id sid tid token lemma pos crln-9068 1 1 feb14_b.indd feb14_b.indd NOUN crln-9068 1 2 february february PROPN crln-9068 1 3 2014 2014 NUM crln-9068 1 4 69 69 NUM crln-9068 1 5 c&rl c&rl NOUN crln-9068 1 6 news news NOUN crln-9068 1 7 the the DET crln-9068 1 8 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 1 9 first first ADJ crln-9068 1 10 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 1 11 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 1 12 doctrine doctrine NOUN crln-9068 1 13 gives give VERB crln-9068 1 14 the the DET crln-9068 1 15 owners owner NOUN crln-9068 1 16 of of ADP crln-9068 1 17 copyrighted copyright VERB crln-9068 1 18 works work VERB crln-9068 1 19 the the DET crln-9068 1 20 rights right NOUN crln-9068 1 21 to to PART crln-9068 1 22 sell sell VERB crln-9068 1 23 , , PUNCT crln-9068 1 24 lend lend VERB crln-9068 1 25 , , PUNCT crln-9068 1 26 or or CCONJ crln-9068 1 27 share share VERB crln-9068 1 28 their their PRON crln-9068 1 29 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 1 30 without without ADP crln-9068 1 31 having have VERB crln-9068 1 32 to to PART crln-9068 1 33 obtain obtain VERB crln-9068 1 34 permission permission NOUN crln-9068 1 35 or or CCONJ crln-9068 1 36 pay pay VERB crln-9068 1 37 fees fee NOUN crln-9068 1 38 . . PUNCT crln-9068 2 1 the the DET crln-9068 2 2 copy copy NOUN crln-9068 2 3 becomes become VERB crln-9068 2 4 like like ADP crln-9068 2 5 any any DET crln-9068 2 6 piece piece NOUN crln-9068 2 7 of of ADP crln-9068 2 8 physical physical ADJ crln-9068 2 9 property property NOUN crln-9068 2 10 ; ; PUNCT crln-9068 2 11 you you PRON crln-9068 2 12 ’ve ’ve AUX crln-9068 2 13 purchased purchase VERB crln-9068 2 14 it it PRON crln-9068 2 15 , , PUNCT crln-9068 2 16 you you PRON crln-9068 2 17 own own VERB crln-9068 2 18 it it PRON crln-9068 2 19 . . PUNCT crln-9068 3 1 you you PRON crln-9068 3 2 can can AUX crln-9068 3 3 not not PART crln-9068 3 4 make make VERB crln-9068 3 5 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 3 6 and and CCONJ crln-9068 3 7 sell sell VERB crln-9068 3 8 them they PRON crln-9068 3 9 — — PUNCT crln-9068 3 10 the the DET crln-9068 3 11 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 3 12 owner owner NOUN crln-9068 3 13 retains retain VERB crln-9068 3 14 those those DET crln-9068 3 15 rights right NOUN crln-9068 3 16 . . PUNCT crln-9068 4 1 but but CCONJ crln-9068 4 2 the the DET crln-9068 4 3 physical physical ADJ crln-9068 4 4 book book NOUN crln-9068 4 5 is be AUX crln-9068 4 6 yours yours PRON crln-9068 4 7 . . PUNCT crln-9068 5 1 first first ADJ crln-9068 5 2 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 5 3 has have AUX crln-9068 5 4 long long ADV crln-9068 5 5 been be AUX crln-9068 5 6 important important ADJ crln-9068 5 7 for for ADP crln-9068 5 8 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 5 9 , , PUNCT crln-9068 5 10 as as SCONJ crln-9068 5 11 it it PRON crln-9068 5 12 allows allow VERB crln-9068 5 13 them they PRON crln-9068 5 14 to to PART crln-9068 5 15 lend lend VERB crln-9068 5 16 books book NOUN crln-9068 5 17 without without ADP crln-9068 5 18 legal legal ADJ crln-9068 5 19 hurdles hurdle NOUN crln-9068 5 20 . . PUNCT crln-9068 6 1 the the DET crln-9068 6 2 first first ADJ crln-9068 6 3 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 6 4 doctrine doctrine NOUN crln-9068 6 5 originated originate VERB crln-9068 6 6 in in ADP crln-9068 6 7 the the DET crln-9068 6 8 1908 1908 NUM crln-9068 6 9 supreme supreme PROPN crln-9068 6 10 court court PROPN crln-9068 6 11 decision decision NOUN crln-9068 6 12 bobbs bobb VERB crln-9068 6 13 - - PUNCT crln-9068 6 14 merrill merrill PROPN crln-9068 6 15 co. co. PROPN crln-9068 6 16 v. v. PROPN crln-9068 6 17 straus straus PROPN crln-9068 6 18 . . PUNCT crln-9068 7 1 the the DET crln-9068 7 2 publisher publisher NOUN crln-9068 7 3 had have AUX crln-9068 7 4 put put VERB crln-9068 7 5 this this DET crln-9068 7 6 notice notice NOUN crln-9068 7 7 on on ADP crln-9068 7 8 its its PRON crln-9068 7 9 novel novel NOUN crln-9068 7 10 : : PUNCT crln-9068 7 11 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 7 12 the the DET crln-9068 7 13 price price NOUN crln-9068 7 14 of of ADP crln-9068 7 15 this this DET crln-9068 7 16 book book NOUN crln-9068 7 17 at at ADP crln-9068 7 18 retail retail NOUN crln-9068 7 19 is be AUX crln-9068 7 20 $ $ SYM crln-9068 7 21 1 1 NUM crln-9068 7 22 net net NOUN crln-9068 7 23 . . PUNCT crln-9068 8 1 no no DET crln-9068 8 2 dealer dealer NOUN crln-9068 8 3 is be AUX crln-9068 8 4 licensed license VERB crln-9068 8 5 to to PART crln-9068 8 6 sell sell VERB crln-9068 8 7 it it PRON crln-9068 8 8 at at ADP crln-9068 8 9 a a DET crln-9068 8 10 less less ADJ crln-9068 8 11 price price NOUN crln-9068 8 12 , , PUNCT crln-9068 8 13 and and CCONJ crln-9068 8 14 a a DET crln-9068 8 15 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 8 16 at at ADP crln-9068 8 17 a a DET crln-9068 8 18 less less ADJ crln-9068 8 19 price price NOUN crln-9068 8 20 will will AUX crln-9068 8 21 be be AUX crln-9068 8 22 treated treat VERB crln-9068 8 23 as as ADP crln-9068 8 24 an an DET crln-9068 8 25 infringement infringement NOUN crln-9068 8 26 of of ADP crln-9068 8 27 the the DET crln-9068 8 28 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 8 29 . . PUNCT crln-9068 8 30 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 9 1 at at ADP crln-9068 9 2 the the DET crln-9068 9 3 time time NOUN crln-9068 9 4 , , PUNCT crln-9068 9 5 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 9 6 owners owner NOUN crln-9068 9 7 enjoyed enjoy VERB crln-9068 9 8 the the DET crln-9068 9 9 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 9 10 sole sole ADJ crln-9068 9 11 right right NOUN crln-9068 9 12 . . PUNCT crln-9068 9 13 . . PUNCT crln-9068 9 14 . . PUNCT crln-9068 10 1 of of ADP crln-9068 10 2 printing printing NOUN crln-9068 10 3 , , PUNCT crln-9068 10 4 reprinting reprint VERB crln-9068 10 5 , , PUNCT crln-9068 10 6 publishing publishing NOUN crln-9068 10 7 , , PUNCT crln-9068 10 8 and and CCONJ crln-9068 10 9 vending vend VERB crln-9068 10 10 . . PUNCT crln-9068 10 11 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 11 1 the the DET crln-9068 11 2 court court NOUN crln-9068 11 3 held hold VERB crln-9068 11 4 that that SCONJ crln-9068 11 5 congress congress PROPN crln-9068 11 6 did do AUX crln-9068 11 7 not not PART crln-9068 11 8 intend intend VERB crln-9068 11 9 for for ADP crln-9068 11 10 the the DET crln-9068 11 11 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 11 12 vending vend VERB crln-9068 11 13 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 11 14 right right NOUN crln-9068 11 15 to to PART crln-9068 11 16 extend extend VERB crln-9068 11 17 beyond beyond ADP crln-9068 11 18 the the DET crln-9068 11 19 initial initial ADJ crln-9068 11 20 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 11 21 : : PUNCT crln-9068 11 22 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 11 23 one one NUM crln-9068 11 24 who who PRON crln-9068 11 25 has have AUX crln-9068 11 26 sold sell VERB crln-9068 11 27 a a DET crln-9068 11 28 copyrighted copyright VERB crln-9068 11 29 article article NOUN crln-9068 11 30 , , PUNCT crln-9068 11 31 without without ADP crln-9068 11 32 restriction restriction NOUN crln-9068 11 33 , , PUNCT crln-9068 11 34 has have AUX crln-9068 11 35 parted part VERB crln-9068 11 36 with with ADP crln-9068 11 37 all all DET crln-9068 11 38 right right NOUN crln-9068 11 39 to to PART crln-9068 11 40 control control VERB crln-9068 11 41 the the DET crln-9068 11 42 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 11 43 of of ADP crln-9068 11 44 it it PRON crln-9068 11 45 . . PUNCT crln-9068 12 1 the the DET crln-9068 12 2 purchaser purchaser NOUN crln-9068 12 3 of of ADP crln-9068 12 4 a a DET crln-9068 12 5 book book NOUN crln-9068 12 6 . . PUNCT crln-9068 12 7 . . PUNCT crln-9068 12 8 . . PUNCT crln-9068 13 1 may may AUX crln-9068 13 2 sell sell VERB crln-9068 13 3 it it PRON crln-9068 13 4 again again ADV crln-9068 13 5 , , PUNCT crln-9068 13 6 although although SCONJ crln-9068 13 7 he he PRON crln-9068 13 8 could could AUX crln-9068 13 9 not not PART crln-9068 13 10 publish publish VERB crln-9068 13 11 a a DET crln-9068 13 12 new new ADJ crln-9068 13 13 edition edition NOUN crln-9068 13 14 of of ADP crln-9068 13 15 it it PRON crln-9068 13 16 . . PUNCT crln-9068 13 17 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 14 1 the the DET crln-9068 14 2 year year NOUN crln-9068 14 3 after after ADP crln-9068 14 4 the the DET crln-9068 14 5 bobbs bobbs NOUN crln-9068 14 6 - - PUNCT crln-9068 14 7 merrill merrill NOUN crln-9068 14 8 decision decision NOUN crln-9068 14 9 , , PUNCT crln-9068 14 10 the the DET crln-9068 14 11 first first ADJ crln-9068 14 12 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 14 13 doctrine doctrine NOUN crln-9068 14 14 was be AUX crln-9068 14 15 codified codify VERB crln-9068 14 16 in in ADP crln-9068 14 17 the the DET crln-9068 14 18 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 14 19 statute statute NOUN crln-9068 14 20 , , PUNCT crln-9068 14 21 and and CCONJ crln-9068 14 22 it it PRON crln-9068 14 23 is be AUX crln-9068 14 24 currently currently ADV crln-9068 14 25 in in ADP crln-9068 14 26 section section NOUN crln-9068 14 27 109(a 109(a NUM crln-9068 14 28 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 14 29 of of ADP crln-9068 14 30 our our PRON crln-9068 14 31 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 14 32 law law NOUN crln-9068 14 33 . . PUNCT crln-9068 15 1 you you PRON crln-9068 15 2 own own VERB crln-9068 15 3 your your PRON crln-9068 15 4 books book NOUN crln-9068 15 5 . . PUNCT crln-9068 16 1 at at ADP crln-9068 16 2 least least ADJ crln-9068 16 3 the the DET crln-9068 16 4 physical physical ADJ crln-9068 16 5 ones one NOUN crln-9068 16 6 . . PUNCT crln-9068 17 1 first first ADJ crln-9068 17 2 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 17 3 produces produce VERB crln-9068 17 4 a a DET crln-9068 17 5 number number NOUN crln-9068 17 6 of of ADP crln-9068 17 7 benefits benefit NOUN crln-9068 17 8 . . PUNCT crln-9068 18 1 allowing allow VERB crln-9068 18 2 consumers consumer NOUN crln-9068 18 3 to to PART crln-9068 18 4 sell sell VERB crln-9068 18 5 their their PRON crln-9068 18 6 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 18 7 of of ADP crln-9068 18 8 copyrighted copyright VERB crln-9068 18 9 works work NOUN crln-9068 18 10 creates create VERB crln-9068 18 11 a a DET crln-9068 18 12 competitive competitive ADJ crln-9068 18 13 market market NOUN crln-9068 18 14 for for ADP crln-9068 18 15 less less ADV crln-9068 18 16 expensive expensive ADJ crln-9068 18 17 second second ADJ crln-9068 18 18 - - PUNCT crln-9068 18 19 hand hand NOUN crln-9068 18 20 goods good NOUN crln-9068 18 21 . . PUNCT crln-9068 19 1 the the DET crln-9068 19 2 person person NOUN crln-9068 19 3 who who PRON crln-9068 19 4 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 19 5 ca can AUX crln-9068 19 6 n’t not PART crln-9068 19 7 wait wait VERB crln-9068 19 8 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 19 9 for for SCONJ crln-9068 19 10 the the DET crln-9068 19 11 new new PROPN crln-9068 19 12 harry harry PROPN crln-9068 19 13 potter potter PROPN crln-9068 19 14 pays pay VERB crln-9068 19 15 for for ADP crln-9068 19 16 the the DET crln-9068 19 17 hardback hardback NOUN crln-9068 19 18 . . PUNCT crln-9068 20 1 the the DET crln-9068 20 2 casual casual ADJ crln-9068 20 3 fan fan NOUN crln-9068 20 4 waits wait NOUN crln-9068 20 5 for for ADP crln-9068 20 6 the the DET crln-9068 20 7 paperback paperback NOUN crln-9068 20 8 . . PUNCT crln-9068 21 1 the the DET crln-9068 21 2 impoverished impoverished ADJ crln-9068 21 3 potter potter NOUN crln-9068 21 4 - - PUNCT crln-9068 21 5 lover lover PROPN crln-9068 21 6 can can AUX crln-9068 21 7 buy buy VERB crln-9068 21 8 the the DET crln-9068 21 9 used use VERB crln-9068 21 10 book book NOUN crln-9068 21 11 . . PUNCT crln-9068 22 1 and and CCONJ crln-9068 22 2 , , PUNCT crln-9068 22 3 of of ADP crln-9068 22 4 course course NOUN crln-9068 22 5 , , PUNCT crln-9068 22 6 first first ADJ crln-9068 22 7 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 22 8 makes make VERB crln-9068 22 9 it it PRON crln-9068 22 10 possible possible ADJ crln-9068 22 11 for for SCONJ crln-9068 22 12 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 22 13 to to PART crln-9068 22 14 fulfill fulfill VERB crln-9068 22 15 their their PRON crln-9068 22 16 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 22 17 vital vital ADJ crln-9068 22 18 function function NOUN crln-9068 22 19 in in ADP crln-9068 22 20 society”1 society”1 NOUN crln-9068 22 21 by by ADP crln-9068 22 22 enabling enable VERB crln-9068 22 23 the the DET crln-9068 22 24 unrestricted unrestricted ADJ crln-9068 22 25 lending lending NOUN crln-9068 22 26 of of ADP crln-9068 22 27 books.2 books.2 PROPN crln-9068 22 28 why why SCONJ crln-9068 22 29 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 22 30 ca can AUX crln-9068 22 31 n’t not PART crln-9068 22 32 freely freely ADV crln-9068 22 33 lend lend VERB crln-9068 22 34 e e NOUN crln-9068 22 35 - - NOUN crln-9068 22 36 books book NOUN crln-9068 22 37 , , PUNCT crln-9068 22 38 part part NOUN crln-9068 22 39 1 1 NUM crln-9068 22 40 : : PUNCT crln-9068 22 41 they they PRON crln-9068 22 42 ’re ’re AUX crln-9068 22 43 licensed license VERB crln-9068 22 44 , , PUNCT crln-9068 22 45 not not PART crln-9068 22 46 sold sell VERB crln-9068 22 47 while while SCONJ crln-9068 22 48 physical physical ADJ crln-9068 22 49 books book NOUN crln-9068 22 50 are be AUX crln-9068 22 51 generally generally ADV crln-9068 22 52 sold sell VERB crln-9068 22 53 or or CCONJ crln-9068 22 54 donated donate VERB crln-9068 22 55 to to ADP crln-9068 22 56 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 22 57 , , PUNCT crln-9068 22 58 most most ADJ crln-9068 22 59 electronic electronic ADJ crln-9068 22 60 books book NOUN crln-9068 22 61 and and CCONJ crln-9068 22 62 journals journal NOUN crln-9068 22 63 are be AUX crln-9068 22 64 licensed license VERB crln-9068 22 65 , , PUNCT crln-9068 22 66 meaning mean VERB crln-9068 22 67 that that SCONJ crln-9068 22 68 first first ADJ crln-9068 22 69 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 22 70 might might AUX crln-9068 22 71 not not PART crln-9068 22 72 apply apply VERB crln-9068 22 73 . . PUNCT crln-9068 23 1 these these DET crln-9068 23 2 licenses license NOUN crln-9068 23 3 restrict restrict VERB crln-9068 23 4 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 23 5 ’ ' PUNCT crln-9068 23 6 uses use NOUN crln-9068 23 7 of of ADP crln-9068 23 8 e e NOUN crln-9068 23 9 - - NOUN crln-9068 23 10 books book NOUN crln-9068 23 11 . . PUNCT crln-9068 24 1 if if SCONJ crln-9068 24 2 a a DET crln-9068 24 3 library library NOUN crln-9068 24 4 has have VERB crln-9068 24 5 a a DET crln-9068 24 6 physical physical ADJ crln-9068 24 7 book book NOUN crln-9068 24 8 , , PUNCT crln-9068 24 9 it it PRON crln-9068 24 10 can can AUX crln-9068 24 11 loan loan VERB crln-9068 24 12 it it PRON crln-9068 24 13 out out ADP crln-9068 24 14 as as ADV crln-9068 24 15 many many ADJ crln-9068 24 16 times time NOUN crln-9068 24 17 as as SCONJ crln-9068 24 18 it it PRON crln-9068 24 19 is be AUX crln-9068 24 20 requested request VERB crln-9068 24 21 . . PUNCT crln-9068 25 1 it it PRON crln-9068 25 2 can can AUX crln-9068 25 3 send send VERB crln-9068 25 4 the the DET crln-9068 25 5 book book NOUN crln-9068 25 6 to to ADP crln-9068 25 7 another another DET crln-9068 25 8 institution institution NOUN crln-9068 25 9 via via ADP crln-9068 25 10 interlibrary interlibrary ADJ crln-9068 25 11 loan loan NOUN crln-9068 25 12 . . PUNCT crln-9068 26 1 licenses license NOUN crln-9068 26 2 often often ADV crln-9068 26 3 limit limit VERB crln-9068 26 4 these these DET crln-9068 26 5 activities activity NOUN crln-9068 26 6 . . PUNCT crln-9068 27 1 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 27 2 rights right NOUN crln-9068 27 3 management management NOUN crln-9068 27 4 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 27 5 drm drm X crln-9068 27 6 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 27 7 adds add VERB crln-9068 27 8 a a DET crln-9068 27 9 layer layer NOUN crln-9068 27 10 of of ADP crln-9068 27 11 technological technological ADJ crln-9068 27 12 controls control NOUN crln-9068 27 13 that that PRON crln-9068 27 14 further far ADV crln-9068 27 15 restrain restrain VERB crln-9068 27 16 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 27 17 ’ ' PUNCT crln-9068 27 18 freedoms freedom NOUN crln-9068 27 19 . . PUNCT crln-9068 28 1 jennifer jennifer PROPN crln-9068 28 2 jenkins jenkins PROPN crln-9068 28 3 is be AUX crln-9068 28 4 senior senior ADJ crln-9068 28 5 lecturing lecture VERB crln-9068 28 6 fellow fellow NOUN crln-9068 28 7 at at ADP crln-9068 28 8 duke duke PROPN crln-9068 28 9 law law NOUN crln-9068 28 10 school school NOUN crln-9068 28 11 and and CCONJ crln-9068 28 12 director director NOUN crln-9068 28 13 of of ADP crln-9068 28 14 the the DET crln-9068 28 15 center center NOUN crln-9068 28 16 for for ADP crln-9068 28 17 the the DET crln-9068 28 18 study study NOUN crln-9068 28 19 of of ADP crln-9068 28 20 the the DET crln-9068 28 21 public public ADJ crln-9068 28 22 domain domain NOUN crln-9068 28 23 , , PUNCT crln-9068 28 24 e e NOUN crln-9068 28 25 - - NOUN crln-9068 28 26 mail mail NOUN crln-9068 28 27 : : PUNCT crln-9068 28 28 jenkins@law.duke.edu jenkins@law.duke.edu PROPN crln-9068 28 29 contact contact NOUN crln-9068 28 30 series series NOUN crln-9068 28 31 editors editor NOUN crln-9068 29 1 zach zach VERB crln-9068 29 2 coble coble ADJ crln-9068 29 3 , , PUNCT crln-9068 29 4 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 29 5 scholarship scholarship NOUN crln-9068 29 6 specialist specialist NOUN crln-9068 29 7 at at ADP crln-9068 29 8 new new PROPN crln-9068 29 9 york york PROPN crln-9068 29 10 university university PROPN crln-9068 29 11 , , PUNCT crln-9068 29 12 and and CCONJ crln-9068 29 13 adrian adrian ADJ crln-9068 29 14 ho ho PROPN crln-9068 29 15 , , PUNCT crln-9068 29 16 director director NOUN crln-9068 29 17 of of ADP crln-9068 29 18 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 29 19 scholarship scholarship NOUN crln-9068 29 20 at at ADP crln-9068 29 21 the the DET crln-9068 29 22 university university PROPN crln-9068 29 23 of of ADP crln-9068 29 24 kentucky kentucky PROPN crln-9068 29 25 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 29 26 , , PUNCT crln-9068 29 27 at at ADP crln-9068 29 28 crlnscholcomm@gmail.com crlnscholcomm@gmail.com NUM crln-9068 29 29 with with ADP crln-9068 29 30 article article NOUN crln-9068 29 31 ideas idea NOUN crln-9068 29 32 © © PROPN crln-9068 29 33 2014 2014 NUM crln-9068 29 34 jennifer jennifer PROPN crln-9068 29 35 jenkins jenkins PROPN crln-9068 29 36 jennifer jennifer VERB crln-9068 29 37 jenkins jenkins PROPN crln-9068 29 38 last last ADJ crln-9068 29 39 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 29 40 ? ? PUNCT crln-9068 30 1 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 30 2 ’ ' PUNCT crln-9068 30 3 rights right NOUN crln-9068 30 4 in in ADP crln-9068 30 5 the the DET crln-9068 30 6 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 30 7 age age NOUN crln-9068 30 8 scholarly scholarly ADJ crln-9068 30 9 communication communication NOUN crln-9068 30 10 c&rl c&rl PROPN crln-9068 30 11 news news NOUN crln-9068 30 12 february february PROPN crln-9068 30 13 2014 2014 NUM crln-9068 30 14 70 70 NUM crln-9068 30 15 what what PRON crln-9068 30 16 ’s ’ VERB crln-9068 30 17 the the DET crln-9068 30 18 difference difference NOUN crln-9068 30 19 between between ADP crln-9068 30 20 a a DET crln-9068 30 21 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 30 22 and and CCONJ crln-9068 30 23 license license NOUN crln-9068 30 24 ? ? PUNCT crln-9068 31 1 normally normally ADV crln-9068 31 2 , , PUNCT crln-9068 31 3 the the DET crln-9068 31 4 law law NOUN crln-9068 31 5 is be AUX crln-9068 31 6 skeptical skeptical ADJ crln-9068 31 7 of of ADP crln-9068 31 8 limitations limitation NOUN crln-9068 31 9 on on ADP crln-9068 31 10 transfers transfer NOUN crln-9068 31 11 of of ADP crln-9068 31 12 property property NOUN crln-9068 31 13 . . PUNCT crln-9068 32 1 can can AUX crln-9068 32 2 snickers snicker NOUN crln-9068 32 3 say say VERB crln-9068 32 4 you you PRON crln-9068 32 5 merely merely ADV crln-9068 32 6 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 32 7 licensed license VERB crln-9068 32 8 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 32 9 that that SCONJ crln-9068 32 10 candy candy NOUN crln-9068 32 11 bar bar NOUN crln-9068 32 12 because because SCONJ crln-9068 32 13 there there PRON crln-9068 32 14 was be VERB crln-9068 32 15 fine fine ADJ crln-9068 32 16 print print NOUN crln-9068 32 17 on on ADP crln-9068 32 18 the the DET crln-9068 32 19 label label NOUN crln-9068 32 20 ? ? PUNCT crln-9068 33 1 a a DET crln-9068 33 2 court court NOUN crln-9068 33 3 would would AUX crln-9068 33 4 be be AUX crln-9068 33 5 unlikely unlikely ADJ crln-9068 33 6 to to PART crln-9068 33 7 agree agree VERB crln-9068 33 8 . . PUNCT crln-9068 34 1 can can AUX crln-9068 34 2 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 34 3 argue argue VERB crln-9068 34 4 that that SCONJ crln-9068 34 5 though though SCONJ crln-9068 34 6 e e NOUN crln-9068 34 7 - - NOUN crln-9068 34 8 books book NOUN crln-9068 34 9 come come VERB crln-9068 34 10 with with ADP crln-9068 34 11 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 34 12 a a DET crln-9068 34 13 license license NOUN crln-9068 34 14 , , PUNCT crln-9068 34 15 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 34 16 the the DET crln-9068 34 17 library library NOUN crln-9068 34 18 is be AUX crln-9068 34 19 nevertheless nevertheless ADV crln-9068 34 20 an an DET crln-9068 34 21 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 34 22 owner owner NOUN crln-9068 34 23 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 34 24 with with ADP crln-9068 34 25 first first ADJ crln-9068 34 26 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 34 27 rights right NOUN crln-9068 34 28 ? ? PUNCT crln-9068 35 1 the the DET crln-9068 35 2 answer answer NOUN crln-9068 35 3 at at ADP crln-9068 35 4 the the DET crln-9068 35 5 moment moment NOUN crln-9068 35 6 is be AUX crln-9068 35 7 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 35 8 probably probably ADV crln-9068 35 9 not not PART crln-9068 35 10 . . PUNCT crln-9068 35 11 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 36 1 while while SCONJ crln-9068 36 2 the the DET crln-9068 36 3 law law NOUN crln-9068 36 4 in in ADP crln-9068 36 5 this this DET crln-9068 36 6 area area NOUN crln-9068 36 7 is be AUX crln-9068 36 8 unsettled unsettled ADJ crln-9068 36 9 , , PUNCT crln-9068 36 10 recent recent ADJ crln-9068 36 11 cases case NOUN crln-9068 36 12 favor favor VERB crln-9068 36 13 publishers publisher NOUN crln-9068 36 14 . . PUNCT crln-9068 37 1 an an DET crln-9068 37 2 influential influential ADJ crln-9068 37 3 case2 case2 NOUN crln-9068 37 4 held hold VERB crln-9068 37 5 that that SCONJ crln-9068 37 6 a a DET crln-9068 37 7 user user NOUN crln-9068 37 8 of of ADP crln-9068 37 9 copyrighted copyright VERB crln-9068 37 10 software software NOUN crln-9068 37 11 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 37 12 is be AUX crln-9068 37 13 a a DET crln-9068 37 14 licensee licensee NOUN crln-9068 37 15 rather rather ADV crln-9068 37 16 than than ADP crln-9068 37 17 an an DET crln-9068 37 18 owner owner NOUN crln-9068 37 19 of of ADP crln-9068 37 20 a a DET crln-9068 37 21 copy copy NOUN crln-9068 37 22 where where SCONJ crln-9068 37 23 the the DET crln-9068 37 24 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 37 25 owner owner NOUN crln-9068 37 26 : : PUNCT crln-9068 37 27 1 1 X crln-9068 37 28 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 37 29 specifies specify VERB crln-9068 37 30 that that SCONJ crln-9068 37 31 the the DET crln-9068 37 32 user user NOUN crln-9068 37 33 is be AUX crln-9068 37 34 granted grant VERB crln-9068 37 35 a a DET crln-9068 37 36 license license NOUN crln-9068 37 37 [ [ X crln-9068 37 38 as as SCONJ crln-9068 37 39 opposed oppose VERB crln-9068 37 40 to to ADP crln-9068 37 41 a a DET crln-9068 37 42 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 37 43 ] ] PUNCT crln-9068 37 44 ; ; PUNCT crln-9068 37 45 2 2 X crln-9068 37 46 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 37 47 significantly significantly ADV crln-9068 37 48 restricts restrict VERB crln-9068 37 49 the the DET crln-9068 37 50 user user NOUN crln-9068 37 51 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 37 52 ability ability NOUN crln-9068 37 53 to to PART crln-9068 37 54 transfer transfer VERB crln-9068 37 55 the the DET crln-9068 37 56 software software NOUN crln-9068 37 57 ; ; PUNCT crln-9068 37 58 and and CCONJ crln-9068 37 59 3 3 X crln-9068 37 60 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 37 61 imposes impose VERB crln-9068 37 62 notable notable ADJ crln-9068 37 63 use use NOUN crln-9068 37 64 restrictions restriction NOUN crln-9068 37 65 . . PUNCT crln-9068 37 66 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 38 1 ironically ironically ADV crln-9068 38 2 , , PUNCT crln-9068 38 3 the the DET crln-9068 38 4 more more ADJ crln-9068 38 5 restrictions restriction NOUN crln-9068 38 6 , , PUNCT crln-9068 38 7 the the PRON crln-9068 38 8 more more ADV crln-9068 38 9 likely likely ADJ crln-9068 38 10 the the DET crln-9068 38 11 law law NOUN crln-9068 38 12 will will AUX crln-9068 38 13 see see VERB crln-9068 38 14 a a DET crln-9068 38 15 license license NOUN crln-9068 38 16 , , PUNCT crln-9068 38 17 not not PART crln-9068 38 18 a a DET crln-9068 38 19 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 38 20 . . PUNCT crln-9068 39 1 this this PRON crln-9068 39 2 can can AUX crln-9068 39 3 be be AUX crln-9068 39 4 a a DET crln-9068 39 5 good good ADJ crln-9068 39 6 thing thing NOUN crln-9068 39 7 : : PUNCT crln-9068 39 8 licenses license NOUN crln-9068 39 9 facilitate facilitate VERB crln-9068 39 10 customized customize VERB crln-9068 39 11 pricing pricing NOUN crln-9068 39 12 , , PUNCT crln-9068 39 13 and and CCONJ crln-9068 39 14 restrictive restrictive ADJ crln-9068 39 15 terms term NOUN crln-9068 39 16 can can AUX crln-9068 39 17 counter counter VERB crln-9068 39 18 the the DET crln-9068 39 19 potential potential ADJ crln-9068 39 20 market market NOUN crln-9068 39 21 harm harm NOUN crln-9068 39 22 from from ADP crln-9068 39 23 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 39 24 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 39 25 . . PUNCT crln-9068 40 1 on on ADP crln-9068 40 2 the the DET crln-9068 40 3 other other ADJ crln-9068 40 4 hand hand NOUN crln-9068 40 5 , , PUNCT crln-9068 40 6 especially especially ADV crln-9068 40 7 with with ADP crln-9068 40 8 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 40 9 , , PUNCT crln-9068 40 10 licenses license NOUN crln-9068 40 11 restrict restrict VERB crln-9068 40 12 important important ADJ crln-9068 40 13 , , PUNCT crln-9068 40 14 beneficial beneficial ADJ crln-9068 40 15 activities activity NOUN crln-9068 40 16 — — PUNCT crln-9068 40 17 including include VERB crln-9068 40 18 those those PRON crln-9068 40 19 enabled enable VERB crln-9068 40 20 by by ADP crln-9068 40 21 first first ADJ crln-9068 40 22 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 40 23 . . PUNCT crln-9068 41 1 why why SCONJ crln-9068 41 2 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 41 3 ca can AUX crln-9068 41 4 n’t not PART crln-9068 41 5 freely freely ADV crln-9068 41 6 lend lend VERB crln-9068 41 7 e e NOUN crln-9068 41 8 - - NOUN crln-9068 41 9 books book NOUN crln-9068 41 10 , , PUNCT crln-9068 41 11 part part NOUN crln-9068 41 12 2 2 NUM crln-9068 41 13 : : PUNCT crln-9068 41 14 there there PRON crln-9068 41 15 ’s ’ VERB crln-9068 41 16 no no DET crln-9068 41 17 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 41 18 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 41 19 first first ADJ crln-9068 41 20 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 41 21 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 41 22 doctrine doctrine NOUN crln-9068 41 23 in in ADP crln-9068 41 24 2013 2013 NUM crln-9068 41 25 the the DET crln-9068 41 26 supreme supreme PROPN crln-9068 41 27 court court PROPN crln-9068 41 28 noted note VERB crln-9068 41 29 that that SCONJ crln-9068 41 30 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 41 31 for for ADP crln-9068 41 32 at at ADV crln-9068 41 33 least least ADJ crln-9068 41 34 a a PRON crln-9068 41 35 century century NOUN crln-9068 41 36 the the DET crln-9068 41 37 ‘ ' PUNCT crln-9068 41 38 first first ADJ crln-9068 41 39 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 41 40 ’ ' PUNCT crln-9068 41 41 doctrine doctrine NOUN crln-9068 41 42 has have AUX crln-9068 41 43 played play VERB crln-9068 41 44 an an DET crln-9068 41 45 important important ADJ crln-9068 41 46 role role NOUN crln-9068 41 47 in in ADP crln-9068 41 48 american american ADJ crln-9068 41 49 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 41 50 law law NOUN crln-9068 41 51 . . PUNCT crln-9068 41 52 ”3 ”3 SPACE crln-9068 42 1 but but CCONJ crln-9068 42 2 does do AUX crln-9068 42 3 this this DET crln-9068 42 4 role role NOUN crln-9068 42 5 extend extend VERB crln-9068 42 6 to to ADP crln-9068 42 7 the the DET crln-9068 42 8 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 42 9 environment environment NOUN crln-9068 42 10 ? ? PUNCT crln-9068 43 1 even even ADV crln-9068 43 2 if if SCONJ crln-9068 43 3 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 43 4 were be AUX crln-9068 43 5 owners owner NOUN crln-9068 43 6 rather rather ADV crln-9068 43 7 than than ADP crln-9068 43 8 licensees licensee NOUN crln-9068 43 9 , , PUNCT crln-9068 43 10 could could AUX crln-9068 43 11 they they PRON crln-9068 43 12 lend lend VERB crln-9068 43 13 e e NOUN crln-9068 43 14 - - NOUN crln-9068 43 15 books book NOUN crln-9068 43 16 without without ADP crln-9068 43 17 permission permission NOUN crln-9068 43 18 ? ? PUNCT crln-9068 44 1 thus thus ADV crln-9068 44 2 far far ADV crln-9068 44 3 , , PUNCT crln-9068 44 4 the the DET crln-9068 44 5 answer answer NOUN crln-9068 44 6 appears appear VERB crln-9068 44 7 to to PART crln-9068 44 8 be be AUX crln-9068 44 9 no no ADV crln-9068 44 10 . . PUNCT crln-9068 45 1 in in ADP crln-9068 45 2 a a DET crln-9068 45 3 2001 2001 NUM crln-9068 45 4 report,4 report,4 VERB crln-9068 45 5 the the DET crln-9068 45 6 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 45 7 office office NOUN crln-9068 45 8 recommended recommend VERB crln-9068 45 9 against against ADP crln-9068 45 10 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 45 11 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 45 12 first first ADJ crln-9068 45 13 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 45 14 , , PUNCT crln-9068 45 15 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 45 16 and and CCONJ crln-9068 45 17 since since SCONJ crln-9068 45 18 then then ADV crln-9068 45 19 neither neither CCONJ crln-9068 45 20 courts court NOUN crln-9068 45 21 nor nor CCONJ crln-9068 45 22 congress congress NOUN crln-9068 45 23 have have AUX crln-9068 45 24 been be AUX crln-9068 45 25 inclined incline VERB crln-9068 45 26 to to PART crln-9068 45 27 recognize recognize VERB crln-9068 45 28 such such DET crln-9068 45 29 a a DET crln-9068 45 30 freedom freedom NOUN crln-9068 45 31 . . PUNCT crln-9068 46 1 the the DET crln-9068 46 2 first first ADJ crln-9068 46 3 hurdle hurdle NOUN crln-9068 46 4 to to ADP crln-9068 46 5 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 46 6 first first ADJ crln-9068 46 7 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 46 8 comes come VERB crln-9068 46 9 from from ADP crln-9068 46 10 the the DET crln-9068 46 11 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 46 12 statute statute PROPN crln-9068 46 13 . . PUNCT crln-9068 47 1 first first ADJ crln-9068 47 2 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 47 3 predated predate VERB crln-9068 47 4 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 47 5 technology technology NOUN crln-9068 47 6 , , PUNCT crln-9068 47 7 and and CCONJ crln-9068 47 8 it it PRON crln-9068 47 9 does do AUX crln-9068 47 10 not not PART crln-9068 47 11 readily readily ADV crln-9068 47 12 transpose transpose ADJ crln-9068 47 13 to to ADP crln-9068 47 14 the the DET crln-9068 47 15 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 47 16 world world NOUN crln-9068 47 17 . . PUNCT crln-9068 48 1 the the DET crln-9068 48 2 copyright copyright PROPN crln-9068 48 3 act act NOUN crln-9068 48 4 grants grant VERB crln-9068 48 5 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 48 6 owners owner NOUN crln-9068 48 7 the the DET crln-9068 48 8 exclusive exclusive ADJ crln-9068 48 9 rights right NOUN crln-9068 48 10 to to PART crln-9068 48 11 reproduce reproduce VERB crln-9068 48 12 , , PUNCT crln-9068 48 13 distribute distribute VERB crln-9068 48 14 , , PUNCT crln-9068 48 15 publicly publicly ADV crln-9068 48 16 perform perform VERB crln-9068 48 17 , , PUNCT crln-9068 48 18 publicly publicly ADV crln-9068 48 19 display display NOUN crln-9068 48 20 , , PUNCT crln-9068 48 21 and and CCONJ crln-9068 48 22 adapt adapt VERB crln-9068 48 23 their their PRON crln-9068 48 24 works work NOUN crln-9068 48 25 . . PUNCT crln-9068 49 1 the the DET crln-9068 49 2 first first ADJ crln-9068 49 3 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 49 4 provision provision NOUN crln-9068 49 5 only only ADV crln-9068 49 6 refers refer VERB crln-9068 49 7 to to ADP crln-9068 49 8 the the DET crln-9068 49 9 distribution distribution NOUN crln-9068 49 10 right right ADV crln-9068 49 11 ; ; PUNCT crln-9068 49 12 the the DET crln-9068 49 13 other other ADJ crln-9068 49 14 rights right NOUN crln-9068 49 15 are be AUX crln-9068 49 16 unaffected unaffected ADJ crln-9068 49 17 . . PUNCT crln-9068 50 1 you you PRON crln-9068 50 2 can can AUX crln-9068 50 3 resell resell VERB crln-9068 50 4 your your PRON crln-9068 50 5 copy copy NOUN crln-9068 50 6 of of ADP crln-9068 50 7 harry harry PROPN crln-9068 50 8 potter potter PROPN crln-9068 50 9 , , PUNCT crln-9068 50 10 but but CCONJ crln-9068 50 11 you you PRON crln-9068 50 12 can can AUX crln-9068 50 13 not not PART crln-9068 50 14 sell sell VERB crln-9068 50 15 photocopies photocopy NOUN crln-9068 50 16 or or CCONJ crln-9068 50 17 make make VERB crln-9068 50 18 a a DET crln-9068 50 19 movie movie NOUN crln-9068 50 20 version version NOUN crln-9068 50 21 . . PUNCT crln-9068 51 1 limiting limit VERB crln-9068 51 2 first first ADJ crln-9068 51 3 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 51 4 protection protection NOUN crln-9068 51 5 to to ADP crln-9068 51 6 distribution distribution NOUN crln-9068 51 7 made make VERB crln-9068 51 8 sense sense NOUN crln-9068 51 9 in in ADP crln-9068 51 10 the the DET crln-9068 51 11 analog analog NOUN crln-9068 51 12 world world NOUN crln-9068 51 13 because because SCONJ crln-9068 51 14 other other ADJ crln-9068 51 15 rights right NOUN crln-9068 51 16 were be AUX crln-9068 51 17 not not PART crln-9068 51 18 implicated implicate VERB crln-9068 51 19 . . PUNCT crln-9068 52 1 to to PART crln-9068 52 2 give give VERB crln-9068 52 3 you you PRON crln-9068 52 4 a a DET crln-9068 52 5 book book NOUN crln-9068 52 6 , , PUNCT crln-9068 52 7 i i PRON crln-9068 52 8 did do AUX crln-9068 52 9 not not PART crln-9068 52 10 have have VERB crln-9068 52 11 to to PART crln-9068 52 12 make make VERB crln-9068 52 13 a a DET crln-9068 52 14 copy copy NOUN crln-9068 52 15 of of ADP crln-9068 52 16 it it PRON crln-9068 52 17 . . PUNCT crln-9068 53 1 but but CCONJ crln-9068 53 2 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 53 3 distribution distribution NOUN crln-9068 53 4 is be AUX crln-9068 53 5 different different ADJ crln-9068 53 6 : : PUNCT crln-9068 53 7 it it PRON crln-9068 53 8 generally generally ADV crln-9068 53 9 entails entail VERB crln-9068 53 10 one one NUM crln-9068 53 11 or or CCONJ crln-9068 53 12 more more ADJ crln-9068 53 13 reproductions reproduction NOUN crln-9068 53 14 . . PUNCT crln-9068 54 1 because because SCONJ crln-9068 54 2 these these DET crln-9068 54 3 reproductions reproduction NOUN crln-9068 54 4 are be AUX crln-9068 54 5 not not PART crln-9068 54 6 covered cover VERB crln-9068 54 7 by by ADP crln-9068 54 8 the the DET crln-9068 54 9 statutory statutory ADJ crln-9068 54 10 language language NOUN crln-9068 54 11 , , PUNCT crln-9068 54 12 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 54 13 transmissions transmission NOUN crln-9068 54 14 may may AUX crln-9068 54 15 fall fall VERB crln-9068 54 16 outside outside ADP crln-9068 54 17 the the DET crln-9068 54 18 ambit ambit NOUN crln-9068 54 19 of of ADP crln-9068 54 20 first first ADJ crln-9068 54 21 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 54 22 protection protection NOUN crln-9068 54 23 . . PUNCT crln-9068 55 1 what what PRON crln-9068 55 2 if if SCONJ crln-9068 55 3 we we PRON crln-9068 55 4 developed develop VERB crln-9068 55 5 a a DET crln-9068 55 6 technology technology NOUN crln-9068 55 7 that that PRON crln-9068 55 8 deleted delete VERB crln-9068 55 9 my my PRON crln-9068 55 10 copy copy NOUN crln-9068 55 11 of of ADP crln-9068 55 12 an an DET crln-9068 55 13 e e NOUN crln-9068 55 14 - - NOUN crln-9068 55 15 book book NOUN crln-9068 55 16 at at ADP crln-9068 55 17 the the DET crln-9068 55 18 moment moment NOUN crln-9068 55 19 it it PRON crln-9068 55 20 transferred transfer VERB crln-9068 55 21 a a DET crln-9068 55 22 copy copy NOUN crln-9068 55 23 , , PUNCT crln-9068 55 24 so so SCONJ crln-9068 55 25 that that SCONJ crln-9068 55 26 at at ADP crln-9068 55 27 the the DET crln-9068 55 28 end end NOUN crln-9068 55 29 of of ADP crln-9068 55 30 the the DET crln-9068 55 31 day day NOUN crln-9068 55 32 , , PUNCT crln-9068 55 33 there there PRON crln-9068 55 34 was be VERB crln-9068 55 35 still still ADV crln-9068 55 36 only only ADV crln-9068 55 37 one one NUM crln-9068 55 38 copy copy NOUN crln-9068 55 39 ? ? PUNCT crln-9068 56 1 the the DET crln-9068 56 2 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 56 3 office office NOUN crln-9068 56 4 was be AUX crln-9068 56 5 unconvinced unconvinced ADJ crln-9068 56 6 that that SCONJ crln-9068 56 7 this this PRON crln-9068 56 8 would would AUX crln-9068 56 9 make make VERB crln-9068 56 10 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 56 11 transfers transfer NOUN crln-9068 56 12 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 56 13 essentially essentially ADV crln-9068 56 14 identical identical ADJ crln-9068 56 15 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 56 16 to to ADP crln-9068 56 17 physical physical ADJ crln-9068 56 18 transfers transfer NOUN crln-9068 56 19 . . PUNCT crln-9068 57 1 in in ADP crln-9068 57 2 its its PRON crln-9068 57 3 opinion opinion NOUN crln-9068 57 4 , , PUNCT crln-9068 57 5 first first ADJ crln-9068 57 6 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 57 7 was be AUX crln-9068 57 8 limited limit VERB crln-9068 57 9 to to ADP crln-9068 57 10 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 57 11 physical physical ADJ crln-9068 57 12 artifact[s artifact[ NOUN crln-9068 57 13 ] ] PUNCT crln-9068 57 14 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 57 15 because because SCONJ crln-9068 57 16 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 57 17 [ [ X crln-9068 57 18 p]hysical p]hysical ADJ crln-9068 57 19 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 57 20 degrade degrade VERB crln-9068 57 21 with with ADP crln-9068 57 22 time time NOUN crln-9068 57 23 and and CCONJ crln-9068 57 24 use use NOUN crln-9068 57 25 ; ; PUNCT crln-9068 57 26 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 57 27 information information NOUN crln-9068 57 28 does do AUX crln-9068 57 29 not not PART crln-9068 57 30 … … PUNCT crln-9068 57 31 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 57 32 transmissions transmission NOUN crln-9068 57 33 can can AUX crln-9068 57 34 adversely adversely ADV crln-9068 57 35 effect effect VERB crln-9068 57 36 the the DET crln-9068 57 37 market market NOUN crln-9068 57 38 for for ADP crln-9068 57 39 the the DET crln-9068 57 40 original original NOUN crln-9068 57 41 to to ADP crln-9068 57 42 a a DET crln-9068 57 43 much much ADV crln-9068 57 44 greater great ADJ crln-9068 57 45 degree degree NOUN crln-9068 57 46 than than ADP crln-9068 57 47 transfers transfer NOUN crln-9068 57 48 of of ADP crln-9068 57 49 physical physical ADJ crln-9068 57 50 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 57 51 . . PUNCT crln-9068 57 52 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 58 1 because because SCONJ crln-9068 58 2 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 58 3 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 58 4 are be AUX crln-9068 58 5 perfect perfect ADJ crln-9068 58 6 and and CCONJ crln-9068 58 7 can can AUX crln-9068 58 8 be be AUX crln-9068 58 9 easily easily ADV crln-9068 58 10 replicated replicate VERB crln-9068 58 11 , , PUNCT crln-9068 58 12 some some PRON crln-9068 58 13 argue argue VERB crln-9068 58 14 that that SCONJ crln-9068 58 15 they they PRON crln-9068 58 16 are be AUX crln-9068 58 17 more more ADV crln-9068 58 18 likely likely ADJ crln-9068 58 19 to to PART crln-9068 58 20 cause cause VERB crln-9068 58 21 market market NOUN crln-9068 58 22 harm harm NOUN crln-9068 58 23 and and CCONJ crln-9068 58 24 should should AUX crln-9068 58 25 be be AUX crln-9068 58 26 more more ADV crln-9068 58 27 tightly tightly ADV crln-9068 58 28 controlled control VERB crln-9068 58 29 than than ADP crln-9068 58 30 physical physical ADJ crln-9068 58 31 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 58 32 . . PUNCT crln-9068 59 1 the the DET crln-9068 59 2 increased increase VERB crln-9068 59 3 potential potential NOUN crln-9068 59 4 for for ADP crln-9068 59 5 market market NOUN crln-9068 59 6 substitution substitution NOUN crln-9068 59 7 is be AUX crln-9068 59 8 a a DET crln-9068 59 9 valid valid ADJ crln-9068 59 10 concern concern NOUN crln-9068 59 11 . . PUNCT crln-9068 60 1 however however ADV crln-9068 60 2 , , PUNCT crln-9068 60 3 the the DET crln-9068 60 4 relative relative ADJ crln-9068 60 5 tendency tendency NOUN crln-9068 60 6 of of ADP crln-9068 60 7 physical physical ADJ crln-9068 60 8 and and CCONJ crln-9068 60 9 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 60 10 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 60 11 to to PART crln-9068 60 12 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 60 13 degrade degrade VERB crln-9068 60 14 with with ADP crln-9068 60 15 time time NOUN crln-9068 60 16 and and CCONJ crln-9068 60 17 use use NOUN crln-9068 60 18 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 60 19 can can AUX crln-9068 60 20 not not PART crln-9068 60 21 itself itself PRON crln-9068 60 22 justify justify VERB crln-9068 60 23 the the DET crln-9068 60 24 rejection rejection NOUN crln-9068 60 25 of of ADP crln-9068 60 26 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 60 27 first first ADJ crln-9068 60 28 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 60 29 . . PUNCT crln-9068 61 1 if if SCONJ crln-9068 61 2 we we PRON crln-9068 61 3 invented invent VERB crln-9068 61 4 perfect perfect ADJ crln-9068 61 5 paper paper NOUN crln-9068 61 6 that that PRON crln-9068 61 7 never never ADV crln-9068 61 8 yellowed yellow VERB crln-9068 61 9 or or CCONJ crln-9068 61 10 decayed decay VERB crln-9068 61 11 , , PUNCT crln-9068 61 12 books book NOUN crln-9068 61 13 printed print VERB crln-9068 61 14 on on ADP crln-9068 61 15 that that DET crln-9068 61 16 paper paper NOUN crln-9068 61 17 would would AUX crln-9068 61 18 nevertheless nevertheless ADV crln-9068 61 19 be be AUX crln-9068 61 20 subject subject ADJ crln-9068 61 21 to to ADP crln-9068 61 22 first first ADJ crln-9068 61 23 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 61 24 . . PUNCT crln-9068 62 1 in in ADP crln-9068 62 2 addition addition NOUN crln-9068 62 3 , , PUNCT crln-9068 62 4 both both CCONJ crln-9068 62 5 physical physical ADJ crln-9068 62 6 and and CCONJ crln-9068 62 7 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 62 8 media medium NOUN crln-9068 62 9 are be AUX crln-9068 62 10 subject subject ADJ crln-9068 62 11 to to ADP crln-9068 62 12 temporal temporal ADJ crln-9068 62 13 degradation degradation NOUN crln-9068 62 14 . . PUNCT crln-9068 63 1 a a DET crln-9068 63 2 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 63 3 copy copy NOUN crln-9068 63 4 remains remain VERB crln-9068 63 5 flawless flawless ADJ crln-9068 63 6 , , PUNCT crln-9068 63 7 but but CCONJ crln-9068 63 8 its its PRON crln-9068 63 9 market market NOUN crln-9068 63 10 value value NOUN crln-9068 63 11 nevertheless nevertheless ADV crln-9068 63 12 diminishes diminish VERB crln-9068 63 13 over over ADP crln-9068 63 14 time time NOUN crln-9068 63 15 . . PUNCT crln-9068 64 1 in in ADP crln-9068 64 2 the the DET crln-9068 64 3 2013 2013 NUM crln-9068 64 4 case case NOUN crln-9068 64 5 capitol capitol PROPN crln-9068 64 6 records record NOUN crln-9068 64 7 v. v. PROPN crln-9068 64 8 redigi,5 redigi,5 PROPN crln-9068 64 9 a a DET crln-9068 64 10 court court NOUN crln-9068 64 11 assessed assess VERB crln-9068 64 12 a a DET crln-9068 64 13 sophisticated sophisticated ADJ crln-9068 64 14 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 64 15 first first ADJ crln-9068 64 16 february february PROPN crln-9068 64 17 2014 2014 NUM crln-9068 64 18 71 71 NUM crln-9068 64 19 c&rl c&rl PROPN crln-9068 64 20 news news NOUN crln-9068 64 21 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 64 22 system system NOUN crln-9068 64 23 . . PUNCT crln-9068 65 1 redigi redigi PROPN crln-9068 65 2 wanted want VERB crln-9068 65 3 to to PART crln-9068 65 4 be be AUX crln-9068 65 5 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 65 6 the the DET crln-9068 65 7 world world NOUN crln-9068 65 8 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 65 9 first first ADV crln-9068 65 10 . . PUNCT crln-9068 65 11 . . PUNCT crln-9068 65 12 . . PUNCT crln-9068 66 1 online online ADJ crln-9068 66 2 marketplace marketplace NOUN crln-9068 66 3 for for ADP crln-9068 66 4 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 66 5 used use VERB crln-9068 66 6 music music NOUN crln-9068 66 7 . . PUNCT crln-9068 66 8 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 67 1 it it PRON crln-9068 67 2 had have AUX crln-9068 67 3 developed develop VERB crln-9068 67 4 technology technology NOUN crln-9068 67 5 that that PRON crln-9068 67 6 made make VERB crln-9068 67 7 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 67 8 resales resale NOUN crln-9068 67 9 similar similar ADJ crln-9068 67 10 to to ADP crln-9068 67 11 physical physical ADJ crln-9068 67 12 ones one NOUN crln-9068 67 13 . . PUNCT crln-9068 68 1 users user NOUN crln-9068 68 2 wishing wish VERB crln-9068 68 3 to to PART crln-9068 68 4 sell sell VERB crln-9068 68 5 music music NOUN crln-9068 68 6 would would AUX crln-9068 68 7 upload upload VERB crln-9068 68 8 their their PRON crln-9068 68 9 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 68 10 files file NOUN crln-9068 68 11 to to PART crln-9068 68 12 redigi redigi VERB crln-9068 68 13 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 68 14 cloud cloud PROPN crln-9068 68 15 locker locker PROPN crln-9068 68 16 , , PUNCT crln-9068 68 17 and and CCONJ crln-9068 68 18 the the DET crln-9068 68 19 technology technology NOUN crln-9068 68 20 would would AUX crln-9068 68 21 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 68 22 migrate migrate VERB crln-9068 68 23 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 68 24 the the DET crln-9068 68 25 files file NOUN crln-9068 68 26 , , PUNCT crln-9068 68 27 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 68 28 packet packet NOUN crln-9068 68 29 by by ADP crln-9068 68 30 packet packet NOUN crln-9068 68 31 . . PUNCT crln-9068 68 32 . . PUNCT crln-9068 68 33 . . PUNCT crln-9068 69 1 so so ADV crln-9068 69 2 that that SCONJ crln-9068 69 3 data data NOUN crln-9068 69 4 does do AUX crln-9068 69 5 not not PART crln-9068 69 6 exist exist VERB crln-9068 69 7 in in ADP crln-9068 69 8 two two NUM crln-9068 69 9 places place NOUN crln-9068 69 10 at at ADP crln-9068 69 11 any any DET crln-9068 69 12 one one NUM crln-9068 69 13 time time NOUN crln-9068 69 14 . . PUNCT crln-9068 69 15 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 70 1 redigi redigi PROPN crln-9068 70 2 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 70 3 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 70 4 media medium NOUN crln-9068 70 5 manager manager NOUN crln-9068 70 6 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 70 7 ensured ensure VERB crln-9068 70 8 that that SCONJ crln-9068 70 9 only only ADV crln-9068 70 10 lawfully lawfully ADV crln-9068 70 11 acquired acquire VERB crln-9068 70 12 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 70 13 were be AUX crln-9068 70 14 eligible eligible ADJ crln-9068 70 15 for for ADP crln-9068 70 16 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 70 17 , , PUNCT crln-9068 70 18 and and CCONJ crln-9068 70 19 that that SCONJ crln-9068 70 20 any any DET crln-9068 70 21 residual residual ADJ crln-9068 70 22 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 70 23 on on ADP crln-9068 70 24 the the DET crln-9068 70 25 user user NOUN crln-9068 70 26 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 70 27 computer computer NOUN crln-9068 70 28 were be AUX crln-9068 70 29 deleted delete VERB crln-9068 70 30 after after ADP crln-9068 70 31 uploading upload VERB crln-9068 70 32 . . PUNCT crln-9068 71 1 when when SCONJ crln-9068 71 2 the the DET crln-9068 71 3 music music NOUN crln-9068 71 4 was be AUX crln-9068 71 5 sold sell VERB crln-9068 71 6 , , PUNCT crln-9068 71 7 access access NOUN crln-9068 71 8 to to ADP crln-9068 71 9 the the DET crln-9068 71 10 file file NOUN crln-9068 71 11 in in ADP crln-9068 71 12 the the DET crln-9068 71 13 cloud cloud NOUN crln-9068 71 14 was be AUX crln-9068 71 15 transferred transfer VERB crln-9068 71 16 from from ADP crln-9068 71 17 seller seller NOUN crln-9068 71 18 to to ADP crln-9068 71 19 purchaser purchaser PROPN crln-9068 71 20 . . PUNCT crln-9068 72 1 redigi redigi PROPN crln-9068 72 2 argued argue VERB crln-9068 72 3 that that SCONJ crln-9068 72 4 its its PRON crln-9068 72 5 service service NOUN crln-9068 72 6 was be AUX crln-9068 72 7 protected protect VERB crln-9068 72 8 by by ADP crln-9068 72 9 the the DET crln-9068 72 10 first first ADJ crln-9068 72 11 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 72 12 doctrine doctrine NOUN crln-9068 72 13 , , PUNCT crln-9068 72 14 but but CCONJ crln-9068 72 15 the the DET crln-9068 72 16 court court NOUN crln-9068 72 17 strongly strongly ADV crln-9068 72 18 disagreed disagree VERB crln-9068 72 19 . . PUNCT crln-9068 73 1 it it PRON crln-9068 73 2 found find VERB crln-9068 73 3 that that SCONJ crln-9068 73 4 first first ADJ crln-9068 73 5 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 73 6 should should AUX crln-9068 73 7 be be AUX crln-9068 73 8 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 73 9 limited limit VERB crln-9068 73 10 to to ADP crln-9068 73 11 material material ADJ crln-9068 73 12 items item NOUN crln-9068 73 13 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 73 14 and and CCONJ crln-9068 73 15 quoted quote VERB crln-9068 73 16 the the DET crln-9068 73 17 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 73 18 office office NOUN crln-9068 73 19 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 73 20 reasoning reasoning NOUN crln-9068 73 21 that that SCONJ crln-9068 73 22 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 73 23 [ [ X crln-9068 73 24 p]hysical p]hysical ADJ crln-9068 73 25 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 73 26 of of ADP crln-9068 73 27 works work NOUN crln-9068 73 28 degrade degrade VERB crln-9068 73 29 with with ADP crln-9068 73 30 time time NOUN crln-9068 73 31 and and CCONJ crln-9068 73 32 use use NOUN crln-9068 73 33 . . PUNCT crln-9068 73 34 . . PUNCT crln-9068 73 35 . . PUNCT crln-9068 73 36 . . PUNCT crln-9068 74 1 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 74 2 information information NOUN crln-9068 74 3 does do AUX crln-9068 74 4 not not PART crln-9068 74 5 degrade degrade VERB crln-9068 74 6 , , PUNCT crln-9068 74 7 . . PUNCT crln-9068 74 8 . . PUNCT crln-9068 74 9 . . PUNCT crln-9068 75 1 the the DET crln-9068 75 2 ‘ ' PUNCT crln-9068 75 3 used use VERB crln-9068 75 4 ’ ' PUNCT crln-9068 75 5 copy copy NOUN crln-9068 75 6 is be AUX crln-9068 75 7 just just ADV crln-9068 75 8 as as ADV crln-9068 75 9 desirable desirable ADJ crln-9068 75 10 as as ADP crln-9068 75 11 . . PUNCT crln-9068 75 12 . . PUNCT crln-9068 75 13 . . PUNCT crln-9068 76 1 a a DET crln-9068 76 2 new new ADJ crln-9068 76 3 copy copy NOUN crln-9068 76 4 . . PUNCT crln-9068 76 5 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 77 1 the the DET crln-9068 77 2 court court NOUN crln-9068 77 3 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 77 4 legal legal ADJ crln-9068 77 5 analysis analysis NOUN crln-9068 77 6 focused focus VERB crln-9068 77 7 on on ADP crln-9068 77 8 the the DET crln-9068 77 9 reproductions reproduction NOUN crln-9068 77 10 made make VERB crln-9068 77 11 during during ADP crln-9068 77 12 online online ADJ crln-9068 77 13 resale resale NOUN crln-9068 77 14 . . PUNCT crln-9068 78 1 at at ADP crln-9068 78 2 oral oral ADJ crln-9068 78 3 argument argument NOUN crln-9068 78 4 , , PUNCT crln-9068 78 5 the the DET crln-9068 78 6 judge judge NOUN crln-9068 78 7 used use VERB crln-9068 78 8 an an DET crln-9068 78 9 analogy analogy NOUN crln-9068 78 10 to to PART crln-9068 78 11 star star VERB crln-9068 78 12 trek trek PROPN crln-9068 78 13 , , PUNCT crln-9068 78 14 and and CCONJ crln-9068 78 15 asked ask VERB crln-9068 78 16 whether whether SCONJ crln-9068 78 17 redigi redigi NOUN crln-9068 78 18 was be AUX crln-9068 78 19 more more ADV crln-9068 78 20 like like ADP crln-9068 78 21 the the DET crln-9068 78 22 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 78 23 transporter transporter NOUN crln-9068 78 24 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 78 25 that that PRON crln-9068 78 26 sends send VERB crln-9068 78 27 captain captain NOUN crln-9068 78 28 kirk kirk PROPN crln-9068 78 29 to to ADP crln-9068 78 30 a a DET crln-9068 78 31 planet planet NOUN crln-9068 78 32 without without ADP crln-9068 78 33 duplicating duplicate VERB crln-9068 78 34 him he PRON crln-9068 78 35 , , PUNCT crln-9068 78 36 or or CCONJ crln-9068 78 37 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 78 38 the the DET crln-9068 78 39 cloning cloning NOUN crln-9068 78 40 where where SCONJ crln-9068 78 41 there there PRON crln-9068 78 42 ’s ’ VERB crln-9068 78 43 a a DET crln-9068 78 44 good good NOUN crln-9068 78 45 and and CCONJ crln-9068 78 46 a a DET crln-9068 78 47 bad bad ADJ crln-9068 78 48 captain captain NOUN crln-9068 78 49 kirk kirk NOUN crln-9068 78 50 where where SCONJ crln-9068 78 51 they they PRON crln-9068 78 52 ’re ’re AUX crln-9068 78 53 both both PRON crln-9068 78 54 running run VERB crln-9068 78 55 around around ADV crln-9068 78 56 . . PUNCT crln-9068 78 57 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 79 1 even even ADV crln-9068 79 2 though though SCONJ crln-9068 79 3 redigi redigi NOUN crln-9068 79 4 may may AUX crln-9068 79 5 seem seem VERB crln-9068 79 6 closer close ADJ crln-9068 79 7 to to ADP crln-9068 79 8 the the DET crln-9068 79 9 transporter transporter NOUN crln-9068 79 10 , , PUNCT crln-9068 79 11 the the DET crln-9068 79 12 court court NOUN crln-9068 79 13 declined decline VERB crln-9068 79 14 to to PART crln-9068 79 15 be be AUX crln-9068 79 16 beamed beam VERB crln-9068 79 17 up up ADP crln-9068 79 18 . . PUNCT crln-9068 80 1 it it PRON crln-9068 80 2 held hold VERB crln-9068 80 3 that that SCONJ crln-9068 80 4 whenever whenever SCONJ crln-9068 80 5 a a DET crln-9068 80 6 file file NOUN crln-9068 80 7 was be AUX crln-9068 80 8 uploaded upload VERB crln-9068 80 9 by by ADP crln-9068 80 10 a a DET crln-9068 80 11 seller seller NOUN crln-9068 80 12 or or CCONJ crln-9068 80 13 downloaded download VERB crln-9068 80 14 by by ADP crln-9068 80 15 a a DET crln-9068 80 16 buyer buyer NOUN crln-9068 80 17 , , PUNCT crln-9068 80 18 there there PRON crln-9068 80 19 was be VERB crln-9068 80 20 an an DET crln-9068 80 21 infringing infringing ADJ crln-9068 80 22 reproduction reproduction NOUN crln-9068 80 23 . . PUNCT crln-9068 81 1 this this PRON crln-9068 81 2 was be AUX crln-9068 81 3 not not PART crln-9068 81 4 the the DET crln-9068 81 5 only only ADJ crln-9068 81 6 possible possible ADJ crln-9068 81 7 outcome outcome NOUN crln-9068 81 8 . . PUNCT crln-9068 82 1 rather rather ADV crln-9068 82 2 than than ADP crln-9068 82 3 focusing focus VERB crln-9068 82 4 on on ADP crln-9068 82 5 the the DET crln-9068 82 6 technicalities technicality NOUN crln-9068 82 7 of of ADP crln-9068 82 8 reproduction reproduction NOUN crln-9068 82 9 , , PUNCT crln-9068 82 10 the the DET crln-9068 82 11 court court NOUN crln-9068 82 12 could could AUX crln-9068 82 13 have have AUX crln-9068 82 14 concluded conclude VERB crln-9068 82 15 that that SCONJ crln-9068 82 16 redigi redigi NOUN crln-9068 82 17 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 82 18 service service NOUN crln-9068 82 19 was be AUX crln-9068 82 20 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 82 21 essentially essentially ADV crln-9068 82 22 identical identical ADJ crln-9068 82 23 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 82 24 to to ADP crln-9068 82 25 a a DET crln-9068 82 26 used use VERB crln-9068 82 27 record record NOUN crln-9068 82 28 store store NOUN crln-9068 82 29 . . PUNCT crln-9068 83 1 that that PRON crln-9068 83 2 said say VERB crln-9068 83 3 , , PUNCT crln-9068 83 4 the the DET crln-9068 83 5 court court NOUN crln-9068 83 6 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 83 7 reluctance reluctance NOUN crln-9068 83 8 to to PART crln-9068 83 9 break break VERB crln-9068 83 10 new new ADJ crln-9068 83 11 ground ground NOUN crln-9068 83 12 by by ADP crln-9068 83 13 recognizing recognize VERB crln-9068 83 14 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 83 15 first first ADJ crln-9068 83 16 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 83 17 , , PUNCT crln-9068 83 18 when when SCONJ crln-9068 83 19 neither neither CCONJ crln-9068 83 20 congress congress PROPN crln-9068 83 21 nor nor CCONJ crln-9068 83 22 the the DET crln-9068 83 23 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 83 24 office office NOUN crln-9068 83 25 had have AUX crln-9068 83 26 done do VERB crln-9068 83 27 so so ADV crln-9068 83 28 , , PUNCT crln-9068 83 29 is be AUX crln-9068 83 30 understandable understandable ADJ crln-9068 83 31 . . PUNCT crln-9068 84 1 the the DET crln-9068 84 2 threat threat NOUN crln-9068 84 3 of of ADP crln-9068 84 4 market market NOUN crln-9068 84 5 harm harm NOUN crln-9068 84 6 if if SCONJ crln-9068 84 7 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 84 8 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 84 9 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 84 10 run run VERB crln-9068 84 11 loose loose ADJ crln-9068 84 12 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 84 13 is be AUX crln-9068 84 14 real real ADJ crln-9068 84 15 . . PUNCT crln-9068 85 1 cheaper cheap ADJ crln-9068 85 2 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 85 3 used use VERB crln-9068 85 4 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 85 5 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 85 6 could could AUX crln-9068 85 7 compete compete VERB crln-9068 85 8 with with ADP crln-9068 85 9 more more ADV crln-9068 85 10 expensive expensive ADJ crln-9068 85 11 originals original NOUN crln-9068 85 12 . . PUNCT crln-9068 86 1 if if SCONJ crln-9068 86 2 those those PRON crln-9068 86 3 were be AUX crln-9068 86 4 the the DET crln-9068 86 5 only only ADJ crln-9068 86 6 two two NUM crln-9068 86 7 alternatives alternative NOUN crln-9068 86 8 for for ADP crln-9068 86 9 consumers consumer NOUN crln-9068 86 10 , , PUNCT crln-9068 86 11 it it PRON crln-9068 86 12 might might AUX crln-9068 86 13 be be AUX crln-9068 86 14 a a DET crln-9068 86 15 good good ADJ crln-9068 86 16 reason reason NOUN crln-9068 86 17 to to PART crln-9068 86 18 forbid forbid VERB crln-9068 86 19 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 86 20 first first ADJ crln-9068 86 21 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 86 22 . . PUNCT crln-9068 87 1 unfortunately unfortunately ADV crln-9068 87 2 , , PUNCT crln-9068 87 3 a a DET crln-9068 87 4 third third ADJ crln-9068 87 5 alternative alternative NOUN crln-9068 87 6 is be AUX crln-9068 87 7 illicitly illicitly ADV crln-9068 87 8 downloading download VERB crln-9068 87 9 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 87 10 for for ADP crln-9068 87 11 free free ADJ crln-9068 87 12 . . PUNCT crln-9068 88 1 studies6 studies6 PROPN crln-9068 88 2 have have AUX crln-9068 88 3 shown show VERB crln-9068 88 4 that that SCONJ crln-9068 88 5 the the DET crln-9068 88 6 effective effective ADJ crln-9068 88 7 way way NOUN crln-9068 88 8 to to PART crln-9068 88 9 drive drive VERB crln-9068 88 10 down down ADP crln-9068 88 11 rates rate NOUN crln-9068 88 12 of of ADP crln-9068 88 13 illicit illicit ADJ crln-9068 88 14 copying copying NOUN crln-9068 88 15 is be AUX crln-9068 88 16 to to PART crln-9068 88 17 provide provide VERB crln-9068 88 18 cheap cheap ADJ crln-9068 88 19 and and CCONJ crln-9068 88 20 legal legal ADJ crln-9068 88 21 alternatives alternative NOUN crln-9068 88 22 . . PUNCT crln-9068 89 1 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 89 2 first first ADJ crln-9068 89 3 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 89 4 could could AUX crln-9068 89 5 lead lead VERB crln-9068 89 6 would would AUX crln-9068 89 7 - - PUNCT crln-9068 89 8 be be AUX crln-9068 89 9 downloaders downloader NOUN crln-9068 89 10 to to PART crln-9068 89 11 turn turn VERB crln-9068 89 12 to to ADP crln-9068 89 13 a a DET crln-9068 89 14 legal legal ADJ crln-9068 89 15 second second ADJ crln-9068 89 16 - - PUNCT crln-9068 89 17 hand hand NOUN crln-9068 89 18 market market NOUN crln-9068 89 19 , , PUNCT crln-9068 89 20 indirectly indirectly ADV crln-9068 89 21 increasing increase VERB crln-9068 89 22 the the DET crln-9068 89 23 willingness willingness NOUN crln-9068 89 24 of of ADP crln-9068 89 25 first first ADJ crln-9068 89 26 - - PUNCT crln-9068 89 27 time time NOUN crln-9068 89 28 purchasers purchaser NOUN crln-9068 89 29 to to PART crln-9068 89 30 buy buy VERB crln-9068 89 31 . . PUNCT crln-9068 90 1 time time NOUN crln-9068 90 2 for for ADP crln-9068 90 3 reform reform NOUN crln-9068 90 4 ? ? PUNCT crln-9068 91 1 in in ADP crln-9068 91 2 2013 2013 NUM crln-9068 91 3 , , PUNCT crln-9068 91 4 maria maria PROPN crln-9068 91 5 pallante pallante PROPN crln-9068 91 6 , , PUNCT crln-9068 91 7 director director NOUN crln-9068 91 8 of of ADP crln-9068 91 9 the the DET crln-9068 91 10 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 91 11 office office NOUN crln-9068 91 12 , , PUNCT crln-9068 91 13 outlined outline VERB crln-9068 91 14 congress congress PROPN crln-9068 91 15 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 91 16 options option NOUN crln-9068 91 17 , , PUNCT crln-9068 91 18 should should AUX crln-9068 91 19 it it PRON crln-9068 91 20 revisit revisit VERB crln-9068 91 21 the the DET crln-9068 91 22 question question NOUN crln-9068 91 23 of of ADP crln-9068 91 24 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 91 25 first first ADJ crln-9068 91 26 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 91 27 : : PUNCT crln-9068 91 28 on on ADP crln-9068 91 29 the the DET crln-9068 91 30 one one NUM crln-9068 91 31 hand hand NOUN crln-9068 91 32 , , PUNCT crln-9068 91 33 congress congress PROPN crln-9068 91 34 may may AUX crln-9068 91 35 believe believe VERB crln-9068 91 36 that that SCONJ crln-9068 91 37 in in ADP crln-9068 91 38 a a DET crln-9068 91 39 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 91 40 marketplace marketplace NOUN crln-9068 91 41 , , PUNCT crln-9068 91 42 the the DET crln-9068 91 43 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 91 44 owner owner NOUN crln-9068 91 45 should should AUX crln-9068 91 46 control control VERB crln-9068 91 47 all all DET crln-9068 91 48 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 91 49 of of ADP crln-9068 91 50 his his PRON crln-9068 91 51 work work NOUN crln-9068 91 52 , , PUNCT crln-9068 91 53 particularly particularly ADV crln-9068 91 54 because because SCONJ crln-9068 91 55 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 91 56 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 91 57 are be AUX crln-9068 91 58 perfect perfect ADJ crln-9068 91 59 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 91 60 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 91 61 not not PART crln-9068 91 62 dog dog NOUN crln-9068 91 63 - - PUNCT crln-9068 91 64 eared eare VERB crln-9068 91 65 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 91 66 of of ADP crln-9068 91 67 lesser less ADJ crln-9068 91 68 value value NOUN crln-9068 91 69 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 91 70 or or CCONJ crln-9068 91 71 because because SCONJ crln-9068 91 72 in in ADP crln-9068 91 73 online online ADJ crln-9068 91 74 commerce commerce NOUN crln-9068 91 75 the the DET crln-9068 91 76 migration migration NOUN crln-9068 91 77 from from ADP crln-9068 91 78 the the DET crln-9068 91 79 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 91 80 of of ADP crln-9068 91 81 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 91 82 to to ADP crln-9068 91 83 the the DET crln-9068 91 84 proffering proffering NOUN crln-9068 91 85 of of ADP crln-9068 91 86 licenses license NOUN crln-9068 91 87 has have AUX crln-9068 91 88 negated negate VERB crln-9068 91 89 the the DET crln-9068 91 90 issue issue NOUN crln-9068 91 91 . . PUNCT crln-9068 92 1 on on ADP crln-9068 92 2 the the DET crln-9068 92 3 other other ADJ crln-9068 92 4 hand hand NOUN crln-9068 92 5 , , PUNCT crln-9068 92 6 congress congress PROPN crln-9068 92 7 may may AUX crln-9068 92 8 find find VERB crln-9068 92 9 that that SCONJ crln-9068 92 10 the the DET crln-9068 92 11 general general ADJ crln-9068 92 12 principle principle NOUN crln-9068 92 13 of of ADP crln-9068 92 14 first first ADJ crln-9068 92 15 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 92 16 has have VERB crln-9068 92 17 ongoing ongoing ADJ crln-9068 92 18 merit merit NOUN crln-9068 92 19 in in ADP crln-9068 92 20 the the DET crln-9068 92 21 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 92 22 age age NOUN crln-9068 92 23 and and CCONJ crln-9068 92 24 can can AUX crln-9068 92 25 be be AUX crln-9068 92 26 adequately adequately ADV crln-9068 92 27 policed police VERB crln-9068 92 28 through through ADP crln-9068 92 29 technology technology NOUN crln-9068 92 30 — — PUNCT crln-9068 92 31 for for ADP crln-9068 92 32 example example NOUN crln-9068 92 33 , , PUNCT crln-9068 92 34 through through ADP crln-9068 92 35 measures measure NOUN crln-9068 92 36 that that PRON crln-9068 92 37 would would AUX crln-9068 92 38 prevent prevent VERB crln-9068 92 39 or or CCONJ crln-9068 92 40 destroy destroy VERB crln-9068 92 41 duplicative duplicative ADJ crln-9068 92 42 copies copy NOUN crln-9068 92 43 . . PUNCT crln-9068 93 1 or or CCONJ crln-9068 93 2 , , PUNCT crln-9068 93 3 more more ADV crln-9068 93 4 simply simply ADV crln-9068 93 5 , , PUNCT crln-9068 93 6 congress congress PROPN crln-9068 93 7 may may AUX crln-9068 93 8 not not PART crln-9068 93 9 want want VERB crln-9068 93 10 a a DET crln-9068 93 11 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 93 12 law law NOUN crln-9068 93 13 where where SCONJ crln-9068 93 14 everything everything PRON crln-9068 93 15 is be AUX crln-9068 93 16 licensed license VERB crln-9068 93 17 and and CCONJ crln-9068 93 18 nothing nothing PRON crln-9068 93 19 is be AUX crln-9068 93 20 owned.7 owned.7 PROPN crln-9068 93 21 that that SCONJ crln-9068 93 22 last last ADJ crln-9068 93 23 phrase phrase NOUN crln-9068 93 24 , , PUNCT crln-9068 93 25 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 93 26 where where SCONJ crln-9068 93 27 everything everything PRON crln-9068 93 28 is be AUX crln-9068 93 29 licensed license VERB crln-9068 93 30 and and CCONJ crln-9068 93 31 nothing nothing PRON crln-9068 93 32 is be AUX crln-9068 93 33 owned own VERB crln-9068 93 34 , , PUNCT crln-9068 93 35 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 93 36 is be AUX crln-9068 93 37 worth worth ADJ crln-9068 93 38 thinking think VERB crln-9068 93 39 about about ADP crln-9068 93 40 . . PUNCT crln-9068 94 1 we we PRON crln-9068 94 2 have have AUX crln-9068 94 3 grown grow VERB crln-9068 94 4 up up ADP crln-9068 94 5 assuming assume VERB crln-9068 94 6 that that SCONJ crln-9068 94 7 people people NOUN crln-9068 94 8 owned own VERB crln-9068 94 9 their their PRON crln-9068 94 10 books book NOUN crln-9068 94 11 and and CCONJ crln-9068 94 12 their their PRON crln-9068 94 13 music music NOUN crln-9068 94 14 . . PUNCT crln-9068 95 1 with with ADP crln-9068 95 2 ownership ownership NOUN crln-9068 95 3 came come VERB crln-9068 95 4 rights right NOUN crln-9068 95 5 that that PRON crln-9068 95 6 allowed allow VERB crln-9068 95 7 us we PRON crln-9068 95 8 to to PART crln-9068 95 9 share share VERB crln-9068 95 10 , , PUNCT crln-9068 95 11 to to PART crln-9068 95 12 lend lend VERB crln-9068 95 13 , , PUNCT crln-9068 95 14 to to PART crln-9068 95 15 resell resell VERB crln-9068 95 16 , , PUNCT crln-9068 95 17 all all PRON crln-9068 95 18 without without ADP crln-9068 95 19 being be AUX crln-9068 95 20 monitored monitor VERB crln-9068 95 21 . . PUNCT crln-9068 96 1 by by ADP crln-9068 96 2 contrast contrast NOUN crln-9068 96 3 , , PUNCT crln-9068 96 4 imagine imagine VERB crln-9068 96 5 having have VERB crln-9068 96 6 a a DET crln-9068 96 7 library library NOUN crln-9068 96 8 of of ADP crln-9068 96 9 books book NOUN crln-9068 96 10 whose whose DET crln-9068 96 11 shelves shelf NOUN crln-9068 96 12 might might AUX crln-9068 96 13 be be AUX crln-9068 96 14 bare bare ADJ crln-9068 96 15 one one NUM crln-9068 96 16 morning morning NOUN crln-9068 96 17 due due ADP crln-9068 96 18 to to ADP crln-9068 96 19 licensing licensing NOUN crln-9068 96 20 problems problem NOUN crln-9068 96 21 . . PUNCT crln-9068 97 1 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 97 2 this this PRON crln-9068 97 3 is be AUX crln-9068 97 4 not not PART crln-9068 97 5 hyperbole hyperbole NOUN crln-9068 97 6 . . PUNCT crln-9068 98 1 amazon amazon PROPN crln-9068 98 2 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 98 3 disappeared disappear VERB crln-9068 98 4 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 98 5 books book NOUN crln-9068 98 6 from from ADP crln-9068 98 7 hundreds hundred NOUN crln-9068 98 8 of of ADP crln-9068 98 9 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 98 10 continues continue VERB crln-9068 98 11 on on ADP crln-9068 98 12 page page NOUN crln-9068 98 13 75 75 NUM crln-9068 98 14 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 98 15 february february PROPN crln-9068 98 16 2014 2014 NUM crln-9068 99 1 75 75 NUM crln-9068 99 2 c&rl c&rl PROPN crln-9068 99 3 news news NOUN crln-9068 99 4 2 2 NUM crln-9068 99 5 . . PROPN crln-9068 99 6 suzanne suzanne PROPN crln-9068 99 7 julian julian PROPN crln-9068 99 8 , , PUNCT crln-9068 99 9 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 99 10 reinventing reinvent VERB crln-9068 99 11 classroom classroom NOUN crln-9068 99 12 space space NOUN crln-9068 99 13 to to PART crln-9068 99 14 re re VERB crln-9068 99 15 - - VERB crln-9068 99 16 energise energise VERB crln-9068 99 17 information information NOUN crln-9068 99 18 literacy literacy NOUN crln-9068 99 19 instruction instruction NOUN crln-9068 99 20 , , PUNCT crln-9068 99 21 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 99 22 journal journal NOUN crln-9068 99 23 of of ADP crln-9068 99 24 information information NOUN crln-9068 99 25 literacy literacy NOUN crln-9068 99 26 7 7 NUM crln-9068 99 27 , , PUNCT crln-9068 99 28 no no NOUN crln-9068 99 29 . . NOUN crln-9068 99 30 1 1 NUM crln-9068 99 31 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 99 32 2013 2013 NUM crln-9068 99 33 ): ): PUNCT crln-9068 99 34 69 69 NUM crln-9068 99 35 - - SYM crln-9068 99 36 82 82 NUM crln-9068 99 37 . . PUNCT crln-9068 100 1 our our PRON crln-9068 100 2 university university NOUN crln-9068 100 3 has have AUX crln-9068 100 4 not not PART crln-9068 100 5 implemented implement VERB crln-9068 100 6 a a DET crln-9068 100 7 universal universal ADJ crln-9068 100 8 ipad ipad NOUN crln-9068 100 9 program program NOUN crln-9068 100 10 , , PUNCT crln-9068 100 11 but but CCONJ crln-9068 100 12 julian julian ADJ crln-9068 100 13 points point NOUN crln-9068 100 14 to to ADP crln-9068 100 15 the the DET crln-9068 100 16 ease ease NOUN crln-9068 100 17 and and CCONJ crln-9068 100 18 general general ADJ crln-9068 100 19 success success NOUN crln-9068 100 20 of of ADP crln-9068 100 21 students student NOUN crln-9068 100 22 using use VERB crln-9068 100 23 the the DET crln-9068 100 24 ipad ipad NOUN crln-9068 100 25 in in ADP crln-9068 100 26 the the DET crln-9068 100 27 classroom classroom NOUN crln-9068 100 28 . . PUNCT crln-9068 101 1 3 3 X crln-9068 101 2 . . X crln-9068 101 3 megan megan PROPN crln-9068 101 4 lotts lott NOUN crln-9068 101 5 and and CCONJ crln-9068 101 6 stephanie stephanie NOUN crln-9068 101 7 graves grave NOUN crln-9068 101 8 , , PUNCT crln-9068 101 9 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 101 10 using use VERB crln-9068 101 11 the the DET crln-9068 101 12 ipad ipad NOUN crln-9068 101 13 for for ADP crln-9068 101 14 reference reference NOUN crln-9068 101 15 services service NOUN crln-9068 101 16 : : PUNCT crln-9068 101 17 librarians librarians PROPN crln-9068 101 18 go go VERB crln-9068 101 19 mobile mobile ADJ crln-9068 101 20 , , PUNCT crln-9068 101 21 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 101 22 college college NOUN crln-9068 101 23 & & CCONJ crln-9068 101 24 research research PROPN crln-9068 101 25 readers reader NOUN crln-9068 101 26 ’ ’ PART crln-9068 101 27 kindles kindle NOUN crln-9068 101 28 when when SCONJ crln-9068 101 29 it it PRON crln-9068 101 30 determined determine VERB crln-9068 101 31 that that SCONJ crln-9068 101 32 the the DET crln-9068 101 33 seller seller NOUN crln-9068 101 34 did do AUX crln-9068 101 35 not not PART crln-9068 101 36 have have VERB crln-9068 101 37 the the DET crln-9068 101 38 necessary necessary ADJ crln-9068 101 39 rights right NOUN crln-9068 101 40 . . PUNCT crln-9068 102 1 one one NUM crln-9068 102 2 of of ADP crln-9068 102 3 the the DET crln-9068 102 4 vanishing vanish VERB crln-9068 102 5 books book NOUN crln-9068 102 6 was be AUX crln-9068 102 7 orwell orwell ADJ crln-9068 102 8 ’s ’s NUM crln-9068 102 9 1984 1984 NUM crln-9068 102 10 . . PUNCT crln-9068 102 11 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 103 1 imagine imagine VERB crln-9068 103 2 cultural cultural ADJ crln-9068 103 3 usage usage NOUN crln-9068 103 4 entirely entirely ADV crln-9068 103 5 dependent dependent ADJ crln-9068 103 6 on on ADP crln-9068 103 7 the the DET crln-9068 103 8 person person NOUN crln-9068 103 9 writing write VERB crln-9068 103 10 the the DET crln-9068 103 11 license license NOUN crln-9068 103 12 . . PUNCT crln-9068 104 1 in in ADP crln-9068 104 2 july july PROPN crln-9068 104 3 2013 2013 NUM crln-9068 104 4 , , PUNCT crln-9068 104 5 the the DET crln-9068 104 6 department department PROPN crln-9068 104 7 of of ADP crln-9068 104 8 commerce commerce PROPN crln-9068 104 9 released release VERB crln-9068 104 10 a a DET crln-9068 104 11 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 104 12 green green ADJ crln-9068 104 13 paper”8 paper”8 PROPN crln-9068 104 14 on on ADP crln-9068 104 15 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 104 16 that that PRON crln-9068 104 17 solicited solicit VERB crln-9068 104 18 comments comment NOUN crln-9068 104 19 on on ADP crln-9068 104 20 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 104 21 first first ADJ crln-9068 104 22 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 104 23 . . PUNCT crln-9068 105 1 in in ADP crln-9068 105 2 response response NOUN crln-9068 105 3 , , PUNCT crln-9068 105 4 the the DET crln-9068 105 5 library library PROPN crln-9068 105 6 copyright copyright PROPN crln-9068 105 7 alliance alliance PROPN crln-9068 105 8 expressed express VERB crln-9068 105 9 concern concern NOUN crln-9068 105 10 about about ADP crln-9068 105 11 the the DET crln-9068 105 12 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 105 13 proliferation proliferation NOUN crln-9068 105 14 of of ADP crln-9068 105 15 licensing licensing NOUN crln-9068 105 16 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 105 17 and and CCONJ crln-9068 105 18 advocated advocate VERB crln-9068 105 19 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 105 20 restrictions restriction NOUN crln-9068 105 21 on on ADP crln-9068 105 22 the the DET crln-9068 105 23 enforcement enforcement NOUN crln-9068 105 24 of of ADP crln-9068 105 25 contractual contractual ADJ crln-9068 105 26 terms term NOUN crln-9068 105 27 that that PRON crln-9068 105 28 attempt attempt VERB crln-9068 105 29 to to PART crln-9068 105 30 limit limit VERB crln-9068 105 31 exceptions exception NOUN crln-9068 105 32 to to ADP crln-9068 105 33 the the DET crln-9068 105 34 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 105 35 act act NOUN crln-9068 105 36 such such ADJ crln-9068 105 37 as as ADP crln-9068 105 38 first first ADJ crln-9068 105 39 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 105 40 or or CCONJ crln-9068 105 41 fair fair ADJ crln-9068 105 42 use use NOUN crln-9068 105 43 . . PUNCT crln-9068 105 44 ”9 ”9 SPACE crln-9068 106 1 why why SCONJ crln-9068 106 2 ? ? PUNCT crln-9068 107 1 because because SCONJ crln-9068 107 2 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 107 3 ’s ’s NOUN crln-9068 107 4 exceptions exception NOUN crln-9068 107 5 are be AUX crln-9068 107 6 as as ADV crln-9068 107 7 important important ADJ crln-9068 107 8 to to ADP crln-9068 107 9 its its PRON crln-9068 107 10 scheme scheme NOUN crln-9068 107 11 as as ADP crln-9068 107 12 the the DET crln-9068 107 13 exclusive exclusive ADJ crln-9068 107 14 rights right NOUN crln-9068 107 15 themselves themselves PRON crln-9068 107 16 . . PUNCT crln-9068 108 1 many many ADJ crln-9068 108 2 librarians librarian NOUN crln-9068 108 3 are be AUX crln-9068 108 4 concerned concerned ADJ crln-9068 108 5 that that SCONJ crln-9068 108 6 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 108 7 technology technology NOUN crln-9068 108 8 has have AUX crln-9068 108 9 upset upset VERB crln-9068 108 10 the the DET crln-9068 108 11 balance balance NOUN crln-9068 108 12 between between ADP crln-9068 108 13 users user NOUN crln-9068 108 14 ’ ' PUNCT crln-9068 108 15 and and CCONJ crln-9068 108 16 owners owner NOUN crln-9068 108 17 ’ ’ PART crln-9068 108 18 rights right NOUN crln-9068 108 19 . . PUNCT crln-9068 109 1 in in ADP crln-9068 109 2 effect effect NOUN crln-9068 109 3 , , PUNCT crln-9068 109 4 we we PRON crln-9068 109 5 are be AUX crln-9068 109 6 back back ADV crln-9068 109 7 to to ADP crln-9068 109 8 1908 1908 NUM crln-9068 109 9 , , PUNCT crln-9068 109 10 except except SCONJ crln-9068 109 11 that that SCONJ crln-9068 109 12 now now ADV crln-9068 109 13 the the DET crln-9068 109 14 notice notice NOUN crln-9068 109 15 that that SCONJ crln-9068 109 16 the the DET crln-9068 109 17 publisher publisher NOUN crln-9068 109 18 inserted insert VERB crln-9068 109 19 in in ADP crln-9068 109 20 that that DET crln-9068 109 21 book book NOUN crln-9068 109 22 would would AUX crln-9068 109 23 have have AUX crln-9068 109 24 legal legal ADJ crln-9068 109 25 force force NOUN crln-9068 109 26 , , PUNCT crln-9068 109 27 and and CCONJ crln-9068 109 28 would would AUX crln-9068 109 29 be be AUX crln-9068 109 30 accompanied accompany VERB crln-9068 109 31 by by ADP crln-9068 109 32 more more ADJ crln-9068 109 33 restrictions restriction NOUN crln-9068 109 34 . . PUNCT crln-9068 110 1 what what PRON crln-9068 110 2 would would AUX crln-9068 110 3 legal legal ADJ crln-9068 110 4 reform reform NOUN crln-9068 110 5 look look VERB crln-9068 110 6 like like ADP crln-9068 110 7 ? ? PUNCT crln-9068 111 1 a a DET crln-9068 111 2 farreaching farreache VERB crln-9068 111 3 option option NOUN crln-9068 111 4 would would AUX crln-9068 111 5 be be AUX crln-9068 111 6 the the DET crln-9068 111 7 introduction introduction NOUN crln-9068 111 8 of of ADP crln-9068 111 9 a a DET crln-9068 111 10 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 111 11 first first ADJ crln-9068 111 12 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 111 13 right right NOUN crln-9068 111 14 that that PRON crln-9068 111 15 can can AUX crln-9068 111 16 not not PART crln-9068 111 17 be be AUX crln-9068 111 18 waived waive VERB crln-9068 111 19 by by ADP crln-9068 111 20 contract contract NOUN crln-9068 111 21 . . PUNCT crln-9068 112 1 short short ADJ crln-9068 112 2 of of ADP crln-9068 112 3 this this PRON crln-9068 112 4 , , PUNCT crln-9068 112 5 congress congress PROPN crln-9068 112 6 could could AUX crln-9068 112 7 grant grant VERB crln-9068 112 8 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 112 9 specific specific ADJ crln-9068 112 10 rights right NOUN crln-9068 112 11 allowing allow VERB crln-9068 112 12 them they PRON crln-9068 112 13 to to PART crln-9068 112 14 lend lend VERB crln-9068 112 15 , , PUNCT crln-9068 112 16 preserve preserve VERB crln-9068 112 17 , , PUNCT crln-9068 112 18 and and CCONJ crln-9068 112 19 archive archive ADJ crln-9068 112 20 electronic electronic ADJ crln-9068 112 21 materials material NOUN crln-9068 112 22 . . PUNCT crln-9068 113 1 courts court NOUN crln-9068 113 2 might might AUX crln-9068 113 3 continue continue VERB crln-9068 113 4 to to PART crln-9068 113 5 allow allow VERB crln-9068 113 6 fair fair ADJ crln-9068 113 7 use use NOUN crln-9068 113 8 to to PART crln-9068 113 9 shelter shelter VERB crln-9068 113 10 beneficial beneficial ADJ crln-9068 113 11 activities activity NOUN crln-9068 113 12 . . PUNCT crln-9068 114 1 finally finally ADV crln-9068 114 2 , , PUNCT crln-9068 114 3 private private ADJ crln-9068 114 4 initiatives initiative NOUN crln-9068 114 5 , , PUNCT crln-9068 114 6 such such ADJ crln-9068 114 7 as as ADP crln-9068 114 8 the the DET crln-9068 114 9 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 114 10 public public ADJ crln-9068 114 11 library library NOUN crln-9068 114 12 of of ADP crln-9068 114 13 america america PROPN crln-9068 114 14 and and CCONJ crln-9068 114 15 related relate VERB crln-9068 114 16 academic academic ADJ crln-9068 114 17 projects project NOUN crln-9068 114 18 , , PUNCT crln-9068 114 19 could could AUX crln-9068 114 20 step step VERB crln-9068 114 21 in in ADP crln-9068 114 22 to to PART crln-9068 114 23 offer offer VERB crln-9068 114 24 their their PRON crln-9068 114 25 own own ADJ crln-9068 114 26 solutions solution NOUN crln-9068 114 27 to to PART crln-9068 114 28 preserve preserve VERB crln-9068 114 29 libraries librarie VERB crln-9068 114 30 news news NOUN crln-9068 114 31 72 72 NUM crln-9068 114 32 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 114 33 april april PROPN crln-9068 114 34 2011 2011 NUM crln-9068 114 35 ): ): PUNCT crln-9068 114 36 217 217 NUM crln-9068 114 37 - - SYM crln-9068 114 38 20 20 NUM crln-9068 114 39 , , PUNCT crln-9068 114 40 http://crln.acrl.org/content/72/4/217.full http://crln.acrl.org/content/72/4/217.full PROPN crln-9068 114 41 . . PUNCT crln-9068 115 1 pdf+html?sid=0668456c-5592 pdf+html?sid=0668456c-5592 PROPN crln-9068 115 2 - - PUNCT crln-9068 115 3 4891 4891 NUM crln-9068 115 4 - - SYM crln-9068 115 5 90a2 90a2 NUM crln-9068 115 6 -52b954761733 -52b954761733 NOUN crln-9068 115 7 4 4 NUM crln-9068 115 8 . . PROPN crln-9068 115 9 hanna hanna PROPN crln-9068 115 10 rosin rosin PROPN crln-9068 115 11 , , PUNCT crln-9068 115 12 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 115 13 the the DET crln-9068 115 14 touch touch NOUN crln-9068 115 15 - - PUNCT crln-9068 115 16 screen screen NOUN crln-9068 115 17 generation generation NOUN crln-9068 115 18 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 115 19 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 115 20 cover cover VERB crln-9068 115 21 story story NOUN crln-9068 115 22 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 115 23 , , PUNCT crln-9068 115 24 atlantic atlantic PROPN crln-9068 115 25 monthly monthly PROPN crln-9068 115 26 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 115 27 10727825 10727825 NUM crln-9068 115 28 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 115 29 311 311 NUM crln-9068 115 30 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 115 31 3 3 NUM crln-9068 115 32 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 115 33 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 115 34 04 04 NUM crln-9068 115 35 ): ): PUNCT crln-9068 115 36 56 56 NUM crln-9068 115 37 - - SYM crln-9068 115 38 65 65 NUM crln-9068 115 39 . . PUNCT crln-9068 116 1 it it PRON crln-9068 116 2 is be AUX crln-9068 116 3 hard hard ADJ crln-9068 116 4 to to PART crln-9068 116 5 ignore ignore VERB crln-9068 116 6 the the DET crln-9068 116 7 changes change NOUN crln-9068 116 8 in in ADP crln-9068 116 9 learning learn VERB crln-9068 116 10 at at ADP crln-9068 116 11 all all DET crln-9068 116 12 levels level NOUN crln-9068 116 13 when when SCONJ crln-9068 116 14 bringing bring VERB crln-9068 116 15 tablets tablet NOUN crln-9068 116 16 to to ADP crln-9068 116 17 the the DET crln-9068 116 18 classroom classroom NOUN crln-9068 116 19 of of ADP crln-9068 116 20 college college NOUN crln-9068 116 21 - - PUNCT crln-9068 116 22 level level NOUN crln-9068 116 23 students student NOUN crln-9068 116 24 . . PUNCT crln-9068 117 1 libraries library NOUN crln-9068 117 2 ’ ' PUNCT crln-9068 117 3 freedoms freedom NOUN crln-9068 117 4 . . PUNCT crln-9068 118 1 these these DET crln-9068 118 2 efforts effort NOUN crln-9068 118 3 to to PART crln-9068 118 4 restore restore VERB crln-9068 118 5 balance balance NOUN crln-9068 118 6 are be AUX crln-9068 118 7 important important ADJ crln-9068 118 8 : : PUNCT crln-9068 118 9 publishers publisher NOUN crln-9068 118 10 ’ ’ PART crln-9068 118 11 concerns concern NOUN crln-9068 118 12 are be AUX crln-9068 118 13 legitimate legitimate ADJ crln-9068 118 14 , , PUNCT crln-9068 118 15 but but CCONJ crln-9068 118 16 the the DET crln-9068 118 17 cultural cultural ADJ crln-9068 118 18 freedoms freedom NOUN crln-9068 118 19 that that PRON crln-9068 118 20 first first ADJ crln-9068 118 21 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 118 22 protects protect NOUN crln-9068 118 23 should should AUX crln-9068 118 24 not not PART crln-9068 118 25 depend depend VERB crln-9068 118 26 entirely entirely ADV crln-9068 118 27 on on ADP crln-9068 118 28 a a DET crln-9068 118 29 licensor licensor NOUN crln-9068 118 30 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 118 31 whims whim NOUN crln-9068 118 32 , , PUNCT crln-9068 118 33 either either CCONJ crln-9068 118 34 in in ADP crln-9068 118 35 1908 1908 NUM crln-9068 118 36 or or CCONJ crln-9068 118 37 today today NOUN crln-9068 118 38 . . PUNCT crln-9068 119 1 notes note NOUN crln-9068 119 2 1 1 NUM crln-9068 119 3 . . PUNCT crln-9068 120 1 u.s u.s PROPN crln-9068 120 2 . . PROPN crln-9068 120 3 copyright copyright PROPN crln-9068 120 4 office office PROPN crln-9068 120 5 , , PUNCT crln-9068 120 6 dmca dmca NOUN crln-9068 120 7 section section NOUN crln-9068 120 8 104 104 NUM crln-9068 120 9 report report NOUN crln-9068 120 10 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 120 11 2001 2001 NUM crln-9068 120 12 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 120 13 . . PUNCT crln-9068 121 1 2 2 X crln-9068 121 2 . . X crln-9068 121 3 vernor vernor PROPN crln-9068 121 4 v. v. PROPN crln-9068 121 5 autodesk autodesk PROPN crln-9068 121 6 , , PUNCT crln-9068 121 7 inc inc PROPN crln-9068 121 8 . . PROPN crln-9068 121 9 , , PUNCT crln-9068 121 10 621 621 NUM crln-9068 121 11 f.3d f.3d SYM crln-9068 121 12 1102 1102 NUM crln-9068 121 13 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 121 14 9th 9th ADJ crln-9068 121 15 cir cir NOUN crln-9068 121 16 . . PUNCT crln-9068 121 17 2010 2010 NUM crln-9068 121 18 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 121 19 . . PUNCT crln-9068 122 1 3 3 X crln-9068 122 2 . . X crln-9068 122 3 kirtsaeng kirtsaeng PROPN crln-9068 122 4 v. v. PROPN crln-9068 122 5 john john PROPN crln-9068 122 6 wiley wiley PROPN crln-9068 122 7 & & CCONJ crln-9068 122 8 sons son NOUN crln-9068 122 9 , , PUNCT crln-9068 122 10 inc inc PROPN crln-9068 122 11 . . PROPN crln-9068 122 12 ,133 ,133 PROPN crln-9068 122 13 s.ct s.ct PROPN crln-9068 122 14 . . PUNCT crln-9068 123 1 1351 1351 NUM crln-9068 123 2 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 123 3 2013 2013 NUM crln-9068 123 4 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 123 5 . . PUNCT crln-9068 124 1 4 4 X crln-9068 124 2 . . X crln-9068 124 3 u.s u.s PROPN crln-9068 124 4 . . PROPN crln-9068 124 5 copyright copyright PROPN crln-9068 124 6 office office PROPN crln-9068 124 7 , , PUNCT crln-9068 124 8 dmca dmca NOUN crln-9068 124 9 section section NOUN crln-9068 124 10 104 104 NUM crln-9068 124 11 report report NOUN crln-9068 124 12 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 124 13 2001 2001 NUM crln-9068 124 14 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 124 15 . . PUNCT crln-9068 125 1 5 5 X crln-9068 125 2 . . X crln-9068 125 3 capitol capitol PROPN crln-9068 125 4 records record NOUN crln-9068 125 5 , , PUNCT crln-9068 125 6 llc llc PROPN crln-9068 125 7 v. v. PROPN crln-9068 125 8 redigi redigi PROPN crln-9068 125 9 inc inc PROPN crln-9068 125 10 . . PROPN crln-9068 125 11 , , PUNCT crln-9068 125 12 934 934 NUM crln-9068 125 13 f.supp.2d f.supp.2d NOUN crln-9068 125 14 640 640 NUM crln-9068 125 15 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 125 16 s.d.n.y s.d.n.y PROPN crln-9068 125 17 . . PROPN crln-9068 125 18 2013 2013 NUM crln-9068 125 19 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 125 20 . . PUNCT crln-9068 126 1 6 6 X crln-9068 126 2 . . X crln-9068 126 3 the the DET crln-9068 126 4 social social ADJ crln-9068 126 5 science science PROPN crln-9068 126 6 research research PROPN crln-9068 126 7 council council PROPN crln-9068 126 8 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 126 9 recent recent ADJ crln-9068 126 10 study study NOUN crln-9068 126 11 summarizes summarize VERB crln-9068 126 12 the the DET crln-9068 126 13 evidence evidence NOUN crln-9068 126 14 . . PUNCT crln-9068 127 1 see see VERB crln-9068 127 2 joe joe PROPN crln-9068 127 3 karaganis karaganis PROPN crln-9068 127 4 and and CCONJ crln-9068 127 5 lennart lennart PROPN crln-9068 127 6 renkema renkema PROPN crln-9068 127 7 , , PUNCT crln-9068 127 8 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 127 9 copy copy VERB crln-9068 127 10 culture culture NOUN crln-9068 127 11 in in ADP crln-9068 127 12 the the DET crln-9068 127 13 u.s u.s PROPN crln-9068 127 14 . . PROPN crln-9068 127 15 and and CCONJ crln-9068 127 16 germany germany PROPN crln-9068 127 17 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 127 18 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 127 19 january january PROPN crln-9068 127 20 2013 2013 NUM crln-9068 127 21 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 127 22 . . PUNCT crln-9068 128 1 7 7 X crln-9068 128 2 . . PROPN crln-9068 128 3 maria maria PROPN crln-9068 128 4 a. a. PROPN crln-9068 128 5 pallante pallante PROPN crln-9068 128 6 , , PUNCT crln-9068 128 7 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 128 8 the the DET crln-9068 128 9 next next ADJ crln-9068 128 10 great great ADJ crln-9068 128 11 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 128 12 act act NOUN crln-9068 128 13 – – PUNCT crln-9068 128 14 twenty twenty NUM crln-9068 128 15 - - PUNCT crln-9068 128 16 sixth sixth ADJ crln-9068 128 17 horace horace NOUN crln-9068 128 18 s. s. PROPN crln-9068 128 19 manges manges PROPN crln-9068 128 20 lecture lecture NOUN crln-9068 128 21 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 128 22 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 128 23 march march PROPN crln-9068 128 24 2013 2013 NUM crln-9068 128 25 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 128 26 . . PUNCT crln-9068 129 1 8 8 X crln-9068 129 2 . . X crln-9068 129 3 department department PROPN crln-9068 129 4 of of ADP crln-9068 129 5 commerce commerce PROPN crln-9068 129 6 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 129 7 internet internet NOUN crln-9068 129 8 policy policy NOUN crln-9068 129 9 task task NOUN crln-9068 129 10 force force NOUN crln-9068 129 11 green green PROPN crln-9068 129 12 paper paper NOUN crln-9068 129 13 on on ADP crln-9068 129 14 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 129 15 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 129 16 policy policy NOUN crln-9068 129 17 , , PUNCT crln-9068 129 18 creativity creativity NOUN crln-9068 129 19 , , PUNCT crln-9068 129 20 and and CCONJ crln-9068 129 21 innovation innovation NOUN crln-9068 129 22 in in ADP crln-9068 129 23 the the DET crln-9068 129 24 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 129 25 economy economy NOUN crln-9068 129 26 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 129 27 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 129 28 july july PROPN crln-9068 129 29 2013 2013 NUM crln-9068 129 30 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 129 31 . . PUNCT crln-9068 130 1 9 9 X crln-9068 130 2 . . X crln-9068 130 3 library library PROPN crln-9068 130 4 copyright copyright PROPN crln-9068 130 5 alliance alliance PROPN crln-9068 130 6 ’s ’s PART crln-9068 130 7 response response NOUN crln-9068 130 8 to to ADP crln-9068 130 9 the the DET crln-9068 130 10 request request NOUN crln-9068 130 11 for for ADP crln-9068 130 12 comments comment NOUN crln-9068 130 13 on on ADP crln-9068 130 14 the the DET crln-9068 130 15 department department PROPN crln-9068 130 16 of of ADP crln-9068 130 17 commerce commerce PROPN crln-9068 130 18 green green PROPN crln-9068 130 19 paper paper PROPN crln-9068 130 20 , , PUNCT crln-9068 130 21 copyright copyright NOUN crln-9068 130 22 policy policy NOUN crln-9068 130 23 , , PUNCT crln-9068 130 24 creativity creativity NOUN crln-9068 130 25 , , PUNCT crln-9068 130 26 and and CCONJ crln-9068 130 27 innovation innovation NOUN crln-9068 130 28 in in ADP crln-9068 130 29 the the DET crln-9068 130 30 digital digital ADJ crln-9068 130 31 economy economy NOUN crln-9068 130 32 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 130 33 november november PROPN crln-9068 130 34 2013 2013 NUM crln-9068 130 35 ) ) PUNCT crln-9068 130 36 . . PUNCT crln-9068 131 1 ( ( PUNCT crln-9068 131 2 “ " PUNCT crln-9068 131 3 last last ADJ crln-9068 131 4 sale sale NOUN crln-9068 131 5 ? ? PUNCT crln-9068 131 6 ” " PUNCT crln-9068 131 7 cont cont NOUN crln-9068 131 8 . . PUNCT crln-9068 132 1 from from ADP crln-9068 132 2 page page NOUN crln-9068 132 3 71 71 NUM crln-9068 132 4 ) ) PUNCT