOUN crl-14716 53 11 of of ADP crl-14716 53 12 the the DET crl-14716 53 13 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 53 14 who who PRON crl-14716 53 15 participated participate VERB crl-14716 53 16 in in ADP crl-14716 53 17 the the DET crl-14716 53 18 study study NOUN crl-14716 53 19 was be AUX crl-14716 53 20 comparable comparable ADJ crl-14716 53 21 across across ADP crl-14716 53 22 the the DET crl-14716 53 23 three three NUM crl-14716 53 24 groups group NOUN crl-14716 53 25 . . PUNCT crl-14716 54 1 in in ADP crl-14716 54 2 fact fact NOUN crl-14716 54 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 54 4 a a DET crl-14716 54 5 one one NUM crl-14716 54 6 - - PUNCT crl-14716 54 7 way way NOUN crl-14716 54 8 analysis analysis NOUN crl-14716 54 9 of of ADP crl-14716 54 10 variance variance NOUN crl-14716 54 11 revealed reveal VERB crl-14716 54 12 that that SCONJ crl-14716 54 13 there there PRON crl-14716 54 14 was be VERB crl-14716 54 15 no no DET crl-14716 54 16 significant significant ADJ crl-14716 54 17 difference difference NOUN crl-14716 54 18 in in ADP crl-14716 54 19 the the DET crl-14716 54 20 years year NOUN crl-14716 54 21 of of ADP crl-14716 54 22 working work VERB crl-14716 54 23 experience experience NOUN crl-14716 54 24 of of ADP crl-14716 54 25 the the DET crl-14716 54 26 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 54 27 , , PUNCT crl-14716 54 28 special special ADJ crl-14716 54 29 , , PUNCT crl-14716 54 30 and and CCONJ crl-14716 54 31 public public ADJ crl-14716 54 32 library library NOUN crl-14716 54 33 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 54 34 and and CCONJ crl-14716 54 35 , , PUNCT crl-14716 54 36 in in ADP crl-14716 54 37 terms term NOUN crl-14716 54 38 of of ADP crl-14716 54 39 their their PRON crl-14716 54 40 experience experience NOUN crl-14716 54 41 in in ADP crl-14716 54 42 delivering deliver VERB crl-14716 54 43 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 54 44 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 54 45 , , PUNCT crl-14716 54 46 the the DET crl-14716 54 47 groups group NOUN crl-14716 54 48 were be AUX crl-14716 54 49 remarkably remarkably ADV crl-14716 54 50 similar similar ADJ crl-14716 54 51 . . PUNCT crl-14716 55 1 as as ADP crl-14716 55 2 table table NOUN crl-14716 55 3 2 2 NUM crl-14716 55 4 shows show NOUN crl-14716 55 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 55 6 nearly nearly ADV crl-14716 55 7 all all DET crl-14716 55 8 the the DET crl-14716 55 9 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 55 10 had have AUX crl-14716 55 11 conducted conduct VERB crl-14716 55 12 some some DET crl-14716 55 13 user user NOUN crl-14716 55 14 education education NOUN crl-14716 55 15 , , PUNCT crl-14716 55 16 especially especially ADV crl-14716 55 17 one one NUM crl-14716 55 18 - - PUNCT crl-14716 55 19 to to ADP crl-14716 55 20 - - PUNCT crl-14716 55 21 one one NUM crl-14716 55 22 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 55 23 with with ADP crl-14716 55 24 library library NOUN crl-14716 55 25 patrons patron NOUN crl-14716 55 26 . . PUNCT crl-14716 56 1 and and CCONJ crl-14716 56 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 56 3 while while SCONJ crl-14716 56 4 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 56 5 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 56 6 were be AUX crl-14716 56 7 somewhat somewhat ADV crl-14716 56 8 more more ADV crl-14716 56 9 likely likely ADJ crl-14716 56 10 to to PART crl-14716 56 11 have have AUX crl-14716 56 12 reported report VERB crl-14716 56 13 that that SCONJ crl-14716 56 14 they they PRON crl-14716 56 15 had have AUX crl-14716 56 16 given give VERB crl-14716 56 17 group group NOUN crl-14716 56 18 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 56 19 , , PUNCT crl-14716 56 20 a a DET crl-14716 56 21 surpris252 surpris252 PROPN crl-14716 56 22 college college PROPN crl-14716 56 23 & & CCONJ crl-14716 56 24 research research PROPN crl-14716 56 25 libraries librarie VERB crl-14716 56 26 may1992 may1992 ADJ crl-14716 56 27 table2 table2 PROPN crl-14716 56 28 respondent respondent NOUN crl-14716 56 29 characteristics characteristic NOUN crl-14716 56 30 type type NOUN crl-14716 56 31 of of ADP crl-14716 56 32 librarian librarian ADJ crl-14716 56 33 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 56 34 public public ADJ crl-14716 56 35 special special ADJ crl-14716 56 36 female female ADJ crl-14716 56 37 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 56 38 67 67 NUM crl-14716 56 39 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 40 77 77 NUM crl-14716 56 41 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 42 87 87 NUM crl-14716 56 43 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 44 mean mean ADJ crl-14716 56 45 years year NOUN crl-14716 56 46 experience experience VERB crl-14716 56 47 15.32 15.32 NUM crl-14716 56 48 13.57 13.57 NUM crl-14716 56 49 12.42 12.42 NUM crl-14716 56 50 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 56 51 standard standard ADJ crl-14716 56 52 deviation deviation NOUN crl-14716 56 53 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 56 54 7.67 7.67 NUM crl-14716 56 55 8.03 8.03 NUM crl-14716 56 56 8.28 8.28 NUM crl-14716 56 57 number number NOUN crl-14716 56 58 without without ADP crl-14716 56 59 graduate graduate NOUN crl-14716 56 60 degrees degree NOUN crl-14716 56 61 2 2 NUM crl-14716 56 62 2 2 NUM crl-14716 56 63 4 4 NUM crl-14716 56 64 library library NOUN crl-14716 56 65 collection collection NOUN crl-14716 56 66 greater great ADJ crl-14716 56 67 than than ADP crl-14716 56 68 100,000 100,000 NUM crl-14716 56 69 volumes volume NOUN crl-14716 56 70 100 100 NUM crl-14716 56 71 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 72 * * NOUN crl-14716 56 73 63 63 NUM crl-14716 56 74 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 75 38 38 NUM crl-14716 56 76 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 77 public public ADJ crl-14716 56 78 services service NOUN crl-14716 56 79 component component NOUN crl-14716 56 80 to to ADP crl-14716 56 81 current current ADJ crl-14716 56 82 job job NOUN crl-14716 56 83 80 80 NUM crl-14716 56 84 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 85 57 57 NUM crl-14716 56 86 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 87 100 100 NUM crl-14716 56 88 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 89 experience experience NOUN crl-14716 56 90 with with ADP crl-14716 56 91 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 56 92 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 56 93 100 100 NUM crl-14716 56 94 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 95 90 90 NUM crl-14716 56 96 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 97 93 93 NUM crl-14716 56 98 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 99 individual individual ADJ crl-14716 56 100 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 56 101 87 87 NUM crl-14716 56 102 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 103 86 86 NUM crl-14716 56 104 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 105 82 82 NUM crl-14716 56 106 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 107 group group NOUN crl-14716 56 108 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 56 109 , , PUNCT crl-14716 56 110 tours tour NOUN crl-14716 56 111 80 80 NUM crl-14716 56 112 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 113 77 77 NUM crl-14716 56 114 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 115 65 65 NUM crl-14716 56 116 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 117 formal formal ADJ crl-14716 56 118 lectures lecture VERB crl-14716 56 119 47 47 NUM crl-14716 56 120 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 121 9 9 NUM crl-14716 56 122 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 123 9 9 NUM crl-14716 56 124 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 125 developed develop VERB crl-14716 56 126 instructional instructional ADJ crl-14716 56 127 materials material NOUN crl-14716 56 128 5 5 NUM crl-14716 56 129 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 130 7 7 NUM crl-14716 56 131 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 132 3 3 NUM crl-14716 56 133 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 134 trained train VERB crl-14716 56 135 in in ADP crl-14716 56 136 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 56 137 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 56 138 59 59 NUM crl-14716 56 139 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 140 31 31 NUM crl-14716 56 141 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 142 29 29 NUM crl-14716 56 143 % % NOUN crl-14716 56 144 training training NOUN crl-14716 56 145 received receive VERB crl-14716 56 146 in in ADP crl-14716 56 147 library library NOUN crl-14716 56 148 school+ school+ PUNCT crl-14716 57 1 12 12 NUM crl-14716 57 2 % % NOUN crl-14716 57 3 45 45 NUM crl-14716 57 4 % % NOUN crl-14716 57 5 30 30 NUM crl-14716 57 6 % % NOUN crl-14716 57 7 library library NOUN crl-14716 57 8 has have VERB crl-14716 57 9 policy policy NOUN crl-14716 57 10 on on ADP crl-14716 57 11 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 57 12 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 57 13 62 62 NUM crl-14716 57 14 % % NOUN crl-14716 57 15 24 24 NUM crl-14716 57 16 % % NOUN crl-14716 57 17 25 25 NUM crl-14716 57 18 % % NOUN crl-14716 57 19 • • NUM crl-14716 57 20 these these DET crl-14716 57 21 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 57 22 work work VERB crl-14716 57 23 in in ADP crl-14716 57 24 university university NOUN crl-14716 57 25 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 57 26 that that PRON crl-14716 57 27 tend tend VERB crl-14716 57 28 to to PART crl-14716 57 29 be be AUX crl-14716 57 30 lar lar ADJ crl-14716 57 31 ~ ~ SYM crl-14716 57 32 e e X crl-14716 57 33 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 57 34 i.e. i.e. X crl-14716 57 35 , , PUNCT crl-14716 57 36 with with ADP crl-14716 57 37 holdings holding NOUN crl-14716 57 38 in in ADP crl-14716 57 39 excess excess NOUN crl-14716 57 40 of of ADP crl-14716 57 41 100,000 100,000 NUM crl-14716 57 42 volumes volume NOUN crl-14716 57 43 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 57 44 . . PUNCT crl-14716 58 1 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 58 2 working work VERB crl-14716 58 3 in in ADP crl-14716 58 4 smaller small ADJ crl-14716 58 5 college college NOUN crl-14716 58 6 libranes librane NOUN crl-14716 58 7 were be AUX crl-14716 58 8 excluded exclude VERB crl-14716 58 9 from from ADP crl-14716 58 10 the the DET crl-14716 58 11 study study NOUN crl-14716 58 12 since since SCONJ crl-14716 58 13 the the DET crl-14716 58 14 term term NOUN crl-14716 58 15 college college NOUN crl-14716 58 16 in in ADP crl-14716 58 17 canada canada PROPN crl-14716 58 18 often often ADV crl-14716 58 19 refers refer VERB crl-14716 58 20 to to ADP crl-14716 58 21 two two NUM crl-14716 58 22 - - PUNCT crl-14716 58 23 year year NOUN crl-14716 58 24 postsecondary postsecondary ADJ crl-14716 58 25 educational educational ADJ crl-14716 58 26 institutions institution NOUN crl-14716 58 27 in in ADP crl-14716 58 28 which which PRON crl-14716 58 29 the the DET crl-14716 58 30 emphasis emphasis NOUN crl-14716 58 31 is be AUX crl-14716 58 32 on on ADP crl-14716 58 33 technical technical ADJ crl-14716 58 34 rather rather ADV crl-14716 58 35 than than ADP crl-14716 58 36 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 58 37 fields field NOUN crl-14716 58 38 of of ADP crl-14716 58 39 study study NOUN crl-14716 58 40 . . PUNCT crl-14716 59 1 t t PROPN crl-14716 59 2 refers refer VERB crl-14716 59 3 only only ADV crl-14716 59 4 to to ADP crl-14716 59 5 those those DET crl-14716 59 6 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 59 7 who who PRON crl-14716 59 8 indicated indicate VERB crl-14716 59 9 that that SCONJ crl-14716 59 10 they they PRON crl-14716 59 11 had have AUX crl-14716 59 12 actually actually ADV crl-14716 59 13 received receive VERB crl-14716 59 14 some some DET crl-14716 59 15 form form NOUN crl-14716 59 16 of of ADP crl-14716 59 17 training training NOUN crl-14716 59 18 . . PUNCT crl-14716 60 1 ingly ingly ADV crl-14716 60 2 high high ADJ crl-14716 60 3 number number NOUN crl-14716 60 4 of of ADP crl-14716 60 5 public public ADJ crl-14716 60 6 and and CCONJ crl-14716 60 7 special special ADJ crl-14716 60 8 library library NOUN crl-14716 60 9 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 60 10 had have AUX crl-14716 60 11 also also ADV crl-14716 60 12 given give VERB crl-14716 60 13 library library NOUN crl-14716 60 14 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 60 15 to to ADP crl-14716 60 16 groups group NOUN crl-14716 60 17 including include VERB crl-14716 60 18 orientation orientation NOUN crl-14716 60 19 groups group NOUN crl-14716 60 20 , , PUNCT crl-14716 60 21 library library NOUN crl-14716 60 22 tours tour NOUN crl-14716 60 23 , , PUNCT crl-14716 60 24 and and CCONJ crl-14716 60 25 group group NOUN crl-14716 60 26 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 60 27 in in ADP crl-14716 60 28 the the DET crl-14716 60 29 use use NOUN crl-14716 60 30 of of ADP crl-14716 60 31 particular particular ADJ crl-14716 60 32 tools tool NOUN crl-14716 60 33 . . PUNCT crl-14716 61 1 the the DET crl-14716 61 2 major major ADJ crl-14716 61 3 difference difference NOUN crl-14716 61 4 , , PUNCT crl-14716 61 5 however however ADV crl-14716 61 6 , , PUNCT crl-14716 61 7 between between ADP crl-14716 61 8 the the DET crl-14716 61 9 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 61 10 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 61 11 and and CCONJ crl-14716 61 12 the the DET crl-14716 61 13 other other ADJ crl-14716 61 14 two two NUM crl-14716 61 15 groups group NOUN crl-14716 61 16 was be AUX crl-14716 61 17 with with ADP crl-14716 61 18 respect respect NOUN crl-14716 61 19 to to ADP crl-14716 61 20 formal formal ADJ crl-14716 61 21 , , PUNCT crl-14716 61 22 classroom classroom NOUN crl-14716 61 23 - - PUNCT crl-14716 61 24 type type NOUN crl-14716 61 25 lectures lecture NOUN crl-14716 61 26 . . PUNCT crl-14716 62 1 nearly nearly ADV crl-14716 62 2 half half NOUN crl-14716 62 3 of of ADP crl-14716 62 4 the the DET crl-14716 62 5 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 62 6 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 62 7 reported report VERB crl-14716 62 8 that that SCONJ crl-14716 62 9 they they PRON crl-14716 62 10 had have AUX crl-14716 62 11 done do VERB crl-14716 62 12 some some DET crl-14716 62 13 teaching teaching NOUN crl-14716 62 14 of of ADP crl-14716 62 15 this this DET crl-14716 62 16 sort sort NOUN crl-14716 62 17 , , PUNCT crl-14716 62 18 while while SCONJ crl-14716 62 19 very very ADV crl-14716 62 20 few few ADJ crl-14716 62 21 of of ADP crl-14716 62 22 the the DET crl-14716 62 23 public public ADJ crl-14716 62 24 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 62 25 or or CCONJ crl-14716 62 26 special special ADJ crl-14716 62 27 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 62 28 indicated indicate VERB crl-14716 62 29 that that SCONJ crl-14716 62 30 they they PRON crl-14716 62 31 had have AUX crl-14716 62 32 had have VERB crl-14716 62 33 this this DET crl-14716 62 34 type type NOUN crl-14716 62 35 of of ADP crl-14716 62 36 experience experience NOUN crl-14716 62 37 in in ADP crl-14716 62 38 their their PRON crl-14716 62 39 current current ADJ crl-14716 62 40 work work NOUN crl-14716 62 41 settings setting NOUN crl-14716 62 42 . . PUNCT crl-14716 63 1 it it PRON crl-14716 63 2 is be AUX crl-14716 63 3 noteworthy noteworthy ADJ crl-14716 63 4 that that SCONJ crl-14716 63 5 although although SCONJ crl-14716 63 6 most most ADJ crl-14716 63 7 of of ADP crl-14716 63 8 the the DET crl-14716 63 9 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 63 10 who who PRON crl-14716 63 11 participated participate VERB crl-14716 63 12 in in ADP crl-14716 63 13 the the DET crl-14716 63 14 study study NOUN crl-14716 63 15 had have AUX crl-14716 63 16 delivered deliver VERB crl-14716 63 17 some some DET crl-14716 63 18 form form NOUN crl-14716 63 19 of of ADP crl-14716 63 20 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 63 21 to to ADP crl-14716 63 22 users user NOUN crl-14716 63 23 , , PUNCT crl-14716 63 24 a a DET crl-14716 63 25 significant significant ADJ crl-14716 63 26 number number NOUN crl-14716 63 27 had have AUX crl-14716 63 28 not not PART crl-14716 63 29 been be AUX crl-14716 63 30 trained train VERB crl-14716 63 31 to to PART crl-14716 63 32 do do VERB crl-14716 63 33 so so ADV crl-14716 63 34 and and CCONJ crl-14716 63 35 worked work VERB crl-14716 63 36 in in ADP crl-14716 63 37 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 63 38 in in ADP crl-14716 63 39 which which PRON crl-14716 63 40 there there PRON crl-14716 63 41 is be VERB crl-14716 63 42 no no DET crl-14716 63 43 policy policy NOUN crl-14716 63 44 with with ADP crl-14716 63 45 regard regard NOUN crl-14716 63 46 to to ADP crl-14716 63 47 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 63 48 . . PUNCT crl-14716 64 1 not not PART crl-14716 64 2 surprisingly surprisingly ADV crl-14716 64 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 64 4 however however ADV crl-14716 64 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 64 6 considerably considerably ADV crl-14716 64 7 more more ADJ crl-14716 64 8 of of ADP crl-14716 64 9 the the DET crl-14716 64 10 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 64 11 who who PRON crl-14716 64 12 worked work VERB crl-14716 64 13 in in ADP crl-14716 64 14 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 64 15 settings setting NOUN crl-14716 64 16 reported report VERB crl-14716 64 17 that that SCONJ crl-14716 64 18 their their PRON crl-14716 64 19 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 64 20 had have VERB crl-14716 64 21 explicit explicit ADJ crl-14716 64 22 policy policy NOUN crl-14716 64 23 statements statement NOUN crl-14716 64 24 on on ADP crl-14716 64 25 user user NOUN crl-14716 64 26 education education NOUN crl-14716 64 27 than than SCONJ crl-14716 64 28 was be AUX crl-14716 64 29 true true ADJ crl-14716 64 30 of of ADP crl-14716 64 31 either either CCONJ crl-14716 64 32 the the DET crl-14716 64 33 public public ADJ crl-14716 64 34 or or CCONJ crl-14716 64 35 special special ADJ crl-14716 64 36 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 64 37 . . PUNCT crl-14716 65 1 beliefs belief NOUN crl-14716 65 2 about about ADP crl-14716 65 3 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 65 4 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 65 5 one one NUM crl-14716 65 6 - - PUNCT crl-14716 65 7 way way NOUN crl-14716 65 8 analyses analysis NOUN crl-14716 65 9 of of ADP crl-14716 65 10 variance variance NOUN crl-14716 65 11 revealed reveal VERB crl-14716 65 12 that that SCONJ crl-14716 65 13 each each PRON crl-14716 65 14 of of ADP crl-14716 65 15 the the DET crl-14716 65 16 statements statement NOUN crl-14716 65 17 concerning concern VERB crl-14716 65 18 the the DET crl-14716 65 19 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 65 20 ' ' PART crl-14716 65 21 beliefs belief NOUN crl-14716 65 22 about about ADP crl-14716 65 23 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 65 24 elicited elicit VERB crl-14716 65 25 significant significant ADJ crl-14716 65 26 differences difference NOUN crl-14716 65 27 between between ADP crl-14716 65 28 the the DET crl-14716 65 29 three three NUM crl-14716 65 30 groups group NOUN crl-14716 65 31 of of ADP crl-14716 65 32 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 65 33 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 65 34 see see VERB crl-14716 65 35 table table NOUN crl-14716 65 36 3 3 NUM crl-14716 65 37 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 65 38 . . PUNCT crl-14716 66 1 without without ADP crl-14716 66 2 exception exception NOUN crl-14716 66 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 66 4 the the DET crl-14716 66 5 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 66 6 and and CCONJ crl-14716 66 7 special special ADJ crl-14716 66 8 librarians librarians PROPN crl-14716 66 9 disagreed disagree VERB crl-14716 66 10 significantly significantly ADV crl-14716 66 11 with with ADP crl-14716 66 12 one one NUM crl-14716 66 13 another another DET crl-14716 66 14 on on ADP crl-14716 66 15 the the DET crl-14716 66 16 statements statement NOUN crl-14716 66 17 about about ADP crl-14716 66 18 user user NOUN crl-14716 66 19 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 66 20 , , PUNCT crl-14716 66 21 while while SCONJ crl-14716 66 22 the the DET crl-14716 66 23 public public NOUN crl-14716 66 24 librarians librarian VERB crl-14716 66 25 nearly nearly ADV crl-14716 66 26 always always ADV crl-14716 66 27 took take VERB crl-14716 66 28 a a DET crl-14716 66 29 position position NOUN crl-14716 66 30 somewhere somewhere ADV crl-14716 66 31 in in ADP crl-14716 66 32 between between ADP crl-14716 66 33 . . PUNCT crl-14716 67 1 it it PRON crl-14716 67 2 is be AUX crl-14716 67 3 perhaps perhaps ADV crl-14716 67 4 not not PART crl-14716 67 5 surprising surprising ADJ crl-14716 67 6 that that SCONJ crl-14716 67 7 the the DET crl-14716 67 8 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 67 9 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 67 10 tended tend VERB crl-14716 67 11 to to PART crl-14716 67 12 endorse endorse VERB crl-14716 67 13 the the DET crl-14716 67 14 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 67 15 - - PUNCT crl-14716 67 16 oriented orient VERB crl-14716 67 17 items item NOUN crl-14716 67 18 while while SCONJ crl-14716 67 19 the the DET crl-14716 67 20 special special ADJ crl-14716 67 21 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 67 22 were be AUX crl-14716 67 23 more more ADV crl-14716 67 24 likely likely ADJ crl-14716 67 25 to to PART crl-14716 67 26 endorse endorse VERB crl-14716 67 27 viewpoints viewpoint NOUN crl-14716 67 28 that that PRON crl-14716 67 29 are be AUX crl-14716 67 30 informationoriented informationoriente VERB crl-14716 67 31 . . PUNCT crl-14716 68 1 thus thus ADV crl-14716 68 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 68 3 for for ADP crl-14716 68 4 example example NOUN crl-14716 68 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 68 6 in in ADP crl-14716 68 7 comparison comparison NOUN crl-14716 68 8 with with ADP crl-14716 68 9 the the DET crl-14716 68 10 public public ADJ crl-14716 68 11 and and CCONJ crl-14716 68 12 special special ADJ crl-14716 68 13 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 68 14 , , PUNCT crl-14716 68 15 the the DET crl-14716 68 16 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 68 17 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 68 18 were be AUX crl-14716 68 19 less less ADJ crl-14716 68 20 in in ADP crl-14716 68 21 agreement agreement NOUN crl-14716 68 22 bibliographic bibliographic NOUN crl-14716 68 23 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 68 24 253 253 NUM crl-14716 68 25 table3 table3 PROPN crl-14716 68 26 beliefs belief NOUN crl-14716 68 27 about about ADP crl-14716 68 28 user user NOUN crl-14716 68 29 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 68 30 : : PUNCT crl-14716 68 31 mean mean PROPN crl-14716 68 32 scores score NOUN crl-14716 68 33 .. .. PUNCT crl-14716 68 34 type type NOUN crl-14716 68 35 of of ADP crl-14716 68 36 librarian librarian ADJ crl-14716 68 37 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 68 38 public public ADJ crl-14716 68 39 special special ADJ crl-14716 68 40 ft ft NOUN crl-14716 68 41 the the DET crl-14716 68 42 primary primary ADJ crl-14716 68 43 goal goal NOUN crl-14716 68 44 of of ADP crl-14716 68 45 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 68 46 should should AUX crl-14716 68 47 be be AUX crl-14716 68 48 to to PART crl-14716 68 49 provide provide VERB crl-14716 68 50 users user NOUN crl-14716 68 51 with with ADP crl-14716 68 52 information information NOUN crl-14716 68 53 . . PUNCT crl-14716 69 1 4.69 4.69 NUM crl-14716 69 2 6.00 6.00 NUM crl-14716 69 3 5.29 5.29 NUM crl-14716 69 4 28.35 28.35 NUM crl-14716 69 5 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 69 6 is be AUX crl-14716 69 7 ' ' PUNCT crl-14716 69 8 appropriate appropriate ADJ crl-14716 69 9 with with ADP crl-14716 69 10 new new ADJ crl-14716 69 11 users user NOUN crl-14716 69 12 . . PUNCT crl-14716 70 1 6.44 6.44 NUM crl-14716 70 2 5.87 5.87 NUM crl-14716 70 3 5.64 5.64 NUM crl-14716 70 4 8.75 8.75 NUM crl-14716 70 5 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 70 6 should should AUX crl-14716 70 7 be be AUX crl-14716 70 8 made make VERB crl-14716 70 9 available available ADJ crl-14716 70 10 only only ADV crl-14716 70 11 when when SCONJ crl-14716 70 12 users user NOUN crl-14716 70 13 request request VERB crl-14716 70 14 it it PRON crl-14716 70 15 . . PUNCT crl-14716 71 1 1.79 1.79 NUM crl-14716 71 2 2.76 2.76 NUM crl-14716 71 3 3.52 3.52 NUM crl-14716 71 4 30.09 30.09 NUM crl-14716 71 5 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 71 6 should should AUX crl-14716 71 7 be be AUX crl-14716 71 8 a a DET crl-14716 71 9 regular regular ADJ crl-14716 71 10 part part NOUN crl-14716 71 11 of of ADP crl-14716 71 12 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 71 13 transactions transaction NOUN crl-14716 71 14 with with ADP crl-14716 71 15 most most ADJ crl-14716 71 16 users user NOUN crl-14716 71 17 . . PUNCT crl-14716 72 1 6.19 6.19 NUM crl-14716 72 2 5.46 5.46 NUM crl-14716 72 3 4.21 4.21 NUM crl-14716 72 4 34.11 34.11 NUM crl-14716 72 5 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 72 6 should should AUX crl-14716 72 7 avoid avoid VERB crl-14716 72 8 spoon spoon NOUN crl-14716 72 9 - - PUNCT crl-14716 72 10 feeding feed VERB crl-14716 72 11 information information NOUN crl-14716 72 12 to to ADP crl-14716 72 13 users user NOUN crl-14716 72 14 . . PUNCT crl-14716 73 1 4.56 4.56 NUM crl-14716 73 2 4.02 4.02 NUM crl-14716 73 3 3.22 3.22 NUM crl-14716 73 4 11.04 11.04 NUM crl-14716 73 5 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 73 6 is be AUX crl-14716 73 7 appropriate appropriate ADJ crl-14716 73 8 for for ADP crl-14716 73 9 most most ADJ crl-14716 73 10 types type NOUN crl-14716 73 11 of of ADP crl-14716 73 12 users user NOUN crl-14716 73 13 . . PUNCT crl-14716 74 1 5.90 5.90 NUM crl-14716 74 2 5.26 5.26 NUM crl-14716 74 3 4.41 4.41 NUM crl-14716 74 4 18.43 18.43 NUM crl-14716 74 5 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 74 6 is be AUX crl-14716 74 7 best well ADV crl-14716 74 8 done do VERB crl-14716 74 9 by by ADP crl-14716 74 10 teaching teach VERB crl-14716 74 11 groups group NOUN crl-14716 74 12 rather rather ADV crl-14716 74 13 than than ADP crl-14716 74 14 individuals individual NOUN crl-14716 74 15 . . PUNCT crl-14716 75 1 2.88 2.88 NUM crl-14716 75 2 2.85 2.85 NUM crl-14716 75 3 3.91 3.91 NUM crl-14716 75 4 18.42 18.42 NUM crl-14716 75 5 the the DET crl-14716 75 6 primary primary ADJ crl-14716 75 7 goal goal NOUN crl-14716 75 8 of of ADP crl-14716 75 9 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 75 10 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 75 11 should should AUX crl-14716 75 12 be be AUX crl-14716 75 13 to to PART crl-14716 75 14 help help VERB crl-14716 75 15 users user NOUN crl-14716 75 16 become become VERB crl-14716 75 17 independent independent ADJ crl-14716 75 18 . . PUNCT crl-14716 76 1 5.59 5.59 NUM crl-14716 76 2 4.37 4.37 NUM crl-14716 76 3 3.61 3.61 NUM crl-14716 76 4 26.38 26.38 NUM crl-14716 76 5 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 76 6 have have VERB crl-14716 76 7 an an DET crl-14716 76 8 obligation obligation NOUN crl-14716 76 9 to to PART crl-14716 76 10 teach teach VERB crl-14716 76 11 users user NOUN crl-14716 76 12 about about ADP crl-14716 76 13 the the DET crl-14716 76 14 correct correct ADJ crl-14716 76 15 use use NOUN crl-14716 76 16 of of ADP crl-14716 76 17 library library NOUN crl-14716 76 18 tools tool NOUN crl-14716 76 19 . . PUNCT crl-14716 77 1 6.18 6.18 NUM crl-14716 77 2 5.43 5.43 NUM crl-14716 77 3 4.18 4.18 NUM crl-14716 77 4 34.69 34.69 NUM crl-14716 77 5 the the DET crl-14716 77 6 teaching teaching NOUN crl-14716 77 7 function function NOUN crl-14716 77 8 of of ADP crl-14716 77 9 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 77 10 is be AUX crl-14716 77 11 as as ADV crl-14716 77 12 important important ADJ crl-14716 77 13 as as ADP crl-14716 77 14 information information NOUN crl-14716 77 15 provision provision NOUN crl-14716 77 16 . . PUNCT crl-14716 78 1 6.02 6.02 NUM crl-14716 78 2 4.15 4.15 NUM crl-14716 78 3 3.76 3.76 NUM crl-14716 78 4 44.38 44.38 NUM crl-14716 78 5 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 78 6 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 78 7 perform perform VERB crl-14716 78 8 similar similar ADJ crl-14716 78 9 work work NOUN crl-14716 78 10 to to ADP crl-14716 78 11 that that PRON crl-14716 78 12 of of ADP crl-14716 78 13 teachers teacher NOUN crl-14716 78 14 . . PUNCT crl-14716 79 1 4.82 4.82 NUM crl-14716 79 2 3.29 3.29 NUM crl-14716 79 3 2.67 2.67 NUM crl-14716 79 4 37.41 37.41 NUM crl-14716 80 1 the the DET crl-14716 80 2 best good ADJ crl-14716 80 3 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 80 4 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 80 5 combine combine VERB crl-14716 80 6 information information NOUN crl-14716 80 7 provision provision NOUN crl-14716 80 8 with with ADP crl-14716 80 9 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 80 10 . . PUNCT crl-14716 81 1 6.61 6.61 NUM crl-14716 81 2 6.03 6.03 NUM crl-14716 81 3 4.91 4.91 NUM crl-14716 81 4 33.20 33.20 NUM crl-14716 81 5 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 81 6 enhances enhance VERB crl-14716 81 7 the the DET crl-14716 81 8 image image NOUN crl-14716 81 9 or or CCONJ crl-14716 81 10 status status NOUN crl-14716 81 11 of of ADP crl-14716 81 12 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 81 13 . . PUNCT crl-14716 82 1 4.13 4.13 NUM crl-14716 82 2 5.53 5.53 NUM crl-14716 82 3 34.55 34.55 NUM crl-14716 82 4 · · NUM crl-14716 82 5 scores score NOUN crl-14716 82 6 ranged range VERB crl-14716 82 7 from from ADP crl-14716 82 8 1 1 NUM crl-14716 82 9 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 82 10 strongly strongly ADV crl-14716 82 11 disagree disagree VERB crl-14716 82 12 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 82 13 to to ADP crl-14716 82 14 7 7 NUM crl-14716 82 15 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 82 16 strongly strongly ADV crl-14716 82 17 agree agree VERB crl-14716 82 18 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 82 19 . . PUNCT crl-14716 83 1 tfor tfor VERB crl-14716 83 2 each each DET crl-14716 83 3 item item NOUN crl-14716 83 4 the the DET crl-14716 83 5 probability probability NOUN crl-14716 83 6 of of ADP crl-14716 83 7 the the DET crl-14716 83 8 f f PROPN crl-14716 83 9 value value NOUN crl-14716 83 10 was be AUX crl-14716 83 11 .0002 .0002 PUNCT crl-14716 83 12 or or CCONJ crl-14716 83 13 less less ADJ crl-14716 83 14 . . PUNCT crl-14716 84 1 * * PUNCT crl-14716 84 2 item item NOUN crl-14716 84 3 not not PART crl-14716 84 4 included include VERB crl-14716 84 5 in in ADP crl-14716 84 6 original original ADJ crl-14716 84 7 survey survey NOUN crl-14716 84 8 of of ADP crl-14716 84 9 public public ADJ crl-14716 84 10 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 84 11 . . PUNCT crl-14716 85 1 with with ADP crl-14716 85 2 the the DET crl-14716 85 3 statement statement NOUN crl-14716 85 4 that that SCONJ crl-14716 85 5 the the DET crl-14716 85 6 primary primary ADJ crl-14716 85 7 goal goal NOUN crl-14716 85 8 of of ADP crl-14716 85 9 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 85 10 libraria libraria PROPN crl-14716 85 11 ~ ~ NOUN crl-14716 85 12 s s PRON crl-14716 85 13 should should AUX crl-14716 85 14 be be AUX crl-14716 85 15 to to PART crl-14716 85 16 provide provide VERB crl-14716 85 17 users user NOUN crl-14716 85 18 with with ADP crl-14716 85 19 information information NOUN crl-14716 85 20 and and CCONJ crl-14716 85 21 more more ADV crl-14716 85 22 strongly strongly ADV crl-14716 85 23 endorsed endorse VERB crl-14716 85 24 the the DET crl-14716 85 25 position position NOUN crl-14716 85 26 that that SCONJ crl-14716 85 27 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 85 28 is be AUX crl-14716 85 29 appropriate appropriate ADJ crl-14716 85 30 for for ADP crl-14716 85 31 new new ADJ crl-14716 85 32 users user NOUN crl-14716 85 33 and and CCONJ crl-14716 85 34 that that SCONJ crl-14716 85 35 the the DET crl-14716 85 36 teaching teaching NOUN crl-14716 85 37 function function NOUN crl-14716 85 38 of of ADP crl-14716 85 39 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 85 40 work work NOUN crl-14716 85 41 is be AUX crl-14716 85 42 as as ADV crl-14716 85 43 important important ADJ crl-14716 85 44 as as ADP crl-14716 85 45 information information NOUN crl-14716 85 46 provision provision NOUN crl-14716 85 47 . . PUNCT crl-14716 86 1 special special ADJ crl-14716 86 2 librarians librarians PROPN crl-14716 86 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 86 4 on on ADP crl-14716 86 5 the the DET crl-14716 86 6 other other ADJ crl-14716 86 7 hand hand NOUN crl-14716 86 8 , , PUNCT crl-14716 86 9 more more ADV crl-14716 86 10 strongly strongly ADV crl-14716 86 11 endorsed endorse VERB crl-14716 86 12 the the DET crl-14716 86 13 statement statement NOUN crl-14716 86 14 that that SCONJ crl-14716 86 15 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 86 16 should should AUX crl-14716 86 17 be be AUX crl-14716 86 18 available available ADJ crl-14716 86 19 only only ADV crl-14716 86 20 when when SCONJ crl-14716 86 21 users user NOUN crl-14716 86 22 request request VERB crl-14716 86 23 it it PRON crl-14716 86 24 and and CCONJ crl-14716 86 25 disagreed disagree VERB crl-14716 86 26 more more ADJ crl-14716 86 27 than than ADP crl-14716 86 28 the the DET crl-14716 86 29 other other ADJ crl-14716 86 30 groups group NOUN crl-14716 86 31 that that PRON crl-14716 86 32 librarians librarian VERB crl-14716 86 33 should should AUX crl-14716 86 34 avoid avoid VERB crl-14716 86 35 spoon spoon NOUN crl-14716 86 36 - - PUNCT crl-14716 86 37 feeding feed VERB crl-14716 86 38 users user NOUN crl-14716 86 39 . . PUNCT crl-14716 87 1 despite despite SCONJ crl-14716 87 2 the the DET crl-14716 87 3 special special ADJ crl-14716 87 4 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 87 5 ' ' PART crl-14716 87 6 information information NOUN crl-14716 87 7 - - PUNCT crl-14716 87 8 delivery delivery NOUN crl-14716 87 9 orientation orientation NOUN crl-14716 87 10 , , PUNCT crl-14716 87 11 however however ADV crl-14716 87 12 , , PUNCT crl-14716 87 13 they they PRON crl-14716 87 14 were be AUX crl-14716 87 15 more more ADV crl-14716 87 16 likely likely ADJ crl-14716 87 17 than than ADP crl-14716 87 18 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 87 19 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 87 20 to to PART crl-14716 87 21 endorse endorse VERB crl-14716 87 22 the the DET crl-14716 87 23 notion notion NOUN crl-14716 87 24 that that SCONJ crl-14716 87 25 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 87 26 enhances enhance VERB crl-14716 87 27 the the DET crl-14716 87 28 status status NOUN crl-14716 87 29 of of ADP crl-14716 87 30 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 87 31 . . PUNCT crl-14716 88 1 discussion discussion NOUN crl-14716 88 2 the the DET crl-14716 88 3 results result NOUN crl-14716 88 4 of of ADP crl-14716 88 5 this this DET crl-14716 88 6 investigation investigation NOUN crl-14716 88 7 indi·cated indi·cate VERB crl-14716 88 8 that that PRON crl-14716 88 9 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 88 10 , , PUNCT crl-14716 88 11 public public ADJ crl-14716 88 12 , , PUNCT crl-14716 88 13 and and CCONJ crl-14716 88 14 special special ADJ crl-14716 88 15 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 88 16 with with ADP crl-14716 88 17 similar similar ADJ crl-14716 88 18 levels level NOUN crl-14716 88 19 of of ADP crl-14716 88 20 education education NOUN crl-14716 88 21 and and CCONJ crl-14716 88 22 work work NOUN crl-14716 88 23 experience experience NOUN crl-14716 88 24 have have VERB crl-14716 88 25 very very ADV crl-14716 88 26 dissimilar dissimilar ADJ crl-14716 88 27 views view NOUN crl-14716 88 28 about about ADP crl-14716 88 29 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 88 30 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 88 31 . . PUNCT crl-14716 89 1 on on ADP crl-14716 89 2 the the DET crl-14716 89 3 information information NOUN crl-14716 89 4 - - PUNCT crl-14716 89 5 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 89 6 continuum continuum NOUN crl-14716 89 7 , , PUNCT crl-14716 89 8 the the DET crl-14716 89 9 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 89 10 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 89 11 fall fall VERB crl-14716 89 12 toward toward ADP crl-14716 89 13 the the DET crl-14716 89 14 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 89 15 end end NOUN crl-14716 89 16 and and CCONJ crl-14716 89 17 the the DET crl-14716 89 18 special special ADJ crl-14716 89 19 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 89 20 toward toward ADP crl-14716 89 21 the the DET crl-14716 89 22 information information NOUN crl-14716 89 23 end end NOUN crl-14716 89 24 , , PUNCT crl-14716 89 25 while while SCONJ crl-14716 89 26 the the DET crl-14716 89 27 public public NOUN crl-14716 89 28 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 89 29 fall fall VERB crl-14716 89 30 somewhere somewhere ADV crl-14716 89 31 in in ADP crl-14716 89 32 between between ADP crl-14716 89 33 . . PUNCT crl-14716 90 1 clearly clearly ADV crl-14716 90 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 90 3 then then ADV crl-14716 90 4 , , PUNCT crl-14716 90 5 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 90 6 who who PRON crl-14716 90 7 work work VERB crl-14716 90 8 in in ADP crl-14716 90 9 different different ADJ crl-14716 90 10 settings setting NOUN crl-14716 90 11 tend tend VERB crl-14716 90 12 to to PART crl-14716 90 13 have have VERB crl-14716 90 14 quite quite ADV crl-14716 90 15 different different ADJ crl-14716 90 16 perceptions perception NOUN crl-14716 90 17 254 254 NUM crl-14716 90 18 college college NOUN crl-14716 90 19 & & CCONJ crl-14716 90 20 resea resea NOUN crl-14716 90 21 ~ ~ PUNCT crl-14716 90 22 ch ch NOUN crl-14716 90 23 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 90 24 of of ADP crl-14716 90 25 the the DET crl-14716 90 26 role role NOUN crl-14716 90 27 of of ADP crl-14716 90 28 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 90 29 in in ADP crl-14716 90 30 the the DET crl-14716 90 31 provision provision NOUN crl-14716 90 32 of of ADP crl-14716 90 33 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 90 34 services service NOUN crl-14716 90 35 . . PUNCT crl-14716 91 1 user user NOUN crl-14716 91 2 independence independence NOUN crl-14716 91 3 at at ADP crl-14716 91 4 the the DET crl-14716 91 5 root root NOUN crl-14716 91 6 of of ADP crl-14716 91 7 these these DET crl-14716 91 8 differences difference NOUN crl-14716 91 9 seems seem VERB crl-14716 91 10 to to PART crl-14716 91 11 be be AUX crl-14716 91 12 the the DET crl-14716 91 13 question question NOUN crl-14716 91 14 of of ADP crl-14716 91 15 user user NOUN crl-14716 91 16 independence independence NOUN crl-14716 91 17 . . PUNCT crl-14716 92 1 within within ADP crl-14716 92 2 the the DET crl-14716 92 3 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 92 4 library library NOUN crl-14716 92 5 setting setting NOUN crl-14716 92 6 , , PUNCT crl-14716 92 7 the the DET crl-14716 92 8 common common ADJ crl-14716 92 9 view view NOUN crl-14716 92 10 of of ADP crl-14716 92 11 users user NOUN crl-14716 92 12 appears appear VERB crl-14716 92 13 to to PART crl-14716 92 14 be be AUX crl-14716 92 15 that that SCONJ crl-14716 92 16 they they PRON crl-14716 92 17 will will AUX crl-14716 92 18 be be AUX crl-14716 92 19 liberated liberate VERB crl-14716 92 20 by by ADP crl-14716 92 21 library library NOUN crl-14716 92 22 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 92 23 , , PUNCT crl-14716 92 24 that that ADV crl-14716 92 25 is is ADV crl-14716 92 26 , , PUNCT crl-14716 92 27 they they PRON crl-14716 92 28 will will AUX crl-14716 92 29 be be AUX crl-14716 92 30 free free ADJ crl-14716 92 31 to to PART crl-14716 92 32 pursue pursue VERB crl-14716 92 33 their their PRON crl-14716 92 34 own own ADJ crl-14716 92 35 information information NOUN crl-14716 92 36 needs need VERB crl-14716 92 37 once once SCONJ crl-14716 92 38 they they PRON crl-14716 92 39 have have AUX crl-14716 92 40 been be AUX crl-14716 92 41 taught teach VERB crl-14716 92 42 how how SCONJ crl-14716 92 43 the the DET crl-14716 92 44 library library NOUN crl-14716 92 45 works work VERB crl-14716 92 46 and and CCONJ crl-14716 92 47 when when SCONJ crl-14716 92 48 the the DET crl-14716 92 49 tools tool NOUN crl-14716 92 50 relevant relevant ADJ crl-14716 92 51 to to ADP crl-14716 92 52 their their PRON crl-14716 92 53 fields field NOUN crl-14716 92 54 of of ADP crl-14716 92 55 study study NOUN crl-14716 92 56 have have AUX crl-14716 92 57 been be AUX crl-14716 92 58 demystified demystify VERB crl-14716 92 59 for for ADP crl-14716 92 60 them they PRON crl-14716 92 61 . . PUNCT crl-14716 93 1 examples example NOUN crl-14716 93 2 of of ADP crl-14716 93 3 this this DET crl-14716 93 4 perspective perspective NOUN crl-14716 93 5 are be AUX crl-14716 93 6 typified typify VERB crl-14716 93 7 by by ADP crl-14716 93 8 the the DET crl-14716 93 9 following follow VERB crl-14716 93 10 comments comment NOUN crl-14716 93 11 made make VERB crl-14716 93 12 by by ADP crl-14716 93 13 some some PRON crl-14716 93 14 of of ADP crl-14716 93 15 the the DET crl-14716 93 16 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 93 17 library library NOUN crl-14716 93 18 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 93 19 : : PUNCT crl-14716 94 1 i i PRON crl-14716 94 2 believe believe VERB crl-14716 94 3 that that SCONJ crl-14716 94 4 learning learn VERB crl-14716 94 5 to to PART crl-14716 94 6 use use VERB crl-14716 94 7 information information NOUN crl-14716 94 8 sources source NOUN crl-14716 94 9 effectively effectively ADV crl-14716 94 10 and and CCONJ crl-14716 94 11 efficiently efficiently ADV crl-14716 94 12 is be AUX crl-14716 94 13 an an DET crl-14716 94 14 important important ADJ crl-14716 94 15 part part NOUN crl-14716 94 16 of of ADP crl-14716 94 17 lifelong lifelong ADJ crl-14716 94 18 learning learning NOUN crl-14716 94 19 . . PUNCT crl-14716 95 1 no no DET crl-14716 95 2 student student NOUN crl-14716 95 3 should should AUX crl-14716 95 4 graduate graduate VERB crl-14716 95 5 without without ADP crl-14716 95 6 knowing know VERB crl-14716 95 7 how how SCONJ crl-14716 95 8 to to PART crl-14716 95 9 use use VERB crl-14716 95 10 a a DET crl-14716 95 11 research research NOUN crl-14716 95 12 library library NOUN crl-14716 95 13 to to PART crl-14716 95 14 locate locate VERB crl-14716 95 15 information information NOUN crl-14716 95 16 in in ADP crl-14716 95 17 her she PRON crl-14716 95 18 or or CCONJ crl-14716 95 19 his his PRON crl-14716 95 20 field field NOUN crl-14716 95 21 . . PUNCT crl-14716 96 1 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 96 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 96 3 public public ADJ crl-14716 96 4 , , PUNCT crl-14716 96 5 and and CCONJ crl-14716 96 6 special special ADJ crl-14716 96 7 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 96 8 with with ADP crl-14716 96 9 similar similar ADJ crl-14716 96 10 levels level NOUN crl-14716 96 11 of of ADP crl-14716 96 12 education education NOUN crl-14716 96 13 and and CCONJ crl-14716 96 14 work work NOUN crl-14716 96 15 experience experience NOUN crl-14716 96 16 have have VERB crl-14716 96 17 very very ADV crl-14716 96 18 dissimilar dissimilar ADJ crl-14716 96 19 views view NOUN crl-14716 96 20 about about ADP crl-14716 96 21 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 96 22 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 96 23 . . PUNCT crl-14716 97 1 related relate VERB crl-14716 97 2 to to ADP crl-14716 97 3 the the DET crl-14716 97 4 idea idea NOUN crl-14716 97 5 of of ADP crl-14716 97 6 user user NOUN crl-14716 97 7 independence independence NOUN crl-14716 97 8 is be AUX crl-14716 97 9 the the DET crl-14716 97 10 notion notion NOUN crl-14716 97 11 that that SCONJ crl-14716 97 12 library library NOUN crl-14716 97 13 patrons patron NOUN crl-14716 97 14 should should AUX crl-14716 97 15 be be AUX crl-14716 97 16 instructed instruct VERB crl-14716 97 17 , , PUNCT crl-14716 97 18 whether whether SCONJ crl-14716 97 19 or or CCONJ crl-14716 97 20 not not PART crl-14716 97 21 they they PRON crl-14716 97 22 wish wish VERB crl-14716 97 23 to to PART crl-14716 97 24 be be AUX crl-14716 97 25 . . PUNCT crl-14716 98 1 thus thus ADV crl-14716 98 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 98 3 some some PRON crl-14716 98 4 of of ADP crl-14716 98 5 the the DET crl-14716 98 6 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 98 7 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 98 8 commented comment VERB crl-14716 98 9 , , PUNCT crl-14716 98 10 for for ADP crl-14716 98 11 instance instance NOUN crl-14716 98 12 , , PUNCT crl-14716 98 13 that that SCONJ crl-14716 98 14 : : PUNCT crl-14716 98 15 every every DET crl-14716 98 16 time time NOUN crl-14716 98 17 you you PRON crl-14716 98 18 interact interact VERB crl-14716 98 19 with with ADP crl-14716 98 20 a a DET crl-14716 98 21 user user NOUN crl-14716 98 22 you you PRON crl-14716 98 23 should should AUX crl-14716 98 24 teach teach VERB crl-14716 98 25 [ [ PUNCT crl-14716 98 26 him he PRON crl-14716 98 27 or or CCONJ crl-14716 98 28 her she PRON crl-14716 98 29 ] ] PUNCT crl-14716 98 30 a a DET crl-14716 98 31 little little ADJ crl-14716 98 32 something something PRON crl-14716 98 33 . . PUNCT crl-14716 99 1 the the DET crl-14716 99 2 ideal ideal NOUN crl-14716 99 3 is be AUX crl-14716 99 4 to to PART crl-14716 99 5 use use VERB crl-14716 99 6 each each DET crl-14716 99 7 encounter encounter NOUN crl-14716 99 8 between between ADP crl-14716 99 9 user user NOUN crl-14716 99 10 and and CCONJ crl-14716 99 11 librarian librarian NOUN crl-14716 99 12 as as ADP crl-14716 99 13 an an DET crl-14716 99 14 opportunity opportunity NOUN crl-14716 99 15 to to PART crl-14716 99 16 instruct instruct VERB crl-14716 99 17 .... .... PUNCT crl-14716 100 1 unfortunately unfortunately ADV crl-14716 100 2 not not PART crl-14716 100 3 all all DET crl-14716 100 4 users user NOUN crl-14716 100 5 are be AUX crl-14716 100 6 amenable amenable ADJ crl-14716 100 7 to to ADP crl-14716 100 8 this this DET crl-14716 100 9 approach approach NOUN crl-14716 100 10 so so SCONJ crl-14716 100 11 some some DET crl-14716 100 12 " " PUNCT crl-14716 100 13 spoon spoon NOUN crl-14716 100 14 - - PUNCT crl-14716 100 15 feeding feed VERB crl-14716 100 16 " " PUNCT crl-14716 100 17 is be AUX crl-14716 100 18 necessary necessary ADJ crl-14716 100 19 . . PUNCT crl-14716 101 1 these these DET crl-14716 101 2 comments comment NOUN crl-14716 101 3 suggest suggest VERB crl-14716 101 4 that that SCONJ crl-14716 101 5 some some DET crl-14716 101 6 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 101 7 feel feel VERB crl-14716 101 8 an an DET crl-14716 101 9 imperative imperative NOUN crl-14716 101 10 to to PART crl-14716 101 11 teach teach VERB crl-14716 101 12 , , PUNCT crl-14716 101 13 no no ADV crl-14716 101 14 matter matter ADV crl-14716 101 15 what what PRON crl-14716 101 16 . . PUNCT crl-14716 102 1 this this DET crl-14716 102 2 imperative imperative NOUN crl-14716 102 3 was be AUX crl-14716 102 4 also also ADV crl-14716 102 5 evident evident ADJ crl-14716 102 6 in in ADP crl-14716 102 7 the the DET crl-14716 102 8 comments comment NOUN crl-14716 102 9 of of ADP crl-14716 102 10 several several ADJ crl-14716 102 11 public public ADJ crl-14716 102 12 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 102 13 , , PUNCT crl-14716 102 14 one one NUM crl-14716 102 15 of of ADP crl-14716 102 16 whom whom PRON crl-14716 102 17 recommended recommend VERB crl-14716 102 18 that that SCONJ crl-14716 102 19 even even ADV crl-14716 102 20 if if SCONJ crl-14716 102 21 a a DET crl-14716 102 22 patron patron NOUN crl-14716 102 23 does do AUX crl-14716 102 24 n't not PART crl-14716 102 25 may1992 may1992 VERB crl-14716 102 26 want want VERB crl-14716 102 27 to to PART crl-14716 102 28 be be AUX crl-14716 102 29 instructed instruct VERB crl-14716 102 30 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 102 31 should should AUX crl-14716 102 32 " " PUNCT crl-14716 102 33 try try VERB crl-14716 102 34 hard hard ADV crl-14716 102 35 to to PART crl-14716 102 36 sneak sneak VERB crl-14716 102 37 it it PRON crl-14716 102 38 in in ADP crl-14716 102 39 ! ! PUNCT crl-14716 102 40 " " PUNCT crl-14716 103 1 conversely conversely ADV crl-14716 103 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 103 3 within within ADP crl-14716 103 4 the the DET crl-14716 103 5 special special ADJ crl-14716 103 6 library library NOUN crl-14716 103 7 setting setting NOUN crl-14716 103 8 , , PUNCT crl-14716 103 9 delivery delivery NOUN crl-14716 103 10 of of ADP crl-14716 103 11 information information NOUN crl-14716 103 12 to to ADP crl-14716 103 13 the the DET crl-14716 103 14 user user NOUN crl-14716 103 15 is be AUX crl-14716 103 16 seen see VERB crl-14716 103 17 as as ADP crl-14716 103 18 the the DET crl-14716 103 19 key key ADJ crl-14716 103 20 function function NOUN crl-14716 103 21 of of ADP crl-14716 103 22 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 103 23 service service NOUN crl-14716 103 24 , , PUNCT crl-14716 103 25 and and CCONJ crl-14716 103 26 whether whether SCONJ crl-14716 103 27 the the DET crl-14716 103 28 user user NOUN crl-14716 103 29 knows know VERB crl-14716 103 30 about about ADP crl-14716 103 31 the the DET crl-14716 103 32 library library NOUN crl-14716 103 33 and and CCONJ crl-14716 103 34 its its PRON crl-14716 103 35 tools tool NOUN crl-14716 103 36 is be AUX crl-14716 103 37 incidental incidental ADJ crl-14716 103 38 to to ADP crl-14716 103 39 this this DET crl-14716 103 40 goal goal NOUN crl-14716 103 41 . . PUNCT crl-14716 104 1 typical typical ADJ crl-14716 104 2 of of ADP crl-14716 104 3 the the DET crl-14716 104 4 special special ADJ crl-14716 104 5 librarians librarians PROPN crl-14716 104 6 ' ' PART crl-14716 104 7 responses response NOUN crl-14716 104 8 were be AUX crl-14716 104 9 comments comment NOUN crl-14716 104 10 such such ADJ crl-14716 104 11 as as ADP crl-14716 104 12 : : PUNCT crl-14716 104 13 the the DET crl-14716 104 14 only only ADJ crl-14716 104 15 justifiable justifiable ADJ crl-14716 104 16 role role NOUN crl-14716 104 17 for for ADP crl-14716 104 18 bi bi PROPN crl-14716 104 19 in in ADP crl-14716 104 20 special special ADJ crl-14716 104 21 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 104 22 is be AUX crl-14716 104 23 as as ADP crl-14716 104 24 a a DET crl-14716 104 25 marketing marketing NOUN crl-14716 104 26 technique technique NOUN crl-14716 104 27 . . PUNCT crl-14716 105 1 one one NUM crl-14716 105 2 of of ADP crl-14716 105 3 the the DET crl-14716 105 4 strongest strong ADJ crl-14716 105 5 selling selling NOUN crl-14716 105 6 points point NOUN crl-14716 105 7 to to PART crl-14716 105 8 justify justify VERB crl-14716 105 9 having have VERB crl-14716 105 10 a a DET crl-14716 105 11 special special ADJ crl-14716 105 12 library library NOUN crl-14716 105 13 is be AUX crl-14716 105 14 that that SCONJ crl-14716 105 15 it it PRON crl-14716 105 16 saves save VERB crl-14716 105 17 valuable valuable ADJ crl-14716 105 18 management management NOUN crl-14716 105 19 time time NOUN crl-14716 105 20 by by ADP crl-14716 105 21 having have VERB crl-14716 105 22 specialists specialist NOUN crl-14716 105 23 do do VERB crl-14716 105 24 research research NOUN crl-14716 105 25 for for ADP crl-14716 105 26 users user NOUN crl-14716 105 27 . . PUNCT crl-14716 106 1 users user NOUN crl-14716 106 2 in in ADP crl-14716 106 3 special special ADJ crl-14716 106 4 corporate corporate ADJ crl-14716 106 5 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 106 6 need need VERB crl-14716 106 7 information information NOUN crl-14716 106 8 immediately immediately ADV crl-14716 106 9 - - PUNCT crl-14716 106 10 they they PRON crl-14716 106 11 do do AUX crl-14716 106 12 n't not PART crl-14716 106 13 care care VERB crl-14716 106 14 where where SCONJ crl-14716 106 15 it it PRON crl-14716 106 16 came come VERB crl-14716 106 17 from from ADP crl-14716 106 18 and and CCONJ crl-14716 106 19 do do AUX crl-14716 106 20 n't not PART crl-14716 106 21 want want VERB crl-14716 106 22 to to PART crl-14716 106 23 know know VERB crl-14716 106 24 how how SCONJ crl-14716 106 25 to to PART crl-14716 106 26 get get VERB crl-14716 106 27 itthat itthat PROPN crl-14716 106 28 's be AUX crl-14716 106 29 what what PRON crl-14716 106 30 they they PRON crl-14716 106 31 pay pay VERB crl-14716 106 32 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 106 33 to to PART crl-14716 106 34 do do VERB crl-14716 106 35 . . PUNCT crl-14716 107 1 users user NOUN crl-14716 107 2 of of ADP crl-14716 107 3 special special ADJ crl-14716 107 4 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 107 5 are be AUX crl-14716 107 6 generally generally ADV crl-14716 107 7 not not PART crl-14716 107 8 interested interested ADJ crl-14716 107 9 in in ADP crl-14716 107 10 knowing know VERB crl-14716 107 11 how how SCONJ crl-14716 107 12 the the DET crl-14716 107 13 library library NOUN crl-14716 107 14 " " PUNCT crl-14716 107 15 works work VERB crl-14716 107 16 . . PUNCT crl-14716 107 17 " " PUNCT crl-14716 108 1 they they PRON crl-14716 108 2 want want VERB crl-14716 108 3 to to PART crl-14716 108 4 get get VERB crl-14716 108 5 their their PRON crl-14716 108 6 information information NOUN crl-14716 108 7 and and CCONJ crl-14716 108 8 leave leave VERB crl-14716 108 9 . . PUNCT crl-14716 109 1 senior senior ADJ crl-14716 109 2 vice vice NOUN crl-14716 109 3 presidents president NOUN crl-14716 109 4 are be AUX crl-14716 109 5 willing willing ADJ crl-14716 109 6 to to PART crl-14716 109 7 spend spend VERB crl-14716 109 8 time time NOUN crl-14716 109 9 clarifying clarify VERB crl-14716 109 10 their their PRON crl-14716 109 11 needs need NOUN crl-14716 109 12 but but CCONJ crl-14716 109 13 not not PART crl-14716 109 14 learning learn VERB crl-14716 109 15 how how SCONJ crl-14716 109 16 to to PART crl-14716 109 17 embrace embrace VERB crl-14716 109 18 my my PRON crl-14716 109 19 profession profession NOUN crl-14716 109 20 . . PUNCT crl-14716 110 1 public public ADJ crl-14716 110 2 librarians librarians PROPN crl-14716 110 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 110 4 by by ADP crl-14716 110 5 falling fall VERB crl-14716 110 6 somewhere somewhere ADV crl-14716 110 7 in in ADP crl-14716 110 8 between between ADP crl-14716 110 9 the the DET crl-14716 110 10 information information NOUN crl-14716 110 11 and and CCONJ crl-14716 110 12 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 110 13 positions position NOUN crl-14716 110 14 , , PUNCT crl-14716 110 15 appear appear VERB crl-14716 110 16 to to PART crl-14716 110 17 have have VERB crl-14716 110 18 some some DET crl-14716 110 19 ambivalence ambivalence NOUN crl-14716 110 20 about about ADP crl-14716 110 21 the the DET crl-14716 110 22 issue issue NOUN crl-14716 110 23 of of ADP crl-14716 110 24 user user NOUN crl-14716 110 25 education education NOUN crl-14716 110 26 - - PUNCT crl-14716 110 27 some some PRON crl-14716 110 28 taking take VERB crl-14716 110 29 a a DET crl-14716 110 30 position position NOUN crl-14716 110 31 with with ADP crl-14716 110 32 respect respect NOUN crl-14716 110 33 to to ADP crl-14716 110 34 users user NOUN crl-14716 110 35 that that PRON crl-14716 110 36 is be AUX crl-14716 110 37 more more ADJ crl-14716 110 38 in in ADP crl-14716 110 39 line line NOUN crl-14716 110 40 with with ADP crl-14716 110 41 that that PRON crl-14716 110 42 of of ADP crl-14716 110 43 their their PRON crl-14716 110 44 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 110 45 colleagues colleague NOUN crl-14716 110 46 , , PUNCT crl-14716 110 47 others other NOUN crl-14716 110 48 taking take VERB crl-14716 110 49 the the DET crl-14716 110 50 view view NOUN crl-14716 110 51 .that .that ADP crl-14716 110 52 information information NOUN crl-14716 110 53 delivery delivery NOUN crl-14716 110 54 is be AUX crl-14716 110 55 the the DET crl-14716 110 56 key key ADJ crl-14716 110 57 function function NOUN crl-14716 110 58 of of ADP crl-14716 110 59 public public ADJ crl-14716 110 60 library library NOUN crl-14716 110 61 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 110 62 service service NOUN crl-14716 110 63 , , PUNCT crl-14716 110 64 and and CCONJ crl-14716 110 65 still still ADV crl-14716 110 66 others other NOUN crl-14716 110 67 acknowledging acknowledge VERB crl-14716 110 68 the the DET crl-14716 110 69 validity validity NOUN crl-14716 110 70 of of ADP crl-14716 110 71 both both DET crl-14716 110 72 positions position NOUN crl-14716 110 73 . . PUNCT crl-14716 111 1 for for ADP crl-14716 111 2 instance instance NOUN crl-14716 111 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 111 4 one one NUM crl-14716 111 5 respondent respondent NOUN crl-14716 111 6 commented comment VERB crl-14716 111 7 : : PUNCT crl-14716 111 8 many many ADJ crl-14716 111 9 patrons patron NOUN crl-14716 111 10 like like VERB crl-14716 111 11 to to PART crl-14716 111 12 be be AUX crl-14716 111 13 informed inform VERB crl-14716 111 14 so so SCONJ crl-14716 111 15 that that SCONJ crl-14716 111 16 they they PRON crl-14716 111 17 will will AUX crl-14716 111 18 bring bring VERB crl-14716 111 19 more more ADJ crl-14716 111 20 skill skill NOUN crl-14716 111 21 to to ADP crl-14716 111 22 their their PRON crl-14716 111 23 next next ADJ crl-14716 111 24 library library NOUN crl-14716 111 25 visit visit NOUN crl-14716 111 26 . . PUNCT crl-14716 112 1 however however ADV crl-14716 112 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 112 3 just just ADV crl-14716 112 4 as as ADP crl-14716 112 5 many many ADJ crl-14716 112 6 patrons patron NOUN crl-14716 112 7 are be AUX crl-14716 112 8 not not PART crl-14716 112 9 interested interested ADJ crl-14716 112 10 in in ADP crl-14716 112 11 how how SCONJ crl-14716 112 12 the the DET crl-14716 112 13 library library NOUN crl-14716 112 14 works work VERB crl-14716 112 15 ; ; PUNCT crl-14716 112 16 they they PRON crl-14716 112 17 just just ADV crl-14716 112 18 want want VERB crl-14716 112 19 the the DET crl-14716 112 20 information information NOUN crl-14716 112 21 . . PUNCT crl-14716 113 1 i i PRON crl-14716 113 2 equate equate VERB crl-14716 113 3 this this PRON crl-14716 113 4 to to ADP crl-14716 113 5 me i PRON crl-14716 113 6 and and CCONJ crl-14716 113 7 the the DET crl-14716 113 8 grocery grocery NOUN crl-14716 113 9 store store NOUN crl-14716 113 10 : : PUNCT crl-14716 113 11 i i PRON crl-14716 113 12 want want VERB crl-14716 113 13 to to PART crl-14716 113 14 know know VERB crl-14716 113 15 where where SCONJ crl-14716 113 16 the the DET crl-14716 113 17 cat cat NOUN crl-14716 113 18 food food NOUN crl-14716 113 19 is be AUX crl-14716 113 20 , , PUNCT crl-14716 113 21 not not PART crl-14716 113 22 why why SCONJ crl-14716 113 23 or or CCONJ crl-14716 113 24 how how SCONJ crl-14716 113 25 the the DET crl-14716 113 26 store store NOUN crl-14716 113 27 decided decide VERB crl-14716 113 28 to to PART crl-14716 113 29 put put VERB crl-14716 113 30 it it PRON crl-14716 113 31 there there ADV crl-14716 113 32 . . PUNCT crl-14716 114 1 the the DET crl-14716 114 2 ambivalence ambivalence NOUN crl-14716 114 3 of of ADP crl-14716 114 4 the the DET crl-14716 114 5 public public ADJ crl-14716 114 6 librarians librarians PROPN crl-14716 114 7 was be AUX crl-14716 114 8 also also ADV crl-14716 114 9 shared share VERB crl-14716 114 10 by by ADP crl-14716 114 11 some some PRON crl-14716 114 12 of of ADP crl-14716 114 13 the the DET crl-14716 114 14 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 114 15 in in ADP crl-14716 114 16 the the DET crl-14716 114 17 other other ADJ crl-14716 114 18 groups group NOUN crl-14716 114 19 . . PUNCT crl-14716 115 1 a a DET crl-14716 115 2 number number NOUN crl-14716 115 3 of of ADP crl-14716 115 4 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 115 5 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 115 6 , , PUNCT crl-14716 115 7 for for ADP crl-14716 115 8 instance instance NOUN crl-14716 115 9 , , PUNCT crl-14716 115 10 pointed point VERB crl-14716 115 11 out out ADP crl-14716 115 12 that that SCONJ crl-14716 115 13 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 115 14 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 115 15 can can AUX crl-14716 115 16 never never ADV crl-14716 115 17 take take VERB crl-14716 115 18 the the DET crl-14716 115 19 place place NOUN crl-14716 115 20 of of ADP crl-14716 115 21 good good ADJ crl-14716 115 22 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 115 23 service service NOUN crl-14716 115 24 . . PUNCT crl-14716 116 1 for for ADP crl-14716 116 2 example example NOUN crl-14716 116 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 116 4 one one NUM crl-14716 116 5 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 116 6 librarian librarian NOUN crl-14716 116 7 observed observe VERB crl-14716 116 8 that that SCONJ crl-14716 116 9 " " PUNCT crl-14716 116 10 bi bi PROPN crl-14716 116 11 is be AUX crl-14716 116 12 necessary necessary ADJ crl-14716 116 13 but but CCONJ crl-14716 116 14 it it PRON crl-14716 116 15 complements complement VERB crl-14716 116 16 rather rather ADV crl-14716 116 17 than than ADP crl-14716 116 18 replaces replace VERB crl-14716 116 19 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 116 20 assistance assistance NOUN crl-14716 116 21 . . PUNCT crl-14716 117 1 people people NOUN crl-14716 117 2 do do AUX crl-14716 117 3 need need VERB crl-14716 117 4 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 117 5 assistance assistance NOUN crl-14716 117 6 even even ADV crl-14716 117 7 after after ADP crl-14716 117 8 becoming become VERB crl-14716 117 9 fairly fairly ADV crl-14716 117 10 competent competent ADJ crl-14716 117 11 in in ADP crl-14716 117 12 library library NOUN crl-14716 117 13 use use NOUN crl-14716 117 14 . . PUNCT crl-14716 117 15 " " PUNCT crl-14716 118 1 other other ADJ crl-14716 118 2 agendas agenda NOUN crl-14716 118 3 some some PRON crl-14716 118 4 of of ADP crl-14716 118 5 the the DET crl-14716 118 6 public public ADJ crl-14716 118 7 and and CCONJ crl-14716 118 8 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 118 9 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 118 10 ' ' PART crl-14716 118 11 comments comment NOUN crl-14716 118 12 suggest suggest VERB crl-14716 118 13 that that SCONJ crl-14716 118 14 user user NOUN crl-14716 118 15 education education NOUN crl-14716 118 16 can can AUX crl-14716 118 17 also also ADV crl-14716 118 18 serve serve VERB crl-14716 118 19 an an DET crl-14716 118 20 agenda agenda NOUN crl-14716 118 21 in in ADP crl-14716 118 22 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 118 23 that that PRON crl-14716 118 24 has have VERB crl-14716 118 25 little little ADJ crl-14716 118 26 to to PART crl-14716 118 27 do do VERB crl-14716 118 28 with with ADP crl-14716 118 29 the the DET crl-14716 118 30 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 118 31 - - PUNCT crl-14716 118 32 versus versus ADP crl-14716 118 33 - - PUNCT crl-14716 118 34 information information NOUN crl-14716 118 35 debate debate NOUN crl-14716 118 36 over over ADP crl-14716 118 37 the the DET crl-14716 118 38 " " PUNCT crl-14716 118 39 best good ADJ crl-14716 118 40 " " PUNCT crl-14716 118 41 way way NOUN crl-14716 118 42 to to PART crl-14716 118 43 deliver deliver VERB crl-14716 118 44 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 118 45 services service NOUN crl-14716 118 46 . . PUNCT crl-14716 119 1 instead instead ADV crl-14716 119 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 119 3 what what PRON crl-14716 119 4 they they PRON crl-14716 119 5 seemed seem VERB crl-14716 119 6 to to PART crl-14716 119 7 be be AUX crl-14716 119 8 implying imply VERB crl-14716 119 9 was be AUX crl-14716 119 10 that that SCONJ crl-14716 119 11 user user NOUN crl-14716 119 12 education education NOUN crl-14716 119 13 is be AUX crl-14716 119 14 promoted promote VERB crl-14716 119 15 in in ADP crl-14716 119 16 their their PRON crl-14716 119 17 institutions institution NOUN crl-14716 119 18 not not PART crl-14716 119 19 so so ADV crl-14716 119 20 much much ADJ crl-14716 119 21 for for ADP crl-14716 119 22 the the DET crl-14716 119 23 patrons patron NOUN crl-14716 119 24 ' ' PART crl-14716 119 25 benefit benefit NOUN crl-14716 119 26 but but CCONJ crl-14716 119 27 rather rather ADV crl-14716 119 28 as as ADP crl-14716 119 29 a a DET crl-14716 119 30 potential potential ADJ crl-14716 119 31 cost cost NOUN crl-14716 119 32 saver saver NOUN crl-14716 119 33 . . PUNCT crl-14716 120 1 typical typical ADJ crl-14716 120 2 of of ADP crl-14716 120 3 such such ADJ crl-14716 120 4 comments comment NOUN crl-14716 120 5 were be AUX crl-14716 120 6 : : PUNCT crl-14716 120 7 financial financial ADJ crl-14716 120 8 constraints constraint NOUN crl-14716 120 9 mean mean VERB crl-14716 120 10 that that SCONJ crl-14716 120 11 less less ADJ crl-14716 120 12 time time NOUN crl-14716 120 13 is be AUX crl-14716 120 14 available available ADJ crl-14716 120 15 to to PART crl-14716 120 16 actually actually ADV crl-14716 120 17 provide provide VERB crl-14716 120 18 users user NOUN crl-14716 120 19 · · PUNCT crl-14716 120 20 with with ADP crl-14716 120 21 information information NOUN crl-14716 120 22 . . PUNCT crl-14716 121 1 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 121 2 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 121 3 do do AUX crl-14716 121 4 n't not PART crl-14716 121 5 have have VERB crl-14716 121 6 the the DET crl-14716 121 7 luxury luxury NOUN crl-14716 121 8 to to PART crl-14716 121 9 provide provide VERB crl-14716 121 10 such such ADJ crl-14716 121 11 service service NOUN crl-14716 121 12 now now ADV crl-14716 121 13 even even ADV crl-14716 121 14 if if SCONJ crl-14716 121 15 they they PRON crl-14716 121 16 wanted want VERB crl-14716 121 17 to to PART crl-14716 121 18 . . PUNCT crl-14716 122 1 at at ADP crl-14716 122 2 our our PRON crl-14716 122 3 institution institution NOUN crl-14716 122 4 the the DET crl-14716 122 5 prime prime ADJ crl-14716 122 6 objective objective NOUN crl-14716 122 7 of of ADP crl-14716 122 8 bi bi PROPN crl-14716 122 9 is be AUX crl-14716 122 10 self self NOUN crl-14716 122 11 - - PUNCT crl-14716 122 12 sufficiency sufficiency NOUN crl-14716 122 13 since since SCONJ crl-14716 122 14 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 122 15 staffing staffing NOUN crl-14716 122 16 is be AUX crl-14716 122 17 minimal minimal ADJ crl-14716 122 18 . . PUNCT crl-14716 123 1 in in ADP crl-14716 123 2 an an DET crl-14716 123 3 interesting interesting ADJ crl-14716 123 4 reversal reversal NOUN crl-14716 123 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 123 6 some some PRON crl-14716 123 7 of of ADP crl-14716 123 8 the the DET crl-14716 123 9 special special ADJ crl-14716 123 10 library library NOUN crl-14716 123 11 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 123 12 cited cite VERB crl-14716 123 13 financial financial ADJ crl-14716 123 14 constraints constraint NOUN crl-14716 123 15 as as ADP crl-14716 123 16 the the DET crl-14716 123 17 justification justification NOUN crl-14716 123 18 for for ADP crl-14716 123 19 not not PART crl-14716 123 20 engaging engage VERB crl-14716 123 21 in in ADP crl-14716 123 22 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 123 23 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 123 24 . . PUNCT crl-14716 124 1 for for ADP crl-14716 124 2 example example NOUN crl-14716 124 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 124 4 " " PUNCT crl-14716 124 5 many many ADJ crl-14716 124 6 special special ADJ crl-14716 124 7 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 124 8 do do AUX crl-14716 124 9 not not PART crl-14716 124 10 have have VERB crl-14716 124 11 sufficient sufficient ADJ crl-14716 124 12 staff staff NOUN crl-14716 124 13 to to PART crl-14716 124 14 be be AUX crl-14716 124 15 able able ADJ crl-14716 124 16 to to PART crl-14716 124 17 spend spend VERB crl-14716 124 18 as as ADV crl-14716 124 19 much much ADJ crl-14716 124 20 time time NOUN crl-14716 124 21 as as SCONJ crl-14716 124 22 they they PRON crl-14716 124 23 wish wish VERB crl-14716 124 24 on on ADP crl-14716 124 25 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 124 26 . . PUNCT crl-14716 124 27 " " PUNCT crl-14716 125 1 user user NOUN crl-14716 125 2 education education NOUN crl-14716 125 3 and and CCONJ crl-14716 125 4 librarian librarian ADJ crl-14716 125 5 status status NOUN crl-14716 125 6 one one NUM crl-14716 125 7 of of ADP crl-14716 125 8 the the DET crl-14716 125 9 more more ADV crl-14716 125 10 curious curious ADJ crl-14716 125 11 findings finding NOUN crl-14716 125 12 to to PART crl-14716 125 13 emerge emerge VERB crl-14716 125 14 from from ADP crl-14716 125 15 this this DET crl-14716 125 16 study study NOUN crl-14716 125 17 concerns concern VERB crl-14716 125 18 the the DET crl-14716 125 19 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 125 20 ' ' PART crl-14716 125 21 perceptions perception NOUN crl-14716 125 22 of of ADP crl-14716 125 23 the the DET crl-14716 125 24 status status NOUN crl-14716 125 25 - - PUNCT crl-14716 125 26 enhancing enhance VERB crl-14716 125 27 impact impact NOUN crl-14716 125 28 of of ADP crl-14716 125 29 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 125 30 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 125 31 . . PUNCT crl-14716 126 1 it it PRON crl-14716 126 2 has have AUX crl-14716 126 3 been be AUX crl-14716 126 4 argued argue VERB crl-14716 126 5 many many ADJ crl-14716 126 6 times time NOUN crl-14716 126 7 in in ADP crl-14716 126 8 the the DET crl-14716 126 9 literature literature NOUN crl-14716 126 10 that that PRON crl-14716 126 11 part part NOUN crl-14716 126 12 of of ADP crl-14716 126 13 the the DET crl-14716 126 14 attraction attraction NOUN crl-14716 126 15 of of ADP crl-14716 126 16 the the DET crl-14716 126 17 teaching teaching NOUN crl-14716 126 18 role role NOUN crl-14716 126 19 for for ADP crl-14716 126 20 librarians librarians PROPN crl-14716 126 21 rests rest VERB crl-14716 126 22 in in ADP crl-14716 126 23 its its PRON crl-14716 126 24 potential potential NOUN crl-14716 126 25 for for ADP crl-14716 126 26 increased increase VERB crl-14716 126 27 statusy statusy ADJ crl-14716 126 28 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 126 29 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 126 30 particularly particularly ADV crl-14716 126 31 see see VERB crl-14716 126 32 the the DET crl-14716 126 33 adoption adoption NOUN crl-14716 126 34 of of ADP crl-14716 126 35 a a DET crl-14716 126 36 teaching teaching NOUN crl-14716 126 37 role role NOUN crl-14716 126 38 as as ADP crl-14716 126 39 a a DET crl-14716 126 40 means mean NOUN crl-14716 126 41 by by ADP crl-14716 126 42 which which PRON crl-14716 126 43 they they PRON crl-14716 126 44 can can AUX crl-14716 126 45 become become VERB crl-14716 126 46 more more ADV crl-14716 126 47 like like ADP crl-14716 126 48 their their PRON crl-14716 126 49 faculty faculty NOUN crl-14716 126 50 colleagues colleague NOUN crl-14716 126 51 , , PUNCT crl-14716 126 52 thereby thereby ADV crl-14716 126 53 increasing increase VERB crl-14716 126 54 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 126 55 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 126 56 255 255 NUM crl-14716 126 57 their their PRON crl-14716 126 58 chances chance NOUN crl-14716 126 59 of of ADP crl-14716 126 60 achieving achieve VERB crl-14716 126 61 or or CCONJ crl-14716 126 62 maintaining maintain VERB crl-14716 126 63 faculty faculty NOUN crl-14716 126 64 status status NOUN crl-14716 126 65 . . PUNCT crl-14716 127 1 in in ADP crl-14716 127 2 this this DET crl-14716 127 3 study study NOUN crl-14716 127 4 , , PUNCT crl-14716 127 5 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 127 6 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 127 7 , , PUNCT crl-14716 127 8 whose whose DET crl-14716 127 9 formal formal ADJ crl-14716 127 10 instructional instructional ADJ crl-14716 127 11 role role NOUN crl-14716 127 12 is be AUX crl-14716 127 13 perhaps perhaps ADV crl-14716 127 14 more more ADV crl-14716 127 15 prominent prominent ADJ crl-14716 127 16 than than ADP crl-14716 127 17 that that PRON crl-14716 127 18 of of ADP crl-14716 127 19 other other ADJ crl-14716 127 20 types type NOUN crl-14716 127 21 of of ADP crl-14716 127 22 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 127 23 , , PUNCT crl-14716 127 24 were be AUX crl-14716 127 25 less less ADV crl-14716 127 26 likely likely ADJ crl-14716 127 27 than than ADP crl-14716 127 28 the the DET crl-14716 127 29 special special ADJ crl-14716 127 30 library library NOUN crl-14716 127 31 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 127 32 to to PART crl-14716 127 33 believe believe VERB crl-14716 127 34 that that SCONJ crl-14716 127 35 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 127 36 carries carry VERB crl-14716 127 37 with with ADP crl-14716 127 38 it it PRON crl-14716 127 39 such such DET crl-14716 127 40 a a DET crl-14716 127 41 status status NOUN crl-14716 127 42 - - PUNCT crl-14716 127 43 enhancing enhance VERB crl-14716 127 44 effect effect NOUN crl-14716 127 45 . . PUNCT crl-14716 128 1 this this DET crl-14716 128 2 result result NOUN crl-14716 128 3 is be AUX crl-14716 128 4 rather rather ADV crl-14716 128 5 difficult difficult ADJ crl-14716 128 6 to to PART crl-14716 128 7 explain explain VERB crl-14716 128 8 . . PUNCT crl-14716 129 1 perhaps perhaps ADV crl-14716 129 2 user user NOUN crl-14716 129 3 education education NOUN crl-14716 129 4 is be AUX crl-14716 129 5 indeed indeed ADV crl-14716 129 6 accompanied accompany VERB crl-14716 129 7 by by ADP crl-14716 129 8 an an DET crl-14716 129 9 increased increase VERB crl-14716 129 10 status status NOUN crl-14716 129 11 for for ADP crl-14716 129 12 special special ADJ crl-14716 129 13 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 129 14 but but CCONJ crl-14716 129 15 not not PART crl-14716 129 16 for for ADP crl-14716 129 17 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 129 18 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 129 19 . . PUNCT crl-14716 130 1 alternatively alternatively ADV crl-14716 130 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 130 3 and and CCONJ crl-14716 130 4 probably probably ADV crl-14716 130 5 more more ADV crl-14716 130 6 likely likely ADJ crl-14716 130 7 , , PUNCT crl-14716 130 8 because because SCONJ crl-14716 130 9 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 130 10 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 130 11 engage engage VERB crl-14716 130 12 in in ADP crl-14716 130 13 formal formal ADJ crl-14716 130 14 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 130 15 more more ADV crl-14716 130 16 often often ADV crl-14716 130 17 than than ADP crl-14716 130 18 their their PRON crl-14716 130 19 counterparts counterpart NOUN crl-14716 130 20 in in ADP crl-14716 130 21 special special ADJ crl-14716 130 22 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 130 23 , , PUNCT crl-14716 130 24 they they PRON crl-14716 130 25 are be AUX crl-14716 130 26 able able ADJ crl-14716 130 27 toassess toassess ADV crl-14716 130 28 more more ADV crl-14716 130 29 realistically realistically ADV crl-14716 130 30 the the DET crl-14716 130 31 the the DET crl-14716 130 32 practice practice NOUN crl-14716 130 33 of of ADP crl-14716 130 34 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 130 35 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 130 36 , , PUNCT crl-14716 130 37 judging judge VERB crl-14716 130 38 by by ADP crl-14716 130 39 the the DET crl-14716 130 40 results result NOUN crl-14716 130 41 of of ADP crl-14716 130 42 this this DET crl-14716 130 43 study study NOUN crl-14716 130 44 , , PUNCT crl-14716 130 45 seems seem VERB crl-14716 130 46 to to PART crl-14716 130 47 be be AUX crl-14716 130 48 , , PUNCT crl-14716 130 49 by by ADP crl-14716 130 50 and and CCONJ crl-14716 130 51 large large ADJ crl-14716 130 52 , , PUNCT crl-14716 130 53 unregulated unregulated ADJ crl-14716 130 54 . . PUNCT crl-14716 131 1 likelihood likelihood NOUN crl-14716 131 2 of of ADP crl-14716 131 3 increased increase VERB crl-14716 131 4 gains gain NOUN crl-14716 131 5 in in ADP crl-14716 131 6 status status NOUN crl-14716 131 7 . . PUNCT crl-14716 132 1 for for ADP crl-14716 132 2 instance instance NOUN crl-14716 132 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 132 4 it it PRON crl-14716 132 5 is be AUX crl-14716 132 6 not not PART crl-14716 132 7 uncommon uncommon ADJ crl-14716 132 8 for for SCONJ crl-14716 132 9 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 132 10 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 132 11 to to PART crl-14716 132 12 report report VERB crl-14716 132 13 that that SCONJ crl-14716 132 14 even even ADV crl-14716 132 15 where where SCONJ crl-14716 132 16 they they PRON crl-14716 132 17 enjoy enjoy VERB crl-14716 132 18 faculty faculty NOUN crl-14716 132 19 status status NOUN crl-14716 132 20 , , PUNCT crl-14716 132 21 they they PRON crl-14716 132 22 tend tend VERB crl-14716 132 23 to to PART crl-14716 132 24 be be AUX crl-14716 132 25 perceived perceive VERB crl-14716 132 26 by by ADP crl-14716 132 27 their their PRON crl-14716 132 28 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 132 29 colleagues colleague NOUN crl-14716 132 30 as as ADP crl-14716 132 31 second second ADJ crl-14716 132 32 - - PUNCT crl-14716 132 33 class class NOUN crl-14716 132 34 citizens citizen NOUN crl-14716 132 35 . . PUNCT crl-14716 133 1 14 14 NUM crl-14716 133 2 in in ADP crl-14716 133 3 other other ADJ crl-14716 133 4 words word NOUN crl-14716 133 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 133 6 this this DET crl-14716 133 7 result result NOUN crl-14716 133 8 may may AUX crl-14716 133 9 be be AUX crl-14716 133 10 due due ADJ crl-14716 133 11 , , PUNCT crl-14716 133 12 in in ADP crl-14716 133 13 part part NOUN crl-14716 133 14 , , PUNCT crl-14716 133 15 to to ADP crl-14716 133 16 wishful wishful ADJ crl-14716 133 17 thinking thinking NOUN crl-14716 133 18 on on ADP crl-14716 133 19 the the DET crl-14716 133 20 part part NOUN crl-14716 133 21 of of ADP crl-14716 133 22 some some DET crl-14716 133 23 special special ADJ crl-14716 133 24 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 133 25 and and CCONJ crl-14716 133 26 realism realism NOUN crl-14716 133 27 on on ADP crl-14716 133 28 the the DET crl-14716 133 29 part part NOUN crl-14716 133 30 of of ADP crl-14716 133 31 the the DET crl-14716 133 32 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 133 33 library library NOUN crl-14716 133 34 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 133 35 . . PUNCT crl-14716 134 1 little little ADJ crl-14716 134 2 policy policy NOUN crl-14716 134 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 134 4 little little ADJ crl-14716 134 5 training training NOUN crl-14716 134 6 whatever whatever PRON crl-14716 134 7 the the DET crl-14716 134 8 values value NOUN crl-14716 134 9 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 134 10 may may AUX crl-14716 134 11 hold hold VERB crl-14716 134 12 about about ADP crl-14716 134 13 the the DET crl-14716 134 14 role role NOUN crl-14716 134 15 of of ADP crl-14716 134 16 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 134 17 in in ADP crl-14716 134 18 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 134 19 service service NOUN crl-14716 134 20 , , PUNCT crl-14716 134 21 the the DET crl-14716 134 22 practice practice NOUN crl-14716 134 23 of of ADP crl-14716 134 24 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 134 25 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 134 26 , , PUNCT crl-14716 134 27 judging judge VERB crl-14716 134 28 by by ADP crl-14716 134 29 the the DET crl-14716 134 30 results result NOUN crl-14716 134 31 of of ADP crl-14716 134 32 this this DET crl-14716 134 33 study study NOUN crl-14716 134 34 , , PUNCT crl-14716 134 35 seems seem VERB crl-14716 134 36 to to PART crl-14716 134 37 be be AUX crl-14716 134 38 , , PUNCT crl-14716 134 39 by by ADP crl-14716 134 40 and and CCONJ crl-14716 134 41 large large ADJ crl-14716 134 42 , , PUNCT crl-14716 134 43 unregulated unregulated ADJ crl-14716 134 44 . . PUNCT crl-14716 135 1 although although SCONJ crl-14716 135 2 nearly nearly ADV crl-14716 135 3 all all PRON crl-14716 135 4 of of ADP crl-14716 135 5 the the DET crl-14716 135 6 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 135 7 had have AUX crl-14716 135 8 done do VERB crl-14716 135 9 some some DET crl-14716 135 10 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 135 11 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 135 12 , , PUNCT crl-14716 135 13 not not PART crl-14716 135 14 only only ADV crl-14716 135 15 did do AUX crl-14716 135 16 relatively relatively ADV crl-14716 135 17 few few ADJ crl-14716 135 18 of of ADP crl-14716 135 19 them they PRON crl-14716 135 20 report report VERB crl-14716 135 21 that that SCONJ crl-14716 135 22 their their PRON crl-14716 135 23 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 135 24 had have VERB crl-14716 135 25 any any DET crl-14716 135 26 policy policy NOUN crl-14716 135 27 on on ADP crl-14716 135 28 user user NOUN crl-14716 135 29 education education NOUN crl-14716 135 30 , , PUNCT crl-14716 135 31 but but CCONJ crl-14716 135 32 their their PRON crl-14716 135 33 background background NOUN crl-14716 135 34 preparation preparation NOUN crl-14716 135 35 for for ADP crl-14716 135 36 offering offer VERB crl-14716 135 37 this this DET crl-14716 135 38 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 135 39 was be AUX crl-14716 135 40 often often ADV crl-14716 135 41 inadequate inadequate ADJ crl-14716 135 42 . . PUNCT crl-14716 136 1 many many ADJ crl-14716 136 2 had have AUX crl-14716 136 3 received receive VERB crl-14716 136 4 no no DET crl-14716 136 5 formal formal ADJ crl-14716 136 6 training training NOUN crl-14716 136 7 in in ADP crl-14716 136 8 user user NOUN crl-14716 136 9 education education NOUN crl-14716 136 10 and and CCONJ crl-14716 136 11 , , PUNCT crl-14716 136 12 of of ADP crl-14716 136 13 those those PRON crl-14716 136 14 who who PRON crl-14716 136 15 reported report VERB crl-14716 136 16 that that SCONJ crl-14716 136 17 they they PRON crl-14716 136 18 had have AUX crl-14716 136 19 been be AUX crl-14716 136 20 trained train VERB crl-14716 136 21 , , PUNCT crl-14716 136 22 very very ADV crl-14716 136 23 few few ADJ crl-14716 136 24 had have AUX crl-14716 136 25 learned learn VERB crl-14716 136 26 about about ADP crl-14716 136 27 256 256 NUM crl-14716 136 28 college college NOUN crl-14716 136 29 & & CCONJ crl-14716 136 30 research research PROPN crl-14716 136 31 libraries librarie VERB crl-14716 136 32 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 136 33 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 136 34 as as ADP crl-14716 136 35 part part NOUN crl-14716 136 36 of of ADP crl-14716 136 37 their their PRON crl-14716 136 38 professional professional ADJ crl-14716 136 39 education education NOUN crl-14716 136 40 in in ADP crl-14716 136 41 library library NOUN crl-14716 136 42 school school NOUN crl-14716 136 43 . . PUNCT crl-14716 137 1 this this DET crl-14716 137 2 pattern pattern NOUN crl-14716 137 3 of of ADP crl-14716 137 4 results result NOUN crl-14716 137 5 is be AUX crl-14716 137 6 consistent consistent ADJ crl-14716 137 7 with with ADP crl-14716 137 8 patterson patterson NOUN crl-14716 137 9 and and CCONJ crl-14716 137 10 howell howell PROPN crl-14716 137 11 's 's PART crl-14716 137 12 observation observation NOUN crl-14716 137 13 that that SCONJ crl-14716 137 14 professional professional ADJ crl-14716 137 15 education education NOUN crl-14716 137 16 in in ADP crl-14716 137 17 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 137 18 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 137 19 " " PUNCT crl-14716 137 20 remains remain VERB crl-14716 137 21 uneven uneven ADJ crl-14716 137 22 and and CCONJ crl-14716 137 23 haphazard haphazard ADJ crl-14716 137 24 , , PUNCT crl-14716 137 25 and and CCONJ crl-14716 137 26 [ [ X crl-14716 137 27 that that X crl-14716 137 28 ] ] X crl-14716 137 29 few few ADJ crl-14716 137 30 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 137 31 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 137 32 have have VERB crl-14716 137 33 the the DET crl-14716 137 34 necessary necessary ADJ crl-14716 137 35 courses course NOUN crl-14716 137 36 and and CCONJ crl-14716 137 37 practical practical ADJ crl-14716 137 38 experience experience NOUN crl-14716 137 39 in in ADP crl-14716 137 40 their their PRON crl-14716 137 41 formal formal ADJ crl-14716 137 42 library library NOUN crl-14716 137 43 education education NOUN crl-14716 137 44 programs program NOUN crl-14716 137 45 to to PART crl-14716 137 46 prepare prepare VERB crl-14716 137 47 them they PRON crl-14716 137 48 even even ADV crl-14716 137 49 minimally minimally ADV crl-14716 137 50 for for ADP crl-14716 137 51 what what PRON crl-14716 137 52 is be AUX crl-14716 137 53 encountered encounter VERB crl-14716 137 54 on on ADP crl-14716 137 55 the the DET crl-14716 137 56 job job NOUN crl-14716 137 57 . . PUNCT crl-14716 137 58 " " PUNCT crl-14716 138 1 15 15 NUM crl-14716 138 2 the the DET crl-14716 138 3 results result NOUN crl-14716 138 4 also also ADV crl-14716 138 5 lend lend VERB crl-14716 138 6 some some DET crl-14716 138 7 credence credence NOUN crl-14716 138 8 to to ADP crl-14716 138 9 roberts robert NOUN crl-14716 138 10 ' ' PART crl-14716 138 11 view view NOUN crl-14716 138 12 that that SCONJ crl-14716 138 13 the the DET crl-14716 138 14 absence absence NOUN crl-14716 138 15 of of ADP crl-14716 138 16 any any DET crl-14716 138 17 training training NOUN crl-14716 138 18 information information NOUN crl-14716 138 19 for for ADP crl-14716 138 20 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 138 21 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 138 22 in in ADP crl-14716 138 23 the the DET crl-14716 138 24 literature literature NOUN crl-14716 138 25 may may AUX crl-14716 138 26 be be AUX crl-14716 138 27 due due ADJ crl-14716 138 28 , , PUNCT crl-14716 138 29 in in ADP crl-14716 138 30 part part NOUN crl-14716 138 31 , , PUNCT crl-14716 138 32 to to ADP crl-14716 138 33 the the DET crl-14716 138 34 myth myth NOUN crl-14716 138 35 that that SCONJ crl-14716 138 36 " " PUNCT crl-14716 138 37 anyone anyone PRON crl-14716 138 38 can can AUX crl-14716 138 39 teach teach VERB crl-14716 138 40 . . PUNCT crl-14716 138 41 " " PUNCT crl-14716 139 1 16 16 NUM crl-14716 139 2 may1992 may1992 NOUN crl-14716 139 3 conclusion conclusion NOUN crl-14716 139 4 the the DET crl-14716 139 5 results result NOUN crl-14716 139 6 of of ADP crl-14716 139 7 the the DET crl-14716 139 8 study study NOUN crl-14716 139 9 suggest suggest VERB crl-14716 139 10 that that SCONJ crl-14716 139 11 the the DET crl-14716 139 12 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 139 13 - - PUNCT crl-14716 139 14 versus versus ADP crl-14716 139 15 - - PUNCT crl-14716 139 16 information information NOUN crl-14716 139 17 controversy controversy NOUN crl-14716 139 18 over over ADP crl-14716 139 19 user user NOUN crl-14716 139 20 education education NOUN crl-14716 139 21 is be AUX crl-14716 139 22 far far ADV crl-14716 139 23 from from ADP crl-14716 139 24 over over ADV crl-14716 139 25 . . PUNCT crl-14716 140 1 many many ADJ crl-14716 140 2 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 140 3 , , PUNCT crl-14716 140 4 especially especially ADV crl-14716 140 5 those those PRON crl-14716 140 6 who who PRON crl-14716 140 7 work work VERB crl-14716 140 8 in in ADP crl-14716 140 9 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 140 10 and and CCONJ crl-14716 140 11 special special ADJ crl-14716 140 12 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 140 13 , , PUNCT crl-14716 140 14 remain remain VERB crl-14716 140 15 polarized polarize VERB crl-14716 140 16 on on ADP crl-14716 140 17 the the DET crl-14716 140 18 issue issue NOUN crl-14716 140 19 . . PUNCT crl-14716 141 1 however however ADV crl-14716 141 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 141 3 not not PART crl-14716 141 4 all all PRON crl-14716 141 5 who who PRON crl-14716 141 6 advocate advocate VERB crl-14716 141 7 the the DET crl-14716 141 8 virtues virtue NOUN crl-14716 141 9 of of ADP crl-14716 141 10 user user NOUN crl-14716 141 11 independence independence NOUN crl-14716 141 12 do do VERB crl-14716 141 13 so so ADV crl-14716 141 14 simply simply ADV crl-14716 141 15 because because SCONJ crl-14716 141 16 of of ADP crl-14716 141 17 their their PRON crl-14716 141 18 commitment commitment NOUN crl-14716 141 19 to to ADP crl-14716 141 20 a a DET crl-14716 141 21 particular particular ADJ crl-14716 141 22 philosophy philosophy NOUN crl-14716 141 23 about about ADP crl-14716 141 24 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 141 25 service service NOUN crl-14716 141 26 . . PUNCT crl-14716 142 1 rather rather ADV crl-14716 142 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 142 3 the the DET crl-14716 142 4 comments comment NOUN crl-14716 142 5 received receive VERB crl-14716 142 6 from from ADP crl-14716 142 7 the the DET crl-14716 142 8 respondents respondent NOUN crl-14716 142 9 indicate indicate VERB crl-14716 142 10 that that SCONJ crl-14716 142 11 , , PUNCT crl-14716 142 12 at at ADP crl-14716 142 13 least least ADJ crl-14716 142 14 for for ADP crl-14716 142 15 some some PRON crl-14716 142 16 , , PUNCT crl-14716 142 17 the the DET crl-14716 142 18 stress stress NOUN crl-14716 142 19 on on ADP crl-14716 142 20 user user NOUN crl-14716 142 21 education education NOUN crl-14716 142 22 has have VERB crl-14716 142 23 little little ADJ crl-14716 142 24 to to PART crl-14716 142 25 do do VERB crl-14716 142 26 with with ADP crl-14716 142 27 what what PRON crl-14716 142 28 is be AUX crl-14716 142 29 best good ADJ crl-14716 142 30 for for SCONJ crl-14716 142 31 the the DET crl-14716 142 32 user user NOUN crl-14716 142 33 and and CCONJ crl-14716 142 34 more more ADJ crl-14716 142 35 to to PART crl-14716 142 36 do do VERB crl-14716 142 37 with with ADP crl-14716 142 38 what what PRON crl-14716 142 39 is be AUX crl-14716 142 40 financially financially ADV crl-14716 142 41 expedient expedient ADJ crl-14716 142 42 . . PUNCT crl-14716 143 1 references reference NOUN crl-14716 143 2 and and CCONJ crl-14716 143 3 notes note NOUN crl-14716 143 4 1 1 NUM crl-14716 143 5 . . PUNCT crl-14716 143 6 tom tom PROPN crl-14716 143 7 eadie eadie PROPN crl-14716 143 8 , , PUNCT crl-14716 143 9 " " PUNCT crl-14716 143 10 immodest immodest ADJ crl-14716 143 11 proposals proposal NOUN crl-14716 143 12 , , PUNCT crl-14716 143 13 " " PUNCT crl-14716 143 14 library library NOUN crl-14716 143 15 ] ] PUNCT crl-14716 143 16 ournal115:43 ournal115:43 PROPN crl-14716 143 17 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 143 18 oct oct PROPN crl-14716 143 19 . . PROPN crl-14716 143 20 1990 1990 NUM crl-14716 143 21 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 143 22 . . PUNCT crl-14716 144 1 2 2 X crl-14716 144 2 . . X crl-14716 144 3 mona mona PROPN crl-14716 144 4 mccormick mccormick PROPN crl-14716 144 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 144 6 " " PUNCT crl-14716 144 7 critical critical ADJ crl-14716 144 8 thinking thinking NOUN crl-14716 144 9 and and CCONJ crl-14716 144 10 library library NOUN crl-14716 144 11 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 144 12 , , PUNCT crl-14716 144 13 " " PUNCT crl-14716 144 14 rq rq X crl-14716 144 15 22:339 22:339 NUM crl-14716 144 16 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 144 17 summer summer NOUN crl-14716 144 18 1983 1983 NUM crl-14716 144 19 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 144 20 . . PUNCT crl-14716 145 1 3 3 X crl-14716 145 2 . . PROPN crl-14716 145 3 mary mary PROPN crl-14716 145 4 huston huston PROPN crl-14716 145 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 145 6 " " PUNCT crl-14716 145 7 rethinking rethink VERB crl-14716 145 8 our our PRON crl-14716 145 9 approach approach NOUN crl-14716 145 10 for for ADP crl-14716 145 11 research research NOUN crl-14716 145 12 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 145 13 , , PUNCT crl-14716 145 14 " " PUNCT crl-14716 145 15 research research NOUN crl-14716 145 16 strategies strategy NOUN crl-14716 145 17 1:185 1:185 NUM crl-14716 145 18 - - SYM crl-14716 145 19 86 86 NUM crl-14716 145 20 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 145 21 1983 1983 NUM crl-14716 145 22 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 145 23 . . PUNCT crl-14716 146 1 4 4 X crl-14716 146 2 . . PROPN crl-14716 146 3 willie willie PROPN crl-14716 146 4 l. l. PROPN crl-14716 146 5 parson parson PROPN crl-14716 146 6 , , PUNCT crl-14716 146 7 " " PUNCT crl-14716 146 8 user user NOUN crl-14716 146 9 perspective perspective NOUN crl-14716 146 10 on on ADP crl-14716 146 11 a a DET crl-14716 146 12 new new ADJ crl-14716 146 13 paradigm paradigm NOUN crl-14716 146 14 for for ADP crl-14716 146 15 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-14716 146 16 , , PUNCT crl-14716 146 17 " " PUNCT crl-14716 146 18 college college NOUN crl-14716 146 19 & & CCONJ crl-14716 146 20 research research PROPN crl-14716 146 21 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 146 22 45:371 45:371 NUM crl-14716 146 23 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 146 24 sept sept PROPN crl-14716 146 25 . . PROPN crl-14716 146 26 1984 1984 NUM crl-14716 146 27 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 146 28 . . PUNCT crl-14716 147 1 5 5 X crl-14716 147 2 . . X crl-14716 147 3 eadie eadie PROPN crl-14716 147 4 , , PUNCT crl-14716 147 5 " " PUNCT crl-14716 147 6 immodest immodest ADJ crl-14716 147 7 proposals proposal NOUN crl-14716 147 8 , , PUNCT crl-14716 147 9 " " PUNCT crl-14716 147 10 p.45 p.45 X crl-14716 147 11 . . PUNCT crl-14716 148 1 6 6 X crl-14716 148 2 . . X crl-14716 148 3 pauline pauline PROPN crl-14716 148 4 wilson wilson PROPN crl-14716 148 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 148 6 " " PUNCT crl-14716 148 7 librarians librarian VERB crl-14716 148 8 as as ADP crl-14716 148 9 teachers teacher NOUN crl-14716 148 10 : : PUNCT crl-14716 148 11 the the DET crl-14716 148 12 study study NOUN crl-14716 148 13 of of ADP crl-14716 148 14 an an DET crl-14716 148 15 organization organization NOUN crl-14716 148 16 fiction fiction NOUN crl-14716 148 17 , , PUNCT crl-14716 148 18 " " PUNCT crl-14716 148 19 library library NOUN crl-14716 148 20 quarterly quarterly PROPN crl-14716 148 21 49:146 49:146 PROPN crl-14716 148 22 - - SYM crl-14716 148 23 52 52 NUM crl-14716 148 24 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 148 25 apr apr NOUN crl-14716 148 26 . . PROPN crl-14716 148 27 1979 1979 NUM crl-14716 148 28 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 148 29 . . PUNCT crl-14716 149 1 7 7 X crl-14716 149 2 . . PROPN crl-14716 149 3 charles charles PROPN crl-14716 149 4 d. d. PROPN crl-14716 149 5 patterson patterson PROPN crl-14716 149 6 and and CCONJ crl-14716 149 7 donna donna PROPN crl-14716 149 8 w. w. PROPN crl-14716 149 9 howell howell PROPN crl-14716 149 10 , , PUNCT crl-14716 149 11 " " PUNCT crl-14716 149 12 library library NOUN crl-14716 149 13 user user NOUN crl-14716 149 14 education education NOUN crl-14716 149 15 : : PUNCT crl-14716 149 16 assessing assess VERB crl-14716 149 17 the the DET crl-14716 149 18 attitudes attitude NOUN crl-14716 149 19 of of ADP crl-14716 149 20 those those PRON crl-14716 149 21 who who PRON crl-14716 149 22 teach teach VERB crl-14716 149 23 , , PUNCT crl-14716 149 24 " " PUNCT crl-14716 149 25 rq rq X crl-14716 149 26 29:515 29:515 NUM crl-14716 149 27 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 149 28 summer summer NOUN crl-14716 149 29 1990 1990 NUM crl-14716 149 30 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 149 31 . . PUNCT crl-14716 150 1 8 8 X crl-14716 150 2 . . PROPN crl-14716 150 3 anne anne PROPN crl-14716 150 4 f. f. PROPN crl-14716 150 5 roberts roberts PROPN crl-14716 150 6 , , PUNCT crl-14716 150 7 " " PUNCT crl-14716 150 8 training training NOUN crl-14716 150 9 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 150 10 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 150 11 using use VERB crl-14716 150 12 library library NOUN crl-14716 150 13 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 150 14 methods method NOUN crl-14716 150 15 , , PUNCT crl-14716 150 16 " " PUNCT crl-14716 150 17 the the DET crl-14716 150 18 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 150 19 librarian10:70 librarian10:70 NOUN crl-14716 150 20 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 150 21 spring spring NOUN crl-14716 150 22 / / SYM crl-14716 150 23 summer summer NOUN crl-14716 150 24 1984 1984 NUM crl-14716 150 25 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 150 26 . . PUNCT crl-14716 151 1 9 9 X crl-14716 151 2 . . PROPN crl-14716 151 3 brian brian PROPN crl-14716 151 4 nielsen nielsen PROPN crl-14716 151 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 151 6 " " PUNCT crl-14716 151 7 teacher teacher NOUN crl-14716 151 8 or or CCONJ crl-14716 151 9 intermediary intermediary NOUN crl-14716 151 10 : : PUNCT crl-14716 151 11 alternative alternative ADJ crl-14716 151 12 professional professional ADJ crl-14716 151 13 models model NOUN crl-14716 151 14 in in ADP crl-14716 151 15 the the DET crl-14716 151 16 information information NOUN crl-14716 151 17 age age NOUN crl-14716 151 18 , , PUNCT crl-14716 151 19 " " PUNCT crl-14716 151 20 in in ADP crl-14716 151 21 constance constance PROPN crl-14716 151 22 a. a. NOUN crl-14716 151 23 mellon mellon PROPN crl-14716 151 24 , , PUNCT crl-14716 151 25 ed ed PROPN crl-14716 151 26 . . PROPN crl-14716 151 27 , , PUNCT crl-14716 151 28 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 151 29 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 151 30 : : PUNCT crl-14716 151 31 the the DET crl-14716 151 32 second second ADJ crl-14716 151 33 generation generation NOUN crl-14716 151 34 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 151 35 littleton littleton PROPN crl-14716 151 36 , , PUNCT crl-14716 151 37 colo colo PROPN crl-14716 151 38 . . PUNCT crl-14716 151 39 : : PUNCT crl-14716 151 40 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 151 41 unlimited unlimited ADJ crl-14716 151 42 , , PUNCT crl-14716 151 43 1987 1987 NUM crl-14716 151 44 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 151 45 , , PUNCT crl-14716 151 46 p.32 p.32 PROPN crl-14716 151 47 . . PUNCT crl-14716 152 1 10 10 NUM crl-14716 152 2 . . PUNCT crl-14716 152 3 roma roma PROPN crl-14716 152 4 m. m. PROPN crl-14716 152 5 harris harris PROPN crl-14716 152 6 , , PUNCT crl-14716 152 7 " " PUNCT crl-14716 152 8 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-14716 152 9 instruction instruction NOUN crl-14716 152 10 in in ADP crl-14716 152 11 public public ADJ crl-14716 152 12 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 152 13 : : PUNCT crl-14716 152 14 a a DET crl-14716 152 15 question question NOUN crl-14716 152 16 of of ADP crl-14716 152 17 philosophy philosophy NOUN crl-14716 152 18 , , PUNCT crl-14716 152 19 " " PUNCT crl-14716 152 20 rq rq X crl-14716 152 21 29:92 29:92 NUM crl-14716 152 22 - - SYM crl-14716 152 23 98 98 NUM crl-14716 152 24 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 152 25 fall fall NOUN crl-14716 152 26 1989 1989 NUM crl-14716 152 27 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 152 28 . . PUNCT crl-14716 153 1 11 11 X crl-14716 153 2 . . PUNCT crl-14716 153 3 see see VERB crl-14716 153 4 connie connie PROPN crl-14716 153 5 miller miller PROPN crl-14716 153 6 and and CCONJ crl-14716 153 7 patricia patricia PROPN crl-14716 153 8 tegler tegler NOUN crl-14716 153 9 , , PUNCT crl-14716 153 10 " " PUNCT crl-14716 153 11 in in ADP crl-14716 153 12 pursuit pursuit NOUN crl-14716 153 13 of of ADP crl-14716 153 14 windmills windmill NOUN crl-14716 153 15 : : PUNCT crl-14716 153 16 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 153 17 and and CCONJ crl-14716 153 18 the the DET crl-14716 153 19 determination determination NOUN crl-14716 153 20 to to PART crl-14716 153 21 instruct instruct VERB crl-14716 153 22 , , PUNCT crl-14716 153 23 " " PUNCT crl-14716 153 24 the the DET crl-14716 153 25 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 153 26 librarian librarian PROPN crl-14716 153 27 18:119 18:119 NUM crl-14716 153 28 - - SYM crl-14716 153 29 34 34 NUM crl-14716 153 30 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 153 31 summer summer NOUN crl-14716 153 32 1987 1987 NUM crl-14716 153 33 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 153 34 . . PUNCT crl-14716 154 1 12 12 NUM crl-14716 154 2 . . PUNCT crl-14716 155 1 school school NOUN crl-14716 155 2 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 155 3 were be AUX crl-14716 155 4 excluded exclude VERB crl-14716 155 5 from from ADP crl-14716 155 6 the the DET crl-14716 155 7 study study NOUN crl-14716 155 8 because because SCONJ crl-14716 155 9 in in ADP crl-14716 155 10 canada canada PROPN crl-14716 155 11 their their PRON crl-14716 155 12 professional professional ADJ crl-14716 155 13 training training NOUN crl-14716 155 14 and and CCONJ crl-14716 155 15 the the DET crl-14716 155 16 conditions condition NOUN crl-14716 155 17 of of ADP crl-14716 155 18 their their PRON crl-14716 155 19 work work NOUN crl-14716 155 20 are be AUX crl-14716 155 21 quite quite ADV crl-14716 155 22 different different ADJ crl-14716 155 23 than than ADP crl-14716 155 24 those those PRON crl-14716 155 25 of of ADP crl-14716 155 26 other other ADJ crl-14716 155 27 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 155 28 . . PUNCT crl-14716 156 1 indeed indeed ADV crl-14716 156 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 156 3 they they PRON crl-14716 156 4 are be AUX crl-14716 156 5 generally generally ADV crl-14716 156 6 considered consider VERB crl-14716 156 7 to to PART crl-14716 156 8 belong belong VERB crl-14716 156 9 to to ADP crl-14716 156 10 the the DET crl-14716 156 11 teaching teaching NOUN crl-14716 156 12 profession profession NOUN crl-14716 156 13 rather rather ADV crl-14716 156 14 than than ADP crl-14716 156 15 to to ADP crl-14716 156 16 that that PRON crl-14716 156 17 of of ADP crl-14716 156 18 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-14716 156 19 . . PUNCT crl-14716 157 1 13 13 NUM crl-14716 157 2 . . PUNCT crl-14716 158 1 see see VERB crl-14716 158 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 158 3 for for ADP crl-14716 158 4 example example NOUN crl-14716 158 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 158 6 david david PROPN crl-14716 158 7 peele peele PROPN crl-14716 158 8 , , PUNCT crl-14716 158 9 " " PUNCT crl-14716 158 10 librarians librarian VERB crl-14716 158 11 as as ADP crl-14716 158 12 teachers teacher NOUN crl-14716 158 13 : : PUNCT crl-14716 158 14 some some DET crl-14716 158 15 reality reality NOUN crl-14716 158 16 , , PUNCT crl-14716 158 17 mostly mostly ADV crl-14716 158 18 myth myth NOUN crl-14716 158 19 , , PUNCT crl-14716 158 20 " " PUNCT crl-14716 158 21 journal journal NOUN crl-14716 158 22 of of ADP crl-14716 158 23 academic academic ADJ crl-14716 158 24 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-14716 158 25 10:267 10:267 NUM crl-14716 158 26 - - SYM crl-14716 158 27 71 71 NUM crl-14716 158 28 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 158 29 nov nov PROPN crl-14716 158 30 . . PROPN crl-14716 158 31 1984 1984 NUM crl-14716 158 32 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 158 33 . . PUNCT crl-14716 159 1 14 14 NUM crl-14716 159 2 . . PUNCT crl-14716 160 1 see see VERB crl-14716 160 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 160 3 for for ADP crl-14716 160 4 example example NOUN crl-14716 160 5 , , PUNCT crl-14716 160 6 gaby gaby NOUN crl-14716 160 7 divay divay NOUN crl-14716 160 8 , , PUNCT crl-14716 160 9 adam adam PROPN crl-14716 160 10 . . PUNCT crl-14716 160 11 ducas ducas PROPN crl-14716 160 12 , , PUNCT crl-14716 160 13 and and CCONJ crl-14716 160 14 nicole nicole PROPN crl-14716 160 15 michaud michaud NOUN crl-14716 160 16 - - PUNCT crl-14716 160 17 ostryk ostryk ADV crl-14716 160 18 , , PUNCT crl-14716 160 19 " " PUNCT crl-14716 160 20 faculty faculty NOUN crl-14716 160 21 perceptions perception NOUN crl-14716 160 22 of of ADP crl-14716 160 23 the the DET crl-14716 160 24 librarians librarians PROPN crl-14716 160 25 at at ADP crl-14716 160 26 the the DET crl-14716 160 27 university university PROPN crl-14716 160 28 of of ADP crl-14716 160 29 manitoba manitoba PROPN crl-14716 160 30 , , PUNCT crl-14716 160 31 " " PUNCT crl-14716 160 32 college college NOUN crl-14716 160 33 & & CCONJ crl-14716 160 34 research research PROPN crl-14716 160 35 libraries library NOUN crl-14716 160 36 , , PUNCT crl-14716 160 37 48:27 48:27 NUM crl-14716 160 38 - - SYM crl-14716 160 39 35 35 NUM crl-14716 160 40 ( ( PUNCT crl-14716 160 41 jan jan PROPN crl-14716 160 42 . . PROPN crl-14716 160 43 1987 1987 NUM crl-14716 160 44 ) ) PUNCT crl-14716 160 45 . . PUNCT crl-14716 161 1 15 15 NUM crl-14716 161 2 . . X crl-14716 161 3 patterson patterson PROPN crl-14716 161 4 and and CCONJ crl-14716 161 5 howell howell PROPN crl-14716 161 6 , , PUNCT crl-14716 161 7 " " PUNCT crl-14716 161 8 library library NOUN crl-14716 161 9 user user NOUN crl-14716 161 10 education education NOUN crl-14716 161 11 , , PUNCT crl-14716 161 12 " " PUNCT crl-14716 161 13 p.522 p.522 NOUN crl-14716 161 14 . . PUNCT crl-14716 162 1 16 16 NUM crl-14716 162 2 . . PUNCT crl-14716 163 1 roberts robert NOUN crl-14716 163 2 , , PUNCT crl-14716 163 3 " " PUNCT crl-14716 163 4 training training NOUN crl-14716 163 5 reference reference NOUN crl-14716 163 6 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14716 163 7 , , PUNCT crl-14716 163 8 " " PUNCT crl-14716 163 9 p.70 p.70 X crl-14716 163 10 . . PUNCT