id sid tid token lemma pos 42759 1 1 generously generously RB 42759 1 2 made make VBN 42759 1 3 available available JJ 42759 1 4 by by IN 42759 1 5 Internet Internet NNP 42759 1 6 Archive Archive NNP 42759 1 7 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1 8 https://archive.org https://archive.org NNP 42759 1 9 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1 10 Note note VB 42759 1 11 : : : 42759 1 12 Images image NNS 42759 1 13 of of IN 42759 1 14 the the DT 42759 1 15 original original JJ 42759 1 16 pages page NNS 42759 1 17 are be VBP 42759 1 18 available available JJ 42759 1 19 through through IN 42759 1 20 Internet Internet NNP 42759 1 21 Archive Archive NNP 42759 1 22 . . . 42759 2 1 See see VB 42759 2 2 https://archive.org/details/distributivejust00ryaniala https://archive.org/details/distributivejust00ryaniala JJ 42759 2 3 DISTRIBUTIVE DISTRIBUTIVE NNP 42759 2 4 JUSTICE justice NN 42759 2 5 * * NFP 42759 2 6 * * NFP 42759 2 7 * * NFP 42759 2 8 * * NFP 42759 2 9 * * NFP 42759 2 10 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2 11 Illustration illustration NN 42759 2 12 : : : 42759 2 13 ( ( -LRB- 42759 2 14 MACMILLAN MACMILLAN NNP 42759 2 15 LOGO LOGO NNP 42759 2 16 ) ) -RRB- 42759 2 17 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2 18 THE the DT 42759 2 19 MACMILLAN MACMILLAN NNP 42759 2 20 COMPANY COMPANY NNP 42759 2 21 NEW NEW NNP 42759 2 22 YORK YORK NNP 42759 2 23 · · NFP 42759 2 24 BOSTON BOSTON NNP 42759 2 25 · · NFP 42759 2 26 CHICAGO CHICAGO NNP 42759 2 27 · · NFP 42759 2 28 DALLAS DALLAS NNP 42759 2 29 ATLANTA ATLANTA NNP 42759 2 30 · · NFP 42759 2 31 SAN SAN NNP 42759 2 32 FRANCISCO FRANCISCO NNP 42759 2 33 MACMILLAN MACMILLAN NNP 42759 2 34 & & CC 42759 2 35 CO CO NNP 42759 2 36 . . NNP 42759 2 37 , , , 42759 2 38 LIMITED LIMITED NNP 42759 2 39 LONDON LONDON NNP 42759 2 40 · · NFP 42759 2 41 BOMBAY BOMBAY NNP 42759 2 42 · · NFP 42759 2 43 CALCUTTA CALCUTTA NNS 42759 2 44 MELBOURNE melbourne RB 42759 2 45 THE the DT 42759 2 46 MACMILLAN MACMILLAN NNP 42759 2 47 CO CO NNP 42759 2 48 . . . 42759 2 49 OF of IN 42759 2 50 CANADA CANADA NNP 42759 2 51 , , , 42759 2 52 LTD LTD NNP 42759 2 53 . . . 42759 2 54 TORONTO TORONTO NNP 42759 2 55 * * NFP 42759 2 56 * * NFP 42759 2 57 * * NFP 42759 2 58 * * NFP 42759 2 59 * * NFP 42759 2 60 DISTRIBUTIVE DISTRIBUTIVE NNP 42759 2 61 JUSTICE JUSTICE NNP 42759 2 62 The The NNP 42759 2 63 Right Right NNP 42759 2 64 and and CC 42759 2 65 Wrong wrong NN 42759 2 66 of of IN 42759 2 67 Our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2 68 Present present JJ 42759 2 69 Distribution distribution NN 42759 2 70 of of IN 42759 2 71 Wealth wealth NN 42759 2 72 by by IN 42759 2 73 JOHN JOHN NNP 42759 2 74 A. a. NN 42759 2 75 RYAN RYAN NNP 42759 2 76 , , , 42759 2 77 D.D. D.D. NNP 42759 3 1 Associate associate JJ 42759 3 2 Professor Professor NNP 42759 3 3 of of IN 42759 3 4 Political Political NNP 42759 3 5 Science Science NNP 42759 3 6 at at IN 42759 3 7 the the DT 42759 3 8 Catholic Catholic NNP 42759 3 9 University University NNP 42759 3 10 of of IN 42759 3 11 America America NNP 42759 3 12 ; ; : 42759 3 13 Professor Professor NNP 42759 3 14 of of IN 42759 3 15 Economics Economics NNP 42759 3 16 at at IN 42759 3 17 Trinity Trinity NNP 42759 3 18 College College NNP 42759 3 19 ; ; , 42759 3 20 Author author NN 42759 3 21 of of IN 42759 3 22 " " `` 42759 3 23 A a DT 42759 3 24 Living live VBG 42759 3 25 Wage wage NN 42759 3 26 , , , 42759 3 27 " " '' 42759 3 28 " " `` 42759 3 29 Alleged alleged JJ 42759 3 30 Socialism socialism NN 42759 3 31 of of IN 42759 3 32 the the DT 42759 3 33 Church Church NNP 42759 3 34 Fathers father NNS 42759 3 35 , , , 42759 3 36 " " '' 42759 3 37 Joint Joint NNP 42759 3 38 Author author NN 42759 3 39 with with IN 42759 3 40 Morris Morris NNP 42759 3 41 Hillquit Hillquit NNP 42759 3 42 of of IN 42759 3 43 " " `` 42759 3 44 Socialism socialism NN 42759 3 45 : : : 42759 3 46 Promise promise NN 42759 3 47 or or CC 42759 3 48 Menace menace NN 42759 3 49 ? ? . 42759 3 50 " " '' 42759 4 1 New New NNP 42759 4 2 York York NNP 42759 4 3 The the DT 42759 4 4 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 4 5 Company Company NNP 42759 4 6 1916 1916 CD 42759 4 7 All all DT 42759 4 8 rights right NNS 42759 4 9 reserved reserve VBD 42759 4 10 Nihil Nihil NNP 42759 4 11 Obstat Obstat NNP 42759 4 12 . . . 42759 5 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5 2 REMIGIUS REMIGIUS NNP 42759 5 3 LAFORT LAFORT NNP 42759 5 4 , , , 42759 5 5 S. S. NNP 42759 5 6 T. T. NNP 42759 5 7 D. D. NNP 42759 5 8 , , , 42759 5 9 Censor Censor NNP 42759 5 10 _ _ NNP 42759 5 11 . . . 42759 6 1 Imprimatur Imprimatur NNP 42759 6 2 . . . 42759 7 1 _ _ NNP 42759 7 2 JOHN JOHN NNP 42759 7 3 CARDINAL CARDINAL NNP 42759 7 4 FARLEY FARLEY NNP 42759 7 5 , , , 42759 7 6 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 42759 7 7 of of IN 42759 7 8 New New NNP 42759 7 9 York York NNP 42759 7 10 _ _ NNP 42759 7 11 . . . 42759 8 1 COPYRIGHT COPYRIGHT NNP 42759 8 2 , , , 42759 8 3 1916 1916 CD 42759 8 4 , , , 42759 8 5 BY by IN 42759 8 6 THE the DT 42759 8 7 MACMILLAN MACMILLAN NNP 42759 8 8 COMPANY COMPANY NNP 42759 8 9 Set Set VBD 42759 8 10 up up RP 42759 8 11 and and CC 42759 8 12 electrotyped electrotype VBD 42759 8 13 . . . 42759 9 1 Published Published NNP 42759 9 2 November November NNP 42759 9 3 , , , 42759 9 4 1916 1916 CD 42759 9 5 . . . 42759 10 1 TO to IN 42759 10 2 ARCHBISHOP ARCHBISHOP NNP 42759 10 3 IRELAND IRELAND NNP 42759 10 4 IN in IN 42759 10 5 ADMIRATION admiration NN 42759 10 6 AND and CC 42759 10 7 GRATITUDE GRATITUDE NNP 42759 10 8 PREFACE PREFACE NNP 42759 10 9 Five five CD 42759 10 10 of of IN 42759 10 11 the the DT 42759 10 12 nine nine CD 42759 10 13 members member NNS 42759 10 14 of of IN 42759 10 15 the the DT 42759 10 16 late late JJ 42759 10 17 Federal Federal NNP 42759 10 18 Commission Commission NNP 42759 10 19 on on IN 42759 10 20 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 10 21 Relations Relations NNPS 42759 10 22 united unite VBD 42759 10 23 in in IN 42759 10 24 the the DT 42759 10 25 declaration declaration NN 42759 10 26 that that IN 42759 10 27 the the DT 42759 10 28 first first JJ 42759 10 29 cause cause NN 42759 10 30 of of IN 42759 10 31 industrial industrial JJ 42759 10 32 unrest unrest NN 42759 10 33 is be VBZ 42759 10 34 , , , 42759 10 35 " " `` 42759 10 36 unjust unjust JJ 42759 10 37 distribution distribution NN 42759 10 38 of of IN 42759 10 39 wealth wealth NN 42759 10 40 and and CC 42759 10 41 income income NN 42759 10 42 . . . 42759 10 43 " " '' 42759 11 1 In in IN 42759 11 2 all all DT 42759 11 3 probability probability NN 42759 11 4 this this DT 42759 11 5 judgment judgment NN 42759 11 6 is be VBZ 42759 11 7 shared share VBN 42759 11 8 by by IN 42759 11 9 the the DT 42759 11 10 majority majority NN 42759 11 11 of of IN 42759 11 12 the the DT 42759 11 13 American american JJ 42759 11 14 people people NNS 42759 11 15 . . . 42759 12 1 Regarding regard VBG 42759 12 2 the the DT 42759 12 3 precise precise JJ 42759 12 4 nature nature NN 42759 12 5 and and CC 42759 12 6 extent extent NN 42759 12 7 of of IN 42759 12 8 the the DT 42759 12 9 injustice injustice NN 42759 12 10 , , , 42759 12 11 however however RB 42759 12 12 , , , 42759 12 13 there there EX 42759 12 14 is be VBZ 42759 12 15 no no DT 42759 12 16 such such JJ 42759 12 17 preponderance preponderance NN 42759 12 18 of of IN 42759 12 19 opinion opinion NN 42759 12 20 . . . 42759 13 1 Even even RB 42759 13 2 the the DT 42759 13 3 makers maker NNS 42759 13 4 of of IN 42759 13 5 ethical ethical JJ 42759 13 6 and and CC 42759 13 7 economic economic JJ 42759 13 8 treatises treatise NNS 42759 13 9 fail fail VBP 42759 13 10 to to TO 42759 13 11 give give VB 42759 13 12 us -PRON- PRP 42759 13 13 anything anything NN 42759 13 14 like like IN 42759 13 15 uniform uniform JJ 42759 13 16 or or CC 42759 13 17 definite definite JJ 42759 13 18 pronouncements pronouncement NNS 42759 13 19 concerning concern VBG 42759 13 20 the the DT 42759 13 21 moral moral JJ 42759 13 22 defects defect NNS 42759 13 23 of of IN 42759 13 24 the the DT 42759 13 25 present present JJ 42759 13 26 distribution distribution NN 42759 13 27 . . . 42759 14 1 While while IN 42759 14 2 the the DT 42759 14 3 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 14 4 and and CC 42759 14 5 the the DT 42759 14 6 Single Single NNP 42759 14 7 Taxers Taxers NNPS 42759 14 8 are be VBP 42759 14 9 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 14 10 positive positive JJ 42759 14 11 in in IN 42759 14 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 14 13 statements statement NNS 42759 14 14 , , , 42759 14 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 14 16 form form VBP 42759 14 17 only only RB 42759 14 18 a a DT 42759 14 19 small small JJ 42759 14 20 portion portion NN 42759 14 21 of of IN 42759 14 22 the the DT 42759 14 23 total total JJ 42759 14 24 population population NN 42759 14 25 , , , 42759 14 26 and and CC 42759 14 27 include include VBP 42759 14 28 only only RB 42759 14 29 an an DT 42759 14 30 insignificant insignificant JJ 42759 14 31 fraction fraction NN 42759 14 32 of of IN 42759 14 33 the the DT 42759 14 34 recognised recognise VBN 42759 14 35 authorities authority NNS 42759 14 36 on on IN 42759 14 37 either either DT 42759 14 38 ethics ethic NNS 42759 14 39 or or CC 42759 14 40 economics economic NNS 42759 14 41 . . . 42759 15 1 The the DT 42759 15 2 volume volume NN 42759 15 3 in in IN 42759 15 4 hand hand NN 42759 15 5 represents represent VBZ 42759 15 6 an an DT 42759 15 7 attempt attempt NN 42759 15 8 to to TO 42759 15 9 discuss discuss VB 42759 15 10 systematically systematically RB 42759 15 11 and and CC 42759 15 12 comprehensively comprehensively RB 42759 15 13 the the DT 42759 15 14 justice justice NN 42759 15 15 of of IN 42759 15 16 the the DT 42759 15 17 processes process NNS 42759 15 18 by by IN 42759 15 19 which which WDT 42759 15 20 the the DT 42759 15 21 product product NN 42759 15 22 of of IN 42759 15 23 industry industry NN 42759 15 24 is be VBZ 42759 15 25 distributed distribute VBN 42759 15 26 . . . 42759 16 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 16 2 as as IN 42759 16 3 the the DT 42759 16 4 product product NN 42759 16 5 is be VBZ 42759 16 6 actually actually RB 42759 16 7 apportioned apportion VBN 42759 16 8 among among IN 42759 16 9 landowners landowner NNS 42759 16 10 , , , 42759 16 11 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 16 12 , , , 42759 16 13 business business NN 42759 16 14 men man NNS 42759 16 15 , , , 42759 16 16 and and CC 42759 16 17 labourers labourer NNS 42759 16 18 , , , 42759 16 19 the the DT 42759 16 20 moral moral JJ 42759 16 21 aspects aspect NNS 42759 16 22 of of IN 42759 16 23 the the DT 42759 16 24 distribution distribution NN 42759 16 25 are be VBP 42759 16 26 studied study VBN 42759 16 27 with with IN 42759 16 28 reference reference NN 42759 16 29 to to IN 42759 16 30 these these DT 42759 16 31 four four CD 42759 16 32 classes class NNS 42759 16 33 . . . 42759 17 1 While while IN 42759 17 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 17 3 rights right NNS 42759 17 4 and and CC 42759 17 5 obligations obligation NNS 42759 17 6 form form VBP 42759 17 7 the the DT 42759 17 8 main main JJ 42759 17 9 subject subject NN 42759 17 10 of of IN 42759 17 11 the the DT 42759 17 12 book book NN 42759 17 13 , , , 42759 17 14 the the DT 42759 17 15 effort effort NN 42759 17 16 is be VBZ 42759 17 17 also also RB 42759 17 18 made make VBN 42759 17 19 to to TO 42759 17 20 propose propose VB 42759 17 21 reforms reform NNS 42759 17 22 that that WDT 42759 17 23 would would MD 42759 17 24 remove remove VB 42759 17 25 the the DT 42759 17 26 principal principal JJ 42759 17 27 defects defect NNS 42759 17 28 of of IN 42759 17 29 the the DT 42759 17 30 present present JJ 42759 17 31 system system NN 42759 17 32 and and CC 42759 17 33 bring bring VB 42759 17 34 about about RP 42759 17 35 a a DT 42759 17 36 larger large JJR 42759 17 37 measure measure NN 42759 17 38 of of IN 42759 17 39 justice justice NN 42759 17 40 . . . 42759 18 1 Many many JJ 42759 18 2 treatises treatise NNS 42759 18 3 have have VBP 42759 18 4 been be VBN 42759 18 5 written write VBN 42759 18 6 concerning concern VBG 42759 18 7 the the DT 42759 18 8 morality morality NN 42759 18 9 of of IN 42759 18 10 one one CD 42759 18 11 or or CC 42759 18 12 other other JJ 42759 18 13 element element NN 42759 18 14 or or CC 42759 18 15 section section NN 42759 18 16 of of IN 42759 18 17 the the DT 42759 18 18 distributive distributive JJ 42759 18 19 process process NN 42759 18 20 ; ; : 42759 18 21 for for IN 42759 18 22 example example NN 42759 18 23 , , , 42759 18 24 wages wage NNS 42759 18 25 , , , 42759 18 26 interest interest NN 42759 18 27 , , , 42759 18 28 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 18 29 , , , 42759 18 30 the the DT 42759 18 31 land land NN 42759 18 32 question question NN 42759 18 33 ; ; : 42759 18 34 but but CC 42759 18 35 , , , 42759 18 36 so so RB 42759 18 37 far far RB 42759 18 38 as as IN 42759 18 39 the the DT 42759 18 40 author author NN 42759 18 41 knows know VBZ 42759 18 42 , , , 42759 18 43 no no DT 42759 18 44 attempt attempt NN 42759 18 45 has have VBZ 42759 18 46 hitherto hitherto VBN 42759 18 47 been be VBN 42759 18 48 made make VBN 42759 18 49 to to TO 42759 18 50 discuss discuss VB 42759 18 51 the the DT 42759 18 52 moral moral JJ 42759 18 53 aspects aspect NNS 42759 18 54 of of IN 42759 18 55 the the DT 42759 18 56 entire entire JJ 42759 18 57 process process NN 42759 18 58 in in IN 42759 18 59 all all PDT 42759 18 60 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 18 61 parts part NNS 42759 18 62 . . . 42759 19 1 At at RB 42759 19 2 least least JJS 42759 19 3 , , , 42759 19 4 no no DT 42759 19 5 such such JJ 42759 19 6 task task NN 42759 19 7 has have VBZ 42759 19 8 been be VBN 42759 19 9 undertaken undertake VBN 42759 19 10 by by IN 42759 19 11 any any DT 42759 19 12 one one NN 42759 19 13 who who WP 42759 19 14 believes believe VBZ 42759 19 15 that that IN 42759 19 16 the the DT 42759 19 17 existing exist VBG 42759 19 18 economic economic JJ 42759 19 19 system system NN 42759 19 20 is be VBZ 42759 19 21 not not RB 42759 19 22 inherently inherently RB 42759 19 23 unjust unjust JJ 42759 19 24 . . . 42759 20 1 That that IN 42759 20 2 the the DT 42759 20 3 present present JJ 42759 20 4 essay essay NN 42759 20 5 in in IN 42759 20 6 this this DT 42759 20 7 field field NN 42759 20 8 falls fall VBZ 42759 20 9 far far RB 42759 20 10 short short RB 42759 20 11 of of IN 42759 20 12 adequate adequate JJ 42759 20 13 achievement achievement NN 42759 20 14 the the DT 42759 20 15 author author NN 42759 20 16 fully fully RB 42759 20 17 realises realise VBZ 42759 20 18 , , , 42759 20 19 but but CC 42759 20 20 he -PRON- PRP 42759 20 21 is be VBZ 42759 20 22 sustained sustain VBN 42759 20 23 by by IN 42759 20 24 the the DT 42759 20 25 hope hope NN 42759 20 26 that that IN 42759 20 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 20 28 will will MD 42759 20 29 provoke provoke VB 42759 20 30 discussion discussion NN 42759 20 31 , , , 42759 20 32 and and CC 42759 20 33 move move VB 42759 20 34 some some DT 42759 20 35 more more RBR 42759 20 36 competent competent JJ 42759 20 37 person person NN 42759 20 38 to to IN 42759 20 39 till till IN 42759 20 40 the the DT 42759 20 41 same same JJ 42759 20 42 field field NN 42759 20 43 in in IN 42759 20 44 a a DT 42759 20 45 more more RBR 42759 20 46 thorough thorough JJ 42759 20 47 and and CC 42759 20 48 fruitful fruitful JJ 42759 20 49 way way NN 42759 20 50 . . . 42759 21 1 JOHN JOHN NNP 42759 21 2 A. a. NN 42759 21 3 RYAN RYAN NNS 42759 21 4 . . . 42759 22 1 The the DT 42759 22 2 Catholic Catholic NNP 42759 22 3 University University NNP 42759 22 4 of of IN 42759 22 5 America America NNP 42759 22 6 , , , 42759 22 7 Washington Washington NNP 42759 22 8 , , , 42759 22 9 D. D. NNP 42759 22 10 C. C. NNP 42759 22 11 , , , 42759 22 12 June June NNP 42759 22 13 14 14 CD 42759 22 14 , , , 42759 22 15 1916 1916 CD 42759 22 16 . . . 42759 23 1 CONTENTS content NNS 42759 23 2 PREFACE preface NN 42759 23 3 vii vii VBP 42759 23 4 INTRODUCTORY INTRODUCTORY NNP 42759 23 5 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 23 6 : : : 42759 23 7 THE the DT 42759 23 8 ELEMENTS element NNS 42759 23 9 AND and CC 42759 23 10 SCOPE scope NN 42759 23 11 OF of IN 42759 23 12 THE the DT 42759 23 13 PROBLEM PROBLEM NNP 42759 23 14 xiii xiii NN 42759 23 15 General General NNP 42759 23 16 References References NNPS 42759 23 17 xvii xvii NN 42759 23 18 SECTION section NN 42759 23 19 I -PRON- PRP 42759 23 20 THE the DT 42759 23 21 MORALITY morality NN 42759 23 22 OF of IN 42759 23 23 PRIVATE private JJ 42759 23 24 LANDOWNERSHIP landownership NN 42759 23 25 AND and CC 42759 23 26 RENT RENT NNP 42759 23 27 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 23 28 PAGE page NN 42759 23 29 I -PRON- PRP 42759 23 30 THE the DT 42759 23 31 LANDOWNER LANDOWNER NNP 42759 23 32 'S 's POS 42759 23 33 SHARE share NN 42759 23 34 OF of IN 42759 23 35 THE the DT 42759 23 36 NATIONAL NATIONAL NNP 42759 23 37 PRODUCT PRODUCT NNP 42759 23 38 3 3 CD 42759 23 39 Economic Economic NNP 42759 23 40 Rent Rent NNP 42759 23 41 Always always RB 42759 23 42 Goes go VBZ 42759 23 43 to to IN 42759 23 44 the the DT 42759 23 45 Landowner Landowner NNP 42759 23 46 4 4 CD 42759 23 47 Economic Economic NNP 42759 23 48 Rent Rent NNP 42759 23 49 and and CC 42759 23 50 Commercial Commercial NNP 42759 23 51 Rent Rent NNP 42759 23 52 5 5 CD 42759 23 53 The the DT 42759 23 54 Cause cause NN 42759 23 55 of of IN 42759 23 56 Economic Economic NNP 42759 23 57 Rent Rent NNP 42759 23 58 6 6 CD 42759 23 59 II II NNP 42759 23 60 LANDOWNERSHIP landownership NN 42759 23 61 IN in IN 42759 23 62 HISTORY history NN 42759 23 63 8 8 CD 42759 23 64 No no DT 42759 23 65 Private private JJ 42759 23 66 Ownership ownership NN 42759 23 67 in in IN 42759 23 68 Pre Pre NNP 42759 23 69 - - NNP 42759 23 70 Agricultural Agricultural NNP 42759 23 71 Conditions Conditions NNPS 42759 23 72 10 10 CD 42759 23 73 How how WRB 42759 23 74 the the DT 42759 23 75 Change change NN 42759 23 76 Probably probably RB 42759 23 77 Took take VBD 42759 23 78 Place place NN 42759 23 79 12 12 CD 42759 23 80 Limited Limited NNP 42759 23 81 Character Character NNP 42759 23 82 of of IN 42759 23 83 Primitive Primitive NNP 42759 23 84 Common Common NNP 42759 23 85 Ownership Ownership NNP 42759 23 86 14 14 CD 42759 23 87 Private private JJ 42759 23 88 Ownership Ownership NNP 42759 23 89 General General NNP 42759 23 90 in in IN 42759 23 91 Historical Historical NNP 42759 23 92 Times Times NNP 42759 23 93 15 15 CD 42759 23 94 Conclusions Conclusions NNPS 42759 23 95 from from IN 42759 23 96 History history NN 42759 23 97 17 17 CD 42759 23 98 III iii CD 42759 23 99 THE the DT 42759 23 100 ARGUMENTS argument NNS 42759 23 101 AGAINST against IN 42759 23 102 PRIVATE private JJ 42759 23 103 LANDOWNERSHIP landownership NN 42759 23 104 19 19 CD 42759 23 105 Arguments argument NNS 42759 23 106 by by IN 42759 23 107 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 23 108 19 19 CD 42759 23 109 Henry Henry NNP 42759 23 110 George George NNP 42759 23 111 's 's POS 42759 23 112 Attack Attack NNP 42759 23 113 on on IN 42759 23 114 the the DT 42759 23 115 Title title NN 42759 23 116 of of IN 42759 23 117 First First NNP 42759 23 118 Occupancy Occupancy NNP 42759 23 119 21 21 CD 42759 23 120 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 23 121 Defence Defence NNP 42759 23 122 of of IN 42759 23 123 the the DT 42759 23 124 Title title NN 42759 23 125 of of IN 42759 23 126 Labour Labour NNP 42759 23 127 24 24 CD 42759 23 128 The the DT 42759 23 129 Right right NN 42759 23 130 of of IN 42759 23 131 all all DT 42759 23 132 Men Men NNPS 42759 23 133 to to IN 42759 23 134 the the DT 42759 23 135 Bounty Bounty NNP 42759 23 136 of of IN 42759 23 137 the the DT 42759 23 138 Earth Earth NNP 42759 23 139 30 30 CD 42759 23 140 The the DT 42759 23 141 Alleged Alleged NNP 42759 23 142 Right Right NNP 42759 23 143 of of IN 42759 23 144 the the DT 42759 23 145 Community Community NNP 42759 23 146 to to IN 42759 23 147 Land Land NNP 42759 23 148 Values value NNS 42759 23 149 39 39 CD 42759 23 150 IV iv NN 42759 23 151 PRIVATE private JJ 42759 23 152 OWNERSHIP OWNERSHIP VBD 42759 23 153 THE the DT 42759 23 154 BEST best NN 42759 23 155 SYSTEM system NN 42759 23 156 OF of IN 42759 23 157 LAND land NN 42759 23 158 TENURE tenure NN 42759 23 159 48 48 CD 42759 23 160 The the DT 42759 23 161 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 23 162 Proposals Proposals NNPS 42759 23 163 Impracticable Impracticable NNP 42759 23 164 48 48 CD 42759 23 165 Inferiority Inferiority NNP 42759 23 166 of of IN 42759 23 167 the the DT 42759 23 168 Single Single NNP 42759 23 169 Tax Tax NNP 42759 23 170 System System NNP 42759 23 171 51 51 CD 42759 23 172 V v NN 42759 23 173 PRIVATE private JJ 42759 23 174 LANDOWNERSHIP LANDOWNERSHIP NNP 42759 23 175 A a DT 42759 23 176 NATURAL natural JJ 42759 23 177 RIGHT right NN 42759 23 178 56 56 CD 42759 23 179 Three three CD 42759 23 180 Principal principal JJ 42759 23 181 Kinds Kinds NNPS 42759 23 182 of of IN 42759 23 183 Natural Natural NNP 42759 23 184 Rights Rights NNPS 42759 23 185 57 57 CD 42759 23 186 Private private JJ 42759 23 187 Landownership landownership NN 42759 23 188 Indirectly indirectly RB 42759 23 189 Necessary necessary JJ 42759 23 190 for for IN 42759 23 191 Individual Individual NNP 42759 23 192 Welfare Welfare NNP 42759 23 193 59 59 CD 42759 23 194 Excessive excessive JJ 42759 23 195 Interpretations Interpretations NNPS 42759 23 196 of of IN 42759 23 197 the the DT 42759 23 198 Right Right NNP 42759 23 199 of of IN 42759 23 200 Private Private NNP 42759 23 201 Landownership Landownership NNP 42759 23 202 61 61 CD 42759 23 203 The the DT 42759 23 204 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 42759 23 205 of of IN 42759 23 206 the the DT 42759 23 207 Fathers father NNS 42759 23 208 and and CC 42759 23 209 the the DT 42759 23 210 Theologians Theologians NNPS 42759 23 211 62 62 CD 42759 23 212 The the DT 42759 23 213 Teaching teaching NN 42759 23 214 of of IN 42759 23 215 Pope Pope NNP 42759 23 216 Leo Leo NNP 42759 23 217 XIII XIII NNP 42759 23 218 64 64 CD 42759 23 219 VI VI NNP 42759 23 220 LIMITATIONS limitations NN 42759 23 221 OF of IN 42759 23 222 THE the DT 42759 23 223 LANDOWNER LANDOWNER NNP 42759 23 224 'S 's POS 42759 23 225 RIGHT right NN 42759 23 226 TO to IN 42759 23 227 RENT rent VB 42759 23 228 67 67 CD 42759 23 229 The the DT 42759 23 230 Tenant Tenant NNP 42759 23 231 's 's POS 42759 23 232 Right right NN 42759 23 233 to to IN 42759 23 234 a a DT 42759 23 235 Decent Decent NNP 42759 23 236 Livelihood Livelihood NNP 42759 23 237 69 69 CD 42759 23 238 The the DT 42759 23 239 Labourer Labourer NNP 42759 23 240 's 's POS 42759 23 241 Claim claim NN 42759 23 242 Upon upon IN 42759 23 243 the the DT 42759 23 244 Rent Rent NNP 42759 23 245 71 71 CD 42759 23 246 VII VII NNP 42759 23 247 DEFECTS DEFECTS NNP 42759 23 248 OF of IN 42759 23 249 THE the DT 42759 23 250 EXISTING exist VBG 42759 23 251 LAND land NN 42759 23 252 SYSTEM system NN 42759 23 253 74 74 CD 42759 23 254 Landownership landownership NN 42759 23 255 and and CC 42759 23 256 Monopoly Monopoly NNP 42759 23 257 75 75 CD 42759 23 258 Excessive excessive JJ 42759 23 259 Gains gain NNS 42759 23 260 from from IN 42759 23 261 Private Private NNP 42759 23 262 Landownership landownership NN 42759 23 263 80 80 CD 42759 23 264 Exclusion exclusion NN 42759 23 265 from from IN 42759 23 266 the the DT 42759 23 267 Land Land NNP 42759 23 268 90 90 CD 42759 23 269 VIII viii NN 42759 23 270 METHODS method NNS 42759 23 271 OF of IN 42759 23 272 REFORMING reform VBG 42759 23 273 OUR our PRP$ 42759 23 274 LAND land NN 42759 23 275 SYSTEM system NN 42759 23 276 94 94 CD 42759 23 277 The the DT 42759 23 278 Leasing lease VBG 42759 23 279 System system NN 42759 23 280 95 95 CD 42759 23 281 Public Public NNP 42759 23 282 Agricultural Agricultural NNP 42759 23 283 Lands Lands NNPS 42759 23 284 97 97 CD 42759 23 285 Public public JJ 42759 23 286 Ownership Ownership NNP 42759 23 287 of of IN 42759 23 288 Urban Urban NNP 42759 23 289 Land Land NNP 42759 23 290 98 98 CD 42759 23 291 Appropriating Appropriating NNP 42759 23 292 Future Future NNP 42759 23 293 Increases Increases NNPS 42759 23 294 of of IN 42759 23 295 Land land NN 42759 23 296 Value Value NNP 42759 23 297 100 100 CD 42759 23 298 Some some DT 42759 23 299 Objections objection NNS 42759 23 300 to to IN 42759 23 301 the the DT 42759 23 302 Increment Increment NNP 42759 23 303 Tax Tax NNP 42759 23 304 102 102 CD 42759 23 305 The the DT 42759 23 306 Morality morality NN 42759 23 307 of of IN 42759 23 308 the the DT 42759 23 309 Proposal Proposal NNP 42759 23 310 108 108 CD 42759 23 311 The the DT 42759 23 312 German german JJ 42759 23 313 and and CC 42759 23 314 British british JJ 42759 23 315 Increment Increment NNP 42759 23 316 Taxes Taxes NNP 42759 23 317 114 114 CD 42759 23 318 Transferring transfer VBG 42759 23 319 Other other JJ 42759 23 320 Taxes taxis NNS 42759 23 321 to to IN 42759 23 322 Land land NN 42759 23 323 117 117 CD 42759 23 324 The the DT 42759 23 325 Morality morality NN 42759 23 326 of of IN 42759 23 327 the the DT 42759 23 328 Plan Plan NNP 42759 23 329 120 120 CD 42759 23 330 Amount Amount NNP 42759 23 331 of of IN 42759 23 332 Taxes taxis NNS 42759 23 333 Practically practically RB 42759 23 334 Transferable Transferable NNP 42759 23 335 122 122 CD 42759 23 336 The the DT 42759 23 337 Social Social NNP 42759 23 338 Benefits Benefits NNPS 42759 23 339 of of IN 42759 23 340 the the DT 42759 23 341 Plan plan NN 42759 23 342 127 127 CD 42759 23 343 A a DT 42759 23 344 Supertax supertax NN 42759 23 345 on on IN 42759 23 346 Large large JJ 42759 23 347 Holdings holding NNS 42759 23 348 130 130 CD 42759 23 349 References reference NNS 42759 23 350 on on IN 42759 23 351 Section section NN 42759 23 352 I i NN 42759 23 353 133 133 CD 42759 23 354 SECTION section NN 42759 23 355 II ii CD 42759 23 356 THE the DT 42759 23 357 MORALITY morality NN 42759 23 358 OF of IN 42759 23 359 PRIVATE private JJ 42759 23 360 CAPITAL capital NN 42759 23 361 AND and CC 42759 23 362 INTEREST interest NN 42759 23 363 IX IX NNP 42759 23 364 THE the DT 42759 23 365 NATURE NATURE NNS 42759 23 366 AND and CC 42759 23 367 THE the DT 42759 23 368 RATE rate NN 42759 23 369 OF of IN 42759 23 370 INTEREST interest NN 42759 23 371 137 137 CD 42759 23 372 Meaning Meaning NNP 42759 23 373 of of IN 42759 23 374 Capital Capital NNP 42759 23 375 and and CC 42759 23 376 Capitalist Capitalist NNP 42759 23 377 137 137 CD 42759 23 378 Meaning Meaning NNP 42759 23 379 of of IN 42759 23 380 Interest interest NN 42759 23 381 138 138 CD 42759 23 382 The the DT 42759 23 383 Rate rate NN 42759 23 384 of of IN 42759 23 385 Interest interest NN 42759 23 386 141 141 CD 42759 23 387 X X NNS 42759 23 388 THE the DT 42759 23 389 ALLEGED alleged JJ 42759 23 390 RIGHT right NN 42759 23 391 OF of IN 42759 23 392 LABOUR labour NN 42759 23 393 TO to IN 42759 23 394 THE the DT 42759 23 395 ENTIRE ENTIRE NNP 42759 23 396 PRODUCT product NN 42759 23 397 OF of IN 42759 23 398 INDUSTRY industry NN 42759 23 399 145 145 CD 42759 23 400 The the DT 42759 23 401 Labour Labour NNP 42759 23 402 Theory Theory NNP 42759 23 403 of of IN 42759 23 404 Value Value NNP 42759 23 405 146 146 CD 42759 23 406 The the DT 42759 23 407 Right right NN 42759 23 408 of of IN 42759 23 409 Productivity Productivity NNP 42759 23 410 149 149 CD 42759 23 411 XI XI NNP 42759 23 412 THE the DT 42759 23 413 SOCIALIST socialist JJ 42759 23 414 SCHEME scheme NN 42759 23 415 OF of IN 42759 23 416 INDUSTRY INDUSTRY NNP 42759 23 417 152 152 CD 42759 23 418 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 23 419 Inconsistency Inconsistency NNP 42759 23 420 152 152 CD 42759 23 421 Expropriating expropriate VBG 42759 23 422 the the DT 42759 23 423 Capitalists Capitalists NNPS 42759 23 424 154 154 CD 42759 23 425 Inefficient Inefficient NNP 42759 23 426 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 23 427 Leadership Leadership NNP 42759 23 428 158 158 CD 42759 23 429 Inefficient Inefficient NNP 42759 23 430 Labour Labour NNP 42759 23 431 162 162 CD 42759 23 432 Attempted Attempted NNP 42759 23 433 Replies Replies NNPS 42759 23 434 to to IN 42759 23 435 Objections objection NNS 42759 23 436 162 162 CD 42759 23 437 Restricting restrict VBG 42759 23 438 Individual Individual NNP 42759 23 439 Liberty Liberty NNP 42759 23 440 168 168 CD 42759 23 441 XII XII NNP 42759 23 442 ALLEGED alleged JJ 42759 23 443 INTRINSIC intrinsic NN 42759 23 444 JUSTIFICATIONS justifications NN 42759 23 445 OF of IN 42759 23 446 INTEREST interest NN 42759 23 447 171 171 CD 42759 23 448 Attitude attitude NN 42759 23 449 of of IN 42759 23 450 the the DT 42759 23 451 Church Church NNP 42759 23 452 Toward toward IN 42759 23 453 Interest Interest NNP 42759 23 454 on on IN 42759 23 455 Loans Loans NNP 42759 23 456 172 172 CD 42759 23 457 Interest interest NN 42759 23 458 on on IN 42759 23 459 Productive Productive NNP 42759 23 460 Capital Capital NNP 42759 23 461 175 175 CD 42759 23 462 The the DT 42759 23 463 Claims claim NNS 42759 23 464 of of IN 42759 23 465 Productivity Productivity NNP 42759 23 466 177 177 CD 42759 23 467 The the DT 42759 23 468 Claims Claims NNPS 42759 23 469 of of IN 42759 23 470 Service service NN 42759 23 471 181 181 CD 42759 23 472 The the DT 42759 23 473 Claims claim NNS 42759 23 474 of of IN 42759 23 475 Abstinence abstinence NN 42759 23 476 182 182 CD 42759 23 477 XIII xiii NN 42759 23 478 SOCIAL SOCIAL NNS 42759 23 479 AND and CC 42759 23 480 PRESUMPTIVE presumptive NN 42759 23 481 JUSTIFICATIONS justifications NN 42759 23 482 OF of IN 42759 23 483 INTEREST interest NN 42759 23 484 187 187 CD 42759 23 485 Limitations Limitations NNPS 42759 23 486 of of IN 42759 23 487 the the DT 42759 23 488 Sacrifice Sacrifice NNP 42759 23 489 Principle Principle NNP 42759 23 490 187 187 CD 42759 23 491 The the DT 42759 23 492 Value Value NNP 42759 23 493 of of IN 42759 23 494 Capital capital NN 42759 23 495 in in IN 42759 23 496 a a DT 42759 23 497 No no DT 42759 23 498 - - HYPH 42759 23 499 Interest interest NN 42759 23 500 Régime Régime NNP 42759 23 501 188 188 CD 42759 23 502 Whether whether IN 42759 23 503 the the DT 42759 23 504 Present Present NNP 42759 23 505 Rate Rate NNP 42759 23 506 of of IN 42759 23 507 Interest interest NN 42759 23 508 is be VBZ 42759 23 509 Necessary necessary JJ 42759 23 510 191 191 CD 42759 23 511 Whether whether IN 42759 23 512 at at RB 42759 23 513 Least least RBS 42759 23 514 two two CD 42759 23 515 Per Per NNP 42759 23 516 Cent Cent NNP 42759 23 517 . . . 42759 24 1 is be VBZ 42759 24 2 Necessary necessary JJ 42759 24 3 193 193 CD 42759 24 4 Whether whether IN 42759 24 5 any any DT 42759 24 6 Interest interest NN 42759 24 7 is be VBZ 42759 24 8 Necessary necessary JJ 42759 24 9 196 196 CD 42759 24 10 The the DT 42759 24 11 State State NNP 42759 24 12 is be VBZ 42759 24 13 Justified justified JJ 42759 24 14 in in IN 42759 24 15 Permitting Permitting NNP 42759 24 16 Interest Interest NNP 42759 24 17 199 199 CD 42759 24 18 Civil civil JJ 42759 24 19 Authorisation authorisation NN 42759 24 20 not not RB 42759 24 21 Sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 24 22 for for IN 42759 24 23 Individual Individual NNP 42759 24 24 Justification Justification NNP 42759 24 25 201 201 CD 42759 24 26 How how WRB 42759 24 27 the the DT 42759 24 28 Interest Interest NNP 42759 24 29 - - HYPH 42759 24 30 Taker Taker NNP 42759 24 31 is be VBZ 42759 24 32 Justified Justified NNP 42759 24 33 204 204 CD 42759 24 34 XIV XIV NNP 42759 24 35 CO CO NNP 42759 24 36 - - HYPH 42759 24 37 OPERATION OPERATION NNP 42759 24 38 A a DT 42759 24 39 PARTIAL PARTIAL NNP 42759 24 40 SOLVENT solvent NN 42759 24 41 OF of IN 42759 24 42 CAPITALISM CAPITALISM NNP 42759 24 43 210 210 CD 42759 24 44 Reducing reduce VBG 42759 24 45 the the DT 42759 24 46 Rate rate NN 42759 24 47 of of IN 42759 24 48 Interest interest NN 42759 24 49 211 211 CD 42759 24 50 Need Need NNP 42759 24 51 for for IN 42759 24 52 a a DT 42759 24 53 Wider wide JJR 42759 24 54 Distribution distribution NN 42759 24 55 of of IN 42759 24 56 Capital capital NN 42759 24 57 213 213 CD 42759 24 58 The the DT 42759 24 59 Essence Essence NNP 42759 24 60 of of IN 42759 24 61 Co co NN 42759 24 62 - - NN 42759 24 63 operative operative JJ 42759 24 64 Enterprise enterprise NN 42759 24 65 214 214 CD 42759 24 66 Co co NN 42759 24 67 - - NN 42759 24 68 operative operative JJ 42759 24 69 Credit Credit NNP 42759 24 70 Societies Societies NNPS 42759 24 71 216 216 CD 42759 24 72 Co co NN 42759 24 73 - - NN 42759 24 74 operative operative JJ 42759 24 75 Agricultural Agricultural NNP 42759 24 76 Societies Societies NNPS 42759 24 77 217 217 CD 42759 24 78 Co co NN 42759 24 79 - - NN 42759 24 80 operative operative JJ 42759 24 81 Mercantile Mercantile NNP 42759 24 82 Societies Societies NNP 42759 24 83 220 220 CD 42759 24 84 Co co NN 42759 24 85 - - NN 42759 24 86 operation operation NN 42759 24 87 in in IN 42759 24 88 Production production NN 42759 24 89 222 222 CD 42759 24 90 Advantages Advantages NNPS 42759 24 91 and and CC 42759 24 92 Prospects Prospects NNPS 42759 24 93 of of IN 42759 24 94 Co co NN 42759 24 95 - - NN 42759 24 96 operation operation NN 42759 24 97 228 228 CD 42759 24 98 References reference NNS 42759 24 99 on on IN 42759 24 100 Section section NN 42759 24 101 II II NNP 42759 24 102 233 233 CD 42759 24 103 SECTION section NN 42759 24 104 III III NNP 42759 24 105 THE the DT 42759 24 106 MORAL moral JJ 42759 24 107 ASPECT ASPECT NNS 42759 24 108 OF of IN 42759 24 109 PROFITS profit NNS 42759 24 110 XV XV NNP 42759 24 111 THE the DT 42759 24 112 NATURE NATURE NNS 42759 24 113 OF of IN 42759 24 114 PROFITS PROFITS NNP 42759 24 115 237 237 CD 42759 24 116 The the DT 42759 24 117 Functions Functions NNPS 42759 24 118 and and CC 42759 24 119 Rewards Rewards NNPS 42759 24 120 of of IN 42759 24 121 the the DT 42759 24 122 Business Business NNP 42759 24 123 Man Man NNP 42759 24 124 237 237 CD 42759 24 125 The the DT 42759 24 126 Amount Amount NNP 42759 24 127 of of IN 42759 24 128 Profits profit NNS 42759 24 129 239 239 CD 42759 24 130 Profits profit NNS 42759 24 131 in in IN 42759 24 132 a a DT 42759 24 133 Joint Joint NNP 42759 24 134 - - HYPH 42759 24 135 Stock Stock NNP 42759 24 136 Company Company NNP 42759 24 137 241 241 CD 42759 24 138 XVI xvi NN 42759 24 139 THE the DT 42759 24 140 PRINCIPAL principal JJ 42759 24 141 CANONS canon NNS 42759 24 142 OF of IN 42759 24 143 DISTRIBUTIVE DISTRIBUTIVE NNP 42759 24 144 JUSTICE JUSTICE VBD 42759 24 145 243 243 CD 42759 24 146 The the DT 42759 24 147 Canon Canon NNP 42759 24 148 of of IN 42759 24 149 Equality equality NN 42759 24 150 243 243 CD 42759 24 151 The the DT 42759 24 152 Canon Canon NNP 42759 24 153 of of IN 42759 24 154 Needs Needs NNP 42759 24 155 244 244 CD 42759 24 156 The the DT 42759 24 157 Canon Canon NNP 42759 24 158 of of IN 42759 24 159 Efforts Efforts NNPS 42759 24 160 and and CC 42759 24 161 Sacrifice Sacrifice NNP 42759 24 162 246 246 CD 42759 24 163 The the DT 42759 24 164 Canon Canon NNP 42759 24 165 of of IN 42759 24 166 Productivity Productivity NNP 42759 24 167 247 247 CD 42759 24 168 The the DT 42759 24 169 Canon Canon NNP 42759 24 170 of of IN 42759 24 171 Scarcity Scarcity NNP 42759 24 172 250 250 CD 42759 24 173 The the DT 42759 24 174 Canon Canon NNP 42759 24 175 of of IN 42759 24 176 Human Human NNP 42759 24 177 Welfare Welfare NNP 42759 24 178 252 252 CD 42759 24 179 XVII XVII NNP 42759 24 180 JUST just RB 42759 24 181 PROFITS profit NNS 42759 24 182 IN in IN 42759 24 183 CONDITIONS conditions NN 42759 24 184 OF of IN 42759 24 185 COMPETITION COMPETITION NNP 42759 24 186 254 254 CD 42759 24 187 The the DT 42759 24 188 Question Question NNP 42759 24 189 of of IN 42759 24 190 Indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 24 191 Large large JJ 42759 24 192 Profits profit NNS 42759 24 193 255 255 CD 42759 24 194 The the DT 42759 24 195 Question Question NNP 42759 24 196 of of IN 42759 24 197 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 24 198 Profits Profits NNPS 42759 24 199 258 258 CD 42759 24 200 The the DT 42759 24 201 Question question NN 42759 24 202 of of IN 42759 24 203 Superfluous Superfluous NNP 42759 24 204 Business Business NNP 42759 24 205 Men Men NNP 42759 24 206 260 260 CD 42759 24 207 XVIII xviii VB 42759 24 208 THE the DT 42759 24 209 MORAL moral JJ 42759 24 210 ASPECT ASPECT NNS 42759 24 211 OF of IN 42759 24 212 MONOPOLY monopoly NN 42759 24 213 262 262 CD 42759 24 214 Surplus surplus JJ 42759 24 215 and and CC 42759 24 216 Excessive Excessive NNP 42759 24 217 Profits profit NNS 42759 24 218 263 263 CD 42759 24 219 The the DT 42759 24 220 Question Question NNP 42759 24 221 of of IN 42759 24 222 Monopolistic Monopolistic NNP 42759 24 223 Efficiency Efficiency NNP 42759 24 224 265 265 CD 42759 24 225 Discriminative Discriminative NNP 42759 24 226 Underselling Underselling NNP 42759 24 227 267 267 CD 42759 24 228 Exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 24 229 - - HYPH 42759 24 230 Sales sale NNS 42759 24 231 Contracts contract NNS 42759 24 232 270 270 CD 42759 24 233 Discriminative Discriminative NNP 42759 24 234 Transportation Transportation NNP 42759 24 235 Arrangements Arrangements NNPS 42759 24 236 272 272 CD 42759 24 237 Natural Natural NNP 42759 24 238 Monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 24 239 273 273 CD 42759 24 240 Methods method NNS 42759 24 241 of of IN 42759 24 242 Preventing Preventing NNP 42759 24 243 Monopolistic Monopolistic NNP 42759 24 244 Injustice Injustice NNP 42759 24 245 275 275 CD 42759 24 246 Legalised Legalised NNP 42759 24 247 Price Price NNP 42759 24 248 Agreements Agreements NNP 42759 24 249 277 277 CD 42759 24 250 XIX xix NN 42759 24 251 THE the DT 42759 24 252 MORAL moral JJ 42759 24 253 ASPECTS aspect NNS 42759 24 254 OF of IN 42759 24 255 STOCKWATERING stockwatering NN 42759 24 256 279 279 CD 42759 24 257 Injurious injurious JJ 42759 24 258 Effects effect NNS 42759 24 259 of of IN 42759 24 260 Stockwatering stockwatere VBG 42759 24 261 281 281 CD 42759 24 262 The the DT 42759 24 263 Moral Moral NNP 42759 24 264 Wrong Wrong NNP 42759 24 265 284 284 CD 42759 24 266 The the DT 42759 24 267 " " `` 42759 24 268 Innocent Innocent NNP 42759 24 269 " " '' 42759 24 270 Investor investor NN 42759 24 271 286 286 CD 42759 24 272 Magnitude Magnitude NNP 42759 24 273 of of IN 42759 24 274 Overcapitalisation Overcapitalisation NNP 42759 24 275 288 288 CD 42759 24 276 XX XX NNP 42759 24 277 THE the DT 42759 24 278 LEGAL legal NN 42759 24 279 LIMITATION limitation NN 42759 24 280 OF of IN 42759 24 281 FORTUNES FORTUNES NNP 42759 24 282 291 291 CD 42759 24 283 The the DT 42759 24 284 Method Method NNP 42759 24 285 of of IN 42759 24 286 Direct Direct NNP 42759 24 287 Limitation Limitation NNP 42759 24 288 292 292 CD 42759 24 289 Limitation Limitation NNP 42759 24 290 Through through IN 42759 24 291 Progressive Progressive NNP 42759 24 292 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 24 293 296 296 CD 42759 24 294 The the DT 42759 24 295 Proper Proper NNP 42759 24 296 Rate rate NN 42759 24 297 of of IN 42759 24 298 Income Income NNP 42759 24 299 and and CC 42759 24 300 Inheritance Inheritance NNP 42759 24 301 Taxes Taxes NNP 42759 24 302 299 299 CD 42759 24 303 Effectiveness effectiveness NN 42759 24 304 of of IN 42759 24 305 Such Such NNP 42759 24 306 Taxation taxation NN 42759 24 307 300 300 CD 42759 24 308 XXI XXI NNP 42759 24 309 THE the DT 42759 24 310 DUTY DUTY NNS 42759 24 311 OF of IN 42759 24 312 DISTRIBUTING distribute VBG 42759 24 313 SUPERFLUOUS SUPERFLUOUS NNP 42759 24 314 WEALTH WEALTH NNP 42759 24 315 303 303 CD 42759 24 316 The the DT 42759 24 317 Question question NN 42759 24 318 of of IN 42759 24 319 Distributing distribute VBG 42759 24 320 Some some DT 42759 24 321 303 303 CD 42759 24 322 The the DT 42759 24 323 Question question NN 42759 24 324 of of IN 42759 24 325 Distributing distribute VBG 42759 24 326 All all DT 42759 24 327 308 308 CD 42759 24 328 Some some DT 42759 24 329 Objections objection NNS 42759 24 330 311 311 CD 42759 24 331 A a DT 42759 24 332 False false JJ 42759 24 333 Conception Conception NNP 42759 24 334 of of IN 42759 24 335 Welfare Welfare NNP 42759 24 336 and and CC 42759 24 337 Superfluous Superfluous NNP 42759 24 338 Goods good NNS 42759 24 339 314 314 CD 42759 24 340 The the DT 42759 24 341 True True NNP 42759 24 342 Conception Conception NNP 42759 24 343 of of IN 42759 24 344 Welfare Welfare NNP 42759 24 345 316 316 CD 42759 24 346 References References NNPS 42759 24 347 on on IN 42759 24 348 Section section NN 42759 24 349 III III NNP 42759 24 350 318 318 CD 42759 24 351 SECTION section NN 42759 24 352 IV IV NNP 42759 24 353 THE the DT 42759 24 354 MORAL moral JJ 42759 24 355 ASPECTS aspect NNS 42759 24 356 OF of IN 42759 24 357 WAGES wages NN 42759 24 358 XXII XXII NNPS 42759 24 359 SOME some NN 42759 24 360 UNACCEPTABLE unacceptable VBP 42759 24 361 THEORIES theory NNS 42759 24 362 OF of IN 42759 24 363 WAGE wage NN 42759 24 364 - - HYPH 42759 24 365 JUSTICE justice NN 42759 24 366 323 323 CD 42759 24 367 I I NNP 42759 24 368 The the DT 42759 24 369 Prevailing Prevailing NNP 42759 24 370 - - HYPH 42759 24 371 Rate Rate NNP 42759 24 372 Theory theory NN 42759 24 373 323 323 VBZ 42759 24 374 Not not RB 42759 24 375 in in IN 42759 24 376 Harmony harmony NN 42759 24 377 with with IN 42759 24 378 Justice Justice NNP 42759 24 379 325 325 CD 42759 24 380 II II NNP 42759 24 381 Exchange Exchange NNP 42759 24 382 - - HYPH 42759 24 383 Equivalence Equivalence NNP 42759 24 384 Theories theory NNS 42759 24 385 326 326 CD 42759 24 386 The the DT 42759 24 387 Rule Rule NNP 42759 24 388 of of IN 42759 24 389 Equal Equal NNP 42759 24 390 Gains gain NNS 42759 24 391 326 326 CD 42759 24 392 The the DT 42759 24 393 Rule Rule NNP 42759 24 394 of of IN 42759 24 395 Free Free NNP 42759 24 396 Contract Contract NNP 42759 24 397 328 328 CD 42759 24 398 The the DT 42759 24 399 Rule Rule NNP 42759 24 400 of of IN 42759 24 401 Market market NN 42759 24 402 Value value NN 42759 24 403 330 330 CD 42759 24 404 The the DT 42759 24 405 Mediæval Mediæval NNP 42759 24 406 Theory theory NN 42759 24 407 332 332 CD 42759 24 408 A a DT 42759 24 409 Modern modern JJ 42759 24 410 Variation variation NN 42759 24 411 of of IN 42759 24 412 the the DT 42759 24 413 Mediæval Mediæval NNP 42759 24 414 Theory Theory NNP 42759 24 415 337 337 CD 42759 24 416 III iii CD 42759 24 417 Productivity Productivity NNP 42759 24 418 Theories Theories NNP 42759 24 419 340 340 NNP 42759 24 420 Labour Labour NNP 42759 24 421 's 's POS 42759 24 422 Right right NN 42759 24 423 to to IN 42759 24 424 the the DT 42759 24 425 Whole Whole NNP 42759 24 426 Product Product NNP 42759 24 427 341 341 CD 42759 24 428 Clark Clark NNP 42759 24 429 's 's POS 42759 24 430 Theory Theory NNP 42759 24 431 of of IN 42759 24 432 Specific Specific NNP 42759 24 433 Productivity Productivity NNP 42759 24 434 347 347 CD 42759 24 435 Carver Carver NNP 42759 24 436 's 's POS 42759 24 437 Modified Modified NNP 42759 24 438 Version Version NNP 42759 24 439 of of IN 42759 24 440 Productivity Productivity NNP 42759 24 441 351 351 CD 42759 24 442 XXIII xxiii NN 42759 24 443 THE the DT 42759 24 444 MINIMUM MINIMUM NNP 42759 24 445 OF of IN 42759 24 446 JUSTICE JUSTICE NNP 42759 24 447 ; ; : 42759 24 448 A a DT 42759 24 449 LIVING living NN 42759 24 450 WAGE wage NN 42759 24 451 356 356 CD 42759 24 452 The the DT 42759 24 453 Principle Principle NNP 42759 24 454 of of IN 42759 24 455 Needs Needs NNP 42759 24 456 356 356 CD 42759 24 457 Three three CD 42759 24 458 Fundamental Fundamental NNP 42759 24 459 Principles Principles NNPS 42759 24 460 358 358 CD 42759 24 461 The the DT 42759 24 462 Right right NN 42759 24 463 to to IN 42759 24 464 a a DT 42759 24 465 Decent Decent NNP 42759 24 466 Livelihood Livelihood NNP 42759 24 467 360 360 CD 42759 24 468 The the DT 42759 24 469 Claim claim NN 42759 24 470 to to IN 42759 24 471 a a DT 42759 24 472 Decent Decent NNP 42759 24 473 Livelihood Livelihood NNP 42759 24 474 from from IN 42759 24 475 a a DT 42759 24 476 Present Present NNP 42759 24 477 Occupation Occupation NNP 42759 24 478 362 362 CD 42759 24 479 The the DT 42759 24 480 Labourer Labourer NNP 42759 24 481 's 's POS 42759 24 482 Right right NN 42759 24 483 to to IN 42759 24 484 a a DT 42759 24 485 Living live VBG 42759 24 486 Wage wage NN 42759 24 487 363 363 CD 42759 24 488 When when WRB 42759 24 489 the the DT 42759 24 490 Employer Employer NNP 42759 24 491 is be VBZ 42759 24 492 Unable unable JJ 42759 24 493 to to TO 42759 24 494 Pay pay VB 42759 24 495 a a DT 42759 24 496 Living live VBG 42759 24 497 Wage wage NN 42759 24 498 366 366 CD 42759 24 499 An an DT 42759 24 500 Objection objection NN 42759 24 501 and and CC 42759 24 502 Some some DT 42759 24 503 Difficulties difficulty NNS 42759 24 504 370 370 CD 42759 24 505 The the DT 42759 24 506 Family Family NNP 42759 24 507 Living live VBG 42759 24 508 Wage wage NN 42759 24 509 373 373 CD 42759 24 510 Other other JJ 42759 24 511 Arguments argument NNS 42759 24 512 in in IN 42759 24 513 Favour favour NN 42759 24 514 of of IN 42759 24 515 a a DT 42759 24 516 Living live VBG 42759 24 517 Wage wage NN 42759 24 518 376 376 CD 42759 24 519 The the DT 42759 24 520 Money money NN 42759 24 521 Measure measure NN 42759 24 522 of of IN 42759 24 523 a a DT 42759 24 524 Living live VBG 42759 24 525 Wage wage NN 42759 24 526 378 378 CD 42759 24 527 XXIV xxiv NN 42759 24 528 THE the DT 42759 24 529 PROBLEM problem NN 42759 24 530 OF of IN 42759 24 531 COMPLETE COMPLETE NNP 42759 24 532 WAGE wage NN 42759 24 533 JUSTICE justice NN 42759 24 534 381 381 CD 42759 24 535 Comparative comparative JJ 42759 24 536 Claims Claims NNPS 42759 24 537 of of IN 42759 24 538 Different Different NNP 42759 24 539 Labour Labour NNP 42759 24 540 Groups Groups NNPS 42759 24 541 381 381 CD 42759 24 542 Wages wage NNS 42759 24 543 Versus Versus NNP 42759 24 544 Profits Profits NNP 42759 24 545 388 388 CD 42759 24 546 Wages wage NNS 42759 24 547 Versus Versus NNP 42759 24 548 Interest interest NN 42759 24 549 390 390 CD 42759 24 550 Wages wage NNS 42759 24 551 Versus Versus NNP 42759 24 552 Prices price NNS 42759 24 553 393 393 CD 42759 24 554 Concluding conclude VBG 42759 24 555 Remarks remark NNS 42759 24 556 398 398 CD 42759 24 557 XXV xxv NN 42759 24 558 METHODS methods JJ 42759 24 559 OF of IN 42759 24 560 INCREASING increase VBG 42759 24 561 WAGES wages NN 42759 24 562 400 400 CD 42759 24 563 The the DT 42759 24 564 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 24 565 Wage Wage NNP 42759 24 566 in in IN 42759 24 567 Operation operation NN 42759 24 568 400 400 CD 42759 24 569 The the DT 42759 24 570 Question Question NNP 42759 24 571 of of IN 42759 24 572 Constitutionality constitutionality NN 42759 24 573 405 405 CD 42759 24 574 The the DT 42759 24 575 Ethical ethical JJ 42759 24 576 and and CC 42759 24 577 Political Political NNP 42759 24 578 Aspects Aspects NNPS 42759 24 579 407 407 CD 42759 24 580 The the DT 42759 24 581 Economic Economic NNP 42759 24 582 Aspect Aspect NNP 42759 24 583 408 408 CD 42759 24 584 Opinions Opinions NNPS 42759 24 585 of of IN 42759 24 586 Economists Economists NNPS 42759 24 587 412 412 CD 42759 24 588 Other other JJ 42759 24 589 Legislative legislative JJ 42759 24 590 Proposals proposal NNS 42759 24 591 416 416 CD 42759 24 592 Labour Labour NNP 42759 24 593 Unions Unions NNPS 42759 24 594 417 417 CD 42759 24 595 Organisation Organisation NNP 42759 24 596 Versus Versus NNP 42759 24 597 Legislation Legislation NNP 42759 24 598 420 420 CD 42759 24 599 Participation Participation NNP 42759 24 600 in in IN 42759 24 601 Capital Capital NNP 42759 24 602 Ownership ownership NN 42759 24 603 423 423 CD 42759 24 604 References References NNPS 42759 24 605 on on IN 42759 24 606 Section Section NNP 42759 24 607 IV IV NNP 42759 24 608 425 425 CD 42759 24 609 XXVI xxvi NN 42759 24 610 SUMMARY summary NN 42759 24 611 AND and CC 42759 24 612 CONCLUSION conclusion NN 42759 24 613 426 426 CD 42759 24 614 The the DT 42759 24 615 Landowner Landowner NNP 42759 24 616 and and CC 42759 24 617 Rent Rent NNP 42759 24 618 426 426 CD 42759 24 619 The the DT 42759 24 620 Capitalist Capitalist NNP 42759 24 621 and and CC 42759 24 622 Interest Interest NNP 42759 24 623 427 427 CD 42759 24 624 The the DT 42759 24 625 Business Business NNP 42759 24 626 Man Man NNP 42759 24 627 and and CC 42759 24 628 Profits profit VBZ 42759 24 629 428 428 CD 42759 24 630 The the DT 42759 24 631 Labourer Labourer NNP 42759 24 632 and and CC 42759 24 633 Wages Wages NNP 42759 24 634 430 430 CD 42759 24 635 Concluding Concluding NNP 42759 24 636 Observations observation NNS 42759 24 637 431 431 CD 42759 24 638 INDEX INDEX VBD 42759 24 639 453 453 CD 42759 24 640 INTRODUCTORY INTRODUCTORY NNP 42759 24 641 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 24 642 THE the DT 42759 24 643 ELEMENTS element NNS 42759 24 644 AND and CC 42759 24 645 SCOPE scope NN 42759 24 646 OF of IN 42759 24 647 THE the DT 42759 24 648 PROBLEM PROBLEM NNP 42759 24 649 Distributive distributive JJ 42759 24 650 justice justice NN 42759 24 651 is be VBZ 42759 24 652 primarily primarily RB 42759 24 653 a a DT 42759 24 654 problem problem NN 42759 24 655 of of IN 42759 24 656 incomes income NNS 42759 24 657 rather rather RB 42759 24 658 than than IN 42759 24 659 of of IN 42759 24 660 possessions possession NNS 42759 24 661 . . . 42759 25 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 25 2 is be VBZ 42759 25 3 not not RB 42759 25 4 immediately immediately RB 42759 25 5 concerned concerned JJ 42759 25 6 with with IN 42759 25 7 John John NNP 42759 25 8 Brown Brown NNP 42759 25 9 's 's POS 42759 25 10 railway railway NN 42759 25 11 stock stock NN 42759 25 12 , , , 42759 25 13 John John NNP 42759 25 14 White White NNP 42759 25 15 's 's POS 42759 25 16 house house NN 42759 25 17 , , , 42759 25 18 or or CC 42759 25 19 John John NNP 42759 25 20 Smith Smith NNP 42759 25 21 's 's POS 42759 25 22 automobile automobile NN 42759 25 23 . . . 42759 26 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 26 2 deals deal VBZ 42759 26 3 with with IN 42759 26 4 the the DT 42759 26 5 morality morality NN 42759 26 6 of of IN 42759 26 7 such such JJ 42759 26 8 possessions possession NNS 42759 26 9 only only RB 42759 26 10 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 26 11 and and CC 42759 26 12 under under IN 42759 26 13 one one CD 42759 26 14 aspect aspect NN 42759 26 15 ; ; : 42759 26 16 that that RB 42759 26 17 is is RB 42759 26 18 , , , 42759 26 19 in in IN 42759 26 20 so so RB 42759 26 21 far far RB 42759 26 22 as as IN 42759 26 23 they -PRON- PRP 42759 26 24 have have VBP 42759 26 25 been be VBN 42759 26 26 acquired acquire VBN 42759 26 27 through through IN 42759 26 28 income income NN 42759 26 29 . . . 42759 27 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 27 2 , , , 42759 27 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 27 4 deals deal VBZ 42759 27 5 only only RB 42759 27 6 with with IN 42759 27 7 those those DT 42759 27 8 incomes income NNS 42759 27 9 that that WDT 42759 27 10 are be VBP 42759 27 11 derived derive VBN 42759 27 12 from from IN 42759 27 13 participation participation NN 42759 27 14 in in IN 42759 27 15 the the DT 42759 27 16 process process NN 42759 27 17 of of IN 42759 27 18 production production NN 42759 27 19 . . . 42759 28 1 For for IN 42759 28 2 example example NN 42759 28 3 ; ; : 42759 28 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 28 5 considers consider VBZ 42759 28 6 the the DT 42759 28 7 labourer labourer NN 42759 28 8 's 's POS 42759 28 9 wages wage NNS 42759 28 10 , , , 42759 28 11 but but CC 42759 28 12 not not RB 42759 28 13 the the DT 42759 28 14 subsidies subsidy NNS 42759 28 15 that that WDT 42759 28 16 he -PRON- PRP 42759 28 17 may may MD 42759 28 18 receive receive VB 42759 28 19 through through IN 42759 28 20 charity charity NN 42759 28 21 or or CC 42759 28 22 friendship friendship NN 42759 28 23 . . . 42759 29 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 29 2 province province NN 42759 29 3 is be VBZ 42759 29 4 not not RB 42759 29 5 the the DT 42759 29 6 distribution distribution NN 42759 29 7 of of IN 42759 29 8 all all PDT 42759 29 9 the the DT 42759 29 10 goods good NNS 42759 29 11 of of IN 42759 29 12 the the DT 42759 29 13 country country NN 42759 29 14 among among IN 42759 29 15 all all PDT 42759 29 16 the the DT 42759 29 17 people people NNS 42759 29 18 of of IN 42759 29 19 the the DT 42759 29 20 country country NN 42759 29 21 , , , 42759 29 22 but but CC 42759 29 23 only only RB 42759 29 24 the the DT 42759 29 25 distribution distribution NN 42759 29 26 of of IN 42759 29 27 the the DT 42759 29 28 products product NNS 42759 29 29 of of IN 42759 29 30 industry industry NN 42759 29 31 among among IN 42759 29 32 the the DT 42759 29 33 classes class NNS 42759 29 34 that that WDT 42759 29 35 have have VBP 42759 29 36 taken take VBN 42759 29 37 part part NN 42759 29 38 in in IN 42759 29 39 the the DT 42759 29 40 making making NN 42759 29 41 of of IN 42759 29 42 these these DT 42759 29 43 products product NNS 42759 29 44 . . . 42759 30 1 These these DT 42759 30 2 classes class NNS 42759 30 3 are be VBP 42759 30 4 four four CD 42759 30 5 , , , 42759 30 6 designated designate VBN 42759 30 7 as as IN 42759 30 8 landowners landowner NNS 42759 30 9 , , , 42759 30 10 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 30 11 , , , 42759 30 12 undertakers undertaker NNS 42759 30 13 or or CC 42759 30 14 business business NN 42759 30 15 men man NNS 42759 30 16 , , , 42759 30 17 and and CC 42759 30 18 labourers labourer NNS 42759 30 19 or or CC 42759 30 20 wage wage NN 42759 30 21 earners earner NNS 42759 30 22 . . . 42759 31 1 The the DT 42759 31 2 individual individual JJ 42759 31 3 member member NN 42759 31 4 of of IN 42759 31 5 each each DT 42759 31 6 class class NN 42759 31 7 is be VBZ 42759 31 8 an an DT 42759 31 9 _ _ NNP 42759 31 10 agent agent NN 42759 31 11 _ _ NNP 42759 31 12 of of IN 42759 31 13 production production NN 42759 31 14 , , , 42759 31 15 while while IN 42759 31 16 the the DT 42759 31 17 instrument instrument NN 42759 31 18 or or CC 42759 31 19 energy energy NN 42759 31 20 that that WDT 42759 31 21 he -PRON- PRP 42759 31 22 owns own VBZ 42759 31 23 and and CC 42759 31 24 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 31 25 is be VBZ 42759 31 26 a a DT 42759 31 27 _ _ NNP 42759 31 28 factor factor NN 42759 31 29 _ _ NNP 42759 31 30 of of IN 42759 31 31 production production NN 42759 31 32 . . . 42759 32 1 Thus thus RB 42759 32 2 , , , 42759 32 3 the the DT 42759 32 4 landowner landowner NN 42759 32 5 is be VBZ 42759 32 6 an an DT 42759 32 7 agent agent NN 42759 32 8 of of IN 42759 32 9 production production NN 42759 32 10 because because IN 42759 32 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 32 12 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 32 13 to to IN 42759 32 14 the the DT 42759 32 15 productive productive JJ 42759 32 16 process process NN 42759 32 17 the the DT 42759 32 18 factor factor NN 42759 32 19 known know VBN 42759 32 20 as as IN 42759 32 21 land land NN 42759 32 22 , , , 42759 32 23 and and CC 42759 32 24 the the DT 42759 32 25 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 32 26 is be VBZ 42759 32 27 an an DT 42759 32 28 agent agent NN 42759 32 29 of of IN 42759 32 30 production production NN 42759 32 31 because because IN 42759 32 32 he -PRON- PRP 42759 32 33 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 32 34 the the DT 42759 32 35 factor factor NN 42759 32 36 known know VBN 42759 32 37 as as IN 42759 32 38 capital capital NN 42759 32 39 ; ; : 42759 32 40 while while IN 42759 32 41 the the DT 42759 32 42 business business NN 42759 32 43 man man NN 42759 32 44 and and CC 42759 32 45 the the DT 42759 32 46 labourer labourer NN 42759 32 47 are be VBP 42759 32 48 agents agent NNS 42759 32 49 not not RB 42759 32 50 only only RB 42759 32 51 in in IN 42759 32 52 the the DT 42759 32 53 sense sense NN 42759 32 54 that that IN 42759 32 55 they -PRON- PRP 42759 32 56 contribute contribute VBP 42759 32 57 factors factor NNS 42759 32 58 to to IN 42759 32 59 the the DT 42759 32 60 process process NN 42759 32 61 , , , 42759 32 62 but but CC 42759 32 63 in in IN 42759 32 64 the the DT 42759 32 65 very very RB 42759 32 66 special special JJ 42759 32 67 sense sense NN 42759 32 68 that that IN 42759 32 69 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 32 70 contributions contribution NNS 42759 32 71 involve involve VBP 42759 32 72 the the DT 42759 32 73 continuous continuous JJ 42759 32 74 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 32 75 of of IN 42759 32 76 human human JJ 42759 32 77 energy energy NN 42759 32 78 . . . 42759 33 1 Now now RB 42759 33 2 the the DT 42759 33 3 product product NN 42759 33 4 of of IN 42759 33 5 industry industry NN 42759 33 6 is be VBZ 42759 33 7 distributed distribute VBN 42759 33 8 among among IN 42759 33 9 these these DT 42759 33 10 four four CD 42759 33 11 classes class NNS 42759 33 12 precisely precisely RB 42759 33 13 because because IN 42759 33 14 they -PRON- PRP 42759 33 15 are be VBP 42759 33 16 agents agent NNS 42759 33 17 of of IN 42759 33 18 production production NN 42759 33 19 ; ; : 42759 33 20 that that DT 42759 33 21 is be VBZ 42759 33 22 because because IN 42759 33 23 they -PRON- PRP 42759 33 24 own own VBP 42759 33 25 and and CC 42759 33 26 put put VBD 42759 33 27 at at IN 42759 33 28 the the DT 42759 33 29 disposal disposal NN 42759 33 30 of of IN 42759 33 31 industry industry NN 42759 33 32 the the DT 42759 33 33 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 33 34 factors factor NNS 42759 33 35 of of IN 42759 33 36 production production NN 42759 33 37 . . . 42759 34 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 34 2 say say VBP 42759 34 3 that that IN 42759 34 4 the the DT 42759 34 5 agents agent NNS 42759 34 6 of of IN 42759 34 7 production production NN 42759 34 8 " " `` 42759 34 9 put put VBD 42759 34 10 the the DT 42759 34 11 factors factor NNS 42759 34 12 of of IN 42759 34 13 production production NN 42759 34 14 at at IN 42759 34 15 the the DT 42759 34 16 disposal disposal NN 42759 34 17 of of IN 42759 34 18 industry industry NN 42759 34 19 , , , 42759 34 20 " " '' 42759 34 21 rather rather RB 42759 34 22 than than IN 42759 34 23 " " `` 42759 34 24 exercise exercise VB 42759 34 25 or or CC 42759 34 26 operate operate VBP 42759 34 27 the the DT 42759 34 28 factors factor NNS 42759 34 29 , , , 42759 34 30 " " '' 42759 34 31 because because IN 42759 34 32 neither neither CC 42759 34 33 the the DT 42759 34 34 landowner landowner NN 42759 34 35 nor nor CC 42759 34 36 the the DT 42759 34 37 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 34 38 , , , 42759 34 39 as as IN 42759 34 40 such such JJ 42759 34 41 , , , 42759 34 42 expend expend JJ 42759 34 43 continuous continuous JJ 42759 34 44 energy energy NN 42759 34 45 in in IN 42759 34 46 the the DT 42759 34 47 productive productive JJ 42759 34 48 process process NN 42759 34 49 . . . 42759 35 1 All all DT 42759 35 2 that that WDT 42759 35 3 is be VBZ 42759 35 4 necessary necessary JJ 42759 35 5 to to TO 42759 35 6 enforce enforce VB 42759 35 7 a a DT 42759 35 8 claim claim NN 42759 35 9 upon upon IN 42759 35 10 the the DT 42759 35 11 product product NN 42759 35 12 is be VBZ 42759 35 13 to to TO 42759 35 14 contribute contribute VB 42759 35 15 an an DT 42759 35 16 instrument instrument NN 42759 35 17 or or CC 42759 35 18 factor factor NN 42759 35 19 without without IN 42759 35 20 which which WDT 42759 35 21 production production NN 42759 35 22 can can MD 42759 35 23 not not RB 42759 35 24 be be VB 42759 35 25 carried carry VBN 42759 35 26 on on IN 42759 35 27 . . . 42759 36 1 The the DT 42759 36 2 product product NN 42759 36 3 distributed distribute VBN 42759 36 4 in in IN 42759 36 5 any any DT 42759 36 6 country country NN 42759 36 7 during during IN 42759 36 8 a a DT 42759 36 9 single single JJ 42759 36 10 year year NN 42759 36 11 is be VBZ 42759 36 12 variously variously RB 42759 36 13 described describe VBN 42759 36 14 by by IN 42759 36 15 economists economist NNS 42759 36 16 as as IN 42759 36 17 the the DT 42759 36 18 national national JJ 42759 36 19 product product NN 42759 36 20 , , , 42759 36 21 the the DT 42759 36 22 national national JJ 42759 36 23 income income NN 42759 36 24 , , , 42759 36 25 the the DT 42759 36 26 national national JJ 42759 36 27 dividend dividend NN 42759 36 28 . . . 42759 37 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 37 2 consists consist VBZ 42759 37 3 not not RB 42759 37 4 merely merely RB 42759 37 5 of of IN 42759 37 6 material material JJ 42759 37 7 goods good NNS 42759 37 8 , , , 42759 37 9 such such JJ 42759 37 10 as as IN 42759 37 11 houses house NNS 42759 37 12 , , , 42759 37 13 food food NN 42759 37 14 , , , 42759 37 15 clothing clothing NN 42759 37 16 , , , 42759 37 17 and and CC 42759 37 18 automobiles automobile NNS 42759 37 19 , , , 42759 37 20 but but CC 42759 37 21 also also RB 42759 37 22 of of IN 42759 37 23 those those DT 42759 37 24 non non JJ 42759 37 25 - - JJ 42759 37 26 material material JJ 42759 37 27 goods good NNS 42759 37 28 known know VBN 42759 37 29 as as IN 42759 37 30 services service NNS 42759 37 31 . . . 42759 38 1 Such such JJ 42759 38 2 are be VBP 42759 38 3 the the DT 42759 38 4 tasks task NNS 42759 38 5 performed perform VBN 42759 38 6 by by IN 42759 38 7 the the DT 42759 38 8 domestic domestic JJ 42759 38 9 servant servant NN 42759 38 10 , , , 42759 38 11 the the DT 42759 38 12 barber barber NN 42759 38 13 , , , 42759 38 14 the the DT 42759 38 15 chauffeur chauffeur NN 42759 38 16 , , , 42759 38 17 the the DT 42759 38 18 public public JJ 42759 38 19 official official NN 42759 38 20 , , , 42759 38 21 the the DT 42759 38 22 physician physician NN 42759 38 23 , , , 42759 38 24 the the DT 42759 38 25 teacher teacher NN 42759 38 26 ; ; : 42759 38 27 or or CC 42759 38 28 any any DT 42759 38 29 other other JJ 42759 38 30 personal personal JJ 42759 38 31 service service NN 42759 38 32 " " '' 42759 38 33 that that WDT 42759 38 34 is be VBZ 42759 38 35 valued value VBN 42759 38 36 , , , 42759 38 37 as as IN 42759 38 38 material material NN 42759 38 39 commodities commodity NNS 42759 38 40 are be VBP 42759 38 41 valued value VBN 42759 38 42 , , , 42759 38 43 according accord VBG 42759 38 44 to to IN 42759 38 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 38 46 selling sell VBG 42759 38 47 prices price NNS 42759 38 48 . . . 42759 38 49 " " '' 42759 39 1 Even even RB 42759 39 2 the the DT 42759 39 3 services service NNS 42759 39 4 of of IN 42759 39 5 the the DT 42759 39 6 clergyman clergyman NN 42759 39 7 are be VBP 42759 39 8 included include VBN 42759 39 9 in in IN 42759 39 10 the the DT 42759 39 11 national national JJ 42759 39 12 income income NN 42759 39 13 or or CC 42759 39 14 product product NN 42759 39 15 , , , 42759 39 16 since since IN 42759 39 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 39 18 are be VBP 42759 39 19 paid pay VBN 42759 39 20 for for IN 42759 39 21 and and CC 42759 39 22 form form VB 42759 39 23 a a DT 42759 39 24 part part NN 42759 39 25 of of IN 42759 39 26 the the DT 42759 39 27 annual annual JJ 42759 39 28 supply supply NN 42759 39 29 of of IN 42759 39 30 good good JJ 42759 39 31 things thing NNS 42759 39 32 produced produce VBN 42759 39 33 and and CC 42759 39 34 distributed distribute VBN 42759 39 35 within within IN 42759 39 36 the the DT 42759 39 37 country country NN 42759 39 38 . . . 42759 40 1 In in IN 42759 40 2 the the DT 42759 40 3 language language NN 42759 40 4 of of IN 42759 40 5 the the DT 42759 40 6 economist economist NN 42759 40 7 , , , 42759 40 8 anything anything NN 42759 40 9 that that WDT 42759 40 10 satisfies satisfy VBZ 42759 40 11 a a DT 42759 40 12 human human JJ 42759 40 13 want want NN 42759 40 14 is be VBZ 42759 40 15 a a DT 42759 40 16 utility utility NN 42759 40 17 , , , 42759 40 18 and and CC 42759 40 19 forms form VBZ 42759 40 20 part part NN 42759 40 21 of of IN 42759 40 22 the the DT 42759 40 23 national national JJ 42759 40 24 wealth wealth NN 42759 40 25 ; ; : 42759 40 26 hence hence RB 42759 40 27 there there EX 42759 40 28 can can MD 42759 40 29 be be VB 42759 40 30 no no DT 42759 40 31 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 40 32 reason reason NN 42759 40 33 for for IN 42759 40 34 excluding exclude VBG 42759 40 35 from from IN 42759 40 36 the the DT 42759 40 37 national national JJ 42759 40 38 income income NN 42759 40 39 goods good NNS 42759 40 40 which which WDT 42759 40 41 minister minister NN 42759 40 42 to to IN 42759 40 43 spiritual spiritual JJ 42759 40 44 or or CC 42759 40 45 intellectual intellectual JJ 42759 40 46 wants want VBZ 42759 40 47 . . . 42759 41 1 The the DT 42759 41 2 services service NNS 42759 41 3 of of IN 42759 41 4 the the DT 42759 41 5 clergyman clergyman NN 42759 41 6 , , , 42759 41 7 the the DT 42759 41 8 actor actor NN 42759 41 9 , , , 42759 41 10 the the DT 42759 41 11 author author NN 42759 41 12 , , , 42759 41 13 the the DT 42759 41 14 painter painter NN 42759 41 15 , , , 42759 41 16 and and CC 42759 41 17 the the DT 42759 41 18 physician physician NN 42759 41 19 are be VBP 42759 41 20 quite quite RB 42759 41 21 as as RB 42759 41 22 much much JJ 42759 41 23 a a DT 42759 41 24 part part NN 42759 41 25 of of IN 42759 41 26 the the DT 42759 41 27 utilities utility NNS 42759 41 28 of of IN 42759 41 29 life life NN 42759 41 30 as as IN 42759 41 31 the the DT 42759 41 32 services service NNS 42759 41 33 of of IN 42759 41 34 the the DT 42759 41 35 cook cook NN 42759 41 36 , , , 42759 41 37 the the DT 42759 41 38 chambermaid chambermaid NN 42759 41 39 , , , 42759 41 40 or or CC 42759 41 41 the the DT 42759 41 42 barber barber NN 42759 41 43 ; ; : 42759 41 44 and and CC 42759 41 45 all all DT 42759 41 46 are be VBP 42759 41 47 as as RB 42759 41 48 clearly clearly RB 42759 41 49 utilities utility NNS 42759 41 50 as as IN 42759 41 51 bread bread NN 42759 41 52 , , , 42759 41 53 hats hat NNS 42759 41 54 , , , 42759 41 55 houses house NNS 42759 41 56 , , , 42759 41 57 or or CC 42759 41 58 any any DT 42759 41 59 other other JJ 42759 41 60 material material NN 42759 41 61 thing thing NN 42759 41 62 . . . 42759 42 1 In in IN 42759 42 2 a a DT 42759 42 3 general general JJ 42759 42 4 way way NN 42759 42 5 , , , 42759 42 6 therefore therefore RB 42759 42 7 , , , 42759 42 8 we -PRON- PRP 42759 42 9 say say VBP 42759 42 10 that that IN 42759 42 11 the the DT 42759 42 12 national national JJ 42759 42 13 product product NN 42759 42 14 which which WDT 42759 42 15 is be VBZ 42759 42 16 available available JJ 42759 42 17 for for IN 42759 42 18 distribution distribution NN 42759 42 19 among among IN 42759 42 20 the the DT 42759 42 21 different different JJ 42759 42 22 productive productive JJ 42759 42 23 classes class NNS 42759 42 24 comprises comprise VBZ 42759 42 25 all all PDT 42759 42 26 the the DT 42759 42 27 utilities utility NNS 42759 42 28 , , , 42759 42 29 material material NN 42759 42 30 and and CC 42759 42 31 non non JJ 42759 42 32 - - JJ 42759 42 33 material material JJ 42759 42 34 , , , 42759 42 35 that that WDT 42759 42 36 are be VBP 42759 42 37 produced produce VBN 42759 42 38 through through IN 42759 42 39 human human JJ 42759 42 40 agents agent NNS 42759 42 41 and and CC 42759 42 42 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 42 43 human human JJ 42759 42 44 desires desire NNS 42759 42 45 . . . 42759 43 1 In in IN 42759 43 2 the the DT 42759 43 3 great great JJ 42759 43 4 majority majority NN 42759 43 5 of of IN 42759 43 6 instances instance NNS 42759 43 7 the the DT 42759 43 8 product product NN 42759 43 9 is be VBZ 42759 43 10 not not RB 42759 43 11 distributed distribute VBN 42759 43 12 in in IN 42759 43 13 kind kind NN 42759 43 14 . . . 42759 44 1 The the DT 42759 44 2 wheat wheat NN 42759 44 3 produced produce VBD 42759 44 4 on on IN 42759 44 5 a a DT 42759 44 6 given give VBN 42759 44 7 farm farm NN 42759 44 8 is be VBZ 42759 44 9 not not RB 42759 44 10 directly directly RB 42759 44 11 apportioned apportion VBN 42759 44 12 among among IN 42759 44 13 the the DT 42759 44 14 farmers farmer NNS 42759 44 15 , , , 42759 44 16 labourers labourer NNS 42759 44 17 , , , 42759 44 18 and and CC 42759 44 19 landowners landowner NNS 42759 44 20 that that WDT 42759 44 21 have have VBP 42759 44 22 co co VBN 42759 44 23 - - VBN 42759 44 24 operated operate VBN 42759 44 25 in in IN 42759 44 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 44 27 production production NN 42759 44 28 ; ; : 42759 44 29 nor nor CC 42759 44 30 are be VBP 42759 44 31 the the DT 42759 44 32 shoes shoe NNS 42759 44 33 turned turn VBD 42759 44 34 out out RP 42759 44 35 by by IN 42759 44 36 a a DT 42759 44 37 given give VBN 42759 44 38 factory factory NN 42759 44 39 divided divide VBN 42759 44 40 among among IN 42759 44 41 the the DT 42759 44 42 co co NN 42759 44 43 - - JJ 42759 44 44 operating operating JJ 42759 44 45 labourers labourer NNS 42759 44 46 and and CC 42759 44 47 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 44 48 ; ; : 42759 44 49 and and CC 42759 44 50 it -PRON- PRP 42759 44 51 is be VBZ 42759 44 52 obvious obvious JJ 42759 44 53 that that IN 42759 44 54 personal personal JJ 42759 44 55 services service NNS 42759 44 56 can can MD 42759 44 57 not not RB 42759 44 58 be be VB 42759 44 59 returned return VBN 42759 44 60 to to IN 42759 44 61 the the DT 42759 44 62 persons person NNS 42759 44 63 that that WDT 42759 44 64 have have VBP 42759 44 65 rendered render VBN 42759 44 66 them -PRON- PRP 42759 44 67 . . . 42759 45 1 Cases case NNS 42759 45 2 of of IN 42759 45 3 partial partial JJ 42759 45 4 direct direct JJ 42759 45 5 distribution distribution NN 42759 45 6 do do VB 42759 45 7 , , , 42759 45 8 indeed indeed RB 42759 45 9 , , , 42759 45 10 occur occur VB 42759 45 11 ; ; : 42759 45 12 as as IN 42759 45 13 when when WRB 42759 45 14 the the DT 42759 45 15 tenant tenant NN 42759 45 16 takes take VBZ 42759 45 17 two two CD 42759 45 18 - - HYPH 42759 45 19 thirds third NNS 42759 45 20 and and CC 42759 45 21 the the DT 42759 45 22 landowner landown JJR 42759 45 23 one one CD 42759 45 24 - - HYPH 42759 45 25 third third NN 42759 45 26 of of IN 42759 45 27 the the DT 42759 45 28 crop crop NN 42759 45 29 raised raise VBN 42759 45 30 by by IN 42759 45 31 the the DT 42759 45 32 former former JJ 42759 45 33 on on IN 42759 45 34 land land NN 42759 45 35 belonging belong VBG 42759 45 36 to to IN 42759 45 37 the the DT 42759 45 38 latter latter JJ 42759 45 39 ; ; : 42759 45 40 or or CC 42759 45 41 when when WRB 42759 45 42 the the DT 42759 45 43 miller miller NN 42759 45 44 receives receive VBZ 42759 45 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 45 46 compensation compensation NN 42759 45 47 in in IN 42759 45 48 a a DT 42759 45 49 part part NN 42759 45 50 of of IN 42759 45 51 the the DT 42759 45 52 flour flour NN 42759 45 53 that that WDT 42759 45 54 he -PRON- PRP 42759 45 55 grinds grind VBZ 42759 45 56 . . . 42759 46 1 To to NN 42759 46 2 - - HYPH 42759 46 3 day day NN 42759 46 4 , , , 42759 46 5 however however RB 42759 46 6 , , , 42759 46 7 such such JJ 42759 46 8 instances instance NNS 42759 46 9 are be VBP 42759 46 10 relatively relatively RB 42759 46 11 insignificant insignificant JJ 42759 46 12 . . . 42759 47 1 By by IN 42759 47 2 far far RB 42759 47 3 the the DT 42759 47 4 greater great JJR 42759 47 5 part part NN 42759 47 6 of of IN 42759 47 7 the the DT 42759 47 8 material material JJ 42759 47 9 product product NN 42759 47 10 is be VBZ 42759 47 11 sold sell VBN 42759 47 12 by by IN 42759 47 13 the the DT 42759 47 14 undertaker undertaker NN 42759 47 15 or or CC 42759 47 16 business business NN 42759 47 17 man man NN 42759 47 18 , , , 42759 47 19 and and CC 42759 47 20 the the DT 42759 47 21 price price NN 42759 47 22 is be VBZ 42759 47 23 then then RB 42759 47 24 divided divide VBN 42759 47 25 between between IN 42759 47 26 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 47 27 and and CC 42759 47 28 the the DT 42759 47 29 other other JJ 42759 47 30 agents agent NNS 42759 47 31 of of IN 42759 47 32 production production NN 42759 47 33 . . . 42759 48 1 All all DT 42759 48 2 personal personal JJ 42759 48 3 services service NNS 42759 48 4 are be VBP 42759 48 5 sold sell VBN 42759 48 6 , , , 42759 48 7 and and CC 42759 48 8 the the DT 42759 48 9 price price NN 42759 48 10 is be VBZ 42759 48 11 obtained obtain VBN 42759 48 12 by by IN 42759 48 13 the the DT 42759 48 14 performers performer NNS 42759 48 15 thereof thereof RB 42759 48 16 . . . 42759 49 1 The the DT 42759 49 2 farmer farmer NN 42759 49 3 sells sell VBZ 42759 49 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 49 5 wheat wheat NN 42759 49 6 , , , 42759 49 7 the the DT 42759 49 8 miller miller NN 42759 49 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 49 10 flour flour NN 42759 49 11 , , , 42759 49 12 and and CC 42759 49 13 the the DT 42759 49 14 barber barber NN 42759 49 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 49 16 services service NNS 42759 49 17 . . . 42759 50 1 With with IN 42759 50 2 the the DT 42759 50 3 money money NN 42759 50 4 received receive VBN 42759 50 5 for for IN 42759 50 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 50 7 part part NN 42759 50 8 in in IN 42759 50 9 production production NN 42759 50 10 each each DT 42759 50 11 productive productive JJ 42759 50 12 agent agent NN 42759 50 13 obtains obtain NNS 42759 50 14 possession possession NN 42759 50 15 of of IN 42759 50 16 such such JJ 42759 50 17 kinds kind NNS 42759 50 18 and and CC 42759 50 19 amounts amount NNS 42759 50 20 of of IN 42759 50 21 the the DT 42759 50 22 national national JJ 42759 50 23 product product NN 42759 50 24 as as IN 42759 50 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 50 26 desires desire NNS 42759 50 27 dictate dictate VBP 42759 50 28 and and CC 42759 50 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 50 30 income income NN 42759 50 31 will will MD 42759 50 32 procure procure VB 42759 50 33 . . . 42759 51 1 Hence hence RB 42759 51 2 the the DT 42759 51 3 distribution distribution NN 42759 51 4 of of IN 42759 51 5 the the DT 42759 51 6 product product NN 42759 51 7 is be VBZ 42759 51 8 effected effect VBN 42759 51 9 through through IN 42759 51 10 the the DT 42759 51 11 conversion conversion NN 42759 51 12 of of IN 42759 51 13 producers producer NNS 42759 51 14 ' ' POS 42759 51 15 claims claim NNS 42759 51 16 into into IN 42759 51 17 money money NN 42759 51 18 , , , 42759 51 19 and and CC 42759 51 20 the the DT 42759 51 21 exchange exchange NN 42759 51 22 of of IN 42759 51 23 the the DT 42759 51 24 latter latter JJ 42759 51 25 for for IN 42759 51 26 specific specific JJ 42759 51 27 quantities quantity NNS 42759 51 28 and and CC 42759 51 29 qualities quality NNS 42759 51 30 of of IN 42759 51 31 the the DT 42759 51 32 product product NN 42759 51 33 . . . 42759 52 1 While while IN 42759 52 2 the the DT 42759 52 3 national national JJ 42759 52 4 product product NN 42759 52 5 as as IN 42759 52 6 a a DT 42759 52 7 whole whole NN 42759 52 8 is be VBZ 42759 52 9 divided divide VBN 42759 52 10 among among IN 42759 52 11 the the DT 42759 52 12 four four CD 42759 52 13 productive productive JJ 42759 52 14 classes class NNS 42759 52 15 , , , 42759 52 16 not not RB 42759 52 17 every every DT 42759 52 18 portion portion NN 42759 52 19 of of IN 42759 52 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 52 21 is be VBZ 42759 52 22 distributed distribute VBN 42759 52 23 among among IN 42759 52 24 actually actually RB 42759 52 25 distinct distinct JJ 42759 52 26 representatives representative NNS 42759 52 27 of of IN 42759 52 28 these these DT 42759 52 29 classes class NNS 42759 52 30 . . . 42759 53 1 When when WRB 42759 53 2 more more JJR 42759 53 3 than than IN 42759 53 4 one one CD 42759 53 5 factor factor NN 42759 53 6 of of IN 42759 53 7 production production NN 42759 53 8 is be VBZ 42759 53 9 owned own VBN 42759 53 10 by by IN 42759 53 11 the the DT 42759 53 12 same same JJ 42759 53 13 person person NN 42759 53 14 , , , 42759 53 15 the the DT 42759 53 16 product product NN 42759 53 17 will will MD 42759 53 18 obviously obviously RB 42759 53 19 not not RB 42759 53 20 go go VB 42759 53 21 to to IN 42759 53 22 four four CD 42759 53 23 different different JJ 42759 53 24 classes class NNS 42759 53 25 of of IN 42759 53 26 persons person NNS 42759 53 27 . . . 42759 54 1 For for IN 42759 54 2 example example NN 42759 54 3 ; ; : 42759 54 4 the the DT 42759 54 5 crop crop NN 42759 54 6 raised raise VBN 42759 54 7 by by IN 42759 54 8 a a DT 42759 54 9 man man NN 42759 54 10 on on IN 42759 54 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 54 12 own own JJ 42759 54 13 unmortgaged unmortgaged JJ 42759 54 14 land land NN 42759 54 15 , , , 42759 54 16 with with IN 42759 54 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 54 18 own own JJ 42759 54 19 instruments instrument NNS 42759 54 20 , , , 42759 54 21 and and CC 42759 54 22 without without IN 42759 54 23 any any DT 42759 54 24 hired hire VBN 42759 54 25 assistance assistance NN 42759 54 26 ; ; : 42759 54 27 and and CC 42759 54 28 the the DT 42759 54 29 products product NNS 42759 54 30 of of IN 42759 54 31 the the DT 42759 54 32 small small JJ 42759 54 33 shopkeeper shopkeeper NN 42759 54 34 , , , 42759 54 35 tailor tailor NN 42759 54 36 , , , 42759 54 37 and and CC 42759 54 38 barber barber NN 42759 54 39 who who WP 42759 54 40 are be VBP 42759 54 41 similarly similarly RB 42759 54 42 self self NN 42759 54 43 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 54 44 and and CC 42759 54 45 independent,--are independent,--are VBP 42759 54 46 in in IN 42759 54 47 each each DT 42759 54 48 case case NN 42759 54 49 obtained obtain VBN 42759 54 50 by by IN 42759 54 51 one one CD 42759 54 52 person person NN 42759 54 53 , , , 42759 54 54 and and CC 42759 54 55 do do VBP 42759 54 56 not not RB 42759 54 57 undergo undergo VB 42759 54 58 any any DT 42759 54 59 actual actual JJ 42759 54 60 distribution distribution NN 42759 54 61 . . . 42759 55 1 Even even RB 42759 55 2 in in IN 42759 55 3 these these DT 42759 55 4 instances instance NNS 42759 55 5 , , , 42759 55 6 however however RB 42759 55 7 , , , 42759 55 8 there there EX 42759 55 9 occurs occur VBZ 42759 55 10 what what WP 42759 55 11 may may MD 42759 55 12 be be VB 42759 55 13 called call VBN 42759 55 14 _ _ NNP 42759 55 15 virtual virtual JJ 42759 55 16 _ _ NNP 42759 55 17 distribution distribution NN 42759 55 18 , , , 42759 55 19 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 55 20 as as IN 42759 55 21 the the DT 42759 55 22 single single JJ 42759 55 23 agent agent NN 42759 55 24 owns own VBZ 42759 55 25 more more JJR 42759 55 26 than than IN 42759 55 27 one one CD 42759 55 28 factor factor NN 42759 55 29 , , , 42759 55 30 and and CC 42759 55 31 performs perform VBZ 42759 55 32 more more JJR 42759 55 33 than than IN 42759 55 34 one one CD 42759 55 35 productive productive JJ 42759 55 36 function function NN 42759 55 37 . . . 42759 56 1 And and CC 42759 56 2 the the DT 42759 56 3 problem problem NN 42759 56 4 of of IN 42759 56 5 distributive distributive JJ 42759 56 6 justice justice NN 42759 56 7 in in IN 42759 56 8 such such JJ 42759 56 9 cases case NNS 42759 56 10 is be VBZ 42759 56 11 to to TO 42759 56 12 determine determine VB 42759 56 13 whether whether IN 42759 56 14 all all PDT 42759 56 15 these these DT 42759 56 16 productive productive JJ 42759 56 17 functions function NNS 42759 56 18 are be VBP 42759 56 19 properly properly RB 42759 56 20 rewarded reward VBN 42759 56 21 through through IN 42759 56 22 the the DT 42759 56 23 total total JJ 42759 56 24 amount amount NN 42759 56 25 which which WDT 42759 56 26 the the DT 42759 56 27 individual individual NN 42759 56 28 has have VBZ 42759 56 29 received receive VBN 42759 56 30 . . . 42759 57 1 Where where WRB 42759 57 2 the the DT 42759 57 3 factors factor NNS 42759 57 4 are be VBP 42759 57 5 owned own VBN 42759 57 6 by by IN 42759 57 7 distinct distinct JJ 42759 57 8 persons person NNS 42759 57 9 , , , 42759 57 10 or or CC 42759 57 11 groups group NNS 42759 57 12 of of IN 42759 57 13 persons person NNS 42759 57 14 , , , 42759 57 15 the the DT 42759 57 16 problem problem NN 42759 57 17 is be VBZ 42759 57 18 to to TO 42759 57 19 determine determine VB 42759 57 20 whether whether IN 42759 57 21 each each DT 42759 57 22 group group NN 42759 57 23 is be VBZ 42759 57 24 properly properly RB 42759 57 25 remunerated remunerate VBN 42759 57 26 for for IN 42759 57 27 the the DT 42759 57 28 single single JJ 42759 57 29 function function NN 42759 57 30 that that IN 42759 57 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 57 32 has have VBZ 42759 57 33 performed perform VBN 42759 57 34 . . . 42759 58 1 The the DT 42759 58 2 problem problem NN 42759 58 3 of of IN 42759 58 4 the the DT 42759 58 5 morality morality NN 42759 58 6 of of IN 42759 58 7 industrial industrial JJ 42759 58 8 incomes income NNS 42759 58 9 is be VBZ 42759 58 10 obviously obviously RB 42759 58 11 complex complex JJ 42759 58 12 . . . 42759 59 1 For for IN 42759 59 2 example example NN 42759 59 3 ; ; : 42759 59 4 the the DT 42759 59 5 income income NN 42759 59 6 of of IN 42759 59 7 the the DT 42759 59 8 farmer farmer NN 42759 59 9 is be VBZ 42759 59 10 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 59 11 derived derive VBN 42759 59 12 from from IN 42759 59 13 a a DT 42759 59 14 product product NN 42759 59 15 which which WDT 42759 59 16 he -PRON- PRP 42759 59 17 must must MD 42759 59 18 divide divide VB 42759 59 19 with with IN 42759 59 20 a a DT 42759 59 21 landowner landowner NN 42759 59 22 and and CC 42759 59 23 with with IN 42759 59 24 labourers labourer NNS 42759 59 25 ; ; : 42759 59 26 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 59 27 from from IN 42759 59 28 a a DT 42759 59 29 product product NN 42759 59 30 which which WDT 42759 59 31 he -PRON- PRP 42759 59 32 shares share VBZ 42759 59 33 with with IN 42759 59 34 labourers labourer NNS 42759 59 35 only only RB 42759 59 36 ; ; : 42759 59 37 and and CC 42759 59 38 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 59 39 from from IN 42759 59 40 a a DT 42759 59 41 product product NN 42759 59 42 which which WDT 42759 59 43 he -PRON- PRP 42759 59 44 can can MD 42759 59 45 retain retain VB 42759 59 46 wholly wholly RB 42759 59 47 for for IN 42759 59 48 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 59 49 . . . 42759 60 1 The the DT 42759 60 2 labourer labourer NN 42759 60 3 's 's POS 42759 60 4 income income NN 42759 60 5 arises arise VBZ 42759 60 6 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 60 7 out out IN 42759 60 8 of of IN 42759 60 9 a a DT 42759 60 10 product product NN 42759 60 11 which which WDT 42759 60 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 60 13 divides divide VBZ 42759 60 14 with with IN 42759 60 15 other other JJ 42759 60 16 agents agent NNS 42759 60 17 of of IN 42759 60 18 production production NN 42759 60 19 ; ; : 42759 60 20 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 60 21 out out IN 42759 60 22 of of IN 42759 60 23 a a DT 42759 60 24 product product NN 42759 60 25 which which WDT 42759 60 26 he -PRON- PRP 42759 60 27 divides divide VBZ 42759 60 28 with with IN 42759 60 29 other other JJ 42759 60 30 labourers labourer NNS 42759 60 31 as as RB 42759 60 32 well well RB 42759 60 33 as as IN 42759 60 34 other other JJ 42759 60 35 agents agent NNS 42759 60 36 ; ; : 42759 60 37 and and CC 42759 60 38 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 60 39 out out IN 42759 60 40 of of IN 42759 60 41 a a DT 42759 60 42 product product NN 42759 60 43 of of IN 42759 60 44 which which WDT 42759 60 45 he -PRON- PRP 42759 60 46 receives receive VBZ 42759 60 47 the the DT 42759 60 48 full full JJ 42759 60 49 money money NN 42759 60 50 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 60 51 . . . 42759 61 1 The the DT 42759 61 2 complexity complexity NN 42759 61 3 of of IN 42759 61 4 the the DT 42759 61 5 forces force NNS 42759 61 6 determining determine VBG 42759 61 7 distribution distribution NN 42759 61 8 and and CC 42759 61 9 income income NN 42759 61 10 indicate indicate VBP 42759 61 11 a a DT 42759 61 12 complexity complexity NN 42759 61 13 in in IN 42759 61 14 the the DT 42759 61 15 forces force NNS 42759 61 16 affecting affect VBG 42759 61 17 the the DT 42759 61 18 morality morality NN 42759 61 19 of of IN 42759 61 20 income income NN 42759 61 21 . . . 42759 62 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 62 2 , , , 42759 62 3 there there EX 42759 62 4 is be VBZ 42759 62 5 the the DT 42759 62 6 more more RBR 42759 62 7 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 62 8 ethical ethical JJ 42759 62 9 question question NN 42759 62 10 concerning concern VBG 42759 62 11 the the DT 42759 62 12 titles title NNS 42759 62 13 of of IN 42759 62 14 distribution distribution NN 42759 62 15 : : : 42759 62 16 whether whether IN 42759 62 17 mere mere JJ 42759 62 18 ownership ownership NN 42759 62 19 of of IN 42759 62 20 a a DT 42759 62 21 factor factor NN 42759 62 22 of of IN 42759 62 23 production production NN 42759 62 24 gives give VBZ 42759 62 25 a a DT 42759 62 26 just just JJ 42759 62 27 claim claim NN 42759 62 28 upon upon IN 42759 62 29 the the DT 42759 62 30 product product NN 42759 62 31 , , , 42759 62 32 as as IN 42759 62 33 in in IN 42759 62 34 the the DT 42759 62 35 case case NN 42759 62 36 of of IN 42759 62 37 the the DT 42759 62 38 landowner landowner NN 42759 62 39 and and CC 42759 62 40 the the DT 42759 62 41 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 62 42 ; ; : 42759 62 43 whether whether IN 42759 62 44 such such PDT 42759 62 45 a a DT 42759 62 46 claim claim NN 42759 62 47 , , , 42759 62 48 assuming assume VBG 42759 62 49 it -PRON- PRP 42759 62 50 to to TO 42759 62 51 be be VB 42759 62 52 valid valid JJ 42759 62 53 , , , 42759 62 54 is be VBZ 42759 62 55 as as RB 42759 62 56 good good JJ 42759 62 57 as as IN 42759 62 58 that that DT 42759 62 59 of of IN 42759 62 60 the the DT 42759 62 61 labourer labourer NN 42759 62 62 and and CC 42759 62 63 the the DT 42759 62 64 business business NN 42759 62 65 man man NN 42759 62 66 , , , 42759 62 67 who who WP 42759 62 68 expend expend VBP 42759 62 69 human human JJ 42759 62 70 energy energy NN 42759 62 71 in in IN 42759 62 72 the the DT 42759 62 73 productive productive JJ 42759 62 74 process process NN 42759 62 75 ; ; : 42759 62 76 whether whether IN 42759 62 77 different different JJ 42759 62 78 kinds kind NNS 42759 62 79 of of IN 42759 62 80 productive productive JJ 42759 62 81 activity activity NN 42759 62 82 should should MD 42759 62 83 be be VB 42759 62 84 rewarded reward VBN 42759 62 85 at at IN 42759 62 86 different different JJ 42759 62 87 rates rate NNS 42759 62 88 ; ; : 42759 62 89 and and CC 42759 62 90 if if IN 42759 62 91 so so RB 42759 62 92 in in IN 42759 62 93 what what WDT 42759 62 94 proportion proportion NN 42759 62 95 . . . 42759 63 1 Why why WRB 42759 63 2 should should MD 42759 63 3 the the DT 42759 63 4 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 63 5 receive receive VB 42759 63 6 six six CD 42759 63 7 per per IN 42759 63 8 cent cent NN 42759 63 9 . . . 42759 63 10 , , , 42759 63 11 rather rather RB 42759 63 12 than than IN 42759 63 13 two two CD 42759 63 14 per per NN 42759 63 15 cent cent NN 42759 63 16 . . . 42759 63 17 , , , 42759 63 18 or or CC 42759 63 19 sixteen sixteen CD 42759 63 20 per per IN 42759 63 21 cent cent NN 42759 63 22 . . . 42759 63 23 ? ? . 42759 64 1 Why why WRB 42759 64 2 should should MD 42759 64 3 the the DT 42759 64 4 locomotive locomotive JJ 42759 64 5 engineer engineer NN 42759 64 6 receive receive VBP 42759 64 7 more more JJR 42759 64 8 than than IN 42759 64 9 the the DT 42759 64 10 trackman trackman NN 42759 64 11 ? ? . 42759 65 1 Why why WRB 42759 65 2 should should MD 42759 65 3 not not RB 42759 65 4 all all DT 42759 65 5 persons person NNS 42759 65 6 be be VB 42759 65 7 compensated compensate VBN 42759 65 8 equally equally RB 42759 65 9 ? ? . 42759 66 1 Should Should MD 42759 66 2 all all DT 42759 66 3 or or CC 42759 66 4 any any DT 42759 66 5 of of IN 42759 66 6 the the DT 42759 66 7 benefits benefit NNS 42759 66 8 of of IN 42759 66 9 industrial industrial JJ 42759 66 10 improvements improvement NNS 42759 66 11 go go VB 42759 66 12 to to IN 42759 66 13 the the DT 42759 66 14 consumer consumer NN 42759 66 15 ? ? . 42759 67 1 Such such JJ 42759 67 2 are be VBP 42759 67 3 typical typical JJ 42759 67 4 questions question NNS 42759 67 5 in in IN 42759 67 6 the the DT 42759 67 7 study study NN 42759 67 8 of of IN 42759 67 9 distributive distributive JJ 42759 67 10 justice justice NN 42759 67 11 . . . 42759 68 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 68 2 are be VBP 42759 68 3 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 68 4 to to TO 42759 68 5 give give VB 42759 68 6 some some DT 42759 68 7 idea idea NN 42759 68 8 of of IN 42759 68 9 the the DT 42759 68 10 magnitude magnitude NN 42759 68 11 and and CC 42759 68 12 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 68 13 of of IN 42759 68 14 the the DT 42759 68 15 problem problem NN 42759 68 16 . . . 42759 69 1 Scarcely scarcely RB 42759 69 2 less less RBR 42759 69 3 formidable formidable JJ 42759 69 4 is be VBZ 42759 69 5 the the DT 42759 69 6 task task NN 42759 69 7 of of IN 42759 69 8 suggesting suggest VBG 42759 69 9 means mean NNS 42759 69 10 to to TO 42759 69 11 correct correct VB 42759 69 12 the the DT 42759 69 13 injustices injustice NNS 42759 69 14 of of IN 42759 69 15 the the DT 42759 69 16 present present JJ 42759 69 17 distribution distribution NN 42759 69 18 . . . 42759 70 1 The the DT 42759 70 2 difficulties difficulty NNS 42759 70 3 in in IN 42759 70 4 this this DT 42759 70 5 part part NN 42759 70 6 of of IN 42759 70 7 the the DT 42759 70 8 field field NN 42759 70 9 are be VBP 42759 70 10 indicated indicate VBN 42759 70 11 by by IN 42759 70 12 the the DT 42759 70 13 multiplicity multiplicity NN 42759 70 14 of of IN 42759 70 15 social social JJ 42759 70 16 remedies remedy NNS 42759 70 17 that that WDT 42759 70 18 have have VBP 42759 70 19 been be VBN 42759 70 20 proposed propose VBN 42759 70 21 , , , 42759 70 22 and and CC 42759 70 23 by by IN 42759 70 24 the the DT 42759 70 25 fact fact NN 42759 70 26 that that IN 42759 70 27 none none NN 42759 70 28 of of IN 42759 70 29 them -PRON- PRP 42759 70 30 has have VBZ 42759 70 31 succeeded succeed VBN 42759 70 32 in in IN 42759 70 33 winning win VBG 42759 70 34 the the DT 42759 70 35 adhesion adhesion NN 42759 70 36 of of IN 42759 70 37 more more JJR 42759 70 38 than than IN 42759 70 39 a a DT 42759 70 40 minority minority NN 42759 70 41 of of IN 42759 70 42 the the DT 42759 70 43 population population NN 42759 70 44 . . . 42759 71 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 71 2 shall shall MD 42759 71 3 be be VB 42759 71 4 obliged oblige VBN 42759 71 5 not not RB 42759 71 6 only only RB 42759 71 7 to to TO 42759 71 8 pass pass VB 42759 71 9 moral moral JJ 42759 71 10 judgment judgment NN 42759 71 11 upon upon IN 42759 71 12 the the DT 42759 71 13 most most RBS 42759 71 14 important important JJ 42759 71 15 of of IN 42759 71 16 these these DT 42759 71 17 proposals proposal NNS 42759 71 18 , , , 42759 71 19 but but CC 42759 71 20 to to TO 42759 71 21 indicate indicate VB 42759 71 22 and and CC 42759 71 23 advocate advocate VB 42759 71 24 a a DT 42759 71 25 more more RBR 42759 71 26 or or CC 42759 71 27 less less RBR 42759 71 28 complete complete JJ 42759 71 29 and and CC 42759 71 30 systematic systematic JJ 42759 71 31 group group NN 42759 71 32 of of IN 42759 71 33 such such JJ 42759 71 34 reforms reform NNS 42759 71 35 as as IN 42759 71 36 seem seem VBP 42759 71 37 to to TO 42759 71 38 be be VB 42759 71 39 at at IN 42759 71 40 once once RB 42759 71 41 feasible feasible JJ 42759 71 42 and and CC 42759 71 43 righteous righteous JJ 42759 71 44 . . . 42759 72 1 GENERAL GENERAL NNP 42759 72 2 REFERENCES reference NNS 42759 72 3 TAUSSIG taussig FW 42759 72 4 : : : 42759 72 5 Principles principle NNS 42759 72 6 of of IN 42759 72 7 Economics Economics NNP 42759 72 8 . . . 42759 73 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 73 2 ; ; : 42759 73 3 1911 1911 CD 42759 73 4 . . . 42759 74 1 DEVAS DEVAS NNP 42759 74 2 : : : 42759 74 3 Political Political NNP 42759 74 4 Economy Economy NNP 42759 74 5 . . . 42759 75 1 Longmans longman NNS 42759 75 2 ; ; : 42759 75 3 1901 1901 CD 42759 75 4 . . . 42759 76 1 HOBSON HOBSON NNP 42759 76 2 : : : 42759 76 3 The the DT 42759 76 4 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 76 5 System System NNP 42759 76 6 . . . 42759 77 1 Longmans longman NNS 42759 77 2 ; ; : 42759 77 3 1909 1909 CD 42759 77 4 . . . 42759 78 1 CLARK CLARK NNP 42759 78 2 : : : 42759 78 3 The the DT 42759 78 4 Distribution Distribution NNP 42759 78 5 of of IN 42759 78 6 Wealth wealth NN 42759 78 7 . . . 42759 79 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 79 2 ; ; : 42759 79 3 1899 1899 CD 42759 79 4 . . . 42759 80 1 SMART SMART NNP 42759 80 2 : : : 42759 80 3 The the DT 42759 80 4 Distribution Distribution NNP 42759 80 5 of of IN 42759 80 6 Income Income NNP 42759 80 7 . . . 42759 81 1 London London NNP 42759 81 2 ; ; : 42759 81 3 1899 1899 CD 42759 81 4 . . . 42759 82 1 WILLOUGHBY willoughby NN 42759 82 2 : : : 42759 82 3 Social Social NNP 42759 82 4 Justice Justice NNP 42759 82 5 . . . 42759 83 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 83 2 ; ; : 42759 83 3 1900 1900 CD 42759 83 4 . . . 42759 84 1 CARVER carver NN 42759 84 2 : : : 42759 84 3 Essays essay NNS 42759 84 4 in in IN 42759 84 5 Social Social NNP 42759 84 6 Justice Justice NNP 42759 84 7 . . . 42759 85 1 Harvard Harvard NNP 42759 85 2 University University NNP 42759 85 3 Press Press NNP 42759 85 4 ; ; : 42759 85 5 1915 1915 CD 42759 85 6 . . . 42759 86 1 ELY ELY NNP 42759 86 2 : : : 42759 86 3 Property Property NNP 42759 86 4 and and CC 42759 86 5 Contract Contract NNP 42759 86 6 in in IN 42759 86 7 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 86 8 Relations Relations NNPS 42759 86 9 to to IN 42759 86 10 the the DT 42759 86 11 Distribution Distribution NNP 42759 86 12 of of IN 42759 86 13 Wealth wealth NN 42759 86 14 . . . 42759 87 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 87 2 ; ; : 42759 87 3 1914 1914 CD 42759 87 4 . . . 42759 88 1 NEARING nearing NN 42759 88 2 : : : 42759 88 3 Income income NN 42759 88 4 . . . 42759 89 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 89 2 ; ; : 42759 89 3 1915 1915 CD 42759 89 4 . . . 42759 90 1 STREIGHTOFF STREIGHTOFF NNP 42759 90 2 : : : 42759 90 3 The the DT 42759 90 4 Distribution Distribution NNP 42759 90 5 of of IN 42759 90 6 Incomes Incomes NNPS 42759 90 7 in in IN 42759 90 8 the the DT 42759 90 9 United United NNP 42759 90 10 States States NNP 42759 90 11 . . . 42759 91 1 Longmans longman NNS 42759 91 2 ; ; : 42759 91 3 1912 1912 CD 42759 91 4 . . . 42759 92 1 WAGNER wagner NN 42759 92 2 : : : 42759 92 3 Grundlegung Grundlegung NNP 42759 92 4 der der VBP 42759 92 5 Nationaloekonomie Nationaloekonomie NNP 42759 92 6 . . . 42759 93 1 Leipzig Leipzig NNP 42759 93 2 ; ; : 42759 93 3 1892 1892 CD 42759 93 4 - - SYM 42759 93 5 1894 1894 CD 42759 93 6 . . . 42759 94 1 PESCH PESCH NNP 42759 94 2 : : : 42759 94 3 Lehrbuch lehrbuch NN 42759 94 4 der der NN 42759 94 5 Nationaloekonomie Nationaloekonomie NNP 42759 94 6 . . . 42759 95 1 Freiburg freiburg NN 42759 95 2 ; ; : 42759 95 3 1905 1905 CD 42759 95 4 - - SYM 42759 95 5 1913 1913 CD 42759 95 6 . . . 42759 96 1 ANTOINE ANTOINE NNP 42759 96 2 : : : 42759 96 3 Cours cour NNS 42759 96 4 d'Économie d'Économie NNP 42759 96 5 Sociale Sociale NNP 42759 96 6 . . . 42759 97 1 Paris Paris NNP 42759 97 2 ; ; : 42759 97 3 1899 1899 CD 42759 97 4 . . . 42759 98 1 HITZE HITZE NNP 42759 98 2 : : : 42759 98 3 Capital capital NN 42759 98 4 et et NNP 42759 98 5 Travail Travail NNP 42759 98 6 . . . 42759 99 1 Louvain louvain NN 42759 99 2 ; ; : 42759 99 3 1898 1898 CD 42759 99 4 . . . 42759 100 1 HOLLANDER HOLLANDER NNP 42759 100 2 : : : 42759 100 3 The the DT 42759 100 4 Abolition Abolition NNP 42759 100 5 of of IN 42759 100 6 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 100 7 . . . 42759 101 1 Houghton Houghton NNP 42759 101 2 Mifflin Mifflin NNP 42759 101 3 Company Company NNP 42759 101 4 ; ; : 42759 101 5 1914 1914 CD 42759 101 6 . . . 42759 102 1 ELLWOOD ellwood NN 42759 102 2 : : : 42759 102 3 The the DT 42759 102 4 Social Social NNP 42759 102 5 Problem Problem NNP 42759 102 6 . . . 42759 103 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 103 2 ; ; : 42759 103 3 1915 1915 CD 42759 103 4 . . . 42759 104 1 GARRIGUET GARRIGUET NNP 42759 104 2 : : : 42759 104 3 The the DT 42759 104 4 Social Social NNP 42759 104 5 Value Value NNP 42759 104 6 of of IN 42759 104 7 the the DT 42759 104 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 42759 104 9 . . . 42759 105 1 Herder herder NN 42759 105 2 ; ; : 42759 105 3 1911 1911 CD 42759 105 4 . . . 42759 106 1 PARKINSON PARKINSON NNP 42759 106 2 : : : 42759 106 3 A A NNP 42759 106 4 Primer Primer NNP 42759 106 5 of of IN 42759 106 6 Social Social NNP 42759 106 7 Science Science NNP 42759 106 8 . . . 42759 107 1 Devin Devin NNP 42759 107 2 - - HYPH 42759 107 3 Adair Adair NNP 42759 107 4 Co. Co. NNP 42759 107 5 ; ; : 42759 107 6 1913 1913 CD 42759 107 7 . . . 42759 108 1 VERMEERSCH VERMEERSCH NNP 42759 108 2 : : : 42759 108 3 Quaestiones Quaestiones NNP 42759 108 4 de de NNP 42759 108 5 Justitia Justitia NNP 42759 108 6 . . . 42759 109 1 Bruges bruge NNS 42759 109 2 ; ; : 42759 109 3 1901 1901 CD 42759 109 4 . . . 42759 110 1 KING KING NNP 42759 110 2 : : : 42759 110 3 The the DT 42759 110 4 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 110 5 and and CC 42759 110 6 Income Income NNP 42759 110 7 of of IN 42759 110 8 the the DT 42759 110 9 People People NNS 42759 110 10 of of IN 42759 110 11 the the DT 42759 110 12 United United NNP 42759 110 13 States States NNP 42759 110 14 . . . 42759 111 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 111 2 ; ; : 42759 111 3 1915 1915 CD 42759 111 4 . . . 42759 112 1 COMMISSION COMMISSION VBN 42759 112 2 ON on IN 42759 112 3 INDUSTRIAL INDUSTRIAL NNP 42759 112 4 RELATIONS RELATIONS NNP 42759 112 5 . . . 42759 113 1 Final Final NNP 42759 113 2 Report Report NNP 42759 113 3 ; ; : 42759 113 4 1915 1915 CD 42759 113 5 . . . 42759 114 1 SECTION section NN 42759 114 2 I -PRON- PRP 42759 114 3 THE the DT 42759 114 4 MORALITY morality NN 42759 114 5 OF of IN 42759 114 6 PRIVATE private JJ 42759 114 7 LANDOWNERSHIP landownership NN 42759 114 8 AND and CC 42759 114 9 RENT rent NN 42759 114 10 DISTRIBUTIVE DISTRIBUTIVE NNP 42759 114 11 JUSTICE JUSTICE NNP 42759 114 12 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 114 13 I -PRON- PRP 42759 114 14 THE the DT 42759 114 15 LANDOWNER LANDOWNER NNP 42759 114 16 'S 's POS 42759 114 17 SHARE share NN 42759 114 18 OF of IN 42759 114 19 THE the DT 42759 114 20 NATIONAL NATIONAL NNP 42759 114 21 PRODUCT PRODUCT NNP 42759 114 22 That that DT 42759 114 23 part part NN 42759 114 24 of of IN 42759 114 25 the the DT 42759 114 26 national national JJ 42759 114 27 product product NN 42759 114 28 which which WDT 42759 114 29 represents represent VBZ 42759 114 30 land land NN 42759 114 31 , , , 42759 114 32 and and CC 42759 114 33 is be VBZ 42759 114 34 attributed attribute VBN 42759 114 35 specifically specifically RB 42759 114 36 to to IN 42759 114 37 land land NN 42759 114 38 , , , 42759 114 39 goes go VBZ 42759 114 40 to to IN 42759 114 41 the the DT 42759 114 42 landowner landowner NN 42759 114 43 . . . 42759 115 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 115 2 is be VBZ 42759 115 3 called call VBN 42759 115 4 economic economic JJ 42759 115 5 rent rent NN 42759 115 6 , , , 42759 115 7 or or CC 42759 115 8 simply simply RB 42759 115 9 rent rent VB 42759 115 10 . . . 42759 116 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 116 2 say say VBP 42759 116 3 that that IN 42759 116 4 rent rent NN 42759 116 5 " " `` 42759 116 6 is be VBZ 42759 116 7 attributed attribute VBN 42759 116 8 specifically specifically RB 42759 116 9 to to IN 42759 116 10 land land NN 42759 116 11 , , , 42759 116 12 " " '' 42759 116 13 rather rather RB 42759 116 14 than than IN 42759 116 15 " " `` 42759 116 16 is be VBZ 42759 116 17 produced produce VBN 42759 116 18 specifically specifically RB 42759 116 19 by by IN 42759 116 20 land land NN 42759 116 21 , , , 42759 116 22 " " '' 42759 116 23 because because IN 42759 116 24 we -PRON- PRP 42759 116 25 do do VBP 42759 116 26 not not RB 42759 116 27 know know VB 42759 116 28 what what WDT 42759 116 29 proportion proportion NN 42759 116 30 of of IN 42759 116 31 the the DT 42759 116 32 joint joint JJ 42759 116 33 product product NN 42759 116 34 of of IN 42759 116 35 the the DT 42759 116 36 different different JJ 42759 116 37 factors factor NNS 42759 116 38 of of IN 42759 116 39 production production NN 42759 116 40 exactly exactly RB 42759 116 41 reflects reflect VBZ 42759 116 42 the the DT 42759 116 43 productive productive JJ 42759 116 44 contribution contribution NN 42759 116 45 of of IN 42759 116 46 any any DT 42759 116 47 factor factor NN 42759 116 48 . . . 42759 117 1 Economic economic JJ 42759 117 2 rent rent NN 42759 117 3 represents represent VBZ 42759 117 4 the the DT 42759 117 5 productivity productivity NN 42759 117 6 of of IN 42759 117 7 land land NN 42759 117 8 in in IN 42759 117 9 so so RB 42759 117 10 far far RB 42759 117 11 as as IN 42759 117 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 117 13 indicates indicate VBZ 42759 117 14 what what WP 42759 117 15 men man NNS 42759 117 16 are be VBP 42759 117 17 willing willing JJ 42759 117 18 to to TO 42759 117 19 pay pay VB 42759 117 20 for for IN 42759 117 21 land land NN 42759 117 22 - - HYPH 42759 117 23 use use NN 42759 117 24 in in IN 42759 117 25 the the DT 42759 117 26 productive productive JJ 42759 117 27 process process NN 42759 117 28 . . . 42759 118 1 In in IN 42759 118 2 any any DT 42759 118 3 particular particular JJ 42759 118 4 case case NN 42759 118 5 rent rent NN 42759 118 6 comes come VBZ 42759 118 7 into into IN 42759 118 8 existence existence NN 42759 118 9 because because IN 42759 118 10 the the DT 42759 118 11 land land NN 42759 118 12 makes make VBZ 42759 118 13 a a DT 42759 118 14 commercially commercially RB 42759 118 15 valuable valuable JJ 42759 118 16 contribution contribution NN 42759 118 17 to to IN 42759 118 18 the the DT 42759 118 19 product product NN 42759 118 20 ; ; : 42759 118 21 and and CC 42759 118 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 118 23 goes go VBZ 42759 118 24 to to IN 42759 118 25 the the DT 42759 118 26 landowner landowner NN 42759 118 27 because because IN 42759 118 28 this this DT 42759 118 29 is be VBZ 42759 118 30 one one CD 42759 118 31 of of IN 42759 118 32 the the DT 42759 118 33 powers power NNS 42759 118 34 or or CC 42759 118 35 rights right NNS 42759 118 36 included include VBN 42759 118 37 in in IN 42759 118 38 the the DT 42759 118 39 institution institution NN 42759 118 40 of of IN 42759 118 41 private private JJ 42759 118 42 ownership ownership NN 42759 118 43 . . . 42759 119 1 And and CC 42759 119 2 the the DT 42759 119 3 landowner landowner NN 42759 119 4 's 's POS 42759 119 5 share share NN 42759 119 6 is be VBZ 42759 119 7 received receive VBN 42759 119 8 by by IN 42759 119 9 him -PRON- PRP 42759 119 10 precisely precisely RB 42759 119 11 in in IN 42759 119 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 119 13 capacity capacity NN 42759 119 14 as as IN 42759 119 15 landowner landowner NN 42759 119 16 , , , 42759 119 17 and and CC 42759 119 18 not not RB 42759 119 19 because because IN 42759 119 20 he -PRON- PRP 42759 119 21 may may MD 42759 119 22 happen happen VB 42759 119 23 to to TO 42759 119 24 be be VB 42759 119 25 labourer labourer NN 42759 119 26 , , , 42759 119 27 farmer farmer NN 42759 119 28 , , , 42759 119 29 or or CC 42759 119 30 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 119 31 of of IN 42759 119 32 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 119 33 capital capital NN 42759 119 34 . . . 42759 120 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 120 2 is be VBZ 42759 120 3 perhaps perhaps RB 42759 120 4 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 120 5 to to TO 42759 120 6 observe observe VB 42759 120 7 that that IN 42759 120 8 not not RB 42759 120 9 all all DT 42759 120 10 land land NN 42759 120 11 produces produce VBZ 42759 120 12 rent rent NN 42759 120 13 . . . 42759 121 1 While while IN 42759 121 2 almost almost RB 42759 121 3 all all DT 42759 121 4 land land NN 42759 121 5 is be VBZ 42759 121 6 useful useful JJ 42759 121 7 and and CC 42759 121 8 productive productive JJ 42759 121 9 , , , 42759 121 10 at at IN 42759 121 11 least least JJS 42759 121 12 potentially potentially RB 42759 121 13 , , , 42759 121 14 there there EX 42759 121 15 is be VBZ 42759 121 16 in in IN 42759 121 17 almost almost RB 42759 121 18 every every DT 42759 121 19 locality locality NN 42759 121 20 some some DT 42759 121 21 land land NN 42759 121 22 which which WDT 42759 121 23 in in IN 42759 121 24 present present JJ 42759 121 25 conditions condition NNS 42759 121 26 does do VBZ 42759 121 27 not not RB 42759 121 28 warrant warrant VB 42759 121 29 men man NNS 42759 121 30 in in IN 42759 121 31 paying pay VBG 42759 121 32 a a DT 42759 121 33 price price NN 42759 121 34 for for IN 42759 121 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 121 36 use use NN 42759 121 37 . . . 42759 122 1 If if IN 42759 122 2 the the DT 42759 122 3 crop crop NN 42759 122 4 raised raise VBD 42759 122 5 on on IN 42759 122 6 very very RB 42759 122 7 sandy sandy JJ 42759 122 8 soil soil NN 42759 122 9 is be VBZ 42759 122 10 so so RB 42759 122 11 small small JJ 42759 122 12 as as IN 42759 122 13 to to TO 42759 122 14 cover cover VB 42759 122 15 merely merely RB 42759 122 16 the the DT 42759 122 17 outlay outlay NN 42759 122 18 for for IN 42759 122 19 labour labour NN 42759 122 20 and and CC 42759 122 21 capital capital NN 42759 122 22 , , , 42759 122 23 men man NNS 42759 122 24 will will MD 42759 122 25 not not RB 42759 122 26 pay pay VB 42759 122 27 rent rent NN 42759 122 28 for for IN 42759 122 29 the the DT 42759 122 30 use use NN 42759 122 31 of of IN 42759 122 32 that that DT 42759 122 33 soil soil NN 42759 122 34 . . . 42759 123 1 Yet yet RB 42759 123 2 the the DT 42759 123 3 land land NN 42759 123 4 has have VBZ 42759 123 5 contributed contribute VBN 42759 123 6 something something NN 42759 123 7 to to IN 42759 123 8 the the DT 42759 123 9 product product NN 42759 123 10 . . . 42759 124 1 Herein Herein NNP 42759 124 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 124 3 have have VBP 42759 124 4 another another DT 42759 124 5 indication indication NN 42759 124 6 that that IN 42759 124 7 rent rent NN 42759 124 8 is be VBZ 42759 124 9 not not RB 42759 124 10 an an DT 42759 124 11 adequate adequate JJ 42759 124 12 measure measure NN 42759 124 13 of of IN 42759 124 14 land land NN 42759 124 15 productivity productivity NN 42759 124 16 . . . 42759 125 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 125 2 merely merely RB 42759 125 3 represents represent VBZ 42759 125 4 land land NN 42759 125 5 value,--at value,--at NNP 42759 125 6 a a DT 42759 125 7 given give VBN 42759 125 8 time time NN 42759 125 9 , , , 42759 125 10 in in IN 42759 125 11 given give VBN 42759 125 12 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 125 13 . . . 42759 126 1 _ _ NNP 42759 126 2 Economic Economic NNP 42759 126 3 Rent Rent NNP 42759 126 4 Always always RB 42759 126 5 Goes go VBZ 42759 126 6 to to IN 42759 126 7 the the DT 42759 126 8 Landowner Landowner NNP 42759 126 9 _ _ XX 42759 126 10 All all DT 42759 126 11 land land NN 42759 126 12 that that WDT 42759 126 13 is be VBZ 42759 126 14 in in IN 42759 126 15 use use NN 42759 126 16 , , , 42759 126 17 and and CC 42759 126 18 for for IN 42759 126 19 the the DT 42759 126 20 use use NN 42759 126 21 of of IN 42759 126 22 which which WDT 42759 126 23 men man NNS 42759 126 24 are be VBP 42759 126 25 willing willing JJ 42759 126 26 to to TO 42759 126 27 pay pay VB 42759 126 28 a a DT 42759 126 29 price price NN 42759 126 30 yields yield NNS 42759 126 31 rent rent NN 42759 126 32 , , , 42759 126 33 whether whether IN 42759 126 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 126 35 is be VBZ 42759 126 36 used use VBN 42759 126 37 by by IN 42759 126 38 a a DT 42759 126 39 tenant tenant NN 42759 126 40 or or CC 42759 126 41 by by IN 42759 126 42 the the DT 42759 126 43 owner owner NN 42759 126 44 . . . 42759 127 1 In in IN 42759 127 2 the the DT 42759 127 3 latter latter JJ 42759 127 4 case case NN 42759 127 5 the the DT 42759 127 6 owner owner NN 42759 127 7 may may MD 42759 127 8 not not RB 42759 127 9 call call VB 42759 127 10 the the DT 42759 127 11 rent rent NN 42759 127 12 that that IN 42759 127 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 127 14 receives receive VBZ 42759 127 15 by by IN 42759 127 16 that that DT 42759 127 17 name name NN 42759 127 18 ; ; : 42759 127 19 he -PRON- PRP 42759 127 20 may may MD 42759 127 21 not not RB 42759 127 22 distinguish distinguish VB 42759 127 23 between between IN 42759 127 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 127 25 and and CC 42759 127 26 the the DT 42759 127 27 other other JJ 42759 127 28 portions portion NNS 42759 127 29 of of IN 42759 127 30 the the DT 42759 127 31 product product NN 42759 127 32 that that WDT 42759 127 33 he -PRON- PRP 42759 127 34 gets get VBZ 42759 127 35 from from IN 42759 127 36 the the DT 42759 127 37 land land NN 42759 127 38 ; ; : 42759 127 39 he -PRON- PRP 42759 127 40 may may MD 42759 127 41 call call VB 42759 127 42 the the DT 42759 127 43 entire entire JJ 42759 127 44 product product NN 42759 127 45 profits profit NNS 42759 127 46 , , , 42759 127 47 or or CC 42759 127 48 wages wage NNS 42759 127 49 . . . 42759 128 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 128 2 the the DT 42759 128 3 rent rent NN 42759 128 4 exists exist VBZ 42759 128 5 as as IN 42759 128 6 a a DT 42759 128 7 surplus surplus NN 42759 128 8 over over IN 42759 128 9 that that DT 42759 128 10 part part NN 42759 128 11 of of IN 42759 128 12 the the DT 42759 128 13 product product NN 42759 128 14 that that IN 42759 128 15 he -PRON- PRP 42759 128 16 can can MD 42759 128 17 regard regard VB 42759 128 18 as as IN 42759 128 19 the the DT 42759 128 20 proper proper JJ 42759 128 21 return return NN 42759 128 22 for for IN 42759 128 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 128 24 labour labour NN 42759 128 25 , , , 42759 128 26 and and CC 42759 128 27 for for IN 42759 128 28 the the DT 42759 128 29 use use NN 42759 128 30 of of IN 42759 128 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 128 32 capital capital NN 42759 128 33 - - HYPH 42759 128 34 instruments instrument NNS 42759 128 35 , , , 42759 128 36 such such JJ 42759 128 37 as as IN 42759 128 38 , , , 42759 128 39 horses horse NNS 42759 128 40 , , , 42759 128 41 buildings building NNS 42759 128 42 , , , 42759 128 43 and and CC 42759 128 44 machinery machinery NN 42759 128 45 . . . 42759 129 1 If if IN 42759 129 2 a a DT 42759 129 3 farmer farmer NN 42759 129 4 employs employ VBZ 42759 129 5 the the DT 42759 129 6 same same JJ 42759 129 7 amount amount NN 42759 129 8 and and CC 42759 129 9 kind kind RB 42759 129 10 of of RB 42759 129 11 labour labour NN 42759 129 12 and and CC 42759 129 13 capital capital NN 42759 129 14 in in IN 42759 129 15 the the DT 42759 129 16 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 129 17 of of IN 42759 129 18 two two CD 42759 129 19 pieces piece NNS 42759 129 20 of of IN 42759 129 21 land land NN 42759 129 22 , , , 42759 129 23 one one CD 42759 129 24 of of IN 42759 129 25 which which WDT 42759 129 26 he -PRON- PRP 42759 129 27 owns own VBZ 42759 129 28 , , , 42759 129 29 the the DT 42759 129 30 other other JJ 42759 129 31 being be VBG 42759 129 32 hired hire VBN 42759 129 33 from from IN 42759 129 34 some some DT 42759 129 35 one one NN 42759 129 36 else else RB 42759 129 37 ; ; : 42759 129 38 if if IN 42759 129 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 129 40 net net JJ 42759 129 41 product product NN 42759 129 42 is be VBZ 42759 129 43 the the DT 42759 129 44 same same JJ 42759 129 45 in in IN 42759 129 46 both both DT 42759 129 47 cases case NNS 42759 129 48 , , , 42759 129 49 say say VB 42759 129 50 , , , 42759 129 51 1,000 1,000 CD 42759 129 52 dollars dollar NNS 42759 129 53 ; ; : 42759 129 54 and and CC 42759 129 55 if if IN 42759 129 56 he -PRON- PRP 42759 129 57 must must MD 42759 129 58 pay pay VB 42759 129 59 200 200 CD 42759 129 60 dollars dollar NNS 42759 129 61 to to IN 42759 129 62 the the DT 42759 129 63 owner owner NN 42759 129 64 of of IN 42759 129 65 the the DT 42759 129 66 hired hire VBN 42759 129 67 land,--then land,--then NNP 42759 129 68 , , , 42759 129 69 200 200 CD 42759 129 70 of of IN 42759 129 71 the the DT 42759 129 72 1,000 1,000 CD 42759 129 73 dollars dollar NNS 42759 129 74 that that WDT 42759 129 75 he -PRON- PRP 42759 129 76 receives receive VBZ 42759 129 77 from from IN 42759 129 78 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 129 79 own own JJ 42759 129 80 land land NN 42759 129 81 , , , 42759 129 82 is be VBZ 42759 129 83 likewise likewise RB 42759 129 84 to to TO 42759 129 85 be be VB 42759 129 86 attributed attribute VBN 42759 129 87 specifically specifically RB 42759 129 88 to to IN 42759 129 89 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 129 90 land land NN 42759 129 91 rather rather RB 42759 129 92 than than IN 42759 129 93 to to IN 42759 129 94 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 129 95 capital capital NN 42759 129 96 or or CC 42759 129 97 labour labour NN 42759 129 98 . . . 42759 130 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 130 2 is be VBZ 42759 130 3 rent rent NN 42759 130 4 . . . 42759 131 1 While while IN 42759 131 2 the the DT 42759 131 3 whole whole JJ 42759 131 4 product product NN 42759 131 5 is be VBZ 42759 131 6 due due JJ 42759 131 7 in in IN 42759 131 8 some some DT 42759 131 9 degree degree NN 42759 131 10 to to IN 42759 131 11 the the DT 42759 131 12 productive productive JJ 42759 131 13 power power NN 42759 131 14 of of IN 42759 131 15 land land NN 42759 131 16 , , , 42759 131 17 200 200 CD 42759 131 18 dollars dollar NNS 42759 131 19 of of IN 42759 131 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 131 21 represents represent VBZ 42759 131 22 land land NN 42759 131 23 value value NN 42759 131 24 in in IN 42759 131 25 the the DT 42759 131 26 process process NN 42759 131 27 of of IN 42759 131 28 production production NN 42759 131 29 , , , 42759 131 30 and and CC 42759 131 31 goes go VBZ 42759 131 32 to to IN 42759 131 33 him -PRON- PRP 42759 131 34 solely solely RB 42759 131 35 in in IN 42759 131 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 131 37 capacity capacity NN 42759 131 38 as as IN 42759 131 39 landowner landowner NN 42759 131 40 . . . 42759 132 1 The the DT 42759 132 2 rent rent NN 42759 132 3 that that WDT 42759 132 4 arises arise VBZ 42759 132 5 on on IN 42759 132 6 land land NN 42759 132 7 used use VBN 42759 132 8 for for IN 42759 132 9 building build VBG 42759 132 10 sites site NNS 42759 132 11 is be VBZ 42759 132 12 of of IN 42759 132 13 the the DT 42759 132 14 same same JJ 42759 132 15 general general JJ 42759 132 16 character character NN 42759 132 17 , , , 42759 132 18 and and CC 42759 132 19 goes go VBZ 42759 132 20 likewise likewise RB 42759 132 21 to to IN 42759 132 22 the the DT 42759 132 23 owner owner NN 42759 132 24 of of IN 42759 132 25 the the DT 42759 132 26 land land NN 42759 132 27 . . . 42759 133 1 The the DT 42759 133 2 owner owner NN 42759 133 3 of of IN 42759 133 4 the the DT 42759 133 5 site site NN 42759 133 6 upon upon IN 42759 133 7 which which WDT 42759 133 8 a a DT 42759 133 9 factory factory NN 42759 133 10 is be VBZ 42759 133 11 located locate VBN 42759 133 12 may may MD 42759 133 13 hire hire VB 42759 133 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 133 15 to to IN 42759 133 16 another another DT 42759 133 17 for for IN 42759 133 18 a a DT 42759 133 19 certain certain JJ 42759 133 20 sum sum NN 42759 133 21 annually annually RB 42759 133 22 , , , 42759 133 23 or or CC 42759 133 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 133 25 may may MD 42759 133 26 operate operate VB 42759 133 27 the the DT 42759 133 28 factory factory NN 42759 133 29 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 133 30 . . . 42759 134 1 In in IN 42759 134 2 either either DT 42759 134 3 case case NN 42759 134 4 he -PRON- PRP 42759 134 5 receives receive VBZ 42759 134 6 rent rent NN 42759 134 7 , , , 42759 134 8 the the DT 42759 134 9 amount amount NN 42759 134 10 that that WDT 42759 134 11 the the DT 42759 134 12 land land NN 42759 134 13 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 134 14 is be VBZ 42759 134 15 worth worth JJ 42759 134 16 for for IN 42759 134 17 use use NN 42759 134 18 , , , 42759 134 19 independently independently RB 42759 134 20 of of IN 42759 134 21 the the DT 42759 134 22 return return NN 42759 134 23 that that WDT 42759 134 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 134 25 obtains obtain VBZ 42759 134 26 for for IN 42759 134 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 134 28 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 134 29 of of IN 42759 134 30 capital capital NN 42759 134 31 and and CC 42759 134 32 labour labour NN 42759 134 33 . . . 42759 135 1 Even even RB 42759 135 2 when when WRB 42759 135 3 a a DT 42759 135 4 person person NN 42759 135 5 uses use VBZ 42759 135 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 135 7 land land NN 42759 135 8 as as IN 42759 135 9 a a DT 42759 135 10 site site NN 42759 135 11 for for IN 42759 135 12 a a DT 42759 135 13 dwelling dwelling NN 42759 135 14 which which WDT 42759 135 15 he -PRON- PRP 42759 135 16 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 135 17 occupies occupy VBZ 42759 135 18 , , , 42759 135 19 the the DT 42759 135 20 land land NN 42759 135 21 still still RB 42759 135 22 brings bring VBZ 42759 135 23 him -PRON- PRP 42759 135 24 economic economic JJ 42759 135 25 rent rent NN 42759 135 26 , , , 42759 135 27 since since IN 42759 135 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 135 29 affords afford VBZ 42759 135 30 him -PRON- PRP 42759 135 31 something something NN 42759 135 32 for for IN 42759 135 33 which which WDT 42759 135 34 he -PRON- PRP 42759 135 35 would would MD 42759 135 36 be be VB 42759 135 37 obliged oblige VBN 42759 135 38 to to TO 42759 135 39 pay pay VB 42759 135 40 if if IN 42759 135 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 135 42 house house NN 42759 135 43 were be VBD 42759 135 44 located locate VBN 42759 135 45 on on IN 42759 135 46 land land NN 42759 135 47 of of IN 42759 135 48 the the DT 42759 135 49 same same JJ 42759 135 50 kind kind NN 42759 135 51 owned own VBN 42759 135 52 by by IN 42759 135 53 some some DT 42759 135 54 one one NN 42759 135 55 else else RB 42759 135 56 . . . 42759 136 1 _ _ NNP 42759 136 2 Economic Economic NNP 42759 136 3 Rent Rent NNP 42759 136 4 and and CC 42759 136 5 Commercial Commercial NNP 42759 136 6 Rent Rent NNP 42759 136 7 _ _ NNP 42759 136 8 It -PRON- PRP 42759 136 9 will will MD 42759 136 10 be be VB 42759 136 11 observed observe VBN 42759 136 12 that that IN 42759 136 13 the the DT 42759 136 14 landowner landowner NN 42759 136 15 's 's POS 42759 136 16 share share NN 42759 136 17 of of IN 42759 136 18 the the DT 42759 136 19 product product NN 42759 136 20 , , , 42759 136 21 or or CC 42759 136 22 economic economic JJ 42759 136 23 rent rent NN 42759 136 24 , , , 42759 136 25 is be VBZ 42759 136 26 not not RB 42759 136 27 identical identical JJ 42759 136 28 with with IN 42759 136 29 commercial commercial JJ 42759 136 30 rent rent NN 42759 136 31 . . . 42759 137 1 The the DT 42759 137 2 latter latter NN 42759 137 3 is be VBZ 42759 137 4 a a DT 42759 137 5 payment payment NN 42759 137 6 for for IN 42759 137 7 land land NN 42759 137 8 and and CC 42759 137 9 capital capital NN 42759 137 10 , , , 42759 137 11 or or CC 42759 137 12 land land NN 42759 137 13 and and CC 42759 137 14 improvements improvement NNS 42759 137 15 , , , 42759 137 16 combined combine VBN 42759 137 17 . . . 42759 138 1 When when WRB 42759 138 2 a a DT 42759 138 3 man man NN 42759 138 4 pays pay VBZ 42759 138 5 nine nine CD 42759 138 6 hundred hundred CD 42759 138 7 dollars dollar NNS 42759 138 8 for for IN 42759 138 9 the the DT 42759 138 10 use use NN 42759 138 11 of of IN 42759 138 12 a a DT 42759 138 13 house house NN 42759 138 14 and and CC 42759 138 15 lot lot NN 42759 138 16 for for IN 42759 138 17 a a DT 42759 138 18 year year NN 42759 138 19 , , , 42759 138 20 this this DT 42759 138 21 sum sum NN 42759 138 22 contains contain VBZ 42759 138 23 two two CD 42759 138 24 elements element NNS 42759 138 25 , , , 42759 138 26 economic economic JJ 42759 138 27 rent rent NN 42759 138 28 for for IN 42759 138 29 the the DT 42759 138 30 lot lot NN 42759 138 31 , , , 42759 138 32 and and CC 42759 138 33 interest interest NN 42759 138 34 on on IN 42759 138 35 the the DT 42759 138 36 money money NN 42759 138 37 invested invest VBN 42759 138 38 in in IN 42759 138 39 the the DT 42759 138 40 house house NN 42759 138 41 . . . 42759 139 1 Assuming assume VBG 42759 139 2 that that IN 42759 139 3 the the DT 42759 139 4 house house NN 42759 139 5 is be VBZ 42759 139 6 worth worth JJ 42759 139 7 ten ten CD 42759 139 8 thousand thousand CD 42759 139 9 dollars dollar NNS 42759 139 10 , , , 42759 139 11 and and CC 42759 139 12 that that IN 42759 139 13 the the DT 42759 139 14 usual usual JJ 42759 139 15 return return NN 42759 139 16 on on IN 42759 139 17 such such JJ 42759 139 18 investments investment NNS 42759 139 19 is be VBZ 42759 139 20 eight eight CD 42759 139 21 per per NN 42759 139 22 cent cent NN 42759 139 23 . . . 42759 139 24 , , , 42759 139 25 we -PRON- PRP 42759 139 26 see see VBP 42759 139 27 that that IN 42759 139 28 eight eight CD 42759 139 29 hundred hundred CD 42759 139 30 dollars dollar NNS 42759 139 31 goes go VBZ 42759 139 32 to to IN 42759 139 33 the the DT 42759 139 34 owner owner NN 42759 139 35 as as IN 42759 139 36 interest interest NN 42759 139 37 on on IN 42759 139 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 139 39 capital capital NN 42759 139 40 , , , 42759 139 41 and and CC 42759 139 42 only only RB 42759 139 43 one one CD 42759 139 44 hundred hundred CD 42759 139 45 dollars dollar NNS 42759 139 46 as as IN 42759 139 47 rent rent NN 42759 139 48 for for IN 42759 139 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 139 50 land land NN 42759 139 51 . . . 42759 140 1 Similarly similarly RB 42759 140 2 the the DT 42759 140 3 price price NN 42759 140 4 paid pay VBN 42759 140 5 by by IN 42759 140 6 a a DT 42759 140 7 tenant tenant NN 42759 140 8 for for IN 42759 140 9 the the DT 42759 140 10 use use NN 42759 140 11 of of IN 42759 140 12 an an DT 42759 140 13 improved improved JJ 42759 140 14 farm farm NN 42759 140 15 is be VBZ 42759 140 16 partly partly RB 42759 140 17 interest interest NN 42759 140 18 on on IN 42759 140 19 the the DT 42759 140 20 value value NN 42759 140 21 of of IN 42759 140 22 the the DT 42759 140 23 improvements improvement NNS 42759 140 24 , , , 42759 140 25 and and CC 42759 140 26 partly partly RB 42759 140 27 economic economic JJ 42759 140 28 rent rent NN 42759 140 29 . . . 42759 141 1 In in IN 42759 141 2 both both DT 42759 141 3 cases case NNS 42759 141 4 the the DT 42759 141 5 owner owner NN 42759 141 6 may may MD 42759 141 7 reckon reckon VB 42759 141 8 the the DT 42759 141 9 land land NN 42759 141 10 as as IN 42759 141 11 so so RB 42759 141 12 much much JJ 42759 141 13 capital capital NN 42759 141 14 value value NN 42759 141 15 , , , 42759 141 16 and and CC 42759 141 17 the the DT 42759 141 18 economic economic JJ 42759 141 19 rent rent NN 42759 141 20 as as IN 42759 141 21 interest interest NN 42759 141 22 thereon thereon NN 42759 141 23 , , , 42759 141 24 just just RB 42759 141 25 as as IN 42759 141 26 the the DT 42759 141 27 commercial commercial JJ 42759 141 28 rent rent NN 42759 141 29 for for IN 42759 141 30 the the DT 42759 141 31 buildings building NNS 42759 141 32 and and CC 42759 141 33 other other JJ 42759 141 34 improvements improvement NNS 42759 141 35 is be VBZ 42759 141 36 interest interest NN 42759 141 37 on on IN 42759 141 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 141 39 capital capital NN 42759 141 40 value value NN 42759 141 41 ; ; : 42759 141 42 but but CC 42759 141 43 the the DT 42759 141 44 economist economist NN 42759 141 45 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 42759 141 46 between between IN 42759 141 47 them -PRON- PRP 42759 141 48 because because IN 42759 141 49 he -PRON- PRP 42759 141 50 knows know VBZ 42759 141 51 that that IN 42759 141 52 they -PRON- PRP 42759 141 53 are be VBP 42759 141 54 determined determine VBN 42759 141 55 by by IN 42759 141 56 different different JJ 42759 141 57 forces force NNS 42759 141 58 , , , 42759 141 59 and and CC 42759 141 60 that that IN 42759 141 61 the the DT 42759 141 62 distinction distinction NN 42759 141 63 is be VBZ 42759 141 64 of of IN 42759 141 65 importance importance NN 42759 141 66 . . . 42759 142 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 142 2 knows know VBZ 42759 142 3 , , , 42759 142 4 for for IN 42759 142 5 example example NN 42759 142 6 , , , 42759 142 7 that that IN 42759 142 8 the the DT 42759 142 9 supply supply NN 42759 142 10 of of IN 42759 142 11 land land NN 42759 142 12 is be VBZ 42759 142 13 fixed fix VBN 42759 142 14 , , , 42759 142 15 while while IN 42759 142 16 the the DT 42759 142 17 supply supply NN 42759 142 18 of of IN 42759 142 19 capital capital NN 42759 142 20 is be VBZ 42759 142 21 capable capable JJ 42759 142 22 of of IN 42759 142 23 indefinite indefinite JJ 42759 142 24 increase increase NN 42759 142 25 . . . 42759 143 1 In in IN 42759 143 2 many many JJ 42759 143 3 situations situation NNS 42759 143 4 , , , 42759 143 5 therefore therefore RB 42759 143 6 , , , 42759 143 7 rent rent NN 42759 143 8 increases increase NNS 42759 143 9 , , , 42759 143 10 but but CC 42759 143 11 interest interest NN 42759 143 12 remains remain VBZ 42759 143 13 stationary stationary JJ 42759 143 14 or or CC 42759 143 15 declines decline NNS 42759 143 16 . . . 42759 144 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 42759 144 2 , , , 42759 144 3 though though IN 42759 144 4 more more RBR 42759 144 5 rarely rarely RB 42759 144 6 , , , 42759 144 7 the the DT 42759 144 8 reverse reverse NN 42759 144 9 occurs occur VBZ 42759 144 10 . . . 42759 145 1 As as IN 42759 145 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 145 3 shall shall MD 42759 145 4 see see VB 42759 145 5 later later RBR 42759 145 6 , , , 42759 145 7 this this DT 42759 145 8 and and CC 42759 145 9 some some DT 42759 145 10 other other JJ 42759 145 11 specific specific JJ 42759 145 12 characteristics characteristic NNS 42759 145 13 of of IN 42759 145 14 land land NN 42759 145 15 and and CC 42759 145 16 rent rent NN 42759 145 17 have have VBP 42759 145 18 important important JJ 42759 145 19 moral moral JJ 42759 145 20 aspects aspect NNS 42759 145 21 ; ; , 42759 145 22 consequently consequently RB 42759 145 23 the the DT 42759 145 24 moralist moralist NN 42759 145 25 can can MD 42759 145 26 not not RB 42759 145 27 afford afford VB 42759 145 28 to to TO 42759 145 29 confuse confuse VB 42759 145 30 rent rent NN 42759 145 31 with with IN 42759 145 32 interest interest NN 42759 145 33 . . . 42759 146 1 _ _ NNP 42759 146 2 The the DT 42759 146 3 Cause Cause NNP 42759 146 4 of of IN 42759 146 5 Economic Economic NNP 42759 146 6 Rent Rent NNP 42759 146 7 _ _ NNP 42759 146 8 The the DT 42759 146 9 cause cause NN 42759 146 10 of of IN 42759 146 11 economic economic JJ 42759 146 12 rent rent NN 42759 146 13 is be VBZ 42759 146 14 the the DT 42759 146 15 fact fact NN 42759 146 16 that that IN 42759 146 17 land land NN 42759 146 18 is be VBZ 42759 146 19 limited limit VBN 42759 146 20 relatively relatively RB 42759 146 21 to to IN 42759 146 22 the the DT 42759 146 23 demand demand NN 42759 146 24 for for IN 42759 146 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 146 26 . . . 42759 147 1 If if IN 42759 147 2 land land NN 42759 147 3 were be VBD 42759 147 4 as as RB 42759 147 5 plentiful plentiful JJ 42759 147 6 as as IN 42759 147 7 air air NN 42759 147 8 mere mere JJ 42759 147 9 ownership ownership NN 42759 147 10 of of IN 42759 147 11 some some DT 42759 147 12 portion portion NN 42759 147 13 of of IN 42759 147 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 147 15 would would MD 42759 147 16 not not RB 42759 147 17 enable enable VB 42759 147 18 the the DT 42759 147 19 owner owner NN 42759 147 20 to to TO 42759 147 21 collect collect VB 42759 147 22 rent rent NN 42759 147 23 . . . 42759 148 1 As as IN 42759 148 2 landowner landowner NN 42759 148 3 he -PRON- PRP 42759 148 4 would would MD 42759 148 5 receive receive VB 42759 148 6 no no DT 42759 148 7 income income NN 42759 148 8 . . . 42759 149 1 If if IN 42759 149 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 149 3 cultivated cultivate VBD 42759 149 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 149 5 land land NN 42759 149 6 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 149 7 the the DT 42759 149 8 return return NN 42759 149 9 therefrom therefrom NN 42759 149 10 would would MD 42759 149 11 not not RB 42759 149 12 exceed exceed VB 42759 149 13 normal normal JJ 42759 149 14 compensation compensation NN 42759 149 15 for for IN 42759 149 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 149 17 labour labour NN 42759 149 18 , , , 42759 149 19 and and CC 42759 149 20 normal normal JJ 42759 149 21 interest interest NN 42759 149 22 on on IN 42759 149 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 149 24 capital capital NN 42759 149 25 . . . 42759 150 1 Since since IN 42759 150 2 no no DT 42759 150 3 one one PRP 42759 150 4 would would MD 42759 150 5 be be VB 42759 150 6 compelled compel VBN 42759 150 7 to to TO 42759 150 8 pay pay VB 42759 150 9 for for IN 42759 150 10 the the DT 42759 150 11 use use NN 42759 150 12 of of IN 42759 150 13 land land NN 42759 150 14 , , , 42759 150 15 competition competition NN 42759 150 16 among among IN 42759 150 17 the the DT 42759 150 18 different different JJ 42759 150 19 cultivators cultivator NNS 42759 150 20 would would MD 42759 150 21 keep keep VB 42759 150 22 the the DT 42759 150 23 price price NN 42759 150 24 of of IN 42759 150 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 150 26 product product NN 42759 150 27 so so RB 42759 150 28 low low JJ 42759 150 29 that that IN 42759 150 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 150 31 would would MD 42759 150 32 merely merely RB 42759 150 33 reimburse reimburse VB 42759 150 34 them -PRON- PRP 42759 150 35 for for IN 42759 150 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 150 37 expenditures expenditure NNS 42759 150 38 of of IN 42759 150 39 capital capital NN 42759 150 40 and and CC 42759 150 41 labour labour NN 42759 150 42 . . . 42759 151 1 In in IN 42759 151 2 similar similar JJ 42759 151 3 conditions condition NNS 42759 151 4 no no DT 42759 151 5 rent rent NN 42759 151 6 would would MD 42759 151 7 arise arise VB 42759 151 8 on on IN 42759 151 9 building build VBG 42759 151 10 sites site NNS 42759 151 11 . . . 42759 152 1 The the DT 42759 152 2 cause cause NN 42759 152 3 of of IN 42759 152 4 the the DT 42759 152 5 _ _ NNP 42759 152 6 amount amount NN 42759 152 7 _ _ NNP 42759 152 8 of of IN 42759 152 9 rent rent NN 42759 152 10 may may MD 42759 152 11 also also RB 42759 152 12 be be VB 42759 152 13 stated state VBN 42759 152 14 in in IN 42759 152 15 terms term NNS 42759 152 16 of of IN 42759 152 17 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 152 18 . . . 42759 153 1 At at IN 42759 153 2 any any DT 42759 153 3 given give VBN 42759 153 4 time time NN 42759 153 5 and and CC 42759 153 6 place place NN 42759 153 7 , , , 42759 153 8 the the DT 42759 153 9 rent rent NN 42759 153 10 of of IN 42759 153 11 a a DT 42759 153 12 piece piece NN 42759 153 13 of of IN 42759 153 14 land land NN 42759 153 15 will will MD 42759 153 16 be be VB 42759 153 17 determined determine VBN 42759 153 18 by by IN 42759 153 19 the the DT 42759 153 20 supply supply NN 42759 153 21 of of IN 42759 153 22 that that DT 42759 153 23 kind kind NN 42759 153 24 of of IN 42759 153 25 land land NN 42759 153 26 relatively relatively RB 42759 153 27 to to IN 42759 153 28 the the DT 42759 153 29 demand demand NN 42759 153 30 for for IN 42759 153 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 153 32 . . . 42759 154 1 However however RB 42759 154 2 , , , 42759 154 3 the the DT 42759 154 4 demand demand NN 42759 154 5 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 154 6 will will MD 42759 154 7 be be VB 42759 154 8 regulated regulate VBN 42759 154 9 by by IN 42759 154 10 the the DT 42759 154 11 fertility fertility NN 42759 154 12 or or CC 42759 154 13 by by IN 42759 154 14 the the DT 42759 154 15 location location NN 42759 154 16 of of IN 42759 154 17 the the DT 42759 154 18 land land NN 42759 154 19 in in IN 42759 154 20 question question NN 42759 154 21 . . . 42759 155 1 Two two CD 42759 155 2 pieces piece NNS 42759 155 3 of of IN 42759 155 4 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 155 5 land land NN 42759 155 6 equally equally RB 42759 155 7 distant distant JJ 42759 155 8 from from IN 42759 155 9 a a DT 42759 155 10 city city NN 42759 155 11 , , , 42759 155 12 but but CC 42759 155 13 of of IN 42759 155 14 varying vary VBG 42759 155 15 fertility fertility NN 42759 155 16 , , , 42759 155 17 will will MD 42759 155 18 yield yield VB 42759 155 19 different different JJ 42759 155 20 rents rent NNS 42759 155 21 because because IN 42759 155 22 of of IN 42759 155 23 this this DT 42759 155 24 difference difference NN 42759 155 25 in in IN 42759 155 26 natural natural JJ 42759 155 27 productiveness productiveness NN 42759 155 28 . . . 42759 156 1 Two two CD 42759 156 2 pieces piece NNS 42759 156 3 of of IN 42759 156 4 ground ground NN 42759 156 5 of of IN 42759 156 6 equal equal JJ 42759 156 7 natural natural JJ 42759 156 8 adaptability adaptability NN 42759 156 9 for for IN 42759 156 10 building build VBG 42759 156 11 sites site NNS 42759 156 12 , , , 42759 156 13 but but CC 42759 156 14 at at IN 42759 156 15 unequal unequal JJ 42759 156 16 distances distance NNS 42759 156 17 from from IN 42759 156 18 the the DT 42759 156 19 centre centre NN 42759 156 20 of of IN 42759 156 21 a a DT 42759 156 22 city city NN 42759 156 23 , , , 42759 156 24 will will MD 42759 156 25 produce produce VB 42759 156 26 different different JJ 42759 156 27 rents rent NNS 42759 156 28 on on IN 42759 156 29 account account NN 42759 156 30 of of IN 42759 156 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 156 32 difference difference NN 42759 156 33 of of IN 42759 156 34 location location NN 42759 156 35 . . . 42759 157 1 The the DT 42759 157 2 absolute absolute JJ 42759 157 3 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 157 4 of of IN 42759 157 5 land land NN 42759 157 6 is be VBZ 42759 157 7 , , , 42759 157 8 of of IN 42759 157 9 course course NN 42759 157 10 , , , 42759 157 11 fixed fix VBN 42759 157 12 by by IN 42759 157 13 nature nature NN 42759 157 14 ; ; : 42759 157 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 157 16 relative relative JJ 42759 157 17 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 157 18 is be VBZ 42759 157 19 the the DT 42759 157 20 result result NN 42759 157 21 of of IN 42759 157 22 human human JJ 42759 157 23 activities activity NNS 42759 157 24 and and CC 42759 157 25 desires desire NNS 42759 157 26 . . . 42759 158 1 The the DT 42759 158 2 definition definition NN 42759 158 3 of of IN 42759 158 4 rent rent NN 42759 158 5 adopted adopt VBN 42759 158 6 in in IN 42759 158 7 these these DT 42759 158 8 pages page NNS 42759 158 9 , , , 42759 158 10 " " `` 42759 158 11 what what WP 42759 158 12 men man NNS 42759 158 13 are be VBP 42759 158 14 willing willing JJ 42759 158 15 to to TO 42759 158 16 pay pay VB 42759 158 17 for for IN 42759 158 18 the the DT 42759 158 19 use use NN 42759 158 20 of of IN 42759 158 21 land land NN 42759 158 22 , , , 42759 158 23 " " '' 42759 158 24 or or CC 42759 158 25 , , , 42759 158 26 " " '' 42759 158 27 what what WDT 42759 158 28 land land NN 42759 158 29 is be VBZ 42759 158 30 worth worth JJ 42759 158 31 for for IN 42759 158 32 use use NN 42759 158 33 , , , 42759 158 34 " " '' 42759 158 35 is be VBZ 42759 158 36 simpler simple JJR 42759 158 37 and and CC 42759 158 38 more more JJR 42759 158 39 concrete concrete JJ 42759 158 40 , , , 42759 158 41 though though IN 42759 158 42 possibly possibly RB 42759 158 43 less less RBR 42759 158 44 scientific scientific JJ 42759 158 45 , , , 42759 158 46 than than IN 42759 158 47 those those DT 42759 158 48 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 158 49 found find VBD 42759 158 50 in in IN 42759 158 51 manuals manual NNS 42759 158 52 of of IN 42759 158 53 economics economic NNS 42759 158 54 , , , 42759 158 55 namely namely RB 42759 158 56 : : : 42759 158 57 " " `` 42759 158 58 that that DT 42759 158 59 portion portion NN 42759 158 60 of of IN 42759 158 61 the the DT 42759 158 62 product product NN 42759 158 63 that that WDT 42759 158 64 remains remain VBZ 42759 158 65 after after IN 42759 158 66 all all PDT 42759 158 67 the the DT 42759 158 68 usual usual JJ 42759 158 69 expenditures expenditure NNS 42759 158 70 for for IN 42759 158 71 labour labour NN 42759 158 72 , , , 42759 158 73 capital capital NN 42759 158 74 , , , 42759 158 75 and and CC 42759 158 76 directive directive NN 42759 158 77 ability ability NN 42759 158 78 have have VBP 42759 158 79 been be VBN 42759 158 80 deducted deduct VBN 42759 158 81 ; ; : 42759 158 82 " " `` 42759 158 83 or or CC 42759 158 84 , , , 42759 158 85 " " '' 42759 158 86 the the DT 42759 158 87 surplus surplus NN 42759 158 88 which which WDT 42759 158 89 any any DT 42759 158 90 piece piece NN 42759 158 91 of of IN 42759 158 92 land land NN 42759 158 93 yields yield NNS 42759 158 94 over over IN 42759 158 95 the the DT 42759 158 96 poorest poor JJS 42759 158 97 land land NN 42759 158 98 devoted devote VBN 42759 158 99 to to IN 42759 158 100 the the DT 42759 158 101 same same JJ 42759 158 102 use use NN 42759 158 103 , , , 42759 158 104 when when WRB 42759 158 105 the the DT 42759 158 106 return return NN 42759 158 107 from from IN 42759 158 108 the the DT 42759 158 109 latter latter NN 42759 158 110 is be VBZ 42759 158 111 only only RB 42759 158 112 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 158 113 to to TO 42759 158 114 cover cover VB 42759 158 115 the the DT 42759 158 116 usual usual JJ 42759 158 117 expenses expense NNS 42759 158 118 of of IN 42759 158 119 production production NN 42759 158 120 . . . 42759 158 121 " " '' 42759 159 1 The the DT 42759 159 2 statement statement NN 42759 159 3 that that IN 42759 159 4 all all DT 42759 159 5 rent rent NN 42759 159 6 goes go VBZ 42759 159 7 to to IN 42759 159 8 the the DT 42759 159 9 landowner landowner NN 42759 159 10 supposes suppose NNS 42759 159 11 that that IN 42759 159 12 , , , 42759 159 13 in in IN 42759 159 14 the the DT 42759 159 15 case case NN 42759 159 16 of of IN 42759 159 17 hired hire VBN 42759 159 18 land land NN 42759 159 19 , , , 42759 159 20 the the DT 42759 159 21 tenant tenant NN 42759 159 22 pays pay VBZ 42759 159 23 the the DT 42759 159 24 full full JJ 42759 159 25 amount amount NN 42759 159 26 that that WDT 42759 159 27 would would MD 42759 159 28 result result VB 42759 159 29 from from IN 42759 159 30 competitive competitive JJ 42759 159 31 bidding bidding NN 42759 159 32 . . . 42759 160 1 Evidently evidently RB 42759 160 2 this this DT 42759 160 3 was be VBD 42759 160 4 not not RB 42759 160 5 the the DT 42759 160 6 case case NN 42759 160 7 under under IN 42759 160 8 the the DT 42759 160 9 feudal feudal JJ 42759 160 10 system system NN 42759 160 11 , , , 42759 160 12 when when WRB 42759 160 13 rents rent NNS 42759 160 14 were be VBD 42759 160 15 fixed fix VBN 42759 160 16 by by IN 42759 160 17 custom custom NN 42759 160 18 and and CC 42759 160 19 remained remain VBD 42759 160 20 stationary stationary JJ 42759 160 21 for for IN 42759 160 22 centuries century NNS 42759 160 23 . . . 42759 161 1 Even even RB 42759 161 2 to to TO 42759 161 3 - - HYPH 42759 161 4 day day NN 42759 161 5 , , , 42759 161 6 competition competition NN 42759 161 7 is be VBZ 42759 161 8 not not RB 42759 161 9 perfect perfect JJ 42759 161 10 , , , 42759 161 11 and and CC 42759 161 12 men man NNS 42759 161 13 often often RB 42759 161 14 obtain obtain VBP 42759 161 15 the the DT 42759 161 16 use use NN 42759 161 17 of of IN 42759 161 18 land land NN 42759 161 19 for for IN 42759 161 20 less less JJR 42759 161 21 than than IN 42759 161 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 161 23 or or CC 42759 161 24 others other NNS 42759 161 25 might may MD 42759 161 26 have have VB 42759 161 27 been be VBN 42759 161 28 willing willing JJ 42759 161 29 to to TO 42759 161 30 give give VB 42759 161 31 . . . 42759 162 1 But but CC 42759 162 2 the the DT 42759 162 3 statement statement NN 42759 162 4 in in IN 42759 162 5 question question NN 42759 162 6 does do VBZ 42759 162 7 describe describe VB 42759 162 8 what what WP 42759 162 9 tends tend VBZ 42759 162 10 to to TO 42759 162 11 happen happen VB 42759 162 12 in in IN 42759 162 13 a a DT 42759 162 14 system system NN 42759 162 15 of of IN 42759 162 16 competitive competitive JJ 42759 162 17 rents rent NNS 42759 162 18 . . . 42759 163 1 Before before IN 42759 163 2 discussing discuss VBG 42759 163 3 the the DT 42759 163 4 morality morality NN 42759 163 5 of of IN 42759 163 6 the the DT 42759 163 7 landowner landowner NN 42759 163 8 's 's POS 42759 163 9 income income NN 42759 163 10 , , , 42759 163 11 and and CC 42759 163 12 of of IN 42759 163 13 rent rent NN 42759 163 14 receiving receiving NN 42759 163 15 , , , 42759 163 16 we -PRON- PRP 42759 163 17 may may MD 42759 163 18 with with IN 42759 163 19 profit profit NN 42759 163 20 glance glance NN 42759 163 21 at at IN 42759 163 22 the the DT 42759 163 23 history history NN 42759 163 24 of of IN 42759 163 25 land land NN 42759 163 26 tenure tenure NN 42759 163 27 . . . 42759 164 1 Thus thus RB 42759 164 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 164 3 shall shall MD 42759 164 4 get get VB 42759 164 5 some some DT 42759 164 6 idea idea NN 42759 164 7 , , , 42759 164 8 first first RB 42759 164 9 , , , 42759 164 10 of of IN 42759 164 11 the the DT 42759 164 12 antiquity antiquity NN 42759 164 13 of of IN 42759 164 14 the the DT 42759 164 15 present present JJ 42759 164 16 system system NN 42759 164 17 , , , 42759 164 18 and and CC 42759 164 19 , , , 42759 164 20 second second JJ 42759 164 21 , , , 42759 164 22 of of IN 42759 164 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 164 24 effects effect NNS 42759 164 25 upon upon IN 42759 164 26 individual individual JJ 42759 164 27 and and CC 42759 164 28 social social JJ 42759 164 29 welfare welfare NN 42759 164 30 . . . 42759 165 1 Both both CC 42759 165 2 these these DT 42759 165 3 considerations consideration NNS 42759 165 4 have have VBP 42759 165 5 an an DT 42759 165 6 important important JJ 42759 165 7 bearing bearing NN 42759 165 8 upon upon IN 42759 165 9 the the DT 42759 165 10 moral moral JJ 42759 165 11 problem problem NN 42759 165 12 ; ; : 42759 165 13 for for IN 42759 165 14 length length NN 42759 165 15 of of IN 42759 165 16 existence existence NN 42759 165 17 creates create VBZ 42759 165 18 a a DT 42759 165 19 presumption presumption NN 42759 165 20 in in IN 42759 165 21 favour favour NN 42759 165 22 of of IN 42759 165 23 the the DT 42759 165 24 social social NN 42759 165 25 , , , 42759 165 26 and and CC 42759 165 27 therefore therefore RB 42759 165 28 the the DT 42759 165 29 moral moral JJ 42759 165 30 , , , 42759 165 31 value value NN 42759 165 32 of of IN 42759 165 33 any any DT 42759 165 34 institution institution NN 42759 165 35 ; ; : 42759 165 36 and and CC 42759 165 37 past past JJ 42759 165 38 experience experience NN 42759 165 39 is be VBZ 42759 165 40 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 165 41 chief chief JJ 42759 165 42 means mean NNS 42759 165 43 of of IN 42759 165 44 determining determine VBG 42759 165 45 whether whether IN 42759 165 46 an an DT 42759 165 47 institution institution NN 42759 165 48 is be VBZ 42759 165 49 likely likely JJ 42759 165 50 to to TO 42759 165 51 be be VB 42759 165 52 socially socially RB 42759 165 53 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 165 54 , , , 42759 165 55 and and CC 42759 165 56 therefore therefore RB 42759 165 57 morally morally RB 42759 165 58 right right RB 42759 165 59 , , , 42759 165 60 in in IN 42759 165 61 the the DT 42759 165 62 future future NN 42759 165 63 . . . 42759 166 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 42759 166 2 II II NNP 42759 166 3 LANDOWNERSHIP LANDOWNERSHIP NNP 42759 166 4 IN in IN 42759 166 5 HISTORY history NN 42759 166 6 Thirty thirty CD 42759 166 7 or or CC 42759 166 8 thirty thirty CD 42759 166 9 - - HYPH 42759 166 10 five five CD 42759 166 11 years year NNS 42759 166 12 ago ago RB 42759 166 13 , , , 42759 166 14 the the DT 42759 166 15 majority majority NN 42759 166 16 of of IN 42759 166 17 economic economic JJ 42759 166 18 historians historians NNPS 42759 166 19 seemed seem VBD 42759 166 20 to to TO 42759 166 21 accept accept VB 42759 166 22 the the DT 42759 166 23 theory theory NN 42759 166 24 that that IN 42759 166 25 land land NN 42759 166 26 was be VBD 42759 166 27 originally originally RB 42759 166 28 owned own VBN 42759 166 29 in in IN 42759 166 30 common common JJ 42759 166 31 . . . 42759 167 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 167 2 1 1 LS 42759 167 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 167 4 They -PRON- PRP 42759 167 5 held hold VBD 42759 167 6 that that IN 42759 167 7 in in IN 42759 167 8 the the DT 42759 167 9 beginning beginning NN 42759 167 10 the the DT 42759 167 11 community community NN 42759 167 12 , , , 42759 167 13 usually usually RB 42759 167 14 a a DT 42759 167 15 village village NN 42759 167 16 community community NN 42759 167 17 , , , 42759 167 18 was be VBD 42759 167 19 the the DT 42759 167 20 landowner landowner NN 42759 167 21 ; ; : 42759 167 22 that that IN 42759 167 23 the the DT 42759 167 24 community community NN 42759 167 25 either either CC 42759 167 26 cultivated cultivate VBD 42759 167 27 the the DT 42759 167 28 land land NN 42759 167 29 as as IN 42759 167 30 a a DT 42759 167 31 corporation corporation NN 42759 167 32 , , , 42759 167 33 and and CC 42759 167 34 distributed distribute VBD 42759 167 35 the the DT 42759 167 36 product product NN 42759 167 37 among among IN 42759 167 38 the the DT 42759 167 39 individual individual JJ 42759 167 40 members member NNS 42759 167 41 , , , 42759 167 42 or or CC 42759 167 43 periodically periodically RB 42759 167 44 divided divide VBD 42759 167 45 the the DT 42759 167 46 land land NN 42759 167 47 among among IN 42759 167 48 the the DT 42759 167 49 social social JJ 42759 167 50 units unit NNS 42759 167 51 , , , 42759 167 52 and and CC 42759 167 53 permitted permit VBD 42759 167 54 the the DT 42759 167 55 latter latter JJ 42759 167 56 to to TO 42759 167 57 cultivate cultivate VB 42759 167 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 167 59 allotments allotment NNS 42759 167 60 separately separately RB 42759 167 61 . . . 42759 168 1 The the DT 42759 168 2 second second JJ 42759 168 3 of of IN 42759 168 4 these these DT 42759 168 5 forms form NNS 42759 168 6 of of IN 42759 168 7 tenure tenure NN 42759 168 8 was be VBD 42759 168 9 the the DT 42759 168 10 more more RBR 42759 168 11 general general JJ 42759 168 12 . . . 42759 169 1 The the DT 42759 169 2 primitive primitive JJ 42759 169 3 time time NN 42759 169 4 to to TO 42759 169 5 which which WDT 42759 169 6 the the DT 42759 169 7 theory theory NN 42759 169 8 referred refer VBD 42759 169 9 was be VBD 42759 169 10 not not RB 42759 169 11 the the DT 42759 169 12 period period NN 42759 169 13 when when WRB 42759 169 14 men man NNS 42759 169 15 got get VBD 42759 169 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 169 17 living living NN 42759 169 18 by by IN 42759 169 19 hunting hunting NN 42759 169 20 and and CC 42759 169 21 fishing fishing NN 42759 169 22 , , , 42759 169 23 or or CC 42759 169 24 by by IN 42759 169 25 rearing rear VBG 42759 169 26 herds herd NNS 42759 169 27 , , , 42759 169 28 but but CC 42759 169 29 the the DT 42759 169 30 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 169 31 stage stage NN 42759 169 32 of of IN 42759 169 33 economic economic JJ 42759 169 34 development development NN 42759 169 35 , , , 42759 169 36 when when WRB 42759 169 37 life life NN 42759 169 38 had have VBD 42759 169 39 become become VBN 42759 169 40 settled settle VBN 42759 169 41 . . . 42759 170 1 Of of IN 42759 170 2 the the DT 42759 170 3 arguments argument NNS 42759 170 4 upon upon IN 42759 170 5 which which WDT 42759 170 6 the the DT 42759 170 7 theory theory NN 42759 170 8 was be VBD 42759 170 9 based base VBN 42759 170 10 , , , 42759 170 11 some some DT 42759 170 12 consisted consist VBD 42759 170 13 of of IN 42759 170 14 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 42759 170 15 statements statement NNS 42759 170 16 by by IN 42759 170 17 ancient ancient JJ 42759 170 18 writers writer NNS 42759 170 19 , , , 42759 170 20 such such JJ 42759 170 21 as as IN 42759 170 22 Plato Plato NNP 42759 170 23 , , , 42759 170 24 Cæsar Cæsar NNP 42759 170 25 , , , 42759 170 26 and and CC 42759 170 27 Tacitus Tacitus NNP 42759 170 28 , , , 42759 170 29 and and CC 42759 170 30 others other NNS 42759 170 31 were be VBD 42759 170 32 merely merely RB 42759 170 33 inferences inference NNS 42759 170 34 drawn draw VBN 42759 170 35 from from IN 42759 170 36 the the DT 42759 170 37 existence existence NN 42759 170 38 of of IN 42759 170 39 certain certain JJ 42759 170 40 agrarian agrarian JJ 42759 170 41 institutions institution NNS 42759 170 42 : : : 42759 170 43 family family NN 42759 170 44 ownership ownership NN 42759 170 45 of of IN 42759 170 46 land land NN 42759 170 47 ; ; , 42759 170 48 common common JJ 42759 170 49 pasture pasture NN 42759 170 50 lands land NNS 42759 170 51 and and CC 42759 170 52 woodlands woodland NNS 42759 170 53 ; ; : 42759 170 54 periodical periodical JJ 42759 170 55 distribution distribution NN 42759 170 56 of of IN 42759 170 57 land land NN 42759 170 58 among among IN 42759 170 59 the the DT 42759 170 60 cultivators cultivator NNS 42759 170 61 , , , 42759 170 62 as as IN 42759 170 63 in in IN 42759 170 64 the the DT 42759 170 65 German German NNP 42759 170 66 Mark Mark NNP 42759 170 67 , , , 42759 170 68 the the DT 42759 170 69 Russian russian JJ 42759 170 70 Mir Mir NNP 42759 170 71 , , , 42759 170 72 the the DT 42759 170 73 Slavonic Slavonic NNP 42759 170 74 Zadruga Zadruga NNP 42759 170 75 , , , 42759 170 76 and and CC 42759 170 77 the the DT 42759 170 78 Javanese Javanese NNP 42759 170 79 Dessa Dessa NNP 42759 170 80 . . . 42759 171 1 All all PDT 42759 171 2 these these DT 42759 171 3 practices practice NNS 42759 171 4 have have VBP 42759 171 5 been be VBN 42759 171 6 interpreted interpret VBN 42759 171 7 as as IN 42759 171 8 " " `` 42759 171 9 survivals survival NNS 42759 171 10 " " '' 42759 171 11 of of IN 42759 171 12 primitive primitive JJ 42759 171 13 common common JJ 42759 171 14 ownership ownership NN 42759 171 15 . . . 42759 172 1 Only only RB 42759 172 2 on on IN 42759 172 3 this this DT 42759 172 4 hypothesis hypothesis NN 42759 172 5 , , , 42759 172 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 172 7 is be VBZ 42759 172 8 argued argue VBN 42759 172 9 , , , 42759 172 10 can can MD 42759 172 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 172 12 be be VB 42759 172 13 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 42759 172 14 explained explain VBN 42759 172 15 . . . 42759 173 1 More more RBR 42759 173 2 recent recent JJ 42759 173 3 writers writer NNS 42759 173 4 have have VBP 42759 173 5 subjected subject VBN 42759 173 6 the the DT 42759 173 7 various various JJ 42759 173 8 arguments argument NNS 42759 173 9 for for IN 42759 173 10 this this DT 42759 173 11 theory theory NN 42759 173 12 to to IN 42759 173 13 a a DT 42759 173 14 searching search VBG 42759 173 15 criticism criticism NN 42759 173 16 . . . 42759 174 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 174 2 2 2 LS 42759 174 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 174 4 To to NN 42759 174 5 - - HYPH 42759 174 6 day day NN 42759 174 7 the the DT 42759 174 8 great great JJ 42759 174 9 majority majority NN 42759 174 10 of of IN 42759 174 11 scholars scholar NNS 42759 174 12 would would MD 42759 174 13 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 174 14 accept accept VB 42759 174 15 the the DT 42759 174 16 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 174 17 of of IN 42759 174 18 Fustel Fustel NNP 42759 174 19 de de NNP 42759 174 20 Coulanges Coulanges NNP 42759 174 21 , , , 42759 174 22 that that IN 42759 174 23 the the DT 42759 174 24 arguments argument NNS 42759 174 25 and and CC 42759 174 26 evidence evidence NN 42759 174 27 are be VBP 42759 174 28 not not RB 42759 174 29 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 174 30 to to TO 42759 174 31 prove prove VB 42759 174 32 that that DT 42759 174 33 in in IN 42759 174 34 the the DT 42759 174 35 earliest early JJS 42759 174 36 stages stage NNS 42759 174 37 of of IN 42759 174 38 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 174 39 life life NN 42759 174 40 land land NN 42759 174 41 was be VBD 42759 174 42 held hold VBN 42759 174 43 in in IN 42759 174 44 common common JJ 42759 174 45 ; ; : 42759 174 46 and and CC 42759 174 47 a a DT 42759 174 48 majority majority NN 42759 174 49 would would MD 42759 174 50 probably probably RB 42759 174 51 take take VB 42759 174 52 the the DT 42759 174 53 more more RBR 42759 174 54 positive positive JJ 42759 174 55 ground ground NN 42759 174 56 that that IN 42759 174 57 common common JJ 42759 174 58 ownership ownership NN 42759 174 59 in in IN 42759 174 60 the the DT 42759 174 61 sense sense NN 42759 174 62 of of IN 42759 174 63 communal communal JJ 42759 174 64 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 174 65 and and CC 42759 174 66 distribution distribution NN 42759 174 67 , , , 42759 174 68 never never RB 42759 174 69 existed exist VBD 42759 174 70 for for IN 42759 174 71 any any DT 42759 174 72 considerable considerable JJ 42759 174 73 length length NN 42759 174 74 of of IN 42759 174 75 time time NN 42759 174 76 among among IN 42759 174 77 any any DT 42759 174 78 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 174 79 people people NNS 42759 174 80 . . . 42759 175 1 The the DT 42759 175 2 present present JJ 42759 175 3 authoritative authoritative JJ 42759 175 4 opinion opinion NN 42759 175 5 on on IN 42759 175 6 the the DT 42759 175 7 subject subject NN 42759 175 8 is be VBZ 42759 175 9 thus thus RB 42759 175 10 summarized summarize VBN 42759 175 11 by by IN 42759 175 12 Professor Professor NNP 42759 175 13 Ashley Ashley NNP 42759 175 14 : : : 42759 175 15 " " `` 42759 175 16 From from IN 42759 175 17 the the DT 42759 175 18 earliest early JJS 42759 175 19 historical historical JJ 42759 175 20 times time NNS 42759 175 21 , , , 42759 175 22 in in IN 42759 175 23 Gaul Gaul NNP 42759 175 24 and and CC 42759 175 25 Germany Germany NNP 42759 175 26 , , , 42759 175 27 very very RB 42759 175 28 much much JJ 42759 175 29 land land NN 42759 175 30 was be VBD 42759 175 31 owned own VBN 42759 175 32 individually individually RB 42759 175 33 , , , 42759 175 34 and and CC 42759 175 35 wealth wealth NN 42759 175 36 on on IN 42759 175 37 one one CD 42759 175 38 side side NN 42759 175 39 and and CC 42759 175 40 slavery slavery NN 42759 175 41 on on IN 42759 175 42 the the DT 42759 175 43 other other JJ 42759 175 44 were be VBD 42759 175 45 always always RB 42759 175 46 very very RB 42759 175 47 important important JJ 42759 175 48 factors factor NNS 42759 175 49 in in IN 42759 175 50 the the DT 42759 175 51 situation situation NN 42759 175 52 . . . 42759 176 1 " " `` 42759 176 2 Even even RB 42759 176 3 in in IN 42759 176 4 Germany Germany NNP 42759 176 5 , , , 42759 176 6 communal communal JJ 42759 176 7 ownership ownership NN 42759 176 8 of of IN 42759 176 9 land land NN 42759 176 10 was be VBD 42759 176 11 never never RB 42759 176 12 a a DT 42759 176 13 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 176 14 or or CC 42759 176 15 generally generally RB 42759 176 16 pervasive pervasive JJ 42759 176 17 social social JJ 42759 176 18 institution institution NN 42759 176 19 ; ; : 42759 176 20 there there EX 42759 176 21 was be VBD 42759 176 22 something something NN 42759 176 23 very very RB 42759 176 24 much much RB 42759 176 25 like like IN 42759 176 26 large large JJ 42759 176 27 private private JJ 42759 176 28 estates estate NNS 42759 176 29 , , , 42759 176 30 worked work VBN 42759 176 31 by by IN 42759 176 32 dependents dependent NNS 42759 176 33 and and CC 42759 176 34 slaves slave NNS 42759 176 35 , , , 42759 176 36 from from IN 42759 176 37 the the DT 42759 176 38 very very RB 42759 176 39 earliest early JJS 42759 176 40 days day NNS 42759 176 41 of of IN 42759 176 42 Teutonic Teutonic NNP 42759 176 43 Settlement Settlement NNP 42759 176 44 . . . 42759 177 1 " " `` 42759 177 2 As as IN 42759 177 3 to to IN 42759 177 4 England England NNP 42759 177 5 , , , 42759 177 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 177 7 is be VBZ 42759 177 8 highly highly RB 42759 177 9 probable probable JJ 42759 177 10 that that IN 42759 177 11 we -PRON- PRP 42759 177 12 shall shall MD 42759 177 13 not not RB 42759 177 14 find find VB 42759 177 15 anything anything NN 42759 177 16 that that WDT 42759 177 17 can can MD 42759 177 18 fairly fairly RB 42759 177 19 be be VB 42759 177 20 called call VBN 42759 177 21 a a DT 42759 177 22 general general JJ 42759 177 23 communal communal JJ 42759 177 24 system system NN 42759 177 25 of of IN 42759 177 26 landowning landowning NN 42759 177 27 , , , 42759 177 28 combined combine VBN 42759 177 29 with with IN 42759 177 30 a a DT 42759 177 31 substantial substantial JJ 42759 177 32 equality equality NN 42759 177 33 among among IN 42759 177 34 the the DT 42759 177 35 majority majority NN 42759 177 36 of of IN 42759 177 37 the the DT 42759 177 38 people people NNS 42759 177 39 , , , 42759 177 40 under under IN 42759 177 41 conditions condition NNS 42759 177 42 of of IN 42759 177 43 settled settle VBN 42759 177 44 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 177 45 . . . 42759 178 1 To to TO 42759 178 2 find find VB 42759 178 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 178 4 in in IN 42759 178 5 any any DT 42759 178 6 sense sense NN 42759 178 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 178 8 shall shall MD 42759 178 9 have have VB 42759 178 10 to to TO 42759 178 11 go go VB 42759 178 12 back back RB 42759 178 13 to to IN 42759 178 14 an an DT 42759 178 15 earlier early JJR 42759 178 16 and and CC 42759 178 17 ' ' `` 42759 178 18 tribal tribal JJ 42759 178 19 ' ' '' 42759 178 20 condition condition NN 42759 178 21 , , , 42759 178 22 if if IN 42759 178 23 , , , 42759 178 24 indeed indeed RB 42759 178 25 , , , 42759 178 26 we -PRON- PRP 42759 178 27 shall shall MD 42759 178 28 find find VB 42759 178 29 it -PRON- PRP 42759 178 30 there there RB 42759 178 31 ! ! . 42759 179 1 " " `` 42759 179 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 179 3 3 3 CD 42759 179 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 179 5 _ _ NNP 42759 179 6 No No NNP 42759 179 7 Private Private NNP 42759 179 8 Ownership Ownership NNP 42759 179 9 in in IN 42759 179 10 Pre Pre NNP 42759 179 11 - - NNP 42759 179 12 Agricultural Agricultural NNP 42759 179 13 Conditions Conditions NNPS 42759 179 14 _ _ NNP 42759 179 15 Whenever Whenever NNP 42759 179 16 and and CC 42759 179 17 wherever wherever WRB 42759 179 18 men man NNS 42759 179 19 got get VBD 42759 179 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 179 21 living living NN 42759 179 22 by by IN 42759 179 23 hunting hunting NN 42759 179 24 and and CC 42759 179 25 fishing fishing NN 42759 179 26 , , , 42759 179 27 there there EX 42759 179 28 was be VBD 42759 179 29 no no DT 42759 179 30 inducement inducement NN 42759 179 31 to to TO 42759 179 32 own own JJ 42759 179 33 land land NN 42759 179 34 privately privately RB 42759 179 35 , , , 42759 179 36 except except IN 42759 179 37 possibly possibly RB 42759 179 38 those those DT 42759 179 39 portions portion NNS 42759 179 40 upon upon IN 42759 179 41 which which WDT 42759 179 42 they -PRON- PRP 42759 179 43 built build VBD 42759 179 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 179 45 huts hut NNS 42759 179 46 or or CC 42759 179 47 houses house NNS 42759 179 48 . . . 42759 180 1 " " `` 42759 180 2 Until until IN 42759 180 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 180 4 become become VBP 42759 180 5 more more RBR 42759 180 6 or or CC 42759 180 7 less less RBR 42759 180 8 an an DT 42759 180 9 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 180 10 people people NNS 42759 180 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 180 12 are be VBP 42759 180 13 usually usually RB 42759 180 14 hunters hunter NNS 42759 180 15 or or CC 42759 180 16 fishermen fisherman NNS 42759 180 17 or or CC 42759 180 18 both both DT 42759 180 19 , , , 42759 180 20 and and CC 42759 180 21 possibly possibly RB 42759 180 22 also also RB 42759 180 23 to to IN 42759 180 24 a a DT 42759 180 25 limited limited JJ 42759 180 26 extent extent NN 42759 180 27 keepers keeper NNS 42759 180 28 of of IN 42759 180 29 sheep sheep NNS 42759 180 30 and and CC 42759 180 31 cattle cattle NNS 42759 180 32 . . . 42759 181 1 Population population NN 42759 181 2 is be VBZ 42759 181 3 then then RB 42759 181 4 sparse sparse JJ 42759 181 5 and and CC 42759 181 6 unoccupied unoccupied JJ 42759 181 7 territory territory NN 42759 181 8 is be VBZ 42759 181 9 plentiful plentiful JJ 42759 181 10 , , , 42759 181 11 and and CC 42759 181 12 questions question NNS 42759 181 13 of of IN 42759 181 14 the the DT 42759 181 15 ownership ownership NN 42759 181 16 of of IN 42759 181 17 particular particular JJ 42759 181 18 tracts tract NNS 42759 181 19 of of IN 42759 181 20 land land NN 42759 181 21 do do VBP 42759 181 22 not not RB 42759 181 23 concern concern VB 42759 181 24 them -PRON- PRP 42759 181 25 . . . 42759 182 1 " " `` 42759 182 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 182 3 4 4 CD 42759 182 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 182 5 In in IN 42759 182 6 any any DT 42759 182 7 region region NN 42759 182 8 occupied occupy VBN 42759 182 9 by by IN 42759 182 10 a a DT 42759 182 11 group group NN 42759 182 12 or or CC 42759 182 13 tribe tribe NN 42759 182 14 , , , 42759 182 15 all all DT 42759 182 16 portions portion NNS 42759 182 17 of of IN 42759 182 18 the the DT 42759 182 19 land land NN 42759 182 20 and and CC 42759 182 21 the the DT 42759 182 22 water water NN 42759 182 23 were be VBD 42759 182 24 about about IN 42759 182 25 equally equally RB 42759 182 26 productive productive JJ 42759 182 27 of of IN 42759 182 28 game game NN 42759 182 29 and and CC 42759 182 30 fish fish NN 42759 182 31 ; ; : 42759 182 32 the the DT 42759 182 33 amount amount NN 42759 182 34 obtainable obtainable JJ 42759 182 35 by by IN 42759 182 36 any any DT 42759 182 37 individual individual NN 42759 182 38 had have VBD 42759 182 39 no no DT 42759 182 40 relation relation NN 42759 182 41 to to IN 42759 182 42 labour labour NN 42759 182 43 on on IN 42759 182 44 any any DT 42759 182 45 particular particular JJ 42759 182 46 piece piece NN 42759 182 47 of of IN 42759 182 48 soil soil NN 42759 182 49 ; ; : 42759 182 50 and and CC 42759 182 51 it -PRON- PRP 42759 182 52 was be VBD 42759 182 53 much much RB 42759 182 54 easier easy JJR 42759 182 55 for for IN 42759 182 56 each each DT 42759 182 57 to to TO 42759 182 58 range range VB 42759 182 59 over over RP 42759 182 60 the the DT 42759 182 61 whole whole JJ 42759 182 62 region region NN 42759 182 63 in in IN 42759 182 64 common common JJ 42759 182 65 with with IN 42759 182 66 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 182 67 fellows fellow NNS 42759 182 68 than than IN 42759 182 69 to to TO 42759 182 70 mark mark VB 42759 182 71 off off RP 42759 182 72 a a DT 42759 182 73 definite definite JJ 42759 182 74 section section NN 42759 182 75 upon upon IN 42759 182 76 which which WDT 42759 182 77 he -PRON- PRP 42759 182 78 would would MD 42759 182 79 not not RB 42759 182 80 permit permit VB 42759 182 81 others other NNS 42759 182 82 to to TO 42759 182 83 come come VB 42759 182 84 , , , 42759 182 85 but but CC 42759 182 86 beyond beyond IN 42759 182 87 which which WDT 42759 182 88 he -PRON- PRP 42759 182 89 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 182 90 would would MD 42759 182 91 not not RB 42759 182 92 be be VB 42759 182 93 permitted permit VBN 42759 182 94 to to TO 42759 182 95 go go VB 42759 182 96 . . . 42759 183 1 In in IN 42759 183 2 such such JJ 42759 183 3 conditions condition NNS 42759 183 4 private private JJ 42759 183 5 ownership ownership NN 42759 183 6 of of IN 42759 183 7 land land NN 42759 183 8 would would MD 42759 183 9 have have VB 42759 183 10 been be VBN 42759 183 11 folly folly JJ 42759 183 12 . . . 42759 184 1 Tribal Tribal NNP 42759 184 2 or or CC 42759 184 3 group group NN 42759 184 4 ownership ownership NN 42759 184 5 was be VBD 42759 184 6 , , , 42759 184 7 however however RB 42759 184 8 , , , 42759 184 9 in in IN 42759 184 10 vogue vogue NN 42759 184 11 , , , 42759 184 12 especially especially RB 42759 184 13 among among IN 42759 184 14 those those DT 42759 184 15 groups group NNS 42759 184 16 that that WDT 42759 184 17 were be VBD 42759 184 18 in in IN 42759 184 19 control control NN 42759 184 20 of of IN 42759 184 21 the the DT 42759 184 22 better well JJR 42759 184 23 grounds ground NNS 42759 184 24 or or CC 42759 184 25 streams stream NNS 42759 184 26 . . . 42759 185 1 Even even RB 42759 185 2 this this DT 42759 185 3 form form NN 42759 185 4 of of IN 42759 185 5 proprietorship proprietorship NN 42759 185 6 was be VBD 42759 185 7 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 185 8 unstable unstable JJ 42759 185 9 , , , 42759 185 10 since since IN 42759 185 11 the the DT 42759 185 12 people people NNS 42759 185 13 were be VBD 42759 185 14 to to IN 42759 185 15 a a DT 42759 185 16 considerable considerable JJ 42759 185 17 degree degree NN 42759 185 18 nomadic nomadic JJ 42759 185 19 , , , 42759 185 20 and and CC 42759 185 21 were be VBD 42759 185 22 willing willing JJ 42759 185 23 to to TO 42759 185 24 abandon abandon VB 42759 185 25 present present JJ 42759 185 26 possessions possession NNS 42759 185 27 whenever whenever WRB 42759 185 28 there there EX 42759 185 29 was be VBD 42759 185 30 a a DT 42759 185 31 prospect prospect NN 42759 185 32 of of IN 42759 185 33 obtaining obtain VBG 42759 185 34 better well JJR 42759 185 35 ones one NNS 42759 185 36 elsewhere elsewhere RB 42759 185 37 . . . 42759 186 1 Among among IN 42759 186 2 men man NNS 42759 186 3 who who WP 42759 186 4 got get VBD 42759 186 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 186 6 living living NN 42759 186 7 by by IN 42759 186 8 rearing rear VBG 42759 186 9 herds herd NNS 42759 186 10 , , , 42759 186 11 the the DT 42759 186 12 inducement inducement NN 42759 186 13 to to TO 42759 186 14 hold hold VB 42759 186 15 land land NN 42759 186 16 in in IN 42759 186 17 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 186 18 private private JJ 42759 186 19 control control NN 42759 186 20 would would MD 42759 186 21 be be VB 42759 186 22 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 186 23 stronger strong JJR 42759 186 24 . . . 42759 187 1 The the DT 42759 187 2 better well JJR 42759 187 3 grazing grazing NN 42759 187 4 tracts tract NNS 42759 187 5 would would MD 42759 187 6 be be VB 42759 187 7 coveted covet VBN 42759 187 8 by by IN 42759 187 9 many many JJ 42759 187 10 different different JJ 42759 187 11 persons person NNS 42759 187 12 , , , 42759 187 13 especially especially RB 42759 187 14 in in IN 42759 187 15 the the DT 42759 187 16 more more RBR 42759 187 17 populous populous JJ 42759 187 18 communities community NNS 42759 187 19 . . . 42759 188 1 And and CC 42759 188 2 there there EX 42759 188 3 would would MD 42759 188 4 always always RB 42759 188 5 be be VB 42759 188 6 the the DT 42759 188 7 possibility possibility NN 42759 188 8 of of IN 42759 188 9 confusion confusion NN 42759 188 10 among among IN 42759 188 11 the the DT 42759 188 12 different different JJ 42759 188 13 herds herd NNS 42759 188 14 , , , 42759 188 15 and and CC 42759 188 16 contention contention NN 42759 188 17 among among IN 42759 188 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 188 19 owners owner NNS 42759 188 20 . . . 42759 189 1 In in IN 42759 189 2 such such JJ 42759 189 3 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 189 4 the the DT 42759 189 5 advantages advantage NNS 42759 189 6 of of IN 42759 189 7 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 189 8 control control NN 42759 189 9 would would MD 42759 189 10 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 189 11 outweigh outweigh VB 42759 189 12 the the DT 42759 189 13 benefits benefit NNS 42759 189 14 of of IN 42759 189 15 common common JJ 42759 189 16 use use NN 42759 189 17 and and CC 42759 189 18 ownership ownership NN 42759 189 19 . . . 42759 190 1 In in IN 42759 190 2 the the DT 42759 190 3 thirteenth thirteenth JJ 42759 190 4 chapter chapter NN 42759 190 5 of of IN 42759 190 6 Genesis Genesis NNP 42759 190 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 190 8 are be VBP 42759 190 9 told tell VBN 42759 190 10 that that IN 42759 190 11 , , , 42759 190 12 owing owe VBG 42759 190 13 to to IN 42759 190 14 strife strife NN 42759 190 15 between between IN 42759 190 16 the the DT 42759 190 17 herdsmen herdsman NNS 42759 190 18 of of IN 42759 190 19 Abram Abram NNP 42759 190 20 and and CC 42759 190 21 Lot Lot NNP 42759 190 22 , , , 42759 190 23 the the DT 42759 190 24 brothers brother NNS 42759 190 25 separated separate VBD 42759 190 26 , , , 42759 190 27 and and CC 42759 190 28 agreed agree VBD 42759 190 29 to to TO 42759 190 30 become become VB 42759 190 31 the the DT 42759 190 32 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 190 33 possessors possessor NNS 42759 190 34 of of IN 42759 190 35 different different JJ 42759 190 36 territories territory NNS 42759 190 37 . . . 42759 191 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 191 2 , , , 42759 191 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 191 4 is be VBZ 42759 191 5 probable probable JJ 42759 191 6 that that IN 42759 191 7 tribal tribal JJ 42759 191 8 ownership ownership NN 42759 191 9 was be VBD 42759 191 10 the the DT 42759 191 11 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 191 12 form form NN 42759 191 13 of of IN 42759 191 14 land land NN 42759 191 15 tenure tenure NN 42759 191 16 so so RB 42759 191 17 long long RB 42759 191 18 as as IN 42759 191 19 people people NNS 42759 191 20 remained remain VBD 42759 191 21 mainly mainly RB 42759 191 22 in in IN 42759 191 23 pastoral pastoral JJ 42759 191 24 conditions condition NNS 42759 191 25 . . . 42759 192 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 192 2 is be VBZ 42759 192 3 likewise likewise RB 42759 192 4 probable probable JJ 42759 192 5 that that IN 42759 192 6 the the DT 42759 192 7 same same JJ 42759 192 8 system system NN 42759 192 9 continued continue VBD 42759 192 10 in in IN 42759 192 11 many many JJ 42759 192 12 cases case NNS 42759 192 13 for for IN 42759 192 14 some some DT 42759 192 15 time time NN 42759 192 16 after after IN 42759 192 17 men man NNS 42759 192 18 began begin VBD 42759 192 19 to to TO 42759 192 20 cultivate cultivate VB 42759 192 21 the the DT 42759 192 22 soil soil NN 42759 192 23 . . . 42759 193 1 At at RB 42759 193 2 least least RBS 42759 193 3 , , , 42759 193 4 this this DT 42759 193 5 would would MD 42759 193 6 seem seem VB 42759 193 7 to to TO 42759 193 8 have have VB 42759 193 9 been be VBN 42759 193 10 the the DT 42759 193 11 natural natural JJ 42759 193 12 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 193 13 while while IN 42759 193 14 land land NN 42759 193 15 was be VBD 42759 193 16 plentiful plentiful JJ 42759 193 17 , , , 42759 193 18 and and CC 42759 193 19 the the DT 42759 193 20 methods method NNS 42759 193 21 of of IN 42759 193 22 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 193 23 crude crude NN 42759 193 24 and and CC 42759 193 25 soil soil NN 42759 193 26 - - HYPH 42759 193 27 exhausting exhaust VBG 42759 193 28 . . . 42759 194 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 194 2 would would MD 42759 194 3 be be VB 42759 194 4 more more RBR 42759 194 5 profitable profitable JJ 42759 194 6 to to TO 42759 194 7 take take VB 42759 194 8 up up RP 42759 194 9 new new JJ 42759 194 10 lands land NNS 42759 194 11 than than IN 42759 194 12 to to TO 42759 194 13 continue continue VB 42759 194 14 upon upon IN 42759 194 15 the the DT 42759 194 16 old old JJ 42759 194 17 . . . 42759 195 1 Within within IN 42759 195 2 historical historical JJ 42759 195 3 times time NNS 42759 195 4 this this DT 42759 195 5 system system NN 42759 195 6 prevailed prevail VBD 42759 195 7 among among IN 42759 195 8 the the DT 42759 195 9 ancient ancient JJ 42759 195 10 Germans Germans NNPS 42759 195 11 , , , 42759 195 12 some some DT 42759 195 13 of of IN 42759 195 14 the the DT 42759 195 15 tribes tribe NNS 42759 195 16 of of IN 42759 195 17 New New NNP 42759 195 18 Zealand Zealand NNP 42759 195 19 , , , 42759 195 20 and and CC 42759 195 21 some some DT 42759 195 22 of of IN 42759 195 23 the the DT 42759 195 24 tribes tribe NNS 42759 195 25 of of IN 42759 195 26 Western Western NNP 42759 195 27 Africa Africa NNP 42759 195 28 . . . 42759 196 1 Where where WRB 42759 196 2 land land NN 42759 196 3 was be VBD 42759 196 4 not not RB 42759 196 5 so so RB 42759 196 6 plentiful plentiful JJ 42759 196 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 196 8 was be VBD 42759 196 9 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 196 10 redistributed redistribute VBN 42759 196 11 among among IN 42759 196 12 individuals individual NNS 42759 196 13 or or CC 42759 196 14 heads head NNS 42759 196 15 of of IN 42759 196 16 families family NNS 42759 196 17 , , , 42759 196 18 as as RB 42759 196 19 often often RB 42759 196 20 as as IN 42759 196 21 a a DT 42759 196 22 death death NN 42759 196 23 occurred occur VBD 42759 196 24 or or CC 42759 196 25 a a DT 42759 196 26 new new JJ 42759 196 27 member member NN 42759 196 28 arrived arrive VBD 42759 196 29 in in IN 42759 196 30 the the DT 42759 196 31 community community NN 42759 196 32 . . . 42759 197 1 Some some DT 42759 197 2 of of IN 42759 197 3 the the DT 42759 197 4 tribes tribe NNS 42759 197 5 and and CC 42759 197 6 peoples people NNS 42759 197 7 who who WP 42759 197 8 observed observe VBD 42759 197 9 this this DT 42759 197 10 practice practice NN 42759 197 11 were be VBD 42759 197 12 the the DT 42759 197 13 ancient ancient JJ 42759 197 14 Irish irish JJ 42759 197 15 , , , 42759 197 16 the the DT 42759 197 17 aborigines aborigine NNS 42759 197 18 of of IN 42759 197 19 Peru Peru NNP 42759 197 20 , , , 42759 197 21 Mexico Mexico NNP 42759 197 22 , , , 42759 197 23 and and CC 42759 197 24 parts part NNS 42759 197 25 of of IN 42759 197 26 what what WP 42759 197 27 is be VBZ 42759 197 28 now now RB 42759 197 29 the the DT 42759 197 30 United United NNP 42759 197 31 States States NNP 42759 197 32 , , , 42759 197 33 and and CC 42759 197 34 Australia Australia NNP 42759 197 35 , , , 42759 197 36 and and CC 42759 197 37 some some DT 42759 197 38 of of IN 42759 197 39 the the DT 42759 197 40 tribes tribe NNS 42759 197 41 of of IN 42759 197 42 Africa Africa NNP 42759 197 43 , , , 42759 197 44 India India NNP 42759 197 45 , , , 42759 197 46 and and CC 42759 197 47 Malaysia Malaysia NNP 42759 197 48 . . . 42759 198 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 198 2 5 5 CD 42759 198 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 198 4 Whether whether IN 42759 198 5 the the DT 42759 198 6 most most RBS 42759 198 7 primitive primitive JJ 42759 198 8 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 198 9 systems system NNS 42759 198 10 of of IN 42759 198 11 every every DT 42759 198 12 people people NNS 42759 198 13 were be VBD 42759 198 14 of of IN 42759 198 15 this this DT 42759 198 16 nature nature NN 42759 198 17 we -PRON- PRP 42759 198 18 have have VBP 42759 198 19 , , , 42759 198 20 of of IN 42759 198 21 course course NN 42759 198 22 , , , 42759 198 23 no no DT 42759 198 24 means means NN 42759 198 25 of of IN 42759 198 26 knowing know VBG 42759 198 27 , , , 42759 198 28 but but CC 42759 198 29 the the DT 42759 198 30 supposition supposition NN 42759 198 31 is be VBZ 42759 198 32 antecedently antecedently RB 42759 198 33 probable probable JJ 42759 198 34 ; ; : 42759 198 35 for for IN 42759 198 36 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 198 37 must must MD 42759 198 38 have have VB 42759 198 39 begun begin VBN 42759 198 40 very very RB 42759 198 41 gradually gradually RB 42759 198 42 , , , 42759 198 43 and and CC 42759 198 44 been be VBN 42759 198 45 for for IN 42759 198 46 some some DT 42759 198 47 time time NN 42759 198 48 practised practise VBN 42759 198 49 in in IN 42759 198 50 connection connection NN 42759 198 51 with with IN 42759 198 52 the the DT 42759 198 53 more more RBR 42759 198 54 primitive primitive JJ 42759 198 55 methods method NNS 42759 198 56 of of IN 42759 198 57 obtaining obtain VBG 42759 198 58 a a DT 42759 198 59 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 198 60 . . . 42759 199 1 As as IN 42759 199 2 the the DT 42759 199 3 land land NN 42759 199 4 had have VBD 42759 199 5 been be VBN 42759 199 6 held hold VBN 42759 199 7 for for IN 42759 199 8 the the DT 42759 199 9 most most JJS 42759 199 10 part part NN 42759 199 11 in in IN 42759 199 12 common common JJ 42759 199 13 during during IN 42759 199 14 the the DT 42759 199 15 hunting hunting NN 42759 199 16 and and CC 42759 199 17 fishing fishing NN 42759 199 18 stage stage NN 42759 199 19 and and CC 42759 199 20 during during IN 42759 199 21 the the DT 42759 199 22 pastoral pastoral JJ 42759 199 23 stage stage NN 42759 199 24 , , , 42759 199 25 the the DT 42759 199 26 same same JJ 42759 199 27 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 199 28 would would MD 42759 199 29 probably probably RB 42759 199 30 continue continue VB 42759 199 31 until until IN 42759 199 32 the the DT 42759 199 33 people people NNS 42759 199 34 found find VBD 42759 199 35 it -PRON- PRP 42759 199 36 necessary necessary JJ 42759 199 37 to to TO 42759 199 38 cultivate cultivate VB 42759 199 39 the the DT 42759 199 40 same same JJ 42759 199 41 tracts tract NNS 42759 199 42 of of IN 42759 199 43 land land NN 42759 199 44 year year NN 42759 199 45 after after IN 42759 199 46 year year NN 42759 199 47 , , , 42759 199 48 and and CC 42759 199 49 conceived conceive VBD 42759 199 50 the the DT 42759 199 51 desire desire NN 42759 199 52 to to TO 42759 199 53 retain retain VB 42759 199 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 199 55 holdings holding NNS 42759 199 56 in in IN 42759 199 57 stable stable JJ 42759 199 58 possession possession NN 42759 199 59 and and CC 42759 199 60 to to TO 42759 199 61 transmit transmit VB 42759 199 62 them -PRON- PRP 42759 199 63 to to IN 42759 199 64 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 199 65 children child NNS 42759 199 66 . . . 42759 200 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 200 2 , , , 42759 200 3 so so RB 42759 200 4 long long RB 42759 200 5 as as IN 42759 200 6 the the DT 42759 200 7 members member NNS 42759 200 8 of of IN 42759 200 9 the the DT 42759 200 10 clan clan NN 42759 200 11 remained remain VBD 42759 200 12 strongly strongly RB 42759 200 13 conscious conscious JJ 42759 200 14 of of IN 42759 200 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 200 16 kinship kinship NN 42759 200 17 , , , 42759 200 18 and and CC 42759 200 19 realised realise VBD 42759 200 20 the the DT 42759 200 21 necessity necessity NN 42759 200 22 of of IN 42759 200 23 acting act VBG 42759 200 24 as as IN 42759 200 25 a a DT 42759 200 26 unit unit NN 42759 200 27 against against IN 42759 200 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 200 29 enemies enemy NNS 42759 200 30 , , , 42759 200 31 there there EX 42759 200 32 would would MD 42759 200 33 be be VB 42759 200 34 a a DT 42759 200 35 strong strong JJ 42759 200 36 incentive incentive NN 42759 200 37 to to IN 42759 200 38 clan clan NN 42759 200 39 ownership ownership NN 42759 200 40 of of IN 42759 200 41 the the DT 42759 200 42 land land NN 42759 200 43 , , , 42759 200 44 and and CC 42759 200 45 clan clan NN 42759 200 46 allotment allotment NN 42759 200 47 of of IN 42759 200 48 it -PRON- PRP 42759 200 49 among among IN 42759 200 50 the the DT 42759 200 51 individual individual JJ 42759 200 52 members member NNS 42759 200 53 . . . 42759 201 1 In in IN 42759 201 2 other other JJ 42759 201 3 words word NNS 42759 201 4 , , , 42759 201 5 the the DT 42759 201 6 clan clan NN 42759 201 7 would would MD 42759 201 8 , , , 42759 201 9 in in IN 42759 201 10 these these DT 42759 201 11 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 201 12 , , , 42759 201 13 have have VBP 42759 201 14 the the DT 42759 201 15 same same JJ 42759 201 16 motives motive NNS 42759 201 17 for for IN 42759 201 18 common common JJ 42759 201 19 ownership ownership NN 42759 201 20 that that WDT 42759 201 21 exist exist VBP 42759 201 22 to to IN 42759 201 23 - - HYPH 42759 201 24 day day NN 42759 201 25 in in IN 42759 201 26 the the DT 42759 201 27 family family NN 42759 201 28 . . . 42759 202 1 The the DT 42759 202 2 oldest old JJS 42759 202 3 historical historical JJ 42759 202 4 peoples people NNS 42759 202 5 , , , 42759 202 6 the the DT 42759 202 7 Israelites Israelites NNPS 42759 202 8 , , , 42759 202 9 Egyptians Egyptians NNPS 42759 202 10 , , , 42759 202 11 Assyrians Assyrians NNPS 42759 202 12 , , , 42759 202 13 Babylonians Babylonians NNPS 42759 202 14 , , , 42759 202 15 and and CC 42759 202 16 Chinese Chinese NNP 42759 202 17 , , , 42759 202 18 had have VBD 42759 202 19 private private JJ 42759 202 20 ownership ownership NN 42759 202 21 of of IN 42759 202 22 land land NN 42759 202 23 at at IN 42759 202 24 the the DT 42759 202 25 beginning beginning NN 42759 202 26 of of IN 42759 202 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 202 28 recorded record VBN 42759 202 29 history history NN 42759 202 30 . . . 42759 203 1 Most Most JJS 42759 203 2 of of IN 42759 203 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 203 4 , , , 42759 203 5 however however RB 42759 203 6 , , , 42759 203 7 had have VBD 42759 203 8 been be VBN 42759 203 9 cultivating cultivate VBG 42759 203 10 land land NN 42759 203 11 for for IN 42759 203 12 a a DT 42759 203 13 considerable considerable JJ 42759 203 14 length length NN 42759 203 15 of of IN 42759 203 16 time time NN 42759 203 17 , , , 42759 203 18 and and CC 42759 203 19 had have VBD 42759 203 20 acquired acquire VBN 42759 203 21 a a DT 42759 203 22 considerable considerable JJ 42759 203 23 degree degree NN 42759 203 24 of of IN 42759 203 25 civilisation civilisation NN 42759 203 26 , , , 42759 203 27 before before IN 42759 203 28 the the DT 42759 203 29 earliest early JJS 42759 203 30 period period NN 42759 203 31 of of IN 42759 203 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 203 33 existence existence NN 42759 203 34 of of IN 42759 203 35 which which WDT 42759 203 36 we -PRON- PRP 42759 203 37 have have VBP 42759 203 38 any any DT 42759 203 39 knowledge knowledge NN 42759 203 40 . . . 42759 204 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 204 2 is be VBZ 42759 204 3 quite quite RB 42759 204 4 possible possible JJ 42759 204 5 that that IN 42759 204 6 those those DT 42759 204 7 among among IN 42759 204 8 them -PRON- PRP 42759 204 9 that that WDT 42759 204 10 had have VBD 42759 204 11 passed pass VBN 42759 204 12 through through IN 42759 204 13 the the DT 42759 204 14 hunting hunting NN 42759 204 15 and and CC 42759 204 16 fishing fishing NN 42759 204 17 or or CC 42759 204 18 the the DT 42759 204 19 pastoral pastoral JJ 42759 204 20 stage stage NN 42759 204 21 of of IN 42759 204 22 existence existence NN 42759 204 23 , , , 42759 204 24 had have VBD 42759 204 25 practised practise VBN 42759 204 26 tribal tribal JJ 42759 204 27 or or CC 42759 204 28 common common JJ 42759 204 29 ownership ownership NN 42759 204 30 during during IN 42759 204 31 the the DT 42759 204 32 earlier early JJR 42759 204 33 portion portion NN 42759 204 34 of of IN 42759 204 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 204 36 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 204 37 life life NN 42759 204 38 . . . 42759 205 1 _ _ NNP 42759 205 2 How how WRB 42759 205 3 the the DT 42759 205 4 Change change NN 42759 205 5 Probably probably RB 42759 205 6 Took take VBD 42759 205 7 Place Place NNP 42759 205 8 _ _ NNP 42759 205 9 The the DT 42759 205 10 change change NN 42759 205 11 from from IN 42759 205 12 tribal tribal JJ 42759 205 13 to to IN 42759 205 14 private private JJ 42759 205 15 landownership landownership NN 42759 205 16 could could MD 42759 205 17 have have VB 42759 205 18 occurred occur VBN 42759 205 19 in in IN 42759 205 20 a a DT 42759 205 21 great great JJ 42759 205 22 variety variety NN 42759 205 23 of of IN 42759 205 24 ways way NNS 42759 205 25 . . . 42759 206 1 For for IN 42759 206 2 example example NN 42759 206 3 , , , 42759 206 4 the the DT 42759 206 5 chief chief NN 42759 206 6 , , , 42759 206 7 patriarch patriarch JJ 42759 206 8 , , , 42759 206 9 or or CC 42759 206 10 king king NN 42759 206 11 might may MD 42759 206 12 have have VB 42759 206 13 gradually gradually RB 42759 206 14 obtained obtain VBN 42759 206 15 greater great JJR 42759 206 16 authority authority NN 42759 206 17 in in IN 42759 206 18 making make VBG 42759 206 19 the the DT 42759 206 20 allotments allotment NNS 42759 206 21 of of IN 42759 206 22 land land NN 42759 206 23 among among IN 42759 206 24 the the DT 42759 206 25 members member NNS 42759 206 26 of of IN 42759 206 27 the the DT 42759 206 28 tribe tribe NN 42759 206 29 or or CC 42759 206 30 group group NN 42759 206 31 , , , 42759 206 32 and and CC 42759 206 33 thus thus RB 42759 206 34 acquired acquire VBD 42759 206 35 a a DT 42759 206 36 degree degree NN 42759 206 37 of of IN 42759 206 38 control control NN 42759 206 39 over over IN 42759 206 40 the the DT 42759 206 41 land land NN 42759 206 42 which which WDT 42759 206 43 in in IN 42759 206 44 time time NN 42759 206 45 became become VBD 42759 206 46 practical practical JJ 42759 206 47 ownership ownership NN 42759 206 48 ; ; : 42759 206 49 he -PRON- PRP 42759 206 50 might may MD 42759 206 51 have have VB 42759 206 52 seized seize VBN 42759 206 53 the the DT 42759 206 54 holdings holding NNS 42759 206 55 of of IN 42759 206 56 deceased deceased JJ 42759 206 57 persons person NNS 42759 206 58 , , , 42759 206 59 or or CC 42759 206 60 of of IN 42759 206 61 those those DT 42759 206 62 who who WP 42759 206 63 were be VBD 42759 206 64 unable unable JJ 42759 206 65 to to TO 42759 206 66 pay pay VB 42759 206 67 him -PRON- PRP 42759 206 68 the the DT 42759 206 69 tax tax NN 42759 206 70 or or CC 42759 206 71 tribute tribute NN 42759 206 72 that that WDT 42759 206 73 he -PRON- PRP 42759 206 74 demanded demand VBD 42759 206 75 , , , 42759 206 76 or or CC 42759 206 77 of of IN 42759 206 78 those those DT 42759 206 79 who who WP 42759 206 80 were be VBD 42759 206 81 for for IN 42759 206 82 any any DT 42759 206 83 reason reason NN 42759 206 84 obnoxious obnoxious JJ 42759 206 85 to to IN 42759 206 86 him -PRON- PRP 42759 206 87 . . . 42759 207 1 Again again RB 42759 207 2 , , , 42759 207 3 the the DT 42759 207 4 taxes taxis NNS 42759 207 5 paid pay VBN 42759 207 6 to to IN 42759 207 7 the the DT 42759 207 8 chief chief JJ 42759 207 9 man man NN 42759 207 10 in in IN 42759 207 11 a a DT 42759 207 12 community community NN 42759 207 13 for for IN 42759 207 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 207 15 services service NNS 42759 207 16 as as IN 42759 207 17 ruler ruler NN 42759 207 18 might may MD 42759 207 19 have have VB 42759 207 20 come come VBN 42759 207 21 in in IN 42759 207 22 time time NN 42759 207 23 to to TO 42759 207 24 be be VB 42759 207 25 regarded regard VBN 42759 207 26 as as IN 42759 207 27 a a DT 42759 207 28 payment payment NN 42759 207 29 for for IN 42759 207 30 the the DT 42759 207 31 use use NN 42759 207 32 of of IN 42759 207 33 the the DT 42759 207 34 land land NN 42759 207 35 , , , 42759 207 36 and and CC 42759 207 37 therefore therefore RB 42759 207 38 as as IN 42759 207 39 an an DT 42759 207 40 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 42759 207 41 that that IN 42759 207 42 the the DT 42759 207 43 chief chief NN 42759 207 44 was be VBD 42759 207 45 also also RB 42759 207 46 the the DT 42759 207 47 landlord landlord NN 42759 207 48 . . . 42759 208 1 Even even RB 42759 208 2 in in IN 42759 208 3 the the DT 42759 208 4 Middle Middle NNP 42759 208 5 Ages Ages NNP 42759 208 6 the the DT 42759 208 7 rents rent NNS 42759 208 8 received receive VBN 42759 208 9 by by IN 42759 208 10 the the DT 42759 208 11 feudal feudal JJ 42759 208 12 lords lord NNS 42759 208 13 were be VBD 42759 208 14 in in IN 42759 208 15 great great JJ 42759 208 16 measure measure NN 42759 208 17 a a DT 42759 208 18 return return NN 42759 208 19 for for IN 42759 208 20 social social JJ 42759 208 21 and and CC 42759 208 22 political political JJ 42759 208 23 services service NNS 42759 208 24 , , , 42759 208 25 just just RB 42759 208 26 as as IN 42759 208 27 are be VBP 42759 208 28 the the DT 42759 208 29 taxes taxis NNS 42759 208 30 received receive VBN 42759 208 31 to to IN 42759 208 32 - - HYPH 42759 208 33 day day NN 42759 208 34 from from IN 42759 208 35 private private JJ 42759 208 36 landowners landowner NNS 42759 208 37 by by IN 42759 208 38 the the DT 42759 208 39 State State NNP 42759 208 40 . . . 42759 209 1 In in IN 42759 209 2 primitive primitive JJ 42759 209 3 times time NNS 42759 209 4 , , , 42759 209 5 as as RB 42759 209 6 well well RB 42759 209 7 as as IN 42759 209 8 later later RB 42759 209 9 on on RB 42759 209 10 , , , 42759 209 11 the the DT 42759 209 12 chief chief NN 42759 209 13 would would MD 42759 209 14 naturally naturally RB 42759 209 15 do do VB 42759 209 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 209 17 best good JJS 42759 209 18 to to TO 42759 209 19 convert convert VB 42759 209 20 this this DT 42759 209 21 institution institution NN 42759 209 22 of of IN 42759 209 23 tax tax NN 42759 209 24 paying paying NN 42759 209 25 or or CC 42759 209 26 tribute tribute NN 42759 209 27 paying pay VBG 42759 209 28 into into IN 42759 209 29 rent rent NN 42759 209 30 paying pay VBG 42759 209 31 , , , 42759 209 32 and and CC 42759 209 33 to to TO 42759 209 34 add add VB 42759 209 35 the the DT 42759 209 36 position position NN 42759 209 37 of of IN 42759 209 38 landowner landowner NN 42759 209 39 to to IN 42759 209 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 209 41 other other JJ 42759 209 42 prerogatives prerogative NNS 42759 209 43 . . . 42759 210 1 After after RB 42759 210 2 all all RB 42759 210 3 , , , 42759 210 4 the the DT 42759 210 5 transition transition NN 42759 210 6 from from IN 42759 210 7 tribal tribal JJ 42759 210 8 ownership ownership NN 42759 210 9 , , , 42759 210 10 with with IN 42759 210 11 private private JJ 42759 210 12 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 210 13 and and CC 42759 210 14 private private JJ 42759 210 15 receipt receipt NN 42759 210 16 of of IN 42759 210 17 the the DT 42759 210 18 produce produce NN 42759 210 19 of of IN 42759 210 20 individual individual JJ 42759 210 21 allotments allotment NNS 42759 210 22 , , , 42759 210 23 to to IN 42759 210 24 overlordship overlordship NN 42759 210 25 and and CC 42759 210 26 landlordism landlordism NN 42759 210 27 , , , 42759 210 28 would would MD 42759 210 29 not not RB 42759 210 30 have have VB 42759 210 31 been be VBN 42759 210 32 greater great JJR 42759 210 33 than than IN 42759 210 34 that that DT 42759 210 35 which which WDT 42759 210 36 actually actually RB 42759 210 37 took take VBD 42759 210 38 place place NN 42759 210 39 in in IN 42759 210 40 England England NNP 42759 210 41 between between IN 42759 210 42 the the DT 42759 210 43 fifteenth fifteenth NN 42759 210 44 and and CC 42759 210 45 the the DT 42759 210 46 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 42759 210 47 centuries century NNS 42759 210 48 , , , 42759 210 49 when when WRB 42759 210 50 the the DT 42759 210 51 lords lord NNS 42759 210 52 became become VBD 42759 210 53 absolute absolute JJ 42759 210 54 owners owner NNS 42759 210 55 of of IN 42759 210 56 land land NN 42759 210 57 that that WDT 42759 210 58 they -PRON- PRP 42759 210 59 had have VBD 42759 210 60 previously previously RB 42759 210 61 held hold VBN 42759 210 62 with with IN 42759 210 63 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 210 64 tenants tenant NNS 42759 210 65 in in IN 42759 210 66 a a DT 42759 210 67 sort sort NN 42759 210 68 of of IN 42759 210 69 divided divided JJ 42759 210 70 or or CC 42759 210 71 dual dual JJ 42759 210 72 ownership ownership NN 42759 210 73 . . . 42759 211 1 In in IN 42759 211 2 a a DT 42759 211 3 word word NN 42759 211 4 , , , 42759 211 5 tribal tribal JJ 42759 211 6 ownership ownership NN 42759 211 7 could could MD 42759 211 8 have have VB 42759 211 9 been be VBN 42759 211 10 displaced displace VBN 42759 211 11 by by IN 42759 211 12 landlordism landlordism NN 42759 211 13 through through IN 42759 211 14 the the DT 42759 211 15 same same JJ 42759 211 16 methods method NNS 42759 211 17 that that WDT 42759 211 18 have have VBP 42759 211 19 been be VBN 42759 211 20 used use VBN 42759 211 21 everywhere everywhere RB 42759 211 22 by by IN 42759 211 23 the the DT 42759 211 24 powerful powerful JJ 42759 211 25 , , , 42759 211 26 the the DT 42759 211 27 ambitious ambitious JJ 42759 211 28 , , , 42759 211 29 and and CC 42759 211 30 the the DT 42759 211 31 greedy greedy JJ 42759 211 32 against against IN 42759 211 33 the the DT 42759 211 34 weak weak JJ 42759 211 35 , , , 42759 211 36 the the DT 42759 211 37 indifferent indifferent NN 42759 211 38 , , , 42759 211 39 and and CC 42759 211 40 the the DT 42759 211 41 upright upright JJ 42759 211 42 . . . 42759 212 1 Nor nor CC 42759 212 2 must must MD 42759 212 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 212 4 forget forget VB 42759 212 5 the the DT 42759 212 6 influence influence NN 42759 212 7 of of IN 42759 212 8 conquest conquest NN 42759 212 9 . . . 42759 213 1 Most Most JJS 42759 213 2 of of IN 42759 213 3 the the DT 42759 213 4 countries country NNS 42759 213 5 that that WDT 42759 213 6 appear appear VBP 42759 213 7 in in IN 42759 213 8 historical historical JJ 42759 213 9 times time NNS 42759 213 10 with with IN 42759 213 11 a a DT 42759 213 12 system system NN 42759 213 13 of of IN 42759 213 14 private private JJ 42759 213 15 ownership ownership NN 42759 213 16 had have VBD 42759 213 17 at at IN 42759 213 18 some some DT 42759 213 19 previous previous JJ 42759 213 20 period period NN 42759 213 21 been be VBN 42759 213 22 subjugated subjugate VBN 42759 213 23 by by IN 42759 213 24 an an DT 42759 213 25 alien alien JJ 42759 213 26 people people NNS 42759 213 27 . . . 42759 214 1 In in IN 42759 214 2 many many JJ 42759 214 3 of of IN 42759 214 4 these these DT 42759 214 5 the the DT 42759 214 6 conquerors conqueror NNS 42759 214 7 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 214 8 introduced introduce VBD 42759 214 9 a a DT 42759 214 10 considerable considerable JJ 42759 214 11 degree degree NN 42759 214 12 of of IN 42759 214 13 individual individual JJ 42759 214 14 ownership ownership NN 42759 214 15 , , , 42759 214 16 the the DT 42759 214 17 more more RBR 42759 214 18 powerful powerful JJ 42759 214 19 among among IN 42759 214 20 them -PRON- PRP 42759 214 21 becoming become VBG 42759 214 22 landlords landlord NNS 42759 214 23 , , , 42759 214 24 while while IN 42759 214 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 214 26 weaker weak JJR 42759 214 27 companions companion NNS 42759 214 28 and and CC 42759 214 29 the the DT 42759 214 30 mass mass NN 42759 214 31 of of IN 42759 214 32 the the DT 42759 214 33 conquered conquer VBN 42759 214 34 population population NN 42759 214 35 were be VBD 42759 214 36 established establish VBN 42759 214 37 in in IN 42759 214 38 a a DT 42759 214 39 condition condition NN 42759 214 40 of of IN 42759 214 41 tenancy tenancy NN 42759 214 42 . . . 42759 215 1 Where where WRB 42759 215 2 a a DT 42759 215 3 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 215 4 widely widely RB 42759 215 5 diffused diffuse VBN 42759 215 6 private private JJ 42759 215 7 ownership ownership NN 42759 215 8 succeeded succeed VBD 42759 215 9 the the DT 42759 215 10 primitive primitive JJ 42759 215 11 system system NN 42759 215 12 , , , 42759 215 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 215 14 was be VBD 42759 215 15 probably probably RB 42759 215 16 due due IN 42759 215 17 to to IN 42759 215 18 the the DT 42759 215 19 free free JJ 42759 215 20 action action NN 42759 215 21 of of IN 42759 215 22 the the DT 42759 215 23 cultivators cultivator NNS 42759 215 24 , , , 42759 215 25 as as RB 42759 215 26 soon soon RB 42759 215 27 as as IN 42759 215 28 they -PRON- PRP 42759 215 29 came come VBD 42759 215 30 to to TO 42759 215 31 realise realise VB 42759 215 32 the the DT 42759 215 33 inconveniences inconvenience NNS 42759 215 34 of of IN 42759 215 35 ownership ownership NN 42759 215 36 in in IN 42759 215 37 common common JJ 42759 215 38 . . . 42759 216 1 " " `` 42759 216 2 Any any DT 42759 216 3 enclosed enclose VBN 42759 216 4 land land NN 42759 216 5 round round IN 42759 216 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 216 7 permanent permanent JJ 42759 216 8 dwellings dwelling NNS 42759 216 9 , , , 42759 216 10 and and CC 42759 216 11 any any DT 42759 216 12 land land NN 42759 216 13 outside outside IN 42759 216 14 the the DT 42759 216 15 settlement settlement NN 42759 216 16 which which WDT 42759 216 17 was be VBD 42759 216 18 cleared clear VBN 42759 216 19 , , , 42759 216 20 reclaimed reclaim VBN 42759 216 21 , , , 42759 216 22 and and CC 42759 216 23 cultivated cultivate VBN 42759 216 24 , , , 42759 216 25 or or CC 42759 216 26 occupied occupy VBN 42759 216 27 with with IN 42759 216 28 cattle cattle NNS 42759 216 29 by by IN 42759 216 30 individuals individual NNS 42759 216 31 or or CC 42759 216 32 families family NNS 42759 216 33 , , , 42759 216 34 was be VBD 42759 216 35 recognised recognise VBN 42759 216 36 as as IN 42759 216 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 216 38 personal personal JJ 42759 216 39 property property NN 42759 216 40 . . . 42759 217 1 Only only RB 42759 217 2 those those DT 42759 217 3 who who WP 42759 217 4 were be VBD 42759 217 5 industrious industrious JJ 42759 217 6 , , , 42759 217 7 enterprising enterprising JJ 42759 217 8 , , , 42759 217 9 and and CC 42759 217 10 courageous courageous JJ 42759 217 11 enough enough RB 42759 217 12 would would MD 42759 217 13 clear clear VB 42759 217 14 , , , 42759 217 15 occupy occupy VB 42759 217 16 , , , 42759 217 17 retain retain VB 42759 217 18 , , , 42759 217 19 cultivate cultivate VBP 42759 217 20 , , , 42759 217 21 and and CC 42759 217 22 defend defend VB 42759 217 23 waste waste NN 42759 217 24 land land NN 42759 217 25 . . . 42759 218 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 218 2 would would MD 42759 218 3 become become VB 42759 218 4 personal personal JJ 42759 218 5 owners owner NNS 42759 218 6 of of IN 42759 218 7 cattle cattle NNS 42759 218 8 , , , 42759 218 9 and and CC 42759 218 10 would would MD 42759 218 11 gradually gradually RB 42759 218 12 acquire acquire VB 42759 218 13 wealth wealth NN 42759 218 14 which which WDT 42759 218 15 would would MD 42759 218 16 enable enable VB 42759 218 17 them -PRON- PRP 42759 218 18 to to TO 42759 218 19 employ employ VB 42759 218 20 others other NNS 42759 218 21 and and CC 42759 218 22 still still RB 42759 218 23 further further RB 42759 218 24 improve improve VB 42759 218 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 218 26 position position NN 42759 218 27 . . . 42759 219 1 As as IN 42759 219 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 219 3 power power NN 42759 219 4 increased increase VBD 42759 219 5 , , , 42759 219 6 and and CC 42759 219 7 as as IN 42759 219 8 population population NN 42759 219 9 grew grow VBD 42759 219 10 , , , 42759 219 11 the the DT 42759 219 12 bravest brave JJS 42759 219 13 , , , 42759 219 14 wealthiest wealthy JJS 42759 219 15 , , , 42759 219 16 and and CC 42759 219 17 most most RBS 42759 219 18 capable capable JJ 42759 219 19 fighting fighting NN 42759 219 20 men man NNS 42759 219 21 amongst amongst IN 42759 219 22 them -PRON- PRP 42759 219 23 would would MD 42759 219 24 become become VB 42759 219 25 chiefs chief NNS 42759 219 26 or or CC 42759 219 27 a a DT 42759 219 28 species species NN 42759 219 29 of of IN 42759 219 30 nobles noble NNS 42759 219 31 , , , 42759 219 32 and and CC 42759 219 33 the the DT 42759 219 34 force force NN 42759 219 35 of of IN 42759 219 36 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 219 37 , , , 42759 219 38 often often RB 42759 219 39 no no RB 42759 219 40 doubt doubt RB 42759 219 41 aided aid VBN 42759 219 42 by by IN 42759 219 43 force force NN 42759 219 44 and and CC 42759 219 45 fraud fraud NN 42759 219 46 , , , 42759 219 47 would would MD 42759 219 48 eventually eventually RB 42759 219 49 make make VB 42759 219 50 them -PRON- PRP 42759 219 51 the the DT 42759 219 52 landowners landowner NNS 42759 219 53 of of IN 42759 219 54 the the DT 42759 219 55 greater great JJR 42759 219 56 part part NN 42759 219 57 of of IN 42759 219 58 the the DT 42759 219 59 district district NN 42759 219 60 , , , 42759 219 61 with with IN 42759 219 62 the the DT 42759 219 63 more more RBR 42759 219 64 or or CC 42759 219 65 less less RBR 42759 219 66 willing willing JJ 42759 219 67 acquiescence acquiescence NN 42759 219 68 and and CC 42759 219 69 consent consent NN 42759 219 70 of of IN 42759 219 71 the the DT 42759 219 72 community community NN 42759 219 73 amongst amongst IN 42759 219 74 whom whom WP 42759 219 75 they -PRON- PRP 42759 219 76 lived live VBD 42759 219 77 , , , 42759 219 78 and and CC 42759 219 79 to to TO 42759 219 80 whom whom WP 42759 219 81 they -PRON- PRP 42759 219 82 extended extend VBD 42759 219 83 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 219 84 protection protection NN 42759 219 85 . . . 42759 220 1 " " `` 42759 220 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 220 3 6 6 CD 42759 220 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 220 5 _ _ NNP 42759 220 6 Limited Limited NNP 42759 220 7 Character Character NNP 42759 220 8 of of IN 42759 220 9 Primitive Primitive NNP 42759 220 10 Common Common NNP 42759 220 11 Ownership Ownership NNP 42759 220 12 _ _ NNP 42759 220 13 A a DT 42759 220 14 great great JJ 42759 220 15 deal deal NN 42759 220 16 of of IN 42759 220 17 the the DT 42759 220 18 opposition opposition NN 42759 220 19 to to IN 42759 220 20 the the DT 42759 220 21 theory theory NN 42759 220 22 of of IN 42759 220 23 primitive primitive JJ 42759 220 24 common common JJ 42759 220 25 ownership ownership NN 42759 220 26 of of IN 42759 220 27 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 220 28 land land NN 42759 220 29 , , , 42759 220 30 seems seem VBZ 42759 220 31 to to TO 42759 220 32 be be VB 42759 220 33 based base VBN 42759 220 34 upon upon IN 42759 220 35 an an DT 42759 220 36 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 42759 220 37 conception conception NN 42759 220 38 of of IN 42759 220 39 the the DT 42759 220 40 scope scope NN 42759 220 41 of of IN 42759 220 42 that that DT 42759 220 43 institution institution NN 42759 220 44 . . . 42759 221 1 The the DT 42759 221 2 average average JJ 42759 221 3 man man NN 42759 221 4 who who WP 42759 221 5 thinks think VBZ 42759 221 6 or or CC 42759 221 7 speaks speak VBZ 42759 221 8 of of IN 42759 221 9 ownership ownership NN 42759 221 10 to to IN 42759 221 11 - - HYPH 42759 221 12 day day NN 42759 221 13 has have VBZ 42759 221 14 in in IN 42759 221 15 mind mind NN 42759 221 16 the the DT 42759 221 17 Roman roman JJ 42759 221 18 concept concept NN 42759 221 19 and and CC 42759 221 20 practice practice NN 42759 221 21 of of IN 42759 221 22 private private JJ 42759 221 23 property property NN 42759 221 24 . . . 42759 222 1 This this DT 42759 222 2 includes include VBZ 42759 222 3 the the DT 42759 222 4 unrestricted unrestricted JJ 42759 222 5 right right NN 42759 222 6 of of IN 42759 222 7 disposal disposal NN 42759 222 8 ; ; : 42759 222 9 that that RB 42759 222 10 is is RB 42759 222 11 , , , 42759 222 12 the the DT 42759 222 13 power power NN 42759 222 14 to to TO 42759 222 15 hold hold VB 42759 222 16 permanently permanently RB 42759 222 17 , , , 42759 222 18 to to TO 42759 222 19 transfer transfer VB 42759 222 20 or or CC 42759 222 21 transmit transmit VB 42759 222 22 , , , 42759 222 23 to to TO 42759 222 24 use use VB 42759 222 25 or or CC 42759 222 26 to to TO 42759 222 27 abuse abuse VB 42759 222 28 or or CC 42759 222 29 not not RB 42759 222 30 to to TO 42759 222 31 use use VB 42759 222 32 at at RB 42759 222 33 all all RB 42759 222 34 , , , 42759 222 35 to to TO 42759 222 36 retain retain VB 42759 222 37 the the DT 42759 222 38 product product NN 42759 222 39 of of IN 42759 222 40 the the DT 42759 222 41 owner owner NN 42759 222 42 's 's POS 42759 222 43 use use NN 42759 222 44 , , , 42759 222 45 to to TO 42759 222 46 rent rent VB 42759 222 47 the the DT 42759 222 48 property property NN 42759 222 49 to to IN 42759 222 50 any any DT 42759 222 51 person person NN 42759 222 52 and and CC 42759 222 53 for for IN 42759 222 54 any any DT 42759 222 55 period period NN 42759 222 56 that that IN 42759 222 57 the the DT 42759 222 58 owner owner NN 42759 222 59 chooses choose VBZ 42759 222 60 , , , 42759 222 61 and and CC 42759 222 62 to to TO 42759 222 63 obtain obtain VB 42759 222 64 a a DT 42759 222 65 price price NN 42759 222 66 in in IN 42759 222 67 return return NN 42759 222 68 called call VBN 42759 222 69 rent rent NN 42759 222 70 . . . 42759 223 1 Any any DT 42759 223 2 man man NN 42759 223 3 who who WP 42759 223 4 takes take VBZ 42759 223 5 the the DT 42759 223 6 theory theory NN 42759 223 7 of of IN 42759 223 8 primitive primitive JJ 42759 223 9 common common JJ 42759 223 10 ownership ownership NN 42759 223 11 to to TO 42759 223 12 imply imply VB 42759 223 13 that that IN 42759 223 14 the the DT 42759 223 15 community community NN 42759 223 16 or or CC 42759 223 17 tribe tribe NN 42759 223 18 exercised exercise VBD 42759 223 19 all all PDT 42759 223 20 these these DT 42759 223 21 powers power NNS 42759 223 22 over over IN 42759 223 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 223 24 land land NN 42759 223 25 , , , 42759 223 26 will will MD 42759 223 27 have have VB 42759 223 28 no no DT 42759 223 29 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 223 30 in in IN 42759 223 31 proving prove VBG 42759 223 32 that that IN 42759 223 33 the the DT 42759 223 34 evidence evidence NN 42759 223 35 is be VBZ 42759 223 36 overwhelmingly overwhelmingly RB 42759 223 37 against against IN 42759 223 38 any any DT 42759 223 39 such such JJ 42759 223 40 theory theory NN 42759 223 41 . . . 42759 224 1 Even even RB 42759 224 2 among among IN 42759 224 3 those those DT 42759 224 4 people people NNS 42759 224 5 that that WDT 42759 224 6 are be VBP 42759 224 7 certainly certainly RB 42759 224 8 known know VBN 42759 224 9 to to TO 42759 224 10 have have VB 42759 224 11 practised practise VBN 42759 224 12 so so RB 42759 224 13 - - HYPH 42759 224 14 called call VBN 42759 224 15 common common JJ 42759 224 16 ownership ownership NN 42759 224 17 of of IN 42759 224 18 land land NN 42759 224 19 , , , 42759 224 20 there there EX 42759 224 21 are be VBP 42759 224 22 very very RB 42759 224 23 few few JJ 42759 224 24 instances instance NNS 42759 224 25 of of IN 42759 224 26 communal communal JJ 42759 224 27 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 224 28 , , , 42759 224 29 or or CC 42759 224 30 communal communal JJ 42759 224 31 distribution distribution NN 42759 224 32 of of IN 42759 224 33 the the DT 42759 224 34 product product NN 42759 224 35 . . . 42759 225 1 Yet yet RB 42759 225 2 these these DT 42759 225 3 are be VBP 42759 225 4 included include VBN 42759 225 5 in in IN 42759 225 6 the the DT 42759 225 7 Roman roman JJ 42759 225 8 concept concept NN 42759 225 9 of of IN 42759 225 10 ownership ownership NN 42759 225 11 . . . 42759 226 1 The the DT 42759 226 2 usual usual JJ 42759 226 3 method method NN 42759 226 4 seems seem VBZ 42759 226 5 to to TO 42759 226 6 have have VB 42759 226 7 been be VBN 42759 226 8 periodical periodical JJ 42759 226 9 allotment allotment NN 42759 226 10 by by IN 42759 226 11 the the DT 42759 226 12 community community NN 42759 226 13 of of IN 42759 226 14 the the DT 42759 226 15 land land NN 42759 226 16 among among IN 42759 226 17 individuals individual NNS 42759 226 18 , , , 42759 226 19 individual individual JJ 42759 226 20 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 226 21 of of IN 42759 226 22 the the DT 42759 226 23 allotted allot VBN 42759 226 24 tracts tract NNS 42759 226 25 , , , 42759 226 26 and and CC 42759 226 27 individual individual JJ 42759 226 28 ownership ownership NN 42759 226 29 of of IN 42759 226 30 the the DT 42759 226 31 product product NN 42759 226 32 . . . 42759 227 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 227 2 , , , 42759 227 3 there there EX 42759 227 4 was be VBD 42759 227 5 always always RB 42759 227 6 a a DT 42759 227 7 chief chief JJ 42759 227 8 or or CC 42759 227 9 patriarch patriarch NN 42759 227 10 who who WP 42759 227 11 exercised exercise VBD 42759 227 12 considerable considerable JJ 42759 227 13 authority authority NN 42759 227 14 in in IN 42759 227 15 the the DT 42759 227 16 distribution distribution NN 42759 227 17 of of IN 42759 227 18 the the DT 42759 227 19 land land NN 42759 227 20 , , , 42759 227 21 frequently frequently RB 42759 227 22 collected collect VBD 42759 227 23 a a DT 42759 227 24 rent rent NN 42759 227 25 or or CC 42759 227 26 tax tax NN 42759 227 27 from from IN 42759 227 28 the the DT 42759 227 29 cultivators cultivator NNS 42759 227 30 , , , 42759 227 31 and and CC 42759 227 32 almost almost RB 42759 227 33 invariably invariably RB 42759 227 34 exercised exercise VBN 42759 227 35 something something NN 42759 227 36 like like IN 42759 227 37 private private JJ 42759 227 38 ownership ownership NN 42759 227 39 of of IN 42759 227 40 a a DT 42759 227 41 portion portion NN 42759 227 42 of of IN 42759 227 43 the the DT 42759 227 44 land land NN 42759 227 45 for for IN 42759 227 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 227 47 direct direct JJ 42759 227 48 and and CC 42759 227 49 special special JJ 42759 227 50 benefit benefit NN 42759 227 51 . . . 42759 228 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 42759 228 2 other other JJ 42759 228 3 men man NNS 42759 228 4 of of IN 42759 228 5 importance importance NN 42759 228 6 in in IN 42759 228 7 the the DT 42759 228 8 community community NN 42759 228 9 possessed possess VBN 42759 228 10 land land NN 42759 228 11 which which WDT 42759 228 12 was be VBD 42759 228 13 not not RB 42759 228 14 subject subject JJ 42759 228 15 to to IN 42759 228 16 the the DT 42759 228 17 communal communal JJ 42759 228 18 allotment allotment NN 42759 228 19 . . . 42759 229 1 Primitive primitive JJ 42759 229 2 ownership ownership NN 42759 229 3 of of IN 42759 229 4 land land NN 42759 229 5 in in IN 42759 229 6 common common JJ 42759 229 7 was be VBD 42759 229 8 , , , 42759 229 9 therefore therefore RB 42759 229 10 , , , 42759 229 11 very very RB 42759 229 12 far far RB 42759 229 13 from from IN 42759 229 14 vesting vest VBG 42759 229 15 in in IN 42759 229 16 the the DT 42759 229 17 community community NN 42759 229 18 all all PDT 42759 229 19 the the DT 42759 229 20 powers power NNS 42759 229 21 that that WDT 42759 229 22 inhere inhere VBP 42759 229 23 in in IN 42759 229 24 the the DT 42759 229 25 private private JJ 42759 229 26 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 229 27 of of IN 42759 229 28 land land NN 42759 229 29 according accord VBG 42759 229 30 to to IN 42759 229 31 the the DT 42759 229 32 Roman roman JJ 42759 229 33 law law NN 42759 229 34 and and CC 42759 229 35 usage usage NN 42759 229 36 . . . 42759 230 1 _ _ NNP 42759 230 2 Private Private NNP 42759 230 3 Ownership Ownership NNP 42759 230 4 General General NNP 42759 230 5 in in IN 42759 230 6 Historical Historical NNP 42759 230 7 Times Times NNP 42759 230 8 _ _ NNP 42759 230 9 So so RB 42759 230 10 much much JJ 42759 230 11 for for IN 42759 230 12 land land NN 42759 230 13 tenure tenure NN 42759 230 14 in in IN 42759 230 15 prehistoric prehistoric JJ 42759 230 16 times time NNS 42759 230 17 . . . 42759 231 1 During during IN 42759 231 2 the the DT 42759 231 3 historical historical JJ 42759 231 4 period period NN 42759 231 5 of of IN 42759 231 6 the the DT 42759 231 7 existence existence NN 42759 231 8 of of IN 42759 231 9 the the DT 42759 231 10 race race NN 42759 231 11 , , , 42759 231 12 almost almost RB 42759 231 13 all all DT 42759 231 14 civilised civilise VBN 42759 231 15 peoples people NNS 42759 231 16 have have VBP 42759 231 17 practised practise VBN 42759 231 18 some some DT 42759 231 19 form form NN 42759 231 20 of of IN 42759 231 21 private private JJ 42759 231 22 ownership ownership NN 42759 231 23 in in IN 42759 231 24 the the DT 42759 231 25 matter matter NN 42759 231 26 of of IN 42759 231 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 231 28 arable arable JJ 42759 231 29 lands land NNS 42759 231 30 . . . 42759 232 1 While while IN 42759 232 2 differing differ VBG 42759 232 3 considerably considerably RB 42759 232 4 at at IN 42759 232 5 various various JJ 42759 232 6 times time NNS 42759 232 7 and and CC 42759 232 8 places place NNS 42759 232 9 , , , 42759 232 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 232 11 has have VBZ 42759 232 12 always always RB 42759 232 13 excluded exclude VBN 42759 232 14 communal communal JJ 42759 232 15 allotment allotment NN 42759 232 16 of of IN 42759 232 17 land land NN 42759 232 18 and and CC 42759 232 19 communal communal JJ 42759 232 20 distribution distribution NN 42759 232 21 of of IN 42759 232 22 the the DT 42759 232 23 product product NN 42759 232 24 , , , 42759 232 25 and and CC 42759 232 26 has have VBZ 42759 232 27 always always RB 42759 232 28 included include VBN 42759 232 29 private private JJ 42759 232 30 receipt receipt NN 42759 232 31 of of IN 42759 232 32 the the DT 42759 232 33 product product NN 42759 232 34 by by IN 42759 232 35 the the DT 42759 232 36 owner owner NN 42759 232 37 - - HYPH 42759 232 38 user user NN 42759 232 39 , , , 42759 232 40 or or CC 42759 232 41 private private JJ 42759 232 42 receipt receipt NN 42759 232 43 of of IN 42759 232 44 rent rent NN 42759 232 45 when when WRB 42759 232 46 the the DT 42759 232 47 owner owner NN 42759 232 48 transferred transfer VBD 42759 232 49 the the DT 42759 232 50 use use NN 42759 232 51 to to IN 42759 232 52 some some DT 42759 232 53 one one NN 42759 232 54 else else RB 42759 232 55 . . . 42759 233 1 But but CC 42759 233 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 233 3 did do VBD 42759 233 4 not not RB 42759 233 5 always always RB 42759 233 6 include include VB 42759 233 7 the the DT 42759 233 8 right right NN 42759 233 9 to to TO 42759 233 10 determine determine VB 42759 233 11 who who WP 42759 233 12 should should MD 42759 233 13 be be VB 42759 233 14 the the DT 42759 233 15 user user NN 42759 233 16 . . . 42759 234 1 In in IN 42759 234 2 the the DT 42759 234 3 later later JJ 42759 234 4 centuries century NNS 42759 234 5 of of IN 42759 234 6 the the DT 42759 234 7 feudal feudal JJ 42759 234 8 system system NN 42759 234 9 , , , 42759 234 10 for for IN 42759 234 11 example example NN 42759 234 12 , , , 42759 234 13 the the DT 42759 234 14 lord lord NNP 42759 234 15 could could MD 42759 234 16 not not RB 42759 234 17 always always RB 42759 234 18 expel expel VB 42759 234 19 the the DT 42759 234 20 tenants tenant NNS 42759 234 21 from from IN 42759 234 22 the the DT 42759 234 23 land land NN 42759 234 24 , , , 42759 234 25 nor nor CC 42759 234 26 prevent prevent VB 42759 234 27 them -PRON- PRP 42759 234 28 from from IN 42759 234 29 transmitting transmit VBG 42759 234 30 the the DT 42759 234 31 use use NN 42759 234 32 of of IN 42759 234 33 it -PRON- PRP 42759 234 34 to to IN 42759 234 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 234 36 children child NNS 42759 234 37 . . . 42759 235 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 235 2 , , , 42759 235 3 the the DT 42759 235 4 rent rent NN 42759 235 5 that that IN 42759 235 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 235 7 received receive VBD 42759 235 8 was be VBD 42759 235 9 customary customary JJ 42759 235 10 and and CC 42759 235 11 fixed fixed JJ 42759 235 12 , , , 42759 235 13 not not RB 42759 235 14 competitive competitive JJ 42759 235 15 and and CC 42759 235 16 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 42759 235 17 , , , 42759 235 18 and and CC 42759 235 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 235 20 was be VBD 42759 235 21 looked look VBN 42759 235 22 upon upon IN 42759 235 23 in in IN 42759 235 24 great great JJ 42759 235 25 measure measure NN 42759 235 26 as as IN 42759 235 27 a a DT 42759 235 28 return return NN 42759 235 29 to to IN 42759 235 30 the the DT 42759 235 31 lord lord NNP 42759 235 32 for for IN 42759 235 33 social social NNP 42759 235 34 , , , 42759 235 35 military military JJ 42759 235 36 , , , 42759 235 37 and and CC 42759 235 38 political political JJ 42759 235 39 services service NNS 42759 235 40 , , , 42759 235 41 as as RB 42759 235 42 well well RB 42759 235 43 as as IN 42759 235 44 a a DT 42759 235 45 payment payment NN 42759 235 46 for for IN 42759 235 47 the the DT 42759 235 48 use use NN 42759 235 49 of of IN 42759 235 50 land land NN 42759 235 51 . . . 42759 236 1 This this DT 42759 236 2 system system NN 42759 236 3 was be VBD 42759 236 4 private private JJ 42759 236 5 ownership ownership NN 42759 236 6 , , , 42759 236 7 indeed indeed RB 42759 236 8 , , , 42759 236 9 but but CC 42759 236 10 if if IN 42759 236 11 we -PRON- PRP 42759 236 12 apply apply VBP 42759 236 13 the the DT 42759 236 14 Roman roman JJ 42759 236 15 notion notion NN 42759 236 16 of of IN 42759 236 17 ownership ownership NN 42759 236 18 we -PRON- PRP 42759 236 19 shall shall MD 42759 236 20 find find VB 42759 236 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 236 22 difficult difficult JJ 42759 236 23 to to TO 42759 236 24 decide decide VB 42759 236 25 whether whether IN 42759 236 26 the the DT 42759 236 27 tenant tenant NN 42759 236 28 or or CC 42759 236 29 the the DT 42759 236 30 lord lord NNP 42759 236 31 should should MD 42759 236 32 more more RBR 42759 236 33 properly properly RB 42759 236 34 be be VB 42759 236 35 called call VBN 42759 236 36 the the DT 42759 236 37 owner owner NN 42759 236 38 . . . 42759 237 1 At at IN 42759 237 2 any any DT 42759 237 3 rate rate NN 42759 237 4 , , , 42759 237 5 the the DT 42759 237 6 right right NN 42759 237 7 of of IN 42759 237 8 ownership ownership NN 42759 237 9 possessed possess VBN 42759 237 10 by by IN 42759 237 11 the the DT 42759 237 12 lord lord NNP 42759 237 13 was be VBD 42759 237 14 greatly greatly RB 42759 237 15 limited limit VBN 42759 237 16 by by IN 42759 237 17 restrictions restriction NNS 42759 237 18 which which WDT 42759 237 19 favoured favour VBD 42759 237 20 the the DT 42759 237 21 masses masse NNS 42759 237 22 of of IN 42759 237 23 the the DT 42759 237 24 cultivators cultivator NNS 42759 237 25 . . . 42759 238 1 In in IN 42759 238 2 every every DT 42759 238 3 community community NN 42759 238 4 there there EX 42759 238 5 were be VBD 42759 238 6 common common JJ 42759 238 7 wood wood NN 42759 238 8 lands land NNS 42759 238 9 and and CC 42759 238 10 pasture pasture NN 42759 238 11 lands land NNS 42759 238 12 for for IN 42759 238 13 the the DT 42759 238 14 free free JJ 42759 238 15 use use NN 42759 238 16 of of IN 42759 238 17 all all PDT 42759 238 18 the the DT 42759 238 19 inhabitants inhabitant NNS 42759 238 20 . . . 42759 239 1 Among among IN 42759 239 2 other other JJ 42759 239 3 restrictions restriction NNS 42759 239 4 of of IN 42759 239 5 private private JJ 42759 239 6 ownership ownership NN 42759 239 7 and and CC 42759 239 8 control control NN 42759 239 9 in in IN 42759 239 10 favour favour NN 42759 239 11 of of IN 42759 239 12 the the DT 42759 239 13 principle principle NN 42759 239 14 of of IN 42759 239 15 equal equal JJ 42759 239 16 access access NN 42759 239 17 to to IN 42759 239 18 the the DT 42759 239 19 land land NN 42759 239 20 by by IN 42759 239 21 all all DT 42759 239 22 persons person NNS 42759 239 23 , , , 42759 239 24 we -PRON- PRP 42759 239 25 may may MD 42759 239 26 mention mention VB 42759 239 27 the the DT 42759 239 28 division division NN 42759 239 29 of of IN 42759 239 30 the the DT 42759 239 31 English English NNP 42759 239 32 villein villein NN 42759 239 33 's 's POS 42759 239 34 holding holding NN 42759 239 35 into into IN 42759 239 36 several several JJ 42759 239 37 portions portion NNS 42759 239 38 , , , 42759 239 39 intermingled intermingle VBN 42759 239 40 with with IN 42759 239 41 those those DT 42759 239 42 of of IN 42759 239 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 239 44 neighbours neighbour NNS 42759 239 45 , , , 42759 239 46 so so IN 42759 239 47 that that IN 42759 239 48 each each DT 42759 239 49 would would MD 42759 239 50 have have VB 42759 239 51 about about IN 42759 239 52 the the DT 42759 239 53 same same JJ 42759 239 54 amount amount NN 42759 239 55 of of IN 42759 239 56 good good JJ 42759 239 57 land land NN 42759 239 58 ; ; : 42759 239 59 and and CC 42759 239 60 the the DT 42759 239 61 ancient ancient JJ 42759 239 62 Hebrew hebrew JJ 42759 239 63 law law NN 42759 239 64 whereby whereby WRB 42759 239 65 alienated alienate VBN 42759 239 66 land land NN 42759 239 67 was be VBD 42759 239 68 returned return VBN 42759 239 69 to to IN 42759 239 70 the the DT 42759 239 71 descendants descendant NNS 42759 239 72 of of IN 42759 239 73 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 239 74 original original JJ 42759 239 75 owners owner NNS 42759 239 76 every every DT 42759 239 77 fifty fifty CD 42759 239 78 years year NNS 42759 239 79 . . . 42759 240 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 240 2 7 7 CD 42759 240 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 240 4 Reckoning reckon VBG 42759 240 5 the the DT 42759 240 6 feudal feudal JJ 42759 240 7 lord lord NNP 42759 240 8 , , , 42759 240 9 and and CC 42759 240 10 all all DT 42759 240 11 other other JJ 42759 240 12 overlords overlord NNS 42759 240 13 who who WP 42759 240 14 had have VBD 42759 240 15 the the DT 42759 240 16 same same JJ 42759 240 17 control control NN 42759 240 18 over over IN 42759 240 19 land land NN 42759 240 20 , , , 42759 240 21 as as IN 42759 240 22 private private JJ 42759 240 23 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 240 24 , , , 42759 240 25 we -PRON- PRP 42759 240 26 may may MD 42759 240 27 say say VB 42759 240 28 that that IN 42759 240 29 in in IN 42759 240 30 historical historical JJ 42759 240 31 times time NNS 42759 240 32 the the DT 42759 240 33 arable arable JJ 42759 240 34 land land NN 42759 240 35 of of IN 42759 240 36 every every DT 42759 240 37 country country NN 42759 240 38 has have VBZ 42759 240 39 been be VBN 42759 240 40 owned own VBN 42759 240 41 by by IN 42759 240 42 a a DT 42759 240 43 minority minority NN 42759 240 44 of of IN 42759 240 45 the the DT 42759 240 46 population population NN 42759 240 47 . . . 42759 241 1 Since since IN 42759 241 2 the the DT 42759 241 3 downfall downfall NN 42759 241 4 of of IN 42759 241 5 feudalism feudalism NN 42759 241 6 , , , 42759 241 7 the the DT 42759 241 8 tendency tendency NN 42759 241 9 in in IN 42759 241 10 most most JJS 42759 241 11 regions region NNS 42759 241 12 of of IN 42759 241 13 the the DT 42759 241 14 Western western JJ 42759 241 15 world world NN 42759 241 16 has have VBZ 42759 241 17 been be VBN 42759 241 18 toward toward IN 42759 241 19 an an DT 42759 241 20 increase increase NN 42759 241 21 in in IN 42759 241 22 the the DT 42759 241 23 number number NN 42759 241 24 of of IN 42759 241 25 owners owner NNS 42759 241 26 , , , 42759 241 27 and and CC 42759 241 28 a a DT 42759 241 29 decrease decrease NN 42759 241 30 in in IN 42759 241 31 the the DT 42759 241 32 number number NN 42759 241 33 of of IN 42759 241 34 great great JJ 42759 241 35 estates estate NNS 42759 241 36 . . . 42759 242 1 This this DT 42759 242 2 tendency tendency NN 42759 242 3 has have VBZ 42759 242 4 been be VBN 42759 242 5 especially especially RB 42759 242 6 marked mark VBN 42759 242 7 during during IN 42759 242 8 the the DT 42759 242 9 last last JJ 42759 242 10 one one CD 42759 242 11 hundred hundred CD 42759 242 12 years year NNS 42759 242 13 . . . 42759 243 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 243 2 will will MD 42759 243 3 , , , 42759 243 4 however however RB 42759 243 5 , , , 42759 243 6 need need VBP 42759 243 7 to to TO 42759 243 8 continue continue VB 42759 243 9 for for IN 42759 243 10 a a DT 42759 243 11 very very RB 42759 243 12 long long JJ 42759 243 13 time time NN 42759 243 14 , , , 42759 243 15 or or CC 42759 243 16 else else RB 42759 243 17 to to TO 42759 243 18 increase increase VB 42759 243 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 243 20 pace pace NN 42759 243 21 very very RB 42759 243 22 rapidly rapidly RB 42759 243 23 , , , 42759 243 24 before before IN 42759 243 25 land land NN 42759 243 26 ownership ownership NN 42759 243 27 will will MD 42759 243 28 be be VB 42759 243 29 diffused diffuse VBN 42759 243 30 in in IN 42759 243 31 anything anything NN 42759 243 32 like like IN 42759 243 33 the the DT 42759 243 34 measure measure NN 42759 243 35 that that WDT 42759 243 36 is be VBZ 42759 243 37 necessary necessary JJ 42759 243 38 if if IN 42759 243 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 243 40 benefits benefit NNS 42759 243 41 are be VBP 42759 243 42 to to TO 42759 243 43 be be VB 42759 243 44 shared share VBN 42759 243 45 by by IN 42759 243 46 all all PDT 42759 243 47 the the DT 42759 243 48 people people NNS 42759 243 49 . . . 42759 244 1 Even even RB 42759 244 2 in in IN 42759 244 3 the the DT 42759 244 4 United United NNP 42759 244 5 States States NNP 42759 244 6 , , , 42759 244 7 where where WRB 42759 244 8 the the DT 42759 244 9 distribution distribution NN 42759 244 10 is be VBZ 42759 244 11 perhaps perhaps RB 42759 244 12 more more RBR 42759 244 13 general general JJ 42759 244 14 than than IN 42759 244 15 in in IN 42759 244 16 any any DT 42759 244 17 other other JJ 42759 244 18 country country NN 42759 244 19 , , , 42759 244 20 only only RB 42759 244 21 38.4 38.4 CD 42759 244 22 per per NN 42759 244 23 cent cent NN 42759 244 24 . . . 42759 245 1 of of IN 42759 245 2 the the DT 42759 245 3 families family NNS 42759 245 4 in in IN 42759 245 5 towns town NNS 42759 245 6 and and CC 42759 245 7 cities city NNS 42759 245 8 owned own VBN 42759 245 9 , , , 42759 245 10 in in IN 42759 245 11 1910 1910 CD 42759 245 12 , , , 42759 245 13 the the DT 42759 245 14 homes home NNS 42759 245 15 in in IN 42759 245 16 which which WDT 42759 245 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 245 18 lived live VBD 42759 245 19 , , , 42759 245 20 and and CC 42759 245 21 therefore therefore RB 42759 245 22 the the DT 42759 245 23 land land NN 42759 245 24 upon upon IN 42759 245 25 which which WDT 42759 245 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 245 27 homes home NNS 42759 245 28 were be VBD 42759 245 29 located locate VBN 42759 245 30 . . . 42759 246 1 In in IN 42759 246 2 the the DT 42759 246 3 rural rural JJ 42759 246 4 districts district NNS 42759 246 5 the the DT 42759 246 6 per per IN 42759 246 7 cent cent NN 42759 246 8 . . . 42759 247 1 of of IN 42759 247 2 home home RB 42759 247 3 - - HYPH 42759 247 4 owning own VBG 42759 247 5 families family NNS 42759 247 6 was be VBD 42759 247 7 only only RB 42759 247 8 62.8 62.8 CD 42759 247 9 . . . 42759 248 1 _ _ NNP 42759 248 2 Conclusions Conclusions NNPS 42759 248 3 from from IN 42759 248 4 History history NN 42759 248 5 _ _ NNP 42759 248 6 What what WDT 42759 248 7 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 248 8 does do VBZ 42759 248 9 history history NN 42759 248 10 warrant warrant VB 42759 248 11 concerning concern VBG 42759 248 12 the the DT 42759 248 13 social social JJ 42759 248 14 and and CC 42759 248 15 moral moral JJ 42759 248 16 value value NN 42759 248 17 of of IN 42759 248 18 private private JJ 42759 248 19 landownership landownership NN 42759 248 20 ? ? . 42759 249 1 Here here RB 42759 249 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 249 3 are be VBP 42759 249 4 on on IN 42759 249 5 very very RB 42759 249 6 uncertain uncertain JJ 42759 249 7 ground ground NN 42759 249 8 ; ; : 42759 249 9 for for IN 42759 249 10 different different JJ 42759 249 11 inferences inference NNS 42759 249 12 may may MD 42759 249 13 be be VB 42759 249 14 drawn draw VBN 42759 249 15 from from IN 42759 249 16 the the DT 42759 249 17 same same JJ 42759 249 18 group group NN 42759 249 19 of of IN 42759 249 20 facts fact NNS 42759 249 21 if if IN 42759 249 22 a a DT 42759 249 23 different different JJ 42759 249 24 section section NN 42759 249 25 of of IN 42759 249 26 them -PRON- PRP 42759 249 27 be be VB 42759 249 28 selected select VBN 42759 249 29 for for IN 42759 249 30 emphasis emphasis NN 42759 249 31 . . . 42759 250 1 Sir Sir NNP 42759 250 2 Henry Henry NNP 42759 250 3 Maine Maine NNP 42759 250 4 and and CC 42759 250 5 Henry Henry NNP 42759 250 6 George George NNP 42759 250 7 both both DT 42759 250 8 accepted accept VBD 42759 250 9 the the DT 42759 250 10 theory theory NN 42759 250 11 of of IN 42759 250 12 primitive primitive JJ 42759 250 13 agrarian agrarian JJ 42759 250 14 communism communism NN 42759 250 15 , , , 42759 250 16 but but CC 42759 250 17 the the DT 42759 250 18 former former JJ 42759 250 19 saw saw NN 42759 250 20 in in IN 42759 250 21 this this DT 42759 250 22 assumed assume VBN 42759 250 23 fact fact NN 42759 250 24 a a DT 42759 250 25 proof proof NN 42759 250 26 that that IN 42759 250 27 common common JJ 42759 250 28 ownership ownership NN 42759 250 29 was be VBD 42759 250 30 suited suit VBN 42759 250 31 only only RB 42759 250 32 to to IN 42759 250 33 the the DT 42759 250 34 needs need NNS 42759 250 35 of of IN 42759 250 36 rude rude JJ 42759 250 37 and and CC 42759 250 38 undeveloped undeveloped JJ 42759 250 39 peoples people NNS 42759 250 40 , , , 42759 250 41 while while IN 42759 250 42 the the DT 42759 250 43 latter latter JJ 42759 250 44 regarded regard VBD 42759 250 45 it -PRON- PRP 42759 250 46 as as IN 42759 250 47 a a DT 42759 250 48 sure sure JJ 42759 250 49 indication indication NN 42759 250 50 that that IN 42759 250 51 common common JJ 42759 250 52 ownership ownership NN 42759 250 53 was be VBD 42759 250 54 fundamentally fundamentally RB 42759 250 55 natural natural JJ 42759 250 56 and and CC 42759 250 57 in in IN 42759 250 58 accordance accordance NN 42759 250 59 with with IN 42759 250 60 permanent permanent JJ 42759 250 61 social social JJ 42759 250 62 welfare welfare NN 42759 250 63 . . . 42759 251 1 The the DT 42759 251 2 fact fact NN 42759 251 3 that that IN 42759 251 4 practically practically RB 42759 251 5 all all DT 42759 251 6 peoples people NNS 42759 251 7 whose whose WP$ 42759 251 8 history history NN 42759 251 9 we -PRON- PRP 42759 251 10 know know VBP 42759 251 11 discarded discard VBN 42759 251 12 communal communal NN 42759 251 13 for for IN 42759 251 14 private private JJ 42759 251 15 ownership ownership NN 42759 251 16 as as RB 42759 251 17 soon soon RB 42759 251 18 as as IN 42759 251 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 251 20 had have VBD 42759 251 21 acquired acquire VBN 42759 251 22 a a DT 42759 251 23 moderate moderate JJ 42759 251 24 degree degree NN 42759 251 25 of of IN 42759 251 26 proficiency proficiency NN 42759 251 27 in in IN 42759 251 28 methods method NNS 42759 251 29 of of IN 42759 251 30 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 251 31 and and CC 42759 251 32 in in IN 42759 251 33 the the DT 42759 251 34 arts art NNS 42759 251 35 of of IN 42759 251 36 civilised civilised JJ 42759 251 37 life life NN 42759 251 38 does do VBZ 42759 251 39 , , , 42759 251 40 indeed indeed RB 42759 251 41 , , , 42759 251 42 create create VB 42759 251 43 a a DT 42759 251 44 presumption presumption NN 42759 251 45 that that IN 42759 251 46 the the DT 42759 251 47 latter latter JJ 42759 251 48 system system NN 42759 251 49 is be VBZ 42759 251 50 the the DT 42759 251 51 better well JJR 42759 251 52 for for IN 42759 251 53 civilised civilised JJ 42759 251 54 men man NNS 42759 251 55 . . . 42759 252 1 To to IN 42759 252 2 this this DT 42759 252 3 extent extent NN 42759 252 4 Sir Sir NNP 42759 252 5 Henry Henry NNP 42759 252 6 Maine Maine NNP 42759 252 7 is be VBZ 42759 252 8 right right JJ 42759 252 9 . . . 42759 253 1 Against against IN 42759 253 2 this this DT 42759 253 3 presumption presumption NN 42759 253 4 Henry Henry NNP 42759 253 5 George George NNP 42759 253 6 maintained maintain VBD 42759 253 7 that that IN 42759 253 8 common common JJ 42759 253 9 ownership ownership NN 42759 253 10 was be VBD 42759 253 11 abandoned abandon VBN 42759 253 12 solely solely RB 42759 253 13 because because IN 42759 253 14 of of IN 42759 253 15 the the DT 42759 253 16 usurpation usurpation NN 42759 253 17 , , , 42759 253 18 fraud fraud NN 42759 253 19 , , , 42759 253 20 and and CC 42759 253 21 force force NN 42759 253 22 employed employ VBN 42759 253 23 by by IN 42759 253 24 the the DT 42759 253 25 powerful powerful JJ 42759 253 26 and and CC 42759 253 27 privileged privileged JJ 42759 253 28 classes class NNS 42759 253 29 . . . 42759 254 1 Undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 254 2 this this DT 42759 254 3 factor factor NN 42759 254 4 played play VBD 42759 254 5 a a DT 42759 254 6 great great JJ 42759 254 7 part part NN 42759 254 8 in in IN 42759 254 9 bringing bring VBG 42759 254 10 about about RP 42759 254 11 the the DT 42759 254 12 private private JJ 42759 254 13 ownership ownership NN 42759 254 14 that that WDT 42759 254 15 has have VBZ 42759 254 16 existed exist VBN 42759 254 17 and and CC 42759 254 18 still still RB 42759 254 19 exists exist VBZ 42759 254 20 , , , 42759 254 21 but but CC 42759 254 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 254 23 does do VBZ 42759 254 24 not not RB 42759 254 25 account account VB 42759 254 26 for for IN 42759 254 27 the the DT 42759 254 28 institution institution NN 42759 254 29 as as IN 42759 254 30 a a DT 42759 254 31 whole whole NN 42759 254 32 and and CC 42759 254 33 everywhere everywhere RB 42759 254 34 . . . 42759 255 1 If if IN 42759 255 2 chiefs chief NNS 42759 255 3 , , , 42759 255 4 kings king NNS 42759 255 5 , , , 42759 255 6 and and CC 42759 255 7 other other JJ 42759 255 8 powerful powerful JJ 42759 255 9 personages personage NNS 42759 255 10 had have VBD 42759 255 11 never never RB 42759 255 12 usurped usurp VBN 42759 255 13 control control NN 42759 255 14 of of IN 42759 255 15 the the DT 42759 255 16 land land NN 42759 255 17 , , , 42759 255 18 if if IN 42759 255 19 no no DT 42759 255 20 people people NNS 42759 255 21 had have VBD 42759 255 22 ever ever RB 42759 255 23 conquered conquer VBN 42759 255 24 the the DT 42759 255 25 territory territory NN 42759 255 26 of of IN 42759 255 27 another another DT 42759 255 28 , , , 42759 255 29 it -PRON- PRP 42759 255 30 is be VBZ 42759 255 31 probable probable JJ 42759 255 32 that that IN 42759 255 33 private private JJ 42759 255 34 ownership ownership NN 42759 255 35 would would MD 42759 255 36 have have VB 42759 255 37 taken take VBN 42759 255 38 place place NN 42759 255 39 to to IN 42759 255 40 the the DT 42759 255 41 same same JJ 42759 255 42 extent extent NN 42759 255 43 , , , 42759 255 44 although although IN 42759 255 45 it -PRON- PRP 42759 255 46 would would MD 42759 255 47 have have VB 42759 255 48 been be VBN 42759 255 49 much much RB 42759 255 50 more more RBR 42759 255 51 widely widely RB 42759 255 52 diffused diffuse VBN 42759 255 53 . . . 42759 256 1 For for IN 42759 256 2 the the DT 42759 256 3 system system NN 42759 256 4 of of IN 42759 256 5 periodical periodical JJ 42759 256 6 repartition repartition NN 42759 256 7 of of IN 42759 256 8 land land NN 42759 256 9 , , , 42759 256 10 to to TO 42759 256 11 say say VB 42759 256 12 nothing nothing NN 42759 256 13 of of IN 42759 256 14 communal communal JJ 42759 256 15 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 256 16 and and CC 42759 256 17 communal communal JJ 42759 256 18 distribution distribution NN 42759 256 19 of of IN 42759 256 20 the the DT 42759 256 21 product product NN 42759 256 22 , , , 42759 256 23 does do VBZ 42759 256 24 hinder hinder VB 42759 256 25 that that DT 42759 256 26 attachment attachment NN 42759 256 27 to to IN 42759 256 28 a a DT 42759 256 29 particular particular JJ 42759 256 30 portion portion NN 42759 256 31 of of IN 42759 256 32 the the DT 42759 256 33 soil soil NN 42759 256 34 and and CC 42759 256 35 that that DT 42759 256 36 intensive intensive JJ 42759 256 37 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 256 38 which which WDT 42759 256 39 are be VBP 42759 256 40 so so RB 42759 256 41 necessary necessary JJ 42759 256 42 to to IN 42759 256 43 the the DT 42759 256 44 best good JJS 42759 256 45 interests interest NNS 42759 256 46 of of IN 42759 256 47 the the DT 42759 256 48 cultivator cultivator NN 42759 256 49 , , , 42759 256 50 the the DT 42759 256 51 most most RBS 42759 256 52 productive productive JJ 42759 256 53 use use NN 42759 256 54 of of IN 42759 256 55 the the DT 42759 256 56 land land NN 42759 256 57 , , , 42759 256 58 and and CC 42759 256 59 therefore therefore RB 42759 256 60 the the DT 42759 256 61 welfare welfare NN 42759 256 62 of of IN 42759 256 63 society society NN 42759 256 64 . . . 42759 257 1 On on IN 42759 257 2 the the DT 42759 257 3 other other JJ 42759 257 4 hand hand NN 42759 257 5 , , , 42759 257 6 the the DT 42759 257 7 limitations limitation NNS 42759 257 8 on on IN 42759 257 9 the the DT 42759 257 10 right right NN 42759 257 11 of of IN 42759 257 12 private private JJ 42759 257 13 ownership ownership NN 42759 257 14 which which WDT 42759 257 15 have have VBP 42759 257 16 been be VBN 42759 257 17 established establish VBN 42759 257 18 in in IN 42759 257 19 so so RB 42759 257 20 many many JJ 42759 257 21 places place NNS 42759 257 22 and and CC 42759 257 23 times time NNS 42759 257 24 in in IN 42759 257 25 favour favour NN 42759 257 26 of of IN 42759 257 27 those those DT 42759 257 28 who who WP 42759 257 29 were be VBD 42759 257 30 not not RB 42759 257 31 owners owner NNS 42759 257 32 , , , 42759 257 33 show show VBP 42759 257 34 that that IN 42759 257 35 men man NNS 42759 257 36 have have VBP 42759 257 37 very very RB 42759 257 38 generally generally RB 42759 257 39 looked look VBN 42759 257 40 upon upon IN 42759 257 41 land land NN 42759 257 42 as as IN 42759 257 43 in in IN 42759 257 44 some some DT 42759 257 45 measure measure NN 42759 257 46 the the DT 42759 257 47 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 257 48 of of IN 42759 257 49 all all PDT 42759 257 50 the the DT 42759 257 51 people people NNS 42759 257 52 . . . 42759 258 1 Hence hence RB 42759 258 2 arises arise VBZ 42759 258 3 the the DT 42759 258 4 presumption presumption NN 42759 258 5 that that IN 42759 258 6 this this DT 42759 258 7 conviction conviction NN 42759 258 8 is be VBZ 42759 258 9 but but CC 42759 258 10 the the DT 42759 258 11 reflection reflection NN 42759 258 12 of of IN 42759 258 13 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 258 14 and and CC 42759 258 15 permanent permanent JJ 42759 258 16 human human JJ 42759 258 17 needs need NNS 42759 258 18 . . . 42759 259 1 Summing sum VBG 42759 259 2 up up RP 42759 259 3 the the DT 42759 259 4 matter matter NN 42759 259 5 , , , 42759 259 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 259 7 may may MD 42759 259 8 say say VB 42759 259 9 that that IN 42759 259 10 the the DT 42759 259 11 history history NN 42759 259 12 of of IN 42759 259 13 land land NN 42759 259 14 tenure tenure NN 42759 259 15 points point NNS 42759 259 16 on on IN 42759 259 17 the the DT 42759 259 18 whole whole NN 42759 259 19 to to IN 42759 259 20 the the DT 42759 259 21 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 259 22 that that IN 42759 259 23 private private JJ 42759 259 24 ownership ownership NN 42759 259 25 is be VBZ 42759 259 26 socially socially RB 42759 259 27 and and CC 42759 259 28 individually individually RB 42759 259 29 preferable preferable JJ 42759 259 30 to to IN 42759 259 31 agrarian agrarian JJ 42759 259 32 communism communism NN 42759 259 33 , , , 42759 259 34 but but CC 42759 259 35 that that IN 42759 259 36 it -PRON- PRP 42759 259 37 should should MD 42759 259 38 be be VB 42759 259 39 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 259 40 strictly strictly RB 42759 259 41 limited limited JJ 42759 259 42 in in IN 42759 259 43 the the DT 42759 259 44 interest interest NN 42759 259 45 of of IN 42759 259 46 the the DT 42759 259 47 non non JJ 42759 259 48 - - NNS 42759 259 49 owners owner NNS 42759 259 50 , , , 42759 259 51 and and CC 42759 259 52 of of IN 42759 259 53 the the DT 42759 259 54 community community NN 42759 259 55 as as IN 42759 259 56 a a DT 42759 259 57 whole whole NN 42759 259 58 . . . 42759 260 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 260 2 : : : 42759 260 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 260 4 1 1 LS 42759 260 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 260 6 The the DT 42759 260 7 most most RBS 42759 260 8 notable notable JJ 42759 260 9 exponents exponent NNS 42759 260 10 of of IN 42759 260 11 this this DT 42759 260 12 view view NN 42759 260 13 were be VBD 42759 260 14 : : : 42759 260 15 Von Von NNP 42759 260 16 Maurer Maurer NNP 42759 260 17 , , , 42759 260 18 " " '' 42759 260 19 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 42759 260 20 zur zur NNP 42759 260 21 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 42759 260 22 der der VBD 42759 260 23 Mark Mark NNP 42759 260 24 , , , 42759 260 25 " " '' 42759 260 26 1854 1854 CD 42759 260 27 ; ; : 42759 260 28 Viollet Viollet NNP 42759 260 29 , , , 42759 260 30 " " `` 42759 260 31 Bibliotheque Bibliotheque NNP 42759 260 32 de de FW 42759 260 33 l'école l'école FW 42759 260 34 des des NNP 42759 260 35 chartres chartre VBZ 42759 260 36 , , , 42759 260 37 " " '' 42759 260 38 1872 1872 CD 42759 260 39 ; ; : 42759 260 40 Maine Maine NNP 42759 260 41 , , , 42759 260 42 " " `` 42759 260 43 Village village NN 42759 260 44 Communities Communities NNPS 42759 260 45 in in IN 42759 260 46 the the DT 42759 260 47 East East NNP 42759 260 48 and and CC 42759 260 49 the the DT 42759 260 50 West West NNP 42759 260 51 , , , 42759 260 52 " " '' 42759 260 53 1872 1872 CD 42759 260 54 ; ; : 42759 260 55 and and CC 42759 260 56 De De NNP 42759 260 57 Laveleye Laveleye NNP 42759 260 58 , , , 42759 260 59 " " `` 42759 260 60 De De NNP 42759 260 61 la la NNP 42759 260 62 propriété propriété NNP 42759 260 63 et et NNP 42759 260 64 ses se VBZ 42759 260 65 formes forme NNS 42759 260 66 primitives primitive NNS 42759 260 67 , , , 42759 260 68 " " '' 42759 260 69 1874 1874 CD 42759 260 70 , , , 42759 260 71 of of IN 42759 260 72 which which WDT 42759 260 73 an an DT 42759 260 74 English english JJ 42759 260 75 translation translation NN 42759 260 76 appeared appear VBD 42759 260 77 in in IN 42759 260 78 1878 1878 CD 42759 260 79 under under IN 42759 260 80 the the DT 42759 260 81 title title NN 42759 260 82 , , , 42759 260 83 " " `` 42759 260 84 Primitive Primitive NNP 42759 260 85 Property Property NNP 42759 260 86 . . . 42759 260 87 " " '' 42759 261 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 261 2 2 2 LS 42759 261 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 261 4 Chief Chief NNP 42759 261 5 among among IN 42759 261 6 these these DT 42759 261 7 writers writer NNS 42759 261 8 are be VBP 42759 261 9 : : : 42759 261 10 Fustel Fustel NNP 42759 261 11 de de FW 42759 261 12 Coulanges Coulanges NNP 42759 261 13 in in IN 42759 261 14 an an DT 42759 261 15 article article NN 42759 261 16 in in IN 42759 261 17 " " `` 42759 261 18 Revue Revue NNP 42759 261 19 des des NNP 42759 261 20 Questions Questions NNP 42759 261 21 Historiques Historiques NNP 42759 261 22 , , , 42759 261 23 " " `` 42759 261 24 April April NNP 42759 261 25 , , , 42759 261 26 1889 1889 CD 42759 261 27 ; ; : 42759 261 28 translated translate VBN 42759 261 29 by by IN 42759 261 30 Margaret Margaret NNP 42759 261 31 Ashley Ashley NNP 42759 261 32 , , , 42759 261 33 and and CC 42759 261 34 published publish VBN 42759 261 35 with with IN 42759 261 36 an an DT 42759 261 37 introductory introductory JJ 42759 261 38 chapter chapter NN 42759 261 39 by by IN 42759 261 40 W. W. NNP 42759 261 41 J. J. NNP 42759 261 42 Ashley Ashley NNP 42759 261 43 under under IN 42759 261 44 the the DT 42759 261 45 title title NN 42759 261 46 , , , 42759 261 47 " " `` 42759 261 48 The the DT 42759 261 49 Origin Origin NNP 42759 261 50 of of IN 42759 261 51 Property Property NNP 42759 261 52 in in IN 42759 261 53 Land Land NNP 42759 261 54 , , , 42759 261 55 " " '' 42759 261 56 1891 1891 CD 42759 261 57 ; ; : 42759 261 58 G. G. NNP 42759 261 59 Von Von NNP 42759 261 60 Below below RB 42759 261 61 , , , 42759 261 62 " " `` 42759 261 63 Beilage beilage NN 42759 261 64 zur zur NNP 42759 261 65 Allgemeine Allgemeine NNP 42759 261 66 Zeitung Zeitung NNP 42759 261 67 : : : 42759 261 68 Das Das NNP 42759 261 69 kurze kurze NNP 42759 261 70 Leben Leben NNP 42759 261 71 einer einer NN 42759 261 72 vielgenannten vielgenannten JJ 42759 261 73 Theorie Theorie NNP 42759 261 74 , , , 42759 261 75 " " '' 42759 261 76 1903 1903 CD 42759 261 77 ; ; : 42759 261 78 F. F. NNP 42759 261 79 Seebohm Seebohm NNP 42759 261 80 , , , 42759 261 81 " " `` 42759 261 82 The the DT 42759 261 83 Village Village NNP 42759 261 84 Community community NN 42759 261 85 , , , 42759 261 86 " " '' 42759 261 87 1883 1883 CD 42759 261 88 . . . 42759 262 1 Cf cf NN 42759 262 2 . . . 42759 263 1 Whittaker Whittaker NNP 42759 263 2 , , , 42759 263 3 " " `` 42759 263 4 Ownership Ownership NNP 42759 263 5 , , , 42759 263 6 Tenure Tenure NNP 42759 263 7 , , , 42759 263 8 and and CC 42759 263 9 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 263 10 of of IN 42759 263 11 Land Land NNP 42759 263 12 , , , 42759 263 13 " " '' 42759 263 14 1914 1914 CD 42759 263 15 , , , 42759 263 16 ch ch NN 42759 263 17 . . . 42759 264 1 ii ii LS 42759 264 2 ; ; : 42759 264 3 Cathrein Cathrein NNP 42759 264 4 , , , 42759 264 5 " " `` 42759 264 6 Das Das NNP 42759 264 7 Privatgrundeigenthum Privatgrundeigenthum NNP 42759 264 8 und und JJ 42759 264 9 seine seine NN 42759 264 10 Gegner Gegner NNP 42759 264 11 , , , 42759 264 12 " " '' 42759 264 13 1909 1909 CD 42759 264 14 ; ; : 42759 264 15 and and CC 42759 264 16 Pesch Pesch NNP 42759 264 17 , , , 42759 264 18 " " '' 42759 264 19 Lehrbuch lehrbuch NN 42759 264 20 der der NN 42759 264 21 Nationaloekonomie Nationaloekonomie NNP 42759 264 22 , , , 42759 264 23 " " `` 42759 264 24 I -PRON- PRP 42759 264 25 , , , 42759 264 26 183 183 CD 42759 264 27 - - SYM 42759 264 28 188 188 CD 42759 264 29 . . . 42759 265 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 265 2 3 3 LS 42759 265 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 265 4 Quoted quote VBN 42759 265 5 in in IN 42759 265 6 Whittaker Whittaker NNP 42759 265 7 , , , 42759 265 8 op op NN 42759 265 9 . . . 42759 266 1 cit cit NNP 42759 266 2 . . . 42759 266 3 , , , 42759 266 4 pp pp NNP 42759 266 5 . . . 42759 267 1 27 27 CD 42759 267 2 , , , 42759 267 3 28 28 CD 42759 267 4 . . . 42759 268 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 268 2 4 4 LS 42759 268 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 268 4 Idem Idem NNP 42759 268 5 , , , 42759 268 6 p. p. NN 42759 268 7 29 29 CD 42759 268 8 . . . 42759 269 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 269 2 5 5 CD 42759 269 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 269 4 Cf cf NN 42759 269 5 . . . 42759 270 1 P. P. NNP 42759 270 2 W. W. NNP 42759 270 3 Joyce Joyce NNP 42759 270 4 , , , 42759 270 5 " " `` 42759 270 6 A a DT 42759 270 7 Social Social NNP 42759 270 8 History history NN 42759 270 9 of of IN 42759 270 10 Ancient Ancient NNP 42759 270 11 Ireland Ireland NNP 42759 270 12 , , , 42759 270 13 " " '' 42759 270 14 1903 1903 CD 42759 270 15 ; ; : 42759 270 16 and and CC 42759 270 17 Letourneau Letourneau NNP 42759 270 18 , , , 42759 270 19 " " `` 42759 270 20 Property property NN 42759 270 21 : : : 42759 270 22 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 270 23 Origin Origin NNP 42759 270 24 and and CC 42759 270 25 Development Development NNP 42759 270 26 , , , 42759 270 27 " " '' 42759 270 28 1896 1896 CD 42759 270 29 . . . 42759 271 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 271 2 6 6 CD 42759 271 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 271 4 Whittaker Whittaker NNP 42759 271 5 , , , 42759 271 6 op op NN 42759 271 7 . . . 42759 272 1 cit cit NNP 42759 272 2 . . . 42759 272 3 , , , 42759 272 4 pp pp NNP 42759 272 5 . . . 42759 273 1 30 30 CD 42759 273 2 , , , 42759 273 3 31 31 CD 42759 273 4 . . . 42759 274 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 274 2 7 7 LS 42759 274 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 274 4 Leviticus Leviticus NNP 42759 274 5 xxv xxv NNP 42759 274 6 , , , 42759 274 7 23 23 CD 42759 274 8 - - SYM 42759 274 9 28 28 CD 42759 274 10 . . . 42759 275 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 42759 275 2 III III NNP 42759 275 3 THE the DT 42759 275 4 ARGUMENTS argument NNS 42759 275 5 AGAINST against IN 42759 275 6 PRIVATE private JJ 42759 275 7 LANDOWNERSHIP landownership NN 42759 275 8 If if IN 42759 275 9 land land NN 42759 275 10 were be VBD 42759 275 11 not not RB 42759 275 12 privately privately RB 42759 275 13 owned own VBN 42759 275 14 there there EX 42759 275 15 would would MD 42759 275 16 be be VB 42759 275 17 no no DT 42759 275 18 receiving receiving NN 42759 275 19 of of IN 42759 275 20 rent rent NN 42759 275 21 by by IN 42759 275 22 individuals individual NNS 42759 275 23 . . . 42759 276 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 276 2 , , , 42759 276 3 the the DT 42759 276 4 morality morality NN 42759 276 5 of of IN 42759 276 6 the the DT 42759 276 7 landlord landlord NN 42759 276 8 's 's POS 42759 276 9 share share NN 42759 276 10 of of IN 42759 276 11 the the DT 42759 276 12 national national JJ 42759 276 13 product product NN 42759 276 14 is be VBZ 42759 276 15 intimately intimately RB 42759 276 16 related related JJ 42759 276 17 to to IN 42759 276 18 , , , 42759 276 19 and and CC 42759 276 20 is be VBZ 42759 276 21 usually usually RB 42759 276 22 treated treat VBN 42759 276 23 in in IN 42759 276 24 connection connection NN 42759 276 25 with with IN 42759 276 26 , , , 42759 276 27 the the DT 42759 276 28 morality morality NN 42759 276 29 of of IN 42759 276 30 private private JJ 42759 276 31 ownership ownership NN 42759 276 32 . . . 42759 277 1 Substantially substantially RB 42759 277 2 all all PDT 42759 277 3 the the DT 42759 277 4 opponents opponent NNS 42759 277 5 of of IN 42759 277 6 private private JJ 42759 277 7 property property NN 42759 277 8 in in IN 42759 277 9 land land NN 42759 277 10 to to IN 42759 277 11 - - HYPH 42759 277 12 day day NN 42759 277 13 are be VBP 42759 277 14 either either DT 42759 277 15 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 277 16 or or CC 42759 277 17 disciples disciple NNS 42759 277 18 of of IN 42759 277 19 Henry Henry NNP 42759 277 20 George George NNP 42759 277 21 . . . 42759 278 1 In in IN 42759 278 2 the the DT 42759 278 3 view view NN 42759 278 4 of of IN 42759 278 5 the the DT 42759 278 6 former former JJ 42759 278 7 , , , 42759 278 8 land land NN 42759 278 9 as as RB 42759 278 10 well well RB 42759 278 11 as as IN 42759 278 12 the the DT 42759 278 13 other other JJ 42759 278 14 means mean NNS 42759 278 15 of of IN 42759 278 16 production production NN 42759 278 17 should should MD 42759 278 18 be be VB 42759 278 19 owned own VBN 42759 278 20 and and CC 42759 278 21 managed manage VBN 42759 278 22 by by IN 42759 278 23 the the DT 42759 278 24 State State NNP 42759 278 25 . . . 42759 279 1 Although although IN 42759 279 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 279 3 are be VBP 42759 279 4 more more RBR 42759 279 5 numerous numerous JJ 42759 279 6 than than IN 42759 279 7 the the DT 42759 279 8 Georgeites Georgeites NNPS 42759 279 9 , , , 42759 279 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 279 11 attack attack NN 42759 279 12 upon upon IN 42759 279 13 private private JJ 42759 279 14 landownership landownership NN 42759 279 15 is be VBZ 42759 279 16 less less RBR 42759 279 17 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 42759 279 18 and and CC 42759 279 19 less less RBR 42759 279 20 formidable formidable JJ 42759 279 21 than than IN 42759 279 22 the the DT 42759 279 23 propaganda propaganda NN 42759 279 24 carried carry VBN 42759 279 25 on on RP 42759 279 26 by by IN 42759 279 27 the the DT 42759 279 28 Henry Henry NNP 42759 279 29 George George NNP 42759 279 30 men man NNS 42759 279 31 . . . 42759 280 1 The the DT 42759 280 2 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 280 3 give give VBP 42759 280 4 most most JJS 42759 280 5 of of IN 42759 280 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 280 7 attention attention NN 42759 280 8 to to IN 42759 280 9 the the DT 42759 280 10 artificial artificial JJ 42759 280 11 instruments instrument NNS 42759 280 12 of of IN 42759 280 13 production production NN 42759 280 14 , , , 42759 280 15 dealing deal VBG 42759 280 16 with with IN 42759 280 17 land land NN 42759 280 18 only only RB 42759 280 19 incidentally incidentally RB 42759 280 20 , , , 42759 280 21 implicitly implicitly RB 42759 280 22 , , , 42759 280 23 or or CC 42759 280 24 occasionally occasionally RB 42759 280 25 . . . 42759 281 1 The the DT 42759 281 2 followers follower NNS 42759 281 3 of of IN 42759 281 4 Henry Henry NNP 42759 281 5 George George NNP 42759 281 6 , , , 42759 281 7 commonly commonly RB 42759 281 8 known know VBN 42759 281 9 as as IN 42759 281 10 Single Single NNP 42759 281 11 Taxers Taxers NNPS 42759 281 12 or or CC 42759 281 13 Single Single NNP 42759 281 14 Tax tax NN 42759 281 15 men man NNS 42759 281 16 , , , 42759 281 17 defend defend VBP 42759 281 18 the the DT 42759 281 19 private private JJ 42759 281 20 ownership ownership NN 42759 281 21 of of IN 42759 281 22 artificial artificial JJ 42759 281 23 capital capital NN 42759 281 24 , , , 42759 281 25 or or CC 42759 281 26 capital capital NN 42759 281 27 in in IN 42759 281 28 the the DT 42759 281 29 strict strict JJ 42759 281 30 economic economic JJ 42759 281 31 sense sense NN 42759 281 32 , , , 42759 281 33 but but CC 42759 281 34 desire desire VB 42759 281 35 that that IN 42759 281 36 the the DT 42759 281 37 control control NN 42759 281 38 of of IN 42759 281 39 the the DT 42759 281 40 community community NN 42759 281 41 over over IN 42759 281 42 the the DT 42759 281 43 natural natural JJ 42759 281 44 means mean NNS 42759 281 45 of of IN 42759 281 46 production production NN 42759 281 47 should should MD 42759 281 48 be be VB 42759 281 49 so so RB 42759 281 50 far far RB 42759 281 51 extended extended JJ 42759 281 52 as as IN 42759 281 53 to to TO 42759 281 54 appropriate appropriate VB 42759 281 55 for for IN 42759 281 56 public public JJ 42759 281 57 uses use VBZ 42759 281 58 all all DT 42759 281 59 economic economic JJ 42759 281 60 rent rent NN 42759 281 61 . . . 42759 282 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 282 2 criticism criticism NN 42759 282 3 of of IN 42759 282 4 private private JJ 42759 282 5 ownership ownership NN 42759 282 6 is be VBZ 42759 282 7 not not RB 42759 282 8 only only RB 42759 282 9 more more RBR 42759 282 10 prominent prominent JJ 42759 282 11 than than IN 42759 282 12 that that DT 42759 282 13 made make VBN 42759 282 14 by by IN 42759 282 15 the the DT 42759 282 16 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 282 17 , , , 42759 282 18 but but CC 42759 282 19 is be VBZ 42759 282 20 based base VBN 42759 282 21 to to IN 42759 282 22 a a DT 42759 282 23 much much RB 42759 282 24 greater great JJR 42759 282 25 extent extent NN 42759 282 26 upon upon IN 42759 282 27 ethical ethical JJ 42759 282 28 considerations consideration NNS 42759 282 29 . . . 42759 283 1 _ _ NNP 42759 283 2 Arguments argument NNS 42759 283 3 by by IN 42759 283 4 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 283 5 _ _ NNP 42759 283 6 Indeed indeed RB 42759 283 7 , , , 42759 283 8 the the DT 42759 283 9 orthodox orthodox NN 42759 283 10 or or CC 42759 283 11 Marxian Marxian NNP 42759 283 12 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 283 13 are be VBP 42759 283 14 logically logically RB 42759 283 15 debarred debar VBN 42759 283 16 by by IN 42759 283 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 283 18 social social JJ 42759 283 19 philosophy philosophy NN 42759 283 20 from from IN 42759 283 21 passing pass VBG 42759 283 22 a a DT 42759 283 23 strictly strictly RB 42759 283 24 moral moral JJ 42759 283 25 judgment judgment NN 42759 283 26 upon upon IN 42759 283 27 property property NN 42759 283 28 in in IN 42759 283 29 land land NN 42759 283 30 . . . 42759 284 1 For for IN 42759 284 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 284 3 theory theory NN 42759 284 4 of of IN 42759 284 5 economic economic JJ 42759 284 6 determinism determinism NN 42759 284 7 , , , 42759 284 8 or or CC 42759 284 9 historical historical JJ 42759 284 10 materialism materialism NN 42759 284 11 , , , 42759 284 12 involves involve VBZ 42759 284 13 the the DT 42759 284 14 belief belief NN 42759 284 15 that that IN 42759 284 16 private private JJ 42759 284 17 landownership landownership NN 42759 284 18 , , , 42759 284 19 like like IN 42759 284 20 all all DT 42759 284 21 other other JJ 42759 284 22 social social JJ 42759 284 23 institutions institution NNS 42759 284 24 , , , 42759 284 25 is be VBZ 42759 284 26 a a DT 42759 284 27 _ _ NNP 42759 284 28 necessary necessary JJ 42759 284 29 product product NN 42759 284 30 _ _ NNP 42759 284 31 of of IN 42759 284 32 economic economic JJ 42759 284 33 forces force NNS 42759 284 34 and and CC 42759 284 35 processes process NNS 42759 284 36 . . . 42759 285 1 Hence hence RB 42759 285 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 285 3 is be VBZ 42759 285 4 neither neither CC 42759 285 5 morally morally RB 42759 285 6 good good JJ 42759 285 7 nor nor CC 42759 285 8 morally morally RB 42759 285 9 bad bad JJ 42759 285 10 . . . 42759 286 1 Since since IN 42759 286 2 neither neither CC 42759 286 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 286 4 existence existence NN 42759 286 5 nor nor CC 42759 286 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 286 7 continuance continuance NN 42759 286 8 depends depend VBZ 42759 286 9 upon upon IN 42759 286 10 the the DT 42759 286 11 human human NN 42759 286 12 will will NN 42759 286 13 , , , 42759 286 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 286 15 is be VBZ 42759 286 16 entirely entirely RB 42759 286 17 devoid devoid JJ 42759 286 18 of of IN 42759 286 19 moral moral JJ 42759 286 20 quality quality NN 42759 286 21 . . . 42759 287 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 287 2 is be VBZ 42759 287 3 as as RB 42759 287 4 unmoral unmoral JJ 42759 287 5 as as IN 42759 287 6 the the DT 42759 287 7 succession succession NN 42759 287 8 of of IN 42759 287 9 the the DT 42759 287 10 seasons season NNS 42759 287 11 , , , 42759 287 12 or or CC 42759 287 13 the the DT 42759 287 14 movement movement NN 42759 287 15 of of IN 42759 287 16 the the DT 42759 287 17 tides tide NNS 42759 287 18 . . . 42759 288 1 And and CC 42759 288 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 288 3 will will MD 42759 288 4 disappear disappear VB 42759 288 5 through through IN 42759 288 6 the the DT 42759 288 7 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 288 8 processes process NNS 42759 288 9 of of IN 42759 288 10 economic economic JJ 42759 288 11 evolution evolution NN 42759 288 12 . . . 42759 289 1 As as IN 42759 289 2 expressed express VBN 42759 289 3 by by IN 42759 289 4 Engels Engels NNP 42759 289 5 : : : 42759 289 6 " " `` 42759 289 7 The the DT 42759 289 8 growing grow VBG 42759 289 9 perception perception NN 42759 289 10 that that IN 42759 289 11 existing exist VBG 42759 289 12 social social JJ 42759 289 13 institutions institution NNS 42759 289 14 are be VBP 42759 289 15 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 289 16 and and CC 42759 289 17 unjust unjust JJ 42759 289 18 , , , 42759 289 19 that that DT 42759 289 20 reason reason NN 42759 289 21 has have VBZ 42759 289 22 become become VBN 42759 289 23 unreason unreason NNP 42759 289 24 , , , 42759 289 25 and and CC 42759 289 26 right right RB 42759 289 27 wrong wrong NN 42759 289 28 , , , 42759 289 29 is be VBZ 42759 289 30 only only RB 42759 289 31 proof proof NN 42759 289 32 that that IN 42759 289 33 in in IN 42759 289 34 the the DT 42759 289 35 modes mode NNS 42759 289 36 of of IN 42759 289 37 production production NN 42759 289 38 and and CC 42759 289 39 exchange exchange NN 42759 289 40 changes change NNS 42759 289 41 have have VBP 42759 289 42 taken take VBN 42759 289 43 place place NN 42759 289 44 , , , 42759 289 45 with with IN 42759 289 46 which which WDT 42759 289 47 the the DT 42759 289 48 social social JJ 42759 289 49 order order NN 42759 289 50 , , , 42759 289 51 adapted adapt VBN 42759 289 52 to to IN 42759 289 53 earlier early JJR 42759 289 54 economic economic JJ 42759 289 55 conditions condition NNS 42759 289 56 , , , 42759 289 57 is be VBZ 42759 289 58 no no DT 42759 289 59 longer long RBR 42759 289 60 in in IN 42759 289 61 keeping keep VBG 42759 289 62 . . . 42759 290 1 " " `` 42759 290 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 290 3 8 8 CD 42759 290 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 290 5 Frequently frequently RB 42759 290 6 , , , 42759 290 7 however however RB 42759 290 8 , , , 42759 290 9 the the DT 42759 290 10 individual individual JJ 42759 290 11 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 290 12 forgets forget NNS 42759 290 13 this this DT 42759 290 14 materialistic materialistic JJ 42759 290 15 theory theory NN 42759 290 16 , , , 42759 290 17 and and CC 42759 290 18 falls fall VBZ 42759 290 19 back back RB 42759 290 20 upon upon IN 42759 290 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 290 22 common common JJ 42759 290 23 sense sense NN 42759 290 24 , , , 42759 290 25 and and CC 42759 290 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 290 27 innate innate JJ 42759 290 28 conceptions conception NNS 42759 290 29 of of IN 42759 290 30 right right NN 42759 290 31 and and CC 42759 290 32 wrong wrong NN 42759 290 33 , , , 42759 290 34 of of IN 42759 290 35 free free JJ 42759 290 36 will will NN 42759 290 37 and and CC 42759 290 38 responsibility responsibility NN 42759 290 39 . . . 42759 291 1 Instead instead RB 42759 291 2 of of IN 42759 291 3 regarding regard VBG 42759 291 4 the the DT 42759 291 5 existing exist VBG 42759 291 6 land land NN 42759 291 7 system system NN 42759 291 8 as as IN 42759 291 9 a a DT 42759 291 10 mere mere JJ 42759 291 11 product product NN 42759 291 12 of of IN 42759 291 13 blind blind JJ 42759 291 14 economic economic JJ 42759 291 15 forces force NNS 42759 291 16 , , , 42759 291 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 291 18 often often RB 42759 291 19 denounces denounce VBZ 42759 291 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 291 21 as as RB 42759 291 22 morally morally RB 42759 291 23 wrong wrong JJ 42759 291 24 and and CC 42759 291 25 unjust unjust JJ 42759 291 26 . . . 42759 292 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 292 2 contentions contention NNS 42759 292 3 may may MD 42759 292 4 be be VB 42759 292 5 reduced reduce VBN 42759 292 6 to to IN 42759 292 7 two two CD 42759 292 8 propositions proposition NNS 42759 292 9 : : : 42759 292 10 The the DT 42759 292 11 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 292 12 who who WP 42759 292 13 takes take VBZ 42759 292 14 rent rent NN 42759 292 15 from from IN 42759 292 16 a a DT 42759 292 17 cultivator cultivator NN 42759 292 18 robs rob VBZ 42759 292 19 the the DT 42759 292 20 producer producer NN 42759 292 21 of of IN 42759 292 22 a a DT 42759 292 23 part part NN 42759 292 24 of of IN 42759 292 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 292 26 product product NN 42759 292 27 ; ; : 42759 292 28 and and CC 42759 292 29 no no DT 42759 292 30 one one NN 42759 292 31 has have VBZ 42759 292 32 a a DT 42759 292 33 right right NN 42759 292 34 to to TO 42759 292 35 take take VB 42759 292 36 for for IN 42759 292 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 292 38 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 292 39 use use NN 42759 292 40 that that DT 42759 292 41 which which WDT 42759 292 42 is be VBZ 42759 292 43 the the DT 42759 292 44 natural natural JJ 42759 292 45 heritage heritage NN 42759 292 46 and and CC 42759 292 47 means mean NNS 42759 292 48 of of IN 42759 292 49 support support NN 42759 292 50 for for IN 42759 292 51 all all PDT 42759 292 52 the the DT 42759 292 53 people people NNS 42759 292 54 . . . 42759 293 1 Referring refer VBG 42759 293 2 to to IN 42759 293 3 the the DT 42759 293 4 receipt receipt NN 42759 293 5 of of IN 42759 293 6 35,000,000 35,000,000 CD 42759 293 7 pounds pound NNS 42759 293 8 a a DT 42759 293 9 year year NN 42759 293 10 in in IN 42759 293 11 rent rent NN 42759 293 12 by by IN 42759 293 13 8,000 8,000 CD 42759 293 14 British british JJ 42759 293 15 landlords landlord NNS 42759 293 16 , , , 42759 293 17 Hyndman Hyndman NNP 42759 293 18 and and CC 42759 293 19 Morris Morris NNP 42759 293 20 exclaim exclaim VBP 42759 293 21 : : : 42759 293 22 " " `` 42759 293 23 Yet yet CC 42759 293 24 in in IN 42759 293 25 the the DT 42759 293 26 face face NN 42759 293 27 of of IN 42759 293 28 all all PDT 42759 293 29 this this DT 42759 293 30 a a DT 42759 293 31 certain certain JJ 42759 293 32 school school NN 42759 293 33 still still RB 42759 293 34 contend contend VBP 42759 293 35 that that IN 42759 293 36 there there EX 42759 293 37 is be VBZ 42759 293 38 no no DT 42759 293 39 class class NN 42759 293 40 robbery robbery NN 42759 293 41 . . . 42759 294 1 " " `` 42759 294 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 294 3 9 9 CD 42759 294 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 294 5 Since since IN 42759 294 6 the the DT 42759 294 7 claim claim NN 42759 294 8 that that IN 42759 294 9 the the DT 42759 294 10 labourer labourer NN 42759 294 11 has have VBZ 42759 294 12 a a DT 42759 294 13 right right NN 42759 294 14 to to IN 42759 294 15 the the DT 42759 294 16 full full JJ 42759 294 17 product product NN 42759 294 18 of of IN 42759 294 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 294 20 labour labour NN 42759 294 21 applies apply VBZ 42759 294 22 to to IN 42759 294 23 capital capital VB 42759 294 24 as as RB 42759 294 25 well well RB 42759 294 26 as as IN 42759 294 27 to to IN 42759 294 28 land land NN 42759 294 29 , , , 42759 294 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 294 31 can can MD 42759 294 32 be be VB 42759 294 33 more more RBR 42759 294 34 conveniently conveniently RB 42759 294 35 considered consider VBN 42759 294 36 when when WRB 42759 294 37 we -PRON- PRP 42759 294 38 come come VBP 42759 294 39 to to TO 42759 294 40 treat treat VB 42759 294 41 of of IN 42759 294 42 the the DT 42759 294 43 income income NN 42759 294 44 of of IN 42759 294 45 the the DT 42759 294 46 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 294 47 . . . 42759 295 1 With with IN 42759 295 2 regard regard NN 42759 295 3 to to IN 42759 295 4 the the DT 42759 295 5 second second JJ 42759 295 6 contention contention NN 42759 295 7 , , , 42759 295 8 the the DT 42759 295 9 following follow VBG 42759 295 10 statement statement NN 42759 295 11 by by IN 42759 295 12 Robert Robert NNP 42759 295 13 Blatchford Blatchford NNP 42759 295 14 may may MD 42759 295 15 be be VB 42759 295 16 taken take VBN 42759 295 17 as as RB 42759 295 18 fairly fairly RB 42759 295 19 representative representative NN 42759 295 20 of of IN 42759 295 21 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 295 22 thought thought NN 42759 295 23 : : : 42759 295 24 " " `` 42759 295 25 The the DT 42759 295 26 earth earth NN 42759 295 27 belongs belong VBZ 42759 295 28 to to IN 42759 295 29 the the DT 42759 295 30 people people NNS 42759 295 31 .... .... . 42759 296 1 So so IN 42759 296 2 that that IN 42759 296 3 he -PRON- PRP 42759 296 4 who who WP 42759 296 5 possesses possess VBZ 42759 296 6 land land NN 42759 296 7 possesses possesse NNS 42759 296 8 that that DT 42759 296 9 to to TO 42759 296 10 which which WDT 42759 296 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 296 12 has have VBZ 42759 296 13 no no DT 42759 296 14 right right NN 42759 296 15 , , , 42759 296 16 and and CC 42759 296 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 296 18 who who WP 42759 296 19 invests invest VBZ 42759 296 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 296 21 savings saving NNS 42759 296 22 in in IN 42759 296 23 land land NN 42759 296 24 becomes become VBZ 42759 296 25 the the DT 42759 296 26 purchaser purchaser NN 42759 296 27 of of IN 42759 296 28 stolen steal VBN 42759 296 29 property property NN 42759 296 30 . . . 42759 297 1 " " `` 42759 297 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 297 3 10 10 CD 42759 297 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 297 5 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 297 6 as as IN 42759 297 7 this this DT 42759 297 8 argument argument NN 42759 297 9 is be VBZ 42759 297 10 substantially substantially RB 42759 297 11 the the DT 42759 297 12 same same JJ 42759 297 13 as as IN 42759 297 14 one one CD 42759 297 15 of of IN 42759 297 16 the the DT 42759 297 17 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 297 18 contentions contention NNS 42759 297 19 in in IN 42759 297 20 the the DT 42759 297 21 system system NN 42759 297 22 of of IN 42759 297 23 Henry Henry NNP 42759 297 24 George George NNP 42759 297 25 , , , 42759 297 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 297 27 will will MD 42759 297 28 be be VB 42759 297 29 discussed discuss VBN 42759 297 30 in in IN 42759 297 31 connection connection NN 42759 297 32 with with IN 42759 297 33 the the DT 42759 297 34 latter latter JJ 42759 297 35 , , , 42759 297 36 in in IN 42759 297 37 the the DT 42759 297 38 pages page NNS 42759 297 39 immediately immediately RB 42759 297 40 following follow VBG 42759 297 41 . . . 42759 298 1 _ _ NNP 42759 298 2 Henry Henry NNP 42759 298 3 George George NNP 42759 298 4 's 's POS 42759 298 5 Attack Attack NNP 42759 298 6 on on IN 42759 298 7 the the DT 42759 298 8 Title title NN 42759 298 9 of of IN 42759 298 10 First First NNP 42759 298 11 Occupancy Occupancy NNP 42759 298 12 _ _ NNP 42759 298 13 Every every DT 42759 298 14 concrete concrete JJ 42759 298 15 right right NN 42759 298 16 , , , 42759 298 17 whether whether IN 42759 298 18 to to TO 42759 298 19 land land VB 42759 298 20 or or CC 42759 298 21 to to IN 42759 298 22 artificial artificial JJ 42759 298 23 goods good NNS 42759 298 24 , , , 42759 298 25 is be VBZ 42759 298 26 based base VBN 42759 298 27 upon upon IN 42759 298 28 some some DT 42759 298 29 contingent contingent JJ 42759 298 30 fact fact NN 42759 298 31 or or CC 42759 298 32 ground ground NN 42759 298 33 , , , 42759 298 34 called call VBD 42759 298 35 a a DT 42759 298 36 title title NN 42759 298 37 . . . 42759 299 1 By by IN 42759 299 2 reason reason NN 42759 299 3 of of IN 42759 299 4 some some DT 42759 299 5 title title NN 42759 299 6 a a DT 42759 299 7 man man NN 42759 299 8 is be VBZ 42759 299 9 justified justify VBN 42759 299 10 in in IN 42759 299 11 appropriating appropriate VBG 42759 299 12 a a DT 42759 299 13 particular particular JJ 42759 299 14 farm farm NN 42759 299 15 , , , 42759 299 16 house house NN 42759 299 17 , , , 42759 299 18 or or CC 42759 299 19 hat hat NN 42759 299 20 . . . 42759 300 1 When when WRB 42759 300 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 300 3 becomes become VBZ 42759 300 4 the the DT 42759 300 5 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 300 6 of of IN 42759 300 7 a a DT 42759 300 8 thing thing NN 42759 300 9 that that WDT 42759 300 10 has have VBZ 42759 300 11 hitherto hitherto VBN 42759 300 12 been be VBN 42759 300 13 ownerless ownerless JJ 42759 300 14 , , , 42759 300 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 300 16 title title NN 42759 300 17 is be VBZ 42759 300 18 said say VBN 42759 300 19 to to TO 42759 300 20 be be VB 42759 300 21 original original JJ 42759 300 22 ; ; : 42759 300 23 when when WRB 42759 300 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 300 25 acquires acquire VBZ 42759 300 26 an an DT 42759 300 27 article article NN 42759 300 28 from from IN 42759 300 29 some some DT 42759 300 30 previous previous JJ 42759 300 31 owner owner NN 42759 300 32 , , , 42759 300 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 300 34 title title NN 42759 300 35 is be VBZ 42759 300 36 said say VBN 42759 300 37 to to TO 42759 300 38 be be VB 42759 300 39 derived derive VBN 42759 300 40 . . . 42759 301 1 As as IN 42759 301 2 an an DT 42759 301 3 endless endless JJ 42759 301 4 series series NN 42759 301 5 of of IN 42759 301 6 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 301 7 is be VBZ 42759 301 8 impossible impossible JJ 42759 301 9 , , , 42759 301 10 every every DT 42759 301 11 derived derive VBN 42759 301 12 title title NN 42759 301 13 must must MD 42759 301 14 be be VB 42759 301 15 traceable traceable JJ 42759 301 16 ultimately ultimately RB 42759 301 17 to to IN 42759 301 18 some some DT 42759 301 19 original original JJ 42759 301 20 title title NN 42759 301 21 . . . 42759 302 1 Among among IN 42759 302 2 the the DT 42759 302 3 derived derive VBN 42759 302 4 titles title NNS 42759 302 5 the the DT 42759 302 6 most most RBS 42759 302 7 important important JJ 42759 302 8 are be VBP 42759 302 9 contract contract NN 42759 302 10 , , , 42759 302 11 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 302 12 , , , 42759 302 13 and and CC 42759 302 14 prescription prescription NN 42759 302 15 . . . 42759 303 1 The the DT 42759 303 2 original original JJ 42759 303 3 title title NN 42759 303 4 is be VBZ 42759 303 5 either either CC 42759 303 6 first first JJ 42759 303 7 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 303 8 or or CC 42759 303 9 labour labour NN 42759 303 10 . . . 42759 304 1 The the DT 42759 304 2 prevailing prevailing JJ 42759 304 3 view view NN 42759 304 4 among among IN 42759 304 5 the the DT 42759 304 6 defenders defender NNS 42759 304 7 of of IN 42759 304 8 private private JJ 42759 304 9 landownership landownership NN 42759 304 10 has have VBZ 42759 304 11 always always RB 42759 304 12 been be VBN 42759 304 13 that that IN 42759 304 14 the the DT 42759 304 15 original original JJ 42759 304 16 title title NN 42759 304 17 is be VBZ 42759 304 18 not not RB 42759 304 19 labour labour JJ 42759 304 20 but but CC 42759 304 21 first first JJ 42759 304 22 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 304 23 . . . 42759 305 1 If if IN 42759 305 2 this this DT 42759 305 3 title title NN 42759 305 4 be be VBP 42759 305 5 not not RB 42759 305 6 valid valid JJ 42759 305 7 every every DT 42759 305 8 derived derive VBN 42759 305 9 title title NN 42759 305 10 is be VBZ 42759 305 11 worthless worthless JJ 42759 305 12 , , , 42759 305 13 and and CC 42759 305 14 no no DT 42759 305 15 man man NN 42759 305 16 has have VBZ 42759 305 17 a a DT 42759 305 18 true true JJ 42759 305 19 right right NN 42759 305 20 to to IN 42759 305 21 the the DT 42759 305 22 land land NN 42759 305 23 that that WDT 42759 305 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 305 25 calls call VBZ 42759 305 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 305 27 own own JJ 42759 305 28 . . . 42759 306 1 Henry Henry NNP 42759 306 2 George George NNP 42759 306 3 's 's POS 42759 306 4 attack attack NN 42759 306 5 upon upon IN 42759 306 6 the the DT 42759 306 7 title title NN 42759 306 8 of of IN 42759 306 9 first first JJ 42759 306 10 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 306 11 is be VBZ 42759 306 12 an an DT 42759 306 13 important important JJ 42759 306 14 link link NN 42759 306 15 in in IN 42759 306 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 306 17 argument argument NN 42759 306 18 against against IN 42759 306 19 private private JJ 42759 306 20 property property NN 42759 306 21 in in IN 42759 306 22 land land NN 42759 306 23 . . . 42759 307 1 " " `` 42759 307 2 Priority priority NN 42759 307 3 of of IN 42759 307 4 occupation occupation NN 42759 307 5 give give VBP 42759 307 6 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 307 7 and and CC 42759 307 8 perpetual perpetual JJ 42759 307 9 title title NN 42759 307 10 to to IN 42759 307 11 the the DT 42759 307 12 surface surface NN 42759 307 13 of of IN 42759 307 14 a a DT 42759 307 15 globe globe NN 42759 307 16 in in IN 42759 307 17 which which WDT 42759 307 18 , , , 42759 307 19 in in IN 42759 307 20 the the DT 42759 307 21 order order NN 42759 307 22 of of IN 42759 307 23 nature nature NN 42759 307 24 , , , 42759 307 25 countless countless JJ 42759 307 26 generations generation NNS 42759 307 27 succeed succeed VBP 42759 307 28 each each DT 42759 307 29 other other JJ 42759 307 30 ! ! . 42759 307 31 ... ... . 42759 308 1 Has have VBZ 42759 308 2 the the DT 42759 308 3 first first JJ 42759 308 4 comer comer NN 42759 308 5 at at IN 42759 308 6 a a DT 42759 308 7 banquet banquet NN 42759 308 8 the the DT 42759 308 9 right right NN 42759 308 10 to to TO 42759 308 11 turn turn VB 42759 308 12 back back RB 42759 308 13 all all PDT 42759 308 14 the the DT 42759 308 15 chairs chair NNS 42759 308 16 , , , 42759 308 17 and and CC 42759 308 18 claim claim VBP 42759 308 19 that that IN 42759 308 20 none none NN 42759 308 21 of of IN 42759 308 22 the the DT 42759 308 23 other other JJ 42759 308 24 guests guest NNS 42759 308 25 shall shall MD 42759 308 26 partake partake VB 42759 308 27 of of IN 42759 308 28 the the DT 42759 308 29 food food NN 42759 308 30 provided provide VBN 42759 308 31 , , , 42759 308 32 except except IN 42759 308 33 as as IN 42759 308 34 they -PRON- PRP 42759 308 35 make make VBP 42759 308 36 terms term NNS 42759 308 37 with with IN 42759 308 38 him -PRON- PRP 42759 308 39 ? ? . 42759 309 1 Does do VBZ 42759 309 2 the the DT 42759 309 3 first first JJ 42759 309 4 man man NN 42759 309 5 who who WP 42759 309 6 presents present VBZ 42759 309 7 a a DT 42759 309 8 ticket ticket NN 42759 309 9 at at IN 42759 309 10 the the DT 42759 309 11 door door NN 42759 309 12 of of IN 42759 309 13 a a DT 42759 309 14 theatre theatre NN 42759 309 15 , , , 42759 309 16 and and CC 42759 309 17 passes pass VBZ 42759 309 18 in in RP 42759 309 19 , , , 42759 309 20 acquire acquire VB 42759 309 21 by by IN 42759 309 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 309 23 priority priority NN 42759 309 24 the the DT 42759 309 25 right right NN 42759 309 26 to to TO 42759 309 27 shut shut VB 42759 309 28 the the DT 42759 309 29 doors door NNS 42759 309 30 and and CC 42759 309 31 have have VBP 42759 309 32 the the DT 42759 309 33 performance performance NN 42759 309 34 go go VB 42759 309 35 on on RP 42759 309 36 for for IN 42759 309 37 him -PRON- PRP 42759 309 38 alone alone JJ 42759 309 39 ? ? . 42759 309 40 ... ... . 42759 310 1 And and CC 42759 310 2 to to IN 42759 310 3 this this DT 42759 310 4 manifest manif JJS 42759 310 5 absurdity absurdity NN 42759 310 6 does do VBZ 42759 310 7 the the DT 42759 310 8 recognition recognition NN 42759 310 9 of of IN 42759 310 10 the the DT 42759 310 11 individual individual JJ 42759 310 12 right right NN 42759 310 13 to to IN 42759 310 14 land land NN 42759 310 15 come come VB 42759 310 16 when when WRB 42759 310 17 carried carry VBN 42759 310 18 to to IN 42759 310 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 310 20 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 310 21 that that IN 42759 310 22 any any DT 42759 310 23 human human JJ 42759 310 24 being being NN 42759 310 25 , , , 42759 310 26 could could MD 42759 310 27 he -PRON- PRP 42759 310 28 concentrate concentrate VB 42759 310 29 in in IN 42759 310 30 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 310 31 the the DT 42759 310 32 individual individual JJ 42759 310 33 rights right NNS 42759 310 34 to to IN 42759 310 35 the the DT 42759 310 36 land land NN 42759 310 37 of of IN 42759 310 38 any any DT 42759 310 39 country country NN 42759 310 40 , , , 42759 310 41 could could MD 42759 310 42 expel expel VB 42759 310 43 therefrom therefrom NN 42759 310 44 all all PDT 42759 310 45 the the DT 42759 310 46 rest rest NN 42759 310 47 of of IN 42759 310 48 the the DT 42759 310 49 inhabitants inhabitant NNS 42759 310 50 ; ; : 42759 310 51 and and CC 42759 310 52 could could MD 42759 310 53 he -PRON- PRP 42759 310 54 concentrate concentrate VB 42759 310 55 the the DT 42759 310 56 individual individual JJ 42759 310 57 rights right NNS 42759 310 58 to to IN 42759 310 59 the the DT 42759 310 60 whole whole JJ 42759 310 61 surface surface NN 42759 310 62 of of IN 42759 310 63 the the DT 42759 310 64 globe globe NN 42759 310 65 , , , 42759 310 66 he -PRON- PRP 42759 310 67 alone alone RB 42759 310 68 of of IN 42759 310 69 all all PDT 42759 310 70 the the DT 42759 310 71 teeming teem VBG 42759 310 72 population population NN 42759 310 73 of of IN 42759 310 74 the the DT 42759 310 75 earth earth NN 42759 310 76 would would MD 42759 310 77 have have VB 42759 310 78 the the DT 42759 310 79 right right NN 42759 310 80 to to TO 42759 310 81 live live VB 42759 310 82 . . . 42759 311 1 " " `` 42759 311 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 311 3 11 11 CD 42759 311 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 311 5 In in IN 42759 311 6 passing pass VBG 42759 311 7 , , , 42759 311 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 311 9 may may MD 42759 311 10 be be VB 42759 311 11 observed observe VBN 42759 311 12 that that IN 42759 311 13 Henry Henry NNP 42759 311 14 George George NNP 42759 311 15 was be VBD 42759 311 16 not not RB 42759 311 17 the the DT 42759 311 18 first first JJ 42759 311 19 distinguished distinguished JJ 42759 311 20 writer writer NN 42759 311 21 to to TO 42759 311 22 use use VB 42759 311 23 the the DT 42759 311 24 illustration illustration NN 42759 311 25 drawn draw VBN 42759 311 26 from from IN 42759 311 27 the the DT 42759 311 28 theatre theatre NN 42759 311 29 . . . 42759 312 1 Cicero Cicero NNP 42759 312 2 , , , 42759 312 3 St. St. NNP 42759 313 1 Basil Basil NNP 42759 313 2 , , , 42759 313 3 and and CC 42759 313 4 St. St. NNP 42759 313 5 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 313 6 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 42759 313 7 all all DT 42759 313 8 employed employ VBD 42759 313 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 313 10 to to TO 42759 313 11 refute refute VB 42759 313 12 extravagant extravagant JJ 42759 313 13 conceptions conception NNS 42759 313 14 of of IN 42759 313 15 private private JJ 42759 313 16 ownership ownership NN 42759 313 17 . . . 42759 314 1 In in IN 42759 314 2 reply reply NN 42759 314 3 to to IN 42759 314 4 the the DT 42759 314 5 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 314 6 argument argument NN 42759 314 7 of of IN 42759 314 8 Henry Henry NNP 42759 314 9 George George NNP 42759 314 10 , , , 42759 314 11 we -PRON- PRP 42759 314 12 point point VBP 42759 314 13 out out RP 42759 314 14 : : : 42759 314 15 first first RB 42759 314 16 , , , 42759 314 17 that that IN 42759 314 18 the the DT 42759 314 19 right right NN 42759 314 20 of of IN 42759 314 21 ownership ownership NN 42759 314 22 created create VBN 42759 314 23 by by IN 42759 314 24 first first JJ 42759 314 25 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 314 26 is be VBZ 42759 314 27 not not RB 42759 314 28 unlimited unlimited JJ 42759 314 29 , , , 42759 314 30 either either CC 42759 314 31 extensively extensively RB 42759 314 32 or or CC 42759 314 33 intensively intensively RB 42759 314 34 ; ; : 42759 314 35 and and CC 42759 314 36 , , , 42759 314 37 second second RB 42759 314 38 , , , 42759 314 39 that that IN 42759 314 40 the the DT 42759 314 41 historical historical JJ 42759 314 42 injustices injustice NNS 42759 314 43 connected connect VBN 42759 314 44 with with IN 42759 314 45 private private JJ 42759 314 46 ownership ownership NN 42759 314 47 have have VBP 42759 314 48 been be VBN 42759 314 49 in in IN 42759 314 50 only only RB 42759 314 51 a a DT 42759 314 52 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 314 53 slight slight JJ 42759 314 54 degree degree NN 42759 314 55 due due IN 42759 314 56 to to IN 42759 314 57 the the DT 42759 314 58 first first JJ 42759 314 59 occupation occupation NN 42759 314 60 of of IN 42759 314 61 very very RB 42759 314 62 large large JJ 42759 314 63 tracts tract NNS 42759 314 64 of of IN 42759 314 65 land land NN 42759 314 66 . . . 42759 315 1 The the DT 42759 315 2 right right NN 42759 315 3 of of IN 42759 315 4 first first JJ 42759 315 5 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 315 6 does do VBZ 42759 315 7 not not RB 42759 315 8 involve involve VB 42759 315 9 the the DT 42759 315 10 right right NN 42759 315 11 to to TO 42759 315 12 take take VB 42759 315 13 a a DT 42759 315 14 whole whole JJ 42759 315 15 region region NN 42759 315 16 or or CC 42759 315 17 continent continent NN 42759 315 18 , , , 42759 315 19 compelling compel VBG 42759 315 20 all all DT 42759 315 21 subsequent subsequent JJ 42759 315 22 arrivals arrival NNS 42759 315 23 to to TO 42759 315 24 become become VB 42759 315 25 tenants tenant NNS 42759 315 26 of of IN 42759 315 27 the the DT 42759 315 28 first first JJ 42759 315 29 . . . 42759 316 1 There there EX 42759 316 2 seems seem VBZ 42759 316 3 to to TO 42759 316 4 be be VB 42759 316 5 no no DT 42759 316 6 good good JJ 42759 316 7 reason reason NN 42759 316 8 to to TO 42759 316 9 think think VB 42759 316 10 that that IN 42759 316 11 the the DT 42759 316 12 first first JJ 42759 316 13 occupant occupant NN 42759 316 14 is be VBZ 42759 316 15 justified justify VBN 42759 316 16 in in IN 42759 316 17 claiming claim VBG 42759 316 18 as as IN 42759 316 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 316 20 own own JJ 42759 316 21 more more JJR 42759 316 22 land land NN 42759 316 23 than than IN 42759 316 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 316 25 can can MD 42759 316 26 cultivate cultivate VB 42759 316 27 by by IN 42759 316 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 316 29 own own JJ 42759 316 30 labour labour NN 42759 316 31 , , , 42759 316 32 or or CC 42759 316 33 with with IN 42759 316 34 the the DT 42759 316 35 assistance assistance NN 42759 316 36 of of IN 42759 316 37 those those DT 42759 316 38 who who WP 42759 316 39 prefer prefer VBP 42759 316 40 to to TO 42759 316 41 be be VB 42759 316 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 316 43 employés employés NN 42759 316 44 or or CC 42759 316 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 316 46 tenants tenant NNS 42759 316 47 rather rather RB 42759 316 48 than than IN 42759 316 49 independent independent JJ 42759 316 50 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 316 51 . . . 42759 317 1 " " `` 42759 317 2 He -PRON- PRP 42759 317 3 has have VBZ 42759 317 4 not not RB 42759 317 5 the the DT 42759 317 6 right right NN 42759 317 7 to to TO 42759 317 8 reserve reserve VB 42759 317 9 for for IN 42759 317 10 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 317 11 alone alone JJ 42759 317 12 the the DT 42759 317 13 whole whole JJ 42759 317 14 territory territory NN 42759 317 15 , , , 42759 317 16 but but CC 42759 317 17 only only RB 42759 317 18 that that DT 42759 317 19 part part NN 42759 317 20 of of IN 42759 317 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 317 22 which which WDT 42759 317 23 is be VBZ 42759 317 24 really really RB 42759 317 25 useful useful JJ 42759 317 26 to to IN 42759 317 27 him -PRON- PRP 42759 317 28 , , , 42759 317 29 which which WDT 42759 317 30 he -PRON- PRP 42759 317 31 can can MD 42759 317 32 make make VB 42759 317 33 fruitful fruitful JJ 42759 317 34 . . . 42759 318 1 " " `` 42759 318 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 318 3 12 12 CD 42759 318 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 318 5 Nor nor CC 42759 318 6 is be VBZ 42759 318 7 the the DT 42759 318 8 right right NN 42759 318 9 of of IN 42759 318 10 private private JJ 42759 318 11 landownership landownership NN 42759 318 12 , , , 42759 318 13 on on IN 42759 318 14 whatever whatever WDT 42759 318 15 title title NN 42759 318 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 318 17 may may MD 42759 318 18 rest rest VB 42759 318 19 , , , 42759 318 20 unlimited unlimited JJ 42759 318 21 intensively intensively RB 42759 318 22 , , , 42759 318 23 that that RB 42759 318 24 is is RB 42759 318 25 , , , 42759 318 26 in in IN 42759 318 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 318 28 powers power NNS 42759 318 29 or or CC 42759 318 30 comprehension comprehension NN 42759 318 31 . . . 42759 319 1 Though though IN 42759 319 2 a a DT 42759 319 3 man man NN 42759 319 4 should should MD 42759 319 5 have have VB 42759 319 6 become become VBN 42759 319 7 the the DT 42759 319 8 rightful rightful JJ 42759 319 9 owner owner NN 42759 319 10 of of IN 42759 319 11 all all PDT 42759 319 12 the the DT 42759 319 13 land land NN 42759 319 14 in in IN 42759 319 15 a a DT 42759 319 16 neighbourhood neighbourhood NN 42759 319 17 , , , 42759 319 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 319 19 would would MD 42759 319 20 have have VB 42759 319 21 no no DT 42759 319 22 moral moral JJ 42759 319 23 right right NN 42759 319 24 to to TO 42759 319 25 exclude exclude VB 42759 319 26 therefrom therefrom JJ 42759 319 27 those those DT 42759 319 28 persons person NNS 42759 319 29 who who WP 42759 319 30 could could MD 42759 319 31 not not RB 42759 319 32 without without IN 42759 319 33 extreme extreme JJ 42759 319 34 inconvenience inconvenience NN 42759 319 35 find find VBP 42759 319 36 a a DT 42759 319 37 living living NN 42759 319 38 elsewhere elsewhere RB 42759 319 39 . . . 42759 320 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 320 2 would would MD 42759 320 3 be be VB 42759 320 4 morally morally RB 42759 320 5 bound bind VBN 42759 320 6 to to TO 42759 320 7 let let VB 42759 320 8 them -PRON- PRP 42759 320 9 cultivate cultivate VB 42759 320 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 320 11 at at IN 42759 320 12 a a DT 42759 320 13 fair fair JJ 42759 320 14 rental rental NN 42759 320 15 . . . 42759 321 1 The the DT 42759 321 2 Christian christian JJ 42759 321 3 conception conception NN 42759 321 4 of of IN 42759 321 5 the the DT 42759 321 6 intensive intensive JJ 42759 321 7 limitations limitation NNS 42759 321 8 of of IN 42759 321 9 private private JJ 42759 321 10 ownership ownership NN 42759 321 11 is be VBZ 42759 321 12 well well RB 42759 321 13 exemplified exemplify VBN 42759 321 14 in in IN 42759 321 15 the the DT 42759 321 16 action action NN 42759 321 17 of of IN 42759 321 18 Pope Pope NNP 42759 321 19 Clement Clement NNP 42759 321 20 IV IV NNP 42759 321 21 , , , 42759 321 22 who who WP 42759 321 23 permitted permit VBD 42759 321 24 strangers stranger NNS 42759 321 25 to to TO 42759 321 26 occupy occupy VB 42759 321 27 the the DT 42759 321 28 third third JJ 42759 321 29 part part NN 42759 321 30 of of IN 42759 321 31 any any DT 42759 321 32 estate estate NN 42759 321 33 which which WDT 42759 321 34 the the DT 42759 321 35 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 321 36 refused refuse VBD 42759 321 37 to to TO 42759 321 38 cultivate cultivate VB 42759 321 39 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 321 40 . . . 42759 322 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 322 2 13 13 CD 42759 322 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 322 4 Ownership ownership NN 42759 322 5 understood understand VBD 42759 322 6 as as IN 42759 322 7 the the DT 42759 322 8 right right NN 42759 322 9 to to TO 42759 322 10 do do VB 42759 322 11 what what WP 42759 322 12 one one PRP 42759 322 13 pleases please VBZ 42759 322 14 with with IN 42759 322 15 one one PRP 42759 322 16 's 's POS 42759 322 17 possessions possession NNS 42759 322 18 , , , 42759 322 19 is be VBZ 42759 322 20 due due JJ 42759 322 21 partly partly RB 42759 322 22 to to IN 42759 322 23 the the DT 42759 322 24 Roman roman JJ 42759 322 25 law law NN 42759 322 26 , , , 42759 322 27 partly partly RB 42759 322 28 to to IN 42759 322 29 the the DT 42759 322 30 Code Code NNP 42759 322 31 Napoléon Napoléon NNP 42759 322 32 , , , 42759 322 33 but but CC 42759 322 34 chiefly chiefly RB 42759 322 35 to to IN 42759 322 36 modern modern JJ 42759 322 37 theories theory NNS 42759 322 38 of of IN 42759 322 39 individualism individualism NN 42759 322 40 . . . 42759 323 1 In in IN 42759 323 2 the the DT 42759 323 3 second second JJ 42759 323 4 place place NN 42759 323 5 , , , 42759 323 6 the the DT 42759 323 7 abuses abuse NNS 42759 323 8 which which WDT 42759 323 9 have have VBP 42759 323 10 accompanied accompany VBN 42759 323 11 private private JJ 42759 323 12 property property NN 42759 323 13 in in IN 42759 323 14 land land NN 42759 323 15 are be VBP 42759 323 16 very very RB 42759 323 17 rarely rarely RB 42759 323 18 traceable traceable JJ 42759 323 19 to to IN 42759 323 20 abuses abuse NNS 42759 323 21 of of IN 42759 323 22 the the DT 42759 323 23 right right NN 42759 323 24 of of IN 42759 323 25 first first JJ 42759 323 26 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 323 27 . . . 42759 324 1 The the DT 42759 324 2 men man NNS 42759 324 3 who who WP 42759 324 4 have have VBP 42759 324 5 possessed possess VBN 42759 324 6 too too RB 42759 324 7 much much JJ 42759 324 8 land land NN 42759 324 9 , , , 42759 324 10 and and CC 42759 324 11 the the DT 42759 324 12 men man NNS 42759 324 13 who who WP 42759 324 14 have have VBP 42759 324 15 used use VBN 42759 324 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 324 17 land land NN 42759 324 18 as as IN 42759 324 19 an an DT 42759 324 20 instrument instrument NN 42759 324 21 of of IN 42759 324 22 social social JJ 42759 324 23 oppression oppression NN 42759 324 24 , , , 42759 324 25 have have VBP 42759 324 26 scarcely scarcely RB 42759 324 27 ever ever RB 42759 324 28 been be VBN 42759 324 29 first first JJ 42759 324 30 occupants occupant NNS 42759 324 31 or or CC 42759 324 32 the the DT 42759 324 33 successors successor NNS 42759 324 34 thereof thereof RB 42759 324 35 through through IN 42759 324 36 derived derive VBN 42759 324 37 titles title NNS 42759 324 38 . . . 42759 325 1 This this DT 42759 325 2 is be VBZ 42759 325 3 especially especially RB 42759 325 4 true true JJ 42759 325 5 of of IN 42759 325 6 modern modern JJ 42759 325 7 abuses abuse NNS 42759 325 8 , , , 42759 325 9 and and CC 42759 325 10 modern modern JJ 42759 325 11 legal legal JJ 42759 325 12 titles title NNS 42759 325 13 . . . 42759 326 1 In in IN 42759 326 2 the the DT 42759 326 3 words word NNS 42759 326 4 of of IN 42759 326 5 Herbert Herbert NNP 42759 326 6 Spencer Spencer NNP 42759 326 7 : : : 42759 326 8 " " `` 42759 326 9 Violence violence NN 42759 326 10 , , , 42759 326 11 fraud fraud NN 42759 326 12 , , , 42759 326 13 the the DT 42759 326 14 prerogative prerogative NN 42759 326 15 of of IN 42759 326 16 force force NN 42759 326 17 , , , 42759 326 18 the the DT 42759 326 19 claims claim NNS 42759 326 20 of of IN 42759 326 21 superior superior JJ 42759 326 22 cunning,--these cunning,--these NNP 42759 326 23 are be VBP 42759 326 24 the the DT 42759 326 25 sources source NNS 42759 326 26 to to TO 42759 326 27 which which WDT 42759 326 28 these these DT 42759 326 29 titles title NNS 42759 326 30 may may MD 42759 326 31 be be VB 42759 326 32 traced trace VBN 42759 326 33 . . . 42759 327 1 The the DT 42759 327 2 original original JJ 42759 327 3 deeds deed NNS 42759 327 4 were be VBD 42759 327 5 written write VBN 42759 327 6 with with IN 42759 327 7 the the DT 42759 327 8 sword sword NN 42759 327 9 , , , 42759 327 10 rather rather RB 42759 327 11 than than IN 42759 327 12 with with IN 42759 327 13 the the DT 42759 327 14 pen pen NN 42759 327 15 : : : 42759 327 16 not not RB 42759 327 17 lawyers lawyer NNS 42759 327 18 but but CC 42759 327 19 soldiers soldier NNS 42759 327 20 were be VBD 42759 327 21 the the DT 42759 327 22 conveyancers conveyancer NNS 42759 327 23 : : : 42759 327 24 blows blow NNS 42759 327 25 were be VBD 42759 327 26 the the DT 42759 327 27 current current JJ 42759 327 28 coin coin NN 42759 327 29 given give VBN 42759 327 30 in in IN 42759 327 31 payment payment NN 42759 327 32 ; ; : 42759 327 33 and and CC 42759 327 34 for for IN 42759 327 35 seals seal NNS 42759 327 36 blood blood NN 42759 327 37 was be VBD 42759 327 38 used use VBN 42759 327 39 in in IN 42759 327 40 preference preference NN 42759 327 41 to to IN 42759 327 42 wax wax NN 42759 327 43 . . . 42759 328 1 " " `` 42759 328 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 328 3 14 14 CD 42759 328 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 328 5 Not not RB 42759 328 6 the the DT 42759 328 7 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 328 8 of of IN 42759 328 9 land land NN 42759 328 10 which which WDT 42759 328 11 nobody nobody NN 42759 328 12 owned own VBD 42759 328 13 , , , 42759 328 14 but but CC 42759 328 15 the the DT 42759 328 16 forcible forcible JJ 42759 328 17 and and CC 42759 328 18 fraudulent fraudulent JJ 42759 328 19 seizure seizure NN 42759 328 20 of of IN 42759 328 21 land land NN 42759 328 22 which which WDT 42759 328 23 had have VBD 42759 328 24 already already RB 42759 328 25 been be VBN 42759 328 26 occupied occupy VBN 42759 328 27 , , , 42759 328 28 has have VBZ 42759 328 29 been be VBN 42759 328 30 one one CD 42759 328 31 of of IN 42759 328 32 the the DT 42759 328 33 main main JJ 42759 328 34 causes cause NNS 42759 328 35 of of IN 42759 328 36 the the DT 42759 328 37 evils evil NNS 42759 328 38 attending attend VBG 42759 328 39 upon upon IN 42759 328 40 private private JJ 42759 328 41 landownership landownership NN 42759 328 42 . . . 42759 329 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 329 2 , , , 42759 329 3 in in IN 42759 329 4 England England NNP 42759 329 5 and and CC 42759 329 6 all all DT 42759 329 7 other other JJ 42759 329 8 countries country NNS 42759 329 9 that that WDT 42759 329 10 have have VBP 42759 329 11 adopted adopt VBN 42759 329 12 her -PRON- PRP$ 42759 329 13 legal legal JJ 42759 329 14 system system NN 42759 329 15 , , , 42759 329 16 the the DT 42759 329 17 title title NN 42759 329 18 of of IN 42759 329 19 first first JJ 42759 329 20 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 329 21 could could MD 42759 329 22 never never RB 42759 329 23 be be VB 42759 329 24 utilised utilise VBN 42759 329 25 by by IN 42759 329 26 individuals individual NNS 42759 329 27 : : : 42759 329 28 all all DT 42759 329 29 unoccupied unoccupied JJ 42759 329 30 land land NN 42759 329 31 was be VBD 42759 329 32 claimed claim VBN 42759 329 33 by by IN 42759 329 34 the the DT 42759 329 35 Crown Crown NNP 42759 329 36 or or CC 42759 329 37 by by IN 42759 329 38 the the DT 42759 329 39 State State NNP 42759 329 40 , , , 42759 329 41 and and CC 42759 329 42 transferred transfer VBD 42759 329 43 thence thence NN 42759 329 44 to to IN 42759 329 45 private private JJ 42759 329 46 persons person NNS 42759 329 47 or or CC 42759 329 48 corporations corporation NNS 42759 329 49 . . . 42759 330 1 If if IN 42759 330 2 some some DT 42759 330 3 individuals individual NNS 42759 330 4 have have VBP 42759 330 5 got get VBN 42759 330 6 possession possession NN 42759 330 7 of of IN 42759 330 8 too too RB 42759 330 9 much much JJ 42759 330 10 land land NN 42759 330 11 through through IN 42759 330 12 this this DT 42759 330 13 process process NN 42759 330 14 , , , 42759 330 15 the the DT 42759 330 16 State State NNP 42759 330 17 , , , 42759 330 18 not not RB 42759 330 19 the the DT 42759 330 20 title title NN 42759 330 21 of of IN 42759 330 22 first first JJ 42759 330 23 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 330 24 , , , 42759 330 25 must must MD 42759 330 26 bear bear VB 42759 330 27 the the DT 42759 330 28 blame blame NN 42759 330 29 . . . 42759 331 1 This this DT 42759 331 2 is be VBZ 42759 331 3 quite quite RB 42759 331 4 clear clear JJ 42759 331 5 in in IN 42759 331 6 the the DT 42759 331 7 history history NN 42759 331 8 of of IN 42759 331 9 land land NN 42759 331 10 tenure tenure NN 42759 331 11 in in IN 42759 331 12 the the DT 42759 331 13 United United NNP 42759 331 14 States States NNP 42759 331 15 and and CC 42759 331 16 Australasia Australasia NNP 42759 331 17 . . . 42759 332 1 Henry Henry NNP 42759 332 2 George George NNP 42759 332 3 's 's POS 42759 332 4 attack attack NN 42759 332 5 upon upon IN 42759 332 6 private private JJ 42759 332 7 landownership landownership NN 42759 332 8 through through IN 42759 332 9 the the DT 42759 332 10 title title NN 42759 332 11 of of IN 42759 332 12 first first JJ 42759 332 13 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 332 14 is be VBZ 42759 332 15 therefore therefore RB 42759 332 16 ineffective ineffective JJ 42759 332 17 ; ; : 42759 332 18 for for IN 42759 332 19 he -PRON- PRP 42759 332 20 attributes attribute VBZ 42759 332 21 to to IN 42759 332 22 this this DT 42759 332 23 qualities quality NNS 42759 332 24 that that IN 42759 332 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 332 26 does do VBZ 42759 332 27 not not RB 42759 332 28 possess possess VB 42759 332 29 , , , 42759 332 30 and and CC 42759 332 31 consequences consequence NNS 42759 332 32 for for IN 42759 332 33 which which WDT 42759 332 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 332 35 is be VBZ 42759 332 36 not not RB 42759 332 37 responsible responsible JJ 42759 332 38 . . . 42759 333 1 _ _ NNP 42759 333 2 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 333 3 Defence Defence NNP 42759 333 4 of of IN 42759 333 5 the the DT 42759 333 6 Title title NN 42759 333 7 of of IN 42759 333 8 Labour Labour NNP 42759 333 9 _ _ NNP 42759 333 10 Thinking think VBG 42759 333 11 that that IN 42759 333 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 333 13 has have VBZ 42759 333 14 shattered shatter VBN 42759 333 15 the the DT 42759 333 16 title title NN 42759 333 17 of of IN 42759 333 18 first first JJ 42759 333 19 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 333 20 , , , 42759 333 21 Henry Henry NNP 42759 333 22 George George NNP 42759 333 23 undertakes undertake VBZ 42759 333 24 to to TO 42759 333 25 set set VB 42759 333 26 up up RP 42759 333 27 in in IN 42759 333 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 333 29 place place NN 42759 333 30 the the DT 42759 333 31 title title NN 42759 333 32 of of IN 42759 333 33 labour labour NN 42759 333 34 . . . 42759 334 1 " " `` 42759 334 2 There there EX 42759 334 3 can can MD 42759 334 4 be be VB 42759 334 5 to to IN 42759 334 6 the the DT 42759 334 7 ownership ownership NN 42759 334 8 of of IN 42759 334 9 anything anything NN 42759 334 10 no no DT 42759 334 11 rightful rightful JJ 42759 334 12 title title NN 42759 334 13 which which WDT 42759 334 14 is be VBZ 42759 334 15 not not RB 42759 334 16 derived derive VBN 42759 334 17 from from IN 42759 334 18 the the DT 42759 334 19 title title NN 42759 334 20 of of IN 42759 334 21 the the DT 42759 334 22 producer producer NN 42759 334 23 , , , 42759 334 24 and and CC 42759 334 25 does do VBZ 42759 334 26 not not RB 42759 334 27 rest rest VB 42759 334 28 on on IN 42759 334 29 the the DT 42759 334 30 natural natural JJ 42759 334 31 right right NN 42759 334 32 of of IN 42759 334 33 the the DT 42759 334 34 man man NN 42759 334 35 to to IN 42759 334 36 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 334 37 . . . 42759 335 1 " " `` 42759 335 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 335 3 15 15 CD 42759 335 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 335 5 The the DT 42759 335 6 only only JJ 42759 335 7 original original JJ 42759 335 8 title title NN 42759 335 9 is be VBZ 42759 335 10 man man NN 42759 335 11 's 's POS 42759 335 12 right right NN 42759 335 13 to to IN 42759 335 14 the the DT 42759 335 15 exercise exercise NN 42759 335 16 of of IN 42759 335 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 335 18 own own JJ 42759 335 19 faculties faculty NNS 42759 335 20 ; ; : 42759 335 21 from from IN 42759 335 22 this this DT 42759 335 23 right right NN 42759 335 24 follows follow VBZ 42759 335 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 335 26 right right NN 42759 335 27 to to IN 42759 335 28 what what WP 42759 335 29 he -PRON- PRP 42759 335 30 produces produce VBZ 42759 335 31 ; ; : 42759 335 32 now now RB 42759 335 33 man man NN 42759 335 34 does do VBZ 42759 335 35 not not RB 42759 335 36 produce produce VB 42759 335 37 land land NN 42759 335 38 ; ; : 42759 335 39 therefore therefore RB 42759 335 40 he -PRON- PRP 42759 335 41 can can MD 42759 335 42 not not RB 42759 335 43 have have VB 42759 335 44 rightful rightful JJ 42759 335 45 property property NN 42759 335 46 in in IN 42759 335 47 land land NN 42759 335 48 . . . 42759 336 1 Of of IN 42759 336 2 these these DT 42759 336 3 four four CD 42759 336 4 propositions proposition NNS 42759 336 5 the the DT 42759 336 6 first first JJ 42759 336 7 is be VBZ 42759 336 8 a a DT 42759 336 9 pure pure JJ 42759 336 10 assumption assumption NN 42759 336 11 , , , 42759 336 12 the the DT 42759 336 13 second second JJ 42759 336 14 is be VBZ 42759 336 15 untrue untrue JJ 42759 336 16 , , , 42759 336 17 the the DT 42759 336 18 third third JJ 42759 336 19 is be VBZ 42759 336 20 a a DT 42759 336 21 truism truism NN 42759 336 22 , , , 42759 336 23 and and CC 42759 336 24 the the DT 42759 336 25 fourth fourth JJ 42759 336 26 is be VBZ 42759 336 27 as as RB 42759 336 28 unfounded unfounded JJ 42759 336 29 as as IN 42759 336 30 the the DT 42759 336 31 first first JJ 42759 336 32 . . . 42759 337 1 Dependently dependently RB 42759 337 2 upon upon IN 42759 337 3 God God NNP 42759 337 4 , , , 42759 337 5 man man NN 42759 337 6 has have VBZ 42759 337 7 , , , 42759 337 8 indeed indeed RB 42759 337 9 , , , 42759 337 10 a a DT 42759 337 11 right right NN 42759 337 12 to to IN 42759 337 13 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 337 14 and and CC 42759 337 15 to to IN 42759 337 16 the the DT 42759 337 17 exercise exercise NN 42759 337 18 of of IN 42759 337 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 337 20 own own JJ 42759 337 21 faculties faculty NNS 42759 337 22 ; ; : 42759 337 23 but but CC 42759 337 24 this this DT 42759 337 25 is be VBZ 42759 337 26 a a DT 42759 337 27 right right NN 42759 337 28 of of IN 42759 337 29 action action NN 42759 337 30 , , , 42759 337 31 not not RB 42759 337 32 of of IN 42759 337 33 property property NN 42759 337 34 . . . 42759 338 1 By by IN 42759 338 2 the the DT 42759 338 3 exercise exercise NN 42759 338 4 of of IN 42759 338 5 this this DT 42759 338 6 right right UH 42759 338 7 alone alone JJ 42759 338 8 man man NN 42759 338 9 can can MD 42759 338 10 never never RB 42759 338 11 produce produce VB 42759 338 12 anything anything NN 42759 338 13 , , , 42759 338 14 never never RB 42759 338 15 become become VB 42759 338 16 the the DT 42759 338 17 owner owner NN 42759 338 18 of of IN 42759 338 19 anything anything NN 42759 338 20 . . . 42759 339 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 339 2 can can MD 42759 339 3 produce produce VB 42759 339 4 only only RB 42759 339 5 by by IN 42759 339 6 exerting exert VBG 42759 339 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 339 8 powers power NNS 42759 339 9 upon upon IN 42759 339 10 something something NN 42759 339 11 outside outside IN 42759 339 12 of of IN 42759 339 13 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 339 14 ; ; : 42759 339 15 that that RB 42759 339 16 is is RB 42759 339 17 , , , 42759 339 18 upon upon IN 42759 339 19 the the DT 42759 339 20 goods good NNS 42759 339 21 of of IN 42759 339 22 external external JJ 42759 339 23 nature nature NN 42759 339 24 . . . 42759 340 1 To to TO 42759 340 2 become become VB 42759 340 3 the the DT 42759 340 4 producer producer NN 42759 340 5 and and CC 42759 340 6 the the DT 42759 340 7 owner owner NN 42759 340 8 of of IN 42759 340 9 a a DT 42759 340 10 product product NN 42759 340 11 , , , 42759 340 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 340 13 must must MD 42759 340 14 first first RB 42759 340 15 become become VB 42759 340 16 the the DT 42759 340 17 owner owner NN 42759 340 18 of of IN 42759 340 19 materials material NNS 42759 340 20 . . . 42759 341 1 By by IN 42759 341 2 what what WDT 42759 341 3 title title NN 42759 341 4 is be VBZ 42759 341 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 341 6 to to TO 42759 341 7 acquire acquire VB 42759 341 8 these these DT 42759 341 9 ? ? . 42759 342 1 In in IN 42759 342 2 one one CD 42759 342 3 passage[16 passage[16 NN 42759 342 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 342 5 Henry Henry NNP 42759 342 6 George George NNP 42759 342 7 seems seem VBZ 42759 342 8 to to TO 42759 342 9 think think VB 42759 342 10 that that IN 42759 342 11 no no DT 42759 342 12 title title NN 42759 342 13 is be VBZ 42759 342 14 necessary necessary JJ 42759 342 15 , , , 42759 342 16 and and CC 42759 342 17 refers refer VBZ 42759 342 18 to to IN 42759 342 19 the the DT 42759 342 20 raw raw JJ 42759 342 21 material material NN 42759 342 22 as as IN 42759 342 23 an an DT 42759 342 24 " " `` 42759 342 25 accident accident NN 42759 342 26 , , , 42759 342 27 " " '' 42759 342 28 while while IN 42759 342 29 the the DT 42759 342 30 finished finished JJ 42759 342 31 product product NN 42759 342 32 is be VBZ 42759 342 33 the the DT 42759 342 34 " " `` 42759 342 35 essence essence NN 42759 342 36 , , , 42759 342 37 " " '' 42759 342 38 declaring declare VBG 42759 342 39 that that IN 42759 342 40 " " `` 42759 342 41 the the DT 42759 342 42 right right NN 42759 342 43 of of IN 42759 342 44 private private JJ 42759 342 45 ownership ownership NN 42759 342 46 attaches attach VBZ 42759 342 47 the the DT 42759 342 48 accident accident NN 42759 342 49 to to IN 42759 342 50 the the DT 42759 342 51 essence essence NN 42759 342 52 , , , 42759 342 53 and and CC 42759 342 54 gives give VBZ 42759 342 55 the the DT 42759 342 56 right right NN 42759 342 57 of of IN 42759 342 58 ownership ownership NN 42759 342 59 to to IN 42759 342 60 the the DT 42759 342 61 natural natural JJ 42759 342 62 material material NN 42759 342 63 in in IN 42759 342 64 which which WDT 42759 342 65 the the DT 42759 342 66 labour labour NN 42759 342 67 of of IN 42759 342 68 production production NN 42759 342 69 is be VBZ 42759 342 70 embodied embody VBN 42759 342 71 . . . 42759 342 72 " " '' 42759 343 1 Now now RB 42759 343 2 this this DT 42759 343 3 solution solution NN 42759 343 4 of of IN 42759 343 5 the the DT 42759 343 6 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 343 7 is be VBZ 42759 343 8 too too RB 42759 343 9 simple simple JJ 42759 343 10 and and CC 42759 343 11 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 42759 343 12 . . . 42759 344 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 344 2 author author NN 42759 344 3 would would MD 42759 344 4 have have VB 42759 344 5 shrunk shrink VBN 42759 344 6 from from IN 42759 344 7 applying apply VBG 42759 344 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 344 9 universally universally RB 42759 344 10 ; ; : 42759 344 11 for for IN 42759 344 12 example example NN 42759 344 13 , , , 42759 344 14 to to IN 42759 344 15 the the DT 42759 344 16 case case NN 42759 344 17 of of IN 42759 344 18 the the DT 42759 344 19 shoemaker shoemaker NN 42759 344 20 who who WP 42759 344 21 produces produce VBZ 42759 344 22 a a DT 42759 344 23 pair pair NN 42759 344 24 of of IN 42759 344 25 shoes shoe NNS 42759 344 26 out out IN 42759 344 27 of of IN 42759 344 28 stolen steal VBN 42759 344 29 materials material NNS 42759 344 30 , , , 42759 344 31 or or CC 42759 344 32 the the DT 42759 344 33 burglar burglar NN 42759 344 34 who who WP 42759 344 35 makes make VBZ 42759 344 36 an an DT 42759 344 37 overcoat overcoat NN 42759 344 38 more more RBR 42759 344 39 useful useful JJ 42759 344 40 ( ( -LRB- 42759 344 41 and and CC 42759 344 42 therefore therefore RB 42759 344 43 performs perform VBZ 42759 344 44 a a DT 42759 344 45 task task NN 42759 344 46 of of IN 42759 344 47 production production NN 42759 344 48 ) ) -RRB- 42759 344 49 by by IN 42759 344 50 transferring transfer VBG 42759 344 51 it -PRON- PRP 42759 344 52 from from IN 42759 344 53 a a DT 42759 344 54 warehouse warehouse NN 42759 344 55 to to IN 42759 344 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 344 57 shivering shivering NN 42759 344 58 back back RB 42759 344 59 ! ! . 42759 345 1 Evidently evidently RB 42759 345 2 Henry Henry NNP 42759 345 3 George George NNP 42759 345 4 has have VBZ 42759 345 5 in in IN 42759 345 6 mind mind NN 42759 345 7 only only RB 42759 345 8 raw raw JJ 42759 345 9 material material NN 42759 345 10 in in IN 42759 345 11 the the DT 42759 345 12 strict strict JJ 42759 345 13 sense sense NN 42759 345 14 , , , 42759 345 15 that that IN 42759 345 16 which which WDT 42759 345 17 has have VBZ 42759 345 18 not not RB 42759 345 19 yet yet RB 42759 345 20 been be VBN 42759 345 21 separated separate VBN 42759 345 22 from from IN 42759 345 23 the the DT 42759 345 24 storehouse storehouse NN 42759 345 25 of of IN 42759 345 26 nature nature NN 42759 345 27 ; ; : 42759 345 28 for for IN 42759 345 29 he -PRON- PRP 42759 345 30 declares declare VBZ 42759 345 31 in in IN 42759 345 32 another another DT 42759 345 33 place place NN 42759 345 34 that that IN 42759 345 35 " " `` 42759 345 36 the the DT 42759 345 37 right right NN 42759 345 38 to to IN 42759 345 39 the the DT 42759 345 40 produce produce NN 42759 345 41 of of IN 42759 345 42 labour labour NN 42759 345 43 can can MD 42759 345 44 not not RB 42759 345 45 be be VB 42759 345 46 enjoyed enjoy VBN 42759 345 47 without without IN 42759 345 48 the the DT 42759 345 49 free free JJ 42759 345 50 use use NN 42759 345 51 of of IN 42759 345 52 the the DT 42759 345 53 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 345 54 offered offer VBN 42759 345 55 by by IN 42759 345 56 nature nature NN 42759 345 57 . . . 42759 346 1 " " `` 42759 346 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 346 3 17 17 CD 42759 346 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 346 5 In in IN 42759 346 6 other other JJ 42759 346 7 words word NNS 42759 346 8 , , , 42759 346 9 man man NN 42759 346 10 's 's POS 42759 346 11 title title NN 42759 346 12 to to IN 42759 346 13 the the DT 42759 346 14 materials material NNS 42759 346 15 upon upon IN 42759 346 16 which which WDT 42759 346 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 346 18 is be VBZ 42759 346 19 to to TO 42759 346 20 exercise exercise VB 42759 346 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 346 22 faculties faculty NNS 42759 346 23 , , , 42759 346 24 and and CC 42759 346 25 of of IN 42759 346 26 which which WDT 42759 346 27 he -PRON- PRP 42759 346 28 is be VBZ 42759 346 29 to to TO 42759 346 30 become become VB 42759 346 31 the the DT 42759 346 32 owner owner NN 42759 346 33 by by IN 42759 346 34 right right NN 42759 346 35 of of IN 42759 346 36 production production NN 42759 346 37 , , , 42759 346 38 is be VBZ 42759 346 39 the the DT 42759 346 40 title title NN 42759 346 41 of of IN 42759 346 42 gift gift NN 42759 346 43 conferred confer VBN 42759 346 44 by by IN 42759 346 45 nature nature NN 42759 346 46 , , , 42759 346 47 or or CC 42759 346 48 nature nature NN 42759 346 49 's be VBZ 42759 346 50 God God NNP 42759 346 51 . . . 42759 347 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 347 2 this this DT 42759 347 3 title title NN 42759 347 4 is be VBZ 42759 347 5 applicable applicable JJ 42759 347 6 only only RB 42759 347 7 to to IN 42759 347 8 those those DT 42759 347 9 goods good NNS 42759 347 10 that that WDT 42759 347 11 exist exist VBP 42759 347 12 in in IN 42759 347 13 unlimited unlimited JJ 42759 347 14 abundance abundance NN 42759 347 15 , , , 42759 347 16 not not RB 42759 347 17 to to IN 42759 347 18 those those DT 42759 347 19 parts part NNS 42759 347 20 of of IN 42759 347 21 the the DT 42759 347 22 natural natural JJ 42759 347 23 bounty bounty NN 42759 347 24 that that WDT 42759 347 25 are be VBP 42759 347 26 scarce scarce JJ 42759 347 27 and and CC 42759 347 28 possess possess VB 42759 347 29 economic economic JJ 42759 347 30 value value NN 42759 347 31 . . . 42759 348 1 A a DT 42759 348 2 general general JJ 42759 348 3 assumption assumption NN 42759 348 4 by by IN 42759 348 5 producers producer NNS 42759 348 6 that that IN 42759 348 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 348 8 were be VBD 42759 348 9 entitled entitle VBN 42759 348 10 to to TO 42759 348 11 take take VB 42759 348 12 possession possession NN 42759 348 13 of of IN 42759 348 14 the the DT 42759 348 15 gifts gift NNS 42759 348 16 of of IN 42759 348 17 nature nature NN 42759 348 18 indiscriminately indiscriminately RB 42759 348 19 would would MD 42759 348 20 mean mean VB 42759 348 21 industrial industrial JJ 42759 348 22 anarchy anarchy NN 42759 348 23 and and CC 42759 348 24 civil civil JJ 42759 348 25 war war NN 42759 348 26 . . . 42759 349 1 Hence hence RB 42759 349 2 Henry Henry NNP 42759 349 3 George George NNP 42759 349 4 tells tell VBZ 42759 349 5 us -PRON- PRP 42759 349 6 that that IN 42759 349 7 the the DT 42759 349 8 individual individual NN 42759 349 9 should should MD 42759 349 10 pay pay VB 42759 349 11 rent rent NN 42759 349 12 to to IN 42759 349 13 " " `` 42759 349 14 the the DT 42759 349 15 community community NN 42759 349 16 to to TO 42759 349 17 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 349 18 the the DT 42759 349 19 equal equal JJ 42759 349 20 rights right NNS 42759 349 21 of of IN 42759 349 22 all all DT 42759 349 23 other other JJ 42759 349 24 members member NNS 42759 349 25 of of IN 42759 349 26 the the DT 42759 349 27 community community NN 42759 349 28 . . . 42759 350 1 " " `` 42759 350 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 350 3 18 18 CD 42759 350 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 350 5 Inasmuch Inasmuch NNP 42759 350 6 as as IN 42759 350 7 the the DT 42759 350 8 individual individual NN 42759 350 9 must must MD 42759 350 10 pay pay VB 42759 350 11 this this DT 42759 350 12 price price NN 42759 350 13 before before IN 42759 350 14 he -PRON- PRP 42759 350 15 begins begin VBZ 42759 350 16 to to TO 42759 350 17 produce produce VB 42759 350 18 , , , 42759 350 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 350 20 right right NN 42759 350 21 to to IN 42759 350 22 the the DT 42759 350 23 use use NN 42759 350 24 of of IN 42759 350 25 natural natural JJ 42759 350 26 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 350 27 is be VBZ 42759 350 28 not not RB 42759 350 29 " " `` 42759 350 30 free free JJ 42759 350 31 , , , 42759 350 32 " " '' 42759 350 33 nor nor CC 42759 350 34 does do VBZ 42759 350 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 350 36 labour labour NN 42759 350 37 alone alone RB 42759 350 38 constitute constitute VB 42759 350 39 a a DT 42759 350 40 title title NN 42759 350 41 to to IN 42759 350 42 that that DT 42759 350 43 part part NN 42759 350 44 of of IN 42759 350 45 them -PRON- PRP 42759 350 46 that that WDT 42759 350 47 he -PRON- PRP 42759 350 48 utilises utilise VBZ 42759 350 49 in in IN 42759 350 50 production production NN 42759 350 51 . . . 42759 351 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 351 2 labour labour NN 42759 351 3 does do VBZ 42759 351 4 not not RB 42759 351 5 create create VB 42759 351 6 a a DT 42759 351 7 right right NN 42759 351 8 to to IN 42759 351 9 the the DT 42759 351 10 concrete concrete JJ 42759 351 11 product product NN 42759 351 12 . . . 42759 352 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 352 2 merely merely RB 42759 352 3 gives give VBZ 42759 352 4 the the DT 42759 352 5 producer producer NN 42759 352 6 a a DT 42759 352 7 right right NN 42759 352 8 to to IN 42759 352 9 the the DT 42759 352 10 value value NN 42759 352 11 that that WDT 42759 352 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 352 13 adds add VBZ 42759 352 14 to to IN 42759 352 15 the the DT 42759 352 16 raw raw JJ 42759 352 17 material material NN 42759 352 18 . . . 42759 353 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 353 2 right right NN 42759 353 3 to to IN 42759 353 4 the the DT 42759 353 5 raw raw JJ 42759 353 6 material material NN 42759 353 7 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 353 8 , , , 42759 353 9 to to IN 42759 353 10 the the DT 42759 353 11 elements element NNS 42759 353 12 that that WDT 42759 353 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 353 14 withdraws withdraw VBZ 42759 353 15 from from IN 42759 353 16 the the DT 42759 353 17 common common JJ 42759 353 18 store store NN 42759 353 19 , , , 42759 353 20 and and CC 42759 353 21 fashions fashion NNS 42759 353 22 into into IN 42759 353 23 a a DT 42759 353 24 product product NN 42759 353 25 , , , 42759 353 26 say say VB 42759 353 27 , , , 42759 353 28 wheat wheat NN 42759 353 29 , , , 42759 353 30 lumber lumber NN 42759 353 31 , , , 42759 353 32 or or CC 42759 353 33 steel steel NN 42759 353 34 , , , 42759 353 35 does do VBZ 42759 353 36 not not RB 42759 353 37 originate originate VB 42759 353 38 in in IN 42759 353 39 the the DT 42759 353 40 title title NN 42759 353 41 of of IN 42759 353 42 labour labour NN 42759 353 43 but but CC 42759 353 44 in in IN 42759 353 45 the the DT 42759 353 46 title title NN 42759 353 47 of of IN 42759 353 48 contract contract NN 42759 353 49 . . . 42759 354 1 This this DT 42759 354 2 is be VBZ 42759 354 3 the the DT 42759 354 4 contract contract NN 42759 354 5 by by IN 42759 354 6 which which WDT 42759 354 7 in in IN 42759 354 8 exchange exchange NN 42759 354 9 for for IN 42759 354 10 rent rent NN 42759 354 11 paid pay VBN 42759 354 12 to to IN 42759 354 13 the the DT 42759 354 14 community community NN 42759 354 15 he -PRON- PRP 42759 354 16 is be VBZ 42759 354 17 authorised authorise VBN 42759 354 18 to to TO 42759 354 19 utilise utilise VB 42759 354 20 these these DT 42759 354 21 materials material NNS 42759 354 22 . . . 42759 355 1 Until until IN 42759 355 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 355 3 has have VBZ 42759 355 4 made make VBN 42759 355 5 this this DT 42759 355 6 contract contract NN 42759 355 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 355 8 has have VBZ 42759 355 9 manifestly manifestly RB 42759 355 10 no no DT 42759 355 11 full full JJ 42759 355 12 right right NN 42759 355 13 to to IN 42759 355 14 the the DT 42759 355 15 product product NN 42759 355 16 into into IN 42759 355 17 which which WDT 42759 355 18 natural natural JJ 42759 355 19 forces force NNS 42759 355 20 as as RB 42759 355 21 well well RB 42759 355 22 as as IN 42759 355 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 355 24 own own JJ 42759 355 25 labour labour NN 42759 355 26 have have VBP 42759 355 27 entered enter VBN 42759 355 28 . . . 42759 356 1 According accord VBG 42759 356 2 to to IN 42759 356 3 Henry Henry NNP 42759 356 4 George George NNP 42759 356 5 's 's POS 42759 356 6 own own JJ 42759 356 7 statements statement NNS 42759 356 8 , , , 42759 356 9 therefore therefore RB 42759 356 10 , , , 42759 356 11 the the DT 42759 356 12 right right NN 42759 356 13 to to IN 42759 356 14 the the DT 42759 356 15 product product NN 42759 356 16 does do VBZ 42759 356 17 not not RB 42759 356 18 spring spring VB 42759 356 19 from from IN 42759 356 20 labour labour NN 42759 356 21 alone alone RB 42759 356 22 , , , 42759 356 23 but but CC 42759 356 24 from from IN 42759 356 25 labour labour NN 42759 356 26 plus plus CC 42759 356 27 compensation compensation NN 42759 356 28 to to IN 42759 356 29 the the DT 42759 356 30 community community NN 42759 356 31 . . . 42759 357 1 Since since IN 42759 357 2 the the DT 42759 357 3 contract contract NN 42759 357 4 by by IN 42759 357 5 which which WDT 42759 357 6 the the DT 42759 357 7 prospective prospective JJ 42759 357 8 user user NN 42759 357 9 agrees agree VBZ 42759 357 10 to to TO 42759 357 11 pay pay VB 42759 357 12 this this DT 42759 357 13 compensation compensation NN 42759 357 14 or or CC 42759 357 15 rent rent NN 42759 357 16 must must MD 42759 357 17 precede precede VB 42759 357 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 357 19 application application NN 42759 357 20 of of IN 42759 357 21 labour labour NN 42759 357 22 , , , 42759 357 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 357 24 instead instead RB 42759 357 25 of of IN 42759 357 26 labour labour NN 42759 357 27 is be VBZ 42759 357 28 the the DT 42759 357 29 original original JJ 42759 357 30 title title NN 42759 357 31 . . . 42759 358 1 Since since IN 42759 358 2 the the DT 42759 358 3 contract contract NN 42759 358 4 is be VBZ 42759 358 5 made make VBN 42759 358 6 with with IN 42759 358 7 a a DT 42759 358 8 particular particular JJ 42759 358 9 community community NN 42759 358 10 for for IN 42759 358 11 the the DT 42759 358 12 use use NN 42759 358 13 of of IN 42759 358 14 a a DT 42759 358 15 particular particular JJ 42759 358 16 piece piece NN 42759 358 17 of of IN 42759 358 18 land land NN 42759 358 19 , , , 42759 358 20 the the DT 42759 358 21 title title NN 42759 358 22 that that WDT 42759 358 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 358 24 conveys convey VBZ 42759 358 25 must must MD 42759 358 26 derive derive VB 42759 358 27 ultimately ultimately RB 42759 358 28 from from IN 42759 358 29 the the DT 42759 358 30 occupation occupation NN 42759 358 31 of of IN 42759 358 32 that that DT 42759 358 33 land land NN 42759 358 34 by by IN 42759 358 35 that that DT 42759 358 36 community,--or community,--or NN 42759 358 37 some some DT 42759 358 38 previous previous JJ 42759 358 39 community community NN 42759 358 40 of of IN 42759 358 41 which which WDT 42759 358 42 the the DT 42759 358 43 present present JJ 42759 358 44 one one CD 42759 358 45 is be VBZ 42759 358 46 the the DT 42759 358 47 legal legal JJ 42759 358 48 heir heir NN 42759 358 49 . . . 42759 359 1 So so RB 42759 359 2 far far RB 42759 359 3 as as IN 42759 359 4 economically economically RB 42759 359 5 valuable valuable JJ 42759 359 6 materials material NNS 42759 359 7 are be VBP 42759 359 8 concerned concern VBN 42759 359 9 , , , 42759 359 10 therefore therefore RB 42759 359 11 , , , 42759 359 12 the the DT 42759 359 13 logic logic NN 42759 359 14 of of IN 42759 359 15 Henry Henry NNP 42759 359 16 George George NNP 42759 359 17 's 's POS 42759 359 18 principles principle NNS 42759 359 19 leads lead VBZ 42759 359 20 inevitably inevitably RB 42759 359 21 to to IN 42759 359 22 the the DT 42759 359 23 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 359 24 that that IN 42759 359 25 the the DT 42759 359 26 original original JJ 42759 359 27 title title NN 42759 359 28 of of IN 42759 359 29 ownership ownership NN 42759 359 30 is be VBZ 42759 359 31 first first JJ 42759 359 32 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 359 33 . . . 42759 360 1 Even even RB 42759 360 2 in in IN 42759 360 3 the the DT 42759 360 4 case case NN 42759 360 5 of of IN 42759 360 6 economically economically RB 42759 360 7 free free JJ 42759 360 8 goods good NNS 42759 360 9 , , , 42759 360 10 the the DT 42759 360 11 original original JJ 42759 360 12 title title NN 42759 360 13 of of IN 42759 360 14 ownership ownership NN 42759 360 15 is be VBZ 42759 360 16 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 360 17 . . . 42759 361 1 Henry Henry NNP 42759 361 2 George George NNP 42759 361 3 declares declare VBZ 42759 361 4 that that IN 42759 361 5 the the DT 42759 361 6 traveller traveller NN 42759 361 7 who who WP 42759 361 8 has have VBZ 42759 361 9 filled fill VBN 42759 361 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 361 11 vessels vessel NNS 42759 361 12 at at IN 42759 361 13 a a DT 42759 361 14 free free JJ 42759 361 15 - - HYPH 42759 361 16 for for IN 42759 361 17 - - HYPH 42759 361 18 all all DT 42759 361 19 spring spring NN 42759 361 20 owns own VBZ 42759 361 21 the the DT 42759 361 22 water water NN 42759 361 23 when when WRB 42759 361 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 361 25 has have VBZ 42759 361 26 carried carry VBN 42759 361 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 361 28 into into IN 42759 361 29 a a DT 42759 361 30 desert desert NN 42759 361 31 , , , 42759 361 32 by by IN 42759 361 33 the the DT 42759 361 34 title title NN 42759 361 35 of of IN 42759 361 36 labour labour NN 42759 361 37 . . . 42759 362 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 362 2 19 19 CD 42759 362 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 362 4 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 362 5 , , , 42759 362 6 in in IN 42759 362 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 362 8 original original JJ 42759 362 9 place place NN 42759 362 10 this this DT 42759 362 11 water water NN 42759 362 12 belonged belong VBD 42759 362 13 either either CC 42759 362 14 to to IN 42759 362 15 the the DT 42759 362 16 community community NN 42759 362 17 or or CC 42759 362 18 to to IN 42759 362 19 nobody nobody NN 42759 362 20 . . . 42759 363 1 In in IN 42759 363 2 the the DT 42759 363 3 former former JJ 42759 363 4 supposition supposition NN 42759 363 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 363 6 can can MD 42759 363 7 become become VB 42759 363 8 the the DT 42759 363 9 property property NN 42759 363 10 of of IN 42759 363 11 the the DT 42759 363 12 traveller traveller NN 42759 363 13 only only RB 42759 363 14 through through IN 42759 363 15 an an DT 42759 363 16 explicit explicit JJ 42759 363 17 or or CC 42759 363 18 implicit implicit JJ 42759 363 19 gift gift NN 42759 363 20 from from IN 42759 363 21 the the DT 42759 363 22 community community NN 42759 363 23 ; ; : 42759 363 24 and and CC 42759 363 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 363 26 is be VBZ 42759 363 27 this this DT 42759 363 28 contract contract NN 42759 363 29 , , , 42759 363 30 not not RB 42759 363 31 labour labour NN 42759 363 32 , , , 42759 363 33 that that WDT 42759 363 34 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 363 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 363 36 title title NN 42759 363 37 to to IN 42759 363 38 the the DT 42759 363 39 water water NN 42759 363 40 . . . 42759 364 1 If if IN 42759 364 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 364 3 assume assume VBP 42759 364 4 that that IN 42759 364 5 the the DT 42759 364 6 spring spring NN 42759 364 7 was be VBD 42759 364 8 ownerless ownerless JJ 42759 364 9 , , , 42759 364 10 we -PRON- PRP 42759 364 11 see see VBP 42759 364 12 that that IN 42759 364 13 the the DT 42759 364 14 labour labour NN 42759 364 15 of of IN 42759 364 16 carrying carry VBG 42759 364 17 a a DT 42759 364 18 portion portion NN 42759 364 19 of of IN 42759 364 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 364 21 into into IN 42759 364 22 the the DT 42759 364 23 desert desert NN 42759 364 24 still still RB 42759 364 25 lacks lack VBZ 42759 364 26 the the DT 42759 364 27 qualifications qualification NNS 42759 364 28 of of IN 42759 364 29 a a DT 42759 364 30 title title NN 42759 364 31 ; ; : 42759 364 32 for for IN 42759 364 33 the the DT 42759 364 34 abstracted abstract VBN 42759 364 35 water water NN 42759 364 36 must must MD 42759 364 37 have have VB 42759 364 38 belonged belong VBN 42759 364 39 to to IN 42759 364 40 him -PRON- PRP 42759 364 41 before before IN 42759 364 42 he -PRON- PRP 42759 364 43 began begin VBD 42759 364 44 the the DT 42759 364 45 journey journey NN 42759 364 46 . . . 42759 365 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 365 2 must must MD 42759 365 3 have have VB 42759 365 4 been be VBN 42759 365 5 his -PRON- PRP 42759 365 6 from from IN 42759 365 7 the the DT 42759 365 8 moment moment NN 42759 365 9 that that WDT 42759 365 10 he -PRON- PRP 42759 365 11 separated separate VBD 42759 365 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 365 13 from from IN 42759 365 14 the the DT 42759 365 15 spring spring NN 42759 365 16 . . . 42759 366 1 Otherwise otherwise RB 42759 366 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 366 3 had have VBD 42759 366 4 no no DT 42759 366 5 right right NN 42759 366 6 to to TO 42759 366 7 take take VB 42759 366 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 366 9 away away RB 42759 366 10 . . . 42759 367 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 367 2 labour labour NN 42759 367 3 of of IN 42759 367 4 transporting transporting NN 42759 367 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 367 6 gave give VBD 42759 367 7 him -PRON- PRP 42759 367 8 a a DT 42759 367 9 right right NN 42759 367 10 to to IN 42759 367 11 the the DT 42759 367 12 utility utility NN 42759 367 13 thus thus RB 42759 367 14 added add VBD 42759 367 15 to to IN 42759 367 16 the the DT 42759 367 17 water water NN 42759 367 18 , , , 42759 367 19 but but CC 42759 367 20 not not RB 42759 367 21 a a DT 42759 367 22 right right NN 42759 367 23 to to IN 42759 367 24 the the DT 42759 367 25 water water NN 42759 367 26 when when WRB 42759 367 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 367 28 first first RB 42759 367 29 found find VBD 42759 367 30 a a DT 42759 367 31 local local JJ 42759 367 32 habitation habitation NN 42759 367 33 in in IN 42759 367 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 367 35 vessels vessel NNS 42759 367 36 . . . 42759 368 1 Nor nor CC 42759 368 2 was be VBD 42759 368 3 the the DT 42759 368 4 labour labour NN 42759 368 5 of of IN 42759 368 6 transferring transfer VBG 42759 368 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 368 8 from from IN 42759 368 9 the the DT 42759 368 10 spring spring NN 42759 368 11 into into IN 42759 368 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 368 13 vessels vessel NNS 42759 368 14 the the DT 42759 368 15 true true JJ 42759 368 16 title title NN 42759 368 17 ; ; : 42759 368 18 for for IN 42759 368 19 labour labour NN 42759 368 20 alone alone RB 42759 368 21 can can MD 42759 368 22 not not RB 42759 368 23 create create VB 42759 368 24 a a DT 42759 368 25 right right NN 42759 368 26 to to IN 42759 368 27 the the DT 42759 368 28 material material NN 42759 368 29 upon upon IN 42759 368 30 which which WDT 42759 368 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 368 32 is be VBZ 42759 368 33 exerted exert VBN 42759 368 34 , , , 42759 368 35 as as IN 42759 368 36 we -PRON- PRP 42759 368 37 see see VBP 42759 368 38 in in IN 42759 368 39 the the DT 42759 368 40 case case NN 42759 368 41 of of IN 42759 368 42 stolen steal VBN 42759 368 43 objects object NNS 42759 368 44 . . . 42759 369 1 If if IN 42759 369 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 369 3 be be VB 42759 369 4 contended contend VBN 42759 369 5 that that IN 42759 369 6 labour labour NN 42759 369 7 together together RB 42759 369 8 with with IN 42759 369 9 the the DT 42759 369 10 natural natural JJ 42759 369 11 right right NN 42759 369 12 to to TO 42759 369 13 use use VB 42759 369 14 the the DT 42759 369 15 ownerless ownerless JJ 42759 369 16 goods good NNS 42759 369 17 of of IN 42759 369 18 nature nature NN 42759 369 19 have have VBP 42759 369 20 all all PDT 42759 369 21 the the DT 42759 369 22 elements element NNS 42759 369 23 of of IN 42759 369 24 a a DT 42759 369 25 valid valid JJ 42759 369 26 title title NN 42759 369 27 , , , 42759 369 28 the the DT 42759 369 29 assertion assertion NN 42759 369 30 must must MD 42759 369 31 be be VB 42759 369 32 rejected reject VBN 42759 369 33 as as IN 42759 369 34 unprecise unprecise JJ 42759 369 35 and and CC 42759 369 36 inadequate inadequate JJ 42759 369 37 . . . 42759 370 1 The the DT 42759 370 2 right right NN 42759 370 3 to to TO 42759 370 4 use use VB 42759 370 5 ownerless ownerless JJ 42759 370 6 goods good NNS 42759 370 7 is be VBZ 42759 370 8 a a DT 42759 370 9 general general JJ 42759 370 10 and and CC 42759 370 11 abstract abstract JJ 42759 370 12 right right UH 42759 370 13 that that WDT 42759 370 14 requires require VBZ 42759 370 15 to to TO 42759 370 16 become become VB 42759 370 17 specific specific JJ 42759 370 18 and and CC 42759 370 19 concrete concrete JJ 42759 370 20 through through IN 42759 370 21 some some DT 42759 370 22 title title NN 42759 370 23 . . . 42759 371 1 In in IN 42759 371 2 the the DT 42759 371 3 case case NN 42759 371 4 of of IN 42759 371 5 water water NN 42759 371 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 371 7 is be VBZ 42759 371 8 a a DT 42759 371 9 right right NN 42759 371 10 to to IN 42759 371 11 water water NN 42759 371 12 in in IN 42759 371 13 general general JJ 42759 371 14 , , , 42759 371 15 to to IN 42759 371 16 some some DT 42759 371 17 water water NN 42759 371 18 , , , 42759 371 19 but but CC 42759 371 20 not not RB 42759 371 21 a a DT 42759 371 22 right right NN 42759 371 23 to to IN 42759 371 24 a a DT 42759 371 25 definite definite JJ 42759 371 26 portion portion NN 42759 371 27 of of IN 42759 371 28 the the DT 42759 371 29 water water NN 42759 371 30 in in IN 42759 371 31 this this DT 42759 371 32 particular particular JJ 42759 371 33 spring spring NN 42759 371 34 . . . 42759 372 1 The the DT 42759 372 2 required required JJ 42759 372 3 and and CC 42759 372 4 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 372 5 title title NN 42759 372 6 here here RB 42759 372 7 is be VBZ 42759 372 8 that that DT 42759 372 9 of of IN 42759 372 10 apprehension apprehension NN 42759 372 11 , , , 42759 372 12 occupation occupation NN 42759 372 13 , , , 42759 372 14 the the DT 42759 372 15 act act NN 42759 372 16 of of IN 42759 372 17 separating separate VBG 42759 372 18 a a DT 42759 372 19 portion portion NN 42759 372 20 from from IN 42759 372 21 the the DT 42759 372 22 natural natural JJ 42759 372 23 reservoir reservoir NN 42759 372 24 . . . 42759 373 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 373 2 , , , 42759 373 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 373 4 is be VBZ 42759 373 5 first first JJ 42759 373 6 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 373 7 as as IN 42759 373 8 exemplified exemplify VBN 42759 373 9 in in IN 42759 373 10 mere mere JJ 42759 373 11 seizure seizure NN 42759 373 12 of of IN 42759 373 13 an an DT 42759 373 14 ownerless ownerless JJ 42759 373 15 good good JJ 42759 373 16 , , , 42759 373 17 not not RB 42759 373 18 labour labour JJ 42759 373 19 in in IN 42759 373 20 the the DT 42759 373 21 sense sense NN 42759 373 22 of of IN 42759 373 23 productive productive JJ 42759 373 24 activity activity NN 42759 373 25 , , , 42759 373 26 nor nor CC 42759 373 27 labour labour NN 42759 373 28 in in IN 42759 373 29 the the DT 42759 373 30 sense sense NN 42759 373 31 of of IN 42759 373 32 painful painful JJ 42759 373 33 exertion exertion NN 42759 373 34 , , , 42759 373 35 that that WDT 42759 373 36 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 373 37 the the DT 42759 373 38 precise precise JJ 42759 373 39 title title NN 42759 373 40 whereby whereby WRB 42759 373 41 the the DT 42759 373 42 man man NN 42759 373 43 acquires acquire VBZ 42759 373 44 a a DT 42759 373 45 right right NN 42759 373 46 to to IN 42759 373 47 the the DT 42759 373 48 water water NN 42759 373 49 that that WDT 42759 373 50 he -PRON- PRP 42759 373 51 has have VBZ 42759 373 52 put put VBN 42759 373 53 into into IN 42759 373 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 373 55 cup cup NN 42759 373 56 or or CC 42759 373 57 barrel barrel NN 42759 373 58 . . . 42759 374 1 Mere mere JJ 42759 374 2 seizure seizure NN 42759 374 3 is be VBZ 42759 374 4 a a DT 42759 374 5 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 374 6 title title NN 42759 374 7 in in IN 42759 374 8 all all DT 42759 374 9 such such JJ 42759 374 10 cases case NNS 42759 374 11 as as IN 42759 374 12 that that DT 42759 374 13 which which WDT 42759 374 14 we -PRON- PRP 42759 374 15 are be VBP 42759 374 16 now now RB 42759 374 17 considering consider VBG 42759 374 18 , , , 42759 374 19 simply simply RB 42759 374 20 because because IN 42759 374 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 374 22 is be VBZ 42759 374 23 a a DT 42759 374 24 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 374 25 method method NN 42759 374 26 of of IN 42759 374 27 determining determine VBG 42759 374 28 and and CC 42759 374 29 specifying specify VBG 42759 374 30 ownership ownership NN 42759 374 31 . . . 42759 375 1 There there EX 42759 375 2 is be VBZ 42759 375 3 no no DT 42759 375 4 need need NN 42759 375 5 whatever whatever WDT 42759 375 6 of of IN 42759 375 7 having have VBG 42759 375 8 recourse recourse NN 42759 375 9 to to IN 42759 375 10 the the DT 42759 375 11 concept concept NN 42759 375 12 of of IN 42759 375 13 labour labour NN 42759 375 14 to to TO 42759 375 15 justify justify VB 42759 375 16 this this DT 42759 375 17 kind kind NN 42759 375 18 of of IN 42759 375 19 property property NN 42759 375 20 right right RB 42759 375 21 . . . 42759 376 1 In in IN 42759 376 2 the the DT 42759 376 3 present present JJ 42759 376 4 case case NN 42759 376 5 , , , 42759 376 6 indeed indeed RB 42759 376 7 , , , 42759 376 8 the the DT 42759 376 9 acts act NNS 42759 376 10 of of IN 42759 376 11 apprehension apprehension NN 42759 376 12 and and CC 42759 376 13 of of IN 42759 376 14 productive productive JJ 42759 376 15 labour labour NN 42759 376 16 ( ( -LRB- 42759 376 17 the the DT 42759 376 18 labour labour NN 42759 376 19 of of IN 42759 376 20 dipping dip VBG 42759 376 21 the the DT 42759 376 22 water water NN 42759 376 23 into into IN 42759 376 24 a a DT 42759 376 25 vessel vessel NN 42759 376 26 _ _ NNP 42759 376 27 is be VBZ 42759 376 28 _ _ NNP 42759 376 29 productive productive JJ 42759 376 30 inasmuch inasmuch NN 42759 376 31 as as IN 42759 376 32 the the DT 42759 376 33 water water NN 42759 376 34 is be VBZ 42759 376 35 more more RBR 42759 376 36 useful useful JJ 42759 376 37 there there RB 42759 376 38 than than IN 42759 376 39 in in IN 42759 376 40 the the DT 42759 376 41 spring spring NN 42759 376 42 ) ) -RRB- 42759 376 43 are be VBP 42759 376 44 the the DT 42759 376 45 same same JJ 42759 376 46 physically physically RB 42759 376 47 , , , 42759 376 48 but but CC 42759 376 49 they -PRON- PRP 42759 376 50 are be VBP 42759 376 51 distinct distinct JJ 42759 376 52 logically logically RB 42759 376 53 and and CC 42759 376 54 ethically ethically RB 42759 376 55 . . . 42759 377 1 One one CD 42759 377 2 is be VBZ 42759 377 3 mere mere JJ 42759 377 4 occupation occupation NN 42759 377 5 , , , 42759 377 6 while while IN 42759 377 7 the the DT 42759 377 8 other other JJ 42759 377 9 is be VBZ 42759 377 10 production production NN 42759 377 11 ; ; : 42759 377 12 and and CC 42759 377 13 ownership ownership NN 42759 377 14 of of IN 42759 377 15 a a DT 42759 377 16 thing thing NN 42759 377 17 must must MD 42759 377 18 precede precede VB 42759 377 19 , , , 42759 377 20 in in IN 42759 377 21 morals moral NNS 42759 377 22 if if IN 42759 377 23 not not RB 42759 377 24 in in IN 42759 377 25 time time NN 42759 377 26 , , , 42759 377 27 the the DT 42759 377 28 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 377 29 upon upon IN 42759 377 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 377 31 of of IN 42759 377 32 productive productive JJ 42759 377 33 labour labour NN 42759 377 34 . . . 42759 378 1 " " `` 42759 378 2 The the DT 42759 378 3 theory theory NN 42759 378 4 which which WDT 42759 378 5 bases base VBZ 42759 378 6 the the DT 42759 378 7 right right NN 42759 378 8 of of IN 42759 378 9 property property NN 42759 378 10 on on IN 42759 378 11 labour labour NN 42759 378 12 really really RB 42759 378 13 depends depend VBZ 42759 378 14 in in IN 42759 378 15 the the DT 42759 378 16 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 378 17 resort resort NN 42759 378 18 on on IN 42759 378 19 the the DT 42759 378 20 right right NN 42759 378 21 of of IN 42759 378 22 possession possession NN 42759 378 23 and and CC 42759 378 24 the the DT 42759 378 25 fact fact NN 42759 378 26 that that IN 42759 378 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 378 28 is be VBZ 42759 378 29 socially socially RB 42759 378 30 expedient expedient JJ 42759 378 31 , , , 42759 378 32 and and CC 42759 378 33 is be VBZ 42759 378 34 therefore therefore RB 42759 378 35 upheld uphold VBN 42759 378 36 by by IN 42759 378 37 the the DT 42759 378 38 laws law NNS 42759 378 39 of of IN 42759 378 40 society society NN 42759 378 41 . . . 42759 379 1 Grotius Grotius NNP 42759 379 2 , , , 42759 379 3 discussing discuss VBG 42759 379 4 this this DT 42759 379 5 in in IN 42759 379 6 the the DT 42759 379 7 old old JJ 42759 379 8 Roman roman JJ 42759 379 9 days day NNS 42759 379 10 , , , 42759 379 11 pointed point VBD 42759 379 12 out out RP 42759 379 13 that that IN 42759 379 14 since since IN 42759 379 15 nothing nothing NN 42759 379 16 can can MD 42759 379 17 be be VB 42759 379 18 made make VBN 42759 379 19 except except IN 42759 379 20 out out IN 42759 379 21 of of IN 42759 379 22 pre pre JJ 42759 379 23 - - JJ 42759 379 24 existing existing JJ 42759 379 25 matter matter NN 42759 379 26 , , , 42759 379 27 acquisition acquisition NN 42759 379 28 by by IN 42759 379 29 means mean NNS 42759 379 30 of of IN 42759 379 31 labour labour NN 42759 379 32 depends depend VBZ 42759 379 33 , , , 42759 379 34 ultimately ultimately RB 42759 379 35 , , , 42759 379 36 on on IN 42759 379 37 possession possession NN 42759 379 38 by by IN 42759 379 39 means mean NNS 42759 379 40 of of IN 42759 379 41 occupation occupation NN 42759 379 42 . . . 42759 380 1 " " `` 42759 380 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 380 3 20 20 CD 42759 380 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 380 5 Since since IN 42759 380 6 man man NN 42759 380 7 's 's POS 42759 380 8 right right NN 42759 380 9 to to IN 42759 380 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 380 11 faculties faculty NNS 42759 380 12 does do VBZ 42759 380 13 not not RB 42759 380 14 of of IN 42759 380 15 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 380 16 give give VB 42759 380 17 him -PRON- PRP 42759 380 18 a a DT 42759 380 19 right right NN 42759 380 20 to to TO 42759 380 21 exercise exercise VB 42759 380 22 them -PRON- PRP 42759 380 23 upon upon IN 42759 380 24 material material JJ 42759 380 25 objects object NNS 42759 380 26 , , , 42759 380 27 productive productive JJ 42759 380 28 labour labour NN 42759 380 29 can can MD 42759 380 30 not not RB 42759 380 31 of of IN 42759 380 32 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 380 33 give give VB 42759 380 34 him -PRON- PRP 42759 380 35 a a DT 42759 380 36 right right NN 42759 380 37 to to IN 42759 380 38 the the DT 42759 380 39 product product NN 42759 380 40 therefrom therefrom JJ 42759 380 41 created create VBN 42759 380 42 , , , 42759 380 43 nor nor CC 42759 380 44 constitute constitute VB 42759 380 45 the the DT 42759 380 46 original original JJ 42759 380 47 title title NN 42759 380 48 of of IN 42759 380 49 ownership ownership NN 42759 380 50 . . . 42759 381 1 Since since IN 42759 381 2 labour labour NN 42759 381 3 is be VBZ 42759 381 4 not not RB 42759 381 5 the the DT 42759 381 6 original original JJ 42759 381 7 title title NN 42759 381 8 to to IN 42759 381 9 property property NN 42759 381 10 , , , 42759 381 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 381 12 is be VBZ 42759 381 13 not not RB 42759 381 14 the the DT 42759 381 15 only only JJ 42759 381 16 possible possible JJ 42759 381 17 title title NN 42759 381 18 to to IN 42759 381 19 property property NN 42759 381 20 in in IN 42759 381 21 land land NN 42759 381 22 . . . 42759 382 1 Hence hence RB 42759 382 2 the the DT 42759 382 3 fact fact NN 42759 382 4 that that IN 42759 382 5 labour labour NN 42759 382 6 does do VBZ 42759 382 7 not not RB 42759 382 8 produce produce VB 42759 382 9 land land NN 42759 382 10 , , , 42759 382 11 has have VBZ 42759 382 12 no no DT 42759 382 13 bearing bearing NN 42759 382 14 on on IN 42759 382 15 the the DT 42759 382 16 question question NN 42759 382 17 of of IN 42759 382 18 private private JJ 42759 382 19 landownership landownership NN 42759 382 20 . . . 42759 383 1 In in IN 42759 383 2 passing pass VBG 42759 383 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 383 4 may may MD 42759 383 5 be be VB 42759 383 6 observed observe VBN 42759 383 7 that that IN 42759 383 8 Henry Henry NNP 42759 383 9 George George NNP 42759 383 10 implicitly implicitly RB 42759 383 11 admitted admit VBD 42759 383 12 that that IN 42759 383 13 the the DT 42759 383 14 argument argument NN 42759 383 15 from from IN 42759 383 16 the the DT 42759 383 17 labour labour NNP 42759 383 18 title title NN 42759 383 19 was be VBD 42759 383 20 not not RB 42759 383 21 of of IN 42759 383 22 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 383 23 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 383 24 to to TO 42759 383 25 disprove disprove VB 42759 383 26 the the DT 42759 383 27 right right NN 42759 383 28 of of IN 42759 383 29 private private JJ 42759 383 30 property property NN 42759 383 31 in in IN 42759 383 32 land land NN 42759 383 33 . . . 42759 384 1 Considering consider VBG 42759 384 2 the the DT 42759 384 3 objection objection NN 42759 384 4 , , , 42759 384 5 " " `` 42759 384 6 if if IN 42759 384 7 private private JJ 42759 384 8 property property NN 42759 384 9 in in IN 42759 384 10 land land NN 42759 384 11 be be VB 42759 384 12 not not RB 42759 384 13 just just RB 42759 384 14 , , , 42759 384 15 then then RB 42759 384 16 private private JJ 42759 384 17 property property NN 42759 384 18 in in IN 42759 384 19 the the DT 42759 384 20 products product NNS 42759 384 21 of of IN 42759 384 22 land land NN 42759 384 23 is be VBZ 42759 384 24 not not RB 42759 384 25 just just RB 42759 384 26 , , , 42759 384 27 as as IN 42759 384 28 the the DT 42759 384 29 material material NN 42759 384 30 of of IN 42759 384 31 these these DT 42759 384 32 products product NNS 42759 384 33 is be VBZ 42759 384 34 taken take VBN 42759 384 35 from from IN 42759 384 36 the the DT 42759 384 37 land land NN 42759 384 38 , , , 42759 384 39 " " '' 42759 384 40 he -PRON- PRP 42759 384 41 replied reply VBD 42759 384 42 that that IN 42759 384 43 the the DT 42759 384 44 latter latter JJ 42759 384 45 form form NN 42759 384 46 of of IN 42759 384 47 ownership ownership NN 42759 384 48 " " '' 42759 384 49 is be VBZ 42759 384 50 in in IN 42759 384 51 reality reality NN 42759 384 52 a a DT 42759 384 53 mere mere JJ 42759 384 54 right right NN 42759 384 55 of of IN 42759 384 56 temporary temporary JJ 42759 384 57 possession possession NN 42759 384 58 , , , 42759 384 59 " " '' 42759 384 60 since since IN 42759 384 61 the the DT 42759 384 62 raw raw JJ 42759 384 63 material material NN 42759 384 64 in in IN 42759 384 65 the the DT 42759 384 66 products product NNS 42759 384 67 sooner sooner RB 42759 384 68 or or CC 42759 384 69 later later RB 42759 384 70 returns return NNS 42759 384 71 to to IN 42759 384 72 the the DT 42759 384 73 " " `` 42759 384 74 reservoirs reservoir NNS 42759 384 75 provided provide VBN 42759 384 76 for for IN 42759 384 77 all all DT 42759 384 78 ... ... : 42759 384 79 and and CC 42759 384 80 thus thus RB 42759 384 81 the the DT 42759 384 82 ownership ownership NN 42759 384 83 of of IN 42759 384 84 them -PRON- PRP 42759 384 85 by by IN 42759 384 86 one one CD 42759 384 87 works work VBZ 42759 384 88 no no DT 42759 384 89 injury injury NN 42759 384 90 to to IN 42759 384 91 others other NNS 42759 384 92 . . . 42759 385 1 " " `` 42759 385 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 385 3 21 21 CD 42759 385 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 385 5 But but CC 42759 385 6 private private JJ 42759 385 7 ownership ownership NN 42759 385 8 of of IN 42759 385 9 land land NN 42759 385 10 , , , 42759 385 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 385 12 continued continue VBD 42759 385 13 , , , 42759 385 14 shuts shut NNS 42759 385 15 out out RP 42759 385 16 others other NNS 42759 385 17 from from IN 42759 385 18 the the DT 42759 385 19 very very JJ 42759 385 20 reservoirs reservoir NNS 42759 385 21 . . . 42759 386 1 Here here RB 42759 386 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 386 3 have have VBP 42759 386 4 a a DT 42759 386 5 complete complete JJ 42759 386 6 abandonment abandonment NN 42759 386 7 of of IN 42759 386 8 the the DT 42759 386 9 principle principle NN 42759 386 10 which which WDT 42759 386 11 underlies underlie VBZ 42759 386 12 the the DT 42759 386 13 labour labour JJ 42759 386 14 argument argument NN 42759 386 15 . . . 42759 387 1 Instead instead RB 42759 387 2 of of IN 42759 387 3 trying try VBG 42759 387 4 to to TO 42759 387 5 show show VB 42759 387 6 from from IN 42759 387 7 the the DT 42759 387 8 nature nature NN 42759 387 9 of of IN 42759 387 10 the the DT 42759 387 11 situation situation NN 42759 387 12 that that IN 42759 387 13 there there EX 42759 387 14 is be VBZ 42759 387 15 a a DT 42759 387 16 logical logical JJ 42759 387 17 difference difference NN 42759 387 18 between between IN 42759 387 19 the the DT 42759 387 20 two two CD 42759 387 21 kinds kind NNS 42759 387 22 of of IN 42759 387 23 ownership ownership NN 42759 387 24 , , , 42759 387 25 he -PRON- PRP 42759 387 26 shifts shift VBZ 42759 387 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 387 28 ground ground NN 42759 387 29 to to IN 42759 387 30 a a DT 42759 387 31 consideration consideration NN 42759 387 32 of of IN 42759 387 33 consequences consequence NNS 42759 387 34 . . . 42759 388 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 388 2 makes make VBZ 42759 388 3 the the DT 42759 388 4 title title NN 42759 388 5 of of IN 42759 388 6 social social JJ 42759 388 7 utility utility NN 42759 388 8 instead instead RB 42759 388 9 of of IN 42759 388 10 the the DT 42759 388 11 title title NN 42759 388 12 of of IN 42759 388 13 labour labour NN 42759 388 14 the the DT 42759 388 15 distinguishing distinguishing JJ 42759 388 16 and and CC 42759 388 17 decisive decisive JJ 42759 388 18 consideration consideration NN 42759 388 19 . . . 42759 389 1 As as IN 42759 389 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 389 3 shall shall MD 42759 389 4 see see VB 42759 389 5 later later RBR 42759 389 6 , , , 42759 389 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 389 8 is be VBZ 42759 389 9 wrong wrong JJ 42759 389 10 even even RB 42759 389 11 on on IN 42759 389 12 this this DT 42759 389 13 ground ground NN 42759 389 14 ; ; : 42759 389 15 for for IN 42759 389 16 the the DT 42759 389 17 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 389 18 justification justification NN 42759 389 19 of of IN 42759 389 20 private private JJ 42759 389 21 landownership landownership NN 42759 389 22 is be VBZ 42759 389 23 precisely precisely RB 42759 389 24 the the DT 42759 389 25 fact fact NN 42759 389 26 that that IN 42759 389 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 389 28 is be VBZ 42759 389 29 the the DT 42759 389 30 system system NN 42759 389 31 of of IN 42759 389 32 land land NN 42759 389 33 tenure tenure NN 42759 389 34 most most RBS 42759 389 35 conducive conducive JJ 42759 389 36 to to IN 42759 389 37 human human JJ 42759 389 38 welfare welfare NN 42759 389 39 . . . 42759 390 1 At at IN 42759 390 2 present present NN 42759 390 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 390 4 merely merely RB 42759 390 5 call call VBP 42759 390 6 attention attention NN 42759 390 7 to to IN 42759 390 8 the the DT 42759 390 9 breakdown breakdown NN 42759 390 10 in in IN 42759 390 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 390 12 own own JJ 42759 390 13 hands hand NNS 42759 390 14 of of IN 42759 390 15 the the DT 42759 390 16 labour labour JJ 42759 390 17 argument argument NN 42759 390 18 . . . 42759 391 1 To to TO 42759 391 2 sum sum VB 42759 391 3 up up RP 42759 391 4 the the DT 42759 391 5 entire entire JJ 42759 391 6 discussion discussion NN 42759 391 7 on on IN 42759 391 8 the the DT 42759 391 9 original original JJ 42759 391 10 title title NN 42759 391 11 of of IN 42759 391 12 ownership ownership NN 42759 391 13 : : : 42759 391 14 Henry Henry NNP 42759 391 15 George George NNP 42759 391 16 's 's POS 42759 391 17 attack attack NN 42759 391 18 upon upon IN 42759 391 19 first first JJ 42759 391 20 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 391 21 is be VBZ 42759 391 22 futile futile JJ 42759 391 23 because because IN 42759 391 24 based base VBN 42759 391 25 upon upon IN 42759 391 26 an an DT 42759 391 27 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 42759 391 28 conception conception NN 42759 391 29 of of IN 42759 391 30 the the DT 42759 391 31 scope scope NN 42759 391 32 of of IN 42759 391 33 private private JJ 42759 391 34 landownership landownership NN 42759 391 35 , , , 42759 391 36 and and CC 42759 391 37 upon upon IN 42759 391 38 a a DT 42759 391 39 false false JJ 42759 391 40 assumption assumption NN 42759 391 41 concerning concern VBG 42759 391 42 the the DT 42759 391 43 responsibility responsibility NN 42759 391 44 of of IN 42759 391 45 that that DT 42759 391 46 title title NN 42759 391 47 for for IN 42759 391 48 the the DT 42759 391 49 historical historical JJ 42759 391 50 evils evil NNS 42759 391 51 of of IN 42759 391 52 the the DT 42759 391 53 system system NN 42759 391 54 . . . 42759 392 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 392 2 attempt attempt NN 42759 392 3 to to TO 42759 392 4 substitute substitute VB 42759 392 5 labour labour NN 42759 392 6 as as IN 42759 392 7 the the DT 42759 392 8 original original JJ 42759 392 9 title title NN 42759 392 10 is be VBZ 42759 392 11 likewise likewise RB 42759 392 12 unsuccessful unsuccessful JJ 42759 392 13 , , , 42759 392 14 since since IN 42759 392 15 labour labour NN 42759 392 16 can can MD 42759 392 17 give give VB 42759 392 18 a a DT 42759 392 19 right right NN 42759 392 20 only only RB 42759 392 21 to to IN 42759 392 22 the the DT 42759 392 23 utility utility NN 42759 392 24 added add VBN 42759 392 25 to to IN 42759 392 26 natural natural JJ 42759 392 27 materials material NNS 42759 392 28 , , , 42759 392 29 not not RB 42759 392 30 to to IN 42759 392 31 the the DT 42759 392 32 materials material NNS 42759 392 33 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 392 34 . . . 42759 393 1 Ownership ownership NN 42759 393 2 of of IN 42759 393 3 the the DT 42759 393 4 latter latter JJ 42759 393 5 reaches reach NNS 42759 393 6 back back RB 42759 393 7 finally finally RB 42759 393 8 to to IN 42759 393 9 occupation occupation NN 42759 393 10 . . . 42759 394 1 Whence whence IN 42759 394 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 394 3 follows follow VBZ 42759 394 4 that that IN 42759 394 5 the the DT 42759 394 6 title title NN 42759 394 7 to to IN 42759 394 8 an an DT 42759 394 9 artificial artificial JJ 42759 394 10 thing thing NN 42759 394 11 , , , 42759 394 12 such such JJ 42759 394 13 as as IN 42759 394 14 a a DT 42759 394 15 hat hat NN 42759 394 16 or or CC 42759 394 17 coat coat NN 42759 394 18 , , , 42759 394 19 water water NN 42759 394 20 taken take VBN 42759 394 21 from from IN 42759 394 22 a a DT 42759 394 23 spring spring NN 42759 394 24 , , , 42759 394 25 a a DT 42759 394 26 fish fish NN 42759 394 27 drawn draw VBN 42759 394 28 from from IN 42759 394 29 the the DT 42759 394 30 sea sea NN 42759 394 31 , , , 42759 394 32 is be VBZ 42759 394 33 a a DT 42759 394 34 joint joint JJ 42759 394 35 or or CC 42759 394 36 two two CD 42759 394 37 - - HYPH 42759 394 38 fold fold JJ 42759 394 39 title title NN 42759 394 40 ; ; : 42759 394 41 namely namely RB 42759 394 42 , , , 42759 394 43 occupation occupation NN 42759 394 44 and and CC 42759 394 45 labour labour NN 42759 394 46 . . . 42759 395 1 Where where WRB 42759 395 2 the the DT 42759 395 3 product product NN 42759 395 4 embodies embody VBZ 42759 395 5 scarce scarce JJ 42759 395 6 and and CC 42759 395 7 economically economically RB 42759 395 8 valuable valuable JJ 42759 395 9 raw raw JJ 42759 395 10 material material NN 42759 395 11 , , , 42759 395 12 occupation occupation NN 42759 395 13 is be VBZ 42759 395 14 usually usually RB 42759 395 15 prior prior RB 42759 395 16 to to IN 42759 395 17 labour labour NN 42759 395 18 in in IN 42759 395 19 time time NN 42759 395 20 ; ; : 42759 395 21 in in IN 42759 395 22 _ _ NNP 42759 395 23 all all DT 42759 395 24 _ _ NNP 42759 395 25 cases case NNS 42759 395 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 395 27 is be VBZ 42759 395 28 prior prior JJ 42759 395 29 to to IN 42759 395 30 labour labour NN 42759 395 31 logically logically RB 42759 395 32 and and CC 42759 395 33 ethically ethically RB 42759 395 34 . . . 42759 396 1 Since since IN 42759 396 2 labour labour NN 42759 396 3 is be VBZ 42759 396 4 not not RB 42759 396 5 the the DT 42759 396 6 original original JJ 42759 396 7 title title NN 42759 396 8 , , , 42759 396 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 396 10 absence absence NN 42759 396 11 in in IN 42759 396 12 the the DT 42759 396 13 case case NN 42759 396 14 of of IN 42759 396 15 land land NN 42759 396 16 does do VBZ 42759 396 17 not not RB 42759 396 18 leave leave VB 42759 396 19 that that DT 42759 396 20 form form NN 42759 396 21 of of IN 42759 396 22 property property NN 42759 396 23 unjustified unjustified NN 42759 396 24 . . . 42759 397 1 The the DT 42759 397 2 title title NN 42759 397 3 of of IN 42759 397 4 first first JJ 42759 397 5 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 397 6 remains remain VBZ 42759 397 7 . . . 42759 398 1 In in IN 42759 398 2 a a DT 42759 398 3 word word NN 42759 398 4 , , , 42759 398 5 the the DT 42759 398 6 one one CD 42759 398 7 original original JJ 42759 398 8 title title NN 42759 398 9 of of IN 42759 398 10 all all DT 42759 398 11 property property NN 42759 398 12 , , , 42759 398 13 natural natural JJ 42759 398 14 and and CC 42759 398 15 artificial artificial JJ 42759 398 16 , , , 42759 398 17 is be VBZ 42759 398 18 first first JJ 42759 398 19 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 398 20 . . . 42759 399 1 The the DT 42759 399 2 other other JJ 42759 399 3 arguments argument NNS 42759 399 4 of of IN 42759 399 5 Henry Henry NNP 42759 399 6 George George NNP 42759 399 7 against against IN 42759 399 8 private private JJ 42759 399 9 landownership landownership NN 42759 399 10 are be VBP 42759 399 11 based base VBN 42759 399 12 upon upon IN 42759 399 13 the the DT 42759 399 14 assumed assumed JJ 42759 399 15 right right NN 42759 399 16 of of IN 42759 399 17 all all DT 42759 399 18 mankind mankind NN 42759 399 19 to to TO 42759 399 20 land land NN 42759 399 21 and and CC 42759 399 22 land land NN 42759 399 23 values value NNS 42759 399 24 , , , 42759 399 25 and and CC 42759 399 26 on on IN 42759 399 27 the the DT 42759 399 28 contention contention NN 42759 399 29 that that IN 42759 399 30 this this DT 42759 399 31 right right NN 42759 399 32 is be VBZ 42759 399 33 violated violate VBN 42759 399 34 by by IN 42759 399 35 the the DT 42759 399 36 present present JJ 42759 399 37 system system NN 42759 399 38 of of IN 42759 399 39 tenure tenure NN 42759 399 40 . . . 42759 400 1 _ _ NNP 42759 400 2 The the DT 42759 400 3 Right Right NNP 42759 400 4 of of IN 42759 400 5 All all DT 42759 400 6 Men Men NNPS 42759 400 7 to to IN 42759 400 8 the the DT 42759 400 9 Bounty Bounty NNP 42759 400 10 of of IN 42759 400 11 the the DT 42759 400 12 Earth Earth NNP 42759 400 13 _ _ NNP 42759 400 14 " " `` 42759 400 15 The the DT 42759 400 16 equal equal JJ 42759 400 17 right right NN 42759 400 18 of of IN 42759 400 19 all all DT 42759 400 20 men man NNS 42759 400 21 to to IN 42759 400 22 the the DT 42759 400 23 use use NN 42759 400 24 of of IN 42759 400 25 land land NN 42759 400 26 is be VBZ 42759 400 27 as as RB 42759 400 28 clear clear JJ 42759 400 29 as as IN 42759 400 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 400 31 equal equal JJ 42759 400 32 right right NN 42759 400 33 to to TO 42759 400 34 breathe breathe VB 42759 400 35 the the DT 42759 400 36 air air NN 42759 400 37 -- -- : 42759 400 38 it -PRON- PRP 42759 400 39 is be VBZ 42759 400 40 a a DT 42759 400 41 right right JJ 42759 400 42 proclaimed proclaim VBN 42759 400 43 by by IN 42759 400 44 the the DT 42759 400 45 fact fact NN 42759 400 46 of of IN 42759 400 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 400 48 existence existence NN 42759 400 49 . . . 42759 401 1 For for IN 42759 401 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 401 3 can can MD 42759 401 4 not not RB 42759 401 5 suppose suppose VB 42759 401 6 that that IN 42759 401 7 some some DT 42759 401 8 men man NNS 42759 401 9 have have VBP 42759 401 10 a a DT 42759 401 11 right right NN 42759 401 12 to to TO 42759 401 13 be be VB 42759 401 14 in in IN 42759 401 15 the the DT 42759 401 16 world world NN 42759 401 17 , , , 42759 401 18 and and CC 42759 401 19 others other NNS 42759 401 20 no no UH 42759 401 21 right right RB 42759 401 22 . . . 42759 402 1 " " `` 42759 402 2 If if IN 42759 402 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 402 4 are be VBP 42759 402 5 here here RB 42759 402 6 by by IN 42759 402 7 the the DT 42759 402 8 equal equal JJ 42759 402 9 permission permission NN 42759 402 10 of of IN 42759 402 11 the the DT 42759 402 12 Creator Creator NNP 42759 402 13 , , , 42759 402 14 we -PRON- PRP 42759 402 15 are be VBP 42759 402 16 all all RB 42759 402 17 here here RB 42759 402 18 with with IN 42759 402 19 an an DT 42759 402 20 equal equal JJ 42759 402 21 title title NN 42759 402 22 to to IN 42759 402 23 the the DT 42759 402 24 enjoyment enjoyment NN 42759 402 25 of of IN 42759 402 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 402 27 bounty bounty NN 42759 402 28 -- -- : 42759 402 29 with with IN 42759 402 30 an an DT 42759 402 31 equal equal JJ 42759 402 32 right right NN 42759 402 33 to to IN 42759 402 34 the the DT 42759 402 35 use use NN 42759 402 36 of of IN 42759 402 37 all all PDT 42759 402 38 that that DT 42759 402 39 nature nature NN 42759 402 40 so so RB 42759 402 41 impartially impartially RB 42759 402 42 offers offer VBZ 42759 402 43 .... .... . 42759 403 1 There there EX 42759 403 2 is be VBZ 42759 403 3 in in IN 42759 403 4 nature nature NN 42759 403 5 no no DT 42759 403 6 such such JJ 42759 403 7 thing thing NN 42759 403 8 as as IN 42759 403 9 a a DT 42759 403 10 fee fee NN 42759 403 11 simple simple NN 42759 403 12 in in IN 42759 403 13 land land NN 42759 403 14 . . . 42759 404 1 There there EX 42759 404 2 is be VBZ 42759 404 3 on on IN 42759 404 4 earth earth NN 42759 404 5 no no DT 42759 404 6 power power NN 42759 404 7 which which WDT 42759 404 8 can can MD 42759 404 9 rightfully rightfully RB 42759 404 10 make make VB 42759 404 11 a a DT 42759 404 12 grant grant NN 42759 404 13 of of IN 42759 404 14 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 404 15 ownership ownership NN 42759 404 16 of of IN 42759 404 17 land land NN 42759 404 18 . . . 42759 405 1 If if IN 42759 405 2 all all DT 42759 405 3 existing exist VBG 42759 405 4 men man NNS 42759 405 5 were be VBD 42759 405 6 to to TO 42759 405 7 grant grant VB 42759 405 8 away away RB 42759 405 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 405 10 equal equal JJ 42759 405 11 rights right NNS 42759 405 12 , , , 42759 405 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 405 14 could could MD 42759 405 15 not not RB 42759 405 16 grant grant VB 42759 405 17 away away RB 42759 405 18 the the DT 42759 405 19 rights right NNS 42759 405 20 of of IN 42759 405 21 those those DT 42759 405 22 who who WP 42759 405 23 follow follow VBP 42759 405 24 them -PRON- PRP 42759 405 25 . . . 42759 406 1 For for IN 42759 406 2 what what WP 42759 406 3 are be VBP 42759 406 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 406 5 but but CC 42759 406 6 tenants tenant NNS 42759 406 7 for for IN 42759 406 8 a a DT 42759 406 9 day day NN 42759 406 10 ? ? . 42759 407 1 Have have VBP 42759 407 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 407 3 made make VBN 42759 407 4 the the DT 42759 407 5 earth earth NN 42759 407 6 that that WDT 42759 407 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 407 8 should should MD 42759 407 9 determine determine VB 42759 407 10 the the DT 42759 407 11 rights right NNS 42759 407 12 of of IN 42759 407 13 those those DT 42759 407 14 who who WP 42759 407 15 after after IN 42759 407 16 us -PRON- PRP 42759 407 17 shall shall MD 42759 407 18 tenant tenant VB 42759 407 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 407 20 in in IN 42759 407 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 407 22 turn turn NN 42759 407 23 ? ? . 42759 408 1 " " `` 42759 408 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 408 3 22 22 CD 42759 408 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 408 5 The the DT 42759 408 6 right right NN 42759 408 7 to to TO 42759 408 8 use use VB 42759 408 9 the the DT 42759 408 10 goods good NNS 42759 408 11 of of IN 42759 408 12 nature nature NN 42759 408 13 for for IN 42759 408 14 the the DT 42759 408 15 support support NN 42759 408 16 of of IN 42759 408 17 life life NN 42759 408 18 is be VBZ 42759 408 19 certainly certainly RB 42759 408 20 a a DT 42759 408 21 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 408 22 natural natural JJ 42759 408 23 right right NN 42759 408 24 ; ; : 42759 408 25 and and CC 42759 408 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 408 27 is be VBZ 42759 408 28 substantially substantially RB 42759 408 29 equal equal JJ 42759 408 30 in in IN 42759 408 31 all all DT 42759 408 32 persons person NNS 42759 408 33 . . . 42759 409 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 409 2 arises arise VBZ 42759 409 3 , , , 42759 409 4 on on IN 42759 409 5 the the DT 42759 409 6 one one CD 42759 409 7 hand hand NN 42759 409 8 , , , 42759 409 9 from from IN 42759 409 10 man man NN 42759 409 11 's 's POS 42759 409 12 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 409 13 worth worth NN 42759 409 14 , , , 42759 409 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 409 16 essential essential JJ 42759 409 17 needs need NNS 42759 409 18 , , , 42759 409 19 and and CC 42759 409 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 409 21 final final JJ 42759 409 22 destiny destiny NN 42759 409 23 ; ; : 42759 409 24 and and CC 42759 409 25 , , , 42759 409 26 on on IN 42759 409 27 the the DT 42759 409 28 other other JJ 42759 409 29 hand hand NN 42759 409 30 , , , 42759 409 31 from from IN 42759 409 32 the the DT 42759 409 33 fact fact NN 42759 409 34 that that IN 42759 409 35 nature nature NN 42759 409 36 's 's POS 42759 409 37 bounty bounty NN 42759 409 38 has have VBZ 42759 409 39 been be VBN 42759 409 40 placed place VBN 42759 409 41 by by IN 42759 409 42 God God NNP 42759 409 43 at at IN 42759 409 44 the the DT 42759 409 45 disposal disposal NN 42759 409 46 of of IN 42759 409 47 all all PDT 42759 409 48 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 409 49 children child NNS 42759 409 50 indiscriminately indiscriminately RB 42759 409 51 . . . 42759 410 1 But but CC 42759 410 2 this this DT 42759 410 3 is be VBZ 42759 410 4 a a DT 42759 410 5 general general JJ 42759 410 6 and and CC 42759 410 7 abstract abstract JJ 42759 410 8 right right NN 42759 410 9 . . . 42759 411 1 What what WP 42759 411 2 does do VBZ 42759 411 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 411 4 imply imply VB 42759 411 5 specifically specifically RB 42759 411 6 and and CC 42759 411 7 in in IN 42759 411 8 the the DT 42759 411 9 concrete concrete NN 42759 411 10 ? ? . 42759 412 1 In in IN 42759 412 2 the the DT 42759 412 3 first first JJ 42759 412 4 place place NN 42759 412 5 , , , 42759 412 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 412 7 includes include VBZ 42759 412 8 the the DT 42759 412 9 actual actual JJ 42759 412 10 and and CC 42759 412 11 continuous continuous JJ 42759 412 12 use use NN 42759 412 13 of of IN 42759 412 14 some some DT 42759 412 15 land land NN 42759 412 16 ; ; : 42759 412 17 for for IN 42759 412 18 a a DT 42759 412 19 man man NN 42759 412 20 can can MD 42759 412 21 not not RB 42759 412 22 support support VB 42759 412 23 life life NN 42759 412 24 unless unless IN 42759 412 25 he -PRON- PRP 42759 412 26 is be VBZ 42759 412 27 permitted permit VBN 42759 412 28 to to TO 42759 412 29 occupy occupy VB 42759 412 30 some some DT 42759 412 31 portion portion NN 42759 412 32 of of IN 42759 412 33 the the DT 42759 412 34 earth earth NN 42759 412 35 for for IN 42759 412 36 the the DT 42759 412 37 purposes purpose NNS 42759 412 38 of of IN 42759 412 39 working working NN 42759 412 40 , , , 42759 412 41 and and CC 42759 412 42 eating eat VBG 42759 412 43 , , , 42759 412 44 and and CC 42759 412 45 sleeping sleep VBG 42759 412 46 . . . 42759 413 1 Secondly secondly RB 42759 413 2 , , , 42759 413 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 413 4 means mean VBZ 42759 413 5 that that IN 42759 413 6 in in IN 42759 413 7 time time NN 42759 413 8 of of IN 42759 413 9 extreme extreme JJ 42759 413 10 need need NN 42759 413 11 , , , 42759 413 12 and and CC 42759 413 13 when when WRB 42759 413 14 more more RBR 42759 413 15 orderly orderly JJ 42759 413 16 methods method NNS 42759 413 17 are be VBP 42759 413 18 not not RB 42759 413 19 available available JJ 42759 413 20 , , , 42759 413 21 a a DT 42759 413 22 man man NN 42759 413 23 has have VBZ 42759 413 24 the the DT 42759 413 25 right right NN 42759 413 26 to to TO 42759 413 27 seize seize VB 42759 413 28 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 413 29 goods good NNS 42759 413 30 , , , 42759 413 31 natural natural JJ 42759 413 32 or or CC 42759 413 33 produced produce VBN 42759 413 34 , , , 42759 413 35 public public JJ 42759 413 36 or or CC 42759 413 37 private private JJ 42759 413 38 , , , 42759 413 39 to to TO 42759 413 40 support support VB 42759 413 41 life life NN 42759 413 42 . . . 42759 414 1 So so RB 42759 414 2 much much JJ 42759 414 3 is be VBZ 42759 414 4 admitted admit VBN 42759 414 5 and and CC 42759 414 6 taught teach VBN 42759 414 7 by by IN 42759 414 8 all all DT 42759 414 9 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 414 10 authorities authority NNS 42759 414 11 , , , 42759 414 12 and and CC 42759 414 13 probably probably RB 42759 414 14 by by IN 42759 414 15 all all DT 42759 414 16 other other JJ 42759 414 17 authorities authority NNS 42759 414 18 . . . 42759 415 1 Furthermore furthermore RB 42759 415 2 , , , 42759 415 3 the the DT 42759 415 4 abstract abstract JJ 42759 415 5 right right NN 42759 415 6 in in IN 42759 415 7 question question NN 42759 415 8 seems seem VBZ 42759 415 9 very very RB 42759 415 10 clearly clearly RB 42759 415 11 to to TO 42759 415 12 include include VB 42759 415 13 the the DT 42759 415 14 concrete concrete JJ 42759 415 15 right right NN 42759 415 16 to to TO 42759 415 17 obtain obtain VB 42759 415 18 on on IN 42759 415 19 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 415 20 conditions condition NNS 42759 415 21 at at IN 42759 415 22 least least JJS 42759 415 23 the the DT 42759 415 24 requisites requisite NNS 42759 415 25 of of IN 42759 415 26 a a DT 42759 415 27 decent decent JJ 42759 415 28 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 415 29 ; ; : 42759 415 30 for for IN 42759 415 31 example example NN 42759 415 32 , , , 42759 415 33 by by IN 42759 415 34 direct direct JJ 42759 415 35 access access NN 42759 415 36 to to IN 42759 415 37 a a DT 42759 415 38 piece piece NN 42759 415 39 of of IN 42759 415 40 land land NN 42759 415 41 , , , 42759 415 42 or or CC 42759 415 43 in in IN 42759 415 44 return return NN 42759 415 45 for for IN 42759 415 46 a a DT 42759 415 47 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 415 48 amount amount NN 42759 415 49 of of IN 42759 415 50 useful useful JJ 42759 415 51 labour labour NN 42759 415 52 . . . 42759 416 1 All all DT 42759 416 2 of of IN 42759 416 3 these these DT 42759 416 4 particular particular JJ 42759 416 5 rights right NNS 42759 416 6 are be VBP 42759 416 7 equally equally RB 42759 416 8 valid valid JJ 42759 416 9 in in IN 42759 416 10 all all DT 42759 416 11 persons person NNS 42759 416 12 . . . 42759 417 1 Does do VBZ 42759 417 2 the the DT 42759 417 3 equal equal JJ 42759 417 4 right right NN 42759 417 5 to to TO 42759 417 6 use use VB 42759 417 7 the the DT 42759 417 8 bounty bounty NN 42759 417 9 of of IN 42759 417 10 nature nature NN 42759 417 11 include include VBP 42759 417 12 the the DT 42759 417 13 right right NN 42759 417 14 to to TO 42759 417 15 equal equal VB 42759 417 16 _ _ NNP 42759 417 17 shares share NNS 42759 417 18 _ _ NNP 42759 417 19 of of IN 42759 417 20 land land NN 42759 417 21 , , , 42759 417 22 or or CC 42759 417 23 land land NN 42759 417 24 values value NNS 42759 417 25 , , , 42759 417 26 or or CC 42759 417 27 land land NN 42759 417 28 advantages advantage NNS 42759 417 29 ? ? . 42759 418 1 Since since IN 42759 418 2 the the DT 42759 418 3 resources resource NNS 42759 418 4 of of IN 42759 418 5 nature nature NN 42759 418 6 have have VBP 42759 418 7 been be VBN 42759 418 8 given give VBN 42759 418 9 to to IN 42759 418 10 all all DT 42759 418 11 men man NNS 42759 418 12 in in IN 42759 418 13 general general JJ 42759 418 14 , , , 42759 418 15 and and CC 42759 418 16 since since IN 42759 418 17 human human JJ 42759 418 18 nature nature NN 42759 418 19 is be VBZ 42759 418 20 specifically specifically RB 42759 418 21 and and CC 42759 418 22 juridically juridically RB 42759 418 23 equal equal JJ 42759 418 24 in in IN 42759 418 25 all all DT 42759 418 26 , , , 42759 418 27 have have VBP 42759 418 28 not not RB 42759 418 29 all all DT 42759 418 30 persons person NNS 42759 418 31 the the DT 42759 418 32 right right NN 42759 418 33 to to TO 42759 418 34 share share VB 42759 418 35 equally equally RB 42759 418 36 in in IN 42759 418 37 these these DT 42759 418 38 resources resource NNS 42759 418 39 ? ? . 42759 419 1 Suppose suppose VB 42759 419 2 that that IN 42759 419 3 some some DT 42759 419 4 philanthropist philanthropist NN 42759 419 5 hands hand NNS 42759 419 6 over over RP 42759 419 7 to to IN 42759 419 8 one one CD 42759 419 9 hundred hundred CD 42759 419 10 persons person NNS 42759 419 11 an an DT 42759 419 12 uninhabited uninhabited JJ 42759 419 13 island island NN 42759 419 14 , , , 42759 419 15 on on IN 42759 419 16 condition condition NN 42759 419 17 that that IN 42759 419 18 they -PRON- PRP 42759 419 19 shall shall MD 42759 419 20 divide divide VB 42759 419 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 419 22 among among IN 42759 419 23 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 419 24 with with IN 42759 419 25 absolute absolute JJ 42759 419 26 justice justice NN 42759 419 27 . . . 42759 420 1 Are be VBP 42759 420 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 420 3 not not RB 42759 420 4 obliged oblige VBN 42759 420 5 to to TO 42759 420 6 divide divide VB 42759 420 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 420 8 equally equally RB 42759 420 9 ? ? . 42759 421 1 On on IN 42759 421 2 what what WDT 42759 421 3 ground ground NN 42759 421 4 can can MD 42759 421 5 any any DT 42759 421 6 person person NN 42759 421 7 claim claim NN 42759 421 8 or or CC 42759 421 9 be be VB 42759 421 10 awarded award VBN 42759 421 11 a a DT 42759 421 12 larger large JJR 42759 421 13 share share NN 42759 421 14 than than IN 42759 421 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 421 16 fellows fellow NNS 42759 421 17 ? ? . 42759 422 1 None none NN 42759 422 2 is be VBZ 42759 422 3 of of IN 42759 422 4 greater great JJR 42759 422 5 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 422 6 worth worth NN 42759 422 7 than than IN 42759 422 8 another another DT 42759 422 9 , , , 42759 422 10 nor nor CC 42759 422 11 has have VBZ 42759 422 12 any any DT 42759 422 13 one one CD 42759 422 14 made make VBN 42759 422 15 efforts effort NNS 42759 422 16 , , , 42759 422 17 or or CC 42759 422 18 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 422 19 , , , 42759 422 20 or or CC 42759 422 21 products product NNS 42759 422 22 which which WDT 42759 422 23 will will MD 42759 422 24 entitle entitle VB 42759 422 25 him -PRON- PRP 42759 422 26 to to IN 42759 422 27 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 422 28 treatment treatment NN 42759 422 29 . . . 42759 423 1 The the DT 42759 423 2 correct correct JJ 42759 423 3 principle principle NN 42759 423 4 of of IN 42759 423 5 distribution distribution NN 42759 423 6 would would MD 42759 423 7 seem seem VB 42759 423 8 to to TO 42759 423 9 be be VB 42759 423 10 absolute absolute JJ 42759 423 11 equality equality NN 42759 423 12 , , , 42759 423 13 except except IN 42759 423 14 in in IN 42759 423 15 so so RB 42759 423 16 far far RB 42759 423 17 as as IN 42759 423 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 423 19 may may MD 42759 423 20 be be VB 42759 423 21 modified modify VBN 42759 423 22 on on IN 42759 423 23 account account NN 42759 423 24 of of IN 42759 423 25 varying varying NN 42759 423 26 needs need NNS 42759 423 27 , , , 42759 423 28 and and CC 42759 423 29 varying vary VBG 42759 423 30 capacities capacity NNS 42759 423 31 for for IN 42759 423 32 social social JJ 42759 423 33 service service NN 42759 423 34 . . . 42759 424 1 In in IN 42759 424 2 any any DT 42759 424 3 just just JJ 42759 424 4 distribution distribution NN 42759 424 5 account account NN 42759 424 6 must must MD 42759 424 7 be be VB 42759 424 8 taken take VBN 42759 424 9 of of IN 42759 424 10 differences difference NNS 42759 424 11 in in IN 42759 424 12 needs need NNS 42759 424 13 and and CC 42759 424 14 capacities capacity NNS 42759 424 15 ; ; : 42759 424 16 for for IN 42759 424 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 424 18 is be VBZ 42759 424 19 not not RB 42759 424 20 just just RB 42759 424 21 to to TO 42759 424 22 treat treat VB 42759 424 23 men man NNS 42759 424 24 as as IN 42759 424 25 equal equal JJ 42759 424 26 in in IN 42759 424 27 those those DT 42759 424 28 respects respect NNS 42759 424 29 in in IN 42759 424 30 which which WDT 42759 424 31 they -PRON- PRP 42759 424 32 are be VBP 42759 424 33 unequal unequal JJ 42759 424 34 , , , 42759 424 35 nor nor CC 42759 424 36 is be VBZ 42759 424 37 it -PRON- PRP 42759 424 38 fair fair JJ 42759 424 39 to to TO 42759 424 40 deprive deprive VB 42759 424 41 the the DT 42759 424 42 community community NN 42759 424 43 of of IN 42759 424 44 those those DT 42759 424 45 social social JJ 42759 424 46 benefits benefit NNS 42759 424 47 which which WDT 42759 424 48 can can MD 42759 424 49 be be VB 42759 424 50 obtained obtain VBN 42759 424 51 only only RB 42759 424 52 by by IN 42759 424 53 giving give VBG 42759 424 54 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 424 55 rewards reward NNS 42759 424 56 for for IN 42759 424 57 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 424 58 services service NNS 42759 424 59 . . . 42759 425 1 The the DT 42759 425 2 same same JJ 42759 425 3 amount amount NN 42759 425 4 of of IN 42759 425 5 food food NN 42759 425 6 allotted allot VBN 42759 425 7 to to IN 42759 425 8 two two CD 42759 425 9 persons person NNS 42759 425 10 might may MD 42759 425 11 leave leave VB 42759 425 12 one one CD 42759 425 13 hungry hungry JJ 42759 425 14 and and CC 42759 425 15 the the DT 42759 425 16 other other JJ 42759 425 17 sated sate VBD 42759 425 18 ; ; : 42759 425 19 the the DT 42759 425 20 same same JJ 42759 425 21 amount amount NN 42759 425 22 of of IN 42759 425 23 land land NN 42759 425 24 assigned assign VBN 42759 425 25 to to IN 42759 425 26 two two CD 42759 425 27 persons person NNS 42759 425 28 might may MD 42759 425 29 tempt tempt VB 42759 425 30 the the DT 42759 425 31 one one NN 42759 425 32 to to TO 42759 425 33 wastefulness wastefulness VB 42759 425 34 and and CC 42759 425 35 discourage discourage VB 42759 425 36 the the DT 42759 425 37 other other JJ 42759 425 38 . . . 42759 426 1 To to TO 42759 426 2 be be VB 42759 426 3 sure sure JJ 42759 426 4 , , , 42759 426 5 the the DT 42759 426 6 factor factor NN 42759 426 7 of of IN 42759 426 8 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 426 9 capacity capacity NN 42759 426 10 should should MD 42759 426 11 not not RB 42759 426 12 figure figure VB 42759 426 13 in in IN 42759 426 14 the the DT 42759 426 15 distribution distribution NN 42759 426 16 until until IN 42759 426 17 all all DT 42759 426 18 persons person NNS 42759 426 19 had have VBD 42759 426 20 received receive VBN 42759 426 21 that that DT 42759 426 22 measure measure NN 42759 426 23 of of IN 42759 426 24 natural natural JJ 42759 426 25 goods good NNS 42759 426 26 which which WDT 42759 426 27 was be VBD 42759 426 28 in in IN 42759 426 29 each each DT 42759 426 30 case case NN 42759 426 31 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 426 32 for for IN 42759 426 33 a a DT 42759 426 34 decent decent JJ 42759 426 35 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 426 36 . . . 42759 427 1 For for IN 42759 427 2 the the DT 42759 427 3 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 427 4 justification justification NN 42759 427 5 of of IN 42759 427 6 any any DT 42759 427 7 distribution distribution NN 42759 427 8 is be VBZ 42759 427 9 to to TO 42759 427 10 be be VB 42759 427 11 sought seek VBN 42759 427 12 in in IN 42759 427 13 human human JJ 42759 427 14 needs need NNS 42759 427 15 ; ; : 42759 427 16 and and CC 42759 427 17 among among IN 42759 427 18 human human JJ 42759 427 19 needs need NNS 42759 427 20 the the DT 42759 427 21 most most RBS 42759 427 22 deserving deserving JJ 42759 427 23 and and CC 42759 427 24 the the DT 42759 427 25 most most RBS 42759 427 26 urgent urgent JJ 42759 427 27 are be VBP 42759 427 28 those those DT 42759 427 29 which which WDT 42759 427 30 must must MD 42759 427 31 be be VB 42759 427 32 satisfied satisfied JJ 42759 427 33 as as IN 42759 427 34 a a DT 42759 427 35 prerequisite prerequisite NN 42759 427 36 to to IN 42759 427 37 right right JJ 42759 427 38 and and CC 42759 427 39 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 427 40 life life NN 42759 427 41 . . . 42759 428 1 Now now RB 42759 428 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 428 3 is be VBZ 42759 428 4 true true JJ 42759 428 5 that that IN 42759 428 6 private private JJ 42759 428 7 ownership ownership NN 42759 428 8 of of IN 42759 428 9 land land NN 42759 428 10 has have VBZ 42759 428 11 nowhere nowhere RB 42759 428 12 realised realise VBN 42759 428 13 this this DT 42759 428 14 principle principle NN 42759 428 15 of of IN 42759 428 16 proportional proportional JJ 42759 428 17 equality equality NN 42759 428 18 and and CC 42759 428 19 proportional proportional JJ 42759 428 20 justice justice NN 42759 428 21 . . . 42759 429 1 No no DT 42759 429 2 such such JJ 42759 429 3 result result NN 42759 429 4 is be VBZ 42759 429 5 possible possible JJ 42759 429 6 in in IN 42759 429 7 a a DT 42759 429 8 system system NN 42759 429 9 that that WDT 42759 429 10 , , , 42759 429 11 in in IN 42759 429 12 addition addition NN 42759 429 13 to to IN 42759 429 14 other other JJ 42759 429 15 difficulties difficulty NNS 42759 429 16 , , , 42759 429 17 would would MD 42759 429 18 be be VB 42759 429 19 required require VBN 42759 429 20 to to TO 42759 429 21 make make VB 42759 429 22 a a DT 42759 429 23 new new JJ 42759 429 24 distribution distribution NN 42759 429 25 at at IN 42759 429 26 every every DT 42759 429 27 birth birth NN 42759 429 28 and and CC 42759 429 29 at at IN 42759 429 30 every every DT 42759 429 31 death death NN 42759 429 32 . . . 42759 430 1 Private private JJ 42759 430 2 ownership ownership NN 42759 430 3 of of IN 42759 430 4 land land NN 42759 430 5 can can MD 42759 430 6 never never RB 42759 430 7 bring bring VB 42759 430 8 about about RP 42759 430 9 ideal ideal JJ 42759 430 10 justice justice NN 42759 430 11 in in IN 42759 430 12 distribution distribution NN 42759 430 13 . . . 42759 431 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 431 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 431 3 is be VBZ 42759 431 4 not not RB 42759 431 5 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 431 6 out out IN 42759 431 7 of of IN 42759 431 8 harmony harmony NN 42759 431 9 with with IN 42759 431 10 the the DT 42759 431 11 demands demand NNS 42759 431 12 of of IN 42759 431 13 _ _ NNP 42759 431 14 practical practical JJ 42759 431 15 _ _ NNP 42759 431 16 justice justice NN 42759 431 17 . . . 42759 432 1 A a DT 42759 432 2 community community NN 42759 432 3 that that WDT 42759 432 4 lacks lack VBZ 42759 432 5 either either CC 42759 432 6 the the DT 42759 432 7 knowledge knowledge NN 42759 432 8 or or CC 42759 432 9 the the DT 42759 432 10 power power NN 42759 432 11 to to TO 42759 432 12 establish establish VB 42759 432 13 the the DT 42759 432 14 ideal ideal JJ 42759 432 15 system system NN 42759 432 16 is be VBZ 42759 432 17 not not RB 42759 432 18 guilty guilty JJ 42759 432 19 of of IN 42759 432 20 actual actual JJ 42759 432 21 injustice injustice NN 42759 432 22 because because IN 42759 432 23 of of IN 42759 432 24 this this DT 42759 432 25 failure failure NN 42759 432 26 . . . 42759 433 1 In in IN 42759 433 2 such such PDT 42759 433 3 a a DT 42759 433 4 situation situation NN 42759 433 5 the the DT 42759 433 6 proportionally proportionally RB 42759 433 7 equal equal JJ 42759 433 8 rights right NNS 42759 433 9 of of IN 42759 433 10 all all DT 42759 433 11 men man NNS 42759 433 12 to to IN 42759 433 13 the the DT 42759 433 14 bounty bounty NN 42759 433 15 of of IN 42759 433 16 nature nature NN 42759 433 17 are be VBP 42759 433 18 not not RB 42759 433 19 actual actual JJ 42759 433 20 rights right NNS 42759 433 21 . . . 42759 434 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 434 2 are be VBP 42759 434 3 conditional conditional JJ 42759 434 4 , , , 42759 434 5 or or CC 42759 434 6 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 42759 434 7 , , , 42759 434 8 or or CC 42759 434 9 suspended suspend VBN 42759 434 10 . . . 42759 435 1 At at IN 42759 435 2 best good JJS 42759 435 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 435 4 have have VBP 42759 435 5 no no DT 42759 435 6 more more RBR 42759 435 7 moral moral JJ 42759 435 8 validity validity NN 42759 435 9 than than IN 42759 435 10 the the DT 42759 435 11 right right NN 42759 435 12 of of IN 42759 435 13 a a DT 42759 435 14 creditor creditor NN 42759 435 15 to to IN 42759 435 16 a a DT 42759 435 17 loan loan NN 42759 435 18 that that WDT 42759 435 19 , , , 42759 435 20 owing owe VBG 42759 435 21 to to IN 42759 435 22 the the DT 42759 435 23 untimely untimely JJ 42759 435 24 death death NN 42759 435 25 of of IN 42759 435 26 the the DT 42759 435 27 debtor debtor NN 42759 435 28 , , , 42759 435 29 he -PRON- PRP 42759 435 30 can can MD 42759 435 31 never never RB 42759 435 32 recover recover VB 42759 435 33 . . . 42759 436 1 In in IN 42759 436 2 both both DT 42759 436 3 cases case NNS 42759 436 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 436 5 is be VBZ 42759 436 6 misleading mislead VBG 42759 436 7 to to TO 42759 436 8 talk talk VB 42759 436 9 of of IN 42759 436 10 injustice injustice NN 42759 436 11 ; ; : 42759 436 12 for for IN 42759 436 13 this this DT 42759 436 14 term term NN 42759 436 15 always always RB 42759 436 16 implies imply VBZ 42759 436 17 that that IN 42759 436 18 some some DT 42759 436 19 person person NN 42759 436 20 or or CC 42759 436 21 community community NN 42759 436 22 is be VBZ 42759 436 23 guilty guilty JJ 42759 436 24 of of IN 42759 436 25 some some DT 42759 436 26 action action NN 42759 436 27 which which WDT 42759 436 28 could could MD 42759 436 29 have have VB 42759 436 30 been be VBN 42759 436 31 avoided avoid VBN 42759 436 32 . . . 42759 437 1 The the DT 42759 437 2 system system NN 42759 437 3 of of IN 42759 437 4 private private JJ 42759 437 5 landownership landownership NN 42759 437 6 is be VBZ 42759 437 7 not not RB 42759 437 8 , , , 42759 437 9 indeed indeed RB 42759 437 10 , , , 42759 437 11 perfect perfect JJ 42759 437 12 ; ; : 42759 437 13 but but CC 42759 437 14 this this DT 42759 437 15 is be VBZ 42759 437 16 not not RB 42759 437 17 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 437 18 in in IN 42759 437 19 a a DT 42759 437 20 world world NN 42759 437 21 where where WRB 42759 437 22 the the DT 42759 437 23 ideal ideal NN 42759 437 24 is be VBZ 42759 437 25 never never RB 42759 437 26 attained attain VBN 42759 437 27 , , , 42759 437 28 and and CC 42759 437 29 all all DT 42759 437 30 things thing NNS 42759 437 31 are be VBP 42759 437 32 imperfect imperfect JJ 42759 437 33 . . . 42759 438 1 Henry Henry NNP 42759 438 2 George George NNP 42759 438 3 declares declare VBZ 42759 438 4 that that IN 42759 438 5 " " `` 42759 438 6 there there EX 42759 438 7 is be VBZ 42759 438 8 on on IN 42759 438 9 earth earth NN 42759 438 10 no no DT 42759 438 11 power power NN 42759 438 12 which which WDT 42759 438 13 can can MD 42759 438 14 rightfully rightfully RB 42759 438 15 make make VB 42759 438 16 a a DT 42759 438 17 grant grant NN 42759 438 18 of of IN 42759 438 19 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 438 20 ownership ownership NN 42759 438 21 in in IN 42759 438 22 land land NN 42759 438 23 " " '' 42759 438 24 ; ; : 42759 438 25 but but CC 42759 438 26 what what WP 42759 438 27 would would MD 42759 438 28 he -PRON- PRP 42759 438 29 have have VB 42759 438 30 a a DT 42759 438 31 community community NN 42759 438 32 do do VB 42759 438 33 which which WDT 42759 438 34 has have VBZ 42759 438 35 never never RB 42759 438 36 heard hear VBN 42759 438 37 of of IN 42759 438 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 438 39 system system NN 42759 438 40 ? ? . 42759 439 1 Introduce introduce VB 42759 439 2 some some DT 42759 439 3 crude crude JJ 42759 439 4 form form NN 42759 439 5 of of IN 42759 439 6 communism communism NN 42759 439 7 , , , 42759 439 8 or or CC 42759 439 9 refrain refrain VB 42759 439 10 from from IN 42759 439 11 using use VBG 42759 439 12 the the DT 42759 439 13 land land NN 42759 439 14 at at RB 42759 439 15 all all RB 42759 439 16 , , , 42759 439 17 and and CC 42759 439 18 permit permit VB 42759 439 19 the the DT 42759 439 20 people people NNS 42759 439 21 to to TO 42759 439 22 starve starve VB 42759 439 23 to to IN 42759 439 24 death death NN 42759 439 25 in in IN 42759 439 26 the the DT 42759 439 27 interests interest NNS 42759 439 28 of of IN 42759 439 29 ideal ideal JJ 42759 439 30 justice justice NN 42759 439 31 ? ? . 42759 440 1 Evidently evidently RB 42759 440 2 such such PDT 42759 440 3 a a DT 42759 440 4 community community NN 42759 440 5 must must MD 42759 440 6 make make VB 42759 440 7 grants grant NNS 42759 440 8 of of IN 42759 440 9 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 440 10 ownership ownership NN 42759 440 11 , , , 42759 440 12 and and CC 42759 440 13 these these DT 42759 440 14 will will MD 42759 440 15 be be VB 42759 440 16 as as RB 42759 440 17 valid valid JJ 42759 440 18 in in IN 42759 440 19 reason reason NN 42759 440 20 and and CC 42759 440 21 in in IN 42759 440 22 morals moral NNS 42759 440 23 as as IN 42759 440 24 any any DT 42759 440 25 other other JJ 42759 440 26 act act NN 42759 440 27 that that WDT 42759 440 28 is be VBZ 42759 440 29 subject subject JJ 42759 440 30 to to IN 42759 440 31 human human JJ 42759 440 32 limitations limitation NNS 42759 440 33 which which WDT 42759 440 34 are be VBP 42759 440 35 at at IN 42759 440 36 the the DT 42759 440 37 time time NN 42759 440 38 irremovable irremovable JJ 42759 440 39 . . . 42759 441 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 42759 441 2 the the DT 42759 441 3 Single Single NNP 42759 441 4 Taxer Taxer NNP 42759 441 5 would would MD 42759 441 6 admit admit VB 42759 441 7 the the DT 42759 441 8 force force NN 42759 441 9 of of IN 42759 441 10 the the DT 42759 441 11 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 441 12 argument argument NN 42759 441 13 . . . 42759 442 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 442 2 might may MD 42759 442 3 insist insist VB 42759 442 4 that that IN 42759 442 5 the the DT 42759 442 6 titles title NNS 42759 442 7 given give VBN 42759 442 8 by by IN 42759 442 9 the the DT 42759 442 10 State State NNP 42759 442 11 in in IN 42759 442 12 such such JJ 42759 442 13 conditions condition NNS 42759 442 14 were be VBD 42759 442 15 not not RB 42759 442 16 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 442 17 grants grant NNS 42759 442 18 in in IN 42759 442 19 the the DT 42759 442 20 strict strict JJ 42759 442 21 sense sense NN 42759 442 22 , , , 42759 442 23 but but CC 42759 442 24 were be VBD 42759 442 25 valid valid JJ 42759 442 26 only only RB 42759 442 27 until until IN 42759 442 28 a a DT 42759 442 29 better well JJR 42759 442 30 system system NN 42759 442 31 could could MD 42759 442 32 be be VB 42759 442 33 set set VBN 42759 442 34 up up RP 42759 442 35 , , , 42759 442 36 and and CC 42759 442 37 the the DT 42759 442 38 people people NNS 42759 442 39 put put VBP 42759 442 40 in in IN 42759 442 41 possession possession NN 42759 442 42 of of IN 42759 442 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 442 44 natural natural JJ 42759 442 45 heritage heritage NN 42759 442 46 . . . 42759 443 1 Let let VB 42759 443 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 443 3 suppose suppose VB 42759 443 4 , , , 42759 443 5 then then RB 42759 443 6 , , , 42759 443 7 that that IN 42759 443 8 a a DT 42759 443 9 nation nation NN 42759 443 10 were be VBD 42759 443 11 shown show VBN 42759 443 12 " " `` 42759 443 13 a a DT 42759 443 14 more more RBR 42759 443 15 excellent excellent JJ 42759 443 16 way way NN 42759 443 17 . . . 42759 443 18 " " '' 42759 444 1 Suppose suppose VB 42759 444 2 that that IN 42759 444 3 the the DT 42759 444 4 people people NNS 42759 444 5 of of IN 42759 444 6 the the DT 42759 444 7 United United NNP 42759 444 8 States States NNP 42759 444 9 set set VBD 42759 444 10 about about RP 42759 444 11 to to TO 42759 444 12 establish establish VB 42759 444 13 Henry Henry NNP 42759 444 14 George George NNP 42759 444 15 's 's POS 42759 444 16 system system NN 42759 444 17 in in IN 42759 444 18 the the DT 42759 444 19 way way NN 42759 444 20 that that WDT 42759 444 21 he -PRON- PRP 42759 444 22 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 444 23 advocated advocate VBD 42759 444 24 . . . 42759 445 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 445 2 would would MD 42759 445 3 forthwith forthwith VB 42759 445 4 impose impose VB 42759 445 5 upon upon IN 42759 445 6 all all DT 42759 445 7 land land NN 42759 445 8 an an DT 42759 445 9 annual annual JJ 42759 445 10 tax tax NN 42759 445 11 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 445 12 to to IN 42759 445 13 the the DT 42759 445 14 annual annual JJ 42759 445 15 rent rent NN 42759 445 16 . . . 42759 446 1 What what WP 42759 446 2 would would MD 42759 446 3 be be VB 42759 446 4 the the DT 42759 446 5 effect effect NN 42759 446 6 upon upon IN 42759 446 7 private private JJ 42759 446 8 land land NN 42759 446 9 - - HYPH 42759 446 10 incomes income NNS 42759 446 11 , , , 42759 446 12 and and CC 42759 446 13 private private JJ 42759 446 14 land land NN 42759 446 15 - - HYPH 42759 446 16 wealth wealth NN 42759 446 17 ? ? . 42759 447 1 Since since IN 42759 447 2 the the DT 42759 447 3 first first JJ 42759 447 4 would would MD 42759 447 5 be be VB 42759 447 6 handed hand VBN 42759 447 7 over over RP 42759 447 8 to to IN 42759 447 9 the the DT 42759 447 10 State State NNP 42759 447 11 in in IN 42759 447 12 the the DT 42759 447 13 form form NN 42759 447 14 of of IN 42759 447 15 a a DT 42759 447 16 tax tax NN 42759 447 17 , , , 42759 447 18 the the DT 42759 447 19 second second JJ 42759 447 20 would would MD 42759 447 21 utterly utterly RB 42759 447 22 disappear disappear VB 42759 447 23 . . . 42759 448 1 For for IN 42759 448 2 the the DT 42759 448 3 value value NN 42759 448 4 of of IN 42759 448 5 land land NN 42759 448 6 , , , 42759 448 7 like like IN 42759 448 8 the the DT 42759 448 9 value value NN 42759 448 10 of of IN 42759 448 11 any any DT 42759 448 12 other other JJ 42759 448 13 economic economic JJ 42759 448 14 good good NN 42759 448 15 , , , 42759 448 16 depends depend VBZ 42759 448 17 upon upon IN 42759 448 18 the the DT 42759 448 19 utilities utility NNS 42759 448 20 that that WDT 42759 448 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 448 22 embodies embody VBZ 42759 448 23 or or CC 42759 448 24 produces produce VBZ 42759 448 25 . . . 42759 449 1 Whoever whoever WP 42759 449 2 controls control VBZ 42759 449 3 these these DT 42759 449 4 will will MD 42759 449 5 control control VB 42759 449 6 the the DT 42759 449 7 market market NN 42759 449 8 value value NN 42759 449 9 of of IN 42759 449 10 the the DT 42759 449 11 land land NN 42759 449 12 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 449 13 . . . 42759 450 1 No no DT 42759 450 2 man man NN 42759 450 3 will will MD 42759 450 4 pay pay VB 42759 450 5 anything anything NN 42759 450 6 for for IN 42759 450 7 a a DT 42759 450 8 revenue revenue NN 42759 450 9 - - HYPH 42759 450 10 producing produce VBG 42759 450 11 property property NN 42759 450 12 if if IN 42759 450 13 some some DT 42759 450 14 one one NN 42759 450 15 else else RB 42759 450 16 , , , 42759 450 17 for for IN 42759 450 18 example example NN 42759 450 19 , , , 42759 450 20 the the DT 42759 450 21 State State NNP 42759 450 22 , , , 42759 450 23 is be VBZ 42759 450 24 forever forever RB 42759 450 25 to to TO 42759 450 26 take take VB 42759 450 27 the the DT 42759 450 28 revenue revenue NN 42759 450 29 . . . 42759 451 1 The the DT 42759 451 2 owner owner NN 42759 451 3 of of IN 42759 451 4 a a DT 42759 451 5 piece piece NN 42759 451 6 of of IN 42759 451 7 land land NN 42759 451 8 which which WDT 42759 451 9 brings bring VBZ 42759 451 10 him -PRON- PRP 42759 451 11 an an DT 42759 451 12 annual annual JJ 42759 451 13 revenue revenue NN 42759 451 14 or or CC 42759 451 15 rent rent NN 42759 451 16 of of IN 42759 451 17 one one CD 42759 451 18 hundred hundred CD 42759 451 19 dollars dollar NNS 42759 451 20 , , , 42759 451 21 will will MD 42759 451 22 not not RB 42759 451 23 find find VB 42759 451 24 a a DT 42759 451 25 purchaser purchaser NN 42759 451 26 for for IN 42759 451 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 451 28 if if IN 42759 451 29 the the DT 42759 451 30 State State NNP 42759 451 31 appropriates appropriate VBZ 42759 451 32 the the DT 42759 451 33 one one CD 42759 451 34 hundred hundred CD 42759 451 35 dollars dollar NNS 42759 451 36 in in IN 42759 451 37 the the DT 42759 451 38 form form NN 42759 451 39 of of IN 42759 451 40 a a DT 42759 451 41 tax tax NN 42759 451 42 that that WDT 42759 451 43 is be VBZ 42759 451 44 to to TO 42759 451 45 be be VB 42759 451 46 levied levy VBN 42759 451 47 year year NN 42759 451 48 after after IN 42759 451 49 year year NN 42759 451 50 for for IN 42759 451 51 all all DT 42759 451 52 time time NN 42759 451 53 . . . 42759 452 1 On on IN 42759 452 2 the the DT 42759 452 3 assumption assumption NN 42759 452 4 that that IN 42759 452 5 the the DT 42759 452 6 revenue revenue NN 42759 452 7 represents represent VBZ 42759 452 8 a a DT 42759 452 9 selling sell VBG 42759 452 10 value value NN 42759 452 11 of of IN 42759 452 12 two two CD 42759 452 13 thousand thousand CD 42759 452 14 dollars dollar NNS 42759 452 15 , , , 42759 452 16 the the DT 42759 452 17 private private JJ 42759 452 18 owner owner NN 42759 452 19 will will MD 42759 452 20 be be VB 42759 452 21 worth worth JJ 42759 452 22 that that IN 42759 452 23 much much RB 42759 452 24 less less JJR 42759 452 25 after after IN 42759 452 26 the the DT 42759 452 27 introduction introduction NN 42759 452 28 of of IN 42759 452 29 the the DT 42759 452 30 new new JJ 42759 452 31 system system NN 42759 452 32 . . . 42759 453 1 Henry Henry NNP 42759 453 2 George George NNP 42759 453 3 defends defend VBZ 42759 453 4 this this DT 42759 453 5 proceeding proceeding NN 42759 453 6 as as IN 42759 453 7 emphatically emphatically RB 42759 453 8 just just RB 42759 453 9 , , , 42759 453 10 and and CC 42759 453 11 denies deny VBZ 42759 453 12 the the DT 42759 453 13 justice justice NN 42759 453 14 of of IN 42759 453 15 compensating compensate VBG 42759 453 16 the the DT 42759 453 17 private private JJ 42759 453 18 owners owner NNS 42759 453 19 . . . 42759 454 1 In in IN 42759 454 2 the the DT 42759 454 3 chapter chapter NN 42759 454 4 of of IN 42759 454 5 " " `` 42759 454 6 Progress Progress NNP 42759 454 7 and and CC 42759 454 8 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 454 9 " " '' 42759 454 10 headed head VBD 42759 454 11 , , , 42759 454 12 " " '' 42759 454 13 Claim Claim NNP 42759 454 14 of of IN 42759 454 15 Land Land NNP 42759 454 16 Owners Owners NNP 42759 454 17 to to IN 42759 454 18 Compensation Compensation NNP 42759 454 19 , , , 42759 454 20 " " '' 42759 454 21 he -PRON- PRP 42759 454 22 declares declare VBZ 42759 454 23 that that IN 42759 454 24 " " `` 42759 454 25 private private JJ 42759 454 26 property property NN 42759 454 27 in in IN 42759 454 28 land land NN 42759 454 29 is be VBZ 42759 454 30 a a DT 42759 454 31 bold bold JJ 42759 454 32 , , , 42759 454 33 bare bare JJ 42759 454 34 , , , 42759 454 35 enormous enormous JJ 42759 454 36 wrong wrong NN 42759 454 37 , , , 42759 454 38 like like IN 42759 454 39 that that DT 42759 454 40 of of IN 42759 454 41 chattel chattel NNP 42759 454 42 slavery slavery NNP 42759 454 43 " " '' 42759 454 44 ; ; : 42759 454 45 and and CC 42759 454 46 against against IN 42759 454 47 Mill Mill NNP 42759 454 48 's 's POS 42759 454 49 statement statement NN 42759 454 50 that that IN 42759 454 51 land land NN 42759 454 52 owners owner NNS 42759 454 53 have have VBP 42759 454 54 a a DT 42759 454 55 right right NN 42759 454 56 to to TO 42759 454 57 rent rent VB 42759 454 58 and and CC 42759 454 59 to to IN 42759 454 60 the the DT 42759 454 61 selling selling NN 42759 454 62 value value NN 42759 454 63 of of IN 42759 454 64 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 454 65 holdings holding NNS 42759 454 66 , , , 42759 454 67 he -PRON- PRP 42759 454 68 exclaims exclaim VBZ 42759 454 69 : : : 42759 454 70 " " `` 42759 454 71 If if IN 42759 454 72 the the DT 42759 454 73 land land NN 42759 454 74 of of IN 42759 454 75 any any DT 42759 454 76 country country NN 42759 454 77 belong belong VBP 42759 454 78 to to IN 42759 454 79 the the DT 42759 454 80 people people NNS 42759 454 81 of of IN 42759 454 82 that that DT 42759 454 83 country country NN 42759 454 84 , , , 42759 454 85 what what WDT 42759 454 86 right right UH 42759 454 87 , , , 42759 454 88 in in IN 42759 454 89 morality morality NN 42759 454 90 and and CC 42759 454 91 justice justice NN 42759 454 92 , , , 42759 454 93 have have VBP 42759 454 94 the the DT 42759 454 95 individuals individual NNS 42759 454 96 called call VBN 42759 454 97 land land NN 42759 454 98 owners owner NNS 42759 454 99 to to IN 42759 454 100 the the DT 42759 454 101 rent rent NN 42759 454 102 ? ? . 42759 455 1 If if IN 42759 455 2 the the DT 42759 455 3 land land NN 42759 455 4 belong belong VBP 42759 455 5 to to IN 42759 455 6 the the DT 42759 455 7 people people NNS 42759 455 8 , , , 42759 455 9 why why WRB 42759 455 10 in in IN 42759 455 11 the the DT 42759 455 12 name name NN 42759 455 13 of of IN 42759 455 14 morality morality NN 42759 455 15 and and CC 42759 455 16 justice justice NN 42759 455 17 should should MD 42759 455 18 the the DT 42759 455 19 people people NNS 42759 455 20 pay pay VB 42759 455 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 455 22 salable salable JJ 42759 455 23 value value NN 42759 455 24 for for IN 42759 455 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 455 26 own own JJ 42759 455 27 ? ? . 42759 456 1 " " `` 42759 456 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 456 3 23 23 CD 42759 456 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 456 5 Here here RB 42759 456 6 , , , 42759 456 7 then then RB 42759 456 8 , , , 42759 456 9 we -PRON- PRP 42759 456 10 have have VBP 42759 456 11 the the DT 42759 456 12 full full JJ 42759 456 13 implication implication NN 42759 456 14 of of IN 42759 456 15 the the DT 42759 456 16 Georgean georgean JJ 42759 456 17 principle principle NN 42759 456 18 that that IN 42759 456 19 private private JJ 42759 456 20 property property NN 42759 456 21 in in IN 42759 456 22 land land NN 42759 456 23 is be VBZ 42759 456 24 essentially essentially RB 42759 456 25 unjust unjust JJ 42759 456 26 . . . 42759 457 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 457 2 is be VBZ 42759 457 3 not not RB 42759 457 4 merely merely RB 42759 457 5 imperfect,--tolerable imperfect,--tolerable JJ 42759 457 6 while while IN 42759 457 7 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 42759 457 8 . . . 42759 458 1 When when WRB 42759 458 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 458 3 can can MD 42759 458 4 be be VB 42759 458 5 supplanted supplant VBN 42759 458 6 by by IN 42759 458 7 the the DT 42759 458 8 right right JJ 42759 458 9 system system NN 42759 458 10 , , , 42759 458 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 458 12 inequalities inequality NNS 42759 458 13 must must MD 42759 458 14 not not RB 42759 458 15 continue continue VB 42759 458 16 under under IN 42759 458 17 another another DT 42759 458 18 form form NN 42759 458 19 . . . 42759 459 1 If if IN 42759 459 2 inequalities inequality NNS 42759 459 3 are be VBP 42759 459 4 continued continue VBN 42759 459 5 through through IN 42759 459 6 the the DT 42759 459 7 compensation compensation NN 42759 459 8 of of IN 42759 459 9 private private JJ 42759 459 10 owners owner NNS 42759 459 11 , , , 42759 459 12 individuals individual NNS 42759 459 13 are be VBP 42759 459 14 still still RB 42759 459 15 hindered hinder VBN 42759 459 16 from from IN 42759 459 17 enjoying enjoy VBG 42759 459 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 459 19 equal equal JJ 42759 459 20 rights right NNS 42759 459 21 to to IN 42759 459 22 land land NN 42759 459 23 , , , 42759 459 24 and and CC 42759 459 25 the the DT 42759 459 26 State state NN 42759 459 27 becomes become VBZ 42759 459 28 guilty guilty JJ 42759 459 29 of of IN 42759 459 30 formal formal JJ 42759 459 31 and and CC 42759 459 32 culpable culpable JJ 42759 459 33 injustice injustice NN 42759 459 34 . . . 42759 460 1 The the DT 42759 460 2 titles title NNS 42759 460 3 which which WDT 42759 460 4 the the DT 42759 460 5 State State NNP 42759 460 6 formerly formerly RB 42759 460 7 guaranteed guarantee VBN 42759 460 8 to to IN 42759 460 9 the the DT 42759 460 10 private private JJ 42759 460 11 owners owner NNS 42759 460 12 did do VBD 42759 460 13 not not RB 42759 460 14 have have VB 42759 460 15 in in IN 42759 460 16 morals moral NNS 42759 460 17 the the DT 42759 460 18 perpetual perpetual JJ 42759 460 19 validity validity NN 42759 460 20 which which WDT 42759 460 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 460 22 professed profess VBD 42759 460 23 to to TO 42759 460 24 have have VB 42759 460 25 . . . 42759 461 1 Since since IN 42759 461 2 the the DT 42759 461 3 State State NNP 42759 461 4 is be VBZ 42759 461 5 not not RB 42759 461 6 the the DT 42759 461 7 owner owner NN 42759 461 8 of of IN 42759 461 9 the the DT 42759 461 10 land land NN 42759 461 11 , , , 42759 461 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 461 13 was be VBD 42759 461 14 morally morally RB 42759 461 15 powerless powerless JJ 42759 461 16 to to TO 42759 461 17 create create VB 42759 461 18 or or CC 42759 461 19 sanction sanction VB 42759 461 20 titles title NNS 42759 461 21 of of IN 42759 461 22 this this DT 42759 461 23 character character NN 42759 461 24 . . . 42759 462 1 Even even RB 42759 462 2 if if IN 42759 462 3 all all PDT 42759 462 4 the the DT 42759 462 5 citizens citizen NNS 42759 462 6 at at IN 42759 462 7 any any DT 42759 462 8 given give VBN 42759 462 9 time time NN 42759 462 10 had have VBD 42759 462 11 deliberately deliberately RB 42759 462 12 transferred transfer VBN 42759 462 13 the the DT 42759 462 14 necessary necessary JJ 42759 462 15 authorisation authorisation NN 42759 462 16 to to IN 42759 462 17 the the DT 42759 462 18 State state NN 42759 462 19 , , , 42759 462 20 " " '' 42759 462 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 462 22 could could MD 42759 462 23 not not RB 42759 462 24 , , , 42759 462 25 " " '' 42759 462 26 in in IN 42759 462 27 the the DT 42759 462 28 words word NNS 42759 462 29 of of IN 42759 462 30 Henry Henry NNP 42759 462 31 George George NNP 42759 462 32 , , , 42759 462 33 " " '' 42759 462 34 grant grant VB 42759 462 35 away away RB 42759 462 36 the the DT 42759 462 37 right right NN 42759 462 38 of of IN 42759 462 39 those those DT 42759 462 40 who who WP 42759 462 41 follow follow VBP 42759 462 42 them -PRON- PRP 42759 462 43 . . . 42759 462 44 " " '' 42759 463 1 The the DT 42759 463 2 individual individual NN 42759 463 3 's 's POS 42759 463 4 right right NN 42759 463 5 to to IN 42759 463 6 land land NN 42759 463 7 is be VBZ 42759 463 8 innate innate JJ 42759 463 9 and and CC 42759 463 10 natural natural JJ 42759 463 11 , , , 42759 463 12 not not RB 42759 463 13 civil civil JJ 42759 463 14 or or CC 42759 463 15 social social JJ 42759 463 16 . . . 42759 464 1 The the DT 42759 464 2 author author NN 42759 464 3 of of IN 42759 464 4 " " `` 42759 464 5 Progress Progress NNP 42759 464 6 and and CC 42759 464 7 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 464 8 " " '' 42759 464 9 attributes attribute VBZ 42759 464 10 to to IN 42759 464 11 the the DT 42759 464 12 individual individual NN 42759 464 13 's 's POS 42759 464 14 _ _ NNP 42759 464 15 common common JJ 42759 464 16 _ _ NNP 42759 464 17 right right NN 42759 464 18 to to TO 42759 464 19 land land VB 42759 464 20 precisely precisely RB 42759 464 21 the the DT 42759 464 22 same same JJ 42759 464 23 absolute absolute JJ 42759 464 24 character character NN 42759 464 25 that that IN 42759 464 26 Father Father NNP 42759 464 27 Liberatore Liberatore NNP 42759 464 28 predicates predicate NNS 42759 464 29 of of IN 42759 464 30 the the DT 42759 464 31 right right NN 42759 464 32 to to TO 42759 464 33 become become VB 42759 464 34 a a DT 42759 464 35 _ _ NNP 42759 464 36 private private JJ 42759 464 37 _ _ NNP 42759 464 38 land land NN 42759 464 39 owner owner NN 42759 464 40 . . . 42759 465 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 465 2 24 24 CD 42759 465 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 465 4 In in IN 42759 465 5 the the DT 42759 465 6 view view NN 42759 465 7 of of IN 42759 465 8 Henry Henry NNP 42759 465 9 George George NNP 42759 465 10 , , , 42759 465 11 the the DT 42759 465 12 State State NNP 42759 465 13 is be VBZ 42759 465 14 merely merely RB 42759 465 15 the the DT 42759 465 16 trustee trustee NN 42759 465 17 of of IN 42759 465 18 the the DT 42759 465 19 land land NN 42759 465 20 , , , 42759 465 21 having have VBG 42759 465 22 the the DT 42759 465 23 duty duty NN 42759 465 24 of of IN 42759 465 25 distributing distribute VBG 42759 465 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 465 27 benefits benefit NNS 42759 465 28 and and CC 42759 465 29 values value NNS 42759 465 30 so so IN 42759 465 31 as as IN 42759 465 32 to to TO 42759 465 33 make make VB 42759 465 34 effective effective JJ 42759 465 35 the the DT 42759 465 36 equal equal JJ 42759 465 37 rights right NNS 42759 465 38 of of IN 42759 465 39 all all DT 42759 465 40 individuals individual NNS 42759 465 41 . . . 42759 466 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 466 2 , , , 42759 466 3 the the DT 42759 466 4 legal legal JJ 42759 466 5 titles title NNS 42759 466 6 of of IN 42759 466 7 private private JJ 42759 466 8 ownership ownership NN 42759 466 9 which which WDT 42759 466 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 466 11 creates create VBZ 42759 466 12 or or CC 42759 466 13 sanctions sanction NNS 42759 466 14 are be VBP 42759 466 15 valid valid JJ 42759 466 16 only only RB 42759 466 17 so so RB 42759 466 18 long long RB 42759 466 19 as as IN 42759 466 20 nothing nothing NN 42759 466 21 better well JJR 42759 466 22 is be VBZ 42759 466 23 available available JJ 42759 466 24 . . . 42759 467 1 At at IN 42759 467 2 best good JJS 42759 467 3 such such JJ 42759 467 4 titles title NNS 42759 467 5 have have VBP 42759 467 6 no no DT 42759 467 7 greater great JJR 42759 467 8 moral moral JJ 42759 467 9 force force NN 42759 467 10 than than IN 42759 467 11 the the DT 42759 467 12 title title NN 42759 467 13 by by IN 42759 467 14 which which WDT 42759 467 15 an an DT 42759 467 16 innocent innocent JJ 42759 467 17 purchaser purchaser NN 42759 467 18 holds hold VBZ 42759 467 19 a a DT 42759 467 20 stolen steal VBN 42759 467 21 watch watch NN 42759 467 22 ; ; : 42759 467 23 and and CC 42759 467 24 the the DT 42759 467 25 persons person NNS 42759 467 26 who who WP 42759 467 27 are be VBP 42759 467 28 thereby thereby RB 42759 467 29 deprived deprive VBN 42759 467 30 of of IN 42759 467 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 467 32 proper proper JJ 42759 467 33 shares share NNS 42759 467 34 of of IN 42759 467 35 land land NN 42759 467 36 benefits benefit NNS 42759 467 37 , , , 42759 467 38 have have VBP 42759 467 39 the the DT 42759 467 40 same same JJ 42759 467 41 right right NN 42759 467 42 to to TO 42759 467 43 recover recover VB 42759 467 44 them -PRON- PRP 42759 467 45 from from IN 42759 467 46 the the DT 42759 467 47 existing exist VBG 42759 467 48 private private JJ 42759 467 49 owners owner NNS 42759 467 50 that that WDT 42759 467 51 the the DT 42759 467 52 watch watch NN 42759 467 53 - - HYPH 42759 467 54 owner owner NN 42759 467 55 has have VBZ 42759 467 56 to to TO 42759 467 57 recover recover VB 42759 467 58 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 467 59 property property NN 42759 467 60 from from IN 42759 467 61 the the DT 42759 467 62 innocent innocent JJ 42759 467 63 purchaser purchaser NN 42759 467 64 . . . 42759 468 1 Hence hence RB 42759 468 2 the the DT 42759 468 3 demand demand NN 42759 468 4 for for IN 42759 468 5 compensation compensation NN 42759 468 6 has have VBZ 42759 468 7 no no DT 42759 468 8 more more JJR 42759 468 9 merit merit NN 42759 468 10 in in IN 42759 468 11 the the DT 42759 468 12 one one CD 42759 468 13 case case NN 42759 468 14 than than IN 42759 468 15 in in IN 42759 468 16 the the DT 42759 468 17 other other JJ 42759 468 18 . . . 42759 469 1 To to IN 42759 469 2 the the DT 42759 469 3 objection objection NN 42759 469 4 that that IN 42759 469 5 the the DT 42759 469 6 civil civil JJ 42759 469 7 laws law NNS 42759 469 8 of of IN 42759 469 9 many many JJ 42759 469 10 civilised civilised JJ 42759 469 11 countries country NNS 42759 469 12 would would MD 42759 469 13 permit permit VB 42759 469 14 the the DT 42759 469 15 innocent innocent JJ 42759 469 16 purchaser purchaser NN 42759 469 17 of of IN 42759 469 18 the the DT 42759 469 19 watch watch NN 42759 469 20 to to TO 42759 469 21 retain retain VB 42759 469 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 469 23 , , , 42759 469 24 provided provide VBN 42759 469 25 that that IN 42759 469 26 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 469 27 time time NN 42759 469 28 had have VBD 42759 469 29 elapsed elapse VBN 42759 469 30 to to TO 42759 469 31 create create VB 42759 469 32 a a DT 42759 469 33 title title NN 42759 469 34 of of IN 42759 469 35 prescription prescription NN 42759 469 36 , , , 42759 469 37 the the DT 42759 469 38 Single Single NNP 42759 469 39 Taxer Taxer NNP 42759 469 40 would would MD 42759 469 41 reply reply VB 42759 469 42 that that IN 42759 469 43 the the DT 42759 469 44 two two CD 42759 469 45 kinds kind NNS 42759 469 46 of of IN 42759 469 47 goods good NNS 42759 469 48 are be VBP 42759 469 49 not not RB 42759 469 50 on on IN 42759 469 51 the the DT 42759 469 52 same same JJ 42759 469 53 moral moral JJ 42759 469 54 basis basis NN 42759 469 55 in in IN 42759 469 56 all all DT 42759 469 57 respects respect NNS 42759 469 58 . . . 42759 470 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 470 2 would would MD 42759 470 3 contend contend VB 42759 470 4 that that IN 42759 470 5 the the DT 42759 470 6 natural natural JJ 42759 470 7 heritage heritage NN 42759 470 8 of of IN 42759 470 9 the the DT 42759 470 10 race race NN 42759 470 11 is be VBZ 42759 470 12 too too RB 42759 470 13 valuable valuable JJ 42759 470 14 , , , 42759 470 15 and and CC 42759 470 16 too too RB 42759 470 17 important important JJ 42759 470 18 for for IN 42759 470 19 human human JJ 42759 470 20 welfare welfare NN 42759 470 21 to to TO 42759 470 22 fall fall VB 42759 470 23 under under IN 42759 470 24 the the DT 42759 470 25 title title NN 42759 470 26 of of IN 42759 470 27 prescription prescription NN 42759 470 28 . . . 42759 471 1 To to TO 42759 471 2 put put VB 42759 471 3 the the DT 42759 471 4 matter matter NN 42759 471 5 briefly briefly RB 42759 471 6 , , , 42759 471 7 then then RB 42759 471 8 , , , 42759 471 9 Henry Henry NNP 42759 471 10 George George NNP 42759 471 11 contends contend VBZ 42759 471 12 that that IN 42759 471 13 the the DT 42759 471 14 individual individual NN 42759 471 15 's 's POS 42759 471 16 equal equal JJ 42759 471 17 right right NN 42759 471 18 to to IN 42759 471 19 land land NN 42759 471 20 is be VBZ 42759 471 21 so so RB 42759 471 22 much much RB 42759 471 23 superior superior JJ 42759 471 24 to to IN 42759 471 25 the the DT 42759 471 26 claim claim NN 42759 471 27 of of IN 42759 471 28 the the DT 42759 471 29 private private JJ 42759 471 30 owner owner NN 42759 471 31 that that WDT 42759 471 32 the the DT 42759 471 33 latter latter NN 42759 471 34 must must MD 42759 471 35 give give VB 42759 471 36 way way NN 42759 471 37 , , , 42759 471 38 even even RB 42759 471 39 when when WRB 42759 471 40 it -PRON- PRP 42759 471 41 represents represent VBZ 42759 471 42 an an DT 42759 471 43 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 471 44 of of IN 42759 471 45 money money NN 42759 471 46 or or CC 42759 471 47 other other JJ 42759 471 48 valuable valuable JJ 42759 471 49 goods good NNS 42759 471 50 . . . 42759 472 1 The the DT 42759 472 2 average average JJ 42759 472 3 opponent opponent NN 42759 472 4 does do VBZ 42759 472 5 not not RB 42759 472 6 seem seem VB 42759 472 7 to to TO 42759 472 8 realise realise VB 42759 472 9 the the DT 42759 472 10 full full JJ 42759 472 11 force force NN 42759 472 12 of of IN 42759 472 13 the the DT 42759 472 14 impression impression NN 42759 472 15 which which WDT 42759 472 16 this this DT 42759 472 17 theory theory NN 42759 472 18 makes make VBZ 42759 472 19 upon upon IN 42759 472 20 the the DT 42759 472 21 man man NN 42759 472 22 who who WP 42759 472 23 overemphasises overemphasise VBZ 42759 472 24 the the DT 42759 472 25 innate innate JJ 42759 472 26 rights right NNS 42759 472 27 of of IN 42759 472 28 men man NNS 42759 472 29 to to IN 42759 472 30 a a DT 42759 472 31 share share NN 42759 472 32 in in IN 42759 472 33 the the DT 42759 472 34 gifts gift NNS 42759 472 35 of of IN 42759 472 36 nature nature NN 42759 472 37 . . . 42759 473 1 Let let VB 42759 473 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 473 3 see see VB 42759 473 4 whether whether IN 42759 473 5 this this DT 42759 473 6 right right NN 42759 473 7 has have VBZ 42759 473 8 the the DT 42759 473 9 absolute absolute JJ 42759 473 10 and and CC 42759 473 11 overpowering overpowering JJ 42759 473 12 value value NN 42759 473 13 which which WDT 42759 473 14 is be VBZ 42759 473 15 attributed attribute VBN 42759 473 16 to to IN 42759 473 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 473 18 by by IN 42759 473 19 Henry Henry NNP 42759 473 20 George George NNP 42759 473 21 . . . 42759 474 1 In in IN 42759 474 2 considering consider VBG 42759 474 3 this this DT 42759 474 4 question question NN 42759 474 5 , , , 42759 474 6 the the DT 42759 474 7 supremely supremely RB 42759 474 8 important important JJ 42759 474 9 fact fact NN 42759 474 10 to to TO 42759 474 11 be be VB 42759 474 12 kept keep VBN 42759 474 13 in in IN 42759 474 14 mind mind NN 42759 474 15 is be VBZ 42759 474 16 that that IN 42759 474 17 the the DT 42759 474 18 natural natural JJ 42759 474 19 right right NN 42759 474 20 to to IN 42759 474 21 land land NN 42759 474 22 is be VBZ 42759 474 23 not not RB 42759 474 24 an an DT 42759 474 25 end end NN 42759 474 26 in in IN 42759 474 27 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 474 28 . . . 42759 475 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 475 2 is be VBZ 42759 475 3 not not RB 42759 475 4 a a DT 42759 475 5 prerogative prerogative NN 42759 475 6 that that WDT 42759 475 7 inheres inhere VBZ 42759 475 8 in in IN 42759 475 9 men man NNS 42759 475 10 , , , 42759 475 11 regardless regardless RB 42759 475 12 of of IN 42759 475 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 475 14 purposes purpose NNS 42759 475 15 or or CC 42759 475 16 effects effect NNS 42759 475 17 . . . 42759 476 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 476 2 has have VBZ 42759 476 3 validity validity NN 42759 476 4 only only RB 42759 476 5 in in IN 42759 476 6 so so RB 42759 476 7 far far RB 42759 476 8 as as IN 42759 476 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 476 10 promotes promote VBZ 42759 476 11 individual individual JJ 42759 476 12 and and CC 42759 476 13 social social JJ 42759 476 14 welfare welfare NN 42759 476 15 . . . 42759 477 1 As as IN 42759 477 2 regards regard VBZ 42759 477 3 individual individual JJ 42759 477 4 welfare welfare NN 42759 477 5 , , , 42759 477 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 477 7 must must MD 42759 477 8 bear bear VB 42759 477 9 in in IN 42759 477 10 mind mind NN 42759 477 11 that that IN 42759 477 12 this this DT 42759 477 13 phrase phrase NN 42759 477 14 includes include VBZ 42759 477 15 the the DT 42759 477 16 well well JJ 42759 477 17 being being NN 42759 477 18 of of IN 42759 477 19 all all DT 42759 477 20 persons person NNS 42759 477 21 , , , 42759 477 22 of of IN 42759 477 23 those those DT 42759 477 24 who who WP 42759 477 25 do do VBP 42759 477 26 as as RB 42759 477 27 well well RB 42759 477 28 as as IN 42759 477 29 of of IN 42759 477 30 those those DT 42759 477 31 who who WP 42759 477 32 do do VBP 42759 477 33 not not RB 42759 477 34 at at IN 42759 477 35 present present JJ 42759 477 36 enjoy enjoy VB 42759 477 37 the the DT 42759 477 38 benefits benefit NNS 42759 477 39 of of IN 42759 477 40 private private JJ 42759 477 41 landownership landownership NN 42759 477 42 . . . 42759 478 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 478 2 the the DT 42759 478 3 proposal proposal NN 42759 478 4 to to TO 42759 478 5 restore restore VB 42759 478 6 to to IN 42759 478 7 the the DT 42759 478 8 " " `` 42759 478 9 disinherited disinherit VBN 42759 478 10 " " '' 42759 478 11 the the DT 42759 478 12 use use NN 42759 478 13 of of IN 42759 478 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 478 15 land land NN 42759 478 16 rights right NNS 42759 478 17 must must MD 42759 478 18 be be VB 42759 478 19 judged judge VBN 42759 478 20 by by IN 42759 478 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 478 22 effects effect NNS 42759 478 23 upon upon IN 42759 478 24 the the DT 42759 478 25 welfare welfare NN 42759 478 26 of of IN 42759 478 27 all all DT 42759 478 28 persons person NNS 42759 478 29 . . . 42759 479 1 If if IN 42759 479 2 existing existing JJ 42759 479 3 landowners landowner NNS 42759 479 4 are be VBP 42759 479 5 not not RB 42759 479 6 compensated compensate VBN 42759 479 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 479 8 are be VBP 42759 479 9 deprived deprive VBN 42759 479 10 , , , 42759 479 11 in in IN 42759 479 12 varying vary VBG 42759 479 13 amounts amount NNS 42759 479 14 , , , 42759 479 15 of of IN 42759 479 16 the the DT 42759 479 17 conditions condition NNS 42759 479 18 of of IN 42759 479 19 material material NN 42759 479 20 well well UH 42759 479 21 being be VBG 42759 479 22 to to TO 42759 479 23 which which WDT 42759 479 24 they -PRON- PRP 42759 479 25 have have VBP 42759 479 26 become become VBN 42759 479 27 accustomed accustomed JJ 42759 479 28 , , , 42759 479 29 and and CC 42759 479 30 are be VBP 42759 479 31 thereby thereby RB 42759 479 32 subjected subject VBN 42759 479 33 to to IN 42759 479 34 varying vary VBG 42759 479 35 degrees degree NNS 42759 479 36 of of IN 42759 479 37 positive positive JJ 42759 479 38 inconvenience inconvenience NN 42759 479 39 and and CC 42759 479 40 hardship hardship NN 42759 479 41 . . . 42759 480 1 The the DT 42759 480 2 assertion assertion NN 42759 480 3 that that IN 42759 480 4 this this DT 42759 480 5 loss loss NN 42759 480 6 would would MD 42759 480 7 be be VB 42759 480 8 offset offset VBN 42759 480 9 by by IN 42759 480 10 the the DT 42759 480 11 moral moral JJ 42759 480 12 gain gain NN 42759 480 13 in in IN 42759 480 14 altruistic altruistic JJ 42759 480 15 feelings feeling NNS 42759 480 16 and and CC 42759 480 17 consciousness consciousness NN 42759 480 18 , , , 42759 480 19 may may MD 42759 480 20 be be VB 42759 480 21 passed pass VBN 42759 480 22 over over RP 42759 480 23 as as IN 42759 480 24 applying apply VBG 42759 480 25 to to IN 42759 480 26 a a DT 42759 480 27 different different JJ 42759 480 28 race race NN 42759 480 29 of of IN 42759 480 30 beings being NNS 42759 480 31 from from IN 42759 480 32 those those DT 42759 480 33 who who WP 42759 480 34 would would MD 42759 480 35 be be VB 42759 480 36 despoiled despoil VBN 42759 480 37 . . . 42759 481 1 The the DT 42759 481 2 hardship hardship NN 42759 481 3 is be VBZ 42759 481 4 aggravated aggravate VBN 42759 481 5 considerably considerably RB 42759 481 6 by by IN 42759 481 7 the the DT 42759 481 8 fact fact NN 42759 481 9 that that IN 42759 481 10 very very RB 42759 481 11 many many JJ 42759 481 12 of of IN 42759 481 13 the the DT 42759 481 14 dispossessed dispossess VBN 42759 481 15 private private JJ 42759 481 16 owners owner NNS 42759 481 17 have have VBP 42759 481 18 paid pay VBN 42759 481 19 the the DT 42759 481 20 full full JJ 42759 481 21 value value NN 42759 481 22 of of IN 42759 481 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 481 24 land land NN 42759 481 25 out out IN 42759 481 26 of of IN 42759 481 27 the the DT 42759 481 28 earnings earning NNS 42759 481 29 of of IN 42759 481 30 labour labour NN 42759 481 31 or or CC 42759 481 32 capital capital NN 42759 481 33 , , , 42759 481 34 and and CC 42759 481 35 that that IN 42759 481 36 all all DT 42759 481 37 of of IN 42759 481 38 them -PRON- PRP 42759 481 39 have have VBP 42759 481 40 been be VBN 42759 481 41 encouraged encourage VBN 42759 481 42 by by IN 42759 481 43 society society NN 42759 481 44 and and CC 42759 481 45 the the DT 42759 481 46 State State NNP 42759 481 47 to to TO 42759 481 48 regard regard VB 42759 481 49 landed land VBD 42759 481 50 property property NN 42759 481 51 in in IN 42759 481 52 precisely precisely RB 42759 481 53 the the DT 42759 481 54 same same JJ 42759 481 55 way way NN 42759 481 56 as as IN 42759 481 57 any any DT 42759 481 58 other other JJ 42759 481 59 kind kind NN 42759 481 60 of of IN 42759 481 61 property property NN 42759 481 62 . . . 42759 482 1 In in IN 42759 482 2 the the DT 42759 482 3 latter latter JJ 42759 482 4 respect respect NN 42759 482 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 482 6 are be VBP 42759 482 7 not not RB 42759 482 8 in in IN 42759 482 9 the the DT 42759 482 10 same same JJ 42759 482 11 position position NN 42759 482 12 as as IN 42759 482 13 the the DT 42759 482 14 innocent innocent JJ 42759 482 15 purchaser purchaser NN 42759 482 16 of of IN 42759 482 17 the the DT 42759 482 18 stolen steal VBN 42759 482 19 watch watch NN 42759 482 20 ; ; : 42759 482 21 for for IN 42759 482 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 482 23 have have VBP 42759 482 24 never never RB 42759 482 25 been be VBN 42759 482 26 warned warn VBN 42759 482 27 by by IN 42759 482 28 society society NN 42759 482 29 that that WDT 42759 482 30 the the DT 42759 482 31 land land NN 42759 482 32 might may MD 42759 482 33 have have VB 42759 482 34 been be VBN 42759 482 35 virtually virtually RB 42759 482 36 stolen steal VBN 42759 482 37 , , , 42759 482 38 or or CC 42759 482 39 that that IN 42759 482 40 the the DT 42759 482 41 supposedly supposedly RB 42759 482 42 rightful rightful JJ 42759 482 43 claimants claimant NNS 42759 482 44 might may MD 42759 482 45 some some DT 42759 482 46 day day NN 42759 482 47 be be VB 42759 482 48 empowered empower VBN 42759 482 49 by by IN 42759 482 50 the the DT 42759 482 51 law law NN 42759 482 52 to to TO 42759 482 53 recover recover VB 42759 482 54 possession possession NN 42759 482 55 . . . 42759 483 1 On on IN 42759 483 2 the the DT 42759 483 3 other other JJ 42759 483 4 hand hand NN 42759 483 5 , , , 42759 483 6 the the DT 42759 483 7 persons person NNS 42759 483 8 who who WP 42759 483 9 own own VBP 42759 483 10 no no DT 42759 483 11 land land NN 42759 483 12 under under IN 42759 483 13 the the DT 42759 483 14 present present JJ 42759 483 15 system system NN 42759 483 16 , , , 42759 483 17 the the DT 42759 483 18 persons person NNS 42759 483 19 who who WP 42759 483 20 are be VBP 42759 483 21 deprived deprive VBN 42759 483 22 of of IN 42759 483 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 483 24 " " `` 42759 483 25 birthright birthright NN 42759 483 26 , , , 42759 483 27 " " '' 42759 483 28 suffer suffer VBP 42759 483 29 no no DT 42759 483 30 such such JJ 42759 483 31 degree degree NN 42759 483 32 of of IN 42759 483 33 hardship hardship NN 42759 483 34 when when WRB 42759 483 35 they -PRON- PRP 42759 483 36 are be VBP 42759 483 37 continued continue VBN 42759 483 38 in in IN 42759 483 39 that that DT 42759 483 40 condition condition NN 42759 483 41 . . . 42759 484 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 484 2 are be VBP 42759 484 3 kept keep VBN 42759 484 4 out out IN 42759 484 5 of of IN 42759 484 6 something something NN 42759 484 7 which which WDT 42759 484 8 they -PRON- PRP 42759 484 9 have have VBP 42759 484 10 never never RB 42759 484 11 possessed possess VBN 42759 484 12 , , , 42759 484 13 which which WDT 42759 484 14 they -PRON- PRP 42759 484 15 have have VBP 42759 484 16 never never RB 42759 484 17 hoped hope VBN 42759 484 18 to to TO 42759 484 19 get get VB 42759 484 20 by by IN 42759 484 21 any any DT 42759 484 22 such such JJ 42759 484 23 easy easy JJ 42759 484 24 method method NN 42759 484 25 , , , 42759 484 26 and and CC 42759 484 27 from from IN 42759 484 28 which which WDT 42759 484 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 484 30 have have VBP 42759 484 31 not not RB 42759 484 32 been be VBN 42759 484 33 accustomed accustom VBN 42759 484 34 to to TO 42759 484 35 derive derive VB 42759 484 36 any any DT 42759 484 37 benefit benefit NN 42759 484 38 . . . 42759 485 1 To to TO 42759 485 2 prolong prolong VB 42759 485 3 this this DT 42759 485 4 condition condition NN 42759 485 5 is be VBZ 42759 485 6 not not RB 42759 485 7 to to TO 42759 485 8 inflict inflict VB 42759 485 9 upon upon IN 42759 485 10 them -PRON- PRP 42759 485 11 any any DT 42759 485 12 new new JJ 42759 485 13 or or CC 42759 485 14 positive positive JJ 42759 485 15 inconvenience inconvenience NN 42759 485 16 . . . 42759 486 1 Evidently evidently RB 42759 486 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 486 3 welfare welfare NN 42759 486 4 and and CC 42759 486 5 claims claim NNS 42759 486 6 in in IN 42759 486 7 the the DT 42759 486 8 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 486 9 are be VBP 42759 486 10 not not RB 42759 486 11 of of IN 42759 486 12 the the DT 42759 486 13 same same JJ 42759 486 14 moral moral JJ 42759 486 15 importance importance NN 42759 486 16 as as IN 42759 486 17 the the DT 42759 486 18 welfare welfare NN 42759 486 19 and and CC 42759 486 20 claims claim NNS 42759 486 21 of of IN 42759 486 22 persons person NNS 42759 486 23 who who WP 42759 486 24 would would MD 42759 486 25 be be VB 42759 486 26 called call VBN 42759 486 27 upon upon IN 42759 486 28 to to TO 42759 486 29 suffer suffer VB 42759 486 30 the the DT 42759 486 31 loss loss NN 42759 486 32 of of IN 42759 486 33 goods good NNS 42759 486 34 already already RB 42759 486 35 possessed possess VBN 42759 486 36 and and CC 42759 486 37 enjoyed enjoyed JJ 42759 486 38 , , , 42759 486 39 and and CC 42759 486 40 acquired acquire VBD 42759 486 41 with with IN 42759 486 42 the the DT 42759 486 43 full full JJ 42759 486 44 sanction sanction NN 42759 486 45 of of IN 42759 486 46 society society NN 42759 486 47 . . . 42759 487 1 Henry Henry NNP 42759 487 2 George George NNP 42759 487 3 is be VBZ 42759 487 4 fond fond JJ 42759 487 5 of of IN 42759 487 6 comparing compare VBG 42759 487 7 the the DT 42759 487 8 private private JJ 42759 487 9 owner owner NN 42759 487 10 of of IN 42759 487 11 land land NN 42759 487 12 with with IN 42759 487 13 the the DT 42759 487 14 slave slave NN 42759 487 15 owner owner NN 42759 487 16 , , , 42759 487 17 and and CC 42759 487 18 the the DT 42759 487 19 landless landless JJ 42759 487 20 man man NN 42759 487 21 with with IN 42759 487 22 the the DT 42759 487 23 man man NN 42759 487 24 enslaved enslave VBD 42759 487 25 ; ; : 42759 487 26 but but CC 42759 487 27 there there EX 42759 487 28 is be VBZ 42759 487 29 a a DT 42759 487 30 world world NN 42759 487 31 of of IN 42759 487 32 difference difference NN 42759 487 33 between between IN 42759 487 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 487 35 respective respective JJ 42759 487 36 positions position NNS 42759 487 37 and and CC 42759 487 38 moral moral JJ 42759 487 39 claims claim NNS 42759 487 40 . . . 42759 488 1 Liberty liberty NN 42759 488 2 is be VBZ 42759 488 3 immeasurably immeasurably RB 42759 488 4 more more RBR 42759 488 5 important important JJ 42759 488 6 than than IN 42759 488 7 land land NN 42759 488 8 , , , 42759 488 9 and and CC 42759 488 10 the the DT 42759 488 11 hardship hardship NN 42759 488 12 suffered suffer VBN 42759 488 13 by by IN 42759 488 14 the the DT 42759 488 15 master master NN 42759 488 16 when when WRB 42759 488 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 488 18 is be VBZ 42759 488 19 compelled compel VBN 42759 488 20 to to TO 42759 488 21 free free VB 42759 488 22 the the DT 42759 488 23 slave slave NN 42759 488 24 is be VBZ 42759 488 25 immeasurably immeasurably RB 42759 488 26 less less JJR 42759 488 27 than than IN 42759 488 28 that that DT 42759 488 29 endured endure VBN 42759 488 30 by by IN 42759 488 31 the the DT 42759 488 32 slave slave NN 42759 488 33 who who WP 42759 488 34 is be VBZ 42759 488 35 forcibly forcibly RB 42759 488 36 detained detain VBN 42759 488 37 in in IN 42759 488 38 bondage bondage NN 42759 488 39 . . . 42759 489 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 489 2 , , , 42759 489 3 the the DT 42759 489 4 moral moral JJ 42759 489 5 sense sense NN 42759 489 6 of of IN 42759 489 7 mankind mankind NN 42759 489 8 recognises recognise VBZ 42759 489 9 that that IN 42759 489 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 489 11 is be VBZ 42759 489 12 in in IN 42759 489 13 accordance accordance NN 42759 489 14 with with IN 42759 489 15 equity equity NN 42759 489 16 to to TO 42759 489 17 compensate compensate VB 42759 489 18 slave slave NN 42759 489 19 owners owner NNS 42759 489 20 when when WRB 42759 489 21 the the DT 42759 489 22 slaves slave NNS 42759 489 23 are be VBP 42759 489 24 legally legally RB 42759 489 25 emancipated emancipate VBN 42759 489 26 . . . 42759 490 1 Infinitely infinitely RB 42759 490 2 stronger strong JJR 42759 490 3 is be VBZ 42759 490 4 the the DT 42759 490 5 claim claim NN 42759 490 6 of of IN 42759 490 7 the the DT 42759 490 8 landowner landowner NN 42759 490 9 to to IN 42759 490 10 compensation compensation NN 42759 490 11 . . . 42759 491 1 If if IN 42759 491 2 the the DT 42759 491 3 Georgeite Georgeite NNP 42759 491 4 replies reply VBZ 42759 491 5 that that IN 42759 491 6 the the DT 42759 491 7 landless landless JJ 42759 491 8 man man NN 42759 491 9 is be VBZ 42759 491 10 at at IN 42759 491 11 present present JJ 42759 491 12 kept keep VBD 42759 491 13 out out IN 42759 491 14 of of IN 42759 491 15 something something NN 42759 491 16 to to TO 42759 491 17 which which WDT 42759 491 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 491 19 has have VBZ 42759 491 20 a a DT 42759 491 21 right right NN 42759 491 22 , , , 42759 491 23 while while IN 42759 491 24 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 491 25 would would MD 42759 491 26 take take VB 42759 491 27 from from IN 42759 491 28 the the DT 42759 491 29 private private JJ 42759 491 30 owner owner NN 42759 491 31 something something NN 42759 491 32 which which WDT 42759 491 33 does do VBZ 42759 491 34 not not RB 42759 491 35 really really RB 42759 491 36 belong belong VB 42759 491 37 to to IN 42759 491 38 him -PRON- PRP 42759 491 39 , , , 42759 491 40 the the DT 42759 491 41 rejoinder rejoinder NN 42759 491 42 must must MD 42759 491 43 be be VB 42759 491 44 that that IN 42759 491 45 this this DT 42759 491 46 assertion assertion NN 42759 491 47 begs beg VBZ 42759 491 48 the the DT 42759 491 49 question question NN 42759 491 50 . . . 42759 492 1 The the DT 42759 492 2 question question NN 42759 492 3 is be VBZ 42759 492 4 likewise likewise RB 42759 492 5 begged beg VBN 42759 492 6 when when WRB 42759 492 7 the the DT 42759 492 8 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 492 9 defender defender NN 42759 492 10 of of IN 42759 492 11 private private JJ 42759 492 12 property property NN 42759 492 13 declares declare NNS 42759 492 14 that that IN 42759 492 15 the the DT 42759 492 16 right right NN 42759 492 17 of of IN 42759 492 18 the the DT 42759 492 19 landless landless NN 42759 492 20 is be VBZ 42759 492 21 vague vague JJ 42759 492 22 and and CC 42759 492 23 undetermined undetermined JJ 42759 492 24 , , , 42759 492 25 and and CC 42759 492 26 therefore therefore RB 42759 492 27 morally morally RB 42759 492 28 inferior inferior JJ 42759 492 29 to to IN 42759 492 30 the the DT 42759 492 31 determinate determinate NN 42759 492 32 and and CC 42759 492 33 specific specific JJ 42759 492 34 right right NN 42759 492 35 of of IN 42759 492 36 the the DT 42759 492 37 individual individual JJ 42759 492 38 landowner landowner NN 42759 492 39 . . . 42759 493 1 This this DT 42759 493 2 is be VBZ 42759 493 3 precisely precisely RB 42759 493 4 the the DT 42759 493 5 question question NN 42759 493 6 to to TO 42759 493 7 be be VB 42759 493 8 solved solve VBN 42759 493 9 . . . 42759 494 1 Does do VBZ 42759 494 2 the the DT 42759 494 3 abstract abstract JJ 42759 494 4 right right NN 42759 494 5 of of IN 42759 494 6 the the DT 42759 494 7 landless landless JJ 42759 494 8 man man NN 42759 494 9 become become VB 42759 494 10 a a DT 42759 494 11 concrete concrete JJ 42759 494 12 right right NN 42759 494 13 which which WDT 42759 494 14 is be VBZ 42759 494 15 so so RB 42759 494 16 strong strong JJ 42759 494 17 as as IN 42759 494 18 to to TO 42759 494 19 justify justify VB 42759 494 20 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 494 21 ? ? . 42759 495 1 Is be VBZ 42759 495 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 495 3 natural natural JJ 42759 495 4 right right JJ 42759 495 5 valid valid NN 42759 495 6 against against IN 42759 495 7 the the DT 42759 495 8 acquired acquire VBN 42759 495 9 right right NN 42759 495 10 of of IN 42759 495 11 the the DT 42759 495 12 private private JJ 42759 495 13 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 495 14 ? ? . 42759 496 1 These these DT 42759 496 2 questions question NNS 42759 496 3 can can MD 42759 496 4 be be VB 42759 496 5 answered answer VBN 42759 496 6 intelligently intelligently RB 42759 496 7 only only RB 42759 496 8 by by IN 42759 496 9 applying apply VBG 42759 496 10 the the DT 42759 496 11 test test NN 42759 496 12 of of IN 42759 496 13 human human JJ 42759 496 14 welfare welfare NN 42759 496 15 , , , 42759 496 16 individual individual JJ 42759 496 17 and and CC 42759 496 18 social social JJ 42759 496 19 . . . 42759 497 1 To to TO 42759 497 2 say say VB 42759 497 3 that that DT 42759 497 4 land land NN 42759 497 5 of of IN 42759 497 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 497 7 very very JJ 42759 497 8 nature nature NN 42759 497 9 is be VBZ 42759 497 10 not not RB 42759 497 11 morally morally RB 42759 497 12 susceptible susceptible JJ 42759 497 13 of of IN 42759 497 14 private private JJ 42759 497 15 ownership ownership NN 42759 497 16 , , , 42759 497 17 is be VBZ 42759 497 18 to to TO 42759 497 19 make make VB 42759 497 20 an an DT 42759 497 21 easy easy JJ 42759 497 22 assertion assertion NN 42759 497 23 that that WDT 42759 497 24 may may MD 42759 497 25 be be VB 42759 497 26 as as RB 42759 497 27 easily easily RB 42759 497 28 denied deny VBN 42759 497 29 . . . 42759 498 1 To to TO 42759 498 2 interpret interpret VB 42759 498 3 man man NN 42759 498 4 's 's POS 42759 498 5 natural natural JJ 42759 498 6 right right NN 42759 498 7 to to IN 42759 498 8 land land NN 42759 498 9 by by IN 42759 498 10 any any DT 42759 498 11 other other JJ 42759 498 12 standard standard NN 42759 498 13 than than IN 42759 498 14 human human JJ 42759 498 15 welfare welfare NN 42759 498 16 , , , 42759 498 17 is be VBZ 42759 498 18 to to TO 42759 498 19 make make VB 42759 498 20 of of IN 42759 498 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 498 22 a a DT 42759 498 23 fetish fetish NN 42759 498 24 , , , 42759 498 25 not not RB 42759 498 26 a a DT 42759 498 27 thing thing NN 42759 498 28 of of IN 42759 498 29 reason reason NN 42759 498 30 . . . 42759 499 1 Henry Henry NNP 42759 499 2 George George NNP 42759 499 3 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 499 4 seemed seem VBD 42759 499 5 to to TO 42759 499 6 recognise recognise VB 42759 499 7 this this DT 42759 499 8 when when WRB 42759 499 9 he -PRON- PRP 42759 499 10 wrote write VBD 42759 499 11 that that IN 42759 499 12 wonderfully wonderfully RB 42759 499 13 eloquent eloquent JJ 42759 499 14 but but CC 42759 499 15 overdrawn overdrawn JJ 42759 499 16 and and CC 42759 499 17 one one CD 42759 499 18 - - HYPH 42759 499 19 sided sided JJ 42759 499 20 description description NN 42759 499 21 of of IN 42759 499 22 the the DT 42759 499 23 effects effect NNS 42759 499 24 of of IN 42759 499 25 private private JJ 42759 499 26 ownership ownership NN 42759 499 27 which which WDT 42759 499 28 occurs occur VBZ 42759 499 29 in in IN 42759 499 30 the the DT 42759 499 31 chapter chapter NN 42759 499 32 entitled entitle VBN 42759 499 33 , , , 42759 499 34 " " `` 42759 499 35 Claim claim NN 42759 499 36 of of IN 42759 499 37 Landowners Landowners NNPS 42759 499 38 to to IN 42759 499 39 Compensation Compensation NNP 42759 499 40 . . . 42759 500 1 " " `` 42759 500 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 500 3 25 25 CD 42759 500 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 500 5 When when WRB 42759 500 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 500 7 say say VBP 42759 500 8 that that IN 42759 500 9 human human JJ 42759 500 10 welfare welfare NN 42759 500 11 is be VBZ 42759 500 12 the the DT 42759 500 13 final final JJ 42759 500 14 determinant determinant NN 42759 500 15 of of IN 42759 500 16 the the DT 42759 500 17 right right NN 42759 500 18 to to IN 42759 500 19 land land NN 42759 500 20 , , , 42759 500 21 we -PRON- PRP 42759 500 22 understand understand VBP 42759 500 23 this this DT 42759 500 24 phrase phrase NN 42759 500 25 in in IN 42759 500 26 the the DT 42759 500 27 widest wide JJS 42759 500 28 possible possible JJ 42759 500 29 sense sense NN 42759 500 30 . . . 42759 501 1 To to TO 42759 501 2 divide divide VB 42759 501 3 the the DT 42759 501 4 goods good NNS 42759 501 5 of of IN 42759 501 6 the the DT 42759 501 7 idle idle JJ 42759 501 8 rich rich JJ 42759 501 9 among among IN 42759 501 10 the the DT 42759 501 11 deserving deserve VBG 42759 501 12 poor poor JJ 42759 501 13 , , , 42759 501 14 might may MD 42759 501 15 be be VB 42759 501 16 temporarily temporarily RB 42759 501 17 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 501 18 to to IN 42759 501 19 both both PDT 42759 501 20 these these DT 42759 501 21 classes class NNS 42759 501 22 , , , 42759 501 23 but but CC 42759 501 24 the the DT 42759 501 25 more more RBR 42759 501 26 remote remote JJ 42759 501 27 and and CC 42759 501 28 enduring endure VBG 42759 501 29 consequences consequence NNS 42759 501 30 would would MD 42759 501 31 be be VB 42759 501 32 individually individually RB 42759 501 33 and and CC 42759 501 34 socially socially RB 42759 501 35 disastrous disastrous JJ 42759 501 36 . . . 42759 502 1 To to TO 42759 502 2 restore restore VB 42759 502 3 a a DT 42759 502 4 legacy legacy NN 42759 502 5 to to IN 42759 502 6 persons person NNS 42759 502 7 who who WP 42759 502 8 had have VBD 42759 502 9 been be VBN 42759 502 10 defrauded defraud VBN 42759 502 11 of of IN 42759 502 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 502 13 when when WRB 42759 502 14 very very RB 42759 502 15 young young JJ 42759 502 16 , , , 42759 502 17 would would MD 42759 502 18 probably probably RB 42759 502 19 cause cause VB 42759 502 20 more more JJR 42759 502 21 hardship hardship NN 42759 502 22 to to IN 42759 502 23 the the DT 42759 502 24 swindler swindler NN 42759 502 25 than than IN 42759 502 26 the the DT 42759 502 27 heirs heir NNS 42759 502 28 would would MD 42759 502 29 have have VB 42759 502 30 suffered suffer VBN 42759 502 31 had have VBD 42759 502 32 there there EX 42759 502 33 been be VBN 42759 502 34 no no DT 42759 502 35 restitution restitution NN 42759 502 36 ; ; : 42759 502 37 nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 502 38 the the DT 42759 502 39 larger large JJR 42759 502 40 view view NN 42759 502 41 of of IN 42759 502 42 human human JJ 42759 502 43 welfare welfare NN 42759 502 44 requires require VBZ 42759 502 45 that that IN 42759 502 46 the the DT 42759 502 47 legacy legacy NN 42759 502 48 should should MD 42759 502 49 be be VB 42759 502 50 restored restore VBN 42759 502 51 . . . 42759 503 1 When when WRB 42759 503 2 , , , 42759 503 3 however however RB 42759 503 4 , , , 42759 503 5 two two CD 42759 503 6 or or CC 42759 503 7 three three CD 42759 503 8 generations generation NNS 42759 503 9 have have VBP 42759 503 10 been be VBN 42759 503 11 kept keep VBN 42759 503 12 out out IN 42759 503 13 of of IN 42759 503 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 503 15 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 503 16 , , , 42759 503 17 the the DT 42759 503 18 civil civil JJ 42759 503 19 law law NN 42759 503 20 permits permit VBZ 42759 503 21 the the DT 42759 503 22 children child NNS 42759 503 23 of of IN 42759 503 24 the the DT 42759 503 25 swindler swindler NN 42759 503 26 to to TO 42759 503 27 retain retain VB 42759 503 28 the the DT 42759 503 29 property property NN 42759 503 30 by by IN 42759 503 31 the the DT 42759 503 32 title title NN 42759 503 33 of of IN 42759 503 34 prescription prescription NN 42759 503 35 ; ; : 42759 503 36 and and CC 42759 503 37 for for IN 42759 503 38 precisely precisely RB 42759 503 39 the the DT 42759 503 40 same same JJ 42759 503 41 reason reason NN 42759 503 42 , , , 42759 503 43 human human JJ 42759 503 44 welfare welfare NN 42759 503 45 . . . 42759 504 1 The the DT 42759 504 2 social social JJ 42759 504 3 consequences consequence NNS 42759 504 4 of of IN 42759 504 5 the the DT 42759 504 6 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 504 7 of of IN 42759 504 8 rent rent NN 42759 504 9 and and CC 42759 504 10 land land NN 42759 504 11 values value NNS 42759 504 12 , , , 42759 504 13 would would MD 42759 504 14 be be VB 42759 504 15 even even RB 42759 504 16 more more RBR 42759 504 17 injurious injurious JJ 42759 504 18 than than IN 42759 504 19 those those DT 42759 504 20 falling fall VBG 42759 504 21 upon upon IN 42759 504 22 the the DT 42759 504 23 individuals individual NNS 42759 504 24 despoiled despoil VBN 42759 504 25 . . . 42759 505 1 Social social JJ 42759 505 2 peace peace NN 42759 505 3 and and CC 42759 505 4 order order NN 42759 505 5 would would MD 42759 505 6 be be VB 42759 505 7 gravely gravely RB 42759 505 8 disturbed disturb VBN 42759 505 9 by by IN 42759 505 10 the the DT 42759 505 11 protests protest NNS 42759 505 12 and and CC 42759 505 13 opposition opposition NN 42759 505 14 of of IN 42759 505 15 the the DT 42759 505 16 landowners landowner NNS 42759 505 17 , , , 42759 505 18 while while IN 42759 505 19 the the DT 42759 505 20 popular popular JJ 42759 505 21 conception conception NN 42759 505 22 of of IN 42759 505 23 property property NN 42759 505 24 rights right NNS 42759 505 25 , , , 42759 505 26 and and CC 42759 505 27 of of IN 42759 505 28 the the DT 42759 505 29 inviolability inviolability NN 42759 505 30 of of IN 42759 505 31 property property NN 42759 505 32 , , , 42759 505 33 would would MD 42759 505 34 be be VB 42759 505 35 greatly greatly RB 42759 505 36 weakened weaken VBN 42759 505 37 , , , 42759 505 38 if if IN 42759 505 39 not not RB 42759 505 40 entirely entirely RB 42759 505 41 destroyed destroy VBN 42759 505 42 . . . 42759 506 1 The the DT 42759 506 2 average average JJ 42759 506 3 man man NN 42759 506 4 would would MD 42759 506 5 not not RB 42759 506 6 grasp grasp VB 42759 506 7 or or CC 42759 506 8 seriously seriously RB 42759 506 9 consider consider VB 42759 506 10 the the DT 42759 506 11 Georgean georgean JJ 42759 506 12 distinction distinction NN 42759 506 13 between between IN 42759 506 14 land land NN 42759 506 15 and and CC 42759 506 16 other other JJ 42759 506 17 kinds kind NNS 42759 506 18 of of IN 42759 506 19 property property NN 42759 506 20 in in IN 42759 506 21 this this DT 42759 506 22 connection connection NN 42759 506 23 . . . 42759 507 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 507 2 would would MD 42759 507 3 infer infer VB 42759 507 4 that that DT 42759 507 5 purchase purchase NN 42759 507 6 , , , 42759 507 7 or or CC 42759 507 8 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 507 9 , , , 42759 507 10 or or CC 42759 507 11 bequest bequest NNP 42759 507 12 , , , 42759 507 13 or or CC 42759 507 14 any any DT 42759 507 15 other other JJ 42759 507 16 title title NN 42759 507 17 having have VBG 42759 507 18 the the DT 42759 507 19 immemorial immemorial JJ 42759 507 20 sanction sanction NN 42759 507 21 of of IN 42759 507 22 the the DT 42759 507 23 State State NNP 42759 507 24 , , , 42759 507 25 does do VBZ 42759 507 26 not not RB 42759 507 27 create create VB 42759 507 28 a a DT 42759 507 29 moral moral JJ 42759 507 30 right right NN 42759 507 31 to to IN 42759 507 32 movable movable JJ 42759 507 33 goods good NNS 42759 507 34 any any DT 42759 507 35 more more RBR 42759 507 36 than than IN 42759 507 37 to to IN 42759 507 38 land land NN 42759 507 39 . . . 42759 508 1 This this DT 42759 508 2 would would MD 42759 508 3 be be VB 42759 508 4 especially especially RB 42759 508 5 likely likely JJ 42759 508 6 in in IN 42759 508 7 the the DT 42759 508 8 matter matter NN 42759 508 9 of of IN 42759 508 10 capital capital NN 42759 508 11 . . . 42759 509 1 Why why WRB 42759 509 2 should should MD 42759 509 3 the the DT 42759 509 4 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 509 5 , , , 42759 509 6 who who WP 42759 509 7 is be VBZ 42759 509 8 no no DT 42759 509 9 more more JJR 42759 509 10 a a DT 42759 509 11 worker worker NN 42759 509 12 than than IN 42759 509 13 the the DT 42759 509 14 landowner landowner NN 42759 509 15 , , , 42759 509 16 be be VB 42759 509 17 permitted permit VBN 42759 509 18 to to TO 42759 509 19 extract extract VB 42759 509 20 revenue revenue NN 42759 509 21 from from IN 42759 509 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 509 23 possessions possession NNS 42759 509 24 ? ? . 42759 510 1 In in IN 42759 510 2 both both DT 42759 510 3 cases case NNS 42759 510 4 the the DT 42759 510 5 most most RBS 42759 510 6 significant significant JJ 42759 510 7 and and CC 42759 510 8 practical practical JJ 42759 510 9 feature feature NN 42759 510 10 is be VBZ 42759 510 11 that that IN 42759 510 12 one one CD 42759 510 13 class class NN 42759 510 14 of of IN 42759 510 15 men man NNS 42759 510 16 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 510 17 to to IN 42759 510 18 another another DT 42759 510 19 class class NN 42759 510 20 an an DT 42759 510 21 annual annual JJ 42759 510 22 payment payment NN 42759 510 23 for for IN 42759 510 24 the the DT 42759 510 25 use use NN 42759 510 26 of of IN 42759 510 27 socially socially RB 42759 510 28 necessary necessary JJ 42759 510 29 productive productive JJ 42759 510 30 goods good NNS 42759 510 31 . . . 42759 511 1 If if IN 42759 511 2 rent rent NN 42759 511 3 - - HYPH 42759 511 4 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 511 5 would would MD 42759 511 6 benefit benefit VB 42759 511 7 a a DT 42759 511 8 large large JJ 42759 511 9 number number NN 42759 511 10 of of IN 42759 511 11 people people NNS 42759 511 12 , , , 42759 511 13 why why WRB 42759 511 14 not not RB 42759 511 15 increase increase VB 42759 511 16 the the DT 42759 511 17 number number NN 42759 511 18 by by IN 42759 511 19 confiscating confiscate VBG 42759 511 20 interest interest NN 42759 511 21 ? ? . 42759 512 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 512 2 , , , 42759 512 3 the the DT 42759 512 4 proposal proposal NN 42759 512 5 to to TO 42759 512 6 confiscate confiscate VB 42759 512 7 rent rent NN 42759 512 8 is be VBZ 42759 512 9 so so RB 42759 512 10 abhorrent abhorrent JJ 42759 512 11 to to IN 42759 512 12 the the DT 42759 512 13 moral moral JJ 42759 512 14 sense sense NN 42759 512 15 of of IN 42759 512 16 the the DT 42759 512 17 average average JJ 42759 512 18 man man NN 42759 512 19 that that IN 42759 512 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 512 21 could could MD 42759 512 22 never never RB 42759 512 23 take take VB 42759 512 24 place place NN 42759 512 25 except except IN 42759 512 26 in in IN 42759 512 27 conditions condition NNS 42759 512 28 of of IN 42759 512 29 revolution revolution NN 42759 512 30 and and CC 42759 512 31 anarchy anarchy NN 42759 512 32 . . . 42759 513 1 If if IN 42759 513 2 that that DT 42759 513 3 day day NN 42759 513 4 should should MD 42759 513 5 ever ever RB 42759 513 6 arrive arrive VB 42759 513 7 the the DT 42759 513 8 policy policy NN 42759 513 9 of of IN 42759 513 10 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 513 11 would would MD 42759 513 12 not not RB 42759 513 13 stop stop VB 42759 513 14 with with IN 42759 513 15 land land NN 42759 513 16 . . . 42759 514 1 _ _ NNP 42759 514 2 The the DT 42759 514 3 Alleged Alleged NNP 42759 514 4 Right Right NNP 42759 514 5 of of IN 42759 514 6 the the DT 42759 514 7 Community Community NNP 42759 514 8 to to IN 42759 514 9 Land Land NNP 42759 514 10 Values Values NNPS 42759 514 11 _ _ XX 42759 514 12 In in IN 42759 514 13 the the DT 42759 514 14 foregoing forego VBG 42759 514 15 pages page NNS 42759 514 16 we -PRON- PRP 42759 514 17 have have VBP 42759 514 18 confined confine VBN 42759 514 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 514 20 attention attention NN 42759 514 21 to to IN 42759 514 22 the the DT 42759 514 23 Georgean georgean JJ 42759 514 24 principle principle NN 42759 514 25 which which WDT 42759 514 26 bases base VBZ 42759 514 27 men man NNS 42759 514 28 's 's POS 42759 514 29 common common JJ 42759 514 30 right right NN 42759 514 31 to to IN 42759 514 32 land land NN 42759 514 33 and and CC 42759 514 34 rent rent VB 42759 514 35 upon upon IN 42759 514 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 514 37 common common JJ 42759 514 38 nature nature NN 42759 514 39 , , , 42759 514 40 and and CC 42759 514 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 514 42 common common JJ 42759 514 43 claims claim NNS 42759 514 44 to to IN 42759 514 45 the the DT 42759 514 46 material material JJ 42759 514 47 gifts gift NNS 42759 514 48 of of IN 42759 514 49 the the DT 42759 514 50 Creator Creator NNP 42759 514 51 . . . 42759 515 1 Another another DT 42759 515 2 argument argument NN 42759 515 3 against against IN 42759 515 4 private private JJ 42759 515 5 ownership ownership NN 42759 515 6 takes take VBZ 42759 515 7 this this DT 42759 515 8 form form NN 42759 515 9 : : : 42759 515 10 " " `` 42759 515 11 Consider consider VB 42759 515 12 what what WP 42759 515 13 rent rent NN 42759 515 14 is be VBZ 42759 515 15 . . . 42759 516 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 516 2 does do VBZ 42759 516 3 not not RB 42759 516 4 arise arise VB 42759 516 5 spontaneously spontaneously RB 42759 516 6 from from IN 42759 516 7 the the DT 42759 516 8 soil soil NN 42759 516 9 ; ; : 42759 516 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 516 11 is be VBZ 42759 516 12 due due JJ 42759 516 13 to to IN 42759 516 14 nothing nothing NN 42759 516 15 that that IN 42759 516 16 the the DT 42759 516 17 landowners landowner NNS 42759 516 18 have have VBP 42759 516 19 done do VBN 42759 516 20 . . . 42759 517 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 517 2 represents represent VBZ 42759 517 3 a a DT 42759 517 4 value value NN 42759 517 5 created create VBN 42759 517 6 by by IN 42759 517 7 the the DT 42759 517 8 whole whole JJ 42759 517 9 community community NN 42759 517 10 .... .... . 42759 518 1 But but CC 42759 518 2 rent rent VB 42759 518 3 , , , 42759 518 4 the the DT 42759 518 5 creation creation NN 42759 518 6 of of IN 42759 518 7 the the DT 42759 518 8 whole whole JJ 42759 518 9 community community NN 42759 518 10 , , , 42759 518 11 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 518 12 belongs belong VBZ 42759 518 13 to to IN 42759 518 14 the the DT 42759 518 15 whole whole JJ 42759 518 16 community community NN 42759 518 17 . . . 42759 519 1 " " `` 42759 519 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 519 3 26 26 CD 42759 519 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 519 5 Before before IN 42759 519 6 taking take VBG 42759 519 7 up up RP 42759 519 8 the the DT 42759 519 9 main main JJ 42759 519 10 contention contention NN 42759 519 11 in in IN 42759 519 12 this this DT 42759 519 13 passage passage NN 42759 519 14 , , , 42759 519 15 let let VB 42759 519 16 us -PRON- PRP 42759 519 17 notice notice VB 42759 519 18 two two CD 42759 519 19 incidental incidental JJ 42759 519 20 points point NNS 42759 519 21 . . . 42759 520 1 If if IN 42759 520 2 all all DT 42759 520 3 rent rent NN 42759 520 4 be be VB 42759 520 5 due due IN 42759 520 6 to to IN 42759 520 7 the the DT 42759 520 8 community community NN 42759 520 9 by by IN 42759 520 10 the the DT 42759 520 11 title title NN 42759 520 12 of of IN 42759 520 13 social social JJ 42759 520 14 production production NN 42759 520 15 , , , 42759 520 16 why why WRB 42759 520 17 does do VBZ 42759 520 18 Henry Henry NNP 42759 520 19 George George NNP 42759 520 20 defend defend VB 42759 520 21 at at IN 42759 520 22 such such JJ 42759 520 23 length length NN 42759 520 24 the the DT 42759 520 25 title title NN 42759 520 26 of of IN 42759 520 27 birthright birthright NN 42759 520 28 ? ? . 42759 521 1 If if IN 42759 521 2 the the DT 42759 521 3 latter latter JJ 42759 521 4 title title NN 42759 521 5 does do VBZ 42759 521 6 not not RB 42759 521 7 extend extend VB 42759 521 8 to to TO 42759 521 9 rent rent VB 42759 521 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 521 11 is be VBZ 42759 521 12 restricted restrict VBN 42759 521 13 to to TO 42759 521 14 land land NN 42759 521 15 which which WDT 42759 521 16 is be VBZ 42759 521 17 so so RB 42759 521 18 plentiful plentiful JJ 42759 521 19 as as IN 42759 521 20 to to TO 42759 521 21 yield yield VB 42759 521 22 no no DT 42759 521 23 rent rent NN 42759 521 24 . . . 42759 522 1 Since since IN 42759 522 2 the the DT 42759 522 3 owners owner NNS 42759 522 4 or or CC 42759 522 5 holders holder NNS 42759 522 6 of of IN 42759 522 7 such such JJ 42759 522 8 land land NN 42759 522 9 rarely rarely RB 42759 522 10 take take VBP 42759 522 11 the the DT 42759 522 12 trouble trouble NN 42759 522 13 to to TO 42759 522 14 exclude exclude VB 42759 522 15 any any DT 42759 522 16 one one NN 42759 522 17 from from IN 42759 522 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 522 19 , , , 42759 522 20 the the DT 42759 522 21 right right NN 42759 522 22 in in IN 42759 522 23 question question NN 42759 522 24 , , , 42759 522 25 the the DT 42759 522 26 inborn inborn NN 42759 522 27 right right NN 42759 522 28 , , , 42759 522 29 has have VBZ 42759 522 30 not not RB 42759 522 31 much much JJ 42759 522 32 practical practical JJ 42759 522 33 value value NN 42759 522 34 . . . 42759 523 1 Probably probably RB 42759 523 2 , , , 42759 523 3 however however RB 42759 523 4 , , , 42759 523 5 the the DT 42759 523 6 words word NNS 42759 523 7 quoted quote VBN 42759 523 8 above above RB 42759 523 9 ought ought MD 42759 523 10 not not RB 42759 523 11 to to TO 42759 523 12 be be VB 42759 523 13 interpreted interpret VBN 42759 523 14 as as IN 42759 523 15 excluding exclude VBG 42759 523 16 the the DT 42759 523 17 title title NN 42759 523 18 of of IN 42759 523 19 birthright birthright NN 42759 523 20 . . . 42759 524 1 In in IN 42759 524 2 that that DT 42759 524 3 case case NN 42759 524 4 , , , 42759 524 5 the the DT 42759 524 6 meaning meaning NN 42759 524 7 would would MD 42759 524 8 be be VB 42759 524 9 that that IN 42759 524 10 rent rent NN 42759 524 11 belongs belong VBZ 42759 524 12 to to IN 42759 524 13 the the DT 42759 524 14 community community NN 42759 524 15 by by IN 42759 524 16 the the DT 42759 524 17 title title NN 42759 524 18 of of IN 42759 524 19 production production NN 42759 524 20 , , , 42759 524 21 as as RB 42759 524 22 well well RB 42759 524 23 as as IN 42759 524 24 by by IN 42759 524 25 the the DT 42759 524 26 congenital congenital JJ 42759 524 27 title title NN 42759 524 28 . . . 42759 525 1 The the DT 42759 525 2 second second JJ 42759 525 3 preliminary preliminary JJ 42759 525 4 consideration consideration NN 42759 525 5 is be VBZ 42759 525 6 that that IN 42759 525 7 the the DT 42759 525 8 community community NN 42759 525 9 does do VBZ 42759 525 10 not not RB 42759 525 11 create create VB 42759 525 12 _ _ NNP 42759 525 13 all all DT 42759 525 14 _ _ NNP 42759 525 15 land land NN 42759 525 16 values value NNS 42759 525 17 nor nor CC 42759 525 18 _ _ NNP 42759 525 19 all all DT 42759 525 20 _ _ NNP 42759 525 21 rent rent NN 42759 525 22 . . . 42759 526 1 These these DT 42759 526 2 things thing NNS 42759 526 3 are be VBP 42759 526 4 as as RB 42759 526 5 certainly certainly RB 42759 526 6 due due JJ 42759 526 7 to to IN 42759 526 8 nature nature NN 42759 526 9 as as IN 42759 526 10 to to IN 42759 526 11 social social JJ 42759 526 12 action action NN 42759 526 13 . . . 42759 527 1 In in IN 42759 527 2 no no DT 42759 527 3 case case NN 42759 527 4 can can MD 42759 527 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 527 6 be be VB 42759 527 7 attributed attribute VBN 42759 527 8 exclusively exclusively RB 42759 527 9 to to IN 42759 527 10 one one CD 42759 527 11 factor factor NN 42759 527 12 . . . 42759 528 1 Land land NN 42759 528 2 that that WDT 42759 528 3 has have VBZ 42759 528 4 no no DT 42759 528 5 natural natural JJ 42759 528 6 qualities quality NNS 42759 528 7 or or CC 42759 528 8 capacities capacity NNS 42759 528 9 suitable suitable JJ 42759 528 10 for for IN 42759 528 11 the the DT 42759 528 12 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 528 13 of of IN 42759 528 14 human human JJ 42759 528 15 wants want NNS 42759 528 16 will will MD 42759 528 17 never never RB 42759 528 18 have have VB 42759 528 19 value value NN 42759 528 20 or or CC 42759 528 21 yield yield VB 42759 528 22 rent rent NN 42759 528 23 , , , 42759 528 24 no no RB 42759 528 25 matter matter RB 42759 528 26 what what WDT 42759 528 27 society society NN 42759 528 28 does do VBZ 42759 528 29 in in IN 42759 528 30 connection connection NN 42759 528 31 with with IN 42759 528 32 it -PRON- PRP 42759 528 33 : : : 42759 528 34 the the DT 42759 528 35 richest rich JJS 42759 528 36 land land NN 42759 528 37 in in IN 42759 528 38 the the DT 42759 528 39 world world NN 42759 528 40 will will MD 42759 528 41 likewise likewise RB 42759 528 42 remain remain VB 42759 528 43 valueless valueless NN 42759 528 44 , , , 42759 528 45 until until IN 42759 528 46 it -PRON- PRP 42759 528 47 is be VBZ 42759 528 48 brought bring VBN 42759 528 49 into into IN 42759 528 50 relation relation NN 42759 528 51 with with IN 42759 528 52 society society NN 42759 528 53 , , , 42759 528 54 with with IN 42759 528 55 at at RB 42759 528 56 least least RBS 42759 528 57 two two CD 42759 528 58 human human JJ 42759 528 59 beings being NNS 42759 528 60 . . . 42759 529 1 If if IN 42759 529 2 Henry Henry NNP 42759 529 3 George George NNP 42759 529 4 merely merely RB 42759 529 5 means mean VBZ 42759 529 6 to to TO 42759 529 7 say say VB 42759 529 8 that that IN 42759 529 9 , , , 42759 529 10 without without IN 42759 529 11 the the DT 42759 529 12 presence presence NN 42759 529 13 of of IN 42759 529 14 the the DT 42759 529 15 community community NN 42759 529 16 , , , 42759 529 17 land land NN 42759 529 18 will will MD 42759 529 19 not not RB 42759 529 20 produce produce VB 42759 529 21 rent rent NN 42759 529 22 , , , 42759 529 23 he -PRON- PRP 42759 529 24 is be VBZ 42759 529 25 stating state VBG 42759 529 26 something something NN 42759 529 27 that that WDT 42759 529 28 is be VBZ 42759 529 29 perfectly perfectly RB 42759 529 30 obvious obvious JJ 42759 529 31 , , , 42759 529 32 but but CC 42759 529 33 it -PRON- PRP 42759 529 34 is be VBZ 42759 529 35 not not RB 42759 529 36 peculiar peculiar JJ 42759 529 37 to to TO 42759 529 38 land land NN 42759 529 39 . . . 42759 530 1 Manufactured manufactured JJ 42759 530 2 products product NNS 42759 530 3 would would MD 42759 530 4 have have VB 42759 530 5 no no DT 42759 530 6 value value NN 42759 530 7 outside outside IN 42759 530 8 of of IN 42759 530 9 society society NN 42759 530 10 , , , 42759 530 11 yet yet CC 42759 530 12 no no DT 42759 530 13 one one NN 42759 530 14 maintains maintain VBZ 42759 530 15 that that IN 42759 530 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 530 17 value value NN 42759 530 18 is be VBZ 42759 530 19 all all RB 42759 530 20 created create VBN 42759 530 21 by by IN 42759 530 22 social social JJ 42759 530 23 action action NN 42759 530 24 . . . 42759 531 1 Although although IN 42759 531 2 the the DT 42759 531 3 value value NN 42759 531 4 of of IN 42759 531 5 land land NN 42759 531 6 is be VBZ 42759 531 7 always always RB 42759 531 8 due due JJ 42759 531 9 to to IN 42759 531 10 both both DT 42759 531 11 nature nature NN 42759 531 12 and and CC 42759 531 13 society society NN 42759 531 14 , , , 42759 531 15 for for IN 42759 531 16 practical practical JJ 42759 531 17 purposes purpose NNS 42759 531 18 we -PRON- PRP 42759 531 19 may may MD 42759 531 20 correctly correctly RB 42759 531 21 attribute attribute VB 42759 531 22 the the DT 42759 531 23 value value NN 42759 531 24 of of IN 42759 531 25 a a DT 42759 531 26 particular particular JJ 42759 531 27 piece piece NN 42759 531 28 of of IN 42759 531 29 land land NN 42759 531 30 predominantly predominantly RB 42759 531 31 to to IN 42759 531 32 nature nature NN 42759 531 33 , , , 42759 531 34 or or CC 42759 531 35 predominantly predominantly RB 42759 531 36 to to IN 42759 531 37 society society NN 42759 531 38 . . . 42759 532 1 When when WRB 42759 532 2 three three CD 42759 532 3 tracts tract NNS 42759 532 4 , , , 42759 532 5 equally equally RB 42759 532 6 distant distant JJ 42759 532 7 from from IN 42759 532 8 a a DT 42759 532 9 city city NN 42759 532 10 , , , 42759 532 11 and and CC 42759 532 12 equally equally RB 42759 532 13 affected affect VBN 42759 532 14 by by IN 42759 532 15 society society NN 42759 532 16 and and CC 42759 532 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 532 18 activities activity NNS 42759 532 19 , , , 42759 532 20 have have VBP 42759 532 21 different different JJ 42759 532 22 values value NNS 42759 532 23 because because IN 42759 532 24 one one CD 42759 532 25 is be VBZ 42759 532 26 fit fit JJ 42759 532 27 only only RB 42759 532 28 for for IN 42759 532 29 grazing grazing NN 42759 532 30 , , , 42759 532 31 while while IN 42759 532 32 the the DT 42759 532 33 second second JJ 42759 532 34 produces produce VBZ 42759 532 35 large large JJ 42759 532 36 crops crop NNS 42759 532 37 of of IN 42759 532 38 wheat wheat NN 42759 532 39 , , , 42759 532 40 and and CC 42759 532 41 the the DT 42759 532 42 third third JJ 42759 532 43 contains contain VBZ 42759 532 44 a a DT 42759 532 45 rich rich JJ 42759 532 46 coal coal NN 42759 532 47 mine mine NN 42759 532 48 , , , 42759 532 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 532 50 relative relative JJ 42759 532 51 values value NNS 42759 532 52 are be VBP 42759 532 53 evidently evidently RB 42759 532 54 due due JJ 42759 532 55 to to IN 42759 532 56 nature nature NN 42759 532 57 rather rather RB 42759 532 58 than than IN 42759 532 59 to to IN 42759 532 60 society society NN 42759 532 61 . . . 42759 533 1 On on IN 42759 533 2 the the DT 42759 533 3 other other JJ 42759 533 4 hand hand NN 42759 533 5 , , , 42759 533 6 the the DT 42759 533 7 varying vary VBG 42759 533 8 values value NNS 42759 533 9 of of IN 42759 533 10 two two CD 42759 533 11 equally equally RB 42759 533 12 fertile fertile JJ 42759 533 13 pieces piece NNS 42759 533 14 of of IN 42759 533 15 land land NN 42759 533 16 unequally unequally RB 42759 533 17 distant distant JJ 42759 533 18 from from IN 42759 533 19 a a DT 42759 533 20 city city NN 42759 533 21 , , , 42759 533 22 must must MD 42759 533 23 be be VB 42759 533 24 ascribed ascribe VBN 42759 533 25 primarily primarily RB 42759 533 26 to to IN 42759 533 27 social social JJ 42759 533 28 action action NN 42759 533 29 . . . 42759 534 1 In in IN 42759 534 2 general general JJ 42759 534 3 , , , 42759 534 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 534 5 is be VBZ 42759 534 6 probably probably RB 42759 534 7 safe safe JJ 42759 534 8 to to TO 42759 534 9 say say VB 42759 534 10 that that IN 42759 534 11 almost almost RB 42759 534 12 all all PDT 42759 534 13 the the DT 42759 534 14 value value NN 42759 534 15 of of IN 42759 534 16 land land NN 42759 534 17 in in IN 42759 534 18 cities city NNS 42759 534 19 , , , 42759 534 20 and and CC 42759 534 21 the the DT 42759 534 22 greater great JJR 42759 534 23 part part NN 42759 534 24 of of IN 42759 534 25 the the DT 42759 534 26 value value NN 42759 534 27 of of IN 42759 534 28 land land NN 42759 534 29 in in IN 42759 534 30 thickly thickly JJ 42759 534 31 settled settle VBN 42759 534 32 districts district NNS 42759 534 33 , , , 42759 534 34 is be VBZ 42759 534 35 specifically specifically RB 42759 534 36 due due JJ 42759 534 37 to to IN 42759 534 38 social social JJ 42759 534 39 action action NN 42759 534 40 rather rather RB 42759 534 41 than than IN 42759 534 42 to to IN 42759 534 43 differences difference NNS 42759 534 44 in in IN 42759 534 45 fertility fertility NN 42759 534 46 . . . 42759 535 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 535 2 , , , 42759 535 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 535 4 remains remain VBZ 42759 535 5 true true JJ 42759 535 6 that that IN 42759 535 7 the the DT 42759 535 8 value value NN 42759 535 9 of of IN 42759 535 10 every every DT 42759 535 11 piece piece NN 42759 535 12 of of IN 42759 535 13 land land NN 42759 535 14 arises arise VBZ 42759 535 15 partly partly RB 42759 535 16 from from IN 42759 535 17 nature nature NN 42759 535 18 , , , 42759 535 19 and and CC 42759 535 20 partly partly RB 42759 535 21 from from IN 42759 535 22 society society NN 42759 535 23 ; ; : 42759 535 24 but but CC 42759 535 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 535 26 is be VBZ 42759 535 27 impossible impossible JJ 42759 535 28 to to TO 42759 535 29 say say VB 42759 535 30 in in IN 42759 535 31 what what WDT 42759 535 32 proportion proportion NN 42759 535 33 . . . 42759 536 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 536 2 present present JJ 42759 536 3 concern concern NN 42759 536 4 is be VBZ 42759 536 5 with with IN 42759 536 6 those those DT 42759 536 7 values value NNS 42759 536 8 and and CC 42759 536 9 rents rent NNS 42759 536 10 which which WDT 42759 536 11 are be VBP 42759 536 12 to to TO 42759 536 13 be be VB 42759 536 14 attributed attribute VBN 42759 536 15 to to IN 42759 536 16 social social JJ 42759 536 17 action action NN 42759 536 18 . . . 42759 537 1 These these DT 42759 537 2 can can MD 42759 537 3 not not RB 42759 537 4 be be VB 42759 537 5 claimed claim VBN 42759 537 6 by by IN 42759 537 7 any any DT 42759 537 8 person person NN 42759 537 9 , , , 42759 537 10 nor nor CC 42759 537 11 by by IN 42759 537 12 any any DT 42759 537 13 community community NN 42759 537 14 , , , 42759 537 15 in in IN 42759 537 16 virtue virtue NN 42759 537 17 of of IN 42759 537 18 the the DT 42759 537 19 individual individual NN 42759 537 20 's 's POS 42759 537 21 natural natural JJ 42759 537 22 right right NN 42759 537 23 to to IN 42759 537 24 the the DT 42759 537 25 bounty bounty NN 42759 537 26 of of IN 42759 537 27 nature nature NN 42759 537 28 . . . 42759 538 1 Since since IN 42759 538 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 538 3 are be VBP 42759 538 4 not not RB 42759 538 5 included include VBN 42759 538 6 among among IN 42759 538 7 the the DT 42759 538 8 ready ready JJ 42759 538 9 made make VBD 42759 538 10 gifts gift NNS 42759 538 11 of of IN 42759 538 12 God God NNP 42759 538 13 , , , 42759 538 14 they -PRON- PRP 42759 538 15 are be VBP 42759 538 16 no no DT 42759 538 17 part part NN 42759 538 18 of of IN 42759 538 19 man man NN 42759 538 20 's 's POS 42759 538 21 birthright birthright NN 42759 538 22 . . . 42759 539 1 If if IN 42759 539 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 539 3 belong belong VBP 42759 539 4 to to IN 42759 539 5 all all PDT 42759 539 6 the the DT 42759 539 7 people people NNS 42759 539 8 the the DT 42759 539 9 title title NN 42759 539 10 to to IN 42759 539 11 them -PRON- PRP 42759 539 12 must must MD 42759 539 13 be be VB 42759 539 14 sought seek VBN 42759 539 15 in in IN 42759 539 16 some some DT 42759 539 17 historical historical JJ 42759 539 18 fact fact NN 42759 539 19 , , , 42759 539 20 some some DT 42759 539 21 fact fact NN 42759 539 22 of of IN 42759 539 23 experience experience NN 42759 539 24 , , , 42759 539 25 some some DT 42759 539 26 social social JJ 42759 539 27 fact fact NN 42759 539 28 . . . 42759 540 1 According accord VBG 42759 540 2 to to IN 42759 540 3 Henry Henry NNP 42759 540 4 George George NNP 42759 540 5 , , , 42759 540 6 the the DT 42759 540 7 required require VBN 42759 540 8 title title NN 42759 540 9 is be VBZ 42759 540 10 found find VBN 42759 540 11 in in IN 42759 540 12 the the DT 42759 540 13 fact fact NN 42759 540 14 of of IN 42759 540 15 production production NN 42759 540 16 . . . 42759 541 1 Socially socially RB 42759 541 2 created create VBN 42759 541 3 land land NN 42759 541 4 values value NNS 42759 541 5 and and CC 42759 541 6 rents rent NNS 42759 541 7 belong belong VBP 42759 541 8 to to IN 42759 541 9 the the DT 42759 541 10 community community NN 42759 541 11 because because IN 42759 541 12 the the DT 42759 541 13 community community NN 42759 541 14 , , , 42759 541 15 not not RB 42759 541 16 the the DT 42759 541 17 private private JJ 42759 541 18 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 541 19 , , , 42759 541 20 has have VBZ 42759 541 21 produced produce VBN 42759 541 22 them -PRON- PRP 42759 541 23 . . . 42759 542 1 Let let VB 42759 542 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 542 3 see see VB 42759 542 4 in in IN 42759 542 5 what what WDT 42759 542 6 sense sense NN 42759 542 7 the the DT 42759 542 8 community community NN 42759 542 9 produces produce VBZ 42759 542 10 the the DT 42759 542 11 social social JJ 42759 542 12 value value NN 42759 542 13 of of IN 42759 542 14 land land NN 42759 542 15 . . . 42759 543 1 In in IN 42759 543 2 the the DT 42759 543 3 first first JJ 42759 543 4 place place NN 42759 543 5 , , , 42759 543 6 this this DT 42759 543 7 value value NN 42759 543 8 is be VBZ 42759 543 9 produced produce VBN 42759 543 10 by by IN 42759 543 11 the the DT 42759 543 12 community community NN 42759 543 13 in in IN 42759 543 14 two two CD 42759 543 15 different different JJ 42759 543 16 senses sense NNS 42759 543 17 of of IN 42759 543 18 the the DT 42759 543 19 word word NN 42759 543 20 community community NN 42759 543 21 , , , 42759 543 22 namely namely RB 42759 543 23 , , , 42759 543 24 as as IN 42759 543 25 a a DT 42759 543 26 civil civil JJ 42759 543 27 , , , 42759 543 28 corporate corporate JJ 42759 543 29 entity entity NN 42759 543 30 , , , 42759 543 31 and and CC 42759 543 32 as as IN 42759 543 33 a a DT 42759 543 34 group group NN 42759 543 35 of of IN 42759 543 36 individuals individual NNS 42759 543 37 who who WP 42759 543 38 do do VBP 42759 543 39 not not RB 42759 543 40 form form VB 42759 543 41 a a DT 42759 543 42 moral moral JJ 42759 543 43 unit unit NN 42759 543 44 . . . 42759 544 1 Under under IN 42759 544 2 the the DT 42759 544 3 first first JJ 42759 544 4 head head NN 42759 544 5 must must MD 42759 544 6 be be VB 42759 544 7 placed place VBN 42759 544 8 a a DT 42759 544 9 great great JJ 42759 544 10 deal deal NN 42759 544 11 of of IN 42759 544 12 the the DT 42759 544 13 value value NN 42759 544 14 of of IN 42759 544 15 land land NN 42759 544 16 in in IN 42759 544 17 cities city NNS 42759 544 18 ; ; : 42759 544 19 for for IN 42759 544 20 example example NN 42759 544 21 , , , 42759 544 22 that that WDT 42759 544 23 which which WDT 42759 544 24 arises arise VBZ 42759 544 25 from from IN 42759 544 26 municipal municipal JJ 42759 544 27 institutions institution NNS 42759 544 28 and and CC 42759 544 29 improvements improvement NNS 42759 544 30 , , , 42759 544 31 such such JJ 42759 544 32 as as IN 42759 544 33 , , , 42759 544 34 fire fire NN 42759 544 35 and and CC 42759 544 36 police police NN 42759 544 37 protection protection NN 42759 544 38 , , , 42759 544 39 water water NN 42759 544 40 works work NNS 42759 544 41 , , , 42759 544 42 sewers sewer NNS 42759 544 43 , , , 42759 544 44 paved paved JJ 42759 544 45 streets street NNS 42759 544 46 , , , 42759 544 47 and and CC 42759 544 48 parks park NNS 42759 544 49 . . . 42759 545 1 On on IN 42759 545 2 the the DT 42759 545 3 other other JJ 42759 545 4 hand hand NN 42759 545 5 , , , 42759 545 6 a a DT 42759 545 7 considerable considerable JJ 42759 545 8 part part NN 42759 545 9 of of IN 42759 545 10 land land NN 42759 545 11 values value NNS 42759 545 12 both both CC 42759 545 13 within within IN 42759 545 14 and and CC 42759 545 15 without without IN 42759 545 16 cities city NNS 42759 545 17 is be VBZ 42759 545 18 due due JJ 42759 545 19 , , , 42759 545 20 not not RB 42759 545 21 to to IN 42759 545 22 the the DT 42759 545 23 community community NN 42759 545 24 as as IN 42759 545 25 a a DT 42759 545 26 civil civil JJ 42759 545 27 body body NN 42759 545 28 , , , 42759 545 29 but but CC 42759 545 30 to to IN 42759 545 31 the the DT 42759 545 32 community community NN 42759 545 33 as as IN 42759 545 34 a a DT 42759 545 35 collection collection NN 42759 545 36 of of IN 42759 545 37 individuals individual NNS 42759 545 38 and and CC 42759 545 39 groups group NNS 42759 545 40 of of IN 42759 545 41 individuals individual NNS 42759 545 42 . . . 42759 546 1 Thus thus RB 42759 546 2 , , , 42759 546 3 the the DT 42759 546 4 erection erection NN 42759 546 5 and and CC 42759 546 6 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 546 7 of of IN 42759 546 8 buildings building NNS 42759 546 9 , , , 42759 546 10 the the DT 42759 546 11 various various JJ 42759 546 12 economic economic JJ 42759 546 13 exchanges exchange NNS 42759 546 14 of of IN 42759 546 15 goods good NNS 42759 546 16 and and CC 42759 546 17 labour labour NN 42759 546 18 , , , 42759 546 19 the the DT 42759 546 20 superior superior JJ 42759 546 21 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 546 22 for for IN 42759 546 23 social social JJ 42759 546 24 intercourse intercourse NN 42759 546 25 and and CC 42759 546 26 amusement amusement NN 42759 546 27 which which WDT 42759 546 28 characterise characterise VBP 42759 546 29 a a DT 42759 546 30 city city NN 42759 546 31 , , , 42759 546 32 make make VB 42759 546 33 the the DT 42759 546 34 land land NN 42759 546 35 of of IN 42759 546 36 the the DT 42759 546 37 city city NN 42759 546 38 and and CC 42759 546 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 546 40 environs environ NNS 42759 546 41 more more RBR 42759 546 42 valuable valuable JJ 42759 546 43 than than IN 42759 546 44 land land NN 42759 546 45 at at IN 42759 546 46 a a DT 42759 546 47 distance distance NN 42759 546 48 . . . 42759 547 1 While while IN 42759 547 2 the the DT 42759 547 3 activities activity NNS 42759 547 4 involved involve VBN 42759 547 5 in in IN 42759 547 6 these these DT 42759 547 7 economic economic JJ 42759 547 8 and and CC 42759 547 9 " " `` 42759 547 10 social social JJ 42759 547 11 " " '' 42759 547 12 facts fact NNS 42759 547 13 and and CC 42759 547 14 relations relation NNS 42759 547 15 are be VBP 42759 547 16 , , , 42759 547 17 indeed indeed RB 42759 547 18 , , , 42759 547 19 a a DT 42759 547 20 social social NN 42759 547 21 not not RB 42759 547 22 an an DT 42759 547 23 individual individual JJ 42759 547 24 product product NN 42759 547 25 , , , 42759 547 26 they -PRON- PRP 42759 547 27 are be VBP 42759 547 28 the the DT 42759 547 29 product product NN 42759 547 30 of of IN 42759 547 31 small small JJ 42759 547 32 , , , 42759 547 33 temporary temporary JJ 42759 547 34 , , , 42759 547 35 and and CC 42759 547 36 shifting shift VBG 42759 547 37 groups group NNS 42759 547 38 within within IN 42759 547 39 the the DT 42759 547 40 community community NN 42759 547 41 . . . 42759 548 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 548 2 are be VBP 42759 548 3 not not RB 42759 548 4 the the DT 42759 548 5 activities activity NNS 42759 548 6 of of IN 42759 548 7 the the DT 42759 548 8 community community NN 42759 548 9 as as IN 42759 548 10 a a DT 42759 548 11 moral moral JJ 42759 548 12 whole whole NN 42759 548 13 . . . 42759 549 1 For for IN 42759 549 2 example example NN 42759 549 3 , , , 42759 549 4 the the DT 42759 549 5 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 549 6 of of IN 42759 549 7 a a DT 42759 549 8 grocery grocery NN 42759 549 9 business business NN 42759 549 10 implies imply VBZ 42759 549 11 a a DT 42759 549 12 series series NN 42759 549 13 of of IN 42759 549 14 social social JJ 42759 549 15 relations relation NNS 42759 549 16 and and CC 42759 549 17 agreements agreement NNS 42759 549 18 between between IN 42759 549 19 the the DT 42759 549 20 grocer grocer NN 42759 549 21 and and CC 42759 549 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 549 23 customers customer NNS 42759 549 24 ; ; : 42759 549 25 but but CC 42759 549 26 none none NN 42759 549 27 of of IN 42759 549 28 these these DT 42759 549 29 transactions transaction NNS 42759 549 30 is be VBZ 42759 549 31 participated participate VBN 42759 549 32 in in RP 42759 549 33 by by IN 42759 549 34 the the DT 42759 549 35 community community NN 42759 549 36 acting act VBG 42759 549 37 as as IN 42759 549 38 a a DT 42759 549 39 community community NN 42759 549 40 . . . 42759 550 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 550 2 such such JJ 42759 550 3 actions action NNS 42759 550 4 and and CC 42759 550 5 relations relation NNS 42759 550 6 , , , 42759 550 7 and and CC 42759 550 8 the the DT 42759 550 9 land land NN 42759 550 10 values value NNS 42759 550 11 to to TO 42759 550 12 which which WDT 42759 550 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 550 14 give give VBP 42759 550 15 rise rise NN 42759 550 16 are be VBP 42759 550 17 not not RB 42759 550 18 due due JJ 42759 550 19 to to IN 42759 550 20 , , , 42759 550 21 are be VBP 42759 550 22 not not RB 42759 550 23 the the DT 42759 550 24 products product NNS 42759 550 25 of of IN 42759 550 26 the the DT 42759 550 27 community community NN 42759 550 28 as as IN 42759 550 29 a a DT 42759 550 30 unit unit NN 42759 550 31 , , , 42759 550 32 as as IN 42759 550 33 a a DT 42759 550 34 moral moral JJ 42759 550 35 body body NN 42759 550 36 , , , 42759 550 37 as as IN 42759 550 38 an an DT 42759 550 39 organic organic JJ 42759 550 40 entity entity NN 42759 550 41 . . . 42759 551 1 What what WP 42759 551 2 is be VBZ 42759 551 3 true true JJ 42759 551 4 of of IN 42759 551 5 the the DT 42759 551 6 land land NN 42759 551 7 values value NNS 42759 551 8 created create VBN 42759 551 9 by by IN 42759 551 10 the the DT 42759 551 11 grocery grocery NN 42759 551 12 business business NN 42759 551 13 applies apply VBZ 42759 551 14 to to IN 42759 551 15 the the DT 42759 551 16 values value NNS 42759 551 17 which which WDT 42759 551 18 are be VBP 42759 551 19 due due JJ 42759 551 20 to to IN 42759 551 21 other other JJ 42759 551 22 economic economic JJ 42759 551 23 institutions institution NNS 42759 551 24 and and CC 42759 551 25 relations relation NNS 42759 551 26 , , , 42759 551 27 as as RB 42759 551 28 well well RB 42759 551 29 as as IN 42759 551 30 to to IN 42759 551 31 those those DT 42759 551 32 values value NNS 42759 551 33 which which WDT 42759 551 34 arise arise VBP 42759 551 35 out out IN 42759 551 36 of of IN 42759 551 37 the the DT 42759 551 38 purely purely RB 42759 551 39 " " `` 42759 551 40 social social JJ 42759 551 41 " " '' 42759 551 42 activities activity NNS 42759 551 43 and and CC 42759 551 44 advantages advantage NNS 42759 551 45 . . . 42759 552 1 If if IN 42759 552 2 these these DT 42759 552 3 values value NNS 42759 552 4 are be VBP 42759 552 5 to to TO 42759 552 6 go go VB 42759 552 7 to to IN 42759 552 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 552 9 producers producer NNS 42759 552 10 they -PRON- PRP 42759 552 11 must must MD 42759 552 12 be be VB 42759 552 13 taken take VBN 42759 552 14 , , , 42759 552 15 in in IN 42759 552 16 various various JJ 42759 552 17 proportions proportion NNS 42759 552 18 , , , 42759 552 19 by by IN 42759 552 20 the the DT 42759 552 21 different different JJ 42759 552 22 small small JJ 42759 552 23 groups group NNS 42759 552 24 and and CC 42759 552 25 the the DT 42759 552 26 various various JJ 42759 552 27 individuals individual NNS 42759 552 28 whose whose WP$ 42759 552 29 actions action NNS 42759 552 30 and and CC 42759 552 31 transactions transaction NNS 42759 552 32 have have VBP 42759 552 33 been be VBN 42759 552 34 directly directly RB 42759 552 35 responsible responsible JJ 42759 552 36 . . . 42759 553 1 To to TO 42759 553 2 distribute distribute VB 42759 553 3 these these DT 42759 553 4 values value NNS 42759 553 5 among among IN 42759 553 6 the the DT 42759 553 7 producers producer NNS 42759 553 8 thereof thereof VBP 42759 553 9 in in IN 42759 553 10 proportion proportion NN 42759 553 11 to to IN 42759 553 12 the the DT 42759 553 13 productive productive JJ 42759 553 14 contribution contribution NN 42759 553 15 of of IN 42759 553 16 each each DT 42759 553 17 person person NN 42759 553 18 is be VBZ 42759 553 19 obviously obviously RB 42759 553 20 impossible impossible JJ 42759 553 21 . . . 42759 554 1 How how WRB 42759 554 2 can can MD 42759 554 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 554 4 be be VB 42759 554 5 known know VBN 42759 554 6 , , , 42759 554 7 for for IN 42759 554 8 example example NN 42759 554 9 , , , 42759 554 10 what what WDT 42759 554 11 portion portion NN 42759 554 12 of of IN 42759 554 13 the the DT 42759 554 14 increase increase NN 42759 554 15 in in IN 42759 554 16 the the DT 42759 554 17 value value NN 42759 554 18 of of IN 42759 554 19 a a DT 42759 554 20 city city NN 42759 554 21 's 's POS 42759 554 22 real real JJ 42759 554 23 estate estate NN 42759 554 24 during during IN 42759 554 25 a a DT 42759 554 26 given give VBN 42759 554 27 year year NN 42759 554 28 is be VBZ 42759 554 29 due due JJ 42759 554 30 to to IN 42759 554 31 the the DT 42759 554 32 merchants merchant NNS 42759 554 33 , , , 42759 554 34 the the DT 42759 554 35 manufacturers manufacturer NNS 42759 554 36 , , , 42759 554 37 the the DT 42759 554 38 railroads railroad NNS 42759 554 39 , , , 42759 554 40 the the DT 42759 554 41 labourers labourer NNS 42759 554 42 , , , 42759 554 43 the the DT 42759 554 44 professional professional JJ 42759 554 45 classes class NNS 42759 554 46 , , , 42759 554 47 or or CC 42759 554 48 the the DT 42759 554 49 city city NN 42759 554 50 as as IN 42759 554 51 a a DT 42759 554 52 corporation corporation NN 42759 554 53 ? ? . 42759 555 1 The the DT 42759 555 2 only only JJ 42759 555 3 practical practical JJ 42759 555 4 method method NN 42759 555 5 is be VBZ 42759 555 6 for for IN 42759 555 7 the the DT 42759 555 8 city city NN 42759 555 9 or or CC 42759 555 10 other other JJ 42759 555 11 political political JJ 42759 555 12 unit unit NN 42759 555 13 to to TO 42759 555 14 act act VB 42759 555 15 as as IN 42759 555 16 the the DT 42759 555 17 representative representative NN 42759 555 18 of of IN 42759 555 19 all all DT 42759 555 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 555 21 members member NNS 42759 555 22 , , , 42759 555 23 appropriate appropriate VBP 42759 555 24 the the DT 42759 555 25 increase increase NN 42759 555 26 in in IN 42759 555 27 value value NN 42759 555 28 , , , 42759 555 29 and and CC 42759 555 30 distribute distribute VB 42759 555 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 555 32 among among IN 42759 555 33 the the DT 42759 555 34 citizens citizen NNS 42759 555 35 in in IN 42759 555 36 the the DT 42759 555 37 form form NN 42759 555 38 of of IN 42759 555 39 public public JJ 42759 555 40 services service NNS 42759 555 41 , , , 42759 555 42 institutions institution NNS 42759 555 43 , , , 42759 555 44 and and CC 42759 555 45 improvements improvement NNS 42759 555 46 . . . 42759 556 1 Assuming assume VBG 42759 556 2 that that IN 42759 556 3 the the DT 42759 556 4 socially socially RB 42759 556 5 produced produce VBN 42759 556 6 value value NN 42759 556 7 of of IN 42759 556 8 land land NN 42759 556 9 ought ought MD 42759 556 10 to to TO 42759 556 11 go go VB 42759 556 12 to to IN 42759 556 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 556 14 social social JJ 42759 556 15 producer producer NN 42759 556 16 rather rather RB 42759 556 17 than than IN 42759 556 18 to to IN 42759 556 19 the the DT 42759 556 20 individual individual JJ 42759 556 21 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 556 22 , , , 42759 556 23 this this DT 42759 556 24 method method NN 42759 556 25 of of IN 42759 556 26 public public JJ 42759 556 27 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 556 28 and and CC 42759 556 29 disbursement disbursement NN 42759 556 30 would would MD 42759 556 31 seem seem VB 42759 556 32 to to TO 42759 556 33 be be VB 42759 556 34 the the DT 42759 556 35 nearest near JJS 42759 556 36 approximation approximation NN 42759 556 37 to to IN 42759 556 38 practical practical JJ 42759 556 39 justice justice NN 42759 556 40 that that WDT 42759 556 41 is be VBZ 42759 556 42 available available JJ 42759 556 43 . . . 42759 557 1 Is be VBZ 42759 557 2 the the DT 42759 557 3 assumption assumption NN 42759 557 4 correct correct JJ 42759 557 5 ? ? . 42759 558 1 Do do VB 42759 558 2 the the DT 42759 558 3 socially socially RB 42759 558 4 produced produce VBN 42759 558 5 land land NN 42759 558 6 values value NNS 42759 558 7 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 558 8 belong belong VBP 42759 558 9 to to IN 42759 558 10 the the DT 42759 558 11 producer producer NN 42759 558 12 , , , 42759 558 13 society society NN 42759 558 14 ? ? . 42759 559 1 Does do VBZ 42759 559 2 not not RB 42759 559 3 the the DT 42759 559 4 assumption assumption NN 42759 559 5 rest rest VB 42759 559 6 upon upon IN 42759 559 7 a a DT 42759 559 8 misconception misconception NN 42759 559 9 of of IN 42759 559 10 the the DT 42759 559 11 moral moral JJ 42759 559 12 validity validity NN 42759 559 13 of of IN 42759 559 14 production production NN 42759 559 15 as as IN 42759 559 16 a a DT 42759 559 17 canon canon NN 42759 559 18 of of IN 42759 559 19 distribution distribution NN 42759 559 20 ? ? . 42759 560 1 Let let VB 42759 560 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 560 3 examine examine VB 42759 560 4 some some DT 42759 560 5 of of IN 42759 560 6 the the DT 42759 560 7 ways way NNS 42759 560 8 in in IN 42759 560 9 which which WDT 42759 560 10 values value NNS 42759 560 11 are be VBP 42759 560 12 produced produce VBN 42759 560 13 . . . 42759 561 1 The the DT 42759 561 2 man man NN 42759 561 3 who who WP 42759 561 4 converts convert VBZ 42759 561 5 leather leather NN 42759 561 6 and and CC 42759 561 7 other other JJ 42759 561 8 suitable suitable JJ 42759 561 9 raw raw JJ 42759 561 10 materials material NNS 42759 561 11 into into IN 42759 561 12 a a DT 42759 561 13 pair pair NN 42759 561 14 of of IN 42759 561 15 shoes shoe NNS 42759 561 16 , , , 42759 561 17 increases increase VBZ 42759 561 18 the the DT 42759 561 19 utility utility NN 42759 561 20 of of IN 42759 561 21 these these DT 42759 561 22 materials material NNS 42759 561 23 , , , 42759 561 24 and and CC 42759 561 25 in in IN 42759 561 26 normal normal JJ 42759 561 27 market market NN 42759 561 28 conditions condition NNS 42759 561 29 increases increase VBZ 42759 561 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 561 31 value value NN 42759 561 32 . . . 42759 562 1 In in IN 42759 562 2 a a DT 42759 562 3 certain certain JJ 42759 562 4 sense sense NN 42759 562 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 562 6 has have VBZ 42759 562 7 created create VBN 42759 562 8 value value NN 42759 562 9 , , , 42759 562 10 and and CC 42759 562 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 562 12 is be VBZ 42759 562 13 universally universally RB 42759 562 14 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 42759 562 15 to to TO 42759 562 16 have have VB 42759 562 17 a a DT 42759 562 18 right right NN 42759 562 19 to to IN 42759 562 20 this this DT 42759 562 21 product product NN 42759 562 22 . . . 42759 563 1 Similarly similarly RB 42759 563 2 the the DT 42759 563 3 man man NN 42759 563 4 who who WP 42759 563 5 increases increase VBZ 42759 563 6 the the DT 42759 563 7 utility utility NN 42759 563 8 and and CC 42759 563 9 value value NN 42759 563 10 of of IN 42759 563 11 land land NN 42759 563 12 by by IN 42759 563 13 fertilising fertilise VBG 42759 563 14 , , , 42759 563 15 irrigating irrigate VBG 42759 563 16 , , , 42759 563 17 or or CC 42759 563 18 draining drain VBG 42759 563 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 563 20 , , , 42759 563 21 is be VBZ 42759 563 22 conceded concede VBN 42759 563 23 the the DT 42759 563 24 benefit benefit NN 42759 563 25 of of IN 42759 563 26 these these DT 42759 563 27 improvements improvement NNS 42759 563 28 by by IN 42759 563 29 the the DT 42759 563 30 title title NN 42759 563 31 of of IN 42759 563 32 production production NN 42759 563 33 . . . 42759 564 1 But but CC 42759 564 2 value value NN 42759 564 3 may may MD 42759 564 4 be be VB 42759 564 5 increased increase VBN 42759 564 6 by by IN 42759 564 7 mere mere JJ 42759 564 8 restriction restriction NN 42759 564 9 of of IN 42759 564 10 supply supply NN 42759 564 11 , , , 42759 564 12 and and CC 42759 564 13 by by IN 42759 564 14 mere mere JJ 42759 564 15 increase increase NN 42759 564 16 in in IN 42759 564 17 demand demand NN 42759 564 18 . . . 42759 565 1 If if IN 42759 565 2 a a DT 42759 565 3 group group NN 42759 565 4 of of IN 42759 565 5 men man NNS 42759 565 6 get get VBP 42759 565 7 control control NN 42759 565 8 of of IN 42759 565 9 the the DT 42759 565 10 existing exist VBG 42759 565 11 supply supply NN 42759 565 12 of of IN 42759 565 13 wheat wheat NN 42759 565 14 or or CC 42759 565 15 cotton cotton NN 42759 565 16 , , , 42759 565 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 565 18 can can MD 42759 565 19 artificially artificially RB 42759 565 20 raise raise VB 42759 565 21 the the DT 42759 565 22 price price NN 42759 565 23 , , , 42759 565 24 thereby thereby RB 42759 565 25 producing produce VBG 42759 565 26 value value NN 42759 565 27 as as RB 42759 565 28 effectively effectively RB 42759 565 29 as as IN 42759 565 30 the the DT 42759 565 31 shoemaker shoemaker NN 42759 565 32 or or CC 42759 565 33 the the DT 42759 565 34 farmer farmer NN 42759 565 35 . . . 42759 566 1 If if IN 42759 566 2 a a DT 42759 566 3 syndicate syndicate NN 42759 566 4 of of IN 42759 566 5 speculators speculator NNS 42759 566 6 gets get VBZ 42759 566 7 possession possession NN 42759 566 8 of of IN 42759 566 9 all all PDT 42759 566 10 the the DT 42759 566 11 land land NN 42759 566 12 of of IN 42759 566 13 a a DT 42759 566 14 certain certain JJ 42759 566 15 quality quality NN 42759 566 16 in in IN 42759 566 17 a a DT 42759 566 18 community community NN 42759 566 19 , , , 42759 566 20 they -PRON- PRP 42759 566 21 can can MD 42759 566 22 likewise likewise RB 42759 566 23 increase increase VB 42759 566 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 566 25 value value NN 42759 566 26 , , , 42759 566 27 produce produce VB 42759 566 28 new new JJ 42759 566 29 value value NN 42759 566 30 . . . 42759 567 1 If if IN 42759 567 2 a a DT 42759 567 3 few few JJ 42759 567 4 powerful powerful JJ 42759 567 5 leaders leader NNS 42759 567 6 of of IN 42759 567 7 fashion fashion NN 42759 567 8 decide decide VBP 42759 567 9 to to TO 42759 567 10 adopt adopt VB 42759 567 11 a a DT 42759 567 12 certain certain JJ 42759 567 13 style style NN 42759 567 14 of of IN 42759 567 15 millinery millinery NN 42759 567 16 , , , 42759 567 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 567 18 action action NN 42759 567 19 and and CC 42759 567 20 example example NN 42759 567 21 will will MD 42759 567 22 effect effect VB 42759 567 23 an an DT 42759 567 24 increase increase NN 42759 567 25 in in IN 42759 567 26 the the DT 42759 567 27 demand demand NN 42759 567 28 for for IN 42759 567 29 and and CC 42759 567 30 the the DT 42759 567 31 value value NN 42759 567 32 of of IN 42759 567 33 that that DT 42759 567 34 kind kind NN 42759 567 35 of of IN 42759 567 36 goods good NNS 42759 567 37 . . . 42759 568 1 Yet yet RB 42759 568 2 none none NN 42759 568 3 of of IN 42759 568 4 these these DT 42759 568 5 producers producer NNS 42759 568 6 of of IN 42759 568 7 value value NN 42759 568 8 are be VBP 42759 568 9 regarded regard VBN 42759 568 10 as as IN 42759 568 11 having have VBG 42759 568 12 a a DT 42759 568 13 moral moral JJ 42759 568 14 right right NN 42759 568 15 to to IN 42759 568 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 568 17 product product NN 42759 568 18 . . . 42759 569 1 When when WRB 42759 569 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 569 3 turn turn VBP 42759 569 4 to to IN 42759 569 5 what what WP 42759 569 6 is be VBZ 42759 569 7 called call VBN 42759 569 8 the the DT 42759 569 9 social social JJ 42759 569 10 creation creation NN 42759 569 11 of of IN 42759 569 12 land land NN 42759 569 13 values value NNS 42759 569 14 , , , 42759 569 15 we -PRON- PRP 42759 569 16 find find VBP 42759 569 17 that that IN 42759 569 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 569 19 takes take VBZ 42759 569 20 two two CD 42759 569 21 forms form NNS 42759 569 22 . . . 42759 570 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 570 2 always always RB 42759 570 3 implies imply VBZ 42759 570 4 increase increase NN 42759 570 5 of of IN 42759 570 6 social social JJ 42759 570 7 demand demand NN 42759 570 8 ; ; : 42759 570 9 but but CC 42759 570 10 the the DT 42759 570 11 latter latter JJ 42759 570 12 may may MD 42759 570 13 be be VB 42759 570 14 either either CC 42759 570 15 purely purely RB 42759 570 16 subjective subjective JJ 42759 570 17 , , , 42759 570 18 reflecting reflect VBG 42759 570 19 merely merely RB 42759 570 20 the the DT 42759 570 21 desires desire NNS 42759 570 22 and and CC 42759 570 23 power power NN 42759 570 24 of of IN 42759 570 25 the the DT 42759 570 26 demanders demander NNS 42759 570 27 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 570 28 , , , 42759 570 29 or or CC 42759 570 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 570 31 may may MD 42759 570 32 have have VB 42759 570 33 an an DT 42759 570 34 objective objective JJ 42759 570 35 basis basis NN 42759 570 36 connected connect VBN 42759 570 37 with with IN 42759 570 38 the the DT 42759 570 39 land land NN 42759 570 40 . . . 42759 571 1 In in IN 42759 571 2 the the DT 42759 571 3 first first JJ 42759 571 4 case case NN 42759 571 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 571 6 may may MD 42759 571 7 be be VB 42759 571 8 due due JJ 42759 571 9 solely solely RB 42759 571 10 to to IN 42759 571 11 an an DT 42759 571 12 increase increase NN 42759 571 13 of of IN 42759 571 14 population population NN 42759 571 15 . . . 42759 572 1 Within within IN 42759 572 2 the the DT 42759 572 3 last last JJ 42759 572 4 few few JJ 42759 572 5 years year NNS 42759 572 6 , , , 42759 572 7 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 572 8 land land NN 42759 572 9 which which WDT 42759 572 10 is be VBZ 42759 572 11 no no DT 42759 572 12 more more RBR 42759 572 13 fertile fertile JJ 42759 572 14 nor nor CC 42759 572 15 any any DT 42759 572 16 better well RBR 42759 572 17 situated situate VBN 42759 572 18 with with IN 42759 572 19 regard regard NN 42759 572 20 to to IN 42759 572 21 markets market NNS 42759 572 22 or or CC 42759 572 23 other other JJ 42759 572 24 social social JJ 42759 572 25 advantages advantage NNS 42759 572 26 than than IN 42759 572 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 572 28 was be VBD 42759 572 29 thirty thirty CD 42759 572 30 years year NNS 42759 572 31 ago ago RB 42759 572 32 , , , 42759 572 33 has have VBZ 42759 572 34 risen rise VBN 42759 572 35 in in IN 42759 572 36 value value NN 42759 572 37 because because IN 42759 572 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 572 39 products product NNS 42759 572 40 have have VBP 42759 572 41 risen rise VBN 42759 572 42 in in IN 42759 572 43 value value NN 42759 572 44 . . . 42759 573 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 573 2 products product NNS 42759 573 3 have have VBP 42759 573 4 become become VBN 42759 573 5 dearer dearer NN 42759 573 6 because because IN 42759 573 7 population population NN 42759 573 8 , , , 42759 573 9 and and CC 42759 573 10 therefore therefore RB 42759 573 11 demand demand VBP 42759 573 12 , , , 42759 573 13 have have VBP 42759 573 14 grown grow VBN 42759 573 15 faster fast RBR 42759 573 16 than than IN 42759 573 17 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 573 18 production production NN 42759 573 19 . . . 42759 574 1 Merely merely RB 42759 574 2 by by IN 42759 574 3 increasing increase VBG 42759 574 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 574 5 wants want VBZ 42759 574 6 the the DT 42759 574 7 population population NN 42759 574 8 has have VBZ 42759 574 9 produced produce VBN 42759 574 10 land land NN 42759 574 11 values value NNS 42759 574 12 ; ; , 42759 574 13 but but CC 42759 574 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 574 15 has have VBZ 42759 574 16 obviously obviously RB 42759 574 17 no no DT 42759 574 18 more more RBR 42759 574 19 right right JJ 42759 574 20 to to IN 42759 574 21 them -PRON- PRP 42759 574 22 than than IN 42759 574 23 have have VB 42759 574 24 the the DT 42759 574 25 leaders leader NNS 42759 574 26 of of IN 42759 574 27 fashion fashion NN 42759 574 28 to to IN 42759 574 29 the the DT 42759 574 30 enhanced enhance VBN 42759 574 31 value value NN 42759 574 32 which which WDT 42759 574 33 they -PRON- PRP 42759 574 34 have have VBP 42759 574 35 given give VBN 42759 574 36 to to IN 42759 574 37 feminine feminine JJ 42759 574 38 headgear headgear NN 42759 574 39 . . . 42759 575 1 On on IN 42759 575 2 the the DT 42759 575 3 other other JJ 42759 575 4 hand hand NN 42759 575 5 , , , 42759 575 6 the the DT 42759 575 7 increased increase VBN 42759 575 8 demand demand NN 42759 575 9 for for IN 42759 575 10 land land NN 42759 575 11 , , , 42759 575 12 and and CC 42759 575 13 the the DT 42759 575 14 consequent consequent JJ 42759 575 15 increase increase NN 42759 575 16 in in IN 42759 575 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 575 18 value value NN 42759 575 19 , , , 42759 575 20 are be VBP 42759 575 21 frequently frequently RB 42759 575 22 attributable attributable JJ 42759 575 23 specifically specifically RB 42759 575 24 to to IN 42759 575 25 changes change NNS 42759 575 26 connected connect VBN 42759 575 27 with with IN 42759 575 28 the the DT 42759 575 29 land land NN 42759 575 30 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 575 31 . . . 42759 576 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 576 2 are be VBP 42759 576 3 changes change NNS 42759 576 4 which which WDT 42759 576 5 affect affect VBP 42759 576 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 576 7 utility utility NN 42759 576 8 rather rather RB 42759 576 9 than than IN 42759 576 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 576 11 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 576 12 . . . 42759 577 1 The the DT 42759 577 2 farmer farmer NN 42759 577 3 who who WP 42759 577 4 irrigates irrigate VBZ 42759 577 5 desert desert NN 42759 577 6 land land NN 42759 577 7 increases increase VBZ 42759 577 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 577 9 utility utility NN 42759 577 10 , , , 42759 577 11 as as IN 42759 577 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 577 13 were be VBD 42759 577 14 , , , 42759 577 15 _ _ NNP 42759 577 16 intrinsically intrinsically RB 42759 577 17 _ _ NNP 42759 577 18 . . . 42759 578 1 The the DT 42759 578 2 community community NN 42759 578 3 that that WDT 42759 578 4 establishes establish VBZ 42759 578 5 a a DT 42759 578 6 city city NN 42759 578 7 increases increase VBZ 42759 578 8 the the DT 42759 578 9 utility utility NN 42759 578 10 of of IN 42759 578 11 the the DT 42759 578 12 land land NN 42759 578 13 therein therein RB 42759 578 14 and and CC 42759 578 15 thereabout thereabout RB 42759 578 16 _ _ NNP 42759 578 17 extrinsically extrinsically RB 42759 578 18 _ _ NNP 42759 578 19 . . . 42759 579 1 New New NNP 42759 579 2 _ _ NNP 42759 579 3 relations relation NNS 42759 579 4 _ _ NNP 42759 579 5 are be VBP 42759 579 6 introduced introduce VBN 42759 579 7 between between IN 42759 579 8 that that DT 42759 579 9 land land NN 42759 579 10 and and CC 42759 579 11 certain certain JJ 42759 579 12 desirable desirable JJ 42759 579 13 social social JJ 42759 579 14 institutions institution NNS 42759 579 15 . . . 42759 580 1 Land land NN 42759 580 2 that that WDT 42759 580 3 was be VBD 42759 580 4 formerly formerly RB 42759 580 5 useful useful JJ 42759 580 6 only only RB 42759 580 7 for for IN 42759 580 8 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 580 9 becomes become VBZ 42759 580 10 profitable profitable JJ 42759 580 11 for for IN 42759 580 12 a a DT 42759 580 13 factory factory NN 42759 580 14 or or CC 42759 580 15 a a DT 42759 580 16 store store NN 42759 580 17 . . . 42759 581 1 Through through IN 42759 581 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 581 3 new new JJ 42759 581 4 external external JJ 42759 581 5 relations relation NNS 42759 581 6 , , , 42759 581 7 the the DT 42759 581 8 land land NN 42759 581 9 acquires acquire VBZ 42759 581 10 new new JJ 42759 581 11 utility utility NN 42759 581 12 ; ; : 42759 581 13 or or CC 42759 581 14 better well JJR 42759 581 15 , , , 42759 581 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 581 17 latent latent NN 42759 581 18 and and CC 42759 581 19 potential potential JJ 42759 581 20 uses use NNS 42759 581 21 have have VBP 42759 581 22 become become VBN 42759 581 23 actual actual JJ 42759 581 24 . . . 42759 582 1 Now now RB 42759 582 2 these these DT 42759 582 3 new new JJ 42759 582 4 relations relation NNS 42759 582 5 , , , 42759 582 6 these these DT 42759 582 7 utility utility NN 42759 582 8 - - : 42759 582 9 creating creating NN 42759 582 10 and and CC 42759 582 11 value value NN 42759 582 12 - - HYPH 42759 582 13 creating create VBG 42759 582 14 relations relation NNS 42759 582 15 , , , 42759 582 16 have have VBP 42759 582 17 been be VBN 42759 582 18 established establish VBN 42759 582 19 by by IN 42759 582 20 society society NN 42759 582 21 , , , 42759 582 22 in in IN 42759 582 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 582 24 corporate corporate JJ 42759 582 25 capacity capacity NN 42759 582 26 through through IN 42759 582 27 civil civil JJ 42759 582 28 institutions institution NNS 42759 582 29 and and CC 42759 582 30 activities activity NNS 42759 582 31 , , , 42759 582 32 and and CC 42759 582 33 in in IN 42759 582 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 582 35 non non JJ 42759 582 36 - - JJ 42759 582 37 corporate corporate JJ 42759 582 38 capacity capacity NN 42759 582 39 through through IN 42759 582 40 the the DT 42759 582 41 economic economic JJ 42759 582 42 and and CC 42759 582 43 " " `` 42759 582 44 social social JJ 42759 582 45 " " '' 42759 582 46 ( ( -LRB- 42759 582 47 in in IN 42759 582 48 the the DT 42759 582 49 narrower narrow JJR 42759 582 50 " " `` 42759 582 51 society society NN 42759 582 52 " " '' 42759 582 53 sense sense NN 42759 582 54 ) ) -RRB- 42759 582 55 activities activity NNS 42759 582 56 of of IN 42759 582 57 groups group NNS 42759 582 58 and and CC 42759 582 59 individuals individual NNS 42759 582 60 . . . 42759 583 1 In in IN 42759 583 2 this this DT 42759 583 3 sense sense NN 42759 583 4 , , , 42759 583 5 then then RB 42759 583 6 , , , 42759 583 7 the the DT 42759 583 8 community community NN 42759 583 9 has have VBZ 42759 583 10 created create VBN 42759 583 11 the the DT 42759 583 12 increased increase VBN 42759 583 13 land land NN 42759 583 14 values value NNS 42759 583 15 . . . 42759 584 1 Has have VBZ 42759 584 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 584 3 a a DT 42759 584 4 strict strict JJ 42759 584 5 right right NN 42759 584 6 to to IN 42759 584 7 them -PRON- PRP 42759 584 8 ? ? . 42759 585 1 a a DT 42759 585 2 right right RB 42759 585 3 so so RB 42759 585 4 rigorous rigorous JJ 42759 585 5 and and CC 42759 585 6 exact exact JJ 42759 585 7 that that IN 42759 585 8 private private JJ 42759 585 9 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 585 10 of of IN 42759 585 11 them -PRON- PRP 42759 585 12 is be VBZ 42759 585 13 unjust unjust JJ 42759 585 14 ? ? . 42759 586 1 As as IN 42759 586 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 586 3 have have VBP 42759 586 4 just just RB 42759 586 5 seen see VBN 42759 586 6 , , , 42759 586 7 men man NNS 42759 586 8 do do VBP 42759 586 9 not not RB 42759 586 10 admit admit VB 42759 586 11 that that IN 42759 586 12 mere mere JJ 42759 586 13 production production NN 42759 586 14 of of IN 42759 586 15 value value NN 42759 586 16 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 586 17 a a DT 42759 586 18 title title NN 42759 586 19 of of IN 42759 586 20 ownership ownership NN 42759 586 21 . . . 42759 587 1 Neither neither CC 42759 587 2 the the DT 42759 587 3 monopolist monopolist NN 42759 587 4 who who WP 42759 587 5 increases increase VBZ 42759 587 6 value value NN 42759 587 7 by by IN 42759 587 8 restricting restrict VBG 42759 587 9 supply supply NN 42759 587 10 , , , 42759 587 11 nor nor CC 42759 587 12 the the DT 42759 587 13 pace pace NN 42759 587 14 - - HYPH 42759 587 15 makers maker NNS 42759 587 16 of of IN 42759 587 17 fashion fashion NN 42759 587 18 , , , 42759 587 19 who who WP 42759 587 20 increase increase VBP 42759 587 21 value value NN 42759 587 22 by by IN 42759 587 23 merely merely RB 42759 587 24 increasing increase VBG 42759 587 25 demand demand NN 42759 587 26 , , , 42759 587 27 are be VBP 42759 587 28 regarded regard VBN 42759 587 29 as as IN 42759 587 30 possessing possess VBG 42759 587 31 a a DT 42759 587 32 moral moral JJ 42759 587 33 right right NN 42759 587 34 to to IN 42759 587 35 the the DT 42759 587 36 value value NN 42759 587 37 that that WDT 42759 587 38 they -PRON- PRP 42759 587 39 have have VBP 42759 587 40 " " `` 42759 587 41 created create VBN 42759 587 42 . . . 42759 587 43 " " '' 42759 588 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 588 2 is be VBZ 42759 588 3 increase increase NN 42759 588 4 of of IN 42759 588 5 utility utility NN 42759 588 6 , , , 42759 588 7 and and CC 42759 588 8 not not RB 42759 588 9 either either CC 42759 588 10 actual actual JJ 42759 588 11 or or CC 42759 588 12 virtual virtual JJ 42759 588 13 increase increase NN 42759 588 14 of of IN 42759 588 15 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 588 16 to to IN 42759 588 17 which which WDT 42759 588 18 men man NNS 42759 588 19 attribute attribute VBP 42759 588 20 a a DT 42759 588 21 moral moral JJ 42759 588 22 claim claim NN 42759 588 23 . . . 42759 589 1 Why why WRB 42759 589 2 do do VBP 42759 589 3 men man NNS 42759 589 4 assign assign VB 42759 589 5 these these DT 42759 589 6 different different JJ 42759 589 7 ethical ethical JJ 42759 589 8 qualities quality NNS 42759 589 9 to to IN 42759 589 10 the the DT 42759 589 11 production production NN 42759 589 12 of of IN 42759 589 13 value value NN 42759 589 14 ? ? . 42759 590 1 Why why WRB 42759 590 2 has have VBZ 42759 590 3 the the DT 42759 590 4 shoemaker shoemaker NN 42759 590 5 a a DT 42759 590 6 right right NN 42759 590 7 to to IN 42759 590 8 the the DT 42759 590 9 value value NN 42759 590 10 that that WDT 42759 590 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 590 12 adds add VBZ 42759 590 13 to to IN 42759 590 14 the the DT 42759 590 15 raw raw JJ 42759 590 16 material material NN 42759 590 17 in in IN 42759 590 18 making make VBG 42759 590 19 a a DT 42759 590 20 pair pair NN 42759 590 21 of of IN 42759 590 22 shoes shoe NNS 42759 590 23 ? ? . 42759 591 1 What what WP 42759 591 2 is be VBZ 42759 591 3 the the DT 42759 591 4 precise precise JJ 42759 591 5 basis basis NN 42759 591 6 of of IN 42759 591 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 591 8 right right NN 42759 591 9 ? ? . 42759 592 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 592 2 can can MD 42759 592 3 not not RB 42759 592 4 be be VB 42759 592 5 labour labour NN 42759 592 6 merely merely RB 42759 592 7 ; ; : 42759 592 8 for for IN 42759 592 9 the the DT 42759 592 10 cotton cotton NN 42759 592 11 monopolist monopolist NN 42759 592 12 has have VBZ 42759 592 13 laboured labour VBN 42759 592 14 in in IN 42759 592 15 getting get VBG 42759 592 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 592 17 corner corner NN 42759 592 18 on on IN 42759 592 19 cotton cotton NN 42759 592 20 . . . 42759 593 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 593 2 can can MD 42759 593 3 not not RB 42759 593 4 be be VB 42759 593 5 the the DT 42759 593 6 fact fact NN 42759 593 7 that that IN 42759 593 8 the the DT 42759 593 9 shoemaker shoemaker NN 42759 593 10 's 's POS 42759 593 11 labour labour NN 42759 593 12 is be VBZ 42759 593 13 socially socially RB 42759 593 14 useful useful JJ 42759 593 15 ; ; : 42759 593 16 for for IN 42759 593 17 a a DT 42759 593 18 chemist chemist NN 42759 593 19 might may MD 42759 593 20 spend spend VB 42759 593 21 laborious laborious JJ 42759 593 22 days day NNS 42759 593 23 and and CC 42759 593 24 nights night NNS 42759 593 25 producing produce VBG 42759 593 26 water water NN 42759 593 27 from from IN 42759 593 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 593 29 component component NN 42759 593 30 elements element NNS 42759 593 31 , , , 42759 593 32 and and CC 42759 593 33 find find VB 42759 593 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 593 35 product product NN 42759 593 36 a a DT 42759 593 37 drug drug NN 42759 593 38 on on IN 42759 593 39 the the DT 42759 593 40 market market NN 42759 593 41 . . . 42759 594 1 Yet yet CC 42759 594 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 594 3 would would MD 42759 594 4 have have VB 42759 594 5 no no DT 42759 594 6 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 594 7 ground ground NN 42759 594 8 of of IN 42759 594 9 complaint complaint NN 42759 594 10 . . . 42759 595 1 Why why WRB 42759 595 2 , , , 42759 595 3 then then RB 42759 595 4 , , , 42759 595 5 is be VBZ 42759 595 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 595 7 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 595 8 for for IN 42759 595 9 the the DT 42759 595 10 shoemaker shoemaker NN 42759 595 11 to to TO 42759 595 12 require require VB 42759 595 13 , , , 42759 595 14 why why WRB 42759 595 15 has have VBZ 42759 595 16 he -PRON- PRP 42759 595 17 a a DT 42759 595 18 right right NN 42759 595 19 to to TO 42759 595 20 require require VB 42759 595 21 payment payment NN 42759 595 22 for for IN 42759 595 23 the the DT 42759 595 24 utilities utility NNS 42759 595 25 that that WDT 42759 595 26 he -PRON- PRP 42759 595 27 produces produce VBZ 42759 595 28 ? ? . 42759 596 1 Because because IN 42759 596 2 men man NNS 42759 596 3 want want VBP 42759 596 4 to to TO 42759 596 5 use use VB 42759 596 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 596 7 products product NNS 42759 596 8 , , , 42759 596 9 and and CC 42759 596 10 because because IN 42759 596 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 596 12 have have VBP 42759 596 13 no no DT 42759 596 14 right right NN 42759 596 15 to to TO 42759 596 16 require require VB 42759 596 17 him -PRON- PRP 42759 596 18 to to TO 42759 596 19 serve serve VB 42759 596 20 them -PRON- PRP 42759 596 21 without without IN 42759 596 22 compensation compensation NN 42759 596 23 . . . 42759 597 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 597 2 is be VBZ 42759 597 3 morally morally RB 42759 597 4 and and CC 42759 597 5 juridically juridically RB 42759 597 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 597 7 equal equal JJ 42759 597 8 , , , 42759 597 9 and and CC 42759 597 10 has have VBZ 42759 597 11 the the DT 42759 597 12 same same JJ 42759 597 13 right right NN 42759 597 14 as as IN 42759 597 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 597 16 to to TO 42759 597 17 have have VB 42759 597 18 access access NN 42759 597 19 on on IN 42759 597 20 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 597 21 terms term NNS 42759 597 22 to to IN 42759 597 23 the the DT 42759 597 24 earth earth NN 42759 597 25 and and CC 42759 597 26 the the DT 42759 597 27 earth earth NN 42759 597 28 's 's POS 42759 597 29 possibilities possibility NNS 42759 597 30 of of IN 42759 597 31 a a DT 42759 597 32 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 597 33 . . . 42759 598 1 Being be VBG 42759 598 2 thus thus RB 42759 598 3 equal equal JJ 42759 598 4 to to IN 42759 598 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 598 6 fellows fellow NNS 42759 598 7 , , , 42759 598 8 he -PRON- PRP 42759 598 9 is be VBZ 42759 598 10 under under IN 42759 598 11 no no DT 42759 598 12 obligation obligation NN 42759 598 13 to to TO 42759 598 14 subordinate subordinate VB 42759 598 15 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 598 16 to to IN 42759 598 17 them -PRON- PRP 42759 598 18 by by IN 42759 598 19 becoming become VBG 42759 598 20 a a DT 42759 598 21 mere mere JJ 42759 598 22 instrument instrument NN 42759 598 23 for for IN 42759 598 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 598 25 welfare welfare NN 42759 598 26 . . . 42759 599 1 To to TO 42759 599 2 assume assume VB 42759 599 3 that that IN 42759 599 4 he -PRON- PRP 42759 599 5 is be VBZ 42759 599 6 obliged oblige VBN 42759 599 7 to to TO 42759 599 8 produce produce VB 42759 599 9 socially socially RB 42759 599 10 useful useful JJ 42759 599 11 things thing NNS 42759 599 12 without without IN 42759 599 13 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 599 14 , , , 42759 599 15 is be VBZ 42759 599 16 to to TO 42759 599 17 assume assume VB 42759 599 18 that that IN 42759 599 19 all all PDT 42759 599 20 these these DT 42759 599 21 propositions proposition NNS 42759 599 22 are be VBP 42759 599 23 false false JJ 42759 599 24 ; ; : 42759 599 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 599 26 is be VBZ 42759 599 27 to to TO 42759 599 28 assume assume VB 42759 599 29 that that IN 42759 599 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 599 31 life life NN 42759 599 32 and and CC 42759 599 33 personality personality NN 42759 599 34 and and CC 42759 599 35 personal personal JJ 42759 599 36 development development NN 42759 599 37 are be VBP 42759 599 38 of of IN 42759 599 39 no no DT 42759 599 40 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 599 41 importance importance NN 42759 599 42 , , , 42759 599 43 and and CC 42759 599 44 that that IN 42759 599 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 599 46 pursuit pursuit NN 42759 599 47 of of IN 42759 599 48 the the DT 42759 599 49 essential essential JJ 42759 599 50 ends end NNS 42759 599 51 of of IN 42759 599 52 life life NN 42759 599 53 has have VBZ 42759 599 54 no no DT 42759 599 55 meaning meaning NN 42759 599 56 except except IN 42759 599 57 in in IN 42759 599 58 so so RB 42759 599 59 far far RB 42759 599 60 as as IN 42759 599 61 may may MD 42759 599 62 be be VB 42759 599 63 conducive conducive JJ 42759 599 64 to to IN 42759 599 65 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 599 66 function function NN 42759 599 67 as as IN 42759 599 68 an an DT 42759 599 69 instrument instrument NN 42759 599 70 of of IN 42759 599 71 production production NN 42759 599 72 . . . 42759 600 1 In in IN 42759 600 2 a a DT 42759 600 3 word word NN 42759 600 4 , , , 42759 600 5 the the DT 42759 600 6 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 600 7 basis basis NN 42759 600 8 of of IN 42759 600 9 the the DT 42759 600 10 producer producer NN 42759 600 11 's 's POS 42759 600 12 right right NN 42759 600 13 to to IN 42759 600 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 600 15 product product NN 42759 600 16 , , , 42759 600 17 or or CC 42759 600 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 600 19 value value NN 42759 600 20 , , , 42759 600 21 is be VBZ 42759 600 22 the the DT 42759 600 23 fact fact NN 42759 600 24 that that IN 42759 600 25 this this DT 42759 600 26 is be VBZ 42759 600 27 the the DT 42759 600 28 only only JJ 42759 600 29 way way NN 42759 600 30 in in IN 42759 600 31 which which WDT 42759 600 32 he -PRON- PRP 42759 600 33 can can MD 42759 600 34 get get VB 42759 600 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 600 36 just just JJ 42759 600 37 share share NN 42759 600 38 of of IN 42759 600 39 the the DT 42759 600 40 earth earth NN 42759 600 41 's 's POS 42759 600 42 goods good NNS 42759 600 43 , , , 42759 600 44 and and CC 42759 600 45 of of IN 42759 600 46 the the DT 42759 600 47 means mean NNS 42759 600 48 of of IN 42759 600 49 life life NN 42759 600 50 and and CC 42759 600 51 personal personal JJ 42759 600 52 development development NN 42759 600 53 . . . 42759 601 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 601 2 right right NN 42759 601 3 to to IN 42759 601 4 compensation compensation NN 42759 601 5 does do VBZ 42759 601 6 not not RB 42759 601 7 rest rest VB 42759 601 8 on on IN 42759 601 9 the the DT 42759 601 10 mere mere JJ 42759 601 11 fact fact NN 42759 601 12 of of IN 42759 601 13 value value NN 42759 601 14 - - HYPH 42759 601 15 production production NN 42759 601 16 . . . 42759 602 1 As as IN 42759 602 2 a a DT 42759 602 3 producer producer NN 42759 602 4 of of IN 42759 602 5 land land NN 42759 602 6 values value NNS 42759 602 7 , , , 42759 602 8 the the DT 42759 602 9 community community NN 42759 602 10 is be VBZ 42759 602 11 not not RB 42759 602 12 on on IN 42759 602 13 the the DT 42759 602 14 same same JJ 42759 602 15 moral moral JJ 42759 602 16 ground ground NN 42759 602 17 with with IN 42759 602 18 the the DT 42759 602 19 shoemaker shoemaker NN 42759 602 20 . . . 42759 603 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 603 2 productive productive JJ 42759 603 3 action action NN 42759 603 4 is be VBZ 42759 603 5 indirect indirect JJ 42759 603 6 and and CC 42759 603 7 extrinsic extrinsic JJ 42759 603 8 , , , 42759 603 9 instead instead RB 42759 603 10 of of IN 42759 603 11 direct direct JJ 42759 603 12 and and CC 42759 603 13 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 603 14 , , , 42759 603 15 and and CC 42759 603 16 is be VBZ 42759 603 17 merely merely RB 42759 603 18 incidental incidental JJ 42759 603 19 to to IN 42759 603 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 603 21 principal principal JJ 42759 603 22 activities activity NNS 42759 603 23 and and CC 42759 603 24 purposes purpose NNS 42759 603 25 . . . 42759 604 1 Land land NN 42759 604 2 values value NNS 42759 604 3 are be VBP 42759 604 4 a a DT 42759 604 5 by by IN 42759 604 6 - - HYPH 42759 604 7 product product NN 42759 604 8 which which WDT 42759 604 9 do do VBP 42759 604 10 not not RB 42759 604 11 require require VB 42759 604 12 the the DT 42759 604 13 community community NN 42759 604 14 to to TO 42759 604 15 devote devote VB 42759 604 16 thereto thereto IN 42759 604 17 a a DT 42759 604 18 single single JJ 42759 604 19 moment moment NN 42759 604 20 of of IN 42759 604 21 time time NN 42759 604 22 or or CC 42759 604 23 a a DT 42759 604 24 single single JJ 42759 604 25 ounce ounce NN 42759 604 26 of of IN 42759 604 27 effort effort NN 42759 604 28 . . . 42759 605 1 The the DT 42759 605 2 activities activity NNS 42759 605 3 of of IN 42759 605 4 which which WDT 42759 605 5 land land NN 42759 605 6 values value NNS 42759 605 7 are be VBP 42759 605 8 a a DT 42759 605 9 by by IN 42759 605 10 - - HYPH 42759 605 11 product product NN 42759 605 12 , , , 42759 605 13 have have VBP 42759 605 14 already already RB 42759 605 15 been be VBN 42759 605 16 remunerated remunerate VBN 42759 605 17 in in IN 42759 605 18 the the DT 42759 605 19 price price NN 42759 605 20 paid pay VBN 42759 605 21 to to IN 42759 605 22 the the DT 42759 605 23 wage wage NN 42759 605 24 - - HYPH 42759 605 25 earner earner NN 42759 605 26 for for IN 42759 605 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 605 28 labour labour NN 42759 605 29 , , , 42759 605 30 the the DT 42759 605 31 physician physician NN 42759 605 32 for for IN 42759 605 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 605 34 services service NNS 42759 605 35 , , , 42759 605 36 the the DT 42759 605 37 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 605 38 and and CC 42759 605 39 the the DT 42759 605 40 merchant merchant NN 42759 605 41 for for IN 42759 605 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 605 43 wares ware NNS 42759 605 44 , , , 42759 605 45 and and CC 42759 605 46 the the DT 42759 605 47 municipal municipal JJ 42759 605 48 corporation corporation NN 42759 605 49 in in IN 42759 605 50 the the DT 42759 605 51 form form NN 42759 605 52 of of IN 42759 605 53 taxes taxis NNS 42759 605 54 . . . 42759 606 1 On on IN 42759 606 2 what what WDT 42759 606 3 ground ground NN 42759 606 4 can can MD 42759 606 5 the the DT 42759 606 6 community community NN 42759 606 7 , , , 42759 606 8 or or CC 42759 606 9 any any DT 42759 606 10 part part NN 42759 606 11 of of IN 42759 606 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 606 13 , , , 42759 606 14 set set VBD 42759 606 15 up up RP 42759 606 16 a a DT 42759 606 17 claim claim NN 42759 606 18 in in IN 42759 606 19 strict strict JJ 42759 606 20 justice justice NN 42759 606 21 to to IN 42759 606 22 the the DT 42759 606 23 increased increase VBN 42759 606 24 land land NN 42759 606 25 values value NNS 42759 606 26 ? ? . 42759 607 1 The the DT 42759 607 2 right right NN 42759 607 3 of of IN 42759 607 4 the the DT 42759 607 5 members member NNS 42759 607 6 of of IN 42759 607 7 the the DT 42759 607 8 community community NN 42759 607 9 to to IN 42759 607 10 the the DT 42759 607 11 means mean NNS 42759 607 12 of of IN 42759 607 13 living living NN 42759 607 14 and and CC 42759 607 15 self self NN 42759 607 16 development development NN 42759 607 17 is be VBZ 42759 607 18 not not RB 42759 607 19 dependent dependent JJ 42759 607 20 upon upon IN 42759 607 21 the the DT 42759 607 22 taking taking NN 42759 607 23 of of IN 42759 607 24 these these DT 42759 607 25 values value NNS 42759 607 26 by by IN 42759 607 27 the the DT 42759 607 28 community community NN 42759 607 29 . . . 42759 608 1 Nor nor CC 42759 608 2 are be VBP 42759 608 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 608 4 treated treat VBN 42759 608 5 as as IN 42759 608 6 instruments instrument NNS 42759 608 7 to to IN 42759 608 8 the the DT 42759 608 9 welfare welfare NN 42759 608 10 of of IN 42759 608 11 the the DT 42759 608 12 private private JJ 42759 608 13 owners owner NNS 42759 608 14 who who WP 42759 608 15 do do VBP 42759 608 16 get get VB 42759 608 17 the the DT 42759 608 18 socially socially RB 42759 608 19 created create VBN 42759 608 20 land land NN 42759 608 21 values value NNS 42759 608 22 ; ; , 42759 608 23 for for IN 42759 608 24 they -PRON- PRP 42759 608 25 expend expend VBP 42759 608 26 neither neither CC 42759 608 27 time time NN 42759 608 28 nor nor CC 42759 608 29 labour labour NN 42759 608 30 in in IN 42759 608 31 the the DT 42759 608 32 interest interest NN 42759 608 33 of of IN 42759 608 34 the the DT 42759 608 35 latter latter JJ 42759 608 36 directly directly RB 42759 608 37 . . . 42759 609 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 609 2 labour labour NN 42759 609 3 is be VBZ 42759 609 4 precisely precisely RB 42759 609 5 what what WP 42759 609 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 609 7 would would MD 42759 609 8 have have VB 42759 609 9 been be VBN 42759 609 10 had have VBN 42759 609 11 there there RB 42759 609 12 been be VBN 42759 609 13 no no DT 42759 609 14 increase increase NN 42759 609 15 in in IN 42759 609 16 the the DT 42759 609 17 value value NN 42759 609 18 of of IN 42759 609 19 the the DT 42759 609 20 land land NN 42759 609 21 . . . 42759 610 1 Since since IN 42759 610 2 social social JJ 42759 610 3 production production NN 42759 610 4 does do VBZ 42759 610 5 not not RB 42759 610 6 constitute constitute VB 42759 610 7 a a DT 42759 610 8 right right NN 42759 610 9 to to IN 42759 610 10 land land NN 42759 610 11 values value NNS 42759 610 12 nor nor CC 42759 610 13 to to TO 42759 610 14 rent rent VB 42759 610 15 , , , 42759 610 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 610 17 affords afford VBZ 42759 610 18 not not RB 42759 610 19 a a DT 42759 610 20 shadow shadow NN 42759 610 21 of of IN 42759 610 22 justification justification NN 42759 610 23 for for IN 42759 610 24 the the DT 42759 610 25 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 610 26 of of IN 42759 610 27 these these DT 42759 610 28 things thing NNS 42759 610 29 by by IN 42759 610 30 the the DT 42759 610 31 community community NN 42759 610 32 . . . 42759 611 1 If if IN 42759 611 2 social social JJ 42759 611 3 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 611 4 of of IN 42759 611 5 socially socially RB 42759 611 6 created create VBN 42759 611 7 land land NN 42759 611 8 values value NNS 42759 611 9 had have VBD 42759 611 10 been be VBN 42759 611 11 introduced introduce VBN 42759 611 12 with with IN 42759 611 13 the the DT 42759 611 14 first first JJ 42759 611 15 occupation occupation NN 42759 611 16 of of IN 42759 611 17 a a DT 42759 611 18 piece piece NN 42759 611 19 of of IN 42759 611 20 land land NN 42759 611 21 , , , 42759 611 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 611 23 might may MD 42759 611 24 possibly possibly RB 42759 611 25 have have VB 42759 611 26 proved prove VBN 42759 611 27 more more RBR 42759 611 28 generally generally RB 42759 611 29 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 611 30 than than IN 42759 611 31 the the DT 42759 611 32 present present JJ 42759 611 33 system system NN 42759 611 34 . . . 42759 612 1 In in IN 42759 612 2 that that DT 42759 612 3 case case NN 42759 612 4 , , , 42759 612 5 however however RB 42759 612 6 , , , 42759 612 7 the the DT 42759 612 8 moral moral JJ 42759 612 9 claim claim NN 42759 612 10 of of IN 42759 612 11 the the DT 42759 612 12 community community NN 42759 612 13 to to IN 42759 612 14 these these DT 42759 612 15 values value NNS 42759 612 16 would would MD 42759 612 17 have have VB 42759 612 18 rested rest VBN 42759 612 19 on on IN 42759 612 20 the the DT 42759 612 21 fact fact NN 42759 612 22 that that IN 42759 612 23 they -PRON- PRP 42759 612 24 did do VBD 42759 612 25 not not RB 42759 612 26 belong belong VB 42759 612 27 to to IN 42759 612 28 anybody anybody NN 42759 612 29 by by IN 42759 612 30 a a DT 42759 612 31 title title NN 42759 612 32 of of IN 42759 612 33 strict strict JJ 42759 612 34 justice justice NN 42759 612 35 . . . 42759 613 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 613 2 would would MD 42759 613 3 have have VB 42759 613 4 been be VBN 42759 613 5 a a DT 42759 613 6 " " `` 42759 613 7 res res NNP 42759 613 8 nullius nullius NN 42759 613 9 " " '' 42759 613 10 ( ( -LRB- 42759 613 11 " " `` 42759 613 12 nobody nobody NN 42759 613 13 's 's POS 42759 613 14 property property NN 42759 613 15 " " '' 42759 613 16 ) ) -RRB- 42759 613 17 which which WDT 42759 613 18 might may MD 42759 613 19 fairly fairly RB 42759 613 20 have have VB 42759 613 21 been be VBN 42759 613 22 taken take VBN 42759 613 23 by by IN 42759 613 24 the the DT 42759 613 25 community community NN 42759 613 26 according accord VBG 42759 613 27 as as IN 42759 613 28 they -PRON- PRP 42759 613 29 made make VBD 42759 613 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 613 31 appearance appearance NN 42759 613 32 . . . 42759 614 1 The the DT 42759 614 2 community community NN 42759 614 3 could could MD 42759 614 4 have have VB 42759 614 5 appropriated appropriate VBN 42759 614 6 them -PRON- PRP 42759 614 7 by by IN 42759 614 8 the the DT 42759 614 9 title title NN 42759 614 10 of of IN 42759 614 11 first first JJ 42759 614 12 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 614 13 . . . 42759 615 1 But but CC 42759 615 2 there there EX 42759 615 3 could could MD 42759 615 4 have have VB 42759 615 5 been be VBN 42759 615 6 no no DT 42759 615 7 moral moral JJ 42759 615 8 title title NN 42759 615 9 of of IN 42759 615 10 social social JJ 42759 615 11 production production NN 42759 615 12 . . . 42759 616 1 When when WRB 42759 616 2 , , , 42759 616 3 however however RB 42759 616 4 , , , 42759 616 5 the the DT 42759 616 6 community community NN 42759 616 7 or or CC 42759 616 8 the the DT 42759 616 9 State State NNP 42759 616 10 failed fail VBD 42759 616 11 to to TO 42759 616 12 take take VB 42759 616 13 advantage advantage NN 42759 616 14 of of IN 42759 616 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 616 16 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 616 17 to to TO 42759 616 18 be be VB 42759 616 19 the the DT 42759 616 20 first first JJ 42759 616 21 occupant occupant NN 42759 616 22 of of IN 42759 616 23 these these DT 42759 616 24 values value NNS 42759 616 25 , , , 42759 616 26 when when WRB 42759 616 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 616 28 permitted permit VBD 42759 616 29 the the DT 42759 616 30 individual individual JJ 42759 616 31 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 616 32 to to TO 42759 616 33 appropriate appropriate VB 42759 616 34 them -PRON- PRP 42759 616 35 , , , 42759 616 36 it -PRON- PRP 42759 616 37 forfeited forfeit VBD 42759 616 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 616 39 own own JJ 42759 616 40 claim claim NN 42759 616 41 . . . 42759 617 1 Ever ever RB 42759 617 2 since since IN 42759 617 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 617 4 has have VBZ 42759 617 5 had have VBN 42759 617 6 no no DT 42759 617 7 more more RBR 42759 617 8 right right JJ 42759 617 9 to to IN 42759 617 10 already already RB 42759 617 11 existing exist VBG 42759 617 12 land land NN 42759 617 13 values value NNS 42759 617 14 than than IN 42759 617 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 617 16 has have VBZ 42759 617 17 to to TO 42759 617 18 seize seize VB 42759 617 19 the the DT 42759 617 20 labourer labourer NN 42759 617 21 's 's POS 42759 617 22 wages wage NNS 42759 617 23 or or CC 42759 617 24 the the DT 42759 617 25 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 617 26 's 's POS 42759 617 27 interest,--no interest,--no NNP 42759 617 28 more more RBR 42759 617 29 right right JJ 42759 617 30 than than IN 42759 617 31 one one CD 42759 617 32 person person NN 42759 617 33 has have VBZ 42759 617 34 to to TO 42759 617 35 recover recover VB 42759 617 36 a a DT 42759 617 37 gift gift NN 42759 617 38 or or CC 42759 617 39 donation donation NN 42759 617 40 that that IN 42759 617 41 he -PRON- PRP 42759 617 42 has have VBZ 42759 617 43 unconditionally unconditionally RB 42759 617 44 bestowed bestow VBN 42759 617 45 upon upon IN 42759 617 46 another another DT 42759 617 47 . . . 42759 618 1 To to TO 42759 618 2 sum sum VB 42759 618 3 up up RP 42759 618 4 the the DT 42759 618 5 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 618 6 of of IN 42759 618 7 this this DT 42759 618 8 chapter chapter NN 42759 618 9 : : : 42759 618 10 The the DT 42759 618 11 argument argument NN 42759 618 12 against against IN 42759 618 13 first first JJ 42759 618 14 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 618 15 is be VBZ 42759 618 16 valid valid JJ 42759 618 17 only only RB 42759 618 18 with with IN 42759 618 19 regard regard NN 42759 618 20 to to IN 42759 618 21 the the DT 42759 618 22 abuses abuse NNS 42759 618 23 of of IN 42759 618 24 private private JJ 42759 618 25 ownership ownership NN 42759 618 26 , , , 42759 618 27 not not RB 42759 618 28 with with IN 42759 618 29 regard regard NN 42759 618 30 to to IN 42759 618 31 the the DT 42759 618 32 institution institution NN 42759 618 33 ; ; : 42759 618 34 the the DT 42759 618 35 argument argument NN 42759 618 36 based base VBN 42759 618 37 upon upon IN 42759 618 38 the the DT 42759 618 39 title title NN 42759 618 40 of of IN 42759 618 41 labour labour NN 42759 618 42 is be VBZ 42759 618 43 the the DT 42759 618 44 outcome outcome NN 42759 618 45 of of IN 42759 618 46 a a DT 42759 618 47 faulty faulty JJ 42759 618 48 analysis analysis NN 42759 618 49 , , , 42759 618 50 and and CC 42759 618 51 is be VBZ 42759 618 52 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 42759 618 53 with with IN 42759 618 54 other other JJ 42759 618 55 statements statement NNS 42759 618 56 of of IN 42759 618 57 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 618 58 author author NN 42759 618 59 ; ; : 42759 618 60 the the DT 42759 618 61 argument argument NN 42759 618 62 derived derive VBD 42759 618 63 from from IN 42759 618 64 men man NNS 42759 618 65 's 's POS 42759 618 66 equal equal JJ 42759 618 67 rights right NNS 42759 618 68 to to TO 42759 618 69 land land NN 42759 618 70 merely merely RB 42759 618 71 proves prove VBZ 42759 618 72 that that IN 42759 618 73 private private JJ 42759 618 74 ownership ownership NN 42759 618 75 does do VBZ 42759 618 76 not not RB 42759 618 77 secure secure VB 42759 618 78 perfect perfect JJ 42759 618 79 justice justice NN 42759 618 80 , , , 42759 618 81 and and CC 42759 618 82 the the DT 42759 618 83 proposal proposal NN 42759 618 84 to to TO 42759 618 85 correct correct VB 42759 618 86 this this DT 42759 618 87 defect defect NN 42759 618 88 by by IN 42759 618 89 confiscating confiscate VBG 42759 618 90 rent rent NN 42759 618 91 is be VBZ 42759 618 92 unjust unjust JJ 42759 618 93 because because IN 42759 618 94 it -PRON- PRP 42759 618 95 would would MD 42759 618 96 produce produce VB 42759 618 97 greater great JJR 42759 618 98 evils evil NNS 42759 618 99 ; ; : 42759 618 100 and and CC 42759 618 101 the the DT 42759 618 102 so so RB 42759 618 103 called call VBN 42759 618 104 production production NN 42759 618 105 of of IN 42759 618 106 the the DT 42759 618 107 social social JJ 42759 618 108 values value NNS 42759 618 109 of of IN 42759 618 110 land land NN 42759 618 111 confers confer NNS 42759 618 112 upon upon IN 42759 618 113 the the DT 42759 618 114 community community NN 42759 618 115 no no DT 42759 618 116 property property NN 42759 618 117 right right RB 42759 618 118 whatever whatever WDT 42759 618 119 . . . 42759 619 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 619 2 : : : 42759 619 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 619 4 8 8 CD 42759 619 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 619 6 " " `` 42759 619 7 Socialism socialism NN 42759 619 8 : : : 42759 619 9 Utopian Utopian NNP 42759 619 10 and and CC 42759 619 11 Scientific Scientific NNP 42759 619 12 , , , 42759 619 13 " " '' 42759 619 14 p. p. NN 42759 619 15 45 45 CD 42759 619 16 ; ; : 42759 619 17 Chicago Chicago NNP 42759 619 18 , , , 42759 619 19 1900 1900 CD 42759 619 20 . . . 42759 620 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 620 2 9 9 CD 42759 620 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 620 4 " " `` 42759 620 5 A a DT 42759 620 6 summary summary NN 42759 620 7 of of IN 42759 620 8 the the DT 42759 620 9 Principles Principles NNPS 42759 620 10 of of IN 42759 620 11 Socialism socialism NN 42759 620 12 , , , 42759 620 13 " " '' 42759 620 14 p. p. NN 42759 620 15 23 23 CD 42759 620 16 ; ; : 42759 620 17 London London NNP 42759 620 18 , , , 42759 620 19 1899 1899 CD 42759 620 20 . . . 42759 621 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 621 2 10 10 CD 42759 621 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 621 4 " " `` 42759 621 5 Socialism socialism NN 42759 621 6 : : : 42759 621 7 A A NNP 42759 621 8 Reply Reply NNP 42759 621 9 to to IN 42759 621 10 the the DT 42759 621 11 Pope Pope NNP 42759 621 12 's 's POS 42759 621 13 Encyclical Encyclical NNP 42759 621 14 , , , 42759 621 15 " " '' 42759 621 16 p. p. NN 42759 621 17 4 4 CD 42759 621 18 ; ; : 42759 621 19 London London NNP 42759 621 20 , , , 42759 621 21 1899 1899 CD 42759 621 22 . . . 42759 622 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 622 2 11 11 CD 42759 622 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 622 4 " " `` 42759 622 5 Progress Progress NNP 42759 622 6 and and CC 42759 622 7 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 622 8 , , , 42759 622 9 " " '' 42759 622 10 book book NN 42759 622 11 vii vii NN 42759 622 12 , , , 42759 622 13 ch ch NN 42759 622 14 . . . 42759 623 1 i. i. NNP 42759 624 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 624 2 12 12 CD 42759 624 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 624 4 " " `` 42759 624 5 La La NNP 42759 624 6 Propriété Propriété NNP 42759 624 7 Privée Privée NNP 42759 624 8 , , , 42759 624 9 " " '' 42759 624 10 par par NN 42759 624 11 L. L. NNP 42759 624 12 Garriguet Garriguet NNP 42759 624 13 , , , 42759 624 14 I -PRON- PRP 42759 624 15 , , , 42759 624 16 62 62 CD 42759 624 17 ; ; : 42759 624 18 Paris Paris NNP 42759 624 19 , , , 42759 624 20 1903 1903 CD 42759 624 21 . . . 42759 625 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 625 2 13 13 CD 42759 625 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 625 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 625 5 . . . 42759 626 1 Ardant ardant JJ 42759 626 2 , , , 42759 626 3 " " '' 42759 626 4 Papes Papes NNPS 42759 626 5 et et NN 42759 626 6 Paysans Paysans NNPS 42759 626 7 , , , 42759 626 8 " " '' 42759 626 9 pp pp NNP 42759 626 10 . . . 42759 627 1 41 41 CD 42759 627 2 , , , 42759 627 3 sq sq NNP 42759 627 4 . . . 42759 628 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 628 2 14 14 CD 42759 628 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 628 4 " " `` 42759 628 5 Social Social NNP 42759 628 6 Statics Statics NNPS 42759 628 7 , , , 42759 628 8 " " '' 42759 628 9 chap chap NNP 42759 628 10 , , , 42759 628 11 ix ix IN 42759 628 12 ; ; : 42759 628 13 1850 1850 CD 42759 628 14 . . . 42759 629 1 Spencer Spencer NNP 42759 629 2 's 's POS 42759 629 3 retractation retractation NN 42759 629 4 , , , 42759 629 5 in in IN 42759 629 6 a a DT 42759 629 7 later later JJ 42759 629 8 edition edition NN 42759 629 9 of of IN 42759 629 10 this this DT 42759 629 11 work work NN 42759 629 12 , , , 42759 629 13 of of IN 42759 629 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 629 15 earlier early JJR 42759 629 16 views view NNS 42759 629 17 on on IN 42759 629 18 the the DT 42759 629 19 right right NN 42759 629 20 of of IN 42759 629 21 property property NN 42759 629 22 in in IN 42759 629 23 land land NN 42759 629 24 does do VBZ 42759 629 25 not not RB 42759 629 26 affect affect VB 42759 629 27 the the DT 42759 629 28 truth truth NN 42759 629 29 of of IN 42759 629 30 the the DT 42759 629 31 description description NN 42759 629 32 quoted quote VBN 42759 629 33 in in IN 42759 629 34 the the DT 42759 629 35 passage passage NN 42759 629 36 above above RB 42759 629 37 . . . 42759 630 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 630 2 15 15 CD 42759 630 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 630 4 " " `` 42759 630 5 Progress Progress NNP 42759 630 6 and and CC 42759 630 7 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 630 8 , , , 42759 630 9 " " '' 42759 630 10 loc loc NNP 42759 630 11 . . . 42759 631 1 cit cit NNP 42759 631 2 . . . 42759 632 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 632 2 16 16 CD 42759 632 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 632 4 " " `` 42759 632 5 Open Open NNP 42759 632 6 Letter letter NN 42759 632 7 to to IN 42759 632 8 Pope Pope NNP 42759 632 9 Leo Leo NNP 42759 632 10 XIII XIII NNP 42759 632 11 , , , 42759 632 12 " " '' 42759 632 13 page page NN 42759 632 14 25 25 CD 42759 632 15 of of IN 42759 632 16 Vierth Vierth NNP 42759 632 17 's 's POS 42759 632 18 edition edition NN 42759 632 19 . . . 42759 633 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 633 2 17 17 CD 42759 633 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 633 4 " " `` 42759 633 5 Progress Progress NNP 42759 633 6 and and CC 42759 633 7 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 633 8 , , , 42759 633 9 " " '' 42759 633 10 loc loc NNP 42759 633 11 . . . 42759 634 1 cit cit NNP 42759 634 2 . . . 42759 635 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 635 2 18 18 CD 42759 635 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 635 4 " " `` 42759 635 5 Progress Progress NNP 42759 635 6 and and CC 42759 635 7 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 635 8 , , , 42759 635 9 " " '' 42759 635 10 loc loc NNP 42759 635 11 . . . 42759 636 1 cit cit NNP 42759 636 2 . . . 42759 637 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 637 2 19 19 CD 42759 637 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 637 4 " " `` 42759 637 5 Open Open NNP 42759 637 6 Letter letter NN 42759 637 7 to to IN 42759 637 8 Pope Pope NNP 42759 637 9 Leo Leo NNP 42759 637 10 XIII XIII NNP 42759 637 11 , , , 42759 637 12 " " '' 42759 637 13 loc loc NN 42759 637 14 . . . 42759 638 1 cit cit NNP 42759 638 2 . . . 42759 639 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 639 2 20 20 CD 42759 639 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 639 4 Whittaker Whittaker NNP 42759 639 5 , , , 42759 639 6 op op NN 42759 639 7 . . . 42759 640 1 cit cit NNP 42759 640 2 . . NNP 42759 640 3 , , , 42759 640 4 p. p. NN 42759 640 5 32 32 CD 42759 640 6 . . . 42759 641 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 641 2 21 21 CD 42759 641 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 641 4 " " `` 42759 641 5 Open Open NNP 42759 641 6 Letter letter NN 42759 641 7 , , , 42759 641 8 " " '' 42759 641 9 loc loc NNP 42759 641 10 . . . 42759 642 1 cit cit NNP 42759 642 2 . . . 42759 643 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 643 2 22 22 CD 42759 643 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 643 4 " " `` 42759 643 5 Progress Progress NNP 42759 643 6 and and CC 42759 643 7 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 643 8 , , , 42759 643 9 " " '' 42759 643 10 book book NN 42759 643 11 vii vii NN 42759 643 12 , , , 42759 643 13 ch ch NN 42759 643 14 . . . 42759 644 1 i. i. NNP 42759 645 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 645 2 23 23 CD 42759 645 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 645 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 645 5 . . . 42759 646 1 chapter chapter NN 42759 646 2 entitled entitle VBN 42759 646 3 " " `` 42759 646 4 Compensation Compensation NNP 42759 646 5 " " '' 42759 646 6 in in IN 42759 646 7 " " `` 42759 646 8 A A NNP 42759 646 9 Perplexed perplexed JJ 42759 646 10 Philosopher philosopher NN 42759 646 11 . . . 42759 646 12 " " '' 42759 647 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 647 2 24 24 CD 42759 647 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 647 4 Cf cf NN 42759 647 5 . . . 42759 648 1 " " `` 42759 648 2 Principles principle NNS 42759 648 3 of of IN 42759 648 4 Political political JJ 42759 648 5 Economy Economy NNP 42759 648 6 , , , 42759 648 7 " " '' 42759 648 8 1891 1891 CD 42759 648 9 , , , 42759 648 10 p. p. NN 42759 648 11 130 130 CD 42759 648 12 . . . 42759 649 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 649 2 25 25 CD 42759 649 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 649 4 " " `` 42759 649 5 Progress Progress NNP 42759 649 6 and and CC 42759 649 7 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 649 8 . . . 42759 649 9 " " '' 42759 650 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 650 2 26 26 CD 42759 650 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 650 4 " " `` 42759 650 5 Progress Progress NNP 42759 650 6 and and CC 42759 650 7 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 650 8 , , , 42759 650 9 " " '' 42759 650 10 book book NN 42759 650 11 vii vii NN 42759 650 12 , , , 42759 650 13 ch ch NN 42759 650 14 . . . 42759 651 1 iii iii NNP 42759 651 2 . . . 42759 652 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 42759 652 2 IV IV NNP 42759 652 3 PRIVATE private JJ 42759 652 4 OWNERSHIP OWNERSHIP VBD 42759 652 5 THE the DT 42759 652 6 BEST best NN 42759 652 7 SYSTEM system NN 42759 652 8 OF of IN 42759 652 9 LAND land NN 42759 652 10 TENURE tenure NN 42759 652 11 The the DT 42759 652 12 defence defence NN 42759 652 13 of of IN 42759 652 14 private private JJ 42759 652 15 landownership landownership NN 42759 652 16 set set VBN 42759 652 17 forth forth RP 42759 652 18 in in IN 42759 652 19 the the DT 42759 652 20 last last JJ 42759 652 21 chapter chapter NN 42759 652 22 has have VBZ 42759 652 23 been be VBN 42759 652 24 conditional conditional JJ 42759 652 25 . . . 42759 653 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 653 2 has have VBZ 42759 653 3 tended tend VBN 42759 653 4 to to TO 42759 653 5 show show VB 42759 653 6 that that IN 42759 653 7 the the DT 42759 653 8 institution institution NN 42759 653 9 is be VBZ 42759 653 10 morally morally RB 42759 653 11 lawful lawful JJ 42759 653 12 so so RB 42759 653 13 long long RB 42759 653 14 as as IN 42759 653 15 no no DT 42759 653 16 better well JJR 42759 653 17 system system NN 42759 653 18 is be VBZ 42759 653 19 available available JJ 42759 653 20 . . . 42759 654 1 As as RB 42759 654 2 soon soon RB 42759 654 3 as as IN 42759 654 4 a a DT 42759 654 5 better well JJR 42759 654 6 system system NN 42759 654 7 has have VBZ 42759 654 8 been be VBN 42759 654 9 discovered discover VBN 42759 654 10 , , , 42759 654 11 the the DT 42759 654 12 State State NNP 42759 654 13 and and CC 42759 654 14 the the DT 42759 654 15 citizens citizen NNS 42759 654 16 are be VBP 42759 654 17 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 654 18 under under IN 42759 654 19 some some DT 42759 654 20 degree degree NN 42759 654 21 of of IN 42759 654 22 moral moral JJ 42759 654 23 obligation obligation NN 42759 654 24 to to TO 42759 654 25 put put VB 42759 654 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 654 27 into into IN 42759 654 28 practice practice NN 42759 654 29 . . . 42759 655 1 Hence hence RB 42759 655 2 the the DT 42759 655 3 important important JJ 42759 655 4 present present JJ 42759 655 5 question question NN 42759 655 6 is be VBZ 42759 655 7 whether whether IN 42759 655 8 this this DT 42759 655 9 condition condition NN 42759 655 10 or or CC 42759 655 11 contingency contingency NN 42759 655 12 has have VBZ 42759 655 13 become become VBN 42759 655 14 a a DT 42759 655 15 reality reality NN 42759 655 16 . . . 42759 656 1 The the DT 42759 656 2 only only JJ 42759 656 3 proposed propose VBN 42759 656 4 and and CC 42759 656 5 the the DT 42759 656 6 only only JJ 42759 656 7 possible possible JJ 42759 656 8 alternative alternative JJ 42759 656 9 systems system NNS 42759 656 10 are be VBP 42759 656 11 Socialism socialism NN 42759 656 12 and and CC 42759 656 13 the the DT 42759 656 14 Single Single NNP 42759 656 15 Tax Tax NNP 42759 656 16 . . . 42759 657 1 All all DT 42759 657 2 other other JJ 42759 657 3 forms form NNS 42759 657 4 of of IN 42759 657 5 tenure tenure NN 42759 657 6 are be VBP 42759 657 7 properly properly RB 42759 657 8 classed class VBN 42759 657 9 as as IN 42759 657 10 modifications modification NNS 42759 657 11 of of IN 42759 657 12 private private JJ 42759 657 13 ownership ownership NN 42759 657 14 , , , 42759 657 15 rather rather RB 42759 657 16 than than IN 42759 657 17 as as RB 42759 657 18 distinct distinct JJ 42759 657 19 systems system NNS 42759 657 20 . . . 42759 658 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 658 2 the the DT 42759 658 3 worth worth JJ 42759 658 4 , , , 42759 658 5 and and CC 42759 658 6 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 658 7 , , , 42759 658 8 and and CC 42759 658 9 morality morality NN 42759 658 10 of of IN 42759 658 11 private private JJ 42759 658 12 ownership ownership NN 42759 658 13 can can MD 42759 658 14 be be VB 42759 658 15 adequately adequately RB 42759 658 16 determined determine VBN 42759 658 17 by by IN 42759 658 18 comparison comparison NN 42759 658 19 with with IN 42759 658 20 the the DT 42759 658 21 two two CD 42759 658 22 just just RB 42759 658 23 mentioned mention VBN 42759 658 24 . . . 42759 659 1 _ _ NNP 42759 659 2 The the DT 42759 659 3 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 659 4 Proposals Proposals NNPS 42759 659 5 Impracticable Impracticable NNP 42759 659 6 _ _ NNP 42759 659 7 As as IN 42759 659 8 now now RB 42759 659 9 existing exist VBG 42759 659 10 and and CC 42759 659 11 as as IN 42759 659 12 commonly commonly RB 42759 659 13 understood understand VBN 42759 659 14 , , , 42759 659 15 private private JJ 42759 659 16 landownership landownership NN 42759 659 17 comprises comprise VBZ 42759 659 18 four four CD 42759 659 19 elements element NNS 42759 659 20 which which WDT 42759 659 21 are be VBP 42759 659 22 not not RB 42759 659 23 found find VBN 42759 659 24 together together RB 42759 659 25 in in IN 42759 659 26 either either CC 42759 659 27 Socialism socialism NN 42759 659 28 or or CC 42759 659 29 the the DT 42759 659 30 Single Single NNP 42759 659 31 Tax Tax NNP 42759 659 32 . . . 42759 660 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 660 2 are be VBP 42759 660 3 : : : 42759 660 4 security security NN 42759 660 5 of of IN 42759 660 6 possession possession NN 42759 660 7 combined combine VBN 42759 660 8 with with IN 42759 660 9 the the DT 42759 660 10 power power NN 42759 660 11 to to TO 42759 660 12 transfer transfer VB 42759 660 13 and and CC 42759 660 14 transmit transmit VB 42759 660 15 ; ; : 42759 660 16 the the DT 42759 660 17 use use NN 42759 660 18 of of IN 42759 660 19 land land NN 42759 660 20 combined combine VBN 42759 660 21 with with IN 42759 660 22 the the DT 42759 660 23 power power NN 42759 660 24 to to TO 42759 660 25 let let VB 42759 660 26 the the DT 42759 660 27 use use NN 42759 660 28 to to IN 42759 660 29 others other NNS 42759 660 30 ; ; : 42759 660 31 the the DT 42759 660 32 receipt receipt NN 42759 660 33 of of IN 42759 660 34 revenue revenue NN 42759 660 35 from from IN 42759 660 36 improvements improvement NNS 42759 660 37 in in IN 42759 660 38 or or CC 42759 660 39 upon upon IN 42759 660 40 the the DT 42759 660 41 land land NN 42759 660 42 ; ; : 42759 660 43 and and CC 42759 660 44 the the DT 42759 660 45 receipt receipt NN 42759 660 46 of of IN 42759 660 47 economic economic JJ 42759 660 48 rent rent NN 42759 660 49 , , , 42759 660 50 the the DT 42759 660 51 revenue revenue NN 42759 660 52 due due IN 42759 660 53 to to IN 42759 660 54 the the DT 42759 660 55 land land NN 42759 660 56 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 660 57 , , , 42759 660 58 apart apart RB 42759 660 59 from from IN 42759 660 60 improvements improvement NNS 42759 660 61 . . . 42759 661 1 In in IN 42759 661 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 661 3 extreme extreme JJ 42759 661 4 form form NN 42759 661 5 , , , 42759 661 6 and and CC 42759 661 7 as as IN 42759 661 8 formerly formerly RB 42759 661 9 understood understand VBN 42759 661 10 by by IN 42759 661 11 the the DT 42759 661 12 majority majority NN 42759 661 13 of of IN 42759 661 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 661 15 authoritative authoritative JJ 42759 661 16 exponents exponent NNS 42759 661 17 , , , 42759 661 18 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 661 19 would would MD 42759 661 20 take take VB 42759 661 21 from from IN 42759 661 22 the the DT 42759 661 23 individual individual NN 42759 661 24 all all DT 42759 661 25 of of IN 42759 661 26 these these DT 42759 661 27 elements element NNS 42759 661 28 or or CC 42759 661 29 powers power NNS 42759 661 30 . . . 42759 662 1 The the DT 42759 662 2 State State NNP 42759 662 3 , , , 42759 662 4 or or CC 42759 662 5 the the DT 42759 662 6 Collectivity collectivity NN 42759 662 7 , , , 42759 662 8 would would MD 42759 662 9 own own VB 42759 662 10 and and CC 42759 662 11 manage manage VB 42759 662 12 all all DT 42759 662 13 productive productive JJ 42759 662 14 land land NN 42759 662 15 and and CC 42759 662 16 land land NN 42759 662 17 - - HYPH 42759 662 18 capital capital NN 42759 662 19 , , , 42759 662 20 and and CC 42759 662 21 would would MD 42759 662 22 receive receive VB 42759 662 23 and and CC 42759 662 24 distribute distribute VB 42759 662 25 the the DT 42759 662 26 product product NN 42759 662 27 . . . 42759 663 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 663 2 the the DT 42759 663 3 cultivators cultivator NNS 42759 663 4 of of IN 42759 663 5 the the DT 42759 663 6 land land NN 42759 663 7 would would MD 42759 663 8 be be VB 42759 663 9 deprived deprive VBN 42759 663 10 of of IN 42759 663 11 even even RB 42759 663 12 that that DT 42759 663 13 limited limited JJ 42759 663 14 degree degree NN 42759 663 15 of of IN 42759 663 16 control control NN 42759 663 17 which which WDT 42759 663 18 is be VBZ 42759 663 19 now now RB 42759 663 20 possessed possess VBN 42759 663 21 by by IN 42759 663 22 the the DT 42759 663 23 tenant tenant NN 42759 663 24 on on IN 42759 663 25 a a DT 42759 663 26 rented rent VBN 42759 663 27 farm farm NN 42759 663 28 ; ; : 42759 663 29 for for IN 42759 663 30 the the DT 42759 663 31 latter latter JJ 42759 663 32 , , , 42759 663 33 though though IN 42759 663 34 not not RB 42759 663 35 a a DT 42759 663 36 landowner landowner NN 42759 663 37 , , , 42759 663 38 is be VBZ 42759 663 39 the the DT 42759 663 40 owner owner NN 42759 663 41 of of IN 42759 663 42 a a DT 42759 663 43 farming farming NN 42759 663 44 business business NN 42759 663 45 , , , 42759 663 46 and and CC 42759 663 47 of of IN 42759 663 48 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 663 49 instruments instrument NNS 42759 663 50 of of IN 42759 663 51 production production NN 42759 663 52 . . . 42759 664 1 Under under IN 42759 664 2 Socialism socialism NN 42759 664 3 the the DT 42759 664 4 users user NNS 42759 664 5 of of IN 42759 664 6 the the DT 42759 664 7 land land NN 42759 664 8 would would MD 42759 664 9 not not RB 42759 664 10 receive receive VB 42759 664 11 the the DT 42759 664 12 revenue revenue NN 42759 664 13 either either CC 42759 664 14 from from IN 42759 664 15 improvements improvement NNS 42759 664 16 or or CC 42759 664 17 from from IN 42759 664 18 the the DT 42759 664 19 land land NN 42759 664 20 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 664 21 . . . 42759 665 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 665 2 would would MD 42759 665 3 be be VB 42759 665 4 substantially substantially RB 42759 665 5 employés employés JJ 42759 665 6 of of IN 42759 665 7 the the DT 42759 665 8 community community NN 42759 665 9 , , , 42759 665 10 receiving receive VBG 42759 665 11 a a DT 42759 665 12 share share NN 42759 665 13 of of IN 42759 665 14 the the DT 42759 665 15 product product NN 42759 665 16 according accord VBG 42759 665 17 to to IN 42759 665 18 some some DT 42759 665 19 plan plan NN 42759 665 20 of of IN 42759 665 21 distribution distribution NN 42759 665 22 established establish VBN 42759 665 23 by by IN 42759 665 24 public public JJ 42759 665 25 authority authority NN 42759 665 26 . . . 42759 666 1 Land land NN 42759 666 2 occupied occupy VBN 42759 666 3 by by IN 42759 666 4 dwellings dwelling NNS 42759 666 5 would would MD 42759 666 6 likewise likewise RB 42759 666 7 be be VB 42759 666 8 owned own VBN 42759 666 9 and and CC 42759 666 10 managed manage VBN 42759 666 11 by by IN 42759 666 12 the the DT 42759 666 13 State State NNP 42759 666 14 , , , 42759 666 15 although although IN 42759 666 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 666 17 product product NN 42759 666 18 , , , 42759 666 19 the the DT 42759 666 20 benefit benefit NN 42759 666 21 of of IN 42759 666 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 666 23 use use NN 42759 666 24 , , , 42759 666 25 would would MD 42759 666 26 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 666 27 go go VB 42759 666 28 in in IN 42759 666 29 the the DT 42759 666 30 first first JJ 42759 666 31 instance instance NN 42759 666 32 to to IN 42759 666 33 the the DT 42759 666 34 occupier occupier NN 42759 666 35 . . . 42759 667 1 In in IN 42759 667 2 return return NN 42759 667 3 for for IN 42759 667 4 this this DT 42759 667 5 benefit benefit NN 42759 667 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 667 7 would would MD 42759 667 8 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 667 9 be be VB 42759 667 10 required require VBN 42759 667 11 to to TO 42759 667 12 pay pay VB 42759 667 13 some some DT 42759 667 14 kind kind NN 42759 667 15 of of IN 42759 667 16 rent rent NN 42759 667 17 to to IN 42759 667 18 the the DT 42759 667 19 State State NNP 42759 667 20 . . . 42759 668 1 Now now RB 42759 668 2 the the DT 42759 668 3 majority majority NN 42759 668 4 of of IN 42759 668 5 persons person NNS 42759 668 6 believe believe VBP 42759 668 7 that that IN 42759 668 8 this this DT 42759 668 9 system system NN 42759 668 10 of of IN 42759 668 11 land land NN 42759 668 12 tenure tenure NN 42759 668 13 would would MD 42759 668 14 be be VB 42759 668 15 inferior inferior JJ 42759 668 16 to to IN 42759 668 17 private private JJ 42759 668 18 ownership ownership NN 42759 668 19 , , , 42759 668 20 both both CC 42759 668 21 as as IN 42759 668 22 regards regard VBZ 42759 668 23 individual individual JJ 42759 668 24 welfare welfare NN 42759 668 25 and and CC 42759 668 26 social social JJ 42759 668 27 welfare welfare NN 42759 668 28 . . . 42759 669 1 The the DT 42759 669 2 reasons reason NNS 42759 669 3 for for IN 42759 669 4 this this DT 42759 669 5 belief belief NN 42759 669 6 will will MD 42759 669 7 be be VB 42759 669 8 given give VBN 42759 669 9 in in IN 42759 669 10 detail detail NN 42759 669 11 in in IN 42759 669 12 the the DT 42759 669 13 chapter chapter NN 42759 669 14 on on IN 42759 669 15 " " `` 42759 669 16 The The NNP 42759 669 17 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 669 18 Scheme Scheme NNP 42759 669 19 of of IN 42759 669 20 Industry Industry NNP 42759 669 21 . . . 42759 669 22 " " '' 42759 670 1 For for IN 42759 670 2 the the DT 42759 670 3 present present NN 42759 670 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 670 5 will will MD 42759 670 6 be be VB 42759 670 7 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 670 8 to to TO 42759 670 9 point point VB 42759 670 10 out out RP 42759 670 11 in in IN 42759 670 12 a a DT 42759 670 13 summary summary NN 42759 670 14 way way NN 42759 670 15 that that IN 42759 670 16 Socialism socialism NN 42759 670 17 would would MD 42759 670 18 be be VB 42759 670 19 unable unable JJ 42759 670 20 to to TO 42759 670 21 organise organise VB 42759 670 22 and and CC 42759 670 23 carry carry VB 42759 670 24 on on RP 42759 670 25 efficiently efficiently RB 42759 670 26 all all DT 42759 670 27 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 670 28 and and CC 42759 670 29 extractive extractive JJ 42759 670 30 industries industry NNS 42759 670 31 , , , 42759 670 32 either either CC 42759 670 33 under under IN 42759 670 34 one one CD 42759 670 35 central central JJ 42759 670 36 direction direction NN 42759 670 37 or or CC 42759 670 38 under under IN 42759 670 39 many many JJ 42759 670 40 provincial provincial JJ 42759 670 41 authorities authority NNS 42759 670 42 ; ; : 42759 670 43 that that IN 42759 670 44 it -PRON- PRP 42759 670 45 could could MD 42759 670 46 not not RB 42759 670 47 adjust adjust VB 42759 670 48 wages wage NNS 42759 670 49 and and CC 42759 670 50 salaries salary NNS 42759 670 51 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 42759 670 52 , , , 42759 670 53 nor nor CC 42759 670 54 give give VB 42759 670 55 the the DT 42759 670 56 individual individual JJ 42759 670 57 worker worker NN 42759 670 58 an an DT 42759 670 59 incentive incentive NN 42759 670 60 as as RB 42759 670 61 effective effective JJ 42759 670 62 as as IN 42759 670 63 the the DT 42759 670 64 self self NN 42759 670 65 interest interest NN 42759 670 66 that that WDT 42759 670 67 goes go VBZ 42759 670 68 with with IN 42759 670 69 private private JJ 42759 670 70 ownership ownership NN 42759 670 71 ; ; : 42759 670 72 that that IN 42759 670 73 it -PRON- PRP 42759 670 74 would would MD 42759 670 75 deprive deprive VB 42759 670 76 the the DT 42759 670 77 worker worker NN 42759 670 78 of of IN 42759 670 79 a a DT 42759 670 80 great great JJ 42759 670 81 part part NN 42759 670 82 of of IN 42759 670 83 the the DT 42759 670 84 freedom freedom NN 42759 670 85 that that WDT 42759 670 86 he -PRON- PRP 42759 670 87 now now RB 42759 670 88 enjoys enjoy VBZ 42759 670 89 in in IN 42759 670 90 the the DT 42759 670 91 matters matter NNS 42759 670 92 of of IN 42759 670 93 occupation occupation NN 42759 670 94 and and CC 42759 670 95 residence residence NN 42759 670 96 ; ; : 42759 670 97 that that IN 42759 670 98 it -PRON- PRP 42759 670 99 would would MD 42759 670 100 leave leave VB 42759 670 101 to to IN 42759 670 102 the the DT 42759 670 103 consumer consumer NN 42759 670 104 less less JJR 42759 670 105 choice choice NN 42759 670 106 in in IN 42759 670 107 the the DT 42759 670 108 demand demand NN 42759 670 109 for for IN 42759 670 110 the the DT 42759 670 111 products product NNS 42759 670 112 of of IN 42759 670 113 land land NN 42759 670 114 ; ; : 42759 670 115 that that IN 42759 670 116 it -PRON- PRP 42759 670 117 would would MD 42759 670 118 place place VB 42759 670 119 all all PDT 42759 670 120 the the DT 42759 670 121 people people NNS 42759 670 122 in in IN 42759 670 123 a a DT 42759 670 124 position position NN 42759 670 125 of of IN 42759 670 126 dependence dependence NN 42759 670 127 upon upon IN 42759 670 128 a a DT 42759 670 129 single single JJ 42759 670 130 agency agency NN 42759 670 131 for for IN 42759 670 132 all all PDT 42759 670 133 these these DT 42759 670 134 products product NNS 42759 670 135 ; ; , 42759 670 136 and and CC 42759 670 137 that that IN 42759 670 138 it -PRON- PRP 42759 670 139 would would MD 42759 670 140 make make VB 42759 670 141 all all DT 42759 670 142 land land NN 42759 670 143 users user NNS 42759 670 144 , , , 42759 670 145 whether whether IN 42759 670 146 as as IN 42759 670 147 workers worker NNS 42759 670 148 or or CC 42759 670 149 as as IN 42759 670 150 residents resident NNS 42759 670 151 , , , 42759 670 152 tenants tenant NNS 42759 670 153 - - HYPH 42759 670 154 at at IN 42759 670 155 - - HYPH 42759 670 156 will will NN 42759 670 157 on on IN 42759 670 158 the the DT 42759 670 159 property property NN 42759 670 160 of of IN 42759 670 161 the the DT 42759 670 162 State State NNP 42759 670 163 . . . 42759 671 1 From from IN 42759 671 2 the the DT 42759 671 3 nature nature NN 42759 671 4 of of IN 42759 671 5 the the DT 42759 671 6 case case NN 42759 671 7 , , , 42759 671 8 none none NN 42759 671 9 of of IN 42759 671 10 the the DT 42759 671 11 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 671 12 propositions proposition NNS 42759 671 13 can can MD 42759 671 14 be be VB 42759 671 15 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 42759 671 16 mathematically mathematically RB 42759 671 17 . . . 42759 672 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 672 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 672 3 are be VBP 42759 672 4 as as RB 42759 672 5 nearly nearly RB 42759 672 6 evident evident JJ 42759 672 7 as as IN 42759 672 8 any any DT 42759 672 9 other other JJ 42759 672 10 practical practical JJ 42759 672 11 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 672 12 which which WDT 42759 672 13 are be VBP 42759 672 14 based base VBN 42759 672 15 upon upon IN 42759 672 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 672 17 general general JJ 42759 672 18 experience experience NN 42759 672 19 of of IN 42759 672 20 human human JJ 42759 672 21 nature nature NN 42759 672 22 , , , 42759 672 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 672 24 tendencies tendency NNS 42759 672 25 , , , 42759 672 26 and and CC 42759 672 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 672 28 limitations limitation NNS 42759 672 29 . . . 42759 673 1 At at IN 42759 673 2 any any DT 42759 673 3 rate rate NN 42759 673 4 , , , 42759 673 5 the the DT 42759 673 6 burden burden NN 42759 673 7 of of IN 42759 673 8 proof proof NN 42759 673 9 is be VBZ 42759 673 10 upon upon IN 42759 673 11 the the DT 42759 673 12 advocates advocate NNS 42759 673 13 of of IN 42759 673 14 the the DT 42759 673 15 new new JJ 42759 673 16 system system NN 42759 673 17 . . . 42759 674 1 Until until IN 42759 674 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 674 3 have have VBP 42759 674 4 assumed assume VBN 42759 674 5 and and CC 42759 674 6 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 42759 674 7 disposed dispose VBN 42759 674 8 of of IN 42759 674 9 this this DT 42759 674 10 burden burden NN 42759 674 11 , , , 42759 674 12 we -PRON- PRP 42759 674 13 are be VBP 42759 674 14 justified justify VBN 42759 674 15 in in IN 42759 674 16 rejecting reject VBG 42759 674 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 674 18 prophecies prophecy NNS 42759 674 19 , , , 42759 674 20 and and CC 42759 674 21 in in IN 42759 674 22 maintaining maintain VBG 42759 674 23 the the DT 42759 674 24 superiority superiority NN 42759 674 25 of of IN 42759 674 26 private private JJ 42759 674 27 ownership ownership NN 42759 674 28 . . . 42759 675 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 675 2 27 27 CD 42759 675 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 675 4 To to NN 42759 675 5 - - HYPH 42759 675 6 day day NN 42759 675 7 , , , 42759 675 8 however however RB 42759 675 9 , , , 42759 675 10 many many JJ 42759 675 11 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 675 12 , , , 42759 675 13 possibly possibly RB 42759 675 14 the the DT 42759 675 15 majority majority NN 42759 675 16 of of IN 42759 675 17 them -PRON- PRP 42759 675 18 in in IN 42759 675 19 some some DT 42759 675 20 countries country NNS 42759 675 21 , , , 42759 675 22 would would MD 42759 675 23 reject reject VB 42759 675 24 the the DT 42759 675 25 extreme extreme JJ 42759 675 26 form form NN 42759 675 27 of of IN 42759 675 28 land land NN 42759 675 29 socialisation socialisation NN 42759 675 30 discussed discuss VBN 42759 675 31 in in IN 42759 675 32 the the DT 42759 675 33 preceding precede VBG 42759 675 34 paragraphs paragraph NNS 42759 675 35 . . . 42759 676 1 " " `` 42759 676 2 The the DT 42759 676 3 nearest near JJS 42759 676 4 approach approach NN 42759 676 5 which which WDT 42759 676 6 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 676 7 have have VBP 42759 676 8 made make VBN 42759 676 9 to to IN 42759 676 10 a a DT 42759 676 11 _ _ NNP 42759 676 12 volte volte NNP 42759 676 13 face face NN 42759 676 14 _ _ NNP 42759 676 15 since since IN 42759 676 16 Marx Marx NNP 42759 676 17 , , , 42759 676 18 has have VBZ 42759 676 19 been be VBN 42759 676 20 in in IN 42759 676 21 relation relation NN 42759 676 22 to to IN 42759 676 23 Agrarianism agrarianism NN 42759 676 24 .... .... . 42759 676 25 Marx Marx NNP 42759 676 26 thought think VBD 42759 676 27 that that IN 42759 676 28 the the DT 42759 676 29 advantage advantage NN 42759 676 30 of of IN 42759 676 31 concentrating concentrating NN 42759 676 32 capital capital NN 42759 676 33 would would MD 42759 676 34 be be VB 42759 676 35 felt feel VBN 42759 676 36 in in IN 42759 676 37 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 676 38 as as IN 42759 676 39 in in IN 42759 676 40 other other JJ 42759 676 41 industries industry NNS 42759 676 42 ; ; : 42759 676 43 but but CC 42759 676 44 , , , 42759 676 45 in in IN 42759 676 46 spite spite NN 42759 676 47 of of IN 42759 676 48 a a DT 42759 676 49 temporary temporary JJ 42759 676 50 confirmation confirmation NN 42759 676 51 of of IN 42759 676 52 this this DT 42759 676 53 view view NN 42759 676 54 by by IN 42759 676 55 the the DT 42759 676 56 mammoth mammoth JJ 42759 676 57 farms farm NNS 42759 676 58 which which WDT 42759 676 59 sprang spring VBD 42759 676 60 up up RP 42759 676 61 in in IN 42759 676 62 North North NNP 42759 676 63 America America NNP 42759 676 64 , , , 42759 676 65 it -PRON- PRP 42759 676 66 now now RB 42759 676 67 appears appear VBZ 42759 676 68 very very RB 42759 676 69 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 676 70 .... .... . 42759 677 1 Recognition Recognition NNP 42759 677 2 of of IN 42759 677 3 this this DT 42759 677 4 has have VBZ 42759 677 5 led lead VBN 42759 677 6 reformists reformist NNS 42759 677 7 to to TO 42759 677 8 substitute substitute VB 42759 677 9 a a DT 42759 677 10 policy policy NN 42759 677 11 of of IN 42759 677 12 actively actively RB 42759 677 13 assisting assist VBG 42759 677 14 the the DT 42759 677 15 peasants peasant NNS 42759 677 16 for for IN 42759 677 17 the the DT 42759 677 18 orthodox orthodox JJ 42759 677 19 policy policy NN 42759 677 20 of of IN 42759 677 21 leaving leave VBG 42759 677 22 them -PRON- PRP 42759 677 23 to to TO 42759 677 24 succumb succumb VB 42759 677 25 to to IN 42759 677 26 capitalism capitalism NN 42759 677 27 . . . 42759 678 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 678 2 formula formula NN 42759 678 3 is be VBZ 42759 678 4 : : : 42759 678 5 ' ' '' 42759 678 6 Collectivise Collectivise NNP 42759 678 7 credit credit NN 42759 678 8 , , , 42759 678 9 transport transport NN 42759 678 10 , , , 42759 678 11 exchange exchange NN 42759 678 12 , , , 42759 678 13 and and CC 42759 678 14 all all DT 42759 678 15 subsidiary subsidiary NN 42759 678 16 manufacture manufacture NN 42759 678 17 , , , 42759 678 18 but but CC 42759 678 19 individualise individualise NN 42759 678 20 culture culture NN 42759 678 21 . . . 42759 679 1 ' ' `` 42759 679 2 " " `` 42759 679 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 679 4 28 28 CD 42759 679 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 679 6 The the DT 42759 679 7 Belgian belgian JJ 42759 679 8 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 679 9 leader leader NN 42759 679 10 , , , 42759 679 11 Vandervelde Vandervelde NNP 42759 679 12 , , , 42759 679 13 seems seem VBZ 42759 679 14 to to TO 42759 679 15 prefer prefer VB 42759 679 16 State state NN 42759 679 17 ownership ownership NN 42759 679 18 and and CC 42759 679 19 management management NN 42759 679 20 of of IN 42759 679 21 the the DT 42759 679 22 great great JJ 42759 679 23 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 679 24 industries industry NNS 42759 679 25 which which WDT 42759 679 26 require require VBP 42759 679 27 large large JJ 42759 679 28 masses masse NNS 42759 679 29 of of IN 42759 679 30 capital capital NN 42759 679 31 for for IN 42759 679 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 679 33 efficient efficient JJ 42759 679 34 operation operation NN 42759 679 35 , , , 42759 679 36 such such JJ 42759 679 37 as as IN 42759 679 38 dairying dairying NN 42759 679 39 , , , 42759 679 40 distilling distil VBG 42759 679 41 , , , 42759 679 42 and and CC 42759 679 43 sugar sugar NN 42759 679 44 making making NN 42759 679 45 , , , 42759 679 46 together together RB 42759 679 47 with with IN 42759 679 48 State State NNP 42759 679 49 ownership ownership NN 42759 679 50 of of IN 42759 679 51 the the DT 42759 679 52 land land NN 42759 679 53 thus thus RB 42759 679 54 used use VBD 42759 679 55 . . . 42759 680 1 Other other JJ 42759 680 2 lands land NNS 42759 680 3 he -PRON- PRP 42759 680 4 would would MD 42759 680 5 have have VB 42759 680 6 owned own VBN 42759 680 7 by by IN 42759 680 8 the the DT 42759 680 9 State State NNP 42759 680 10 , , , 42759 680 11 but but CC 42759 680 12 cultivated cultivate VBN 42759 680 13 by by IN 42759 680 14 individuals individual NNS 42759 680 15 according accord VBG 42759 680 16 to to IN 42759 680 17 a a DT 42759 680 18 system system NN 42759 680 19 of of IN 42759 680 20 leasing leasing NN 42759 680 21 and and CC 42759 680 22 rent rent NN 42759 680 23 - - HYPH 42759 680 24 paying paying NN 42759 680 25 . . . 42759 681 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 681 2 29 29 CD 42759 681 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 681 4 By by IN 42759 681 5 a a DT 42759 681 6 referendum referendum NN 42759 681 7 vote vote NN 42759 681 8 the the DT 42759 681 9 members member NNS 42759 681 10 of of IN 42759 681 11 the the DT 42759 681 12 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 681 13 party party NN 42759 681 14 in in IN 42759 681 15 the the DT 42759 681 16 United United NNP 42759 681 17 States States NNP 42759 681 18 recently recently RB 42759 681 19 amended amend VBD 42759 681 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 681 21 platform platform NN 42759 681 22 on on IN 42759 681 23 land land NN 42759 681 24 , , , 42759 681 25 to to TO 42759 681 26 read read VB 42759 681 27 as as IN 42759 681 28 follows follow VBZ 42759 681 29 : : : 42759 681 30 " " `` 42759 681 31 The the DT 42759 681 32 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 681 33 party party NN 42759 681 34 strives strive VBZ 42759 681 35 to to TO 42759 681 36 prevent prevent VB 42759 681 37 land land NN 42759 681 38 from from IN 42759 681 39 being be VBG 42759 681 40 used use VBN 42759 681 41 for for IN 42759 681 42 the the DT 42759 681 43 purpose purpose NN 42759 681 44 of of IN 42759 681 45 exploitation exploitation NN 42759 681 46 and and CC 42759 681 47 speculation speculation NN 42759 681 48 . . . 42759 682 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 682 2 demands demand VBZ 42759 682 3 the the DT 42759 682 4 collective collective JJ 42759 682 5 possession possession NN 42759 682 6 , , , 42759 682 7 control control NN 42759 682 8 or or CC 42759 682 9 management management NN 42759 682 10 of of IN 42759 682 11 land land NN 42759 682 12 to to IN 42759 682 13 whatever whatever WDT 42759 682 14 extent extent NN 42759 682 15 may may MD 42759 682 16 be be VB 42759 682 17 necessary necessary JJ 42759 682 18 to to TO 42759 682 19 attain attain VB 42759 682 20 that that DT 42759 682 21 end end NN 42759 682 22 . . . 42759 683 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 683 2 is be VBZ 42759 683 3 not not RB 42759 683 4 opposed opposed JJ 42759 683 5 to to IN 42759 683 6 the the DT 42759 683 7 occupation occupation NN 42759 683 8 and and CC 42759 683 9 possession possession NN 42759 683 10 of of IN 42759 683 11 land land NN 42759 683 12 by by IN 42759 683 13 those those DT 42759 683 14 using use VBG 42759 683 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 683 16 in in IN 42759 683 17 a a DT 42759 683 18 useful useful JJ 42759 683 19 and and CC 42759 683 20 bona bona JJ 42759 683 21 fide fide JJ 42759 683 22 manner manner NN 42759 683 23 without without IN 42759 683 24 exploitation exploitation NN 42759 683 25 . . . 42759 684 1 " " `` 42759 684 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 684 3 30 30 CD 42759 684 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 684 5 As as IN 42759 684 6 to to IN 42759 684 7 land land NN 42759 684 8 occupied occupy VBN 42759 684 9 by by IN 42759 684 10 dwellings dwelling NNS 42759 684 11 , , , 42759 684 12 perhaps perhaps RB 42759 684 13 the the DT 42759 684 14 majority majority NN 42759 684 15 of of IN 42759 684 16 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 684 17 would would MD 42759 684 18 now now RB 42759 684 19 agree agree VB 42759 684 20 with with IN 42759 684 21 Spargo Spargo NNP 42759 684 22 in in IN 42759 684 23 the the DT 42759 684 24 statement statement NN 42759 684 25 that that IN 42759 684 26 , , , 42759 684 27 " " `` 42759 684 28 so so RB 42759 684 29 far far RB 42759 684 30 as as IN 42759 684 31 the the DT 42759 684 32 central central JJ 42759 684 33 principle principle NN 42759 684 34 of of IN 42759 684 35 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 684 36 is be VBZ 42759 684 37 concerned concern VBN 42759 684 38 , , , 42759 684 39 there there EX 42759 684 40 is be VBZ 42759 684 41 no no DT 42759 684 42 more more JJR 42759 684 43 reason reason NN 42759 684 44 for for IN 42759 684 45 denying deny VBG 42759 684 46 the the DT 42759 684 47 right right NN 42759 684 48 of of IN 42759 684 49 a a DT 42759 684 50 man man NN 42759 684 51 to to TO 42759 684 52 own own VB 42759 684 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 684 54 own own JJ 42759 684 55 home home NN 42759 684 56 than than IN 42759 684 57 there there EX 42759 684 58 is be VBZ 42759 684 59 to to TO 42759 684 60 deny deny VB 42759 684 61 him -PRON- PRP 42759 684 62 the the DT 42759 684 63 right right NN 42759 684 64 to to TO 42759 684 65 own own VB 42759 684 66 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 684 67 hat hat NN 42759 684 68 . . . 42759 685 1 " " `` 42759 685 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 685 3 31 31 CD 42759 685 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 685 5 In in IN 42759 685 6 so so RB 42759 685 7 far far RB 42759 685 8 as as IN 42759 685 9 the the DT 42759 685 10 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 685 11 modifications modification NNS 42759 685 12 of of IN 42759 685 13 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 685 14 proposals proposal NNS 42759 685 15 would would MD 42759 685 16 allow allow VB 42759 685 17 the the DT 42759 685 18 individual individual NN 42759 685 19 to to TO 42759 685 20 own own VB 42759 685 21 the the DT 42759 685 22 land land NN 42759 685 23 that that WDT 42759 685 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 685 25 cultivates cultivate VBZ 42759 685 26 or or CC 42759 685 27 occupies occupie NNS 42759 685 28 , , , 42759 685 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 685 30 do do VBP 42759 685 31 not not RB 42759 685 32 call call VB 42759 685 33 for for IN 42759 685 34 further further JJ 42759 685 35 discussion discussion NN 42759 685 36 here here RB 42759 685 37 . . . 42759 686 1 In in IN 42759 686 2 so so RB 42759 686 3 far far RB 42759 686 4 as as IN 42759 686 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 686 6 combine combine VBP 42759 686 7 State state NN 42759 686 8 ownership ownership NN 42759 686 9 of of IN 42759 686 10 land land NN 42759 686 11 with with IN 42759 686 12 individual individual JJ 42759 686 13 management management NN 42759 686 14 of of IN 42759 686 15 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 686 16 , , , 42759 686 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 686 18 are be VBP 42759 686 19 subject subject JJ 42759 686 20 to to IN 42759 686 21 at at RB 42759 686 22 least least RBS 42759 686 23 all all PDT 42759 686 24 the the DT 42759 686 25 limitations limitation NNS 42759 686 26 of of IN 42759 686 27 the the DT 42759 686 28 Single Single NNP 42759 686 29 Tax Tax NNP 42759 686 30 . . . 42759 687 1 To to IN 42759 687 2 the the DT 42759 687 3 latter latter JJ 42759 687 4 system system NN 42759 687 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 687 6 now now RB 42759 687 7 turn turn VBP 42759 687 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 687 9 attention attention NN 42759 687 10 . . . 42759 688 1 _ _ NNP 42759 688 2 Inferiority Inferiority NNP 42759 688 3 of of IN 42759 688 4 the the DT 42759 688 5 Single Single NNP 42759 688 6 Tax Tax NNP 42759 688 7 System System NNP 42759 688 8 _ _ NNP 42759 688 9 Of of IN 42759 688 10 the the DT 42759 688 11 four four CD 42759 688 12 leading lead VBG 42759 688 13 elements element NNS 42759 688 14 of of IN 42759 688 15 private private JJ 42759 688 16 ownership ownership NN 42759 688 17 enumerated enumerate VBD 42759 688 18 above above RB 42759 688 19 , , , 42759 688 20 the the DT 42759 688 21 Single Single NNP 42759 688 22 Tax Tax NNP 42759 688 23 scheme scheme NN 42759 688 24 would would MD 42759 688 25 comprise comprise VB 42759 688 26 all all DT 42759 688 27 but but IN 42759 688 28 one one CD 42759 688 29 . . . 42759 689 1 In in IN 42759 689 2 the the DT 42759 689 3 words word NNS 42759 689 4 of of IN 42759 689 5 Henry Henry NNP 42759 689 6 George George NNP 42759 689 7 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 689 8 : : : 42759 689 9 " " `` 42759 689 10 Let let VB 42759 689 11 the the DT 42759 689 12 individuals individual NNS 42759 689 13 who who WP 42759 689 14 now now RB 42759 689 15 hold hold VBP 42759 689 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 689 17 still still RB 42759 689 18 retain retain VB 42759 689 19 , , , 42759 689 20 if if IN 42759 689 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 689 22 want want VBP 42759 689 23 to to TO 42759 689 24 , , , 42759 689 25 possession possession NN 42759 689 26 of of IN 42759 689 27 what what WP 42759 689 28 they -PRON- PRP 42759 689 29 are be VBP 42759 689 30 pleased pleased JJ 42759 689 31 to to TO 42759 689 32 call call VB 42759 689 33 _ _ NNP 42759 689 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 689 35 _ _ NNP 42759 689 36 land land NN 42759 689 37 . . . 42759 690 1 Let let VB 42759 690 2 them -PRON- PRP 42759 690 3 continue continue VB 42759 690 4 to to TO 42759 690 5 call call VB 42759 690 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 690 7 _ _ IN 42759 690 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 690 9 _ _ NNP 42759 690 10 land land NN 42759 690 11 . . . 42759 691 1 Let let VB 42759 691 2 them -PRON- PRP 42759 691 3 buy buy VB 42759 691 4 and and CC 42759 691 5 sell sell VB 42759 691 6 , , , 42759 691 7 and and CC 42759 691 8 bequeath bequeath NNP 42759 691 9 and and CC 42759 691 10 devise devise VB 42759 691 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 691 12 . . . 42759 692 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 692 2 may may MD 42759 692 3 safely safely RB 42759 692 4 leave leave VB 42759 692 5 them -PRON- PRP 42759 692 6 the the DT 42759 692 7 shell shell NN 42759 692 8 , , , 42759 692 9 if if IN 42759 692 10 we -PRON- PRP 42759 692 11 take take VBP 42759 692 12 the the DT 42759 692 13 kernel kernel NN 42759 692 14 . . . 42759 693 1 _ _ NNP 42759 693 2 It -PRON- PRP 42759 693 3 is be VBZ 42759 693 4 not not RB 42759 693 5 necessary necessary JJ 42759 693 6 to to TO 42759 693 7 confiscate confiscate VB 42759 693 8 land land NN 42759 693 9 ; ; : 42759 693 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 693 11 is be VBZ 42759 693 12 only only RB 42759 693 13 necessary necessary JJ 42759 693 14 to to TO 42759 693 15 confiscate confiscate VB 42759 693 16 rent rent NN 42759 693 17 .... .... . 42759 693 18 _ _ NNP 42759 693 19 In in IN 42759 693 20 this this DT 42759 693 21 way way NN 42759 693 22 the the DT 42759 693 23 State state NN 42759 693 24 may may MD 42759 693 25 become become VB 42759 693 26 the the DT 42759 693 27 universal universal JJ 42759 693 28 landlord landlord NN 42759 693 29 without without IN 42759 693 30 calling call VBG 42759 693 31 herself -PRON- PRP 42759 693 32 so so RB 42759 693 33 , , , 42759 693 34 and and CC 42759 693 35 without without IN 42759 693 36 assuming assume VBG 42759 693 37 a a DT 42759 693 38 single single JJ 42759 693 39 new new JJ 42759 693 40 function function NN 42759 693 41 . . . 42759 694 1 In in IN 42759 694 2 form form NN 42759 694 3 , , , 42759 694 4 the the DT 42759 694 5 ownership ownership NN 42759 694 6 of of IN 42759 694 7 land land NN 42759 694 8 would would MD 42759 694 9 remain remain VB 42759 694 10 just just RB 42759 694 11 as as RB 42759 694 12 now now RB 42759 694 13 . . . 42759 695 1 No no DT 42759 695 2 owner owner NN 42759 695 3 of of IN 42759 695 4 land land NN 42759 695 5 need nee MD 42759 695 6 be be VB 42759 695 7 dispossessed dispossess VBN 42759 695 8 , , , 42759 695 9 and and CC 42759 695 10 no no DT 42759 695 11 restriction restriction NN 42759 695 12 need nee MD 42759 695 13 be be VB 42759 695 14 placed place VBN 42759 695 15 upon upon IN 42759 695 16 the the DT 42759 695 17 amount amount NN 42759 695 18 of of IN 42759 695 19 land land NN 42759 695 20 that that WDT 42759 695 21 any any DT 42759 695 22 one one PRP 42759 695 23 could could MD 42759 695 24 hold hold VB 42759 695 25 . . . 42759 696 1 " " `` 42759 696 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 696 3 32 32 CD 42759 696 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 696 5 Individuals individual NNS 42759 696 6 would would MD 42759 696 7 , , , 42759 696 8 therefore therefore RB 42759 696 9 , , , 42759 696 10 still still RB 42759 696 11 enjoy enjoy VB 42759 696 12 security security NN 42759 696 13 of of IN 42759 696 14 possession possession NN 42759 696 15 , , , 42759 696 16 the the DT 42759 696 17 managerial managerial JJ 42759 696 18 use use NN 42759 696 19 of of IN 42759 696 20 land land NN 42759 696 21 , , , 42759 696 22 and and CC 42759 696 23 the the DT 42759 696 24 revenue revenue NN 42759 696 25 due due IN 42759 696 26 to to IN 42759 696 27 improvements improvement NNS 42759 696 28 . . . 42759 697 1 The the DT 42759 697 2 income income NN 42759 697 3 arising arise VBG 42759 697 4 from from IN 42759 697 5 the the DT 42759 697 6 land land NN 42759 697 7 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 697 8 , , , 42759 697 9 the the DT 42759 697 10 economic economic JJ 42759 697 11 rent rent NN 42759 697 12 , , , 42759 697 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 697 14 would would MD 42759 697 15 be be VB 42759 697 16 obliged oblige VBN 42759 697 17 to to TO 42759 697 18 hand hand VB 42759 697 19 over over RP 42759 697 20 as as IN 42759 697 21 a a DT 42759 697 22 free free JJ 42759 697 23 gift gift NN 42759 697 24 to to IN 42759 697 25 the the DT 42759 697 26 State State NNP 42759 697 27 . . . 42759 698 1 As as IN 42759 698 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 698 3 have have VBP 42759 698 4 seen see VBN 42759 698 5 in in IN 42759 698 6 a a DT 42759 698 7 preceding precede VBG 42759 698 8 chapter chapter NN 42759 698 9 , , , 42759 698 10 this this DT 42759 698 11 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 698 12 of of IN 42759 698 13 rent rent NN 42759 698 14 by by IN 42759 698 15 the the DT 42759 698 16 State State NNP 42759 698 17 would would MD 42759 698 18 be be VB 42759 698 19 pure pure JJ 42759 698 20 and and CC 42759 698 21 simple simple JJ 42759 698 22 robbery robbery NN 42759 698 23 of of IN 42759 698 24 the the DT 42759 698 25 private private JJ 42759 698 26 owner owner NN 42759 698 27 . . . 42759 699 1 Suppose suppose VB 42759 699 2 , , , 42759 699 3 however however RB 42759 699 4 , , , 42759 699 5 that that IN 42759 699 6 the the DT 42759 699 7 State State NNP 42759 699 8 were be VBD 42759 699 9 willing willing JJ 42759 699 10 to to TO 42759 699 11 compensate compensate VB 42759 699 12 individual individual JJ 42759 699 13 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 699 14 with with IN 42759 699 15 a a DT 42759 699 16 sum sum NN 42759 699 17 equal equal JJ 42759 699 18 to to IN 42759 699 19 the the DT 42759 699 20 present present JJ 42759 699 21 value value NN 42759 699 22 , , , 42759 699 23 or or CC 42759 699 24 the the DT 42759 699 25 capitalised capitalise VBN 42759 699 26 rent rent NN 42759 699 27 , , , 42759 699 28 of of IN 42759 699 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 699 30 land land NN 42759 699 31 . . . 42759 700 1 In in IN 42759 700 2 that that DT 42759 700 3 case case NN 42759 700 4 the the DT 42759 700 5 only only JJ 42759 700 6 difference difference NN 42759 700 7 made make VBN 42759 700 8 to to IN 42759 700 9 the the DT 42759 700 10 individual individual NN 42759 700 11 would would MD 42759 700 12 be be VB 42759 700 13 that that IN 42759 700 14 he -PRON- PRP 42759 700 15 could could MD 42759 700 16 no no RB 42759 700 17 longer longer RB 42759 700 18 invest invest VB 42759 700 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 700 20 money money NN 42759 700 21 in in IN 42759 700 22 land land NN 42759 700 23 nor nor CC 42759 700 24 profit profit NN 42759 700 25 by by IN 42759 700 26 the the DT 42759 700 27 increases increase NNS 42759 700 28 in in IN 42759 700 29 land land NN 42759 700 30 values value NNS 42759 700 31 . . . 42759 701 1 While while IN 42759 701 2 this this DT 42759 701 3 would would MD 42759 701 4 deprive deprive VB 42759 701 5 some some DT 42759 701 6 persons person NNS 42759 701 7 of of IN 42759 701 8 advantages advantage NNS 42759 701 9 that that IN 42759 701 10 they -PRON- PRP 42759 701 11 now now RB 42759 701 12 enjoy enjoy VBP 42759 701 13 , , , 42759 701 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 701 15 would would MD 42759 701 16 be be VB 42759 701 17 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 701 18 to to IN 42759 701 19 the the DT 42759 701 20 majority majority NN 42759 701 21 , , , 42759 701 22 and and CC 42759 701 23 to to IN 42759 701 24 the the DT 42759 701 25 community community NN 42759 701 26 . . . 42759 702 1 Since since IN 42759 702 2 no no DT 42759 702 3 man man NN 42759 702 4 would would MD 42759 702 5 find find VB 42759 702 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 702 7 profitable profitable JJ 42759 702 8 to to TO 42759 702 9 retain retain VB 42759 702 10 control control NN 42759 702 11 of of IN 42759 702 12 more more JJR 42759 702 13 land land NN 42759 702 14 than than IN 42759 702 15 he -PRON- PRP 42759 702 16 could could MD 42759 702 17 use use VB 42759 702 18 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 702 19 , , , 42759 702 20 the the DT 42759 702 21 number number NN 42759 702 22 of of IN 42759 702 23 actual actual JJ 42759 702 24 land land NN 42759 702 25 users user NNS 42759 702 26 would would MD 42759 702 27 be be VB 42759 702 28 increased increase VBN 42759 702 29 . . . 42759 703 1 The the DT 42759 703 2 land land NN 42759 703 3 speculator speculator NN 42759 703 4 would would MD 42759 703 5 disappear disappear VB 42759 703 6 , , , 42759 703 7 together together RB 42759 703 8 with with IN 42759 703 9 the the DT 42759 703 10 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 703 11 of of IN 42759 703 12 making make VBG 42759 703 13 and and CC 42759 703 14 losing lose VBG 42759 703 15 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 703 16 by by IN 42759 703 17 gambling gamble VBG 42759 703 18 on on IN 42759 703 19 the the DT 42759 703 20 changes change NNS 42759 703 21 in in IN 42759 703 22 land land NN 42759 703 23 values value NNS 42759 703 24 . . . 42759 704 1 Owing owe VBG 42759 704 2 to to IN 42759 704 3 the the DT 42759 704 4 removal removal NN 42759 704 5 of of IN 42759 704 6 taxation taxation NN 42759 704 7 from from IN 42759 704 8 the the DT 42759 704 9 necessaries necessary NNS 42759 704 10 of of IN 42759 704 11 life life NN 42759 704 12 and and CC 42759 704 13 from from IN 42759 704 14 industry industry NN 42759 704 15 , , , 42759 704 16 consumers consumer NNS 42759 704 17 would would MD 42759 704 18 get get VB 42759 704 19 goods good NNS 42759 704 20 cheaper cheap JJR 42759 704 21 , , , 42759 704 22 and and CC 42759 704 23 some some DT 42759 704 24 stimulus stimulus NN 42759 704 25 would would MD 42759 704 26 be be VB 42759 704 27 given give VBN 42759 704 28 to to IN 42759 704 29 production production NN 42759 704 30 and and CC 42759 704 31 employment employment NN 42759 704 32 . . . 42759 705 1 Those those DT 42759 705 2 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 705 3 which which WDT 42759 705 4 derive derive VBP 42759 705 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 705 6 strength strength NN 42759 705 7 from from IN 42759 705 8 land land NN 42759 705 9 would would MD 42759 705 10 become become VB 42759 705 11 weaker weak JJR 42759 705 12 and and CC 42759 705 13 tend tend VBP 42759 705 14 to to TO 42759 705 15 disappear disappear VB 42759 705 16 . . . 42759 706 1 Sooner soon RBR 42759 706 2 or or CC 42759 706 3 later later RB 42759 706 4 there there EX 42759 706 5 would would MD 42759 706 6 probably probably RB 42759 706 7 be be VB 42759 706 8 a a DT 42759 706 9 considerable considerable JJ 42759 706 10 increase increase NN 42759 706 11 in in IN 42759 706 12 the the DT 42759 706 13 amount amount NN 42759 706 14 of of IN 42759 706 15 money money NN 42759 706 16 available available JJ 42759 706 17 for for IN 42759 706 18 public public JJ 42759 706 19 improvements improvement NNS 42759 706 20 and and CC 42759 706 21 socially socially RB 42759 706 22 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 706 23 institutions institution NNS 42759 706 24 . . . 42759 707 1 On on IN 42759 707 2 the the DT 42759 707 3 other other JJ 42759 707 4 hand hand NN 42759 707 5 , , , 42759 707 6 there there EX 42759 707 7 would would MD 42759 707 8 be be VB 42759 707 9 certain certain JJ 42759 707 10 and and CC 42759 707 11 serious serious JJ 42759 707 12 disadvantages disadvantage NNS 42759 707 13 . . . 42759 708 1 A a DT 42759 708 2 considerable considerable JJ 42759 708 3 number number NN 42759 708 4 of of IN 42759 708 5 land land NN 42759 708 6 users user NNS 42759 708 7 might may MD 42759 708 8 permit permit VB 42759 708 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 708 10 holdings holding NNS 42759 708 11 to to TO 42759 708 12 deteriorate deteriorate VB 42759 708 13 through through IN 42759 708 14 careless careless JJ 42759 708 15 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 708 16 . . . 42759 709 1 To to TO 42759 709 2 be be VB 42759 709 3 sure sure JJ 42759 709 4 , , , 42759 709 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 709 6 would would MD 42759 709 7 not not RB 42759 709 8 find find VB 42759 709 9 this this DT 42759 709 10 a a DT 42759 709 11 profitable profitable JJ 42759 709 12 course course NN 42759 709 13 if if IN 42759 709 14 they -PRON- PRP 42759 709 15 intended intend VBD 42759 709 16 to to TO 42759 709 17 remain remain VB 42759 709 18 on on IN 42759 709 19 the the DT 42759 709 20 land land NN 42759 709 21 permanently permanently RB 42759 709 22 ; ; : 42759 709 23 but but CC 42759 709 24 they -PRON- PRP 42759 709 25 might may MD 42759 709 26 prefer prefer VB 42759 709 27 to to TO 42759 709 28 exhaust exhaust VB 42759 709 29 the the DT 42759 709 30 best good JJS 42759 709 31 qualities quality NNS 42759 709 32 of of IN 42759 709 33 a a DT 42759 709 34 farm farm NN 42759 709 35 in in IN 42759 709 36 a a DT 42759 709 37 few few JJ 42759 709 38 years year NNS 42759 709 39 , , , 42759 709 40 and and CC 42759 709 41 then then RB 42759 709 42 retire retire VB 42759 709 43 , , , 42759 709 44 or or CC 42759 709 45 go go VB 42759 709 46 into into IN 42759 709 47 some some DT 42759 709 48 other other JJ 42759 709 49 business business NN 42759 709 50 , , , 42759 709 51 or or CC 42759 709 52 repeat repeat VB 42759 709 53 the the DT 42759 709 54 wearing wear VBG 42759 709 55 - - HYPH 42759 709 56 out out RP 42759 709 57 process process NN 42759 709 58 on on IN 42759 709 59 other other JJ 42759 709 60 lands land NNS 42759 709 61 . . . 42759 710 1 Thus thus RB 42759 710 2 the the DT 42759 710 3 community community NN 42759 710 4 would would MD 42759 710 5 suffer suffer VB 42759 710 6 through through IN 42759 710 7 the the DT 42759 710 8 lowered lower VBN 42759 710 9 productiveness productiveness NN 42759 710 10 of of IN 42759 710 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 710 12 land land NN 42759 710 13 , , , 42759 710 14 and and CC 42759 710 15 because because IN 42759 710 16 of of IN 42759 710 17 the the DT 42759 710 18 lower low JJR 42759 710 19 rent rent NN 42759 710 20 that that IN 42759 710 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 710 22 would would MD 42759 710 23 receive receive VB 42759 710 24 from from IN 42759 710 25 all all DT 42759 710 26 subsequent subsequent JJ 42759 710 27 users user NNS 42759 710 28 of of IN 42759 710 29 the the DT 42759 710 30 deteriorated deteriorate VBN 42759 710 31 tracts tract NNS 42759 710 32 . . . 42759 711 1 In in IN 42759 711 2 the the DT 42759 711 3 second second JJ 42759 711 4 place place NN 42759 711 5 , , , 42759 711 6 the the DT 42759 711 7 administrative administrative JJ 42759 711 8 machinery machinery NN 42759 711 9 required require VBN 42759 711 10 to to TO 42759 711 11 levy levy VB 42759 711 12 and and CC 42759 711 13 collect collect VB 42759 711 14 the the DT 42759 711 15 rent rent NN 42759 711 16 , , , 42759 711 17 and and CC 42759 711 18 to to TO 42759 711 19 apportion apportion VB 42759 711 20 the the DT 42759 711 21 different different JJ 42759 711 22 holdings holding NNS 42759 711 23 among among IN 42759 711 24 competitive competitive JJ 42759 711 25 bidders bidder NNS 42759 711 26 , , , 42759 711 27 would would MD 42759 711 28 inevitably inevitably RB 42759 711 29 involve involve VB 42759 711 30 a a DT 42759 711 31 vast vast JJ 42759 711 32 amount amount NN 42759 711 33 of of IN 42759 711 34 error error NN 42759 711 35 , , , 42759 711 36 inequality inequality NN 42759 711 37 , , , 42759 711 38 favouritism favouritism NN 42759 711 39 , , , 42759 711 40 and and CC 42759 711 41 corruption corruption NN 42759 711 42 . . . 42759 712 1 For for IN 42759 712 2 the the DT 42759 712 3 land land NN 42759 712 4 tax tax NN 42759 712 5 to to TO 42759 712 6 be be VB 42759 712 7 levied levy VBN 42759 712 8 and and CC 42759 712 9 collected collect VBN 42759 712 10 would would MD 42759 712 11 not not RB 42759 712 12 be be VB 42759 712 13 , , , 42759 712 14 as as IN 42759 712 15 now now RB 42759 712 16 , , , 42759 712 17 a a DT 42759 712 18 fraction fraction NN 42759 712 19 of of IN 42759 712 20 the the DT 42759 712 21 rental rental JJ 42759 712 22 value value NN 42759 712 23 , , , 42759 712 24 but but CC 42759 712 25 the the DT 42759 712 26 full full JJ 42759 712 27 amount amount NN 42759 712 28 of of IN 42759 712 29 the the DT 42759 712 30 annual annual JJ 42759 712 31 rent rent NN 42759 712 32 . . . 42759 713 1 In in IN 42759 713 2 the the DT 42759 713 3 third third JJ 42759 713 4 place place NN 42759 713 5 , , , 42759 713 6 cultivators cultivator NNS 42759 713 7 would would MD 42759 713 8 not not RB 42759 713 9 have have VB 42759 713 10 the the DT 42759 713 11 inducement inducement NN 42759 713 12 to to TO 42759 713 13 make make VB 42759 713 14 improvements improvement NNS 42759 713 15 which which WDT 42759 713 16 arises arise VBZ 42759 713 17 from from IN 42759 713 18 the the DT 42759 713 19 hope hope NN 42759 713 20 of of IN 42759 713 21 selling sell VBG 42759 713 22 both both CC 42759 713 23 the the DT 42759 713 24 improvements improvement NNS 42759 713 25 and and CC 42759 713 26 the the DT 42759 713 27 land land NN 42759 713 28 at at IN 42759 713 29 a a DT 42759 713 30 profit profit NN 42759 713 31 , , , 42759 713 32 owing owe VBG 42759 713 33 to to IN 42759 713 34 the the DT 42759 713 35 increased increase VBN 42759 713 36 demand demand NN 42759 713 37 for for IN 42759 713 38 the the DT 42759 713 39 land land NN 42759 713 40 . . . 42759 714 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 42759 714 2 the the DT 42759 714 3 greatest great JJS 42759 714 4 disadvantage disadvantage NN 42759 714 5 of of IN 42759 714 6 the the DT 42759 714 7 system system NN 42759 714 8 would would MD 42759 714 9 be be VB 42759 714 10 the the DT 42759 714 11 instability instability NN 42759 714 12 of of IN 42759 714 13 tenure tenure NN 42759 714 14 , , , 42759 714 15 with with IN 42759 714 16 regard regard NN 42759 714 17 to to IN 42759 714 18 both both CC 42759 714 19 productive productive JJ 42759 714 20 and and CC 42759 714 21 residential residential JJ 42759 714 22 lands land NNS 42759 714 23 . . . 42759 715 1 Owing owe VBG 42759 715 2 to to IN 42759 715 3 misfortunes misfortune NNS 42759 715 4 of of IN 42759 715 5 various various JJ 42759 715 6 kinds kind NNS 42759 715 7 , , , 42759 715 8 for for IN 42759 715 9 example example NN 42759 715 10 , , , 42759 715 11 one one CD 42759 715 12 or or CC 42759 715 13 two two CD 42759 715 14 bad bad JJ 42759 715 15 crops crop NNS 42759 715 16 , , , 42759 715 17 many many JJ 42759 715 18 cultivators cultivator NNS 42759 715 19 would would MD 42759 715 20 be be VB 42759 715 21 temporarily temporarily RB 42759 715 22 unable unable JJ 42759 715 23 to to TO 42759 715 24 pay pay VB 42759 715 25 the the DT 42759 715 26 full full JJ 42759 715 27 amount amount NN 42759 715 28 of of IN 42759 715 29 the the DT 42759 715 30 land land NN 42759 715 31 tax tax NN 42759 715 32 or or CC 42759 715 33 rent rent NN 42759 715 34 . . . 42759 716 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 716 2 is be VBZ 42759 716 3 scarcely scarcely RB 42759 716 4 conceivable conceivable JJ 42759 716 5 that that IN 42759 716 6 the the DT 42759 716 7 State State NNP 42759 716 8 would would MD 42759 716 9 remit remit VB 42759 716 10 the the DT 42759 716 11 deficiency deficiency NN 42759 716 12 , , , 42759 716 13 or or CC 42759 716 14 refuse refuse VBP 42759 716 15 to to TO 42759 716 16 turn turn VB 42759 716 17 the the DT 42759 716 18 land land NN 42759 716 19 over over RP 42759 716 20 to to IN 42759 716 21 other other JJ 42759 716 22 persons person NNS 42759 716 23 on on IN 42759 716 24 terms term NNS 42759 716 25 more more RBR 42759 716 26 advantageous advantageous JJ 42759 716 27 to to IN 42759 716 28 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 716 29 . . . 42759 717 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 717 2 as as IN 42759 717 3 the the DT 42759 717 4 value value NN 42759 717 5 and and CC 42759 717 6 rent rent NN 42759 717 7 of of IN 42759 717 8 land land NN 42759 717 9 would would MD 42759 717 10 be be VB 42759 717 11 continuously continuously RB 42759 717 12 adjusted adjust VBN 42759 717 13 by by IN 42759 717 14 competition competition NN 42759 717 15 , , , 42759 717 16 the the DT 42759 717 17 more more RBR 42759 717 18 efficient efficient JJ 42759 717 19 and and CC 42759 717 20 more more RBR 42759 717 21 wealthy wealthy JJ 42759 717 22 would would MD 42759 717 23 frequently frequently RB 42759 717 24 supplant supplant VB 42759 717 25 the the DT 42759 717 26 less less RBR 42759 717 27 efficient efficient JJ 42759 717 28 and and CC 42759 717 29 the the DT 42759 717 30 less less RBR 42759 717 31 wealthy wealthy JJ 42759 717 32 , , , 42759 717 33 even even RB 42759 717 34 though though IN 42759 717 35 the the DT 42759 717 36 latter latter NN 42759 717 37 had have VBD 42759 717 38 occupied occupy VBN 42759 717 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 717 40 holdings holding NNS 42759 717 41 or or CC 42759 717 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 717 43 dwellings dwelling NNS 42759 717 44 for for IN 42759 717 45 a a DT 42759 717 46 great great JJ 42759 717 47 number number NN 42759 717 48 of of IN 42759 717 49 years year NNS 42759 717 50 . . . 42759 718 1 Legal legal JJ 42759 718 2 security security NN 42759 718 3 of of IN 42759 718 4 tenure tenure NN 42759 718 5 , , , 42759 718 6 though though IN 42759 718 7 theoretically theoretically RB 42759 718 8 the the DT 42759 718 9 same same JJ 42759 718 10 as as IN 42759 718 11 that that DT 42759 718 12 enjoyed enjoy VBN 42759 718 13 by by IN 42759 718 14 the the DT 42759 718 15 private private JJ 42759 718 16 owner owner NN 42759 718 17 to to IN 42759 718 18 - - HYPH 42759 718 19 day day NN 42759 718 20 , , , 42759 718 21 would would MD 42759 718 22 be be VB 42759 718 23 much much RB 42759 718 24 less less RBR 42759 718 25 effective effective JJ 42759 718 26 practically practically RB 42759 718 27 . . . 42759 719 1 In in IN 42759 719 2 this this DT 42759 719 3 respect respect NN 42759 719 4 land land NN 42759 719 5 users user NNS 42759 719 6 would would MD 42759 719 7 be be VB 42759 719 8 in in RB 42759 719 9 almost almost RB 42759 719 10 as as RB 42759 719 11 bad bad JJ 42759 719 12 a a DT 42759 719 13 case case NN 42759 719 14 as as IN 42759 719 15 renters renter NNS 42759 719 16 are be VBP 42759 719 17 at at IN 42759 719 18 present present JJ 42759 719 19 . . . 42759 720 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 720 2 33 33 CD 42759 720 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 720 4 Our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 720 5 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 720 6 , , , 42759 720 7 then then RB 42759 720 8 , , , 42759 720 9 is be VBZ 42759 720 10 that that DT 42759 720 11 private private JJ 42759 720 12 landownership landownership NN 42759 720 13 is be VBZ 42759 720 14 certainly certainly RB 42759 720 15 better well JJR 42759 720 16 than than IN 42759 720 17 extreme extreme JJ 42759 720 18 Socialism socialism NN 42759 720 19 , , , 42759 720 20 or or CC 42759 720 21 any any DT 42759 720 22 form form NN 42759 720 23 of of IN 42759 720 24 Socialism socialism NN 42759 720 25 which which WDT 42759 720 26 does do VBZ 42759 720 27 not not RB 42759 720 28 concede concede VB 42759 720 29 to to IN 42759 720 30 the the DT 42759 720 31 land land NN 42759 720 32 user user NN 42759 720 33 all all PDT 42759 720 34 the the DT 42759 720 35 control control NN 42759 720 36 that that IN 42759 720 37 he -PRON- PRP 42759 720 38 would would MD 42759 720 39 have have VB 42759 720 40 under under IN 42759 720 41 the the DT 42759 720 42 Single Single NNP 42759 720 43 Tax Tax NNP 42759 720 44 system system NN 42759 720 45 , , , 42759 720 46 and and CC 42759 720 47 that that IN 42759 720 48 it -PRON- PRP 42759 720 49 is be VBZ 42759 720 50 very very RB 42759 720 51 probably probably RB 42759 720 52 superior superior JJ 42759 720 53 to to IN 42759 720 54 the the DT 42759 720 55 latter latter JJ 42759 720 56 . . . 42759 721 1 In in IN 42759 721 2 making make VBG 42759 721 3 this this DT 42759 721 4 comparison comparison NN 42759 721 5 and and CC 42759 721 6 drawing draw VBG 42759 721 7 this this DT 42759 721 8 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 721 9 , , , 42759 721 10 we -PRON- PRP 42759 721 11 have have VBP 42759 721 12 in in IN 42759 721 13 mind mind NN 42759 721 14 private private JJ 42759 721 15 ownership ownership NN 42759 721 16 , , , 42759 721 17 not not RB 42759 721 18 at at IN 42759 721 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 721 20 worst bad JJS 42759 721 21 nor nor CC 42759 721 22 as as IN 42759 721 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 721 24 exists exist VBZ 42759 721 25 or or CC 42759 721 26 has have VBZ 42759 721 27 existed exist VBN 42759 721 28 in in IN 42759 721 29 any any DT 42759 721 30 particular particular JJ 42759 721 31 country country NN 42759 721 32 , , , 42759 721 33 but but CC 42759 721 34 private private JJ 42759 721 35 ownership ownership NN 42759 721 36 in in IN 42759 721 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 721 38 essential essential JJ 42759 721 39 elements element NNS 42759 721 40 , , , 42759 721 41 and and CC 42759 721 42 with with IN 42759 721 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 721 44 capacity capacity NN 42759 721 45 for for IN 42759 721 46 modification modification NN 42759 721 47 and and CC 42759 721 48 improvement improvement NN 42759 721 49 . . . 42759 722 1 If if IN 42759 722 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 722 3 were be VBD 42759 722 4 to to TO 42759 722 5 examine examine VB 42759 722 6 carefully carefully RB 42759 722 7 the the DT 42759 722 8 results result NNS 42759 722 9 of of IN 42759 722 10 private private JJ 42759 722 11 ownership ownership NN 42759 722 12 as as IN 42759 722 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 722 14 obtained obtain VBD 42759 722 15 in in IN 42759 722 16 Ireland Ireland NNP 42759 722 17 for for IN 42759 722 18 several several JJ 42759 722 19 centuries century NNS 42759 722 20 before before IN 42759 722 21 the the DT 42759 722 22 enactment enactment NN 42759 722 23 of of IN 42759 722 24 the the DT 42759 722 25 recent recent JJ 42759 722 26 Land Land NNP 42759 722 27 Purchase Purchase NNP 42759 722 28 Act Act NNP 42759 722 29 , , , 42759 722 30 we -PRON- PRP 42759 722 31 should should MD 42759 722 32 probably probably RB 42759 722 33 be be VB 42759 722 34 tempted tempt VBN 42759 722 35 to to TO 42759 722 36 declare declare VB 42759 722 37 that that IN 42759 722 38 the the DT 42759 722 39 most most RBS 42759 722 40 extreme extreme JJ 42759 722 41 form form NN 42759 722 42 of of IN 42759 722 43 agrarian agrarian JJ 42759 722 44 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 722 45 could could MD 42759 722 46 scarcely scarcely RB 42759 722 47 have have VB 42759 722 48 been be VBN 42759 722 49 productive productive JJ 42759 722 50 of of IN 42759 722 51 more more JJR 42759 722 52 individual individual JJ 42759 722 53 and and CC 42759 722 54 social social JJ 42759 722 55 injury injury NN 42759 722 56 . . . 42759 723 1 Certain certain JJ 42759 723 2 other other JJ 42759 723 3 countries country NNS 42759 723 4 present present VBP 42759 723 5 almost almost RB 42759 723 6 equally equally RB 42759 723 7 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 42759 723 8 conditions condition NNS 42759 723 9 of of IN 42759 723 10 comparison comparison NN 42759 723 11 . . . 42759 724 1 Failure failure NN 42759 724 2 to to TO 42759 724 3 note note VB 42759 724 4 this this DT 42759 724 5 distinction distinction NN 42759 724 6 between between IN 42759 724 7 the the DT 42759 724 8 historical historical JJ 42759 724 9 and and CC 42759 724 10 the the DT 42759 724 11 potential potential JJ 42759 724 12 aspects aspect NNS 42759 724 13 of of IN 42759 724 14 private private JJ 42759 724 15 landownership landownership NN 42759 724 16 has have VBZ 42759 724 17 vitiated vitiate VBN 42759 724 18 many many JJ 42759 724 19 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 724 20 excellent excellent JJ 42759 724 21 defences defence NNS 42759 724 22 of of IN 42759 724 23 the the DT 42759 724 24 institution institution NN 42759 724 25 . . . 42759 725 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 725 2 has have VBZ 42759 725 3 provoked provoke VBN 42759 725 4 the the DT 42759 725 5 retort retort NN 42759 725 6 that that IN 42759 725 7 almost almost RB 42759 725 8 any any DT 42759 725 9 plausible plausible JJ 42759 725 10 change change NN 42759 725 11 would would MD 42759 725 12 be be VB 42759 725 13 an an DT 42759 725 14 improvement improvement NN 42759 725 15 upon upon IN 42759 725 16 private private JJ 42759 725 17 ownership ownership NN 42759 725 18 as as IN 42759 725 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 725 20 has have VBZ 42759 725 21 existed exist VBN 42759 725 22 in in IN 42759 725 23 this this DT 42759 725 24 or or CC 42759 725 25 that that DT 42759 725 26 country country NN 42759 725 27 . . . 42759 726 1 But but CC 42759 726 2 these these DT 42759 726 3 are be VBP 42759 726 4 not not RB 42759 726 5 the the DT 42759 726 6 real real JJ 42759 726 7 alternatives alternative NNS 42759 726 8 . . . 42759 727 1 The the DT 42759 727 2 practical practical JJ 42759 727 3 choice choice NN 42759 727 4 is be VBZ 42759 727 5 between between IN 42759 727 6 private private JJ 42759 727 7 ownership ownership NN 42759 727 8 as as IN 42759 727 9 shown show VBN 42759 727 10 by by IN 42759 727 11 experience experience NN 42759 727 12 and and CC 42759 727 13 reason reason NN 42759 727 14 to to TO 42759 727 15 be be VB 42759 727 16 capable capable JJ 42759 727 17 of of IN 42759 727 18 improvement improvement NN 42759 727 19 , , , 42759 727 20 and and CC 42759 727 21 some some DT 42759 727 22 untried untried JJ 42759 727 23 system system NN 42759 727 24 which which WDT 42759 727 25 is be VBZ 42759 727 26 subject subject JJ 42759 727 27 to to IN 42759 727 28 grave grave JJ 42759 727 29 defects defect NNS 42759 727 30 , , , 42759 727 31 and and CC 42759 727 32 which which WDT 42759 727 33 at at IN 42759 727 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 727 35 best good JJS 42759 727 36 would would MD 42759 727 37 be be VB 42759 727 38 probably probably RB 42759 727 39 inferior inferior JJ 42759 727 40 to to IN 42759 727 41 modified modify VBN 42759 727 42 private private JJ 42759 727 43 ownership ownership NN 42759 727 44 . . . 42759 728 1 An an DT 42759 728 2 attempt attempt NN 42759 728 3 to to TO 42759 728 4 describe describe VB 42759 728 5 some some DT 42759 728 6 of of IN 42759 728 7 these these DT 42759 728 8 modifications modification NNS 42759 728 9 and and CC 42759 728 10 improvements improvement NNS 42759 728 11 will will MD 42759 728 12 be be VB 42759 728 13 made make VBN 42759 728 14 in in IN 42759 728 15 a a DT 42759 728 16 subsequent subsequent JJ 42759 728 17 chapter chapter NN 42759 728 18 . . . 42759 729 1 In in IN 42759 729 2 the the DT 42759 729 3 meantime meantime NN 42759 729 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 729 5 content content VBP 42759 729 6 ourselves -PRON- PRP 42759 729 7 with with IN 42759 729 8 the the DT 42759 729 9 statement statement NN 42759 729 10 that that IN 42759 729 11 private private JJ 42759 729 12 land land NN 42759 729 13 ownership ownership NN 42759 729 14 is be VBZ 42759 729 15 capable capable JJ 42759 729 16 of of IN 42759 729 17 becoming become VBG 42759 729 18 better well JJR 42759 729 19 than than IN 42759 729 20 Socialism socialism NN 42759 729 21 certainly certainly RB 42759 729 22 , , , 42759 729 23 and and CC 42759 729 24 probably probably RB 42759 729 25 better well RBR 42759 729 26 than than IN 42759 729 27 the the DT 42759 729 28 Single Single NNP 42759 729 29 Tax Tax NNP 42759 729 30 system system NN 42759 729 31 . . . 42759 730 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 730 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 730 3 is be VBZ 42759 730 4 justified justified JJ 42759 730 5 not not RB 42759 730 6 merely merely RB 42759 730 7 so so RB 42759 730 8 long long RB 42759 730 9 as as IN 42759 730 10 neither neither DT 42759 730 11 of of IN 42759 730 12 these these DT 42759 730 13 schemes scheme NNS 42759 730 14 is be VBZ 42759 730 15 introduced introduce VBN 42759 730 16 , , , 42759 730 17 but but CC 42759 730 18 as as IN 42759 730 19 an an DT 42759 730 20 institution institution NN 42759 730 21 which which WDT 42759 730 22 the the DT 42759 730 23 State State NNP 42759 730 24 would would MD 42759 730 25 do do VB 42759 730 26 well well RB 42759 730 27 to to TO 42759 730 28 maintain maintain VB 42759 730 29 , , , 42759 730 30 protect protect VB 42759 730 31 , , , 42759 730 32 and and CC 42759 730 33 improve improve VB 42759 730 34 . . . 42759 731 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 731 2 : : : 42759 731 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 731 4 27 27 CD 42759 731 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 731 6 Cf Cf NNP 42759 731 7 . . . 42759 732 1 Chapter chapter NN 42759 732 2 xi xi NNP 42759 732 3 . . . 42759 733 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 733 2 28 28 CD 42759 733 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 733 4 Ensor ensor NN 42759 733 5 , , , 42759 733 6 " " `` 42759 733 7 Modern modern JJ 42759 733 8 Socialism socialism NN 42759 733 9 , , , 42759 733 10 " " '' 42759 733 11 p. p. NNP 42759 733 12 xxxi xxxi NNP 42759 733 13 , , , 42759 733 14 N. N. NNP 42759 733 15 Y. Y. NNP 42759 733 16 , , , 42759 733 17 1904 1904 CD 42759 733 18 . . . 42759 734 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 734 2 29 29 CD 42759 734 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 734 4 Idem Idem NNP 42759 734 5 , , , 42759 734 6 pp pp NNP 42759 734 7 . . . 42759 735 1 213 213 CD 42759 735 2 - - SYM 42759 735 3 216 216 CD 42759 735 4 . . . 42759 736 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 736 2 30 30 CD 42759 736 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 736 4 Cited cite VBN 42759 736 5 by by IN 42759 736 6 Spargo Spargo NNP 42759 736 7 , , , 42759 736 8 " " `` 42759 736 9 The the DT 42759 736 10 Substance Substance NNP 42759 736 11 of of IN 42759 736 12 Socialism socialism NN 42759 736 13 , , , 42759 736 14 " " '' 42759 736 15 p. p. NN 42759 736 16 88 88 CD 42759 736 17 , , , 42759 736 18 N. N. NNP 42759 736 19 Y. Y. NNP 42759 736 20 , , , 42759 736 21 1909 1909 CD 42759 736 22 . . . 42759 737 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 737 2 31 31 CD 42759 737 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 737 4 Idem Idem NNP 42759 737 5 , , , 42759 737 6 p. p. NN 42759 737 7 90 90 CD 42759 737 8 . . . 42759 738 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 738 2 32 32 CD 42759 738 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 738 4 " " `` 42759 738 5 Progress Progress NNP 42759 738 6 and and CC 42759 738 7 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 738 8 , , , 42759 738 9 " " '' 42759 738 10 book book NN 42759 738 11 viii viii NN 42759 738 12 , , , 42759 738 13 ch ch NN 42759 738 14 . . . 42759 739 1 ii ii LS 42759 739 2 . . . 42759 740 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 740 2 33 33 CD 42759 740 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 740 4 Cf cf NN 42759 740 5 . . . 42759 741 1 Walker Walker NNP 42759 741 2 , , , 42759 741 3 " " `` 42759 741 4 Land land NN 42759 741 5 and and CC 42759 741 6 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 741 7 Rent Rent NNP 42759 741 8 " " '' 42759 741 9 ; ; : 42759 741 10 and and CC 42759 741 11 Seligman Seligman NNP 42759 741 12 , , , 42759 741 13 " " `` 42759 741 14 Essays essay NNS 42759 741 15 in in IN 42759 741 16 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 741 17 . . . 42759 741 18 " " '' 42759 742 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 742 2 V V NNP 42759 742 3 PRIVATE private JJ 42759 742 4 LANDOWNERSHIP LANDOWNERSHIP NNP 42759 742 5 A a DT 42759 742 6 NATURAL natural JJ 42759 742 7 RIGHT right NN 42759 742 8 The the DT 42759 742 9 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 742 10 of of IN 42759 742 11 the the DT 42759 742 12 preceding precede VBG 42759 742 13 chapter chapter NN 42759 742 14 include include VBP 42759 742 15 the the DT 42759 742 16 statement statement NN 42759 742 17 that that IN 42759 742 18 individuals individual NNS 42759 742 19 are be VBP 42759 742 20 morally morally RB 42759 742 21 justified justify VBN 42759 742 22 in in IN 42759 742 23 becoming become VBG 42759 742 24 and and CC 42759 742 25 remaining remain VBG 42759 742 26 landowners landowner NNS 42759 742 27 . . . 42759 743 1 May May MD 42759 743 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 743 3 take take VB 42759 743 4 a a DT 42759 743 5 further further JJ 42759 743 6 step step NN 42759 743 7 , , , 42759 743 8 and and CC 42759 743 9 assert assert VB 42759 743 10 that that DT 42759 743 11 private private JJ 42759 743 12 landownership landownership NN 42759 743 13 is be VBZ 42759 743 14 a a DT 42759 743 15 natural natural JJ 42759 743 16 right right NN 42759 743 17 of of IN 42759 743 18 the the DT 42759 743 19 individual individual NN 42759 743 20 ? ? . 42759 744 1 If if IN 42759 744 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 744 3 is be VBZ 42759 744 4 , , , 42759 744 5 the the DT 42759 744 6 abolition abolition NN 42759 744 7 of of IN 42759 744 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 744 9 by by IN 42759 744 10 the the DT 42759 744 11 State State NNP 42759 744 12 , , , 42759 744 13 even even RB 42759 744 14 with with IN 42759 744 15 compensation compensation NN 42759 744 16 to to IN 42759 744 17 the the DT 42759 744 18 owners owner NNS 42759 744 19 , , , 42759 744 20 would would MD 42759 744 21 be be VB 42759 744 22 an an DT 42759 744 23 act act NN 42759 744 24 of of IN 42759 744 25 injustice injustice NN 42759 744 26 . . . 42759 745 1 The the DT 42759 745 2 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 745 3 of of IN 42759 745 4 natural natural JJ 42759 745 5 rights right NNS 42759 745 6 is be VBZ 42759 745 7 so so RB 42759 745 8 prominent prominent JJ 42759 745 9 in in IN 42759 745 10 the the DT 42759 745 11 arguments argument NNS 42759 745 12 of of IN 42759 745 13 both both DT 42759 745 14 the the DT 42759 745 15 advocates advocate NNS 42759 745 16 and and CC 42759 745 17 the the DT 42759 745 18 opponents opponent NNS 42759 745 19 of of IN 42759 745 20 private private JJ 42759 745 21 landownership landownership NN 42759 745 22 that that WDT 42759 745 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 745 24 deserves deserve VBZ 42759 745 25 specific specific JJ 42759 745 26 treatment treatment NN 42759 745 27 . . . 42759 746 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 746 2 , , , 42759 746 3 the the DT 42759 746 4 claim claim NN 42759 746 5 that that IN 42759 746 6 private private JJ 42759 746 7 landownership landownership NN 42759 746 8 is be VBZ 42759 746 9 a a DT 42759 746 10 natural natural JJ 42759 746 11 right right JJ 42759 746 12 rests rest NNS 42759 746 13 upon upon IN 42759 746 14 precisely precisely RB 42759 746 15 the the DT 42759 746 16 same same JJ 42759 746 17 basis basis NN 42759 746 18 as as IN 42759 746 19 the the DT 42759 746 20 similar similar JJ 42759 746 21 claim claim NN 42759 746 22 with with IN 42759 746 23 regard regard NN 42759 746 24 to to IN 42759 746 25 the the DT 42759 746 26 individual individual JJ 42759 746 27 ownership ownership NN 42759 746 28 of of IN 42759 746 29 capital capital NN 42759 746 30 ; ; , 42759 746 31 and and CC 42759 746 32 the the DT 42759 746 33 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 746 34 pertinent pertinent JJ 42759 746 35 to to IN 42759 746 36 the the DT 42759 746 37 former former JJ 42759 746 38 will will MD 42759 746 39 be be VB 42759 746 40 equally equally RB 42759 746 41 applicable applicable JJ 42759 746 42 to to IN 42759 746 43 the the DT 42759 746 44 latter latter JJ 42759 746 45 . . . 42759 747 1 A a DT 42759 747 2 natural natural JJ 42759 747 3 right right NN 42759 747 4 is be VBZ 42759 747 5 a a DT 42759 747 6 right right NN 42759 747 7 derived derive VBN 42759 747 8 from from IN 42759 747 9 the the DT 42759 747 10 nature nature NN 42759 747 11 of of IN 42759 747 12 the the DT 42759 747 13 individual individual NN 42759 747 14 , , , 42759 747 15 and and CC 42759 747 16 existing exist VBG 42759 747 17 for for IN 42759 747 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 747 19 welfare welfare NN 42759 747 20 . . . 42759 748 1 Hence hence RB 42759 748 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 748 3 differs differ VBZ 42759 748 4 from from IN 42759 748 5 a a DT 42759 748 6 civil civil JJ 42759 748 7 right right NN 42759 748 8 , , , 42759 748 9 which which WDT 42759 748 10 is be VBZ 42759 748 11 derived derive VBN 42759 748 12 from from IN 42759 748 13 society society NN 42759 748 14 or or CC 42759 748 15 the the DT 42759 748 16 State State NNP 42759 748 17 , , , 42759 748 18 and and CC 42759 748 19 is be VBZ 42759 748 20 intended intend VBN 42759 748 21 for for IN 42759 748 22 a a DT 42759 748 23 social social JJ 42759 748 24 or or CC 42759 748 25 civil civil JJ 42759 748 26 purpose purpose NN 42759 748 27 . . . 42759 749 1 Such such JJ 42759 749 2 , , , 42759 749 3 for for IN 42759 749 4 example example NN 42759 749 5 , , , 42759 749 6 is be VBZ 42759 749 7 the the DT 42759 749 8 right right NN 42759 749 9 to to TO 42759 749 10 vote vote VB 42759 749 11 , , , 42759 749 12 or or CC 42759 749 13 the the DT 42759 749 14 right right NN 42759 749 15 to to TO 42759 749 16 hold hold VB 42759 749 17 a a DT 42759 749 18 public public JJ 42759 749 19 office office NN 42759 749 20 . . . 42759 750 1 Since since IN 42759 750 2 a a DT 42759 750 3 natural natural JJ 42759 750 4 right right NN 42759 750 5 neither neither CC 42759 750 6 proceeds proceed VBZ 42759 750 7 from from IN 42759 750 8 nor nor CC 42759 750 9 is be VBZ 42759 750 10 primarily primarily RB 42759 750 11 designed design VBN 42759 750 12 for for IN 42759 750 13 a a DT 42759 750 14 civil civil JJ 42759 750 15 end end NN 42759 750 16 , , , 42759 750 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 750 18 can can MD 42759 750 19 not not RB 42759 750 20 be be VB 42759 750 21 annulled annul VBN 42759 750 22 , , , 42759 750 23 and and CC 42759 750 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 750 25 may may MD 42759 750 26 not not RB 42759 750 27 be be VB 42759 750 28 ignored ignore VBN 42759 750 29 , , , 42759 750 30 by by IN 42759 750 31 the the DT 42759 750 32 State State NNP 42759 750 33 . . . 42759 751 1 For for IN 42759 751 2 example example NN 42759 751 3 : : : 42759 751 4 the the DT 42759 751 5 right right NN 42759 751 6 to to IN 42759 751 7 life life NN 42759 751 8 and and CC 42759 751 9 the the DT 42759 751 10 right right NN 42759 751 11 to to IN 42759 751 12 liberty liberty NN 42759 751 13 are be VBP 42759 751 14 so so RB 42759 751 15 sacred sacred JJ 42759 751 16 to to IN 42759 751 17 the the DT 42759 751 18 individual individual NN 42759 751 19 , , , 42759 751 20 so so RB 42759 751 21 necessary necessary JJ 42759 751 22 to to IN 42759 751 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 751 24 welfare welfare NN 42759 751 25 , , , 42759 751 26 that that IN 42759 751 27 the the DT 42759 751 28 State State NNP 42759 751 29 can can MD 42759 751 30 not not RB 42759 751 31 rightfully rightfully RB 42759 751 32 kill kill VB 42759 751 33 an an DT 42759 751 34 innocent innocent JJ 42759 751 35 man man NN 42759 751 36 , , , 42759 751 37 nor nor CC 42759 751 38 punish punish VB 42759 751 39 him -PRON- PRP 42759 751 40 by by IN 42759 751 41 a a DT 42759 751 42 term term NN 42759 751 43 in in IN 42759 751 44 prison prison NN 42759 751 45 . . . 42759 752 1 _ _ NNP 42759 752 2 Three Three NNP 42759 752 3 Principal principal JJ 42759 752 4 Kinds Kinds NNPS 42759 752 5 of of IN 42759 752 6 Natural Natural NNP 42759 752 7 Rights Rights NNPS 42759 752 8 _ _ NNP 42759 752 9 Although although IN 42759 752 10 natural natural JJ 42759 752 11 rights right NNS 42759 752 12 are be VBP 42759 752 13 all all DT 42759 752 14 equally equally RB 42759 752 15 valid valid JJ 42759 752 16 , , , 42759 752 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 752 18 differ differ VBP 42759 752 19 in in IN 42759 752 20 regard regard NN 42759 752 21 to to IN 42759 752 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 752 23 basis basis NN 42759 752 24 , , , 42759 752 25 and and CC 42759 752 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 752 27 urgency urgency NN 42759 752 28 or or CC 42759 752 29 importance importance NN 42759 752 30 . . . 42759 753 1 From from IN 42759 753 2 this this DT 42759 753 3 point point NN 42759 753 4 of of IN 42759 753 5 view view NN 42759 753 6 , , , 42759 753 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 753 8 may may MD 42759 753 9 profitably profitably RB 42759 753 10 distinguish distinguish VB 42759 753 11 three three CD 42759 753 12 principal principal JJ 42759 753 13 types type NNS 42759 753 14 . . . 42759 754 1 The the DT 42759 754 2 first first JJ 42759 754 3 is be VBZ 42759 754 4 exemplified exemplify VBN 42759 754 5 in in IN 42759 754 6 the the DT 42759 754 7 right right NN 42759 754 8 to to TO 42759 754 9 live live VB 42759 754 10 . . . 42759 755 1 The the DT 42759 755 2 object object NN 42759 755 3 of of IN 42759 755 4 this this DT 42759 755 5 right right NN 42759 755 6 , , , 42759 755 7 life life NN 42759 755 8 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 755 9 , , , 42759 755 10 is be VBZ 42759 755 11 intrinsically intrinsically RB 42759 755 12 good good JJ 42759 755 13 , , , 42759 755 14 good good JJ 42759 755 15 for for IN 42759 755 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 755 17 own own JJ 42759 755 18 sake sake NN 42759 755 19 , , , 42759 755 20 an an DT 42759 755 21 end end NN 42759 755 22 in in IN 42759 755 23 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 755 24 . . . 42759 756 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 756 2 is be VBZ 42759 756 3 the the DT 42759 756 4 end end NN 42759 756 5 to to TO 42759 756 6 which which WDT 42759 756 7 even even RB 42759 756 8 civil civil JJ 42759 756 9 society society NN 42759 756 10 is be VBZ 42759 756 11 a a DT 42759 756 12 means means NN 42759 756 13 . . . 42759 757 1 Since since IN 42759 757 2 life life NN 42759 757 3 is be VBZ 42759 757 4 good good JJ 42759 757 5 intrinsically intrinsically RB 42759 757 6 , , , 42759 757 7 the the DT 42759 757 8 right right NN 42759 757 9 to to IN 42759 757 10 life life NN 42759 757 11 is be VBZ 42759 757 12 also also RB 42759 757 13 valid valid JJ 42759 757 14 intrinsically intrinsically RB 42759 757 15 , , , 42759 757 16 and and CC 42759 757 17 not not RB 42759 757 18 because because IN 42759 757 19 of of IN 42759 757 20 consequences consequence NNS 42759 757 21 . . . 42759 758 1 Since since IN 42759 758 2 there there EX 42759 758 3 is be VBZ 42759 758 4 no no DT 42759 758 5 conceivable conceivable JJ 42759 758 6 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 758 7 for for IN 42759 758 8 life life NN 42759 758 9 in in IN 42759 758 10 the the DT 42759 758 11 case case NN 42759 758 12 of of IN 42759 758 13 any any DT 42759 758 14 individual individual NN 42759 758 15 in in IN 42759 758 16 any any DT 42759 758 17 contingency contingency NN 42759 758 18 , , , 42759 758 19 the the DT 42759 758 20 right right NN 42759 758 21 to to IN 42759 758 22 life life NN 42759 758 23 is be VBZ 42759 758 24 immediate immediate JJ 42759 758 25 and and CC 42759 758 26 direct direct JJ 42759 758 27 in in IN 42759 758 28 all all DT 42759 758 29 possible possible JJ 42759 758 30 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 758 31 . . . 42759 759 1 Among among IN 42759 759 2 the the DT 42759 759 3 natural natural JJ 42759 759 4 rights right NNS 42759 759 5 of of IN 42759 759 6 the the DT 42759 759 7 second second JJ 42759 759 8 class class NN 42759 759 9 , , , 42759 759 10 the the DT 42759 759 11 most most RBS 42759 759 12 prominent prominent JJ 42759 759 13 are be VBP 42759 759 14 the the DT 42759 759 15 right right NN 42759 759 16 to to TO 42759 759 17 marry marry VB 42759 759 18 , , , 42759 759 19 to to TO 42759 759 20 enjoy enjoy VB 42759 759 21 personal personal JJ 42759 759 22 freedom freedom NN 42759 759 23 , , , 42759 759 24 and and CC 42759 759 25 to to TO 42759 759 26 own own VB 42759 759 27 consumption consumption NN 42759 759 28 - - HYPH 42759 759 29 goods good NNS 42759 759 30 , , , 42759 759 31 such such JJ 42759 759 32 as as IN 42759 759 33 food food NN 42759 759 34 and and CC 42759 759 35 clothing clothing NN 42759 759 36 . . . 42759 760 1 The the DT 42759 760 2 objects object NNS 42759 760 3 of of IN 42759 760 4 these these DT 42759 760 5 rights right NNS 42759 760 6 are be VBP 42759 760 7 not not RB 42759 760 8 ends end VBZ 42759 760 9 in in IN 42759 760 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 760 11 , , , 42759 760 12 but but CC 42759 760 13 means mean VBZ 42759 760 14 to to IN 42759 760 15 human human JJ 42759 760 16 welfare welfare NN 42759 760 17 . . . 42759 761 1 Confining confine VBG 42759 761 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 761 3 attention attention NN 42759 761 4 to to IN 42759 761 5 marriage marriage NN 42759 761 6 , , , 42759 761 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 761 8 see see VBP 42759 761 9 that that DT 42759 761 10 membership membership NN 42759 761 11 in in IN 42759 761 12 the the DT 42759 761 13 conjugal conjugal NNP 42759 761 14 union union NNP 42759 761 15 is be VBZ 42759 761 16 an an DT 42759 761 17 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 761 18 means mean NNS 42759 761 19 to to TO 42759 761 20 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 761 21 life life NN 42759 761 22 and and CC 42759 761 23 self self NN 42759 761 24 development development NN 42759 761 25 in in IN 42759 761 26 the the DT 42759 761 27 majority majority NN 42759 761 28 of of IN 42759 761 29 persons person NNS 42759 761 30 . . . 42759 762 1 The the DT 42759 762 2 only only JJ 42759 762 3 conceivable conceivable JJ 42759 762 4 substitutes substitute NNS 42759 762 5 are be VBP 42759 762 6 free free JJ 42759 762 7 love love NN 42759 762 8 and and CC 42759 762 9 celibacy celibacy NN 42759 762 10 . . . 42759 763 1 Of of IN 42759 763 2 these these DT 42759 763 3 the the DT 42759 763 4 first first JJ 42759 763 5 is be VBZ 42759 763 6 inadequate inadequate JJ 42759 763 7 for for IN 42759 763 8 any any DT 42759 763 9 person person NN 42759 763 10 , , , 42759 763 11 and and CC 42759 763 12 the the DT 42759 763 13 second second JJ 42759 763 14 is be VBZ 42759 763 15 adequate adequate JJ 42759 763 16 only only RB 42759 763 17 for for IN 42759 763 18 a a DT 42759 763 19 minority minority NN 42759 763 20 . . . 42759 764 1 Marriage marriage NN 42759 764 2 is be VBZ 42759 764 3 , , , 42759 764 4 therefore therefore RB 42759 764 5 , , , 42759 764 6 _ _ NNP 42759 764 7 directly directly RB 42759 764 8 _ _ NNP 42759 764 9 and and CC 42759 764 10 _ _ NNP 42759 764 11 per per FW 42759 764 12 se se FW 42759 764 13 _ _ NNP 42759 764 14 necessary necessary JJ 42759 764 15 for for IN 42759 764 16 the the DT 42759 764 17 majority majority NN 42759 764 18 of of IN 42759 764 19 individuals individual NNS 42759 764 20 ; ; : 42759 764 21 for for IN 42759 764 22 the the DT 42759 764 23 majority majority NN 42759 764 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 764 25 is be VBZ 42759 764 26 an an DT 42759 764 27 _ _ NNP 42759 764 28 individual individual NN 42759 764 29 _ _ NNP 42759 764 30 necessity necessity NN 42759 764 31 . . . 42759 765 1 If if IN 42759 765 2 the the DT 42759 765 3 State State NNP 42759 765 4 were be VBD 42759 765 5 to to TO 42759 765 6 abolish abolish VB 42759 765 7 marriage marriage NN 42759 765 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 765 9 would would MD 42759 765 10 deprive deprive VB 42759 765 11 the the DT 42759 765 12 majority majority NN 42759 765 13 of of IN 42759 765 14 an an DT 42759 765 15 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 765 16 means mean NNS 42759 765 17 of of IN 42759 765 18 right right JJ 42759 765 19 and and CC 42759 765 20 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 765 21 life life NN 42759 765 22 . . . 42759 766 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 766 2 the the DT 42759 766 3 majority majority NN 42759 766 4 have have VBP 42759 766 5 a a DT 42759 766 6 _ _ NNP 42759 766 7 direct direct JJ 42759 766 8 _ _ NNP 42759 766 9 natural natural JJ 42759 766 10 right right NN 42759 766 11 to to IN 42759 766 12 the the DT 42759 766 13 legal legal JJ 42759 766 14 power power NN 42759 766 15 of of IN 42759 766 16 marrying marrying NN 42759 766 17 . . . 42759 767 1 In in IN 42759 767 2 the the DT 42759 767 3 case case NN 42759 767 4 of of IN 42759 767 5 the the DT 42759 767 6 minority minority NN 42759 767 7 who who WP 42759 767 8 do do VBP 42759 767 9 not not RB 42759 767 10 need need VB 42759 767 11 to to TO 42759 767 12 marry marry VB 42759 767 13 , , , 42759 767 14 who who WP 42759 767 15 can can MD 42759 767 16 live live VB 42759 767 17 as as RB 42759 767 18 well well RB 42759 767 19 or or CC 42759 767 20 better well RBR 42759 767 21 as as IN 42759 767 22 celibates celibate NNS 42759 767 23 , , , 42759 767 24 the the DT 42759 767 25 legal legal JJ 42759 767 26 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 767 27 of of IN 42759 767 28 marriage marriage NN 42759 767 29 is be VBZ 42759 767 30 evidently evidently RB 42759 767 31 not not RB 42759 767 32 directly directly RB 42759 767 33 necessary necessary JJ 42759 767 34 . . . 42759 768 1 But but CC 42759 768 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 768 3 is be VBZ 42759 768 4 necessary necessary JJ 42759 768 5 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 768 6 , , , 42759 768 7 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 768 8 as as IN 42759 768 9 the the DT 42759 768 10 _ _ NNP 42759 768 11 power power NN 42759 768 12 of of IN 42759 768 13 choice choice NN 42759 768 14 _ _ NNP 42759 768 15 between between IN 42759 768 16 marriage marriage NN 42759 768 17 and and CC 42759 768 18 celibacy celibacy NN 42759 768 19 is be VBZ 42759 768 20 an an DT 42759 768 21 individual individual JJ 42759 768 22 necessity necessity NN 42759 768 23 . . . 42759 769 1 No no DT 42759 769 2 argument argument NN 42759 769 3 is be VBZ 42759 769 4 required require VBN 42759 769 5 to to TO 42759 769 6 show show VB 42759 769 7 that that IN 42759 769 8 the the DT 42759 769 9 State State NNP 42759 769 10 could could MD 42759 769 11 not not RB 42759 769 12 decide decide VB 42759 769 13 this this DT 42759 769 14 matter matter NN 42759 769 15 consistently consistently RB 42759 769 16 with with IN 42759 769 17 individual individual JJ 42759 769 18 welfare welfare NN 42759 769 19 or or CC 42759 769 20 social social JJ 42759 769 21 peace peace NN 42759 769 22 . . . 42759 770 1 Whence whence IN 42759 770 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 770 3 follows follow VBZ 42759 770 4 that that IN 42759 770 5 even even RB 42759 770 6 the the DT 42759 770 7 minority minority NN 42759 770 8 who who WP 42759 770 9 do do VBP 42759 770 10 not not RB 42759 770 11 wish wish VB 42759 770 12 or or CC 42759 770 13 do do VBP 42759 770 14 not not RB 42759 770 15 need need VB 42759 770 16 to to TO 42759 770 17 marry marry VB 42759 770 18 , , , 42759 770 19 have have VB 42759 770 20 a a DT 42759 770 21 natural natural JJ 42759 770 22 right right NN 42759 770 23 to to TO 42759 770 24 embrace embrace VB 42759 770 25 or or CC 42759 770 26 reject reject VB 42759 770 27 the the DT 42759 770 28 conjugal conjugal JJ 42759 770 29 condition condition NN 42759 770 30 . . . 42759 771 1 In in IN 42759 771 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 771 3 case case NN 42759 771 4 the the DT 42759 771 5 right right NN 42759 771 6 to to TO 42759 771 7 marry marry VB 42759 771 8 is be VBZ 42759 771 9 indirect indirect JJ 42759 771 10 , , , 42759 771 11 but but CC 42759 771 12 none none NN 42759 771 13 the the DT 42759 771 14 less less RBR 42759 771 15 inviolable inviolable JJ 42759 771 16 . . . 42759 772 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 772 2 34 34 CD 42759 772 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 772 4 Private private JJ 42759 772 5 ownership ownership NN 42759 772 6 of of IN 42759 772 7 land land NN 42759 772 8 belongs belong VBZ 42759 772 9 in in IN 42759 772 10 a a DT 42759 772 11 third third JJ 42759 772 12 class class NN 42759 772 13 of of IN 42759 772 14 natural natural JJ 42759 772 15 rights right NNS 42759 772 16 . . . 42759 773 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 773 2 as as IN 42759 773 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 773 4 is be VBZ 42759 773 5 not not RB 42759 773 6 an an DT 42759 773 7 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 773 8 good good NN 42759 773 9 , , , 42759 773 10 but but CC 42759 773 11 merely merely RB 42759 773 12 a a DT 42759 773 13 means means NN 42759 773 14 to to IN 42759 773 15 human human JJ 42759 773 16 welfare welfare NN 42759 773 17 , , , 42759 773 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 773 19 differs differ VBZ 42759 773 20 from from IN 42759 773 21 life life NN 42759 773 22 and and CC 42759 773 23 resembles resemble VBZ 42759 773 24 marriage marriage NN 42759 773 25 . . . 42759 774 1 On on IN 42759 774 2 the the DT 42759 774 3 other other JJ 42759 774 4 hand hand NN 42759 774 5 , , , 42759 774 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 774 7 is be VBZ 42759 774 8 unlike unlike IN 42759 774 9 marriage marriage NN 42759 774 10 in in IN 42759 774 11 that that IN 42759 774 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 774 13 is be VBZ 42759 774 14 not not RB 42759 774 15 _ _ NNP 42759 774 16 directly directly RB 42759 774 17 _ _ NNP 42759 774 18 necessary necessary JJ 42759 774 19 for for IN 42759 774 20 any any DT 42759 774 21 individual individual NN 42759 774 22 whatever whatever WDT 42759 774 23 . . . 42759 775 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 775 2 35 35 CD 42759 775 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 775 4 The the DT 42759 775 5 alternative alternative NN 42759 775 6 to to IN 42759 775 7 marriage marriage NN 42759 775 8 , , , 42759 775 9 namely namely RB 42759 775 10 , , , 42759 775 11 celibacy celibacy NN 42759 775 12 , , , 42759 775 13 would would MD 42759 775 14 not not RB 42759 775 15 even even RB 42759 775 16 under under IN 42759 775 17 the the DT 42759 775 18 best good JJS 42759 775 19 social social JJ 42759 775 20 administration administration NN 42759 775 21 enable enable VBP 42759 775 22 the the DT 42759 775 23 majority majority NN 42759 775 24 to to TO 42759 775 25 lead lead VB 42759 775 26 right right JJ 42759 775 27 and and CC 42759 775 28 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 775 29 lives life NNS 42759 775 30 . . . 42759 776 1 The the DT 42759 776 2 alternative alternative NN 42759 776 3 to to IN 42759 776 4 private private JJ 42759 776 5 landownership landownership NN 42759 776 6 ( ( -LRB- 42759 776 7 and and CC 42759 776 8 to to TO 42759 776 9 private private JJ 42759 776 10 ownership ownership NN 42759 776 11 of of IN 42759 776 12 capital capital NN 42759 776 13 as as RB 42759 776 14 well well RB 42759 776 15 ) ) -RRB- 42759 776 16 , , , 42759 776 17 namely namely RB 42759 776 18 , , , 42759 776 19 some some DT 42759 776 20 form form NN 42759 776 21 of of IN 42759 776 22 employment employment NN 42759 776 23 as as IN 42759 776 24 wage wage NN 42759 776 25 receiver receiver NN 42759 776 26 , , , 42759 776 27 salary salary NN 42759 776 28 receiver receiver NN 42759 776 29 , , , 42759 776 30 or or CC 42759 776 31 fee fee NN 42759 776 32 receiver receiver NN 42759 776 33 enables enable VBZ 42759 776 34 the the DT 42759 776 35 individual individual NN 42759 776 36 to to TO 42759 776 37 attain attain VB 42759 776 38 all all PDT 42759 776 39 the the DT 42759 776 40 vital vital JJ 42759 776 41 ends end NNS 42759 776 42 of of IN 42759 776 43 private private JJ 42759 776 44 ownership ownership NN 42759 776 45 : : : 42759 776 46 food food NN 42759 776 47 , , , 42759 776 48 clothing clothing NN 42759 776 49 , , , 42759 776 50 shelter shelter NN 42759 776 51 , , , 42759 776 52 security security NN 42759 776 53 of of IN 42759 776 54 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 776 55 and and CC 42759 776 56 residence residence NN 42759 776 57 , , , 42759 776 58 and and CC 42759 776 59 the the DT 42759 776 60 means mean NNS 42759 776 61 of of IN 42759 776 62 mental mental JJ 42759 776 63 , , , 42759 776 64 moral moral JJ 42759 776 65 , , , 42759 776 66 and and CC 42759 776 67 spiritual spiritual JJ 42759 776 68 development development NN 42759 776 69 . . . 42759 777 1 None none NN 42759 777 2 of of IN 42759 777 3 these these DT 42759 777 4 vital vital JJ 42759 777 5 ends end NNS 42759 777 6 or or CC 42759 777 7 needs need VBZ 42759 777 8 is be VBZ 42759 777 9 essentially essentially RB 42759 777 10 dependent dependent JJ 42759 777 11 upon upon IN 42759 777 12 private private JJ 42759 777 13 ownership ownership NN 42759 777 14 of of IN 42759 777 15 land land NN 42759 777 16 ; ; : 42759 777 17 for for IN 42759 777 18 millions million NNS 42759 777 19 of of IN 42759 777 20 persons person NNS 42759 777 21 satisfy satisfy VBP 42759 777 22 them -PRON- PRP 42759 777 23 every every DT 42759 777 24 day day NN 42759 777 25 without without IN 42759 777 26 becoming become VBG 42759 777 27 landowners landowner NNS 42759 777 28 . . . 42759 778 1 Nor nor CC 42759 778 2 are be VBP 42759 778 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 778 4 exceptions exception NNS 42759 778 5 , , , 42759 778 6 as as IN 42759 778 7 those those DT 42759 778 8 who who WP 42759 778 9 can can MD 42759 778 10 get get VB 42759 778 11 along along RP 42759 778 12 without without IN 42759 778 13 marriage marriage NN 42759 778 14 are be VBP 42759 778 15 exceptions exception NNS 42759 778 16 . . . 42759 779 1 The the DT 42759 779 2 persons person NNS 42759 779 3 who who WP 42759 779 4 live live VBP 42759 779 5 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 779 6 lives life NNS 42759 779 7 without without IN 42759 779 8 owning own VBG 42759 779 9 land land NN 42759 779 10 are be VBP 42759 779 11 average average JJ 42759 779 12 persons person NNS 42759 779 13 . . . 42759 780 1 What what WP 42759 780 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 780 3 do do VBP 42759 780 4 any any DT 42759 780 5 other other JJ 42759 780 6 person person NN 42759 780 7 could could MD 42759 780 8 do do VB 42759 780 9 if if IN 42759 780 10 placed place VBN 42759 780 11 in in IN 42759 780 12 the the DT 42759 780 13 same same JJ 42759 780 14 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 780 15 . . . 42759 781 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 781 2 , , , 42759 781 3 private private JJ 42759 781 4 landownership landownership NN 42759 781 5 is be VBZ 42759 781 6 not not RB 42759 781 7 directly directly RB 42759 781 8 necessary necessary JJ 42759 781 9 for for IN 42759 781 10 the the DT 42759 781 11 welfare welfare NN 42759 781 12 of of IN 42759 781 13 any any DT 42759 781 14 individual individual NN 42759 781 15 . . . 42759 782 1 _ _ NNP 42759 782 2 Private Private NNP 42759 782 3 Landownership landownership NN 42759 782 4 Indirectly indirectly RB 42759 782 5 Necessary necessary JJ 42759 782 6 for for IN 42759 782 7 Individual Individual NNP 42759 782 8 Welfare Welfare NNP 42759 782 9 _ _ NNP 42759 782 10 In in IN 42759 782 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 782 12 present present JJ 42759 782 13 industrial industrial JJ 42759 782 14 civilisation civilisation NN 42759 782 15 , , , 42759 782 16 however however RB 42759 782 17 , , , 42759 782 18 private private JJ 42759 782 19 landownership landownership NN 42759 782 20 is be VBZ 42759 782 21 _ _ NNP 42759 782 22 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 782 23 _ _ NNP 42759 782 24 necessary necessary JJ 42759 782 25 for for IN 42759 782 26 the the DT 42759 782 27 welfare welfare NN 42759 782 28 of of IN 42759 782 29 the the DT 42759 782 30 individual individual NN 42759 782 31 . . . 42759 783 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 783 2 is be VBZ 42759 783 3 said say VBN 42759 783 4 to to TO 42759 783 5 be be VB 42759 783 6 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 783 7 necessary necessary JJ 42759 783 8 because because IN 42759 783 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 783 10 is be VBZ 42759 783 11 necessary necessary JJ 42759 783 12 as as IN 42759 783 13 a a DT 42759 783 14 _ _ NNP 42759 783 15 social social JJ 42759 783 16 institution institution NN 42759 783 17 _ _ NNP 42759 783 18 , , , 42759 783 19 rather rather RB 42759 783 20 than than IN 42759 783 21 as as IN 42759 783 22 something something NN 42759 783 23 immediately immediately RB 42759 783 24 connected connect VBN 42759 783 25 with with IN 42759 783 26 individual individual JJ 42759 783 27 needs need NNS 42759 783 28 as as IN 42759 783 29 such such JJ 42759 783 30 . . . 42759 784 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 784 2 is be VBZ 42759 784 3 not not RB 42759 784 4 , , , 42759 784 5 indeed indeed RB 42759 784 6 , , , 42759 784 7 so so RB 42759 784 8 necessary necessary JJ 42759 784 9 that that IN 42759 784 10 society society NN 42759 784 11 would would MD 42759 784 12 promptly promptly RB 42759 784 13 go go VB 42759 784 14 to to IN 42759 784 15 pieces piece NNS 42759 784 16 under under IN 42759 784 17 any any DT 42759 784 18 other other JJ 42759 784 19 form form NN 42759 784 20 of of IN 42759 784 21 land land NN 42759 784 22 tenure tenure NN 42759 784 23 . . . 42759 785 1 As as IN 42759 785 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 785 3 have have VBP 42759 785 4 seen see VBN 42759 785 5 in in IN 42759 785 6 the the DT 42759 785 7 last last JJ 42759 785 8 chapter chapter NN 42759 785 9 , , , 42759 785 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 785 11 is be VBZ 42759 785 12 necessary necessary JJ 42759 785 13 in in IN 42759 785 14 the the DT 42759 785 15 sense sense NN 42759 785 16 that that IN 42759 785 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 785 18 is be VBZ 42759 785 19 capable capable JJ 42759 785 20 of of IN 42759 785 21 promoting promote VBG 42759 785 22 the the DT 42759 785 23 welfare welfare NN 42759 785 24 of of IN 42759 785 25 the the DT 42759 785 26 average average JJ 42759 785 27 person person NN 42759 785 28 , , , 42759 785 29 of of IN 42759 785 30 the the DT 42759 785 31 majority majority NN 42759 785 32 of of IN 42759 785 33 persons person NNS 42759 785 34 , , , 42759 785 35 to to IN 42759 785 36 a a DT 42759 785 37 much much RB 42759 785 38 greater great JJR 42759 785 39 degree degree NN 42759 785 40 than than IN 42759 785 41 State state NN 42759 785 42 ownership ownership NN 42759 785 43 . . . 42759 786 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 786 2 is be VBZ 42759 786 3 necessary necessary JJ 42759 786 4 for for IN 42759 786 5 the the DT 42759 786 6 same same JJ 42759 786 7 reason reason NN 42759 786 8 and and CC 42759 786 9 in in IN 42759 786 10 the the DT 42759 786 11 same same JJ 42759 786 12 way way NN 42759 786 13 as as IN 42759 786 14 a a DT 42759 786 15 civil civil JJ 42759 786 16 police police NN 42759 786 17 force force NN 42759 786 18 . . . 42759 787 1 As as IN 42759 787 2 the the DT 42759 787 3 State State NNP 42759 787 4 is be VBZ 42759 787 5 obliged oblige VBN 42759 787 6 to to TO 42759 787 7 maintain maintain VB 42759 787 8 a a DT 42759 787 9 police police NN 42759 787 10 force force NN 42759 787 11 , , , 42759 787 12 so so CC 42759 787 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 787 14 is be VBZ 42759 787 15 obliged oblige VBN 42759 787 16 to to TO 42759 787 17 maintain maintain VB 42759 787 18 a a DT 42759 787 19 system system NN 42759 787 20 of of IN 42759 787 21 private private JJ 42759 787 22 landownership landownership NN 42759 787 23 . . . 42759 788 1 As as IN 42759 788 2 the the DT 42759 788 3 citizen citizen NN 42759 788 4 has have VBZ 42759 788 5 a a DT 42759 788 6 right right NN 42759 788 7 to to IN 42759 788 8 police police NN 42759 788 9 protection protection NN 42759 788 10 , , , 42759 788 11 so so CC 42759 788 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 788 13 has have VBZ 42759 788 14 a a DT 42759 788 15 right right NN 42759 788 16 to to IN 42759 788 17 the the DT 42759 788 18 social social JJ 42759 788 19 and and CC 42759 788 20 economic economic JJ 42759 788 21 advantages advantage NNS 42759 788 22 which which WDT 42759 788 23 are be VBP 42759 788 24 connected connect VBN 42759 788 25 with with IN 42759 788 26 the the DT 42759 788 27 system system NN 42759 788 28 of of IN 42759 788 29 private private JJ 42759 788 30 ownership ownership NN 42759 788 31 of of IN 42759 788 32 land land NN 42759 788 33 . . . 42759 789 1 These these DT 42759 789 2 rights right NNS 42759 789 3 are be VBP 42759 789 4 natural natural JJ 42759 789 5 , , , 42759 789 6 derived derive VBN 42759 789 7 from from IN 42759 789 8 the the DT 42759 789 9 needs need NNS 42759 789 10 of of IN 42759 789 11 the the DT 42759 789 12 individual individual NN 42759 789 13 in in IN 42759 789 14 society society NN 42759 789 15 , , , 42759 789 16 not not RB 42759 789 17 dependent dependent JJ 42759 789 18 upon upon IN 42759 789 19 the the DT 42759 789 20 good good JJ 42759 789 21 pleasure pleasure NN 42759 789 22 of of IN 42759 789 23 the the DT 42759 789 24 city city NN 42759 789 25 or or CC 42759 789 26 the the DT 42759 789 27 State State NNP 42759 789 28 . . . 42759 790 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 790 2 are be VBP 42759 790 3 individual individual JJ 42759 790 4 rights right NNS 42759 790 5 to to IN 42759 790 6 the the DT 42759 790 7 presence presence NN 42759 790 8 and and CC 42759 790 9 benefits benefit NNS 42759 790 10 of of IN 42759 790 11 these these DT 42759 790 12 social social JJ 42759 790 13 institutions institution NNS 42759 790 14 . . . 42759 791 1 But but CC 42759 791 2 man man NN 42759 791 3 's 's POS 42759 791 4 rights right NNS 42759 791 5 in in IN 42759 791 6 the the DT 42759 791 7 matter matter NN 42759 791 8 of of IN 42759 791 9 land land NN 42759 791 10 tenure tenure NN 42759 791 11 are be VBP 42759 791 12 more more RBR 42759 791 13 extensive extensive JJ 42759 791 14 than than IN 42759 791 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 791 16 rights right NNS 42759 791 17 with with IN 42759 791 18 regard regard NN 42759 791 19 to to IN 42759 791 20 a a DT 42759 791 21 police police NN 42759 791 22 force force NN 42759 791 23 . . . 42759 792 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 792 2 are be VBP 42759 792 3 not not RB 42759 792 4 restricted restrict VBN 42759 792 5 to to IN 42759 792 6 the the DT 42759 792 7 presence presence NN 42759 792 8 and and CC 42759 792 9 functioning functioning NN 42759 792 10 of of IN 42759 792 11 a a DT 42759 792 12 social social JJ 42759 792 13 institution institution NN 42759 792 14 . . . 42759 793 1 Every every DT 42759 793 2 citizen citizen NN 42759 793 3 has have VBZ 42759 793 4 a a DT 42759 793 5 natural natural JJ 42759 793 6 right right NN 42759 793 7 to to IN 42759 793 8 police police NN 42759 793 9 protection protection NN 42759 793 10 , , , 42759 793 11 but but CC 42759 793 12 no no DT 42759 793 13 citizen citizen NN 42759 793 14 has have VBZ 42759 793 15 a a DT 42759 793 16 natural natural JJ 42759 793 17 right right NN 42759 793 18 to to TO 42759 793 19 become become VB 42759 793 20 a a DT 42759 793 21 policeman policeman NN 42759 793 22 . . . 42759 794 1 The the DT 42759 794 2 welfare welfare NN 42759 794 3 of of IN 42759 794 4 the the DT 42759 794 5 citizen citizen NN 42759 794 6 is be VBZ 42759 794 7 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 794 8 looked look VBN 42759 794 9 after after IN 42759 794 10 when when WRB 42759 794 11 the the DT 42759 794 12 members member NNS 42759 794 13 of of IN 42759 794 14 the the DT 42759 794 15 police police NN 42759 794 16 are be VBP 42759 794 17 selected select VBN 42759 794 18 by by IN 42759 794 19 the the DT 42759 794 20 authorities authority NNS 42759 794 21 of of IN 42759 794 22 the the DT 42759 794 23 city city NN 42759 794 24 . . . 42759 795 1 On on IN 42759 795 2 the the DT 42759 795 3 contrary contrary NN 42759 795 4 , , , 42759 795 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 795 6 welfare welfare NN 42759 795 7 would would MD 42759 795 8 not not RB 42759 795 9 be be VB 42759 795 10 adequately adequately RB 42759 795 11 safeguarded safeguard VBN 42759 795 12 if if IN 42759 795 13 the the DT 42759 795 14 State State NNP 42759 795 15 were be VBD 42759 795 16 to to TO 42759 795 17 decide decide VB 42759 795 18 who who WP 42759 795 19 might may MD 42759 795 20 and and CC 42759 795 21 who who WP 42759 795 22 might may MD 42759 795 23 not not RB 42759 795 24 become become VB 42759 795 25 landowners landowner NNS 42759 795 26 . . . 42759 796 1 In in IN 42759 796 2 the the DT 42759 796 3 first first JJ 42759 796 4 place place NN 42759 796 5 , , , 42759 796 6 the the DT 42759 796 7 ideal ideal JJ 42759 796 8 condition condition NN 42759 796 9 is be VBZ 42759 796 10 that that IN 42759 796 11 in in IN 42759 796 12 which which WDT 42759 796 13 _ _ NNP 42759 796 14 all all DT 42759 796 15 _ _ NNP 42759 796 16 persons person NNS 42759 796 17 can can MD 42759 796 18 easily easily RB 42759 796 19 become become VB 42759 796 20 actual actual JJ 42759 796 21 owners owner NNS 42759 796 22 . . . 42759 797 1 In in IN 42759 797 2 the the DT 42759 797 3 second second JJ 42759 797 4 place place NN 42759 797 5 , , , 42759 797 6 the the DT 42759 797 7 mere mere JJ 42759 797 8 legal legal JJ 42759 797 9 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 797 10 of of IN 42759 797 11 becoming become VBG 42759 797 12 owners owner NNS 42759 797 13 is be VBZ 42759 797 14 a a DT 42759 797 15 considerable considerable JJ 42759 797 16 stimulus stimulus NN 42759 797 17 to to IN 42759 797 18 the the DT 42759 797 19 energy energy NN 42759 797 20 and and CC 42759 797 21 ambition ambition NN 42759 797 22 of of IN 42759 797 23 all all DT 42759 797 24 persons person NNS 42759 797 25 , , , 42759 797 26 even even RB 42759 797 27 of of IN 42759 797 28 those those DT 42759 797 29 who who WP 42759 797 30 are be VBP 42759 797 31 never never RB 42759 797 32 able able JJ 42759 797 33 to to TO 42759 797 34 convert convert VB 42759 797 35 it -PRON- PRP 42759 797 36 into into IN 42759 797 37 an an DT 42759 797 38 economic economic JJ 42759 797 39 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 797 40 . . . 42759 798 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 798 2 , , , 42759 798 3 only only RB 42759 798 4 a a DT 42759 798 5 very very RB 42759 798 6 powerful powerful JJ 42759 798 7 reason reason NN 42759 798 8 of of IN 42759 798 9 social social JJ 42759 798 10 utility utility NN 42759 798 11 would would MD 42759 798 12 justify justify VB 42759 798 13 the the DT 42759 798 14 State State NNP 42759 798 15 in in IN 42759 798 16 excluding exclude VBG 42759 798 17 any any DT 42759 798 18 person person NN 42759 798 19 or or CC 42759 798 20 any any DT 42759 798 21 class class NN 42759 798 22 from from IN 42759 798 23 the the DT 42759 798 24 legal legal JJ 42759 798 25 power power NN 42759 798 26 to to TO 42759 798 27 own own VB 42759 798 28 land land NN 42759 798 29 . . . 42759 799 1 No no DT 42759 799 2 such such JJ 42759 799 3 reason reason NN 42759 799 4 exists exist VBZ 42759 799 5 ; ; : 42759 799 6 and and CC 42759 799 7 there there EX 42759 799 8 are be VBP 42759 799 9 many many JJ 42759 799 10 reasons reason NNS 42759 799 11 why why WRB 42759 799 12 the the DT 42759 799 13 State state NN 42759 799 14 should should MD 42759 799 15 not not RB 42759 799 16 attempt attempt VB 42759 799 17 anything anything NN 42759 799 18 of of IN 42759 799 19 the the DT 42759 799 20 sort sort NN 42759 799 21 . . . 42759 800 1 As as IN 42759 800 2 a a DT 42759 800 3 consequence consequence NN 42759 800 4 of of IN 42759 800 5 these these DT 42759 800 6 facts fact NNS 42759 800 7 , , , 42759 800 8 every every DT 42759 800 9 person person NN 42759 800 10 , , , 42759 800 11 whether whether IN 42759 800 12 an an DT 42759 800 13 actual actual JJ 42759 800 14 owner owner NN 42759 800 15 or or CC 42759 800 16 not not RB 42759 800 17 , , , 42759 800 18 has have VBZ 42759 800 19 a a DT 42759 800 20 natural natural JJ 42759 800 21 right right NN 42759 800 22 to to TO 42759 800 23 acquire acquire VB 42759 800 24 property property NN 42759 800 25 in in IN 42759 800 26 land land NN 42759 800 27 . . . 42759 801 1 This this DT 42759 801 2 right right NN 42759 801 3 is be VBZ 42759 801 4 evidently evidently RB 42759 801 5 a a DT 42759 801 6 necessary necessary JJ 42759 801 7 condition condition NN 42759 801 8 of of IN 42759 801 9 a a DT 42759 801 10 fair fair JJ 42759 801 11 and and CC 42759 801 12 efficient efficient JJ 42759 801 13 system system NN 42759 801 14 of of IN 42759 801 15 private private JJ 42759 801 16 ownership ownership NN 42759 801 17 , , , 42759 801 18 which which WDT 42759 801 19 is be VBZ 42759 801 20 in in IN 42759 801 21 turn turn NN 42759 801 22 a a DT 42759 801 23 necessary necessary JJ 42759 801 24 condition condition NN 42759 801 25 of of IN 42759 801 26 individual individual JJ 42759 801 27 welfare welfare NN 42759 801 28 . . . 42759 802 1 The the DT 42759 802 2 right right NN 42759 802 3 of of IN 42759 802 4 private private JJ 42759 802 5 landownership landownership NN 42759 802 6 is be VBZ 42759 802 7 , , , 42759 802 8 therefore therefore RB 42759 802 9 , , , 42759 802 10 an an DT 42759 802 11 indirect indirect JJ 42759 802 12 right right NN 42759 802 13 ; ; : 42759 802 14 but but CC 42759 802 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 802 16 is be VBZ 42759 802 17 quite quite RB 42759 802 18 as as RB 42759 802 19 valid valid JJ 42759 802 20 and and CC 42759 802 21 quite quite RB 42759 802 22 as as RB 42759 802 23 certain certain JJ 42759 802 24 as as IN 42759 802 25 any any DT 42759 802 26 other other JJ 42759 802 27 natural natural JJ 42759 802 28 right right NN 42759 802 29 . . . 42759 803 1 Now now RB 42759 803 2 this this DT 42759 803 3 right right NN 42759 803 4 is be VBZ 42759 803 5 certainly certainly RB 42759 803 6 valid valid JJ 42759 803 7 as as IN 42759 803 8 against against IN 42759 803 9 complete complete JJ 42759 803 10 Socialism socialism NN 42759 803 11 , , , 42759 803 12 which which WDT 42759 803 13 includes include VBZ 42759 803 14 State state NN 42759 803 15 management management NN 42759 803 16 and and CC 42759 803 17 use use NN 42759 803 18 , , , 42759 803 19 as as RB 42759 803 20 well well RB 42759 803 21 as as IN 42759 803 22 State state NN 42759 803 23 ownership ownership NN 42759 803 24 . . . 42759 804 1 Is be VBZ 42759 804 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 804 3 valid valid JJ 42759 804 4 against against IN 42759 804 5 the the DT 42759 804 6 Single Single NNP 42759 804 7 Tax Tax NNP 42759 804 8 system system NN 42759 804 9 , , , 42759 804 10 or or CC 42759 804 11 against against IN 42759 804 12 such such JJ 42759 804 13 modified modify VBN 42759 804 14 forms form NNS 42759 804 15 of of IN 42759 804 16 Socialism socialism NN 42759 804 17 as as IN 42759 804 18 would would MD 42759 804 19 allow allow VB 42759 804 20 the the DT 42759 804 21 individual individual NN 42759 804 22 to to TO 42759 804 23 rent rent VB 42759 804 24 and and CC 42759 804 25 use use VB 42759 804 26 the the DT 42759 804 27 land land NN 42759 804 28 as as IN 42759 804 29 an an DT 42759 804 30 independent independent JJ 42759 804 31 cultivator cultivator NN 42759 804 32 with with IN 42759 804 33 security security NN 42759 804 34 of of IN 42759 804 35 tenure tenure NN 42759 804 36 ? ? . 42759 805 1 Would Would MD 42759 805 2 the the DT 42759 805 3 introduction introduction NN 42759 805 4 of of IN 42759 805 5 some some DT 42759 805 6 such such JJ 42759 805 7 scheme scheme NN 42759 805 8 in in IN 42759 805 9 a a DT 42759 805 10 country country NN 42759 805 11 in in IN 42759 805 12 which which WDT 42759 805 13 only only RB 42759 805 14 a a DT 42759 805 15 small small JJ 42759 805 16 minority minority NN 42759 805 17 of of IN 42759 805 18 the the DT 42759 805 19 population population NN 42759 805 20 were be VBD 42759 805 21 actual actual JJ 42759 805 22 owners owner NNS 42759 805 23 , , , 42759 805 24 constitute constitute VBP 42759 805 25 a a DT 42759 805 26 violation violation NN 42759 805 27 of of IN 42759 805 28 individual individual JJ 42759 805 29 rights right NNS 42759 805 30 ? ? . 42759 806 1 While while IN 42759 806 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 806 3 can can MD 42759 806 4 not not RB 42759 806 5 with with IN 42759 806 6 any any DT 42759 806 7 feeling feeling NN 42759 806 8 of of IN 42759 806 9 certainty certainty NN 42759 806 10 return return VB 42759 806 11 an an DT 42759 806 12 affirmative affirmative JJ 42759 806 13 answer answer NN 42759 806 14 to to IN 42759 806 15 these these DT 42759 806 16 questions question NNS 42759 806 17 , , , 42759 806 18 we -PRON- PRP 42759 806 19 can can MD 42759 806 20 confidently confidently RB 42759 806 21 affirm affirm VB 42759 806 22 that that DT 42759 806 23 reform reform NN 42759 806 24 within within IN 42759 806 25 the the DT 42759 806 26 lines line NNS 42759 806 27 of of IN 42759 806 28 private private JJ 42759 806 29 ownership ownership NN 42759 806 30 would would MD 42759 806 31 in in IN 42759 806 32 the the DT 42759 806 33 long long JJ 42759 806 34 run run NN 42759 806 35 be be VB 42759 806 36 more more RBR 42759 806 37 effective effective JJ 42759 806 38 , , , 42759 806 39 and and CC 42759 806 40 , , , 42759 806 41 therefore therefore RB 42759 806 42 , , , 42759 806 43 that that IN 42759 806 44 the the DT 42759 806 45 right right NN 42759 806 46 of of IN 42759 806 47 private private JJ 42759 806 48 ownership ownership NN 42759 806 49 is be VBZ 42759 806 50 _ _ NNP 42759 806 51 probably probably RB 42759 806 52 _ _ NNP 42759 806 53 valid valid JJ 42759 806 54 even even RB 42759 806 55 against against IN 42759 806 56 these these DT 42759 806 57 modified modify VBN 42759 806 58 forms form NNS 42759 806 59 of of IN 42759 806 60 common common JJ 42759 806 61 ownership ownership NN 42759 806 62 . . . 42759 807 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 807 2 36 36 CD 42759 807 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 807 4 _ _ NNP 42759 807 5 Excessive Excessive NNP 42759 807 6 Interpretations Interpretations NNPS 42759 807 7 of of IN 42759 807 8 the the DT 42759 807 9 Right Right NNP 42759 807 10 of of IN 42759 807 11 Private Private NNP 42759 807 12 Landownership Landownership NNP 42759 807 13 _ _ IN 42759 807 14 The the DT 42759 807 15 indirect indirect JJ 42759 807 16 character character NN 42759 807 17 of of IN 42759 807 18 the the DT 42759 807 19 right right NN 42759 807 20 of of IN 42759 807 21 private private JJ 42759 807 22 landownership landownership NN 42759 807 23 , , , 42759 807 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 807 25 relativity relativity NN 42759 807 26 to to IN 42759 807 27 and and CC 42759 807 28 dependence dependence NN 42759 807 29 upon upon IN 42759 807 30 social social JJ 42759 807 31 conditions condition NNS 42759 807 32 , , , 42759 807 33 is be VBZ 42759 807 34 not not RB 42759 807 35 always always RB 42759 807 36 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 807 37 grasped grasp VBN 42759 807 38 by by IN 42759 807 39 either either CC 42759 807 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 807 41 advocates advocate NNS 42759 807 42 or or CC 42759 807 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 807 44 opponents opponent NNS 42759 807 45 . . . 42759 808 1 In in IN 42759 808 2 the the DT 42759 808 3 writings writing NNS 42759 808 4 of of IN 42759 808 5 the the DT 42759 808 6 former former JJ 42759 808 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 808 8 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 808 9 find find VBP 42759 808 10 language language NN 42759 808 11 which which WDT 42759 808 12 suggests suggest VBZ 42759 808 13 that that IN 42759 808 14 this this DT 42759 808 15 right right NN 42759 808 16 is be VBZ 42759 808 17 as as RB 42759 808 18 independent independent JJ 42759 808 19 of of IN 42759 808 20 social social JJ 42759 808 21 conditions condition NNS 42759 808 22 as as IN 42759 808 23 the the DT 42759 808 24 right right NN 42759 808 25 to to TO 42759 808 26 marriage marriage VB 42759 808 27 or or CC 42759 808 28 the the DT 42759 808 29 right right NN 42759 808 30 to to IN 42759 808 31 life life NN 42759 808 32 . . . 42759 809 1 " " `` 42759 809 2 The the DT 42759 809 3 State State NNP 42759 809 4 has have VBZ 42759 809 5 no no DT 42759 809 6 right right NN 42759 809 7 to to TO 42759 809 8 abolish abolish VB 42759 809 9 private private JJ 42759 809 10 property property NN 42759 809 11 [ [ -LRB- 42759 809 12 in in IN 42759 809 13 land land NN 42759 809 14 ] ] -RRB- 42759 809 15 because because IN 42759 809 16 private private JJ 42759 809 17 property property NN 42759 809 18 is be VBZ 42759 809 19 not not RB 42759 809 20 a a DT 42759 809 21 social social JJ 42759 809 22 right right NN 42759 809 23 , , , 42759 809 24 but but CC 42759 809 25 an an DT 42759 809 26 individual individual JJ 42759 809 27 right right NN 42759 809 28 derived derive VBN 42759 809 29 from from IN 42759 809 30 nature nature NN 42759 809 31 , , , 42759 809 32 not not RB 42759 809 33 derived derive VBN 42759 809 34 from from IN 42759 809 35 the the DT 42759 809 36 State State NNP 42759 809 37 . . . 42759 809 38 " " '' 42759 810 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 810 2 exists exist VBZ 42759 810 3 for for IN 42759 810 4 _ _ NNP 42759 810 5 human human NNP 42759 810 6 _ _ NNP 42759 810 7 welfare welfare NN 42759 810 8 , , , 42759 810 9 not not RB 42759 810 10 merely merely RB 42759 810 11 for for IN 42759 810 12 _ _ NNP 42759 810 13 civil civil JJ 42759 810 14 _ _ NNP 42759 810 15 welfare welfare NN 42759 810 16 . . . 42759 811 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 811 2 37 37 CD 42759 811 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 811 4 The the DT 42759 811 5 only only JJ 42759 811 6 defect defect NN 42759 811 7 in in IN 42759 811 8 this this DT 42759 811 9 reasoning reasoning NN 42759 811 10 is be VBZ 42759 811 11 that that IN 42759 811 12 the the DT 42759 811 13 premises premise NNS 42759 811 14 do do VBP 42759 811 15 not not RB 42759 811 16 justify justify VB 42759 811 17 the the DT 42759 811 18 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 811 19 . . . 42759 812 1 Undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 812 2 the the DT 42759 812 3 State state NN 42759 812 4 may may MD 42759 812 5 not not RB 42759 812 6 abolish abolish VB 42759 812 7 private private JJ 42759 812 8 ownership ownership NN 42759 812 9 , , , 42759 812 10 _ _ NNP 42759 812 11 so so RB 42759 812 12 long long RB 42759 812 13 as as IN 42759 812 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 812 15 is be VBZ 42759 812 16 necessary necessary JJ 42759 812 17 for for IN 42759 812 18 human human JJ 42759 812 19 or or CC 42759 812 20 individual individual JJ 42759 812 21 welfare welfare NN 42759 812 22 _ _ NNP 42759 812 23 ; ; : 42759 812 24 but but CC 42759 812 25 , , , 42759 812 26 when when WRB 42759 812 27 this this DT 42759 812 28 necessity necessity NN 42759 812 29 ceases cease VBZ 42759 812 30 , , , 42759 812 31 the the DT 42759 812 32 moral moral JJ 42759 812 33 justification justification NN 42759 812 34 of of IN 42759 812 35 the the DT 42759 812 36 institution institution NN 42759 812 37 likewise likewise RB 42759 812 38 disappears disappear VBZ 42759 812 39 . . . 42759 813 1 The the DT 42759 813 2 institution institution NN 42759 813 3 may may MD 42759 813 4 then then RB 42759 813 5 be be VB 42759 813 6 abolished abolish VBN 42759 813 7 , , , 42759 813 8 somehow somehow RB 42759 813 9 , , , 42759 813 10 by by IN 42759 813 11 some some DT 42759 813 12 agency agency NN 42759 813 13 , , , 42759 813 14 without without IN 42759 813 15 any any DT 42759 813 16 violation violation NN 42759 813 17 of of IN 42759 813 18 individual individual JJ 42759 813 19 rights right NNS 42759 813 20 . . . 42759 814 1 Why why WRB 42759 814 2 may may MD 42759 814 3 not not RB 42759 814 4 the the DT 42759 814 5 task task NN 42759 814 6 of of IN 42759 814 7 abolition abolition NN 42759 814 8 be be VB 42759 814 9 performed perform VBN 42759 814 10 by by IN 42759 814 11 the the DT 42759 814 12 State State NNP 42759 814 13 ? ? . 42759 815 1 No no DT 42759 815 2 other other JJ 42759 815 3 agency agency NN 42759 815 4 is be VBZ 42759 815 5 available available JJ 42759 815 6 . . . 42759 816 1 The the DT 42759 816 2 assertion assertion NN 42759 816 3 that that IN 42759 816 4 the the DT 42759 816 5 State State NNP 42759 816 6 is be VBZ 42759 816 7 incompetent incompetent JJ 42759 816 8 to to TO 42759 816 9 decide decide VB 42759 816 10 whether whether IN 42759 816 11 the the DT 42759 816 12 institution institution NN 42759 816 13 of of IN 42759 816 14 private private JJ 42759 816 15 ownership ownership NN 42759 816 16 has have VBZ 42759 816 17 outlived outlive VBN 42759 816 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 816 19 usefulness usefulness NN 42759 816 20 , , , 42759 816 21 is be VBZ 42759 816 22 entirely entirely RB 42759 816 23 gratuitous gratuitous JJ 42759 816 24 ; ; : 42759 816 25 besides besides RB 42759 816 26 , , , 42759 816 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 816 28 implies imply VBZ 42759 816 29 that that IN 42759 816 30 a a DT 42759 816 31 small small JJ 42759 816 32 minority minority NN 42759 816 33 of of IN 42759 816 34 selfishly selfishly RB 42759 816 35 interested interested JJ 42759 816 36 persons person NNS 42759 816 37 may may MD 42759 816 38 justly justly RB 42759 816 39 require require VB 42759 816 40 the the DT 42759 816 41 continuation continuation NN 42759 816 42 of of IN 42759 816 43 a a DT 42759 816 44 system system NN 42759 816 45 of of IN 42759 816 46 land land NN 42759 816 47 tenure tenure NN 42759 816 48 which which WDT 42759 816 49 has have VBZ 42759 816 50 become become VBN 42759 816 51 harmful harmful JJ 42759 816 52 to to IN 42759 816 53 the the DT 42759 816 54 overwhelming overwhelming JJ 42759 816 55 majority majority NN 42759 816 56 of of IN 42759 816 57 the the DT 42759 816 58 community community NN 42759 816 59 . . . 42759 817 1 Extreme extreme JJ 42759 817 2 defences defence NNS 42759 817 3 of of IN 42759 817 4 the the DT 42759 817 5 right right NN 42759 817 6 of of IN 42759 817 7 private private JJ 42759 817 8 landownership landownership NN 42759 817 9 are be VBP 42759 817 10 largely largely RB 42759 817 11 responsible responsible JJ 42759 817 12 for for IN 42759 817 13 the the DT 42759 817 14 misconceptions misconception NNS 42759 817 15 of of IN 42759 817 16 many many JJ 42759 817 17 of of IN 42759 817 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 817 19 opponents opponent NNS 42759 817 20 . . . 42759 818 1 Occasionally occasionally RB 42759 818 2 the the DT 42759 818 3 latter latter JJ 42759 818 4 represent represent NN 42759 818 5 this this DT 42759 818 6 right right NN 42759 818 7 as as IN 42759 818 8 an an DT 42759 818 9 _ _ NNP 42759 818 10 a a DT 42759 818 11 priori priori FW 42759 818 12 _ _ NNP 42759 818 13 monstrosity monstrosity NN 42759 818 14 which which WDT 42759 818 15 is be VBZ 42759 818 16 serenely serenely RB 42759 818 17 independent independent JJ 42759 818 18 of of IN 42759 818 19 the the DT 42759 818 20 facts fact NNS 42759 818 21 of of IN 42759 818 22 life life NN 42759 818 23 and and CC 42759 818 24 industry industry NN 42759 818 25 . . . 42759 819 1 While while IN 42759 819 2 such such JJ 42759 819 3 persons person NNS 42759 819 4 are be VBP 42759 819 5 at at IN 42759 819 6 liberty liberty NN 42759 819 7 to to TO 42759 819 8 reject reject VB 42759 819 9 the the DT 42759 819 10 interpretations interpretation NNS 42759 819 11 of of IN 42759 819 12 facts fact NNS 42759 819 13 contained contain VBN 42759 819 14 in in IN 42759 819 15 the the DT 42759 819 16 preceding precede VBG 42759 819 17 paragraphs paragraph NNS 42759 819 18 , , , 42759 819 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 819 20 can can MD 42759 819 21 not not RB 42759 819 22 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 819 23 deny deny VB 42759 819 24 the the DT 42759 819 25 logic logic NN 42759 819 26 of of IN 42759 819 27 the the DT 42759 819 28 process process NN 42759 819 29 which which WDT 42759 819 30 has have VBZ 42759 819 31 led lead VBN 42759 819 32 to to IN 42759 819 33 the the DT 42759 819 34 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 819 35 that that IN 42759 819 36 the the DT 42759 819 37 individual individual NN 42759 819 38 has have VBZ 42759 819 39 a a DT 42759 819 40 natural natural JJ 42759 819 41 right right NN 42759 819 42 to to TO 42759 819 43 own own JJ 42759 819 44 land land NN 42759 819 45 . . . 42759 820 1 So so RB 42759 820 2 much much JJ 42759 820 3 for for IN 42759 820 4 the the DT 42759 820 5 natural natural JJ 42759 820 6 right right NN 42759 820 7 of of IN 42759 820 8 landownership landownership NN 42759 820 9 as as IN 42759 820 10 seen see VBN 42759 820 11 in in IN 42759 820 12 the the DT 42759 820 13 light light NN 42759 820 14 of of IN 42759 820 15 reason reason NN 42759 820 16 . . . 42759 821 1 Let let VB 42759 821 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 821 3 now now RB 42759 821 4 consider consider VB 42759 821 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 821 6 briefly briefly RB 42759 821 7 from from IN 42759 821 8 the the DT 42759 821 9 side side NN 42759 821 10 of of IN 42759 821 11 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 42759 821 12 authority authority NN 42759 821 13 , , , 42759 821 14 namely namely RB 42759 821 15 , , , 42759 821 16 the the DT 42759 821 17 writings writing NNS 42759 821 18 of of IN 42759 821 19 the the DT 42759 821 20 Fathers Fathers NNPS 42759 821 21 and and CC 42759 821 22 Theologians Theologians NNPS 42759 821 23 of of IN 42759 821 24 the the DT 42759 821 25 Church Church NNP 42759 821 26 , , , 42759 821 27 and and CC 42759 821 28 the the DT 42759 821 29 formal formal JJ 42759 821 30 pronouncements pronouncement NNS 42759 821 31 of of IN 42759 821 32 the the DT 42759 821 33 Popes Popes NNPS 42759 821 34 . . . 42759 822 1 _ _ NNP 42759 822 2 The the DT 42759 822 3 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 42759 822 4 of of IN 42759 822 5 the the DT 42759 822 6 Fathers father NNS 42759 822 7 and and CC 42759 822 8 Theologians Theologians NNPS 42759 822 9 _ _ NNP 42759 822 10 Some some DT 42759 822 11 of of IN 42759 822 12 the the DT 42759 822 13 Church Church NNP 42759 822 14 Fathers father NNS 42759 822 15 , , , 42759 822 16 particularly particularly RB 42759 822 17 Augustine Augustine NNP 42759 822 18 , , , 42759 822 19 Ambrose Ambrose NNP 42759 822 20 , , , 42759 822 21 Basil Basil NNP 42759 822 22 , , , 42759 822 23 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 42759 822 24 , , , 42759 822 25 and and CC 42759 822 26 Jerome Jerome NNP 42759 822 27 , , , 42759 822 28 denounced denounce VBD 42759 822 29 riches rich NNS 42759 822 30 and and CC 42759 822 31 the the DT 42759 822 32 rich rich JJ 42759 822 33 so so RB 42759 822 34 severely severely RB 42759 822 35 that that IN 42759 822 36 they -PRON- PRP 42759 822 37 have have VBP 42759 822 38 been be VBN 42759 822 39 accused accuse VBN 42759 822 40 of of IN 42759 822 41 denying deny VBG 42759 822 42 the the DT 42759 822 43 right right NN 42759 822 44 of of IN 42759 822 45 private private JJ 42759 822 46 ownership ownership NN 42759 822 47 . . . 42759 823 1 The the DT 42759 823 2 facts fact NNS 42759 823 3 , , , 42759 823 4 however however RB 42759 823 5 , , , 42759 823 6 are be VBP 42759 823 7 that that IN 42759 823 8 none none NN 42759 823 9 of of IN 42759 823 10 the the DT 42759 823 11 passages passage NNS 42759 823 12 upon upon IN 42759 823 13 which which WDT 42759 823 14 this this DT 42759 823 15 accusation accusation NN 42759 823 16 is be VBZ 42759 823 17 based base VBN 42759 823 18 proves prove VBZ 42759 823 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 823 20 to to TO 42759 823 21 be be VB 42759 823 22 true true JJ 42759 823 23 , , , 42759 823 24 and and CC 42759 823 25 that that IN 42759 823 26 in in IN 42759 823 27 numerous numerous JJ 42759 823 28 other other JJ 42759 823 29 passages passage NNS 42759 823 30 all all DT 42759 823 31 of of IN 42759 823 32 these these DT 42759 823 33 writers writer NNS 42759 823 34 explicitly explicitly RB 42759 823 35 affirm affirm VBP 42759 823 36 that that IN 42759 823 37 private private JJ 42759 823 38 ownership ownership NN 42759 823 39 is be VBZ 42759 823 40 lawful lawful JJ 42759 823 41 . . . 42759 824 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 824 2 38 38 CD 42759 824 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 824 4 Speaking speak VBG 42759 824 5 generally generally RB 42759 824 6 , , , 42759 824 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 824 8 may may MD 42759 824 9 say say VB 42759 824 10 that that IN 42759 824 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 824 12 taught teach VBD 42759 824 13 the the DT 42759 824 14 moral moral JJ 42759 824 15 goodness goodness NN 42759 824 16 of of IN 42759 824 17 private private JJ 42759 824 18 ownership ownership NN 42759 824 19 without without IN 42759 824 20 insisting insist VBG 42759 824 21 upon upon IN 42759 824 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 824 23 necessity necessity NN 42759 824 24 . . . 42759 825 1 Hence hence RB 42759 825 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 825 3 can can MD 42759 825 4 not not RB 42759 825 5 be be VB 42759 825 6 cited cite VBN 42759 825 7 as as IN 42759 825 8 authorities authority NNS 42759 825 9 for for IN 42759 825 10 the the DT 42759 825 11 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 825 12 that that IN 42759 825 13 the the DT 42759 825 14 individual individual NN 42759 825 15 has have VBZ 42759 825 16 a a DT 42759 825 17 natural natural JJ 42759 825 18 right right NN 42759 825 19 to to TO 42759 825 20 own own JJ 42759 825 21 land land NN 42759 825 22 . . . 42759 826 1 Some some DT 42759 826 2 of of IN 42759 826 3 the the DT 42759 826 4 great great JJ 42759 826 5 theologians theologian NNS 42759 826 6 of of IN 42759 826 7 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 826 8 and and CC 42759 826 9 post post JJ 42759 826 10 - - JJ 42759 826 11 mediæval mediæval JJ 42759 826 12 times time NNS 42759 826 13 denied deny VBD 42759 826 14 this this DT 42759 826 15 right right NN 42759 826 16 , , , 42759 826 17 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 826 18 as as IN 42759 826 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 826 20 denied deny VBD 42759 826 21 that that IN 42759 826 22 the the DT 42759 826 23 institution institution NN 42759 826 24 of of IN 42759 826 25 private private JJ 42759 826 26 ownership ownership NN 42759 826 27 was be VBD 42759 826 28 imposed impose VBN 42759 826 29 or or CC 42759 826 30 commanded command VBN 42759 826 31 by by IN 42759 826 32 the the DT 42759 826 33 natural natural JJ 42759 826 34 law law NN 42759 826 35 . . . 42759 827 1 Among among IN 42759 827 2 them -PRON- PRP 42759 827 3 are be VBP 42759 827 4 Scotus,[39 Scotus,[39 . 42759 827 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 827 6 Molina,[40 Molina,[40 NNP 42759 827 7 ] ] -RRB- 42759 827 8 Lessius,[41 lessius,[41 NN 42759 827 9 ] ] -RRB- 42759 827 10 Suarez,[42 suarez,[42 NN 42759 827 11 ] ] -RRB- 42759 827 12 Vasquez,[43 Vasquez,[43 NNP 42759 827 13 ] ] -RRB- 42759 827 14 and and CC 42759 827 15 Billuart Billuart NNP 42759 827 16 . . . 42759 828 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 828 2 44 44 CD 42759 828 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 828 4 Since since IN 42759 828 5 private private JJ 42759 828 6 ownership ownership NN 42759 828 7 is be VBZ 42759 828 8 not not RB 42759 828 9 absolutely absolutely RB 42759 828 10 necessary necessary JJ 42759 828 11 to to IN 42759 828 12 human human JJ 42759 828 13 welfare welfare NN 42759 828 14 in in IN 42759 828 15 all all DT 42759 828 16 forms form NNS 42759 828 17 of of IN 42759 828 18 society society NN 42759 828 19 , , , 42759 828 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 828 21 can can MD 42759 828 22 not not RB 42759 828 23 , , , 42759 828 24 in in IN 42759 828 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 828 26 view view NN 42759 828 27 , , , 42759 828 28 be be VB 42759 828 29 regarded regard VBN 42759 828 30 as as IN 42759 828 31 strictly strictly RB 42759 828 32 prescribed prescribe VBN 42759 828 33 by by IN 42759 828 34 the the DT 42759 828 35 natural natural JJ 42759 828 36 law law NN 42759 828 37 , , , 42759 828 38 nor nor CC 42759 828 39 be be VB 42759 828 40 instituted institute VBN 42759 828 41 without without IN 42759 828 42 the the DT 42759 828 43 positive positive JJ 42759 828 44 action action NN 42759 828 45 of of IN 42759 828 46 civil civil JJ 42759 828 47 authority authority NN 42759 828 48 , , , 42759 828 49 or or CC 42759 828 50 the the DT 42759 828 51 consent consent NN 42759 828 52 of of IN 42759 828 53 the the DT 42759 828 54 community community NN 42759 828 55 . . . 42759 829 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 829 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 829 3 all all DT 42759 829 4 admit admit VBP 42759 829 5 that that IN 42759 829 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 829 7 is be VBZ 42759 829 8 much much RB 42759 829 9 better well JJR 42759 829 10 than than IN 42759 829 11 common common JJ 42759 829 12 ownership ownership NN 42759 829 13 in in IN 42759 829 14 contemporary contemporary JJ 42759 829 15 societies society NNS 42759 829 16 . . . 42759 830 1 The the DT 42759 830 2 difference difference NN 42759 830 3 between between IN 42759 830 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 830 5 position position NN 42759 830 6 and and CC 42759 830 7 that that DT 42759 830 8 of of IN 42759 830 9 de de NNP 42759 830 10 Lugo Lugo NNP 42759 830 11 , , , 42759 830 12 for for IN 42759 830 13 example example NN 42759 830 14 , , , 42759 830 15 seems seem VBZ 42759 830 16 to to TO 42759 830 17 be be VB 42759 830 18 two two CD 42759 830 19 - - HYPH 42759 830 20 fold fold RB 42759 830 21 : : : 42759 830 22 First first RB 42759 830 23 , , , 42759 830 24 they -PRON- PRP 42759 830 25 put put VBP 42759 830 26 stronger strong JJR 42759 830 27 emphasis emphasis NN 42759 830 28 upon upon IN 42759 830 29 the the DT 42759 830 30 doctrines doctrine NNS 42759 830 31 that that WDT 42759 830 32 the the DT 42759 830 33 earth earth NN 42759 830 34 belongs belong VBZ 42759 830 35 to to IN 42759 830 36 all all DT 42759 830 37 men man NNS 42759 830 38 in in IN 42759 830 39 common common JJ 42759 830 40 , , , 42759 830 41 that that IN 42759 830 42 in in IN 42759 830 43 the the DT 42759 830 44 absence absence NN 42759 830 45 of of IN 42759 830 46 original original JJ 42759 830 47 sin sin NN 42759 830 48 ownership ownership NN 42759 830 49 would would MD 42759 830 50 likewise likewise RB 42759 830 51 have have VB 42759 830 52 been be VBN 42759 830 53 common common JJ 42759 830 54 , , , 42759 830 55 and and CC 42759 830 56 that that IN 42759 830 57 this this DT 42759 830 58 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 830 59 is be VBZ 42759 830 60 therefore therefore RB 42759 830 61 in in IN 42759 830 62 a a DT 42759 830 63 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 830 64 sense sense NN 42759 830 65 normal normal JJ 42759 830 66 , , , 42759 830 67 agreeing agree VBG 42759 830 68 with with IN 42759 830 69 nature nature NN 42759 830 70 and and CC 42759 830 71 the the DT 42759 830 72 natural natural JJ 42759 830 73 law law NN 42759 830 74 ; ; : 42759 830 75 and and CC 42759 830 76 , , , 42759 830 77 second second JJ 42759 830 78 , , , 42759 830 79 they -PRON- PRP 42759 830 80 put put VBD 42759 830 81 a a DT 42759 830 82 lower low JJR 42759 830 83 estimate estimate NN 42759 830 84 upon upon IN 42759 830 85 the the DT 42759 830 86 superiority superiority NN 42759 830 87 of of IN 42759 830 88 private private JJ 42759 830 89 ownership ownership NN 42759 830 90 even even RB 42759 830 91 in in IN 42759 830 92 contemporary contemporary JJ 42759 830 93 conditions condition NNS 42759 830 94 . . . 42759 831 1 In in IN 42759 831 2 a a DT 42759 831 3 word word NN 42759 831 4 , , , 42759 831 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 831 6 denied deny VBD 42759 831 7 that that IN 42759 831 8 private private JJ 42759 831 9 ownership ownership NN 42759 831 10 was be VBD 42759 831 11 so so RB 42759 831 12 much much RB 42759 831 13 better well JJR 42759 831 14 than than IN 42759 831 15 any any DT 42759 831 16 alternative alternative JJ 42759 831 17 system system NN 42759 831 18 as as IN 42759 831 19 to to TO 42759 831 20 confer confer VB 42759 831 21 upon upon IN 42759 831 22 the the DT 42759 831 23 individual individual NN 42759 831 24 a a DT 42759 831 25 natural natural JJ 42759 831 26 right right NN 42759 831 27 in in IN 42759 831 28 the the DT 42759 831 29 strict strict JJ 42759 831 30 sense sense NN 42759 831 31 ; ; : 42759 831 32 that that RB 42759 831 33 is is RB 42759 831 34 , , , 42759 831 35 a a DT 42759 831 36 right right NN 42759 831 37 which which WDT 42759 831 38 laid lay VBD 42759 831 39 upon upon IN 42759 831 40 the the DT 42759 831 41 State State NNP 42759 831 42 the the DT 42759 831 43 correlative correlative JJ 42759 831 44 obligation obligation NN 42759 831 45 of of IN 42759 831 46 maintaining maintain VBG 42759 831 47 the the DT 42759 831 48 institution institution NN 42759 831 49 of of IN 42759 831 50 private private JJ 42759 831 51 landownership landownership NN 42759 831 52 . . . 42759 832 1 On on IN 42759 832 2 the the DT 42759 832 3 other other JJ 42759 832 4 hand hand NN 42759 832 5 , , , 42759 832 6 many many JJ 42759 832 7 of of IN 42759 832 8 the the DT 42759 832 9 ablest able JJS 42759 832 10 theologians theologian NNS 42759 832 11 of of IN 42759 832 12 the the DT 42759 832 13 same same JJ 42759 832 14 period period NN 42759 832 15 declared declare VBD 42759 832 16 that that IN 42759 832 17 private private JJ 42759 832 18 ownership ownership NN 42759 832 19 was be VBD 42759 832 20 enjoined enjoin VBN 42759 832 21 by by IN 42759 832 22 the the DT 42759 832 23 natural natural JJ 42759 832 24 law law NN 42759 832 25 and and CC 42759 832 26 right right JJ 42759 832 27 reason reason NN 42759 832 28 , , , 42759 832 29 and and CC 42759 832 30 consequently consequently RB 42759 832 31 that that IN 42759 832 32 it -PRON- PRP 42759 832 33 was be VBD 42759 832 34 among among IN 42759 832 35 the the DT 42759 832 36 individual individual NN 42759 832 37 's 's POS 42759 832 38 natural natural JJ 42759 832 39 rights right NNS 42759 832 40 . . . 42759 833 1 According accord VBG 42759 833 2 to to IN 42759 833 3 St. St. NNP 42759 833 4 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 833 5 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 42759 833 6 , , , 42759 833 7 private private JJ 42759 833 8 property property NN 42759 833 9 is be VBZ 42759 833 10 " " `` 42759 833 11 necessary necessary JJ 42759 833 12 for for IN 42759 833 13 human human JJ 42759 833 14 life life NN 42759 833 15 , , , 42759 833 16 " " '' 42759 833 17 and and CC 42759 833 18 is be VBZ 42759 833 19 one one CD 42759 833 20 of of IN 42759 833 21 those those DT 42759 833 22 social social JJ 42759 833 23 institutions institution NNS 42759 833 24 which which WDT 42759 833 25 are be VBP 42759 833 26 prescribed prescribe VBN 42759 833 27 by by IN 42759 833 28 the the DT 42759 833 29 _ _ NNP 42759 833 30 jus jus NNP 42759 833 31 gentium gentium NNP 42759 833 32 _ _ NNP 42759 833 33 ; ; : 42759 833 34 and and CC 42759 833 35 the the DT 42759 833 36 content content NN 42759 833 37 of of IN 42759 833 38 the the DT 42759 833 39 _ _ NNP 42759 833 40 jus jus NNP 42759 833 41 gentium gentium NNP 42759 833 42 _ _ NNP 42759 833 43 is be VBZ 42759 833 44 not not RB 42759 833 45 determined determine VBN 42759 833 46 by by IN 42759 833 47 positive positive JJ 42759 833 48 law law NN 42759 833 49 , , , 42759 833 50 but but CC 42759 833 51 by by IN 42759 833 52 the the DT 42759 833 53 dictates dictate NNS 42759 833 54 of of IN 42759 833 55 " " `` 42759 833 56 natural natural JJ 42759 833 57 reason reason NN 42759 833 58 , , , 42759 833 59 " " '' 42759 833 60 by by IN 42759 833 61 " " `` 42759 833 62 natural natural JJ 42759 833 63 reason reason NN 42759 833 64 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 833 65 . . . 42759 834 1 " " `` 42759 834 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 834 3 45 45 CD 42759 834 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 834 5 These these DT 42759 834 6 statements statement NNS 42759 834 7 seem seem VBP 42759 834 8 to to TO 42759 834 9 convey convey VB 42759 834 10 the the DT 42759 834 11 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 834 12 of of IN 42759 834 13 natural natural JJ 42759 834 14 right right NN 42759 834 15 as as RB 42759 834 16 clearly clearly RB 42759 834 17 as as IN 42759 834 18 could could MD 42759 834 19 be be VB 42759 834 20 expected expect VBN 42759 834 21 in in IN 42759 834 22 the the DT 42759 834 23 absence absence NN 42759 834 24 of of IN 42759 834 25 an an DT 42759 834 26 explicit explicit JJ 42759 834 27 declaration declaration NN 42759 834 28 . . . 42759 835 1 Cardinal Cardinal NNP 42759 835 2 de de IN 42759 835 3 Lugo Lugo NNP 42759 835 4 sets set VBZ 42759 835 5 forth forth RB 42759 835 6 the the DT 42759 835 7 same same JJ 42759 835 8 teaching teaching NN 42759 835 9 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 835 10 more more RBR 42759 835 11 compactly compactly RB 42759 835 12 , , , 42759 835 13 but but CC 42759 835 14 in in IN 42759 835 15 substantially substantially RB 42759 835 16 the the DT 42759 835 17 same same JJ 42759 835 18 terms term NNS 42759 835 19 : : : 42759 835 20 " " `` 42759 835 21 Speaking speak VBG 42759 835 22 generally generally RB 42759 835 23 , , , 42759 835 24 a a DT 42759 835 25 division division NN 42759 835 26 of of IN 42759 835 27 goods good NNS 42759 835 28 and and CC 42759 835 29 of of IN 42759 835 30 ownership ownership NN 42759 835 31 - - HYPH 42759 835 32 titles title NNS 42759 835 33 proceeds proceed NNS 42759 835 34 from from IN 42759 835 35 the the DT 42759 835 36 law law NN 42759 835 37 of of IN 42759 835 38 nature nature NN 42759 835 39 , , , 42759 835 40 for for IN 42759 835 41 natural natural JJ 42759 835 42 reason reason NN 42759 835 43 dictates dictate VBZ 42759 835 44 such such JJ 42759 835 45 division division NN 42759 835 46 as as IN 42759 835 47 necessary necessary JJ 42759 835 48 in in IN 42759 835 49 the the DT 42759 835 50 present present JJ 42759 835 51 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 835 52 of of IN 42759 835 53 fallen fall VBN 42759 835 54 nature nature NN 42759 835 55 and and CC 42759 835 56 dense dense JJ 42759 835 57 populations population NNS 42759 835 58 . . . 42759 836 1 " " `` 42759 836 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 836 3 46 46 CD 42759 836 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 836 5 This this DT 42759 836 6 view view NN 42759 836 7 is be VBZ 42759 836 8 to to IN 42759 836 9 - - HYPH 42759 836 10 day day NN 42759 836 11 universally universally RB 42759 836 12 accepted accept VBN 42759 836 13 among among IN 42759 836 14 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 836 15 writers writer NNS 42759 836 16 . . . 42759 837 1 _ _ NNP 42759 837 2 The the DT 42759 837 3 Teaching Teaching NNP 42759 837 4 of of IN 42759 837 5 Pope Pope NNP 42759 837 6 Leo Leo NNP 42759 837 7 XIII XIII NNP 42759 837 8 _ _ NNP 42759 837 9 The the DT 42759 837 10 official official JJ 42759 837 11 teaching teaching NN 42759 837 12 of of IN 42759 837 13 the the DT 42759 837 14 Church Church NNP 42759 837 15 on on IN 42759 837 16 the the DT 42759 837 17 subject subject NN 42759 837 18 is be VBZ 42759 837 19 found find VBN 42759 837 20 in in IN 42759 837 21 the the DT 42759 837 22 Encyclical Encyclical NNP 42759 837 23 , , , 42759 837 24 " " '' 42759 837 25 On on IN 42759 837 26 the the DT 42759 837 27 Condition Condition NNP 42759 837 28 of of IN 42759 837 29 Labour Labour NNP 42759 837 30 , , , 42759 837 31 " " '' 42759 837 32 by by IN 42759 837 33 Pope Pope NNP 42759 837 34 Leo Leo NNP 42759 837 35 XIII XIII NNP 42759 837 36 . . . 42759 838 1 In in IN 42759 838 2 this this DT 42759 838 3 document document NN 42759 838 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 838 5 are be VBP 42759 838 6 told tell VBN 42759 838 7 that that IN 42759 838 8 the the DT 42759 838 9 proposals proposal NNS 42759 838 10 of of IN 42759 838 11 the the DT 42759 838 12 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 838 13 are be VBP 42759 838 14 " " `` 42759 838 15 manifestly manifestly RB 42759 838 16 against against IN 42759 838 17 justice justice NN 42759 838 18 " " '' 42759 838 19 ; ; : 42759 838 20 that that IN 42759 838 21 the the DT 42759 838 22 right right NN 42759 838 23 of of IN 42759 838 24 private private JJ 42759 838 25 property property NN 42759 838 26 in in IN 42759 838 27 land land NN 42759 838 28 is be VBZ 42759 838 29 " " `` 42759 838 30 granted grant VBN 42759 838 31 to to TO 42759 838 32 man man VB 42759 838 33 by by IN 42759 838 34 nature nature NN 42759 838 35 " " '' 42759 838 36 ; ; : 42759 838 37 that that IN 42759 838 38 it -PRON- PRP 42759 838 39 is be VBZ 42759 838 40 derived derive VBN 42759 838 41 " " '' 42759 838 42 from from IN 42759 838 43 nature nature NN 42759 838 44 not not RB 42759 838 45 from from IN 42759 838 46 man man NN 42759 838 47 , , , 42759 838 48 and and CC 42759 838 49 the the DT 42759 838 50 State State NNP 42759 838 51 has have VBZ 42759 838 52 the the DT 42759 838 53 right right NN 42759 838 54 to to TO 42759 838 55 control control VB 42759 838 56 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 838 57 use use NN 42759 838 58 in in IN 42759 838 59 the the DT 42759 838 60 interest interest NN 42759 838 61 of of IN 42759 838 62 the the DT 42759 838 63 public public JJ 42759 838 64 good good NN 42759 838 65 alone alone RB 42759 838 66 , , , 42759 838 67 but but CC 42759 838 68 by by IN 42759 838 69 no no DT 42759 838 70 means means NN 42759 838 71 to to TO 42759 838 72 abolish abolish VB 42759 838 73 it -PRON- PRP 42759 838 74 altogether altogether RB 42759 838 75 . . . 42759 838 76 " " '' 42759 839 1 These these DT 42759 839 2 statements statement NNS 42759 839 3 the the DT 42759 839 4 Pope Pope NNP 42759 839 5 deduces deduce VBZ 42759 839 6 from from IN 42759 839 7 a a DT 42759 839 8 consideration consideration NN 42759 839 9 of of IN 42759 839 10 man man NN 42759 839 11 's 's POS 42759 839 12 needs need NNS 42759 839 13 . . . 42759 840 1 Private private JJ 42759 840 2 property property NN 42759 840 3 in in IN 42759 840 4 land land NN 42759 840 5 is be VBZ 42759 840 6 necessary necessary JJ 42759 840 7 to to TO 42759 840 8 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 840 9 the the DT 42759 840 10 wants want NNS 42759 840 11 , , , 42759 840 12 present present JJ 42759 840 13 and and CC 42759 840 14 future future NN 42759 840 15 , , , 42759 840 16 of of IN 42759 840 17 the the DT 42759 840 18 individual individual NN 42759 840 19 and and CC 42759 840 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 840 21 family family NN 42759 840 22 . . . 42759 841 1 Were be VBD 42759 841 2 the the DT 42759 841 3 State State NNP 42759 841 4 to to TO 42759 841 5 attempt attempt VB 42759 841 6 the the DT 42759 841 7 task task NN 42759 841 8 of of IN 42759 841 9 making make VBG 42759 841 10 this this DT 42759 841 11 provision provision NN 42759 841 12 , , , 42759 841 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 841 14 would would MD 42759 841 15 exceed exceed VB 42759 841 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 841 17 proper proper JJ 42759 841 18 sphere sphere NN 42759 841 19 , , , 42759 841 20 and and CC 42759 841 21 produce produce VB 42759 841 22 manifold manifold JJ 42759 841 23 domestic domestic JJ 42759 841 24 and and CC 42759 841 25 social social JJ 42759 841 26 confusion confusion NN 42759 841 27 . . . 42759 842 1 While while IN 42759 842 2 Pope Pope NNP 42759 842 3 Leo Leo NNP 42759 842 4 defines define VBZ 42759 842 5 the the DT 42759 842 6 natural natural JJ 42759 842 7 right right NN 42759 842 8 of of IN 42759 842 9 private private JJ 42759 842 10 ownership ownership NN 42759 842 11 as as IN 42759 842 12 incompatible incompatible JJ 42759 842 13 with with IN 42759 842 14 complete complete JJ 42759 842 15 Socialism socialism NN 42759 842 16 , , , 42759 842 17 that that RB 42759 842 18 is is RB 42759 842 19 , , , 42759 842 20 collective collective JJ 42759 842 21 use use NN 42759 842 22 as as RB 42759 842 23 well well RB 42759 842 24 as as IN 42759 842 25 collective collective JJ 42759 842 26 ownership ownership NN 42759 842 27 , , , 42759 842 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 842 29 statements statement NNS 42759 842 30 can can MD 42759 842 31 not not RB 42759 842 32 fairly fairly RB 42759 842 33 or or CC 42759 842 34 certainly certainly RB 42759 842 35 be be VB 42759 842 36 interpreted interpret VBN 42759 842 37 as as IN 42759 842 38 condemning condemn VBG 42759 842 39 the the DT 42759 842 40 Single Single NNP 42759 842 41 Tax Tax NNP 42759 842 42 system system NN 42759 842 43 , , , 42759 842 44 or or CC 42759 842 45 any any DT 42759 842 46 other other JJ 42759 842 47 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 842 48 which which WDT 42759 842 49 would would MD 42759 842 50 leave leave VB 42759 842 51 to to IN 42759 842 52 the the DT 42759 842 53 individual individual JJ 42759 842 54 managerial managerial JJ 42759 842 55 use use NN 42759 842 56 and and CC 42759 842 57 secure secure JJ 42759 842 58 possession possession NN 42759 842 59 of of IN 42759 842 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 842 61 holding holding NN 42759 842 62 , , , 42759 842 63 together together RB 42759 842 64 with with IN 42759 842 65 the the DT 42759 842 66 power power NN 42759 842 67 to to TO 42759 842 68 transmit transmit VB 42759 842 69 and and CC 42759 842 70 transfer transfer VB 42759 842 71 it -PRON- PRP 42759 842 72 , , , 42759 842 73 and and CC 42759 842 74 full full JJ 42759 842 75 ownership ownership NN 42759 842 76 of of IN 42759 842 77 improvements improvement NNS 42759 842 78 . . . 42759 843 1 These these DT 42759 843 2 are be VBP 42759 843 3 the the DT 42759 843 4 only only JJ 42759 843 5 elements element NNS 42759 843 6 of of IN 42759 843 7 ownership ownership NN 42759 843 8 which which WDT 42759 843 9 the the DT 42759 843 10 Holy Holy NNP 42759 843 11 Father Father NNP 42759 843 12 defends defend VBZ 42759 843 13 , , , 42759 843 14 and and CC 42759 843 15 which which WDT 42759 843 16 he -PRON- PRP 42759 843 17 insists insist VBZ 42759 843 18 upon upon IN 42759 843 19 as as RB 42759 843 20 necessary necessary JJ 42759 843 21 . . . 42759 844 1 The the DT 42759 844 2 one one CD 42759 844 3 element element NN 42759 844 4 of of IN 42759 844 5 private private JJ 42759 844 6 ownership ownership NN 42759 844 7 which which WDT 42759 844 8 the the DT 42759 844 9 Single Single NNP 42759 844 10 Tax Tax NNP 42759 844 11 system system NN 42759 844 12 would would MD 42759 844 13 exclude exclude VB 42759 844 14 ; ; : 42759 844 15 namely namely RB 42759 844 16 , , , 42759 844 17 the the DT 42759 844 18 power power NN 42759 844 19 to to TO 42759 844 20 take take VB 42759 844 21 rent rent NN 42759 844 22 from from IN 42759 844 23 and and CC 42759 844 24 profit profit NN 42759 844 25 by by IN 42759 844 26 the the DT 42759 844 27 changes change NNS 42759 844 28 in in IN 42759 844 29 land land NN 42759 844 30 values value NNS 42759 844 31 , , , 42759 844 32 finds find VBZ 42759 844 33 no no DT 42759 844 34 place place NN 42759 844 35 among among IN 42759 844 36 the the DT 42759 844 37 advantages advantage NNS 42759 844 38 of of IN 42759 844 39 private private JJ 42759 844 40 ownership ownership NN 42759 844 41 enumerated enumerate VBN 42759 844 42 in in IN 42759 844 43 the the DT 42759 844 44 Encyclical Encyclical NNP 42759 844 45 . . . 42759 845 1 There there EX 42759 845 2 is be VBZ 42759 845 3 , , , 42759 845 4 indeed indeed RB 42759 845 5 , , , 42759 845 6 one one CD 42759 845 7 passage passage NN 42759 845 8 of of IN 42759 845 9 the the DT 42759 845 10 Encyclical Encyclical NNP 42759 845 11 in in IN 42759 845 12 which which WDT 42759 845 13 Pope Pope NNP 42759 845 14 Leo Leo NNP 42759 845 15 seems seem VBZ 42759 845 16 to to TO 42759 845 17 allude allude VB 42759 845 18 to to IN 42759 845 19 the the DT 42759 845 20 Single Single NNP 42759 845 21 Tax Tax NNP 42759 845 22 , , , 42759 845 23 or or CC 42759 845 24 to to IN 42759 845 25 some some DT 42759 845 26 similar similar JJ 42759 845 27 proposal proposal NN 42759 845 28 . . . 42759 846 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 846 2 expresses express VBZ 42759 846 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 846 4 amazement amazement NN 42759 846 5 at at IN 42759 846 6 those those DT 42759 846 7 persons person NNS 42759 846 8 who who WP 42759 846 9 " " `` 42759 846 10 assert assert VBP 42759 846 11 that that IN 42759 846 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 846 13 is be VBZ 42759 846 14 right right JJ 42759 846 15 for for IN 42759 846 16 private private JJ 42759 846 17 persons person NNS 42759 846 18 to to TO 42759 846 19 have have VB 42759 846 20 the the DT 42759 846 21 use use NN 42759 846 22 of of IN 42759 846 23 the the DT 42759 846 24 soil soil NN 42759 846 25 and and CC 42759 846 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 846 27 various various JJ 42759 846 28 fruits fruit NNS 42759 846 29 , , , 42759 846 30 but but CC 42759 846 31 that that IN 42759 846 32 it -PRON- PRP 42759 846 33 is be VBZ 42759 846 34 unjust unjust JJ 42759 846 35 for for IN 42759 846 36 any any DT 42759 846 37 one one NN 42759 846 38 to to TO 42759 846 39 possess possess VB 42759 846 40 outright outright RB 42759 846 41 either either CC 42759 846 42 the the DT 42759 846 43 land land NN 42759 846 44 on on IN 42759 846 45 which which WDT 42759 846 46 he -PRON- PRP 42759 846 47 has have VBZ 42759 846 48 built build VBN 42759 846 49 , , , 42759 846 50 or or CC 42759 846 51 the the DT 42759 846 52 estate estate NN 42759 846 53 which which WDT 42759 846 54 he -PRON- PRP 42759 846 55 has have VBZ 42759 846 56 brought bring VBN 42759 846 57 under under IN 42759 846 58 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 846 59 . . . 42759 847 1 But but CC 42759 847 2 those those DT 42759 847 3 who who WP 42759 847 4 deny deny VBP 42759 847 5 these these DT 42759 847 6 rights right NNS 42759 847 7 do do VBP 42759 847 8 not not RB 42759 847 9 perceive perceive VB 42759 847 10 that that IN 42759 847 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 847 12 are be VBP 42759 847 13 defrauding defraud VBG 42759 847 14 man man NN 42759 847 15 of of IN 42759 847 16 what what WP 42759 847 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 847 18 own own JJ 42759 847 19 labour labour NN 42759 847 20 has have VBZ 42759 847 21 produced produce VBN 42759 847 22 . . . 42759 848 1 For for IN 42759 848 2 the the DT 42759 848 3 soil soil NN 42759 848 4 which which WDT 42759 848 5 is be VBZ 42759 848 6 tilled till VBN 42759 848 7 and and CC 42759 848 8 cultivated cultivate VBN 42759 848 9 with with IN 42759 848 10 toil toil NN 42759 848 11 and and CC 42759 848 12 skill skill NN 42759 848 13 utterly utterly RB 42759 848 14 changes change VBZ 42759 848 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 848 16 conditions condition NNS 42759 848 17 : : : 42759 848 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 848 19 was be VBD 42759 848 20 wild wild JJ 42759 848 21 before before RB 42759 848 22 , , , 42759 848 23 now now RB 42759 848 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 848 25 is be VBZ 42759 848 26 fruitful fruitful JJ 42759 848 27 ; ; : 42759 848 28 was be VBD 42759 848 29 barren barren JJ 42759 848 30 , , , 42759 848 31 but but CC 42759 848 32 now now RB 42759 848 33 brings bring VBZ 42759 848 34 forth forth RP 42759 848 35 in in IN 42759 848 36 abundance abundance NN 42759 848 37 . . . 42759 849 1 That that DT 42759 849 2 which which WDT 42759 849 3 has have VBZ 42759 849 4 thus thus RB 42759 849 5 altered alter VBN 42759 849 6 and and CC 42759 849 7 improved improve VBD 42759 849 8 the the DT 42759 849 9 land land NN 42759 849 10 becomes become VBZ 42759 849 11 so so RB 42759 849 12 truly truly RB 42759 849 13 a a DT 42759 849 14 part part NN 42759 849 15 of of IN 42759 849 16 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 849 17 as as IN 42759 849 18 to to TO 42759 849 19 be be VB 42759 849 20 in in IN 42759 849 21 great great JJ 42759 849 22 measure measure NN 42759 849 23 indistinguishable indistinguishable JJ 42759 849 24 and and CC 42759 849 25 inseparable inseparable JJ 42759 849 26 from from IN 42759 849 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 849 28 . . . 42759 850 1 Is be VBZ 42759 850 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 850 3 just just RB 42759 850 4 that that IN 42759 850 5 the the DT 42759 850 6 fruit fruit NN 42759 850 7 of of IN 42759 850 8 a a DT 42759 850 9 man man NN 42759 850 10 's 's POS 42759 850 11 own own JJ 42759 850 12 labour labour NN 42759 850 13 should should MD 42759 850 14 be be VB 42759 850 15 possessed possess VBN 42759 850 16 and and CC 42759 850 17 enjoyed enjoy VBN 42759 850 18 by by IN 42759 850 19 any any DT 42759 850 20 one one NN 42759 850 21 else else RB 42759 850 22 ? ? . 42759 851 1 As as IN 42759 851 2 effects effect NNS 42759 851 3 follow follow VBP 42759 851 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 851 5 cause cause NN 42759 851 6 , , , 42759 851 7 so so RB 42759 851 8 is be VBZ 42759 851 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 851 10 just just RB 42759 851 11 and and CC 42759 851 12 right right RB 42759 851 13 that that IN 42759 851 14 the the DT 42759 851 15 results result NNS 42759 851 16 of of IN 42759 851 17 labour labour NN 42759 851 18 should should MD 42759 851 19 belong belong VB 42759 851 20 to to IN 42759 851 21 those those DT 42759 851 22 who who WP 42759 851 23 have have VBP 42759 851 24 bestowed bestow VBN 42759 851 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 851 26 labour labour NN 42759 851 27 . . . 42759 851 28 " " '' 42759 852 1 In in IN 42759 852 2 this this DT 42759 852 3 passage passage NN 42759 852 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 852 5 find find VBP 42759 852 6 two two CD 42759 852 7 principal principal JJ 42759 852 8 statements statement NNS 42759 852 9 : : : 42759 852 10 first first RB 42759 852 11 , , , 42759 852 12 that that IN 42759 852 13 those those DT 42759 852 14 persons person NNS 42759 852 15 are be VBP 42759 852 16 in in IN 42759 852 17 error error NN 42759 852 18 who who WP 42759 852 19 declare declare VBP 42759 852 20 full full JJ 42759 852 21 private private JJ 42759 852 22 ownership ownership NN 42759 852 23 of of IN 42759 852 24 land land NN 42759 852 25 to to TO 42759 852 26 be be VB 42759 852 27 unjust unjust JJ 42759 852 28 ; ; : 42759 852 29 and and CC 42759 852 30 , , , 42759 852 31 second second RB 42759 852 32 , , , 42759 852 33 that that IN 42759 852 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 852 35 is be VBZ 42759 852 36 wrong wrong JJ 42759 852 37 to to TO 42759 852 38 deprive deprive VB 42759 852 39 a a DT 42759 852 40 man man NN 42759 852 41 of of IN 42759 852 42 the the DT 42759 852 43 improvements improvement NNS 42759 852 44 which which WDT 42759 852 45 he -PRON- PRP 42759 852 46 makes make VBZ 42759 852 47 in in IN 42759 852 48 the the DT 42759 852 49 soil soil NN 42759 852 50 . . . 42759 853 1 Now now RB 42759 853 2 the the DT 42759 853 3 first first JJ 42759 853 4 of of IN 42759 853 5 these these DT 42759 853 6 propositions proposition NNS 42759 853 7 does do VBZ 42759 853 8 not not RB 42759 853 9 touch touch VB 42759 853 10 the the DT 42759 853 11 Single Single NNP 42759 853 12 Tax Tax NNP 42759 853 13 system system NN 42759 853 14 as as IN 42759 853 15 such such JJ 42759 853 16 ; ; : 42759 853 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 853 18 only only RB 42759 853 19 condemns condemn VBZ 42759 853 20 the the DT 42759 853 21 assertion assertion NN 42759 853 22 of of IN 42759 853 23 Henry Henry NNP 42759 853 24 George George NNP 42759 853 25 that that DT 42759 853 26 private private JJ 42759 853 27 ownership ownership NN 42759 853 28 is be VBZ 42759 853 29 essentially essentially RB 42759 853 30 unjust unjust JJ 42759 853 31 . . . 42759 854 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 854 2 is be VBZ 42759 854 3 directed direct VBN 42759 854 4 against against IN 42759 854 5 one one CD 42759 854 6 of of IN 42759 854 7 the the DT 42759 854 8 arguments argument NNS 42759 854 9 for for IN 42759 854 10 the the DT 42759 854 11 system system NN 42759 854 12 , , , 42759 854 13 not not RB 42759 854 14 against against IN 42759 854 15 the the DT 42759 854 16 system system NN 42759 854 17 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 854 18 . . . 42759 855 1 More more RBR 42759 855 2 specifically specifically RB 42759 855 3 , , , 42759 855 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 855 5 is be VBZ 42759 855 6 a a DT 42759 855 7 refutation refutation NN 42759 855 8 of of IN 42759 855 9 an an DT 42759 855 10 argument argument NN 42759 855 11 against against IN 42759 855 12 private private JJ 42759 855 13 land land NN 42759 855 14 ownership ownership NN 42759 855 15 , , , 42759 855 16 rather rather RB 42759 855 17 than than IN 42759 855 18 a a DT 42759 855 19 positive positive JJ 42759 855 20 attack attack NN 42759 855 21 upon upon IN 42759 855 22 any any DT 42759 855 23 other other JJ 42759 855 24 system system NN 42759 855 25 . . . 42759 856 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 856 2 could could MD 42759 856 3 be be VB 42759 856 4 accepted accept VBN 42759 856 5 by by IN 42759 856 6 any any DT 42759 856 7 Single Single NNP 42759 856 8 Taxer Taxer NNP 42759 856 9 who who WP 42759 856 10 does do VBZ 42759 856 11 not not RB 42759 856 12 agree agree VB 42759 856 13 with with IN 42759 856 14 Henry Henry NNP 42759 856 15 George George NNP 42759 856 16 that that IN 42759 856 17 the the DT 42759 856 18 present present JJ 42759 856 19 system system NN 42759 856 20 is be VBZ 42759 856 21 essentially essentially RB 42759 856 22 unjust unjust JJ 42759 856 23 . . . 42759 857 1 The the DT 42759 857 2 second second JJ 42759 857 3 proposition proposition NN 42759 857 4 does do VBZ 42759 857 5 not not RB 42759 857 6 apply apply VB 42759 857 7 to to IN 42759 857 8 the the DT 42759 857 9 Single Single NNP 42759 857 10 Tax Tax NNP 42759 857 11 system system NN 42759 857 12 at at RB 42759 857 13 all all RB 42759 857 14 ; ; : 42759 857 15 for for IN 42759 857 16 the the DT 42759 857 17 latter latter JJ 42759 857 18 would would MD 42759 857 19 concede concede VB 42759 857 20 to to IN 42759 857 21 the the DT 42759 857 22 individual individual JJ 42759 857 23 holder holder NN 42759 857 24 the the DT 42759 857 25 full full JJ 42759 857 26 ownership ownership NN 42759 857 27 and and CC 42759 857 28 benefit benefit NN 42759 857 29 of of IN 42759 857 30 improvements improvement NNS 42759 857 31 ; ; : 42759 857 32 and and CC 42759 857 33 it -PRON- PRP 42759 857 34 could could MD 42759 857 35 easily easily RB 42759 857 36 be be VB 42759 857 37 so so RB 42759 857 38 administered administer VBN 42759 857 39 as as IN 42759 857 40 to to TO 42759 857 41 protect protect VB 42759 857 42 him -PRON- PRP 42759 857 43 against against IN 42759 857 44 injury injury NN 42759 857 45 in in IN 42759 857 46 any any DT 42759 857 47 case case NN 42759 857 48 in in IN 42759 857 49 which which WDT 42759 857 50 improvement improvement NN 42759 857 51 values value NNS 42759 857 52 were be VBD 42759 857 53 not not RB 42759 857 54 exactly exactly RB 42759 857 55 and and CC 42759 857 56 clearly clearly RB 42759 857 57 distinguishable distinguishable JJ 42759 857 58 from from IN 42759 857 59 land land NN 42759 857 60 values value NNS 42759 857 61 . . . 42759 858 1 While while IN 42759 858 2 Henry Henry NNP 42759 858 3 George George NNP 42759 858 4 opposed oppose VBD 42759 858 5 the the DT 42759 858 6 doctrines doctrine NNS 42759 858 7 of of IN 42759 858 8 the the DT 42759 858 9 Encyclical Encyclical NNP 42759 858 10 in in IN 42759 858 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 858 12 " " `` 42759 858 13 Open Open NNP 42759 858 14 Letter letter NN 42759 858 15 to to IN 42759 858 16 Pope Pope NNP 42759 858 17 Leo Leo NNP 42759 858 18 XIII XIII NNP 42759 858 19 , , , 42759 858 20 " " '' 42759 858 21 all all DT 42759 858 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 858 23 arguments argument NNS 42759 858 24 are be VBP 42759 858 25 directed direct VBN 42759 858 26 against against IN 42759 858 27 the the DT 42759 858 28 proposition proposition NN 42759 858 29 that that IN 42759 858 30 private private JJ 42759 858 31 ownership ownership NN 42759 858 32 is be VBZ 42759 858 33 right right JJ 42759 858 34 and and CC 42759 858 35 just just RB 42759 858 36 . . . 42759 859 1 The the DT 42759 859 2 " " `` 42759 859 3 Letter letter NN 42759 859 4 " " '' 42759 859 5 is be VBZ 42759 859 6 an an DT 42759 859 7 attack attack NN 42759 859 8 upon upon IN 42759 859 9 private private JJ 42759 859 10 ownership ownership NN 42759 859 11 rather rather RB 42759 859 12 than than IN 42759 859 13 a a DT 42759 859 14 defence defence NN 42759 859 15 of of IN 42759 859 16 the the DT 42759 859 17 Single Single NNP 42759 859 18 Tax Tax NNP 42759 859 19 . . . 42759 860 1 Apparently apparently RB 42759 860 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 860 3 author author NN 42759 860 4 did do VBD 42759 860 5 not not RB 42759 860 6 find find VB 42759 860 7 that that IN 42759 860 8 Pope Pope NNP 42759 860 9 Leo Leo NNP 42759 860 10 condemned condemn VBD 42759 860 11 any any DT 42759 860 12 positive positive JJ 42759 860 13 or or CC 42759 860 14 essential essential JJ 42759 860 15 element element NN 42759 860 16 of of IN 42759 860 17 the the DT 42759 860 18 Single Single NNP 42759 860 19 Tax Tax NNP 42759 860 20 as as IN 42759 860 21 a a DT 42759 860 22 proposed propose VBN 42759 860 23 system system NN 42759 860 24 of of IN 42759 860 25 land land NN 42759 860 26 tenure tenure NN 42759 860 27 . . . 42759 861 1 If if IN 42759 861 2 the the DT 42759 861 3 rejoinder rejoinder NN 42759 861 4 be be VB 42759 861 5 made make VBN 42759 861 6 that that IN 42759 861 7 Pope Pope NNP 42759 861 8 Leo Leo NNP 42759 861 9 could could MD 42759 861 10 have have VB 42759 861 11 had have VBN 42759 861 12 no no DT 42759 861 13 other other JJ 42759 861 14 group group NN 42759 861 15 of of IN 42759 861 16 persons person NNS 42759 861 17 in in IN 42759 861 18 mind mind NN 42759 861 19 than than IN 42759 861 20 the the DT 42759 861 21 Single Single NNP 42759 861 22 Taxers Taxers NNPS 42759 861 23 , , , 42759 861 24 when when WRB 42759 861 25 he -PRON- PRP 42759 861 26 wrote write VBD 42759 861 27 the the DT 42759 861 28 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 861 29 quoted quote VBN 42759 861 30 above above RB 42759 861 31 , , , 42759 861 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 861 33 answer answer NN 42759 861 34 must must MD 42759 861 35 be be VB 42759 861 36 that that IN 42759 861 37 he -PRON- PRP 42759 861 38 did do VBD 42759 861 39 not not RB 42759 861 40 definitely definitely RB 42759 861 41 identify identify VB 42759 861 42 them -PRON- PRP 42759 861 43 , , , 42759 861 44 either either CC 42759 861 45 by by IN 42759 861 46 naming name VBG 42759 861 47 them -PRON- PRP 42759 861 48 , , , 42759 861 49 as as IN 42759 861 50 he -PRON- PRP 42759 861 51 named name VBD 42759 861 52 the the DT 42759 861 53 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 861 54 , , , 42759 861 55 or or CC 42759 861 56 by by IN 42759 861 57 any any DT 42759 861 58 other other JJ 42759 861 59 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 861 60 explicit explicit JJ 42759 861 61 designation designation NN 42759 861 62 . . . 42759 862 1 Applying apply VBG 42759 862 2 to to IN 42759 862 3 this this DT 42759 862 4 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 862 5 the the DT 42759 862 6 customary customary NN 42759 862 7 and and CC 42759 862 8 recognised recognise VBD 42759 862 9 rules rule NNS 42759 862 10 of of IN 42759 862 11 interpretation interpretation NN 42759 862 12 , , , 42759 862 13 we -PRON- PRP 42759 862 14 are be VBP 42759 862 15 obliged oblige VBN 42759 862 16 to to TO 42759 862 17 conclude conclude VB 42759 862 18 that that IN 42759 862 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 862 20 does do VBZ 42759 862 21 not not RB 42759 862 22 contain contain VB 42759 862 23 an an DT 42759 862 24 explicit explicit JJ 42759 862 25 condemnation condemnation NN 42759 862 26 of of IN 42759 862 27 the the DT 42759 862 28 Single Single NNP 42759 862 29 Tax Tax NNP 42759 862 30 system system NN 42759 862 31 . . . 42759 863 1 To to TO 42759 863 2 put put VB 42759 863 3 the the DT 42759 863 4 substance substance NN 42759 863 5 of of IN 42759 863 6 this this DT 42759 863 7 chapter chapter NN 42759 863 8 in in IN 42759 863 9 two two CD 42759 863 10 sentences sentence NNS 42759 863 11 : : : 42759 863 12 Private private JJ 42759 863 13 landownership landownership NN 42759 863 14 is be VBZ 42759 863 15 a a DT 42759 863 16 natural natural JJ 42759 863 17 right right NN 42759 863 18 because because IN 42759 863 19 in in IN 42759 863 20 present present JJ 42759 863 21 conditions condition NNS 42759 863 22 the the DT 42759 863 23 institution institution NN 42759 863 24 is be VBZ 42759 863 25 necessary necessary JJ 42759 863 26 for for IN 42759 863 27 individual individual JJ 42759 863 28 and and CC 42759 863 29 social social JJ 42759 863 30 welfare welfare NN 42759 863 31 . . . 42759 864 1 The the DT 42759 864 2 right right NN 42759 864 3 is be VBZ 42759 864 4 certainly certainly RB 42759 864 5 valid valid JJ 42759 864 6 as as IN 42759 864 7 against against IN 42759 864 8 complete complete JJ 42759 864 9 Socialism socialism NN 42759 864 10 , , , 42759 864 11 and and CC 42759 864 12 probably probably RB 42759 864 13 valid valid JJ 42759 864 14 as as IN 42759 864 15 against against IN 42759 864 16 any any DT 42759 864 17 such such JJ 42759 864 18 radical radical JJ 42759 864 19 modification modification NN 42759 864 20 of of IN 42759 864 21 the the DT 42759 864 22 present present JJ 42759 864 23 system system NN 42759 864 24 as as IN 42759 864 25 that that WDT 42759 864 26 contemplated contemplate VBD 42759 864 27 by by IN 42759 864 28 the the DT 42759 864 29 thoroughgoing thoroughgoe VBG 42759 864 30 Single Single NNP 42759 864 31 Taxers taxer NNS 42759 864 32 . . . 42759 865 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 865 2 : : : 42759 865 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 865 4 34 34 CD 42759 865 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 865 6 The the DT 42759 865 7 marriage marriage NN 42759 865 8 rights right NNS 42759 865 9 of of IN 42759 865 10 criminals criminal NNS 42759 865 11 , , , 42759 865 12 degenerates degenerate NNS 42759 865 13 , , , 42759 865 14 and and CC 42759 865 15 other other JJ 42759 865 16 socially socially RB 42759 865 17 dangerous dangerous JJ 42759 865 18 persons person NNS 42759 865 19 , , , 42759 865 20 are be VBP 42759 865 21 passed pass VBN 42759 865 22 over over RP 42759 865 23 here here RB 42759 865 24 as as RB 42759 865 25 not not RB 42759 865 26 pertinent pertinent JJ 42759 865 27 to to IN 42759 865 28 the the DT 42759 865 29 present present JJ 42759 865 30 discussion discussion NN 42759 865 31 . . . 42759 866 1 For for IN 42759 866 2 the the DT 42759 866 3 same same JJ 42759 866 4 reason reason NN 42759 866 5 nothing nothing NN 42759 866 6 is be VBZ 42759 866 7 said say VBD 42759 866 8 of of IN 42759 866 9 the the DT 42759 866 10 perfectly perfectly RB 42759 866 11 valid valid JJ 42759 866 12 _ _ NNP 42759 866 13 social social JJ 42759 866 14 _ _ NNP 42759 866 15 argument argument NN 42759 866 16 in in IN 42759 866 17 favour favour NN 42759 866 18 of of IN 42759 866 19 the the DT 42759 866 20 individual individual JJ 42759 866 21 right right NN 42759 866 22 of of IN 42759 866 23 marriage marriage NN 42759 866 24 . . . 42759 867 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 867 2 35 35 CD 42759 867 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 867 4 Cf cf NN 42759 867 5 . . . 42759 868 1 Vermeersch Vermeersch NNP 42759 868 2 , , , 42759 868 3 " " '' 42759 868 4 Quaestiones Quaestiones NNP 42759 868 5 de de NNP 42759 868 6 Justitia Justitia NNP 42759 868 7 , , , 42759 868 8 " " `` 42759 868 9 no no UH 42759 868 10 . . . 42759 869 1 204 204 CD 42759 869 2 . . . 42759 870 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 870 2 36 36 CD 42759 870 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 870 4 The the DT 42759 870 5 argument argument NN 42759 870 6 in in IN 42759 870 7 the the DT 42759 870 8 text text NN 42759 870 9 is be VBZ 42759 870 10 obviously obviously RB 42759 870 11 empirical empirical JJ 42759 870 12 , , , 42759 870 13 drawn draw VBN 42759 870 14 from from IN 42759 870 15 consequences consequence NNS 42759 870 16 . . . 42759 871 1 There there EX 42759 871 2 is be VBZ 42759 871 3 , , , 42759 871 4 however however RB 42759 871 5 , , , 42759 871 6 a a DT 42759 871 7 putatively putatively RB 42759 871 8 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 871 9 or or CC 42759 871 10 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 42759 871 11 argument argument NN 42759 871 12 which which WDT 42759 871 13 is be VBZ 42759 871 14 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 871 15 urged urge VBN 42759 871 16 against against IN 42759 871 17 the the DT 42759 871 18 justice justice NN 42759 871 19 of of IN 42759 871 20 the the DT 42759 871 21 Single Single NNP 42759 871 22 Tax Tax NNP 42759 871 23 system system NN 42759 871 24 . . . 42759 872 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 872 2 runs run VBZ 42759 872 3 thus thus RB 42759 872 4 : : : 42759 872 5 since since IN 42759 872 6 the the DT 42759 872 7 fruits fruit NNS 42759 872 8 of of IN 42759 872 9 a a DT 42759 872 10 thing thing NN 42759 872 11 belong belong VBP 42759 872 12 to to IN 42759 872 13 the the DT 42759 872 14 owner owner NN 42759 872 15 of of IN 42759 872 16 the the DT 42759 872 17 thing thing NN 42759 872 18 , , , 42759 872 19 " " '' 42759 872 20 res re VBZ 42759 872 21 fructificat fructificat NNP 42759 872 22 domino domino NN 42759 872 23 , , , 42759 872 24 " " '' 42759 872 25 rent rent NN 42759 872 26 , , , 42759 872 27 which which WDT 42759 872 28 is be VBZ 42759 872 29 the the DT 42759 872 30 economically economically RB 42759 872 31 imputed impute VBN 42759 872 32 fruit fruit NN 42759 872 33 of of IN 42759 872 34 land land NN 42759 872 35 , , , 42759 872 36 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 872 37 and and CC 42759 872 38 as as IN 42759 872 39 a a DT 42759 872 40 matter matter NN 42759 872 41 of of IN 42759 872 42 natural natural JJ 42759 872 43 right right NN 42759 872 44 should should MD 42759 872 45 go go VB 42759 872 46 to to IN 42759 872 47 the the DT 42759 872 48 owner owner NN 42759 872 49 of of IN 42759 872 50 the the DT 42759 872 51 land land NN 42759 872 52 . . . 42759 873 1 As as IN 42759 873 2 will will MD 42759 873 3 be be VB 42759 873 4 shown show VBN 42759 873 5 later later RB 42759 873 6 , , , 42759 873 7 the the DT 42759 873 8 formula formula NN 42759 873 9 at at IN 42759 873 10 the the DT 42759 873 11 basis basis NN 42759 873 12 of of IN 42759 873 13 this this DT 42759 873 14 contention contention NN 42759 873 15 is be VBZ 42759 873 16 not not RB 42759 873 17 a a DT 42759 873 18 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 42759 873 19 principle principle NN 42759 873 20 at at RB 42759 873 21 all all RB 42759 873 22 , , , 42759 873 23 but but CC 42759 873 24 a a DT 42759 873 25 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 873 26 from from IN 42759 873 27 experience experience NN 42759 873 28 . . . 42759 874 1 Like like IN 42759 874 2 every every DT 42759 874 3 other other JJ 42759 874 4 formula formula NN 42759 874 5 or or CC 42759 874 6 principle principle NN 42759 874 7 of of IN 42759 874 8 property property NN 42759 874 9 rights right NNS 42759 874 10 , , , 42759 874 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 874 12 must must MD 42759 874 13 find find VB 42759 874 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 874 15 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 874 16 basis basis NN 42759 874 17 in in IN 42759 874 18 human human JJ 42759 874 19 welfare welfare NN 42759 874 20 . . . 42759 875 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 875 2 37 37 CD 42759 875 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 875 4 Liberatore Liberatore NNP 42759 875 5 , , , 42759 875 6 " " `` 42759 875 7 Principles principle NNS 42759 875 8 of of IN 42759 875 9 Political Political NNP 42759 875 10 Economy Economy NNP 42759 875 11 , , , 42759 875 12 " " '' 42759 875 13 pp pp NNP 42759 875 14 . . . 42759 876 1 130 130 CD 42759 876 2 , , , 42759 876 3 134 134 CD 42759 876 4 . . . 42759 877 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 877 2 38 38 CD 42759 877 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 877 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 877 5 . . . 42759 878 1 Vermeersch Vermeersch NNP 42759 878 2 , , , 42759 878 3 op op NN 42759 878 4 . . . 42759 879 1 cit cit NNP 42759 879 2 . . . 42759 879 3 , , , 42759 879 4 no no UH 42759 879 5 . . . 42759 880 1 210 210 CD 42759 880 2 ; ; : 42759 880 3 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 880 4 , , , 42759 880 5 " " '' 42759 880 6 Alleged alleged JJ 42759 880 7 Socialism socialism NN 42759 880 8 of of IN 42759 880 9 the the DT 42759 880 10 Church Church NNP 42759 880 11 Fathers Fathers NNPS 42759 880 12 . . . 42759 880 13 " " '' 42759 881 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 881 2 39 39 CD 42759 881 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 881 4 " " `` 42759 881 5 In in IN 42759 881 6 IV IV NNP 42759 881 7 Sent Sent NNP 42759 881 8 . . . 42759 881 9 , , , 42759 881 10 " " '' 42759 881 11 d. d. NNP 42759 881 12 15 15 CD 42759 881 13 , , , 42759 881 14 q. q. NNP 42759 882 1 2 2 CD 42759 882 2 , , , 42759 882 3 n. n. NNP 42759 882 4 5 5 CD 42759 882 5 ; ; : 42759 882 6 and and CC 42759 882 7 " " `` 42759 882 8 Reportata Reportata NNP 42759 882 9 parisiensia parisiensia NNS 42759 882 10 , , , 42759 882 11 " " '' 42759 882 12 d. d. NNP 42759 882 13 15 15 CD 42759 882 14 , , , 42759 882 15 q. q. NNP 42759 883 1 4 4 LS 42759 883 2 , , , 42759 883 3 n. n. NNP 42759 883 4 7 7 CD 42759 883 5 - - SYM 42759 883 6 12 12 CD 42759 883 7 . . . 42759 884 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 884 2 40 40 CD 42759 884 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 884 4 " " `` 42759 884 5 De De NNP 42759 884 6 Justitia Justitia NNP 42759 884 7 et et NNP 42759 884 8 Jure Jure NNP 42759 884 9 , , , 42759 884 10 " " '' 42759 884 11 tr tr JJ 42759 884 12 . . . 42759 885 1 2 2 CD 42759 885 2 , , , 42759 885 3 d. d. NNP 42759 885 4 18 18 CD 42759 885 5 and and CC 42759 885 6 20 20 CD 42759 885 7 . . . 42759 886 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 886 2 41 41 CD 42759 886 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 886 4 " " `` 42759 886 5 De De NNP 42759 886 6 Justitia Justitia NNP 42759 886 7 et et NNP 42759 886 8 Jure Jure NNP 42759 886 9 , , , 42759 886 10 " " '' 42759 886 11 c. c. NNP 42759 886 12 5 5 CD 42759 886 13 , , , 42759 886 14 n. n. NNP 42759 886 15 3 3 CD 42759 886 16 . . . 42759 887 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 887 2 42 42 CD 42759 887 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 887 4 " " `` 42759 887 5 De De NNP 42759 887 6 Legibus Legibus NNP 42759 887 7 , , , 42759 887 8 " " '' 42759 887 9 l. l. NNP 42759 887 10 2 2 CD 42759 887 11 , , , 42759 887 12 c. c. NNP 42759 887 13 14 14 CD 42759 887 14 , , , 42759 887 15 n. n. NNP 42759 887 16 13 13 CD 42759 887 17 and and CC 42759 887 18 16 16 CD 42759 887 19 . . . 42759 888 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 888 2 43 43 CD 42759 888 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 888 4 " " `` 42759 888 5 In in IN 42759 888 6 Summa Summa NNP 42759 888 7 , , , 42759 888 8 " " '' 42759 888 9 1ma 1ma JJ 42759 888 10 2ae 2ae NN 42759 888 11 , , , 42759 888 12 d. d. NNP 42759 888 13 157 157 CD 42759 888 14 , , , 42759 888 15 n. n. NNP 42759 888 16 17 17 CD 42759 888 17 . . . 42759 889 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 889 2 44 44 CD 42759 889 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 889 4 " " `` 42759 889 5 De De NNP 42759 889 6 Justitia Justitia NNP 42759 889 7 et et NNP 42759 889 8 Jure Jure NNP 42759 889 9 , , , 42759 889 10 " " '' 42759 889 11 d. d. NNP 42759 889 12 4 4 CD 42759 889 13 , , , 42759 889 14 a. a. NN 42759 890 1 1 1 LS 42759 890 2 . . . 42759 891 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 891 2 45 45 CD 42759 891 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 891 4 " " `` 42759 891 5 Summa Summa NNP 42759 891 6 Theologica Theologica NNP 42759 891 7 , , , 42759 891 8 " " '' 42759 891 9 2a 2a CD 42759 891 10 2ae 2ae NNP 42759 891 11 , , , 42759 891 12 q. q. NNP 42759 892 1 57 57 CD 42759 892 2 , , , 42759 892 3 a. a. NN 42759 893 1 2 2 CD 42759 893 2 and and CC 42759 893 3 3 3 CD 42759 893 4 . . . 42759 894 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 894 2 46 46 CD 42759 894 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 894 4 " " `` 42759 894 5 De De NNP 42759 894 6 Justitia Justitia NNP 42759 894 7 et et NNP 42759 894 8 Jure Jure NNP 42759 894 9 , , , 42759 894 10 " " '' 42759 894 11 d. d. NNP 42759 894 12 6 6 CD 42759 894 13 , , , 42759 894 14 s. s. NNP 42759 894 15 1 1 CD 42759 894 16 , , , 42759 894 17 n. n. NNP 42759 894 18 6 6 CD 42759 894 19 . . . 42759 895 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 42759 895 2 VI VI NNP 42759 895 3 LIMITATIONS limitation VBZ 42759 895 4 ON on IN 42759 895 5 THE the DT 42759 895 6 LANDOWNER LANDOWNER NNP 42759 895 7 'S 's POS 42759 895 8 RIGHT right NN 42759 895 9 TO to IN 42759 895 10 RENT rent VB 42759 895 11 The the DT 42759 895 12 chapters chapter NNS 42759 895 13 immediately immediately RB 42759 895 14 preceding precede VBG 42759 895 15 have have VBP 42759 895 16 led lead VBN 42759 895 17 to to IN 42759 895 18 the the DT 42759 895 19 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 895 20 that that IN 42759 895 21 private private JJ 42759 895 22 ownership ownership NN 42759 895 23 is be VBZ 42759 895 24 the the DT 42759 895 25 best good JJS 42759 895 26 system system NN 42759 895 27 of of IN 42759 895 28 land land NN 42759 895 29 tenure tenure NN 42759 895 30 , , , 42759 895 31 and and CC 42759 895 32 that that IN 42759 895 33 the the DT 42759 895 34 individual individual NN 42759 895 35 has have VBZ 42759 895 36 a a DT 42759 895 37 natural natural JJ 42759 895 38 right right NN 42759 895 39 to to TO 42759 895 40 participate participate VB 42759 895 41 in in IN 42759 895 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 895 43 advantages advantage NNS 42759 895 44 . . . 42759 896 1 Although although IN 42759 896 2 this this DT 42759 896 3 system system NN 42759 896 4 confers confer VBZ 42759 896 5 upon upon IN 42759 896 6 the the DT 42759 896 7 individual individual JJ 42759 896 8 owner owner NN 42759 896 9 the the DT 42759 896 10 power power NN 42759 896 11 to to TO 42759 896 12 take take VB 42759 896 13 the the DT 42759 896 14 rent rent NN 42759 896 15 of of IN 42759 896 16 the the DT 42759 896 17 land land NN 42759 896 18 , , , 42759 896 19 we -PRON- PRP 42759 896 20 are be VBP 42759 896 21 not not RB 42759 896 22 logically logically RB 42759 896 23 debarred debar VBN 42759 896 24 from from IN 42759 896 25 raising raise VBG 42759 896 26 the the DT 42759 896 27 question question NN 42759 896 28 whether whether IN 42759 896 29 this this DT 42759 896 30 power power NN 42759 896 31 is be VBZ 42759 896 32 a a DT 42759 896 33 necessary necessary JJ 42759 896 34 part part NN 42759 896 35 of of IN 42759 896 36 the the DT 42759 896 37 moral moral JJ 42759 896 38 rights right NNS 42759 896 39 of of IN 42759 896 40 landownership landownership NN 42759 896 41 . . . 42759 897 1 Does do VBZ 42759 897 2 the the DT 42759 897 3 right right NN 42759 897 4 to to TO 42759 897 5 own own VB 42759 897 6 a a DT 42759 897 7 piece piece NN 42759 897 8 of of IN 42759 897 9 land land NN 42759 897 10 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 897 11 include include VBP 42759 897 12 the the DT 42759 897 13 right right NN 42759 897 14 to to TO 42759 897 15 take take VB 42759 897 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 897 17 rent rent NN 42759 897 18 ? ? . 42759 898 1 By by IN 42759 898 2 what what WDT 42759 898 3 ethical ethical JJ 42759 898 4 principle principle NN 42759 898 5 of of IN 42759 898 6 distribution distribution NN 42759 898 7 is be VBZ 42759 898 8 the the DT 42759 898 9 landowner landowner RB 42759 898 10 justified justified JJ 42759 898 11 in in IN 42759 898 12 appropriating appropriate VBG 42759 898 13 a a DT 42759 898 14 revenue revenue NN 42759 898 15 in in IN 42759 898 16 return return NN 42759 898 17 for for IN 42759 898 18 which which WDT 42759 898 19 he -PRON- PRP 42759 898 20 has have VBZ 42759 898 21 performed perform VBN 42759 898 22 no no DT 42759 898 23 labour labour NN 42759 898 24 , , , 42759 898 25 nor nor CC 42759 898 26 made make VBD 42759 898 27 any any DT 42759 898 28 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 898 29 ? ? . 42759 899 1 This this DT 42759 899 2 is be VBZ 42759 899 3 unquestionably unquestionably RB 42759 899 4 what what WP 42759 899 5 happens happen VBZ 42759 899 6 when when WRB 42759 899 7 a a DT 42759 899 8 man man NN 42759 899 9 hires hire VBZ 42759 899 10 out out RP 42759 899 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 899 12 land land NN 42759 899 13 to to IN 42759 899 14 another another DT 42759 899 15 . . . 42759 900 1 And and CC 42759 900 2 in in IN 42759 900 3 conditions condition NNS 42759 900 4 of of IN 42759 900 5 perfect perfect JJ 42759 900 6 competition competition NN 42759 900 7 , , , 42759 900 8 those those DT 42759 900 9 owners owner NNS 42759 900 10 who who WP 42759 900 11 operate operate VBP 42759 900 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 900 13 own own JJ 42759 900 14 land land NN 42759 900 15 are be VBP 42759 900 16 fully fully RB 42759 900 17 remunerated remunerate VBN 42759 900 18 for for IN 42759 900 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 900 20 labour labour NN 42759 900 21 in in IN 42759 900 22 the the DT 42759 900 23 form form NN 42759 900 24 of of IN 42759 900 25 profits profit NNS 42759 900 26 . . . 42759 901 1 Over over IN 42759 901 2 and and CC 42759 901 3 above above IN 42759 901 4 this this DT 42759 901 5 sum sum NN 42759 901 6 they -PRON- PRP 42759 901 7 receive receive VBP 42759 901 8 rent rent NN 42759 901 9 , , , 42759 901 10 the the DT 42759 901 11 payment payment NN 42759 901 12 that that WDT 42759 901 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 901 14 could could MD 42759 901 15 get get VB 42759 901 16 from from IN 42759 901 17 the the DT 42759 901 18 land land NN 42759 901 19 if if IN 42759 901 20 they -PRON- PRP 42759 901 21 were be VBD 42759 901 22 to to TO 42759 901 23 let let VB 42759 901 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 901 25 use use NN 42759 901 26 to to IN 42759 901 27 tenants tenant NNS 42759 901 28 . . . 42759 902 1 In in IN 42759 902 2 the the DT 42759 902 3 normal normal JJ 42759 902 4 situation situation NN 42759 902 5 , , , 42759 902 6 therefore therefore RB 42759 902 7 , , , 42759 902 8 rent rent NN 42759 902 9 is be VBZ 42759 902 10 a a DT 42759 902 11 workless workless NN 42759 902 12 income income NN 42759 902 13 . . . 42759 903 1 On on IN 42759 903 2 what what WDT 42759 903 3 moral moral JJ 42759 903 4 ground ground NN 42759 903 5 may may MD 42759 903 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 903 7 be be VB 42759 903 8 taken take VBN 42759 903 9 by by IN 42759 903 10 the the DT 42759 903 11 landowner landowner NN 42759 903 12 ? ? . 42759 904 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 904 2 47 47 CD 42759 904 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 904 4 The the DT 42759 904 5 fact fact NN 42759 904 6 that that IN 42759 904 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 904 8 have have VBP 42759 904 9 rejected reject VBN 42759 904 10 the the DT 42759 904 11 Single Single NNP 42759 904 12 Tax Tax NNP 42759 904 13 and and CC 42759 904 14 the the DT 42759 904 15 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 904 16 of of IN 42759 904 17 rent rent NN 42759 904 18 by by IN 42759 904 19 the the DT 42759 904 20 community community NN 42759 904 21 , , , 42759 904 22 does do VBZ 42759 904 23 not not RB 42759 904 24 of of IN 42759 904 25 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 904 26 commit commit VB 42759 904 27 us -PRON- PRP 42759 904 28 to to IN 42759 904 29 the the DT 42759 904 30 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 904 31 that that IN 42759 904 32 the the DT 42759 904 33 private private JJ 42759 904 34 owner owner NN 42759 904 35 has have VBZ 42759 904 36 a a DT 42759 904 37 moral moral JJ 42759 904 38 right right NN 42759 904 39 to to TO 42759 904 40 receive receive VB 42759 904 41 rent rent NN 42759 904 42 . . . 42759 905 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 905 2 have have VBP 42759 905 3 condemned condemn VBN 42759 905 4 the the DT 42759 905 5 State State NNP 42759 905 6 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 905 7 of of IN 42759 905 8 rent rent NN 42759 905 9 on on IN 42759 905 10 the the DT 42759 905 11 assumption assumption NN 42759 905 12 that that IN 42759 905 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 905 14 would would MD 42759 905 15 take take VB 42759 905 16 place place NN 42759 905 17 without without IN 42759 905 18 a a DT 42759 905 19 similar similar JJ 42759 905 20 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 905 21 of of IN 42759 905 22 interest interest NN 42759 905 23 . . . 42759 906 1 Such such JJ 42759 906 2 discrimination discrimination NN 42759 906 3 would would MD 42759 906 4 be be VB 42759 906 5 grossly grossly RB 42759 906 6 unfair unfair JJ 42759 906 7 ; ; : 42759 906 8 for for IN 42759 906 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 906 10 would would MD 42759 906 11 cause cause VB 42759 906 12 land land NN 42759 906 13 values value NNS 42759 906 14 to to TO 42759 906 15 sink sink VB 42759 906 16 to to IN 42759 906 17 zero zero CD 42759 906 18 , , , 42759 906 19 while while IN 42759 906 20 leaving leave VBG 42759 906 21 the the DT 42759 906 22 value value NN 42759 906 23 of of IN 42759 906 24 capital capital NN 42759 906 25 substantially substantially RB 42759 906 26 undisturbed undisturbed JJ 42759 906 27 . . . 42759 907 1 To to TO 42759 907 2 carry carry VB 42759 907 3 out out RP 42759 907 4 such such JJ 42759 907 5 a a DT 42759 907 6 programme programme NN 42759 907 7 would would MD 42759 907 8 be be VB 42759 907 9 to to TO 42759 907 10 treat treat VB 42759 907 11 property property NN 42759 907 12 owners owner NNS 42759 907 13 unequally unequally RB 42759 907 14 , , , 42759 907 15 to to TO 42759 907 16 penalise penalise VB 42759 907 17 one one CD 42759 907 18 set set NN 42759 907 19 of of IN 42759 907 20 beneficiaries beneficiary NNS 42759 907 21 of of IN 42759 907 22 " " `` 42759 907 23 workless workless NN 42759 907 24 " " '' 42759 907 25 incomes income NNS 42759 907 26 , , , 42759 907 27 while while IN 42759 907 28 leaving leave VBG 42759 907 29 another another DT 42759 907 30 set set NN 42759 907 31 untouched untouched JJ 42759 907 32 . . . 42759 908 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 908 2 , , , 42759 908 3 the the DT 42759 908 4 State state NN 42759 908 5 is be VBZ 42759 908 6 not not RB 42759 908 7 justified justify VBN 42759 908 8 in in IN 42759 908 9 confiscating confiscate VBG 42759 908 10 rent rent NN 42759 908 11 unless unless IN 42759 908 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 908 13 is be VBZ 42759 908 14 justified justify VBN 42759 908 15 in in IN 42759 908 16 confiscating confiscate VBG 42759 908 17 or or CC 42759 908 18 prohibiting prohibit VBG 42759 908 19 interest interest NN 42759 908 20 ; ; : 42759 908 21 and and CC 42759 908 22 the the DT 42759 908 23 landowner landowner NN 42759 908 24 is be VBZ 42759 908 25 as as RB 42759 908 26 fully fully RB 42759 908 27 justified justify VBN 42759 908 28 in in IN 42759 908 29 taking take VBG 42759 908 30 rent rent NN 42759 908 31 as as IN 42759 908 32 the the DT 42759 908 33 capital capital NN 42759 908 34 owner owner NN 42759 908 35 is be VBZ 42759 908 36 in in IN 42759 908 37 taking take VBG 42759 908 38 interest interest NN 42759 908 39 . . . 42759 909 1 The the DT 42759 909 2 contention contention NN 42759 909 3 of of IN 42759 909 4 the the DT 42759 909 5 Single Single NNP 42759 909 6 Taxer Taxer NNP 42759 909 7 that that WDT 42759 909 8 ownership ownership NN 42759 909 9 of of IN 42759 909 10 the the DT 42759 909 11 former former JJ 42759 909 12 kind kind NN 42759 909 13 is be VBZ 42759 909 14 morally morally RB 42759 909 15 wrong wrong JJ 42759 909 16 , , , 42759 909 17 while while IN 42759 909 18 ownership ownership NN 42759 909 19 of of IN 42759 909 20 capital capital NN 42759 909 21 is be VBZ 42759 909 22 morally morally RB 42759 909 23 legitimate legitimate JJ 42759 909 24 , , , 42759 909 25 has have VBZ 42759 909 26 already already RB 42759 909 27 received receive VBN 42759 909 28 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 909 29 discussion discussion NN 42759 909 30 . . . 42759 910 1 The the DT 42759 910 2 specific specific JJ 42759 910 3 question question NN 42759 910 4 remains remain VBZ 42759 910 5 , , , 42759 910 6 therefore,--whether therefore,--whether , 42759 910 7 the the DT 42759 910 8 landowner landowner NN 42759 910 9 and and CC 42759 910 10 the the DT 42759 910 11 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 910 12 are be VBP 42759 910 13 justified justify VBN 42759 910 14 in in IN 42759 910 15 receiving receive VBG 42759 910 16 and and CC 42759 910 17 retaining retain VBG 42759 910 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 910 19 " " `` 42759 910 20 workless workless NN 42759 910 21 " " '' 42759 910 22 incomes income NNS 42759 910 23 . . . 42759 911 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 911 2 as as IN 42759 911 3 the the DT 42759 911 4 principles principle NNS 42759 911 5 and and CC 42759 911 6 pertinent pertinent JJ 42759 911 7 facts fact NNS 42759 911 8 involved involve VBN 42759 911 9 in in IN 42759 911 10 this this DT 42759 911 11 question question NN 42759 911 12 can can MD 42759 911 13 be be VB 42759 911 14 more more RBR 42759 911 15 effectively effectively RB 42759 911 16 and and CC 42759 911 17 more more RBR 42759 911 18 conveniently conveniently RB 42759 911 19 discussed discuss VBN 42759 911 20 in in IN 42759 911 21 relation relation NN 42759 911 22 to to IN 42759 911 23 interest interest NN 42759 911 24 than than IN 42759 911 25 in in IN 42759 911 26 relation relation NN 42759 911 27 to to TO 42759 911 28 rent rent VB 42759 911 29 , , , 42759 911 30 the the DT 42759 911 31 solution solution NN 42759 911 32 will will MD 42759 911 33 be be VB 42759 911 34 deferred defer VBN 42759 911 35 to to IN 42759 911 36 the the DT 42759 911 37 chapters chapter NNS 42759 911 38 on on IN 42759 911 39 interest interest NN 42759 911 40 . . . 42759 912 1 Assuming assume VBG 42759 912 2 provisionally provisionally RB 42759 912 3 that that IN 42759 912 4 the the DT 42759 912 5 outcome outcome NN 42759 912 6 of of IN 42759 912 7 the the DT 42759 912 8 discussion discussion NN 42759 912 9 will will MD 42759 912 10 be be VB 42759 912 11 favourable favourable JJ 42759 912 12 to to IN 42759 912 13 the the DT 42759 912 14 claims claim NNS 42759 912 15 of of IN 42759 912 16 the the DT 42759 912 17 landowner landowner NN 42759 912 18 , , , 42759 912 19 let let VB 42759 912 20 us -PRON- PRP 42759 912 21 inquire inquire VB 42759 912 22 whether whether IN 42759 912 23 he -PRON- PRP 42759 912 24 always always RB 42759 912 25 has have VBZ 42759 912 26 a a DT 42759 912 27 moral moral JJ 42759 912 28 right right NN 42759 912 29 to to IN 42759 912 30 _ _ NNP 42759 912 31 all all DT 42759 912 32 _ _ NNP 42759 912 33 the the DT 42759 912 34 rent rent NN 42759 912 35 . . . 42759 913 1 The the DT 42759 913 2 parallel parallel JJ 42759 913 3 question question NN 42759 913 4 regarding regard VBG 42759 913 5 the the DT 42759 913 6 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 913 7 will will MD 42759 913 8 be be VB 42759 913 9 considered consider VBN 42759 913 10 in in IN 42759 913 11 connection connection NN 42759 913 12 with with IN 42759 913 13 the the DT 42759 913 14 right right NN 42759 913 15 of of IN 42759 913 16 the the DT 42759 913 17 labourer labourer NN 42759 913 18 to to IN 42759 913 19 a a DT 42759 913 20 living living NN 42759 913 21 wage wage NN 42759 913 22 . . . 42759 914 1 _ _ NNP 42759 914 2 The the DT 42759 914 3 Tenant Tenant NNP 42759 914 4 's 's POS 42759 914 5 Right right NN 42759 914 6 to to IN 42759 914 7 a a DT 42759 914 8 Decent Decent NNP 42759 914 9 Livelihood Livelihood NNP 42759 914 10 _ _ NNP 42759 914 11 The the DT 42759 914 12 actual actual JJ 42759 914 13 payments payment NNS 42759 914 14 made make VBN 42759 914 15 by by IN 42759 914 16 tenants tenant NNS 42759 914 17 to to IN 42759 914 18 landowners landowner NNS 42759 914 19 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 914 20 leave leave VBP 42759 914 21 the the DT 42759 914 22 former former JJ 42759 914 23 without without IN 42759 914 24 the the DT 42759 914 25 means mean NNS 42759 914 26 of of IN 42759 914 27 decent decent JJ 42759 914 28 living living NN 42759 914 29 . . . 42759 915 1 Such such JJ 42759 915 2 had have VBD 42759 915 3 been be VBN 42759 915 4 the the DT 42759 915 5 condition condition NN 42759 915 6 of of IN 42759 915 7 a a DT 42759 915 8 large large JJ 42759 915 9 part part NN 42759 915 10 of of IN 42759 915 11 the the DT 42759 915 12 Irish irish JJ 42759 915 13 tenant tenant NN 42759 915 14 farmers farmer NNS 42759 915 15 before before IN 42759 915 16 1881 1881 CD 42759 915 17 , , , 42759 915 18 when when WRB 42759 915 19 the the DT 42759 915 20 Land Land NNP 42759 915 21 Courts Courts NNPS 42759 915 22 were be VBD 42759 915 23 established establish VBN 42759 915 24 . . . 42759 916 1 In in IN 42759 916 2 the the DT 42759 916 3 course course NN 42759 916 4 of of IN 42759 916 5 twenty twenty CD 42759 916 6 - - HYPH 42759 916 7 five five CD 42759 916 8 years year NNS 42759 916 9 these these DT 42759 916 10 courts court NNS 42759 916 11 reduced reduce VBD 42759 916 12 the the DT 42759 916 13 rents rent NNS 42759 916 14 by by IN 42759 916 15 twenty twenty CD 42759 916 16 per per NN 42759 916 17 cent cent NN 42759 916 18 . . . 42759 917 1 on on IN 42759 917 2 the the DT 42759 917 3 average average NN 42759 917 4 in in IN 42759 917 5 upwards upward NNS 42759 917 6 of of IN 42759 917 7 half half PDT 42759 917 8 a a DT 42759 917 9 million million CD 42759 917 10 cases case NNS 42759 917 11 . . . 42759 918 1 While while IN 42759 918 2 a a DT 42759 918 3 part part NN 42759 918 4 of of IN 42759 918 5 the the DT 42759 918 6 reductions reduction NNS 42759 918 7 was be VBD 42759 918 8 intended intend VBN 42759 918 9 to to TO 42759 918 10 free free VB 42759 918 11 the the DT 42759 918 12 tenants tenant NNS 42759 918 13 from from IN 42759 918 14 the the DT 42759 918 15 unjust unjust JJ 42759 918 16 burden burden NN 42759 918 17 of of IN 42759 918 18 paying pay VBG 42759 918 19 rent rent NN 42759 918 20 on on IN 42759 918 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 918 22 own own JJ 42759 918 23 improvements improvement NNS 42759 918 24 , , , 42759 918 25 another another DT 42759 918 26 part part NN 42759 918 27 was be VBD 42759 918 28 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 918 29 ordered order VBN 42759 918 30 on on IN 42759 918 31 the the DT 42759 918 32 theory theory NN 42759 918 33 that that IN 42759 918 34 the the DT 42759 918 35 tenants tenant NNS 42759 918 36 were be VBD 42759 918 37 entitled entitle VBN 42759 918 38 to to TO 42759 918 39 retain retain VB 42759 918 40 a a DT 42759 918 41 larger large JJR 42759 918 42 share share NN 42759 918 43 of of IN 42759 918 44 the the DT 42759 918 45 product product NN 42759 918 46 for for IN 42759 918 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 918 48 own own JJ 42759 918 49 support support NN 42759 918 50 . . . 42759 919 1 Yet yet CC 42759 919 2 the the DT 42759 919 3 latter latter JJ 42759 919 4 portion portion NN 42759 919 5 of of IN 42759 919 6 the the DT 42759 919 7 reduction reduction NN 42759 919 8 apparently apparently RB 42759 919 9 represented represent VBD 42759 919 10 true true JJ 42759 919 11 economic economic JJ 42759 919 12 rent rent NN 42759 919 13 ; ; : 42759 919 14 for for IN 42759 919 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 919 16 was be VBD 42759 919 17 included include VBN 42759 919 18 in in IN 42759 919 19 the the DT 42759 919 20 difference difference NN 42759 919 21 between between IN 42759 919 22 the the DT 42759 919 23 product product NN 42759 919 24 and and CC 42759 919 25 the the DT 42759 919 26 current current JJ 42759 919 27 cost cost NN 42759 919 28 of of IN 42759 919 29 production production NN 42759 919 30 ; ; : 42759 919 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 919 32 was be VBD 42759 919 33 included include VBN 42759 919 34 in in IN 42759 919 35 the the DT 42759 919 36 amount amount NN 42759 919 37 that that WDT 42759 919 38 men man NNS 42759 919 39 in in IN 42759 919 40 Ireland Ireland NNP 42759 919 41 were be VBD 42759 919 42 willing willing JJ 42759 919 43 to to TO 42759 919 44 pay pay VB 42759 919 45 for for IN 42759 919 46 the the DT 42759 919 47 use use NN 42759 919 48 of of IN 42759 919 49 land land NN 42759 919 50 . . . 42759 920 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 920 2 was be VBD 42759 920 3 a a DT 42759 920 4 part part NN 42759 920 5 of of IN 42759 920 6 the the DT 42759 920 7 surplus surplus NN 42759 920 8 that that WDT 42759 920 9 they -PRON- PRP 42759 920 10 had have VBD 42759 920 11 left leave VBN 42759 920 12 after after IN 42759 920 13 defraying defray VBG 42759 920 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 920 15 expenditures expenditure NNS 42759 920 16 for for IN 42759 920 17 capital capital NN 42759 920 18 and and CC 42759 920 19 labour labour NN 42759 920 20 . . . 42759 921 1 To to TO 42759 921 2 be be VB 42759 921 3 sure sure JJ 42759 921 4 , , , 42759 921 5 the the DT 42759 921 6 tenants tenant NNS 42759 921 7 in in IN 42759 921 8 some some DT 42759 921 9 other other JJ 42759 921 10 countries country NNS 42759 921 11 , , , 42759 921 12 say say VB 42759 921 13 , , , 42759 921 14 the the DT 42759 921 15 United United NNP 42759 921 16 States States NNP 42759 921 17 , , , 42759 921 18 would would MD 42759 921 19 not not RB 42759 921 20 have have VB 42759 921 21 been be VBN 42759 921 22 satisfied satisfy VBN 42759 921 23 with with IN 42759 921 24 such such PDT 42759 921 25 a a DT 42759 921 26 small small JJ 42759 921 27 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 921 28 , , , 42759 921 29 and and CC 42759 921 30 would would MD 42759 921 31 not not RB 42759 921 32 have have VB 42759 921 33 handed hand VBN 42759 921 34 over over RP 42759 921 35 so so RB 42759 921 36 much much RB 42759 921 37 to to IN 42759 921 38 the the DT 42759 921 39 landlord landlord NN 42759 921 40 ; ; : 42759 921 41 but but CC 42759 921 42 if if IN 42759 921 43 the the DT 42759 921 44 concept concept NN 42759 921 45 of of IN 42759 921 46 economic economic JJ 42759 921 47 rent rent NN 42759 921 48 is be VBZ 42759 921 49 to to TO 42759 921 50 have have VB 42759 921 51 any any DT 42759 921 52 serviceable serviceable JJ 42759 921 53 meaning meaning NN 42759 921 54 it -PRON- PRP 42759 921 55 must must MD 42759 921 56 be be VB 42759 921 57 determined determine VBN 42759 921 58 by by IN 42759 921 59 the the DT 42759 921 60 actual actual JJ 42759 921 61 returns return NNS 42759 921 62 to to IN 42759 921 63 capital capital NN 42759 921 64 and and CC 42759 921 65 labour labour NN 42759 921 66 in in IN 42759 921 67 each each DT 42759 921 68 locality locality NN 42759 921 69 , , , 42759 921 70 and and CC 42759 921 71 not not RB 42759 921 72 by by IN 42759 921 73 the the DT 42759 921 74 standards standard NNS 42759 921 75 of of IN 42759 921 76 some some DT 42759 921 77 other other JJ 42759 921 78 place place NN 42759 921 79 which which WDT 42759 921 80 are be VBP 42759 921 81 assumed assume VBN 42759 921 82 to to TO 42759 921 83 be be VB 42759 921 84 normal normal JJ 42759 921 85 . . . 42759 922 1 In in IN 42759 922 2 any any DT 42759 922 3 case case NN 42759 922 4 , , , 42759 922 5 the the DT 42759 922 6 Irish Irish NNP 42759 922 7 Land Land NNP 42759 922 8 Courts Courts NNPS 42759 922 9 did do VBD 42759 922 10 reduce reduce VB 42759 922 11 the the DT 42759 922 12 rents rent NNS 42759 922 13 below below IN 42759 922 14 the the DT 42759 922 15 level level NN 42759 922 16 fixed fix VBN 42759 922 17 by by IN 42759 922 18 competition competition NN 42759 922 19 , , , 42759 922 20 by by IN 42759 922 21 the the DT 42759 922 22 unregulated unregulated JJ 42759 922 23 forces force NNS 42759 922 24 of of IN 42759 922 25 supply supply NN 42759 922 26 and and CC 42759 922 27 demand demand NN 42759 922 28 . . . 42759 923 1 Was be VBD 42759 923 2 this this DT 42759 923 3 treating treat VBG 42759 923 4 the the DT 42759 923 5 landlords landlord NNS 42759 923 6 justly justly RB 42759 923 7 ? ? . 42759 924 1 May May MD 42759 924 2 a a DT 42759 924 3 tenant tenant NN 42759 924 4 ever ever RB 42759 924 5 retain retain VBP 42759 924 6 a a DT 42759 924 7 part part NN 42759 924 8 of of IN 42759 924 9 the the DT 42759 924 10 rent rent NN 42759 924 11 which which WDT 42759 924 12 the the DT 42759 924 13 free free JJ 42759 924 14 course course NN 42759 924 15 of of IN 42759 924 16 competition competition NN 42759 924 17 would would MD 42759 924 18 yield yield VB 42759 924 19 to to IN 42759 924 20 the the DT 42759 924 21 landowner landowner NN 42759 924 22 ? ? . 42759 925 1 Here here RB 42759 925 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 925 3 must must MD 42759 925 4 distinguish distinguish VB 42759 925 5 between between IN 42759 925 6 the the DT 42759 925 7 tenant tenant NN 42759 925 8 who who WP 42759 925 9 is be VBZ 42759 925 10 and and CC 42759 925 11 the the DT 42759 925 12 tenant tenant NN 42759 925 13 who who WP 42759 925 14 is be VBZ 42759 925 15 not not RB 42759 925 16 in in IN 42759 925 17 possession possession NN 42759 925 18 of of IN 42759 925 19 a a DT 42759 925 20 holding holding NN 42759 925 21 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 925 22 large large JJ 42759 925 23 to to TO 42759 925 24 require require VB 42759 925 25 all all PDT 42759 925 26 the the DT 42759 925 27 time time NN 42759 925 28 and and CC 42759 925 29 labour labour NN 42759 925 30 of of IN 42759 925 31 a a DT 42759 925 32 cultivator cultivator NN 42759 925 33 possessing possess VBG 42759 925 34 average average JJ 42759 925 35 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 925 36 . . . 42759 926 1 The the DT 42759 926 2 tenant tenant NN 42759 926 3 who who WP 42759 926 4 controls control VBZ 42759 926 5 and and CC 42759 926 6 cultivates cultivate VBZ 42759 926 7 less less JJR 42759 926 8 than than IN 42759 926 9 this this DT 42759 926 10 amount amount NN 42759 926 11 of of IN 42759 926 12 land land NN 42759 926 13 ought ought MD 42759 926 14 not not RB 42759 926 15 to to TO 42759 926 16 expect expect VB 42759 926 17 to to TO 42759 926 18 get get VB 42759 926 19 all all PDT 42759 926 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 926 21 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 926 22 therefrom therefrom NN 42759 926 23 . . . 42759 927 1 Failure failure NN 42759 927 2 to to TO 42759 927 3 do do VB 42759 927 4 so so RB 42759 927 5 would would MD 42759 927 6 not not RB 42759 927 7 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 927 8 mean mean VB 42759 927 9 that that IN 42759 927 10 he -PRON- PRP 42759 927 11 was be VBD 42759 927 12 paying pay VBG 42759 927 13 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 42759 927 14 rent rent NN 42759 927 15 . . . 42759 928 1 Holdings holding NNS 42759 928 2 of of IN 42759 928 3 this this DT 42759 928 4 sort sort NN 42759 928 5 are be VBP 42759 928 6 rightly rightly RB 42759 928 7 called call VBN 42759 928 8 " " `` 42759 928 9 uneconomic uneconomic JJ 42759 928 10 " " '' 42759 928 11 ; ; : 42759 928 12 that that RB 42759 928 13 is is RB 42759 928 14 , , , 42759 928 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 928 16 are be VBP 42759 928 17 too too RB 42759 928 18 small small JJ 42759 928 19 to to TO 42759 928 20 permit permit VB 42759 928 21 a a DT 42759 928 22 profitable profitable JJ 42759 928 23 and and CC 42759 928 24 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 928 25 application application NN 42759 928 26 of of IN 42759 928 27 labour labour NN 42759 928 28 and and CC 42759 928 29 capital capital NN 42759 928 30 . . . 42759 929 1 On on IN 42759 929 2 such such JJ 42759 929 3 holdings holding NNS 42759 929 4 the the DT 42759 929 5 fair fair JJ 42759 929 6 rent rent NN 42759 929 7 would would MD 42759 929 8 be be VB 42759 929 9 that that DT 42759 929 10 amount amount NN 42759 929 11 per per IN 42759 929 12 acre acre NN 42759 929 13 which which WDT 42759 929 14 would would MD 42759 929 15 be be VB 42759 929 16 regarded regard VBN 42759 929 17 as as IN 42759 929 18 fair fair JJ 42759 929 19 for for IN 42759 929 20 the the DT 42759 929 21 use use NN 42759 929 22 of of IN 42759 929 23 the the DT 42759 929 24 same same JJ 42759 929 25 land land NN 42759 929 26 held hold VBN 42759 929 27 in in IN 42759 929 28 farms farm NNS 42759 929 29 of of IN 42759 929 30 " " `` 42759 929 31 economic economic JJ 42759 929 32 " " '' 42759 929 33 size size NN 42759 929 34 . . . 42759 930 1 The the DT 42759 930 2 proper proper JJ 42759 930 3 recourse recourse NN 42759 930 4 for for IN 42759 930 5 the the DT 42759 930 6 occupiers occupier NNS 42759 930 7 of of IN 42759 930 8 uneconomic uneconomic JJ 42759 930 9 holdings holding NNS 42759 930 10 is be VBZ 42759 930 11 to to TO 42759 930 12 get get VB 42759 930 13 control control NN 42759 930 14 of of IN 42759 930 15 more more JJR 42759 930 16 land land NN 42759 930 17 , , , 42759 930 18 which which WDT 42759 930 19 is be VBZ 42759 930 20 exactly exactly RB 42759 930 21 what what WP 42759 930 22 has have VBZ 42759 930 23 been be VBN 42759 930 24 happening happen VBG 42759 930 25 in in IN 42759 930 26 Ireland Ireland NNP 42759 930 27 through through IN 42759 930 28 the the DT 42759 930 29 action action NN 42759 930 30 of of IN 42759 930 31 the the DT 42759 930 32 Congested Congested NNP 42759 930 33 Districts Districts NNPS 42759 930 34 Board Board NNP 42759 930 35 . . . 42759 931 1 This this DT 42759 931 2 brings bring VBZ 42759 931 3 us -PRON- PRP 42759 931 4 to to IN 42759 931 5 the the DT 42759 931 6 case case NN 42759 931 7 of of IN 42759 931 8 the the DT 42759 931 9 man man NN 42759 931 10 who who WP 42759 931 11 can can MD 42759 931 12 not not RB 42759 931 13 pay pay VB 42759 931 14 the the DT 42759 931 15 competitive competitive JJ 42759 931 16 rent rent NN 42759 931 17 on on IN 42759 931 18 a a DT 42759 931 19 holding holding NN 42759 931 20 of of IN 42759 931 21 normal normal JJ 42759 931 22 size size NN 42759 931 23 , , , 42759 931 24 and and CC 42759 931 25 have have VB 42759 931 26 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 931 27 left leave VBN 42759 931 28 to to TO 42759 931 29 provide provide VB 42759 931 30 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 931 31 and and CC 42759 931 32 family family NN 42759 931 33 with with IN 42759 931 34 a a DT 42759 931 35 decent decent JJ 42759 931 36 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 931 37 . . . 42759 932 1 The the DT 42759 932 2 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 932 3 reason reason NN 42759 932 4 why why WRB 42759 932 5 the the DT 42759 932 6 rent rent NN 42759 932 7 is be VBZ 42759 932 8 so so RB 42759 932 9 high high JJ 42759 932 10 is be VBZ 42759 932 11 to to TO 42759 932 12 be be VB 42759 932 13 found find VBN 42759 932 14 in in IN 42759 932 15 the the DT 42759 932 16 economic economic JJ 42759 932 17 weakness weakness NN 42759 932 18 of of IN 42759 932 19 the the DT 42759 932 20 great great JJ 42759 932 21 mass mass NN 42759 932 22 of of IN 42759 932 23 the the DT 42759 932 24 tenants tenant NNS 42759 932 25 , , , 42759 932 26 who who WP 42759 932 27 can can MD 42759 932 28 neither neither CC 42759 932 29 emigrate emigrate VB 42759 932 30 to to IN 42759 932 31 another another DT 42759 932 32 country country NN 42759 932 33 nor nor CC 42759 932 34 get get VB 42759 932 35 a a DT 42759 932 36 better well JJR 42759 932 37 living living NN 42759 932 38 as as IN 42759 932 39 wage wage NN 42759 932 40 earners earner NNS 42759 932 41 in in IN 42759 932 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 932 43 own own JJ 42759 932 44 . . . 42759 933 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 933 2 predicament predicament NN 42759 933 3 is be VBZ 42759 933 4 exactly exactly RB 42759 933 5 the the DT 42759 933 6 same same JJ 42759 933 7 as as IN 42759 933 8 that that DT 42759 933 9 of of IN 42759 933 10 the the DT 42759 933 11 helpless helpless JJ 42759 933 12 and and CC 42759 933 13 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 933 14 labourers labourer NNS 42759 933 15 who who WP 42759 933 16 are be VBP 42759 933 17 compelled compel VBN 42759 933 18 by by IN 42759 933 19 the the DT 42759 933 20 force force NN 42759 933 21 of of IN 42759 933 22 competition competition NN 42759 933 23 to to TO 42759 933 24 accept accept VB 42759 933 25 less less JJR 42759 933 26 than than IN 42759 933 27 living live VBG 42759 933 28 wages wage NNS 42759 933 29 . . . 42759 934 1 In in IN 42759 934 2 these these DT 42759 934 3 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 934 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 934 5 seems seem VBZ 42759 934 6 clear clear JJ 42759 934 7 that that IN 42759 934 8 a a DT 42759 934 9 government government NN 42759 934 10 commission commission NN 42759 934 11 would would MD 42759 934 12 be be VB 42759 934 13 justified justify VBN 42759 934 14 in in IN 42759 934 15 reducing reduce VBG 42759 934 16 the the DT 42759 934 17 rents rent NNS 42759 934 18 to to IN 42759 934 19 such such PDT 42759 934 20 a a DT 42759 934 21 level level NN 42759 934 22 as as IN 42759 934 23 would would MD 42759 934 24 leave leave VB 42759 934 25 the the DT 42759 934 26 tenants tenant NNS 42759 934 27 of of IN 42759 934 28 average average JJ 42759 934 29 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 934 30 on on IN 42759 934 31 normal normal JJ 42759 934 32 holdings holding NNS 42759 934 33 the the DT 42759 934 34 means mean NNS 42759 934 35 of of IN 42759 934 36 maintaining maintain VBG 42759 934 37 a a DT 42759 934 38 decent decent JJ 42759 934 39 standard standard NN 42759 934 40 of of IN 42759 934 41 living living NN 42759 934 42 . . . 42759 935 1 In in IN 42759 935 2 such such JJ 42759 935 3 cases case NNS 42759 935 4 , , , 42759 935 5 then then RB 42759 935 6 , , , 42759 935 7 the the DT 42759 935 8 landowner landowner NN 42759 935 9 has have VBZ 42759 935 10 not not RB 42759 935 11 a a DT 42759 935 12 right right NN 42759 935 13 to to IN 42759 935 14 the the DT 42759 935 15 full full JJ 42759 935 16 economic economic JJ 42759 935 17 or or CC 42759 935 18 competitive competitive JJ 42759 935 19 rent rent NN 42759 935 20 . . . 42759 936 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 936 2 right right JJ 42759 936 3 thereto thereto NN 42759 936 4 is be VBZ 42759 936 5 morally morally RB 42759 936 6 inferior inferior JJ 42759 936 7 to to IN 42759 936 8 the the DT 42759 936 9 tenant tenant NN 42759 936 10 's 's POS 42759 936 11 right right NN 42759 936 12 to to IN 42759 936 13 a a DT 42759 936 14 decent decent JJ 42759 936 15 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 936 16 , , , 42759 936 17 just just RB 42759 936 18 as as IN 42759 936 19 the the DT 42759 936 20 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 936 21 - - HYPH 42759 936 22 employer employer NN 42759 936 23 's 's POS 42759 936 24 right right NN 42759 936 25 to to IN 42759 936 26 the the DT 42759 936 27 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 936 28 rate rate NN 42759 936 29 of of IN 42759 936 30 interest interest NN 42759 936 31 is be VBZ 42759 936 32 morally morally RB 42759 936 33 inferior inferior JJ 42759 936 34 to to IN 42759 936 35 the the DT 42759 936 36 labourer labourer NN 42759 936 37 's 's POS 42759 936 38 right right NN 42759 936 39 to to IN 42759 936 40 a a DT 42759 936 41 living living NN 42759 936 42 wage wage NN 42759 936 43 . . . 42759 937 1 Neither neither CC 42759 937 2 in in IN 42759 937 3 the the DT 42759 937 4 one one CD 42759 937 5 case case NN 42759 937 6 nor nor CC 42759 937 7 in in IN 42759 937 8 the the DT 42759 937 9 other other JJ 42759 937 10 is be VBZ 42759 937 11 mere mere JJ 42759 937 12 competition competition NN 42759 937 13 the the DT 42759 937 14 final final JJ 42759 937 15 determinant determinant NN 42759 937 16 and and CC 42759 937 17 measure measure NN 42759 937 18 of of IN 42759 937 19 justice justice NN 42759 937 20 . . . 42759 938 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 938 2 has have VBZ 42759 938 3 no no DT 42759 938 4 moral moral JJ 42759 938 5 validity validity NN 42759 938 6 when when WRB 42759 938 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 938 8 comes come VBZ 42759 938 9 into into IN 42759 938 10 conflict conflict NN 42759 938 11 with with IN 42759 938 12 man man NN 42759 938 13 's 's POS 42759 938 14 natural natural JJ 42759 938 15 right right NN 42759 938 16 to to TO 42759 938 17 get get VB 42759 938 18 a a DT 42759 938 19 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 938 20 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 938 21 on on IN 42759 938 22 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 938 23 conditions condition NNS 42759 938 24 from from IN 42759 938 25 the the DT 42759 938 26 bounty bounty NN 42759 938 27 of of IN 42759 938 28 the the DT 42759 938 29 earth earth NN 42759 938 30 . . . 42759 939 1 These these DT 42759 939 2 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 939 3 questions question NNS 42759 939 4 will will MD 42759 939 5 be be VB 42759 939 6 discussed discuss VBN 42759 939 7 at at IN 42759 939 8 length length NN 42759 939 9 in in IN 42759 939 10 the the DT 42759 939 11 chapters chapter NNS 42759 939 12 on on IN 42759 939 13 wages wage NNS 42759 939 14 . . . 42759 940 1 To to IN 42759 940 2 the the DT 42759 940 3 possible possible JJ 42759 940 4 objection objection NN 42759 940 5 that that IN 42759 940 6 the the DT 42759 940 7 concept concept NN 42759 940 8 of of IN 42759 940 9 a a DT 42759 940 10 " " `` 42759 940 11 normal normal JJ 42759 940 12 " " '' 42759 940 13 holding holding NN 42759 940 14 is be VBZ 42759 940 15 vague vague JJ 42759 940 16 , , , 42759 940 17 the the DT 42759 940 18 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 940 19 reply reply NN 42759 940 20 is be VBZ 42759 940 21 that that IN 42759 940 22 in in IN 42759 940 23 practice practice NN 42759 940 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 940 25 can can MD 42759 940 26 be be VB 42759 940 27 estimated estimate VBN 42759 940 28 with with IN 42759 940 29 as as RB 42759 940 30 much much JJ 42759 940 31 definiteness definiteness NN 42759 940 32 as as IN 42759 940 33 the the DT 42759 940 34 concept concept NN 42759 940 35 of of IN 42759 940 36 the the DT 42759 940 37 " " `` 42759 940 38 average average JJ 42759 940 39 " " '' 42759 940 40 labourer labourer NN 42759 940 41 . . . 42759 941 1 As as IN 42759 941 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 941 3 see see VBP 42759 941 4 from from IN 42759 941 5 the the DT 42759 941 6 history history NN 42759 941 7 of of IN 42759 941 8 the the DT 42759 941 9 Irish Irish NNP 42759 941 10 Land Land NNP 42759 941 11 Courts Courts NNPS 42759 941 12 and and CC 42759 941 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 941 14 " " `` 42759 941 15 Judicial judicial JJ 42759 941 16 Rents rent NNS 42759 941 17 , , , 42759 941 18 " " '' 42759 941 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 941 20 can can MD 42759 941 21 be be VB 42759 941 22 defined define VBN 42759 941 23 with with IN 42759 941 24 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 941 25 accuracy accuracy NN 42759 941 26 to to TO 42759 941 27 serve serve VB 42759 941 28 the the DT 42759 941 29 ends end NNS 42759 941 30 of of IN 42759 941 31 practical practical JJ 42759 941 32 justice justice NN 42759 941 33 . . . 42759 942 1 More More JJR 42759 942 2 than than IN 42759 942 3 this this DT 42759 942 4 is be VBZ 42759 942 5 not not RB 42759 942 6 attained attain VBN 42759 942 7 in in IN 42759 942 8 any any DT 42759 942 9 department department NN 42759 942 10 of of IN 42759 942 11 human human JJ 42759 942 12 relations relation NNS 42759 942 13 , , , 42759 942 14 particularly particularly RB 42759 942 15 , , , 42759 942 16 economic economic JJ 42759 942 17 relations relation NNS 42759 942 18 . . . 42759 943 1 _ _ NNP 42759 943 2 The the DT 42759 943 3 Labourer Labourer NNP 42759 943 4 's 's POS 42759 943 5 Claim claim NN 42759 943 6 Upon upon IN 42759 943 7 the the DT 42759 943 8 Rent Rent NNP 42759 943 9 _ _ NNP 42759 943 10 Should Should MD 42759 943 11 any any DT 42759 943 12 part part NN 42759 943 13 of of IN 42759 943 14 the the DT 42759 943 15 rent rent NN 42759 943 16 go go VB 42759 943 17 to to IN 42759 943 18 the the DT 42759 943 19 labourer labourer NN 42759 943 20 ? ? . 42759 944 1 Let let VB 42759 944 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 944 3 take take VB 42759 944 4 first first RB 42759 944 5 the the DT 42759 944 6 case case NN 42759 944 7 of of IN 42759 944 8 the the DT 42759 944 9 labourer labourer NN 42759 944 10 who who WP 42759 944 11 is be VBZ 42759 944 12 employed employ VBN 42759 944 13 by by IN 42759 944 14 a a DT 42759 944 15 tenant tenant NN 42759 944 16 , , , 42759 944 17 and and CC 42759 944 18 who who WP 42759 944 19 is be VBZ 42759 944 20 not not RB 42759 944 21 occupied occupy VBN 42759 944 22 in in IN 42759 944 23 personal personal JJ 42759 944 24 service service NN 42759 944 25 but but CC 42759 944 26 in in IN 42759 944 27 some some DT 42759 944 28 productive productive JJ 42759 944 29 task task NN 42759 944 30 connected connect VBN 42759 944 31 with with IN 42759 944 32 the the DT 42759 944 33 land land NN 42759 944 34 . . . 42759 945 1 Like like IN 42759 945 2 all all DT 42759 945 3 other other JJ 42759 945 4 wage wage NN 42759 945 5 earners earner NNS 42759 945 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 945 7 has have VBZ 42759 945 8 a a DT 42759 945 9 right right NN 42759 945 10 to to IN 42759 945 11 a a DT 42759 945 12 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 945 13 share share NN 42759 945 14 of of IN 42759 945 15 the the DT 42759 945 16 product product NN 42759 945 17 to to TO 42759 945 18 afford afford VB 42759 945 19 him -PRON- PRP 42759 945 20 a a DT 42759 945 21 decent decent JJ 42759 945 22 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 945 23 . . . 42759 946 1 Since since IN 42759 946 2 the the DT 42759 946 3 tenant tenant NN 42759 946 4 is be VBZ 42759 946 5 the the DT 42759 946 6 employer employer NN 42759 946 7 , , , 42759 946 8 the the DT 42759 946 9 director director NN 42759 946 10 of of IN 42759 946 11 the the DT 42759 946 12 business business NN 42759 946 13 , , , 42759 946 14 and and CC 42759 946 15 the the DT 42759 946 16 owner owner NN 42759 946 17 of of IN 42759 946 18 the the DT 42759 946 19 product product NN 42759 946 20 , , , 42759 946 21 he -PRON- PRP 42759 946 22 rather rather RB 42759 946 23 than than IN 42759 946 24 the the DT 42759 946 25 landowner landowner NN 42759 946 26 is be VBZ 42759 946 27 the the DT 42759 946 28 person person NN 42759 946 29 who who WP 42759 946 30 is be VBZ 42759 946 31 primarily primarily RB 42759 946 32 charged charge VBN 42759 946 33 with with IN 42759 946 34 the the DT 42759 946 35 obligation obligation NN 42759 946 36 of of IN 42759 946 37 providing provide VBG 42759 946 38 the the DT 42759 946 39 labourer labourer NN 42759 946 40 with with IN 42759 946 41 a a DT 42759 946 42 living living NN 42759 946 43 wage wage NN 42759 946 44 . . . 42759 947 1 As as IN 42759 947 2 noted note VBN 42759 947 3 above above RB 42759 947 4 , , , 42759 947 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 947 6 own own JJ 42759 947 7 claim claim NN 42759 947 8 to to IN 42759 947 9 a a DT 42759 947 10 decent decent JJ 42759 947 11 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 947 12 is be VBZ 42759 947 13 morally morally RB 42759 947 14 superior superior JJ 42759 947 15 to to IN 42759 947 16 the the DT 42759 947 17 landlord landlord NN 42759 947 18 's 's POS 42759 947 19 claim claim NN 42759 947 20 to to TO 42759 947 21 rent rent VB 42759 947 22 ; ; : 42759 947 23 but but CC 42759 947 24 if if IN 42759 947 25 , , , 42759 947 26 having have VBG 42759 947 27 taken take VBN 42759 947 28 this this DT 42759 947 29 amount amount NN 42759 947 30 from from IN 42759 947 31 the the DT 42759 947 32 product product NN 42759 947 33 , , , 42759 947 34 he -PRON- PRP 42759 947 35 finds find VBZ 42759 947 36 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 947 37 unable unable JJ 42759 947 38 to to TO 42759 947 39 pay pay VB 42759 947 40 living live VBG 42759 947 41 wages wage NNS 42759 947 42 to to IN 42759 947 43 all all DT 42759 947 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 947 45 employees employee NNS 42759 947 46 unless unless IN 42759 947 47 he -PRON- PRP 42759 947 48 deducts deduct VBZ 42759 947 49 something something NN 42759 947 50 either either CC 42759 947 51 from from IN 42759 947 52 the the DT 42759 947 53 normal normal JJ 42759 947 54 interest interest NN 42759 947 55 - - HYPH 42759 947 56 return return NN 42759 947 57 on on IN 42759 947 58 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 947 59 own own JJ 42759 947 60 capital capital NN 42759 947 61 or or CC 42759 947 62 from from IN 42759 947 63 the the DT 42759 947 64 rent rent NN 42759 947 65 that that WDT 42759 947 66 would would MD 42759 947 67 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 947 68 go go VB 42759 947 69 to to IN 42759 947 70 the the DT 42759 947 71 landowner landowner NN 42759 947 72 , , , 42759 947 73 he -PRON- PRP 42759 947 74 is be VBZ 42759 947 75 morally morally RB 42759 947 76 bound bind VBN 42759 947 77 to to TO 42759 947 78 choose choose VB 42759 947 79 the the DT 42759 947 80 former former JJ 42759 947 81 course course NN 42759 947 82 . . . 42759 948 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 948 2 , , , 42759 948 3 not not RB 42759 948 4 the the DT 42759 948 5 landowner landowner NN 42759 948 6 , , , 42759 948 7 is be VBZ 42759 948 8 the the DT 42759 948 9 wage wage NN 42759 948 10 payer payer NN 42759 948 11 . . . 42759 949 1 That that IN 42759 949 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 949 3 is be VBZ 42759 949 4 obliged oblige VBN 42759 949 5 to to TO 42759 949 6 provide provide VB 42759 949 7 living live VBG 42759 949 8 wages wage NNS 42759 949 9 to to IN 42759 949 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 949 11 labour labour JJ 42759 949 12 force force NN 42759 949 13 even even RB 42759 949 14 at at IN 42759 949 15 the the DT 42759 949 16 cost cost NN 42759 949 17 of of IN 42759 949 18 interest interest NN 42759 949 19 on on IN 42759 949 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 949 21 own own JJ 42759 949 22 investment investment NN 42759 949 23 in in IN 42759 949 24 the the DT 42759 949 25 business business NN 42759 949 26 , , , 42759 949 27 is be VBZ 42759 949 28 a a DT 42759 949 29 proposition proposition NN 42759 949 30 that that WDT 42759 949 31 will will MD 42759 949 32 receive receive VB 42759 949 33 ample ample JJ 42759 949 34 discussion discussion NN 42759 949 35 and and CC 42759 949 36 defence defence NN 42759 949 37 in in IN 42759 949 38 a a DT 42759 949 39 later later JJ 42759 949 40 chapter chapter NN 42759 949 41 . . . 42759 950 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 950 2 48 48 CD 42759 950 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 950 4 Suppose suppose VB 42759 950 5 , , , 42759 950 6 however however RB 42759 950 7 , , , 42759 950 8 that that IN 42759 950 9 the the DT 42759 950 10 tenant tenant NN 42759 950 11 has have VBZ 42759 950 12 not not RB 42759 950 13 the the DT 42759 950 14 means mean NNS 42759 950 15 of of IN 42759 950 16 paying pay VBG 42759 950 17 full full JJ 42759 950 18 living living NN 42759 950 19 wages wage NNS 42759 950 20 after after IN 42759 950 21 turning turn VBG 42759 950 22 into into IN 42759 950 23 the the DT 42759 950 24 wage wage NN 42759 950 25 fund fund NN 42759 950 26 all all PDT 42759 950 27 the the DT 42759 950 28 money money NN 42759 950 29 that that WDT 42759 950 30 he -PRON- PRP 42759 950 31 had have VBD 42759 950 32 hoped hope VBN 42759 950 33 to to TO 42759 950 34 retain retain VB 42759 950 35 as as IN 42759 950 36 interest interest NN 42759 950 37 on on IN 42759 950 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 950 39 capital capital NN 42759 950 40 . . . 42759 951 1 May May MD 42759 951 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 951 3 withhold withhold VBD 42759 951 4 from from IN 42759 951 5 the the DT 42759 951 6 landowner landowner NN 42759 951 7 a a DT 42759 951 8 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 951 9 portion portion NN 42759 951 10 of of IN 42759 951 11 the the DT 42759 951 12 rent rent NN 42759 951 13 to to TO 42759 951 14 cover cover VB 42759 951 15 the the DT 42759 951 16 deficit deficit NN 42759 951 17 in in IN 42759 951 18 wages wage NNS 42759 951 19 ? ? . 42759 952 1 Were be VBD 42759 952 2 this this DT 42759 952 3 action action NN 42759 952 4 practicable practicable JJ 42759 952 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 952 6 would would MD 42759 952 7 be be VB 42759 952 8 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 952 9 justifiable justifiable JJ 42759 952 10 ; ; : 42759 952 11 for for IN 42759 952 12 the the DT 42759 952 13 landowner landowner NN 42759 952 14 's 's POS 42759 952 15 claim claim NN 42759 952 16 to to TO 42759 952 17 rent rent VB 42759 952 18 is be VBZ 42759 952 19 no no DT 42759 952 20 stronger strong JJR 42759 952 21 than than IN 42759 952 22 the the DT 42759 952 23 tenant tenant NN 42759 952 24 - - HYPH 42759 952 25 capitalist capitalist NNP 42759 952 26 's 's POS 42759 952 27 claim claim NN 42759 952 28 to to IN 42759 952 29 interest interest NN 42759 952 30 . . . 42759 953 1 As as IN 42759 953 2 claims claim NNS 42759 953 3 upon upon IN 42759 953 4 the the DT 42759 953 5 product product NN 42759 953 6 , , , 42759 953 7 both both DT 42759 953 8 are be VBP 42759 953 9 morally morally RB 42759 953 10 weaker weak JJR 42759 953 11 than than IN 42759 953 12 the the DT 42759 953 13 labourer labourer NN 42759 953 14 's 's POS 42759 953 15 right right NN 42759 953 16 to to IN 42759 953 17 a a DT 42759 953 18 living living NN 42759 953 19 wage wage NN 42759 953 20 . . . 42759 954 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 954 2 , , , 42759 954 3 the the DT 42759 954 4 tenant tenant NN 42759 954 5 who who WP 42759 954 6 should should MD 42759 954 7 attempt attempt VB 42759 954 8 to to TO 42759 954 9 carry carry VB 42759 954 10 out out RP 42759 954 11 this this DT 42759 954 12 course course NN 42759 954 13 would would MD 42759 954 14 probably probably RB 42759 954 15 be be VB 42759 954 16 prosecuted prosecute VBN 42759 954 17 for for IN 42759 954 18 non non JJ 42759 954 19 - - JJ 42759 954 20 fulfilment fulfilment NN 42759 954 21 of of IN 42759 954 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 954 23 contract contract NN 42759 954 24 with with IN 42759 954 25 the the DT 42759 954 26 landowner landowner NN 42759 954 27 , , , 42759 954 28 or or CC 42759 954 29 would would MD 42759 954 30 be be VB 42759 954 31 evicted evict VBN 42759 954 32 from from IN 42759 954 33 the the DT 42759 954 34 holding holding NN 42759 954 35 . . . 42759 955 1 Nor nor CC 42759 955 2 is be VBZ 42759 955 3 the the DT 42759 955 4 landowner landowner RB 42759 955 5 obliged oblige VBN 42759 955 6 in in IN 42759 955 7 such such JJ 42759 955 8 cases case NNS 42759 955 9 to to TO 42759 955 10 give give VB 42759 955 11 up up RP 42759 955 12 the the DT 42759 955 13 rent rent NN 42759 955 14 in in IN 42759 955 15 order order NN 42759 955 16 that that IN 42759 955 17 a a DT 42759 955 18 living living NN 42759 955 19 wage wage NN 42759 955 20 may may MD 42759 955 21 be be VB 42759 955 22 paid pay VBN 42759 955 23 to to IN 42759 955 24 the the DT 42759 955 25 tenant tenant NN 42759 955 26 's 's POS 42759 955 27 labour labour JJ 42759 955 28 force force NN 42759 955 29 . . . 42759 956 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 956 2 can can MD 42759 956 3 not not RB 42759 956 4 be be VB 42759 956 5 certain certain JJ 42759 956 6 that that IN 42759 956 7 the the DT 42759 956 8 failure failure NN 42759 956 9 of of IN 42759 956 10 the the DT 42759 956 11 latter latter JJ 42759 956 12 to to TO 42759 956 13 receive receive VB 42759 956 14 full full JJ 42759 956 15 living living NN 42759 956 16 wages wage NNS 42759 956 17 has have VBZ 42759 956 18 not not RB 42759 956 19 been be VBN 42759 956 20 due due JJ 42759 956 21 to to IN 42759 956 22 inefficiency inefficiency NN 42759 956 23 or or CC 42759 956 24 fraudulent fraudulent JJ 42759 956 25 conduct conduct NN 42759 956 26 on on IN 42759 956 27 the the DT 42759 956 28 part part NN 42759 956 29 of of IN 42759 956 30 the the DT 42759 956 31 tenant tenant NN 42759 956 32 . . . 42759 957 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 957 2 , , , 42759 957 3 the the DT 42759 957 4 landowner landowner NN 42759 957 5 would would MD 42759 957 6 be be VB 42759 957 7 justified justify VBN 42759 957 8 in in IN 42759 957 9 seeking seek VBG 42759 957 10 to to TO 42759 957 11 protect protect VB 42759 957 12 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 957 13 against against IN 42759 957 14 the the DT 42759 957 15 recurrence recurrence NN 42759 957 16 of of IN 42759 957 17 such such JJ 42759 957 18 situations situation NNS 42759 957 19 by by IN 42759 957 20 putting put VBG 42759 957 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 957 22 land land NN 42759 957 23 in in IN 42759 957 24 charge charge NN 42759 957 25 of of IN 42759 957 26 a a DT 42759 957 27 more more RBR 42759 957 28 capable capable JJ 42759 957 29 tenant tenant NN 42759 957 30 , , , 42759 957 31 or or CC 42759 957 32 by by IN 42759 957 33 selling sell VBG 42759 957 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 957 35 and and CC 42759 957 36 investing invest VBG 42759 957 37 or or CC 42759 957 38 lending lend VBG 42759 957 39 the the DT 42759 957 40 money money NN 42759 957 41 elsewhere elsewhere RB 42759 957 42 . . . 42759 958 1 However however WRB 42759 958 2 clear clear JJ 42759 958 3 may may MD 42759 958 4 be be VB 42759 958 5 the the DT 42759 958 6 abstract abstract JJ 42759 958 7 proposition proposition NN 42759 958 8 that that IN 42759 958 9 the the DT 42759 958 10 claim claim NN 42759 958 11 to to IN 42759 958 12 a a DT 42759 958 13 living living NN 42759 958 14 wage wage NN 42759 958 15 possessed possess VBN 42759 958 16 by by IN 42759 958 17 the the DT 42759 958 18 employee employee NN 42759 958 19 of of IN 42759 958 20 the the DT 42759 958 21 tenant tenant NN 42759 958 22 is be VBZ 42759 958 23 superior superior JJ 42759 958 24 to to IN 42759 958 25 the the DT 42759 958 26 claim claim NN 42759 958 27 to to TO 42759 958 28 rent rent VB 42759 958 29 possessed possess VBN 42759 958 30 by by IN 42759 958 31 the the DT 42759 958 32 landowner landowner NN 42759 958 33 , , , 42759 958 34 the the DT 42759 958 35 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 958 36 of of IN 42759 958 37 realising realise VBG 42759 958 38 this this DT 42759 958 39 right right NN 42759 958 40 in in IN 42759 958 41 practice practice NN 42759 958 42 is be VBZ 42759 958 43 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 958 44 to to TO 42759 958 45 relieve relieve VB 42759 958 46 even even RB 42759 958 47 conscientious conscientious JJ 42759 958 48 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 958 49 from from IN 42759 958 50 the the DT 42759 958 51 obligation obligation NN 42759 958 52 of of IN 42759 958 53 giving give VBG 42759 958 54 up up RP 42759 958 55 the the DT 42759 958 56 rent rent NN 42759 958 57 for for IN 42759 958 58 this this DT 42759 958 59 purpose purpose NN 42759 958 60 . . . 42759 959 1 When when WRB 42759 959 2 the the DT 42759 959 3 landowner landowner NN 42759 959 4 is be VBZ 42759 959 5 operating operate VBG 42759 959 6 or or CC 42759 959 7 cultivating cultivate VBG 42759 959 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 959 9 land land NN 42759 959 10 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 959 11 , , , 42759 959 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 959 13 is be VBZ 42759 959 14 evidently evidently RB 42759 959 15 obliged oblige VBN 42759 959 16 to to TO 42759 959 17 pay pay VB 42759 959 18 a a DT 42759 959 19 living living NN 42759 959 20 wage wage NN 42759 959 21 to to IN 42759 959 22 all all DT 42759 959 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 959 24 employees employee NNS 42759 959 25 at at IN 42759 959 26 the the DT 42759 959 27 expense expense NN 42759 959 28 of of IN 42759 959 29 rent rent NN 42759 959 30 , , , 42759 959 31 just just RB 42759 959 32 as as IN 42759 959 33 he -PRON- PRP 42759 959 34 is be VBZ 42759 959 35 obliged oblige VBN 42759 959 36 to to TO 42759 959 37 do do VB 42759 959 38 so so RB 42759 959 39 at at IN 42759 959 40 the the DT 42759 959 41 cost cost NN 42759 959 42 of of IN 42759 959 43 interest interest NN 42759 959 44 on on IN 42759 959 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 959 46 artificial artificial JJ 42759 959 47 capital capital NN 42759 959 48 . . . 42759 960 1 To to TO 42759 960 2 be be VB 42759 960 3 sure sure JJ 42759 960 4 , , , 42759 960 5 the the DT 42759 960 6 first first JJ 42759 960 7 charge charge NN 42759 960 8 upon upon IN 42759 960 9 the the DT 42759 960 10 product product NN 42759 960 11 should should MD 42759 960 12 be be VB 42759 960 13 a a DT 42759 960 14 decent decent JJ 42759 960 15 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 960 16 for for IN 42759 960 17 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 960 18 ; ; : 42759 960 19 but but CC 42759 960 20 , , , 42759 960 21 when when WRB 42759 960 22 he -PRON- PRP 42759 960 23 has have VBZ 42759 960 24 obtained obtain VBN 42759 960 25 this this DT 42759 960 26 , , , 42759 960 27 the the DT 42759 960 28 right right NN 42759 960 29 of of IN 42759 960 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 960 31 employees employee NNS 42759 960 32 to to IN 42759 960 33 a a DT 42759 960 34 living living NN 42759 960 35 wage wage NN 42759 960 36 is be VBZ 42759 960 37 morally morally RB 42759 960 38 superior superior JJ 42759 960 39 to to IN 42759 960 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 960 41 right right NN 42759 960 42 to to IN 42759 960 43 either either CC 42759 960 44 rent rent NN 42759 960 45 or or CC 42759 960 46 interest interest NN 42759 960 47 . . . 42759 961 1 At at IN 42759 961 2 present present JJ 42759 961 3 the the DT 42759 961 4 State state NN 42759 961 5 takes take VBZ 42759 961 6 a a DT 42759 961 7 part part NN 42759 961 8 of of IN 42759 961 9 the the DT 42759 961 10 rent rent NN 42759 961 11 through through IN 42759 961 12 taxation taxation NN 42759 961 13 . . . 42759 962 1 May May MD 42759 962 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 962 3 take take VB 42759 962 4 a a DT 42759 962 5 larger large JJR 42759 962 6 share share NN 42759 962 7 without without IN 42759 962 8 violating violate VBG 42759 962 9 justice justice NN 42759 962 10 ? ? . 42759 963 1 This this DT 42759 963 2 question question NN 42759 963 3 will will MD 42759 963 4 be be VB 42759 963 5 considered consider VBN 42759 963 6 in in IN 42759 963 7 the the DT 42759 963 8 second second JJ 42759 963 9 chapter chapter NN 42759 963 10 following follow VBG 42759 963 11 . . . 42759 964 1 In in IN 42759 964 2 the the DT 42759 964 3 meantime meantime NN 42759 964 4 , , , 42759 964 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 964 6 shall shall MD 42759 964 7 examine examine VB 42759 964 8 the the DT 42759 964 9 principal principal JJ 42759 964 10 defects defect NNS 42759 964 11 of of IN 42759 964 12 the the DT 42759 964 13 existing exist VBG 42759 964 14 system system NN 42759 964 15 of of IN 42759 964 16 land land NN 42759 964 17 tenure tenure NN 42759 964 18 with with IN 42759 964 19 a a DT 42759 964 20 view view NN 42759 964 21 to to IN 42759 964 22 the the DT 42759 964 23 suggestion suggestion NN 42759 964 24 of of IN 42759 964 25 appropriate appropriate JJ 42759 964 26 remedies remedy NNS 42759 964 27 , , , 42759 964 28 whether whether IN 42759 964 29 through through IN 42759 964 30 taxation taxation NN 42759 964 31 or or CC 42759 964 32 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 964 33 . . . 42759 965 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 965 2 : : : 42759 965 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 965 4 47 47 CD 42759 965 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 965 6 The the DT 42759 965 7 assumption assumption NN 42759 965 8 that that WDT 42759 965 9 perfect perfect JJ 42759 965 10 competition competition NN 42759 965 11 is be VBZ 42759 965 12 even even RB 42759 965 13 roughly roughly RB 42759 965 14 approximated approximate VBN 42759 965 15 in in IN 42759 965 16 relation relation NN 42759 965 17 to to IN 42759 965 18 men man NNS 42759 965 19 who who WP 42759 965 20 operate operate VBP 42759 965 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 965 22 own own JJ 42759 965 23 land land NN 42759 965 24 , , , 42759 965 25 and and CC 42759 965 26 that that IN 42759 965 27 they -PRON- PRP 42759 965 28 generally generally RB 42759 965 29 obtain obtain VBP 42759 965 30 an an DT 42759 965 31 adequate adequate JJ 42759 965 32 return return NN 42759 965 33 for for IN 42759 965 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 965 35 labour labour NN 42759 965 36 in in IN 42759 965 37 addition addition NN 42759 965 38 to to IN 42759 965 39 the the DT 42759 965 40 sum sum NN 42759 965 41 that that WDT 42759 965 42 they -PRON- PRP 42759 965 43 might may MD 42759 965 44 have have VB 42759 965 45 obtained obtain VBN 42759 965 46 through through IN 42759 965 47 hiring hire VBG 42759 965 48 out out RP 42759 965 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 965 50 land land NN 42759 965 51 , , , 42759 965 52 may may MD 42759 965 53 appear appear VB 42759 965 54 rather rather RB 42759 965 55 violent violent JJ 42759 965 56 in in IN 42759 965 57 view view NN 42759 965 58 of of IN 42759 965 59 the the DT 42759 965 60 estimate estimate NN 42759 965 61 that that IN 42759 965 62 the the DT 42759 965 63 average average JJ 42759 965 64 farmer farmer NN 42759 965 65 in in IN 42759 965 66 the the DT 42759 965 67 United United NNP 42759 965 68 States States NNP 42759 965 69 gets get VBZ 42759 965 70 only only RB 42759 965 71 $ $ $ 42759 965 72 402 402 CD 42759 965 73 annually annually RB 42759 965 74 in in IN 42759 965 75 payment payment NN 42759 965 76 for for IN 42759 965 77 the the DT 42759 965 78 labour labour NN 42759 965 79 of of IN 42759 965 80 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 965 81 and and CC 42759 965 82 family family NN 42759 965 83 . . . 42759 966 1 See see VB 42759 966 2 article article NN 42759 966 3 on on IN 42759 966 4 " " `` 42759 966 5 The the DT 42759 966 6 Farmer Farmer NNP 42759 966 7 's 's POS 42759 966 8 Income Income NNP 42759 966 9 " " '' 42759 966 10 in in IN 42759 966 11 the the DT 42759 966 12 _ _ NNP 42759 966 13 American American NNP 42759 966 14 Economic Economic NNP 42759 966 15 Review Review NNP 42759 966 16 _ _ NNP 42759 966 17 , , , 42759 966 18 March March NNP 42759 966 19 , , , 42759 966 20 1916 1916 CD 42759 966 21 . . . 42759 967 1 However however RB 42759 967 2 , , , 42759 967 3 this this DT 42759 967 4 income income NN 42759 967 5 is be VBZ 42759 967 6 mostly mostly RB 42759 967 7 in in IN 42759 967 8 the the DT 42759 967 9 form form NN 42759 967 10 of of IN 42759 967 11 food food NN 42759 967 12 , , , 42759 967 13 fuel fuel NN 42759 967 14 , , , 42759 967 15 and and CC 42759 967 16 shelter shelter NN 42759 967 17 , , , 42759 967 18 which which WDT 42759 967 19 would would MD 42759 967 20 cost cost VB 42759 967 21 very very RB 42759 967 22 much much RB 42759 967 23 more more JJR 42759 967 24 in in IN 42759 967 25 the the DT 42759 967 26 city city NN 42759 967 27 ; ; : 42759 967 28 consequently consequently RB 42759 967 29 it -PRON- PRP 42759 967 30 is be VBZ 42759 967 31 probably probably RB 42759 967 32 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 967 33 to to IN 42759 967 34 an an DT 42759 967 35 urban urban JJ 42759 967 36 income income NN 42759 967 37 of of IN 42759 967 38 $ $ $ 42759 967 39 600 600 CD 42759 967 40 . . . 42759 968 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 968 2 value value NN 42759 968 3 is be VBZ 42759 968 4 still still RB 42759 968 5 further further RB 42759 968 6 enhanced enhance VBN 42759 968 7 by by IN 42759 968 8 the the DT 42759 968 9 farmer farmer NN 42759 968 10 's 's POS 42759 968 11 independent independent JJ 42759 968 12 position position NN 42759 968 13 , , , 42759 968 14 and and CC 42759 968 15 by by IN 42759 968 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 968 17 expectation expectation NN 42759 968 18 of of IN 42759 968 19 profiting profit VBG 42759 968 20 by by IN 42759 968 21 the the DT 42759 968 22 future future JJ 42759 968 23 increase increase NN 42759 968 24 of of IN 42759 968 25 land land NN 42759 968 26 values value NNS 42759 968 27 . . . 42759 969 1 Hence hence RB 42759 969 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 969 3 would would MD 42759 969 4 seem seem VB 42759 969 5 that that IN 42759 969 6 the the DT 42759 969 7 rent rent NN 42759 969 8 and and CC 42759 969 9 interest interest NN 42759 969 10 allowance allowance NN 42759 969 11 of of IN 42759 969 12 $ $ $ 42759 969 13 322 322 CD 42759 969 14 might may MD 42759 969 15 fairly fairly RB 42759 969 16 be be VB 42759 969 17 regarded regard VBN 42759 969 18 as as IN 42759 969 19 a a DT 42759 969 20 surplus surplus NN 42759 969 21 in in IN 42759 969 22 excess excess NN 42759 969 23 of of IN 42759 969 24 the the DT 42759 969 25 necessary necessary JJ 42759 969 26 payment payment NN 42759 969 27 for for IN 42759 969 28 labour labour NN 42759 969 29 . . . 42759 970 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 970 2 48 48 CD 42759 970 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 970 4 Chapter chapter NN 42759 970 5 xxii xxii NNP 42759 970 6 . . . 42759 971 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 42759 971 2 VII vii NN 42759 971 3 DEFECTS DEFECTS NNP 42759 971 4 OF of IN 42759 971 5 THE the DT 42759 971 6 EXISTING exist VBG 42759 971 7 LAND land NN 42759 971 8 SYSTEM system NN 42759 971 9 Starting start VBG 42759 971 10 from from IN 42759 971 11 the the DT 42759 971 12 principle principle NN 42759 971 13 that that IN 42759 971 14 the the DT 42759 971 15 rightness rightness NN 42759 971 16 or or CC 42759 971 17 wrongness wrongness NN 42759 971 18 of of IN 42759 971 19 any any DT 42759 971 20 system system NN 42759 971 21 of of IN 42759 971 22 land land NN 42759 971 23 tenure tenure NN 42759 971 24 is be VBZ 42759 971 25 determined determine VBN 42759 971 26 not not RB 42759 971 27 by by IN 42759 971 28 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 42759 971 29 and and CC 42759 971 30 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 971 31 considerations consideration NNS 42759 971 32 , , , 42759 971 33 but but CC 42759 971 34 by by IN 42759 971 35 the the DT 42759 971 36 effects effect NNS 42759 971 37 of of IN 42759 971 38 the the DT 42759 971 39 institution institution NN 42759 971 40 upon upon IN 42759 971 41 human human JJ 42759 971 42 welfare welfare NN 42759 971 43 , , , 42759 971 44 we -PRON- PRP 42759 971 45 arrived arrive VBD 42759 971 46 at at IN 42759 971 47 the the DT 42759 971 48 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 971 49 that that IN 42759 971 50 private private JJ 42759 971 51 landownership landownership NN 42759 971 52 is be VBZ 42759 971 53 not not RB 42759 971 54 unjust unjust JJ 42759 971 55 , , , 42759 971 56 so so RB 42759 971 57 long long RB 42759 971 58 as as IN 42759 971 59 no no DT 42759 971 60 better well JJR 42759 971 61 system system NN 42759 971 62 is be VBZ 42759 971 63 available available JJ 42759 971 64 . . . 42759 972 1 By by IN 42759 972 2 the the DT 42759 972 3 same same JJ 42759 972 4 test test NN 42759 972 5 of of IN 42759 972 6 human human JJ 42759 972 7 welfare welfare NN 42759 972 8 we -PRON- PRP 42759 972 9 found find VBD 42759 972 10 that that IN 42759 972 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 972 12 would would MD 42759 972 13 be be VB 42759 972 14 wrong wrong JJ 42759 972 15 to to TO 42759 972 16 substitute substitute VB 42759 972 17 a a DT 42759 972 18 better well JJR 42759 972 19 system system NN 42759 972 20 through through IN 42759 972 21 the the DT 42759 972 22 process process NN 42759 972 23 of of IN 42759 972 24 confiscating confiscate VBG 42759 972 25 rent rent NN 42759 972 26 , , , 42759 972 27 while while IN 42759 972 28 leaving leave VBG 42759 972 29 interest interest NN 42759 972 30 undisturbed undisturbed JJ 42759 972 31 . . . 42759 973 1 A a DT 42759 973 2 further further JJ 42759 973 3 step step NN 42759 973 4 brought bring VBD 42759 973 5 us -PRON- PRP 42759 973 6 to to IN 42759 973 7 the the DT 42759 973 8 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 973 9 that that IN 42759 973 10 complete complete JJ 42759 973 11 Socialism socialism NN 42759 973 12 would would MD 42759 973 13 certainly certainly RB 42759 973 14 , , , 42759 973 15 and and CC 42759 973 16 the the DT 42759 973 17 complete complete JJ 42759 973 18 Single Single NNP 42759 973 19 Tax Tax NNP 42759 973 20 probably probably RB 42759 973 21 , , , 42759 973 22 be be VB 42759 973 23 inferior inferior JJ 42759 973 24 to to IN 42759 973 25 the the DT 42759 973 26 present present JJ 42759 973 27 system system NN 42759 973 28 . . . 42759 974 1 As as IN 42759 974 2 a a DT 42759 974 3 sort sort NN 42759 974 4 of of IN 42759 974 5 corollary corollary JJ 42759 974 6 , , , 42759 974 7 the the DT 42759 974 8 social social JJ 42759 974 9 and and CC 42759 974 10 moral moral JJ 42759 974 11 superiority superiority NN 42759 974 12 of of IN 42759 974 13 private private JJ 42759 974 14 landownership landownership NN 42759 974 15 was be VBD 42759 974 16 stated state VBN 42759 974 17 in in IN 42759 974 18 terms term NNS 42759 974 19 of of IN 42759 974 20 natural natural JJ 42759 974 21 rights right NNS 42759 974 22 . . . 42759 975 1 Finally finally RB 42759 975 2 , , , 42759 975 3 the the DT 42759 975 4 question question NN 42759 975 5 was be VBD 42759 975 6 raised raise VBN 42759 975 7 whether whether IN 42759 975 8 the the DT 42759 975 9 landowner landowner NN 42759 975 10 has have VBZ 42759 975 11 a a DT 42759 975 12 right right NN 42759 975 13 to to TO 42759 975 14 take take VB 42759 975 15 rent rent NN 42759 975 16 , , , 42759 975 17 and and CC 42759 975 18 to to TO 42759 975 19 take take VB 42759 975 20 all all PDT 42759 975 21 the the DT 42759 975 22 rent rent NN 42759 975 23 . . . 42759 976 1 In in IN 42759 976 2 stating state VBG 42759 976 3 the the DT 42759 976 4 superiority superiority NN 42759 976 5 of of IN 42759 976 6 the the DT 42759 976 7 present present JJ 42759 976 8 system system NN 42759 976 9 , , , 42759 976 10 we -PRON- PRP 42759 976 11 explicitly explicitly RB 42759 976 12 noted note VBD 42759 976 13 that that IN 42759 976 14 we -PRON- PRP 42759 976 15 had have VBD 42759 976 16 in in IN 42759 976 17 mind mind NN 42759 976 18 the the DT 42759 976 19 system system NN 42759 976 20 as as IN 42759 976 21 capable capable JJ 42759 976 22 of of IN 42759 976 23 improvement improvement NN 42759 976 24 . . . 42759 977 1 This this DT 42759 977 2 implied imply VBD 42759 977 3 that that IN 42759 977 4 there there EX 42759 977 5 are be VBP 42759 977 6 defects defect NNS 42759 977 7 in in IN 42759 977 8 the the DT 42759 977 9 present present JJ 42759 977 10 form form NN 42759 977 11 of of IN 42759 977 12 land land NN 42759 977 13 tenure tenure NN 42759 977 14 , , , 42759 977 15 and and CC 42759 977 16 that that IN 42759 977 17 these these DT 42759 977 18 can can MD 42759 977 19 be be VB 42759 977 20 eliminated eliminate VBN 42759 977 21 in in IN 42759 977 22 such such PDT 42759 977 23 a a DT 42759 977 24 way way NN 42759 977 25 as as IN 42759 977 26 to to TO 42759 977 27 make make VB 42759 977 28 the the DT 42759 977 29 system system NN 42759 977 30 more more RBR 42759 977 31 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 977 32 and and CC 42759 977 33 more more RBR 42759 977 34 in in IN 42759 977 35 harmony harmony NN 42759 977 36 with with IN 42759 977 37 the the DT 42759 977 38 principles principle NNS 42759 977 39 of of IN 42759 977 40 justice justice NN 42759 977 41 . . . 42759 978 1 In in IN 42759 978 2 the the DT 42759 978 3 present present JJ 42759 978 4 chapter chapter NN 42759 978 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 978 6 shall shall MD 42759 978 7 give give VB 42759 978 8 a a DT 42759 978 9 summary summary NN 42759 978 10 review review NN 42759 978 11 of of IN 42759 978 12 the the DT 42759 978 13 principal principal JJ 42759 978 14 defects defect NNS 42759 978 15 , , , 42759 978 16 and and CC 42759 978 17 in in IN 42759 978 18 the the DT 42759 978 19 following following JJ 42759 978 20 chapter chapter NN 42759 978 21 we -PRON- PRP 42759 978 22 shall shall MD 42759 978 23 suggest suggest VB 42759 978 24 some some DT 42759 978 25 methods method NNS 42759 978 26 of of IN 42759 978 27 reform reform NN 42759 978 28 . . . 42759 979 1 All all PDT 42759 979 2 the the DT 42759 979 3 defects defect NNS 42759 979 4 and and CC 42759 979 5 abuses abuse NNS 42759 979 6 may may MD 42759 979 7 conveniently conveniently RB 42759 979 8 be be VB 42759 979 9 grouped group VBN 42759 979 10 under under IN 42759 979 11 three three CD 42759 979 12 heads head NNS 42759 979 13 : : : 42759 979 14 Monopoly Monopoly NNP 42759 979 15 ; ; : 42759 979 16 Excessive Excessive NNP 42759 979 17 Gains gain NNS 42759 979 18 ; ; : 42759 979 19 and and CC 42759 979 20 Exclusion exclusion NN 42759 979 21 from from IN 42759 979 22 the the DT 42759 979 23 Land land NN 42759 979 24 . . . 42759 980 1 _ _ NNP 42759 980 2 Landownership Landownership NNP 42759 980 3 and and CC 42759 980 4 Monopoly Monopoly NNP 42759 980 5 _ _ NNP 42759 980 6 In in IN 42759 980 7 the the DT 42759 980 8 literature literature NN 42759 980 9 of of IN 42759 980 10 the the DT 42759 980 11 Single Single NNP 42759 980 12 Tax Tax NNP 42759 980 13 movement movement NN 42759 980 14 the the DT 42759 980 15 phrase phrase NN 42759 980 16 , , , 42759 980 17 " " `` 42759 980 18 land land NN 42759 980 19 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 980 20 , , , 42759 980 21 " " '' 42759 980 22 is be VBZ 42759 980 23 constantly constantly RB 42759 980 24 recurring recur VBG 42759 980 25 . . . 42759 981 1 The the DT 42759 981 2 expression expression NN 42759 981 3 is be VBZ 42759 981 4 inaccurate inaccurate JJ 42759 981 5 ; ; : 42759 981 6 for for IN 42759 981 7 the the DT 42759 981 8 system system NN 42759 981 9 of of IN 42759 981 10 individual individual JJ 42759 981 11 landownership landownership NN 42759 981 12 does do VBZ 42759 981 13 not not RB 42759 981 14 conform conform VB 42759 981 15 to to IN 42759 981 16 the the DT 42759 981 17 requirements requirement NNS 42759 981 18 of of IN 42759 981 19 a a DT 42759 981 20 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 981 21 . . . 42759 982 1 There there EX 42759 982 2 is be VBZ 42759 982 3 , , , 42759 982 4 indeed indeed RB 42759 982 5 , , , 42759 982 6 a a DT 42759 982 7 certain certain JJ 42759 982 8 resemblance resemblance NN 42759 982 9 between between IN 42759 982 10 the the DT 42759 982 11 control control NN 42759 982 12 exercised exercise VBN 42759 982 13 by by IN 42759 982 14 the the DT 42759 982 15 owner owner NN 42759 982 16 of of IN 42759 982 17 land land NN 42759 982 18 and and CC 42759 982 19 that that IN 42759 982 20 possessed possess VBN 42759 982 21 by by IN 42759 982 22 the the DT 42759 982 23 monopolist monopolist NN 42759 982 24 . . . 42759 983 1 As as IN 42759 983 2 the the DT 42759 983 3 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 983 4 of of IN 42759 983 5 every every DT 42759 983 6 superior superior JJ 42759 983 7 soil soil NN 42759 983 8 or or CC 42759 983 9 site site NN 42759 983 10 has have VBZ 42759 983 11 an an DT 42759 983 12 economic economic JJ 42759 983 13 advantage advantage NN 42759 983 14 over over IN 42759 983 15 the the DT 42759 983 16 owner owner NN 42759 983 17 of of IN 42759 983 18 the the DT 42759 983 19 poorest poor JJS 42759 983 20 soil soil NN 42759 983 21 or or CC 42759 983 22 site site NN 42759 983 23 , , , 42759 983 24 so so IN 42759 983 25 the the DT 42759 983 26 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 983 27 of of IN 42759 983 28 a a DT 42759 983 29 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 983 30 business business NN 42759 983 31 obtains obtain VBZ 42759 983 32 larger large JJR 42759 983 33 gains gain NNS 42759 983 34 than than IN 42759 983 35 the the DT 42759 983 36 man man NN 42759 983 37 who who WP 42759 983 38 must must MD 42759 983 39 operate operate VB 42759 983 40 in in IN 42759 983 41 conditions condition NNS 42759 983 42 of of IN 42759 983 43 competition competition NN 42759 983 44 . . . 42759 984 1 In in IN 42759 984 2 both both DT 42759 984 3 cases case NNS 42759 984 4 the the DT 42759 984 5 advantage advantage NN 42759 984 6 is be VBZ 42759 984 7 based base VBN 42759 984 8 upon upon IN 42759 984 9 the the DT 42759 984 10 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 984 11 of of IN 42759 984 12 the the DT 42759 984 13 thing thing NN 42759 984 14 controlled control VBN 42759 984 15 , , , 42759 984 16 and and CC 42759 984 17 the the DT 42759 984 18 extent extent NN 42759 984 19 of of IN 42759 984 20 the the DT 42759 984 21 advantage advantage NN 42759 984 22 is be VBZ 42759 984 23 measured measure VBN 42759 984 24 by by IN 42759 984 25 the the DT 42759 984 26 degree degree NN 42759 984 27 of of IN 42759 984 28 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 984 29 . . . 42759 985 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 985 2 , , , 42759 985 3 there there EX 42759 985 4 is be VBZ 42759 985 5 an an DT 42759 985 6 important important JJ 42759 985 7 difference difference NN 42759 985 8 between between IN 42759 985 9 landownership landownership NN 42759 985 10 and and CC 42759 985 11 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 985 12 . . . 42759 986 1 The the DT 42759 986 2 latter latter NN 42759 986 3 is be VBZ 42759 986 4 usually usually RB 42759 986 5 defined define VBN 42759 986 6 as as IN 42759 986 7 that that DT 42759 986 8 degree degree NN 42759 986 9 of of IN 42759 986 10 unified unified JJ 42759 986 11 control control NN 42759 986 12 which which WDT 42759 986 13 enables enable VBZ 42759 986 14 the the DT 42759 986 15 persons person NNS 42759 986 16 in in IN 42759 986 17 control control NN 42759 986 18 arbitrarily arbitrarily RB 42759 986 19 to to TO 42759 986 20 limit limit VB 42759 986 21 supply supply NN 42759 986 22 and and CC 42759 986 23 raise raise VB 42759 986 24 price price NN 42759 986 25 . . . 42759 987 1 As as IN 42759 987 2 a a DT 42759 987 3 rule rule NN 42759 987 4 , , , 42759 987 5 no no DT 42759 987 6 such such JJ 42759 987 7 power power NN 42759 987 8 is be VBZ 42759 987 9 exercised exercise VBN 42759 987 10 by by IN 42759 987 11 individuals individual NNS 42759 987 12 , , , 42759 987 13 or or CC 42759 987 14 by by IN 42759 987 15 combinations combination NNS 42759 987 16 of of IN 42759 987 17 individuals individual NNS 42759 987 18 with with IN 42759 987 19 regard regard NN 42759 987 20 to to IN 42759 987 21 land land NN 42759 987 22 . . . 42759 988 1 The the DT 42759 988 2 pecuniary pecuniary JJ 42759 988 3 advantage advantage NN 42759 988 4 possessed possess VBN 42759 988 5 by by IN 42759 988 6 the the DT 42759 988 7 landowner landowner NN 42759 988 8 , , , 42759 988 9 that that RB 42759 988 10 is is RB 42759 988 11 , , , 42759 988 12 the the DT 42759 988 13 power power NN 42759 988 14 to to TO 42759 988 15 take take VB 42759 988 16 rent rent NN 42759 988 17 , , , 42759 988 18 is be VBZ 42759 988 19 conferred confer VBN 42759 988 20 and and CC 42759 988 21 determined determine VBN 42759 988 22 by by IN 42759 988 23 influences influence NNS 42759 988 24 outside outside RB 42759 988 25 of of IN 42759 988 26 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 988 27 , , , 42759 988 28 by by IN 42759 988 29 the the DT 42759 988 30 natural natural JJ 42759 988 31 superiority superiority NN 42759 988 32 of of IN 42759 988 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 988 34 land land NN 42759 988 35 , , , 42759 988 36 or or CC 42759 988 37 by by IN 42759 988 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 988 39 proximity proximity NN 42759 988 40 to to IN 42759 988 41 a a DT 42759 988 42 city city NN 42759 988 43 . . . 42759 989 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 989 2 can can MD 42759 989 3 neither neither CC 42759 989 4 diminish diminish VB 42759 989 5 the the DT 42759 989 6 amount amount NN 42759 989 7 of of IN 42759 989 8 land land NN 42759 989 9 in in IN 42759 989 10 existence existence NN 42759 989 11 nor nor CC 42759 989 12 raise raise VB 42759 989 13 the the DT 42759 989 14 price price NN 42759 989 15 of of IN 42759 989 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 989 17 own own JJ 42759 989 18 . . . 42759 990 1 The the DT 42759 990 2 former former JJ 42759 990 3 result result NN 42759 990 4 is be VBZ 42759 990 5 inhibited inhibit VBN 42759 990 6 by by IN 42759 990 7 nature nature NN 42759 990 8 ; ; : 42759 990 9 the the DT 42759 990 10 latter latter JJ 42759 990 11 by by IN 42759 990 12 the the DT 42759 990 13 competition competition NN 42759 990 14 of of IN 42759 990 15 other other JJ 42759 990 16 persons person NNS 42759 990 17 who who WP 42759 990 18 own own VBP 42759 990 19 the the DT 42759 990 20 same same JJ 42759 990 21 kind kind NN 42759 990 22 of of IN 42759 990 23 land land NN 42759 990 24 . . . 42759 991 1 To to TO 42759 991 2 be be VB 42759 991 3 sure sure JJ 42759 991 4 , , , 42759 991 5 there there EX 42759 991 6 are be VBP 42759 991 7 certain certain JJ 42759 991 8 kinds kind NNS 42759 991 9 of of IN 42759 991 10 land land NN 42759 991 11 which which WDT 42759 991 12 are be VBP 42759 991 13 so so RB 42759 991 14 scarce scarce JJ 42759 991 15 and and CC 42759 991 16 so so RB 42759 991 17 concentrated concentrate VBD 42759 991 18 that that IN 42759 991 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 991 20 do do VBP 42759 991 21 fall fall VB 42759 991 22 under under IN 42759 991 23 true true JJ 42759 991 24 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 991 25 control control NN 42759 991 26 . . . 42759 992 1 Such such JJ 42759 992 2 are be VBP 42759 992 3 the the DT 42759 992 4 anthracite anthracite NN 42759 992 5 coal coal NN 42759 992 6 mines mine NNS 42759 992 7 of of IN 42759 992 8 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP 42759 992 9 , , , 42759 992 10 and and CC 42759 992 11 some some DT 42759 992 12 peculiarly peculiarly RB 42759 992 13 situated situate VBN 42759 992 14 plots plot NNS 42759 992 15 in in IN 42759 992 16 a a DT 42759 992 17 few few JJ 42759 992 18 great great JJ 42759 992 19 cities city NNS 42759 992 20 , , , 42759 992 21 for for IN 42759 992 22 example example NN 42759 992 23 , , , 42759 992 24 land land NN 42759 992 25 that that WDT 42759 992 26 is be VBZ 42759 992 27 desired desire VBN 42759 992 28 for for IN 42759 992 29 a a DT 42759 992 30 railway railway NN 42759 992 31 terminal terminal NN 42759 992 32 . . . 42759 993 1 But but CC 42759 993 2 these these DT 42759 993 3 instances instance NNS 42759 993 4 are be VBP 42759 993 5 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 993 6 . . . 42759 994 1 The the DT 42759 994 2 general general JJ 42759 994 3 fact fact NN 42759 994 4 is be VBZ 42759 994 5 that that IN 42759 994 6 the the DT 42759 994 7 owners owner NNS 42759 994 8 of of IN 42759 994 9 any any DT 42759 994 10 kind kind NN 42759 994 11 of of IN 42759 994 12 land land NN 42759 994 13 are be VBP 42759 994 14 in in IN 42759 994 15 competition competition NN 42759 994 16 with with IN 42759 994 17 similar similar JJ 42759 994 18 owners owner NNS 42759 994 19 . . . 42759 995 1 While while IN 42759 995 2 the the DT 42759 995 3 element element NN 42759 995 4 of of IN 42759 995 5 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 995 6 is be VBZ 42759 995 7 common common JJ 42759 995 8 to to TO 42759 995 9 landownership landownership NN 42759 995 10 and and CC 42759 995 11 to to IN 42759 995 12 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 995 13 , , , 42759 995 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 995 15 differs differ VBZ 42759 995 16 in in IN 42759 995 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 995 18 operation operation NN 42759 995 19 . . . 42759 996 1 In in IN 42759 996 2 the the DT 42759 996 3 case case NN 42759 996 4 of of IN 42759 996 5 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 996 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 996 7 is be VBZ 42759 996 8 subject subject JJ 42759 996 9 , , , 42759 996 10 within within IN 42759 996 11 limits limit NNS 42759 996 12 , , , 42759 996 13 to to IN 42759 996 14 the the DT 42759 996 15 human human NN 42759 996 16 will will NN 42759 996 17 . . . 42759 997 1 This this DT 42759 997 2 difference difference NN 42759 997 3 is be VBZ 42759 997 4 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 997 5 important important JJ 42759 997 6 , , , 42759 997 7 both both DT 42759 997 8 theoretically theoretically RB 42759 997 9 and and CC 42759 997 10 practically practically RB 42759 997 11 , , , 42759 997 12 to to TO 42759 997 13 forbid forbid VB 42759 997 14 the the DT 42759 997 15 identification identification NN 42759 997 16 or or CC 42759 997 17 confusion confusion NN 42759 997 18 of of IN 42759 997 19 landownership landownership NN 42759 997 20 with with IN 42759 997 21 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 997 22 . . . 42759 998 1 A a DT 42759 998 2 notable notable JJ 42759 998 3 illustration illustration NN 42759 998 4 of of IN 42759 998 5 such such JJ 42759 998 6 confusion confusion NN 42759 998 7 is be VBZ 42759 998 8 the the DT 42759 998 9 volume volume NN 42759 998 10 by by IN 42759 998 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 42759 998 12 F. F. NNP 42759 998 13 C. C. NNP 42759 998 14 Howe Howe NNP 42759 998 15 , , , 42759 998 16 entitled entitle VBN 42759 998 17 , , , 42759 998 18 " " `` 42759 998 19 Privilege Privilege NNP 42759 998 20 and and CC 42759 998 21 Democracy Democracy NNP 42759 998 22 in in IN 42759 998 23 America America NNP 42759 998 24 . . . 42759 998 25 " " '' 42759 999 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 999 2 maintains maintain VBZ 42759 999 3 that that IN 42759 999 4 bituminous bituminous JJ 42759 999 5 coal coal NN 42759 999 6 , , , 42759 999 7 copper copper NN 42759 999 8 ore ore NN 42759 999 9 , , , 42759 999 10 and and CC 42759 999 11 natural natural JJ 42759 999 12 gas gas NN 42759 999 13 are be VBP 42759 999 14 true true JJ 42759 999 15 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 999 16 , , , 42759 999 17 but but CC 42759 999 18 gives give VBZ 42759 999 19 no no DT 42759 999 20 adequate adequate JJ 42759 999 21 proof proof NN 42759 999 22 to to TO 42759 999 23 support support VB 42759 999 24 this this DT 42759 999 25 assertion assertion NN 42759 999 26 . . . 42759 1000 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 1000 2 , , , 42759 1000 3 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1000 4 exaggerates exaggerate VBZ 42759 1000 5 considerably considerably RB 42759 1000 6 the the DT 42759 1000 7 part part NN 42759 1000 8 played play VBN 42759 1000 9 by by IN 42759 1000 10 landownership landownership NN 42759 1000 11 in in IN 42759 1000 12 the the DT 42759 1000 13 formation formation NN 42759 1000 14 of of IN 42759 1000 15 industrial industrial JJ 42759 1000 16 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 1000 17 . . . 42759 1001 1 Thus thus RB 42759 1001 2 , , , 42759 1001 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1001 4 contention contention NN 42759 1001 5 that that IN 42759 1001 6 the the DT 42759 1001 7 petroleum petroleum NN 42759 1001 8 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1001 9 is be VBZ 42759 1001 10 due due JJ 42759 1001 11 to to IN 42759 1001 12 ownership ownership NN 42759 1001 13 of of IN 42759 1001 14 oil oil NN 42759 1001 15 - - HYPH 42759 1001 16 producing produce VBG 42759 1001 17 lands land NNS 42759 1001 18 is be VBZ 42759 1001 19 certainly certainly RB 42759 1001 20 incorrect incorrect JJ 42759 1001 21 ; ; : 42759 1001 22 for for IN 42759 1001 23 the the DT 42759 1001 24 Standard Standard NNP 42759 1001 25 Oil Oil NNP 42759 1001 26 Company Company NNP 42759 1001 27 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1001 28 or or CC 42759 1001 29 companies company NNS 42759 1001 30 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1001 31 has have VBZ 42759 1001 32 never never RB 42759 1001 33 controlled control VBN 42759 1001 34 as as RB 42759 1001 35 much much JJ 42759 1001 36 as as IN 42759 1001 37 half half PDT 42759 1001 38 the the DT 42759 1001 39 supply supply NN 42759 1001 40 of of IN 42759 1001 41 raw raw JJ 42759 1001 42 material material NN 42759 1001 43 . . . 42759 1002 1 " " `` 42759 1002 2 The the DT 42759 1002 3 power power NN 42759 1002 4 of of IN 42759 1002 5 the the DT 42759 1002 6 Standard Standard NNP 42759 1002 7 does do VBZ 42759 1002 8 not not RB 42759 1002 9 rest rest VB 42759 1002 10 upon upon IN 42759 1002 11 a a DT 42759 1002 12 direct direct JJ 42759 1002 13 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1002 14 of of IN 42759 1002 15 the the DT 42759 1002 16 production production NN 42759 1002 17 of of IN 42759 1002 18 crude crude JJ 42759 1002 19 oil oil NN 42759 1002 20 through through IN 42759 1002 21 ownership ownership NN 42759 1002 22 of of IN 42759 1002 23 the the DT 42759 1002 24 wells well NNS 42759 1002 25 . . . 42759 1003 1 " " `` 42759 1003 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1003 3 49 49 CD 42759 1003 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1003 5 Perhaps perhaps RB 42759 1003 6 the the DT 42759 1003 7 most most RBS 42759 1003 8 remarkable remarkable JJ 42759 1003 9 misstatement misstatement NN 42759 1003 10 in in IN 42759 1003 11 the the DT 42759 1003 12 volume volume NN 42759 1003 13 is be VBZ 42759 1003 14 this this DT 42759 1003 15 : : : 42759 1003 16 " " `` 42759 1003 17 The the DT 42759 1003 18 railway railway NN 42759 1003 19 is be VBZ 42759 1003 20 a a DT 42759 1003 21 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1003 22 because because IN 42759 1003 23 of of IN 42759 1003 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1003 25 identity identity NN 42759 1003 26 with with IN 42759 1003 27 land land NN 42759 1003 28 . . . 42759 1004 1 " " `` 42759 1004 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1004 3 50 50 CD 42759 1004 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1004 5 Now now RB 42759 1004 6 there there EX 42759 1004 7 are be VBP 42759 1004 8 a a DT 42759 1004 9 few few JJ 42759 1004 10 important important JJ 42759 1004 11 railway railway NN 42759 1004 12 lines line NNS 42759 1004 13 traversing traverse VBG 42759 1004 14 routes route NNS 42759 1004 15 or or CC 42759 1004 16 possessing possess VBG 42759 1004 17 terminal terminal JJ 42759 1004 18 sites site NNS 42759 1004 19 which which WDT 42759 1004 20 are be VBP 42759 1004 21 so so RB 42759 1004 22 much much RB 42759 1004 23 better well JJR 42759 1004 24 than than IN 42759 1004 25 any any DT 42759 1004 26 alternative alternative JJ 42759 1004 27 routes route NNS 42759 1004 28 or or CC 42759 1004 29 sites site NNS 42759 1004 30 as as IN 42759 1004 31 to to TO 42759 1004 32 give give VB 42759 1004 33 all all PDT 42759 1004 34 the the DT 42759 1004 35 advantages advantage NNS 42759 1004 36 of of IN 42759 1004 37 a a DT 42759 1004 38 true true JJ 42759 1004 39 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1004 40 . . . 42759 1005 1 But but CC 42759 1005 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1005 3 are be VBP 42759 1005 4 in in IN 42759 1005 5 a a DT 42759 1005 6 small small JJ 42759 1005 7 minority minority NN 42759 1005 8 . . . 42759 1006 1 In in IN 42759 1006 2 the the DT 42759 1006 3 great great JJ 42759 1006 4 majority majority NN 42759 1006 5 of of IN 42759 1006 6 cases case NNS 42759 1006 7 , , , 42759 1006 8 a a DT 42759 1006 9 second second JJ 42759 1006 10 parallel parallel JJ 42759 1006 11 strip strip NN 42759 1006 12 or or CC 42759 1006 13 parallel parallel JJ 42759 1006 14 site site NN 42759 1006 15 could could MD 42759 1006 16 be be VB 42759 1006 17 found find VBN 42759 1006 18 which which WDT 42759 1006 19 would would MD 42759 1006 20 be be VB 42759 1006 21 equally equally RB 42759 1006 22 or or CC 42759 1006 23 almost almost RB 42759 1006 24 equally equally RB 42759 1006 25 suitable suitable JJ 42759 1006 26 . . . 42759 1007 1 Neither neither CC 42759 1007 2 the the DT 42759 1007 3 amount amount NN 42759 1007 4 nor nor CC 42759 1007 5 the the DT 42759 1007 6 kind kind NN 42759 1007 7 of of IN 42759 1007 8 land land NN 42759 1007 9 owned own VBN 42759 1007 10 by by IN 42759 1007 11 a a DT 42759 1007 12 railroad railroad NN 42759 1007 13 , , , 42759 1007 14 nor nor CC 42759 1007 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1007 16 legal legal JJ 42759 1007 17 privilege privilege NN 42759 1007 18 of of IN 42759 1007 19 holding hold VBG 42759 1007 20 land land NN 42759 1007 21 in in IN 42759 1007 22 a a DT 42759 1007 23 long long JJ 42759 1007 24 , , , 42759 1007 25 continuous continuous JJ 42759 1007 26 strip strip NN 42759 1007 27 , , , 42759 1007 28 is be VBZ 42759 1007 29 the the DT 42759 1007 30 efficient efficient JJ 42759 1007 31 cause cause NN 42759 1007 32 of of IN 42759 1007 33 a a DT 42759 1007 34 railway railway NN 42759 1007 35 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1007 36 . . . 42759 1008 1 To to TO 42759 1008 2 attribute attribute VB 42759 1008 3 the the DT 42759 1008 4 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1008 5 to to IN 42759 1008 6 land land NN 42759 1008 7 is be VBZ 42759 1008 8 to to TO 42759 1008 9 confound confound VB 42759 1008 10 a a DT 42759 1008 11 condition condition NN 42759 1008 12 with with IN 42759 1008 13 a a DT 42759 1008 14 cause cause NN 42759 1008 15 . . . 42759 1009 1 One one CD 42759 1009 2 might may MD 42759 1009 3 as as RB 42759 1009 4 well well RB 42759 1009 5 say say VB 42759 1009 6 that that IN 42759 1009 7 the the DT 42759 1009 8 land land NN 42759 1009 9 underlying underlie VBG 42759 1009 10 the the DT 42759 1009 11 " " `` 42759 1009 12 wheat wheat NN 42759 1009 13 king king NN 42759 1009 14 's 's POS 42759 1009 15 " " `` 42759 1009 16 office office NN 42759 1009 17 is be VBZ 42759 1009 18 the the DT 42759 1009 19 cause cause NN 42759 1009 20 of of IN 42759 1009 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1009 22 corner corner NN 42759 1009 23 in in IN 42759 1009 24 wheat wheat NN 42759 1009 25 . . . 42759 1010 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1010 2 is be VBZ 42759 1010 3 true true JJ 42759 1010 4 that that IN 42759 1010 5 in in IN 42759 1010 6 a a DT 42759 1010 7 few few JJ 42759 1010 8 of of IN 42759 1010 9 the the DT 42759 1010 10 great great JJ 42759 1010 11 cities city NNS 42759 1010 12 the the DT 42759 1010 13 existing exist VBG 42759 1010 14 railroads railroad NNS 42759 1010 15 may may MD 42759 1010 16 , , , 42759 1010 17 through through IN 42759 1010 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1010 19 ownership ownership NN 42759 1010 20 of of IN 42759 1010 21 all all PDT 42759 1010 22 the the DT 42759 1010 23 suitable suitable JJ 42759 1010 24 terminal terminal NN 42759 1010 25 sites site NNS 42759 1010 26 , , , 42759 1010 27 prevent prevent VB 42759 1010 28 the the DT 42759 1010 29 entrance entrance NN 42759 1010 30 of of IN 42759 1010 31 a a DT 42759 1010 32 competing compete VBG 42759 1010 33 line line NN 42759 1010 34 . . . 42759 1011 1 In in IN 42759 1011 2 the the DT 42759 1011 3 first first JJ 42759 1011 4 place place NN 42759 1011 5 , , , 42759 1011 6 such such JJ 42759 1011 7 instances instance NNS 42759 1011 8 are be VBP 42759 1011 9 rare rare JJ 42759 1011 10 ; ; : 42759 1011 11 in in IN 42759 1011 12 the the DT 42759 1011 13 second second JJ 42759 1011 14 place place NN 42759 1011 15 , , , 42759 1011 16 the the DT 42759 1011 17 fact fact NN 42759 1011 18 that that IN 42759 1011 19 there there EX 42759 1011 20 are be VBP 42759 1011 21 several several JJ 42759 1011 22 roads road NNS 42759 1011 23 already already RB 42759 1011 24 in in IN 42759 1011 25 existence existence NN 42759 1011 26 shows show VBZ 42759 1011 27 that that IN 42759 1011 28 competition competition NN 42759 1011 29 was be VBD 42759 1011 30 possible possible JJ 42759 1011 31 without without IN 42759 1011 32 the the DT 42759 1011 33 entrance entrance NN 42759 1011 34 of of IN 42759 1011 35 another another DT 42759 1011 36 one one NN 42759 1011 37 . . . 42759 1012 1 The the DT 42759 1012 2 influence influence NN 42759 1012 3 impelling impel VBG 42759 1012 4 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1012 5 to to TO 42759 1012 6 form form VB 42759 1012 7 a a DT 42759 1012 8 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1012 9 for for IN 42759 1012 10 the the DT 42759 1012 11 regulation regulation NN 42759 1012 12 of of IN 42759 1012 13 charges charge NNS 42759 1012 14 is be VBZ 42759 1012 15 not not RB 42759 1012 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1012 17 ownership ownership NN 42759 1012 18 of of IN 42759 1012 19 terminal terminal JJ 42759 1012 20 sites site NNS 42759 1012 21 . . . 42759 1013 1 No no DT 42759 1013 2 sort sort NN 42759 1013 3 of of IN 42759 1013 4 uniform uniform JJ 42759 1013 5 action action NN 42759 1013 6 with with IN 42759 1013 7 regard regard NN 42759 1013 8 to to IN 42759 1013 9 terminals terminal NNS 42759 1013 10 would would MD 42759 1013 11 produce produce VB 42759 1013 12 any any DT 42759 1013 13 such such JJ 42759 1013 14 effect effect NN 42759 1013 15 . . . 42759 1014 1 The the DT 42759 1014 2 true true JJ 42759 1014 3 source source NN 42759 1014 4 of of IN 42759 1014 5 the the DT 42759 1014 6 monopoly monopoly NNP 42759 1014 7 element element NN 42759 1014 8 in in IN 42759 1014 9 railways railway NNS 42759 1014 10 is be VBZ 42759 1014 11 inherent inherent JJ 42759 1014 12 in in IN 42759 1014 13 the the DT 42759 1014 14 industry industry NN 42759 1014 15 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 1014 16 . . . 42759 1015 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1015 2 is be VBZ 42759 1015 3 the the DT 42759 1015 4 fact fact NN 42759 1015 5 of of IN 42759 1015 6 " " `` 42759 1015 7 increasing increase VBG 42759 1015 8 returns return NNS 42759 1015 9 , , , 42759 1015 10 " " '' 42759 1015 11 which which WDT 42759 1015 12 means mean VBZ 42759 1015 13 that that IN 42759 1015 14 each each DT 42759 1015 15 additional additional JJ 42759 1015 16 increment increment NN 42759 1015 17 of of IN 42759 1015 18 business business NN 42759 1015 19 is be VBZ 42759 1015 20 more more RBR 42759 1015 21 profitable profitable JJ 42759 1015 22 than than IN 42759 1015 23 the the DT 42759 1015 24 preceding precede VBG 42759 1015 25 one one CD 42759 1015 26 , , , 42759 1015 27 and and CC 42759 1015 28 that that IN 42759 1015 29 in in IN 42759 1015 30 most most JJS 42759 1015 31 cases case NNS 42759 1015 32 this this DT 42759 1015 33 process process NN 42759 1015 34 can can MD 42759 1015 35 be be VB 42759 1015 36 kept keep VBN 42759 1015 37 up up RP 42759 1015 38 indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 1015 39 . . . 42759 1016 1 As as IN 42759 1016 2 a a DT 42759 1016 3 consequence consequence NN 42759 1016 4 , , , 42759 1016 5 each each DT 42759 1016 6 of of IN 42759 1016 7 two two CD 42759 1016 8 or or CC 42759 1016 9 more more JJR 42759 1016 10 railroads railroad NNS 42759 1016 11 between between IN 42759 1016 12 two two CD 42759 1016 13 points point NNS 42759 1016 14 strives strive NNS 42759 1016 15 to to TO 42759 1016 16 get get VB 42759 1016 17 all all PDT 42759 1016 18 the the DT 42759 1016 19 traffic traffic NN 42759 1016 20 ; ; : 42759 1016 21 then then RB 42759 1016 22 follows follow VBZ 42759 1016 23 unprofitable unprofitable JJ 42759 1016 24 rate rate NN 42759 1016 25 cutting cutting NN 42759 1016 26 , , , 42759 1016 27 and and CC 42759 1016 28 finally finally RB 42759 1016 29 combination combination NN 42759 1016 30 . . . 42759 1017 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1017 2 51 51 CD 42759 1017 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1017 4 The the DT 42759 1017 5 same same JJ 42759 1017 6 forces force NNS 42759 1017 7 would would MD 42759 1017 8 produce produce VB 42759 1017 9 identical identical JJ 42759 1017 10 results result NNS 42759 1017 11 if if IN 42759 1017 12 railroad railroad NN 42759 1017 13 tracks track NNS 42759 1017 14 and and CC 42759 1017 15 terminals terminal NNS 42759 1017 16 were be VBD 42759 1017 17 suspended suspend VBN 42759 1017 18 in in IN 42759 1017 19 the the DT 42759 1017 20 air air NN 42759 1017 21 . . . 42759 1018 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 42759 1018 2 Howe Howe NNP 42759 1018 3 asserts assert VBZ 42759 1018 4 that that IN 42759 1018 5 the the DT 42759 1018 6 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 1018 7 character character NN 42759 1018 8 of of IN 42759 1018 9 such such JJ 42759 1018 10 public public JJ 42759 1018 11 utility utility NN 42759 1018 12 corporations corporation NNS 42759 1018 13 as as IN 42759 1018 14 street street NN 42759 1018 15 railways railway NNS 42759 1018 16 and and CC 42759 1018 17 telephone telephone NN 42759 1018 18 companies company NNS 42759 1018 19 is be VBZ 42759 1018 20 due due JJ 42759 1018 21 to to IN 42759 1018 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1018 23 occupation occupation NN 42759 1018 24 of of IN 42759 1018 25 " " `` 42759 1018 26 favoured favour VBN 42759 1018 27 sites site NNS 42759 1018 28 . . . 42759 1019 1 " " `` 42759 1019 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1019 3 52 52 CD 42759 1019 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1019 5 How how WRB 42759 1019 6 can can MD 42759 1019 7 this this DT 42759 1019 8 be be VB 42759 1019 9 true true JJ 42759 1019 10 , , , 42759 1019 11 when when WRB 42759 1019 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1019 13 is be VBZ 42759 1019 14 possible possible JJ 42759 1019 15 to to TO 42759 1019 16 build build VB 42759 1019 17 a a DT 42759 1019 18 competing compete VBG 42759 1019 19 line line NN 42759 1019 20 on on IN 42759 1019 21 an an DT 42759 1019 22 adjoining adjoining JJ 42759 1019 23 and and CC 42759 1019 24 parallel parallel JJ 42759 1019 25 street street NN 42759 1019 26 ? ? . 42759 1020 1 If if IN 42759 1020 2 the the DT 42759 1020 3 city city NN 42759 1020 4 forbids forbid VBZ 42759 1020 5 this this DT 42759 1020 6 , , , 42759 1020 7 and and CC 42759 1020 8 gives give VBZ 42759 1020 9 an an DT 42759 1020 10 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 1020 11 franchise franchise NN 42759 1020 12 to to IN 42759 1020 13 one one CD 42759 1020 14 company company NN 42759 1020 15 , , , 42759 1020 16 this this DT 42759 1020 17 legal legal JJ 42759 1020 18 ordinance ordinance NN 42759 1020 19 , , , 42759 1020 20 and and CC 42759 1020 21 not not RB 42759 1020 22 any any DT 42759 1020 23 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 1020 24 advantage advantage NN 42759 1020 25 in in IN 42759 1020 26 the the DT 42759 1020 27 nature nature NN 42759 1020 28 of of IN 42759 1020 29 the the DT 42759 1020 30 land land NN 42759 1020 31 occupied occupy VBN 42759 1020 32 , , , 42759 1020 33 is be VBZ 42759 1020 34 the the DT 42759 1020 35 specific specific JJ 42759 1020 36 cause cause NN 42759 1020 37 of of IN 42759 1020 38 the the DT 42759 1020 39 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1020 40 . . . 42759 1021 1 If if IN 42759 1021 2 the the DT 42759 1021 3 city city NN 42759 1021 4 permits permit VBZ 42759 1021 5 a a DT 42759 1021 6 competing compete VBG 42759 1021 7 line line NN 42759 1021 8 , , , 42759 1021 9 and and CC 42759 1021 10 if if IN 42759 1021 11 the the DT 42759 1021 12 two two CD 42759 1021 13 lines line NNS 42759 1021 14 sooner sooner RB 42759 1021 15 or or CC 42759 1021 16 later later RB 42759 1021 17 enter enter VB 42759 1021 18 into into IN 42759 1021 19 a a DT 42759 1021 20 combination combination NN 42759 1021 21 , , , 42759 1021 22 the the DT 42759 1021 23 true true JJ 42759 1021 24 source source NN 42759 1021 25 and and CC 42759 1021 26 explanation explanation NN 42759 1021 27 are be VBP 42759 1021 28 to to TO 42759 1021 29 be be VB 42759 1021 30 found find VBN 42759 1021 31 in in IN 42759 1021 32 the the DT 42759 1021 33 fact fact NN 42759 1021 34 of of IN 42759 1021 35 increasing increase VBG 42759 1021 36 returns return NNS 42759 1021 37 . . . 42759 1022 1 Combination combination NN 42759 1022 2 is be VBZ 42759 1022 3 immeasurably immeasurably RB 42759 1022 4 more more RBR 42759 1022 5 profitable profitable JJ 42759 1022 6 than than IN 42759 1022 7 cut cut JJ 42759 1022 8 - - HYPH 42759 1022 9 throat throat JJ 42759 1022 10 competition competition NN 42759 1022 11 . . . 42759 1023 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 1023 2 , , , 42759 1023 3 the the DT 42759 1023 4 evils evil NNS 42759 1023 5 of of IN 42759 1023 6 public public JJ 42759 1023 7 service service NN 42759 1023 8 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 1023 9 can can MD 42759 1023 10 be be VB 42759 1023 11 remedied remedie VBN 42759 1023 12 through through IN 42759 1023 13 public public JJ 42759 1023 14 control control NN 42759 1023 15 of of IN 42759 1023 16 charges charge NNS 42759 1023 17 and and CC 42759 1023 18 through through IN 42759 1023 19 taxation taxation NN 42759 1023 20 . . . 42759 1024 1 Neither neither CC 42759 1024 2 in in IN 42759 1024 3 railroads railroad NNS 42759 1024 4 nor nor CC 42759 1024 5 in in IN 42759 1024 6 public public JJ 42759 1024 7 utilities utility NNS 42759 1024 8 is be VBZ 42759 1024 9 land land NN 42759 1024 10 an an DT 42759 1024 11 impelling impelling JJ 42759 1024 12 cause cause NN 42759 1024 13 of of IN 42759 1024 14 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1024 15 , , , 42759 1024 16 or or CC 42759 1024 17 a a DT 42759 1024 18 serious serious JJ 42759 1024 19 hindrance hindrance NN 42759 1024 20 to to IN 42759 1024 21 proper proper JJ 42759 1024 22 regulation regulation NN 42759 1024 23 . . . 42759 1025 1 Most Most JJS 42759 1025 2 of of IN 42759 1025 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 42759 1025 4 Howe Howe NNP 42759 1025 5 's 's POS 42759 1025 6 exaggerations exaggeration NNS 42759 1025 7 of of IN 42759 1025 8 the the DT 42759 1025 9 influence influence NN 42759 1025 10 of of IN 42759 1025 11 land land NN 42759 1025 12 upon upon IN 42759 1025 13 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1025 14 take take VBP 42759 1025 15 the the DT 42759 1025 16 form form NN 42759 1025 17 of of IN 42759 1025 18 suggestion suggestion NN 42759 1025 19 rather rather RB 42759 1025 20 than than IN 42759 1025 21 of of IN 42759 1025 22 specific specific JJ 42759 1025 23 and and CC 42759 1025 24 direct direct JJ 42759 1025 25 statement statement NN 42759 1025 26 . . . 42759 1026 1 When when WRB 42759 1026 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1026 3 attempts attempt VBZ 42759 1026 4 in in IN 42759 1026 5 precise precise JJ 42759 1026 6 language language NN 42759 1026 7 to to TO 42759 1026 8 enumerate enumerate VB 42759 1026 9 the the DT 42759 1026 10 leading lead VBG 42759 1026 11 sources source NNS 42759 1026 12 of of IN 42759 1026 13 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1026 14 , , , 42759 1026 15 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1026 16 mentions mention VBZ 42759 1026 17 four four CD 42759 1026 18 ; ; : 42759 1026 19 namely namely RB 42759 1026 20 , , , 42759 1026 21 land land NN 42759 1026 22 , , , 42759 1026 23 railways railway NNS 42759 1026 24 , , , 42759 1026 25 the the DT 42759 1026 26 tariff tariff NN 42759 1026 27 , , , 42759 1026 28 and and CC 42759 1026 29 public public JJ 42759 1026 30 service service NN 42759 1026 31 franchises franchise NNS 42759 1026 32 . . . 42759 1027 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1027 2 53 53 CD 42759 1027 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1027 4 Nor nor CC 42759 1027 5 is be VBZ 42759 1027 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1027 7 able able JJ 42759 1027 8 to to TO 42759 1027 9 prove prove VB 42759 1027 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1027 11 assertion assertion NN 42759 1027 12 that that IN 42759 1027 13 of of IN 42759 1027 14 these these DT 42759 1027 15 the the DT 42759 1027 16 most most RBS 42759 1027 17 important important JJ 42759 1027 18 is be VBZ 42759 1027 19 land land NN 42759 1027 20 . . . 42759 1028 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 1028 2 , , , 42759 1028 3 land land NN 42759 1028 4 is be VBZ 42759 1028 5 one one CD 42759 1028 6 of of IN 42759 1028 7 the the DT 42759 1028 8 foremost foremost JJ 42759 1028 9 causes cause NNS 42759 1028 10 . . . 42759 1029 1 The the DT 42759 1029 2 most most RBS 42759 1029 3 prominent prominent JJ 42759 1029 4 examples example NNS 42759 1029 5 of of IN 42759 1029 6 land land NN 42759 1029 7 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1029 8 in in IN 42759 1029 9 this this DT 42759 1029 10 country country NN 42759 1029 11 are be VBP 42759 1029 12 the the DT 42759 1029 13 anthracite anthracite NN 42759 1029 14 coal coal NN 42759 1029 15 mines mine NNS 42759 1029 16 and and CC 42759 1029 17 the the DT 42759 1029 18 iron iron NN 42759 1029 19 ore ore NN 42759 1029 20 beds bed NNS 42759 1029 21 . . . 42759 1030 1 Fully fully RB 42759 1030 2 ninety ninety CD 42759 1030 3 per per IN 42759 1030 4 cent cent NN 42759 1030 5 . . . 42759 1031 1 of of IN 42759 1031 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1031 3 anthracite anthracite NN 42759 1031 4 coal coal NN 42759 1031 5 supply supply NN 42759 1031 6 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1031 7 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 1031 8 of of IN 42759 1031 9 Alaska Alaska NNP 42759 1031 10 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1031 11 is be VBZ 42759 1031 12 under under IN 42759 1031 13 the the DT 42759 1031 14 control control NN 42759 1031 15 of of IN 42759 1031 16 eight eight CD 42759 1031 17 railway railway NN 42759 1031 18 systems system NNS 42759 1031 19 which which WDT 42759 1031 20 in in IN 42759 1031 21 this this DT 42759 1031 22 matter matter NN 42759 1031 23 act act NN 42759 1031 24 as as IN 42759 1031 25 a a DT 42759 1031 26 unit unit NN 42759 1031 27 . . . 42759 1032 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1032 2 54 54 CD 42759 1032 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1032 4 According accord VBG 42759 1032 5 to to IN 42759 1032 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 42759 1032 7 Howe Howe NNP 42759 1032 8 , , , 42759 1032 9 the the DT 42759 1032 10 excessive excessive JJ 42759 1032 11 profits profit NNS 42759 1032 12 reaped reap VBD 42759 1032 13 from from IN 42759 1032 14 this this DT 42759 1032 15 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 1032 16 control control NN 42759 1032 17 amount amount NN 42759 1032 18 to to IN 42759 1032 19 between between IN 42759 1032 20 one one CD 42759 1032 21 hundred hundred CD 42759 1032 22 and and CC 42759 1032 23 two two CD 42759 1032 24 hundred hundred CD 42759 1032 25 million million CD 42759 1032 26 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1032 27 annually annually RB 42759 1032 28 . . . 42759 1033 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1033 2 55 55 CD 42759 1033 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1033 4 In in IN 42759 1033 5 other other JJ 42759 1033 6 words word NNS 42759 1033 7 , , , 42759 1033 8 the the DT 42759 1033 9 consumers consumer NNS 42759 1033 10 of of IN 42759 1033 11 anthracite anthracite NN 42759 1033 12 coal coal NN 42759 1033 13 must must MD 42759 1033 14 pay pay VB 42759 1033 15 every every DT 42759 1033 16 year year NN 42759 1033 17 that that RB 42759 1033 18 much much RB 42759 1033 19 more more JJR 42759 1033 20 than than IN 42759 1033 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1033 22 would would MD 42759 1033 23 have have VB 42759 1033 24 expended expend VBN 42759 1033 25 if if IN 42759 1033 26 the the DT 42759 1033 27 supply supply NN 42759 1033 28 had have VBD 42759 1033 29 not not RB 42759 1033 30 been be VBN 42759 1033 31 monopolised monopolise VBN 42759 1033 32 . . . 42759 1034 1 On on IN 42759 1034 2 the the DT 42759 1034 3 other other JJ 42759 1034 4 hand hand NN 42759 1034 5 , , , 42759 1034 6 the the DT 42759 1034 7 formation formation NN 42759 1034 8 of of IN 42759 1034 9 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1034 10 would would MD 42759 1034 11 have have VB 42759 1034 12 been be VBN 42759 1034 13 much much RB 42759 1034 14 more more RBR 42759 1034 15 difficult difficult JJ 42759 1034 16 if if IN 42759 1034 17 the the DT 42759 1034 18 railroads railroad NNS 42759 1034 19 had have VBD 42759 1034 20 been be VBN 42759 1034 21 legally legally RB 42759 1034 22 forbidden forbid VBN 42759 1034 23 to to TO 42759 1034 24 own own VB 42759 1034 25 coal coal NN 42759 1034 26 mines mine NNS 42759 1034 27 . . . 42759 1035 1 As as IN 42759 1035 2 things thing NNS 42759 1035 3 stand stand VBP 42759 1035 4 , , , 42759 1035 5 railway railway NN 42759 1035 6 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1035 7 is be VBZ 42759 1035 8 an an DT 42759 1035 9 important important JJ 42759 1035 10 cause cause NN 42759 1035 11 of of IN 42759 1035 12 the the DT 42759 1035 13 anthracite anthracite NN 42759 1035 14 coal coal NN 42759 1035 15 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1035 16 . . . 42759 1036 1 Some some DT 42759 1036 2 authorities authority NNS 42759 1036 3 are be VBP 42759 1036 4 of of IN 42759 1036 5 the the DT 42759 1036 6 opinion opinion NN 42759 1036 7 that that IN 42759 1036 8 a a DT 42759 1036 9 similar similar JJ 42759 1036 10 condition condition NN 42759 1036 11 of of IN 42759 1036 12 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1036 13 will will MD 42759 1036 14 ultimately ultimately RB 42759 1036 15 prevail prevail VB 42759 1036 16 in in IN 42759 1036 17 the the DT 42759 1036 18 bituminous bituminous JJ 42759 1036 19 coal coal NN 42759 1036 20 mines mine NNS 42759 1036 21 . . . 42759 1037 1 Iron iron NN 42759 1037 2 ore ore NN 42759 1037 3 has have VBZ 42759 1037 4 been be VBN 42759 1037 5 brought bring VBN 42759 1037 6 under under IN 42759 1037 7 the the DT 42759 1037 8 control control NN 42759 1037 9 of of IN 42759 1037 10 the the DT 42759 1037 11 United United NNP 42759 1037 12 States States NNP 42759 1037 13 Steel Steel NNP 42759 1037 14 Corporation Corporation NNP 42759 1037 15 to to IN 42759 1037 16 such such PDT 42759 1037 17 an an DT 42759 1037 18 extent extent NN 42759 1037 19 that that IN 42759 1037 20 the the DT 42759 1037 21 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 1037 22 of of IN 42759 1037 23 Corporations Corporations NNP 42759 1037 24 writes write VBZ 42759 1037 25 : : : 42759 1037 26 " " `` 42759 1037 27 Indeed indeed RB 42759 1037 28 , , , 42759 1037 29 so so RB 42759 1037 30 far far RB 42759 1037 31 as as IN 42759 1037 32 the the DT 42759 1037 33 Steel Steel NNP 42759 1037 34 Corporation Corporation NNP 42759 1037 35 's 's POS 42759 1037 36 position position NN 42759 1037 37 in in IN 42759 1037 38 the the DT 42759 1037 39 entire entire JJ 42759 1037 40 iron iron NN 42759 1037 41 and and CC 42759 1037 42 steel steel NN 42759 1037 43 industry industry NN 42759 1037 44 is be VBZ 42759 1037 45 of of IN 42759 1037 46 a a DT 42759 1037 47 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 1037 48 character character NN 42759 1037 49 , , , 42759 1037 50 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1037 51 is be VBZ 42759 1037 52 chiefly chiefly RB 42759 1037 53 through through IN 42759 1037 54 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1037 55 control control NN 42759 1037 56 of of IN 42759 1037 57 ore ore NNP 42759 1037 58 holdings holding NNS 42759 1037 59 and and CC 42759 1037 60 the the DT 42759 1037 61 transportation transportation NN 42759 1037 62 of of IN 42759 1037 63 ore ore NN 42759 1037 64 . . . 42759 1037 65 "[56 "[56 '' 42759 1037 66 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1037 67 From from IN 42759 1037 68 this this DT 42759 1037 69 statement statement NN 42759 1037 70 , , , 42759 1037 71 however however RB 42759 1037 72 , , , 42759 1037 73 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1037 74 is be VBZ 42759 1037 75 evident evident JJ 42759 1037 76 that that IN 42759 1037 77 the the DT 42759 1037 78 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1037 79 depends depend VBZ 42759 1037 80 upon upon IN 42759 1037 81 control control NN 42759 1037 82 of of IN 42759 1037 83 transportation transportation NN 42759 1037 84 as as RB 42759 1037 85 well well RB 42759 1037 86 as as IN 42759 1037 87 upon upon IN 42759 1037 88 ownership ownership NN 42759 1037 89 of of IN 42759 1037 90 the the DT 42759 1037 91 ore ore NN 42759 1037 92 beds bed NNS 42759 1037 93 . . . 42759 1038 1 If if IN 42759 1038 2 the the DT 42759 1038 3 former former JJ 42759 1038 4 were be VBD 42759 1038 5 properly properly RB 42759 1038 6 regulated regulate VBN 42759 1038 7 by by IN 42759 1038 8 law law NN 42759 1038 9 , , , 42759 1038 10 the the DT 42759 1038 11 latter latter JJ 42759 1038 12 would would MD 42759 1038 13 not not RB 42759 1038 14 be be VB 42759 1038 15 so so RB 42759 1038 16 effective effective JJ 42759 1038 17 in in IN 42759 1038 18 promoting promote VBG 42759 1038 19 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1038 20 . . . 42759 1039 1 Speaking speak VBG 42759 1039 2 generally generally RB 42759 1039 3 , , , 42759 1039 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1039 5 may may MD 42759 1039 6 say say VB 42759 1039 7 that that IN 42759 1039 8 when when WRB 42759 1039 9 a a DT 42759 1039 10 great great JJ 42759 1039 11 corporation corporation NN 42759 1039 12 controls control VBZ 42759 1039 13 a a DT 42759 1039 14 large large JJ 42759 1039 15 proportion proportion NN 42759 1039 16 of of IN 42759 1039 17 the the DT 42759 1039 18 raw raw JJ 42759 1039 19 material material NN 42759 1039 20 entering enter VBG 42759 1039 21 into into IN 42759 1039 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1039 23 manufactured manufacture VBN 42759 1039 24 products product NNS 42759 1039 25 , , , 42759 1039 26 such such JJ 42759 1039 27 control control NN 42759 1039 28 will will MD 42759 1039 29 supplement supplement VB 42759 1039 30 and and CC 42759 1039 31 reinforce reinforce VB 42759 1039 32 very very RB 42759 1039 33 materially materially RB 42759 1039 34 those those DT 42759 1039 35 other other JJ 42759 1039 36 special special JJ 42759 1039 37 advantages advantage NNS 42759 1039 38 which which WDT 42759 1039 39 make make VBP 42759 1039 40 for for IN 42759 1039 41 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1039 42 . . . 42759 1040 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1040 2 57 57 CD 42759 1040 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1040 4 Prominent prominent JJ 42759 1040 5 examples example NNS 42759 1040 6 are be VBP 42759 1040 7 to to TO 42759 1040 8 be be VB 42759 1040 9 found find VBN 42759 1040 10 in in IN 42759 1040 11 steel steel NN 42759 1040 12 , , , 42759 1040 13 natural natural JJ 42759 1040 14 gas gas NN 42759 1040 15 , , , 42759 1040 16 petroleum petroleum NN 42759 1040 17 , , , 42759 1040 18 and and CC 42759 1040 19 water water NN 42759 1040 20 powers power NNS 42759 1040 21 . . . 42759 1041 1 In in IN 42759 1041 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1041 3 " " `` 42759 1041 4 Report Report NNP 42759 1041 5 on on IN 42759 1041 6 Water Water NNP 42759 1041 7 Power Power NNP 42759 1041 8 Development Development NNP 42759 1041 9 in in IN 42759 1041 10 the the DT 42759 1041 11 United United NNP 42759 1041 12 States States NNP 42759 1041 13 , , , 42759 1041 14 " " '' 42759 1041 15 the the DT 42759 1041 16 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 1041 17 of of IN 42759 1041 18 Corporations Corporations NNP 42759 1041 19 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1041 20 March March NNP 42759 1041 21 14 14 CD 42759 1041 22 , , , 42759 1041 23 1912 1912 CD 42759 1041 24 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1041 25 declared declare VBD 42759 1041 26 that that IN 42759 1041 27 the the DT 42759 1041 28 rapidly rapidly RB 42759 1041 29 increasing increase VBG 42759 1041 30 concentration concentration NN 42759 1041 31 of of IN 42759 1041 32 control control NN 42759 1041 33 might may MD 42759 1041 34 easily easily RB 42759 1041 35 become become VB 42759 1041 36 the the DT 42759 1041 37 nucleus nucleus NN 42759 1041 38 of of IN 42759 1041 39 a a DT 42759 1041 40 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1041 41 of of IN 42759 1041 42 both both CC 42759 1041 43 steam steam NN 42759 1041 44 and and CC 42759 1041 45 water water NN 42759 1041 46 power power NN 42759 1041 47 . . . 42759 1042 1 Ten ten CD 42759 1042 2 great great JJ 42759 1042 3 groups group NNS 42759 1042 4 of of IN 42759 1042 5 interests interest NNS 42759 1042 6 , , , 42759 1042 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1042 8 said say VBD 42759 1042 9 , , , 42759 1042 10 already already RB 42759 1042 11 dominated dominate VBN 42759 1042 12 about about RB 42759 1042 13 sixty sixty CD 42759 1042 14 per per IN 42759 1042 15 cent cent NN 42759 1042 16 . . . 42759 1043 1 of of IN 42759 1043 2 the the DT 42759 1043 3 developed developed JJ 42759 1043 4 water water NN 42759 1043 5 power power NN 42759 1043 6 , , , 42759 1043 7 and and CC 42759 1043 8 were be VBD 42759 1043 9 pursuing pursue VBG 42759 1043 10 a a DT 42759 1043 11 policy policy NN 42759 1043 12 characterised characterise VBN 42759 1043 13 by by IN 42759 1043 14 a a DT 42759 1043 15 large large JJ 42759 1043 16 measure measure NN 42759 1043 17 of of IN 42759 1043 18 agreement agreement NN 42759 1043 19 . . . 42759 1044 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1044 2 58 58 CD 42759 1044 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1044 4 As as IN 42759 1044 5 a a DT 42759 1044 6 rough rough JJ 42759 1044 7 generalisation generalisation NN 42759 1044 8 , , , 42759 1044 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1044 10 would would MD 42759 1044 11 be be VB 42759 1044 12 fair fair JJ 42759 1044 13 to to TO 42759 1044 14 say say VB 42759 1044 15 that that IN 42759 1044 16 in in IN 42759 1044 17 one one CD 42759 1044 18 or or CC 42759 1044 19 two two CD 42759 1044 20 instances instance NNS 42759 1044 21 , , , 42759 1044 22 at at IN 42759 1044 23 least least JJS 42759 1044 24 , , , 42759 1044 25 landownership landownership NN 42759 1044 26 is be VBZ 42759 1044 27 the the DT 42759 1044 28 chief chief JJ 42759 1044 29 basis basis NN 42759 1044 30 , , , 42759 1044 31 and and CC 42759 1044 32 in in IN 42759 1044 33 several several JJ 42759 1044 34 other other JJ 42759 1044 35 cases case NNS 42759 1044 36 an an DT 42759 1044 37 important important JJ 42759 1044 38 contributory contributory NN 42759 1044 39 cause cause NN 42759 1044 40 of of IN 42759 1044 41 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1044 42 . . . 42759 1045 1 Even even RB 42759 1045 2 an an DT 42759 1045 3 approximately approximately RB 42759 1045 4 accurate accurate JJ 42759 1045 5 estimate estimate NN 42759 1045 6 of of IN 42759 1045 7 the the DT 42759 1045 8 amount amount NN 42759 1045 9 of of IN 42759 1045 10 money money NN 42759 1045 11 which which WDT 42759 1045 12 consumers consumer NNS 42759 1045 13 are be VBP 42759 1045 14 compelled compel VBN 42759 1045 15 to to TO 42759 1045 16 pay pay VB 42759 1045 17 annually annually RB 42759 1045 18 for for IN 42759 1045 19 the the DT 42759 1045 20 products product NNS 42759 1045 21 of of IN 42759 1045 22 such such JJ 42759 1045 23 concerns concern NNS 42759 1045 24 over over IN 42759 1045 25 and and CC 42759 1045 26 above above IN 42759 1045 27 what what WP 42759 1045 28 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1045 29 would would MD 42759 1045 30 pay pay VB 42759 1045 31 if if IN 42759 1045 32 the the DT 42759 1045 33 raw raw JJ 42759 1045 34 material material NN 42759 1045 35 were be VBD 42759 1045 36 not not RB 42759 1045 37 wholly wholly RB 42759 1045 38 or or CC 42759 1045 39 partially partially RB 42759 1045 40 monopolised monopolise VBN 42759 1045 41 , , , 42759 1045 42 is be VBZ 42759 1045 43 obviously obviously RB 42759 1045 44 impossible impossible JJ 42759 1045 45 . . . 42759 1046 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1046 2 may may MD 42759 1046 3 possibly possibly RB 42759 1046 4 run run VB 42759 1046 5 into into IN 42759 1046 6 hundreds hundred NNS 42759 1046 7 of of IN 42759 1046 8 millions million NNS 42759 1046 9 of of IN 42759 1046 10 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1046 11 . . . 42759 1047 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1047 2 Excessive Excessive NNP 42759 1047 3 Gains Gains NNPS 42759 1047 4 from from IN 42759 1047 5 Private Private NNP 42759 1047 6 Landownership Landownership NNP 42759 1047 7 _ _ IN 42759 1047 8 The the DT 42759 1047 9 second second JJ 42759 1047 10 evil evil NN 42759 1047 11 of of IN 42759 1047 12 private private JJ 42759 1047 13 landownership landownership NN 42759 1047 14 to to TO 42759 1047 15 be be VB 42759 1047 16 considered consider VBN 42759 1047 17 here here RB 42759 1047 18 , , , 42759 1047 19 is be VBZ 42759 1047 20 the the DT 42759 1047 21 general general JJ 42759 1047 22 fact fact NN 42759 1047 23 that that IN 42759 1047 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1047 25 enables enable VBZ 42759 1047 26 some some DT 42759 1047 27 men man NNS 42759 1047 28 to to TO 42759 1047 29 take take VB 42759 1047 30 a a DT 42759 1047 31 larger large JJR 42759 1047 32 share share NN 42759 1047 33 of of IN 42759 1047 34 the the DT 42759 1047 35 national national JJ 42759 1047 36 product product NN 42759 1047 37 than than IN 42759 1047 38 is be VBZ 42759 1047 39 consistent consistent JJ 42759 1047 40 with with IN 42759 1047 41 the the DT 42759 1047 42 welfare welfare NN 42759 1047 43 of of IN 42759 1047 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1047 45 neighbours neighbour NNS 42759 1047 46 and and CC 42759 1047 47 of of IN 42759 1047 48 society society NN 42759 1047 49 as as IN 42759 1047 50 a a DT 42759 1047 51 whole whole NN 42759 1047 52 . . . 42759 1048 1 As as IN 42759 1048 2 in in IN 42759 1048 3 the the DT 42759 1048 4 matter matter NN 42759 1048 5 of of IN 42759 1048 6 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1048 7 , , , 42759 1048 8 however however RB 42759 1048 9 , , , 42759 1048 10 so so CC 42759 1048 11 here here RB 42759 1048 12 , , , 42759 1048 13 Single Single NNP 42759 1048 14 Tax Tax NNP 42759 1048 15 advocates advocate NNS 42759 1048 16 are be VBP 42759 1048 17 chargeable chargeable JJ 42759 1048 18 with with IN 42759 1048 19 a a DT 42759 1048 20 certain certain JJ 42759 1048 21 amount amount NN 42759 1048 22 of of IN 42759 1048 23 overstatement overstatement NN 42759 1048 24 . . . 42759 1049 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 1049 2 contend contend VBP 42759 1049 3 that that IN 42759 1049 4 the the DT 42759 1049 5 landowner landowner NN 42759 1049 6 's 's POS 42759 1049 7 share share NN 42759 1049 8 of of IN 42759 1049 9 the the DT 42759 1049 10 national national JJ 42759 1049 11 product product NN 42759 1049 12 is be VBZ 42759 1049 13 constantly constantly RB 42759 1049 14 increasing increase VBG 42759 1049 15 , , , 42759 1049 16 that that IN 42759 1049 17 rent rent NN 42759 1049 18 advances advance NNS 42759 1049 19 faster fast RBR 42759 1049 20 than than IN 42759 1049 21 interest interest NN 42759 1049 22 or or CC 42759 1049 23 wages wage NNS 42759 1049 24 , , , 42759 1049 25 nay nay NNP 42759 1049 26 , , , 42759 1049 27 that that IN 42759 1049 28 all all DT 42759 1049 29 of of IN 42759 1049 30 the the DT 42759 1049 31 annual annual JJ 42759 1049 32 increase increase NN 42759 1049 33 in in IN 42759 1049 34 the the DT 42759 1049 35 national national JJ 42759 1049 36 product product NN 42759 1049 37 tends tend VBZ 42759 1049 38 to to TO 42759 1049 39 be be VB 42759 1049 40 gathered gather VBN 42759 1049 41 in in RP 42759 1049 42 by by IN 42759 1049 43 the the DT 42759 1049 44 landowner landowner NN 42759 1049 45 , , , 42759 1049 46 while while IN 42759 1049 47 wages wage NNS 42759 1049 48 and and CC 42759 1049 49 interest interest NN 42759 1049 50 remain remain VBP 42759 1049 51 stationary stationary JJ 42759 1049 52 , , , 42759 1049 53 if if IN 42759 1049 54 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1049 55 do do VBP 42759 1049 56 not not RB 42759 1049 57 actually actually RB 42759 1049 58 decline decline VB 42759 1049 59 . . . 42759 1050 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1050 2 59 59 LS 42759 1050 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1050 4 The the DT 42759 1050 5 share share NN 42759 1050 6 of of IN 42759 1050 7 the the DT 42759 1050 8 product product NN 42759 1050 9 received receive VBN 42759 1050 10 by by IN 42759 1050 11 any any DT 42759 1050 12 of of IN 42759 1050 13 the the DT 42759 1050 14 four four CD 42759 1050 15 agents agent NNS 42759 1050 16 of of IN 42759 1050 17 production production NN 42759 1050 18 depends depend VBZ 42759 1050 19 upon upon IN 42759 1050 20 the the DT 42759 1050 21 relative relative JJ 42759 1050 22 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 1050 23 of of IN 42759 1050 24 the the DT 42759 1050 25 corresponding corresponding JJ 42759 1050 26 factor factor NN 42759 1050 27 . . . 42759 1051 1 When when WRB 42759 1051 2 undertaking undertake VBG 42759 1051 3 ability ability NN 42759 1051 4 becomes become VBZ 42759 1051 5 scarce scarce JJ 42759 1051 6 in in IN 42759 1051 7 proportion proportion NN 42759 1051 8 to to IN 42759 1051 9 the the DT 42759 1051 10 supply supply NN 42759 1051 11 of of IN 42759 1051 12 land land NN 42759 1051 13 , , , 42759 1051 14 labour labour NN 42759 1051 15 , , , 42759 1051 16 and and CC 42759 1051 17 capital capital NN 42759 1051 18 , , , 42759 1051 19 there there EX 42759 1051 20 is be VBZ 42759 1051 21 a a DT 42759 1051 22 rise rise NN 42759 1051 23 in in IN 42759 1051 24 the the DT 42759 1051 25 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 1051 26 of of IN 42759 1051 27 the the DT 42759 1051 28 business business NN 42759 1051 29 man man NN 42759 1051 30 ; ; : 42759 1051 31 when when WRB 42759 1051 32 labour labour NN 42759 1051 33 decreases decrease VBZ 42759 1051 34 relatively relatively RB 42759 1051 35 to to IN 42759 1051 36 undertaking undertaking NN 42759 1051 37 ability ability NN 42759 1051 38 , , , 42759 1051 39 land land NN 42759 1051 40 , , , 42759 1051 41 and and CC 42759 1051 42 capital capital NN 42759 1051 43 , , , 42759 1051 44 there there EX 42759 1051 45 is be VBZ 42759 1051 46 an an DT 42759 1051 47 increase increase NN 42759 1051 48 in in IN 42759 1051 49 wages wage NNS 42759 1051 50 . . . 42759 1052 1 Similar similar JJ 42759 1052 2 statements statement NNS 42759 1052 3 are be VBP 42759 1052 4 true true JJ 42759 1052 5 of of IN 42759 1052 6 the the DT 42759 1052 7 other other JJ 42759 1052 8 two two CD 42759 1052 9 agents agent NNS 42759 1052 10 and and CC 42759 1052 11 factors factor NNS 42759 1052 12 . . . 42759 1053 1 All all PDT 42759 1053 2 these these DT 42759 1053 3 propositions proposition NNS 42759 1053 4 are be VBP 42759 1053 5 merely merely RB 42759 1053 6 particular particular JJ 42759 1053 7 illustrations illustration NNS 42759 1053 8 of of IN 42759 1053 9 the the DT 42759 1053 10 general general JJ 42759 1053 11 rule rule NN 42759 1053 12 that that IN 42759 1053 13 the the DT 42759 1053 14 price price NN 42759 1053 15 of of IN 42759 1053 16 any any DT 42759 1053 17 commodity commodity NN 42759 1053 18 is be VBZ 42759 1053 19 immediately immediately RB 42759 1053 20 governed govern VBN 42759 1053 21 by by IN 42759 1053 22 the the DT 42759 1053 23 movement movement NN 42759 1053 24 of of IN 42759 1053 25 supply supply NN 42759 1053 26 and and CC 42759 1053 27 demand demand NN 42759 1053 28 . . . 42759 1054 1 In in IN 42759 1054 2 view view NN 42759 1054 3 of of IN 42759 1054 4 this this DT 42759 1054 5 fact fact NN 42759 1054 6 , , , 42759 1054 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1054 8 is be VBZ 42759 1054 9 not not RB 42759 1054 10 impossible impossible JJ 42759 1054 11 that that IN 42759 1054 12 rent rent NN 42759 1054 13 might may MD 42759 1054 14 increase increase VB 42759 1054 15 to to IN 42759 1054 16 the the DT 42759 1054 17 extent extent NN 42759 1054 18 described describe VBN 42759 1054 19 in in IN 42759 1054 20 the the DT 42759 1054 21 preceding precede VBG 42759 1054 22 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 1054 23 . . . 42759 1055 1 All all DT 42759 1055 2 that that WDT 42759 1055 3 is be VBZ 42759 1055 4 necessary necessary JJ 42759 1055 5 is be VBZ 42759 1055 6 that that IN 42759 1055 7 land land NN 42759 1055 8 should should MD 42759 1055 9 become become VB 42759 1055 10 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 1055 11 scarce scarce JJ 42759 1055 12 , , , 42759 1055 13 and and CC 42759 1055 14 the the DT 42759 1055 15 other other JJ 42759 1055 16 factors factor NNS 42759 1055 17 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 1055 18 plentiful plentiful JJ 42759 1055 19 . . . 42759 1056 1 As as IN 42759 1056 2 a a DT 42759 1056 3 fact fact NN 42759 1056 4 , , , 42759 1056 5 the the DT 42759 1056 6 supply supply NN 42759 1056 7 of of IN 42759 1056 8 land land NN 42759 1056 9 is be VBZ 42759 1056 10 strictly strictly RB 42759 1056 11 limited limit VBN 42759 1056 12 by by IN 42759 1056 13 nature nature NN 42759 1056 14 , , , 42759 1056 15 while while IN 42759 1056 16 the the DT 42759 1056 17 other other JJ 42759 1056 18 factors factor NNS 42759 1056 19 can can MD 42759 1056 20 and and CC 42759 1056 21 do do VB 42759 1056 22 increase increase VB 42759 1056 23 . . . 42759 1057 1 There there EX 42759 1057 2 are be VBP 42759 1057 3 , , , 42759 1057 4 however however RB 42759 1057 5 , , , 42759 1057 6 several several JJ 42759 1057 7 forces force NNS 42759 1057 8 which which WDT 42759 1057 9 neutralise neutralise VBP 42759 1057 10 or or CC 42759 1057 11 retard retard VB 42759 1057 12 the the DT 42759 1057 13 tendency tendency NN 42759 1057 14 of of IN 42759 1057 15 land land NN 42759 1057 16 to to TO 42759 1057 17 become become VB 42759 1057 18 scarce scarce JJ 42759 1057 19 , , , 42759 1057 20 and and CC 42759 1057 21 of of IN 42759 1057 22 rent rent NN 42759 1057 23 to to TO 42759 1057 24 rise rise VB 42759 1057 25 . . . 42759 1058 1 Modern modern JJ 42759 1058 2 methods method NNS 42759 1058 3 of of IN 42759 1058 4 transportation transportation NN 42759 1058 5 , , , 42759 1058 6 of of IN 42759 1058 7 drainage drainage NN 42759 1058 8 , , , 42759 1058 9 and and CC 42759 1058 10 of of IN 42759 1058 11 irrigation irrigation NN 42759 1058 12 have have VBP 42759 1058 13 greatly greatly RB 42759 1058 14 increased increase VBN 42759 1058 15 the the DT 42759 1058 16 supply supply NN 42759 1058 17 of of IN 42759 1058 18 available available JJ 42759 1058 19 land land NN 42759 1058 20 , , , 42759 1058 21 and and CC 42759 1058 22 of of IN 42759 1058 23 commercially commercially RB 42759 1058 24 profitable profitable JJ 42759 1058 25 land land NN 42759 1058 26 . . . 42759 1059 1 During during IN 42759 1059 2 the the DT 42759 1059 3 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 42759 1059 4 century century NN 42759 1059 5 , , , 42759 1059 6 the the DT 42759 1059 7 transcontinental transcontinental JJ 42759 1059 8 railroads railroad NNS 42759 1059 9 of of IN 42759 1059 10 the the DT 42759 1059 11 United United NNP 42759 1059 12 States States NNP 42759 1059 13 made make VBD 42759 1059 14 so so RB 42759 1059 15 much much JJ 42759 1059 16 of of IN 42759 1059 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1059 18 Western western JJ 42759 1059 19 territory territory NN 42759 1059 20 accessible accessible JJ 42759 1059 21 that that IN 42759 1059 22 the the DT 42759 1059 23 value value NN 42759 1059 24 and and CC 42759 1059 25 rent rent NN 42759 1059 26 of of IN 42759 1059 27 New New NNP 42759 1059 28 England England NNP 42759 1059 29 lands land NNS 42759 1059 30 actually actually RB 42759 1059 31 declined decline VBD 42759 1059 32 ; ; : 42759 1059 33 and and CC 42759 1059 34 there there EX 42759 1059 35 are be VBP 42759 1059 36 still still RB 42759 1059 37 many many JJ 42759 1059 38 millions million NNS 42759 1059 39 of of IN 42759 1059 40 acres acre NNS 42759 1059 41 throughout throughout IN 42759 1059 42 the the DT 42759 1059 43 country country NN 42759 1059 44 which which WDT 42759 1059 45 can can MD 42759 1059 46 be be VB 42759 1059 47 made make VBN 42759 1059 48 productive productive JJ 42759 1059 49 through through IN 42759 1059 50 drainage drainage NN 42759 1059 51 and and CC 42759 1059 52 irrigation irrigation NN 42759 1059 53 . . . 42759 1060 1 In in IN 42759 1060 2 the the DT 42759 1060 3 second second JJ 42759 1060 4 place place NN 42759 1060 5 , , , 42759 1060 6 every every DT 42759 1060 7 increase increase NN 42759 1060 8 of of IN 42759 1060 9 what what WP 42759 1060 10 is be VBZ 42759 1060 11 called call VBN 42759 1060 12 the the DT 42759 1060 13 " " `` 42759 1060 14 intensive intensive JJ 42759 1060 15 use use NN 42759 1060 16 " " '' 42759 1060 17 of of IN 42759 1060 18 land land NN 42759 1060 19 gives give VBZ 42759 1060 20 employment employment NN 42759 1060 21 to to IN 42759 1060 22 labour labour NN 42759 1060 23 and and CC 42759 1060 24 capital capital NN 42759 1060 25 which which WDT 42759 1060 26 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 1060 27 would would MD 42759 1060 28 have have VB 42759 1060 29 to to TO 42759 1060 30 go go VB 42759 1060 31 upon upon IN 42759 1060 32 new new JJ 42759 1060 33 land land NN 42759 1060 34 . . . 42759 1061 1 In in IN 42759 1061 2 America America NNP 42759 1061 3 this this DT 42759 1061 4 practice practice NN 42759 1061 5 is be VBZ 42759 1061 6 only only RB 42759 1061 7 in in IN 42759 1061 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1061 9 infancy infancy NN 42759 1061 10 . . . 42759 1062 1 With with IN 42759 1062 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1062 3 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 1062 4 growth growth NN 42759 1062 5 , , , 42759 1062 6 both both CC 42759 1062 7 in in IN 42759 1062 8 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 1062 9 and and CC 42759 1062 10 mining mining NN 42759 1062 11 , , , 42759 1062 12 the the DT 42759 1062 13 demand demand NN 42759 1062 14 for for IN 42759 1062 15 additional additional JJ 42759 1062 16 land land NN 42759 1062 17 will will MD 42759 1062 18 be be VB 42759 1062 19 checked check VBN 42759 1062 20 , , , 42759 1062 21 and and CC 42759 1062 22 the the DT 42759 1062 23 rise rise NN 42759 1062 24 in in IN 42759 1062 25 land land NN 42759 1062 26 values value NNS 42759 1062 27 and and CC 42759 1062 28 rents rent NNS 42759 1062 29 be be VB 42759 1062 30 correspondingly correspondingly RB 42759 1062 31 diminished diminish VBN 42759 1062 32 . . . 42759 1063 1 Finally finally RB 42759 1063 2 , , , 42759 1063 3 the the DT 42759 1063 4 proportion proportion NN 42759 1063 5 of of IN 42759 1063 6 capital capital NN 42759 1063 7 and and CC 42759 1063 8 labour labour NN 42759 1063 9 that that WDT 42759 1063 10 is be VBZ 42759 1063 11 absorbed absorb VBN 42759 1063 12 in in IN 42759 1063 13 the the DT 42759 1063 14 manufacturing manufacturing NN 42759 1063 15 , , , 42759 1063 16 finishing finish VBG 42759 1063 17 , , , 42759 1063 18 and and CC 42759 1063 19 distributive distributive JJ 42759 1063 20 operations operation NNS 42759 1063 21 of of IN 42759 1063 22 modern modern JJ 42759 1063 23 industry industry NN 42759 1063 24 is be VBZ 42759 1063 25 constantly constantly RB 42759 1063 26 increasing increase VBG 42759 1063 27 . . . 42759 1064 1 These these DT 42759 1064 2 processes process NNS 42759 1064 3 call call VBP 42759 1064 4 for for IN 42759 1064 5 very very RB 42759 1064 6 little little JJ 42759 1064 7 land land NN 42759 1064 8 in in IN 42759 1064 9 comparison comparison NN 42759 1064 10 with with IN 42759 1064 11 that that DT 42759 1064 12 required require VBN 42759 1064 13 for for IN 42759 1064 14 the the DT 42759 1064 15 extractive extractive JJ 42759 1064 16 operations operation NNS 42759 1064 17 of of IN 42759 1064 18 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 1064 19 and and CC 42759 1064 20 mining mining NN 42759 1064 21 . . . 42759 1065 1 An an DT 42759 1065 2 increase increase NN 42759 1065 3 of of IN 42759 1065 4 one one CD 42759 1065 5 - - HYPH 42759 1065 6 fifth fifth NN 42759 1065 7 in in IN 42759 1065 8 the the DT 42759 1065 9 amount amount NN 42759 1065 10 of of IN 42759 1065 11 capital capital NN 42759 1065 12 and and CC 42759 1065 13 labour labour NN 42759 1065 14 occupied occupy VBN 42759 1065 15 in in IN 42759 1065 16 growing grow VBG 42759 1065 17 wheat wheat NN 42759 1065 18 or or CC 42759 1065 19 in in IN 42759 1065 20 taking take VBG 42759 1065 21 out out RP 42759 1065 22 coal coal NN 42759 1065 23 , , , 42759 1065 24 implies imply VBZ 42759 1065 25 a a DT 42759 1065 26 much much RB 42759 1065 27 greater great JJR 42759 1065 28 demand demand NN 42759 1065 29 for for IN 42759 1065 30 land land NN 42759 1065 31 than than IN 42759 1065 32 the the DT 42759 1065 33 same same JJ 42759 1065 34 quantity quantity NN 42759 1065 35 employed employ VBN 42759 1065 36 in in IN 42759 1065 37 factories factory NNS 42759 1065 38 , , , 42759 1065 39 stores store NNS 42759 1065 40 , , , 42759 1065 41 and and CC 42759 1065 42 railroads railroad NNS 42759 1065 43 . . . 42759 1066 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1066 2 60 60 CD 42759 1066 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1066 4 As as IN 42759 1066 5 a a DT 42759 1066 6 consequence consequence NN 42759 1066 7 of of IN 42759 1066 8 these these DT 42759 1066 9 counteracting counteract VBG 42759 1066 10 influences influence NNS 42759 1066 11 , , , 42759 1066 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1066 13 appears appear VBZ 42759 1066 14 that that IN 42759 1066 15 the the DT 42759 1066 16 share share NN 42759 1066 17 of of IN 42759 1066 18 the the DT 42759 1066 19 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1066 20 has have VBZ 42759 1066 21 not not RB 42759 1066 22 increased increase VBN 42759 1066 23 disproportionately disproportionately RB 42759 1066 24 . . . 42759 1067 1 The the DT 42759 1067 2 most most RBS 42759 1067 3 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 1067 4 endeavour endeavour NN 42759 1067 5 yet yet RB 42759 1067 6 made make VBN 42759 1067 7 to to TO 42759 1067 8 determine determine VB 42759 1067 9 the the DT 42759 1067 10 growth growth NN 42759 1067 11 and and CC 42759 1067 12 relative relative JJ 42759 1067 13 size size NN 42759 1067 14 of of IN 42759 1067 15 the the DT 42759 1067 16 different different JJ 42759 1067 17 shares share NNS 42759 1067 18 of of IN 42759 1067 19 the the DT 42759 1067 20 national national JJ 42759 1067 21 product product NN 42759 1067 22 is be VBZ 42759 1067 23 embodied embody VBN 42759 1067 24 in in IN 42759 1067 25 Professor Professor NNP 42759 1067 26 W. W. NNP 42759 1067 27 I. I. NNP 42759 1068 1 King King NNP 42759 1068 2 's 's POS 42759 1068 3 volume volume NN 42759 1068 4 , , , 42759 1068 5 " " `` 42759 1068 6 The the DT 42759 1068 7 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 1068 8 and and CC 42759 1068 9 Income Income NNP 42759 1068 10 of of IN 42759 1068 11 the the DT 42759 1068 12 People People NNS 42759 1068 13 of of IN 42759 1068 14 the the DT 42759 1068 15 United United NNP 42759 1068 16 States States NNP 42759 1068 17 , , , 42759 1068 18 " " '' 42759 1068 19 published publish VBN 42759 1068 20 in in IN 42759 1068 21 1915 1915 CD 42759 1068 22 . . . 42759 1069 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1069 2 estimates estimate VBZ 42759 1069 3 that that IN 42759 1069 4 the the DT 42759 1069 5 total total JJ 42759 1069 6 annual annual JJ 42759 1069 7 income income NN 42759 1069 8 of of IN 42759 1069 9 the the DT 42759 1069 10 nation nation NN 42759 1069 11 increased increase VBD 42759 1069 12 from from IN 42759 1069 13 a a DT 42759 1069 14 little little JJ 42759 1069 15 less less JJR 42759 1069 16 than than IN 42759 1069 17 two two CD 42759 1069 18 and and CC 42759 1069 19 one one CD 42759 1069 20 - - HYPH 42759 1069 21 fourth fourth JJ 42759 1069 22 billions billion NNS 42759 1069 23 of of IN 42759 1069 24 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1069 25 in in IN 42759 1069 26 1850 1850 CD 42759 1069 27 to to IN 42759 1069 28 a a DT 42759 1069 29 little little JJ 42759 1069 30 more more JJR 42759 1069 31 than than IN 42759 1069 32 thirty thirty CD 42759 1069 33 and and CC 42759 1069 34 one one CD 42759 1069 35 - - HYPH 42759 1069 36 half half NN 42759 1069 37 billions billion NNS 42759 1069 38 in in IN 42759 1069 39 1910 1910 CD 42759 1069 40 , , , 42759 1069 41 or or CC 42759 1069 42 slightly slightly RB 42759 1069 43 more more JJR 42759 1069 44 than than IN 42759 1069 45 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 1069 46 times time NNS 42759 1069 47 . . . 42759 1070 1 During during IN 42759 1070 2 the the DT 42759 1070 3 same same JJ 42759 1070 4 period period NN 42759 1070 5 rent rent NN 42759 1070 6 , , , 42759 1070 7 the the DT 42759 1070 8 share share NN 42759 1070 9 of of IN 42759 1070 10 the the DT 42759 1070 11 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1070 12 , , , 42759 1070 13 advanced advance VBN 42759 1070 14 from from IN 42759 1070 15 $ $ $ 42759 1070 16 170,600,000 170,600,000 CD 42759 1070 17 to to IN 42759 1070 18 $ $ $ 42759 1070 19 2,673,900,000 2,673,900,000 CD 42759 1070 20 , , , 42759 1070 21 or or CC 42759 1070 22 about about RB 42759 1070 23 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 1070 24 and and CC 42759 1070 25 three three CD 42759 1070 26 quarter quarter NN 42759 1070 27 times time NNS 42759 1070 28 . . . 42759 1071 1 In in IN 42759 1071 2 the the DT 42759 1071 3 year year NN 42759 1071 4 1910 1910 CD 42759 1071 5 , , , 42759 1071 6 therefore therefore RB 42759 1071 7 , , , 42759 1071 8 the the DT 42759 1071 9 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1071 10 were be VBD 42759 1071 11 receiving receive VBG 42759 1071 12 but but CC 42759 1071 13 a a DT 42759 1071 14 very very RB 42759 1071 15 small small JJ 42759 1071 16 fraction fraction NN 42759 1071 17 more more JJR 42759 1071 18 of of IN 42759 1071 19 the the DT 42759 1071 20 national national JJ 42759 1071 21 product product NN 42759 1071 22 than than IN 42759 1071 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1071 24 predecessors predecessor NNS 42759 1071 25 obtained obtain VBD 42759 1071 26 sixty sixty CD 42759 1071 27 years year NNS 42759 1071 28 earlier early RBR 42759 1071 29 . . . 42759 1072 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1072 2 61 61 CD 42759 1072 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1072 4 As as IN 42759 1072 5 to to IN 42759 1072 6 the the DT 42759 1072 7 relative relative JJ 42759 1072 8 size size NN 42759 1072 9 of of IN 42759 1072 10 the the DT 42759 1072 11 shares share NNS 42759 1072 12 going go VBG 42759 1072 13 to to IN 42759 1072 14 the the DT 42759 1072 15 different different JJ 42759 1072 16 factors factor NNS 42759 1072 17 in in IN 42759 1072 18 1910 1910 CD 42759 1072 19 , , , 42759 1072 20 the the DT 42759 1072 21 figures figure NNS 42759 1072 22 are be VBP 42759 1072 23 even even RB 42759 1072 24 more more RBR 42759 1072 25 remarkable remarkable JJ 42759 1072 26 . . . 42759 1073 1 Wages wage NNS 42759 1073 2 and and CC 42759 1073 3 salaries salary NNS 42759 1073 4 absorbed absorb VBD 42759 1073 5 46.9 46.9 CD 42759 1073 6 per per IN 42759 1073 7 cent cent NN 42759 1073 8 . . . 42759 1074 1 ; ; , 42759 1074 2 profits profit NNS 42759 1074 3 , , , 42759 1074 4 27.5 27.5 CD 42759 1074 5 per per IN 42759 1074 6 cent cent NN 42759 1074 7 . . . 42759 1075 1 ; ; : 42759 1075 2 interest interest NN 42759 1075 3 , , , 42759 1075 4 16.8 16.8 CD 42759 1075 5 per per IN 42759 1075 6 cent cent NN 42759 1075 7 . . . 42759 1076 1 ; ; : 42759 1076 2 and and CC 42759 1076 3 rent rent VB 42759 1076 4 , , , 42759 1076 5 only only RB 42759 1076 6 8.8 8.8 CD 42759 1076 7 per per NN 42759 1076 8 cent cent NN 42759 1076 9 . . . 42759 1077 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1077 2 62 62 CD 42759 1077 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1077 4 This this DT 42759 1077 5 was be VBD 42759 1077 6 exactly exactly RB 42759 1077 7 the the DT 42759 1077 8 same same JJ 42759 1077 9 per per IN 42759 1077 10 cent cent NN 42759 1077 11 . . . 42759 1078 1 that that IN 42759 1078 2 the the DT 42759 1078 3 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1078 4 received receive VBN 42759 1078 5 in in IN 42759 1078 6 1860 1860 CD 42759 1078 7 . . . 42759 1079 1 To to TO 42759 1079 2 be be VB 42759 1079 3 sure sure JJ 42759 1079 4 , , , 42759 1079 5 these these DT 42759 1079 6 figures figure NNS 42759 1079 7 are be VBP 42759 1079 8 only only RB 42759 1079 9 approximations approximation NNS 42759 1079 10 , , , 42759 1079 11 but but CC 42759 1079 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1079 13 are be VBP 42759 1079 14 probably probably RB 42759 1079 15 the the DT 42759 1079 16 most most RBS 42759 1079 17 reliable reliable JJ 42759 1079 18 that that WDT 42759 1079 19 can can MD 42759 1079 20 be be VB 42759 1079 21 obtained obtain VBN 42759 1079 22 from from IN 42759 1079 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1079 24 notoriously notoriously RB 42759 1079 25 incomplete incomplete JJ 42759 1079 26 statistics statistic NNS 42759 1079 27 , , , 42759 1079 28 and and CC 42759 1079 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1079 30 will will MD 42759 1079 31 deserve deserve VB 42759 1079 32 respectful respectful JJ 42759 1079 33 consideration consideration NN 42759 1079 34 until until IN 42759 1079 35 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1079 36 have have VBP 42759 1079 37 been be VBN 42759 1079 38 refuted refute VBN 42759 1079 39 by by IN 42759 1079 40 specific specific JJ 42759 1079 41 criticism criticism NN 42759 1079 42 and and CC 42759 1079 43 argument argument NN 42759 1079 44 . . . 42759 1080 1 In in IN 42759 1080 2 the the DT 42759 1080 3 opinion opinion NN 42759 1080 4 of of IN 42759 1080 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1080 6 compiler compiler NN 42759 1080 7 : : : 42759 1080 8 " " `` 42759 1080 9 The the DT 42759 1080 10 figures figure NNS 42759 1080 11 for for IN 42759 1080 12 wages wage NNS 42759 1080 13 and and CC 42759 1080 14 salaries salary NNS 42759 1080 15 are be VBP 42759 1080 16 believed believe VBN 42759 1080 17 to to TO 42759 1080 18 be be VB 42759 1080 19 fairly fairly RB 42759 1080 20 accurate accurate JJ 42759 1080 21 ; ; : 42759 1080 22 those those DT 42759 1080 23 for for IN 42759 1080 24 rent rent NN 42759 1080 25 are be VBP 42759 1080 26 thought think VBN 42759 1080 27 to to TO 42759 1080 28 have have VB 42759 1080 29 an an DT 42759 1080 30 error error NN 42759 1080 31 of of IN 42759 1080 32 not not RB 42759 1080 33 more more JJR 42759 1080 34 than than IN 42759 1080 35 twenty twenty CD 42759 1080 36 per per IN 42759 1080 37 cent cent NN 42759 1080 38 . . . 42759 1081 1 The the DT 42759 1081 2 separation separation NN 42759 1081 3 of of IN 42759 1081 4 the the DT 42759 1081 5 share share NN 42759 1081 6 of of IN 42759 1081 7 capital capital NN 42759 1081 8 from from IN 42759 1081 9 that that DT 42759 1081 10 of of IN 42759 1081 11 the the DT 42759 1081 12 entrepreneur entrepreneur NN 42759 1081 13 is be VBZ 42759 1081 14 very very RB 42759 1081 15 crudely crudely RB 42759 1081 16 done do VBN 42759 1081 17 and and CC 42759 1081 18 no no DT 42759 1081 19 stress stress NN 42759 1081 20 should should MD 42759 1081 21 be be VB 42759 1081 22 laid lay VBN 42759 1081 23 on on IN 42759 1081 24 the the DT 42759 1081 25 results result NNS 42759 1081 26 . . . 42759 1082 1 The the DT 42759 1082 2 total total NN 42759 1082 3 for for IN 42759 1082 4 all all DT 42759 1082 5 shares share NNS 42759 1082 6 is be VBZ 42759 1082 7 thought think VBN 42759 1082 8 to to TO 42759 1082 9 be be VB 42759 1082 10 more more RBR 42759 1082 11 accurate accurate JJ 42759 1082 12 than than IN 42759 1082 13 the the DT 42759 1082 14 mode mode NN 42759 1082 15 of of IN 42759 1082 16 distribution distribution NN 42759 1082 17 , , , 42759 1082 18 and and CC 42759 1082 19 for for IN 42759 1082 20 the the DT 42759 1082 21 last last JJ 42759 1082 22 three three CD 42759 1082 23 census census NN 42759 1082 24 years year NNS 42759 1082 25 should should MD 42759 1082 26 come come VB 42759 1082 27 within within IN 42759 1082 28 ten ten CD 42759 1082 29 per per IN 42759 1082 30 cent cent NN 42759 1082 31 . . . 42759 1083 1 of of IN 42759 1083 2 the the DT 42759 1083 3 correct correct JJ 42759 1083 4 statement statement NN 42759 1083 5 of of IN 42759 1083 6 the the DT 42759 1083 7 national national JJ 42759 1083 8 income income NN 42759 1083 9 . . . 42759 1084 1 For for IN 42759 1084 2 earlier early JJR 42759 1084 3 years year NNS 42759 1084 4 the the DT 42759 1084 5 error error NN 42759 1084 6 should should MD 42759 1084 7 not not RB 42759 1084 8 be be VB 42759 1084 9 over over IN 42759 1084 10 twenty twenty CD 42759 1084 11 per per IN 42759 1084 12 cent cent NN 42759 1084 13 . . . 42759 1085 1 at at IN 42759 1085 2 the the DT 42759 1085 3 outside outside NN 42759 1085 4 . . . 42759 1086 1 " " `` 42759 1086 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1086 3 63 63 CD 42759 1086 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1086 5 If if IN 42759 1086 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1086 7 make make VBP 42759 1086 8 the the DT 42759 1086 9 maximum maximum JJ 42759 1086 10 allowance allowance NN 42759 1086 11 for for IN 42759 1086 12 error error NN 42759 1086 13 in in IN 42759 1086 14 reference reference NN 42759 1086 15 to to IN 42759 1086 16 the the DT 42759 1086 17 share share NN 42759 1086 18 of of IN 42759 1086 19 the the DT 42759 1086 20 landowner landowner NN 42759 1086 21 , , , 42759 1086 22 and and CC 42759 1086 23 assume assume VB 42759 1086 24 that that IN 42759 1086 25 the the DT 42759 1086 26 rent rent NN 42759 1086 27 estimate estimate NN 42759 1086 28 is be VBZ 42759 1086 29 twenty twenty CD 42759 1086 30 per per IN 42759 1086 31 cent cent NN 42759 1086 32 . . . 42759 1087 1 too too RB 42759 1087 2 low low JJ 42759 1087 3 , , , 42759 1087 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1087 5 find find VBP 42759 1087 6 that that IN 42759 1087 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1087 8 was be VBD 42759 1087 9 still still RB 42759 1087 10 only only RB 42759 1087 11 ten ten CD 42759 1087 12 and and CC 42759 1087 13 one one CD 42759 1087 14 - - HYPH 42759 1087 15 half half NN 42759 1087 16 per per IN 42759 1087 17 cent cent NN 42759 1087 18 . . . 42759 1088 1 of of IN 42759 1088 2 the the DT 42759 1088 3 total total JJ 42759 1088 4 product product NN 42759 1088 5 in in IN 42759 1088 6 1910 1910 CD 42759 1088 7 , , , 42759 1088 8 which which WDT 42759 1088 9 represents represent VBZ 42759 1088 10 an an DT 42759 1088 11 increase increase NN 42759 1088 12 of of IN 42759 1088 13 less less JJR 42759 1088 14 than than IN 42759 1088 15 three three CD 42759 1088 16 per per IN 42759 1088 17 cent cent NN 42759 1088 18 . . . 42759 1089 1 since since IN 42759 1089 2 1850 1850 CD 42759 1089 3 . . . 42759 1090 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1090 2 is be VBZ 42759 1090 3 significant significant JJ 42759 1090 4 that that IN 42759 1090 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 42759 1090 6 Howe Howe NNP 42759 1090 7 , , , 42759 1090 8 who who WP 42759 1090 9 has have VBZ 42759 1090 10 no no DT 42759 1090 11 bias bias NN 42759 1090 12 toward toward IN 42759 1090 13 belittling belittle VBG 42759 1090 14 the the DT 42759 1090 15 share share NN 42759 1090 16 of of IN 42759 1090 17 the the DT 42759 1090 18 landowner landowner NN 42759 1090 19 , , , 42759 1090 20 suggested suggest VBD 42759 1090 21 as as IN 42759 1090 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1090 23 minimum minimum JJ 42759 1090 24 and and CC 42759 1090 25 maximum maximum JJ 42759 1090 26 estimates estimate NNS 42759 1090 27 of of IN 42759 1090 28 the the DT 42759 1090 29 land land NN 42759 1090 30 values value NNS 42759 1090 31 of of IN 42759 1090 32 the the DT 42759 1090 33 country country NN 42759 1090 34 in in IN 42759 1090 35 1910 1910 CD 42759 1090 36 figures figure NNS 42759 1090 37 which which WDT 42759 1090 38 are be VBP 42759 1090 39 respectively respectively RB 42759 1090 40 fifty fifty CD 42759 1090 41 per per IN 42759 1090 42 cent cent NN 42759 1090 43 . . . 42759 1091 1 below below IN 42759 1091 2 and and CC 42759 1091 3 only only RB 42759 1091 4 five five CD 42759 1091 5 per per NN 42759 1091 6 cent cent NN 42759 1091 7 . . . 42759 1092 1 above above IN 42759 1092 2 the the DT 42759 1092 3 amount amount NN 42759 1092 4 taken take VBN 42759 1092 5 by by IN 42759 1092 6 Professor Professor NNP 42759 1092 7 King King NNP 42759 1092 8 as as IN 42759 1092 9 the the DT 42759 1092 10 basis basis NN 42759 1092 11 for for IN 42759 1092 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1092 13 estimate estimate NN 42759 1092 14 of of IN 42759 1092 15 rent rent NN 42759 1092 16 . . . 42759 1093 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1093 2 64 64 CD 42759 1093 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1093 4 There there EX 42759 1093 5 is be VBZ 42759 1093 6 , , , 42759 1093 7 consequently consequently RB 42759 1093 8 , , , 42759 1093 9 a a DT 42759 1093 10 strong strong JJ 42759 1093 11 presumption presumption NN 42759 1093 12 that that WDT 42759 1093 13 Professor Professor NNP 42759 1093 14 King King NNP 42759 1093 15 is be VBZ 42759 1093 16 right right JJ 42759 1093 17 when when WRB 42759 1093 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1093 19 stigmatises stigmatise VBZ 42759 1093 20 as as IN 42759 1093 21 " " `` 42759 1093 22 absurd absurd JJ 42759 1093 23 " " '' 42759 1093 24 the the DT 42759 1093 25 contention contention NN 42759 1093 26 of of IN 42759 1093 27 the the DT 42759 1093 28 Single Single NNP 42759 1093 29 Taxer Taxer NNP 42759 1093 30 , , , 42759 1093 31 " " '' 42759 1093 32 that that IN 42759 1093 33 all all PDT 42759 1093 34 the the DT 42759 1093 35 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1093 36 of of IN 42759 1093 37 industry industry NN 42759 1093 38 result result VBP 42759 1093 39 only only RB 42759 1093 40 in in IN 42759 1093 41 the the DT 42759 1093 42 enrichment enrichment NN 42759 1093 43 of of IN 42759 1093 44 the the DT 42759 1093 45 landlord landlord NN 42759 1093 46 .... .... . 42759 1094 1 The the DT 42759 1094 2 value value NN 42759 1094 3 of of IN 42759 1094 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1094 5 products product NNS 42759 1094 6 has have VBZ 42759 1094 7 increased increase VBN 42759 1094 8 since since IN 42759 1094 9 1850 1850 CD 42759 1094 10 to to IN 42759 1094 11 the the DT 42759 1094 12 extent extent NN 42759 1094 13 of of IN 42759 1094 14 some some DT 42759 1094 15 twenty twenty CD 42759 1094 16 - - HYPH 42759 1094 17 eight eight CD 42759 1094 18 billions billion NNS 42759 1094 19 of of IN 42759 1094 20 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1094 21 , , , 42759 1094 22 while while IN 42759 1094 23 rent rent NN 42759 1094 24 has have VBZ 42759 1094 25 gained gain VBN 42759 1094 26 less less JJR 42759 1094 27 than than IN 42759 1094 28 three three CD 42759 1094 29 billions billion NNS 42759 1094 30 . . . 42759 1095 1 Evidently evidently RB 42759 1095 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1095 3 has have VBZ 42759 1095 4 captured capture VBN 42759 1095 5 but but CC 42759 1095 6 a a DT 42759 1095 7 meagre meagre JJ 42759 1095 8 part part NN 42759 1095 9 of of IN 42759 1095 10 the the DT 42759 1095 11 new new JJ 42759 1095 12 production production NN 42759 1095 13 . . . 42759 1096 1 " " `` 42759 1096 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1096 3 65 65 CD 42759 1096 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1096 5 There there EX 42759 1096 6 are be VBP 42759 1096 7 strong strong JJ 42759 1096 8 indications indication NNS 42759 1096 9 , , , 42759 1096 10 however however RB 42759 1096 11 , , , 42759 1096 12 that that IN 42759 1096 13 the the DT 42759 1096 14 per per NNP 42759 1096 15 cent cent NN 42759 1096 16 . . . 42759 1097 1 of of IN 42759 1097 2 the the DT 42759 1097 3 product product NN 42759 1097 4 going go VBG 42759 1097 5 to to IN 42759 1097 6 the the DT 42759 1097 7 owners owner NNS 42759 1097 8 of of IN 42759 1097 9 land land NN 42759 1097 10 has have VBZ 42759 1097 11 increased increase VBN 42759 1097 12 considerably considerably RB 42759 1097 13 in in IN 42759 1097 14 the the DT 42759 1097 15 last last JJ 42759 1097 16 twenty twenty CD 42759 1097 17 years year NNS 42759 1097 18 , , , 42759 1097 19 and and CC 42759 1097 20 that that IN 42759 1097 21 this this DT 42759 1097 22 movement movement NN 42759 1097 23 will will MD 42759 1097 24 continue continue VB 42759 1097 25 indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 1097 26 . . . 42759 1098 1 According accord VBG 42759 1098 2 to to IN 42759 1098 3 Professor Professor NNP 42759 1098 4 King King NNP 42759 1098 5 's 's POS 42759 1098 6 calculations calculation NNS 42759 1098 7 , , , 42759 1098 8 the the DT 42759 1098 9 per per NNP 42759 1098 10 cent cent NN 42759 1098 11 . . . 42759 1099 1 of of IN 42759 1099 2 the the DT 42759 1099 3 total total JJ 42759 1099 4 product product NN 42759 1099 5 assignable assignable JJ 42759 1099 6 as as IN 42759 1099 7 rent rent NN 42759 1099 8 advanced advanced JJ 42759 1099 9 from from IN 42759 1099 10 7.8 7.8 CD 42759 1099 11 in in IN 42759 1099 12 1900 1900 CD 42759 1099 13 to to IN 42759 1099 14 8.8 8.8 CD 42759 1099 15 in in IN 42759 1099 16 1910 1910 CD 42759 1099 17 , , , 42759 1099 18 which which WDT 42759 1099 19 meant mean VBD 42759 1099 20 that that IN 42759 1099 21 during during IN 42759 1099 22 that that DT 42759 1099 23 period period NN 42759 1099 24 the the DT 42759 1099 25 national national JJ 42759 1099 26 income income NN 42759 1099 27 increased increase VBD 42759 1099 28 only only RB 42759 1099 29 70 70 CD 42759 1099 30 per per NN 42759 1099 31 cent cent NN 42759 1099 32 . . . 42759 1099 33 , , , 42759 1099 34 while while IN 42759 1099 35 the the DT 42759 1099 36 share share NN 42759 1099 37 of of IN 42759 1099 38 the the DT 42759 1099 39 landowner landowner RB 42759 1099 40 increased increase VBN 42759 1099 41 91 91 CD 42759 1099 42 per per IN 42759 1099 43 cent cent NN 42759 1099 44 . . . 42759 1100 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1100 2 66 66 CD 42759 1100 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1100 4 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1100 5 is be VBZ 42759 1100 6 true true JJ 42759 1100 7 that that IN 42759 1100 8 a a DT 42759 1100 9 disproportionate disproportionate JJ 42759 1100 10 advance advance NN 42759 1100 11 in in IN 42759 1100 12 rent rent NN 42759 1100 13 has have VBZ 42759 1100 14 occurred occur VBN 42759 1100 15 between between IN 42759 1100 16 other other JJ 42759 1100 17 census census NN 42759 1100 18 years year NNS 42759 1100 19 , , , 42759 1100 20 only only RB 42759 1100 21 to to TO 42759 1100 22 be be VB 42759 1100 23 neutralised neutralise VBN 42759 1100 24 by by IN 42759 1100 25 subsequent subsequent JJ 42759 1100 26 decreases decrease NNS 42759 1100 27 ; ; : 42759 1100 28 but but CC 42759 1100 29 the the DT 42759 1100 30 present present JJ 42759 1100 31 instance instance NN 42759 1100 32 seems seem VBZ 42759 1100 33 to to TO 42759 1100 34 include include VB 42759 1100 35 certain certain JJ 42759 1100 36 features feature NNS 42759 1100 37 which which WDT 42759 1100 38 did do VBD 42759 1100 39 not not RB 42759 1100 40 characterise characterise VB 42759 1100 41 any any DT 42759 1100 42 of of IN 42759 1100 43 the the DT 42759 1100 44 former former JJ 42759 1100 45 gains gain NNS 42759 1100 46 in in IN 42759 1100 47 the the DT 42759 1100 48 relative relative JJ 42759 1100 49 share share NN 42759 1100 50 of of IN 42759 1100 51 the the DT 42759 1100 52 landowner landowner NN 42759 1100 53 . . . 42759 1101 1 Since since IN 42759 1101 2 1896 1896 CD 42759 1101 3 the the DT 42759 1101 4 prices price NNS 42759 1101 5 of of IN 42759 1101 6 food food NN 42759 1101 7 products product NNS 42759 1101 8 " " '' 42759 1101 9 rose rise VBD 42759 1101 10 most most RBS 42759 1101 11 rapidly rapidly RB 42759 1101 12 in in IN 42759 1101 13 the the DT 42759 1101 14 case case NN 42759 1101 15 of of IN 42759 1101 16 meat meat NN 42759 1101 17 , , , 42759 1101 18 dairy dairy NN 42759 1101 19 products product NNS 42759 1101 20 , , , 42759 1101 21 and and CC 42759 1101 22 cereals cereal NNS 42759 1101 23 , , , 42759 1101 24 which which WDT 42759 1101 25 were be VBD 42759 1101 26 derived derive VBN 42759 1101 27 directly directly RB 42759 1101 28 from from IN 42759 1101 29 the the DT 42759 1101 30 land land NN 42759 1101 31 . . . 42759 1102 1 The the DT 42759 1102 2 prices price NNS 42759 1102 3 of of IN 42759 1102 4 raw raw JJ 42759 1102 5 materials material NNS 42759 1102 6 show show VBP 42759 1102 7 a a DT 42759 1102 8 like like JJ 42759 1102 9 relation relation NN 42759 1102 10 . . . 42759 1103 1 Timber timber NN 42759 1103 2 , , , 42759 1103 3 grain grain NN 42759 1103 4 , , , 42759 1103 5 and and CC 42759 1103 6 other other JJ 42759 1103 7 raw raw JJ 42759 1103 8 materials material NNS 42759 1103 9 obtained obtain VBN 42759 1103 10 directly directly RB 42759 1103 11 from from IN 42759 1103 12 the the DT 42759 1103 13 land land NN 42759 1103 14 have have VBP 42759 1103 15 risen rise VBN 42759 1103 16 rapidly rapidly RB 42759 1103 17 in in IN 42759 1103 18 price price NN 42759 1103 19 , , , 42759 1103 20 while while IN 42759 1103 21 semi semi JJ 42759 1103 22 - - JJ 42759 1103 23 manufactured manufacture VBN 42759 1103 24 articles article NNS 42759 1103 25 have have VBP 42759 1103 26 increased increase VBN 42759 1103 27 less less RBR 42759 1103 28 rapidly rapidly RB 42759 1103 29 , , , 42759 1103 30 or or CC 42759 1103 31 have have VBP 42759 1103 32 decreased decrease VBN 42759 1103 33 in in IN 42759 1103 34 price price NN 42759 1103 35 .... .... . 42759 1104 1 There there EX 42759 1104 2 is be VBZ 42759 1104 3 no no DT 42759 1104 4 parallel parallel NN 42759 1104 5 in in IN 42759 1104 6 any any DT 42759 1104 7 other other JJ 42759 1104 8 field field NN 42759 1104 9 to to IN 42759 1104 10 the the DT 42759 1104 11 advance advance NN 42759 1104 12 in in IN 42759 1104 13 those those DT 42759 1104 14 land land NN 42759 1104 15 values value NNS 42759 1104 16 upon upon IN 42759 1104 17 which which WDT 42759 1104 18 civilisation civilisation NN 42759 1104 19 most most RBS 42759 1104 20 directly directly RB 42759 1104 21 depends depend VBZ 42759 1104 22 -- -- : 42759 1104 23 timber timber NN 42759 1104 24 lands land NNS 42759 1104 25 , , , 42759 1104 26 fertile fertile JJ 42759 1104 27 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1104 28 land land NN 42759 1104 29 , , , 42759 1104 30 and and CC 42759 1104 31 land land NN 42759 1104 32 in in IN 42759 1104 33 large large JJ 42759 1104 34 commercial commercial JJ 42759 1104 35 and and CC 42759 1104 36 industrial industrial JJ 42759 1104 37 centres centre NNS 42759 1104 38 . . . 42759 1105 1 The the DT 42759 1105 2 recent recent JJ 42759 1105 3 rise rise NN 42759 1105 4 in in IN 42759 1105 5 land land NN 42759 1105 6 values value NNS 42759 1105 7 has have VBZ 42759 1105 8 been be VBN 42759 1105 9 little little JJ 42759 1105 10 short short JJ 42759 1105 11 of of IN 42759 1105 12 revolutionary revolutionary JJ 42759 1105 13 . . . 42759 1106 1 " " `` 42759 1106 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1106 3 67 67 CD 42759 1106 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1106 5 Between between IN 42759 1106 6 1900 1900 CD 42759 1106 7 and and CC 42759 1106 8 1910 1910 CD 42759 1106 9 the the DT 42759 1106 10 value value NN 42759 1106 11 of of IN 42759 1106 12 farm farm NN 42759 1106 13 lands land NNS 42759 1106 14 _ _ NNP 42759 1106 15 per per IN 42759 1106 16 acre acre NN 42759 1106 17 _ _ NNP 42759 1106 18 in in IN 42759 1106 19 the the DT 42759 1106 20 United United NNP 42759 1106 21 States States NNP 42759 1106 22 advanced advance VBD 42759 1106 23 108.1 108.1 CD 42759 1106 24 per per IN 42759 1106 25 cent cent NN 42759 1106 26 . . . 42759 1107 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1107 2 68 68 CD 42759 1107 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1107 4 During during IN 42759 1107 5 the the DT 42759 1107 6 eight eight CD 42759 1107 7 years year NNS 42759 1107 8 beginning begin VBG 42759 1107 9 with with IN 42759 1107 10 July July NNP 42759 1107 11 1 1 CD 42759 1107 12 , , , 42759 1107 13 1906 1906 CD 42759 1107 14 , , , 42759 1107 15 the the DT 42759 1107 16 value value NN 42759 1107 17 of of IN 42759 1107 18 land land NN 42759 1107 19 in in IN 42759 1107 20 Greater Greater NNP 42759 1107 21 New New NNP 42759 1107 22 York York NNP 42759 1107 23 increased increase VBD 42759 1107 24 something something NN 42759 1107 25 more more JJR 42759 1107 26 than than IN 42759 1107 27 one one CD 42759 1107 28 - - HYPH 42759 1107 29 third third NN 42759 1107 30 ; ; : 42759 1107 31 in in IN 42759 1107 32 the the DT 42759 1107 33 principal principal JJ 42759 1107 34 cities city NNS 42759 1107 35 of of IN 42759 1107 36 New New NNP 42759 1107 37 Jersey Jersey NNP 42759 1107 38 , , , 42759 1107 39 and and CC 42759 1107 40 in in IN 42759 1107 41 Worcester Worcester NNP 42759 1107 42 , , , 42759 1107 43 Washington Washington NNP 42759 1107 44 , , , 42759 1107 45 Boston Boston NNP 42759 1107 46 , , , 42759 1107 47 and and CC 42759 1107 48 Buffalo Buffalo NNP 42759 1107 49 , , , 42759 1107 50 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 1107 51 less less JJR 42759 1107 52 ; ; : 42759 1107 53 in in IN 42759 1107 54 Springfield Springfield NNP 42759 1107 55 and and CC 42759 1107 56 Holyoke Holyoke NNP 42759 1107 57 , , , 42759 1107 58 considerably considerably RB 42759 1107 59 more more JJR 42759 1107 60 . . . 42759 1108 1 In in IN 42759 1108 2 the the DT 42759 1108 3 most most RBS 42759 1108 4 recent recent JJ 42759 1108 5 ten ten CD 42759 1108 6 years year NNS 42759 1108 7 for for IN 42759 1108 8 which which WDT 42759 1108 9 figures figure NNS 42759 1108 10 are be VBP 42759 1108 11 available available JJ 42759 1108 12 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1108 13 since since IN 42759 1108 14 1900 1900 CD 42759 1108 15 in in IN 42759 1108 16 every every DT 42759 1108 17 case case NN 42759 1108 18 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1108 19 the the DT 42759 1108 20 land land NN 42759 1108 21 values value NNS 42759 1108 22 of of IN 42759 1108 23 Milwaukee Milwaukee NNP 42759 1108 24 , , , 42759 1108 25 St. St. NNP 42759 1108 26 Louis Louis NNP 42759 1108 27 and and CC 42759 1108 28 San San NNP 42759 1108 29 Francisco Francisco NNP 42759 1108 30 averaged average VBD 42759 1108 31 only only RB 42759 1108 32 a a DT 42759 1108 33 slight slight JJ 42759 1108 34 degree degree NN 42759 1108 35 of of IN 42759 1108 36 expansion expansion NN 42759 1108 37 , , , 42759 1108 38 while while IN 42759 1108 39 those those DT 42759 1108 40 of of IN 42759 1108 41 Kansas Kansas NNP 42759 1108 42 City City NNP 42759 1108 43 doubled double VBD 42759 1108 44 , , , 42759 1108 45 and and CC 42759 1108 46 those those DT 42759 1108 47 of of IN 42759 1108 48 Houston Houston NNP 42759 1108 49 , , , 42759 1108 50 Dallas Dallas NNP 42759 1108 51 , , , 42759 1108 52 Los Los NNP 42759 1108 53 Angeles Angeles NNP 42759 1108 54 , , , 42759 1108 55 and and CC 42759 1108 56 Seattle Seattle NNP 42759 1108 57 trebled treble VBD 42759 1108 58 . . . 42759 1109 1 To to TO 42759 1109 2 quote quote VB 42759 1109 3 Professor Professor NNP 42759 1109 4 Nearing Nearing NNP 42759 1109 5 , , , 42759 1109 6 from from IN 42759 1109 7 whose whose WP$ 42759 1109 8 compilations compilation NNS 42759 1109 9 these these DT 42759 1109 10 estimates estimate NNS 42759 1109 11 have have VBP 42759 1109 12 been be VBN 42759 1109 13 summarised summarise VBN 42759 1109 14 : : : 42759 1109 15 " " `` 42759 1109 16 The the DT 42759 1109 17 total total JJ 42759 1109 18 extent extent NN 42759 1109 19 of of IN 42759 1109 20 the the DT 42759 1109 21 increase increase NN 42759 1109 22 in in IN 42759 1109 23 American american JJ 42759 1109 24 city city NN 42759 1109 25 land land NN 42759 1109 26 values value NNS 42759 1109 27 may may MD 42759 1109 28 be be VB 42759 1109 29 hinted hint VBN 42759 1109 30 at at IN 42759 1109 31 rather rather RB 42759 1109 32 than than IN 42759 1109 33 stated state VBN 42759 1109 34 with with IN 42759 1109 35 any any DT 42759 1109 36 certainty certainty NN 42759 1109 37 . . . 42759 1110 1 The the DT 42759 1110 2 scattering scatter VBG 42759 1110 3 instances instance NNS 42759 1110 4 in in IN 42759 1110 5 which which WDT 42759 1110 6 land land NN 42759 1110 7 and and CC 42759 1110 8 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1110 9 are be VBP 42759 1110 10 separately separately RB 42759 1110 11 assessed assess VBN 42759 1110 12 led lead VBD 42759 1110 13 to to IN 42759 1110 14 the the DT 42759 1110 15 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 1110 16 that that IN 42759 1110 17 in in IN 42759 1110 18 a a DT 42759 1110 19 large large JJ 42759 1110 20 , , , 42759 1110 21 well well RB 42759 1110 22 - - HYPH 42759 1110 23 established establish VBN 42759 1110 24 city city NN 42759 1110 25 , , , 42759 1110 26 growing grow VBG 42759 1110 27 at at IN 42759 1110 28 approximately approximately RB 42759 1110 29 the the DT 42759 1110 30 same same JJ 42759 1110 31 rate rate NN 42759 1110 32 as as IN 42759 1110 33 the the DT 42759 1110 34 other other JJ 42759 1110 35 portions portion NNS 42759 1110 36 of of IN 42759 1110 37 the the DT 42759 1110 38 United United NNP 42759 1110 39 States States NNP 42759 1110 40 , , , 42759 1110 41 the the DT 42759 1110 42 land land NN 42759 1110 43 value value NN 42759 1110 44 is be VBZ 42759 1110 45 doubling double VBG 42759 1110 46 in in RP 42759 1110 47 from from IN 42759 1110 48 ten ten CD 42759 1110 49 to to IN 42759 1110 50 twenty twenty CD 42759 1110 51 - - HYPH 42759 1110 52 five five CD 42759 1110 53 years year NNS 42759 1110 54 . . . 42759 1111 1 In in IN 42759 1111 2 the the DT 42759 1111 3 new new JJ 42759 1111 4 , , , 42759 1111 5 rapidly rapidly RB 42759 1111 6 growing grow VBG 42759 1111 7 city city NN 42759 1111 8 of of IN 42759 1111 9 the the DT 42759 1111 10 middle middle NNP 42759 1111 11 and and CC 42759 1111 12 far far RB 42759 1111 13 West West NNP 42759 1111 14 and and CC 42759 1111 15 in in IN 42759 1111 16 some some DT 42759 1111 17 of of IN 42759 1111 18 the the DT 42759 1111 19 smaller small JJR 42759 1111 20 cities city NNS 42759 1111 21 of of IN 42759 1111 22 the the DT 42759 1111 23 East East NNP 42759 1111 24 , , , 42759 1111 25 the the DT 42759 1111 26 ratio ratio NN 42759 1111 27 of of IN 42759 1111 28 increase increase NN 42759 1111 29 in in IN 42759 1111 30 land land NN 42759 1111 31 values value NNS 42759 1111 32 is be VBZ 42759 1111 33 far far RB 42759 1111 34 greater great JJR 42759 1111 35 , , , 42759 1111 36 amounting amount VBG 42759 1111 37 to to IN 42759 1111 38 two two CD 42759 1111 39 - - HYPH 42759 1111 40 fold fold RB 42759 1111 41 or or CC 42759 1111 42 even even RB 42759 1111 43 three three CD 42759 1111 44 - - : 42759 1111 45 fold fold VBP 42759 1111 46 in in IN 42759 1111 47 a a DT 42759 1111 48 decade decade NN 42759 1111 49 . . . 42759 1112 1 In in IN 42759 1112 2 a a DT 42759 1112 3 few few JJ 42759 1112 4 instances instance NNS 42759 1112 5 the the DT 42759 1112 6 rate rate NN 42759 1112 7 of of IN 42759 1112 8 increase increase NN 42759 1112 9 is be VBZ 42759 1112 10 much much RB 42759 1112 11 smaller small JJR 42759 1112 12 , , , 42759 1112 13 and and CC 42759 1112 14 in in IN 42759 1112 15 one one CD 42759 1112 16 case case NN 42759 1112 17 , , , 42759 1112 18 Jersey Jersey NNP 42759 1112 19 City City NNP 42759 1112 20 , , , 42759 1112 21 land land NN 42759 1112 22 values value NNS 42759 1112 23 over over IN 42759 1112 24 a a DT 42759 1112 25 period period NN 42759 1112 26 of of IN 42759 1112 27 seven seven CD 42759 1112 28 years year NNS 42759 1112 29 have have VBP 42759 1112 30 actually actually RB 42759 1112 31 decreased decrease VBN 42759 1112 32 .... .... . 42759 1113 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 1113 2 , , , 42759 1113 3 the the DT 42759 1113 4 few few JJ 42759 1113 5 available available JJ 42759 1113 6 long long JJ 42759 1113 7 range range NN 42759 1113 8 figures figure NNS 42759 1113 9 indicate indicate VBP 42759 1113 10 a a DT 42759 1113 11 widespread widespread JJ 42759 1113 12 and and CC 42759 1113 13 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1113 14 increase increase NN 42759 1113 15 in in IN 42759 1113 16 American american JJ 42759 1113 17 city city NN 42759 1113 18 land land NN 42759 1113 19 values value NNS 42759 1113 20 . . . 42759 1114 1 " " `` 42759 1114 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1114 3 69 69 CD 42759 1114 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1114 5 The the DT 42759 1114 6 rise rise NN 42759 1114 7 in in IN 42759 1114 8 the the DT 42759 1114 9 value value NN 42759 1114 10 of of IN 42759 1114 11 timber timber NN 42759 1114 12 lands land NNS 42759 1114 13 during during IN 42759 1114 14 the the DT 42759 1114 15 last last JJ 42759 1114 16 thirty thirty CD 42759 1114 17 years year NNS 42759 1114 18 has have VBZ 42759 1114 19 been be VBN 42759 1114 20 , , , 42759 1114 21 in in IN 42759 1114 22 the the DT 42759 1114 23 words word NNS 42759 1114 24 of of IN 42759 1114 25 the the DT 42759 1114 26 federal federal JJ 42759 1114 27 investigators investigator NNS 42759 1114 28 , , , 42759 1114 29 " " `` 42759 1114 30 enormous enormous JJ 42759 1114 31 . . . 42759 1114 32 " " '' 42759 1115 1 For for IN 42759 1115 2 the the DT 42759 1115 3 ten ten CD 42759 1115 4 - - HYPH 42759 1115 5 year year NN 42759 1115 6 period period NN 42759 1115 7 ending end VBG 42759 1115 8 in in IN 42759 1115 9 1908 1908 CD 42759 1115 10 , , , 42759 1115 11 " " `` 42759 1115 12 the the DT 42759 1115 13 value value NN 42759 1115 14 of of IN 42759 1115 15 a a DT 42759 1115 16 given give VBN 42759 1115 17 piece piece NN 42759 1115 18 of of IN 42759 1115 19 southern southern JJ 42759 1115 20 pine pine NN 42759 1115 21 taken take VBN 42759 1115 22 at at IN 42759 1115 23 random random JJ 42759 1115 24 is be VBZ 42759 1115 25 likely likely JJ 42759 1115 26 to to TO 42759 1115 27 have have VB 42759 1115 28 increased increase VBN 42759 1115 29 in in IN 42759 1115 30 any any DT 42759 1115 31 ratio ratio NN 42759 1115 32 from from IN 42759 1115 33 three three CD 42759 1115 34 - - RB 42759 1115 35 fold fold RB 42759 1115 36 to to IN 42759 1115 37 ten ten CD 42759 1115 38 - - HYPH 42759 1115 39 fold fold RB 42759 1115 40 . . . 42759 1115 41 " " '' 42759 1116 1 About about RB 42759 1116 2 the the DT 42759 1116 3 same same JJ 42759 1116 4 ratio ratio NN 42759 1116 5 of of IN 42759 1116 6 increase increase NN 42759 1116 7 obtained obtain VBN 42759 1116 8 in in IN 42759 1116 9 the the DT 42759 1116 10 Pacific Pacific NNP 42759 1116 11 Northwest Northwest NNP 42759 1116 12 , , , 42759 1116 13 and and CC 42759 1116 14 a a DT 42759 1116 15 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 1116 16 smaller small JJR 42759 1116 17 increase increase NN 42759 1116 18 in in IN 42759 1116 19 the the DT 42759 1116 20 region region NN 42759 1116 21 of of IN 42759 1116 22 the the DT 42759 1116 23 Great Great NNP 42759 1116 24 Lakes Lakes NNPS 42759 1116 25 . . . 42759 1117 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1117 2 70 70 CD 42759 1117 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1117 4 While while IN 42759 1117 5 a a DT 42759 1117 6 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1117 7 decline decline NN 42759 1117 8 has have VBZ 42759 1117 9 taken take VBN 42759 1117 10 place place NN 42759 1117 11 since since IN 42759 1117 12 1908 1908 CD 42759 1117 13 , , , 42759 1117 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1117 15 is be VBZ 42759 1117 16 only only RB 42759 1117 17 temporary temporary JJ 42759 1117 18 ; ; : 42759 1117 19 for for IN 42759 1117 20 the the DT 42759 1117 21 demand demand NN 42759 1117 22 for for IN 42759 1117 23 timber timber NN 42759 1117 24 is be VBZ 42759 1117 25 notoriously notoriously RB 42759 1117 26 increasing increase VBG 42759 1117 27 several several JJ 42759 1117 28 times time NNS 42759 1117 29 as as RB 42759 1117 30 fast fast RB 42759 1117 31 as as IN 42759 1117 32 the the DT 42759 1117 33 supply supply NN 42759 1117 34 . . . 42759 1118 1 That that IN 42759 1118 2 this this DT 42759 1118 3 upward upward JJ 42759 1118 4 movement movement NN 42759 1118 5 in in IN 42759 1118 6 the the DT 42759 1118 7 value value NN 42759 1118 8 of of IN 42759 1118 9 all all DT 42759 1118 10 three three CD 42759 1118 11 kinds kind NNS 42759 1118 12 of of IN 42759 1118 13 land land NN 42759 1118 14 will will MD 42759 1118 15 continue continue VB 42759 1118 16 without without IN 42759 1118 17 serious serious JJ 42759 1118 18 interruption interruption NN 42759 1118 19 , , , 42759 1118 20 seems seem VBZ 42759 1118 21 to to TO 42759 1118 22 be be VB 42759 1118 23 as as RB 42759 1118 24 nearly nearly RB 42759 1118 25 certain certain JJ 42759 1118 26 as as IN 42759 1118 27 any any DT 42759 1118 28 economic economic JJ 42759 1118 29 proposition proposition NN 42759 1118 30 that that WDT 42759 1118 31 is be VBZ 42759 1118 32 dependent dependent JJ 42759 1118 33 upon upon IN 42759 1118 34 the the DT 42759 1118 35 future future NN 42759 1118 36 . . . 42759 1119 1 Although although IN 42759 1119 2 millions million NNS 42759 1119 3 of of IN 42759 1119 4 acres acre NNS 42759 1119 5 of of IN 42759 1119 6 arable arable JJ 42759 1119 7 lands land NNS 42759 1119 8 are be VBP 42759 1119 9 still still RB 42759 1119 10 unoccupied unoccupied JJ 42759 1119 11 in in IN 42759 1119 12 the the DT 42759 1119 13 United United NNP 42759 1119 14 States States NNP 42759 1119 15 and and CC 42759 1119 16 Canada Canada NNP 42759 1119 17 , , , 42759 1119 18 the the DT 42759 1119 19 far far RB 42759 1119 20 greater great JJR 42759 1119 21 part part NN 42759 1119 22 of of IN 42759 1119 23 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1119 24 require require VBP 42759 1119 25 a a DT 42759 1119 26 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 1119 27 large large JJ 42759 1119 28 initial initial JJ 42759 1119 29 outlay outlay NN 42759 1119 30 for for IN 42759 1119 31 draining draining NN 42759 1119 32 , , , 42759 1119 33 clearing clearing NN 42759 1119 34 , , , 42759 1119 35 irrigation irrigation NN 42759 1119 36 , , , 42759 1119 37 etc etc FW 42759 1119 38 . . FW 42759 1119 39 , , , 42759 1119 40 in in IN 42759 1119 41 order order NN 42759 1119 42 to to TO 42759 1119 43 become become VB 42759 1119 44 productive productive JJ 42759 1119 45 . . . 42759 1120 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1120 2 there there EX 42759 1120 3 is be VBZ 42759 1120 4 no no DT 42759 1120 5 likelihood likelihood NN 42759 1120 6 that that IN 42759 1120 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1120 8 can can MD 42759 1120 9 be be VB 42759 1120 10 brought bring VBN 42759 1120 11 under under IN 42759 1120 12 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 1120 13 fast fast RB 42759 1120 14 enough enough RB 42759 1120 15 to to TO 42759 1120 16 halt halt VB 42759 1120 17 or or CC 42759 1120 18 greatly greatly RB 42759 1120 19 retard retard VB 42759 1120 20 the the DT 42759 1120 21 advancing advance VBG 42759 1120 22 values value NNS 42759 1120 23 which which WDT 42759 1120 24 follow follow VBP 42759 1120 25 upon upon IN 42759 1120 26 the the DT 42759 1120 27 growth growth NN 42759 1120 28 of of IN 42759 1120 29 population population NN 42759 1120 30 and and CC 42759 1120 31 the the DT 42759 1120 32 increased increase VBN 42759 1120 33 demand demand NN 42759 1120 34 for for IN 42759 1120 35 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1120 36 products product NNS 42759 1120 37 . . . 42759 1121 1 In in IN 42759 1121 2 all all DT 42759 1121 3 probability probability NN 42759 1121 4 the the DT 42759 1121 5 greater great JJR 42759 1121 6 part part NN 42759 1121 7 of of IN 42759 1121 8 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1121 9 will will MD 42759 1121 10 not not RB 42759 1121 11 come come VB 42759 1121 12 into into IN 42759 1121 13 use use NN 42759 1121 14 until until IN 42759 1121 15 the the DT 42759 1121 16 prices price NNS 42759 1121 17 of of IN 42759 1121 18 farm farm NN 42759 1121 19 products product NNS 42759 1121 20 have have VBP 42759 1121 21 risen rise VBN 42759 1121 22 above above IN 42759 1121 23 the the DT 42759 1121 24 present present JJ 42759 1121 25 level level NN 42759 1121 26 . . . 42759 1122 1 Obviously obviously RB 42759 1122 2 this this DT 42759 1122 3 supposes suppose VBZ 42759 1122 4 an an DT 42759 1122 5 increase increase NN 42759 1122 6 in in IN 42759 1122 7 the the DT 42759 1122 8 value value NN 42759 1122 9 of of IN 42759 1122 10 all all DT 42759 1122 11 farm farm NN 42759 1122 12 land land NN 42759 1122 13 , , , 42759 1122 14 old old JJ 42759 1122 15 and and CC 42759 1122 16 new new JJ 42759 1122 17 . . . 42759 1123 1 Nor nor CC 42759 1123 2 is be VBZ 42759 1123 3 the the DT 42759 1123 4 adoption adoption NN 42759 1123 5 of of IN 42759 1123 6 better well JJR 42759 1123 7 methods method NNS 42759 1123 8 of of IN 42759 1123 9 farming farming NN 42759 1123 10 likely likely JJ 42759 1123 11 to to TO 42759 1123 12 check check VB 42759 1123 13 seriously seriously RB 42759 1123 14 the the DT 42759 1123 15 upward upward JJ 42759 1123 16 movement movement NN 42759 1123 17 . . . 42759 1124 1 Between between IN 42759 1124 2 1900 1900 CD 42759 1124 3 and and CC 42759 1124 4 1910 1910 CD 42759 1124 5 the the DT 42759 1124 6 urban urban JJ 42759 1124 7 population population NN 42759 1124 8 of of IN 42759 1124 9 America America NNP 42759 1124 10 increased increase VBD 42759 1124 11 34.8 34.8 CD 42759 1124 12 per per IN 42759 1124 13 cent cent NN 42759 1124 14 . . . 42759 1124 15 , , , 42759 1124 16 as as IN 42759 1124 17 against against IN 42759 1124 18 a a DT 42759 1124 19 gain gain NN 42759 1124 20 of of IN 42759 1124 21 only only RB 42759 1124 22 21 21 CD 42759 1124 23 per per NN 42759 1124 24 cent cent NN 42759 1124 25 . . . 42759 1125 1 in in IN 42759 1125 2 the the DT 42759 1125 3 total total JJ 42759 1125 4 population population NN 42759 1125 5 . . . 42759 1126 1 This this DT 42759 1126 2 disproportionate disproportionate JJ 42759 1126 3 growth growth NN 42759 1126 4 in in IN 42759 1126 5 the the DT 42759 1126 6 number number NN 42759 1126 7 of of IN 42759 1126 8 the the DT 42759 1126 9 city city NN 42759 1126 10 dwellers dweller NNS 42759 1126 11 will will MD 42759 1126 12 if if IN 42759 1126 13 continued continue VBN 42759 1126 14 make make VB 42759 1126 15 certain certain JJ 42759 1126 16 what what WP 42759 1126 17 is be VBZ 42759 1126 18 in in IN 42759 1126 19 any any DT 42759 1126 20 case case NN 42759 1126 21 extremely extremely RB 42759 1126 22 probable probable JJ 42759 1126 23 , , , 42759 1126 24 a a DT 42759 1126 25 steady steady JJ 42759 1126 26 and and CC 42759 1126 27 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1126 28 advance advance NN 42759 1126 29 in in IN 42759 1126 30 urban urban JJ 42759 1126 31 land land NN 42759 1126 32 values value NNS 42759 1126 33 and and CC 42759 1126 34 rents rent NNS 42759 1126 35 . . . 42759 1127 1 The the DT 42759 1127 2 circumstance circumstance NN 42759 1127 3 that that WDT 42759 1127 4 these these DT 42759 1127 5 remarkable remarkable JJ 42759 1127 6 increases increase NNS 42759 1127 7 in in IN 42759 1127 8 land land NN 42759 1127 9 values value NNS 42759 1127 10 are be VBP 42759 1127 11 a a DT 42759 1127 12 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 1127 13 recent recent JJ 42759 1127 14 phenomenon phenomenon NN 42759 1127 15 has have VBZ 42759 1127 16 prevented prevent VBN 42759 1127 17 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1127 18 from from IN 42759 1127 19 receiving receive VBG 42759 1127 20 the the DT 42759 1127 21 attention attention NN 42759 1127 22 that that WDT 42759 1127 23 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1127 24 deserve deserve VBP 42759 1127 25 , , , 42759 1127 26 either either CC 42759 1127 27 from from IN 42759 1127 28 the the DT 42759 1127 29 general general JJ 42759 1127 30 public public NN 42759 1127 31 or or CC 42759 1127 32 from from IN 42759 1127 33 the the DT 42759 1127 34 students student NNS 42759 1127 35 of of IN 42759 1127 36 economic economic JJ 42759 1127 37 and and CC 42759 1127 38 social social JJ 42759 1127 39 problems problem NNS 42759 1127 40 . . . 42759 1128 1 The the DT 42759 1128 2 total total JJ 42759 1128 3 value value NN 42759 1128 4 of of IN 42759 1128 5 the the DT 42759 1128 6 land land NN 42759 1128 7 of of IN 42759 1128 8 the the DT 42759 1128 9 country country NN 42759 1128 10 has have VBZ 42759 1128 11 increased increase VBN 42759 1128 12 steadily steadily RB 42759 1128 13 from from IN 42759 1128 14 decade decade NN 42759 1128 15 to to IN 42759 1128 16 decade decade NN 42759 1128 17 , , , 42759 1128 18 but but CC 42759 1128 19 so so RB 42759 1128 20 has have VBZ 42759 1128 21 the the DT 42759 1128 22 total total JJ 42759 1128 23 value value NN 42759 1128 24 of of IN 42759 1128 25 capital capital NN 42759 1128 26 , , , 42759 1128 27 and and CC 42759 1128 28 even even RB 42759 1128 29 between between IN 42759 1128 30 1900 1900 CD 42759 1128 31 and and CC 42759 1128 32 1910 1910 CD 42759 1128 33 the the DT 42759 1128 34 increase increase NN 42759 1128 35 in in IN 42759 1128 36 the the DT 42759 1128 37 share share NN 42759 1128 38 of of IN 42759 1128 39 the the DT 42759 1128 40 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 1128 41 was be VBD 42759 1128 42 exactly exactly RB 42759 1128 43 equal equal JJ 42759 1128 44 to to IN 42759 1128 45 the the DT 42759 1128 46 increase increase NN 42759 1128 47 in in IN 42759 1128 48 the the DT 42759 1128 49 share share NN 42759 1128 50 of of IN 42759 1128 51 the the DT 42759 1128 52 landowner landowner NN 42759 1128 53 , , , 42759 1128 54 that that RB 42759 1128 55 is is RB 42759 1128 56 , , , 42759 1128 57 91 91 CD 42759 1128 58 per per NN 42759 1128 59 cent cent NN 42759 1128 60 . . . 42759 1129 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1129 2 71 71 CD 42759 1129 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1129 4 Those those DT 42759 1129 5 persons person NNS 42759 1129 6 who who WP 42759 1129 7 complacently complacently RB 42759 1129 8 make make VBP 42759 1129 9 such such JJ 42759 1129 10 comparisons comparison NNS 42759 1129 11 overlook overlook VB 42759 1129 12 the the DT 42759 1129 13 new new JJ 42759 1129 14 and and CC 42759 1129 15 significant significant JJ 42759 1129 16 feature feature NN 42759 1129 17 of of IN 42759 1129 18 the the DT 42759 1129 19 more more RBR 42759 1129 20 recent recent JJ 42759 1129 21 advances advance NNS 42759 1129 22 in in IN 42759 1129 23 land land NN 42759 1129 24 value value NN 42759 1129 25 ; ; : 42759 1129 26 namely namely RB 42759 1129 27 , , , 42759 1129 28 that that IN 42759 1129 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1129 30 are be VBP 42759 1129 31 due due JJ 42759 1129 32 in in IN 42759 1129 33 only only RB 42759 1129 34 a a DT 42759 1129 35 slight slight JJ 42759 1129 36 degree degree NN 42759 1129 37 to to IN 42759 1129 38 an an DT 42759 1129 39 expansion expansion NN 42759 1129 40 of of IN 42759 1129 41 the the DT 42759 1129 42 _ _ NNP 42759 1129 43 area area NN 42759 1129 44 _ _ NNP 42759 1129 45 of of IN 42759 1129 46 land land NN 42759 1129 47 under under IN 42759 1129 48 consideration consideration NN 42759 1129 49 . . . 42759 1130 1 The the DT 42759 1130 2 increases increase NNS 42759 1130 3 of of IN 42759 1130 4 value value NN 42759 1130 5 quoted quote VBN 42759 1130 6 in in IN 42759 1130 7 the the DT 42759 1130 8 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 1130 9 paragraphs paragraph NNS 42759 1130 10 are be VBP 42759 1130 11 increases increase NNS 42759 1130 12 _ _ NNP 42759 1130 13 per per IN 42759 1130 14 acre acre NN 42759 1130 15 _ _ NNP 42759 1130 16 and and CC 42759 1130 17 _ _ NNP 42759 1130 18 per per IN 42759 1130 19 urban urban JJ 42759 1130 20 lot lot NN 42759 1130 21 _ _ NNP 42759 1130 22 , , , 42759 1130 23 not not RB 42759 1130 24 increases increase NNS 42759 1130 25 derived derive VBN 42759 1130 26 from from IN 42759 1130 27 bringing bring VBG 42759 1130 28 new new JJ 42759 1130 29 land land NN 42759 1130 30 under under IN 42759 1130 31 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 1130 32 or or CC 42759 1130 33 new new JJ 42759 1130 34 tracts tract NNS 42759 1130 35 within within IN 42759 1130 36 municipal municipal JJ 42759 1130 37 limits limit NNS 42759 1130 38 . . . 42759 1131 1 On on IN 42759 1131 2 the the DT 42759 1131 3 other other JJ 42759 1131 4 hand hand NN 42759 1131 5 , , , 42759 1131 6 the the DT 42759 1131 7 increases increase NNS 42759 1131 8 in in IN 42759 1131 9 the the DT 42759 1131 10 value value NN 42759 1131 11 of of IN 42759 1131 12 capital capital NN 42759 1131 13 , , , 42759 1131 14 now now RB 42759 1131 15 as as IN 42759 1131 16 always always RB 42759 1131 17 , , , 42759 1131 18 represent represent VB 42759 1131 19 for for IN 42759 1131 20 the the DT 42759 1131 21 most most JJS 42759 1131 22 part part NN 42759 1131 23 concrete concrete JJ 42759 1131 24 additions addition NNS 42759 1131 25 to to IN 42759 1131 26 the the DT 42759 1131 27 existing exist VBG 42759 1131 28 stock stock NN 42759 1131 29 of of IN 42759 1131 30 productive productive JJ 42759 1131 31 instruments instrument NNS 42759 1131 32 . . . 42759 1132 1 Except except IN 42759 1132 2 where where WRB 42759 1132 3 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1132 4 holds hold VBZ 42759 1132 5 sway sway NNP 42759 1132 6 , , , 42759 1132 7 particular particular JJ 42759 1132 8 capital capital NN 42759 1132 9 instruments instrument NNS 42759 1132 10 , , , 42759 1132 11 unlike unlike IN 42759 1132 12 particular particular JJ 42759 1132 13 pieces piece NNS 42759 1132 14 of of IN 42759 1132 15 land land NN 42759 1132 16 , , , 42759 1132 17 do do VBP 42759 1132 18 not not RB 42759 1132 19 increase increase VB 42759 1132 20 in in IN 42759 1132 21 value value NN 42759 1132 22 . . . 42759 1133 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1133 2 the the DT 42759 1133 3 owner owner NN 42759 1133 4 of of IN 42759 1133 5 a a DT 42759 1133 6 given give VBN 42759 1133 7 amount amount NN 42759 1133 8 of of IN 42759 1133 9 capital capital NN 42759 1133 10 does do VBZ 42759 1133 11 not not RB 42759 1133 12 profit profit VB 42759 1133 13 by by IN 42759 1133 14 the the DT 42759 1133 15 advance advance NN 42759 1133 16 in in IN 42759 1133 17 the the DT 42759 1133 18 total total JJ 42759 1133 19 value value NN 42759 1133 20 of of IN 42759 1133 21 capital capital NN 42759 1133 22 as as IN 42759 1133 23 the the DT 42759 1133 24 owner owner NN 42759 1133 25 of of IN 42759 1133 26 the the DT 42759 1133 27 average average JJ 42759 1133 28 parcel parcel NN 42759 1133 29 of of IN 42759 1133 30 land land NN 42759 1133 31 profits profit NNS 42759 1133 32 by by IN 42759 1133 33 the the DT 42759 1133 34 general general JJ 42759 1133 35 increase increase NN 42759 1133 36 in in IN 42759 1133 37 the the DT 42759 1133 38 value value NN 42759 1133 39 of of IN 42759 1133 40 land land NN 42759 1133 41 . . . 42759 1134 1 This this DT 42759 1134 2 means mean VBZ 42759 1134 3 that that IN 42759 1134 4 all all PDT 42759 1134 5 those those DT 42759 1134 6 consumers consumer NNS 42759 1134 7 of of IN 42759 1134 8 products product NNS 42759 1134 9 who who WP 42759 1134 10 are be VBP 42759 1134 11 not not RB 42759 1134 12 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1134 13 must must MD 42759 1134 14 pay pay VB 42759 1134 15 an an DT 42759 1134 16 increasing increase VBG 42759 1134 17 tribute tribute NN 42759 1134 18 to to IN 42759 1134 19 those those DT 42759 1134 20 who who WP 42759 1134 21 are be VBP 42759 1134 22 landed land VBN 42759 1134 23 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 1134 24 . . . 42759 1135 1 So so RB 42759 1135 2 much much JJ 42759 1135 3 for for IN 42759 1135 4 the the DT 42759 1135 5 _ _ NNP 42759 1135 6 proportion proportion NN 42759 1135 7 _ _ NNP 42759 1135 8 of of IN 42759 1135 9 the the DT 42759 1135 10 national national JJ 42759 1135 11 product product NN 42759 1135 12 which which WDT 42759 1135 13 goes go VBZ 42759 1135 14 to to IN 42759 1135 15 the the DT 42759 1135 16 landowning landowning NN 42759 1135 17 class class NN 42759 1135 18 . . . 42759 1136 1 Let let VB 42759 1136 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 1136 3 next next JJ 42759 1136 4 inquire inquire NN 42759 1136 5 how how WRB 42759 1136 6 the the DT 42759 1136 7 landowner landowner NN 42759 1136 8 's 's POS 42759 1136 9 share share NN 42759 1136 10 , , , 42759 1136 11 or or CC 42759 1136 12 rent rent NN 42759 1136 13 , , , 42759 1136 14 is be VBZ 42759 1136 15 distributed distribute VBN 42759 1136 16 throughout throughout IN 42759 1136 17 the the DT 42759 1136 18 population population NN 42759 1136 19 . . . 42759 1137 1 If if IN 42759 1137 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1137 3 were be VBD 42759 1137 4 equally equally RB 42759 1137 5 divided divide VBN 42759 1137 6 among among IN 42759 1137 7 all all DT 42759 1137 8 persons person NNS 42759 1137 9 , , , 42759 1137 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1137 11 increase increase NN 42759 1137 12 relatively relatively RB 42759 1137 13 to to IN 42759 1137 14 the the DT 42759 1137 15 shares share NNS 42759 1137 16 of of IN 42759 1137 17 the the DT 42759 1137 18 other other JJ 42759 1137 19 factors factor NNS 42759 1137 20 would would MD 42759 1137 21 , , , 42759 1137 22 from from IN 42759 1137 23 the the DT 42759 1137 24 social social JJ 42759 1137 25 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 1137 26 , , , 42759 1137 27 be be VB 42759 1137 28 a a DT 42759 1137 29 matter matter NN 42759 1137 30 of of IN 42759 1137 31 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1137 32 indifference indifference NN 42759 1137 33 . . . 42759 1138 1 On on IN 42759 1138 2 the the DT 42759 1138 3 other other JJ 42759 1138 4 hand hand NN 42759 1138 5 , , , 42759 1138 6 if if IN 42759 1138 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1138 8 is be VBZ 42759 1138 9 secured secure VBN 42759 1138 10 by by IN 42759 1138 11 a a DT 42759 1138 12 minority minority NN 42759 1138 13 of of IN 42759 1138 14 the the DT 42759 1138 15 population population NN 42759 1138 16 , , , 42759 1138 17 and and CC 42759 1138 18 if if IN 42759 1138 19 that that DT 42759 1138 20 minority minority NN 42759 1138 21 tends tend VBZ 42759 1138 22 to to TO 42759 1138 23 become become VB 42759 1138 24 smaller small JJR 42759 1138 25 as as IN 42759 1138 26 the the DT 42759 1138 27 share share NN 42759 1138 28 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 1138 29 becomes become VBZ 42759 1138 30 larger large JJR 42759 1138 31 , , , 42759 1138 32 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1138 33 have have VBP 42759 1138 34 a a DT 42759 1138 35 socially socially RB 42759 1138 36 undesirable undesirable JJ 42759 1138 37 condition condition NN 42759 1138 38 . . . 42759 1139 1 In in IN 42759 1139 2 the the DT 42759 1139 3 twenty twenty CD 42759 1139 4 years year NNS 42759 1139 5 between between IN 42759 1139 6 1890 1890 CD 42759 1139 7 and and CC 42759 1139 8 1910 1910 CD 42759 1139 9 , , , 42759 1139 10 the the DT 42759 1139 11 proportion proportion NN 42759 1139 12 of of IN 42759 1139 13 farm farm NN 42759 1139 14 families family NNS 42759 1139 15 in in IN 42759 1139 16 the the DT 42759 1139 17 United United NNP 42759 1139 18 States States NNP 42759 1139 19 owning own VBG 42759 1139 20 farm farm NN 42759 1139 21 land land NN 42759 1139 22 , , , 42759 1139 23 mortgaged mortgage VBD 42759 1139 24 or or CC 42759 1139 25 unmortgaged unmortgage VBD 42759 1139 26 , , , 42759 1139 27 declined decline VBD 42759 1139 28 from from IN 42759 1139 29 65.9 65.9 CD 42759 1139 30 per per NN 42759 1139 31 cent cent NN 42759 1139 32 . . . 42759 1140 1 to to IN 42759 1140 2 62.8 62.8 CD 42759 1140 3 per per NN 42759 1140 4 cent cent NN 42759 1140 5 . . . 42759 1141 1 ; ; : 42759 1141 2 the the DT 42759 1141 3 proportion proportion NN 42759 1141 4 of of IN 42759 1141 5 urban urban JJ 42759 1141 6 families family NNS 42759 1141 7 owning own VBG 42759 1141 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1141 9 homes home NNS 42759 1141 10 , , , 42759 1141 11 encumbered encumbered JJ 42759 1141 12 or or CC 42759 1141 13 unencumbered unencumbered JJ 42759 1141 14 , , , 42759 1141 15 increased increase VBD 42759 1141 16 from from IN 42759 1141 17 36.9 36.9 CD 42759 1141 18 to to IN 42759 1141 19 38.4 38.4 CD 42759 1141 20 per per IN 42759 1141 21 cent cent NN 42759 1141 22 . . . 42759 1141 23 , , , 42759 1141 24 and and CC 42759 1141 25 the the DT 42759 1141 26 proportion proportion NN 42759 1141 27 of of IN 42759 1141 28 all all DT 42759 1141 29 families family NNS 42759 1141 30 owning own VBG 42759 1141 31 homes home NNS 42759 1141 32 , , , 42759 1141 33 encumbered encumber VBN 42759 1141 34 or or CC 42759 1141 35 unencumbered unencumbered JJ 42759 1141 36 , , , 42759 1141 37 fell fall VBD 42759 1141 38 from from IN 42759 1141 39 47.8 47.8 CD 42759 1141 40 to to IN 42759 1141 41 45.8 45.8 CD 42759 1141 42 per per IN 42759 1141 43 cent cent NN 42759 1141 44 . . . 42759 1142 1 Of of IN 42759 1142 2 the the DT 42759 1142 3 homes home NNS 42759 1142 4 owned own VBN 42759 1142 5 by by IN 42759 1142 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1142 7 occupiers occupier NNS 42759 1142 8 , , , 42759 1142 9 28 28 CD 42759 1142 10 per per NN 42759 1142 11 cent cent NN 42759 1142 12 . . . 42759 1143 1 were be VBD 42759 1143 2 mortgaged mortgage VBN 42759 1143 3 in in IN 42759 1143 4 1890 1890 CD 42759 1143 5 , , , 42759 1143 6 and and CC 42759 1143 7 32.8 32.8 CD 42759 1143 8 per per IN 42759 1143 9 cent cent NN 42759 1143 10 . . . 42759 1144 1 in in IN 42759 1144 2 1910 1910 CD 42759 1144 3 . . . 42759 1145 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1145 2 72 72 CD 42759 1145 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1145 4 While while IN 42759 1145 5 a a DT 42759 1145 6 decline decline NN 42759 1145 7 of of IN 42759 1145 8 two two CD 42759 1145 9 per per NN 42759 1145 10 cent cent NN 42759 1145 11 . . . 42759 1146 1 in in IN 42759 1146 2 the the DT 42759 1146 3 home home NN 42759 1146 4 owning owning NN 42759 1146 5 and and CC 42759 1146 6 landowning landowne VBG 42759 1146 7 families family NNS 42759 1146 8 in in IN 42759 1146 9 twenty twenty CD 42759 1146 10 years year NNS 42759 1146 11 , , , 42759 1146 12 and and CC 42759 1146 13 an an DT 42759 1146 14 increase increase NN 42759 1146 15 of of IN 42759 1146 16 almost almost RB 42759 1146 17 five five CD 42759 1146 18 per per IN 42759 1146 19 cent cent NN 42759 1146 20 . . . 42759 1147 1 in in IN 42759 1147 2 the the DT 42759 1147 3 number number NN 42759 1147 4 of of IN 42759 1147 5 those those DT 42759 1147 6 families family NNS 42759 1147 7 who who WP 42759 1147 8 hold hold VBP 42759 1147 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1147 10 property property NN 42759 1147 11 subject subject NN 42759 1147 12 to to IN 42759 1147 13 encumbrance encumbrance NN 42759 1147 14 , , , 42759 1147 15 may may MD 42759 1147 16 not not RB 42759 1147 17 seem seem VB 42759 1147 18 very very RB 42759 1147 19 serious serious JJ 42759 1147 20 in in IN 42759 1147 21 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 1147 22 , , , 42759 1147 23 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1147 24 indicate indicate VBP 42759 1147 25 a a DT 42759 1147 26 definitely definitely RB 42759 1147 27 unhealthy unhealthy JJ 42759 1147 28 trend trend NN 42759 1147 29 . . . 42759 1148 1 Not not RB 42759 1148 2 only only RB 42759 1148 3 are be VBP 42759 1148 4 the the DT 42759 1148 5 landowning landowne VBG 42759 1148 6 families family NNS 42759 1148 7 in in IN 42759 1148 8 a a DT 42759 1148 9 minority minority NN 42759 1148 10 , , , 42759 1148 11 but but CC 42759 1148 12 the the DT 42759 1148 13 minority minority NN 42759 1148 14 is be VBZ 42759 1148 15 becoming become VBG 42759 1148 16 smaller small JJR 42759 1148 17 . . . 42759 1149 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 1149 2 , , , 42759 1149 3 when when WRB 42759 1149 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1149 5 consider consider VBP 42759 1149 6 the the DT 42759 1149 7 amount amount NN 42759 1149 8 of of IN 42759 1149 9 gains gain NNS 42759 1149 10 accruing accrue VBG 42759 1149 11 to to IN 42759 1149 12 the the DT 42759 1149 13 average average JJ 42759 1149 14 member member NN 42759 1149 15 of of IN 42759 1149 16 the the DT 42759 1149 17 landowning landowning NN 42759 1149 18 class class NN 42759 1149 19 , , , 42759 1149 20 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1149 21 do do VBP 42759 1149 22 not not RB 42759 1149 23 find find VB 42759 1149 24 that that IN 42759 1149 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1149 26 is be VBZ 42759 1149 27 unreasonably unreasonably RB 42759 1149 28 large large JJ 42759 1149 29 . . . 42759 1150 1 The the DT 42759 1150 2 great great JJ 42759 1150 3 majority majority NN 42759 1150 4 of of IN 42759 1150 5 landed landed JJ 42759 1150 6 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 1150 7 have have VBP 42759 1150 8 not not RB 42759 1150 9 received receive VBN 42759 1150 10 , , , 42759 1150 11 nor nor CC 42759 1150 12 are be VBP 42759 1150 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1150 14 likely likely JJ 42759 1150 15 to to TO 42759 1150 16 receive receive VB 42759 1150 17 , , , 42759 1150 18 from from IN 42759 1150 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1150 20 holdings holding NNS 42759 1150 21 incomes income NNS 42759 1150 22 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 1150 23 large large JJ 42759 1150 24 to to TO 42759 1150 25 be be VB 42759 1150 26 called call VBN 42759 1150 27 excessive excessive JJ 42759 1150 28 shares share NNS 42759 1150 29 of of IN 42759 1150 30 the the DT 42759 1150 31 national national JJ 42759 1150 32 product product NN 42759 1150 33 . . . 42759 1151 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1151 2 gross gross JJ 42759 1151 3 returns return NNS 42759 1151 4 from from IN 42759 1151 5 land land NN 42759 1151 6 have have VBP 42759 1151 7 not not RB 42759 1151 8 exceeded exceed VBN 42759 1151 9 the the DT 42759 1151 10 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 1151 11 of of IN 42759 1151 12 fair fair JJ 42759 1151 13 interest interest NN 42759 1151 14 on on IN 42759 1151 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1151 16 actual actual JJ 42759 1151 17 investment investment NN 42759 1151 18 , , , 42759 1151 19 and and CC 42759 1151 20 fair fair JJ 42759 1151 21 wages wage NNS 42759 1151 22 for for IN 42759 1151 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1151 24 labour labour NN 42759 1151 25 . . . 42759 1152 1 The the DT 42759 1152 2 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1152 3 who who WP 42759 1152 4 have have VBP 42759 1152 5 been be VBN 42759 1152 6 enabled enable VBN 42759 1152 7 through through IN 42759 1152 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1152 9 holdings holding NNS 42759 1152 10 to to TO 42759 1152 11 rise rise VB 42759 1152 12 above above IN 42759 1152 13 the the DT 42759 1152 14 level level NN 42759 1152 15 of of IN 42759 1152 16 moderate moderate JJ 42759 1152 17 living living NN 42759 1152 18 constitute constitute VB 42759 1152 19 a a DT 42759 1152 20 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 1152 21 small small JJ 42759 1152 22 minority minority NN 42759 1152 23 . . . 42759 1153 1 And and CC 42759 1153 2 these these DT 42759 1153 3 statements statement NNS 42759 1153 4 are be VBP 42759 1153 5 true true JJ 42759 1153 6 of of IN 42759 1153 7 both both CC 42759 1153 8 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1153 9 and and CC 42759 1153 10 urban urban JJ 42759 1153 11 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 1153 12 . . . 42759 1154 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1154 2 is be VBZ 42759 1154 3 true true JJ 42759 1154 4 that that IN 42759 1154 5 a a DT 42759 1154 6 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1154 7 number number NN 42759 1154 8 of of IN 42759 1154 9 persons person NNS 42759 1154 10 , , , 42759 1154 11 absolutely absolutely RB 42759 1154 12 speaking speak VBG 42759 1154 13 , , , 42759 1154 14 have have VBP 42759 1154 15 amassed amass VBN 42759 1154 16 great great JJ 42759 1154 17 wealth wealth NN 42759 1154 18 out out IN 42759 1154 19 of of IN 42759 1154 20 land land NN 42759 1154 21 . . . 42759 1155 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1155 2 is be VBZ 42759 1155 3 a a DT 42759 1155 4 well well RB 42759 1155 5 known know VBN 42759 1155 6 fact fact NN 42759 1155 7 that that IN 42759 1155 8 land land NN 42759 1155 9 was be VBD 42759 1155 10 the the DT 42759 1155 11 principal principal JJ 42759 1155 12 source source NN 42759 1155 13 of of IN 42759 1155 14 the the DT 42759 1155 15 great great JJ 42759 1155 16 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 1155 17 and and CC 42759 1155 18 post post JJ 42759 1155 19 - - JJ 42759 1155 20 mediæval mediæval JJ 42759 1155 21 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 1155 22 , , , 42759 1155 23 down down RB 42759 1155 24 to to IN 42759 1155 25 the the DT 42759 1155 26 end end NN 42759 1155 27 of of IN 42759 1155 28 the the DT 42759 1155 29 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 42759 1155 30 century century NN 42759 1155 31 . . . 42759 1156 1 " " `` 42759 1156 2 The the DT 42759 1156 3 historical historical JJ 42759 1156 4 foundation foundation NN 42759 1156 5 of of IN 42759 1156 6 capitalism capitalism NN 42759 1156 7 is be VBZ 42759 1156 8 rent rent NN 42759 1156 9 . . . 42759 1157 1 " " `` 42759 1157 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1157 3 73 73 CD 42759 1157 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1157 5 Capitalism Capitalism NNP 42759 1157 6 had have VBD 42759 1157 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1157 8 beginning beginning NN 42759 1157 9 in in IN 42759 1157 10 the the DT 42759 1157 11 revenue revenue NN 42759 1157 12 from from IN 42759 1157 13 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1157 14 lands land NNS 42759 1157 15 , , , 42759 1157 16 city city NN 42759 1157 17 sites site NNS 42759 1157 18 , , , 42759 1157 19 and and CC 42759 1157 20 mines mine NNS 42759 1157 21 . . . 42759 1158 1 A a DT 42759 1158 2 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 42759 1158 3 example example NN 42759 1158 4 is be VBZ 42759 1158 5 that that DT 42759 1158 6 of of IN 42759 1158 7 the the DT 42759 1158 8 great great JJ 42759 1158 9 Fugger Fugger NNP 42759 1158 10 family family NN 42759 1158 11 of of IN 42759 1158 12 the the DT 42759 1158 13 sixteenth sixteenth JJ 42759 1158 14 century century NN 42759 1158 15 , , , 42759 1158 16 whose whose WP$ 42759 1158 17 wealth wealth NN 42759 1158 18 was be VBD 42759 1158 19 mostly mostly RB 42759 1158 20 derived derive VBN 42759 1158 21 from from IN 42759 1158 22 the the DT 42759 1158 23 ownership ownership NN 42759 1158 24 and and CC 42759 1158 25 exploitation exploitation NN 42759 1158 26 of of IN 42759 1158 27 rich rich JJ 42759 1158 28 mineral mineral NN 42759 1158 29 lands land NNS 42759 1158 30 . . . 42759 1159 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1159 2 74 74 CD 42759 1159 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1159 4 In in IN 42759 1159 5 the the DT 42759 1159 6 United United NNP 42759 1159 7 States States NNP 42759 1159 8 very very RB 42759 1159 9 few few JJ 42759 1159 10 large large JJ 42759 1159 11 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 1159 12 have have VBP 42759 1159 13 been be VBN 42759 1159 14 obtained obtain VBN 42759 1159 15 from from IN 42759 1159 16 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1159 17 land land NN 42759 1159 18 , , , 42759 1159 19 but but CC 42759 1159 20 the the DT 42759 1159 21 same same JJ 42759 1159 22 is be VBZ 42759 1159 23 not not RB 42759 1159 24 true true JJ 42759 1159 25 of of IN 42759 1159 26 mineral mineral JJ 42759 1159 27 lands land NNS 42759 1159 28 , , , 42759 1159 29 timber timber NN 42759 1159 30 lands land NNS 42759 1159 31 , , , 42759 1159 32 or or CC 42759 1159 33 urban urban JJ 42759 1159 34 sites site NNS 42759 1159 35 . . . 42759 1160 1 " " `` 42759 1160 2 The the DT 42759 1160 3 growth growth NN 42759 1160 4 of of IN 42759 1160 5 cities city NNS 42759 1160 6 has have VBZ 42759 1160 7 , , , 42759 1160 8 through through IN 42759 1160 9 real real JJ 42759 1160 10 estate estate NN 42759 1160 11 speculation speculation NN 42759 1160 12 and and CC 42759 1160 13 incremental incremental JJ 42759 1160 14 income income NN 42759 1160 15 , , , 42759 1160 16 made make VBD 42759 1160 17 many many JJ 42759 1160 18 of of IN 42759 1160 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1160 20 millionaires millionaire NNS 42759 1160 21 . . . 42759 1161 1 " " `` 42759 1161 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1161 3 75 75 CD 42759 1161 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1161 5 " " `` 42759 1161 6 As as IN 42759 1161 7 with with IN 42759 1161 8 the the DT 42759 1161 9 unearned unearned JJ 42759 1161 10 income income NN 42759 1161 11 of of IN 42759 1161 12 city city NN 42759 1161 13 land land NN 42759 1161 14 , , , 42759 1161 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1161 16 mineral mineral NN 42759 1161 17 resources resource NNS 42759 1161 18 have have VBP 42759 1161 19 been be VBN 42759 1161 20 conspicuously conspicuously RB 42759 1161 21 prolific prolific JJ 42759 1161 22 producers producer NNS 42759 1161 23 of of IN 42759 1161 24 millionaires millionaire NNS 42759 1161 25 . . . 42759 1162 1 " " `` 42759 1162 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1162 3 76 76 CD 42759 1162 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1162 5 The the DT 42759 1162 6 most most RBS 42759 1162 7 striking striking JJ 42759 1162 8 instance instance NN 42759 1162 9 of of IN 42759 1162 10 great great JJ 42759 1162 11 wealth wealth NN 42759 1162 12 derived derive VBN 42759 1162 13 from from IN 42759 1162 14 urban urban JJ 42759 1162 15 land land NN 42759 1162 16 is be VBZ 42759 1162 17 the the DT 42759 1162 18 fortune fortune NN 42759 1162 19 of of IN 42759 1162 20 the the DT 42759 1162 21 Astor Astor NNP 42759 1162 22 family family NN 42759 1162 23 . . . 42759 1163 1 While while IN 42759 1163 2 gains gain NNS 42759 1163 3 from from IN 42759 1163 4 trading trading NN 42759 1163 5 ventures venture NNS 42759 1163 6 formed form VBD 42759 1163 7 the the DT 42759 1163 8 beginning beginning NN 42759 1163 9 of of IN 42759 1163 10 the the DT 42759 1163 11 riches rich NNS 42759 1163 12 of of IN 42759 1163 13 the the DT 42759 1163 14 original original JJ 42759 1163 15 Astor Astor NNP 42759 1163 16 , , , 42759 1163 17 John John NNP 42759 1163 18 Jacob Jacob NNP 42759 1163 19 , , , 42759 1163 20 these these DT 42759 1163 21 were be VBD 42759 1163 22 " " `` 42759 1163 23 a a DT 42759 1163 24 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 1163 25 insignificant insignificant JJ 42759 1163 26 portion portion NN 42759 1163 27 of of IN 42759 1163 28 the the DT 42759 1163 29 great great JJ 42759 1163 30 fortune fortune NN 42759 1163 31 which which WDT 42759 1163 32 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1163 33 transmitted transmit VBD 42759 1163 34 to to IN 42759 1163 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1163 36 descendants descendant NNS 42759 1163 37 . . . 42759 1164 1 " " `` 42759 1164 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1164 3 77 77 CD 42759 1164 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1164 5 At at IN 42759 1164 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1164 7 death death NN 42759 1164 8 , , , 42759 1164 9 in in IN 42759 1164 10 1848 1848 CD 42759 1164 11 , , , 42759 1164 12 John John NNP 42759 1164 13 Jacob Jacob NNP 42759 1164 14 Astor Astor NNP 42759 1164 15 's 's POS 42759 1164 16 real real JJ 42759 1164 17 estate estate NN 42759 1164 18 holdings holding NNS 42759 1164 19 in in IN 42759 1164 20 New New NNP 42759 1164 21 York York NNP 42759 1164 22 City City NNP 42759 1164 23 were be VBD 42759 1164 24 valued value VBN 42759 1164 25 at at IN 42759 1164 26 eighteen eighteen CD 42759 1164 27 or or CC 42759 1164 28 twenty twenty CD 42759 1164 29 million million CD 42759 1164 30 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1164 31 . . . 42759 1165 1 To to NN 42759 1165 2 - - HYPH 42759 1165 3 day day NN 42759 1165 4 the the DT 42759 1165 5 Astor Astor NNP 42759 1165 6 estate estate NN 42759 1165 7 in in IN 42759 1165 8 that that DT 42759 1165 9 city city NN 42759 1165 10 is be VBZ 42759 1165 11 estimated estimate VBN 42759 1165 12 at at IN 42759 1165 13 between between IN 42759 1165 14 450 450 CD 42759 1165 15 and and CC 42759 1165 16 500 500 CD 42759 1165 17 millions million NNS 42759 1165 18 , , , 42759 1165 19 and and CC 42759 1165 20 within within IN 42759 1165 21 a a DT 42759 1165 22 quarter quarter NN 42759 1165 23 of of IN 42759 1165 24 a a DT 42759 1165 25 century century NN 42759 1165 26 will will MD 42759 1165 27 not not RB 42759 1165 28 improbably improbably RB 42759 1165 29 be be VB 42759 1165 30 worth worth JJ 42759 1165 31 one one CD 42759 1165 32 billion billion CD 42759 1165 33 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1165 34 . . . 42759 1166 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1166 2 78 78 CD 42759 1166 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1166 4 According accord VBG 42759 1166 5 to to IN 42759 1166 6 an an DT 42759 1166 7 investigation investigation NN 42759 1166 8 made make VBN 42759 1166 9 in in IN 42759 1166 10 1892 1892 CD 42759 1166 11 by by IN 42759 1166 12 the the DT 42759 1166 13 _ _ NNP 42759 1166 14 New New NNP 42759 1166 15 York York NNP 42759 1166 16 Tribune Tribune NNP 42759 1166 17 _ _ NNP 42759 1166 18 , , , 42759 1166 19 26.4 26.4 CD 42759 1166 20 per per IN 42759 1166 21 cent cent NN 42759 1166 22 . . . 42759 1167 1 of of IN 42759 1167 2 the the DT 42759 1167 3 millionaire millionaire NN 42759 1167 4 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 1167 5 of of IN 42759 1167 6 the the DT 42759 1167 7 United United NNP 42759 1167 8 States States NNP 42759 1167 9 at at IN 42759 1167 10 that that DT 42759 1167 11 time time NN 42759 1167 12 were be VBD 42759 1167 13 traceable traceable JJ 42759 1167 14 to to IN 42759 1167 15 landownership landownership NN 42759 1167 16 , , , 42759 1167 17 while while IN 42759 1167 18 41.5 41.5 CD 42759 1167 19 per per IN 42759 1167 20 cent cent NN 42759 1167 21 . . . 42759 1168 1 were be VBD 42759 1168 2 derived derive VBN 42759 1168 3 from from IN 42759 1168 4 competitive competitive JJ 42759 1168 5 industries industry NNS 42759 1168 6 which which WDT 42759 1168 7 were be VBD 42759 1168 8 largely largely RB 42759 1168 9 assisted assist VBN 42759 1168 10 by by IN 42759 1168 11 land land NN 42759 1168 12 possessions possession NNS 42759 1168 13 . . . 42759 1169 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1169 2 79 79 LS 42759 1169 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1169 4 The the DT 42759 1169 5 proportion proportion NN 42759 1169 6 of of IN 42759 1169 7 such such JJ 42759 1169 8 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 1169 9 that that WDT 42759 1169 10 is be VBZ 42759 1169 11 due due JJ 42759 1169 12 , , , 42759 1169 13 directly directly RB 42759 1169 14 or or CC 42759 1169 15 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 1169 16 , , , 42759 1169 17 in in IN 42759 1169 18 whole whole NN 42759 1169 19 or or CC 42759 1169 20 in in IN 42759 1169 21 part part NN 42759 1169 22 , , , 42759 1169 23 to to IN 42759 1169 24 landownership landownership NN 42759 1169 25 has have VBZ 42759 1169 26 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 1169 27 increased increase VBN 42759 1169 28 considerably considerably RB 42759 1169 29 since since IN 42759 1169 30 1892 1892 CD 42759 1169 31 . . . 42759 1170 1 With with IN 42759 1170 2 regard regard NN 42759 1170 3 to to IN 42759 1170 4 great great JJ 42759 1170 5 individual individual JJ 42759 1170 6 or or CC 42759 1170 7 corporate corporate JJ 42759 1170 8 land land NN 42759 1170 9 holdings holding NNS 42759 1170 10 , , , 42759 1170 11 there there EX 42759 1170 12 exist exist VBP 42759 1170 13 no no DT 42759 1170 14 adequate adequate JJ 42759 1170 15 statistics statistic NNS 42759 1170 16 . . . 42759 1171 1 A a DT 42759 1171 2 few few JJ 42759 1171 3 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 42759 1171 4 instances instance NNS 42759 1171 5 may may MD 42759 1171 6 be be VB 42759 1171 7 cited cite VBN 42759 1171 8 . . . 42759 1172 1 The the DT 42759 1172 2 United United NNP 42759 1172 3 States States NNP 42759 1172 4 Steel Steel NNP 42759 1172 5 Corporation Corporation NNP 42759 1172 6 owns own VBZ 42759 1172 7 lands land NNS 42759 1172 8 yielding yield VBG 42759 1172 9 iron iron NN 42759 1172 10 ore ore NN 42759 1172 11 , , , 42759 1172 12 coal coal NN 42759 1172 13 , , , 42759 1172 14 coke coke NN 42759 1172 15 , , , 42759 1172 16 and and CC 42759 1172 17 timber timber NN 42759 1172 18 which which WDT 42759 1172 19 are be VBP 42759 1172 20 valued value VBN 42759 1172 21 by by IN 42759 1172 22 the the DT 42759 1172 23 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 1172 24 of of IN 42759 1172 25 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 1172 26 at at IN 42759 1172 27 nearly nearly RB 42759 1172 28 250 250 CD 42759 1172 29 million million CD 42759 1172 30 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1172 31 , , , 42759 1172 32 and and CC 42759 1172 33 by by IN 42759 1172 34 the the DT 42759 1172 35 Steel Steel NNP 42759 1172 36 Corporation Corporation NNP 42759 1172 37 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 1172 38 at at IN 42759 1172 39 more more JJR 42759 1172 40 than than IN 42759 1172 41 800 800 CD 42759 1172 42 million million CD 42759 1172 43 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1172 44 . . . 42759 1173 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1173 2 80 80 CD 42759 1173 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1173 4 Three three CD 42759 1173 5 companies company NNS 42759 1173 6 own own VBP 42759 1173 7 nearly nearly RB 42759 1173 8 eleven eleven CD 42759 1173 9 per per IN 42759 1173 10 cent cent NN 42759 1173 11 . . . 42759 1173 12 , , , 42759 1173 13 and and CC 42759 1173 14 195 195 CD 42759 1173 15 individuals individual NNS 42759 1173 16 or or CC 42759 1173 17 corporations corporation NNS 42759 1173 18 own own VBP 42759 1173 19 48 48 CD 42759 1173 20 per per NN 42759 1173 21 cent cent NN 42759 1173 22 . . . 42759 1174 1 of of IN 42759 1174 2 all all PDT 42759 1174 3 the the DT 42759 1174 4 privately privately RB 42759 1174 5 owned own VBN 42759 1174 6 timber timber NN 42759 1174 7 in in IN 42759 1174 8 the the DT 42759 1174 9 United United NNP 42759 1174 10 States States NNP 42759 1174 11 . . . 42759 1175 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1175 2 81 81 CD 42759 1175 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1175 4 The the DT 42759 1175 5 United United NNP 42759 1175 6 States States NNP 42759 1175 7 Census Census NNP 42759 1175 8 of of IN 42759 1175 9 1910 1910 CD 42759 1175 10 shows show VBZ 42759 1175 11 that that IN 42759 1175 12 the the DT 42759 1175 13 number number NN 42759 1175 14 of of IN 42759 1175 15 farms farm NNS 42759 1175 16 containing contain VBG 42759 1175 17 500 500 CD 42759 1175 18 acres acre NNS 42759 1175 19 or or CC 42759 1175 20 over over RB 42759 1175 21 was be VBD 42759 1175 22 about about RB 42759 1175 23 175,000 175,000 CD 42759 1175 24 , , , 42759 1175 25 and and CC 42759 1175 26 comprised comprise VBD 42759 1175 27 ten ten CD 42759 1175 28 per per IN 42759 1175 29 cent cent NN 42759 1175 30 . . . 42759 1176 1 of of IN 42759 1176 2 the the DT 42759 1176 3 total total JJ 42759 1176 4 farm farm NN 42759 1176 5 acreage acreage NN 42759 1176 6 . . . 42759 1177 1 One one CD 42759 1177 2 hundred hundred CD 42759 1177 3 and and CC 42759 1177 4 fifty fifty CD 42759 1177 5 persons person NNS 42759 1177 6 and and CC 42759 1177 7 corporations corporation NNS 42759 1177 8 are be VBP 42759 1177 9 said say VBN 42759 1177 10 to to TO 42759 1177 11 own own VB 42759 1177 12 220,000,000 220,000,000 CD 42759 1177 13 acres acre NNS 42759 1177 14 of of IN 42759 1177 15 various various JJ 42759 1177 16 kinds kind NNS 42759 1177 17 of of IN 42759 1177 18 land land NN 42759 1177 19 . . . 42759 1178 1 None none NN 42759 1178 2 of of IN 42759 1178 3 these these DT 42759 1178 4 holders holder NNS 42759 1178 5 has have VBZ 42759 1178 6 less less JJR 42759 1178 7 than than IN 42759 1178 8 ten ten CD 42759 1178 9 thousand thousand CD 42759 1178 10 acres acre NNS 42759 1178 11 , , , 42759 1178 12 and and CC 42759 1178 13 two two CD 42759 1178 14 of of IN 42759 1178 15 the the DT 42759 1178 16 syndicates syndicate NNS 42759 1178 17 possess possess VBP 42759 1178 18 fifty fifty CD 42759 1178 19 million million CD 42759 1178 20 acres acre NNS 42759 1178 21 each each DT 42759 1178 22 . . . 42759 1179 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1179 2 82 82 CD 42759 1179 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1179 4 _ _ NNP 42759 1179 5 Exclusion Exclusion NNP 42759 1179 6 from from IN 42759 1179 7 the the DT 42759 1179 8 Land Land NNP 42759 1179 9 _ _ NNP 42759 1179 10 One one CD 42759 1179 11 of of IN 42759 1179 12 the the DT 42759 1179 13 most most RBS 42759 1179 14 frequent frequent JJ 42759 1179 15 charges charge NNS 42759 1179 16 brought bring VBN 42759 1179 17 against against IN 42759 1179 18 the the DT 42759 1179 19 present present JJ 42759 1179 20 system system NN 42759 1179 21 of of IN 42759 1179 22 land land NN 42759 1179 23 tenure tenure NN 42759 1179 24 is be VBZ 42759 1179 25 that that IN 42759 1179 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1179 27 keeps keep VBZ 42759 1179 28 a a DT 42759 1179 29 large large JJ 42759 1179 30 proportion proportion NN 42759 1179 31 of of IN 42759 1179 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1179 33 natural natural JJ 42759 1179 34 resources resource NNS 42759 1179 35 out out IN 42759 1179 36 of of IN 42759 1179 37 use use NN 42759 1179 38 . . . 42759 1180 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1180 2 is be VBZ 42759 1180 3 contended contend VBN 42759 1180 4 that that IN 42759 1180 5 this this DT 42759 1180 6 evil evil NN 42759 1180 7 appears appear VBZ 42759 1180 8 in in IN 42759 1180 9 three three CD 42759 1180 10 principal principal JJ 42759 1180 11 forms form NNS 42759 1180 12 : : : 42759 1180 13 owners owner NNS 42759 1180 14 of of IN 42759 1180 15 large large JJ 42759 1180 16 estates estate NNS 42759 1180 17 refuse refuse VBP 42759 1180 18 to to TO 42759 1180 19 break break VB 42759 1180 20 up up RP 42759 1180 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1180 22 holdings holding NNS 42759 1180 23 by by IN 42759 1180 24 sale sale NN 42759 1180 25 ; ; : 42759 1180 26 many many JJ 42759 1180 27 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 1180 28 are be VBP 42759 1180 29 unwilling unwilling JJ 42759 1180 30 to to TO 42759 1180 31 let let VB 42759 1180 32 the the DT 42759 1180 33 use use NN 42759 1180 34 of of IN 42759 1180 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1180 36 land land NN 42759 1180 37 on on IN 42759 1180 38 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 1180 39 terms term NNS 42759 1180 40 ; ; : 42759 1180 41 and and CC 42759 1180 42 a a DT 42759 1180 43 great great JJ 42759 1180 44 deal deal NN 42759 1180 45 of of IN 42759 1180 46 land land NN 42759 1180 47 is be VBZ 42759 1180 48 held hold VBN 42759 1180 49 at at IN 42759 1180 50 speculative speculative JJ 42759 1180 51 prices price NNS 42759 1180 52 , , , 42759 1180 53 instead instead RB 42759 1180 54 of of IN 42759 1180 55 at at IN 42759 1180 56 economic economic JJ 42759 1180 57 prices price NNS 42759 1180 58 . . . 42759 1181 1 So so RB 42759 1181 2 far far RB 42759 1181 3 as as IN 42759 1181 4 the the DT 42759 1181 5 United United NNP 42759 1181 6 States States NNP 42759 1181 7 are be VBP 42759 1181 8 concerned concern VBN 42759 1181 9 , , , 42759 1181 10 the the DT 42759 1181 11 first first JJ 42759 1181 12 of of IN 42759 1181 13 these these DT 42759 1181 14 charges charge NNS 42759 1181 15 does do VBZ 42759 1181 16 not not RB 42759 1181 17 seem seem VB 42759 1181 18 to to TO 42759 1181 19 represent represent VB 42759 1181 20 a a DT 42759 1181 21 condition condition NN 42759 1181 22 that that WDT 42759 1181 23 is be VBZ 42759 1181 24 at at RB 42759 1181 25 all all RB 42759 1181 26 general general JJ 42759 1181 27 . . . 42759 1182 1 Although although IN 42759 1182 2 many many JJ 42759 1182 3 holders holder NNS 42759 1182 4 of of IN 42759 1182 5 large large JJ 42759 1182 6 mineral mineral NN 42759 1182 7 and and CC 42759 1182 8 timber timber NN 42759 1182 9 tracts tract NNS 42759 1182 10 seem seem VBP 42759 1182 11 to to TO 42759 1182 12 be be VB 42759 1182 13 in in IN 42759 1182 14 no no DT 42759 1182 15 hurry hurry NN 42759 1182 16 to to TO 42759 1182 17 sell sell VB 42759 1182 18 portions portion NNS 42759 1182 19 of of IN 42759 1182 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1182 21 holdings holding NNS 42759 1182 22 , , , 42759 1182 23 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1182 24 are be VBP 42759 1182 25 probably probably RB 42759 1182 26 moved move VBN 42759 1182 27 by by IN 42759 1182 28 a a DT 42759 1182 29 desire desire NN 42759 1182 30 to to TO 42759 1182 31 obtain obtain VB 42759 1182 32 higher high JJR 42759 1182 33 prices price NNS 42759 1182 34 rather rather RB 42759 1182 35 than than IN 42759 1182 36 to to TO 42759 1182 37 continue continue VB 42759 1182 38 as as IN 42759 1182 39 large large JJ 42759 1182 40 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1182 41 . . . 42759 1183 1 As as IN 42759 1183 2 a a DT 42759 1183 3 rule rule NN 42759 1183 4 , , , 42759 1183 5 the the DT 42759 1183 6 great great JJ 42759 1183 7 landholders landholder NNS 42759 1183 8 of of IN 42759 1183 9 America America NNP 42759 1183 10 are be VBP 42759 1183 11 without without IN 42759 1183 12 those those DT 42759 1183 13 sentiments sentiment NNS 42759 1183 14 of of IN 42759 1183 15 tradition tradition NN 42759 1183 16 , , , 42759 1183 17 local local JJ 42759 1183 18 attachment attachment NN 42759 1183 19 , , , 42759 1183 20 and and CC 42759 1183 21 social social JJ 42759 1183 22 ascendency ascendency NN 42759 1183 23 which which WDT 42759 1183 24 are be VBP 42759 1183 25 so so RB 42759 1183 26 powerful powerful JJ 42759 1183 27 in in IN 42759 1183 28 maintaining maintain VBG 42759 1183 29 intact intact JJ 42759 1183 30 the the DT 42759 1183 31 immense immense JJ 42759 1183 32 estates estate NNS 42759 1183 33 of of IN 42759 1183 34 Great Great NNP 42759 1183 35 Britain Britain NNP 42759 1183 36 . . . 42759 1184 1 On on IN 42759 1184 2 the the DT 42759 1184 3 contrary contrary NN 42759 1184 4 , , , 42759 1184 5 one one CD 42759 1184 6 of of IN 42759 1184 7 the the DT 42759 1184 8 common common JJ 42759 1184 9 facts fact NNS 42759 1184 10 of of IN 42759 1184 11 to to IN 42759 1184 12 - - HYPH 42759 1184 13 day day NN 42759 1184 14 is be VBZ 42759 1184 15 the the DT 42759 1184 16 persistent persistent JJ 42759 1184 17 effort effort NN 42759 1184 18 carried carry VBN 42759 1184 19 on on RP 42759 1184 20 by by IN 42759 1184 21 railroads railroad NNS 42759 1184 22 and and CC 42759 1184 23 other other JJ 42759 1184 24 holders holder NNS 42759 1184 25 of of IN 42759 1184 26 large large JJ 42759 1184 27 tracts tract NNS 42759 1184 28 to to TO 42759 1184 29 dispose dispose VB 42759 1184 30 of of IN 42759 1184 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1184 32 land land NN 42759 1184 33 to to IN 42759 1184 34 settlers settler NNS 42759 1184 35 . . . 42759 1185 1 While while IN 42759 1185 2 the the DT 42759 1185 3 price price NN 42759 1185 4 asked ask VBN 42759 1185 5 by by IN 42759 1185 6 these these DT 42759 1185 7 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 1185 8 is be VBZ 42759 1185 9 frequently frequently RB 42759 1185 10 higher high JJR 42759 1185 11 than than IN 42759 1185 12 that that DT 42759 1185 13 which which WDT 42759 1185 14 corresponds correspond VBZ 42759 1185 15 to to IN 42759 1185 16 the the DT 42759 1185 17 present present JJ 42759 1185 18 productiveness productiveness NN 42759 1185 19 of of IN 42759 1185 20 the the DT 42759 1185 21 land land NN 42759 1185 22 , , , 42759 1185 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1185 24 is be VBZ 42759 1185 25 generally generally RB 42759 1185 26 as as RB 42759 1185 27 low low JJ 42759 1185 28 as as IN 42759 1185 29 that that DT 42759 1185 30 which which WDT 42759 1185 31 is be VBZ 42759 1185 32 demanded demand VBN 42759 1185 33 by by IN 42759 1185 34 the the DT 42759 1185 35 owners owner NNS 42759 1185 36 of of IN 42759 1185 37 smaller small JJR 42759 1185 38 parcels parcel NNS 42759 1185 39 . . . 42759 1186 1 To to TO 42759 1186 2 be be VB 42759 1186 3 sure sure JJ 42759 1186 4 , , , 42759 1186 5 this this DT 42759 1186 6 is be VBZ 42759 1186 7 one one CD 42759 1186 8 way way NN 42759 1186 9 of of IN 42759 1186 10 unreasonably unreasonably RB 42759 1186 11 hindering hinder VBG 42759 1186 12 access access NN 42759 1186 13 to to IN 42759 1186 14 the the DT 42759 1186 15 land land NN 42759 1186 16 , , , 42759 1186 17 but but CC 42759 1186 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1186 19 falls fall VBZ 42759 1186 20 properly properly RB 42759 1186 21 under under IN 42759 1186 22 the the DT 42759 1186 23 head head NN 42759 1186 24 of of IN 42759 1186 25 the the DT 42759 1186 26 third third JJ 42759 1186 27 charge charge NN 42759 1186 28 enumerated enumerate VBD 42759 1186 29 above above RB 42759 1186 30 . . . 42759 1187 1 There there EX 42759 1187 2 is be VBZ 42759 1187 3 no no DT 42759 1187 4 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 1187 5 evidence evidence NN 42759 1187 6 that that IN 42759 1187 7 the the DT 42759 1187 8 _ _ NNP 42759 1187 9 large large JJ 42759 1187 10 _ _ NNP 42759 1187 11 landholders landholder NNS 42759 1187 12 are be VBP 42759 1187 13 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 1187 14 offenders offender NNS 42759 1187 15 in in IN 42759 1187 16 refusing refuse VBG 42759 1187 17 to to TO 42759 1187 18 sell sell VB 42759 1187 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1187 20 holdings holding NNS 42759 1187 21 to to IN 42759 1187 22 actual actual JJ 42759 1187 23 settlers settler NNS 42759 1187 24 . . . 42759 1188 1 The the DT 42759 1188 2 assertion assertion NN 42759 1188 3 that that WDT 42759 1188 4 unused unused JJ 42759 1188 5 land land NN 42759 1188 6 can can MD 42759 1188 7 not not RB 42759 1188 8 be be VB 42759 1188 9 rented rent VBN 42759 1188 10 on on IN 42759 1188 11 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 1188 12 terms term NNS 42759 1188 13 is be VBZ 42759 1188 14 in in IN 42759 1188 15 the the DT 42759 1188 16 main main JJ 42759 1188 17 unfounded unfounded JJ 42759 1188 18 , , , 42759 1188 19 so so RB 42759 1188 20 far far RB 42759 1188 21 as as IN 42759 1188 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1188 23 refers refer VBZ 42759 1188 24 to to IN 42759 1188 25 land land NN 42759 1188 26 which which WDT 42759 1188 27 is be VBZ 42759 1188 28 desired desire VBN 42759 1188 29 for for IN 42759 1188 30 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 1188 31 . . . 42759 1189 1 As as IN 42759 1189 2 a a DT 42759 1189 3 rule rule NN 42759 1189 4 , , , 42759 1189 5 any any DT 42759 1189 6 man man NN 42759 1189 7 who who WP 42759 1189 8 wishes wish VBZ 42759 1189 9 to to TO 42759 1189 10 cultivate cultivate VB 42759 1189 11 a a DT 42759 1189 12 portion portion NN 42759 1189 13 of of IN 42759 1189 14 such such JJ 42759 1189 15 land land NN 42759 1189 16 can can MD 42759 1189 17 fulfil fulfil VB 42759 1189 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1189 19 desire desire NN 42759 1189 20 if if IN 42759 1189 21 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1189 22 is be VBZ 42759 1189 23 willing willing JJ 42759 1189 24 to to TO 42759 1189 25 pay pay VB 42759 1189 26 a a DT 42759 1189 27 rent rent NN 42759 1189 28 that that WDT 42759 1189 29 corresponds correspond VBZ 42759 1189 30 to to IN 42759 1189 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1189 32 productiveness productiveness NN 42759 1189 33 . . . 42759 1190 1 After after RB 42759 1190 2 all all RB 42759 1190 3 , , , 42759 1190 4 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1190 5 are be VBP 42759 1190 6 neither neither CC 42759 1190 7 fools fool NNS 42759 1190 8 nor nor CC 42759 1190 9 fanatics fanatic NNS 42759 1190 10 : : : 42759 1190 11 while while IN 42759 1190 12 awaiting await VBG 42759 1190 13 a a DT 42759 1190 14 higher high JJR 42759 1190 15 price price NN 42759 1190 16 than than IN 42759 1190 17 is be VBZ 42759 1190 18 now now RB 42759 1190 19 obtainable obtainable JJ 42759 1190 20 for for IN 42759 1190 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1190 22 land land NN 42759 1190 23 , , , 42759 1190 24 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1190 25 would would MD 42759 1190 26 prefer prefer VB 42759 1190 27 to to TO 42759 1190 28 get get VB 42759 1190 29 from from IN 42759 1190 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1190 31 some some DT 42759 1190 32 revenue revenue NN 42759 1190 33 rather rather RB 42759 1190 34 than than IN 42759 1190 35 none none NN 42759 1190 36 at at RB 42759 1190 37 all all RB 42759 1190 38 . . . 42759 1191 1 As as IN 42759 1191 2 a a DT 42759 1191 3 matter matter NN 42759 1191 4 of of IN 42759 1191 5 fact fact NN 42759 1191 6 , , , 42759 1191 7 almost almost RB 42759 1191 8 all all PDT 42759 1191 9 the the DT 42759 1191 10 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1191 11 land land NN 42759 1191 12 that that WDT 42759 1191 13 is be VBZ 42759 1191 14 immediately immediately RB 42759 1191 15 available available JJ 42759 1191 16 for for IN 42759 1191 17 renting renting NN 42759 1191 18 , , , 42759 1191 19 is be VBZ 42759 1191 20 constantly constantly RB 42759 1191 21 under under IN 42759 1191 22 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 1191 23 . . . 42759 1192 1 This this DT 42759 1192 2 refers refer VBZ 42759 1192 3 to to IN 42759 1192 4 land land NN 42759 1192 5 that that WDT 42759 1192 6 is be VBZ 42759 1192 7 already already RB 42759 1192 8 under under IN 42759 1192 9 the the DT 42759 1192 10 plough plough NN 42759 1192 11 , , , 42759 1192 12 and and CC 42759 1192 13 is be VBZ 42759 1192 14 provided provide VBN 42759 1192 15 with with IN 42759 1192 16 buildings building NNS 42759 1192 17 and and CC 42759 1192 18 other other JJ 42759 1192 19 necessary necessary JJ 42759 1192 20 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1192 21 . . . 42759 1193 1 Practically practically RB 42759 1193 2 none none NN 42759 1193 3 of of IN 42759 1193 4 this this DT 42759 1193 5 is be VBZ 42759 1193 6 out out IN 42759 1193 7 of of IN 42759 1193 8 use use NN 42759 1193 9 . . . 42759 1194 1 New new JJ 42759 1194 2 land land NN 42759 1194 3 which which WDT 42759 1194 4 is be VBZ 42759 1194 5 without without IN 42759 1194 6 buildings building NNS 42759 1194 7 is be VBZ 42759 1194 8 not not RB 42759 1194 9 wanted want VBN 42759 1194 10 by by IN 42759 1194 11 tenants tenant NNS 42759 1194 12 , , , 42759 1194 13 unless unless IN 42759 1194 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1194 15 is be VBZ 42759 1194 16 convenient convenient JJ 42759 1194 17 to to IN 42759 1194 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1194 19 residences residence NNS 42759 1194 20 , , , 42759 1194 21 because because IN 42759 1194 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1194 23 do do VBP 42759 1194 24 not not RB 42759 1194 25 desire desire VB 42759 1194 26 to to TO 42759 1194 27 expend expend VB 42759 1194 28 money money NN 42759 1194 29 for for IN 42759 1194 30 permanent permanent JJ 42759 1194 31 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1194 32 upon upon IN 42759 1194 33 land land NN 42759 1194 34 that that WDT 42759 1194 35 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1194 36 do do VBP 42759 1194 37 not not RB 42759 1194 38 own own VB 42759 1194 39 . . . 42759 1195 1 True true JJ 42759 1195 2 , , , 42759 1195 3 the the DT 42759 1195 4 present present JJ 42759 1195 5 owners owner NNS 42759 1195 6 of of IN 42759 1195 7 such such JJ 42759 1195 8 land land NN 42759 1195 9 might may MD 42759 1195 10 erect erect VB 42759 1195 11 buildings building NNS 42759 1195 12 , , , 42759 1195 13 and and CC 42759 1195 14 then then RB 42759 1195 15 let let VB 42759 1195 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1195 17 to to IN 42759 1195 18 tenants tenant NNS 42759 1195 19 . . . 42759 1196 1 In in IN 42759 1196 2 so so RB 42759 1196 3 far far RB 42759 1196 4 as as IN 42759 1196 5 new new JJ 42759 1196 6 land land NN 42759 1196 7 might may MD 42759 1196 8 profitably profitably RB 42759 1196 9 be be VB 42759 1196 10 improved improve VBN 42759 1196 11 and and CC 42759 1196 12 cultivated cultivate VBN 42759 1196 13 , , , 42759 1196 14 and and CC 42759 1196 15 in in IN 42759 1196 16 so so RB 42759 1196 17 far far RB 42759 1196 18 as as IN 42759 1196 19 the the DT 42759 1196 20 owners owner NNS 42759 1196 21 are be VBP 42759 1196 22 unwilling unwilling JJ 42759 1196 23 or or CC 42759 1196 24 unable unable JJ 42759 1196 25 to to TO 42759 1196 26 provide provide VB 42759 1196 27 the the DT 42759 1196 28 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1196 29 , , , 42759 1196 30 the the DT 42759 1196 31 present present JJ 42759 1196 32 system system NN 42759 1196 33 does do VBZ 42759 1196 34 keep keep VB 42759 1196 35 out out IN 42759 1196 36 of of IN 42759 1196 37 use use VB 42759 1196 38 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1196 39 land land NN 42759 1196 40 that that WDT 42759 1196 41 could could MD 42759 1196 42 be be VB 42759 1196 43 cultivated cultivate VBN 42759 1196 44 by by IN 42759 1196 45 tenants tenant NNS 42759 1196 46 . . . 42759 1197 1 Mineral mineral NN 42759 1197 2 and and CC 42759 1197 3 timber timber NN 42759 1197 4 lands land NNS 42759 1197 5 are be VBP 42759 1197 6 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 1197 7 withheld withhold VBN 42759 1197 8 from from IN 42759 1197 9 tenants tenant NNS 42759 1197 10 because because IN 42759 1197 11 the the DT 42759 1197 12 owners owner NNS 42759 1197 13 wish wish VBP 42759 1197 14 to to TO 42759 1197 15 limit limit VB 42759 1197 16 the the DT 42759 1197 17 supply supply NN 42759 1197 18 of of IN 42759 1197 19 the the DT 42759 1197 20 product product NN 42759 1197 21 , , , 42759 1197 22 or or CC 42759 1197 23 because because IN 42759 1197 24 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1197 25 fear fear VBP 42759 1197 26 that that IN 42759 1197 27 a a DT 42759 1197 28 long long JJ 42759 1197 29 - - HYPH 42759 1197 30 term term NN 42759 1197 31 lease lease NN 42759 1197 32 would would MD 42759 1197 33 prevent prevent VB 42759 1197 34 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1197 35 from from IN 42759 1197 36 selling sell VBG 42759 1197 37 the the DT 42759 1197 38 land land NN 42759 1197 39 to to IN 42759 1197 40 the the DT 42759 1197 41 best good JJS 42759 1197 42 advantage advantage NN 42759 1197 43 . . . 42759 1198 1 As as IN 42759 1198 2 to to IN 42759 1198 3 urban urban JJ 42759 1198 4 sites site NNS 42759 1198 5 , , , 42759 1198 6 the the DT 42759 1198 7 contention contention NN 42759 1198 8 that that IN 42759 1198 9 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1198 10 are be VBP 42759 1198 11 now now RB 42759 1198 12 examining examine VBG 42759 1198 13 is be VBZ 42759 1198 14 generally generally RB 42759 1198 15 true true JJ 42759 1198 16 . . . 42759 1199 1 The the DT 42759 1199 2 practice practice NN 42759 1199 3 of of IN 42759 1199 4 leasing lease VBG 42759 1199 5 land land NN 42759 1199 6 to to IN 42759 1199 7 persons person NNS 42759 1199 8 who who WP 42759 1199 9 wish wish VBP 42759 1199 10 to to TO 42759 1199 11 build build VB 42759 1199 12 thereon thereon NN 42759 1199 13 does do VBZ 42759 1199 14 not not RB 42759 1199 15 , , , 42759 1199 16 with with IN 42759 1199 17 the the DT 42759 1199 18 exception exception NN 42759 1199 19 of of IN 42759 1199 20 a a DT 42759 1199 21 very very RB 42759 1199 22 few few JJ 42759 1199 23 cities city NNS 42759 1199 24 , , , 42759 1199 25 obtain obtain VBP 42759 1199 26 in in IN 42759 1199 27 the the DT 42759 1199 28 United United NNP 42759 1199 29 States States NNP 42759 1199 30 for for IN 42759 1199 31 other other JJ 42759 1199 32 than than IN 42759 1199 33 very very RB 42759 1199 34 large large JJ 42759 1199 35 business business NN 42759 1199 36 structures structure NNS 42759 1199 37 . . . 42759 1200 1 As as IN 42759 1200 2 a a DT 42759 1200 3 rule rule NN 42759 1200 4 , , , 42759 1200 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1200 6 does do VBZ 42759 1200 7 not not RB 42759 1200 8 apply apply VB 42759 1200 9 to to IN 42759 1200 10 sites site NNS 42759 1200 11 for for IN 42759 1200 12 residences residence NNS 42759 1200 13 . . . 42759 1201 1 The the DT 42759 1201 2 man man NN 42759 1201 3 who who WP 42759 1201 4 wants want VBZ 42759 1201 5 a a DT 42759 1201 6 piece piece NN 42759 1201 7 of of IN 42759 1201 8 urban urban JJ 42759 1201 9 land land NN 42759 1201 10 for for IN 42759 1201 11 a a DT 42759 1201 12 dwelling dwelling NN 42759 1201 13 or or CC 42759 1201 14 for for IN 42759 1201 15 a a DT 42759 1201 16 moderately moderately RB 42759 1201 17 sized sized JJ 42759 1201 18 business business NN 42759 1201 19 building building NN 42759 1201 20 can can MD 42759 1201 21 not not RB 42759 1201 22 obtain obtain VB 42759 1201 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1201 24 except except IN 42759 1201 25 by by IN 42759 1201 26 purchase purchase NN 42759 1201 27 . . . 42759 1202 1 Can can MD 42759 1202 2 not not RB 42759 1202 3 the the DT 42759 1202 4 land land NN 42759 1202 5 be be VB 42759 1202 6 bought buy VBN 42759 1202 7 at at IN 42759 1202 8 a a DT 42759 1202 9 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 1202 10 price price NN 42759 1202 11 ? ? . 42759 1203 1 This this DT 42759 1203 2 brings bring VBZ 42759 1203 3 us -PRON- PRP 42759 1203 4 to to IN 42759 1203 5 the the DT 42759 1203 6 third third JJ 42759 1203 7 and and CC 42759 1203 8 most most RBS 42759 1203 9 serious serious JJ 42759 1203 10 of of IN 42759 1203 11 the the DT 42759 1203 12 charges charge NNS 42759 1203 13 concerning concern VBG 42759 1203 14 exclusion exclusion NN 42759 1203 15 from from IN 42759 1203 16 the the DT 42759 1203 17 land land NN 42759 1203 18 . . . 42759 1204 1 Since since IN 42759 1204 2 the the DT 42759 1204 3 value value NN 42759 1204 4 of of IN 42759 1204 5 land land NN 42759 1204 6 in in IN 42759 1204 7 most most JJS 42759 1204 8 cities city NNS 42759 1204 9 is be VBZ 42759 1204 10 rising rise VBG 42759 1204 11 , , , 42759 1204 12 and and CC 42759 1204 13 apparently apparently RB 42759 1204 14 will will MD 42759 1204 15 continue continue VB 42759 1204 16 to to TO 42759 1204 17 rise rise VB 42759 1204 18 more more RBR 42759 1204 19 or or CC 42759 1204 20 less less RBR 42759 1204 21 steadily steadily RB 42759 1204 22 , , , 42759 1204 23 the the DT 42759 1204 24 price price NN 42759 1204 25 at at IN 42759 1204 26 which which WDT 42759 1204 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1204 28 is be VBZ 42759 1204 29 held hold VBN 42759 1204 30 and and CC 42759 1204 31 purchasable purchasable JJ 42759 1204 32 is be VBZ 42759 1204 33 not not RB 42759 1204 34 the the DT 42759 1204 35 economic economic JJ 42759 1204 36 price price NN 42759 1204 37 but but CC 42759 1204 38 a a DT 42759 1204 39 speculative speculative JJ 42759 1204 40 price price NN 42759 1204 41 . . . 42759 1205 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1205 2 is be VBZ 42759 1205 3 higher high JJR 42759 1205 4 than than IN 42759 1205 5 the the DT 42759 1205 6 capitalised capitalise VBN 42759 1205 7 value value NN 42759 1205 8 of of IN 42759 1205 9 the the DT 42759 1205 10 present present JJ 42759 1205 11 revenue revenue NN 42759 1205 12 or or CC 42759 1205 13 rent rent NN 42759 1205 14 . . . 42759 1206 1 For for IN 42759 1206 2 example example NN 42759 1206 3 : : : 42759 1206 4 if if IN 42759 1206 5 five five CD 42759 1206 6 per per IN 42759 1206 7 cent cent NN 42759 1206 8 . . . 42759 1207 1 be be VB 42759 1207 2 the the DT 42759 1207 3 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 1207 4 rate rate NN 42759 1207 5 of of IN 42759 1207 6 interest interest NN 42759 1207 7 , , , 42759 1207 8 a a DT 42759 1207 9 piece piece NN 42759 1207 10 of of IN 42759 1207 11 land land NN 42759 1207 12 which which WDT 42759 1207 13 returns return VBZ 42759 1207 14 that that IN 42759 1207 15 rate rate NN 42759 1207 16 on on IN 42759 1207 17 a a DT 42759 1207 18 capital capital NN 42759 1207 19 of of IN 42759 1207 20 one one CD 42759 1207 21 thousand thousand CD 42759 1207 22 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1207 23 can can MD 42759 1207 24 not not RB 42759 1207 25 be be VB 42759 1207 26 bought buy VBN 42759 1207 27 for for IN 42759 1207 28 one one CD 42759 1207 29 thousand thousand CD 42759 1207 30 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1207 31 . . . 42759 1208 1 The the DT 42759 1208 2 purchaser purchaser NN 42759 1208 3 is be VBZ 42759 1208 4 willing willing JJ 42759 1208 5 to to TO 42759 1208 6 pay pay VB 42759 1208 7 more more JJR 42759 1208 8 because because IN 42759 1208 9 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1208 10 hopes hope VBZ 42759 1208 11 to to TO 42759 1208 12 sell sell VB 42759 1208 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1208 14 for for IN 42759 1208 15 a a DT 42759 1208 16 still still RB 42759 1208 17 higher high JJR 42759 1208 18 price price NN 42759 1208 19 within within IN 42759 1208 20 a a DT 42759 1208 21 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 1208 22 time time NN 42759 1208 23 . . . 42759 1209 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 1209 2 knows know VBZ 42759 1209 3 that that IN 42759 1209 4 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1209 5 can can MD 42759 1209 6 not not RB 42759 1209 7 immediately immediately RB 42759 1209 8 obtain obtain VB 42759 1209 9 five five CD 42759 1209 10 per per IN 42759 1209 11 cent cent NN 42759 1209 12 . . . 42759 1210 1 on on IN 42759 1210 2 the the DT 42759 1210 3 amount amount NN 42759 1210 4 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1210 5 say say UH 42759 1210 6 , , , 42759 1210 7 1,200 1,200 CD 42759 1210 8 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1210 9 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1210 10 that that IN 42759 1210 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1210 12 is be VBZ 42759 1210 13 ready ready JJ 42759 1210 14 to to TO 42759 1210 15 pay pay VB 42759 1210 16 for for IN 42759 1210 17 the the DT 42759 1210 18 land land NN 42759 1210 19 , , , 42759 1210 20 but but CC 42759 1210 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1210 22 valuation valuation NN 42759 1210 23 of of IN 42759 1210 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1210 25 is be VBZ 42759 1210 26 not not RB 42759 1210 27 determined determine VBN 42759 1210 28 merely merely RB 42759 1210 29 by by IN 42759 1210 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1210 31 present present JJ 42759 1210 32 income income NN 42759 1210 33 - - HYPH 42759 1210 34 producing produce VBG 42759 1210 35 power power NN 42759 1210 36 , , , 42759 1210 37 but but CC 42759 1210 38 by by IN 42759 1210 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1210 40 anticipated anticipate VBN 42759 1210 41 revenue revenue NN 42759 1210 42 value value NN 42759 1210 43 and and CC 42759 1210 44 selling selling NN 42759 1210 45 value value NN 42759 1210 46 . . . 42759 1211 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1211 2 83 83 CD 42759 1211 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1211 4 The the DT 42759 1211 5 buyer buyer NN 42759 1211 6 will will MD 42759 1211 7 pay pay VB 42759 1211 8 more more JJR 42759 1211 9 for for IN 42759 1211 10 such such JJ 42759 1211 11 land land NN 42759 1211 12 than than IN 42759 1211 13 for for IN 42759 1211 14 a a DT 42759 1211 15 house house NN 42759 1211 16 which which WDT 42759 1211 17 yields yield VBZ 42759 1211 18 the the DT 42759 1211 19 same same JJ 42759 1211 20 return return NN 42759 1211 21 ; ; : 42759 1211 22 for for IN 42759 1211 23 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1211 24 knows know VBZ 42759 1211 25 that that IN 42759 1211 26 the the DT 42759 1211 27 latter latter JJ 42759 1211 28 will will MD 42759 1211 29 not not RB 42759 1211 30 , , , 42759 1211 31 and and CC 42759 1211 32 hopes hope VBZ 42759 1211 33 that that IN 42759 1211 34 the the DT 42759 1211 35 former former JJ 42759 1211 36 will will NN 42759 1211 37 , , , 42759 1211 38 bring bring VB 42759 1211 39 a a DT 42759 1211 40 higher high JJR 42759 1211 41 return return NN 42759 1211 42 and and CC 42759 1211 43 a a DT 42759 1211 44 higher high JJR 42759 1211 45 price price NN 42759 1211 46 in in IN 42759 1211 47 the the DT 42759 1211 48 future future NN 42759 1211 49 . . . 42759 1212 1 Wherever wherever WRB 42759 1212 2 this this DT 42759 1212 3 discounting discounting NN 42759 1212 4 of of IN 42759 1212 5 the the DT 42759 1212 6 future future JJ 42759 1212 7 obtains obtain NNS 42759 1212 8 , , , 42759 1212 9 the the DT 42759 1212 10 price price NN 42759 1212 11 of of IN 42759 1212 12 land land NN 42759 1212 13 is be VBZ 42759 1212 14 unreasonably unreasonably RB 42759 1212 15 high high JJ 42759 1212 16 , , , 42759 1212 17 and and CC 42759 1212 18 access access NN 42759 1212 19 to to IN 42759 1212 20 vacant vacant JJ 42759 1212 21 land land NN 42759 1212 22 is be VBZ 42759 1212 23 unreasonably unreasonably RB 42759 1212 24 difficult difficult JJ 42759 1212 25 . . . 42759 1213 1 This this DT 42759 1213 2 condition condition NN 42759 1213 3 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 1213 4 exists exist VBZ 42759 1213 5 most most JJS 42759 1213 6 of of IN 42759 1213 7 the the DT 42759 1213 8 time time NN 42759 1213 9 in in IN 42759 1213 10 the the DT 42759 1213 11 great great JJ 42759 1213 12 majority majority NN 42759 1213 13 of of IN 42759 1213 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1213 15 larger large JJR 42759 1213 16 cities city NNS 42759 1213 17 . . . 42759 1214 1 Men man NNS 42759 1214 2 will will MD 42759 1214 3 not not RB 42759 1214 4 sell sell VB 42759 1214 5 vacant vacant JJ 42759 1214 6 land land NN 42759 1214 7 at at IN 42759 1214 8 a a DT 42759 1214 9 price price NN 42759 1214 10 which which WDT 42759 1214 11 will will MD 42759 1214 12 enable enable VB 42759 1214 13 the the DT 42759 1214 14 buyer buyer NN 42759 1214 15 to to TO 42759 1214 16 obtain obtain VB 42759 1214 17 immediately immediately RB 42759 1214 18 a a DT 42759 1214 19 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 1214 20 return return NN 42759 1214 21 on on IN 42759 1214 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1214 23 investment investment NN 42759 1214 24 . . . 42759 1215 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 1215 2 demand demand VBP 42759 1215 3 in in IN 42759 1215 4 addition addition NN 42759 1215 5 a a DT 42759 1215 6 part part NN 42759 1215 7 of of IN 42759 1215 8 the the DT 42759 1215 9 anticipated anticipated JJ 42759 1215 10 increase increase NN 42759 1215 11 in in IN 42759 1215 12 value value NN 42759 1215 13 . . . 42759 1216 1 In in IN 42759 1216 2 the the DT 42759 1216 3 rural rural JJ 42759 1216 4 regions region NNS 42759 1216 5 this this DT 42759 1216 6 evil evil NN 42759 1216 7 appears appear VBZ 42759 1216 8 to to TO 42759 1216 9 be be VB 42759 1216 10 smaller small JJR 42759 1216 11 and and CC 42759 1216 12 less less RBR 42759 1216 13 general general JJ 42759 1216 14 . . . 42759 1217 1 The the DT 42759 1217 2 owners owner NNS 42759 1217 3 of of IN 42759 1217 4 unused unused JJ 42759 1217 5 or or CC 42759 1217 6 uneconomically uneconomically RB 42759 1217 7 used use VBN 42759 1217 8 arable arable JJ 42759 1217 9 land land NN 42759 1217 10 are be VBP 42759 1217 11 more more RBR 42759 1217 12 eager eager JJ 42759 1217 13 to to TO 42759 1217 14 sell sell VB 42759 1217 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1217 16 holdings holding NNS 42759 1217 17 than than IN 42759 1217 18 the the DT 42759 1217 19 average average JJ 42759 1217 20 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 1217 21 of of IN 42759 1217 22 a a DT 42759 1217 23 vacant vacant JJ 42759 1217 24 lot lot NN 42759 1217 25 . . . 42759 1218 1 So so RB 42759 1218 2 far far RB 42759 1218 3 as as IN 42759 1218 4 this this DT 42759 1218 5 sort sort NN 42759 1218 6 of of IN 42759 1218 7 land land NN 42759 1218 8 is be VBZ 42759 1218 9 concerned concern VBN 42759 1218 10 , , , 42759 1218 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1218 12 is be VBZ 42759 1218 13 probable probable JJ 42759 1218 14 that that IN 42759 1218 15 most most JJS 42759 1218 16 of of IN 42759 1218 17 the the DT 42759 1218 18 denunciation denunciation NN 42759 1218 19 of of IN 42759 1218 20 " " `` 42759 1218 21 land land NN 42759 1218 22 speculators speculator NNS 42759 1218 23 " " '' 42759 1218 24 and and CC 42759 1218 25 " " `` 42759 1218 26 land land NN 42759 1218 27 monopolists monopolist NNS 42759 1218 28 " " `` 42759 1218 29 overshoots overshoot VBZ 42759 1218 30 the the DT 42759 1218 31 mark mark NN 42759 1218 32 . . . 42759 1219 1 Not not RB 42759 1219 2 the the DT 42759 1219 3 high high JJ 42759 1219 4 price price NN 42759 1219 5 at at IN 42759 1219 6 which which WDT 42759 1219 7 unused unused JJ 42759 1219 8 arable arable JJ 42759 1219 9 lands land NNS 42759 1219 10 are be VBP 42759 1219 11 held hold VBN 42759 1219 12 , , , 42759 1219 13 but but CC 42759 1219 14 the the DT 42759 1219 15 great great JJ 42759 1219 16 initial initial JJ 42759 1219 17 cost cost NN 42759 1219 18 of of IN 42759 1219 19 draining draining NN 42759 1219 20 , , , 42759 1219 21 clearing clearing NN 42759 1219 22 , , , 42759 1219 23 or or CC 42759 1219 24 irrigating irrigate VBG 42759 1219 25 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1219 26 , , , 42759 1219 27 is be VBZ 42759 1219 28 the the DT 42759 1219 29 main main JJ 42759 1219 30 reason reason NN 42759 1219 31 why why WRB 42759 1219 32 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1219 33 are be VBP 42759 1219 34 not not RB 42759 1219 35 purchased purchase VBN 42759 1219 36 by by IN 42759 1219 37 cultivators cultivator NNS 42759 1219 38 . . . 42759 1220 1 While while IN 42759 1220 2 no no DT 42759 1220 3 general general JJ 42759 1220 4 and and CC 42759 1220 5 precise precise JJ 42759 1220 6 estimate estimate NN 42759 1220 7 can can MD 42759 1220 8 be be VB 42759 1220 9 given give VBN 42759 1220 10 of of IN 42759 1220 11 the the DT 42759 1220 12 extent extent NN 42759 1220 13 to to TO 42759 1220 14 which which WDT 42759 1220 15 the the DT 42759 1220 16 speculative speculative NN 42759 1220 17 exceeds exceed VBZ 42759 1220 18 the the DT 42759 1220 19 actual actual JJ 42759 1220 20 rent rent NN 42759 1220 21 - - HYPH 42759 1220 22 producing produce VBG 42759 1220 23 value value NN 42759 1220 24 of of IN 42759 1220 25 land land NN 42759 1220 26 in in IN 42759 1220 27 growing grow VBG 42759 1220 28 cities city NNS 42759 1220 29 , , , 42759 1220 30 twenty twenty CD 42759 1220 31 - - HYPH 42759 1220 32 five five CD 42759 1220 33 per per IN 42759 1220 34 cent cent NN 42759 1220 35 . . . 42759 1221 1 would would MD 42759 1221 2 not not RB 42759 1221 3 improbably improbably RB 42759 1221 4 be be VB 42759 1221 5 a a DT 42759 1221 6 fair fair JJ 42759 1221 7 conjecture conjecture NN 42759 1221 8 . . . 42759 1222 1 Even even RB 42759 1222 2 when when WRB 42759 1222 3 a a DT 42759 1222 4 reaction reaction NN 42759 1222 5 occurs occur VBZ 42759 1222 6 after after IN 42759 1222 7 a a DT 42759 1222 8 period period NN 42759 1222 9 of of IN 42759 1222 10 excessive excessive JJ 42759 1222 11 " " `` 42759 1222 12 land land NN 42759 1222 13 - - HYPH 42759 1222 14 booming booming NN 42759 1222 15 , , , 42759 1222 16 " " '' 42759 1222 17 the the DT 42759 1222 18 lower low JJR 42759 1222 19 prices price NNS 42759 1222 20 do do VBP 42759 1222 21 not not RB 42759 1222 22 bring bring VB 42759 1222 23 the the DT 42759 1222 24 manless manless JJ 42759 1222 25 land land NN 42759 1222 26 any any DT 42759 1222 27 nearer nearer NN 42759 1222 28 to to IN 42759 1222 29 the the DT 42759 1222 30 landless landless JJ 42759 1222 31 men man NNS 42759 1222 32 . . . 42759 1223 1 Only only RB 42759 1223 2 the the DT 42759 1223 3 few few JJ 42759 1223 4 who who WP 42759 1223 5 possess possess VBP 42759 1223 6 ready ready JJ 42759 1223 7 money money NN 42759 1223 8 or or CC 42759 1223 9 excellent excellent JJ 42759 1223 10 credit credit NN 42759 1223 11 can can MD 42759 1223 12 take take VB 42759 1223 13 advantage advantage NN 42759 1223 14 of of IN 42759 1223 15 such such PDT 42759 1223 16 a a DT 42759 1223 17 situation situation NN 42759 1223 18 . . . 42759 1224 1 On on IN 42759 1224 2 the the DT 42759 1224 3 whole whole NN 42759 1224 4 the the DT 42759 1224 5 evil evil NN 42759 1224 6 that that WDT 42759 1224 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1224 8 are be VBP 42759 1224 9 now now RB 42759 1224 10 considering consider VBG 42759 1224 11 is be VBZ 42759 1224 12 probably probably RB 42759 1224 13 greater great JJR 42759 1224 14 than than IN 42759 1224 15 any any DT 42759 1224 16 other other JJ 42759 1224 17 connected connect VBN 42759 1224 18 with with IN 42759 1224 19 the the DT 42759 1224 20 private private JJ 42759 1224 21 ownership ownership NN 42759 1224 22 of of IN 42759 1224 23 land land NN 42759 1224 24 . . . 42759 1225 1 All all PDT 42759 1225 2 the the DT 42759 1225 3 tendencies tendency NNS 42759 1225 4 and and CC 42759 1225 5 forces force NNS 42759 1225 6 that that WDT 42759 1225 7 have have VBP 42759 1225 8 been be VBN 42759 1225 9 described describe VBN 42759 1225 10 in in IN 42759 1225 11 the the DT 42759 1225 12 present present JJ 42759 1225 13 chapter chapter NN 42759 1225 14 under under IN 42759 1225 15 the the DT 42759 1225 16 heads head NNS 42759 1225 17 of of IN 42759 1225 18 Monopoly Monopoly NNP 42759 1225 19 , , , 42759 1225 20 Excessive Excessive NNP 42759 1225 21 Gains Gains NNPS 42759 1225 22 , , , 42759 1225 23 and and CC 42759 1225 24 Exclusion exclusion NN 42759 1225 25 from from IN 42759 1225 26 the the DT 42759 1225 27 Land Land NNP 42759 1225 28 , , , 42759 1225 29 are be VBP 42759 1225 30 in in IN 42759 1225 31 some some DT 42759 1225 32 degree degree NN 42759 1225 33 real real JJ 42759 1225 34 defects defect NNS 42759 1225 35 and and CC 42759 1225 36 abuses abuse NNS 42759 1225 37 of of IN 42759 1225 38 the the DT 42759 1225 39 existing exist VBG 42759 1225 40 system system NN 42759 1225 41 of of IN 42759 1225 42 land land NN 42759 1225 43 tenure tenure NN 42759 1225 44 . . . 42759 1226 1 Most Most JJS 42759 1226 2 of of IN 42759 1226 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1226 4 do do VBP 42759 1226 5 not not RB 42759 1226 6 seem seem VB 42759 1226 7 to to TO 42759 1226 8 be be VB 42759 1226 9 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 1226 10 understood understand VBN 42759 1226 11 or or CC 42759 1226 12 appreciated appreciate VBN 42759 1226 13 by by IN 42759 1226 14 the the DT 42759 1226 15 more more RBR 42759 1226 16 ardent ardent JJ 42759 1226 17 defenders defender NNS 42759 1226 18 of of IN 42759 1226 19 private private JJ 42759 1226 20 ownership ownership NN 42759 1226 21 . . . 42759 1227 1 To to TO 42759 1227 2 recognise recognise VB 42759 1227 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1227 4 , , , 42759 1227 5 and and CC 42759 1227 6 to to TO 42759 1227 7 seek seek VB 42759 1227 8 adequate adequate JJ 42759 1227 9 correctives corrective NNS 42759 1227 10 of of IN 42759 1227 11 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1227 12 would would MD 42759 1227 13 seem seem VB 42759 1227 14 to to TO 42759 1227 15 be be VB 42759 1227 16 the the DT 42759 1227 17 task task NN 42759 1227 18 of of IN 42759 1227 19 both both CC 42759 1227 20 righteousness righteousness NN 42759 1227 21 and and CC 42759 1227 22 expediency expediency NN 42759 1227 23 . . . 42759 1228 1 In in IN 42759 1228 2 the the DT 42759 1228 3 next next JJ 42759 1228 4 and and CC 42759 1228 5 final final JJ 42759 1228 6 chapter chapter NN 42759 1228 7 of of IN 42759 1228 8 this this DT 42759 1228 9 Section Section NNP 42759 1228 10 , , , 42759 1228 11 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1228 12 shall shall MD 42759 1228 13 consider consider VB 42759 1228 14 certain certain JJ 42759 1228 15 remedies remedy NNS 42759 1228 16 that that WDT 42759 1228 17 seem seem VBP 42759 1228 18 to to TO 42759 1228 19 be be VB 42759 1228 20 at at IN 42759 1228 21 once once RB 42759 1228 22 effective effective JJ 42759 1228 23 and and CC 42759 1228 24 just just RB 42759 1228 25 . . . 42759 1229 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 1229 2 : : : 42759 1229 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1229 4 49 49 CD 42759 1229 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1229 6 " " `` 42759 1229 7 Report Report NNP 42759 1229 8 of of IN 42759 1229 9 the the DT 42759 1229 10 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 1229 11 of of IN 42759 1229 12 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 1229 13 on on IN 42759 1229 14 the the DT 42759 1229 15 Petroleum Petroleum NNP 42759 1229 16 Industry Industry NNP 42759 1229 17 , , , 42759 1229 18 " " `` 42759 1229 19 Part part NN 42759 1229 20 I -PRON- PRP 42759 1229 21 , , , 42759 1229 22 p. p. NN 42759 1229 23 8 8 CD 42759 1229 24 . . . 42759 1230 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1230 2 50 50 CD 42759 1230 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1230 4 P. p. NN 42759 1230 5 138 138 CD 42759 1230 6 . . . 42759 1231 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1231 2 51 51 CD 42759 1231 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1231 4 Cf cf NN 42759 1231 5 . . . 42759 1232 1 Ely Ely NNP 42759 1232 2 , , , 42759 1232 3 " " `` 42759 1232 4 Monopolies Monopolies NNPS 42759 1232 5 and and CC 42759 1232 6 Trusts Trusts NNPS 42759 1232 7 , , , 42759 1232 8 " " '' 42759 1232 9 pp pp NNP 42759 1232 10 . . . 42759 1233 1 59 59 CD 42759 1233 2 , , , 42759 1233 3 sq sq NNP 42759 1233 4 . . . 42759 1234 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1234 2 52 52 CD 42759 1234 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1234 4 P. P. NNP 42759 1234 5 133 133 CD 42759 1234 6 . . . 42759 1235 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1235 2 53 53 CD 42759 1235 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1235 4 Pp Pp NNP 42759 1235 5 . . . 42759 1236 1 68 68 CD 42759 1236 2 , , , 42759 1236 3 69 69 CD 42759 1236 4 . . . 42759 1237 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1237 2 54 54 CD 42759 1237 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1237 4 " " `` 42759 1237 5 Final Final NNP 42759 1237 6 Report Report NNP 42759 1237 7 of of IN 42759 1237 8 the the DT 42759 1237 9 U. U. NNP 42759 1237 10 S. S. NNP 42759 1237 11 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 1237 12 Commission Commission NNP 42759 1237 13 , , , 42759 1237 14 " " '' 42759 1237 15 p. p. NN 42759 1237 16 463 463 CD 42759 1237 17 ; ; : 42759 1237 18 Bliss Bliss NNP 42759 1237 19 , , , 42759 1237 20 " " `` 42759 1237 21 New new JJ 42759 1237 22 Encyclopedia Encyclopedia NNP 42759 1237 23 of of IN 42759 1237 24 Social Social NNP 42759 1237 25 Reform Reform NNP 42759 1237 26 , , , 42759 1237 27 " " '' 42759 1237 28 pp pp NNP 42759 1237 29 . . . 42759 1238 1 245 245 CD 42759 1238 2 , , , 42759 1238 3 770 770 CD 42759 1238 4 ; ; : 42759 1238 5 Van Van NNP 42759 1238 6 Hise Hise NNP 42759 1238 7 , , , 42759 1238 8 " " `` 42759 1238 9 Concentration Concentration NNP 42759 1238 10 and and CC 42759 1238 11 Control Control NNP 42759 1238 12 , , , 42759 1238 13 " " '' 42759 1238 14 pp pp NNP 42759 1238 15 . . . 42759 1239 1 32 32 CD 42759 1239 2 , , , 42759 1239 3 33 33 CD 42759 1239 4 . . . 42759 1240 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1240 2 55 55 CD 42759 1240 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1240 4 Idem Idem NNP 42759 1240 5 , , , 42759 1240 6 pp pp NNP 42759 1240 7 . . . 42759 1241 1 46 46 CD 42759 1241 2 , , , 42759 1241 3 47 47 CD 42759 1241 4 ; ; : 42759 1241 5 cf cf NN 42759 1241 6 . . . 42759 1242 1 " " `` 42759 1242 2 Final Final NNP 42759 1242 3 Report Report NNP 42759 1242 4 of of IN 42759 1242 5 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 1242 6 Commission Commission NNP 42759 1242 7 , , , 42759 1242 8 " " '' 42759 1242 9 pp pp NNP 42759 1242 10 . . . 42759 1243 1 463 463 CD 42759 1243 2 - - SYM 42759 1243 3 465 465 CD 42759 1243 4 . . . 42759 1244 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1244 2 56 56 CD 42759 1244 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1244 4 " " `` 42759 1244 5 Report Report NNP 42759 1244 6 of of IN 42759 1244 7 the the DT 42759 1244 8 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 1244 9 of of IN 42759 1244 10 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 1244 11 on on IN 42759 1244 12 the the DT 42759 1244 13 Steel Steel NNP 42759 1244 14 Industry industry NN 42759 1244 15 , , , 42759 1244 16 " " `` 42759 1244 17 Part part NN 42759 1244 18 I -PRON- PRP 42759 1244 19 , , , 42759 1244 20 p. p. NN 42759 1244 21 60 60 CD 42759 1244 22 . . . 42759 1245 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1245 2 57 57 CD 42759 1245 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1245 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 1245 5 . . . 42759 1246 1 Hobson Hobson NNP 42759 1246 2 , , , 42759 1246 3 " " `` 42759 1246 4 The the DT 42759 1246 5 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 1246 6 System System NNP 42759 1246 7 , , , 42759 1246 8 " " '' 42759 1246 9 pp pp NNP 42759 1246 10 . . . 42759 1247 1 192 192 CD 42759 1247 2 - - SYM 42759 1247 3 197 197 CD 42759 1247 4 . . . 42759 1248 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1248 2 58 58 CD 42759 1248 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1248 4 Pp Pp NNP 42759 1248 5 . . . 42759 1249 1 15 15 CD 42759 1249 2 , , , 42759 1249 3 16 16 CD 42759 1249 4 , , , 42759 1249 5 29 29 CD 42759 1249 6 - - SYM 42759 1249 7 31 31 CD 42759 1249 8 . . . 42759 1250 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1250 2 59 59 CD 42759 1250 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1250 4 Cf cf NN 42759 1250 5 . . . 42759 1251 1 " " `` 42759 1251 2 Progress Progress NNP 42759 1251 3 and and CC 42759 1251 4 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 1251 5 , , , 42759 1251 6 " " '' 42759 1251 7 books book NNS 42759 1251 8 III III NNP 42759 1251 9 and and CC 42759 1251 10 IV IV NNP 42759 1251 11 . . . 42759 1252 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1252 2 60 60 CD 42759 1252 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1252 4 Cf cf NN 42759 1252 5 . . . 42759 1253 1 Walker Walker NNP 42759 1253 2 , , , 42759 1253 3 " " `` 42759 1253 4 Land land NN 42759 1253 5 and and CC 42759 1253 6 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1253 7 Rent Rent NNP 42759 1253 8 , , , 42759 1253 9 " " '' 42759 1253 10 pp pp NNP 42759 1253 11 . . . 42759 1254 1 168 168 CD 42759 1254 2 - - SYM 42759 1254 3 182 182 CD 42759 1254 4 , , , 42759 1254 5 Boston Boston NNP 42759 1254 6 , , , 42759 1254 7 1883 1883 CD 42759 1254 8 . . . 42759 1255 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1255 2 61 61 CD 42759 1255 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1255 4 Page page NN 42759 1255 5 158 158 CD 42759 1255 6 . . . 42759 1256 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1256 2 62 62 CD 42759 1256 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1256 4 Page page NN 42759 1256 5 160 160 CD 42759 1256 6 . . . 42759 1257 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1257 2 63 63 CD 42759 1257 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1257 4 Page page NN 42759 1257 5 158 158 CD 42759 1257 6 ; ; : 42759 1257 7 footnote footnote NN 42759 1257 8 . . . 42759 1258 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1258 2 64 64 CD 42759 1258 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1258 4 " " `` 42759 1258 5 Privilege Privilege NNP 42759 1258 6 and and CC 42759 1258 7 Democracy Democracy NNP 42759 1258 8 , , , 42759 1258 9 " " '' 42759 1258 10 p. p. NN 42759 1258 11 307 307 CD 42759 1258 12 . . . 42759 1259 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1259 2 65 65 CD 42759 1259 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1259 4 Page page NN 42759 1259 5 160 160 CD 42759 1259 6 . . . 42759 1260 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1260 2 66 66 CD 42759 1260 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1260 4 Op Op NNP 42759 1260 5 . . . 42759 1261 1 cit cit NNP 42759 1261 2 . . NNP 42759 1261 3 , , , 42759 1261 4 pages page VBZ 42759 1261 5 160 160 CD 42759 1261 6 , , , 42759 1261 7 158 158 CD 42759 1261 8 . . . 42759 1262 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1262 2 67 67 CD 42759 1262 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1262 4 Professor Professor NNP 42759 1262 5 Nearing Nearing NNP 42759 1262 6 in in IN 42759 1262 7 " " `` 42759 1262 8 The the DT 42759 1262 9 Annals Annals NNPS 42759 1262 10 of of IN 42759 1262 11 the the DT 42759 1262 12 American American NNP 42759 1262 13 Academy Academy NNP 42759 1262 14 of of IN 42759 1262 15 Political Political NNP 42759 1262 16 and and CC 42759 1262 17 Social Social NNP 42759 1262 18 Science Science NNP 42759 1262 19 , , , 42759 1262 20 " " '' 42759 1262 21 March March NNP 42759 1262 22 , , , 42759 1262 23 1915 1915 CD 42759 1262 24 . . . 42759 1263 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1263 2 68 68 CD 42759 1263 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1263 4 Thirteenth Thirteenth NNP 42759 1263 5 Census Census NNP 42759 1263 6 , , , 42759 1263 7 Bulletin Bulletin NNP 42759 1263 8 on on IN 42759 1263 9 " " `` 42759 1263 10 Farms Farms NNPS 42759 1263 11 and and CC 42759 1263 12 Farm Farm NNP 42759 1263 13 Property Property NNP 42759 1263 14 , , , 42759 1263 15 " " '' 42759 1263 16 page page NN 42759 1263 17 1 1 CD 42759 1263 18 . . . 42759 1264 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1264 2 69 69 CD 42759 1264 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1264 4 _ _ NNP 42759 1264 5 The The NNP 42759 1264 6 Public Public NNP 42759 1264 7 _ _ NNP 42759 1264 8 , , , 42759 1264 9 Nov. November NNP 42759 1264 10 26 26 CD 42759 1264 11 , , , 42759 1264 12 1915 1915 CD 42759 1264 13 . . . 42759 1265 1 For for IN 42759 1265 2 an an DT 42759 1265 3 account account NN 42759 1265 4 of of IN 42759 1265 5 increases increase NNS 42759 1265 6 in in IN 42759 1265 7 the the DT 42759 1265 8 principal principal JJ 42759 1265 9 European european JJ 42759 1265 10 cities city NNS 42759 1265 11 , , , 42759 1265 12 see see VB 42759 1265 13 Camille Camille NNP 42759 1265 14 - - HYPH 42759 1265 15 Husymans Husymans NNPS 42759 1265 16 , , , 42759 1265 17 " " '' 42759 1265 18 La La NNP 42759 1265 19 plus plus JJ 42759 1265 20 - - HYPH 42759 1265 21 value value NN 42759 1265 22 immobilière immobilière NN 42759 1265 23 dans dan NNS 42759 1265 24 les les VBP 42759 1265 25 communes communes NNP 42759 1265 26 belges belge NNS 42759 1265 27 " " '' 42759 1265 28 ; ; : 42759 1265 29 Gand Gand NNP 42759 1265 30 , , , 42759 1265 31 1909 1909 CD 42759 1265 32 . . . 42759 1266 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1266 2 70 70 CD 42759 1266 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1266 4 " " `` 42759 1266 5 Report Report NNP 42759 1266 6 of of IN 42759 1266 7 the the DT 42759 1266 8 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 1266 9 of of IN 42759 1266 10 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 1266 11 on on IN 42759 1266 12 the the DT 42759 1266 13 Lumber Lumber NNP 42759 1266 14 Industry Industry NNP 42759 1266 15 , , , 42759 1266 16 " " `` 42759 1266 17 Part part NN 42759 1266 18 I I NNP 42759 1266 19 , , , 42759 1266 20 pp pp ADD 42759 1266 21 . . . 42759 1267 1 214 214 CD 42759 1267 2 - - SYM 42759 1267 3 216 216 CD 42759 1267 4 . . . 42759 1268 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1268 2 71 71 CD 42759 1268 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1268 4 King King NNP 42759 1268 5 , , , 42759 1268 6 op op NN 42759 1268 7 . . . 42759 1269 1 cit cit NNP 42759 1269 2 . . . 42759 1269 3 , , , 42759 1269 4 p. p. NN 42759 1269 5 158 158 CD 42759 1269 6 . . . 42759 1270 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1270 2 72 72 CD 42759 1270 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1270 4 Thirteenth Thirteenth NNP 42759 1270 5 Census Census NNP 42759 1270 6 , , , 42759 1270 7 Vol Vol NNP 42759 1270 8 . . . 42759 1271 1 I -PRON- PRP 42759 1271 2 , , , 42759 1271 3 p. p. NN 42759 1271 4 1295 1295 CD 42759 1271 5 . . . 42759 1272 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1272 2 73 73 CD 42759 1272 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1272 4 Hobson Hobson NNP 42759 1272 5 , , , 42759 1272 6 " " `` 42759 1272 7 The the DT 42759 1272 8 Evolution Evolution NNP 42759 1272 9 of of IN 42759 1272 10 Modern Modern NNP 42759 1272 11 Capitalism Capitalism NNP 42759 1272 12 , , , 42759 1272 13 " " '' 42759 1272 14 p. p. NN 42759 1272 15 4 4 CD 42759 1272 16 ; ; : 42759 1272 17 London London NNP 42759 1272 18 , , , 42759 1272 19 1907 1907 CD 42759 1272 20 . . . 42759 1273 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1273 2 74 74 CD 42759 1273 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1273 4 _ _ NNP 42759 1273 5 Harper Harper NNP 42759 1273 6 's 's POS 42759 1273 7 Monthly Monthly NNP 42759 1273 8 Magazine Magazine NNP 42759 1273 9 _ _ NNP 42759 1273 10 , , , 42759 1273 11 Jan. January NNP 42759 1273 12 , , , 42759 1273 13 1910 1910 CD 42759 1273 14 . . . 42759 1274 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1274 2 75 75 CD 42759 1274 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1274 4 Watkins Watkins NNP 42759 1274 5 , , , 42759 1274 6 " " `` 42759 1274 7 The the DT 42759 1274 8 Growth growth NN 42759 1274 9 of of IN 42759 1274 10 Large large JJ 42759 1274 11 Fortunes Fortunes NNPS 42759 1274 12 , , , 42759 1274 13 " " '' 42759 1274 14 p. p. NN 42759 1274 15 75 75 CD 42759 1274 16 ; ; : 42759 1274 17 N. N. NNP 42759 1274 18 Y. Y. NNP 42759 1274 19 , , , 42759 1274 20 1907 1907 CD 42759 1274 21 . . . 42759 1275 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1275 2 76 76 CD 42759 1275 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1275 4 Idem Idem NNP 42759 1275 5 , , , 42759 1275 6 p. p. NN 42759 1275 7 93 93 CD 42759 1275 8 . . . 42759 1276 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1276 2 77 77 CD 42759 1276 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1276 4 Youngman Youngman NNP 42759 1276 5 , , , 42759 1276 6 " " `` 42759 1276 7 The the DT 42759 1276 8 Economic Economic NNP 42759 1276 9 Causes Causes NNPS 42759 1276 10 of of IN 42759 1276 11 Great Great NNP 42759 1276 12 Fortunes Fortunes NNPS 42759 1276 13 , , , 42759 1276 14 " " '' 42759 1276 15 p. p. NN 42759 1276 16 45 45 CD 42759 1276 17 ; ; : 42759 1276 18 N. N. NNP 42759 1276 19 Y. Y. NNP 42759 1276 20 , , , 42759 1276 21 1909 1909 CD 42759 1276 22 . . . 42759 1277 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1277 2 78 78 CD 42759 1277 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1277 4 Howe Howe NNP 42759 1277 5 , , , 42759 1277 6 op op NN 42759 1277 7 . . . 42759 1278 1 cit cit NNP 42759 1278 2 . . . 42759 1278 3 , , , 42759 1278 4 pp pp NNP 42759 1278 5 . . . 42759 1279 1 125 125 CD 42759 1279 2 , , , 42759 1279 3 126 126 CD 42759 1279 4 . . . 42759 1280 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1280 2 79 79 CD 42759 1280 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1280 4 Cf cf NN 42759 1280 5 . . . 42759 1281 1 Commons common NNS 42759 1281 2 , , , 42759 1281 3 " " `` 42759 1281 4 The the DT 42759 1281 5 Distribution distribution NN 42759 1281 6 of of IN 42759 1281 7 Wealth wealth NN 42759 1281 8 , , , 42759 1281 9 " " '' 42759 1281 10 pp pp NNP 42759 1281 11 . . . 42759 1282 1 252 252 CD 42759 1282 2 , , , 42759 1282 3 257 257 CD 42759 1282 4 ; ; : 42759 1282 5 N. N. NNP 42759 1282 6 Y. Y. NNP 42759 1282 7 , , , 42759 1282 8 1893 1893 CD 42759 1282 9 . . . 42759 1283 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1283 2 80 80 CD 42759 1283 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1283 4 " " `` 42759 1283 5 Report Report NNP 42759 1283 6 of of IN 42759 1283 7 the the DT 42759 1283 8 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 1283 9 of of IN 42759 1283 10 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 1283 11 on on IN 42759 1283 12 the the DT 42759 1283 13 Steel Steel NNP 42759 1283 14 Industry industry NN 42759 1283 15 , , , 42759 1283 16 " " `` 42759 1283 17 Part part NN 42759 1283 18 I -PRON- PRP 42759 1283 19 , , , 42759 1283 20 p. p. NN 42759 1283 21 314 314 CD 42759 1283 22 . . . 42759 1284 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1284 2 81 81 CD 42759 1284 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1284 4 " " `` 42759 1284 5 Summary Summary NNP 42759 1284 6 of of IN 42759 1284 7 Report Report NNP 42759 1284 8 of of IN 42759 1284 9 the the DT 42759 1284 10 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 1284 11 of of IN 42759 1284 12 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 1284 13 on on IN 42759 1284 14 the the DT 42759 1284 15 Lumber Lumber NNP 42759 1284 16 Industry Industry NNP 42759 1284 17 , , , 42759 1284 18 " " '' 42759 1284 19 pp pp NNP 42759 1284 20 . . . 42759 1285 1 3 3 CD 42759 1285 2 - - SYM 42759 1285 3 8 8 CD 42759 1285 4 . . . 42759 1286 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1286 2 82 82 CD 42759 1286 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1286 4 From from IN 42759 1286 5 articles article NNS 42759 1286 6 in in IN 42759 1286 7 " " `` 42759 1286 8 The the DT 42759 1286 9 Single Single NNP 42759 1286 10 Tax Tax NNP 42759 1286 11 Review Review NNP 42759 1286 12 , , , 42759 1286 13 " " '' 42759 1286 14 vol vol NNP 42759 1286 15 . . . 42759 1287 1 9 9 CD 42759 1287 2 , , , 42759 1287 3 nos nos NNP 42759 1287 4 . . . 42759 1288 1 5 5 CD 42759 1288 2 , , , 42759 1288 3 6 6 CD 42759 1288 4 . . . 42759 1289 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1289 2 83 83 CD 42759 1289 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1289 4 " " `` 42759 1289 5 In in IN 42759 1289 6 a a DT 42759 1289 7 growing grow VBG 42759 1289 8 city city NN 42759 1289 9 , , , 42759 1289 10 an an DT 42759 1289 11 advantageous advantageous JJ 42759 1289 12 site site NN 42759 1289 13 will will MD 42759 1289 14 command command VB 42759 1289 15 a a DT 42759 1289 16 price price NN 42759 1289 17 more more JJR 42759 1289 18 than than IN 42759 1289 19 in in IN 42759 1289 20 proportion proportion NN 42759 1289 21 to to IN 42759 1289 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1289 23 present present JJ 42759 1289 24 rent rent NN 42759 1289 25 , , , 42759 1289 26 because because IN 42759 1289 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1289 28 is be VBZ 42759 1289 29 expected expect VBN 42759 1289 30 that that IN 42759 1289 31 the the DT 42759 1289 32 rent rent NN 42759 1289 33 will will MD 42759 1289 34 increase increase VB 42759 1289 35 still still RB 42759 1289 36 further far RBR 42759 1289 37 as as IN 42759 1289 38 the the DT 42759 1289 39 years year NNS 42759 1289 40 go go VBP 42759 1289 41 on on RP 42759 1289 42 . . . 42759 1289 43 " " '' 42759 1290 1 Taussig Taussig NNS 42759 1290 2 , , , 42759 1290 3 " " `` 42759 1290 4 Principles Principles NNPS 42759 1290 5 of of IN 42759 1290 6 Economics Economics NNP 42759 1290 7 , , , 42759 1290 8 " " '' 42759 1290 9 II ii CD 42759 1290 10 , , , 42759 1290 11 98 98 CD 42759 1290 12 ; ; : 42759 1290 13 N. N. NNP 42759 1290 14 Y. Y. NNP 42759 1290 15 , , , 42759 1290 16 1911 1911 CD 42759 1290 17 . . . 42759 1291 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 1291 2 VIII viii NN 42759 1291 3 METHODS method NNS 42759 1291 4 OF of IN 42759 1291 5 REFORMING reform VBG 42759 1291 6 OUR our PRP$ 42759 1291 7 LAND land NN 42759 1291 8 SYSTEM system NN 42759 1291 9 In in IN 42759 1291 10 economic economic JJ 42759 1291 11 and and CC 42759 1291 12 social social JJ 42759 1291 13 discussion discussion NN 42759 1291 14 the the DT 42759 1291 15 word word NN 42759 1291 16 reform reform NN 42759 1291 17 is be VBZ 42759 1291 18 commonly commonly RB 42759 1291 19 opposed oppose VBN 42759 1291 20 to to IN 42759 1291 21 the the DT 42759 1291 22 word word NN 42759 1291 23 revolution revolution NN 42759 1291 24 . . . 42759 1292 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1292 2 implies imply VBZ 42759 1292 3 modification modification NN 42759 1292 4 rather rather RB 42759 1292 5 than than IN 42759 1292 6 abolition abolition NN 42759 1292 7 , , , 42759 1292 8 gradual gradual JJ 42759 1292 9 rather rather RB 42759 1292 10 than than IN 42759 1292 11 violent violent JJ 42759 1292 12 change change NN 42759 1292 13 . . . 42759 1293 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1293 2 reforms reform NNS 42759 1293 3 of of IN 42759 1293 4 the the DT 42759 1293 5 system system NN 42759 1293 6 of of IN 42759 1293 7 land land NN 42759 1293 8 tenure tenure NN 42759 1293 9 do do VBP 42759 1293 10 not not RB 42759 1293 11 include include VB 42759 1293 12 such such JJ 42759 1293 13 radical radical JJ 42759 1293 14 proposals proposal NNS 42759 1293 15 as as IN 42759 1293 16 those those DT 42759 1293 17 of of IN 42759 1293 18 land land NN 42759 1293 19 nationalisation nationalisation NN 42759 1293 20 or or CC 42759 1293 21 the the DT 42759 1293 22 Single Single NNP 42759 1293 23 Tax Tax NNP 42759 1293 24 . . . 42759 1294 1 On on IN 42759 1294 2 the the DT 42759 1294 3 other other JJ 42759 1294 4 hand hand NN 42759 1294 5 , , , 42759 1294 6 some some DT 42759 1294 7 extension extension NN 42759 1294 8 of of IN 42759 1294 9 State State NNP 42759 1294 10 ownership ownership NN 42759 1294 11 of of IN 42759 1294 12 land land NN 42759 1294 13 , , , 42759 1294 14 and and CC 42759 1294 15 some some DT 42759 1294 16 increase increase NN 42759 1294 17 in in IN 42759 1294 18 the the DT 42759 1294 19 proportion proportion NN 42759 1294 20 of of IN 42759 1294 21 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1294 22 imposed impose VBN 42759 1294 23 upon upon IN 42759 1294 24 land land NN 42759 1294 25 , , , 42759 1294 26 may may MD 42759 1294 27 quite quite RB 42759 1294 28 properly properly RB 42759 1294 29 be be VB 42759 1294 30 placed place VBN 42759 1294 31 under under IN 42759 1294 32 the the DT 42759 1294 33 head head NN 42759 1294 34 of of IN 42759 1294 35 reform reform NN 42759 1294 36 , , , 42759 1294 37 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 1294 38 as as IN 42759 1294 39 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1294 40 are be VBP 42759 1294 41 changes change NNS 42759 1294 42 in in IN 42759 1294 43 rather rather RB 42759 1294 44 than than IN 42759 1294 45 a a DT 42759 1294 46 destruction destruction NN 42759 1294 47 of of IN 42759 1294 48 the the DT 42759 1294 49 existing exist VBG 42759 1294 50 system system NN 42759 1294 51 . . . 42759 1295 1 In in IN 42759 1295 2 general general JJ 42759 1295 3 , , , 42759 1295 4 the the DT 42759 1295 5 reform reform NN 42759 1295 6 measures measure NNS 42759 1295 7 needed need VBN 42759 1295 8 are be VBP 42759 1295 9 such such JJ 42759 1295 10 as as IN 42759 1295 11 will will MD 42759 1295 12 meet meet VB 42759 1295 13 the the DT 42759 1295 14 defects defect NNS 42759 1295 15 described describe VBN 42759 1295 16 in in IN 42759 1295 17 the the DT 42759 1295 18 last last JJ 42759 1295 19 chapter chapter NN 42759 1295 20 ; ; : 42759 1295 21 namely namely RB 42759 1295 22 , , , 42759 1295 23 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1295 24 , , , 42759 1295 25 excessive excessive JJ 42759 1295 26 gains gain NNS 42759 1295 27 , , , 42759 1295 28 and and CC 42759 1295 29 exclusion exclusion NN 42759 1295 30 from from IN 42759 1295 31 the the DT 42759 1295 32 land land NN 42759 1295 33 . . . 42759 1296 1 Obviously obviously RB 42759 1296 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1296 3 can can MD 42759 1296 4 be be VB 42759 1296 5 provided provide VBN 42759 1296 6 only only RB 42759 1296 7 by by IN 42759 1296 8 legislation legislation NN 42759 1296 9 ; ; : 42759 1296 10 and and CC 42759 1296 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1296 12 may may MD 42759 1296 13 all all RB 42759 1296 14 be be VB 42759 1296 15 included include VBN 42759 1296 16 under under IN 42759 1296 17 two two CD 42759 1296 18 heads head NNS 42759 1296 19 , , , 42759 1296 20 ownership ownership NN 42759 1296 21 and and CC 42759 1296 22 taxation taxation NN 42759 1296 23 . . . 42759 1297 1 By by IN 42759 1297 2 far far RB 42759 1297 3 the the DT 42759 1297 4 greater great JJR 42759 1297 5 part part NN 42759 1297 6 of of IN 42759 1297 7 the the DT 42759 1297 8 more more RBR 42759 1297 9 valuable valuable JJ 42759 1297 10 lands land NNS 42759 1297 11 of of IN 42759 1297 12 the the DT 42759 1297 13 country country NN 42759 1297 14 are be VBP 42759 1297 15 no no RB 42759 1297 16 longer longer RB 42759 1297 17 under under IN 42759 1297 18 the the DT 42759 1297 19 ownership ownership NN 42759 1297 20 of of IN 42759 1297 21 the the DT 42759 1297 22 State State NNP 42759 1297 23 . . . 42759 1298 1 Urban urban JJ 42759 1298 2 land land NN 42759 1298 3 is be VBZ 42759 1298 4 practically practically RB 42759 1298 5 all all DT 42759 1298 6 in in IN 42759 1298 7 the the DT 42759 1298 8 hands hand NNS 42759 1298 9 of of IN 42759 1298 10 private private JJ 42759 1298 11 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 1298 12 . . . 42759 1299 1 While while IN 42759 1299 2 many many JJ 42759 1299 3 millions million NNS 42759 1299 4 of of IN 42759 1299 5 acres acre NNS 42759 1299 6 of of IN 42759 1299 7 land land NN 42759 1299 8 suitable suitable JJ 42759 1299 9 for for IN 42759 1299 10 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 1299 11 are be VBP 42759 1299 12 still still RB 42759 1299 13 under under IN 42759 1299 14 public public JJ 42759 1299 15 ownership ownership NN 42759 1299 16 , , , 42759 1299 17 almost almost RB 42759 1299 18 all all DT 42759 1299 19 of of IN 42759 1299 20 this this DT 42759 1299 21 area area NN 42759 1299 22 requires require VBZ 42759 1299 23 a a DT 42759 1299 24 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1299 25 outlay outlay NN 42759 1299 26 for for IN 42759 1299 27 irrigation irrigation NN 42759 1299 28 , , , 42759 1299 29 clearing clearing NN 42759 1299 30 , , , 42759 1299 31 and and CC 42759 1299 32 draining drain VBG 42759 1299 33 before before IN 42759 1299 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1299 35 can can MD 42759 1299 36 become become VB 42759 1299 37 productive productive JJ 42759 1299 38 . . . 42759 1300 1 Forty forty CD 42759 1300 2 years year NNS 42759 1300 3 ago ago RB 42759 1300 4 , , , 42759 1300 5 three three CD 42759 1300 6 - - HYPH 42759 1300 7 fourths fourth NNS 42759 1300 8 of of IN 42759 1300 9 the the DT 42759 1300 10 timber timber NN 42759 1300 11 now now RB 42759 1300 12 standing stand VBG 42759 1300 13 was be VBD 42759 1300 14 public public JJ 42759 1300 15 property property NN 42759 1300 16 ; ; : 42759 1300 17 at at IN 42759 1300 18 present present NN 42759 1300 19 about about RB 42759 1300 20 four four CD 42759 1300 21 - - HYPH 42759 1300 22 fifths fifth NNS 42759 1300 23 of of IN 42759 1300 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1300 25 is be VBZ 42759 1300 26 owned own VBN 42759 1300 27 by by IN 42759 1300 28 private private JJ 42759 1300 29 persons person NNS 42759 1300 30 or or CC 42759 1300 31 corporations corporation NNS 42759 1300 32 . . . 42759 1301 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1301 2 84 84 CD 42759 1301 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1301 4 The the DT 42759 1301 5 bulk bulk NN 42759 1301 6 of of IN 42759 1301 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1301 8 mineral mineral NN 42759 1301 9 deposits deposit NNS 42759 1301 10 , , , 42759 1301 11 coal coal NN 42759 1301 12 , , , 42759 1301 13 copper copper NN 42759 1301 14 , , , 42759 1301 15 gold gold NN 42759 1301 16 , , , 42759 1301 17 silver silver NN 42759 1301 18 , , , 42759 1301 19 etc etc FW 42759 1301 20 . . . 42759 1301 21 , , , 42759 1301 22 have have VBP 42759 1301 23 likewise likewise RB 42759 1301 24 fallen fall VBN 42759 1301 25 under under IN 42759 1301 26 private private JJ 42759 1301 27 ownership ownership NN 42759 1301 28 , , , 42759 1301 29 with with IN 42759 1301 30 the the DT 42759 1301 31 exception exception NN 42759 1301 32 of of IN 42759 1301 33 those those DT 42759 1301 34 of of IN 42759 1301 35 Alaska Alaska NNP 42759 1301 36 . . . 42759 1302 1 The the DT 42759 1302 2 undeveloped undeveloped JJ 42759 1302 3 water water NN 42759 1302 4 power power NN 42759 1302 5 remaining remain VBG 42759 1302 6 under under IN 42759 1302 7 government government NN 42759 1302 8 ownership ownership NN 42759 1302 9 has have VBZ 42759 1302 10 been be VBN 42759 1302 11 roughly roughly RB 42759 1302 12 estimated estimate VBN 42759 1302 13 at at IN 42759 1302 14 fourteen fourteen CD 42759 1302 15 million million CD 42759 1302 16 horse horse NN 42759 1302 17 power power NN 42759 1302 18 in in IN 42759 1302 19 the the DT 42759 1302 20 national national JJ 42759 1302 21 forests forest NNS 42759 1302 22 , , , 42759 1302 23 and and CC 42759 1302 24 considerably considerably RB 42759 1302 25 less less JJR 42759 1302 26 than than IN 42759 1302 27 that that DT 42759 1302 28 amount amount NN 42759 1302 29 in in IN 42759 1302 30 other other JJ 42759 1302 31 parts part NNS 42759 1302 32 of of IN 42759 1302 33 the the DT 42759 1302 34 public public JJ 42759 1302 35 domain domain NN 42759 1302 36 . . . 42759 1303 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1303 2 85 85 CD 42759 1303 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1303 4 This this DT 42759 1303 5 is be VBZ 42759 1303 6 a a DT 42759 1303 7 gratifying gratifying JJ 42759 1303 8 proportion proportion NN 42759 1303 9 of of IN 42759 1303 10 the the DT 42759 1303 11 whole whole JJ 42759 1303 12 supply supply NN 42759 1303 13 , , , 42759 1303 14 developed developed JJ 42759 1303 15 and and CC 42759 1303 16 undeveloped undeveloped JJ 42759 1303 17 , , , 42759 1303 18 of of IN 42759 1303 19 this this DT 42759 1303 20 national national JJ 42759 1303 21 resource resource NN 42759 1303 22 , , , 42759 1303 23 which which WDT 42759 1303 24 is be VBZ 42759 1303 25 said say VBN 42759 1303 26 to to TO 42759 1303 27 be be VB 42759 1303 28 somewhere somewhere RB 42759 1303 29 between between IN 42759 1303 30 27 27 CD 42759 1303 31 and and CC 42759 1303 32 60 60 CD 42759 1303 33 millions million NNS 42759 1303 34 horse horse NN 42759 1303 35 power power NN 42759 1303 36 . . . 42759 1304 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1304 2 86 86 CD 42759 1304 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1304 4 Only only RB 42759 1304 5 about about RB 42759 1304 6 seven seven CD 42759 1304 7 million million CD 42759 1304 8 horse horse NN 42759 1304 9 power power NN 42759 1304 10 has have VBZ 42759 1304 11 yet yet RB 42759 1304 12 been be VBN 42759 1304 13 developed develop VBN 42759 1304 14 , , , 42759 1304 15 almost almost RB 42759 1304 16 all all DT 42759 1304 17 of of IN 42759 1304 18 which which WDT 42759 1304 19 is be VBZ 42759 1304 20 privately privately RB 42759 1304 21 owned own VBN 42759 1304 22 . . . 42759 1305 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1305 2 The the DT 42759 1305 3 Leasing Leasing NNP 42759 1305 4 System System NNP 42759 1305 5 _ _ NNP 42759 1305 6 In in IN 42759 1305 7 many many JJ 42759 1305 8 countries country NNS 42759 1305 9 of of IN 42759 1305 10 Europe Europe NNP 42759 1305 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1305 12 has have VBZ 42759 1305 13 long long RB 42759 1305 14 been be VBN 42759 1305 15 the the DT 42759 1305 16 policy policy NN 42759 1305 17 of of IN 42759 1305 18 governments government NNS 42759 1305 19 to to TO 42759 1305 20 retain retain VB 42759 1305 21 ownership ownership NN 42759 1305 22 of of IN 42759 1305 23 all all DT 42759 1305 24 lands land NNS 42759 1305 25 containing contain VBG 42759 1305 26 timber timber NN 42759 1305 27 , , , 42759 1305 28 minerals mineral NNS 42759 1305 29 , , , 42759 1305 30 oil oil NN 42759 1305 31 , , , 42759 1305 32 natural natural JJ 42759 1305 33 gas gas NN 42759 1305 34 , , , 42759 1305 35 phosphate phosphate NN 42759 1305 36 , , , 42759 1305 37 and and CC 42759 1305 38 water water NN 42759 1305 39 power power NN 42759 1305 40 . . . 42759 1306 1 The the DT 42759 1306 2 products product NNS 42759 1306 3 of of IN 42759 1306 4 these these DT 42759 1306 5 lands land NNS 42759 1306 6 are be VBP 42759 1306 7 extracted extract VBN 42759 1306 8 and and CC 42759 1306 9 put put VBN 42759 1306 10 upon upon IN 42759 1306 11 the the DT 42759 1306 12 market market NN 42759 1306 13 through through IN 42759 1306 14 a a DT 42759 1306 15 leasing leasing NN 42759 1306 16 system system NN 42759 1306 17 . . . 42759 1307 1 That that DT 42759 1307 2 is is RB 42759 1307 3 ; ; : 42759 1307 4 the the DT 42759 1307 5 user user NN 42759 1307 6 of of IN 42759 1307 7 the the DT 42759 1307 8 land land NN 42759 1307 9 pays pay VBZ 42759 1307 10 to to IN 42759 1307 11 the the DT 42759 1307 12 State State NNP 42759 1307 13 a a DT 42759 1307 14 rental rental NN 42759 1307 15 according accord VBG 42759 1307 16 to to IN 42759 1307 17 the the DT 42759 1307 18 amount amount NN 42759 1307 19 and and CC 42759 1307 20 quality quality NN 42759 1307 21 of of IN 42759 1307 22 raw raw JJ 42759 1307 23 material material NN 42759 1307 24 which which WDT 42759 1307 25 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1307 26 takes take VBZ 42759 1307 27 from from IN 42759 1307 28 the the DT 42759 1307 29 storehouse storehouse NN 42759 1307 30 of of IN 42759 1307 31 nature nature NN 42759 1307 32 . . . 42759 1308 1 Theoretically theoretically RB 42759 1308 2 , , , 42759 1308 3 the the DT 42759 1308 4 State state NN 42759 1308 5 could could MD 42759 1308 6 sell sell VB 42759 1308 7 such such JJ 42759 1308 8 lands land NNS 42759 1308 9 at at IN 42759 1308 10 prices price NNS 42759 1308 11 that that WDT 42759 1308 12 would would MD 42759 1308 13 bring bring VB 42759 1308 14 in in RP 42759 1308 15 as as RB 42759 1308 16 much much JJ 42759 1308 17 revenue revenue NN 42759 1308 18 as as IN 42759 1308 19 does do VBZ 42759 1308 20 the the DT 42759 1308 21 leasing leasing NN 42759 1308 22 system system NN 42759 1308 23 ; ; : 42759 1308 24 practically practically RB 42759 1308 25 , , , 42759 1308 26 this this DT 42759 1308 27 result result NN 42759 1308 28 has have VBZ 42759 1308 29 never never RB 42759 1308 30 been be VBN 42759 1308 31 attained attain VBN 42759 1308 32 . . . 42759 1309 1 The the DT 42759 1309 2 principal principal JJ 42759 1309 3 advantages advantage NNS 42759 1309 4 of of IN 42759 1309 5 the the DT 42759 1309 6 leasing leasing NN 42759 1309 7 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 1309 8 are be VBP 42759 1309 9 : : : 42759 1309 10 to to TO 42759 1309 11 prevent prevent VB 42759 1309 12 the the DT 42759 1309 13 premature premature JJ 42759 1309 14 destruction destruction NN 42759 1309 15 of of IN 42759 1309 16 forests forest NNS 42759 1309 17 , , , 42759 1309 18 the the DT 42759 1309 19 private private JJ 42759 1309 20 monopolisation monopolisation NN 42759 1309 21 of of IN 42759 1309 22 limited limited JJ 42759 1309 23 natural natural JJ 42759 1309 24 resources resource NNS 42759 1309 25 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1309 26 which which WDT 42759 1309 27 has have VBZ 42759 1309 28 happened happen VBN 42759 1309 29 in in IN 42759 1309 30 the the DT 42759 1309 31 case case NN 42759 1309 32 of of IN 42759 1309 33 the the DT 42759 1309 34 anthracite anthracite NN 42759 1309 35 coal coal NN 42759 1309 36 fields field NNS 42759 1309 37 of of IN 42759 1309 38 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP 42759 1309 39 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1309 40 and and CC 42759 1309 41 the the DT 42759 1309 42 private private JJ 42759 1309 43 acquisition acquisition NN 42759 1309 44 of of IN 42759 1309 45 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 1309 46 valuable valuable JJ 42759 1309 47 land land NN 42759 1309 48 at at IN 42759 1309 49 ridiculously ridiculously RB 42759 1309 50 low low JJ 42759 1309 51 prices price NNS 42759 1309 52 ; ; : 42759 1309 53 and and CC 42759 1309 54 to to TO 42759 1309 55 enable enable VB 42759 1309 56 the the DT 42759 1309 57 State State NNP 42759 1309 58 to to TO 42759 1309 59 secure secure VB 42759 1309 60 just just RB 42759 1309 61 treatment treatment NN 42759 1309 62 for for IN 42759 1309 63 the the DT 42759 1309 64 consumer consumer NN 42759 1309 65 and and CC 42759 1309 66 the the DT 42759 1309 67 labourer labourer NN 42759 1309 68 by by IN 42759 1309 69 stipulating stipulate VBG 42759 1309 70 that that IN 42759 1309 71 the the DT 42759 1309 72 former former JJ 42759 1309 73 shall shall MD 42759 1309 74 obtain obtain VB 42759 1309 75 the the DT 42759 1309 76 product product NN 42759 1309 77 at at IN 42759 1309 78 fair fair JJ 42759 1309 79 prices price NNS 42759 1309 80 , , , 42759 1309 81 and and CC 42759 1309 82 that that IN 42759 1309 83 the the DT 42759 1309 84 latter latter JJ 42759 1309 85 shall shall MD 42759 1309 86 receive receive VB 42759 1309 87 fair fair JJ 42759 1309 88 wages wage NNS 42759 1309 89 . . . 42759 1310 1 This this DT 42759 1310 2 example example NN 42759 1310 3 should should MD 42759 1310 4 be be VB 42759 1310 5 followed follow VBN 42759 1310 6 by by IN 42759 1310 7 the the DT 42759 1310 8 United United NNP 42759 1310 9 States States NNP 42759 1310 10 . . . 42759 1311 1 All all DT 42759 1311 2 timber timber NN 42759 1311 3 , , , 42759 1311 4 mineral mineral NN 42759 1311 5 , , , 42759 1311 6 gas gas NN 42759 1311 7 , , , 42759 1311 8 oil oil NN 42759 1311 9 , , , 42759 1311 10 and and CC 42759 1311 11 water water NN 42759 1311 12 power power NN 42759 1311 13 lands land NNS 42759 1311 14 which which WDT 42759 1311 15 have have VBP 42759 1311 16 not not RB 42759 1311 17 been be VBN 42759 1311 18 alienated alienated JJ 42759 1311 19 to to IN 42759 1311 20 private private JJ 42759 1311 21 persons person NNS 42759 1311 22 should should MD 42759 1311 23 remain remain VB 42759 1311 24 under under IN 42759 1311 25 government government NN 42759 1311 26 ownership ownership NN 42759 1311 27 , , , 42759 1311 28 and and CC 42759 1311 29 be be VB 42759 1311 30 brought bring VBN 42759 1311 31 into into IN 42759 1311 32 use use NN 42759 1311 33 through through IN 42759 1311 34 a a DT 42759 1311 35 leasing leasing NN 42759 1311 36 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 1311 37 which which WDT 42759 1311 38 would would MD 42759 1311 39 enable enable VB 42759 1311 40 the the DT 42759 1311 41 private private JJ 42759 1311 42 operators operator NNS 42759 1311 43 to to TO 42759 1311 44 obtain obtain VB 42759 1311 45 the the DT 42759 1311 46 rates rate NNS 42759 1311 47 of of IN 42759 1311 48 profit profit NN 42759 1311 49 and and CC 42759 1311 50 interest interest NN 42759 1311 51 which which WDT 42759 1311 52 are be VBP 42759 1311 53 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 1311 54 yielded yield VBN 42759 1311 55 by by IN 42759 1311 56 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 1311 57 subject subject JJ 42759 1311 58 to to IN 42759 1311 59 the the DT 42759 1311 60 same same JJ 42759 1311 61 degree degree NN 42759 1311 62 of of IN 42759 1311 63 risk risk NN 42759 1311 64 . . . 42759 1312 1 Happily happily RB 42759 1312 2 this this DT 42759 1312 3 policy policy NN 42759 1312 4 now now RB 42759 1312 5 seems seem VBZ 42759 1312 6 likely likely JJ 42759 1312 7 to to TO 42759 1312 8 be be VB 42759 1312 9 adopted adopt VBN 42759 1312 10 . . . 42759 1313 1 In in IN 42759 1313 2 1913 1913 CD 42759 1313 3 a a DT 42759 1313 4 law law NN 42759 1313 5 was be VBD 42759 1313 6 passed pass VBN 42759 1313 7 by by IN 42759 1313 8 the the DT 42759 1313 9 United United NNP 42759 1313 10 States States NNP 42759 1313 11 providing provide VBG 42759 1313 12 for for IN 42759 1313 13 the the DT 42759 1313 14 operation operation NN 42759 1313 15 of of IN 42759 1313 16 the the DT 42759 1313 17 coal coal NN 42759 1313 18 mines mine NNS 42759 1313 19 of of IN 42759 1313 20 Alaska Alaska NNP 42759 1313 21 on on IN 42759 1313 22 leases lease NNS 42759 1313 23 . . . 42759 1314 1 The the DT 42759 1314 2 amount amount NN 42759 1314 3 that that WDT 42759 1314 4 can can MD 42759 1314 5 be be VB 42759 1314 6 leased lease VBN 42759 1314 7 by by IN 42759 1314 8 any any DT 42759 1314 9 person person NN 42759 1314 10 or or CC 42759 1314 11 corporation corporation NN 42759 1314 12 is be VBZ 42759 1314 13 limited limit VBN 42759 1314 14 to to IN 42759 1314 15 2560 2560 CD 42759 1314 16 acres acre NNS 42759 1314 17 , , , 42759 1314 18 and and CC 42759 1314 19 the the DT 42759 1314 20 penalty penalty NN 42759 1314 21 for for IN 42759 1314 22 attempting attempt VBG 42759 1314 23 to to TO 42759 1314 24 monopolise monopolise VB 42759 1314 25 the the DT 42759 1314 26 product product NN 42759 1314 27 is be VBZ 42759 1314 28 forfeiture forfeiture NN 42759 1314 29 of of IN 42759 1314 30 tenure tenure NN 42759 1314 31 . . . 42759 1315 1 The the DT 42759 1315 2 Secretary Secretary NNP 42759 1315 3 of of IN 42759 1315 4 the the DT 42759 1315 5 Interior Interior NNP 42759 1315 6 has have VBZ 42759 1315 7 urged urge VBN 42759 1315 8 a a DT 42759 1315 9 similar similar JJ 42759 1315 10 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 1315 11 for for IN 42759 1315 12 the the DT 42759 1315 13 development development NN 42759 1315 14 and and CC 42759 1315 15 extraction extraction NN 42759 1315 16 of of IN 42759 1315 17 water water NN 42759 1315 18 power power NN 42759 1315 19 , , , 42759 1315 20 coal coal NN 42759 1315 21 , , , 42759 1315 22 oil oil NN 42759 1315 23 , , , 42759 1315 24 gas gas NN 42759 1315 25 , , , 42759 1315 26 phosphate phosphate NN 42759 1315 27 , , , 42759 1315 28 sodium sodium NN 42759 1315 29 , , , 42759 1315 30 and and CC 42759 1315 31 potassium potassium NN 42759 1315 32 on on IN 42759 1315 33 the the DT 42759 1315 34 public public JJ 42759 1315 35 domain domain NN 42759 1315 36 of of IN 42759 1315 37 Continental Continental NNP 42759 1315 38 United United NNP 42759 1315 39 States States NNP 42759 1315 40 , , , 42759 1315 41 and and CC 42759 1315 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1315 43 recommendation recommendation NN 42759 1315 44 will will MD 42759 1315 45 probably probably RB 42759 1315 46 be be VB 42759 1315 47 adopted adopt VBN 42759 1315 48 by by IN 42759 1315 49 Congress Congress NNP 42759 1315 50 . . . 42759 1316 1 Thus thus RB 42759 1316 2 the the DT 42759 1316 3 rent rent NN 42759 1316 4 of of IN 42759 1316 5 these these DT 42759 1316 6 lands land NNS 42759 1316 7 will will MD 42759 1316 8 go go VB 42759 1316 9 to to IN 42759 1316 10 the the DT 42759 1316 11 whole whole JJ 42759 1316 12 people people NNS 42759 1316 13 instead instead RB 42759 1316 14 of of IN 42759 1316 15 to to IN 42759 1316 16 a a DT 42759 1316 17 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 1316 18 small small JJ 42759 1316 19 number number NN 42759 1316 20 of of IN 42759 1316 21 individuals individual NNS 42759 1316 22 , , , 42759 1316 23 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1316 24 of of IN 42759 1316 25 the the DT 42759 1316 26 products product NNS 42759 1316 27 will will MD 42759 1316 28 be be VB 42759 1316 29 made make VBN 42759 1316 30 impossible impossible JJ 42759 1316 31 , , , 42759 1316 32 and and CC 42759 1316 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1316 34 remaining remain VBG 42759 1316 35 public public JJ 42759 1316 36 resources resource NNS 42759 1316 37 will will MD 42759 1316 38 be be VB 42759 1316 39 protected protect VBN 42759 1316 40 from from IN 42759 1316 41 rapid rapid JJ 42759 1316 42 and and CC 42759 1316 43 ruinous ruinous JJ 42759 1316 44 exploitation exploitation NN 42759 1316 45 . . . 42759 1317 1 To to IN 42759 1317 2 the the DT 42759 1317 3 objection objection NN 42759 1317 4 that that IN 42759 1317 5 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 1317 6 will will MD 42759 1317 7 not not RB 42759 1317 8 invest invest VB 42759 1317 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1317 10 money money NN 42759 1317 11 in in RP 42759 1317 12 nor nor CC 42759 1317 13 carry carry VB 42759 1317 14 on on RP 42759 1317 15 extractive extractive JJ 42759 1317 16 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 1317 17 on on IN 42759 1317 18 a a DT 42759 1317 19 leasing lease VBG 42759 1317 20 basis basis NN 42759 1317 21 , , , 42759 1317 22 the the DT 42759 1317 23 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 1317 24 answer answer NN 42759 1317 25 is be VBZ 42759 1317 26 that that IN 42759 1317 27 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1317 28 are be VBP 42759 1317 29 doing do VBG 42759 1317 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1317 31 now now RB 42759 1317 32 . . . 42759 1318 1 In in IN 42759 1318 2 1909 1909 CD 42759 1318 3 , , , 42759 1318 4 24.5 24.5 CD 42759 1318 5 per per IN 42759 1318 6 cent cent NN 42759 1318 7 . . . 42759 1319 1 of of IN 42759 1319 2 all all PDT 42759 1319 3 the the DT 42759 1319 4 lands land NNS 42759 1319 5 producing produce VBG 42759 1319 6 minerals mineral NNS 42759 1319 7 , , , 42759 1319 8 precious precious JJ 42759 1319 9 metals metal NNS 42759 1319 10 , , , 42759 1319 11 and and CC 42759 1319 12 stone stone NN 42759 1319 13 ; ; : 42759 1319 14 94.6 94.6 CD 42759 1319 15 per per IN 42759 1319 16 cent cent NN 42759 1319 17 . . . 42759 1320 1 of of IN 42759 1320 2 the the DT 42759 1320 3 lands land NNS 42759 1320 4 producing produce VBG 42759 1320 5 petroleum petroleum NN 42759 1320 6 and and CC 42759 1320 7 gas gas NN 42759 1320 8 ; ; : 42759 1320 9 and and CC 42759 1320 10 61.2 61.2 CD 42759 1320 11 per per IN 42759 1320 12 cent cent NN 42759 1320 13 . . . 42759 1321 1 of of IN 42759 1321 2 the the DT 42759 1321 3 two two CD 42759 1321 4 groups group NNS 42759 1321 5 of of IN 42759 1321 6 lands land NNS 42759 1321 7 combined combine VBN 42759 1321 8 , , , 42759 1321 9 were be VBD 42759 1321 10 operated operate VBN 42759 1321 11 under under IN 42759 1321 12 leases lease NNS 42759 1321 13 from from IN 42759 1321 14 private private JJ 42759 1321 15 owners owner NNS 42759 1321 16 or or CC 42759 1321 17 from from IN 42759 1321 18 the the DT 42759 1321 19 government government NN 42759 1321 20 . . . 42759 1322 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1322 2 87 87 CD 42759 1322 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1322 4 If if IN 42759 1322 5 the the DT 42759 1322 6 rental rental NN 42759 1322 7 or or CC 42759 1322 8 royalty royalty NN 42759 1322 9 demanded demand VBD 42759 1322 10 is be VBZ 42759 1322 11 not not RB 42759 1322 12 unreasonably unreasonably RB 42759 1322 13 high high JJ 42759 1322 14 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 1322 15 will will MD 42759 1322 16 be be VB 42759 1322 17 quite quite RB 42759 1322 18 as as RB 42759 1322 19 willing willing JJ 42759 1322 20 to to TO 42759 1322 21 produce produce VB 42759 1322 22 raw raw JJ 42759 1322 23 materials material NNS 42759 1322 24 of of IN 42759 1322 25 these these DT 42759 1322 26 kinds kind NNS 42759 1322 27 from from IN 42759 1322 28 leased lease VBN 42759 1322 29 land land NN 42759 1322 30 as as IN 42759 1322 31 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1322 32 are be VBP 42759 1322 33 to to TO 42759 1322 34 manufacture manufacture VB 42759 1322 35 or or CC 42759 1322 36 sell sell VB 42759 1322 37 goods good NNS 42759 1322 38 in in IN 42759 1322 39 a a DT 42759 1322 40 rented rent VBN 42759 1322 41 building building NN 42759 1322 42 . . . 42759 1323 1 Not not RB 42759 1323 2 the the DT 42759 1323 3 leasing leasing NN 42759 1323 4 system system NN 42759 1323 5 , , , 42759 1323 6 but but CC 42759 1323 7 the the DT 42759 1323 8 terms term NNS 42759 1323 9 of of IN 42759 1323 10 the the DT 42759 1323 11 particular particular JJ 42759 1323 12 lease lease NN 42759 1323 13 are be VBP 42759 1323 14 the the DT 42759 1323 15 important important JJ 42759 1323 16 consideration consideration NN 42759 1323 17 . . . 42759 1324 1 Public public JJ 42759 1324 2 grazing grazing NN 42759 1324 3 lands land NNS 42759 1324 4 should should MD 42759 1324 5 remain remain VB 42759 1324 6 government government NN 42759 1324 7 property property NN 42759 1324 8 until until IN 42759 1324 9 such such JJ 42759 1324 10 time time NN 42759 1324 11 as as IN 42759 1324 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1324 13 become become VBP 42759 1324 14 available available JJ 42759 1324 15 for for IN 42759 1324 16 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 1324 17 . . . 42759 1325 1 Cattle Cattle NNS 42759 1325 2 owners owner NNS 42759 1325 3 could could MD 42759 1325 4 lease lease VB 42759 1325 5 the the DT 42759 1325 6 land land NN 42759 1325 7 from from IN 42759 1325 8 the the DT 42759 1325 9 State State NNP 42759 1325 10 on on IN 42759 1325 11 equitable equitable JJ 42759 1325 12 terms term NNS 42759 1325 13 , , , 42759 1325 14 and and CC 42759 1325 15 receive receive VBP 42759 1325 16 ample ample JJ 42759 1325 17 protection protection NN 42759 1325 18 for for IN 42759 1325 19 money money NN 42759 1325 20 invested invest VBN 42759 1325 21 in in IN 42759 1325 22 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1325 23 . . . 42759 1326 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1326 2 Public Public NNP 42759 1326 3 Agricultural Agricultural NNP 42759 1326 4 Lands Lands NNPS 42759 1326 5 _ _ NNP 42759 1326 6 The the DT 42759 1326 7 leasing leasing NN 42759 1326 8 system system NN 42759 1326 9 can can MD 42759 1326 10 not not RB 42759 1326 11 well well RB 42759 1326 12 be be VB 42759 1326 13 applied apply VBN 42759 1326 14 to to IN 42759 1326 15 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1326 16 lands land NNS 42759 1326 17 . . . 42759 1327 1 In in IN 42759 1327 2 order order NN 42759 1327 3 that that IN 42759 1327 4 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1327 5 may may MD 42759 1327 6 be be VB 42759 1327 7 continuously continuously RB 42759 1327 8 improved improve VBN 42759 1327 9 and and CC 42759 1327 10 protected protect VBN 42759 1327 11 against against IN 42759 1327 12 deterioration deterioration NN 42759 1327 13 , , , 42759 1327 14 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1327 15 must must MD 42759 1327 16 be be VB 42759 1327 17 owned own VBN 42759 1327 18 by by IN 42759 1327 19 the the DT 42759 1327 20 cultivators cultivator NNS 42759 1327 21 . . . 42759 1328 1 The the DT 42759 1328 2 temptation temptation NN 42759 1328 3 to to TO 42759 1328 4 wear wear VB 42759 1328 5 out out RP 42759 1328 6 a a DT 42759 1328 7 piece piece NN 42759 1328 8 of of IN 42759 1328 9 land land NN 42759 1328 10 quickly quickly RB 42759 1328 11 , , , 42759 1328 12 and and CC 42759 1328 13 then then RB 42759 1328 14 move move VB 42759 1328 15 to to IN 42759 1328 16 another another DT 42759 1328 17 piece piece NN 42759 1328 18 , , , 42759 1328 19 and and CC 42759 1328 20 all all PDT 42759 1328 21 the the DT 42759 1328 22 other other JJ 42759 1328 23 obstacles obstacle NNS 42759 1328 24 that that WDT 42759 1328 25 stand stand VBP 42759 1328 26 in in IN 42759 1328 27 the the DT 42759 1328 28 way way NN 42759 1328 29 of of IN 42759 1328 30 the the DT 42759 1328 31 Single Single NNP 42759 1328 32 Tax Tax NNP 42759 1328 33 as as IN 42759 1328 34 applied apply VBN 42759 1328 35 to to IN 42759 1328 36 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1328 37 land land NN 42759 1328 38 , , , 42759 1328 39 show show VBP 42759 1328 40 that that IN 42759 1328 41 the the DT 42759 1328 42 government government NN 42759 1328 43 can can MD 42759 1328 44 not not RB 42759 1328 45 with with IN 42759 1328 46 advantage advantage NN 42759 1328 47 assume assume VB 42759 1328 48 the the DT 42759 1328 49 function function NN 42759 1328 50 of of IN 42759 1328 51 landlord landlord NN 42759 1328 52 in in IN 42759 1328 53 this this DT 42759 1328 54 domain domain NN 42759 1328 55 . . . 42759 1329 1 In in IN 42759 1329 2 the the DT 42759 1329 3 great great JJ 42759 1329 4 majority majority NN 42759 1329 5 of of IN 42759 1329 6 cases case NNS 42759 1329 7 the the DT 42759 1329 8 State State NNP 42759 1329 9 would would MD 42759 1329 10 do do VB 42759 1329 11 better well JJR 42759 1329 12 to to TO 42759 1329 13 sell sell VB 42759 1329 14 the the DT 42759 1329 15 land land NN 42759 1329 16 in in IN 42759 1329 17 small small JJ 42759 1329 18 parcels parcel NNS 42759 1329 19 to to IN 42759 1329 20 genuine genuine JJ 42759 1329 21 settlers settler NNS 42759 1329 22 . . . 42759 1330 1 There there EX 42759 1330 2 are be VBP 42759 1330 3 , , , 42759 1330 4 indeed indeed RB 42759 1330 5 , , , 42759 1330 6 many many JJ 42759 1330 7 situations situation NNS 42759 1330 8 , , , 42759 1330 9 especially especially RB 42759 1330 10 in in IN 42759 1330 11 connection connection NN 42759 1330 12 with with IN 42759 1330 13 government government NN 42759 1330 14 projects project NNS 42759 1330 15 of of IN 42759 1330 16 irrigation irrigation NN 42759 1330 17 , , , 42759 1330 18 clearing clearing NN 42759 1330 19 , , , 42759 1330 20 and and CC 42759 1330 21 drainage drainage NN 42759 1330 22 , , , 42759 1330 23 in in IN 42759 1330 24 which which WDT 42759 1330 25 the the DT 42759 1330 26 leasing leasing NN 42759 1330 27 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 1330 28 could could MD 42759 1330 29 be be VB 42759 1330 30 adopted adopt VBN 42759 1330 31 temporarily temporarily RB 42759 1330 32 . . . 42759 1331 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1331 2 should should MD 42759 1331 3 not not RB 42759 1331 4 be be VB 42759 1331 5 continued continue VBN 42759 1331 6 longer long RBR 42759 1331 7 than than IN 42759 1331 8 is be VBZ 42759 1331 9 necessary necessary JJ 42759 1331 10 to to TO 42759 1331 11 enable enable VB 42759 1331 12 the the DT 42759 1331 13 tenants tenant NNS 42759 1331 14 to to TO 42759 1331 15 become become VB 42759 1331 16 owners owner NNS 42759 1331 17 . . . 42759 1332 1 With with IN 42759 1332 2 this this DT 42759 1332 3 end end NN 42759 1332 4 in in IN 42759 1332 5 view view NN 42759 1332 6 the the DT 42759 1332 7 State state NN 42759 1332 8 should should MD 42759 1332 9 make make VB 42759 1332 10 loans loan NNS 42759 1332 11 to to IN 42759 1332 12 cultivators cultivator NNS 42759 1332 13 at at IN 42759 1332 14 moderate moderate JJ 42759 1332 15 rates rate NNS 42759 1332 16 of of IN 42759 1332 17 interest interest NN 42759 1332 18 , , , 42759 1332 19 as as IN 42759 1332 20 is be VBZ 42759 1332 21 done do VBN 42759 1332 22 in in IN 42759 1332 23 New New NNP 42759 1332 24 Zealand Zealand NNP 42759 1332 25 and and CC 42759 1332 26 Australia Australia NNP 42759 1332 27 . . . 42759 1333 1 Whether whether IN 42759 1333 2 the the DT 42759 1333 3 State State NNP 42759 1333 4 ought ought MD 42759 1333 5 to to TO 42759 1333 6 purchase purchase VB 42759 1333 7 undeveloped undeveloped JJ 42759 1333 8 land land NN 42759 1333 9 from from IN 42759 1333 10 private private JJ 42759 1333 11 owners owner NNS 42759 1333 12 in in IN 42759 1333 13 order order NN 42759 1333 14 to to TO 42759 1333 15 sell sell VB 42759 1333 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1333 17 to to IN 42759 1333 18 settlers settler NNS 42759 1333 19 , , , 42759 1333 20 may may MD 42759 1333 21 well well RB 42759 1333 22 be be VB 42759 1333 23 doubted doubt VBN 42759 1333 24 . . . 42759 1334 1 The the DT 42759 1334 2 only only JJ 42759 1334 3 lands land NNS 42759 1334 4 to to TO 42759 1334 5 which which WDT 42759 1334 6 such such PDT 42759 1334 7 a a DT 42759 1334 8 scheme scheme NN 42759 1334 9 would would MD 42759 1334 10 be be VB 42759 1334 11 at at RB 42759 1334 12 all all RB 42759 1334 13 applicable applicable JJ 42759 1334 14 are be VBP 42759 1334 15 large large JJ 42759 1334 16 estates estate NNS 42759 1334 17 which which WDT 42759 1334 18 are be VBP 42759 1334 19 held hold VBN 42759 1334 20 out out IN 42759 1334 21 of of IN 42759 1334 22 use use NN 42759 1334 23 by by IN 42759 1334 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1334 25 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 1334 26 . . . 42759 1335 1 Even even RB 42759 1335 2 here here RB 42759 1335 3 the the DT 42759 1335 4 transfer transfer NN 42759 1335 5 of of IN 42759 1335 6 the the DT 42759 1335 7 land land NN 42759 1335 8 to to IN 42759 1335 9 cultivators cultivator NNS 42759 1335 10 could could MD 42759 1335 11 be be VB 42759 1335 12 accomplished accomplish VBN 42759 1335 13 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 1335 14 , , , 42759 1335 15 through through IN 42759 1335 16 an an DT 42759 1335 17 extra extra JJ 42759 1335 18 heavy heavy JJ 42759 1335 19 tax tax NN 42759 1335 20 . . . 42759 1336 1 This this DT 42759 1336 2 method method NN 42759 1336 3 has have VBZ 42759 1336 4 been be VBN 42759 1336 5 adopted adopt VBN 42759 1336 6 with with IN 42759 1336 7 success success NN 42759 1336 8 by by IN 42759 1336 9 Australia Australia NNP 42759 1336 10 and and CC 42759 1336 11 New New NNP 42759 1336 12 Zealand Zealand NNP 42759 1336 13 . . . 42759 1337 1 The the DT 42759 1337 2 only only JJ 42759 1337 3 other other JJ 42759 1337 4 action action NN 42759 1337 5 by by IN 42759 1337 6 the the DT 42759 1337 7 State State NNP 42759 1337 8 that that WDT 42759 1337 9 seems seem VBZ 42759 1337 10 necessary necessary JJ 42759 1337 11 or or CC 42759 1337 12 wise wise JJ 42759 1337 13 in in IN 42759 1337 14 order order NN 42759 1337 15 to to TO 42759 1337 16 place place VB 42759 1337 17 settlers settler NNS 42759 1337 18 upon upon IN 42759 1337 19 privately privately RB 42759 1337 20 owned own VBN 42759 1337 21 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1337 22 land land NN 42759 1337 23 , , , 42759 1337 24 is be VBZ 42759 1337 25 the the DT 42759 1337 26 establishment establishment NN 42759 1337 27 of of IN 42759 1337 28 a a DT 42759 1337 29 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 1337 30 system system NN 42759 1337 31 of of IN 42759 1337 32 rural rural JJ 42759 1337 33 credits credit NNS 42759 1337 34 . . . 42759 1338 1 The the DT 42759 1338 2 need need NN 42759 1338 3 of of IN 42759 1338 4 cheaper cheap JJR 42759 1338 5 food food NN 42759 1338 6 products product NNS 42759 1338 7 , , , 42759 1338 8 and and CC 42759 1338 9 the the DT 42759 1338 10 desirability desirability NN 42759 1338 11 of of IN 42759 1338 12 checking check VBG 42759 1338 13 the the DT 42759 1338 14 abnormal abnormal JJ 42759 1338 15 growth growth NN 42759 1338 16 of of IN 42759 1338 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1338 18 urban urban JJ 42759 1338 19 populations population NNS 42759 1338 20 , , , 42759 1338 21 are be VBP 42759 1338 22 powerful powerful JJ 42759 1338 23 additional additional JJ 42759 1338 24 reasons reason NNS 42759 1338 25 for for IN 42759 1338 26 the the DT 42759 1338 27 adoption adoption NN 42759 1338 28 of of IN 42759 1338 29 this this DT 42759 1338 30 policy policy NN 42759 1338 31 . . . 42759 1339 1 The the DT 42759 1339 2 Hollis Hollis NNP 42759 1339 3 Rural Rural NNP 42759 1339 4 Credits Credits NNPS 42759 1339 5 Bill Bill NNP 42759 1339 6 recently recently RB 42759 1339 7 enacted enact VBD 42759 1339 8 into into IN 42759 1339 9 law law NN 42759 1339 10 by by IN 42759 1339 11 Congress Congress NNP 42759 1339 12 goes go VBZ 42759 1339 13 a a DT 42759 1339 14 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1339 15 way way NN 42759 1339 16 toward toward IN 42759 1339 17 meeting meet VBG 42759 1339 18 these these DT 42759 1339 19 needs need NNS 42759 1339 20 . . . 42759 1340 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1340 2 Public Public NNP 42759 1340 3 Ownership Ownership NNP 42759 1340 4 of of IN 42759 1340 5 Urban Urban NNP 42759 1340 6 Land Land NNP 42759 1340 7 _ _ NNP 42759 1340 8 No no DT 42759 1340 9 city city NN 42759 1340 10 should should MD 42759 1340 11 part part VB 42759 1340 12 with with IN 42759 1340 13 the the DT 42759 1340 14 ownership ownership NN 42759 1340 15 of of IN 42759 1340 16 any any DT 42759 1340 17 land land NN 42759 1340 18 that that WDT 42759 1340 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1340 20 now now RB 42759 1340 21 possesses possess VBZ 42759 1340 22 . . . 42759 1341 1 Since since IN 42759 1341 2 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 1341 3 are be VBP 42759 1341 4 willing willing JJ 42759 1341 5 to to TO 42759 1341 6 erect erect VB 42759 1341 7 costly costly JJ 42759 1341 8 buildings building NNS 42759 1341 9 on on IN 42759 1341 10 sites site NNS 42759 1341 11 leased lease VBN 42759 1341 12 from from IN 42759 1341 13 private private JJ 42759 1341 14 owners owner NNS 42759 1341 15 , , , 42759 1341 16 there there EX 42759 1341 17 is be VBZ 42759 1341 18 no no DT 42759 1341 19 good good JJ 42759 1341 20 reason reason NN 42759 1341 21 why why WRB 42759 1341 22 any any DT 42759 1341 23 one one PRP 42759 1341 24 should should MD 42759 1341 25 refuse refuse VB 42759 1341 26 to to TO 42759 1341 27 put put VB 42759 1341 28 up up RP 42759 1341 29 or or CC 42759 1341 30 purchase purchase VB 42759 1341 31 any any DT 42759 1341 32 sort sort NN 42759 1341 33 of of IN 42759 1341 34 structure structure NN 42759 1341 35 on on IN 42759 1341 36 land land NN 42759 1341 37 owned own VBN 42759 1341 38 by by IN 42759 1341 39 the the DT 42759 1341 40 municipality municipality NN 42759 1341 41 . . . 42759 1342 1 The the DT 42759 1342 2 situation situation NN 42759 1342 3 differs differ VBZ 42759 1342 4 from from IN 42759 1342 5 that that DT 42759 1342 6 presented present VBN 42759 1342 7 by by IN 42759 1342 8 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1342 9 land land NN 42759 1342 10 ; ; : 42759 1342 11 for for IN 42759 1342 12 the the DT 42759 1342 13 value value NN 42759 1342 14 of of IN 42759 1342 15 the the DT 42759 1342 16 land land NN 42759 1342 17 can can MD 42759 1342 18 easily easily RB 42759 1342 19 be be VB 42759 1342 20 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 1342 21 from from IN 42759 1342 22 that that DT 42759 1342 23 of of IN 42759 1342 24 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1342 25 , , , 42759 1342 26 the the DT 42759 1342 27 owner owner NN 42759 1342 28 of of IN 42759 1342 29 the the DT 42759 1342 30 latter latter JJ 42759 1342 31 can can MD 42759 1342 32 sell sell VB 42759 1342 33 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1342 34 even even RB 42759 1342 35 if if IN 42759 1342 36 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1342 37 is be VBZ 42759 1342 38 not not RB 42759 1342 39 the the DT 42759 1342 40 owner owner NN 42759 1342 41 of of IN 42759 1342 42 the the DT 42759 1342 43 land land NN 42759 1342 44 , , , 42759 1342 45 and and CC 42759 1342 46 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1342 47 can can MD 42759 1342 48 not not RB 42759 1342 49 be be VB 42759 1342 50 deprived deprive VBN 42759 1342 51 of of IN 42759 1342 52 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1342 53 without without IN 42759 1342 54 full full JJ 42759 1342 55 compensation compensation NN 42759 1342 56 . . . 42759 1343 1 While while IN 42759 1343 2 the the DT 42759 1343 3 lessee lessee NN 42759 1343 4 paid pay VBD 42759 1343 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1343 6 annual annual JJ 42759 1343 7 rent rent NN 42759 1343 8 , , , 42759 1343 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1343 10 control control NN 42759 1343 11 of of IN 42759 1343 12 the the DT 42759 1343 13 land land NN 42759 1343 14 would would MD 42759 1343 15 be be VB 42759 1343 16 as as RB 42759 1343 17 complete complete JJ 42759 1343 18 and and CC 42759 1343 19 certain certain JJ 42759 1343 20 as as IN 42759 1343 21 that that DT 42759 1343 22 of of IN 42759 1343 23 the the DT 42759 1343 24 landowner landowner NN 42759 1343 25 who who WP 42759 1343 26 continues continue VBZ 42759 1343 27 to to TO 42759 1343 28 pay pay VB 42759 1343 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1343 30 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1343 31 . . . 42759 1344 1 On on IN 42759 1344 2 the the DT 42759 1344 3 other other JJ 42759 1344 4 hand hand NN 42759 1344 5 , , , 42759 1344 6 the the DT 42759 1344 7 leaseholder leaseholder NN 42759 1344 8 could could MD 42759 1344 9 not not RB 42759 1344 10 permit permit VB 42759 1344 11 or or CC 42759 1344 12 cause cause VB 42759 1344 13 the the DT 42759 1344 14 land land NN 42759 1344 15 to to TO 42759 1344 16 deteriorate deteriorate VB 42759 1344 17 if if IN 42759 1344 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1344 19 would would MD 42759 1344 20 ; ; : 42759 1344 21 for for IN 42759 1344 22 the the DT 42759 1344 23 nature nature NN 42759 1344 24 of of IN 42759 1344 25 the the DT 42759 1344 26 land land NN 42759 1344 27 renders render VBZ 42759 1344 28 this this DT 42759 1344 29 impossible impossible JJ 42759 1344 30 . . . 42759 1345 1 Finally finally RB 42759 1345 2 , , , 42759 1345 3 the the DT 42759 1345 4 official official JJ 42759 1345 5 activities activity NNS 42759 1345 6 involved involve VBN 42759 1345 7 in in IN 42759 1345 8 the the DT 42759 1345 9 collection collection NN 42759 1345 10 of of IN 42759 1345 11 the the DT 42759 1345 12 rent rent NN 42759 1345 13 and and CC 42759 1345 14 the the DT 42759 1345 15 periodical periodical JJ 42759 1345 16 revaluation revaluation NN 42759 1345 17 of of IN 42759 1345 18 the the DT 42759 1345 19 land land NN 42759 1345 20 , , , 42759 1345 21 would would MD 42759 1345 22 not not RB 42759 1345 23 differ differ VB 42759 1345 24 essentially essentially RB 42759 1345 25 from from IN 42759 1345 26 those those DT 42759 1345 27 now now RB 42759 1345 28 required require VBN 42759 1345 29 to to TO 42759 1345 30 make make VB 42759 1345 31 assessments assessment NNS 42759 1345 32 and and CC 42759 1345 33 gather gather VB 42759 1345 34 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1345 35 . . . 42759 1346 1 The the DT 42759 1346 2 benefits benefit NNS 42759 1346 3 of of IN 42759 1346 4 this this DT 42759 1346 5 system system NN 42759 1346 6 would would MD 42759 1346 7 be be VB 42759 1346 8 great great JJ 42759 1346 9 and and CC 42759 1346 10 manifest manifest JJ 42759 1346 11 . . . 42759 1347 1 Persons person NNS 42759 1347 2 who who WP 42759 1347 3 were be VBD 42759 1347 4 unable unable JJ 42759 1347 5 to to TO 42759 1347 6 own own VB 42759 1347 7 a a DT 42759 1347 8 home home NN 42759 1347 9 because because IN 42759 1347 10 of of IN 42759 1347 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1347 12 inability inability NN 42759 1347 13 to to TO 42759 1347 14 purchase purchase VB 42759 1347 15 land land NN 42759 1347 16 , , , 42759 1347 17 could could MD 42759 1347 18 get get VB 42759 1347 19 secure secure JJ 42759 1347 20 possession possession NN 42759 1347 21 of of IN 42759 1347 22 the the DT 42759 1347 23 necessary necessary JJ 42759 1347 24 land land NN 42759 1347 25 through through IN 42759 1347 26 a a DT 42759 1347 27 lease lease NN 42759 1347 28 from from IN 42759 1347 29 the the DT 42759 1347 30 city city NN 42759 1347 31 . . . 42759 1348 1 Instead instead RB 42759 1348 2 of of IN 42759 1348 3 spending spend VBG 42759 1348 4 all all DT 42759 1348 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1348 6 lives life NNS 42759 1348 7 in in IN 42759 1348 8 rented rented JJ 42759 1348 9 houses house NNS 42759 1348 10 , , , 42759 1348 11 thousands thousand NNS 42759 1348 12 upon upon IN 42759 1348 13 thousands thousand NNS 42759 1348 14 of of IN 42759 1348 15 families family NNS 42759 1348 16 could could MD 42759 1348 17 become become VB 42759 1348 18 the the DT 42759 1348 19 owners owner NNS 42759 1348 20 and and CC 42759 1348 21 occupiers occupier NNS 42759 1348 22 of of IN 42759 1348 23 homes home NNS 42759 1348 24 . . . 42759 1349 1 The the DT 42759 1349 2 greater great JJR 42759 1349 3 the the DT 42759 1349 4 amount amount NN 42759 1349 5 of of IN 42759 1349 6 land land NN 42759 1349 7 thus thus RB 42759 1349 8 owned own VBN 42759 1349 9 and and CC 42759 1349 10 leased lease VBN 42759 1349 11 by by IN 42759 1349 12 the the DT 42759 1349 13 city city NN 42759 1349 14 , , , 42759 1349 15 the the DT 42759 1349 16 less less JJR 42759 1349 17 would would MD 42759 1349 18 be be VB 42759 1349 19 the the DT 42759 1349 20 power power NN 42759 1349 21 of of IN 42759 1349 22 private private JJ 42759 1349 23 owners owner NNS 42759 1349 24 to to TO 42759 1349 25 hold hold VB 42759 1349 26 land land NN 42759 1349 27 for for IN 42759 1349 28 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 42759 1349 29 prices price NNS 42759 1349 30 . . . 42759 1350 1 Competition competition NN 42759 1350 2 with with IN 42759 1350 3 the the DT 42759 1350 4 city city NN 42759 1350 5 would would MD 42759 1350 6 compel compel VB 42759 1350 7 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1350 8 to to TO 42759 1350 9 sell sell VB 42759 1350 10 the the DT 42759 1350 11 land land NN 42759 1350 12 at at IN 42759 1350 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1350 14 revenue revenue NN 42759 1350 15 - - HYPH 42759 1350 16 producing produce VBG 42759 1350 17 value value NN 42759 1350 18 instead instead RB 42759 1350 19 of of IN 42759 1350 20 at at IN 42759 1350 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1350 22 speculative speculative JJ 42759 1350 23 value value NN 42759 1350 24 . . . 42759 1351 1 Finally finally RB 42759 1351 2 , , , 42759 1351 3 the the DT 42759 1351 4 city city NN 42759 1351 5 would would MD 42759 1351 6 obtain obtain VB 42759 1351 7 the the DT 42759 1351 8 benefit benefit NN 42759 1351 9 of of IN 42759 1351 10 every every DT 42759 1351 11 increase increase NN 42759 1351 12 in in IN 42759 1351 13 the the DT 42759 1351 14 value value NN 42759 1351 15 of of IN 42759 1351 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1351 17 land land NN 42759 1351 18 by by IN 42759 1351 19 means mean NNS 42759 1351 20 of of IN 42759 1351 21 periodical periodical JJ 42759 1351 22 revaluation revaluation NN 42759 1351 23 , , , 42759 1351 24 and and CC 42759 1351 25 periodical periodical JJ 42759 1351 26 readjustment readjustment NN 42759 1351 27 of of IN 42759 1351 28 rent rent NN 42759 1351 29 . . . 42759 1352 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 42759 1352 2 the the DT 42759 1352 3 amount amount NN 42759 1352 4 of of IN 42759 1352 5 municipal municipal JJ 42759 1352 6 land land NN 42759 1352 7 available available JJ 42759 1352 8 for for IN 42759 1352 9 such such PDT 42759 1352 10 an an DT 42759 1352 11 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 1352 12 in in IN 42759 1352 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1352 14 American american JJ 42759 1352 15 cities city NNS 42759 1352 16 is be VBZ 42759 1352 17 negligible negligible JJ 42759 1352 18 . . . 42759 1353 1 If if IN 42759 1353 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1353 3 are be VBP 42759 1353 4 to to TO 42759 1353 5 establish establish VB 42759 1353 6 the the DT 42759 1353 7 system system NN 42759 1353 8 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1353 9 must must MD 42759 1353 10 first first RB 42759 1353 11 purchase purchase VB 42759 1353 12 the the DT 42759 1353 13 land land NN 42759 1353 14 from from IN 42759 1353 15 private private JJ 42759 1353 16 owners owner NNS 42759 1353 17 . . . 42759 1354 1 Undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 1354 2 this this DT 42759 1354 3 ought ought MD 42759 1354 4 to to TO 42759 1354 5 be be VB 42759 1354 6 done do VBN 42759 1354 7 by by IN 42759 1354 8 all all DT 42759 1354 9 large large JJ 42759 1354 10 cities city NNS 42759 1354 11 in in IN 42759 1354 12 which which WDT 42759 1354 13 the the DT 42759 1354 14 housing housing NN 42759 1354 15 problem problem NN 42759 1354 16 has have VBZ 42759 1354 17 become become VBN 42759 1354 18 acute acute JJ 42759 1354 19 , , , 42759 1354 20 and and CC 42759 1354 21 the the DT 42759 1354 22 value value NN 42759 1354 23 of of IN 42759 1354 24 land land NN 42759 1354 25 is be VBZ 42759 1354 26 constantly constantly RB 42759 1354 27 rising rise VBG 42759 1354 28 . . . 42759 1355 1 This this DT 42759 1355 2 policy policy NN 42759 1355 3 has have VBZ 42759 1355 4 been be VBN 42759 1355 5 adopted adopt VBN 42759 1355 6 with with IN 42759 1355 7 happy happy JJ 42759 1355 8 results result NNS 42759 1355 9 by by IN 42759 1355 10 many many JJ 42759 1355 11 of of IN 42759 1355 12 the the DT 42759 1355 13 municipalities municipality NNS 42759 1355 14 of of IN 42759 1355 15 France France NNP 42759 1355 16 and and CC 42759 1355 17 Germany Germany NNP 42759 1355 18 . . . 42759 1356 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1356 2 88 88 CD 42759 1356 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1356 4 At at IN 42759 1356 5 the the DT 42759 1356 6 state state NN 42759 1356 7 election election NN 42759 1356 8 of of IN 42759 1356 9 1915 1915 CD 42759 1356 10 the the DT 42759 1356 11 voters voter NNS 42759 1356 12 of of IN 42759 1356 13 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 42759 1356 14 adopted adopt VBN 42759 1356 15 by by IN 42759 1356 16 an an DT 42759 1356 17 overwhelming overwhelming JJ 42759 1356 18 majority majority NN 42759 1356 19 a a DT 42759 1356 20 constitutional constitutional JJ 42759 1356 21 amendment amendment NN 42759 1356 22 authorising authorise VBG 42759 1356 23 the the DT 42759 1356 24 cities city NNS 42759 1356 25 of of IN 42759 1356 26 the the DT 42759 1356 27 commonwealth commonwealth NNP 42759 1356 28 to to TO 42759 1356 29 acquire acquire VB 42759 1356 30 land land NN 42759 1356 31 for for IN 42759 1356 32 prospective prospective JJ 42759 1356 33 home home NN 42759 1356 34 builders builder NNS 42759 1356 35 . . . 42759 1357 1 In in IN 42759 1357 2 Savannah Savannah NNP 42759 1357 3 , , , 42759 1357 4 Georgia Georgia NNP 42759 1357 5 , , , 42759 1357 6 no no DT 42759 1357 7 extension extension NN 42759 1357 8 of of IN 42759 1357 9 the the DT 42759 1357 10 municipal municipal JJ 42759 1357 11 limits limit NNS 42759 1357 12 is be VBZ 42759 1357 13 made make VBN 42759 1357 14 until until IN 42759 1357 15 the the DT 42759 1357 16 land land NN 42759 1357 17 to to TO 42759 1357 18 be be VB 42759 1357 19 embraced embrace VBN 42759 1357 20 has have VBZ 42759 1357 21 passed pass VBN 42759 1357 22 into into IN 42759 1357 23 the the DT 42759 1357 24 ownership ownership NN 42759 1357 25 of of IN 42759 1357 26 the the DT 42759 1357 27 city city NN 42759 1357 28 . . . 42759 1358 1 Another another DT 42759 1358 2 method method NN 42759 1358 3 is be VBZ 42759 1358 4 to to TO 42759 1358 5 refrain refrain VB 42759 1358 6 from from IN 42759 1358 7 opening open VBG 42759 1358 8 a a DT 42759 1358 9 new new JJ 42759 1358 10 street street NN 42759 1358 11 in in IN 42759 1358 12 a a DT 42759 1358 13 suburban suburban JJ 42759 1358 14 district district NN 42759 1358 15 until until IN 42759 1358 16 the the DT 42759 1358 17 city city NN 42759 1358 18 has have VBZ 42759 1358 19 become become VBN 42759 1358 20 the the DT 42759 1358 21 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 1358 22 of of IN 42759 1358 23 the the DT 42759 1358 24 abutting abut VBG 42759 1358 25 land land NN 42759 1358 26 . . . 42759 1359 1 Whatever whatever WDT 42759 1359 2 be be VB 42759 1359 3 the the DT 42759 1359 4 particular particular JJ 42759 1359 5 means mean NNS 42759 1359 6 adopted adopt VBN 42759 1359 7 , , , 42759 1359 8 the the DT 42759 1359 9 objects object NNS 42759 1359 10 of of IN 42759 1359 11 municipal municipal JJ 42759 1359 12 purchase purchase NN 42759 1359 13 and and CC 42759 1359 14 ownership ownership NN 42759 1359 15 of of IN 42759 1359 16 land land NN 42759 1359 17 are be VBP 42759 1359 18 definite definite JJ 42759 1359 19 and and CC 42759 1359 20 obvious obvious JJ 42759 1359 21 : : : 42759 1359 22 to to TO 42759 1359 23 check check VB 42759 1359 24 the the DT 42759 1359 25 congestion congestion NN 42759 1359 26 of of IN 42759 1359 27 population population NN 42759 1359 28 in in IN 42759 1359 29 the the DT 42759 1359 30 great great JJ 42759 1359 31 urban urban JJ 42759 1359 32 centres centre NNS 42759 1359 33 , , , 42759 1359 34 to to TO 42759 1359 35 provide provide VB 42759 1359 36 homes home NNS 42759 1359 37 for for IN 42759 1359 38 the the DT 42759 1359 39 homeless homeless JJ 42759 1359 40 , , , 42759 1359 41 and and CC 42759 1359 42 to to TO 42759 1359 43 secure secure VB 42759 1359 44 for for IN 42759 1359 45 the the DT 42759 1359 46 whole whole JJ 42759 1359 47 community community NN 42759 1359 48 the the DT 42759 1359 49 socially socially RB 42759 1359 50 occasioned occasion VBN 42759 1359 51 increases increase NNS 42759 1359 52 in in IN 42759 1359 53 land land NN 42759 1359 54 values value NNS 42759 1359 55 . . . 42759 1360 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 1360 2 , , , 42759 1360 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1360 4 is be VBZ 42759 1360 5 probable probable JJ 42759 1360 6 that that IN 42759 1360 7 no no DT 42759 1360 8 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 1360 9 scheme scheme NN 42759 1360 10 of of IN 42759 1360 11 housing housing NN 42759 1360 12 reform reform NN 42759 1360 13 can can MD 42759 1360 14 be be VB 42759 1360 15 realised realise VBN 42759 1360 16 without without IN 42759 1360 17 a a DT 42759 1360 18 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1360 19 amount amount NN 42759 1360 20 of of IN 42759 1360 21 land land NN 42759 1360 22 purchase purchase NN 42759 1360 23 by by IN 42759 1360 24 the the DT 42759 1360 25 municipalities municipality NNS 42759 1360 26 . . . 42759 1361 1 Cities city NNS 42759 1361 2 must must MD 42759 1361 3 be be VB 42759 1361 4 in in IN 42759 1361 5 a a DT 42759 1361 6 position position NN 42759 1361 7 to to TO 42759 1361 8 provide provide VB 42759 1361 9 sites site NNS 42759 1361 10 for for IN 42759 1361 11 those those DT 42759 1361 12 home home NN 42759 1361 13 builders builder NNS 42759 1361 14 who who WP 42759 1361 15 can can MD 42759 1361 16 not not RB 42759 1361 17 obtain obtain VB 42759 1361 18 land land NN 42759 1361 19 on on IN 42759 1361 20 fair fair JJ 42759 1361 21 conditions condition NNS 42759 1361 22 from from IN 42759 1361 23 private private JJ 42759 1361 24 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 1361 25 . . . 42759 1362 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1362 2 89 89 CD 42759 1362 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1362 4 Turning turn VBG 42759 1362 5 now now RB 42759 1362 6 from from IN 42759 1362 7 the the DT 42759 1362 8 direct direct JJ 42759 1362 9 method method NN 42759 1362 10 of of IN 42759 1362 11 public public JJ 42759 1362 12 ownership ownership NN 42759 1362 13 to to IN 42759 1362 14 the the DT 42759 1362 15 indirect indirect JJ 42759 1362 16 method method NN 42759 1362 17 of of IN 42759 1362 18 reform reform NN 42759 1362 19 through through IN 42759 1362 20 taxation taxation NN 42759 1362 21 , , , 42759 1362 22 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1362 23 reject reject VBP 42759 1362 24 the the DT 42759 1362 25 thoroughgoing thoroughgoe VBG 42759 1362 26 proposals proposal NNS 42759 1362 27 of of IN 42759 1362 28 the the DT 42759 1362 29 Single Single NNP 42759 1362 30 Taxers Taxers NNPS 42759 1362 31 . . . 42759 1363 1 To to TO 42759 1363 2 appropriate appropriate VB 42759 1363 3 all all DT 42759 1363 4 economic economic JJ 42759 1363 5 rent rent NN 42759 1363 6 for for IN 42759 1363 7 the the DT 42759 1363 8 public public JJ 42759 1363 9 treasury treasury NN 42759 1363 10 would would MD 42759 1363 11 be be VB 42759 1363 12 to to TO 42759 1363 13 transfer transfer VB 42759 1363 14 all all PDT 42759 1363 15 the the DT 42759 1363 16 value value NN 42759 1363 17 of of IN 42759 1363 18 land land NN 42759 1363 19 without without IN 42759 1363 20 compensation compensation NN 42759 1363 21 from from IN 42759 1363 22 the the DT 42759 1363 23 private private JJ 42759 1363 24 owner owner NN 42759 1363 25 to to IN 42759 1363 26 the the DT 42759 1363 27 State State NNP 42759 1363 28 . . . 42759 1364 1 For for IN 42759 1364 2 example example NN 42759 1364 3 : : : 42759 1364 4 a a DT 42759 1364 5 piece piece NN 42759 1364 6 of of IN 42759 1364 7 land land NN 42759 1364 8 that that WDT 42759 1364 9 brought bring VBD 42759 1364 10 to to IN 42759 1364 11 the the DT 42759 1364 12 owner owner NN 42759 1364 13 an an DT 42759 1364 14 annual annual JJ 42759 1364 15 revenue revenue NN 42759 1364 16 of of IN 42759 1364 17 one one CD 42759 1364 18 hundred hundred CD 42759 1364 19 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1364 20 would would MD 42759 1364 21 be be VB 42759 1364 22 taxed tax VBN 42759 1364 23 exactly exactly RB 42759 1364 24 that that DT 42759 1364 25 amount amount NN 42759 1364 26 ; ; : 42759 1364 27 if if IN 42759 1364 28 the the DT 42759 1364 29 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 1364 30 rate rate NN 42759 1364 31 of of IN 42759 1364 32 interest interest NN 42759 1364 33 were be VBD 42759 1364 34 five five CD 42759 1364 35 per per IN 42759 1364 36 cent cent NN 42759 1364 37 . . . 42759 1365 1 the the DT 42759 1365 2 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 1365 3 would would MD 42759 1365 4 be be VB 42759 1365 5 deprived deprive VBN 42759 1365 6 of of IN 42759 1365 7 wealth wealth NN 42759 1365 8 to to IN 42759 1365 9 the the DT 42759 1365 10 amount amount NN 42759 1365 11 of of IN 42759 1365 12 two two CD 42759 1365 13 thousand thousand CD 42759 1365 14 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1365 15 ; ; : 42759 1365 16 for for IN 42759 1365 17 the the DT 42759 1365 18 value value NN 42759 1365 19 of of IN 42759 1365 20 all all DT 42759 1365 21 productive productive JJ 42759 1365 22 goods good NNS 42759 1365 23 is be VBZ 42759 1365 24 determined determine VBN 42759 1365 25 by by IN 42759 1365 26 the the DT 42759 1365 27 revenue revenue NN 42759 1365 28 that that WDT 42759 1365 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1365 30 yield yield VBP 42759 1365 31 , , , 42759 1365 32 and and CC 42759 1365 33 benefits benefit VBZ 42759 1365 34 the the DT 42759 1365 35 person person NN 42759 1365 36 who who WP 42759 1365 37 receives receive VBZ 42759 1365 38 the the DT 42759 1365 39 revenue revenue NN 42759 1365 40 . . . 42759 1366 1 Thus thus RB 42759 1366 2 the the DT 42759 1366 3 State state NN 42759 1366 4 would would MD 42759 1366 5 become become VB 42759 1366 6 the the DT 42759 1366 7 beneficiary beneficiary NN 42759 1366 8 and and CC 42759 1366 9 the the DT 42759 1366 10 virtual virtual JJ 42759 1366 11 owner owner NN 42759 1366 12 of of IN 42759 1366 13 the the DT 42759 1366 14 land land NN 42759 1366 15 . . . 42759 1367 1 Inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 1367 2 as as IN 42759 1367 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1367 4 do do VBP 42759 1367 5 not not RB 42759 1367 6 admit admit VB 42759 1367 7 that that IN 42759 1367 8 the the DT 42759 1367 9 so so RB 42759 1367 10 - - HYPH 42759 1367 11 called call VBN 42759 1367 12 social social JJ 42759 1367 13 creation creation NN 42759 1367 14 of of IN 42759 1367 15 land land NN 42759 1367 16 values value NNS 42759 1367 17 gives give VBZ 42759 1367 18 the the DT 42759 1367 19 State state NN 42759 1367 20 a a DT 42759 1367 21 moral moral JJ 42759 1367 22 right right NN 42759 1367 23 to to IN 42759 1367 24 these these DT 42759 1367 25 values value NNS 42759 1367 26 , , , 42759 1367 27 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1367 28 must must MD 42759 1367 29 regard regard VB 42759 1367 30 the the DT 42759 1367 31 complete complete JJ 42759 1367 32 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 1367 33 of of IN 42759 1367 34 economic economic JJ 42759 1367 35 rent rent NN 42759 1367 36 through through IN 42759 1367 37 taxation taxation NN 42759 1367 38 as as IN 42759 1367 39 an an DT 42759 1367 40 act act NN 42759 1367 41 of of IN 42759 1367 42 pure pure JJ 42759 1367 43 and and CC 42759 1367 44 simple simple JJ 42759 1367 45 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 1367 46 . . . 42759 1368 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1368 2 90 90 CD 42759 1368 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1368 4 _ _ NNP 42759 1368 5 Appropriating Appropriating NNP 42759 1368 6 Future Future NNP 42759 1368 7 Increases Increases NNPS 42759 1368 8 of of IN 42759 1368 9 Land Land NNP 42759 1368 10 Value Value NNP 42759 1368 11 _ _ NNP 42759 1368 12 Let let VB 42759 1368 13 us -PRON- PRP 42759 1368 14 examine examine VB 42759 1368 15 , , , 42759 1368 16 then then RB 42759 1368 17 , , , 42759 1368 18 the the DT 42759 1368 19 milder milder NN 42759 1368 20 suggestion suggestion NN 42759 1368 21 of of IN 42759 1368 22 John John NNP 42759 1368 23 Stuart Stuart NNP 42759 1368 24 Mill Mill NNP 42759 1368 25 , , , 42759 1368 26 that that IN 42759 1368 27 the the DT 42759 1368 28 State State NNP 42759 1368 29 should should MD 42759 1368 30 impose impose VB 42759 1368 31 a a DT 42759 1368 32 tax tax NN 42759 1368 33 upon upon IN 42759 1368 34 land land NN 42759 1368 35 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 1368 36 to to TO 42759 1368 37 absorb absorb VB 42759 1368 38 all all DT 42759 1368 39 future future JJ 42759 1368 40 increases increase NNS 42759 1368 41 in in IN 42759 1368 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1368 43 value value NN 42759 1368 44 . . . 42759 1369 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1369 2 91 91 CD 42759 1369 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1369 4 This this DT 42759 1369 5 scheme scheme NN 42759 1369 6 is be VBZ 42759 1369 7 commonly commonly RB 42759 1369 8 known know VBN 42759 1369 9 as as IN 42759 1369 10 the the DT 42759 1369 11 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 1369 12 of of IN 42759 1369 13 future future JJ 42759 1369 14 unearned unearned JJ 42759 1369 15 increment increment NN 42759 1369 16 . . . 42759 1370 1 Either either CC 42759 1370 2 in in IN 42759 1370 3 whole whole NN 42759 1370 4 or or CC 42759 1370 5 in in IN 42759 1370 6 part part NN 42759 1370 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1370 8 is be VBZ 42759 1370 9 at at IN 42759 1370 10 least least JJS 42759 1370 11 plausible plausible JJ 42759 1370 12 , , , 42759 1370 13 and and CC 42759 1370 14 is be VBZ 42759 1370 15 to to TO 42759 1370 16 - - HYPH 42759 1370 17 day day NN 42759 1370 18 within within IN 42759 1370 19 the the DT 42759 1370 20 range range NN 42759 1370 21 of of IN 42759 1370 22 practical practical JJ 42759 1370 23 discussion discussion NN 42759 1370 24 . . . 42759 1371 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1371 2 is be VBZ 42759 1371 3 expected expect VBN 42759 1371 4 to to TO 42759 1371 5 obtain obtain VB 42759 1371 6 for for IN 42759 1371 7 the the DT 42759 1371 8 whole whole JJ 42759 1371 9 community community NN 42759 1371 10 all all DT 42759 1371 11 future future JJ 42759 1371 12 increases increase NNS 42759 1371 13 in in IN 42759 1371 14 land land NN 42759 1371 15 values value NNS 42759 1371 16 , , , 42759 1371 17 and and CC 42759 1371 18 to to TO 42759 1371 19 wipe wipe VB 42759 1371 20 out out RP 42759 1371 21 the the DT 42759 1371 22 speculative speculative NN 42759 1371 23 , , , 42759 1371 24 as as IN 42759 1371 25 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 1371 26 from from IN 42759 1371 27 the the DT 42759 1371 28 revenue revenue NN 42759 1371 29 - - HYPH 42759 1371 30 producing produce VBG 42759 1371 31 value value NN 42759 1371 32 of of IN 42759 1371 33 land land NN 42759 1371 34 . . . 42759 1372 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 1372 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1372 3 would would MD 42759 1372 4 make make VB 42759 1372 5 land land NN 42759 1372 6 cheaper cheap JJR 42759 1372 7 and and CC 42759 1372 8 more more RBR 42759 1372 9 accessible accessible JJ 42759 1372 10 than than IN 42759 1372 11 would would MD 42759 1372 12 be be VB 42759 1372 13 the the DT 42759 1372 14 case case NN 42759 1372 15 if if IN 42759 1372 16 the the DT 42759 1372 17 present present JJ 42759 1372 18 system system NN 42759 1372 19 of of IN 42759 1372 20 land land NN 42759 1372 21 taxation taxation NN 42759 1372 22 were be VBD 42759 1372 23 continued continue VBN 42759 1372 24 . . . 42759 1373 1 Before before IN 42759 1373 2 discussing discuss VBG 42759 1373 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1373 4 moral moral JJ 42759 1373 5 character character NN 42759 1373 6 , , , 42759 1373 7 let let VB 42759 1373 8 us -PRON- PRP 42759 1373 9 see see VB 42759 1373 10 briefly briefly RB 42759 1373 11 whether whether IN 42759 1373 12 the the DT 42759 1373 13 ends end NNS 42759 1373 14 that that WDT 42759 1373 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1373 16 seeks seek VBZ 42759 1373 17 may may MD 42759 1373 18 properly properly RB 42759 1373 19 be be VB 42759 1373 20 sought seek VBN 42759 1373 21 by by IN 42759 1373 22 the the DT 42759 1373 23 method method NN 42759 1373 24 of of IN 42759 1373 25 taxation taxation NN 42759 1373 26 . . . 42759 1374 1 For for IN 42759 1374 2 these these DT 42759 1374 3 ends end NNS 42759 1374 4 are be VBP 42759 1374 5 mainly mainly RB 42759 1374 6 social social JJ 42759 1374 7 rather rather RB 42759 1374 8 than than IN 42759 1374 9 fiscal fiscal JJ 42759 1374 10 . . . 42759 1375 1 To to TO 42759 1375 2 use use VB 42759 1375 3 the the DT 42759 1375 4 taxing tax VBG 42759 1375 5 power power NN 42759 1375 6 for for IN 42759 1375 7 a a DT 42759 1375 8 social social JJ 42759 1375 9 purpose purpose NN 42759 1375 10 is be VBZ 42759 1375 11 neither neither CC 42759 1375 12 unusual unusual JJ 42759 1375 13 nor nor CC 42759 1375 14 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 1375 15 . . . 42759 1376 1 " " `` 42759 1376 2 All all DT 42759 1376 3 governments government NNS 42759 1376 4 , , , 42759 1376 5 " " '' 42759 1376 6 says say VBZ 42759 1376 7 Professor Professor NNP 42759 1376 8 Seligman Seligman NNP 42759 1376 9 , , , 42759 1376 10 " " '' 42759 1376 11 have have VBP 42759 1376 12 allowed allow VBN 42759 1376 13 social social JJ 42759 1376 14 considerations consideration NNS 42759 1376 15 in in IN 42759 1376 16 the the DT 42759 1376 17 wider wide JJR 42759 1376 18 sense sense NN 42759 1376 19 to to TO 42759 1376 20 influence influence VB 42759 1376 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1376 22 revenue revenue NN 42759 1376 23 policy policy NN 42759 1376 24 . . . 42759 1377 1 The the DT 42759 1377 2 whole whole JJ 42759 1377 3 system system NN 42759 1377 4 of of IN 42759 1377 5 productive productive JJ 42759 1377 6 duties duty NNS 42759 1377 7 has have VBZ 42759 1377 8 been be VBN 42759 1377 9 framed frame VBN 42759 1377 10 not not RB 42759 1377 11 merely merely RB 42759 1377 12 with with IN 42759 1377 13 reference reference NN 42759 1377 14 to to IN 42759 1377 15 revenue revenue NN 42759 1377 16 considerations consideration NNS 42759 1377 17 , , , 42759 1377 18 but but CC 42759 1377 19 in in IN 42759 1377 20 order order NN 42759 1377 21 to to TO 42759 1377 22 produce produce VB 42759 1377 23 results result NNS 42759 1377 24 which which WDT 42759 1377 25 should should MD 42759 1377 26 directly directly RB 42759 1377 27 affect affect VB 42759 1377 28 social social JJ 42759 1377 29 and and CC 42759 1377 30 national national JJ 42759 1377 31 prosperity prosperity NN 42759 1377 32 . . . 42759 1378 1 Taxes taxis NNS 42759 1378 2 on on IN 42759 1378 3 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 1378 4 have have VBP 42759 1378 5 often often RB 42759 1378 6 been be VBN 42759 1378 7 mere mere JJ 42759 1378 8 sumptuary sumptuary JJ 42759 1378 9 laws law NNS 42759 1378 10 designed design VBN 42759 1378 11 as as RB 42759 1378 12 much much RB 42759 1378 13 to to TO 42759 1378 14 check check VB 42759 1378 15 consumption consumption NN 42759 1378 16 as as IN 42759 1378 17 to to TO 42759 1378 18 yield yield VB 42759 1378 19 revenue revenue NN 42759 1378 20 . . . 42759 1379 1 Excise excise NN 42759 1379 2 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1379 3 have have VBP 42759 1379 4 as as RB 42759 1379 5 frequently frequently RB 42759 1379 6 been be VBN 42759 1379 7 levied levy VBN 42759 1379 8 from from IN 42759 1379 9 a a DT 42759 1379 10 wide wide JJ 42759 1379 11 social social JJ 42759 1379 12 , , , 42759 1379 13 as as IN 42759 1379 14 from from IN 42759 1379 15 a a DT 42759 1379 16 narrow narrow JJ 42759 1379 17 fiscal fiscal JJ 42759 1379 18 , , , 42759 1379 19 standpoint standpoint NN 42759 1379 20 . . . 42759 1380 1 From from IN 42759 1380 2 the the DT 42759 1380 3 very very JJ 42759 1380 4 beginning beginning NN 42759 1380 5 of of IN 42759 1380 6 all all DT 42759 1380 7 tax tax NN 42759 1380 8 systems system NNS 42759 1380 9 these these DT 42759 1380 10 social social JJ 42759 1380 11 reasons reason NNS 42759 1380 12 have have VBP 42759 1380 13 often often RB 42759 1380 14 been be VBN 42759 1380 15 present present JJ 42759 1380 16 . . . 42759 1381 1 " " `` 42759 1381 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1381 3 92 92 CD 42759 1381 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1381 5 Our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1381 6 Federal federal JJ 42759 1381 7 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1381 8 on on IN 42759 1381 9 imports import NNS 42759 1381 10 , , , 42759 1381 11 on on IN 42759 1381 12 intoxicating intoxicate VBG 42759 1381 13 liquors liquor NNS 42759 1381 14 , , , 42759 1381 15 on on IN 42759 1381 16 oleo oleo NNP 42759 1381 17 - - HYPH 42759 1381 18 margarine margarine NNP 42759 1381 19 , , , 42759 1381 20 and and CC 42759 1381 21 on on IN 42759 1381 22 white white JJ 42759 1381 23 phosphorus phosphorus NN 42759 1381 24 matches match NNS 42759 1381 25 , , , 42759 1381 26 and and CC 42759 1381 27 many many JJ 42759 1381 28 of of IN 42759 1381 29 the the DT 42759 1381 30 license license NN 42759 1381 31 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1381 32 in in IN 42759 1381 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1381 34 municipalities municipality NNS 42759 1381 35 , , , 42759 1381 36 as as IN 42759 1381 37 on on IN 42759 1381 38 pedlars pedlar NNS 42759 1381 39 , , , 42759 1381 40 saloon saloon NN 42759 1381 41 keepers keeper NNS 42759 1381 42 , , , 42759 1381 43 and and CC 42759 1381 44 dog dog NN 42759 1381 45 owners owner NNS 42759 1381 46 , , , 42759 1381 47 are be VBP 42759 1381 48 in in IN 42759 1381 49 large large JJ 42759 1381 50 part part NN 42759 1381 51 intended intend VBN 42759 1381 52 to to TO 42759 1381 53 meet meet VB 42759 1381 54 social social JJ 42759 1381 55 as as RB 42759 1381 56 well well RB 42759 1381 57 as as IN 42759 1381 58 fiscal fiscal JJ 42759 1381 59 ends end NNS 42759 1381 60 . . . 42759 1382 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 1382 2 are be VBP 42759 1382 3 in in IN 42759 1382 4 the the DT 42759 1382 5 interest interest NN 42759 1382 6 of of IN 42759 1382 7 domestic domestic JJ 42759 1382 8 production production NN 42759 1382 9 , , , 42759 1382 10 public public JJ 42759 1382 11 health health NN 42759 1382 12 , , , 42759 1382 13 and and CC 42759 1382 14 public public JJ 42759 1382 15 safety safety NN 42759 1382 16 . . . 42759 1383 1 The the DT 42759 1383 2 reasonableness reasonableness NN 42759 1383 3 of of IN 42759 1383 4 effecting effect VBG 42759 1383 5 social social JJ 42759 1383 6 reforms reform NNS 42759 1383 7 through through IN 42759 1383 8 taxation taxation NN 42759 1383 9 can can MD 42759 1383 10 not not RB 42759 1383 11 be be VB 42759 1383 12 seriously seriously RB 42759 1383 13 questioned question VBN 42759 1383 14 . . . 42759 1384 1 While while IN 42759 1384 2 the the DT 42759 1384 3 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 1384 4 of of IN 42759 1384 5 government government NN 42759 1384 6 is be VBZ 42759 1384 7 the the DT 42759 1384 8 primary primary JJ 42759 1384 9 object object NN 42759 1384 10 of of IN 42759 1384 11 taxation taxation NN 42759 1384 12 , , , 42759 1384 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1384 14 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 1384 15 end end NN 42759 1384 16 , , , 42759 1384 17 the the DT 42759 1384 18 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 1384 19 end end NN 42759 1384 20 of of IN 42759 1384 21 government government NN 42759 1384 22 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 1384 23 , , , 42759 1384 24 is be VBZ 42759 1384 25 the the DT 42759 1384 26 welfare welfare NN 42759 1384 27 of of IN 42759 1384 28 the the DT 42759 1384 29 people people NNS 42759 1384 30 . . . 42759 1385 1 Now now RB 42759 1385 2 if if IN 42759 1385 3 the the DT 42759 1385 4 public public JJ 42759 1385 5 welfare welfare NN 42759 1385 6 can can MD 42759 1385 7 be be VB 42759 1385 8 promoted promote VBN 42759 1385 9 by by IN 42759 1385 10 certain certain JJ 42759 1385 11 social social JJ 42759 1385 12 changes change NNS 42759 1385 13 , , , 42759 1385 14 and and CC 42759 1385 15 if if IN 42759 1385 16 these these DT 42759 1385 17 in in IN 42759 1385 18 turn turn NN 42759 1385 19 can can MD 42759 1385 20 be be VB 42759 1385 21 effected effect VBN 42759 1385 22 through through IN 42759 1385 23 taxation taxation NN 42759 1385 24 , , , 42759 1385 25 this this DT 42759 1385 26 use use NN 42759 1385 27 of of IN 42759 1385 28 the the DT 42759 1385 29 taxing tax VBG 42759 1385 30 power power NN 42759 1385 31 will will MD 42759 1385 32 be be VB 42759 1385 33 quite quite RB 42759 1385 34 as as RB 42759 1385 35 normal normal JJ 42759 1385 36 and and CC 42759 1385 37 legitimate legitimate JJ 42759 1385 38 as as IN 42759 1385 39 though though IN 42759 1385 40 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1385 41 were be VBD 42759 1385 42 employed employ VBN 42759 1385 43 for for IN 42759 1385 44 the the DT 42759 1385 45 upkeep upkeep NN 42759 1385 46 of of IN 42759 1385 47 government government NN 42759 1385 48 . . . 42759 1386 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1386 2 the the DT 42759 1386 3 morality morality NN 42759 1386 4 of of IN 42759 1386 5 taxing tax VBG 42759 1386 6 land land NN 42759 1386 7 for for IN 42759 1386 8 purposes purpose NNS 42759 1386 9 of of IN 42759 1386 10 social social JJ 42759 1386 11 reform reform NN 42759 1386 12 will will MD 42759 1386 13 depend depend VB 42759 1386 14 entirely entirely RB 42759 1386 15 upon upon IN 42759 1386 16 the the DT 42759 1386 17 nature nature NN 42759 1386 18 of of IN 42759 1386 19 the the DT 42759 1386 20 particular particular JJ 42759 1386 21 tax tax NN 42759 1386 22 that that WDT 42759 1386 23 is be VBZ 42759 1386 24 imposed impose VBN 42759 1386 25 . . . 42759 1387 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1387 2 Some some DT 42759 1387 3 Objections Objections NNPS 42759 1387 4 to to IN 42759 1387 5 the the DT 42759 1387 6 Increment Increment NNP 42759 1387 7 Tax Tax NNP 42759 1387 8 _ _ NNP 42759 1387 9 The the DT 42759 1387 10 tax tax NN 42759 1387 11 that that WDT 42759 1387 12 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1387 13 are be VBP 42759 1387 14 now now RB 42759 1387 15 considering consider VBG 42759 1387 16 can can MD 42759 1387 17 be be VB 42759 1387 18 condemned condemn VBN 42759 1387 19 as as IN 42759 1387 20 unjust unjust JJ 42759 1387 21 on on IN 42759 1387 22 only only RB 42759 1387 23 two two CD 42759 1387 24 possible possible JJ 42759 1387 25 grounds ground NNS 42759 1387 26 : : : 42759 1387 27 first first RB 42759 1387 28 , , , 42759 1387 29 that that IN 42759 1387 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1387 31 would would MD 42759 1387 32 be be VB 42759 1387 33 injurious injurious JJ 42759 1387 34 to to IN 42759 1387 35 society society NN 42759 1387 36 ; ; : 42759 1387 37 and and CC 42759 1387 38 , , , 42759 1387 39 second second RB 42759 1387 40 , , , 42759 1387 41 that that IN 42759 1387 42 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1387 43 would would MD 42759 1387 44 wrong wrong VB 42759 1387 45 the the DT 42759 1387 46 private private JJ 42759 1387 47 landowner landowner NN 42759 1387 48 . . . 42759 1388 1 If if IN 42759 1388 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1388 3 were be VBD 42759 1388 4 fairly fairly RB 42759 1388 5 adjusted adjust VBN 42759 1388 6 and and CC 42759 1388 7 efficiently efficiently RB 42759 1388 8 administered administer VBN 42759 1388 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1388 10 could could MD 42759 1388 11 not not RB 42759 1388 12 prove prove VB 42759 1388 13 harmful harmful JJ 42759 1388 14 to to IN 42759 1388 15 the the DT 42759 1388 16 community community NN 42759 1388 17 . . . 42759 1389 1 In in IN 42759 1389 2 the the DT 42759 1389 3 first first JJ 42759 1389 4 place place NN 42759 1389 5 , , , 42759 1389 6 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1389 7 could could MD 42759 1389 8 not not RB 42759 1389 9 shift shift VB 42759 1389 10 the the DT 42759 1389 11 tax tax NN 42759 1389 12 to to IN 42759 1389 13 the the DT 42759 1389 14 consumer consumer NN 42759 1389 15 . . . 42759 1390 1 All all PDT 42759 1390 2 the the DT 42759 1390 3 authorities authority NNS 42759 1390 4 on on IN 42759 1390 5 the the DT 42759 1390 6 subject subject JJ 42759 1390 7 admit admit NN 42759 1390 8 that that IN 42759 1390 9 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1390 10 on on IN 42759 1390 11 land land NN 42759 1390 12 stay stay NN 42759 1390 13 where where WRB 42759 1390 14 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1390 15 are be VBP 42759 1390 16 put put VBN 42759 1390 17 , , , 42759 1390 18 and and CC 42759 1390 19 are be VBP 42759 1390 20 paid pay VBN 42759 1390 21 by by IN 42759 1390 22 those those DT 42759 1390 23 upon upon IN 42759 1390 24 whom whom WP 42759 1390 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1390 26 are be VBP 42759 1390 27 levied levy VBN 42759 1390 28 in in IN 42759 1390 29 the the DT 42759 1390 30 first first JJ 42759 1390 31 instance instance NN 42759 1390 32 . . . 42759 1391 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1391 2 93 93 CD 42759 1391 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1391 4 The the DT 42759 1391 5 only only JJ 42759 1391 6 way way NN 42759 1391 7 in in IN 42759 1391 8 which which WDT 42759 1391 9 the the DT 42759 1391 10 owners owner NNS 42759 1391 11 of of IN 42759 1391 12 a a DT 42759 1391 13 commodity commodity NN 42759 1391 14 can can MD 42759 1391 15 shift shift VB 42759 1391 16 a a DT 42759 1391 17 tax tax NN 42759 1391 18 to to IN 42759 1391 19 the the DT 42759 1391 20 users user NNS 42759 1391 21 or or CC 42759 1391 22 consumers consumer NNS 42759 1391 23 of of IN 42759 1391 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1391 25 , , , 42759 1391 26 is be VBZ 42759 1391 27 by by IN 42759 1391 28 limiting limit VBG 42759 1391 29 the the DT 42759 1391 30 supply supply NN 42759 1391 31 until until IN 42759 1391 32 the the DT 42759 1391 33 price price NN 42759 1391 34 rises rise VBZ 42759 1391 35 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 1391 36 to to TO 42759 1391 37 cover cover VB 42759 1391 38 the the DT 42759 1391 39 tax tax NN 42759 1391 40 . . . 42759 1392 1 By by IN 42759 1392 2 the the DT 42759 1392 3 simple simple JJ 42759 1392 4 device device NN 42759 1392 5 of of IN 42759 1392 6 refusing refuse VBG 42759 1392 7 to to TO 42759 1392 8 erect erect VB 42759 1392 9 more more JJR 42759 1392 10 buildings building NNS 42759 1392 11 until until IN 42759 1392 12 those those DT 42759 1392 13 in in IN 42759 1392 14 existence existence NN 42759 1392 15 have have VBP 42759 1392 16 become become VBN 42759 1392 17 scarce scarce JJ 42759 1392 18 enough enough RB 42759 1392 19 to to TO 42759 1392 20 command command VB 42759 1392 21 an an DT 42759 1392 22 increase increase NN 42759 1392 23 in in IN 42759 1392 24 rent rent NN 42759 1392 25 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 1392 26 to to IN 42759 1392 27 the the DT 42759 1392 28 new new JJ 42759 1392 29 tax tax NN 42759 1392 30 , , , 42759 1392 31 the the DT 42759 1392 32 actual actual JJ 42759 1392 33 and and CC 42759 1392 34 prospective prospective JJ 42759 1392 35 owners owner NNS 42759 1392 36 of of IN 42759 1392 37 buildings building NNS 42759 1392 38 can can MD 42759 1392 39 pass pass VB 42759 1392 40 the the DT 42759 1392 41 tax tax NN 42759 1392 42 on on RP 42759 1392 43 to to IN 42759 1392 44 the the DT 42759 1392 45 tenants tenant NNS 42759 1392 46 thereof thereof RB 42759 1392 47 . . . 42759 1393 1 By by IN 42759 1393 2 refusing refuse VBG 42759 1393 3 to to TO 42759 1393 4 put put VB 42759 1393 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1393 6 money money NN 42759 1393 7 into into IN 42759 1393 8 , , , 42759 1393 9 say say UH 42759 1393 10 , , , 42759 1393 11 shoe shoe NN 42759 1393 12 factories factory NNS 42759 1393 13 , , , 42759 1393 14 investors investor NNS 42759 1393 15 can can MD 42759 1393 16 limit limit VB 42759 1393 17 the the DT 42759 1393 18 supply supply NN 42759 1393 19 of of IN 42759 1393 20 shoes shoe NNS 42759 1393 21 until until IN 42759 1393 22 any any DT 42759 1393 23 new new JJ 42759 1393 24 tax tax NN 42759 1393 25 on on IN 42759 1393 26 this this DT 42759 1393 27 commodity commodity NN 42759 1393 28 is be VBZ 42759 1393 29 shifted shift VBN 42759 1393 30 upon upon IN 42759 1393 31 the the DT 42759 1393 32 wearers wearer NNS 42759 1393 33 of of IN 42759 1393 34 shoes shoe NNS 42759 1393 35 in in IN 42759 1393 36 the the DT 42759 1393 37 form form NN 42759 1393 38 of of IN 42759 1393 39 higher high JJR 42759 1393 40 prices price NNS 42759 1393 41 . . . 42759 1394 1 Until until IN 42759 1394 2 these these DT 42759 1394 3 rises rise NNS 42759 1394 4 take take VBP 42759 1394 5 place place NN 42759 1394 6 in in IN 42759 1394 7 the the DT 42759 1394 8 rent rent NN 42759 1394 9 of of IN 42759 1394 10 buildings building NNS 42759 1394 11 and and CC 42759 1394 12 the the DT 42759 1394 13 price price NN 42759 1394 14 of of IN 42759 1394 15 shoes shoe NNS 42759 1394 16 , , , 42759 1394 17 investors investor NNS 42759 1394 18 will will MD 42759 1394 19 put put VB 42759 1394 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1394 21 money money NN 42759 1394 22 into into IN 42759 1394 23 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 1394 24 which which WDT 42759 1394 25 are be VBP 42759 1394 26 not not RB 42759 1394 27 burdened burden VBN 42759 1394 28 with with IN 42759 1394 29 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 1394 30 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1394 31 . . . 42759 1395 1 But but CC 42759 1395 2 nothing nothing NN 42759 1395 3 of of IN 42759 1395 4 this this DT 42759 1395 5 sort sort NN 42759 1395 6 can can MD 42759 1395 7 follow follow VB 42759 1395 8 the the DT 42759 1395 9 imposition imposition NN 42759 1395 10 of of IN 42759 1395 11 a a DT 42759 1395 12 new new JJ 42759 1395 13 tax tax NN 42759 1395 14 upon upon IN 42759 1395 15 land land NN 42759 1395 16 . . . 42759 1396 1 The the DT 42759 1396 2 supply supply NN 42759 1396 3 of of IN 42759 1396 4 land land NN 42759 1396 5 is be VBZ 42759 1396 6 fixed fix VBN 42759 1396 7 , , , 42759 1396 8 and and CC 42759 1396 9 can can MD 42759 1396 10 not not RB 42759 1396 11 be be VB 42759 1396 12 affected affect VBN 42759 1396 13 by by IN 42759 1396 14 any any DT 42759 1396 15 action action NN 42759 1396 16 of of IN 42759 1396 17 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1396 18 or or CC 42759 1396 19 would would MD 42759 1396 20 - - HYPH 42759 1396 21 be be VB 42759 1396 22 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1396 23 . . . 42759 1397 1 The the DT 42759 1397 2 users user NNS 42759 1397 3 of of IN 42759 1397 4 land land NN 42759 1397 5 and and CC 42759 1397 6 the the DT 42759 1397 7 consumers consumer NNS 42759 1397 8 of of IN 42759 1397 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1397 10 products product NNS 42759 1397 11 are be VBP 42759 1397 12 at at IN 42759 1397 13 present present JJ 42759 1397 14 paying pay VBG 42759 1397 15 all all PDT 42759 1397 16 that that DT 42759 1397 17 competition competition NN 42759 1397 18 can can MD 42759 1397 19 compel compel VB 42759 1397 20 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1397 21 to to TO 42759 1397 22 pay pay VB 42759 1397 23 . . . 42759 1398 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 1398 2 would would MD 42759 1398 3 not not RB 42759 1398 4 pay pay VB 42759 1398 5 more more RBR 42759 1398 6 merely merely RB 42759 1398 7 because because IN 42759 1398 8 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1398 9 were be VBD 42759 1398 10 requested request VBN 42759 1398 11 to to TO 42759 1398 12 do do VB 42759 1398 13 so so RB 42759 1398 14 by by IN 42759 1398 15 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1398 16 who who WP 42759 1398 17 were be VBD 42759 1398 18 labouring labour VBG 42759 1398 19 under under IN 42759 1398 20 the the DT 42759 1398 21 burden burden NN 42759 1398 22 of of IN 42759 1398 23 a a DT 42759 1398 24 new new JJ 42759 1398 25 tax tax NN 42759 1398 26 . . . 42759 1399 1 If if IN 42759 1399 2 all all DT 42759 1399 3 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1399 4 were be VBD 42759 1399 5 to to TO 42759 1399 6 carry carry VB 42759 1399 7 out out RP 42759 1399 8 an an DT 42759 1399 9 agreement agreement NN 42759 1399 10 to to TO 42759 1399 11 refrain refrain VB 42759 1399 12 from from IN 42759 1399 13 producing produce VBG 42759 1399 14 , , , 42759 1399 15 and and CC 42759 1399 16 to to TO 42759 1399 17 withhold withhold VB 42759 1399 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1399 19 land land NN 42759 1399 20 from from IN 42759 1399 21 others other NNS 42759 1399 22 until until IN 42759 1399 23 rents rent NNS 42759 1399 24 and and CC 42759 1399 25 prices price NNS 42759 1399 26 had have VBD 42759 1399 27 gone go VBN 42759 1399 28 up up RP 42759 1399 29 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 1399 30 to to TO 42759 1399 31 offset offset VB 42759 1399 32 the the DT 42759 1399 33 tax tax NN 42759 1399 34 , , , 42759 1399 35 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1399 36 could could MD 42759 1399 37 , , , 42759 1399 38 indeed indeed RB 42759 1399 39 , , , 42759 1399 40 shift shift VB 42759 1399 41 the the DT 42759 1399 42 latter latter JJ 42759 1399 43 to to IN 42759 1399 44 the the DT 42759 1399 45 renters renter NNS 42759 1399 46 of of IN 42759 1399 47 land land NN 42759 1399 48 and and CC 42759 1399 49 the the DT 42759 1399 50 consumers consumer NNS 42759 1399 51 of of IN 42759 1399 52 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1399 53 products product NNS 42759 1399 54 . . . 42759 1400 1 Such such PDT 42759 1400 2 a a DT 42759 1400 3 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1400 4 , , , 42759 1400 5 however however RB 42759 1400 6 , , , 42759 1400 7 is be VBZ 42759 1400 8 not not RB 42759 1400 9 within within IN 42759 1400 10 the the DT 42759 1400 11 range range NN 42759 1400 12 of of IN 42759 1400 13 practical practical JJ 42759 1400 14 achievement achievement NN 42759 1400 15 . . . 42759 1401 1 In in IN 42759 1401 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1401 3 absence absence NN 42759 1401 4 , , , 42759 1401 5 individual individual JJ 42759 1401 6 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1401 7 are be VBP 42759 1401 8 not not RB 42759 1401 9 likely likely JJ 42759 1401 10 to to TO 42759 1401 11 withhold withhold VB 42759 1401 12 land land NN 42759 1401 13 nor nor CC 42759 1401 14 to to TO 42759 1401 15 discontinue discontinue VB 42759 1401 16 production production NN 42759 1401 17 in in IN 42759 1401 18 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 1401 19 numbers number NNS 42759 1401 20 to to TO 42759 1401 21 raise raise VB 42759 1401 22 rents rent NNS 42759 1401 23 or or CC 42759 1401 24 prices price NNS 42759 1401 25 . . . 42759 1402 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 1402 2 , , , 42759 1402 3 the the DT 42759 1402 4 tendency tendency NN 42759 1402 5 will will MD 42759 1402 6 be be VB 42759 1402 7 all all PDT 42759 1402 8 the the DT 42759 1402 9 other other JJ 42759 1402 10 way way NN 42759 1402 11 ; ; : 42759 1402 12 for for IN 42759 1402 13 all all DT 42759 1402 14 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1402 15 , , , 42759 1402 16 including include VBG 42759 1402 17 the the DT 42759 1402 18 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 1402 19 of of IN 42759 1402 20 land land NN 42759 1402 21 now now RB 42759 1402 22 vacant vacant JJ 42759 1402 23 , , , 42759 1402 24 will will MD 42759 1402 25 be be VB 42759 1402 26 anxious anxious JJ 42759 1402 27 to to TO 42759 1402 28 put put VB 42759 1402 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1402 30 land land NN 42759 1402 31 to to IN 42759 1402 32 the the DT 42759 1402 33 best good JJS 42759 1402 34 use use NN 42759 1402 35 in in IN 42759 1402 36 order order NN 42759 1402 37 to to TO 42759 1402 38 have have VB 42759 1402 39 the the DT 42759 1402 40 means mean NNS 42759 1402 41 of of IN 42759 1402 42 paying pay VBG 42759 1402 43 the the DT 42759 1402 44 tax tax NN 42759 1402 45 . . . 42759 1403 1 Owing owe VBG 42759 1403 2 to to IN 42759 1403 3 this this DT 42759 1403 4 increased increase VBN 42759 1403 5 production production NN 42759 1403 6 , , , 42759 1403 7 and and CC 42759 1403 8 the the DT 42759 1403 9 increased increase VBN 42759 1403 10 willingness willingness NN 42759 1403 11 to to TO 42759 1403 12 sell sell VB 42759 1403 13 and and CC 42759 1403 14 let let VB 42759 1403 15 land land NN 42759 1403 16 , , , 42759 1403 17 rents rent NNS 42759 1403 18 and and CC 42759 1403 19 prices price NNS 42759 1403 20 must must MD 42759 1403 21 fall fall VB 42759 1403 22 . . . 42759 1404 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1404 2 is be VBZ 42759 1404 3 axiomatic axiomatic JJ 42759 1404 4 that that IN 42759 1404 5 new new JJ 42759 1404 6 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1404 7 upon upon IN 42759 1404 8 land land NN 42759 1404 9 always always RB 42759 1404 10 make make VBP 42759 1404 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1404 12 cheaper cheap JJR 42759 1404 13 than than IN 42759 1404 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1404 15 would would MD 42759 1404 16 have have VB 42759 1404 17 been be VBN 42759 1404 18 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 1404 19 , , , 42759 1404 20 and and CC 42759 1404 21 are be VBP 42759 1404 22 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 1404 23 to to IN 42759 1404 24 the the DT 42759 1404 25 community community NN 42759 1404 26 as as IN 42759 1404 27 against against IN 42759 1404 28 the the DT 42759 1404 29 present present JJ 42759 1404 30 owners owner NNS 42759 1404 31 . . . 42759 1405 1 In in IN 42759 1405 2 the the DT 42759 1405 3 second second JJ 42759 1405 4 place place NN 42759 1405 5 , , , 42759 1405 6 the the DT 42759 1405 7 tax tax NN 42759 1405 8 in in IN 42759 1405 9 question question NN 42759 1405 10 could could MD 42759 1405 11 not not RB 42759 1405 12 injure injure VB 42759 1405 13 the the DT 42759 1405 14 community community NN 42759 1405 15 on on IN 42759 1405 16 account account NN 42759 1405 17 of of IN 42759 1405 18 discouraging discourage VBG 42759 1405 19 investment investment NN 42759 1405 20 in in IN 42759 1405 21 land land NN 42759 1405 22 . . . 42759 1406 1 Once once IN 42759 1406 2 men man NNS 42759 1406 3 could could MD 42759 1406 4 no no RB 42759 1406 5 longer longer RB 42759 1406 6 hope hope VB 42759 1406 7 to to TO 42759 1406 8 sell sell VB 42759 1406 9 land land NN 42759 1406 10 at at IN 42759 1406 11 an an DT 42759 1406 12 advance advance NN 42759 1406 13 in in IN 42759 1406 14 price price NN 42759 1406 15 , , , 42759 1406 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1406 17 would would MD 42759 1406 18 not not RB 42759 1406 19 seek seek VB 42759 1406 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1406 21 to to IN 42759 1406 22 the the DT 42759 1406 23 extent extent NN 42759 1406 24 that that IN 42759 1406 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1406 26 now now RB 42759 1406 27 do do VBP 42759 1406 28 as as IN 42759 1406 29 a a DT 42759 1406 30 field field NN 42759 1406 31 of of IN 42759 1406 32 investment investment NN 42759 1406 33 . . . 42759 1407 1 For for IN 42759 1407 2 the the DT 42759 1407 3 same same JJ 42759 1407 4 reason reason NN 42759 1407 5 many many JJ 42759 1407 6 of of IN 42759 1407 7 the the DT 42759 1407 8 present present JJ 42759 1407 9 owners owner NNS 42759 1407 10 would would MD 42759 1407 11 sell sell VB 42759 1407 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1407 13 holdings holding NNS 42759 1407 14 sooner soon RBR 42759 1407 15 than than IN 42759 1407 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1407 17 would would MD 42759 1407 18 have have VB 42759 1407 19 sold sell VBN 42759 1407 20 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1407 21 if if IN 42759 1407 22 the the DT 42759 1407 23 tax tax NN 42759 1407 24 had have VBD 42759 1407 25 not not RB 42759 1407 26 been be VBN 42759 1407 27 levied levy VBN 42759 1407 28 . . . 42759 1408 1 From from IN 42759 1408 2 the the DT 42759 1408 3 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 1408 4 of of IN 42759 1408 5 the the DT 42759 1408 6 public public NN 42759 1408 7 the the DT 42759 1408 8 outcome outcome NN 42759 1408 9 of of IN 42759 1408 10 this this DT 42759 1408 11 situation situation NN 42759 1408 12 would would MD 42759 1408 13 be be VB 42759 1408 14 wholly wholly RB 42759 1408 15 good good JJ 42759 1408 16 . . . 42759 1409 1 Land land NN 42759 1409 2 would would MD 42759 1409 3 be be VB 42759 1409 4 cheaper cheap JJR 42759 1409 5 and and CC 42759 1409 6 more more RBR 42759 1409 7 easy easy JJ 42759 1409 8 of of IN 42759 1409 9 access access NN 42759 1409 10 to to IN 42759 1409 11 all all DT 42759 1409 12 who who WP 42759 1409 13 desired desire VBD 42759 1409 14 to to TO 42759 1409 15 buy buy VB 42759 1409 16 or or CC 42759 1409 17 use use VB 42759 1409 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1409 19 for for IN 42759 1409 20 the the DT 42759 1409 21 sake sake NN 42759 1409 22 of of IN 42759 1409 23 production production NN 42759 1409 24 , , , 42759 1409 25 rather rather RB 42759 1409 26 than than IN 42759 1409 27 for for IN 42759 1409 28 the the DT 42759 1409 29 sake sake NN 42759 1409 30 of of IN 42759 1409 31 speculation speculation NN 42759 1409 32 . . . 42759 1410 1 Investments investment NNS 42759 1410 2 in in IN 42759 1410 3 land land NN 42759 1410 4 which which WDT 42759 1410 5 have have VBP 42759 1410 6 as as IN 42759 1410 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1410 8 main main JJ 42759 1410 9 object object NN 42759 1410 10 a a DT 42759 1410 11 rise rise NN 42759 1410 12 in in IN 42759 1410 13 value value NN 42759 1410 14 are be VBP 42759 1410 15 an an DT 42759 1410 16 injury injury NN 42759 1410 17 rather rather RB 42759 1410 18 than than IN 42759 1410 19 a a DT 42759 1410 20 benefit benefit NN 42759 1410 21 to to IN 42759 1410 22 the the DT 42759 1410 23 community community NN 42759 1410 24 ; ; : 42759 1410 25 for for CC 42759 1410 26 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1410 27 do do VBP 42759 1410 28 not not RB 42759 1410 29 increase increase VB 42759 1410 30 the the DT 42759 1410 31 products product NNS 42759 1410 32 of of IN 42759 1410 33 land land NN 42759 1410 34 , , , 42759 1410 35 while while IN 42759 1410 36 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1410 37 do do VBP 42759 1410 38 advance advance VB 42759 1410 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1410 40 price price NN 42759 1410 41 , , , 42759 1410 42 thereby thereby RB 42759 1410 43 keeping keep VBG 42759 1410 44 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1410 45 out out IN 42759 1410 46 of of IN 42759 1410 47 use use NN 42759 1410 48 . . . 42759 1411 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1411 2 the the DT 42759 1411 3 State state NN 42759 1411 4 should should MD 42759 1411 5 discourage discourage VB 42759 1411 6 instead instead RB 42759 1411 7 of of IN 42759 1411 8 encouraging encourage VBG 42759 1411 9 mere mere JJ 42759 1411 10 speculators speculator NNS 42759 1411 11 in in IN 42759 1411 12 land land NN 42759 1411 13 . . . 42759 1412 1 Whether whether IN 42759 1412 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1412 3 is be VBZ 42759 1412 4 or or CC 42759 1412 5 is be VBZ 42759 1412 6 not not RB 42759 1412 7 bought buy VBN 42759 1412 8 and and CC 42759 1412 9 sold sell VBN 42759 1412 10 , , , 42759 1412 11 the the DT 42759 1412 12 supply supply NN 42759 1412 13 of of IN 42759 1412 14 land land NN 42759 1412 15 remains remain VBZ 42759 1412 16 the the DT 42759 1412 17 same same JJ 42759 1412 18 . . . 42759 1413 1 The the DT 42759 1413 2 supreme supreme JJ 42759 1413 3 interest interest NN 42759 1413 4 of of IN 42759 1413 5 the the DT 42759 1413 6 community community NN 42759 1413 7 is be VBZ 42759 1413 8 that that IN 42759 1413 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1413 10 should should MD 42759 1413 11 be be VB 42759 1413 12 put put VBN 42759 1413 13 to to IN 42759 1413 14 use use NN 42759 1413 15 , , , 42759 1413 16 and and CC 42759 1413 17 made make VBN 42759 1413 18 to to TO 42759 1413 19 supply supply VB 42759 1413 20 the the DT 42759 1413 21 wants want NNS 42759 1413 22 of of IN 42759 1413 23 the the DT 42759 1413 24 people people NNS 42759 1413 25 . . . 42759 1414 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 1414 2 the the DT 42759 1414 3 only only JJ 42759 1414 4 land land NN 42759 1414 5 investments investment NNS 42759 1414 6 that that WDT 42759 1414 7 help help VBP 42759 1414 8 the the DT 42759 1414 9 community community NN 42759 1414 10 are be VBP 42759 1414 11 those those DT 42759 1414 12 that that WDT 42759 1414 13 tend tend VBP 42759 1414 14 to to TO 42759 1414 15 make make VB 42759 1414 16 the the DT 42759 1414 17 land land NN 42759 1414 18 productive productive JJ 42759 1414 19 . . . 42759 1415 1 Under under IN 42759 1415 2 a a DT 42759 1415 3 tax tax NN 42759 1415 4 on on IN 42759 1415 5 future future JJ 42759 1415 6 increases increase NNS 42759 1415 7 in in IN 42759 1415 8 value value NN 42759 1415 9 , , , 42759 1415 10 such such JJ 42759 1415 11 investments investment NNS 42759 1415 12 would would MD 42759 1415 13 increase increase VB 42759 1415 14 for for IN 42759 1415 15 the the DT 42759 1415 16 simple simple JJ 42759 1415 17 reason reason NN 42759 1415 18 that that IN 42759 1415 19 land land NN 42759 1415 20 would would MD 42759 1415 21 be be VB 42759 1415 22 cheaper cheap JJR 42759 1415 23 than than IN 42759 1415 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1415 25 would would MD 42759 1415 26 have have VB 42759 1415 27 been be VBN 42759 1415 28 without without IN 42759 1415 29 the the DT 42759 1415 30 tax tax NN 42759 1415 31 . . . 42759 1416 1 Men man NNS 42759 1416 2 who who WP 42759 1416 3 desired desire VBD 42759 1416 4 land land NN 42759 1416 5 for for IN 42759 1416 6 the the DT 42759 1416 7 sake sake NN 42759 1416 8 of of IN 42759 1416 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1416 10 rent rent NN 42759 1416 11 or or CC 42759 1416 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1416 13 product product NN 42759 1416 14 would would MD 42759 1416 15 continue continue VB 42759 1416 16 as as IN 42759 1416 17 now now RB 42759 1416 18 to to TO 42759 1416 19 pay pay VB 42759 1416 20 such such JJ 42759 1416 21 prices price NNS 42759 1416 22 for for IN 42759 1416 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1416 24 as as IN 42759 1416 25 would would MD 42759 1416 26 enable enable VB 42759 1416 27 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1416 28 to to TO 42759 1416 29 obtain obtain VB 42759 1416 30 the the DT 42759 1416 31 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 1416 32 rate rate NN 42759 1416 33 of of IN 42759 1416 34 interest interest NN 42759 1416 35 on on IN 42759 1416 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1416 37 investment investment NN 42759 1416 38 after after IN 42759 1416 39 all all DT 42759 1416 40 charges charge NNS 42759 1416 41 , , , 42759 1416 42 including include VBG 42759 1416 43 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1416 44 , , , 42759 1416 45 had have VBD 42759 1416 46 been be VBN 42759 1416 47 paid pay VBN 42759 1416 48 . . . 42759 1417 1 Men man NNS 42759 1417 2 who who WP 42759 1417 3 wanted want VBD 42759 1417 4 to to TO 42759 1417 5 rent rent VB 42759 1417 6 land land NN 42759 1417 7 would would MD 42759 1417 8 continue continue VB 42759 1417 9 as as IN 42759 1417 10 now now RB 42759 1417 11 to to TO 42759 1417 12 get get VB 42759 1417 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1417 14 at at IN 42759 1417 15 a a DT 42759 1417 16 rental rental NN 42759 1417 17 that that WDT 42759 1417 18 would would MD 42759 1417 19 give give VB 42759 1417 20 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1417 21 the the DT 42759 1417 22 usual usual JJ 42759 1417 23 return return NN 42759 1417 24 for for IN 42759 1417 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1417 26 capital capital NN 42759 1417 27 and and CC 42759 1417 28 labour labour NN 42759 1417 29 . . . 42759 1418 1 So so RB 42759 1418 2 much much JJ 42759 1418 3 for for IN 42759 1418 4 the the DT 42759 1418 5 effect effect NN 42759 1418 6 of of IN 42759 1418 7 the the DT 42759 1418 8 tax tax NN 42759 1418 9 upon upon IN 42759 1418 10 the the DT 42759 1418 11 community community NN 42759 1418 12 . . . 42759 1419 1 Would Would MD 42759 1419 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1419 3 not not RB 42759 1419 4 , , , 42759 1419 5 however however RB 42759 1419 6 , , , 42759 1419 7 be be VB 42759 1419 8 unjust unjust JJ 42759 1419 9 to to IN 42759 1419 10 the the DT 42759 1419 11 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1419 12 ? ? . 42759 1420 1 Does do VBZ 42759 1420 2 not not RB 42759 1420 3 private private JJ 42759 1420 4 ownership ownership NN 42759 1420 5 of of IN 42759 1420 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1420 7 very very JJ 42759 1420 8 nature nature NN 42759 1420 9 demand demand NN 42759 1420 10 that that WDT 42759 1420 11 increases increase VBZ 42759 1420 12 in in IN 42759 1420 13 the the DT 42759 1420 14 value value NN 42759 1420 15 of of IN 42759 1420 16 the the DT 42759 1420 17 property property NN 42759 1420 18 should should MD 42759 1420 19 go go VB 42759 1420 20 to to IN 42759 1420 21 the the DT 42759 1420 22 owners owner NNS 42759 1420 23 thereof thereof RB 42759 1420 24 ? ? . 42759 1421 1 " " `` 42759 1421 2 Res res VB 42759 1421 3 fructificat fructificat JJ 42759 1421 4 domino domino NN 42759 1421 5 : : : 42759 1421 6 " " `` 42759 1421 7 a a DT 42759 1421 8 thing thing NN 42759 1421 9 fructifies fructifie NNS 42759 1421 10 to to IN 42759 1421 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1421 12 owner owner NN 42759 1421 13 ; ; , 42759 1421 14 and and CC 42759 1421 15 value value NN 42759 1421 16 - - HYPH 42759 1421 17 increases increase NNS 42759 1421 18 may may MD 42759 1421 19 be be VB 42759 1421 20 classed class VBN 42759 1421 21 as as IN 42759 1421 22 a a DT 42759 1421 23 kind kind NN 42759 1421 24 of of IN 42759 1421 25 fruit fruit NN 42759 1421 26 . . . 42759 1422 1 In in IN 42759 1422 2 the the DT 42759 1422 3 first first JJ 42759 1422 4 place place NN 42759 1422 5 , , , 42759 1422 6 this this DT 42759 1422 7 formula formula NN 42759 1422 8 was be VBD 42759 1422 9 originally originally RB 42759 1422 10 a a DT 42759 1422 11 dictum dictum NN 42759 1422 12 of of IN 42759 1422 13 the the DT 42759 1422 14 civil civil JJ 42759 1422 15 law law NN 42759 1422 16 merely merely RB 42759 1422 17 , , , 42759 1422 18 the the DT 42759 1422 19 law law NN 42759 1422 20 of of IN 42759 1422 21 the the DT 42759 1422 22 Roman Roman NNP 42759 1422 23 Empire Empire NNP 42759 1422 24 . . . 42759 1423 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1423 2 was be VBD 42759 1423 3 a a DT 42759 1423 4 legal legal JJ 42759 1423 5 rather rather RB 42759 1423 6 than than IN 42759 1423 7 an an DT 42759 1423 8 ethical ethical JJ 42759 1423 9 maxim maxim NN 42759 1423 10 . . . 42759 1424 1 Whatever whatever WDT 42759 1424 2 validity validity NN 42759 1424 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1424 4 has have VBZ 42759 1424 5 in in IN 42759 1424 6 morals moral NNS 42759 1424 7 must must MD 42759 1424 8 be be VB 42759 1424 9 established establish VBN 42759 1424 10 on on IN 42759 1424 11 moral moral JJ 42759 1424 12 grounds ground NNS 42759 1424 13 , , , 42759 1424 14 by by IN 42759 1424 15 moral moral JJ 42759 1424 16 arguments argument NNS 42759 1424 17 . . . 42759 1425 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1425 2 can can MD 42759 1425 3 not not RB 42759 1425 4 forthwith forthwith VB 42759 1425 5 be be VB 42759 1425 6 assumed assume VBN 42759 1425 7 to to TO 42759 1425 8 be be VB 42759 1425 9 morally morally RB 42759 1425 10 sound sound JJ 42759 1425 11 on on IN 42759 1425 12 the the DT 42759 1425 13 mere mere JJ 42759 1425 14 authority authority NN 42759 1425 15 of of IN 42759 1425 16 legal legal JJ 42759 1425 17 usage usage NN 42759 1425 18 . . . 42759 1426 1 In in IN 42759 1426 2 the the DT 42759 1426 3 second second JJ 42759 1426 4 place place NN 42759 1426 5 , , , 42759 1426 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1426 7 was be VBD 42759 1426 8 for for IN 42759 1426 9 a a DT 42759 1426 10 long long JJ 42759 1426 11 time time NN 42759 1426 12 applied apply VBN 42759 1426 13 only only RB 42759 1426 14 to to IN 42759 1426 15 natural natural JJ 42759 1426 16 products product NNS 42759 1426 17 , , , 42759 1426 18 to to IN 42759 1426 19 the the DT 42759 1426 20 grain grain NN 42759 1426 21 grown grow VBN 42759 1426 22 in in IN 42759 1426 23 a a DT 42759 1426 24 field field NN 42759 1426 25 , , , 42759 1426 26 to to IN 42759 1426 27 the the DT 42759 1426 28 offspring offspring NN 42759 1426 29 of of IN 42759 1426 30 domestic domestic JJ 42759 1426 31 animals animal NNS 42759 1426 32 . . . 42759 1427 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1427 2 simply simply RB 42759 1427 3 enunciated enunciate VBD 42759 1427 4 the the DT 42759 1427 5 policy policy NN 42759 1427 6 of of IN 42759 1427 7 the the DT 42759 1427 8 law law NN 42759 1427 9 to to TO 42759 1427 10 defend defend VB 42759 1427 11 the the DT 42759 1427 12 owner owner NN 42759 1427 13 of of IN 42759 1427 14 the the DT 42759 1427 15 land land NN 42759 1427 16 in in IN 42759 1427 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1427 18 claim claim NN 42759 1427 19 to to IN 42759 1427 20 such such JJ 42759 1427 21 fruits fruit NNS 42759 1427 22 , , , 42759 1427 23 as as IN 42759 1427 24 against against IN 42759 1427 25 any any DT 42759 1427 26 outsider outsider NN 42759 1427 27 who who WP 42759 1427 28 should should MD 42759 1427 29 attempt attempt VB 42759 1427 30 to to TO 42759 1427 31 set set VB 42759 1427 32 up up RP 42759 1427 33 an an DT 42759 1427 34 adverse adverse JJ 42759 1427 35 title title NN 42759 1427 36 through through IN 42759 1427 37 mere mere JJ 42759 1427 38 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 1427 39 or or CC 42759 1427 40 possession possession NN 42759 1427 41 . . . 42759 1428 1 Thus thus RB 42759 1428 2 far far RB 42759 1428 3 , , , 42759 1428 4 the the DT 42759 1428 5 formula formula NN 42759 1428 6 was be VBD 42759 1428 7 evidently evidently RB 42759 1428 8 in in IN 42759 1428 9 conformity conformity NN 42759 1428 10 with with IN 42759 1428 11 reason reason NN 42759 1428 12 and and CC 42759 1428 13 justice justice NN 42759 1428 14 . . . 42759 1429 1 Later later RB 42759 1429 2 on on IN 42759 1429 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1429 4 was be VBD 42759 1429 5 extended extend VBN 42759 1429 6 , , , 42759 1429 7 both both CC 42759 1429 8 by by IN 42759 1429 9 lawyers lawyer NNS 42759 1429 10 and and CC 42759 1429 11 moralists moralist NNS 42759 1429 12 , , , 42759 1429 13 to to TO 42759 1429 14 cover cover VB 42759 1429 15 commercial commercial JJ 42759 1429 16 " " `` 42759 1429 17 fruits fruit NNS 42759 1429 18 , , , 42759 1429 19 " " '' 42759 1429 20 such such JJ 42759 1429 21 as as IN 42759 1429 22 , , , 42759 1429 23 rent rent NN 42759 1429 24 from from IN 42759 1429 25 lands land NNS 42759 1429 26 and and CC 42759 1429 27 houses house NNS 42759 1429 28 , , , 42759 1429 29 and and CC 42759 1429 30 interest interest NN 42759 1429 31 from from IN 42759 1429 32 loans loan NNS 42759 1429 33 and and CC 42759 1429 34 investments investment NNS 42759 1429 35 . . . 42759 1430 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1430 2 validity validity NN 42759 1430 3 in in IN 42759 1430 4 this this DT 42759 1430 5 field field NN 42759 1430 6 will will MD 42759 1430 7 be be VB 42759 1430 8 examined examine VBN 42759 1430 9 in in IN 42759 1430 10 connection connection NN 42759 1430 11 with with IN 42759 1430 12 the the DT 42759 1430 13 justification justification NN 42759 1430 14 of of IN 42759 1430 15 interest interest NN 42759 1430 16 . . . 42759 1431 1 More more RBR 42759 1431 2 recently recently RB 42759 1431 3 the the DT 42759 1431 4 maxim maxim NN 42759 1431 5 has have VBZ 42759 1431 6 received receive VBN 42759 1431 7 the the DT 42759 1431 8 still still RB 42759 1431 9 wider wide JJR 42759 1431 10 application application NN 42759 1431 11 which which WDT 42759 1431 12 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1431 13 are be VBP 42759 1431 14 now now RB 42759 1431 15 considering consider VBG 42759 1431 16 . . . 42759 1432 1 Obviously obviously RB 42759 1432 2 increases increase VBZ 42759 1432 3 in in IN 42759 1432 4 value value NN 42759 1432 5 are be VBP 42759 1432 6 quite quite PDT 42759 1432 7 a a DT 42759 1432 8 different different JJ 42759 1432 9 thing thing NN 42759 1432 10 from from IN 42759 1432 11 the the DT 42759 1432 12 concrete concrete JJ 42759 1432 13 fruit fruit NN 42759 1432 14 of of IN 42759 1432 15 the the DT 42759 1432 16 land land NN 42759 1432 17 , , , 42759 1432 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1432 19 natural natural JJ 42759 1432 20 product product NN 42759 1432 21 . . . 42759 1433 1 A a DT 42759 1433 2 right right NN 42759 1433 3 to to IN 42759 1433 4 the the DT 42759 1433 5 latter latter JJ 42759 1433 6 does do VBZ 42759 1433 7 not not RB 42759 1433 8 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 1433 9 and and CC 42759 1433 10 forthwith forthwith NNP 42759 1433 11 imply imply VB 42759 1433 12 a a DT 42759 1433 13 right right NN 42759 1433 14 to to IN 42759 1433 15 the the DT 42759 1433 16 former former JJ 42759 1433 17 . . . 42759 1434 1 In in IN 42759 1434 2 the the DT 42759 1434 3 third third JJ 42759 1434 4 place place NN 42759 1434 5 , , , 42759 1434 6 the the DT 42759 1434 7 formula formula NN 42759 1434 8 in in IN 42759 1434 9 question question NN 42759 1434 10 is be VBZ 42759 1434 11 not not RB 42759 1434 12 a a DT 42759 1434 13 self self NN 42759 1434 14 evident evident JJ 42759 1434 15 , , , 42759 1434 16 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 1434 17 principle principle NN 42759 1434 18 . . . 42759 1435 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1435 2 is be VBZ 42759 1435 3 merely merely RB 42759 1435 4 a a DT 42759 1435 5 summary summary NN 42759 1435 6 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 1435 7 drawn draw VBN 42759 1435 8 from from IN 42759 1435 9 the the DT 42759 1435 10 consideration consideration NN 42759 1435 11 of of IN 42759 1435 12 the the DT 42759 1435 13 facts fact NNS 42759 1435 14 and and CC 42759 1435 15 principles principle NNS 42759 1435 16 of of IN 42759 1435 17 social social JJ 42759 1435 18 and and CC 42759 1435 19 industrial industrial JJ 42759 1435 20 life life NN 42759 1435 21 . . . 42759 1436 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 1436 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1436 3 validity validity NN 42759 1436 4 as as IN 42759 1436 5 applied apply VBN 42759 1436 6 to to IN 42759 1436 7 any any DT 42759 1436 8 particular particular JJ 42759 1436 9 situation situation NN 42759 1436 10 will will MD 42759 1436 11 depend depend VB 42759 1436 12 on on IN 42759 1436 13 the the DT 42759 1436 14 correctness correctness NN 42759 1436 15 of of IN 42759 1436 16 these these DT 42759 1436 17 premises premise NNS 42759 1436 18 , , , 42759 1436 19 and and CC 42759 1436 20 on on IN 42759 1436 21 the the DT 42759 1436 22 soundness soundness NN 42759 1436 23 of of IN 42759 1436 24 the the DT 42759 1436 25 process process NN 42759 1436 26 by by IN 42759 1436 27 which which WDT 42759 1436 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1436 29 has have VBZ 42759 1436 30 been be VBN 42759 1436 31 deduced deduce VBN 42759 1436 32 . . . 42759 1437 1 The the DT 42759 1437 2 increment increment JJ 42759 1437 3 tax tax NN 42759 1437 4 is be VBZ 42759 1437 5 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 1437 6 opposed oppose VBN 42759 1437 7 on on IN 42759 1437 8 the the DT 42759 1437 9 ground ground NN 42759 1437 10 that that IN 42759 1437 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1437 12 is be VBZ 42759 1437 13 new new JJ 42759 1437 14 , , , 42759 1437 15 in in IN 42759 1437 16 fact fact NN 42759 1437 17 , , , 42759 1437 18 revolutionary revolutionary JJ 42759 1437 19 . . . 42759 1438 1 In in IN 42759 1438 2 some some DT 42759 1438 3 degree degree NN 42759 1438 4 the the DT 42759 1438 5 charge charge NN 42759 1438 6 is be VBZ 42759 1438 7 true true JJ 42759 1438 8 , , , 42759 1438 9 but but CC 42759 1438 10 the the DT 42759 1438 11 conditions condition NNS 42759 1438 12 which which WDT 42759 1438 13 the the DT 42759 1438 14 proposal proposal NN 42759 1438 15 is be VBZ 42759 1438 16 intended intend VBN 42759 1438 17 to to TO 42759 1438 18 meet meet VB 42759 1438 19 are be VBP 42759 1438 20 likewise likewise RB 42759 1438 21 of of IN 42759 1438 22 recent recent JJ 42759 1438 23 origin origin NN 42759 1438 24 . . . 42759 1439 1 The the DT 42759 1439 2 case case NN 42759 1439 3 for for IN 42759 1439 4 this this DT 42759 1439 5 legislation legislation NN 42759 1439 6 rests rest VBZ 42759 1439 7 mainly mainly RB 42759 1439 8 on on IN 42759 1439 9 the the DT 42759 1439 10 fact fact NN 42759 1439 11 that that IN 42759 1439 12 , , , 42759 1439 13 for for IN 42759 1439 14 the the DT 42759 1439 15 first first JJ 42759 1439 16 time time NN 42759 1439 17 in in IN 42759 1439 18 the the DT 42759 1439 19 world world NN 42759 1439 20 's 's POS 42759 1439 21 history history NN 42759 1439 22 , , , 42759 1439 23 land land NN 42759 1439 24 values value NNS 42759 1439 25 everywhere everywhere RB 42759 1439 26 show show VBP 42759 1439 27 an an DT 42759 1439 28 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 42759 1439 29 tendency tendency NN 42759 1439 30 to to TO 42759 1439 31 advance advance VB 42759 1439 32 indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 1439 33 . . . 42759 1440 1 This this DT 42759 1440 2 means mean VBZ 42759 1440 3 that that IN 42759 1440 4 the the DT 42759 1440 5 landowning landowne VBG 42759 1440 6 minority minority NN 42759 1440 7 will will MD 42759 1440 8 be be VB 42759 1440 9 in in IN 42759 1440 10 a a DT 42759 1440 11 position position NN 42759 1440 12 to to TO 42759 1440 13 reap reap VB 42759 1440 14 unbought unbought JJ 42759 1440 15 and and CC 42759 1440 16 continuous continuous JJ 42759 1440 17 benefits benefit NNS 42759 1440 18 at at IN 42759 1440 19 the the DT 42759 1440 20 expense expense NN 42759 1440 21 of of IN 42759 1440 22 the the DT 42759 1440 23 landless landless JJ 42759 1440 24 majority majority NN 42759 1440 25 . . . 42759 1441 1 This this DT 42759 1441 2 new new JJ 42759 1441 3 fact fact NN 42759 1441 4 , , , 42759 1441 5 with with IN 42759 1441 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1441 7 very very RB 42759 1441 8 important important JJ 42759 1441 9 significance significance NN 42759 1441 10 for for IN 42759 1441 11 human human JJ 42759 1441 12 welfare welfare NN 42759 1441 13 , , , 42759 1441 14 may may MD 42759 1441 15 well well RB 42759 1441 16 require require VB 42759 1441 17 a a DT 42759 1441 18 new new JJ 42759 1441 19 limitation limitation NN 42759 1441 20 on on IN 42759 1441 21 the the DT 42759 1441 22 right right NN 42759 1441 23 of of IN 42759 1441 24 property property NN 42759 1441 25 in in IN 42759 1441 26 land land NN 42759 1441 27 . . . 42759 1442 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1442 2 is be VBZ 42759 1442 3 also also RB 42759 1442 4 objected object VBN 42759 1442 5 that that DT 42759 1442 6 to to TO 42759 1442 7 deprive deprive VB 42759 1442 8 men man NNS 42759 1442 9 of of IN 42759 1442 10 the the DT 42759 1442 11 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 1442 12 of of IN 42759 1442 13 profiting profit VBG 42759 1442 14 by by IN 42759 1442 15 changes change NNS 42759 1442 16 in in IN 42759 1442 17 the the DT 42759 1442 18 value value NN 42759 1442 19 of of IN 42759 1442 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1442 21 land land NN 42759 1442 22 would would MD 42759 1442 23 be be VB 42759 1442 24 an an DT 42759 1442 25 unfair unfair JJ 42759 1442 26 discrimination discrimination NN 42759 1442 27 against against IN 42759 1442 28 one one CD 42759 1442 29 class class NN 42759 1442 30 of of IN 42759 1442 31 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 1442 32 . . . 42759 1443 1 But but CC 42759 1443 2 there there EX 42759 1443 3 are be VBP 42759 1443 4 good good JJ 42759 1443 5 reasons reason NNS 42759 1443 6 for for IN 42759 1443 7 making make VBG 42759 1443 8 the the DT 42759 1443 9 distinction distinction NN 42759 1443 10 . . . 42759 1444 1 Except except IN 42759 1444 2 in in IN 42759 1444 3 the the DT 42759 1444 4 case case NN 42759 1444 5 of of IN 42759 1444 6 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1444 7 , , , 42759 1444 8 increases increase NNS 42759 1444 9 in in IN 42759 1444 10 the the DT 42759 1444 11 value value NN 42759 1444 12 of of IN 42759 1444 13 goods good NNS 42759 1444 14 other other JJ 42759 1444 15 than than IN 42759 1444 16 land land NN 42759 1444 17 are be VBP 42759 1444 18 almost almost RB 42759 1444 19 always always RB 42759 1444 20 due due JJ 42759 1444 21 to to IN 42759 1444 22 expenditures expenditure NNS 42759 1444 23 of of IN 42759 1444 24 labour labour NN 42759 1444 25 or or CC 42759 1444 26 money money NN 42759 1444 27 upon upon IN 42759 1444 28 the the DT 42759 1444 29 goods good NNS 42759 1444 30 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 1444 31 . . . 42759 1445 1 The the DT 42759 1445 2 value value NN 42759 1445 3 increases increase VBZ 42759 1445 4 that that WDT 42759 1445 5 can can MD 42759 1445 6 be be VB 42759 1445 7 specifically specifically RB 42759 1445 8 traced trace VBN 42759 1445 9 to to IN 42759 1445 10 external external JJ 42759 1445 11 and and CC 42759 1445 12 social social JJ 42759 1445 13 influences influence NNS 42759 1445 14 are be VBP 42759 1445 15 intermittent intermittent JJ 42759 1445 16 , , , 42759 1445 17 uncertain uncertain JJ 42759 1445 18 , , , 42759 1445 19 and and CC 42759 1445 20 temporary temporary JJ 42759 1445 21 . . . 42759 1446 1 Houses house NNS 42759 1446 2 , , , 42759 1446 3 furniture furniture NN 42759 1446 4 , , , 42759 1446 5 machinery machinery NN 42759 1446 6 , , , 42759 1446 7 and and CC 42759 1446 8 every every DT 42759 1446 9 other other JJ 42759 1446 10 important important JJ 42759 1446 11 category category NN 42759 1446 12 of of IN 42759 1446 13 artificial artificial JJ 42759 1446 14 goods good NNS 42759 1446 15 are be VBP 42759 1446 16 perishable perishable JJ 42759 1446 17 , , , 42759 1446 18 and and CC 42759 1446 19 decline decline VBP 42759 1446 20 steadily steadily RB 42759 1446 21 in in IN 42759 1446 22 value value NN 42759 1446 23 . . . 42759 1447 1 Land land NN 42759 1447 2 , , , 42759 1447 3 however however RB 42759 1447 4 , , , 42759 1447 5 is be VBZ 42759 1447 6 substantially substantially RB 42759 1447 7 imperishable imperishable JJ 42759 1447 8 , , , 42759 1447 9 becomes become VBZ 42759 1447 10 steadily steadily RB 42759 1447 11 scarcer scarcer NN 42759 1447 12 relatively relatively RB 42759 1447 13 to to IN 42759 1447 14 the the DT 42759 1447 15 demand demand NN 42759 1447 16 , , , 42759 1447 17 and and CC 42759 1447 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1447 19 value value NN 42759 1447 20 - - HYPH 42759 1447 21 increases increase NNS 42759 1447 22 are be VBP 42759 1447 23 on on IN 42759 1447 24 the the DT 42759 1447 25 whole whole JJ 42759 1447 26 constant constant JJ 42759 1447 27 , , , 42759 1447 28 certain certain JJ 42759 1447 29 , , , 42759 1447 30 and and CC 42759 1447 31 permanent permanent JJ 42759 1447 32 . . . 42759 1448 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 1448 2 , , , 42759 1448 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1448 4 is be VBZ 42759 1448 5 the the DT 42759 1448 6 settled settled JJ 42759 1448 7 policy policy NN 42759 1448 8 of of IN 42759 1448 9 most most RBS 42759 1448 10 enlightened enlighten VBN 42759 1448 11 governments government NNS 42759 1448 12 to to TO 42759 1448 13 appropriate appropriate VB 42759 1448 14 or or CC 42759 1448 15 to to TO 42759 1448 16 prevent prevent VB 42759 1448 17 all all DT 42759 1448 18 notable notable JJ 42759 1448 19 increases increase NNS 42759 1448 20 in in IN 42759 1448 21 the the DT 42759 1448 22 value value NN 42759 1448 23 of of IN 42759 1448 24 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 1448 25 goods good NNS 42759 1448 26 , , , 42759 1448 27 either either CC 42759 1448 28 through through IN 42759 1448 29 special special JJ 42759 1448 30 taxation taxation NN 42759 1448 31 or or CC 42759 1448 32 through through IN 42759 1448 33 regulation regulation NN 42759 1448 34 of of IN 42759 1448 35 prices price NNS 42759 1448 36 and and CC 42759 1448 37 charges charge NNS 42759 1448 38 . . . 42759 1449 1 Taking take VBG 42759 1449 2 the the DT 42759 1449 3 increment increment JJ 42759 1449 4 values value NNS 42759 1449 5 of of IN 42759 1449 6 land land NN 42759 1449 7 is be VBZ 42759 1449 8 , , , 42759 1449 9 therefore therefore RB 42759 1449 10 , , , 42759 1449 11 not not RB 42759 1449 12 so so RB 42759 1449 13 discriminative discriminative JJ 42759 1449 14 as as IN 42759 1449 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1449 16 appears appear VBZ 42759 1449 17 at at IN 42759 1449 18 first first JJ 42759 1449 19 glance glance NN 42759 1449 20 . . . 42759 1450 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1450 2 94 94 CD 42759 1450 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1450 4 Another another DT 42759 1450 5 objection objection NN 42759 1450 6 is be VBZ 42759 1450 7 that that IN 42759 1450 8 the the DT 42759 1450 9 proposal proposal NN 42759 1450 10 would would MD 42759 1450 11 violate violate VB 42759 1450 12 the the DT 42759 1450 13 canons canon NNS 42759 1450 14 of of IN 42759 1450 15 just just RB 42759 1450 16 taxation taxation NN 42759 1450 17 , , , 42759 1450 18 since since IN 42759 1450 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1450 20 would would MD 42759 1450 21 impose impose VB 42759 1450 22 a a DT 42759 1450 23 specially specially RB 42759 1450 24 heavy heavy JJ 42759 1450 25 burden burden NN 42759 1450 26 upon upon IN 42759 1450 27 one one CD 42759 1450 28 form form NN 42759 1450 29 of of IN 42759 1450 30 property property NN 42759 1450 31 . . . 42759 1451 1 The the DT 42759 1451 2 general general JJ 42759 1451 3 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 1451 4 of of IN 42759 1451 5 justice justice NN 42759 1451 6 in in IN 42759 1451 7 taxation taxation NN 42759 1451 8 which which WDT 42759 1451 9 is be VBZ 42759 1451 10 held hold VBN 42759 1451 11 by by IN 42759 1451 12 substantially substantially RB 42759 1451 13 all all DT 42759 1451 14 economists economist NNS 42759 1451 15 to to IN 42759 1451 16 - - HYPH 42759 1451 17 day day NN 42759 1451 18 , , , 42759 1451 19 and and CC 42759 1451 20 which which WDT 42759 1451 21 has have VBZ 42759 1451 22 been be VBN 42759 1451 23 taught teach VBN 42759 1451 24 by by IN 42759 1451 25 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 1451 26 moralists moralist NNS 42759 1451 27 for for IN 42759 1451 28 centuries century NNS 42759 1451 29 , , , 42759 1451 30 is be VBZ 42759 1451 31 that that DT 42759 1451 32 known know VBN 42759 1451 33 as as IN 42759 1451 34 the the DT 42759 1451 35 " " `` 42759 1451 36 faculty faculty NN 42759 1451 37 " " '' 42759 1451 38 theory theory NN 42759 1451 39 . . . 42759 1452 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1452 2 95 95 CD 42759 1452 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1452 4 Men men NN 42759 1452 5 should should MD 42759 1452 6 be be VB 42759 1452 7 taxed tax VBN 42759 1452 8 in in IN 42759 1452 9 proportion proportion NN 42759 1452 10 to to IN 42759 1452 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1452 12 ability ability NN 42759 1452 13 to to TO 42759 1452 14 pay pay VB 42759 1452 15 , , , 42759 1452 16 not not RB 42759 1452 17 in in IN 42759 1452 18 accordance accordance NN 42759 1452 19 with with IN 42759 1452 20 the the DT 42759 1452 21 benefits benefit NNS 42759 1452 22 that that WDT 42759 1452 23 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1452 24 may may MD 42759 1452 25 be be VB 42759 1452 26 assumed assume VBN 42759 1452 27 to to TO 42759 1452 28 receive receive VB 42759 1452 29 from from IN 42759 1452 30 the the DT 42759 1452 31 State State NNP 42759 1452 32 . . . 42759 1453 1 And and CC 42759 1453 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1453 3 is be VBZ 42759 1453 4 universally universally RB 42759 1453 5 recognised recognise VBN 42759 1453 6 that that IN 42759 1453 7 the the DT 42759 1453 8 proper proper JJ 42759 1453 9 measure measure NN 42759 1453 10 of of IN 42759 1453 11 " " `` 42759 1453 12 ability ability NN 42759 1453 13 " " '' 42759 1453 14 is be VBZ 42759 1453 15 not not RB 42759 1453 16 a a DT 42759 1453 17 man man NN 42759 1453 18 's 's POS 42759 1453 19 total total JJ 42759 1453 20 possessions possession NNS 42759 1453 21 , , , 42759 1453 22 productive productive JJ 42759 1453 23 and and CC 42759 1453 24 unproductive unproductive JJ 42759 1453 25 , , , 42759 1453 26 but but CC 42759 1453 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1453 28 income income NN 42759 1453 29 , , , 42759 1453 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1453 31 annual annual JJ 42759 1453 32 revenue revenue NN 42759 1453 33 . . . 42759 1454 1 Now now RB 42759 1454 2 , , , 42759 1454 3 the the DT 42759 1454 4 increment increment JJ 42759 1454 5 tax tax NN 42759 1454 6 does do VBZ 42759 1454 7 seem seem VB 42759 1454 8 to to TO 42759 1454 9 violate violate VB 42759 1454 10 the the DT 42759 1454 11 rule rule NN 42759 1454 12 of of IN 42759 1454 13 taxation taxation NN 42759 1454 14 according accord VBG 42759 1454 15 to to IN 42759 1454 16 ability ability NN 42759 1454 17 , , , 42759 1454 18 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 1454 19 as as IN 42759 1454 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1454 21 would would MD 42759 1454 22 take take VB 42759 1454 23 all all DT 42759 1454 24 of of IN 42759 1454 25 one one CD 42759 1454 26 species specie NNS 42759 1454 27 of of IN 42759 1454 28 revenue revenue NN 42759 1454 29 , , , 42759 1454 30 while while IN 42759 1454 31 all all DT 42759 1454 32 other other JJ 42759 1454 33 incomes income NNS 42759 1454 34 and and CC 42759 1454 35 properties property NNS 42759 1454 36 pay pay VBP 42759 1454 37 only only RB 42759 1454 38 a a DT 42759 1454 39 certain certain JJ 42759 1454 40 percentage percentage NN 42759 1454 41 . . . 42759 1455 1 All all PDT 42759 1455 2 the the DT 42759 1455 3 adherents adherent NNS 42759 1455 4 of of IN 42759 1455 5 the the DT 42759 1455 6 faculty faculty NN 42759 1455 7 theory theory NN 42759 1455 8 maintain maintain VB 42759 1455 9 , , , 42759 1455 10 however however RB 42759 1455 11 , , , 42759 1455 12 that that IN 42759 1455 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1455 14 is be VBZ 42759 1455 15 subject subject JJ 42759 1455 16 to to IN 42759 1455 17 certain certain JJ 42759 1455 18 modifications modification NNS 42759 1455 19 . . . 42759 1456 1 Incomes income NNS 42759 1456 2 from from IN 42759 1456 3 interest interest NN 42759 1456 4 , , , 42759 1456 5 rent rent NN 42759 1456 6 , , , 42759 1456 7 and and CC 42759 1456 8 socially socially RB 42759 1456 9 occasioned occasion VBN 42759 1456 10 increases increase NNS 42759 1456 11 in in IN 42759 1456 12 the the DT 42759 1456 13 value value NN 42759 1456 14 of of IN 42759 1456 15 property property NN 42759 1456 16 should should MD 42759 1456 17 be be VB 42759 1456 18 taxed tax VBN 42759 1456 19 at at IN 42759 1456 20 a a DT 42759 1456 21 higher high JJR 42759 1456 22 rate rate NN 42759 1456 23 than than IN 42759 1456 24 incomes income NNS 42759 1456 25 that that WDT 42759 1456 26 represent represent VBP 42759 1456 27 expenditures expenditure NNS 42759 1456 28 of of IN 42759 1456 29 labour labour NN 42759 1456 30 ; ; : 42759 1456 31 for for IN 42759 1456 32 to to TO 42759 1456 33 give give VB 42759 1456 34 up up RP 42759 1456 35 a a DT 42759 1456 36 certain certain JJ 42759 1456 37 per per IN 42759 1456 38 cent cent NN 42759 1456 39 . . . 42759 1457 1 of of IN 42759 1457 2 the the DT 42759 1457 3 former former JJ 42759 1457 4 involves involve NNS 42759 1457 5 less less JJR 42759 1457 6 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 1457 7 than than IN 42759 1457 8 to to TO 42759 1457 9 give give VB 42759 1457 10 up up RP 42759 1457 11 the the DT 42759 1457 12 same same JJ 42759 1457 13 per per NN 42759 1457 14 cent cent NN 42759 1457 15 . . . 42759 1458 1 of of IN 42759 1458 2 the the DT 42759 1458 3 latter latter JJ 42759 1458 4 . . . 42759 1459 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 1459 2 , , , 42759 1459 3 increments increment NNS 42759 1459 4 of of IN 42759 1459 5 land land NN 42759 1459 6 - - HYPH 42759 1459 7 value value NN 42759 1459 8 may may MD 42759 1459 9 be be VB 42759 1459 10 fairly fairly RB 42759 1459 11 taxed tax VBN 42759 1459 12 at at IN 42759 1459 13 a a DT 42759 1459 14 higher high JJR 42759 1459 15 rate rate NN 42759 1459 16 than than IN 42759 1459 17 salaries salary NNS 42759 1459 18 , , , 42759 1459 19 personal personal JJ 42759 1459 20 property property NN 42759 1459 21 , , , 42759 1459 22 or or CC 42759 1459 23 even even RB 42759 1459 24 rent rent NN 42759 1459 25 and and CC 42759 1459 26 interest interest NN 42759 1459 27 . . . 42759 1460 1 When when WRB 42759 1460 2 , , , 42759 1460 3 however however RB 42759 1460 4 , , , 42759 1460 5 the the DT 42759 1460 6 law law NN 42759 1460 7 absorbs absorb VBZ 42759 1460 8 the the DT 42759 1460 9 whole whole NN 42759 1460 10 of of IN 42759 1460 11 the the DT 42759 1460 12 value value NN 42759 1460 13 increments increment NNS 42759 1460 14 , , , 42759 1460 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1460 16 seems seem VBZ 42759 1460 17 to to TO 42759 1460 18 be be VB 42759 1460 19 something something NN 42759 1460 20 more more JJR 42759 1460 21 than than IN 42759 1460 22 a a DT 42759 1460 23 tax tax NN 42759 1460 24 . . . 42759 1461 1 The the DT 42759 1461 2 essential essential JJ 42759 1461 3 nature nature NN 42759 1461 4 of of IN 42759 1461 5 a a DT 42759 1461 6 tax tax NN 42759 1461 7 is be VBZ 42759 1461 8 to to TO 42759 1461 9 take take VB 42759 1461 10 only only RB 42759 1461 11 a a DT 42759 1461 12 portion portion NN 42759 1461 13 of of IN 42759 1461 14 the the DT 42759 1461 15 particular particular JJ 42759 1461 16 class class NN 42759 1461 17 of of IN 42759 1461 18 income income NN 42759 1461 19 or or CC 42759 1461 20 property property NN 42759 1461 21 upon upon IN 42759 1461 22 which which WDT 42759 1461 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1461 24 is be VBZ 42759 1461 25 imposed impose VBN 42759 1461 26 . . . 42759 1462 1 The the DT 42759 1462 2 nearest near JJS 42759 1462 3 approach approach NN 42759 1462 4 to to IN 42759 1462 5 the the DT 42759 1462 6 plan plan NN 42759 1462 7 of of IN 42759 1462 8 taking take VBG 42759 1462 9 all all DT 42759 1462 10 future future JJ 42759 1462 11 increases increase NNS 42759 1462 12 in in IN 42759 1462 13 land land NN 42759 1462 14 value value NN 42759 1462 15 is be VBZ 42759 1462 16 to to TO 42759 1462 17 be be VB 42759 1462 18 found find VBN 42759 1462 19 in in IN 42759 1462 20 the the DT 42759 1462 21 special special JJ 42759 1462 22 assessments assessment NNS 42759 1462 23 that that WDT 42759 1462 24 are be VBP 42759 1462 25 levied levy VBN 42759 1462 26 in in IN 42759 1462 27 many many JJ 42759 1462 28 American american JJ 42759 1462 29 cities city NNS 42759 1462 30 . . . 42759 1463 1 Thus thus RB 42759 1463 2 , , , 42759 1463 3 the the DT 42759 1463 4 owners owner NNS 42759 1463 5 of of IN 42759 1463 6 urban urban JJ 42759 1463 7 lots lot NNS 42759 1463 8 are be VBP 42759 1463 9 frequently frequently RB 42759 1463 10 compelled compel VBN 42759 1463 11 to to TO 42759 1463 12 defray defray VB 42759 1463 13 the the DT 42759 1463 14 entire entire JJ 42759 1463 15 cost cost NN 42759 1463 16 of of IN 42759 1463 17 street street NN 42759 1463 18 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1463 19 on on IN 42759 1463 20 the the DT 42759 1463 21 theory theory NN 42759 1463 22 that that IN 42759 1463 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1463 24 land land NN 42759 1463 25 is be VBZ 42759 1463 26 thereby thereby RB 42759 1463 27 and and CC 42759 1463 28 to to IN 42759 1463 29 that that DT 42759 1463 30 extent extent NN 42759 1463 31 increased increase VBD 42759 1463 32 in in IN 42759 1463 33 value value NN 42759 1463 34 . . . 42759 1464 1 In in IN 42759 1464 2 such such JJ 42759 1464 3 cases case NNS 42759 1464 4 the the DT 42759 1464 5 contribution contribution NN 42759 1464 6 is be VBZ 42759 1464 7 levied levy VBN 42759 1464 8 not not RB 42759 1464 9 on on IN 42759 1464 10 the the DT 42759 1464 11 basis basis NN 42759 1464 12 of of IN 42759 1464 13 the the DT 42759 1464 14 faculty faculty NN 42759 1464 15 theory theory NN 42759 1464 16 , , , 42759 1464 17 but but CC 42759 1464 18 on on IN 42759 1464 19 that that DT 42759 1464 20 of of IN 42759 1464 21 the the DT 42759 1464 22 benefit benefit NN 42759 1464 23 theory theory NN 42759 1464 24 ; ; : 42759 1464 25 that that DT 42759 1464 26 is is RB 42759 1464 27 , , , 42759 1464 28 the the DT 42759 1464 29 owners owner NNS 42759 1464 30 are be VBP 42759 1464 31 required require VBN 42759 1464 32 to to TO 42759 1464 33 pay pay VB 42759 1464 34 in in IN 42759 1464 35 proportion proportion NN 42759 1464 36 to to IN 42759 1464 37 benefits benefit NNS 42759 1464 38 received receive VBN 42759 1464 39 . . . 42759 1465 1 All all DT 42759 1465 2 adherents adherent NNS 42759 1465 3 of of IN 42759 1465 4 the the DT 42759 1465 5 faculty faculty NN 42759 1465 6 theory theory NN 42759 1465 7 admit admit VBP 42759 1465 8 that that IN 42759 1465 9 the the DT 42759 1465 10 benefit benefit NN 42759 1465 11 theory theory NN 42759 1465 12 is be VBZ 42759 1465 13 justifiably justifiably RB 42759 1465 14 applied apply VBN 42759 1465 15 in in IN 42759 1465 16 situations situation NNS 42759 1465 17 of of IN 42759 1465 18 this this DT 42759 1465 19 kind kind NN 42759 1465 20 . . . 42759 1466 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1466 2 might may MD 42759 1466 3 be be VB 42759 1466 4 argued argue VBN 42759 1466 5 that that IN 42759 1466 6 the the DT 42759 1466 7 latter latter JJ 42759 1466 8 theory theory NN 42759 1466 9 can can MD 42759 1466 10 also also RB 42759 1466 11 be be VB 42759 1466 12 fairly fairly RB 42759 1466 13 applied apply VBN 42759 1466 14 to to IN 42759 1466 15 increments increment NNS 42759 1466 16 of of IN 42759 1466 17 land land NN 42759 1466 18 value value NN 42759 1466 19 that that WDT 42759 1466 20 are be VBP 42759 1466 21 to to TO 42759 1466 22 arise arise VB 42759 1466 23 in in IN 42759 1466 24 the the DT 42759 1466 25 future future NN 42759 1466 26 . . . 42759 1467 1 In in IN 42759 1467 2 both both DT 42759 1467 3 cases case NNS 42759 1467 4 the the DT 42759 1467 5 owner owner NN 42759 1467 6 returns return VBZ 42759 1467 7 to to IN 42759 1467 8 the the DT 42759 1467 9 State state NN 42759 1467 10 the the DT 42759 1467 11 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 1467 12 of of IN 42759 1467 13 benefits benefit NNS 42759 1467 14 which which WDT 42759 1467 15 have have VBP 42759 1467 16 cost cost VBN 42759 1467 17 him -PRON- PRP 42759 1467 18 nothing nothing NN 42759 1467 19 . . . 42759 1468 1 There there EX 42759 1468 2 is be VBZ 42759 1468 3 , , , 42759 1468 4 however however RB 42759 1468 5 , , , 42759 1468 6 a a DT 42759 1468 7 difference difference NN 42759 1468 8 . . . 42759 1469 1 In in IN 42759 1469 2 the the DT 42759 1469 3 former former JJ 42759 1469 4 case case NN 42759 1469 5 the the DT 42759 1469 6 value value NN 42759 1469 7 increases increase NNS 42759 1469 8 are be VBP 42759 1469 9 specifically specifically RB 42759 1469 10 due due JJ 42759 1469 11 to to IN 42759 1469 12 expenditures expenditure NNS 42759 1469 13 made make VBN 42759 1469 14 by by IN 42759 1469 15 the the DT 42759 1469 16 State State NNP 42759 1469 17 , , , 42759 1469 18 while while IN 42759 1469 19 in in IN 42759 1469 20 the the DT 42759 1469 21 latter latter JJ 42759 1469 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1469 23 are be VBP 42759 1469 24 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 1469 25 brought bring VBN 42759 1469 26 about about RP 42759 1469 27 by by IN 42759 1469 28 the the DT 42759 1469 29 general general JJ 42759 1469 30 activities activity NNS 42759 1469 31 of of IN 42759 1469 32 the the DT 42759 1469 33 community community NN 42759 1469 34 . . . 42759 1470 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 1470 2 do do VBP 42759 1470 3 not not RB 42759 1470 4 admit admit VB 42759 1470 5 with with IN 42759 1470 6 the the DT 42759 1470 7 Single Single NNP 42759 1470 8 Taxers Taxers NNPS 42759 1470 9 that that IN 42759 1470 10 this this DT 42759 1470 11 " " `` 42759 1470 12 social social JJ 42759 1470 13 production production NN 42759 1470 14 " " '' 42759 1470 15 of of IN 42759 1470 16 value value NN 42759 1470 17 increments increment NNS 42759 1470 18 creates create VBZ 42759 1470 19 a a DT 42759 1470 20 right right JJ 42759 1470 21 thereto thereto NN 42759 1470 22 on on IN 42759 1470 23 the the DT 42759 1470 24 part part NN 42759 1470 25 of of IN 42759 1470 26 either either CC 42759 1470 27 the the DT 42759 1470 28 community community NN 42759 1470 29 or or CC 42759 1470 30 the the DT 42759 1470 31 civil civil JJ 42759 1470 32 body body NN 42759 1470 33 ; ; : 42759 1470 34 but but CC 42759 1470 35 even even RB 42759 1470 36 if if IN 42759 1470 37 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1470 38 did do VBD 42759 1470 39 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1470 40 should should MD 42759 1470 41 be be VB 42759 1470 42 compelled compel VBN 42759 1470 43 to to TO 42759 1470 44 admit admit VB 42759 1470 45 that that IN 42759 1470 46 the the DT 42759 1470 47 two two CD 42759 1470 48 situations situation NNS 42759 1470 49 are be VBP 42759 1470 50 not not RB 42759 1470 51 exactly exactly RB 42759 1470 52 parallel parallel JJ 42759 1470 53 ; ; : 42759 1470 54 for for IN 42759 1470 55 the the DT 42759 1470 56 social social JJ 42759 1470 57 production production NN 42759 1470 58 of of IN 42759 1470 59 increases increase NNS 42759 1470 60 in in IN 42759 1470 61 the the DT 42759 1470 62 value value NN 42759 1470 63 of of IN 42759 1470 64 land land NN 42759 1470 65 involves involve VBZ 42759 1470 66 no no DT 42759 1470 67 special special JJ 42759 1470 68 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 1470 69 of of IN 42759 1470 70 labour labour NN 42759 1470 71 or or CC 42759 1470 72 money money NN 42759 1470 73 . . . 42759 1471 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1471 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1471 3 is be VBZ 42759 1471 4 very very RB 42759 1471 5 questionable questionable JJ 42759 1471 6 whether whether IN 42759 1471 7 the the DT 42759 1471 8 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 1471 9 of of IN 42759 1471 10 the the DT 42759 1471 11 whole whole NN 42759 1471 12 of of IN 42759 1471 13 the the DT 42759 1471 14 future future JJ 42759 1471 15 value value NN 42759 1471 16 increments increment NNS 42759 1471 17 can can MD 42759 1471 18 be be VB 42759 1471 19 harmonised harmonise VBN 42759 1471 20 with with IN 42759 1471 21 the the DT 42759 1471 22 received receive VBN 42759 1471 23 conceptions conception NNS 42759 1471 24 and and CC 42759 1471 25 applications application NNS 42759 1471 26 of of IN 42759 1471 27 the the DT 42759 1471 28 canons canon NNS 42759 1471 29 of of IN 42759 1471 30 taxation taxation NN 42759 1471 31 . . . 42759 1472 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1472 2 The the DT 42759 1472 3 Morality Morality NNP 42759 1472 4 of of IN 42759 1472 5 the the DT 42759 1472 6 Proposal Proposal NNP 42759 1472 7 _ _ NNP 42759 1472 8 However however RB 42759 1472 9 , , , 42759 1472 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1472 11 is be VBZ 42759 1472 12 neither neither CC 42759 1472 13 necessary necessary JJ 42759 1472 14 nor nor CC 42759 1472 15 desirable desirable JJ 42759 1472 16 to to TO 42759 1472 17 justify justify VB 42759 1472 18 the the DT 42759 1472 19 proposal proposal NN 42759 1472 20 on on IN 42759 1472 21 the the DT 42759 1472 22 mere mere JJ 42759 1472 23 ground ground NN 42759 1472 24 of of IN 42759 1472 25 taxation taxation NN 42759 1472 26 . . . 42759 1473 1 Only only RB 42759 1473 2 in in IN 42759 1473 3 form form NN 42759 1473 4 and and CC 42759 1473 5 administration administration NN 42759 1473 6 is be VBZ 42759 1473 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1473 8 a a DT 42759 1473 9 tax tax NN 42759 1473 10 ; ; : 42759 1473 11 primarily primarily RB 42759 1473 12 and and CC 42759 1473 13 in in IN 42759 1473 14 essence essence NN 42759 1473 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1473 16 is be VBZ 42759 1473 17 a a DT 42759 1473 18 method method NN 42759 1473 19 of of IN 42759 1473 20 distribution distribution NN 42759 1473 21 . . . 42759 1474 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1474 2 resembles resemble VBZ 42759 1474 3 the the DT 42759 1474 4 action action NN 42759 1474 5 by by IN 42759 1474 6 which which WDT 42759 1474 7 the the DT 42759 1474 8 State state NN 42759 1474 9 takes take VBZ 42759 1474 10 possession possession NN 42759 1474 11 of of IN 42759 1474 12 a a DT 42759 1474 13 newly newly RB 42759 1474 14 discovered discover VBN 42759 1474 15 territory territory NN 42759 1474 16 by by IN 42759 1474 17 the the DT 42759 1474 18 title title NN 42759 1474 19 of of IN 42759 1474 20 first first JJ 42759 1474 21 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 1474 22 . . . 42759 1475 1 The the DT 42759 1475 2 future future JJ 42759 1475 3 increases increase NNS 42759 1475 4 of of IN 42759 1475 5 land land NN 42759 1475 6 value value NN 42759 1475 7 may may MD 42759 1475 8 be be VB 42759 1475 9 regarded regard VBN 42759 1475 10 as as IN 42759 1475 11 a a DT 42759 1475 12 sort sort NN 42759 1475 13 of of IN 42759 1475 14 no no DT 42759 1475 15 man man NN 42759 1475 16 's 's POS 42759 1475 17 property property NN 42759 1475 18 which which WDT 42759 1475 19 the the DT 42759 1475 20 State state NN 42759 1475 21 appropriates appropriate VBZ 42759 1475 22 for for IN 42759 1475 23 the the DT 42759 1475 24 benefit benefit NN 42759 1475 25 of of IN 42759 1475 26 the the DT 42759 1475 27 community community NN 42759 1475 28 . . . 42759 1476 1 And and CC 42759 1476 2 the the DT 42759 1476 3 morality morality NN 42759 1476 4 of of IN 42759 1476 5 this this DT 42759 1476 6 proceeding proceeding NN 42759 1476 7 must must MD 42759 1476 8 be be VB 42759 1476 9 determined determine VBN 42759 1476 10 by by IN 42759 1476 11 the the DT 42759 1476 12 same same JJ 42759 1476 13 criterion criterion NN 42759 1476 14 that that WDT 42759 1476 15 is be VBZ 42759 1476 16 applied apply VBN 42759 1476 17 to to IN 42759 1476 18 every every DT 42759 1476 19 other other JJ 42759 1476 20 method method NN 42759 1476 21 or or CC 42759 1476 22 rule rule NN 42759 1476 23 of of IN 42759 1476 24 distribution distribution NN 42759 1476 25 ; ; : 42759 1476 26 namely namely RB 42759 1476 27 , , , 42759 1476 28 social social JJ 42759 1476 29 and and CC 42759 1476 30 individual individual JJ 42759 1476 31 consequences consequence NNS 42759 1476 32 . . . 42759 1477 1 No no DT 42759 1477 2 principle principle NN 42759 1477 3 , , , 42759 1477 4 title title NN 42759 1477 5 , , , 42759 1477 6 or or CC 42759 1477 7 practice practice NN 42759 1477 8 of of IN 42759 1477 9 ownership ownership NN 42759 1477 10 , , , 42759 1477 11 nor nor CC 42759 1477 12 any any DT 42759 1477 13 canon canon NN 42759 1477 14 of of IN 42759 1477 15 taxation taxation NN 42759 1477 16 , , , 42759 1477 17 has have VBZ 42759 1477 18 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 1477 19 or or CC 42759 1477 20 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 42759 1477 21 value value NN 42759 1477 22 . . . 42759 1478 1 All all DT 42759 1478 2 are be VBP 42759 1478 3 to to TO 42759 1478 4 be be VB 42759 1478 5 evaluated evaluate VBN 42759 1478 6 with with IN 42759 1478 7 reference reference NN 42759 1478 8 to to IN 42759 1478 9 human human JJ 42759 1478 10 welfare welfare NN 42759 1478 11 . . . 42759 1479 1 Since since IN 42759 1479 2 the the DT 42759 1479 3 right right NN 42759 1479 4 of of IN 42759 1479 5 property property NN 42759 1479 6 is be VBZ 42759 1479 7 not not RB 42759 1479 8 an an DT 42759 1479 9 end end NN 42759 1479 10 in in IN 42759 1479 11 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 1479 12 , , , 42759 1479 13 but but CC 42759 1479 14 only only RB 42759 1479 15 a a DT 42759 1479 16 means means NN 42759 1479 17 of of IN 42759 1479 18 human human JJ 42759 1479 19 welfare welfare NN 42759 1479 20 , , , 42759 1479 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1479 22 just just JJ 42759 1479 23 prerogatives prerogative NNS 42759 1479 24 and and CC 42759 1479 25 limitations limitation NNS 42759 1479 26 are be VBP 42759 1479 27 determined determine VBN 42759 1479 28 by by IN 42759 1479 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1479 30 conduciveness conduciveness NN 42759 1479 31 to to IN 42759 1479 32 the the DT 42759 1479 33 welfare welfare NN 42759 1479 34 of of IN 42759 1479 35 human human JJ 42759 1479 36 beings being NNS 42759 1479 37 . . . 42759 1480 1 By by IN 42759 1480 2 human human JJ 42759 1480 3 welfare welfare NN 42759 1480 4 is be VBZ 42759 1480 5 meant mean VBN 42759 1480 6 not not RB 42759 1480 7 merely merely RB 42759 1480 8 the the DT 42759 1480 9 good good NN 42759 1480 10 of of IN 42759 1480 11 society society NN 42759 1480 12 as as IN 42759 1480 13 a a DT 42759 1480 14 whole whole NN 42759 1480 15 , , , 42759 1480 16 but but CC 42759 1480 17 the the DT 42759 1480 18 good good NN 42759 1480 19 of of IN 42759 1480 20 all all DT 42759 1480 21 individuals individual NNS 42759 1480 22 and and CC 42759 1480 23 classes class NNS 42759 1480 24 of of IN 42759 1480 25 individuals individual NNS 42759 1480 26 . . . 42759 1481 1 For for IN 42759 1481 2 society society NN 42759 1481 3 is be VBZ 42759 1481 4 made make VBN 42759 1481 5 up up RP 42759 1481 6 of of IN 42759 1481 7 individuals individual NNS 42759 1481 8 , , , 42759 1481 9 all all DT 42759 1481 10 of of IN 42759 1481 11 whom whom WP 42759 1481 12 are be VBP 42759 1481 13 of of IN 42759 1481 14 equal equal JJ 42759 1481 15 worth worth NN 42759 1481 16 and and CC 42759 1481 17 importance importance NN 42759 1481 18 , , , 42759 1481 19 and and CC 42759 1481 20 have have VBP 42759 1481 21 equal equal JJ 42759 1481 22 claims claim NNS 42759 1481 23 to to IN 42759 1481 24 consideration consideration NN 42759 1481 25 in in IN 42759 1481 26 the the DT 42759 1481 27 matter matter NN 42759 1481 28 of of IN 42759 1481 29 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 1481 30 , , , 42759 1481 31 material material NN 42759 1481 32 goods good NNS 42759 1481 33 , , , 42759 1481 34 and and CC 42759 1481 35 property property NN 42759 1481 36 . . . 42759 1482 1 In in IN 42759 1482 2 general general JJ 42759 1482 3 , , , 42759 1482 4 then then RB 42759 1482 5 , , , 42759 1482 6 any any DT 42759 1482 7 method method NN 42759 1482 8 of of IN 42759 1482 9 distribution distribution NN 42759 1482 10 , , , 42759 1482 11 any any DT 42759 1482 12 modification modification NN 42759 1482 13 of of IN 42759 1482 14 property property NN 42759 1482 15 rights right NNS 42759 1482 16 , , , 42759 1482 17 any any DT 42759 1482 18 form form NN 42759 1482 19 of of IN 42759 1482 20 taxation taxation NN 42759 1482 21 , , , 42759 1482 22 is be VBZ 42759 1482 23 morally morally RB 42759 1482 24 lawful lawful JJ 42759 1482 25 which which WDT 42759 1482 26 promotes promote VBZ 42759 1482 27 the the DT 42759 1482 28 interests interest NNS 42759 1482 29 of of IN 42759 1482 30 the the DT 42759 1482 31 whole whole JJ 42759 1482 32 community community NN 42759 1482 33 , , , 42759 1482 34 without without IN 42759 1482 35 causing cause VBG 42759 1482 36 undue undue JJ 42759 1482 37 inconvenience inconvenience NN 42759 1482 38 to to IN 42759 1482 39 any any DT 42759 1482 40 individual individual NN 42759 1482 41 . . . 42759 1483 1 Whether whether IN 42759 1483 2 a a DT 42759 1483 3 given give VBN 42759 1483 4 rule rule NN 42759 1483 5 of of IN 42759 1483 6 ownership ownership NN 42759 1483 7 or or CC 42759 1483 8 method method NN 42759 1483 9 of of IN 42759 1483 10 distribution distribution NN 42759 1483 11 which which WDT 42759 1483 12 is be VBZ 42759 1483 13 evidently evidently RB 42759 1483 14 conducive conducive JJ 42759 1483 15 to to IN 42759 1483 16 the the DT 42759 1483 17 public public JJ 42759 1483 18 good good NN 42759 1483 19 is be VBZ 42759 1483 20 , , , 42759 1483 21 nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 1483 22 , , , 42759 1483 23 unduly unduly RB 42759 1483 24 severe severe JJ 42759 1483 25 on on IN 42759 1483 26 a a DT 42759 1483 27 certain certain JJ 42759 1483 28 class class NN 42759 1483 29 of of IN 42759 1483 30 individuals individual NNS 42759 1483 31 , , , 42759 1483 32 is be VBZ 42759 1483 33 a a DT 42759 1483 34 question question NN 42759 1483 35 that that WDT 42759 1483 36 is be VBZ 42759 1483 37 not not RB 42759 1483 38 always always RB 42759 1483 39 easily easily RB 42759 1483 40 answered answer VBN 42759 1483 41 . . . 42759 1484 1 Some some DT 42759 1484 2 of of IN 42759 1484 3 the the DT 42759 1484 4 methods method NNS 42759 1484 5 and and CC 42759 1484 6 practices practice NNS 42759 1484 7 appearing appear VBG 42759 1484 8 in in IN 42759 1484 9 history history NN 42759 1484 10 were be VBD 42759 1484 11 clearly clearly RB 42759 1484 12 fair fair JJ 42759 1484 13 and and CC 42759 1484 14 just just JJ 42759 1484 15 , , , 42759 1484 16 others other NNS 42759 1484 17 clearly clearly RB 42759 1484 18 unfair unfair JJ 42759 1484 19 and and CC 42759 1484 20 unjust unjust JJ 42759 1484 21 , , , 42759 1484 22 and and CC 42759 1484 23 still still RB 42759 1484 24 others other NNS 42759 1484 25 of of IN 42759 1484 26 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 1484 27 morality morality NN 42759 1484 28 . . . 42759 1485 1 Frequently frequently RB 42759 1485 2 the the DT 42759 1485 3 State state NN 42759 1485 4 has have VBZ 42759 1485 5 compelled compel VBN 42759 1485 6 private private JJ 42759 1485 7 persons person NNS 42759 1485 8 to to TO 42759 1485 9 give give VB 42759 1485 10 up up RP 42759 1485 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1485 12 land land NN 42759 1485 13 at at IN 42759 1485 14 a a DT 42759 1485 15 lower low JJR 42759 1485 16 price price NN 42759 1485 17 than than IN 42759 1485 18 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1485 19 paid pay VBD 42759 1485 20 for for IN 42759 1485 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1485 22 ; ; : 42759 1485 23 in in IN 42759 1485 24 more more JJR 42759 1485 25 than than IN 42759 1485 26 one one CD 42759 1485 27 country country NN 42759 1485 28 freebooters freebooter NNS 42759 1485 29 and and CC 42759 1485 30 kingly kingly NNP 42759 1485 31 favourites favourite VBZ 42759 1485 32 robbed rob VBD 42759 1485 33 the the DT 42759 1485 34 people people NNS 42759 1485 35 of of IN 42759 1485 36 the the DT 42759 1485 37 land land NN 42759 1485 38 , , , 42759 1485 39 yet yet CC 42759 1485 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1485 41 heirs heir NNS 42759 1485 42 and and CC 42759 1485 43 successors successor NNS 42759 1485 44 are be VBP 42759 1485 45 recognised recognise VBN 42759 1485 46 by by IN 42759 1485 47 both both DT 42759 1485 48 moralists moralist NNS 42759 1485 49 and and CC 42759 1485 50 statesmen statesman NNS 42759 1485 51 as as IN 42759 1485 52 the the DT 42759 1485 53 legitimate legitimate JJ 42759 1485 54 owners owner NNS 42759 1485 55 of of IN 42759 1485 56 that that DT 42759 1485 57 land land NN 42759 1485 58 ; ; : 42759 1485 59 in in IN 42759 1485 60 Ireland Ireland NNP 42759 1485 61 stubborn stubborn JJ 42759 1485 62 landlords landlord NNS 42759 1485 63 are be VBP 42759 1485 64 to to IN 42759 1485 65 - - HYPH 42759 1485 66 day day NN 42759 1485 67 compelled compel VBN 42759 1485 68 by by IN 42759 1485 69 the the DT 42759 1485 70 British british JJ 42759 1485 71 government government NN 42759 1485 72 to to TO 42759 1485 73 sell sell VB 42759 1485 74 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1485 75 holdings holding NNS 42759 1485 76 to to IN 42759 1485 77 the the DT 42759 1485 78 tenants tenant NNS 42759 1485 79 at at IN 42759 1485 80 an an DT 42759 1485 81 appraised appraised JJ 42759 1485 82 valuation valuation NN 42759 1485 83 ; ; : 42759 1485 84 in in IN 42759 1485 85 many many JJ 42759 1485 86 countries country NNS 42759 1485 87 men man NNS 42759 1485 88 may may MD 42759 1485 89 become become VB 42759 1485 90 owners owner NNS 42759 1485 91 of of IN 42759 1485 92 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1485 93 neighbours neighbour NNS 42759 1485 94 ' ' POS 42759 1485 95 lands land NNS 42759 1485 96 by by IN 42759 1485 97 the the DT 42759 1485 98 title title NN 42759 1485 99 of of IN 42759 1485 100 prescription prescription NN 42759 1485 101 , , , 42759 1485 102 without without IN 42759 1485 103 the the DT 42759 1485 104 payment payment NN 42759 1485 105 of of IN 42759 1485 106 a a DT 42759 1485 107 cent cent NN 42759 1485 108 of of IN 42759 1485 109 compensation compensation NN 42759 1485 110 . . . 42759 1486 1 All all PDT 42759 1486 2 these these DT 42759 1486 3 practices practice NNS 42759 1486 4 and and CC 42759 1486 5 titles title NNS 42759 1486 6 inflict inflict VBP 42759 1486 7 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1486 8 hardship hardship NN 42759 1486 9 upon upon IN 42759 1486 10 individuals individual NNS 42759 1486 11 , , , 42759 1486 12 but but CC 42759 1486 13 most most JJS 42759 1486 14 of of IN 42759 1486 15 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1486 16 are be VBP 42759 1486 17 held hold VBN 42759 1486 18 to to TO 42759 1486 19 be be VB 42759 1486 20 justified justify VBN 42759 1486 21 on on IN 42759 1486 22 grounds ground NNS 42759 1486 23 of of IN 42759 1486 24 social social JJ 42759 1486 25 welfare welfare NN 42759 1486 26 . . . 42759 1487 1 Now now RB 42759 1487 2 the the DT 42759 1487 3 public public JJ 42759 1487 4 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 1487 5 of of IN 42759 1487 6 all all DT 42759 1487 7 future future JJ 42759 1487 8 increments increment NNS 42759 1487 9 of of IN 42759 1487 10 land land NN 42759 1487 11 value value NN 42759 1487 12 would would MD 42759 1487 13 evidently evidently RB 42759 1487 14 be be VB 42759 1487 15 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 1487 16 to to IN 42759 1487 17 the the DT 42759 1487 18 community community NN 42759 1487 19 as as IN 42759 1487 20 a a DT 42759 1487 21 whole whole NN 42759 1487 22 . . . 42759 1488 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1488 2 would would MD 42759 1488 3 enable enable VB 42759 1488 4 all all PDT 42759 1488 5 the the DT 42759 1488 6 people people NNS 42759 1488 7 to to TO 42759 1488 8 profit profit VB 42759 1488 9 by by IN 42759 1488 10 gains gain NNS 42759 1488 11 that that WDT 42759 1488 12 now now RB 42759 1488 13 go go VBP 42759 1488 14 to to IN 42759 1488 15 a a DT 42759 1488 16 minority minority NN 42759 1488 17 , , , 42759 1488 18 and and CC 42759 1488 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1488 20 would would MD 42759 1488 21 enable enable VB 42759 1488 22 the the DT 42759 1488 23 landless landless JJ 42759 1488 24 majority majority NN 42759 1488 25 to to TO 42759 1488 26 acquire acquire VB 42759 1488 27 land land NN 42759 1488 28 more more RBR 42759 1488 29 easily easily RB 42759 1488 30 and and CC 42759 1488 31 more more RBR 42759 1488 32 cheaply cheaply RB 42759 1488 33 . . . 42759 1489 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 1489 2 have have VBP 42759 1489 3 in in IN 42759 1489 4 mind mind NN 42759 1489 5 , , , 42759 1489 6 of of IN 42759 1489 7 course course NN 42759 1489 8 , , , 42759 1489 9 only only RB 42759 1489 10 those those DT 42759 1489 11 value value NN 42759 1489 12 increases increase NNS 42759 1489 13 that that WDT 42759 1489 14 are be VBP 42759 1489 15 not not RB 42759 1489 16 due due JJ 42759 1489 17 to to IN 42759 1489 18 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1489 19 in in IN 42759 1489 20 or or CC 42759 1489 21 on on IN 42759 1489 22 the the DT 42759 1489 23 land land NN 42759 1489 24 , , , 42759 1489 25 and and CC 42759 1489 26 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1489 27 assume assume VBP 42759 1489 28 that that IN 42759 1489 29 these these DT 42759 1489 30 could could MD 42759 1489 31 be be VB 42759 1489 32 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 1489 33 in in IN 42759 1489 34 practice practice NN 42759 1489 35 from from IN 42759 1489 36 the the DT 42759 1489 37 increments increment NNS 42759 1489 38 of of IN 42759 1489 39 value value NN 42759 1489 40 that that WDT 42759 1489 41 represent represent VBP 42759 1489 42 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1489 43 . . . 42759 1490 1 Would Would MD 42759 1490 2 the the DT 42759 1490 3 measure measure NN 42759 1490 4 in in IN 42759 1490 5 question question NN 42759 1490 6 inflict inflict FW 42759 1490 7 undue undue JJ 42759 1490 8 hardship hardship NN 42759 1490 9 upon upon IN 42759 1490 10 individuals individual NNS 42759 1490 11 ? ? . 42759 1491 1 Here here RB 42759 1491 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1491 3 must must MD 42759 1491 4 make make VB 42759 1491 5 a a DT 42759 1491 6 distinction distinction NN 42759 1491 7 between between IN 42759 1491 8 those those DT 42759 1491 9 persons person NNS 42759 1491 10 who who WP 42759 1491 11 own own VBP 42759 1491 12 land land NN 42759 1491 13 at at IN 42759 1491 14 the the DT 42759 1491 15 time time NN 42759 1491 16 that that IN 42759 1491 17 , , , 42759 1491 18 and and CC 42759 1491 19 those those DT 42759 1491 20 who who WP 42759 1491 21 buy buy VBP 42759 1491 22 land land NN 42759 1491 23 after after RB 42759 1491 24 , , , 42759 1491 25 the the DT 42759 1491 26 law law NN 42759 1491 27 is be VBZ 42759 1491 28 enacted enact VBN 42759 1491 29 . . . 42759 1492 1 The the DT 42759 1492 2 only only JJ 42759 1492 3 inconvenience inconvenience NN 42759 1492 4 falling fall VBG 42759 1492 5 upon upon IN 42759 1492 6 the the DT 42759 1492 7 latter latter JJ 42759 1492 8 class class NN 42759 1492 9 would would MD 42759 1492 10 be be VB 42759 1492 11 deprivation deprivation NN 42759 1492 12 of of IN 42759 1492 13 the the DT 42759 1492 14 power power NN 42759 1492 15 to to TO 42759 1492 16 obtain obtain VB 42759 1492 17 future future JJ 42759 1492 18 increases increase NNS 42759 1492 19 in in IN 42759 1492 20 value value NN 42759 1492 21 . . . 42759 1493 1 The the DT 42759 1493 2 law law NN 42759 1493 3 would would MD 42759 1493 4 not not RB 42759 1493 5 cause cause VB 42759 1493 6 the the DT 42759 1493 7 value value NN 42759 1493 8 of of IN 42759 1493 9 the the DT 42759 1493 10 land land NN 42759 1493 11 to to TO 42759 1493 12 decline decline VB 42759 1493 13 below below IN 42759 1493 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1493 15 purchase purchase NN 42759 1493 16 price price NN 42759 1493 17 . . . 42759 1494 1 Other other JJ 42759 1494 2 forces force NNS 42759 1494 3 might may MD 42759 1494 4 , , , 42759 1494 5 indeed indeed RB 42759 1494 6 , , , 42759 1494 7 bring bring VB 42759 1494 8 about about RP 42759 1494 9 such such PDT 42759 1494 10 a a DT 42759 1494 11 result result NN 42759 1494 12 ; ; : 42759 1494 13 but but CC 42759 1494 14 , , , 42759 1494 15 as as IN 42759 1494 16 a a DT 42759 1494 17 rule rule NN 42759 1494 18 , , , 42759 1494 19 such such JJ 42759 1494 20 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 1494 21 would would MD 42759 1494 22 be be VB 42759 1494 23 relatively relatively RB 42759 1494 24 insignificant insignificant JJ 42759 1494 25 , , , 42759 1494 26 for for IN 42759 1494 27 the the DT 42759 1494 28 simple simple JJ 42759 1494 29 reason reason NN 42759 1494 30 that that IN 42759 1494 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1494 32 would would MD 42759 1494 33 already already RB 42759 1494 34 have have VB 42759 1494 35 been be VBN 42759 1494 36 " " `` 42759 1494 37 discounted discount VBN 42759 1494 38 " " '' 42759 1494 39 in in IN 42759 1494 40 the the DT 42759 1494 41 reduction reduction NN 42759 1494 42 of of IN 42759 1494 43 value value NN 42759 1494 44 which which WDT 42759 1494 45 followed follow VBD 42759 1494 46 the the DT 42759 1494 47 law law NN 42759 1494 48 at at IN 42759 1494 49 the the DT 42759 1494 50 outset outset NN 42759 1494 51 . . . 42759 1495 1 The the DT 42759 1495 2 very very JJ 42759 1495 3 knowledge knowledge NN 42759 1495 4 that that IN 42759 1495 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1495 6 could could MD 42759 1495 7 not not RB 42759 1495 8 hope hope VB 42759 1495 9 to to TO 42759 1495 10 profit profit VB 42759 1495 11 by by IN 42759 1495 12 future future JJ 42759 1495 13 increases increase NNS 42759 1495 14 in in IN 42759 1495 15 the the DT 42759 1495 16 value value NN 42759 1495 17 of of IN 42759 1495 18 the the DT 42759 1495 19 land land NN 42759 1495 20 would would MD 42759 1495 21 impel impel VB 42759 1495 22 purchasers purchaser NNS 42759 1495 23 to to TO 42759 1495 24 lower lower VB 42759 1495 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1495 26 price price NN 42759 1495 27 accordingly accordingly RB 42759 1495 28 . . . 42759 1496 1 While while IN 42759 1496 2 taking take VBG 42759 1496 3 away away RB 42759 1496 4 the the DT 42759 1496 5 possibility possibility NN 42759 1496 6 of of IN 42759 1496 7 gaining gaining NN 42759 1496 8 , , , 42759 1496 9 the the DT 42759 1496 10 law law NN 42759 1496 11 enables enable VBZ 42759 1496 12 the the DT 42759 1496 13 buyers buyer NNS 42759 1496 14 to to TO 42759 1496 15 take take VB 42759 1496 16 the the DT 42759 1496 17 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 1496 18 precautions precaution NNS 42759 1496 19 against against IN 42759 1496 20 losing losing NN 42759 1496 21 . . . 42759 1497 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 1497 2 , , , 42759 1497 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1497 4 does do VBZ 42759 1497 5 not not RB 42759 1497 6 , , , 42759 1497 7 as as IN 42759 1497 8 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 1497 9 objected object VBN 42759 1497 10 , , , 42759 1497 11 lessen lessen VB 42759 1497 12 the the DT 42759 1497 13 so so RB 42759 1497 14 called call VBN 42759 1497 15 " " `` 42759 1497 16 gambler gambler NNP 42759 1497 17 's 's POS 42759 1497 18 chances chance NNS 42759 1497 19 . . . 42759 1497 20 " " '' 42759 1498 1 On on IN 42759 1498 2 the the DT 42759 1498 3 other other JJ 42759 1498 4 hand hand NN 42759 1498 5 , , , 42759 1498 6 the the DT 42759 1498 7 tax tax NN 42759 1498 8 does do VBZ 42759 1498 9 not not RB 42759 1498 10 deprive deprive VB 42759 1498 11 the the DT 42759 1498 12 owners owner NNS 42759 1498 13 of of IN 42759 1498 14 any any DT 42759 1498 15 value value NN 42759 1498 16 that that WDT 42759 1498 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1498 18 may may MD 42759 1498 19 add add VB 42759 1498 20 to to IN 42759 1498 21 the the DT 42759 1498 22 land land NN 42759 1498 23 through through IN 42759 1498 24 the the DT 42759 1498 25 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 1498 26 of of IN 42759 1498 27 labour labour NN 42759 1498 28 or or CC 42759 1498 29 money money NN 42759 1498 30 , , , 42759 1498 31 nor nor CC 42759 1498 32 in in IN 42759 1498 33 any any DT 42759 1498 34 way way NN 42759 1498 35 discourage discourage NN 42759 1498 36 productive productive JJ 42759 1498 37 effort effort NN 42759 1498 38 . . . 42759 1499 1 Now now RB 42759 1499 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1499 3 is be VBZ 42759 1499 4 , , , 42759 1499 5 as as IN 42759 1499 6 a a DT 42759 1499 7 rule rule NN 42759 1499 8 , , , 42759 1499 9 better well JJR 42759 1499 10 for for IN 42759 1499 11 individuals individual NNS 42759 1499 12 as as RB 42759 1499 13 well well RB 42759 1499 14 as as IN 42759 1499 15 for for IN 42759 1499 16 society society NN 42759 1499 17 that that WDT 42759 1499 18 men man NNS 42759 1499 19 's 's POS 42759 1499 20 incomes income NNS 42759 1499 21 should should MD 42759 1499 22 represent represent VB 42759 1499 23 labour labour NN 42759 1499 24 , , , 42759 1499 25 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 1499 26 , , , 42759 1499 27 and and CC 42759 1499 28 saving save VBG 42759 1499 29 instead instead RB 42759 1499 30 of of IN 42759 1499 31 being be VBG 42759 1499 32 the the DT 42759 1499 33 result result NN 42759 1499 34 of of IN 42759 1499 35 " " `` 42759 1499 36 windfalls windfall NNS 42759 1499 37 , , , 42759 1499 38 " " '' 42759 1499 39 or or CC 42759 1499 40 other other JJ 42759 1499 41 fortuitous fortuitous JJ 42759 1499 42 and and CC 42759 1499 43 conjunctural conjunctural JJ 42759 1499 44 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 1499 45 . . . 42759 1500 1 And and CC 42759 1500 2 the the DT 42759 1500 3 power power NN 42759 1500 4 to to TO 42759 1500 5 take take VB 42759 1500 6 future future JJ 42759 1500 7 value value NN 42759 1500 8 increments increment NNS 42759 1500 9 is be VBZ 42759 1500 10 not not RB 42759 1500 11 an an DT 42759 1500 12 intrinsically intrinsically RB 42759 1500 13 essential essential JJ 42759 1500 14 element element NN 42759 1500 15 of of IN 42759 1500 16 private private JJ 42759 1500 17 property property NN 42759 1500 18 in in IN 42759 1500 19 land land NN 42759 1500 20 . . . 42759 1501 1 Like like IN 42759 1501 2 every every DT 42759 1501 3 other other JJ 42759 1501 4 condition condition NN 42759 1501 5 of of IN 42759 1501 6 ownership ownership NN 42759 1501 7 , , , 42759 1501 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1501 9 morality morality NN 42759 1501 10 is be VBZ 42759 1501 11 determined determine VBN 42759 1501 12 by by IN 42759 1501 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1501 14 effects effect NNS 42759 1501 15 upon upon IN 42759 1501 16 human human JJ 42759 1501 17 welfare welfare NN 42759 1501 18 . . . 42759 1502 1 But but CC 42759 1502 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1502 3 have have VBP 42759 1502 4 seen see VBN 42759 1502 5 in in IN 42759 1502 6 the the DT 42759 1502 7 last last JJ 42759 1502 8 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 1502 9 that that IN 42759 1502 10 human human JJ 42759 1502 11 welfare welfare NN 42759 1502 12 in in IN 42759 1502 13 the the DT 42759 1502 14 sense sense NN 42759 1502 15 of of IN 42759 1502 16 the the DT 42759 1502 17 social social JJ 42759 1502 18 good good NN 42759 1502 19 is be VBZ 42759 1502 20 better well RBR 42759 1502 21 promoted promote VBN 42759 1502 22 by by IN 42759 1502 23 a a DT 42759 1502 24 system system NN 42759 1502 25 of of IN 42759 1502 26 landownership landownership NN 42759 1502 27 which which WDT 42759 1502 28 does do VBZ 42759 1502 29 not not RB 42759 1502 30 include include VB 42759 1502 31 this this DT 42759 1502 32 element element NN 42759 1502 33 ; ; : 42759 1502 34 and and CC 42759 1502 35 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1502 36 have have VBP 42759 1502 37 just just RB 42759 1502 38 shown show VBN 42759 1502 39 that that IN 42759 1502 40 such such PDT 42759 1502 41 a a DT 42759 1502 42 system system NN 42759 1502 43 causes cause VBZ 42759 1502 44 no no DT 42759 1502 45 undue undue JJ 42759 1502 46 hardship hardship NN 42759 1502 47 to to IN 42759 1502 48 the the DT 42759 1502 49 individual individual NN 42759 1502 50 who who WP 42759 1502 51 buys buy VBZ 42759 1502 52 land land NN 42759 1502 53 after after IN 42759 1502 54 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1502 55 establishment establishment NN 42759 1502 56 . . . 42759 1503 1 Such such JJ 42759 1503 2 is be VBZ 42759 1503 3 the the DT 42759 1503 4 answer answer NN 42759 1503 5 to to IN 42759 1503 6 the the DT 42759 1503 7 contention contention NN 42759 1503 8 , , , 42759 1503 9 noticed notice VBD 42759 1503 10 a a DT 42759 1503 11 few few JJ 42759 1503 12 pages page NNS 42759 1503 13 back back RB 42759 1503 14 , , , 42759 1503 15 that that IN 42759 1503 16 the the DT 42759 1503 17 landowner landowner NN 42759 1503 18 has have VBZ 42759 1503 19 a a DT 42759 1503 20 right right NN 42759 1503 21 to to IN 42759 1503 22 future future JJ 42759 1503 23 increments increment NNS 42759 1503 24 of of IN 42759 1503 25 value value NN 42759 1503 26 because because IN 42759 1503 27 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1503 28 are be VBP 42759 1503 29 a a DT 42759 1503 30 kind kind NN 42759 1503 31 of of IN 42759 1503 32 fruit fruit NN 42759 1503 33 of of IN 42759 1503 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1503 35 property property NN 42759 1503 36 . . . 42759 1504 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1504 2 is be VBZ 42759 1504 3 more more RBR 42759 1504 4 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 1504 5 that that IN 42759 1504 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1504 7 should should MD 42759 1504 8 not not RB 42759 1504 9 enjoy enjoy VB 42759 1504 10 this this DT 42759 1504 11 particular particular JJ 42759 1504 12 and and CC 42759 1504 13 peculiar peculiar JJ 42759 1504 14 " " '' 42759 1504 15 fruit fruit NN 42759 1504 16 . . . 42759 1504 17 " " '' 42759 1505 1 Were be VBD 42759 1505 2 the the DT 42759 1505 3 increment increment JJ 42759 1505 4 tax tax NN 42759 1505 5 introduced introduce VBN 42759 1505 6 into into IN 42759 1505 7 a a DT 42759 1505 8 new new JJ 42759 1505 9 community community NN 42759 1505 10 before before IN 42759 1505 11 any any DT 42759 1505 12 one one NN 42759 1505 13 had have VBD 42759 1505 14 purchased purchase VBN 42759 1505 15 land land NN 42759 1505 16 , , , 42759 1505 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1505 18 would would MD 42759 1505 19 clearly clearly RB 42759 1505 20 be be VB 42759 1505 21 a a DT 42759 1505 22 fair fair JJ 42759 1505 23 and and CC 42759 1505 24 valid valid JJ 42759 1505 25 limitation limitation NN 42759 1505 26 on on IN 42759 1505 27 the the DT 42759 1505 28 right right NN 42759 1505 29 of of IN 42759 1505 30 ownership ownership NN 42759 1505 31 . . . 42759 1506 1 Those those DT 42759 1506 2 who who WP 42759 1506 3 should should MD 42759 1506 4 become become VB 42759 1506 5 owners owner NNS 42759 1506 6 after after IN 42759 1506 7 the the DT 42759 1506 8 regulation regulation NN 42759 1506 9 went go VBD 42759 1506 10 into into IN 42759 1506 11 effect effect NN 42759 1506 12 in in IN 42759 1506 13 an an DT 42759 1506 14 old old JJ 42759 1506 15 community community NN 42759 1506 16 would would MD 42759 1506 17 be be VB 42759 1506 18 in in IN 42759 1506 19 exactly exactly RB 42759 1506 20 the the DT 42759 1506 21 same same JJ 42759 1506 22 moral moral JJ 42759 1506 23 and and CC 42759 1506 24 economic economic JJ 42759 1506 25 position position NN 42759 1506 26 . . . 42759 1507 1 Finally finally RB 42759 1507 2 , , , 42759 1507 3 there there EX 42759 1507 4 exists exist VBZ 42759 1507 5 some some DT 42759 1507 6 kind kind NN 42759 1507 7 of of IN 42759 1507 8 legal legal JJ 42759 1507 9 precedent precedent NN 42759 1507 10 for for IN 42759 1507 11 the the DT 42759 1507 12 proposal proposal NN 42759 1507 13 in in IN 42759 1507 14 the the DT 42759 1507 15 present present JJ 42759 1507 16 policy policy NN 42759 1507 17 of of IN 42759 1507 18 efficient efficient JJ 42759 1507 19 governments government NNS 42759 1507 20 with with IN 42759 1507 21 regard regard NN 42759 1507 22 to to IN 42759 1507 23 the the DT 42759 1507 24 only only JJ 42759 1507 25 important important JJ 42759 1507 26 increases increase NNS 42759 1507 27 that that WDT 42759 1507 28 occur occur VBP 42759 1507 29 in in IN 42759 1507 30 the the DT 42759 1507 31 value value NN 42759 1507 32 of of IN 42759 1507 33 goods good NNS 42759 1507 34 other other JJ 42759 1507 35 than than IN 42759 1507 36 land land NN 42759 1507 37 ; ; : 42759 1507 38 namely namely RB 42759 1507 39 , , , 42759 1507 40 increases increase NNS 42759 1507 41 due due JJ 42759 1507 42 to to IN 42759 1507 43 the the DT 42759 1507 44 possession possession NN 42759 1507 45 of of IN 42759 1507 46 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1507 47 power power NN 42759 1507 48 . . . 42759 1508 1 By by IN 42759 1508 2 various various JJ 42759 1508 3 devices device NNS 42759 1508 4 these these DT 42759 1508 5 are be VBP 42759 1508 6 either either CC 42759 1508 7 prevented prevent VBN 42759 1508 8 or or CC 42759 1508 9 appropriated appropriate VBN 42759 1508 10 by by IN 42759 1508 11 the the DT 42759 1508 12 State State NNP 42759 1508 13 . . . 42759 1509 1 Those those DT 42759 1509 2 persons person NNS 42759 1509 3 who who WP 42759 1509 4 are be VBP 42759 1509 5 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1509 6 when when WRB 42759 1509 7 the the DT 42759 1509 8 increment increment JJ 42759 1509 9 tax tax NN 42759 1509 10 goes go VBZ 42759 1509 11 into into IN 42759 1509 12 effect effect NN 42759 1509 13 are be VBP 42759 1509 14 in in IN 42759 1509 15 a a DT 42759 1509 16 very very RB 42759 1509 17 different different JJ 42759 1509 18 situation situation NN 42759 1509 19 from from IN 42759 1509 20 those those DT 42759 1509 21 that that WDT 42759 1509 22 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1509 23 have have VBP 42759 1509 24 just just RB 42759 1509 25 been be VBN 42759 1509 26 considering consider VBG 42759 1509 27 . . . 42759 1510 1 Many many JJ 42759 1510 2 of of IN 42759 1510 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1510 4 would would MD 42759 1510 5 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 1510 6 suffer suffer VB 42759 1510 7 injury injury NN 42759 1510 8 through through IN 42759 1510 9 the the DT 42759 1510 10 operation operation NN 42759 1510 11 of of IN 42759 1510 12 the the DT 42759 1510 13 measure measure NN 42759 1510 14 , , , 42759 1510 15 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 1510 16 as as IN 42759 1510 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1510 18 land land NN 42759 1510 19 would would MD 42759 1510 20 reach reach VB 42759 1510 21 and and CC 42759 1510 22 maintain maintain VB 42759 1510 23 a a DT 42759 1510 24 level level NN 42759 1510 25 of of IN 42759 1510 26 value value NN 42759 1510 27 below below IN 42759 1510 28 the the DT 42759 1510 29 price price NN 42759 1510 30 that that WDT 42759 1510 31 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1510 32 had have VBD 42759 1510 33 paid pay VBN 42759 1510 34 for for IN 42759 1510 35 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1510 36 . . . 42759 1511 1 The the DT 42759 1511 2 immediate immediate JJ 42759 1511 3 effect effect NN 42759 1511 4 of of IN 42759 1511 5 the the DT 42759 1511 6 increment increment JJ 42759 1511 7 tax tax NN 42759 1511 8 would would MD 42759 1511 9 be be VB 42759 1511 10 a a DT 42759 1511 11 decline decline NN 42759 1511 12 in in IN 42759 1511 13 the the DT 42759 1511 14 value value NN 42759 1511 15 of of IN 42759 1511 16 all all DT 42759 1511 17 land land NN 42759 1511 18 , , , 42759 1511 19 caused cause VBN 42759 1511 20 by by IN 42759 1511 21 men man NNS 42759 1511 22 's 's POS 42759 1511 23 increased increased JJ 42759 1511 24 desire desire NN 42759 1511 25 to to TO 42759 1511 26 sell sell VB 42759 1511 27 and and CC 42759 1511 28 decreased decrease VBD 42759 1511 29 desire desire NN 42759 1511 30 to to TO 42759 1511 31 buy buy VB 42759 1511 32 . . . 42759 1512 1 In in IN 42759 1512 2 all all DT 42759 1512 3 growing grow VBG 42759 1512 4 communities community NNS 42759 1512 5 a a DT 42759 1512 6 part part NN 42759 1512 7 of of IN 42759 1512 8 the the DT 42759 1512 9 present present JJ 42759 1512 10 value value NN 42759 1512 11 of of IN 42759 1512 12 land land NN 42759 1512 13 is be VBZ 42759 1512 14 speculative speculative JJ 42759 1512 15 ; ; : 42759 1512 16 that that RB 42759 1512 17 is is RB 42759 1512 18 , , , 42759 1512 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1512 20 is be VBZ 42759 1512 21 due due JJ 42759 1512 22 to to IN 42759 1512 23 demand demand NN 42759 1512 24 for for IN 42759 1512 25 the the DT 42759 1512 26 land land NN 42759 1512 27 by by IN 42759 1512 28 persons person NNS 42759 1512 29 who who WP 42759 1512 30 want want VBP 42759 1512 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1512 32 mainly mainly RB 42759 1512 33 to to TO 42759 1512 34 sell sell VB 42759 1512 35 at at IN 42759 1512 36 an an DT 42759 1512 37 expected expect VBN 42759 1512 38 rise rise NN 42759 1512 39 , , , 42759 1512 40 and and CC 42759 1512 41 also also RB 42759 1512 42 to to IN 42759 1512 43 the the DT 42759 1512 44 disinclination disinclination NN 42759 1512 45 of of IN 42759 1512 46 present present JJ 42759 1512 47 owners owner NNS 42759 1512 48 to to TO 42759 1512 49 sell sell VB 42759 1512 50 until until IN 42759 1512 51 this this DT 42759 1512 52 expectation expectation NN 42759 1512 53 is be VBZ 42759 1512 54 realised realise VBN 42759 1512 55 . . . 42759 1513 1 The the DT 42759 1513 2 practical practical JJ 42759 1513 3 result result NN 42759 1513 4 of of IN 42759 1513 5 the the DT 42759 1513 6 attitude attitude NN 42759 1513 7 of of IN 42759 1513 8 these these DT 42759 1513 9 two two CD 42759 1513 10 classes class NNS 42759 1513 11 of of IN 42759 1513 12 persons person NNS 42759 1513 13 is be VBZ 42759 1513 14 that that IN 42759 1513 15 the the DT 42759 1513 16 demand demand NN 42759 1513 17 for for IN 42759 1513 18 , , , 42759 1513 19 and and CC 42759 1513 20 therefore therefore RB 42759 1513 21 the the DT 42759 1513 22 value value NN 42759 1513 23 of of IN 42759 1513 24 land land NN 42759 1513 25 is be VBZ 42759 1513 26 considerably considerably RB 42759 1513 27 enhanced enhance VBN 42759 1513 28 . . . 42759 1514 1 Let let VB 42759 1514 2 a a DT 42759 1514 3 law law NN 42759 1514 4 be be VB 42759 1514 5 enacted enact VBN 42759 1514 6 depriving deprive VBG 42759 1514 7 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1514 8 of of IN 42759 1514 9 all all DT 42759 1514 10 hope hope NN 42759 1514 11 of of IN 42759 1514 12 securing secure VBG 42759 1514 13 the the DT 42759 1514 14 anticipated anticipated JJ 42759 1514 15 increases increase NNS 42759 1514 16 in in IN 42759 1514 17 value value NN 42759 1514 18 , , , 42759 1514 19 and and CC 42759 1514 20 the the DT 42759 1514 21 one one CD 42759 1514 22 group group NN 42759 1514 23 will will MD 42759 1514 24 cease cease VB 42759 1514 25 to to TO 42759 1514 26 buy buy VB 42759 1514 27 , , , 42759 1514 28 while while IN 42759 1514 29 the the DT 42759 1514 30 other other JJ 42759 1514 31 will will MD 42759 1514 32 hasten hasten VB 42759 1514 33 to to TO 42759 1514 34 sell sell VB 42759 1514 35 , , , 42759 1514 36 thus thus RB 42759 1514 37 causing cause VBG 42759 1514 38 a a DT 42759 1514 39 decline decline NN 42759 1514 40 in in IN 42759 1514 41 demand demand NN 42759 1514 42 relatively relatively RB 42759 1514 43 to to TO 42759 1514 44 supply supply VB 42759 1514 45 , , , 42759 1514 46 and and CC 42759 1514 47 therefore therefore RB 42759 1514 48 a a DT 42759 1514 49 decline decline NN 42759 1514 50 in in IN 42759 1514 51 value value NN 42759 1514 52 and and CC 42759 1514 53 price price NN 42759 1514 54 . . . 42759 1515 1 All all DT 42759 1515 2 persons person NNS 42759 1515 3 who who WP 42759 1515 4 had have VBD 42759 1515 5 paid pay VBN 42759 1515 6 more more JJR 42759 1515 7 for for IN 42759 1515 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1515 9 land land NN 42759 1515 10 than than IN 42759 1515 11 the the DT 42759 1515 12 value value NN 42759 1515 13 which which WDT 42759 1515 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1515 15 came come VBD 42759 1515 16 to to TO 42759 1515 17 have have VB 42759 1515 18 as as IN 42759 1515 19 a a DT 42759 1515 20 result result NN 42759 1515 21 of of IN 42759 1515 22 the the DT 42759 1515 23 increment increment JJ 42759 1515 24 tax tax NN 42759 1515 25 law law NN 42759 1515 26 , , , 42759 1515 27 would would MD 42759 1515 28 lose lose VB 42759 1515 29 the the DT 42759 1515 30 difference difference NN 42759 1515 31 . . . 42759 1516 1 For for IN 42759 1516 2 , , , 42759 1516 3 no no RB 42759 1516 4 matter matter RB 42759 1516 5 how how WRB 42759 1516 6 much much RB 42759 1516 7 the the DT 42759 1516 8 land land NN 42759 1516 9 might may MD 42759 1516 10 rise rise VB 42759 1516 11 in in IN 42759 1516 12 value value NN 42759 1516 13 subsequently subsequently RB 42759 1516 14 , , , 42759 1516 15 the the DT 42759 1516 16 increase increase NN 42759 1516 17 would would MD 42759 1516 18 all all DT 42759 1516 19 be be VB 42759 1516 20 taken take VBN 42759 1516 21 by by IN 42759 1516 22 the the DT 42759 1516 23 State State NNP 42759 1516 24 . . . 42759 1517 1 And and CC 42759 1517 2 all all DT 42759 1517 3 owners owner NNS 42759 1517 4 of of IN 42759 1517 5 vacant vacant JJ 42759 1517 6 land land NN 42759 1517 7 the the DT 42759 1517 8 value value NN 42759 1517 9 of of IN 42759 1517 10 which which WDT 42759 1517 11 after after IN 42759 1517 12 the the DT 42759 1517 13 law law NN 42759 1517 14 was be VBD 42759 1517 15 passed pass VBN 42759 1517 16 did do VBD 42759 1517 17 not not RB 42759 1517 18 remain remain VB 42759 1517 19 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 1517 20 high high JJ 42759 1517 21 to to TO 42759 1517 22 provide provide VB 42759 1517 23 accumulated accumulate VBN 42759 1517 24 interest interest NN 42759 1517 25 on on IN 42759 1517 26 the the DT 42759 1517 27 purchase purchase NN 42759 1517 28 price price NN 42759 1517 29 , , , 42759 1517 30 would would MD 42759 1517 31 also also RB 42759 1517 32 lose lose VB 42759 1517 33 accordingly accordingly RB 42759 1517 34 . . . 42759 1518 1 To to TO 42759 1518 2 be be VB 42759 1518 3 sure sure JJ 42759 1518 4 , , , 42759 1518 5 both both PDT 42759 1518 6 these these DT 42759 1518 7 kinds kind NNS 42759 1518 8 of of IN 42759 1518 9 losses loss NNS 42759 1518 10 would would MD 42759 1518 11 exist exist VB 42759 1518 12 even even RB 42759 1518 13 if if IN 42759 1518 14 the the DT 42759 1518 15 law law NN 42759 1518 16 should should MD 42759 1518 17 cause cause VB 42759 1518 18 no no DT 42759 1518 19 decline decline NN 42759 1518 20 in in IN 42759 1518 21 the the DT 42759 1518 22 value value NN 42759 1518 23 of of IN 42759 1518 24 land land NN 42759 1518 25 , , , 42759 1518 26 but but CC 42759 1518 27 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1518 28 would would MD 42759 1518 29 not not RB 42759 1518 30 be be VB 42759 1518 31 so so RB 42759 1518 32 great great JJ 42759 1518 33 either either CC 42759 1518 34 in in IN 42759 1518 35 number number NN 42759 1518 36 or or CC 42759 1518 37 in in IN 42759 1518 38 volume volume NN 42759 1518 39 . . . 42759 1519 1 Landowners landowner NNS 42759 1519 2 who who WP 42759 1519 3 should should MD 42759 1519 4 suffer suffer VB 42759 1519 5 either either DT 42759 1519 6 of of IN 42759 1519 7 these these DT 42759 1519 8 sorts sort NNS 42759 1519 9 of of IN 42759 1519 10 losses loss NNS 42759 1519 11 would would MD 42759 1519 12 have have VB 42759 1519 13 a a DT 42759 1519 14 valid valid JJ 42759 1519 15 moral moral JJ 42759 1519 16 claim claim NN 42759 1519 17 against against IN 42759 1519 18 the the DT 42759 1519 19 State State NNP 42759 1519 20 for for IN 42759 1519 21 compensation compensation NN 42759 1519 22 . . . 42759 1520 1 Through through IN 42759 1520 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1520 3 silence silence NN 42759 1520 4 on on IN 42759 1520 5 the the DT 42759 1520 6 subject subject NN 42759 1520 7 of of IN 42759 1520 8 increment increment JJ 42759 1520 9 - - HYPH 42759 1520 10 tax tax NN 42759 1520 11 legislation legislation NN 42759 1520 12 , , , 42759 1520 13 the the DT 42759 1520 14 State State NNP 42759 1520 15 virtually virtually RB 42759 1520 16 promised promise VBD 42759 1520 17 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1520 18 at at IN 42759 1520 19 the the DT 42759 1520 20 time time NN 42759 1520 21 of of IN 42759 1520 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1520 23 purchases purchase NNS 42759 1520 24 that that IN 42759 1520 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1520 26 would would MD 42759 1520 27 not not RB 42759 1520 28 thus thus RB 42759 1520 29 interfere interfere VB 42759 1520 30 with with IN 42759 1520 31 the the DT 42759 1520 32 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 1520 33 course course NN 42759 1520 34 of of IN 42759 1520 35 values value NNS 42759 1520 36 . . . 42759 1521 1 Had have VBD 42759 1521 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1521 3 given give VBN 42759 1521 4 any any DT 42759 1521 5 intimation intimation NN 42759 1521 6 that that IN 42759 1521 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1521 8 would would MD 42759 1521 9 enact enact VB 42759 1521 10 such such PDT 42759 1521 11 a a DT 42759 1521 12 law law NN 42759 1521 13 at at IN 42759 1521 14 a a DT 42759 1521 15 future future JJ 42759 1521 16 time time NN 42759 1521 17 , , , 42759 1521 18 these these DT 42759 1521 19 persons person NNS 42759 1521 20 would would MD 42759 1521 21 not not RB 42759 1521 22 have have VB 42759 1521 23 paid pay VBN 42759 1521 24 as as RB 42759 1521 25 much much JJ 42759 1521 26 for for IN 42759 1521 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1521 28 land land NN 42759 1521 29 as as IN 42759 1521 30 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1521 31 actually actually RB 42759 1521 32 did do VBD 42759 1521 33 pay pay VB 42759 1521 34 . . . 42759 1522 1 When when WRB 42759 1522 2 the the DT 42759 1522 3 State state NN 42759 1522 4 passes pass VBZ 42759 1522 5 the the DT 42759 1522 6 law law NN 42759 1522 7 , , , 42759 1522 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1522 9 violates violate VBZ 42759 1522 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1522 11 implicit implicit JJ 42759 1522 12 promise promise NN 42759 1522 13 , , , 42759 1522 14 and and CC 42759 1522 15 consequently consequently RB 42759 1522 16 is be VBZ 42759 1522 17 under under IN 42759 1522 18 obligation obligation NN 42759 1522 19 to to TO 42759 1522 20 make make VB 42759 1522 21 good good JJ 42759 1522 22 the the DT 42759 1522 23 resulting result VBG 42759 1522 24 losses loss NNS 42759 1522 25 . . . 42759 1523 1 Is be VBZ 42759 1523 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1523 3 not not RB 42759 1523 4 obliged oblige VBN 42759 1523 5 to to TO 42759 1523 6 go go VB 42759 1523 7 further far RBR 42759 1523 8 , , , 42759 1523 9 and and CC 42759 1523 10 pay pay VB 42759 1523 11 for for IN 42759 1523 12 the the DT 42759 1523 13 positive positive JJ 42759 1523 14 gains gain NNS 42759 1523 15 that that WDT 42759 1523 16 many many JJ 42759 1523 17 of of IN 42759 1523 18 the the DT 42759 1523 19 owners owner NNS 42759 1523 20 would would MD 42759 1523 21 have have VB 42759 1523 22 reaped reap VBN 42759 1523 23 in in IN 42759 1523 24 the the DT 42759 1523 25 absence absence NN 42759 1523 26 of of IN 42759 1523 27 the the DT 42759 1523 28 law law NN 42759 1523 29 ? ? . 42759 1524 1 For for IN 42759 1524 2 example example NN 42759 1524 3 : : : 42759 1524 4 a a DT 42759 1524 5 piece piece NN 42759 1524 6 of of IN 42759 1524 7 land land NN 42759 1524 8 is be VBZ 42759 1524 9 worth worth JJ 42759 1524 10 one one CD 42759 1524 11 thousand thousand CD 42759 1524 12 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1524 13 the the DT 42759 1524 14 day day NN 42759 1524 15 after after IN 42759 1524 16 the the DT 42759 1524 17 tax tax NN 42759 1524 18 goes go VBZ 42759 1524 19 into into IN 42759 1524 20 effect effect NN 42759 1524 21 , , , 42759 1524 22 and and CC 42759 1524 23 that that DT 42759 1524 24 was be VBD 42759 1524 25 exactly exactly RB 42759 1524 26 the the DT 42759 1524 27 price price NN 42759 1524 28 paid pay VBN 42759 1524 29 for for IN 42759 1524 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1524 31 by by IN 42759 1524 32 the the DT 42759 1524 33 present present JJ 42759 1524 34 owner owner NN 42759 1524 35 ; ; : 42759 1524 36 another another DT 42759 1524 37 piece piece NN 42759 1524 38 has have VBZ 42759 1524 39 the the DT 42759 1524 40 same same JJ 42759 1524 41 value value NN 42759 1524 42 , , , 42759 1524 43 but but CC 42759 1524 44 was be VBD 42759 1524 45 bought buy VBN 42759 1524 46 by by IN 42759 1524 47 the the DT 42759 1524 48 present present JJ 42759 1524 49 owner owner NN 42759 1524 50 for for IN 42759 1524 51 eight eight CD 42759 1524 52 hundred hundred CD 42759 1524 53 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1524 54 . . . 42759 1525 1 While while IN 42759 1525 2 neither neither DT 42759 1525 3 of of IN 42759 1525 4 these these DT 42759 1525 5 men man NNS 42759 1525 6 suffer suffer VBP 42759 1525 7 any any DT 42759 1525 8 loss loss NN 42759 1525 9 on on IN 42759 1525 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1525 11 investments investment NNS 42759 1525 12 , , , 42759 1525 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1525 14 are be VBP 42759 1525 15 deprived deprive VBN 42759 1525 16 of of IN 42759 1525 17 possible possible JJ 42759 1525 18 gains gain NNS 42759 1525 19 ; ; , 42759 1525 20 for for IN 42759 1525 21 had have VBD 42759 1525 22 the the DT 42759 1525 23 law law NN 42759 1525 24 not not RB 42759 1525 25 been be VBN 42759 1525 26 enacted enact VBN 42759 1525 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1525 28 holdings holding NNS 42759 1525 29 would would MD 42759 1525 30 be be VB 42759 1525 31 worth worth JJ 42759 1525 32 , , , 42759 1525 33 say say UH 42759 1525 34 , , , 42759 1525 35 eleven eleven CD 42759 1525 36 hundred hundred CD 42759 1525 37 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1525 38 . . . 42759 1526 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 1526 2 , , , 42759 1526 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1526 4 are be VBP 42759 1526 5 no no RB 42759 1526 6 worse bad JJR 42759 1526 7 off off RB 42759 1526 8 in in IN 42759 1526 9 this this DT 42759 1526 10 respect respect NN 42759 1526 11 than than IN 42759 1526 12 those those DT 42759 1526 13 persons person NNS 42759 1526 14 who who WP 42759 1526 15 buy buy VBP 42759 1526 16 land land NN 42759 1526 17 after after IN 42759 1526 18 the the DT 42759 1526 19 increment increment JJ 42759 1526 20 tax tax NN 42759 1526 21 goes go VBZ 42759 1526 22 into into IN 42759 1526 23 effect effect NN 42759 1526 24 , , , 42759 1526 25 and and CC 42759 1526 26 have have VBP 42759 1526 27 no no DT 42759 1526 28 greater great JJR 42759 1526 29 claim claim NN 42759 1526 30 to to IN 42759 1526 31 compensation compensation NN 42759 1526 32 for for IN 42759 1526 33 abolished abolished JJ 42759 1526 34 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 1526 35 of of IN 42759 1526 36 positive positive JJ 42759 1526 37 gain gain NN 42759 1526 38 . . . 42759 1527 1 As as IN 42759 1527 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1527 3 have have VBP 42759 1527 4 seen see VBN 42759 1527 5 above above RB 42759 1527 6 , , , 42759 1527 7 the the DT 42759 1527 8 certain certain JJ 42759 1527 9 advantages advantage NNS 42759 1527 10 of of IN 42759 1527 11 the the DT 42759 1527 12 measure measure NN 42759 1527 13 to to IN 42759 1527 14 the the DT 42759 1527 15 community community NN 42759 1527 16 , , , 42759 1527 17 the the DT 42759 1527 18 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 1527 19 advantages advantage NNS 42759 1527 20 to to IN 42759 1527 21 individuals individual NNS 42759 1527 22 of of IN 42759 1527 23 profiting profit VBG 42759 1527 24 by by IN 42759 1527 25 changes change NNS 42759 1527 26 in in IN 42759 1527 27 price price NN 42759 1527 28 which which WDT 42759 1527 29 do do VBP 42759 1527 30 not not RB 42759 1527 31 represent represent VB 42759 1527 32 labour labour NN 42759 1527 33 , , , 42759 1527 34 expense expense NN 42759 1527 35 , , , 42759 1527 36 or or CC 42759 1527 37 saving saving NN 42759 1527 38 , , , 42759 1527 39 show show VB 42759 1527 40 that that IN 42759 1527 41 the the DT 42759 1527 42 owners owner NNS 42759 1527 43 have have VBP 42759 1527 44 no no DT 42759 1527 45 strict strict JJ 42759 1527 46 right right NN 42759 1527 47 to to IN 42759 1527 48 compensation compensation NN 42759 1527 49 . . . 42759 1528 1 And and CC 42759 1528 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1528 3 is be VBZ 42759 1528 4 still still RB 42759 1528 5 clearer clear JJR 42759 1528 6 that that IN 42759 1528 7 no no DT 42759 1528 8 landowner landowner NN 42759 1528 9 has have VBZ 42759 1528 10 a a DT 42759 1528 11 valid valid JJ 42759 1528 12 claim claim NN 42759 1528 13 on on IN 42759 1528 14 account account NN 42759 1528 15 of of IN 42759 1528 16 value value NN 42759 1528 17 increases increase NNS 42759 1528 18 that that WDT 42759 1528 19 would would MD 42759 1528 20 have have VB 42759 1528 21 taken take VBN 42759 1528 22 place place NN 42759 1528 23 subsequent subsequent JJ 42759 1528 24 to to IN 42759 1528 25 the the DT 42759 1528 26 time time NN 42759 1528 27 that that WDT 42759 1528 28 the the DT 42759 1528 29 measure measure NN 42759 1528 30 was be VBD 42759 1528 31 enacted enact VBN 42759 1528 32 . . . 42759 1529 1 There there EX 42759 1529 2 is be VBZ 42759 1529 3 no no DT 42759 1529 4 way way NN 42759 1529 5 by by IN 42759 1529 6 which which WDT 42759 1529 7 owners owner NNS 42759 1529 8 who who WP 42759 1529 9 would would MD 42759 1529 10 have have VB 42759 1529 11 held hold VBN 42759 1529 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1529 13 land land NN 42759 1529 14 long long RB 42759 1529 15 enough enough RB 42759 1529 16 to to TO 42759 1529 17 profit profit VB 42759 1529 18 by by IN 42759 1529 19 these these DT 42759 1529 20 increments increment NNS 42759 1529 21 can can MD 42759 1529 22 be be VB 42759 1529 23 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 1529 24 from from IN 42759 1529 25 owners owner NNS 42759 1529 26 who who WP 42759 1529 27 would would MD 42759 1529 28 not not RB 42759 1529 29 have have VB 42759 1529 30 availed avail VBN 42759 1529 31 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 1529 32 of of IN 42759 1529 33 this this DT 42759 1529 34 conjectural conjectural JJ 42759 1529 35 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 1529 36 , , , 42759 1529 37 nor nor CC 42759 1529 38 any any DT 42759 1529 39 method method NN 42759 1529 40 by by IN 42759 1529 41 which which WDT 42759 1529 42 the the DT 42759 1529 43 amount amount NN 42759 1529 44 of of IN 42759 1529 45 such such JJ 42759 1529 46 gains gain NNS 42759 1529 47 can can MD 42759 1529 48 be be VB 42759 1529 49 determined determine VBN 42759 1529 50 . . . 42759 1530 1 On on IN 42759 1530 2 the the DT 42759 1530 3 other other JJ 42759 1530 4 hand hand NN 42759 1530 5 , , , 42759 1530 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1530 7 might may MD 42759 1530 8 be be VB 42759 1530 9 objected object VBN 42759 1530 10 that that IN 42759 1530 11 , , , 42759 1530 12 in in IN 42759 1530 13 reimbursing reimburse VBG 42759 1530 14 all all DT 42759 1530 15 owners owner NNS 42759 1530 16 who who WP 42759 1530 17 suffer suffer VBP 42759 1530 18 the the DT 42759 1530 19 positive positive JJ 42759 1530 20 losses loss NNS 42759 1530 21 above above IN 42759 1530 22 described describe VBN 42759 1530 23 , , , 42759 1530 24 the the DT 42759 1530 25 State State NNP 42759 1530 26 is be VBZ 42759 1530 27 unduly unduly RB 42759 1530 28 generous generous JJ 42759 1530 29 ; ; : 42759 1530 30 for for IN 42759 1530 31 if if IN 42759 1530 32 the the DT 42759 1530 33 law law NN 42759 1530 34 had have VBD 42759 1530 35 not not RB 42759 1530 36 been be VBN 42759 1530 37 enacted enact VBN 42759 1530 38 many many JJ 42759 1530 39 of of IN 42759 1530 40 the the DT 42759 1530 41 reimbursed reimburse VBN 42759 1530 42 persons person NNS 42759 1530 43 would would MD 42759 1530 44 have have VB 42759 1530 45 sold sell VBN 42759 1530 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1530 47 holdings holding NNS 42759 1530 48 at at IN 42759 1530 49 a a DT 42759 1530 50 price price NN 42759 1530 51 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 1530 52 to to TO 42759 1530 53 cover cover VB 42759 1530 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1530 55 losses loss NNS 42759 1530 56 . . . 42759 1531 1 But but CC 42759 1531 2 these these DT 42759 1531 3 can can MD 42759 1531 4 not not RB 42759 1531 5 be be VB 42759 1531 6 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 1531 7 from from IN 42759 1531 8 those those DT 42759 1531 9 who who WP 42759 1531 10 would would MD 42759 1531 11 have have VB 42759 1531 12 sold sell VBN 42759 1531 13 at at IN 42759 1531 14 a a DT 42759 1531 15 remunerative remunerative JJ 42759 1531 16 price price NN 42759 1531 17 . . . 42759 1532 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1532 2 the the DT 42759 1532 3 State state NN 42759 1532 4 must must MD 42759 1532 5 compensate compensate VB 42759 1532 6 all all DT 42759 1532 7 or or CC 42759 1532 8 none none NN 42759 1532 9 . . . 42759 1533 1 The the DT 42759 1533 2 former former JJ 42759 1533 3 alternative alternative NN 42759 1533 4 is be VBZ 42759 1533 5 not not RB 42759 1533 6 only only RB 42759 1533 7 the the DT 42759 1533 8 more more RBR 42759 1533 9 just just RB 42759 1533 10 all all DT 42759 1533 11 round round JJ 42759 1533 12 , , , 42759 1533 13 but but CC 42759 1533 14 in in IN 42759 1533 15 the the DT 42759 1533 16 long long JJ 42759 1533 17 run run NN 42759 1533 18 the the DT 42759 1533 19 more more JJR 42759 1533 20 expedient expedient NN 42759 1533 21 . . . 42759 1534 1 In in IN 42759 1534 2 view view NN 42759 1534 3 of of IN 42759 1534 4 the the DT 42759 1534 5 social social JJ 42759 1534 6 benefits benefit NNS 42759 1534 7 of of IN 42759 1534 8 the the DT 42759 1534 9 increment increment NN 42759 1534 10 tax tax NN 42759 1534 11 , , , 42759 1534 12 especially especially RB 42759 1534 13 the the DT 42759 1534 14 removal removal NN 42759 1534 15 of of IN 42759 1534 16 many many JJ 42759 1534 17 of of IN 42759 1534 18 the the DT 42759 1534 19 inequities inequity NNS 42759 1534 20 of of IN 42759 1534 21 the the DT 42759 1534 22 present present JJ 42759 1534 23 taxing taxing NN 42759 1534 24 system system NN 42759 1534 25 , , , 42759 1534 26 the the DT 42759 1534 27 State state NN 42759 1534 28 might may MD 42759 1534 29 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 1534 30 be be VB 42759 1534 31 justified justify VBN 42759 1534 32 in in IN 42759 1534 33 making make VBG 42759 1534 34 good good JJ 42759 1534 35 only only RB 42759 1534 36 a a DT 42759 1534 37 part part NN 42759 1534 38 of of IN 42759 1534 39 the the DT 42759 1534 40 losses loss NNS 42759 1534 41 that that WDT 42759 1534 42 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1534 43 have have VBP 42759 1534 44 been be VBN 42759 1534 45 discussing discuss VBG 42759 1534 46 . . . 42759 1535 1 But but CC 42759 1535 2 this this DT 42759 1535 3 could could MD 42759 1535 4 probably probably RB 42759 1535 5 occur occur VB 42759 1535 6 only only RB 42759 1535 7 for for IN 42759 1535 8 administrative administrative JJ 42759 1535 9 reasons reason NNS 42759 1535 10 , , , 42759 1535 11 such such JJ 42759 1535 12 as as IN 42759 1535 13 the the DT 42759 1535 14 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 1535 15 of of IN 42759 1535 16 determining determine VBG 42759 1535 17 the the DT 42759 1535 18 persons person NNS 42759 1535 19 entitled entitle VBN 42759 1535 20 to to IN 42759 1535 21 and and CC 42759 1535 22 the the DT 42759 1535 23 amounts amount NNS 42759 1535 24 of of IN 42759 1535 25 compensation compensation NN 42759 1535 26 . . . 42759 1536 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1536 2 would would MD 42759 1536 3 not not RB 42759 1536 4 be be VB 42759 1536 5 justified justify VBN 42759 1536 6 merely merely RB 42759 1536 7 to to TO 42759 1536 8 enable enable VB 42759 1536 9 the the DT 42759 1536 10 State state NN 42759 1536 11 to to TO 42759 1536 12 profit profit VB 42759 1536 13 at at IN 42759 1536 14 the the DT 42759 1536 15 expense expense NN 42759 1536 16 of of IN 42759 1536 17 individuals individual NNS 42759 1536 18 . . . 42759 1537 1 And and CC 42759 1537 2 , , , 42759 1537 3 in in IN 42759 1537 4 any any DT 42759 1537 5 case case NN 42759 1537 6 , , , 42759 1537 7 there there EX 42759 1537 8 seems seem VBZ 42759 1537 9 to to TO 42759 1537 10 be be VB 42759 1537 11 no no DT 42759 1537 12 good good JJ 42759 1537 13 reason reason NN 42759 1537 14 why why WRB 42759 1537 15 the the DT 42759 1537 16 unpaid unpaid JJ 42759 1537 17 losses loss NNS 42759 1537 18 should should MD 42759 1537 19 amount amount VB 42759 1537 20 to to IN 42759 1537 21 more more JJR 42759 1537 22 than than IN 42759 1537 23 a a DT 42759 1537 24 small small JJ 42759 1537 25 fraction fraction NN 42759 1537 26 of of IN 42759 1537 27 the the DT 42759 1537 28 whole whole NN 42759 1537 29 . . . 42759 1538 1 In in IN 42759 1538 2 the the DT 42759 1538 3 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 1538 4 pages page NNS 42759 1538 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1538 6 have have VBP 42759 1538 7 been be VBN 42759 1538 8 considering consider VBG 42759 1538 9 a a DT 42759 1538 10 law law NN 42759 1538 11 which which WDT 42759 1538 12 would would MD 42759 1538 13 from from IN 42759 1538 14 the the DT 42759 1538 15 beginning beginning NN 42759 1538 16 of of IN 42759 1538 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1538 18 operation operation NN 42759 1538 19 take take VB 42759 1538 20 _ _ NNP 42759 1538 21 all all DT 42759 1538 22 _ _ NNP 42759 1538 23 the the DT 42759 1538 24 future future JJ 42759 1538 25 increments increment NNS 42759 1538 26 of of IN 42759 1538 27 land land NN 42759 1538 28 value value NN 42759 1538 29 . . . 42759 1539 1 There there EX 42759 1539 2 is be VBZ 42759 1539 3 , , , 42759 1539 4 however however RB 42759 1539 5 , , , 42759 1539 6 no no DT 42759 1539 7 likelihood likelihood NN 42759 1539 8 that that IN 42759 1539 9 any any DT 42759 1539 10 such such JJ 42759 1539 11 measure measure NN 42759 1539 12 will will MD 42759 1539 13 soon soon RB 42759 1539 14 be be VB 42759 1539 15 enacted enact VBN 42759 1539 16 in in IN 42759 1539 17 any any DT 42759 1539 18 country country NN 42759 1539 19 , , , 42759 1539 20 least least JJS 42759 1539 21 of of IN 42759 1539 22 all all DT 42759 1539 23 , , , 42759 1539 24 in in IN 42759 1539 25 the the DT 42759 1539 26 United United NNP 42759 1539 27 States States NNP 42759 1539 28 . . . 42759 1540 1 What what WP 42759 1540 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1540 3 shall shall MD 42759 1540 4 probably probably RB 42759 1540 5 see see VB 42759 1540 6 is be VBZ 42759 1540 7 the the DT 42759 1540 8 spread spread NN 42759 1540 9 of of IN 42759 1540 10 legislation legislation NN 42759 1540 11 designed design VBN 42759 1540 12 to to TO 42759 1540 13 take take VB 42759 1540 14 a a DT 42759 1540 15 part part NN 42759 1540 16 , , , 42759 1540 17 and and CC 42759 1540 18 a a DT 42759 1540 19 gradual gradual JJ 42759 1540 20 growing grow VBG 42759 1540 21 part part NN 42759 1540 22 , , , 42759 1540 23 of of IN 42759 1540 24 value value NN 42759 1540 25 increases increase NNS 42759 1540 26 , , , 42759 1540 27 after after IN 42759 1540 28 the the DT 42759 1540 29 example example NN 42759 1540 30 of of IN 42759 1540 31 Germany Germany NNP 42759 1540 32 and and CC 42759 1540 33 Great Great NNP 42759 1540 34 Britain Britain NNP 42759 1540 35 . . . 42759 1541 1 Let let VB 42759 1541 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 1541 3 glance glance VB 42759 1541 4 at at IN 42759 1541 5 the the DT 42759 1541 6 laws law NNS 42759 1541 7 in in IN 42759 1541 8 force force NN 42759 1541 9 in in IN 42759 1541 10 these these DT 42759 1541 11 two two CD 42759 1541 12 countries country NNS 42759 1541 13 . . . 42759 1542 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1542 2 The the DT 42759 1542 3 German german JJ 42759 1542 4 and and CC 42759 1542 5 British british JJ 42759 1542 6 Increment Increment NNP 42759 1542 7 Taxes Taxes NNP 42759 1542 8 _ _ NNP 42759 1542 9 The the DT 42759 1542 10 first first JJ 42759 1542 11 increment increment NN 42759 1542 12 tax tax NN 42759 1542 13 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1542 14 Werthzuwachssteuer Werthzuwachssteuer NNP 42759 1542 15 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1542 16 was be VBD 42759 1542 17 established establish VBN 42759 1542 18 in in IN 42759 1542 19 the the DT 42759 1542 20 year year NN 42759 1542 21 1898 1898 CD 42759 1542 22 in in IN 42759 1542 23 the the DT 42759 1542 24 German german JJ 42759 1542 25 colony colony NN 42759 1542 26 of of IN 42759 1542 27 Kiautschou Kiautschou NNP 42759 1542 28 , , , 42759 1542 29 China China NNP 42759 1542 30 . . . 42759 1543 1 In in IN 42759 1543 2 1904 1904 CD 42759 1543 3 the the DT 42759 1543 4 principle principle NN 42759 1543 5 of of IN 42759 1543 6 the the DT 42759 1543 7 tax tax NN 42759 1543 8 was be VBD 42759 1543 9 adopted adopt VBN 42759 1543 10 by by IN 42759 1543 11 Frankfort Frankfort NNP 42759 1543 12 - - HYPH 42759 1543 13 am am NNP 42759 1543 14 - - HYPH 42759 1543 15 Main main JJ 42759 1543 16 , , , 42759 1543 17 and and CC 42759 1543 18 in in IN 42759 1543 19 1905 1905 CD 42759 1543 20 by by IN 42759 1543 21 Cologne Cologne NNP 42759 1543 22 . . . 42759 1544 1 By by IN 42759 1544 2 April April NNP 42759 1544 3 , , , 42759 1544 4 1910 1910 CD 42759 1544 5 , , , 42759 1544 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1544 7 had have VBD 42759 1544 8 already already RB 42759 1544 9 been be VBN 42759 1544 10 enacted enact VBN 42759 1544 11 in in IN 42759 1544 12 457 457 CD 42759 1544 13 cities city NNS 42759 1544 14 and and CC 42759 1544 15 towns town NNS 42759 1544 16 of of IN 42759 1544 17 Germany Germany NNP 42759 1544 18 , , , 42759 1544 19 some some DT 42759 1544 20 twenty twenty CD 42759 1544 21 of of IN 42759 1544 22 which which WDT 42759 1544 23 had have VBD 42759 1544 24 a a DT 42759 1544 25 population population NN 42759 1544 26 of of IN 42759 1544 27 more more JJR 42759 1544 28 than than IN 42759 1544 29 100,000 100,000 CD 42759 1544 30 each each DT 42759 1544 31 , , , 42759 1544 32 in in IN 42759 1544 33 652 652 CD 42759 1544 34 communes commune NNS 42759 1544 35 , , , 42759 1544 36 several several JJ 42759 1544 37 districts district NNS 42759 1544 38 , , , 42759 1544 39 one one CD 42759 1544 40 principality principality NN 42759 1544 41 , , , 42759 1544 42 and and CC 42759 1544 43 one one CD 42759 1544 44 grand grand JJ 42759 1544 45 duchy duchy NN 42759 1544 46 . . . 42759 1545 1 In in IN 42759 1545 2 1911 1911 CD 42759 1545 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1545 4 was be VBD 42759 1545 5 inserted insert VBN 42759 1545 6 in in IN 42759 1545 7 the the DT 42759 1545 8 imperial imperial JJ 42759 1545 9 fiscal fiscal JJ 42759 1545 10 system system NN 42759 1545 11 , , , 42759 1545 12 and and CC 42759 1545 13 thus thus RB 42759 1545 14 extended extend VBN 42759 1545 15 over over IN 42759 1545 16 the the DT 42759 1545 17 whole whole JJ 42759 1545 18 German German NNP 42759 1545 19 Empire Empire NNP 42759 1545 20 . . . 42759 1546 1 While while IN 42759 1546 2 these these DT 42759 1546 3 laws law NNS 42759 1546 4 are be VBP 42759 1546 5 all all RB 42759 1546 6 alike alike RB 42759 1546 7 in in IN 42759 1546 8 certain certain JJ 42759 1546 9 essentials essential NNS 42759 1546 10 , , , 42759 1546 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1546 12 vary vary VBP 42759 1546 13 greatly greatly RB 42759 1546 14 in in IN 42759 1546 15 details detail NNS 42759 1546 16 . . . 42759 1547 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 1547 2 agree agree VBP 42759 1547 3 in in IN 42759 1547 4 taking take VBG 42759 1547 5 only only RB 42759 1547 6 a a DT 42759 1547 7 per per NN 42759 1547 8 cent cent NN 42759 1547 9 . . . 42759 1548 1 of of IN 42759 1548 2 the the DT 42759 1548 3 value value NN 42759 1548 4 increases increase NNS 42759 1548 5 , , , 42759 1548 6 and and CC 42759 1548 7 in in IN 42759 1548 8 imposing impose VBG 42759 1548 9 a a DT 42759 1548 10 higher high JJR 42759 1548 11 rate rate NN 42759 1548 12 on on IN 42759 1548 13 the the DT 42759 1548 14 more more RBR 42759 1548 15 rapid rapid JJ 42759 1548 16 increases increase NNS 42759 1548 17 . . . 42759 1549 1 The the DT 42759 1549 2 rates rate NNS 42759 1549 3 of of IN 42759 1549 4 the the DT 42759 1549 5 imperial imperial JJ 42759 1549 6 law law NN 42759 1549 7 vary vary VBP 42759 1549 8 from from IN 42759 1549 9 ten ten CD 42759 1549 10 per per IN 42759 1549 11 cent cent NN 42759 1549 12 . . . 42759 1550 1 on on IN 42759 1550 2 increases increase NNS 42759 1550 3 of of IN 42759 1550 4 ten ten CD 42759 1550 5 per per IN 42759 1550 6 cent cent NN 42759 1550 7 . . . 42759 1551 1 or or CC 42759 1551 2 less less JJR 42759 1551 3 to to TO 42759 1551 4 thirty thirty CD 42759 1551 5 per per IN 42759 1551 6 cent cent NN 42759 1551 7 . . . 42759 1552 1 on on IN 42759 1552 2 increases increase NNS 42759 1552 3 of of IN 42759 1552 4 290 290 CD 42759 1552 5 per per NN 42759 1552 6 cent cent NN 42759 1552 7 . . . 42759 1553 1 or or CC 42759 1553 2 over over RB 42759 1553 3 . . . 42759 1554 1 In in IN 42759 1554 2 Dortmund Dortmund NNP 42759 1554 3 the the DT 42759 1554 4 scale scale NN 42759 1554 5 progresses progress NNS 42759 1554 6 from from IN 42759 1554 7 one one CD 42759 1554 8 to to TO 42759 1554 9 12 12 CD 42759 1554 10 - - SYM 42759 1554 11 1/2 1/2 CD 42759 1554 12 per per IN 42759 1554 13 cent cent NN 42759 1554 14 . . . 42759 1555 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 1555 2 as as IN 42759 1555 3 the the DT 42759 1555 4 highest high JJS 42759 1555 5 rate rate NN 42759 1555 6 in in IN 42759 1555 7 the the DT 42759 1555 8 imperial imperial JJ 42759 1555 9 law law NN 42759 1555 10 is be VBZ 42759 1555 11 30 30 CD 42759 1555 12 per per NN 42759 1555 13 cent cent NN 42759 1555 14 . . . 42759 1555 15 , , , 42759 1555 16 and and CC 42759 1555 17 in in IN 42759 1555 18 any any DT 42759 1555 19 municipal municipal JJ 42759 1555 20 law law NN 42759 1555 21 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1555 22 Cologne Cologne NNP 42759 1555 23 and and CC 42759 1555 24 Frankfort Frankfort NNP 42759 1555 25 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1555 26 25 25 CD 42759 1555 27 per per NN 42759 1555 28 cent cent NN 42759 1555 29 . . . 42759 1556 1 ; ; : 42759 1556 2 inasmuch inasmuch VB 42759 1556 3 as as IN 42759 1556 4 all all PDT 42759 1556 5 the the DT 42759 1556 6 laws law NNS 42759 1556 7 allow allow VBP 42759 1556 8 deductions deduction NNS 42759 1556 9 from from IN 42759 1556 10 the the DT 42759 1556 11 tax tax NN 42759 1556 12 to to TO 42759 1556 13 cover cover VB 42759 1556 14 the the DT 42759 1556 15 interest interest NN 42759 1556 16 that that WDT 42759 1556 17 was be VBD 42759 1556 18 not not RB 42759 1556 19 obtained obtain VBN 42759 1556 20 while while IN 42759 1556 21 the the DT 42759 1556 22 land land NN 42759 1556 23 was be VBD 42759 1556 24 unproductive unproductive JJ 42759 1556 25 ; ; : 42759 1556 26 and and CC 42759 1556 27 inasmuch inasmuch VB 42759 1556 28 as as IN 42759 1556 29 only only RB 42759 1556 30 those those DT 42759 1556 31 increases increase NNS 42759 1556 32 are be VBP 42759 1556 33 taxed tax VBN 42759 1556 34 which which WDT 42759 1556 35 are be VBP 42759 1556 36 measured measure VBN 42759 1556 37 from from IN 42759 1556 38 the the DT 42759 1556 39 value value NN 42759 1556 40 that that WDT 42759 1556 41 the the DT 42759 1556 42 land land NN 42759 1556 43 had have VBD 42759 1556 44 when when WRB 42759 1556 45 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1556 46 came come VBD 42759 1556 47 into into IN 42759 1556 48 the the DT 42759 1556 49 possession possession NN 42759 1556 50 of of IN 42759 1556 51 the the DT 42759 1556 52 present present JJ 42759 1556 53 owner,--it owner,--it NNP 42759 1556 54 is be VBZ 42759 1556 55 clear clear JJ 42759 1556 56 that that IN 42759 1556 57 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1556 58 are be VBP 42759 1556 59 not not RB 42759 1556 60 obliged oblige VBN 42759 1556 61 to to TO 42759 1556 62 undergo undergo VB 42759 1556 63 any any DT 42759 1556 64 positive positive JJ 42759 1556 65 loss loss NN 42759 1556 66 , , , 42759 1556 67 and and CC 42759 1556 68 that that IN 42759 1556 69 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1556 70 are be VBP 42759 1556 71 permitted permit VBN 42759 1556 72 to to TO 42759 1556 73 retain retain VB 42759 1556 74 the the DT 42759 1556 75 lion lion NN 42759 1556 76 's 's POS 42759 1556 77 share share NN 42759 1556 78 of of IN 42759 1556 79 the the DT 42759 1556 80 " " `` 42759 1556 81 unearned unearned JJ 42759 1556 82 increment increment NN 42759 1556 83 . . . 42759 1557 1 " " `` 42759 1557 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1557 3 96 96 CD 42759 1557 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1557 5 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1557 6 is be VBZ 42759 1557 7 to to TO 42759 1557 8 be be VB 42759 1557 9 noted note VBN 42759 1557 10 that that IN 42759 1557 11 most most JJS 42759 1557 12 of of IN 42759 1557 13 the the DT 42759 1557 14 German german JJ 42759 1557 15 laws law NNS 42759 1557 16 are be VBP 42759 1557 17 retroactive retroactive JJ 42759 1557 18 , , , 42759 1557 19 since since IN 42759 1557 20 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1557 21 apply apply VBP 42759 1557 22 not not RB 42759 1557 23 merely merely RB 42759 1557 24 to to IN 42759 1557 25 future future JJ 42759 1557 26 value value NN 42759 1557 27 increases increase NNS 42759 1557 28 , , , 42759 1557 29 but but CC 42759 1557 30 to to IN 42759 1557 31 some some DT 42759 1557 32 of of IN 42759 1557 33 those those DT 42759 1557 34 that that WDT 42759 1557 35 occurred occur VBD 42759 1557 36 before before IN 42759 1557 37 the the DT 42759 1557 38 law law NN 42759 1557 39 was be VBD 42759 1557 40 enacted enact VBN 42759 1557 41 . . . 42759 1558 1 Thus thus RB 42759 1558 2 , , , 42759 1558 3 the the DT 42759 1558 4 Hamburg Hamburg NNP 42759 1558 5 ordinance ordinance NN 42759 1558 6 measures measure VBZ 42759 1558 7 the the DT 42759 1558 8 increases increase NNS 42759 1558 9 from from IN 42759 1558 10 the the DT 42759 1558 11 last last JJ 42759 1558 12 sale sale NN 42759 1558 13 , , , 42759 1558 14 no no RB 42759 1558 15 matter matter RB 42759 1558 16 how how WRB 42759 1558 17 long long RB 42759 1558 18 ago ago RB 42759 1558 19 that that IN 42759 1558 20 transaction transaction NN 42759 1558 21 took take VBD 42759 1558 22 place place NN 42759 1558 23 . . . 42759 1559 1 The the DT 42759 1559 2 imperial imperial JJ 42759 1559 3 law law NN 42759 1559 4 uses use VBZ 42759 1559 5 the the DT 42759 1559 6 same same JJ 42759 1559 7 starting starting NN 42759 1559 8 point point NN 42759 1559 9 , , , 42759 1559 10 except except IN 42759 1559 11 in in IN 42759 1559 12 cases case NNS 42759 1559 13 where where WRB 42759 1559 14 the the DT 42759 1559 15 last last JJ 42759 1559 16 sale sale NN 42759 1559 17 occurred occur VBD 42759 1559 18 before before IN 42759 1559 19 1885 1885 CD 42759 1559 20 . . . 42759 1560 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 42759 1560 2 , , , 42759 1560 3 a a DT 42759 1560 4 man man NN 42759 1560 5 who who WP 42759 1560 6 had have VBD 42759 1560 7 in in IN 42759 1560 8 1880 1880 CD 42759 1560 9 paid pay VBD 42759 1560 10 2500 2500 CD 42759 1560 11 marks mark NNS 42759 1560 12 for for IN 42759 1560 13 a a DT 42759 1560 14 piece piece NN 42759 1560 15 of of IN 42759 1560 16 land land NN 42759 1560 17 which which WDT 42759 1560 18 in in IN 42759 1560 19 1885 1885 CD 42759 1560 20 was be VBD 42759 1560 21 worth worth JJ 42759 1560 22 only only RB 42759 1560 23 2000 2000 CD 42759 1560 24 marks mark NNS 42759 1560 25 , , , 42759 1560 26 and and CC 42759 1560 27 who who WP 42759 1560 28 sold sell VBD 42759 1560 29 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1560 30 for for IN 42759 1560 31 3000 3000 CD 42759 1560 32 marks mark NNS 42759 1560 33 after after IN 42759 1560 34 the the DT 42759 1560 35 law law NN 42759 1560 36 went go VBD 42759 1560 37 into into IN 42759 1560 38 effect effect NN 42759 1560 39 , , , 42759 1560 40 would would MD 42759 1560 41 pay pay VB 42759 1560 42 the the DT 42759 1560 43 increment increment JJ 42759 1560 44 tax tax NN 42759 1560 45 on on IN 42759 1560 46 1000 1000 CD 42759 1560 47 marks,--unless marks,--unless . 42759 1560 48 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1560 49 could could MD 42759 1560 50 prove prove VB 42759 1560 51 that that IN 42759 1560 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1560 53 purchase purchase NN 42759 1560 54 price price NN 42759 1560 55 was be VBD 42759 1560 56 2500 2500 CD 42759 1560 57 marks mark NNS 42759 1560 58 . . . 42759 1561 1 In in IN 42759 1561 2 all all DT 42759 1561 3 such such JJ 42759 1561 4 cases case NNS 42759 1561 5 the the DT 42759 1561 6 burden burden NN 42759 1561 7 of of IN 42759 1561 8 proof proof NN 42759 1561 9 is be VBZ 42759 1561 10 on on IN 42759 1561 11 the the DT 42759 1561 12 owner owner NN 42759 1561 13 to to TO 42759 1561 14 show show VB 42759 1561 15 that that IN 42759 1561 16 the the DT 42759 1561 17 value value NN 42759 1561 18 of of IN 42759 1561 19 the the DT 42759 1561 20 land land NN 42759 1561 21 in in IN 42759 1561 22 1885 1885 CD 42759 1561 23 was be VBD 42759 1561 24 lower low JJR 42759 1561 25 than than IN 42759 1561 26 when when WRB 42759 1561 27 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1561 28 had have VBD 42759 1561 29 bought buy VBN 42759 1561 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1561 31 at at IN 42759 1561 32 the the DT 42759 1561 33 earlier early JJR 42759 1561 34 date date NN 42759 1561 35 . . . 42759 1562 1 Obviously obviously RB 42759 1562 2 this this DT 42759 1562 3 retroactive retroactive JJ 42759 1562 4 feature feature NN 42759 1562 5 of of IN 42759 1562 6 the the DT 42759 1562 7 German german JJ 42759 1562 8 legislation legislation NN 42759 1562 9 inflicts inflict VBZ 42759 1562 10 no no DT 42759 1562 11 wrong wrong NN 42759 1562 12 on on IN 42759 1562 13 the the DT 42759 1562 14 owner owner NN 42759 1562 15 , , , 42759 1562 16 since since IN 42759 1562 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1562 18 does do VBZ 42759 1562 19 not not RB 42759 1562 20 touch touch VB 42759 1562 21 value value NN 42759 1562 22 increases increase NNS 42759 1562 23 that that IN 42759 1562 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1562 25 has have VBZ 42759 1562 26 paid pay VBN 42759 1562 27 for for IN 42759 1562 28 . . . 42759 1563 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 1563 2 , , , 42759 1563 3 the the DT 42759 1563 4 value value NN 42759 1563 5 of of IN 42759 1563 6 the the DT 42759 1563 7 land land NN 42759 1563 8 when when WRB 42759 1563 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1563 10 came come VBD 42759 1563 11 into into IN 42759 1563 12 the the DT 42759 1563 13 present present JJ 42759 1563 14 owner owner NN 42759 1563 15 's 's POS 42759 1563 16 possession possession NN 42759 1563 17 seems seem VBZ 42759 1563 18 to to TO 42759 1563 19 be be VB 42759 1563 20 a a DT 42759 1563 21 fairer fair JJR 42759 1563 22 and and CC 42759 1563 23 more more RBR 42759 1563 24 easily easily RB 42759 1563 25 ascertained ascertained JJ 42759 1563 26 basis basis NN 42759 1563 27 from from IN 42759 1563 28 which which WDT 42759 1563 29 to to TO 42759 1563 30 reckon reckon VB 42759 1563 31 increases increase NNS 42759 1563 32 than than IN 42759 1563 33 any any DT 42759 1563 34 date date NN 42759 1563 35 subsequent subsequent JJ 42759 1563 36 to to IN 42759 1563 37 the the DT 42759 1563 38 enactment enactment NN 42759 1563 39 of of IN 42759 1563 40 the the DT 42759 1563 41 law law NN 42759 1563 42 . . . 42759 1564 1 On on IN 42759 1564 2 the the DT 42759 1564 3 one one CD 42759 1564 4 hand hand NN 42759 1564 5 , , , 42759 1564 6 persons person NNS 42759 1564 7 whose whose WP$ 42759 1564 8 lands land NNS 42759 1564 9 had have VBD 42759 1564 10 fallen fall VBN 42759 1564 11 in in IN 42759 1564 12 value value NN 42759 1564 13 during during IN 42759 1564 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1564 15 ownership ownership NN 42759 1564 16 would would MD 42759 1564 17 be be VB 42759 1564 18 automatically automatically RB 42759 1564 19 excluded exclude VBN 42759 1564 20 from from IN 42759 1564 21 the the DT 42759 1564 22 operation operation NN 42759 1564 23 of of IN 42759 1564 24 the the DT 42759 1564 25 law law NN 42759 1564 26 until until IN 42759 1564 27 such such JJ 42759 1564 28 time time NN 42759 1564 29 as as IN 42759 1564 30 the the DT 42759 1564 31 acquisition acquisition NN 42759 1564 32 value value NN 42759 1564 33 was be VBD 42759 1564 34 again again RB 42759 1564 35 reached reach VBN 42759 1564 36 ; ; : 42759 1564 37 on on IN 42759 1564 38 the the DT 42759 1564 39 other other JJ 42759 1564 40 hand hand NN 42759 1564 41 , , , 42759 1564 42 those those DT 42759 1564 43 owners owner NNS 42759 1564 44 whose whose WP$ 42759 1564 45 lands land NNS 42759 1564 46 had have VBD 42759 1564 47 increased increase VBN 42759 1564 48 in in IN 42759 1564 49 value value NN 42759 1564 50 before before IN 42759 1564 51 the the DT 42759 1564 52 law law NN 42759 1564 53 went go VBD 42759 1564 54 into into IN 42759 1564 55 effect effect NN 42759 1564 56 would would MD 42759 1564 57 be be VB 42759 1564 58 taxed tax VBN 42759 1564 59 as as RB 42759 1564 60 well well RB 42759 1564 61 as as IN 42759 1564 62 those those DT 42759 1564 63 whose whose WP$ 42759 1564 64 gains gain NNS 42759 1564 65 began begin VBD 42759 1564 66 after after IN 42759 1564 67 that that DT 42759 1564 68 event event NN 42759 1564 69 ; ; : 42759 1564 70 thus thus RB 42759 1564 71 the the DT 42759 1564 72 law law NN 42759 1564 73 would would MD 42759 1564 74 reach reach VB 42759 1564 75 a a DT 42759 1564 76 greater great JJR 42759 1564 77 proportion proportion NN 42759 1564 78 of of IN 42759 1564 79 the the DT 42759 1564 80 existing exist VBG 42759 1564 81 beneficiaries beneficiary NNS 42759 1564 82 of of IN 42759 1564 83 " " `` 42759 1564 84 unearned unearned JJ 42759 1564 85 increment increment NN 42759 1564 86 . . . 42759 1564 87 " " '' 42759 1565 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 1565 2 , , , 42759 1565 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1565 4 would would MD 42759 1565 5 bring bring VB 42759 1565 6 in in RP 42759 1565 7 a a DT 42759 1565 8 larger large JJR 42759 1565 9 amount amount NN 42759 1565 10 of of IN 42759 1565 11 revenue revenue NN 42759 1565 12 . . . 42759 1566 1 The the DT 42759 1566 2 British british JJ 42759 1566 3 law law NN 42759 1566 4 formed form VBD 42759 1566 5 a a DT 42759 1566 6 part part NN 42759 1566 7 of of IN 42759 1566 8 the the DT 42759 1566 9 famous famous JJ 42759 1566 10 Lloyd Lloyd NNP 42759 1566 11 - - HYPH 42759 1566 12 George George NNP 42759 1566 13 budget budget NN 42759 1566 14 of of IN 42759 1566 15 1909 1909 CD 42759 1566 16 . . . 42759 1567 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1567 2 taxes tax VBZ 42759 1567 3 only only RB 42759 1567 4 those those DT 42759 1567 5 increments increment NNS 42759 1567 6 that that WDT 42759 1567 7 occur occur VBP 42759 1567 8 after after IN 42759 1567 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1567 10 enactment enactment NN 42759 1567 11 . . . 42759 1568 1 These these DT 42759 1568 2 are be VBP 42759 1568 3 subject subject JJ 42759 1568 4 to to IN 42759 1568 5 a a DT 42759 1568 6 tax tax NN 42759 1568 7 of of IN 42759 1568 8 twenty twenty CD 42759 1568 9 per per NN 42759 1568 10 cent cent NN 42759 1568 11 . . . 42759 1569 1 on on IN 42759 1569 2 the the DT 42759 1569 3 occasion occasion NN 42759 1569 4 of of IN 42759 1569 5 the the DT 42759 1569 6 next next JJ 42759 1569 7 transfer transfer NN 42759 1569 8 of of IN 42759 1569 9 the the DT 42759 1569 10 land land NN 42759 1569 11 , , , 42759 1569 12 by by IN 42759 1569 13 sale sale NN 42759 1569 14 , , , 42759 1569 15 bequest bequest NNP 42759 1569 16 , , , 42759 1569 17 or or CC 42759 1569 18 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 1569 19 . . . 42759 1570 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1570 2 97 97 CD 42759 1570 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1570 4 In in IN 42759 1570 5 some some DT 42759 1570 6 cases case NNS 42759 1570 7 this this DT 42759 1570 8 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 1570 9 will will MD 42759 1570 10 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 1570 11 cause cause VB 42759 1570 12 hardship hardship NN 42759 1570 13 . . . 42759 1571 1 For for IN 42759 1571 2 example example NN 42759 1571 3 : : : 42759 1571 4 if if IN 42759 1571 5 land land NN 42759 1571 6 which which WDT 42759 1571 7 was be VBD 42759 1571 8 bought buy VBN 42759 1571 9 for for IN 42759 1571 10 1,000 1,000 CD 42759 1571 11 pounds pound NNS 42759 1571 12 in in IN 42759 1571 13 1900 1900 CD 42759 1571 14 had have VBD 42759 1571 15 fallen fall VBN 42759 1571 16 to to IN 42759 1571 17 800 800 CD 42759 1571 18 pounds pound NNS 42759 1571 19 in in IN 42759 1571 20 1909 1909 CD 42759 1571 21 , , , 42759 1571 22 and and CC 42759 1571 23 were be VBD 42759 1571 24 sold sell VBN 42759 1571 25 for for IN 42759 1571 26 1,000 1,000 CD 42759 1571 27 pounds pound NNS 42759 1571 28 in in IN 42759 1571 29 1915 1915 CD 42759 1571 30 , , , 42759 1571 31 the the DT 42759 1571 32 owner owner NN 42759 1571 33 would would MD 42759 1571 34 have have VB 42759 1571 35 to to TO 42759 1571 36 pay pay VB 42759 1571 37 a a DT 42759 1571 38 tax tax NN 42759 1571 39 of of IN 42759 1571 40 twenty twenty CD 42759 1571 41 per per NN 42759 1571 42 cent cent NN 42759 1571 43 . . . 42759 1572 1 on on IN 42759 1572 2 200 200 CD 42759 1572 3 pounds pound NNS 42759 1572 4 . . . 42759 1573 1 This this DT 42759 1573 2 would would MD 42759 1573 3 mean mean VB 42759 1573 4 a a DT 42759 1573 5 net net JJ 42759 1573 6 loss loss NN 42759 1573 7 of of IN 42759 1573 8 forty forty CD 42759 1573 9 pounds pound NNS 42759 1573 10 , , , 42759 1573 11 to to TO 42759 1573 12 say say VB 42759 1573 13 nothing nothing NN 42759 1573 14 of of IN 42759 1573 15 the the DT 42759 1573 16 loss loss NN 42759 1573 17 of of IN 42759 1573 18 interest interest NN 42759 1573 19 in in IN 42759 1573 20 case case NN 42759 1573 21 the the DT 42759 1573 22 land land NN 42759 1573 23 was be VBD 42759 1573 24 unproductive unproductive JJ 42759 1573 25 . . . 42759 1574 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1574 2 would would MD 42759 1574 3 seem seem VB 42759 1574 4 that that IN 42759 1574 5 some some DT 42759 1574 6 compensation compensation NN 42759 1574 7 ought ought MD 42759 1574 8 to to TO 42759 1574 9 be be VB 42759 1574 10 given give VBN 42759 1574 11 here here RB 42759 1574 12 ; ; : 42759 1574 13 yet yet CC 42759 1574 14 the the DT 42759 1574 15 rarity rarity NN 42759 1574 16 of of IN 42759 1574 17 such such JJ 42759 1574 18 instances instance NNS 42759 1574 19 , , , 42759 1574 20 the the DT 42759 1574 21 administrative administrative JJ 42759 1574 22 difficulties difficulty NNS 42759 1574 23 , , , 42759 1574 24 and and CC 42759 1574 25 the the DT 42759 1574 26 general general JJ 42759 1574 27 advantages advantage NNS 42759 1574 28 of of IN 42759 1574 29 this this DT 42759 1574 30 sort sort NN 42759 1574 31 of of IN 42759 1574 32 legislation legislation NN 42759 1574 33 quite quite RB 42759 1574 34 conceivably conceivably RB 42759 1574 35 might may MD 42759 1574 36 forbid forbid VB 42759 1574 37 the the DT 42759 1574 38 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 1574 39 that that IN 42759 1574 40 the the DT 42759 1574 41 owner owner NN 42759 1574 42 was be VBD 42759 1574 43 made make VBN 42759 1574 44 to to TO 42759 1574 45 suffer suffer VB 42759 1574 46 certain certain JJ 42759 1574 47 injustice injustice NN 42759 1574 48 . . . 42759 1575 1 The the DT 42759 1575 2 compensating compensating JJ 42759 1575 3 social social JJ 42759 1575 4 advantages advantage NNS 42759 1575 5 of of IN 42759 1575 6 the the DT 42759 1575 7 increment increment JJ 42759 1575 8 tax tax NN 42759 1575 9 as as RB 42759 1575 10 well well RB 42759 1575 11 as as IN 42759 1575 12 of of IN 42759 1575 13 other other JJ 42759 1575 14 special special JJ 42759 1575 15 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1575 16 on on IN 42759 1575 17 land land NN 42759 1575 18 , , , 42759 1575 19 will will MD 42759 1575 20 receive receive VB 42759 1575 21 adequate adequate JJ 42759 1575 22 discussion discussion NN 42759 1575 23 presently presently RB 42759 1575 24 . . . 42759 1576 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1576 2 Transferring transfer VBG 42759 1576 3 Other other JJ 42759 1576 4 Taxes taxis NNS 42759 1576 5 to to IN 42759 1576 6 Land Land NNP 42759 1576 7 _ _ NNP 42759 1576 8 Another another DT 42759 1576 9 taxation taxation NN 42759 1576 10 plan plan NN 42759 1576 11 for for IN 42759 1576 12 reducing reduce VBG 42759 1576 13 the the DT 42759 1576 14 evils evil NNS 42759 1576 15 of of IN 42759 1576 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1576 17 land land NN 42759 1576 18 system system NN 42759 1576 19 consists consist VBZ 42759 1576 20 in in IN 42759 1576 21 the the DT 42759 1576 22 imposition imposition NN 42759 1576 23 of of IN 42759 1576 24 special special JJ 42759 1576 25 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1576 26 on on IN 42759 1576 27 the the DT 42759 1576 28 _ _ NNP 42759 1576 29 present present JJ 42759 1576 30 _ _ NNP 42759 1576 31 value value NN 42759 1576 32 of of IN 42759 1576 33 land land NN 42759 1576 34 . . . 42759 1577 1 As as IN 42759 1577 2 a a DT 42759 1577 3 rule rule NN 42759 1577 4 , , , 42759 1577 5 these these DT 42759 1577 6 imply imply VBP 42759 1577 7 , , , 42759 1577 8 not not RB 42759 1577 9 an an DT 42759 1577 10 addition addition NN 42759 1577 11 to to IN 42759 1577 12 the the DT 42759 1577 13 total total JJ 42759 1577 14 tax tax NN 42759 1577 15 levy levy NN 42759 1577 16 , , , 42759 1577 17 but but CC 42759 1577 18 a a DT 42759 1577 19 transfer transfer NN 42759 1577 20 of of IN 42759 1577 21 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1577 22 from from IN 42759 1577 23 other other JJ 42759 1577 24 forms form NNS 42759 1577 25 of of IN 42759 1577 26 property property NN 42759 1577 27 . . . 42759 1578 1 The the DT 42759 1578 2 usual usual JJ 42759 1578 3 practice practice NN 42759 1578 4 is be VBZ 42759 1578 5 to to TO 42759 1578 6 begin begin VB 42759 1578 7 by by IN 42759 1578 8 exempting exempt VBG 42759 1578 9 either either CC 42759 1578 10 partly partly RB 42759 1578 11 or or CC 42759 1578 12 wholly wholly RB 42759 1578 13 buildings building NNS 42759 1578 14 and and CC 42759 1578 15 other other JJ 42759 1578 16 kinds kind NNS 42759 1578 17 of of IN 42759 1578 18 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1578 19 from from IN 42759 1578 20 taxation taxation NN 42759 1578 21 , , , 42759 1578 22 and and CC 42759 1578 23 then then RB 42759 1578 24 to to TO 42759 1578 25 apply apply VB 42759 1578 26 the the DT 42759 1578 27 same same JJ 42759 1578 28 measure measure NN 42759 1578 29 to to IN 42759 1578 30 certain certain JJ 42759 1578 31 kinds kind NNS 42759 1578 32 of of IN 42759 1578 33 personal personal JJ 42759 1578 34 property property NN 42759 1578 35 . . . 42759 1579 1 In in IN 42759 1579 2 most most JJS 42759 1579 3 cases case NNS 42759 1579 4 the the DT 42759 1579 5 transfer transfer NN 42759 1579 6 of of IN 42759 1579 7 such such JJ 42759 1579 8 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1579 9 to to IN 42759 1579 10 land land NN 42759 1579 11 is be VBZ 42759 1579 12 gradual gradual JJ 42759 1579 13 , , , 42759 1579 14 extending extend VBG 42759 1579 15 over over IN 42759 1579 16 a a DT 42759 1579 17 period period NN 42759 1579 18 of of IN 42759 1579 19 five five CD 42759 1579 20 , , , 42759 1579 21 ten ten CD 42759 1579 22 , , , 42759 1579 23 or or CC 42759 1579 24 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 1579 25 years year NNS 42759 1579 26 . . . 42759 1580 1 The the DT 42759 1580 2 plan plan NN 42759 1580 3 is be VBZ 42759 1580 4 in in IN 42759 1580 5 operation operation NN 42759 1580 6 in in IN 42759 1580 7 Canada Canada NNP 42759 1580 8 and and CC 42759 1580 9 Australasia Australasia NNP 42759 1580 10 , , , 42759 1580 11 and and CC 42759 1580 12 to to IN 42759 1580 13 a a DT 42759 1580 14 slight slight JJ 42759 1580 15 extent extent NN 42759 1580 16 in in IN 42759 1580 17 the the DT 42759 1580 18 United United NNP 42759 1580 19 States States NNP 42759 1580 20 . . . 42759 1581 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1581 2 has have VBZ 42759 1581 3 received receive VBN 42759 1581 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1581 5 greatest great JJS 42759 1581 6 development development NN 42759 1581 7 in in IN 42759 1581 8 the the DT 42759 1581 9 western western JJ 42759 1581 10 provinces province NNS 42759 1581 11 of of IN 42759 1581 12 Canada Canada NNP 42759 1581 13 ; ; : 42759 1581 14 namely namely RB 42759 1581 15 , , , 42759 1581 16 British British NNP 42759 1581 17 Columbia Columbia NNP 42759 1581 18 , , , 42759 1581 19 Alberta Alberta NNP 42759 1581 20 , , , 42759 1581 21 Saskatchewan Saskatchewan NNP 42759 1581 22 , , , 42759 1581 23 and and CC 42759 1581 24 Manitoba Manitoba NNP 42759 1581 25 . . . 42759 1582 1 The the DT 42759 1582 2 cities city NNS 42759 1582 3 of of IN 42759 1582 4 Edmonton Edmonton NNP 42759 1582 5 , , , 42759 1582 6 Medicine Medicine NNP 42759 1582 7 Hat Hat NNP 42759 1582 8 , , , 42759 1582 9 and and CC 42759 1582 10 Red red JJ 42759 1582 11 Deer Deer NNP 42759 1582 12 ; ; : 42759 1582 13 Vancouver Vancouver NNP 42759 1582 14 , , , 42759 1582 15 Victoria Victoria NNP 42759 1582 16 , , , 42759 1582 17 and and CC 42759 1582 18 thirteen thirteen CD 42759 1582 19 others other NNS 42759 1582 20 of of IN 42759 1582 21 the the DT 42759 1582 22 thirty thirty CD 42759 1582 23 - - HYPH 42759 1582 24 three three CD 42759 1582 25 cities city NNS 42759 1582 26 of of IN 42759 1582 27 British British NNP 42759 1582 28 Columbia Columbia NNP 42759 1582 29 ; ; : 42759 1582 30 all all PDT 42759 1582 31 the the DT 42759 1582 32 towns town NNS 42759 1582 33 of of IN 42759 1582 34 Alberta Alberta NNP 42759 1582 35 except except IN 42759 1582 36 two two CD 42759 1582 37 ; ; : 42759 1582 38 all all DT 42759 1582 39 but but IN 42759 1582 40 one one CD 42759 1582 41 of of IN 42759 1582 42 the the DT 42759 1582 43 villages village NNS 42759 1582 44 of of IN 42759 1582 45 Alberta Alberta NNP 42759 1582 46 , , , 42759 1582 47 and and CC 42759 1582 48 one one CD 42759 1582 49 - - HYPH 42759 1582 50 fourth fourth NN 42759 1582 51 of of IN 42759 1582 52 those those DT 42759 1582 53 in in IN 42759 1582 54 Saskatchewan Saskatchewan NNP 42759 1582 55 ; ; : 42759 1582 56 all all PDT 42759 1582 57 the the DT 42759 1582 58 rural rural JJ 42759 1582 59 municipalities municipality NNS 42759 1582 60 and and CC 42759 1582 61 local local JJ 42759 1582 62 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1582 63 districts district NNS 42759 1582 64 in in IN 42759 1582 65 Alberta Alberta NNP 42759 1582 66 , , , 42759 1582 67 Manitoba Manitoba NNP 42759 1582 68 , , , 42759 1582 69 and and CC 42759 1582 70 Saskatchewan Saskatchewan NNP 42759 1582 71 , , , 42759 1582 72 and and CC 42759 1582 73 24 24 CD 42759 1582 74 of of IN 42759 1582 75 the the DT 42759 1582 76 28 28 CD 42759 1582 77 in in IN 42759 1582 78 British British NNP 42759 1582 79 Columbia,--exempt Columbia,--exempt NNP 42759 1582 80 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1582 81 entirely entirely RB 42759 1582 82 from from IN 42759 1582 83 taxation taxation NN 42759 1582 84 . . . 42759 1583 1 The the DT 42759 1583 2 three three CD 42759 1583 3 cities city NNS 42759 1583 4 in in IN 42759 1583 5 Alberta Alberta NNP 42759 1583 6 which which WDT 42759 1583 7 retain retain VBP 42759 1583 8 some some DT 42759 1583 9 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1583 10 on on IN 42759 1583 11 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1583 12 ; ; : 42759 1583 13 all all PDT 42759 1583 14 the the DT 42759 1583 15 cities city NNS 42759 1583 16 and and CC 42759 1583 17 towns town NNS 42759 1583 18 and and CC 42759 1583 19 three three CD 42759 1583 20 - - HYPH 42759 1583 21 fourths fourth NNS 42759 1583 22 of of IN 42759 1583 23 the the DT 42759 1583 24 villages village NNS 42759 1583 25 in in IN 42759 1583 26 Saskatchewan Saskatchewan NNP 42759 1583 27 ; ; : 42759 1583 28 the the DT 42759 1583 29 four four CD 42759 1583 30 largest large JJS 42759 1583 31 cities city NNS 42759 1583 32 in in IN 42759 1583 33 Manitoba Manitoba NNP 42759 1583 34 ; ; : 42759 1583 35 and and CC 42759 1583 36 a a DT 42759 1583 37 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1583 38 number number NN 42759 1583 39 of of IN 42759 1583 40 the the DT 42759 1583 41 municipalities municipality NNS 42759 1583 42 in in IN 42759 1583 43 Ontario Ontario NNP 42759 1583 44 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1583 45 by by IN 42759 1583 46 the the DT 42759 1583 47 device device NN 42759 1583 48 of of IN 42759 1583 49 illegal illegal JJ 42759 1583 50 under under NN 42759 1583 51 - - HYPH 42759 1583 52 assessment assessment NN 42759 1583 53 in in IN 42759 1583 54 this this DT 42759 1583 55 instance),--tax instance),--tax JJ 42759 1583 56 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1583 57 at at IN 42759 1583 58 less less JJR 42759 1583 59 than than IN 42759 1583 60 full full JJ 42759 1583 61 value value NN 42759 1583 62 , , , 42759 1583 63 in in IN 42759 1583 64 some some DT 42759 1583 65 cases case NNS 42759 1583 66 as as RB 42759 1583 67 low low JJ 42759 1583 68 as as IN 42759 1583 69 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 1583 70 per per IN 42759 1583 71 cent cent NN 42759 1583 72 . . . 42759 1584 1 Land land NN 42759 1584 2 is be VBZ 42759 1584 3 invariably invariably RB 42759 1584 4 assessed assess VBN 42759 1584 5 at at IN 42759 1584 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1584 7 full full JJ 42759 1584 8 value value NN 42759 1584 9 . . . 42759 1585 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1585 2 is be VBZ 42759 1585 3 to to TO 42759 1585 4 be be VB 42759 1585 5 observed observe VBN 42759 1585 6 that that IN 42759 1585 7 these these DT 42759 1585 8 special special JJ 42759 1585 9 land land NN 42759 1585 10 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1585 11 provide provide VBP 42759 1585 12 only only RB 42759 1585 13 local local JJ 42759 1585 14 revenues revenue NNS 42759 1585 15 ; ; : 42759 1585 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1585 17 do do VBP 42759 1585 18 not not RB 42759 1585 19 contribute contribute VB 42759 1585 20 anything anything NN 42759 1585 21 to to IN 42759 1585 22 the the DT 42759 1585 23 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 1585 24 of of IN 42759 1585 25 either either CC 42759 1585 26 the the DT 42759 1585 27 provincial provincial NN 42759 1585 28 or or CC 42759 1585 29 the the DT 42759 1585 30 dominion dominion NN 42759 1585 31 governments government NNS 42759 1585 32 . . . 42759 1586 1 The the DT 42759 1586 2 reason reason NN 42759 1586 3 why why WRB 42759 1586 4 the the DT 42759 1586 5 local local JJ 42759 1586 6 jurisdictions jurisdiction NNS 42759 1586 7 have have VBP 42759 1586 8 adopted adopt VBN 42759 1586 9 these these DT 42759 1586 10 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1586 11 so so RB 42759 1586 12 much much RB 42759 1586 13 more more RBR 42759 1586 14 extensively extensively RB 42759 1586 15 in in IN 42759 1586 16 Alberta Alberta NNP 42759 1586 17 than than IN 42759 1586 18 in in IN 42759 1586 19 the the DT 42759 1586 20 other other JJ 42759 1586 21 provinces province NNS 42759 1586 22 is be VBZ 42759 1586 23 to to TO 42759 1586 24 be be VB 42759 1586 25 found find VBN 42759 1586 26 in in IN 42759 1586 27 a a DT 42759 1586 28 provincial provincial JJ 42759 1586 29 law law NN 42759 1586 30 enacted enact VBN 42759 1586 31 in in IN 42759 1586 32 1912 1912 CD 42759 1586 33 , , , 42759 1586 34 which which WDT 42759 1586 35 requires require VBZ 42759 1586 36 all all DT 42759 1586 37 towns town NNS 42759 1586 38 , , , 42759 1586 39 villages village NNS 42759 1586 40 , , , 42759 1586 41 and and CC 42759 1586 42 rural rural JJ 42759 1586 43 areas area NNS 42759 1586 44 to to TO 42759 1586 45 establish establish VB 42759 1586 46 within within IN 42759 1586 47 seven seven CD 42759 1586 48 years year NNS 42759 1586 49 the the DT 42759 1586 50 practice practice NN 42759 1586 51 of of IN 42759 1586 52 exempting exempt VBG 42759 1586 53 from from IN 42759 1586 54 taxation taxation NN 42759 1586 55 personal personal JJ 42759 1586 56 property property NN 42759 1586 57 and and CC 42759 1586 58 buildings building NNS 42759 1586 59 . . . 42759 1587 1 Saskatchewan Saskatchewan NNP 42759 1587 2 permits permit VBZ 42759 1587 3 cities city NNS 42759 1587 4 and and CC 42759 1587 5 towns town NNS 42759 1587 6 to to IN 42759 1587 7 tax tax NN 42759 1587 8 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1587 9 up up IN 42759 1587 10 to to TO 42759 1587 11 sixty sixty CD 42759 1587 12 per per IN 42759 1587 13 cent cent NN 42759 1587 14 . . . 42759 1588 1 of of IN 42759 1588 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1588 3 value value NN 42759 1588 4 , , , 42759 1588 5 while while IN 42759 1588 6 British British NNP 42759 1588 7 Columbia Columbia NNP 42759 1588 8 and and CC 42759 1588 9 Manitoba Manitoba NNP 42759 1588 10 leave leave VBP 42759 1588 11 the the DT 42759 1588 12 matter matter NN 42759 1588 13 entirely entirely RB 42759 1588 14 in in IN 42759 1588 15 the the DT 42759 1588 16 hands hand NNS 42759 1588 17 of of IN 42759 1588 18 the the DT 42759 1588 19 local local JJ 42759 1588 20 authorities authority NNS 42759 1588 21 . . . 42759 1589 1 The the DT 42759 1589 2 provincial provincial JJ 42759 1589 3 revenues revenue NNS 42759 1589 4 are be VBP 42759 1589 5 derived derive VBN 42759 1589 6 from from IN 42759 1589 7 many many JJ 42759 1589 8 sources source NNS 42759 1589 9 , , , 42759 1589 10 chiefly chiefly RB 42759 1589 11 real real JJ 42759 1589 12 estate estate NN 42759 1589 13 , , , 42759 1589 14 personal personal JJ 42759 1589 15 property property NN 42759 1589 16 , , , 42759 1589 17 and and CC 42759 1589 18 incomes income NNS 42759 1589 19 ; ; : 42759 1589 20 but but CC 42759 1589 21 British British NNP 42759 1589 22 Columbia Columbia NNP 42759 1589 23 , , , 42759 1589 24 Saskatchewan Saskatchewan NNP 42759 1589 25 , , , 42759 1589 26 and and CC 42759 1589 27 Alberta Alberta NNP 42759 1589 28 levy levy VBP 42759 1589 29 a a DT 42759 1589 30 special special JJ 42759 1589 31 tax tax NN 42759 1589 32 on on IN 42759 1589 33 unimproved unimproved JJ 42759 1589 34 and and CC 42759 1589 35 only only RB 42759 1589 36 slightly slightly RB 42759 1589 37 improved improve VBN 42759 1589 38 rural rural JJ 42759 1589 39 land land NN 42759 1589 40 . . . 42759 1590 1 The the DT 42759 1590 2 rate rate NN 42759 1590 3 of of IN 42759 1590 4 this this DT 42759 1590 5 " " `` 42759 1590 6 wild wild JJ 42759 1590 7 lands land NNS 42759 1590 8 tax tax NN 42759 1590 9 " " '' 42759 1590 10 is be VBZ 42759 1590 11 in in IN 42759 1590 12 British British NNP 42759 1590 13 Columbia Columbia NNP 42759 1590 14 four four CD 42759 1590 15 per per IN 42759 1590 16 cent cent NN 42759 1590 17 . . . 42759 1590 18 , , , 42759 1590 19 and and CC 42759 1590 20 in in IN 42759 1590 21 the the DT 42759 1590 22 other other JJ 42759 1590 23 two two CD 42759 1590 24 provinces province NNS 42759 1590 25 one one CD 42759 1590 26 per per IN 42759 1590 27 cent cent NN 42759 1590 28 . . . 42759 1591 1 Some some DT 42759 1591 2 of of IN 42759 1591 3 the the DT 42759 1591 4 municipalities municipality NNS 42759 1591 5 of of IN 42759 1591 6 British British NNP 42759 1591 7 Columbia Columbia NNP 42759 1591 8 and and CC 42759 1591 9 Saskatchewan Saskatchewan NNP 42759 1591 10 also also RB 42759 1591 11 impose impose VBP 42759 1591 12 a a DT 42759 1591 13 " " `` 42759 1591 14 wild wild JJ 42759 1591 15 lands land NNS 42759 1591 16 tax tax NN 42759 1591 17 . . . 42759 1591 18 " " '' 42759 1592 1 By by IN 42759 1592 2 a a DT 42759 1592 3 law law NN 42759 1592 4 passed pass VBN 42759 1592 5 in in IN 42759 1592 6 1913 1913 CD 42759 1592 7 Alberta Alberta NNP 42759 1592 8 levies levy VBZ 42759 1592 9 a a DT 42759 1592 10 provincial provincial JJ 42759 1592 11 tax tax NN 42759 1592 12 of of IN 42759 1592 13 five five CD 42759 1592 14 per per NN 42759 1592 15 cent cent NN 42759 1592 16 . . . 42759 1593 1 on on IN 42759 1593 2 the the DT 42759 1593 3 value value NN 42759 1593 4 increases increase NNS 42759 1593 5 of of IN 42759 1593 6 non non JJ 42759 1593 7 - - JJ 42759 1593 8 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1593 9 lands land NNS 42759 1593 10 . . . 42759 1594 1 A a DT 42759 1594 2 movement movement NN 42759 1594 3 for for IN 42759 1594 4 the the DT 42759 1594 5 reduction reduction NN 42759 1594 6 of of IN 42759 1594 7 the the DT 42759 1594 8 tax tax NN 42759 1594 9 on on IN 42759 1594 10 buildings building NNS 42759 1594 11 has have VBZ 42759 1594 12 developed develop VBN 42759 1594 13 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1594 14 strength strength NN 42759 1594 15 in in IN 42759 1594 16 the the DT 42759 1594 17 eastern eastern JJ 42759 1594 18 provinces province NNS 42759 1594 19 of of IN 42759 1594 20 Ontario Ontario NNP 42759 1594 21 , , , 42759 1594 22 Nova Nova NNP 42759 1594 23 Scotia Scotia NNP 42759 1594 24 , , , 42759 1594 25 and and CC 42759 1594 26 New New NNP 42759 1594 27 Brunswick Brunswick NNP 42759 1594 28 . . . 42759 1595 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1595 2 98 98 CD 42759 1595 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1595 4 New New NNP 42759 1595 5 Zealand Zealand NNP 42759 1595 6 and and CC 42759 1595 7 most most JJS 42759 1595 8 of of IN 42759 1595 9 the the DT 42759 1595 10 states state NNS 42759 1595 11 of of IN 42759 1595 12 Australia Australia NNP 42759 1595 13 have have VBP 42759 1595 14 for for IN 42759 1595 15 several several JJ 42759 1595 16 years year NNS 42759 1595 17 levied levy VBD 42759 1595 18 special special JJ 42759 1595 19 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1595 20 on on IN 42759 1595 21 land land NN 42759 1595 22 , , , 42759 1595 23 consisting consist VBG 42759 1595 24 mainly mainly RB 42759 1595 25 of of IN 42759 1595 26 general general JJ 42759 1595 27 rates rate NNS 42759 1595 28 on on IN 42759 1595 29 estates estate NNS 42759 1595 30 of of IN 42759 1595 31 moderate moderate JJ 42759 1595 32 size size NN 42759 1595 33 , , , 42759 1595 34 and and CC 42759 1595 35 a a DT 42759 1595 36 progressive progressive JJ 42759 1595 37 super super JJ 42759 1595 38 tax tax NN 42759 1595 39 on on IN 42759 1595 40 large large JJ 42759 1595 41 estates estate NNS 42759 1595 42 . . . 42759 1596 1 The the DT 42759 1596 2 Commonwealth Commonwealth NNP 42759 1596 3 of of IN 42759 1596 4 Australia Australia NNP 42759 1596 5 also also RB 42759 1596 6 imposes impose VBZ 42759 1596 7 a a DT 42759 1596 8 tax tax NN 42759 1596 9 of of IN 42759 1596 10 one one CD 42759 1596 11 penny penny NN 42759 1596 12 in in IN 42759 1596 13 the the DT 42759 1596 14 pound pound NN 42759 1596 15 on on IN 42759 1596 16 the the DT 42759 1596 17 value value NN 42759 1596 18 of of IN 42759 1596 19 land land NN 42759 1596 20 . . . 42759 1597 1 A a DT 42759 1597 2 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1597 3 proportion proportion NN 42759 1597 4 of of IN 42759 1597 5 the the DT 42759 1597 6 cities city NNS 42759 1597 7 and and CC 42759 1597 8 towns town NNS 42759 1597 9 in in IN 42759 1597 10 both both DT 42759 1597 11 New New NNP 42759 1597 12 Zealand Zealand NNP 42759 1597 13 and and CC 42759 1597 14 Australia Australia NNP 42759 1597 15 derive derive VBP 42759 1597 16 practically practically RB 42759 1597 17 all all PDT 42759 1597 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1597 19 revenues revenue NNS 42759 1597 20 from from IN 42759 1597 21 land land NN 42759 1597 22 , , , 42759 1597 23 exempting exempt VBG 42759 1597 24 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1597 25 entirely entirely RB 42759 1597 26 . . . 42759 1598 1 In in IN 42759 1598 2 both both DT 42759 1598 3 countries country NNS 42759 1598 4 , , , 42759 1598 5 however however RB 42759 1598 6 , , , 42759 1598 7 the the DT 42759 1598 8 bulk bulk NN 42759 1598 9 of of IN 42759 1598 10 the the DT 42759 1598 11 total total JJ 42759 1598 12 revenue revenue NN 42759 1598 13 is be VBZ 42759 1598 14 obtained obtain VBN 42759 1598 15 from from IN 42759 1598 16 other other JJ 42759 1598 17 sources source NNS 42759 1598 18 than than IN 42759 1598 19 land land NN 42759 1598 20 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1598 21 . . . 42759 1599 1 In in IN 42759 1599 2 New New NNP 42759 1599 3 Zealand Zealand NNP 42759 1599 4 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1599 5 yield yield VBP 42759 1599 6 less less JJR 42759 1599 7 than than IN 42759 1599 8 thirteen thirteen CD 42759 1599 9 per per IN 42759 1599 10 cent cent NN 42759 1599 11 . . . 42759 1600 1 of of IN 42759 1600 2 the the DT 42759 1600 3 national national JJ 42759 1600 4 receipts receipt NNS 42759 1600 5 . . . 42759 1601 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1601 2 99 99 CD 42759 1601 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1601 4 Pittsburgh Pittsburgh NNP 42759 1601 5 and and CC 42759 1601 6 Scranton Scranton NNP 42759 1601 7 were be VBD 42759 1601 8 required require VBN 42759 1601 9 by by IN 42759 1601 10 a a DT 42759 1601 11 law law NN 42759 1601 12 enacted enact VBN 42759 1601 13 in in IN 42759 1601 14 1913 1913 CD 42759 1601 15 to to TO 42759 1601 16 reduce reduce VB 42759 1601 17 the the DT 42759 1601 18 local local JJ 42759 1601 19 tax tax NN 42759 1601 20 rate rate NN 42759 1601 21 on on IN 42759 1601 22 buildings building NNS 42759 1601 23 at at IN 42759 1601 24 such such PDT 42759 1601 25 a a DT 42759 1601 26 pace pace NN 42759 1601 27 that that WDT 42759 1601 28 in in IN 42759 1601 29 1925 1925 CD 42759 1601 30 and and CC 42759 1601 31 thereafter thereafter RB 42759 1601 32 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1601 33 would would MD 42759 1601 34 be be VB 42759 1601 35 only only RB 42759 1601 36 one one CD 42759 1601 37 - - HYPH 42759 1601 38 half half NN 42759 1601 39 the the DT 42759 1601 40 highest high JJS 42759 1601 41 rate rate NN 42759 1601 42 on on IN 42759 1601 43 other other JJ 42759 1601 44 forms form NNS 42759 1601 45 of of IN 42759 1601 46 property property NN 42759 1601 47 . . . 42759 1602 1 Everett Everett NNP 42759 1602 2 , , , 42759 1602 3 Wash. Washington NNP 42759 1602 4 , , , 42759 1602 5 and and CC 42759 1602 6 Pueblo Pueblo NNP 42759 1602 7 , , , 42759 1602 8 Col Col NNP 42759 1602 9 . . NNP 42759 1602 10 , , , 42759 1602 11 within within IN 42759 1602 12 recent recent JJ 42759 1602 13 years year NNS 42759 1602 14 adopted adopt VBN 42759 1602 15 by by IN 42759 1602 16 popular popular JJ 42759 1602 17 vote vote NN 42759 1602 18 more more RBR 42759 1602 19 sweeping sweeping JJ 42759 1602 20 measures measure NNS 42759 1602 21 of of IN 42759 1602 22 the the DT 42759 1602 23 same same JJ 42759 1602 24 character character NN 42759 1602 25 , , , 42759 1602 26 but but CC 42759 1602 27 the the DT 42759 1602 28 Everett Everett NNP 42759 1602 29 law law NN 42759 1602 30 has have VBZ 42759 1602 31 never never RB 42759 1602 32 gone go VBN 42759 1602 33 into into IN 42759 1602 34 effect effect NN 42759 1602 35 , , , 42759 1602 36 and and CC 42759 1602 37 the the DT 42759 1602 38 Pueblo Pueblo NNP 42759 1602 39 statute statute NN 42759 1602 40 was be VBD 42759 1602 41 repealed repeal VBN 42759 1602 42 two two CD 42759 1602 43 years year NNS 42759 1602 44 after after IN 42759 1602 45 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1602 46 had have VBD 42759 1602 47 been be VBN 42759 1602 48 passed pass VBN 42759 1602 49 . . . 42759 1603 1 In in IN 42759 1603 2 many many JJ 42759 1603 3 cities city NNS 42759 1603 4 of of IN 42759 1603 5 the the DT 42759 1603 6 United United NNP 42759 1603 7 States States NNP 42759 1603 8 , , , 42759 1603 9 buildings building NNS 42759 1603 10 are be VBP 42759 1603 11 undervalued undervalue VBN 42759 1603 12 relatively relatively RB 42759 1603 13 to to IN 42759 1603 14 land land NN 42759 1603 15 by by IN 42759 1603 16 the the DT 42759 1603 17 informal informal JJ 42759 1603 18 and and CC 42759 1603 19 illegal illegal JJ 42759 1603 20 action action NN 42759 1603 21 of of IN 42759 1603 22 assessors assessor NNS 42759 1603 23 . . . 42759 1604 1 The the DT 42759 1604 2 most most RBS 42759 1604 3 pronounced pronounced JJ 42759 1604 4 and and CC 42759 1604 5 best good JJS 42759 1604 6 known know VBN 42759 1604 7 instance instance NN 42759 1604 8 of of IN 42759 1604 9 this this DT 42759 1604 10 kind kind NN 42759 1604 11 is be VBZ 42759 1604 12 Houston Houston NNP 42759 1604 13 , , , 42759 1604 14 Texas Texas NNP 42759 1604 15 , , , 42759 1604 16 where where WRB 42759 1604 17 in in IN 42759 1604 18 1914 1914 CD 42759 1604 19 land land NN 42759 1604 20 was be VBD 42759 1604 21 assessed assess VBN 42759 1604 22 at at IN 42759 1604 23 seventy seventy CD 42759 1604 24 per per NN 42759 1604 25 cent cent NN 42759 1604 26 . . . 42759 1605 1 of of IN 42759 1605 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1605 3 value value NN 42759 1605 4 and and CC 42759 1605 5 buildings building NNS 42759 1605 6 at at IN 42759 1605 7 only only RB 42759 1605 8 twenty twenty CD 42759 1605 9 - - HYPH 42759 1605 10 five five CD 42759 1605 11 per per IN 42759 1605 12 cent cent NN 42759 1605 13 . . . 42759 1606 1 In in IN 42759 1606 2 1915 1915 CD 42759 1606 3 , , , 42759 1606 4 however however RB 42759 1606 5 , , , 42759 1606 6 the the DT 42759 1606 7 practice practice NN 42759 1606 8 was be VBD 42759 1606 9 forbidden forbid VBN 42759 1606 10 by by IN 42759 1606 11 the the DT 42759 1606 12 courts court NNS 42759 1606 13 as as IN 42759 1606 14 contrary contrary RB 42759 1606 15 to to IN 42759 1606 16 the the DT 42759 1606 17 Texas Texas NNP 42759 1606 18 constitution constitution NN 42759 1606 19 . . . 42759 1607 1 At at IN 42759 1607 2 more more JJR 42759 1607 3 than than IN 42759 1607 4 one one CD 42759 1607 5 recent recent JJ 42759 1607 6 session session NN 42759 1607 7 of of IN 42759 1607 8 the the DT 42759 1607 9 New New NNP 42759 1607 10 York York NNP 42759 1607 11 legislature legislature NN 42759 1607 12 , , , 42759 1607 13 bills bill NNS 42759 1607 14 have have VBP 42759 1607 15 been be VBN 42759 1607 16 introduced introduce VBN 42759 1607 17 providing provide VBG 42759 1607 18 for for IN 42759 1607 19 the the DT 42759 1607 20 gradual gradual JJ 42759 1607 21 reduction reduction NN 42759 1607 22 of of IN 42759 1607 23 the the DT 42759 1607 24 tax tax NN 42759 1607 25 on on IN 42759 1607 26 buildings building NNS 42759 1607 27 in in IN 42759 1607 28 New New NNP 42759 1607 29 York York NNP 42759 1607 30 City City NNP 42759 1607 31 to to IN 42759 1607 32 a a DT 42759 1607 33 basis basis NN 42759 1607 34 of of IN 42759 1607 35 fifty fifty CD 42759 1607 36 per per IN 42759 1607 37 cent cent NN 42759 1607 38 . . . 42759 1608 1 of of IN 42759 1608 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1608 3 value value NN 42759 1608 4 . . . 42759 1609 1 While while IN 42759 1609 2 none none NN 42759 1609 3 of of IN 42759 1609 4 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1609 5 has have VBZ 42759 1609 6 been be VBN 42759 1609 7 passed pass VBN 42759 1609 8 , , , 42759 1609 9 the the DT 42759 1609 10 sentiment sentiment NN 42759 1609 11 in in IN 42759 1609 12 favour favour NN 42759 1609 13 of of IN 42759 1609 14 some some DT 42759 1609 15 such such JJ 42759 1609 16 measure measure NN 42759 1609 17 is be VBZ 42759 1609 18 probably probably RB 42759 1609 19 increasing increase VBG 42759 1609 20 . . . 42759 1610 1 A a DT 42759 1610 2 similar similar JJ 42759 1610 3 movement movement NN 42759 1610 4 of of IN 42759 1610 5 opinion opinion NN 42759 1610 6 is be VBZ 42759 1610 7 apparent apparent JJ 42759 1610 8 in in IN 42759 1610 9 many many JJ 42759 1610 10 other other JJ 42759 1610 11 sections section NNS 42759 1610 12 of of IN 42759 1610 13 the the DT 42759 1610 14 country country NN 42759 1610 15 . . . 42759 1611 1 On on IN 42759 1611 2 the the DT 42759 1611 3 whole whole NN 42759 1611 4 , , , 42759 1611 5 the the DT 42759 1611 6 special special JJ 42759 1611 7 land land NN 42759 1611 8 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1611 9 of of IN 42759 1611 10 Canada Canada NNP 42759 1611 11 and and CC 42759 1611 12 Australasia Australasia NNP 42759 1611 13 are be VBP 42759 1611 14 not not RB 42759 1611 15 remarkably remarkably RB 42759 1611 16 high high JJ 42759 1611 17 . . . 42759 1612 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 1612 2 seem seem VBP 42759 1612 3 to to TO 42759 1612 4 be be VB 42759 1612 5 as as RB 42759 1612 6 low low JJ 42759 1612 7 or or CC 42759 1612 8 lower low JJR 42759 1612 9 than than IN 42759 1612 10 the the DT 42759 1612 11 average average JJ 42759 1612 12 rates rate NNS 42759 1612 13 imposed impose VBN 42759 1612 14 on on IN 42759 1612 15 land land NN 42759 1612 16 , , , 42759 1612 17 as as RB 42759 1612 18 well well RB 42759 1612 19 as as IN 42759 1612 20 on on IN 42759 1612 21 other other JJ 42759 1612 22 forms form NNS 42759 1612 23 of of IN 42759 1612 24 general general JJ 42759 1612 25 property property NN 42759 1612 26 , , , 42759 1612 27 in in IN 42759 1612 28 the the DT 42759 1612 29 United United NNP 42759 1612 30 States States NNP 42759 1612 31 . . . 42759 1613 1 In in IN 42759 1613 2 the the DT 42759 1613 3 provinces province NNS 42759 1613 4 , , , 42759 1613 5 the the DT 42759 1613 6 special special JJ 42759 1613 7 land land NN 42759 1613 8 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1613 9 provide provide VBP 42759 1613 10 only only RB 42759 1613 11 a a DT 42759 1613 12 small small JJ 42759 1613 13 portion portion NN 42759 1613 14 of of IN 42759 1613 15 the the DT 42759 1613 16 total total JJ 42759 1613 17 revenues revenue NNS 42759 1613 18 ; ; : 42759 1613 19 in in IN 42759 1613 20 the the DT 42759 1613 21 cities city NNS 42759 1613 22 and and CC 42759 1613 23 towns town NNS 42759 1613 24 , , , 42759 1613 25 there there EX 42759 1613 26 are be VBP 42759 1613 27 , , , 42759 1613 28 as as IN 42759 1613 29 a a DT 42759 1613 30 rule rule NN 42759 1613 31 , , , 42759 1613 32 other other JJ 42759 1613 33 sources source NNS 42759 1613 34 of of IN 42759 1613 35 revenue revenue NN 42759 1613 36 as as RB 42759 1613 37 well well RB 42759 1613 38 as as IN 42759 1613 39 land land NN 42759 1613 40 , , , 42759 1613 41 and and CC 42759 1613 42 the the DT 42759 1613 43 expenses expense NNS 42759 1613 44 of of IN 42759 1613 45 municipal municipal JJ 42759 1613 46 government government NN 42759 1613 47 are be VBP 42759 1613 48 probably probably RB 42759 1613 49 not not RB 42759 1613 50 as as RB 42759 1613 51 high high JJ 42759 1613 52 as as IN 42759 1613 53 in in IN 42759 1613 54 this this DT 42759 1613 55 country country NN 42759 1613 56 . . . 42759 1614 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1614 2 the the DT 42759 1614 3 land land NN 42759 1614 4 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1614 5 of of IN 42759 1614 6 Canada Canada NNP 42759 1614 7 have have VBP 42759 1614 8 not not RB 42759 1614 9 reached reach VBN 42759 1614 10 an an DT 42759 1614 11 abnormally abnormally RB 42759 1614 12 high high JJ 42759 1614 13 level level NN 42759 1614 14 , , , 42759 1614 15 and and CC 42759 1614 16 are be VBP 42759 1614 17 probably probably RB 42759 1614 18 lower low JJR 42759 1614 19 than than IN 42759 1614 20 most most JJS 42759 1614 21 persons person NNS 42759 1614 22 who who WP 42759 1614 23 have have VBP 42759 1614 24 heard hear VBN 42759 1614 25 of of IN 42759 1614 26 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1614 27 would would MD 42759 1614 28 be be VB 42759 1614 29 inclined incline VBN 42759 1614 30 to to TO 42759 1614 31 expect expect VB 42759 1614 32 . . . 42759 1615 1 The the DT 42759 1615 2 chief chief JJ 42759 1615 3 exceptions exception NNS 42759 1615 4 to to IN 42759 1615 5 the the DT 42759 1615 6 foregoing foregoing NN 42759 1615 7 statements statement NNS 42759 1615 8 are be VBP 42759 1615 9 to to TO 42759 1615 10 be be VB 42759 1615 11 found find VBN 42759 1615 12 in in IN 42759 1615 13 the the DT 42759 1615 14 " " `` 42759 1615 15 wild wild JJ 42759 1615 16 lands land NNS 42759 1615 17 tax tax NN 42759 1615 18 " " '' 42759 1615 19 of of IN 42759 1615 20 British British NNP 42759 1615 21 Columbia Columbia NNP 42759 1615 22 , , , 42759 1615 23 and and CC 42759 1615 24 in in IN 42759 1615 25 the the DT 42759 1615 26 land land NN 42759 1615 27 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1615 28 of of IN 42759 1615 29 some some DT 42759 1615 30 of of IN 42759 1615 31 the the DT 42759 1615 32 towns town NNS 42759 1615 33 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1615 34 not not RB 42759 1615 35 the the DT 42759 1615 36 cities city NNS 42759 1615 37 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1615 38 of of IN 42759 1615 39 Alberta Alberta NNP 42759 1615 40 . . . 42759 1616 1 A a DT 42759 1616 2 rate rate NN 42759 1616 3 of of IN 42759 1616 4 four four CD 42759 1616 5 per per NN 42759 1616 6 cent cent NN 42759 1616 7 . . . 42759 1617 1 on on IN 42759 1617 2 unimproved unimproved JJ 42759 1617 3 and and CC 42759 1617 4 slightly slightly RB 42759 1617 5 improved improve VBN 42759 1617 6 rural rural JJ 42759 1617 7 land land NN 42759 1617 8 is be VBZ 42759 1617 9 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 42759 1617 10 in in IN 42759 1617 11 fiscal fiscal JJ 42759 1617 12 annals annal NNS 42759 1617 13 , , , 42759 1617 14 and and CC 42759 1617 15 is be VBZ 42759 1617 16 scarcely scarcely RB 42759 1617 17 warranted warrant VBN 42759 1617 18 by by IN 42759 1617 19 any any DT 42759 1617 20 received received JJ 42759 1617 21 principle principle NN 42759 1617 22 of of IN 42759 1617 23 taxation taxation NN 42759 1617 24 , , , 42759 1617 25 although although IN 42759 1617 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1617 27 may may MD 42759 1617 28 possibly possibly RB 42759 1617 29 be be VB 42759 1617 30 justified justify VBN 42759 1617 31 by by IN 42759 1617 32 peculiar peculiar JJ 42759 1617 33 social social JJ 42759 1617 34 and and CC 42759 1617 35 administrative administrative JJ 42759 1617 36 conditions condition NNS 42759 1617 37 in in IN 42759 1617 38 the the DT 42759 1617 39 province province NN 42759 1617 40 of of IN 42759 1617 41 British British NNP 42759 1617 42 Columbia Columbia NNP 42759 1617 43 . . . 42759 1618 1 Some some DT 42759 1618 2 of of IN 42759 1618 3 the the DT 42759 1618 4 smaller small JJR 42759 1618 5 towns town NNS 42759 1618 6 of of IN 42759 1618 7 Alberta Alberta NNP 42759 1618 8 which which WDT 42759 1618 9 adopted adopt VBD 42759 1618 10 the the DT 42759 1618 11 land land NN 42759 1618 12 tax tax NN 42759 1618 13 during during IN 42759 1618 14 the the DT 42759 1618 15 recent recent JJ 42759 1618 16 period period NN 42759 1618 17 of of IN 42759 1618 18 depression depression NN 42759 1618 19 have have VBP 42759 1618 20 been be VBN 42759 1618 21 compelled compel VBN 42759 1618 22 to to TO 42759 1618 23 impose impose VB 42759 1618 24 even even RB 42759 1618 25 higher high JJR 42759 1618 26 rates rate NNS 42759 1618 27 , , , 42759 1618 28 the the DT 42759 1618 29 maximum maximum NN 42759 1618 30 being be VBG 42759 1618 31 reached reach VBN 42759 1618 32 by by IN 42759 1618 33 Castor Castor NNP 42759 1618 34 in in IN 42759 1618 35 1912 1912 CD 42759 1618 36 , , , 42759 1618 37 with with IN 42759 1618 38 a a DT 42759 1618 39 rate rate NN 42759 1618 40 of of IN 42759 1618 41 8 8 CD 42759 1618 42 - - SYM 42759 1618 43 1/2 1/2 CD 42759 1618 44 per per IN 42759 1618 45 cent cent NN 42759 1618 46 . . . 42759 1619 1 As as IN 42759 1619 2 a a DT 42759 1619 3 natural natural JJ 42759 1619 4 consequence consequence NN 42759 1619 5 , , , 42759 1619 6 a a DT 42759 1619 7 large large JJ 42759 1619 8 proportion proportion NN 42759 1619 9 of of IN 42759 1619 10 the the DT 42759 1619 11 land land NN 42759 1619 12 in in IN 42759 1619 13 this this DT 42759 1619 14 town town NN 42759 1619 15 was be VBD 42759 1619 16 surrendered surrender VBN 42759 1619 17 by by IN 42759 1619 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1619 19 owners owner NNS 42759 1619 20 to to IN 42759 1619 21 the the DT 42759 1619 22 municipality municipality NN 42759 1619 23 . . . 42759 1620 1 While while IN 42759 1620 2 this this DT 42759 1620 3 amazing amazing JJ 42759 1620 4 tax tax NN 42759 1620 5 rate rate NN 42759 1620 6 is be VBZ 42759 1620 7 probably probably RB 42759 1620 8 temporary temporary JJ 42759 1620 9 , , , 42759 1620 10 and and CC 42759 1620 11 is be VBZ 42759 1620 12 likely likely JJ 42759 1620 13 to to TO 42759 1620 14 be be VB 42759 1620 15 lowered lower VBN 42759 1620 16 after after IN 42759 1620 17 the the DT 42759 1620 18 return return NN 42759 1620 19 of of IN 42759 1620 20 the the DT 42759 1620 21 average average JJ 42759 1620 22 conditions condition NNS 42759 1620 23 of of IN 42759 1620 24 prosperity prosperity NN 42759 1620 25 , , , 42759 1620 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1620 27 inflicts inflict VBZ 42759 1620 28 unfair unfair JJ 42759 1620 29 hardship hardship NN 42759 1620 30 upon upon IN 42759 1620 31 those those DT 42759 1620 32 owners owner NNS 42759 1620 33 whose whose WP$ 42759 1620 34 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 1620 35 are be VBP 42759 1620 36 such such JJ 42759 1620 37 that that IN 42759 1620 38 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1620 39 must must MD 42759 1620 40 give give VB 42759 1620 41 up up RP 42759 1620 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1620 43 land land NN 42759 1620 44 , , , 42759 1620 45 instead instead RB 42759 1620 46 of of IN 42759 1620 47 awaiting await VBG 42759 1620 48 the the DT 42759 1620 49 hoped hope VBN 42759 1620 50 for for IN 42759 1620 51 decline decline NN 42759 1620 52 in in IN 42759 1620 53 the the DT 42759 1620 54 rate rate NN 42759 1620 55 of of IN 42759 1620 56 taxation taxation NN 42759 1620 57 . . . 42759 1621 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1621 2 The the DT 42759 1621 3 Morality morality NN 42759 1621 4 of of IN 42759 1621 5 the the DT 42759 1621 6 Plan Plan NNP 42759 1621 7 _ _ NNP 42759 1621 8 The the DT 42759 1621 9 losses loss NNS 42759 1621 10 of of IN 42759 1621 11 various various JJ 42759 1621 12 kinds kind NNS 42759 1621 13 that that WDT 42759 1621 14 would would MD 42759 1621 15 result result VB 42759 1621 16 from from IN 42759 1621 17 the the DT 42759 1621 18 transfer transfer NN 42759 1621 19 of of IN 42759 1621 20 other other JJ 42759 1621 21 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1621 22 to to IN 42759 1621 23 land land NN 42759 1621 24 may may MD 42759 1621 25 be be VB 42759 1621 26 thus thus RB 42759 1621 27 summarised summarise VBN 42759 1621 28 . . . 42759 1622 1 Land land NN 42759 1622 2 would would MD 42759 1622 3 depreciate depreciate VB 42759 1622 4 in in IN 42759 1622 5 value value NN 42759 1622 6 by by IN 42759 1622 7 an an DT 42759 1622 8 amount amount NN 42759 1622 9 equal equal JJ 42759 1622 10 to to IN 42759 1622 11 the the DT 42759 1622 12 capitalised capitalise VBN 42759 1622 13 tax tax NN 42759 1622 14 . . . 42759 1623 1 For for IN 42759 1623 2 example example NN 42759 1623 3 ; ; : 42759 1623 4 if if IN 42759 1623 5 the the DT 42759 1623 6 rate rate NN 42759 1623 7 of of IN 42759 1623 8 interest interest NN 42759 1623 9 were be VBD 42759 1623 10 five five CD 42759 1623 11 per per IN 42759 1623 12 cent cent NN 42759 1623 13 . . . 42759 1623 14 , , , 42759 1623 15 an an DT 42759 1623 16 additional additional JJ 42759 1623 17 tax tax NN 42759 1623 18 of of IN 42759 1623 19 one one CD 42759 1623 20 per per IN 42759 1623 21 cent cent NN 42759 1623 22 . . . 42759 1624 1 would would MD 42759 1624 2 reduce reduce VB 42759 1624 3 land land NN 42759 1624 4 worth worth JJ 42759 1624 5 one one CD 42759 1624 6 hundred hundred CD 42759 1624 7 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1624 8 an an DT 42759 1624 9 acre acre NN 42759 1624 10 to to IN 42759 1624 11 eighty eighty CD 42759 1624 12 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1624 13 . . . 42759 1625 1 This this DT 42759 1625 2 decline decline NN 42759 1625 3 might may MD 42759 1625 4 , , , 42759 1625 5 indeed indeed RB 42759 1625 6 , , , 42759 1625 7 be be VB 42759 1625 8 partly partly RB 42759 1625 9 , , , 42759 1625 10 wholly wholly RB 42759 1625 11 , , , 42759 1625 12 or or CC 42759 1625 13 more more JJR 42759 1625 14 than than IN 42759 1625 15 offset offset VBN 42759 1625 16 by by IN 42759 1625 17 a a DT 42759 1625 18 simultaneous simultaneous JJ 42759 1625 19 rise rise NN 42759 1625 20 due due IN 42759 1625 21 to to IN 42759 1625 22 economic economic JJ 42759 1625 23 forces force NNS 42759 1625 24 . . . 42759 1626 1 In in IN 42759 1626 2 any any DT 42759 1626 3 case case NN 42759 1626 4 , , , 42759 1626 5 however however RB 42759 1626 6 , , , 42759 1626 7 the the DT 42759 1626 8 land land NN 42759 1626 9 would would MD 42759 1626 10 be be VB 42759 1626 11 worth worth JJ 42759 1626 12 twenty twenty CD 42759 1626 13 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1626 14 less less JJR 42759 1626 15 than than IN 42759 1626 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1626 17 would would MD 42759 1626 18 have have VB 42759 1626 19 been be VBN 42759 1626 20 worth worth JJ 42759 1626 21 had have VBD 42759 1626 22 the the DT 42759 1626 23 tax tax NN 42759 1626 24 not not RB 42759 1626 25 been be VBN 42759 1626 26 imposed impose VBN 42759 1626 27 . . . 42759 1627 1 For for IN 42759 1627 2 some some DT 42759 1627 3 owners owner NNS 42759 1627 4 this this DT 42759 1627 5 would would MD 42759 1627 6 mean mean VB 42759 1627 7 a a DT 42759 1627 8 positive positive JJ 42759 1627 9 loss loss NN 42759 1627 10 ; ; : 42759 1627 11 for for IN 42759 1627 12 others other NNS 42759 1627 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1627 14 would would MD 42759 1627 15 signify signify VB 42759 1627 16 mere mere JJ 42759 1627 17 failure failure NN 42759 1627 18 to to IN 42759 1627 19 gain gain VB 42759 1627 20 . . . 42759 1628 1 The the DT 42759 1628 2 latter latter JJ 42759 1628 3 would would MD 42759 1628 4 happen happen VB 42759 1628 5 in in IN 42759 1628 6 the the DT 42759 1628 7 case case NN 42759 1628 8 of of IN 42759 1628 9 all all PDT 42759 1628 10 those those DT 42759 1628 11 owners owner NNS 42759 1628 12 who who WP 42759 1628 13 at at IN 42759 1628 14 any any DT 42759 1628 15 time time NN 42759 1628 16 after after IN 42759 1628 17 the the DT 42759 1628 18 imposition imposition NN 42759 1628 19 of of IN 42759 1628 20 the the DT 42759 1628 21 tax tax NN 42759 1628 22 sold sell VBD 42759 1628 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1628 24 land land NN 42759 1628 25 at at IN 42759 1628 26 as as RB 42759 1628 27 high high JJ 42759 1628 28 a a DT 42759 1628 29 price price NN 42759 1628 30 as as IN 42759 1628 31 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1628 32 had have VBD 42759 1628 33 paid pay VBN 42759 1628 34 for for IN 42759 1628 35 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1628 36 . . . 42759 1629 1 Not not RB 42759 1629 2 all all DT 42759 1629 3 of of IN 42759 1629 4 the the DT 42759 1629 5 owners owner NNS 42759 1629 6 whose whose WP$ 42759 1629 7 land land NN 42759 1629 8 was be VBD 42759 1629 9 forced force VBN 42759 1629 10 by by IN 42759 1629 11 the the DT 42759 1629 12 tax tax NN 42759 1629 13 to to IN 42759 1629 14 a a DT 42759 1629 15 figure figure NN 42759 1629 16 below below IN 42759 1629 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1629 18 purchase purchase NN 42759 1629 19 price price NN 42759 1629 20 would would MD 42759 1629 21 suffer suffer VB 42759 1629 22 positive positive JJ 42759 1629 23 loss loss NN 42759 1629 24 ; ; : 42759 1629 25 for for IN 42759 1629 26 the the DT 42759 1629 27 land land NN 42759 1629 28 might may MD 42759 1629 29 subsequently subsequently RB 42759 1629 30 rise rise VB 42759 1629 31 in in IN 42759 1629 32 value value NN 42759 1629 33 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 1629 34 to to TO 42759 1629 35 wipe wipe VB 42759 1629 36 out out RP 42759 1629 37 the the DT 42759 1629 38 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 42759 1629 39 difference difference NN 42759 1629 40 . . . 42759 1630 1 In in IN 42759 1630 2 this this DT 42759 1630 3 respect respect NN 42759 1630 4 a a DT 42759 1630 5 special special JJ 42759 1630 6 tax tax NN 42759 1630 7 on on IN 42759 1630 8 the the DT 42759 1630 9 present present JJ 42759 1630 10 value value NN 42759 1630 11 of of IN 42759 1630 12 land land NN 42759 1630 13 has have VBZ 42759 1630 14 a a DT 42759 1630 15 different different JJ 42759 1630 16 effect effect NN 42759 1630 17 from from IN 42759 1630 18 a a DT 42759 1630 19 tax tax NN 42759 1630 20 that that WDT 42759 1630 21 appropriates appropriate VBZ 42759 1630 22 all all PDT 42759 1630 23 the the DT 42759 1630 24 future future JJ 42759 1630 25 value value NN 42759 1630 26 increases increase NNS 42759 1630 27 . . . 42759 1631 1 Only only RB 42759 1631 2 those those DT 42759 1631 3 owners owner NNS 42759 1631 4 who who WP 42759 1631 5 actually actually RB 42759 1631 6 sold sell VBD 42759 1631 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1631 8 land land NN 42759 1631 9 below below IN 42759 1631 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1631 11 purchase purchase NN 42759 1631 12 price price NN 42759 1631 13 could could MD 42759 1631 14 charge charge VB 42759 1631 15 the the DT 42759 1631 16 former former JJ 42759 1631 17 tax tax NN 42759 1631 18 with with IN 42759 1631 19 inflicting inflict VBG 42759 1631 20 upon upon IN 42759 1631 21 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1631 22 positive positive JJ 42759 1631 23 losses loss NNS 42759 1631 24 . . . 42759 1632 1 In in IN 42759 1632 2 the the DT 42759 1632 3 case case NN 42759 1632 4 of of IN 42759 1632 5 the the DT 42759 1632 6 land land NN 42759 1632 7 exemplified exemplify VBN 42759 1632 8 above above RB 42759 1632 9 , , , 42759 1632 10 the the DT 42759 1632 11 owner owner NN 42759 1632 12 who who WP 42759 1632 13 sold sell VBD 42759 1632 14 at at IN 42759 1632 15 ninety ninety CD 42759 1632 16 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1632 17 per per IN 42759 1632 18 acre acre NN 42759 1632 19 could could MD 42759 1632 20 properly properly RB 42759 1632 21 attribute attribute VB 42759 1632 22 to to IN 42759 1632 23 the the DT 42759 1632 24 tax tax NN 42759 1632 25 a a DT 42759 1632 26 loss loss NN 42759 1632 27 of of IN 42759 1632 28 ten ten CD 42759 1632 29 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1632 30 ; ; : 42759 1632 31 the the DT 42759 1632 32 owner owner NN 42759 1632 33 who who WP 42759 1632 34 sold sell VBD 42759 1632 35 at at IN 42759 1632 36 eighty eighty CD 42759 1632 37 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1632 38 would would MD 42759 1632 39 have have VB 42759 1632 40 a a DT 42759 1632 41 grievance grievance NN 42759 1632 42 amounting amount VBG 42759 1632 43 to to IN 42759 1632 44 twenty twenty CD 42759 1632 45 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1632 46 ; ; : 42759 1632 47 and and CC 42759 1632 48 a a DT 42759 1632 49 loss loss NN 42759 1632 50 would would MD 42759 1632 51 be be VB 42759 1632 52 suffered suffer VBN 42759 1632 53 by by IN 42759 1632 54 any any DT 42759 1632 55 owner owner NN 42759 1632 56 who who WP 42759 1632 57 sold sell VBD 42759 1632 58 for for IN 42759 1632 59 less less JJR 42759 1632 60 than than IN 42759 1632 61 eighty eighty CD 42759 1632 62 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1632 63 . . . 42759 1633 1 In in IN 42759 1633 2 the the DT 42759 1633 3 second second JJ 42759 1633 4 place place NN 42759 1633 5 , , , 42759 1633 6 all all DT 42759 1633 7 owners owner NNS 42759 1633 8 of of IN 42759 1633 9 vacant vacant JJ 42759 1633 10 land land NN 42759 1633 11 who who WP 42759 1633 12 sold sell VBD 42759 1633 13 at at IN 42759 1633 14 a a DT 42759 1633 15 price price NN 42759 1633 16 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 1633 17 to to TO 42759 1633 18 provide provide VB 42759 1633 19 for for IN 42759 1633 20 accumulated accumulate VBN 42759 1633 21 interest interest NN 42759 1633 22 on on IN 42759 1633 23 the the DT 42759 1633 24 purchase purchase NN 42759 1633 25 price price NN 42759 1633 26 , , , 42759 1633 27 could could MD 42759 1633 28 justly justly RB 42759 1633 29 hold hold VB 42759 1633 30 the the DT 42759 1633 31 tax tax NN 42759 1633 32 responsible responsible JJ 42759 1633 33 , , , 42759 1633 34 so so RB 42759 1633 35 long long RB 42759 1633 36 as as IN 42759 1633 37 the the DT 42759 1633 38 deficiency deficiency NN 42759 1633 39 did do VBD 42759 1633 40 not not RB 42759 1633 41 exceed exceed VB 42759 1633 42 the the DT 42759 1633 43 value value NN 42759 1633 44 - - HYPH 42759 1633 45 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 1633 46 caused cause VBN 42759 1633 47 by by IN 42759 1633 48 the the DT 42759 1633 49 tax tax NN 42759 1633 50 . . . 42759 1634 1 Thirdly thirdly RB 42759 1634 2 , , , 42759 1634 3 all all DT 42759 1634 4 persons person NNS 42759 1634 5 whose whose WP$ 42759 1634 6 land land NN 42759 1634 7 had have VBD 42759 1634 8 an an DT 42759 1634 9 unusually unusually RB 42759 1634 10 high high JJ 42759 1634 11 value value NN 42759 1634 12 relatively relatively RB 42759 1634 13 to to IN 42759 1634 14 the the DT 42759 1634 15 value value NN 42759 1634 16 of of IN 42759 1634 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1634 18 exempted exempt VBN 42759 1634 19 property property NN 42759 1634 20 , , , 42759 1634 21 would would MD 42759 1634 22 suffer suffer VB 42759 1634 23 losses loss NNS 42759 1634 24 as as IN 42759 1634 25 taxpayers taxpayer NNS 42759 1634 26 . . . 42759 1635 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 1635 2 would would MD 42759 1635 3 lose lose VB 42759 1635 4 more more JJR 42759 1635 5 through through IN 42759 1635 6 the the DT 42759 1635 7 heavier heavy JJR 42759 1635 8 land land NN 42759 1635 9 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1635 10 than than IN 42759 1635 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1635 12 would would MD 42759 1635 13 gain gain VB 42759 1635 14 through through IN 42759 1635 15 the the DT 42759 1635 16 lighter light JJR 42759 1635 17 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1635 18 , , , 42759 1635 19 or or CC 42759 1635 20 the the DT 42759 1635 21 absence absence NN 42759 1635 22 of of IN 42759 1635 23 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1635 24 , , , 42759 1635 25 on on IN 42759 1635 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1635 27 other other JJ 42759 1635 28 property property NN 42759 1635 29 . . . 42759 1636 1 To to TO 42759 1636 2 compensate compensate VB 42759 1636 3 all all DT 42759 1636 4 owners owner NNS 42759 1636 5 who who WP 42759 1636 6 underwent undergo VBD 42759 1636 7 these these DT 42759 1636 8 three three CD 42759 1636 9 kinds kind NNS 42759 1636 10 of of IN 42759 1636 11 losses loss NNS 42759 1636 12 would would MD 42759 1636 13 be be VB 42759 1636 14 practically practically RB 42759 1636 15 impossible impossible JJ 42759 1636 16 . . . 42759 1637 1 The the DT 42759 1637 2 number number NN 42759 1637 3 of of IN 42759 1637 4 persons person NNS 42759 1637 5 would would MD 42759 1637 6 be be VB 42759 1637 7 too too RB 42759 1637 8 large large JJ 42759 1637 9 , , , 42759 1637 10 the the DT 42759 1637 11 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 1637 12 of of IN 42759 1637 13 proving prove VBG 42759 1637 14 many many JJ 42759 1637 15 of of IN 42759 1637 16 the the DT 42759 1637 17 claims claim NNS 42759 1637 18 would would MD 42759 1637 19 be be VB 42759 1637 20 too too RB 42759 1637 21 expensive expensive JJ 42759 1637 22 , , , 42759 1637 23 and and CC 42759 1637 24 the the DT 42759 1637 25 compensation compensation NN 42759 1637 26 process process NN 42759 1637 27 would would MD 42759 1637 28 be be VB 42759 1637 29 too too RB 42759 1637 30 long long RB 42759 1637 31 drawn draw VBN 42759 1637 32 out out RP 42759 1637 33 , , , 42759 1637 34 since since IN 42759 1637 35 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1637 36 would would MD 42759 1637 37 have have VB 42759 1637 38 to to TO 42759 1637 39 continue continue VB 42759 1637 40 until until IN 42759 1637 41 the the DT 42759 1637 42 death death NN 42759 1637 43 of of IN 42759 1637 44 all all DT 42759 1637 45 persons person NNS 42759 1637 46 who who WP 42759 1637 47 had have VBD 42759 1637 48 owned own VBN 42759 1637 49 land land NN 42759 1637 50 when when WRB 42759 1637 51 the the DT 42759 1637 52 last last JJ 42759 1637 53 instalment instalment NN 42759 1637 54 of of IN 42759 1637 55 the the DT 42759 1637 56 increased increase VBN 42759 1637 57 land land NN 42759 1637 58 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1637 59 went go VBD 42759 1637 60 into into IN 42759 1637 61 effect effect NN 42759 1637 62 . . . 42759 1638 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 1638 2 , , , 42759 1638 3 the the DT 42759 1638 4 losses loss NNS 42759 1638 5 in in IN 42759 1638 6 question question NN 42759 1638 7 must must MD 42759 1638 8 be be VB 42759 1638 9 counterbalanced counterbalance VBN 42759 1638 10 by by IN 42759 1638 11 other other JJ 42759 1638 12 and and CC 42759 1638 13 indirect indirect JJ 42759 1638 14 methods method NNS 42759 1638 15 . . . 42759 1639 1 These these DT 42759 1639 2 will will MD 42759 1639 3 be be VB 42759 1639 4 found find VBN 42759 1639 5 mainly mainly RB 42759 1639 6 in in IN 42759 1639 7 the the DT 42759 1639 8 following follow VBG 42759 1639 9 considerations consideration NNS 42759 1639 10 : : : 42759 1639 11 the the DT 42759 1639 12 amount amount NN 42759 1639 13 of of IN 42759 1639 14 the the DT 42759 1639 15 new new JJ 42759 1639 16 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1639 17 ; ; : 42759 1639 18 the the DT 42759 1639 19 gradual gradual JJ 42759 1639 20 method method NN 42759 1639 21 of of IN 42759 1639 22 imposing impose VBG 42759 1639 23 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1639 24 ; ; : 42759 1639 25 and and CC 42759 1639 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1639 27 socially socially RB 42759 1639 28 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 1639 29 results result NNS 42759 1639 30 . . . 42759 1640 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1640 2 Amount Amount NNP 42759 1640 3 of of IN 42759 1640 4 Taxes Taxes NNP 42759 1640 5 Practically practically RB 42759 1640 6 Transferable transferable JJ 42759 1640 7 _ _ NNP 42759 1640 8 According accord VBG 42759 1640 9 to to IN 42759 1640 10 Professor Professor NNP 42759 1640 11 King King NNP 42759 1640 12 's 's POS 42759 1640 13 computations computation NNS 42759 1640 14 , , , 42759 1640 15 the the DT 42759 1640 16 total total JJ 42759 1640 17 rent rent NN 42759 1640 18 of of IN 42759 1640 19 land land NN 42759 1640 20 in in IN 42759 1640 21 the the DT 42759 1640 22 United United NNP 42759 1640 23 States States NNP 42759 1640 24 in in IN 42759 1640 25 1910 1910 CD 42759 1640 26 was be VBD 42759 1640 27 $ $ $ 42759 1640 28 2,673,900,000 2,673,900,000 CD 42759 1640 29 , , , 42759 1640 30 while while IN 42759 1640 31 the the DT 42759 1640 32 total total JJ 42759 1640 33 expenditures expenditure NNS 42759 1640 34 of of IN 42759 1640 35 national national JJ 42759 1640 36 , , , 42759 1640 37 state state NN 42759 1640 38 , , , 42759 1640 39 county county NN 42759 1640 40 and and CC 42759 1640 41 city city NN 42759 1640 42 governments government NNS 42759 1640 43 were be VBD 42759 1640 44 $ $ $ 42759 1640 45 2,591,800,000 2,591,800,000 CD 42759 1640 46 . . . 42759 1641 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1641 2 100 100 CD 42759 1641 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1641 4 In in IN 42759 1641 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1641 6 opinion opinion NN 42759 1641 7 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1641 8 p. p. NN 42759 1641 9 162 162 CD 42759 1641 10 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1641 11 " " `` 42759 1641 12 the the DT 42759 1641 13 rent rent NN 42759 1641 14 would would MD 42759 1641 15 have have VB 42759 1641 16 been be VBN 42759 1641 17 barely barely RB 42759 1641 18 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 1641 19 to to TO 42759 1641 20 pay pay VB 42759 1641 21 off off RP 42759 1641 22 the the DT 42759 1641 23 various various JJ 42759 1641 24 governmental governmental JJ 42759 1641 25 budgets budget NNS 42759 1641 26 as as IN 42759 1641 27 at at IN 42759 1641 28 present present JJ 42759 1641 29 constituted constituted JJ 42759 1641 30 , , , 42759 1641 31 and and CC 42759 1641 32 with with IN 42759 1641 33 the the DT 42759 1641 34 growing grow VBG 42759 1641 35 concentration concentration NN 42759 1641 36 of of IN 42759 1641 37 activities activity NNS 42759 1641 38 in in IN 42759 1641 39 the the DT 42759 1641 40 hands hand NNS 42759 1641 41 of of IN 42759 1641 42 the the DT 42759 1641 43 government government NN 42759 1641 44 , , , 42759 1641 45 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1641 46 appears appear VBZ 42759 1641 47 that that DT 42759 1641 48 rent rent NN 42759 1641 49 will will MD 42759 1641 50 soon soon RB 42759 1641 51 be be VB 42759 1641 52 a a DT 42759 1641 53 quantity quantity NN 42759 1641 54 far far RB 42759 1641 55 too too RB 42759 1641 56 small small JJ 42759 1641 57 to to TO 42759 1641 58 meet meet VB 42759 1641 59 the the DT 42759 1641 60 required require VBN 42759 1641 61 changes change NNS 42759 1641 62 . . . 42759 1642 1 With with IN 42759 1642 2 increasing increase VBG 42759 1642 3 pressure pressure NN 42759 1642 4 on on IN 42759 1642 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1642 6 natural natural JJ 42759 1642 7 resources resource NNS 42759 1642 8 , , , 42759 1642 9 however however RB 42759 1642 10 , , , 42759 1642 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1642 12 is be VBZ 42759 1642 13 probable probable JJ 42759 1642 14 that that IN 42759 1642 15 the the DT 42759 1642 16 percentage percentage NN 42759 1642 17 of of IN 42759 1642 18 the the DT 42759 1642 19 total total JJ 42759 1642 20 income income NN 42759 1642 21 paid pay VBN 42759 1642 22 for for IN 42759 1642 23 rent rent NN 42759 1642 24 will will MD 42759 1642 25 gradually gradually RB 42759 1642 26 increase increase VB 42759 1642 27 and and CC 42759 1642 28 , , , 42759 1642 29 since since IN 42759 1642 30 this this DT 42759 1642 31 is be VBZ 42759 1642 32 true true JJ 42759 1642 33 , , , 42759 1642 34 the the DT 42759 1642 35 lag lag NN 42759 1642 36 behind behind IN 42759 1642 37 the the DT 42759 1642 38 growing grow VBG 42759 1642 39 governmental governmental JJ 42759 1642 40 expenses expense NNS 42759 1642 41 will will MD 42759 1642 42 be be VB 42759 1642 43 considerably considerably RB 42759 1642 44 less less JJR 42759 1642 45 than than IN 42759 1642 46 would would MD 42759 1642 47 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 1642 48 be be VB 42759 1642 49 the the DT 42759 1642 50 case case NN 42759 1642 51 . . . 42759 1642 52 " " '' 42759 1643 1 A a DT 42759 1643 2 change change NN 42759 1643 3 in in IN 42759 1643 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1643 5 fiscal fiscal JJ 42759 1643 6 system system NN 42759 1643 7 providing provide VBG 42759 1643 8 for for IN 42759 1643 9 the the DT 42759 1643 10 immediate immediate JJ 42759 1643 11 derivation derivation NN 42759 1643 12 of of IN 42759 1643 13 all all DT 42759 1643 14 revenues revenue NNS 42759 1643 15 from from IN 42759 1643 16 land land NN 42759 1643 17 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1643 18 would would MD 42759 1643 19 , , , 42759 1643 20 therefore therefore RB 42759 1643 21 , , , 42759 1643 22 involve involve VBP 42759 1643 23 the the DT 42759 1643 24 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 1643 25 of of IN 42759 1643 26 all all DT 42759 1643 27 rent rent NN 42759 1643 28 , , , 42759 1643 29 and and CC 42759 1643 30 the the DT 42759 1643 31 destruction destruction NN 42759 1643 32 of of IN 42759 1643 33 all all DT 42759 1643 34 private private JJ 42759 1643 35 land land NN 42759 1643 36 values value NNS 42759 1643 37 . . . 42759 1644 1 Land land NN 42759 1644 2 would would MD 42759 1644 3 be be VB 42759 1644 4 worth worth JJ 42759 1644 5 nothing nothing NN 42759 1644 6 to to IN 42759 1644 7 the the DT 42759 1644 8 owners owner NNS 42759 1644 9 when when WRB 42759 1644 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1644 11 entire entire JJ 42759 1644 12 annual annual JJ 42759 1644 13 return return NN 42759 1644 14 was be VBD 42759 1644 15 taken take VBN 42759 1644 16 by by IN 42759 1644 17 the the DT 42759 1644 18 State State NNP 42759 1644 19 in in IN 42759 1644 20 the the DT 42759 1644 21 guise guise NN 42759 1644 22 of of IN 42759 1644 23 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1644 24 . . . 42759 1645 1 Even even RB 42759 1645 2 if if IN 42759 1645 3 the the DT 42759 1645 4 process process NN 42759 1645 5 of of IN 42759 1645 6 imposing impose VBG 42759 1645 7 the the DT 42759 1645 8 new new JJ 42759 1645 9 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1645 10 on on IN 42759 1645 11 land land NN 42759 1645 12 were be VBD 42759 1645 13 extended extend VBN 42759 1645 14 over over IN 42759 1645 15 a a DT 42759 1645 16 long long JJ 42759 1645 17 term term NN 42759 1645 18 of of IN 42759 1645 19 years year NNS 42759 1645 20 the the DT 42759 1645 21 same same JJ 42759 1645 22 result result NN 42759 1645 23 would would MD 42759 1645 24 be be VB 42759 1645 25 reached reach VBN 42759 1645 26 in in IN 42759 1645 27 the the DT 42759 1645 28 end end NN 42759 1645 29 ; ; : 42759 1645 30 for for IN 42759 1645 31 whatever whatever WDT 42759 1645 32 increase increase NN 42759 1645 33 had have VBD 42759 1645 34 taken take VBN 42759 1645 35 place place NN 42759 1645 36 in in IN 42759 1645 37 the the DT 42759 1645 38 economic economic JJ 42759 1645 39 value value NN 42759 1645 40 of of IN 42759 1645 41 land land NN 42759 1645 42 during during IN 42759 1645 43 the the DT 42759 1645 44 process process NN 42759 1645 45 would would MD 42759 1645 46 in in IN 42759 1645 47 all all DT 42759 1645 48 probability probability NN 42759 1645 49 have have VBP 42759 1645 50 been be VBN 42759 1645 51 neutralised neutralise VBN 42759 1645 52 by by IN 42759 1645 53 the the DT 42759 1645 54 increase increase NN 42759 1645 55 in in IN 42759 1645 56 governmental governmental JJ 42759 1645 57 expenditures expenditure NNS 42759 1645 58 . . . 42759 1646 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1646 2 is be VBZ 42759 1646 3 evident evident JJ 42759 1646 4 , , , 42759 1646 5 therefore therefore RB 42759 1646 6 , , , 42759 1646 7 that that IN 42759 1646 8 the the DT 42759 1646 9 proposal proposal NN 42759 1646 10 to to TO 42759 1646 11 put put VB 42759 1646 12 _ _ NNP 42759 1646 13 all all DT 42759 1646 14 _ _ NNP 42759 1646 15 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1646 16 on on IN 42759 1646 17 land land NN 42759 1646 18 must must MD 42759 1646 19 be be VB 42759 1646 20 rejected reject VBN 42759 1646 21 on on IN 42759 1646 22 grounds ground NNS 42759 1646 23 of of IN 42759 1646 24 both both DT 42759 1646 25 morals moral NNS 42759 1646 26 and and CC 42759 1646 27 expediency expediency NN 42759 1646 28 . . . 42759 1647 1 Let let VB 42759 1647 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 1647 3 suppose suppose VB 42759 1647 4 that that IN 42759 1647 5 all all DT 42759 1647 6 national national JJ 42759 1647 7 revenues revenue NNS 42759 1647 8 continued continue VBD 42759 1647 9 , , , 42759 1647 10 as as IN 42759 1647 11 now now RB 42759 1647 12 , , , 42759 1647 13 to to TO 42759 1647 14 be be VB 42759 1647 15 raised raise VBN 42759 1647 16 from from IN 42759 1647 17 other other JJ 42759 1647 18 sources source NNS 42759 1647 19 than than IN 42759 1647 20 land land NN 42759 1647 21 , , , 42759 1647 22 and and CC 42759 1647 23 that that IN 42759 1647 24 all all DT 42759 1647 25 state state NN 42759 1647 26 , , , 42759 1647 27 county county NN 42759 1647 28 , , , 42759 1647 29 and and CC 42759 1647 30 city city NN 42759 1647 31 revenues revenue NNS 42759 1647 32 remained remain VBD 42759 1647 33 as as IN 42759 1647 34 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1647 35 are be VBP 42759 1647 36 , , , 42759 1647 37 except except IN 42759 1647 38 those those DT 42759 1647 39 derived derive VBN 42759 1647 40 from from IN 42759 1647 41 the the DT 42759 1647 42 general general JJ 42759 1647 43 property property NN 42759 1647 44 tax tax NN 42759 1647 45 . . . 42759 1648 1 This this DT 42759 1648 2 would would MD 42759 1648 3 mean mean VB 42759 1648 4 that that IN 42759 1648 5 all all PDT 42759 1648 6 the the DT 42759 1648 7 following follow VBG 42759 1648 8 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1648 9 would would MD 42759 1648 10 be be VB 42759 1648 11 unchanged unchanged JJ 42759 1648 12 : : : 42759 1648 13 all all DT 42759 1648 14 federal federal JJ 42759 1648 15 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1648 16 , , , 42759 1648 17 the the DT 42759 1648 18 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1648 19 on on IN 42759 1648 20 licenses license NNS 42759 1648 21 of of IN 42759 1648 22 all all DT 42759 1648 23 kinds kind NNS 42759 1648 24 , , , 42759 1648 25 all all DT 42759 1648 26 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1648 27 on on IN 42759 1648 28 business business NN 42759 1648 29 , , , 42759 1648 30 incomes income NNS 42759 1648 31 , , , 42759 1648 32 and and CC 42759 1648 33 inheritances inheritance NNS 42759 1648 34 , , , 42759 1648 35 and and CC 42759 1648 36 all all DT 42759 1648 37 special special JJ 42759 1648 38 property property NN 42759 1648 39 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1648 40 . . . 42759 1649 1 If if IN 42759 1649 2 , , , 42759 1649 3 then then RB 42759 1649 4 , , , 42759 1649 5 the the DT 42759 1649 6 whole whole NN 42759 1649 7 of of IN 42759 1649 8 the the DT 42759 1649 9 general general JJ 42759 1649 10 property property NN 42759 1649 11 tax tax NN 42759 1649 12 were be VBD 42759 1649 13 concentrated concentrate VBN 42759 1649 14 on on IN 42759 1649 15 land land NN 42759 1649 16 ; ; : 42759 1649 17 that that RB 42759 1649 18 is is RB 42759 1649 19 , , , 42759 1649 20 if if IN 42759 1649 21 all all PDT 42759 1649 22 the the DT 42759 1649 23 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1649 24 on on IN 42759 1649 25 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1649 26 and and CC 42759 1649 27 on on IN 42759 1649 28 all all DT 42759 1649 29 forms form NNS 42759 1649 30 of of IN 42759 1649 31 personal personal JJ 42759 1649 32 property property NN 42759 1649 33 were be VBD 42759 1649 34 legally legally RB 42759 1649 35 shifted shift VBN 42759 1649 36 to to IN 42759 1649 37 land,--the land,--the DT 42759 1649 38 entire entire JJ 42759 1649 39 revenue revenue NN 42759 1649 40 to to TO 42759 1649 41 be be VB 42759 1649 42 raised raise VBN 42759 1649 43 from from IN 42759 1649 44 land land NN 42759 1649 45 would would MD 42759 1649 46 in in IN 42759 1649 47 1912 1912 CD 42759 1649 48 have have VBP 42759 1649 49 amounted amount VBN 42759 1649 50 to to IN 42759 1649 51 $ $ $ 42759 1649 52 1,349,841,038 1,349,841,038 CD 42759 1649 53 . . . 42759 1650 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1650 2 101 101 CD 42759 1650 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1650 4 This this DT 42759 1650 5 is be VBZ 42759 1650 6 slightly slightly RB 42759 1650 7 more more JJR 42759 1650 8 than than IN 42759 1650 9 one one CD 42759 1650 10 - - HYPH 42759 1650 11 half half NN 42759 1650 12 of of IN 42759 1650 13 Professor Professor NNP 42759 1650 14 King King NNP 42759 1650 15 's 's POS 42759 1650 16 estimate estimate NN 42759 1650 17 of of IN 42759 1650 18 the the DT 42759 1650 19 total total JJ 42759 1650 20 rent rent NN 42759 1650 21 for for IN 42759 1650 22 1910 1910 CD 42759 1650 23 , , , 42759 1650 24 which which WDT 42759 1650 25 was be VBD 42759 1650 26 $ $ $ 42759 1650 27 2,673,900,000 2,673,900,000 CD 42759 1650 28 . . . 42759 1651 1 But but CC 42759 1651 2 this this DT 42759 1651 3 figure figure NN 42759 1651 4 equals equal VBZ 42759 1651 5 four four CD 42759 1651 6 per per IN 42759 1651 7 cent cent NN 42759 1651 8 . . . 42759 1652 1 of of IN 42759 1652 2 the the DT 42759 1652 3 land land NN 42759 1652 4 values value NNS 42759 1652 5 of of IN 42759 1652 6 the the DT 42759 1652 7 country country NN 42759 1652 8 ; ; : 42759 1652 9 hence hence RB 42759 1652 10 the the DT 42759 1652 11 concentration concentration NN 42759 1652 12 of of IN 42759 1652 13 the the DT 42759 1652 14 general general JJ 42759 1652 15 property property NN 42759 1652 16 tax tax NN 42759 1652 17 on on IN 42759 1652 18 land land NN 42759 1652 19 would would MD 42759 1652 20 mean mean VB 42759 1652 21 a a DT 42759 1652 22 tax tax NN 42759 1652 23 rate rate NN 42759 1652 24 of of IN 42759 1652 25 two two CD 42759 1652 26 per per NN 42759 1652 27 cent cent NN 42759 1652 28 . . . 42759 1653 1 on on IN 42759 1653 2 the the DT 42759 1653 3 full full JJ 42759 1653 4 value value NN 42759 1653 5 of of IN 42759 1653 6 the the DT 42759 1653 7 land land NN 42759 1653 8 . . . 42759 1654 1 How how WRB 42759 1654 2 much much JJ 42759 1654 3 would would MD 42759 1654 4 this this DT 42759 1654 5 change change VB 42759 1654 6 increase increase VB 42759 1654 7 the the DT 42759 1654 8 present present JJ 42759 1654 9 rate rate NN 42759 1654 10 of of IN 42759 1654 11 land land NN 42759 1654 12 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1654 13 , , , 42759 1654 14 and and CC 42759 1654 15 decrease decrease VB 42759 1654 16 existing exist VBG 42759 1654 17 land land NN 42759 1654 18 values value NNS 42759 1654 19 ? ? . 42759 1655 1 While while IN 42759 1655 2 no no DT 42759 1655 3 accurate accurate JJ 42759 1655 4 and and CC 42759 1655 5 definite definite JJ 42759 1655 6 answer answer NN 42759 1655 7 can can MD 42759 1655 8 be be VB 42759 1655 9 given give VBN 42759 1655 10 to to IN 42759 1655 11 either either DT 42759 1655 12 of of IN 42759 1655 13 these these DT 42759 1655 14 questions question NNS 42759 1655 15 , , , 42759 1655 16 certain certain JJ 42759 1655 17 approximations approximation NNS 42759 1655 18 can can MD 42759 1655 19 be be VB 42759 1655 20 attempted attempt VBN 42759 1655 21 which which WDT 42759 1655 22 should should MD 42759 1655 23 be be VB 42759 1655 24 of of IN 42759 1655 25 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1655 26 service service NN 42759 1655 27 . . . 42759 1656 1 In in IN 42759 1656 2 1912 1912 CD 42759 1656 3 the the DT 42759 1656 4 average average JJ 42759 1656 5 tax tax NN 42759 1656 6 rate rate NN 42759 1656 7 on on IN 42759 1656 8 the the DT 42759 1656 9 assessed assessed JJ 42759 1656 10 valuation valuation NN 42759 1656 11 of of IN 42759 1656 12 all all DT 42759 1656 13 goods good NNS 42759 1656 14 subject subject JJ 42759 1656 15 to to IN 42759 1656 16 the the DT 42759 1656 17 general general JJ 42759 1656 18 property property NN 42759 1656 19 tax tax NN 42759 1656 20 was be VBD 42759 1656 21 .0194 .0194 NN 42759 1656 22 , , , 42759 1656 23 or or CC 42759 1656 24 $ $ $ 42759 1656 25 19.40 19.40 CD 42759 1656 26 per per IN 42759 1656 27 thousand thousand CD 42759 1656 28 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1656 29 . . . 42759 1657 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1657 2 102 102 CD 42759 1657 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1657 4 The the DT 42759 1657 5 assessed assessed JJ 42759 1657 6 valuation valuation NN 42759 1657 7 of of IN 42759 1657 8 taxed tax VBN 42759 1657 9 real real JJ 42759 1657 10 property property NN 42759 1657 11 and and CC 42759 1657 12 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1657 13 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1657 14 land land NN 42759 1657 15 , , , 42759 1657 16 buildings building NNS 42759 1657 17 , , , 42759 1657 18 and and CC 42759 1657 19 other other JJ 42759 1657 20 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1657 21 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1657 22 was be VBD 42759 1657 23 nearly nearly RB 42759 1657 24 fifty fifty CD 42759 1657 25 - - HYPH 42759 1657 26 two two CD 42759 1657 27 billion billion CD 42759 1657 28 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1657 29 , , , 42759 1657 30 while while IN 42759 1657 31 the the DT 42759 1657 32 true true JJ 42759 1657 33 value value NN 42759 1657 34 of of IN 42759 1657 35 the the DT 42759 1657 36 same same JJ 42759 1657 37 property property NN 42759 1657 38 was be VBD 42759 1657 39 nearly nearly RB 42759 1657 40 ninety ninety CD 42759 1657 41 - - HYPH 42759 1657 42 eight eight CD 42759 1657 43 and and CC 42759 1657 44 one one CD 42759 1657 45 - - HYPH 42759 1657 46 half half NN 42759 1657 47 billions billion NNS 42759 1657 48 . . . 42759 1658 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1658 2 103 103 CD 42759 1658 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1658 4 Consequently consequently RB 42759 1658 5 , , , 42759 1658 6 the the DT 42759 1658 7 actual actual JJ 42759 1658 8 tax tax NN 42759 1658 9 rate rate NN 42759 1658 10 of of IN 42759 1658 11 .0194 .0194 . 42759 1658 12 on on IN 42759 1658 13 the the DT 42759 1658 14 assessed assessed JJ 42759 1658 15 valuation valuation NN 42759 1658 16 was be VBD 42759 1658 17 exactly exactly RB 42759 1658 18 one one CD 42759 1658 19 per per IN 42759 1658 20 cent cent NN 42759 1658 21 . . . 42759 1659 1 on on IN 42759 1659 2 the the DT 42759 1659 3 true true JJ 42759 1659 4 value value NN 42759 1659 5 of of IN 42759 1659 6 real real JJ 42759 1659 7 estate estate NN 42759 1659 8 . . . 42759 1660 1 On on IN 42759 1660 2 the the DT 42759 1660 3 assumption assumption NN 42759 1660 4 that that IN 42759 1660 5 both both DT 42759 1660 6 land land NN 42759 1660 7 and and CC 42759 1660 8 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1660 9 were be VBD 42759 1660 10 undervalued undervalue VBN 42759 1660 11 to to IN 42759 1660 12 the the DT 42759 1660 13 same same JJ 42759 1660 14 extent extent NN 42759 1660 15 , , , 42759 1660 16 the the DT 42759 1660 17 land land NN 42759 1660 18 tax tax NN 42759 1660 19 was be VBD 42759 1660 20 one one CD 42759 1660 21 per per IN 42759 1660 22 cent cent NN 42759 1660 23 . . . 42759 1661 1 of of IN 42759 1661 2 the the DT 42759 1661 3 full full JJ 42759 1661 4 value value NN 42759 1661 5 of of IN 42759 1661 6 the the DT 42759 1661 7 land land NN 42759 1661 8 . . . 42759 1662 1 If if IN 42759 1662 2 now now RB 42759 1662 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1662 4 take take VBP 42759 1662 5 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 1662 6 G. G. NNP 42759 1662 7 Shearman Shearman NNP 42759 1662 8 's 's POS 42759 1662 9 estimate estimate NN 42759 1662 10 , , , 42759 1662 11 that that IN 42759 1662 12 land land NN 42759 1662 13 values value NNS 42759 1662 14 form form VBP 42759 1662 15 sixty sixty CD 42759 1662 16 per per IN 42759 1662 17 cent cent NN 42759 1662 18 . . . 42759 1663 1 of of IN 42759 1663 2 the the DT 42759 1663 3 total total JJ 42759 1663 4 value value NN 42759 1663 5 of of IN 42759 1663 6 real real JJ 42759 1663 7 estate estate NN 42759 1663 8 , , , 42759 1663 9 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1663 10 find find VBP 42759 1663 11 that that IN 42759 1663 12 the the DT 42759 1663 13 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1663 14 derived derive VBN 42759 1663 15 from from IN 42759 1663 16 land land NN 42759 1663 17 constituted constitute VBD 42759 1663 18 only only RB 42759 1663 19 forty forty CD 42759 1663 20 - - HYPH 42759 1663 21 four four CD 42759 1663 22 per per IN 42759 1663 23 cent cent NN 42759 1663 24 . . . 42759 1664 1 of of IN 42759 1664 2 the the DT 42759 1664 3 total total JJ 42759 1664 4 revenues revenue NNS 42759 1664 5 raised raise VBN 42759 1664 6 by by IN 42759 1664 7 the the DT 42759 1664 8 general general JJ 42759 1664 9 property property NN 42759 1664 10 tax tax NN 42759 1664 11 . . . 42759 1665 1 To to TO 42759 1665 2 concentrate concentrate VB 42759 1665 3 the the DT 42759 1665 4 whole whole NN 42759 1665 5 of of IN 42759 1665 6 the the DT 42759 1665 7 general general JJ 42759 1665 8 property property NN 42759 1665 9 tax tax NN 42759 1665 10 on on IN 42759 1665 11 land land NN 42759 1665 12 , , , 42759 1665 13 by by IN 42759 1665 14 transferring transfer VBG 42759 1665 15 thereto thereto NN 42759 1665 16 the the DT 42759 1665 17 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1665 18 on on IN 42759 1665 19 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1665 20 and and CC 42759 1665 21 on on IN 42759 1665 22 personal personal JJ 42759 1665 23 property property NN 42759 1665 24 , , , 42759 1665 25 would would MD 42759 1665 26 , , , 42759 1665 27 accordingly accordingly RB 42759 1665 28 , , , 42759 1665 29 cause cause VB 42759 1665 30 the the DT 42759 1665 31 land land NN 42759 1665 32 tax tax NN 42759 1665 33 to to TO 42759 1665 34 be be VB 42759 1665 35 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 1665 36 more more RBR 42759 1665 37 than than IN 42759 1665 38 doubled double VBN 42759 1665 39 . . . 42759 1666 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1666 2 would would MD 42759 1666 3 be be VB 42759 1666 4 slightly slightly RB 42759 1666 5 above above IN 42759 1666 6 two two CD 42759 1666 7 per per NN 42759 1666 8 cent cent NN 42759 1666 9 . . . 42759 1667 1 on on IN 42759 1667 2 the the DT 42759 1667 3 full full JJ 42759 1667 4 value value NN 42759 1667 5 of of IN 42759 1667 6 the the DT 42759 1667 7 land land NN 42759 1667 8 . . . 42759 1668 1 This this DT 42759 1668 2 is be VBZ 42759 1668 3 the the DT 42759 1668 4 same same JJ 42759 1668 5 estimate estimate NN 42759 1668 6 that that WDT 42759 1668 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1668 8 obtained obtain VBD 42759 1668 9 above above RB 42759 1668 10 by by IN 42759 1668 11 a a DT 42759 1668 12 different different JJ 42759 1668 13 process process NN 42759 1668 14 ; ; : 42759 1668 15 that that RB 42759 1668 16 is is RB 42759 1668 17 , , , 42759 1668 18 by by IN 42759 1668 19 comparing compare VBG 42759 1668 20 Professor Professor NNP 42759 1668 21 King King NNP 42759 1668 22 's 's POS 42759 1668 23 estimate estimate NN 42759 1668 24 of of IN 42759 1668 25 land land NN 42759 1668 26 value value NN 42759 1668 27 and and CC 42759 1668 28 rent rent NN 42759 1668 29 with with IN 42759 1668 30 the the DT 42759 1668 31 total total JJ 42759 1668 32 revenues revenue NNS 42759 1668 33 derived derive VBN 42759 1668 34 from from IN 42759 1668 35 the the DT 42759 1668 36 general general JJ 42759 1668 37 property property NN 42759 1668 38 tax tax NN 42759 1668 39 . . . 42759 1669 1 However however RB 42759 1669 2 , , , 42759 1669 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1669 4 is be VBZ 42759 1669 5 not not RB 42759 1669 6 improbable improbable JJ 42759 1669 7 that that IN 42759 1669 8 sixty sixty CD 42759 1669 9 per per IN 42759 1669 10 cent cent NN 42759 1669 11 . . . 42759 1670 1 is be VBZ 42759 1670 2 too too RB 42759 1670 3 low low JJ 42759 1670 4 an an DT 42759 1670 5 estimate estimate NN 42759 1670 6 of of IN 42759 1670 7 the the DT 42759 1670 8 ratio ratio NN 42759 1670 9 of of IN 42759 1670 10 land land NN 42759 1670 11 values value NNS 42759 1670 12 to to IN 42759 1670 13 entire entire JJ 42759 1670 14 real real JJ 42759 1670 15 estate estate NN 42759 1670 16 values value NNS 42759 1670 17 . . . 42759 1671 1 In in IN 42759 1671 2 1900 1900 CD 42759 1671 3 , , , 42759 1671 4 farm farm NN 42759 1671 5 land land NN 42759 1671 6 and and CC 42759 1671 7 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1671 8 , , , 42759 1671 9 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 1671 10 of of IN 42759 1671 11 buildings building NNS 42759 1671 12 , , , 42759 1671 13 formed form VBN 42759 1671 14 78.6 78.6 CD 42759 1671 15 per per NN 42759 1671 16 cent cent NN 42759 1671 17 . . . 42759 1672 1 of of IN 42759 1672 2 the the DT 42759 1672 3 value value NN 42759 1672 4 of of IN 42759 1672 5 real real JJ 42759 1672 6 estate estate NN 42759 1672 7 , , , 42759 1672 8 i.e. i.e. FW 42759 1672 9 , , , 42759 1672 10 land land NN 42759 1672 11 , , , 42759 1672 12 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1672 13 , , , 42759 1672 14 and and CC 42759 1672 15 buildings building NNS 42759 1672 16 . . . 42759 1673 1 In in IN 42759 1673 2 1910 1910 CD 42759 1673 3 , , , 42759 1673 4 the the DT 42759 1673 5 per per IN 42759 1673 6 cent cent NN 42759 1673 7 . . . 42759 1674 1 was be VBD 42759 1674 2 a a DT 42759 1674 3 little little JJ 42759 1674 4 less less JJR 42759 1674 5 than than IN 42759 1674 6 82 82 CD 42759 1674 7 . . . 42759 1675 1 Now now RB 42759 1675 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1675 3 is be VBZ 42759 1675 4 quite quite RB 42759 1675 5 unlikely unlikely JJ 42759 1675 6 that that IN 42759 1675 7 the the DT 42759 1675 8 value value NN 42759 1675 9 of of IN 42759 1675 10 non non JJ 42759 1675 11 - - JJ 42759 1675 12 building building JJ 42759 1675 13 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1675 14 on on IN 42759 1675 15 farms farm NNS 42759 1675 16 amounted amount VBD 42759 1675 17 to to IN 42759 1675 18 the the DT 42759 1675 19 difference difference NN 42759 1675 20 between between IN 42759 1675 21 sixty sixty CD 42759 1675 22 per per NN 42759 1675 23 cent cent NN 42759 1675 24 . . . 42759 1676 1 and and CC 42759 1676 2 seventy seventy CD 42759 1676 3 - - HYPH 42759 1676 4 eight eight CD 42759 1676 5 per per NN 42759 1676 6 cent cent NN 42759 1676 7 . . . 42759 1677 1 in in IN 42759 1677 2 1900 1900 CD 42759 1677 3 , , , 42759 1677 4 or or CC 42759 1677 5 between between IN 42759 1677 6 sixty sixty CD 42759 1677 7 per per IN 42759 1677 8 cent cent NN 42759 1677 9 . . . 42759 1678 1 and and CC 42759 1678 2 eighty eighty CD 42759 1678 3 - - HYPH 42759 1678 4 two two CD 42759 1678 5 per per IN 42759 1678 6 cent cent NN 42759 1678 7 . . . 42759 1679 1 in in IN 42759 1679 2 1910 1910 CD 42759 1679 3 . . . 42759 1680 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1680 2 the the DT 42759 1680 3 value value NN 42759 1680 4 of of IN 42759 1680 5 farm farm NN 42759 1680 6 land land NN 42759 1680 7 is be VBZ 42759 1680 8 something something NN 42759 1680 9 more more JJR 42759 1680 10 than than IN 42759 1680 11 sixty sixty CD 42759 1680 12 per per IN 42759 1680 13 cent cent NN 42759 1680 14 . . . 42759 1681 1 of of IN 42759 1681 2 farm farm NNP 42759 1681 3 real real JJ 42759 1681 4 estate estate NN 42759 1681 5 . . . 42759 1682 1 On on IN 42759 1682 2 the the DT 42759 1682 3 other other JJ 42759 1682 4 hand hand NN 42759 1682 5 , , , 42759 1682 6 the the DT 42759 1682 7 value value NN 42759 1682 8 of of IN 42759 1682 9 factory factory NN 42759 1682 10 land land NN 42759 1682 11 in in IN 42759 1682 12 1900 1900 CD 42759 1682 13 formed form VBD 42759 1682 14 only only RB 42759 1682 15 41.5 41.5 CD 42759 1682 16 per per IN 42759 1682 17 cent cent NN 42759 1682 18 . . . 42759 1683 1 of of IN 42759 1683 2 the the DT 42759 1683 3 total total JJ 42759 1683 4 value value NN 42759 1683 5 of of IN 42759 1683 6 factory factory NN 42759 1683 7 land land NN 42759 1683 8 and and CC 42759 1683 9 buildings building NNS 42759 1683 10 , , , 42759 1683 11 while while IN 42759 1683 12 the the DT 42759 1683 13 value value NN 42759 1683 14 of of IN 42759 1683 15 city city NN 42759 1683 16 and and CC 42759 1683 17 town town NN 42759 1683 18 lots lot NNS 42759 1683 19 in in IN 42759 1683 20 five five CD 42759 1683 21 rural rural JJ 42759 1683 22 states state NNS 42759 1683 23 varied vary VBD 42759 1683 24 from from IN 42759 1683 25 34 34 CD 42759 1683 26 to to TO 42759 1683 27 62 62 CD 42759 1683 28 per per NN 42759 1683 29 cent cent NN 42759 1683 30 . . . 42759 1684 1 of of IN 42759 1684 2 this this DT 42759 1684 3 species specie NNS 42759 1684 4 of of IN 42759 1684 5 real real JJ 42759 1684 6 estate estate NN 42759 1684 7 . . . 42759 1685 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1685 2 104 104 CD 42759 1685 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1685 4 In in IN 42759 1685 5 Greater Greater NNP 42759 1685 6 New New NNP 42759 1685 7 York York NNP 42759 1685 8 land land NN 42759 1685 9 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 1685 10 61 61 CD 42759 1685 11 per per NN 42759 1685 12 cent cent NN 42759 1685 13 . . . 42759 1686 1 of of IN 42759 1686 2 real real JJ 42759 1686 3 estate estate NN 42759 1686 4 values value NNS 42759 1686 5 . . . 42759 1687 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1687 2 105 105 CD 42759 1687 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1687 4 Owing owe VBG 42759 1687 5 to to IN 42759 1687 6 the the DT 42759 1687 7 lack lack NN 42759 1687 8 of of IN 42759 1687 9 data datum NNS 42759 1687 10 , , , 42759 1687 11 the the DT 42759 1687 12 average average JJ 42759 1687 13 ratio ratio NN 42759 1687 14 for for IN 42759 1687 15 all all DT 42759 1687 16 kinds kind NNS 42759 1687 17 of of IN 42759 1687 18 real real JJ 42759 1687 19 estate estate NN 42759 1687 20 for for IN 42759 1687 21 the the DT 42759 1687 22 whole whole JJ 42759 1687 23 country country NN 42759 1687 24 is be VBZ 42759 1687 25 impossible impossible JJ 42759 1687 26 of of IN 42759 1687 27 determination determination NN 42759 1687 28 . . . 42759 1688 1 If if IN 42759 1688 2 the the DT 42759 1688 3 estimate estimate NN 42759 1688 4 of of IN 42759 1688 5 seventy seventy CD 42759 1688 6 per per IN 42759 1688 7 cent cent NN 42759 1688 8 . . . 42759 1689 1 be be VB 42759 1689 2 adopted adopt VBN 42759 1689 3 , , , 42759 1689 4 which which WDT 42759 1689 5 is be VBZ 42759 1689 6 probably probably RB 42759 1689 7 the the DT 42759 1689 8 upper upper JJ 42759 1689 9 limit limit NN 42759 1689 10 of of IN 42759 1689 11 the the DT 42759 1689 12 average average JJ 42759 1689 13 proportion proportion NN 42759 1689 14 between between IN 42759 1689 15 land land NN 42759 1689 16 values value NNS 42759 1689 17 and and CC 42759 1689 18 real real JJ 42759 1689 19 estate estate NN 42759 1689 20 values value NNS 42759 1689 21 throughout throughout IN 42759 1689 22 the the DT 42759 1689 23 country country NN 42759 1689 24 , , , 42759 1689 25 the the DT 42759 1689 26 portion portion NN 42759 1689 27 of of IN 42759 1689 28 the the DT 42759 1689 29 general general JJ 42759 1689 30 property property NN 42759 1689 31 tax tax NN 42759 1689 32 now now RB 42759 1689 33 paid pay VBN 42759 1689 34 by by IN 42759 1689 35 land land NN 42759 1689 36 amounts amount NNS 42759 1689 37 to to IN 42759 1689 38 about about RB 42759 1689 39 fifty fifty CD 42759 1689 40 - - HYPH 42759 1689 41 two two CD 42759 1689 42 per per NN 42759 1689 43 cent cent NN 42759 1689 44 . . . 42759 1690 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 1690 2 the the DT 42759 1690 3 imposition imposition NN 42759 1690 4 of of IN 42759 1690 5 the the DT 42759 1690 6 whole whole JJ 42759 1690 7 general general JJ 42759 1690 8 property property NN 42759 1690 9 tax tax NN 42759 1690 10 on on IN 42759 1690 11 land land NN 42759 1690 12 would would MD 42759 1690 13 not not RB 42759 1690 14 quite quite RB 42759 1690 15 double double VB 42759 1690 16 the the DT 42759 1690 17 present present JJ 42759 1690 18 rate rate NN 42759 1690 19 on on IN 42759 1690 20 land land NN 42759 1690 21 . . . 42759 1691 1 To to IN 42759 1691 2 the the DT 42759 1691 3 first first JJ 42759 1691 4 of of IN 42759 1691 5 the the DT 42759 1691 6 two two CD 42759 1691 7 questions question NNS 42759 1691 8 raised raise VBN 42759 1691 9 above above IN 42759 1691 10 the the DT 42759 1691 11 answer answer NN 42759 1691 12 can can MD 42759 1691 13 be be VB 42759 1691 14 given give VBN 42759 1691 15 with with IN 42759 1691 16 a a DT 42759 1691 17 fair fair JJ 42759 1691 18 amount amount NN 42759 1691 19 of of IN 42759 1691 20 confidence confidence NN 42759 1691 21 that that IN 42759 1691 22 the the DT 42759 1691 23 transfer transfer NN 42759 1691 24 of of IN 42759 1691 25 improvement improvement NN 42759 1691 26 and and CC 42759 1691 27 personal personal JJ 42759 1691 28 property property NN 42759 1691 29 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1691 30 to to IN 42759 1691 31 land land NN 42759 1691 32 would would MD 42759 1691 33 cause cause VB 42759 1691 34 land land NN 42759 1691 35 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1691 36 to to TO 42759 1691 37 be be VB 42759 1691 38 about about RB 42759 1691 39 twice twice PDT 42759 1691 40 what what WP 42759 1691 41 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1691 42 are be VBP 42759 1691 43 at at IN 42759 1691 44 present present JJ 42759 1691 45 . . . 42759 1692 1 To to IN 42759 1692 2 the the DT 42759 1692 3 second second JJ 42759 1692 4 question question NN 42759 1692 5 , , , 42759 1692 6 concerning concern VBG 42759 1692 7 the the DT 42759 1692 8 extent extent NN 42759 1692 9 to to TO 42759 1692 10 which which WDT 42759 1692 11 land land NN 42759 1692 12 values value NNS 42759 1692 13 would would MD 42759 1692 14 fall fall VB 42759 1692 15 in in IN 42759 1692 16 consequence consequence NN 42759 1692 17 of of IN 42759 1692 18 the the DT 42759 1692 19 heavier heavy JJR 42759 1692 20 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1692 21 , , , 42759 1692 22 the the DT 42759 1692 23 answer answer NN 42759 1692 24 must must MD 42759 1692 25 be be VB 42759 1692 26 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 1692 27 less less RBR 42759 1692 28 definite definite JJ 42759 1692 29 . . . 42759 1693 1 The the DT 42759 1693 2 added add VBN 42759 1693 3 land land NN 42759 1693 4 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1693 5 would would MD 42759 1693 6 be be VB 42759 1693 7 about about RB 42759 1693 8 one one CD 42759 1693 9 - - HYPH 42759 1693 10 half half NN 42759 1693 11 the the DT 42759 1693 12 present present JJ 42759 1693 13 general general JJ 42759 1693 14 property property NN 42759 1693 15 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1693 16 , , , 42759 1693 17 or or CC 42759 1693 18 $ $ $ 42759 1693 19 675,000,000 675,000,000 CD 42759 1693 20 . . . 42759 1694 1 This this DT 42759 1694 2 is be VBZ 42759 1694 3 about about RB 42759 1694 4 one one CD 42759 1694 5 per per IN 42759 1694 6 cent cent NN 42759 1694 7 . . . 42759 1695 1 the the DT 42759 1695 2 total total JJ 42759 1695 3 land land NN 42759 1695 4 values value NNS 42759 1695 5 of of IN 42759 1695 6 the the DT 42759 1695 7 country country NN 42759 1695 8 . . . 42759 1696 1 One one CD 42759 1696 2 per per IN 42759 1696 3 cent cent NN 42759 1696 4 . . . 42759 1697 1 of of IN 42759 1697 2 land land NN 42759 1697 3 values value NNS 42759 1697 4 capitalised capitalise VBN 42759 1697 5 at at IN 42759 1697 6 five five CD 42759 1697 7 per per NN 42759 1697 8 cent cent NN 42759 1697 9 . . . 42759 1698 1 represents represent VBZ 42759 1698 2 a a DT 42759 1698 3 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 1698 4 of of IN 42759 1698 5 twenty twenty CD 42759 1698 6 per per IN 42759 1698 7 cent cent NN 42759 1698 8 . . . 42759 1699 1 in in IN 42759 1699 2 the the DT 42759 1699 3 value value NN 42759 1699 4 of of IN 42759 1699 5 land land NN 42759 1699 6 ; ; , 42759 1699 7 capitalised capitalise VBD 42759 1699 8 at at IN 42759 1699 9 four four CD 42759 1699 10 per per NN 42759 1699 11 cent cent NN 42759 1699 12 . . . 42759 1699 13 , , , 42759 1699 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1699 15 represents represent VBZ 42759 1699 16 a a DT 42759 1699 17 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 1699 18 of of IN 42759 1699 19 twenty twenty CD 42759 1699 20 - - HYPH 42759 1699 21 five five CD 42759 1699 22 per per IN 42759 1699 23 cent cent NN 42759 1699 24 . . . 42759 1700 1 For for IN 42759 1700 2 example example NN 42759 1700 3 ; ; : 42759 1700 4 if if IN 42759 1700 5 land land NN 42759 1700 6 worth worth JJ 42759 1700 7 one one CD 42759 1700 8 hundred hundred CD 42759 1700 9 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1700 10 an an DT 42759 1700 11 acre acre NN 42759 1700 12 returns return NNS 42759 1700 13 to to IN 42759 1700 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1700 15 owner owner NN 42759 1700 16 a a DT 42759 1700 17 net net JJ 42759 1700 18 income income NN 42759 1700 19 of of IN 42759 1700 20 five five CD 42759 1700 21 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1700 22 annually annually RB 42759 1700 23 , , , 42759 1700 24 the the DT 42759 1700 25 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 1700 26 of of IN 42759 1700 27 one one CD 42759 1700 28 dollar dollar NN 42759 1700 29 by by IN 42759 1700 30 a a DT 42759 1700 31 new new JJ 42759 1700 32 tax tax NN 42759 1700 33 will will MD 42759 1700 34 leave leave VB 42759 1700 35 a a DT 42759 1700 36 net net JJ 42759 1700 37 revenue revenue NN 42759 1700 38 of of IN 42759 1700 39 only only JJ 42759 1700 40 four four CD 42759 1700 41 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1700 42 ; ; , 42759 1700 43 capitalised capitalise VBN 42759 1700 44 at at IN 42759 1700 45 the the DT 42759 1700 46 current current JJ 42759 1700 47 rate rate NN 42759 1700 48 of of IN 42759 1700 49 five five CD 42759 1700 50 per per NN 42759 1700 51 cent cent NN 42759 1700 52 . . . 42759 1700 53 , , , 42759 1700 54 this this DT 42759 1700 55 represents represent VBZ 42759 1700 56 only only RB 42759 1700 57 eighty eighty CD 42759 1700 58 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1700 59 of of IN 42759 1700 60 land land NN 42759 1700 61 value value NN 42759 1700 62 , , , 42759 1700 63 or or CC 42759 1700 64 a a DT 42759 1700 65 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 1700 66 of of IN 42759 1700 67 twenty twenty CD 42759 1700 68 per per IN 42759 1700 69 cent cent NN 42759 1700 70 . . . 42759 1701 1 If if IN 42759 1701 2 the the DT 42759 1701 3 land land NN 42759 1701 4 has have VBZ 42759 1701 5 the the DT 42759 1701 6 same same JJ 42759 1701 7 value value NN 42759 1701 8 of of IN 42759 1701 9 one one CD 42759 1701 10 hundred hundred CD 42759 1701 11 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1701 12 , , , 42759 1701 13 and and CC 42759 1701 14 still still RB 42759 1701 15 yields yield VBZ 42759 1701 16 only only RB 42759 1701 17 four four CD 42759 1701 18 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1701 19 revenue revenue NN 42759 1701 20 , , , 42759 1701 21 a a DT 42759 1701 22 deduction deduction NN 42759 1701 23 of of IN 42759 1701 24 one one CD 42759 1701 25 dollar dollar NN 42759 1701 26 in in IN 42759 1701 27 new new JJ 42759 1701 28 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1701 29 will will MD 42759 1701 30 leave leave VB 42759 1701 31 only only RB 42759 1701 32 three three CD 42759 1701 33 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1701 34 net net JJ 42759 1701 35 ; ; , 42759 1701 36 capitalised capitalise VBN 42759 1701 37 at at IN 42759 1701 38 the the DT 42759 1701 39 current current JJ 42759 1701 40 rate rate NN 42759 1701 41 of of IN 42759 1701 42 four four CD 42759 1701 43 per per NN 42759 1701 44 cent cent NN 42759 1701 45 . . . 42759 1701 46 , , , 42759 1701 47 this this DT 42759 1701 48 represents represent VBZ 42759 1701 49 only only RB 42759 1701 50 seventy seventy CD 42759 1701 51 - - HYPH 42759 1701 52 five five CD 42759 1701 53 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1701 54 of of IN 42759 1701 55 land land NN 42759 1701 56 value value NN 42759 1701 57 , , , 42759 1701 58 or or CC 42759 1701 59 a a DT 42759 1701 60 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 1701 61 of of IN 42759 1701 62 twenty twenty CD 42759 1701 63 - - HYPH 42759 1701 64 five five CD 42759 1701 65 per per IN 42759 1701 66 cent cent NN 42759 1701 67 . . . 42759 1702 1 Using use VBG 42759 1702 2 the the DT 42759 1702 3 other other JJ 42759 1702 4 method method NN 42759 1702 5 of of IN 42759 1702 6 calculation calculation NN 42759 1702 7 , , , 42759 1702 8 which which WDT 42759 1702 9 estimated estimate VBD 42759 1702 10 the the DT 42759 1702 11 present present JJ 42759 1702 12 tax tax NN 42759 1702 13 rate rate NN 42759 1702 14 on on IN 42759 1702 15 the the DT 42759 1702 16 full full JJ 42759 1702 17 value value NN 42759 1702 18 of of IN 42759 1702 19 land land NN 42759 1702 20 at at IN 42759 1702 21 one one CD 42759 1702 22 per per IN 42759 1702 23 cent cent NN 42759 1702 24 . . . 42759 1702 25 , , , 42759 1702 26 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1702 27 get get VBP 42759 1702 28 exactly exactly RB 42759 1702 29 the the DT 42759 1702 30 same same JJ 42759 1702 31 results result NNS 42759 1702 32 ; ; : 42759 1702 33 namely namely RB 42759 1702 34 , , , 42759 1702 35 the the DT 42759 1702 36 new new JJ 42759 1702 37 tax tax NN 42759 1702 38 is be VBZ 42759 1702 39 one one CD 42759 1702 40 per per IN 42759 1702 41 cent cent NN 42759 1702 42 . . . 42759 1702 43 , , , 42759 1702 44 which which WDT 42759 1702 45 is be VBZ 42759 1702 46 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 1702 47 to to IN 42759 1702 48 a a DT 42759 1702 49 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 1702 50 of of IN 42759 1702 51 twenty twenty CD 42759 1702 52 per per IN 42759 1702 53 cent cent NN 42759 1702 54 . . . 42759 1703 1 or or CC 42759 1703 2 of of IN 42759 1703 3 twenty twenty CD 42759 1703 4 - - HYPH 42759 1703 5 five five CD 42759 1703 6 per per IN 42759 1703 7 cent cent NN 42759 1703 8 . . . 42759 1703 9 , , , 42759 1703 10 according accord VBG 42759 1703 11 as as IN 42759 1703 12 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1703 13 assume assume VBP 42759 1703 14 an an DT 42759 1703 15 interest interest NN 42759 1703 16 rate rate NN 42759 1703 17 of of IN 42759 1703 18 five five CD 42759 1703 19 per per NN 42759 1703 20 cent cent NN 42759 1703 21 . . . 42759 1704 1 or or CC 42759 1704 2 of of IN 42759 1704 3 four four CD 42759 1704 4 per per NN 42759 1704 5 cent cent NN 42759 1704 6 . . . 42759 1705 1 Suppose suppose VB 42759 1705 2 , , , 42759 1705 3 however however RB 42759 1705 4 , , , 42759 1705 5 that that IN 42759 1705 6 the the DT 42759 1705 7 assessors assessor NNS 42759 1705 8 do do VBP 42759 1705 9 not not RB 42759 1705 10 undervalue undervalue VB 42759 1705 11 land land NN 42759 1705 12 to to IN 42759 1705 13 the the DT 42759 1705 14 extent extent NN 42759 1705 15 that that WDT 42759 1705 16 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1705 17 have have VBP 42759 1705 18 been be VBN 42759 1705 19 assuming assume VBG 42759 1705 20 ; ; : 42759 1705 21 suppose suppose VB 42759 1705 22 that that IN 42759 1705 23 the the DT 42759 1705 24 present present JJ 42759 1705 25 rate rate NN 42759 1705 26 of of IN 42759 1705 27 .0194 .0194 NN 42759 1705 28 on on IN 42759 1705 29 assessed assessed JJ 42759 1705 30 valuation valuation NN 42759 1705 31 is be VBZ 42759 1705 32 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 1705 33 to to IN 42759 1705 34 , , , 42759 1705 35 not not RB 42759 1705 36 merely merely RB 42759 1705 37 one one CD 42759 1705 38 per per IN 42759 1705 39 cent cent NN 42759 1705 40 . . . 42759 1705 41 , , , 42759 1705 42 but but CC 42759 1705 43 one one CD 42759 1705 44 and and CC 42759 1705 45 one one CD 42759 1705 46 - - HYPH 42759 1705 47 half half NN 42759 1705 48 per per IN 42759 1705 49 cent cent NN 42759 1705 50 . . . 42759 1706 1 of of IN 42759 1706 2 the the DT 42759 1706 3 full full JJ 42759 1706 4 value value NN 42759 1706 5 of of IN 42759 1706 6 land land NN 42759 1706 7 . . . 42759 1707 1 In in IN 42759 1707 2 that that DT 42759 1707 3 hypothesis hypothesis NN 42759 1707 4 the the DT 42759 1707 5 additional additional JJ 42759 1707 6 tax tax NN 42759 1707 7 would would MD 42759 1707 8 likewise likewise RB 42759 1707 9 be be VB 42759 1707 10 one one CD 42759 1707 11 and and CC 42759 1707 12 one one CD 42759 1707 13 - - HYPH 42759 1707 14 half half NN 42759 1707 15 per per IN 42759 1707 16 cent cent NN 42759 1707 17 . . . 42759 1707 18 , , , 42759 1707 19 which which WDT 42759 1707 20 capitalised capitalise VBD 42759 1707 21 at at IN 42759 1707 22 five five CD 42759 1707 23 per per NN 42759 1707 24 cent cent NN 42759 1707 25 , , , 42759 1707 26 would would MD 42759 1707 27 represent represent VB 42759 1707 28 a a DT 42759 1707 29 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 1707 30 of of IN 42759 1707 31 thirty thirty CD 42759 1707 32 per per IN 42759 1707 33 cent cent NN 42759 1707 34 . . . 42759 1707 35 , , , 42759 1707 36 and and CC 42759 1707 37 at at IN 42759 1707 38 four four CD 42759 1707 39 per per NN 42759 1707 40 cent cent NN 42759 1707 41 . . . 42759 1708 1 a a DT 42759 1708 2 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 1708 3 of of IN 42759 1708 4 thirty thirty CD 42759 1708 5 - - HYPH 42759 1708 6 seven seven CD 42759 1708 7 and and CC 42759 1708 8 one one CD 42759 1708 9 - - HYPH 42759 1708 10 half half NN 42759 1708 11 per per IN 42759 1708 12 cent cent NN 42759 1708 13 . . . 42759 1709 1 Combining combine VBG 42759 1709 2 in in IN 42759 1709 3 one one CD 42759 1709 4 generalisation generalisation NN 42759 1709 5 the the DT 42759 1709 6 various various JJ 42759 1709 7 suppositions supposition NNS 42759 1709 8 made make VBN 42759 1709 9 in in IN 42759 1709 10 this this DT 42759 1709 11 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 1709 12 , , , 42759 1709 13 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1709 14 estimate estimate VBP 42759 1709 15 the the DT 42759 1709 16 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 1709 17 of of IN 42759 1709 18 land land NN 42759 1709 19 values value NNS 42759 1709 20 resulting result VBG 42759 1709 21 from from IN 42759 1709 22 the the DT 42759 1709 23 proposed propose VBN 42759 1709 24 tax tax NN 42759 1709 25 transfer transfer NN 42759 1709 26 as as RB 42759 1709 27 somewhere somewhere RB 42759 1709 28 between between IN 42759 1709 29 twenty twenty CD 42759 1709 30 and and CC 42759 1709 31 forty forty CD 42759 1709 32 per per IN 42759 1709 33 cent cent NN 42759 1709 34 . . . 42759 1710 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 1710 2 have have VBP 42759 1710 3 considered consider VBN 42759 1710 4 two two CD 42759 1710 5 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 42759 1710 6 transfers transfer NNS 42759 1710 7 of of IN 42759 1710 8 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1710 9 to to IN 42759 1710 10 land land NN 42759 1710 11 . . . 42759 1711 1 The the DT 42759 1711 2 first first JJ 42759 1711 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1711 4 found find VBD 42759 1711 5 to to TO 42759 1711 6 be be VB 42759 1711 7 out out IN 42759 1711 8 of of IN 42759 1711 9 the the DT 42759 1711 10 question question NN 42759 1711 11 because because IN 42759 1711 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1711 13 would would MD 42759 1711 14 appropriate appropriate VB 42759 1711 15 the the DT 42759 1711 16 whole whole NN 42759 1711 17 of of IN 42759 1711 18 the the DT 42759 1711 19 rent rent NN 42759 1711 20 and and CC 42759 1711 21 destroy destroy VB 42759 1711 22 all all DT 42759 1711 23 private private JJ 42759 1711 24 land land NN 42759 1711 25 values value NNS 42759 1711 26 . . . 42759 1712 1 The the DT 42759 1712 2 second second JJ 42759 1712 3 would would MD 42759 1712 4 apparently apparently RB 42759 1712 5 amount amount VB 42759 1712 6 to to IN 42759 1712 7 two two CD 42759 1712 8 per per NN 42759 1712 9 cent cent NN 42759 1712 10 . . . 42759 1713 1 of of IN 42759 1713 2 the the DT 42759 1713 3 value value NN 42759 1713 4 of of IN 42759 1713 5 land land NN 42759 1713 6 , , , 42759 1713 7 and and CC 42759 1713 8 cause cause VB 42759 1713 9 land land NN 42759 1713 10 values value NNS 42759 1713 11 to to TO 42759 1713 12 depreciate depreciate VB 42759 1713 13 from from IN 42759 1713 14 twenty twenty CD 42759 1713 15 to to TO 42759 1713 16 forty forty CD 42759 1713 17 per per IN 42759 1713 18 cent cent NN 42759 1713 19 . . . 42759 1714 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1714 2 is be VBZ 42759 1714 3 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 1714 4 to to TO 42759 1714 5 consider consider VB 42759 1714 6 the the DT 42759 1714 7 probable probable JJ 42759 1714 8 effects effect NNS 42759 1714 9 of of IN 42759 1714 10 any any DT 42759 1714 11 plan plan NN 42759 1714 12 that that WDT 42759 1714 13 would would MD 42759 1714 14 involve involve VB 42759 1714 15 heavier heavy JJR 42759 1714 16 land land NN 42759 1714 17 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1714 18 than than IN 42759 1714 19 the the DT 42759 1714 20 second second JJ 42759 1714 21 ; ; : 42759 1714 22 that that RB 42759 1714 23 is is RB 42759 1714 24 , , , 42759 1714 25 the the DT 42759 1714 26 scheme scheme NN 42759 1714 27 of of IN 42759 1714 28 imposing impose VBG 42759 1714 29 all all PDT 42759 1714 30 the the DT 42759 1714 31 general general JJ 42759 1714 32 property property NN 42759 1714 33 tax tax NN 42759 1714 34 on on IN 42759 1714 35 land land NN 42759 1714 36 ; ; : 42759 1714 37 for for IN 42759 1714 38 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1714 39 represents represent VBZ 42759 1714 40 the the DT 42759 1714 41 extreme extreme JJ 42759 1714 42 feasible feasible JJ 42759 1714 43 and and CC 42759 1714 44 fair fair JJ 42759 1714 45 limit limit NN 42759 1714 46 of of IN 42759 1714 47 the the DT 42759 1714 48 movement movement NN 42759 1714 49 within within IN 42759 1714 50 , , , 42759 1714 51 at at IN 42759 1714 52 any any DT 42759 1714 53 rate rate NN 42759 1714 54 , , , 42759 1714 55 the the DT 42759 1714 56 next next JJ 42759 1714 57 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 1714 58 or or CC 42759 1714 59 twenty twenty CD 42759 1714 60 years year NNS 42759 1714 61 . . . 42759 1715 1 Even even RB 42759 1715 2 this this DT 42759 1715 3 degree degree NN 42759 1715 4 of of IN 42759 1715 5 tax tax NN 42759 1715 6 transference transference NN 42759 1715 7 would would MD 42759 1715 8 be be VB 42759 1715 9 unjust unjust JJ 42759 1715 10 to to IN 42759 1715 11 the the DT 42759 1715 12 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1715 13 if if IN 42759 1715 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1715 15 were be VBD 42759 1715 16 brought bring VBN 42759 1715 17 about about RP 42759 1715 18 at at IN 42759 1715 19 once once RB 42759 1715 20 . . . 42759 1716 1 No no DT 42759 1716 2 social social JJ 42759 1716 3 or or CC 42759 1716 4 other other JJ 42759 1716 5 considerations consideration NNS 42759 1716 6 exist exist VBP 42759 1716 7 that that WDT 42759 1716 8 would would MD 42759 1716 9 justify justify VB 42759 1716 10 a a DT 42759 1716 11 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 1716 12 in in IN 42759 1716 13 land land NN 42759 1716 14 values value NNS 42759 1716 15 of of IN 42759 1716 16 from from IN 42759 1716 17 twenty twenty CD 42759 1716 18 to to TO 42759 1716 19 forty forty CD 42759 1716 20 per per IN 42759 1716 21 cent cent NN 42759 1716 22 . . . 42759 1717 1 If if IN 42759 1717 2 , , , 42759 1717 3 however however RB 42759 1717 4 , , , 42759 1717 5 the the DT 42759 1717 6 process process NN 42759 1717 7 were be VBD 42759 1717 8 extended extend VBN 42759 1717 9 over over IN 42759 1717 10 a a DT 42759 1717 11 period period NN 42759 1717 12 of of IN 42759 1717 13 , , , 42759 1717 14 say say UH 42759 1717 15 , , , 42759 1717 16 twenty twenty CD 42759 1717 17 years year NNS 42759 1717 18 , , , 42759 1717 19 the the DT 42759 1717 20 decline decline NN 42759 1717 21 would would MD 42759 1717 22 be be VB 42759 1717 23 only only RB 42759 1717 24 one one CD 42759 1717 25 or or CC 42759 1717 26 two two CD 42759 1717 27 per per NN 42759 1717 28 cent cent NN 42759 1717 29 . . . 42759 1718 1 annually annually RB 42759 1718 2 , , , 42759 1718 3 which which WDT 42759 1718 4 is be VBZ 42759 1718 5 considerably considerably RB 42759 1718 6 less less JJR 42759 1718 7 than than IN 42759 1718 8 the the DT 42759 1718 9 rate rate NN 42759 1718 10 at at IN 42759 1718 11 which which WDT 42759 1718 12 farm farm NN 42759 1718 13 lands land NNS 42759 1718 14 and and CC 42759 1718 15 the the DT 42759 1718 16 land land NN 42759 1718 17 in in IN 42759 1718 18 large large JJ 42759 1718 19 cities city NNS 42759 1718 20 have have VBP 42759 1718 21 risen rise VBN 42759 1718 22 in in IN 42759 1718 23 value value NN 42759 1718 24 during during IN 42759 1718 25 recent recent JJ 42759 1718 26 years year NNS 42759 1718 27 . . . 42759 1719 1 Under under IN 42759 1719 2 such such PDT 42759 1719 3 an an DT 42759 1719 4 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 1719 5 the the DT 42759 1719 6 great great JJ 42759 1719 7 majority majority NN 42759 1719 8 of of IN 42759 1719 9 owners owner NNS 42759 1719 10 would would MD 42759 1719 11 probably probably RB 42759 1719 12 find find VB 42759 1719 13 that that IN 42759 1719 14 the the DT 42759 1719 15 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 1719 16 caused cause VBN 42759 1719 17 by by IN 42759 1719 18 the the DT 42759 1719 19 heavier heavy JJR 42759 1719 20 land land NN 42759 1719 21 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1719 22 , , , 42759 1719 23 had have VBD 42759 1719 24 been be VBN 42759 1719 25 more more JJR 42759 1719 26 than than IN 42759 1719 27 offset offset VBN 42759 1719 28 by by IN 42759 1719 29 the the DT 42759 1719 30 upward upward JJ 42759 1719 31 tendency tendency NN 42759 1719 32 resulting result VBG 42759 1719 33 from from IN 42759 1719 34 the the DT 42759 1719 35 increased increase VBN 42759 1719 36 demand demand NN 42759 1719 37 for for IN 42759 1719 38 land land NN 42759 1719 39 . . . 42759 1720 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 1720 2 , , , 42759 1720 3 there there EX 42759 1720 4 would would MD 42759 1720 5 still still RB 42759 1720 6 be be VB 42759 1720 7 positive positive JJ 42759 1720 8 losses loss NNS 42759 1720 9 of of IN 42759 1720 10 the the DT 42759 1720 11 three three CD 42759 1720 12 kinds kind NNS 42759 1720 13 described describe VBD 42759 1720 14 a a DT 42759 1720 15 few few JJ 42759 1720 16 pages page NNS 42759 1720 17 back back RB 42759 1720 18 ; ; : 42759 1720 19 namely namely RB 42759 1720 20 , , , 42759 1720 21 to to IN 42759 1720 22 owners owner NNS 42759 1720 23 who who WP 42759 1720 24 sold sell VBD 42759 1720 25 land land NN 42759 1720 26 below below IN 42759 1720 27 the the DT 42759 1720 28 price price NN 42759 1720 29 that that WDT 42759 1720 30 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1720 31 had have VBD 42759 1720 32 paid pay VBN 42759 1720 33 for for IN 42759 1720 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1720 35 ; ; : 42759 1720 36 to to IN 42759 1720 37 owners owner NNS 42759 1720 38 who who WP 42759 1720 39 sold sell VBD 42759 1720 40 vacant vacant JJ 42759 1720 41 land land NN 42759 1720 42 at at IN 42759 1720 43 a a DT 42759 1720 44 price price NN 42759 1720 45 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 1720 46 to to TO 42759 1720 47 cover cover VB 42759 1720 48 accumulated accumulate VBN 42759 1720 49 interest interest NN 42759 1720 50 on on IN 42759 1720 51 the the DT 42759 1720 52 investment investment NN 42759 1720 53 ; ; : 42759 1720 54 and and CC 42759 1720 55 to to IN 42759 1720 56 owners owner NNS 42759 1720 57 whose whose WP$ 42759 1720 58 aggregate aggregate JJ 42759 1720 59 tax tax NN 42759 1720 60 burdens burden NNS 42759 1720 61 were be VBD 42759 1720 62 increased increase VBN 42759 1720 63 . . . 42759 1721 1 Some some DT 42759 1721 2 degree degree NN 42759 1721 3 of of IN 42759 1721 4 each each DT 42759 1721 5 of of IN 42759 1721 6 these these DT 42759 1721 7 sorts sort NNS 42759 1721 8 of of IN 42759 1721 9 losses loss NNS 42759 1721 10 would would MD 42759 1721 11 be be VB 42759 1721 12 due due JJ 42759 1721 13 specifically specifically RB 42759 1721 14 to to IN 42759 1721 15 the the DT 42759 1721 16 new new JJ 42759 1721 17 land land NN 42759 1721 18 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1721 19 . . . 42759 1722 1 As as IN 42759 1722 2 noted note VBN 42759 1722 3 above above IN 42759 1722 4 , , , 42759 1722 5 public public JJ 42759 1722 6 compensation compensation NN 42759 1722 7 in in IN 42759 1722 8 all all DT 42759 1722 9 such such JJ 42759 1722 10 cases case NNS 42759 1722 11 would would MD 42759 1722 12 be be VB 42759 1722 13 impracticable impracticable JJ 42759 1722 14 . . . 42759 1723 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 1723 2 the the DT 42759 1723 3 justification justification NN 42759 1723 4 of of IN 42759 1723 5 a a DT 42759 1723 6 law law NN 42759 1723 7 that that WDT 42759 1723 8 inflicts inflict VBZ 42759 1723 9 such such JJ 42759 1723 10 losses loss NNS 42759 1723 11 must must MD 42759 1723 12 be be VB 42759 1723 13 found find VBN 42759 1723 14 , , , 42759 1723 15 if if IN 42759 1723 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1723 17 exists exist VBZ 42759 1723 18 , , , 42759 1723 19 in in IN 42759 1723 20 social social JJ 42759 1723 21 considerations consideration NNS 42759 1723 22 . . . 42759 1724 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1724 2 The the DT 42759 1724 3 Social Social NNP 42759 1724 4 Benefits Benefits NNPS 42759 1724 5 of of IN 42759 1724 6 the the DT 42759 1724 7 Plan Plan NNP 42759 1724 8 _ _ NNP 42759 1724 9 These these DT 42759 1724 10 may may MD 42759 1724 11 be be VB 42759 1724 12 summed sum VBN 42759 1724 13 up up RP 42759 1724 14 under under IN 42759 1724 15 three three CD 42759 1724 16 heads head NNS 42759 1724 17 : : : 42759 1724 18 making make VBG 42759 1724 19 land land NN 42759 1724 20 easier easy JJR 42759 1724 21 to to TO 42759 1724 22 acquire acquire VB 42759 1724 23 ; ; : 42759 1724 24 cheapening cheapen VBG 42759 1724 25 the the DT 42759 1724 26 products product NNS 42759 1724 27 and and CC 42759 1724 28 rent rent NN 42759 1724 29 of of IN 42759 1724 30 land land NN 42759 1724 31 ; ; , 42759 1724 32 and and CC 42759 1724 33 reducing reduce VBG 42759 1724 34 the the DT 42759 1724 35 burdens burden NNS 42759 1724 36 of of IN 42759 1724 37 taxation taxation NN 42759 1724 38 borne bear VBN 42759 1724 39 by by IN 42759 1724 40 the the DT 42759 1724 41 poorer poor JJR 42759 1724 42 and and CC 42759 1724 43 middle middle JJ 42759 1724 44 classes class NNS 42759 1724 45 . . . 42759 1725 1 An an DT 42759 1725 2 increase increase NN 42759 1725 3 in in IN 42759 1725 4 the the DT 42759 1725 5 tax tax NN 42759 1725 6 on on IN 42759 1725 7 land land NN 42759 1725 8 would would MD 42759 1725 9 reduce reduce VB 42759 1725 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1725 11 value value NN 42759 1725 12 and and CC 42759 1725 13 price price NN 42759 1725 14 , , , 42759 1725 15 or or CC 42759 1725 16 at at IN 42759 1725 17 least least JJS 42759 1725 18 cause cause VB 42759 1725 19 the the DT 42759 1725 20 price price NN 42759 1725 21 to to TO 42759 1725 22 be be VB 42759 1725 23 lower low JJR 42759 1725 24 than than IN 42759 1725 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1725 26 would would MD 42759 1725 27 have have VB 42759 1725 28 been be VBN 42759 1725 29 in in IN 42759 1725 30 the the DT 42759 1725 31 absence absence NN 42759 1725 32 of of IN 42759 1725 33 the the DT 42759 1725 34 tax tax NN 42759 1725 35 . . . 42759 1726 1 This this DT 42759 1726 2 does do VBZ 42759 1726 3 not not RB 42759 1726 4 mean mean VB 42759 1726 5 that that DT 42759 1726 6 land land NN 42759 1726 7 would would MD 42759 1726 8 be be VB 42759 1726 9 more more RBR 42759 1726 10 profitable profitable JJ 42759 1726 11 to to IN 42759 1726 12 the the DT 42759 1726 13 purchaser purchaser NN 42759 1726 14 , , , 42759 1726 15 since since IN 42759 1726 16 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1726 17 is be VBZ 42759 1726 18 enabled enable VBN 42759 1726 19 to to TO 42759 1726 20 buy buy VB 42759 1726 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1726 22 at at IN 42759 1726 23 a a DT 42759 1726 24 lower low JJR 42759 1726 25 price price NN 42759 1726 26 only only RB 42759 1726 27 because because IN 42759 1726 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1726 29 yields yield VBZ 42759 1726 30 him -PRON- PRP 42759 1726 31 less less RBR 42759 1726 32 net net JJ 42759 1726 33 revenue revenue NN 42759 1726 34 , , , 42759 1726 35 or or CC 42759 1726 36 because because IN 42759 1726 37 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1726 38 is be VBZ 42759 1726 39 less less RBR 42759 1726 40 likely likely JJ 42759 1726 41 to to TO 42759 1726 42 increase increase VB 42759 1726 43 in in IN 42759 1726 44 value value NN 42759 1726 45 . . . 42759 1727 1 The the DT 42759 1727 2 value value NN 42759 1727 3 of of IN 42759 1727 4 land land NN 42759 1727 5 is be VBZ 42759 1727 6 always always RB 42759 1727 7 determined determine VBN 42759 1727 8 by by IN 42759 1727 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1727 10 revenue revenue NN 42759 1727 11 - - HYPH 42759 1727 12 producing produce VBG 42759 1727 13 power power NN 42759 1727 14 , , , 42759 1727 15 and and CC 42759 1727 16 by by IN 42759 1727 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1727 18 probabilities probability NNS 42759 1727 19 of of IN 42759 1727 20 price price NN 42759 1727 21 - - HYPH 42759 1727 22 appreciation appreciation NN 42759 1727 23 . . . 42759 1728 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 1728 2 , , , 42759 1728 3 what what WP 42759 1728 4 the the DT 42759 1728 5 purchasers purchaser NNS 42759 1728 6 would would MD 42759 1728 7 gain gain VB 42759 1728 8 by by IN 42759 1728 9 the the DT 42759 1728 10 lower low JJR 42759 1728 11 price price NN 42759 1728 12 resulting result VBG 42759 1728 13 from from IN 42759 1728 14 the the DT 42759 1728 15 new new JJ 42759 1728 16 tax tax NN 42759 1728 17 , , , 42759 1728 18 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1728 19 would would MD 42759 1728 20 lose lose VB 42759 1728 21 when when WRB 42759 1728 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1728 23 came come VBD 42759 1728 24 to to TO 42759 1728 25 pay pay VB 42759 1728 26 the the DT 42759 1728 27 tax tax NN 42759 1728 28 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 1728 29 , , , 42759 1728 30 and and CC 42759 1728 31 when when WRB 42759 1728 32 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1728 33 found find VBD 42759 1728 34 the the DT 42759 1728 35 chances chance NNS 42759 1728 36 of of IN 42759 1728 37 value value NN 42759 1728 38 increases increase NNS 42759 1728 39 diminished diminish VBN 42759 1728 40 . . . 42759 1729 1 If if IN 42759 1729 2 a a DT 42759 1729 3 piece piece NN 42759 1729 4 of of IN 42759 1729 5 land land NN 42759 1729 6 which which WDT 42759 1729 7 brings bring VBZ 42759 1729 8 a a DT 42759 1729 9 return return NN 42759 1729 10 of of IN 42759 1729 11 five five CD 42759 1729 12 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1729 13 a a DT 42759 1729 14 year year NN 42759 1729 15 costs cost VBZ 42759 1729 16 one one CD 42759 1729 17 hundred hundred CD 42759 1729 18 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1729 19 before before IN 42759 1729 20 the the DT 42759 1729 21 new new JJ 42759 1729 22 tax tax NN 42759 1729 23 of of IN 42759 1729 24 one one CD 42759 1729 25 per per IN 42759 1729 26 cent cent NN 42759 1729 27 . . . 42759 1730 1 is be VBZ 42759 1730 2 imposed impose VBN 42759 1730 3 , , , 42759 1730 4 and and CC 42759 1730 5 can can MD 42759 1730 6 be be VB 42759 1730 7 bought buy VBN 42759 1730 8 for for IN 42759 1730 9 eighty eighty CD 42759 1730 10 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1730 11 afterward afterward RB 42759 1730 12 , , , 42759 1730 13 the the DT 42759 1730 14 net net JJ 42759 1730 15 interest interest NN 42759 1730 16 on on IN 42759 1730 17 the the DT 42759 1730 18 purchase purchase NN 42759 1730 19 price price NN 42759 1730 20 has have VBZ 42759 1730 21 not not RB 42759 1730 22 changed change VBN 42759 1730 23 . . . 42759 1731 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1731 2 is be VBZ 42759 1731 3 still still RB 42759 1731 4 five five CD 42759 1731 5 per per IN 42759 1731 6 cent cent NN 42759 1731 7 . . . 42759 1732 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1732 2 the the DT 42759 1732 3 only only JJ 42759 1732 4 advantage advantage NN 42759 1732 5 to to IN 42759 1732 6 the the DT 42759 1732 7 prospective prospective JJ 42759 1732 8 purchaser purchaser NN 42759 1732 9 of of IN 42759 1732 10 land land NN 42759 1732 11 in in IN 42759 1732 12 getting get VBG 42759 1732 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1732 14 cheaper cheap JJR 42759 1732 15 consists consist VBZ 42759 1732 16 in in IN 42759 1732 17 the the DT 42759 1732 18 fact fact NN 42759 1732 19 that that IN 42759 1732 20 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1732 21 can can MD 42759 1732 22 obtain obtain VB 42759 1732 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1732 24 with with IN 42759 1732 25 a a DT 42759 1732 26 smaller small JJR 42759 1732 27 outlay outlay NN 42759 1732 28 of of IN 42759 1732 29 capital capital NN 42759 1732 30 . . . 42759 1733 1 For for IN 42759 1733 2 persons person NNS 42759 1733 3 in in IN 42759 1733 4 moderate moderate JJ 42759 1733 5 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 1733 6 this this DT 42759 1733 7 is be VBZ 42759 1733 8 a a DT 42759 1733 9 very very RB 42759 1733 10 important important JJ 42759 1733 11 consideration consideration NN 42759 1733 12 . . . 42759 1734 1 In in IN 42759 1734 2 the the DT 42759 1734 3 second second JJ 42759 1734 4 place place NN 42759 1734 5 , , , 42759 1734 6 higher high JJR 42759 1734 7 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1734 8 would would MD 42759 1734 9 cause cause VB 42759 1734 10 many many JJ 42759 1734 11 existing exist VBG 42759 1734 12 owners owner NNS 42759 1734 13 either either CC 42759 1734 14 to to TO 42759 1734 15 improve improve VB 42759 1734 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1734 17 land land NN 42759 1734 18 , , , 42759 1734 19 in in IN 42759 1734 20 order order NN 42759 1734 21 to to TO 42759 1734 22 have have VB 42759 1734 23 the the DT 42759 1734 24 means mean NNS 42759 1734 25 of of IN 42759 1734 26 meeting meet VBG 42759 1734 27 the the DT 42759 1734 28 added add VBN 42759 1734 29 fiscal fiscal JJ 42759 1734 30 charges charge NNS 42759 1734 31 , , , 42759 1734 32 or or CC 42759 1734 33 to to TO 42759 1734 34 sell sell VB 42759 1734 35 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1734 36 to to IN 42759 1734 37 persons person NNS 42759 1734 38 who who WP 42759 1734 39 would would MD 42759 1734 40 be be VB 42759 1734 41 willing willing JJ 42759 1734 42 to to TO 42759 1734 43 make make VB 42759 1734 44 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1734 45 . . . 42759 1735 1 And and CC 42759 1735 2 the the DT 42759 1735 3 desire desire NN 42759 1735 4 to to TO 42759 1735 5 erect erect VB 42759 1735 6 buildings building NNS 42759 1735 7 and and CC 42759 1735 8 other other JJ 42759 1735 9 forms form NNS 42759 1735 10 of of IN 42759 1735 11 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1735 12 would would MD 42759 1735 13 be be VB 42759 1735 14 reinforced reinforce VBN 42759 1735 15 by by IN 42759 1735 16 the the DT 42759 1735 17 reduction reduction NN 42759 1735 18 or or CC 42759 1735 19 abolition abolition NN 42759 1735 20 of of IN 42759 1735 21 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1735 22 on on IN 42759 1735 23 those those DT 42759 1735 24 kinds kind NNS 42759 1735 25 of of IN 42759 1735 26 personal personal JJ 42759 1735 27 property property NN 42759 1735 28 which which WDT 42759 1735 29 consist consist VBP 42759 1735 30 of of IN 42759 1735 31 building build VBG 42759 1735 32 materials material NNS 42759 1735 33 . . . 42759 1736 1 An an DT 42759 1736 2 increase increase NN 42759 1736 3 in in IN 42759 1736 4 the the DT 42759 1736 5 rapidity rapidity NN 42759 1736 6 of of IN 42759 1736 7 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1736 8 on on IN 42759 1736 9 land land NN 42759 1736 10 would would MD 42759 1736 11 mean mean VB 42759 1736 12 an an DT 42759 1736 13 increase increase NN 42759 1736 14 in in IN 42759 1736 15 the the DT 42759 1736 16 rate rate NN 42759 1736 17 at at IN 42759 1736 18 which which WDT 42759 1736 19 land land NN 42759 1736 20 was be VBD 42759 1736 21 brought bring VBN 42759 1736 22 into into IN 42759 1736 23 use use NN 42759 1736 24 , , , 42759 1736 25 and and CC 42759 1736 26 therefore therefore RB 42759 1736 27 an an DT 42759 1736 28 unusual unusual JJ 42759 1736 29 increase increase NN 42759 1736 30 in in IN 42759 1736 31 the the DT 42759 1736 32 volume volume NN 42759 1736 33 of of IN 42759 1736 34 products product NNS 42759 1736 35 . . . 42759 1737 1 This this DT 42759 1737 2 virtual virtual JJ 42759 1737 3 increase increase NN 42759 1737 4 in in IN 42759 1737 5 the the DT 42759 1737 6 supply supply NN 42759 1737 7 of of IN 42759 1737 8 land land NN 42759 1737 9 , , , 42759 1737 10 and and CC 42759 1737 11 actual actual JJ 42759 1737 12 increase increase NN 42759 1737 13 in in IN 42759 1737 14 the the DT 42759 1737 15 supply supply NN 42759 1737 16 of of IN 42759 1737 17 products product NNS 42759 1737 18 , , , 42759 1737 19 would would MD 42759 1737 20 cause cause VB 42759 1737 21 a a DT 42759 1737 22 fall fall NN 42759 1737 23 in in IN 42759 1737 24 three three CD 42759 1737 25 kinds kind NNS 42759 1737 26 of of IN 42759 1737 27 prices price NNS 42759 1737 28 : : : 42759 1737 29 the the DT 42759 1737 30 price price NN 42759 1737 31 of of IN 42759 1737 32 products product NNS 42759 1737 33 , , , 42759 1737 34 the the DT 42759 1737 35 rent rent NN 42759 1737 36 of of IN 42759 1737 37 land land NN 42759 1737 38 , , , 42759 1737 39 and and CC 42759 1737 40 the the DT 42759 1737 41 price price NN 42759 1737 42 of of IN 42759 1737 43 land land NN 42759 1737 44 . . . 42759 1738 1 The the DT 42759 1738 2 last last JJ 42759 1738 3 named name VBN 42759 1738 4 reduction reduction NN 42759 1738 5 would would MD 42759 1738 6 be be VB 42759 1738 7 distinct distinct JJ 42759 1738 8 from from IN 42759 1738 9 the the DT 42759 1738 10 reduction reduction NN 42759 1738 11 of of IN 42759 1738 12 land land NN 42759 1738 13 value value NN 42759 1738 14 caused cause VBN 42759 1738 15 in in IN 42759 1738 16 the the DT 42759 1738 17 first first JJ 42759 1738 18 instance instance NN 42759 1738 19 by by IN 42759 1738 20 the the DT 42759 1738 21 imposition imposition NN 42759 1738 22 of of IN 42759 1738 23 the the DT 42759 1738 24 tax tax NN 42759 1738 25 . . . 42759 1739 1 In in IN 42759 1739 2 the the DT 42759 1739 3 third third JJ 42759 1739 4 place place NN 42759 1739 5 , , , 42759 1739 6 the the DT 42759 1739 7 reduction reduction NN 42759 1739 8 , , , 42759 1739 9 and and CC 42759 1739 10 finally finally RB 42759 1739 11 the the DT 42759 1739 12 abolition abolition NN 42759 1739 13 , , , 42759 1739 14 of of IN 42759 1739 15 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1739 16 on on IN 42759 1739 17 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1739 18 and and CC 42759 1739 19 personal personal JJ 42759 1739 20 property property NN 42759 1739 21 would would MD 42759 1739 22 be be VB 42759 1739 23 especially especially RB 42759 1739 24 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 1739 25 to to IN 42759 1739 26 the the DT 42759 1739 27 poorer poor JJR 42759 1739 28 and and CC 42759 1739 29 middle middle JJ 42759 1739 30 classes class NNS 42759 1739 31 because because IN 42759 1739 32 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1739 33 now now RB 42759 1739 34 pay pay VBP 42759 1739 35 a a DT 42759 1739 36 disproportionate disproportionate JJ 42759 1739 37 share share NN 42759 1739 38 of of IN 42759 1739 39 these these DT 42759 1739 40 charges charge NNS 42759 1739 41 . . . 42759 1740 1 Lower low JJR 42759 1740 2 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1740 3 on on IN 42759 1740 4 dwellings dwelling NNS 42759 1740 5 would would MD 42759 1740 6 mean mean VB 42759 1740 7 lower low JJR 42759 1740 8 rents rent NNS 42759 1740 9 for for IN 42759 1740 10 all all DT 42759 1740 11 persons person NNS 42759 1740 12 who who WP 42759 1740 13 did do VBD 42759 1740 14 not not RB 42759 1740 15 own own VB 42759 1740 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1740 17 homes home NNS 42759 1740 18 , , , 42759 1740 19 and and CC 42759 1740 20 lower low JJR 42759 1740 21 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1740 22 for for IN 42759 1740 23 all all DT 42759 1740 24 owners owner NNS 42759 1740 25 whose whose WP$ 42759 1740 26 residence residence NN 42759 1740 27 values value NNS 42759 1740 28 were be VBD 42759 1740 29 unusually unusually RB 42759 1740 30 large large JJ 42759 1740 31 relatively relatively RB 42759 1740 32 to to IN 42759 1740 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1740 34 land land NN 42759 1740 35 values value NNS 42759 1740 36 . . . 42759 1741 1 And and CC 42759 1741 2 the the DT 42759 1741 3 tendency tendency NN 42759 1741 4 to to TO 42759 1741 5 lower lower VB 42759 1741 6 rents rent NNS 42759 1741 7 on on IN 42759 1741 8 dwellings dwelling NNS 42759 1741 9 would would MD 42759 1741 10 be be VB 42759 1741 11 reinforced reinforce VBN 42759 1741 12 by by IN 42759 1741 13 the the DT 42759 1741 14 lower low JJR 42759 1741 15 cost cost NN 42759 1741 16 of of IN 42759 1741 17 building build VBG 42759 1741 18 materials material NNS 42759 1741 19 resulting result VBG 42759 1741 20 , , , 42759 1741 21 as as IN 42759 1741 22 noted note VBN 42759 1741 23 above above IN 42759 1741 24 , , , 42759 1741 25 from from IN 42759 1741 26 the the DT 42759 1741 27 increased increase VBN 42759 1741 28 supply supply NN 42759 1741 29 and and CC 42759 1741 30 the the DT 42759 1741 31 lower low JJR 42759 1741 32 tax tax NN 42759 1741 33 on on IN 42759 1741 34 this this DT 42759 1741 35 form form NN 42759 1741 36 of of IN 42759 1741 37 personal personal JJ 42759 1741 38 property property NN 42759 1741 39 . . . 42759 1742 1 Lower low JJR 42759 1742 2 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1742 3 on on IN 42759 1742 4 that that DT 42759 1742 5 species specie NNS 42759 1742 6 of of IN 42759 1742 7 personal personal JJ 42759 1742 8 property property NN 42759 1742 9 which which WDT 42759 1742 10 consists consist VBZ 42759 1742 11 of of IN 42759 1742 12 consumers consumer NNS 42759 1742 13 ' ' POS 42759 1742 14 goods good NNS 42759 1742 15 , , , 42759 1742 16 such such JJ 42759 1742 17 as as IN 42759 1742 18 household household NN 42759 1742 19 furniture furniture NN 42759 1742 20 and and CC 42759 1742 21 wearing wear VBG 42759 1742 22 apparel apparel NN 42759 1742 23 , , , 42759 1742 24 would would MD 42759 1742 25 lessen lessen VB 42759 1742 26 the the DT 42759 1742 27 present present JJ 42759 1742 28 inequity inequity NN 42759 1742 29 of of IN 42759 1742 30 taxation taxation NN 42759 1742 31 because because IN 42759 1742 32 this this DT 42759 1742 33 class class NN 42759 1742 34 of of IN 42759 1742 35 goods good NNS 42759 1742 36 is be VBZ 42759 1742 37 reached reach VBN 42759 1742 38 to to IN 42759 1742 39 a a DT 42759 1742 40 much much RB 42759 1742 41 greater great JJR 42759 1742 42 extent extent NN 42759 1742 43 in in IN 42759 1742 44 the the DT 42759 1742 45 case case NN 42759 1742 46 of of IN 42759 1742 47 the the DT 42759 1742 48 poor poor JJ 42759 1742 49 than than IN 42759 1742 50 in in IN 42759 1742 51 the the DT 42759 1742 52 case case NN 42759 1742 53 of of IN 42759 1742 54 the the DT 42759 1742 55 rich rich JJ 42759 1742 56 . . . 42759 1743 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1743 2 is be VBZ 42759 1743 3 not not RB 42759 1743 4 easy easy JJ 42759 1743 5 to to TO 42759 1743 6 conceal conceal VB 42759 1743 7 or or CC 42759 1743 8 to to TO 42759 1743 9 undervalue undervalue VB 42759 1743 10 a a DT 42759 1743 11 relatively relatively RB 42759 1743 12 small small JJ 42759 1743 13 number number NN 42759 1743 14 of of IN 42759 1743 15 simple simple JJ 42759 1743 16 and and CC 42759 1743 17 standard standard JJ 42759 1743 18 articles article NNS 42759 1743 19 ; ; : 42759 1743 20 but but CC 42759 1743 21 diamonds diamond NNS 42759 1743 22 , , , 42759 1743 23 costly costly JJ 42759 1743 24 furniture furniture NN 42759 1743 25 , , , 42759 1743 26 and and CC 42759 1743 27 luxurious luxurious JJ 42759 1743 28 wardrobes wardrobe NNS 42759 1743 29 can can MD 42759 1743 30 be be VB 42759 1743 31 either either CC 42759 1743 32 hidden hide VBN 42759 1743 33 , , , 42759 1743 34 or or CC 42759 1743 35 certified certify VBN 42759 1743 36 to to IN 42759 1743 37 the the DT 42759 1743 38 assessor assessor NN 42759 1743 39 at at IN 42759 1743 40 a a DT 42759 1743 41 low low JJ 42759 1743 42 valuation valuation NN 42759 1743 43 . . . 42759 1744 1 As as IN 42759 1744 2 for for IN 42759 1744 3 those those DT 42759 1744 4 forms form NNS 42759 1744 5 of of IN 42759 1744 6 personal personal JJ 42759 1744 7 property property NN 42759 1744 8 which which WDT 42759 1744 9 are be VBP 42759 1744 10 of of IN 42759 1744 11 the the DT 42759 1744 12 nature nature NN 42759 1744 13 of of IN 42759 1744 14 capital capital NN 42759 1744 15 and and CC 42759 1744 16 other other JJ 42759 1744 17 profit profit NN 42759 1744 18 producing produce VBG 42759 1744 19 goods good NNS 42759 1744 20 , , , 42759 1744 21 such such JJ 42759 1744 22 as as IN 42759 1744 23 machinery machinery NN 42759 1744 24 and and CC 42759 1744 25 tools tool NNS 42759 1744 26 of of IN 42759 1744 27 all all DT 42759 1744 28 kinds kind NNS 42759 1744 29 , , , 42759 1744 30 productive productive JJ 42759 1744 31 animals animal NNS 42759 1744 32 , , , 42759 1744 33 money money NN 42759 1744 34 , , , 42759 1744 35 mortgages mortgage NNS 42759 1744 36 , , , 42759 1744 37 securities security NNS 42759 1744 38 , , , 42759 1744 39 the the DT 42759 1744 40 stocks stock NNS 42759 1744 41 of of IN 42759 1744 42 goods good NNS 42759 1744 43 held hold VBN 42759 1744 44 by by IN 42759 1744 45 manufacturers manufacturer NNS 42759 1744 46 and and CC 42759 1744 47 merchants merchant NNS 42759 1744 48 , , , 42759 1744 49 and and CC 42759 1744 50 likewise likewise RB 42759 1744 51 buildings building NNS 42759 1744 52 which which WDT 42759 1744 53 are be VBP 42759 1744 54 used use VBN 42759 1744 55 for for IN 42759 1744 56 productive productive JJ 42759 1744 57 purposes,--the purposes,--the DT 42759 1744 58 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1744 59 on on IN 42759 1744 60 all all PDT 42759 1744 61 these these DT 42759 1744 62 kinds kind NNS 42759 1744 63 of of IN 42759 1744 64 property property NN 42759 1744 65 are be VBP 42759 1744 66 for for IN 42759 1744 67 the the DT 42759 1744 68 most most JJS 42759 1744 69 part part NN 42759 1744 70 shifted shift VBD 42759 1744 71 to to IN 42759 1744 72 the the DT 42759 1744 73 consumer consumer NN 42759 1744 74 . . . 42759 1745 1 The the DT 42759 1745 2 latter latter JJ 42759 1745 3 ultimately ultimately RB 42759 1745 4 pays pay VBZ 42759 1745 5 the the DT 42759 1745 6 tax tax NN 42759 1745 7 in in IN 42759 1745 8 the the DT 42759 1745 9 form form NN 42759 1745 10 of of IN 42759 1745 11 higher high JJR 42759 1745 12 prices price NNS 42759 1745 13 for for IN 42759 1745 14 food food NN 42759 1745 15 , , , 42759 1745 16 clothing clothing NN 42759 1745 17 , , , 42759 1745 18 shelter shelter NN 42759 1745 19 , , , 42759 1745 20 and and CC 42759 1745 21 the the DT 42759 1745 22 other other JJ 42759 1745 23 necessaries necessary NNS 42759 1745 24 and and CC 42759 1745 25 comforts comfort NNS 42759 1745 26 of of IN 42759 1745 27 life life NN 42759 1745 28 . . . 42759 1746 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1746 2 106 106 CD 42759 1746 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1746 4 Now now RB 42759 1746 5 a a DT 42759 1746 6 tax tax NN 42759 1746 7 on on IN 42759 1746 8 consumption consumption NN 42759 1746 9 is be VBZ 42759 1746 10 notoriously notoriously RB 42759 1746 11 unfair unfair JJ 42759 1746 12 to to IN 42759 1746 13 the the DT 42759 1746 14 poorer poor JJR 42759 1746 15 and and CC 42759 1746 16 middle middle JJ 42759 1746 17 classes class NNS 42759 1746 18 because because IN 42759 1746 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1746 20 affects affect VBZ 42759 1746 21 a a DT 42759 1746 22 greater great JJR 42759 1746 23 portion portion NN 42759 1746 24 of of IN 42759 1746 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1746 26 total total JJ 42759 1746 27 expenditures expenditure NNS 42759 1746 28 , , , 42759 1746 29 and and CC 42759 1746 30 takes take VBZ 42759 1746 31 a a DT 42759 1746 32 larger large JJR 42759 1746 33 per per IN 42759 1746 34 cent cent NN 42759 1746 35 . . . 42759 1747 1 of of IN 42759 1747 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1747 3 income income NN 42759 1747 4 than than IN 42759 1747 5 in in IN 42759 1747 6 the the DT 42759 1747 7 case case NN 42759 1747 8 of of IN 42759 1747 9 the the DT 42759 1747 10 rich rich JJ 42759 1747 11 . . . 42759 1748 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1748 2 the the DT 42759 1748 3 removal removal NN 42759 1748 4 of of IN 42759 1748 5 the the DT 42759 1748 6 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1748 7 specified specify VBN 42759 1748 8 in in IN 42759 1748 9 this this DT 42759 1748 10 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 1748 11 would would MD 42759 1748 12 be be VB 42759 1748 13 at at IN 42759 1748 14 once once RB 42759 1748 15 the the DT 42759 1748 16 abolition abolition NN 42759 1748 17 of of IN 42759 1748 18 a a DT 42759 1748 19 fiscal fiscal JJ 42759 1748 20 injustice injustice NN 42759 1748 21 , , , 42759 1748 22 and and CC 42759 1748 23 a a DT 42759 1748 24 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1748 25 assistance assistance NN 42759 1748 26 to to IN 42759 1748 27 the the DT 42759 1748 28 less less RBR 42759 1748 29 fortunate fortunate JJ 42759 1748 30 classes class NNS 42759 1748 31 . . . 42759 1749 1 All all PDT 42759 1749 2 those those DT 42759 1749 3 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1749 4 who who WP 42759 1749 5 occupied occupy VBD 42759 1749 6 rented rent VBN 42759 1749 7 dwellings dwelling NNS 42759 1749 8 would would MD 42759 1749 9 benefit benefit VB 42759 1749 10 by by IN 42759 1749 11 the the DT 42759 1749 12 reduction reduction NN 42759 1749 13 in in IN 42759 1749 14 house house NN 42759 1749 15 rent rent NN 42759 1749 16 , , , 42759 1749 17 and and CC 42759 1749 18 all all DT 42759 1749 19 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1749 20 without without IN 42759 1749 21 exception exception NN 42759 1749 22 would would MD 42759 1749 23 reap reap VB 42759 1749 24 some some DT 42759 1749 25 advantage advantage NN 42759 1749 26 from from IN 42759 1749 27 the the DT 42759 1749 28 reduction reduction NN 42759 1749 29 or or CC 42759 1749 30 abolition abolition NN 42759 1749 31 of of IN 42759 1749 32 the the DT 42759 1749 33 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1749 34 on on IN 42759 1749 35 consumers consumer NNS 42759 1749 36 ' ' POS 42759 1749 37 goods good NNS 42759 1749 38 and and CC 42759 1749 39 on on IN 42759 1749 40 the the DT 42759 1749 41 various various JJ 42759 1749 42 forms form NNS 42759 1749 43 of of IN 42759 1749 44 producers producer NNS 42759 1749 45 ' ' POS 42759 1749 46 goods good NNS 42759 1749 47 . . . 42759 1750 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1750 2 is be VBZ 42759 1750 3 not not RB 42759 1750 4 improbable improbable JJ 42759 1750 5 that that IN 42759 1750 6 a a DT 42759 1750 7 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1750 8 proportion proportion NN 42759 1750 9 of of IN 42759 1750 10 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1750 11 would would MD 42759 1750 12 gain gain VB 42759 1750 13 as as RB 42759 1750 14 much much JJ 42759 1750 15 in in IN 42759 1750 16 these these DT 42759 1750 17 respects respect NNS 42759 1750 18 as as IN 42759 1750 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1750 20 would would MD 42759 1750 21 lose lose VB 42759 1750 22 in in IN 42759 1750 23 the the DT 42759 1750 24 capacity capacity NN 42759 1750 25 of of IN 42759 1750 26 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1750 27 . . . 42759 1751 1 Would Would MD 42759 1751 2 the the DT 42759 1751 3 social social JJ 42759 1751 4 benefits benefit NNS 42759 1751 5 summarily summarily RB 42759 1751 6 described describe VBN 42759 1751 7 in in IN 42759 1751 8 the the DT 42759 1751 9 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 1751 10 paragraphs paragraph NNS 42759 1751 11 be be VB 42759 1751 12 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 1751 13 to to TO 42759 1751 14 justify justify VB 42759 1751 15 the the DT 42759 1751 16 increased increase VBN 42759 1751 17 land land NN 42759 1751 18 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1751 19 in in IN 42759 1751 20 the the DT 42759 1751 21 face face NN 42759 1751 22 of of IN 42759 1751 23 the the DT 42759 1751 24 losses loss NNS 42759 1751 25 that that WDT 42759 1751 26 would would MD 42759 1751 27 be be VB 42759 1751 28 undergone undergo VBN 42759 1751 29 by by IN 42759 1751 30 some some DT 42759 1751 31 landowners landowner NNS 42759 1751 32 in in IN 42759 1751 33 the the DT 42759 1751 34 three three CD 42759 1751 35 ways way NNS 42759 1751 36 already already RB 42759 1751 37 specified specify VBN 42759 1751 38 ? ? . 42759 1752 1 In in IN 42759 1752 2 view view NN 42759 1752 3 of of IN 42759 1752 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1752 5 ignorance ignorance NN 42759 1752 6 concerning concern VBG 42759 1752 7 the the DT 42759 1752 8 probable probable JJ 42759 1752 9 amount amount NN 42759 1752 10 of of IN 42759 1752 11 benefits benefit NNS 42759 1752 12 on on IN 42759 1752 13 the the DT 42759 1752 14 one one CD 42759 1752 15 hand hand NN 42759 1752 16 and and CC 42759 1752 17 losses loss NNS 42759 1752 18 on on IN 42759 1752 19 the the DT 42759 1752 20 other other JJ 42759 1752 21 , , , 42759 1752 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1752 23 is be VBZ 42759 1752 24 impossible impossible JJ 42759 1752 25 to to TO 42759 1752 26 give give VB 42759 1752 27 a a DT 42759 1752 28 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 42759 1752 29 answer answer NN 42759 1752 30 . . . 42759 1753 1 However however RB 42759 1753 2 , , , 42759 1753 3 when when WRB 42759 1753 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1753 5 reflect reflect VBP 42759 1753 6 on on IN 42759 1753 7 the the DT 42759 1753 8 manifold manifold JJ 42759 1753 9 social social JJ 42759 1753 10 evils evil NNS 42759 1753 11 that that WDT 42759 1753 12 are be VBP 42759 1753 13 threatened threaten VBN 42759 1753 14 by by IN 42759 1753 15 a a DT 42759 1753 16 rapid rapid JJ 42759 1753 17 and and CC 42759 1753 18 continuous continuous JJ 42759 1753 19 increase increase NN 42759 1753 20 in in IN 42759 1753 21 land land NN 42759 1753 22 values value NNS 42759 1753 23 , , , 42759 1753 24 and and CC 42759 1753 25 the the DT 42759 1753 26 resulting result VBG 42759 1753 27 decrease decrease NN 42759 1753 28 in in IN 42759 1753 29 the the DT 42759 1753 30 proportion proportion NN 42759 1753 31 of of IN 42759 1753 32 the the DT 42759 1753 33 population population NN 42759 1753 34 that that WDT 42759 1753 35 can can MD 42759 1753 36 hope hope VB 42759 1753 37 to to TO 42759 1753 38 participate participate VB 42759 1753 39 in in IN 42759 1753 40 the the DT 42759 1753 41 ownership ownership NN 42759 1753 42 of of IN 42759 1753 43 land land NN 42759 1753 44 , , , 42759 1753 45 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1753 46 are be VBP 42759 1753 47 forced force VBN 42759 1753 48 to to TO 42759 1753 49 conclude conclude VB 42759 1753 50 that that IN 42759 1753 51 some some DT 42759 1753 52 means mean NNS 42759 1753 53 of of IN 42759 1753 54 checking check VBG 42759 1753 55 both both DT 42759 1753 56 tendencies tendency NNS 42759 1753 57 is be VBZ 42759 1753 58 urgently urgently RB 42759 1753 59 necessary necessary JJ 42759 1753 60 for for IN 42759 1753 61 the the DT 42759 1753 62 sake sake NN 42759 1753 63 of of IN 42759 1753 64 social social JJ 42759 1753 65 justice justice NN 42759 1753 66 and and CC 42759 1753 67 social social JJ 42759 1753 68 peace peace NN 42759 1753 69 . . . 42759 1754 1 The the DT 42759 1754 2 project project NN 42759 1754 3 that that WDT 42759 1754 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1754 5 have have VBP 42759 1754 6 been be VBN 42759 1754 7 considering consider VBG 42759 1754 8 ; ; : 42759 1754 9 namely namely RB 42759 1754 10 , , , 42759 1754 11 the the DT 42759 1754 12 transfer transfer NN 42759 1754 13 of of IN 42759 1754 14 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1754 15 on on IN 42759 1754 16 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1754 17 and and CC 42759 1754 18 on on IN 42759 1754 19 personal personal JJ 42759 1754 20 property property NN 42759 1754 21 to to TO 42759 1754 22 land land NN 42759 1754 23 by by IN 42759 1754 24 a a DT 42759 1754 25 process process NN 42759 1754 26 extending extend VBG 42759 1754 27 over over IN 42759 1754 28 twenty twenty CD 42759 1754 29 years year NNS 42759 1754 30 , , , 42759 1754 31 seems seem VBZ 42759 1754 32 to to TO 42759 1754 33 involve involve VB 42759 1754 34 a a DT 42759 1754 35 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 1754 36 large large JJ 42759 1754 37 amount amount NN 42759 1754 38 of of IN 42759 1754 39 advantage advantage NN 42759 1754 40 and and CC 42759 1754 41 a a DT 42759 1754 42 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 1754 43 small small JJ 42759 1754 44 amount amount NN 42759 1754 45 of of IN 42759 1754 46 disadvantage disadvantage NN 42759 1754 47 to to TO 42759 1754 48 justify justify VB 42759 1754 49 systematic systematic JJ 42759 1754 50 and and CC 42759 1754 51 careful careful JJ 42759 1754 52 experiment experiment NN 42759 1754 53 . . . 42759 1755 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1755 2 A a DT 42759 1755 3 Supertax Supertax NNP 42759 1755 4 on on IN 42759 1755 5 Large large JJ 42759 1755 6 Holdings Holdings NNPS 42759 1755 7 _ _ NNP 42759 1755 8 Every every DT 42759 1755 9 estate estate NN 42759 1755 10 containing contain VBG 42759 1755 11 more more JJR 42759 1755 12 than than IN 42759 1755 13 a a DT 42759 1755 14 maximum maximum JJ 42759 1755 15 number number NN 42759 1755 16 of of IN 42759 1755 17 acres acre NNS 42759 1755 18 , , , 42759 1755 19 say say UH 42759 1755 20 , , , 42759 1755 21 ten ten CD 42759 1755 22 thousand thousand CD 42759 1755 23 , , , 42759 1755 24 whether whether IN 42759 1755 25 composed compose VBN 42759 1755 26 of of IN 42759 1755 27 a a DT 42759 1755 28 single single JJ 42759 1755 29 tract tract NN 42759 1755 30 or or CC 42759 1755 31 of of IN 42759 1755 32 several several JJ 42759 1755 33 tracts tract NNS 42759 1755 34 , , , 42759 1755 35 could could MD 42759 1755 36 be be VB 42759 1755 37 compelled compel VBN 42759 1755 38 to to TO 42759 1755 39 pay pay VB 42759 1755 40 a a DT 42759 1755 41 special special JJ 42759 1755 42 tax tax NN 42759 1755 43 in in IN 42759 1755 44 addition addition NN 42759 1755 45 to to IN 42759 1755 46 the the DT 42759 1755 47 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 1755 48 tax tax NN 42759 1755 49 levied levy VBN 42759 1755 50 on on IN 42759 1755 51 land land NN 42759 1755 52 of of IN 42759 1755 53 the the DT 42759 1755 54 same same JJ 42759 1755 55 value value NN 42759 1755 56 . . . 42759 1756 1 The the DT 42759 1756 2 rate rate NN 42759 1756 3 of of IN 42759 1756 4 this this DT 42759 1756 5 supertax supertax NN 42759 1756 6 should should MD 42759 1756 7 increase increase VB 42759 1756 8 with with IN 42759 1756 9 the the DT 42759 1756 10 size size NN 42759 1756 11 of of IN 42759 1756 12 the the DT 42759 1756 13 estate estate NN 42759 1756 14 above above IN 42759 1756 15 the the DT 42759 1756 16 fixed fix VBN 42759 1756 17 maximum maximum NN 42759 1756 18 . . . 42759 1757 1 Through through IN 42759 1757 2 this this DT 42759 1757 3 device device NN 42759 1757 4 large large JJ 42759 1757 5 holdings holding NNS 42759 1757 6 could could MD 42759 1757 7 be be VB 42759 1757 8 broken break VBN 42759 1757 9 up up RP 42759 1757 10 , , , 42759 1757 11 and and CC 42759 1757 12 divided divide VBN 42759 1757 13 among among IN 42759 1757 14 many many JJ 42759 1757 15 owners owner NNS 42759 1757 16 and and CC 42759 1757 17 occupiers occupier NNS 42759 1757 18 . . . 42759 1758 1 For for IN 42759 1758 2 several several JJ 42759 1758 3 years year NNS 42759 1758 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1758 5 has have VBZ 42759 1758 6 been be VBN 42759 1758 7 successfully successfully RB 42759 1758 8 applied apply VBN 42759 1758 9 for for IN 42759 1758 10 this this DT 42759 1758 11 purpose purpose NN 42759 1758 12 in in IN 42759 1758 13 New New NNP 42759 1758 14 Zealand Zealand NNP 42759 1758 15 and and CC 42759 1758 16 Australia Australia NNP 42759 1758 17 . . . 42759 1759 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1759 2 107 107 CD 42759 1759 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1759 4 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 1759 5 as as IN 42759 1759 6 this this DT 42759 1759 7 tax tax NN 42759 1759 8 exemplifies exemplify VBZ 42759 1759 9 the the DT 42759 1759 10 principle principle NN 42759 1759 11 of of IN 42759 1759 12 progression progression NN 42759 1759 13 , , , 42759 1759 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1759 15 is be VBZ 42759 1759 16 in in IN 42759 1759 17 accord accord NN 42759 1759 18 with with IN 42759 1759 19 the the DT 42759 1759 20 principles principle NNS 42759 1759 21 of of IN 42759 1759 22 justice justice NN 42759 1759 23 ; ; : 42759 1759 24 for for IN 42759 1759 25 relative relative JJ 42759 1759 26 ability ability NN 42759 1759 27 to to TO 42759 1759 28 pay pay VB 42759 1759 29 is be VBZ 42759 1759 30 closely closely RB 42759 1759 31 connected connect VBN 42759 1759 32 with with IN 42759 1759 33 relative relative JJ 42759 1759 34 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 1759 35 . . . 42759 1760 1 Other other JJ 42759 1760 2 things thing NNS 42759 1760 3 being be VBG 42759 1760 4 equal equal JJ 42759 1760 5 , , , 42759 1760 6 the the DT 42759 1760 7 less less RBR 42759 1760 8 the the DT 42759 1760 9 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 1760 10 involved involve VBN 42759 1760 11 , , , 42759 1760 12 the the DT 42759 1760 13 greater great JJR 42759 1760 14 is be VBZ 42759 1760 15 the the DT 42759 1760 16 ability ability NN 42759 1760 17 of of IN 42759 1760 18 the the DT 42759 1760 19 individual individual NN 42759 1760 20 to to TO 42759 1760 21 pay pay VB 42759 1760 22 the the DT 42759 1760 23 tax tax NN 42759 1760 24 . . . 42759 1761 1 Thus thus RB 42759 1761 2 , , , 42759 1761 3 the the DT 42759 1761 4 man man NN 42759 1761 5 with with IN 42759 1761 6 an an DT 42759 1761 7 income income NN 42759 1761 8 of of IN 42759 1761 9 ten ten CD 42759 1761 10 thousand thousand CD 42759 1761 11 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1761 12 a a DT 42759 1761 13 year year NN 42759 1761 14 makes make VBZ 42759 1761 15 a a DT 42759 1761 16 smaller small JJR 42759 1761 17 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 1761 18 in in IN 42759 1761 19 giving give VBG 42759 1761 20 up up RP 42759 1761 21 two two CD 42759 1761 22 per per IN 42759 1761 23 cent cent NN 42759 1761 24 . . . 42759 1762 1 of of IN 42759 1762 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1762 3 than than IN 42759 1762 4 the the DT 42759 1762 5 man man NN 42759 1762 6 whose whose WP$ 42759 1762 7 income income NN 42759 1762 8 is be VBZ 42759 1762 9 only only RB 42759 1762 10 one one CD 42759 1762 11 thousand thousand CD 42759 1762 12 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1762 13 ; ; : 42759 1762 14 for for IN 42759 1762 15 the the DT 42759 1762 16 latter latter JJ 42759 1762 17 case case NN 42759 1762 18 the the DT 42759 1762 19 twenty twenty CD 42759 1762 20 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1762 21 surrendered surrender VBN 42759 1762 22 represent represent VBP 42759 1762 23 a a DT 42759 1762 24 privation privation NN 42759 1762 25 of of IN 42759 1762 26 the the DT 42759 1762 27 necessaries necessary NNS 42759 1762 28 or or CC 42759 1762 29 the the DT 42759 1762 30 elementary elementary JJ 42759 1762 31 comforts comfort NNS 42759 1762 32 of of IN 42759 1762 33 life life NN 42759 1762 34 , , , 42759 1762 35 while while IN 42759 1762 36 the the DT 42759 1762 37 two two CD 42759 1762 38 hundred hundred CD 42759 1762 39 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1762 40 taken take VBN 42759 1762 41 from from IN 42759 1762 42 the the DT 42759 1762 43 rich rich JJ 42759 1762 44 man man NN 42759 1762 45 would would MD 42759 1762 46 have have VB 42759 1762 47 been be VBN 42759 1762 48 expended expend VBN 42759 1762 49 for for IN 42759 1762 50 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 1762 51 or or CC 42759 1762 52 converted convert VBN 42759 1762 53 into into IN 42759 1762 54 capital capital NN 42759 1762 55 . . . 42759 1763 1 While while IN 42759 1763 2 the the DT 42759 1763 3 incomes income NNS 42759 1763 4 of of IN 42759 1763 5 both both DT 42759 1763 6 are be VBP 42759 1763 7 reduced reduce VBN 42759 1763 8 in in IN 42759 1763 9 the the DT 42759 1763 10 same same JJ 42759 1763 11 proportion proportion NN 42759 1763 12 , , , 42759 1763 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1763 14 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 42759 1763 15 are be VBP 42759 1763 16 not not RB 42759 1763 17 diminished diminish VBN 42759 1763 18 to to IN 42759 1763 19 the the DT 42759 1763 20 same same JJ 42759 1763 21 degree degree NN 42759 1763 22 . . . 42759 1764 1 The the DT 42759 1764 2 wants want NNS 42759 1764 3 that that WDT 42759 1764 4 are be VBP 42759 1764 5 deprived deprive VBN 42759 1764 6 of of IN 42759 1764 7 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 1764 8 are be VBP 42759 1764 9 much much RB 42759 1764 10 less less RBR 42759 1764 11 important important JJ 42759 1764 12 in in IN 42759 1764 13 the the DT 42759 1764 14 case case NN 42759 1764 15 of of IN 42759 1764 16 the the DT 42759 1764 17 richer rich JJR 42759 1764 18 than than IN 42759 1764 19 in in IN 42759 1764 20 that that DT 42759 1764 21 of of IN 42759 1764 22 the the DT 42759 1764 23 poorer poor JJR 42759 1764 24 man man NN 42759 1764 25 . . . 42759 1765 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1765 2 the the DT 42759 1765 3 only only JJ 42759 1765 4 way way NN 42759 1765 5 to to TO 42759 1765 6 bring bring VB 42759 1765 7 about about IN 42759 1765 8 anything anything NN 42759 1765 9 like like IN 42759 1765 10 equality equality NN 42759 1765 11 of of IN 42759 1765 12 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 1765 13 between between IN 42759 1765 14 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1765 15 is be VBZ 42759 1765 16 to to TO 42759 1765 17 increase increase VB 42759 1765 18 the the DT 42759 1765 19 proportion proportion NN 42759 1765 20 of of IN 42759 1765 21 income income NN 42759 1765 22 taken take VBN 42759 1765 23 from from IN 42759 1765 24 the the DT 42759 1765 25 former former JJ 42759 1765 26 . . . 42759 1766 1 This this DT 42759 1766 2 means mean VBZ 42759 1766 3 that that IN 42759 1766 4 the the DT 42759 1766 5 rate rate NN 42759 1766 6 of of IN 42759 1766 7 taxation taxation NN 42759 1766 8 would would MD 42759 1766 9 be be VB 42759 1766 10 progressive progressive JJ 42759 1766 11 . . . 42759 1767 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1767 2 108 108 CD 42759 1767 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1767 4 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1767 5 is be VBZ 42759 1767 6 in in IN 42759 1767 7 order order NN 42759 1767 8 to to TO 42759 1767 9 object object VB 42759 1767 10 that that IN 42759 1767 11 the the DT 42759 1767 12 principle principle NN 42759 1767 13 of of IN 42759 1767 14 progression progression NN 42759 1767 15 should should MD 42759 1767 16 not not RB 42759 1767 17 be be VB 42759 1767 18 applied apply VBN 42759 1767 19 to to IN 42759 1767 20 the the DT 42759 1767 21 taxation taxation NN 42759 1767 22 of of IN 42759 1767 23 great great JJ 42759 1767 24 landed landed JJ 42759 1767 25 estates estate NNS 42759 1767 26 , , , 42759 1767 27 since since IN 42759 1767 28 a a DT 42759 1767 29 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1767 30 part part NN 42759 1767 31 of of IN 42759 1767 32 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1767 33 is be VBZ 42759 1767 34 unproductive unproductive JJ 42759 1767 35 , , , 42759 1767 36 and and CC 42759 1767 37 consequently consequently RB 42759 1767 38 does do VBZ 42759 1767 39 not not RB 42759 1767 40 directly directly RB 42759 1767 41 affect affect VB 42759 1767 42 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 1767 43 . . . 42759 1768 1 But but CC 42759 1768 2 the the DT 42759 1768 3 same same JJ 42759 1768 4 objection objection NN 42759 1768 5 can can MD 42759 1768 6 be be VB 42759 1768 7 urged urge VBN 42759 1768 8 against against IN 42759 1768 9 any any DT 42759 1768 10 taxation taxation NN 42759 1768 11 of of IN 42759 1768 12 unoccupied unoccupied JJ 42759 1768 13 land land NN 42759 1768 14 . . . 42759 1769 1 The the DT 42759 1769 2 obvious obvious JJ 42759 1769 3 reply reply NN 42759 1769 4 is be VBZ 42759 1769 5 that that IN 42759 1769 6 the the DT 42759 1769 7 equal equal JJ 42759 1769 8 taxation taxation NN 42759 1769 9 of of IN 42759 1769 10 unproductive unproductive NN 42759 1769 11 with with IN 42759 1769 12 productive productive JJ 42759 1769 13 land land NN 42759 1769 14 is be VBZ 42759 1769 15 justified justify VBN 42759 1769 16 by by IN 42759 1769 17 social social JJ 42759 1769 18 reasons reason NNS 42759 1769 19 , , , 42759 1769 20 chiefly chiefly RB 42759 1769 21 , , , 42759 1769 22 the the DT 42759 1769 23 unwisdom unwisdom NN 42759 1769 24 of of IN 42759 1769 25 permitting permit VBG 42759 1769 26 land land NN 42759 1769 27 to to TO 42759 1769 28 be be VB 42759 1769 29 held hold VBN 42759 1769 30 out out IN 42759 1769 31 of of IN 42759 1769 32 use use NN 42759 1769 33 . . . 42759 1770 1 The the DT 42759 1770 2 same same JJ 42759 1770 3 social social JJ 42759 1770 4 reasons reason NNS 42759 1770 5 apply apply VBP 42759 1770 6 to to IN 42759 1770 7 the the DT 42759 1770 8 question question NN 42759 1770 9 of of IN 42759 1770 10 levying levy VBG 42759 1770 11 an an DT 42759 1770 12 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 1770 13 high high JJ 42759 1770 14 tax tax NN 42759 1770 15 on on IN 42759 1770 16 large large JJ 42759 1770 17 estates estate NNS 42759 1770 18 , , , 42759 1770 19 even even RB 42759 1770 20 though though IN 42759 1770 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1770 22 may may MD 42759 1770 23 at at IN 42759 1770 24 present present JJ 42759 1770 25 produce produce NN 42759 1770 26 no no DT 42759 1770 27 revenue revenue NN 42759 1770 28 . . . 42759 1771 1 While while IN 42759 1771 2 the the DT 42759 1771 3 tax tax NN 42759 1771 4 is be VBZ 42759 1771 5 sound sound JJ 42759 1771 6 in in IN 42759 1771 7 principle principle NN 42759 1771 8 , , , 42759 1771 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1771 10 is be VBZ 42759 1771 11 probably probably RB 42759 1771 12 not not RB 42759 1771 13 much much RB 42759 1771 14 needed need VBN 42759 1771 15 in in IN 42759 1771 16 America America NNP 42759 1771 17 in in IN 42759 1771 18 connection connection NN 42759 1771 19 with with IN 42759 1771 20 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 1771 21 or or CC 42759 1771 22 urban urban JJ 42759 1771 23 land land NN 42759 1771 24 . . . 42759 1772 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1772 2 main main JJ 42759 1772 3 sphere sphere NN 42759 1772 4 of of IN 42759 1772 5 usefulness usefulness NN 42759 1772 6 would would MD 42759 1772 7 seem seem VB 42759 1772 8 to to TO 42759 1772 9 be be VB 42759 1772 10 certain certain JJ 42759 1772 11 great great JJ 42759 1772 12 holdings holding NNS 42759 1772 13 of of IN 42759 1772 14 mineral mineral NN 42759 1772 15 , , , 42759 1772 16 timber timber NN 42759 1772 17 , , , 42759 1772 18 and and CC 42759 1772 19 water water NN 42759 1772 20 power power NN 42759 1772 21 lands land NNS 42759 1772 22 . . . 42759 1773 1 " " `` 42759 1773 2 There there EX 42759 1773 3 are be VBP 42759 1773 4 many many JJ 42759 1773 5 great great JJ 42759 1773 6 combinations combination NNS 42759 1773 7 in in IN 42759 1773 8 other other JJ 42759 1773 9 industries industry NNS 42759 1773 10 whose whose WP$ 42759 1773 11 formation formation NN 42759 1773 12 is be VBZ 42759 1773 13 complete complete JJ 42759 1773 14 . . . 42759 1774 1 In in IN 42759 1774 2 the the DT 42759 1774 3 lumber lumber NN 42759 1774 4 industry industry NN 42759 1774 5 , , , 42759 1774 6 on on IN 42759 1774 7 the the DT 42759 1774 8 other other JJ 42759 1774 9 hand hand NN 42759 1774 10 , , , 42759 1774 11 the the DT 42759 1774 12 Bureau Bureau NNP 42759 1774 13 now now RB 42759 1774 14 finds find VBZ 42759 1774 15 in in IN 42759 1774 16 the the DT 42759 1774 17 making make VBG 42759 1774 18 a a DT 42759 1774 19 combination combination NN 42759 1774 20 caused cause VBN 42759 1774 21 , , , 42759 1774 22 fundamentally fundamentally RB 42759 1774 23 , , , 42759 1774 24 by by IN 42759 1774 25 a a DT 42759 1774 26 long long JJ 42759 1774 27 standing stand VBG 42759 1774 28 public public JJ 42759 1774 29 policy policy NN 42759 1774 30 . . . 42759 1775 1 The the DT 42759 1775 2 concentration concentration NN 42759 1775 3 already already RB 42759 1775 4 existing exist VBG 42759 1775 5 is be VBZ 42759 1775 6 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 1775 7 impressive impressive JJ 42759 1775 8 . . . 42759 1776 1 Still still RB 42759 1776 2 more more RBR 42759 1776 3 impressive impressive JJ 42759 1776 4 are be VBP 42759 1776 5 the the DT 42759 1776 6 possibilities possibility NNS 42759 1776 7 for for IN 42759 1776 8 the the DT 42759 1776 9 future future NN 42759 1776 10 . . . 42759 1777 1 In in IN 42759 1777 2 the the DT 42759 1777 3 last last JJ 42759 1777 4 forty forty CD 42759 1777 5 years year NNS 42759 1777 6 concentration concentration NN 42759 1777 7 has have VBZ 42759 1777 8 so so RB 42759 1777 9 proceeded proceed VBN 42759 1777 10 that that IN 42759 1777 11 195 195 CD 42759 1777 12 holders holder NNS 42759 1777 13 , , , 42759 1777 14 many many JJ 42759 1777 15 interrelated interrelate VBD 42759 1777 16 , , , 42759 1777 17 now now RB 42759 1777 18 have have VBP 42759 1777 19 practically practically RB 42759 1777 20 one one CD 42759 1777 21 - - HYPH 42759 1777 22 half half NN 42759 1777 23 of of IN 42759 1777 24 the the DT 42759 1777 25 privately privately RB 42759 1777 26 owned own VBN 42759 1777 27 timber timber NN 42759 1777 28 in in IN 42759 1777 29 the the DT 42759 1777 30 investigation investigation NN 42759 1777 31 area area NN 42759 1777 32 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1777 33 which which WDT 42759 1777 34 contains contain VBZ 42759 1777 35 eighty eighty CD 42759 1777 36 per per IN 42759 1777 37 cent cent NN 42759 1777 38 . . . 42759 1778 1 of of IN 42759 1778 2 the the DT 42759 1778 3 whole whole NN 42759 1778 4 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1778 5 . . . 42759 1779 1 This this DT 42759 1779 2 formidable formidable JJ 42759 1779 3 process process NN 42759 1779 4 of of IN 42759 1779 5 concentration concentration NN 42759 1779 6 , , , 42759 1779 7 in in IN 42759 1779 8 timber timber NN 42759 1779 9 and and CC 42759 1779 10 in in IN 42759 1779 11 land land NN 42759 1779 12 , , , 42759 1779 13 clearly clearly RB 42759 1779 14 involves involve VBZ 42759 1779 15 grave grave JJ 42759 1779 16 future future JJ 42759 1779 17 possibilities possibility NNS 42759 1779 18 of of IN 42759 1779 19 impregnable impregnable JJ 42759 1779 20 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 1779 21 conditions condition NNS 42759 1779 22 , , , 42759 1779 23 whose whose WP$ 42759 1779 24 far far RB 42759 1779 25 reaching reach VBG 42759 1779 26 consequences consequence NNS 42759 1779 27 to to IN 42759 1779 28 society society NN 42759 1779 29 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1779 30 is be VBZ 42759 1779 31 now now RB 42759 1779 32 difficult difficult JJ 42759 1779 33 to to TO 42759 1779 34 anticipate anticipate VB 42759 1779 35 fully fully RB 42759 1779 36 or or CC 42759 1779 37 to to TO 42759 1779 38 overestimate overestimate VB 42759 1779 39 . . . 42759 1780 1 " " `` 42759 1780 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1780 3 109 109 CD 42759 1780 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1780 5 In in IN 42759 1780 6 January January NNP 42759 1780 7 , , , 42759 1780 8 1916 1916 CD 42759 1780 9 , , , 42759 1780 10 the the DT 42759 1780 11 Secretary Secretary NNP 42759 1780 12 of of IN 42759 1780 13 Agriculture Agriculture NNP 42759 1780 14 called call VBD 42759 1780 15 the the DT 42759 1780 16 attention attention NN 42759 1780 17 of of IN 42759 1780 18 Congress Congress NNP 42759 1780 19 to to IN 42759 1780 20 the the DT 42759 1780 21 fact fact NN 42759 1780 22 that that IN 42759 1780 23 a a DT 42759 1780 24 small small JJ 42759 1780 25 number number NN 42759 1780 26 of of IN 42759 1780 27 corporations corporation NNS 42759 1780 28 closely closely RB 42759 1780 29 associated associate VBN 42759 1780 30 in in IN 42759 1780 31 a a DT 42759 1780 32 policy policy NN 42759 1780 33 of of IN 42759 1780 34 community community NN 42759 1780 35 of of IN 42759 1780 36 interest interest NN 42759 1780 37 were be VBD 42759 1780 38 threatening threaten VBG 42759 1780 39 to to TO 42759 1780 40 secure secure VB 42759 1780 41 and and CC 42759 1780 42 exercise exercise VB 42759 1780 43 a a DT 42759 1780 44 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 1780 45 over over IN 42759 1780 46 the the DT 42759 1780 47 developed developed JJ 42759 1780 48 water water NN 42759 1780 49 power power NN 42759 1780 50 of of IN 42759 1780 51 the the DT 42759 1780 52 country country NN 42759 1780 53 . . . 42759 1781 1 Ninety ninety CD 42759 1781 2 per per IN 42759 1781 3 cent cent NN 42759 1781 4 . . . 42759 1782 1 of of IN 42759 1782 2 the the DT 42759 1782 3 anthracite anthracite NN 42759 1782 4 coal coal NN 42759 1782 5 lands land NNS 42759 1782 6 of of IN 42759 1782 7 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP 42759 1782 8 are be VBP 42759 1782 9 owned own VBN 42759 1782 10 or or CC 42759 1782 11 controlled control VBN 42759 1782 12 by by IN 42759 1782 13 some some DT 42759 1782 14 nine nine CD 42759 1782 15 railroads railroad NNS 42759 1782 16 acting act VBG 42759 1782 17 as as IN 42759 1782 18 a a DT 42759 1782 19 unit unit NN 42759 1782 20 in in IN 42759 1782 21 all all DT 42759 1782 22 important important JJ 42759 1782 23 matters matter NNS 42759 1782 24 . . . 42759 1783 1 For for IN 42759 1783 2 situations situation NNS 42759 1783 3 of of IN 42759 1783 4 this this DT 42759 1783 5 kind kind NN 42759 1783 6 a a DT 42759 1783 7 supertax supertax NN 42759 1783 8 on on IN 42759 1783 9 large large JJ 42759 1783 10 estates estate NNS 42759 1783 11 would would MD 42759 1783 12 seem seem VB 42759 1783 13 to to TO 42759 1783 14 hold hold VB 42759 1783 15 the the DT 42759 1783 16 promise promise NN 42759 1783 17 of of IN 42759 1783 18 a a DT 42759 1783 19 large large JJ 42759 1783 20 measure measure NN 42759 1783 21 of of IN 42759 1783 22 relief relief NN 42759 1783 23 . . . 42759 1784 1 To to TO 42759 1784 2 sum sum VB 42759 1784 3 up up RP 42759 1784 4 the the DT 42759 1784 5 main main JJ 42759 1784 6 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 1784 7 of of IN 42759 1784 8 this this DT 42759 1784 9 very very RB 42759 1784 10 long long JJ 42759 1784 11 chapter chapter NN 42759 1784 12 : : : 42759 1784 13 Exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 1784 14 valuable valuable JJ 42759 1784 15 lands land NNS 42759 1784 16 , , , 42759 1784 17 as as IN 42759 1784 18 those those DT 42759 1784 19 containing contain VBG 42759 1784 20 timber timber NN 42759 1784 21 , , , 42759 1784 22 minerals mineral NNS 42759 1784 23 , , , 42759 1784 24 oil oil NN 42759 1784 25 , , , 42759 1784 26 gas gas NN 42759 1784 27 , , , 42759 1784 28 phosphate phosphate NN 42759 1784 29 , , , 42759 1784 30 and and CC 42759 1784 31 water water NN 42759 1784 32 power power NN 42759 1784 33 , , , 42759 1784 34 which which WDT 42759 1784 35 are be VBP 42759 1784 36 still still RB 42759 1784 37 under under IN 42759 1784 38 public public JJ 42759 1784 39 ownership ownership NN 42759 1784 40 should should MD 42759 1784 41 remain remain VB 42759 1784 42 there there RB 42759 1784 43 . . . 42759 1785 1 Through through IN 42759 1785 2 a a DT 42759 1785 3 judicious judicious JJ 42759 1785 4 system system NN 42759 1785 5 of of IN 42759 1785 6 loans loan NNS 42759 1785 7 , , , 42759 1785 8 deserving deserving JJ 42759 1785 9 and and CC 42759 1785 10 efficient efficient JJ 42759 1785 11 persons person NNS 42759 1785 12 should should MD 42759 1785 13 be be VB 42759 1785 14 assisted assist VBN 42759 1785 15 to to TO 42759 1785 16 get get VB 42759 1785 17 possession possession NN 42759 1785 18 of of IN 42759 1785 19 some some DT 42759 1785 20 land land NN 42759 1785 21 . . . 42759 1786 1 Municipalities municipality NNS 42759 1786 2 should should MD 42759 1786 3 lease lease VB 42759 1786 4 rather rather RB 42759 1786 5 than than IN 42759 1786 6 sell sell VB 42759 1786 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1786 8 lands land NNS 42759 1786 9 , , , 42759 1786 10 and and CC 42759 1786 11 should should MD 42759 1786 12 strive strive VB 42759 1786 13 to to TO 42759 1786 14 increase increase VB 42759 1786 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1786 16 holdings holding NNS 42759 1786 17 . . . 42759 1787 1 To to TO 42759 1787 2 take take VB 42759 1787 3 all all PDT 42759 1787 4 the the DT 42759 1787 5 future future JJ 42759 1787 6 increases increase NNS 42759 1787 7 in in IN 42759 1787 8 the the DT 42759 1787 9 value value NN 42759 1787 10 of of IN 42759 1787 11 land land NN 42759 1787 12 would would MD 42759 1787 13 be be VB 42759 1787 14 morally morally RB 42759 1787 15 lawful lawful JJ 42759 1787 16 , , , 42759 1787 17 provided provide VBN 42759 1787 18 that that IN 42759 1787 19 compensation compensation NN 42759 1787 20 were be VBD 42759 1787 21 given give VBN 42759 1787 22 to to IN 42759 1787 23 owners owner NNS 42759 1787 24 who who WP 42759 1787 25 thereby thereby RB 42759 1787 26 suffered suffer VBD 42759 1787 27 positive positive JJ 42759 1787 28 losses loss NNS 42759 1787 29 of of IN 42759 1787 30 interest interest NN 42759 1787 31 or or CC 42759 1787 32 principal principal NN 42759 1787 33 . . . 42759 1788 1 To to TO 42759 1788 2 take take VB 42759 1788 3 a a DT 42759 1788 4 small small JJ 42759 1788 5 part part NN 42759 1788 6 of of IN 42759 1788 7 the the DT 42759 1788 8 increase increase NN 42759 1788 9 , , , 42759 1788 10 and and CC 42759 1788 11 to to TO 42759 1788 12 transfer transfer VB 42759 1788 13 very very RB 42759 1788 14 gradually gradually RB 42759 1788 15 the the DT 42759 1788 16 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1788 17 on on IN 42759 1788 18 improvements improvement NNS 42759 1788 19 and and CC 42759 1788 20 on on IN 42759 1788 21 personal personal JJ 42759 1788 22 property property NN 42759 1788 23 to to IN 42759 1788 24 land land NN 42759 1788 25 , , , 42759 1788 26 would would MD 42759 1788 27 probably probably RB 42759 1788 28 be be VB 42759 1788 29 just just RB 42759 1788 30 , , , 42759 1788 31 owing owe VBG 42759 1788 32 to to IN 42759 1788 33 the the DT 42759 1788 34 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 1788 35 effects effect NNS 42759 1788 36 upon upon IN 42759 1788 37 public public JJ 42759 1788 38 welfare welfare NN 42759 1788 39 . . . 42759 1789 1 A a DT 42759 1789 2 supertax supertax NN 42759 1789 3 on on IN 42759 1789 4 large large JJ 42759 1789 5 holdings holding NNS 42759 1789 6 of of IN 42759 1789 7 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 1789 8 valuable valuable JJ 42759 1789 9 and and CC 42759 1789 10 scarce scarce JJ 42759 1789 11 land land NN 42759 1789 12 would would MD 42759 1789 13 likewise likewise RB 42759 1789 14 be be VB 42759 1789 15 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 1789 16 and and CC 42759 1789 17 legitimate legitimate JJ 42759 1789 18 . . . 42759 1790 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1790 2 110 110 CD 42759 1790 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1790 4 REFERENCES reference NNS 42759 1790 5 ON on IN 42759 1790 6 SECTION section NN 42759 1790 7 I -PRON- PRP 42759 1790 8 ASHLEY ashley VBP 42759 1790 9 : : : 42759 1790 10 The the DT 42759 1790 11 Origin Origin NNP 42759 1790 12 of of IN 42759 1790 13 Property Property NNP 42759 1790 14 in in IN 42759 1790 15 Land Land NNP 42759 1790 16 . . . 42759 1791 1 London London NNP 42759 1791 2 ; ; : 42759 1791 3 1892 1892 CD 42759 1791 4 . . . 42759 1792 1 LAVELEYE laveleye NN 42759 1792 2 : : : 42759 1792 3 Primitive Primitive NNP 42759 1792 4 Property Property NNP 42759 1792 5 . . . 42759 1793 1 London London NNP 42759 1793 2 ; ; : 42759 1793 3 1878 1878 CD 42759 1793 4 . . . 42759 1794 1 WHITTAKER WHITTAKER NNP 42759 1794 2 : : : 42759 1794 3 The the DT 42759 1794 4 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1794 5 , , , 42759 1794 6 Tenure Tenure NNP 42759 1794 7 , , , 42759 1794 8 and and CC 42759 1794 9 Ownership ownership NN 42759 1794 10 of of IN 42759 1794 11 Land Land NNP 42759 1794 12 . . . 42759 1795 1 London London NNP 42759 1795 2 ; ; : 42759 1795 3 1914 1914 CD 42759 1795 4 . . . 42759 1796 1 PREUSS preuss NN 42759 1796 2 : : : 42759 1796 3 The the DT 42759 1796 4 Fundamental Fundamental NNP 42759 1796 5 Fallacy Fallacy NNP 42759 1796 6 of of IN 42759 1796 7 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 1796 8 . . . 42759 1797 1 St. St. NNP 42759 1797 2 Louis Louis NNP 42759 1797 3 ; ; : 42759 1797 4 1908 1908 CD 42759 1797 5 . . . 42759 1798 1 GEORGE GEORGE NNP 42759 1798 2 : : : 42759 1798 3 Progress Progress NNP 42759 1798 4 and and CC 42759 1798 5 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 1798 6 ; ; : 42759 1798 7 and and CC 42759 1798 8 A a DT 42759 1798 9 Perplexed perplex VBN 42759 1798 10 Philosopher Philosopher NNP 42759 1798 11 . . . 42759 1799 1 MARSH MARSH NNP 42759 1799 2 : : : 42759 1799 3 Land Land NNP 42759 1799 4 Value Value NNP 42759 1799 5 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1799 6 in in IN 42759 1799 7 American American NNP 42759 1799 8 Cities Cities NNP 42759 1799 9 . . . 42759 1800 1 N. N. NNP 42759 1800 2 Y. Y. NNP 42759 1800 3 ; ; : 42759 1800 4 1911 1911 CD 42759 1800 5 . . . 42759 1801 1 FILLEBROWN fillebrown NN 42759 1801 2 : : : 42759 1801 3 A a DT 42759 1801 4 Single Single NNP 42759 1801 5 Tax tax NN 42759 1801 6 Handbook Handbook NNP 42759 1801 7 for for IN 42759 1801 8 1913 1913 CD 42759 1801 9 . . . 42759 1802 1 Boston Boston NNP 42759 1802 2 ; ; : 42759 1802 3 1912 1912 CD 42759 1802 4 . . . 42759 1803 1 YOUNG young JJ 42759 1803 2 : : : 42759 1803 3 The the DT 42759 1803 4 Single Single NNP 42759 1803 5 Tax Tax NNP 42759 1803 6 Movement Movement NNP 42759 1803 7 in in IN 42759 1803 8 the the DT 42759 1803 9 United United NNP 42759 1803 10 States States NNP 42759 1803 11 . . . 42759 1804 1 Princeton Princeton NNP 42759 1804 2 ; ; : 42759 1804 3 1916 1916 CD 42759 1804 4 . . . 42759 1805 1 SHEARMAN SHEARMAN NNP 42759 1805 2 : : : 42759 1805 3 Natural Natural NNP 42759 1805 4 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1805 5 . . . 42759 1806 1 N. N. NNP 42759 1806 2 Y. Y. NNP 42759 1806 3 ; ; : 42759 1806 4 1898 1898 CD 42759 1806 5 . . . 42759 1807 1 MATHEWS MATHEWS NNP 42759 1807 2 : : : 42759 1807 3 Taxation taxation NN 42759 1807 4 and and CC 42759 1807 5 the the DT 42759 1807 6 Distribution distribution NN 42759 1807 7 of of IN 42759 1807 8 Wealth wealth NN 42759 1807 9 . . . 42759 1808 1 N. N. NNP 42759 1808 2 Y. Y. NNP 42759 1808 3 ; ; : 42759 1808 4 1914 1914 CD 42759 1808 5 . . . 42759 1809 1 CATHREIN CATHREIN NNS 42759 1809 2 : : : 42759 1809 3 Das Das NNP 42759 1809 4 Privatgrundeigenthum Privatgrundeigenthum NNP 42759 1809 5 und und JJ 42759 1809 6 seine seine NN 42759 1809 7 Gegner Gegner NNP 42759 1809 8 . . . 42759 1810 1 Freiburg Freiburg NNP 42759 1810 2 ; ; : 42759 1810 3 1909 1909 CD 42759 1810 4 . . . 42759 1811 1 FALLON fallon NN 42759 1811 2 : : : 42759 1811 3 Les Les NNP 42759 1811 4 Plus Plus NNP 42759 1811 5 - - HYPH 42759 1811 6 Values Values NNP 42759 1811 7 et et NN 42759 1811 8 l'Impot l'Impot NNP 42759 1811 9 . . . 42759 1812 1 Paris Paris NNP 42759 1812 2 ; ; : 42759 1812 3 1914 1914 CD 42759 1812 4 . . . 42759 1813 1 NEARING nearing NN 42759 1813 2 : : : 42759 1813 3 Anthracite anthracite NN 42759 1813 4 . . . 42759 1814 1 Philadelphia Philadelphia NNP 42759 1814 2 ; ; : 42759 1814 3 1916 1916 CD 42759 1814 4 . . . 42759 1815 1 HAIG HAIG NNP 42759 1815 2 : : : 42759 1815 3 Final Final NNP 42759 1815 4 Report Report NNP 42759 1815 5 of of IN 42759 1815 6 the the DT 42759 1815 7 Committee Committee NNP 42759 1815 8 on on IN 42759 1815 9 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1815 10 of of IN 42759 1815 11 the the DT 42759 1815 12 City City NNP 42759 1815 13 of of IN 42759 1815 14 New New NNP 42759 1815 15 York York NNP 42759 1815 16 ; ; : 42759 1815 17 1916 1916 CD 42759 1815 18 . . . 42759 1816 1 The the DT 42759 1816 2 exemption exemption NN 42759 1816 3 of of IN 42759 1816 4 Improvements Improvements NNPS 42759 1816 5 from from IN 42759 1816 6 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1816 7 in in IN 42759 1816 8 Canada Canada NNP 42759 1816 9 and and CC 42759 1816 10 U. U. NNP 42759 1816 11 S. S. NNP 42759 1816 12 ; ; : 42759 1816 13 1915 1915 CD 42759 1816 14 . . . 42759 1817 1 Some some DT 42759 1817 2 Probable probable JJ 42759 1817 3 Effects effect NNS 42759 1817 4 of of IN 42759 1817 5 Exemption exemption NN 42759 1817 6 in in IN 42759 1817 7 City City NNP 42759 1817 8 of of IN 42759 1817 9 New New NNP 42759 1817 10 York York NNP 42759 1817 11 ; ; : 42759 1817 12 1915 1915 CD 42759 1817 13 . . . 42759 1818 1 KELLEHER kelleher VB 42759 1818 2 : : : 42759 1818 3 Private private JJ 42759 1818 4 Ownership ownership NN 42759 1818 5 . . . 42759 1819 1 Dublin Dublin NNP 42759 1819 2 ; ; : 42759 1819 3 1911 1911 CD 42759 1819 4 . . . 42759 1820 1 Proceedings proceeding NNS 42759 1820 2 of of IN 42759 1820 3 the the DT 42759 1820 4 1913 1913 CD 42759 1820 5 Meeting Meeting NNP 42759 1820 6 of of IN 42759 1820 7 the the DT 42759 1820 8 American American NNP 42759 1820 9 Economic Economic NNP 42759 1820 10 Association Association NNP 42759 1820 11 . . . 42759 1821 1 U. U. NNP 42759 1821 2 S. S. NNP 42759 1821 3 COMMISSIONER COMMISSIONER NNP 42759 1821 4 OF of IN 42759 1821 5 CORPORATIONS corporations NN 42759 1821 6 : : : 42759 1821 7 Reports report NNS 42759 1821 8 on on IN 42759 1821 9 the the DT 42759 1821 10 Lumber Lumber NNP 42759 1821 11 , , , 42759 1821 12 Petroleum Petroleum NNP 42759 1821 13 , , , 42759 1821 14 Steel Steel NNP 42759 1821 15 , , , 42759 1821 16 and and CC 42759 1821 17 Water Water NNP 42759 1821 18 Power Power NNP 42759 1821 19 of of IN 42759 1821 20 the the DT 42759 1821 21 United United NNP 42759 1821 22 States States NNP 42759 1821 23 . . . 42759 1822 1 SELIGMAN SELIGMAN NNP 42759 1822 2 : : : 42759 1822 3 Essays essay NNS 42759 1822 4 in in IN 42759 1822 5 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1822 6 ; ; : 42759 1822 7 Shifting Shifting NNP 42759 1822 8 and and CC 42759 1822 9 Incidence Incidence NNP 42759 1822 10 of of IN 42759 1822 11 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1822 12 ; ; : 42759 1822 13 and and CC 42759 1822 14 Progressive Progressive NNP 42759 1822 15 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1822 16 in in IN 42759 1822 17 Theory Theory NNP 42759 1822 18 and and CC 42759 1822 19 Practice Practice NNP 42759 1822 20 . . . 42759 1823 1 Also also RB 42759 1823 2 the the DT 42759 1823 3 works work NNS 42759 1823 4 of of IN 42759 1823 5 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 1823 6 , , , 42759 1823 7 Devas Devas NNP 42759 1823 8 , , , 42759 1823 9 Carver Carver NNP 42759 1823 10 , , , 42759 1823 11 Pesch Pesch NNP 42759 1823 12 , , , 42759 1823 13 King King NNP 42759 1823 14 , , , 42759 1823 15 Vermeersch Vermeersch NNP 42759 1823 16 , , , 42759 1823 17 Willoughby Willoughby NNP 42759 1823 18 , , , 42759 1823 19 and and CC 42759 1823 20 the the DT 42759 1823 21 Commission Commission NNP 42759 1823 22 on on IN 42759 1823 23 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 1823 24 Relations Relations NNPS 42759 1823 25 , , , 42759 1823 26 all all DT 42759 1823 27 of of IN 42759 1823 28 which which WDT 42759 1823 29 are be VBP 42759 1823 30 cited cite VBN 42759 1823 31 at at IN 42759 1823 32 the the DT 42759 1823 33 end end NN 42759 1823 34 of of IN 42759 1823 35 the the DT 42759 1823 36 introductory introductory JJ 42759 1823 37 chapter chapter NN 42759 1823 38 . . . 42759 1824 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 1824 2 : : : 42759 1824 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1824 4 84 84 CD 42759 1824 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1824 6 " " `` 42759 1824 7 Summary Summary NNP 42759 1824 8 of of IN 42759 1824 9 Report Report NNP 42759 1824 10 of of IN 42759 1824 11 the the DT 42759 1824 12 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 1824 13 of of IN 42759 1824 14 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 1824 15 on on IN 42759 1824 16 the the DT 42759 1824 17 Timber Timber NNP 42759 1824 18 Industry Industry NNP 42759 1824 19 in in IN 42759 1824 20 the the DT 42759 1824 21 United United NNP 42759 1824 22 States States NNP 42759 1824 23 , , , 42759 1824 24 " " '' 42759 1824 25 p. p. NN 42759 1824 26 3 3 CD 42759 1824 27 . . . 42759 1825 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1825 2 85 85 CD 42759 1825 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1825 4 " " `` 42759 1825 5 Report Report NNP 42759 1825 6 of of IN 42759 1825 7 the the DT 42759 1825 8 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 1825 9 of of IN 42759 1825 10 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 1825 11 on on IN 42759 1825 12 Water Water NNP 42759 1825 13 Power Power NNP 42759 1825 14 Development Development NNP 42759 1825 15 in in IN 42759 1825 16 the the DT 42759 1825 17 United United NNP 42759 1825 18 States States NNP 42759 1825 19 , , , 42759 1825 20 " " '' 42759 1825 21 pp pp NNP 42759 1825 22 . . . 42759 1826 1 193 193 CD 42759 1826 2 - - SYM 42759 1826 3 195 195 CD 42759 1826 4 . . . 42759 1827 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1827 2 86 86 CD 42759 1827 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1827 4 Idem Idem NNP 42759 1827 5 , , , 42759 1827 6 pp pp NNP 42759 1827 7 . . . 42759 1828 1 4 4 CD 42759 1828 2 , , , 42759 1828 3 5 5 CD 42759 1828 4 . . . 42759 1829 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1829 2 87 87 CD 42759 1829 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1829 4 " " `` 42759 1829 5 Abstract Abstract NNP 42759 1829 6 of of IN 42759 1829 7 the the DT 42759 1829 8 Thirteenth Thirteenth NNP 42759 1829 9 Census Census NNP 42759 1829 10 , , , 42759 1829 11 " " '' 42759 1829 12 p. p. NN 42759 1829 13 552 552 CD 42759 1829 14 . . . 42759 1830 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1830 2 88 88 CD 42759 1830 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1830 4 Cf cf NN 42759 1830 5 . . . 42759 1831 1 Marsh Marsh NNP 42759 1831 2 , , , 42759 1831 3 " " `` 42759 1831 4 Land Land NNP 42759 1831 5 Value Value NNP 42759 1831 6 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1831 7 in in IN 42759 1831 8 American American NNP 42759 1831 9 Cities Cities NNPS 42759 1831 10 , , , 42759 1831 11 " " '' 42759 1831 12 p. p. NN 42759 1831 13 95 95 CD 42759 1831 14 . . . 42759 1832 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1832 2 89 89 CD 42759 1832 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1832 4 Municipal municipal JJ 42759 1832 5 purchase purchase NN 42759 1832 6 and and CC 42759 1832 7 ownership ownership NN 42759 1832 8 of of IN 42759 1832 9 land land NN 42759 1832 10 have have VBP 42759 1832 11 been be VBN 42759 1832 12 advocated advocate VBN 42759 1832 13 by by IN 42759 1832 14 such such PDT 42759 1832 15 a a DT 42759 1832 16 conservative conservative JJ 42759 1832 17 authority authority NN 42759 1832 18 as as IN 42759 1832 19 the the DT 42759 1832 20 Rev. Rev. NNP 42759 1833 1 Heinrich Heinrich NNP 42759 1833 2 Pesch Pesch NNP 42759 1833 3 , , , 42759 1833 4 S.J. S.J. NNP 42759 1834 1 " " `` 42759 1834 2 Lehrbuch lehrbuch NN 42759 1834 3 der der NN 42759 1834 4 Nationaloekonomie Nationaloekonomie NNP 42759 1834 5 , , , 42759 1834 6 " " `` 42759 1834 7 I -PRON- PRP 42759 1834 8 , , , 42759 1834 9 203 203 CD 42759 1834 10 . . . 42759 1835 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1835 2 90 90 CD 42759 1835 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1835 4 As as IN 42759 1835 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1835 6 shall shall MD 42759 1835 7 see see VB 42759 1835 8 in in IN 42759 1835 9 a a DT 42759 1835 10 later later JJ 42759 1835 11 chapter chapter NN 42759 1835 12 , , , 42759 1835 13 the the DT 42759 1835 14 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 1835 15 and and CC 42759 1835 16 injustice injustice NN 42759 1835 17 would would MD 42759 1835 18 be be VB 42759 1835 19 smaller small JJR 42759 1835 20 if if IN 42759 1835 21 the the DT 42759 1835 22 State State NNP 42759 1835 23 should should MD 42759 1835 24 simultaneously simultaneously RB 42759 1835 25 abolish abolish VB 42759 1835 26 interest interest NN 42759 1835 27 . . . 42759 1836 1 In in IN 42759 1836 2 any any DT 42759 1836 3 case case NN 42759 1836 4 , , , 42759 1836 5 the the DT 42759 1836 6 decline decline NN 42759 1836 7 in in IN 42759 1836 8 land land NN 42759 1836 9 value value NN 42759 1836 10 resulting result VBG 42759 1836 11 from from IN 42759 1836 12 complete complete JJ 42759 1836 13 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 1836 14 of of IN 42759 1836 15 rent rent NN 42759 1836 16 should should MD 42759 1836 17 be be VB 42759 1836 18 made make VBN 42759 1836 19 up up RP 42759 1836 20 to to IN 42759 1836 21 the the DT 42759 1836 22 private private JJ 42759 1836 23 owner owner NN 42759 1836 24 by by IN 42759 1836 25 public public JJ 42759 1836 26 compensation compensation NN 42759 1836 27 . . . 42759 1837 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1837 2 91 91 CD 42759 1837 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1837 4 " " `` 42759 1837 5 Principles principle NNS 42759 1837 6 of of IN 42759 1837 7 Political political JJ 42759 1837 8 Economy Economy NNP 42759 1837 9 , , , 42759 1837 10 " " '' 42759 1837 11 book book NN 42759 1837 12 V v NN 42759 1837 13 , , , 42759 1837 14 ch ch NN 42759 1837 15 . . . 42759 1838 1 2 2 CD 42759 1838 2 , , , 42759 1838 3 sect sect JJ 42759 1838 4 . . . 42759 1839 1 v. v. CC 42759 1839 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1839 3 92 92 CD 42759 1839 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1839 5 " " `` 42759 1839 6 Progressive Progressive NNP 42759 1839 7 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1839 8 in in IN 42759 1839 9 Theory Theory NNP 42759 1839 10 and and CC 42759 1839 11 Practice Practice NNP 42759 1839 12 , , , 42759 1839 13 " " '' 42759 1839 14 1908 1908 CD 42759 1839 15 , , , 42759 1839 16 p. p. NN 42759 1839 17 130 130 CD 42759 1839 18 . . . 42759 1840 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1840 2 93 93 CD 42759 1840 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1840 4 Cf cf NN 42759 1840 5 . . . 42759 1841 1 Taussig Taussig NNS 42759 1841 2 , , , 42759 1841 3 " " `` 42759 1841 4 Principles Principles NNPS 42759 1841 5 of of IN 42759 1841 6 Economics Economics NNP 42759 1841 7 , , , 42759 1841 8 " " '' 42759 1841 9 II ii CD 42759 1841 10 , , , 42759 1841 11 516 516 CD 42759 1841 12 : : : 42759 1841 13 Seligman seligman NN 42759 1841 14 , , , 42759 1841 15 " " `` 42759 1841 16 The the DT 42759 1841 17 Shifting Shifting NNP 42759 1841 18 and and CC 42759 1841 19 Incidence Incidence NNP 42759 1841 20 of of IN 42759 1841 21 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1841 22 , , , 42759 1841 23 " " '' 42759 1841 24 p. p. NN 42759 1841 25 223 223 CD 42759 1841 26 . . . 42759 1842 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1842 2 94 94 CD 42759 1842 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1842 4 The the DT 42759 1842 5 " " `` 42759 1842 6 discrimination discrimination NN 42759 1842 7 " " '' 42759 1842 8 objection objection NN 42759 1842 9 is be VBZ 42759 1842 10 put put VBN 42759 1842 11 in in RP 42759 1842 12 a a DT 42759 1842 13 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 1842 14 different different JJ 42759 1842 15 form form NN 42759 1842 16 by by IN 42759 1842 17 the the DT 42759 1842 18 Rev. Rev. NNP 42759 1843 1 Sydney Sydney NNP 42759 1843 2 F. F. NNP 42759 1843 3 Smith Smith NNP 42759 1843 4 , , , 42759 1843 5 S.J. S.J. NNP 42759 1843 6 , , , 42759 1843 7 in in IN 42759 1843 8 an an DT 42759 1843 9 article article NN 42759 1843 10 in in IN 42759 1843 11 _ _ NNP 42759 1843 12 The The NNP 42759 1843 13 Month Month NNP 42759 1843 14 _ _ NNP 42759 1843 15 , , , 42759 1843 16 Sept. September NNP 42759 1843 17 , , , 42759 1843 18 1909 1909 CD 42759 1843 19 , , , 42759 1843 20 entitled entitle VBN 42759 1843 21 " " `` 42759 1843 22 The the DT 42759 1843 23 Theory Theory NNP 42759 1843 24 of of IN 42759 1843 25 Unearned Unearned NNP 42759 1843 26 Increment Increment NNP 42759 1843 27 . . . 42759 1843 28 " " '' 42759 1844 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1844 2 argument argument NN 42759 1844 3 is be VBZ 42759 1844 4 in in IN 42759 1844 5 substance substance NN 42759 1844 6 that that IN 42759 1844 7 if if IN 42759 1844 8 the the DT 42759 1844 9 people people NNS 42759 1844 10 of of IN 42759 1844 11 a a DT 42759 1844 12 city city NN 42759 1844 13 can can MD 42759 1844 14 claim claim VB 42759 1844 15 the the DT 42759 1844 16 increases increase NNS 42759 1844 17 in in IN 42759 1844 18 land land NN 42759 1844 19 values value NNS 42759 1844 20 which which WDT 42759 1844 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1844 22 presence presence NN 42759 1844 23 and and CC 42759 1844 24 activity activity NN 42759 1844 25 have have VBP 42759 1844 26 occasioned occasion VBN 42759 1844 27 , , , 42759 1844 28 the the DT 42759 1844 29 purchasers purchaser NNS 42759 1844 30 of of IN 42759 1844 31 food food NN 42759 1844 32 , , , 42759 1844 33 clothes clothe NNS 42759 1844 34 , , , 42759 1844 35 books book NNS 42759 1844 36 , , , 42759 1844 37 or or CC 42759 1844 38 concert concert NN 42759 1844 39 tickets ticket NNS 42759 1844 40 are be VBP 42759 1844 41 equally equally RB 42759 1844 42 justified justified JJ 42759 1844 43 in in IN 42759 1844 44 claiming claim VBG 42759 1844 45 that that IN 42759 1844 46 , , , 42759 1844 47 " " '' 42759 1844 48 having have VBG 42759 1844 49 added add VBN 42759 1844 50 to to IN 42759 1844 51 the the DT 42759 1844 52 value value NN 42759 1844 53 of of IN 42759 1844 54 the the DT 42759 1844 55 shops shop NNS 42759 1844 56 and and CC 42759 1844 57 music music NN 42759 1844 58 halls hall NNS 42759 1844 59 , , , 42759 1844 60 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1844 61 had have VBD 42759 1844 62 acquired acquire VBN 42759 1844 63 a a DT 42759 1844 64 co co JJ 42759 1844 65 - - JJ 42759 1844 66 proprietary proprietary JJ 42759 1844 67 right right NN 42759 1844 68 in in IN 42759 1844 69 the the DT 42759 1844 70 increased increase VBN 42759 1844 71 value value NN 42759 1844 72 of of IN 42759 1844 73 the the DT 42759 1844 74 owners owner NNS 42759 1844 75 ' ' POS 42759 1844 76 stock stock NN 42759 1844 77 , , , 42759 1844 78 and and CC 42759 1844 79 the the DT 42759 1844 80 owners owner NNS 42759 1844 81 ' ' POS 42759 1844 82 premises premise NNS 42759 1844 83 . . . 42759 1844 84 " " '' 42759 1845 1 While while IN 42759 1845 2 this this DT 42759 1845 3 argument argument NN 42759 1845 4 is be VBZ 42759 1845 5 specifically specifically RB 42759 1845 6 directed direct VBN 42759 1845 7 against against IN 42759 1845 8 those those DT 42759 1845 9 who who WP 42759 1845 10 maintain maintain VBP 42759 1845 11 that that IN 42759 1845 12 the the DT 42759 1845 13 " " `` 42759 1845 14 social social JJ 42759 1845 15 production production NN 42759 1845 16 " " '' 42759 1845 17 of of IN 42759 1845 18 values value NNS 42759 1845 19 confers confer NNS 42759 1845 20 a a DT 42759 1845 21 right right JJ 42759 1845 22 thereto thereto NN 42759 1845 23 , , , 42759 1845 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1845 25 affects affect VBZ 42759 1845 26 to to IN 42759 1845 27 some some DT 42759 1845 28 extent extent NN 42759 1845 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1845 30 thesis thesis NN 42759 1845 31 that that IN 42759 1845 32 there there EX 42759 1845 33 is be VBZ 42759 1845 34 a a DT 42759 1845 35 vast vast JJ 42759 1845 36 difference difference NN 42759 1845 37 between between IN 42759 1845 38 value value NN 42759 1845 39 - - HYPH 42759 1845 40 increases increase NNS 42759 1845 41 in in IN 42759 1845 42 land land NN 42759 1845 43 and and CC 42759 1845 44 in in IN 42759 1845 45 other other JJ 42759 1845 46 goods good NNS 42759 1845 47 . . . 42759 1846 1 Father Father NNP 42759 1846 2 Smith Smith NNP 42759 1846 3 seems seem VBZ 42759 1846 4 to to TO 42759 1846 5 confuse confuse VB 42759 1846 6 the the DT 42759 1846 7 origination origination NN 42759 1846 8 of of IN 42759 1846 9 value value NN 42759 1846 10 with with IN 42759 1846 11 the the DT 42759 1846 12 increase increase NN 42759 1846 13 of of IN 42759 1846 14 value value NN 42759 1846 15 . . . 42759 1847 1 The the DT 42759 1847 2 presence presence NN 42759 1847 3 of of IN 42759 1847 4 consumers consumer NNS 42759 1847 5 is be VBZ 42759 1847 6 an an DT 42759 1847 7 obvious obvious JJ 42759 1847 8 prerequisite prerequisite NN 42759 1847 9 to to IN 42759 1847 10 the the DT 42759 1847 11 existence existence NN 42759 1847 12 of of IN 42759 1847 13 any any DT 42759 1847 14 value value NN 42759 1847 15 at at RB 42759 1847 16 all all RB 42759 1847 17 in in IN 42759 1847 18 any any DT 42759 1847 19 kind kind NN 42759 1847 20 of of IN 42759 1847 21 goods good NNS 42759 1847 22 , , , 42759 1847 23 but but CC 42759 1847 24 labour labour NN 42759 1847 25 and and CC 42759 1847 26 financial financial JJ 42759 1847 27 outlay outlay NN 42759 1847 28 on on IN 42759 1847 29 the the DT 42759 1847 30 part part NN 42759 1847 31 of of IN 42759 1847 32 the the DT 42759 1847 33 producers producer NNS 42759 1847 34 of of IN 42759 1847 35 the the DT 42759 1847 36 goods good NNS 42759 1847 37 are be VBP 42759 1847 38 an an DT 42759 1847 39 equally equally RB 42759 1847 40 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 1847 41 prerequisite prerequisite NN 42759 1847 42 . . . 42759 1848 1 The the DT 42759 1848 2 reason reason NN 42759 1848 3 why why WRB 42759 1848 4 the the DT 42759 1848 5 value value NN 42759 1848 6 is be VBZ 42759 1848 7 appropriated appropriate VBN 42759 1848 8 by by IN 42759 1848 9 the the DT 42759 1848 10 latter latter JJ 42759 1848 11 rather rather RB 42759 1848 12 than than IN 42759 1848 13 the the DT 42759 1848 14 former former JJ 42759 1848 15 is be VBZ 42759 1848 16 that that IN 42759 1848 17 this this DT 42759 1848 18 is be VBZ 42759 1848 19 clearly clearly RB 42759 1848 20 the the DT 42759 1848 21 only only JJ 42759 1848 22 rational rational JJ 42759 1848 23 method method NN 42759 1848 24 of of IN 42759 1848 25 distribution distribution NN 42759 1848 26 . . . 42759 1849 1 What what WP 42759 1849 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1849 3 are be VBP 42759 1849 4 concerned concern VBN 42759 1849 5 with with IN 42759 1849 6 here here RB 42759 1849 7 , , , 42759 1849 8 however however RB 42759 1849 9 , , , 42759 1849 10 is be VBZ 42759 1849 11 not not RB 42759 1849 12 this this DT 42759 1849 13 initial initial JJ 42759 1849 14 or or CC 42759 1849 15 cost cost NN 42759 1849 16 - - HYPH 42759 1849 17 of of IN 42759 1849 18 - - HYPH 42759 1849 19 production production NN 42759 1849 20 - - HYPH 42759 1849 21 value value NN 42759 1849 22 of of IN 42759 1849 23 artificial artificial JJ 42759 1849 24 goods good NNS 42759 1849 25 , , , 42759 1849 26 but but CC 42759 1849 27 the the DT 42759 1849 28 _ _ NNP 42759 1849 29 increases increase VBZ 42759 1849 30 _ _ NNP 42759 1849 31 in in IN 42759 1849 32 value value NN 42759 1849 33 above above IN 42759 1849 34 this this DT 42759 1849 35 level level NN 42759 1849 36 which which WDT 42759 1849 37 are be VBP 42759 1849 38 brought bring VBN 42759 1849 39 about about RP 42759 1849 40 by by IN 42759 1849 41 external external JJ 42759 1849 42 and and CC 42759 1849 43 social social JJ 42759 1849 44 influences influence NNS 42759 1849 45 . . . 42759 1850 1 Theoretically theoretically RB 42759 1850 2 , , , 42759 1850 3 the the DT 42759 1850 4 State state NN 42759 1850 5 could could MD 42759 1850 6 as as RB 42759 1850 7 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 1850 8 take take VB 42759 1850 9 these these DT 42759 1850 10 as as IN 42759 1850 11 the the DT 42759 1850 12 increases increase NNS 42759 1850 13 in in IN 42759 1850 14 the the DT 42759 1850 15 value value NN 42759 1850 16 of of IN 42759 1850 17 land land NN 42759 1850 18 ; ; : 42759 1850 19 practically practically RB 42759 1850 20 , , , 42759 1850 21 such such PDT 42759 1850 22 a a DT 42759 1850 23 performance performance NN 42759 1850 24 is be VBZ 42759 1850 25 out out IN 42759 1850 26 of of IN 42759 1850 27 the the DT 42759 1850 28 question question NN 42759 1850 29 , , , 42759 1850 30 for for IN 42759 1850 31 the the DT 42759 1850 32 simple simple JJ 42759 1850 33 reason reason NN 42759 1850 34 that that IN 42759 1850 35 such such JJ 42759 1850 36 increases increase NNS 42759 1850 37 are be VBP 42759 1850 38 spasmodic spasmodic JJ 42759 1850 39 and and CC 42759 1850 40 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 1850 41 . . . 42759 1851 1 If if IN 42759 1851 2 Father Father NNP 42759 1851 3 Smith Smith NNP 42759 1851 4 thinks think VBZ 42759 1851 5 that that IN 42759 1851 6 " " `` 42759 1851 7 food food NN 42759 1851 8 or or CC 42759 1851 9 clothes clothe NNS 42759 1851 10 , , , 42759 1851 11 or or CC 42759 1851 12 books book NNS 42759 1851 13 , , , 42759 1851 14 or or CC 42759 1851 15 concert concert NN 42759 1851 16 tickets ticket NNS 42759 1851 17 " " `` 42759 1851 18 regularly regularly RB 42759 1851 19 advance advance NN 42759 1851 20 above above IN 42759 1851 21 the the DT 42759 1851 22 cost cost NN 42759 1851 23 - - HYPH 42759 1851 24 of of IN 42759 1851 25 - - HYPH 42759 1851 26 production production NN 42759 1851 27 - - HYPH 42759 1851 28 value value NN 42759 1851 29 , , , 42759 1851 30 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1851 31 is be VBZ 42759 1851 32 simply simply RB 42759 1851 33 mistaken mistaken JJ 42759 1851 34 . . . 42759 1852 1 Since since IN 42759 1852 2 these these DT 42759 1852 3 and and CC 42759 1852 4 other other JJ 42759 1852 5 artificial artificial JJ 42759 1852 6 goods good NNS 42759 1852 7 bring bring VBP 42759 1852 8 to to IN 42759 1852 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1852 10 owners owner NNS 42759 1852 11 as as IN 42759 1852 12 a a DT 42759 1852 13 rule rule NN 42759 1852 14 no no RB 42759 1852 15 socially socially RB 42759 1852 16 occasioned occasion VBN 42759 1852 17 increments increment NNS 42759 1852 18 of of IN 42759 1852 19 value value NN 42759 1852 20 , , , 42759 1852 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1852 22 and and CC 42759 1852 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1852 24 owners owner NNS 42759 1852 25 are be VBP 42759 1852 26 in in IN 42759 1852 27 quite quite PDT 42759 1852 28 a a DT 42759 1852 29 different different JJ 42759 1852 30 situation situation NN 42759 1852 31 from from IN 42759 1852 32 land land NN 42759 1852 33 and and CC 42759 1852 34 the the DT 42759 1852 35 owners owner NNS 42759 1852 36 of of IN 42759 1852 37 land land NN 42759 1852 38 . . . 42759 1853 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1853 2 95 95 CD 42759 1853 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1853 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 1853 5 . . . 42759 1854 1 Seligman seligman NN 42759 1854 2 , , , 42759 1854 3 " " `` 42759 1854 4 Progressive Progressive NNP 42759 1854 5 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1854 6 in in IN 42759 1854 7 Theory Theory NNP 42759 1854 8 and and CC 42759 1854 9 Practice Practice NNP 42759 1854 10 , , , 42759 1854 11 " " '' 42759 1854 12 part part NN 42759 1854 13 II II NNP 42759 1854 14 , , , 42759 1854 15 chs chs NNP 42759 1854 16 . . . 42759 1855 1 ii ii NNP 42759 1855 2 and and CC 42759 1855 3 iii iii NNP 42759 1855 4 ; ; : 42759 1855 5 also also RB 42759 1855 6 the the DT 42759 1855 7 classic classic JJ 42759 1855 8 refutation refutation NN 42759 1855 9 of of IN 42759 1855 10 the the DT 42759 1855 11 " " `` 42759 1855 12 benefit benefit NN 42759 1855 13 " " '' 42759 1855 14 theory theory NN 42759 1855 15 by by IN 42759 1855 16 John John NNP 42759 1855 17 Stuart Stuart NNP 42759 1855 18 Mill Mill NNP 42759 1855 19 in in IN 42759 1855 20 " " `` 42759 1855 21 Principles principle NNS 42759 1855 22 of of IN 42759 1855 23 Political political JJ 42759 1855 24 Economy Economy NNP 42759 1855 25 , , , 42759 1855 26 " " '' 42759 1855 27 book book NN 42759 1855 28 V v NN 42759 1855 29 , , , 42759 1855 30 ch ch NN 42759 1855 31 . . . 42759 1856 1 ii ii NNP 42759 1856 2 , , , 42759 1856 3 sec sec NNP 42759 1856 4 . . . 42759 1857 1 2 2 LS 42759 1857 2 . . . 42759 1858 1 The the DT 42759 1858 2 traditional traditional JJ 42759 1858 3 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 1858 4 teaching teaching NN 42759 1858 5 on on IN 42759 1858 6 the the DT 42759 1858 7 subject subject NN 42759 1858 8 is be VBZ 42759 1858 9 compactly compactly RB 42759 1858 10 stated state VBN 42759 1858 11 by by IN 42759 1858 12 Cardinal Cardinal NNP 42759 1858 13 de de IN 42759 1858 14 Lugo Lugo NNP 42759 1858 15 in in IN 42759 1858 16 " " `` 42759 1858 17 De De NNP 42759 1858 18 Justitia Justitia NNP 42759 1858 19 et et NNP 42759 1858 20 Jure Jure NNP 42759 1858 21 , , , 42759 1858 22 " " '' 42759 1858 23 disp disp RB 42759 1858 24 . . . 42759 1859 1 36 36 CD 42759 1859 2 ; ; : 42759 1859 3 cf cf NN 42759 1859 4 . . . 42759 1860 1 Devas Devas NNP 42759 1860 2 , , , 42759 1860 3 " " `` 42759 1860 4 Political political JJ 42759 1860 5 Economy Economy NNP 42759 1860 6 , , , 42759 1860 7 " " '' 42759 1860 8 p. p. NN 42759 1860 9 594 594 CD 42759 1860 10 , , , 42759 1860 11 2d 2d CD 42759 1860 12 ed ed NNP 42759 1860 13 . . . 42759 1861 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1861 2 96 96 CD 42759 1861 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1861 4 Cf cf NN 42759 1861 5 . . . 42759 1862 1 Fallon fallon NN 42759 1862 2 , , , 42759 1862 3 " " '' 42759 1862 4 Les Les NNP 42759 1862 5 Plus Plus NNP 42759 1862 6 - - HYPH 42759 1862 7 Values Values NNP 42759 1862 8 et et FW 42759 1862 9 l'Impot l'Impot NNP 42759 1862 10 , , , 42759 1862 11 " " '' 42759 1862 12 pp pp NNP 42759 1862 13 . . . 42759 1863 1 455 455 CD 42759 1863 2 , , , 42759 1863 3 sq sq NNP 42759 1863 4 . . . 42759 1864 1 ; ; : 42759 1864 2 Paris Paris NNP 42759 1864 3 , , , 42759 1864 4 1914 1914 CD 42759 1864 5 ; ; : 42759 1864 6 Fillebrown Fillebrown NNP 42759 1864 7 , , , 42759 1864 8 " " `` 42759 1864 9 A a DT 42759 1864 10 Single single JJ 42759 1864 11 Tax tax NN 42759 1864 12 Handbook Handbook NNP 42759 1864 13 for for IN 42759 1864 14 1913 1913 CD 42759 1864 15 " " '' 42759 1864 16 ; ; : 42759 1864 17 Boston Boston NNP 42759 1864 18 , , , 42759 1864 19 1912 1912 CD 42759 1864 20 ; ; : 42759 1864 21 Marsh Marsh NNP 42759 1864 22 , , , 42759 1864 23 " " `` 42759 1864 24 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1864 25 of of IN 42759 1864 26 Land Land NNP 42759 1864 27 Values value NNS 42759 1864 28 in in IN 42759 1864 29 American American NNP 42759 1864 30 Cities Cities NNPS 42759 1864 31 , , , 42759 1864 32 " " '' 42759 1864 33 pp pp NNP 42759 1864 34 . . . 42759 1865 1 90 90 CD 42759 1865 2 - - SYM 42759 1865 3 92 92 CD 42759 1865 4 ; ; : 42759 1865 5 New New NNP 42759 1865 6 York York NNP 42759 1865 7 , , , 42759 1865 8 1911 1911 CD 42759 1865 9 ; ; : 42759 1865 10 " " `` 42759 1865 11 The the DT 42759 1865 12 Quarterly Quarterly NNP 42759 1865 13 Journal Journal NNP 42759 1865 14 of of IN 42759 1865 15 Economics Economics NNP 42759 1865 16 , , , 42759 1865 17 " " '' 42759 1865 18 vols vol NNS 42759 1865 19 . . . 42759 1866 1 22 22 CD 42759 1866 2 , , , 42759 1866 3 24 24 CD 42759 1866 4 , , , 42759 1866 5 25 25 CD 42759 1866 6 ; ; : 42759 1866 7 " " `` 42759 1866 8 The the DT 42759 1866 9 Single Single NNP 42759 1866 10 Tax Tax NNP 42759 1866 11 Review Review NNP 42759 1866 12 , , , 42759 1866 13 " " '' 42759 1866 14 March March NNP 42759 1866 15 - - HYPH 42759 1866 16 April April NNP 42759 1866 17 , , , 42759 1866 18 1912 1912 CD 42759 1866 19 ; ; : 42759 1866 20 " " `` 42759 1866 21 Stimmen Stimmen NNP 42759 1866 22 aus au VBD 42759 1866 23 Maria Maria NNP 42759 1866 24 - - HYPH 42759 1866 25 Laach Laach NNP 42759 1866 26 , , , 42759 1866 27 " " '' 42759 1866 28 Oct. October NNP 42759 1866 29 , , , 42759 1866 30 1907 1907 CD 42759 1866 31 . . . 42759 1867 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1867 2 97 97 CD 42759 1867 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1867 4 See see VB 42759 1867 5 the the DT 42759 1867 6 references reference NNS 42759 1867 7 in in IN 42759 1867 8 the the DT 42759 1867 9 second second JJ 42759 1867 10 last last JJ 42759 1867 11 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 1867 12 . . . 42759 1868 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1868 2 98 98 CD 42759 1868 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1868 4 The the DT 42759 1868 5 most most RBS 42759 1868 6 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 1868 7 and and CC 42759 1868 8 reliable reliable JJ 42759 1868 9 account account NN 42759 1868 10 of of IN 42759 1868 11 the the DT 42759 1868 12 special special JJ 42759 1868 13 land land NN 42759 1868 14 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1868 15 in in IN 42759 1868 16 Canada Canada NNP 42759 1868 17 is be VBZ 42759 1868 18 contained contain VBN 42759 1868 19 in in IN 42759 1868 20 the the DT 42759 1868 21 report report NN 42759 1868 22 prepared prepare VBN 42759 1868 23 for for IN 42759 1868 24 the the DT 42759 1868 25 Committee Committee NNP 42759 1868 26 on on IN 42759 1868 27 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1868 28 of of IN 42759 1868 29 the the DT 42759 1868 30 City City NNP 42759 1868 31 of of IN 42759 1868 32 New New NNP 42759 1868 33 York York NNP 42759 1868 34 , , , 42759 1868 35 by by IN 42759 1868 36 Robert Robert NNP 42759 1868 37 Murray Murray NNP 42759 1868 38 Haig Haig NNP 42759 1868 39 , , , 42759 1868 40 Ph.D. ph.d. NN 42759 1868 41 , , , 42759 1868 42 entitled entitle VBN 42759 1868 43 , , , 42759 1868 44 " " `` 42759 1868 45 The the DT 42759 1868 46 Exemption Exemption NNP 42759 1868 47 of of IN 42759 1868 48 Improvements Improvements NNPS 42759 1868 49 from from IN 42759 1868 50 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1868 51 in in IN 42759 1868 52 Canada Canada NNP 42759 1868 53 and and CC 42759 1868 54 the the DT 42759 1868 55 United United NNP 42759 1868 56 States States NNP 42759 1868 57 " " '' 42759 1868 58 ; ; : 42759 1868 59 New New NNP 42759 1868 60 York York NNP 42759 1868 61 , , , 42759 1868 62 1915 1915 CD 42759 1868 63 . . . 42759 1869 1 See see VB 42759 1869 2 also also RB 42759 1869 3 Fallon Fallon NNP 42759 1869 4 , , , 42759 1869 5 op op NN 42759 1869 6 . . . 42759 1870 1 cit cit NNP 42759 1870 2 . . . 42759 1870 3 , , , 42759 1870 4 pp pp NNP 42759 1870 5 . . . 42759 1871 1 452 452 CD 42759 1871 2 - - SYM 42759 1871 3 455 455 CD 42759 1871 4 . . . 42759 1872 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1872 2 99 99 CD 42759 1872 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1872 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 1872 5 . . . 42759 1873 1 Fallon fallon NN 42759 1873 2 , , , 42759 1873 3 op op NN 42759 1873 4 . . . 42759 1874 1 cit cit NNP 42759 1874 2 . . . 42759 1874 3 , , , 42759 1874 4 pp pp NNP 42759 1874 5 . . . 42759 1875 1 443 443 CD 42759 1875 2 - - SYM 42759 1875 3 452 452 CD 42759 1875 4 . . . 42759 1876 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1876 2 100 100 CD 42759 1876 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1876 4 " " `` 42759 1876 5 The the DT 42759 1876 6 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 1876 7 and and CC 42759 1876 8 Income Income NNP 42759 1876 9 of of IN 42759 1876 10 the the DT 42759 1876 11 People People NNS 42759 1876 12 of of IN 42759 1876 13 the the DT 42759 1876 14 United United NNP 42759 1876 15 States States NNP 42759 1876 16 , , , 42759 1876 17 " " '' 42759 1876 18 pp pp NNP 42759 1876 19 . . . 42759 1877 1 158 158 CD 42759 1877 2 , , , 42759 1877 3 143 143 CD 42759 1877 4 . . . 42759 1878 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1878 2 101 101 CD 42759 1878 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1878 4 " " `` 42759 1878 5 Abstract Abstract NNP 42759 1878 6 of of IN 42759 1878 7 Bulletins Bulletins NNPS 42759 1878 8 on on IN 42759 1878 9 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 1878 10 , , , 42759 1878 11 Debt Debt NNP 42759 1878 12 , , , 42759 1878 13 and and CC 42759 1878 14 Taxation taxation NN 42759 1878 15 , , , 42759 1878 16 " " '' 42759 1878 17 p. p. NN 42759 1878 18 16 16 CD 42759 1878 19 ; ; : 42759 1878 20 U. U. NNP 42759 1878 21 S. S. NNP 42759 1878 22 Census Census NNP 42759 1878 23 , , , 42759 1878 24 1913 1913 CD 42759 1878 25 . . . 42759 1879 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1879 2 102 102 CD 42759 1879 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1879 4 Idem Idem NNP 42759 1879 5 , , , 42759 1879 6 p. p. NN 42759 1879 7 15 15 CD 42759 1879 8 . . . 42759 1880 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1880 2 103 103 CD 42759 1880 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1880 4 Idem Idem NNP 42759 1880 5 , , , 42759 1880 6 p. p. NN 42759 1880 7 16 16 CD 42759 1880 8 ; ; : 42759 1880 9 and and CC 42759 1880 10 Bulletin Bulletin NNP 42759 1880 11 of of IN 42759 1880 12 the the DT 42759 1880 13 Census Census NNP 42759 1880 14 on on IN 42759 1880 15 " " `` 42759 1880 16 Estimated estimated JJ 42759 1880 17 Valuation valuation NN 42759 1880 18 of of IN 42759 1880 19 National National NNP 42759 1880 20 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 1880 21 , , , 42759 1880 22 " " '' 42759 1880 23 p. p. NN 42759 1880 24 15 15 CD 42759 1880 25 . . . 42759 1881 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1881 2 104 104 CD 42759 1881 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1881 4 " " `` 42759 1881 5 Special Special NNP 42759 1881 6 Report Report NNP 42759 1881 7 of of IN 42759 1881 8 the the DT 42759 1881 9 Twelfth Twelfth NNP 42759 1881 10 Census Census NNP 42759 1881 11 on on IN 42759 1881 12 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 1881 13 , , , 42759 1881 14 Debt Debt NNP 42759 1881 15 , , , 42759 1881 16 and and CC 42759 1881 17 Taxation taxation NN 42759 1881 18 , , , 42759 1881 19 " " '' 42759 1881 20 pp pp NNP 42759 1881 21 . . . 42759 1882 1 12 12 CD 42759 1882 2 , , , 42759 1882 3 13 13 CD 42759 1882 4 . . . 42759 1883 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1883 2 105 105 CD 42759 1883 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1883 4 Haig Haig NNP 42759 1883 5 , , , 42759 1883 6 " " '' 42759 1883 7 Probable probable JJ 42759 1883 8 Effects effect NNS 42759 1883 9 of of IN 42759 1883 10 Exemption exemption NN 42759 1883 11 of of IN 42759 1883 12 Improvements improvement NNS 42759 1883 13 .... .... NFP 42759 1883 14 " " '' 42759 1883 15 , , , 42759 1883 16 p. p. NN 42759 1883 17 23 23 CD 42759 1883 18 . . . 42759 1884 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1884 2 106 106 CD 42759 1884 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1884 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 1884 5 . . . 42759 1885 1 Seligman seligman NN 42759 1885 2 , , , 42759 1885 3 " " `` 42759 1885 4 The the DT 42759 1885 5 Shifting Shifting NNP 42759 1885 6 and and CC 42759 1885 7 Incidence Incidence NNP 42759 1885 8 of of IN 42759 1885 9 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1885 10 , , , 42759 1885 11 " " '' 42759 1885 12 pp pp NNP 42759 1885 13 . . . 42759 1886 1 187 187 CD 42759 1886 2 , , , 42759 1886 3 245 245 CD 42759 1886 4 , , , 42759 1886 5 272 272 CD 42759 1886 6 , , , 42759 1886 7 and and CC 42759 1886 8 all all DT 42759 1886 9 of of IN 42759 1886 10 part part NN 42759 1886 11 II ii CD 42759 1886 12 ; ; : 42759 1886 13 N. N. NNP 42759 1886 14 Y. Y. NNP 42759 1886 15 , , , 42759 1886 16 1899 1899 CD 42759 1886 17 ; ; : 42759 1886 18 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 1886 19 , , , 42759 1886 20 " " `` 42759 1886 21 Principles Principles NNPS 42759 1886 22 of of IN 42759 1886 23 Economics Economics NNP 42759 1886 24 , , , 42759 1886 25 " " '' 42759 1886 26 II ii CD 42759 1886 27 , , , 42759 1886 28 518 518 CD 42759 1886 29 - - SYM 42759 1886 30 549 549 CD 42759 1886 31 , , , 42759 1886 32 and and CC 42759 1886 33 chs chs NNP 42759 1886 34 . . . 42759 1887 1 67 67 CD 42759 1887 2 - - SYM 42759 1887 3 69 69 CD 42759 1887 4 . . . 42759 1888 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1888 2 107 107 CD 42759 1888 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1888 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 1888 5 . . . 42759 1889 1 Fallon fallon NN 42759 1889 2 , , , 42759 1889 3 op op NN 42759 1889 4 . . . 42759 1890 1 cit cit NNP 42759 1890 2 . . . 42759 1890 3 , , , 42759 1890 4 pp pp NNP 42759 1890 5 . . . 42759 1891 1 442 442 CD 42759 1891 2 , , , 42759 1891 3 sq sq NNP 42759 1891 4 . . . 42759 1892 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1892 2 108 108 CD 42759 1892 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1892 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 1892 5 . . . 42759 1893 1 Vermeersch Vermeersch NNP 42759 1893 2 , , , 42759 1893 3 " " '' 42759 1893 4 Quaestiones Quaestiones NNP 42759 1893 5 de de NNP 42759 1893 6 Justitia Justitia NNP 42759 1893 7 , , , 42759 1893 8 " " '' 42759 1893 9 pp pp NNP 42759 1893 10 . . . 42759 1894 1 94 94 CD 42759 1894 2 - - SYM 42759 1894 3 126 126 CD 42759 1894 4 ; ; : 42759 1894 5 Seligman Seligman NNP 42759 1894 6 , , , 42759 1894 7 " " `` 42759 1894 8 Progressive Progressive NNP 42759 1894 9 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1894 10 in in IN 42759 1894 11 Theory Theory NNP 42759 1894 12 and and CC 42759 1894 13 Practice Practice NNP 42759 1894 14 , , , 42759 1894 15 " " '' 42759 1894 16 pp pp NNP 42759 1894 17 . . . 42759 1895 1 210 210 CD 42759 1895 2 , , , 42759 1895 3 211 211 CD 42759 1895 4 ; ; : 42759 1895 5 Mill mill NN 42759 1895 6 , , , 42759 1895 7 " " '' 42759 1895 8 Principles principle NNS 42759 1895 9 of of IN 42759 1895 10 Political political JJ 42759 1895 11 Economy Economy NNP 42759 1895 12 , , , 42759 1895 13 " " '' 42759 1895 14 book book NN 42759 1895 15 V v NN 42759 1895 16 , , , 42759 1895 17 ch ch NN 42759 1895 18 . . . 42759 1896 1 ii ii NNP 42759 1896 2 , , , 42759 1896 3 sec sec NNP 42759 1896 4 . . . 42759 1897 1 3 3 LS 42759 1897 2 . . . 42759 1898 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1898 2 109 109 CD 42759 1898 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1898 4 " " `` 42759 1898 5 Summary Summary NNP 42759 1898 6 of of IN 42759 1898 7 Report Report NNP 42759 1898 8 of of IN 42759 1898 9 the the DT 42759 1898 10 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 1898 11 of of IN 42759 1898 12 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 1898 13 on on IN 42759 1898 14 the the DT 42759 1898 15 Lumber Lumber NNP 42759 1898 16 Industry Industry NNP 42759 1898 17 in in IN 42759 1898 18 the the DT 42759 1898 19 United United NNP 42759 1898 20 States States NNP 42759 1898 21 , , , 42759 1898 22 " " '' 42759 1898 23 p. p. NN 42759 1898 24 8 8 CD 42759 1898 25 . . . 42759 1899 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 1899 2 110 110 CD 42759 1899 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 1899 4 Probably probably RB 42759 1899 5 the the DT 42759 1899 6 most most RBS 42759 1899 7 concrete concrete JJ 42759 1899 8 and and CC 42759 1899 9 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 1899 10 discussion discussion NN 42759 1899 11 of of IN 42759 1899 12 the the DT 42759 1899 13 increment increment JJ 42759 1899 14 tax tax NN 42759 1899 15 and and CC 42759 1899 16 the the DT 42759 1899 17 project project NN 42759 1899 18 to to TO 42759 1899 19 transfer transfer VB 42759 1899 20 improvement improvement NN 42759 1899 21 taxes taxis NNS 42759 1899 22 to to IN 42759 1899 23 land land NN 42759 1899 24 , , , 42759 1899 25 is be VBZ 42759 1899 26 that that DT 42759 1899 27 presented present VBN 42759 1899 28 in in IN 42759 1899 29 the the DT 42759 1899 30 " " `` 42759 1899 31 Final Final NNP 42759 1899 32 Report Report NNP 42759 1899 33 of of IN 42759 1899 34 the the DT 42759 1899 35 Committee Committee NNP 42759 1899 36 on on IN 42759 1899 37 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 1899 38 of of IN 42759 1899 39 the the DT 42759 1899 40 City City NNP 42759 1899 41 of of IN 42759 1899 42 New New NNP 42759 1899 43 York York NNP 42759 1899 44 " " '' 42759 1899 45 ; ; : 42759 1899 46 1916 1916 CD 42759 1899 47 . . . 42759 1900 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1900 2 contains contain VBZ 42759 1900 3 brief brief JJ 42759 1900 4 , , , 42759 1900 5 though though IN 42759 1900 6 complete complete JJ 42759 1900 7 , , , 42759 1900 8 statements statement NNS 42759 1900 9 of of IN 42759 1900 10 all all DT 42759 1900 11 phases phase NNS 42759 1900 12 of of IN 42759 1900 13 the the DT 42759 1900 14 subject subject NN 42759 1900 15 , , , 42759 1900 16 together together RB 42759 1900 17 with with IN 42759 1900 18 concise concise JJ 42759 1900 19 arguments argument NNS 42759 1900 20 on on IN 42759 1900 21 both both DT 42759 1900 22 sides side NNS 42759 1900 23 , , , 42759 1900 24 majority majority NN 42759 1900 25 and and CC 42759 1900 26 minority minority NN 42759 1900 27 recommendations recommendation NNS 42759 1900 28 , , , 42759 1900 29 a a DT 42759 1900 30 great great JJ 42759 1900 31 variety variety NN 42759 1900 32 of of IN 42759 1900 33 dissenting dissent VBG 42759 1900 34 individual individual JJ 42759 1900 35 opinions opinion NNS 42759 1900 36 , , , 42759 1900 37 and and CC 42759 1900 38 considerable considerable JJ 42759 1900 39 testimony testimony NN 42759 1900 40 by by IN 42759 1900 41 experts expert NNS 42759 1900 42 , , , 42759 1900 43 authorities authority NNS 42759 1900 44 , , , 42759 1900 45 and and CC 42759 1900 46 other other JJ 42759 1900 47 interested interested JJ 42759 1900 48 persons person NNS 42759 1900 49 . . . 42759 1901 1 SECTION section NN 42759 1901 2 II II NNP 42759 1901 3 THE the DT 42759 1901 4 MORALITY morality NN 42759 1901 5 OF of IN 42759 1901 6 PRIVATE private JJ 42759 1901 7 CAPITAL capital NN 42759 1901 8 AND and CC 42759 1901 9 INTEREST INTEREST NNP 42759 1901 10 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 42759 1901 11 IX IX NNP 42759 1901 12 THE the DT 42759 1901 13 NATURE NATURE NNS 42759 1901 14 AND and CC 42759 1901 15 THE the DT 42759 1901 16 RATE rate NN 42759 1901 17 OF of IN 42759 1901 18 INTEREST interest NN 42759 1901 19 Interest interest NN 42759 1901 20 denotes denote VBZ 42759 1901 21 that that DT 42759 1901 22 part part NN 42759 1901 23 of of IN 42759 1901 24 the the DT 42759 1901 25 product product NN 42759 1901 26 of of IN 42759 1901 27 industry industry NN 42759 1901 28 which which WDT 42759 1901 29 goes go VBZ 42759 1901 30 to to IN 42759 1901 31 the the DT 42759 1901 32 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 1901 33 . . . 42759 1902 1 As as IN 42759 1902 2 the the DT 42759 1902 3 ownership ownership NN 42759 1902 4 of of IN 42759 1902 5 land land NN 42759 1902 6 commands command NNS 42759 1902 7 rent rent NN 42759 1902 8 , , , 42759 1902 9 so so IN 42759 1902 10 the the DT 42759 1902 11 ownership ownership NN 42759 1902 12 of of IN 42759 1902 13 capital capital NN 42759 1902 14 commands command NNS 42759 1902 15 interest interest NN 42759 1902 16 ; ; : 42759 1902 17 as as IN 42759 1902 18 rent rent NN 42759 1902 19 is be VBZ 42759 1902 20 a a DT 42759 1902 21 price price NN 42759 1902 22 paid pay VBN 42759 1902 23 for for IN 42759 1902 24 the the DT 42759 1902 25 use use NN 42759 1902 26 of of IN 42759 1902 27 land land NN 42759 1902 28 , , , 42759 1902 29 so so CC 42759 1902 30 interest interest NN 42759 1902 31 is be VBZ 42759 1902 32 a a DT 42759 1902 33 price price NN 42759 1902 34 paid pay VBN 42759 1902 35 for for IN 42759 1902 36 the the DT 42759 1902 37 use use NN 42759 1902 38 of of IN 42759 1902 39 capital capital NN 42759 1902 40 . . . 42759 1903 1 However however RB 42759 1903 2 , , , 42759 1903 3 the the DT 42759 1903 4 term term NN 42759 1903 5 capital capital NN 42759 1903 6 is be VBZ 42759 1903 7 less less RBR 42759 1903 8 definite definite JJ 42759 1903 9 and and CC 42759 1903 10 unambiguous unambiguous JJ 42759 1903 11 , , , 42759 1903 12 both both CC 42759 1903 13 in in IN 42759 1903 14 popular popular JJ 42759 1903 15 and and CC 42759 1903 16 in in IN 42759 1903 17 economic economic JJ 42759 1903 18 usage usage NN 42759 1903 19 , , , 42759 1903 20 than than IN 42759 1903 21 the the DT 42759 1903 22 word word NN 42759 1903 23 land land NN 42759 1903 24 . . . 42759 1904 1 The the DT 42759 1904 2 farmer farmer NN 42759 1904 3 , , , 42759 1904 4 the the DT 42759 1904 5 merchant merchant NN 42759 1904 6 , , , 42759 1904 7 and and CC 42759 1904 8 the the DT 42759 1904 9 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 1904 10 often often RB 42759 1904 11 speak speak VBP 42759 1904 12 of of IN 42759 1904 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1904 14 land land NN 42759 1904 15 , , , 42759 1904 16 buildings building NNS 42759 1904 17 , , , 42759 1904 18 and and CC 42759 1904 19 chattels chattel NNS 42759 1904 20 as as IN 42759 1904 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1904 22 capital capital NN 42759 1904 23 , , , 42759 1904 24 and and CC 42759 1904 25 reckon reckon VB 42759 1904 26 the the DT 42759 1904 27 returns return NNS 42759 1904 28 from from IN 42759 1904 29 all all PDT 42759 1904 30 these these DT 42759 1904 31 sources source NNS 42759 1904 32 as as IN 42759 1904 33 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 1904 34 to to IN 42759 1904 35 a a DT 42759 1904 36 certain certain JJ 42759 1904 37 per per IN 42759 1904 38 cent cent NN 42759 1904 39 . . . 42759 1905 1 of of IN 42759 1905 2 interest interest NN 42759 1905 3 or or CC 42759 1905 4 profit profit NN 42759 1905 5 . . . 42759 1906 1 This this DT 42759 1906 2 is be VBZ 42759 1906 3 not not RB 42759 1906 4 technically technically RB 42759 1906 5 correct correct JJ 42759 1906 6 ; ; : 42759 1906 7 when when WRB 42759 1906 8 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1906 9 use use VBP 42759 1906 10 the the DT 42759 1906 11 terms term NNS 42759 1906 12 capital capital NN 42759 1906 13 and and CC 42759 1906 14 interest interest NN 42759 1906 15 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1906 16 should should MD 42759 1906 17 exclude exclude VB 42759 1906 18 the the DT 42759 1906 19 notions notion NNS 42759 1906 20 of of IN 42759 1906 21 land land NN 42759 1906 22 and and CC 42759 1906 23 rent rent NN 42759 1906 24 . . . 42759 1907 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1907 2 Meaning Meaning NNP 42759 1907 3 of of IN 42759 1907 4 Capital Capital NNP 42759 1907 5 and and CC 42759 1907 6 Capitalist Capitalist NNP 42759 1907 7 _ _ NNP 42759 1907 8 Capital Capital NNP 42759 1907 9 is be VBZ 42759 1907 10 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 1907 11 defined define VBN 42759 1907 12 as as IN 42759 1907 13 , , , 42759 1907 14 wealth wealth NN 42759 1907 15 employed employ VBN 42759 1907 16 directly directly RB 42759 1907 17 for for IN 42759 1907 18 the the DT 42759 1907 19 production production NN 42759 1907 20 of of IN 42759 1907 21 new new JJ 42759 1907 22 wealth wealth NN 42759 1907 23 . . . 42759 1908 1 According accord VBG 42759 1908 2 as as IN 42759 1908 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1908 4 is be VBZ 42759 1908 5 considered consider VBN 42759 1908 6 in in IN 42759 1908 7 the the DT 42759 1908 8 abstract abstract NN 42759 1908 9 or or CC 42759 1908 10 the the DT 42759 1908 11 concrete concrete NN 42759 1908 12 , , , 42759 1908 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1908 14 is be VBZ 42759 1908 15 capital capital NN 42759 1908 16 - - HYPH 42759 1908 17 value value NN 42759 1908 18 or or CC 42759 1908 19 capital capital NN 42759 1908 20 - - HYPH 42759 1908 21 instruments instrument NNS 42759 1908 22 . . . 42759 1909 1 For for IN 42759 1909 2 example example NN 42759 1909 3 , , , 42759 1909 4 the the DT 42759 1909 5 owner owner NN 42759 1909 6 of of IN 42759 1909 7 a a DT 42759 1909 8 wagon wagon NN 42759 1909 9 factory factory NN 42759 1909 10 may may MD 42759 1909 11 describe describe VB 42759 1909 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1909 13 capital capital NN 42759 1909 14 as as IN 42759 1909 15 having have VBG 42759 1909 16 a a DT 42759 1909 17 value value NN 42759 1909 18 of of IN 42759 1909 19 100,000 100,000 CD 42759 1909 20 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1909 21 , , , 42759 1909 22 or or CC 42759 1909 23 as as IN 42759 1909 24 consisting consist VBG 42759 1909 25 of of IN 42759 1909 26 certain certain JJ 42759 1909 27 buildings building NNS 42759 1909 28 , , , 42759 1909 29 machines machine NNS 42759 1909 30 , , , 42759 1909 31 tools tool NNS 42759 1909 32 , , , 42759 1909 33 office office NN 42759 1909 34 furniture furniture NN 42759 1909 35 , , , 42759 1909 36 etc etc FW 42759 1909 37 . . . 42759 1910 1 In in IN 42759 1910 2 the the DT 42759 1910 3 former former JJ 42759 1910 4 case case NN 42759 1910 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1910 6 thinks think VBZ 42759 1910 7 of of IN 42759 1910 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1910 9 capital capital NN 42759 1910 10 as as IN 42759 1910 11 so so RB 42759 1910 12 much much JJ 42759 1910 13 abstract abstract JJ 42759 1910 14 value value NN 42759 1910 15 which which WDT 42759 1910 16 , , , 42759 1910 17 through through IN 42759 1910 18 a a DT 42759 1910 19 sale sale NN 42759 1910 20 , , , 42759 1910 21 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1910 22 could could MD 42759 1910 23 take take VB 42759 1910 24 out out IN 42759 1910 25 of of IN 42759 1910 26 the the DT 42759 1910 27 factory factory NN 42759 1910 28 , , , 42759 1910 29 and and CC 42759 1910 30 put put VBN 42759 1910 31 into into IN 42759 1910 32 other other JJ 42759 1910 33 concrete concrete JJ 42759 1910 34 capital capital NN 42759 1910 35 forms form NNS 42759 1910 36 , , , 42759 1910 37 such such JJ 42759 1910 38 as as IN 42759 1910 39 a a DT 42759 1910 40 railroad railroad NN 42759 1910 41 or or CC 42759 1910 42 a a DT 42759 1910 43 jobbing job VBG 42759 1910 44 house house NN 42759 1910 45 . . . 42759 1911 1 In in IN 42759 1911 2 the the DT 42759 1911 3 latter latter JJ 42759 1911 4 case case NN 42759 1911 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1911 6 has have VBZ 42759 1911 7 in in IN 42759 1911 8 mind mind NN 42759 1911 9 the the DT 42759 1911 10 particular particular JJ 42759 1911 11 instruments instrument NNS 42759 1911 12 in in IN 42759 1911 13 which which WDT 42759 1911 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1911 15 capital capital NN 42759 1911 16 is be VBZ 42759 1911 17 at at IN 42759 1911 18 present present JJ 42759 1911 19 embodied embody VBN 42759 1911 20 . . . 42759 1912 1 The the DT 42759 1912 2 capital capital NN 42759 1912 3 - - HYPH 42759 1912 4 value value NN 42759 1912 5 concept concept NN 42759 1912 6 is be VBZ 42759 1912 7 the the DT 42759 1912 8 more more RBR 42759 1912 9 convenient convenient JJ 42759 1912 10 , , , 42759 1912 11 and and CC 42759 1912 12 is be VBZ 42759 1912 13 usually usually RB 42759 1912 14 intended intend VBN 42759 1912 15 when when WRB 42759 1912 16 the the DT 42759 1912 17 word word NN 42759 1912 18 capital capital NN 42759 1912 19 is be VBZ 42759 1912 20 used use VBN 42759 1912 21 without without IN 42759 1912 22 qualification qualification NN 42759 1912 23 . . . 42759 1913 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1913 2 is be VBZ 42759 1913 3 also also RB 42759 1913 4 the the DT 42759 1913 5 basis basis NN 42759 1913 6 upon upon IN 42759 1913 7 which which WDT 42759 1913 8 interest interest NN 42759 1913 9 is be VBZ 42759 1913 10 reckoned reckon VBN 42759 1913 11 ; ; : 42759 1913 12 for for IN 42759 1913 13 the the DT 42759 1913 14 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 1913 15 does do VBZ 42759 1913 16 not not RB 42759 1913 17 measure measure VB 42759 1913 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1913 19 share share NN 42759 1913 20 of of IN 42759 1913 21 the the DT 42759 1913 22 product product NN 42759 1913 23 as as IN 42759 1913 24 so so RB 42759 1913 25 many many JJ 42759 1913 26 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1913 27 of of IN 42759 1913 28 rent rent NN 42759 1913 29 on on IN 42759 1913 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1913 31 capital capital NN 42759 1913 32 - - HYPH 42759 1913 33 instruments instrument NNS 42759 1913 34 , , , 42759 1913 35 but but CC 42759 1913 36 as as IN 42759 1913 37 so so RB 42759 1913 38 many many JJ 42759 1913 39 per per IN 42759 1913 40 cent cent NN 42759 1913 41 . . . 42759 1914 1 on on IN 42759 1914 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1914 3 capital capital NN 42759 1914 4 - - HYPH 42759 1914 5 value value NN 42759 1914 6 . . . 42759 1915 1 Capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 1915 2 are be VBP 42759 1915 3 of of IN 42759 1915 4 two two CD 42759 1915 5 principal principal JJ 42759 1915 6 kinds kind NNS 42759 1915 7 : : : 42759 1915 8 those those DT 42759 1915 9 who who WP 42759 1915 10 employ employ VBP 42759 1915 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1915 12 own own JJ 42759 1915 13 money money NN 42759 1915 14 in in IN 42759 1915 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1915 16 own own JJ 42759 1915 17 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 1915 18 ; ; : 42759 1915 19 and and CC 42759 1915 20 those those DT 42759 1915 21 who who WP 42759 1915 22 lend lend VBP 42759 1915 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1915 24 money money NN 42759 1915 25 to to IN 42759 1915 26 others other NNS 42759 1915 27 for for IN 42759 1915 28 use use NN 42759 1915 29 in in IN 42759 1915 30 industry industry NN 42759 1915 31 . . . 42759 1916 1 The the DT 42759 1916 2 former former JJ 42759 1916 3 may may MD 42759 1916 4 be be VB 42759 1916 5 called call VBN 42759 1916 6 active active JJ 42759 1916 7 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 1916 8 , , , 42759 1916 9 the the DT 42759 1916 10 latter latter JJ 42759 1916 11 loan loan NN 42759 1916 12 - - HYPH 42759 1916 13 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 1916 14 . . . 42759 1917 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 42759 1917 2 a a DT 42759 1917 3 majority majority NN 42759 1917 4 of of IN 42759 1917 5 active active JJ 42759 1917 6 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 1917 7 use use VBP 42759 1917 8 some some DT 42759 1917 9 borrowed borrow VBN 42759 1917 10 money money NN 42759 1917 11 in in IN 42759 1917 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1917 13 business business NN 42759 1917 14 . . . 42759 1918 1 To to IN 42759 1918 2 the the DT 42759 1918 3 lenders lender NNS 42759 1918 4 of of IN 42759 1918 5 this this DT 42759 1918 6 borrowed borrow VBN 42759 1918 7 money money NN 42759 1918 8 or or CC 42759 1918 9 capital capital NN 42759 1918 10 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1918 11 turn turn VBP 42759 1918 12 over over RP 42759 1918 13 a a DT 42759 1918 14 part part NN 42759 1918 15 of of IN 42759 1918 16 the the DT 42759 1918 17 product product NN 42759 1918 18 in in IN 42759 1918 19 the the DT 42759 1918 20 form form NN 42759 1918 21 of of IN 42759 1918 22 interest interest NN 42759 1918 23 . . . 42759 1919 1 When when WRB 42759 1919 2 , , , 42759 1919 3 therefore therefore RB 42759 1919 4 , , , 42759 1919 5 interest interest NN 42759 1919 6 is be VBZ 42759 1919 7 defined define VBN 42759 1919 8 as as IN 42759 1919 9 the the DT 42759 1919 10 share share NN 42759 1919 11 of of IN 42759 1919 12 the the DT 42759 1919 13 product product NN 42759 1919 14 that that WDT 42759 1919 15 goes go VBZ 42759 1919 16 to to IN 42759 1919 17 the the DT 42759 1919 18 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 1919 19 , , , 42759 1919 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1919 21 is be VBZ 42759 1919 22 the the DT 42759 1919 23 owner owner NN 42759 1919 24 of of IN 42759 1919 25 capital capital NN 42759 1919 26 - - HYPH 42759 1919 27 value value NN 42759 1919 28 rather rather RB 42759 1919 29 than than IN 42759 1919 30 of of IN 42759 1919 31 capital capital NN 42759 1919 32 - - HYPH 42759 1919 33 instruments instrument NNS 42759 1919 34 that that WDT 42759 1919 35 is be VBZ 42759 1919 36 meant mean VBN 42759 1919 37 . . . 42759 1920 1 For for IN 42759 1920 2 the the DT 42759 1920 3 man man NN 42759 1920 4 who who WP 42759 1920 5 has have VBZ 42759 1920 6 loaned loan VBN 42759 1920 7 50,000 50,000 CD 42759 1920 8 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1920 9 at at IN 42759 1920 10 five five CD 42759 1920 11 per per NN 42759 1920 12 cent cent NN 42759 1920 13 . . . 42759 1921 1 to to IN 42759 1921 2 the the DT 42759 1921 3 wagon wagon NN 42759 1921 4 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 1921 5 is be VBZ 42759 1921 6 not not RB 42759 1921 7 , , , 42759 1921 8 except except IN 42759 1921 9 hypothetically hypothetically RB 42759 1921 10 , , , 42759 1921 11 the the DT 42759 1921 12 owner owner NN 42759 1921 13 of of IN 42759 1921 14 the the DT 42759 1921 15 buildings building NNS 42759 1921 16 which which WDT 42759 1921 17 have have VBP 42759 1921 18 been be VBN 42759 1921 19 erected erect VBN 42759 1921 20 with with IN 42759 1921 21 that that DT 42759 1921 22 money money NN 42759 1921 23 . . . 42759 1922 1 These these DT 42759 1922 2 are be VBP 42759 1922 3 owned own VBN 42759 1922 4 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1922 5 subject subject JJ 42759 1922 6 possibly possibly RB 42759 1922 7 to to IN 42759 1922 8 a a DT 42759 1922 9 mortgage mortgage NN 42759 1922 10 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1922 11 by by IN 42759 1922 12 the the DT 42759 1922 13 borrower borrower NN 42759 1922 14 , , , 42759 1922 15 the the DT 42759 1922 16 active active JJ 42759 1922 17 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 1922 18 . . . 42759 1923 1 But but CC 42759 1923 2 the the DT 42759 1923 3 abstract abstract JJ 42759 1923 4 value value NN 42759 1923 5 which which WDT 42759 1923 6 has have VBZ 42759 1923 7 gone go VBN 42759 1923 8 into into IN 42759 1923 9 them -PRON- PRP 42759 1923 10 continues continue VBZ 42759 1923 11 to to TO 42759 1923 12 be be VB 42759 1923 13 the the DT 42759 1923 14 property property NN 42759 1923 15 of of IN 42759 1923 16 the the DT 42759 1923 17 lender lender NN 42759 1923 18 . . . 42759 1924 1 As as IN 42759 1924 2 owner owner NN 42759 1924 3 thereof thereof RB 42759 1924 4 , , , 42759 1924 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1924 6 , , , 42759 1924 7 instead instead RB 42759 1924 8 of of IN 42759 1924 9 the the DT 42759 1924 10 active active JJ 42759 1924 11 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 1924 12 , , , 42759 1924 13 receives receive VBZ 42759 1924 14 the the DT 42759 1924 15 interest interest NN 42759 1924 16 that that WDT 42759 1924 17 is be VBZ 42759 1924 18 assigned assign VBN 42759 1924 19 to to IN 42759 1924 20 this this DT 42759 1924 21 portion portion NN 42759 1924 22 of of IN 42759 1924 23 the the DT 42759 1924 24 total total JJ 42759 1924 25 capital capital NN 42759 1924 26 . . . 42759 1925 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1925 2 interest interest NN 42759 1925 3 is be VBZ 42759 1925 4 the the DT 42759 1925 5 share share NN 42759 1925 6 of of IN 42759 1925 7 the the DT 42759 1925 8 product product NN 42759 1925 9 that that WDT 42759 1925 10 is be VBZ 42759 1925 11 taken take VBN 42759 1925 12 by by IN 42759 1925 13 the the DT 42759 1925 14 owner owner NN 42759 1925 15 of of IN 42759 1925 16 capital capital NN 42759 1925 17 , , , 42759 1925 18 whether whether IN 42759 1925 19 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1925 20 employs employ VBZ 42759 1925 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1925 22 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 1925 23 or or CC 42759 1925 24 lends lend VBZ 42759 1925 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1925 26 to to IN 42759 1925 27 some some DT 42759 1925 28 one one NN 42759 1925 29 else else RB 42759 1925 30 . . . 42759 1926 1 While while IN 42759 1926 2 the the DT 42759 1926 3 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 1926 4 reason reason NN 42759 1926 5 of of IN 42759 1926 6 interest interest NN 42759 1926 7 is be VBZ 42759 1926 8 the the DT 42759 1926 9 fact fact NN 42759 1926 10 that that IN 42759 1926 11 certain certain JJ 42759 1926 12 concrete concrete JJ 42759 1926 13 instruments instrument NNS 42759 1926 14 are be VBP 42759 1926 15 necessary necessary JJ 42759 1926 16 to to IN 42759 1926 17 the the DT 42759 1926 18 making making NN 42759 1926 19 of of IN 42759 1926 20 the the DT 42759 1926 21 product product NN 42759 1926 22 , , , 42759 1926 23 interest interest NN 42759 1926 24 is be VBZ 42759 1926 25 always always RB 42759 1926 26 _ _ NNP 42759 1926 27 reckoned reckon VBD 42759 1926 28 _ _ NNP 42759 1926 29 on on IN 42759 1926 30 capital capital NN 42759 1926 31 - - HYPH 42759 1926 32 value value NN 42759 1926 33 , , , 42759 1926 34 and and CC 42759 1926 35 goes go VBZ 42759 1926 36 to to IN 42759 1926 37 the the DT 42759 1926 38 owner owner NN 42759 1926 39 of of IN 42759 1926 40 the the DT 42759 1926 41 capital capital NN 42759 1926 42 - - HYPH 42759 1926 43 value value NN 42759 1926 44 . . . 42759 1927 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1927 2 goes go VBZ 42759 1927 3 to to IN 42759 1927 4 the the DT 42759 1927 5 man man NN 42759 1927 6 whose whose WP$ 42759 1927 7 money money NN 42759 1927 8 has have VBZ 42759 1927 9 been be VBN 42759 1927 10 put put VBN 42759 1927 11 into into IN 42759 1927 12 the the DT 42759 1927 13 instruments instrument NNS 42759 1927 14 , , , 42759 1927 15 whether whether IN 42759 1927 16 or or CC 42759 1927 17 not not RB 42759 1927 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1927 19 is be VBZ 42759 1927 20 the the DT 42759 1927 21 owner owner NN 42759 1927 22 of of IN 42759 1927 23 the the DT 42759 1927 24 instruments instrument NNS 42759 1927 25 . . . 42759 1928 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1928 2 Meaning Meaning NNP 42759 1928 3 of of IN 42759 1928 4 Interest Interest NNP 42759 1928 5 _ _ NNP 42759 1928 6 Interest Interest NNP 42759 1928 7 is be VBZ 42759 1928 8 the the DT 42759 1928 9 share share NN 42759 1928 10 of of IN 42759 1928 11 the the DT 42759 1928 12 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 1928 13 as as IN 42759 1928 14 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 1928 15 . . . 42759 1929 1 The the DT 42759 1929 2 man man NN 42759 1929 3 who who WP 42759 1929 4 employs employ VBZ 42759 1929 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1929 6 own own JJ 42759 1929 7 capital capital NN 42759 1929 8 in in IN 42759 1929 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1929 10 own own JJ 42759 1929 11 business business NN 42759 1929 12 receives receive VBZ 42759 1929 13 therefrom therefrom NN 42759 1929 14 in in IN 42759 1929 15 addition addition NN 42759 1929 16 to to IN 42759 1929 17 interest interest VB 42759 1929 18 other other JJ 42759 1929 19 returns return NNS 42759 1929 20 . . . 42759 1930 1 Let let VB 42759 1930 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 1930 3 suppose suppose VB 42759 1930 4 that that IN 42759 1930 5 some some DT 42759 1930 6 one one NN 42759 1930 7 has have VBZ 42759 1930 8 invested invest VBN 42759 1930 9 100,000 100,000 CD 42759 1930 10 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1930 11 of of IN 42759 1930 12 borrowed borrow VBN 42759 1930 13 money money NN 42759 1930 14 and and CC 42759 1930 15 100,000 100,000 CD 42759 1930 16 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1930 17 of of IN 42759 1930 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1930 19 own own JJ 42759 1930 20 money money NN 42759 1930 21 in in IN 42759 1930 22 a a DT 42759 1930 23 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 1930 24 grocery grocery NN 42759 1930 25 business business NN 42759 1930 26 . . . 42759 1931 1 At at IN 42759 1931 2 the the DT 42759 1931 3 end end NN 42759 1931 4 of of IN 42759 1931 5 the the DT 42759 1931 6 year year NN 42759 1931 7 , , , 42759 1931 8 after after IN 42759 1931 9 defraying defray VBG 42759 1931 10 the the DT 42759 1931 11 cost cost NN 42759 1931 12 of of IN 42759 1931 13 labour labour NN 42759 1931 14 , , , 42759 1931 15 materials material NNS 42759 1931 16 , , , 42759 1931 17 rent rent NN 42759 1931 18 , , , 42759 1931 19 repairs repair NNS 42759 1931 20 , , , 42759 1931 21 and and CC 42759 1931 22 replacement replacement NN 42759 1931 23 , , , 42759 1931 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1931 25 gross gross JJ 42759 1931 26 returns return NNS 42759 1931 27 are be VBP 42759 1931 28 15,000 15,000 CD 42759 1931 29 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1931 30 . . . 42759 1932 1 Out out IN 42759 1932 2 of of IN 42759 1932 3 this this DT 42759 1932 4 sum sum NN 42759 1932 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1932 6 must must MD 42759 1932 7 pay pay VB 42759 1932 8 five five CD 42759 1932 9 thousand thousand CD 42759 1932 10 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1932 11 as as IN 42759 1932 12 interest interest NN 42759 1932 13 on on IN 42759 1932 14 the the DT 42759 1932 15 money money NN 42759 1932 16 that that WDT 42759 1932 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1932 18 has have VBZ 42759 1932 19 borrowed borrow VBN 42759 1932 20 . . . 42759 1933 1 This this DT 42759 1933 2 leaves leave VBZ 42759 1933 3 him -PRON- PRP 42759 1933 4 a a DT 42759 1933 5 total total JJ 42759 1933 6 amount amount NN 42759 1933 7 of of IN 42759 1933 8 ten ten CD 42759 1933 9 thousand thousand CD 42759 1933 10 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1933 11 , , , 42759 1933 12 as as IN 42759 1933 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1933 14 share share NN 42759 1933 15 of of IN 42759 1933 16 the the DT 42759 1933 17 product product NN 42759 1933 18 of of IN 42759 1933 19 the the DT 42759 1933 20 industry industry NN 42759 1933 21 . . . 42759 1934 1 Since since IN 42759 1934 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1934 3 could could MD 42759 1934 4 command command VB 42759 1934 5 a a DT 42759 1934 6 salary salary NN 42759 1934 7 of of IN 42759 1934 8 three three CD 42759 1934 9 thousand thousand CD 42759 1934 10 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1934 11 if if IN 42759 1934 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1934 13 worked work VBD 42759 1934 14 for for IN 42759 1934 15 some some DT 42759 1934 16 one one NN 42759 1934 17 else else RB 42759 1934 18 , , , 42759 1934 19 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1934 20 regards regard VBZ 42759 1934 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1934 22 labour labour NN 42759 1934 23 of of IN 42759 1934 24 directing direct VBG 42759 1934 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1934 26 own own JJ 42759 1934 27 business business NN 42759 1934 28 as as IN 42759 1934 29 worth worth JJ 42759 1934 30 at at IN 42759 1934 31 least least JJS 42759 1934 32 this this DT 42759 1934 33 sum sum NN 42759 1934 34 . . . 42759 1935 1 Deducting deduct VBG 42759 1935 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1935 3 from from IN 42759 1935 4 ten ten CD 42759 1935 5 thousand thousand CD 42759 1935 6 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1935 7 , , , 42759 1935 8 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1935 9 has have VBZ 42759 1935 10 left leave VBN 42759 1935 11 seven seven CD 42759 1935 12 thousand thousand CD 42759 1935 13 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1935 14 , , , 42759 1935 15 which which WDT 42759 1935 16 must must MD 42759 1935 17 in in IN 42759 1935 18 some some DT 42759 1935 19 sense sense NN 42759 1935 20 be be VB 42759 1935 21 accredited accredit VBN 42759 1935 22 as as IN 42759 1935 23 payment payment NN 42759 1935 24 for for IN 42759 1935 25 the the DT 42759 1935 26 use use NN 42759 1935 27 of of IN 42759 1935 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1935 29 own own JJ 42759 1935 30 capital capital NN 42759 1935 31 . . . 42759 1936 1 However however RB 42759 1936 2 , , , 42759 1936 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1936 4 is be VBZ 42759 1936 5 not not RB 42759 1936 6 all all DT 42759 1936 7 pure pure JJ 42759 1936 8 interest interest NN 42759 1936 9 ; ; : 42759 1936 10 for for IN 42759 1936 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1936 12 runs run VBZ 42759 1936 13 the the DT 42759 1936 14 risk risk NN 42759 1936 15 of of IN 42759 1936 16 losing lose VBG 42759 1936 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1936 18 capital capital NN 42759 1936 19 , , , 42759 1936 20 and and CC 42759 1936 21 also also RB 42759 1936 22 of of IN 42759 1936 23 failing fail VBG 42759 1936 24 to to TO 42759 1936 25 get get VB 42759 1936 26 the the DT 42759 1936 27 normal normal JJ 42759 1936 28 rate rate NN 42759 1936 29 of of IN 42759 1936 30 interest interest NN 42759 1936 31 on on IN 42759 1936 32 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1936 33 during during IN 42759 1936 34 future future JJ 42759 1936 35 unprosperous unprosperous JJ 42759 1936 36 years year NNS 42759 1936 37 . . . 42759 1937 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1937 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1937 3 will will MD 42759 1937 4 require require VB 42759 1937 5 a a DT 42759 1937 6 part part NN 42759 1937 7 of of IN 42759 1937 8 the the DT 42759 1937 9 seven seven CD 42759 1937 10 thousand thousand CD 42759 1937 11 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1937 12 as as IN 42759 1937 13 insurance insurance NN 42759 1937 14 against against IN 42759 1937 15 these these DT 42759 1937 16 two two CD 42759 1937 17 contingencies contingency NNS 42759 1937 18 . . . 42759 1938 1 Two two CD 42759 1938 2 per per IN 42759 1938 3 cent cent NN 42759 1938 4 . . . 42759 1939 1 of of IN 42759 1939 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1939 3 capital capital NN 42759 1939 4 , , , 42759 1939 5 or or CC 42759 1939 6 two two CD 42759 1939 7 thousand thousand CD 42759 1939 8 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1939 9 , , , 42759 1939 10 is be VBZ 42759 1939 11 not not RB 42759 1939 12 an an DT 42759 1939 13 excessive excessive JJ 42759 1939 14 allowance allowance NN 42759 1939 15 . . . 42759 1940 1 If if IN 42759 1940 2 the the DT 42759 1940 3 business business NN 42759 1940 4 did do VBD 42759 1940 5 not not RB 42759 1940 6 provide provide VB 42759 1940 7 him -PRON- PRP 42759 1940 8 with with IN 42759 1940 9 this this DT 42759 1940 10 amount amount NN 42759 1940 11 of of IN 42759 1940 12 insurance insurance NN 42759 1940 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1940 14 would would MD 42759 1940 15 probably probably RB 42759 1940 16 regard regard VB 42759 1940 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1940 18 as as IN 42759 1940 19 unsafe unsafe JJ 42759 1940 20 , , , 42759 1940 21 and and CC 42759 1940 22 would would MD 42759 1940 23 sell sell VB 42759 1940 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1940 25 and and CC 42759 1940 26 invest invest VB 42759 1940 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1940 28 money money NN 42759 1940 29 elsewhere elsewhere RB 42759 1940 30 . . . 42759 1941 1 Subtracting subtract VBG 42759 1941 2 two two CD 42759 1941 3 thousand thousand CD 42759 1941 4 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1941 5 from from IN 42759 1941 6 seven seven CD 42759 1941 7 thousand thousand CD 42759 1941 8 , , , 42759 1941 9 we -PRON- PRP 42759 1941 10 have have VBP 42759 1941 11 five five CD 42759 1941 12 thousand thousand CD 42759 1941 13 left left JJ 42759 1941 14 as as IN 42759 1941 15 pure pure JJ 42759 1941 16 interest interest NN 42759 1941 17 on on IN 42759 1941 18 the the DT 42759 1941 19 director director NN 42759 1941 20 's 's POS 42759 1941 21 own own JJ 42759 1941 22 capital capital NN 42759 1941 23 . . . 42759 1942 1 This this DT 42759 1942 2 is be VBZ 42759 1942 3 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 1942 4 to to IN 42759 1942 5 five five CD 42759 1942 6 per per IN 42759 1942 7 cent cent NN 42759 1942 8 . . . 42759 1942 9 , , , 42759 1942 10 which which WDT 42759 1942 11 is be VBZ 42759 1942 12 the the DT 42759 1942 13 rate rate NN 42759 1942 14 that that IN 42759 1942 15 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1942 16 is be VBZ 42759 1942 17 paying pay VBG 42759 1942 18 on on IN 42759 1942 19 the the DT 42759 1942 20 capital capital NN 42759 1942 21 that that WDT 42759 1942 22 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1942 23 has have VBZ 42759 1942 24 borrowed borrow VBN 42759 1942 25 . . . 42759 1943 1 If if IN 42759 1943 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1943 3 could could MD 42759 1943 4 not not RB 42759 1943 5 get get VB 42759 1943 6 this this DT 42759 1943 7 rate rate NN 42759 1943 8 on on IN 42759 1943 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1943 10 own own JJ 42759 1943 11 money money NN 42759 1943 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1943 13 would would MD 42759 1943 14 probably probably RB 42759 1943 15 prefer prefer VB 42759 1943 16 to to TO 42759 1943 17 become become VB 42759 1943 18 a a DT 42759 1943 19 lender lender NN 42759 1943 20 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 1943 21 , , , 42759 1943 22 a a DT 42759 1943 23 loan loan NN 42759 1943 24 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 1943 25 instead instead RB 42759 1943 26 of of IN 42759 1943 27 an an DT 42759 1943 28 active active JJ 42759 1943 29 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 1943 30 . . . 42759 1944 1 This this DT 42759 1944 2 part part NN 42759 1944 3 of of IN 42759 1944 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1944 5 total total JJ 42759 1944 6 share share NN 42759 1944 7 , , , 42759 1944 8 then then RB 42759 1944 9 , , , 42759 1944 10 and and CC 42759 1944 11 only only RB 42759 1944 12 this this DT 42759 1944 13 part part NN 42759 1944 14 , , , 42759 1944 15 is be VBZ 42759 1944 16 pure pure JJ 42759 1944 17 interest interest NN 42759 1944 18 . . . 42759 1945 1 The the DT 42759 1945 2 other other JJ 42759 1945 3 two two CD 42759 1945 4 sums sum NNS 42759 1945 5 that that WDT 42759 1945 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1945 7 receives receive VBZ 42759 1945 8 , , , 42759 1945 9 the the DT 42759 1945 10 three three CD 42759 1945 11 thousand thousand CD 42759 1945 12 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1945 13 and and CC 42759 1945 14 the the DT 42759 1945 15 two two CD 42759 1945 16 thousand thousand CD 42759 1945 17 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1945 18 , , , 42759 1945 19 are be VBP 42759 1945 20 respectively respectively RB 42759 1945 21 wages wage NNS 42759 1945 22 for for IN 42759 1945 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1945 24 labour labour NN 42759 1945 25 and and CC 42759 1945 26 insurance insurance NN 42759 1945 27 against against IN 42759 1945 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1945 29 risks risk NNS 42759 1945 30 . . . 42759 1946 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 42759 1946 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1946 3 are be VBP 42759 1946 4 classified classify VBN 42759 1946 5 together together RB 42759 1946 6 under under IN 42759 1946 7 the the DT 42759 1946 8 general general JJ 42759 1946 9 name name NN 42759 1946 10 of of IN 42759 1946 11 profits profit NNS 42759 1946 12 . . . 42759 1947 1 Let let VB 42759 1947 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 1947 3 suppose suppose VB 42759 1947 4 , , , 42759 1947 5 however however RB 42759 1947 6 , , , 42759 1947 7 that that IN 42759 1947 8 the the DT 42759 1947 9 gross gross JJ 42759 1947 10 returns return NNS 42759 1947 11 are be VBP 42759 1947 12 not not RB 42759 1947 13 15,000 15,000 CD 42759 1947 14 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1947 15 , , , 42759 1947 16 but but CC 42759 1947 17 17,000 17,000 CD 42759 1947 18 . . . 42759 1948 1 How how WRB 42759 1948 2 is be VBZ 42759 1948 3 the the DT 42759 1948 4 additional additional JJ 42759 1948 5 sum sum NN 42759 1948 6 to to TO 42759 1948 7 be be VB 42759 1948 8 denominated denominate VBN 42759 1948 9 ? ? . 42759 1949 1 In in IN 42759 1949 2 strict strict JJ 42759 1949 3 economic economic JJ 42759 1949 4 language language NN 42759 1949 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1949 6 would would MD 42759 1949 7 probably probably RB 42759 1949 8 be be VB 42759 1949 9 called call VBN 42759 1949 10 net net JJ 42759 1949 11 profits profit NNS 42759 1949 12 , , , 42759 1949 13 as as IN 42759 1949 14 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 1949 15 from from IN 42759 1949 16 normal normal JJ 42759 1949 17 or or CC 42759 1949 18 necessary necessary JJ 42759 1949 19 profits profit NNS 42759 1949 20 , , , 42759 1949 21 which which WDT 42759 1949 22 comprise comprise VBP 42759 1949 23 wages wage NNS 42759 1949 24 of of IN 42759 1949 25 direction direction NN 42759 1949 26 and and CC 42759 1949 27 insurance insurance NN 42759 1949 28 against against IN 42759 1949 29 loss loss NN 42759 1949 30 . . . 42759 1950 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 42759 1950 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1950 3 is be VBZ 42759 1950 4 called call VBN 42759 1950 5 interest interest NN 42759 1950 6 . . . 42759 1951 1 In in IN 42759 1951 2 that that DT 42759 1951 3 case case NN 42759 1951 4 the the DT 42759 1951 5 owner owner NN 42759 1951 6 of of IN 42759 1951 7 the the DT 42759 1951 8 store store NN 42759 1951 9 would would MD 42759 1951 10 receive receive VB 42759 1951 11 seven seven CD 42759 1951 12 instead instead RB 42759 1951 13 of of IN 42759 1951 14 five five CD 42759 1951 15 per per NN 42759 1951 16 cent cent NN 42759 1951 17 , , , 42759 1951 18 on on IN 42759 1951 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1951 20 own own JJ 42759 1951 21 capital capital NN 42759 1951 22 . . . 42759 1952 1 Whether whether IN 42759 1952 2 the the DT 42759 1952 3 extra extra JJ 42759 1952 4 two two CD 42759 1952 5 per per IN 42759 1952 6 cent cent NN 42759 1952 7 . . . 42759 1953 1 ( ( -LRB- 42759 1953 2 2,000 2,000 CD 42759 1953 3 dollars dollar NNS 42759 1953 4 ) ) -RRB- 42759 1953 5 be be VB 42759 1953 6 called call VBN 42759 1953 7 net net JJ 42759 1953 8 profits profit NNS 42759 1953 9 or or CC 42759 1953 10 surplus surplus JJ 42759 1953 11 interest interest NN 42759 1953 12 , , , 42759 1953 13 is be VBZ 42759 1953 14 mainly mainly RB 42759 1953 15 a a DT 42759 1953 16 matter matter NN 42759 1953 17 of of IN 42759 1953 18 terminology terminology NN 42759 1953 19 . . . 42759 1954 1 The the DT 42759 1954 2 important important JJ 42759 1954 3 thing thing NN 42759 1954 4 is be VBZ 42759 1954 5 to to TO 42759 1954 6 indicate indicate VB 42759 1954 7 clearly clearly RB 42759 1954 8 that that IN 42759 1954 9 these these DT 42759 1954 10 terms term NNS 42759 1954 11 designate designate VBP 42759 1954 12 the the DT 42759 1954 13 surplus surplus NN 42759 1954 14 which which WDT 42759 1954 15 goes go VBZ 42759 1954 16 to to IN 42759 1954 17 the the DT 42759 1954 18 active active JJ 42759 1954 19 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 1954 20 in in IN 42759 1954 21 addition addition NN 42759 1954 22 to to IN 42759 1954 23 necessary necessary JJ 42759 1954 24 profits profit NNS 42759 1954 25 and and CC 42759 1954 26 necessary necessary JJ 42759 1954 27 interest interest NN 42759 1954 28 . . . 42759 1955 1 At at IN 42759 1955 2 the the DT 42759 1955 3 risk risk NN 42759 1955 4 of of IN 42759 1955 5 wearisome wearisome NN 42759 1955 6 repetition repetition NN 42759 1955 7 , , , 42759 1955 8 one one CD 42759 1955 9 more more JJR 42759 1955 10 example example NN 42759 1955 11 will will MD 42759 1955 12 be be VB 42759 1955 13 given give VBN 42759 1955 14 to to TO 42759 1955 15 illustrate illustrate VB 42759 1955 16 the the DT 42759 1955 17 distinction distinction NN 42759 1955 18 between between IN 42759 1955 19 interest interest NN 42759 1955 20 and and CC 42759 1955 21 the the DT 42759 1955 22 other other JJ 42759 1955 23 returns return NNS 42759 1955 24 that that WDT 42759 1955 25 are be VBP 42759 1955 26 received receive VBN 42759 1955 27 in in IN 42759 1955 28 connection connection NN 42759 1955 29 with with IN 42759 1955 30 capital capital NN 42759 1955 31 . . . 42759 1956 1 The the DT 42759 1956 2 annual annual JJ 42759 1956 3 income income NN 42759 1956 4 from from IN 42759 1956 5 a a DT 42759 1956 6 railway railway NN 42759 1956 7 bond bond NN 42759 1956 8 is be VBZ 42759 1956 9 interest interest NN 42759 1956 10 on on IN 42759 1956 11 lender lender NNP 42759 1956 12 's 's POS 42759 1956 13 capital capital NN 42759 1956 14 , , , 42759 1956 15 and and CC 42759 1956 16 consequently consequently RB 42759 1956 17 pure pure JJ 42759 1956 18 interest interest NN 42759 1956 19 . . . 42759 1957 1 Ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 1957 2 the the DT 42759 1957 3 bondholder bondholder NN 42759 1957 4 is be VBZ 42759 1957 5 adequately adequately RB 42759 1957 6 protected protect VBN 42759 1957 7 against against IN 42759 1957 8 the the DT 42759 1957 9 loss loss NN 42759 1957 10 of of IN 42759 1957 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1957 12 capital capital NN 42759 1957 13 by by IN 42759 1957 14 a a DT 42759 1957 15 mortgage mortgage NN 42759 1957 16 on on IN 42759 1957 17 the the DT 42759 1957 18 railroad railroad NN 42759 1957 19 . . . 42759 1958 1 On on IN 42759 1958 2 the the DT 42759 1958 3 other other JJ 42759 1958 4 hand hand NN 42759 1958 5 , , , 42759 1958 6 the the DT 42759 1958 7 holder holder NN 42759 1958 8 of of IN 42759 1958 9 a a DT 42759 1958 10 share share NN 42759 1958 11 of of IN 42759 1958 12 railway railway NN 42759 1958 13 stock stock NN 42759 1958 14 is be VBZ 42759 1958 15 a a DT 42759 1958 16 part part NN 42759 1958 17 owner owner NN 42759 1958 18 of of IN 42759 1958 19 the the DT 42759 1958 20 railroad railroad NN 42759 1958 21 , , , 42759 1958 22 and and CC 42759 1958 23 consequently consequently RB 42759 1958 24 incurs incur VBZ 42759 1958 25 the the DT 42759 1958 26 risk risk NN 42759 1958 27 of of IN 42759 1958 28 losing lose VBG 42759 1958 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1958 30 property property NN 42759 1958 31 . . . 42759 1959 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1959 2 the the DT 42759 1959 3 dividend dividend NN 42759 1959 4 that that IN 42759 1959 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 1959 6 receives receive VBZ 42759 1959 7 on on IN 42759 1959 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 1959 9 stock stock NN 42759 1959 10 comprises comprise VBZ 42759 1959 11 interest interest NN 42759 1959 12 on on IN 42759 1959 13 capital capital NN 42759 1959 14 plus plus CC 42759 1959 15 insurance insurance NN 42759 1959 16 against against IN 42759 1959 17 loss loss NN 42759 1959 18 . . . 42759 1960 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1960 2 is be VBZ 42759 1960 3 usually usually RB 42759 1960 4 one one CD 42759 1960 5 or or CC 42759 1960 6 two two CD 42759 1960 7 per per NN 42759 1960 8 cent cent NN 42759 1960 9 . . . 42759 1961 1 higher high JJR 42759 1961 2 than than IN 42759 1961 3 the the DT 42759 1961 4 rate rate NN 42759 1961 5 on on IN 42759 1961 6 the the DT 42759 1961 7 bonds bond NNS 42759 1961 8 . . . 42759 1962 1 Since since IN 42759 1962 2 the the DT 42759 1962 3 officers officer NNS 42759 1962 4 and and CC 42759 1962 5 directors director NNS 42759 1962 6 are be VBP 42759 1962 7 the the DT 42759 1962 8 only only JJ 42759 1962 9 shareholders shareholder NNS 42759 1962 10 who who WP 42759 1962 11 perform perform VBP 42759 1962 12 any any DT 42759 1962 13 labour labour NN 42759 1962 14 in in IN 42759 1962 15 the the DT 42759 1962 16 management management NN 42759 1962 17 of of IN 42759 1962 18 the the DT 42759 1962 19 railroad railroad NN 42759 1962 20 , , , 42759 1962 21 only only RB 42759 1962 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1962 23 receive receive VBP 42759 1962 24 wages wage NNS 42759 1962 25 of of IN 42759 1962 26 management management NN 42759 1962 27 . . . 42759 1963 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 1963 2 the the DT 42759 1963 3 gross gross JJ 42759 1963 4 profits profit NNS 42759 1963 5 are be VBP 42759 1963 6 divided divide VBN 42759 1963 7 into into IN 42759 1963 8 interest interest NN 42759 1963 9 and and CC 42759 1963 10 dividends dividend NNS 42759 1963 11 at at IN 42759 1963 12 fixed fix VBN 42759 1963 13 rates rate NNS 42759 1963 14 , , , 42759 1963 15 and and CC 42759 1963 16 fixed fix VBN 42759 1963 17 salaries salary NNS 42759 1963 18 . . . 42759 1964 1 When when WRB 42759 1964 2 a a DT 42759 1964 3 surplus surplus NN 42759 1964 4 exists exist VBZ 42759 1964 5 above above IN 42759 1964 6 these these DT 42759 1964 7 requirements requirement NNS 42759 1964 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1964 9 is be VBZ 42759 1964 10 not not RB 42759 1964 11 , , , 42759 1964 12 as as IN 42759 1964 13 a a DT 42759 1964 14 rule rule NN 42759 1964 15 , , , 42759 1964 16 distributed distribute VBN 42759 1964 17 among among IN 42759 1964 18 the the DT 42759 1964 19 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 1964 20 annually annually RB 42759 1964 21 . . . 42759 1965 1 In in IN 42759 1965 2 railroads railroad NNS 42759 1965 3 , , , 42759 1965 4 therefore therefore RB 42759 1965 5 , , , 42759 1965 6 and and CC 42759 1965 7 many many JJ 42759 1965 8 other other JJ 42759 1965 9 corporations corporation NNS 42759 1965 10 , , , 42759 1965 11 interest interest NN 42759 1965 12 is be VBZ 42759 1965 13 easily easily RB 42759 1965 14 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 1965 15 from from IN 42759 1965 16 those those DT 42759 1965 17 other other JJ 42759 1965 18 returns return NNS 42759 1965 19 with with IN 42759 1965 20 which which WDT 42759 1965 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1965 22 is be VBZ 42759 1965 23 frequently frequently RB 42759 1965 24 confused confuse VBN 42759 1965 25 in in IN 42759 1965 26 partnerships partnership NNS 42759 1965 27 and and CC 42759 1965 28 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 1965 29 carried carry VBN 42759 1965 30 on on RP 42759 1965 31 by by IN 42759 1965 32 individuals individual NNS 42759 1965 33 . . . 42759 1966 1 _ _ NNP 42759 1966 2 The the DT 42759 1966 3 Rate Rate NNP 42759 1966 4 of of IN 42759 1966 5 Interest Interest NNP 42759 1966 6 _ _ NNP 42759 1966 7 Is be VBZ 42759 1966 8 there there EX 42759 1966 9 a a DT 42759 1966 10 single single JJ 42759 1966 11 rate rate NN 42759 1966 12 of of IN 42759 1966 13 interest interest NN 42759 1966 14 throughout throughout IN 42759 1966 15 industry industry NN 42759 1966 16 ? ? . 42759 1967 1 At at IN 42759 1967 2 first first JJ 42759 1967 3 sight sight NN 42759 1967 4 this this DT 42759 1967 5 question question NN 42759 1967 6 would would MD 42759 1967 7 seem seem VB 42759 1967 8 to to TO 42759 1967 9 demand demand VB 42759 1967 10 a a DT 42759 1967 11 negative negative JJ 42759 1967 12 answer answer NN 42759 1967 13 . . . 42759 1968 1 United United NNP 42759 1968 2 States States NNP 42759 1968 3 bonds bond NNS 42759 1968 4 pay pay VBP 42759 1968 5 about about RB 42759 1968 6 two two CD 42759 1968 7 per per NN 42759 1968 8 cent cent NN 42759 1968 9 . . . 42759 1969 1 ; ; : 42759 1969 2 banks bank NNS 42759 1969 3 about about RB 42759 1969 4 three three CD 42759 1969 5 per per IN 42759 1969 6 cent cent NN 42759 1969 7 . . . 42759 1970 1 ; ; : 42759 1970 2 municipal municipal JJ 42759 1970 3 bonds bond NNS 42759 1970 4 about about RB 42759 1970 5 four four CD 42759 1970 6 per per NN 42759 1970 7 cent cent NN 42759 1970 8 . . . 42759 1971 1 ; ; : 42759 1971 2 railway railway NN 42759 1971 3 bonds bond NNS 42759 1971 4 about about RB 42759 1971 5 five five CD 42759 1971 6 per per NN 42759 1971 7 cent cent NN 42759 1971 8 . . . 42759 1972 1 ; ; : 42759 1972 2 the the DT 42759 1972 3 stocks stock NNS 42759 1972 4 of of IN 42759 1972 5 stable stable JJ 42759 1972 6 industrial industrial JJ 42759 1972 7 corporations corporation NNS 42759 1972 8 about about IN 42759 1972 9 six six CD 42759 1972 10 per per IN 42759 1972 11 cent cent NN 42759 1972 12 . . . 42759 1973 1 net net JJ 42759 1973 2 ; ; : 42759 1973 3 real real JJ 42759 1973 4 estate estate NN 42759 1973 5 mortgages mortgage NNS 42759 1973 6 from from IN 42759 1973 7 five five CD 42759 1973 8 to to TO 42759 1973 9 seven seven CD 42759 1973 10 per per IN 42759 1973 11 cent cent NN 42759 1973 12 . . . 42759 1974 1 ; ; : 42759 1974 2 promissory promissory JJ 42759 1974 3 notes note NNS 42759 1974 4 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 1974 5 higher high JJR 42759 1974 6 rates rate NNS 42759 1974 7 ; ; : 42759 1974 8 and and CC 42759 1974 9 pawnbrokers pawnbroker NNS 42759 1974 10 ' ' POS 42759 1974 11 loans loan NNS 42759 1974 12 from from IN 42759 1974 13 twelve twelve CD 42759 1974 14 per per IN 42759 1974 15 cent cent NN 42759 1974 16 . . . 42759 1975 1 upwards upwards RB 42759 1975 2 . . . 42759 1976 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 1976 2 , , , 42759 1976 3 the the DT 42759 1976 4 same same JJ 42759 1976 5 kind kind NN 42759 1976 6 of of IN 42759 1976 7 loans loan NNS 42759 1976 8 brings bring VBZ 42759 1976 9 different different JJ 42759 1976 10 rates rate NNS 42759 1976 11 in in IN 42759 1976 12 different different JJ 42759 1976 13 places place NNS 42759 1976 14 . . . 42759 1977 1 For for IN 42759 1977 2 example example NN 42759 1977 3 , , , 42759 1977 4 money money NN 42759 1977 5 lent lend VBN 42759 1977 6 on on IN 42759 1977 7 the the DT 42759 1977 8 security security NN 42759 1977 9 of of IN 42759 1977 10 farm farm NN 42759 1977 11 mortgages mortgage NNS 42759 1977 12 yields yield NNS 42759 1977 13 only only RB 42759 1977 14 about about RB 42759 1977 15 five five CD 42759 1977 16 per per NN 42759 1977 17 cent cent NN 42759 1977 18 . . . 42759 1978 1 in in IN 42759 1978 2 the the DT 42759 1978 3 states state NNS 42759 1978 4 of of IN 42759 1978 5 the the DT 42759 1978 6 East East NNP 42759 1978 7 , , , 42759 1978 8 but but CC 42759 1978 9 seven seven CD 42759 1978 10 or or CC 42759 1978 11 eight eight CD 42759 1978 12 per per NN 42759 1978 13 cent cent NN 42759 1978 14 . . . 42759 1979 1 on on IN 42759 1979 2 the the DT 42759 1979 3 Pacific Pacific NNP 42759 1979 4 coast coast NN 42759 1979 5 . . . 42759 1980 1 These these DT 42759 1980 2 and and CC 42759 1980 3 similar similar JJ 42759 1980 4 variations variation NNS 42759 1980 5 are be VBP 42759 1980 6 differences difference NNS 42759 1980 7 not not RB 42759 1980 8 so so RB 42759 1980 9 much much JJ 42759 1980 10 of of IN 42759 1980 11 interest interest NN 42759 1980 12 as as IN 42759 1980 13 of of IN 42759 1980 14 security security NN 42759 1980 15 , , , 42759 1980 16 cost cost NN 42759 1980 17 of of IN 42759 1980 18 negotiation negotiation NN 42759 1980 19 , , , 42759 1980 20 and and CC 42759 1980 21 mental mental JJ 42759 1980 22 attitude attitude NN 42759 1980 23 . . . 42759 1981 1 The the DT 42759 1981 2 farm farm NN 42759 1981 3 mortgage mortgage NN 42759 1981 4 pays pay VBZ 42759 1981 5 a a DT 42759 1981 6 higher high JJR 42759 1981 7 rate rate NN 42759 1981 8 than than IN 42759 1981 9 the the DT 42759 1981 10 government government NN 42759 1981 11 bond bond NN 42759 1981 12 partly partly RB 42759 1981 13 because because IN 42759 1981 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1981 15 is be VBZ 42759 1981 16 less less RBR 42759 1981 17 secure secure JJ 42759 1981 18 , , , 42759 1981 19 partly partly RB 42759 1981 20 because because IN 42759 1981 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1981 22 involves involve VBZ 42759 1981 23 greater great JJR 42759 1981 24 trouble trouble NN 42759 1981 25 of of IN 42759 1981 26 investment investment NN 42759 1981 27 , , , 42759 1981 28 and and CC 42759 1981 29 partly partly RB 42759 1981 30 because because IN 42759 1981 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1981 32 does do VBZ 42759 1981 33 not not RB 42759 1981 34 run run VB 42759 1981 35 for for IN 42759 1981 36 so so RB 42759 1981 37 long long RB 42759 1981 38 a a DT 42759 1981 39 time time NN 42759 1981 40 . . . 42759 1982 1 For for IN 42759 1982 2 the the DT 42759 1982 3 same same JJ 42759 1982 4 reasons reason NNS 42759 1982 5 a a DT 42759 1982 6 higher high JJR 42759 1982 7 rate rate NN 42759 1982 8 of of IN 42759 1982 9 interest interest NN 42759 1982 10 is be VBZ 42759 1982 11 charged charge VBN 42759 1982 12 on on IN 42759 1982 13 a a DT 42759 1982 14 promissory promissory JJ 42759 1982 15 note note NN 42759 1982 16 than than IN 42759 1982 17 on on IN 42759 1982 18 a a DT 42759 1982 19 bank bank NN 42759 1982 20 deposit deposit NN 42759 1982 21 certificate certificate NN 42759 1982 22 . . . 42759 1983 1 Again again RB 42759 1983 2 , , , 42759 1983 3 the the DT 42759 1983 4 lower low JJR 42759 1983 5 rates rate NNS 42759 1983 6 on on IN 42759 1983 7 government government NN 42759 1983 8 bonds bond NNS 42759 1983 9 and and CC 42759 1983 10 bank bank NN 42759 1983 11 deposits deposit NNS 42759 1983 12 are be VBP 42759 1983 13 due due JJ 42759 1983 14 in in IN 42759 1983 15 some some DT 42759 1983 16 degree degree NN 42759 1983 17 to to IN 42759 1983 18 the the DT 42759 1983 19 peculiar peculiar JJ 42759 1983 20 attitude attitude NN 42759 1983 21 of of IN 42759 1983 22 that that DT 42759 1983 23 class class NN 42759 1983 24 of of IN 42759 1983 25 investors investor NNS 42759 1983 26 whose whose WP$ 42759 1983 27 savings saving NNS 42759 1983 28 are be VBP 42759 1983 29 small small JJ 42759 1983 30 in in IN 42759 1983 31 amount amount NN 42759 1983 32 , , , 42759 1983 33 who who WP 42759 1983 34 are be VBP 42759 1983 35 not not RB 42759 1983 36 well well RB 42759 1983 37 aware aware JJ 42759 1983 38 of of IN 42759 1983 39 the the DT 42759 1983 40 range range NN 42759 1983 41 of of IN 42759 1983 42 investment investment NN 42759 1983 43 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 1983 44 , , , 42759 1983 45 and and CC 42759 1983 46 to to IN 42759 1983 47 whom whom WP 42759 1983 48 security security NN 42759 1983 49 and and CC 42759 1983 50 convenience convenience NN 42759 1983 51 are be VBP 42759 1983 52 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 1983 53 important important JJ 42759 1983 54 considerations consideration NNS 42759 1983 55 . . . 42759 1984 1 If if IN 42759 1984 2 such such JJ 42759 1984 3 persons person NNS 42759 1984 4 did do VBD 42759 1984 5 not not RB 42759 1984 6 exist exist VB 42759 1984 7 the the DT 42759 1984 8 rates rate NNS 42759 1984 9 on on IN 42759 1984 10 government government NN 42759 1984 11 bonds bond NNS 42759 1984 12 and and CC 42759 1984 13 savings saving NNS 42759 1984 14 deposits deposit NNS 42759 1984 15 would would MD 42759 1984 16 be be VB 42759 1984 17 higher high JJR 42759 1984 18 than than IN 42759 1984 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1984 20 actually actually RB 42759 1984 21 are be VBP 42759 1984 22 . . . 42759 1985 1 The the DT 42759 1985 2 higher high JJR 42759 1985 3 rates rate NNS 42759 1985 4 in in IN 42759 1985 5 a a DT 42759 1985 6 new new JJ 42759 1985 7 country country NN 42759 1985 8 on on IN 42759 1985 9 , , , 42759 1985 10 say say UH 42759 1985 11 , , , 42759 1985 12 farm farm NN 42759 1985 13 mortgages mortgage NNS 42759 1985 14 are be VBP 42759 1985 15 likewise likewise RB 42759 1985 16 due due JJ 42759 1985 17 in in IN 42759 1985 18 part part NN 42759 1985 19 to to IN 42759 1985 20 psychical psychical JJ 42759 1985 21 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 42759 1985 22 . . . 42759 1986 1 Where where WRB 42759 1986 2 men man NNS 42759 1986 3 are be VBP 42759 1986 4 more more RBR 42759 1986 5 speculative speculative JJ 42759 1986 6 and and CC 42759 1986 7 more more RBR 42759 1986 8 eager eager JJ 42759 1986 9 to to TO 42759 1986 10 borrow borrow VB 42759 1986 11 money money NN 42759 1986 12 for for IN 42759 1986 13 industrial industrial JJ 42759 1986 14 purposes purpose NNS 42759 1986 15 , , , 42759 1986 16 the the DT 42759 1986 17 demand demand NN 42759 1986 18 for for IN 42759 1986 19 loans loan NNS 42759 1986 20 is be VBZ 42759 1986 21 greater great JJR 42759 1986 22 relatively relatively RB 42759 1986 23 to to IN 42759 1986 24 the the DT 42759 1986 25 supply supply NN 42759 1986 26 than than IN 42759 1986 27 in in IN 42759 1986 28 older old JJR 42759 1986 29 and and CC 42759 1986 30 more more JJR 42759 1986 31 conservative conservative JJ 42759 1986 32 communities community NNS 42759 1986 33 . . . 42759 1987 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 1987 2 , , , 42759 1987 3 the the DT 42759 1987 4 price price NN 42759 1987 5 of of IN 42759 1987 6 the the DT 42759 1987 7 loans loan NNS 42759 1987 8 , , , 42759 1987 9 the the DT 42759 1987 10 rate rate NN 42759 1987 11 of of IN 42759 1987 12 interest interest NN 42759 1987 13 , , , 42759 1987 14 is be VBZ 42759 1987 15 higher high JJR 42759 1987 16 . . . 42759 1988 1 In in IN 42759 1988 2 one one CD 42759 1988 3 sense sense NN 42759 1988 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1988 5 would would MD 42759 1988 6 seem seem VB 42759 1988 7 that that IN 42759 1988 8 the the DT 42759 1988 9 lowest low JJS 42759 1988 10 of of IN 42759 1988 11 the the DT 42759 1988 12 rates rate NNS 42759 1988 13 cited cite VBN 42759 1988 14 above above RB 42759 1988 15 , , , 42759 1988 16 namely namely RB 42759 1988 17 , , , 42759 1988 18 that that IN 42759 1988 19 on on IN 42759 1988 20 United United NNP 42759 1988 21 States States NNP 42759 1988 22 bonds bond NNS 42759 1988 23 , , , 42759 1988 24 represents represent VBZ 42759 1988 25 pure pure JJ 42759 1988 26 interest interest NN 42759 1988 27 , , , 42759 1988 28 and and CC 42759 1988 29 that that IN 42759 1988 30 all all PDT 42759 1988 31 the the DT 42759 1988 32 other other JJ 42759 1988 33 rates rate NNS 42759 1988 34 are be VBP 42759 1988 35 interest interest NN 42759 1988 36 plus plus CC 42759 1988 37 something something NN 42759 1988 38 else else RB 42759 1988 39 . . . 42759 1989 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 1989 2 , , , 42759 1989 3 the the DT 42759 1989 4 sums sum NNS 42759 1989 5 invested invest VBN 42759 1989 6 in in IN 42759 1989 7 these these DT 42759 1989 8 bonds bond NNS 42759 1989 9 form form VBP 42759 1989 10 but but CC 42759 1989 11 a a DT 42759 1989 12 very very RB 42759 1989 13 small small JJ 42759 1989 14 part part NN 42759 1989 15 of of IN 42759 1989 16 the the DT 42759 1989 17 whole whole JJ 42759 1989 18 amount amount NN 42759 1989 19 of of IN 42759 1989 20 money money NN 42759 1989 21 and and CC 42759 1989 22 capital capital NN 42759 1989 23 drawing drawing NN 42759 1989 24 interest interest NN 42759 1989 25 , , , 42759 1989 26 and and CC 42759 1989 27 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1989 28 come come VBP 42759 1989 29 from from IN 42759 1989 30 persons person NNS 42759 1989 31 who who WP 42759 1989 32 do do VBP 42759 1989 33 not not RB 42759 1989 34 display display VB 42759 1989 35 the the DT 42759 1989 36 average average JJ 42759 1989 37 degree degree NN 42759 1989 38 either either CC 42759 1989 39 of of IN 42759 1989 40 business business NN 42759 1989 41 ability ability NN 42759 1989 42 or or CC 42759 1989 43 of of IN 42759 1989 44 willingness willingness NN 42759 1989 45 to to TO 42759 1989 46 take take VB 42759 1989 47 risks risk NNS 42759 1989 48 . . . 42759 1990 1 Hence hence RB 42759 1990 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1990 3 is be VBZ 42759 1990 4 more more RBR 42759 1990 5 convenient convenient JJ 42759 1990 6 and and CC 42759 1990 7 more more RBR 42759 1990 8 correct correct JJ 42759 1990 9 to to TO 42759 1990 10 regard regard VB 42759 1990 11 as as IN 42759 1990 12 the the DT 42759 1990 13 standard standard JJ 42759 1990 14 rate rate NN 42759 1990 15 of of IN 42759 1990 16 interest interest NN 42759 1990 17 in in IN 42759 1990 18 any any DT 42759 1990 19 community community NN 42759 1990 20 that that WDT 42759 1990 21 which which WDT 42759 1990 22 is be VBZ 42759 1990 23 obtained obtain VBN 42759 1990 24 on on IN 42759 1990 25 first first JJ 42759 1990 26 class class NN 42759 1990 27 industrial industrial JJ 42759 1990 28 security security NN 42759 1990 29 , , , 42759 1990 30 such such JJ 42759 1990 31 as as IN 42759 1990 32 the the DT 42759 1990 33 bonds bond NNS 42759 1990 34 of of IN 42759 1990 35 railroads railroad NNS 42759 1990 36 and and CC 42759 1990 37 other other JJ 42759 1990 38 stable stable JJ 42759 1990 39 corporations corporation NNS 42759 1990 40 , , , 42759 1990 41 and and CC 42759 1990 42 mortgages mortgage NNS 42759 1990 43 on on IN 42759 1990 44 real real JJ 42759 1990 45 estate estate NN 42759 1990 46 . . . 42759 1991 1 Loans loan NNS 42759 1991 2 to to IN 42759 1991 3 these these DT 42759 1991 4 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 1991 5 are be VBP 42759 1991 6 subject subject JJ 42759 1991 7 to to IN 42759 1991 8 what what WP 42759 1991 9 may may MD 42759 1991 10 properly properly RB 42759 1991 11 be be VB 42759 1991 12 called call VBN 42759 1991 13 the the DT 42759 1991 14 average average JJ 42759 1991 15 or or CC 42759 1991 16 prevailing prevailing JJ 42759 1991 17 industrial industrial JJ 42759 1991 18 risks risk NNS 42759 1991 19 , , , 42759 1991 20 are be VBP 42759 1991 21 negotiated negotiate VBN 42759 1991 22 in in IN 42759 1991 23 average average JJ 42759 1991 24 psychical psychical JJ 42759 1991 25 conditions condition NNS 42759 1991 26 , , , 42759 1991 27 and and CC 42759 1991 28 embrace embrace VB 42759 1991 29 by by IN 42759 1991 30 far far RB 42759 1991 31 the the DT 42759 1991 32 greater great JJR 42759 1991 33 part part NN 42759 1991 34 of of IN 42759 1991 35 all all DT 42759 1991 36 money money NN 42759 1991 37 drawing draw VBG 42759 1991 38 interest interest NN 42759 1991 39 ; ; : 42759 1991 40 consequently consequently RB 42759 1991 41 the the DT 42759 1991 42 rate rate NN 42759 1991 43 that that WDT 42759 1991 44 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1991 45 command command NN 42759 1991 46 may may MD 42759 1991 47 be be VB 42759 1991 48 looked look VBN 42759 1991 49 upon upon IN 42759 1991 50 as as IN 42759 1991 51 in in IN 42759 1991 52 a a DT 42759 1991 53 very very RB 42759 1991 54 real real JJ 42759 1991 55 and and CC 42759 1991 56 practical practical JJ 42759 1991 57 sense sense NN 42759 1991 58 normal normal JJ 42759 1991 59 . . . 42759 1992 1 While while IN 42759 1992 2 this this DT 42759 1992 3 conception conception NN 42759 1992 4 of of IN 42759 1992 5 the the DT 42759 1992 6 normal normal JJ 42759 1992 7 rate rate NN 42759 1992 8 is be VBZ 42759 1992 9 in in IN 42759 1992 10 a a DT 42759 1992 11 measure measure NN 42759 1992 12 conventional conventional JJ 42759 1992 13 , , , 42759 1992 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1992 15 accords accord VBZ 42759 1992 16 with with IN 42759 1992 17 popular popular JJ 42759 1992 18 usage usage NN 42759 1992 19 . . . 42759 1993 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 1993 2 is be VBZ 42759 1993 3 what what WP 42759 1993 4 most most JJS 42759 1993 5 men man NNS 42759 1993 6 have have VBP 42759 1993 7 in in IN 42759 1993 8 mind mind NN 42759 1993 9 when when WRB 42759 1993 10 they -PRON- PRP 42759 1993 11 speak speak VBP 42759 1993 12 of of IN 42759 1993 13 the the DT 42759 1993 14 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 1993 15 rate rate NN 42759 1993 16 of of IN 42759 1993 17 interest interest NN 42759 1993 18 . . . 42759 1994 1 The the DT 42759 1994 2 prevailing prevailing JJ 42759 1994 3 or or CC 42759 1994 4 standard standard JJ 42759 1994 5 rate rate NN 42759 1994 6 in in IN 42759 1994 7 any any DT 42759 1994 8 community community NN 42759 1994 9 can can MD 42759 1994 10 usually usually RB 42759 1994 11 be be VB 42759 1994 12 stated state VBN 42759 1994 13 with with IN 42759 1994 14 a a DT 42759 1994 15 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 1994 16 approach approach NN 42759 1994 17 to to IN 42759 1994 18 precision precision NN 42759 1994 19 to to TO 42759 1994 20 be be VB 42759 1994 21 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 1994 22 for for IN 42759 1994 23 all all DT 42759 1994 24 practical practical JJ 42759 1994 25 purposes purpose NNS 42759 1994 26 . . . 42759 1995 1 In in IN 42759 1995 2 all all PDT 42759 1995 3 the the DT 42759 1995 4 Eastern Eastern NNP 42759 1995 5 States States NNPS 42759 1995 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1995 7 is be VBZ 42759 1995 8 now now RB 42759 1995 9 about about RB 42759 1995 10 five five CD 42759 1995 11 per per NN 42759 1995 12 cent cent NN 42759 1995 13 . . . 42759 1996 1 ; ; : 42759 1996 2 in in IN 42759 1996 3 the the DT 42759 1996 4 Middle Middle NNP 42759 1996 5 West West NNP 42759 1996 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1996 7 is be VBZ 42759 1996 8 somewhere somewhere RB 42759 1996 9 between between IN 42759 1996 10 five five CD 42759 1996 11 and and CC 42759 1996 12 six six CD 42759 1996 13 per per IN 42759 1996 14 cent cent NN 42759 1996 15 . . . 42759 1997 1 ; ; : 42759 1997 2 on on IN 42759 1997 3 the the DT 42759 1997 4 Pacific Pacific NNP 42759 1997 5 coast coast NN 42759 1997 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 1997 7 is be VBZ 42759 1997 8 between between IN 42759 1997 9 six six CD 42759 1997 10 and and CC 42759 1997 11 seven seven CD 42759 1997 12 per per IN 42759 1997 13 cent cent NN 42759 1997 14 . . . 42759 1998 1 The the DT 42759 1998 2 supreme supreme JJ 42759 1998 3 court court NN 42759 1998 4 of of IN 42759 1998 5 Minnesota Minnesota NNP 42759 1998 6 decided decide VBD 42759 1998 7 in in IN 42759 1998 8 1896 1896 CD 42759 1998 9 that that IN 42759 1998 10 , , , 42759 1998 11 in in IN 42759 1998 12 view view NN 42759 1998 13 of of IN 42759 1998 14 the the DT 42759 1998 15 actual actual JJ 42759 1998 16 rates rate NNS 42759 1998 17 of of IN 42759 1998 18 interest interest NN 42759 1998 19 then then RB 42759 1998 20 obtaining obtain VBG 42759 1998 21 , , , 42759 1998 22 five five CD 42759 1998 23 per per NN 42759 1998 24 cent cent NN 42759 1998 25 . . . 42759 1999 1 on on IN 42759 1999 2 the the DT 42759 1999 3 reproduction reproduction NN 42759 1999 4 cost cost NN 42759 1999 5 of of IN 42759 1999 6 railroads railroad NNS 42759 1999 7 was be VBD 42759 1999 8 a a DT 42759 1999 9 fairly fairly RB 42759 1999 10 liberal liberal JJ 42759 1999 11 return return NN 42759 1999 12 , , , 42759 1999 13 and and CC 42759 1999 14 could could MD 42759 1999 15 be be VB 42759 1999 16 adopted adopt VBN 42759 1999 17 by by IN 42759 1999 18 the the DT 42759 1999 19 state state NN 42759 1999 20 authorities authority NNS 42759 1999 21 in in IN 42759 1999 22 fixing fix VBG 42759 1999 23 charges charge NNS 42759 1999 24 for for IN 42759 1999 25 carrying carry VBG 42759 1999 26 freight freight NN 42759 1999 27 and and CC 42759 1999 28 passengers passenger NNS 42759 1999 29 . . . 42759 2000 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2000 2 111 111 CD 42759 2000 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2000 4 A a DT 42759 2000 5 few few JJ 42759 2000 6 years year NNS 42759 2000 7 later later RBR 42759 2000 8 the the DT 42759 2000 9 Michigan Michigan NNP 42759 2000 10 tax tax NN 42759 2000 11 commission commission NN 42759 2000 12 allowed allow VBD 42759 2000 13 the the DT 42759 2000 14 railroads railroad NNS 42759 2000 15 four four CD 42759 2000 16 per per IN 42759 2000 17 cent cent NN 42759 2000 18 . . . 42759 2001 1 on on IN 42759 2001 2 the the DT 42759 2001 3 reproduction reproduction NN 42759 2001 4 cost cost NN 42759 2001 5 of of IN 42759 2001 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2001 7 property property NN 42759 2001 8 , , , 42759 2001 9 on on IN 42759 2001 10 the the DT 42759 2001 11 ground ground NN 42759 2001 12 that that IN 42759 2001 13 investments investment NNS 42759 2001 14 which which WDT 42759 2001 15 yielded yield VBD 42759 2001 16 that that DT 42759 2001 17 rate rate NN 42759 2001 18 in in IN 42759 2001 19 addition addition NN 42759 2001 20 to to IN 42759 2001 21 the the DT 42759 2001 22 usual usual JJ 42759 2001 23 tax tax NN 42759 2001 24 of of IN 42759 2001 25 one one CD 42759 2001 26 per per IN 42759 2001 27 cent cent NN 42759 2001 28 . . . 42759 2002 1 ( ( -LRB- 42759 2002 2 or or CC 42759 2002 3 five five CD 42759 2002 4 per per IN 42759 2002 5 cent cent NN 42759 2002 6 . . . 42759 2003 1 before before IN 42759 2003 2 the the DT 42759 2003 3 deduction deduction NN 42759 2003 4 of of IN 42759 2003 5 the the DT 42759 2003 6 tax tax NN 42759 2003 7 ) ) -RRB- 42759 2003 8 stood stand VBD 42759 2003 9 at at IN 42759 2003 10 par par NN 42759 2003 11 on on IN 42759 2003 12 the the DT 42759 2003 13 stock stock NN 42759 2003 14 market market NN 42759 2003 15 . . . 42759 2004 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2004 2 112 112 CD 42759 2004 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2004 4 In in IN 42759 2004 5 other other JJ 42759 2004 6 words word NNS 42759 2004 7 , , , 42759 2004 8 the the DT 42759 2004 9 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 2004 10 rate rate NN 42759 2004 11 was be VBD 42759 2004 12 five five CD 42759 2004 13 per per IN 42759 2004 14 cent cent NN 42759 2004 15 . . . 42759 2005 1 At at IN 42759 2005 2 the the DT 42759 2005 3 beginning beginning NN 42759 2005 4 of of IN 42759 2005 5 the the DT 42759 2005 6 year year NN 42759 2005 7 1907 1907 CD 42759 2005 8 , , , 42759 2005 9 the the DT 42759 2005 10 railroad railroad NN 42759 2005 11 commission commission NN 42759 2005 12 of of IN 42759 2005 13 Wisconsin Wisconsin NNP 42759 2005 14 fixed fix VBD 42759 2005 15 six six CD 42759 2005 16 per per IN 42759 2005 17 cent cent NN 42759 2005 18 . . . 42759 2006 1 as as IN 42759 2006 2 the the DT 42759 2006 3 return return NN 42759 2006 4 to to IN 42759 2006 5 which which WDT 42759 2006 6 the the DT 42759 2006 7 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 2006 8 of of IN 42759 2006 9 railroads railroad NNS 42759 2006 10 were be VBD 42759 2006 11 entitled entitle VBN 42759 2006 12 , , , 42759 2006 13 because because IN 42759 2006 14 this this DT 42759 2006 15 was be VBD 42759 2006 16 about about IN 42759 2006 17 the the DT 42759 2006 18 return return NN 42759 2006 19 which which WDT 42759 2006 20 investors investor NNS 42759 2006 21 generally generally RB 42759 2006 22 were be VBD 42759 2006 23 able able JJ 42759 2006 24 to to TO 42759 2006 25 get get VB 42759 2006 26 on on IN 42759 2006 27 that that DT 42759 2006 28 kind kind NN 42759 2006 29 of of IN 42759 2006 30 security security NN 42759 2006 31 . . . 42759 2007 1 In in IN 42759 2007 2 the the DT 42759 2007 3 view view NN 42759 2007 4 of of IN 42759 2007 5 the the DT 42759 2007 6 Commission Commission NNP 42759 2007 7 , , , 42759 2007 8 the the DT 42759 2007 9 current current JJ 42759 2007 10 rate rate NN 42759 2007 11 of of IN 42759 2007 12 interest interest NN 42759 2007 13 on on IN 42759 2007 14 railroad railroad NN 42759 2007 15 _ _ NNP 42759 2007 16 bonds bond NNS 42759 2007 17 _ _ NNP 42759 2007 18 , , , 42759 2007 19 and and CC 42759 2007 20 similar similar JJ 42759 2007 21 investments investment NNS 42759 2007 22 , , , 42759 2007 23 was be VBD 42759 2007 24 about about RB 42759 2007 25 five five CD 42759 2007 26 per per NN 42759 2007 27 cent cent NN 42759 2007 28 . . . 42759 2008 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2008 2 113 113 CD 42759 2008 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2008 4 The the DT 42759 2008 5 significance significance NN 42759 2008 6 of of IN 42759 2008 7 these these DT 42759 2008 8 decisions decision NNS 42759 2008 9 by by IN 42759 2008 10 the the DT 42759 2008 11 public public JJ 42759 2008 12 authorities authority NNS 42759 2008 13 of of IN 42759 2008 14 three three CD 42759 2008 15 states state NNS 42759 2008 16 is be VBZ 42759 2008 17 found find VBN 42759 2008 18 not not RB 42759 2008 19 so so RB 42759 2008 20 much much JJ 42759 2008 21 in in IN 42759 2008 22 the the DT 42759 2008 23 particular particular JJ 42759 2008 24 rates rate NNS 42759 2008 25 which which WDT 42759 2008 26 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2008 27 sanctioned sanction VBD 42759 2008 28 as as IN 42759 2008 29 in in IN 42759 2008 30 the the DT 42759 2008 31 fact fact NN 42759 2008 32 that that IN 42759 2008 33 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2008 34 were be VBD 42759 2008 35 able able JJ 42759 2008 36 to to TO 42759 2008 37 determine determine VB 42759 2008 38 a a DT 42759 2008 39 standard standard JJ 42759 2008 40 or or CC 42759 2008 41 prevailing prevailing NN 42759 2008 42 rate rate NN 42759 2008 43 . . . 42759 2009 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 2009 2 a a DT 42759 2009 3 standard standard JJ 42759 2009 4 rate rate NN 42759 2009 5 exists exist VBZ 42759 2009 6 . . . 42759 2010 1 At at IN 42759 2010 2 the the DT 42759 2010 3 same same JJ 42759 2010 4 time time NN 42759 2010 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2010 6 is be VBZ 42759 2010 7 interesting interesting JJ 42759 2010 8 to to TO 42759 2010 9 note note VB 42759 2010 10 that that IN 42759 2010 11 in in IN 42759 2010 12 all all DT 42759 2010 13 three three CD 42759 2010 14 states state NNS 42759 2010 15 the the DT 42759 2010 16 rate rate NN 42759 2010 17 of of IN 42759 2010 18 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2010 19 interest interest NN 42759 2010 20 was be VBD 42759 2010 21 declared declare VBN 42759 2010 22 to to TO 42759 2010 23 be be VB 42759 2010 24 about about IN 42759 2010 25 the the DT 42759 2010 26 same same JJ 42759 2010 27 , , , 42759 2010 28 that that RB 42759 2010 29 is is RB 42759 2010 30 , , , 42759 2010 31 five five CD 42759 2010 32 per per NN 42759 2010 33 cent cent NN 42759 2010 34 . . . 42759 2011 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 42759 2011 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2011 3 is be VBZ 42759 2011 4 safe safe JJ 42759 2011 5 to to TO 42759 2011 6 say say VB 42759 2011 7 that that IN 42759 2011 8 , , , 42759 2011 9 throughout throughout IN 42759 2011 10 the the DT 42759 2011 11 greater great JJR 42759 2011 12 part part NN 42759 2011 13 of of IN 42759 2011 14 the the DT 42759 2011 15 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2011 16 field field NN 42759 2011 17 of of IN 42759 2011 18 America America NNP 42759 2011 19 , , , 42759 2011 20 five five CD 42759 2011 21 or or CC 42759 2011 22 six six CD 42759 2011 23 per per IN 42759 2011 24 cent cent NN 42759 2011 25 . . . 42759 2012 1 is be VBZ 42759 2012 2 the the DT 42759 2012 3 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 2012 4 rate rate NN 42759 2012 5 of of IN 42759 2012 6 interest interest NN 42759 2012 7 . . . 42759 2013 1 What what WP 42759 2013 2 causes cause VBZ 42759 2013 3 the the DT 42759 2013 4 rate rate NN 42759 2013 5 to to TO 42759 2013 6 be be VB 42759 2013 7 five five CD 42759 2013 8 per per IN 42759 2013 9 cent cent NN 42759 2013 10 . . . 42759 2013 11 , , , 42759 2013 12 or or CC 42759 2013 13 six six CD 42759 2013 14 per per IN 42759 2013 15 cent cent NN 42759 2013 16 . . . 42759 2013 17 , , , 42759 2013 18 or or CC 42759 2013 19 any any DT 42759 2013 20 other other JJ 42759 2013 21 per per IN 42759 2013 22 cent cent NN 42759 2013 23 . . . 42759 2013 24 ? ? . 42759 2014 1 Briefly briefly RB 42759 2014 2 stated state VBD 42759 2014 3 , , , 42759 2014 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2014 5 is be VBZ 42759 2014 6 the the DT 42759 2014 7 interplay interplay NN 42759 2014 8 of of IN 42759 2014 9 supply supply NN 42759 2014 10 and and CC 42759 2014 11 demand demand NN 42759 2014 12 . . . 42759 2015 1 Since since IN 42759 2015 2 interest interest NN 42759 2015 3 is be VBZ 42759 2015 4 a a DT 42759 2015 5 price price NN 42759 2015 6 paid pay VBN 42759 2015 7 for for IN 42759 2015 8 the the DT 42759 2015 9 use use NN 42759 2015 10 of of IN 42759 2015 11 a a DT 42759 2015 12 thing thing NN 42759 2015 13 , , , 42759 2015 14 i.e. i.e. FW 42759 2015 15 , , , 42759 2015 16 capital capital NN 42759 2015 17 , , , 42759 2015 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2015 19 rate rate NN 42759 2015 20 or or CC 42759 2015 21 level level NN 42759 2015 22 is be VBZ 42759 2015 23 determined determine VBN 42759 2015 24 by by IN 42759 2015 25 the the DT 42759 2015 26 same same JJ 42759 2015 27 general general JJ 42759 2015 28 forces force NNS 42759 2015 29 that that WDT 42759 2015 30 govern govern VBP 42759 2015 31 the the DT 42759 2015 32 price price NN 42759 2015 33 of of IN 42759 2015 34 wheat wheat NN 42759 2015 35 , , , 42759 2015 36 or or CC 42759 2015 37 shoes shoe NNS 42759 2015 38 , , , 42759 2015 39 or or CC 42759 2015 40 hats hat NNS 42759 2015 41 , , , 42759 2015 42 or or CC 42759 2015 43 any any DT 42759 2015 44 other other JJ 42759 2015 45 commodity commodity NN 42759 2015 46 that that WDT 42759 2015 47 is be VBZ 42759 2015 48 bought buy VBN 42759 2015 49 and and CC 42759 2015 50 sold sell VBN 42759 2015 51 in in IN 42759 2015 52 the the DT 42759 2015 53 market market NN 42759 2015 54 . . . 42759 2016 1 The the DT 42759 2016 2 rate rate NN 42759 2016 3 is be VBZ 42759 2016 4 five five CD 42759 2016 5 or or CC 42759 2016 6 six six CD 42759 2016 7 per per IN 42759 2016 8 cent cent NN 42759 2016 9 . . . 42759 2017 1 because because IN 42759 2017 2 at at IN 42759 2017 3 that that DT 42759 2017 4 rate rate NN 42759 2017 5 the the DT 42759 2017 6 amount amount NN 42759 2017 7 of of IN 42759 2017 8 money money NN 42759 2017 9 offered offer VBN 42759 2017 10 by by IN 42759 2017 11 lenders lender NNS 42759 2017 12 equals equal VBZ 42759 2017 13 the the DT 42759 2017 14 amount amount NN 42759 2017 15 demanded demand VBN 42759 2017 16 by by IN 42759 2017 17 borrowers borrower NNS 42759 2017 18 . . . 42759 2018 1 Should Should MD 42759 2018 2 the the DT 42759 2018 3 amount amount NN 42759 2018 4 offered offer VBN 42759 2018 5 at at IN 42759 2018 6 that that DT 42759 2018 7 rate rate NN 42759 2018 8 increase increase NN 42759 2018 9 without without IN 42759 2018 10 a a DT 42759 2018 11 corresponding corresponding JJ 42759 2018 12 increase increase NN 42759 2018 13 in in IN 42759 2018 14 the the DT 42759 2018 15 amount amount NN 42759 2018 16 demanded demand VBN 42759 2018 17 , , , 42759 2018 18 the the DT 42759 2018 19 rate rate NN 42759 2018 20 would would MD 42759 2018 21 fall fall VB 42759 2018 22 , , , 42759 2018 23 just just RB 42759 2018 24 as as IN 42759 2018 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2018 26 would would MD 42759 2018 27 rise rise VB 42759 2018 28 under under IN 42759 2018 29 opposite opposite JJ 42759 2018 30 conditions condition NNS 42759 2018 31 . . . 42759 2019 1 Supply supply NN 42759 2019 2 and and CC 42759 2019 3 demand demand NN 42759 2019 4 , , , 42759 2019 5 however however RB 42759 2019 6 , , , 42759 2019 7 are be VBP 42759 2019 8 merely merely RB 42759 2019 9 the the DT 42759 2019 10 immediate immediate JJ 42759 2019 11 forces force NNS 42759 2019 12 . . . 42759 2020 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2020 2 are be VBP 42759 2020 3 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 2020 4 the the DT 42759 2020 5 outcome outcome NN 42759 2020 6 or or CC 42759 2020 7 resultant resultant JJ 42759 2020 8 of of IN 42759 2020 9 factors factor NNS 42759 2020 10 more more RBR 42759 2020 11 remote remote JJ 42759 2020 12 . . . 42759 2021 1 On on IN 42759 2021 2 the the DT 42759 2021 3 side side NN 42759 2021 4 of of IN 42759 2021 5 supply supply NN 42759 2021 6 , , , 42759 2021 7 the the DT 42759 2021 8 principal principal JJ 42759 2021 9 remote remote JJ 42759 2021 10 forces force NNS 42759 2021 11 which which WDT 42759 2021 12 regulate regulate VBP 42759 2021 13 the the DT 42759 2021 14 rate rate NN 42759 2021 15 of of IN 42759 2021 16 interest interest NN 42759 2021 17 are be VBP 42759 2021 18 : : : 42759 2021 19 the the DT 42759 2021 20 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2021 21 resources resource NNS 42759 2021 22 of of IN 42759 2021 23 the the DT 42759 2021 24 community community NN 42759 2021 25 , , , 42759 2021 26 and and CC 42759 2021 27 the the DT 42759 2021 28 relative relative JJ 42759 2021 29 strength strength NN 42759 2021 30 of of IN 42759 2021 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2021 32 habits habit NNS 42759 2021 33 of of IN 42759 2021 34 saving saving NN 42759 2021 35 and and CC 42759 2021 36 spending spending NN 42759 2021 37 . . . 42759 2022 1 On on IN 42759 2022 2 the the DT 42759 2022 3 side side NN 42759 2022 4 of of IN 42759 2022 5 demand demand NN 42759 2022 6 , , , 42759 2022 7 the the DT 42759 2022 8 chief chief JJ 42759 2022 9 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 2022 10 factors factor NNS 42759 2022 11 are be VBP 42759 2022 12 : : : 42759 2022 13 the the DT 42759 2022 14 productivity productivity NN 42759 2022 15 of of IN 42759 2022 16 capital capital NN 42759 2022 17 - - HYPH 42759 2022 18 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2022 19 , , , 42759 2022 20 the the DT 42759 2022 21 comparative comparative JJ 42759 2022 22 intensity intensity NN 42759 2022 23 of of IN 42759 2022 24 the the DT 42759 2022 25 social social JJ 42759 2022 26 desires desire NNS 42759 2022 27 of of IN 42759 2022 28 investing investing NN 42759 2022 29 and and CC 42759 2022 30 lending lending NN 42759 2022 31 , , , 42759 2022 32 and and CC 42759 2022 33 the the DT 42759 2022 34 supplies supply NNS 42759 2022 35 of of IN 42759 2022 36 land land NN 42759 2022 37 , , , 42759 2022 38 business business NN 42759 2022 39 ability ability NN 42759 2022 40 and and CC 42759 2022 41 labour labour NN 42759 2022 42 . . . 42759 2023 1 Each each DT 42759 2023 2 of of IN 42759 2023 3 these these DT 42759 2023 4 factors factor NNS 42759 2023 5 exercises exercise VBZ 42759 2023 6 upon upon IN 42759 2023 7 the the DT 42759 2023 8 rate rate NN 42759 2023 9 of of IN 42759 2023 10 interest interest NN 42759 2023 11 an an DT 42759 2023 12 influence influence NN 42759 2023 13 of of IN 42759 2023 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2023 15 own own JJ 42759 2023 16 , , , 42759 2023 17 and and CC 42759 2023 18 each each DT 42759 2023 19 of of IN 42759 2023 20 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2023 21 may may MD 42759 2023 22 be be VB 42759 2023 23 assisted assist VBN 42759 2023 24 or or CC 42759 2023 25 counteracted counteract VBN 42759 2023 26 by by IN 42759 2023 27 one one CD 42759 2023 28 or or CC 42759 2023 29 more more JJR 42759 2023 30 of of IN 42759 2023 31 the the DT 42759 2023 32 others other NNS 42759 2023 33 . . . 42759 2024 1 Precisely precisely RB 42759 2024 2 what what WDT 42759 2024 3 rate rate NN 42759 2024 4 will will MD 42759 2024 5 result result VB 42759 2024 6 from from IN 42759 2024 7 any any DT 42759 2024 8 given give VBN 42759 2024 9 condition condition NN 42759 2024 10 of of IN 42759 2024 11 the the DT 42759 2024 12 factors factor NNS 42759 2024 13 , , , 42759 2024 14 can can MD 42759 2024 15 not not RB 42759 2024 16 be be VB 42759 2024 17 stated state VBN 42759 2024 18 beforehand beforehand RB 42759 2024 19 , , , 42759 2024 20 for for IN 42759 2024 21 the the DT 42759 2024 22 factors factor NNS 42759 2024 23 can can MD 42759 2024 24 not not RB 42759 2024 25 be be VB 42759 2024 26 measured measure VBN 42759 2024 27 in in IN 42759 2024 28 such such PDT 42759 2024 29 a a DT 42759 2024 30 way way NN 42759 2024 31 as as IN 42759 2024 32 to to TO 42759 2024 33 provide provide VB 42759 2024 34 a a DT 42759 2024 35 basis basis NN 42759 2024 36 for for IN 42759 2024 37 this this DT 42759 2024 38 kind kind NN 42759 2024 39 of of IN 42759 2024 40 forecast forecast NN 42759 2024 41 . . . 42759 2025 1 All all DT 42759 2025 2 that that WDT 42759 2025 3 can can MD 42759 2025 4 be be VB 42759 2025 5 said say VBN 42759 2025 6 is be VBZ 42759 2025 7 that that DT 42759 2025 8 , , , 42759 2025 9 when when WRB 42759 2025 10 changes change NNS 42759 2025 11 occur occur VBP 42759 2025 12 on on IN 42759 2025 13 the the DT 42759 2025 14 side side NN 42759 2025 15 of of IN 42759 2025 16 either either DT 42759 2025 17 demand demand NN 42759 2025 18 or or CC 42759 2025 19 supply supply NN 42759 2025 20 , , , 42759 2025 21 there there EX 42759 2025 22 will will MD 42759 2025 23 be be VB 42759 2025 24 a a DT 42759 2025 25 corresponding corresponding JJ 42759 2025 26 change change NN 42759 2025 27 in in IN 42759 2025 28 the the DT 42759 2025 29 rate rate NN 42759 2025 30 of of IN 42759 2025 31 interest interest NN 42759 2025 32 , , , 42759 2025 33 provided provide VBN 42759 2025 34 that that IN 42759 2025 35 no no DT 42759 2025 36 neutralising neutralise VBG 42759 2025 37 change change NN 42759 2025 38 takes take VBZ 42759 2025 39 place place NN 42759 2025 40 on on IN 42759 2025 41 the the DT 42759 2025 42 other other JJ 42759 2025 43 side side NN 42759 2025 44 . . . 42759 2026 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 2026 2 : : : 42759 2026 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2026 4 111 111 CD 42759 2026 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2026 6 " " `` 42759 2026 7 Final Final NNP 42759 2026 8 Report Report NNP 42759 2026 9 of of IN 42759 2026 10 the the DT 42759 2026 11 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 2026 12 Commission Commission NNP 42759 2026 13 , , , 42759 2026 14 " " '' 42759 2026 15 pp pp NNP 42759 2026 16 . . . 42759 2027 1 410 410 CD 42759 2027 2 , , , 42759 2027 3 411 411 CD 42759 2027 4 . . . 42759 2028 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2028 2 112 112 CD 42759 2028 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2028 4 " " `` 42759 2028 5 Report Report NNP 42759 2028 6 of of IN 42759 2028 7 the the DT 42759 2028 8 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 2028 9 Commission Commission NNP 42759 2028 10 , , , 42759 2028 11 " " '' 42759 2028 12 vol vol NNP 42759 2028 13 . . . 42759 2029 1 IX ix NN 42759 2029 2 , , , 42759 2029 3 p. p. NN 42759 2029 4 380 380 CD 42759 2029 5 . . . 42759 2030 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2030 2 113 113 CD 42759 2030 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2030 4 " " `` 42759 2030 5 Publication publication NN 42759 2030 6 No no NN 42759 2030 7 . . . 42759 2031 1 32 32 CD 42759 2031 2 of of IN 42759 2031 3 the the DT 42759 2031 4 Railroad Railroad NNP 42759 2031 5 Commission Commission NNP 42759 2031 6 of of IN 42759 2031 7 Wisconsin Wisconsin NNP 42759 2031 8 , , , 42759 2031 9 " " '' 42759 2031 10 pp pp NNP 42759 2031 11 . . . 42759 2032 1 165 165 CD 42759 2032 2 , , , 42759 2032 3 166 166 CD 42759 2032 4 . . . 42759 2033 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 2033 2 X X NNP 42759 2033 3 THE the DT 42759 2033 4 ALLEGED alleged JJ 42759 2033 5 RIGHT right NN 42759 2033 6 OF of IN 42759 2033 7 LABOUR labour NN 42759 2033 8 TO to IN 42759 2033 9 THE the DT 42759 2033 10 ENTIRE ENTIRE NNP 42759 2033 11 PRODUCT product NN 42759 2033 12 OF of IN 42759 2033 13 INDUSTRY industry NN 42759 2033 14 In in IN 42759 2033 15 a a DT 42759 2033 16 preceding precede VBG 42759 2033 17 chapter chapter NN 42759 2033 18 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2033 19 saw see VBD 42759 2033 20 that that IN 42759 2033 21 Marxian Marxian NNP 42759 2033 22 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 2033 23 is be VBZ 42759 2033 24 logically logically RB 42759 2033 25 debarred debar VBN 42759 2033 26 from from IN 42759 2033 27 passing pass VBG 42759 2033 28 _ _ NNP 42759 2033 29 moral moral JJ 42759 2033 30 _ _ NNP 42759 2033 31 judgment judgment NN 42759 2033 32 upon upon IN 42759 2033 33 any any DT 42759 2033 34 social social JJ 42759 2033 35 institution institution NN 42759 2033 36 or or CC 42759 2033 37 practice practice NN 42759 2033 38 . . . 42759 2034 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2034 2 114 114 CD 42759 2034 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2034 4 If if IN 42759 2034 5 social social JJ 42759 2034 6 institutions institution NNS 42759 2034 7 are be VBP 42759 2034 8 produced produce VBN 42759 2034 9 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 2034 10 by by IN 42759 2034 11 socio socio JJ 42759 2034 12 - - HYPH 42759 2034 13 economic economic JJ 42759 2034 14 forces force NNS 42759 2034 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2034 16 are be VBP 42759 2034 17 neither neither RB 42759 2034 18 morally morally RB 42759 2034 19 good good JJ 42759 2034 20 nor nor CC 42759 2034 21 morally morally RB 42759 2034 22 bad bad JJ 42759 2034 23 . . . 42759 2035 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2035 2 are be VBP 42759 2035 3 quite quite RB 42759 2035 4 as as RB 42759 2035 5 unmoral unmoral JJ 42759 2035 6 as as IN 42759 2035 7 rain rain NN 42759 2035 8 and and CC 42759 2035 9 snow snow NN 42759 2035 10 , , , 42759 2035 11 verdure verdure NN 42759 2035 12 and and CC 42759 2035 13 decay decay JJ 42759 2035 14 , , , 42759 2035 15 tadpoles tadpole NNS 42759 2035 16 and and CC 42759 2035 17 elephants elephant NNS 42759 2035 18 . . . 42759 2036 1 Consistent consistent JJ 42759 2036 2 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2036 3 can can MD 42759 2036 4 not not RB 42759 2036 5 , , , 42759 2036 6 therefore therefore RB 42759 2036 7 , , , 42759 2036 8 censure censure NN 42759 2036 9 on on IN 42759 2036 10 purely purely RB 42759 2036 11 ethical ethical JJ 42759 2036 12 grounds ground NNS 42759 2036 13 the the DT 42759 2036 14 system system NN 42759 2036 15 of of IN 42759 2036 16 private private JJ 42759 2036 17 capital capital NN 42759 2036 18 and and CC 42759 2036 19 interest interest NN 42759 2036 20 . . . 42759 2037 1 This this DT 42759 2037 2 logical logical JJ 42759 2037 3 requirement requirement NN 42759 2037 4 of of IN 42759 2037 5 the the DT 42759 2037 6 theory theory NN 42759 2037 7 of of IN 42759 2037 8 economic economic JJ 42759 2037 9 determinism determinism NN 42759 2037 10 is be VBZ 42759 2037 11 exemplified exemplify VBN 42759 2037 12 in in IN 42759 2037 13 much much JJ 42759 2037 14 of of IN 42759 2037 15 the the DT 42759 2037 16 rigidly rigidly RB 42759 2037 17 scientific scientific JJ 42759 2037 18 discussions discussion NNS 42759 2037 19 of of IN 42759 2037 20 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2037 21 . . . 42759 2038 1 Marx Marx NNP 42759 2038 2 maintained maintain VBD 42759 2038 3 that that IN 42759 2038 4 the the DT 42759 2038 5 value value NN 42759 2038 6 of of IN 42759 2038 7 commodities commodity NNS 42759 2038 8 is be VBZ 42759 2038 9 all all DT 42759 2038 10 determined determined JJ 42759 2038 11 and and CC 42759 2038 12 created create VBN 42759 2038 13 by by IN 42759 2038 14 labour labour NN 42759 2038 15 , , , 42759 2038 16 and and CC 42759 2038 17 that that DT 42759 2038 18 interest interest NN 42759 2038 19 is be VBZ 42759 2038 20 the the DT 42759 2038 21 surplus surplus NN 42759 2038 22 which which WDT 42759 2038 23 the the DT 42759 2038 24 labourer labourer NN 42759 2038 25 produces produce VBZ 42759 2038 26 above above IN 42759 2038 27 the the DT 42759 2038 28 cost cost NN 42759 2038 29 of of IN 42759 2038 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2038 31 keep keep NN 42759 2038 32 ; ; : 42759 2038 33 nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2038 34 Marx Marx NNP 42759 2038 35 did do VBD 42759 2038 36 not not RB 42759 2038 37 formally formally RB 42759 2038 38 assert assert VB 42759 2038 39 that that IN 42759 2038 40 the the DT 42759 2038 41 labourer labourer NN 42759 2038 42 has have VBZ 42759 2038 43 a a DT 42759 2038 44 moral moral JJ 42759 2038 45 right right NN 42759 2038 46 to to IN 42759 2038 47 the the DT 42759 2038 48 whole whole JJ 42759 2038 49 product product NN 42759 2038 50 , , , 42759 2038 51 nor nor CC 42759 2038 52 that that DT 42759 2038 53 interest interest NN 42759 2038 54 is be VBZ 42759 2038 55 theft theft NN 42759 2038 56 . . . 42759 2039 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2039 2 set set VBD 42759 2039 3 forth forth RP 42759 2039 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2039 5 theories theory NNS 42759 2039 6 of of IN 42759 2039 7 value value NN 42759 2039 8 and and CC 42759 2039 9 surplus surplus NN 42759 2039 10 value value NN 42759 2039 11 as as IN 42759 2039 12 positive positive JJ 42759 2039 13 explanations explanation NNS 42759 2039 14 of of IN 42759 2039 15 economic economic JJ 42759 2039 16 facts fact NNS 42759 2039 17 , , , 42759 2039 18 not not RB 42759 2039 19 as as IN 42759 2039 20 an an DT 42759 2039 21 ethical ethical JJ 42759 2039 22 evaluation evaluation NN 42759 2039 23 of of IN 42759 2039 24 human human JJ 42759 2039 25 actions action NNS 42759 2039 26 . . . 42759 2040 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2040 2 object object NN 42759 2040 3 was be VBD 42759 2040 4 to to TO 42759 2040 5 show show VB 42759 2040 6 the the DT 42759 2040 7 causes cause NNS 42759 2040 8 and and CC 42759 2040 9 nature nature NN 42759 2040 10 of of IN 42759 2040 11 value value NN 42759 2040 12 , , , 42759 2040 13 wages wage NNS 42759 2040 14 , , , 42759 2040 15 and and CC 42759 2040 16 interest interest NN 42759 2040 17 , , , 42759 2040 18 not not RB 42759 2040 19 to to TO 42759 2040 20 estimate estimate VB 42759 2040 21 the the DT 42759 2040 22 moral moral JJ 42759 2040 23 claims claim NNS 42759 2040 24 of of IN 42759 2040 25 the the DT 42759 2040 26 agents agent NNS 42759 2040 27 of of IN 42759 2040 28 production production NN 42759 2040 29 , , , 42759 2040 30 or or CC 42759 2040 31 the the DT 42759 2040 32 morality morality NN 42759 2040 33 of of IN 42759 2040 34 the the DT 42759 2040 35 distributive distributive JJ 42759 2040 36 process process NN 42759 2040 37 . . . 42759 2041 1 In in IN 42759 2041 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2041 3 formal formal JJ 42759 2041 4 discussion discussion NN 42759 2041 5 of of IN 42759 2041 6 the the DT 42759 2041 7 theory theory NN 42759 2041 8 of of IN 42759 2041 9 value value NN 42759 2041 10 and and CC 42759 2041 11 of of IN 42759 2041 12 surplus surplus NN 42759 2041 13 value value NN 42759 2041 14 , , , 42759 2041 15 Marx Marx NNP 42759 2041 16 said say VBD 42759 2041 17 nothing nothing NN 42759 2041 18 that that IN 42759 2041 19 implied imply VBD 42759 2041 20 a a DT 42759 2041 21 belief belief NN 42759 2041 22 in in IN 42759 2041 23 genuine genuine JJ 42759 2041 24 moral moral JJ 42759 2041 25 responsibility responsibility NN 42759 2041 26 , , , 42759 2041 27 or or CC 42759 2041 28 that that IN 42759 2041 29 contradicted contradict VBD 42759 2041 30 the the DT 42759 2041 31 principles principle NNS 42759 2041 32 of of IN 42759 2041 33 philosophical philosophical JJ 42759 2041 34 materialism materialism NN 42759 2041 35 and and CC 42759 2041 36 economic economic JJ 42759 2041 37 determinism determinism NN 42759 2041 38 . . . 42759 2042 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2042 2 is be VBZ 42759 2042 3 , , , 42759 2042 4 therefore therefore RB 42759 2042 5 , , , 42759 2042 6 quite quite RB 42759 2042 7 erroneous erroneous JJ 42759 2042 8 to to TO 42759 2042 9 infer infer VB 42759 2042 10 that that IN 42759 2042 11 , , , 42759 2042 12 since since IN 42759 2042 13 the the DT 42759 2042 14 Marxian marxian JJ 42759 2042 15 theory theory NN 42759 2042 16 attributes attribute VBZ 42759 2042 17 all all DT 42759 2042 18 value value NN 42759 2042 19 and and CC 42759 2042 20 products product NNS 42759 2042 21 to to IN 42759 2042 22 the the DT 42759 2042 23 action action NN 42759 2042 24 of of IN 42759 2042 25 labour labour NN 42759 2042 26 , , , 42759 2042 27 Marxian Marxian NNP 42759 2042 28 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2042 29 must must MD 42759 2042 30 condemn condemn VB 42759 2042 31 the the DT 42759 2042 32 interest interest NN 42759 2042 33 - - HYPH 42759 2042 34 taker taker NN 42759 2042 35 as as IN 42759 2042 36 a a DT 42759 2042 37 robber robber NN 42759 2042 38 . . . 42759 2043 1 Neither neither DT 42759 2043 2 Marx Marx NNP 42759 2043 3 nor nor CC 42759 2043 4 any any DT 42759 2043 5 other other JJ 42759 2043 6 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 2043 7 authority authority NN 42759 2043 8 , , , 42759 2043 9 however however RB 42759 2043 10 , , , 42759 2043 11 has have VBZ 42759 2043 12 always always RB 42759 2043 13 held hold VBN 42759 2043 14 consistently consistently RB 42759 2043 15 to to IN 42759 2043 16 this this DT 42759 2043 17 purely purely RB 42759 2043 18 positive positive JJ 42759 2043 19 method method NN 42759 2043 20 of of IN 42759 2043 21 economic economic JJ 42759 2043 22 exposition exposition NN 42759 2043 23 . . . 42759 2044 1 When when WRB 42759 2044 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2044 3 declare declare VBP 42759 2044 4 that that IN 42759 2044 5 the the DT 42759 2044 6 labourer labourer NN 42759 2044 7 is be VBZ 42759 2044 8 " " `` 42759 2044 9 exploited exploit VBN 42759 2044 10 , , , 42759 2044 11 " " '' 42759 2044 12 that that IN 42759 2044 13 surplus surplus JJ 42759 2044 14 value value NN 42759 2044 15 is be VBZ 42759 2044 16 " " `` 42759 2044 17 filched filch VBN 42759 2044 18 " " '' 42759 2044 19 from from IN 42759 2044 20 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2044 21 , , , 42759 2044 22 that that IN 42759 2044 23 the the DT 42759 2044 24 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2044 25 is be VBZ 42759 2044 26 a a DT 42759 2044 27 " " `` 42759 2044 28 parasite parasite NN 42759 2044 29 , , , 42759 2044 30 " " '' 42759 2044 31 etc etc FW 42759 2044 32 . . FW 42759 2044 33 , , , 42759 2044 34 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2044 35 are be VBP 42759 2044 36 expressing express VBG 42759 2044 37 and and CC 42759 2044 38 conveying convey VBG 42759 2044 39 distinct distinct JJ 42759 2044 40 moral moral JJ 42759 2044 41 judgments judgment NNS 42759 2044 42 . . . 42759 2045 1 In in IN 42759 2045 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2045 3 more more RBR 42759 2045 4 popular popular JJ 42759 2045 5 writings writing NNS 42759 2045 6 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2045 7 authors author NNS 42759 2045 8 do do VBP 42759 2045 9 not not RB 42759 2045 10 seriously seriously RB 42759 2045 11 attempt attempt VB 42759 2045 12 to to TO 42759 2045 13 observe observe VB 42759 2045 14 the the DT 42759 2045 15 logical logical JJ 42759 2045 16 requirements requirement NNS 42759 2045 17 of of IN 42759 2045 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2045 19 necessitarian necessitarian JJ 42759 2045 20 philosophy philosophy NN 42759 2045 21 . . . 42759 2046 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2046 2 assume assume VBP 42759 2046 3 the the DT 42759 2046 4 same same JJ 42759 2046 5 ethical ethical JJ 42759 2046 6 postulates postulate NNS 42759 2046 7 , , , 42759 2046 8 and and CC 42759 2046 9 give give VB 42759 2046 10 expression expression NN 42759 2046 11 to to IN 42759 2046 12 the the DT 42759 2046 13 same same JJ 42759 2046 14 ethical ethical JJ 42759 2046 15 intuitions intuition NNS 42759 2046 16 as as IN 42759 2046 17 the the DT 42759 2046 18 man man NN 42759 2046 19 who who WP 42759 2046 20 believes believe VBZ 42759 2046 21 in in IN 42759 2046 22 the the DT 42759 2046 23 human human JJ 42759 2046 24 soul soul NN 42759 2046 25 and and CC 42759 2046 26 free free JJ 42759 2046 27 will will NN 42759 2046 28 . . . 42759 2047 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2047 2 115 115 CD 42759 2047 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2047 4 And and CC 42759 2047 5 the the DT 42759 2047 6 great great JJ 42759 2047 7 majority majority NN 42759 2047 8 of of IN 42759 2047 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2047 10 followers follower NNS 42759 2047 11 likewise likewise RB 42759 2047 12 regard regard VBP 42759 2047 13 the the DT 42759 2047 14 question question NN 42759 2047 15 of of IN 42759 2047 16 distribution distribution NN 42759 2047 17 as as IN 42759 2047 18 a a DT 42759 2047 19 moral moral JJ 42759 2047 20 question question NN 42759 2047 21 , , , 42759 2047 22 as as IN 42759 2047 23 a a DT 42759 2047 24 question question NN 42759 2047 25 of of IN 42759 2047 26 justice justice NN 42759 2047 27 . . . 42759 2048 1 In in IN 42759 2048 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2048 3 view view NN 42759 2048 4 the the DT 42759 2048 5 labourer labourer NN 42759 2048 6 not not RB 42759 2048 7 only only RB 42759 2048 8 creates create VBZ 42759 2048 9 all all DT 42759 2048 10 value value NN 42759 2048 11 , , , 42759 2048 12 but but CC 42759 2048 13 has have VBZ 42759 2048 14 a a DT 42759 2048 15 just just RB 42759 2048 16 claim claim NN 42759 2048 17 to to IN 42759 2048 18 the the DT 42759 2048 19 whole whole JJ 42759 2048 20 product product NN 42759 2048 21 . . . 42759 2049 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2049 2 The the DT 42759 2049 3 Labour Labour NNP 42759 2049 4 Theory Theory NNP 42759 2049 5 of of IN 42759 2049 6 Value Value NNP 42759 2049 7 _ _ NNP 42759 2049 8 This this DT 42759 2049 9 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 2049 10 is be VBZ 42759 2049 11 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 2049 12 formally formally RB 42759 2049 13 based base VBN 42759 2049 14 upon upon IN 42759 2049 15 the the DT 42759 2049 16 Marxian marxian JJ 42759 2049 17 theory theory NN 42759 2049 18 of of IN 42759 2049 19 value value NN 42759 2049 20 , , , 42759 2049 21 and and CC 42759 2049 22 is be VBZ 42759 2049 23 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 2049 24 defended defend VBN 42759 2049 25 independently independently RB 42759 2049 26 of of IN 42759 2049 27 that that DT 42759 2049 28 theory theory NN 42759 2049 29 . . . 42759 2050 1 In in IN 42759 2050 2 the the DT 42759 2050 3 former former JJ 42759 2050 4 case case NN 42759 2050 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2050 6 groundwork groundwork NN 42759 2050 7 is be VBZ 42759 2050 8 about about RB 42759 2050 9 as as IN 42759 2050 10 follows follow VBZ 42759 2050 11 : : : 42759 2050 12 By by IN 42759 2050 13 eliminating eliminate VBG 42759 2050 14 the the DT 42759 2050 15 factors factor NNS 42759 2050 16 of of IN 42759 2050 17 utility utility NN 42759 2050 18 and and CC 42759 2050 19 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 2050 20 , , , 42759 2050 21 Marx Marx NNP 42759 2050 22 found find VBD 42759 2050 23 that that IN 42759 2050 24 the the DT 42759 2050 25 only only JJ 42759 2050 26 element element NN 42759 2050 27 common common JJ 42759 2050 28 to to IN 42759 2050 29 all all DT 42759 2050 30 commodities commodity NNS 42759 2050 31 is be VBZ 42759 2050 32 labour labour JJ 42759 2050 33 , , , 42759 2050 34 and and CC 42759 2050 35 then then RB 42759 2050 36 concluded conclude VBD 42759 2050 37 that that IN 42759 2050 38 labour labour NN 42759 2050 39 is be VBZ 42759 2050 40 the the DT 42759 2050 41 only only JJ 42759 2050 42 possible possible JJ 42759 2050 43 explanation explanation NN 42759 2050 44 , , , 42759 2050 45 creator creator NN 42759 2050 46 , , , 42759 2050 47 and and CC 42759 2050 48 determinant determinant NN 42759 2050 49 of of IN 42759 2050 50 value value NN 42759 2050 51 . . . 42759 2051 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2051 2 116 116 CD 42759 2051 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2051 4 Since since IN 42759 2051 5 capital capital NN 42759 2051 6 , , , 42759 2051 7 that that RB 42759 2051 8 is is RB 42759 2051 9 , , , 42759 2051 10 concrete concrete JJ 42759 2051 11 capital capital NN 42759 2051 12 , , , 42759 2051 13 is be VBZ 42759 2051 14 a a DT 42759 2051 15 commodity commodity NN 42759 2051 16 , , , 42759 2051 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2051 18 value value NN 42759 2051 19 is be VBZ 42759 2051 20 likewise likewise RB 42759 2051 21 determined determine VBN 42759 2051 22 and and CC 42759 2051 23 created create VBN 42759 2051 24 by by IN 42759 2051 25 labour labour NN 42759 2051 26 . . . 42759 2052 1 Since since IN 42759 2052 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2052 3 can can MD 42759 2052 4 not not RB 42759 2052 5 create create VB 42759 2052 6 value value NN 42759 2052 7 , , , 42759 2052 8 for for IN 42759 2052 9 only only RB 42759 2052 10 labour labour NN 42759 2052 11 has have VBZ 42759 2052 12 that that DT 42759 2052 13 power power NN 42759 2052 14 , , , 42759 2052 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2052 16 can can MD 42759 2052 17 contribute contribute VB 42759 2052 18 to to IN 42759 2052 19 the the DT 42759 2052 20 product product NN 42759 2052 21 of of IN 42759 2052 22 the the DT 42759 2052 23 productive productive JJ 42759 2052 24 process process NN 42759 2052 25 in in IN 42759 2052 26 which which WDT 42759 2052 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2052 28 is be VBZ 42759 2052 29 engaged engage VBN 42759 2052 30 only only RB 42759 2052 31 as as RB 42759 2052 32 much much JJ 42759 2052 33 value value NN 42759 2052 34 as as IN 42759 2052 35 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2052 36 originally originally RB 42759 2052 37 received receive VBD 42759 2052 38 . . . 42759 2053 1 Since since IN 42759 2053 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2053 3 is be VBZ 42759 2053 4 only only RB 42759 2053 5 a a DT 42759 2053 6 reservoir reservoir NN 42759 2053 7 of of IN 42759 2053 8 value value NN 42759 2053 9 , , , 42759 2053 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2053 11 can can MD 42759 2053 12 not not RB 42759 2053 13 transfer transfer VB 42759 2053 14 more more JJR 42759 2053 15 value value NN 42759 2053 16 than than IN 42759 2053 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2053 18 holds hold VBZ 42759 2053 19 and and CC 42759 2053 20 possesses possess VBZ 42759 2053 21 . . . 42759 2054 1 In in IN 42759 2054 2 the the DT 42759 2054 3 words word NNS 42759 2054 4 of of IN 42759 2054 5 Marx Marx NNP 42759 2054 6 , , , 42759 2054 7 " " '' 42759 2054 8 the the DT 42759 2054 9 means mean NNS 42759 2054 10 of of IN 42759 2054 11 production production NN 42759 2054 12 transfer transfer NN 42759 2054 13 value value NN 42759 2054 14 to to IN 42759 2054 15 the the DT 42759 2054 16 new new JJ 42759 2054 17 product product NN 42759 2054 18 , , , 42759 2054 19 so so RB 42759 2054 20 far far RB 42759 2054 21 only only RB 42759 2054 22 as as IN 42759 2054 23 during during IN 42759 2054 24 the the DT 42759 2054 25 labour labour NN 42759 2054 26 - - HYPH 42759 2054 27 process process NN 42759 2054 28 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2054 29 lose lose VBP 42759 2054 30 value value NN 42759 2054 31 in in IN 42759 2054 32 the the DT 42759 2054 33 shape shape NN 42759 2054 34 of of IN 42759 2054 35 the the DT 42759 2054 36 old old JJ 42759 2054 37 use use NN 42759 2054 38 - - HYPH 42759 2054 39 value value NN 42759 2054 40 . . . 42759 2055 1 The the DT 42759 2055 2 maximum maximum JJ 42759 2055 3 loss loss NN 42759 2055 4 of of IN 42759 2055 5 value value NN 42759 2055 6 that that WDT 42759 2055 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2055 8 can can MD 42759 2055 9 suffer suffer VB 42759 2055 10 in in IN 42759 2055 11 the the DT 42759 2055 12 process process NN 42759 2055 13 is be VBZ 42759 2055 14 plainly plainly RB 42759 2055 15 limited limit VBN 42759 2055 16 by by IN 42759 2055 17 the the DT 42759 2055 18 amount amount NN 42759 2055 19 of of IN 42759 2055 20 the the DT 42759 2055 21 original original JJ 42759 2055 22 value value NN 42759 2055 23 with with IN 42759 2055 24 which which WDT 42759 2055 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2055 26 came come VBD 42759 2055 27 into into IN 42759 2055 28 the the DT 42759 2055 29 process process NN 42759 2055 30 , , , 42759 2055 31 or or CC 42759 2055 32 , , , 42759 2055 33 in in IN 42759 2055 34 other other JJ 42759 2055 35 words word NNS 42759 2055 36 , , , 42759 2055 37 by by IN 42759 2055 38 the the DT 42759 2055 39 labour labour NN 42759 2055 40 time time NN 42759 2055 41 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2055 42 for for IN 42759 2055 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2055 44 production production NN 42759 2055 45 . . . 42759 2056 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 2056 2 , , , 42759 2056 3 the the DT 42759 2056 4 means mean NNS 42759 2056 5 of of IN 42759 2056 6 production production NN 42759 2056 7 can can MD 42759 2056 8 ever ever RB 42759 2056 9 add add VB 42759 2056 10 more more JJR 42759 2056 11 value value NN 42759 2056 12 to to IN 42759 2056 13 the the DT 42759 2056 14 product product NN 42759 2056 15 than than IN 42759 2056 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2056 17 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 2056 18 possess possess VBP 42759 2056 19 independently independently RB 42759 2056 20 of of IN 42759 2056 21 the the DT 42759 2056 22 process process NN 42759 2056 23 in in IN 42759 2056 24 which which WDT 42759 2056 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2056 26 assist assist VBP 42759 2056 27 . . . 42759 2057 1 However however WRB 42759 2057 2 useful useful JJ 42759 2057 3 a a DT 42759 2057 4 given give VBN 42759 2057 5 kind kind NN 42759 2057 6 of of IN 42759 2057 7 raw raw JJ 42759 2057 8 material material NN 42759 2057 9 , , , 42759 2057 10 or or CC 42759 2057 11 a a DT 42759 2057 12 machine machine NN 42759 2057 13 , , , 42759 2057 14 or or CC 42759 2057 15 other other JJ 42759 2057 16 means mean NNS 42759 2057 17 of of IN 42759 2057 18 production production NN 42759 2057 19 may may MD 42759 2057 20 be be VB 42759 2057 21 , , , 42759 2057 22 though though IN 42759 2057 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2057 24 may may MD 42759 2057 25 cost cost VB 42759 2057 26 150 150 CD 42759 2057 27 pounds pound NNS 42759 2057 28 , , , 42759 2057 29 or or CC 42759 2057 30 say say VBP 42759 2057 31 500 500 CD 42759 2057 32 days day NNS 42759 2057 33 ' ' POS 42759 2057 34 labour labour NN 42759 2057 35 , , , 42759 2057 36 yet yet CC 42759 2057 37 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2057 38 can can MD 42759 2057 39 not not RB 42759 2057 40 , , , 42759 2057 41 under under IN 42759 2057 42 any any DT 42759 2057 43 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 2057 44 , , , 42759 2057 45 add add VB 42759 2057 46 to to IN 42759 2057 47 the the DT 42759 2057 48 value value NN 42759 2057 49 of of IN 42759 2057 50 the the DT 42759 2057 51 product product NN 42759 2057 52 more more JJR 42759 2057 53 than than IN 42759 2057 54 150 150 CD 42759 2057 55 pounds pound NNS 42759 2057 56 . . . 42759 2058 1 " " `` 42759 2058 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2058 3 117 117 CD 42759 2058 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2058 5 To to TO 42759 2058 6 view view VB 42759 2058 7 the the DT 42759 2058 8 matter matter NN 42759 2058 9 from from IN 42759 2058 10 another another DT 42759 2058 11 angle angle NN 42759 2058 12 : : : 42759 2058 13 capital capital NN 42759 2058 14 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 2058 15 to to IN 42759 2058 16 the the DT 42759 2058 17 product product NN 42759 2058 18 only only RB 42759 2058 19 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2058 20 value value NN 42759 2058 21 to to TO 42759 2058 22 pay pay VB 42759 2058 23 for for IN 42759 2058 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2058 25 own own JJ 42759 2058 26 reproduction reproduction NN 42759 2058 27 . . . 42759 2059 1 When when WRB 42759 2059 2 , , , 42759 2059 3 as as IN 42759 2059 4 is be VBZ 42759 2059 5 the the DT 42759 2059 6 normal normal JJ 42759 2059 7 usage usage NN 42759 2059 8 , , , 42759 2059 9 the the DT 42759 2059 10 undertaker undertaker NN 42759 2059 11 has have VBZ 42759 2059 12 deducted deduct VBN 42759 2059 13 from from IN 42759 2059 14 the the DT 42759 2059 15 product product NN 42759 2059 16 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2059 17 value value NN 42759 2059 18 or or CC 42759 2059 19 money money NN 42759 2059 20 to to TO 42759 2059 21 replace replace VB 42759 2059 22 the the DT 42759 2059 23 deteriorated deteriorated JJ 42759 2059 24 or or CC 42759 2059 25 worn wear VBN 42759 2059 26 out out RP 42759 2059 27 machine machine NN 42759 2059 28 , , , 42759 2059 29 or or CC 42759 2059 30 other other JJ 42759 2059 31 concrete concrete JJ 42759 2059 32 capital capital NN 42759 2059 33 , , , 42759 2059 34 all all PDT 42759 2059 35 the the DT 42759 2059 36 remaining remain VBG 42759 2059 37 value value NN 42759 2059 38 in in IN 42759 2059 39 the the DT 42759 2059 40 product product NN 42759 2059 41 is be VBZ 42759 2059 42 due due JJ 42759 2059 43 specifically specifically RB 42759 2059 44 to to IN 42759 2059 45 labour labour NN 42759 2059 46 . . . 42759 2060 1 When when WRB 42759 2060 2 , , , 42759 2060 3 therefore therefore RB 42759 2060 4 , , , 42759 2060 5 the the DT 42759 2060 6 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2060 7 goes go VBZ 42759 2060 8 further far RBR 42759 2060 9 , , , 42759 2060 10 and and CC 42759 2060 11 appropriates appropriate VBZ 42759 2060 12 from from IN 42759 2060 13 the the DT 42759 2060 14 product product NN 42759 2060 15 interest interest NN 42759 2060 16 and and CC 42759 2060 17 profits profit NNS 42759 2060 18 , , , 42759 2060 19 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2060 20 takes take VBZ 42759 2060 21 a a DT 42759 2060 22 part part NN 42759 2060 23 of of IN 42759 2060 24 the the DT 42759 2060 25 value value NN 42759 2060 26 that that WDT 42759 2060 27 labour labour NN 42759 2060 28 has have VBZ 42759 2060 29 created create VBN 42759 2060 30 . . . 42759 2061 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2061 2 seizes seize VBZ 42759 2061 3 the the DT 42759 2061 4 surplus surplus NN 42759 2061 5 value value NN 42759 2061 6 which which WDT 42759 2061 7 labour labour NN 42759 2061 8 has have VBZ 42759 2061 9 produced produce VBN 42759 2061 10 in in IN 42759 2061 11 excess excess NN 42759 2061 12 of of IN 42759 2061 13 the the DT 42759 2061 14 wages wage NNS 42759 2061 15 that that WDT 42759 2061 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2061 17 receives receive VBZ 42759 2061 18 . . . 42759 2062 1 In in IN 42759 2062 2 ethical ethical JJ 42759 2062 3 terms term NNS 42759 2062 4 , , , 42759 2062 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2062 6 robs rob VBZ 42759 2062 7 the the DT 42759 2062 8 labourers labourer NNS 42759 2062 9 of of IN 42759 2062 10 a a DT 42759 2062 11 part part NN 42759 2062 12 of of IN 42759 2062 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2062 14 product product NN 42759 2062 15 . . . 42759 2063 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2063 2 is be VBZ 42759 2063 3 not not RB 42759 2063 4 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2063 5 to to TO 42759 2063 6 introduce introduce VB 42759 2063 7 any any DT 42759 2063 8 extended extended JJ 42759 2063 9 refutation refutation NN 42759 2063 10 of of IN 42759 2063 11 this this DT 42759 2063 12 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 42759 2063 13 , , , 42759 2063 14 unreal unreal JJ 42759 2063 15 , , , 42759 2063 16 and and CC 42759 2063 17 fantastic fantastic JJ 42759 2063 18 argument argument NN 42759 2063 19 . . . 42759 2064 1 " " `` 42759 2064 2 The the DT 42759 2064 3 theory theory NN 42759 2064 4 that that IN 42759 2064 5 labour labour NN 42759 2064 6 is be VBZ 42759 2064 7 the the DT 42759 2064 8 sole sole JJ 42759 2064 9 source source NN 42759 2064 10 of of IN 42759 2064 11 value value NN 42759 2064 12 has have VBZ 42759 2064 13 few few JJ 42759 2064 14 defenders defender NNS 42759 2064 15 to to IN 42759 2064 16 - - HYPH 42759 2064 17 day day NN 42759 2064 18 . . . 42759 2065 1 In in IN 42759 2065 2 the the DT 42759 2065 3 face face NN 42759 2065 4 of of IN 42759 2065 5 the the DT 42759 2065 6 overwhelming overwhelming JJ 42759 2065 7 criticism criticism NN 42759 2065 8 which which WDT 42759 2065 9 has have VBZ 42759 2065 10 been be VBN 42759 2065 11 directed direct VBN 42759 2065 12 against against IN 42759 2065 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2065 14 , , , 42759 2065 15 even even RB 42759 2065 16 good good JJ 42759 2065 17 Marxists marxist NNS 42759 2065 18 are be VBP 42759 2065 19 forced force VBN 42759 2065 20 to to TO 42759 2065 21 abandon abandon VB 42759 2065 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2065 23 , , , 42759 2065 24 or or CC 42759 2065 25 to to TO 42759 2065 26 explain explain VB 42759 2065 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2065 28 away away RB 42759 2065 29 . . . 42759 2066 1 " " `` 42759 2066 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2066 3 118 118 CD 42759 2066 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2066 5 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2066 6 may may MD 42759 2066 7 , , , 42759 2066 8 however however RB 42759 2066 9 , , , 42759 2066 10 be be VB 42759 2066 11 useful useful JJ 42759 2066 12 to to TO 42759 2066 13 recount recount VB 42759 2066 14 very very RB 42759 2066 15 briefly briefly RB 42759 2066 16 the the DT 42759 2066 17 facts fact NNS 42759 2066 18 which which WDT 42759 2066 19 disprove disprove VBP 42759 2066 20 the the DT 42759 2066 21 theory theory NN 42759 2066 22 . . . 42759 2067 1 Labour labour NN 42759 2067 2 creates create VBZ 42759 2067 3 some some DT 42759 2067 4 things thing NNS 42759 2067 5 which which WDT 42759 2067 6 have have VBP 42759 2067 7 no no DT 42759 2067 8 value value NN 42759 2067 9 , , , 42759 2067 10 as as IN 42759 2067 11 wooden wooden JJ 42759 2067 12 shoes shoe NNS 42759 2067 13 in in IN 42759 2067 14 a a DT 42759 2067 15 community community NN 42759 2067 16 that that WDT 42759 2067 17 does do VBZ 42759 2067 18 not not RB 42759 2067 19 desire desire VB 42759 2067 20 wooden wooden JJ 42759 2067 21 shoes shoe NNS 42759 2067 22 ; ; , 42759 2067 23 some some DT 42759 2067 24 things thing NNS 42759 2067 25 have have VBP 42759 2067 26 value value NN 42759 2067 27 , , , 42759 2067 28 exchange exchange NN 42759 2067 29 value value NN 42759 2067 30 , , , 42759 2067 31 although although IN 42759 2067 32 no no DT 42759 2067 33 labour labour NN 42759 2067 34 has have VBZ 42759 2067 35 been be VBN 42759 2067 36 expended expend VBN 42759 2067 37 upon upon IN 42759 2067 38 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2067 39 , , , 42759 2067 40 as as IN 42759 2067 41 land land NN 42759 2067 42 and and CC 42759 2067 43 minerals mineral NNS 42759 2067 44 ; ; : 42759 2067 45 the the DT 42759 2067 46 value value NN 42759 2067 47 of of IN 42759 2067 48 things thing NNS 42759 2067 49 is be VBZ 42759 2067 50 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 2067 51 greater great JJR 42759 2067 52 , , , 42759 2067 53 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 2067 54 less less JJR 42759 2067 55 , , , 42759 2067 56 proportionately proportionately RB 42759 2067 57 , , , 42759 2067 58 than than IN 42759 2067 59 the the DT 42759 2067 60 labour labour NN 42759 2067 61 embodied embody VBN 42759 2067 62 in in IN 42759 2067 63 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2067 64 ; ; : 42759 2067 65 for for IN 42759 2067 66 example example NN 42759 2067 67 , , , 42759 2067 68 paintings painting NNS 42759 2067 69 by by IN 42759 2067 70 the the DT 42759 2067 71 old old JJ 42759 2067 72 masters master NNS 42759 2067 73 , , , 42759 2067 74 and and CC 42759 2067 75 last last JJ 42759 2067 76 year year NN 42759 2067 77 's 's POS 42759 2067 78 styles style NNS 42759 2067 79 of of IN 42759 2067 80 millinery millinery NN 42759 2067 81 ; ; : 42759 2067 82 and and CC 42759 2067 83 , , , 42759 2067 84 finally finally RB 42759 2067 85 , , , 42759 2067 86 the the DT 42759 2067 87 true true JJ 42759 2067 88 determinants determinant NNS 42759 2067 89 of of IN 42759 2067 90 value value NN 42759 2067 91 are be VBP 42759 2067 92 utility utility NN 42759 2067 93 and and CC 42759 2067 94 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 2067 95 . . . 42759 2068 1 If if IN 42759 2068 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2068 3 be be VB 42759 2068 4 objected object VBN 42759 2068 5 that that IN 42759 2068 6 Marx Marx NNP 42759 2068 7 was be VBD 42759 2068 8 aware aware JJ 42759 2068 9 of of IN 42759 2068 10 these these DT 42759 2068 11 two two CD 42759 2068 12 factors factor NNS 42759 2068 13 , , , 42759 2068 14 the the DT 42759 2068 15 reply reply NN 42759 2068 16 is be VBZ 42759 2068 17 that that IN 42759 2068 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2068 19 either either CC 42759 2068 20 restricted restrict VBD 42759 2068 21 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2068 22 to to IN 42759 2068 23 the the DT 42759 2068 24 function function NN 42759 2068 25 of of IN 42759 2068 26 conditions condition NNS 42759 2068 27 rather rather RB 42759 2068 28 than than IN 42759 2068 29 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2068 30 causes cause NNS 42759 2068 31 of of IN 42759 2068 32 value value NN 42759 2068 33 , , , 42759 2068 34 or or CC 42759 2068 35 attributed attribute VBN 42759 2068 36 to to IN 42759 2068 37 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2068 38 an an DT 42759 2068 39 influence influence NN 42759 2068 40 that that WDT 42759 2068 41 is be VBZ 42759 2068 42 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 42759 2068 43 with with IN 42759 2068 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2068 45 main main JJ 42759 2068 46 theory theory NN 42759 2068 47 that that IN 42759 2068 48 labour labour NN 42759 2068 49 is be VBZ 42759 2068 50 the the DT 42759 2068 51 sole sole JJ 42759 2068 52 determinant determinant NN 42759 2068 53 of of IN 42759 2068 54 value value NN 42759 2068 55 . . . 42759 2069 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 2069 2 , , , 42759 2069 3 the the DT 42759 2069 4 contradictions contradiction NNS 42759 2069 5 into into IN 42759 2069 6 which which WDT 42759 2069 7 Marx Marx NNP 42759 2069 8 was be VBD 42759 2069 9 led lead VBN 42759 2069 10 by by IN 42759 2069 11 the the DT 42759 2069 12 theory theory NN 42759 2069 13 are be VBP 42759 2069 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2069 15 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2069 16 refutation refutation NN 42759 2069 17 . . . 42759 2070 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2070 2 119 119 CD 42759 2070 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2070 4 With with IN 42759 2070 5 the the DT 42759 2070 6 destruction destruction NN 42759 2070 7 of of IN 42759 2070 8 the the DT 42759 2070 9 labour labour NN 42759 2070 10 theory theory NN 42759 2070 11 of of IN 42759 2070 12 value value NN 42759 2070 13 , , , 42759 2070 14 the the DT 42759 2070 15 Marxian marxian JJ 42759 2070 16 contention contention NN 42759 2070 17 that that IN 42759 2070 18 capital capital NN 42759 2070 19 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 2070 20 only only RB 42759 2070 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2070 22 own own JJ 42759 2070 23 original original JJ 42759 2070 24 value value NN 42759 2070 25 to to IN 42759 2070 26 the the DT 42759 2070 27 product product NN 42759 2070 28 is be VBZ 42759 2070 29 likewise likewise RB 42759 2070 30 overthrown overthrow VBN 42759 2070 31 . . . 42759 2071 1 The the DT 42759 2071 2 same same JJ 42759 2071 3 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 2071 4 is be VBZ 42759 2071 5 reached reach VBN 42759 2071 6 more more RBR 42759 2071 7 directly directly RB 42759 2071 8 by by IN 42759 2071 9 recalling recall VBG 42759 2071 10 the the DT 42759 2071 11 obvious obvious JJ 42759 2071 12 facts fact NNS 42759 2071 13 of of IN 42759 2071 14 experience experience NN 42759 2071 15 that that WDT 42759 2071 16 , , , 42759 2071 17 since since IN 42759 2071 18 the the DT 42759 2071 19 joint joint JJ 42759 2071 20 action action NN 42759 2071 21 of of IN 42759 2071 22 both both DT 42759 2071 23 capital capital NN 42759 2071 24 and and CC 42759 2071 25 labour labour NN 42759 2071 26 is be VBZ 42759 2071 27 required require VBN 42759 2071 28 to to TO 42759 2071 29 bring bring VB 42759 2071 30 into into IN 42759 2071 31 being be VBG 42759 2071 32 every every DT 42759 2071 33 atom atom NN 42759 2071 34 of of IN 42759 2071 35 the the DT 42759 2071 36 product product NN 42759 2071 37 , , , 42759 2071 38 each each DT 42759 2071 39 is be VBZ 42759 2071 40 in in IN 42759 2071 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2071 42 own own JJ 42759 2071 43 order order NN 42759 2071 44 the the DT 42759 2071 45 cause cause NN 42759 2071 46 of of IN 42759 2071 47 the the DT 42759 2071 48 whole whole JJ 42759 2071 49 product product NN 42759 2071 50 , , , 42759 2071 51 and and CC 42759 2071 52 the the DT 42759 2071 53 proportion proportion NN 42759 2071 54 of of IN 42759 2071 55 the the DT 42759 2071 56 whole whole NN 42759 2071 57 that that WDT 42759 2071 58 is be VBZ 42759 2071 59 specifically specifically RB 42759 2071 60 due due JJ 42759 2071 61 to to IN 42759 2071 62 the the DT 42759 2071 63 casual casual JJ 42759 2071 64 influence influence NN 42759 2071 65 of of IN 42759 2071 66 either either CC 42759 2071 67 is be VBZ 42759 2071 68 as as RB 42759 2071 69 incapable incapable JJ 42759 2071 70 of of IN 42759 2071 71 determination determination NN 42759 2071 72 as as IN 42759 2071 73 the the DT 42759 2071 74 procreative procreative JJ 42759 2071 75 contribution contribution NN 42759 2071 76 of of IN 42759 2071 77 either either DT 42759 2071 78 parent parent NN 42759 2071 79 to to IN 42759 2071 80 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2071 81 common common JJ 42759 2071 82 offspring offspring NN 42759 2071 83 . . . 42759 2072 1 The the DT 42759 2072 2 productive productive JJ 42759 2072 3 process process NN 42759 2072 4 carried carry VBN 42759 2072 5 on on RP 42759 2072 6 by by IN 42759 2072 7 labour labour NN 42759 2072 8 and and CC 42759 2072 9 capital capital NN 42759 2072 10 is be VBZ 42759 2072 11 virtually virtually RB 42759 2072 12 an an DT 42759 2072 13 organic organic JJ 42759 2072 14 process process NN 42759 2072 15 , , , 42759 2072 16 in in IN 42759 2072 17 which which WDT 42759 2072 18 the the DT 42759 2072 19 precise precise JJ 42759 2072 20 amount amount NN 42759 2072 21 contributed contribute VBN 42759 2072 22 by by IN 42759 2072 23 either either DT 42759 2072 24 factor factor NN 42759 2072 25 is be VBZ 42759 2072 26 unknown unknown JJ 42759 2072 27 and and CC 42759 2072 28 unknowable unknowable JJ 42759 2072 29 . . . 42759 2073 1 In in IN 42759 2073 2 so so RB 42759 2073 3 far far RB 42759 2073 4 , , , 42759 2073 5 therefore therefore RB 42759 2073 6 , , , 42759 2073 7 as as IN 42759 2073 8 the the DT 42759 2073 9 alleged allege VBN 42759 2073 10 right right NN 42759 2073 11 of of IN 42759 2073 12 labour labour NN 42759 2073 13 to to IN 42759 2073 14 the the DT 42759 2073 15 whole whole JJ 42759 2073 16 product product NN 42759 2073 17 is be VBZ 42759 2073 18 based base VBN 42759 2073 19 upon upon IN 42759 2073 20 the the DT 42759 2073 21 Marxian marxian JJ 42759 2073 22 theory theory NN 42759 2073 23 of of IN 42759 2073 24 value value NN 42759 2073 25 , , , 42759 2073 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2073 27 has have VBZ 42759 2073 28 not not RB 42759 2073 29 a a DT 42759 2073 30 shadow shadow NN 42759 2073 31 of of IN 42759 2073 32 validity validity NN 42759 2073 33 . . . 42759 2074 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2074 2 The the DT 42759 2074 3 Right Right NNP 42759 2074 4 of of IN 42759 2074 5 Productivity Productivity NNP 42759 2074 6 _ _ NNP 42759 2074 7 But but CC 42759 2074 8 the the DT 42759 2074 9 claim claim NN 42759 2074 10 is be VBZ 42759 2074 11 not not RB 42759 2074 12 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 2074 13 dependent dependent JJ 42759 2074 14 upon upon IN 42759 2074 15 this this DT 42759 2074 16 foundation foundation NN 42759 2074 17 . . . 42759 2075 1 Those those DT 42759 2075 2 Socialists socialist NNS 42759 2075 3 who who WP 42759 2075 4 have have VBP 42759 2075 5 abandoned abandon VBN 42759 2075 6 the the DT 42759 2075 7 labour labour NN 42759 2075 8 theory theory NN 42759 2075 9 of of IN 42759 2075 10 value value NN 42759 2075 11 can can MD 42759 2075 12 argue argue VB 42759 2075 13 that that IN 42759 2075 14 the the DT 42759 2075 15 labourer labourer NN 42759 2075 16 ( ( -LRB- 42759 2075 17 including include VBG 42759 2075 18 the the DT 42759 2075 19 active active JJ 42759 2075 20 director director NN 42759 2075 21 of of IN 42759 2075 22 industry industry NN 42759 2075 23 ) ) -RRB- 42759 2075 24 is be VBZ 42759 2075 25 the the DT 42759 2075 26 only only JJ 42759 2075 27 _ _ NNP 42759 2075 28 human human NN 42759 2075 29 _ _ NNP 42759 2075 30 producer producer NN 42759 2075 31 , , , 42759 2075 32 that that IN 42759 2075 33 the the DT 42759 2075 34 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2075 35 as as IN 42759 2075 36 such such JJ 42759 2075 37 produces produce VBZ 42759 2075 38 nothing nothing NN 42759 2075 39 , , , 42759 2075 40 and and CC 42759 2075 41 consequently consequently RB 42759 2075 42 has have VBZ 42759 2075 43 no no DT 42759 2075 44 moral moral JJ 42759 2075 45 claim claim NN 42759 2075 46 to to IN 42759 2075 47 any any DT 42759 2075 48 part part NN 42759 2075 49 of of IN 42759 2075 50 the the DT 42759 2075 51 product product NN 42759 2075 52 . . . 42759 2076 1 Whatever whatever WDT 42759 2076 2 theory theory NN 42759 2076 3 of of IN 42759 2076 4 value value NN 42759 2076 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2076 6 may may MD 42759 2076 7 adopt adopt VB 42759 2076 8 , , , 42759 2076 9 or or CC 42759 2076 10 whether whether IN 42759 2076 11 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2076 12 adopt adopt VBP 42759 2076 13 any any DT 42759 2076 14 , , , 42759 2076 15 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2076 16 can can MD 42759 2076 17 not not RB 42759 2076 18 annul annul VB 42759 2076 19 the the DT 42759 2076 20 fact fact NN 42759 2076 21 that that IN 42759 2076 22 interest interest NN 42759 2076 23 does do VBZ 42759 2076 24 not not RB 42759 2076 25 represent represent VB 42759 2076 26 labour labour NN 42759 2076 27 expended expend VBN 42759 2076 28 upon upon IN 42759 2076 29 the the DT 42759 2076 30 product product NN 42759 2076 31 by by IN 42759 2076 32 the the DT 42759 2076 33 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2076 34 . . . 42759 2077 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2077 2 , , , 42759 2077 3 this this DT 42759 2077 4 fact fact NN 42759 2077 5 does do VBZ 42759 2077 6 not not RB 42759 2077 7 compel compel VB 42759 2077 8 the the DT 42759 2077 9 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 2077 10 that that IN 42759 2077 11 the the DT 42759 2077 12 share share NN 42759 2077 13 of of IN 42759 2077 14 the the DT 42759 2077 15 product product NN 42759 2077 16 now now RB 42759 2077 17 taken take VBN 42759 2077 18 by by IN 42759 2077 19 the the DT 42759 2077 20 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 2077 21 belongs belong VBZ 42759 2077 22 of of IN 42759 2077 23 right right NN 42759 2077 24 to to IN 42759 2077 25 the the DT 42759 2077 26 labourer labourer NN 42759 2077 27 . . . 42759 2078 1 Productivity productivity NN 42759 2078 2 does do VBZ 42759 2078 3 not not RB 42759 2078 4 of of IN 42759 2078 5 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2078 6 create create VB 42759 2078 7 a a DT 42759 2078 8 right right NN 42759 2078 9 to to IN 42759 2078 10 the the DT 42759 2078 11 product product NN 42759 2078 12 . . . 42759 2079 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2079 2 is be VBZ 42759 2079 3 not not RB 42759 2079 4 an an DT 42759 2079 5 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2079 6 title title NN 42759 2079 7 . . . 42759 2080 1 That that DT 42759 2080 2 is be VBZ 42759 2080 3 to to TO 42759 2080 4 say say VB 42759 2080 5 , , , 42759 2080 6 a a DT 42759 2080 7 right right NN 42759 2080 8 to to IN 42759 2080 9 the the DT 42759 2080 10 product product NN 42759 2080 11 is be VBZ 42759 2080 12 not not RB 42759 2080 13 inherent inherent JJ 42759 2080 14 in in IN 42759 2080 15 the the DT 42759 2080 16 relation relation NN 42759 2080 17 between between IN 42759 2080 18 product product NN 42759 2080 19 and and CC 42759 2080 20 producer producer NN 42759 2080 21 . . . 42759 2081 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2081 2 is be VBZ 42759 2081 3 determined determine VBN 42759 2081 4 by by IN 42759 2081 5 certain certain JJ 42759 2081 6 extrinsic extrinsic NN 42759 2081 7 relations relation NNS 42759 2081 8 . . . 42759 2082 1 When when WRB 42759 2082 2 Brown Brown NNP 42759 2082 3 makes make VBZ 42759 2082 4 a a DT 42759 2082 5 pair pair NN 42759 2082 6 of of IN 42759 2082 7 shoes shoe NNS 42759 2082 8 out out IN 42759 2082 9 of of IN 42759 2082 10 materials material NNS 42759 2082 11 that that WDT 42759 2082 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2082 13 has have VBZ 42759 2082 14 stolen steal VBN 42759 2082 15 , , , 42759 2082 16 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2082 17 has have VBZ 42759 2082 18 not not RB 42759 2082 19 a a DT 42759 2082 20 right right NN 42759 2082 21 to to IN 42759 2082 22 the the DT 42759 2082 23 whole whole JJ 42759 2082 24 product product NN 42759 2082 25 ; ; : 42759 2082 26 when when WRB 42759 2082 27 Jones Jones NNP 42759 2082 28 turns turn VBZ 42759 2082 29 out out RP 42759 2082 30 a a DT 42759 2082 31 similar similar JJ 42759 2082 32 product product NN 42759 2082 33 from from IN 42759 2082 34 materials material NNS 42759 2082 35 that that IN 42759 2082 36 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2082 37 has have VBZ 42759 2082 38 bought buy VBN 42759 2082 39 , , , 42759 2082 40 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2082 41 becomes become VBZ 42759 2082 42 the the DT 42759 2082 43 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 2082 44 owner owner NN 42759 2082 45 of of IN 42759 2082 46 the the DT 42759 2082 47 shoes shoe NNS 42759 2082 48 . . . 42759 2083 1 The the DT 42759 2083 2 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2083 3 relation relation NN 42759 2083 4 of of IN 42759 2083 5 productivity productivity NN 42759 2083 6 is be VBZ 42759 2083 7 the the DT 42759 2083 8 same same JJ 42759 2083 9 in in IN 42759 2083 10 both both DT 42759 2083 11 cases case NNS 42759 2083 12 . . . 42759 2084 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2084 2 is be VBZ 42759 2084 3 the the DT 42759 2084 4 difference difference NN 42759 2084 5 of of IN 42759 2084 6 extrinsic extrinsic NN 42759 2084 7 relation relation NN 42759 2084 8 , , , 42759 2084 9 namely namely RB 42759 2084 10 , , , 42759 2084 11 the the DT 42759 2084 12 relation relation NN 42759 2084 13 between between IN 42759 2084 14 the the DT 42759 2084 15 producer producer NN 42759 2084 16 and and CC 42759 2084 17 the the DT 42759 2084 18 material material NN 42759 2084 19 , , , 42759 2084 20 that that WDT 42759 2084 21 begets beget VBZ 42759 2084 22 the the DT 42759 2084 23 difference difference NN 42759 2084 24 between between IN 42759 2084 25 the the DT 42759 2084 26 moral moral JJ 42759 2084 27 claims claim NNS 42759 2084 28 of of IN 42759 2084 29 the the DT 42759 2084 30 two two CD 42759 2084 31 producers producer NNS 42759 2084 32 upon upon IN 42759 2084 33 the the DT 42759 2084 34 product product NN 42759 2084 35 . . . 42759 2085 1 The the DT 42759 2085 2 right right NN 42759 2085 3 of of IN 42759 2085 4 the the DT 42759 2085 5 producer producer NN 42759 2085 6 is be VBZ 42759 2085 7 conditioned condition VBN 42759 2085 8 by by IN 42759 2085 9 certain certain JJ 42759 2085 10 other other JJ 42759 2085 11 and and CC 42759 2085 12 more more RBR 42759 2085 13 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 2085 14 relations relation NNS 42759 2085 15 . . . 42759 2086 1 Why why WRB 42759 2086 2 has have VBZ 42759 2086 3 Jones Jones NNP 42759 2086 4 a a DT 42759 2086 5 right right NN 42759 2086 6 to to IN 42759 2086 7 the the DT 42759 2086 8 shoes shoe NNS 42759 2086 9 that that WDT 42759 2086 10 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2086 11 has have VBZ 42759 2086 12 made make VBN 42759 2086 13 out out IN 42759 2086 14 of of IN 42759 2086 15 materials material NNS 42759 2086 16 that that WDT 42759 2086 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2086 18 has have VBZ 42759 2086 19 bought buy VBN 42759 2086 20 ? ? . 42759 2087 1 Not not RB 42759 2087 2 because because IN 42759 2087 3 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2087 4 needs need VBZ 42759 2087 5 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2087 6 ; ; : 42759 2087 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2087 8 is be VBZ 42759 2087 9 not not RB 42759 2087 10 alone alone JJ 42759 2087 11 in in IN 42759 2087 12 this this DT 42759 2087 13 condition condition NN 42759 2087 14 . . . 42759 2088 1 The the DT 42759 2088 2 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 2088 3 reason reason NN 42759 2088 4 and and CC 42759 2088 5 basis basis NN 42759 2088 6 of of IN 42759 2088 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2088 8 ownership ownership NN 42759 2088 9 is be VBZ 42759 2088 10 to to TO 42759 2088 11 be be VB 42759 2088 12 sought seek VBN 42759 2088 13 in in IN 42759 2088 14 the the DT 42759 2088 15 practical practical JJ 42759 2088 16 requirements requirement NNS 42759 2088 17 of of IN 42759 2088 18 an an DT 42759 2088 19 equitable equitable JJ 42759 2088 20 social social JJ 42759 2088 21 distribution distribution NN 42759 2088 22 . . . 42759 2089 1 Unless unless IN 42759 2089 2 men man NNS 42759 2089 3 receive receive VBP 42759 2089 4 an an DT 42759 2089 5 adequate adequate JJ 42759 2089 6 return return NN 42759 2089 7 for for IN 42759 2089 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2089 9 labour labour NN 42759 2089 10 , , , 42759 2089 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2089 12 will will MD 42759 2089 13 not not RB 42759 2089 14 be be VB 42759 2089 15 able able JJ 42759 2089 16 to to TO 42759 2089 17 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 2089 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2089 19 wants want NNS 42759 2089 20 in in IN 42759 2089 21 a a DT 42759 2089 22 regular regular JJ 42759 2089 23 and and CC 42759 2089 24 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2089 25 manner manner NN 42759 2089 26 . . . 42759 2090 1 If if IN 42759 2090 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2090 3 are be VBP 42759 2090 4 forced force VBN 42759 2090 5 to to TO 42759 2090 6 labour labour NN 42759 2090 7 for for IN 42759 2090 8 others other NNS 42759 2090 9 without without IN 42759 2090 10 compensation compensation NN 42759 2090 11 , , , 42759 2090 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2090 13 are be VBP 42759 2090 14 deprived deprive VBN 42759 2090 15 of of IN 42759 2090 16 the the DT 42759 2090 17 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 2090 18 to to TO 42759 2090 19 develop develop VB 42759 2090 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2090 21 personality personality NN 42759 2090 22 . . . 42759 2091 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2091 2 are be VBP 42759 2091 3 treated treat VBN 42759 2091 4 as as IN 42759 2091 5 mere mere JJ 42759 2091 6 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2091 7 to to IN 42759 2091 8 the the DT 42759 2091 9 welfare welfare NN 42759 2091 10 of of IN 42759 2091 11 beings being NNS 42759 2091 12 who who WP 42759 2091 13 are be VBP 42759 2091 14 not not RB 42759 2091 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2091 16 superiors superior NNS 42759 2091 17 , , , 42759 2091 18 but but CC 42759 2091 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2091 20 moral moral JJ 42759 2091 21 and and CC 42759 2091 22 juridical juridical JJ 42759 2091 23 equals equal NNS 42759 2091 24 . . . 42759 2092 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2092 2 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2092 3 worth worth NN 42759 2092 4 and and CC 42759 2092 5 sacredness sacredness NN 42759 2092 6 of of IN 42759 2092 7 personality personality NN 42759 2092 8 is be VBZ 42759 2092 9 outraged outraged JJ 42759 2092 10 , , , 42759 2092 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2092 12 essential essential JJ 42759 2092 13 equality equality NN 42759 2092 14 with with IN 42759 2092 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2092 16 fellows fellow NNS 42759 2092 17 is be VBZ 42759 2092 18 disregarded disregard VBN 42759 2092 19 , , , 42759 2092 20 and and CC 42759 2092 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2092 22 indestructible indestructible JJ 42759 2092 23 rights right NNS 42759 2092 24 are be VBP 42759 2092 25 violated violate VBN 42759 2092 26 . . . 42759 2093 1 On on IN 42759 2093 2 the the DT 42759 2093 3 other other JJ 42759 2093 4 hand hand NN 42759 2093 5 , , , 42759 2093 6 when when WRB 42759 2093 7 a a DT 42759 2093 8 producer producer NN 42759 2093 9 , , , 42759 2093 10 such such JJ 42759 2093 11 as as IN 42759 2093 12 Jones Jones NNP 42759 2093 13 , , , 42759 2093 14 gets get VBZ 42759 2093 15 possession possession NN 42759 2093 16 of of IN 42759 2093 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2093 18 product product NN 42759 2093 19 , , , 42759 2093 20 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2093 21 subordinates subordinate VBZ 42759 2093 22 no no DT 42759 2093 23 human human NN 42759 2093 24 being be VBG 42759 2093 25 to to IN 42759 2093 26 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 2093 27 , , , 42759 2093 28 deprives deprive VBZ 42759 2093 29 no no DT 42759 2093 30 man man NN 42759 2093 31 of of IN 42759 2093 32 the the DT 42759 2093 33 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 2093 34 to to TO 42759 2093 35 perform perform VB 42759 2093 36 remunerative remunerative JJ 42759 2093 37 labour labour NN 42759 2093 38 , , , 42759 2093 39 nor nor CC 42759 2093 40 appropriates appropriate VBZ 42759 2093 41 an an DT 42759 2093 42 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 2093 43 share share NN 42759 2093 44 of of IN 42759 2093 45 the the DT 42759 2093 46 common common JJ 42759 2093 47 bounty bounty NN 42759 2093 48 of of IN 42759 2093 49 the the DT 42759 2093 50 earth earth NN 42759 2093 51 . . . 42759 2094 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2094 2 has have VBZ 42759 2094 3 a a DT 42759 2094 4 right right NN 42759 2094 5 to to IN 42759 2094 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2094 7 product product NN 42759 2094 8 because because IN 42759 2094 9 this this DT 42759 2094 10 is be VBZ 42759 2094 11 one one CD 42759 2094 12 of of IN 42759 2094 13 the the DT 42759 2094 14 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2094 15 methods method NNS 42759 2094 16 of of IN 42759 2094 17 distribution distribution NN 42759 2094 18 . . . 42759 2095 1 In in IN 42759 2095 2 fact fact NN 42759 2095 3 , , , 42759 2095 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2095 5 is be VBZ 42759 2095 6 the the DT 42759 2095 7 exigencies exigency NNS 42759 2095 8 of of IN 42759 2095 9 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2095 10 distribution distribution NN 42759 2095 11 that that WDT 42759 2095 12 constitute constitute VBP 42759 2095 13 the the DT 42759 2095 14 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 2095 15 justification justification NN 42759 2095 16 of of IN 42759 2095 17 every every DT 42759 2095 18 title title NN 42759 2095 19 of of IN 42759 2095 20 ownership ownership NN 42759 2095 21 . . . 42759 2096 1 The the DT 42759 2096 2 title title NN 42759 2096 3 of of IN 42759 2096 4 purchase purchase NN 42759 2096 5 by by IN 42759 2096 6 which which WDT 42759 2096 7 a a DT 42759 2096 8 man man NN 42759 2096 9 claims claim VBZ 42759 2096 10 the the DT 42759 2096 11 hat hat NN 42759 2096 12 that that WDT 42759 2096 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2096 14 wears wear VBZ 42759 2096 15 ; ; : 42759 2096 16 the the DT 42759 2096 17 title title NN 42759 2096 18 of of IN 42759 2096 19 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 2096 20 by by IN 42759 2096 21 which which WDT 42759 2096 22 a a DT 42759 2096 23 son son NN 42759 2096 24 claims claim VBZ 42759 2096 25 the the DT 42759 2096 26 house house NN 42759 2096 27 that that WDT 42759 2096 28 once once RB 42759 2096 29 belonged belong VBD 42759 2096 30 to to IN 42759 2096 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2096 32 father father NN 42759 2096 33 ; ; : 42759 2096 34 the the DT 42759 2096 35 title title NN 42759 2096 36 of of IN 42759 2096 37 contract contract NN 42759 2096 38 through through IN 42759 2096 39 which which WDT 42759 2096 40 a a DT 42759 2096 41 labourer labourer NN 42759 2096 42 gets get VBZ 42759 2096 43 wages wage NNS 42759 2096 44 , , , 42759 2096 45 a a DT 42759 2096 46 merchant merchant NN 42759 2096 47 prices price NNS 42759 2096 48 , , , 42759 2096 49 and and CC 42759 2096 50 a a DT 42759 2096 51 landlord landlord NN 42759 2096 52 rent,--are rent,--are `` 42759 2096 53 all all DT 42759 2096 54 valid valid JJ 42759 2096 55 simply simply RB 42759 2096 56 because because IN 42759 2096 57 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2096 58 are be VBP 42759 2096 59 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2096 60 devices device NNS 42759 2096 61 for for IN 42759 2096 62 enabling enable VBG 42759 2096 63 men man NNS 42759 2096 64 to to TO 42759 2096 65 obtain obtain VB 42759 2096 66 the the DT 42759 2096 67 goods good NNS 42759 2096 68 of of IN 42759 2096 69 the the DT 42759 2096 70 earth earth NN 42759 2096 71 for for IN 42759 2096 72 the the DT 42759 2096 73 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 2096 74 of of IN 42759 2096 75 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2096 76 wants want NNS 42759 2096 77 . . . 42759 2097 1 All all DT 42759 2097 2 titles title NNS 42759 2097 3 of of IN 42759 2097 4 property property NN 42759 2097 5 , , , 42759 2097 6 productivity productivity NN 42759 2097 7 included include VBD 42759 2097 8 , , , 42759 2097 9 are be VBP 42759 2097 10 conventional conventional JJ 42759 2097 11 institutions institution NNS 42759 2097 12 which which WDT 42759 2097 13 reason reason NN 42759 2097 14 and and CC 42759 2097 15 experience experience NN 42759 2097 16 have have VBP 42759 2097 17 shown show VBN 42759 2097 18 to to TO 42759 2097 19 be be VB 42759 2097 20 conducive conducive JJ 42759 2097 21 to to IN 42759 2097 22 human human JJ 42759 2097 23 welfare welfare NN 42759 2097 24 . . . 42759 2098 1 None none NN 42759 2098 2 of of IN 42759 2098 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2098 4 possesses possess VBZ 42759 2098 5 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2098 6 or or CC 42759 2098 7 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 42759 2098 8 validity validity NN 42759 2098 9 . . . 42759 2099 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2099 2 120 120 CD 42759 2099 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2099 4 Therefore therefore RB 42759 2099 5 , , , 42759 2099 6 the the DT 42759 2099 7 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 2099 8 can can MD 42759 2099 9 not not RB 42759 2099 10 establish establish VB 42759 2099 11 the the DT 42759 2099 12 right right NN 42759 2099 13 of of IN 42759 2099 14 labour labour NN 42759 2099 15 to to IN 42759 2099 16 the the DT 42759 2099 17 full full JJ 42759 2099 18 product product NN 42759 2099 19 of of IN 42759 2099 20 industry industry NN 42759 2099 21 until until IN 42759 2099 22 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2099 23 proves prove VBZ 42759 2099 24 that that IN 42759 2099 25 this this DT 42759 2099 26 so so RB 42759 2099 27 - - HYPH 42759 2099 28 called call VBN 42759 2099 29 right right NN 42759 2099 30 could could MD 42759 2099 31 be be VB 42759 2099 32 reduced reduce VBN 42759 2099 33 to to TO 42759 2099 34 practice practice VB 42759 2099 35 consistently consistently RB 42759 2099 36 with with IN 42759 2099 37 individual individual JJ 42759 2099 38 and and CC 42759 2099 39 social social JJ 42759 2099 40 welfare welfare NN 42759 2099 41 . . . 42759 2100 1 In in IN 42759 2100 2 other other JJ 42759 2100 3 words word NNS 42759 2100 4 , , , 42759 2100 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2100 6 must must MD 42759 2100 7 show show VB 42759 2100 8 that that DT 42759 2100 9 to to TO 42759 2100 10 give give VB 42759 2100 11 the the DT 42759 2100 12 entire entire JJ 42759 2100 13 product product NN 42759 2100 14 to to IN 42759 2100 15 the the DT 42759 2100 16 labourer labourer NN 42759 2100 17 would would MD 42759 2100 18 be be VB 42759 2100 19 a a DT 42759 2100 20 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2100 21 method method NN 42759 2100 22 of of IN 42759 2100 23 distribution distribution NN 42759 2100 24 . . . 42759 2101 1 Now now RB 42759 2101 2 the the DT 42759 2101 3 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 2101 4 by by IN 42759 2101 5 which which WDT 42759 2101 6 the the DT 42759 2101 7 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2101 8 proposes propose VBZ 42759 2101 9 to to TO 42759 2101 10 award award VB 42759 2101 11 the the DT 42759 2101 12 whole whole JJ 42759 2101 13 product product NN 42759 2101 14 of of IN 42759 2101 15 labour labour NN 42759 2101 16 is be VBZ 42759 2101 17 the the DT 42759 2101 18 collective collective JJ 42759 2101 19 ownership ownership NN 42759 2101 20 and and CC 42759 2101 21 operation operation NN 42759 2101 22 of of IN 42759 2101 23 the the DT 42759 2101 24 means mean NNS 42759 2101 25 of of IN 42759 2101 26 production production NN 42759 2101 27 , , , 42759 2101 28 and and CC 42759 2101 29 the the DT 42759 2101 30 social social JJ 42759 2101 31 distribution distribution NN 42759 2101 32 of of IN 42759 2101 33 the the DT 42759 2101 34 product product NN 42759 2101 35 . . . 42759 2102 1 If if IN 42759 2102 2 this this DT 42759 2102 3 system system NN 42759 2102 4 would would MD 42759 2102 5 not not RB 42759 2102 6 enable enable VB 42759 2102 7 the the DT 42759 2102 8 labourer labourer NN 42759 2102 9 and and CC 42759 2102 10 the the DT 42759 2102 11 members member NNS 42759 2102 12 of of IN 42759 2102 13 society society NN 42759 2102 14 generally generally RB 42759 2102 15 to to TO 42759 2102 16 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 2102 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2102 18 wants want NNS 42759 2102 19 to to TO 42759 2102 20 better well JJR 42759 2102 21 advantage advantage NN 42759 2102 22 than than IN 42759 2102 23 is be VBZ 42759 2102 24 possible possible JJ 42759 2102 25 under under IN 42759 2102 26 the the DT 42759 2102 27 present present JJ 42759 2102 28 system system NN 42759 2102 29 , , , 42759 2102 30 the the DT 42759 2102 31 contention contention NN 42759 2102 32 that that IN 42759 2102 33 the the DT 42759 2102 34 labourer labourer NN 42759 2102 35 has have VBZ 42759 2102 36 a a DT 42759 2102 37 right right NN 42759 2102 38 to to IN 42759 2102 39 the the DT 42759 2102 40 entire entire JJ 42759 2102 41 product product NN 42759 2102 42 of of IN 42759 2102 43 industry industry NN 42759 2102 44 falls fall VBZ 42759 2102 45 to to IN 42759 2102 46 the the DT 42759 2102 47 ground ground NN 42759 2102 48 . . . 42759 2103 1 The the DT 42759 2103 2 question question NN 42759 2103 3 will will MD 42759 2103 4 be be VB 42759 2103 5 considered consider VBN 42759 2103 6 in in IN 42759 2103 7 the the DT 42759 2103 8 following follow VBG 42759 2103 9 chapter chapter NN 42759 2103 10 . . . 42759 2104 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 2104 2 : : : 42759 2104 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2104 4 114 114 CD 42759 2104 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2104 6 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2104 7 . . . 42759 2105 1 Engels Engels NNP 42759 2105 2 , , , 42759 2105 3 " " `` 42759 2105 4 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2105 5 : : : 42759 2105 6 Utopian Utopian NNP 42759 2105 7 and and CC 42759 2105 8 Scientific Scientific NNP 42759 2105 9 , , , 42759 2105 10 " " '' 42759 2105 11 pp pp NNP 42759 2105 12 . . . 42759 2106 1 45 45 CD 42759 2106 2 , , , 42759 2106 3 46 46 CD 42759 2106 4 ; ; : 42759 2106 5 and and CC 42759 2106 6 Hillquit Hillquit NNP 42759 2106 7 - - HYPH 42759 2106 8 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 2106 9 , , , 42759 2106 10 " " `` 42759 2106 11 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2106 12 : : : 42759 2106 13 Promise promise NN 42759 2106 14 or or CC 42759 2106 15 Menace menace NN 42759 2106 16 , , , 42759 2106 17 " " '' 42759 2106 18 103 103 CD 42759 2106 19 , , , 42759 2106 20 104 104 CD 42759 2106 21 , , , 42759 2106 22 143 143 CD 42759 2106 23 - - SYM 42759 2106 24 145 145 CD 42759 2106 25 . . . 42759 2107 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2107 2 115 115 CD 42759 2107 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2107 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2107 5 . . . 42759 2108 1 Hillquit Hillquit NNP 42759 2108 2 - - HYPH 42759 2108 3 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 2108 4 , , , 42759 2108 5 op op NN 42759 2108 6 . . . 42759 2109 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2109 2 . . . 42759 2109 3 , , , 42759 2109 4 pp pp NNP 42759 2109 5 . . . 42759 2110 1 75 75 CD 42759 2110 2 , , , 42759 2110 3 76 76 CD 42759 2110 4 . . . 42759 2111 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2111 2 116 116 CD 42759 2111 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2111 4 " " `` 42759 2111 5 Capital Capital NNP 42759 2111 6 , , , 42759 2111 7 " " '' 42759 2111 8 pp pp NNP 42759 2111 9 . . . 42759 2112 1 1 1 CD 42759 2112 2 - - SYM 42759 2112 3 9 9 CD 42759 2112 4 . . . 42759 2113 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2113 2 117 117 CD 42759 2113 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2113 4 Op Op NNP 42759 2113 5 . . . 42759 2114 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2114 2 . . . 42759 2114 3 , , , 42759 2114 4 p. p. NN 42759 2114 5 117 117 CD 42759 2114 6 ; ; : 42759 2114 7 Humboldt Humboldt NNP 42759 2114 8 Edition Edition NNP 42759 2114 9 . . . 42759 2115 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2115 2 118 118 CD 42759 2115 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2115 4 Skelton Skelton NNP 42759 2115 5 , , , 42759 2115 6 " " `` 42759 2115 7 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2115 8 : : : 42759 2115 9 A a DT 42759 2115 10 Critical Critical NNP 42759 2115 11 Analysis Analysis NNP 42759 2115 12 , , , 42759 2115 13 " " '' 42759 2115 14 pp pp NNP 42759 2115 15 . . . 42759 2116 1 121 121 CD 42759 2116 2 , , , 42759 2116 3 122 122 CD 42759 2116 4 . . . 42759 2117 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2117 2 119 119 CD 42759 2117 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2117 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2117 5 . . . 42759 2118 1 Skelton Skelton NNP 42759 2118 2 , , , 42759 2118 3 loc loc NNP 42759 2118 4 . . . 42759 2119 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2119 2 . . . 42759 2120 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2120 2 120 120 CD 42759 2120 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2120 4 The the DT 42759 2120 5 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 42759 2120 6 claims claim NNS 42759 2120 7 made make VBN 42759 2120 8 on on IN 42759 2120 9 behalf behalf NN 42759 2120 10 of of IN 42759 2120 11 social social JJ 42759 2120 12 productivity productivity NN 42759 2120 13 in in IN 42759 2120 14 the the DT 42759 2120 15 matter matter NN 42759 2120 16 of of IN 42759 2120 17 land land NN 42759 2120 18 values value NNS 42759 2120 19 have have VBP 42759 2120 20 been be VBN 42759 2120 21 examined examine VBN 42759 2120 22 in in IN 42759 2120 23 a a DT 42759 2120 24 previous previous JJ 42759 2120 25 chapter chapter NN 42759 2120 26 . . . 42759 2121 1 Similar similar JJ 42759 2121 2 exaggerations exaggeration NNS 42759 2121 3 with with IN 42759 2121 4 regard regard NN 42759 2121 5 to to IN 42759 2121 6 capital capital NN 42759 2121 7 will will MD 42759 2121 8 be be VB 42759 2121 9 considered consider VBN 42759 2121 10 in in IN 42759 2121 11 chapter chapter NN 42759 2121 12 xii xii NNP 42759 2121 13 . . . 42759 2122 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 2122 2 XI XI NNP 42759 2122 3 THE the DT 42759 2122 4 SOCIALIST socialist JJ 42759 2122 5 SCHEME scheme NN 42759 2122 6 OF of IN 42759 2122 7 INDUSTRY INDUSTRY NNP 42759 2122 8 " " `` 42759 2122 9 Never never RB 42759 2122 10 has have VBZ 42759 2122 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2122 12 party party NN 42759 2122 13 told tell VBD 42759 2122 14 the the DT 42759 2122 15 workingman workingman NN 42759 2122 16 about about IN 42759 2122 17 a a DT 42759 2122 18 ' ' `` 42759 2122 19 State state NN 42759 2122 20 of of IN 42759 2122 21 the the DT 42759 2122 22 future future NN 42759 2122 23 , , , 42759 2122 24 ' ' '' 42759 2122 25 never never RB 42759 2122 26 in in IN 42759 2122 27 any any DT 42759 2122 28 way way NN 42759 2122 29 than than IN 42759 2122 30 as as IN 42759 2122 31 a a DT 42759 2122 32 mere mere JJ 42759 2122 33 utopia utopia NN 42759 2122 34 . . . 42759 2123 1 If if IN 42759 2123 2 anybody anybody NN 42759 2123 3 says say VBZ 42759 2123 4 : : : 42759 2123 5 ' ' `` 42759 2123 6 I -PRON- PRP 42759 2123 7 picture picture VBP 42759 2123 8 to to IN 42759 2123 9 myself -PRON- PRP 42759 2123 10 society society NN 42759 2123 11 after after IN 42759 2123 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2123 13 programme programme NN 42759 2123 14 has have VBZ 42759 2123 15 been be VBN 42759 2123 16 realised realise VBN 42759 2123 17 , , , 42759 2123 18 after after IN 42759 2123 19 wage wage NN 42759 2123 20 labour labour NN 42759 2123 21 has have VBZ 42759 2123 22 been be VBN 42759 2123 23 abolished abolish VBN 42759 2123 24 , , , 42759 2123 25 and and CC 42759 2123 26 the the DT 42759 2123 27 exploitation exploitation NN 42759 2123 28 of of IN 42759 2123 29 men man NNS 42759 2123 30 has have VBZ 42759 2123 31 ceased cease VBN 42759 2123 32 , , , 42759 2123 33 in in IN 42759 2123 34 such such JJ 42759 2123 35 and and CC 42759 2123 36 such such JJ 42759 2123 37 a a DT 42759 2123 38 manner,-- manner,-- NNS 42759 2123 39 ' ' POS 42759 2123 40 well well NN 42759 2123 41 and and CC 42759 2123 42 good good JJ 42759 2123 43 ; ; : 42759 2123 44 ideas idea NNS 42759 2123 45 are be VBP 42759 2123 46 free free JJ 42759 2123 47 , , , 42759 2123 48 and and CC 42759 2123 49 everybody everybody NN 42759 2123 50 may may MD 42759 2123 51 conceive conceive VB 42759 2123 52 the the DT 42759 2123 53 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 2123 54 State State NNP 42759 2123 55 as as IN 42759 2123 56 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2123 57 pleases please VBZ 42759 2123 58 . . . 42759 2124 1 Whoever whoever WP 42759 2124 2 believes believe VBZ 42759 2124 3 in in IN 42759 2124 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2124 5 may may MD 42759 2124 6 do do VB 42759 2124 7 so so RB 42759 2124 8 ; ; : 42759 2124 9 whoever whoever WP 42759 2124 10 does do VBZ 42759 2124 11 not not RB 42759 2124 12 , , , 42759 2124 13 need need VB 42759 2124 14 not not RB 42759 2124 15 . . . 42759 2125 1 These these DT 42759 2125 2 pictures picture NNS 42759 2125 3 are be VBP 42759 2125 4 but but CC 42759 2125 5 dreams dream NNS 42759 2125 6 , , , 42759 2125 7 and and CC 42759 2125 8 Social Social NNP 42759 2125 9 Democracy Democracy NNP 42759 2125 10 has have VBZ 42759 2125 11 never never RB 42759 2125 12 understood understand VBN 42759 2125 13 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2125 14 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 2125 15 . . . 42759 2126 1 " " `` 42759 2126 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2126 3 121 121 CD 42759 2126 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2126 5 Such such JJ 42759 2126 6 is be VBZ 42759 2126 7 the the DT 42759 2126 8 official official JJ 42759 2126 9 attitude attitude NN 42759 2126 10 of of IN 42759 2126 11 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2126 12 toward toward IN 42759 2126 13 descriptions description NNS 42759 2126 14 of of IN 42759 2126 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2126 16 contemplated contemplated JJ 42759 2126 17 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2126 18 organisation organisation NN 42759 2126 19 . . . 42759 2127 1 The the DT 42759 2127 2 party party NN 42759 2127 3 has have VBZ 42759 2127 4 never never RB 42759 2127 5 drawn draw VBN 42759 2127 6 up up RP 42759 2127 7 nor nor CC 42759 2127 8 approved approve VBN 42759 2127 9 any any DT 42759 2127 10 of of IN 42759 2127 11 the the DT 42759 2127 12 various various JJ 42759 2127 13 outlines outline NNS 42759 2127 14 of of IN 42759 2127 15 this this DT 42759 2127 16 sort sort NN 42759 2127 17 which which WDT 42759 2127 18 have have VBP 42759 2127 19 been be VBN 42759 2127 20 defended defend VBN 42759 2127 21 by by IN 42759 2127 22 individual individual JJ 42759 2127 23 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2127 24 . . . 42759 2128 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2128 2 maintains maintain VBZ 42759 2128 3 that that IN 42759 2128 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2128 5 can can MD 42759 2128 6 not not RB 42759 2128 7 anticipate anticipate VB 42759 2128 8 even even RB 42759 2128 9 the the DT 42759 2128 10 essential essential JJ 42759 2128 11 factors factor NNS 42759 2128 12 in in IN 42759 2128 13 the the DT 42759 2128 14 operation operation NN 42759 2128 15 of of IN 42759 2128 16 a a DT 42759 2128 17 social social JJ 42759 2128 18 and and CC 42759 2128 19 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2128 20 system system NN 42759 2128 21 which which WDT 42759 2128 22 will will MD 42759 2128 23 differ differ VB 42759 2128 24 so so RB 42759 2128 25 widely widely RB 42759 2128 26 from from IN 42759 2128 27 the the DT 42759 2128 28 one one NN 42759 2128 29 that that WDT 42759 2128 30 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2128 31 have have VBP 42759 2128 32 to to IN 42759 2128 33 - - HYPH 42759 2128 34 day day NN 42759 2128 35 , , , 42759 2128 36 and and CC 42759 2128 37 which which WDT 42759 2128 38 will will MD 42759 2128 39 be be VB 42759 2128 40 so so RB 42759 2128 41 profoundly profoundly RB 42759 2128 42 determined determine VBN 42759 2128 43 by by IN 42759 2128 44 events event NNS 42759 2128 45 that that WDT 42759 2128 46 are be VBP 42759 2128 47 in in IN 42759 2128 48 the the DT 42759 2128 49 nature nature NN 42759 2128 50 of of IN 42759 2128 51 the the DT 42759 2128 52 case case NN 42759 2128 53 impossible impossible JJ 42759 2128 54 to to TO 42759 2128 55 prognosticate prognosticate VB 42759 2128 56 . . . 42759 2129 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2129 2 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 2129 3 Inconsistency Inconsistency NNP 42759 2129 4 _ _ NNP 42759 2129 5 From from IN 42759 2129 6 the the DT 42759 2129 7 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 2129 8 of of IN 42759 2129 9 all all DT 42759 2129 10 but but CC 42759 2129 11 convinced convinced JJ 42759 2129 12 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2129 13 , , , 42759 2129 14 this this DT 42759 2129 15 position position NN 42759 2129 16 is be VBZ 42759 2129 17 indefensible indefensible JJ 42759 2129 18 . . . 42759 2130 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 2130 2 are be VBP 42759 2130 3 asked ask VBN 42759 2130 4 to to TO 42759 2130 5 believe believe VB 42759 2130 6 that that IN 42759 2130 7 the the DT 42759 2130 8 collective collective JJ 42759 2130 9 ownership ownership NN 42759 2130 10 and and CC 42759 2130 11 operation operation NN 42759 2130 12 of of IN 42759 2130 13 the the DT 42759 2130 14 means mean NNS 42759 2130 15 of of IN 42759 2130 16 production production NN 42759 2130 17 would would MD 42759 2130 18 be be VB 42759 2130 19 more more RBR 42759 2130 20 just just RB 42759 2130 21 and and CC 42759 2130 22 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 2130 23 than than IN 42759 2130 24 the the DT 42759 2130 25 present present JJ 42759 2130 26 plan plan NN 42759 2130 27 of of IN 42759 2130 28 private private JJ 42759 2130 29 ownership ownership NN 42759 2130 30 and and CC 42759 2130 31 operation operation NN 42759 2130 32 . . . 42759 2131 1 Yet yet CC 42759 2131 2 the the DT 42759 2131 3 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2131 4 party party NN 42759 2131 5 refuses refuse VBZ 42759 2131 6 to to TO 42759 2131 7 tell tell VB 42759 2131 8 us -PRON- PRP 42759 2131 9 how how WRB 42759 2131 10 the the DT 42759 2131 11 scheme scheme NN 42759 2131 12 would would MD 42759 2131 13 bring bring VB 42759 2131 14 about about RP 42759 2131 15 these these DT 42759 2131 16 results result NNS 42759 2131 17 ; ; , 42759 2131 18 refuses refuse VBZ 42759 2131 19 to to TO 42759 2131 20 give give VB 42759 2131 21 us -PRON- PRP 42759 2131 22 , , , 42759 2131 23 even even RB 42759 2131 24 in in IN 42759 2131 25 outline outline NN 42759 2131 26 , , , 42759 2131 27 a a DT 42759 2131 28 picture picture NN 42759 2131 29 of of IN 42759 2131 30 the the DT 42759 2131 31 machine machine NN 42759 2131 32 at at IN 42759 2131 33 work work NN 42759 2131 34 . . . 42759 2132 1 As as IN 42759 2132 2 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 2132 3 might may MD 42759 2132 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2132 5 be be VB 42759 2132 6 expected expect VBN 42759 2132 7 to to TO 42759 2132 8 turn turn VB 42759 2132 9 the the DT 42759 2132 10 direction direction NN 42759 2132 11 of of IN 42759 2132 12 industry industry NN 42759 2132 13 over over IN 42759 2132 14 to to IN 42759 2132 15 a a DT 42759 2132 16 Rockefeller Rockefeller NNP 42759 2132 17 or or CC 42759 2132 18 a a DT 42759 2132 19 Morgan Morgan NNP 42759 2132 20 , , , 42759 2132 21 making make VBG 42759 2132 22 an an DT 42759 2132 23 act act NN 42759 2132 24 of of IN 42759 2132 25 faith faith NN 42759 2132 26 in in IN 42759 2132 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2132 28 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 2132 29 and and CC 42759 2132 30 fairness fairness NN 42759 2132 31 . . . 42759 2133 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 2133 2 are be VBP 42759 2133 3 in in IN 42759 2133 4 the the DT 42759 2133 5 position position NN 42759 2133 6 of of IN 42759 2133 7 a a DT 42759 2133 8 man man NN 42759 2133 9 who who WP 42759 2133 10 should should MD 42759 2133 11 be be VB 42759 2133 12 advised advise VBN 42759 2133 13 to to TO 42759 2133 14 demolish demolish VB 42759 2133 15 an an DT 42759 2133 16 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 42759 2133 17 house house NN 42759 2133 18 , , , 42759 2133 19 without without IN 42759 2133 20 receiving receive VBG 42759 2133 21 any any DT 42759 2133 22 solid solid JJ 42759 2133 23 assurance assurance NN 42759 2133 24 that that IN 42759 2133 25 the the DT 42759 2133 26 proposed propose VBN 42759 2133 27 new new JJ 42759 2133 28 one one PRP 42759 2133 29 would would MD 42759 2133 30 be be VB 42759 2133 31 as as RB 42759 2133 32 good good JJ 42759 2133 33 . . . 42759 2134 1 To to IN 42759 2134 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2134 3 requests request NNS 42759 2134 4 for for IN 42759 2134 5 specific specific JJ 42759 2134 6 information information NN 42759 2134 7 about about IN 42759 2134 8 the the DT 42759 2134 9 working working NN 42759 2134 10 of of IN 42759 2134 11 the the DT 42759 2134 12 new new JJ 42759 2134 13 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2134 14 order order NN 42759 2134 15 the the DT 42759 2134 16 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2134 17 , , , 42759 2134 18 as as IN 42759 2134 19 a a DT 42759 2134 20 rule rule NN 42759 2134 21 , , , 42759 2134 22 answer answer VB 42759 2134 23 in in IN 42759 2134 24 terms term NNS 42759 2134 25 of of IN 42759 2134 26 prophesied prophesy VBN 42759 2134 27 results result NNS 42759 2134 28 . . . 42759 2135 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2135 2 leave leave VBP 42759 2135 3 us -PRON- PRP 42759 2135 4 in in IN 42759 2135 5 the the DT 42759 2135 6 dark dark NN 42759 2135 7 concerning concern VBG 42759 2135 8 the the DT 42759 2135 9 causes cause NNS 42759 2135 10 by by IN 42759 2135 11 which which WDT 42759 2135 12 these these DT 42759 2135 13 wonderful wonderful JJ 42759 2135 14 results result NNS 42759 2135 15 are be VBP 42759 2135 16 to to TO 42759 2135 17 be be VB 42759 2135 18 produced produce VBN 42759 2135 19 . . . 42759 2136 1 From from IN 42759 2136 2 the the DT 42759 2136 3 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 2136 4 of of IN 42759 2136 5 the the DT 42759 2136 6 confirmed confirm VBN 42759 2136 7 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 2136 8 , , , 42759 2136 9 however however RB 42759 2136 10 , , , 42759 2136 11 this this DT 42759 2136 12 failure failure NN 42759 2136 13 to to TO 42759 2136 14 be be VB 42759 2136 15 specific specific JJ 42759 2136 16 is be VBZ 42759 2136 17 not not RB 42759 2136 18 at at RB 42759 2136 19 all all RB 42759 2136 20 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 2136 21 . . . 42759 2137 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2137 2 can can MD 42759 2137 3 have have VB 42759 2137 4 faith faith NN 42759 2137 5 in in IN 42759 2137 6 the the DT 42759 2137 7 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2137 8 system system NN 42759 2137 9 without without IN 42759 2137 10 knowing know VBG 42759 2137 11 beforehand beforehand RB 42759 2137 12 how how WRB 42759 2137 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2137 14 will will MD 42759 2137 15 work work VB 42759 2137 16 . . . 42759 2138 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2138 2 believes believe VBZ 42759 2138 3 in in IN 42759 2138 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2138 5 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 2138 6 because because IN 42759 2138 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2138 8 believes believe VBZ 42759 2138 9 that that IN 42759 2138 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2138 11 is be VBZ 42759 2138 12 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 2138 13 . . . 42759 2139 1 In in IN 42759 2139 2 the the DT 42759 2139 3 words word NNS 42759 2139 4 of of IN 42759 2139 5 Kautsky Kautsky NNP 42759 2139 6 , , , 42759 2139 7 " " '' 42759 2139 8 what what WP 42759 2139 9 is be VBZ 42759 2139 10 proved prove VBN 42759 2139 11 to to TO 42759 2139 12 be be VB 42759 2139 13 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 2139 14 is be VBZ 42759 2139 15 proved prove VBN 42759 2139 16 not not RB 42759 2139 17 only only RB 42759 2139 18 to to TO 42759 2139 19 be be VB 42759 2139 20 possible possible JJ 42759 2139 21 , , , 42759 2139 22 but but CC 42759 2139 23 to to TO 42759 2139 24 be be VB 42759 2139 25 the the DT 42759 2139 26 only only JJ 42759 2139 27 possible possible JJ 42759 2139 28 outcome outcome NN 42759 2139 29 . . . 42759 2140 1 " " `` 42759 2140 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2140 3 122 122 CD 42759 2140 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2140 5 The the DT 42759 2140 6 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 2140 7 believes believe VBZ 42759 2140 8 that that IN 42759 2140 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2140 10 scheme scheme NN 42759 2140 11 is be VBZ 42759 2140 12 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 2140 13 because because IN 42759 2140 14 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2140 15 thinks think VBZ 42759 2140 16 that that IN 42759 2140 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2140 18 is be VBZ 42759 2140 19 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 2140 20 included include VBN 42759 2140 21 in in IN 42759 2140 22 the the DT 42759 2140 23 outcome outcome NN 42759 2140 24 of of IN 42759 2140 25 economic economic JJ 42759 2140 26 and and CC 42759 2140 27 social social JJ 42759 2140 28 evolution evolution NN 42759 2140 29 . . . 42759 2141 1 Neither neither CC 42759 2141 2 the the DT 42759 2141 3 premises premise NNS 42759 2141 4 nor nor CC 42759 2141 5 the the DT 42759 2141 6 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 2141 7 of of IN 42759 2141 8 this this DT 42759 2141 9 reasoning reasoning NN 42759 2141 10 is be VBZ 42759 2141 11 valid valid JJ 42759 2141 12 . . . 42759 2142 1 The the DT 42759 2142 2 doctrines doctrine NNS 42759 2142 3 of of IN 42759 2142 4 economic economic JJ 42759 2142 5 determinism determinism NN 42759 2142 6 , , , 42759 2142 7 the the DT 42759 2142 8 class class NN 42759 2142 9 struggle struggle NN 42759 2142 10 , , , 42759 2142 11 the the DT 42759 2142 12 concentration concentration NN 42759 2142 13 of of IN 42759 2142 14 capital capital NN 42759 2142 15 , , , 42759 2142 16 the the DT 42759 2142 17 disappearance disappearance NN 42759 2142 18 of of IN 42759 2142 19 the the DT 42759 2142 20 middle middle JJ 42759 2142 21 classes class NNS 42759 2142 22 , , , 42759 2142 23 the the DT 42759 2142 24 progressive progressive JJ 42759 2142 25 pauperisation pauperisation NN 42759 2142 26 of of IN 42759 2142 27 the the DT 42759 2142 28 working work VBG 42759 2142 29 classes class NNS 42759 2142 30 , , , 42759 2142 31 and and CC 42759 2142 32 all all PDT 42759 2142 33 the the DT 42759 2142 34 other other JJ 42759 2142 35 tenets tenet NNS 42759 2142 36 of of IN 42759 2142 37 the the DT 42759 2142 38 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2142 39 philosophy philosophy NN 42759 2142 40 , , , 42759 2142 41 have have VBP 42759 2142 42 been be VBN 42759 2142 43 thoroughly thoroughly RB 42759 2142 44 discredited discredit VBN 42759 2142 45 by by IN 42759 2142 46 the the DT 42759 2142 47 facts fact NNS 42759 2142 48 of of IN 42759 2142 49 psychology psychology NN 42759 2142 50 , , , 42759 2142 51 the the DT 42759 2142 52 experience experience NN 42759 2142 53 of of IN 42759 2142 54 the the DT 42759 2142 55 last last JJ 42759 2142 56 half half JJ 42759 2142 57 century century NN 42759 2142 58 , , , 42759 2142 59 and and CC 42759 2142 60 the the DT 42759 2142 61 present present JJ 42759 2142 62 trend trend NN 42759 2142 63 of of IN 42759 2142 64 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2142 65 and and CC 42759 2142 66 social social JJ 42759 2142 67 forces force NNS 42759 2142 68 . . . 42759 2143 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2143 2 123 123 CD 42759 2143 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2143 4 Even even RB 42759 2143 5 if if IN 42759 2143 6 the the DT 42759 2143 7 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2143 8 outcome outcome NN 42759 2143 9 were be VBD 42759 2143 10 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 2143 11 , , , 42759 2143 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2143 13 would would MD 42759 2143 14 not not RB 42759 2143 15 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 2143 16 be be VB 42759 2143 17 an an DT 42759 2143 18 improvement improvement NN 42759 2143 19 on on IN 42759 2143 20 the the DT 42759 2143 21 present present JJ 42759 2143 22 system system NN 42759 2143 23 . . . 42759 2144 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2144 2 might may MD 42759 2144 3 illustrate illustrate VB 42759 2144 4 the the DT 42759 2144 5 principle principle NN 42759 2144 6 of of IN 42759 2144 7 retrogression retrogression NN 42759 2144 8 . . . 42759 2145 1 Since since IN 42759 2145 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2145 3 can can MD 42759 2145 4 not not RB 42759 2145 5 make make VB 42759 2145 6 an an DT 42759 2145 7 act act NN 42759 2145 8 of of IN 42759 2145 9 faith faith NN 42759 2145 10 in in IN 42759 2145 11 either either CC 42759 2145 12 the the DT 42759 2145 13 inevitableness inevitableness NN 42759 2145 14 or or CC 42759 2145 15 the the DT 42759 2145 16 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 2145 17 of of IN 42759 2145 18 the the DT 42759 2145 19 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2145 20 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2145 21 scheme scheme NN 42759 2145 22 , , , 42759 2145 23 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2145 24 are be VBP 42759 2145 25 compelled compel VBN 42759 2145 26 to to TO 42759 2145 27 submit submit VB 42759 2145 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2145 29 to to IN 42759 2145 30 the the DT 42759 2145 31 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 2145 32 tests test NNS 42759 2145 33 of of IN 42759 2145 34 examination examination NN 42759 2145 35 and and CC 42759 2145 36 criticism criticism NN 42759 2145 37 . . . 42759 2146 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 2146 2 must must MD 42759 2146 3 try try VB 42759 2146 4 to to TO 42759 2146 5 see see VB 42759 2146 6 what what WP 42759 2146 7 would would MD 42759 2146 8 be be VB 42759 2146 9 the the DT 42759 2146 10 essential essential JJ 42759 2146 11 structure structure NN 42759 2146 12 , , , 42759 2146 13 elements element NNS 42759 2146 14 , , , 42759 2146 15 and and CC 42759 2146 16 operation operation NN 42759 2146 17 of of IN 42759 2146 18 a a DT 42759 2146 19 system system NN 42759 2146 20 in in IN 42759 2146 21 which which WDT 42759 2146 22 the the DT 42759 2146 23 means mean NNS 42759 2146 24 of of IN 42759 2146 25 production production NN 42759 2146 26 were be VBD 42759 2146 27 owned own VBN 42759 2146 28 and and CC 42759 2146 29 managed manage VBN 42759 2146 30 collectively collectively RB 42759 2146 31 , , , 42759 2146 32 and and CC 42759 2146 33 the the DT 42759 2146 34 product product NN 42759 2146 35 socially socially RB 42759 2146 36 distributed distribute VBN 42759 2146 37 . . . 42759 2147 1 In in IN 42759 2147 2 attempting attempt VBG 42759 2147 3 to to TO 42759 2147 4 describe describe VB 42759 2147 5 the the DT 42759 2147 6 system system NN 42759 2147 7 , , , 42759 2147 8 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2147 9 shall shall MD 42759 2147 10 be be VB 42759 2147 11 guided guide VBN 42759 2147 12 by by IN 42759 2147 13 what what WP 42759 2147 14 seems seem VBZ 42759 2147 15 to to TO 42759 2147 16 be be VB 42759 2147 17 inherently inherently RB 42759 2147 18 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2147 19 to to IN 42759 2147 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2147 21 , , , 42759 2147 22 and and CC 42759 2147 23 by by IN 42759 2147 24 the the DT 42759 2147 25 prevalent prevalent JJ 42759 2147 26 conception conception NN 42759 2147 27 of of IN 42759 2147 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2147 29 among among IN 42759 2147 30 present present JJ 42759 2147 31 day day NN 42759 2147 32 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2147 33 . . . 42759 2148 1 In in IN 42759 2148 2 this this DT 42759 2148 3 connection connection NN 42759 2148 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2148 5 have have VBP 42759 2148 6 to to TO 42759 2148 7 observe observe VB 42759 2148 8 that that IN 42759 2148 9 some some DT 42759 2148 10 of of IN 42759 2148 11 the the DT 42759 2148 12 criticisms criticism NNS 42759 2148 13 of of IN 42759 2148 14 the the DT 42759 2148 15 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2148 16 order order NN 42759 2148 17 attribute attribute NN 42759 2148 18 to to IN 42759 2148 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2148 20 elements element VBZ 42759 2148 21 that that WDT 42759 2148 22 are be VBP 42759 2148 23 not not RB 42759 2148 24 essential essential JJ 42759 2148 25 , , , 42759 2148 26 nor nor CC 42759 2148 27 any any DT 42759 2148 28 longer long RBR 42759 2148 29 demanded demand VBN 42759 2148 30 by by IN 42759 2148 31 the the DT 42759 2148 32 authoritative authoritative JJ 42759 2148 33 spokesmen spokesman NNS 42759 2148 34 of of IN 42759 2148 35 the the DT 42759 2148 36 movement movement NN 42759 2148 37 ; ; : 42759 2148 38 for for IN 42759 2148 39 example example NN 42759 2148 40 , , , 42759 2148 41 complete complete JJ 42759 2148 42 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 2148 43 of of IN 42759 2148 44 capital capital NN 42759 2148 45 , , , 42759 2148 46 compulsory compulsory JJ 42759 2148 47 assignment assignment NN 42759 2148 48 of of IN 42759 2148 49 men man NNS 42759 2148 50 to to IN 42759 2148 51 the the DT 42759 2148 52 different different JJ 42759 2148 53 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2148 54 tasks task NNS 42759 2148 55 , , , 42759 2148 56 equality equality NN 42759 2148 57 of of IN 42759 2148 58 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 2148 59 , , , 42759 2148 60 the the DT 42759 2148 61 use use NN 42759 2148 62 of of IN 42759 2148 63 labour labour JJ 42759 2148 64 checks check NNS 42759 2148 65 instead instead RB 42759 2148 66 of of IN 42759 2148 67 money money NN 42759 2148 68 , , , 42759 2148 69 the the DT 42759 2148 70 socialisation socialisation NN 42759 2148 71 of of IN 42759 2148 72 all all DT 42759 2148 73 capital capital NN 42759 2148 74 down down RB 42759 2148 75 to to IN 42759 2148 76 the the DT 42759 2148 77 smallest small JJS 42759 2148 78 tool tool NN 42759 2148 79 , , , 42759 2148 80 and and CC 42759 2148 81 collective collective JJ 42759 2148 82 ownership ownership NN 42759 2148 83 of of IN 42759 2148 84 homes home NNS 42759 2148 85 . . . 42759 2149 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2149 2 Expropriating expropriate VBG 42759 2149 3 the the DT 42759 2149 4 Capitalists Capitalists NNPS 42759 2149 5 _ _ IN 42759 2149 6 The the DT 42759 2149 7 first first JJ 42759 2149 8 problem problem NN 42759 2149 9 confronting confront VBG 42759 2149 10 a a DT 42759 2149 11 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2149 12 administration administration NN 42759 2149 13 would would MD 42759 2149 14 be be VB 42759 2149 15 the the DT 42759 2149 16 method method NN 42759 2149 17 of of IN 42759 2149 18 getting get VBG 42759 2149 19 possession possession NN 42759 2149 20 of of IN 42759 2149 21 the the DT 42759 2149 22 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2149 23 of of IN 42759 2149 24 production production NN 42759 2149 25 . . . 42759 2150 1 In in IN 42759 2150 2 the the DT 42759 2150 3 early early JJ 42759 2150 4 years year NNS 42759 2150 5 of of IN 42759 2150 6 the the DT 42759 2150 7 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2150 8 movement movement NN 42759 2150 9 , , , 42759 2150 10 most most JJS 42759 2150 11 of of IN 42759 2150 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2150 13 adherents adherent NNS 42759 2150 14 seemed seem VBD 42759 2150 15 to to TO 42759 2150 16 favour favour VB 42759 2150 17 a a DT 42759 2150 18 policy policy NN 42759 2150 19 of of IN 42759 2150 20 outright outright JJ 42759 2150 21 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 2150 22 . . . 42759 2151 1 Professor Professor NNP 42759 2151 2 Nearing Nearing NNP 42759 2151 3 estimates estimate VBZ 42759 2151 4 the the DT 42759 2151 5 total total JJ 42759 2151 6 property property NN 42759 2151 7 income income NN 42759 2151 8 now now RB 42759 2151 9 paid pay VBN 42759 2151 10 in in IN 42759 2151 11 the the DT 42759 2151 12 United United NNP 42759 2151 13 States States NNP 42759 2151 14 as as IN 42759 2151 15 , , , 42759 2151 16 " " `` 42759 2151 17 well well RB 42759 2151 18 above above IN 42759 2151 19 the the DT 42759 2151 20 six six CD 42759 2151 21 - - HYPH 42759 2151 22 billion billion CD 42759 2151 23 - - HYPH 42759 2151 24 dollar dollar NN 42759 2151 25 mark mark NN 42759 2151 26 . . . 42759 2152 1 " " `` 42759 2152 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2152 3 124 124 CD 42759 2152 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2152 5 Were be VBD 42759 2152 6 the the DT 42759 2152 7 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 2152 8 State State NNP 42759 2152 9 to to TO 42759 2152 10 seize seize VB 42759 2152 11 all all DT 42759 2152 12 land land NN 42759 2152 13 and and CC 42759 2152 14 capital capital NN 42759 2152 15 without without IN 42759 2152 16 compensation compensation NN 42759 2152 17 , , , 42759 2152 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2152 19 could could MD 42759 2152 20 conceivably conceivably RB 42759 2152 21 transfer transfer VB 42759 2152 22 more more JJR 42759 2152 23 than than IN 42759 2152 24 six six CD 42759 2152 25 billion billion CD 42759 2152 26 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2152 27 annually annually RB 42759 2152 28 from from IN 42759 2152 29 landowners landowner NNS 42759 2152 30 and and CC 42759 2152 31 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 2152 32 to to IN 42759 2152 33 the the DT 42759 2152 34 community community NN 42759 2152 35 . . . 42759 2153 1 Not not RB 42759 2153 2 all all DT 42759 2153 3 of of IN 42759 2153 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2153 5 , , , 42759 2153 6 however however RB 42759 2153 7 , , , 42759 2153 8 would would MD 42759 2153 9 be be VB 42759 2153 10 available available JJ 42759 2153 11 for for IN 42759 2153 12 diversion diversion NN 42759 2153 13 to to IN 42759 2153 14 the the DT 42759 2153 15 labourers labourer NNS 42759 2153 16 . . . 42759 2154 1 According accord VBG 42759 2154 2 to to IN 42759 2154 3 the the DT 42759 2154 4 computations computation NNS 42759 2154 5 of of IN 42759 2154 6 Professor Professor NNP 42759 2154 7 King King NNP 42759 2154 8 , , , 42759 2154 9 about about RB 42759 2154 10 two two CD 42759 2154 11 billion billion CD 42759 2154 12 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2154 13 were be VBD 42759 2154 14 in in IN 42759 2154 15 1910 1910 CD 42759 2154 16 saved save VBD 42759 2154 17 and and CC 42759 2154 18 converted convert VBN 42759 2154 19 into into IN 42759 2154 20 capital capital NN 42759 2154 21 . . . 42759 2155 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2155 2 125 125 CD 42759 2155 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2155 4 A a DT 42759 2155 5 progressive progressive JJ 42759 2155 6 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2155 7 régime régime NN 42759 2155 8 would would MD 42759 2155 9 want want VB 42759 2155 10 to to TO 42759 2155 11 appropriate appropriate VB 42759 2155 12 at at IN 42759 2155 13 least least JJS 42759 2155 14 that that DT 42759 2155 15 sum sum NN 42759 2155 16 for for IN 42759 2155 17 the the DT 42759 2155 18 renewal renewal NN 42759 2155 19 and and CC 42759 2155 20 increase increase NN 42759 2155 21 of of IN 42759 2155 22 the the DT 42759 2155 23 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2155 24 of of IN 42759 2155 25 production production NN 42759 2155 26 . . . 42759 2156 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 2156 2 , , , 42759 2156 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2156 4 would would MD 42759 2156 5 have have VB 42759 2156 6 only only RB 42759 2156 7 four four CD 42759 2156 8 billion billion CD 42759 2156 9 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2156 10 to to TO 42759 2156 11 add add VB 42759 2156 12 to to IN 42759 2156 13 the the DT 42759 2156 14 present present JJ 42759 2156 15 total total JJ 42759 2156 16 income income NN 42759 2156 17 of of IN 42759 2156 18 labour labour NN 42759 2156 19 . . . 42759 2157 1 This this DT 42759 2157 2 would would MD 42759 2157 3 be be VB 42759 2157 4 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 2157 5 to to IN 42759 2157 6 $ $ $ 42759 2157 7 43.50 43.50 CD 42759 2157 8 for for IN 42759 2157 9 every every DT 42759 2157 10 person person NN 42759 2157 11 in in IN 42759 2157 12 the the DT 42759 2157 13 United United NNP 42759 2157 14 States States NNP 42759 2157 15 . . . 42759 2158 1 Desirable desirable JJ 42759 2158 2 as as IN 42759 2158 3 would would MD 42759 2158 4 be be VB 42759 2158 5 such such PDT 42759 2158 6 an an DT 42759 2158 7 addition addition NN 42759 2158 8 to to IN 42759 2158 9 the the DT 42759 2158 10 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 2158 11 of of IN 42759 2158 12 labour labour NN 42759 2158 13 , , , 42759 2158 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2158 15 could could MD 42759 2158 16 never never RB 42759 2158 17 be be VB 42759 2158 18 realised realise VBN 42759 2158 19 through through IN 42759 2158 20 the the DT 42759 2158 21 process process NN 42759 2158 22 of of IN 42759 2158 23 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 2158 24 . . . 42759 2159 1 The the DT 42759 2159 2 owners owner NNS 42759 2159 3 of of IN 42759 2159 4 land land NN 42759 2159 5 and and CC 42759 2159 6 capital capital NN 42759 2159 7 would would MD 42759 2159 8 be be VB 42759 2159 9 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 2159 10 powerful powerful JJ 42759 2159 11 to to TO 42759 2159 12 defeat defeat VB 42759 2159 13 any any DT 42759 2159 14 such such JJ 42759 2159 15 simple simple JJ 42759 2159 16 scheme scheme NN 42759 2159 17 of of IN 42759 2159 18 setting set VBG 42759 2159 19 up up RP 42759 2159 20 the the DT 42759 2159 21 collectivist collectivist NN 42759 2159 22 commonwealth commonwealth NN 42759 2159 23 . . . 42759 2160 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2160 2 constitute constitute VBP 42759 2160 3 probably probably RB 42759 2160 4 a a DT 42759 2160 5 majority majority NN 42759 2160 6 of of IN 42759 2160 7 the the DT 42759 2160 8 adults adult NNS 42759 2160 9 of of IN 42759 2160 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2160 11 population population NN 42759 2160 12 , , , 42759 2160 13 and and CC 42759 2160 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2160 15 economic economic JJ 42759 2160 16 advantages advantage NNS 42759 2160 17 would would MD 42759 2160 18 make make VB 42759 2160 19 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2160 20 much much RB 42759 2160 21 stronger strong JJR 42759 2160 22 relatively relatively RB 42759 2160 23 than than IN 42759 2160 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2160 25 numbers number NNS 42759 2160 26 . . . 42759 2161 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2161 2 126 126 CD 42759 2161 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2161 4 Ethically ethically RB 42759 2161 5 the the DT 42759 2161 6 policy policy NN 42759 2161 7 of of IN 42759 2161 8 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 2161 9 would would MD 42759 2161 10 be be VB 42759 2161 11 , , , 42759 2161 12 on on IN 42759 2161 13 the the DT 42759 2161 14 whole whole JJ 42759 2161 15 , , , 42759 2161 16 sheer sheer JJ 42759 2161 17 robbery robbery NN 42759 2161 18 . . . 42759 2162 1 To to TO 42759 2162 2 be be VB 42759 2162 3 sure sure JJ 42759 2162 4 , , , 42759 2162 5 not not RB 42759 2162 6 all all DT 42759 2162 7 owners owner NNS 42759 2162 8 of of IN 42759 2162 9 land land NN 42759 2162 10 and and CC 42759 2162 11 capital capital NN 42759 2162 12 have have VBP 42759 2162 13 a a DT 42759 2162 14 valid valid JJ 42759 2162 15 claim claim NN 42759 2162 16 to to IN 42759 2162 17 all all DT 42759 2162 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2162 19 possessions possession NNS 42759 2162 20 , , , 42759 2162 21 but but CC 42759 2162 22 practically practically RB 42759 2162 23 all all DT 42759 2162 24 of of IN 42759 2162 25 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2162 26 hold hold VBP 42759 2162 27 the the DT 42759 2162 28 greater great JJR 42759 2162 29 part part NN 42759 2162 30 of of IN 42759 2162 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2162 32 wealth wealth NN 42759 2162 33 by by IN 42759 2162 34 some some DT 42759 2162 35 kind kind NN 42759 2162 36 of of IN 42759 2162 37 just just JJ 42759 2162 38 title title NN 42759 2162 39 . . . 42759 2163 1 Much much JJ 42759 2163 2 land land NN 42759 2163 3 and and CC 42759 2163 4 capital capital NN 42759 2163 5 that that WDT 42759 2163 6 was be VBD 42759 2163 7 originally originally RB 42759 2163 8 acquired acquire VBN 42759 2163 9 by by IN 42759 2163 10 unjust unjust JJ 42759 2163 11 means mean NNS 42759 2163 12 has have VBZ 42759 2163 13 become become VBN 42759 2163 14 morally morally RB 42759 2163 15 legitimatised legitimatise VBN 42759 2163 16 by by IN 42759 2163 17 the the DT 42759 2163 18 title title NN 42759 2163 19 of of IN 42759 2163 20 prescription prescription NN 42759 2163 21 . . . 42759 2164 1 The the DT 42759 2164 2 majority majority NN 42759 2164 3 of of IN 42759 2164 4 present present JJ 42759 2164 5 day day NN 42759 2164 6 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2164 7 seem seem VBP 42759 2164 8 to to TO 42759 2164 9 advocate advocate VB 42759 2164 10 at at IN 42759 2164 11 least least JJS 42759 2164 12 partial partial JJ 42759 2164 13 compensation compensation NN 42759 2164 14 . . . 42759 2165 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2165 2 127 127 CD 42759 2165 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2165 4 But but CC 42759 2165 5 this this DT 42759 2165 6 plan plan NN 42759 2165 7 does do VBZ 42759 2165 8 not not RB 42759 2165 9 seem seem VB 42759 2165 10 to to TO 42759 2165 11 offer offer VB 42759 2165 12 any any DT 42759 2165 13 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2165 14 advantage advantage NN 42759 2165 15 over over IN 42759 2165 16 complete complete JJ 42759 2165 17 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 2165 18 . . . 42759 2166 1 As as IN 42759 2166 2 regards regard VBZ 42759 2166 3 morality morality NN 42759 2166 4 , , , 42759 2166 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2166 6 would would MD 42759 2166 7 differ differ VB 42759 2166 8 only only RB 42759 2166 9 in in IN 42759 2166 10 the the DT 42759 2166 11 degree degree NN 42759 2166 12 of of IN 42759 2166 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2166 14 injustice injustice NN 42759 2166 15 ; ; : 42759 2166 16 as as IN 42759 2166 17 regards regard VBZ 42759 2166 18 expediency expediency NN 42759 2166 19 , , , 42759 2166 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2166 21 would would MD 42759 2166 22 be be VB 42759 2166 23 at at IN 42759 2166 24 best good JJS 42759 2166 25 of of IN 42759 2166 26 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 2166 27 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 2166 28 . . . 42759 2167 1 If if IN 42759 2167 2 the the DT 42759 2167 3 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 2167 4 were be VBD 42759 2167 5 given give VBN 42759 2167 6 only only RB 42759 2167 7 a a DT 42759 2167 8 small small JJ 42759 2167 9 fraction fraction NN 42759 2167 10 of of IN 42759 2167 11 the the DT 42759 2167 12 value value NN 42759 2167 13 of of IN 42759 2167 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2167 15 holdings holding NNS 42759 2167 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2167 17 would would MD 42759 2167 18 oppose oppose VB 42759 2167 19 the the DT 42759 2167 20 change change NN 42759 2167 21 with with IN 42759 2167 22 quite quite PDT 42759 2167 23 as as RB 42759 2167 24 much much JJ 42759 2167 25 determination determination NN 42759 2167 26 as as IN 42759 2167 27 though though IN 42759 2167 28 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2167 29 were be VBD 42759 2167 30 offered offer VBN 42759 2167 31 nothing nothing NN 42759 2167 32 ; ; : 42759 2167 33 if if IN 42759 2167 34 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2167 35 were be VBD 42759 2167 36 paid pay VBN 42759 2167 37 almost almost RB 42759 2167 38 the the DT 42759 2167 39 full full JJ 42759 2167 40 value value NN 42759 2167 41 of of IN 42759 2167 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2167 43 possessions possession NNS 42759 2167 44 there there EX 42759 2167 45 would would MD 42759 2167 46 be be VB 42759 2167 47 no no DT 42759 2167 48 substantial substantial JJ 42759 2167 49 gain gain NN 42759 2167 50 to to IN 42759 2167 51 the the DT 42759 2167 52 community community NN 42759 2167 53 from from IN 42759 2167 54 the the DT 42759 2167 55 transfer transfer NN 42759 2167 56 ; ; : 42759 2167 57 if if IN 42759 2167 58 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2167 59 were be VBD 42759 2167 60 compensated compensate VBN 42759 2167 61 at at IN 42759 2167 62 a a DT 42759 2167 63 figure figure NN 42759 2167 64 somewhere somewhere RB 42759 2167 65 between between IN 42759 2167 66 these these DT 42759 2167 67 two two CD 42759 2167 68 extremes extreme NNS 42759 2167 69 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2167 70 resistance resistance NN 42759 2167 71 would would MD 42759 2167 72 still still RB 42759 2167 73 be be VB 42759 2167 74 more more RBR 42759 2167 75 costly costly JJ 42759 2167 76 to to IN 42759 2167 77 the the DT 42759 2167 78 State State NNP 42759 2167 79 than than IN 42759 2167 80 the the DT 42759 2167 81 extra extra JJ 42759 2167 82 amount amount NN 42759 2167 83 required require VBN 42759 2167 84 to to TO 42759 2167 85 make make VB 42759 2167 86 full full JJ 42759 2167 87 compensation compensation NN 42759 2167 88 . . . 42759 2168 1 Finally finally RB 42759 2168 2 , , , 42759 2168 3 if if IN 42759 2168 4 full full JJ 42759 2168 5 compensation compensation NN 42759 2168 6 were be VBD 42759 2168 7 offered offer VBN 42759 2168 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2168 9 would would MD 42759 2168 10 have have VB 42759 2168 11 to to TO 42759 2168 12 take take VB 42759 2168 13 the the DT 42759 2168 14 form form NN 42759 2168 15 of of IN 42759 2168 16 government government NN 42759 2168 17 obligations obligation NNS 42759 2168 18 , , , 42759 2168 19 securities security NNS 42759 2168 20 , , , 42759 2168 21 or or CC 42759 2168 22 bonds bond NNS 42759 2168 23 . . . 42759 2169 1 If if IN 42759 2169 2 these these DT 42759 2169 3 did do VBD 42759 2169 4 not not RB 42759 2169 5 bear bear VB 42759 2169 6 interest interest NN 42759 2169 7 the the DT 42759 2169 8 great great JJ 42759 2169 9 majority majority NN 42759 2169 10 of of IN 42759 2169 11 capital capital NN 42759 2169 12 owners owner NNS 42759 2169 13 would would MD 42759 2169 14 regard regard VB 42759 2169 15 the the DT 42759 2169 16 scheme scheme NN 42759 2169 17 as as IN 42759 2169 18 partial partial JJ 42759 2169 19 and and CC 42759 2169 20 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2169 21 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 2169 22 , , , 42759 2169 23 and and CC 42759 2169 24 would would MD 42759 2169 25 fight fight VB 42759 2169 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2169 27 with with IN 42759 2169 28 determination determination NN 42759 2169 29 and and CC 42759 2169 30 effectiveness effectiveness NN 42759 2169 31 . . . 42759 2170 1 If if IN 42759 2170 2 the the DT 42759 2170 3 State State NNP 42759 2170 4 bound bind VBD 42759 2170 5 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2170 6 to to TO 42759 2170 7 pay pay VB 42759 2170 8 interest interest NN 42759 2170 9 on on IN 42759 2170 10 the the DT 42759 2170 11 bonds bond NNS 42759 2170 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2170 13 would would MD 42759 2170 14 probably probably RB 42759 2170 15 find find VB 42759 2170 16 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2170 17 giving give VBG 42759 2170 18 the the DT 42759 2170 19 dispossessed dispossess VBN 42759 2170 20 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 2170 21 as as IN 42759 2170 22 high high JJ 42759 2170 23 a a DT 42759 2170 24 rate rate NN 42759 2170 25 of of IN 42759 2170 26 return return NN 42759 2170 27 on on IN 42759 2170 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2170 29 capital capital NN 42759 2170 30 , , , 42759 2170 31 as as IN 42759 2170 32 large large JJ 42759 2170 33 a a DT 42759 2170 34 share share NN 42759 2170 35 of of IN 42759 2170 36 the the DT 42759 2170 37 national national JJ 42759 2170 38 product product NN 42759 2170 39 , , , 42759 2170 40 as as IN 42759 2170 41 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2170 42 receive receive VBP 42759 2170 43 under under IN 42759 2170 44 the the DT 42759 2170 45 present present JJ 42759 2170 46 system system NN 42759 2170 47 . . . 42759 2171 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 2171 2 , , , 42759 2171 3 the the DT 42759 2171 4 expropriation expropriation NN 42759 2171 5 of of IN 42759 2171 6 the the DT 42759 2171 7 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 2171 8 would would MD 42759 2171 9 bring bring VB 42759 2171 10 no no DT 42759 2171 11 direct direct JJ 42759 2171 12 and and CC 42759 2171 13 pecuniary pecuniary JJ 42759 2171 14 gain gain NN 42759 2171 15 to to IN 42759 2171 16 the the DT 42759 2171 17 labouring labour VBG 42759 2171 18 classes class NNS 42759 2171 19 . . . 42759 2172 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 2172 2 , , , 42759 2172 3 the the DT 42759 2172 4 latter latter JJ 42759 2172 5 would would MD 42759 2172 6 suffer suffer VB 42759 2172 7 positive positive JJ 42759 2172 8 loss loss NN 42759 2172 9 by by IN 42759 2172 10 the the DT 42759 2172 11 change change NN 42759 2172 12 , , , 42759 2172 13 owing owe VBG 42759 2172 14 to to IN 42759 2172 15 the the DT 42759 2172 16 fact fact NN 42759 2172 17 that that IN 42759 2172 18 the the DT 42759 2172 19 State State NNP 42759 2172 20 would would MD 42759 2172 21 be be VB 42759 2172 22 required require VBN 42759 2172 23 to to TO 42759 2172 24 withdraw withdraw VB 42759 2172 25 from from IN 42759 2172 26 the the DT 42759 2172 27 national national JJ 42759 2172 28 product product NN 42759 2172 29 a a DT 42759 2172 30 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2172 31 amount amount NN 42759 2172 32 for for IN 42759 2172 33 the the DT 42759 2172 34 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 2172 35 , , , 42759 2172 36 renewal renewal NN 42759 2172 37 , , , 42759 2172 38 and and CC 42759 2172 39 expansion expansion NN 42759 2172 40 of of IN 42759 2172 41 the the DT 42759 2172 42 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2172 43 of of IN 42759 2172 44 production production NN 42759 2172 45 . . . 42759 2173 1 At at IN 42759 2173 2 present present JJ 42759 2173 3 the the DT 42759 2173 4 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 2173 5 class class NN 42759 2173 6 performs perform VBZ 42759 2173 7 the the DT 42759 2173 8 greater great JJR 42759 2173 9 part part NN 42759 2173 10 of of IN 42759 2173 11 this this DT 42759 2173 12 function function NN 42759 2173 13 through through IN 42759 2173 14 the the DT 42759 2173 15 reinvestment reinvestment NN 42759 2173 16 of of IN 42759 2173 17 the the DT 42759 2173 18 incomes income NNS 42759 2173 19 that that WDT 42759 2173 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2173 21 receives receive VBZ 42759 2173 22 in in IN 42759 2173 23 the the DT 42759 2173 24 form form NN 42759 2173 25 of of IN 42759 2173 26 interest interest NN 42759 2173 27 and and CC 42759 2173 28 rent rent NN 42759 2173 29 . . . 42759 2174 1 The the DT 42759 2174 2 average average JJ 42759 2174 3 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 2174 4 entirely entirely RB 42759 2174 5 ignores ignore VBZ 42759 2174 6 this this DT 42759 2174 7 capitalistic capitalistic JJ 42759 2174 8 service service NN 42759 2174 9 , , , 42759 2174 10 when when WRB 42759 2174 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2174 12 draws draw VBZ 42759 2174 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2174 14 pessimistic pessimistic JJ 42759 2174 15 picture picture NN 42759 2174 16 of of IN 42759 2174 17 the the DT 42759 2174 18 vast vast JJ 42759 2174 19 share share NN 42759 2174 20 of of IN 42759 2174 21 the the DT 42759 2174 22 national national JJ 42759 2174 23 product product NN 42759 2174 24 which which WDT 42759 2174 25 now now RB 42759 2174 26 goes go VBZ 42759 2174 27 to to IN 42759 2174 28 " " `` 42759 2174 29 idle idle JJ 42759 2174 30 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 2174 31 . . . 42759 2174 32 " " '' 42759 2175 1 So so RB 42759 2175 2 far far RB 42759 2175 3 as as IN 42759 2175 4 the the DT 42759 2175 5 larger large JJR 42759 2175 6 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 2175 7 incomes income NNS 42759 2175 8 are be VBP 42759 2175 9 concerned concern VBN 42759 2175 10 ; ; : 42759 2175 11 that that RB 42759 2175 12 is is RB 42759 2175 13 , , , 42759 2175 14 those those DT 42759 2175 15 in in IN 42759 2175 16 excess excess NN 42759 2175 17 of of IN 42759 2175 18 twenty twenty CD 42759 2175 19 - - HYPH 42759 2175 20 five five CD 42759 2175 21 thousand thousand CD 42759 2175 22 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2175 23 annually annually RB 42759 2175 24 , , , 42759 2175 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2175 26 is be VBZ 42759 2175 27 probable probable JJ 42759 2175 28 that that IN 42759 2175 29 the the DT 42759 2175 30 greater great JJR 42759 2175 31 part part NN 42759 2175 32 is be VBZ 42759 2175 33 not not RB 42759 2175 34 consumed consume VBN 42759 2175 35 by by IN 42759 2175 36 the the DT 42759 2175 37 receivers receiver NNS 42759 2175 38 , , , 42759 2175 39 but but CC 42759 2175 40 is be VBZ 42759 2175 41 converted convert VBN 42759 2175 42 into into IN 42759 2175 43 socially socially RB 42759 2175 44 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2175 45 capital capital NN 42759 2175 46 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2175 47 . . . 42759 2176 1 Since since IN 42759 2176 2 this this DT 42759 2176 3 would would MD 42759 2176 4 not not RB 42759 2176 5 be be VB 42759 2176 6 permitted permit VBN 42759 2176 7 in in IN 42759 2176 8 a a DT 42759 2176 9 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2176 10 order order NN 42759 2176 11 , , , 42759 2176 12 the the DT 42759 2176 13 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 2176 14 would would MD 42759 2176 15 strive strive VB 42759 2176 16 to to TO 42759 2176 17 consume consume VB 42759 2176 18 the the DT 42759 2176 19 whole whole NN 42759 2176 20 of of IN 42759 2176 21 the the DT 42759 2176 22 incomes income NNS 42759 2176 23 received receive VBN 42759 2176 24 from from IN 42759 2176 25 the the DT 42759 2176 26 public public JJ 42759 2176 27 securities security NNS 42759 2176 28 , , , 42759 2176 29 and and CC 42759 2176 30 the the DT 42759 2176 31 State State NNP 42759 2176 32 would would MD 42759 2176 33 be be VB 42759 2176 34 compelled compel VBN 42759 2176 35 to to TO 42759 2176 36 provide provide VB 42759 2176 37 the the DT 42759 2176 38 required require VBN 42759 2176 39 new new JJ 42759 2176 40 capital capital NN 42759 2176 41 out out IN 42759 2176 42 of of IN 42759 2176 43 the the DT 42759 2176 44 current current JJ 42759 2176 45 national national JJ 42759 2176 46 product product NN 42759 2176 47 . . . 42759 2177 1 In in IN 42759 2177 2 a a DT 42759 2177 3 word word NN 42759 2177 4 , , , 42759 2177 5 society society NN 42759 2177 6 would would MD 42759 2177 7 have have VB 42759 2177 8 to to TO 42759 2177 9 give give VB 42759 2177 10 the the DT 42759 2177 11 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 2177 12 as as RB 42759 2177 13 much much RB 42759 2177 14 as as IN 42759 2177 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2177 16 does do VBZ 42759 2177 17 at at IN 42759 2177 18 present present JJ 42759 2177 19 , , , 42759 2177 20 and and CC 42759 2177 21 to to TO 42759 2177 22 withhold withhold VB 42759 2177 23 from from IN 42759 2177 24 the the DT 42759 2177 25 labourers labourer NNS 42759 2177 26 for for IN 42759 2177 27 new new JJ 42759 2177 28 capital capital NN 42759 2177 29 an an DT 42759 2177 30 immense immense JJ 42759 2177 31 sum sum NN 42759 2177 32 which which WDT 42759 2177 33 is be VBZ 42759 2177 34 now now RB 42759 2177 35 furnished furnish VBN 42759 2177 36 by by IN 42759 2177 37 the the DT 42759 2177 38 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 2177 39 . . . 42759 2178 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2178 2 is be VBZ 42759 2178 3 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 2178 4 true true JJ 42759 2178 5 that that IN 42759 2178 6 the the DT 42759 2178 7 richest rich JJS 42759 2178 8 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 2178 9 would would MD 42759 2178 10 be be VB 42759 2178 11 unable unable JJ 42759 2178 12 to to TO 42759 2178 13 expend expend VB 42759 2178 14 the the DT 42759 2178 15 whole whole NN 42759 2178 16 of of IN 42759 2178 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2178 18 incomes income NNS 42759 2178 19 upon upon IN 42759 2178 20 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 2178 21 and and CC 42759 2178 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2178 23 families family NNS 42759 2178 24 . . . 42759 2179 1 If if IN 42759 2179 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2179 3 turned turn VBD 42759 2179 4 a a DT 42759 2179 5 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2179 6 part part NN 42759 2179 7 of of IN 42759 2179 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2179 9 over over RP 42759 2179 10 to to IN 42759 2179 11 the the DT 42759 2179 12 State State NNP 42759 2179 13 , , , 42759 2179 14 the the DT 42759 2179 15 surrendered surrender VBN 42759 2179 16 sum sum NN 42759 2179 17 would would MD 42759 2179 18 be be VB 42759 2179 19 available available JJ 42759 2179 20 as as IN 42759 2179 21 capital capital NN 42759 2179 22 , , , 42759 2179 23 thereby thereby RB 42759 2179 24 reducing reduce VBG 42759 2179 25 the the DT 42759 2179 26 amount amount NN 42759 2179 27 that that WDT 42759 2179 28 the the DT 42759 2179 29 State State NNP 42759 2179 30 would would MD 42759 2179 31 need need VB 42759 2179 32 to to TO 42759 2179 33 take take VB 42759 2179 34 out out IN 42759 2179 35 of of IN 42759 2179 36 the the DT 42759 2179 37 national national JJ 42759 2179 38 product product NN 42759 2179 39 for for IN 42759 2179 40 this this DT 42759 2179 41 purpose purpose NN 42759 2179 42 . . . 42759 2180 1 Were be VBD 42759 2180 2 all all PDT 42759 2180 3 those those DT 42759 2180 4 possessing possess VBG 42759 2180 5 incomes income NNS 42759 2180 6 in in IN 42759 2180 7 excess excess NN 42759 2180 8 of of IN 42759 2180 9 fifty fifty CD 42759 2180 10 thousand thousand CD 42759 2180 11 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2180 12 per per IN 42759 2180 13 family family NN 42759 2180 14 to to TO 42759 2180 15 give give VB 42759 2180 16 up up RP 42759 2180 17 all all DT 42759 2180 18 above above IN 42759 2180 19 that that DT 42759 2180 20 amount amount NN 42759 2180 21 , , , 42759 2180 22 the the DT 42759 2180 23 total total NN 42759 2180 24 thus thus RB 42759 2180 25 accruing accrue VBG 42759 2180 26 to to IN 42759 2180 27 the the DT 42759 2180 28 State State NNP 42759 2180 29 would would MD 42759 2180 30 be be VB 42759 2180 31 a a DT 42759 2180 32 little little JJ 42759 2180 33 more more JJR 42759 2180 34 than than IN 42759 2180 35 one one CD 42759 2180 36 billion billion CD 42759 2180 37 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2180 38 . . . 42759 2181 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2181 2 128 128 CD 42759 2181 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2181 4 But but CC 42759 2181 5 this this DT 42759 2181 6 would would MD 42759 2181 7 be be VB 42759 2181 8 only only RB 42759 2181 9 one one CD 42759 2181 10 - - HYPH 42759 2181 11 half half NN 42759 2181 12 the the DT 42759 2181 13 required require VBN 42759 2181 14 new new JJ 42759 2181 15 capital capital NN 42759 2181 16 . . . 42759 2182 1 A a DT 42759 2182 2 part part NN 42759 2182 3 of of IN 42759 2182 4 the the DT 42759 2182 5 additional additional JJ 42759 2182 6 one one CD 42759 2182 7 billion billion CD 42759 2182 8 is be VBZ 42759 2182 9 now now RB 42759 2182 10 provided provide VBN 42759 2182 11 out out IN 42759 2182 12 of of IN 42759 2182 13 wages wage NNS 42759 2182 14 and and CC 42759 2182 15 salaries salary NNS 42759 2182 16 , , , 42759 2182 17 but but CC 42759 2182 18 the the DT 42759 2182 19 greater great JJR 42759 2182 20 part part NN 42759 2182 21 probably probably RB 42759 2182 22 comes come VBZ 42759 2182 23 out out IN 42759 2182 24 of of IN 42759 2182 25 rent rent NN 42759 2182 26 and and CC 42759 2182 27 interest interest NN 42759 2182 28 . . . 42759 2183 1 Under under IN 42759 2183 2 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2183 3 this this DT 42759 2183 4 latter latter JJ 42759 2183 5 portion portion NN 42759 2183 6 would would MD 42759 2183 7 have have VB 42759 2183 8 to to TO 42759 2183 9 be be VB 42759 2183 10 deducted deduct VBN 42759 2183 11 from from IN 42759 2183 12 that that DT 42759 2183 13 part part NN 42759 2183 14 of of IN 42759 2183 15 the the DT 42759 2183 16 national national JJ 42759 2183 17 product product NN 42759 2183 18 which which WDT 42759 2183 19 at at IN 42759 2183 20 present present NN 42759 2183 21 goes go VBZ 42759 2183 22 to to IN 42759 2183 23 the the DT 42759 2183 24 workers worker NNS 42759 2183 25 and and CC 42759 2183 26 is be VBZ 42759 2183 27 consumed consume VBN 42759 2183 28 by by IN 42759 2183 29 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2183 30 . . . 42759 2184 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2184 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2184 3 would would MD 42759 2184 4 undergo undergo VB 42759 2184 5 a a DT 42759 2184 6 loss loss NN 42759 2184 7 of of IN 42759 2184 8 several several JJ 42759 2184 9 hundred hundred CD 42759 2184 10 million million CD 42759 2184 11 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2184 12 . . . 42759 2185 1 One one CD 42759 2185 2 reply reply NN 42759 2185 3 to to IN 42759 2185 4 this this DT 42759 2185 5 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 2185 6 is be VBZ 42759 2185 7 that that IN 42759 2185 8 the the DT 42759 2185 9 total total JJ 42759 2185 10 product product NN 42759 2185 11 of of IN 42759 2185 12 industry industry NN 42759 2185 13 would would MD 42759 2185 14 be be VB 42759 2185 15 much much RB 42759 2185 16 increased increase VBN 42759 2185 17 under under IN 42759 2185 18 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2185 19 . . . 42759 2186 1 Undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 2186 2 an an DT 42759 2186 3 _ _ NNP 42759 2186 4 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2186 5 _ _ NNP 42759 2186 6 organisation organisation NN 42759 2186 7 of of IN 42759 2186 8 industry industry NN 42759 2186 9 on on IN 42759 2186 10 collectivist collectivist JJ 42759 2186 11 lines line NNS 42759 2186 12 would would MD 42759 2186 13 be be VB 42759 2186 14 able able JJ 42759 2186 15 to to TO 42759 2186 16 effect effect VB 42759 2186 17 economies economy NNS 42759 2186 18 by by IN 42759 2186 19 combining combine VBG 42759 2186 20 manufacturing manufacturing NN 42759 2186 21 plants plant NNS 42759 2186 22 , , , 42759 2186 23 distributive distributive JJ 42759 2186 24 concerns concern NNS 42759 2186 25 , , , 42759 2186 26 and and CC 42759 2186 27 transportation transportation NN 42759 2186 28 systems system NNS 42759 2186 29 , , , 42759 2186 30 and and CC 42759 2186 31 by by IN 42759 2186 32 reducing reduce VBG 42759 2186 33 unemployment unemployment NN 42759 2186 34 to to IN 42759 2186 35 a a DT 42759 2186 36 minimum minimum NN 42759 2186 37 ; ; : 42759 2186 38 but but CC 42759 2186 39 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2186 40 could could MD 42759 2186 41 not not RB 42759 2186 42 possibly possibly RB 42759 2186 43 make make VB 42759 2186 44 the the DT 42759 2186 45 enormous enormous JJ 42759 2186 46 economies economy NNS 42759 2186 47 that that WDT 42759 2186 48 are be VBP 42759 2186 49 promised promise VBN 42759 2186 50 by by IN 42759 2186 51 the the DT 42759 2186 52 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2186 53 . . . 42759 2187 1 The the DT 42759 2187 2 assertion assertion NN 42759 2187 3 that that IN 42759 2187 4 under under IN 42759 2187 5 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2187 6 men man NNS 42759 2187 7 would would MD 42759 2187 8 be be VB 42759 2187 9 able able JJ 42759 2187 10 to to TO 42759 2187 11 provide provide VB 42759 2187 12 abundantly abundantly RB 42759 2187 13 for for IN 42759 2187 14 all all PDT 42759 2187 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2187 16 wants want NNS 42759 2187 17 on on IN 42759 2187 18 a a DT 42759 2187 19 basis basis NN 42759 2187 20 of of IN 42759 2187 21 a a DT 42759 2187 22 working work VBG 42759 2187 23 day day NN 42759 2187 24 of of IN 42759 2187 25 four four CD 42759 2187 26 , , , 42759 2187 27 or or CC 42759 2187 28 even even RB 42759 2187 29 two two CD 42759 2187 30 , , , 42759 2187 31 hours hour NNS 42759 2187 32 is be VBZ 42759 2187 33 seductive seductive JJ 42759 2187 34 and and CC 42759 2187 35 interesting interesting JJ 42759 2187 36 , , , 42759 2187 37 but but CC 42759 2187 38 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2187 39 has have VBZ 42759 2187 40 no no DT 42759 2187 41 support support NN 42759 2187 42 in in IN 42759 2187 43 the the DT 42759 2187 44 ascertainable ascertainable JJ 42759 2187 45 facts fact NNS 42759 2187 46 of of IN 42759 2187 47 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2187 48 resources resource NNS 42759 2187 49 . . . 42759 2188 1 Even even RB 42759 2188 2 if if IN 42759 2188 3 the the DT 42759 2188 4 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2188 5 organisation organisation NN 42759 2188 6 were be VBD 42759 2188 7 operating operate VBG 42759 2188 8 with with IN 42759 2188 9 a a DT 42759 2188 10 fair fair JJ 42759 2188 11 degree degree NN 42759 2188 12 of of IN 42759 2188 13 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 2188 14 , , , 42759 2188 15 the the DT 42759 2188 16 gains gain NNS 42759 2188 17 that that IN 42759 2188 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2188 19 could could MD 42759 2188 20 effect effect VB 42759 2188 21 over over IN 42759 2188 22 the the DT 42759 2188 23 present present JJ 42759 2188 24 system system NN 42759 2188 25 would would MD 42759 2188 26 probably probably RB 42759 2188 27 not not RB 42759 2188 28 more more JJR 42759 2188 29 than than IN 42759 2188 30 offset offset VB 42759 2188 31 the the DT 42759 2188 32 social social JJ 42759 2188 33 losses loss NNS 42759 2188 34 resulting result VBG 42759 2188 35 from from IN 42759 2188 36 increased increase VBN 42759 2188 37 consumption consumption NN 42759 2188 38 by by IN 42759 2188 39 the the DT 42759 2188 40 compensated compensate VBN 42759 2188 41 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 2188 42 . . . 42759 2189 1 But but CC 42759 2189 2 the the DT 42759 2189 3 proposed propose VBN 42759 2189 4 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2189 5 organisation organisation NN 42759 2189 6 would would MD 42759 2189 7 not not RB 42759 2189 8 operate operate VB 42759 2189 9 with with IN 42759 2189 10 a a DT 42759 2189 11 fair fair JJ 42759 2189 12 degree degree NN 42759 2189 13 of of IN 42759 2189 14 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 2189 15 . . . 42759 2190 1 According accord VBG 42759 2190 2 to to IN 42759 2190 3 present present JJ 42759 2190 4 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2190 5 thought thought NN 42759 2190 6 , , , 42759 2190 7 industries industry NNS 42759 2190 8 that that WDT 42759 2190 9 are be VBP 42759 2190 10 national national JJ 42759 2190 11 in in IN 42759 2190 12 scope scope NN 42759 2190 13 , , , 42759 2190 14 such such JJ 42759 2190 15 as as IN 42759 2190 16 the the DT 42759 2190 17 manufacture manufacture NN 42759 2190 18 of of IN 42759 2190 19 petroleum petroleum NN 42759 2190 20 , , , 42759 2190 21 steel steel NN 42759 2190 22 , , , 42759 2190 23 and and CC 42759 2190 24 tobacco tobacco NN 42759 2190 25 , , , 42759 2190 26 would would MD 42759 2190 27 be be VB 42759 2190 28 carried carry VBN 42759 2190 29 on on RP 42759 2190 30 under under IN 42759 2190 31 national national JJ 42759 2190 32 direction direction NN 42759 2190 33 , , , 42759 2190 34 while while IN 42759 2190 35 those those DT 42759 2190 36 that that WDT 42759 2190 37 supplied supply VBD 42759 2190 38 only only RB 42759 2190 39 a a DT 42759 2190 40 local local JJ 42759 2190 41 market market NN 42759 2190 42 , , , 42759 2190 43 such such JJ 42759 2190 44 as as IN 42759 2190 45 laundries laundry NNS 42759 2190 46 , , , 42759 2190 47 bakeries bakery NNS 42759 2190 48 , , , 42759 2190 49 and and CC 42759 2190 50 retail retail JJ 42759 2190 51 stores store NNS 42759 2190 52 , , , 42759 2190 53 would would MD 42759 2190 54 be be VB 42759 2190 55 managed manage VBN 42759 2190 56 by by IN 42759 2190 57 the the DT 42759 2190 58 municipalities municipality NNS 42759 2190 59 . . . 42759 2191 1 This this DT 42759 2191 2 division division NN 42759 2191 3 of of IN 42759 2191 4 control control NN 42759 2191 5 would would MD 42759 2191 6 be be VB 42759 2191 7 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 2191 8 wise wise JJ 42759 2191 9 and and CC 42759 2191 10 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2191 11 . . . 42759 2192 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 2192 2 , , , 42759 2192 3 the the DT 42759 2192 4 majority majority NN 42759 2192 5 of of IN 42759 2192 6 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2192 7 no no RB 42759 2192 8 longer long RBR 42759 2192 9 demand demand VBP 42759 2192 10 that that IN 42759 2192 11 _ _ NNP 42759 2192 12 all all DT 42759 2192 13 _ _ NNP 42759 2192 14 tools tool NNS 42759 2192 15 and and CC 42759 2192 16 all all DT 42759 2192 17 industries industry NNS 42759 2192 18 should should MD 42759 2192 19 be be VB 42759 2192 20 brought bring VBN 42759 2192 21 under under IN 42759 2192 22 collective collective JJ 42759 2192 23 or or CC 42759 2192 24 governmental governmental JJ 42759 2192 25 direction direction NN 42759 2192 26 . . . 42759 2193 1 Very very RB 42759 2193 2 small small JJ 42759 2193 3 concerns concern NNS 42759 2193 4 which which WDT 42759 2193 5 employed employ VBD 42759 2193 6 no no DT 42759 2193 7 hired hire VBN 42759 2193 8 labour labour NN 42759 2193 9 , , , 42759 2193 10 or or CC 42759 2193 11 at at IN 42759 2193 12 most most RBS 42759 2193 13 one one CD 42759 2193 14 or or CC 42759 2193 15 two two CD 42759 2193 16 persons person NNS 42759 2193 17 , , , 42759 2193 18 could could MD 42759 2193 19 remain remain VB 42759 2193 20 under under IN 42759 2193 21 private private JJ 42759 2193 22 ownership ownership NN 42759 2193 23 and and CC 42759 2193 24 operation operation NN 42759 2193 25 , , , 42759 2193 26 while while IN 42759 2193 27 even even RB 42759 2193 28 larger large JJR 42759 2193 29 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 2193 30 might may MD 42759 2193 31 be be VB 42759 2193 32 carried carry VBN 42759 2193 33 on on RP 42759 2193 34 by by IN 42759 2193 35 co co JJ 42759 2193 36 - - JJ 42759 2193 37 operative operative JJ 42759 2193 38 associations association NNS 42759 2193 39 . . . 42759 2194 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2194 2 129 129 CD 42759 2194 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2194 4 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2194 5 the the DT 42759 2194 6 attempt attempt NN 42759 2194 7 to to TO 42759 2194 8 organise organise VB 42759 2194 9 and and CC 42759 2194 10 operate operate VB 42759 2194 11 collectively collectively RB 42759 2194 12 the the DT 42759 2194 13 industries industry NNS 42759 2194 14 of of IN 42759 2194 15 the the DT 42759 2194 16 country country NN 42759 2194 17 , , , 42759 2194 18 even even RB 42759 2194 19 with with IN 42759 2194 20 these these DT 42759 2194 21 limitations limitation NNS 42759 2194 22 , , , 42759 2194 23 would would MD 42759 2194 24 encounter encounter VB 42759 2194 25 certain certain JJ 42759 2194 26 insuperable insuperable JJ 42759 2194 27 obstacles obstacle NNS 42759 2194 28 . . . 42759 2195 1 These these DT 42759 2195 2 will will MD 42759 2195 3 be be VB 42759 2195 4 considered consider VBN 42759 2195 5 under under IN 42759 2195 6 the the DT 42759 2195 7 general general JJ 42759 2195 8 heads head NNS 42759 2195 9 of of IN 42759 2195 10 inefficient inefficient JJ 42759 2195 11 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2195 12 leadership leadership NN 42759 2195 13 , , , 42759 2195 14 inefficient inefficient JJ 42759 2195 15 labour labour NN 42759 2195 16 , , , 42759 2195 17 and and CC 42759 2195 18 interference interference NN 42759 2195 19 with with IN 42759 2195 20 individual individual JJ 42759 2195 21 liberty liberty NN 42759 2195 22 . . . 42759 2196 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2196 2 Inefficient Inefficient NNP 42759 2196 3 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 2196 4 Leadership Leadership NNP 42759 2196 5 _ _ NNP 42759 2196 6 Under under IN 42759 2196 7 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2196 8 the the DT 42759 2196 9 boards board NNS 42759 2196 10 of of IN 42759 2196 11 directors director NNS 42759 2196 12 or or CC 42759 2196 13 commissions commission NNS 42759 2196 14 which which WDT 42759 2196 15 exercised exercise VBD 42759 2196 16 supreme supreme NNP 42759 2196 17 control control NNP 42759 2196 18 in in IN 42759 2196 19 the the DT 42759 2196 20 various various JJ 42759 2196 21 industries industry NNS 42759 2196 22 , , , 42759 2196 23 would would MD 42759 2196 24 have have VB 42759 2196 25 to to TO 42759 2196 26 be be VB 42759 2196 27 chosen choose VBN 42759 2196 28 either either CC 42759 2196 29 by by IN 42759 2196 30 the the DT 42759 2196 31 general general JJ 42759 2196 32 popular popular JJ 42759 2196 33 vote vote NN 42759 2196 34 , , , 42759 2196 35 by by IN 42759 2196 36 the the DT 42759 2196 37 government government NN 42759 2196 38 , , , 42759 2196 39 or or CC 42759 2196 40 by by IN 42759 2196 41 the the DT 42759 2196 42 workers worker NNS 42759 2196 43 in in IN 42759 2196 44 each each DT 42759 2196 45 particular particular JJ 42759 2196 46 industry industry NN 42759 2196 47 . . . 42759 2197 1 The the DT 42759 2197 2 first first JJ 42759 2197 3 method method NN 42759 2197 4 may may MD 42759 2197 5 be be VB 42759 2197 6 at at IN 42759 2197 7 once once RB 42759 2197 8 excluded exclude VBN 42759 2197 9 from from IN 42759 2197 10 consideration consideration NN 42759 2197 11 . . . 42759 2198 1 Even even RB 42759 2198 2 now now RB 42759 2198 3 the the DT 42759 2198 4 number number NN 42759 2198 5 of of IN 42759 2198 6 officials official NNS 42759 2198 7 chosen choose VBN 42759 2198 8 directly directly RB 42759 2198 9 by by IN 42759 2198 10 the the DT 42759 2198 11 people people NNS 42759 2198 12 is be VBZ 42759 2198 13 far far RB 42759 2198 14 too too RB 42759 2198 15 large large JJ 42759 2198 16 ; ; : 42759 2198 17 hence hence RB 42759 2198 18 the the DT 42759 2198 19 widespread widespread JJ 42759 2198 20 agitation agitation NN 42759 2198 21 for for IN 42759 2198 22 the the DT 42759 2198 23 " " `` 42759 2198 24 short short JJ 42759 2198 25 ballot ballot NN 42759 2198 26 . . . 42759 2198 27 " " '' 42759 2199 1 Public public JJ 42759 2199 2 opinion opinion NN 42759 2199 3 is be VBZ 42759 2199 4 coming come VBG 42759 2199 5 to to TO 42759 2199 6 realise realise VB 42759 2199 7 that that IN 42759 2199 8 the the DT 42759 2199 9 voters voter NNS 42759 2199 10 should should MD 42759 2199 11 be be VB 42759 2199 12 required require VBN 42759 2199 13 to to TO 42759 2199 14 select select VB 42759 2199 15 only only RB 42759 2199 16 a a DT 42759 2199 17 few few JJ 42759 2199 18 important important JJ 42759 2199 19 officials official NNS 42759 2199 20 , , , 42759 2199 21 whose whose WP$ 42759 2199 22 qualifications qualification NNS 42759 2199 23 should should MD 42759 2199 24 be be VB 42759 2199 25 general general JJ 42759 2199 26 rather rather RB 42759 2199 27 than than IN 42759 2199 28 technical technical JJ 42759 2199 29 , , , 42759 2199 30 and and CC 42759 2199 31 therefore therefore RB 42759 2199 32 easily easily RB 42759 2199 33 recognised recognise VBN 42759 2199 34 by by IN 42759 2199 35 the the DT 42759 2199 36 masses masse NNS 42759 2199 37 . . . 42759 2200 1 These these DT 42759 2200 2 supreme supreme JJ 42759 2200 3 functionaries functionary NNS 42759 2200 4 should should MD 42759 2200 5 have have VB 42759 2200 6 the the DT 42759 2200 7 power power NN 42759 2200 8 of of IN 42759 2200 9 filling fill VBG 42759 2200 10 all all DT 42759 2200 11 administrative administrative JJ 42759 2200 12 offices office NNS 42759 2200 13 , , , 42759 2200 14 and and CC 42759 2200 15 all all DT 42759 2200 16 positions position NNS 42759 2200 17 demanding demand VBG 42759 2200 18 expert expert NN 42759 2200 19 or or CC 42759 2200 20 technical technical JJ 42759 2200 21 ability ability NN 42759 2200 22 . . . 42759 2201 1 If if IN 42759 2201 2 the the DT 42759 2201 3 task task NN 42759 2201 4 of of IN 42759 2201 5 choosing choose VBG 42759 2201 6 administrative administrative JJ 42759 2201 7 experts expert NNS 42759 2201 8 can can MD 42759 2201 9 not not RB 42759 2201 10 be be VB 42759 2201 11 safely safely RB 42759 2201 12 left leave VBN 42759 2201 13 to to IN 42759 2201 14 the the DT 42759 2201 15 mass mass NN 42759 2201 16 of of IN 42759 2201 17 the the DT 42759 2201 18 voters voter NNS 42759 2201 19 at at IN 42759 2201 20 present present JJ 42759 2201 21 , , , 42759 2201 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2201 23 certainly certainly RB 42759 2201 24 ought ought MD 42759 2201 25 not not RB 42759 2201 26 to to TO 42759 2201 27 be be VB 42759 2201 28 assigned assign VBN 42759 2201 29 to to IN 42759 2201 30 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2201 31 under under IN 42759 2201 32 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2201 33 , , , 42759 2201 34 when when WRB 42759 2201 35 the the DT 42759 2201 36 number number NN 42759 2201 37 and and CC 42759 2201 38 qualifications qualification NNS 42759 2201 39 of of IN 42759 2201 40 these these DT 42759 2201 41 functionaries functionary NNS 42759 2201 42 would would MD 42759 2201 43 be be VB 42759 2201 44 indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 2201 45 increased increase VBN 42759 2201 46 . . . 42759 2202 1 If if IN 42759 2202 2 the the DT 42759 2202 3 boards board NNS 42759 2202 4 of of IN 42759 2202 5 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2202 6 directors director NNS 42759 2202 7 were be VBD 42759 2202 8 selected select VBN 42759 2202 9 by by IN 42759 2202 10 the the DT 42759 2202 11 government government NN 42759 2202 12 , , , 42759 2202 13 that that RB 42759 2202 14 is is RB 42759 2202 15 , , , 42759 2202 16 by by IN 42759 2202 17 the the DT 42759 2202 18 national national JJ 42759 2202 19 and and CC 42759 2202 20 municipal municipal JJ 42759 2202 21 authorities authority NNS 42759 2202 22 , , , 42759 2202 23 the the DT 42759 2202 24 result result NN 42759 2202 25 would would MD 42759 2202 26 be be VB 42759 2202 27 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2202 28 inefficiency inefficiency NN 42759 2202 29 and and CC 42759 2202 30 an an DT 42759 2202 31 intolerable intolerable JJ 42759 2202 32 bureaucracy bureaucracy NN 42759 2202 33 . . . 42759 2203 1 No no DT 42759 2203 2 body body NN 42759 2203 3 of of IN 42759 2203 4 officials official NNS 42759 2203 5 , , , 42759 2203 6 whether whether IN 42759 2203 7 legislative legislative JJ 42759 2203 8 or or CC 42759 2203 9 executive executive JJ 42759 2203 10 , , , 42759 2203 11 would would MD 42759 2203 12 possess possess VB 42759 2203 13 the the DT 42759 2203 14 varied varied JJ 42759 2203 15 , , , 42759 2203 16 extensive extensive JJ 42759 2203 17 , , , 42759 2203 18 and and CC 42759 2203 19 specific specific JJ 42759 2203 20 knowledge knowledge NN 42759 2203 21 required require VBN 42759 2203 22 to to TO 42759 2203 23 pick pick VB 42759 2203 24 out out RP 42759 2203 25 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2203 26 administrative administrative JJ 42759 2203 27 commissions commission NNS 42759 2203 28 for for IN 42759 2203 29 all all PDT 42759 2203 30 the the DT 42759 2203 31 industries industry NNS 42759 2203 32 of of IN 42759 2203 33 the the DT 42759 2203 34 country country NN 42759 2203 35 or or CC 42759 2203 36 the the DT 42759 2203 37 city city NN 42759 2203 38 . . . 42759 2204 1 And and CC 42759 2204 2 no no DT 42759 2204 3 group group NN 42759 2204 4 of of IN 42759 2204 5 political political JJ 42759 2204 6 persons person NNS 42759 2204 7 could could MD 42759 2204 8 safely safely RB 42759 2204 9 be be VB 42759 2204 10 entrusted entrust VBN 42759 2204 11 with with IN 42759 2204 12 such such JJ 42759 2204 13 tremendous tremendous JJ 42759 2204 14 power power NN 42759 2204 15 . . . 42759 2205 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2205 2 would would MD 42759 2205 3 enable enable VB 42759 2205 4 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2205 5 to to TO 42759 2205 6 dominate dominate VB 42759 2205 7 the the DT 42759 2205 8 industrial industrial NN 42759 2205 9 as as RB 42759 2205 10 well well RB 42759 2205 11 as as IN 42759 2205 12 the the DT 42759 2205 13 political political JJ 42759 2205 14 life life NN 42759 2205 15 of of IN 42759 2205 16 the the DT 42759 2205 17 nation nation NN 42759 2205 18 or or CC 42759 2205 19 the the DT 42759 2205 20 municipality municipality NN 42759 2205 21 , , , 42759 2205 22 to to TO 42759 2205 23 establish establish VB 42759 2205 24 a a DT 42759 2205 25 bureaucracy bureaucracy NN 42759 2205 26 that that WDT 42759 2205 27 would would MD 42759 2205 28 be be VB 42759 2205 29 impregnable impregnable JJ 42759 2205 30 for for IN 42759 2205 31 a a DT 42759 2205 32 long long JJ 42759 2205 33 period period NN 42759 2205 34 of of IN 42759 2205 35 years year NNS 42759 2205 36 , , , 42759 2205 37 and and CC 42759 2205 38 to to TO 42759 2205 39 revive revive VB 42759 2205 40 all all PDT 42759 2205 41 the the DT 42759 2205 42 conceivable conceivable JJ 42759 2205 43 evils evil NNS 42759 2205 44 of of IN 42759 2205 45 governmental governmental JJ 42759 2205 46 absolutism absolutism NN 42759 2205 47 . . . 42759 2206 1 The the DT 42759 2206 2 third third JJ 42759 2206 3 method method NN 42759 2206 4 is be VBZ 42759 2206 5 apparently apparently RB 42759 2206 6 the the DT 42759 2206 7 one one NN 42759 2206 8 now now RB 42759 2206 9 favoured favour VBN 42759 2206 10 by by IN 42759 2206 11 most most JJS 42759 2206 12 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2206 13 . . . 42759 2207 1 " " `` 42759 2207 2 The the DT 42759 2207 3 workers worker NNS 42759 2207 4 in in IN 42759 2207 5 each each DT 42759 2207 6 industry industry NN 42759 2207 7 may may MD 42759 2207 8 periodically periodically RB 42759 2207 9 select select VB 42759 2207 10 the the DT 42759 2207 11 managing manage VBG 42759 2207 12 authority authority NN 42759 2207 13 , , , 42759 2207 14 " " '' 42759 2207 15 says say VBZ 42759 2207 16 Morris Morris NNP 42759 2207 17 Hillquit Hillquit NNP 42759 2207 18 . . . 42759 2208 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2208 2 130 130 CD 42759 2208 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2208 4 Even even RB 42759 2208 5 if if IN 42759 2208 6 the the DT 42759 2208 7 workers worker NNS 42759 2208 8 were be VBD 42759 2208 9 as as RB 42759 2208 10 able able JJ 42759 2208 11 as as IN 42759 2208 12 the the DT 42759 2208 13 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 2208 14 of of IN 42759 2208 15 a a DT 42759 2208 16 corporation corporation NN 42759 2208 17 to to TO 42759 2208 18 select select VB 42759 2208 19 an an DT 42759 2208 20 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2208 21 governing governing NN 42759 2208 22 board board NN 42759 2208 23 , , , 42759 2208 24 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2208 25 would would MD 42759 2208 26 be be VB 42759 2208 27 much much RB 42759 2208 28 less less RBR 42759 2208 29 likely likely JJ 42759 2208 30 to to TO 42759 2208 31 choose choose VB 42759 2208 32 men man NNS 42759 2208 33 who who WP 42759 2208 34 would would MD 42759 2208 35 insist insist VB 42759 2208 36 on on IN 42759 2208 37 hard hard JJ 42759 2208 38 and and CC 42759 2208 39 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2208 40 work work NN 42759 2208 41 from from IN 42759 2208 42 all all DT 42759 2208 43 subordinates subordinate NNS 42759 2208 44 . . . 42759 2209 1 The the DT 42759 2209 2 members member NNS 42759 2209 3 of of IN 42759 2209 4 a a DT 42759 2209 5 private private JJ 42759 2209 6 corporation corporation NN 42759 2209 7 have have VBP 42759 2209 8 a a DT 42759 2209 9 strong strong JJ 42759 2209 10 pecuniary pecuniary JJ 42759 2209 11 interest interest NN 42759 2209 12 in in IN 42759 2209 13 selecting select VBG 42759 2209 14 directors director NNS 42759 2209 15 who who WP 42759 2209 16 will will MD 42759 2209 17 secure secure VB 42759 2209 18 the the DT 42759 2209 19 maximum maximum NN 42759 2209 20 of of IN 42759 2209 21 product product NN 42759 2209 22 at at IN 42759 2209 23 the the DT 42759 2209 24 minimum minimum NN 42759 2209 25 of of IN 42759 2209 26 cost cost NN 42759 2209 27 , , , 42759 2209 28 while while IN 42759 2209 29 the the DT 42759 2209 30 employés employés NN 42759 2209 31 in in IN 42759 2209 32 a a DT 42759 2209 33 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2209 34 industry industry NN 42759 2209 35 would would MD 42759 2209 36 want want VB 42759 2209 37 managing manage VBG 42759 2209 38 authorities authority NNS 42759 2209 39 who who WP 42759 2209 40 were be VBD 42759 2209 41 willing willing JJ 42759 2209 42 to to TO 42759 2209 43 make make VB 42759 2209 44 working working NN 42759 2209 45 conditions condition NNS 42759 2209 46 as as RB 42759 2209 47 easy easy RB 42759 2209 48 as as IN 42759 2209 49 possible possible JJ 42759 2209 50 . . . 42759 2210 1 The the DT 42759 2210 2 dependence dependence NN 42759 2210 3 of of IN 42759 2210 4 the the DT 42759 2210 5 boards board NNS 42759 2210 6 of of IN 42759 2210 7 directors director NNS 42759 2210 8 upon upon IN 42759 2210 9 the the DT 42759 2210 10 mass mass NN 42759 2210 11 of of IN 42759 2210 12 the the DT 42759 2210 13 workers worker NNS 42759 2210 14 , , , 42759 2210 15 and and CC 42759 2210 16 the the DT 42759 2210 17 lack lack NN 42759 2210 18 of of IN 42759 2210 19 adequate adequate JJ 42759 2210 20 pecuniary pecuniary JJ 42759 2210 21 motives motive NNS 42759 2210 22 , , , 42759 2210 23 would would MD 42759 2210 24 render render VB 42759 2210 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2210 26 management management NN 42759 2210 27 much much RB 42759 2210 28 less less RBR 42759 2210 29 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2210 30 and and CC 42759 2210 31 progressive progressive JJ 42759 2210 32 than than IN 42759 2210 33 that that DT 42759 2210 34 of of IN 42759 2210 35 private private JJ 42759 2210 36 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 2210 37 . . . 42759 2211 1 In in IN 42759 2211 2 the the DT 42759 2211 3 rules rule NNS 42759 2211 4 that that IN 42759 2211 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2211 6 would would MD 42759 2211 7 make make VB 42759 2211 8 for for IN 42759 2211 9 the the DT 42759 2211 10 administration administration NN 42759 2211 11 of of IN 42759 2211 12 the the DT 42759 2211 13 industry industry NN 42759 2211 14 and and CC 42759 2211 15 the the DT 42759 2211 16 government government NN 42759 2211 17 of of IN 42759 2211 18 the the DT 42759 2211 19 labour labour JJ 42759 2211 20 force force NN 42759 2211 21 , , , 42759 2211 22 in in IN 42759 2211 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2211 24 selection selection NN 42759 2211 25 of of IN 42759 2211 26 subordinate subordinate JJ 42759 2211 27 officers officer NNS 42759 2211 28 , , , 42759 2211 29 such such JJ 42759 2211 30 as as IN 42759 2211 31 superintendents superintendent NNS 42759 2211 32 , , , 42759 2211 33 general general JJ 42759 2211 34 managers manager NNS 42759 2211 35 , , , 42759 2211 36 and and CC 42759 2211 37 foremen foreman NNS 42759 2211 38 , , , 42759 2211 39 and and CC 42759 2211 40 in in IN 42759 2211 41 all all PDT 42759 2211 42 the the DT 42759 2211 43 other other JJ 42759 2211 44 details detail NNS 42759 2211 45 of of IN 42759 2211 46 management management NN 42759 2211 47 , , , 42759 2211 48 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2211 49 would would MD 42759 2211 50 have have VB 42759 2211 51 always always RB 42759 2211 52 before before IN 42759 2211 53 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2211 54 the the DT 42759 2211 55 abiding abide VBG 42759 2211 56 fact fact NN 42759 2211 57 that that IN 42759 2211 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2211 59 authority authority NN 42759 2211 60 was be VBD 42759 2211 61 derived derive VBN 42759 2211 62 from from IN 42759 2211 63 and and CC 42759 2211 64 dependent dependent JJ 42759 2211 65 upon upon IN 42759 2211 66 the the DT 42759 2211 67 votes vote NNS 42759 2211 68 of of IN 42759 2211 69 the the DT 42759 2211 70 majority majority NN 42759 2211 71 of of IN 42759 2211 72 the the DT 42759 2211 73 employés employés NN 42759 2211 74 . . . 42759 2212 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2212 2 supreme supreme JJ 42759 2212 3 consideration consideration NN 42759 2212 4 would would MD 42759 2212 5 be be VB 42759 2212 6 to to TO 42759 2212 7 conduct conduct VB 42759 2212 8 the the DT 42759 2212 9 industry industry NN 42759 2212 10 in in IN 42759 2212 11 such such PDT 42759 2212 12 a a DT 42759 2212 13 way way NN 42759 2212 14 as as IN 42759 2212 15 to to TO 42759 2212 16 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 2212 17 the the DT 42759 2212 18 men man NNS 42759 2212 19 who who WP 42759 2212 20 elected elect VBD 42759 2212 21 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2212 22 . . . 42759 2213 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2213 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2213 3 would would MD 42759 2213 4 strive strive VB 42759 2213 5 to to TO 42759 2213 6 maintain maintain VB 42759 2213 7 an an DT 42759 2213 8 administration administration NN 42759 2213 9 which which WDT 42759 2213 10 would would MD 42759 2213 11 permit permit VB 42759 2213 12 the the DT 42759 2213 13 mass mass NN 42759 2213 14 of of IN 42759 2213 15 the the DT 42759 2213 16 labour labour JJ 42759 2213 17 force force NN 42759 2213 18 to to TO 42759 2213 19 work work VB 42759 2213 20 leisurely leisurely RB 42759 2213 21 , , , 42759 2213 22 to to TO 42759 2213 23 be be VB 42759 2213 24 provided provide VBN 42759 2213 25 with with IN 42759 2213 26 the the DT 42759 2213 27 most most RBS 42759 2213 28 expensive expensive JJ 42759 2213 29 conditions condition NNS 42759 2213 30 of of IN 42759 2213 31 employment employment NN 42759 2213 32 , , , 42759 2213 33 and and CC 42759 2213 34 to to TO 42759 2213 35 be be VB 42759 2213 36 immune immune JJ 42759 2213 37 from from IN 42759 2213 38 discharge discharge NN 42759 2213 39 except except IN 42759 2213 40 in in IN 42759 2213 41 rare rare JJ 42759 2213 42 and and CC 42759 2213 43 flagrant flagrant JJ 42759 2213 44 cases case NNS 42759 2213 45 . . . 42759 2214 1 Even even RB 42759 2214 2 if if IN 42759 2214 3 the the DT 42759 2214 4 members member NNS 42759 2214 5 of of IN 42759 2214 6 the the DT 42759 2214 7 directing directing NN 42759 2214 8 boards board NNS 42759 2214 9 were be VBD 42759 2214 10 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 2214 11 courageous courageous JJ 42759 2214 12 or or CC 42759 2214 13 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 2214 14 conscientious conscientious JJ 42759 2214 15 to to TO 42759 2214 16 exact exact VB 42759 2214 17 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2214 18 and and CC 42759 2214 19 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2214 20 service service NN 42759 2214 21 from from IN 42759 2214 22 all all PDT 42759 2214 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2214 24 subordinates subordinate NNS 42759 2214 25 and and CC 42759 2214 26 all all PDT 42759 2214 27 the the DT 42759 2214 28 workers worker NNS 42759 2214 29 , , , 42759 2214 30 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2214 31 would would MD 42759 2214 32 not not RB 42759 2214 33 have have VB 42759 2214 34 the the DT 42759 2214 35 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2214 36 pecuniary pecuniary JJ 42759 2214 37 motives motive NNS 42759 2214 38 . . . 42759 2215 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2215 2 salaries salary NNS 42759 2215 3 would would MD 42759 2215 4 be be VB 42759 2215 5 fixed fix VBN 42759 2215 6 by by IN 42759 2215 7 the the DT 42759 2215 8 government government NN 42759 2215 9 , , , 42759 2215 10 and and CC 42759 2215 11 in in IN 42759 2215 12 the the DT 42759 2215 13 nature nature NN 42759 2215 14 of of IN 42759 2215 15 things thing NNS 42759 2215 16 could could MD 42759 2215 17 not not RB 42759 2215 18 be be VB 42759 2215 19 promptly promptly RB 42759 2215 20 adjusted adjust VBN 42759 2215 21 to to TO 42759 2215 22 reward reward VB 42759 2215 23 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2215 24 and and CC 42759 2215 25 to to TO 42759 2215 26 punish punish VB 42759 2215 27 inefficient inefficient JJ 42759 2215 28 management management NN 42759 2215 29 . . . 42759 2216 1 So so RB 42759 2216 2 long long RB 42759 2216 3 as as IN 42759 2216 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2216 5 administration administration NN 42759 2216 6 of of IN 42759 2216 7 industry industry NN 42759 2216 8 maintained maintain VBD 42759 2216 9 a a DT 42759 2216 10 certain certain JJ 42759 2216 11 routine routine JJ 42759 2216 12 level level NN 42759 2216 13 of of IN 42759 2216 14 mediocrity mediocrity NN 42759 2216 15 , , , 42759 2216 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2216 17 would would MD 42759 2216 18 have have VB 42759 2216 19 no no DT 42759 2216 20 fear fear NN 42759 2216 21 of of IN 42759 2216 22 being be VBG 42759 2216 23 removed remove VBN 42759 2216 24 ; ; : 42759 2216 25 since since IN 42759 2216 26 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2216 27 would would MD 42759 2216 28 be be VB 42759 2216 29 supervised supervise VBN 42759 2216 30 and and CC 42759 2216 31 paid pay VBN 42759 2216 32 by by IN 42759 2216 33 public public JJ 42759 2216 34 officials official NNS 42759 2216 35 who who WP 42759 2216 36 would would MD 42759 2216 37 have have VB 42759 2216 38 neither neither CC 42759 2216 39 the the DT 42759 2216 40 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 42759 2216 41 capacity capacity NN 42759 2216 42 nor nor CC 42759 2216 43 the the DT 42759 2216 44 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2216 45 incentive incentive NN 42759 2216 46 to to TO 42759 2216 47 recognise recognise VB 42759 2216 48 and and CC 42759 2216 49 reward reward VB 42759 2216 50 promptly promptly RB 42759 2216 51 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2216 52 management management NN 42759 2216 53 , , , 42759 2216 54 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2216 55 would would MD 42759 2216 56 lack lack VB 42759 2216 57 the the DT 42759 2216 58 powerful powerful JJ 42759 2216 59 stimulus stimulus NN 42759 2216 60 which which WDT 42759 2216 61 is be VBZ 42759 2216 62 provided provide VBN 42759 2216 63 by by IN 42759 2216 64 the the DT 42759 2216 65 hope hope NN 42759 2216 66 of of IN 42759 2216 67 gain gain NN 42759 2216 68 . . . 42759 2217 1 In in IN 42759 2217 2 the the DT 42759 2217 3 large large JJ 42759 2217 4 private private JJ 42759 2217 5 corporations corporation NNS 42759 2217 6 , , , 42759 2217 7 the the DT 42759 2217 8 tenure tenure NN 42759 2217 9 of of IN 42759 2217 10 the the DT 42759 2217 11 boards board NNS 42759 2217 12 of of IN 42759 2217 13 directors director NNS 42759 2217 14 depends depend VBZ 42759 2217 15 not not RB 42759 2217 16 upon upon IN 42759 2217 17 the the DT 42759 2217 18 workers worker NNS 42759 2217 19 but but CC 42759 2217 20 upon upon IN 42759 2217 21 the the DT 42759 2217 22 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 2217 23 , , , 42759 2217 24 whose whose WP$ 42759 2217 25 main main JJ 42759 2217 26 interest interest NN 42759 2217 27 is be VBZ 42759 2217 28 to to TO 42759 2217 29 obtain obtain VB 42759 2217 30 a a DT 42759 2217 31 maximum maximum NN 42759 2217 32 of of IN 42759 2217 33 product product NN 42759 2217 34 at at IN 42759 2217 35 a a DT 42759 2217 36 minimum minimum NN 42759 2217 37 of of IN 42759 2217 38 cost cost NN 42759 2217 39 , , , 42759 2217 40 and and CC 42759 2217 41 who who WP 42759 2217 42 will will MD 42759 2217 43 employ employ VB 42759 2217 44 and and CC 42759 2217 45 discharge discharge VB 42759 2217 46 , , , 42759 2217 47 reward reward NN 42759 2217 48 and and CC 42759 2217 49 punish punish NN 42759 2217 50 , , , 42759 2217 51 according accord VBG 42759 2217 52 as as IN 42759 2217 53 this this DT 42759 2217 54 end end NN 42759 2217 55 is be VBZ 42759 2217 56 attained attain VBN 42759 2217 57 . . . 42759 2218 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 2218 2 , , , 42759 2218 3 the the DT 42759 2218 4 members member NNS 42759 2218 5 of of IN 42759 2218 6 the the DT 42759 2218 7 boards board NNS 42759 2218 8 , , , 42759 2218 9 and and CC 42759 2218 10 the the DT 42759 2218 11 executive executive JJ 42759 2218 12 officers officer NNS 42759 2218 13 generally generally RB 42759 2218 14 , , , 42759 2218 15 are be VBP 42759 2218 16 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 2218 17 financially financially RB 42759 2218 18 interested interested JJ 42759 2218 19 in in IN 42759 2218 20 the the DT 42759 2218 21 business business NN 42759 2218 22 and and CC 42759 2218 23 in in IN 42759 2218 24 the the DT 42759 2218 25 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 2218 26 of of IN 42759 2218 27 the the DT 42759 2218 28 policy policy NN 42759 2218 29 demanded demand VBN 42759 2218 30 by by IN 42759 2218 31 the the DT 42759 2218 32 other other JJ 42759 2218 33 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 2218 34 . . . 42759 2219 1 All all PDT 42759 2219 2 the the DT 42759 2219 3 subordinate subordinate JJ 42759 2219 4 officers officer NNS 42759 2219 5 , , , 42759 2219 6 such such JJ 42759 2219 7 as as IN 42759 2219 8 department department NN 42759 2219 9 managers manager NNS 42759 2219 10 , , , 42759 2219 11 superintendents superintendent NNS 42759 2219 12 , , , 42759 2219 13 foremen foreman NNS 42759 2219 14 , , , 42759 2219 15 etc etc FW 42759 2219 16 . . . 42759 2219 17 , , , 42759 2219 18 would would MD 42759 2219 19 exemplify exemplify VB 42759 2219 20 the the DT 42759 2219 21 same same JJ 42759 2219 22 absence absence NN 42759 2219 23 of of IN 42759 2219 24 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 2219 25 . . . 42759 2220 1 Knowing know VBG 42759 2220 2 that that IN 42759 2220 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2220 4 must must MD 42759 2220 5 carry carry VB 42759 2220 6 out out RP 42759 2220 7 the the DT 42759 2220 8 prudent prudent JJ 42759 2220 9 policy policy NN 42759 2220 10 of of IN 42759 2220 11 the the DT 42759 2220 12 board board NN 42759 2220 13 of of IN 42759 2220 14 directors director NNS 42759 2220 15 , , , 42759 2220 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2220 17 would would MD 42759 2220 18 be be VB 42759 2220 19 slow slow JJ 42759 2220 20 to to TO 42759 2220 21 punish punish VB 42759 2220 22 shirking shirking NN 42759 2220 23 or or CC 42759 2220 24 to to TO 42759 2220 25 discharge discharge VB 42759 2220 26 incompetents incompetent NNS 42759 2220 27 . . . 42759 2221 1 Realising realise VBG 42759 2221 2 that that IN 42759 2221 3 the the DT 42759 2221 4 board board NN 42759 2221 5 of of IN 42759 2221 6 directors director NNS 42759 2221 7 lacked lack VBD 42759 2221 8 the the DT 42759 2221 9 incentive incentive NN 42759 2221 10 to to TO 42759 2221 11 make make VB 42759 2221 12 promotions promotion NNS 42759 2221 13 promptly promptly RB 42759 2221 14 for for IN 42759 2221 15 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2221 16 service service NN 42759 2221 17 , , , 42759 2221 18 or or CC 42759 2221 19 to to TO 42759 2221 20 discharge discharge VB 42759 2221 21 promptly promptly RB 42759 2221 22 for for IN 42759 2221 23 inefficient inefficient JJ 42759 2221 24 service service NN 42759 2221 25 , , , 42759 2221 26 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2221 27 would would MD 42759 2221 28 devote devote VB 42759 2221 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2221 30 main main JJ 42759 2221 31 energies energy NNS 42759 2221 32 to to IN 42759 2221 33 the the DT 42759 2221 34 task task NN 42759 2221 35 of of IN 42759 2221 36 holding hold VBG 42759 2221 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2221 38 positions position NNS 42759 2221 39 through through IN 42759 2221 40 a a DT 42759 2221 41 policy policy NN 42759 2221 42 of of IN 42759 2221 43 indifferent indifferent JJ 42759 2221 44 and and CC 42759 2221 45 routine routine JJ 42759 2221 46 administration administration NN 42759 2221 47 . . . 42759 2222 1 Invention invention NN 42759 2222 2 and and CC 42759 2222 3 progress progress NN 42759 2222 4 would would MD 42759 2222 5 likewise likewise RB 42759 2222 6 suffer suffer VB 42759 2222 7 . . . 42759 2223 1 Men man NNS 42759 2223 2 who who WP 42759 2223 3 were be VBD 42759 2223 4 capable capable JJ 42759 2223 5 of of IN 42759 2223 6 devising devise VBG 42759 2223 7 new new JJ 42759 2223 8 machines machine NNS 42759 2223 9 , , , 42759 2223 10 new new JJ 42759 2223 11 processes process NNS 42759 2223 12 , , , 42759 2223 13 new new JJ 42759 2223 14 methods method NNS 42759 2223 15 of of IN 42759 2223 16 combining combine VBG 42759 2223 17 capital capital NN 42759 2223 18 and and CC 42759 2223 19 labour labour NN 42759 2223 20 , , , 42759 2223 21 would would MD 42759 2223 22 be be VB 42759 2223 23 slow slow JJ 42759 2223 24 to to TO 42759 2223 25 convert convert VB 42759 2223 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2223 27 potencies potency NNS 42759 2223 28 into into IN 42759 2223 29 action action NN 42759 2223 30 . . . 42759 2224 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2224 2 would would MD 42759 2224 3 be be VB 42759 2224 4 painfully painfully RB 42759 2224 5 aware aware JJ 42759 2224 6 that that IN 42759 2224 7 the the DT 42759 2224 8 spirit spirit NNP 42759 2224 9 of of IN 42759 2224 10 inertia inertia NN 42759 2224 11 and and CC 42759 2224 12 routine routine JJ 42759 2224 13 prevailing prevailing NN 42759 2224 14 throughout throughout IN 42759 2224 15 the the DT 42759 2224 16 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2224 17 and and CC 42759 2224 18 political political JJ 42759 2224 19 organisation organisation NN 42759 2224 20 would would MD 42759 2224 21 prevent prevent VB 42759 2224 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2224 23 efforts effort NNS 42759 2224 24 from from IN 42759 2224 25 receiving receive VBG 42759 2224 26 quick quick JJ 42759 2224 27 recognition recognition NN 42759 2224 28 and and CC 42759 2224 29 adequate adequate JJ 42759 2224 30 rewards reward NNS 42759 2224 31 . . . 42759 2225 1 Inventors inventor NNS 42759 2225 2 of of IN 42759 2225 3 mechanical mechanical JJ 42759 2225 4 devices device NNS 42759 2225 5 particularly particularly RB 42759 2225 6 would would MD 42759 2225 7 be be VB 42759 2225 8 deprived deprive VBN 42759 2225 9 of of IN 42759 2225 10 the the DT 42759 2225 11 stimulus stimulus NN 42759 2225 12 which which WDT 42759 2225 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2225 14 now now RB 42759 2225 15 find find VBP 42759 2225 16 in in IN 42759 2225 17 the the DT 42759 2225 18 hope hope NN 42759 2225 19 of of IN 42759 2225 20 indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 2225 21 large large JJ 42759 2225 22 gains gain NNS 42759 2225 23 . . . 42759 2226 1 Boards board NNS 42759 2226 2 of of IN 42759 2226 3 directors director NNS 42759 2226 4 , , , 42759 2226 5 general general JJ 42759 2226 6 managers manager NNS 42759 2226 7 , , , 42759 2226 8 and and CC 42759 2226 9 other other JJ 42759 2226 10 persons person NNS 42759 2226 11 exercising exercise VBG 42759 2226 12 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2226 13 authority authority NN 42759 2226 14 would would MD 42759 2226 15 be be VB 42759 2226 16 very very RB 42759 2226 17 slow slow JJ 42759 2226 18 to to TO 42759 2226 19 introduce introduce VB 42759 2226 20 new new JJ 42759 2226 21 and and CC 42759 2226 22 more more RBR 42759 2226 23 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2226 24 financial financial JJ 42759 2226 25 or or CC 42759 2226 26 technical technical JJ 42759 2226 27 methods method NNS 42759 2226 28 when when WRB 42759 2226 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2226 30 had have VBD 42759 2226 31 no no DT 42759 2226 32 certainty certainty NN 42759 2226 33 that that IN 42759 2226 34 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2226 35 would would MD 42759 2226 36 receive receive VB 42759 2226 37 adequate adequate JJ 42759 2226 38 reward reward NN 42759 2226 39 in in IN 42759 2226 40 the the DT 42759 2226 41 form form NN 42759 2226 42 of of IN 42759 2226 43 either either DT 42759 2226 44 promotion promotion NN 42759 2226 45 or or CC 42759 2226 46 money money NN 42759 2226 47 compensation compensation NN 42759 2226 48 . . . 42759 2227 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2227 2 would would MD 42759 2227 3 see see VB 42759 2227 4 no no DT 42759 2227 5 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2227 6 reason reason NN 42759 2227 7 for for IN 42759 2227 8 abandoning abandon VBG 42759 2227 9 the the DT 42759 2227 10 established established JJ 42759 2227 11 and and CC 42759 2227 12 pleasant pleasant JJ 42759 2227 13 policy policy NN 42759 2227 14 of of IN 42759 2227 15 routine routine JJ 42759 2227 16 methods method NNS 42759 2227 17 and and CC 42759 2227 18 unprogressive unprogressive JJ 42759 2227 19 management management NN 42759 2227 20 . . . 42759 2228 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2228 2 Inefficient Inefficient NNP 42759 2228 3 Labour Labour NNP 42759 2228 4 _ _ NNP 42759 2228 5 The the DT 42759 2228 6 same same JJ 42759 2228 7 spirit spirit NN 42759 2228 8 of of IN 42759 2228 9 inefficiency inefficiency NN 42759 2228 10 and and CC 42759 2228 11 mediocrity mediocrity NN 42759 2228 12 would would MD 42759 2228 13 permeate permeate VB 42759 2228 14 the the DT 42759 2228 15 rank rank NN 42759 2228 16 and and CC 42759 2228 17 file file NN 42759 2228 18 of of IN 42759 2228 19 the the DT 42759 2228 20 workers worker NNS 42759 2228 21 . . . 42759 2229 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 2229 2 , , , 42759 2229 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2229 4 would would MD 42759 2229 5 operate operate VB 42759 2229 6 even even RB 42759 2229 7 more more RBR 42759 2229 8 strongly strongly RB 42759 2229 9 among among IN 42759 2229 10 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2229 11 than than IN 42759 2229 12 among among IN 42759 2229 13 the the DT 42759 2229 14 officers officer NNS 42759 2229 15 and and CC 42759 2229 16 superiors superior NNS 42759 2229 17 ; ; : 42759 2229 18 for for IN 42759 2229 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2229 20 intellectual intellectual JJ 42759 2229 21 limitations limitation NNS 42759 2229 22 and and CC 42759 2229 23 the the DT 42759 2229 24 nature nature NN 42759 2229 25 of of IN 42759 2229 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2229 27 tasks task NNS 42759 2229 28 would would MD 42759 2229 29 make make VB 42759 2229 30 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2229 31 less less RBR 42759 2229 32 responsive responsive JJ 42759 2229 33 to to IN 42759 2229 34 other other JJ 42759 2229 35 than than IN 42759 2229 36 material material JJ 42759 2229 37 and and CC 42759 2229 38 pecuniary pecuniary JJ 42759 2229 39 motives motive NNS 42759 2229 40 . . . 42759 2230 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2230 2 would would MD 42759 2230 3 desire desire VB 42759 2230 4 to to TO 42759 2230 5 follow follow VB 42759 2230 6 the the DT 42759 2230 7 line line NN 42759 2230 8 of of IN 42759 2230 9 least least JJS 42759 2230 10 resistance resistance NN 42759 2230 11 , , , 42759 2230 12 to to IN 42759 2230 13 labour labour NN 42759 2230 14 in in RP 42759 2230 15 the the DT 42759 2230 16 most most RBS 42759 2230 17 pleasant pleasant JJ 42759 2230 18 conditions condition NNS 42759 2230 19 , , , 42759 2230 20 to to TO 42759 2230 21 reduce reduce VB 42759 2230 22 irksome irksome JJ 42759 2230 23 toil toil NN 42759 2230 24 to to IN 42759 2230 25 a a DT 42759 2230 26 minimum minimum NN 42759 2230 27 . . . 42759 2231 1 Since since IN 42759 2231 2 the the DT 42759 2231 3 great great JJ 42759 2231 4 bulk bulk NN 42759 2231 5 of of IN 42759 2231 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2231 7 tasks task NNS 42759 2231 8 would would MD 42759 2231 9 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 2231 10 be be VB 42759 2231 11 mechanical mechanical JJ 42759 2231 12 and and CC 42759 2231 13 monotonous monotonous JJ 42759 2231 14 , , , 42759 2231 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2231 16 would would MD 42759 2231 17 demand demand VB 42759 2231 18 the the DT 42759 2231 19 shortest shortest RBS 42759 2231 20 possible possible JJ 42759 2231 21 working work VBG 42759 2231 22 day day NN 42759 2231 23 , , , 42759 2231 24 and and CC 42759 2231 25 the the DT 42759 2231 26 most most RBS 42759 2231 27 leisurely leisurely JJ 42759 2231 28 rate rate NN 42759 2231 29 of of IN 42759 2231 30 working work VBG 42759 2231 31 speed speed NN 42759 2231 32 . . . 42759 2232 1 And and CC 42759 2232 2 because because IN 42759 2232 3 of of IN 42759 2232 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2232 5 numerical numerical JJ 42759 2232 6 strength strength NN 42759 2232 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2232 8 would would MD 42759 2232 9 have have VB 42759 2232 10 the the DT 42759 2232 11 power power NN 42759 2232 12 to to TO 42759 2232 13 enforce enforce VB 42759 2232 14 this this DT 42759 2232 15 policy policy NN 42759 2232 16 throughout throughout IN 42759 2232 17 the the DT 42759 2232 18 field field NN 42759 2232 19 of of IN 42759 2232 20 industry industry NN 42759 2232 21 . . . 42759 2233 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2233 2 would would MD 42759 2233 3 have have VB 42759 2233 4 the the DT 42759 2233 5 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2233 6 and and CC 42759 2233 7 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2233 8 votes vote NNS 42759 2233 9 . . . 42759 2234 1 In in IN 42759 2234 2 a a DT 42759 2234 3 general general JJ 42759 2234 4 way way NN 42759 2234 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2234 6 might may MD 42759 2234 7 , , , 42759 2234 8 indeed indeed RB 42759 2234 9 , , , 42759 2234 10 realise realise VB 42759 2234 11 that that IN 42759 2234 12 the the DT 42759 2234 13 practice practice NN 42759 2234 14 of of IN 42759 2234 15 universal universal JJ 42759 2234 16 shirking shirking NN 42759 2234 17 and and CC 42759 2234 18 laziness laziness NN 42759 2234 19 must must MD 42759 2234 20 sooner sooner RB 42759 2234 21 or or CC 42759 2234 22 later later RB 42759 2234 23 result result VB 42759 2234 24 in in IN 42759 2234 25 such such PDT 42759 2234 26 a a DT 42759 2234 27 diminution diminution NN 42759 2234 28 of of IN 42759 2234 29 the the DT 42759 2234 30 national national JJ 42759 2234 31 product product NN 42759 2234 32 as as IN 42759 2234 33 to to TO 42759 2234 34 cause cause VB 42759 2234 35 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2234 36 great great JJ 42759 2234 37 hardship hardship NN 42759 2234 38 , , , 42759 2234 39 but but CC 42759 2234 40 the the DT 42759 2234 41 workers worker NNS 42759 2234 42 in in IN 42759 2234 43 each each DT 42759 2234 44 industry industry NN 42759 2234 45 would would MD 42759 2234 46 hope hope VB 42759 2234 47 that that IN 42759 2234 48 those those DT 42759 2234 49 in in IN 42759 2234 50 all all PDT 42759 2234 51 the the DT 42759 2234 52 others other NNS 42759 2234 53 would would MD 42759 2234 54 be be VB 42759 2234 55 more more RBR 42759 2234 56 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2234 57 ; ; : 42759 2234 58 or or CC 42759 2234 59 doubt doubt VB 42759 2234 60 that that IN 42759 2234 61 a a DT 42759 2234 62 better well JJR 42759 2234 63 example example NN 42759 2234 64 set set VBN 42759 2234 65 by by IN 42759 2234 66 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 2234 67 would would MD 42759 2234 68 be be VB 42759 2234 69 imitated imitate VBN 42759 2234 70 by by IN 42759 2234 71 the the DT 42759 2234 72 workers worker NNS 42759 2234 73 in in IN 42759 2234 74 other other JJ 42759 2234 75 industries industry NNS 42759 2234 76 . . . 42759 2235 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2235 2 would would MD 42759 2235 3 not not RB 42759 2235 4 be be VB 42759 2235 5 keen keen JJ 42759 2235 6 to to TO 42759 2235 7 give give VB 42759 2235 8 up up RP 42759 2235 9 the the DT 42759 2235 10 certainty certainty NN 42759 2235 11 of of IN 42759 2235 12 easy easy JJ 42759 2235 13 working working NN 42759 2235 14 conditions condition NNS 42759 2235 15 for for IN 42759 2235 16 the the DT 42759 2235 17 remote remote JJ 42759 2235 18 possibility possibility NN 42759 2235 19 of of IN 42759 2235 20 a a DT 42759 2235 21 larger large JJR 42759 2235 22 national national JJ 42759 2235 23 product product NN 42759 2235 24 . . . 42759 2236 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2236 2 Attempted Attempted NNP 42759 2236 3 Replies Replies NNPS 42759 2236 4 to to IN 42759 2236 5 Objections objection NNS 42759 2236 6 _ _ NNP 42759 2236 7 All all PDT 42759 2236 8 the the DT 42759 2236 9 attempts attempt NNS 42759 2236 10 made make VBN 42759 2236 11 by by IN 42759 2236 12 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2236 13 to to TO 42759 2236 14 answer answer VB 42759 2236 15 or or CC 42759 2236 16 explain explain VB 42759 2236 17 away away RB 42759 2236 18 the the DT 42759 2236 19 foregoing forego VBG 42759 2236 20 difficulties difficulty NNS 42759 2236 21 may may MD 42759 2236 22 be be VB 42759 2236 23 reduced reduce VBN 42759 2236 24 to to IN 42759 2236 25 two two CD 42759 2236 26 : : : 42759 2236 27 the the DT 42759 2236 28 achievements achievement NNS 42759 2236 29 of of IN 42759 2236 30 government government NN 42759 2236 31 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 2236 32 in in IN 42759 2236 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2236 34 present present JJ 42759 2236 35 system system NN 42759 2236 36 ; ; : 42759 2236 37 and and CC 42759 2236 38 the the DT 42759 2236 39 assumed assumed JJ 42759 2236 40 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 2236 41 of of IN 42759 2236 42 altruism altruism NN 42759 2236 43 and and CC 42759 2236 44 public public JJ 42759 2236 45 honour honour NN 42759 2236 46 in in IN 42759 2236 47 a a DT 42759 2236 48 régime régime NN 42759 2236 49 of of IN 42759 2236 50 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2236 51 . . . 42759 2237 1 Under under IN 42759 2237 2 the the DT 42759 2237 3 first first JJ 42759 2237 4 head head NN 42759 2237 5 appeal appeal NN 42759 2237 6 is be VBZ 42759 2237 7 made make VBN 42759 2237 8 to to IN 42759 2237 9 such such JJ 42759 2237 10 publicly publicly RB 42759 2237 11 owned own VBN 42759 2237 12 and and CC 42759 2237 13 managed manage VBN 42759 2237 14 concerns concern NNS 42759 2237 15 as as IN 42759 2237 16 the the DT 42759 2237 17 post post NNP 42759 2237 18 office office NN 42759 2237 19 , , , 42759 2237 20 railroads railroad NNS 42759 2237 21 , , , 42759 2237 22 telegraphs telegraph NNS 42759 2237 23 , , , 42759 2237 24 telephones telephone NNS 42759 2237 25 , , , 42759 2237 26 street street NN 42759 2237 27 railways railway NNS 42759 2237 28 , , , 42759 2237 29 water water NN 42759 2237 30 works work NNS 42759 2237 31 , , , 42759 2237 32 and and CC 42759 2237 33 lighting lighting NN 42759 2237 34 plants plant NNS 42759 2237 35 . . . 42759 2238 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2238 2 is be VBZ 42759 2238 3 probably probably RB 42759 2238 4 true true JJ 42759 2238 5 that that IN 42759 2238 6 all all PDT 42759 2238 7 these these DT 42759 2238 8 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 2238 9 are be VBP 42759 2238 10 on on IN 42759 2238 11 the the DT 42759 2238 12 whole whole NN 42759 2238 13 carried carry VBN 42759 2238 14 on on RP 42759 2238 15 with with IN 42759 2238 16 better well JJR 42759 2238 17 results result NNS 42759 2238 18 to to IN 42759 2238 19 the the DT 42759 2238 20 public public NN 42759 2238 21 than than IN 42759 2238 22 if if IN 42759 2238 23 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2238 24 were be VBD 42759 2238 25 in in IN 42759 2238 26 private private JJ 42759 2238 27 hands hand NNS 42759 2238 28 . . . 42759 2239 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2239 2 is be VBZ 42759 2239 3 likewise likewise RB 42759 2239 4 probable probable JJ 42759 2239 5 that that IN 42759 2239 6 these these DT 42759 2239 7 and and CC 42759 2239 8 all all DT 42759 2239 9 other other JJ 42759 2239 10 public public JJ 42759 2239 11 utility utility NN 42759 2239 12 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 2239 13 will will MD 42759 2239 14 sooner sooner RB 42759 2239 15 or or CC 42759 2239 16 later later RB 42759 2239 17 be be VB 42759 2239 18 taken take VBN 42759 2239 19 over over RP 42759 2239 20 by by IN 42759 2239 21 the the DT 42759 2239 22 State State NNP 42759 2239 23 in in IN 42759 2239 24 all all DT 42759 2239 25 advanced advanced JJ 42759 2239 26 countries country NNS 42759 2239 27 . . . 42759 2240 1 Even even RB 42759 2240 2 if if IN 42759 2240 3 this this DT 42759 2240 4 should should MD 42759 2240 5 prove prove VB 42759 2240 6 in in IN 42759 2240 7 all all DT 42759 2240 8 cases case NNS 42759 2240 9 to to TO 42759 2240 10 be be VB 42759 2240 11 a a DT 42759 2240 12 better well JJR 42759 2240 13 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 2240 14 from from IN 42759 2240 15 the the DT 42759 2240 16 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 2240 17 of of IN 42759 2240 18 the the DT 42759 2240 19 general general JJ 42759 2240 20 public public JJ 42759 2240 21 welfare welfare NN 42759 2240 22 than than IN 42759 2240 23 private private JJ 42759 2240 24 ownership ownership NN 42759 2240 25 and and CC 42759 2240 26 management management NN 42759 2240 27 , , , 42759 2240 28 the the DT 42759 2240 29 fact fact NN 42759 2240 30 would would MD 42759 2240 31 constitute constitute VB 42759 2240 32 no no DT 42759 2240 33 argument argument NN 42759 2240 34 for for IN 42759 2240 35 a a DT 42759 2240 36 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2240 37 organisation organisation NN 42759 2240 38 of of IN 42759 2240 39 all all DT 42759 2240 40 industry industry NN 42759 2240 41 . . . 42759 2241 1 In in IN 42759 2241 2 the the DT 42759 2241 3 first first JJ 42759 2241 4 place place NN 42759 2241 5 , , , 42759 2241 6 the the DT 42759 2241 7 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 2241 8 of of IN 42759 2241 9 labour labour NN 42759 2241 10 , , , 42759 2241 11 management management NN 42759 2241 12 , , , 42759 2241 13 and and CC 42759 2241 14 technical technical JJ 42759 2241 15 organisation organisation NN 42759 2241 16 is be VBZ 42759 2241 17 generally generally RB 42759 2241 18 lower low JJR 42759 2241 19 in in IN 42759 2241 20 public public NN 42759 2241 21 than than IN 42759 2241 22 in in IN 42759 2241 23 private private JJ 42759 2241 24 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 2241 25 , , , 42759 2241 26 and and CC 42759 2241 27 the the DT 42759 2241 28 cost cost NN 42759 2241 29 of of IN 42759 2241 30 operation operation NN 42759 2241 31 higher higher RBR 42759 2241 32 . . . 42759 2242 1 Despite despite IN 42759 2242 2 these these DT 42759 2242 3 defects defect NNS 42759 2242 4 , , , 42759 2242 5 government government NN 42759 2242 6 ownership ownership NN 42759 2242 7 of of IN 42759 2242 8 public public JJ 42759 2242 9 utilities utility NNS 42759 2242 10 , , , 42759 2242 11 such such JJ 42759 2242 12 as as IN 42759 2242 13 street street NN 42759 2242 14 railways railway NNS 42759 2242 15 and and CC 42759 2242 16 lighting lighting NN 42759 2242 17 concerns concern NNS 42759 2242 18 , , , 42759 2242 19 may may MD 42759 2242 20 be be VB 42759 2242 21 socially socially RB 42759 2242 22 preferable preferable JJ 42759 2242 23 because because IN 42759 2242 24 these these DT 42759 2242 25 industries industry NNS 42759 2242 26 are be VBP 42759 2242 27 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 2242 28 . . . 42759 2243 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 2243 2 as as IN 42759 2243 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2243 4 charges charge NNS 42759 2243 5 and and CC 42759 2243 6 services service NNS 42759 2243 7 can can MD 42759 2243 8 not not RB 42759 2243 9 be be VB 42759 2243 10 regulated regulate VBN 42759 2243 11 by by IN 42759 2243 12 the the DT 42759 2243 13 automatic automatic JJ 42759 2243 14 action action NN 42759 2243 15 of of IN 42759 2243 16 competition competition NN 42759 2243 17 , , , 42759 2243 18 the the DT 42759 2243 19 only only JJ 42759 2243 20 alternative alternative NN 42759 2243 21 to to IN 42759 2243 22 public public JJ 42759 2243 23 ownership ownership NN 42759 2243 24 is be VBZ 42759 2243 25 public public JJ 42759 2243 26 supervision supervision NN 42759 2243 27 . . . 42759 2244 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 2244 2 as as IN 42759 2244 3 the the DT 42759 2244 4 latter latter NN 42759 2244 5 is be VBZ 42759 2244 6 often often RB 42759 2244 7 incapable incapable JJ 42759 2244 8 of of IN 42759 2244 9 securing secure VBG 42759 2244 10 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 2244 11 service service NN 42759 2244 12 at at IN 42759 2244 13 fair fair JJ 42759 2244 14 prices price NNS 42759 2244 15 , , , 42759 2244 16 public public JJ 42759 2244 17 ownership ownership NN 42759 2244 18 and and CC 42759 2244 19 management management NN 42759 2244 20 becomes become VBZ 42759 2244 21 on on IN 42759 2244 22 the the DT 42759 2244 23 whole whole JJ 42759 2244 24 more more RBR 42759 2244 25 conducive conducive JJ 42759 2244 26 to to IN 42759 2244 27 social social JJ 42759 2244 28 welfare welfare NN 42759 2244 29 . . . 42759 2245 1 In in IN 42759 2245 2 other other JJ 42759 2245 3 words word NNS 42759 2245 4 , , , 42759 2245 5 the the DT 42759 2245 6 losses loss NNS 42759 2245 7 through through IN 42759 2245 8 inefficient inefficient JJ 42759 2245 9 operation operation NN 42759 2245 10 are be VBP 42759 2245 11 more more JJR 42759 2245 12 than than IN 42759 2245 13 offset offset VBN 42759 2245 14 by by IN 42759 2245 15 the the DT 42759 2245 16 gains gain NNS 42759 2245 17 from from IN 42759 2245 18 better well JJR 42759 2245 19 service service NN 42759 2245 20 and and CC 42759 2245 21 lower low JJR 42759 2245 22 charges charge NNS 42759 2245 23 . . . 42759 2246 1 Three three CD 42759 2246 2 cent cent NN 42759 2246 3 fares fare NNS 42759 2246 4 and and CC 42759 2246 5 adequate adequate JJ 42759 2246 6 service service NN 42759 2246 7 on on IN 42759 2246 8 an an DT 42759 2246 9 inefficiently inefficiently RB 42759 2246 10 managed manage VBN 42759 2246 11 municipal municipal JJ 42759 2246 12 street street NN 42759 2246 13 railway railway NN 42759 2246 14 are be VBP 42759 2246 15 preferable preferable JJ 42759 2246 16 to to IN 42759 2246 17 five five CD 42759 2246 18 cent cent NN 42759 2246 19 fares fare NNS 42759 2246 20 on on IN 42759 2246 21 a a DT 42759 2246 22 privately privately RB 42759 2246 23 owned own VBN 42759 2246 24 street street NN 42759 2246 25 railway railway NN 42759 2246 26 whose whose WP$ 42759 2246 27 management management NN 42759 2246 28 is be VBZ 42759 2246 29 superior superior JJ 42759 2246 30 . . . 42759 2247 1 On on IN 42759 2247 2 the the DT 42759 2247 3 other other JJ 42759 2247 4 hand hand NN 42759 2247 5 , , , 42759 2247 6 all all PDT 42759 2247 7 those those DT 42759 2247 8 industries industry NNS 42759 2247 9 which which WDT 42759 2247 10 are be VBP 42759 2247 11 not not RB 42759 2247 12 natural natural JJ 42759 2247 13 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 2247 14 can can MD 42759 2247 15 be be VB 42759 2247 16 prevented prevent VBN 42759 2247 17 from from IN 42759 2247 18 practising practise VBG 42759 2247 19 extortion extortion NN 42759 2247 20 upon upon IN 42759 2247 21 the the DT 42759 2247 22 public public NN 42759 2247 23 through through IN 42759 2247 24 regulated regulate VBN 42759 2247 25 competition competition NN 42759 2247 26 . . . 42759 2248 1 In in IN 42759 2248 2 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2248 3 , , , 42759 2248 4 therefore therefore RB 42759 2248 5 , , , 42759 2248 6 the the DT 42759 2248 7 advantages advantage NNS 42759 2248 8 of of IN 42759 2248 9 private private JJ 42759 2248 10 operation operation NN 42759 2248 11 , , , 42759 2248 12 of of IN 42759 2248 13 which which WDT 42759 2248 14 competition competition NN 42759 2248 15 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2248 16 is be VBZ 42759 2248 17 not not RB 42759 2248 18 the the DT 42759 2248 19 least least JJS 42759 2248 20 , , , 42759 2248 21 should should MD 42759 2248 22 be be VB 42759 2248 23 retained retain VBN 42759 2248 24 . . . 42759 2249 1 In in IN 42759 2249 2 the the DT 42759 2249 3 second second JJ 42759 2249 4 place place NN 42759 2249 5 , , , 42759 2249 6 practically practically RB 42759 2249 7 all all PDT 42759 2249 8 the the DT 42759 2249 9 public public JJ 42759 2249 10 service service NN 42759 2249 11 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 2249 12 are be VBP 42759 2249 13 simpler simple JJR 42759 2249 14 in in IN 42759 2249 15 structure structure NN 42759 2249 16 , , , 42759 2249 17 more more RBR 42759 2249 18 routine routine JJ 42759 2249 19 in in IN 42759 2249 20 operation operation NN 42759 2249 21 , , , 42759 2249 22 and and CC 42759 2249 23 more more RBR 42759 2249 24 mature mature JJ 42759 2249 25 in in IN 42759 2249 26 organisation organisation NN 42759 2249 27 and and CC 42759 2249 28 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 2249 29 than than IN 42759 2249 30 the the DT 42759 2249 31 other other JJ 42759 2249 32 industries industry NNS 42759 2249 33 . . . 42759 2250 1 The the DT 42759 2250 2 degree degree NN 42759 2250 3 of of IN 42759 2250 4 managerial managerial JJ 42759 2250 5 ability ability NN 42759 2250 6 required require VBN 42759 2250 7 , , , 42759 2250 8 the the DT 42759 2250 9 necessity necessity NN 42759 2250 10 of of IN 42759 2250 11 experimenting experiment VBG 42759 2250 12 with with IN 42759 2250 13 new new JJ 42759 2250 14 methods method NNS 42759 2250 15 and and CC 42759 2250 16 processes process NNS 42759 2250 17 , , , 42759 2250 18 and and CC 42759 2250 19 the the DT 42759 2250 20 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 2250 21 of of IN 42759 2250 22 introducing introduce VBG 42759 2250 23 further further JJ 42759 2250 24 improvements improvement NNS 42759 2250 25 in in IN 42759 2250 26 organisation organisation NN 42759 2250 27 are be VBP 42759 2250 28 relatively relatively RB 42759 2250 29 less less JJR 42759 2250 30 . . . 42759 2251 1 Now now RB 42759 2251 2 , , , 42759 2251 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2251 4 is be VBZ 42759 2251 5 precisely precisely RB 42759 2251 6 in in IN 42759 2251 7 these these DT 42759 2251 8 respects respect NNS 42759 2251 9 that that IN 42759 2251 10 private private JJ 42759 2251 11 has have VBZ 42759 2251 12 shown show VBN 42759 2251 13 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2251 14 superior superior JJ 42759 2251 15 to to IN 42759 2251 16 public public JJ 42759 2251 17 operation operation NN 42759 2251 18 . . . 42759 2252 1 Initiative initiative NN 42759 2252 2 , , , 42759 2252 3 inventiveness inventiveness NN 42759 2252 4 , , , 42759 2252 5 and and CC 42759 2252 6 eagerness eagerness NN 42759 2252 7 to to TO 42759 2252 8 effect effect VB 42759 2252 9 economies economy NNS 42759 2252 10 and and CC 42759 2252 11 increase increase NN 42759 2252 12 profits profit NNS 42759 2252 13 are be VBP 42759 2252 14 the the DT 42759 2252 15 qualities quality NNS 42759 2252 16 in in IN 42759 2252 17 which which WDT 42759 2252 18 private private JJ 42759 2252 19 management management NN 42759 2252 20 excels excel NNS 42759 2252 21 . . . 42759 2253 1 When when WRB 42759 2253 2 the the DT 42759 2253 3 nature nature NN 42759 2253 4 and and CC 42759 2253 5 maturity maturity NN 42759 2253 6 of of IN 42759 2253 7 the the DT 42759 2253 8 concern concern NN 42759 2253 9 have have VBP 42759 2253 10 rendered render VBN 42759 2253 11 these these DT 42759 2253 12 qualities quality NNS 42759 2253 13 relatively relatively RB 42759 2253 14 unimportant unimportant JJ 42759 2253 15 , , , 42759 2253 16 public public JJ 42759 2253 17 management management NN 42759 2253 18 can can MD 42759 2253 19 exemplify exemplify VB 42759 2253 20 a a DT 42759 2253 21 fair fair JJ 42759 2253 22 degree degree NN 42759 2253 23 of of IN 42759 2253 24 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 2253 25 . . . 42759 2254 1 In in IN 42759 2254 2 the the DT 42759 2254 3 third third JJ 42759 2254 4 place place NN 42759 2254 5 , , , 42759 2254 6 the the DT 42759 2254 7 ability ability NN 42759 2254 8 of of IN 42759 2254 9 the the DT 42759 2254 10 State State NNP 42759 2254 11 to to TO 42759 2254 12 operate operate VB 42759 2254 13 a a DT 42759 2254 14 few few JJ 42759 2254 15 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 2254 16 , , , 42759 2254 17 does do VBZ 42759 2254 18 not not RB 42759 2254 19 prove prove VB 42759 2254 20 that that IN 42759 2254 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2254 22 could could MD 42759 2254 23 repeat repeat VB 42759 2254 24 the the DT 42759 2254 25 performance performance NN 42759 2254 26 with with IN 42759 2254 27 an an DT 42759 2254 28 equal equal JJ 42759 2254 29 degree degree NN 42759 2254 30 of of IN 42759 2254 31 success success NN 42759 2254 32 in in IN 42759 2254 33 all all DT 42759 2254 34 industries industry NNS 42759 2254 35 . . . 42759 2255 1 I -PRON- PRP 42759 2255 2 can can MD 42759 2255 3 drive drive VB 42759 2255 4 two two CD 42759 2255 5 horses horse NNS 42759 2255 6 , , , 42759 2255 7 but but CC 42759 2255 8 I -PRON- PRP 42759 2255 9 could could MD 42759 2255 10 not not RB 42759 2255 11 drive drive VB 42759 2255 12 twenty twenty CD 42759 2255 13 - - HYPH 42759 2255 14 two two CD 42759 2255 15 . . . 42759 2256 1 No no RB 42759 2256 2 matter matter RB 42759 2256 3 how how WRB 42759 2256 4 scientific scientific JJ 42759 2256 5 the the DT 42759 2256 6 organisation organisation NN 42759 2256 7 and and CC 42759 2256 8 departmentalisation departmentalisation NN 42759 2256 9 of of IN 42759 2256 10 industries industry NNS 42759 2256 11 under under IN 42759 2256 12 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 2256 13 , , , 42759 2256 14 the the DT 42759 2256 15 final final JJ 42759 2256 16 control control NN 42759 2256 17 of of IN 42759 2256 18 and and CC 42759 2256 19 responsibility responsibility NN 42759 2256 20 for for IN 42759 2256 21 all all DT 42759 2256 22 of of IN 42759 2256 23 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2256 24 would would MD 42759 2256 25 rest rest VB 42759 2256 26 with with IN 42759 2256 27 one one CD 42759 2256 28 organ organ NN 42759 2256 29 , , , 42759 2256 30 one one CD 42759 2256 31 authority authority NN 42759 2256 32 , , , 42759 2256 33 namely namely RB 42759 2256 34 , , , 42759 2256 35 the the DT 42759 2256 36 city city NN 42759 2256 37 in in IN 42759 2256 38 municipal municipal JJ 42759 2256 39 industries industry NNS 42759 2256 40 , , , 42759 2256 41 and and CC 42759 2256 42 the the DT 42759 2256 43 nation nation NN 42759 2256 44 in in IN 42759 2256 45 industries industry NNS 42759 2256 46 having have VBG 42759 2256 47 national national JJ 42759 2256 48 scope scope NN 42759 2256 49 . . . 42759 2257 1 This this DT 42759 2257 2 would would MD 42759 2257 3 prove prove VB 42759 2257 4 too too RB 42759 2257 5 great great JJ 42759 2257 6 a a DT 42759 2257 7 task task NN 42759 2257 8 , , , 42759 2257 9 too too RB 42759 2257 10 heavy heavy JJ 42759 2257 11 a a DT 42759 2257 12 burden burden NN 42759 2257 13 , , , 42759 2257 14 for for IN 42759 2257 15 any any DT 42759 2257 16 body body NN 42759 2257 17 of of IN 42759 2257 18 officials official NNS 42759 2257 19 , , , 42759 2257 20 for for IN 42759 2257 21 any any DT 42759 2257 22 group group NN 42759 2257 23 of of IN 42759 2257 24 human human JJ 42759 2257 25 beings being NNS 42759 2257 26 . . . 42759 2258 1 Finally finally RB 42759 2258 2 , , , 42759 2258 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2258 4 must must MD 42759 2258 5 be be VB 42759 2258 6 kept keep VBN 42759 2258 7 in in IN 42759 2258 8 mind mind NN 42759 2258 9 that that IN 42759 2258 10 the the DT 42759 2258 11 publicly publicly RB 42759 2258 12 operated operate VBN 42759 2258 13 utilities utility NNS 42759 2258 14 are be VBP 42759 2258 15 subject subject JJ 42759 2258 16 continuously continuously RB 42759 2258 17 to to IN 42759 2258 18 the the DT 42759 2258 19 indirect indirect JJ 42759 2258 20 competition competition NN 42759 2258 21 of of IN 42759 2258 22 private private JJ 42759 2258 23 management management NN 42759 2258 24 . . . 42759 2259 1 By by IN 42759 2259 2 far far RB 42759 2259 3 the the DT 42759 2259 4 greater great JJR 42759 2259 5 part part NN 42759 2259 6 of of IN 42759 2259 7 industry industry NN 42759 2259 8 is be VBZ 42759 2259 9 now now RB 42759 2259 10 under under IN 42759 2259 11 private private JJ 42759 2259 12 control control NN 42759 2259 13 , , , 42759 2259 14 which which WDT 42759 2259 15 sets set VBZ 42759 2259 16 the the DT 42759 2259 17 pace pace NN 42759 2259 18 for for IN 42759 2259 19 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2259 20 operation operation NN 42759 2259 21 in in IN 42759 2259 22 a a DT 42759 2259 23 hundred hundred CD 42759 2259 24 particulars particular NNS 42759 2259 25 . . . 42759 2260 1 As as IN 42759 2260 2 a a DT 42759 2260 3 consequence consequence NN 42759 2260 4 , , , 42759 2260 5 comparisons comparison NNS 42759 2260 6 are be VBP 42759 2260 7 steadily steadily RB 42759 2260 8 provoked provoke VBN 42759 2260 9 between between IN 42759 2260 10 public public JJ 42759 2260 11 and and CC 42759 2260 12 private private JJ 42759 2260 13 management management NN 42759 2260 14 , , , 42759 2260 15 and and CC 42759 2260 16 the the DT 42759 2260 17 former former JJ 42759 2260 18 is be VBZ 42759 2260 19 subject subject JJ 42759 2260 20 to to IN 42759 2260 21 constant constant JJ 42759 2260 22 criticism criticism NN 42759 2260 23 . . . 42759 2261 1 The the DT 42759 2261 2 managers manager NNS 42759 2261 3 of of IN 42759 2261 4 the the DT 42759 2261 5 State state NN 42759 2261 6 concerns concern NNS 42759 2261 7 are be VBP 42759 2261 8 stimulated stimulate VBN 42759 2261 9 and and CC 42759 2261 10 practically practically RB 42759 2261 11 compelled compel VBN 42759 2261 12 to to TO 42759 2261 13 emulate emulate VB 42759 2261 14 the the DT 42759 2261 15 success success NN 42759 2261 16 of of IN 42759 2261 17 private private JJ 42759 2261 18 management management NN 42759 2261 19 . . . 42759 2262 1 This this DT 42759 2262 2 factor factor NN 42759 2262 3 is be VBZ 42759 2262 4 probably probably RB 42759 2262 5 more more RBR 42759 2262 6 effective effective JJ 42759 2262 7 in in IN 42759 2262 8 securing secure VBG 42759 2262 9 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 2262 10 in in IN 42759 2262 11 public public JJ 42759 2262 12 industries industry NNS 42759 2262 13 than than IN 42759 2262 14 all all DT 42759 2262 15 other other JJ 42759 2262 16 causes cause NNS 42759 2262 17 put put VBN 42759 2262 18 together together RB 42759 2262 19 . . . 42759 2263 1 In in IN 42759 2263 2 the the DT 42759 2263 3 words word NNS 42759 2263 4 of of IN 42759 2263 5 Professor Professor NNP 42759 2263 6 Skelton Skelton NNP 42759 2263 7 : : : 42759 2263 8 " " `` 42759 2263 9 A a DT 42759 2263 10 limited limited JJ 42759 2263 11 degree degree NN 42759 2263 12 of of IN 42759 2263 13 public public JJ 42759 2263 14 ownership ownership NN 42759 2263 15 succeeds succeed VBZ 42759 2263 16 simply simply RB 42759 2263 17 because because IN 42759 2263 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2263 19 is be VBZ 42759 2263 20 a a DT 42759 2263 21 limited limited JJ 42759 2263 22 degree degree NN 42759 2263 23 , , , 42759 2263 24 succeeds succeed VBZ 42759 2263 25 because because IN 42759 2263 26 private private JJ 42759 2263 27 industry industry NN 42759 2263 28 , , , 42759 2263 29 in in IN 42759 2263 30 individual individual JJ 42759 2263 31 forms form NNS 42759 2263 32 or or CC 42759 2263 33 in in IN 42759 2263 34 the the DT 42759 2263 35 socialised socialised JJ 42759 2263 36 joint joint JJ 42759 2263 37 stock stock NN 42759 2263 38 form form NN 42759 2263 39 , , , 42759 2263 40 dominates dominate VBZ 42759 2263 41 the the DT 42759 2263 42 field field NN 42759 2263 43 as as IN 42759 2263 44 a a DT 42759 2263 45 whole whole NN 42759 2263 46 . . . 42759 2264 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2264 2 is be VBZ 42759 2264 3 private private JJ 42759 2264 4 industry industry NN 42759 2264 5 that that WDT 42759 2264 6 provides provide VBZ 42759 2264 7 the the DT 42759 2264 8 capital capital NN 42759 2264 9 , , , 42759 2264 10 private private JJ 42759 2264 11 industry industry NN 42759 2264 12 that that WDT 42759 2264 13 trains train VBZ 42759 2264 14 the the DT 42759 2264 15 men man NNS 42759 2264 16 and and CC 42759 2264 17 tries try VBZ 42759 2264 18 out out RP 42759 2264 19 the the DT 42759 2264 20 methods method NNS 42759 2264 21 , , , 42759 2264 22 private private JJ 42759 2264 23 industry industry NN 42759 2264 24 that that WDT 42759 2264 25 sets set VBZ 42759 2264 26 the the DT 42759 2264 27 pace pace NN 42759 2264 28 , , , 42759 2264 29 and and CC 42759 2264 30 -- -- : 42759 2264 31 not not RB 42759 2264 32 the the DT 42759 2264 33 least least JJS 42759 2264 34 of of IN 42759 2264 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2264 36 services service NNS 42759 2264 37 -- -- : 42759 2264 38 private private JJ 42759 2264 39 industry industry NN 42759 2264 40 that that WDT 42759 2264 41 provides provide VBZ 42759 2264 42 the the DT 42759 2264 43 ever ever RB 42759 2264 44 - - HYPH 42759 2264 45 possible possible JJ 42759 2264 46 outlet outlet NN 42759 2264 47 of of IN 42759 2264 48 escape escape NN 42759 2264 49 . . . 42759 2265 1 " " `` 42759 2265 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2265 3 131 131 CD 42759 2265 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2265 5 The the DT 42759 2265 6 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2265 7 expectation expectation NN 42759 2265 8 that that IN 42759 2265 9 altruistic altruistic JJ 42759 2265 10 sentiments sentiment NNS 42759 2265 11 and and CC 42759 2265 12 public public JJ 42759 2265 13 honour honour NN 42759 2265 14 would would MD 42759 2265 15 induce induce VB 42759 2265 16 all all DT 42759 2265 17 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2265 18 leaders leader NNS 42759 2265 19 and and CC 42759 2265 20 all all DT 42759 2265 21 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 2265 22 workers worker NNS 42759 2265 23 to to TO 42759 2265 24 exert exert VB 42759 2265 25 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 2265 26 as as RB 42759 2265 27 effectively effectively RB 42759 2265 28 as as IN 42759 2265 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2265 30 now now RB 42759 2265 31 do do VBP 42759 2265 32 for for IN 42759 2265 33 the the DT 42759 2265 34 sake sake NN 42759 2265 35 of of IN 42759 2265 36 money money NN 42759 2265 37 , , , 42759 2265 38 is be VBZ 42759 2265 39 based base VBN 42759 2265 40 upon upon IN 42759 2265 41 the the DT 42759 2265 42 very very RB 42759 2265 43 shallow shallow JJ 42759 2265 44 fallacy fallacy NN 42759 2265 45 that that IN 42759 2265 46 what what WP 42759 2265 47 is be VBZ 42759 2265 48 true true JJ 42759 2265 49 of of IN 42759 2265 50 a a DT 42759 2265 51 few few JJ 42759 2265 52 men man NNS 42759 2265 53 may may MD 42759 2265 54 very very RB 42759 2265 55 readily readily RB 42759 2265 56 become become VB 42759 2265 57 true true JJ 42759 2265 58 of of IN 42759 2265 59 all all DT 42759 2265 60 men man NNS 42759 2265 61 . . . 42759 2266 1 There there EX 42759 2266 2 are be VBP 42759 2266 3 , , , 42759 2266 4 indeed indeed RB 42759 2266 5 , , , 42759 2266 6 persons person NNS 42759 2266 7 in in IN 42759 2266 8 every every DT 42759 2266 9 walk walk NN 42759 2266 10 of of IN 42759 2266 11 life life NN 42759 2266 12 who who WP 42759 2266 13 work work VBP 42759 2266 14 faithfully faithfully RB 42759 2266 15 under under IN 42759 2266 16 the the DT 42759 2266 17 influence influence NN 42759 2266 18 of of IN 42759 2266 19 the the DT 42759 2266 20 higher high JJR 42759 2266 21 motives motive NNS 42759 2266 22 , , , 42759 2266 23 but but CC 42759 2266 24 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2266 25 are be VBP 42759 2266 26 and and CC 42759 2266 27 always always RB 42759 2266 28 have have VBP 42759 2266 29 been be VBN 42759 2266 30 the the DT 42759 2266 31 exceptions exception NNS 42759 2266 32 in in IN 42759 2266 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2266 34 respective respective JJ 42759 2266 35 classes class NNS 42759 2266 36 . . . 42759 2267 1 The the DT 42759 2267 2 great great JJ 42759 2267 3 majority majority NN 42759 2267 4 have have VBP 42759 2267 5 been be VBN 42759 2267 6 affected affect VBN 42759 2267 7 only only RB 42759 2267 8 feebly feebly RB 42759 2267 9 , , , 42759 2267 10 intermittently intermittently RB 42759 2267 11 , , , 42759 2267 12 and and CC 42759 2267 13 on on IN 42759 2267 14 the the DT 42759 2267 15 whole whole NN 42759 2267 16 ineffectively ineffectively RB 42759 2267 17 by by IN 42759 2267 18 either either DT 42759 2267 19 love love NN 42759 2267 20 of of IN 42759 2267 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2267 22 kind kind NN 42759 2267 23 or or CC 42759 2267 24 the the DT 42759 2267 25 hope hope NN 42759 2267 26 of of IN 42759 2267 27 public public JJ 42759 2267 28 approval approval NN 42759 2267 29 . . . 42759 2268 1 A a DT 42759 2268 2 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2268 3 order order NN 42759 2268 4 could could MD 42759 2268 5 generate generate VB 42759 2268 6 no no DT 42759 2268 7 forces force NNS 42759 2268 8 which which WDT 42759 2268 9 would would MD 42759 2268 10 be be VB 42759 2268 11 as as IN 42759 2268 12 productive productive JJ 42759 2268 13 of of IN 42759 2268 14 unselfish unselfish JJ 42759 2268 15 conduct conduct NN 42759 2268 16 as as IN 42759 2268 17 the the DT 42759 2268 18 motives motive NNS 42759 2268 19 that that WDT 42759 2268 20 are be VBP 42759 2268 21 drawn draw VBN 42759 2268 22 from from IN 42759 2268 23 religion religion NN 42759 2268 24 . . . 42759 2269 1 History history NN 42759 2269 2 shows show VBZ 42759 2269 3 nothing nothing NN 42759 2269 4 comparable comparable JJ 42759 2269 5 either either CC 42759 2269 6 in in IN 42759 2269 7 extent extent NN 42759 2269 8 or or CC 42759 2269 9 intensity intensity NN 42759 2269 10 to to IN 42759 2269 11 the the DT 42759 2269 12 record record NN 42759 2269 13 of of IN 42759 2269 14 self self NN 42759 2269 15 surrender surrender NN 42759 2269 16 and and CC 42759 2269 17 service service NN 42759 2269 18 to to IN 42759 2269 19 the the DT 42759 2269 20 neighbour neighbour NN 42759 2269 21 which which WDT 42759 2269 22 are be VBP 42759 2269 23 due due JJ 42759 2269 24 to to IN 42759 2269 25 the the DT 42759 2269 26 latter latter JJ 42759 2269 27 influence influence NN 42759 2269 28 . . . 42759 2270 1 Yet yet CC 42759 2270 2 religion religion NN 42759 2270 3 has have VBZ 42759 2270 4 never never RB 42759 2270 5 been be VBN 42759 2270 6 able able JJ 42759 2270 7 , , , 42759 2270 8 even even RB 42759 2270 9 in in IN 42759 2270 10 the the DT 42759 2270 11 periods period NNS 42759 2270 12 and and CC 42759 2270 13 places place NNS 42759 2270 14 most most RBS 42759 2270 15 thoroughly thoroughly RB 42759 2270 16 dominated dominate VBN 42759 2270 17 by by IN 42759 2270 18 Christianity Christianity NNP 42759 2270 19 , , , 42759 2270 20 to to TO 42759 2270 21 induce induce VB 42759 2270 22 more more JJR 42759 2270 23 than than IN 42759 2270 24 a a DT 42759 2270 25 small small JJ 42759 2270 26 minority minority NN 42759 2270 27 of of IN 42759 2270 28 the the DT 42759 2270 29 population population NN 42759 2270 30 to to TO 42759 2270 31 adopt adopt VB 42759 2270 32 that that DT 42759 2270 33 life life NN 42759 2270 34 of of IN 42759 2270 35 altruism altruism NN 42759 2270 36 which which WDT 42759 2270 37 would would MD 42759 2270 38 be be VB 42759 2270 39 required require VBN 42759 2270 40 of of IN 42759 2270 41 the the DT 42759 2270 42 great great JJ 42759 2270 43 majority majority NN 42759 2270 44 under under IN 42759 2270 45 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 2270 46 . . . 42759 2271 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 2271 2 , , , 42759 2271 3 the the DT 42759 2271 4 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 2271 5 of of IN 42759 2271 6 the the DT 42759 2271 7 higher high JJR 42759 2271 8 motives motive NNS 42759 2271 9 is be VBZ 42759 2271 10 much much RB 42759 2271 11 greater great JJR 42759 2271 12 among among IN 42759 2271 13 men man NNS 42759 2271 14 devoted devote VBN 42759 2271 15 to to IN 42759 2271 16 scientific scientific JJ 42759 2271 17 , , , 42759 2271 18 intellectual intellectual JJ 42759 2271 19 , , , 42759 2271 20 and and CC 42759 2271 21 religious religious JJ 42759 2271 22 pursuits pursuit NNS 42759 2271 23 than than IN 42759 2271 24 in in IN 42759 2271 25 either either CC 42759 2271 26 the the DT 42759 2271 27 leaders leader NNS 42759 2271 28 or or CC 42759 2271 29 the the DT 42759 2271 30 rank rank NN 42759 2271 31 and and CC 42759 2271 32 file file NN 42759 2271 33 engaged engage VBN 42759 2271 34 in in IN 42759 2271 35 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2271 36 occupations occupation NNS 42759 2271 37 . . . 42759 2272 1 The the DT 42759 2272 2 cause cause NN 42759 2272 3 of of IN 42759 2272 4 this this DT 42759 2272 5 difference difference NN 42759 2272 6 is be VBZ 42759 2272 7 to to TO 42759 2272 8 be be VB 42759 2272 9 sought seek VBN 42759 2272 10 in in IN 42759 2272 11 the the DT 42759 2272 12 varying varying NN 42759 2272 13 nature nature NN 42759 2272 14 of of IN 42759 2272 15 the the DT 42759 2272 16 two two CD 42759 2272 17 classes class NNS 42759 2272 18 of of IN 42759 2272 19 activity activity NN 42759 2272 20 : : : 42759 2272 21 the the DT 42759 2272 22 first first JJ 42759 2272 23 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 2272 24 develops develop VBZ 42759 2272 25 an an DT 42759 2272 26 appreciation appreciation NN 42759 2272 27 of of IN 42759 2272 28 the the DT 42759 2272 29 higher high JJR 42759 2272 30 goods good NNS 42759 2272 31 , , , 42759 2272 32 the the DT 42759 2272 33 things thing NNS 42759 2272 34 of of IN 42759 2272 35 the the DT 42759 2272 36 mind mind NN 42759 2272 37 and and CC 42759 2272 38 the the DT 42759 2272 39 soul soul NN 42759 2272 40 ; ; : 42759 2272 41 the the DT 42759 2272 42 second second JJ 42759 2272 43 compels compel VBZ 42759 2272 44 the the DT 42759 2272 45 attention attention NN 42759 2272 46 of of IN 42759 2272 47 men man NNS 42759 2272 48 to to TO 42759 2272 49 rest rest VB 42759 2272 50 upon upon IN 42759 2272 51 matter matter NN 42759 2272 52 , , , 42759 2272 53 upon upon IN 42759 2272 54 the the DT 42759 2272 55 things thing NNS 42759 2272 56 that that WDT 42759 2272 57 appeal appeal VBP 42759 2272 58 to to IN 42759 2272 59 the the DT 42759 2272 60 senses sense NNS 42759 2272 61 , , , 42759 2272 62 upon upon IN 42759 2272 63 the the DT 42759 2272 64 things thing NNS 42759 2272 65 that that WDT 42759 2272 66 are be VBP 42759 2272 67 measurable measurable JJ 42759 2272 68 in in IN 42759 2272 69 terms term NNS 42759 2272 70 of of IN 42759 2272 71 money money NN 42759 2272 72 . . . 42759 2273 1 There there EX 42759 2273 2 is be VBZ 42759 2273 3 a a DT 42759 2273 4 special special JJ 42759 2273 5 fallacy fallacy NN 42759 2273 6 underlying underlie VBG 42759 2273 7 the the DT 42759 2273 8 emphasis emphasis NN 42759 2273 9 placed place VBN 42759 2273 10 by by IN 42759 2273 11 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2273 12 on on IN 42759 2273 13 the the DT 42759 2273 14 power power NN 42759 2273 15 of of IN 42759 2273 16 public public JJ 42759 2273 17 honour honour NN 42759 2273 18 . . . 42759 2274 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2274 2 consists consist VBZ 42759 2274 3 in in IN 42759 2274 4 the the DT 42759 2274 5 failure failure NN 42759 2274 6 to to TO 42759 2274 7 perceive perceive VB 42759 2274 8 that that IN 42759 2274 9 this this DT 42759 2274 10 good good JJ 42759 2274 11 declines decline NNS 42759 2274 12 in in IN 42759 2274 13 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 2274 14 according accord VBG 42759 2274 15 as as IN 42759 2274 16 the the DT 42759 2274 17 number number NN 42759 2274 18 of of IN 42759 2274 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2274 20 recipients recipient NNS 42759 2274 21 increases increase NNS 42759 2274 22 . . . 42759 2275 1 Even even RB 42759 2275 2 if if IN 42759 2275 3 all all PDT 42759 2275 4 the the DT 42759 2275 5 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2275 6 population population NN 42759 2275 7 were be VBD 42759 2275 8 willing willing JJ 42759 2275 9 to to TO 42759 2275 10 work work VB 42759 2275 11 as as RB 42759 2275 12 hard hard JJ 42759 2275 13 for for IN 42759 2275 14 public public JJ 42759 2275 15 approval approval NN 42759 2275 16 as as IN 42759 2275 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2275 18 now now RB 42759 2275 19 do do VBP 42759 2275 20 for for IN 42759 2275 21 money money NN 42759 2275 22 , , , 42759 2275 23 the the DT 42759 2275 24 results result NNS 42759 2275 25 expected expect VBN 42759 2275 26 by by IN 42759 2275 27 Socialists socialist NNS 42759 2275 28 would would MD 42759 2275 29 not not RB 42759 2275 30 be be VB 42759 2275 31 forthcoming forthcoming JJ 42759 2275 32 . . . 42759 2276 1 Public public JJ 42759 2276 2 recognition recognition NN 42759 2276 3 of of IN 42759 2276 4 unselfish unselfish JJ 42759 2276 5 service service NN 42759 2276 6 is be VBZ 42759 2276 7 now now RB 42759 2276 8 available available JJ 42759 2276 9 in in IN 42759 2276 10 relatively relatively RB 42759 2276 11 great great JJ 42759 2276 12 measure measure NN 42759 2276 13 because because IN 42759 2276 14 the the DT 42759 2276 15 persons person NNS 42759 2276 16 qualifying qualify VBG 42759 2276 17 for for IN 42759 2276 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2276 19 are be VBP 42759 2276 20 relatively relatively RB 42759 2276 21 few few JJ 42759 2276 22 . . . 42759 2277 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2277 2 easily easily RB 42759 2277 3 stand stand VBP 42759 2277 4 out out RP 42759 2277 5 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 42759 2277 6 among among IN 42759 2277 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2277 8 fellows fellow NNS 42759 2277 9 . . . 42759 2278 1 Let let VB 42759 2278 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2278 3 numbers number NNS 42759 2278 4 vastly vastly RB 42759 2278 5 increase increase VBP 42759 2278 6 , , , 42759 2278 7 and and CC 42759 2278 8 unselfishness unselfishness NN 42759 2278 9 would would MD 42759 2278 10 become become VB 42759 2278 11 commonplace commonplace JJ 42759 2278 12 . . . 42759 2279 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2279 2 would would MD 42759 2279 3 no no RB 42759 2279 4 longer long RBR 42759 2279 5 command command VB 42759 2279 6 popular popular JJ 42759 2279 7 recognition recognition NN 42759 2279 8 , , , 42759 2279 9 save save VB 42759 2279 10 in in IN 42759 2279 11 those those DT 42759 2279 12 who who WP 42759 2279 13 displayed display VBD 42759 2279 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2279 15 in in IN 42759 2279 16 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 2279 17 or or CC 42759 2279 18 heroic heroic JJ 42759 2279 19 measure measure NN 42759 2279 20 . . . 42759 2280 1 The the DT 42759 2280 2 public public NN 42759 2280 3 would would MD 42759 2280 4 not not RB 42759 2280 5 have have VB 42759 2280 6 the the DT 42759 2280 7 time time NN 42759 2280 8 nor nor CC 42759 2280 9 take take VB 42759 2280 10 the the DT 42759 2280 11 trouble trouble NN 42759 2280 12 to to TO 42759 2280 13 notice notice VB 42759 2280 14 and and CC 42759 2280 15 honour honour NN 42759 2280 16 adequately adequately RB 42759 2280 17 every every DT 42759 2280 18 floor floor NN 42759 2280 19 walker walker NN 42759 2280 20 , , , 42759 2280 21 retail retail JJ 42759 2280 22 clerk clerk NN 42759 2280 23 , , , 42759 2280 24 factory factory NN 42759 2280 25 operative operative NN 42759 2280 26 , , , 42759 2280 27 street street NN 42759 2280 28 cleaner cleaner NN 42759 2280 29 , , , 42759 2280 30 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 2280 31 labourer labourer NN 42759 2280 32 , , , 42759 2280 33 ditch ditch NNP 42759 2280 34 digger digger NN 42759 2280 35 , , , 42759 2280 36 etc etc FW 42759 2280 37 . . FW 42759 2280 38 , , , 42759 2280 39 who who WP 42759 2280 40 might may MD 42759 2280 41 become become VB 42759 2280 42 a a DT 42759 2280 43 candidate candidate NN 42759 2280 44 for for IN 42759 2280 45 such such JJ 42759 2280 46 recognition recognition NN 42759 2280 47 . . . 42759 2281 1 When when WRB 42759 2281 2 the the DT 42759 2281 3 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2281 4 point point VBP 42759 2281 5 to to IN 42759 2281 6 such such JJ 42759 2281 7 examples example NNS 42759 2281 8 of of IN 42759 2281 9 disinterested disinterested JJ 42759 2281 10 public public JJ 42759 2281 11 service service NN 42759 2281 12 as as IN 42759 2281 13 that that DT 42759 2281 14 of of IN 42759 2281 15 Colonel Colonel NNP 42759 2281 16 Goethals Goethals NNPS 42759 2281 17 in in IN 42759 2281 18 building build VBG 42759 2281 19 the the DT 42759 2281 20 Panama Panama NNP 42759 2281 21 Canal Canal NNP 42759 2281 22 , , , 42759 2281 23 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2281 24 confound confound VBP 42759 2281 25 the the DT 42759 2281 26 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 2281 27 with with IN 42759 2281 28 the the DT 42759 2281 29 average average NN 42759 2281 30 . . . 42759 2282 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2282 2 assume assume VBP 42759 2282 3 that that IN 42759 2282 4 , , , 42759 2282 5 since since IN 42759 2282 6 an an DT 42759 2282 7 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 2282 8 man man NN 42759 2282 9 performs perform VBZ 42759 2282 10 an an DT 42759 2282 11 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 2282 12 task task NN 42759 2282 13 from from IN 42759 2282 14 high high JJ 42759 2282 15 motives motive NNS 42759 2282 16 , , , 42759 2282 17 all all DT 42759 2282 18 men man NNS 42759 2282 19 can can MD 42759 2282 20 be be VB 42759 2282 21 got get VBN 42759 2282 22 to to TO 42759 2282 23 act act VB 42759 2282 24 likewise likewise RB 42759 2282 25 in in IN 42759 2282 26 all all DT 42759 2282 27 kinds kind NNS 42759 2282 28 of of IN 42759 2282 29 operations operation NNS 42759 2282 30 . . . 42759 2283 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2283 2 forget forget VBP 42759 2283 3 that that IN 42759 2283 4 the the DT 42759 2283 5 Panama Panama NNP 42759 2283 6 Canal Canal NNP 42759 2283 7 presented present VBD 42759 2283 8 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 2283 9 of of IN 42759 2283 10 self self NN 42759 2283 11 satisfying satisfy VBG 42759 2283 12 achievement achievement NN 42759 2283 13 and and CC 42759 2283 14 fame fame NN 42759 2283 15 which which WDT 42759 2283 16 do do VBP 42759 2283 17 not not RB 42759 2283 18 occur occur VB 42759 2283 19 once once RB 42759 2283 20 in in IN 42759 2283 21 a a DT 42759 2283 22 thousand thousand CD 42759 2283 23 years year NNS 42759 2283 24 ; ; : 42759 2283 25 that that IN 42759 2283 26 the the DT 42759 2283 27 traditions tradition NNS 42759 2283 28 and and CC 42759 2283 29 training training NN 42759 2283 30 of of IN 42759 2283 31 the the DT 42759 2283 32 army army NN 42759 2283 33 have have VBP 42759 2283 34 during during IN 42759 2283 35 many many JJ 42759 2283 36 centuries century NNS 42759 2283 37 deliberately deliberately RB 42759 2283 38 and and CC 42759 2283 39 consistently consistently RB 42759 2283 40 aimed aim VBN 42759 2283 41 and and CC 42759 2283 42 tended tend VBD 42759 2283 43 to to TO 42759 2283 44 produce produce VB 42759 2283 45 an an DT 42759 2283 46 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 2283 47 high high JJ 42759 2283 48 standard standard NN 42759 2283 49 of of IN 42759 2283 50 honour honour NN 42759 2283 51 and and CC 42759 2283 52 disinterestedness disinterestedness NN 42759 2283 53 ; ; : 42759 2283 54 that that IN 42759 2283 55 , , , 42759 2283 56 even even RB 42759 2283 57 so so RB 42759 2283 58 , , , 42759 2283 59 the the DT 42759 2283 60 majority majority NN 42759 2283 61 of of IN 42759 2283 62 army army NN 42759 2283 63 officers officer NNS 42759 2283 64 have have VBP 42759 2283 65 not not RB 42759 2283 66 in in IN 42759 2283 67 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2283 68 civil civil JJ 42759 2283 69 assignments assignment NNS 42759 2283 70 shown show VBD 42759 2283 71 the the DT 42759 2283 72 same same JJ 42759 2283 73 degree degree NN 42759 2283 74 of of IN 42759 2283 75 faithfulness faithfulness NN 42759 2283 76 to to IN 42759 2283 77 the the DT 42759 2283 78 public public JJ 42759 2283 79 welfare welfare NN 42759 2283 80 as as IN 42759 2283 81 Colonel Colonel NNP 42759 2283 82 Goethals Goethals NNPS 42759 2283 83 ; ; : 42759 2283 84 that that IN 42759 2283 85 the the DT 42759 2283 86 Canal Canal NNP 42759 2283 87 was be VBD 42759 2283 88 built build VBN 42759 2283 89 under under IN 42759 2283 90 a a DT 42759 2283 91 régime régime NN 42759 2283 92 of of IN 42759 2283 93 " " `` 42759 2283 94 benevolent benevolent JJ 42759 2283 95 despotism despotism NN 42759 2283 96 , , , 42759 2283 97 " " '' 42759 2283 98 which which WDT 42759 2283 99 placed place VBD 42759 2283 100 no no DT 42759 2283 101 reliance reliance NN 42759 2283 102 upon upon IN 42759 2283 103 the the DT 42759 2283 104 " " `` 42759 2283 105 social social JJ 42759 2283 106 mindedness mindedness NN 42759 2283 107 " " '' 42759 2283 108 of of IN 42759 2283 109 the the DT 42759 2283 110 subordinate subordinate JJ 42759 2283 111 workers worker NNS 42759 2283 112 ; ; : 42759 2283 113 and and CC 42759 2283 114 that that IN 42759 2283 115 the the DT 42759 2283 116 latter latter JJ 42759 2283 117 , , , 42759 2283 118 far far RB 42759 2283 119 from from IN 42759 2283 120 showing show VBG 42759 2283 121 any any DT 42759 2283 122 desire desire NN 42759 2283 123 to to TO 42759 2283 124 qualify qualify VB 42759 2283 125 as as IN 42759 2283 126 altruists altruist NNS 42759 2283 127 or or CC 42759 2283 128 public public JJ 42759 2283 129 benefactors benefactor NNS 42759 2283 130 , , , 42759 2283 131 demanded demand VBD 42759 2283 132 and and CC 42759 2283 133 received receive VBD 42759 2283 134 material material JJ 42759 2283 135 recognition recognition NN 42759 2283 136 in in IN 42759 2283 137 the the DT 42759 2283 138 form form NN 42759 2283 139 of of IN 42759 2283 140 wages wage NNS 42759 2283 141 , , , 42759 2283 142 perquisites perquisite NNS 42759 2283 143 , , , 42759 2283 144 and and CC 42759 2283 145 gratuities gratuity NNS 42759 2283 146 which which WDT 42759 2283 147 greatly greatly RB 42759 2283 148 surpassed surpass VBD 42759 2283 149 the the DT 42759 2283 150 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 2283 151 received receive VBN 42759 2283 152 by by IN 42759 2283 153 any any DT 42759 2283 154 other other JJ 42759 2283 155 labour labour JJ 42759 2283 156 force force NN 42759 2283 157 in in IN 42759 2283 158 history history NN 42759 2283 159 . . . 42759 2284 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2284 2 132 132 CD 42759 2284 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2284 4 In in IN 42759 2284 5 a a DT 42759 2284 6 word word NN 42759 2284 7 , , , 42759 2284 8 wherever wherever WRB 42759 2284 9 in in IN 42759 2284 10 the the DT 42759 2284 11 construction construction NN 42759 2284 12 of of IN 42759 2284 13 the the DT 42759 2284 14 Canal Canal NNP 42759 2284 15 notable notable JJ 42759 2284 16 disinterestedness disinterestedness NN 42759 2284 17 or or CC 42759 2284 18 appreciation appreciation NN 42759 2284 19 of of IN 42759 2284 20 public public JJ 42759 2284 21 honour honour NN 42759 2284 22 was be VBD 42759 2284 23 shown show VBN 42759 2284 24 , , , 42759 2284 25 the the DT 42759 2284 26 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 2284 27 were be VBD 42759 2284 28 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 2284 29 ; ; : 42759 2284 30 where where WRB 42759 2284 31 the the DT 42759 2284 32 situation situation NN 42759 2284 33 was be VBD 42759 2284 34 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 2284 35 , , , 42759 2284 36 the the DT 42759 2284 37 Canal Canal NNP 42759 2284 38 builders builder NNS 42759 2284 39 were be VBD 42759 2284 40 unable unable JJ 42759 2284 41 to to TO 42759 2284 42 rise rise VB 42759 2284 43 above above IN 42759 2284 44 the the DT 42759 2284 45 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 2284 46 motives motive NNS 42759 2284 47 of of IN 42759 2284 48 selfish selfish JJ 42759 2284 49 advantage advantage NN 42759 2284 50 . . . 42759 2285 1 Beneath beneath IN 42759 2285 2 all all PDT 42759 2285 3 the the DT 42759 2285 4 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2285 5 argument argument NN 42759 2285 6 on on IN 42759 2285 7 this this DT 42759 2285 8 subject subject NN 42759 2285 9 lies lie VBZ 42759 2285 10 the the DT 42759 2285 11 assumption assumption NN 42759 2285 12 that that IN 42759 2285 13 the the DT 42759 2285 14 attitude attitude NN 42759 2285 15 of of IN 42759 2285 16 the the DT 42759 2285 17 _ _ NNP 42759 2285 18 average average JJ 42759 2285 19 man man NN 42759 2285 20 _ _ NNP 42759 2285 21 toward toward IN 42759 2285 22 the the DT 42759 2285 23 higher high JJR 42759 2285 24 motives motive NNS 42759 2285 25 can can MD 42759 2285 26 by by IN 42759 2285 27 some some DT 42759 2285 28 mysterious mysterious JJ 42759 2285 29 process process NN 42759 2285 30 be be VB 42759 2285 31 completely completely RB 42759 2285 32 _ _ NNP 42759 2285 33 revolutionised revolutionise VBN 42759 2285 34 _ _ NNP 42759 2285 35 . . . 42759 2286 1 This this DT 42759 2286 2 is be VBZ 42759 2286 3 contrary contrary JJ 42759 2286 4 to to IN 42759 2286 5 all all DT 42759 2286 6 experience experience NN 42759 2286 7 , , , 42759 2286 8 and and CC 42759 2286 9 to to IN 42759 2286 10 all all DT 42759 2286 11 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2286 12 probability probability NN 42759 2286 13 . . . 42759 2287 1 Only only RB 42759 2287 2 a a DT 42759 2287 3 small small JJ 42759 2287 4 minority minority NN 42759 2287 5 of of IN 42759 2287 6 men man NNS 42759 2287 7 have have VBP 42759 2287 8 ever ever RB 42759 2287 9 , , , 42759 2287 10 in in IN 42759 2287 11 any any DT 42759 2287 12 society society NN 42759 2287 13 or or CC 42759 2287 14 environment environment NN 42759 2287 15 , , , 42759 2287 16 been be VBN 42759 2287 17 dominated dominate VBN 42759 2287 18 mainly mainly RB 42759 2287 19 by by IN 42759 2287 20 altruism altruism NN 42759 2287 21 or or CC 42759 2287 22 the the DT 42759 2287 23 desire desire NN 42759 2287 24 of of IN 42759 2287 25 public public JJ 42759 2287 26 honour honour NN 42759 2287 27 . . . 42759 2288 1 What what WDT 42759 2288 2 reason reason NN 42759 2288 3 is be VBZ 42759 2288 4 there there RB 42759 2288 5 to to TO 42759 2288 6 expect expect VB 42759 2288 7 that that IN 42759 2288 8 men man NNS 42759 2288 9 will will MD 42759 2288 10 act act VB 42759 2288 11 differently differently RB 42759 2288 12 in in IN 42759 2288 13 the the DT 42759 2288 14 future future NN 42759 2288 15 ? ? . 42759 2289 1 Neither neither DT 42759 2289 2 legislation legislation NN 42759 2289 3 nor nor CC 42759 2289 4 education education NN 42759 2289 5 can can MD 42759 2289 6 make make VB 42759 2289 7 men man NNS 42759 2289 8 love love VB 42759 2289 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2289 10 neighbours neighbour NNS 42759 2289 11 more more RBR 42759 2289 12 than than IN 42759 2289 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 2289 14 , , , 42759 2289 15 or or CC 42759 2289 16 love love VBP 42759 2289 17 the the DT 42759 2289 18 applause applause NN 42759 2289 19 of of IN 42759 2289 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2289 21 neighbours neighbour NNS 42759 2289 22 more more RBR 42759 2289 23 than than IN 42759 2289 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2289 25 own own JJ 42759 2289 26 material material NN 42759 2289 27 welfare welfare NN 42759 2289 28 . . . 42759 2290 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2290 2 Restricting Restricting NNP 42759 2290 3 Individual Individual NNP 42759 2290 4 Liberty Liberty NNP 42759 2290 5 _ _ NNP 42759 2290 6 Even even RB 42759 2290 7 though though IN 42759 2290 8 human human JJ 42759 2290 9 nature nature NN 42759 2290 10 should should MD 42759 2290 11 undergo undergo VB 42759 2290 12 the the DT 42759 2290 13 degree degree NN 42759 2290 14 of of IN 42759 2290 15 miraculous miraculous JJ 42759 2290 16 transformation transformation NN 42759 2290 17 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2290 18 to to TO 42759 2290 19 maintain maintain VB 42759 2290 20 an an DT 42759 2290 21 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2290 22 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2290 23 system system NN 42759 2290 24 on on IN 42759 2290 25 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2290 26 lines line NNS 42759 2290 27 , , , 42759 2290 28 such such PDT 42759 2290 29 a a DT 42759 2290 30 social social JJ 42759 2290 31 organisation organisation NN 42759 2290 32 must must MD 42759 2290 33 soon soon RB 42759 2290 34 collapse collapse VB 42759 2290 35 because because IN 42759 2290 36 of of IN 42759 2290 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2290 38 injurious injurious JJ 42759 2290 39 effect effect NN 42759 2290 40 upon upon IN 42759 2290 41 individual individual JJ 42759 2290 42 liberty liberty NN 42759 2290 43 . . . 42759 2291 1 Freedom freedom NN 42759 2291 2 of of IN 42759 2291 3 choice choice NN 42759 2291 4 would would MD 42759 2291 5 be be VB 42759 2291 6 abolished abolish VBN 42759 2291 7 in in IN 42759 2291 8 the the DT 42759 2291 9 most most RBS 42759 2291 10 vital vital JJ 42759 2291 11 economic economic JJ 42759 2291 12 transactions transaction NNS 42759 2291 13 ; ; : 42759 2291 14 for for IN 42759 2291 15 there there EX 42759 2291 16 would would MD 42759 2291 17 be be VB 42759 2291 18 but but CC 42759 2291 19 one one CD 42759 2291 20 buyer buyer NN 42759 2291 21 of of IN 42759 2291 22 labour labour NN 42759 2291 23 , , , 42759 2291 24 and and CC 42759 2291 25 one one CD 42759 2291 26 seller seller NN 42759 2291 27 of of IN 42759 2291 28 commodities commodity NNS 42759 2291 29 . . . 42759 2292 1 And and CC 42759 2292 2 these these DT 42759 2292 3 two two CD 42759 2292 4 would would MD 42759 2292 5 be be VB 42759 2292 6 identical identical JJ 42759 2292 7 , , , 42759 2292 8 namely namely RB 42759 2292 9 , , , 42759 2292 10 the the DT 42759 2292 11 State State NNP 42759 2292 12 . . . 42759 2293 1 With with IN 42759 2293 2 the the DT 42759 2293 3 exception exception NN 42759 2293 4 of of IN 42759 2293 5 the the DT 42759 2293 6 small small JJ 42759 2293 7 minority minority NN 42759 2293 8 that that WDT 42759 2293 9 might may MD 42759 2293 10 be be VB 42759 2293 11 engaged engage VBN 42759 2293 12 in in IN 42759 2293 13 purely purely RB 42759 2293 14 individual individual JJ 42759 2293 15 avocations avocation NNS 42759 2293 16 , , , 42759 2293 17 and and CC 42759 2293 18 in in IN 42759 2293 19 co co JJ 42759 2293 20 - - JJ 42759 2293 21 operative operative JJ 42759 2293 22 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 2293 23 , , , 42759 2293 24 men man NNS 42759 2293 25 would would MD 42759 2293 26 be be VB 42759 2293 27 compelled compel VBN 42759 2293 28 to to TO 42759 2293 29 sell sell VB 42759 2293 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2293 31 labour labour NN 42759 2293 32 to to IN 42759 2293 33 either either CC 42759 2293 34 the the DT 42759 2293 35 municipality municipality NN 42759 2293 36 or or CC 42759 2293 37 the the DT 42759 2293 38 national national JJ 42759 2293 39 government government NN 42759 2293 40 . . . 42759 2294 1 As as IN 42759 2294 2 competition competition NN 42759 2294 3 between between IN 42759 2294 4 these these DT 42759 2294 5 two two CD 42759 2294 6 political political JJ 42759 2294 7 agencies agency NNS 42759 2294 8 in in IN 42759 2294 9 the the DT 42759 2294 10 matter matter NN 42759 2294 11 of of IN 42759 2294 12 wages wage NNS 42759 2294 13 and and CC 42759 2294 14 other other JJ 42759 2294 15 conditions condition NNS 42759 2294 16 of of IN 42759 2294 17 labour labour NN 42759 2294 18 could could MD 42759 2294 19 not not RB 42759 2294 20 be be VB 42759 2294 21 permitted permit VBN 42759 2294 22 , , , 42759 2294 23 there there EX 42759 2294 24 would would MD 42759 2294 25 be be VB 42759 2294 26 virtually virtually RB 42759 2294 27 only only RB 42759 2294 28 one one CD 42759 2294 29 employer employer NN 42759 2294 30 . . . 42759 2295 1 Practically practically RB 42759 2295 2 all all DT 42759 2295 3 material material NN 42759 2295 4 goods good NNS 42759 2295 5 would would MD 42759 2295 6 have have VB 42759 2295 7 to to TO 42759 2295 8 be be VB 42759 2295 9 purchased purchase VBN 42759 2295 10 from from IN 42759 2295 11 either either CC 42759 2295 12 the the DT 42759 2295 13 municipal municipal JJ 42759 2295 14 or or CC 42759 2295 15 the the DT 42759 2295 16 national national JJ 42759 2295 17 shops shop NNS 42759 2295 18 and and CC 42759 2295 19 stores store NNS 42759 2295 20 . . . 42759 2296 1 Since since IN 42759 2296 2 the the DT 42759 2296 3 city city NN 42759 2296 4 and and CC 42759 2296 5 the the DT 42759 2296 6 nation nation NN 42759 2296 7 would would MD 42759 2296 8 produce produce VB 42759 2296 9 different different JJ 42759 2296 10 kinds kind NNS 42759 2296 11 of of IN 42759 2296 12 goods good NNS 42759 2296 13 , , , 42759 2296 14 the the DT 42759 2296 15 purchaser purchaser NN 42759 2296 16 of of IN 42759 2296 17 any any DT 42759 2296 18 given give VBN 42759 2296 19 article article NN 42759 2296 20 would would MD 42759 2296 21 be be VB 42759 2296 22 compelled compel VBN 42759 2296 23 to to TO 42759 2296 24 deal deal VB 42759 2296 25 with with IN 42759 2296 26 one one CD 42759 2296 27 seller seller NN 42759 2296 28 . . . 42759 2297 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2297 2 freedom freedom NN 42759 2297 3 of of IN 42759 2297 4 choice choice NN 42759 2297 5 would would MD 42759 2297 6 be be VB 42759 2297 7 further further RB 42759 2297 8 restricted restrict VBN 42759 2297 9 by by IN 42759 2297 10 the the DT 42759 2297 11 fact fact NN 42759 2297 12 that that IN 42759 2297 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2297 14 would would MD 42759 2297 15 have have VB 42759 2297 16 to to TO 42759 2297 17 be be VB 42759 2297 18 content content JJ 42759 2297 19 with with IN 42759 2297 20 those those DT 42759 2297 21 kinds kind NNS 42759 2297 22 and and CC 42759 2297 23 grades grade NNS 42759 2297 24 of of IN 42759 2297 25 commodities commodity NNS 42759 2297 26 which which WDT 42759 2297 27 the the DT 42759 2297 28 seller seller NN 42759 2297 29 saw see VBD 42759 2297 30 fit fit JJ 42759 2297 31 to to TO 42759 2297 32 produce produce VB 42759 2297 33 . . . 42759 2298 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2298 2 could could MD 42759 2298 3 not not RB 42759 2298 4 create create VB 42759 2298 5 an an DT 42759 2298 6 effective effective JJ 42759 2298 7 demand demand NN 42759 2298 8 for for IN 42759 2298 9 new new JJ 42759 2298 10 forms form NNS 42759 2298 11 and and CC 42759 2298 12 varieties variety NNS 42759 2298 13 of of IN 42759 2298 14 goods good NNS 42759 2298 15 , , , 42759 2298 16 as as IN 42759 2298 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2298 18 now now RB 42759 2298 19 does do VBZ 42759 2298 20 , , , 42759 2298 21 by by IN 42759 2298 22 stimulating stimulate VBG 42759 2298 23 the the DT 42759 2298 24 ingenuity ingenuity NN 42759 2298 25 and and CC 42759 2298 26 acquisitiveness acquisitiveness NN 42759 2298 27 of of IN 42759 2298 28 competing compete VBG 42759 2298 29 producers producer NNS 42759 2298 30 and and CC 42759 2298 31 dealers dealer NNS 42759 2298 32 . . . 42759 2299 1 Prices price NNS 42759 2299 2 and and CC 42759 2299 3 wages wage NNS 42759 2299 4 would would MD 42759 2299 5 , , , 42759 2299 6 of of IN 42759 2299 7 course course NN 42759 2299 8 , , , 42759 2299 9 be be VB 42759 2299 10 fixed fix VBN 42759 2299 11 beforehand beforehand RB 42759 2299 12 by by IN 42759 2299 13 the the DT 42759 2299 14 government government NN 42759 2299 15 . . . 42759 2300 1 The the DT 42759 2300 2 supposition supposition NN 42759 2300 3 that that IN 42759 2300 4 this this DT 42759 2300 5 function function NN 42759 2300 6 might may MD 42759 2300 7 be be VB 42759 2300 8 left leave VBN 42759 2300 9 to to IN 42759 2300 10 the the DT 42759 2300 11 workers worker NNS 42759 2300 12 in in IN 42759 2300 13 each each DT 42759 2300 14 industry industry NN 42759 2300 15 is be VBZ 42759 2300 16 utterly utterly RB 42759 2300 17 impracticable impracticable JJ 42759 2300 18 . . . 42759 2301 1 Such such PDT 42759 2301 2 an an DT 42759 2301 3 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 2301 4 would would MD 42759 2301 5 involve involve VB 42759 2301 6 a a DT 42759 2301 7 grand grand JJ 42759 2301 8 scramble scramble NN 42759 2301 9 among among IN 42759 2301 10 the the DT 42759 2301 11 different different JJ 42759 2301 12 industries industry NNS 42759 2301 13 to to TO 42759 2301 14 see see VB 42759 2301 15 which which WDT 42759 2301 16 could could MD 42759 2301 17 pay pay VB 42759 2301 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2301 19 own own JJ 42759 2301 20 members member NNS 42759 2301 21 the the DT 42759 2301 22 highest high JJS 42759 2301 23 wages wage NNS 42759 2301 24 , , , 42759 2301 25 and and CC 42759 2301 26 charge charge VB 42759 2301 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2301 28 neighbours neighbour NNS 42759 2301 29 ' ' POS 42759 2301 30 members member NNS 42759 2301 31 the the DT 42759 2301 32 highest high JJS 42759 2301 33 prices price NNS 42759 2301 34 . . . 42759 2302 1 The the DT 42759 2302 2 final final JJ 42759 2302 3 result result NN 42759 2302 4 would would MD 42759 2302 5 be be VB 42759 2302 6 a a DT 42759 2302 7 level level NN 42759 2302 8 of of IN 42759 2302 9 prices price NNS 42759 2302 10 so so RB 42759 2302 11 high high JJ 42759 2302 12 that that IN 42759 2302 13 only only RB 42759 2302 14 an an DT 42759 2302 15 alert alert JJ 42759 2302 16 and and CC 42759 2302 17 vigorous vigorous JJ 42759 2302 18 section section NN 42759 2302 19 of of IN 42759 2302 20 the the DT 42759 2302 21 workers worker NNS 42759 2302 22 in in IN 42759 2302 23 each each DT 42759 2302 24 industry industry NN 42759 2302 25 could could MD 42759 2302 26 find find VB 42759 2302 27 employment employment NN 42759 2302 28 . . . 42759 2303 1 Not not RB 42759 2303 2 only only RB 42759 2303 3 wages wage NNS 42759 2303 4 and and CC 42759 2303 5 prices price NNS 42759 2303 6 but but CC 42759 2303 7 hours hour NNS 42759 2303 8 , , , 42759 2303 9 safety safety NN 42759 2303 10 requirements requirement NNS 42759 2303 11 , , , 42759 2303 12 and and CC 42759 2303 13 all all PDT 42759 2303 14 the the DT 42759 2303 15 other other JJ 42759 2303 16 general general JJ 42759 2303 17 conditions condition NNS 42759 2303 18 of of IN 42759 2303 19 employment employment NN 42759 2303 20 , , , 42759 2303 21 would would MD 42759 2303 22 be be VB 42759 2303 23 regulated regulate VBN 42759 2303 24 by by IN 42759 2303 25 the the DT 42759 2303 26 government government NN 42759 2303 27 . . . 42759 2304 1 The the DT 42759 2304 2 individuals individual NNS 42759 2304 3 in in IN 42759 2304 4 each each DT 42759 2304 5 industry industry NN 42759 2304 6 could could MD 42759 2304 7 not not RB 42759 2304 8 be be VB 42759 2304 9 permitted permit VBN 42759 2304 10 to to TO 42759 2304 11 determine determine VB 42759 2304 12 these these DT 42759 2304 13 matters matter NNS 42759 2304 14 any any DT 42759 2304 15 more more RBR 42759 2304 16 than than IN 42759 2304 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2304 18 could could MD 42759 2304 19 be be VB 42759 2304 20 permitted permit VBN 42759 2304 21 to to TO 42759 2304 22 determine determine VB 42759 2304 23 wages wage NNS 42759 2304 24 . . . 42759 2305 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 2305 2 , , , 42759 2305 3 all all PDT 42759 2305 4 these these DT 42759 2305 5 regulations regulation NNS 42759 2305 6 would would MD 42759 2305 7 from from IN 42759 2305 8 the the DT 42759 2305 9 nature nature NN 42759 2305 10 of of IN 42759 2305 11 the the DT 42759 2305 12 case case NN 42759 2305 13 continue continue VBP 42759 2305 14 unchanged unchanged JJ 42759 2305 15 for for IN 42759 2305 16 a a DT 42759 2305 17 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2305 18 period period NN 42759 2305 19 of of IN 42759 2305 20 time time NN 42759 2305 21 . . . 42759 2306 1 The the DT 42759 2306 2 restriction restriction NN 42759 2306 3 of of IN 42759 2306 4 choice choice NN 42759 2306 5 enforced enforce VBN 42759 2306 6 upon upon IN 42759 2306 7 the the DT 42759 2306 8 sellers seller NNS 42759 2306 9 of of IN 42759 2306 10 labour labour NN 42759 2306 11 and and CC 42759 2306 12 the the DT 42759 2306 13 buyers buyer NNS 42759 2306 14 of of IN 42759 2306 15 goods good NNS 42759 2306 16 , , , 42759 2306 17 the the DT 42759 2306 18 utter utter JJ 42759 2306 19 dependence dependence NN 42759 2306 20 of of IN 42759 2306 21 the the DT 42759 2306 22 population population NN 42759 2306 23 upon upon IN 42759 2306 24 one one CD 42759 2306 25 agency agency NN 42759 2306 26 in in IN 42759 2306 27 all all PDT 42759 2306 28 the the DT 42759 2306 29 affairs affair NNS 42759 2306 30 of of IN 42759 2306 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2306 32 economic economic JJ 42759 2306 33 as as RB 42759 2306 34 well well RB 42759 2306 35 as as IN 42759 2306 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2306 37 political political JJ 42759 2306 38 life life NN 42759 2306 39 , , , 42759 2306 40 the the DT 42759 2306 41 tremendous tremendous JJ 42759 2306 42 social social JJ 42759 2306 43 power power NN 42759 2306 44 concentrated concentrate VBN 42759 2306 45 in in IN 42759 2306 46 the the DT 42759 2306 47 State State NNP 42759 2306 48 , , , 42759 2306 49 would would MD 42759 2306 50 produce produce VB 42759 2306 51 a a DT 42759 2306 52 diminution diminution NN 42759 2306 53 of of IN 42759 2306 54 individual individual JJ 42759 2306 55 liberty liberty NN 42759 2306 56 and and CC 42759 2306 57 a a DT 42759 2306 58 perfection perfection NN 42759 2306 59 of of IN 42759 2306 60 political political JJ 42759 2306 61 despotism despotism NN 42759 2306 62 surpassing surpass VBG 42759 2306 63 anything anything NN 42759 2306 64 that that WDT 42759 2306 65 the the DT 42759 2306 66 world world NN 42759 2306 67 has have VBZ 42759 2306 68 ever ever RB 42759 2306 69 seen see VBN 42759 2306 70 . . . 42759 2307 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2307 2 would would MD 42759 2307 3 not not RB 42759 2307 4 long long RB 42759 2307 5 be be VB 42759 2307 6 tolerated tolerate VBN 42759 2307 7 by by IN 42759 2307 8 any any DT 42759 2307 9 self self NN 42759 2307 10 respecting respect VBG 42759 2307 11 people people NNS 42759 2307 12 . . . 42759 2308 1 To to TO 42759 2308 2 reply reply VB 42759 2308 3 that that IN 42759 2308 4 the the DT 42759 2308 5 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2308 6 order order NN 42759 2308 7 would would MD 42759 2308 8 be be VB 42759 2308 9 a a DT 42759 2308 10 democracy democracy NN 42759 2308 11 , , , 42759 2308 12 and and CC 42759 2308 13 that that IN 42759 2308 14 the the DT 42759 2308 15 people people NNS 42759 2308 16 could could MD 42759 2308 17 vote vote VB 42759 2308 18 out out IN 42759 2308 19 of of IN 42759 2308 20 existence existence NN 42759 2308 21 any any DT 42759 2308 22 distasteful distasteful JJ 42759 2308 23 regulation regulation NN 42759 2308 24 , , , 42759 2308 25 is be VBZ 42759 2308 26 to to TO 42759 2308 27 play play VB 42759 2308 28 with with IN 42759 2308 29 words word NNS 42759 2308 30 . . . 42759 2309 1 No no RB 42759 2309 2 matter matter RB 42759 2309 3 how how WRB 42759 2309 4 responsive responsive JJ 42759 2309 5 the the DT 42759 2309 6 governing govern VBG 42759 2309 7 and and CC 42759 2309 8 managing manage VBG 42759 2309 9 authorities authority NNS 42759 2309 10 might may MD 42759 2309 11 be be VB 42759 2309 12 to to IN 42759 2309 13 the the DT 42759 2309 14 popular popular JJ 42759 2309 15 will will NN 42759 2309 16 , , , 42759 2309 17 the the DT 42759 2309 18 dependence dependence NN 42759 2309 19 of of IN 42759 2309 20 the the DT 42759 2309 21 individual individual NN 42759 2309 22 would would MD 42759 2309 23 prove prove VB 42759 2309 24 intolerable intolerable JJ 42759 2309 25 . . . 42759 2310 1 Not not RB 42759 2310 2 the the DT 42759 2310 3 manner manner NN 42759 2310 4 in in IN 42759 2310 5 which which WDT 42759 2310 6 this this DT 42759 2310 7 tremendous tremendous JJ 42759 2310 8 social social JJ 42759 2310 9 power power NN 42759 2310 10 is be VBZ 42759 2310 11 constituted constituted JJ 42759 2310 12 , , , 42759 2310 13 nor nor CC 42759 2310 14 the the DT 42759 2310 15 personnel personnel NNS 42759 2310 16 of of IN 42759 2310 17 those those DT 42759 2310 18 exercising exercise VBG 42759 2310 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2310 20 , , , 42759 2310 21 but but CC 42759 2310 22 the the DT 42759 2310 23 fact fact NN 42759 2310 24 that that IN 42759 2310 25 so so RB 42759 2310 26 much much JJ 42759 2310 27 power power NN 42759 2310 28 is be VBZ 42759 2310 29 lodged lodge VBN 42759 2310 30 in in IN 42759 2310 31 one one CD 42759 2310 32 agency agency NN 42759 2310 33 , , , 42759 2310 34 and and CC 42759 2310 35 so so RB 42759 2310 36 little little JJ 42759 2310 37 immediate immediate JJ 42759 2310 38 control control NN 42759 2310 39 of of IN 42759 2310 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2310 41 affairs affair NNS 42759 2310 42 left leave VBN 42759 2310 43 to to IN 42759 2310 44 the the DT 42759 2310 45 individual,--is individual,--is NNP 42759 2310 46 the the DT 42759 2310 47 heart heart NN 42759 2310 48 of of IN 42759 2310 49 the the DT 42759 2310 50 evil evil JJ 42759 2310 51 situation situation NN 42759 2310 52 . . . 42759 2311 1 In in IN 42759 2311 2 a a DT 42759 2311 3 word word NN 42759 2311 4 , , , 42759 2311 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2311 6 is be VBZ 42759 2311 7 a a DT 42759 2311 8 question question NN 42759 2311 9 of of IN 42759 2311 10 the the DT 42759 2311 11 liberty liberty NN 42759 2311 12 of of IN 42759 2311 13 the the DT 42759 2311 14 individual individual NN 42759 2311 15 versus versus IN 42759 2311 16 the the DT 42759 2311 17 all all DT 42759 2311 18 pervading pervade VBG 42759 2311 19 control control NN 42759 2311 20 of of IN 42759 2311 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2311 22 actions action NNS 42759 2311 23 by by IN 42759 2311 24 an an DT 42759 2311 25 agency agency NN 42759 2311 26 other other JJ 42759 2311 27 than than IN 42759 2311 28 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 2311 29 . . . 42759 2312 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 2312 2 , , , 42759 2312 3 the the DT 42759 2312 4 people people NNS 42759 2312 5 in in IN 42759 2312 6 a a DT 42759 2312 7 democracy democracy NN 42759 2312 8 means mean VBZ 42759 2312 9 a a DT 42759 2312 10 majority majority NN 42759 2312 11 , , , 42759 2312 12 or or CC 42759 2312 13 a a DT 42759 2312 14 compact compact JJ 42759 2312 15 minority minority NN 42759 2312 16 . . . 42759 2313 1 Under under IN 42759 2313 2 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2313 3 the the DT 42759 2313 4 controlling control VBG 42759 2313 5 section section NN 42759 2313 6 of of IN 42759 2313 7 the the DT 42759 2313 8 voting voting NN 42759 2313 9 population population NN 42759 2313 10 would would MD 42759 2313 11 possess possess VB 42759 2313 12 so so RB 42759 2313 13 much much JJ 42759 2313 14 power power NN 42759 2313 15 , , , 42759 2313 16 political political JJ 42759 2313 17 and and CC 42759 2313 18 economic economic JJ 42759 2313 19 , , , 42759 2313 20 that that IN 42759 2313 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2313 22 could could MD 42759 2313 23 impose impose VB 42759 2313 24 whatever whatever WDT 42759 2313 25 conditions condition NNS 42759 2313 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2313 27 pleased please VBD 42759 2313 28 upon upon IN 42759 2313 29 the the DT 42759 2313 30 non non JJ 42759 2313 31 - - JJ 42759 2313 32 controlling controlling JJ 42759 2313 33 section section NN 42759 2313 34 for for IN 42759 2313 35 an an DT 42759 2313 36 almost almost RB 42759 2313 37 indefinite indefinite JJ 42759 2313 38 period period NN 42759 2313 39 of of IN 42759 2313 40 time time NN 42759 2313 41 . . . 42759 2314 1 The the DT 42759 2314 2 members member NNS 42759 2314 3 of of IN 42759 2314 4 the the DT 42759 2314 5 latter latter JJ 42759 2314 6 part part NN 42759 2314 7 of of IN 42759 2314 8 the the DT 42759 2314 9 population population NN 42759 2314 10 would would MD 42759 2314 11 not not RB 42759 2314 12 only only RB 42759 2314 13 be be VB 42759 2314 14 deprived deprive VBN 42759 2314 15 of of IN 42759 2314 16 that that DT 42759 2314 17 immediate immediate JJ 42759 2314 18 liberty liberty NN 42759 2314 19 which which WDT 42759 2314 20 consists consist VBZ 42759 2314 21 in in IN 42759 2314 22 the the DT 42759 2314 23 power power NN 42759 2314 24 to to TO 42759 2314 25 determine determine VB 42759 2314 26 the the DT 42759 2314 27 details detail NNS 42759 2314 28 of of IN 42759 2314 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2314 30 economic economic JJ 42759 2314 31 life life NN 42759 2314 32 , , , 42759 2314 33 but but CC 42759 2314 34 of of IN 42759 2314 35 that that DT 42759 2314 36 remote remote JJ 42759 2314 37 liberty liberty NN 42759 2314 38 which which WDT 42759 2314 39 consists consist VBZ 42759 2314 40 in in IN 42759 2314 41 the the DT 42759 2314 42 power power NN 42759 2314 43 to to TO 42759 2314 44 affect affect VB 42759 2314 45 general general JJ 42759 2314 46 conditions condition NNS 42759 2314 47 by by IN 42759 2314 48 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2314 49 votes vote NNS 42759 2314 50 . . . 42759 2315 1 In in IN 42759 2315 2 the the DT 42759 2315 3 last last JJ 42759 2315 4 chapter chapter NN 42759 2315 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2315 6 saw see VBD 42759 2315 7 that that IN 42759 2315 8 the the DT 42759 2315 9 claim claim NN 42759 2315 10 to to IN 42759 2315 11 the the DT 42759 2315 12 full full JJ 42759 2315 13 product product NN 42759 2315 14 of of IN 42759 2315 15 industry industry NN 42759 2315 16 , , , 42759 2315 17 made make VBN 42759 2315 18 on on IN 42759 2315 19 behalf behalf NN 42759 2315 20 of of IN 42759 2315 21 labour labour NN 42759 2315 22 by by IN 42759 2315 23 the the DT 42759 2315 24 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 2315 25 , , , 42759 2315 26 can can MD 42759 2315 27 not not RB 42759 2315 28 be be VB 42759 2315 29 established establish VBN 42759 2315 30 on on IN 42759 2315 31 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2315 32 grounds ground NNS 42759 2315 33 . . . 42759 2316 1 Like like IN 42759 2316 2 all all DT 42759 2316 3 other other JJ 42759 2316 4 claims claim NNS 42759 2316 5 to to IN 42759 2316 6 material material NN 42759 2316 7 goods good NNS 42759 2316 8 , , , 42759 2316 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2316 10 is be VBZ 42759 2316 11 valid valid JJ 42759 2316 12 only only RB 42759 2316 13 if if IN 42759 2316 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2316 15 can can MD 42759 2316 16 be be VB 42759 2316 17 realised realise VBN 42759 2316 18 consistently consistently RB 42759 2316 19 with with IN 42759 2316 20 human human JJ 42759 2316 21 welfare welfare NN 42759 2316 22 . . . 42759 2317 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2317 2 validity validity NN 42759 2317 3 depends depend VBZ 42759 2317 4 upon upon IN 42759 2317 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2317 6 feasibility feasibility NN 42759 2317 7 , , , 42759 2317 8 upon upon IN 42759 2317 9 the the DT 42759 2317 10 possibility possibility NN 42759 2317 11 of of IN 42759 2317 12 constructing construct VBG 42759 2317 13 some some DT 42759 2317 14 social social JJ 42759 2317 15 system system NN 42759 2317 16 that that WDT 42759 2317 17 will will MD 42759 2317 18 enable enable VB 42759 2317 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2317 20 to to TO 42759 2317 21 work work VB 42759 2317 22 . . . 42759 2318 1 The the DT 42759 2318 2 present present JJ 42759 2318 3 chapter chapter NN 42759 2318 4 has have VBZ 42759 2318 5 shown show VBN 42759 2318 6 that that IN 42759 2318 7 the the DT 42759 2318 8 requirements requirement NNS 42759 2318 9 of of IN 42759 2318 10 such such PDT 42759 2318 11 a a DT 42759 2318 12 system system NN 42759 2318 13 are be VBP 42759 2318 14 not not RB 42759 2318 15 met meet VBN 42759 2318 16 by by IN 42759 2318 17 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2318 18 . . . 42759 2319 1 A a DT 42759 2319 2 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2319 3 organisation organisation NN 42759 2319 4 of of IN 42759 2319 5 industry industry NN 42759 2319 6 would would MD 42759 2319 7 make make VB 42759 2319 8 all all DT 42759 2319 9 sections section NNS 42759 2319 10 of of IN 42759 2319 11 the the DT 42759 2319 12 population population NN 42759 2319 13 , , , 42759 2319 14 including include VBG 42759 2319 15 the the DT 42759 2319 16 wage wage NN 42759 2319 17 earning earning NN 42759 2319 18 class class NN 42759 2319 19 , , , 42759 2319 20 worse bad JJR 42759 2319 21 off off RP 42759 2319 22 than than IN 42759 2319 23 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2319 24 are be VBP 42759 2319 25 in in IN 42759 2319 26 the the DT 42759 2319 27 existing exist VBG 42759 2319 28 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2319 29 order order NN 42759 2319 30 . . . 42759 2320 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 2320 2 , , , 42759 2320 3 neither neither CC 42759 2320 4 the the DT 42759 2320 5 private private JJ 42759 2320 6 ownership ownership NN 42759 2320 7 of of IN 42759 2320 8 capital capital NN 42759 2320 9 nor nor CC 42759 2320 10 the the DT 42759 2320 11 individual individual JJ 42759 2320 12 receipt receipt NN 42759 2320 13 of of IN 42759 2320 14 interest interest NN 42759 2320 15 can can MD 42759 2320 16 be be VB 42759 2320 17 proved prove VBN 42759 2320 18 to to TO 42759 2320 19 be be VB 42759 2320 20 immoral immoral JJ 42759 2320 21 by by IN 42759 2320 22 the the DT 42759 2320 23 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2320 24 argument argument NN 42759 2320 25 . . . 42759 2321 1 Since since IN 42759 2321 2 private private JJ 42759 2321 3 ownership ownership NN 42759 2321 4 and and CC 42759 2321 5 management management NN 42759 2321 6 of of IN 42759 2321 7 capital capital NN 42759 2321 8 are be VBP 42759 2321 9 superior superior JJ 42759 2321 10 to to IN 42759 2321 11 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 2321 12 , , , 42759 2321 13 the the DT 42759 2321 14 State State NNP 42759 2321 15 is be VBZ 42759 2321 16 obliged oblige VBN 42759 2321 17 to to TO 42759 2321 18 maintain maintain VB 42759 2321 19 , , , 42759 2321 20 protect protect VB 42759 2321 21 , , , 42759 2321 22 and and CC 42759 2321 23 improve improve VB 42759 2321 24 the the DT 42759 2321 25 existing exist VBG 42759 2321 26 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2321 27 system system NN 42759 2321 28 . . . 42759 2322 1 This this DT 42759 2322 2 is be VBZ 42759 2322 3 precisely precisely RB 42759 2322 4 the the DT 42759 2322 5 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 2322 6 that that IN 42759 2322 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2322 8 reached reach VBD 42759 2322 9 in in IN 42759 2322 10 chapter chapter NN 42759 2322 11 iv iv VBZ 42759 2322 12 with with IN 42759 2322 13 reference reference NN 42759 2322 14 to to IN 42759 2322 15 private private JJ 42759 2322 16 ownership ownership NN 42759 2322 17 of of IN 42759 2322 18 land land NN 42759 2322 19 . . . 42759 2323 1 In in IN 42759 2323 2 chapter chapter NN 42759 2323 3 v v NN 42759 2323 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2323 5 found find VBD 42759 2323 6 , , , 42759 2323 7 moreover moreover RB 42759 2323 8 , , , 42759 2323 9 that that IN 42759 2323 10 individual individual JJ 42759 2323 11 ownership ownership NN 42759 2323 12 of of IN 42759 2323 13 land land NN 42759 2323 14 is be VBZ 42759 2323 15 a a DT 42759 2323 16 natural natural JJ 42759 2323 17 right right NN 42759 2323 18 . . . 42759 2324 1 The the DT 42759 2324 2 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 2324 3 considerations consideration NNS 42759 2324 4 there there RB 42759 2324 5 examined examine VBD 42759 2324 6 lead lead NN 42759 2324 7 to to IN 42759 2324 8 the the DT 42759 2324 9 parallel parallel JJ 42759 2324 10 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 2324 11 that that IN 42759 2324 12 the the DT 42759 2324 13 individual individual NN 42759 2324 14 has have VBZ 42759 2324 15 a a DT 42759 2324 16 natural natural JJ 42759 2324 17 right right NN 42759 2324 18 to to TO 42759 2324 19 own own VB 42759 2324 20 capital capital NN 42759 2324 21 . . . 42759 2325 1 But but CC 42759 2325 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2325 3 could could MD 42759 2325 4 not not RB 42759 2325 5 immediately immediately RB 42759 2325 6 deduce deduce VB 42759 2325 7 from from IN 42759 2325 8 the the DT 42759 2325 9 right right NN 42759 2325 10 to to TO 42759 2325 11 own own VB 42759 2325 12 land land NN 42759 2325 13 the the DT 42759 2325 14 right right NN 42759 2325 15 to to TO 42759 2325 16 take take VB 42759 2325 17 rent rent NN 42759 2325 18 . . . 42759 2326 1 Neither neither CC 42759 2326 2 can can MD 42759 2326 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2326 4 immediately immediately RB 42759 2326 5 deduce deduce VB 42759 2326 6 from from IN 42759 2326 7 the the DT 42759 2326 8 right right NN 42759 2326 9 to to TO 42759 2326 10 own own VB 42759 2326 11 capital capital NN 42759 2326 12 the the DT 42759 2326 13 right right NN 42759 2326 14 to to TO 42759 2326 15 take take VB 42759 2326 16 interest interest NN 42759 2326 17 . . . 42759 2327 1 The the DT 42759 2327 2 positive positive JJ 42759 2327 3 establishment establishment NN 42759 2327 4 of of IN 42759 2327 5 the the DT 42759 2327 6 latter latter JJ 42759 2327 7 right right NN 42759 2327 8 will will MD 42759 2327 9 occupy occupy VB 42759 2327 10 us -PRON- PRP 42759 2327 11 in in IN 42759 2327 12 the the DT 42759 2327 13 two two CD 42759 2327 14 following follow VBG 42759 2327 15 chapters chapter NNS 42759 2327 16 . . . 42759 2328 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 2328 2 : : : 42759 2328 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2328 4 121 121 CD 42759 2328 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2328 6 Wilhelm Wilhelm NNP 42759 2328 7 Liebknecht Liebknecht NNP 42759 2328 8 , , , 42759 2328 9 cited cite VBD 42759 2328 10 in in IN 42759 2328 11 Hillquit Hillquit NNP 42759 2328 12 's 's POS 42759 2328 13 " " `` 42759 2328 14 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2328 15 in in IN 42759 2328 16 Theory Theory NNP 42759 2328 17 and and CC 42759 2328 18 Practice Practice NNP 42759 2328 19 , , , 42759 2328 20 " " '' 42759 2328 21 p. p. NN 42759 2328 22 107 107 CD 42759 2328 23 . . . 42759 2329 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2329 2 122 122 CD 42759 2329 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2329 4 " " `` 42759 2329 5 Das Das NNP 42759 2329 6 Erfurter Erfurter NNP 42759 2329 7 Program Program NNP 42759 2329 8 , , , 42759 2329 9 " " '' 42759 2329 10 cited cite VBN 42759 2329 11 by by IN 42759 2329 12 Skelton Skelton NNP 42759 2329 13 , , , 42759 2329 14 op op NN 42759 2329 15 . . . 42759 2330 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2330 2 . . NNP 42759 2330 3 , , , 42759 2330 4 p. p. NN 42759 2330 5 178 178 CD 42759 2330 6 . . . 42759 2331 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2331 2 123 123 CD 42759 2331 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2331 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2331 5 . . . 42759 2332 1 Skelton Skelton NNP 42759 2332 2 , , , 42759 2332 3 op op NN 42759 2332 4 . . . 42759 2333 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2333 2 . . NNP 42759 2333 3 , , , 42759 2333 4 ch ch NNP 42759 2333 5 . . . 42759 2334 1 vii vii NN 42759 2334 2 ; ; : 42759 2334 3 Bernstein Bernstein NNP 42759 2334 4 , , , 42759 2334 5 " " `` 42759 2334 6 Evolutionary evolutionary JJ 42759 2334 7 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2334 8 , , , 42759 2334 9 " " '' 42759 2334 10 pp pp NNP 42759 2334 11 . . . 42759 2335 1 1 1 CD 42759 2335 2 - - SYM 42759 2335 3 94 94 CD 42759 2335 4 ; ; : 42759 2335 5 Simkhovitch Simkhovitch NNP 42759 2335 6 , , , 42759 2335 7 " " `` 42759 2335 8 Marxism Marxism NNP 42759 2335 9 vs. vs. IN 42759 2335 10 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 2335 11 , , , 42759 2335 12 " " '' 42759 2335 13 _ _ NNP 42759 2335 14 passim passim NNP 42759 2335 15 _ _ NNP 42759 2335 16 ; ; : 42759 2335 17 Walling walling NN 42759 2335 18 , , , 42759 2335 19 " " '' 42759 2335 20 Progressivism progressivism NN 42759 2335 21 and and CC 42759 2335 22 After after RB 42759 2335 23 , , , 42759 2335 24 " " '' 42759 2335 25 _ _ NNP 42759 2335 26 passim passim NNP 42759 2335 27 _ _ NNP 42759 2335 28 ; ; : 42759 2335 29 Hillquit Hillquit NNP 42759 2335 30 - - HYPH 42759 2335 31 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 2335 32 , , , 42759 2335 33 op op NN 42759 2335 34 . . . 42759 2336 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2336 2 . . NNP 42759 2336 3 , , , 42759 2336 4 ch ch NNP 42759 2336 5 . . . 42759 2337 1 iv iv XX 42759 2337 2 . . . 42759 2338 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2338 2 124 124 CD 42759 2338 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2338 4 " " `` 42759 2338 5 Income Income NNP 42759 2338 6 , , , 42759 2338 7 " " '' 42759 2338 8 p. p. NN 42759 2338 9 152 152 CD 42759 2338 10 . . . 42759 2339 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2339 2 125 125 CD 42759 2339 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2339 4 " " `` 42759 2339 5 The the DT 42759 2339 6 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 2339 7 and and CC 42759 2339 8 Income Income NNP 42759 2339 9 of of IN 42759 2339 10 the the DT 42759 2339 11 People People NNS 42759 2339 12 of of IN 42759 2339 13 the the DT 42759 2339 14 United United NNP 42759 2339 15 States States NNP 42759 2339 16 , , , 42759 2339 17 " " '' 42759 2339 18 p. p. NN 42759 2339 19 132 132 CD 42759 2339 20 . . . 42759 2340 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2340 2 126 126 CD 42759 2340 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2340 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2340 5 . . . 42759 2341 1 Hillquit Hillquit NNP 42759 2341 2 - - HYPH 42759 2341 3 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 2341 4 , , , 42759 2341 5 op op NN 42759 2341 6 . . . 42759 2342 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2342 2 . . . 42759 2342 3 , , , 42759 2342 4 pp pp NNP 42759 2342 5 . . . 42759 2343 1 107 107 CD 42759 2343 2 , , , 42759 2343 3 136 136 CD 42759 2343 4 . . . 42759 2344 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2344 2 127 127 CD 42759 2344 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2344 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2344 5 . . . 42759 2345 1 Hillquit Hillquit NNP 42759 2345 2 - - HYPH 42759 2345 3 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 2345 4 , , , 42759 2345 5 op op NN 42759 2345 6 . . . 42759 2346 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2346 2 . . . 42759 2346 3 , , , 42759 2346 4 pp pp NNP 42759 2346 5 . . . 42759 2347 1 73 73 CD 42759 2347 2 - - SYM 42759 2347 3 77 77 CD 42759 2347 4 ; ; : 42759 2347 5 Skelton Skelton NNP 42759 2347 6 , , , 42759 2347 7 op op NN 42759 2347 8 . . . 42759 2348 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2348 2 , , , 42759 2348 3 p. p. NN 42759 2348 4 183 183 CD 42759 2348 5 ; ; : 42759 2348 6 Walling walling NN 42759 2348 7 , , , 42759 2348 8 " " '' 42759 2348 9 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2348 10 as as IN 42759 2348 11 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2348 12 Is be VBZ 42759 2348 13 , , , 42759 2348 14 " " '' 42759 2348 15 p. p. NN 42759 2348 16 429 429 CD 42759 2348 17 . . . 42759 2349 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2349 2 128 128 CD 42759 2349 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2349 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2349 5 . . . 42759 2350 1 King King NNP 42759 2350 2 , , , 42759 2350 3 op op NN 42759 2350 4 . . . 42759 2351 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2351 2 . . . 42759 2351 3 , , , 42759 2351 4 pp pp NNP 42759 2351 5 . . . 42759 2352 1 224 224 CD 42759 2352 2 - - SYM 42759 2352 3 226 226 CD 42759 2352 4 . . . 42759 2353 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2353 2 129 129 CD 42759 2353 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2353 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2353 5 . . . 42759 2354 1 Kautsky Kautsky NNP 42759 2354 2 , , , 42759 2354 3 " " `` 42759 2354 4 The the DT 42759 2354 5 Social Social NNP 42759 2354 6 Revolution Revolution NNP 42759 2354 7 , , , 42759 2354 8 " " '' 42759 2354 9 pp pp NNP 42759 2354 10 . . . 42759 2355 1 166 166 CD 42759 2355 2 , , , 42759 2355 3 167 167 CD 42759 2355 4 ; ; : 42759 2355 5 Hillquit Hillquit NNP 42759 2355 6 - - HYPH 42759 2355 7 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 2355 8 , , , 42759 2355 9 op op NN 42759 2355 10 . . . 42759 2356 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2356 2 . . NNP 42759 2356 3 , , , 42759 2356 4 p. p. NN 42759 2356 5 72 72 CD 42759 2356 6 . . . 42759 2357 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2357 2 130 130 CD 42759 2357 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2357 4 Hillquit Hillquit NNP 42759 2357 5 - - HYPH 42759 2357 6 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 2357 7 , , , 42759 2357 8 op op NN 42759 2357 9 . . . 42759 2358 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2358 2 . . NNP 42759 2358 3 , , , 42759 2358 4 p. p. NN 42759 2358 5 80 80 CD 42759 2358 6 ; ; : 42759 2358 7 cf cf NN 42759 2358 8 . . . 42759 2359 1 Spargo Spargo NNP 42759 2359 2 , , , 42759 2359 3 " " `` 42759 2359 4 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2359 5 , , , 42759 2359 6 " " '' 42759 2359 7 pp pp NNP 42759 2359 8 . . . 42759 2360 1 225 225 CD 42759 2360 2 - - SYM 42759 2360 3 227 227 CD 42759 2360 4 . . . 42759 2361 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2361 2 131 131 CD 42759 2361 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2361 4 " " `` 42759 2361 5 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2361 6 : : : 42759 2361 7 A a DT 42759 2361 8 Critical Critical NNP 42759 2361 9 Analysis Analysis NNP 42759 2361 10 , , , 42759 2361 11 " " '' 42759 2361 12 p. p. NN 42759 2361 13 219 219 CD 42759 2361 14 . . . 42759 2362 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2362 2 132 132 CD 42759 2362 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2362 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2362 5 . . . 42759 2363 1 " " `` 42759 2363 2 The the DT 42759 2363 3 Panama Panama NNP 42759 2363 4 Gateway Gateway NNP 42759 2363 5 , , , 42759 2363 6 " " '' 42759 2363 7 by by IN 42759 2363 8 Joseph Joseph NNP 42759 2363 9 Bucklin Bucklin NNP 42759 2363 10 Bishop Bishop NNP 42759 2363 11 , , , 42759 2363 12 p. p. NN 42759 2363 13 263 263 CD 42759 2363 14 . . . 42759 2364 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 2364 2 XII XII NNP 42759 2364 3 ALLEGED alleged JJ 42759 2364 4 INTRINSIC intrinsic NN 42759 2364 5 JUSTIFICATIONS justifications NN 42759 2364 6 OF of IN 42759 2364 7 INTEREST interest NN 42759 2364 8 In in IN 42759 2364 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2364 10 address address NN 42759 2364 11 as as IN 42759 2364 12 President President NNP 42759 2364 13 of of IN 42759 2364 14 the the DT 42759 2364 15 American American NNP 42759 2364 16 Sociological Sociological NNP 42759 2364 17 Society Society NNP 42759 2364 18 at at IN 42759 2364 19 the the DT 42759 2364 20 annual annual JJ 42759 2364 21 meeting meeting NN 42759 2364 22 , , , 42759 2364 23 Dec. December NNP 42759 2364 24 27 27 CD 42759 2364 25 , , , 42759 2364 26 1913 1913 CD 42759 2364 27 , , , 42759 2364 28 Professor Professor NNP 42759 2364 29 Albion Albion NNP 42759 2364 30 W. W. NNP 42759 2364 31 Small Small NNP 42759 2364 32 denounced denounce VBD 42759 2364 33 " " `` 42759 2364 34 the the DT 42759 2364 35 fallacy fallacy NN 42759 2364 36 of of IN 42759 2364 37 treating treat VBG 42759 2364 38 capital capital NN 42759 2364 39 as as IN 42759 2364 40 though though IN 42759 2364 41 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2364 42 were be VBD 42759 2364 43 an an DT 42759 2364 44 active active JJ 42759 2364 45 agent agent NN 42759 2364 46 in in IN 42759 2364 47 human human JJ 42759 2364 48 processes process NNS 42759 2364 49 , , , 42759 2364 50 and and CC 42759 2364 51 crediting credit VBG 42759 2364 52 income income NN 42759 2364 53 to to IN 42759 2364 54 the the DT 42759 2364 55 personal personal JJ 42759 2364 56 representatives representative NNS 42759 2364 57 of of IN 42759 2364 58 capital capital NN 42759 2364 59 , , , 42759 2364 60 irrespective irrespective RB 42759 2364 61 of of IN 42759 2364 62 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2364 63 actual actual JJ 42759 2364 64 share share NN 42759 2364 65 in in IN 42759 2364 66 human human JJ 42759 2364 67 service service NN 42759 2364 68 . . . 42759 2364 69 " " '' 42759 2365 1 According accord VBG 42759 2365 2 to to IN 42759 2365 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2365 4 explicit explicit JJ 42759 2365 5 declaration declaration NN 42759 2365 6 , , , 42759 2365 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2365 8 criticism criticism NN 42759 2365 9 of of IN 42759 2365 10 the the DT 42759 2365 11 modern modern JJ 42759 2365 12 interest interest NN 42759 2365 13 - - HYPH 42759 2365 14 system system NN 42759 2365 15 was be VBD 42759 2365 16 based base VBN 42759 2365 17 primarily primarily RB 42759 2365 18 upon upon IN 42759 2365 19 grounds ground NNS 42759 2365 20 of of IN 42759 2365 21 social social JJ 42759 2365 22 utility utility NN 42759 2365 23 rather rather RB 42759 2365 24 than than IN 42759 2365 25 upon upon IN 42759 2365 26 formally formally RB 42759 2365 27 ethical ethical JJ 42759 2365 28 considerations consideration NNS 42759 2365 29 . . . 42759 2366 1 A a DT 42759 2366 2 German german JJ 42759 2366 3 priest priest NN 42759 2366 4 has have VBZ 42759 2366 5 attacked attack VBN 42759 2366 6 interest interest NN 42759 2366 7 from from IN 42759 2366 8 the the DT 42759 2366 9 purely purely RB 42759 2366 10 moral moral JJ 42759 2366 11 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 2366 12 . . . 42759 2367 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2367 2 133 133 CD 42759 2367 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2367 4 In in IN 42759 2367 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2367 6 view view NN 42759 2367 7 the the DT 42759 2367 8 owner owner NN 42759 2367 9 of of IN 42759 2367 10 any any DT 42759 2367 11 sort sort NN 42759 2367 12 of of IN 42759 2367 13 capital capital NN 42759 2367 14 who who WP 42759 2367 15 exacts exact VBZ 42759 2367 16 the the DT 42759 2367 17 return return NN 42759 2367 18 of of IN 42759 2367 19 anything anything NN 42759 2367 20 beyond beyond IN 42759 2367 21 the the DT 42759 2367 22 principal principal NN 42759 2367 23 , , , 42759 2367 24 violates violate VBZ 42759 2367 25 strict strict JJ 42759 2367 26 justice justice NN 42759 2367 27 . . . 42759 2368 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2368 2 134 134 CD 42759 2368 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2368 4 The the DT 42759 2368 5 Church Church NNP 42759 2368 6 , , , 42759 2368 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2368 8 maintains maintain VBZ 42759 2368 9 , , , 42759 2368 10 has have VBZ 42759 2368 11 never never RB 42759 2368 12 formally formally RB 42759 2368 13 authorised authorise VBN 42759 2368 14 or or CC 42759 2368 15 permitted permit VBN 42759 2368 16 interest interest NN 42759 2368 17 , , , 42759 2368 18 either either CC 42759 2368 19 on on IN 42759 2368 20 loans loan NNS 42759 2368 21 or or CC 42759 2368 22 on on IN 42759 2368 23 producing produce VBG 42759 2368 24 capital capital NN 42759 2368 25 . . . 42759 2369 1 She -PRON- PRP 42759 2369 2 has have VBZ 42759 2369 3 merely merely RB 42759 2369 4 tolerated tolerate VBN 42759 2369 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2369 6 as as IN 42759 2369 7 an an DT 42759 2369 8 irremovable irremovable JJ 42759 2369 9 evil evil NN 42759 2369 10 . . . 42759 2370 1 Is be VBZ 42759 2370 2 there there EX 42759 2370 3 a a DT 42759 2370 4 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 2370 5 justification justification NN 42759 2370 6 of of IN 42759 2370 7 interest interest NN 42759 2370 8 ? ? . 42759 2371 1 If if IN 42759 2371 2 there there EX 42759 2371 3 is be VBZ 42759 2371 4 , , , 42759 2371 5 does do VBZ 42759 2371 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2371 7 rest rest VB 42759 2371 8 on on IN 42759 2371 9 individual individual NN 42759 2371 10 or or CC 42759 2371 11 on on IN 42759 2371 12 social social JJ 42759 2371 13 grounds ground NNS 42759 2371 14 ? ? . 42759 2372 1 That that DT 42759 2372 2 is be VBZ 42759 2372 3 to to TO 42759 2372 4 say say VB 42759 2372 5 : : : 42759 2372 6 is be VBZ 42759 2372 7 interest interest NN 42759 2372 8 justified justify VBN 42759 2372 9 immediately immediately RB 42759 2372 10 and and CC 42759 2372 11 intrinsically intrinsically RB 42759 2372 12 by by IN 42759 2372 13 the the DT 42759 2372 14 relations relation NNS 42759 2372 15 existing exist VBG 42759 2372 16 between between IN 42759 2372 17 the the DT 42759 2372 18 owner owner NN 42759 2372 19 and and CC 42759 2372 20 the the DT 42759 2372 21 user user NN 42759 2372 22 of of IN 42759 2372 23 capital capital NN 42759 2372 24 ? ? . 42759 2373 1 Or or CC 42759 2373 2 , , , 42759 2373 3 is be VBZ 42759 2373 4 rendered render VBN 42759 2373 5 morally morally RB 42759 2373 6 good good JJ 42759 2373 7 owing owing NN 42759 2373 8 to to IN 42759 2373 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2373 10 effects effect NNS 42759 2373 11 upon upon IN 42759 2373 12 social social JJ 42759 2373 13 welfare welfare NN 42759 2373 14 ? ? . 42759 2374 1 Let let VB 42759 2374 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 2374 3 see see VB 42759 2374 4 what what WDT 42759 2374 5 light light NN 42759 2374 6 is be VBZ 42759 2374 7 thrown throw VBN 42759 2374 8 on on IN 42759 2374 9 these these DT 42759 2374 10 questions question NNS 42759 2374 11 by by IN 42759 2374 12 the the DT 42759 2374 13 anti anti JJ 42759 2374 14 - - JJ 42759 2374 15 usury usury JJ 42759 2374 16 legislation legislation NN 42759 2374 17 of of IN 42759 2374 18 the the DT 42759 2374 19 Catholic Catholic NNP 42759 2374 20 Church Church NNP 42759 2374 21 . . . 42759 2375 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2375 2 Attitude attitude NN 42759 2375 3 of of IN 42759 2375 4 the the DT 42759 2375 5 Church Church NNP 42759 2375 6 Toward toward IN 42759 2375 7 Interest Interest NNP 42759 2375 8 on on IN 42759 2375 9 Loans Loans NNPS 42759 2375 10 _ _ XX 42759 2375 11 During during IN 42759 2375 12 the the DT 42759 2375 13 Middle Middle NNP 42759 2375 14 Ages Ages NNPS 42759 2375 15 all all DT 42759 2375 16 interest interest NN 42759 2375 17 on on IN 42759 2375 18 _ _ NNP 42759 2375 19 loans loan NNS 42759 2375 20 _ _ NNP 42759 2375 21 was be VBD 42759 2375 22 forbidden forbid VBN 42759 2375 23 under under IN 42759 2375 24 severe severe JJ 42759 2375 25 penalties penalty NNS 42759 2375 26 by by IN 42759 2375 27 repeated repeat VBN 42759 2375 28 ordinances ordinance NNS 42759 2375 29 of of IN 42759 2375 30 Popes Popes NNPS 42759 2375 31 and and CC 42759 2375 32 Councils Councils NNP 42759 2375 33 . . . 42759 2376 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2376 2 135 135 CD 42759 2376 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2376 4 Since since IN 42759 2376 5 the the DT 42759 2376 6 end end NN 42759 2376 7 of of IN 42759 2376 8 the the DT 42759 2376 9 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 42759 2376 10 century century NN 42759 2376 11 the the DT 42759 2376 12 Church Church NNP 42759 2376 13 has have VBZ 42759 2376 14 quite quite RB 42759 2376 15 generally generally RB 42759 2376 16 permitted permit VBN 42759 2376 17 interest interest NN 42759 2376 18 on on IN 42759 2376 19 one one CD 42759 2376 20 or or CC 42759 2376 21 more more JJR 42759 2376 22 extrinsic extrinsic JJ 42759 2376 23 grounds ground NNS 42759 2376 24 , , , 42759 2376 25 or or CC 42759 2376 26 " " `` 42759 2376 27 titles title NNS 42759 2376 28 . . . 42759 2376 29 " " '' 42759 2377 1 The the DT 42759 2377 2 first first JJ 42759 2377 3 of of IN 42759 2377 4 these these DT 42759 2377 5 titles title NNS 42759 2377 6 was be VBD 42759 2377 7 known know VBN 42759 2377 8 as as IN 42759 2377 9 " " `` 42759 2377 10 lucrum lucrum NN 42759 2377 11 cessans cessan NNS 42759 2377 12 , , , 42759 2377 13 " " '' 42759 2377 14 or or CC 42759 2377 15 relinquished relinquish VBN 42759 2377 16 gain gain NN 42759 2377 17 . . . 42759 2378 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2378 2 came come VBD 42759 2378 3 into into IN 42759 2378 4 existence existence NN 42759 2378 5 whenever whenever WRB 42759 2378 6 a a DT 42759 2378 7 person person NN 42759 2378 8 who who WP 42759 2378 9 could could MD 42759 2378 10 have have VB 42759 2378 11 invested invest VBN 42759 2378 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2378 13 money money NN 42759 2378 14 in in IN 42759 2378 15 a a DT 42759 2378 16 productive productive JJ 42759 2378 17 object object NN 42759 2378 18 , , , 42759 2378 19 for for IN 42759 2378 20 example example NN 42759 2378 21 , , , 42759 2378 22 a a DT 42759 2378 23 house house NN 42759 2378 24 , , , 42759 2378 25 a a DT 42759 2378 26 farm farm NN 42759 2378 27 , , , 42759 2378 28 or or CC 42759 2378 29 a a DT 42759 2378 30 mercantile mercantile NN 42759 2378 31 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 2378 32 , , , 42759 2378 33 decided decide VBD 42759 2378 34 instead instead RB 42759 2378 35 to to TO 42759 2378 36 lend lend VB 42759 2378 37 the the DT 42759 2378 38 money money NN 42759 2378 39 . . . 42759 2379 1 In in IN 42759 2379 2 such such JJ 42759 2379 3 cases case NNS 42759 2379 4 the the DT 42759 2379 5 interest interest NN 42759 2379 6 on on IN 42759 2379 7 the the DT 42759 2379 8 loan loan NN 42759 2379 9 was be VBD 42759 2379 10 regarded regard VBN 42759 2379 11 as as IN 42759 2379 12 proper proper JJ 42759 2379 13 compensation compensation NN 42759 2379 14 for for IN 42759 2379 15 the the DT 42759 2379 16 gain gain NN 42759 2379 17 which which WDT 42759 2379 18 the the DT 42759 2379 19 owner owner NN 42759 2379 20 might may MD 42759 2379 21 have have VB 42759 2379 22 obtained obtain VBN 42759 2379 23 from from IN 42759 2379 24 an an DT 42759 2379 25 investment investment NN 42759 2379 26 on on IN 42759 2379 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2379 28 own own JJ 42759 2379 29 account account NN 42759 2379 30 . . . 42759 2380 1 The the DT 42759 2380 2 title title NN 42759 2380 3 created create VBN 42759 2380 4 by by IN 42759 2380 5 this this DT 42759 2380 6 situation situation NN 42759 2380 7 was be VBD 42759 2380 8 called call VBN 42759 2380 9 " " `` 42759 2380 10 extrinsic extrinsic NN 42759 2380 11 " " '' 42759 2380 12 because because IN 42759 2380 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2380 14 arose arise VBD 42759 2380 15 out out IN 42759 2380 16 of of IN 42759 2380 17 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 2380 18 external external JJ 42759 2380 19 to to IN 42759 2380 20 the the DT 42759 2380 21 essential essential JJ 42759 2380 22 relations relation NNS 42759 2380 23 of of IN 42759 2380 24 borrower borrower NN 42759 2380 25 and and CC 42759 2380 26 lender lender NN 42759 2380 27 . . . 42759 2381 1 Not not RB 42759 2381 2 because because IN 42759 2381 3 of of IN 42759 2381 4 the the DT 42759 2381 5 loan loan NN 42759 2381 6 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2381 7 , , , 42759 2381 8 but but CC 42759 2381 9 because because IN 42759 2381 10 the the DT 42759 2381 11 loan loan NN 42759 2381 12 prevented prevent VBD 42759 2381 13 the the DT 42759 2381 14 lender lender NN 42759 2381 15 from from IN 42759 2381 16 investing invest VBG 42759 2381 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2381 18 money money NN 42759 2381 19 in in IN 42759 2381 20 a a DT 42759 2381 21 productive productive JJ 42759 2381 22 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 2381 23 , , , 42759 2381 24 was be VBD 42759 2381 25 interest interest NN 42759 2381 26 on on IN 42759 2381 27 the the DT 42759 2381 28 former former JJ 42759 2381 29 held hold VBN 42759 2381 30 to to TO 42759 2381 31 be be VB 42759 2381 32 justified justify VBN 42759 2381 33 . . . 42759 2382 1 In in IN 42759 2382 2 other other JJ 42759 2382 3 words word NNS 42759 2382 4 , , , 42759 2382 5 interest interest NN 42759 2382 6 on on IN 42759 2382 7 the the DT 42759 2382 8 loan loan NN 42759 2382 9 was be VBD 42759 2382 10 looked look VBN 42759 2382 11 upon upon IN 42759 2382 12 as as IN 42759 2382 13 merely merely RB 42759 2382 14 the the DT 42759 2382 15 fair fair JJ 42759 2382 16 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 2382 17 of of IN 42759 2382 18 the the DT 42759 2382 19 interest interest NN 42759 2382 20 that that WDT 42759 2382 21 might may MD 42759 2382 22 have have VB 42759 2382 23 been be VBN 42759 2382 24 obtained obtain VBN 42759 2382 25 on on IN 42759 2382 26 the the DT 42759 2382 27 investment investment NN 42759 2382 28 . . . 42759 2383 1 During during IN 42759 2383 2 the the DT 42759 2383 3 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 42759 2383 4 , , , 42759 2383 5 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 42759 2383 6 , , , 42759 2383 7 and and CC 42759 2383 8 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 42759 2383 9 centuries century NNS 42759 2383 10 , , , 42759 2383 11 another another DT 42759 2383 12 title title NN 42759 2383 13 or or CC 42759 2383 14 justification justification NN 42759 2383 15 of of IN 42759 2383 16 loan loan NN 42759 2383 17 - - HYPH 42759 2383 18 interest interest NN 42759 2383 19 found find VBD 42759 2383 20 some some DT 42759 2383 21 favour favour NN 42759 2383 22 among among IN 42759 2383 23 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 2383 24 moralists moralist NNS 42759 2383 25 . . . 42759 2384 1 This this DT 42759 2384 2 was be VBD 42759 2384 3 the the DT 42759 2384 4 " " `` 42759 2384 5 praemium praemium NN 42759 2384 6 legale legale NN 42759 2384 7 , , , 42759 2384 8 " " '' 42759 2384 9 or or CC 42759 2384 10 legal legal JJ 42759 2384 11 rate rate NN 42759 2384 12 of of IN 42759 2384 13 interest interest NN 42759 2384 14 allowed allow VBN 42759 2384 15 by by IN 42759 2384 16 civil civil JJ 42759 2384 17 governments government NNS 42759 2384 18 . . . 42759 2385 1 Wherever wherever WRB 42759 2385 2 the the DT 42759 2385 3 State state NN 42759 2385 4 authorised authorise VBD 42759 2385 5 a a DT 42759 2385 6 definite definite JJ 42759 2385 7 rate rate NN 42759 2385 8 of of IN 42759 2385 9 interest interest NN 42759 2385 10 , , , 42759 2385 11 the the DT 42759 2385 12 lender lender NN 42759 2385 13 might may MD 42759 2385 14 , , , 42759 2385 15 according accord VBG 42759 2385 16 to to IN 42759 2385 17 these these DT 42759 2385 18 writers writer NNS 42759 2385 19 , , , 42759 2385 20 take take VB 42759 2385 21 advantage advantage NN 42759 2385 22 of of IN 42759 2385 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2385 24 with with IN 42759 2385 25 a a DT 42759 2385 26 clear clear JJ 42759 2385 27 conscience conscience NN 42759 2385 28 . . . 42759 2386 1 To to NN 42759 2386 2 - - HYPH 42759 2386 3 day day NN 42759 2386 4 the the DT 42759 2386 5 majority majority NN 42759 2386 6 of of IN 42759 2386 7 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 2386 8 authorities authority NNS 42759 2386 9 on on IN 42759 2386 10 the the DT 42759 2386 11 subject subject NN 42759 2386 12 prefer prefer VBP 42759 2386 13 the the DT 42759 2386 14 title title NN 42759 2386 15 of of IN 42759 2386 16 virtual virtual JJ 42759 2386 17 productivity productivity NN 42759 2386 18 as as IN 42759 2386 19 a a DT 42759 2386 20 justification justification NN 42759 2386 21 . . . 42759 2387 1 Money money NN 42759 2387 2 , , , 42759 2387 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2387 4 contend contend VBP 42759 2387 5 , , , 42759 2387 6 has have VBZ 42759 2387 7 become become VBN 42759 2387 8 virtually virtually RB 42759 2387 9 productive productive JJ 42759 2387 10 . . . 42759 2388 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2388 2 can can MD 42759 2388 3 readily readily RB 42759 2388 4 be be VB 42759 2388 5 exchanged exchange VBN 42759 2388 6 for for IN 42759 2388 7 income income NN 42759 2388 8 - - HYPH 42759 2388 9 bearing bearing NN 42759 2388 10 or or CC 42759 2388 11 productive productive JJ 42759 2388 12 property property NN 42759 2388 13 , , , 42759 2388 14 such such JJ 42759 2388 15 as as IN 42759 2388 16 , , , 42759 2388 17 land land NN 42759 2388 18 , , , 42759 2388 19 houses house NNS 42759 2388 20 , , , 42759 2388 21 railroads railroad NNS 42759 2388 22 , , , 42759 2388 23 machinery machinery NN 42759 2388 24 , , , 42759 2388 25 and and CC 42759 2388 26 distributive distributive JJ 42759 2388 27 establishments establishment NNS 42759 2388 28 . . . 42759 2389 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2389 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2389 3 has have VBZ 42759 2389 4 become become VBN 42759 2389 5 the the DT 42759 2389 6 economic economic JJ 42759 2389 7 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 2389 8 of of IN 42759 2389 9 productive productive JJ 42759 2389 10 capital capital NN 42759 2389 11 , , , 42759 2389 12 and and CC 42759 2389 13 the the DT 42759 2389 14 interest interest NN 42759 2389 15 which which WDT 42759 2389 16 is be VBZ 42759 2389 17 received receive VBN 42759 2389 18 on on IN 42759 2389 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2389 20 through through IN 42759 2389 21 a a DT 42759 2389 22 loan loan NN 42759 2389 23 is be VBZ 42759 2389 24 quite quite RB 42759 2389 25 as as RB 42759 2389 26 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2389 27 as as IN 42759 2389 28 the the DT 42759 2389 29 annual annual JJ 42759 2389 30 return return NN 42759 2389 31 to to IN 42759 2389 32 the the DT 42759 2389 33 owner owner NN 42759 2389 34 of of IN 42759 2389 35 productive productive JJ 42759 2389 36 capital capital NN 42759 2389 37 . . . 42759 2390 1 Between between IN 42759 2390 2 this this DT 42759 2390 3 theory theory NN 42759 2390 4 and and CC 42759 2390 5 the the DT 42759 2390 6 theory theory NN 42759 2390 7 connected connect VBN 42759 2390 8 with with IN 42759 2390 9 " " `` 42759 2390 10 lucrum lucrum NNP 42759 2390 11 cessans cessan NNS 42759 2390 12 " " '' 42759 2390 13 the the DT 42759 2390 14 only only JJ 42759 2390 15 difference difference NN 42759 2390 16 is be VBZ 42759 2390 17 that that IN 42759 2390 18 the the DT 42759 2390 19 former former JJ 42759 2390 20 shifts shift NNS 42759 2390 21 the the DT 42759 2390 22 justification justification NN 42759 2390 23 of of IN 42759 2390 24 interest interest NN 42759 2390 25 from from IN 42759 2390 26 the the DT 42759 2390 27 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 2390 28 and and CC 42759 2390 29 rights right NNS 42759 2390 30 of of IN 42759 2390 31 the the DT 42759 2390 32 lender lender NN 42759 2390 33 to to IN 42759 2390 34 the the DT 42759 2390 35 present present JJ 42759 2390 36 nature nature NN 42759 2390 37 of of IN 42759 2390 38 the the DT 42759 2390 39 money money NN 42759 2390 40 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2390 41 . . . 42759 2391 1 Not not RB 42759 2391 2 merely merely RB 42759 2391 3 the the DT 42759 2391 4 fact fact NN 42759 2391 5 that that IN 42759 2391 6 the the DT 42759 2391 7 individual individual NN 42759 2391 8 will will MD 42759 2391 9 suffer suffer VB 42759 2391 10 if if IN 42759 2391 11 , , , 42759 2391 12 instead instead RB 42759 2391 13 of of IN 42759 2391 14 investing invest VBG 42759 2391 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2391 16 money money NN 42759 2391 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2391 18 loans loan VBZ 42759 2391 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2391 20 without without IN 42759 2391 21 interest interest NN 42759 2391 22 , , , 42759 2391 23 but but CC 42759 2391 24 the the DT 42759 2391 25 fact fact NN 42759 2391 26 that that IN 42759 2391 27 money money NN 42759 2391 28 is be VBZ 42759 2391 29 generally generally RB 42759 2391 30 and and CC 42759 2391 31 virtually virtually RB 42759 2391 32 productive productive JJ 42759 2391 33 , , , 42759 2391 34 is be VBZ 42759 2391 35 the the DT 42759 2391 36 important important JJ 42759 2391 37 element element NN 42759 2391 38 in in IN 42759 2391 39 the the DT 42759 2391 40 newer new JJR 42759 2391 41 theory theory NN 42759 2391 42 . . . 42759 2392 1 In in IN 42759 2392 2 practice practice NN 42759 2392 3 , , , 42759 2392 4 however however RB 42759 2392 5 , , , 42759 2392 6 the the DT 42759 2392 7 two two CD 42759 2392 8 explanations explanation NNS 42759 2392 9 or or CC 42759 2392 10 justifications justification NNS 42759 2392 11 come come VBP 42759 2392 12 to to IN 42759 2392 13 substantially substantially RB 42759 2392 14 the the DT 42759 2392 15 same same JJ 42759 2392 16 thing thing NN 42759 2392 17 . . . 42759 2393 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2393 2 , , , 42759 2393 3 the the DT 42759 2393 4 Church Church NNP 42759 2393 5 has have VBZ 42759 2393 6 given give VBN 42759 2393 7 no no DT 42759 2393 8 positive positive JJ 42759 2393 9 approval approval NN 42759 2393 10 to to IN 42759 2393 11 any any DT 42759 2393 12 of of IN 42759 2393 13 the the DT 42759 2393 14 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 2393 15 theories theory NNS 42759 2393 16 . . . 42759 2394 1 In in IN 42759 2394 2 the the DT 42759 2394 3 last last JJ 42759 2394 4 formal formal JJ 42759 2394 5 pronouncement pronouncement NN 42759 2394 6 by by IN 42759 2394 7 a a DT 42759 2394 8 Pope Pope NNP 42759 2394 9 on on IN 42759 2394 10 the the DT 42759 2394 11 subject subject NN 42759 2394 12 , , , 42759 2394 13 Benedict Benedict NNP 42759 2394 14 XIV[136 XIV[136 NNP 42759 2394 15 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2394 16 condemned condemn VBN 42759 2394 17 anew anew RB 42759 2394 18 all all DT 42759 2394 19 interest interest NN 42759 2394 20 that that WDT 42759 2394 21 had have VBD 42759 2394 22 no no DT 42759 2394 23 other other JJ 42759 2394 24 support support NN 42759 2394 25 than than IN 42759 2394 26 the the DT 42759 2394 27 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2394 28 conditions condition NNS 42759 2394 29 of of IN 42759 2394 30 the the DT 42759 2394 31 loan loan NN 42759 2394 32 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2394 33 . . . 42759 2395 1 At at IN 42759 2395 2 the the DT 42759 2395 3 same same JJ 42759 2395 4 time time NN 42759 2395 5 , , , 42759 2395 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2395 7 declared declare VBD 42759 2395 8 that that IN 42759 2395 9 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2395 10 had have VBD 42759 2395 11 no no DT 42759 2395 12 intention intention NN 42759 2395 13 of of IN 42759 2395 14 denying deny VBG 42759 2395 15 the the DT 42759 2395 16 lawfulness lawfulness NN 42759 2395 17 of of IN 42759 2395 18 interest interest NN 42759 2395 19 which which WDT 42759 2395 20 was be VBD 42759 2395 21 received receive VBN 42759 2395 22 in in IN 42759 2395 23 virtue virtue NN 42759 2395 24 of of IN 42759 2395 25 the the DT 42759 2395 26 title title NN 42759 2395 27 of of IN 42759 2395 28 " " `` 42759 2395 29 lucrum lucrum NN 42759 2395 30 cessans cessan NNS 42759 2395 31 , , , 42759 2395 32 " " '' 42759 2395 33 nor nor CC 42759 2395 34 the the DT 42759 2395 35 lawfulness lawfulness NN 42759 2395 36 of of IN 42759 2395 37 interest interest NN 42759 2395 38 or or CC 42759 2395 39 profits profit NNS 42759 2395 40 arising arise VBG 42759 2395 41 out out IN 42759 2395 42 of of IN 42759 2395 43 investments investment NNS 42759 2395 44 in in IN 42759 2395 45 productive productive JJ 42759 2395 46 property property NN 42759 2395 47 . . . 42759 2396 1 In in IN 42759 2396 2 other other JJ 42759 2396 3 words word NNS 42759 2396 4 , , , 42759 2396 5 the the DT 42759 2396 6 authorisation authorisation NN 42759 2396 7 that that WDT 42759 2396 8 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2396 9 gave give VBD 42759 2396 10 to to IN 42759 2396 11 both both DT 42759 2396 12 kinds kind NNS 42759 2396 13 of of IN 42759 2396 14 interest interest NN 42759 2396 15 was be VBD 42759 2396 16 merely merely RB 42759 2396 17 negative negative JJ 42759 2396 18 . . . 42759 2397 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2397 2 refrained refrain VBD 42759 2397 3 from from IN 42759 2397 4 condemning condemn VBG 42759 2397 5 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2397 6 . . . 42759 2398 1 In in IN 42759 2398 2 the the DT 42759 2398 3 Responses response NNS 42759 2398 4 given give VBN 42759 2398 5 by by IN 42759 2398 6 the the DT 42759 2398 7 Roman Roman NNP 42759 2398 8 Congregations Congregations NNPS 42759 2398 9 from from IN 42759 2398 10 1822 1822 CD 42759 2398 11 onward onward RB 42759 2398 12 to to IN 42759 2398 13 questions question NNS 42759 2398 14 relating relate VBG 42759 2398 15 to to IN 42759 2398 16 the the DT 42759 2398 17 lawfulness lawfulness NN 42759 2398 18 of of IN 42759 2398 19 loan loan NN 42759 2398 20 - - HYPH 42759 2398 21 interest interest NN 42759 2398 22 , , , 42759 2398 23 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2398 24 may may MD 42759 2398 25 profitably profitably RB 42759 2398 26 consider consider VB 42759 2398 27 four four CD 42759 2398 28 principal principal JJ 42759 2398 29 features feature NNS 42759 2398 30 . . . 42759 2399 1 First first RB 42759 2399 2 , , , 42759 2399 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2399 4 declare declare VBP 42759 2399 5 more more RBR 42759 2399 6 or or CC 42759 2399 7 less less RBR 42759 2399 8 specifically specifically RB 42759 2399 9 that that DT 42759 2399 10 interest interest NN 42759 2399 11 may may MD 42759 2399 12 be be VB 42759 2399 13 taken take VBN 42759 2399 14 in in IN 42759 2399 15 the the DT 42759 2399 16 absence absence NN 42759 2399 17 of of IN 42759 2399 18 the the DT 42759 2399 19 title title NN 42759 2399 20 of of IN 42759 2399 21 " " `` 42759 2399 22 lucrum lucrum NNP 42759 2399 23 cessans cessan NNS 42759 2399 24 " " '' 42759 2399 25 ; ; : 42759 2399 26 second second LS 42759 2399 27 , , , 42759 2399 28 some some DT 42759 2399 29 of of IN 42759 2399 30 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2399 31 definitely definitely RB 42759 2399 32 admit admit VBP 42759 2399 33 the the DT 42759 2399 34 title title NN 42759 2399 35 of of IN 42759 2399 36 " " `` 42759 2399 37 praemium praemium NN 42759 2399 38 legale legale NN 42759 2399 39 , , , 42759 2399 40 " " '' 42759 2399 41 or or CC 42759 2399 42 civil civil JJ 42759 2399 43 authorisation authorisation NN 42759 2399 44 , , , 42759 2399 45 as as IN 42759 2399 46 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2399 47 to to TO 42759 2399 48 give give VB 42759 2399 49 the the DT 42759 2399 50 practice practice NN 42759 2399 51 moral moral JJ 42759 2399 52 sanction sanction NN 42759 2399 53 ; ; : 42759 2399 54 third third LS 42759 2399 55 , , , 42759 2399 56 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2399 57 express express VBP 42759 2399 58 a a DT 42759 2399 59 genuine genuine JJ 42759 2399 60 permission permission NN 42759 2399 61 , , , 42759 2399 62 not not RB 42759 2399 63 a a DT 42759 2399 64 mere mere JJ 42759 2399 65 toleration toleration NN 42759 2399 66 , , , 42759 2399 67 of of IN 42759 2399 68 interest interest NN 42759 2399 69 taking taking NN 42759 2399 70 ; ; : 42759 2399 71 fourth fourth RB 42759 2399 72 , , , 42759 2399 73 none none NN 42759 2399 74 of of IN 42759 2399 75 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2399 76 explicitly explicitly RB 42759 2399 77 declares declare VBZ 42759 2399 78 that that IN 42759 2399 79 any any DT 42759 2399 80 of of IN 42759 2399 81 the the DT 42759 2399 82 titles title NNS 42759 2399 83 or or CC 42759 2399 84 reasons reason NNS 42759 2399 85 for for IN 42759 2399 86 receiving receive VBG 42759 2399 87 loan loan NN 42759 2399 88 - - HYPH 42759 2399 89 interest interest NN 42759 2399 90 will will MD 42759 2399 91 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 2399 92 or or CC 42759 2399 93 always always RB 42759 2399 94 give give VB 42759 2399 95 the the DT 42759 2399 96 lender lender NN 42759 2399 97 a a DT 42759 2399 98 _ _ NNP 42759 2399 99 strict strict JJ 42759 2399 100 right right NN 42759 2399 101 _ _ NNP 42759 2399 102 thereto thereto NN 42759 2399 103 . . . 42759 2400 1 None none NN 42759 2400 2 of of IN 42759 2400 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2400 4 contains contain VBZ 42759 2400 5 a a DT 42759 2400 6 positive positive JJ 42759 2400 7 and and CC 42759 2400 8 reasoned reason VBN 42759 2400 9 approval approval NN 42759 2400 10 of of IN 42759 2400 11 the the DT 42759 2400 12 practice practice NN 42759 2400 13 . . . 42759 2401 1 Most Most JJS 42759 2401 2 of of IN 42759 2401 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2401 4 merely merely RB 42759 2401 5 decide decide VBP 42759 2401 6 that that IN 42759 2401 7 persons person NNS 42759 2401 8 who who WP 42759 2401 9 engage engage VBP 42759 2401 10 in in IN 42759 2401 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2401 12 are be VBP 42759 2401 13 not not RB 42759 2401 14 to to TO 42759 2401 15 be be VB 42759 2401 16 disturbed disturb VBN 42759 2401 17 in in IN 42759 2401 18 conscience conscience NN 42759 2401 19 , , , 42759 2401 20 so so RB 42759 2401 21 long long RB 42759 2401 22 as as IN 42759 2401 23 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2401 24 stand stand VBP 42759 2401 25 ready ready JJ 42759 2401 26 to to TO 42759 2401 27 submit submit VB 42759 2401 28 to to IN 42759 2401 29 a a DT 42759 2401 30 formal formal JJ 42759 2401 31 decision decision NN 42759 2401 32 on on IN 42759 2401 33 the the DT 42759 2401 34 subject subject NN 42759 2401 35 by by IN 42759 2401 36 the the DT 42759 2401 37 Holy Holy NNP 42759 2401 38 See See NNP 42759 2401 39 . . . 42759 2402 1 The the DT 42759 2402 2 insertion insertion NN 42759 2402 3 of of IN 42759 2402 4 the the DT 42759 2402 5 latter latter JJ 42759 2402 6 condition condition NN 42759 2402 7 clearly clearly RB 42759 2402 8 intimates intimate VBZ 42759 2402 9 that that IN 42759 2402 10 some some DT 42759 2402 11 day day NN 42759 2402 12 interest interest NN 42759 2402 13 taking taking NN 42759 2402 14 might may MD 42759 2402 15 be be VB 42759 2402 16 formally formally RB 42759 2402 17 and and CC 42759 2402 18 officially officially RB 42759 2402 19 condemned condemn VBN 42759 2402 20 . . . 42759 2403 1 Should Should MD 42759 2403 2 such such PDT 42759 2403 3 a a DT 42759 2403 4 condemnation condemnation NN 42759 2403 5 ever ever RB 42759 2403 6 appear appear VBP 42759 2403 7 , , , 42759 2403 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2403 9 would would MD 42759 2403 10 not not RB 42759 2403 11 contradict contradict VB 42759 2403 12 any any DT 42759 2403 13 moral moral JJ 42759 2403 14 principle principle NN 42759 2403 15 contained contain VBN 42759 2403 16 in in IN 42759 2403 17 the the DT 42759 2403 18 " " `` 42759 2403 19 Roman roman JJ 42759 2403 20 Responses response NNS 42759 2403 21 , , , 42759 2403 22 " " '' 42759 2403 23 nor nor CC 42759 2403 24 in in IN 42759 2403 25 the the DT 42759 2403 26 present present JJ 42759 2403 27 attitude attitude NN 42759 2403 28 of of IN 42759 2403 29 the the DT 42759 2403 30 Church Church NNP 42759 2403 31 and and CC 42759 2403 32 of of IN 42759 2403 33 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 2403 34 moralists moralist NNS 42759 2403 35 . . . 42759 2404 1 Undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 2404 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2404 3 could could MD 42759 2404 4 come come VB 42759 2404 5 only only RB 42759 2404 6 as as IN 42759 2404 7 the the DT 42759 2404 8 result result NN 42759 2404 9 of of IN 42759 2404 10 a a DT 42759 2404 11 change change NN 42759 2404 12 in in IN 42759 2404 13 the the DT 42759 2404 14 organisation organisation NN 42759 2404 15 of of IN 42759 2404 16 industry industry NN 42759 2404 17 , , , 42759 2404 18 just just RB 42759 2404 19 as as IN 42759 2404 20 the the DT 42759 2404 21 existing exist VBG 42759 2404 22 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 42759 2404 23 attitude attitude NN 42759 2404 24 has have VBZ 42759 2404 25 followed follow VBN 42759 2404 26 the the DT 42759 2404 27 changed change VBN 42759 2404 28 economic economic JJ 42759 2404 29 conditions condition NNS 42759 2404 30 since since IN 42759 2404 31 the the DT 42759 2404 32 Middle Middle NNP 42759 2404 33 Ages Ages NNPS 42759 2404 34 . . . 42759 2405 1 All all PDT 42759 2405 2 the the DT 42759 2405 3 theological theological JJ 42759 2405 4 discussion discussion NN 42759 2405 5 on on IN 42759 2405 6 the the DT 42759 2405 7 subject subject NN 42759 2405 8 , , , 42759 2405 9 and and CC 42759 2405 10 all all PDT 42759 2405 11 the the DT 42759 2405 12 authoritative authoritative JJ 42759 2405 13 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 42759 2405 14 declarations declaration NNS 42759 2405 15 indicate indicate VBP 42759 2405 16 , , , 42759 2405 17 therefore therefore RB 42759 2405 18 , , , 42759 2405 19 that that DT 42759 2405 20 interest interest NN 42759 2405 21 on on IN 42759 2405 22 loans loan NNS 42759 2405 23 is be VBZ 42759 2405 24 to to IN 42759 2405 25 - - HYPH 42759 2405 26 day day NN 42759 2405 27 regarded regard VBD 42759 2405 28 as as RB 42759 2405 29 lawful lawful JJ 42759 2405 30 because because IN 42759 2405 31 a a DT 42759 2405 32 loan loan NN 42759 2405 33 is be VBZ 42759 2405 34 the the DT 42759 2405 35 economic economic JJ 42759 2405 36 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 2405 37 of of IN 42759 2405 38 an an DT 42759 2405 39 investment investment NN 42759 2405 40 . . . 42759 2406 1 Evidently evidently RB 42759 2406 2 this this DT 42759 2406 3 is be VBZ 42759 2406 4 good good JJ 42759 2406 5 logic logic NN 42759 2406 6 and and CC 42759 2406 7 common common JJ 42759 2406 8 sense sense NN 42759 2406 9 . . . 42759 2407 1 If if IN 42759 2407 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2407 3 is be VBZ 42759 2407 4 right right JJ 42759 2407 5 for for IN 42759 2407 6 the the DT 42759 2407 7 stockholder stockholder NN 42759 2407 8 of of IN 42759 2407 9 a a DT 42759 2407 10 railway railway NN 42759 2407 11 to to TO 42759 2407 12 receive receive VB 42759 2407 13 dividends dividend NNS 42759 2407 14 , , , 42759 2407 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2407 16 is be VBZ 42759 2407 17 equally equally RB 42759 2407 18 right right JJ 42759 2407 19 for for IN 42759 2407 20 the the DT 42759 2407 21 bondholder bondholder NN 42759 2407 22 to to TO 42759 2407 23 receive receive VB 42759 2407 24 interest interest NN 42759 2407 25 . . . 42759 2408 1 If if IN 42759 2408 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2408 3 is be VBZ 42759 2408 4 right right JJ 42759 2408 5 for for IN 42759 2408 6 a a DT 42759 2408 7 merchant merchant NN 42759 2408 8 to to TO 42759 2408 9 take take VB 42759 2408 10 from from IN 42759 2408 11 the the DT 42759 2408 12 gross gross JJ 42759 2408 13 returns return NNS 42759 2408 14 of of IN 42759 2408 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2408 16 business business NN 42759 2408 17 a a DT 42759 2408 18 sum sum NN 42759 2408 19 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2408 20 to to TO 42759 2408 21 cover cover VB 42759 2408 22 interest interest NN 42759 2408 23 on on IN 42759 2408 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2408 25 capital capital NN 42759 2408 26 , , , 42759 2408 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2408 28 is be VBZ 42759 2408 29 equally equally RB 42759 2408 30 right right JJ 42759 2408 31 for for IN 42759 2408 32 the the DT 42759 2408 33 man man NN 42759 2408 34 from from IN 42759 2408 35 whom whom WP 42759 2408 36 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2408 37 has have VBZ 42759 2408 38 borrowed borrow VBN 42759 2408 39 money money NN 42759 2408 40 for for IN 42759 2408 41 the the DT 42759 2408 42 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 2408 43 to to TO 42759 2408 44 exact exact JJ 42759 2408 45 interest interest NN 42759 2408 46 . . . 42759 2409 1 The the DT 42759 2409 2 money money NN 42759 2409 3 in in IN 42759 2409 4 a a DT 42759 2409 5 loan loan NN 42759 2409 6 is be VBZ 42759 2409 7 economically economically RB 42759 2409 8 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 2409 9 to to IN 42759 2409 10 , , , 42759 2409 11 convertible convertible JJ 42759 2409 12 into into IN 42759 2409 13 , , , 42759 2409 14 concrete concrete JJ 42759 2409 15 capital capital NN 42759 2409 16 . . . 42759 2410 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2410 2 deserves deserve VBZ 42759 2410 3 , , , 42759 2410 4 therefore therefore RB 42759 2410 5 , , , 42759 2410 6 the the DT 42759 2410 7 same same JJ 42759 2410 8 treatment treatment NN 42759 2410 9 and and CC 42759 2410 10 the the DT 42759 2410 11 same same JJ 42759 2410 12 rewards reward NNS 42759 2410 13 . . . 42759 2411 1 The the DT 42759 2411 2 fact fact NN 42759 2411 3 that that IN 42759 2411 4 the the DT 42759 2411 5 investor investor NN 42759 2411 6 undergoes undergo VBZ 42759 2411 7 a a DT 42759 2411 8 greater great JJR 42759 2411 9 risk risk NN 42759 2411 10 than than IN 42759 2411 11 the the DT 42759 2411 12 lender lender NN 42759 2411 13 , , , 42759 2411 14 and and CC 42759 2411 15 the the DT 42759 2411 16 fact fact NN 42759 2411 17 that that IN 42759 2411 18 the the DT 42759 2411 19 former former JJ 42759 2411 20 often often RB 42759 2411 21 performs perform VBZ 42759 2411 22 labour labour NN 42759 2411 23 in in IN 42759 2411 24 connection connection NN 42759 2411 25 with with IN 42759 2411 26 the the DT 42759 2411 27 operation operation NN 42759 2411 28 of of IN 42759 2411 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2411 30 capital capital NN 42759 2411 31 , , , 42759 2411 32 have have VBP 42759 2411 33 no no DT 42759 2411 34 bearing bearing NN 42759 2411 35 on on IN 42759 2411 36 the the DT 42759 2411 37 moral moral JJ 42759 2411 38 problem problem NN 42759 2411 39 ; ; : 42759 2411 40 for for IN 42759 2411 41 the the DT 42759 2411 42 investor investor NN 42759 2411 43 is be VBZ 42759 2411 44 repaid repay VBN 42759 2411 45 for for IN 42759 2411 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2411 47 extra extra JJ 42759 2411 48 risk risk NN 42759 2411 49 and and CC 42759 2411 50 labour labour NN 42759 2411 51 by by IN 42759 2411 52 the the DT 42759 2411 53 profits profit NNS 42759 2411 54 which which WDT 42759 2411 55 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2411 56 receives receive VBZ 42759 2411 57 , , , 42759 2411 58 and and CC 42759 2411 59 which which WDT 42759 2411 60 the the DT 42759 2411 61 lender lender NN 42759 2411 62 does do VBZ 42759 2411 63 not not RB 42759 2411 64 receive receive VB 42759 2411 65 . . . 42759 2412 1 As as IN 42759 2412 2 a a DT 42759 2412 3 mere mere JJ 42759 2412 4 recipient recipient NN 42759 2412 5 of of IN 42759 2412 6 interest interest NN 42759 2412 7 , , , 42759 2412 8 the the DT 42759 2412 9 investor investor NN 42759 2412 10 undergoes undergo VBZ 42759 2412 11 no no DT 42759 2412 12 more more JJR 42759 2412 13 risk risk NN 42759 2412 14 nor nor CC 42759 2412 15 exertion exertion NN 42759 2412 16 than than IN 42759 2412 17 does do VBZ 42759 2412 18 the the DT 42759 2412 19 lender lender NN 42759 2412 20 . . . 42759 2413 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2413 2 claim claim NN 42759 2413 3 to to IN 42759 2413 4 interest interest NN 42759 2413 5 is be VBZ 42759 2413 6 no no RB 42759 2413 7 better well JJR 42759 2413 8 than than IN 42759 2413 9 that that DT 42759 2413 10 of of IN 42759 2413 11 the the DT 42759 2413 12 latter latter JJ 42759 2413 13 . . . 42759 2414 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2414 2 Interest interest NN 42759 2414 3 on on IN 42759 2414 4 Productive Productive NNP 42759 2414 5 Capital Capital NNP 42759 2414 6 _ _ NNP 42759 2414 7 On on IN 42759 2414 8 what what WDT 42759 2414 9 ground ground NN 42759 2414 10 does do VBZ 42759 2414 11 the the DT 42759 2414 12 Church Church NNP 42759 2414 13 or or CC 42759 2414 14 Catholic Catholic NNP 42759 2414 15 theological theological JJ 42759 2414 16 opinion opinion NN 42759 2414 17 justify justify VBP 42759 2414 18 interest interest NN 42759 2414 19 on on IN 42759 2414 20 invested invest VBN 42759 2414 21 capital capital NN 42759 2414 22 ? ? . 42759 2415 1 on on IN 42759 2415 2 the the DT 42759 2415 3 shares share NNS 42759 2415 4 of of IN 42759 2415 5 the the DT 42759 2415 6 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 2415 7 in in IN 42759 2415 8 corporations corporation NNS 42759 2415 9 ? ? . 42759 2416 1 on on IN 42759 2416 2 the the DT 42759 2416 3 capital capital NN 42759 2416 4 of of IN 42759 2416 5 the the DT 42759 2416 6 merchant merchant NN 42759 2416 7 and and CC 42759 2416 8 the the DT 42759 2416 9 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 2416 10 ? ? . 42759 2417 1 In in IN 42759 2417 2 the the DT 42759 2417 3 early early JJ 42759 2417 4 Middle Middle NNP 42759 2417 5 Ages Ages NNP 42759 2417 6 the the DT 42759 2417 7 only only RB 42759 2417 8 recognised recognise VBN 42759 2417 9 titles title NNS 42759 2417 10 to to TO 42759 2417 11 gain gain VB 42759 2417 12 from from IN 42759 2417 13 the the DT 42759 2417 14 ownership ownership NN 42759 2417 15 of of IN 42759 2417 16 property property NN 42759 2417 17 were be VBD 42759 2417 18 labour labour NN 42759 2417 19 and and CC 42759 2417 20 risk risk NN 42759 2417 21 . . . 42759 2418 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2418 2 137 137 CD 42759 2418 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2418 4 Down down IN 42759 2418 5 to to IN 42759 2418 6 the the DT 42759 2418 7 beginning beginning NN 42759 2418 8 of of IN 42759 2418 9 the the DT 42759 2418 10 fifteenth fifteenth JJ 42759 2418 11 century century NN 42759 2418 12 substantially substantially RB 42759 2418 13 all all PDT 42759 2418 14 the the DT 42759 2418 15 incomes income NNS 42759 2418 16 of of IN 42759 2418 17 all all DT 42759 2418 18 classes class NNS 42759 2418 19 could could MD 42759 2418 20 be be VB 42759 2418 21 explained explain VBN 42759 2418 22 and and CC 42759 2418 23 justified justify VBN 42759 2418 24 by by IN 42759 2418 25 one one CD 42759 2418 26 or or CC 42759 2418 27 other other JJ 42759 2418 28 of of IN 42759 2418 29 these these DT 42759 2418 30 two two CD 42759 2418 31 titles title NNS 42759 2418 32 ; ; : 42759 2418 33 for for IN 42759 2418 34 the the DT 42759 2418 35 amount amount NN 42759 2418 36 of of IN 42759 2418 37 capital capital NN 42759 2418 38 in in IN 42759 2418 39 existence existence NN 42759 2418 40 was be VBD 42759 2418 41 inconsiderable inconsiderable JJ 42759 2418 42 , , , 42759 2418 43 and and CC 42759 2418 44 the the DT 42759 2418 45 number number NN 42759 2418 46 of of IN 42759 2418 47 large large JJ 42759 2418 48 personal personal JJ 42759 2418 49 incomes income NNS 42759 2418 50 insignificant insignificant JJ 42759 2418 51 . . . 42759 2419 1 When when WRB 42759 2419 2 , , , 42759 2419 3 however however RB 42759 2419 4 , , , 42759 2419 5 the the DT 42759 2419 6 traffic traffic NN 42759 2419 7 in in IN 42759 2419 8 rent rent NN 42759 2419 9 charges charge NNS 42759 2419 10 and and CC 42759 2419 11 the the DT 42759 2419 12 operation operation NN 42759 2419 13 of of IN 42759 2419 14 partnerships partnership NNS 42759 2419 15 , , , 42759 2419 16 especially especially RB 42759 2419 17 the the DT 42759 2419 18 " " `` 42759 2419 19 contractus contractus NN 42759 2419 20 trinus trinus NN 42759 2419 21 , , , 42759 2419 22 " " '' 42759 2419 23 or or CC 42759 2419 24 triple triple JJ 42759 2419 25 contract contract NN 42759 2419 26 , , , 42759 2419 27 had have VBD 42759 2419 28 become become VBN 42759 2419 29 fairly fairly RB 42759 2419 30 common common JJ 42759 2419 31 , , , 42759 2419 32 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2419 33 was be VBD 42759 2419 34 obvious obvious JJ 42759 2419 35 that that IN 42759 2419 36 the the DT 42759 2419 37 profits profit NNS 42759 2419 38 from from IN 42759 2419 39 these these DT 42759 2419 40 practices practice NNS 42759 2419 41 could could MD 42759 2419 42 not not RB 42759 2419 43 be be VB 42759 2419 44 correctly correctly RB 42759 2419 45 attributed attribute VBN 42759 2419 46 to to IN 42759 2419 47 either either CC 42759 2419 48 labour labour NN 42759 2419 49 or or CC 42759 2419 50 risk risk NN 42759 2419 51 . . . 42759 2420 1 The the DT 42759 2420 2 person person NN 42759 2420 3 who who WP 42759 2420 4 bought buy VBD 42759 2420 5 , , , 42759 2420 6 not not RB 42759 2420 7 the the DT 42759 2420 8 land land NN 42759 2420 9 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2420 10 , , , 42759 2420 11 but but CC 42759 2420 12 the the DT 42759 2420 13 right right NN 42759 2420 14 to to TO 42759 2420 15 receive receive VB 42759 2420 16 a a DT 42759 2420 17 portion portion NN 42759 2420 18 of of IN 42759 2420 19 the the DT 42759 2420 20 rent rent NN 42759 2420 21 thereof thereof RB 42759 2420 22 , , , 42759 2420 23 and and CC 42759 2420 24 the the DT 42759 2420 25 person person NN 42759 2420 26 who who WP 42759 2420 27 became become VBD 42759 2420 28 the the DT 42759 2420 29 silent silent JJ 42759 2420 30 member member NN 42759 2420 31 of of IN 42759 2420 32 a a DT 42759 2420 33 partnership partnership NN 42759 2420 34 , , , 42759 2420 35 evidently evidently RB 42759 2420 36 performed perform VBD 42759 2420 37 no no DT 42759 2420 38 labour labour NN 42759 2420 39 beyond beyond IN 42759 2420 40 that that DT 42759 2420 41 involved involved JJ 42759 2420 42 in in IN 42759 2420 43 making make VBG 42759 2420 44 the the DT 42759 2420 45 contract contract NN 42759 2420 46 . . . 42759 2421 1 And and CC 42759 2421 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2421 3 profits profit NNS 42759 2421 4 clearly clearly RB 42759 2421 5 exceeded exceed VBD 42759 2421 6 a a DT 42759 2421 7 fair fair JJ 42759 2421 8 compensation compensation NN 42759 2421 9 for for IN 42759 2421 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2421 11 risks risk NNS 42759 2421 12 , , , 42759 2421 13 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 2421 14 as as IN 42759 2421 15 the the DT 42759 2421 16 profits profit NNS 42759 2421 17 produced produce VBD 42759 2421 18 a a DT 42759 2421 19 steady steady JJ 42759 2421 20 income income NN 42759 2421 21 . . . 42759 2422 1 How how WRB 42759 2422 2 then then RB 42759 2422 3 were be VBD 42759 2422 4 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2422 5 to to TO 42759 2422 6 be be VB 42759 2422 7 justified justify VBN 42759 2422 8 ? ? . 42759 2423 1 A a DT 42759 2423 2 few few JJ 42759 2423 3 authorities authority NNS 42759 2423 4 maintained maintain VBD 42759 2423 5 that that IN 42759 2423 6 such such JJ 42759 2423 7 incomes income NNS 42759 2423 8 had have VBD 42759 2423 9 no no DT 42759 2423 10 justification justification NN 42759 2423 11 . . . 42759 2424 1 In in IN 42759 2424 2 the the DT 42759 2424 3 thirteenth thirteenth JJ 42759 2424 4 century century NN 42759 2424 5 Henry Henry NNP 42759 2424 6 of of IN 42759 2424 7 Ghent Ghent NNP 42759 2424 8 condemned condemn VBD 42759 2424 9 the the DT 42759 2424 10 traffic traffic NN 42759 2424 11 in in IN 42759 2424 12 rent rent NN 42759 2424 13 charges charge NNS 42759 2424 14 ; ; : 42759 2424 15 in in IN 42759 2424 16 the the DT 42759 2424 17 sixteenth sixteenth JJ 42759 2424 18 Dominicus Dominicus NNP 42759 2424 19 Soto Soto NNP 42759 2424 20 maintained maintain VBD 42759 2424 21 that that IN 42759 2424 22 the the DT 42759 2424 23 returns return NNS 42759 2424 24 to to IN 42759 2424 25 the the DT 42759 2424 26 silent silent JJ 42759 2424 27 partner partner NN 42759 2424 28 in in IN 42759 2424 29 an an DT 42759 2424 30 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 2424 31 ought ought MD 42759 2424 32 not not RB 42759 2424 33 to to TO 42759 2424 34 exceed exceed VB 42759 2424 35 a a DT 42759 2424 36 fair fair JJ 42759 2424 37 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 2424 38 for for IN 42759 2424 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2424 40 risks risk NNS 42759 2424 41 ; ; : 42759 2424 42 about about IN 42759 2424 43 the the DT 42759 2424 44 same same JJ 42759 2424 45 time time NN 42759 2424 46 Pope Pope NNP 42759 2424 47 Sixtus Sixtus NNP 42759 2424 48 V V NNP 42759 2424 49 denounced denounce VBD 42759 2424 50 the the DT 42759 2424 51 triple triple JJ 42759 2424 52 contract contract NN 42759 2424 53 as as IN 42759 2424 54 a a DT 42759 2424 55 form form NN 42759 2424 56 of of IN 42759 2424 57 usury usury NN 42759 2424 58 . . . 42759 2425 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2425 2 , , , 42759 2425 3 the the DT 42759 2425 4 great great JJ 42759 2425 5 majority majority NN 42759 2425 6 of of IN 42759 2425 7 writers writer NNS 42759 2425 8 admitted admit VBD 42759 2425 9 that that IN 42759 2425 10 all all PDT 42759 2425 11 these these DT 42759 2425 12 transactions transaction NNS 42759 2425 13 were be VBD 42759 2425 14 morally morally RB 42759 2425 15 lawful lawful JJ 42759 2425 16 , , , 42759 2425 17 and and CC 42759 2425 18 the the DT 42759 2425 19 gains gain NNS 42759 2425 20 therefrom therefrom NN 42759 2425 21 just just RB 42759 2425 22 . . . 42759 2426 1 For for IN 42759 2426 2 a a DT 42759 2426 3 time time NN 42759 2426 4 these these DT 42759 2426 5 writers writer NNS 42759 2426 6 employed employ VBD 42759 2426 7 merely merely RB 42759 2426 8 negative negative JJ 42759 2426 9 and and CC 42759 2426 10 _ _ NNP 42759 2426 11 a a DT 42759 2426 12 pari pari NN 42759 2426 13 _ _ NNP 42759 2426 14 arguments argument NNS 42759 2426 15 . . . 42759 2427 1 Gains gain NNS 42759 2427 2 from from IN 42759 2427 3 rent rent NN 42759 2427 4 charges charge NNS 42759 2427 5 , , , 42759 2427 6 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2427 7 pointed point VBD 42759 2427 8 out out RP 42759 2427 9 , , , 42759 2427 10 were be VBD 42759 2427 11 essentially essentially RB 42759 2427 12 as as RB 42759 2427 13 licit licit RB 42759 2427 14 as as IN 42759 2427 15 the the DT 42759 2427 16 net net JJ 42759 2427 17 rent rent NN 42759 2427 18 received receive VBN 42759 2427 19 by by IN 42759 2427 20 the the DT 42759 2427 21 owner owner NN 42759 2427 22 of of IN 42759 2427 23 the the DT 42759 2427 24 land land NN 42759 2427 25 ; ; : 42759 2427 26 and and CC 42759 2427 27 the the DT 42759 2427 28 interest interest NN 42759 2427 29 received receive VBN 42759 2427 30 by by IN 42759 2427 31 a a DT 42759 2427 32 silent silent JJ 42759 2427 33 partner partner NN 42759 2427 34 , , , 42759 2427 35 even even RB 42759 2427 36 in in IN 42759 2427 37 a a DT 42759 2427 38 triple triple JJ 42759 2427 39 contract contract NN 42759 2427 40 , , , 42759 2427 41 had have VBD 42759 2427 42 quite quite RB 42759 2427 43 as as RB 42759 2427 44 sound sound JJ 42759 2427 45 a a DT 42759 2427 46 moral moral JJ 42759 2427 47 basis basis NN 42759 2427 48 as as IN 42759 2427 49 rent rent NN 42759 2427 50 charges charge NNS 42759 2427 51 . . . 42759 2428 1 By by IN 42759 2428 2 the the DT 42759 2428 3 beginning beginning NN 42759 2428 4 of of IN 42759 2428 5 the the DT 42759 2428 6 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 42759 2428 7 century century NN 42759 2428 8 the the DT 42759 2428 9 leading lead VBG 42759 2428 10 authorities authority NNS 42759 2428 11 were be VBD 42759 2428 12 basing base VBG 42759 2428 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2428 14 defence defence NN 42759 2428 15 of of IN 42759 2428 16 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2428 17 interest interest NN 42759 2428 18 on on IN 42759 2428 19 positive positive JJ 42759 2428 20 grounds ground NNS 42759 2428 21 . . . 42759 2429 1 Lugo Lugo NNP 42759 2429 2 , , , 42759 2429 3 Lessius Lessius NNP 42759 2429 4 , , , 42759 2429 5 and and CC 42759 2429 6 Molina Molina NNP 42759 2429 7 adduced adduce VBD 42759 2429 8 the the DT 42759 2429 9 productivity productivity NN 42759 2429 10 of of IN 42759 2429 11 capital capital NN 42759 2429 12 goods good NNS 42759 2429 13 as as IN 42759 2429 14 a a DT 42759 2429 15 reason reason NN 42759 2429 16 for for IN 42759 2429 17 allowing allow VBG 42759 2429 18 gains gain NNS 42759 2429 19 to to IN 42759 2429 20 the the DT 42759 2429 21 investor investor NN 42759 2429 22 . . . 42759 2430 1 Whether whether IN 42759 2430 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2430 3 regarded regard VBD 42759 2430 4 productivity productivity NN 42759 2430 5 as as IN 42759 2430 6 in in IN 42759 2430 7 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2430 8 a a DT 42759 2430 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2430 10 justification justification NN 42759 2430 11 of of IN 42759 2430 12 interest interest NN 42759 2430 13 , , , 42759 2430 14 or or CC 42759 2430 15 merely merely RB 42759 2430 16 as as IN 42759 2430 17 a a DT 42759 2430 18 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2430 19 prerequisite prerequisite NN 42759 2430 20 to to IN 42759 2430 21 justification justification NN 42759 2430 22 , , , 42759 2430 23 can can MD 42759 2430 24 not not RB 42759 2430 25 be be VB 42759 2430 26 determined determine VBN 42759 2430 27 with with IN 42759 2430 28 certainty certainty NN 42759 2430 29 . . . 42759 2431 1 At at IN 42759 2431 2 present present JJ 42759 2431 3 the the DT 42759 2431 4 majority majority NN 42759 2431 5 of of IN 42759 2431 6 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 2431 7 writers writer NNS 42759 2431 8 seem seem VBP 42759 2431 9 to to TO 42759 2431 10 think think VB 42759 2431 11 that that IN 42759 2431 12 a a DT 42759 2431 13 formal formal JJ 42759 2431 14 defence defence NN 42759 2431 15 of of IN 42759 2431 16 interest interest NN 42759 2431 17 on on IN 42759 2431 18 capital capital NN 42759 2431 19 is be VBZ 42759 2431 20 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 2431 21 . . . 42759 2432 1 Apparently apparently RB 42759 2432 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2432 3 assume assume VBP 42759 2432 4 that that IN 42759 2432 5 interest interest NN 42759 2432 6 is be VBZ 42759 2432 7 justified justify VBN 42759 2432 8 by by IN 42759 2432 9 the the DT 42759 2432 10 mere mere JJ 42759 2432 11 productivity productivity NN 42759 2432 12 of of IN 42759 2432 13 capital capital NN 42759 2432 14 . . . 42759 2433 1 However however RB 42759 2433 2 , , , 42759 2433 3 this this DT 42759 2433 4 view view NN 42759 2433 5 has have VBZ 42759 2433 6 never never RB 42759 2433 7 been be VBN 42759 2433 8 explicitly explicitly RB 42759 2433 9 approved approve VBN 42759 2433 10 by by IN 42759 2433 11 the the DT 42759 2433 12 Church Church NNP 42759 2433 13 . . . 42759 2434 1 While while IN 42759 2434 2 she -PRON- PRP 42759 2434 3 permits permit VBZ 42759 2434 4 and and CC 42759 2434 5 authorises authorise VBZ 42759 2434 6 interest interest NN 42759 2434 7 , , , 42759 2434 8 she -PRON- PRP 42759 2434 9 does do VBZ 42759 2434 10 not not RB 42759 2434 11 define define VB 42759 2434 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2434 13 precise precise JJ 42759 2434 14 moral moral JJ 42759 2434 15 basis basis NN 42759 2434 16 . . . 42759 2435 1 So so RB 42759 2435 2 much much JJ 42759 2435 3 for for IN 42759 2435 4 the the DT 42759 2435 5 teaching teaching NN 42759 2435 6 of of IN 42759 2435 7 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 42759 2435 8 and and CC 42759 2435 9 ethical ethical JJ 42759 2435 10 authorities authority NNS 42759 2435 11 . . . 42759 2436 1 What what WP 42759 2436 2 are be VBP 42759 2436 3 the the DT 42759 2436 4 objective objective JJ 42759 2436 5 reasons reason NNS 42759 2436 6 in in IN 42759 2436 7 favour favour NN 42759 2436 8 of of IN 42759 2436 9 the the DT 42759 2436 10 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2436 11 's 's POS 42759 2436 12 claim claim NN 42759 2436 13 to to IN 42759 2436 14 interest interest NN 42759 2436 15 ? ? . 42759 2437 1 In in IN 42759 2437 2 this this DT 42759 2437 3 chapter chapter NN 42759 2437 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2437 5 consider consider VBP 42759 2437 6 only only RB 42759 2437 7 the the DT 42759 2437 8 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2437 9 reasons reason NNS 42759 2437 10 , , , 42759 2437 11 those those DT 42759 2437 12 arising arise VBG 42759 2437 13 wholly wholly RB 42759 2437 14 out out IN 42759 2437 15 of of IN 42759 2437 16 the the DT 42759 2437 17 relations relation NNS 42759 2437 18 between between IN 42759 2437 19 the the DT 42759 2437 20 interest interest NN 42759 2437 21 - - HYPH 42759 2437 22 receiver receiver NN 42759 2437 23 and and CC 42759 2437 24 the the DT 42759 2437 25 interest interest NN 42759 2437 26 - - HYPH 42759 2437 27 payer payer NN 42759 2437 28 . . . 42759 2438 1 Before before IN 42759 2438 2 taking take VBG 42759 2438 3 up up RP 42759 2438 4 the the DT 42759 2438 5 subject subject NN 42759 2438 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2438 7 may may MD 42759 2438 8 be be VB 42759 2438 9 well well JJ 42759 2438 10 to to TO 42759 2438 11 point point VB 42759 2438 12 out out RP 42759 2438 13 the the DT 42759 2438 14 source source NN 42759 2438 15 from from IN 42759 2438 16 which which WDT 42759 2438 17 interest interest NN 42759 2438 18 comes come VBZ 42759 2438 19 , , , 42759 2438 20 the the DT 42759 2438 21 class class NN 42759 2438 22 in in IN 42759 2438 23 the the DT 42759 2438 24 community community NN 42759 2438 25 that that WDT 42759 2438 26 pays pay VBZ 42759 2438 27 the the DT 42759 2438 28 interest interest NN 42759 2438 29 to to IN 42759 2438 30 the the DT 42759 2438 31 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2438 32 . . . 42759 2439 1 From from IN 42759 2439 2 the the DT 42759 2439 3 language language NN 42759 2439 4 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 2439 5 used use VBN 42759 2439 6 by by IN 42759 2439 7 Socialists socialist NNS 42759 2439 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2439 9 might may MD 42759 2439 10 be be VB 42759 2439 11 inferred infer VBN 42759 2439 12 that that IN 42759 2439 13 interest interest NN 42759 2439 14 is be VBZ 42759 2439 15 taken take VBN 42759 2439 16 from from IN 42759 2439 17 the the DT 42759 2439 18 labourer labourer NN 42759 2439 19 , , , 42759 2439 20 and and CC 42759 2439 21 that that IN 42759 2439 22 if if IN 42759 2439 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2439 24 were be VBD 42759 2439 25 abolished abolish VBN 42759 2439 26 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2439 27 would would MD 42759 2439 28 be be VB 42759 2439 29 the the DT 42759 2439 30 chief chief NN 42759 2439 31 if if IN 42759 2439 32 not not RB 42759 2439 33 the the DT 42759 2439 34 only only JJ 42759 2439 35 beneficiary beneficiary NN 42759 2439 36 . . . 42759 2440 1 This this DT 42759 2440 2 is be VBZ 42759 2440 3 incorrect incorrect JJ 42759 2440 4 . . . 42759 2441 1 At at IN 42759 2441 2 any any DT 42759 2441 3 given give VBN 42759 2441 4 time time NN 42759 2441 5 interest interest NN 42759 2441 6 on on IN 42759 2441 7 producing produce VBG 42759 2441 8 capital capital NN 42759 2441 9 is be VBZ 42759 2441 10 paid pay VBN 42759 2441 11 by by IN 42759 2441 12 the the DT 42759 2441 13 consumer consumer NN 42759 2441 14 . . . 42759 2442 1 Those those DT 42759 2442 2 who who WP 42759 2442 3 purchase purchase VBP 42759 2442 4 the the DT 42759 2442 5 products product NNS 42759 2442 6 of of IN 42759 2442 7 industry industry NN 42759 2442 8 must must MD 42759 2442 9 give give VB 42759 2442 10 prices price NNS 42759 2442 11 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 2442 12 high high JJ 42759 2442 13 to to TO 42759 2442 14 provide provide VB 42759 2442 15 interest interest NN 42759 2442 16 in in IN 42759 2442 17 addition addition NN 42759 2442 18 to to IN 42759 2442 19 the the DT 42759 2442 20 other other JJ 42759 2442 21 expenses expense NNS 42759 2442 22 of of IN 42759 2442 23 production production NN 42759 2442 24 . . . 42759 2443 1 Were be VBD 42759 2443 2 interest interest NN 42759 2443 3 abolished abolish VBN 42759 2443 4 and and CC 42759 2443 5 the the DT 42759 2443 6 present present JJ 42759 2443 7 system system NN 42759 2443 8 of of IN 42759 2443 9 private private JJ 42759 2443 10 capital capital NN 42759 2443 11 continued continue VBN 42759 2443 12 , , , 42759 2443 13 the the DT 42759 2443 14 gain gain NN 42759 2443 15 would would MD 42759 2443 16 be be VB 42759 2443 17 mainly mainly RB 42759 2443 18 reaped reap VBN 42759 2443 19 by by IN 42759 2443 20 the the DT 42759 2443 21 consumer consumer NN 42759 2443 22 in in IN 42759 2443 23 the the DT 42759 2443 24 form form NN 42759 2443 25 of of IN 42759 2443 26 lower low JJR 42759 2443 27 prices price NNS 42759 2443 28 ; ; : 42759 2443 29 for for IN 42759 2443 30 the the DT 42759 2443 31 various various JJ 42759 2443 32 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 2443 33 directors director NNS 42759 2443 34 of of IN 42759 2443 35 industry industry NN 42759 2443 36 would would MD 42759 2443 37 bring bring VB 42759 2443 38 about about RP 42759 2443 39 this this DT 42759 2443 40 result result NN 42759 2443 41 through through IN 42759 2443 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2443 43 competitive competitive JJ 42759 2443 44 efforts effort NNS 42759 2443 45 to to TO 42759 2443 46 increase increase VB 42759 2443 47 sales sale NNS 42759 2443 48 . . . 42759 2444 1 Only only RB 42759 2444 2 those those DT 42759 2444 3 labourers labourer NNS 42759 2444 4 who who WP 42759 2444 5 were be VBD 42759 2444 6 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 2444 7 organised organise VBN 42759 2444 8 and and CC 42759 2444 9 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 2444 10 alert alert JJ 42759 2444 11 to to TO 42759 2444 12 make make VB 42759 2444 13 effective effective JJ 42759 2444 14 demands demand NNS 42759 2444 15 for for IN 42759 2444 16 higher high JJR 42759 2444 17 wages wage NNS 42759 2444 18 before before IN 42759 2444 19 the the DT 42759 2444 20 movement movement NN 42759 2444 21 toward toward IN 42759 2444 22 lower low JJR 42759 2444 23 prices price NNS 42759 2444 24 had have VBD 42759 2444 25 got get VBN 42759 2444 26 well well RB 42759 2444 27 under under IN 42759 2444 28 way way NN 42759 2444 29 , , , 42759 2444 30 would would MD 42759 2444 31 obtain obtain VB 42759 2444 32 any any DT 42759 2444 33 direct direct JJ 42759 2444 34 benefit benefit NN 42759 2444 35 from from IN 42759 2444 36 the the DT 42759 2444 37 change change NN 42759 2444 38 . . . 42759 2445 1 The the DT 42759 2445 2 great great JJ 42759 2445 3 majority majority NN 42759 2445 4 of of IN 42759 2445 5 labourers labourer NNS 42759 2445 6 would would MD 42759 2445 7 gain gain VB 42759 2445 8 far far RB 42759 2445 9 more more JJR 42759 2445 10 as as IN 42759 2445 11 consumers consumer NNS 42759 2445 12 than than IN 42759 2445 13 as as IN 42759 2445 14 wage wage NN 42759 2445 15 earners earner NNS 42759 2445 16 . . . 42759 2446 1 Speaking speak VBG 42759 2446 2 generally generally RB 42759 2446 3 , , , 42759 2446 4 then then RB 42759 2446 5 , , , 42759 2446 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2446 7 may may MD 42759 2446 8 say say VB 42759 2446 9 that that IN 42759 2446 10 the the DT 42759 2446 11 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2446 12 's 's POS 42759 2446 13 gain gain NN 42759 2446 14 is be VBZ 42759 2446 15 the the DT 42759 2446 16 consumer consumer NN 42759 2446 17 's 's POS 42759 2446 18 loss loss NN 42759 2446 19 , , , 42759 2446 20 and and CC 42759 2446 21 the the DT 42759 2446 22 question question NN 42759 2446 23 of of IN 42759 2446 24 the the DT 42759 2446 25 justice justice NNP 42759 2446 26 of of IN 42759 2446 27 interest interest NN 42759 2446 28 is be VBZ 42759 2446 29 a a DT 42759 2446 30 question question NN 42759 2446 31 between between IN 42759 2446 32 the the DT 42759 2446 33 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2446 34 and and CC 42759 2446 35 the the DT 42759 2446 36 consumer consumer NN 42759 2446 37 . . . 42759 2447 1 The the DT 42759 2447 2 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2447 3 or or CC 42759 2447 4 individual individual JJ 42759 2447 5 grounds ground NNS 42759 2447 6 upon upon IN 42759 2447 7 which which WDT 42759 2447 8 the the DT 42759 2447 9 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2447 10 's 's POS 42759 2447 11 claim claim NN 42759 2447 12 to to IN 42759 2447 13 interest interest NN 42759 2447 14 has have VBZ 42759 2447 15 been be VBN 42759 2447 16 defended defend VBN 42759 2447 17 are be VBP 42759 2447 18 mainly mainly RB 42759 2447 19 three three CD 42759 2447 20 : : : 42759 2447 21 productivity productivity NN 42759 2447 22 , , , 42759 2447 23 service service NN 42759 2447 24 , , , 42759 2447 25 and and CC 42759 2447 26 abstinence abstinence NN 42759 2447 27 . . . 42759 2448 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2448 2 will will MD 42759 2448 3 be be VB 42759 2448 4 considered consider VBN 42759 2448 5 in in IN 42759 2448 6 this this DT 42759 2448 7 order order NN 42759 2448 8 . . . 42759 2449 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2449 2 The the DT 42759 2449 3 Claims Claims NNPS 42759 2449 4 of of IN 42759 2449 5 Productivity Productivity NNP 42759 2449 6 _ _ NNP 42759 2449 7 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2449 8 is be VBZ 42759 2449 9 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 2449 10 asserted assert VBN 42759 2449 11 that that IN 42759 2449 12 the the DT 42759 2449 13 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2449 14 has have VBZ 42759 2449 15 as as RB 42759 2449 16 good good JJ 42759 2449 17 a a DT 42759 2449 18 right right NN 42759 2449 19 to to IN 42759 2449 20 interest interest NN 42759 2449 21 as as IN 42759 2449 22 the the DT 42759 2449 23 farmer farmer NN 42759 2449 24 has have VBZ 42759 2449 25 to to IN 42759 2449 26 the the DT 42759 2449 27 offspring offspring NN 42759 2449 28 of of IN 42759 2449 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2449 30 animals animal NNS 42759 2449 31 . . . 42759 2450 1 Both both DT 42759 2450 2 are be VBP 42759 2450 3 the the DT 42759 2450 4 products product NNS 42759 2450 5 of of IN 42759 2450 6 the the DT 42759 2450 7 owner owner NN 42759 2450 8 's 's POS 42759 2450 9 property property NN 42759 2450 10 . . . 42759 2451 1 In in IN 42759 2451 2 two two CD 42759 2451 3 respects respect NNS 42759 2451 4 , , , 42759 2451 5 however however RB 42759 2451 6 , , , 42759 2451 7 the the DT 42759 2451 8 comparison comparison NN 42759 2451 9 is be VBZ 42759 2451 10 inadequate inadequate JJ 42759 2451 11 and and CC 42759 2451 12 misleading misleading JJ 42759 2451 13 . . . 42759 2452 1 Since since IN 42759 2452 2 the the DT 42759 2452 3 owner owner NN 42759 2452 4 of of IN 42759 2452 5 a a DT 42759 2452 6 female female JJ 42759 2452 7 animal animal NN 42759 2452 8 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 2452 9 labour labour NN 42759 2452 10 or or CC 42759 2452 11 money money NN 42759 2452 12 or or CC 42759 2452 13 both both DT 42759 2452 14 toward toward IN 42759 2452 15 her -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2452 16 care care NN 42759 2452 17 during during IN 42759 2452 18 the the DT 42759 2452 19 period period NN 42759 2452 20 of of IN 42759 2452 21 gestation gestation NN 42759 2452 22 , , , 42759 2452 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2452 24 claim claim NN 42759 2452 25 to to IN 42759 2452 26 the the DT 42759 2452 27 offspring offspring NN 42759 2452 28 is be VBZ 42759 2452 29 based base VBN 42759 2452 30 in in IN 42759 2452 31 part part NN 42759 2452 32 upon upon IN 42759 2452 33 these these DT 42759 2452 34 grounds ground NNS 42759 2452 35 , , , 42759 2452 36 and and CC 42759 2452 37 only only RB 42759 2452 38 in in IN 42759 2452 39 part part NN 42759 2452 40 upon upon IN 42759 2452 41 the the DT 42759 2452 42 title title NN 42759 2452 43 of of IN 42759 2452 44 interest interest NN 42759 2452 45 . . . 42759 2453 1 In in IN 42759 2453 2 the the DT 42759 2453 3 second second JJ 42759 2453 4 place place NN 42759 2453 5 , , , 42759 2453 6 the the DT 42759 2453 7 offspring offspring NN 42759 2453 8 is be VBZ 42759 2453 9 the the DT 42759 2453 10 definite definite JJ 42759 2453 11 and and CC 42759 2453 12 easily easily RB 42759 2453 13 distinguishable distinguishable JJ 42759 2453 14 product product NN 42759 2453 15 of of IN 42759 2453 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2453 17 parent parent NN 42759 2453 18 . . . 42759 2454 1 But but CC 42759 2454 2 the the DT 42759 2454 3 sixty sixty CD 42759 2454 4 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2454 5 derived derive VBN 42759 2454 6 as as IN 42759 2454 7 interest interest NN 42759 2454 8 from from IN 42759 2454 9 the the DT 42759 2454 10 ownership ownership NN 42759 2454 11 of of IN 42759 2454 12 ten ten CD 42759 2454 13 shares share NNS 42759 2454 14 of of IN 42759 2454 15 railway railway NN 42759 2454 16 stock stock NN 42759 2454 17 , , , 42759 2454 18 can can MD 42759 2454 19 not not RB 42759 2454 20 be be VB 42759 2454 21 identified identify VBN 42759 2454 22 as as IN 42759 2454 23 the the DT 42759 2454 24 exact exact JJ 42759 2454 25 product product NN 42759 2454 26 of of IN 42759 2454 27 one one CD 42759 2454 28 thousand thousand CD 42759 2454 29 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2454 30 of of IN 42759 2454 31 railway railway NN 42759 2454 32 property property NN 42759 2454 33 . . . 42759 2455 1 No no DT 42759 2455 2 man man NN 42759 2455 3 can can MD 42759 2455 4 tell tell VB 42759 2455 5 whether whether IN 42759 2455 6 this this DT 42759 2455 7 amount amount NN 42759 2455 8 of of IN 42759 2455 9 capital capital NN 42759 2455 10 has have VBZ 42759 2455 11 contributed contribute VBN 42759 2455 12 more more RBR 42759 2455 13 or or CC 42759 2455 14 less less JJR 42759 2455 15 than than IN 42759 2455 16 sixty sixty JJ 42759 2455 17 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2455 18 of of IN 42759 2455 19 value value NN 42759 2455 20 to to IN 42759 2455 21 the the DT 42759 2455 22 joint joint JJ 42759 2455 23 product product NN 42759 2455 24 , , , 42759 2455 25 i.e. i.e. FW 42759 2455 26 , , , 42759 2455 27 railway railway NN 42759 2455 28 services service NNS 42759 2455 29 . . . 42759 2456 1 The the DT 42759 2456 2 same same JJ 42759 2456 3 is be VBZ 42759 2456 4 true true JJ 42759 2456 5 of of IN 42759 2456 6 any any DT 42759 2456 7 other other JJ 42759 2456 8 share share NN 42759 2456 9 or or CC 42759 2456 10 piece piece NN 42759 2456 11 of of IN 42759 2456 12 concrete concrete JJ 42759 2456 13 capital capital NN 42759 2456 14 . . . 42759 2457 1 All all DT 42759 2457 2 that that WDT 42759 2457 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2457 4 know know VBP 42759 2457 5 is be VBZ 42759 2457 6 that that IN 42759 2457 7 the the DT 42759 2457 8 interest interest NN 42759 2457 9 , , , 42759 2457 10 be be VB 42759 2457 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2457 12 five five CD 42759 2457 13 , , , 42759 2457 14 six six CD 42759 2457 15 , , , 42759 2457 16 seven seven CD 42759 2457 17 , , , 42759 2457 18 or or CC 42759 2457 19 some some DT 42759 2457 20 other other JJ 42759 2457 21 per per IN 42759 2457 22 cent cent NN 42759 2457 23 . . . 42759 2457 24 , , , 42759 2457 25 describes describe VBZ 42759 2457 26 the the DT 42759 2457 27 share share NN 42759 2457 28 of of IN 42759 2457 29 the the DT 42759 2457 30 product product NN 42759 2457 31 which which WDT 42759 2457 32 goes go VBZ 42759 2457 33 to to IN 42759 2457 34 the the DT 42759 2457 35 owner owner NN 42759 2457 36 of of IN 42759 2457 37 capital capital NN 42759 2457 38 in in IN 42759 2457 39 the the DT 42759 2457 40 present present JJ 42759 2457 41 conditions condition NNS 42759 2457 42 of of IN 42759 2457 43 industry industry NN 42759 2457 44 . . . 42759 2458 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2458 2 is be VBZ 42759 2458 3 the the DT 42759 2458 4 conventional conventional JJ 42759 2458 5 not not RB 42759 2458 6 the the DT 42759 2458 7 actual actual JJ 42759 2458 8 and and CC 42759 2458 9 physical physical JJ 42759 2458 10 product product NN 42759 2458 11 of of IN 42759 2458 12 capital capital NN 42759 2458 13 . . . 42759 2459 1 Another another DT 42759 2459 2 faulty faulty JJ 42759 2459 3 analogy analogy NN 42759 2459 4 is be VBZ 42759 2459 5 that that IN 42759 2459 6 drawn draw VBN 42759 2459 7 between between IN 42759 2459 8 the the DT 42759 2459 9 productivity productivity NN 42759 2459 10 of of IN 42759 2459 11 capital capital NN 42759 2459 12 and and CC 42759 2459 13 the the DT 42759 2459 14 productivity productivity NN 42759 2459 15 of of IN 42759 2459 16 labour labour NN 42759 2459 17 . . . 42759 2460 1 Following follow VBG 42759 2460 2 the the DT 42759 2460 3 terminology terminology NN 42759 2460 4 of of IN 42759 2460 5 the the DT 42759 2460 6 economists economist NNS 42759 2460 7 , , , 42759 2460 8 most most JJS 42759 2460 9 persons person NNS 42759 2460 10 think think VBP 42759 2460 11 of of IN 42759 2460 12 land land NN 42759 2460 13 , , , 42759 2460 14 labour labour NN 42759 2460 15 , , , 42759 2460 16 and and CC 42759 2460 17 capital capital NN 42759 2460 18 as as IN 42759 2460 19 productive productive JJ 42759 2460 20 in in IN 42759 2460 21 the the DT 42759 2460 22 same same JJ 42759 2460 23 sense sense NN 42759 2460 24 . . . 42759 2461 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2461 2 the the DT 42759 2461 3 productivity productivity NN 42759 2461 4 of of IN 42759 2461 5 capital capital NN 42759 2461 6 is be VBZ 42759 2461 7 easily easily RB 42759 2461 8 assumed assume VBN 42759 2461 9 to to TO 42759 2461 10 have have VB 42759 2461 11 the the DT 42759 2461 12 same same JJ 42759 2461 13 moral moral JJ 42759 2461 14 value value NN 42759 2461 15 as as IN 42759 2461 16 the the DT 42759 2461 17 productive productive JJ 42759 2461 18 action action NN 42759 2461 19 of of IN 42759 2461 20 human human JJ 42759 2461 21 beings being NNS 42759 2461 22 ; ; : 42759 2461 23 and and CC 42759 2461 24 the the DT 42759 2461 25 right right NN 42759 2461 26 of of IN 42759 2461 27 the the DT 42759 2461 28 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2461 29 to to IN 42759 2461 30 a a DT 42759 2461 31 part part NN 42759 2461 32 of of IN 42759 2461 33 the the DT 42759 2461 34 product product NN 42759 2461 35 is be VBZ 42759 2461 36 put put VBN 42759 2461 37 on on IN 42759 2461 38 the the DT 42759 2461 39 same same JJ 42759 2461 40 moral moral JJ 42759 2461 41 basis basis NN 42759 2461 42 as as IN 42759 2461 43 the the DT 42759 2461 44 right right NN 42759 2461 45 of of IN 42759 2461 46 the the DT 42759 2461 47 labourer labourer NN 42759 2461 48 . . . 42759 2462 1 Yet yet CC 42759 2462 2 the the DT 42759 2462 3 differences difference NNS 42759 2462 4 between between IN 42759 2462 5 the the DT 42759 2462 6 two two CD 42759 2462 7 kinds kind NNS 42759 2462 8 of of IN 42759 2462 9 productivity productivity NN 42759 2462 10 , , , 42759 2462 11 and and CC 42759 2462 12 between between IN 42759 2462 13 the the DT 42759 2462 14 two two CD 42759 2462 15 moral moral JJ 42759 2462 16 claims claim NNS 42759 2462 17 to to IN 42759 2462 18 the the DT 42759 2462 19 product product NN 42759 2462 20 are be VBP 42759 2462 21 more more RBR 42759 2462 22 important important JJ 42759 2462 23 than than IN 42759 2462 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2462 25 resemblances resemblance NNS 42759 2462 26 . . . 42759 2463 1 In in IN 42759 2463 2 the the DT 42759 2463 3 first first JJ 42759 2463 4 place place NN 42759 2463 5 , , , 42759 2463 6 there there EX 42759 2463 7 is be VBZ 42759 2463 8 an an DT 42759 2463 9 essential essential JJ 42759 2463 10 physical physical JJ 42759 2463 11 difference difference NN 42759 2463 12 . . . 42759 2464 1 As as IN 42759 2464 2 an an DT 42759 2464 3 instrument instrument NN 42759 2464 4 of of IN 42759 2464 5 production production NN 42759 2464 6 , , , 42759 2464 7 labour labour NN 42759 2464 8 is be VBZ 42759 2464 9 active active JJ 42759 2464 10 , , , 42759 2464 11 capital capital NN 42759 2464 12 is be VBZ 42759 2464 13 passive passive JJ 42759 2464 14 . . . 42759 2465 1 As as IN 42759 2465 2 regards regard VBZ 42759 2465 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2465 4 worth worth NN 42759 2465 5 or or CC 42759 2465 6 dignity dignity NN 42759 2465 7 , , , 42759 2465 8 labour labour NN 42759 2465 9 is be VBZ 42759 2465 10 the the DT 42759 2465 11 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 2465 12 of of IN 42759 2465 13 human human JJ 42759 2465 14 energy energy NN 42759 2465 15 , , , 42759 2465 16 the the DT 42759 2465 17 output output NN 42759 2465 18 of of IN 42759 2465 19 a a DT 42759 2465 20 _ _ NNP 42759 2465 21 person person NN 42759 2465 22 _ _ NNP 42759 2465 23 , , , 42759 2465 24 while while IN 42759 2465 25 capital capital NN 42759 2465 26 is be VBZ 42759 2465 27 a a DT 42759 2465 28 material material JJ 42759 2465 29 thing thing NN 42759 2465 30 , , , 42759 2465 31 standing stand VBG 42759 2465 32 apart apart RB 42759 2465 33 from from IN 42759 2465 34 a a DT 42759 2465 35 personality personality NN 42759 2465 36 , , , 42759 2465 37 and and CC 42759 2465 38 possessing possess VBG 42759 2465 39 no no DT 42759 2465 40 human human JJ 42759 2465 41 quality quality NN 42759 2465 42 or or CC 42759 2465 43 human human JJ 42759 2465 44 worth worth NN 42759 2465 45 . . . 42759 2466 1 These these DT 42759 2466 2 significant significant JJ 42759 2466 3 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2466 4 or or CC 42759 2466 5 physical physical JJ 42759 2466 6 differences difference NNS 42759 2466 7 forbid forbid VBP 42759 2466 8 any any DT 42759 2466 9 immediate immediate JJ 42759 2466 10 inference inference NN 42759 2466 11 that that IN 42759 2466 12 the the DT 42759 2466 13 moral moral JJ 42759 2466 14 claims claim NNS 42759 2466 15 of of IN 42759 2466 16 the the DT 42759 2466 17 owners owner NNS 42759 2466 18 of of IN 42759 2466 19 capital capital NN 42759 2466 20 and and CC 42759 2466 21 labour labour NN 42759 2466 22 are be VBP 42759 2466 23 equally equally RB 42759 2466 24 valid valid JJ 42759 2466 25 . . . 42759 2467 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 2467 2 should should MD 42759 2467 3 logically logically RB 42759 2467 4 expect expect VB 42759 2467 5 to to TO 42759 2467 6 find find VB 42759 2467 7 that that IN 42759 2467 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2467 9 moral moral JJ 42759 2467 10 claims claim NNS 42759 2467 11 are be VBP 42759 2467 12 unequal unequal JJ 42759 2467 13 . . . 42759 2468 1 This this DT 42759 2468 2 expectation expectation NN 42759 2468 3 is be VBZ 42759 2468 4 realised realise VBN 42759 2468 5 when when WRB 42759 2468 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2468 7 examine examine VBP 42759 2468 8 the the DT 42759 2468 9 bearing bearing NN 42759 2468 10 of of IN 42759 2468 11 the the DT 42759 2468 12 two two CD 42759 2468 13 kinds kind NNS 42759 2468 14 of of IN 42759 2468 15 productivity productivity NN 42759 2468 16 upon upon IN 42759 2468 17 human human JJ 42759 2468 18 welfare welfare NN 42759 2468 19 . . . 42759 2469 1 In in IN 42759 2469 2 the the DT 42759 2469 3 exercise exercise NN 42759 2469 4 of of IN 42759 2469 5 productive productive JJ 42759 2469 6 effort effort NN 42759 2469 7 the the DT 42759 2469 8 average average JJ 42759 2469 9 labourer labourer NN 42759 2469 10 undergoes undergo VBZ 42759 2469 11 a a DT 42759 2469 12 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2469 13 . . . 42759 2470 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2470 2 is be VBZ 42759 2470 3 engaged engage VBN 42759 2470 4 in in IN 42759 2470 5 a a DT 42759 2470 6 process process NN 42759 2470 7 that that WDT 42759 2470 8 is be VBZ 42759 2470 9 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 2470 10 irksome irksome JJ 42759 2470 11 . . . 42759 2471 1 To to TO 42759 2471 2 require require VB 42759 2471 3 from from IN 42759 2471 4 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2471 5 this this DT 42759 2471 6 toilsome toilsome NN 42759 2471 7 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 2471 8 of of IN 42759 2471 9 energy energy NN 42759 2471 10 without without IN 42759 2471 11 compensation compensation NN 42759 2471 12 , , , 42759 2471 13 would would MD 42759 2471 14 make make VB 42759 2471 15 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2471 16 a a DT 42759 2471 17 mere mere JJ 42759 2471 18 instrument instrument NN 42759 2471 19 of of IN 42759 2471 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2471 21 fellows fellow NNS 42759 2471 22 . . . 42759 2472 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2472 2 would would MD 42759 2472 3 subordinate subordinate VB 42759 2472 4 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2472 5 and and CC 42759 2472 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2472 7 comfort comfort NN 42759 2472 8 to to IN 42759 2472 9 the the DT 42759 2472 10 aggrandisement aggrandisement NN 42759 2472 11 of of IN 42759 2472 12 beings being NNS 42759 2472 13 who who WP 42759 2472 14 are be VBP 42759 2472 15 not not RB 42759 2472 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2472 17 superiors superior NNS 42759 2472 18 but but CC 42759 2472 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2472 20 moral moral JJ 42759 2472 21 equals equal NNS 42759 2472 22 . . . 42759 2473 1 For for IN 42759 2473 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2473 3 is be VBZ 42759 2473 4 a a DT 42759 2473 5 person person NN 42759 2473 6 ; ; : 42759 2473 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2473 8 are be VBP 42759 2473 9 no no RB 42759 2473 10 more more JJR 42759 2473 11 than than IN 42759 2473 12 persons person NNS 42759 2473 13 . . . 42759 2474 1 On on IN 42759 2474 2 the the DT 42759 2474 3 other other JJ 42759 2474 4 hand hand NN 42759 2474 5 , , , 42759 2474 6 the the DT 42759 2474 7 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2474 8 as as IN 42759 2474 9 such such JJ 42759 2474 10 , , , 42759 2474 11 as as IN 42759 2474 12 the the DT 42759 2474 13 recipient recipient NN 42759 2474 14 of of IN 42759 2474 15 interest interest NN 42759 2474 16 , , , 42759 2474 17 performs perform VBZ 42759 2474 18 no no DT 42759 2474 19 labour labour NN 42759 2474 20 , , , 42759 2474 21 painful painful JJ 42759 2474 22 or or CC 42759 2474 23 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 2474 24 . . . 42759 2475 1 Not not RB 42759 2475 2 the the DT 42759 2475 3 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2475 4 , , , 42759 2475 5 but but CC 42759 2475 6 capital capital NN 42759 2475 7 participates participate NNS 42759 2475 8 in in IN 42759 2475 9 the the DT 42759 2475 10 productive productive JJ 42759 2475 11 process process NN 42759 2475 12 . . . 42759 2476 1 Even even RB 42759 2476 2 though though IN 42759 2476 3 the the DT 42759 2476 4 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2476 5 should should MD 42759 2476 6 receive receive VB 42759 2476 7 no no DT 42759 2476 8 interest interest NN 42759 2476 9 , , , 42759 2476 10 the the DT 42759 2476 11 productive productive JJ 42759 2476 12 functioning functioning NN 42759 2476 13 of of IN 42759 2476 14 capital capital NN 42759 2476 15 would would MD 42759 2476 16 not not RB 42759 2476 17 subordinate subordinate VB 42759 2476 18 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2476 19 to to IN 42759 2476 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2476 21 fellows fellow NNS 42759 2476 22 in in IN 42759 2476 23 the the DT 42759 2476 24 way way NN 42759 2476 25 that that WDT 42759 2476 26 wageless wageless VBP 42759 2476 27 labour labour NN 42759 2476 28 would would MD 42759 2476 29 subordinate subordinate VB 42759 2476 30 the the DT 42759 2476 31 labourer labourer NN 42759 2476 32 . . . 42759 2477 1 The the DT 42759 2477 2 precise precise JJ 42759 2477 3 and and CC 42759 2477 4 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 2477 5 reason reason NN 42759 2477 6 for for IN 42759 2477 7 according accord VBG 42759 2477 8 to to IN 42759 2477 9 the the DT 42759 2477 10 labourer labourer NN 42759 2477 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2477 12 product product NN 42759 2477 13 is be VBZ 42759 2477 14 that that IN 42759 2477 15 this this DT 42759 2477 16 is be VBZ 42759 2477 17 the the DT 42759 2477 18 only only JJ 42759 2477 19 rational rational JJ 42759 2477 20 rule rule NN 42759 2477 21 of of IN 42759 2477 22 distribution distribution NN 42759 2477 23 . . . 42759 2478 1 When when WRB 42759 2478 2 a a DT 42759 2478 3 man man NN 42759 2478 4 makes make VBZ 42759 2478 5 a a DT 42759 2478 6 useful useful JJ 42759 2478 7 thing thing NN 42759 2478 8 out out IN 42759 2478 9 of of IN 42759 2478 10 materials material NNS 42759 2478 11 that that WDT 42759 2478 12 are be VBP 42759 2478 13 his -PRON- PRP 42759 2478 14 , , , 42759 2478 15 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2478 16 has have VBZ 42759 2478 17 a a DT 42759 2478 18 strict strict JJ 42759 2478 19 right right NN 42759 2478 20 to to IN 42759 2478 21 the the DT 42759 2478 22 product product NN 42759 2478 23 simply simply RB 42759 2478 24 because because IN 42759 2478 25 there there EX 42759 2478 26 is be VBZ 42759 2478 27 no no DT 42759 2478 28 other other JJ 42759 2478 29 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2478 30 method method NN 42759 2478 31 of of IN 42759 2478 32 distributing distribute VBG 42759 2478 33 the the DT 42759 2478 34 goods good NNS 42759 2478 35 and and CC 42759 2478 36 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 2478 37 of of IN 42759 2478 38 the the DT 42759 2478 39 earth earth NN 42759 2478 40 . . . 42759 2479 1 If if IN 42759 2479 2 another another DT 42759 2479 3 individual individual NN 42759 2479 4 , , , 42759 2479 5 or or CC 42759 2479 6 society society NN 42759 2479 7 , , , 42759 2479 8 were be VBD 42759 2479 9 permitted permit VBN 42759 2479 10 to to TO 42759 2479 11 take take VB 42759 2479 12 this this DT 42759 2479 13 product product NN 42759 2479 14 , , , 42759 2479 15 industry industry NN 42759 2479 16 would would MD 42759 2479 17 be be VB 42759 2479 18 discouraged discourage VBN 42759 2479 19 , , , 42759 2479 20 idleness idleness JJ 42759 2479 21 fostered foster VBN 42759 2479 22 , , , 42759 2479 23 and and CC 42759 2479 24 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2479 25 life life NN 42759 2479 26 and and CC 42759 2479 27 self self NN 42759 2479 28 development development NN 42759 2479 29 rendered render VBN 42759 2479 30 impossible impossible JJ 42759 2479 31 . . . 42759 2480 1 Direful direful JJ 42759 2480 2 consequences consequence NNS 42759 2480 3 of of IN 42759 2480 4 this this DT 42759 2480 5 magnitude magnitude NN 42759 2480 6 would would MD 42759 2480 7 not not RB 42759 2480 8 follow follow VB 42759 2480 9 the the DT 42759 2480 10 abolition abolition NN 42759 2480 11 of of IN 42759 2480 12 interest interest NN 42759 2480 13 . . . 42759 2481 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 42759 2481 2 the the DT 42759 2481 3 most most RBS 42759 2481 4 important important JJ 42759 2481 5 difference difference NN 42759 2481 6 between between IN 42759 2481 7 the the DT 42759 2481 8 moral moral JJ 42759 2481 9 claims claim NNS 42759 2481 10 of of IN 42759 2481 11 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2481 12 and and CC 42759 2481 13 labourer labourer NN 42759 2481 14 is be VBZ 42759 2481 15 the the DT 42759 2481 16 fact fact NN 42759 2481 17 that that IN 42759 2481 18 for for IN 42759 2481 19 the the DT 42759 2481 20 latter latter JJ 42759 2481 21 labour labour NN 42759 2481 22 is be VBZ 42759 2481 23 the the DT 42759 2481 24 sole sole JJ 42759 2481 25 means mean NNS 42759 2481 26 of of IN 42759 2481 27 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 2481 28 . . . 42759 2482 1 Unless unless IN 42759 2482 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2482 3 is be VBZ 42759 2482 4 compensated compensate VBN 42759 2482 5 for for IN 42759 2482 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2482 7 product product NN 42759 2482 8 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2482 9 will will MD 42759 2482 10 perish perish VB 42759 2482 11 . . . 42759 2483 1 But but CC 42759 2483 2 the the DT 42759 2483 3 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2483 4 has have VBZ 42759 2483 5 in in IN 42759 2483 6 addition addition NN 42759 2483 7 to to IN 42759 2483 8 the the DT 42759 2483 9 interest interest NN 42759 2483 10 that that WDT 42759 2483 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2483 12 receives receive VBZ 42759 2483 13 the the DT 42759 2483 14 ability ability NN 42759 2483 15 to to TO 42759 2483 16 work work VB 42759 2483 17 . . . 42759 2484 1 Were be VBD 42759 2484 2 interest interest NN 42759 2484 3 abolished abolish VBD 42759 2484 4 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2484 5 would would MD 42759 2484 6 still still RB 42759 2484 7 be be VB 42759 2484 8 in in IN 42759 2484 9 as as RB 42759 2484 10 good good JJ 42759 2484 11 a a DT 42759 2484 12 position position NN 42759 2484 13 as as IN 42759 2484 14 the the DT 42759 2484 15 labourer labourer NN 42759 2484 16 . . . 42759 2485 1 The the DT 42759 2485 2 product product NN 42759 2485 3 of of IN 42759 2485 4 the the DT 42759 2485 5 labourer labourer NN 42759 2485 6 means mean VBZ 42759 2485 7 to to IN 42759 2485 8 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2485 9 the the DT 42759 2485 10 necessaries necessary NNS 42759 2485 11 of of IN 42759 2485 12 life life NN 42759 2485 13 ; ; : 42759 2485 14 the the DT 42759 2485 15 product product NN 42759 2485 16 of of IN 42759 2485 17 the the DT 42759 2485 18 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2485 19 means mean VBZ 42759 2485 20 to to IN 42759 2485 21 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2485 22 goods good NNS 42759 2485 23 in in IN 42759 2485 24 excess excess NN 42759 2485 25 of of IN 42759 2485 26 a a DT 42759 2485 27 mere mere JJ 42759 2485 28 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 2485 29 . . . 42759 2486 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 2486 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2486 3 claims claim NNS 42759 2486 4 to to IN 42759 2486 5 the the DT 42759 2486 6 product product NN 42759 2486 7 are be VBP 42759 2486 8 greatly greatly RB 42759 2486 9 unequal unequal JJ 42759 2486 10 in in IN 42759 2486 11 vital vital JJ 42759 2486 12 importance importance NN 42759 2486 13 and and CC 42759 2486 14 moral moral JJ 42759 2486 15 value value NN 42759 2486 16 . . . 42759 2487 1 The the DT 42759 2487 2 foregoing forego VBG 42759 2487 3 considerations consideration NNS 42759 2487 4 show show VBP 42759 2487 5 that that IN 42759 2487 6 even even RB 42759 2487 7 the the DT 42759 2487 8 claim claim NN 42759 2487 9 of of IN 42759 2487 10 the the DT 42759 2487 11 labourer labourer NN 42759 2487 12 to to IN 42759 2487 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2487 14 product product NN 42759 2487 15 is be VBZ 42759 2487 16 not not RB 42759 2487 17 based base VBN 42759 2487 18 upon upon IN 42759 2487 19 merely merely RB 42759 2487 20 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2487 21 grounds ground NNS 42759 2487 22 . . . 42759 2488 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2488 2 does do VBZ 42759 2488 3 not not RB 42759 2488 4 spring spring VB 42759 2488 5 entirely entirely RB 42759 2488 6 from from IN 42759 2488 7 the the DT 42759 2488 8 mere mere JJ 42759 2488 9 fact fact NN 42759 2488 10 that that IN 42759 2488 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2488 12 has have VBZ 42759 2488 13 produced produce VBN 42759 2488 14 the the DT 42759 2488 15 product product NN 42759 2488 16 , , , 42759 2488 17 from from IN 42759 2488 18 the the DT 42759 2488 19 mere mere JJ 42759 2488 20 relation relation NN 42759 2488 21 between between IN 42759 2488 22 producer producer NN 42759 2488 23 and and CC 42759 2488 24 thing thing NN 42759 2488 25 produced produce VBN 42759 2488 26 . . . 42759 2489 1 If if IN 42759 2489 2 this this DT 42759 2489 3 is be VBZ 42759 2489 4 true true JJ 42759 2489 5 of of IN 42759 2489 6 labour labour NN 42759 2489 7 - - HYPH 42759 2489 8 productivity productivity NN 42759 2489 9 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2489 10 should should MD 42759 2489 11 expect expect VB 42759 2489 12 to to TO 42759 2489 13 find find VB 42759 2489 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2489 15 even even RB 42759 2489 16 more more RBR 42759 2489 17 evident evident JJ 42759 2489 18 with with IN 42759 2489 19 regard regard NN 42759 2489 20 to to IN 42759 2489 21 the the DT 42759 2489 22 productivity productivity NN 42759 2489 23 of of IN 42759 2489 24 capital capital NN 42759 2489 25 ; ; : 42759 2489 26 for for IN 42759 2489 27 the the DT 42759 2489 28 latter latter JJ 42759 2489 29 is be VBZ 42759 2489 30 passive passive JJ 42759 2489 31 instead instead RB 42759 2489 32 of of IN 42759 2489 33 active active JJ 42759 2489 34 , , , 42759 2489 35 non non JJ 42759 2489 36 rational rational JJ 42759 2489 37 instead instead RB 42759 2489 38 of of IN 42759 2489 39 human human NN 42759 2489 40 . . . 42759 2490 1 The the DT 42759 2490 2 expectation expectation NN 42759 2490 3 is be VBZ 42759 2490 4 well well RB 42759 2490 5 founded found VBN 42759 2490 6 . . . 42759 2491 1 Not not RB 42759 2491 2 a a DT 42759 2491 3 single single JJ 42759 2491 4 conclusive conclusive JJ 42759 2491 5 argument argument NN 42759 2491 6 can can MD 42759 2491 7 be be VB 42759 2491 8 brought bring VBN 42759 2491 9 forward forward RB 42759 2491 10 to to TO 42759 2491 11 show show VB 42759 2491 12 that that IN 42759 2491 13 the the DT 42759 2491 14 productivity productivity NN 42759 2491 15 of of IN 42759 2491 16 capital capital NN 42759 2491 17 directly directly RB 42759 2491 18 and and CC 42759 2491 19 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 2491 20 confers confer NNS 42759 2491 21 upon upon IN 42759 2491 22 the the DT 42759 2491 23 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2491 24 a a DT 42759 2491 25 right right NN 42759 2491 26 to to IN 42759 2491 27 the the DT 42759 2491 28 interest interest NN 42759 2491 29 - - HYPH 42759 2491 30 product product NN 42759 2491 31 . . . 42759 2492 1 All all PDT 42759 2492 2 the the DT 42759 2492 3 attempted attempt VBN 42759 2492 4 arguments argument NNS 42759 2492 5 are be VBP 42759 2492 6 reducible reducible JJ 42759 2492 7 to to IN 42759 2492 8 two two CD 42759 2492 9 formulas formula NNS 42759 2492 10 : : : 42759 2492 11 " " `` 42759 2492 12 res re VBZ 42759 2492 13 fructificat fructificat NNP 42759 2492 14 domino domino NN 42759 2492 15 " " '' 42759 2492 16 ( ( -LRB- 42759 2492 17 " " `` 42759 2492 18 a a DT 42759 2492 19 thing thing NN 42759 2492 20 fructifies fructifie NNS 42759 2492 21 to to IN 42759 2492 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2492 23 owner owner NN 42759 2492 24 " " '' 42759 2492 25 ) ) -RRB- 42759 2492 26 and and CC 42759 2492 27 " " `` 42759 2492 28 the the DT 42759 2492 29 effect effect NN 42759 2492 30 follows follow VBZ 42759 2492 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2492 32 cause cause NN 42759 2492 33 . . . 42759 2492 34 " " '' 42759 2493 1 The the DT 42759 2493 2 first first JJ 42759 2493 3 of of IN 42759 2493 4 these these DT 42759 2493 5 was be VBD 42759 2493 6 originally originally RB 42759 2493 7 a a DT 42759 2493 8 legal legal JJ 42759 2493 9 rather rather RB 42759 2493 10 than than IN 42759 2493 11 an an DT 42759 2493 12 ethical ethical JJ 42759 2493 13 maxim maxim NN 42759 2493 14 ; ; : 42759 2493 15 a a DT 42759 2493 16 rule rule NN 42759 2493 17 by by IN 42759 2493 18 which which WDT 42759 2493 19 the the DT 42759 2493 20 title title NN 42759 2493 21 was be VBD 42759 2493 22 determined determine VBN 42759 2493 23 in in IN 42759 2493 24 the the DT 42759 2493 25 civil civil JJ 42759 2493 26 law law NN 42759 2493 27 , , , 42759 2493 28 not not RB 42759 2493 29 a a DT 42759 2493 30 principle principle NN 42759 2493 31 by by IN 42759 2493 32 which which WDT 42759 2493 33 the the DT 42759 2493 34 right right NN 42759 2493 35 was be VBD 42759 2493 36 determined determine VBN 42759 2493 37 in in IN 42759 2493 38 morals moral NNS 42759 2493 39 . . . 42759 2494 1 The the DT 42759 2494 2 second second JJ 42759 2494 3 is be VBZ 42759 2494 4 an an DT 42759 2494 5 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 42759 2494 6 platitude platitude NN 42759 2494 7 . . . 42759 2495 1 As as IN 42759 2495 2 a a DT 42759 2495 3 juristic juristic JJ 42759 2495 4 principle principle NN 42759 2495 5 , , , 42759 2495 6 neither neither RB 42759 2495 7 is be VBZ 42759 2495 8 self self NN 42759 2495 9 evident evident JJ 42759 2495 10 . . . 42759 2496 1 Why why WRB 42759 2496 2 should should MD 42759 2496 3 the the DT 42759 2496 4 owner owner NN 42759 2496 5 of of IN 42759 2496 6 a a DT 42759 2496 7 piece piece NN 42759 2496 8 of of IN 42759 2496 9 capital capital NN 42759 2496 10 , , , 42759 2496 11 be be VB 42759 2496 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2496 13 a a DT 42759 2496 14 house house NN 42759 2496 15 , , , 42759 2496 16 a a DT 42759 2496 17 machine machine NN 42759 2496 18 , , , 42759 2496 19 or or CC 42759 2496 20 a a DT 42759 2496 21 share share NN 42759 2496 22 of of IN 42759 2496 23 railway railway NN 42759 2496 24 stock stock NN 42759 2496 25 , , , 42759 2496 26 have have VBP 42759 2496 27 a a DT 42759 2496 28 right right NN 42759 2496 29 to to IN 42759 2496 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2496 31 product product NN 42759 2496 32 , , , 42759 2496 33 when when WRB 42759 2496 34 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2496 35 has have VBZ 42759 2496 36 expended expend VBN 42759 2496 37 neither neither DT 42759 2496 38 time time NN 42759 2496 39 , , , 42759 2496 40 labour labour NN 42759 2496 41 , , , 42759 2496 42 money money NN 42759 2496 43 , , , 42759 2496 44 nor nor CC 42759 2496 45 inconvenience inconvenience NN 42759 2496 46 of of IN 42759 2496 47 any any DT 42759 2496 48 kind kind NN 42759 2496 49 ? ? . 42759 2497 1 To to TO 42759 2497 2 answer answer VB 42759 2497 3 , , , 42759 2497 4 " " '' 42759 2497 5 because because IN 42759 2497 6 the the DT 42759 2497 7 thing thing NN 42759 2497 8 which which WDT 42759 2497 9 produced produce VBD 42759 2497 10 the the DT 42759 2497 11 product product NN 42759 2497 12 belongs belong VBZ 42759 2497 13 to to IN 42759 2497 14 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2497 15 , , , 42759 2497 16 " " `` 42759 2497 17 is be VBZ 42759 2497 18 merely merely RB 42759 2497 19 to to TO 42759 2497 20 beg beg VB 42759 2497 21 the the DT 42759 2497 22 question question NN 42759 2497 23 . . . 42759 2498 1 To to TO 42759 2498 2 answer answer VB 42759 2498 3 , , , 42759 2498 4 " " '' 42759 2498 5 because because IN 42759 2498 6 the the DT 42759 2498 7 effect effect NN 42759 2498 8 follows follow VBZ 42759 2498 9 the the DT 42759 2498 10 cause cause NN 42759 2498 11 , , , 42759 2498 12 " " '' 42759 2498 13 is be VBZ 42759 2498 14 to to TO 42759 2498 15 make make VB 42759 2498 16 a a DT 42759 2498 17 statement statement NN 42759 2498 18 which which WDT 42759 2498 19 has have VBZ 42759 2498 20 nothing nothing NN 42759 2498 21 to to TO 42759 2498 22 do do VB 42759 2498 23 with with IN 42759 2498 24 the the DT 42759 2498 25 question question NN 42759 2498 26 . . . 42759 2499 1 What what WP 42759 2499 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2499 3 want want VBP 42759 2499 4 to to TO 42759 2499 5 know know VB 42759 2499 6 is be VBZ 42759 2499 7 why why WRB 42759 2499 8 the the DT 42759 2499 9 ownership ownership NN 42759 2499 10 of of IN 42759 2499 11 a a DT 42759 2499 12 productive productive JJ 42759 2499 13 thing thing NN 42759 2499 14 gives give VBZ 42759 2499 15 a a DT 42759 2499 16 right right NN 42759 2499 17 to to IN 42759 2499 18 the the DT 42759 2499 19 product product NN 42759 2499 20 ; ; : 42759 2499 21 why why WRB 42759 2499 22 this this DT 42759 2499 23 particular particular JJ 42759 2499 24 effect effect NN 42759 2499 25 should should MD 42759 2499 26 follow follow VB 42759 2499 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2499 28 cause cause NN 42759 2499 29 in in IN 42759 2499 30 this this DT 42759 2499 31 particular particular JJ 42759 2499 32 way way NN 42759 2499 33 . . . 42759 2500 1 To to TO 42759 2500 2 answer answer VB 42759 2500 3 by by IN 42759 2500 4 repeating repeat VBG 42759 2500 5 under under IN 42759 2500 6 the the DT 42759 2500 7 guise guise NN 42759 2500 8 of of IN 42759 2500 9 sententious sententious JJ 42759 2500 10 formulas formula NNS 42759 2500 11 the the DT 42759 2500 12 thesis thesis NN 42759 2500 13 to to TO 42759 2500 14 be be VB 42759 2500 15 proved prove VBN 42759 2500 16 , , , 42759 2500 17 is be VBZ 42759 2500 18 scarcely scarcely RB 42759 2500 19 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 2500 20 or or CC 42759 2500 21 convincing convincing JJ 42759 2500 22 . . . 42759 2501 1 To to TO 42759 2501 2 answer answer VB 42759 2501 3 that that IN 42759 2501 4 if if IN 42759 2501 5 the the DT 42759 2501 6 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2501 7 were be VBD 42759 2501 8 not not RB 42759 2501 9 given give VBN 42759 2501 10 interest interest NN 42759 2501 11 industry industry NN 42759 2501 12 and and CC 42759 2501 13 thrift thrift NN 42759 2501 14 would would MD 42759 2501 15 decrease decrease VB 42759 2501 16 and and CC 42759 2501 17 human human JJ 42759 2501 18 welfare welfare NN 42759 2501 19 suffer suffer NN 42759 2501 20 , , , 42759 2501 21 is be VBZ 42759 2501 22 to to TO 42759 2501 23 abandon abandon VB 42759 2501 24 the the DT 42759 2501 25 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2501 26 argument argument NN 42759 2501 27 entirely entirely RB 42759 2501 28 . . . 42759 2502 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2502 2 brings bring VBZ 42759 2502 3 in in IN 42759 2502 4 the the DT 42759 2502 5 extrinsic extrinsic JJ 42759 2502 6 consideration consideration NN 42759 2502 7 of of IN 42759 2502 8 social social JJ 42759 2502 9 consequences consequence NNS 42759 2502 10 . . . 42759 2503 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2503 2 The the DT 42759 2503 3 Claims Claims NNPS 42759 2503 4 of of IN 42759 2503 5 Service Service NNP 42759 2503 6 _ _ NNP 42759 2503 7 The the DT 42759 2503 8 second second JJ 42759 2503 9 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2503 10 ground ground NN 42759 2503 11 upon upon IN 42759 2503 12 which which WDT 42759 2503 13 interest interest NN 42759 2503 14 is be VBZ 42759 2503 15 defended defend VBN 42759 2503 16 , , , 42759 2503 17 is be VBZ 42759 2503 18 the the DT 42759 2503 19 _ _ NNP 42759 2503 20 service service NN 42759 2503 21 _ _ NNP 42759 2503 22 performed perform VBN 42759 2503 23 by by IN 42759 2503 24 the the DT 42759 2503 25 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2503 26 when when WRB 42759 2503 27 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2503 28 permits permit VBZ 42759 2503 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2503 30 capital capital NN 42759 2503 31 to to TO 42759 2503 32 be be VB 42759 2503 33 used use VBN 42759 2503 34 in in IN 42759 2503 35 production production NN 42759 2503 36 . . . 42759 2504 1 Without without IN 42759 2504 2 capital capital NN 42759 2504 3 , , , 42759 2504 4 labourers labourer NNS 42759 2504 5 and and CC 42759 2504 6 consumers consumer NNS 42759 2504 7 would would MD 42759 2504 8 be be VB 42759 2504 9 unable unable JJ 42759 2504 10 to to TO 42759 2504 11 command command VB 42759 2504 12 more more JJR 42759 2504 13 than than IN 42759 2504 14 a a DT 42759 2504 15 fraction fraction NN 42759 2504 16 of of IN 42759 2504 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2504 18 present present JJ 42759 2504 19 means mean NNS 42759 2504 20 of of IN 42759 2504 21 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 2504 22 . . . 42759 2505 1 From from IN 42759 2505 2 this this DT 42759 2505 3 point point NN 42759 2505 4 of of IN 42759 2505 5 view view NN 42759 2505 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2505 7 see see VBP 42759 2505 8 that that IN 42759 2505 9 the the DT 42759 2505 10 service service NN 42759 2505 11 in in IN 42759 2505 12 question question NN 42759 2505 13 is be VBZ 42759 2505 14 worth worth JJ 42759 2505 15 all all PDT 42759 2505 16 that that WDT 42759 2505 17 is be VBZ 42759 2505 18 paid pay VBN 42759 2505 19 in in IN 42759 2505 20 the the DT 42759 2505 21 form form NN 42759 2505 22 of of IN 42759 2505 23 interest interest NN 42759 2505 24 . . . 42759 2506 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2506 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2506 3 does do VBZ 42759 2506 4 not not RB 42759 2506 5 follow follow VB 42759 2506 6 that that IN 42759 2506 7 the the DT 42759 2506 8 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2506 9 has have VBZ 42759 2506 10 a a DT 42759 2506 11 claim claim NN 42759 2506 12 in in IN 42759 2506 13 strict strict JJ 42759 2506 14 justice justice NN 42759 2506 15 to to IN 42759 2506 16 any any DT 42759 2506 17 payment payment NN 42759 2506 18 for for IN 42759 2506 19 this this DT 42759 2506 20 service service NN 42759 2506 21 . . . 42759 2507 1 According accord VBG 42759 2507 2 to to IN 42759 2507 3 St. St. NNP 42759 2507 4 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 2507 5 , , , 42759 2507 6 a a DT 42759 2507 7 seller seller NN 42759 2507 8 may may MD 42759 2507 9 not not RB 42759 2507 10 charge charge VB 42759 2507 11 a a DT 42759 2507 12 buyer buyer NN 42759 2507 13 an an DT 42759 2507 14 extra extra JJ 42759 2507 15 amount amount NN 42759 2507 16 merely merely RB 42759 2507 17 because because IN 42759 2507 18 of of IN 42759 2507 19 the the DT 42759 2507 20 extra extra JJ 42759 2507 21 value value NN 42759 2507 22 attached attach VBN 42759 2507 23 to to IN 42759 2507 24 the the DT 42759 2507 25 commodity commodity NN 42759 2507 26 by by IN 42759 2507 27 the the DT 42759 2507 28 latter latter JJ 42759 2507 29 . . . 42759 2508 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2508 2 138 138 CD 42759 2508 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2508 4 In in IN 42759 2508 5 other other JJ 42759 2508 6 words word NNS 42759 2508 7 , , , 42759 2508 8 a a DT 42759 2508 9 man man NN 42759 2508 10 can can MD 42759 2508 11 not not RB 42759 2508 12 justly justly RB 42759 2508 13 be be VB 42759 2508 14 required require VBN 42759 2508 15 to to TO 42759 2508 16 pay pay VB 42759 2508 17 an an DT 42759 2508 18 unusual unusual JJ 42759 2508 19 price price NN 42759 2508 20 for for IN 42759 2508 21 a a DT 42759 2508 22 benefit benefit NN 42759 2508 23 or or CC 42759 2508 24 advantage advantage NN 42759 2508 25 or or CC 42759 2508 26 service service NN 42759 2508 27 , , , 42759 2508 28 when when WRB 42759 2508 29 the the DT 42759 2508 30 seller seller NN 42759 2508 31 undergoes undergo VBZ 42759 2508 32 no no DT 42759 2508 33 unusual unusual JJ 42759 2508 34 deprivation deprivation NN 42759 2508 35 . . . 42759 2509 1 Father Father NNP 42759 2509 2 Lehmkuhl Lehmkuhl NNP 42759 2509 3 carries carry VBZ 42759 2509 4 the the DT 42759 2509 5 principle principle NN 42759 2509 6 further further RB 42759 2509 7 , , , 42759 2509 8 and and CC 42759 2509 9 declares declare VBZ 42759 2509 10 that that IN 42759 2509 11 the the DT 42759 2509 12 seller seller NN 42759 2509 13 has have VBZ 42759 2509 14 a a DT 42759 2509 15 right right NN 42759 2509 16 to to IN 42759 2509 17 compensation compensation NN 42759 2509 18 only only RB 42759 2509 19 when when WRB 42759 2509 20 and and CC 42759 2509 21 to to IN 42759 2509 22 the the DT 42759 2509 23 extent extent NN 42759 2509 24 that that IN 42759 2509 25 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2509 26 undergoes undergo VBZ 42759 2509 27 a a DT 42759 2509 28 privation privation NN 42759 2509 29 or or CC 42759 2509 30 undertakes undertake VBZ 42759 2509 31 a a DT 42759 2509 32 responsibility responsibility NN 42759 2509 33 . . . 42759 2510 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2510 2 139 139 CD 42759 2510 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2510 4 According accord VBG 42759 2510 5 to to IN 42759 2510 6 this this DT 42759 2510 7 rule rule NN 42759 2510 8 , , , 42759 2510 9 the the DT 42759 2510 10 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2510 11 would would MD 42759 2510 12 have have VB 42759 2510 13 no no DT 42759 2510 14 right right NN 42759 2510 15 to to IN 42759 2510 16 interest interest NN 42759 2510 17 ; ; : 42759 2510 18 for for IN 42759 2510 19 as as IN 42759 2510 20 mere mere JJ 42759 2510 21 interest interest NN 42759 2510 22 - - HYPH 42759 2510 23 receiver receiver NN 42759 2510 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2510 25 undergoes undergo VBZ 42759 2510 26 no no DT 42759 2510 27 privation privation NN 42759 2510 28 . . . 42759 2511 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2511 2 risk risk NN 42759 2511 3 and and CC 42759 2511 4 labour labour NN 42759 2511 5 are be VBP 42759 2511 6 remunerated remunerate VBN 42759 2511 7 in in IN 42759 2511 8 profits profit NNS 42759 2511 9 , , , 42759 2511 10 while while IN 42759 2511 11 the the DT 42759 2511 12 responsibility responsibility NN 42759 2511 13 of of IN 42759 2511 14 not not RB 42759 2511 15 withdrawing withdraw VBG 42759 2511 16 from from IN 42759 2511 17 production production NN 42759 2511 18 something something NN 42759 2511 19 that that WDT 42759 2511 20 can can MD 42759 2511 21 continue continue VB 42759 2511 22 in in IN 42759 2511 23 existence existence NN 42759 2511 24 only only RB 42759 2511 25 by by IN 42759 2511 26 continuing continue VBG 42759 2511 27 in in IN 42759 2511 28 production production NN 42759 2511 29 , , , 42759 2511 30 is be VBZ 42759 2511 31 scarcely scarcely RB 42759 2511 32 deserving deserve VBG 42759 2511 33 of of IN 42759 2511 34 a a DT 42759 2511 35 reward reward NN 42759 2511 36 according accord VBG 42759 2511 37 to to IN 42759 2511 38 the the DT 42759 2511 39 canons canon NNS 42759 2511 40 of of IN 42759 2511 41 strict strict JJ 42759 2511 42 justice justice NN 42759 2511 43 . . . 42759 2512 1 Whatever whatever WDT 42759 2512 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2512 3 may may MD 42759 2512 4 think think VB 42759 2512 5 of of IN 42759 2512 6 this this DT 42759 2512 7 argument argument NN 42759 2512 8 from from IN 42759 2512 9 authority authority NN 42759 2512 10 , , , 42759 2512 11 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2512 12 find find VBP 42759 2512 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2512 14 impossible impossible JJ 42759 2512 15 to to TO 42759 2512 16 prove prove VB 42759 2512 17 objectively objectively RB 42759 2512 18 that that IN 42759 2512 19 a a DT 42759 2512 20 man man NN 42759 2512 21 who who WP 42759 2512 22 renders render VBZ 42759 2512 23 a a DT 42759 2512 24 service service NN 42759 2512 25 to to IN 42759 2512 26 another another DT 42759 2512 27 has have VBZ 42759 2512 28 an an DT 42759 2512 29 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2512 30 right right NN 42759 2512 31 to to IN 42759 2512 32 anything anything NN 42759 2512 33 beyond beyond IN 42759 2512 34 compensation compensation NN 42759 2512 35 for for IN 42759 2512 36 the the DT 42759 2512 37 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 2512 38 of of IN 42759 2512 39 money money NN 42759 2512 40 or or CC 42759 2512 41 labour labour NN 42759 2512 42 involved involve VBN 42759 2512 43 in in IN 42759 2512 44 performing perform VBG 42759 2512 45 the the DT 42759 2512 46 service service NN 42759 2512 47 . . . 42759 2513 1 The the DT 42759 2513 2 man man NN 42759 2513 3 who who WP 42759 2513 4 throws throw VBZ 42759 2513 5 a a DT 42759 2513 6 life life NN 42759 2513 7 preserver preserver RB 42759 2513 8 to to IN 42759 2513 9 a a DT 42759 2513 10 drowning drown VBG 42759 2513 11 person person NN 42759 2513 12 may may MD 42759 2513 13 justly justly RB 42759 2513 14 demand demand VB 42759 2513 15 a a DT 42759 2513 16 payment payment NN 42759 2513 17 for for IN 42759 2513 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2513 19 trouble trouble NN 42759 2513 20 . . . 42759 2514 1 On on IN 42759 2514 2 any any DT 42759 2514 3 recognised recognised JJ 42759 2514 4 basis basis NN 42759 2514 5 of of IN 42759 2514 6 compensation compensation NN 42759 2514 7 , , , 42759 2514 8 this this DT 42759 2514 9 payment payment NN 42759 2514 10 will will MD 42759 2514 11 not not RB 42759 2514 12 exceed exceed VB 42759 2514 13 a a DT 42759 2514 14 few few JJ 42759 2514 15 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2514 16 . . . 42759 2515 1 Yet yet RB 42759 2515 2 the the DT 42759 2515 3 man man NN 42759 2515 4 whose whose WP$ 42759 2515 5 life life NN 42759 2515 6 is be VBZ 42759 2515 7 in in IN 42759 2515 8 danger danger NN 42759 2515 9 would would MD 42759 2515 10 pay pay VB 42759 2515 11 a a DT 42759 2515 12 million million CD 42759 2515 13 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2515 14 for for IN 42759 2515 15 this this DT 42759 2515 16 service service NN 42759 2515 17 if if IN 42759 2515 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2515 19 were be VBD 42759 2515 20 extremely extremely RB 42759 2515 21 rich rich JJ 42759 2515 22 . . . 42759 2516 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2516 2 would would MD 42759 2516 3 regard regard VB 42759 2516 4 the the DT 42759 2516 5 service service NN 42759 2516 6 as as IN 42759 2516 7 worth worth JJ 42759 2516 8 this this DT 42759 2516 9 much much JJ 42759 2516 10 to to IN 42759 2516 11 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2516 12 . . . 42759 2517 1 Has have VBZ 42759 2517 2 the the DT 42759 2517 3 man man NN 42759 2517 4 with with IN 42759 2517 5 the the DT 42759 2517 6 life life NN 42759 2517 7 preserver preserver RB 42759 2517 8 a a DT 42759 2517 9 right right NN 42759 2517 10 to to TO 42759 2517 11 exact exact VB 42759 2517 12 such such PDT 42759 2517 13 a a DT 42759 2517 14 payment payment NN 42759 2517 15 ? ? . 42759 2518 1 Has have VBZ 42759 2518 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2518 3 a a DT 42759 2518 4 right right NN 42759 2518 5 to to TO 42759 2518 6 demand demand VB 42759 2518 7 the the DT 42759 2518 8 full full JJ 42759 2518 9 value value NN 42759 2518 10 of of IN 42759 2518 11 the the DT 42759 2518 12 service service NN 42759 2518 13 ? ? . 42759 2519 1 No no DT 42759 2519 2 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2519 3 person person NN 42759 2519 4 would would MD 42759 2519 5 answer answer VB 42759 2519 6 this this DT 42759 2519 7 question question NN 42759 2519 8 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 2519 9 than than IN 42759 2519 10 in in IN 42759 2519 11 the the DT 42759 2519 12 negative negative NN 42759 2519 13 . . . 42759 2520 1 If if IN 42759 2520 2 the the DT 42759 2520 3 performer performer NN 42759 2520 4 of of IN 42759 2520 5 the the DT 42759 2520 6 service service NN 42759 2520 7 may may MD 42759 2520 8 not not RB 42759 2520 9 charge charge VB 42759 2520 10 the the DT 42759 2520 11 full full JJ 42759 2520 12 value value NN 42759 2520 13 thereof thereof RB 42759 2520 14 , , , 42759 2520 15 as as IN 42759 2520 16 measured measure VBN 42759 2520 17 by by IN 42759 2520 18 the the DT 42759 2520 19 estimate estimate NN 42759 2520 20 put put VBN 42759 2520 21 upon upon IN 42759 2520 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2520 23 by by IN 42759 2520 24 the the DT 42759 2520 25 recipient recipient NN 42759 2520 26 , , , 42759 2520 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2520 28 would would MD 42759 2520 29 seem seem VB 42759 2520 30 that that IN 42759 2520 31 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2520 32 ought ought MD 42759 2520 33 not not RB 42759 2520 34 to to TO 42759 2520 35 demand demand VB 42759 2520 36 anything anything NN 42759 2520 37 in in IN 42759 2520 38 excess excess NN 42759 2520 39 of of IN 42759 2520 40 a a DT 42759 2520 41 fair fair JJ 42759 2520 42 price price NN 42759 2520 43 for for IN 42759 2520 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2520 45 trouble trouble NN 42759 2520 46 . . . 42759 2521 1 In in IN 42759 2521 2 other other JJ 42759 2521 3 words word NNS 42759 2521 4 , , , 42759 2521 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2521 6 may may MD 42759 2521 7 not not RB 42759 2521 8 justly justly RB 42759 2521 9 exact exact VB 42759 2521 10 anything anything NN 42759 2521 11 for for IN 42759 2521 12 the the DT 42759 2521 13 service service NN 42759 2521 14 as as IN 42759 2521 15 such such JJ 42759 2521 16 . . . 42759 2522 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2522 2 would would MD 42759 2522 3 seem seem VB 42759 2522 4 , , , 42759 2522 5 then then RB 42759 2522 6 , , , 42759 2522 7 that that IN 42759 2522 8 the the DT 42759 2522 9 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2522 10 has have VBZ 42759 2522 11 no no DT 42759 2522 12 moral moral JJ 42759 2522 13 claim claim NN 42759 2522 14 to to IN 42759 2522 15 pure pure JJ 42759 2522 16 interest interest NN 42759 2522 17 on on IN 42759 2522 18 the the DT 42759 2522 19 mere mere JJ 42759 2522 20 ground ground NN 42759 2522 21 that that IN 42759 2522 22 the the DT 42759 2522 23 use use NN 42759 2522 24 of of IN 42759 2522 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2522 26 capital capital NN 42759 2522 27 in in IN 42759 2522 28 production production NN 42759 2522 29 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 2522 30 a a DT 42759 2522 31 service service NN 42759 2522 32 to to IN 42759 2522 33 labourers labourer NNS 42759 2522 34 and and CC 42759 2522 35 consumers consumer NNS 42759 2522 36 . . . 42759 2523 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2523 2 would would MD 42759 2523 3 seem seem VB 42759 2523 4 that that IN 42759 2523 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2523 6 has have VBZ 42759 2523 7 no no DT 42759 2523 8 right right NN 42759 2523 9 to to TO 42759 2523 10 demand demand VB 42759 2523 11 a a DT 42759 2523 12 payment payment NN 42759 2523 13 for for IN 42759 2523 14 a a DT 42759 2523 15 costless costless JJ 42759 2523 16 service service NN 42759 2523 17 . . . 42759 2524 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2524 2 The the DT 42759 2524 3 Claims Claims NNPS 42759 2524 4 of of IN 42759 2524 5 Abstinence Abstinence NNP 42759 2524 6 _ _ NNP 42759 2524 7 The the DT 42759 2524 8 third third JJ 42759 2524 9 and and CC 42759 2524 10 last last JJ 42759 2524 11 of of IN 42759 2524 12 the the DT 42759 2524 13 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2524 14 justifications justification NNS 42759 2524 15 of of IN 42759 2524 16 interest interest NN 42759 2524 17 that that WDT 42759 2524 18 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2524 19 shall shall MD 42759 2524 20 consider consider VB 42759 2524 21 is be VBZ 42759 2524 22 _ _ NNP 42759 2524 23 abstinence abstinence NN 42759 2524 24 _ _ NNP 42759 2524 25 . . . 42759 2525 1 This this DT 42759 2525 2 argument argument NN 42759 2525 3 is be VBZ 42759 2525 4 based base VBN 42759 2525 5 upon upon IN 42759 2525 6 the the DT 42759 2525 7 contention contention NN 42759 2525 8 that that IN 42759 2525 9 the the DT 42759 2525 10 person person NN 42759 2525 11 who who WP 42759 2525 12 saves save VBZ 42759 2525 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2525 14 money money NN 42759 2525 15 , , , 42759 2525 16 and and CC 42759 2525 17 invests invest VBZ 42759 2525 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2525 19 in in IN 42759 2525 20 the the DT 42759 2525 21 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2525 22 of of IN 42759 2525 23 production production NN 42759 2525 24 undergoes undergo VBZ 42759 2525 25 a a DT 42759 2525 26 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2525 27 in in IN 42759 2525 28 deferring defer VBG 42759 2525 29 to to IN 42759 2525 30 the the DT 42759 2525 31 future future JJ 42759 2525 32 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 42759 2525 33 that that WDT 42759 2525 34 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2525 35 might may MD 42759 2525 36 enjoy enjoy VB 42759 2525 37 to to IN 42759 2525 38 - - HYPH 42759 2525 39 day day NN 42759 2525 40 . . . 42759 2526 1 One one CD 42759 2526 2 hundred hundred CD 42759 2526 3 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2526 4 now now RB 42759 2526 5 is be VBZ 42759 2526 6 worth worth JJ 42759 2526 7 as as RB 42759 2526 8 much much JJ 42759 2526 9 as as IN 42759 2526 10 one one CD 42759 2526 11 hundred hundred CD 42759 2526 12 and and CC 42759 2526 13 five five CD 42759 2526 14 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2526 15 a a DT 42759 2526 16 year year NN 42759 2526 17 hence hence RB 42759 2526 18 . . . 42759 2527 1 That that RB 42759 2527 2 is is RB 42759 2527 3 , , , 42759 2527 4 when when WRB 42759 2527 5 both both DT 42759 2527 6 are be VBP 42759 2527 7 estimated estimate VBN 42759 2527 8 from from IN 42759 2527 9 the the DT 42759 2527 10 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 2527 11 of of IN 42759 2527 12 the the DT 42759 2527 13 present present NN 42759 2527 14 . . . 42759 2528 1 This this DT 42759 2528 2 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2528 3 of of IN 42759 2528 4 present present JJ 42759 2528 5 to to IN 42759 2528 6 future future JJ 42759 2528 7 enjoyment enjoyment NN 42759 2528 8 which which WDT 42759 2528 9 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 2528 10 a a DT 42759 2528 11 service service NN 42759 2528 12 to to IN 42759 2528 13 the the DT 42759 2528 14 community community NN 42759 2528 15 in in IN 42759 2528 16 the the DT 42759 2528 17 form form NN 42759 2528 18 of of IN 42759 2528 19 capital capital NN 42759 2528 20 , , , 42759 2528 21 creates create VBZ 42759 2528 22 a a DT 42759 2528 23 just just RB 42759 2528 24 claim claim NN 42759 2528 25 upon upon IN 42759 2528 26 the the DT 42759 2528 27 community community NN 42759 2528 28 to to IN 42759 2528 29 compensation compensation NN 42759 2528 30 in in IN 42759 2528 31 the the DT 42759 2528 32 form form NN 42759 2528 33 of of IN 42759 2528 34 interest interest NN 42759 2528 35 . . . 42759 2529 1 If if IN 42759 2529 2 the the DT 42759 2529 3 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2529 4 is be VBZ 42759 2529 5 not not RB 42759 2529 6 rewarded reward VBN 42759 2529 7 for for IN 42759 2529 8 this this DT 42759 2529 9 inconvenience inconvenience NN 42759 2529 10 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2529 11 is be VBZ 42759 2529 12 , , , 42759 2529 13 like like IN 42759 2529 14 the the DT 42759 2529 15 unpaid unpaid JJ 42759 2529 16 labourer labourer NN 42759 2529 17 , , , 42759 2529 18 subordinated subordinate VBN 42759 2529 19 to to IN 42759 2529 20 the the DT 42759 2529 21 aggrandisement aggrandisement NN 42759 2529 22 of of IN 42759 2529 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2529 24 fellows fellow NNS 42759 2529 25 . . . 42759 2530 1 Against against IN 42759 2530 2 this this DT 42759 2530 3 argument argument NN 42759 2530 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2530 5 may may MD 42759 2530 6 place place VB 42759 2530 7 the the DT 42759 2530 8 extreme extreme JJ 42759 2530 9 refutation refutation NN 42759 2530 10 attempted attempt VBN 42759 2530 11 by by IN 42759 2530 12 the the DT 42759 2530 13 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 2530 14 leader leader NN 42759 2530 15 , , , 42759 2530 16 Ferdinand Ferdinand NNP 42759 2530 17 Lassalle Lassalle NNP 42759 2530 18 : : : 42759 2530 19 " " `` 42759 2530 20 But but CC 42759 2530 21 the the DT 42759 2530 22 profit profit NN 42759 2530 23 of of IN 42759 2530 24 capital capital NN 42759 2530 25 is be VBZ 42759 2530 26 _ _ NNP 42759 2530 27 the the DT 42759 2530 28 reward reward NN 42759 2530 29 of of IN 42759 2530 30 abstinence abstinence NN 42759 2530 31 _ _ NNP 42759 2530 32 . . . 42759 2531 1 Truly truly RB 42759 2531 2 a a DT 42759 2531 3 happy happy JJ 42759 2531 4 phrase phrase NN 42759 2531 5 ! ! . 42759 2532 1 European european JJ 42759 2532 2 millionaires millionaire NNS 42759 2532 3 are be VBP 42759 2532 4 ascetics ascetic NNS 42759 2532 5 , , , 42759 2532 6 Indian indian JJ 42759 2532 7 penitents penitent NNS 42759 2532 8 , , , 42759 2532 9 modern modern JJ 42759 2532 10 St. St. NNP 42759 2532 11 Simons Simons NNPS 42759 2532 12 Stylites Stylites NNPS 42759 2532 13 , , , 42759 2532 14 who who WP 42759 2532 15 perched perch VBD 42759 2532 16 on on IN 42759 2532 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2532 18 columns column NNS 42759 2532 19 , , , 42759 2532 20 with with IN 42759 2532 21 withered withered JJ 42759 2532 22 features feature NNS 42759 2532 23 and and CC 42759 2532 24 arms arm NNS 42759 2532 25 and and CC 42759 2532 26 bodies body NNS 42759 2532 27 thrust thrust VBD 42759 2532 28 forward forward RB 42759 2532 29 , , , 42759 2532 30 hold hold VBP 42759 2532 31 out out RP 42759 2532 32 a a DT 42759 2532 33 plate plate NN 42759 2532 34 to to IN 42759 2532 35 the the DT 42759 2532 36 passers passer NNS 42759 2532 37 - - : 42759 2532 38 by by IN 42759 2532 39 that that IN 42759 2532 40 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2532 41 may may MD 42759 2532 42 receive receive VB 42759 2532 43 the the DT 42759 2532 44 wages wage NNS 42759 2532 45 of of IN 42759 2532 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2532 47 privations privation NNS 42759 2532 48 ! ! . 42759 2533 1 In in IN 42759 2533 2 the the DT 42759 2533 3 midst midst NN 42759 2533 4 of of IN 42759 2533 5 this this DT 42759 2533 6 sacro sacro NNP 42759 2533 7 - - HYPH 42759 2533 8 saint saint NNP 42759 2533 9 group group NN 42759 2533 10 , , , 42759 2533 11 high high JJ 42759 2533 12 above above IN 42759 2533 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2533 14 fellow fellow NN 42759 2533 15 - - HYPH 42759 2533 16 mortifiers mortifier NNS 42759 2533 17 of of IN 42759 2533 18 the the DT 42759 2533 19 flesh flesh NN 42759 2533 20 , , , 42759 2533 21 stands stand VBZ 42759 2533 22 the the DT 42759 2533 23 Holy Holy NNP 42759 2533 24 House House NNP 42759 2533 25 of of IN 42759 2533 26 Rothschild Rothschild NNP 42759 2533 27 . . . 42759 2534 1 That that DT 42759 2534 2 is be VBZ 42759 2534 3 the the DT 42759 2534 4 real real JJ 42759 2534 5 truth truth NN 42759 2534 6 about about IN 42759 2534 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2534 8 present present JJ 42759 2534 9 society society NN 42759 2534 10 ! ! . 42759 2535 1 How how WRB 42759 2535 2 could could MD 42759 2535 3 I -PRON- PRP 42759 2535 4 have have VB 42759 2535 5 hitherto hitherto VBN 42759 2535 6 blundered blunder VBN 42759 2535 7 on on IN 42759 2535 8 this this DT 42759 2535 9 point point NN 42759 2535 10 as as IN 42759 2535 11 I -PRON- PRP 42759 2535 12 have have VBP 42759 2535 13 ? ? . 42759 2536 1 " " `` 42759 2536 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2536 3 140 140 CD 42759 2536 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2536 5 Obviously obviously RB 42759 2536 6 this this DT 42759 2536 7 is be VBZ 42759 2536 8 a a DT 42759 2536 9 malevolently malevolently RB 42759 2536 10 one one CD 42759 2536 11 - - HYPH 42759 2536 12 sided sided JJ 42759 2536 13 implication implication NN 42759 2536 14 concerning concern VBG 42759 2536 15 the the DT 42759 2536 16 sources source NNS 42759 2536 17 of of IN 42759 2536 18 capital capital NN 42759 2536 19 . . . 42759 2537 1 But but CC 42759 2537 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2537 3 is be VBZ 42759 2537 4 scarcely scarcely RB 42759 2537 5 less less RBR 42759 2537 6 adequate adequate JJ 42759 2537 7 than than IN 42759 2537 8 the the DT 42759 2537 9 explanation explanation NN 42759 2537 10 in in IN 42759 2537 11 opposition opposition NN 42759 2537 12 to to TO 42759 2537 13 which which WDT 42759 2537 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2537 15 has have VBZ 42759 2537 16 been be VBN 42759 2537 17 quoted quote VBN 42759 2537 18 . . . 42759 2538 1 Both both DT 42759 2538 2 fail fail VBP 42759 2538 3 to to TO 42759 2538 4 distinguish distinguish VB 42759 2538 5 between between IN 42759 2538 6 the the DT 42759 2538 7 different different JJ 42759 2538 8 kinds kind NNS 42759 2538 9 of of IN 42759 2538 10 savers saver NNS 42759 2538 11 , , , 42759 2538 12 the the DT 42759 2538 13 different different JJ 42759 2538 14 kinds kind NNS 42759 2538 15 of of IN 42759 2538 16 capital capital NN 42759 2538 17 - - HYPH 42759 2538 18 owners owner NNS 42759 2538 19 . . . 42759 2539 1 For for IN 42759 2539 2 the the DT 42759 2539 3 purposes purpose NNS 42759 2539 4 of of IN 42759 2539 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2539 6 inquiry inquiry NN 42759 2539 7 savings saving NNS 42759 2539 8 may may MD 42759 2539 9 be be VB 42759 2539 10 divided divide VBN 42759 2539 11 into into IN 42759 2539 12 three three CD 42759 2539 13 classes class NNS 42759 2539 14 . . . 42759 2540 1 First first RB 42759 2540 2 , , , 42759 2540 3 those those DT 42759 2540 4 which which WDT 42759 2540 5 are be VBP 42759 2540 6 accumulated accumulate VBN 42759 2540 7 and and CC 42759 2540 8 invested invest VBN 42759 2540 9 automatically automatically RB 42759 2540 10 . . . 42759 2541 1 Very very RB 42759 2541 2 rich rich JJ 42759 2541 3 persons person NNS 42759 2541 4 save save VBP 42759 2541 5 a a DT 42759 2541 6 great great JJ 42759 2541 7 deal deal NN 42759 2541 8 of of IN 42759 2541 9 money money NN 42759 2541 10 that that WDT 42759 2541 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2541 12 have have VBP 42759 2541 13 no no DT 42759 2541 14 desire desire NN 42759 2541 15 to to TO 42759 2541 16 spend spend VB 42759 2541 17 , , , 42759 2541 18 since since IN 42759 2541 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2541 20 have have VBP 42759 2541 21 already already RB 42759 2541 22 satisfied satisfy VBN 42759 2541 23 or or CC 42759 2541 24 safeguarded safeguard VBN 42759 2541 25 all all PDT 42759 2541 26 the the DT 42759 2541 27 wants want NNS 42759 2541 28 of of IN 42759 2541 29 which which WDT 42759 2541 30 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2541 31 are be VBP 42759 2541 32 conscious conscious JJ 42759 2541 33 . . . 42759 2542 1 Evidently evidently RB 42759 2542 2 this this DT 42759 2542 3 kind kind NN 42759 2542 4 of of IN 42759 2542 5 saving saving NN 42759 2542 6 involves involve VBZ 42759 2542 7 no no DT 42759 2542 8 real real JJ 42759 2542 9 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2542 10 . . . 42759 2543 1 To to IN 42759 2543 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2543 3 the the DT 42759 2543 4 words word NNS 42759 2543 5 of of IN 42759 2543 6 Lassalle Lassalle NNP 42759 2543 7 are be VBP 42759 2543 8 substantially substantially RB 42759 2543 9 applicable applicable JJ 42759 2543 10 , , , 42759 2543 11 and and CC 42759 2543 12 the the DT 42759 2543 13 claim claim NN 42759 2543 14 to to IN 42759 2543 15 interest interest NN 42759 2543 16 for for IN 42759 2543 17 abstinence abstinence NN 42759 2543 18 decidedly decidedly RB 42759 2543 19 inapplicable inapplicable JJ 42759 2543 20 . . . 42759 2544 1 Second second JJ 42759 2544 2 , , , 42759 2544 3 savings saving NNS 42759 2544 4 to to TO 42759 2544 5 provide provide VB 42759 2544 6 for for IN 42759 2544 7 old old JJ 42759 2544 8 age age NN 42759 2544 9 and and CC 42759 2544 10 other other JJ 42759 2544 11 future future JJ 42759 2544 12 contingencies contingency NNS 42759 2544 13 which which WDT 42759 2544 14 are be VBP 42759 2544 15 estimated estimate VBN 42759 2544 16 as as IN 42759 2544 17 more more RBR 42759 2544 18 important important JJ 42759 2544 19 than than IN 42759 2544 20 any any DT 42759 2544 21 of of IN 42759 2544 22 the the DT 42759 2544 23 purposes purpose NNS 42759 2544 24 for for IN 42759 2544 25 which which WDT 42759 2544 26 the the DT 42759 2544 27 money money NN 42759 2544 28 might may MD 42759 2544 29 now now RB 42759 2544 30 be be VB 42759 2544 31 expended expend VBN 42759 2544 32 . . . 42759 2545 1 Were be VBD 42759 2545 2 interest interest NN 42759 2545 3 abolished abolish VBD 42759 2545 4 this this DT 42759 2545 5 kind kind NN 42759 2545 6 of of IN 42759 2545 7 saving saving NN 42759 2545 8 would would MD 42759 2545 9 be be VB 42759 2545 10 even even RB 42759 2545 11 greater great JJR 42759 2545 12 than than IN 42759 2545 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2545 14 is be VBZ 42759 2545 15 at at IN 42759 2545 16 present present JJ 42759 2545 17 ; ; : 42759 2545 18 for for IN 42759 2545 19 a a DT 42759 2545 20 larger large JJR 42759 2545 21 total total NN 42759 2545 22 would would MD 42759 2545 23 be be VB 42759 2545 24 required require VBN 42759 2545 25 to to TO 42759 2545 26 equal equal VB 42759 2545 27 the the DT 42759 2545 28 fund fund NN 42759 2545 29 that that WDT 42759 2545 30 is be VBZ 42759 2545 31 now now RB 42759 2545 32 provided provide VBN 42759 2545 33 through through IN 42759 2545 34 the the DT 42759 2545 35 addition addition NN 42759 2545 36 of of IN 42759 2545 37 interest interest NN 42759 2545 38 to to IN 42759 2545 39 the the DT 42759 2545 40 principal principal NN 42759 2545 41 . . . 42759 2546 1 In in IN 42759 2546 2 a a DT 42759 2546 3 no no DT 42759 2546 4 - - HYPH 42759 2546 5 interest interest NN 42759 2546 6 régime régime NN 42759 2546 7 one one CD 42759 2546 8 thousand thousand CD 42759 2546 9 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2546 10 would would MD 42759 2546 11 have have VB 42759 2546 12 to to TO 42759 2546 13 be be VB 42759 2546 14 set set VBN 42759 2546 15 aside aside RB 42759 2546 16 every every DT 42759 2546 17 year year NN 42759 2546 18 in in IN 42759 2546 19 order order NN 42759 2546 20 to to TO 42759 2546 21 total total VB 42759 2546 22 twenty twenty CD 42759 2546 23 thousand thousand CD 42759 2546 24 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2546 25 in in IN 42759 2546 26 twenty twenty CD 42759 2546 27 years year NNS 42759 2546 28 ; ; : 42759 2546 29 when when WRB 42759 2546 30 interest interest NN 42759 2546 31 is be VBZ 42759 2546 32 accumulated accumulate VBN 42759 2546 33 on on IN 42759 2546 34 the the DT 42759 2546 35 savings saving NNS 42759 2546 36 , , , 42759 2546 37 a a DT 42759 2546 38 smaller small JJR 42759 2546 39 annual annual JJ 42759 2546 40 amount amount NN 42759 2546 41 will will MD 42759 2546 42 suffice suffice VB 42759 2546 43 to to TO 42759 2546 44 produce produce VB 42759 2546 45 the the DT 42759 2546 46 same same JJ 42759 2546 47 fund fund NN 42759 2546 48 . . . 42759 2547 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 2547 2 as as IN 42759 2547 3 this this DT 42759 2547 4 class class NN 42759 2547 5 of of IN 42759 2547 6 persons person NNS 42759 2547 7 would would MD 42759 2547 8 save save VB 42759 2547 9 in in IN 42759 2547 10 an an DT 42759 2547 11 even even RB 42759 2547 12 greater great JJR 42759 2547 13 degree degree NN 42759 2547 14 without without IN 42759 2547 15 interest interest NN 42759 2547 16 , , , 42759 2547 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2547 18 is be VBZ 42759 2547 19 clear clear JJ 42759 2547 20 that that IN 42759 2547 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2547 22 regard regard VBP 42759 2547 23 the the DT 42759 2547 24 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2547 25 involved involve VBN 42759 2547 26 as as IN 42759 2547 27 fully fully RB 42759 2547 28 compensated compensate VBN 42759 2547 29 in in IN 42759 2547 30 the the DT 42759 2547 31 resulting result VBG 42759 2547 32 provision provision NN 42759 2547 33 for for IN 42759 2547 34 the the DT 42759 2547 35 future future NN 42759 2547 36 . . . 42759 2548 1 In in IN 42759 2548 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2548 3 case case NN 42759 2548 4 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2548 5 is be VBZ 42759 2548 6 amply amply RB 42759 2548 7 rewarded reward VBN 42759 2548 8 by by IN 42759 2548 9 accumulation accumulation NN 42759 2548 10 . . . 42759 2549 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2549 2 claim claim NN 42759 2549 3 to to IN 42759 2549 4 additional additional JJ 42759 2549 5 compensation compensation NN 42759 2549 6 in in IN 42759 2549 7 the the DT 42759 2549 8 form form NN 42759 2549 9 of of IN 42759 2549 10 interest interest NN 42759 2549 11 does do VBZ 42759 2549 12 not not RB 42759 2549 13 seem seem VB 42759 2549 14 to to TO 42759 2549 15 have have VB 42759 2549 16 any any DT 42759 2549 17 valid valid JJ 42759 2549 18 basis basis NN 42759 2549 19 . . . 42759 2550 1 In in IN 42759 2550 2 the the DT 42759 2550 3 words word NNS 42759 2550 4 of of IN 42759 2550 5 the the DT 42759 2550 6 late late JJ 42759 2550 7 Professor Professor NNP 42759 2550 8 Devas Devas NNP 42759 2550 9 , , , 42759 2550 10 " " `` 42759 2550 11 there there EX 42759 2550 12 is be VBZ 42759 2550 13 ample ample JJ 42759 2550 14 reward reward NN 42759 2550 15 given give VBN 42759 2550 16 without without IN 42759 2550 17 any any DT 42759 2550 18 need need NN 42759 2550 19 of of IN 42759 2550 20 any any DT 42759 2550 21 interest interest NN 42759 2550 22 or or CC 42759 2550 23 dividend dividend NN 42759 2550 24 . . . 42759 2551 1 For for IN 42759 2551 2 the the DT 42759 2551 3 workers worker NNS 42759 2551 4 with with IN 42759 2551 5 heads head NNS 42759 2551 6 or or CC 42759 2551 7 hands hand NNS 42759 2551 8 keep keep VBP 42759 2551 9 the the DT 42759 2551 10 property property NN 42759 2551 11 intact intact JJ 42759 2551 12 , , , 42759 2551 13 ready ready JJ 42759 2551 14 for for IN 42759 2551 15 the the DT 42759 2551 16 owner owner NN 42759 2551 17 to to TO 42759 2551 18 consume consume VB 42759 2551 19 whenever whenever WRB 42759 2551 20 convenient convenient RB 42759 2551 21 , , , 42759 2551 22 when when WRB 42759 2551 23 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2551 24 gets get VBZ 42759 2551 25 infirm infirm NN 42759 2551 26 or or CC 42759 2551 27 sick sick JJ 42759 2551 28 , , , 42759 2551 29 or or CC 42759 2551 30 when when WRB 42759 2551 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2551 32 children child NNS 42759 2551 33 have have VBP 42759 2551 34 grown grow VBN 42759 2551 35 up up RP 42759 2551 36 , , , 42759 2551 37 and and CC 42759 2551 38 can can MD 42759 2551 39 enjoy enjoy VB 42759 2551 40 the the DT 42759 2551 41 property property NN 42759 2551 42 with with IN 42759 2551 43 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2551 44 . . . 42759 2552 1 " " `` 42759 2552 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2552 3 141 141 CD 42759 2552 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2552 5 The the DT 42759 2552 6 third third JJ 42759 2552 7 kind kind NN 42759 2552 8 of of IN 42759 2552 9 saving saving NN 42759 2552 10 is be VBZ 42759 2552 11 that that IN 42759 2552 12 which which WDT 42759 2552 13 is be VBZ 42759 2552 14 made make VBN 42759 2552 15 by by IN 42759 2552 16 persons person NNS 42759 2552 17 who who WP 42759 2552 18 could could MD 42759 2552 19 spend spend VB 42759 2552 20 , , , 42759 2552 21 and and CC 42759 2552 22 have have VBP 42759 2552 23 some some DT 42759 2552 24 desire desire NN 42759 2552 25 to to TO 42759 2552 26 spend spend VB 42759 2552 27 , , , 42759 2552 28 more more JJR 42759 2552 29 on on IN 42759 2552 30 present present JJ 42759 2552 31 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 42759 2552 32 , , , 42759 2552 33 and and CC 42759 2552 34 who who WP 42759 2552 35 have have VBP 42759 2552 36 already already RB 42759 2552 37 provided provide VBN 42759 2552 38 for for IN 42759 2552 39 all all DT 42759 2552 40 future future NN 42759 2552 41 wants want VBZ 42759 2552 42 in in IN 42759 2552 43 accordance accordance NN 42759 2552 44 with with IN 42759 2552 45 the the DT 42759 2552 46 standards standard NNS 42759 2552 47 of of IN 42759 2552 48 necessaries necessary NNS 42759 2552 49 and and CC 42759 2552 50 comforts comfort NNS 42759 2552 51 that that IN 42759 2552 52 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2552 53 have have VBP 42759 2552 54 adopted adopt VBN 42759 2552 55 . . . 42759 2553 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2553 2 fund fund NN 42759 2553 3 for for IN 42759 2553 4 the the DT 42759 2553 5 future future NN 42759 2553 6 is be VBZ 42759 2553 7 already already RB 42759 2553 8 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2553 9 to to TO 42759 2553 10 meet meet VB 42759 2553 11 all all PDT 42759 2553 12 those those DT 42759 2553 13 needs need NNS 42759 2553 14 which which WDT 42759 2553 15 seem seem VBP 42759 2553 16 weightier weighty JJR 42759 2553 17 than than IN 42759 2553 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2553 19 present present JJ 42759 2553 20 unsatisfied unsatisfied JJ 42759 2553 21 wants want NNS 42759 2553 22 . . . 42759 2554 1 If if IN 42759 2554 2 the the DT 42759 2554 3 surplus surplus NN 42759 2554 4 in in IN 42759 2554 5 question question NN 42759 2554 6 is be VBZ 42759 2554 7 saved save VBN 42759 2554 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2554 9 will will MD 42759 2554 10 go go VB 42759 2554 11 to to TO 42759 2554 12 supply supply VB 42759 2554 13 future future JJ 42759 2554 14 desires desire NNS 42759 2554 15 which which WDT 42759 2554 16 are be VBP 42759 2554 17 no no RB 42759 2554 18 more more RBR 42759 2554 19 important important JJ 42759 2554 20 than than IN 42759 2554 21 those those DT 42759 2554 22 for for IN 42759 2554 23 which which WDT 42759 2554 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2554 25 might may MD 42759 2554 26 be be VB 42759 2554 27 expended expend VBN 42759 2554 28 now now RB 42759 2554 29 . . . 42759 2555 1 In in IN 42759 2555 2 other other JJ 42759 2555 3 words word NNS 42759 2555 4 , , , 42759 2555 5 the the DT 42759 2555 6 alternatives alternative NNS 42759 2555 7 before before IN 42759 2555 8 the the DT 42759 2555 9 prospective prospective JJ 42759 2555 10 saver saver NN 42759 2555 11 are be VBP 42759 2555 12 to to TO 42759 2555 13 procure procure VB 42759 2555 14 a a DT 42759 2555 15 given give VBN 42759 2555 16 amount amount NN 42759 2555 17 of of IN 42759 2555 18 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 2555 19 to to NN 42759 2555 20 - - HYPH 42759 2555 21 day day NN 42759 2555 22 , , , 42759 2555 23 or or CC 42759 2555 24 to to TO 42759 2555 25 defer defer VB 42759 2555 26 the the DT 42759 2555 27 same same JJ 42759 2555 28 degree degree NN 42759 2555 29 of of IN 42759 2555 30 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 2555 31 to to IN 42759 2555 32 a a DT 42759 2555 33 distant distant JJ 42759 2555 34 day day NN 42759 2555 35 . . . 42759 2556 1 In in IN 42759 2556 2 this this DT 42759 2556 3 case case NN 42759 2556 4 the the DT 42759 2556 5 inducement inducement NN 42759 2556 6 of of IN 42759 2556 7 interest interest NN 42759 2556 8 will will MD 42759 2556 9 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 2556 10 be be VB 42759 2556 11 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2556 12 to to TO 42759 2556 13 bring bring VB 42759 2556 14 about about RP 42759 2556 15 saving saving NN 42759 2556 16 . . . 42759 2557 1 As as IN 42759 2557 2 between between IN 42759 2557 3 equal equal JJ 42759 2557 4 amounts amount NNS 42759 2557 5 of of IN 42759 2557 6 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 2557 7 at at IN 42759 2557 8 different different JJ 42759 2557 9 times time NNS 42759 2557 10 , , , 42759 2557 11 the the DT 42759 2557 12 average average JJ 42759 2557 13 person person NN 42759 2557 14 will will MD 42759 2557 15 certainly certainly RB 42759 2557 16 prefer prefer VB 42759 2557 17 those those DT 42759 2557 18 of of IN 42759 2557 19 the the DT 42759 2557 20 present present NN 42759 2557 21 to to IN 42759 2557 22 those those DT 42759 2557 23 of of IN 42759 2557 24 the the DT 42759 2557 25 future future NN 42759 2557 26 . . . 42759 2558 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2558 2 will will MD 42759 2558 3 not not RB 42759 2558 4 decide decide VB 42759 2558 5 in in IN 42759 2558 6 favour favour NN 42759 2558 7 of of IN 42759 2558 8 the the DT 42759 2558 9 future future NN 42759 2558 10 unless unless IN 42759 2558 11 the the DT 42759 2558 12 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 42759 2558 13 then then RB 42759 2558 14 obtainable obtainable JJ 42759 2558 15 are be VBP 42759 2558 16 to to TO 42759 2558 17 be be VB 42759 2558 18 greater great JJR 42759 2558 19 in in IN 42759 2558 20 quantity quantity NN 42759 2558 21 . . . 42759 2559 1 To to IN 42759 2559 2 this this DT 42759 2559 3 situation situation NN 42759 2559 4 the the DT 42759 2559 5 rule rule NN 42759 2559 6 that that WDT 42759 2559 7 deferred defer VBD 42759 2559 8 enjoyments enjoyment NNS 42759 2559 9 are be VBP 42759 2559 10 worth worth JJ 42759 2559 11 less less JJR 42759 2559 12 than than IN 42759 2559 13 present present JJ 42759 2559 14 enjoyments enjoyment NNS 42759 2559 15 , , , 42759 2559 16 is be VBZ 42759 2559 17 strictly strictly RB 42759 2559 18 applicable applicable JJ 42759 2559 19 . . . 42759 2560 1 The the DT 42759 2560 2 increased increase VBN 42759 2560 3 quantity quantity NN 42759 2560 4 of of IN 42759 2560 5 future future JJ 42759 2560 6 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 2560 7 which which WDT 42759 2560 8 is be VBZ 42759 2560 9 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2560 10 to to TO 42759 2560 11 turn turn VB 42759 2560 12 the the DT 42759 2560 13 choice choice NN 42759 2560 14 from from IN 42759 2560 15 the the DT 42759 2560 16 present present NN 42759 2560 17 to to IN 42759 2560 18 the the DT 42759 2560 19 future future NN 42759 2560 20 , , , 42759 2560 21 and and CC 42759 2560 22 to to TO 42759 2560 23 determine determine VB 42759 2560 24 that that IN 42759 2560 25 the the DT 42759 2560 26 surplus surplus NN 42759 2560 27 shall shall MD 42759 2560 28 be be VB 42759 2560 29 saved save VBN 42759 2560 30 rather rather RB 42759 2560 31 than than IN 42759 2560 32 spent spend VBN 42759 2560 33 , , , 42759 2560 34 can can MD 42759 2560 35 be be VB 42759 2560 36 provided provide VBN 42759 2560 37 only only RB 42759 2560 38 through through IN 42759 2560 39 interest interest NN 42759 2560 40 . . . 42759 2561 1 In in IN 42759 2561 2 this this DT 42759 2561 3 way way NN 42759 2561 4 the the DT 42759 2561 5 accumulations accumulation NNS 42759 2561 6 of of IN 42759 2561 7 interest interest NN 42759 2561 8 and and CC 42759 2561 9 savings saving NNS 42759 2561 10 will will MD 42759 2561 11 make make VB 42759 2561 12 the the DT 42759 2561 13 future future JJ 42759 2561 14 fund fund NN 42759 2561 15 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 2561 16 to to IN 42759 2561 17 a a DT 42759 2561 18 larger large JJR 42759 2561 19 amount amount NN 42759 2561 20 of of IN 42759 2561 21 enjoyment enjoyment NN 42759 2561 22 or or CC 42759 2561 23 utility utility NN 42759 2561 24 than than IN 42759 2561 25 could could MD 42759 2561 26 be be VB 42759 2561 27 obtained obtain VBN 42759 2561 28 if if IN 42759 2561 29 the the DT 42759 2561 30 surplus surplus NN 42759 2561 31 were be VBD 42759 2561 32 exchanged exchange VBN 42759 2561 33 for for IN 42759 2561 34 the the DT 42759 2561 35 goods good NNS 42759 2561 36 of of IN 42759 2561 37 the the DT 42759 2561 38 present present NN 42759 2561 39 . . . 42759 2562 1 " " `` 42759 2562 2 Interest interest NN 42759 2562 3 magnifies magnify VBZ 42759 2562 4 the the DT 42759 2562 5 distant distant JJ 42759 2562 6 object object NN 42759 2562 7 . . . 42759 2562 8 " " '' 42759 2563 1 Whenever whenever WRB 42759 2563 2 this this DT 42759 2563 3 magnifying magnify VBG 42759 2563 4 power power NN 42759 2563 5 seems seem VBZ 42759 2563 6 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 2563 7 great great JJ 42759 2563 8 to to TO 42759 2563 9 outweigh outweigh VB 42759 2563 10 the the DT 42759 2563 11 advantage advantage NN 42759 2563 12 of of IN 42759 2563 13 present present JJ 42759 2563 14 over over IN 42759 2563 15 future future JJ 42759 2563 16 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 42759 2563 17 , , , 42759 2563 18 the the DT 42759 2563 19 surplus surplus NN 42759 2563 20 will will MD 42759 2563 21 be be VB 42759 2563 22 saved save VBN 42759 2563 23 instead instead RB 42759 2563 24 of of IN 42759 2563 25 spent spend VBN 42759 2563 26 . . . 42759 2564 1 Among among IN 42759 2564 2 the the DT 42759 2564 3 well well NN 42759 2564 4 - - HYPH 42759 2564 5 to to TO 42759 2564 6 - - HYPH 42759 2564 7 do do VB 42759 2564 8 there there EX 42759 2564 9 is be VBZ 42759 2564 10 probably probably RB 42759 2564 11 a a DT 42759 2564 12 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2564 13 number number NN 42759 2564 14 of of IN 42759 2564 15 persons person NNS 42759 2564 16 who who WP 42759 2564 17 take take VBP 42759 2564 18 this this DT 42759 2564 19 attitude attitude NN 42759 2564 20 toward toward IN 42759 2564 21 a a DT 42759 2564 22 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2564 23 part part NN 42759 2564 24 of of IN 42759 2564 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2564 26 savings saving NNS 42759 2564 27 . . . 42759 2565 1 Since since IN 42759 2565 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2565 3 would would MD 42759 2565 4 not not RB 42759 2565 5 make make VB 42759 2565 6 these these DT 42759 2565 7 savings saving NNS 42759 2565 8 without without IN 42759 2565 9 the the DT 42759 2565 10 inducement inducement NN 42759 2565 11 of of IN 42759 2565 12 interest interest NN 42759 2565 13 , , , 42759 2565 14 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2565 15 regard regard VBP 42759 2565 16 the the DT 42759 2565 17 latter latter JJ 42759 2565 18 as as IN 42759 2565 19 a a DT 42759 2565 20 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2565 21 compensation compensation NN 42759 2565 22 for for IN 42759 2565 23 the the DT 42759 2565 24 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2565 25 of of IN 42759 2565 26 postponed postpone VBN 42759 2565 27 enjoyment enjoyment NN 42759 2565 28 . . . 42759 2566 1 In in IN 42759 2566 2 a a DT 42759 2566 3 general general JJ 42759 2566 4 way way NN 42759 2566 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2566 6 may may MD 42759 2566 7 say say VB 42759 2566 8 that that IN 42759 2566 9 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2566 10 have have VBP 42759 2566 11 a a DT 42759 2566 12 strict strict JJ 42759 2566 13 right right NN 42759 2566 14 to to IN 42759 2566 15 this this DT 42759 2566 16 interest interest NN 42759 2566 17 on on IN 42759 2566 18 the the DT 42759 2566 19 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2566 20 ground ground NN 42759 2566 21 of of IN 42759 2566 22 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2566 23 . . . 42759 2567 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 2567 2 as as IN 42759 2567 3 the the DT 42759 2567 4 community community NN 42759 2567 5 benefits benefit VBZ 42759 2567 6 by by IN 42759 2567 7 the the DT 42759 2567 8 savings saving NNS 42759 2567 9 , , , 42759 2567 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2567 11 may may MD 42759 2567 12 quite quite RB 42759 2567 13 as as RB 42759 2567 14 fairly fairly RB 42759 2567 15 be be VB 42759 2567 16 required require VBN 42759 2567 17 to to TO 42759 2567 18 pay pay VB 42759 2567 19 for for IN 42759 2567 20 the the DT 42759 2567 21 antecedent antecedent NN 42759 2567 22 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 2567 23 of of IN 42759 2567 24 the the DT 42759 2567 25 savers saver NNS 42759 2567 26 as as IN 42759 2567 27 for for IN 42759 2567 28 the the DT 42759 2567 29 inconvenience inconvenience NN 42759 2567 30 undergone undergo VBN 42759 2567 31 by by IN 42759 2567 32 the the DT 42759 2567 33 performer performer NN 42759 2567 34 of of IN 42759 2567 35 any any DT 42759 2567 36 useful useful JJ 42759 2567 37 labour labour NN 42759 2567 38 or or CC 42759 2567 39 service service NN 42759 2567 40 . . . 42759 2568 1 Summing sum VBG 42759 2568 2 up up RP 42759 2568 3 the the DT 42759 2568 4 matter matter NN 42759 2568 5 regarding regard VBG 42759 2568 6 the the DT 42759 2568 7 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2568 8 justification justification NN 42759 2568 9 of of IN 42759 2568 10 interest interest NN 42759 2568 11 , , , 42759 2568 12 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2568 13 find find VBP 42759 2568 14 that that IN 42759 2568 15 the the DT 42759 2568 16 titles title NNS 42759 2568 17 of of IN 42759 2568 18 productivity productivity NN 42759 2568 19 and and CC 42759 2568 20 service service NN 42759 2568 21 do do VBP 42759 2568 22 not not RB 42759 2568 23 conclusively conclusively RB 42759 2568 24 establish establish VB 42759 2568 25 the the DT 42759 2568 26 strict strict JJ 42759 2568 27 right right NN 42759 2568 28 of of IN 42759 2568 29 the the DT 42759 2568 30 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2568 31 to to IN 42759 2568 32 interest interest NN 42759 2568 33 , , , 42759 2568 34 and and CC 42759 2568 35 that that IN 42759 2568 36 the the DT 42759 2568 37 title title NN 42759 2568 38 of of IN 42759 2568 39 abstinence abstinence NN 42759 2568 40 is be VBZ 42759 2568 41 morally morally RB 42759 2568 42 valid valid JJ 42759 2568 43 for for IN 42759 2568 44 only only RB 42759 2568 45 a a DT 42759 2568 46 portion portion NN 42759 2568 47 , , , 42759 2568 48 probably probably RB 42759 2568 49 a a DT 42759 2568 50 rather rather RB 42759 2568 51 small small JJ 42759 2568 52 portion portion NN 42759 2568 53 , , , 42759 2568 54 of of IN 42759 2568 55 the the DT 42759 2568 56 total total JJ 42759 2568 57 amount amount NN 42759 2568 58 of of IN 42759 2568 59 interest interest NN 42759 2568 60 now now RB 42759 2568 61 received receive VBN 42759 2568 62 by by IN 42759 2568 63 the the DT 42759 2568 64 owners owner NNS 42759 2568 65 of of IN 42759 2568 66 capital capital NN 42759 2568 67 . . . 42759 2569 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 2569 2 interest interest NN 42759 2569 3 as as IN 42759 2569 4 a a DT 42759 2569 5 whole whole NN 42759 2569 6 is be VBZ 42759 2569 7 not not RB 42759 2569 8 conclusively conclusively RB 42759 2569 9 vindicated vindicate VBN 42759 2569 10 on on IN 42759 2569 11 individual individual JJ 42759 2569 12 grounds ground NNS 42759 2569 13 . . . 42759 2570 1 If if IN 42759 2570 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2570 3 is be VBZ 42759 2570 4 to to TO 42759 2570 5 be be VB 42759 2570 6 proved prove VBN 42759 2570 7 morally morally RB 42759 2570 8 lawful lawful JJ 42759 2570 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2570 10 justification justification NN 42759 2570 11 must must MD 42759 2570 12 be be VB 42759 2570 13 sought seek VBN 42759 2570 14 in in IN 42759 2570 15 extrinsic extrinsic NN 42759 2570 16 and and CC 42759 2570 17 social social JJ 42759 2570 18 considerations consideration NNS 42759 2570 19 . . . 42759 2571 1 This this DT 42759 2571 2 inquiry inquiry NN 42759 2571 3 will will MD 42759 2571 4 form form VB 42759 2571 5 the the DT 42759 2571 6 subject subject NN 42759 2571 7 of of IN 42759 2571 8 the the DT 42759 2571 9 next next JJ 42759 2571 10 chapter chapter NN 42759 2571 11 . . . 42759 2572 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 2572 2 : : : 42759 2572 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2572 4 133 133 CD 42759 2572 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2572 6 Hohoff Hohoff NNP 42759 2572 7 , , , 42759 2572 8 " " '' 42759 2572 9 Die die VB 42759 2572 10 Bedeutung Bedeutung NNP 42759 2572 11 der der NN 42759 2572 12 Marxschen Marxschen NNP 42759 2572 13 Kapitalkritik Kapitalkritik NNP 42759 2572 14 " " '' 42759 2572 15 ; ; : 42759 2572 16 Paderborn Paderborn NNP 42759 2572 17 , , , 42759 2572 18 1908 1908 CD 42759 2572 19 . . . 42759 2573 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2573 2 134 134 CD 42759 2573 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2573 4 Pp Pp NNP 42759 2573 5 . . . 42759 2574 1 64 64 CD 42759 2574 2 - - SYM 42759 2574 3 67 67 CD 42759 2574 4 , , , 42759 2574 5 88 88 CD 42759 2574 6 , , , 42759 2574 7 89 89 CD 42759 2574 8 , , , 42759 2574 9 96 96 CD 42759 2574 10 . . . 42759 2575 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2575 2 135 135 CD 42759 2575 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2575 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2575 5 . . . 42759 2576 1 Van Van NNP 42759 2576 2 Roey Roey NNP 42759 2576 3 , , , 42759 2576 4 " " `` 42759 2576 5 De De NNP 42759 2576 6 Justo Justo NNP 42759 2576 7 Auctario Auctario NNP 42759 2576 8 ex ex NNP 42759 2576 9 Contractu Contractu NNP 42759 2576 10 Crediti Crediti NNP 42759 2576 11 " " '' 42759 2576 12 ; ; : 42759 2576 13 and and CC 42759 2576 14 Ashley Ashley NNP 42759 2576 15 , , , 42759 2576 16 " " `` 42759 2576 17 English English NNP 42759 2576 18 Economic Economic NNP 42759 2576 19 History history NN 42759 2576 20 . . . 42759 2576 21 " " '' 42759 2577 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2577 2 136 136 CD 42759 2577 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2577 4 Encyclical Encyclical NNP 42759 2577 5 , , , 42759 2577 6 " " '' 42759 2577 7 Vix Vix NNP 42759 2577 8 Pervenit Pervenit NNP 42759 2577 9 , , , 42759 2577 10 " " '' 42759 2577 11 1745 1745 CD 42759 2577 12 . . . 42759 2578 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2578 2 137 137 CD 42759 2578 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2578 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2578 5 . . . 42759 2579 1 St. St. NNP 42759 2579 2 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 2579 3 , , , 42759 2579 4 " " `` 42759 2579 5 Summa Summa NNP 42759 2579 6 Theologica Theologica NNP 42759 2579 7 , , , 42759 2579 8 " " '' 42759 2579 9 2a 2a CD 42759 2579 10 2ae 2ae NNP 42759 2579 11 , , , 42759 2579 12 q. q. NNP 42759 2580 1 78 78 CD 42759 2580 2 , , , 42759 2580 3 a. a. NN 42759 2581 1 2 2 CD 42759 2581 2 et et NN 42759 2581 3 3 3 CD 42759 2581 4 . . . 42759 2582 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2582 2 138 138 CD 42759 2582 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2582 4 " " `` 42759 2582 5 Secunda Secunda NNP 42759 2582 6 Secondae Secondae NNP 42759 2582 7 , , , 42759 2582 8 " " '' 42759 2582 9 q. q. NNP 42759 2583 1 77 77 CD 42759 2583 2 , , , 42759 2583 3 a. a. NN 42759 2584 1 1 1 LS 42759 2584 2 , , , 42759 2584 3 in in IN 42759 2584 4 corp corp NNP 42759 2584 5 . . . 42759 2584 6 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2584 7 139 139 CD 42759 2584 8 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2584 9 " " `` 42759 2584 10 Theologia Theologia NNP 42759 2584 11 Moralis Moralis NNP 42759 2584 12 , , , 42759 2584 13 " " `` 42759 2584 14 I -PRON- PRP 42759 2584 15 , , , 42759 2584 16 no no UH 42759 2584 17 . . . 42759 2585 1 1050 1050 CD 42759 2585 2 . . . 42759 2586 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2586 2 140 140 CD 42759 2586 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2586 4 " " `` 42759 2586 5 What what WP 42759 2586 6 is be VBZ 42759 2586 7 Capital capital NN 42759 2586 8 ? ? . 42759 2586 9 " " '' 42759 2587 1 p. p. NN 42759 2587 2 27 27 CD 42759 2587 3 . . . 42759 2588 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2588 2 141 141 CD 42759 2588 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2588 4 " " `` 42759 2588 5 Political political JJ 42759 2588 6 Economy economy NN 42759 2588 7 , , , 42759 2588 8 " " '' 42759 2588 9 p. p. NN 42759 2588 10 507 507 CD 42759 2588 11 . . . 42759 2589 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 2589 2 XIII xiii NN 42759 2589 3 SOCIAL SOCIAL NNS 42759 2589 4 AND and CC 42759 2589 5 PRESUMPTIVE presumptive NN 42759 2589 6 JUSTIFICATIONS justifications NN 42759 2589 7 OF of IN 42759 2589 8 INTEREST interest NN 42759 2589 9 As as IN 42759 2589 10 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2589 11 saw see VBD 42759 2589 12 in in IN 42759 2589 13 the the DT 42759 2589 14 last last JJ 42759 2589 15 chapter chapter NN 42759 2589 16 , , , 42759 2589 17 interest interest NN 42759 2589 18 can can MD 42759 2589 19 not not RB 42759 2589 20 be be VB 42759 2589 21 conclusively conclusively RB 42759 2589 22 justified justify VBN 42759 2589 23 on on IN 42759 2589 24 the the DT 42759 2589 25 ground ground NN 42759 2589 26 of of IN 42759 2589 27 either either DT 42759 2589 28 productivity productivity NN 42759 2589 29 or or CC 42759 2589 30 service service NN 42759 2589 31 . . . 42759 2590 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2590 2 is be VBZ 42759 2590 3 impossible impossible JJ 42759 2590 4 to to TO 42759 2590 5 demonstrate demonstrate VB 42759 2590 6 that that IN 42759 2590 7 the the DT 42759 2590 8 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2590 9 has have VBZ 42759 2590 10 a a DT 42759 2590 11 strict strict JJ 42759 2590 12 right right NN 42759 2590 13 to to IN 42759 2590 14 interest interest NN 42759 2590 15 because because IN 42759 2590 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2590 17 capital capital NN 42759 2590 18 produces produce VBZ 42759 2590 19 interest interest NN 42759 2590 20 , , , 42759 2590 21 or or CC 42759 2590 22 because because IN 42759 2590 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2590 24 renders render VBZ 42759 2590 25 a a DT 42759 2590 26 service service NN 42759 2590 27 to to IN 42759 2590 28 the the DT 42759 2590 29 labourer labourer NN 42759 2590 30 or or CC 42759 2590 31 the the DT 42759 2590 32 consumer consumer NN 42759 2590 33 . . . 42759 2591 1 A a DT 42759 2591 2 part part NN 42759 2591 3 , , , 42759 2591 4 probably probably RB 42759 2591 5 a a DT 42759 2591 6 small small JJ 42759 2591 7 part part NN 42759 2591 8 , , , 42759 2591 9 of of IN 42759 2591 10 the the DT 42759 2591 11 interest interest NN 42759 2591 12 now now RB 42759 2591 13 received receive VBN 42759 2591 14 can can MD 42759 2591 15 be be VB 42759 2591 16 fairly fairly RB 42759 2591 17 justified justify VBN 42759 2591 18 by by IN 42759 2591 19 the the DT 42759 2591 20 title title NN 42759 2591 21 of of IN 42759 2591 22 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2591 23 . . . 42759 2592 1 Some some DT 42759 2592 2 present present JJ 42759 2592 3 owners owner NNS 42759 2592 4 of of IN 42759 2592 5 capital capital NN 42759 2592 6 would would MD 42759 2592 7 not not RB 42759 2592 8 have have VB 42759 2592 9 saved save VBN 42759 2592 10 had have VBD 42759 2592 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2592 12 not not RB 42759 2592 13 expected expect VBN 42759 2592 14 to to TO 42759 2592 15 receive receive VB 42759 2592 16 interest interest NN 42759 2592 17 . . . 42759 2593 1 In in IN 42759 2593 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2593 3 case case NN 42759 2593 4 interest interest NN 42759 2593 5 may may MD 42759 2593 6 be be VB 42759 2593 7 regarded regard VBN 42759 2593 8 as as IN 42759 2593 9 a a DT 42759 2593 10 just just JJ 42759 2593 11 compensation compensation NN 42759 2593 12 for for IN 42759 2593 13 the the DT 42759 2593 14 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2593 15 that that WDT 42759 2593 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2593 17 underwent undergo VBD 42759 2593 18 when when WRB 42759 2593 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2593 20 decided decide VBD 42759 2593 21 to to TO 42759 2593 22 save save VB 42759 2593 23 instead instead RB 42759 2593 24 of of IN 42759 2593 25 consuming consume VBG 42759 2593 26 . . . 42759 2594 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2594 2 Limitations Limitations NNPS 42759 2594 3 of of IN 42759 2594 4 the the DT 42759 2594 5 Sacrifice Sacrifice NNP 42759 2594 6 Principle Principle NNP 42759 2594 7 _ _ NNP 42759 2594 8 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2594 9 these these DT 42759 2594 10 men man NNS 42759 2594 11 would would MD 42759 2594 12 suffer suffer VB 42759 2594 13 no no DT 42759 2594 14 injustice injustice NN 42759 2594 15 if if IN 42759 2594 16 interest interest NN 42759 2594 17 were be VBD 42759 2594 18 now now RB 42759 2594 19 to to TO 42759 2594 20 be be VB 42759 2594 21 abolished abolish VBN 42759 2594 22 . . . 42759 2595 1 Up up IN 42759 2595 2 to to IN 42759 2595 3 the the DT 42759 2595 4 moment moment NN 42759 2595 5 of of IN 42759 2595 6 the the DT 42759 2595 7 change change NN 42759 2595 8 , , , 42759 2595 9 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2595 10 would would MD 42759 2595 11 have have VB 42759 2595 12 been be VBN 42759 2595 13 in in IN 42759 2595 14 receipt receipt NN 42759 2595 15 of of IN 42759 2595 16 adequate adequate JJ 42759 2595 17 compensation compensation NN 42759 2595 18 ; ; , 42759 2595 19 thereafter thereafter RB 42759 2595 20 , , , 42759 2595 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2595 22 would would MD 42759 2595 23 be be VB 42759 2595 24 in in IN 42759 2595 25 exactly exactly RB 42759 2595 26 the the DT 42759 2595 27 same same JJ 42759 2595 28 position position NN 42759 2595 29 as as IN 42759 2595 30 when when WRB 42759 2595 31 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2595 32 originally originally RB 42759 2595 33 chose choose VBD 42759 2595 34 to to TO 42759 2595 35 save save VB 42759 2595 36 rather rather RB 42759 2595 37 than than IN 42759 2595 38 consume consume VB 42759 2595 39 . . . 42759 2596 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2596 2 would would MD 42759 2596 3 still still RB 42759 2596 4 be be VB 42759 2596 5 able able JJ 42759 2596 6 to to TO 42759 2596 7 sell sell VB 42759 2596 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2596 9 capital capital NN 42759 2596 10 , , , 42759 2596 11 and and CC 42759 2596 12 convert convert VB 42759 2596 13 the the DT 42759 2596 14 proceeds proceed NNS 42759 2596 15 to to IN 42759 2596 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2596 17 immediate immediate JJ 42759 2596 18 uses use NNS 42759 2596 19 and and CC 42759 2596 20 pleasures pleasure NNS 42759 2596 21 . . . 42759 2597 1 In in IN 42759 2597 2 this this DT 42759 2597 3 case case NN 42759 2597 4 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2597 5 would would MD 42759 2597 6 obviously obviously RB 42759 2597 7 have have VB 42759 2597 8 no no DT 42759 2597 9 further further JJ 42759 2597 10 claim claim NN 42759 2597 11 upon upon IN 42759 2597 12 the the DT 42759 2597 13 community community NN 42759 2597 14 for for IN 42759 2597 15 interest interest NN 42759 2597 16 . . . 42759 2598 1 On on IN 42759 2598 2 the the DT 42759 2598 3 other other JJ 42759 2598 4 hand hand NN 42759 2598 5 , , , 42759 2598 6 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2598 7 could could MD 42759 2598 8 retain retain VB 42759 2598 9 the the DT 42759 2598 10 ownership ownership NN 42759 2598 11 of of IN 42759 2598 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2598 13 capital capital NN 42759 2598 14 , , , 42759 2598 15 and and CC 42759 2598 16 postpone postpone VB 42759 2598 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2598 18 consumption consumption NN 42759 2598 19 to to IN 42759 2598 20 some some DT 42759 2598 21 future future JJ 42759 2598 22 time time NN 42759 2598 23 . . . 42759 2599 1 In in IN 42759 2599 2 making make VBG 42759 2599 3 this this DT 42759 2599 4 choice choice NN 42759 2599 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2599 6 would would MD 42759 2599 7 regard regard VB 42759 2599 8 future future NN 42759 2599 9 as as IN 42759 2599 10 more more RBR 42759 2599 11 important important JJ 42759 2599 12 than than IN 42759 2599 13 present present JJ 42759 2599 14 consumption consumption NN 42759 2599 15 , , , 42759 2599 16 and and CC 42759 2599 17 the the DT 42759 2599 18 superiority superiority NN 42759 2599 19 of of IN 42759 2599 20 future future JJ 42759 2599 21 enjoyment enjoyment NN 42759 2599 22 as as IN 42759 2599 23 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 2599 24 great great JJ 42759 2599 25 to to TO 42759 2599 26 compensate compensate VB 42759 2599 27 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2599 28 for for IN 42759 2599 29 the the DT 42759 2599 30 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2599 31 of of IN 42759 2599 32 postponement postponement NN 42759 2599 33 . . . 42759 2600 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2600 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2600 3 would would MD 42759 2600 4 have have VB 42759 2600 5 no no DT 42759 2600 6 moral moral JJ 42759 2600 7 claim claim NN 42759 2600 8 to to IN 42759 2600 9 interest interest NN 42759 2600 10 on on IN 42759 2600 11 the the DT 42759 2600 12 ground ground NN 42759 2600 13 of of IN 42759 2600 14 abstinence abstinence NN 42759 2600 15 . . . 42759 2601 1 In in IN 42759 2601 2 general general JJ 42759 2601 3 , , , 42759 2601 4 then then RB 42759 2601 5 , , , 42759 2601 6 the the DT 42759 2601 7 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2601 8 - - HYPH 42759 2601 9 justification justification NN 42759 2601 10 of of IN 42759 2601 11 interest interest NN 42759 2601 12 continues continue VBZ 42759 2601 13 only only RB 42759 2601 14 so so RB 42759 2601 15 long long RB 42759 2601 16 as as IN 42759 2601 17 the the DT 42759 2601 18 interest interest NN 42759 2601 19 continues continue VBZ 42759 2601 20 . . . 42759 2602 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2602 2 extends extend VBZ 42759 2602 3 only only RB 42759 2602 4 to to IN 42759 2602 5 the the DT 42759 2602 6 interest interest NN 42759 2602 7 received receive VBN 42759 2602 8 by by IN 42759 2602 9 certain certain JJ 42759 2602 10 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 2602 11 in in IN 42759 2602 12 certain certain JJ 42759 2602 13 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 2602 14 , , , 42759 2602 15 not not RB 42759 2602 16 to to IN 42759 2602 17 all all DT 42759 2602 18 interest interest NN 42759 2602 19 in in IN 42759 2602 20 all all DT 42759 2602 21 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 2602 22 . . . 42759 2603 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 2603 2 , , , 42759 2603 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2603 4 presents present VBZ 42759 2603 5 no no DT 42759 2603 6 moral moral JJ 42759 2603 7 obstacle obstacle NN 42759 2603 8 to to IN 42759 2603 9 the the DT 42759 2603 10 complete complete JJ 42759 2603 11 abolition abolition NN 42759 2603 12 of of IN 42759 2603 13 interest interest NN 42759 2603 14 . . . 42759 2604 1 Since since IN 42759 2604 2 probably probably RB 42759 2604 3 the the DT 42759 2604 4 greater great JJR 42759 2604 5 part part NN 42759 2604 6 of of IN 42759 2604 7 the the DT 42759 2604 8 interest interest NN 42759 2604 9 now now RB 42759 2604 10 received receive VBN 42759 2604 11 can can MD 42759 2604 12 not not RB 42759 2604 13 be be VB 42759 2604 14 justified justify VBN 42759 2604 15 on on IN 42759 2604 16 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2604 17 grounds ground NNS 42759 2604 18 , , , 42759 2604 19 and and CC 42759 2604 20 since since IN 42759 2604 21 that that DT 42759 2604 22 part part NN 42759 2604 23 of of IN 42759 2604 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2604 25 which which WDT 42759 2604 26 is be VBZ 42759 2604 27 thus thus RB 42759 2604 28 justified justify VBN 42759 2604 29 could could MD 42759 2604 30 be be VB 42759 2604 31 abolished abolish VBN 42759 2604 32 consistently consistently RB 42759 2604 33 with with IN 42759 2604 34 the the DT 42759 2604 35 rights right NNS 42759 2604 36 of of IN 42759 2604 37 the the DT 42759 2604 38 recipients recipient NNS 42759 2604 39 , , , 42759 2604 40 let let VB 42759 2604 41 us -PRON- PRP 42759 2604 42 see see VB 42759 2604 43 whether whether IN 42759 2604 44 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2604 45 is be VBZ 42759 2604 46 capable capable JJ 42759 2604 47 of of IN 42759 2604 48 justification justification NN 42759 2604 49 for for IN 42759 2604 50 reasons reason NNS 42759 2604 51 of of IN 42759 2604 52 social social JJ 42759 2604 53 welfare welfare NN 42759 2604 54 . . . 42759 2605 1 Would Would MD 42759 2605 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2605 3 suppression suppression NN 42759 2605 4 be be VB 42759 2605 5 socially socially RB 42759 2605 6 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 2605 7 or or CC 42759 2605 8 socially socially RB 42759 2605 9 detrimental detrimental JJ 42759 2605 10 ? ? . 42759 2606 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2606 2 The the DT 42759 2606 3 Value Value NNP 42759 2606 4 of of IN 42759 2606 5 Capital capital NN 42759 2606 6 in in IN 42759 2606 7 a a DT 42759 2606 8 No no DT 42759 2606 9 - - HYPH 42759 2606 10 Interest interest NN 42759 2606 11 Régime Régime NNP 42759 2606 12 _ _ NNP 42759 2606 13 The the DT 42759 2606 14 interest interest NN 42759 2606 15 that that WDT 42759 2606 16 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2606 17 have have VBP 42759 2606 18 in in IN 42759 2606 19 mind mind NN 42759 2606 20 is be VBZ 42759 2606 21 pure pure JJ 42759 2606 22 interest interest NN 42759 2606 23 , , , 42759 2606 24 not not RB 42759 2606 25 undertaker undertaker NNP 42759 2606 26 's 's POS 42759 2606 27 profit profit NN 42759 2606 28 , , , 42759 2606 29 nor nor CC 42759 2606 30 insurance insurance NN 42759 2606 31 against against IN 42759 2606 32 risk risk NN 42759 2606 33 , , , 42759 2606 34 nor nor CC 42759 2606 35 gross gross JJ 42759 2606 36 interest interest NN 42759 2606 37 . . . 42759 2607 1 Even even RB 42759 2607 2 if if IN 42759 2607 3 all all DT 42759 2607 4 pure pure JJ 42759 2607 5 interest interest NN 42759 2607 6 were be VBD 42759 2607 7 abolished abolish VBN 42759 2607 8 the the DT 42759 2607 9 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2607 10 who who WP 42759 2607 11 loaned loan VBD 42759 2607 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2607 13 money money NN 42759 2607 14 would would MD 42759 2607 15 still still RB 42759 2607 16 receive receive VB 42759 2607 17 something something NN 42759 2607 18 from from IN 42759 2607 19 the the DT 42759 2607 20 borrower borrower NN 42759 2607 21 in in IN 42759 2607 22 addition addition NN 42759 2607 23 to to IN 42759 2607 24 the the DT 42759 2607 25 repayment repayment NN 42759 2607 26 of of IN 42759 2607 27 the the DT 42759 2607 28 principal principal NN 42759 2607 29 , , , 42759 2607 30 while while IN 42759 2607 31 the the DT 42759 2607 32 active active JJ 42759 2607 33 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2607 34 would would MD 42759 2607 35 get get VB 42759 2607 36 from from IN 42759 2607 37 the the DT 42759 2607 38 consumer consumer NN 42759 2607 39 more more JJR 42759 2607 40 than than IN 42759 2607 41 the the DT 42759 2607 42 expenses expense NNS 42759 2607 43 of of IN 42759 2607 44 production production NN 42759 2607 45 . . . 42759 2608 1 The the DT 42759 2608 2 former former JJ 42759 2608 3 would would MD 42759 2608 4 require require VB 42759 2608 5 a a DT 42759 2608 6 premium premium NN 42759 2608 7 of of IN 42759 2608 8 , , , 42759 2608 9 say say UH 42759 2608 10 , , , 42759 2608 11 one one CD 42759 2608 12 or or CC 42759 2608 13 two two CD 42759 2608 14 per per NN 42759 2608 15 cent cent NN 42759 2608 16 . . . 42759 2609 1 to to TO 42759 2609 2 protect protect VB 42759 2609 3 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2609 4 against against IN 42759 2609 5 the the DT 42759 2609 6 loss loss NN 42759 2609 7 of of IN 42759 2609 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2609 9 loan loan NN 42759 2609 10 . . . 42759 2610 1 The the DT 42759 2610 2 latter latter JJ 42759 2610 3 would would MD 42759 2610 4 demand demand VB 42759 2610 5 the the DT 42759 2610 6 same same JJ 42759 2610 7 kind kind NN 42759 2610 8 of of IN 42759 2610 9 insurance insurance NN 42759 2610 10 , , , 42759 2610 11 and and CC 42759 2610 12 an an DT 42759 2610 13 additional additional JJ 42759 2610 14 sum sum NN 42759 2610 15 to to TO 42759 2610 16 repay repay VB 42759 2610 17 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2610 18 for for IN 42759 2610 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2610 20 labour labour NN 42759 2610 21 and and CC 42759 2610 22 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 2610 23 . . . 42759 2611 1 None none NN 42759 2611 2 of of IN 42759 2611 3 these these DT 42759 2611 4 payments payment NNS 42759 2611 5 could could MD 42759 2611 6 be be VB 42759 2611 7 avoided avoid VBN 42759 2611 8 in in IN 42759 2611 9 any any DT 42759 2611 10 system system NN 42759 2611 11 of of IN 42759 2611 12 privately privately RB 42759 2611 13 directed direct VBN 42759 2611 14 production production NN 42759 2611 15 . . . 42759 2612 1 The the DT 42759 2612 2 return return NN 42759 2612 3 whose whose WP$ 42759 2612 4 suppression suppression NN 42759 2612 5 is be VBZ 42759 2612 6 considered consider VBN 42759 2612 7 here here RB 42759 2612 8 is be VBZ 42759 2612 9 that that IN 42759 2612 10 which which WDT 42759 2612 11 the the DT 42759 2612 12 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2612 13 receives receive VBZ 42759 2612 14 over over RB 42759 2612 15 and and CC 42759 2612 16 above above IN 42759 2612 17 these these DT 42759 2612 18 payments payment NNS 42759 2612 19 , , , 42759 2612 20 and and CC 42759 2612 21 which which WDT 42759 2612 22 in in IN 42759 2612 23 this this DT 42759 2612 24 country country NN 42759 2612 25 seems seem VBZ 42759 2612 26 to to TO 42759 2612 27 be be VB 42759 2612 28 about about RB 42759 2612 29 three three CD 42759 2612 30 or or CC 42759 2612 31 four four CD 42759 2612 32 per per NN 42759 2612 33 cent cent NN 42759 2612 34 . . . 42759 2613 1 Would Would MD 42759 2613 2 capital capital NN 42759 2613 3 still still RB 42759 2613 4 have have VB 42759 2613 5 value value NN 42759 2613 6 in in IN 42759 2613 7 a a DT 42759 2613 8 no no DT 42759 2613 9 - - HYPH 42759 2613 10 interest interest NN 42759 2613 11 régime régime NN 42759 2613 12 , , , 42759 2613 13 and and CC 42759 2613 14 if if IN 42759 2613 15 so so RB 42759 2613 16 how how WRB 42759 2613 17 would would MD 42759 2613 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2613 19 value value NN 42759 2613 20 be be VB 42759 2613 21 determined determine VBN 42759 2613 22 ? ? . 42759 2614 1 At at IN 42759 2614 2 present present JJ 42759 2614 3 the the DT 42759 2614 4 lower low JJR 42759 2614 5 limit limit NN 42759 2614 6 of of IN 42759 2614 7 the the DT 42759 2614 8 value value NN 42759 2614 9 of of IN 42759 2614 10 productive productive JJ 42759 2614 11 capital capital NN 42759 2614 12 , , , 42759 2614 13 as as IN 42759 2614 14 of of IN 42759 2614 15 all all DT 42759 2614 16 other other JJ 42759 2614 17 artificial artificial JJ 42759 2614 18 goods good NNS 42759 2614 19 , , , 42759 2614 20 is be VBZ 42759 2614 21 fixed fix VBN 42759 2614 22 in in IN 42759 2614 23 the the DT 42759 2614 24 long long JJ 42759 2614 25 run run NN 42759 2614 26 by by IN 42759 2614 27 the the DT 42759 2614 28 cost cost NN 42759 2614 29 of of IN 42759 2614 30 production production NN 42759 2614 31 . . . 42759 2615 1 Capital capital NN 42759 2615 2 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2615 3 that that WDT 42759 2615 4 do do VBP 42759 2615 5 not not RB 42759 2615 6 bring bring VB 42759 2615 7 this this DT 42759 2615 8 price price NN 42759 2615 9 will will MD 42759 2615 10 not not RB 42759 2615 11 continue continue VB 42759 2615 12 to to TO 42759 2615 13 be be VB 42759 2615 14 made make VBN 42759 2615 15 . . . 42759 2616 1 In in IN 42759 2616 2 other other JJ 42759 2616 3 words word NNS 42759 2616 4 , , , 42759 2616 5 cost cost NN 42759 2616 6 of of IN 42759 2616 7 production production NN 42759 2616 8 is be VBZ 42759 2616 9 the the DT 42759 2616 10 governing govern VBG 42759 2616 11 factor factor NN 42759 2616 12 of of IN 42759 2616 13 the the DT 42759 2616 14 value value NN 42759 2616 15 of of IN 42759 2616 16 capital capital NN 42759 2616 17 from from IN 42759 2616 18 the the DT 42759 2616 19 side side NN 42759 2616 20 of of IN 42759 2616 21 supply supply NN 42759 2616 22 . . . 42759 2617 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2617 2 would would MD 42759 2617 3 likewise likewise RB 42759 2617 4 fix fix VB 42759 2617 5 the the DT 42759 2617 6 lower low JJR 42759 2617 7 limit limit NN 42759 2617 8 of of IN 42759 2617 9 value value NN 42759 2617 10 in in IN 42759 2617 11 a a DT 42759 2617 12 no no DT 42759 2617 13 - - HYPH 42759 2617 14 interest interest NN 42759 2617 15 régime régime NN 42759 2617 16 ; ; : 42759 2617 17 only only RB 42759 2617 18 , , , 42759 2617 19 the the DT 42759 2617 20 cost cost NN 42759 2617 21 of of IN 42759 2617 22 producing produce VBG 42759 2617 23 capital capital NN 42759 2617 24 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2617 25 would would MD 42759 2617 26 then then RB 42759 2617 27 be be VB 42759 2617 28 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 2617 29 lower low JJR 42759 2617 30 than than IN 42759 2617 31 to to IN 42759 2617 32 - - HYPH 42759 2617 33 day day NN 42759 2617 34 , , , 42759 2617 35 owing owe VBG 42759 2617 36 to to IN 42759 2617 37 the the DT 42759 2617 38 absence absence NN 42759 2617 39 of of IN 42759 2617 40 an an DT 42759 2617 41 interest interest NN 42759 2617 42 charge charge NN 42759 2617 43 for for IN 42759 2617 44 the the DT 42759 2617 45 working work VBG 42759 2617 46 capital capital NN 42759 2617 47 during during IN 42759 2617 48 the the DT 42759 2617 49 productive productive JJ 42759 2617 50 process process NN 42759 2617 51 . . . 42759 2618 1 But but CC 42759 2618 2 the the DT 42759 2618 3 cost cost NN 42759 2618 4 of of IN 42759 2618 5 production production NN 42759 2618 6 is be VBZ 42759 2618 7 not not RB 42759 2618 8 a a DT 42759 2618 9 constant constant JJ 42759 2618 10 and and CC 42759 2618 11 accurate accurate JJ 42759 2618 12 measure measure NN 42759 2618 13 of of IN 42759 2618 14 the the DT 42759 2618 15 value value NN 42759 2618 16 of of IN 42759 2618 17 artificial artificial JJ 42759 2618 18 capital capital NN 42759 2618 19 . . . 42759 2619 1 The the DT 42759 2619 2 true true JJ 42759 2619 3 measure measure NN 42759 2619 4 is be VBZ 42759 2619 5 found find VBN 42759 2619 6 in in IN 42759 2619 7 the the DT 42759 2619 8 revenue revenue NN 42759 2619 9 or or CC 42759 2619 10 interest interest NN 42759 2619 11 that that WDT 42759 2619 12 a a DT 42759 2619 13 given give VBN 42759 2619 14 piece piece NN 42759 2619 15 of of IN 42759 2619 16 capital capital NN 42759 2619 17 yields yield NNS 42759 2619 18 to to IN 42759 2619 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2619 20 owners owner NNS 42759 2619 21 . . . 42759 2620 1 If if IN 42759 2620 2 the the DT 42759 2620 3 current current JJ 42759 2620 4 rate rate NN 42759 2620 5 of of IN 42759 2620 6 interest interest NN 42759 2620 7 is be VBZ 42759 2620 8 five five CD 42759 2620 9 per per IN 42759 2620 10 cent cent NN 42759 2620 11 . . . 42759 2620 12 , , , 42759 2620 13 a a DT 42759 2620 14 factory factory NN 42759 2620 15 that that WDT 42759 2620 16 brings bring VBZ 42759 2620 17 in in IN 42759 2620 18 ten ten CD 42759 2620 19 thousand thousand CD 42759 2620 20 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2620 21 net net NN 42759 2620 22 return return NN 42759 2620 23 will will MD 42759 2620 24 have have VB 42759 2620 25 a a DT 42759 2620 26 value value NN 42759 2620 27 of of IN 42759 2620 28 about about RB 42759 2620 29 two two CD 42759 2620 30 hundred hundred CD 42759 2620 31 thousand thousand CD 42759 2620 32 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2620 33 . . . 42759 2621 1 This this DT 42759 2621 2 is be VBZ 42759 2621 3 the the DT 42759 2621 4 governing govern VBG 42759 2621 5 factor factor NN 42759 2621 6 of of IN 42759 2621 7 value value NN 42759 2621 8 from from IN 42759 2621 9 the the DT 42759 2621 10 side side NN 42759 2621 11 of of IN 42759 2621 12 demand demand NN 42759 2621 13 . . . 42759 2622 1 In in IN 42759 2622 2 a a DT 42759 2622 3 no no DT 42759 2622 4 - - HYPH 42759 2622 5 interest interest NN 42759 2622 6 economy economy NN 42759 2622 7 the the DT 42759 2622 8 demand demand NN 42759 2622 9 factor factor NN 42759 2622 10 would would MD 42759 2622 11 be be VB 42759 2622 12 quite quite RB 42759 2622 13 different different JJ 42759 2622 14 . . . 42759 2623 1 Capital capital NN 42759 2623 2 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2623 3 would would MD 42759 2623 4 be be VB 42759 2623 5 in in IN 42759 2623 6 demand demand NN 42759 2623 7 , , , 42759 2623 8 not not RB 42759 2623 9 as as IN 42759 2623 10 revenue revenue NN 42759 2623 11 producers producer NNS 42759 2623 12 , , , 42759 2623 13 but but CC 42759 2623 14 as as IN 42759 2623 15 the the DT 42759 2623 16 concrete concrete JJ 42759 2623 17 embodiments embodiment NNS 42759 2623 18 , , , 42759 2623 19 the the DT 42759 2623 20 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 2623 21 requisites requisite NNS 42759 2623 22 of of IN 42759 2623 23 saving saving NN 42759 2623 24 and and CC 42759 2623 25 accumulation accumulation NN 42759 2623 26 . . . 42759 2624 1 For for IN 42759 2624 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2624 3 is be VBZ 42759 2624 4 impossible impossible JJ 42759 2624 5 that that IN 42759 2624 6 saving save VBG 42759 2624 7 should should MD 42759 2624 8 in in IN 42759 2624 9 any any DT 42759 2624 10 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2624 11 amount amount NN 42759 2624 12 take take VB 42759 2624 13 the the DT 42759 2624 14 form form NN 42759 2624 15 of of IN 42759 2624 16 cash cash NN 42759 2624 17 hoards hoard NNS 42759 2624 18 . . . 42759 2625 1 In in IN 42759 2625 2 the the DT 42759 2625 3 words word NNS 42759 2625 4 of of IN 42759 2625 5 Sir Sir NNP 42759 2625 6 Robert Robert NNP 42759 2625 7 Giffen Giffen NNP 42759 2625 8 : : : 42759 2625 9 " " `` 42759 2625 10 The the DT 42759 2625 11 accumulations accumulation NNS 42759 2625 12 of of IN 42759 2625 13 a a DT 42759 2625 14 single single JJ 42759 2625 15 year year NN 42759 2625 16 , , , 42759 2625 17 even even RB 42759 2625 18 taking take VBG 42759 2625 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2625 20 at at IN 42759 2625 21 one one CD 42759 2625 22 hundred hundred CD 42759 2625 23 and and CC 42759 2625 24 fifty fifty CD 42759 2625 25 millions million NNS 42759 2625 26 only only RB 42759 2625 27 , , , 42759 2625 28 ... ... : 42759 2625 29 would would MD 42759 2625 30 absorb absorb VB 42759 2625 31 more more JJR 42759 2625 32 than than IN 42759 2625 33 the the DT 42759 2625 34 entire entire JJ 42759 2625 35 metallic metallic JJ 42759 2625 36 currency currency NN 42759 2625 37 of of IN 42759 2625 38 the the DT 42759 2625 39 country country NN 42759 2625 40 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2625 41 Great Great NNP 42759 2625 42 Britain Britain NNP 42759 2625 43 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2625 44 . . . 42759 2626 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2626 2 can can MD 42759 2626 3 not not RB 42759 2626 4 , , , 42759 2626 5 therefore therefore RB 42759 2626 6 , , , 42759 2626 7 be be VB 42759 2626 8 made make VBN 42759 2626 9 in in IN 42759 2626 10 cash cash NN 42759 2626 11 . . . 42759 2627 1 " " `` 42759 2627 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2627 3 142 142 CD 42759 2627 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2627 5 The the DT 42759 2627 6 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2627 7 of of IN 42759 2627 8 production production NN 42759 2627 9 would would MD 42759 2627 10 be be VB 42759 2627 11 sought seek VBN 42759 2627 12 and and CC 42759 2627 13 valued value VBN 42759 2627 14 by by IN 42759 2627 15 savers saver NNS 42759 2627 16 for for IN 42759 2627 17 the the DT 42759 2627 18 same same JJ 42759 2627 19 reason reason NN 42759 2627 20 that that WDT 42759 2627 21 safes safe VBZ 42759 2627 22 and and CC 42759 2627 23 safety safety NN 42759 2627 24 deposit deposit NN 42759 2627 25 boxes box NNS 42759 2627 26 are be VBP 42759 2627 27 in in IN 42759 2627 28 demand demand NN 42759 2627 29 now now RB 42759 2627 30 . . . 42759 2628 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2628 2 would would MD 42759 2628 3 be be VB 42759 2628 4 the the DT 42759 2628 5 only only JJ 42759 2628 6 means mean NNS 42759 2628 7 of of IN 42759 2628 8 carrying carry VBG 42759 2628 9 savings saving NNS 42759 2628 10 into into IN 42759 2628 11 the the DT 42759 2628 12 future future NN 42759 2628 13 , , , 42759 2628 14 and and CC 42759 2628 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2628 16 would would MD 42759 2628 17 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 2628 18 bring bring VB 42759 2628 19 a a DT 42759 2628 20 price price NN 42759 2628 21 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 2628 22 high high JJ 42759 2628 23 to to TO 42759 2628 24 cover cover VB 42759 2628 25 the the DT 42759 2628 26 cost cost NN 42759 2628 27 of of IN 42759 2628 28 producing produce VBG 42759 2628 29 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2628 30 . . . 42759 2629 1 One one CD 42759 2629 2 man man NN 42759 2629 3 might may MD 42759 2629 4 deposit deposit VB 42759 2629 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2629 6 savings saving NNS 42759 2629 7 in in IN 42759 2629 8 a a DT 42759 2629 9 bank bank NN 42759 2629 10 , , , 42759 2629 11 whence whence NN 42759 2629 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2629 13 would would MD 42759 2629 14 be be VB 42759 2629 15 borrowed borrow VBN 42759 2629 16 without without IN 42759 2629 17 interest interest NN 42759 2629 18 by by IN 42759 2629 19 some some DT 42759 2629 20 director director NN 42759 2629 21 of of IN 42759 2629 22 industry industry NN 42759 2629 23 . . . 42759 2630 1 When when WRB 42759 2630 2 the the DT 42759 2630 3 owner owner NN 42759 2630 4 of of IN 42759 2630 5 the the DT 42759 2630 6 savings saving NNS 42759 2630 7 desired desire VBN 42759 2630 8 to to TO 42759 2630 9 recover recover VB 42759 2630 10 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2630 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2630 12 could could MD 42759 2630 13 obtain obtain VB 42759 2630 14 from from IN 42759 2630 15 the the DT 42759 2630 16 bank bank NN 42759 2630 17 the the DT 42759 2630 18 fund fund NN 42759 2630 19 of of IN 42759 2630 20 some some DT 42759 2630 21 other other JJ 42759 2630 22 depositor depositor NN 42759 2630 23 , , , 42759 2630 24 or or CC 42759 2630 25 get get VB 42759 2630 26 the the DT 42759 2630 27 proceeds proceed NNS 42759 2630 28 of of IN 42759 2630 29 the the DT 42759 2630 30 sale sale NN 42759 2630 31 of of IN 42759 2630 32 the the DT 42759 2630 33 concrete concrete JJ 42759 2630 34 capital capital NN 42759 2630 35 in in IN 42759 2630 36 which which WDT 42759 2630 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2630 38 own own JJ 42759 2630 39 savings saving NNS 42759 2630 40 had have VBD 42759 2630 41 been be VBN 42759 2630 42 embodied embody VBN 42759 2630 43 . . . 42759 2631 1 Another another DT 42759 2631 2 man man NN 42759 2631 3 might may MD 42759 2631 4 prefer prefer VB 42759 2631 5 to to TO 42759 2631 6 invest invest VB 42759 2631 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2631 8 savings saving NNS 42759 2631 9 directly directly RB 42759 2631 10 in in IN 42759 2631 11 a a DT 42759 2631 12 building building NN 42759 2631 13 , , , 42759 2631 14 a a DT 42759 2631 15 machine machine NN 42759 2631 16 , , , 42759 2631 17 or or CC 42759 2631 18 a a DT 42759 2631 19 mercantile mercantile NN 42759 2631 20 business business NN 42759 2631 21 , , , 42759 2631 22 whence whence NN 42759 2631 23 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2631 24 could could MD 42759 2631 25 recover recover VB 42759 2631 26 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2631 27 later later RB 42759 2631 28 from from IN 42759 2631 29 the the DT 42759 2631 30 sale sale NN 42759 2631 31 of of IN 42759 2631 32 the the DT 42759 2631 33 property property NN 42759 2631 34 . . . 42759 2632 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2632 2 the the DT 42759 2632 3 absence absence NN 42759 2632 4 of of IN 42759 2632 5 interest interest NN 42759 2632 6 would would MD 42759 2632 7 not not RB 42759 2632 8 change change VB 42759 2632 9 essentially essentially RB 42759 2632 10 the the DT 42759 2632 11 processes process NNS 42759 2632 12 of of IN 42759 2632 13 saving saving NN 42759 2632 14 or or CC 42759 2632 15 investment investment NN 42759 2632 16 . . . 42759 2633 1 Capital capital NN 42759 2633 2 would would MD 42759 2633 3 still still RB 42759 2633 4 have have VB 42759 2633 5 value value NN 42759 2633 6 , , , 42759 2633 7 but but CC 42759 2633 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2633 9 valuation valuation NN 42759 2633 10 from from IN 42759 2633 11 the the DT 42759 2633 12 demand demand NN 42759 2633 13 side side NN 42759 2633 14 would would MD 42759 2633 15 rest rest VB 42759 2633 16 on on IN 42759 2633 17 a a DT 42759 2633 18 different different JJ 42759 2633 19 basis basis NN 42759 2633 20 . . . 42759 2634 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2634 2 would would MD 42759 2634 3 be be VB 42759 2634 4 valued value VBN 42759 2634 5 not not RB 42759 2634 6 in in IN 42759 2634 7 proportion proportion NN 42759 2634 8 to to IN 42759 2634 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2634 10 power power NN 42759 2634 11 to to TO 42759 2634 12 yield yield VB 42759 2634 13 interest interest NN 42759 2634 14 , , , 42759 2634 15 but but CC 42759 2634 16 because because IN 42759 2634 17 of of IN 42759 2634 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2634 19 capacity capacity NN 42759 2634 20 to to TO 42759 2634 21 become become VB 42759 2634 22 a a DT 42759 2634 23 receptacle receptacle NN 42759 2634 24 for for IN 42759 2634 25 savings saving NNS 42759 2634 26 , , , 42759 2634 27 and and CC 42759 2634 28 to to TO 42759 2634 29 carry carry VB 42759 2634 30 into into IN 42759 2634 31 the the DT 42759 2634 32 future future NN 42759 2634 33 the the DT 42759 2634 34 consuming consume VBG 42759 2634 35 power power NN 42759 2634 36 of of IN 42759 2634 37 the the DT 42759 2634 38 present present NN 42759 2634 39 . . . 42759 2635 1 The the DT 42759 2635 2 question question NN 42759 2635 3 whether whether IN 42759 2635 4 the the DT 42759 2635 5 abolition abolition NN 42759 2635 6 of of IN 42759 2635 7 interest interest NN 42759 2635 8 by by IN 42759 2635 9 the the DT 42759 2635 10 State State NNP 42759 2635 11 would would MD 42759 2635 12 be be VB 42759 2635 13 socially socially RB 42759 2635 14 helpful helpful JJ 42759 2635 15 or or CC 42759 2635 16 socially socially RB 42759 2635 17 harmful harmful JJ 42759 2635 18 is be VBZ 42759 2635 19 mainly mainly RB 42759 2635 20 , , , 42759 2635 21 though though IN 42759 2635 22 not not RB 42759 2635 23 entirely entirely RB 42759 2635 24 , , , 42759 2635 25 a a DT 42759 2635 26 question question NN 42759 2635 27 of of IN 42759 2635 28 the the DT 42759 2635 29 supply supply NN 42759 2635 30 of of IN 42759 2635 31 capital capital NN 42759 2635 32 . . . 42759 2636 1 If if IN 42759 2636 2 the the DT 42759 2636 3 community community NN 42759 2636 4 would would MD 42759 2636 5 not not RB 42759 2636 6 have have VB 42759 2636 7 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2636 8 capital capital NN 42759 2636 9 to to TO 42759 2636 10 provide provide VB 42759 2636 11 for for IN 42759 2636 12 all all DT 42759 2636 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2636 14 needs need NNS 42759 2636 15 , , , 42759 2636 16 actual actual JJ 42759 2636 17 and and CC 42759 2636 18 progressive progressive JJ 42759 2636 19 , , , 42759 2636 20 the the DT 42759 2636 21 suppression suppression NN 42759 2636 22 of of IN 42759 2636 23 interest interest NN 42759 2636 24 would would MD 42759 2636 25 obviously obviously RB 42759 2636 26 be be VB 42759 2636 27 a a DT 42759 2636 28 bad bad JJ 42759 2636 29 policy policy NN 42759 2636 30 . . . 42759 2637 1 Most Most JJS 42759 2637 2 economists economist NNS 42759 2637 3 seem seem VBP 42759 2637 4 inclined inclined JJ 42759 2637 5 to to TO 42759 2637 6 think think VB 42759 2637 7 that that IN 42759 2637 8 this this DT 42759 2637 9 condition condition NN 42759 2637 10 would would MD 42759 2637 11 be be VB 42759 2637 12 realised realise VBN 42759 2637 13 ; ; : 42759 2637 14 that that IN 42759 2637 15 , , , 42759 2637 16 without without IN 42759 2637 17 the the DT 42759 2637 18 inducement inducement NN 42759 2637 19 of of IN 42759 2637 20 interest interest NN 42759 2637 21 , , , 42759 2637 22 men man NNS 42759 2637 23 would would MD 42759 2637 24 neither neither CC 42759 2637 25 make make VB 42759 2637 26 new new JJ 42759 2637 27 savings saving NNS 42759 2637 28 nor nor CC 42759 2637 29 conserve conserve VB 42759 2637 30 existing exist VBG 42759 2637 31 capital capital NN 42759 2637 32 in in IN 42759 2637 33 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2637 34 quantity quantity NN 42759 2637 35 to to TO 42759 2637 36 supply supply VB 42759 2637 37 the the DT 42759 2637 38 wants want NNS 42759 2637 39 of of IN 42759 2637 40 society society NN 42759 2637 41 . . . 42759 2638 1 Very very RB 42759 2638 2 few few JJ 42759 2638 3 of of IN 42759 2638 4 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2638 5 , , , 42759 2638 6 however however RB 42759 2638 7 , , , 42759 2638 8 pretend pretend VBP 42759 2638 9 to to TO 42759 2638 10 be be VB 42759 2638 11 able able JJ 42759 2638 12 to to TO 42759 2638 13 prove prove VB 42759 2638 14 this this DT 42759 2638 15 proposition proposition NN 42759 2638 16 . . . 42759 2639 1 So so RB 42759 2639 2 many many JJ 42759 2639 3 complex complex JJ 42759 2639 4 factors factor NNS 42759 2639 5 with with IN 42759 2639 6 regard regard NN 42759 2639 7 to to IN 42759 2639 8 the the DT 42759 2639 9 possibilities possibility NNS 42759 2639 10 of of IN 42759 2639 11 saving saving NN 42759 2639 12 and and CC 42759 2639 13 the the DT 42759 2639 14 motives motive NNS 42759 2639 15 of of IN 42759 2639 16 savers saver NNS 42759 2639 17 , , , 42759 2639 18 enter enter VB 42759 2639 19 into into IN 42759 2639 20 the the DT 42759 2639 21 situation situation NN 42759 2639 22 that that IN 42759 2639 23 no no DT 42759 2639 24 opinion opinion NN 42759 2639 25 on on IN 42759 2639 26 the the DT 42759 2639 27 subject subject NN 42759 2639 28 can can MD 42759 2639 29 have have VB 42759 2639 30 any any DT 42759 2639 31 stronger strong JJR 42759 2639 32 basis basis NN 42759 2639 33 than than IN 42759 2639 34 probability probability NN 42759 2639 35 . . . 42759 2640 1 As as IN 42759 2640 2 a a DT 42759 2640 3 preliminary preliminary NN 42759 2640 4 to to IN 42759 2640 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2640 6 consideration consideration NN 42759 2640 7 of of IN 42759 2640 8 the the DT 42759 2640 9 question question NN 42759 2640 10 of of IN 42759 2640 11 abolition abolition NN 42759 2640 12 , , , 42759 2640 13 let let VB 42759 2640 14 us -PRON- PRP 42759 2640 15 inquire inquire VB 42759 2640 16 whether whether IN 42759 2640 17 there there EX 42759 2640 18 exists exist VBZ 42759 2640 19 any any DT 42759 2640 20 definite definite JJ 42759 2640 21 relation relation NN 42759 2640 22 between between IN 42759 2640 23 the the DT 42759 2640 24 present present JJ 42759 2640 25 supply supply NN 42759 2640 26 of of IN 42759 2640 27 capital capital NN 42759 2640 28 and and CC 42759 2640 29 the the DT 42759 2640 30 current current JJ 42759 2640 31 rate rate NN 42759 2640 32 of of IN 42759 2640 33 interest interest NN 42759 2640 34 . . . 42759 2641 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2641 2 Whether Whether NNP 42759 2641 3 the the DT 42759 2641 4 Present Present NNP 42759 2641 5 Rate Rate NNP 42759 2641 6 of of IN 42759 2641 7 Interest interest NN 42759 2641 8 Is be VBZ 42759 2641 9 Necessary necessary JJ 42759 2641 10 _ _ IN 42759 2641 11 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2641 12 is be VBZ 42759 2641 13 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 2641 14 contended contend VBN 42759 2641 15 that that IN 42759 2641 16 the the DT 42759 2641 17 interest interest NN 42759 2641 18 rate rate NN 42759 2641 19 must must MD 42759 2641 20 be be VB 42759 2641 21 kept keep VBN 42759 2641 22 up up RP 42759 2641 23 to to IN 42759 2641 24 the the DT 42759 2641 25 present present JJ 42759 2641 26 level level NN 42759 2641 27 if if IN 42759 2641 28 the the DT 42759 2641 29 existing exist VBG 42759 2641 30 supply supply NN 42759 2641 31 of of IN 42759 2641 32 capital capital NN 42759 2641 33 is be VBZ 42759 2641 34 to to TO 42759 2641 35 be be VB 42759 2641 36 maintained maintain VBN 42759 2641 37 . . . 42759 2642 1 The the DT 42759 2642 2 underlying underlie VBG 42759 2642 3 assumption assumption NN 42759 2642 4 is be VBZ 42759 2642 5 that that IN 42759 2642 6 some some DT 42759 2642 7 of of IN 42759 2642 8 the the DT 42759 2642 9 present present JJ 42759 2642 10 savers saver NNS 42759 2642 11 would would MD 42759 2642 12 discontinue discontinue VB 42759 2642 13 that that DT 42759 2642 14 function function NN 42759 2642 15 at at IN 42759 2642 16 any any DT 42759 2642 17 lower low JJR 42759 2642 18 rate rate NN 42759 2642 19 , , , 42759 2642 20 with with IN 42759 2642 21 the the DT 42759 2642 22 consequence consequence NN 42759 2642 23 that that IN 42759 2642 24 the the DT 42759 2642 25 supply supply NN 42759 2642 26 of of IN 42759 2642 27 capital capital NN 42759 2642 28 would would MD 42759 2642 29 fall fall VB 42759 2642 30 below below IN 42759 2642 31 the the DT 42759 2642 32 demand demand NN 42759 2642 33 . . . 42759 2643 1 Owing owe VBG 42759 2643 2 to to IN 42759 2643 3 this this DT 42759 2643 4 excess excess NN 42759 2643 5 of of IN 42759 2643 6 demand demand NN 42759 2643 7 over over IN 42759 2643 8 supply supply NN 42759 2643 9 , , , 42759 2643 10 the the DT 42759 2643 11 rate rate NN 42759 2643 12 of of IN 42759 2643 13 interest interest NN 42759 2643 14 would would MD 42759 2643 15 rise rise VB 42759 2643 16 , , , 42759 2643 17 or or CC 42759 2643 18 tend tend VBP 42759 2643 19 to to TO 42759 2643 20 rise rise VB 42759 2643 21 , , , 42759 2643 22 to to IN 42759 2643 23 the the DT 42759 2643 24 former former JJ 42759 2643 25 level level NN 42759 2643 26 . . . 42759 2644 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 2644 2 , , , 42759 2644 3 the the DT 42759 2644 4 rate rate NN 42759 2644 5 existing exist VBG 42759 2644 6 at at IN 42759 2644 7 any any DT 42759 2644 8 given give VBN 42759 2644 9 time time NN 42759 2644 10 is be VBZ 42759 2644 11 the the DT 42759 2644 12 socially socially RB 42759 2644 13 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2644 14 rate rate NN 42759 2644 15 . . . 42759 2645 1 The the DT 42759 2645 2 rate rate NN 42759 2645 3 of of IN 42759 2645 4 interest interest NN 42759 2645 5 is be VBZ 42759 2645 6 said say VBN 42759 2645 7 to to TO 42759 2645 8 be be VB 42759 2645 9 analogous analogous JJ 42759 2645 10 to to IN 42759 2645 11 the the DT 42759 2645 12 rate rate NN 42759 2645 13 of of IN 42759 2645 14 wages wage NNS 42759 2645 15 . . . 42759 2646 1 For for IN 42759 2646 2 example example NN 42759 2646 3 ; ; : 42759 2646 4 of of IN 42759 2646 5 ten ten CD 42759 2646 6 thousand thousand CD 42759 2646 7 men man NNS 42759 2646 8 receiving receive VBG 42759 2646 9 five five CD 42759 2646 10 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2646 11 a a DT 42759 2646 12 day day NN 42759 2646 13 , , , 42759 2646 14 nine nine CD 42759 2646 15 thousand thousand CD 42759 2646 16 may may MD 42759 2646 17 be be VB 42759 2646 18 willing willing JJ 42759 2646 19 to to TO 42759 2646 20 work work VB 42759 2646 21 for for IN 42759 2646 22 four four CD 42759 2646 23 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2646 24 rather rather RB 42759 2646 25 than than IN 42759 2646 26 quit quit VB 42759 2646 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2646 28 present present JJ 42759 2646 29 jobs job NNS 42759 2646 30 . . . 42759 2647 1 But but CC 42759 2647 2 the the DT 42759 2647 3 other other JJ 42759 2647 4 thousand thousand CD 42759 2647 5 set set VBD 42759 2647 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2647 7 minimum minimum JJ 42759 2647 8 price price NN 42759 2647 9 at at IN 42759 2647 10 five five CD 42759 2647 11 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2647 12 . . . 42759 2648 1 If if IN 42759 2648 2 the the DT 42759 2648 3 wage wage NN 42759 2648 4 is be VBZ 42759 2648 5 reduced reduce VBN 42759 2648 6 to to IN 42759 2648 7 four four CD 42759 2648 8 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2648 9 these these DT 42759 2648 10 men man NNS 42759 2648 11 will will MD 42759 2648 12 get get VB 42759 2648 13 employment employment NN 42759 2648 14 elsewhere elsewhere RB 42759 2648 15 , , , 42759 2648 16 thus thus RB 42759 2648 17 causing cause VBG 42759 2648 18 such such PDT 42759 2648 19 an an DT 42759 2648 20 excess excess NN 42759 2648 21 of of IN 42759 2648 22 demand demand NN 42759 2648 23 over over IN 42759 2648 24 supply supply NN 42759 2648 25 as as IN 42759 2648 26 to to TO 42759 2648 27 force force VB 42759 2648 28 the the DT 42759 2648 29 wage wage NN 42759 2648 30 rate rate NN 42759 2648 31 back back RB 42759 2648 32 to to IN 42759 2648 33 five five CD 42759 2648 34 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2648 35 . . . 42759 2649 1 The the DT 42759 2649 2 same same JJ 42759 2649 3 thing thing NN 42759 2649 4 , , , 42759 2649 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2649 6 is be VBZ 42759 2649 7 contended contend VBN 42759 2649 8 , , , 42759 2649 9 will will MD 42759 2649 10 happen happen VB 42759 2649 11 when when WRB 42759 2649 12 the the DT 42759 2649 13 high high RB 42759 2649 14 - - HYPH 42759 2649 15 priced price VBN 42759 2649 16 section section NN 42759 2649 17 of of IN 42759 2649 18 the the DT 42759 2649 19 savers saver NNS 42759 2649 20 , , , 42759 2649 21 " " '' 42759 2649 22 the the DT 42759 2649 23 marginal marginal JJ 42759 2649 24 savers saver NNS 42759 2649 25 , , , 42759 2649 26 " " `` 42759 2649 27 discontinue discontinue NN 42759 2649 28 saving save VBG 42759 2649 29 on on IN 42759 2649 30 account account NN 42759 2649 31 of of IN 42759 2649 32 the the DT 42759 2649 33 artificial artificial JJ 42759 2649 34 lowering lowering NN 42759 2649 35 of of IN 42759 2649 36 the the DT 42759 2649 37 rate rate NN 42759 2649 38 of of IN 42759 2649 39 interest interest NN 42759 2649 40 . . . 42759 2650 1 The the DT 42759 2650 2 analogy analogy NN 42759 2650 3 , , , 42759 2650 4 however however RB 42759 2650 5 , , , 42759 2650 6 is be VBZ 42759 2650 7 misleading mislead VBG 42759 2650 8 . . . 42759 2651 1 The the DT 42759 2651 2 " " `` 42759 2651 3 marginal marginal JJ 42759 2651 4 " " '' 42759 2651 5 one one CD 42759 2651 6 thousand thousand CD 42759 2651 7 wage wage NN 42759 2651 8 earners earner NNS 42759 2651 9 refuse refuse VBP 42759 2651 10 to to TO 42759 2651 11 work work VB 42759 2651 12 for for IN 42759 2651 13 four four CD 42759 2651 14 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2651 15 a a DT 42759 2651 16 day day NN 42759 2651 17 because because IN 42759 2651 18 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2651 19 can can MD 42759 2651 20 get get VB 42759 2651 21 better well JJR 42759 2651 22 compensation compensation NN 42759 2651 23 in in IN 42759 2651 24 some some DT 42759 2651 25 other other JJ 42759 2651 26 occupation occupation NN 42759 2651 27 . . . 42759 2652 1 This this DT 42759 2652 2 phenomenon phenomenon NN 42759 2652 3 has have VBZ 42759 2652 4 been be VBN 42759 2652 5 proved prove VBN 42759 2652 6 over over RB 42759 2652 7 and and CC 42759 2652 8 over over RB 42759 2652 9 again again RB 42759 2652 10 by by IN 42759 2652 11 observation observation NN 42759 2652 12 and and CC 42759 2652 13 experience experience NN 42759 2652 14 . . . 42759 2653 1 On on IN 42759 2653 2 the the DT 42759 2653 3 other other JJ 42759 2653 4 hand hand NN 42759 2653 5 , , , 42759 2653 6 there there EX 42759 2653 7 is be VBZ 42759 2653 8 no no DT 42759 2653 9 experience experience NN 42759 2653 10 , , , 42759 2653 11 no no DT 42759 2653 12 positive positive JJ 42759 2653 13 evidence evidence NN 42759 2653 14 , , , 42759 2653 15 which which WDT 42759 2653 16 shows show VBZ 42759 2653 17 or or CC 42759 2653 18 tends tend VBZ 42759 2653 19 to to TO 42759 2653 20 show show VB 42759 2653 21 that that IN 42759 2653 22 any any DT 42759 2653 23 _ _ NNP 42759 2653 24 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2653 25 _ _ NNP 42759 2653 26 group group NN 42759 2653 27 of of IN 42759 2653 28 present present JJ 42759 2653 29 savers saver NNS 42759 2653 30 would would MD 42759 2653 31 discontinue discontinue VB 42759 2653 32 or or CC 42759 2653 33 materially materially RB 42759 2653 34 reduce reduce VB 42759 2653 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2653 36 accumulations accumulation NNS 42759 2653 37 if if IN 42759 2653 38 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2653 39 were be VBD 42759 2653 40 no no RB 42759 2653 41 longer long RBR 42759 2653 42 able able JJ 42759 2653 43 to to TO 42759 2653 44 secure secure VB 42759 2653 45 the the DT 42759 2653 46 present present JJ 42759 2653 47 rate rate NN 42759 2653 48 of of IN 42759 2653 49 interest interest NN 42759 2653 50 . . . 42759 2654 1 If if IN 42759 2654 2 the the DT 42759 2654 3 rate rate NN 42759 2654 4 were be VBD 42759 2654 5 lowered lower VBN 42759 2654 6 simultaneously simultaneously RB 42759 2654 7 in in IN 42759 2654 8 all all DT 42759 2654 9 civilised civilised JJ 42759 2654 10 countries country NNS 42759 2654 11 the the DT 42759 2654 12 dissatisfied dissatisfied JJ 42759 2654 13 savers saver NNS 42759 2654 14 , , , 42759 2654 15 unlike unlike IN 42759 2654 16 the the DT 42759 2654 17 dissatisfied dissatisfied JJ 42759 2654 18 labourers labourer NNS 42759 2654 19 , , , 42759 2654 20 would would MD 42759 2654 21 not not RB 42759 2654 22 be be VB 42759 2654 23 able able JJ 42759 2654 24 to to TO 42759 2654 25 get get VB 42759 2654 26 a a DT 42759 2654 27 better well JJR 42759 2654 28 price price NN 42759 2654 29 for for IN 42759 2654 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2654 31 capital capital NN 42759 2654 32 elsewhere elsewhere RB 42759 2654 33 . . . 42759 2655 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2655 2 only only JJ 42759 2655 3 alternative alternative NN 42759 2655 4 would would MD 42759 2655 5 be be VB 42759 2655 6 to to TO 42759 2655 7 spend spend VB 42759 2655 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2655 9 actual actual JJ 42759 2655 10 or or CC 42759 2655 11 potential potential JJ 42759 2655 12 savings saving NNS 42759 2655 13 for for IN 42759 2655 14 present present JJ 42759 2655 15 enjoyment enjoyment NN 42759 2655 16 . . . 42759 2656 1 Now now RB 42759 2656 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2656 3 have have VBP 42759 2656 4 no no DT 42759 2656 5 empirical empirical JJ 42759 2656 6 data datum NNS 42759 2656 7 to to TO 42759 2656 8 justify justify VB 42759 2656 9 the the DT 42759 2656 10 assumption assumption NN 42759 2656 11 that that IN 42759 2656 12 any any DT 42759 2656 13 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2656 14 number number NN 42759 2656 15 of of IN 42759 2656 16 savers saver NNS 42759 2656 17 would would MD 42759 2656 18 choose choose VB 42759 2656 19 this this DT 42759 2656 20 alternative alternative NN 42759 2656 21 in in IN 42759 2656 22 preference preference NN 42759 2656 23 to to IN 42759 2656 24 , , , 42759 2656 25 say say VB 42759 2656 26 , , , 42759 2656 27 three three CD 42759 2656 28 or or CC 42759 2656 29 two two CD 42759 2656 30 per per NN 42759 2656 31 cent cent NN 42759 2656 32 . . . 42759 2657 1 interest interest NN 42759 2657 2 . . . 42759 2658 1 The the DT 42759 2658 2 fact fact NN 42759 2658 3 that that IN 42759 2658 4 any any DT 42759 2658 5 group group NN 42759 2658 6 of of IN 42759 2658 7 savers saver NNS 42759 2658 8 at at IN 42759 2658 9 present present JJ 42759 2658 10 gets get VBZ 42759 2658 11 and and CC 42759 2658 12 insists insist VBZ 42759 2658 13 on on IN 42759 2658 14 getting get VBG 42759 2658 15 a a DT 42759 2658 16 higher high JJR 42759 2658 17 rate rate NN 42759 2658 18 , , , 42759 2658 19 merely merely RB 42759 2658 20 proves prove VBZ 42759 2658 21 that that IN 42759 2658 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2658 23 can can MD 42759 2658 24 get get VB 42759 2658 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2658 26 , , , 42759 2658 27 and and CC 42759 2658 28 that that IN 42759 2658 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2658 30 are be VBP 42759 2658 31 selfish selfish JJ 42759 2658 32 enough enough RB 42759 2658 33 to to TO 42759 2658 34 take take VB 42759 2658 35 advantage advantage NN 42759 2658 36 of of IN 42759 2658 37 the the DT 42759 2658 38 possibility possibility NN 42759 2658 39 . . . 42759 2659 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 2659 2 know know VBP 42759 2659 3 that that IN 42759 2659 4 some some DT 42759 2659 5 men man NNS 42759 2659 6 who who WP 42759 2659 7 now now RB 42759 2659 8 obtain obtain VBP 42759 2659 9 six six CD 42759 2659 10 per per IN 42759 2659 11 cent cent NN 42759 2659 12 . . . 42759 2660 1 interest interest NN 42759 2660 2 would would MD 42759 2660 3 accept accept VB 42759 2660 4 two two CD 42759 2660 5 rather rather RB 42759 2660 6 than than IN 42759 2660 7 cease cease VB 42759 2660 8 to to TO 42759 2660 9 save save VB 42759 2660 10 ; ; : 42759 2660 11 yet yet CC 42759 2660 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2660 13 do do VBP 42759 2660 14 not not RB 42759 2660 15 hesitate hesitate VB 42759 2660 16 to to TO 42759 2660 17 demand demand VB 42759 2660 18 six six CD 42759 2660 19 per per IN 42759 2660 20 cent cent NN 42759 2660 21 . . . 42759 2661 1 So so RB 42759 2661 2 far far RB 42759 2661 3 as as IN 42759 2661 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2661 5 know know VBP 42759 2661 6 , , , 42759 2661 7 all all DT 42759 2661 8 present present JJ 42759 2661 9 savers saver NNS 42759 2661 10 might may MD 42759 2661 11 take take VB 42759 2661 12 the the DT 42759 2661 13 same same JJ 42759 2661 14 attitude attitude NN 42759 2661 15 . . . 42759 2662 1 At at IN 42759 2662 2 any any DT 42759 2662 3 rate rate NN 42759 2662 4 , , , 42759 2662 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2662 6 can can MD 42759 2662 7 not not RB 42759 2662 8 conclude conclude VB 42759 2662 9 that that IN 42759 2662 10 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2662 11 would would MD 42759 2662 12 not not RB 42759 2662 13 take take VB 42759 2662 14 less less JJR 42759 2662 15 from from IN 42759 2662 16 the the DT 42759 2662 17 fact fact NN 42759 2662 18 that that IN 42759 2662 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2662 20 now now RB 42759 2662 21 get get VBP 42759 2662 22 more more JJR 42759 2662 23 . . . 42759 2663 1 Why why WRB 42759 2663 2 then then RB 42759 2663 3 does do VBZ 42759 2663 4 not not RB 42759 2663 5 the the DT 42759 2663 6 rate rate NN 42759 2663 7 of of IN 42759 2663 8 interest interest NN 42759 2663 9 fall fall NN 42759 2663 10 ? ? . 42759 2664 1 If if IN 42759 2664 2 all all DT 42759 2664 3 present present JJ 42759 2664 4 savers saver NNS 42759 2664 5 are be VBP 42759 2664 6 getting get VBG 42759 2664 7 a a DT 42759 2664 8 higher high JJR 42759 2664 9 rate rate NN 42759 2664 10 than than IN 42759 2664 11 is be VBZ 42759 2664 12 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2664 13 to to TO 42759 2664 14 induce induce VB 42759 2664 15 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2664 16 to to TO 42759 2664 17 save save VB 42759 2664 18 , , , 42759 2664 19 why why WRB 42759 2664 20 do do VBP 42759 2664 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2664 22 not not RB 42759 2664 23 increase increase VB 42759 2664 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2664 25 savings saving NNS 42759 2664 26 to to IN 42759 2664 27 such such PDT 42759 2664 28 an an DT 42759 2664 29 extent extent NN 42759 2664 30 that that IN 42759 2664 31 the the DT 42759 2664 32 supply supply NN 42759 2664 33 of of IN 42759 2664 34 capital capital NN 42759 2664 35 will will MD 42759 2664 36 exceed exceed VB 42759 2664 37 the the DT 42759 2664 38 present present JJ 42759 2664 39 volume volume NN 42759 2664 40 of of IN 42759 2664 41 demand demand NN 42759 2664 42 , , , 42759 2664 43 and and CC 42759 2664 44 thus thus RB 42759 2664 45 lead lead VB 42759 2664 46 to to IN 42759 2664 47 a a DT 42759 2664 48 decline decline NN 42759 2664 49 in in IN 42759 2664 50 the the DT 42759 2664 51 rate rate NN 42759 2664 52 of of IN 42759 2664 53 interest interest NN 42759 2664 54 ? ? . 42759 2665 1 This this DT 42759 2665 2 is be VBZ 42759 2665 3 what what WP 42759 2665 4 happens happen VBZ 42759 2665 5 when when WRB 42759 2665 6 the the DT 42759 2665 7 price price NN 42759 2665 8 of of IN 42759 2665 9 consumption consumption NN 42759 2665 10 - - HYPH 42759 2665 11 goods good NNS 42759 2665 12 rises rise VBZ 42759 2665 13 appreciably appreciably RB 42759 2665 14 above above IN 42759 2665 15 the the DT 42759 2665 16 minimum minimum JJ 42759 2665 17 level level NN 42759 2665 18 that that WDT 42759 2665 19 satisfies satisfy VBZ 42759 2665 20 the the DT 42759 2665 21 most most RBS 42759 2665 22 high high RB 42759 2665 23 - - HYPH 42759 2665 24 priced price VBN 42759 2665 25 or or CC 42759 2665 26 " " `` 42759 2665 27 marginal marginal JJ 42759 2665 28 " " '' 42759 2665 29 producers producer NNS 42759 2665 30 . . . 42759 2666 1 There there EX 42759 2666 2 is be VBZ 42759 2666 3 , , , 42759 2666 4 however however RB 42759 2666 5 , , , 42759 2666 6 an an DT 42759 2666 7 important important JJ 42759 2666 8 difference difference NN 42759 2666 9 between between IN 42759 2666 10 the the DT 42759 2666 11 two two CD 42759 2666 12 cases case NNS 42759 2666 13 . . . 42759 2667 1 The the DT 42759 2667 2 capacity capacity NN 42759 2667 3 to to TO 42759 2667 4 produce produce VB 42759 2667 5 more more JJR 42759 2667 6 goods good NNS 42759 2667 7 is be VBZ 42759 2667 8 practically practically RB 42759 2667 9 unlimited unlimited JJ 42759 2667 10 , , , 42759 2667 11 and and CC 42759 2667 12 the the DT 42759 2667 13 corresponding corresponding JJ 42759 2667 14 desire desire NN 42759 2667 15 is be VBZ 42759 2667 16 also also RB 42759 2667 17 unlimited unlimited JJ 42759 2667 18 , , , 42759 2667 19 so so RB 42759 2667 20 long long RB 42759 2667 21 as as IN 42759 2667 22 the the DT 42759 2667 23 price price NN 42759 2667 24 of of IN 42759 2667 25 the the DT 42759 2667 26 product product NN 42759 2667 27 exceeds exceed VBZ 42759 2667 28 the the DT 42759 2667 29 cost cost NN 42759 2667 30 of of IN 42759 2667 31 production production NN 42759 2667 32 . . . 42759 2668 1 The the DT 42759 2668 2 capacity capacity NN 42759 2668 3 to to TO 42759 2668 4 save save VB 42759 2668 5 is be VBZ 42759 2668 6 not not RB 42759 2668 7 unlimited unlimited JJ 42759 2668 8 , , , 42759 2668 9 and and CC 42759 2668 10 the the DT 42759 2668 11 desire desire NN 42759 2668 12 to to TO 42759 2668 13 save save VB 42759 2668 14 is be VBZ 42759 2668 15 neutralised neutralise VBN 42759 2668 16 and and CC 42759 2668 17 sharply sharply RB 42759 2668 18 restricted restrict VBN 42759 2668 19 by by IN 42759 2668 20 other other JJ 42759 2668 21 and and CC 42759 2668 22 more more RBR 42759 2668 23 powerful powerful JJ 42759 2668 24 desires desire NNS 42759 2668 25 . . . 42759 2669 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2669 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2669 3 is be VBZ 42759 2669 4 quite quite RB 42759 2669 5 possible possible JJ 42759 2669 6 that that IN 42759 2669 7 the the DT 42759 2669 8 price price NN 42759 2669 9 of of IN 42759 2669 10 capital capital NN 42759 2669 11 , , , 42759 2669 12 i.e. i.e. FW 42759 2669 13 , , , 42759 2669 14 interest interest NN 42759 2669 15 , , , 42759 2669 16 is be VBZ 42759 2669 17 determined determine VBN 42759 2669 18 to to IN 42759 2669 19 only only RB 42759 2669 20 a a DT 42759 2669 21 slight slight JJ 42759 2669 22 degree degree NN 42759 2669 23 by by IN 42759 2669 24 the the DT 42759 2669 25 " " `` 42759 2669 26 cost cost NN 42759 2669 27 " " '' 42759 2669 28 of of IN 42759 2669 29 saving saving NN 42759 2669 30 , , , 42759 2669 31 being be VBG 42759 2669 32 mainly mainly RB 42759 2669 33 dominated dominate VBN 42759 2669 34 and and CC 42759 2669 35 regulated regulate VBN 42759 2669 36 from from IN 42759 2669 37 the the DT 42759 2669 38 side side NN 42759 2669 39 of of IN 42759 2669 40 demand demand NN 42759 2669 41 . . . 42759 2670 1 Even even RB 42759 2670 2 though though IN 42759 2670 3 many many JJ 42759 2670 4 of of IN 42759 2670 5 the the DT 42759 2670 6 present present JJ 42759 2670 7 savers saver NNS 42759 2670 8 and and CC 42759 2670 9 owners owner NNS 42759 2670 10 of of IN 42759 2670 11 capital capital NN 42759 2670 12 should should MD 42759 2670 13 diminish diminish VB 42759 2670 14 or or CC 42759 2670 15 discontinue discontinue VB 42759 2670 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2670 17 functions function NNS 42759 2670 18 on on IN 42759 2670 19 account account NN 42759 2670 20 of of IN 42759 2670 21 a a DT 42759 2670 22 fall fall NN 42759 2670 23 in in IN 42759 2670 24 the the DT 42759 2670 25 rate rate NN 42759 2670 26 of of IN 42759 2670 27 interest interest NN 42759 2670 28 , , , 42759 2670 29 a a DT 42759 2670 30 reduction reduction NN 42759 2670 31 would would MD 42759 2670 32 not not RB 42759 2670 33 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 2670 34 take take VB 42759 2670 35 place place NN 42759 2670 36 in in IN 42759 2670 37 the the DT 42759 2670 38 supply supply NN 42759 2670 39 of of IN 42759 2670 40 capital capital NN 42759 2670 41 . . . 42759 2671 1 The the DT 42759 2671 2 function function NN 42759 2671 3 of of IN 42759 2671 4 these these DT 42759 2671 5 " " `` 42759 2671 6 marginal marginal JJ 42759 2671 7 savers saver NNS 42759 2671 8 " " '' 42759 2671 9 would would MD 42759 2671 10 in in IN 42759 2671 11 all all DT 42759 2671 12 probability probability NN 42759 2671 13 be be VB 42759 2671 14 performed perform VBN 42759 2671 15 by by IN 42759 2671 16 other other JJ 42759 2671 17 persons person NNS 42759 2671 18 , , , 42759 2671 19 who who WP 42759 2671 20 would would MD 42759 2671 21 be be VB 42759 2671 22 compelled compel VBN 42759 2671 23 to to TO 42759 2671 24 increase increase VB 42759 2671 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2671 26 accumulations accumulation NNS 42759 2671 27 in in IN 42759 2671 28 order order NN 42759 2671 29 to to TO 42759 2671 30 provide provide VB 42759 2671 31 as as RB 42759 2671 32 well well RB 42759 2671 33 for for IN 42759 2671 34 the the DT 42759 2671 35 future future NN 42759 2671 36 as as IN 42759 2671 37 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2671 38 had have VBD 42759 2671 39 previously previously RB 42759 2671 40 been be VBN 42759 2671 41 able able JJ 42759 2671 42 to to TO 42759 2671 43 provide provide VB 42759 2671 44 with with IN 42759 2671 45 a a DT 42759 2671 46 smaller small JJR 42759 2671 47 capital capital NN 42759 2671 48 at at IN 42759 2671 49 a a DT 42759 2671 50 higher high JJR 42759 2671 51 rate rate NN 42759 2671 52 of of IN 42759 2671 53 interest interest NN 42759 2671 54 . . . 42759 2672 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2672 2 143 143 CD 42759 2672 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2672 4 _ _ NNP 42759 2672 5 Whether whether IN 42759 2672 6 at at IN 42759 2672 7 Least Least JJS 42759 2672 8 Two two CD 42759 2672 9 Per Per NNP 42759 2672 10 Cent Cent NNP 42759 2672 11 . . . 42759 2673 1 Is be VBZ 42759 2673 2 Necessary necessary JJ 42759 2673 3 _ _ NNP 42759 2673 4 While while IN 42759 2673 5 admitting admit VBG 42759 2673 6 that that IN 42759 2673 7 the the DT 42759 2673 8 present present JJ 42759 2673 9 rate rate NN 42759 2673 10 is be VBZ 42759 2673 11 unnecessarily unnecessarily RB 42759 2673 12 high high JJ 42759 2673 13 , , , 42759 2673 14 Professor Professor NNP 42759 2673 15 Cassel Cassel NNP 42759 2673 16 maintains maintain VBZ 42759 2673 17 that that IN 42759 2673 18 a a DT 42759 2673 19 certain certain JJ 42759 2673 20 important important JJ 42759 2673 21 class class NN 42759 2673 22 of of IN 42759 2673 23 savers saver NNS 42759 2673 24 would would MD 42759 2673 25 diminish diminish VB 42759 2673 26 very very RB 42759 2673 27 considerably considerably RB 42759 2673 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2673 29 accumulations accumulation NNS 42759 2673 30 if if IN 42759 2673 31 the the DT 42759 2673 32 interest interest NN 42759 2673 33 rate rate NN 42759 2673 34 should should MD 42759 2673 35 fall fall VB 42759 2673 36 much much RB 42759 2673 37 below below IN 42759 2673 38 two two CD 42759 2673 39 per per NN 42759 2673 40 cent cent NN 42759 2673 41 . . . 42759 2674 1 This this DT 42759 2674 2 class class NN 42759 2674 3 comprises comprise VBZ 42759 2674 4 those those DT 42759 2674 5 persons person NNS 42759 2674 6 whose whose WP$ 42759 2674 7 main main JJ 42759 2674 8 object object NN 42759 2674 9 in in IN 42759 2674 10 saving saving NN 42759 2674 11 is be VBZ 42759 2674 12 a a DT 42759 2674 13 fund fund NN 42759 2674 14 which which WDT 42759 2674 15 will will MD 42759 2674 16 some some DT 42759 2674 17 day day NN 42759 2674 18 support support VB 42759 2674 19 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2674 20 from from IN 42759 2674 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2674 22 interest interest NN 42759 2674 23 . . . 42759 2675 1 At at IN 42759 2675 2 six six CD 42759 2675 3 per per IN 42759 2675 4 cent cent NN 42759 2675 5 . . . 42759 2676 1 a a DT 42759 2676 2 person person NN 42759 2676 3 can can MD 42759 2676 4 accumulate accumulate VB 42759 2676 5 in in IN 42759 2676 6 about about RB 42759 2676 7 twelve twelve CD 42759 2676 8 years year NNS 42759 2676 9 a a DT 42759 2676 10 sum sum NN 42759 2676 11 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2676 12 to to TO 42759 2676 13 provide provide VB 42759 2676 14 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2676 15 with with IN 42759 2676 16 an an DT 42759 2676 17 interest interest NN 42759 2676 18 - - HYPH 42759 2676 19 income income NN 42759 2676 20 equal equal JJ 42759 2676 21 to to IN 42759 2676 22 the the DT 42759 2676 23 amount amount NN 42759 2676 24 annually annually RB 42759 2676 25 saved save VBN 42759 2676 26 . . . 42759 2677 1 For for IN 42759 2677 2 example example NN 42759 2677 3 ; ; : 42759 2677 4 two two CD 42759 2677 5 thousand thousand CD 42759 2677 6 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2677 7 put put VBN 42759 2677 8 aside aside RB 42759 2677 9 every every DT 42759 2677 10 year year NN 42759 2677 11 , , , 42759 2677 12 and and CC 42759 2677 13 subjected subject VBN 42759 2677 14 to to IN 42759 2677 15 compound compound NN 42759 2677 16 interest interest NN 42759 2677 17 , , , 42759 2677 18 will will MD 42759 2677 19 aggregate aggregate VB 42759 2677 20 in in IN 42759 2677 21 twelve twelve CD 42759 2677 22 years year NNS 42759 2677 23 a a DT 42759 2677 24 principal principal NN 42759 2677 25 capable capable JJ 42759 2677 26 of of IN 42759 2677 27 yielding yield VBG 42759 2677 28 an an DT 42759 2677 29 annual annual JJ 42759 2677 30 income income NN 42759 2677 31 of of IN 42759 2677 32 two two CD 42759 2677 33 thousand thousand CD 42759 2677 34 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2677 35 . . . 42759 2678 1 At at IN 42759 2678 2 two two CD 42759 2678 3 per per NN 42759 2678 4 cent cent NN 42759 2678 5 . . . 42759 2679 1 the the DT 42759 2679 2 same same JJ 42759 2679 3 amount amount NN 42759 2679 4 of of IN 42759 2679 5 yearly yearly JJ 42759 2679 6 saving saving NN 42759 2679 7 will will MD 42759 2679 8 not not RB 42759 2679 9 lead lead VB 42759 2679 10 to to IN 42759 2679 11 the the DT 42759 2679 12 same same JJ 42759 2679 13 income income NN 42759 2679 14 in in IN 42759 2679 15 less less JJR 42759 2679 16 than than IN 42759 2679 17 thirty thirty CD 42759 2679 18 - - HYPH 42759 2679 19 five five CD 42759 2679 20 years year NNS 42759 2679 21 . . . 42759 2680 1 If if IN 42759 2680 2 the the DT 42759 2680 3 rate rate NN 42759 2680 4 be be VB 42759 2680 5 one one CD 42759 2680 6 and and CC 42759 2680 7 one one CD 42759 2680 8 - - HYPH 42759 2680 9 half half NN 42759 2680 10 per per IN 42759 2680 11 cent cent NN 42759 2680 12 . . . 42759 2680 13 , , , 42759 2680 14 forty forty CD 42759 2680 15 - - HYPH 42759 2680 16 seven seven CD 42759 2680 17 years year NNS 42759 2680 18 will will MD 42759 2680 19 be be VB 42759 2680 20 required require VBN 42759 2680 21 to to TO 42759 2680 22 produce produce VB 42759 2680 23 the the DT 42759 2680 24 desired desire VBN 42759 2680 25 income income NN 42759 2680 26 . . . 42759 2681 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2681 2 , , , 42759 2681 3 concludes conclude VBZ 42759 2681 4 Cassel Cassel NNP 42759 2681 5 , , , 42759 2681 6 if if IN 42759 2681 7 the the DT 42759 2681 8 rate rate NN 42759 2681 9 falls fall VBZ 42759 2681 10 below below IN 42759 2681 11 two two CD 42759 2681 12 per per NN 42759 2681 13 cent cent NN 42759 2681 14 . . . 42759 2682 1 the the DT 42759 2682 2 average average JJ 42759 2682 3 man man NN 42759 2682 4 will will MD 42759 2682 5 decide decide VB 42759 2682 6 that that DT 42759 2682 7 life life NN 42759 2682 8 is be VBZ 42759 2682 9 too too RB 42759 2682 10 short short JJ 42759 2682 11 to to TO 42759 2682 12 provide provide VB 42759 2682 13 for for IN 42759 2682 14 the the DT 42759 2682 15 future future NN 42759 2682 16 by by IN 42759 2682 17 means mean NNS 42759 2682 18 of of IN 42759 2682 19 an an DT 42759 2682 20 interest interest NN 42759 2682 21 - - HYPH 42759 2682 22 income income NN 42759 2682 23 , , , 42759 2682 24 and and CC 42759 2682 25 will will MD 42759 2682 26 expect expect VB 42759 2682 27 to to TO 42759 2682 28 draw draw VB 42759 2682 29 upon upon IN 42759 2682 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2682 31 principal principal NN 42759 2682 32 . . . 42759 2683 1 This this DT 42759 2683 2 means mean VBZ 42759 2683 3 that that IN 42759 2683 4 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2683 5 will will MD 42759 2683 6 not not RB 42759 2683 7 need need VB 42759 2683 8 to to TO 42759 2683 9 save save VB 42759 2683 10 as as RB 42759 2683 11 much much JJ 42759 2683 12 as as IN 42759 2683 13 when when WRB 42759 2683 14 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2683 15 sought seek VBD 42759 2683 16 to to TO 42759 2683 17 accumulate accumulate VB 42759 2683 18 a a DT 42759 2683 19 capital capital NN 42759 2683 20 large large JJ 42759 2683 21 enough enough RB 42759 2683 22 to to TO 42759 2683 23 support support VB 42759 2683 24 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2683 25 out out IN 42759 2683 26 of of IN 42759 2683 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2683 28 interest interest NN 42759 2683 29 alone alone RB 42759 2683 30 . . . 42759 2684 1 The the DT 42759 2684 2 argument argument NN 42759 2684 3 is be VBZ 42759 2684 4 plausible plausible JJ 42759 2684 5 but but CC 42759 2684 6 not not RB 42759 2684 7 conclusive conclusive JJ 42759 2684 8 . . . 42759 2685 1 If if IN 42759 2685 2 the the DT 42759 2685 3 rate rate NN 42759 2685 4 of of IN 42759 2685 5 interest interest NN 42759 2685 6 is be VBZ 42759 2685 7 so so RB 42759 2685 8 low low JJ 42759 2685 9 that that IN 42759 2685 10 a a DT 42759 2685 11 man man NN 42759 2685 12 must must MD 42759 2685 13 save save VB 42759 2685 14 for for IN 42759 2685 15 forty forty CD 42759 2685 16 - - HYPH 42759 2685 17 seven seven CD 42759 2685 18 years year NNS 42759 2685 19 in in IN 42759 2685 20 order order NN 42759 2685 21 to to TO 42759 2685 22 obtain obtain VB 42759 2685 23 a a DT 42759 2685 24 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2685 25 interest interest NN 42759 2685 26 - - HYPH 42759 2685 27 income income NN 42759 2685 28 to to TO 42759 2685 29 support support VB 42759 2685 30 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2685 31 in in IN 42759 2685 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2685 33 declining decline VBG 42759 2685 34 years year NNS 42759 2685 35 , , , 42759 2685 36 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2685 37 will will MD 42759 2685 38 rarely rarely RB 42759 2685 39 attain attain VB 42759 2685 40 that that DT 42759 2685 41 end end NN 42759 2685 42 . . . 42759 2686 1 In in IN 42759 2686 2 the the DT 42759 2686 3 great great JJ 42759 2686 4 majority majority NN 42759 2686 5 of of IN 42759 2686 6 instances instance NNS 42759 2686 7 men man NNS 42759 2686 8 who who WP 42759 2686 9 are be VBP 42759 2686 10 unable unable JJ 42759 2686 11 to to TO 42759 2686 12 save save VB 42759 2686 13 more more JJR 42759 2686 14 annually annually RB 42759 2686 15 than than IN 42759 2686 16 the the DT 42759 2686 17 amount amount NN 42759 2686 18 that that WDT 42759 2686 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2686 20 will will MD 42759 2686 21 need need VB 42759 2686 22 each each DT 42759 2686 23 year year NN 42759 2686 24 in in IN 42759 2686 25 old old JJ 42759 2686 26 age age NN 42759 2686 27 , , , 42759 2686 28 will will MD 42759 2686 29 expect expect VB 42759 2686 30 and and CC 42759 2686 31 be be VB 42759 2686 32 compelled compel VBN 42759 2686 33 to to TO 42759 2686 34 use use VB 42759 2686 35 up up RP 42759 2686 36 a a DT 42759 2686 37 part part NN 42759 2686 38 or or CC 42759 2686 39 all all DT 42759 2686 40 of of IN 42759 2686 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2686 42 capital capital NN 42759 2686 43 in in IN 42759 2686 44 the the DT 42759 2686 45 period period NN 42759 2686 46 following follow VBG 42759 2686 47 the the DT 42759 2686 48 cessation cessation NN 42759 2686 49 of of IN 42759 2686 50 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2686 51 economic economic JJ 42759 2686 52 usefulness usefulness NN 42759 2686 53 . . . 42759 2687 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2687 2 , , , 42759 2687 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2687 4 does do VBZ 42759 2687 5 not not RB 42759 2687 6 follow follow VB 42759 2687 7 that that IN 42759 2687 8 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2687 9 will will MD 42759 2687 10 save save VB 42759 2687 11 less less JJR 42759 2687 12 at at IN 42759 2687 13 one one CD 42759 2687 14 and and CC 42759 2687 15 one one CD 42759 2687 16 - - HYPH 42759 2687 17 half half NN 42759 2687 18 per per IN 42759 2687 19 cent cent NN 42759 2687 20 . . . 42759 2688 1 than than IN 42759 2688 2 at at IN 42759 2688 3 six six CD 42759 2688 4 per per IN 42759 2688 5 cent cent NN 42759 2688 6 . . . 42759 2689 1 The the DT 42759 2689 2 determining determine VBG 42759 2689 3 factor factor NN 42759 2689 4 in in IN 42759 2689 5 the the DT 42759 2689 6 situation situation NN 42759 2689 7 is be VBZ 42759 2689 8 the the DT 42759 2689 9 attitude attitude NN 42759 2689 10 of of IN 42759 2689 11 the the DT 42759 2689 12 saver saver NN 42759 2689 13 toward toward IN 42759 2689 14 the the DT 42759 2689 15 _ _ NNP 42759 2689 16 capital capital NN 42759 2689 17 sum sum NN 42759 2689 18 accumulated accumulate VBN 42759 2689 19 _ _ NNP 42759 2689 20 . . . 42759 2690 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2690 2 either either CC 42759 2690 3 desires desire VBZ 42759 2690 4 or or CC 42759 2690 5 does do VBZ 42759 2690 6 not not RB 42759 2690 7 desire desire VB 42759 2690 8 to to TO 42759 2690 9 leave leave VB 42759 2690 10 this this DT 42759 2690 11 behind behind IN 42759 2690 12 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2690 13 . . . 42759 2691 1 In in IN 42759 2691 2 the the DT 42759 2691 3 latter latter JJ 42759 2691 4 case case NN 42759 2691 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2691 6 will will MD 42759 2691 7 save save VB 42759 2691 8 only only RB 42759 2691 9 as as RB 42759 2691 10 much much JJ 42759 2691 11 as as IN 42759 2691 12 is be VBZ 42759 2691 13 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2691 14 to to TO 42759 2691 15 provide provide VB 42759 2691 16 an an DT 42759 2691 17 annual annual JJ 42759 2691 18 income income NN 42759 2691 19 composed compose VBN 42759 2691 20 partly partly RB 42759 2691 21 of of IN 42759 2691 22 interest interest NN 42759 2691 23 and and CC 42759 2691 24 partly partly RB 42759 2691 25 of of IN 42759 2691 26 the the DT 42759 2691 27 principal principal NN 42759 2691 28 . . . 42759 2692 1 If if IN 42759 2692 2 this this DT 42759 2692 3 contemplated contemplate VBN 42759 2692 4 income income NN 42759 2692 5 is be VBZ 42759 2692 6 two two CD 42759 2692 7 thousand thousand CD 42759 2692 8 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2692 9 , , , 42759 2692 10 and and CC 42759 2692 11 the the DT 42759 2692 12 rate rate NN 42759 2692 13 of of IN 42759 2692 14 interest interest NN 42759 2692 15 is be VBZ 42759 2692 16 six six CD 42759 2692 17 per per IN 42759 2692 18 cent cent NN 42759 2692 19 . . . 42759 2692 20 , , , 42759 2692 21 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2692 22 will will MD 42759 2692 23 not not RB 42759 2692 24 need need VB 42759 2692 25 to to TO 42759 2692 26 save save VB 42759 2692 27 that that DT 42759 2692 28 much much JJ 42759 2692 29 annually annually RB 42759 2692 30 for for IN 42759 2692 31 as as RB 42759 2692 32 long long RB 42759 2692 33 a a DT 42759 2692 34 period period NN 42759 2692 35 as as IN 42759 2692 36 ten ten CD 42759 2692 37 years year NNS 42759 2692 38 . . . 42759 2693 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2693 2 can can MD 42759 2693 3 diminish diminish VB 42759 2693 4 either either CC 42759 2693 5 the the DT 42759 2693 6 yearly yearly JJ 42759 2693 7 amount amount NN 42759 2693 8 saved save VBN 42759 2693 9 or or CC 42759 2693 10 the the DT 42759 2693 11 length length NN 42759 2693 12 of of IN 42759 2693 13 time time NN 42759 2693 14 devoted devote VBN 42759 2693 15 to to IN 42759 2693 16 saving save VBG 42759 2693 17 . . . 42759 2694 1 On on IN 42759 2694 2 the the DT 42759 2694 3 other other JJ 42759 2694 4 hand hand NN 42759 2694 5 , , , 42759 2694 6 if if IN 42759 2694 7 the the DT 42759 2694 8 rate rate NN 42759 2694 9 is be VBZ 42759 2694 10 only only RB 42759 2694 11 one one CD 42759 2694 12 and and CC 42759 2694 13 one one CD 42759 2694 14 - - HYPH 42759 2694 15 half half NN 42759 2694 16 per per IN 42759 2694 17 cent cent NN 42759 2694 18 . . . 42759 2695 1 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2695 2 will will MD 42759 2695 3 be be VB 42759 2695 4 compelled compel VBN 42759 2695 5 to to TO 42759 2695 6 save save VB 42759 2695 7 a a DT 42759 2695 8 larger large JJR 42759 2695 9 total total NN 42759 2695 10 in in IN 42759 2695 11 order order NN 42759 2695 12 to to TO 42759 2695 13 secure secure VB 42759 2695 14 an an DT 42759 2695 15 equal equal JJ 42759 2695 16 accumulation accumulation NN 42759 2695 17 and and CC 42759 2695 18 an an DT 42759 2695 19 equal equal JJ 42759 2695 20 provision provision NN 42759 2695 21 for for IN 42759 2695 22 the the DT 42759 2695 23 future future NN 42759 2695 24 . . . 42759 2696 1 In in IN 42759 2696 2 all all DT 42759 2696 3 cases case NNS 42759 2696 4 , , , 42759 2696 5 therefore therefore RB 42759 2696 6 , , , 42759 2696 7 in in IN 42759 2696 8 which which WDT 42759 2696 9 the the DT 42759 2696 10 saving saving NN 42759 2696 11 is be VBZ 42759 2696 12 carried carry VBN 42759 2696 13 on on IN 42759 2696 14 merely merely RB 42759 2696 15 for for IN 42759 2696 16 the the DT 42759 2696 17 saver saver NN 42759 2696 18 's 's POS 42759 2696 19 own own JJ 42759 2696 20 lifetime lifetime NN 42759 2696 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2696 22 will will MD 42759 2696 23 be be VB 42759 2696 24 increased increase VBN 42759 2696 25 instead instead RB 42759 2696 26 of of IN 42759 2696 27 decreased decrease VBN 42759 2696 28 by by IN 42759 2696 29 a a DT 42759 2696 30 low low JJ 42759 2696 31 rate rate NN 42759 2696 32 of of IN 42759 2696 33 interest interest NN 42759 2696 34 . . . 42759 2697 1 If if IN 42759 2697 2 the the DT 42759 2697 3 saver saver NN 42759 2697 4 does do VBZ 42759 2697 5 desire desire VB 42759 2697 6 to to TO 42759 2697 7 bequeath bequeath VB 42759 2697 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2697 9 capital capital NN 42759 2697 10 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2697 11 will will MD 42759 2697 12 not not RB 42759 2697 13 always always RB 42759 2697 14 be be VB 42759 2697 15 deterred deter VBN 42759 2697 16 from from IN 42759 2697 17 this this DT 42759 2697 18 purpose purpose NN 42759 2697 19 merely merely RB 42759 2697 20 because because IN 42759 2697 21 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2697 22 is be VBZ 42759 2697 23 compelled compel VBN 42759 2697 24 to to TO 42759 2697 25 use use VB 42759 2697 26 some some DT 42759 2697 27 of of IN 42759 2697 28 the the DT 42759 2697 29 capital capital NN 42759 2697 30 for for IN 42759 2697 31 the the DT 42759 2697 32 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 2697 33 of of IN 42759 2697 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2697 35 own own JJ 42759 2697 36 wants want NNS 42759 2697 37 . . . 42759 2698 1 Take take VB 42759 2698 2 the the DT 42759 2698 3 man man NN 42759 2698 4 who who WP 42759 2698 5 can can MD 42759 2698 6 save save VB 42759 2698 7 two two CD 42759 2698 8 thousand thousand CD 42759 2698 9 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2698 10 a a DT 42759 2698 11 year year NN 42759 2698 12 , , , 42759 2698 13 and and CC 42759 2698 14 with with IN 42759 2698 15 the the DT 42759 2698 16 rate rate NN 42759 2698 17 of of IN 42759 2698 18 interest interest NN 42759 2698 19 at at IN 42759 2698 20 six six CD 42759 2698 21 per per IN 42759 2698 22 cent cent NN 42759 2698 23 . . . 42759 2699 1 assure assure VB 42759 2699 2 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 2699 3 an an DT 42759 2699 4 interest interest NN 42759 2699 5 - - HYPH 42759 2699 6 income income NN 42759 2699 7 of of IN 42759 2699 8 the the DT 42759 2699 9 same same JJ 42759 2699 10 amount amount NN 42759 2699 11 , , , 42759 2699 12 and and CC 42759 2699 13 who who WP 42759 2699 14 intends intend VBZ 42759 2699 15 to to TO 42759 2699 16 leave leave VB 42759 2699 17 the the DT 42759 2699 18 principal principal NN 42759 2699 19 ( ( -LRB- 42759 2699 20 some some DT 42759 2699 21 thirty thirty CD 42759 2699 22 - - HYPH 42759 2699 23 three three CD 42759 2699 24 thousand thousand CD 42759 2699 25 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2699 26 ) ) -RRB- 42759 2699 27 to to IN 42759 2699 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2699 29 children child NNS 42759 2699 30 . . . 42759 2700 1 Should Should MD 42759 2700 2 the the DT 42759 2700 3 rate rate NN 42759 2700 4 fall fall VB 42759 2700 5 to to IN 42759 2700 6 one one CD 42759 2700 7 and and CC 42759 2700 8 one one CD 42759 2700 9 - - HYPH 42759 2700 10 half half NN 42759 2700 11 per per IN 42759 2700 12 cent cent NN 42759 2700 13 . . . 42759 2701 1 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2701 2 would would MD 42759 2701 3 be be VB 42759 2701 4 unable unable JJ 42759 2701 5 to to TO 42759 2701 6 accumulate accumulate VB 42759 2701 7 and and CC 42759 2701 8 bequeath bequeath VB 42759 2701 9 nearly nearly RB 42759 2701 10 such such PDT 42759 2701 11 a a DT 42759 2701 12 large large JJ 42759 2701 13 sum sum NN 42759 2701 14 . . . 42759 2702 1 Surely surely RB 42759 2702 2 this this DT 42759 2702 3 fact fact NN 42759 2702 4 , , , 42759 2702 5 discouraging discourage VBG 42759 2702 6 as as IN 42759 2702 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2702 8 is be VBZ 42759 2702 9 , , , 42759 2702 10 will will MD 42759 2702 11 not not RB 42759 2702 12 determine determine VB 42759 2702 13 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2702 14 to to TO 42759 2702 15 save save VB 42759 2702 16 nothing nothing NN 42759 2702 17 . . . 42759 2703 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2703 2 will will MD 42759 2703 3 not not RB 42759 2703 4 , , , 42759 2703 5 as as IN 42759 2703 6 Cassel Cassel NNP 42759 2703 7 's 's POS 42759 2703 8 argument argument NN 42759 2703 9 assumes assume VBZ 42759 2703 10 , , , 42759 2703 11 decide decide VB 42759 2703 12 to to TO 42759 2703 13 leave leave VB 42759 2703 14 nothing nothing NN 42759 2703 15 to to IN 42759 2703 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2703 17 children child NNS 42759 2703 18 , , , 42759 2703 19 and and CC 42759 2703 20 content content VB 42759 2703 21 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 2703 22 with with IN 42759 2703 23 that that DT 42759 2703 24 amount amount NN 42759 2703 25 of of IN 42759 2703 26 saving saving NN 42759 2703 27 which which WDT 42759 2703 28 will will MD 42759 2703 29 suffice suffice VB 42759 2703 30 to to TO 42759 2703 31 provide provide VB 42759 2703 32 for for IN 42759 2703 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2703 34 own own JJ 42759 2703 35 future future NN 42759 2703 36 . . . 42759 2704 1 In in IN 42759 2704 2 all all DT 42759 2704 3 probability probability NN 42759 2704 4 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2704 5 will will MD 42759 2704 6 try try VB 42759 2704 7 to to TO 42759 2704 8 accumulate accumulate VB 42759 2704 9 a a DT 42759 2704 10 sum sum NN 42759 2704 11 which which WDT 42759 2704 12 , , , 42759 2704 13 even even RB 42759 2704 14 when when WRB 42759 2704 15 diminished diminish VBN 42759 2704 16 by by IN 42759 2704 17 future future JJ 42759 2704 18 deductions deduction NNS 42759 2704 19 for for IN 42759 2704 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2704 21 own own JJ 42759 2704 22 wants want NNS 42759 2704 23 , , , 42759 2704 24 will will MD 42759 2704 25 approximate approximate VB 42759 2704 26 as as RB 42759 2704 27 closely closely RB 42759 2704 28 as as IN 42759 2704 29 possible possible JJ 42759 2704 30 the the DT 42759 2704 31 amount amount NN 42759 2704 32 that that WDT 42759 2704 33 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2704 34 could could MD 42759 2704 35 have have VB 42759 2704 36 bequeathed bequeath VBN 42759 2704 37 had have VBD 42759 2704 38 the the DT 42759 2704 39 rate rate NN 42759 2704 40 remained remain VBD 42759 2704 41 at at IN 42759 2704 42 six six CD 42759 2704 43 per per IN 42759 2704 44 cent cent NN 42759 2704 45 . . . 42759 2705 1 This this DT 42759 2705 2 means mean VBZ 42759 2705 3 that that IN 42759 2705 4 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2705 5 will will MD 42759 2705 6 save save VB 42759 2705 7 more more JJR 42759 2705 8 at at IN 42759 2705 9 the the DT 42759 2705 10 low low JJ 42759 2705 11 than than IN 42759 2705 12 at at IN 42759 2705 13 the the DT 42759 2705 14 high high JJ 42759 2705 15 rate rate NN 42759 2705 16 of of IN 42759 2705 17 interest interest NN 42759 2705 18 . . . 42759 2706 1 The the DT 42759 2706 2 relative relative JJ 42759 2706 3 insignificance insignificance NN 42759 2706 4 of of IN 42759 2706 5 the the DT 42759 2706 6 sum sum NN 42759 2706 7 which which WDT 42759 2706 8 would would MD 42759 2706 9 be be VB 42759 2706 10 saved save VBN 42759 2706 11 at at IN 42759 2706 12 a a DT 42759 2706 13 low low JJ 42759 2706 14 rate rate NN 42759 2706 15 might may MD 42759 2706 16 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 2706 17 , , , 42759 2706 18 indeed indeed RB 42759 2706 19 , , , 42759 2706 20 deter deter VB 42759 2706 21 a a DT 42759 2706 22 person person NN 42759 2706 23 from from IN 42759 2706 24 saving save VBG 42759 2706 25 for for IN 42759 2706 26 testamentary testamentary NN 42759 2706 27 purposes purpose NNS 42759 2706 28 . . . 42759 2707 1 With with IN 42759 2707 2 the the DT 42759 2707 3 rate rate NN 42759 2707 4 at at IN 42759 2707 5 six six CD 42759 2707 6 per per IN 42759 2707 7 cent cent NN 42759 2707 8 . . . 42759 2707 9 , , , 42759 2707 10 a a DT 42759 2707 11 man man NN 42759 2707 12 might may MD 42759 2707 13 be be VB 42759 2707 14 willing willing JJ 42759 2707 15 to to TO 42759 2707 16 save save VB 42759 2707 17 six six CD 42759 2707 18 hundred hundred CD 42759 2707 19 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2707 20 a a DT 42759 2707 21 year year NN 42759 2707 22 for for IN 42759 2707 23 a a DT 42759 2707 24 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 2707 25 long long JJ 42759 2707 26 period period NN 42759 2707 27 to to TO 42759 2707 28 provide provide VB 42759 2707 29 a a DT 42759 2707 30 legacy legacy NN 42759 2707 31 of of IN 42759 2707 32 twenty twenty CD 42759 2707 33 thousand thousand CD 42759 2707 34 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2707 35 to to IN 42759 2707 36 an an DT 42759 2707 37 educational educational JJ 42759 2707 38 institution institution NN 42759 2707 39 . . . 42759 2708 1 With with IN 42759 2708 2 the the DT 42759 2708 3 rate rate NN 42759 2708 4 at at IN 42759 2708 5 one one CD 42759 2708 6 and and CC 42759 2708 7 one one CD 42759 2708 8 - - HYPH 42759 2708 9 half half NN 42759 2708 10 per per IN 42759 2708 11 cent cent NN 42759 2708 12 . . . 42759 2708 13 , , , 42759 2708 14 the the DT 42759 2708 15 amount amount NN 42759 2708 16 that that WDT 42759 2708 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2708 18 could could MD 42759 2708 19 hope hope VB 42759 2708 20 to to TO 42759 2708 21 accumulate accumulate VB 42759 2708 22 would would MD 42759 2708 23 be be VB 42759 2708 24 so so RB 42759 2708 25 much much RB 42759 2708 26 smaller small JJR 42759 2708 27 that that IN 42759 2708 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2708 29 might may MD 42759 2708 30 seem seem VB 42759 2708 31 to to IN 42759 2708 32 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2708 33 not not RB 42759 2708 34 worth worth JJ 42759 2708 35 while while IN 42759 2708 36 , , , 42759 2708 37 and and CC 42759 2708 38 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2708 39 would would MD 42759 2708 40 decline decline VB 42759 2708 41 to to TO 42759 2708 42 save save VB 42759 2708 43 the the DT 42759 2708 44 six six CD 42759 2708 45 hundred hundred CD 42759 2708 46 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2708 47 annually annually RB 42759 2708 48 . . . 42759 2709 1 Cases case NNS 42759 2709 2 of of IN 42759 2709 3 this this DT 42759 2709 4 kind kind NN 42759 2709 5 , , , 42759 2709 6 however however RB 42759 2709 7 , , , 42759 2709 8 always always RB 42759 2709 9 involve involve VBP 42759 2709 10 the the DT 42759 2709 11 secondary secondary JJ 42759 2709 12 objects object NNS 42759 2709 13 of of IN 42759 2709 14 saving saving NN 42759 2709 15 , , , 42759 2709 16 the the DT 42759 2709 17 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 2709 18 rather rather RB 42759 2709 19 than than IN 42759 2709 20 the the DT 42759 2709 21 necessaries necessary NNS 42759 2709 22 of of IN 42759 2709 23 testamentary testamentary NN 42759 2709 24 transmission transmission NN 42759 2709 25 . . . 42759 2710 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2710 2 do do VBP 42759 2710 3 not not RB 42759 2710 4 include include VB 42759 2710 5 such such JJ 42759 2710 6 primary primary JJ 42759 2710 7 objects object NNS 42759 2710 8 as as IN 42759 2710 9 provision provision NN 42759 2710 10 for for IN 42759 2710 11 one one NN 42759 2710 12 's 's POS 42759 2710 13 family family NN 42759 2710 14 . . . 42759 2711 1 When when WRB 42759 2711 2 the the DT 42759 2711 3 average average JJ 42759 2711 4 man man NN 42759 2711 5 finds find VBZ 42759 2711 6 that that IN 42759 2711 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2711 8 can can MD 42759 2711 9 not not RB 42759 2711 10 leave leave VB 42759 2711 11 to to IN 42759 2711 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2711 13 family family NN 42759 2711 14 as as RB 42759 2711 15 much much RB 42759 2711 16 as as IN 42759 2711 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2711 18 would would MD 42759 2711 19 desire desire VB 42759 2711 20 , , , 42759 2711 21 as as RB 42759 2711 22 much much RB 42759 2711 23 as as IN 42759 2711 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2711 25 would would MD 42759 2711 26 have have VB 42759 2711 27 bequeathed bequeath VBN 42759 2711 28 to to IN 42759 2711 29 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2711 30 at at IN 42759 2711 31 a a DT 42759 2711 32 higher high JJR 42759 2711 33 rate rate NN 42759 2711 34 of of IN 42759 2711 35 interest interest NN 42759 2711 36 , , , 42759 2711 37 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2711 38 will will MD 42759 2711 39 strive strive VB 42759 2711 40 to to TO 42759 2711 41 increase increase VB 42759 2711 42 rather rather RB 42759 2711 43 than than IN 42759 2711 44 decrease decrease VB 42759 2711 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2711 46 efforts effort NNS 42759 2711 47 to to TO 42759 2711 48 save save VB 42759 2711 49 for for IN 42759 2711 50 this this DT 42759 2711 51 purpose purpose NN 42759 2711 52 . . . 42759 2712 1 Speaking speak VBG 42759 2712 2 generally generally RB 42759 2712 3 , , , 42759 2712 4 then then RB 42759 2712 5 , , , 42759 2712 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2712 7 conclude conclude VBP 42759 2712 8 that that IN 42759 2712 9 the the DT 42759 2712 10 assumption assumption NN 42759 2712 11 underlying underlie VBG 42759 2712 12 Professor Professor NNP 42759 2712 13 Cassel Cassel NNP 42759 2712 14 's 's POS 42759 2712 15 theory theory NN 42759 2712 16 is be VBZ 42759 2712 17 contradicted contradict VBN 42759 2712 18 by by IN 42759 2712 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2712 20 experience experience NN 42759 2712 21 of of IN 42759 2712 22 human human JJ 42759 2712 23 motives motive NNS 42759 2712 24 and and CC 42759 2712 25 practices practice NNS 42759 2712 26 . . . 42759 2713 1 Men man NNS 42759 2713 2 who who WP 42759 2713 3 save save VBP 42759 2713 4 mainly mainly RB 42759 2713 5 for for IN 42759 2713 6 a a DT 42759 2713 7 future future JJ 42759 2713 8 interest interest NN 42759 2713 9 - - HYPH 42759 2713 10 income income NN 42759 2713 11 , , , 42759 2713 12 at at IN 42759 2713 13 the the DT 42759 2713 14 same same JJ 42759 2713 15 time time NN 42759 2713 16 wishing wish VBG 42759 2713 17 to to TO 42759 2713 18 keep keep VB 42759 2713 19 the the DT 42759 2713 20 principal principal NN 42759 2713 21 intact intact JJ 42759 2713 22 until until IN 42759 2713 23 death death NN 42759 2713 24 , , , 42759 2713 25 and and CC 42759 2713 26 who who WP 42759 2713 27 could could MD 42759 2713 28 have have VB 42759 2713 29 fully fully RB 42759 2713 30 realised realise VBN 42759 2713 31 this this DT 42759 2713 32 desire desire NN 42759 2713 33 under under IN 42759 2713 34 a a DT 42759 2713 35 high high JJ 42759 2713 36 interest interest NN 42759 2713 37 régime régime NN 42759 2713 38 , , , 42759 2713 39 will will MD 42759 2713 40 not not RB 42759 2713 41 become become VB 42759 2713 42 entirely entirely RB 42759 2713 43 indifferent indifferent JJ 42759 2713 44 to to IN 42759 2713 45 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2713 46 when when WRB 42759 2713 47 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2713 48 find find VBP 42759 2713 49 that that IN 42759 2713 50 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2713 51 can can MD 42759 2713 52 not not RB 42759 2713 53 attain attain VB 42759 2713 54 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2713 55 completely completely RB 42759 2713 56 . . . 42759 2714 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2714 2 will will MD 42759 2714 3 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 2714 4 try try VB 42759 2714 5 to to TO 42759 2714 6 leave leave VB 42759 2714 7 behind behind IN 42759 2714 8 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2714 9 as as IN 42759 2714 10 large large JJ 42759 2714 11 a a DT 42759 2714 12 capital capital NN 42759 2714 13 or or CC 42759 2714 14 principal principal NN 42759 2714 15 as as IN 42759 2714 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2714 17 can can MD 42759 2714 18 . . . 42759 2715 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2715 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2715 3 will will MD 42759 2715 4 save save VB 42759 2715 5 more more RBR 42759 2715 6 rather rather RB 42759 2715 7 than than IN 42759 2715 8 less less JJR 42759 2715 9 . . . 42759 2716 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2716 2 Whether Whether NNP 42759 2716 3 Any any DT 42759 2716 4 Interest interest NN 42759 2716 5 Is be VBZ 42759 2716 6 Necessary necessary JJ 42759 2716 7 _ _ IN 42759 2716 8 Perhaps perhaps RB 42759 2716 9 the the DT 42759 2716 10 best well RBS 42759 2716 11 known know VBN 42759 2716 12 recent recent JJ 42759 2716 13 statement statement NN 42759 2716 14 of of IN 42759 2716 15 the the DT 42759 2716 16 opinion opinion NN 42759 2716 17 that that IN 42759 2716 18 interest interest NN 42759 2716 19 is be VBZ 42759 2716 20 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 2716 21 , , , 42759 2716 22 appears appear VBZ 42759 2716 23 in in IN 42759 2716 24 Professor Professor NNP 42759 2716 25 Irving Irving NNP 42759 2716 26 Fisher Fisher NNP 42759 2716 27 's 's POS 42759 2716 28 " " `` 42759 2716 29 The the DT 42759 2716 30 Rate rate NN 42759 2716 31 of of IN 42759 2716 32 Interest interest NN 42759 2716 33 . . . 42759 2717 1 " " `` 42759 2717 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2717 3 144 144 CD 42759 2717 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2717 5 While while IN 42759 2717 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2717 7 does do VBZ 42759 2717 8 not not RB 42759 2717 9 assert assert VB 42759 2717 10 explicitly explicitly RB 42759 2717 11 that that IN 42759 2717 12 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2717 13 capital capital NN 42759 2717 14 would would MD 42759 2717 15 not not RB 42759 2717 16 be be VB 42759 2717 17 provided provide VBN 42759 2717 18 without without IN 42759 2717 19 interest interest NN 42759 2717 20 , , , 42759 2717 21 and and CC 42759 2717 22 even even RB 42759 2717 23 admits admit VBZ 42759 2717 24 that that IN 42759 2717 25 in in IN 42759 2717 26 certain certain JJ 42759 2717 27 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 2717 28 interest interest NN 42759 2717 29 might may MD 42759 2717 30 disappear disappear VB 42759 2717 31 , , , 42759 2717 32 the the DT 42759 2717 33 general general JJ 42759 2717 34 logic logic NN 42759 2717 35 and and CC 42759 2717 36 implications implication NNS 42759 2717 37 of of IN 42759 2717 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2717 39 argument argument NN 42759 2717 40 are be VBP 42759 2717 41 decidedly decidedly RB 42759 2717 42 against against IN 42759 2717 43 the the DT 42759 2717 44 supposition supposition NN 42759 2717 45 that that IN 42759 2717 46 society society NN 42759 2717 47 could could MD 42759 2717 48 ever ever RB 42759 2717 49 get get VB 42759 2717 50 along along RP 42759 2717 51 without without IN 42759 2717 52 interest interest NN 42759 2717 53 . . . 42759 2718 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 2718 2 lays lay VBZ 42759 2718 3 such such JJ 42759 2718 4 stress stress NN 42759 2718 5 upon upon IN 42759 2718 6 the the DT 42759 2718 7 factor factor NN 42759 2718 8 of of IN 42759 2718 9 " " `` 42759 2718 10 impatience impatience NN 42759 2718 11 , , , 42759 2718 12 " " '' 42759 2718 13 i.e. i.e. FW 42759 2718 14 , , , 42759 2718 15 man man NN 42759 2718 16 's 's POS 42759 2718 17 unwillingness unwillingness NN 42759 2718 18 to to TO 42759 2718 19 wait wait VB 42759 2718 20 for for IN 42759 2718 21 future future JJ 42759 2718 22 goods good NNS 42759 2718 23 , , , 42759 2718 24 as as IN 42759 2718 25 to to TO 42759 2718 26 suggest suggest VB 42759 2718 27 strongly strongly RB 42759 2718 28 that that IN 42759 2718 29 other other JJ 42759 2718 30 causes cause NNS 42759 2718 31 of of IN 42759 2718 32 interest interest NN 42759 2718 33 , , , 42759 2718 34 and and CC 42759 2718 35 the the DT 42759 2718 36 number number NN 42759 2718 37 of of IN 42759 2718 38 savers saver NNS 42759 2718 39 free free JJ 42759 2718 40 from from IN 42759 2718 41 " " `` 42759 2718 42 impatience impatience NN 42759 2718 43 , , , 42759 2718 44 " " '' 42759 2718 45 are be VBP 42759 2718 46 quite quite RB 42759 2718 47 insignificant insignificant JJ 42759 2718 48 . . . 42759 2719 1 Now now RB 42759 2719 2 , , , 42759 2719 3 if if IN 42759 2719 4 " " `` 42759 2719 5 impatience impatience NN 42759 2719 6 " " '' 42759 2719 7 were be VBD 42759 2719 8 the the DT 42759 2719 9 only only JJ 42759 2719 10 cause cause NN 42759 2719 11 of of IN 42759 2719 12 interest interest NN 42759 2719 13 the the DT 42759 2719 14 latter latter NN 42759 2719 15 must must MD 42759 2719 16 continue continue VB 42759 2719 17 as as RB 42759 2719 18 long long RB 42759 2719 19 as as IN 42759 2719 20 " " `` 42759 2719 21 impatience impatience NN 42759 2719 22 " " '' 42759 2719 23 continues continue VBZ 42759 2719 24 ; ; : 42759 2719 25 and and CC 42759 2719 26 if if IN 42759 2719 27 practically practically RB 42759 2719 28 all all DT 42759 2719 29 savers saver NNS 42759 2719 30 , , , 42759 2719 31 actual actual JJ 42759 2719 32 and and CC 42759 2719 33 possible possible JJ 42759 2719 34 , , , 42759 2719 35 are be VBP 42759 2719 36 completely completely RB 42759 2719 37 dominated dominate VBN 42759 2719 38 by by IN 42759 2719 39 " " `` 42759 2719 40 impatience impatience NN 42759 2719 41 " " '' 42759 2719 42 the the DT 42759 2719 43 abolition abolition NN 42759 2719 44 of of IN 42759 2719 45 interest interest NN 42759 2719 46 would would MD 42759 2719 47 be be VB 42759 2719 48 socially socially RB 42759 2719 49 disastrous disastrous JJ 42759 2719 50 . . . 42759 2720 1 However however RB 42759 2720 2 , , , 42759 2720 3 neither neither DT 42759 2720 4 of of IN 42759 2720 5 these these DT 42759 2720 6 assumptions assumption NNS 42759 2720 7 is be VBZ 42759 2720 8 demonstrable demonstrable JJ 42759 2720 9 . . . 42759 2721 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 2721 2 have have VBP 42759 2721 3 just just RB 42759 2721 4 seen see VBN 42759 2721 5 that that IN 42759 2721 6 the the DT 42759 2721 7 present present JJ 42759 2721 8 rate rate NN 42759 2721 9 of of IN 42759 2721 10 interest interest NN 42759 2721 11 has have VBZ 42759 2721 12 other other JJ 42759 2721 13 causes cause NNS 42759 2721 14 than than IN 42759 2721 15 " " `` 42759 2721 16 impatience impatience NN 42759 2721 17 " " '' 42759 2721 18 ; ; : 42759 2721 19 that that IN 42759 2721 20 a a DT 42759 2721 21 large large JJ 42759 2721 22 proportion proportion NN 42759 2721 23 of of IN 42759 2721 24 savers saver NNS 42759 2721 25 insist insist VBP 42759 2721 26 upon upon IN 42759 2721 27 getting get VBG 42759 2721 28 the the DT 42759 2721 29 present present JJ 42759 2721 30 rate rate NN 42759 2721 31 , , , 42759 2721 32 not not RB 42759 2721 33 because because IN 42759 2721 34 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2721 35 require require VBP 42759 2721 36 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2721 37 to to TO 42759 2721 38 offset offset VB 42759 2721 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2721 40 " " `` 42759 2721 41 impatience impatience NN 42759 2721 42 , , , 42759 2721 43 " " '' 42759 2721 44 but but CC 42759 2721 45 simply simply RB 42759 2721 46 because because IN 42759 2721 47 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2721 48 can can MD 42759 2721 49 obtain obtain VB 42759 2721 50 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2721 51 , , , 42759 2721 52 and and CC 42759 2721 53 because because IN 42759 2721 54 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2721 55 prefer prefer VBP 42759 2721 56 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2721 57 to to IN 42759 2721 58 the the DT 42759 2721 59 lower low JJR 42759 2721 60 rate rate NN 42759 2721 61 . . . 42759 2722 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 2722 2 , , , 42759 2722 3 the the DT 42759 2722 4 mere mere JJ 42759 2722 5 existence existence NN 42759 2722 6 of of IN 42759 2722 7 the the DT 42759 2722 8 present present JJ 42759 2722 9 rate rate NN 42759 2722 10 does do VBZ 42759 2722 11 not not RB 42759 2722 12 prove prove VB 42759 2722 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2722 14 to to TO 42759 2722 15 be be VB 42759 2722 16 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2722 17 . . . 42759 2723 1 By by IN 42759 2723 2 the the DT 42759 2723 3 same same JJ 42759 2723 4 argument argument NN 42759 2723 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2723 6 is be VBZ 42759 2723 7 evident evident JJ 42759 2723 8 that that IN 42759 2723 9 the the DT 42759 2723 10 existence existence NN 42759 2723 11 of of IN 42759 2723 12 any any DT 42759 2723 13 interest interest NN 42759 2723 14 does do VBZ 42759 2723 15 not not RB 42759 2723 16 demonstrate demonstrate VB 42759 2723 17 the the DT 42759 2723 18 necessity necessity NN 42759 2723 19 of of IN 42759 2723 20 some some DT 42759 2723 21 interest interest NN 42759 2723 22 . . . 42759 2724 1 In in IN 42759 2724 2 the the DT 42759 2724 3 second second JJ 42759 2724 4 place place NN 42759 2724 5 , , , 42759 2724 6 the the DT 42759 2724 7 number number NN 42759 2724 8 of of IN 42759 2724 9 savers saver NNS 42759 2724 10 , , , 42759 2724 11 present present JJ 42759 2724 12 and and CC 42759 2724 13 prospective prospective JJ 42759 2724 14 , , , 42759 2724 15 whose whose WP$ 42759 2724 16 " " `` 42759 2724 17 impatience impatience NN 42759 2724 18 " " '' 42759 2724 19 is be VBZ 42759 2724 20 so so RB 42759 2724 21 weak weak JJ 42759 2724 22 as as IN 42759 2724 23 to to TO 42759 2724 24 permit permit VB 42759 2724 25 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2724 26 to to TO 42759 2724 27 save save VB 42759 2724 28 without without IN 42759 2724 29 interest interest NN 42759 2724 30 , , , 42759 2724 31 is be VBZ 42759 2724 32 probably probably RB 42759 2724 33 greater great JJR 42759 2724 34 than than IN 42759 2724 35 the the DT 42759 2724 36 average average JJ 42759 2724 37 reader reader NN 42759 2724 38 of of IN 42759 2724 39 Professor Professor NNP 42759 2724 40 Fisher Fisher NNP 42759 2724 41 's 's POS 42759 2724 42 pages page NNS 42759 2724 43 is be VBZ 42759 2724 44 led lead VBN 42759 2724 45 to to TO 42759 2724 46 assume assume VB 42759 2724 47 . . . 42759 2725 1 The the DT 42759 2725 2 question question NN 42759 2725 3 whether whether IN 42759 2725 4 interest interest NN 42759 2725 5 is be VBZ 42759 2725 6 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2725 7 can can MD 42759 2725 8 not not RB 42759 2725 9 be be VB 42759 2725 10 answered answer VBN 42759 2725 11 by by IN 42759 2725 12 reference reference NN 42759 2725 13 to to IN 42759 2725 14 the the DT 42759 2725 15 general general JJ 42759 2725 16 fact fact NN 42759 2725 17 of of IN 42759 2725 18 human human JJ 42759 2725 19 " " `` 42759 2725 20 impatience impatience NN 42759 2725 21 " " '' 42759 2725 22 ; ; : 42759 2725 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2725 24 demands demand VBZ 42759 2725 25 a a DT 42759 2725 26 preliminary preliminary JJ 42759 2725 27 analysis analysis NN 42759 2725 28 of of IN 42759 2725 29 the the DT 42759 2725 30 extent extent NN 42759 2725 31 to to TO 42759 2725 32 which which WDT 42759 2725 33 " " `` 42759 2725 34 impatience impatience NN 42759 2725 35 " " '' 42759 2725 36 affects affect VBZ 42759 2725 37 the the DT 42759 2725 38 different different JJ 42759 2725 39 classes class NNS 42759 2725 40 of of IN 42759 2725 41 savers saver NNS 42759 2725 42 . . . 42759 2726 1 With with IN 42759 2726 2 interest interest NN 42759 2726 3 abolished abolish VBN 42759 2726 4 , , , 42759 2726 5 those those DT 42759 2726 6 persons person NNS 42759 2726 7 who who WP 42759 2726 8 were be VBD 42759 2726 9 willing willing JJ 42759 2726 10 to to TO 42759 2726 11 subordinate subordinate VB 42759 2726 12 present present JJ 42759 2726 13 secondary secondary JJ 42759 2726 14 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 42759 2726 15 to to IN 42759 2726 16 the the DT 42759 2726 17 primary primary JJ 42759 2726 18 future future JJ 42759 2726 19 needs need NNS 42759 2726 20 of of IN 42759 2726 21 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 2726 22 and and CC 42759 2726 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2726 24 families family NNS 42759 2726 25 , , , 42759 2726 26 would would MD 42759 2726 27 save save VB 42759 2726 28 at at RB 42759 2726 29 least least JJS 42759 2726 30 as as RB 42759 2726 31 much much JJ 42759 2726 32 for for IN 42759 2726 33 these these DT 42759 2726 34 purposes purpose NNS 42759 2726 35 as as IN 42759 2726 36 when when WRB 42759 2726 37 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2726 38 could could MD 42759 2726 39 have have VB 42759 2726 40 obtained obtain VBN 42759 2726 41 interest interest NN 42759 2726 42 . . . 42759 2727 1 Most Most JJS 42759 2727 2 of of IN 42759 2727 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2727 4 would would MD 42759 2727 5 probably probably RB 42759 2727 6 save save VB 42759 2727 7 more more JJR 42759 2727 8 in in IN 42759 2727 9 order order NN 42759 2727 10 to to TO 42759 2727 11 render render VB 42759 2727 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2727 13 future future JJ 42759 2727 14 provision provision NN 42759 2727 15 as as RB 42759 2727 16 nearly nearly RB 42759 2727 17 as as IN 42759 2727 18 possible possible JJ 42759 2727 19 equal equal JJ 42759 2727 20 to to IN 42759 2727 21 what what WP 42759 2727 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2727 23 would would MD 42759 2727 24 have have VB 42759 2727 25 been be VBN 42759 2727 26 had have VBN 42759 2727 27 interest interest NN 42759 2727 28 accrued accrue VBN 42759 2727 29 on on IN 42759 2727 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2727 31 annual annual JJ 42759 2727 32 savings saving NNS 42759 2727 33 . . . 42759 2728 1 Whether whether IN 42759 2728 2 a a DT 42759 2728 3 person person NN 42759 2728 4 intended intend VBN 42759 2728 5 to to TO 42759 2728 6 leave leave VB 42759 2728 7 all all PDT 42759 2728 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2728 9 accumulations accumulation NNS 42759 2728 10 , , , 42759 2728 11 or or CC 42759 2728 12 part part NN 42759 2728 13 of of IN 42759 2728 14 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2728 15 , , , 42759 2728 16 or or CC 42759 2728 17 none none NN 42759 2728 18 of of IN 42759 2728 19 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2728 20 to to IN 42759 2728 21 posterity posterity NN 42759 2728 22 , , , 42759 2728 23 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2728 24 would would MD 42759 2728 25 still still RB 42759 2728 26 desire desire VB 42759 2728 27 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2728 28 to to TO 42759 2728 29 be be VB 42759 2728 30 as as RB 42759 2728 31 large large JJ 42759 2728 32 as as IN 42759 2728 33 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2728 34 might may MD 42759 2728 35 have have VB 42759 2728 36 been be VBN 42759 2728 37 in in IN 42759 2728 38 a a DT 42759 2728 39 régime régime NN 42759 2728 40 of of IN 42759 2728 41 interest interest NN 42759 2728 42 . . . 42759 2729 1 In in IN 42759 2729 2 order order NN 42759 2729 3 to to TO 42759 2729 4 realise realise VB 42759 2729 5 this this DT 42759 2729 6 desire desire NN 42759 2729 7 , , , 42759 2729 8 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2729 9 would would MD 42759 2729 10 be be VB 42759 2729 11 compelled compel VBN 42759 2729 12 to to TO 42759 2729 13 increase increase VB 42759 2729 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2729 15 savings saving NNS 42759 2729 16 . . . 42759 2730 1 And and CC 42759 2730 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2730 3 is be VBZ 42759 2730 4 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2730 5 to to TO 42759 2730 6 expect expect VB 42759 2730 7 that that IN 42759 2730 8 this this DT 42759 2730 9 is be VBZ 42759 2730 10 precisely precisely RB 42759 2730 11 the the DT 42759 2730 12 course course NN 42759 2730 13 that that WDT 42759 2730 14 would would MD 42759 2730 15 be be VB 42759 2730 16 followed follow VBN 42759 2730 17 by by IN 42759 2730 18 men man NNS 42759 2730 19 of of IN 42759 2730 20 average average JJ 42759 2730 21 thrift thrift NN 42759 2730 22 and and CC 42759 2730 23 foresight foresight NN 42759 2730 24 . . . 42759 2731 1 Such such JJ 42759 2731 2 men man NNS 42759 2731 3 regard regard VBP 42759 2731 4 future future JJ 42759 2731 5 necessaries necessary NNS 42759 2731 6 and and CC 42759 2731 7 comforts comfort NNS 42759 2731 8 , , , 42759 2731 9 whether whether IN 42759 2731 10 for for IN 42759 2731 11 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 2731 12 or or CC 42759 2731 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2731 14 children child NNS 42759 2731 15 , , , 42759 2731 16 as as IN 42759 2731 17 more more RBR 42759 2731 18 important important JJ 42759 2731 19 than than IN 42759 2731 20 present present JJ 42759 2731 21 non non JJ 42759 2731 22 - - NNS 42759 2731 23 essentials essential NNS 42759 2731 24 and and CC 42759 2731 25 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 2731 26 . . . 42759 2732 1 Interest interest NN 42759 2732 2 or or CC 42759 2732 3 no no DT 42759 2732 4 interest interest NN 42759 2732 5 , , , 42759 2732 6 prudent prudent JJ 42759 2732 7 men man NNS 42759 2732 8 will will MD 42759 2732 9 subordinate subordinate VB 42759 2732 10 the the DT 42759 2732 11 latter latter JJ 42759 2732 12 goods good NNS 42759 2732 13 to to IN 42759 2732 14 the the DT 42759 2732 15 former former JJ 42759 2732 16 , , , 42759 2732 17 and and CC 42759 2732 18 will will MD 42759 2732 19 save save VB 42759 2732 20 money money NN 42759 2732 21 accordingly accordingly RB 42759 2732 22 . . . 42759 2733 1 When when WRB 42759 2733 2 , , , 42759 2733 3 however however RB 42759 2733 4 , , , 42759 2733 5 both both DT 42759 2733 6 future future NN 42759 2733 7 and and CC 42759 2733 8 present present JJ 42759 2733 9 goods good NNS 42759 2733 10 are be VBP 42759 2733 11 of of IN 42759 2733 12 the the DT 42759 2733 13 same same JJ 42759 2733 14 order order NN 42759 2733 15 and and CC 42759 2733 16 importance importance NN 42759 2733 17 , , , 42759 2733 18 the the DT 42759 2733 19 future future NN 42759 2733 20 is be VBZ 42759 2733 21 no no RB 42759 2733 22 longer long RBR 42759 2733 23 preferred prefer VBN 42759 2733 24 to to IN 42759 2733 25 the the DT 42759 2733 26 present present NN 42759 2733 27 . . . 42759 2734 1 In in IN 42759 2734 2 that that DT 42759 2734 3 case case NN 42759 2734 4 the the DT 42759 2734 5 preference preference NN 42759 2734 6 is be VBZ 42759 2734 7 reversed reverse VBN 42759 2734 8 . . . 42759 2735 1 The the DT 42759 2735 2 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 2735 3 of of IN 42759 2735 4 to to IN 42759 2735 5 - - HYPH 42759 2735 6 day day NN 42759 2735 7 are be VBP 42759 2735 8 more more RBR 42759 2735 9 keenly keenly RB 42759 2735 10 prized prize VBN 42759 2735 11 than than IN 42759 2735 12 the the DT 42759 2735 13 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 2735 14 of of IN 42759 2735 15 to to IN 42759 2735 16 - - HYPH 42759 2735 17 morrow morrow NNP 42759 2735 18 . . . 42759 2736 1 If if IN 42759 2736 2 the the DT 42759 2736 3 latter latter JJ 42759 2736 4 are be VBP 42759 2736 5 to to TO 42759 2736 6 be be VB 42759 2736 7 preferred prefer VBN 42759 2736 8 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2736 9 must must MD 42759 2736 10 possess possess VB 42759 2736 11 some some DT 42759 2736 12 advantage advantage NN 42759 2736 13 over over IN 42759 2736 14 the the DT 42759 2736 15 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 2736 16 that that WDT 42759 2736 17 might may MD 42759 2736 18 be be VB 42759 2736 19 obtained obtain VBN 42759 2736 20 here here RB 42759 2736 21 and and CC 42759 2736 22 now now RB 42759 2736 23 . . . 42759 2737 1 Such such JJ 42759 2737 2 advantage advantage NN 42759 2737 3 may may MD 42759 2737 4 arise arise VB 42759 2737 5 in in IN 42759 2737 6 various various JJ 42759 2737 7 ways way NNS 42759 2737 8 ; ; : 42759 2737 9 for for IN 42759 2737 10 example example NN 42759 2737 11 , , , 42759 2737 12 when when WRB 42759 2737 13 a a DT 42759 2737 14 man man NN 42759 2737 15 decides decide VBZ 42759 2737 16 that that IN 42759 2737 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2737 18 will will MD 42759 2737 19 have have VB 42759 2737 20 more more JJR 42759 2737 21 leisure leisure NN 42759 2737 22 for for IN 42759 2737 23 a a DT 42759 2737 24 foreign foreign JJ 42759 2737 25 journey journey NN 42759 2737 26 two two CD 42759 2737 27 years year NNS 42759 2737 28 hence hence RB 42759 2737 29 than than IN 42759 2737 30 this this DT 42759 2737 31 year year NN 42759 2737 32 , , , 42759 2737 33 or or CC 42759 2737 34 when when WRB 42759 2737 35 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2737 36 prefers prefer VBZ 42759 2737 37 a a DT 42759 2737 38 large large JJ 42759 2737 39 amount amount NN 42759 2737 40 of of IN 42759 2737 41 future future JJ 42759 2737 42 enjoyment enjoyment NN 42759 2737 43 at at IN 42759 2737 44 one one CD 42759 2737 45 time time NN 42759 2737 46 to to TO 42759 2737 47 present present VB 42759 2737 48 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 42759 2737 49 taken take VBN 42759 2737 50 in in IN 42759 2737 51 small small JJ 42759 2737 52 doses dose NNS 42759 2737 53 . . . 42759 2738 1 But but CC 42759 2738 2 the the DT 42759 2738 3 most most RBS 42759 2738 4 general general JJ 42759 2738 5 method method NN 42759 2738 6 of of IN 42759 2738 7 conferring confer VBG 42759 2738 8 advantage advantage NN 42759 2738 9 upon upon IN 42759 2738 10 the the DT 42759 2738 11 secondary secondary JJ 42759 2738 12 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 42759 2738 13 of of IN 42759 2738 14 the the DT 42759 2738 15 future future NN 42759 2738 16 as as IN 42759 2738 17 compared compare VBN 42759 2738 18 with with IN 42759 2738 19 those those DT 42759 2738 20 of of IN 42759 2738 21 the the DT 42759 2738 22 present present NN 42759 2738 23 , , , 42759 2738 24 is be VBZ 42759 2738 25 to to TO 42759 2738 26 increase increase VB 42759 2738 27 the the DT 42759 2738 28 quantity quantity NN 42759 2738 29 . . . 42759 2739 1 The the DT 42759 2739 2 majority majority NN 42759 2739 3 of of IN 42759 2739 4 foreseeing foresee VBG 42759 2739 5 persons person NNS 42759 2739 6 are be VBP 42759 2739 7 willing willing JJ 42759 2739 8 to to TO 42759 2739 9 pass pass VB 42759 2739 10 by by IN 42759 2739 11 one one CD 42759 2739 12 hundred hundred CD 42759 2739 13 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2739 14 ' ' POS 42759 2739 15 worth worth NN 42759 2739 16 of of IN 42759 2739 17 enjoyment enjoyment NN 42759 2739 18 now now RB 42759 2739 19 for for IN 42759 2739 20 the the DT 42759 2739 21 sake sake NN 42759 2739 22 of of IN 42759 2739 23 one one CD 42759 2739 24 hundred hundred CD 42759 2739 25 and and CC 42759 2739 26 five five CD 42759 2739 27 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2739 28 ' ' POS 42759 2739 29 worth worth JJ 42759 2739 30 one one CD 42759 2739 31 year year NN 42759 2739 32 hence hence RB 42759 2739 33 . . . 42759 2740 1 This this DT 42759 2740 2 advantage advantage NN 42759 2740 3 of of IN 42759 2740 4 quantity quantity NN 42759 2740 5 is be VBZ 42759 2740 6 provided provide VBN 42759 2740 7 through through IN 42759 2740 8 the the DT 42759 2740 9 receipt receipt NN 42759 2740 10 of of IN 42759 2740 11 interest interest NN 42759 2740 12 . . . 42759 2741 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2741 2 affects affect VBZ 42759 2741 3 all all PDT 42759 2741 4 those those DT 42759 2741 5 persons person NNS 42759 2741 6 whose whose WP$ 42759 2741 7 saving saving NN 42759 2741 8 , , , 42759 2741 9 as as IN 42759 2741 10 noted note VBN 42759 2741 11 in in IN 42759 2741 12 the the DT 42759 2741 13 last last JJ 42759 2741 14 chapter chapter NN 42759 2741 15 , , , 42759 2741 16 involves involve VBZ 42759 2741 17 a a DT 42759 2741 18 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2741 19 for for IN 42759 2741 20 which which WDT 42759 2741 21 the the DT 42759 2741 22 only only JJ 42759 2741 23 adequate adequate JJ 42759 2741 24 compensation compensation NN 42759 2741 25 is be VBZ 42759 2741 26 interest interest NN 42759 2741 27 , , , 42759 2741 28 and and CC 42759 2741 29 likewise likewise RB 42759 2741 30 all all PDT 42759 2741 31 those those DT 42759 2741 32 persons person NNS 42759 2741 33 who who WP 42759 2741 34 are be VBP 42759 2741 35 in in IN 42759 2741 36 a a DT 42759 2741 37 position position NN 42759 2741 38 to to TO 42759 2741 39 choose choose VB 42759 2741 40 between between IN 42759 2741 41 present present JJ 42759 2741 42 and and CC 42759 2741 43 future future JJ 42759 2741 44 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 2741 45 . . . 42759 2742 1 Were be VBD 42759 2742 2 interest interest NN 42759 2742 3 suppressed suppress VBD 42759 2742 4 these these DT 42759 2742 5 classes class NNS 42759 2742 6 of of IN 42759 2742 7 persons person NNS 42759 2742 8 would would MD 42759 2742 9 cease cease VB 42759 2742 10 to to TO 42759 2742 11 save save VB 42759 2742 12 for for IN 42759 2742 13 this this DT 42759 2742 14 kind kind NN 42759 2742 15 of of IN 42759 2742 16 future future JJ 42759 2742 17 goods good NNS 42759 2742 18 . . . 42759 2743 1 According accord VBG 42759 2743 2 to to IN 42759 2743 3 Professor Professor NNP 42759 2743 4 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 2743 5 , , , 42759 2743 6 " " `` 42759 2743 7 most most JJS 42759 2743 8 saving saving NN 42759 2743 9 is be VBZ 42759 2743 10 done do VBN 42759 2743 11 by by IN 42759 2743 12 the the DT 42759 2743 13 well well RB 42759 2743 14 - - HYPH 42759 2743 15 to to TO 42759 2743 16 - - HYPH 42759 2743 17 do do VB 42759 2743 18 and and CC 42759 2743 19 the the DT 42759 2743 20 rich rich JJ 42759 2743 21 . . . 42759 2744 1 " " `` 42759 2744 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2744 3 145 145 CD 42759 2744 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2744 5 On on IN 42759 2744 6 this this DT 42759 2744 7 hypothesis hypothesis NN 42759 2744 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2744 9 seems seem VBZ 42759 2744 10 probable probable JJ 42759 2744 11 that that IN 42759 2744 12 the the DT 42759 2744 13 abolition abolition NN 42759 2744 14 of of IN 42759 2744 15 interest interest NN 42759 2744 16 would would MD 42759 2744 17 diminish diminish VB 42759 2744 18 the the DT 42759 2744 19 savings saving NNS 42759 2744 20 and and CC 42759 2744 21 capital capital NN 42759 2744 22 of of IN 42759 2744 23 the the DT 42759 2744 24 community community NN 42759 2744 25 very very RB 42759 2744 26 considerably considerably RB 42759 2744 27 ; ; , 42759 2744 28 for for IN 42759 2744 29 the the DT 42759 2744 30 accumulations accumulation NNS 42759 2744 31 of of IN 42759 2744 32 the the DT 42759 2744 33 wealthy wealthy JJ 42759 2744 34 are be VBP 42759 2744 35 derived derive VBN 42759 2744 36 mainly mainly RB 42759 2744 37 from from IN 42759 2744 38 interest interest NN 42759 2744 39 rather rather RB 42759 2744 40 than than IN 42759 2744 41 from from IN 42759 2744 42 salaries salary NNS 42759 2744 43 . . . 42759 2745 1 On on IN 42759 2745 2 the the DT 42759 2745 3 other other JJ 42759 2745 4 hand hand NN 42759 2745 5 , , , 42759 2745 6 the the DT 42759 2745 7 suppression suppression NN 42759 2745 8 of of IN 42759 2745 9 interest interest NN 42759 2745 10 should should MD 42759 2745 11 bring bring VB 42759 2745 12 about about RP 42759 2745 13 a a DT 42759 2745 14 much much RB 42759 2745 15 wider wide JJR 42759 2745 16 diffusion diffusion NN 42759 2745 17 of of IN 42759 2745 18 wealth wealth NN 42759 2745 19 . . . 42759 2746 1 The the DT 42759 2746 2 sums sum NNS 42759 2746 3 formerly formerly RB 42759 2746 4 paid pay VBD 42759 2746 5 out out RP 42759 2746 6 as as IN 42759 2746 7 interest interest NN 42759 2746 8 , , , 42759 2746 9 would would MD 42759 2746 10 be be VB 42759 2746 11 distributed distribute VBN 42759 2746 12 among among IN 42759 2746 13 the the DT 42759 2746 14 masses masse NNS 42759 2746 15 of of IN 42759 2746 16 the the DT 42759 2746 17 population population NN 42759 2746 18 as as IN 42759 2746 19 increased increase VBN 42759 2746 20 wages wage NNS 42759 2746 21 and and CC 42759 2746 22 reduced reduce VBN 42759 2746 23 costs cost NNS 42759 2746 24 of of IN 42759 2746 25 living living NN 42759 2746 26 . . . 42759 2747 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2747 2 the the DT 42759 2747 3 masses masse NNS 42759 2747 4 would would MD 42759 2747 5 possess possess VB 42759 2747 6 an an DT 42759 2747 7 immensely immensely RB 42759 2747 8 increased increase VBN 42759 2747 9 capacity capacity NN 42759 2747 10 for for IN 42759 2747 11 saving saving NN 42759 2747 12 , , , 42759 2747 13 which which WDT 42759 2747 14 might may MD 42759 2747 15 offset offset VB 42759 2747 16 or or CC 42759 2747 17 even even RB 42759 2747 18 exceed exceed VB 42759 2747 19 the the DT 42759 2747 20 loss loss NN 42759 2747 21 of of IN 42759 2747 22 saving saving NN 42759 2747 23 - - HYPH 42759 2747 24 power power NN 42759 2747 25 among among IN 42759 2747 26 those those DT 42759 2747 27 who who WP 42759 2747 28 now now RB 42759 2747 29 receive receive VBP 42759 2747 30 interest interest NN 42759 2747 31 - - HYPH 42759 2747 32 incomes income NNS 42759 2747 33 . . . 42759 2748 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2748 2 146 146 CD 42759 2748 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2748 4 To to TO 42759 2748 5 sum sum VB 42759 2748 6 up up RP 42759 2748 7 the the DT 42759 2748 8 results result NNS 42759 2748 9 of of IN 42759 2748 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2748 11 inquiry inquiry NN 42759 2748 12 concerning concern VBG 42759 2748 13 the the DT 42759 2748 14 necessity necessity NN 42759 2748 15 of of IN 42759 2748 16 interest interest NN 42759 2748 17 : : : 42759 2748 18 The the DT 42759 2748 19 fact fact NN 42759 2748 20 that that IN 42759 2748 21 men man NNS 42759 2748 22 now now RB 42759 2748 23 receive receive VBP 42759 2748 24 interest interest NN 42759 2748 25 does do VBZ 42759 2748 26 not not RB 42759 2748 27 prove prove VB 42759 2748 28 that that IN 42759 2748 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2748 30 would would MD 42759 2748 31 not not RB 42759 2748 32 save save VB 42759 2748 33 without without IN 42759 2748 34 interest interest NN 42759 2748 35 . . . 42759 2749 1 The the DT 42759 2749 2 fact fact NN 42759 2749 3 that that IN 42759 2749 4 many many JJ 42759 2749 5 men man NNS 42759 2749 6 would would MD 42759 2749 7 certainly certainly RB 42759 2749 8 save save VB 42759 2749 9 without without IN 42759 2749 10 interest interest NN 42759 2749 11 does do VBZ 42759 2749 12 not not RB 42759 2749 13 prove prove VB 42759 2749 14 that that IN 42759 2749 15 a a DT 42759 2749 16 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2749 17 amount amount NN 42759 2749 18 would would MD 42759 2749 19 be be VB 42759 2749 20 saved save VBN 42759 2749 21 to to TO 42759 2749 22 provide provide VB 42759 2749 23 the the DT 42759 2749 24 community community NN 42759 2749 25 with with IN 42759 2749 26 the the DT 42759 2749 27 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2749 28 supply supply NN 42759 2749 29 of of IN 42759 2749 30 capital capital NN 42759 2749 31 . . . 42759 2750 1 Whether whether IN 42759 2750 2 the the DT 42759 2750 3 savings saving NNS 42759 2750 4 of of IN 42759 2750 5 those those DT 42759 2750 6 classes class NNS 42759 2750 7 that that WDT 42759 2750 8 increased increase VBD 42759 2750 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2750 10 accumulations accumulation NNS 42759 2750 11 would would MD 42759 2750 12 counteract counteract VB 42759 2750 13 the the DT 42759 2750 14 decreases decrease NNS 42759 2750 15 in in IN 42759 2750 16 the the DT 42759 2750 17 saving saving NN 42759 2750 18 of of IN 42759 2750 19 the the DT 42759 2750 20 richer rich JJR 42759 2750 21 classes class NNS 42759 2750 22 , , , 42759 2750 23 is be VBZ 42759 2750 24 a a DT 42759 2750 25 question question NN 42759 2750 26 that that WDT 42759 2750 27 admits admit VBZ 42759 2750 28 of of IN 42759 2750 29 no no DT 42759 2750 30 definite definite JJ 42759 2750 31 or or CC 42759 2750 32 confident confident JJ 42759 2750 33 answer answer NN 42759 2750 34 . . . 42759 2751 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2751 2 The the DT 42759 2751 3 State State NNP 42759 2751 4 Is be VBZ 42759 2751 5 Justified justify VBN 42759 2751 6 in in IN 42759 2751 7 Permitting permit VBG 42759 2751 8 Interest Interest NNP 42759 2751 9 _ _ NNP 42759 2751 10 If if IN 42759 2751 11 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2751 12 assume assume VBP 42759 2751 13 that that IN 42759 2751 14 the the DT 42759 2751 15 suppression suppression NN 42759 2751 16 of of IN 42759 2751 17 interest interest NN 42759 2751 18 would would MD 42759 2751 19 cause cause VB 42759 2751 20 a a DT 42759 2751 21 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2751 22 decline decline NN 42759 2751 23 in in IN 42759 2751 24 saving saving NN 42759 2751 25 and and CC 42759 2751 26 capital capital NN 42759 2751 27 , , , 42759 2751 28 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2751 29 must must MD 42759 2751 30 conclude conclude VB 42759 2751 31 that that IN 42759 2751 32 the the DT 42759 2751 33 community community NN 42759 2751 34 would would MD 42759 2751 35 be be VB 42759 2751 36 worse bad JJR 42759 2751 37 off off RP 42759 2751 38 than than IN 42759 2751 39 under under IN 42759 2751 40 the the DT 42759 2751 41 present present JJ 42759 2751 42 system system NN 42759 2751 43 . . . 42759 2752 1 To to TO 42759 2752 2 diminish diminish VB 42759 2752 3 greatly greatly RB 42759 2752 4 the the DT 42759 2752 5 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2752 6 of of IN 42759 2752 7 production production NN 42759 2752 8 , , , 42759 2752 9 and and CC 42759 2752 10 consequently consequently RB 42759 2752 11 the the DT 42759 2752 12 supply supply NN 42759 2752 13 of of IN 42759 2752 14 goods good NNS 42759 2752 15 for for IN 42759 2752 16 consumption consumption NN 42759 2752 17 , , , 42759 2752 18 would would MD 42759 2752 19 create create VB 42759 2752 20 far far RB 42759 2752 21 more more JJR 42759 2752 22 hardship hardship NN 42759 2752 23 than than IN 42759 2752 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2752 25 would would MD 42759 2752 26 relieve relieve VB 42759 2752 27 . . . 42759 2753 1 While while IN 42759 2753 2 " " `` 42759 2753 3 workless workless NN 42759 2753 4 " " '' 42759 2753 5 incomes income NNS 42759 2753 6 would would MD 42759 2753 7 be be VB 42759 2753 8 suppressed suppress VBN 42759 2753 9 , , , 42759 2753 10 and and CC 42759 2753 11 personal personal JJ 42759 2753 12 incomes income NNS 42759 2753 13 more more RBR 42759 2753 14 nearly nearly RB 42759 2753 15 equalised equalise VBN 42759 2753 16 , , , 42759 2753 17 the the DT 42759 2753 18 total total JJ 42759 2753 19 amount amount NN 42759 2753 20 available available JJ 42759 2753 21 for for IN 42759 2753 22 distribution distribution NN 42759 2753 23 would would MD 42759 2753 24 probably probably RB 42759 2753 25 be be VB 42759 2753 26 so so RB 42759 2753 27 much much RB 42759 2753 28 smaller small JJR 42759 2753 29 as as IN 42759 2753 30 to to TO 42759 2753 31 cause cause VB 42759 2753 32 a a DT 42759 2753 33 deterioration deterioration NN 42759 2753 34 in in IN 42759 2753 35 the the DT 42759 2753 36 condition condition NN 42759 2753 37 of of IN 42759 2753 38 every every DT 42759 2753 39 class class NN 42759 2753 40 . . . 42759 2754 1 In in IN 42759 2754 2 this this DT 42759 2754 3 hypothesis hypothesis NN 42759 2754 4 the the DT 42759 2754 5 State state NN 42759 2754 6 would would MD 42759 2754 7 do do VB 42759 2754 8 wrong wrong NN 42759 2754 9 to to TO 42759 2754 10 abolish abolish VB 42759 2754 11 the the DT 42759 2754 12 system system NN 42759 2754 13 of of IN 42759 2754 14 interest interest NN 42759 2754 15 . . . 42759 2755 1 If if IN 42759 2755 2 , , , 42759 2755 3 however however RB 42759 2755 4 , , , 42759 2755 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2755 6 assume assume VBP 42759 2755 7 that that IN 42759 2755 8 no no DT 42759 2755 9 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2755 10 amount amount NN 42759 2755 11 of of IN 42759 2755 12 evil evil NN 42759 2755 13 would would MD 42759 2755 14 follow follow VB 42759 2755 15 , , , 42759 2755 16 or or CC 42759 2755 17 that that IN 42759 2755 18 the the DT 42759 2755 19 balance balance NN 42759 2755 20 of of IN 42759 2755 21 results result NNS 42759 2755 22 would would MD 42759 2755 23 be be VB 42759 2755 24 favourable favourable JJ 42759 2755 25 , , , 42759 2755 26 the the DT 42759 2755 27 question question NN 42759 2755 28 of of IN 42759 2755 29 the the DT 42759 2755 30 proper proper JJ 42759 2755 31 action action NN 42759 2755 32 of of IN 42759 2755 33 the the DT 42759 2755 34 State state NN 42759 2755 35 becomes become VBZ 42759 2755 36 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 2755 37 complex complex JJ 42759 2755 38 . . . 42759 2756 1 In in IN 42759 2756 2 the the DT 42759 2756 3 first first JJ 42759 2756 4 place place NN 42759 2756 5 , , , 42759 2756 6 interest interest NN 42759 2756 7 could could MD 42759 2756 8 not not RB 42759 2756 9 rightfully rightfully RB 42759 2756 10 be be VB 42759 2756 11 suppressed suppress VBN 42759 2756 12 while while IN 42759 2756 13 the the DT 42759 2756 14 private private JJ 42759 2756 15 taking taking NN 42759 2756 16 of of IN 42759 2756 17 rent rent NN 42759 2756 18 remained remain VBD 42759 2756 19 . . . 42759 2757 1 To to TO 42759 2757 2 adopt adopt VB 42759 2757 3 such such PDT 42759 2757 4 a a DT 42759 2757 5 course course NN 42759 2757 6 would would MD 42759 2757 7 be be VB 42759 2757 8 to to TO 42759 2757 9 treat treat VB 42759 2757 10 the the DT 42759 2757 11 receivers receiver NNS 42759 2757 12 of of IN 42759 2757 13 property property NN 42759 2757 14 incomes income NNS 42759 2757 15 inequitably inequitably RB 42759 2757 16 . . . 42759 2758 1 Landowners landowner NNS 42759 2758 2 would would MD 42759 2758 3 continue continue VB 42759 2758 4 to to TO 42759 2758 5 receive receive VB 42759 2758 6 an an DT 42759 2758 7 income income NN 42759 2758 8 from from IN 42759 2758 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2758 10 property property NN 42759 2758 11 , , , 42759 2758 12 while while IN 42759 2758 13 capital capital NN 42759 2758 14 owners owner NNS 42759 2758 15 would would MD 42759 2758 16 not not RB 42759 2758 17 ; ; : 42759 2758 18 yet yet RB 42759 2758 19 the the DT 42759 2758 20 moral moral JJ 42759 2758 21 claims claim NNS 42759 2758 22 of of IN 42759 2758 23 the the DT 42759 2758 24 former former JJ 42759 2758 25 to to IN 42759 2758 26 income income NN 42759 2758 27 are be VBP 42759 2758 28 no no RB 42759 2758 29 better well JJR 42759 2758 30 than than IN 42759 2758 31 those those DT 42759 2758 32 of of IN 42759 2758 33 the the DT 42759 2758 34 latter latter JJ 42759 2758 35 . . . 42759 2759 1 In in IN 42759 2759 2 the the DT 42759 2759 3 second second JJ 42759 2759 4 place place NN 42759 2759 5 , , , 42759 2759 6 the the DT 42759 2759 7 State state NN 42759 2759 8 would would MD 42759 2759 9 be be VB 42759 2759 10 obliged oblige VBN 42759 2759 11 to to TO 42759 2759 12 compensate compensate VB 42759 2759 13 the the DT 42759 2759 14 owners owner NNS 42759 2759 15 of of IN 42759 2759 16 existing exist VBG 42759 2759 17 capital capital NN 42759 2759 18 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2759 19 for for IN 42759 2759 20 the the DT 42759 2759 21 decline decline NN 42759 2759 22 in in IN 42759 2759 23 value value NN 42759 2759 24 which which WDT 42759 2759 25 , , , 42759 2759 26 as as IN 42759 2759 27 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2759 28 have have VBP 42759 2759 29 already already RB 42759 2759 30 seen see VBN 42759 2759 31 , , , 42759 2759 32 would would MD 42759 2759 33 occur occur VB 42759 2759 34 when when WRB 42759 2759 35 the the DT 42759 2759 36 item item NN 42759 2759 37 of of IN 42759 2759 38 interest interest NN 42759 2759 39 was be VBD 42759 2759 40 eliminated eliminate VBN 42759 2759 41 from from IN 42759 2759 42 the the DT 42759 2759 43 cost cost NN 42759 2759 44 of of IN 42759 2759 45 reproducing reproduce VBG 42759 2759 46 such such JJ 42759 2759 47 capital capital NN 42759 2759 48 instruments instrument NNS 42759 2759 49 . . . 42759 2760 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2760 2 would would MD 42759 2760 3 likewise likewise RB 42759 2760 4 be be VB 42759 2760 5 under under IN 42759 2760 6 moral moral JJ 42759 2760 7 obligation obligation NN 42759 2760 8 to to TO 42759 2760 9 compensate compensate VB 42759 2760 10 landowners landowner NNS 42759 2760 11 for for IN 42759 2760 12 whatever whatever WDT 42759 2760 13 decrease decrease NN 42759 2760 14 in in IN 42759 2760 15 value value NN 42759 2760 16 befell befell VBP 42759 2760 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2760 18 property property NN 42759 2760 19 as as IN 42759 2760 20 a a DT 42759 2760 21 result result NN 42759 2760 22 of of IN 42759 2760 23 the the DT 42759 2760 24 abolition abolition NN 42759 2760 25 of of IN 42759 2760 26 rent rent NN 42759 2760 27 . . . 42759 2761 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2761 2 , , , 42759 2761 3 the the DT 42759 2761 4 practical practical JJ 42759 2761 5 difficulties difficulty NNS 42759 2761 6 confronting confront VBG 42759 2761 7 the the DT 42759 2761 8 legal legal JJ 42759 2761 9 abolition abolition NN 42759 2761 10 of of IN 42759 2761 11 interest interest NN 42759 2761 12 are be VBP 42759 2761 13 apparently apparently RB 42759 2761 14 so so RB 42759 2761 15 great great JJ 42759 2761 16 as as IN 42759 2761 17 to to TO 42759 2761 18 render render VB 42759 2761 19 the the DT 42759 2761 20 attempt attempt NN 42759 2761 21 socially socially RB 42759 2761 22 unwise unwise JJ 42759 2761 23 and and CC 42759 2761 24 futile futile JJ 42759 2761 25 . . . 42759 2762 1 In in IN 42759 2762 2 order order NN 42759 2762 3 to to TO 42759 2762 4 be be VB 42759 2762 5 effective effective JJ 42759 2762 6 the the DT 42759 2762 7 prohibition prohibition NN 42759 2762 8 would would MD 42759 2762 9 have have VB 42759 2762 10 to to TO 42759 2762 11 be be VB 42759 2762 12 international international JJ 42759 2762 13 . . . 42759 2763 1 Were be VBD 42759 2763 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2763 3 enforced enforce VBN 42759 2763 4 in in IN 42759 2763 5 only only RB 42759 2763 6 one one CD 42759 2763 7 or or CC 42759 2763 8 in in IN 42759 2763 9 a a DT 42759 2763 10 few few JJ 42759 2763 11 countries country NNS 42759 2763 12 , , , 42759 2763 13 these these DT 42759 2763 14 would would MD 42759 2763 15 suffer suffer VB 42759 2763 16 far far RB 42759 2763 17 more more RBR 42759 2763 18 through through IN 42759 2763 19 the the DT 42759 2763 20 flight flight NN 42759 2763 21 of of IN 42759 2763 22 capital capital NN 42759 2763 23 than than IN 42759 2763 24 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2763 25 would would MD 42759 2763 26 gain gain VB 42759 2763 27 through through IN 42759 2763 28 the the DT 42759 2763 29 abolition abolition NN 42759 2763 30 of of IN 42759 2763 31 interest interest NN 42759 2763 32 . . . 42759 2764 1 The the DT 42759 2764 2 technical technical JJ 42759 2764 3 obstacles obstacle NNS 42759 2764 4 in in IN 42759 2764 5 any any DT 42759 2764 6 case case NN 42759 2764 7 would would MD 42759 2764 8 be be VB 42759 2764 9 well well RB 42759 2764 10 nigh nigh NN 42759 2764 11 insuperable insuperable JJ 42759 2764 12 . . . 42759 2765 1 If if IN 42759 2765 2 the the DT 42759 2765 3 attempt attempt NN 42759 2765 4 were be VBD 42759 2765 5 made make VBN 42759 2765 6 to to TO 42759 2765 7 suppress suppress VB 42759 2765 8 interest interest NN 42759 2765 9 on on IN 42759 2765 10 producing produce VBG 42759 2765 11 capital capital NN 42759 2765 12 , , , 42759 2765 13 as as RB 42759 2765 14 well well RB 42759 2765 15 as as IN 42759 2765 16 on on IN 42759 2765 17 loans loan NNS 42759 2765 18 , , , 42759 2765 19 the the DT 42759 2765 20 civil civil JJ 42759 2765 21 authorities authority NNS 42759 2765 22 would would MD 42759 2765 23 be be VB 42759 2765 24 unable unable JJ 42759 2765 25 to to TO 42759 2765 26 determine determine VB 42759 2765 27 with with IN 42759 2765 28 any any DT 42759 2765 29 degree degree NN 42759 2765 30 of of IN 42759 2765 31 precision precision NN 42759 2765 32 what what WDT 42759 2765 33 part part NN 42759 2765 34 of of IN 42759 2765 35 the the DT 42759 2765 36 gross gross JJ 42759 2765 37 returns return NNS 42759 2765 38 of of IN 42759 2765 39 a a DT 42759 2765 40 business business NN 42759 2765 41 was be VBD 42759 2765 42 pure pure JJ 42759 2765 43 interest interest NN 42759 2765 44 , , , 42759 2765 45 and and CC 42759 2765 46 what what WP 42759 2765 47 part part NN 42759 2765 48 was be VBD 42759 2765 49 a a DT 42759 2765 50 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2765 51 compensation compensation NN 42759 2765 52 for for IN 42759 2765 53 risk risk NN 42759 2765 54 and and CC 42759 2765 55 the the DT 42759 2765 56 labour labour NN 42759 2765 57 of of IN 42759 2765 58 management management NN 42759 2765 59 . . . 42759 2766 1 Should Should MD 42759 2766 2 the the DT 42759 2766 3 State State NNP 42759 2766 4 try try VB 42759 2766 5 to to TO 42759 2766 6 solve solve VB 42759 2766 7 this this DT 42759 2766 8 problem problem NN 42759 2766 9 by by IN 42759 2766 10 allowing allow VBG 42759 2766 11 the the DT 42759 2766 12 directors director NNS 42759 2766 13 of of IN 42759 2766 14 industry industry NN 42759 2766 15 varying varying NN 42759 2766 16 salaries salary NNS 42759 2766 17 to to TO 42759 2766 18 correspond correspond VB 42759 2766 19 with with IN 42759 2766 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2766 21 comparative comparative JJ 42759 2766 22 degrees degree NNS 42759 2766 23 of of IN 42759 2766 24 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 2766 25 , , , 42759 2766 26 and and CC 42759 2766 27 different different JJ 42759 2766 28 rates rate NNS 42759 2766 29 of of IN 42759 2766 30 insurance insurance NN 42759 2766 31 - - HYPH 42759 2766 32 payments payment NNS 42759 2766 33 to to TO 42759 2766 34 represent represent VB 42759 2766 35 the the DT 42759 2766 36 different different JJ 42759 2766 37 risks risk NNS 42759 2766 38 , , , 42759 2766 39 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2766 40 would would MD 42759 2766 41 inevitably inevitably RB 42759 2766 42 make make VB 42759 2766 43 some some DT 42759 2766 44 allowances allowance NNS 42759 2766 45 so so RB 42759 2766 46 low low JJ 42759 2766 47 as as IN 42759 2766 48 to to TO 42759 2766 49 discourage discourage VB 42759 2766 50 labour labour NN 42759 2766 51 and and CC 42759 2766 52 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 2766 53 , , , 42759 2766 54 and and CC 42759 2766 55 others other NNS 42759 2766 56 so so RB 42759 2766 57 high high RB 42759 2766 58 as as IN 42759 2766 59 to to TO 42759 2766 60 give give VB 42759 2766 61 the the DT 42759 2766 62 recipients recipient NNS 42759 2766 63 a a DT 42759 2766 64 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2766 65 amount amount NN 42759 2766 66 of of IN 42759 2766 67 pure pure JJ 42759 2766 68 interest interest NN 42759 2766 69 in in IN 42759 2766 70 the the DT 42759 2766 71 guise guise NN 42759 2766 72 of of IN 42759 2766 73 profits profit NNS 42759 2766 74 and and CC 42759 2766 75 salaries salary NNS 42759 2766 76 . . . 42759 2767 1 Should Should MD 42759 2767 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2767 3 fix fix VB 42759 2767 4 a a DT 42759 2767 5 flat flat JJ 42759 2767 6 rate rate NN 42759 2767 7 of of IN 42759 2767 8 salaries salary NNS 42759 2767 9 and and CC 42759 2767 10 profits profit NNS 42759 2767 11 , , , 42759 2767 12 the the DT 42759 2767 13 more more RBR 42759 2767 14 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2767 15 undertakers undertaker NNS 42759 2767 16 would would MD 42759 2767 17 refuse refuse VB 42759 2767 18 to to TO 42759 2767 19 put put VB 42759 2767 20 forth forth RP 42759 2767 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2767 22 best good JJS 42759 2767 23 efforts effort NNS 42759 2767 24 , , , 42759 2767 25 and and CC 42759 2767 26 the the DT 42759 2767 27 more more RBR 42759 2767 28 perilous perilous JJ 42759 2767 29 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 2767 30 would would MD 42759 2767 31 not not RB 42759 2767 32 be be VB 42759 2767 33 undertaken undertake VBN 42759 2767 34 . . . 42759 2768 1 The the DT 42759 2768 2 supervision supervision NN 42759 2768 3 of of IN 42759 2768 4 expenses expense NNS 42759 2768 5 , , , 42759 2768 6 receipts receipt NNS 42759 2768 7 , , , 42759 2768 8 and and CC 42759 2768 9 other other JJ 42759 2768 10 details detail NNS 42759 2768 11 of of IN 42759 2768 12 business business NN 42759 2768 13 that that WDT 42759 2768 14 would would MD 42759 2768 15 be be VB 42759 2768 16 required require VBN 42759 2768 17 to to TO 42759 2768 18 prevent prevent VB 42759 2768 19 evasion evasion NN 42759 2768 20 of of IN 42759 2768 21 the the DT 42759 2768 22 law law NN 42759 2768 23 , , , 42759 2768 24 would would MD 42759 2768 25 not not RB 42759 2768 26 improbably improbably RB 42759 2768 27 cost cost VB 42759 2768 28 more more JJR 42759 2768 29 than than IN 42759 2768 30 the the DT 42759 2768 31 total total JJ 42759 2768 32 amount amount NN 42759 2768 33 now now RB 42759 2768 34 paid pay VBN 42759 2768 35 in in IN 42759 2768 36 the the DT 42759 2768 37 form form NN 42759 2768 38 of of IN 42759 2768 39 interest interest NN 42759 2768 40 . . . 42759 2769 1 On on IN 42759 2769 2 the the DT 42759 2769 3 other other JJ 42759 2769 4 hand hand NN 42759 2769 5 , , , 42759 2769 6 if if IN 42759 2769 7 the the DT 42759 2769 8 method method NN 42759 2769 9 of of IN 42759 2769 10 suppression suppression NN 42759 2769 11 were be VBD 42759 2769 12 confined confine VBN 42759 2769 13 to to IN 42759 2769 14 loans loan NNS 42759 2769 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2769 16 would would MD 42759 2769 17 probably probably RB 42759 2769 18 prove prove VB 42759 2769 19 only only RB 42759 2769 20 a a DT 42759 2769 21 little little RB 42759 2769 22 less less RBR 42759 2769 23 futile futile JJ 42759 2769 24 than than IN 42759 2769 25 the the DT 42759 2769 26 effort effort NN 42759 2769 27 to to TO 42759 2769 28 abolish abolish VB 42759 2769 29 interest interest NN 42759 2769 30 on on IN 42759 2769 31 productive productive JJ 42759 2769 32 capital capital NN 42759 2769 33 . . . 42759 2770 1 The the DT 42759 2770 2 great great JJ 42759 2770 3 majority majority NN 42759 2770 4 of of IN 42759 2770 5 those those DT 42759 2770 6 who who WP 42759 2770 7 were be VBD 42759 2770 8 prevented prevent VBN 42759 2770 9 from from IN 42759 2770 10 lending lend VBG 42759 2770 11 at at IN 42759 2770 12 interest interest NN 42759 2770 13 would would MD 42759 2770 14 invest invest VB 42759 2770 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2770 16 money money NN 42759 2770 17 in in IN 42759 2770 18 stocks stock NNS 42759 2770 19 , , , 42759 2770 20 land land NN 42759 2770 21 , , , 42759 2770 22 buildings building NNS 42759 2770 23 , , , 42759 2770 24 and and CC 42759 2770 25 other other JJ 42759 2770 26 forms form NNS 42759 2770 27 of of IN 42759 2770 28 productive productive JJ 42759 2770 29 property property NN 42759 2770 30 . . . 42759 2771 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 2771 2 , , , 42759 2771 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2771 4 is be VBZ 42759 2771 5 probable probable JJ 42759 2771 6 that that IN 42759 2771 7 a a DT 42759 2771 8 large large JJ 42759 2771 9 volume volume NN 42759 2771 10 of of IN 42759 2771 11 loans loan NNS 42759 2771 12 would would MD 42759 2771 13 be be VB 42759 2771 14 made make VBN 42759 2771 15 despite despite IN 42759 2771 16 the the DT 42759 2771 17 prohibition prohibition NN 42759 2771 18 . . . 42759 2772 1 In in IN 42759 2772 2 the the DT 42759 2772 3 Middle Middle NNP 42759 2772 4 Ages Ages NNPS 42759 2772 5 , , , 42759 2772 6 when when WRB 42759 2772 7 the the DT 42759 2772 8 amount amount NN 42759 2772 9 of of IN 42759 2772 10 money money NN 42759 2772 11 available available JJ 42759 2772 12 for for IN 42759 2772 13 lending lending NN 42759 2772 14 was be VBD 42759 2772 15 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 2772 16 small small JJ 42759 2772 17 , , , 42759 2772 18 and and CC 42759 2772 19 when when WRB 42759 2772 20 State State NNP 42759 2772 21 and and CC 42759 2772 22 Church Church NNP 42759 2772 23 and and CC 42759 2772 24 public public JJ 42759 2772 25 opinion opinion NN 42759 2772 26 were be VBD 42759 2772 27 unanimous unanimous JJ 42759 2772 28 in in IN 42759 2772 29 favour favour NN 42759 2772 30 of of IN 42759 2772 31 the the DT 42759 2772 32 policy policy NN 42759 2772 33 , , , 42759 2772 34 the the DT 42759 2772 35 legal legal JJ 42759 2772 36 prohibition prohibition NN 42759 2772 37 of of IN 42759 2772 38 loans loan NNS 42759 2772 39 was be VBD 42759 2772 40 only only RB 42759 2772 41 partially partially RB 42759 2772 42 effective effective JJ 42759 2772 43 . . . 42759 2773 1 Now now RB 42759 2773 2 that that IN 42759 2773 3 the the DT 42759 2773 4 supply supply NN 42759 2773 5 of of IN 42759 2773 6 and and CC 42759 2773 7 the the DT 42759 2773 8 demand demand NN 42759 2773 9 for for IN 42759 2773 10 loans loan NNS 42759 2773 11 have have VBP 42759 2773 12 enormously enormously RB 42759 2773 13 increased increase VBN 42759 2773 14 , , , 42759 2773 15 and and CC 42759 2773 16 interest interest NN 42759 2773 17 is be VBZ 42759 2773 18 not not RB 42759 2773 19 definitely definitely RB 42759 2773 20 disapproved disapprove VBN 42759 2773 21 by by IN 42759 2773 22 the the DT 42759 2773 23 Church Church NNP 42759 2773 24 or or CC 42759 2773 25 the the DT 42759 2773 26 public public NN 42759 2773 27 , , , 42759 2773 28 a a DT 42759 2773 29 similar similar JJ 42759 2773 30 effort effort NN 42759 2773 31 by by IN 42759 2773 32 the the DT 42759 2773 33 State State NNP 42759 2773 34 would would MD 42759 2773 35 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 2773 36 prove prove VB 42759 2773 37 a a DT 42759 2773 38 failure failure NN 42759 2773 39 . . . 42759 2774 1 Even even RB 42759 2774 2 if if IN 42759 2774 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2774 4 were be VBD 42759 2774 5 entirely entirely RB 42759 2774 6 successful successful JJ 42759 2774 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2774 8 would would MD 42759 2774 9 only only RB 42759 2774 10 decrease decrease VB 42759 2774 11 , , , 42759 2774 12 not not RB 42759 2774 13 abolish abolish VB 42759 2774 14 , , , 42759 2774 15 interest interest NN 42759 2774 16 on on IN 42759 2774 17 productive productive JJ 42759 2774 18 capital capital NN 42759 2774 19 . . . 42759 2775 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2775 2 147 147 CD 42759 2775 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2775 4 In in IN 42759 2775 5 view view NN 42759 2775 6 of of IN 42759 2775 7 the the DT 42759 2775 8 manifold manifold JJ 42759 2775 9 and and CC 42759 2775 10 grave grave JJ 42759 2775 11 uncertainties uncertainty NNS 42759 2775 12 of of IN 42759 2775 13 the the DT 42759 2775 14 situation situation NN 42759 2775 15 , , , 42759 2775 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2775 17 is be VBZ 42759 2775 18 practically practically RB 42759 2775 19 certain certain JJ 42759 2775 20 that that IN 42759 2775 21 modern modern JJ 42759 2775 22 States state NNS 42759 2775 23 are be VBP 42759 2775 24 justified justify VBN 42759 2775 25 in in IN 42759 2775 26 permitting permit VBG 42759 2775 27 interest interest NN 42759 2775 28 . . . 42759 2776 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2776 2 Civil Civil NNP 42759 2776 3 Authorisation Authorisation NNP 42759 2776 4 not not RB 42759 2776 5 Sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2776 6 for for IN 42759 2776 7 Individual Individual NNP 42759 2776 8 Justification Justification NNP 42759 2776 9 _ _ NNP 42759 2776 10 This this DT 42759 2776 11 justification justification NN 42759 2776 12 of of IN 42759 2776 13 the the DT 42759 2776 14 attitude attitude NN 42759 2776 15 of of IN 42759 2776 16 the the DT 42759 2776 17 State State NNP 42759 2776 18 does do VBZ 42759 2776 19 not not RB 42759 2776 20 of of IN 42759 2776 21 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2776 22 demonstrate demonstrate VB 42759 2776 23 that that IN 42759 2776 24 the the DT 42759 2776 25 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2776 26 has have VBZ 42759 2776 27 a a DT 42759 2776 28 right right NN 42759 2776 29 to to TO 42759 2776 30 accept accept VB 42759 2776 31 interest interest NN 42759 2776 32 . . . 42759 2777 1 The the DT 42759 2777 2 civil civil JJ 42759 2777 3 law law NN 42759 2777 4 tolerates tolerate VBZ 42759 2777 5 many many JJ 42759 2777 6 actions action NNS 42759 2777 7 which which WDT 42759 2777 8 are be VBP 42759 2777 9 morally morally RB 42759 2777 10 wrong wrong JJ 42759 2777 11 in in IN 42759 2777 12 the the DT 42759 2777 13 individual individual NN 42759 2777 14 ; ; : 42759 2777 15 for for IN 42759 2777 16 example example NN 42759 2777 17 , , , 42759 2777 18 the the DT 42759 2777 19 payment payment NN 42759 2777 20 of of IN 42759 2777 21 starvation starvation NN 42759 2777 22 wages wage NNS 42759 2777 23 , , , 42759 2777 24 the the DT 42759 2777 25 extortion extortion NN 42759 2777 26 of of IN 42759 2777 27 unjust unjust JJ 42759 2777 28 prices price NNS 42759 2777 29 , , , 42759 2777 30 and and CC 42759 2777 31 the the DT 42759 2777 32 traffic traffic NN 42759 2777 33 in in IN 42759 2777 34 immorality immorality NN 42759 2777 35 . . . 42759 2778 1 Obviously obviously RB 42759 2778 2 legal legal JJ 42759 2778 3 toleration toleration NN 42759 2778 4 does do VBZ 42759 2778 5 not not RB 42759 2778 6 _ _ NNP 42759 2778 7 per per IN 42759 2778 8 se se FW 42759 2778 9 _ _ NNP 42759 2778 10 nor nor CC 42759 2778 11 always always RB 42759 2778 12 exonerate exonerate VB 42759 2778 13 the the DT 42759 2778 14 individual individual JJ 42759 2778 15 offender offender NN 42759 2778 16 . . . 42759 2779 1 How how WRB 42759 2779 2 , , , 42759 2779 3 then then RB 42759 2779 4 , , , 42759 2779 5 shall shall MD 42759 2779 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2779 7 justify justify VB 42759 2779 8 the the DT 42759 2779 9 individual individual JJ 42759 2779 10 receiver receiver NN 42759 2779 11 of of IN 42759 2779 12 interest interest NN 42759 2779 13 ? ? . 42759 2780 1 As as IN 42759 2780 2 already already RB 42759 2780 3 pointed point VBD 42759 2780 4 out out RP 42759 2780 5 more more RBR 42759 2780 6 than than IN 42759 2780 7 once once RB 42759 2780 8 , , , 42759 2780 9 those those DT 42759 2780 10 persons person NNS 42759 2780 11 who who WP 42759 2780 12 would would MD 42759 2780 13 not not RB 42759 2780 14 save save VB 42759 2780 15 without without IN 42759 2780 16 interest interest NN 42759 2780 17 are be VBP 42759 2780 18 justified justify VBN 42759 2780 19 on on IN 42759 2780 20 the the DT 42759 2780 21 ground ground NN 42759 2780 22 of of IN 42759 2780 23 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2780 24 . . . 42759 2781 1 So so RB 42759 2781 2 long long RB 42759 2781 3 as as IN 42759 2781 4 the the DT 42759 2781 5 community community NN 42759 2781 6 desires desire VBZ 42759 2781 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2781 8 savings saving NNS 42759 2781 9 , , , 42759 2781 10 and and CC 42759 2781 11 is be VBZ 42759 2781 12 willing willing JJ 42759 2781 13 to to TO 42759 2781 14 pay pay VB 42759 2781 15 interest interest NN 42759 2781 16 on on IN 42759 2781 17 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2781 18 , , , 42759 2781 19 the the DT 42759 2781 20 savers saver NNS 42759 2781 21 may may MD 42759 2781 22 take take VB 42759 2781 23 interest interest NN 42759 2781 24 as as IN 42759 2781 25 the the DT 42759 2781 26 fair fair JJ 42759 2781 27 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 2781 28 of of IN 42759 2781 29 the the DT 42759 2781 30 inconvenience inconvenience NN 42759 2781 31 that that WDT 42759 2781 32 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2781 33 undergo undergo VBP 42759 2781 34 in in IN 42759 2781 35 performing perform VBG 42759 2781 36 this this DT 42759 2781 37 social social JJ 42759 2781 38 service service NN 42759 2781 39 . . . 42759 2782 1 The the DT 42759 2782 2 precise precise JJ 42759 2782 3 problem problem NN 42759 2782 4 before before IN 42759 2782 5 us -PRON- PRP 42759 2782 6 , , , 42759 2782 7 then then RB 42759 2782 8 , , , 42759 2782 9 is be VBZ 42759 2782 10 the the DT 42759 2782 11 justification justification NN 42759 2782 12 of of IN 42759 2782 13 those those DT 42759 2782 14 savers saver NNS 42759 2782 15 and and CC 42759 2782 16 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 2782 17 who who WP 42759 2782 18 do do VBP 42759 2782 19 not not RB 42759 2782 20 need need VB 42759 2782 21 the the DT 42759 2782 22 inducement inducement NN 42759 2782 23 of of IN 42759 2782 24 interest interest NN 42759 2782 25 , , , 42759 2782 26 and and CC 42759 2782 27 whose whose WP$ 42759 2782 28 functions function NNS 42759 2782 29 of of IN 42759 2782 30 saving save VBG 42759 2782 31 and and CC 42759 2782 32 conserving conserve VBG 42759 2782 33 capital capital NN 42759 2782 34 are be VBP 42759 2782 35 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 2782 36 compensated compensate VBN 42759 2782 37 without without IN 42759 2782 38 interest interest NN 42759 2782 39 . . . 42759 2783 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2783 2 is be VBZ 42759 2783 3 a a DT 42759 2783 4 fact fact NN 42759 2783 5 that that IN 42759 2783 6 the the DT 42759 2783 7 civil civil JJ 42759 2783 8 law law NN 42759 2783 9 can can MD 42759 2783 10 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 2783 11 create create VB 42759 2783 12 moral moral JJ 42759 2783 13 rights right NNS 42759 2783 14 and and CC 42759 2783 15 obligations obligation NNS 42759 2783 16 . . . 42759 2784 1 For for IN 42759 2784 2 example example NN 42759 2784 3 ; ; : 42759 2784 4 the the DT 42759 2784 5 statute statute NN 42759 2784 6 requiring require VBG 42759 2784 7 a a DT 42759 2784 8 person person NN 42759 2784 9 to to TO 42759 2784 10 repair repair VB 42759 2784 11 losses loss NNS 42759 2784 12 that that WDT 42759 2784 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2784 14 has have VBZ 42759 2784 15 unintentionally unintentionally RB 42759 2784 16 inflicted inflict VBN 42759 2784 17 upon upon IN 42759 2784 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2784 19 neighbour neighbour NN 42759 2784 20 is be VBZ 42759 2784 21 held hold VBN 42759 2784 22 by by IN 42759 2784 23 the the DT 42759 2784 24 moral moral JJ 42759 2784 25 theologians theologian NNS 42759 2784 26 to to TO 42759 2784 27 be be VB 42759 2784 28 binding bind VBG 42759 2784 29 _ _ NNP 42759 2784 30 in in IN 42759 2784 31 conscience conscience NN 42759 2784 32 _ _ NNP 42759 2784 33 , , , 42759 2784 34 as as RB 42759 2784 35 soon soon RB 42759 2784 36 as as IN 42759 2784 37 the the DT 42759 2784 38 matter matter NN 42759 2784 39 has have VBZ 42759 2784 40 been be VBN 42759 2784 41 adjudicated adjudicate VBN 42759 2784 42 by by IN 42759 2784 43 the the DT 42759 2784 44 court court NN 42759 2784 45 . . . 42759 2785 1 In in IN 42759 2785 2 other other JJ 42759 2785 3 words word NNS 42759 2785 4 , , , 42759 2785 5 this this DT 42759 2785 6 civil civil JJ 42759 2785 7 regulation regulation NN 42759 2785 8 confers confer NNS 42759 2785 9 on on IN 42759 2785 10 the the DT 42759 2785 11 injured injured JJ 42759 2785 12 man man NN 42759 2785 13 property property NN 42759 2785 14 rights right NNS 42759 2785 15 , , , 42759 2785 16 and and CC 42759 2785 17 imposes impose VBZ 42759 2785 18 on on IN 42759 2785 19 the the DT 42759 2785 20 morally morally RB 42759 2785 21 inculpable inculpable JJ 42759 2785 22 injurer injurer JJ 42759 2785 23 property property NN 42759 2785 24 obligations obligation NNS 42759 2785 25 . . . 42759 2786 1 The the DT 42759 2786 2 civil civil JJ 42759 2786 3 statutes statute NNS 42759 2786 4 also also RB 42759 2786 5 give give VBP 42759 2786 6 moral moral JJ 42759 2786 7 validity validity NN 42759 2786 8 to to IN 42759 2786 9 the the DT 42759 2786 10 title title NN 42759 2786 11 of of IN 42759 2786 12 prescription prescription NN 42759 2786 13 , , , 42759 2786 14 or or CC 42759 2786 15 adverse adverse JJ 42759 2786 16 possession possession NN 42759 2786 17 . . . 42759 2787 1 When when WRB 42759 2787 2 the the DT 42759 2787 3 alien alien JJ 42759 2787 4 possessor possessor NN 42759 2787 5 has have VBZ 42759 2787 6 complied comply VBN 42759 2787 7 with with IN 42759 2787 8 the the DT 42759 2787 9 legal legal JJ 42759 2787 10 provisions provision NNS 42759 2787 11 that that WDT 42759 2787 12 apply apply VBP 42759 2787 13 , , , 42759 2787 14 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2787 15 has have VBZ 42759 2787 16 a a DT 42759 2787 17 moral moral JJ 42759 2787 18 right right NN 42759 2787 19 to to IN 42759 2787 20 the the DT 42759 2787 21 property property NN 42759 2787 22 , , , 42759 2787 23 even even RB 42759 2787 24 though though IN 42759 2787 25 the the DT 42759 2787 26 original original JJ 42759 2787 27 owner owner NN 42759 2787 28 should should MD 42759 2787 29 assert assert VB 42759 2787 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2787 31 claim claim NN 42759 2787 32 at at IN 42759 2787 33 a a DT 42759 2787 34 later later JJ 42759 2787 35 time time NN 42759 2787 36 . . . 42759 2788 1 Some some DT 42759 2788 2 moral moral JJ 42759 2788 3 theologians theologian NNS 42759 2788 4 maintain maintain VBP 42759 2788 5 that that IN 42759 2788 6 a a DT 42759 2788 7 legal legal JJ 42759 2788 8 discharge discharge NN 42759 2788 9 in in IN 42759 2788 10 bankruptcy bankruptcy NN 42759 2788 11 liberates liberate VBZ 42759 2788 12 the the DT 42759 2788 13 bankrupt bankrupt JJ 42759 2788 14 from from IN 42759 2788 15 the the DT 42759 2788 16 moral moral JJ 42759 2788 17 obligation obligation NN 42759 2788 18 of of IN 42759 2788 19 satisfying satisfy VBG 42759 2788 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2788 21 unpaid unpaid JJ 42759 2788 22 debts debt NNS 42759 2788 23 . . . 42759 2789 1 Several several JJ 42759 2789 2 other other JJ 42759 2789 3 situations situation NNS 42759 2789 4 might may MD 42759 2789 5 be be VB 42759 2789 6 cited cite VBN 42759 2789 7 in in IN 42759 2789 8 which which WDT 42759 2789 9 the the DT 42759 2789 10 State State NNP 42759 2789 11 admittedly admittedly RB 42759 2789 12 creates create VBZ 42759 2789 13 moral moral JJ 42759 2789 14 rights right NNS 42759 2789 15 of of IN 42759 2789 16 individual individual JJ 42759 2789 17 ownership ownership NN 42759 2789 18 which which WDT 42759 2789 19 would would MD 42759 2789 20 have have VB 42759 2789 21 no no DT 42759 2789 22 definite definite JJ 42759 2789 23 existence existence NN 42759 2789 24 in in IN 42759 2789 25 the the DT 42759 2789 26 absence absence NN 42759 2789 27 of of IN 42759 2789 28 such such JJ 42759 2789 29 legal legal JJ 42759 2789 30 action action NN 42759 2789 31 and and CC 42759 2789 32 authorisation authorisation NN 42759 2789 33 . . . 42759 2790 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2790 2 148 148 CD 42759 2790 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2790 4 This this DT 42759 2790 5 principle principle NN 42759 2790 6 would would MD 42759 2790 7 seem seem VB 42759 2790 8 to to TO 42759 2790 9 have have VB 42759 2790 10 received receive VBN 42759 2790 11 a a DT 42759 2790 12 particularly particularly RB 42759 2790 13 pertinent pertinent JJ 42759 2790 14 application application NN 42759 2790 15 for for IN 42759 2790 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2790 17 inquiry inquiry NN 42759 2790 18 in in IN 42759 2790 19 the the DT 42759 2790 20 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 2790 21 of of IN 42759 2790 22 _ _ NNP 42759 2790 23 præmium præmium NN 42759 2790 24 _ _ NNP 42759 2790 25 legale legale NN 42759 2790 26 as as IN 42759 2790 27 a a DT 42759 2790 28 title title NN 42759 2790 29 of of IN 42759 2790 30 interest interest NN 42759 2790 31 on on IN 42759 2790 32 loans loan NNS 42759 2790 33 . . . 42759 2791 1 In in IN 42759 2791 2 the the DT 42759 2791 3 " " `` 42759 2791 4 Opus Opus NNP 42759 2791 5 Morale morale NN 42759 2791 6 " " '' 42759 2791 7 of of IN 42759 2791 8 Ballerini Ballerini NNP 42759 2791 9 - - HYPH 42759 2791 10 Palmieri Palmieri NNP 42759 2791 11 can can MD 42759 2791 12 be be VB 42759 2791 13 found find VBN 42759 2791 14 a a DT 42759 2791 15 long long JJ 42759 2791 16 list list NN 42759 2791 17 of of IN 42759 2791 18 moral moral JJ 42759 2791 19 theologians theologian NNS 42759 2791 20 living live VBG 42759 2791 21 in in IN 42759 2791 22 the the DT 42759 2791 23 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 42759 2791 24 and and CC 42759 2791 25 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 42759 2791 26 centuries century NNS 42759 2791 27 who who WP 42759 2791 28 maintained maintain VBD 42759 2791 29 that that IN 42759 2791 30 the the DT 42759 2791 31 mere mere JJ 42759 2791 32 legal legal JJ 42759 2791 33 sanction sanction NN 42759 2791 34 of of IN 42759 2791 35 a a DT 42759 2791 36 certain certain JJ 42759 2791 37 rate rate NN 42759 2791 38 of of IN 42759 2791 39 interest interest NN 42759 2791 40 was be VBD 42759 2791 41 a a DT 42759 2791 42 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2791 43 moral moral JJ 42759 2791 44 justification justification NN 42759 2791 45 for for IN 42759 2791 46 the the DT 42759 2791 47 lender lender NN 42759 2791 48 . . . 42759 2792 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2792 2 149 149 CD 42759 2792 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2792 4 While while IN 42759 2792 5 holding hold VBG 42759 2792 6 to to IN 42759 2792 7 the the DT 42759 2792 8 traditional traditional JJ 42759 2792 9 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 2792 10 that that DT 42759 2792 11 interest interest NN 42759 2792 12 was be VBD 42759 2792 13 not not RB 42759 2792 14 capable capable JJ 42759 2792 15 of of IN 42759 2792 16 being be VBG 42759 2792 17 justified justify VBN 42759 2792 18 on on IN 42759 2792 19 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2792 20 grounds ground NNS 42759 2792 21 , , , 42759 2792 22 these these DT 42759 2792 23 writers writer NNS 42759 2792 24 contended contend VBD 42759 2792 25 that that IN 42759 2792 26 by by IN 42759 2792 27 virtue virtue NN 42759 2792 28 of of IN 42759 2792 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2792 30 power power NN 42759 2792 31 of of IN 42759 2792 32 eminent eminent JJ 42759 2792 33 domain domain NN 42759 2792 34 the the DT 42759 2792 35 State state NN 42759 2792 36 could could MD 42759 2792 37 transfer transfer VB 42759 2792 38 from from IN 42759 2792 39 the the DT 42759 2792 40 borrower borrower NN 42759 2792 41 to to IN 42759 2792 42 the the DT 42759 2792 43 lender lender NN 42759 2792 44 the the DT 42759 2792 45 right right NN 42759 2792 46 to to IN 42759 2792 47 the the DT 42759 2792 48 interest interest NN 42759 2792 49 paid pay VBN 42759 2792 50 on on IN 42759 2792 51 a a DT 42759 2792 52 loan loan NN 42759 2792 53 . . . 42759 2793 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2793 2 did do VBD 42759 2793 3 not not RB 42759 2793 4 mean mean VB 42759 2793 5 that that IN 42759 2793 6 the the DT 42759 2793 7 State State NNP 42759 2793 8 could could MD 42759 2793 9 arbitrarily arbitrarily RB 42759 2793 10 take take VB 42759 2793 11 one one CD 42759 2793 12 man man NN 42759 2793 13 's 's POS 42759 2793 14 property property NN 42759 2793 15 and and CC 42759 2793 16 hand hand VB 42759 2793 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2793 18 over over RP 42759 2793 19 to to IN 42759 2793 20 another another DT 42759 2793 21 , , , 42759 2793 22 but but CC 42759 2793 23 only only RB 42759 2793 24 that that DT 42759 2793 25 , , , 42759 2793 26 when when WRB 42759 2793 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2793 28 sanctioned sanction VBD 42759 2793 29 interest interest NN 42759 2793 30 for for IN 42759 2793 31 the the DT 42759 2793 32 public public JJ 42759 2793 33 welfare welfare NN 42759 2793 34 , , , 42759 2793 35 this this DT 42759 2793 36 extrinsic extrinsic NN 42759 2793 37 circumstance circumstance NN 42759 2793 38 ( ( -LRB- 42759 2793 39 like like IN 42759 2793 40 the the DT 42759 2793 41 other other JJ 42759 2793 42 " " `` 42759 2793 43 extrinsic extrinsic JJ 42759 2793 44 titles title NNS 42759 2793 45 " " '' 42759 2793 46 approved approve VBN 42759 2793 47 by by IN 42759 2793 48 moralists moralist NNS 42759 2793 49 ) ) -RRB- 42759 2793 50 annulled annul VBD 42759 2793 51 the the DT 42759 2793 52 claim claim NN 42759 2793 53 of of IN 42759 2793 54 the the DT 42759 2793 55 borrower borrower NN 42759 2793 56 in in IN 42759 2793 57 favour favour NN 42759 2793 58 of of IN 42759 2793 59 the the DT 42759 2793 60 lender lender NN 42759 2793 61 . . . 42759 2794 1 In in IN 42759 2794 2 other other JJ 42759 2794 3 words word NNS 42759 2794 4 , , , 42759 2794 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2794 6 maintained maintain VBD 42759 2794 7 that that IN 42759 2794 8 the the DT 42759 2794 9 money money NN 42759 2794 10 paid pay VBN 42759 2794 11 in in IN 42759 2794 12 loan loan NN 42759 2794 13 - - HYPH 42759 2794 14 interest interest NN 42759 2794 15 did do VBD 42759 2794 16 not not RB 42759 2794 17 belong belong VB 42759 2794 18 to to IN 42759 2794 19 either either CC 42759 2794 20 borrower borrower NN 42759 2794 21 or or CC 42759 2794 22 lender lender NN 42759 2794 23 with with IN 42759 2794 24 certainty certainty NN 42759 2794 25 or or CC 42759 2794 26 definiteness definiteness NN 42759 2794 27 until until IN 42759 2794 28 the the DT 42759 2794 29 matter matter NN 42759 2794 30 was be VBD 42759 2794 31 determined determine VBN 42759 2794 32 by by IN 42759 2794 33 economic economic JJ 42759 2794 34 conditions condition NNS 42759 2794 35 and and CC 42759 2794 36 extrinsic extrinsic NN 42759 2794 37 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 2794 38 . . . 42759 2795 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2795 2 legal legal JJ 42759 2795 3 authorisation authorisation NN 42759 2795 4 for for IN 42759 2795 5 the the DT 42759 2795 6 common common JJ 42759 2795 7 good good NN 42759 2795 8 was be VBD 42759 2795 9 morally morally RB 42759 2795 10 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2795 11 to to TO 42759 2795 12 award award VB 42759 2795 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2795 14 to to IN 42759 2795 15 the the DT 42759 2795 16 lender lender NN 42759 2795 17 . . . 42759 2796 1 More More JJR 42759 2796 2 than than IN 42759 2796 3 one one CD 42759 2796 4 of of IN 42759 2796 5 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2796 6 declared declare VBD 42759 2796 7 that that IN 42759 2796 8 the the DT 42759 2796 9 State State NNP 42759 2796 10 had have VBD 42759 2796 11 the the DT 42759 2796 12 same same JJ 42759 2796 13 right right NN 42759 2796 14 to to TO 42759 2796 15 determine determine VB 42759 2796 16 this this DT 42759 2796 17 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 42759 2796 18 property property NN 42759 2796 19 , , , 42759 2796 20 to to TO 42759 2796 21 assign assign VB 42759 2796 22 the the DT 42759 2796 23 ownership ownership NN 42759 2796 24 to to IN 42759 2796 25 the the DT 42759 2796 26 lender lender NN 42759 2796 27 , , , 42759 2796 28 that that IN 42759 2796 29 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2796 30 had have VBD 42759 2796 31 to to TO 42759 2796 32 transfer transfer VB 42759 2796 33 property property NN 42759 2796 34 titles title NNS 42759 2796 35 by by IN 42759 2796 36 the the DT 42759 2796 37 device device NN 42759 2796 38 of of IN 42759 2796 39 prescription prescription NN 42759 2796 40 . . . 42759 2797 1 And and CC 42759 2797 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2797 3 general general JJ 42759 2797 4 position position NN 42759 2797 5 seems seem VBZ 42759 2797 6 to to TO 42759 2797 7 have have VB 42759 2797 8 been be VBN 42759 2797 9 confirmed confirm VBN 42759 2797 10 by by IN 42759 2797 11 the the DT 42759 2797 12 response response NN 42759 2797 13 of of IN 42759 2797 14 the the DT 42759 2797 15 Congregation Congregation NNP 42759 2797 16 of of IN 42759 2797 17 the the DT 42759 2797 18 Poenitentiaria Poenitentiaria NNP 42759 2797 19 , , , 42759 2797 20 Feb. February NNP 42759 2797 21 , , , 42759 2797 22 1832 1832 CD 42759 2797 23 , , , 42759 2797 24 to to IN 42759 2797 25 the the DT 42759 2797 26 Bishop Bishop NNP 42759 2797 27 of of IN 42759 2797 28 Verona Verona NNP 42759 2797 29 , , , 42759 2797 30 the the DT 42759 2797 31 substance substance NN 42759 2797 32 of of IN 42759 2797 33 which which WDT 42759 2797 34 was be VBD 42759 2797 35 that that IN 42759 2797 36 a a DT 42759 2797 37 confessor confessor NN 42759 2797 38 might may MD 42759 2797 39 adopt adopt VB 42759 2797 40 and and CC 42759 2797 41 act act VB 42759 2797 42 upon upon IN 42759 2797 43 this this DT 42759 2797 44 position position NN 42759 2797 45 . . . 42759 2798 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2798 2 150 150 CD 42759 2798 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2798 4 And and CC 42759 2798 5 yet yet RB 42759 2798 6 , , , 42759 2798 7 neither neither CC 42759 2798 8 this this DT 42759 2798 9 nor nor CC 42759 2798 10 any any DT 42759 2798 11 of of IN 42759 2798 12 the the DT 42759 2798 13 other other JJ 42759 2798 14 precedents precedent NNS 42759 2798 15 cited cite VBN 42759 2798 16 above above RB 42759 2798 17 , , , 42759 2798 18 are be VBP 42759 2798 19 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2798 20 to to TO 42759 2798 21 give give VB 42759 2798 22 certain certain JJ 42759 2798 23 moral moral JJ 42759 2798 24 sanction sanction NN 42759 2798 25 to to IN 42759 2798 26 the the DT 42759 2798 27 practice practice NN 42759 2798 28 of of IN 42759 2798 29 interest interest NN 42759 2798 30 - - HYPH 42759 2798 31 taking taking NN 42759 2798 32 by by IN 42759 2798 33 those those DT 42759 2798 34 persons person NNS 42759 2798 35 who who WP 42759 2798 36 would would MD 42759 2798 37 continue continue VB 42759 2798 38 to to TO 42759 2798 39 save save VB 42759 2798 40 if if IN 42759 2798 41 interest interest NN 42759 2798 42 were be VBD 42759 2798 43 abolished abolish VBN 42759 2798 44 . . . 42759 2799 1 All all PDT 42759 2799 2 the the DT 42759 2799 3 acts act NNS 42759 2799 4 of of IN 42759 2799 5 legal legal JJ 42759 2799 6 authorisation authorisation NN 42759 2799 7 that that WDT 42759 2799 8 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2799 9 have have VBP 42759 2799 10 been be VBN 42759 2799 11 considering consider VBG 42759 2799 12 relate relate JJ 42759 2799 13 to to IN 42759 2799 14 practices practice NNS 42759 2799 15 which which WDT 42759 2799 16 are be VBP 42759 2799 17 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 2799 18 and and CC 42759 2799 19 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2799 20 to to IN 42759 2799 21 society society NN 42759 2799 22 . . . 42759 2800 1 Only only RB 42759 2800 2 in in IN 42759 2800 3 such such JJ 42759 2800 4 cases case NNS 42759 2800 5 has have VBZ 42759 2800 6 the the DT 42759 2800 7 State State NNP 42759 2800 8 the the DT 42759 2800 9 moral moral JJ 42759 2800 10 authority authority NN 42759 2800 11 to to TO 42759 2800 12 create create VB 42759 2800 13 or or CC 42759 2800 14 annul annul VB 42759 2800 15 property property NN 42759 2800 16 rights right NNS 42759 2800 17 . . . 42759 2801 1 In in IN 42759 2801 2 the the DT 42759 2801 3 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 42759 2801 4 and and CC 42759 2801 5 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 42759 2801 6 centuries century NNS 42759 2801 7 the the DT 42759 2801 8 legal legal JJ 42759 2801 9 authorisation authorisation NN 42759 2801 10 of of IN 42759 2801 11 a a DT 42759 2801 12 certain certain JJ 42759 2801 13 rate rate NN 42759 2801 14 of of IN 42759 2801 15 interest interest NN 42759 2801 16 made make VBD 42759 2801 17 that that DT 42759 2801 18 rate rate NN 42759 2801 19 morally morally RB 42759 2801 20 lawful lawful JJ 42759 2801 21 simply simply RB 42759 2801 22 because because IN 42759 2801 23 this this DT 42759 2801 24 legal legal JJ 42759 2801 25 act act NN 42759 2801 26 gave give VBD 42759 2801 27 formal formal JJ 42759 2801 28 and and CC 42759 2801 29 authoritative authoritative JJ 42759 2801 30 testimony testimony NN 42759 2801 31 to to IN 42759 2801 32 the the DT 42759 2801 33 social social JJ 42759 2801 34 utility utility NN 42759 2801 35 of of IN 42759 2801 36 interest interest NN 42759 2801 37 - - HYPH 42759 2801 38 taking taking NN 42759 2801 39 . . . 42759 2802 1 The the DT 42759 2802 2 State State NNP 42759 2802 3 merely merely RB 42759 2802 4 declared declare VBD 42759 2802 5 the the DT 42759 2802 6 reasonableness reasonableness NN 42759 2802 7 , , , 42759 2802 8 and and CC 42759 2802 9 fixed fix VBD 42759 2802 10 the the DT 42759 2802 11 proper proper JJ 42759 2802 12 limits limit NNS 42759 2802 13 of of IN 42759 2802 14 the the DT 42759 2802 15 practice practice NN 42759 2802 16 . . . 42759 2803 1 The the DT 42759 2803 2 beneficent beneficent JJ 42759 2803 3 effect effect NN 42759 2803 4 of of IN 42759 2803 5 interest interest NN 42759 2803 6 - - HYPH 42759 2803 7 taking take VBG 42759 2803 8 upon upon IN 42759 2803 9 society society NN 42759 2803 10 was be VBD 42759 2803 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2803 12 underlying underlying JJ 42759 2803 13 justification justification NN 42759 2803 14 , , , 42759 2803 15 was be VBD 42759 2803 16 the the DT 42759 2803 17 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 2803 18 fact fact NN 42759 2803 19 which which WDT 42759 2803 20 made make VBD 42759 2803 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2803 22 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2803 23 , , , 42759 2803 24 and and CC 42759 2803 25 which which WDT 42759 2803 26 gave give VBD 42759 2803 27 to to IN 42759 2803 28 the the DT 42759 2803 29 action action NN 42759 2803 30 of of IN 42759 2803 31 the the DT 42759 2803 32 State State NNP 42759 2803 33 moral moral JJ 42759 2803 34 value value NN 42759 2803 35 . . . 42759 2804 1 Had have VBD 42759 2804 2 the the DT 42759 2804 3 taking taking NN 42759 2804 4 of of IN 42759 2804 5 interest interest NN 42759 2804 6 on on IN 42759 2804 7 loans loan NNS 42759 2804 8 not not RB 42759 2804 9 been be VBN 42759 2804 10 allowed allow VBN 42759 2804 11 the the DT 42759 2804 12 bulk bulk NN 42759 2804 13 of of IN 42759 2804 14 possible possible JJ 42759 2804 15 savings saving NNS 42759 2804 16 would would MD 42759 2804 17 either either CC 42759 2804 18 not not RB 42759 2804 19 have have VB 42759 2804 20 been be VBN 42759 2804 21 saved save VBN 42759 2804 22 at at RB 42759 2804 23 all all RB 42759 2804 24 , , , 42759 2804 25 or or CC 42759 2804 26 would would MD 42759 2804 27 have have VB 42759 2804 28 been be VBN 42759 2804 29 hoarded hoard VBN 42759 2804 30 instead instead RB 42759 2804 31 of of IN 42759 2804 32 converted convert VBN 42759 2804 33 into into IN 42759 2804 34 capital capital NN 42759 2804 35 . . . 42759 2805 1 And and CC 42759 2805 2 that that DT 42759 2805 3 money money NN 42759 2805 4 was be VBD 42759 2805 5 badly badly RB 42759 2805 6 needed need VBN 42759 2805 7 in in IN 42759 2805 8 the the DT 42759 2805 9 commercial commercial JJ 42759 2805 10 and and CC 42759 2805 11 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2805 12 operations operation NNS 42759 2805 13 of of IN 42759 2805 14 the the DT 42759 2805 15 time time NN 42759 2805 16 . . . 42759 2806 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2806 2 the the DT 42759 2806 3 owners owner NNS 42759 2806 4 of of IN 42759 2806 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2806 6 were be VBD 42759 2806 7 in in IN 42759 2806 8 the the DT 42759 2806 9 position position NN 42759 2806 10 of of IN 42759 2806 11 persons person NNS 42759 2806 12 who who WP 42759 2806 13 regarded regard VBD 42759 2806 14 saving save VBG 42759 2806 15 and and CC 42759 2806 16 investing invest VBG 42759 2806 17 as as IN 42759 2806 18 a a DT 42759 2806 19 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2806 20 for for IN 42759 2806 21 which which WDT 42759 2806 22 interest interest NN 42759 2806 23 was be VBD 42759 2806 24 a a DT 42759 2806 25 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2806 26 and and CC 42759 2806 27 proper proper JJ 42759 2806 28 compensation compensation NN 42759 2806 29 . . . 42759 2807 1 To to NN 42759 2807 2 - - HYPH 42759 2807 3 day day NN 42759 2807 4 , , , 42759 2807 5 however however RB 42759 2807 6 , , , 42759 2807 7 there there EX 42759 2807 8 are be VBP 42759 2807 9 millions million NNS 42759 2807 10 of of IN 42759 2807 11 persons person NNS 42759 2807 12 who who WP 42759 2807 13 would would MD 42759 2807 14 continue continue VB 42759 2807 15 to to TO 42759 2807 16 perform perform VB 42759 2807 17 both both DT 42759 2807 18 these these DT 42759 2807 19 functions function NNS 42759 2807 20 without without IN 42759 2807 21 the the DT 42759 2807 22 inducement inducement NN 42759 2807 23 of of IN 42759 2807 24 interest interest NN 42759 2807 25 . . . 42759 2808 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 2808 2 , , , 42759 2808 3 the the DT 42759 2808 4 public public JJ 42759 2808 5 good good NN 42759 2808 6 does do VBZ 42759 2808 7 not not RB 42759 2808 8 require require VB 42759 2808 9 that that IN 42759 2808 10 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2808 11 should should MD 42759 2808 12 receive receive VB 42759 2808 13 interest interest NN 42759 2808 14 , , , 42759 2808 15 nor nor CC 42759 2808 16 that that IN 42759 2808 17 the the DT 42759 2808 18 State state NN 42759 2808 19 should should MD 42759 2808 20 have have VB 42759 2808 21 the the DT 42759 2808 22 power power NN 42759 2808 23 to to TO 42759 2808 24 clothe clothe VB 42759 2808 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2808 26 interest interest NN 42759 2808 27 - - HYPH 42759 2808 28 incomes income NNS 42759 2808 29 with with IN 42759 2808 30 moral moral JJ 42759 2808 31 lawfulness lawfulness NN 42759 2808 32 . . . 42759 2809 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 2809 2 as as IN 42759 2809 3 the the DT 42759 2809 4 State State NNP 42759 2809 5 is be VBZ 42759 2809 6 not not RB 42759 2809 7 certain certain JJ 42759 2809 8 that that IN 42759 2809 9 the the DT 42759 2809 10 abolition abolition NN 42759 2809 11 of of IN 42759 2809 12 interest interest NN 42759 2809 13 would would MD 42759 2809 14 be be VB 42759 2809 15 socially socially RB 42759 2809 16 expedient expedient JJ 42759 2809 17 or or CC 42759 2809 18 practically practically RB 42759 2809 19 possible possible JJ 42759 2809 20 , , , 42759 2809 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2809 22 is be VBZ 42759 2809 23 justified justify VBN 42759 2809 24 in in IN 42759 2809 25 permitting permit VBG 42759 2809 26 the the DT 42759 2809 27 institution institution NN 42759 2809 28 to to TO 42759 2809 29 continue continue VB 42759 2809 30 ; ; : 42759 2809 31 but but CC 42759 2809 32 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2809 33 has have VBZ 42759 2809 34 no no DT 42759 2809 35 power power NN 42759 2809 36 to to TO 42759 2809 37 affect affect VB 42759 2809 38 the the DT 42759 2809 39 morality morality NN 42759 2809 40 of of IN 42759 2809 41 interest interest NN 42759 2809 42 - - HYPH 42759 2809 43 taking taking NN 42759 2809 44 as as IN 42759 2809 45 an an DT 42759 2809 46 individual individual JJ 42759 2809 47 action action NN 42759 2809 48 . . . 42759 2810 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2810 2 How how WRB 42759 2810 3 the the DT 42759 2810 4 Interest Interest NNP 42759 2810 5 - - HYPH 42759 2810 6 Taker Taker NNP 42759 2810 7 Is be VBZ 42759 2810 8 Justified Justified NNP 42759 2810 9 _ _ NNP 42759 2810 10 Although although IN 42759 2810 11 the the DT 42759 2810 12 interest interest NN 42759 2810 13 received receive VBN 42759 2810 14 by by IN 42759 2810 15 the the DT 42759 2810 16 non non JJ 42759 2810 17 - - JJ 42759 2810 18 sacrifice sacrifice JJ 42759 2810 19 savers saver NNS 42759 2810 20 is be VBZ 42759 2810 21 not not RB 42759 2810 22 clearly clearly RB 42759 2810 23 justifiable justifiable JJ 42759 2810 24 on on IN 42759 2810 25 either either DT 42759 2810 26 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2810 27 or or CC 42759 2810 28 social social JJ 42759 2810 29 grounds ground NNS 42759 2810 30 , , , 42759 2810 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2810 32 is be VBZ 42759 2810 33 not not RB 42759 2810 34 utterly utterly RB 42759 2810 35 lacking lack VBG 42759 2810 36 in in IN 42759 2810 37 moral moral JJ 42759 2810 38 sanctions sanction NNS 42759 2810 39 . . . 42759 2811 1 In in IN 42759 2811 2 the the DT 42759 2811 3 first first JJ 42759 2811 4 place place NN 42759 2811 5 , , , 42759 2811 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2811 7 have have VBP 42759 2811 8 not not RB 42759 2811 9 contended contend VBN 42759 2811 10 that that IN 42759 2811 11 the the DT 42759 2811 12 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 2811 13 factors factor NNS 42759 2811 14 of of IN 42759 2811 15 productivity productivity NN 42759 2811 16 and and CC 42759 2811 17 service service NN 42759 2811 18 are be VBP 42759 2811 19 _ _ NNP 42759 2811 20 certainly certainly RB 42759 2811 21 _ _ NNP 42759 2811 22 invalid invalid NNP 42759 2811 23 morally morally RB 42759 2811 24 . . . 42759 2812 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 2812 2 have have VBP 42759 2812 3 merely merely RB 42759 2812 4 insisted insist VBN 42759 2812 5 that that IN 42759 2812 6 the the DT 42759 2812 7 moral moral JJ 42759 2812 8 worth worth NN 42759 2812 9 of of IN 42759 2812 10 these these DT 42759 2812 11 titles title NNS 42759 2812 12 has have VBZ 42759 2812 13 never never RB 42759 2812 14 been be VBN 42759 2812 15 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 42759 2812 16 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 42759 2812 17 . . . 42759 2813 1 Possibly possibly RB 42759 2813 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2813 3 have have VBP 42759 2813 4 a a DT 42759 2813 5 greater great JJR 42759 2813 6 and and CC 42759 2813 7 more more RBR 42759 2813 8 definite definite JJ 42759 2813 9 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 2813 10 than than IN 42759 2813 11 has have VBZ 42759 2813 12 yet yet RB 42759 2813 13 been be VBN 42759 2813 14 shown show VBN 42759 2813 15 by by IN 42759 2813 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2813 17 advocates advocate NNS 42759 2813 18 . . . 42759 2814 1 In in IN 42759 2814 2 more more JJR 42759 2814 3 concrete concrete JJ 42759 2814 4 terms term NNS 42759 2814 5 , , , 42759 2814 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2814 7 admit admit VBP 42759 2814 8 that that IN 42759 2814 9 the the DT 42759 2814 10 productivity productivity NN 42759 2814 11 of of IN 42759 2814 12 capital capital NN 42759 2814 13 and and CC 42759 2814 14 the the DT 42759 2814 15 service service NN 42759 2814 16 of of IN 42759 2814 17 the the DT 42759 2814 18 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2814 19 to to IN 42759 2814 20 the the DT 42759 2814 21 community community NN 42759 2814 22 , , , 42759 2814 23 are be VBP 42759 2814 24 possible possible JJ 42759 2814 25 and and CC 42759 2814 26 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 2814 27 titles title NNS 42759 2814 28 to to IN 42759 2814 29 interest interest NN 42759 2814 30 . . . 42759 2815 1 A a DT 42759 2815 2 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 2815 3 title title NN 42759 2815 4 to to IN 42759 2815 5 property property NN 42759 2815 6 is be VBZ 42759 2815 7 , , , 42759 2815 8 indeed indeed RB 42759 2815 9 , , , 42759 2815 10 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 2815 11 by by IN 42759 2815 12 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2815 13 . . . 42759 2816 1 In in IN 42759 2816 2 the the DT 42759 2816 3 case case NN 42759 2816 4 of of IN 42759 2816 5 the the DT 42759 2816 6 interest interest NN 42759 2816 7 receiver receiver NN 42759 2816 8 , , , 42759 2816 9 however however RB 42759 2816 10 , , , 42759 2816 11 the the DT 42759 2816 12 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 2816 13 titles title NNS 42759 2816 14 of of IN 42759 2816 15 productivity productivity NN 42759 2816 16 and and CC 42759 2816 17 service service NN 42759 2816 18 are be VBP 42759 2816 19 reinforced reinforce VBN 42759 2816 20 by by IN 42759 2816 21 the the DT 42759 2816 22 fact fact NN 42759 2816 23 of of IN 42759 2816 24 possession possession NN 42759 2816 25 . . . 42759 2817 1 Thus thus RB 42759 2817 2 supplemented supplement VBN 42759 2817 3 , , , 42759 2817 4 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2817 5 are be VBP 42759 2817 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2817 7 to to TO 42759 2817 8 justify justify VB 42759 2817 9 the the DT 42759 2817 10 non non JJ 42759 2817 11 - - JJ 42759 2817 12 sacrifice sacrifice JJ 42759 2817 13 saver saver NN 42759 2817 14 in in IN 42759 2817 15 giving give VBG 42759 2817 16 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 2817 17 the the DT 42759 2817 18 benefit benefit NN 42759 2817 19 of of IN 42759 2817 20 the the DT 42759 2817 21 doubt doubt NN 42759 2817 22 as as IN 42759 2817 23 regards regard VBZ 42759 2817 24 the the DT 42759 2817 25 validity validity NN 42759 2817 26 of of IN 42759 2817 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2817 28 right right NN 42759 2817 29 to to TO 42759 2817 30 take take VB 42759 2817 31 interest interest NN 42759 2817 32 . . . 42759 2818 1 To to TO 42759 2818 2 be be VB 42759 2818 3 sure sure JJ 42759 2818 4 , , , 42759 2818 5 this this DT 42759 2818 6 indefinite indefinite JJ 42759 2818 7 and and CC 42759 2818 8 uncertain uncertain JJ 42759 2818 9 claim claim NN 42759 2818 10 would would MD 42759 2818 11 be be VB 42759 2818 12 overthrown overthrow VBN 42759 2818 13 by by IN 42759 2818 14 a a DT 42759 2818 15 more more RBR 42759 2818 16 definite definite JJ 42759 2818 17 and and CC 42759 2818 18 positive positive JJ 42759 2818 19 title title NN 42759 2818 20 . . . 42759 2819 1 But but CC 42759 2819 2 no no DT 42759 2819 3 such such JJ 42759 2819 4 antagonistic antagonistic JJ 42759 2819 5 title title NN 42759 2819 6 exists exist VBZ 42759 2819 7 . . . 42759 2820 1 Neither neither CC 42759 2820 2 the the DT 42759 2820 3 consumer consumer NN 42759 2820 4 nor nor CC 42759 2820 5 the the DT 42759 2820 6 labourer labourer NN 42759 2820 7 can can MD 42759 2820 8 show show VB 42759 2820 9 any any DT 42759 2820 10 conclusive conclusive JJ 42759 2820 11 reason reason NN 42759 2820 12 why why WRB 42759 2820 13 interest interest NN 42759 2820 14 should should MD 42759 2820 15 go go VB 42759 2820 16 to to IN 42759 2820 17 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2820 18 rather rather RB 42759 2820 19 than than IN 42759 2820 20 to to IN 42759 2820 21 the the DT 42759 2820 22 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2820 23 . . . 42759 2821 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2821 2 the the DT 42759 2821 3 latter latter NN 42759 2821 4 has have VBZ 42759 2821 5 at at IN 42759 2821 6 least least JJS 42759 2821 7 a a DT 42759 2821 8 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 2821 9 title title NN 42759 2821 10 . . . 42759 2822 1 In in IN 42759 2822 2 the the DT 42759 2822 3 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 2822 4 this this DT 42759 2822 5 is be VBZ 42759 2822 6 morally morally RB 42759 2822 7 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2822 8 . . . 42759 2823 1 To to IN 42759 2823 2 this this DT 42759 2823 3 justification justification NN 42759 2823 4 by by IN 42759 2823 5 presumption presumption NN 42759 2823 6 must must MD 42759 2823 7 be be VB 42759 2823 8 added add VBN 42759 2823 9 a a DT 42759 2823 10 justification justification NN 42759 2823 11 by by IN 42759 2823 12 analogy analogy NN 42759 2823 13 . . . 42759 2824 1 The the DT 42759 2824 2 non non JJ 42759 2824 3 - - JJ 42759 2824 4 sacrifice sacrifice JJ 42759 2824 5 savers saver NNS 42759 2824 6 seem seem VBP 42759 2824 7 to to TO 42759 2824 8 be be VB 42759 2824 9 in in IN 42759 2824 10 about about IN 42759 2824 11 the the DT 42759 2824 12 same same JJ 42759 2824 13 position position NN 42759 2824 14 as as IN 42759 2824 15 those those DT 42759 2824 16 other other JJ 42759 2824 17 agents agent NNS 42759 2824 18 of of IN 42759 2824 19 production production NN 42759 2824 20 whose whose WP$ 42759 2824 21 rewards reward NNS 42759 2824 22 are be VBP 42759 2824 23 out out IN 42759 2824 24 of of IN 42759 2824 25 proportion proportion NN 42759 2824 26 to to IN 42759 2824 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2824 28 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 2824 29 . . . 42759 2825 1 For for IN 42759 2825 2 example example NN 42759 2825 3 ; ; : 42759 2825 4 the the DT 42759 2825 5 labourer labourer NN 42759 2825 6 of of IN 42759 2825 7 superior superior JJ 42759 2825 8 native native JJ 42759 2825 9 ability ability NN 42759 2825 10 gets get VBZ 42759 2825 11 as as RB 42759 2825 12 much much JJ 42759 2825 13 compensation compensation NN 42759 2825 14 for for IN 42759 2825 15 the the DT 42759 2825 16 same same JJ 42759 2825 17 quality quality NN 42759 2825 18 and and CC 42759 2825 19 quantity quantity NN 42759 2825 20 of of IN 42759 2825 21 work work NN 42759 2825 22 as as IN 42759 2825 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2825 24 companion companion NN 42759 2825 25 who who WP 42759 2825 26 has have VBZ 42759 2825 27 only only RB 42759 2825 28 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 2825 29 ability ability NN 42759 2825 30 ; ; : 42759 2825 31 and and CC 42759 2825 32 the the DT 42759 2825 33 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 2825 34 intelligent intelligent JJ 42759 2825 35 business business NN 42759 2825 36 man man NN 42759 2825 37 stands stand VBZ 42759 2825 38 in in IN 42759 2825 39 the the DT 42759 2825 40 same same JJ 42759 2825 41 relation relation NN 42759 2825 42 to to IN 42759 2825 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2825 44 less less RBR 42759 2825 45 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2825 46 competitor competitor NN 42759 2825 47 ; ; : 42759 2825 48 yet yet CC 42759 2825 49 the the DT 42759 2825 50 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 2825 51 undergone undergo VBN 42759 2825 52 by by IN 42759 2825 53 the the DT 42759 2825 54 former former JJ 42759 2825 55 of of IN 42759 2825 56 each each DT 42759 2825 57 pair pair NN 42759 2825 58 is be VBZ 42759 2825 59 less less JJR 42759 2825 60 than than IN 42759 2825 61 that that DT 42759 2825 62 suffered suffer VBN 42759 2825 63 by by IN 42759 2825 64 the the DT 42759 2825 65 latter latter JJ 42759 2825 66 . . . 42759 2826 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2826 2 would would MD 42759 2826 3 seem seem VB 42759 2826 4 that that IN 42759 2826 5 if if IN 42759 2826 6 the the DT 42759 2826 7 more more RBR 42759 2826 8 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2826 9 men man NNS 42759 2826 10 may may MD 42759 2826 11 properly properly RB 42759 2826 12 take take VB 42759 2826 13 the the DT 42759 2826 14 same same JJ 42759 2826 15 rewards reward NNS 42759 2826 16 as as IN 42759 2826 17 those those DT 42759 2826 18 who who WP 42759 2826 19 make make VBP 42759 2826 20 larger large JJR 42759 2826 21 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 2826 22 , , , 42759 2826 23 the the DT 42759 2826 24 non non JJ 42759 2826 25 - - JJ 42759 2826 26 sacrifice sacrifice JJ 42759 2826 27 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2826 28 might may MD 42759 2826 29 lawfully lawfully RB 42759 2826 30 accept accept VB 42759 2826 31 the the DT 42759 2826 32 same same JJ 42759 2826 33 interest interest NN 42759 2826 34 as as IN 42759 2826 35 the the DT 42759 2826 36 man man NN 42759 2826 37 whose whose WP$ 42759 2826 38 saving saving NN 42759 2826 39 involves involve VBZ 42759 2826 40 some some DT 42759 2826 41 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2826 42 . . . 42759 2827 1 On on IN 42759 2827 2 this this DT 42759 2827 3 principle principle NN 42759 2827 4 the the DT 42759 2827 5 lenders lender NNS 42759 2827 6 who who WP 42759 2827 7 would would MD 42759 2827 8 not not RB 42759 2827 9 have have VB 42759 2827 10 invested invest VBN 42759 2827 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2827 12 money money NN 42759 2827 13 in in IN 42759 2827 14 a a DT 42759 2827 15 productive productive JJ 42759 2827 16 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 2827 17 were be VBD 42759 2827 18 nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2827 19 permitted permit VBN 42759 2827 20 by by IN 42759 2827 21 the the DT 42759 2827 22 moralists moralist NNS 42759 2827 23 of of IN 42759 2827 24 the the DT 42759 2827 25 post post JJ 42759 2827 26 - - JJ 42759 2827 27 mediæval mediæval JJ 42759 2827 28 period period NN 42759 2827 29 to to TO 42759 2827 30 take take VB 42759 2827 31 advantage advantage NN 42759 2827 32 of of IN 42759 2827 33 the the DT 42759 2827 34 title title NN 42759 2827 35 of of IN 42759 2827 36 _ _ NNP 42759 2827 37 lucrum lucrum NNP 42759 2827 38 cessans cessans NNP 42759 2827 39 _ _ NNP 42759 2827 40 . . . 42759 2828 1 Although although IN 42759 2828 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2828 3 had have VBD 42759 2828 4 relinquished relinquish VBN 42759 2828 5 no no DT 42759 2828 6 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 2828 7 of of IN 42759 2828 8 gain gain NN 42759 2828 9 , , , 42759 2828 10 nor nor CC 42759 2828 11 made make VBD 42759 2828 12 any any DT 42759 2828 13 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 2828 14 , , , 42759 2828 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2828 16 were be VBD 42759 2828 17 put put VBN 42759 2828 18 on on IN 42759 2828 19 the the DT 42759 2828 20 same same JJ 42759 2828 21 moral moral JJ 42759 2828 22 level level NN 42759 2828 23 as as IN 42759 2828 24 sacrificing sacrifice VBG 42759 2828 25 lenders lender NNS 42759 2828 26 , , , 42759 2828 27 and and CC 42759 2828 28 were be VBD 42759 2828 29 allowed allow VBN 42759 2828 30 to to TO 42759 2828 31 take take VB 42759 2828 32 the the DT 42759 2828 33 same same JJ 42759 2828 34 interest interest NN 42759 2828 35 . . . 42759 2829 1 As as IN 42759 2829 2 a a DT 42759 2829 3 determinant determinant NN 42759 2829 4 of of IN 42759 2829 5 ownership ownership NN 42759 2829 6 , , , 42759 2829 7 possession possession NN 42759 2829 8 is be VBZ 42759 2829 9 the the DT 42759 2829 10 feeblest feeblest NN 42759 2829 11 of of IN 42759 2829 12 all all DT 42759 2829 13 factors factor NNS 42759 2829 14 , , , 42759 2829 15 and and CC 42759 2829 16 yet yet RB 42759 2829 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2829 18 is be VBZ 42759 2829 19 of of IN 42759 2829 20 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2829 21 importance importance NN 42759 2829 22 for for IN 42759 2829 23 a a DT 42759 2829 24 large large JJ 42759 2829 25 proportion proportion NN 42759 2829 26 of of IN 42759 2829 27 incomes income NNS 42759 2829 28 and and CC 42759 2829 29 property property NN 42759 2829 30 . . . 42759 2830 1 In in IN 42759 2830 2 the the DT 42759 2830 3 distribution distribution NN 42759 2830 4 of of IN 42759 2830 5 the the DT 42759 2830 6 national national JJ 42759 2830 7 product product NN 42759 2830 8 , , , 42759 2830 9 as as RB 42759 2830 10 well well RB 42759 2830 11 as as IN 42759 2830 12 in in IN 42759 2830 13 the the DT 42759 2830 14 division division NN 42759 2830 15 of of IN 42759 2830 16 the the DT 42759 2830 17 original original JJ 42759 2830 18 heritage heritage NN 42759 2830 19 of of IN 42759 2830 20 the the DT 42759 2830 21 earth earth NN 42759 2830 22 , , , 42759 2830 23 a a DT 42759 2830 24 large large JJ 42759 2830 25 part part NN 42759 2830 26 is be VBZ 42759 2830 27 played play VBN 42759 2830 28 by by IN 42759 2830 29 the the DT 42759 2830 30 title title NN 42759 2830 31 of of IN 42759 2830 32 first first JJ 42759 2830 33 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 2830 34 . . . 42759 2831 1 Much much JJ 42759 2831 2 of of IN 42759 2831 3 the the DT 42759 2831 4 product product NN 42759 2831 5 of of IN 42759 2831 6 industry industry NN 42759 2831 7 is be VBZ 42759 2831 8 assigned assign VBN 42759 2831 9 to to IN 42759 2831 10 the the DT 42759 2831 11 agents agent NNS 42759 2831 12 of of IN 42759 2831 13 production production NN 42759 2831 14 mainly mainly RB 42759 2831 15 on on IN 42759 2831 16 the the DT 42759 2831 17 basis basis NN 42759 2831 18 of of IN 42759 2831 19 inculpable inculpable JJ 42759 2831 20 possession possession NN 42759 2831 21 . . . 42759 2832 1 That that DT 42759 2832 2 is is RB 42759 2832 3 ; ; : 42759 2832 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2832 5 goes go VBZ 42759 2832 6 to to IN 42759 2832 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2832 8 receivers receiver NNS 42759 2832 9 automatically automatically RB 42759 2832 10 , , , 42759 2832 11 in in IN 42759 2832 12 exchange exchange NN 42759 2832 13 for for IN 42759 2832 14 benefits benefit NNS 42759 2832 15 to to IN 42759 2832 16 those those DT 42759 2832 17 who who WP 42759 2832 18 hand hand VB 42759 2832 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2832 20 over over RP 42759 2832 21 , , , 42759 2832 22 and and CC 42759 2832 23 without without IN 42759 2832 24 excessive excessive JJ 42759 2832 25 exploitation exploitation NN 42759 2832 26 of of IN 42759 2832 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2832 28 needs need NNS 42759 2832 29 . . . 42759 2833 1 Just just RB 42759 2833 2 as as IN 42759 2833 3 the the DT 42759 2833 4 first first JJ 42759 2833 5 arrival arrival NN 42759 2833 6 on on IN 42759 2833 7 a a DT 42759 2833 8 piece piece NN 42759 2833 9 of of IN 42759 2833 10 land land NN 42759 2833 11 may may MD 42759 2833 12 regard regard VB 42759 2833 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2833 14 as as IN 42759 2833 15 a a DT 42759 2833 16 no no DT 42759 2833 17 - - HYPH 42759 2833 18 man man NN 42759 2833 19 's 's POS 42759 2833 20 territory territory NN 42759 2833 21 , , , 42759 2833 22 and and CC 42759 2833 23 make make VB 42759 2833 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2833 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2833 26 own own JJ 42759 2833 27 by by IN 42759 2833 28 the the DT 42759 2833 29 mere mere JJ 42759 2833 30 device device NN 42759 2833 31 of of IN 42759 2833 32 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 2833 33 , , , 42759 2833 34 so so CC 42759 2833 35 the the DT 42759 2833 36 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2833 37 may may MD 42759 2833 38 get get VB 42759 2833 39 morally morally RB 42759 2833 40 valid valid JJ 42759 2833 41 possession possession NN 42759 2833 42 of of IN 42759 2833 43 interest interest NN 42759 2833 44 . . . 42759 2834 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 42759 2834 2 , , , 42759 2834 3 indeed indeed RB 42759 2834 4 , , , 42759 2834 5 this this DT 42759 2834 6 debatable debatable JJ 42759 2834 7 share share NN 42759 2834 8 , , , 42759 2834 9 this this DT 42759 2834 10 no no DT 42759 2834 11 - - HYPH 42759 2834 12 man man NN 42759 2834 13 's 's POS 42759 2834 14 share share NN 42759 2834 15 of of IN 42759 2834 16 the the DT 42759 2834 17 product product NN 42759 2834 18 of of IN 42759 2834 19 industry industry NN 42759 2834 20 , , , 42759 2834 21 is be VBZ 42759 2834 22 secured secure VBN 42759 2834 23 in in IN 42759 2834 24 some some DT 42759 2834 25 part part NN 42759 2834 26 by by IN 42759 2834 27 the the DT 42759 2834 28 consumer consumer NN 42759 2834 29 of of IN 42759 2834 30 the the DT 42759 2834 31 labourer labourer NN 42759 2834 32 . . . 42759 2835 1 In in IN 42759 2835 2 such such JJ 42759 2835 3 cases case NNS 42759 2835 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2835 5 title title NN 42759 2835 6 to to IN 42759 2835 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2835 8 is be VBZ 42759 2835 9 just just RB 42759 2835 10 as as RB 42759 2835 11 valid valid JJ 42759 2835 12 as as IN 42759 2835 13 the the DT 42759 2835 14 title title NN 42759 2835 15 of of IN 42759 2835 16 the the DT 42759 2835 17 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2835 18 , , , 42759 2835 19 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 42759 2835 20 the the DT 42759 2835 21 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 2835 22 titles title NNS 42759 2835 23 of of IN 42759 2835 24 productivity productivity NN 42759 2835 25 and and CC 42759 2835 26 service service NN 42759 2835 27 which which WDT 42759 2835 28 the the DT 42759 2835 29 latter latter NN 42759 2835 30 has have VBZ 42759 2835 31 in in IN 42759 2835 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2835 33 favour favour NN 42759 2835 34 . . . 42759 2836 1 First first JJ 42759 2836 2 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 2836 3 and and CC 42759 2836 4 possession possession NN 42759 2836 5 are be VBP 42759 2836 6 the the DT 42759 2836 7 more more RBR 42759 2836 8 decisive decisive JJ 42759 2836 9 factors factor NNS 42759 2836 10 . . . 42759 2837 1 In in IN 42759 2837 2 the the DT 42759 2837 3 great great JJ 42759 2837 4 majority majority NN 42759 2837 5 of of IN 42759 2837 6 instances instance NNS 42759 2837 7 , , , 42759 2837 8 however however RB 42759 2837 9 , , , 42759 2837 10 the the DT 42759 2837 11 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2837 12 is be VBZ 42759 2837 13 the the DT 42759 2837 14 first first JJ 42759 2837 15 occupant occupant NN 42759 2837 16 , , , 42759 2837 17 and and CC 42759 2837 18 therefore therefore RB 42759 2837 19 the the DT 42759 2837 20 lawful lawful JJ 42759 2837 21 possessor possessor NN 42759 2837 22 of of IN 42759 2837 23 the the DT 42759 2837 24 interest interest NN 42759 2837 25 - - HYPH 42759 2837 26 share share NN 42759 2837 27 . . . 42759 2838 1 The the DT 42759 2838 2 general general JJ 42759 2838 3 justification justification NN 42759 2838 4 of of IN 42759 2838 5 interest interest NN 42759 2838 6 set set VBN 42759 2838 7 forth forth RP 42759 2838 8 in in IN 42759 2838 9 the the DT 42759 2838 10 immediately immediately RB 42759 2838 11 preceding precede VBG 42759 2838 12 paragraphs paragraph NNS 42759 2838 13 is be VBZ 42759 2838 14 supplemented supplement VBN 42759 2838 15 in in IN 42759 2838 16 the the DT 42759 2838 17 case case NN 42759 2838 18 of of IN 42759 2838 19 the the DT 42759 2838 20 great great JJ 42759 2838 21 majority majority NN 42759 2838 22 of of IN 42759 2838 23 capital capital NN 42759 2838 24 owners owner NNS 42759 2838 25 by by IN 42759 2838 26 the the DT 42759 2838 27 fact fact NN 42759 2838 28 that that IN 42759 2838 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2838 30 income income NN 42759 2838 31 from from IN 42759 2838 32 this this DT 42759 2838 33 source source NN 42759 2838 34 is be VBZ 42759 2838 35 relatively relatively RB 42759 2838 36 insignificant insignificant JJ 42759 2838 37 . . . 42759 2839 1 The the DT 42759 2839 2 average average JJ 42759 2839 3 income income NN 42759 2839 4 of of IN 42759 2839 5 the the DT 42759 2839 6 farmers farmer NNS 42759 2839 7 of of IN 42759 2839 8 the the DT 42759 2839 9 United United NNP 42759 2839 10 States States NNP 42759 2839 11 is be VBZ 42759 2839 12 only only RB 42759 2839 13 724 724 CD 42759 2839 14 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2839 15 per per IN 42759 2839 16 year year NN 42759 2839 17 , , , 42759 2839 18 and and CC 42759 2839 19 of of IN 42759 2839 20 this this DT 42759 2839 21 322 322 CD 42759 2839 22 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2839 23 is be VBZ 42759 2839 24 interest interest NN 42759 2839 25 on on IN 42759 2839 26 the the DT 42759 2839 27 capital capital NN 42759 2839 28 invested invest VBN 42759 2839 29 in in IN 42759 2839 30 the the DT 42759 2839 31 farm farm NN 42759 2839 32 . . . 42759 2840 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2840 2 151 151 CD 42759 2840 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2840 4 Even even RB 42759 2840 5 when when WRB 42759 2840 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2840 7 make make VBP 42759 2840 8 due due JJ 42759 2840 9 allowance allowance NN 42759 2840 10 for for IN 42759 2840 11 the the DT 42759 2840 12 high high JJ 42759 2840 13 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 2840 14 power power NN 42759 2840 15 of of IN 42759 2840 16 farm farm NN 42759 2840 17 incomes income NNS 42759 2840 18 , , , 42759 2840 19 due due IN 42759 2840 20 to to IN 42759 2840 21 the the DT 42759 2840 22 lower low JJR 42759 2840 23 cost cost NN 42759 2840 24 of of IN 42759 2840 25 foodstuffs foodstuff NNS 42759 2840 26 and and CC 42759 2840 27 house house NN 42759 2840 28 rent rent NN 42759 2840 29 , , , 42759 2840 30 the the DT 42759 2840 31 total total JJ 42759 2840 32 amount amount NN 42759 2840 33 of of IN 42759 2840 34 724 724 CD 42759 2840 35 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2840 36 provides provide VBZ 42759 2840 37 only only RB 42759 2840 38 a a DT 42759 2840 39 very very RB 42759 2840 40 moderate moderate JJ 42759 2840 41 living living NN 42759 2840 42 . . . 42759 2841 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 2841 2 the the DT 42759 2841 3 great great JJ 42759 2841 4 majority majority NN 42759 2841 5 of of IN 42759 2841 6 farmers farmer NNS 42759 2841 7 can can MD 42759 2841 8 regard regard VB 42759 2841 9 the the DT 42759 2841 10 interest interest NN 42759 2841 11 that that WDT 42759 2841 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2841 13 receive receive VBP 42759 2841 14 as as IN 42759 2841 15 a a DT 42759 2841 16 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2841 17 part part NN 42759 2841 18 of of IN 42759 2841 19 the the DT 42759 2841 20 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 2841 21 that that WDT 42759 2841 22 is be VBZ 42759 2841 23 fairly fairly RB 42759 2841 24 due due JJ 42759 2841 25 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2841 26 on on IN 42759 2841 27 account account NN 42759 2841 28 of of IN 42759 2841 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2841 30 labour labour NN 42759 2841 31 , , , 42759 2841 32 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 2841 33 , , , 42759 2841 34 and and CC 42759 2841 35 risks risk NNS 42759 2841 36 . . . 42759 2842 1 So so RB 42759 2842 2 far far RB 42759 2842 3 as as IN 42759 2842 4 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2842 5 are be VBP 42759 2842 6 concerned concern VBN 42759 2842 7 , , , 42759 2842 8 the the DT 42759 2842 9 justification justification NN 42759 2842 10 of of IN 42759 2842 11 interest interest NN 42759 2842 12 , , , 42759 2842 13 as as IN 42759 2842 14 interest interest NN 42759 2842 15 , , , 42759 2842 16 is be VBZ 42759 2842 17 not not RB 42759 2842 18 a a DT 42759 2842 19 practical practical JJ 42759 2842 20 question question NN 42759 2842 21 . . . 42759 2843 1 The the DT 42759 2843 2 same same JJ 42759 2843 3 observation observation NN 42759 2843 4 applies apply VBZ 42759 2843 5 to to IN 42759 2843 6 the the DT 42759 2843 7 majority majority NN 42759 2843 8 of of IN 42759 2843 9 urban urban JJ 42759 2843 10 business business NN 42759 2843 11 men man NNS 42759 2843 12 , , , 42759 2843 13 such such JJ 42759 2843 14 as as IN 42759 2843 15 small small JJ 42759 2843 16 merchants merchant NNS 42759 2843 17 and and CC 42759 2843 18 manufacturers manufacturer NNS 42759 2843 19 . . . 42759 2844 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2844 2 interest interest NN 42759 2844 3 can can MD 42759 2844 4 be be VB 42759 2844 5 justified justify VBN 42759 2844 6 as as IN 42759 2844 7 not not RB 42759 2844 8 more more JJR 42759 2844 9 than than IN 42759 2844 10 fair fair JJ 42759 2844 11 wages wage NNS 42759 2844 12 and and CC 42759 2844 13 profits profit NNS 42759 2844 14 . . . 42759 2845 1 Again again RB 42759 2845 2 , , , 42759 2845 3 there there EX 42759 2845 4 is be VBZ 42759 2845 5 a a DT 42759 2845 6 large large JJ 42759 2845 7 number number NN 42759 2845 8 of of IN 42759 2845 9 interest interest NN 42759 2845 10 receivers receiver NNS 42759 2845 11 who who WP 42759 2845 12 are be VBP 42759 2845 13 entirely entirely RB 42759 2845 14 dependent dependent JJ 42759 2845 15 upon upon IN 42759 2845 16 this this DT 42759 2845 17 kind kind NN 42759 2845 18 of of IN 42759 2845 19 income income NN 42759 2845 20 , , , 42759 2845 21 and and CC 42759 2845 22 who who WP 42759 2845 23 obtain obtain VBP 42759 2845 24 therefrom therefrom NNP 42759 2845 25 only only RB 42759 2845 26 a a DT 42759 2845 27 moderate moderate JJ 42759 2845 28 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 2845 29 . . . 42759 2846 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2846 2 are be VBP 42759 2846 3 mainly mainly RB 42759 2846 4 children child NNS 42759 2846 5 , , , 42759 2846 6 aged aged JJ 42759 2846 7 persons person NNS 42759 2846 8 , , , 42759 2846 9 and and CC 42759 2846 10 invalids invalid NNS 42759 2846 11 . . . 42759 2847 1 Unlike unlike IN 42759 2847 2 the the DT 42759 2847 3 classes class NNS 42759 2847 4 just just RB 42759 2847 5 described describe VBN 42759 2847 6 , , , 42759 2847 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2847 8 can can MD 42759 2847 9 not not RB 42759 2847 10 justify justify VB 42759 2847 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2847 12 interest interest NN 42759 2847 13 as as IN 42759 2847 14 a a DT 42759 2847 15 fair fair JJ 42759 2847 16 supplement supplement NN 42759 2847 17 to to IN 42759 2847 18 wages wage NNS 42759 2847 19 ; ; : 42759 2847 20 however however RB 42759 2847 21 , , , 42759 2847 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2847 23 may may MD 42759 2847 24 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 2847 25 claim claim VB 42759 2847 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2847 27 as as IN 42759 2847 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2847 29 equitable equitable JJ 42759 2847 30 or or CC 42759 2847 31 charitable charitable JJ 42759 2847 32 share share NN 42759 2847 33 of of IN 42759 2847 34 the the DT 42759 2847 35 common common JJ 42759 2847 36 heritage heritage NN 42759 2847 37 of of IN 42759 2847 38 the the DT 42759 2847 39 earth earth NN 42759 2847 40 . . . 42759 2848 1 If if IN 42759 2848 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2848 3 did do VBD 42759 2848 4 not not RB 42759 2848 5 receive receive VB 42759 2848 6 this this DT 42759 2848 7 interest interest NN 42759 2848 8 - - HYPH 42759 2848 9 income income NN 42759 2848 10 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2848 11 would would MD 42759 2848 12 have have VB 42759 2848 13 to to TO 42759 2848 14 be be VB 42759 2848 15 supported support VBN 42759 2848 16 by by IN 42759 2848 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2848 18 relatives relative NNS 42759 2848 19 or or CC 42759 2848 20 by by IN 42759 2848 21 the the DT 42759 2848 22 State State NNP 42759 2848 23 . . . 42759 2849 1 For for IN 42759 2849 2 many many JJ 42759 2849 3 reasons reason NNS 42759 2849 4 this this DT 42759 2849 5 would would MD 42759 2849 6 be be VB 42759 2849 7 a a DT 42759 2849 8 much much RB 42759 2849 9 less less RBR 42759 2849 10 desirable desirable JJ 42759 2849 11 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 2849 12 . . . 42759 2850 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 2850 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2850 3 general general JJ 42759 2850 4 claim claim NN 42759 2850 5 to to IN 42759 2850 6 interest interest NN 42759 2850 7 is be VBZ 42759 2850 8 supplemented supplement VBN 42759 2850 9 by by IN 42759 2850 10 considerations consideration NNS 42759 2850 11 of of IN 42759 2850 12 human human JJ 42759 2850 13 welfare welfare NN 42759 2850 14 . . . 42759 2851 1 The the DT 42759 2851 2 difference difference NN 42759 2851 3 between between IN 42759 2851 4 the the DT 42759 2851 5 ethical ethical JJ 42759 2851 6 character character NN 42759 2851 7 of of IN 42759 2851 8 the the DT 42759 2851 9 interest interest NN 42759 2851 10 discussed discuss VBN 42759 2851 11 in in IN 42759 2851 12 the the DT 42759 2851 13 last last JJ 42759 2851 14 two two CD 42759 2851 15 paragraphs paragraph NNS 42759 2851 16 and and CC 42759 2851 17 of of IN 42759 2851 18 that that DT 42759 2851 19 received receive VBN 42759 2851 20 by by IN 42759 2851 21 persons person NNS 42759 2851 22 who who WP 42759 2851 23 possess possess VBP 42759 2851 24 large large JJ 42759 2851 25 incomes income NNS 42759 2851 26 , , , 42759 2851 27 is be VBZ 42759 2851 28 too too RB 42759 2851 29 often often RB 42759 2851 30 overlooked overlook VBN 42759 2851 31 in in IN 42759 2851 32 technical technical JJ 42759 2851 33 treatises treatise NNS 42759 2851 34 . . . 42759 2852 1 Every every DT 42759 2852 2 man man NN 42759 2852 3 owning own VBG 42759 2852 4 any any DT 42759 2852 5 productive productive JJ 42759 2852 6 goods good NNS 42759 2852 7 is be VBZ 42759 2852 8 reckoned reckon VBN 42759 2852 9 as as IN 42759 2852 10 a a DT 42759 2852 11 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2852 12 , , , 42759 2852 13 and and CC 42759 2852 14 assumed assume VBN 42759 2852 15 to to TO 42759 2852 16 receive receive VB 42759 2852 17 interest interest NN 42759 2852 18 . . . 42759 2853 1 If if IN 42759 2853 2 , , , 42759 2853 3 however however RB 42759 2853 4 , , , 42759 2853 5 a a DT 42759 2853 6 man man NN 42759 2853 7 's 's POS 42759 2853 8 total total JJ 42759 2853 9 interest interest NN 42759 2853 10 - - HYPH 42759 2853 11 income income NN 42759 2853 12 is be VBZ 42759 2853 13 so so RB 42759 2853 14 small small JJ 42759 2853 15 that that IN 42759 2853 16 when when WRB 42759 2853 17 combined combine VBN 42759 2853 18 with with IN 42759 2853 19 all all PDT 42759 2853 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2853 21 other other JJ 42759 2853 22 revenues revenue NNS 42759 2853 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2853 24 merely merely RB 42759 2853 25 completes complete VBZ 42759 2853 26 the the DT 42759 2853 27 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 2853 28 of of IN 42759 2853 29 a a DT 42759 2853 30 decent decent JJ 42759 2853 31 living living NN 42759 2853 32 , , , 42759 2853 33 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2853 34 is be VBZ 42759 2853 35 surely surely RB 42759 2853 36 of of IN 42759 2853 37 very very RB 42759 2853 38 little little JJ 42759 2853 39 significance significance NN 42759 2853 40 as as IN 42759 2853 41 interest interest NN 42759 2853 42 . . . 42759 2854 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2854 2 stands stand VBZ 42759 2854 3 in in IN 42759 2854 4 no no DT 42759 2854 5 such such JJ 42759 2854 6 need need NN 42759 2854 7 of of IN 42759 2854 8 justification justification NN 42759 2854 9 as as IN 42759 2854 10 the the DT 42759 2854 11 interest interest NN 42759 2854 12 obtained obtain VBN 42759 2854 13 by by IN 42759 2854 14 men man NNS 42759 2854 15 whose whose WP$ 42759 2854 16 incomes income NNS 42759 2854 17 amount amount VBP 42759 2854 18 to to IN 42759 2854 19 , , , 42759 2854 20 say say VB 42759 2854 21 , , , 42759 2854 22 ten ten CD 42759 2854 23 thousand thousand CD 42759 2854 24 dollars dollar NNS 42759 2854 25 a a DT 42759 2854 26 year year NN 42759 2854 27 and and CC 42759 2854 28 upwards upward NNS 42759 2854 29 . . . 42759 2855 1 Still still RB 42759 2855 2 another another DT 42759 2855 3 confirmatory confirmatory JJ 42759 2855 4 title title NN 42759 2855 5 of of IN 42759 2855 6 interest interest NN 42759 2855 7 is be VBZ 42759 2855 8 suggested suggest VBN 42759 2855 9 by by IN 42759 2855 10 the the DT 42759 2855 11 following follow VBG 42759 2855 12 well well RB 42759 2855 13 known know VBN 42759 2855 14 declaration declaration NN 42759 2855 15 of of IN 42759 2855 16 St. St. NNP 42759 2855 17 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 2855 18 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 42759 2855 19 : : : 42759 2855 20 " " `` 42759 2855 21 The the DT 42759 2855 22 possession possession NN 42759 2855 23 of of IN 42759 2855 24 riches rich NNS 42759 2855 25 is be VBZ 42759 2855 26 not not RB 42759 2855 27 in in IN 42759 2855 28 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 2855 29 unlawful unlawful JJ 42759 2855 30 if if IN 42759 2855 31 the the DT 42759 2855 32 order order NN 42759 2855 33 of of IN 42759 2855 34 reason reason NN 42759 2855 35 be be VB 42759 2855 36 observed observe VBN 42759 2855 37 : : : 42759 2855 38 that that IN 42759 2855 39 a a DT 42759 2855 40 man man NN 42759 2855 41 should should MD 42759 2855 42 possess possess VB 42759 2855 43 justly justly RB 42759 2855 44 what what WP 42759 2855 45 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2855 46 owns own VBZ 42759 2855 47 , , , 42759 2855 48 and and CC 42759 2855 49 _ _ NNP 42759 2855 50 use use NN 42759 2855 51 _ _ IN 42759 2855 52 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2855 53 in in IN 42759 2855 54 a a DT 42759 2855 55 proper proper JJ 42759 2855 56 manner manner NN 42759 2855 57 for for IN 42759 2855 58 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 2855 59 and and CC 42759 2855 60 others other NNS 42759 2855 61 . . . 42759 2856 1 " " `` 42759 2856 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2856 3 152 152 CD 42759 2856 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2856 5 Neither neither CC 42759 2856 6 just just RB 42759 2856 7 acquisition acquisition NN 42759 2856 8 nor nor CC 42759 2856 9 proper proper JJ 42759 2856 10 use use NN 42759 2856 11 is be VBZ 42759 2856 12 alone alone RB 42759 2856 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2856 14 to to TO 42759 2856 15 render render VB 42759 2856 16 private private JJ 42759 2856 17 possessions possession NNS 42759 2856 18 morally morally RB 42759 2856 19 good good JJ 42759 2856 20 . . . 42759 2857 1 Both both DT 42759 2857 2 must must MD 42759 2857 3 be be VB 42759 2857 4 present present JJ 42759 2857 5 . . . 42759 2858 1 As as IN 42759 2858 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2858 3 have have VBP 42759 2858 4 seen see VBN 42759 2858 5 above above RB 42759 2858 6 , , , 42759 2858 7 the the DT 42759 2858 8 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2858 9 can can MD 42759 2858 10 appeal appeal VB 42759 2858 11 to to IN 42759 2858 12 certain certain JJ 42759 2858 13 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 2858 14 and and CC 42759 2858 15 analogous analogous JJ 42759 2858 16 titles title NNS 42759 2858 17 which which WDT 42759 2858 18 justify justify VBP 42759 2858 19 practically practically RB 42759 2858 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2858 21 acquisition acquisition NN 42759 2858 22 of of IN 42759 2858 23 interest interest NN 42759 2858 24 ; ; : 42759 2858 25 but but CC 42759 2858 26 there there EX 42759 2858 27 can can MD 42759 2858 28 be be VB 42759 2858 29 no no DT 42759 2858 30 doubt doubt NN 42759 2858 31 that that IN 42759 2858 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2858 33 claim claim NN 42759 2858 34 and and CC 42759 2858 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2858 36 moral moral JJ 42759 2858 37 power power NN 42759 2858 38 of of IN 42759 2858 39 disposal disposal NN 42759 2858 40 are be VBP 42759 2858 41 considerably considerably RB 42759 2858 42 strengthened strengthen VBN 42759 2858 43 when when WRB 42759 2858 44 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2858 45 puts put VBZ 42759 2858 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2858 47 interest interest NN 42759 2858 48 - - HYPH 42759 2858 49 income income NN 42759 2858 50 to to IN 42759 2858 51 a a DT 42759 2858 52 proper proper JJ 42759 2858 53 use use NN 42759 2858 54 . . . 42759 2859 1 One one CD 42759 2859 2 way way NN 42759 2859 3 of of IN 42759 2859 4 so so RB 42759 2859 5 using use VBG 42759 2859 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2859 7 is be VBZ 42759 2859 8 for for IN 42759 2859 9 a a DT 42759 2859 10 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2859 11 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 2859 12 , , , 42759 2859 13 as as IN 42759 2859 14 exemplified exemplify VBN 42759 2859 15 in in IN 42759 2859 16 the the DT 42759 2859 17 case case NN 42759 2859 18 of of IN 42759 2859 19 the the DT 42759 2859 20 farmers farmer NNS 42759 2859 21 , , , 42759 2859 22 business business NN 42759 2859 23 men man NNS 42759 2859 24 , , , 42759 2859 25 and and CC 42759 2859 26 non non NNS 42759 2859 27 - - NNS 42759 2859 28 workers worker NNS 42759 2859 29 whom whom WP 42759 2859 30 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2859 31 considered consider VBD 42759 2859 32 above above RB 42759 2859 33 . . . 42759 2860 1 Those those DT 42759 2860 2 persons person NNS 42759 2860 3 who who WP 42759 2860 4 receive receive VBP 42759 2860 5 incomes income NNS 42759 2860 6 in in IN 42759 2860 7 excess excess NN 42759 2860 8 of of IN 42759 2860 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2860 10 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2860 11 needs need NNS 42759 2860 12 could could MD 42759 2860 13 devote devote VB 42759 2860 14 the the DT 42759 2860 15 surplus surplus NN 42759 2860 16 to to IN 42759 2860 17 religion religion NN 42759 2860 18 , , , 42759 2860 19 charity charity NN 42759 2860 20 , , , 42759 2860 21 education education NN 42759 2860 22 , , , 42759 2860 23 and and CC 42759 2860 24 a a DT 42759 2860 25 great great JJ 42759 2860 26 variety variety NN 42759 2860 27 of of IN 42759 2860 28 altruistic altruistic JJ 42759 2860 29 purposes purpose NNS 42759 2860 30 . . . 42759 2861 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 2861 2 shall shall MD 42759 2861 3 deal deal VB 42759 2861 4 with with IN 42759 2861 5 this this DT 42759 2861 6 matter matter NN 42759 2861 7 specifically specifically RB 42759 2861 8 in in IN 42759 2861 9 the the DT 42759 2861 10 chapter chapter NN 42759 2861 11 on on IN 42759 2861 12 the the DT 42759 2861 13 " " `` 42759 2861 14 Duty Duty NNP 42759 2861 15 of of IN 42759 2861 16 Distributing distribute VBG 42759 2861 17 Superfluous Superfluous NNP 42759 2861 18 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 2861 19 . . . 42759 2861 20 " " '' 42759 2862 1 In in IN 42759 2862 2 the the DT 42759 2862 3 meantime meantime NN 42759 2862 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2862 5 is be VBZ 42759 2862 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2862 7 to to TO 42759 2862 8 note note VB 42759 2862 9 that that IN 42759 2862 10 the the DT 42759 2862 11 rich rich JJ 42759 2862 12 man man NN 42759 2862 13 who who WP 42759 2862 14 makes make VBZ 42759 2862 15 a a DT 42759 2862 16 benevolent benevolent JJ 42759 2862 17 use use NN 42759 2862 18 of of IN 42759 2862 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2862 20 interest interest NN 42759 2862 21 - - HYPH 42759 2862 22 income income NN 42759 2862 23 has have VBZ 42759 2862 24 a a DT 42759 2862 25 special special JJ 42759 2862 26 reason reason NN 42759 2862 27 for for IN 42759 2862 28 believing believe VBG 42759 2862 29 that that IN 42759 2862 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2862 31 receipt receipt NN 42759 2862 32 of of IN 42759 2862 33 interest interest NN 42759 2862 34 is be VBZ 42759 2862 35 justified justify VBN 42759 2862 36 . . . 42759 2863 1 The the DT 42759 2863 2 decisive decisive JJ 42759 2863 3 value value NN 42759 2863 4 attributed attribute VBN 42759 2863 5 to to IN 42759 2863 6 presumption presumption NN 42759 2863 7 , , , 42759 2863 8 analogy analogy NN 42759 2863 9 , , , 42759 2863 10 possession possession NN 42759 2863 11 , , , 42759 2863 12 and and CC 42759 2863 13 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 2863 14 titles title NNS 42759 2863 15 in in IN 42759 2863 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2863 17 vindication vindication NN 42759 2863 18 of of IN 42759 2863 19 the the DT 42759 2863 20 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2863 21 's 's POS 42759 2863 22 claim claim NN 42759 2863 23 to to IN 42759 2863 24 interest interest NN 42759 2863 25 , , , 42759 2863 26 is be VBZ 42759 2863 27 no no DT 42759 2863 28 doubt doubt RB 42759 2863 29 disappointing disappointing JJ 42759 2863 30 to to IN 42759 2863 31 those those DT 42759 2863 32 persons person NNS 42759 2863 33 who who WP 42759 2863 34 desire desire VBP 42759 2863 35 clear clear RB 42759 2863 36 - - HYPH 42759 2863 37 cut cut VBN 42759 2863 38 mathematical mathematical JJ 42759 2863 39 rules rule NNS 42759 2863 40 and and CC 42759 2863 41 principles principle NNS 42759 2863 42 . . . 42759 2864 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2864 2 , , , 42759 2864 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2864 4 are be VBP 42759 2864 5 the the DT 42759 2864 6 only only JJ 42759 2864 7 factors factor NNS 42759 2864 8 that that WDT 42759 2864 9 seem seem VBP 42759 2864 10 to to TO 42759 2864 11 be be VB 42759 2864 12 available available JJ 42759 2864 13 . . . 42759 2865 1 While while IN 42759 2865 2 the the DT 42759 2865 3 title title NN 42759 2865 4 that that WDT 42759 2865 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2865 6 confer confer VBP 42759 2865 7 upon upon IN 42759 2865 8 the the DT 42759 2865 9 interest interest NN 42759 2865 10 receiver receiver NN 42759 2865 11 is be VBZ 42759 2865 12 not not RB 42759 2865 13 as as RB 42759 2865 14 definite definite JJ 42759 2865 15 nor nor CC 42759 2865 16 as as RB 42759 2865 17 noble noble JJ 42759 2865 18 as as IN 42759 2865 19 that that DT 42759 2865 20 by by IN 42759 2865 21 which which WDT 42759 2865 22 the the DT 42759 2865 23 labourer labourer NN 42759 2865 24 claims claim VBZ 42759 2865 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2865 26 wages wage NNS 42759 2865 27 or or CC 42759 2865 28 the the DT 42759 2865 29 business business NN 42759 2865 30 man man NN 42759 2865 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2865 32 profits profit NNS 42759 2865 33 , , , 42759 2865 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2865 35 is be VBZ 42759 2865 36 morally morally RB 42759 2865 37 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2865 38 . . . 42759 2866 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2866 2 will will MD 42759 2866 3 remain remain VB 42759 2866 4 logically logically RB 42759 2866 5 and and CC 42759 2866 6 ethically ethically RB 42759 2866 7 unshaken unshaken JJ 42759 2866 8 until until IN 42759 2866 9 more more JJR 42759 2866 10 cogent cogent JJ 42759 2866 11 arguments argument NNS 42759 2866 12 have have VBP 42759 2866 13 been be VBN 42759 2866 14 brought bring VBN 42759 2866 15 against against IN 42759 2866 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2866 17 than than IN 42759 2866 18 have have VBP 42759 2866 19 yet yet RB 42759 2866 20 appeared appear VBN 42759 2866 21 in in IN 42759 2866 22 the the DT 42759 2866 23 denunciations denunciation NNS 42759 2866 24 of of IN 42759 2866 25 the the DT 42759 2866 26 income income NN 42759 2866 27 of of IN 42759 2866 28 the the DT 42759 2866 29 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2866 30 . . . 42759 2867 1 And and CC 42759 2867 2 what what WP 42759 2867 3 is be VBZ 42759 2867 4 true true JJ 42759 2867 5 of of IN 42759 2867 6 him -PRON- PRP 42759 2867 7 is be VBZ 42759 2867 8 likewise likewise RB 42759 2867 9 true true JJ 42759 2867 10 of of IN 42759 2867 11 the the DT 42759 2867 12 rent rent NN 42759 2867 13 receiver receiver NN 42759 2867 14 , , , 42759 2867 15 and and CC 42759 2867 16 of of IN 42759 2867 17 the the DT 42759 2867 18 person person NN 42759 2867 19 who who WP 42759 2867 20 profits profit VBZ 42759 2867 21 by by IN 42759 2867 22 the the DT 42759 2867 23 " " `` 42759 2867 24 unearned unearned JJ 42759 2867 25 increment increment NN 42759 2867 26 " " '' 42759 2867 27 of of IN 42759 2867 28 land land NN 42759 2867 29 values value NNS 42759 2867 30 . . . 42759 2868 1 In in IN 42759 2868 2 all all DT 42759 2868 3 three three CD 42759 2868 4 cases case NNS 42759 2868 5 the the DT 42759 2868 6 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 2868 7 justification justification NN 42759 2868 8 of of IN 42759 2868 9 " " `` 42759 2868 10 workless workless NN 42759 2868 11 " " '' 42759 2868 12 incomes income NNS 42759 2868 13 will will MD 42759 2868 14 probably probably RB 42759 2868 15 remain remain VB 42759 2868 16 valid valid JJ 42759 2868 17 as as RB 42759 2868 18 long long RB 42759 2868 19 as as IN 42759 2868 20 the the DT 42759 2868 21 present present JJ 42759 2868 22 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2868 23 system system NN 42759 2868 24 endures endure NNS 42759 2868 25 . . . 42759 2869 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 2869 2 : : : 42759 2869 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2869 4 142 142 CD 42759 2869 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2869 6 " " `` 42759 2869 7 Growth Growth NNP 42759 2869 8 of of IN 42759 2869 9 Capital capital NN 42759 2869 10 , , , 42759 2869 11 " " '' 42759 2869 12 p. p. NN 42759 2869 13 152 152 CD 42759 2869 14 . . . 42759 2870 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2870 2 143 143 CD 42759 2870 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2870 4 Cf cf NN 42759 2870 5 . . . 42759 2871 1 Gonner Gonner NNP 42759 2871 2 , , , 42759 2871 3 " " `` 42759 2871 4 Interest Interest NNP 42759 2871 5 and and CC 42759 2871 6 Saving Saving NNP 42759 2871 7 , , , 42759 2871 8 " " '' 42759 2871 9 p. p. NN 42759 2871 10 73 73 CD 42759 2871 11 ; ; : 42759 2871 12 Cassel Cassel NNP 42759 2871 13 , , , 42759 2871 14 " " `` 42759 2871 15 The the DT 42759 2871 16 Nature Nature NNP 42759 2871 17 and and CC 42759 2871 18 Necessity Necessity NNP 42759 2871 19 of of IN 42759 2871 20 Interest Interest NNP 42759 2871 21 , , , 42759 2871 22 " " '' 42759 2871 23 ch ch NN 42759 2871 24 . . . 42759 2872 1 iv iv XX 42759 2872 2 . . . 42759 2873 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2873 2 144 144 CD 42759 2873 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2873 4 New New NNP 42759 2873 5 York York NNP 42759 2873 6 , , , 42759 2873 7 1907 1907 CD 42759 2873 8 . . . 42759 2874 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2874 2 145 145 CD 42759 2874 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2874 4 " " `` 42759 2874 5 Principles Principles NNPS 42759 2874 6 of of IN 42759 2874 7 Economics Economics NNP 42759 2874 8 , , , 42759 2874 9 " " '' 42759 2874 10 II ii CD 42759 2874 11 , , , 42759 2874 12 42 42 CD 42759 2874 13 . . . 42759 2875 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2875 2 146 146 CD 42759 2875 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2875 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2875 5 . . . 42759 2876 1 Hobson Hobson NNP 42759 2876 2 , , , 42759 2876 3 " " `` 42759 2876 4 The the DT 42759 2876 5 Economics Economics NNP 42759 2876 6 of of IN 42759 2876 7 Distribution Distribution NNP 42759 2876 8 , , , 42759 2876 9 " " '' 42759 2876 10 pp pp NNP 42759 2876 11 . . . 42759 2877 1 259 259 CD 42759 2877 2 - - SYM 42759 2877 3 265 265 CD 42759 2877 4 . . . 42759 2878 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2878 2 147 147 CD 42759 2878 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2878 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2878 5 . . . 42759 2879 1 Fisher Fisher NNP 42759 2879 2 , , , 42759 2879 3 " " `` 42759 2879 4 Elementary Elementary NNP 42759 2879 5 Principles Principles NNPS 42759 2879 6 of of IN 42759 2879 7 Economics Economics NNP 42759 2879 8 , , , 42759 2879 9 " " '' 42759 2879 10 pp pp NNP 42759 2879 11 . . . 42759 2880 1 396 396 CD 42759 2880 2 , , , 42759 2880 3 397 397 CD 42759 2880 4 . . . 42759 2881 1 However however RB 42759 2881 2 , , , 42759 2881 3 he -PRON- PRP 42759 2881 4 does do VBZ 42759 2881 5 not not RB 42759 2881 6 discuss discuss VB 42759 2881 7 in in IN 42759 2881 8 this this DT 42759 2881 9 passage passage NN 42759 2881 10 the the DT 42759 2881 11 possibility possibility NN 42759 2881 12 of of IN 42759 2881 13 suppressing suppress VBG 42759 2881 14 interest interest NN 42759 2881 15 on on IN 42759 2881 16 productive productive JJ 42759 2881 17 capital capital NN 42759 2881 18 by by IN 42759 2881 19 a a DT 42759 2881 20 direct direct JJ 42759 2881 21 method method NN 42759 2881 22 . . . 42759 2882 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2882 2 148 148 CD 42759 2882 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2882 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2882 5 . . . 42759 2883 1 Lehmkuhl Lehmkuhl NNP 42759 2883 2 , , , 42759 2883 3 " " `` 42759 2883 4 Theologia Theologia NNP 42759 2883 5 Moralis Moralis NNP 42759 2883 6 , , , 42759 2883 7 " " `` 42759 2883 8 I -PRON- PRP 42759 2883 9 , , , 42759 2883 10 nos nos NNP 42759 2883 11 . . . 42759 2884 1 917 917 CD 42759 2884 2 , , , 42759 2884 3 965 965 CD 42759 2884 4 , , , 42759 2884 5 1035 1035 CD 42759 2884 6 . . . 42759 2885 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2885 2 149 149 CD 42759 2885 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2885 4 Vol Vol NNP 42759 2885 5 . . . 42759 2886 1 3 3 CD 42759 2886 2 , , , 42759 2886 3 pp pp NNP 42759 2886 4 . . . 42759 2887 1 617 617 CD 42759 2887 2 - - SYM 42759 2887 3 629 629 CD 42759 2887 4 ; ; : 42759 2887 5 2d 2d CD 42759 2887 6 ed ed NN 42759 2887 7 . . . 42759 2888 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2888 2 150 150 CD 42759 2888 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2888 4 Ballerini Ballerini NNP 42759 2888 5 - - HYPH 42759 2888 6 Palmieri Palmieri NNP 42759 2888 7 , , , 42759 2888 8 loc loc NN 42759 2888 9 . . . 42759 2889 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2889 2 . . . 42759 2890 1 ; ; : 42759 2890 2 cf cf NN 42759 2890 3 . . . 42759 2891 1 Van Van NNP 42759 2891 2 Roey Roey NNP 42759 2891 3 , , , 42759 2891 4 op op NN 42759 2891 5 . . . 42759 2892 1 cit cit NNP 42759 2892 2 . . . 42759 2892 3 , , , 42759 2892 4 pp pp NNP 42759 2892 5 . . . 42759 2893 1 73 73 CD 42759 2893 2 - - SYM 42759 2893 3 75 75 CD 42759 2893 4 . . . 42759 2894 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2894 2 151 151 CD 42759 2894 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2894 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 2894 5 . . . 42759 2895 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2895 2 American American NNP 42759 2895 3 Economic Economic NNP 42759 2895 4 Review Review NNP 42759 2895 5 _ _ NNP 42759 2895 6 , , , 42759 2895 7 March March NNP 42759 2895 8 , , , 42759 2895 9 1916 1916 CD 42759 2895 10 ; ; : 42759 2895 11 p. p. NN 42759 2895 12 46 46 CD 42759 2895 13 . . . 42759 2896 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2896 2 152 152 CD 42759 2896 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2896 4 " " `` 42759 2896 5 Contra Contra NNP 42759 2896 6 Gentiles Gentiles NNPS 42759 2896 7 , , , 42759 2896 8 " " '' 42759 2896 9 lib lib NNP 42759 2896 10 . . . 42759 2897 1 3 3 CD 42759 2897 2 , , , 42759 2897 3 c. c. NNP 42759 2897 4 123 123 CD 42759 2897 5 . . . 42759 2898 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 42759 2898 2 XIV XIV NNP 42759 2898 3 CO CO NNP 42759 2898 4 - - HYPH 42759 2898 5 OPERATION OPERATION NNP 42759 2898 6 AS AS NNP 42759 2898 7 A a DT 42759 2898 8 PARTIAL PARTIAL NNP 42759 2898 9 SOLVENT solvent NN 42759 2898 10 OF of IN 42759 2898 11 CAPITALISM CAPITALISM NNP 42759 2898 12 Interest Interest NNP 42759 2898 13 is be VBZ 42759 2898 14 not not RB 42759 2898 15 a a DT 42759 2898 16 return return NN 42759 2898 17 for for IN 42759 2898 18 labour labour NN 42759 2898 19 . . . 42759 2899 1 The the DT 42759 2899 2 majority majority NN 42759 2899 3 of of IN 42759 2899 4 interest interest NN 42759 2899 5 receivers receiver NNS 42759 2899 6 are be VBP 42759 2899 7 , , , 42759 2899 8 indeed indeed RB 42759 2899 9 , , , 42759 2899 10 regularly regularly RB 42759 2899 11 engaged engage VBN 42759 2899 12 at at IN 42759 2899 13 some some DT 42759 2899 14 active active JJ 42759 2899 15 task task NN 42759 2899 16 , , , 42759 2899 17 whether whether IN 42759 2899 18 as as IN 42759 2899 19 day day NN 42759 2899 20 labourers labourer NNS 42759 2899 21 , , , 42759 2899 22 salaried salary VBD 42759 2899 23 employés employés JJ 42759 2899 24 , , , 42759 2899 25 directors director NNS 42759 2899 26 of of IN 42759 2899 27 industry industry NN 42759 2899 28 , , , 42759 2899 29 or or CC 42759 2899 30 members member NNS 42759 2899 31 of of IN 42759 2899 32 the the DT 42759 2899 33 professions profession NNS 42759 2899 34 ; ; : 42759 2899 35 but but CC 42759 2899 36 for for IN 42759 2899 37 these these DT 42759 2899 38 services service NNS 42759 2899 39 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2899 40 obtain obtain VBP 42759 2899 41 specific specific JJ 42759 2899 42 and and CC 42759 2899 43 distinct distinct JJ 42759 2899 44 compensation compensation NN 42759 2899 45 . . . 42759 2900 1 The the DT 42759 2900 2 interest interest NN 42759 2900 3 that that WDT 42759 2900 4 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2900 5 get get VBP 42759 2900 6 comes come VBZ 42759 2900 7 to to IN 42759 2900 8 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2900 9 solely solely RB 42759 2900 10 in in IN 42759 2900 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2900 12 capacity capacity NN 42759 2900 13 as as IN 42759 2900 14 owners owner NNS 42759 2900 15 of of IN 42759 2900 16 capital capital NN 42759 2900 17 , , , 42759 2900 18 independently independently RB 42759 2900 19 of of IN 42759 2900 20 any any DT 42759 2900 21 personal personal JJ 42759 2900 22 activity activity NN 42759 2900 23 . . . 42759 2901 1 From from IN 42759 2901 2 the the DT 42759 2901 3 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 2901 4 of of IN 42759 2901 5 economic economic JJ 42759 2901 6 distribution distribution NN 42759 2901 7 , , , 42759 2901 8 interest interest NN 42759 2901 9 is be VBZ 42759 2901 10 a a DT 42759 2901 11 " " `` 42759 2901 12 workless workless NN 42759 2901 13 " " '' 42759 2901 14 income income NN 42759 2901 15 . . . 42759 2902 1 As as IN 42759 2902 2 such such JJ 42759 2902 3 , , , 42759 2902 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2902 5 seems seem VBZ 42759 2902 6 to to TO 42759 2902 7 challenge challenge VB 42759 2902 8 that that DT 42759 2902 9 ethical ethical JJ 42759 2902 10 intuition intuition NN 42759 2902 11 which which WDT 42759 2902 12 connects connect VBZ 42759 2902 13 reward reward VBP 42759 2902 14 with with IN 42759 2902 15 effort effort NN 42759 2902 16 and and CC 42759 2902 17 which which WDT 42759 2902 18 inclines incline VBZ 42759 2902 19 to to TO 42759 2902 20 regard regard VB 42759 2902 21 income income NN 42759 2902 22 from from IN 42759 2902 23 any any DT 42759 2902 24 other other JJ 42759 2902 25 source source NN 42759 2902 26 as as IN 42759 2902 27 not not RB 42759 2902 28 quite quite RB 42759 2902 29 normal normal JJ 42759 2902 30 . . . 42759 2903 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 2903 2 , , , 42759 2903 3 interest interest NN 42759 2903 4 absorbs absorb VBZ 42759 2903 5 a a DT 42759 2903 6 large large JJ 42759 2903 7 part part NN 42759 2903 8 of of IN 42759 2903 9 the the DT 42759 2903 10 national national JJ 42759 2903 11 income income NN 42759 2903 12 , , , 42759 2903 13 and and CC 42759 2903 14 perpetuates perpetuate NNS 42759 2903 15 grave grave VBP 42759 2903 16 economic economic JJ 42759 2903 17 inequalities inequality NNS 42759 2903 18 . . . 42759 2904 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2904 2 153 153 CD 42759 2904 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2904 4 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2904 5 , , , 42759 2904 6 interest interest NN 42759 2904 7 can can MD 42759 2904 8 not not RB 42759 2904 9 be be VB 42759 2904 10 wholly wholly RB 42759 2904 11 abolished abolish VBN 42759 2904 12 . . . 42759 2905 1 As as RB 42759 2905 2 long long RB 42759 2905 3 as as IN 42759 2905 4 capital capital NN 42759 2905 5 remains remain VBZ 42759 2905 6 in in IN 42759 2905 7 private private JJ 42759 2905 8 hands hand NNS 42759 2905 9 , , , 42759 2905 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2905 11 owners owner NNS 42759 2905 12 will will MD 42759 2905 13 demand demand VB 42759 2905 14 and and CC 42759 2905 15 obtain obtain VB 42759 2905 16 interest interest NN 42759 2905 17 . . . 42759 2906 1 The the DT 42759 2906 2 only only JJ 42759 2906 3 way way NN 42759 2906 4 of of IN 42759 2906 5 escape escape NN 42759 2906 6 is be VBZ 42759 2906 7 by by IN 42759 2906 8 the the DT 42759 2906 9 road road NN 42759 2906 10 of of IN 42759 2906 11 Socialism socialism NN 42759 2906 12 , , , 42759 2906 13 and and CC 42759 2906 14 this this DT 42759 2906 15 would would MD 42759 2906 16 prove prove VB 42759 2906 17 a a DT 42759 2906 18 blind blind JJ 42759 2906 19 alley alley NN 42759 2906 20 . . . 42759 2907 1 As as IN 42759 2907 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2907 3 have have VBP 42759 2907 4 seen see VBN 42759 2907 5 in in IN 42759 2907 6 a a DT 42759 2907 7 preceding precede VBG 42759 2907 8 chapter chapter NN 42759 2907 9 , , , 42759 2907 10 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 2907 11 is be VBZ 42759 2907 12 ethically ethically RB 42759 2907 13 and and CC 42759 2907 14 economically economically RB 42759 2907 15 impossible impossible JJ 42759 2907 16 . . . 42759 2908 1 May May MD 42759 2908 2 not not RB 42759 2908 3 the the DT 42759 2908 4 burdens burden NNS 42759 2908 5 and and CC 42759 2908 6 disadvantages disadvantage NNS 42759 2908 7 of of IN 42759 2908 8 interest interest NN 42759 2908 9 be be VB 42759 2908 10 mitigated mitigate VBN 42759 2908 11 or or CC 42759 2908 12 minimised minimise VBN 42759 2908 13 ? ? . 42759 2909 1 Such such PDT 42759 2909 2 a a DT 42759 2909 3 result result NN 42759 2909 4 could could MD 42759 2909 5 conceivably conceivably RB 42759 2909 6 be be VB 42759 2909 7 reached reach VBN 42759 2909 8 in in IN 42759 2909 9 two two CD 42759 2909 10 ways way NNS 42759 2909 11 : : : 42759 2909 12 the the DT 42759 2909 13 sum sum NN 42759 2909 14 total total NN 42759 2909 15 of of IN 42759 2909 16 interest interest NN 42759 2909 17 might may MD 42759 2909 18 be be VB 42759 2909 19 reduced reduce VBN 42759 2909 20 , , , 42759 2909 21 and and CC 42759 2909 22 the the DT 42759 2909 23 incomes income NNS 42759 2909 24 derived derive VBN 42759 2909 25 from from IN 42759 2909 26 interest interest NN 42759 2909 27 might may MD 42759 2909 28 be be VB 42759 2909 29 more more RBR 42759 2909 30 widely widely RB 42759 2909 31 distributed distribute VBN 42759 2909 32 . . . 42759 2910 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2910 2 Reducing reduce VBG 42759 2910 3 the the DT 42759 2910 4 Rate rate NN 42759 2910 5 of of IN 42759 2910 6 Interest interest NN 42759 2910 7 _ _ NNP 42759 2910 8 No no DT 42759 2910 9 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2910 10 diminution diminution NN 42759 2910 11 of of IN 42759 2910 12 the the DT 42759 2910 13 interest interest NN 42759 2910 14 - - HYPH 42759 2910 15 volume volume NN 42759 2910 16 can can MD 42759 2910 17 be be VB 42759 2910 18 expected expect VBN 42759 2910 19 through through IN 42759 2910 20 a a DT 42759 2910 21 decline decline NN 42759 2910 22 in in IN 42759 2910 23 the the DT 42759 2910 24 interest interest NN 42759 2910 25 rate rate NN 42759 2910 26 . . . 42759 2911 1 As as IN 42759 2911 2 far far RB 42759 2911 3 back back RB 42759 2911 4 as as IN 42759 2911 5 the the DT 42759 2911 6 middle middle NN 42759 2911 7 of of IN 42759 2911 8 the the DT 42759 2911 9 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 42759 2911 10 century century NN 42759 2911 11 , , , 42759 2911 12 England England NNP 42759 2911 13 and and CC 42759 2911 14 Holland Holland NNP 42759 2911 15 were be VBD 42759 2911 16 able able JJ 42759 2911 17 to to TO 42759 2911 18 borrow borrow VB 42759 2911 19 money money NN 42759 2911 20 at at IN 42759 2911 21 three three CD 42759 2911 22 per per NN 42759 2911 23 cent cent NN 42759 2911 24 . . . 42759 2912 1 During during IN 42759 2912 2 the the DT 42759 2912 3 period period NN 42759 2912 4 that that WDT 42759 2912 5 has have VBZ 42759 2912 6 since since IN 42759 2912 7 intervened intervene VBN 42759 2912 8 , , , 42759 2912 9 the the DT 42759 2912 10 rate rate NN 42759 2912 11 has have VBZ 42759 2912 12 varied vary VBN 42759 2912 13 from from IN 42759 2912 14 three three CD 42759 2912 15 to to TO 42759 2912 16 six six CD 42759 2912 17 per per IN 42759 2912 18 cent cent NN 42759 2912 19 . . . 42759 2913 1 on on IN 42759 2913 2 this this DT 42759 2913 3 class class NN 42759 2913 4 of of IN 42759 2913 5 loans loan NNS 42759 2913 6 . . . 42759 2914 1 Between between IN 42759 2914 2 1870 1870 CD 42759 2914 3 and and CC 42759 2914 4 1890 1890 CD 42759 2914 5 , , , 42759 2914 6 the the DT 42759 2914 7 general general JJ 42759 2914 8 rate rate NN 42759 2914 9 of of IN 42759 2914 10 interest interest NN 42759 2914 11 declined decline VBD 42759 2914 12 about about RB 42759 2914 13 two two CD 42759 2914 14 per per NN 42759 2914 15 cent cent NN 42759 2914 16 . . . 42759 2914 17 , , , 42759 2914 18 but but CC 42759 2914 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2914 20 has have VBZ 42759 2914 21 risen rise VBN 42759 2914 22 since since IN 42759 2914 23 the the DT 42759 2914 24 latter latter JJ 42759 2914 25 date date NN 42759 2914 26 about about RB 42759 2914 27 one one CD 42759 2914 28 per per IN 42759 2914 29 cent cent NN 42759 2914 30 . . . 42759 2915 1 The the DT 42759 2915 2 Great Great NNP 42759 2915 3 War War NNP 42759 2915 4 now now RB 42759 2915 5 ( ( -LRB- 42759 2915 6 1916 1916 CD 42759 2915 7 ) ) -RRB- 42759 2915 8 in in IN 42759 2915 9 action action NN 42759 2915 10 is be VBZ 42759 2915 11 destroying destroy VBG 42759 2915 12 an an DT 42759 2915 13 enormous enormous JJ 42759 2915 14 amount amount NN 42759 2915 15 of of IN 42759 2915 16 capital capital NN 42759 2915 17 , , , 42759 2915 18 and and CC 42759 2915 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2915 20 will will MD 42759 2915 21 , , , 42759 2915 22 as as IN 42759 2915 23 in in IN 42759 2915 24 the the DT 42759 2915 25 case case NN 42759 2915 26 of of IN 42759 2915 27 all all DT 42759 2915 28 previous previous JJ 42759 2915 29 military military JJ 42759 2915 30 conflicts conflict NNS 42759 2915 31 of of IN 42759 2915 32 importance importance NN 42759 2915 33 , , , 42759 2915 34 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 2915 35 be be VB 42759 2915 36 followed follow VBN 42759 2915 37 by by IN 42759 2915 38 a a DT 42759 2915 39 marked marked JJ 42759 2915 40 rise rise NN 42759 2915 41 in in IN 42759 2915 42 the the DT 42759 2915 43 rate rate NN 42759 2915 44 of of IN 42759 2915 45 interest interest NN 42759 2915 46 . . . 42759 2916 1 On on IN 42759 2916 2 the the DT 42759 2916 3 other other JJ 42759 2916 4 hand hand NN 42759 2916 5 , , , 42759 2916 6 the the DT 42759 2916 7 only only JJ 42759 2916 8 definite definite JJ 42759 2916 9 grounds ground NNS 42759 2916 10 upon upon IN 42759 2916 11 which which WDT 42759 2916 12 a a DT 42759 2916 13 decline decline NN 42759 2916 14 in in IN 42759 2916 15 the the DT 42759 2916 16 rate rate NN 42759 2916 17 can can MD 42759 2916 18 be be VB 42759 2916 19 hoped hope VBN 42759 2916 20 for for IN 42759 2916 21 are be VBP 42759 2916 22 either either DT 42759 2916 23 uncertain uncertain JJ 42759 2916 24 or or CC 42759 2916 25 unimportant unimportant JJ 42759 2916 26 . . . 42759 2917 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2917 2 are be VBP 42759 2917 3 the the DT 42759 2917 4 rapid rapid JJ 42759 2917 5 increase increase NN 42759 2917 6 of of IN 42759 2917 7 capital capital NN 42759 2917 8 , , , 42759 2917 9 and and CC 42759 2917 10 the the DT 42759 2917 11 extension extension NN 42759 2917 12 of of IN 42759 2917 13 government government NN 42759 2917 14 ownership ownership NN 42759 2917 15 and and CC 42759 2917 16 operation operation NN 42759 2917 17 of of IN 42759 2917 18 natural natural JJ 42759 2917 19 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 2917 20 . . . 42759 2918 1 The the DT 42759 2918 2 first first JJ 42759 2918 3 is be VBZ 42759 2918 4 uncertain uncertain JJ 42759 2918 5 in in IN 42759 2918 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2918 7 effects effect NNS 42759 2918 8 upon upon IN 42759 2918 9 the the DT 42759 2918 10 rate rate NN 42759 2918 11 of of IN 42759 2918 12 interest interest NN 42759 2918 13 because because IN 42759 2918 14 the the DT 42759 2918 15 increased increase VBN 42759 2918 16 supply supply NN 42759 2918 17 of of IN 42759 2918 18 capital capital NN 42759 2918 19 is be VBZ 42759 2918 20 often often RB 42759 2918 21 neutralised neutralise VBN 42759 2918 22 by by IN 42759 2918 23 the the DT 42759 2918 24 process process NN 42759 2918 25 of of IN 42759 2918 26 substitution substitution NN 42759 2918 27 . . . 42759 2919 1 That that RB 42759 2919 2 is is RB 42759 2919 3 , , , 42759 2919 4 a a DT 42759 2919 5 large large JJ 42759 2919 6 part part NN 42759 2919 7 of of IN 42759 2919 8 the the DT 42759 2919 9 new new JJ 42759 2919 10 capital capital NN 42759 2919 11 does do VBZ 42759 2919 12 not not RB 42759 2919 13 compete compete VB 42759 2919 14 with with IN 42759 2919 15 and and CC 42759 2919 16 bring bring VB 42759 2919 17 down down RP 42759 2919 18 the the DT 42759 2919 19 price price NN 42759 2919 20 of of IN 42759 2919 21 the the DT 42759 2919 22 old old JJ 42759 2919 23 capital capital NN 42759 2919 24 . . . 42759 2920 1 Instead instead RB 42759 2920 2 , , , 42759 2920 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2920 4 is be VBZ 42759 2920 5 absorbed absorb VBN 42759 2920 6 in in IN 42759 2920 7 new new JJ 42759 2920 8 inventions invention NNS 42759 2920 9 , , , 42759 2920 10 new new JJ 42759 2920 11 types type NNS 42759 2920 12 of of IN 42759 2920 13 machinery machinery NN 42759 2920 14 , , , 42759 2920 15 and and CC 42759 2920 16 new new JJ 42759 2920 17 processes process NNS 42759 2920 18 of of IN 42759 2920 19 production production NN 42759 2920 20 , , , 42759 2920 21 all all DT 42759 2920 22 of of IN 42759 2920 23 which which WDT 42759 2920 24 take take VBP 42759 2920 25 the the DT 42759 2920 26 place place NN 42759 2920 27 of of IN 42759 2920 28 labour labour NN 42759 2920 29 , , , 42759 2920 30 thus thus RB 42759 2920 31 tending tend VBG 42759 2920 32 to to TO 42759 2920 33 increase increase VB 42759 2920 34 rather rather RB 42759 2920 35 than than IN 42759 2920 36 diminish diminish VB 42759 2920 37 the the DT 42759 2920 38 demand demand NN 42759 2920 39 for for IN 42759 2920 40 capital capital NN 42759 2920 41 and and CC 42759 2920 42 the the DT 42759 2920 43 rate rate NN 42759 2920 44 of of IN 42759 2920 45 interest interest NN 42759 2920 46 . . . 42759 2921 1 To to TO 42759 2921 2 be be VB 42759 2921 3 sure sure JJ 42759 2921 4 , , , 42759 2921 5 the the DT 42759 2921 6 demand demand NN 42759 2921 7 for for IN 42759 2921 8 capital capital NN 42759 2921 9 thus thus RB 42759 2921 10 arising arise VBG 42759 2921 11 has have VBZ 42759 2921 12 not not RB 42759 2921 13 always always RB 42759 2921 14 been be VBN 42759 2921 15 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2921 16 to to TO 42759 2921 17 offset offset VB 42759 2921 18 the the DT 42759 2921 19 enlarged enlarged JJ 42759 2921 20 supply supply NN 42759 2921 21 . . . 42759 2922 1 Since since IN 42759 2922 2 the the DT 42759 2922 3 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 2922 4 Revolution Revolution NNP 42759 2922 5 capital capital NN 42759 2922 6 has have VBZ 42759 2922 7 at at IN 42759 2922 8 certain certain JJ 42759 2922 9 periods period NNS 42759 2922 10 and and CC 42759 2922 11 in in IN 42759 2922 12 certain certain JJ 42759 2922 13 regions region NNS 42759 2922 14 increased increase VBD 42759 2922 15 so so RB 42759 2922 16 rapidly rapidly RB 42759 2922 17 that that IN 42759 2922 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2922 19 could could MD 42759 2922 20 not not RB 42759 2922 21 all all DT 42759 2922 22 find find VB 42759 2922 23 employment employment NN 42759 2922 24 in in IN 42759 2922 25 new new JJ 42759 2922 26 forms form NNS 42759 2922 27 and and CC 42759 2922 28 in in IN 42759 2922 29 old old JJ 42759 2922 30 forms form NNS 42759 2922 31 at at IN 42759 2922 32 the the DT 42759 2922 33 old old JJ 42759 2922 34 rate rate NN 42759 2922 35 . . . 42759 2923 1 In in IN 42759 2923 2 some some DT 42759 2923 3 instances instance NNS 42759 2923 4 a a DT 42759 2923 5 decline decline NN 42759 2923 6 in in IN 42759 2923 7 the the DT 42759 2923 8 rate rate NN 42759 2923 9 of of IN 42759 2923 10 interest interest NN 42759 2923 11 can can MD 42759 2923 12 be be VB 42759 2923 13 clearly clearly RB 42759 2923 14 traced trace VBN 42759 2923 15 to to IN 42759 2923 16 the the DT 42759 2923 17 disproportionately disproportionately RB 42759 2923 18 quick quick JJ 42759 2923 19 growth growth NN 42759 2923 20 of of IN 42759 2923 21 capital capital NN 42759 2923 22 . . . 42759 2924 1 But but CC 42759 2924 2 this this DT 42759 2924 3 phenomenon phenomenon NN 42759 2924 4 has have VBZ 42759 2924 5 been be VBN 42759 2924 6 far far RB 42759 2924 7 from from IN 42759 2924 8 uniform uniform NN 42759 2924 9 , , , 42759 2924 10 and and CC 42759 2924 11 there there EX 42759 2924 12 is be VBZ 42759 2924 13 no no DT 42759 2924 14 indication indication NN 42759 2924 15 that that IN 42759 2924 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2924 17 will will MD 42759 2924 18 become become VB 42759 2924 19 so so RB 42759 2924 20 in in IN 42759 2924 21 the the DT 42759 2924 22 future future NN 42759 2924 23 . . . 42759 2925 1 The the DT 42759 2925 2 possibilities possibility NNS 42759 2925 3 of of IN 42759 2925 4 the the DT 42759 2925 5 process process NN 42759 2925 6 of of IN 42759 2925 7 substitution substitution NN 42759 2925 8 have have VBP 42759 2925 9 been be VBN 42759 2925 10 by by IN 42759 2925 11 no no DT 42759 2925 12 means mean NNS 42759 2925 13 exhausted exhausted JJ 42759 2925 14 . . . 42759 2926 1 The the DT 42759 2926 2 effects effect NNS 42759 2926 3 of of IN 42759 2926 4 government government NN 42759 2926 5 ownership ownership NN 42759 2926 6 are be VBP 42759 2926 7 even even RB 42759 2926 8 more more RBR 42759 2926 9 problematical problematical JJ 42759 2926 10 . . . 42759 2927 1 States state NNS 42759 2927 2 and and CC 42759 2927 3 cities city NNS 42759 2927 4 are be VBP 42759 2927 5 , , , 42759 2927 6 indeed indeed RB 42759 2927 7 , , , 42759 2927 8 able able JJ 42759 2927 9 to to TO 42759 2927 10 obtain obtain VB 42759 2927 11 capital capital NN 42759 2927 12 more more RBR 42759 2927 13 cheaply cheaply RB 42759 2927 14 than than IN 42759 2927 15 private private JJ 42759 2927 16 corporations corporation NNS 42759 2927 17 for for IN 42759 2927 18 such such JJ 42759 2927 19 public public JJ 42759 2927 20 utilities utility NNS 42759 2927 21 as as IN 42759 2927 22 railways railway NNS 42759 2927 23 , , , 42759 2927 24 telegraphs telegraphs NNP 42759 2927 25 , , , 42759 2927 26 tramways tramway NNS 42759 2927 27 , , , 42759 2927 28 and and CC 42759 2927 29 street street NN 42759 2927 30 lighting lighting NN 42759 2927 31 ; ; : 42759 2927 32 and and CC 42759 2927 33 public public JJ 42759 2927 34 ownership ownership NN 42759 2927 35 of of IN 42759 2927 36 all all DT 42759 2927 37 such such JJ 42759 2927 38 concerns concern NNS 42759 2927 39 will will MD 42759 2927 40 probably probably RB 42759 2927 41 become become VB 42759 2927 42 general general JJ 42759 2927 43 in in IN 42759 2927 44 the the DT 42759 2927 45 not not RB 42759 2927 46 remote remote JJ 42759 2927 47 future future NN 42759 2927 48 . . . 42759 2928 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2928 2 the the DT 42759 2928 3 social social JJ 42759 2928 4 gain gain NN 42759 2928 5 is be VBZ 42759 2928 6 not not RB 42759 2928 7 likely likely JJ 42759 2928 8 to to TO 42759 2928 9 be be VB 42759 2928 10 proportionate proportionate JJ 42759 2928 11 to to IN 42759 2928 12 the the DT 42759 2928 13 reduction reduction NN 42759 2928 14 of of IN 42759 2928 15 interest interest NN 42759 2928 16 on on IN 42759 2928 17 this this DT 42759 2928 18 section section NN 42759 2928 19 of of IN 42759 2928 20 capital capital NN 42759 2928 21 . . . 42759 2929 1 A a DT 42759 2929 2 part part NN 42759 2929 3 , , , 42759 2929 4 possibly possibly RB 42759 2929 5 a a DT 42759 2929 6 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2929 7 part part NN 42759 2929 8 , , , 42759 2929 9 of of IN 42759 2929 10 the the DT 42759 2929 11 saving saving NN 42759 2929 12 in in IN 42759 2929 13 interest interest NN 42759 2929 14 will will MD 42759 2929 15 be be VB 42759 2929 16 neutralised neutralise VBN 42759 2929 17 by by IN 42759 2929 18 the the DT 42759 2929 19 lower low JJR 42759 2929 20 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 2929 21 and and CC 42759 2929 22 greater great JJR 42759 2929 23 cost cost NN 42759 2929 24 of of IN 42759 2929 25 operation operation NN 42759 2929 26 ; ; : 42759 2929 27 for for IN 42759 2929 28 in in IN 42759 2929 29 this this DT 42759 2929 30 respect respect NN 42759 2929 31 publicly publicly RB 42759 2929 32 managed manage VBN 42759 2929 33 are be VBP 42759 2929 34 inferior inferior JJ 42759 2929 35 to to TO 42759 2929 36 privately privately RB 42759 2929 37 managed manage VBN 42759 2929 38 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 2929 39 . . . 42759 2930 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 2930 2 , , , 42759 2930 3 the the DT 42759 2930 4 charges charge NNS 42759 2930 5 to to IN 42759 2930 6 the the DT 42759 2930 7 public public NN 42759 2930 8 for for IN 42759 2930 9 the the DT 42759 2930 10 services service NNS 42759 2930 11 rendered render VBN 42759 2930 12 by by IN 42759 2930 13 these these DT 42759 2930 14 utilities utility NNS 42759 2930 15 can can MD 42759 2930 16 not not RB 42759 2930 17 be be VB 42759 2930 18 reduced reduce VBN 42759 2930 19 to to IN 42759 2930 20 the the DT 42759 2930 21 same same JJ 42759 2930 22 degree degree NN 42759 2930 23 as as IN 42759 2930 24 the the DT 42759 2930 25 rate rate NN 42759 2930 26 of of IN 42759 2930 27 interest interest NN 42759 2930 28 on on IN 42759 2930 29 the the DT 42759 2930 30 capital capital NN 42759 2930 31 . . . 42759 2931 1 On on IN 42759 2931 2 the the DT 42759 2931 3 other other JJ 42759 2931 4 hand hand NN 42759 2931 5 , , , 42759 2931 6 the the DT 42759 2931 7 exclusion exclusion NN 42759 2931 8 of of IN 42759 2931 9 private private JJ 42759 2931 10 operating operating NN 42759 2931 11 capital capital NN 42759 2931 12 from from IN 42759 2931 13 this this DT 42759 2931 14 very very RB 42759 2931 15 large large JJ 42759 2931 16 field field NN 42759 2931 17 of of IN 42759 2931 18 public public JJ 42759 2931 19 utilities utility NNS 42759 2931 20 should should MD 42759 2931 21 increase increase VB 42759 2931 22 competition competition NN 42759 2931 23 among among IN 42759 2931 24 the the DT 42759 2931 25 various various JJ 42759 2931 26 units unit NNS 42759 2931 27 of of IN 42759 2931 28 capital capital NN 42759 2931 29 , , , 42759 2931 30 and and CC 42759 2931 31 thus thus RB 42759 2931 32 bring bring VB 42759 2931 33 down down RP 42759 2931 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2931 35 rewards reward NNS 42759 2931 36 . . . 42759 2932 1 To to TO 42759 2932 2 what what WDT 42759 2932 3 extent extent NN 42759 2932 4 this this DT 42759 2932 5 would would MD 42759 2932 6 happen happen VB 42759 2932 7 can can MD 42759 2932 8 not not RB 42759 2932 9 be be VB 42759 2932 10 estimated estimate VBN 42759 2932 11 even even RB 42759 2932 12 approximately approximately RB 42759 2932 13 . . . 42759 2933 1 The the DT 42759 2933 2 only only JJ 42759 2933 3 safe safe JJ 42759 2933 4 statement statement NN 42759 2933 5 is be VBZ 42759 2933 6 that that IN 42759 2933 7 the the DT 42759 2933 8 decline decline NN 42759 2933 9 in in IN 42759 2933 10 the the DT 42759 2933 11 general general JJ 42759 2933 12 rate rate NN 42759 2933 13 of of IN 42759 2933 14 interest interest NN 42759 2933 15 would would MD 42759 2933 16 probably probably RB 42759 2933 17 be be VB 42759 2933 18 slight slight JJ 42759 2933 19 . . . 42759 2934 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2934 2 Need Need NNP 42759 2934 3 for for IN 42759 2934 4 a a DT 42759 2934 5 Wider wide JJR 42759 2934 6 Distribution distribution NN 42759 2934 7 of of IN 42759 2934 8 Capital Capital NNP 42759 2934 9 _ _ NNP 42759 2934 10 The the DT 42759 2934 11 main main JJ 42759 2934 12 hope hope NN 42759 2934 13 of of IN 42759 2934 14 lightening lighten VBG 42759 2934 15 the the DT 42759 2934 16 social social JJ 42759 2934 17 burden burden NN 42759 2934 18 of of IN 42759 2934 19 interest interest NN 42759 2934 20 lies lie VBZ 42759 2934 21 in in IN 42759 2934 22 the the DT 42759 2934 23 possible possible JJ 42759 2934 24 reduction reduction NN 42759 2934 25 in in IN 42759 2934 26 the the DT 42759 2934 27 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2934 28 volume volume NN 42759 2934 29 of of IN 42759 2934 30 capital capital NN 42759 2934 31 , , , 42759 2934 32 and and CC 42759 2934 33 especially especially RB 42759 2934 34 in in IN 42759 2934 35 a a DT 42759 2934 36 wider wide JJR 42759 2934 37 distribution distribution NN 42759 2934 38 of of IN 42759 2934 39 interest interest NN 42759 2934 40 - - HYPH 42759 2934 41 incomes income NNS 42759 2934 42 . . . 42759 2935 1 In in IN 42759 2935 2 many many JJ 42759 2935 3 parts part NNS 42759 2935 4 of of IN 42759 2935 5 the the DT 42759 2935 6 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2935 7 field field NN 42759 2935 8 there there EX 42759 2935 9 is be VBZ 42759 2935 10 a a DT 42759 2935 11 considerable considerable JJ 42759 2935 12 waste waste NN 42759 2935 13 of of IN 42759 2935 14 capital capital NN 42759 2935 15 through through IN 42759 2935 16 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 2935 17 duplication duplication NN 42759 2935 18 . . . 42759 2936 1 This this DT 42759 2936 2 means mean VBZ 42759 2936 3 that that IN 42759 2936 4 a a DT 42759 2936 5 large large JJ 42759 2936 6 amount amount NN 42759 2936 7 of of IN 42759 2936 8 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 2936 9 interest interest NN 42759 2936 10 is be VBZ 42759 2936 11 paid pay VBN 42759 2936 12 by by IN 42759 2936 13 the the DT 42759 2936 14 consumer consumer NN 42759 2936 15 in in IN 42759 2936 16 the the DT 42759 2936 17 form form NN 42759 2936 18 of of IN 42759 2936 19 unnecessarily unnecessarily RB 42759 2936 20 high high JJ 42759 2936 21 prices price NNS 42759 2936 22 . . . 42759 2937 1 Again again RB 42759 2937 2 , , , 42759 2937 3 the the DT 42759 2937 4 owners owner NNS 42759 2937 5 of of IN 42759 2937 6 capital capital NN 42759 2937 7 and and CC 42759 2937 8 receivers receiver NNS 42759 2937 9 of of IN 42759 2937 10 interest interest NN 42759 2937 11 constitute constitute VBP 42759 2937 12 only only RB 42759 2937 13 a a DT 42759 2937 14 minority minority NN 42759 2937 15 of of IN 42759 2937 16 the the DT 42759 2937 17 population population NN 42759 2937 18 of of IN 42759 2937 19 all all DT 42759 2937 20 countries country NNS 42759 2937 21 , , , 42759 2937 22 with with IN 42759 2937 23 the the DT 42759 2937 24 possible possible JJ 42759 2937 25 exception exception NN 42759 2937 26 of of IN 42759 2937 27 the the DT 42759 2937 28 United United NNP 42759 2937 29 States States NNP 42759 2937 30 . . . 42759 2938 1 The the DT 42759 2938 2 great great JJ 42759 2938 3 majority majority NN 42759 2938 4 of of IN 42759 2938 5 the the DT 42759 2938 6 wage wage NN 42759 2938 7 earners earner NNS 42759 2938 8 in in IN 42759 2938 9 all all DT 42759 2938 10 lands land NNS 42759 2938 11 possess possess VBP 42759 2938 12 no no DT 42759 2938 13 capital capital NN 42759 2938 14 , , , 42759 2938 15 and and CC 42759 2938 16 obtain obtain VB 42759 2938 17 no no DT 42759 2938 18 interest interest NN 42759 2938 19 . . . 42759 2939 1 Not not RB 42759 2939 2 only only RB 42759 2939 3 are be VBP 42759 2939 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2939 5 incomes income NNS 42759 2939 6 small small JJ 42759 2939 7 , , , 42759 2939 8 often often RB 42759 2939 9 pitiably pitiably RB 42759 2939 10 small small JJ 42759 2939 11 , , , 42759 2939 12 but but CC 42759 2939 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2939 14 lack lack NN 42759 2939 15 of of IN 42759 2939 16 capital capital NN 42759 2939 17 deprives deprive VBZ 42759 2939 18 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2939 19 of of IN 42759 2939 20 the the DT 42759 2939 21 security security NN 42759 2939 22 , , , 42759 2939 23 confidence confidence NN 42759 2939 24 , , , 42759 2939 25 and and CC 42759 2939 26 independence independence NN 42759 2939 27 which which WDT 42759 2939 28 are be VBP 42759 2939 29 required require VBN 42759 2939 30 for for IN 42759 2939 31 comfortable comfortable JJ 42759 2939 32 existence existence NN 42759 2939 33 and and CC 42759 2939 34 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2939 35 citizenship citizenship NN 42759 2939 36 . . . 42759 2940 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2940 2 have have VBP 42759 2940 3 no no DT 42759 2940 4 income income NN 42759 2940 5 from from IN 42759 2940 6 productive productive JJ 42759 2940 7 property property NN 42759 2940 8 to to TO 42759 2940 9 protect protect VB 42759 2940 10 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2940 11 against against IN 42759 2940 12 the the DT 42759 2940 13 cessation cessation NN 42759 2940 14 of of IN 42759 2940 15 wages wage NNS 42759 2940 16 . . . 42759 2941 1 During during IN 42759 2941 2 periods period NNS 42759 2941 3 of of IN 42759 2941 4 unemployment unemployment NN 42759 2941 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2941 6 are be VBP 42759 2941 7 frequently frequently RB 42759 2941 8 compelled compel VBN 42759 2941 9 to to TO 42759 2941 10 have have VB 42759 2941 11 recourse recourse VBN 42759 2941 12 to to IN 42759 2941 13 charity charity NN 42759 2941 14 , , , 42759 2941 15 and and CC 42759 2941 16 to to TO 42759 2941 17 forego forego VB 42759 2941 18 many many JJ 42759 2941 19 of of IN 42759 2941 20 the the DT 42759 2941 21 necessary necessary JJ 42759 2941 22 comforts comfort NNS 42759 2941 23 of of IN 42759 2941 24 life life NN 42759 2941 25 . . . 42759 2942 1 So so RB 42759 2942 2 long long RB 42759 2942 3 as as IN 42759 2942 4 the the DT 42759 2942 5 bulk bulk NN 42759 2942 6 of of IN 42759 2942 7 the the DT 42759 2942 8 means mean NNS 42759 2942 9 of of IN 42759 2942 10 production production NN 42759 2942 11 remains remain VBZ 42759 2942 12 in in IN 42759 2942 13 the the DT 42759 2942 14 hands hand NNS 42759 2942 15 of of IN 42759 2942 16 a a DT 42759 2942 17 distinct distinct JJ 42759 2942 18 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 2942 19 class class NN 42759 2942 20 , , , 42759 2942 21 this this DT 42759 2942 22 demoralising demoralise VBG 42759 2942 23 insecurity insecurity NN 42759 2942 24 of of IN 42759 2942 25 the the DT 42759 2942 26 workers worker NNS 42759 2942 27 must must MD 42759 2942 28 continue continue VB 42759 2942 29 as as IN 42759 2942 30 an an DT 42759 2942 31 essential essential JJ 42759 2942 32 part part NN 42759 2942 33 of of IN 42759 2942 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2942 35 industrial industrial JJ 42759 2942 36 system system NN 42759 2942 37 . . . 42759 2943 1 While while IN 42759 2943 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2943 3 might may MD 42759 2943 4 conceivably conceivably RB 42759 2943 5 be be VB 42759 2943 6 eliminated eliminate VBN 42759 2943 7 through through IN 42759 2943 8 a a DT 42759 2943 9 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 2943 10 scheme scheme NN 42759 2943 11 of of IN 42759 2943 12 State State NNP 42759 2943 13 insurance insurance NN 42759 2943 14 , , , 42759 2943 15 this this DT 42759 2943 16 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 2943 17 would would MD 42759 2943 18 substitute substitute VB 42759 2943 19 dependence dependence NN 42759 2943 20 upon upon IN 42759 2943 21 the the DT 42759 2943 22 State State NNP 42759 2943 23 for for IN 42759 2943 24 dependence dependence NN 42759 2943 25 upon upon IN 42759 2943 26 the the DT 42759 2943 27 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 2943 28 , , , 42759 2943 29 and and CC 42759 2943 30 be be VB 42759 2943 31 much much RB 42759 2943 32 less less RBR 42759 2943 33 desirable desirable JJ 42759 2943 34 than than IN 42759 2943 35 ownership ownership NN 42759 2943 36 of of IN 42759 2943 37 income income NN 42759 2943 38 - - HYPH 42759 2943 39 bearing bear VBG 42759 2943 40 property property NN 42759 2943 41 . . . 42759 2944 1 The the DT 42759 2944 2 workers worker NNS 42759 2944 3 who who WP 42759 2944 4 possess possess VBP 42759 2944 5 no no DT 42759 2944 6 capital capital NN 42759 2944 7 do do VBP 42759 2944 8 not not RB 42759 2944 9 enjoy enjoy VB 42759 2944 10 a a DT 42759 2944 11 normal normal JJ 42759 2944 12 and and CC 42759 2944 13 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 2944 14 degree degree NN 42759 2944 15 of of IN 42759 2944 16 independence independence NN 42759 2944 17 , , , 42759 2944 18 self self NN 42759 2944 19 respect respect NN 42759 2944 20 , , , 42759 2944 21 or or CC 42759 2944 22 self self NN 42759 2944 23 confidence confidence NN 42759 2944 24 . . . 42759 2945 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2945 2 have have VBP 42759 2945 3 not not RB 42759 2945 4 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2945 5 control control NN 42759 2945 6 over over IN 42759 2945 7 the the DT 42759 2945 8 wage wage NN 42759 2945 9 contract contract NN 42759 2945 10 and and CC 42759 2945 11 the the DT 42759 2945 12 other other JJ 42759 2945 13 conditions condition NNS 42759 2945 14 of of IN 42759 2945 15 employment employment NN 42759 2945 16 , , , 42759 2945 17 and and CC 42759 2945 18 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2945 19 have have VBP 42759 2945 20 nothing nothing NN 42759 2945 21 at at RB 42759 2945 22 all all RB 42759 2945 23 to to TO 42759 2945 24 say say VB 42759 2945 25 concerning concern VBG 42759 2945 26 the the DT 42759 2945 27 goods good NNS 42759 2945 28 that that WDT 42759 2945 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2945 30 shall shall MD 42759 2945 31 produce produce VB 42759 2945 32 , , , 42759 2945 33 or or CC 42759 2945 34 the the DT 42759 2945 35 persons person NNS 42759 2945 36 to to TO 42759 2945 37 whom whom WP 42759 2945 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2945 39 product product NN 42759 2945 40 shall shall MD 42759 2945 41 be be VB 42759 2945 42 sold sell VBN 42759 2945 43 . . . 42759 2946 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2946 2 lack lack VBP 42759 2946 3 the the DT 42759 2946 4 incentive incentive NN 42759 2946 5 to to TO 42759 2946 6 put put VB 42759 2946 7 forth forth RP 42759 2946 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2946 9 best good JJS 42759 2946 10 efforts effort NNS 42759 2946 11 in in IN 42759 2946 12 production production NN 42759 2946 13 . . . 42759 2947 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2947 2 can can MD 42759 2947 3 not not RB 42759 2947 4 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 2947 5 adequately adequately RB 42759 2947 6 the the DT 42759 2947 7 instinct instinct NN 42759 2947 8 of of IN 42759 2947 9 property property NN 42759 2947 10 , , , 42759 2947 11 the the DT 42759 2947 12 desire desire NN 42759 2947 13 to to TO 42759 2947 14 control control VB 42759 2947 15 some some DT 42759 2947 16 of of IN 42759 2947 17 the the DT 42759 2947 18 determining determine VBG 42759 2947 19 forms form NNS 42759 2947 20 of of IN 42759 2947 21 material material JJ 42759 2947 22 possession possession NN 42759 2947 23 . . . 42759 2948 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2948 2 are be VBP 42759 2948 3 deprived deprive VBN 42759 2948 4 of of IN 42759 2948 5 that that DT 42759 2948 6 consciousness consciousness NN 42759 2948 7 of of IN 42759 2948 8 power power NN 42759 2948 9 which which WDT 42759 2948 10 is be VBZ 42759 2948 11 generated generate VBN 42759 2948 12 exclusively exclusively RB 42759 2948 13 by by IN 42759 2948 14 property property NN 42759 2948 15 , , , 42759 2948 16 and and CC 42759 2948 17 which which WDT 42759 2948 18 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 2948 19 so so RB 42759 2948 20 powerfully powerfully RB 42759 2948 21 toward toward IN 42759 2948 22 the the DT 42759 2948 23 making making NN 42759 2948 24 of of IN 42759 2948 25 a a DT 42759 2948 26 contended contended JJ 42759 2948 27 and and CC 42759 2948 28 efficient efficient JJ 42759 2948 29 life life NN 42759 2948 30 . . . 42759 2949 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 2949 2 do do VBP 42759 2949 3 not not RB 42759 2949 4 possess possess VB 42759 2949 5 a a DT 42759 2949 6 normal normal JJ 42759 2949 7 amount amount NN 42759 2949 8 of of IN 42759 2949 9 freedom freedom NN 42759 2949 10 in in IN 42759 2949 11 politics politic NNS 42759 2949 12 , , , 42759 2949 13 nor nor CC 42759 2949 14 in in IN 42759 2949 15 those those DT 42759 2949 16 civic civic JJ 42759 2949 17 and and CC 42759 2949 18 social social JJ 42759 2949 19 relations relation NNS 42759 2949 20 which which WDT 42759 2949 21 lie lie VBP 42759 2949 22 outside outside IN 42759 2949 23 the the DT 42759 2949 24 spheres sphere NNS 42759 2949 25 of of IN 42759 2949 26 industry industry NN 42759 2949 27 and and CC 42759 2949 28 politics politic NNS 42759 2949 29 . . . 42759 2950 1 In in IN 42759 2950 2 a a DT 42759 2950 3 word word NN 42759 2950 4 , , , 42759 2950 5 the the DT 42759 2950 6 worker worker NN 42759 2950 7 without without IN 42759 2950 8 capital capital NN 42759 2950 9 has have VBZ 42759 2950 10 not not RB 42759 2950 11 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 2950 12 power power NN 42759 2950 13 over over IN 42759 2950 14 the the DT 42759 2950 15 ordering ordering NN 42759 2950 16 of of IN 42759 2950 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2950 18 own own JJ 42759 2950 19 life life NN 42759 2950 20 . . . 42759 2951 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2951 2 The the DT 42759 2951 3 Essence Essence NNP 42759 2951 4 of of IN 42759 2951 5 Co co NN 42759 2951 6 - - NN 42759 2951 7 operative operative JJ 42759 2951 8 Enterprise enterprise NN 42759 2951 9 _ _ NNP 42759 2951 10 The the DT 42759 2951 11 most most RBS 42759 2951 12 effective effective JJ 42759 2951 13 means mean NNS 42759 2951 14 of of IN 42759 2951 15 lessening lessen VBG 42759 2951 16 the the DT 42759 2951 17 volume volume NN 42759 2951 18 of of IN 42759 2951 19 interest interest NN 42759 2951 20 , , , 42759 2951 21 and and CC 42759 2951 22 bringing bring VBG 42759 2951 23 about about RP 42759 2951 24 a a DT 42759 2951 25 wider wide JJR 42759 2951 26 distribution distribution NN 42759 2951 27 of of IN 42759 2951 28 capital capital NN 42759 2951 29 , , , 42759 2951 30 is be VBZ 42759 2951 31 to to TO 42759 2951 32 be be VB 42759 2951 33 found find VBN 42759 2951 34 in in IN 42759 2951 35 co co JJ 42759 2951 36 - - JJ 42759 2951 37 operative operative JJ 42759 2951 38 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 2951 39 . . . 42759 2952 1 Co co NN 42759 2952 2 - - NN 42759 2952 3 operation operation NN 42759 2952 4 in in IN 42759 2952 5 general general JJ 42759 2952 6 denotes denote VBZ 42759 2952 7 the the DT 42759 2952 8 unified unified JJ 42759 2952 9 action action NN 42759 2952 10 of of IN 42759 2952 11 a a DT 42759 2952 12 group group NN 42759 2952 13 of of IN 42759 2952 14 persons person NNS 42759 2952 15 for for IN 42759 2952 16 a a DT 42759 2952 17 common common JJ 42759 2952 18 end end NN 42759 2952 19 . . . 42759 2953 1 A a DT 42759 2953 2 church church NN 42759 2953 3 , , , 42759 2953 4 a a DT 42759 2953 5 debating debate VBG 42759 2953 6 club club NN 42759 2953 7 , , , 42759 2953 8 a a DT 42759 2953 9 joint joint JJ 42759 2953 10 stock stock NN 42759 2953 11 company company NN 42759 2953 12 , , , 42759 2953 13 exemplifies exemplify VBZ 42759 2953 14 co co NN 42759 2953 15 - - NN 42759 2953 16 operation operation NN 42759 2953 17 in in IN 42759 2953 18 this this DT 42759 2953 19 sense sense NN 42759 2953 20 . . . 42759 2954 1 In in IN 42759 2954 2 the the DT 42759 2954 3 strict strict JJ 42759 2954 4 and and CC 42759 2954 5 technical technical JJ 42759 2954 6 sense sense NN 42759 2954 7 , , , 42759 2954 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2954 9 has have VBZ 42759 2954 10 received receive VBN 42759 2954 11 various various JJ 42759 2954 12 definitions definition NNS 42759 2954 13 . . . 42759 2955 1 Professor Professor NNP 42759 2955 2 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 2955 3 declares declare VBZ 42759 2955 4 that that IN 42759 2955 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2955 6 " " `` 42759 2955 7 consists consist VBZ 42759 2955 8 essentially essentially RB 42759 2955 9 in in IN 42759 2955 10 getting get VBG 42759 2955 11 rid rid VBN 42759 2955 12 of of IN 42759 2955 13 the the DT 42759 2955 14 managing managing NN 42759 2955 15 employer employer NN 42759 2955 16 " " '' 42759 2955 17 ; ; : 42759 2955 18 but but CC 42759 2955 19 this this DT 42759 2955 20 description description NN 42759 2955 21 is be VBZ 42759 2955 22 applicable applicable JJ 42759 2955 23 only only RB 42759 2955 24 to to TO 42759 2955 25 co co NNS 42759 2955 26 - - NNS 42759 2955 27 operatives operative NNS 42759 2955 28 of of IN 42759 2955 29 production production NN 42759 2955 30 . . . 42759 2956 1 " " `` 42759 2956 2 A a DT 42759 2956 3 combination combination NN 42759 2956 4 of of IN 42759 2956 5 individuals individual NNS 42759 2956 6 to to TO 42759 2956 7 economise economise VB 42759 2956 8 by by IN 42759 2956 9 buying buy VBG 42759 2956 10 in in IN 42759 2956 11 common common JJ 42759 2956 12 , , , 42759 2956 13 or or CC 42759 2956 14 increase increase VB 42759 2956 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2956 16 profits profit NNS 42759 2956 17 by by IN 42759 2956 18 selling sell VBG 42759 2956 19 in in IN 42759 2956 20 common common JJ 42759 2956 21 " " '' 42759 2956 22 ( ( -LRB- 42759 2956 23 Encyclopedia Encyclopedia NNP 42759 2956 24 Britannica Britannica NNP 42759 2956 25 ) ) -RRB- 42759 2956 26 is be VBZ 42759 2956 27 likewise likewise RB 42759 2956 28 too too RB 42759 2956 29 narrow narrow JJ 42759 2956 30 , , , 42759 2956 31 since since IN 42759 2956 32 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2956 33 fits fit VBZ 42759 2956 34 only only RB 42759 2956 35 distributive distributive JJ 42759 2956 36 and and CC 42759 2956 37 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 2956 38 co co NN 42759 2956 39 - - NN 42759 2956 40 operation operation NN 42759 2956 41 . . . 42759 2957 1 According accord VBG 42759 2957 2 to to IN 42759 2957 3 C. C. NNP 42759 2957 4 R. R. NNP 42759 2957 5 Fay Fay NNP 42759 2957 6 , , , 42759 2957 7 a a DT 42759 2957 8 co co JJ 42759 2957 9 - - JJ 42759 2957 10 operative operative JJ 42759 2957 11 society society NN 42759 2957 12 is be VBZ 42759 2957 13 " " `` 42759 2957 14 an an DT 42759 2957 15 association association NN 42759 2957 16 for for IN 42759 2957 17 the the DT 42759 2957 18 purpose purpose NN 42759 2957 19 of of IN 42759 2957 20 joint joint JJ 42759 2957 21 trading trading NN 42759 2957 22 , , , 42759 2957 23 originating originate VBG 42759 2957 24 among among IN 42759 2957 25 the the DT 42759 2957 26 weak weak JJ 42759 2957 27 , , , 42759 2957 28 and and CC 42759 2957 29 conducted conduct VBN 42759 2957 30 always always RB 42759 2957 31 in in IN 42759 2957 32 an an DT 42759 2957 33 unselfish unselfish JJ 42759 2957 34 spirit spirit NN 42759 2957 35 . . . 42759 2957 36 " " '' 42759 2958 1 If if IN 42759 2958 2 the the DT 42759 2958 3 word word NN 42759 2958 4 , , , 42759 2958 5 " " `` 42759 2958 6 trading trading NN 42759 2958 7 " " '' 42759 2958 8 be be VB 42759 2958 9 stretched stretch VBN 42759 2958 10 to to TO 42759 2958 11 comprehend comprehend VB 42759 2958 12 manufacturing manufacturing NN 42759 2958 13 as as RB 42759 2958 14 well well RB 42759 2958 15 as as IN 42759 2958 16 commercial commercial JJ 42759 2958 17 activities activity NNS 42759 2958 18 , , , 42759 2958 19 Fay Fay NNP 42759 2958 20 's 's POS 42759 2958 21 definition definition NN 42759 2958 22 is be VBZ 42759 2958 23 fairly fairly RB 42759 2958 24 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 2958 25 . . . 42759 2959 1 The the DT 42759 2959 2 distinguishing distinguish VBG 42759 2959 3 circumstance circumstance NN 42759 2959 4 , , , 42759 2959 5 " " '' 42759 2959 6 originating originate VBG 42759 2959 7 among among IN 42759 2959 8 the the DT 42759 2959 9 weak weak JJ 42759 2959 10 , , , 42759 2959 11 " " '' 42759 2959 12 is be VBZ 42759 2959 13 also also RB 42759 2959 14 emphasised emphasise VBN 42759 2959 15 by by IN 42759 2959 16 Father Father NNP 42759 2959 17 Pesch Pesch NNP 42759 2959 18 in in IN 42759 2959 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2959 20 statement statement NN 42759 2959 21 that that IN 42759 2959 22 the the DT 42759 2959 23 essence essence NN 42759 2959 24 , , , 42759 2959 25 aim aim VBP 42759 2959 26 , , , 42759 2959 27 and and CC 42759 2959 28 meaning meaning NN 42759 2959 29 of of IN 42759 2959 30 co co NN 42759 2959 31 - - NN 42759 2959 32 operation operation NN 42759 2959 33 are be VBP 42759 2959 34 to to TO 42759 2959 35 be be VB 42759 2959 36 found find VBN 42759 2959 37 in in IN 42759 2959 38 " " `` 42759 2959 39 a a DT 42759 2959 40 combination combination NN 42759 2959 41 of of IN 42759 2959 42 the the DT 42759 2959 43 economically economically RB 42759 2959 44 weak weak JJ 42759 2959 45 in in IN 42759 2959 46 common common JJ 42759 2959 47 efforts effort NNS 42759 2959 48 for for IN 42759 2959 49 the the DT 42759 2959 50 security security NN 42759 2959 51 and and CC 42759 2959 52 betterment betterment NN 42759 2959 53 of of IN 42759 2959 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2959 55 condition condition NN 42759 2959 56 . . . 42759 2960 1 " " `` 42759 2960 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 2960 3 154 154 CD 42759 2960 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 2960 5 In in IN 42759 2960 6 order order NN 42759 2960 7 to to TO 42759 2960 8 give give VB 42759 2960 9 the the DT 42759 2960 10 proper proper JJ 42759 2960 11 connotation connotation NN 42759 2960 12 for for IN 42759 2960 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2960 14 purpose purpose NN 42759 2960 15 , , , 42759 2960 16 we -PRON- PRP 42759 2960 17 shall shall MD 42759 2960 18 define define VB 42759 2960 19 co co NN 42759 2960 20 - - NN 42759 2960 21 operation operation NN 42759 2960 22 as as IN 42759 2960 23 , , , 42759 2960 24 that that IN 42759 2960 25 joint joint JJ 42759 2960 26 economic economic JJ 42759 2960 27 action action NN 42759 2960 28 which which WDT 42759 2960 29 seeks seek VBZ 42759 2960 30 to to TO 42759 2960 31 obtain obtain VB 42759 2960 32 for for IN 42759 2960 33 a a DT 42759 2960 34 relatively relatively RB 42759 2960 35 weak weak JJ 42759 2960 36 group group NN 42759 2960 37 all all DT 42759 2960 38 or or CC 42759 2960 39 part part NN 42759 2960 40 of of IN 42759 2960 41 the the DT 42759 2960 42 profits profit NNS 42759 2960 43 and and CC 42759 2960 44 interest interest NN 42759 2960 45 which which WDT 42759 2960 46 in in IN 42759 2960 47 the the DT 42759 2960 48 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 2960 49 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 2960 50 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 2960 51 are be VBP 42759 2960 52 taken take VBN 42759 2960 53 by by IN 42759 2960 54 a a DT 42759 2960 55 smaller small JJR 42759 2960 56 and and CC 42759 2960 57 different different JJ 42759 2960 58 group group NN 42759 2960 59 . . . 42759 2961 1 This this DT 42759 2961 2 formula formula NN 42759 2961 3 puts put VBZ 42759 2961 4 in in IN 42759 2961 5 the the DT 42759 2961 6 foreground foreground NN 42759 2961 7 the the DT 42759 2961 8 important important JJ 42759 2961 9 fact fact NN 42759 2961 10 that that IN 42759 2961 11 in in IN 42759 2961 12 every every DT 42759 2961 13 form form NN 42759 2961 14 of of IN 42759 2961 15 co co JJ 42759 2961 16 - - JJ 42759 2961 17 operative operative JJ 42759 2961 18 effort effort NN 42759 2961 19 , , , 42759 2961 20 some some DT 42759 2961 21 interest interest NN 42759 2961 22 or or CC 42759 2961 23 profits profit NNS 42759 2961 24 , , , 42759 2961 25 or or CC 42759 2961 26 both both DT 42759 2961 27 , , , 42759 2961 28 are be VBP 42759 2961 29 diverted divert VBN 42759 2961 30 from from IN 42759 2961 31 those those DT 42759 2961 32 who who WP 42759 2961 33 would would MD 42759 2961 34 have have VB 42759 2961 35 received receive VBN 42759 2961 36 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2961 37 under under IN 42759 2961 38 purely purely RB 42759 2961 39 capitalistic capitalistic JJ 42759 2961 40 arrangements arrangement NNS 42759 2961 41 , , , 42759 2961 42 and and CC 42759 2961 43 distributed distribute VBN 42759 2961 44 among among IN 42759 2961 45 a a DT 42759 2961 46 larger large JJR 42759 2961 47 number number NN 42759 2961 48 of of IN 42759 2961 49 persons person NNS 42759 2961 50 . . . 42759 2962 1 Thus thus RB 42759 2962 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2962 3 indicates indicate VBZ 42759 2962 4 the the DT 42759 2962 5 bearing bearing NN 42759 2962 6 of of IN 42759 2962 7 co co NN 42759 2962 8 - - NN 42759 2962 9 operation operation NN 42759 2962 10 upon upon IN 42759 2962 11 the the DT 42759 2962 12 problem problem NN 42759 2962 13 of of IN 42759 2962 14 lightening lighten VBG 42759 2962 15 the the DT 42759 2962 16 social social JJ 42759 2962 17 burden burden NN 42759 2962 18 of of IN 42759 2962 19 interest interest NN 42759 2962 20 . . . 42759 2963 1 From from IN 42759 2963 2 the the DT 42759 2963 3 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 2963 4 of of IN 42759 2963 5 economic economic JJ 42759 2963 6 function function NN 42759 2963 7 , , , 42759 2963 8 co co NN 42759 2963 9 - - NN 42759 2963 10 operation operation NN 42759 2963 11 may may MD 42759 2963 12 be be VB 42759 2963 13 divided divide VBN 42759 2963 14 into into IN 42759 2963 15 two two CD 42759 2963 16 general general JJ 42759 2963 17 kinds kind NNS 42759 2963 18 , , , 42759 2963 19 producers producer NNS 42759 2963 20 ' ' POS 42759 2963 21 and and CC 42759 2963 22 consumers consumer NNS 42759 2963 23 ' ' '' 42759 2963 24 . . . 42759 2964 1 The the DT 42759 2964 2 best good JJS 42759 2964 3 example example NN 42759 2964 4 of of IN 42759 2964 5 the the DT 42759 2964 6 former former JJ 42759 2964 7 is be VBZ 42759 2964 8 a a DT 42759 2964 9 wage wage NN 42759 2964 10 earners earner NNS 42759 2964 11 ' ' POS 42759 2964 12 productive productive JJ 42759 2964 13 society society NN 42759 2964 14 ; ; : 42759 2964 15 of of IN 42759 2964 16 the the DT 42759 2964 17 latter latter JJ 42759 2964 18 , , , 42759 2964 19 a a DT 42759 2964 20 co co JJ 42759 2964 21 - - JJ 42759 2964 22 operative operative JJ 42759 2964 23 store store NN 42759 2964 24 . . . 42759 2965 1 Credit credit NN 42759 2965 2 co co NNS 42759 2965 3 - - NNS 42759 2965 4 operatives operative NNS 42759 2965 5 and and CC 42759 2965 6 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 2965 7 co co NNS 42759 2965 8 - - NNS 42759 2965 9 operatives operative NNS 42759 2965 10 fall fall VBP 42759 2965 11 mainly mainly RB 42759 2965 12 under under IN 42759 2965 13 the the DT 42759 2965 14 former former JJ 42759 2965 15 head head NN 42759 2965 16 , , , 42759 2965 17 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 2965 18 as as IN 42759 2965 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2965 20 principal principal JJ 42759 2965 21 object object NN 42759 2965 22 is be VBZ 42759 2965 23 to to TO 42759 2965 24 assist assist VB 42759 2965 25 production production NN 42759 2965 26 , , , 42759 2965 27 and and CC 42759 2965 28 to to TO 42759 2965 29 benefit benefit VB 42759 2965 30 men man NNS 42759 2965 31 as as IN 42759 2965 32 producers producer NNS 42759 2965 33 rather rather RB 42759 2965 34 than than IN 42759 2965 35 as as IN 42759 2965 36 consumers consumer NNS 42759 2965 37 . . . 42759 2966 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2966 2 from from IN 42759 2966 3 the the DT 42759 2966 4 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 2966 5 of of IN 42759 2966 6 type type NN 42759 2966 7 , , , 42759 2966 8 co co NN 42759 2966 9 - - NN 42759 2966 10 operation operation NN 42759 2966 11 may may MD 42759 2966 12 be be VB 42759 2966 13 classified classify VBN 42759 2966 14 as as IN 42759 2966 15 credit credit NN 42759 2966 16 , , , 42759 2966 17 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 2966 18 , , , 42759 2966 19 distributive distributive JJ 42759 2966 20 , , , 42759 2966 21 and and CC 42759 2966 22 productive productive JJ 42759 2966 23 . . . 42759 2967 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2967 2 Co Co NNP 42759 2967 3 - - NN 42759 2967 4 operative operative JJ 42759 2967 5 Credit Credit NNP 42759 2967 6 Societies Societies NNPS 42759 2967 7 _ _ NNP 42759 2967 8 A A NNP 42759 2967 9 co co JJ 42759 2967 10 - - JJ 42759 2967 11 operative operative JJ 42759 2967 12 credit credit NN 42759 2967 13 society society NN 42759 2967 14 is be VBZ 42759 2967 15 a a DT 42759 2967 16 bank bank NN 42759 2967 17 controlled control VBN 42759 2967 18 by by IN 42759 2967 19 the the DT 42759 2967 20 persons person NNS 42759 2967 21 who who WP 42759 2967 22 patronise patronise VBP 42759 2967 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2967 24 , , , 42759 2967 25 and and CC 42759 2967 26 lending lend VBG 42759 2967 27 on on IN 42759 2967 28 personal personal JJ 42759 2967 29 rather rather RB 42759 2967 30 than than IN 42759 2967 31 material material JJ 42759 2967 32 security security NN 42759 2967 33 . . . 42759 2968 1 Such such JJ 42759 2968 2 banks bank NNS 42759 2968 3 are be VBP 42759 2968 4 intended intend VBN 42759 2968 5 almost almost RB 42759 2968 6 exclusively exclusively RB 42759 2968 7 for for IN 42759 2968 8 the the DT 42759 2968 9 relatively relatively RB 42759 2968 10 helpless helpless JJ 42759 2968 11 borrower borrower NN 42759 2968 12 , , , 42759 2968 13 as as IN 42759 2968 14 , , , 42759 2968 15 the the DT 42759 2968 16 small small JJ 42759 2968 17 farmer farmer NN 42759 2968 18 , , , 42759 2968 19 artisan artisan NNP 42759 2968 20 , , , 42759 2968 21 shopkeeper shopkeeper NNP 42759 2968 22 , , , 42759 2968 23 and and CC 42759 2968 24 the the DT 42759 2968 25 small small JJ 42759 2968 26 man man NN 42759 2968 27 generally generally RB 42759 2968 28 . . . 42759 2969 1 Fundamentally fundamentally RB 42759 2969 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2969 3 are be VBP 42759 2969 4 associations association NNS 42759 2969 5 of of IN 42759 2969 6 neighbours neighbour NNS 42759 2969 7 who who WP 42759 2969 8 combine combine VBP 42759 2969 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2969 10 resources resource NNS 42759 2969 11 and and CC 42759 2969 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2969 13 credit credit NN 42759 2969 14 in in IN 42759 2969 15 order order NN 42759 2969 16 to to TO 42759 2969 17 obtain obtain VB 42759 2969 18 loans loan NNS 42759 2969 19 on on IN 42759 2969 20 better well JJR 42759 2969 21 terms term NNS 42759 2969 22 than than IN 42759 2969 23 are be VBP 42759 2969 24 accorded accord VBN 42759 2969 25 by by IN 42759 2969 26 the the DT 42759 2969 27 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 2969 28 commercial commercial JJ 42759 2969 29 banks bank NNS 42759 2969 30 . . . 42759 2970 1 The the DT 42759 2970 2 capital capital NN 42759 2970 3 is be VBZ 42759 2970 4 derived derive VBN 42759 2970 5 partly partly RB 42759 2970 6 from from IN 42759 2970 7 the the DT 42759 2970 8 sale sale NN 42759 2970 9 of of IN 42759 2970 10 shares share NNS 42759 2970 11 of of IN 42759 2970 12 stock stock NN 42759 2970 13 , , , 42759 2970 14 partly partly RB 42759 2970 15 from from IN 42759 2970 16 deposits deposit NNS 42759 2970 17 , , , 42759 2970 18 and and CC 42759 2970 19 partly partly RB 42759 2970 20 from from IN 42759 2970 21 borrowed borrow VBN 42759 2970 22 money money NN 42759 2970 23 . . . 42759 2971 1 In in IN 42759 2971 2 Germany Germany NNP 42759 2971 3 , , , 42759 2971 4 where where WRB 42759 2971 5 credit credit NN 42759 2971 6 associations association NNS 42759 2971 7 have have VBP 42759 2971 8 been be VBN 42759 2971 9 more more RBR 42759 2971 10 widely widely RB 42759 2971 11 extended extended JJ 42759 2971 12 and and CC 42759 2971 13 more more RBR 42759 2971 14 highly highly RB 42759 2971 15 developed developed JJ 42759 2971 16 than than IN 42759 2971 17 in in IN 42759 2971 18 any any DT 42759 2971 19 other other JJ 42759 2971 20 country country NN 42759 2971 21 , , , 42759 2971 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2971 23 are be VBP 42759 2971 24 of of IN 42759 2971 25 two two CD 42759 2971 26 kinds kind NNS 42759 2971 27 , , , 42759 2971 28 named name VBN 42759 2971 29 after after IN 42759 2971 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2971 31 respective respective JJ 42759 2971 32 founders founder NNS 42759 2971 33 , , , 42759 2971 34 Schulze Schulze NNP 42759 2971 35 - - HYPH 42759 2971 36 Delitzsch Delitzsch NNP 42759 2971 37 and and CC 42759 2971 38 Raiffeisen Raiffeisen NNP 42759 2971 39 . . . 42759 2972 1 The the DT 42759 2972 2 former former JJ 42759 2972 3 operates operate VBZ 42759 2972 4 chiefly chiefly RB 42759 2972 5 in in IN 42759 2972 6 the the DT 42759 2972 7 cities city NNS 42759 2972 8 , , , 42759 2972 9 serves serve VBZ 42759 2972 10 the the DT 42759 2972 11 middle middle JJ 42759 2972 12 classes class NNS 42759 2972 13 rather rather RB 42759 2972 14 than than IN 42759 2972 15 the the DT 42759 2972 16 very very RB 42759 2972 17 poor poor JJ 42759 2972 18 , , , 42759 2972 19 requires require VBZ 42759 2972 20 all all PDT 42759 2972 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2972 22 members member NNS 42759 2972 23 to to TO 42759 2972 24 subscribe subscribe VB 42759 2972 25 for for IN 42759 2972 26 capital capital NN 42759 2972 27 stock stock NN 42759 2972 28 , , , 42759 2972 29 commits commit VBZ 42759 2972 30 them -PRON- PRP 42759 2972 31 to to IN 42759 2972 32 a a DT 42759 2972 33 long long JJ 42759 2972 34 course course NN 42759 2972 35 of of IN 42759 2972 36 saving saving NN 42759 2972 37 , , , 42759 2972 38 and and CC 42759 2972 39 thus thus RB 42759 2972 40 develops develop VBZ 42759 2972 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2972 42 interest interest NN 42759 2972 43 as as IN 42759 2972 44 lenders lender NNS 42759 2972 45 . . . 42759 2973 1 The the DT 42759 2973 2 Raiffeisen Raiffeisen NNP 42759 2973 3 societies society NNS 42759 2973 4 have have VBP 42759 2973 5 , , , 42759 2973 6 as as IN 42759 2973 7 a a DT 42759 2973 8 rule rule NN 42759 2973 9 , , , 42759 2973 10 very very RB 42759 2973 11 little little JJ 42759 2973 12 share share NN 42759 2973 13 capital capital NN 42759 2973 14 , , , 42759 2973 15 exist exist VBP 42759 2973 16 chiefly chiefly RB 42759 2973 17 in in IN 42759 2973 18 the the DT 42759 2973 19 country country NN 42759 2973 20 districts district NNS 42759 2973 21 , , , 42759 2973 22 especially especially RB 42759 2973 23 among among IN 42759 2973 24 the the DT 42759 2973 25 poorest poor JJS 42759 2973 26 of of IN 42759 2973 27 the the DT 42759 2973 28 peasantry peasantry NN 42759 2973 29 , , , 42759 2973 30 are be VBP 42759 2973 31 based base VBN 42759 2973 32 mostly mostly RB 42759 2973 33 on on IN 42759 2973 34 personal personal JJ 42759 2973 35 credit credit NN 42759 2973 36 , , , 42759 2973 37 and and CC 42759 2973 38 do do VBP 42759 2973 39 not not RB 42759 2973 40 profess profess VB 42759 2973 41 to to TO 42759 2973 42 encourage encourage VB 42759 2973 43 greatly greatly RB 42759 2973 44 the the DT 42759 2973 45 saving save VBG 42759 2973 46 and and CC 42759 2973 47 lending lending NN 42759 2973 48 activities activity NNS 42759 2973 49 of of IN 42759 2973 50 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2973 51 members member NNS 42759 2973 52 . . . 42759 2974 1 Both both DT 42759 2974 2 forms form NNS 42759 2974 3 of of IN 42759 2974 4 association association NN 42759 2974 5 loan loan NN 42759 2974 6 money money NN 42759 2974 7 to to IN 42759 2974 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2974 9 members member NNS 42759 2974 10 at at IN 42759 2974 11 lower low JJR 42759 2974 12 rates rate NNS 42759 2974 13 of of IN 42759 2974 14 interest interest NN 42759 2974 15 than than IN 42759 2974 16 these these DT 42759 2974 17 persons person NNS 42759 2974 18 could could MD 42759 2974 19 obtain obtain VB 42759 2974 20 elsewhere elsewhere RB 42759 2974 21 . . . 42759 2975 1 Hence hence RB 42759 2975 2 credit credit NN 42759 2975 3 co co NN 42759 2975 4 - - NN 42759 2975 5 operation operation NN 42759 2975 6 directly directly RB 42759 2975 7 reduces reduce VBZ 42759 2975 8 the the DT 42759 2975 9 burden burden NN 42759 2975 10 of of IN 42759 2975 11 interest interest NN 42759 2975 12 . . . 42759 2976 1 The the DT 42759 2976 2 Schulze Schulze NNP 42759 2976 3 - - HYPH 42759 2976 4 Delitzsch Delitzsch NNP 42759 2976 5 societies society NNS 42759 2976 6 have have VBP 42759 2976 7 more more JJR 42759 2976 8 than than IN 42759 2976 9 half half PDT 42759 2976 10 a a DT 42759 2976 11 million million CD 42759 2976 12 members member NNS 42759 2976 13 in in IN 42759 2976 14 the the DT 42759 2976 15 cities city NNS 42759 2976 16 and and CC 42759 2976 17 towns town NNS 42759 2976 18 of of IN 42759 2976 19 Germany Germany NNP 42759 2976 20 , , , 42759 2976 21 sixty sixty CD 42759 2976 22 per per IN 42759 2976 23 cent cent NN 42759 2976 24 . . . 42759 2977 1 of of IN 42759 2977 2 whom whom WP 42759 2977 3 take take VBP 42759 2977 4 advantage advantage NN 42759 2977 5 of of IN 42759 2977 6 the the DT 42759 2977 7 borrowing borrowing NN 42759 2977 8 facilities facility NNS 42759 2977 9 . . . 42759 2978 1 The the DT 42759 2978 2 Raiffeisen Raiffeisen NNP 42759 2978 3 banks bank NNS 42759 2978 4 comprise comprise VBP 42759 2978 5 about about RB 42759 2978 6 one one CD 42759 2978 7 - - HYPH 42759 2978 8 half half NN 42759 2978 9 of of IN 42759 2978 10 all all PDT 42759 2978 11 the the DT 42759 2978 12 independent independent JJ 42759 2978 13 German german JJ 42759 2978 14 agriculturists agriculturist NNS 42759 2978 15 . . . 42759 2979 1 Some some DT 42759 2979 2 form form NN 42759 2979 3 of of IN 42759 2979 4 co co JJ 42759 2979 5 - - JJ 42759 2979 6 operative operative JJ 42759 2979 7 banking banking NN 42759 2979 8 is be VBZ 42759 2979 9 well well RB 42759 2979 10 established establish VBN 42759 2979 11 in in IN 42759 2979 12 every every DT 42759 2979 13 important important JJ 42759 2979 14 country country NN 42759 2979 15 of of IN 42759 2979 16 Europe Europe NNP 42759 2979 17 , , , 42759 2979 18 except except IN 42759 2979 19 Denmark Denmark NNP 42759 2979 20 and and CC 42759 2979 21 Great Great NNP 42759 2979 22 Britain Britain NNP 42759 2979 23 . . . 42759 2980 1 In in IN 42759 2980 2 the the DT 42759 2980 3 former former JJ 42759 2980 4 country country NN 42759 2980 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2980 6 place place NN 42759 2980 7 seems seem VBZ 42759 2980 8 to to TO 42759 2980 9 be be VB 42759 2980 10 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 42759 2980 11 filled fill VBN 42759 2980 12 by by IN 42759 2980 13 the the DT 42759 2980 14 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 2980 15 commercial commercial JJ 42759 2980 16 banks bank NNS 42759 2980 17 . . . 42759 2981 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2981 2 absence absence NN 42759 2981 3 from from IN 42759 2981 4 Great Great NNP 42759 2981 5 Britain Britain NNP 42759 2981 6 is be VBZ 42759 2981 7 apparently apparently RB 42759 2981 8 due due JJ 42759 2981 9 to to IN 42759 2981 10 the the DT 42759 2981 11 credit credit NN 42759 2981 12 system system NN 42759 2981 13 provided provide VBN 42759 2981 14 by by IN 42759 2981 15 the the DT 42759 2981 16 large large JJ 42759 2981 17 landholders landholder NNS 42759 2981 18 , , , 42759 2981 19 to to IN 42759 2981 20 the the DT 42759 2981 21 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 2981 22 of of IN 42759 2981 23 peasant peasant NN 42759 2981 24 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 2981 25 , , , 42759 2981 26 and and CC 42759 2981 27 to to IN 42759 2981 28 general general JJ 42759 2981 29 lack lack NN 42759 2981 30 of of IN 42759 2981 31 initiative initiative NN 42759 2981 32 . . . 42759 2982 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2982 2 is be VBZ 42759 2982 3 especially especially RB 42759 2982 4 strong strong JJ 42759 2982 5 in in IN 42759 2982 6 Italy Italy NNP 42759 2982 7 , , , 42759 2982 8 Belgium Belgium NNP 42759 2982 9 , , , 42759 2982 10 and and CC 42759 2982 11 Austria Austria NNP 42759 2982 12 , , , 42759 2982 13 and and CC 42759 2982 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2982 15 has have VBZ 42759 2982 16 made make VBN 42759 2982 17 a a DT 42759 2982 18 promising promising JJ 42759 2982 19 beginning beginning NN 42759 2982 20 in in IN 42759 2982 21 Ireland Ireland NNP 42759 2982 22 . . . 42759 2983 1 In in IN 42759 2983 2 every every DT 42759 2983 3 country country NN 42759 2983 4 in in IN 42759 2983 5 which which WDT 42759 2983 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2983 7 has have VBZ 42759 2983 8 obtained obtain VBN 42759 2983 9 a a DT 42759 2983 10 foothold foothold NN 42759 2983 11 , , , 42759 2983 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2983 13 gives give VBZ 42759 2983 14 indication indication NN 42759 2983 15 of of IN 42759 2983 16 steady steady JJ 42759 2983 17 and and CC 42759 2983 18 continuous continuous JJ 42759 2983 19 progress progress NN 42759 2983 20 . . . 42759 2984 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 2984 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2984 3 is be VBZ 42759 2984 4 subject subject JJ 42759 2984 5 to to IN 42759 2984 6 definite definite JJ 42759 2984 7 limits limit NNS 42759 2984 8 . . . 42759 2985 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2985 2 can can MD 42759 2985 3 never never RB 42759 2985 4 make make VB 42759 2985 5 much much JJ 42759 2985 6 headway headway NN 42759 2985 7 among among IN 42759 2985 8 that that DT 42759 2985 9 class class NN 42759 2985 10 of of IN 42759 2985 11 persons person NNS 42759 2985 12 whose whose WP$ 42759 2985 13 material material NN 42759 2985 14 resources resource NNS 42759 2985 15 are be VBP 42759 2985 16 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 2985 17 large large JJ 42759 2985 18 and and CC 42759 2985 19 palpable palpable JJ 42759 2985 20 to to TO 42759 2985 21 command command VB 42759 2985 22 loans loan NNS 42759 2985 23 on on IN 42759 2985 24 the the DT 42759 2985 25 usual usual JJ 42759 2985 26 terms term NNS 42759 2985 27 offered offer VBN 42759 2985 28 by by IN 42759 2985 29 the the DT 42759 2985 30 commercial commercial JJ 42759 2985 31 banks bank NNS 42759 2985 32 . . . 42759 2986 1 As as IN 42759 2986 2 a a DT 42759 2986 3 rule rule NN 42759 2986 4 , , , 42759 2986 5 these these DT 42759 2986 6 terms term NNS 42759 2986 7 are be VBP 42759 2986 8 quite quite RB 42759 2986 9 as as RB 42759 2986 10 favourable favourable JJ 42759 2986 11 as as IN 42759 2986 12 those those DT 42759 2986 13 available available JJ 42759 2986 14 through through IN 42759 2986 15 the the DT 42759 2986 16 co co JJ 42759 2986 17 - - JJ 42759 2986 18 operative operative JJ 42759 2986 19 credit credit NN 42759 2986 20 associations association NNS 42759 2986 21 . . . 42759 2987 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 2987 2 is be VBZ 42759 2987 3 only only RB 42759 2987 4 because because IN 42759 2987 5 the the DT 42759 2987 6 poorer poor JJR 42759 2987 7 men man NNS 42759 2987 8 can can MD 42759 2987 9 not not RB 42759 2987 10 obtain obtain VB 42759 2987 11 loans loan NNS 42759 2987 12 from from IN 42759 2987 13 the the DT 42759 2987 14 commercial commercial JJ 42759 2987 15 banks bank NNS 42759 2987 16 on on IN 42759 2987 17 the the DT 42759 2987 18 prevailing prevailing JJ 42759 2987 19 conditions condition NNS 42759 2987 20 that that IN 42759 2987 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2987 22 are be VBP 42759 2987 23 impelled impel VBN 42759 2987 24 to to TO 42759 2987 25 have have VB 42759 2987 26 recourse recourse VBN 42759 2987 27 to to IN 42759 2987 28 the the DT 42759 2987 29 co co JJ 42759 2987 30 - - JJ 42759 2987 31 operative operative JJ 42759 2987 32 associations association NNS 42759 2987 33 . . . 42759 2988 1 _ _ NNP 42759 2988 2 Co Co NNP 42759 2988 3 - - NN 42759 2988 4 operative operative JJ 42759 2988 5 Agricultural Agricultural NNP 42759 2988 6 Societies Societies NNPS 42759 2988 7 _ _ NNP 42759 2988 8 The the DT 42759 2988 9 chief chief JJ 42759 2988 10 operations operation NNS 42759 2988 11 of of IN 42759 2988 12 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 2988 13 co co JJ 42759 2988 14 - - JJ 42759 2988 15 operative operative JJ 42759 2988 16 societies society NNS 42759 2988 17 are be VBP 42759 2988 18 manufacturing manufacture VBG 42759 2988 19 , , , 42759 2988 20 marketing marketing NN 42759 2988 21 , , , 42759 2988 22 and and CC 42759 2988 23 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 2988 24 . . . 42759 2989 1 In in IN 42759 2989 2 the the DT 42759 2989 3 first first JJ 42759 2989 4 named name VBN 42759 2989 5 field field NN 42759 2989 6 the the DT 42759 2989 7 most most RBS 42759 2989 8 important important JJ 42759 2989 9 example example NN 42759 2989 10 is be VBZ 42759 2989 11 the the DT 42759 2989 12 co co JJ 42759 2989 13 - - JJ 42759 2989 14 operative operative JJ 42759 2989 15 dairy dairy NN 42759 2989 16 . . . 42759 2990 1 The the DT 42759 2990 2 owners owner NNS 42759 2990 3 of of IN 42759 2990 4 cows cow NNS 42759 2990 5 hold hold VBP 42759 2990 6 the the DT 42759 2990 7 stock stock NN 42759 2990 8 or or CC 42759 2990 9 shares share NNS 42759 2990 10 of of IN 42759 2990 11 the the DT 42759 2990 12 concern concern NN 42759 2990 13 , , , 42759 2990 14 and and CC 42759 2990 15 in in IN 42759 2990 16 addition addition NN 42759 2990 17 to to IN 42759 2990 18 dividends dividend NNS 42759 2990 19 receive receive VBP 42759 2990 20 profits profit NNS 42759 2990 21 in in IN 42759 2990 22 proportion proportion NN 42759 2990 23 to to IN 42759 2990 24 the the DT 42759 2990 25 amount amount NN 42759 2990 26 of of IN 42759 2990 27 milk milk NN 42759 2990 28 that that WDT 42759 2990 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2990 30 supply supply VBP 42759 2990 31 . . . 42759 2991 1 In in IN 42759 2991 2 Ireland Ireland NNP 42759 2991 3 and and CC 42759 2991 4 some some DT 42759 2991 5 other other JJ 42759 2991 6 countries country NNS 42759 2991 7 , , , 42759 2991 8 a a DT 42759 2991 9 portion portion NN 42759 2991 10 of of IN 42759 2991 11 the the DT 42759 2991 12 profits profit NNS 42759 2991 13 goes go VBZ 42759 2991 14 to to IN 42759 2991 15 the the DT 42759 2991 16 employés employés NN 42759 2991 17 of of IN 42759 2991 18 the the DT 42759 2991 19 dairy dairy NN 42759 2991 20 as as IN 42759 2991 21 a a DT 42759 2991 22 dividend dividend NN 42759 2991 23 on on IN 42759 2991 24 wages wage NNS 42759 2991 25 . . . 42759 2992 1 Other other JJ 42759 2992 2 productive productive JJ 42759 2992 3 co co NNS 42759 2992 4 - - NNS 42759 2992 5 operatives operative NNS 42759 2992 6 of of IN 42759 2992 7 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 2992 8 are be VBP 42759 2992 9 found find VBN 42759 2992 10 in in IN 42759 2992 11 cheese cheese NN 42759 2992 12 making making NN 42759 2992 13 , , , 42759 2992 14 bacon bacon NN 42759 2992 15 curing curing NN 42759 2992 16 , , , 42759 2992 17 distilling distil VBG 42759 2992 18 , , , 42759 2992 19 and and CC 42759 2992 20 wine wine NN 42759 2992 21 making making NN 42759 2992 22 . . . 42759 2993 1 All all DT 42759 2993 2 are be VBP 42759 2993 3 conducted conduct VBN 42759 2993 4 on on IN 42759 2993 5 the the DT 42759 2993 6 same same JJ 42759 2993 7 general general JJ 42759 2993 8 principles principle NNS 42759 2993 9 as as IN 42759 2993 10 the the DT 42759 2993 11 co co JJ 42759 2993 12 - - JJ 42759 2993 13 operative operative JJ 42759 2993 14 dairy dairy NN 42759 2993 15 . . . 42759 2994 1 Through through IN 42759 2994 2 the the DT 42759 2994 3 marketing marketing NN 42759 2994 4 societies society NNS 42759 2994 5 and and CC 42759 2994 6 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 2994 7 societies society NNS 42759 2994 8 , , , 42759 2994 9 the the DT 42759 2994 10 farmers farmer NNS 42759 2994 11 are be VBP 42759 2994 12 enabled enable VBN 42759 2994 13 to to TO 42759 2994 14 sell sell VB 42759 2994 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 2994 16 products product NNS 42759 2994 17 to to IN 42759 2994 18 better well JJR 42759 2994 19 advantage advantage NN 42759 2994 20 , , , 42759 2994 21 and and CC 42759 2994 22 to to TO 42759 2994 23 obtain obtain VB 42759 2994 24 materials material NNS 42759 2994 25 needed need VBN 42759 2994 26 for for IN 42759 2994 27 carrying carry VBG 42759 2994 28 on on IN 42759 2994 29 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 2994 30 operations operation NNS 42759 2994 31 more more RBR 42759 2994 32 cheaply cheaply RB 42759 2994 33 than than IN 42759 2994 34 would would MD 42759 2994 35 be be VB 42759 2994 36 possible possible JJ 42759 2994 37 by by IN 42759 2994 38 isolated isolated JJ 42759 2994 39 individual individual JJ 42759 2994 40 action action NN 42759 2994 41 . . . 42759 2995 1 Some some DT 42759 2995 2 of of IN 42759 2995 3 the the DT 42759 2995 4 products product NNS 42759 2995 5 marketed market VBN 42759 2995 6 by by IN 42759 2995 7 the the DT 42759 2995 8 selling selling NN 42759 2995 9 societies society NNS 42759 2995 10 are be VBP 42759 2995 11 eggs egg NNS 42759 2995 12 , , , 42759 2995 13 milk milk NN 42759 2995 14 , , , 42759 2995 15 poultry poultry NN 42759 2995 16 , , , 42759 2995 17 fruit fruit NN 42759 2995 18 , , , 42759 2995 19 vegetables vegetable NNS 42759 2995 20 , , , 42759 2995 21 live live VB 42759 2995 22 stock stock NN 42759 2995 23 , , , 42759 2995 24 and and CC 42759 2995 25 various various JJ 42759 2995 26 kinds kind NNS 42759 2995 27 of of IN 42759 2995 28 grain grain NN 42759 2995 29 . . . 42759 2996 1 The the DT 42759 2996 2 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 2996 3 societies society NNS 42759 2996 4 supply supply NN 42759 2996 5 for for IN 42759 2996 6 the the DT 42759 2996 7 most most JJS 42759 2996 8 part part NN 42759 2996 9 manures manure NNS 42759 2996 10 , , , 42759 2996 11 seeds seed NNS 42759 2996 12 , , , 42759 2996 13 and and CC 42759 2996 14 machinery machinery NN 42759 2996 15 . . . 42759 2997 1 Occasionally occasionally RB 42759 2997 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2997 3 buy buy VBP 42759 2997 4 the the DT 42759 2997 5 most most RBS 42759 2997 6 costly costly JJ 42759 2997 7 machinery machinery NN 42759 2997 8 in in IN 42759 2997 9 such such PDT 42759 2997 10 a a DT 42759 2997 11 way way NN 42759 2997 12 that that WDT 42759 2997 13 the the DT 42759 2997 14 association association NN 42759 2997 15 becomes become VBZ 42759 2997 16 the the DT 42759 2997 17 corporate corporate JJ 42759 2997 18 owner owner NN 42759 2997 19 of of IN 42759 2997 20 the the DT 42759 2997 21 implements implement NNS 42759 2997 22 . . . 42759 2998 1 In in IN 42759 2998 2 these these DT 42759 2998 3 cases case NNS 42759 2998 4 the the DT 42759 2998 5 individual individual JJ 42759 2998 6 members member NNS 42759 2998 7 have have VBP 42759 2998 8 only only RB 42759 2998 9 the the DT 42759 2998 10 use use NN 42759 2998 11 of of IN 42759 2998 12 the the DT 42759 2998 13 machines machine NNS 42759 2998 14 , , , 42759 2998 15 but but CC 42759 2998 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 2998 17 would would MD 42759 2998 18 be be VB 42759 2998 19 unable unable JJ 42759 2998 20 to to TO 42759 2998 21 enjoy enjoy VB 42759 2998 22 even even RB 42759 2998 23 that that DT 42759 2998 24 advantage advantage NN 42759 2998 25 were be VBD 42759 2998 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 2998 27 not not RB 42759 2998 28 for for IN 42759 2998 29 the the DT 42759 2998 30 intervention intervention NN 42759 2998 31 of of IN 42759 2998 32 the the DT 42759 2998 33 co co JJ 42759 2998 34 - - JJ 42759 2998 35 operative operative JJ 42759 2998 36 society society NN 42759 2998 37 . . . 42759 2999 1 Where where WRB 42759 2999 2 such such JJ 42759 2999 3 arrangements arrangement NNS 42759 2999 4 exist exist VBP 42759 2999 5 , , , 42759 2999 6 the the DT 42759 2999 7 society society NN 42759 2999 8 exemplifies exemplify VBZ 42759 2999 9 not not RB 42759 2999 10 only only RB 42759 2999 11 co co JJ 42759 2999 12 - - JJ 42759 2999 13 operative operative JJ 42759 2999 14 buying buying NN 42759 2999 15 but but CC 42759 2999 16 co co JJ 42759 2999 17 - - JJ 42759 2999 18 operative operative JJ 42759 2999 19 ownership ownership NN 42759 2999 20 . . . 42759 3000 1 Agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 3000 2 co co NN 42759 3000 3 - - NN 42759 3000 4 operation operation NN 42759 3000 5 has have VBZ 42759 3000 6 become become VBN 42759 3000 7 most most RBS 42759 3000 8 widely widely RB 42759 3000 9 extended extend VBN 42759 3000 10 in in IN 42759 3000 11 Denmark Denmark NNP 42759 3000 12 , , , 42759 3000 13 and and CC 42759 3000 14 has have VBZ 42759 3000 15 displayed display VBN 42759 3000 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3000 17 most most RBS 42759 3000 18 striking striking JJ 42759 3000 19 possibilities possibility NNS 42759 3000 20 in in IN 42759 3000 21 Ireland Ireland NNP 42759 3000 22 . . . 42759 3001 1 Relatively relatively RB 42759 3001 2 to to IN 42759 3001 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3001 4 population population NN 42759 3001 5 , , , 42759 3001 6 the the DT 42759 3001 7 former former JJ 42759 3001 8 country country NN 42759 3001 9 has have VBZ 42759 3001 10 more more JJR 42759 3001 11 farmers farmer NNS 42759 3001 12 in in IN 42759 3001 13 co co JJ 42759 3001 14 - - JJ 42759 3001 15 operative operative JJ 42759 3001 16 societies society NNS 42759 3001 17 , , , 42759 3001 18 and and CC 42759 3001 19 has have VBZ 42759 3001 20 derived derive VBN 42759 3001 21 more more JJR 42759 3001 22 profit profit NN 42759 3001 23 therefrom therefrom NN 42759 3001 24 , , , 42759 3001 25 than than IN 42759 3001 26 any any DT 42759 3001 27 other other JJ 42759 3001 28 nation nation NN 42759 3001 29 . . . 42759 3002 1 The the DT 42759 3002 2 rapid rapid JJ 42759 3002 3 growth growth NN 42759 3002 4 and and CC 42759 3002 5 achievements achievement NNS 42759 3002 6 of of IN 42759 3002 7 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 3002 8 co co NN 42759 3002 9 - - NN 42759 3002 10 operation operation NN 42759 3002 11 in in IN 42759 3002 12 the the DT 42759 3002 13 peculiarly peculiarly RB 42759 3002 14 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 42759 3002 15 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 3002 16 of of IN 42759 3002 17 Ireland Ireland NNP 42759 3002 18 constitute constitute VBP 42759 3002 19 the the DT 42759 3002 20 most most RBS 42759 3002 21 convincing convincing JJ 42759 3002 22 proof proof NN 42759 3002 23 to to TO 42759 3002 24 be be VB 42759 3002 25 found find VBN 42759 3002 26 anywhere anywhere RB 42759 3002 27 of of IN 42759 3002 28 the the DT 42759 3002 29 essential essential JJ 42759 3002 30 soundness soundness NN 42759 3002 31 and and CC 42759 3002 32 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 3002 33 of of IN 42759 3002 34 the the DT 42759 3002 35 movement movement NN 42759 3002 36 . . . 42759 3003 1 Various various JJ 42759 3003 2 forms form NNS 42759 3003 3 of of IN 42759 3003 4 rural rural JJ 42759 3003 5 co co JJ 42759 3003 6 - - JJ 42759 3003 7 operative operative JJ 42759 3003 8 societies society NNS 42759 3003 9 are be VBP 42759 3003 10 solidly solidly RB 42759 3003 11 established establish VBN 42759 3003 12 in in IN 42759 3003 13 Germany Germany NNP 42759 3003 14 , , , 42759 3003 15 France France NNP 42759 3003 16 , , , 42759 3003 17 Belgium Belgium NNP 42759 3003 18 , , , 42759 3003 19 Italy Italy NNP 42759 3003 20 , , , 42759 3003 21 and and CC 42759 3003 22 Switzerland Switzerland NNP 42759 3003 23 . . . 42759 3004 1 In in IN 42759 3004 2 recent recent JJ 42759 3004 3 years year NNS 42759 3004 4 the the DT 42759 3004 5 movement movement NN 42759 3004 6 has have VBZ 42759 3004 7 made make VBN 42759 3004 8 some some DT 42759 3004 9 progress progress NN 42759 3004 10 in in IN 42759 3004 11 the the DT 42759 3004 12 United United NNP 42759 3004 13 States States NNP 42759 3004 14 , , , 42759 3004 15 especially especially RB 42759 3004 16 in in IN 42759 3004 17 relation relation NN 42759 3004 18 to to IN 42759 3004 19 dairies dairy NNS 42759 3004 20 , , , 42759 3004 21 grain grain NN 42759 3004 22 elevators elevator NNS 42759 3004 23 , , , 42759 3004 24 the the DT 42759 3004 25 marketing marketing NN 42759 3004 26 of of IN 42759 3004 27 live live JJ 42759 3004 28 stock stock NN 42759 3004 29 and and CC 42759 3004 30 fruit fruit NN 42759 3004 31 , , , 42759 3004 32 and and CC 42759 3004 33 various various JJ 42759 3004 34 forms form NNS 42759 3004 35 of of IN 42759 3004 36 rural rural JJ 42759 3004 37 insurance insurance NN 42759 3004 38 . . . 42759 3005 1 The the DT 42759 3005 2 co co JJ 42759 3005 3 - - JJ 42759 3005 4 operative operative JJ 42759 3005 5 insurance insurance NN 42759 3005 6 companies company NNS 42759 3005 7 effect effect VBP 42759 3005 8 a a DT 42759 3005 9 saving saving NN 42759 3005 10 to to IN 42759 3005 11 the the DT 42759 3005 12 Minnesota Minnesota NNP 42759 3005 13 farmers farmer NNS 42759 3005 14 of of IN 42759 3005 15 $ $ $ 42759 3005 16 700,000 700,000 CD 42759 3005 17 annually annually RB 42759 3005 18 , , , 42759 3005 19 and and CC 42759 3005 20 the the DT 42759 3005 21 co co JJ 42759 3005 22 - - JJ 42759 3005 23 operative operative JJ 42759 3005 24 elevators elevator NNS 42759 3005 25 handle handle VBP 42759 3005 26 about about RB 42759 3005 27 30 30 CD 42759 3005 28 per per NN 42759 3005 29 cent cent NN 42759 3005 30 . . . 42759 3006 1 of of IN 42759 3006 2 the the DT 42759 3006 3 grain grain NN 42759 3006 4 marketed market VBN 42759 3006 5 in in IN 42759 3006 6 that that DT 42759 3006 7 state state NN 42759 3006 8 . . . 42759 3007 1 In in IN 42759 3007 2 1915 1915 CD 42759 3007 3 the the DT 42759 3007 4 business business NN 42759 3007 5 transacted transact VBN 42759 3007 6 by by IN 42759 3007 7 the the DT 42759 3007 8 co co JJ 42759 3007 9 - - JJ 42759 3007 10 operative operative JJ 42759 3007 11 marketing marketing NN 42759 3007 12 and and CC 42759 3007 13 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 3007 14 organisations organisation NNS 42759 3007 15 of of IN 42759 3007 16 the the DT 42759 3007 17 farmers farmer NNS 42759 3007 18 of of IN 42759 3007 19 the the DT 42759 3007 20 United United NNP 42759 3007 21 States States NNP 42759 3007 22 amounted amount VBD 42759 3007 23 to to IN 42759 3007 24 $ $ $ 42759 3007 25 1,400,000,000 1,400,000,000 CD 42759 3007 26 . . . 42759 3008 1 The the DT 42759 3008 2 transformation transformation NN 42759 3008 3 in in IN 42759 3008 4 the the DT 42759 3008 5 rural rural JJ 42759 3008 6 life life NN 42759 3008 7 of of IN 42759 3008 8 more more JJR 42759 3008 9 than than IN 42759 3008 10 one one CD 42759 3008 11 European european JJ 42759 3008 12 community community NN 42759 3008 13 through through IN 42759 3008 14 co co NN 42759 3008 15 - - NN 42759 3008 16 operation operation NN 42759 3008 17 has have VBZ 42759 3008 18 amounted amount VBN 42759 3008 19 to to IN 42759 3008 20 little little JJ 42759 3008 21 less less JJR 42759 3008 22 than than IN 42759 3008 23 a a DT 42759 3008 24 revolution revolution NN 42759 3008 25 . . . 42759 3009 1 Higher high JJR 42759 3009 2 standards standard NNS 42759 3009 3 of of IN 42759 3009 4 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 3009 5 products product NNS 42759 3009 6 and and CC 42759 3009 7 production production NN 42759 3009 8 have have VBP 42759 3009 9 been be VBN 42759 3009 10 set set VBN 42759 3009 11 up up RP 42759 3009 12 and and CC 42759 3009 13 maintained maintain VBD 42759 3009 14 , , , 42759 3009 15 better well JJR 42759 3009 16 methods method NNS 42759 3009 17 of of IN 42759 3009 18 farming farming NN 42759 3009 19 have have VBP 42759 3009 20 been be VBN 42759 3009 21 inculcated inculcate VBN 42759 3009 22 and and CC 42759 3009 23 enforced enforce VBN 42759 3009 24 , , , 42759 3009 25 and and CC 42759 3009 26 the the DT 42759 3009 27 whole whole JJ 42759 3009 28 social social JJ 42759 3009 29 , , , 42759 3009 30 moral moral JJ 42759 3009 31 , , , 42759 3009 32 and and CC 42759 3009 33 civic civic JJ 42759 3009 34 life life NN 42759 3009 35 of of IN 42759 3009 36 the the DT 42759 3009 37 people people NNS 42759 3009 38 has have VBZ 42759 3009 39 been be VBN 42759 3009 40 raised raise VBN 42759 3009 41 to to IN 42759 3009 42 a a DT 42759 3009 43 higher high JJR 42759 3009 44 level level NN 42759 3009 45 . . . 42759 3010 1 From from IN 42759 3010 2 the the DT 42759 3010 3 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 3010 4 of of IN 42759 3010 5 material material JJ 42759 3010 6 gain gain NN 42759 3010 7 , , , 42759 3010 8 the the DT 42759 3010 9 chief chief JJ 42759 3010 10 benefits benefit NNS 42759 3010 11 of of IN 42759 3010 12 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 3010 13 co co NN 42759 3010 14 - - NN 42759 3010 15 operation operation NN 42759 3010 16 have have VBP 42759 3010 17 been be VBN 42759 3010 18 the the DT 42759 3010 19 elimination elimination NN 42759 3010 20 of of IN 42759 3010 21 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 3010 22 middlemen middleman NNS 42759 3010 23 , , , 42759 3010 24 and and CC 42759 3010 25 the the DT 42759 3010 26 economies economy NNS 42759 3010 27 of of IN 42759 3010 28 buying buying NN 42759 3010 29 in in IN 42759 3010 30 large large JJ 42759 3010 31 quantities quantity NNS 42759 3010 32 , , , 42759 3010 33 selling sell VBG 42759 3010 34 in in IN 42759 3010 35 the the DT 42759 3010 36 best good JJS 42759 3010 37 markets market NNS 42759 3010 38 , , , 42759 3010 39 and and CC 42759 3010 40 employing employ VBG 42759 3010 41 the the DT 42759 3010 42 most most RBS 42759 3010 43 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3010 44 implements implement NNS 42759 3010 45 . . . 42759 3011 1 As as IN 42759 3011 2 compared compare VBN 42759 3011 3 with with IN 42759 3011 4 farming farming NN 42759 3011 5 conducted conduct VBN 42759 3011 6 on on IN 42759 3011 7 a a DT 42759 3011 8 large large JJ 42759 3011 9 scale scale NN 42759 3011 10 , , , 42759 3011 11 the the DT 42759 3011 12 small small JJ 42759 3011 13 farm farm NN 42759 3011 14 possesses possess VBZ 42759 3011 15 certain certain JJ 42759 3011 16 advantages advantage NNS 42759 3011 17 , , , 42759 3011 18 and and CC 42759 3011 19 is be VBZ 42759 3011 20 subject subject JJ 42759 3011 21 to to IN 42759 3011 22 certain certain JJ 42759 3011 23 disadvantages disadvantage NNS 42759 3011 24 . . . 42759 3012 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3012 2 is be VBZ 42759 3012 3 less less RBR 42759 3012 4 wasteful wasteful JJ 42759 3012 5 , , , 42759 3012 6 permits permit VBZ 42759 3012 7 greater great JJR 42759 3012 8 attention attention NN 42759 3012 9 to to IN 42759 3012 10 details detail NNS 42759 3012 11 , , , 42759 3012 12 and and CC 42759 3012 13 makes make VBZ 42759 3012 14 a a DT 42759 3012 15 greater great JJR 42759 3012 16 appeal appeal NN 42759 3012 17 to to IN 42759 3012 18 the the DT 42759 3012 19 self self NN 42759 3012 20 interest interest NN 42759 3012 21 of of IN 42759 3012 22 the the DT 42759 3012 23 cultivator cultivator NN 42759 3012 24 ; ; : 42759 3012 25 but but CC 42759 3012 26 the the DT 42759 3012 27 small small JJ 42759 3012 28 farmer farmer NN 42759 3012 29 can can MD 42759 3012 30 not not RB 42759 3012 31 afford afford VB 42759 3012 32 to to TO 42759 3012 33 buy buy VB 42759 3012 34 the the DT 42759 3012 35 best good JJS 42759 3012 36 machinery machinery NN 42759 3012 37 , , , 42759 3012 38 nor nor CC 42759 3012 39 is be VBZ 42759 3012 40 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3012 41 in in IN 42759 3012 42 a a DT 42759 3012 43 position position NN 42759 3012 44 to to TO 42759 3012 45 carry carry VB 42759 3012 46 on on RP 42759 3012 47 to to IN 42759 3012 48 the the DT 42759 3012 49 best good JJS 42759 3012 50 advantage advantage NN 42759 3012 51 the the DT 42759 3012 52 commercial commercial JJ 42759 3012 53 features feature NNS 42759 3012 54 of of IN 42759 3012 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3012 56 occupation occupation NN 42759 3012 57 , , , 42759 3012 58 such such JJ 42759 3012 59 as as IN 42759 3012 60 borrowing borrowing NN 42759 3012 61 , , , 42759 3012 62 buying buying NN 42759 3012 63 , , , 42759 3012 64 and and CC 42759 3012 65 marketing marketing NN 42759 3012 66 . . . 42759 3013 1 Co co NN 42759 3013 2 - - NN 42759 3013 3 operation operation NN 42759 3013 4 frees free VBZ 42759 3013 5 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3013 6 from from IN 42759 3013 7 all all PDT 42759 3013 8 these these DT 42759 3013 9 handicaps handicap NNS 42759 3013 10 . . . 42759 3014 1 " " `` 42759 3014 2 The the DT 42759 3014 3 co co JJ 42759 3014 4 - - JJ 42759 3014 5 operative operative JJ 42759 3014 6 community community NN 42759 3014 7 ... ... : 42759 3014 8 is be VBZ 42759 3014 9 one one CD 42759 3014 10 in in IN 42759 3014 11 which which WDT 42759 3014 12 groups group NNS 42759 3014 13 of of IN 42759 3014 14 humble humble JJ 42759 3014 15 men man NNS 42759 3014 16 combine combine VBP 42759 3014 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3014 18 efforts effort NNS 42759 3014 19 , , , 42759 3014 20 and and CC 42759 3014 21 to to IN 42759 3014 22 some some DT 42759 3014 23 extent extent NN 42759 3014 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3014 25 resources resource NNS 42759 3014 26 , , , 42759 3014 27 in in IN 42759 3014 28 order order NN 42759 3014 29 to to TO 42759 3014 30 secure secure VB 42759 3014 31 for for IN 42759 3014 32 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 3014 33 those those DT 42759 3014 34 advantages advantage NNS 42759 3014 35 in in IN 42759 3014 36 industry industry NN 42759 3014 37 which which WDT 42759 3014 38 the the DT 42759 3014 39 masters master NNS 42759 3014 40 of of IN 42759 3014 41 capital capital NN 42759 3014 42 derive derive VBP 42759 3014 43 from from IN 42759 3014 44 the the DT 42759 3014 45 organisation organisation NN 42759 3014 46 of of IN 42759 3014 47 labour labour NNP 42759 3014 48 , , , 42759 3014 49 from from IN 42759 3014 50 the the DT 42759 3014 51 use use NN 42759 3014 52 of of IN 42759 3014 53 costly costly JJ 42759 3014 54 machinery machinery NN 42759 3014 55 , , , 42759 3014 56 and and CC 42759 3014 57 from from IN 42759 3014 58 the the DT 42759 3014 59 economies economy NNS 42759 3014 60 of of IN 42759 3014 61 business business NN 42759 3014 62 when when WRB 42759 3014 63 done do VBN 42759 3014 64 on on IN 42759 3014 65 a a DT 42759 3014 66 large large JJ 42759 3014 67 scale scale NN 42759 3014 68 . . . 42759 3015 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3015 2 apply apply VBP 42759 3015 3 in in IN 42759 3015 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3015 5 industry industry NN 42759 3015 6 the the DT 42759 3015 7 methods method NNS 42759 3015 8 by by IN 42759 3015 9 which which WDT 42759 3015 10 the the DT 42759 3015 11 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 3015 12 of of IN 42759 3015 13 the the DT 42759 3015 14 magnates magnate NNS 42759 3015 15 in in IN 42759 3015 16 commerce commerce NN 42759 3015 17 and and CC 42759 3015 18 manufacture manufacture NN 42759 3015 19 are be VBP 42759 3015 20 made make VBN 42759 3015 21 . . . 42759 3015 22 " " '' 42759 3016 1 These these DT 42759 3016 2 words word NNS 42759 3016 3 , , , 42759 3016 4 uttered utter VBN 42759 3016 5 by by IN 42759 3016 6 a a DT 42759 3016 7 prominent prominent JJ 42759 3016 8 member member NN 42759 3016 9 of of IN 42759 3016 10 the the DT 42759 3016 11 Irish irish JJ 42759 3016 12 co co JJ 42759 3016 13 - - JJ 42759 3016 14 operative operative JJ 42759 3016 15 movement movement NN 42759 3016 16 , , , 42759 3016 17 summarise summarise VB 42759 3016 18 the the DT 42759 3016 19 aims aim NNS 42759 3016 20 and and CC 42759 3016 21 achievements achievement NNS 42759 3016 22 of of IN 42759 3016 23 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 3016 24 co co NN 42759 3016 25 - - NN 42759 3016 26 operation operation NN 42759 3016 27 in in IN 42759 3016 28 every every DT 42759 3016 29 country country NN 42759 3016 30 of of IN 42759 3016 31 Europe Europe NNP 42759 3016 32 in in IN 42759 3016 33 which which WDT 42759 3016 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3016 35 has have VBZ 42759 3016 36 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3016 37 a a DT 42759 3016 38 strong strong JJ 42759 3016 39 foothold foothold NN 42759 3016 40 . . . 42759 3017 1 In in IN 42759 3017 2 every every DT 42759 3017 3 such such JJ 42759 3017 4 community community NN 42759 3017 5 the the DT 42759 3017 6 small small JJ 42759 3017 7 farm farm NN 42759 3017 8 has have VBZ 42759 3017 9 gained gain VBN 42759 3017 10 at at IN 42759 3017 11 the the DT 42759 3017 12 expense expense NN 42759 3017 13 of of IN 42759 3017 14 the the DT 42759 3017 15 large large JJ 42759 3017 16 farm farm NN 42759 3017 17 system system NN 42759 3017 18 . . . 42759 3018 1 Finally finally RB 42759 3018 2 , , , 42759 3018 3 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 3018 4 co co NN 42759 3018 5 - - NN 42759 3018 6 operation operation NN 42759 3018 7 reduces reduce VBZ 42759 3018 8 the the DT 42759 3018 9 burden burden NN 42759 3018 10 of of IN 42759 3018 11 interest interest NN 42759 3018 12 by by IN 42759 3018 13 eliminating eliminate VBG 42759 3018 14 some some DT 42759 3018 15 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 3018 16 capital capital NN 42759 3018 17 , , , 42759 3018 18 stimulates stimulate VBZ 42759 3018 19 saving save VBG 42759 3018 20 among among IN 42759 3018 21 the the DT 42759 3018 22 tillers tiller NNS 42759 3018 23 of of IN 42759 3018 24 the the DT 42759 3018 25 soil soil NN 42759 3018 26 by by IN 42759 3018 27 providing provide VBG 42759 3018 28 a a DT 42759 3018 29 ready ready JJ 42759 3018 30 and and CC 42759 3018 31 safe safe JJ 42759 3018 32 means mean NNS 42759 3018 33 of of IN 42759 3018 34 investment investment NN 42759 3018 35 , , , 42759 3018 36 and and CC 42759 3018 37 in in IN 42759 3018 38 manifold manifold JJ 42759 3018 39 ways way NNS 42759 3018 40 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 3018 41 materially materially RB 42759 3018 42 toward toward IN 42759 3018 43 a a DT 42759 3018 44 better well JJR 42759 3018 45 distribution distribution NN 42759 3018 46 of of IN 42759 3018 47 wealth wealth NN 42759 3018 48 . . . 42759 3019 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3019 2 Co Co NNP 42759 3019 3 - - NN 42759 3019 4 operative operative JJ 42759 3019 5 Mercantile Mercantile NNP 42759 3019 6 Societies Societies NNPS 42759 3019 7 _ _ NNP 42759 3019 8 Co Co NNP 42759 3019 9 - - JJ 42759 3019 10 operative operative JJ 42759 3019 11 stores store NNS 42759 3019 12 are be VBP 42759 3019 13 organised organise VBN 42759 3019 14 by by IN 42759 3019 15 and and CC 42759 3019 16 for for IN 42759 3019 17 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3019 18 . . . 42759 3020 1 In in IN 42759 3020 2 every every DT 42759 3020 3 country country NN 42759 3020 4 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3020 5 follow follow VBP 42759 3020 6 rather rather RB 42759 3020 7 closely closely RB 42759 3020 8 the the DT 42759 3020 9 Rochdale Rochdale NNP 42759 3020 10 system system NN 42759 3020 11 , , , 42759 3020 12 so so RB 42759 3020 13 called call VBD 42759 3020 14 from from IN 42759 3020 15 the the DT 42759 3020 16 English english JJ 42759 3020 17 town town NN 42759 3020 18 in in IN 42759 3020 19 which which WDT 42759 3020 20 the the DT 42759 3020 21 first first JJ 42759 3020 22 store store NN 42759 3020 23 of of IN 42759 3020 24 this this DT 42759 3020 25 kind kind NN 42759 3020 26 was be VBD 42759 3020 27 established establish VBN 42759 3020 28 in in IN 42759 3020 29 1844 1844 CD 42759 3020 30 . . . 42759 3021 1 The the DT 42759 3021 2 members member NNS 42759 3021 3 of of IN 42759 3021 4 the the DT 42759 3021 5 co co JJ 42759 3021 6 - - JJ 42759 3021 7 operative operative JJ 42759 3021 8 society society NN 42759 3021 9 furnish furnish VB 42759 3021 10 the the DT 42759 3021 11 capital capital NN 42759 3021 12 , , , 42759 3021 13 and and CC 42759 3021 14 receive receive VBP 42759 3021 15 thereon thereon NN 42759 3021 16 interest interest NN 42759 3021 17 at at IN 42759 3021 18 the the DT 42759 3021 19 prevailing prevailing NN 42759 3021 20 rate rate NN 42759 3021 21 , , , 42759 3021 22 usually usually RB 42759 3021 23 five five CD 42759 3021 24 per per IN 42759 3021 25 cent cent NN 42759 3021 26 . . . 42759 3022 1 The the DT 42759 3022 2 stores store NNS 42759 3022 3 sell sell VBP 42759 3022 4 goods good NNS 42759 3022 5 at at IN 42759 3022 6 about about IN 42759 3022 7 the the DT 42759 3022 8 same same JJ 42759 3022 9 prices price NNS 42759 3022 10 as as IN 42759 3022 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3022 12 privately privately RB 42759 3022 13 owned own VBN 42759 3022 14 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3022 15 , , , 42759 3022 16 but but CC 42759 3022 17 return return VB 42759 3022 18 a a DT 42759 3022 19 dividend dividend NN 42759 3022 20 on on IN 42759 3022 21 the the DT 42759 3022 22 purchases purchase NNS 42759 3022 23 of of IN 42759 3022 24 all all PDT 42759 3022 25 those those DT 42759 3022 26 customers customer NNS 42759 3022 27 who who WP 42759 3022 28 are be VBP 42759 3022 29 members member NNS 42759 3022 30 of of IN 42759 3022 31 the the DT 42759 3022 32 society society NN 42759 3022 33 . . . 42759 3023 1 The the DT 42759 3023 2 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3023 3 are be VBP 42759 3023 4 provided provide VBN 42759 3023 5 from from IN 42759 3023 6 the the DT 42759 3023 7 surplus surplus NN 42759 3023 8 which which WDT 42759 3023 9 remains remain VBZ 42759 3023 10 after after IN 42759 3023 11 wages wage NNS 42759 3023 12 , , , 42759 3023 13 interest interest NN 42759 3023 14 on on IN 42759 3023 15 the the DT 42759 3023 16 capital capital NN 42759 3023 17 stock stock NN 42759 3023 18 , , , 42759 3023 19 and and CC 42759 3023 20 all all DT 42759 3023 21 other other JJ 42759 3023 22 expenses expense NNS 42759 3023 23 have have VBP 42759 3023 24 been be VBN 42759 3023 25 paid pay VBN 42759 3023 26 . . . 42759 3024 1 In in IN 42759 3024 2 some some DT 42759 3024 3 co co JJ 42759 3024 4 - - JJ 42759 3024 5 operative operative JJ 42759 3024 6 stores store NNS 42759 3024 7 non non NNS 42759 3024 8 - - NNS 42759 3024 9 members member NNS 42759 3024 10 receive receive VBP 42759 3024 11 a a DT 42759 3024 12 dividend dividend NN 42759 3024 13 on on IN 42759 3024 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3024 15 purchases purchase NNS 42759 3024 16 at at IN 42759 3024 17 half half PDT 42759 3024 18 the the DT 42759 3024 19 rate rate NN 42759 3024 20 accorded accord VBN 42759 3024 21 to to IN 42759 3024 22 members member NNS 42759 3024 23 of of IN 42759 3024 24 the the DT 42759 3024 25 society society NN 42759 3024 26 , , , 42759 3024 27 but but CC 42759 3024 28 only only RB 42759 3024 29 on on IN 42759 3024 30 condition condition NN 42759 3024 31 that that IN 42759 3024 32 these these DT 42759 3024 33 payments payment NNS 42759 3024 34 shall shall MD 42759 3024 35 be be VB 42759 3024 36 invested invest VBN 42759 3024 37 in in IN 42759 3024 38 the the DT 42759 3024 39 capital capital NN 42759 3024 40 stock stock NN 42759 3024 41 of of IN 42759 3024 42 the the DT 42759 3024 43 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3024 44 . . . 42759 3025 1 And and CC 42759 3025 2 the the DT 42759 3025 3 members member NNS 42759 3025 4 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 3025 5 are be VBP 42759 3025 6 strongly strongly RB 42759 3025 7 urged urge VBN 42759 3025 8 to to TO 42759 3025 9 make make VB 42759 3025 10 this this DT 42759 3025 11 disposition disposition NN 42759 3025 12 of of IN 42759 3025 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3025 14 purchase purchase NN 42759 3025 15 - - HYPH 42759 3025 16 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3025 17 . . . 42759 3026 1 Since since IN 42759 3026 2 the the DT 42759 3026 3 latter latter JJ 42759 3026 4 are be VBP 42759 3026 5 paid pay VBN 42759 3026 6 only only RB 42759 3026 7 quarterly quarterly JJ 42759 3026 8 , , , 42759 3026 9 the the DT 42759 3026 10 co co JJ 42759 3026 11 - - JJ 42759 3026 12 operative operative JJ 42759 3026 13 store store NN 42759 3026 14 exercises exercise VBZ 42759 3026 15 a a DT 42759 3026 16 considerable considerable JJ 42759 3026 17 influence influence NN 42759 3026 18 toward toward IN 42759 3026 19 inducing induce VBG 42759 3026 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3026 21 patrons patron NNS 42759 3026 22 to to TO 42759 3026 23 save save VB 42759 3026 24 and and CC 42759 3026 25 to to TO 42759 3026 26 become become VB 42759 3026 27 small small JJ 42759 3026 28 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 3026 29 . . . 42759 3027 1 In in IN 42759 3027 2 Great Great NNP 42759 3027 3 Britain Britain NNP 42759 3027 4 the the DT 42759 3027 5 vast vast JJ 42759 3027 6 majority majority NN 42759 3027 7 of of IN 42759 3027 8 the the DT 42759 3027 9 retail retail JJ 42759 3027 10 stores store NNS 42759 3027 11 have have VBP 42759 3027 12 been be VBN 42759 3027 13 federated federate VBN 42759 3027 14 into into IN 42759 3027 15 two two CD 42759 3027 16 great great JJ 42759 3027 17 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 3027 18 societies society NNS 42759 3027 19 , , , 42759 3027 20 one one CD 42759 3027 21 in in IN 42759 3027 22 England England NNP 42759 3027 23 and and CC 42759 3027 24 the the DT 42759 3027 25 other other JJ 42759 3027 26 in in IN 42759 3027 27 Scotland Scotland NNP 42759 3027 28 . . . 42759 3028 1 The the DT 42759 3028 2 retail retail JJ 42759 3028 3 stores store NNS 42759 3028 4 provide provide VBP 42759 3028 5 the the DT 42759 3028 6 capital capital NN 42759 3028 7 , , , 42759 3028 8 and and CC 42759 3028 9 participate participate VB 42759 3028 10 in in IN 42759 3028 11 the the DT 42759 3028 12 profits profit NNS 42759 3028 13 according accord VBG 42759 3028 14 to to IN 42759 3028 15 the the DT 42759 3028 16 amounts amount NNS 42759 3028 17 purchased purchase VBN 42759 3028 18 , , , 42759 3028 19 just just RB 42759 3028 20 as as IN 42759 3028 21 the the DT 42759 3028 22 individual individual JJ 42759 3028 23 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3028 24 furnish furnish VBP 42759 3028 25 the the DT 42759 3028 26 capital capital NN 42759 3028 27 and and CC 42759 3028 28 share share VB 42759 3028 29 the the DT 42759 3028 30 profits profit NNS 42759 3028 31 of of IN 42759 3028 32 the the DT 42759 3028 33 retail retail JJ 42759 3028 34 establishments establishment NNS 42759 3028 35 . . . 42759 3029 1 The the DT 42759 3029 2 Scottish Scottish NNP 42759 3029 3 Wholesale Wholesale NNP 42759 3029 4 Society Society NNP 42759 3029 5 divides divide VBZ 42759 3029 6 a a DT 42759 3029 7 part part NN 42759 3029 8 of of IN 42759 3029 9 the the DT 42759 3029 10 profits profit NNS 42759 3029 11 among among IN 42759 3029 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3029 13 employés employés NN 42759 3029 14 . . . 42759 3030 1 Besides besides IN 42759 3030 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3030 3 operations operation NNS 42759 3030 4 as as IN 42759 3030 5 jobbers jobber NNS 42759 3030 6 , , , 42759 3030 7 the the DT 42759 3030 8 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 3030 9 societies society NNS 42759 3030 10 are be VBP 42759 3030 11 bankers banker NNS 42759 3030 12 for for IN 42759 3030 13 the the DT 42759 3030 14 retail retail JJ 42759 3030 15 stores store NNS 42759 3030 16 , , , 42759 3030 17 and and CC 42759 3030 18 own own JJ 42759 3030 19 and and CC 42759 3030 20 operate operate VBP 42759 3030 21 factories factory NNS 42759 3030 22 , , , 42759 3030 23 farms farm NNS 42759 3030 24 , , , 42759 3030 25 warehouses warehouse NNS 42759 3030 26 , , , 42759 3030 27 and and CC 42759 3030 28 steamships steamship NNS 42759 3030 29 . . . 42759 3031 1 Many many JJ 42759 3031 2 of of IN 42759 3031 3 the the DT 42759 3031 4 retail retail JJ 42759 3031 5 co co NNS 42759 3031 6 - - NNS 42759 3031 7 operatives operative NNS 42759 3031 8 likewise likewise RB 42759 3031 9 carry carry VBP 42759 3031 10 on on RP 42759 3031 11 productive productive JJ 42759 3031 12 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3031 13 , , , 42759 3031 14 such such JJ 42759 3031 15 as as IN 42759 3031 16 milling milling NN 42759 3031 17 , , , 42759 3031 18 tailoring tailoring NN 42759 3031 19 , , , 42759 3031 20 bread bread NN 42759 3031 21 making making NN 42759 3031 22 , , , 42759 3031 23 and and CC 42759 3031 24 the the DT 42759 3031 25 manufacture manufacture NN 42759 3031 26 of of IN 42759 3031 27 boots boot NNS 42759 3031 28 , , , 42759 3031 29 shoes shoe NNS 42759 3031 30 , , , 42759 3031 31 and and CC 42759 3031 32 other other JJ 42759 3031 33 commodities commodity NNS 42759 3031 34 , , , 42759 3031 35 and and CC 42759 3031 36 some some DT 42759 3031 37 of of IN 42759 3031 38 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3031 39 build build VBP 42759 3031 40 , , , 42759 3031 41 sell sell VB 42759 3031 42 , , , 42759 3031 43 and and CC 42759 3031 44 rent rent NN 42759 3031 45 cottages cottage NNS 42759 3031 46 , , , 42759 3031 47 and and CC 42759 3031 48 lend lend VB 42759 3031 49 money money NN 42759 3031 50 to to IN 42759 3031 51 members member NNS 42759 3031 52 who who WP 42759 3031 53 desire desire VBP 42759 3031 54 to to TO 42759 3031 55 obtain obtain VB 42759 3031 56 homes home NNS 42759 3031 57 . . . 42759 3032 1 The the DT 42759 3032 2 co co JJ 42759 3032 3 - - JJ 42759 3032 4 operative operative JJ 42759 3032 5 store store NN 42759 3032 6 movement movement NN 42759 3032 7 has have VBZ 42759 3032 8 made make VBN 42759 3032 9 greatest great JJS 42759 3032 10 progress progress NN 42759 3032 11 in in IN 42759 3032 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3032 13 original original JJ 42759 3032 14 home home NN 42759 3032 15 , , , 42759 3032 16 Great Great NNP 42759 3032 17 Britain Britain NNP 42759 3032 18 . . . 42759 3033 1 In in IN 42759 3033 2 1913 1913 CD 42759 3033 3 about about IN 42759 3033 4 one one CD 42759 3033 5 person person NN 42759 3033 6 in in IN 42759 3033 7 every every DT 42759 3033 8 three three CD 42759 3033 9 was be VBD 42759 3033 10 to to IN 42759 3033 11 some some DT 42759 3033 12 degree degree NN 42759 3033 13 interested interested JJ 42759 3033 14 in in IN 42759 3033 15 or or CC 42759 3033 16 a a DT 42759 3033 17 beneficiary beneficiary NN 42759 3033 18 of of IN 42759 3033 19 these these DT 42759 3033 20 institutions institution NNS 42759 3033 21 . . . 42759 3034 1 The the DT 42759 3034 2 profits profit NNS 42759 3034 3 of of IN 42759 3034 4 the the DT 42759 3034 5 stores store NNS 42759 3034 6 amounted amount VBD 42759 3034 7 to to IN 42759 3034 8 about about IN 42759 3034 9 $ $ $ 42759 3034 10 71,302,070 71,302,070 CD 42759 3034 11 , , , 42759 3034 12 which which WDT 42759 3034 13 was be VBD 42759 3034 14 about about RB 42759 3034 15 35 35 CD 42759 3034 16 per per NN 42759 3034 17 cent cent NN 42759 3034 18 . . . 42759 3035 1 on on IN 42759 3035 2 the the DT 42759 3035 3 capital capital NN 42759 3035 4 . . . 42759 3036 1 The the DT 42759 3036 2 employés employés NN 42759 3036 3 numbered number VBD 42759 3036 4 about about RB 42759 3036 5 145,000 145,000 CD 42759 3036 6 , , , 42759 3036 7 and and CC 42759 3036 8 the the DT 42759 3036 9 sales sale NNS 42759 3036 10 for for IN 42759 3036 11 the the DT 42759 3036 12 year year NN 42759 3036 13 aggregated aggregate VBD 42759 3036 14 $ $ $ 42759 3036 15 650,000,000 650,000,000 CD 42759 3036 16 . . . 42759 3037 1 The the DT 42759 3037 2 English English NNP 42759 3037 3 Wholesale Wholesale NNP 42759 3037 4 Society Society NNP 42759 3037 5 was be VBD 42759 3037 6 the the DT 42759 3037 7 largest large JJS 42759 3037 8 flour flour NN 42759 3037 9 miller miller NN 42759 3037 10 and and CC 42759 3037 11 shoe shoe NN 42759 3037 12 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 3037 13 in in IN 42759 3037 14 Great Great NNP 42759 3037 15 Britain Britain NNP 42759 3037 16 , , , 42759 3037 17 and and CC 42759 3037 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3037 19 total total JJ 42759 3037 20 business business NN 42759 3037 21 amounted amount VBD 42759 3037 22 to to IN 42759 3037 23 $ $ $ 42759 3037 24 150,000,000 150,000,000 CD 42759 3037 25 . . . 42759 3038 1 Outside outside JJ 42759 3038 2 of of IN 42759 3038 3 Great Great NNP 42759 3038 4 Britain Britain NNP 42759 3038 5 , , , 42759 3038 6 co co JJ 42759 3038 7 - - JJ 42759 3038 8 operative operative JJ 42759 3038 9 distribution distribution NN 42759 3038 10 has have VBZ 42759 3038 11 been be VBN 42759 3038 12 most most RBS 42759 3038 13 successful successful JJ 42759 3038 14 in in IN 42759 3038 15 Germany Germany NNP 42759 3038 16 , , , 42759 3038 17 Belgium Belgium NNP 42759 3038 18 , , , 42759 3038 19 and and CC 42759 3038 20 Switzerland Switzerland NNP 42759 3038 21 . . . 42759 3039 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3039 2 has have VBZ 42759 3039 3 had have VBN 42759 3039 4 a a DT 42759 3039 5 fair fair JJ 42759 3039 6 measure measure NN 42759 3039 7 of of IN 42759 3039 8 development development NN 42759 3039 9 in in IN 42759 3039 10 Italy Italy NNP 42759 3039 11 , , , 42759 3039 12 but but CC 42759 3039 13 has have VBZ 42759 3039 14 failed fail VBN 42759 3039 15 to to TO 42759 3039 16 assume assume VB 42759 3039 17 any any DT 42759 3039 18 importance importance NN 42759 3039 19 in in IN 42759 3039 20 France France NNP 42759 3039 21 . . . 42759 3040 1 " " `` 42759 3040 2 There there EX 42759 3040 3 is be VBZ 42759 3040 4 every every DT 42759 3040 5 sign sign NN 42759 3040 6 that that IN 42759 3040 7 within within IN 42759 3040 8 the the DT 42759 3040 9 near near JJ 42759 3040 10 future future NN 42759 3040 11 -- -- : 42759 3040 12 except except IN 42759 3040 13 in in IN 42759 3040 14 France France NNP 42759 3040 15 -- -- : 42759 3040 16 the the DT 42759 3040 17 stores store NNS 42759 3040 18 will will MD 42759 3040 19 come come VB 42759 3040 20 to to TO 42759 3040 21 include include VB 42759 3040 22 the the DT 42759 3040 23 great great JJ 42759 3040 24 majority majority NN 42759 3040 25 of of IN 42759 3040 26 the the DT 42759 3040 27 wage wage NN 42759 3040 28 earning earning NN 42759 3040 29 class class NN 42759 3040 30 , , , 42759 3040 31 which which WDT 42759 3040 32 is be VBZ 42759 3040 33 a a DT 42759 3040 34 constantly constantly RB 42759 3040 35 growing grow VBG 42759 3040 36 percentage percentage NN 42759 3040 37 of of IN 42759 3040 38 the the DT 42759 3040 39 total total JJ 42759 3040 40 population population NN 42759 3040 41 . . . 42759 3041 1 " " `` 42759 3041 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3041 3 155 155 CD 42759 3041 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3041 5 Within within IN 42759 3041 6 recent recent JJ 42759 3041 7 years year NNS 42759 3041 8 a a DT 42759 3041 9 respectable respectable JJ 42759 3041 10 number number NN 42759 3041 11 of of IN 42759 3041 12 stores store NNS 42759 3041 13 have have VBP 42759 3041 14 been be VBN 42759 3041 15 established establish VBN 42759 3041 16 on on IN 42759 3041 17 a a DT 42759 3041 18 sound sound JJ 42759 3041 19 basis basis NN 42759 3041 20 in in IN 42759 3041 21 Canada Canada NNP 42759 3041 22 and and CC 42759 3041 23 the the DT 42759 3041 24 United United NNP 42759 3041 25 States States NNP 42759 3041 26 . . . 42759 3042 1 Owing owing NN 42759 3042 2 , , , 42759 3042 3 however however RB 42759 3042 4 , , , 42759 3042 5 to to IN 42759 3042 6 the the DT 42759 3042 7 marked marked JJ 42759 3042 8 individualism individualism NN 42759 3042 9 and and CC 42759 3042 10 the the DT 42759 3042 11 better well JJR 42759 3042 12 economic economic JJ 42759 3042 13 conditions condition NNS 42759 3042 14 of of IN 42759 3042 15 these these DT 42759 3042 16 two two CD 42759 3042 17 countries country NNS 42759 3042 18 , , , 42759 3042 19 the the DT 42759 3042 20 co co JJ 42759 3042 21 - - JJ 42759 3042 22 operative operative JJ 42759 3042 23 movement movement NN 42759 3042 24 will will MD 42759 3042 25 continue continue VB 42759 3042 26 for for IN 42759 3042 27 some some DT 42759 3042 28 time time NN 42759 3042 29 to to TO 42759 3042 30 be be VB 42759 3042 31 relatively relatively RB 42759 3042 32 slow slow JJ 42759 3042 33 . . . 42759 3043 1 As as IN 42759 3043 2 in in IN 42759 3043 3 the the DT 42759 3043 4 case case NN 42759 3043 5 of of IN 42759 3043 6 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 3043 7 co co NN 42759 3043 8 - - NN 42759 3043 9 operation operation NN 42759 3043 10 , , , 42759 3043 11 the the DT 42759 3043 12 money money NN 42759 3043 13 benefits benefit VBZ 42759 3043 14 accruing accrue VBG 42759 3043 15 to to IN 42759 3043 16 the the DT 42759 3043 17 members member NNS 42759 3043 18 of of IN 42759 3043 19 the the DT 42759 3043 20 co co JJ 42759 3043 21 - - JJ 42759 3043 22 operative operative JJ 42759 3043 23 stores store NNS 42759 3043 24 consist consist VBP 42759 3043 25 mainly mainly RB 42759 3043 26 of of IN 42759 3043 27 profits profit NNS 42759 3043 28 rather rather RB 42759 3043 29 than than IN 42759 3043 30 interest interest NN 42759 3043 31 . . . 42759 3044 1 In in IN 42759 3044 2 the the DT 42759 3044 3 absence absence NN 42759 3044 4 of of IN 42759 3044 5 the the DT 42759 3044 6 store store NN 42759 3044 7 societies society NNS 42759 3044 8 , , , 42759 3044 9 these these DT 42759 3044 10 profits profit NNS 42759 3044 11 would would MD 42759 3044 12 have have VB 42759 3044 13 gone go VBN 42759 3044 14 for for IN 42759 3044 15 the the DT 42759 3044 16 most most JJS 42759 3044 17 part part NN 42759 3044 18 to to IN 42759 3044 19 middlemen middleman NNS 42759 3044 20 as as IN 42759 3044 21 payments payment NNS 42759 3044 22 for for IN 42759 3044 23 the the DT 42759 3044 24 risks risk NNS 42759 3044 25 and and CC 42759 3044 26 labour labour NN 42759 3044 27 of of IN 42759 3044 28 conducting conduct VBG 42759 3044 29 privately privately RB 42759 3044 30 owned own VBN 42759 3044 31 establishments establishment NNS 42759 3044 32 . . . 42759 3045 1 Forty forty CD 42759 3045 2 - - HYPH 42759 3045 3 seven seven CD 42759 3045 4 of of IN 42759 3045 5 the the DT 42759 3045 6 sixty sixty CD 42759 3045 7 million million CD 42759 3045 8 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3045 9 profits profit NNS 42759 3045 10 of of IN 42759 3045 11 the the DT 42759 3045 12 British british JJ 42759 3045 13 co co JJ 42759 3045 14 - - JJ 42759 3045 15 operative operative JJ 42759 3045 16 stores store NNS 42759 3045 17 in in IN 42759 3045 18 1910 1910 CD 42759 3045 19 were be VBD 42759 3045 20 divided divide VBN 42759 3045 21 among among IN 42759 3045 22 more more JJR 42759 3045 23 than than IN 42759 3045 24 two two CD 42759 3045 25 and and CC 42759 3045 26 one one CD 42759 3045 27 - - HYPH 42759 3045 28 half half CD 42759 3045 29 million million CD 42759 3045 30 members member NNS 42759 3045 31 of of IN 42759 3045 32 these these DT 42759 3045 33 institutions institution NNS 42759 3045 34 , , , 42759 3045 35 instead instead RB 42759 3045 36 of of IN 42759 3045 37 going go VBG 42759 3045 38 to to IN 42759 3045 39 a a DT 42759 3045 40 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 3045 41 small small JJ 42759 3045 42 number number NN 42759 3045 43 of of IN 42759 3045 44 private private JJ 42759 3045 45 merchants merchant NNS 42759 3045 46 . . . 42759 3046 1 The the DT 42759 3046 2 other other JJ 42759 3046 3 thirteen thirteen CD 42759 3046 4 million million CD 42759 3046 5 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3046 6 were be VBD 42759 3046 7 interest interest NN 42759 3046 8 on on IN 42759 3046 9 the the DT 42759 3046 10 capital capital NN 42759 3046 11 stock stock NN 42759 3046 12 . . . 42759 3047 1 Had have VBD 42759 3047 2 the the DT 42759 3047 3 members member NNS 42759 3047 4 invested invest VBD 42759 3047 5 an an DT 42759 3047 6 equal equal JJ 42759 3047 7 amount amount NN 42759 3047 8 in in IN 42759 3047 9 other other JJ 42759 3047 10 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3047 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3047 12 could could MD 42759 3047 13 , , , 42759 3047 14 indeed indeed RB 42759 3047 15 , , , 42759 3047 16 have have VBP 42759 3047 17 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3047 18 about about IN 42759 3047 19 the the DT 42759 3047 20 same same JJ 42759 3047 21 rate rate NN 42759 3047 22 and and CC 42759 3047 23 amount amount NN 42759 3047 24 of of IN 42759 3047 25 interest interest NN 42759 3047 26 , , , 42759 3047 27 but but CC 42759 3047 28 in in IN 42759 3047 29 the the DT 42759 3047 30 absence absence NN 42759 3047 31 of of IN 42759 3047 32 the the DT 42759 3047 33 co co JJ 42759 3047 34 - - JJ 42759 3047 35 operative operative JJ 42759 3047 36 stores store NNS 42759 3047 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3047 38 inducements inducement NNS 42759 3047 39 and and CC 42759 3047 40 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 3047 41 to to TO 42759 3047 42 save save VB 42759 3047 43 would would MD 42759 3047 44 have have VB 42759 3047 45 been be VBN 42759 3047 46 much much RB 42759 3047 47 smaller small JJR 42759 3047 48 . . . 42759 3048 1 For for IN 42759 3048 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3048 3 must must MD 42759 3048 4 be be VB 42759 3048 5 kept keep VBN 42759 3048 6 in in IN 42759 3048 7 mind mind NN 42759 3048 8 that that IN 42759 3048 9 a a DT 42759 3048 10 very very RB 42759 3048 11 large large JJ 42759 3048 12 part part NN 42759 3048 13 of of IN 42759 3048 14 the the DT 42759 3048 15 capital capital NN 42759 3048 16 stock stock NN 42759 3048 17 in in IN 42759 3048 18 the the DT 42759 3048 19 co co JJ 42759 3048 20 - - JJ 42759 3048 21 operative operative JJ 42759 3048 22 stores store NNS 42759 3048 23 is be VBZ 42759 3048 24 derived derive VBN 42759 3048 25 from from IN 42759 3048 26 the the DT 42759 3048 27 members member NNS 42759 3048 28 ' ' POS 42759 3048 29 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3048 30 on on IN 42759 3048 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3048 32 purchases purchase NNS 42759 3048 33 at at IN 42759 3048 34 such such JJ 42759 3048 35 stores store NNS 42759 3048 36 , , , 42759 3048 37 and and CC 42759 3048 38 would would MD 42759 3048 39 not not RB 42759 3048 40 have have VB 42759 3048 41 come come VBN 42759 3048 42 into into IN 42759 3048 43 existence existence NN 42759 3048 44 at at RB 42759 3048 45 all all RB 42759 3048 46 without without IN 42759 3048 47 these these DT 42759 3048 48 establishments establishment NNS 42759 3048 49 . . . 42759 3049 1 The the DT 42759 3049 2 gains gain NNS 42759 3049 3 of of IN 42759 3049 4 the the DT 42759 3049 5 co co JJ 42759 3049 6 - - JJ 42759 3049 7 operative operative JJ 42759 3049 8 stores store NNS 42759 3049 9 , , , 42759 3049 10 whether whether IN 42759 3049 11 classified classify VBN 42759 3049 12 as as IN 42759 3049 13 profits profit NNS 42759 3049 14 or or CC 42759 3049 15 as as IN 42759 3049 16 interest interest NN 42759 3049 17 , , , 42759 3049 18 are be VBP 42759 3049 19 evidently evidently RB 42759 3049 20 a a DT 42759 3049 21 not not RB 42759 3049 22 inconsiderable inconsiderable JJ 42759 3049 23 indication indication NN 42759 3049 24 of of IN 42759 3049 25 a a DT 42759 3049 26 better well JJR 42759 3049 27 distribution distribution NN 42759 3049 28 of of IN 42759 3049 29 wealth wealth NN 42759 3049 30 . . . 42759 3050 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3050 2 Co Co NNP 42759 3050 3 - - NN 42759 3050 4 operation operation NN 42759 3050 5 in in IN 42759 3050 6 Production Production NNP 42759 3050 7 _ _ NNP 42759 3050 8 Co Co NNP 42759 3050 9 - - JJ 42759 3050 10 operative operative JJ 42759 3050 11 production production NN 42759 3050 12 has have VBZ 42759 3050 13 occasionally occasionally RB 42759 3050 14 been be VBN 42759 3050 15 pronounced pronounce VBN 42759 3050 16 a a DT 42759 3050 17 failure failure NN 42759 3050 18 . . . 42759 3051 1 This this DT 42759 3051 2 judgment judgment NN 42759 3051 3 is be VBZ 42759 3051 4 too too RB 42759 3051 5 sweeping sweeping JJ 42759 3051 6 and and CC 42759 3051 7 too too RB 42759 3051 8 severe severe JJ 42759 3051 9 . . . 42759 3052 1 " " `` 42759 3052 2 As as IN 42759 3052 3 a a DT 42759 3052 4 matter matter NN 42759 3052 5 of of IN 42759 3052 6 fact fact NN 42759 3052 7 , , , 42759 3052 8 " " '' 42759 3052 9 says say VBZ 42759 3052 10 a a DT 42759 3052 11 prominent prominent JJ 42759 3052 12 London London NNP 42759 3052 13 weekly weekly NN 42759 3052 14 , , , 42759 3052 15 " " `` 42759 3052 16 the the DT 42759 3052 17 co co NNS 42759 3052 18 - - NNS 42759 3052 19 operators operator NNS 42759 3052 20 ' ' POS 42759 3052 21 success success NN 42759 3052 22 has have VBZ 42759 3052 23 been be VBN 42759 3052 24 even even RB 42759 3052 25 more more RBR 42759 3052 26 remarkable remarkable JJ 42759 3052 27 in in IN 42759 3052 28 production production NN 42759 3052 29 than than IN 42759 3052 30 in in IN 42759 3052 31 distribution distribution NN 42759 3052 32 . . . 42759 3053 1 The the DT 42759 3053 2 co co JJ 42759 3053 3 - - JJ 42759 3053 4 operative operative JJ 42759 3053 5 movement movement NN 42759 3053 6 runs run VBZ 42759 3053 7 five five CD 42759 3053 8 of of IN 42759 3053 9 the the DT 42759 3053 10 largest large JJS 42759 3053 11 of of IN 42759 3053 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3053 13 flour flour NN 42759 3053 14 mills mill NNS 42759 3053 15 ; ; : 42759 3053 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3053 17 has have VBZ 42759 3053 18 , , , 42759 3053 19 amongst amongst IN 42759 3053 20 others other NNS 42759 3053 21 , , , 42759 3053 22 the the DT 42759 3053 23 very very RB 42759 3053 24 largest large JJS 42759 3053 25 of of IN 42759 3053 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3053 27 boot boot NN 42759 3053 28 factories factory NNS 42759 3053 29 ; ; : 42759 3053 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3053 31 makes make VBZ 42759 3053 32 cotton cotton NN 42759 3053 33 cloth cloth NN 42759 3053 34 and and CC 42759 3053 35 woollens woollen NNS 42759 3053 36 , , , 42759 3053 37 and and CC 42759 3053 38 all all DT 42759 3053 39 sorts sort NNS 42759 3053 40 of of IN 42759 3053 41 clothing clothing NN 42759 3053 42 ; ; : 42759 3053 43 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3053 44 has have VBZ 42759 3053 45 even even RB 42759 3053 46 a a DT 42759 3053 47 corset corset JJ 42759 3053 48 factory factory NN 42759 3053 49 of of IN 42759 3053 50 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3053 51 own own JJ 42759 3053 52 ; ; : 42759 3053 53 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3053 54 turns turn VBZ 42759 3053 55 out out RP 42759 3053 56 huge huge JJ 42759 3053 57 quantities quantity NNS 42759 3053 58 of of IN 42759 3053 59 soap soap NN 42759 3053 60 ; ; : 42759 3053 61 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3053 62 makes make VBZ 42759 3053 63 every every DT 42759 3053 64 article article NN 42759 3053 65 of of IN 42759 3053 66 household household NN 42759 3053 67 furniture furniture NN 42759 3053 68 ; ; : 42759 3053 69 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3053 70 produces produce VBZ 42759 3053 71 cocoa cocoa NN 42759 3053 72 and and CC 42759 3053 73 confectionery confectionery NN 42759 3053 74 ; ; : 42759 3053 75 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3053 76 grows grow VBZ 42759 3053 77 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3053 78 own own JJ 42759 3053 79 fruit fruit NN 42759 3053 80 and and CC 42759 3053 81 makes make VBZ 42759 3053 82 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3053 83 own own JJ 42759 3053 84 jams jam NNS 42759 3053 85 ; ; : 42759 3053 86 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3053 87 has have VBZ 42759 3053 88 one one CD 42759 3053 89 of of IN 42759 3053 90 the the DT 42759 3053 91 largest large JJS 42759 3053 92 tobacco tobacco NN 42759 3053 93 factories factory NNS 42759 3053 94 , , , 42759 3053 95 and and CC 42759 3053 96 so so RB 42759 3053 97 on on RB 42759 3053 98 . . . 42759 3053 99 " " '' 42759 3054 1 Obviously obviously RB 42759 3054 2 this this DT 42759 3054 3 passage passage NN 42759 3054 4 refers refer VBZ 42759 3054 5 to to IN 42759 3054 6 that that DT 42759 3054 7 kind kind NN 42759 3054 8 of of IN 42759 3054 9 productive productive JJ 42759 3054 10 co co NN 42759 3054 11 - - NN 42759 3054 12 operation operation NN 42759 3054 13 which which WDT 42759 3054 14 is be VBZ 42759 3054 15 carried carry VBN 42759 3054 16 on on RP 42759 3054 17 by by IN 42759 3054 18 the the DT 42759 3054 19 stores store NNS 42759 3054 20 , , , 42759 3054 21 not not RB 42759 3054 22 to to TO 42759 3054 23 productive productive JJ 42759 3054 24 concerns concern NNS 42759 3054 25 owned own VBN 42759 3054 26 and and CC 42759 3054 27 managed manage VBN 42759 3054 28 by by IN 42759 3054 29 the the DT 42759 3054 30 workers worker NNS 42759 3054 31 therein therein RB 42759 3054 32 employed employ VBN 42759 3054 33 . . . 42759 3055 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 3055 2 the the DT 42759 3055 3 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3055 4 in in IN 42759 3055 5 question question NN 42759 3055 6 are be VBP 42759 3055 7 co co JJ 42759 3055 8 - - JJ 42759 3055 9 operatively operatively RB 42759 3055 10 managed manage VBN 42759 3055 11 , , , 42759 3055 12 and and CC 42759 3055 13 hence hence RB 42759 3055 14 exemplify exemplify VB 42759 3055 15 co co NN 42759 3055 16 - - NN 42759 3055 17 operation operation NN 42759 3055 18 rather rather RB 42759 3055 19 than than IN 42759 3055 20 private private JJ 42759 3055 21 and and CC 42759 3055 22 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3055 23 industry industry NN 42759 3055 24 . . . 42759 3056 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3056 2 ought ought MD 42759 3056 3 not not RB 42759 3056 4 to to TO 42759 3056 5 be be VB 42759 3056 6 left leave VBN 42759 3056 7 out out IN 42759 3056 8 of of IN 42759 3056 9 any any DT 42759 3056 10 statement statement NN 42759 3056 11 of of IN 42759 3056 12 the the DT 42759 3056 13 field field NN 42759 3056 14 occupied occupy VBN 42759 3056 15 by by IN 42759 3056 16 co co JJ 42759 3056 17 - - JJ 42759 3056 18 operative operative JJ 42759 3056 19 production production NN 42759 3056 20 . . . 42759 3057 1 The the DT 42759 3057 2 limitations limitation NNS 42759 3057 3 and and CC 42759 3057 4 possibilities possibility NNS 42759 3057 5 of of IN 42759 3057 6 co co NN 42759 3057 7 - - NN 42759 3057 8 operation operation NN 42759 3057 9 in in IN 42759 3057 10 production production NN 42759 3057 11 can can MD 42759 3057 12 best best RB 42759 3057 13 be be VB 42759 3057 14 set set VBN 42759 3057 15 forth forth RP 42759 3057 16 by by IN 42759 3057 17 considering consider VBG 42759 3057 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3057 19 three three CD 42759 3057 20 different different JJ 42759 3057 21 forms form NNS 42759 3057 22 separately separately RB 42759 3057 23 . . . 42759 3058 1 The the DT 42759 3058 2 " " `` 42759 3058 3 perfect perfect JJ 42759 3058 4 " " '' 42759 3058 5 form form NN 42759 3058 6 occurs occur VBZ 42759 3058 7 when when WRB 42759 3058 8 all all PDT 42759 3058 9 the the DT 42759 3058 10 workers worker NNS 42759 3058 11 engaged engage VBN 42759 3058 12 in in IN 42759 3058 13 a a DT 42759 3058 14 concern concern NN 42759 3058 15 own own VBP 42759 3058 16 all all PDT 42759 3058 17 the the DT 42759 3058 18 share share NN 42759 3058 19 capital capital NN 42759 3058 20 , , , 42759 3058 21 control control VB 42759 3058 22 the the DT 42759 3058 23 entire entire JJ 42759 3058 24 management management NN 42759 3058 25 , , , 42759 3058 26 and and CC 42759 3058 27 receive receive VBP 42759 3058 28 the the DT 42759 3058 29 whole whole NN 42759 3058 30 of of IN 42759 3058 31 the the DT 42759 3058 32 wages wage NNS 42759 3058 33 , , , 42759 3058 34 profits profit NNS 42759 3058 35 , , , 42759 3058 36 and and CC 42759 3058 37 interest interest NN 42759 3058 38 . . . 42759 3059 1 In in IN 42759 3059 2 this this DT 42759 3059 3 field field NN 42759 3059 4 the the DT 42759 3059 5 failures failure NNS 42759 3059 6 have have VBP 42759 3059 7 been be VBN 42759 3059 8 much much RB 42759 3059 9 more more RBR 42759 3059 10 numerous numerous JJ 42759 3059 11 and and CC 42759 3059 12 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 42759 3059 13 than than IN 42759 3059 14 the the DT 42759 3059 15 successes success NNS 42759 3059 16 . . . 42759 3060 1 Godin Godin NNP 42759 3060 2 's 's POS 42759 3060 3 stove stove NN 42759 3060 4 works work VBZ 42759 3060 5 at at IN 42759 3060 6 Guise Guise NNP 42759 3060 7 , , , 42759 3060 8 France France NNP 42759 3060 9 , , , 42759 3060 10 is be VBZ 42759 3060 11 the the DT 42759 3060 12 only only JJ 42759 3060 13 important important JJ 42759 3060 14 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3060 15 of of IN 42759 3060 16 this this DT 42759 3060 17 kind kind NN 42759 3060 18 that that WDT 42759 3060 19 is be VBZ 42759 3060 20 now now RB 42759 3060 21 in in IN 42759 3060 22 existence existence NN 42759 3060 23 . . . 42759 3061 1 Great Great NNP 42759 3061 2 Britain Britain NNP 42759 3061 3 has have VBZ 42759 3061 4 several several JJ 42759 3061 5 establishments establishment NNS 42759 3061 6 in in IN 42759 3061 7 which which WDT 42759 3061 8 the the DT 42759 3061 9 workers worker NNS 42759 3061 10 own own VBP 42759 3061 11 a a DT 42759 3061 12 large large JJ 42759 3061 13 part part NN 42759 3061 14 of of IN 42759 3061 15 the the DT 42759 3061 16 capital capital NN 42759 3061 17 , , , 42759 3061 18 but but CC 42759 3061 19 apparently apparently RB 42759 3061 20 none none NN 42759 3061 21 in in IN 42759 3061 22 which which WDT 42759 3061 23 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3061 24 are be VBP 42759 3061 25 the the DT 42759 3061 26 sole sole JJ 42759 3061 27 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 3061 28 and and CC 42759 3061 29 managers manager NNS 42759 3061 30 . . . 42759 3062 1 The the DT 42759 3062 2 " " `` 42759 3062 3 labour labour JJ 42759 3062 4 societies society NNS 42759 3062 5 " " '' 42759 3062 6 of of IN 42759 3062 7 Italy Italy NNP 42759 3062 8 , , , 42759 3062 9 consisting consist VBG 42759 3062 10 mostly mostly RB 42759 3062 11 of of IN 42759 3062 12 diggers digger NNS 42759 3062 13 , , , 42759 3062 14 masons mason NNS 42759 3062 15 , , , 42759 3062 16 and and CC 42759 3062 17 bricklayers bricklayer NNS 42759 3062 18 , , , 42759 3062 19 co co VBN 42759 3062 20 - - NN 42759 3062 21 operatively operatively RB 42759 3062 22 enter enter VB 42759 3062 23 into into IN 42759 3062 24 contracts contract NNS 42759 3062 25 for for IN 42759 3062 26 the the DT 42759 3062 27 performance performance NN 42759 3062 28 of of IN 42759 3062 29 public public JJ 42759 3062 30 works work NNS 42759 3062 31 , , , 42759 3062 32 and and CC 42759 3062 33 share share VB 42759 3062 34 in in IN 42759 3062 35 the the DT 42759 3062 36 profits profit NNS 42759 3062 37 of of IN 42759 3062 38 the the DT 42759 3062 39 undertaking undertaking NN 42759 3062 40 in in IN 42759 3062 41 addition addition NN 42759 3062 42 to to IN 42759 3062 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3062 44 wages wage NNS 42759 3062 45 ; ; : 42759 3062 46 but but CC 42759 3062 47 the the DT 42759 3062 48 only only JJ 42759 3062 49 capital capital NN 42759 3062 50 that that WDT 42759 3062 51 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3062 52 provide provide VBP 42759 3062 53 consists consist VBZ 42759 3062 54 of of IN 42759 3062 55 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 3062 56 simple simple JJ 42759 3062 57 and and CC 42759 3062 58 inexpensive inexpensive JJ 42759 3062 59 tools tool NNS 42759 3062 60 . . . 42759 3063 1 The the DT 42759 3063 2 raw raw JJ 42759 3063 3 material material NN 42759 3063 4 and and CC 42759 3063 5 other other JJ 42759 3063 6 capital capital NN 42759 3063 7 is be VBZ 42759 3063 8 furnished furnish VBN 42759 3063 9 by by IN 42759 3063 10 the the DT 42759 3063 11 public public NNP 42759 3063 12 authority authority NN 42759 3063 13 which which WDT 42759 3063 14 gives give VBZ 42759 3063 15 the the DT 42759 3063 16 contract contract NN 42759 3063 17 . . . 42759 3064 1 A a DT 42759 3064 2 second second JJ 42759 3064 3 kind kind NN 42759 3064 4 of of IN 42759 3064 5 productive productive JJ 42759 3064 6 co co NN 42759 3064 7 - - NN 42759 3064 8 operation operation NN 42759 3064 9 is be VBZ 42759 3064 10 found find VBN 42759 3064 11 in in IN 42759 3064 12 the the DT 42759 3064 13 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 3064 14 known know VBN 42759 3064 15 as as IN 42759 3064 16 co co NN 42759 3064 17 - - NN 42759 3064 18 partnership partnership NN 42759 3064 19 . . . 42759 3065 1 This this DT 42759 3065 2 is be VBZ 42759 3065 3 " " `` 42759 3065 4 the the DT 42759 3065 5 system system NN 42759 3065 6 under under IN 42759 3065 7 which which WDT 42759 3065 8 , , , 42759 3065 9 in in IN 42759 3065 10 the the DT 42759 3065 11 first first JJ 42759 3065 12 place place NN 42759 3065 13 , , , 42759 3065 14 a a DT 42759 3065 15 substantial substantial JJ 42759 3065 16 and and CC 42759 3065 17 known know VBN 42759 3065 18 share share NN 42759 3065 19 of of IN 42759 3065 20 the the DT 42759 3065 21 profit profit NN 42759 3065 22 of of IN 42759 3065 23 a a DT 42759 3065 24 business business NN 42759 3065 25 belongs belong VBZ 42759 3065 26 to to IN 42759 3065 27 the the DT 42759 3065 28 workers worker NNS 42759 3065 29 in in IN 42759 3065 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3065 31 , , , 42759 3065 32 not not RB 42759 3065 33 by by IN 42759 3065 34 right right NN 42759 3065 35 of of IN 42759 3065 36 any any DT 42759 3065 37 shares share NNS 42759 3065 38 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3065 39 may may MD 42759 3065 40 hold hold VB 42759 3065 41 , , , 42759 3065 42 or or CC 42759 3065 43 any any DT 42759 3065 44 other other JJ 42759 3065 45 title title NN 42759 3065 46 , , , 42759 3065 47 but but CC 42759 3065 48 simply simply RB 42759 3065 49 by by IN 42759 3065 50 right right NN 42759 3065 51 of of IN 42759 3065 52 the the DT 42759 3065 53 labour labour NN 42759 3065 54 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3065 55 have have VBP 42759 3065 56 contributed contribute VBN 42759 3065 57 to to TO 42759 3065 58 make make VB 42759 3065 59 the the DT 42759 3065 60 profit profit NN 42759 3065 61 ; ; : 42759 3065 62 and and CC 42759 3065 63 , , , 42759 3065 64 in in IN 42759 3065 65 the the DT 42759 3065 66 second second JJ 42759 3065 67 place place NN 42759 3065 68 , , , 42759 3065 69 every every DT 42759 3065 70 worker worker NN 42759 3065 71 is be VBZ 42759 3065 72 at at IN 42759 3065 73 liberty liberty NN 42759 3065 74 to to TO 42759 3065 75 invest invest VB 42759 3065 76 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3065 77 profit profit NN 42759 3065 78 , , , 42759 3065 79 or or CC 42759 3065 80 any any DT 42759 3065 81 other other JJ 42759 3065 82 savings saving NNS 42759 3065 83 , , , 42759 3065 84 in in IN 42759 3065 85 shares share NNS 42759 3065 86 of of IN 42759 3065 87 the the DT 42759 3065 88 society society NN 42759 3065 89 or or CC 42759 3065 90 company company NN 42759 3065 91 , , , 42759 3065 92 and and CC 42759 3065 93 so so RB 42759 3065 94 become become VB 42759 3065 95 a a DT 42759 3065 96 member member NN 42759 3065 97 entitled entitle VBN 42759 3065 98 to to TO 42759 3065 99 vote vote VB 42759 3065 100 on on IN 42759 3065 101 the the DT 42759 3065 102 affairs affair NNS 42759 3065 103 of of IN 42759 3065 104 the the DT 42759 3065 105 body body NN 42759 3065 106 which which WDT 42759 3065 107 employs employ VBZ 42759 3065 108 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3065 109 . . . 42759 3066 1 " " `` 42759 3066 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3066 3 156 156 CD 42759 3066 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3066 5 So so RB 42759 3066 6 far far RB 42759 3066 7 as as IN 42759 3066 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3066 9 first first JJ 42759 3066 10 , , , 42759 3066 11 or or CC 42759 3066 12 profit profit NN 42759 3066 13 sharing sharing NN 42759 3066 14 , , , 42759 3066 15 feature feature NN 42759 3066 16 is be VBZ 42759 3066 17 concerned concern VBN 42759 3066 18 , , , 42759 3066 19 co co NN 42759 3066 20 - - NN 42759 3066 21 partnership partnership NN 42759 3066 22 is be VBZ 42759 3066 23 not not RB 42759 3066 24 genuine genuine JJ 42759 3066 25 co co NN 42759 3066 26 - - NN 42759 3066 27 operation operation NN 42759 3066 28 , , , 42759 3066 29 for for IN 42759 3066 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3066 31 includes include VBZ 42759 3066 32 neither neither DT 42759 3066 33 ownership ownership NN 42759 3066 34 of of IN 42759 3066 35 capital capital NN 42759 3066 36 nor nor CC 42759 3066 37 management management NN 42759 3066 38 of of IN 42759 3066 39 the the DT 42759 3066 40 business business NN 42759 3066 41 . . . 42759 3067 1 Co co JJ 42759 3067 2 - - JJ 42759 3067 3 operative operative JJ 42759 3067 4 action action NN 42759 3067 5 begins begin VBZ 42759 3067 6 only only RB 42759 3067 7 with with IN 42759 3067 8 the the DT 42759 3067 9 adoption adoption NN 42759 3067 10 of of IN 42759 3067 11 the the DT 42759 3067 12 second second JJ 42759 3067 13 element element NN 42759 3067 14 . . . 42759 3068 1 In in IN 42759 3068 2 most most JJS 42759 3068 3 of of IN 42759 3068 4 the the DT 42759 3068 5 existing exist VBG 42759 3068 6 co co JJ 42759 3068 7 - - JJ 42759 3068 8 partnership partnership JJ 42759 3068 9 concerns concern NNS 42759 3068 10 , , , 42759 3068 11 all all PDT 42759 3068 12 the the DT 42759 3068 13 employés employés NN 42759 3068 14 are be VBP 42759 3068 15 urged urge VBN 42759 3068 16 , , , 42759 3068 17 and and CC 42759 3068 18 many many JJ 42759 3068 19 of of IN 42759 3068 20 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3068 21 required require VBD 42759 3068 22 to to TO 42759 3068 23 invest invest VB 42759 3068 24 at at IN 42759 3068 25 least least JJS 42759 3068 26 a a DT 42759 3068 27 part part NN 42759 3068 28 of of IN 42759 3068 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3068 30 profits profit NNS 42759 3068 31 in in IN 42759 3068 32 the the DT 42759 3068 33 capital capital NN 42759 3068 34 stock stock NN 42759 3068 35 . . . 42759 3069 1 The the DT 42759 3069 2 most most RBS 42759 3069 3 notable notable JJ 42759 3069 4 and and CC 42759 3069 5 successful successful JJ 42759 3069 6 of of IN 42759 3069 7 these these DT 42759 3069 8 experiments experiment NNS 42759 3069 9 is be VBZ 42759 3069 10 that that IN 42759 3069 11 carried carry VBN 42759 3069 12 on on RP 42759 3069 13 by by IN 42759 3069 14 the the DT 42759 3069 15 South South NNP 42759 3069 16 Metropolitan Metropolitan NNP 42759 3069 17 Gas Gas NNP 42759 3069 18 Company Company NNP 42759 3069 19 of of IN 42759 3069 20 London London NNP 42759 3069 21 . . . 42759 3070 1 Practically practically RB 42759 3070 2 all all PDT 42759 3070 3 the the DT 42759 3070 4 company company NN 42759 3070 5 's 's POS 42759 3070 6 6,000 6,000 CD 42759 3070 7 employés employés NN 42759 3070 8 are be VBP 42759 3070 9 now now RB 42759 3070 10 among among IN 42759 3070 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3070 12 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3070 13 . . . 42759 3071 1 Although although IN 42759 3071 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3071 3 combined combine VBN 42759 3071 4 holdings holding NNS 42759 3071 5 are be VBP 42759 3071 6 only only RB 42759 3071 7 about about RB 42759 3071 8 one one CD 42759 3071 9 - - HYPH 42759 3071 10 twenty twenty CD 42759 3071 11 - - HYPH 42759 3071 12 eighth eighth JJ 42759 3071 13 of of IN 42759 3071 14 the the DT 42759 3071 15 total total NN 42759 3071 16 , , , 42759 3071 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3071 18 are be VBP 42759 3071 19 empowered empower VBN 42759 3071 20 to to TO 42759 3071 21 select select VB 42759 3071 22 two two CD 42759 3071 23 of of IN 42759 3071 24 the the DT 42759 3071 25 ten ten CD 42759 3071 26 members member NNS 42759 3071 27 of of IN 42759 3071 28 the the DT 42759 3071 29 board board NN 42759 3071 30 of of IN 42759 3071 31 directors director NNS 42759 3071 32 . . . 42759 3072 1 Essentially essentially RB 42759 3072 2 the the DT 42759 3072 3 same same JJ 42759 3072 4 co co JJ 42759 3072 5 - - NN 42759 3072 6 partnership partnership NN 42759 3072 7 arrangements arrangement NNS 42759 3072 8 have have VBP 42759 3072 9 been be VBN 42759 3072 10 adopted adopt VBN 42759 3072 11 by by IN 42759 3072 12 about about RB 42759 3072 13 one one CD 42759 3072 14 - - HYPH 42759 3072 15 half half NN 42759 3072 16 the the DT 42759 3072 17 privately privately RB 42759 3072 18 owned own VBN 42759 3072 19 gas gas NN 42759 3072 20 companies company NNS 42759 3072 21 of of IN 42759 3072 22 Great Great NNP 42759 3072 23 Britain Britain NNP 42759 3072 24 . . . 42759 3073 1 In in IN 42759 3073 2 none none NN 42759 3073 3 of of IN 42759 3073 4 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3073 5 , , , 42759 3073 6 however however RB 42759 3073 7 , , , 42759 3073 8 have have VBP 42759 3073 9 the the DT 42759 3073 10 workers worker NNS 42759 3073 11 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3073 12 as as IN 42759 3073 13 yet yet RB 42759 3073 14 such such PDT 42759 3073 15 a a DT 42759 3073 16 large large JJ 42759 3073 17 percentage percentage NN 42759 3073 18 of of IN 42759 3073 19 either either DT 42759 3073 20 ownership ownership NN 42759 3073 21 or or CC 42759 3073 22 control control NN 42759 3073 23 as as IN 42759 3073 24 in in IN 42759 3073 25 the the DT 42759 3073 26 South South NNP 42759 3073 27 Metropolitan Metropolitan NNP 42759 3073 28 . . . 42759 3074 1 Co co NN 42759 3074 2 - - NN 42759 3074 3 partnership partnership NN 42759 3074 4 exists exist VBZ 42759 3074 5 in in IN 42759 3074 6 several several JJ 42759 3074 7 other other JJ 42759 3074 8 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3074 9 in in IN 42759 3074 10 Great Great NNP 42759 3074 11 Britain Britain NNP 42759 3074 12 , , , 42759 3074 13 and and CC 42759 3074 14 is be VBZ 42759 3074 15 found find VBN 42759 3074 16 in in IN 42759 3074 17 a a DT 42759 3074 18 considerable considerable JJ 42759 3074 19 number number NN 42759 3074 20 of of IN 42759 3074 21 French french JJ 42759 3074 22 concerns concern NNS 42759 3074 23 . . . 42759 3075 1 There there EX 42759 3075 2 are be VBP 42759 3075 3 a a DT 42759 3075 4 few few JJ 42759 3075 5 instances instance NNS 42759 3075 6 in in IN 42759 3075 7 the the DT 42759 3075 8 United United NNP 42759 3075 9 States States NNP 42759 3075 10 , , , 42759 3075 11 the the DT 42759 3075 12 most most RBS 42759 3075 13 thoroughgoing thoroughgoing JJ 42759 3075 14 being be VBG 42759 3075 15 that that DT 42759 3075 16 of of IN 42759 3075 17 N. N. NNP 42759 3075 18 O. O. NNP 42759 3075 19 Nelson Nelson NNP 42759 3075 20 & & CC 42759 3075 21 Co. Co. NNP 42759 3075 22 at at IN 42759 3075 23 Le Le NNP 42759 3075 24 Claire Claire NNP 42759 3075 25 , , , 42759 3075 26 Ill. Illinois NNP 42759 3075 27 As as IN 42759 3075 28 already already RB 42759 3075 29 noted note VBN 42759 3075 30 , , , 42759 3075 31 the the DT 42759 3075 32 co co JJ 42759 3075 33 - - JJ 42759 3075 34 operative operative JJ 42759 3075 35 stores store NNS 42759 3075 36 exemplify exemplify VB 42759 3075 37 a a DT 42759 3075 38 third third JJ 42759 3075 39 type type NN 42759 3075 40 of of IN 42759 3075 41 co co JJ 42759 3075 42 - - JJ 42759 3075 43 operative operative JJ 42759 3075 44 production production NN 42759 3075 45 . . . 42759 3076 1 In in IN 42759 3076 2 some some DT 42759 3076 3 cases case NNS 42759 3076 4 the the DT 42759 3076 5 productive productive JJ 42759 3076 6 concern concern NN 42759 3076 7 is be VBZ 42759 3076 8 under under IN 42759 3076 9 the the DT 42759 3076 10 management management NN 42759 3076 11 of of IN 42759 3076 12 a a DT 42759 3076 13 local local JJ 42759 3076 14 retail retail JJ 42759 3076 15 establishment establishment NN 42759 3076 16 , , , 42759 3076 17 but but CC 42759 3076 18 the the DT 42759 3076 19 great great JJ 42759 3076 20 majority majority NN 42759 3076 21 of of IN 42759 3076 22 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3076 23 are be VBP 42759 3076 24 conducted conduct VBN 42759 3076 25 by by IN 42759 3076 26 the the DT 42759 3076 27 English English NNP 42759 3076 28 and and CC 42759 3076 29 Scottish Scottish NNP 42759 3076 30 Wholesale Wholesale NNP 42759 3076 31 Societies Societies NNPS 42759 3076 32 . . . 42759 3077 1 As as IN 42759 3077 2 regards regard VBZ 42759 3077 3 the the DT 42759 3077 4 employés employés NN 42759 3077 5 of of IN 42759 3077 6 these these DT 42759 3077 7 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3077 8 , , , 42759 3077 9 the the DT 42759 3077 10 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 3077 11 is be VBZ 42759 3077 12 not not RB 42759 3077 13 true true JJ 42759 3077 14 co co NN 42759 3077 15 - - NN 42759 3077 16 operation operation NN 42759 3077 17 , , , 42759 3077 18 since since IN 42759 3077 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3077 20 have have VBP 42759 3077 21 no no DT 42759 3077 22 part part NN 42759 3077 23 in in IN 42759 3077 24 the the DT 42759 3077 25 ownership ownership NN 42759 3077 26 of of IN 42759 3077 27 the the DT 42759 3077 28 capital capital NN 42759 3077 29 . . . 42759 3078 1 The the DT 42759 3078 2 Scottish Scottish NNP 42759 3078 3 Wholesale Wholesale NNP 42759 3078 4 Society Society NNP 42759 3078 5 , , , 42759 3078 6 as as IN 42759 3078 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3078 8 have have VBP 42759 3078 9 seen see VBN 42759 3078 10 , , , 42759 3078 11 permits permit VBZ 42759 3078 12 the the DT 42759 3078 13 employés employés NN 42759 3078 14 of of IN 42759 3078 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3078 16 productive productive JJ 42759 3078 17 works work NNS 42759 3078 18 to to TO 42759 3078 19 share share VB 42759 3078 20 in in IN 42759 3078 21 the the DT 42759 3078 22 profits profit NNS 42759 3078 23 thereof thereof RB 42759 3078 24 ; ; : 42759 3078 25 nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 3078 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3078 27 does do VBZ 42759 3078 28 not not RB 42759 3078 29 admit admit VB 42759 3078 30 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3078 31 as as IN 42759 3078 32 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3078 33 , , , 42759 3078 34 nor nor CC 42759 3078 35 give give VB 42759 3078 36 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3078 37 any any DT 42759 3078 38 voice voice NN 42759 3078 39 in in IN 42759 3078 40 the the DT 42759 3078 41 management management NN 42759 3078 42 . . . 42759 3079 1 In in IN 42759 3079 2 all all DT 42759 3079 3 cases case NNS 42759 3079 4 the the DT 42759 3079 5 workers worker NNS 42759 3079 6 may may MD 42759 3079 7 , , , 42759 3079 8 indeed indeed RB 42759 3079 9 , , , 42759 3079 10 become become VB 42759 3079 11 owners owner NNS 42759 3079 12 of of IN 42759 3079 13 stock stock NN 42759 3079 14 in in IN 42759 3079 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3079 16 local local JJ 42759 3079 17 retail retail JJ 42759 3079 18 stores store NNS 42759 3079 19 . . . 42759 3080 1 Since since IN 42759 3080 2 the the DT 42759 3080 3 latter latter JJ 42759 3080 4 are be VBP 42759 3080 5 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3080 6 in in IN 42759 3080 7 the the DT 42759 3080 8 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 3080 9 societies society NNS 42759 3080 10 , , , 42759 3080 11 which which WDT 42759 3080 12 in in IN 42759 3080 13 turn turn NN 42759 3080 14 own own VBP 42759 3080 15 the the DT 42759 3080 16 productive productive JJ 42759 3080 17 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3080 18 , , , 42759 3080 19 the the DT 42759 3080 20 workers worker NNS 42759 3080 21 have have VBP 42759 3080 22 a a DT 42759 3080 23 certain certain JJ 42759 3080 24 indirect indirect NN 42759 3080 25 and and CC 42759 3080 26 attenuated attenuated JJ 42759 3080 27 proprietorship proprietorship NN 42759 3080 28 in in IN 42759 3080 29 the the DT 42759 3080 30 productive productive JJ 42759 3080 31 concerns concern NNS 42759 3080 32 . . . 42759 3081 1 But but CC 42759 3081 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3081 3 derive derive VBP 42759 3081 4 therefrom therefrom JJ 42759 3081 5 no no DT 42759 3081 6 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3081 7 . . . 42759 3082 1 All all PDT 42759 3082 2 the the DT 42759 3082 3 interest interest NN 42759 3082 4 and and CC 42759 3082 5 most most JJS 42759 3082 6 of of IN 42759 3082 7 the the DT 42759 3082 8 profits profit NNS 42759 3082 9 of of IN 42759 3082 10 the the DT 42759 3082 11 productive productive JJ 42759 3082 12 establishments establishment NNS 42759 3082 13 are be VBP 42759 3082 14 taken take VBN 42759 3082 15 by by IN 42759 3082 16 the the DT 42759 3082 17 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 3082 18 and and CC 42759 3082 19 retail retail JJ 42759 3082 20 stores store NNS 42759 3082 21 . . . 42759 3083 1 For for IN 42759 3083 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3083 3 is be VBZ 42759 3083 4 the the DT 42759 3083 5 theory theory NN 42759 3083 6 of of IN 42759 3083 7 the the DT 42759 3083 8 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 3083 9 societies society NNS 42759 3083 10 that that WDT 42759 3083 11 the the DT 42759 3083 12 employés employés NN 42759 3083 13 in in IN 42759 3083 14 the the DT 42759 3083 15 works work NNS 42759 3083 16 of of IN 42759 3083 17 production production NN 42759 3083 18 should should MD 42759 3083 19 share share VB 42759 3083 20 in in IN 42759 3083 21 the the DT 42759 3083 22 gains gain NNS 42759 3083 23 thereof thereof RB 42759 3083 24 only only RB 42759 3083 25 as as IN 42759 3083 26 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3083 27 . . . 42759 3084 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3084 2 are be VBP 42759 3084 3 to to TO 42759 3084 4 profit profit VB 42759 3084 5 only only RB 42759 3084 6 in in IN 42759 3084 7 the the DT 42759 3084 8 same same JJ 42759 3084 9 way way NN 42759 3084 10 and and CC 42759 3084 11 to to IN 42759 3084 12 the the DT 42759 3084 13 same same JJ 42759 3084 14 extent extent NN 42759 3084 15 as as IN 42759 3084 16 other other JJ 42759 3084 17 consumer consumer NN 42759 3084 18 - - HYPH 42759 3084 19 members member NNS 42759 3084 20 of of IN 42759 3084 21 the the DT 42759 3084 22 local local JJ 42759 3084 23 retail retail JJ 42759 3084 24 establishments establishment NNS 42759 3084 25 . . . 42759 3085 1 The the DT 42759 3085 2 most most RBS 42759 3085 3 effective effective JJ 42759 3085 4 and and CC 42759 3085 5 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 3085 6 form form NN 42759 3085 7 of of IN 42759 3085 8 co co JJ 42759 3085 9 - - JJ 42759 3085 10 operative operative JJ 42759 3085 11 production production NN 42759 3085 12 is be VBZ 42759 3085 13 evidently evidently RB 42759 3085 14 that that IN 42759 3085 15 which which WDT 42759 3085 16 has have VBZ 42759 3085 17 been be VBN 42759 3085 18 described describe VBN 42759 3085 19 as as IN 42759 3085 20 the the DT 42759 3085 21 " " `` 42759 3085 22 perfect perfect JJ 42759 3085 23 " " '' 42759 3085 24 type type NN 42759 3085 25 . . . 42759 3086 1 Were be VBD 42759 3086 2 all all DT 42759 3086 3 production production NN 42759 3086 4 organised organise VBN 42759 3086 5 on on IN 42759 3086 6 this this DT 42759 3086 7 plan plan NN 42759 3086 8 , , , 42759 3086 9 the the DT 42759 3086 10 social social JJ 42759 3086 11 burden burden NN 42759 3086 12 of of IN 42759 3086 13 interest interest NN 42759 3086 14 would would MD 42759 3086 15 be be VB 42759 3086 16 insignificant insignificant JJ 42759 3086 17 , , , 42759 3086 18 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3086 19 despotism despotism NN 42759 3086 20 would would MD 42759 3086 21 be be VB 42759 3086 22 ended end VBN 42759 3086 23 , , , 42759 3086 24 and and CC 42759 3086 25 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3086 26 democracy democracy NN 42759 3086 27 realised realise VBD 42759 3086 28 . . . 42759 3087 1 As as IN 42759 3087 2 things thing NNS 42759 3087 3 are be VBP 42759 3087 4 , , , 42759 3087 5 however however RB 42759 3087 6 , , , 42759 3087 7 the the DT 42759 3087 8 establishments establishment NNS 42759 3087 9 exemplifying exemplify VBG 42759 3087 10 this this DT 42759 3087 11 type type NN 42759 3087 12 are be VBP 42759 3087 13 of of IN 42759 3087 14 small small JJ 42759 3087 15 importance importance NN 42759 3087 16 . . . 42759 3088 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3088 2 increase increase NN 42759 3088 3 and and CC 42759 3088 4 expansion expansion NN 42759 3088 5 are be VBP 42759 3088 6 impeded impede VBN 42759 3088 7 by by IN 42759 3088 8 lack lack NN 42759 3088 9 of of IN 42759 3088 10 directive directive JJ 42759 3088 11 ability ability NN 42759 3088 12 and and CC 42759 3088 13 of of IN 42759 3088 14 capital capital NN 42759 3088 15 , , , 42759 3088 16 and and CC 42759 3088 17 the the DT 42759 3088 18 risk risk NN 42759 3088 19 to to IN 42759 3088 20 the the DT 42759 3088 21 workers worker NNS 42759 3088 22 ' ' POS 42759 3088 23 savings saving NNS 42759 3088 24 . . . 42759 3089 1 Yet yet RB 42759 3089 2 none none NN 42759 3089 3 of of IN 42759 3089 4 these these DT 42759 3089 5 obstacles obstacle NNS 42759 3089 6 is be VBZ 42759 3089 7 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 3089 8 insuperable insuperable JJ 42759 3089 9 . . . 42759 3090 1 Directive directive JJ 42759 3090 2 ability ability NN 42759 3090 3 can can MD 42759 3090 4 be be VB 42759 3090 5 developed develop VBN 42759 3090 6 in in IN 42759 3090 7 the the DT 42759 3090 8 course course NN 42759 3090 9 of of IN 42759 3090 10 time time NN 42759 3090 11 , , , 42759 3090 12 just just RB 42759 3090 13 as as IN 42759 3090 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3090 15 was be VBD 42759 3090 16 in in IN 42759 3090 17 the the DT 42759 3090 18 co co JJ 42759 3090 19 - - JJ 42759 3090 20 operative operative JJ 42759 3090 21 stores store NNS 42759 3090 22 . . . 42759 3091 1 Capital capital NN 42759 3091 2 can can MD 42759 3091 3 be be VB 42759 3091 4 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3091 5 fast fast RB 42759 3091 6 enough enough RB 42759 3091 7 perhaps perhaps RB 42759 3091 8 to to TO 42759 3091 9 keep keep VB 42759 3091 10 pace pace NN 42759 3091 11 with with IN 42759 3091 12 the the DT 42759 3091 13 supply supply NN 42759 3091 14 of of IN 42759 3091 15 directive directive NN 42759 3091 16 ability ability NN 42759 3091 17 and and CC 42759 3091 18 the the DT 42759 3091 19 spirit spirit NN 42759 3091 20 of of IN 42759 3091 21 co co NN 42759 3091 22 - - NN 42759 3091 23 operation operation NN 42759 3091 24 . . . 42759 3092 1 The the DT 42759 3092 2 risk risk NN 42759 3092 3 undertaken undertake VBN 42759 3092 4 by by IN 42759 3092 5 workers worker NNS 42759 3092 6 who who WP 42759 3092 7 put put VBP 42759 3092 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3092 9 savings saving NNS 42759 3092 10 into into IN 42759 3092 11 productive productive JJ 42759 3092 12 concerns concern NNS 42759 3092 13 owned own VBN 42759 3092 14 and and CC 42759 3092 15 managed manage VBN 42759 3092 16 by by IN 42759 3092 17 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 3092 18 need nee MD 42759 3092 19 not not RB 42759 3092 20 be be VB 42759 3092 21 greater great JJR 42759 3092 22 than than IN 42759 3092 23 that that DT 42759 3092 24 now now RB 42759 3092 25 borne bear VBN 42759 3092 26 by by IN 42759 3092 27 investors investor NNS 42759 3092 28 in in IN 42759 3092 29 private private JJ 42759 3092 30 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3092 31 of of IN 42759 3092 32 the the DT 42759 3092 33 same same JJ 42759 3092 34 kind kind NN 42759 3092 35 . . . 42759 3093 1 There there EX 42759 3093 2 is be VBZ 42759 3093 3 no no DT 42759 3093 4 essential essential JJ 42759 3093 5 reason reason NN 42759 3093 6 why why WRB 42759 3093 7 the the DT 42759 3093 8 former former JJ 42759 3093 9 should should MD 42759 3093 10 not not RB 42759 3093 11 provide provide VB 42759 3093 12 the the DT 42759 3093 13 same same JJ 42759 3093 14 profits profit NNS 42759 3093 15 and and CC 42759 3093 16 insurance insurance NN 42759 3093 17 against against IN 42759 3093 18 business business NN 42759 3093 19 risks risk NNS 42759 3093 20 as as IN 42759 3093 21 the the DT 42759 3093 22 latter latter JJ 42759 3093 23 . . . 42759 3094 1 While while IN 42759 3094 2 the the DT 42759 3094 3 employés employés NN 42759 3094 4 assume assume VBP 42759 3094 5 none none NN 42759 3094 6 of of IN 42759 3094 7 the the DT 42759 3094 8 risks risk NNS 42759 3094 9 of of IN 42759 3094 10 capitalistic capitalistic JJ 42759 3094 11 industry industry NN 42759 3094 12 , , , 42759 3094 13 neither neither CC 42759 3094 14 do do VBP 42759 3094 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3094 16 receive receive VB 42759 3094 17 any any DT 42759 3094 18 of of IN 42759 3094 19 the the DT 42759 3094 20 profits profit NNS 42759 3094 21 . . . 42759 3095 1 If if IN 42759 3095 2 the the DT 42759 3095 3 co co JJ 42759 3095 4 - - JJ 42759 3095 5 operative operative JJ 42759 3095 6 factory factory NN 42759 3095 7 exhibits exhibit VBZ 42759 3095 8 the the DT 42759 3095 9 same same JJ 42759 3095 10 degree degree NN 42759 3095 11 of of IN 42759 3095 12 business business NN 42759 3095 13 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3095 14 as as IN 42759 3095 15 the the DT 42759 3095 16 private private JJ 42759 3095 17 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3095 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3095 19 will will MD 42759 3095 20 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 3095 21 afford afford VB 42759 3095 22 the the DT 42759 3095 23 workers worker NNS 42759 3095 24 adequate adequate VB 42759 3095 25 protection protection NN 42759 3095 26 for for IN 42759 3095 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3095 28 savings saving NNS 42759 3095 29 and and CC 42759 3095 30 capital capital NN 42759 3095 31 . . . 42759 3096 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 3096 2 , , , 42759 3096 3 if if IN 42759 3096 4 " " `` 42759 3096 5 perfect perfect JJ 42759 3096 6 " " '' 42759 3096 7 co co JJ 42759 3096 8 - - JJ 42759 3096 9 operative operative JJ 42759 3096 10 production production NN 42759 3096 11 is be VBZ 42759 3096 12 to to TO 42759 3096 13 be be VB 42759 3096 14 successful successful JJ 42759 3096 15 at at IN 42759 3096 16 all all PDT 42759 3096 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3096 18 profits profit NNS 42759 3096 19 will will MD 42759 3096 20 be be VB 42759 3096 21 larger large JJR 42759 3096 22 than than IN 42759 3096 23 those those DT 42759 3096 24 of of IN 42759 3096 25 the the DT 42759 3096 26 capitalistic capitalistic JJ 42759 3096 27 concern concern NN 42759 3096 28 , , , 42759 3096 29 owing owe VBG 42759 3096 30 to to IN 42759 3096 31 the the DT 42759 3096 32 greater great JJR 42759 3096 33 interest interest NN 42759 3096 34 taken take VBN 42759 3096 35 by by IN 42759 3096 36 the the DT 42759 3096 37 workers worker NNS 42759 3096 38 in in IN 42759 3096 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3096 40 tasks task NNS 42759 3096 41 , , , 42759 3096 42 and and CC 42759 3096 43 in in IN 42759 3096 44 the the DT 42759 3096 45 management management NN 42759 3096 46 of of IN 42759 3096 47 the the DT 42759 3096 48 business business NN 42759 3096 49 . . . 42759 3097 1 For for IN 42759 3097 2 a a DT 42759 3097 3 long long JJ 42759 3097 4 time time NN 42759 3097 5 to to TO 42759 3097 6 come come VB 42759 3097 7 , , , 42759 3097 8 however however RB 42759 3097 9 , , , 42759 3097 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3097 11 is be VBZ 42759 3097 12 probable probable JJ 42759 3097 13 that that IN 42759 3097 14 " " `` 42759 3097 15 perfect perfect JJ 42759 3097 16 " " '' 42759 3097 17 co co JJ 42759 3097 18 - - JJ 42759 3097 19 operative operative JJ 42759 3097 20 production production NN 42759 3097 21 will will MD 42759 3097 22 be be VB 42759 3097 23 confined confine VBN 42759 3097 24 to to IN 42759 3097 25 relatively relatively RB 42759 3097 26 small small JJ 42759 3097 27 and and CC 42759 3097 28 local local JJ 42759 3097 29 industries industry NNS 42759 3097 30 . . . 42759 3098 1 The the DT 42759 3098 2 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 3098 3 of of IN 42759 3098 4 finding find VBG 42759 3098 5 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3098 6 workers worker NNS 42759 3098 7 ' ' POS 42759 3098 8 capital capital NN 42759 3098 9 and and CC 42759 3098 10 ability ability NN 42759 3098 11 to to TO 42759 3098 12 carry carry VB 42759 3098 13 on on RP 42759 3098 14 , , , 42759 3098 15 for for IN 42759 3098 16 example example NN 42759 3098 17 , , , 42759 3098 18 a a DT 42759 3098 19 transcontinental transcontinental JJ 42759 3098 20 railroad railroad NN 42759 3098 21 or or CC 42759 3098 22 a a DT 42759 3098 23 nationwide nationwide JJ 42759 3098 24 steel steel NN 42759 3098 25 business business NN 42759 3098 26 , , , 42759 3098 27 is be VBZ 42759 3098 28 not not RB 42759 3098 29 likely likely JJ 42759 3098 30 to to TO 42759 3098 31 be be VB 42759 3098 32 overcome overcome VBN 42759 3098 33 for for IN 42759 3098 34 one one CD 42759 3098 35 or or CC 42759 3098 36 two two CD 42759 3098 37 generations generation NNS 42759 3098 38 . . . 42759 3099 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3099 2 157 157 CD 42759 3099 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3099 4 The the DT 42759 3099 5 labour labour NN 42759 3099 6 co co NN 42759 3099 7 - - JJ 42759 3099 8 partnership partnership JJ 42759 3099 9 form form NN 42759 3099 10 of of IN 42759 3099 11 co co NN 42759 3099 12 - - NN 42759 3099 13 operation operation NN 42759 3099 14 is be VBZ 42759 3099 15 susceptible susceptible JJ 42759 3099 16 of of IN 42759 3099 17 much much RB 42759 3099 18 wider wide JJR 42759 3099 19 and and CC 42759 3099 20 more more RBR 42759 3099 21 rapid rapid JJ 42759 3099 22 extension extension NN 42759 3099 23 . . . 42759 3100 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3100 2 can can MD 42759 3100 3 be be VB 42759 3100 4 adapted adapt VBN 42759 3100 5 readily readily RB 42759 3100 6 to to IN 42759 3100 7 the the DT 42759 3100 8 very very RB 42759 3100 9 large large JJ 42759 3100 10 as as RB 42759 3100 11 well well RB 42759 3100 12 as as IN 42759 3100 13 to to IN 42759 3100 14 the the DT 42759 3100 15 small small JJ 42759 3100 16 and and CC 42759 3100 17 medium medium JJ 42759 3100 18 sized sized JJ 42759 3100 19 concerns concern NNS 42759 3100 20 . . . 42759 3101 1 Since since IN 42759 3101 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3101 3 requires require VBZ 42759 3101 4 the the DT 42759 3101 5 workers worker NNS 42759 3101 6 to to TO 42759 3101 7 own own VB 42759 3101 8 but but CC 42759 3101 9 a a DT 42759 3101 10 part part NN 42759 3101 11 of of IN 42759 3101 12 the the DT 42759 3101 13 capital capital NN 42759 3101 14 , , , 42759 3101 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3101 16 can can MD 42759 3101 17 be be VB 42759 3101 18 established establish VBN 42759 3101 19 in in IN 42759 3101 20 any any DT 42759 3101 21 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3101 22 in in IN 42759 3101 23 which which WDT 42759 3101 24 the the DT 42759 3101 25 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 3101 26 show show VBP 42759 3101 27 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 3101 28 willing willing JJ 42759 3101 29 and and CC 42759 3101 30 sympathetic sympathetic JJ 42759 3101 31 . . . 42759 3102 1 In in IN 42759 3102 2 every every DT 42759 3102 3 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3102 4 corporation corporation NN 42759 3102 5 there there EX 42759 3102 6 are be VBP 42759 3102 7 some some DT 42759 3102 8 employés employés NN 42759 3102 9 who who WP 42759 3102 10 possess possess VBP 42759 3102 11 savings saving NNS 42759 3102 12 , , , 42759 3102 13 and and CC 42759 3102 14 these these DT 42759 3102 15 can can MD 42759 3102 16 be be VB 42759 3102 17 considerably considerably RB 42759 3102 18 increased increase VBN 42759 3102 19 through through IN 42759 3102 20 the the DT 42759 3102 21 profit profit NN 42759 3102 22 sharing share VBG 42759 3102 23 feature feature NN 42759 3102 24 of of IN 42759 3102 25 co co NN 42759 3102 26 - - NN 42759 3102 27 partnership partnership NN 42759 3102 28 . . . 42759 3103 1 A a DT 42759 3103 2 very very RB 42759 3103 3 long long JJ 42759 3103 4 time time NN 42759 3103 5 must must MD 42759 3103 6 , , , 42759 3103 7 indeed indeed RB 42759 3103 8 , , , 42759 3103 9 elapse elapse VBN 42759 3103 10 before before IN 42759 3103 11 the the DT 42759 3103 12 workers worker NNS 42759 3103 13 in in IN 42759 3103 14 any any DT 42759 3103 15 of of IN 42759 3103 16 the the DT 42759 3103 17 larger large JJR 42759 3103 18 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3103 19 could could MD 42759 3103 20 get get VB 42759 3103 21 possession possession NN 42759 3103 22 of of IN 42759 3103 23 all all DT 42759 3103 24 , , , 42759 3103 25 or or CC 42759 3103 26 even even RB 42759 3103 27 of of IN 42759 3103 28 a a DT 42759 3103 29 controlling control VBG 42759 3103 30 share share NN 42759 3103 31 of of IN 42759 3103 32 the the DT 42759 3103 33 capital capital NN 42759 3103 34 , , , 42759 3103 35 and and CC 42759 3103 36 a a DT 42759 3103 37 considerable considerable JJ 42759 3103 38 time time NN 42759 3103 39 would would MD 42759 3103 40 be be VB 42759 3103 41 needed need VBN 42759 3103 42 to to TO 42759 3103 43 educate educate VB 42759 3103 44 and and CC 42759 3103 45 fit fit VB 42759 3103 46 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3103 47 for for IN 42759 3103 48 successful successful JJ 42759 3103 49 management management NN 42759 3103 50 . . . 42759 3104 1 Production production NN 42759 3104 2 under under IN 42759 3104 3 the the DT 42759 3104 4 direction direction NN 42759 3104 5 of of IN 42759 3104 6 the the DT 42759 3104 7 co co JJ 42759 3104 8 - - JJ 42759 3104 9 operative operative JJ 42759 3104 10 stores store NNS 42759 3104 11 can can MD 42759 3104 12 be be VB 42759 3104 13 extended extend VBN 42759 3104 14 faster fast RBR 42759 3104 15 than than IN 42759 3104 16 either either DT 42759 3104 17 of of IN 42759 3104 18 the the DT 42759 3104 19 other other JJ 42759 3104 20 two two CD 42759 3104 21 forms form NNS 42759 3104 22 , , , 42759 3104 23 and and CC 42759 3104 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3104 25 has have VBZ 42759 3104 26 before before IN 42759 3104 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3104 28 a a DT 42759 3104 29 very very RB 42759 3104 30 wide wide JJ 42759 3104 31 even even RB 42759 3104 32 though though IN 42759 3104 33 definitely definitely RB 42759 3104 34 limited limited JJ 42759 3104 35 field field NN 42759 3104 36 . . . 42759 3105 1 The the DT 42759 3105 2 British british JJ 42759 3105 3 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 3105 4 societies society NNS 42759 3105 5 have have VBP 42759 3105 6 already already RB 42759 3105 7 shown show VBN 42759 3105 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 3105 9 able able JJ 42759 3105 10 to to TO 42759 3105 11 conduct conduct VB 42759 3105 12 with with IN 42759 3105 13 great great JJ 42759 3105 14 success success NN 42759 3105 15 large large JJ 42759 3105 16 manufacturing manufacturing NN 42759 3105 17 concerns concern NNS 42759 3105 18 , , , 42759 3105 19 have have VBP 42759 3105 20 trained train VBN 42759 3105 21 and and CC 42759 3105 22 attracted attract VBD 42759 3105 23 an an DT 42759 3105 24 adequate adequate JJ 42759 3105 25 number number NN 42759 3105 26 of of IN 42759 3105 27 competent competent JJ 42759 3105 28 leaders leader NNS 42759 3105 29 , , , 42759 3105 30 and and CC 42759 3105 31 have have VBP 42759 3105 32 accumulated accumulate VBN 42759 3105 33 so so RB 42759 3105 34 much much JJ 42759 3105 35 capital capital NN 42759 3105 36 that that WDT 42759 3105 37 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3105 38 have have VBP 42759 3105 39 been be VBN 42759 3105 40 obliged oblige VBN 42759 3105 41 to to TO 42759 3105 42 invest invest VB 42759 3105 43 several several JJ 42759 3105 44 million million CD 42759 3105 45 pounds pound NNS 42759 3105 46 in in IN 42759 3105 47 other other JJ 42759 3105 48 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3105 49 . . . 42759 3106 1 The the DT 42759 3106 2 possible possible JJ 42759 3106 3 scope scope NN 42759 3106 4 of of IN 42759 3106 5 the the DT 42759 3106 6 stores store NNS 42759 3106 7 and and CC 42759 3106 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3106 9 co co JJ 42759 3106 10 - - JJ 42759 3106 11 operative operative JJ 42759 3106 12 production production NN 42759 3106 13 has have VBZ 42759 3106 14 been be VBN 42759 3106 15 well well RB 42759 3106 16 described describe VBN 42759 3106 17 by by IN 42759 3106 18 C. C. NNP 42759 3106 19 R. R. NNP 42759 3106 20 Fay Fay NNP 42759 3106 21 : : : 42759 3106 22 " " `` 42759 3106 23 distribution distribution NN 42759 3106 24 of of IN 42759 3106 25 goods good NNS 42759 3106 26 for for IN 42759 3106 27 personal personal JJ 42759 3106 28 consumption consumption NN 42759 3106 29 , , , 42759 3106 30 first first RB 42759 3106 31 , , , 42759 3106 32 among among IN 42759 3106 33 the the DT 42759 3106 34 working work VBG 42759 3106 35 class class NN 42759 3106 36 population population NN 42759 3106 37 , , , 42759 3106 38 secondly secondly RB 42759 3106 39 , , , 42759 3106 40 among among IN 42759 3106 41 the the DT 42759 3106 42 salaried salary VBN 42759 3106 43 classes class NNS 42759 3106 44 who who WP 42759 3106 45 feel feel VBP 42759 3106 46 a a DT 42759 3106 47 homogeneity homogeneity NN 42759 3106 48 of of IN 42759 3106 49 professional professional JJ 42759 3106 50 interest interest NN 42759 3106 51 ; ; , 42759 3106 52 production production NN 42759 3106 53 by by IN 42759 3106 54 working work VBG 42759 3106 55 class class NN 42759 3106 56 organisations organisation NNS 42759 3106 57 alone alone RB 42759 3106 58 ( ( -LRB- 42759 3106 59 with with IN 42759 3106 60 rare rare JJ 42759 3106 61 exceptions exception NNS 42759 3106 62 in in IN 42759 3106 63 Italy Italy NNP 42759 3106 64 ) ) -RRB- 42759 3106 65 of of IN 42759 3106 66 all all PDT 42759 3106 67 the the DT 42759 3106 68 goods good NNS 42759 3106 69 which which WDT 42759 3106 70 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3106 71 distribute distribute VBP 42759 3106 72 to to IN 42759 3106 73 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3106 74 members member NNS 42759 3106 75 . . . 42759 3107 1 But but CC 42759 3107 2 this this DT 42759 3107 3 is be VBZ 42759 3107 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3107 5 limit limit NN 42759 3107 6 . . . 42759 3108 1 Distribution distribution NN 42759 3108 2 among among IN 42759 3108 3 the the DT 42759 3108 4 remaining remain VBG 42759 3108 5 sections section NNS 42759 3108 6 of of IN 42759 3108 7 the the DT 42759 3108 8 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3108 9 population population NN 42759 3108 10 ; ; , 42759 3108 11 production production NN 42759 3108 12 for for IN 42759 3108 13 distribution distribution NN 42759 3108 14 to to IN 42759 3108 15 these these DT 42759 3108 16 members member NNS 42759 3108 17 ; ; : 42759 3108 18 production production NN 42759 3108 19 of of IN 42759 3108 20 the the DT 42759 3108 21 instruments instrument NNS 42759 3108 22 of of IN 42759 3108 23 production production NN 42759 3108 24 , , , 42759 3108 25 and and CC 42759 3108 26 production production NN 42759 3108 27 for for IN 42759 3108 28 international international JJ 42759 3108 29 trade trade NN 42759 3108 30 ; ; : 42759 3108 31 the the DT 42759 3108 32 services service NNS 42759 3108 33 of of IN 42759 3108 34 transport transport NN 42759 3108 35 and and CC 42759 3108 36 exchange exchange NN 42759 3108 37 : : : 42759 3108 38 all all PDT 42759 3108 39 these these DT 42759 3108 40 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3108 41 departments department NNS 42759 3108 42 are be VBP 42759 3108 43 , , , 42759 3108 44 so so RB 42759 3108 45 far far RB 42759 3108 46 as as IN 42759 3108 47 can can MD 42759 3108 48 be be VB 42759 3108 49 seen see VBN 42759 3108 50 , , , 42759 3108 51 permanently permanently RB 42759 3108 52 outside outside IN 42759 3108 53 the the DT 42759 3108 54 domain domain NN 42759 3108 55 of of IN 42759 3108 56 a a DT 42759 3108 57 store store NN 42759 3108 58 movement movement NN 42759 3108 59 . . . 42759 3109 1 " " `` 42759 3109 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3109 3 158 158 CD 42759 3109 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3109 5 The the DT 42759 3109 6 theory theory NN 42759 3109 7 by by IN 42759 3109 8 which which WDT 42759 3109 9 the the DT 42759 3109 10 stores store NNS 42759 3109 11 attempt attempt VBP 42759 3109 12 to to TO 42759 3109 13 justify justify VB 42759 3109 14 the the DT 42759 3109 15 exclusion exclusion NN 42759 3109 16 of of IN 42759 3109 17 the the DT 42759 3109 18 employés employés NN 42759 3109 19 of of IN 42759 3109 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3109 21 productive productive JJ 42759 3109 22 concerns concern NNS 42759 3109 23 from from IN 42759 3109 24 a a DT 42759 3109 25 share share NN 42759 3109 26 of of IN 42759 3109 27 the the DT 42759 3109 28 profits profit NNS 42759 3109 29 thereof thereof RB 42759 3109 30 is be VBZ 42759 3109 31 that that IN 42759 3109 32 all all DT 42759 3109 33 profits profit NNS 42759 3109 34 come come VBP 42759 3109 35 ultimately ultimately RB 42759 3109 36 from from IN 42759 3109 37 the the DT 42759 3109 38 pockets pocket NNS 42759 3109 39 of of IN 42759 3109 40 the the DT 42759 3109 41 consumer consumer NN 42759 3109 42 , , , 42759 3109 43 and and CC 42759 3109 44 should should MD 42759 3109 45 all all DT 42759 3109 46 return return VB 42759 3109 47 to to IN 42759 3109 48 that that DT 42759 3109 49 source source NN 42759 3109 50 . . . 42759 3110 1 The the DT 42759 3110 2 defect defect NN 42759 3110 3 in in IN 42759 3110 4 this this DT 42759 3110 5 theory theory NN 42759 3110 6 is be VBZ 42759 3110 7 that that IN 42759 3110 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3110 9 ignores ignore VBZ 42759 3110 10 the the DT 42759 3110 11 question question NN 42759 3110 12 whether whether IN 42759 3110 13 the the DT 42759 3110 14 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3110 15 ought ought MD 42759 3110 16 not not RB 42759 3110 17 to to TO 42759 3110 18 be be VB 42759 3110 19 required require VBN 42759 3110 20 to to TO 42759 3110 21 pay pay VB 42759 3110 22 a a DT 42759 3110 23 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3110 24 high high JJ 42759 3110 25 price price NN 42759 3110 26 for for IN 42759 3110 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3110 28 goods good NNS 42759 3110 29 to to TO 42759 3110 30 provide provide VB 42759 3110 31 the the DT 42759 3110 32 producers producer NNS 42759 3110 33 with with IN 42759 3110 34 profits profit NNS 42759 3110 35 in in IN 42759 3110 36 addition addition NN 42759 3110 37 to to IN 42759 3110 38 wages wage NNS 42759 3110 39 . . . 42759 3111 1 While while IN 42759 3111 2 the the DT 42759 3111 3 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 3111 4 stores store NNS 42759 3111 5 are be VBP 42759 3111 6 the the DT 42759 3111 7 owners owner NNS 42759 3111 8 and and CC 42759 3111 9 managers manager NNS 42759 3111 10 of of IN 42759 3111 11 the the DT 42759 3111 12 capital capital NN 42759 3111 13 in in IN 42759 3111 14 the the DT 42759 3111 15 productive productive JJ 42759 3111 16 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3111 17 , , , 42759 3111 18 and and CC 42759 3111 19 on on IN 42759 3111 20 the the DT 42759 3111 21 capitalistic capitalistic JJ 42759 3111 22 principle principle NN 42759 3111 23 should should MD 42759 3111 24 obtain obtain VB 42759 3111 25 the the DT 42759 3111 26 profits profit NNS 42759 3111 27 , , , 42759 3111 28 the the DT 42759 3111 29 question question NN 42759 3111 30 remains remain VBZ 42759 3111 31 whether whether IN 42759 3111 32 this this DT 42759 3111 33 is be VBZ 42759 3111 34 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 3111 35 a a DT 42759 3111 36 sound sound JJ 42759 3111 37 principle principle NN 42759 3111 38 , , , 42759 3111 39 and and CC 42759 3111 40 whether whether IN 42759 3111 41 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3111 42 is be VBZ 42759 3111 43 in in IN 42759 3111 44 harmony harmony NN 42759 3111 45 with with IN 42759 3111 46 the the DT 42759 3111 47 theory theory NN 42759 3111 48 and and CC 42759 3111 49 ideals ideal NNS 42759 3111 50 of of IN 42759 3111 51 co co NN 42759 3111 52 - - NN 42759 3111 53 operation operation NN 42759 3111 54 . . . 42759 3112 1 In in IN 42759 3112 2 those those DT 42759 3112 3 concerns concern NNS 42759 3112 4 which which WDT 42759 3112 5 have have VBP 42759 3112 6 adopted adopt VBN 42759 3112 7 the the DT 42759 3112 8 labour labour NN 42759 3112 9 co co NN 42759 3112 10 - - NN 42759 3112 11 partnership partnership NN 42759 3112 12 scheme scheme NN 42759 3112 13 , , , 42759 3112 14 the the DT 42759 3112 15 workers worker NNS 42759 3112 16 , , , 42759 3112 17 even even RB 42759 3112 18 when when WRB 42759 3112 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3112 20 own own VBP 42759 3112 21 none none NN 42759 3112 22 of of IN 42759 3112 23 the the DT 42759 3112 24 capital capital NN 42759 3112 25 , , , 42759 3112 26 are be VBP 42759 3112 27 accorded accord VBN 42759 3112 28 a a DT 42759 3112 29 part part NN 42759 3112 30 of of IN 42759 3112 31 the the DT 42759 3112 32 profits profit NNS 42759 3112 33 . . . 42759 3113 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3113 2 is be VBZ 42759 3113 3 assumed assume VBN 42759 3113 4 that that IN 42759 3113 5 this this DT 42759 3113 6 is be VBZ 42759 3113 7 a a DT 42759 3113 8 fairer fair JJR 42759 3113 9 and and CC 42759 3113 10 wiser wise JJR 42759 3113 11 method method NN 42759 3113 12 of of IN 42759 3113 13 distribution distribution NN 42759 3113 14 than than IN 42759 3113 15 that that DT 42759 3113 16 which which WDT 42759 3113 17 gives give VBZ 42759 3113 18 the the DT 42759 3113 19 labourer labourer NN 42759 3113 20 only only RB 42759 3113 21 wages wage NNS 42759 3113 22 , , , 42759 3113 23 leaving leave VBG 42759 3113 24 all all PDT 42759 3113 25 the the DT 42759 3113 26 profits profit NNS 42759 3113 27 to to IN 42759 3113 28 the the DT 42759 3113 29 manager manager NN 42759 3113 30 - - HYPH 42759 3113 31 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 3113 32 . . . 42759 3114 1 This this DT 42759 3114 2 feature feature NN 42759 3114 3 of of IN 42759 3114 4 co co NN 42759 3114 5 - - NN 42759 3114 6 partnership partnership JJ 42759 3114 7 rests rest NNS 42759 3114 8 on on IN 42759 3114 9 the the DT 42759 3114 10 theory theory NN 42759 3114 11 that that IN 42759 3114 12 the the DT 42759 3114 13 workers worker NNS 42759 3114 14 can can MD 42759 3114 15 , , , 42759 3114 16 if if IN 42759 3114 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3114 18 will will MD 42759 3114 19 , , , 42759 3114 20 increase increase VB 42759 3114 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3114 22 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3114 23 and and CC 42759 3114 24 reduce reduce VB 42759 3114 25 the the DT 42759 3114 26 friction friction NN 42759 3114 27 between between IN 42759 3114 28 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 3114 29 and and CC 42759 3114 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3114 31 employer employer NN 42759 3114 32 to to IN 42759 3114 33 such such PDT 42759 3114 34 an an DT 42759 3114 35 extent extent NN 42759 3114 36 as as IN 42759 3114 37 to to TO 42759 3114 38 make make VB 42759 3114 39 the the DT 42759 3114 40 profit profit NN 42759 3114 41 sharing share VBG 42759 3114 42 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 3114 43 a a DT 42759 3114 44 good good JJ 42759 3114 45 thing thing NN 42759 3114 46 for for IN 42759 3114 47 both both DT 42759 3114 48 parties party NNS 42759 3114 49 . . . 42759 3115 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 3115 2 the the DT 42759 3115 3 profits profit NNS 42759 3115 4 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3115 5 by by IN 42759 3115 6 the the DT 42759 3115 7 workers worker NNS 42759 3115 8 are be VBP 42759 3115 9 a a DT 42759 3115 10 payment payment NN 42759 3115 11 for for IN 42759 3115 12 this this DT 42759 3115 13 specific specific JJ 42759 3115 14 contribution contribution NN 42759 3115 15 to to IN 42759 3115 16 the the DT 42759 3115 17 prosperity prosperity NN 42759 3115 18 of of IN 42759 3115 19 the the DT 42759 3115 20 business business NN 42759 3115 21 . . . 42759 3116 1 Why why WRB 42759 3116 2 should should MD 42759 3116 3 not not RB 42759 3116 4 this this DT 42759 3116 5 theory theory NN 42759 3116 6 find find VB 42759 3116 7 recognition recognition NN 42759 3116 8 in in IN 42759 3116 9 productive productive JJ 42759 3116 10 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3116 11 conducted conduct VBN 42759 3116 12 by by IN 42759 3116 13 the the DT 42759 3116 14 co co JJ 42759 3116 15 - - JJ 42759 3116 16 operative operative JJ 42759 3116 17 stores store NNS 42759 3116 18 ? ? . 42759 3117 1 In in IN 42759 3117 2 the the DT 42759 3117 3 second second JJ 42759 3117 4 place place NN 42759 3117 5 , , , 42759 3117 6 the the DT 42759 3117 7 workers worker NNS 42759 3117 8 in in IN 42759 3117 9 these these DT 42759 3117 10 concerns concern NNS 42759 3117 11 ought ought MD 42759 3117 12 to to TO 42759 3117 13 be be VB 42759 3117 14 permitted permit VBN 42759 3117 15 to to TO 42759 3117 16 participate participate VB 42759 3117 17 in in IN 42759 3117 18 the the DT 42759 3117 19 capital capital NN 42759 3117 20 ownership ownership NN 42759 3117 21 and and CC 42759 3117 22 management management NN 42759 3117 23 . . . 42759 3118 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3118 2 would would MD 42759 3118 3 thus thus RB 42759 3118 4 be be VB 42759 3118 5 strongly strongly RB 42759 3118 6 encouraged encourage VBN 42759 3118 7 to to TO 42759 3118 8 become become VB 42759 3118 9 better well JJR 42759 3118 10 workers worker NNS 42759 3118 11 , , , 42759 3118 12 to to TO 42759 3118 13 save save VB 42759 3118 14 more more JJR 42759 3118 15 money money NN 42759 3118 16 , , , 42759 3118 17 and and CC 42759 3118 18 to to TO 42759 3118 19 increase increase VB 42759 3118 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3118 21 capacity capacity NN 42759 3118 22 for for IN 42759 3118 23 initiative initiative NN 42759 3118 24 and and CC 42759 3118 25 self self NN 42759 3118 26 government government NN 42759 3118 27 . . . 42759 3119 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 3119 2 , , , 42759 3119 3 this this DT 42759 3119 4 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 3119 5 would would MD 42759 3119 6 go go VB 42759 3119 7 farther far RBR 42759 3119 8 than than IN 42759 3119 9 any any DT 42759 3119 10 other other JJ 42759 3119 11 system system NN 42759 3119 12 toward toward IN 42759 3119 13 reconciling reconcile VBG 42759 3119 14 the the DT 42759 3119 15 interests interest NNS 42759 3119 16 of of IN 42759 3119 17 producer producer NN 42759 3119 18 and and CC 42759 3119 19 consumer consumer NN 42759 3119 20 . . . 42759 3120 1 As as IN 42759 3120 2 producer producer NN 42759 3120 3 , , , 42759 3120 4 the the DT 42759 3120 5 worker worker NN 42759 3120 6 would would MD 42759 3120 7 obtain obtain VB 42759 3120 8 , , , 42759 3120 9 besides besides IN 42759 3120 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3120 11 wages wage NNS 42759 3120 12 , , , 42759 3120 13 interest interest NN 42759 3120 14 and and CC 42759 3120 15 profits profit NNS 42759 3120 16 up up IN 42759 3120 17 to to IN 42759 3120 18 the the DT 42759 3120 19 limit limit NN 42759 3120 20 set set VBN 42759 3120 21 by by IN 42759 3120 22 the the DT 42759 3120 23 competition competition NN 42759 3120 24 of of IN 42759 3120 25 private private JJ 42759 3120 26 productive productive JJ 42759 3120 27 concerns concern NNS 42759 3120 28 . . . 42759 3121 1 As as IN 42759 3121 2 consumer consumer NN 42759 3121 3 , , , 42759 3121 4 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3121 5 would would MD 42759 3121 6 share share VB 42759 3121 7 in in IN 42759 3121 8 the the DT 42759 3121 9 profits profit NNS 42759 3121 10 and and CC 42759 3121 11 interest interest NN 42759 3121 12 which which WDT 42759 3121 13 would would MD 42759 3121 14 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 3121 15 have have VB 42759 3121 16 gone go VBN 42759 3121 17 to to IN 42759 3121 18 the the DT 42759 3121 19 private private JJ 42759 3121 20 distributive distributive JJ 42759 3121 21 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3121 22 . . . 42759 3122 1 In in IN 42759 3122 2 this this DT 42759 3122 3 way way NN 42759 3122 4 the the DT 42759 3122 5 producer producer NN 42759 3122 6 and and CC 42759 3122 7 consumer consumer NN 42759 3122 8 would would MD 42759 3122 9 each each DT 42759 3122 10 get get VB 42759 3122 11 the the DT 42759 3122 12 gains gain NNS 42759 3122 13 that that WDT 42759 3122 14 were be VBD 42759 3122 15 due due JJ 42759 3122 16 specifically specifically RB 42759 3122 17 and and CC 42759 3122 18 respectively respectively RB 42759 3122 19 to to IN 42759 3122 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3122 21 activity activity NN 42759 3122 22 and and CC 42759 3122 23 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3122 24 . . . 42759 3123 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3123 2 Advantages Advantages NNPS 42759 3123 3 and and CC 42759 3123 4 Prospects Prospects NNPS 42759 3123 5 of of IN 42759 3123 6 Co co NN 42759 3123 7 - - NN 42759 3123 8 operation operation NN 42759 3123 9 _ _ NNP 42759 3123 10 At at IN 42759 3123 11 this this DT 42759 3123 12 point point NN 42759 3123 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3123 14 will will MD 42759 3123 15 perhaps perhaps RB 42759 3123 16 be be VB 42759 3123 17 well well JJ 42759 3123 18 to to TO 42759 3123 19 sum sum VB 42759 3123 20 up up RP 42759 3123 21 the the DT 42759 3123 22 advantages advantage NNS 42759 3123 23 and and CC 42759 3123 24 to to TO 42759 3123 25 estimate estimate VB 42759 3123 26 the the DT 42759 3123 27 prospects prospect NNS 42759 3123 28 of of IN 42759 3123 29 the the DT 42759 3123 30 co co JJ 42759 3123 31 - - JJ 42759 3123 32 operative operative JJ 42759 3123 33 movement movement NN 42759 3123 34 . . . 42759 3124 1 In in IN 42759 3124 2 all all DT 42759 3124 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3124 4 forms form NNS 42759 3124 5 co co NN 42759 3124 6 - - JJ 42759 3124 7 operation operation JJ 42759 3124 8 eliminates eliminate NNS 42759 3124 9 some some DT 42759 3124 10 waste waste NN 42759 3124 11 of of IN 42759 3124 12 capital capital NN 42759 3124 13 and and CC 42759 3124 14 energy energy NN 42759 3124 15 , , , 42759 3124 16 and and CC 42759 3124 17 therefore therefore RB 42759 3124 18 transfers transfer VBZ 42759 3124 19 some some DT 42759 3124 20 interest interest NN 42759 3124 21 and and CC 42759 3124 22 profits profit NNS 42759 3124 23 from from IN 42759 3124 24 a a DT 42759 3124 25 special special JJ 42759 3124 26 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 3124 27 and and CC 42759 3124 28 undertaking undertaking NN 42759 3124 29 class class NN 42759 3124 30 to to IN 42759 3124 31 a a DT 42759 3124 32 larger large JJR 42759 3124 33 and and CC 42759 3124 34 economically economically RB 42759 3124 35 weaker weak JJR 42759 3124 36 group group NN 42759 3124 37 of of IN 42759 3124 38 persons person NNS 42759 3124 39 . . . 42759 3125 1 For for IN 42759 3125 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3125 3 must must MD 42759 3125 4 be be VB 42759 3125 5 borne bear VBN 42759 3125 6 in in IN 42759 3125 7 mind mind NN 42759 3125 8 that that IN 42759 3125 9 all all DT 42759 3125 10 co co JJ 42759 3125 11 - - JJ 42759 3125 12 operative operative JJ 42759 3125 13 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3125 14 are be VBP 42759 3125 15 conducted conduct VBN 42759 3125 16 mainly mainly RB 42759 3125 17 by by RB 42759 3125 18 and and CC 42759 3125 19 for for IN 42759 3125 20 labourers labourer NNS 42759 3125 21 or or CC 42759 3125 22 small small JJ 42759 3125 23 farmers farmer NNS 42759 3125 24 . . . 42759 3126 1 Hence hence RB 42759 3126 2 the the DT 42759 3126 3 system system NN 42759 3126 4 always always RB 42759 3126 5 makes make VBZ 42759 3126 6 directly directly RB 42759 3126 7 for for IN 42759 3126 8 a a DT 42759 3126 9 better well JJR 42759 3126 10 distribution distribution NN 42759 3126 11 of of IN 42759 3126 12 wealth wealth NN 42759 3126 13 . . . 42759 3127 1 To to IN 42759 3127 2 a a DT 42759 3127 3 considerable considerable JJ 42759 3127 4 extent extent NN 42759 3127 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3127 6 transfers transfer VBZ 42759 3127 7 capital capital NN 42759 3127 8 ownership ownership NN 42759 3127 9 from from IN 42759 3127 10 those those DT 42759 3127 11 who who WP 42759 3127 12 do do VBP 42759 3127 13 not not RB 42759 3127 14 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 3127 15 work work VB 42759 3127 16 with with IN 42759 3127 17 or or CC 42759 3127 18 upon upon IN 42759 3127 19 capital capital NN 42759 3127 20 to to IN 42759 3127 21 those those DT 42759 3127 22 who who WP 42759 3127 23 are be VBP 42759 3127 24 so so RB 42759 3127 25 engaged engaged JJ 42759 3127 26 ; ; : 42759 3127 27 namely namely RB 42759 3127 28 , , , 42759 3127 29 the the DT 42759 3127 30 labourers labourer NNS 42759 3127 31 and and CC 42759 3127 32 the the DT 42759 3127 33 farmers farmer NNS 42759 3127 34 ; ; : 42759 3127 35 thus thus RB 42759 3127 36 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3127 37 diminishes diminish VBZ 42759 3127 38 the the DT 42759 3127 39 unhealthy unhealthy JJ 42759 3127 40 separation separation NN 42759 3127 41 now now RB 42759 3127 42 existing exist VBG 42759 3127 43 between between IN 42759 3127 44 the the DT 42759 3127 45 owners owner NNS 42759 3127 46 and and CC 42759 3127 47 the the DT 42759 3127 48 users user NNS 42759 3127 49 of of IN 42759 3127 50 the the DT 42759 3127 51 instruments instrument NNS 42759 3127 52 of of IN 42759 3127 53 production production NN 42759 3127 54 . . . 42759 3128 1 Co co NN 42759 3128 2 - - NN 42759 3128 3 operation operation NN 42759 3128 4 has have VBZ 42759 3128 5 , , , 42759 3128 6 in in IN 42759 3128 7 the the DT 42759 3128 8 second second JJ 42759 3128 9 place place NN 42759 3128 10 , , , 42759 3128 11 a a DT 42759 3128 12 very very RB 42759 3128 13 great great JJ 42759 3128 14 educational educational JJ 42759 3128 15 value value NN 42759 3128 16 . . . 42759 3129 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3129 2 enables enable VBZ 42759 3129 3 and and CC 42759 3129 4 induces induce VBZ 42759 3129 5 the the DT 42759 3129 6 weaker weak JJR 42759 3129 7 members member NNS 42759 3129 8 of of IN 42759 3129 9 economic economic JJ 42759 3129 10 society society NN 42759 3129 11 to to TO 42759 3129 12 combine combine VB 42759 3129 13 and and CC 42759 3129 14 utilise utilise VB 42759 3129 15 energies energy NNS 42759 3129 16 and and CC 42759 3129 17 resources resource NNS 42759 3129 18 that that WDT 42759 3129 19 would would MD 42759 3129 20 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 3129 21 remain remain VB 42759 3129 22 unused unused JJ 42759 3129 23 and and CC 42759 3129 24 undeveloped undeveloped JJ 42759 3129 25 ; ; : 42759 3129 26 and and CC 42759 3129 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3129 28 greatly greatly RB 42759 3129 29 stimulates stimulate VBZ 42759 3129 30 and and CC 42759 3129 31 fosters foster NNS 42759 3129 32 initiative initiative NN 42759 3129 33 , , , 42759 3129 34 self self NN 42759 3129 35 confidence confidence NN 42759 3129 36 , , , 42759 3129 37 self self NN 42759 3129 38 restraint restraint NN 42759 3129 39 , , , 42759 3129 40 self self NN 42759 3129 41 government government NN 42759 3129 42 , , , 42759 3129 43 and and CC 42759 3129 44 the the DT 42759 3129 45 capacity capacity NN 42759 3129 46 for for IN 42759 3129 47 democracy democracy NN 42759 3129 48 . . . 42759 3130 1 In in IN 42759 3130 2 other other JJ 42759 3130 3 words word NNS 42759 3130 4 , , , 42759 3130 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3130 6 vastly vastly RB 42759 3130 7 increases increase VBZ 42759 3130 8 the the DT 42759 3130 9 development development NN 42759 3130 10 and and CC 42759 3130 11 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3130 12 of of IN 42759 3130 13 the the DT 42759 3130 14 individual individual NN 42759 3130 15 . . . 42759 3131 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3131 2 likewise likewise RB 42759 3131 3 induces induce VBZ 42759 3131 4 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3131 5 to to TO 42759 3131 6 practise practise VB 42759 3131 7 thrift thrift NN 42759 3131 8 , , , 42759 3131 9 and and CC 42759 3131 10 frequently frequently RB 42759 3131 11 provides provide VBZ 42759 3131 12 better well JJR 42759 3131 13 fields field NNS 42759 3131 14 for for IN 42759 3131 15 investment investment NN 42759 3131 16 than than IN 42759 3131 17 would would MD 42759 3131 18 be be VB 42759 3131 19 open open JJ 42759 3131 20 to to IN 42759 3131 21 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3131 22 outside outside IN 42759 3131 23 the the DT 42759 3131 24 co co JJ 42759 3131 25 - - JJ 42759 3131 26 operative operative JJ 42759 3131 27 movement movement NN 42759 3131 28 . . . 42759 3132 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3132 2 diminishes diminish VBZ 42759 3132 3 selfishness selfishness NN 42759 3132 4 and and CC 42759 3132 5 inculcates inculcate VBZ 42759 3132 6 altruism altruism NN 42759 3132 7 ; ; : 42759 3132 8 for for IN 42759 3132 9 no no DT 42759 3132 10 co co JJ 42759 3132 11 - - JJ 42759 3132 12 operative operative JJ 42759 3132 13 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3132 14 can can MD 42759 3132 15 succeed succeed VB 42759 3132 16 in in IN 42759 3132 17 which which WDT 42759 3132 18 the the DT 42759 3132 19 individual individual JJ 42759 3132 20 members member NNS 42759 3132 21 are be VBP 42759 3132 22 not not RB 42759 3132 23 willing willing JJ 42759 3132 24 to to TO 42759 3132 25 make make VB 42759 3132 26 greater great JJR 42759 3132 27 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3132 28 for for IN 42759 3132 29 the the DT 42759 3132 30 common common JJ 42759 3132 31 good good NN 42759 3132 32 than than IN 42759 3132 33 are be VBP 42759 3132 34 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 3132 35 evoked evoke VBN 42759 3132 36 by by IN 42759 3132 37 private private JJ 42759 3132 38 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3132 39 . . . 42759 3133 1 Precisely precisely RB 42759 3133 2 because because IN 42759 3133 3 co co NN 42759 3133 4 - - NN 42759 3133 5 operation operation NN 42759 3133 6 makes make VBZ 42759 3133 7 such such JJ 42759 3133 8 heavy heavy JJ 42759 3133 9 demands demand NNS 42759 3133 10 upon upon IN 42759 3133 11 the the DT 42759 3133 12 capacity capacity NN 42759 3133 13 for for IN 42759 3133 14 altruism altruism NN 42759 3133 15 , , , 42759 3133 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3133 17 progress progress NN 42759 3133 18 always always RB 42759 3133 19 has have VBZ 42759 3133 20 been be VBN 42759 3133 21 and and CC 42759 3133 22 must must MD 42759 3133 23 always always RB 42759 3133 24 continue continue VB 42759 3133 25 to to TO 42759 3133 26 be be VB 42759 3133 27 relatively relatively RB 42759 3133 28 slow slow JJ 42759 3133 29 . . . 42759 3134 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3134 2 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 3134 3 and and CC 42759 3134 4 perhaps perhaps RB 42759 3134 5 chief chief JJ 42759 3134 6 merit merit NN 42759 3134 7 is be VBZ 42759 3134 8 that that IN 42759 3134 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3134 10 does do VBZ 42759 3134 11 provide provide VB 42759 3134 12 the the DT 42759 3134 13 mechanism mechanism NN 42759 3134 14 and and CC 42759 3134 15 the the DT 42759 3134 16 atmosphere atmosphere NN 42759 3134 17 for for IN 42759 3134 18 a a DT 42759 3134 19 greater great JJR 42759 3134 20 development development NN 42759 3134 21 of of IN 42759 3134 22 the the DT 42759 3134 23 altruistic altruistic JJ 42759 3134 24 spirit spirit NN 42759 3134 25 than than IN 42759 3134 26 is be VBZ 42759 3134 27 possible possible JJ 42759 3134 28 under under IN 42759 3134 29 any any DT 42759 3134 30 other other JJ 42759 3134 31 economic economic JJ 42759 3134 32 system system NN 42759 3134 33 that that WDT 42759 3134 34 has have VBZ 42759 3134 35 ever ever RB 42759 3134 36 been be VBN 42759 3134 37 tried try VBN 42759 3134 38 or or CC 42759 3134 39 devised devise VBN 42759 3134 40 . . . 42759 3135 1 By by IN 42759 3135 2 putting put VBG 42759 3135 3 productive productive JJ 42759 3135 4 property property NN 42759 3135 5 into into IN 42759 3135 6 the the DT 42759 3135 7 hands hand NNS 42759 3135 8 of of IN 42759 3135 9 those those DT 42759 3135 10 who who WP 42759 3135 11 now now RB 42759 3135 12 possess possess VBP 42759 3135 13 little little JJ 42759 3135 14 or or CC 42759 3135 15 nothing nothing NN 42759 3135 16 , , , 42759 3135 17 co co NN 42759 3135 18 - - NN 42759 3135 19 operation operation NN 42759 3135 20 promotes promote VBZ 42759 3135 21 social social JJ 42759 3135 22 stability stability NN 42759 3135 23 and and CC 42759 3135 24 social social JJ 42759 3135 25 progress progress NN 42759 3135 26 . . . 42759 3136 1 This this DT 42759 3136 2 statement statement NN 42759 3136 3 is be VBZ 42759 3136 4 true true JJ 42759 3136 5 in in IN 42759 3136 6 some some DT 42759 3136 7 degree degree NN 42759 3136 8 of of IN 42759 3136 9 all all DT 42759 3136 10 forms form NNS 42759 3136 11 of of IN 42759 3136 12 co co NN 42759 3136 13 - - NN 42759 3136 14 operation operation NN 42759 3136 15 , , , 42759 3136 16 but but CC 42759 3136 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3136 18 applies apply VBZ 42759 3136 19 with with IN 42759 3136 20 particular particular JJ 42759 3136 21 force force NN 42759 3136 22 to to IN 42759 3136 23 those those DT 42759 3136 24 forms form NNS 42759 3136 25 which which WDT 42759 3136 26 are be VBP 42759 3136 27 carried carry VBN 42759 3136 28 on on RP 42759 3136 29 by by IN 42759 3136 30 the the DT 42759 3136 31 working work VBG 42759 3136 32 classes class NNS 42759 3136 33 . . . 42759 3137 1 A a DT 42759 3137 2 steadily steadily RB 42759 3137 3 growing grow VBG 42759 3137 4 number number NN 42759 3137 5 of of IN 42759 3137 6 keen keen JJ 42759 3137 7 - - HYPH 42759 3137 8 sighted sighted JJ 42759 3137 9 social social JJ 42759 3137 10 students student NNS 42759 3137 11 are be VBP 42759 3137 12 coming come VBG 42759 3137 13 to to TO 42759 3137 14 realise realise VB 42759 3137 15 that that IN 42759 3137 16 an an DT 42759 3137 17 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3137 18 system system NN 42759 3137 19 which which WDT 42759 3137 20 permits permit VBZ 42759 3137 21 a a DT 42759 3137 22 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 3137 23 small small JJ 42759 3137 24 section section NN 42759 3137 25 of of IN 42759 3137 26 society society NN 42759 3137 27 to to TO 42759 3137 28 own own VB 42759 3137 29 the the DT 42759 3137 30 means mean NNS 42759 3137 31 of of IN 42759 3137 32 production production NN 42759 3137 33 and and CC 42759 3137 34 the the DT 42759 3137 35 instrumentalities instrumentality NNS 42759 3137 36 of of IN 42759 3137 37 distribution distribution NN 42759 3137 38 , , , 42759 3137 39 leaving leave VBG 42759 3137 40 to to IN 42759 3137 41 the the DT 42759 3137 42 great great JJ 42759 3137 43 majority majority NN 42759 3137 44 of of IN 42759 3137 45 the the DT 42759 3137 46 workers worker NNS 42759 3137 47 nothing nothing NN 42759 3137 48 but but IN 42759 3137 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3137 50 labour labour NN 42759 3137 51 power power NN 42759 3137 52 , , , 42759 3137 53 is be VBZ 42759 3137 54 fundamentally fundamentally RB 42759 3137 55 unstable unstable JJ 42759 3137 56 , , , 42759 3137 57 and and CC 42759 3137 58 contains contain VBZ 42759 3137 59 within within IN 42759 3137 60 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 3137 61 the the DT 42759 3137 62 germs germ NNS 42759 3137 63 of of IN 42759 3137 64 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 3137 65 dissolution dissolution NN 42759 3137 66 . . . 42759 3138 1 No no DT 42759 3138 2 mere mere JJ 42759 3138 3 adequacy adequacy NN 42759 3138 4 of of IN 42759 3138 5 wages wage NNS 42759 3138 6 and and CC 42759 3138 7 other other JJ 42759 3138 8 working working NN 42759 3138 9 conditions condition NNS 42759 3138 10 , , , 42759 3138 11 and and CC 42759 3138 12 no no DT 42759 3138 13 mere mere JJ 42759 3138 14 security security NN 42759 3138 15 of of IN 42759 3138 16 the the DT 42759 3138 17 workers worker NNS 42759 3138 18 ' ' POS 42759 3138 19 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 3138 20 , , , 42759 3138 21 can can MD 42759 3138 22 permanently permanently RB 42759 3138 23 avert avert VB 42759 3138 24 this this DT 42759 3138 25 danger danger NN 42759 3138 26 , , , 42759 3138 27 nor nor CC 42759 3138 28 compensate compensate VB 42759 3138 29 the the DT 42759 3138 30 individual individual NN 42759 3138 31 for for IN 42759 3138 32 the the DT 42759 3138 33 lack lack NN 42759 3138 34 of of IN 42759 3138 35 power power NN 42759 3138 36 to to TO 42759 3138 37 determine determine VB 42759 3138 38 those those DT 42759 3138 39 activities activity NNS 42759 3138 40 of of IN 42759 3138 41 life life NN 42759 3138 42 which which WDT 42759 3138 43 depend depend VBP 42759 3138 44 upon upon IN 42759 3138 45 the the DT 42759 3138 46 possession possession NN 42759 3138 47 of of IN 42759 3138 48 property property NN 42759 3138 49 . . . 42759 3139 1 Through through IN 42759 3139 2 co co NN 42759 3139 3 - - NN 42759 3139 4 operation operation NN 42759 3139 5 this this DT 42759 3139 6 unnatural unnatural JJ 42759 3139 7 divorce divorce NN 42759 3139 8 of of IN 42759 3139 9 the the DT 42759 3139 10 users user NNS 42759 3139 11 from from IN 42759 3139 12 the the DT 42759 3139 13 owners owner NNS 42759 3139 14 of of IN 42759 3139 15 capital capital NN 42759 3139 16 can can MD 42759 3139 17 be be VB 42759 3139 18 minimised minimise VBN 42759 3139 19 . . . 42759 3140 1 The the DT 42759 3140 2 worker worker NN 42759 3140 3 is be VBZ 42759 3140 4 converted convert VBN 42759 3140 5 from from IN 42759 3140 6 a a DT 42759 3140 7 mere mere JJ 42759 3140 8 wage wage NN 42759 3140 9 earner earner NN 42759 3140 10 to to IN 42759 3140 11 a a DT 42759 3140 12 wage wage NN 42759 3140 13 earner earner NN 42759 3140 14 plus plus CC 42759 3140 15 a a DT 42759 3140 16 property property NN 42759 3140 17 owner owner NN 42759 3140 18 , , , 42759 3140 19 thus thus RB 42759 3140 20 becoming become VBG 42759 3140 21 a a DT 42759 3140 22 safer safe JJR 42759 3140 23 and and CC 42759 3140 24 more more RBR 42759 3140 25 useful useful JJ 42759 3140 26 member member NN 42759 3140 27 of of IN 42759 3140 28 society society NN 42759 3140 29 . . . 42759 3141 1 In in IN 42759 3141 2 a a DT 42759 3141 3 word word NN 42759 3141 4 , , , 42759 3141 5 co co NN 42759 3141 6 - - NN 42759 3141 7 operation operation NN 42759 3141 8 produces produce VBZ 42759 3141 9 all all PDT 42759 3141 10 the the DT 42759 3141 11 well well RB 42759 3141 12 recognised recognise VBN 42759 3141 13 individual individual JJ 42759 3141 14 and and CC 42759 3141 15 social social JJ 42759 3141 16 benefits benefit NNS 42759 3141 17 which which WDT 42759 3141 18 have have VBP 42759 3141 19 in in IN 42759 3141 20 all all DT 42759 3141 21 ages age NNS 42759 3141 22 been be VBN 42759 3141 23 evoked evoke VBN 42759 3141 24 by by IN 42759 3141 25 the the DT 42759 3141 26 " " `` 42759 3141 27 magic magic NNP 42759 3141 28 of of IN 42759 3141 29 property property NN 42759 3141 30 . . . 42759 3141 31 " " '' 42759 3142 1 Finally finally RB 42759 3142 2 , , , 42759 3142 3 co co NN 42759 3142 4 - - NN 42759 3142 5 operation operation NN 42759 3142 6 is be VBZ 42759 3142 7 a a DT 42759 3142 8 golden golden JJ 42759 3142 9 mean mean NN 42759 3142 10 between between IN 42759 3142 11 individualism individualism NN 42759 3142 12 and and CC 42759 3142 13 Socialism socialism NN 42759 3142 14 . . . 42759 3143 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3143 2 includes include VBZ 42759 3143 3 all all PDT 42759 3143 4 the the DT 42759 3143 5 good good JJ 42759 3143 6 features feature NNS 42759 3143 7 and and CC 42759 3143 8 excludes exclude VBZ 42759 3143 9 all all PDT 42759 3143 10 the the DT 42759 3143 11 evil evil JJ 42759 3143 12 features feature NNS 42759 3143 13 of of IN 42759 3143 14 both both DT 42759 3143 15 . . . 42759 3144 1 On on IN 42759 3144 2 the the DT 42759 3144 3 one one CD 42759 3144 4 hand hand NN 42759 3144 5 , , , 42759 3144 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3144 7 demands demand VBZ 42759 3144 8 and and CC 42759 3144 9 develops develop VBZ 42759 3144 10 individual individual JJ 42759 3144 11 initiative initiative NN 42759 3144 12 and and CC 42759 3144 13 self self NN 42759 3144 14 reliance reliance NN 42759 3144 15 , , , 42759 3144 16 makes make VBZ 42759 3144 17 the the DT 42759 3144 18 rewards reward NNS 42759 3144 19 of of IN 42759 3144 20 the the DT 42759 3144 21 individual individual NN 42759 3144 22 depend depend VBP 42759 3144 23 upon upon IN 42759 3144 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3144 25 own own JJ 42759 3144 26 efforts effort NNS 42759 3144 27 and and CC 42759 3144 28 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3144 29 , , , 42759 3144 30 and and CC 42759 3144 31 gives give VBZ 42759 3144 32 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3144 33 full full JJ 42759 3144 34 ownership ownership NN 42759 3144 35 of of IN 42759 3144 36 specific specific JJ 42759 3144 37 pieces piece NNS 42759 3144 38 of of IN 42759 3144 39 property property NN 42759 3144 40 . . . 42759 3145 1 On on IN 42759 3145 2 the the DT 42759 3145 3 other other JJ 42759 3145 4 hand hand NN 42759 3145 5 , , , 42759 3145 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3145 7 compels compel VBZ 42759 3145 8 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3145 9 to to TO 42759 3145 10 submerge submerge VB 42759 3145 11 much much JJ 42759 3145 12 of of IN 42759 3145 13 the the DT 42759 3145 14 selfishness selfishness NN 42759 3145 15 and and CC 42759 3145 16 indifference indifference NN 42759 3145 17 to to IN 42759 3145 18 the the DT 42759 3145 19 welfare welfare NN 42759 3145 20 of of IN 42759 3145 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3145 22 fellows fellow NNS 42759 3145 23 which which WDT 42759 3145 24 characterise characterise VBP 42759 3145 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3145 26 individual individual JJ 42759 3145 27 economy economy NN 42759 3145 28 . . . 42759 3146 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3146 2 embraces embrace VBZ 42759 3146 3 all all PDT 42759 3146 4 the the DT 42759 3146 5 good good JJ 42759 3146 6 that that WDT 42759 3146 7 is be VBZ 42759 3146 8 claimed claim VBN 42759 3146 9 for for IN 42759 3146 10 Socialism socialism NN 42759 3146 11 because because IN 42759 3146 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3146 13 induces induce VBZ 42759 3146 14 men man NNS 42759 3146 15 to to TO 42759 3146 16 consider consider VB 42759 3146 17 and and CC 42759 3146 18 to to TO 42759 3146 19 work work VB 42759 3146 20 earnestly earnestly RB 42759 3146 21 for for IN 42759 3146 22 the the DT 42759 3146 23 common common JJ 42759 3146 24 good good NN 42759 3146 25 , , , 42759 3146 26 eliminates eliminate NNS 42759 3146 27 much much JJ 42759 3146 28 of of IN 42759 3146 29 the the DT 42759 3146 30 waste waste NN 42759 3146 31 of of IN 42759 3146 32 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3146 33 industry industry NN 42759 3146 34 , , , 42759 3146 35 reduces reduce VBZ 42759 3146 36 and and CC 42759 3146 37 redistributes redistribute VBZ 42759 3146 38 the the DT 42759 3146 39 burdens burden NNS 42759 3146 40 of of IN 42759 3146 41 profits profit NNS 42759 3146 42 and and CC 42759 3146 43 interest interest NN 42759 3146 44 , , , 42759 3146 45 and and CC 42759 3146 46 puts put VBZ 42759 3146 47 the the DT 42759 3146 48 workers worker NNS 42759 3146 49 in in IN 42759 3146 50 control control NN 42759 3146 51 of of IN 42759 3146 52 capital capital NN 42759 3146 53 and and CC 42759 3146 54 industry industry NN 42759 3146 55 . . . 42759 3147 1 At at IN 42759 3147 2 the the DT 42759 3147 3 same same JJ 42759 3147 4 time time NN 42759 3147 5 , , , 42759 3147 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3147 7 avoids avoid VBZ 42759 3147 8 the the DT 42759 3147 9 evils evil NNS 42759 3147 10 of of IN 42759 3147 11 an an DT 42759 3147 12 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3147 13 despotism despotism NN 42759 3147 14 , , , 42759 3147 15 of of IN 42759 3147 16 bureaucratic bureaucratic JJ 42759 3147 17 inefficiency inefficiency NN 42759 3147 18 , , , 42759 3147 19 of of IN 42759 3147 20 individual individual JJ 42759 3147 21 indifference indifference NN 42759 3147 22 , , , 42759 3147 23 and and CC 42759 3147 24 of of IN 42759 3147 25 an an DT 42759 3147 26 all all DT 42759 3147 27 pervading pervading JJ 42759 3147 28 collective collective JJ 42759 3147 29 ownership ownership NN 42759 3147 30 . . . 42759 3148 1 The the DT 42759 3148 2 resemblances resemblance NNS 42759 3148 3 that that WDT 42759 3148 4 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 3148 5 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3148 6 profess profess VBP 42759 3148 7 to to TO 42759 3148 8 see see VB 42759 3148 9 between between IN 42759 3148 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3148 11 system system NN 42759 3148 12 and and CC 42759 3148 13 co co NN 42759 3148 14 - - NN 42759 3148 15 operation operation NN 42759 3148 16 are be VBP 42759 3148 17 superficial superficial JJ 42759 3148 18 and and CC 42759 3148 19 far far RB 42759 3148 20 less less RBR 42759 3148 21 important important JJ 42759 3148 22 than than IN 42759 3148 23 the the DT 42759 3148 24 differences difference NNS 42759 3148 25 . . . 42759 3149 1 Under under IN 42759 3149 2 both both DT 42759 3149 3 arrangements arrangement NNS 42759 3149 4 the the DT 42759 3149 5 workers worker NNS 42759 3149 6 would would MD 42759 3149 7 , , , 42759 3149 8 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3149 9 are be VBP 42759 3149 10 told tell VBN 42759 3149 11 , , , 42759 3149 12 own own JJ 42759 3149 13 and and CC 42759 3149 14 control control VB 42759 3149 15 the the DT 42759 3149 16 means mean NNS 42759 3149 17 of of IN 42759 3149 18 production production NN 42759 3149 19 ; ; : 42759 3149 20 but but CC 42759 3149 21 the the DT 42759 3149 22 members member NNS 42759 3149 23 of of IN 42759 3149 24 a a DT 42759 3149 25 co co JJ 42759 3149 26 - - JJ 42759 3149 27 operative operative JJ 42759 3149 28 society society NN 42759 3149 29 directly directly RB 42759 3149 30 own own JJ 42759 3149 31 and and CC 42759 3149 32 immediately immediately RB 42759 3149 33 control control VB 42759 3149 34 a a DT 42759 3149 35 _ _ NNP 42759 3149 36 definite definite JJ 42759 3149 37 amount amount NN 42759 3149 38 of of IN 42759 3149 39 specific specific JJ 42759 3149 40 capital capital NN 42759 3149 41 _ _ NNP 42759 3149 42 , , , 42759 3149 43 which which WDT 42759 3149 44 is be VBZ 42759 3149 45 essentially essentially RB 42759 3149 46 _ _ NNP 42759 3149 47 private private JJ 42759 3149 48 _ _ NNP 42759 3149 49 property property NN 42759 3149 50 . . . 42759 3150 1 In in IN 42759 3150 2 a a DT 42759 3150 3 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 3150 4 régime régime NN 42759 3150 5 the the DT 42759 3150 6 workers worker NNS 42759 3150 7 ' ' POS 42759 3150 8 ownership ownership NN 42759 3150 9 of of IN 42759 3150 10 capital capital NN 42759 3150 11 would would MD 42759 3150 12 be be VB 42759 3150 13 collective collective JJ 42759 3150 14 not not RB 42759 3150 15 private private JJ 42759 3150 16 , , , 42759 3150 17 general general JJ 42759 3150 18 not not RB 42759 3150 19 specific specific JJ 42759 3150 20 , , , 42759 3150 21 while while IN 42759 3150 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3150 23 control control NN 42759 3150 24 of of IN 42759 3150 25 the the DT 42759 3150 26 productive productive JJ 42759 3150 27 instruments instrument NNS 42759 3150 28 with with IN 42759 3150 29 which which WDT 42759 3150 30 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3150 31 worked work VBD 42759 3150 32 would would MD 42759 3150 33 be be VB 42759 3150 34 shared share VBN 42759 3150 35 with with IN 42759 3150 36 other other JJ 42759 3150 37 citizens citizen NNS 42759 3150 38 . . . 42759 3151 1 The the DT 42759 3151 2 latter latter JJ 42759 3151 3 would would MD 42759 3151 4 vastly vastly RB 42759 3151 5 outnumber outnumber VB 42759 3151 6 the the DT 42759 3151 7 workers worker NNS 42759 3151 8 in in IN 42759 3151 9 any any DT 42759 3151 10 particular particular JJ 42759 3151 11 industry industry NN 42759 3151 12 , , , 42759 3151 13 and and CC 42759 3151 14 would would MD 42759 3151 15 be be VB 42759 3151 16 interested interested JJ 42759 3151 17 therein therein RB 42759 3151 18 not not RB 42759 3151 19 as as IN 42759 3151 20 producers producer NNS 42759 3151 21 but but CC 42759 3151 22 as as IN 42759 3151 23 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3151 24 . . . 42759 3152 1 No no DT 42759 3152 2 less less RBR 42759 3152 3 obvious obvious JJ 42759 3152 4 and and CC 42759 3152 5 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 3152 6 are be VBP 42759 3152 7 the the DT 42759 3152 8 differences difference NNS 42759 3152 9 in in IN 42759 3152 10 favour favour NN 42759 3152 11 of of IN 42759 3152 12 co co NN 42759 3152 13 - - NN 42759 3152 14 operation operation NN 42759 3152 15 as as IN 42759 3152 16 regards regard VBZ 42759 3152 17 the the DT 42759 3152 18 vital vital JJ 42759 3152 19 matters matter NNS 42759 3152 20 of of IN 42759 3152 21 freedom freedom NN 42759 3152 22 , , , 42759 3152 23 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 3152 24 , , , 42759 3152 25 and and CC 42759 3152 26 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3152 27 . . . 42759 3153 1 In in IN 42759 3153 2 so so RB 42759 3153 3 far far RB 42759 3153 4 as as IN 42759 3153 5 the the DT 42759 3153 6 future future NN 42759 3153 7 of of IN 42759 3153 8 co co NN 42759 3153 9 - - NN 42759 3153 10 operation operation NN 42759 3153 11 can can MD 42759 3153 12 be be VB 42759 3153 13 predicted predict VBN 42759 3153 14 from from IN 42759 3153 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3153 16 past past NN 42759 3153 17 , , , 42759 3153 18 the the DT 42759 3153 19 outlook outlook NN 42759 3153 20 is be VBZ 42759 3153 21 distinctly distinctly RB 42759 3153 22 encouraging encouraging JJ 42759 3153 23 . . . 42759 3154 1 The the DT 42759 3154 2 success success NN 42759 3154 3 attained attain VBD 42759 3154 4 in in IN 42759 3154 5 credit credit NN 42759 3154 6 , , , 42759 3154 7 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 3154 8 , , , 42759 3154 9 and and CC 42759 3154 10 distribution distribution NN 42759 3154 11 , , , 42759 3154 12 is be VBZ 42759 3154 13 a a DT 42759 3154 14 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3154 15 guarantee guarantee NN 42759 3154 16 for for IN 42759 3154 17 these these DT 42759 3154 18 departments department NNS 42759 3154 19 . . . 42759 3155 1 While while IN 42759 3155 2 productive productive JJ 42759 3155 3 co co NN 42759 3155 4 - - NN 42759 3155 5 operation operation NN 42759 3155 6 has have VBZ 42759 3155 7 experienced experience VBN 42759 3155 8 more more JJR 42759 3155 9 failures failure NNS 42759 3155 10 than than IN 42759 3155 11 successes success NNS 42759 3155 12 , , , 42759 3155 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3155 14 has have VBZ 42759 3155 15 finally finally RB 42759 3155 16 shown show VBN 42759 3155 17 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 3155 18 to to TO 42759 3155 19 be be VB 42759 3155 20 sound sound JJ 42759 3155 21 in in IN 42759 3155 22 principle principle NN 42759 3155 23 , , , 42759 3155 24 and and CC 42759 3155 25 feasible feasible JJ 42759 3155 26 in in IN 42759 3155 27 practice practice NN 42759 3155 28 . . . 42759 3156 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3156 2 extension extension NN 42759 3156 3 will will MD 42759 3156 4 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 3156 5 be be VB 42759 3156 6 slow slow JJ 42759 3156 7 , , , 42759 3156 8 but but CC 42759 3156 9 this this DT 42759 3156 10 is be VBZ 42759 3156 11 exactly exactly RB 42759 3156 12 what what WP 42759 3156 13 should should MD 42759 3156 14 be be VB 42759 3156 15 expected expect VBN 42759 3156 16 by by IN 42759 3156 17 any any DT 42759 3156 18 one one NN 42759 3156 19 who who WP 42759 3156 20 is be VBZ 42759 3156 21 acquainted acquaint VBN 42759 3156 22 with with IN 42759 3156 23 the the DT 42759 3156 24 limitations limitation NNS 42759 3156 25 of of IN 42759 3156 26 human human JJ 42759 3156 27 nature nature NN 42759 3156 28 , , , 42759 3156 29 and and CC 42759 3156 30 the the DT 42759 3156 31 history history NN 42759 3156 32 of of IN 42759 3156 33 human human JJ 42759 3156 34 progress progress NN 42759 3156 35 . . . 42759 3157 1 If if IN 42759 3157 2 a a DT 42759 3157 3 movement movement NN 42759 3157 4 that that WDT 42759 3157 5 is be VBZ 42759 3157 6 capable capable JJ 42759 3157 7 of of IN 42759 3157 8 modifying modify VBG 42759 3157 9 so so RB 42759 3157 10 profoundly profoundly RB 42759 3157 11 the the DT 42759 3157 12 condition condition NN 42759 3157 13 of of IN 42759 3157 14 the the DT 42759 3157 15 workers worker NNS 42759 3157 16 as as IN 42759 3157 17 is be VBZ 42759 3157 18 co co JJ 42759 3157 19 - - JJ 42759 3157 20 operative operative JJ 42759 3157 21 production production NN 42759 3157 22 , , , 42759 3157 23 gave give VBD 42759 3157 24 indications indication NNS 42759 3157 25 of of IN 42759 3157 26 increasing increase VBG 42759 3157 27 rapidly rapidly RB 42759 3157 28 , , , 42759 3157 29 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3157 30 should should MD 42759 3157 31 be be VB 42759 3157 32 inclined incline VBN 42759 3157 33 to to TO 42759 3157 34 question question VB 42759 3157 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3157 36 soundness soundness NN 42759 3157 37 and and CC 42759 3157 38 permanence permanence NN 42759 3157 39 . . . 42759 3158 1 Experience experience NN 42759 3158 2 has have VBZ 42759 3158 3 given give VBN 42759 3158 4 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3158 5 abundant abundant JJ 42759 3158 6 proof proof NN 42759 3158 7 that that IN 42759 3158 8 no no DT 42759 3158 9 mere mere JJ 42759 3158 10 system system NN 42759 3158 11 or or CC 42759 3158 12 machinery machinery NN 42759 3158 13 can can MD 42759 3158 14 effect effect VB 42759 3158 15 a a DT 42759 3158 16 revolutionary revolutionary JJ 42759 3158 17 improvement improvement NN 42759 3158 18 in in IN 42759 3158 19 economic economic JJ 42759 3158 20 conditions condition NNS 42759 3158 21 . . . 42759 3159 1 No no DT 42759 3159 2 social social JJ 42759 3159 3 system system NN 42759 3159 4 can can MD 42759 3159 5 do do VB 42759 3159 6 more more JJR 42759 3159 7 than than IN 42759 3159 8 provide provide VB 42759 3159 9 a a DT 42759 3159 10 favourable favourable JJ 42759 3159 11 environment environment NN 42759 3159 12 for for IN 42759 3159 13 the the DT 42759 3159 14 development development NN 42759 3159 15 of of IN 42759 3159 16 those those DT 42759 3159 17 individual individual JJ 42759 3159 18 capacities capacity NNS 42759 3159 19 and and CC 42759 3159 20 energies energy NNS 42759 3159 21 which which WDT 42759 3159 22 are be VBP 42759 3159 23 the the DT 42759 3159 24 true true JJ 42759 3159 25 and and CC 42759 3159 26 the the DT 42759 3159 27 only only JJ 42759 3159 28 causal causal JJ 42759 3159 29 forces force NNS 42759 3159 30 of of IN 42759 3159 31 betterment betterment NN 42759 3159 32 . . . 42759 3160 1 Nor nor CC 42759 3160 2 is be VBZ 42759 3160 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3160 4 to to TO 42759 3160 5 be be VB 42759 3160 6 expected expect VBN 42759 3160 7 that that IN 42759 3160 8 any any DT 42759 3160 9 of of IN 42759 3160 10 the the DT 42759 3160 11 other other JJ 42759 3160 12 three three CD 42759 3160 13 forms form NNS 42759 3160 14 of of IN 42759 3160 15 co co NN 42759 3160 16 - - NN 42759 3160 17 operation operation NN 42759 3160 18 will will MD 42759 3160 19 ever ever RB 42759 3160 20 cover cover VB 42759 3160 21 the the DT 42759 3160 22 entire entire JJ 42759 3160 23 field field NN 42759 3160 24 to to TO 42759 3160 25 which which WDT 42759 3160 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3160 27 might may MD 42759 3160 28 , , , 42759 3160 29 absolutely absolutely RB 42759 3160 30 speaking speak VBG 42759 3160 31 , , , 42759 3160 32 be be VB 42759 3160 33 extended extend VBN 42759 3160 34 ; ; : 42759 3160 35 or or CC 42759 3160 36 that that IN 42759 3160 37 co co NN 42759 3160 38 - - NN 42759 3160 39 operation operation NN 42759 3160 40 as as IN 42759 3160 41 a a DT 42759 3160 42 whole whole NN 42759 3160 43 will will MD 42759 3160 44 become become VB 42759 3160 45 the the DT 42759 3160 46 one one CD 42759 3160 47 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3160 48 system system NN 42759 3160 49 of of IN 42759 3160 50 the the DT 42759 3160 51 future future NN 42759 3160 52 . . . 42759 3161 1 Even even RB 42759 3161 2 if if IN 42759 3161 3 the the DT 42759 3161 4 latter latter JJ 42759 3161 5 contingency contingency NN 42759 3161 6 were be VBD 42759 3161 7 possible possible JJ 42759 3161 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3161 9 would would MD 42759 3161 10 not not RB 42759 3161 11 be be VB 42759 3161 12 desirable desirable JJ 42759 3161 13 . . . 42759 3162 1 The the DT 42759 3162 2 elements element NNS 42759 3162 3 of of IN 42759 3162 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3162 5 economic economic JJ 42759 3162 6 life life NN 42759 3162 7 , , , 42759 3162 8 and and CC 42759 3162 9 the the DT 42759 3162 10 capacities capacity NNS 42759 3162 11 of of IN 42759 3162 12 human human JJ 42759 3162 13 nature nature NN 42759 3162 14 , , , 42759 3162 15 are be VBP 42759 3162 16 too too RB 42759 3162 17 varied varied JJ 42759 3162 18 and and CC 42759 3162 19 too too RB 42759 3162 20 complex complex JJ 42759 3162 21 to to TO 42759 3162 22 be be VB 42759 3162 23 forced force VBN 42759 3162 24 with with IN 42759 3162 25 advantage advantage NN 42759 3162 26 into into IN 42759 3162 27 any any DT 42759 3162 28 one one CD 42759 3162 29 system system NN 42759 3162 30 , , , 42759 3162 31 whether whether IN 42759 3162 32 capitalism capitalism NN 42759 3162 33 , , , 42759 3162 34 Socialism socialism NN 42759 3162 35 , , , 42759 3162 36 or or CC 42759 3162 37 co co NN 42759 3162 38 - - NN 42759 3162 39 operation operation NN 42759 3162 40 . . . 42759 3163 1 Any any DT 42759 3163 2 single single JJ 42759 3163 3 system system NN 42759 3163 4 or or CC 42759 3163 5 form form NN 42759 3163 6 of of IN 42759 3163 7 socio socio JJ 42759 3163 8 - - HYPH 42759 3163 9 economic economic JJ 42759 3163 10 organisation organisation NN 42759 3163 11 would would MD 42759 3163 12 prove prove VB 42759 3163 13 an an DT 42759 3163 14 intolerable intolerable JJ 42759 3163 15 obstacle obstacle NN 42759 3163 16 to to IN 42759 3163 17 individual individual JJ 42759 3163 18 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 3163 19 and and CC 42759 3163 20 social social JJ 42759 3163 21 progress progress NN 42759 3163 22 . . . 42759 3164 1 Multiplicity multiplicity NN 42759 3164 2 and and CC 42759 3164 3 variety variety NN 42759 3164 4 in in IN 42759 3164 5 social social JJ 42759 3164 6 and and CC 42759 3164 7 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3164 8 orders order NNS 42759 3164 9 are be VBP 42759 3164 10 required require VBN 42759 3164 11 for for IN 42759 3164 12 an an DT 42759 3164 13 effective effective JJ 42759 3164 14 range range NN 42759 3164 15 of of IN 42759 3164 16 choices choice NNS 42759 3164 17 , , , 42759 3164 18 and and CC 42759 3164 19 an an DT 42759 3164 20 adequate adequate JJ 42759 3164 21 scope scope NN 42759 3164 22 for for IN 42759 3164 23 human human JJ 42759 3164 24 effort effort NN 42759 3164 25 . . . 42759 3165 1 In in IN 42759 3165 2 a a DT 42759 3165 3 general general JJ 42759 3165 4 way way NN 42759 3165 5 the the DT 42759 3165 6 limits limit NNS 42759 3165 7 of of IN 42759 3165 8 co co NN 42759 3165 9 - - NN 42759 3165 10 operation operation NN 42759 3165 11 in in IN 42759 3165 12 relation relation NN 42759 3165 13 to to IN 42759 3165 14 the the DT 42759 3165 15 other other JJ 42759 3165 16 forms form NNS 42759 3165 17 of of IN 42759 3165 18 economic economic JJ 42759 3165 19 organisation organisation NN 42759 3165 20 have have VBP 42759 3165 21 been be VBN 42759 3165 22 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 42759 3165 23 stated state VBN 42759 3165 24 by by IN 42759 3165 25 Mr. Mr. NNP 42759 3165 26 Aneurin Aneurin NNP 42759 3165 27 Williams Williams NNP 42759 3165 28 : : : 42759 3165 29 " " `` 42759 3165 30 I -PRON- PRP 42759 3165 31 suggest suggest VBP 42759 3165 32 , , , 42759 3165 33 therefore therefore RB 42759 3165 34 , , , 42759 3165 35 that that IN 42759 3165 36 where where WRB 42759 3165 37 there there EX 42759 3165 38 are be VBP 42759 3165 39 great great JJ 42759 3165 40 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3165 41 , , , 42759 3165 42 either either CC 42759 3165 43 natural natural JJ 42759 3165 44 or or CC 42759 3165 45 created create VBN 42759 3165 46 by by IN 42759 3165 47 the the DT 42759 3165 48 combination combination NN 42759 3165 49 of of IN 42759 3165 50 businesses business NNS 42759 3165 51 , , , 42759 3165 52 there there RB 42759 3165 53 you -PRON- PRP 42759 3165 54 have have VBP 42759 3165 55 a a DT 42759 3165 56 presumption presumption NN 42759 3165 57 in in IN 42759 3165 58 favour favour NN 42759 3165 59 of of IN 42759 3165 60 State State NNP 42759 3165 61 and and CC 42759 3165 62 municipal municipal JJ 42759 3165 63 ownership ownership NN 42759 3165 64 . . . 42759 3166 1 In in IN 42759 3166 2 those those DT 42759 3166 3 forms form NNS 42759 3166 4 of of IN 42759 3166 5 industry industry NN 42759 3166 6 where where WRB 42759 3166 7 individuality individuality NN 42759 3166 8 is be VBZ 42759 3166 9 everything everything NN 42759 3166 10 ; ; : 42759 3166 11 where where WRB 42759 3166 12 there there EX 42759 3166 13 are be VBP 42759 3166 14 new new JJ 42759 3166 15 inventions invention NNS 42759 3166 16 to to TO 42759 3166 17 make make VB 42759 3166 18 , , , 42759 3166 19 or or CC 42759 3166 20 to to TO 42759 3166 21 develop develop VB 42759 3166 22 or or CC 42759 3166 23 put put VB 42759 3166 24 on on IN 42759 3166 25 the the DT 42759 3166 26 market market NN 42759 3166 27 , , , 42759 3166 28 or or CC 42759 3166 29 merely merely RB 42759 3166 30 to to TO 42759 3166 31 adopt adopt VB 42759 3166 32 in in IN 42759 3166 33 some some DT 42759 3166 34 rapidly rapidly RB 42759 3166 35 transformed transform VBN 42759 3166 36 industry industry NN 42759 3166 37 ; ; : 42759 3166 38 where where WRB 42759 3166 39 the the DT 42759 3166 40 eye eye NN 42759 3166 41 of of IN 42759 3166 42 the the DT 42759 3166 43 master master NN 42759 3166 44 is be VBZ 42759 3166 45 everything everything NN 42759 3166 46 ; ; : 42759 3166 47 where where WRB 42759 3166 48 reference reference NN 42759 3166 49 to to IN 42759 3166 50 a a DT 42759 3166 51 committee committee NN 42759 3166 52 , , , 42759 3166 53 or or CC 42759 3166 54 appeals appeal NNS 42759 3166 55 from from IN 42759 3166 56 one one CD 42759 3166 57 official official NN 42759 3166 58 to to IN 42759 3166 59 another another DT 42759 3166 60 , , , 42759 3166 61 would would MD 42759 3166 62 cause cause VB 42759 3166 63 fatal fatal JJ 42759 3166 64 delay delay NN 42759 3166 65 : : : 42759 3166 66 there there EX 42759 3166 67 is be VBZ 42759 3166 68 the the DT 42759 3166 69 natural natural JJ 42759 3166 70 sphere sphere NN 42759 3166 71 of of IN 42759 3166 72 individual individual JJ 42759 3166 73 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3166 74 pure pure JJ 42759 3166 75 and and CC 42759 3166 76 simple simple JJ 42759 3166 77 . . . 42759 3167 1 Between between IN 42759 3167 2 these these DT 42759 3167 3 two two CD 42759 3167 4 extremes extreme NNS 42759 3167 5 there there EX 42759 3167 6 is be VBZ 42759 3167 7 surely surely RB 42759 3167 8 a a DT 42759 3167 9 great great JJ 42759 3167 10 sphere sphere NN 42759 3167 11 for for IN 42759 3167 12 voluntary voluntary JJ 42759 3167 13 association association NNP 42759 3167 14 to to TO 42759 3167 15 carry carry VB 42759 3167 16 on on IN 42759 3167 17 commerce commerce NN 42759 3167 18 , , , 42759 3167 19 manufacture manufacture NN 42759 3167 20 , , , 42759 3167 21 and and CC 42759 3167 22 retail retail JJ 42759 3167 23 trade trade NN 42759 3167 24 , , , 42759 3167 25 in in IN 42759 3167 26 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 3167 27 where where WRB 42759 3167 28 there there EX 42759 3167 29 is be VBZ 42759 3167 30 no no DT 42759 3167 31 natural natural JJ 42759 3167 32 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3167 33 , , , 42759 3167 34 and and CC 42759 3167 35 where where WRB 42759 3167 36 the the DT 42759 3167 37 routine routine NN 42759 3167 38 of of IN 42759 3167 39 work work NN 42759 3167 40 is be VBZ 42759 3167 41 not not RB 42759 3167 42 rapidly rapidly RB 42759 3167 43 changing change VBG 42759 3167 44 , , , 42759 3167 45 but but CC 42759 3167 46 on on IN 42759 3167 47 the the DT 42759 3167 48 whole whole JJ 42759 3167 49 fairly fairly RB 42759 3167 50 well well RB 42759 3167 51 established established JJ 42759 3167 52 and and CC 42759 3167 53 constant constant JJ 42759 3167 54 . . . 42759 3168 1 " " `` 42759 3168 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3168 3 159 159 CD 42759 3168 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3168 5 The the DT 42759 3168 6 province province NN 42759 3168 7 open open JJ 42759 3168 8 to to IN 42759 3168 9 co co NN 42759 3168 10 - - NN 42759 3168 11 operation operation NN 42759 3168 12 is be VBZ 42759 3168 13 , , , 42759 3168 14 indeed indeed RB 42759 3168 15 , , , 42759 3168 16 very very RB 42759 3168 17 large large JJ 42759 3168 18 . . . 42759 3169 1 If if IN 42759 3169 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3169 3 were be VBD 42759 3169 4 fully fully RB 42759 3169 5 occupied occupy VBN 42759 3169 6 the the DT 42759 3169 7 danger danger NN 42759 3169 8 of of IN 42759 3169 9 a a DT 42759 3169 10 social social JJ 42759 3169 11 revolution revolution NN 42759 3169 12 would would MD 42759 3169 13 be be VB 42759 3169 14 non non JJ 42759 3169 15 - - JJ 42759 3169 16 existent existent JJ 42759 3169 17 , , , 42759 3169 18 and and CC 42759 3169 19 what what WP 42759 3169 20 remained remain VBD 42759 3169 21 of of IN 42759 3169 22 the the DT 42759 3169 23 socio socio JJ 42759 3169 24 - - HYPH 42759 3169 25 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3169 26 problem problem NN 42759 3169 27 would would MD 42759 3169 28 be be VB 42759 3169 29 relatively relatively RB 42759 3169 30 undisturbing undisturbing JJ 42759 3169 31 and and CC 42759 3169 32 unimportant unimportant JJ 42759 3169 33 . . . 42759 3170 1 The the DT 42759 3170 2 " " `` 42759 3170 3 specialisation specialisation NN 42759 3170 4 of of IN 42759 3170 5 function function NN 42759 3170 6 " " '' 42759 3170 7 in in IN 42759 3170 8 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3170 9 organisation organisation NN 42759 3170 10 , , , 42759 3170 11 as as IN 42759 3170 12 outlined outline VBN 42759 3170 13 by by IN 42759 3170 14 Mr. Mr. NNP 42759 3170 15 Williams Williams NNP 42759 3170 16 , , , 42759 3170 17 would would MD 42759 3170 18 give give VB 42759 3170 19 a a DT 42759 3170 20 balanced balanced JJ 42759 3170 21 economy economy NN 42759 3170 22 in in IN 42759 3170 23 which which WDT 42759 3170 24 the the DT 42759 3170 25 three three CD 42759 3170 26 great great JJ 42759 3170 27 socio socio JJ 42759 3170 28 - - HYPH 42759 3170 29 economic economic JJ 42759 3170 30 systems system NNS 42759 3170 31 and and CC 42759 3170 32 principles principle NNS 42759 3170 33 would would MD 42759 3170 34 have have VB 42759 3170 35 full full JJ 42759 3170 36 play play NN 42759 3170 37 , , , 42759 3170 38 and and CC 42759 3170 39 each each DT 42759 3170 40 would would MD 42759 3170 41 be be VB 42759 3170 42 required require VBN 42759 3170 43 to to TO 42759 3170 44 do do VB 42759 3170 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3170 46 best good JJS 42759 3170 47 in in IN 42759 3170 48 fair fair JJ 42759 3170 49 competition competition NN 42759 3170 50 with with IN 42759 3170 51 the the DT 42759 3170 52 other other JJ 42759 3170 53 two two CD 42759 3170 54 . . . 42759 3171 1 Economic economic JJ 42759 3171 2 life life NN 42759 3171 3 would would MD 42759 3171 4 exhibit exhibit VB 42759 3171 5 a a DT 42759 3171 6 diversity diversity NN 42759 3171 7 making make VBG 42759 3171 8 strongly strongly RB 42759 3171 9 for for IN 42759 3171 10 social social JJ 42759 3171 11 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 3171 12 and and CC 42759 3171 13 stability stability NN 42759 3171 14 , , , 42759 3171 15 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 3171 16 as as IN 42759 3171 17 no no DT 42759 3171 18 very very RB 42759 3171 19 large large JJ 42759 3171 20 section section NN 42759 3171 21 of of IN 42759 3171 22 the the DT 42759 3171 23 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3171 24 population population NN 42759 3171 25 would would MD 42759 3171 26 desire desire VB 42759 3171 27 to to TO 42759 3171 28 overthrow overthrow VB 42759 3171 29 the the DT 42759 3171 30 existing exist VBG 42759 3171 31 order order NN 42759 3171 32 . . . 42759 3172 1 Finally finally RB 42759 3172 2 , , , 42759 3172 3 the the DT 42759 3172 4 choice choice NN 42759 3172 5 of of IN 42759 3172 6 three three CD 42759 3172 7 great great JJ 42759 3172 8 systems system NNS 42759 3172 9 of of IN 42759 3172 10 industry industry NN 42759 3172 11 would would MD 42759 3172 12 offer offer VB 42759 3172 13 the the DT 42759 3172 14 utmost utmost JJ 42759 3172 15 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 3172 16 and and CC 42759 3172 17 scope scope NN 42759 3172 18 for for IN 42759 3172 19 the the DT 42759 3172 20 energies energy NNS 42759 3172 21 and and CC 42759 3172 22 the the DT 42759 3172 23 development development NN 42759 3172 24 of of IN 42759 3172 25 the the DT 42759 3172 26 individual individual NN 42759 3172 27 . . . 42759 3173 1 And and CC 42759 3173 2 this this DT 42759 3173 3 , , , 42759 3173 4 when when WRB 42759 3173 5 all all DT 42759 3173 6 is be VBZ 42759 3173 7 said say VBN 42759 3173 8 , , , 42759 3173 9 remains remain VBZ 42759 3173 10 the the DT 42759 3173 11 supreme supreme JJ 42759 3173 12 end end NN 42759 3173 13 of of IN 42759 3173 14 a a DT 42759 3173 15 just just JJ 42759 3173 16 and and CC 42759 3173 17 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3173 18 socio socio JJ 42759 3173 19 - - HYPH 42759 3173 20 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3173 21 organisation organisation NN 42759 3173 22 . . . 42759 3174 1 REFERENCES reference NNS 42759 3174 2 ON on IN 42759 3174 3 SECTION section NN 42759 3174 4 II II NNP 42759 3174 5 FISHER fisher NN 42759 3174 6 : : : 42759 3174 7 The the DT 42759 3174 8 Rate rate NN 42759 3174 9 of of IN 42759 3174 10 Interest interest NN 42759 3174 11 . . . 42759 3175 1 New New NNP 42759 3175 2 York York NNP 42759 3175 3 ; ; : 42759 3175 4 1907 1907 CD 42759 3175 5 . . . 42759 3176 1 CASSEL CASSEL NNS 42759 3176 2 : : : 42759 3176 3 Nature Nature NNP 42759 3176 4 and and CC 42759 3176 5 Necessity Necessity NNP 42759 3176 6 of of IN 42759 3176 7 Interest Interest NNP 42759 3176 8 . . . 42759 3177 1 London London NNP 42759 3177 2 ; ; : 42759 3177 3 1903 1903 CD 42759 3177 4 . . . 42759 3178 1 GONNER GONNER NNP 42759 3178 2 : : : 42759 3178 3 Interest interest NN 42759 3178 4 and and CC 42759 3178 5 Saving Saving NNP 42759 3178 6 . . . 42759 3179 1 London London NNP 42759 3179 2 ; ; : 42759 3179 3 1906 1906 CD 42759 3179 4 . . . 42759 3180 1 LANDRY LANDRY NNP 42759 3180 2 : : : 42759 3180 3 L'Intérêt L'Intérêt NNP 42759 3180 4 du du NNP 42759 3180 5 Capital Capital NNP 42759 3180 6 . . . 42759 3181 1 Paris Paris NNP 42759 3181 2 ; ; : 42759 3181 3 1904 1904 CD 42759 3181 4 . . . 42759 3182 1 MENGER MENGER NNP 42759 3182 2 : : : 42759 3182 3 The the DT 42759 3182 4 Right right UH 42759 3182 5 to to IN 42759 3182 6 the the DT 42759 3182 7 Whole Whole NNP 42759 3182 8 Produce Produce NNP 42759 3182 9 of of IN 42759 3182 10 Labour Labour NNP 42759 3182 11 . . . 42759 3183 1 London London NNP 42759 3183 2 ; ; : 42759 3183 3 1899 1899 CD 42759 3183 4 . . . 42759 3184 1 CATHREIN CATHREIN NNP 42759 3184 2 - - HYPH 42759 3184 3 GETTELMAN gettelman NN 42759 3184 4 : : : 42759 3184 5 Socialism socialism NN 42759 3184 6 . . . 42759 3185 1 St. St. NNP 42759 3185 2 Louis Louis NNP 42759 3185 3 ; ; : 42759 3185 4 1904 1904 CD 42759 3185 5 . . . 42759 3186 1 SKELTON SKELTON NNP 42759 3186 2 : : : 42759 3186 3 Socialism socialism NN 42759 3186 4 : : : 42759 3186 5 A a DT 42759 3186 6 Critical Critical NNP 42759 3186 7 Analysis Analysis NNP 42759 3186 8 . . . 42759 3187 1 New New NNP 42759 3187 2 York York NNP 42759 3187 3 ; ; : 42759 3187 4 1911 1911 CD 42759 3187 5 . . . 42759 3188 1 SPARGO SPARGO NNP 42759 3188 2 : : : 42759 3188 3 Socialism socialism NN 42759 3188 4 . . . 42759 3189 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 3189 2 ; ; : 42759 3189 3 1906 1906 CD 42759 3189 4 . . . 42759 3190 1 WALLING walling NN 42759 3190 2 : : : 42759 3190 3 Socialism socialism NN 42759 3190 4 As as IN 42759 3190 5 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3190 6 Is be VBZ 42759 3190 7 . . . 42759 3191 1 New New NNP 42759 3191 2 York York NNP 42759 3191 3 ; ; : 42759 3191 4 1912 1912 CD 42759 3191 5 . . . 42759 3192 1 HILLQUIT HILLQUIT NNP 42759 3192 2 - - HYPH 42759 3192 3 RYAN RYAN NNP 42759 3192 4 : : : 42759 3192 5 Socialism socialism NN 42759 3192 6 : : : 42759 3192 7 Promise promise NN 42759 3192 8 or or CC 42759 3192 9 Menace menace NN 42759 3192 10 ? ? . 42759 3193 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 3193 2 ; ; : 42759 3193 3 1914 1914 CD 42759 3193 4 . . . 42759 3194 1 SAVATIER SAVATIER NNP 42759 3194 2 : : : 42759 3194 3 La La NNP 42759 3194 4 Théorie Théorie NNP 42759 3194 5 Moderne Moderne NNP 42759 3194 6 du du NNP 42759 3194 7 Capital Capital NNP 42759 3194 8 et et FW 42759 3194 9 la la NNP 42759 3194 10 Justice Justice NNP 42759 3194 11 . . . 42759 3195 1 Paris Paris NNP 42759 3195 2 ; ; : 42759 3195 3 1898 1898 CD 42759 3195 4 . . . 42759 3196 1 GARRIGUET GARRIGUET NNS 42759 3196 2 : : : 42759 3196 3 Régime Régime NNP 42759 3196 4 du du VB 42759 3196 5 Travail Travail NNP 42759 3196 6 . . . 42759 3197 1 Paris Paris NNP 42759 3197 2 ; ; : 42759 3197 3 1908 1908 CD 42759 3197 4 . . . 42759 3198 1 FUNK FUNK NNP 42759 3198 2 : : : 42759 3198 3 Zins Zins NNP 42759 3198 4 und und VBP 42759 3198 5 Wucher Wucher NNP 42759 3198 6 . . . 42759 3199 1 Tübingen tübingen NN 42759 3199 2 ; ; : 42759 3199 3 1868 1868 CD 42759 3199 4 . . . 42759 3200 1 HOLYOAKE HOLYOAKE NNP 42759 3200 2 : : : 42759 3200 3 The the DT 42759 3200 4 History history NN 42759 3200 5 of of IN 42759 3200 6 Co co NN 42759 3200 7 - - NN 42759 3200 8 operation operation NN 42759 3200 9 . . . 42759 3201 1 London London NNP 42759 3201 2 ; ; : 42759 3201 3 1906 1906 CD 42759 3201 4 . . . 42759 3202 1 FAY FAY NNP 42759 3202 2 : : : 42759 3202 3 Co co NN 42759 3202 4 - - NN 42759 3202 5 operation operation NN 42759 3202 6 at at IN 42759 3202 7 Home Home NNP 42759 3202 8 and and CC 42759 3202 9 Abroad abroad RB 42759 3202 10 . . . 42759 3203 1 London London NNP 42759 3203 2 ; ; : 42759 3203 3 1908 1908 CD 42759 3203 4 . . . 42759 3204 1 WILLIAMS WILLIAMS NNP 42759 3204 2 : : : 42759 3204 3 Copartnership Copartnership NNP 42759 3204 4 and and CC 42759 3204 5 Profit Profit NNP 42759 3204 6 - - HYPH 42759 3204 7 Sharing Sharing NNP 42759 3204 8 . . . 42759 3205 1 Henry Henry NNP 42759 3205 2 Holt Holt NNP 42759 3205 3 & & CC 42759 3205 4 Co. Co. NNP 42759 3205 5 ; ; : 42759 3205 6 1913 1913 CD 42759 3205 7 . . . 42759 3206 1 MANN MANN NNP 42759 3206 2 , , , 42759 3206 3 SIEVERS SIEVERS NNP 42759 3206 4 , , , 42759 3206 5 COX COX NNP 42759 3206 6 : : : 42759 3206 7 The the DT 42759 3206 8 Real real JJ 42759 3206 9 Democracy democracy NN 42759 3206 10 . . . 42759 3207 1 London London NNP 42759 3207 2 ; ; : 42759 3207 3 1913 1913 CD 42759 3207 4 . . . 42759 3208 1 Also also RB 42759 3208 2 the the DT 42759 3208 3 works work NNS 42759 3208 4 of of IN 42759 3208 5 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 3208 6 , , , 42759 3208 7 Devas Devas NNP 42759 3208 8 , , , 42759 3208 9 Antoine Antoine NNP 42759 3208 10 , , , 42759 3208 11 Hobson Hobson NNP 42759 3208 12 , , , 42759 3208 13 Nearing Nearing NNP 42759 3208 14 , , , 42759 3208 15 Willoughby Willoughby NNP 42759 3208 16 , , , 42759 3208 17 and and CC 42759 3208 18 Hitze Hitze NNP 42759 3208 19 , , , 42759 3208 20 which which WDT 42759 3208 21 were be VBD 42759 3208 22 given give VBN 42759 3208 23 at at IN 42759 3208 24 the the DT 42759 3208 25 end end NN 42759 3208 26 of of IN 42759 3208 27 the the DT 42759 3208 28 introductory introductory JJ 42759 3208 29 chapter chapter NN 42759 3208 30 . . . 42759 3209 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 3209 2 : : : 42759 3209 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3209 4 153 153 CD 42759 3209 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3209 6 Professor Professor NNP 42759 3209 7 Scott Scott NNP 42759 3209 8 Nearing Nearing NNP 42759 3209 9 estimates estimate VBZ 42759 3209 10 the the DT 42759 3209 11 annual annual JJ 42759 3209 12 income income NN 42759 3209 13 derived derive VBN 42759 3209 14 from from IN 42759 3209 15 the the DT 42759 3209 16 ownership ownership NN 42759 3209 17 of of IN 42759 3209 18 property property NN 42759 3209 19 in in IN 42759 3209 20 the the DT 42759 3209 21 United United NNP 42759 3209 22 States States NNP 42759 3209 23 ; ; : 42759 3209 24 that that RB 42759 3209 25 is is RB 42759 3209 26 , , , 42759 3209 27 land land NN 42759 3209 28 and and CC 42759 3209 29 all all DT 42759 3209 30 forms form NNS 42759 3209 31 of of IN 42759 3209 32 capital capital NN 42759 3209 33 , , , 42759 3209 34 at at IN 42759 3209 35 from from IN 42759 3209 36 six six CD 42759 3209 37 to to TO 42759 3209 38 nine nine CD 42759 3209 39 billion billion CD 42759 3209 40 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3209 41 . . . 42759 3210 1 Professor Professor NNP 42759 3210 2 W. W. NNP 42759 3210 3 I. I. NNP 42759 3211 1 King King NNP 42759 3211 2 gives give VBZ 42759 3211 3 the the DT 42759 3211 4 combined combined JJ 42759 3211 5 shares share NNS 42759 3211 6 of of IN 42759 3211 7 the the DT 42759 3211 8 national national JJ 42759 3211 9 income income NN 42759 3211 10 received receive VBN 42759 3211 11 by by IN 42759 3211 12 the the DT 42759 3211 13 landowners landowner NNS 42759 3211 14 and and CC 42759 3211 15 the the DT 42759 3211 16 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 3211 17 at at IN 42759 3211 18 more more JJR 42759 3211 19 than than IN 42759 3211 20 six six CD 42759 3211 21 and and CC 42759 3211 22 three three CD 42759 3211 23 - - HYPH 42759 3211 24 quarter quarter NN 42759 3211 25 billions billion NNS 42759 3211 26 in in IN 42759 3211 27 1910 1910 CD 42759 3211 28 . . . 42759 3212 1 According accord VBG 42759 3212 2 to to IN 42759 3212 3 the the DT 42759 3212 4 Census Census NNP 42759 3212 5 Bulletin Bulletin NNP 42759 3212 6 on on IN 42759 3212 7 the the DT 42759 3212 8 " " `` 42759 3212 9 Estimated estimated JJ 42759 3212 10 Valuation Valuation NNP 42759 3212 11 of of IN 42759 3212 12 National National NNP 42759 3212 13 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 3212 14 , , , 42759 3212 15 " " '' 42759 3212 16 the the DT 42759 3212 17 capital capital NN 42759 3212 18 goods good NNS 42759 3212 19 of of IN 42759 3212 20 the the DT 42759 3212 21 country country NN 42759 3212 22 were be VBD 42759 3212 23 in in IN 42759 3212 24 1912 1912 CD 42759 3212 25 approximately approximately RB 42759 3212 26 $ $ $ 42759 3212 27 175,000,000,000.00 175,000,000,000.00 CD 42759 3212 28 . . . 42759 3213 1 At at IN 42759 3213 2 four four CD 42759 3213 3 per per NN 42759 3213 4 cent cent NN 42759 3213 5 . . . 42759 3214 1 this this DT 42759 3214 2 would would MD 42759 3214 3 mean mean VB 42759 3214 4 an an DT 42759 3214 5 annual annual JJ 42759 3214 6 income income NN 42759 3214 7 of of IN 42759 3214 8 seven seven CD 42759 3214 9 billion billion CD 42759 3214 10 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3214 11 . . . 42759 3215 1 The the DT 42759 3215 2 lowest low JJS 42759 3215 3 of of IN 42759 3215 4 the the DT 42759 3215 5 three three CD 42759 3215 6 estimates estimate NNS 42759 3215 7 , , , 42759 3215 8 six six CD 42759 3215 9 billion billion CD 42759 3215 10 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3215 11 , , , 42759 3215 12 is be VBZ 42759 3215 13 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 3215 14 to to IN 42759 3215 15 more more JJR 42759 3215 16 than than IN 42759 3215 17 sixty sixty JJ 42759 3215 18 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3215 19 a a DT 42759 3215 20 year year NN 42759 3215 21 for for IN 42759 3215 22 every every DT 42759 3215 23 man man NN 42759 3215 24 , , , 42759 3215 25 woman woman NN 42759 3215 26 , , , 42759 3215 27 and and CC 42759 3215 28 child child NN 42759 3215 29 in in IN 42759 3215 30 the the DT 42759 3215 31 United United NNP 42759 3215 32 States States NNP 42759 3215 33 . . . 42759 3216 1 If if IN 42759 3216 2 that that DT 42759 3216 3 sum sum NN 42759 3216 4 were be VBD 42759 3216 5 equally equally RB 42759 3216 6 distributed distribute VBN 42759 3216 7 among among IN 42759 3216 8 the the DT 42759 3216 9 whole whole JJ 42759 3216 10 population population NN 42759 3216 11 , , , 42759 3216 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3216 13 would would MD 42759 3216 14 mean mean VB 42759 3216 15 an an DT 42759 3216 16 increase increase NN 42759 3216 17 of of IN 42759 3216 18 between between IN 42759 3216 19 forty forty CD 42759 3216 20 and and CC 42759 3216 21 sixty sixty CD 42759 3216 22 per per IN 42759 3216 23 cent cent NN 42759 3216 24 . . . 42759 3217 1 in in IN 42759 3217 2 the the DT 42759 3217 3 income income NN 42759 3217 4 of of IN 42759 3217 5 the the DT 42759 3217 6 majority majority NN 42759 3217 7 of of IN 42759 3217 8 workingmen workingman NNS 42759 3217 9 's 's POS 42759 3217 10 families family NNS 42759 3217 11 ! ! . 42759 3218 1 Nor nor CC 42759 3218 2 do do VBP 42759 3218 3 present present JJ 42759 3218 4 tendencies tendency NNS 42759 3218 5 hold hold VB 42759 3218 6 out out RP 42759 3218 7 any any DT 42759 3218 8 hope hope NN 42759 3218 9 of of IN 42759 3218 10 an an DT 42759 3218 11 automatic automatic JJ 42759 3218 12 reduction reduction NN 42759 3218 13 of of IN 42759 3218 14 the the DT 42759 3218 15 interest interest NN 42759 3218 16 - - HYPH 42759 3218 17 burden burden NN 42759 3218 18 in in IN 42759 3218 19 the the DT 42759 3218 20 future future NN 42759 3218 21 . . . 42759 3219 1 In in IN 42759 3219 2 the the DT 42759 3219 3 opinion opinion NN 42759 3219 4 of of IN 42759 3219 5 Professor Professor NNP 42759 3219 6 Scott Scott NNP 42759 3219 7 Nearing Nearing NNP 42759 3219 8 , , , 42759 3219 9 " " '' 42759 3219 10 the the DT 42759 3219 11 present present JJ 42759 3219 12 economic economic JJ 42759 3219 13 tendencies tendency NNS 42759 3219 14 will will MD 42759 3219 15 greatly greatly RB 42759 3219 16 increase increase VB 42759 3219 17 the the DT 42759 3219 18 amount amount NN 42759 3219 19 of of IN 42759 3219 20 property property NN 42759 3219 21 income income NN 42759 3219 22 paid pay VBN 42759 3219 23 with with IN 42759 3219 24 each each DT 42759 3219 25 passing pass VBG 42759 3219 26 decade decade NN 42759 3219 27 . . . 42759 3219 28 " " '' 42759 3220 1 " " `` 42759 3220 2 Income income NN 42759 3220 3 , , , 42759 3220 4 " " '' 42759 3220 5 p. p. NN 42759 3220 6 199 199 CD 42759 3220 7 ; ; : 42759 3220 8 New New NNP 42759 3220 9 York York NNP 42759 3220 10 , , , 42759 3220 11 1915 1915 CD 42759 3220 12 . . . 42759 3221 1 See see VB 42759 3221 2 especially especially RB 42759 3221 3 ch ch PRP 42759 3221 4 . . . 42759 3222 1 vii vii NN 42759 3222 2 . . . 42759 3223 1 According accord VBG 42759 3223 2 to to IN 42759 3223 3 Professor Professor NNP 42759 3223 4 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 3223 5 , , , 42759 3223 6 " " '' 42759 3223 7 the the DT 42759 3223 8 absolute absolute JJ 42759 3223 9 amount amount NN 42759 3223 10 of of IN 42759 3223 11 income income NN 42759 3223 12 going go VBG 42759 3223 13 to to IN 42759 3223 14 this this DT 42759 3223 15 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3223 16 the the DT 42759 3223 17 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 3223 18 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3223 19 class class NN 42759 3223 20 tends tend VBZ 42759 3223 21 to to TO 42759 3223 22 increase increase VB 42759 3223 23 , , , 42759 3223 24 and and CC 42759 3223 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3223 26 share share NN 42759 3223 27 of of IN 42759 3223 28 the the DT 42759 3223 29 total total JJ 42759 3223 30 income income NN 42759 3223 31 tends tend VBZ 42759 3223 32 also also RB 42759 3223 33 to to TO 42759 3223 34 increase increase VB 42759 3223 35 ; ; : 42759 3223 36 whereas whereas IN 42759 3223 37 for for IN 42759 3223 38 the the DT 42759 3223 39 labourers labourer NNS 42759 3223 40 , , , 42759 3223 41 though though IN 42759 3223 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3223 43 total total JJ 42759 3223 44 income income NN 42759 3223 45 may may MD 42759 3223 46 increase increase VB 42759 3223 47 , , , 42759 3223 48 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3223 49 share share NN 42759 3223 50 of of IN 42759 3223 51 income income NN 42759 3223 52 of of IN 42759 3223 53 society society NN 42759 3223 54 as as IN 42759 3223 55 a a DT 42759 3223 56 whole whole NN 42759 3223 57 tends tend VBZ 42759 3223 58 to to TO 42759 3223 59 decline decline VB 42759 3223 60 . . . 42759 3223 61 " " '' 42759 3224 1 " " `` 42759 3224 2 Principles Principles NNPS 42759 3224 3 of of IN 42759 3224 4 Economics Economics NNP 42759 3224 5 , , , 42759 3224 6 " " '' 42759 3224 7 II ii CD 42759 3224 8 , , , 42759 3224 9 205 205 CD 42759 3224 10 . . . 42759 3225 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3225 2 154 154 CD 42759 3225 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3225 4 " " `` 42759 3225 5 Lehrbuch lehrbuch NN 42759 3225 6 der der NN 42759 3225 7 Nationaloekonomie Nationaloekonomie NNP 42759 3225 8 , , , 42759 3225 9 " " `` 42759 3225 10 III iii CD 42759 3225 11 , , , 42759 3225 12 517 517 CD 42759 3225 13 . . . 42759 3226 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3226 2 155 155 CD 42759 3226 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3226 4 Fay fay VB 42759 3226 5 , , , 42759 3226 6 " " '' 42759 3226 7 Co co NN 42759 3226 8 - - NN 42759 3226 9 operation operation NN 42759 3226 10 at at IN 42759 3226 11 Home Home NNP 42759 3226 12 and and CC 42759 3226 13 Abroad abroad RB 42759 3226 14 , , , 42759 3226 15 " " '' 42759 3226 16 p. p. NN 42759 3226 17 340 340 CD 42759 3226 18 . . . 42759 3227 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3227 2 156 156 CD 42759 3227 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3227 4 Schloss Schloss NNP 42759 3227 5 , , , 42759 3227 6 " " `` 42759 3227 7 Methods method NNS 42759 3227 8 of of IN 42759 3227 9 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 3227 10 Remuneration Remuneration NNP 42759 3227 11 , , , 42759 3227 12 " " '' 42759 3227 13 pp pp NNP 42759 3227 14 . . . 42759 3228 1 353 353 CD 42759 3228 2 , , , 42759 3228 3 354 354 CD 42759 3228 4 . . . 42759 3229 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3229 2 157 157 CD 42759 3229 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3229 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 3229 5 . . NNP 42759 3229 6 , , , 42759 3229 7 however however RB 42759 3229 8 , , , 42759 3229 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 42759 3229 10 A. A. NNP 42759 3229 11 R. R. NNP 42759 3229 12 Orage Orage NNP 42759 3229 13 's 's POS 42759 3229 14 work work NN 42759 3229 15 , , , 42759 3229 16 " " `` 42759 3229 17 National National NNP 42759 3229 18 Guilds Guilds NNP 42759 3229 19 , , , 42759 3229 20 " " '' 42759 3229 21 London London NNP 42759 3229 22 , , , 42759 3229 23 1914 1914 CD 42759 3229 24 . . . 42759 3230 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3230 2 158 158 CD 42759 3230 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3230 4 Op Op NNP 42759 3230 5 . . . 42759 3231 1 cit cit NNP 42759 3231 2 . . NNP 42759 3231 3 , , , 42759 3231 4 p. p. NN 42759 3231 5 341 341 CD 42759 3231 6 . . . 42759 3232 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3232 2 159 159 CD 42759 3232 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3232 4 " " `` 42759 3232 5 Copartnership Copartnership NNP 42759 3232 6 and and CC 42759 3232 7 Profit Profit NNP 42759 3232 8 - - HYPH 42759 3232 9 Sharing Sharing NNP 42759 3232 10 , , , 42759 3232 11 " " '' 42759 3232 12 p. p. NN 42759 3232 13 235 235 CD 42759 3232 14 . . . 42759 3233 1 SECTION section NN 42759 3233 2 III III NNP 42759 3233 3 THE the DT 42759 3233 4 MORAL moral JJ 42759 3233 5 ASPECT ASPECT NNS 42759 3233 6 OF of IN 42759 3233 7 PROFITS profits JJ 42759 3233 8 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 42759 3233 9 XV XV NNP 42759 3233 10 THE the DT 42759 3233 11 NATURE NATURE NNS 42759 3233 12 OF of IN 42759 3233 13 PROFITS profit NNS 42759 3233 14 We -PRON- PRP 42759 3233 15 have have VBP 42759 3233 16 seen see VBN 42759 3233 17 that that DT 42759 3233 18 rent rent NN 42759 3233 19 goes go VBZ 42759 3233 20 to to IN 42759 3233 21 the the DT 42759 3233 22 landlord landlord NN 42759 3233 23 as as IN 42759 3233 24 the the DT 42759 3233 25 price price NN 42759 3233 26 of of IN 42759 3233 27 land land NN 42759 3233 28 use use NN 42759 3233 29 , , , 42759 3233 30 while while IN 42759 3233 31 interest interest NN 42759 3233 32 is be VBZ 42759 3233 33 received receive VBN 42759 3233 34 by by IN 42759 3233 35 the the DT 42759 3233 36 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 3233 37 as as IN 42759 3233 38 the the DT 42759 3233 39 return return NN 42759 3233 40 for for IN 42759 3233 41 the the DT 42759 3233 42 use use NN 42759 3233 43 of of IN 42759 3233 44 capital capital NN 42759 3233 45 . . . 42759 3234 1 The the DT 42759 3234 2 two two CD 42759 3234 3 shares share NNS 42759 3234 4 of of IN 42759 3234 5 the the DT 42759 3234 6 product product NN 42759 3234 7 which which WDT 42759 3234 8 remain remain VBP 42759 3234 9 to to TO 42759 3234 10 be be VB 42759 3234 11 considered consider VBN 42759 3234 12 include include VBP 42759 3234 13 an an DT 42759 3234 14 element element NN 42759 3234 15 which which WDT 42759 3234 16 is be VBZ 42759 3234 17 absent absent JJ 42759 3234 18 from from IN 42759 3234 19 both both CC 42759 3234 20 rent rent NN 42759 3234 21 and and CC 42759 3234 22 interest interest NN 42759 3234 23 . . . 42759 3235 1 The the DT 42759 3235 2 use use NN 42759 3235 3 for for IN 42759 3235 4 which which WDT 42759 3235 5 profits profit NNS 42759 3235 6 and and CC 42759 3235 7 wages wage NNS 42759 3235 8 are be VBP 42759 3235 9 paid pay VBN 42759 3235 10 comprises comprise NNS 42759 3235 11 not not RB 42759 3235 12 merely merely RB 42759 3235 13 the the DT 42759 3235 14 utilisation utilisation NN 42759 3235 15 of of IN 42759 3235 16 a a DT 42759 3235 17 productive productive JJ 42759 3235 18 factor factor NN 42759 3235 19 , , , 42759 3235 20 but but CC 42759 3235 21 the the DT 42759 3235 22 sustained sustained JJ 42759 3235 23 exertion exertion NN 42759 3235 24 of of IN 42759 3235 25 the the DT 42759 3235 26 factor factor NN 42759 3235 27 's 's POS 42759 3235 28 owner owner NN 42759 3235 29 . . . 42759 3236 1 Like like IN 42759 3236 2 the the DT 42759 3236 3 landowner landowner NN 42759 3236 4 and and CC 42759 3236 5 the the DT 42759 3236 6 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 3236 7 , , , 42759 3236 8 the the DT 42759 3236 9 business business NN 42759 3236 10 man man NN 42759 3236 11 and and CC 42759 3236 12 the the DT 42759 3236 13 labourer labourer NN 42759 3236 14 put put VBD 42759 3236 15 the the DT 42759 3236 16 productive productive JJ 42759 3236 17 factors factor NNS 42759 3236 18 which which WDT 42759 3236 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3236 20 control control VBP 42759 3236 21 at at IN 42759 3236 22 the the DT 42759 3236 23 disposal disposal NN 42759 3236 24 of of IN 42759 3236 25 the the DT 42759 3236 26 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3236 27 process process NN 42759 3236 28 ; ; : 42759 3236 29 but but CC 42759 3236 30 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3236 31 do do VBP 42759 3236 32 so so RB 42759 3236 33 only only RB 42759 3236 34 when when WRB 42759 3236 35 and and CC 42759 3236 36 so so RB 42759 3236 37 long long RB 42759 3236 38 as as IN 42759 3236 39 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3236 40 exercise exercise VBP 42759 3236 41 human human JJ 42759 3236 42 activity activity NN 42759 3236 43 . . . 42759 3237 1 The the DT 42759 3237 2 shares share NNS 42759 3237 3 that that WDT 42759 3237 4 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3237 5 receive receive VBP 42759 3237 6 are be VBP 42759 3237 7 payments payment NNS 42759 3237 8 for for IN 42759 3237 9 the the DT 42759 3237 10 continuous continuous JJ 42759 3237 11 output output NN 42759 3237 12 of of IN 42759 3237 13 human human JJ 42759 3237 14 energy energy NN 42759 3237 15 . . . 42759 3238 1 No no DT 42759 3238 2 such such JJ 42759 3238 3 significance significance NN 42759 3238 4 attaches attach VBZ 42759 3238 5 to to TO 42759 3238 6 rent rent VB 42759 3238 7 or or CC 42759 3238 8 interest interest NN 42759 3238 9 . . . 42759 3239 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3239 2 The the DT 42759 3239 3 Functions Functions NNPS 42759 3239 4 and and CC 42759 3239 5 Rewards Rewards NNPS 42759 3239 6 of of IN 42759 3239 7 the the DT 42759 3239 8 Business Business NNP 42759 3239 9 Man Man NNP 42759 3239 10 _ _ NNP 42759 3239 11 Who who WP 42759 3239 12 is be VBZ 42759 3239 13 the the DT 42759 3239 14 business business NN 42759 3239 15 man man NN 42759 3239 16 , , , 42759 3239 17 and and CC 42759 3239 18 what what WP 42759 3239 19 is be VBZ 42759 3239 20 the the DT 42759 3239 21 nature nature NN 42759 3239 22 of of IN 42759 3239 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3239 24 share share NN 42759 3239 25 of of IN 42759 3239 26 the the DT 42759 3239 27 product product NN 42759 3239 28 of of IN 42759 3239 29 industry industry NN 42759 3239 30 ? ? . 42759 3240 1 Let let VB 42759 3240 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3240 3 suppose suppose VB 42759 3240 4 that that IN 42759 3240 5 the the DT 42759 3240 6 salaried salaried JJ 42759 3240 7 manager manager NN 42759 3240 8 of of IN 42759 3240 9 a a DT 42759 3240 10 hat hat NN 42759 3240 11 factory factory NN 42759 3240 12 decides decide VBZ 42759 3240 13 to to TO 42759 3240 14 set set VB 42759 3240 15 up up RP 42759 3240 16 a a DT 42759 3240 17 business business NN 42759 3240 18 of of IN 42759 3240 19 the the DT 42759 3240 20 same same JJ 42759 3240 21 kind kind NN 42759 3240 22 for for IN 42759 3240 23 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 3240 24 . . . 42759 3241 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 3241 2 wishes wish VBZ 42759 3241 3 to to TO 42759 3241 4 become become VB 42759 3241 5 an an DT 42759 3241 6 entrepreneur entrepreneur NN 42759 3241 7 , , , 42759 3241 8 an an DT 42759 3241 9 undertaker undertaker NN 42759 3241 10 , , , 42759 3241 11 a a DT 42759 3241 12 director director NN 42759 3241 13 of of IN 42759 3241 14 industry industry NN 42759 3241 15 , , , 42759 3241 16 in in IN 42759 3241 17 more more RBR 42759 3241 18 familiar familiar JJ 42759 3241 19 language language NN 42759 3241 20 , , , 42759 3241 21 a a DT 42759 3241 22 business business NN 42759 3241 23 man man NN 42759 3241 24 . . . 42759 3242 1 Let let VB 42759 3242 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3242 3 assume assume VB 42759 3242 4 that that IN 42759 3242 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3242 6 is be VBZ 42759 3242 7 without without IN 42759 3242 8 money money NN 42759 3242 9 , , , 42759 3242 10 but but CC 42759 3242 11 that that IN 42759 3242 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3242 13 commands command VBZ 42759 3242 14 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 42759 3242 15 financial financial JJ 42759 3242 16 credit credit NN 42759 3242 17 . . . 42759 3243 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 3243 2 is be VBZ 42759 3243 3 able able JJ 42759 3243 4 to to TO 42759 3243 5 borrow borrow VB 42759 3243 6 half half PDT 42759 3243 7 a a DT 42759 3243 8 million million CD 42759 3243 9 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3243 10 with with IN 42759 3243 11 which which WDT 42759 3243 12 to to TO 42759 3243 13 organise organise VB 42759 3243 14 , , , 42759 3243 15 equip equip NNP 42759 3243 16 , , , 42759 3243 17 and and CC 42759 3243 18 operate operate VBP 42759 3243 19 the the DT 42759 3243 20 new new JJ 42759 3243 21 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3243 22 . . . 42759 3244 1 Having have VBG 42759 3244 2 selected select VBN 42759 3244 3 a a DT 42759 3244 4 favourable favourable JJ 42759 3244 5 site site NN 42759 3244 6 , , , 42759 3244 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3244 8 rents rent VBZ 42759 3244 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3244 10 on on IN 42759 3244 11 a a DT 42759 3244 12 long long JJ 42759 3244 13 term term NN 42759 3244 14 lease lease NN 42759 3244 15 , , , 42759 3244 16 and and CC 42759 3244 17 erects erect VBZ 42759 3244 18 thereon thereon NN 42759 3244 19 the the DT 42759 3244 20 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3244 21 buildings building NNS 42759 3244 22 . . . 42759 3245 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 3245 2 installs install VBZ 42759 3245 3 all all PDT 42759 3245 4 the the DT 42759 3245 5 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3245 6 machinery machinery NN 42759 3245 7 and and CC 42759 3245 8 other other JJ 42759 3245 9 equipment equipment NN 42759 3245 10 , , , 42759 3245 11 hires hire VBZ 42759 3245 12 capable capable JJ 42759 3245 13 labour labour NN 42759 3245 14 , , , 42759 3245 15 and and CC 42759 3245 16 determines determine VBZ 42759 3245 17 the the DT 42759 3245 18 kinds kind NNS 42759 3245 19 and and CC 42759 3245 20 quantities quantity NNS 42759 3245 21 of of IN 42759 3245 22 hats hat NNS 42759 3245 23 for for IN 42759 3245 24 which which WDT 42759 3245 25 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3245 26 thinks think VBZ 42759 3245 27 that that IN 42759 3245 28 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3245 29 can can MD 42759 3245 30 find find VB 42759 3245 31 a a DT 42759 3245 32 market market NN 42759 3245 33 . . . 42759 3246 1 At at IN 42759 3246 2 the the DT 42759 3246 3 end end NN 42759 3246 4 of of IN 42759 3246 5 a a DT 42759 3246 6 year year NN 42759 3246 7 , , , 42759 3246 8 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3246 9 realises realise VBZ 42759 3246 10 that that IN 42759 3246 11 , , , 42759 3246 12 after after IN 42759 3246 13 paying pay VBG 42759 3246 14 for for IN 42759 3246 15 labour labour NN 42759 3246 16 of of IN 42759 3246 17 all all DT 42759 3246 18 sorts sort NNS 42759 3246 19 , , , 42759 3246 20 returning return VBG 42759 3246 21 interest interest NN 42759 3246 22 to to IN 42759 3246 23 the the DT 42759 3246 24 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 3246 25 and and CC 42759 3246 26 rent rent VB 42759 3246 27 to to IN 42759 3246 28 the the DT 42759 3246 29 landowner landowner NN 42759 3246 30 , , , 42759 3246 31 defraying defray VBG 42759 3246 32 the the DT 42759 3246 33 cost cost NN 42759 3246 34 of of IN 42759 3246 35 repairs repair NNS 42759 3246 36 , , , 42759 3246 37 and and CC 42759 3246 38 setting set VBG 42759 3246 39 aside aside RP 42759 3246 40 a a DT 42759 3246 41 fund fund NN 42759 3246 42 to to TO 42759 3246 43 cover cover VB 42759 3246 44 depreciation depreciation NN 42759 3246 45 , , , 42759 3246 46 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3246 47 has have VBZ 42759 3246 48 left leave VBN 42759 3246 49 for for IN 42759 3246 50 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 3246 51 the the DT 42759 3246 52 sum sum NN 42759 3246 53 of of IN 42759 3246 54 ten ten CD 42759 3246 55 thousand thousand CD 42759 3246 56 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3246 57 . . . 42759 3247 1 This this DT 42759 3247 2 is be VBZ 42759 3247 3 the the DT 42759 3247 4 return return NN 42759 3247 5 for for IN 42759 3247 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3247 7 labour labour NN 42759 3247 8 of of IN 42759 3247 9 organisation organisation NN 42759 3247 10 and and CC 42759 3247 11 direction direction NN 42759 3247 12 , , , 42759 3247 13 and and CC 42759 3247 14 for for IN 42759 3247 15 the the DT 42759 3247 16 risk risk NN 42759 3247 17 that that IN 42759 3247 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3247 19 underwent undergo VBD 42759 3247 20 . . . 42759 3248 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3248 2 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 3248 3 the the DT 42759 3248 4 share share NN 42759 3248 5 called call VBN 42759 3248 6 profits profit NNS 42759 3248 7 , , , 42759 3248 8 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3248 9 specified specify VBN 42759 3248 10 as as IN 42759 3248 11 net net JJ 42759 3248 12 profits profit NNS 42759 3248 13 . . . 42759 3249 1 This this DT 42759 3249 2 case case NN 42759 3249 3 is be VBZ 42759 3249 4 artificial artificial JJ 42759 3249 5 , , , 42759 3249 6 since since IN 42759 3249 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3249 8 assumes assume VBZ 42759 3249 9 that that IN 42759 3249 10 the the DT 42759 3249 11 business business NN 42759 3249 12 man man NN 42759 3249 13 is be VBZ 42759 3249 14 neither neither CC 42759 3249 15 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 3249 16 nor nor CC 42759 3249 17 landowner landown JJR 42759 3249 18 in in IN 42759 3249 19 addition addition NN 42759 3249 20 to to IN 42759 3249 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3249 22 function function NN 42759 3249 23 as as IN 42759 3249 24 director director NN 42759 3249 25 of of IN 42759 3249 26 industry industry NN 42759 3249 27 . . . 42759 3250 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3250 2 has have VBZ 42759 3250 3 , , , 42759 3250 4 however however RB 42759 3250 5 , , , 42759 3250 6 the the DT 42759 3250 7 advantage advantage NN 42759 3250 8 of of IN 42759 3250 9 distinguishing distinguish VBG 42759 3250 10 quite quite RB 42759 3250 11 sharply sharply RB 42759 3250 12 the the DT 42759 3250 13 action action NN 42759 3250 14 of of IN 42759 3250 15 the the DT 42759 3250 16 business business NN 42759 3250 17 man man NN 42759 3250 18 as as IN 42759 3250 19 such such JJ 42759 3250 20 . . . 42759 3251 1 For for IN 42759 3251 2 the the DT 42759 3251 3 latter latter JJ 42759 3251 4 merely merely RB 42759 3251 5 organises organise NNS 42759 3251 6 , , , 42759 3251 7 directs direct NNS 42759 3251 8 , , , 42759 3251 9 and and CC 42759 3251 10 takes take VBZ 42759 3251 11 the the DT 42759 3251 12 risks risk NNS 42759 3251 13 of of IN 42759 3251 14 the the DT 42759 3251 15 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3251 16 process process NN 42759 3251 17 , , , 42759 3251 18 finds find VBZ 42759 3251 19 a a DT 42759 3251 20 market market NN 42759 3251 21 for for IN 42759 3251 22 the the DT 42759 3251 23 product product NN 42759 3251 24 , , , 42759 3251 25 and and CC 42759 3251 26 receives receive VBZ 42759 3251 27 in in IN 42759 3251 28 return return NN 42759 3251 29 neither neither CC 42759 3251 30 rent rent NN 42759 3251 31 nor nor CC 42759 3251 32 interest interest NN 42759 3251 33 but but CC 42759 3251 34 only only RB 42759 3251 35 profits profit NNS 42759 3251 36 . . . 42759 3252 1 In in IN 42759 3252 2 point point NN 42759 3252 3 of of IN 42759 3252 4 fact fact NN 42759 3252 5 , , , 42759 3252 6 however however RB 42759 3252 7 , , , 42759 3252 8 no no DT 42759 3252 9 one one NN 42759 3252 10 ever ever RB 42759 3252 11 functions function NNS 42759 3252 12 solely solely RB 42759 3252 13 as as IN 42759 3252 14 business business NN 42759 3252 15 man man NN 42759 3252 16 . . . 42759 3253 1 Always always RB 42759 3253 2 the the DT 42759 3253 3 business business NN 42759 3253 4 man man NN 42759 3253 5 owns own VBZ 42759 3253 6 some some DT 42759 3253 7 of of IN 42759 3253 8 the the DT 42759 3253 9 capital capital NN 42759 3253 10 , , , 42759 3253 11 and and CC 42759 3253 12 very very RB 42759 3253 13 often often RB 42759 3253 14 some some DT 42759 3253 15 of of IN 42759 3253 16 the the DT 42759 3253 17 land land NN 42759 3253 18 involved involve VBN 42759 3253 19 in in IN 42759 3253 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3253 21 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3253 22 , , , 42759 3253 23 and and CC 42759 3253 24 is be VBZ 42759 3253 25 the the DT 42759 3253 26 receiver receiver NN 42759 3253 27 not not RB 42759 3253 28 only only RB 42759 3253 29 of of IN 42759 3253 30 profits profit NNS 42759 3253 31 but but CC 42759 3253 32 of of IN 42759 3253 33 interest interest NN 42759 3253 34 and and CC 42759 3253 35 rent rent NN 42759 3253 36 . . . 42759 3254 1 Thus thus RB 42759 3254 2 , , , 42759 3254 3 the the DT 42759 3254 4 farmer farmer NN 42759 3254 5 is be VBZ 42759 3254 6 a a DT 42759 3254 7 business business NN 42759 3254 8 man man NN 42759 3254 9 , , , 42759 3254 10 but but CC 42759 3254 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3254 12 is be VBZ 42759 3254 13 also also RB 42759 3254 14 a a DT 42759 3254 15 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 3254 16 , , , 42759 3254 17 and and CC 42759 3254 18 frequently frequently RB 42759 3254 19 a a DT 42759 3254 20 landowner landowner NN 42759 3254 21 . . . 42759 3255 1 The the DT 42759 3255 2 grocer grocer NN 42759 3255 3 , , , 42759 3255 4 the the DT 42759 3255 5 clothier clothier NN 42759 3255 6 , , , 42759 3255 7 the the DT 42759 3255 8 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 3255 9 , , , 42759 3255 10 and and CC 42759 3255 11 even even RB 42759 3255 12 the the DT 42759 3255 13 lawyer lawyer NN 42759 3255 14 and and CC 42759 3255 15 the the DT 42759 3255 16 doctor doctor NN 42759 3255 17 own own VBP 42759 3255 18 a a DT 42759 3255 19 part part NN 42759 3255 20 at at IN 42759 3255 21 least least JJS 42759 3255 22 of of IN 42759 3255 23 the the DT 42759 3255 24 capital capital NN 42759 3255 25 with with IN 42759 3255 26 which which WDT 42759 3255 27 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3255 28 operate operate VBP 42759 3255 29 , , , 42759 3255 30 and and CC 42759 3255 31 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3255 32 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3255 33 own own VBP 42759 3255 34 the the DT 42759 3255 35 land land NN 42759 3255 36 . . . 42759 3256 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 3256 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3256 3 rewards reward NNS 42759 3256 4 as as IN 42759 3256 5 business business NN 42759 3256 6 men man NNS 42759 3256 7 can can MD 42759 3256 8 always always RB 42759 3256 9 be be VB 42759 3256 10 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 3256 11 from from IN 42759 3256 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3256 13 returns return NNS 42759 3256 14 as as IN 42759 3256 15 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 3256 16 and and CC 42759 3256 17 landowners landowner NNS 42759 3256 18 by by IN 42759 3256 19 finding find VBG 42759 3256 20 out out RP 42759 3256 21 what what WP 42759 3256 22 remains remain VBZ 42759 3256 23 after after IN 42759 3256 24 making make VBG 42759 3256 25 due due JJ 42759 3256 26 allowance allowance NN 42759 3256 27 for for IN 42759 3256 28 rent rent NN 42759 3256 29 and and CC 42759 3256 30 interest interest NN 42759 3256 31 . . . 42759 3257 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3257 2 is be VBZ 42759 3257 3 a a DT 42759 3257 4 fact fact NN 42759 3257 5 that that IN 42759 3257 6 many many JJ 42759 3257 7 business business NN 42759 3257 8 men man NNS 42759 3257 9 , , , 42759 3257 10 especially especially RB 42759 3257 11 those those DT 42759 3257 12 directing direct VBG 42759 3257 13 the the DT 42759 3257 14 smaller small JJR 42759 3257 15 establishments establishment NNS 42759 3257 16 , , , 42759 3257 17 use use VB 42759 3257 18 the the DT 42759 3257 19 term term NN 42759 3257 20 profits profit NNS 42759 3257 21 to to TO 42759 3257 22 include include VB 42759 3257 23 rent rent NN 42759 3257 24 and and CC 42759 3257 25 interest interest NN 42759 3257 26 on on IN 42759 3257 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3257 28 own own JJ 42759 3257 29 property property NN 42759 3257 30 . . . 42759 3258 1 In in IN 42759 3258 2 other other JJ 42759 3258 3 words word NNS 42759 3258 4 , , , 42759 3258 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3258 6 describe describe VBP 42759 3258 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3258 8 entire entire JJ 42759 3258 9 income income NN 42759 3258 10 from from IN 42759 3258 11 the the DT 42759 3258 12 business business NN 42759 3258 13 as as IN 42759 3258 14 profits profit NNS 42759 3258 15 . . . 42759 3259 1 In in IN 42759 3259 2 the the DT 42759 3259 3 present present JJ 42759 3259 4 discussion discussion NN 42759 3259 5 , , , 42759 3259 6 and and CC 42759 3259 7 throughout throughout IN 42759 3259 8 this this DT 42759 3259 9 book book NN 42759 3259 10 generally generally RB 42759 3259 11 , , , 42759 3259 12 profits profit NNS 42759 3259 13 are be VBP 42759 3259 14 to to TO 42759 3259 15 be be VB 42759 3259 16 understood understand VBN 42759 3259 17 as as IN 42759 3259 18 comprising comprise VBG 42759 3259 19 merely merely RB 42759 3259 20 that that DT 42759 3259 21 part part NN 42759 3259 22 of of IN 42759 3259 23 the the DT 42759 3259 24 business business NN 42759 3259 25 man man NN 42759 3259 26 's 's POS 42759 3259 27 returns return NNS 42759 3259 28 which which WDT 42759 3259 29 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3259 30 takes take VBZ 42759 3259 31 as as IN 42759 3259 32 the the DT 42759 3259 33 reward reward NN 42759 3259 34 of of IN 42759 3259 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3259 36 labour labour NN 42759 3259 37 , , , 42759 3259 38 and and CC 42759 3259 39 as as IN 42759 3259 40 insurance insurance NN 42759 3259 41 against against IN 42759 3259 42 the the DT 42759 3259 43 risks risk NNS 42759 3259 44 affecting affect VBG 42759 3259 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3259 46 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3259 47 . . . 42759 3260 1 Deduct deduct NN 42759 3260 2 from from IN 42759 3260 3 the the DT 42759 3260 4 business business NN 42759 3260 5 man man NN 42759 3260 6 's 's POS 42759 3260 7 total total JJ 42759 3260 8 income income NN 42759 3260 9 a a DT 42759 3260 10 sum sum NN 42759 3260 11 which which WDT 42759 3260 12 will will MD 42759 3260 13 cover cover VB 42759 3260 14 interest interest NN 42759 3260 15 on on IN 42759 3260 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3260 17 capital capital NN 42759 3260 18 at at IN 42759 3260 19 the the DT 42759 3260 20 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 3260 21 rate rate NN 42759 3260 22 and and CC 42759 3260 23 rent rent NN 42759 3260 24 on on IN 42759 3260 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3260 26 land land NN 42759 3260 27 , , , 42759 3260 28 and and CC 42759 3260 29 you -PRON- PRP 42759 3260 30 have have VBP 42759 3260 31 left leave VBN 42759 3260 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3260 33 income income NN 42759 3260 34 as as IN 42759 3260 35 business business NN 42759 3260 36 man man NN 42759 3260 37 , , , 42759 3260 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3260 39 profits profit NNS 42759 3260 40 . . . 42759 3261 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3261 2 The the DT 42759 3261 3 Amount Amount NNP 42759 3261 4 of of IN 42759 3261 5 Profits Profits NNP 42759 3261 6 _ _ XX 42759 3261 7 In in IN 42759 3261 8 a a DT 42759 3261 9 preceding precede VBG 42759 3261 10 chapter chapter NN 42759 3261 11 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3261 12 have have VBP 42759 3261 13 seen see VBN 42759 3261 14 that that IN 42759 3261 15 where where WRB 42759 3261 16 the the DT 42759 3261 17 conditions condition NNS 42759 3261 18 of of IN 42759 3261 19 capital capital NN 42759 3261 20 are be VBP 42759 3261 21 the the DT 42759 3261 22 same same JJ 42759 3261 23 , , , 42759 3261 24 there there EX 42759 3261 25 exists exist VBZ 42759 3261 26 a a DT 42759 3261 27 fairly fairly RB 42759 3261 28 uniform uniform JJ 42759 3261 29 rate rate NN 42759 3261 30 of of IN 42759 3261 31 interest interest NN 42759 3261 32 . . . 42759 3262 1 No no DT 42759 3262 2 such such JJ 42759 3262 3 uniformity uniformity NN 42759 3262 4 obtains obtain NNS 42759 3262 5 in in IN 42759 3262 6 the the DT 42759 3262 7 field field NN 42759 3262 8 of of IN 42759 3262 9 profits profit NNS 42759 3262 10 . . . 42759 3263 1 Businesses business NNS 42759 3263 2 subject subject JJ 42759 3263 3 to to IN 42759 3263 4 the the DT 42759 3263 5 same same JJ 42759 3263 6 risks risk NNS 42759 3263 7 and and CC 42759 3263 8 requiring require VBG 42759 3263 9 the the DT 42759 3263 10 same same JJ 42759 3263 11 kind kind NN 42759 3263 12 of of IN 42759 3263 13 management management NN 42759 3263 14 yield yield VBP 42759 3263 15 very very RB 42759 3263 16 different different JJ 42759 3263 17 amounts amount NNS 42759 3263 18 of of IN 42759 3263 19 return return NN 42759 3263 20 to to IN 42759 3263 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3263 22 directors director NNS 42759 3263 23 . . . 42759 3264 1 In in IN 42759 3264 2 a a DT 42759 3264 3 sense sense NN 42759 3264 4 the the DT 42759 3264 5 business business NN 42759 3264 6 man man NN 42759 3264 7 may may MD 42759 3264 8 be be VB 42759 3264 9 regarded regard VBN 42759 3264 10 as as IN 42759 3264 11 the the DT 42759 3264 12 residual residual JJ 42759 3264 13 claimant claimant NN 42759 3264 14 of of IN 42759 3264 15 industry industry NN 42759 3264 16 . . . 42759 3265 1 This this DT 42759 3265 2 does do VBZ 42759 3265 3 not not RB 42759 3265 4 mean mean VB 42759 3265 5 that that IN 42759 3265 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3265 7 takes take VBZ 42759 3265 8 no no DT 42759 3265 9 profits profit NNS 42759 3265 10 until until IN 42759 3265 11 all all PDT 42759 3265 12 the the DT 42759 3265 13 other other JJ 42759 3265 14 agents agent NNS 42759 3265 15 of of IN 42759 3265 16 production production NN 42759 3265 17 have have VBP 42759 3265 18 been be VBN 42759 3265 19 fully fully RB 42759 3265 20 remunerated remunerate VBN 42759 3265 21 , , , 42759 3265 22 but but CC 42759 3265 23 that that IN 42759 3265 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3265 25 share share NN 42759 3265 26 remains remain VBZ 42759 3265 27 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 42759 3265 28 until until IN 42759 3265 29 the the DT 42759 3265 30 end end NN 42759 3265 31 of of IN 42759 3265 32 the the DT 42759 3265 33 productive productive JJ 42759 3265 34 period period NN 42759 3265 35 , , , 42759 3265 36 say say UH 42759 3265 37 , , , 42759 3265 38 six six CD 42759 3265 39 months month NNS 42759 3265 40 or or CC 42759 3265 41 a a DT 42759 3265 42 year year NN 42759 3265 43 , , , 42759 3265 44 while while IN 42759 3265 45 the the DT 42759 3265 46 shares share NNS 42759 3265 47 of of IN 42759 3265 48 the the DT 42759 3265 49 other other JJ 42759 3265 50 agents agent NNS 42759 3265 51 are be VBP 42759 3265 52 determined determine VBN 42759 3265 53 beforehand beforehand RB 42759 3265 54 . . . 42759 3266 1 At at IN 42759 3266 2 the the DT 42759 3266 3 end end NN 42759 3266 4 of of IN 42759 3266 5 the the DT 42759 3266 6 productive productive JJ 42759 3266 7 period period NN 42759 3266 8 , , , 42759 3266 9 the the DT 42759 3266 10 business business NN 42759 3266 11 man man NN 42759 3266 12 may may MD 42759 3266 13 find find VB 42759 3266 14 that that IN 42759 3266 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3266 16 profits profit NNS 42759 3266 17 are be VBP 42759 3266 18 large large JJ 42759 3266 19 , , , 42759 3266 20 moderate moderate JJ 42759 3266 21 , , , 42759 3266 22 or or CC 42759 3266 23 small small JJ 42759 3266 24 , , , 42759 3266 25 while while IN 42759 3266 26 the the DT 42759 3266 27 landowner landowner NN 42759 3266 28 , , , 42759 3266 29 the the DT 42759 3266 30 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 3266 31 , , , 42759 3266 32 and and CC 42759 3266 33 the the DT 42759 3266 34 labourer labourer NN 42759 3266 35 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 3266 36 obtain obtain VBP 42759 3266 37 the the DT 42759 3266 38 precise precise JJ 42759 3266 39 amounts amount NNS 42759 3266 40 of of IN 42759 3266 41 rent rent NN 42759 3266 42 , , , 42759 3266 43 interest interest NN 42759 3266 44 , , , 42759 3266 45 and and CC 42759 3266 46 wages wage NNS 42759 3266 47 that that WDT 42759 3266 48 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3266 49 had have VBD 42759 3266 50 expected expect VBN 42759 3266 51 to to TO 42759 3266 52 obtain obtain VB 42759 3266 53 . . . 42759 3267 1 That that IN 42759 3267 2 there there EX 42759 3267 3 exists exist VBZ 42759 3267 4 no no DT 42759 3267 5 definite definite JJ 42759 3267 6 upper upper JJ 42759 3267 7 limit limit NN 42759 3267 8 to to IN 42759 3267 9 profits profit NNS 42759 3267 10 is be VBZ 42759 3267 11 proved prove VBN 42759 3267 12 by by IN 42759 3267 13 the the DT 42759 3267 14 history history NN 42759 3267 15 of of IN 42759 3267 16 modern modern JJ 42759 3267 17 millionaires millionaire NNS 42759 3267 18 . . . 42759 3268 1 That that IN 42759 3268 2 there there EX 42759 3268 3 exists exist VBZ 42759 3268 4 no no DT 42759 3268 5 rigid rigid JJ 42759 3268 6 lower low JJR 42759 3268 7 limit limit NN 42759 3268 8 is be VBZ 42759 3268 9 proved prove VBN 42759 3268 10 by by IN 42759 3268 11 the the DT 42759 3268 12 large large JJ 42759 3268 13 proportion proportion NN 42759 3268 14 of of IN 42759 3268 15 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3268 16 that that WDT 42759 3268 17 meet meet VBP 42759 3268 18 with with IN 42759 3268 19 failure failure NN 42759 3268 20 . . . 42759 3269 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 3269 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3269 3 would would MD 42759 3269 4 be be VB 42759 3269 5 wrong wrong JJ 42759 3269 6 to to TO 42759 3269 7 infer infer VB 42759 3269 8 that that IN 42759 3269 9 the the DT 42759 3269 10 volume volume NN 42759 3269 11 of of IN 42759 3269 12 profits profit NNS 42759 3269 13 is be VBZ 42759 3269 14 governed govern VBN 42759 3269 15 by by IN 42759 3269 16 no no DT 42759 3269 17 law law NN 42759 3269 18 whatever whatever WDT 42759 3269 19 , , , 42759 3269 20 or or CC 42759 3269 21 that that IN 42759 3269 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3269 23 show show VBP 42759 3269 24 no no DT 42759 3269 25 tendency tendency NN 42759 3269 26 toward toward IN 42759 3269 27 uniformity uniformity NN 42759 3269 28 in in IN 42759 3269 29 any any DT 42759 3269 30 part part NN 42759 3269 31 of of IN 42759 3269 32 the the DT 42759 3269 33 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3269 34 field field NN 42759 3269 35 . . . 42759 3270 1 There there EX 42759 3270 2 is be VBZ 42759 3270 3 a a DT 42759 3270 4 calculated calculated JJ 42759 3270 5 or or CC 42759 3270 6 preconceived preconceive VBN 42759 3270 7 minimum minimum NN 42759 3270 8 . . . 42759 3271 1 No no DT 42759 3271 2 man man NN 42759 3271 3 will will MD 42759 3271 4 embark embark VB 42759 3271 5 in in IN 42759 3271 6 business business NN 42759 3271 7 for for IN 42759 3271 8 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 3271 9 unless unless IN 42759 3271 10 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3271 11 has have VBZ 42759 3271 12 reason reason NN 42759 3271 13 to to TO 42759 3271 14 expect expect VB 42759 3271 15 that that IN 42759 3271 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3271 17 will will MD 42759 3271 18 yield yield VB 42759 3271 19 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3271 20 , , , 42759 3271 21 in in IN 42759 3271 22 addition addition NN 42759 3271 23 to to IN 42759 3271 24 protection protection NN 42759 3271 25 against against IN 42759 3271 26 risks risk NNS 42759 3271 27 , , , 42759 3271 28 an an DT 42759 3271 29 income income NN 42759 3271 30 as as RB 42759 3271 31 large large JJ 42759 3271 32 as as IN 42759 3271 33 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3271 34 could could MD 42759 3271 35 obtain obtain VB 42759 3271 36 by by IN 42759 3271 37 hiring hire VBG 42759 3271 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3271 39 services service NNS 42759 3271 40 to to IN 42759 3271 41 some some DT 42759 3271 42 one one NN 42759 3271 43 else else RB 42759 3271 44 . . . 42759 3272 1 In in IN 42759 3272 2 other other JJ 42759 3272 3 words word NNS 42759 3272 4 , , , 42759 3272 5 contemplated contemplated JJ 42759 3272 6 profits profit NNS 42759 3272 7 must must MD 42759 3272 8 be be VB 42759 3272 9 at at IN 42759 3272 10 least least JJS 42759 3272 11 equal equal JJ 42759 3272 12 to to IN 42759 3272 13 the the DT 42759 3272 14 income income NN 42759 3272 15 of of IN 42759 3272 16 the the DT 42759 3272 17 salaried salary VBN 42759 3272 18 business business NN 42759 3272 19 manager manager NN 42759 3272 20 . . . 42759 3273 1 No no DT 42759 3273 2 tendency tendency NN 42759 3273 3 toward toward IN 42759 3273 4 uniformity uniformity NN 42759 3273 5 of of IN 42759 3273 6 profits profit NNS 42759 3273 7 exists exist VBZ 42759 3273 8 among among IN 42759 3273 9 very very RB 42759 3273 10 large large JJ 42759 3273 11 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3273 12 nor nor CC 42759 3273 13 among among IN 42759 3273 14 industries industry NNS 42759 3273 15 which which WDT 42759 3273 16 are be VBP 42759 3273 17 constantly constantly RB 42759 3273 18 adopting adopt VBG 42759 3273 19 new new JJ 42759 3273 20 methods method NNS 42759 3273 21 and and CC 42759 3273 22 new new JJ 42759 3273 23 inventions invention NNS 42759 3273 24 . . . 42759 3274 1 In in IN 42759 3274 2 businesses business NNS 42759 3274 3 of of IN 42759 3274 4 small small JJ 42759 3274 5 and and CC 42759 3274 6 moderate moderate JJ 42759 3274 7 size size NN 42759 3274 8 , , , 42759 3274 9 and and CC 42759 3274 10 in in IN 42759 3274 11 those those DT 42759 3274 12 whose whose WP$ 42759 3274 13 methods method NNS 42759 3274 14 have have VBP 42759 3274 15 become become VBN 42759 3274 16 standardised standardised JJ 42759 3274 17 , , , 42759 3274 18 such such JJ 42759 3274 19 as as IN 42759 3274 20 a a DT 42759 3274 21 retail retail JJ 42759 3274 22 grocery grocery NN 42759 3274 23 store store NN 42759 3274 24 , , , 42759 3274 25 or or CC 42759 3274 26 a a DT 42759 3274 27 factory factory NN 42759 3274 28 that that WDT 42759 3274 29 turns turn VBZ 42759 3274 30 out out RP 42759 3274 31 staple staple JJ 42759 3274 32 kinds kind NNS 42759 3274 33 of of IN 42759 3274 34 shoes shoe NNS 42759 3274 35 , , , 42759 3274 36 profits profit NNS 42759 3274 37 tend tend VBP 42759 3274 38 to to TO 42759 3274 39 be be VB 42759 3274 40 about about IN 42759 3274 41 the the DT 42759 3274 42 same same JJ 42759 3274 43 in in IN 42759 3274 44 the the DT 42759 3274 45 great great JJ 42759 3274 46 majority majority NN 42759 3274 47 of of IN 42759 3274 48 establishments establishment NNS 42759 3274 49 . . . 42759 3275 1 In in IN 42759 3275 2 such such JJ 42759 3275 3 industries industry NNS 42759 3275 4 the the DT 42759 3275 5 profits profit NNS 42759 3275 6 of of IN 42759 3275 7 the the DT 42759 3275 8 business business NN 42759 3275 9 man man NN 42759 3275 10 do do VBP 42759 3275 11 not not RB 42759 3275 12 often often RB 42759 3275 13 exceed exceed VB 42759 3275 14 the the DT 42759 3275 15 salary salary NN 42759 3275 16 that that WDT 42759 3275 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3275 18 could could MD 42759 3275 19 command command VB 42759 3275 20 as as IN 42759 3275 21 general general JJ 42759 3275 22 manager manager NN 42759 3275 23 for for IN 42759 3275 24 some some DT 42759 3275 25 one one NN 42759 3275 26 else else RB 42759 3275 27 in in IN 42759 3275 28 the the DT 42759 3275 29 same same JJ 42759 3275 30 kind kind NN 42759 3275 31 of of IN 42759 3275 32 business business NN 42759 3275 33 . . . 42759 3276 1 Professor Professor NNP 42759 3276 2 King King NNP 42759 3276 3 estimates estimate VBZ 42759 3276 4 the the DT 42759 3276 5 total total JJ 42759 3276 6 volume volume NN 42759 3276 7 of of IN 42759 3276 8 profits profit NNS 42759 3276 9 in in IN 42759 3276 10 the the DT 42759 3276 11 United United NNP 42759 3276 12 States States NNP 42759 3276 13 in in IN 42759 3276 14 1910 1910 CD 42759 3276 15 as as IN 42759 3276 16 almost almost RB 42759 3276 17 eight eight CD 42759 3276 18 and and CC 42759 3276 19 one one CD 42759 3276 20 - - HYPH 42759 3276 21 half half CD 42759 3276 22 billion billion CD 42759 3276 23 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3276 24 . . . 42759 3277 1 This this DT 42759 3277 2 was be VBD 42759 3277 3 27.5 27.5 CD 42759 3277 4 per per IN 42759 3277 5 cent cent NN 42759 3277 6 . . . 42759 3278 1 of of IN 42759 3278 2 the the DT 42759 3278 3 national national JJ 42759 3278 4 product product NN 42759 3278 5 , , , 42759 3278 6 as as IN 42759 3278 7 against against IN 42759 3278 8 24.6 24.6 CD 42759 3278 9 per per NN 42759 3278 10 cent cent NN 42759 3278 11 . . . 42759 3279 1 in in IN 42759 3279 2 1890 1890 CD 42759 3279 3 and and CC 42759 3279 4 30 30 CD 42759 3279 5 per per NN 42759 3279 6 cent cent NN 42759 3279 7 . . . 42759 3280 1 in in IN 42759 3280 2 1900 1900 CD 42759 3280 3 . . . 42759 3281 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3281 2 160 160 CD 42759 3281 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3281 4 He -PRON- PRP 42759 3281 5 interprets interpret VBZ 42759 3281 6 the the DT 42759 3281 7 fall fall NN 42759 3281 8 in in IN 42759 3281 9 the the DT 42759 3281 10 wage wage NN 42759 3281 11 earners earner NNS 42759 3281 12 ' ' POS 42759 3281 13 share share NN 42759 3281 14 which which WDT 42759 3281 15 has have VBZ 42759 3281 16 taken take VBN 42759 3281 17 place place NN 42759 3281 18 since since IN 42759 3281 19 1890 1890 CD 42759 3281 20 ( ( -LRB- 42759 3281 21 53.5 53.5 CD 42759 3281 22 to to TO 42759 3281 23 46.9 46.9 CD 42759 3281 24 per per IN 42759 3281 25 cent cent NN 42759 3281 26 . . . 42759 3281 27 ) ) -RRB- 42759 3282 1 as as IN 42759 3282 2 indicating indicate VBG 42759 3282 3 a a DT 42759 3282 4 considerable considerable JJ 42759 3282 5 increase increase NN 42759 3282 6 in in IN 42759 3282 7 the the DT 42759 3282 8 share share NN 42759 3282 9 of of IN 42759 3282 10 those those DT 42759 3282 11 business business NN 42759 3282 12 men man NNS 42759 3282 13 who who WP 42759 3282 14 control control VBP 42759 3282 15 the the DT 42759 3282 16 very very RB 42759 3282 17 large large JJ 42759 3282 18 industries industry NNS 42759 3282 19 . . . 42759 3283 1 " " `` 42759 3283 2 The the DT 42759 3283 3 promoters promoter NNS 42759 3283 4 and and CC 42759 3283 5 manipulators manipulator NNS 42759 3283 6 of of IN 42759 3283 7 these these DT 42759 3283 8 concerns concern NNS 42759 3283 9 have have VBP 42759 3283 10 received receive VBN 42759 3283 11 , , , 42759 3283 12 as as IN 42759 3283 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3283 14 share share NN 42759 3283 15 of of IN 42759 3283 16 the the DT 42759 3283 17 spoils spoil NNS 42759 3283 18 , , , 42759 3283 19 permanent permanent JJ 42759 3283 20 income income NN 42759 3283 21 claims claim NNS 42759 3283 22 , , , 42759 3283 23 in in IN 42759 3283 24 the the DT 42759 3283 25 shape shape NN 42759 3283 26 of of IN 42759 3283 27 securities security NNS 42759 3283 28 , , , 42759 3283 29 large large JJ 42759 3283 30 enough enough RB 42759 3283 31 to to TO 42759 3283 32 make make VB 42759 3283 33 Croesus Croesus NNP 42759 3283 34 appear appear VB 42759 3283 35 like like IN 42759 3283 36 a a DT 42759 3283 37 pauper pauper NN 42759 3283 38 . . . 42759 3284 1 " " `` 42759 3284 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3284 3 161 161 CD 42759 3284 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3284 5 Moreover moreover RB 42759 3284 6 , , , 42759 3284 7 even even RB 42759 3284 8 outside outside IN 42759 3284 9 this this DT 42759 3284 10 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3284 11 field field NN 42759 3284 12 , , , 42759 3284 13 the the DT 42759 3284 14 more more RBR 42759 3284 15 able able JJ 42759 3284 16 and and CC 42759 3284 17 successful successful JJ 42759 3284 18 business business NN 42759 3284 19 men man NNS 42759 3284 20 seem seem VBP 42759 3284 21 to to TO 42759 3284 22 have have VB 42759 3284 23 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3284 24 in in IN 42759 3284 25 recent recent JJ 42759 3284 26 years year NNS 42759 3284 27 what what WP 42759 3284 28 might may MD 42759 3284 29 be be VB 42759 3284 30 termed term VBN 42759 3284 31 a a DT 42759 3284 32 relatively relatively RB 42759 3284 33 large large JJ 42759 3284 34 share share NN 42759 3284 35 of of IN 42759 3284 36 the the DT 42759 3284 37 product product NN 42759 3284 38 of of IN 42759 3284 39 industry industry NN 42759 3284 40 . . . 42759 3285 1 The the DT 42759 3285 2 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3285 3 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3285 4 undertakers undertaker NNS 42759 3285 5 , , , 42759 3285 6 those those DT 42759 3285 7 possessing possess VBG 42759 3285 8 the the DT 42759 3285 9 imagination imagination NN 42759 3285 10 , , , 42759 3285 11 foresight foresight NN 42759 3285 12 , , , 42759 3285 13 judgment judgment NN 42759 3285 14 , , , 42759 3285 15 and and CC 42759 3285 16 courage courage NN 42759 3285 17 to to TO 42759 3285 18 take take VB 42759 3285 19 full full JJ 42759 3285 20 advantage advantage NN 42759 3285 21 of of IN 42759 3285 22 the the DT 42759 3285 23 recent recent JJ 42759 3285 24 improvements improvement NNS 42759 3285 25 in in IN 42759 3285 26 the the DT 42759 3285 27 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3285 28 arts art NNS 42759 3285 29 , , , 42759 3285 30 and and CC 42759 3285 31 in in IN 42759 3285 32 the the DT 42759 3285 33 methods method NNS 42759 3285 34 of of IN 42759 3285 35 production production NN 42759 3285 36 generally generally RB 42759 3285 37 , , , 42759 3285 38 seem seem VBP 42759 3285 39 to to TO 42759 3285 40 have have VB 42759 3285 41 advanced advance VBN 42759 3285 42 in in IN 42759 3285 43 wealth wealth NN 42759 3285 44 and and CC 42759 3285 45 income income NN 42759 3285 46 more more RBR 42759 3285 47 rapidly rapidly RB 42759 3285 48 than than IN 42759 3285 49 any any DT 42759 3285 50 other other JJ 42759 3285 51 class class NN 42759 3285 52 that that WDT 42759 3285 53 has have VBZ 42759 3285 54 been be VBN 42759 3285 55 subject subject JJ 42759 3285 56 to to IN 42759 3285 57 the the DT 42759 3285 58 operation operation NN 42759 3285 59 of of IN 42759 3285 60 competition competition NN 42759 3285 61 . . . 42759 3286 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3286 2 Profits Profits NNPS 42759 3286 3 in in IN 42759 3286 4 the the DT 42759 3286 5 Joint Joint NNP 42759 3286 6 - - HYPH 42759 3286 7 Stock Stock NNP 42759 3286 8 Company Company NNP 42759 3286 9 _ _ NNP 42759 3286 10 Up up RP 42759 3286 11 to to IN 42759 3286 12 this this DT 42759 3286 13 point point NN 42759 3286 14 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3286 15 have have VBP 42759 3286 16 been be VBN 42759 3286 17 considering consider VBG 42759 3286 18 the the DT 42759 3286 19 independent independent JJ 42759 3286 20 business business NN 42759 3286 21 man man NN 42759 3286 22 , , , 42759 3286 23 the the DT 42759 3286 24 undertaker undertaker NN 42759 3286 25 who who WP 42759 3286 26 manages manage VBZ 42759 3286 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3286 28 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3286 29 either either CC 42759 3286 30 alone alone RB 42759 3286 31 or or CC 42759 3286 32 as as IN 42759 3286 33 a a DT 42759 3286 34 member member NN 42759 3286 35 of of IN 42759 3286 36 a a DT 42759 3286 37 partnership partnership NN 42759 3286 38 . . . 42759 3287 1 In in IN 42759 3287 2 all all DT 42759 3287 3 such such JJ 42759 3287 4 concerns concern NNS 42759 3287 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3287 6 is be VBZ 42759 3287 7 easy easy JJ 42759 3287 8 to to TO 42759 3287 9 identify identify VB 42759 3287 10 the the DT 42759 3287 11 business business NN 42759 3287 12 man man NN 42759 3287 13 . . . 42759 3288 1 Who who WP 42759 3288 2 or or CC 42759 3288 3 where where WRB 42759 3288 4 is be VBZ 42759 3288 5 the the DT 42759 3288 6 business business NN 42759 3288 7 man man NN 42759 3288 8 in in IN 42759 3288 9 a a DT 42759 3288 10 joint joint JJ 42759 3288 11 stock stock NN 42759 3288 12 company company NN 42759 3288 13 ? ? . 42759 3289 1 Where where WRB 42759 3289 2 are be VBP 42759 3289 3 the the DT 42759 3289 4 profits profit NNS 42759 3289 5 , , , 42759 3289 6 and and CC 42759 3289 7 who who WP 42759 3289 8 gets get VBZ 42759 3289 9 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3289 10 ? ? . 42759 3290 1 Strictly strictly RB 42759 3290 2 speaking speak VBG 42759 3290 3 , , , 42759 3290 4 there there EX 42759 3290 5 is be VBZ 42759 3290 6 no no DT 42759 3290 7 undertaker undertaker NN 42759 3290 8 or or CC 42759 3290 9 business business NN 42759 3290 10 man man NN 42759 3290 11 in in IN 42759 3290 12 a a DT 42759 3290 13 corporation corporation NN 42759 3290 14 . . . 42759 3291 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3291 2 functions function NNS 42759 3291 3 of of IN 42759 3291 4 ownership ownership NN 42759 3291 5 , , , 42759 3291 6 responsibility responsibility NN 42759 3291 7 , , , 42759 3291 8 and and CC 42759 3291 9 direction direction NN 42759 3291 10 are be VBP 42759 3291 11 exercised exercise VBN 42759 3291 12 by by IN 42759 3291 13 the the DT 42759 3291 14 whole whole JJ 42759 3291 15 body body NN 42759 3291 16 of of IN 42759 3291 17 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3291 18 through through IN 42759 3291 19 the the DT 42759 3291 20 board board NN 42759 3291 21 of of IN 42759 3291 22 directors director NNS 42759 3291 23 and and CC 42759 3291 24 other other JJ 42759 3291 25 officers officer NNS 42759 3291 26 . . . 42759 3292 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3292 2 is be VBZ 42759 3292 3 true true JJ 42759 3292 4 that that IN 42759 3292 5 in in IN 42759 3292 6 very very RB 42759 3292 7 many many JJ 42759 3292 8 , , , 42759 3292 9 probably probably RB 42759 3292 10 in in IN 42759 3292 11 most most JJS 42759 3292 12 corporations corporation NNS 42759 3292 13 , , , 42759 3292 14 one one CD 42759 3292 15 or or CC 42759 3292 16 a a DT 42759 3292 17 very very RB 42759 3292 18 few few JJ 42759 3292 19 of of IN 42759 3292 20 the the DT 42759 3292 21 largest large JJS 42759 3292 22 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3292 23 dominate dominate VBP 42759 3292 24 the the DT 42759 3292 25 policies policy NNS 42759 3292 26 of of IN 42759 3292 27 the the DT 42759 3292 28 concern concern NN 42759 3292 29 , , , 42759 3292 30 and and CC 42759 3292 31 exercise exercise VB 42759 3292 32 almost almost RB 42759 3292 33 as as IN 42759 3292 34 much much JJ 42759 3292 35 power power NN 42759 3292 36 and and CC 42759 3292 37 authority authority NN 42759 3292 38 as as IN 42759 3292 39 though though IN 42759 3292 40 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3292 41 were be VBD 42759 3292 42 the the DT 42759 3292 43 sole sole JJ 42759 3292 44 owners owner NNS 42759 3292 45 . . . 42759 3293 1 Neither neither CC 42759 3293 2 these these DT 42759 3293 3 , , , 42759 3293 4 however however RB 42759 3293 5 , , , 42759 3293 6 nor nor CC 42759 3293 7 any any DT 42759 3293 8 other other JJ 42759 3293 9 officer officer NN 42759 3293 10 in in IN 42759 3293 11 a a DT 42759 3293 12 corporation corporation NN 42759 3293 13 receives receive VBZ 42759 3293 14 profits profit NNS 42759 3293 15 in in IN 42759 3293 16 the the DT 42759 3293 17 same same JJ 42759 3293 18 sense sense NN 42759 3293 19 as as IN 42759 3293 20 the the DT 42759 3293 21 independent independent JJ 42759 3293 22 owner owner NN 42759 3293 23 of of IN 42759 3293 24 a a DT 42759 3293 25 business business NN 42759 3293 26 . . . 42759 3294 1 For for IN 42759 3294 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3294 3 active active JJ 42759 3294 4 services service NNS 42759 3294 5 the the DT 42759 3294 6 officers officer NNS 42759 3294 7 of of IN 42759 3294 8 the the DT 42759 3294 9 corporation corporation NN 42759 3294 10 are be VBP 42759 3294 11 given give VBN 42759 3294 12 salaries salary NNS 42759 3294 13 ; ; : 42759 3294 14 for for IN 42759 3294 15 the the DT 42759 3294 16 risks risk NNS 42759 3294 17 that that WDT 42759 3294 18 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3294 19 undergo undergo VBP 42759 3294 20 as as IN 42759 3294 21 owners owner NNS 42759 3294 22 of of IN 42759 3294 23 the the DT 42759 3294 24 stock stock NN 42759 3294 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3294 26 are be VBP 42759 3294 27 compensated compensate VBN 42759 3294 28 in in IN 42759 3294 29 the the DT 42759 3294 30 same same JJ 42759 3294 31 way way NN 42759 3294 32 as as IN 42759 3294 33 all all PDT 42759 3294 34 the the DT 42759 3294 35 other other JJ 42759 3294 36 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3294 37 , , , 42759 3294 38 that that RB 42759 3294 39 is is RB 42759 3294 40 , , , 42759 3294 41 through through IN 42759 3294 42 a a DT 42759 3294 43 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3294 44 high high JJ 42759 3294 45 rate rate NN 42759 3294 46 of of IN 42759 3294 47 dividend dividend NN 42759 3294 48 . . . 42759 3295 1 For for IN 42759 3295 2 example example NN 42759 3295 3 , , , 42759 3295 4 in in IN 42759 3295 5 railroads railroad NNS 42759 3295 6 the the DT 42759 3295 7 bonds bond NNS 42759 3295 8 usually usually RB 42759 3295 9 pay pay VBP 42759 3295 10 from from IN 42759 3295 11 four four CD 42759 3295 12 to to TO 42759 3295 13 five five CD 42759 3295 14 per per IN 42759 3295 15 cent cent NN 42759 3295 16 . . . 42759 3295 17 , , , 42759 3295 18 the the DT 42759 3295 19 stock stock NN 42759 3295 20 from from IN 42759 3295 21 five five CD 42759 3295 22 to to TO 42759 3295 23 six six CD 42759 3295 24 per per IN 42759 3295 25 cent cent NN 42759 3295 26 . . . 42759 3296 1 The the DT 42759 3296 2 bonds bond NNS 42759 3296 3 represent represent VBP 42759 3296 4 borrowed borrow VBN 42759 3296 5 money money NN 42759 3296 6 , , , 42759 3296 7 and and CC 42759 3296 8 are be VBP 42759 3296 9 secured secure VBN 42759 3296 10 by by IN 42759 3296 11 a a DT 42759 3296 12 mortgage mortgage NN 42759 3296 13 on on IN 42759 3296 14 the the DT 42759 3296 15 physical physical JJ 42759 3296 16 property property NN 42759 3296 17 . . . 42759 3297 1 The the DT 42759 3297 2 stock stock NN 42759 3297 3 represents represent VBZ 42759 3297 4 the the DT 42759 3297 5 money money NN 42759 3297 6 invested invest VBN 42759 3297 7 by by IN 42759 3297 8 the the DT 42759 3297 9 owners owner NNS 42759 3297 10 , , , 42759 3297 11 and and CC 42759 3297 12 is be VBZ 42759 3297 13 subject subject JJ 42759 3297 14 to to IN 42759 3297 15 all all PDT 42759 3297 16 the the DT 42759 3297 17 risks risk NNS 42759 3297 18 of of IN 42759 3297 19 ownership ownership NN 42759 3297 20 ; ; : 42759 3297 21 hence hence RB 42759 3297 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3297 23 holders holder NNS 42759 3297 24 require require VBP 42759 3297 25 the the DT 42759 3297 26 protection protection NN 42759 3297 27 which which WDT 42759 3297 28 is be VBZ 42759 3297 29 afforded afford VBN 42759 3297 30 by by IN 42759 3297 31 the the DT 42759 3297 32 extra extra JJ 42759 3297 33 one one CD 42759 3297 34 per per IN 42759 3297 35 cent cent NN 42759 3297 36 . . . 42759 3298 1 which which WDT 42759 3298 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3298 3 obtain obtain VBP 42759 3298 4 over over IN 42759 3298 5 that that DT 42759 3298 6 paid pay VBN 42759 3298 7 to to IN 42759 3298 8 the the DT 42759 3298 9 bondholders bondholder NNS 42759 3298 10 . . . 42759 3299 1 While while IN 42759 3299 2 a a DT 42759 3299 3 corporation corporation NN 42759 3299 4 has have VBZ 42759 3299 5 no no DT 42759 3299 6 profits profit NNS 42759 3299 7 in in IN 42759 3299 8 the the DT 42759 3299 9 sense sense NN 42759 3299 10 of of IN 42759 3299 11 a a DT 42759 3299 12 reward reward NN 42759 3299 13 for for IN 42759 3299 14 directive directive NN 42759 3299 15 activity activity NN 42759 3299 16 or or CC 42759 3299 17 a a DT 42759 3299 18 protection protection NN 42759 3299 19 against against IN 42759 3299 20 risk risk NN 42759 3299 21 , , , 42759 3299 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3299 23 frequently frequently RB 42759 3299 24 possesses possess VBZ 42759 3299 25 profits profit NNS 42759 3299 26 in in IN 42759 3299 27 the the DT 42759 3299 28 sense sense NN 42759 3299 29 of of IN 42759 3299 30 a a DT 42759 3299 31 surplus surplus NN 42759 3299 32 which which WDT 42759 3299 33 remains remain VBZ 42759 3299 34 after after IN 42759 3299 35 costs cost NNS 42759 3299 36 and and CC 42759 3299 37 expenses expense NNS 42759 3299 38 of of IN 42759 3299 39 every every DT 42759 3299 40 kind kind NN 42759 3299 41 have have VBP 42759 3299 42 been be VBN 42759 3299 43 defrayed defray VBN 42759 3299 44 . . . 42759 3300 1 These these DT 42759 3300 2 profits profit NNS 42759 3300 3 are be VBP 42759 3300 4 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 3300 5 distributed distribute VBN 42759 3300 6 pro pro JJ 42759 3300 7 rata rata NN 42759 3300 8 among among IN 42759 3300 9 the the DT 42759 3300 10 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3300 11 , , , 42759 3300 12 either either CC 42759 3300 13 outright outright RB 42759 3300 14 in in IN 42759 3300 15 the the DT 42759 3300 16 form form NN 42759 3300 17 of of IN 42759 3300 18 an an DT 42759 3300 19 extra extra JJ 42759 3300 20 dividend dividend NN 42759 3300 21 , , , 42759 3300 22 or or CC 42759 3300 23 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 3300 24 through through IN 42759 3300 25 enlargement enlargement NN 42759 3300 26 of of IN 42759 3300 27 the the DT 42759 3300 28 property property NN 42759 3300 29 and and CC 42759 3300 30 business business NN 42759 3300 31 of of IN 42759 3300 32 the the DT 42759 3300 33 company company NN 42759 3300 34 . . . 42759 3301 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3301 2 are be VBP 42759 3301 3 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3301 4 gains gain NNS 42759 3301 5 or or CC 42759 3301 6 profits profit NNS 42759 3301 7 having have VBG 42759 3301 8 the the DT 42759 3301 9 same same JJ 42759 3301 10 intermittent intermittent NN 42759 3301 11 and and CC 42759 3301 12 speculative speculative JJ 42759 3301 13 character character NN 42759 3301 14 as as IN 42759 3301 15 the the DT 42759 3301 16 extra extra JJ 42759 3301 17 gains gain NNS 42759 3301 18 which which WDT 42759 3301 19 the the DT 42759 3301 20 individual individual JJ 42759 3301 21 business business NN 42759 3301 22 man man NN 42759 3301 23 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3301 24 obtains obtain VBZ 42759 3301 25 in in IN 42759 3301 26 addition addition NN 42759 3301 27 to to IN 42759 3301 28 those those DT 42759 3301 29 profits profit NNS 42759 3301 30 which which WDT 42759 3301 31 are be VBP 42759 3301 32 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3301 33 to to TO 42759 3301 34 remunerate remunerate VB 42759 3301 35 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3301 36 for for IN 42759 3301 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3301 38 labour labour NN 42759 3301 39 , , , 42759 3301 40 and and CC 42759 3301 41 protect protect VB 42759 3301 42 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3301 43 against against IN 42759 3301 44 risks risk NNS 42759 3301 45 . . . 42759 3302 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3302 2 are be VBP 42759 3302 3 not not RB 42759 3302 4 profits profit NNS 42759 3302 5 in in IN 42759 3302 6 the the DT 42759 3302 7 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 3302 8 economic economic JJ 42759 3302 9 sense sense NN 42759 3302 10 of of IN 42759 3302 11 the the DT 42759 3302 12 term term NN 42759 3302 13 . . . 42759 3303 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 3303 2 : : : 42759 3303 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3303 4 160 160 CD 42759 3303 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3303 6 " " `` 42759 3303 7 The the DT 42759 3303 8 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 3303 9 and and CC 42759 3303 10 Income Income NNP 42759 3303 11 of of IN 42759 3303 12 the the DT 42759 3303 13 People People NNS 42759 3303 14 of of IN 42759 3303 15 the the DT 42759 3303 16 United United NNP 42759 3303 17 States States NNP 42759 3303 18 , , , 42759 3303 19 " " '' 42759 3303 20 158 158 CD 42759 3303 21 , , , 42759 3303 22 160 160 CD 42759 3303 23 . . . 42759 3304 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3304 2 161 161 CD 42759 3304 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3304 4 Idem Idem NNP 42759 3304 5 , , , 42759 3304 6 p. p. NN 42759 3304 7 218 218 CD 42759 3304 8 . . . 42759 3305 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 3305 2 XVI XVI NNP 42759 3305 3 THE the DT 42759 3305 4 PRINCIPAL principal JJ 42759 3305 5 CANONS canon NNS 42759 3305 6 OF of IN 42759 3305 7 DISTRIBUTIVE DISTRIBUTIVE NNP 42759 3305 8 JUSTICE justice NN 42759 3305 9 Before before IN 42759 3305 10 taking take VBG 42759 3305 11 up up RP 42759 3305 12 the the DT 42759 3305 13 question question NN 42759 3305 14 of of IN 42759 3305 15 the the DT 42759 3305 16 morality morality NN 42759 3305 17 of of IN 42759 3305 18 profits profit NNS 42759 3305 19 , , , 42759 3305 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3305 21 will will MD 42759 3305 22 be be VB 42759 3305 23 helpful helpful JJ 42759 3305 24 , , , 42759 3305 25 if if IN 42759 3305 26 not not RB 42759 3305 27 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3305 28 , , , 42759 3305 29 to to TO 42759 3305 30 consider consider VB 42759 3305 31 the the DT 42759 3305 32 chief chief JJ 42759 3305 33 rules rule NNS 42759 3305 34 of of IN 42759 3305 35 justice justice NN 42759 3305 36 that that WDT 42759 3305 37 have have VBP 42759 3305 38 been be VBN 42759 3305 39 or or CC 42759 3305 40 might may MD 42759 3305 41 be be VB 42759 3305 42 adopted adopt VBN 42759 3305 43 in in IN 42759 3305 44 distributing distribute VBG 42759 3305 45 the the DT 42759 3305 46 product product NN 42759 3305 47 of of IN 42759 3305 48 industry industry NN 42759 3305 49 among among IN 42759 3305 50 those those DT 42759 3305 51 who who WP 42759 3305 52 participate participate VBP 42759 3305 53 actively actively RB 42759 3305 54 in in IN 42759 3305 55 the the DT 42759 3305 56 productive productive JJ 42759 3305 57 process process NN 42759 3305 58 . . . 42759 3306 1 While while IN 42759 3306 2 the the DT 42759 3306 3 discussion discussion NN 42759 3306 4 is be VBZ 42759 3306 5 undertaken undertake VBN 42759 3306 6 with with IN 42759 3306 7 particular particular JJ 42759 3306 8 reference reference NN 42759 3306 9 to to IN 42759 3306 10 the the DT 42759 3306 11 rewards reward NNS 42759 3306 12 of of IN 42759 3306 13 the the DT 42759 3306 14 business business NN 42759 3306 15 man man NN 42759 3306 16 , , , 42759 3306 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3306 18 will will MD 42759 3306 19 also also RB 42759 3306 20 have have VB 42759 3306 21 an an DT 42759 3306 22 important important JJ 42759 3306 23 bearing bearing NN 42759 3306 24 on on IN 42759 3306 25 the the DT 42759 3306 26 compensation compensation NN 42759 3306 27 of of IN 42759 3306 28 the the DT 42759 3306 29 wage wage NN 42759 3306 30 earner earner NN 42759 3306 31 . . . 42759 3307 1 The the DT 42759 3307 2 morality morality NN 42759 3307 3 of of IN 42759 3307 4 rent rent NN 42759 3307 5 and and CC 42759 3307 6 interest interest NN 42759 3307 7 depends depend VBZ 42759 3307 8 upon upon IN 42759 3307 9 other other JJ 42759 3307 10 principles principle NNS 42759 3307 11 than than IN 42759 3307 12 those those DT 42759 3307 13 governing govern VBG 42759 3307 14 the the DT 42759 3307 15 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 3307 16 of of IN 42759 3307 17 human human JJ 42759 3307 18 activity activity NN 42759 3307 19 ; ; : 42759 3307 20 and and CC 42759 3307 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3307 22 has have VBZ 42759 3307 23 been be VBN 42759 3307 24 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3307 25 treated treat VBN 42759 3307 26 in in IN 42759 3307 27 chapters chapter NNS 42759 3307 28 xii xii NNP 42759 3307 29 and and CC 42759 3307 30 xiii xiii NNP 42759 3307 31 . . . 42759 3308 1 The the DT 42759 3308 2 canons canon NNS 42759 3308 3 of of IN 42759 3308 4 distribution distribution NN 42759 3308 5 applicable applicable JJ 42759 3308 6 to to IN 42759 3308 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3308 8 present present JJ 42759 3308 9 study study NN 42759 3308 10 are be VBP 42759 3308 11 mainly mainly RB 42759 3308 12 six six CD 42759 3308 13 in in IN 42759 3308 14 number number NN 42759 3308 15 : : : 42759 3308 16 arithmetical arithmetical JJ 42759 3308 17 equality equality NN 42759 3308 18 ; ; , 42759 3308 19 proportional proportional JJ 42759 3308 20 needs need NNS 42759 3308 21 ; ; : 42759 3308 22 efforts effort NNS 42759 3308 23 and and CC 42759 3308 24 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3308 25 ; ; , 42759 3308 26 comparative comparative JJ 42759 3308 27 productivity productivity NN 42759 3308 28 ; ; , 42759 3308 29 relative relative JJ 42759 3308 30 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3308 31 ; ; , 42759 3308 32 and and CC 42759 3308 33 human human JJ 42759 3308 34 welfare welfare NN 42759 3308 35 . . . 42759 3309 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3309 2 The the DT 42759 3309 3 Canon Canon NNP 42759 3309 4 of of IN 42759 3309 5 Equality Equality NNP 42759 3309 6 _ _ NNP 42759 3309 7 According accord VBG 42759 3309 8 to to IN 42759 3309 9 the the DT 42759 3309 10 rule rule NN 42759 3309 11 of of IN 42759 3309 12 arithmetical arithmetical JJ 42759 3309 13 equality equality NN 42759 3309 14 , , , 42759 3309 15 all all DT 42759 3309 16 persons person NNS 42759 3309 17 who who WP 42759 3309 18 contribute contribute VBP 42759 3309 19 to to IN 42759 3309 20 the the DT 42759 3309 21 product product NN 42759 3309 22 should should MD 42759 3309 23 receive receive VB 42759 3309 24 the the DT 42759 3309 25 same same JJ 42759 3309 26 amount amount NN 42759 3309 27 of of IN 42759 3309 28 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 3309 29 . . . 42759 3310 1 With with IN 42759 3310 2 the the DT 42759 3310 3 exception exception NN 42759 3310 4 of of IN 42759 3310 5 Bernard Bernard NNP 42759 3310 6 Shaw Shaw NNP 42759 3310 7 , , , 42759 3310 8 no no DT 42759 3310 9 important important JJ 42759 3310 10 writer writer NN 42759 3310 11 defends defend VBZ 42759 3310 12 this this DT 42759 3310 13 rule rule NN 42759 3310 14 to to IN 42759 3310 15 - - HYPH 42759 3310 16 day day NN 42759 3310 17 . . . 42759 3311 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3311 2 is be VBZ 42759 3311 3 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3311 4 because because IN 42759 3311 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3311 6 would would MD 42759 3311 7 treat treat VB 42759 3311 8 unequals unequal NNS 42759 3311 9 equally equally RB 42759 3311 10 . . . 42759 3312 1 Although although IN 42759 3312 2 men man NNS 42759 3312 3 are be VBP 42759 3312 4 equal equal JJ 42759 3312 5 as as IN 42759 3312 6 moral moral JJ 42759 3312 7 entities entity NNS 42759 3312 8 , , , 42759 3312 9 as as IN 42759 3312 10 human human JJ 42759 3312 11 persons person NNS 42759 3312 12 , , , 42759 3312 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3312 14 are be VBP 42759 3312 15 unequal unequal JJ 42759 3312 16 in in IN 42759 3312 17 desires desire NNS 42759 3312 18 , , , 42759 3312 19 capacities capacity NNS 42759 3312 20 , , , 42759 3312 21 and and CC 42759 3312 22 powers power NNS 42759 3312 23 . . . 42759 3313 1 An an DT 42759 3313 2 income income NN 42759 3313 3 that that WDT 42759 3313 4 would would MD 42759 3313 5 fully fully RB 42759 3313 6 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 3313 7 the the DT 42759 3313 8 needs need NNS 42759 3313 9 of of IN 42759 3313 10 one one CD 42759 3313 11 man man NN 42759 3313 12 would would MD 42759 3313 13 meet meet VB 42759 3313 14 only only RB 42759 3313 15 75 75 CD 42759 3313 16 per per NN 42759 3313 17 cent cent NN 42759 3313 18 . . . 42759 3313 19 , , , 42759 3313 20 or or CC 42759 3313 21 50 50 CD 42759 3313 22 per per NN 42759 3313 23 cent cent NN 42759 3313 24 . . . 42759 3313 25 , , , 42759 3313 26 of of IN 42759 3313 27 the the DT 42759 3313 28 capacities capacity NNS 42759 3313 29 of of IN 42759 3313 30 another another DT 42759 3313 31 . . . 42759 3314 1 To to TO 42759 3314 2 allot allot VB 42759 3314 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3314 4 equal equal JJ 42759 3314 5 amounts amount NNS 42759 3314 6 of of IN 42759 3314 7 income income NN 42759 3314 8 would would MD 42759 3314 9 be be VB 42759 3314 10 to to TO 42759 3314 11 treat treat VB 42759 3314 12 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3314 13 unequally unequally RB 42759 3314 14 with with IN 42759 3314 15 regard regard NN 42759 3314 16 to to IN 42759 3314 17 the the DT 42759 3314 18 requisites requisite NNS 42759 3314 19 of of IN 42759 3314 20 life life NN 42759 3314 21 and and CC 42759 3314 22 self self NN 42759 3314 23 development development NN 42759 3314 24 . . . 42759 3315 1 To to TO 42759 3315 2 treat treat VB 42759 3315 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3315 4 unequally unequally RB 42759 3315 5 in in IN 42759 3315 6 these these DT 42759 3315 7 matters matter NNS 42759 3315 8 would would MD 42759 3315 9 be be VB 42759 3315 10 to to TO 42759 3315 11 treat treat VB 42759 3315 12 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3315 13 unequally unequally RB 42759 3315 14 as as IN 42759 3315 15 regards regard VBZ 42759 3315 16 the the DT 42759 3315 17 real real JJ 42759 3315 18 and and CC 42759 3315 19 only only JJ 42759 3315 20 purpose purpose NN 42759 3315 21 of of IN 42759 3315 22 property property NN 42759 3315 23 rights right NNS 42759 3315 24 . . . 42759 3316 1 That that DT 42759 3316 2 purpose purpose NN 42759 3316 3 is be VBZ 42759 3316 4 welfare welfare NN 42759 3316 5 . . . 42759 3317 1 Hence hence RB 42759 3317 2 the the DT 42759 3317 3 equal equal JJ 42759 3317 4 moral moral JJ 42759 3317 5 claims claim NNS 42759 3317 6 of of IN 42759 3317 7 men man NNS 42759 3317 8 which which WDT 42759 3317 9 admittedly admittedly RB 42759 3317 10 arise arise VBP 42759 3317 11 out out IN 42759 3317 12 of of IN 42759 3317 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3317 14 moral moral JJ 42759 3317 15 equality equality NN 42759 3317 16 must must MD 42759 3317 17 be be VB 42759 3317 18 construed construe VBN 42759 3317 19 as as IN 42759 3317 20 claims claim NNS 42759 3317 21 to to TO 42759 3317 22 equal equal VB 42759 3317 23 degrees degree NNS 42759 3317 24 of of IN 42759 3317 25 welfare welfare NN 42759 3317 26 , , , 42759 3317 27 not not RB 42759 3317 28 to to TO 42759 3317 29 equal equal VB 42759 3317 30 amounts amount NNS 42759 3317 31 of of IN 42759 3317 32 external external JJ 42759 3317 33 goods good NNS 42759 3317 34 . . . 42759 3318 1 To to TO 42759 3318 2 put put VB 42759 3318 3 the the DT 42759 3318 4 matter matter NN 42759 3318 5 in in IN 42759 3318 6 another another DT 42759 3318 7 way way NN 42759 3318 8 , , , 42759 3318 9 external external JJ 42759 3318 10 goods good NNS 42759 3318 11 are be VBP 42759 3318 12 not not RB 42759 3318 13 welfare welfare JJ 42759 3318 14 ; ; : 42759 3318 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3318 16 are be VBP 42759 3318 17 only only RB 42759 3318 18 means mean VBZ 42759 3318 19 to to TO 42759 3318 20 welfare welfare VB 42759 3318 21 ; ; : 42759 3318 22 consequently consequently RB 42759 3318 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3318 24 importance importance NN 42759 3318 25 must must MD 42759 3318 26 be be VB 42759 3318 27 determined determine VBN 42759 3318 28 by by IN 42759 3318 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3318 30 bearing bearing NN 42759 3318 31 upon upon IN 42759 3318 32 the the DT 42759 3318 33 welfare welfare NN 42759 3318 34 of of IN 42759 3318 35 the the DT 42759 3318 36 individual individual NN 42759 3318 37 . . . 42759 3319 1 From from IN 42759 3319 2 every every DT 42759 3319 3 point point NN 42759 3319 4 of of IN 42759 3319 5 view view NN 42759 3319 6 , , , 42759 3319 7 therefore therefore RB 42759 3319 8 , , , 42759 3319 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3319 10 is be VBZ 42759 3319 11 evident evident JJ 42759 3319 12 that that IN 42759 3319 13 justice justice NN 42759 3319 14 in in IN 42759 3319 15 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3319 16 distribution distribution NN 42759 3319 17 must must MD 42759 3319 18 be be VB 42759 3319 19 measured measure VBN 42759 3319 20 with with IN 42759 3319 21 reference reference NN 42759 3319 22 to to TO 42759 3319 23 welfare welfare VB 42759 3319 24 rather rather RB 42759 3319 25 than than IN 42759 3319 26 with with IN 42759 3319 27 reference reference NN 42759 3319 28 to to IN 42759 3319 29 incomes income NNS 42759 3319 30 , , , 42759 3319 31 and and CC 42759 3319 32 that that IN 42759 3319 33 any any DT 42759 3319 34 scheme scheme NN 42759 3319 35 of of IN 42759 3319 36 distribution distribution NN 42759 3319 37 which which WDT 42759 3319 38 provided provide VBD 42759 3319 39 equal equal JJ 42759 3319 40 incomes income NNS 42759 3319 41 for for IN 42759 3319 42 all all DT 42759 3319 43 persons person NNS 42759 3319 44 would would MD 42759 3319 45 be be VB 42759 3319 46 radically radically RB 42759 3319 47 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3319 48 . . . 42759 3320 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 3320 2 , , , 42759 3320 3 the the DT 42759 3320 4 rule rule NN 42759 3320 5 of of IN 42759 3320 6 equal equal JJ 42759 3320 7 incomes income NNS 42759 3320 8 is be VBZ 42759 3320 9 socially socially RB 42759 3320 10 impracticable impracticable JJ 42759 3320 11 . . . 42759 3321 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3321 2 would would MD 42759 3321 3 deter deter VB 42759 3321 4 the the DT 42759 3321 5 great great JJ 42759 3321 6 majority majority NN 42759 3321 7 of of IN 42759 3321 8 the the DT 42759 3321 9 more more RBR 42759 3321 10 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3321 11 from from IN 42759 3321 12 putting put VBG 42759 3321 13 forth forth RP 42759 3321 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3321 15 best good JJS 42759 3321 16 efforts effort NNS 42759 3321 17 and and CC 42759 3321 18 turning turn VBG 42759 3321 19 out out RP 42759 3321 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3321 21 maximum maximum JJ 42759 3321 22 product product NN 42759 3321 23 . . . 42759 3322 1 As as IN 42759 3322 2 a a DT 42759 3322 3 consequence consequence NN 42759 3322 4 , , , 42759 3322 5 the the DT 42759 3322 6 total total JJ 42759 3322 7 volume volume NN 42759 3322 8 of of IN 42759 3322 9 product product NN 42759 3322 10 would would MD 42759 3322 11 be be VB 42759 3322 12 so so RB 42759 3322 13 diminished diminish VBN 42759 3322 14 as as IN 42759 3322 15 to to TO 42759 3322 16 render render VB 42759 3322 17 the the DT 42759 3322 18 share share NN 42759 3322 19 of of IN 42759 3322 20 the the DT 42759 3322 21 great great JJ 42759 3322 22 majority majority NN 42759 3322 23 of of IN 42759 3322 24 persons person NNS 42759 3322 25 smaller small JJR 42759 3322 26 than than IN 42759 3322 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3322 28 would would MD 42759 3322 29 have have VB 42759 3322 30 been be VBN 42759 3322 31 under under IN 42759 3322 32 a a DT 42759 3322 33 rational rational JJ 42759 3322 34 plan plan NN 42759 3322 35 of of IN 42759 3322 36 unequal unequal JJ 42759 3322 37 distribution distribution NN 42759 3322 38 . . . 42759 3323 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3323 2 The the DT 42759 3323 3 Canon Canon NNP 42759 3323 4 of of IN 42759 3323 5 Needs Needs NNP 42759 3323 6 _ _ NNP 42759 3323 7 The the DT 42759 3323 8 second second JJ 42759 3323 9 conceivable conceivable JJ 42759 3323 10 rule rule NN 42759 3323 11 is be VBZ 42759 3323 12 that that DT 42759 3323 13 of of IN 42759 3323 14 proportional proportional JJ 42759 3323 15 needs need NNS 42759 3323 16 . . . 42759 3324 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3324 2 would would MD 42759 3324 3 require require VB 42759 3324 4 each each DT 42759 3324 5 person person NN 42759 3324 6 to to TO 42759 3324 7 be be VB 42759 3324 8 rewarded reward VBN 42759 3324 9 in in IN 42759 3324 10 accordance accordance NN 42759 3324 11 with with IN 42759 3324 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3324 13 capacity capacity NN 42759 3324 14 to to TO 42759 3324 15 use use VB 42759 3324 16 goods good NNS 42759 3324 17 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 3324 18 . . . 42759 3325 1 If if IN 42759 3325 2 the the DT 42759 3325 3 task task NN 42759 3325 4 of of IN 42759 3325 5 distribution distribution NN 42759 3325 6 were be VBD 42759 3325 7 entirely entirely RB 42759 3325 8 independent independent JJ 42759 3325 9 of of IN 42759 3325 10 the the DT 42759 3325 11 process process NN 42759 3325 12 of of IN 42759 3325 13 production production NN 42759 3325 14 , , , 42759 3325 15 this this DT 42759 3325 16 rule rule NN 42759 3325 17 would would MD 42759 3325 18 be be VB 42759 3325 19 ideal ideal JJ 42759 3325 20 ; ; : 42759 3325 21 for for IN 42759 3325 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3325 23 would would MD 42759 3325 24 treat treat VB 42759 3325 25 men man NNS 42759 3325 26 as as IN 42759 3325 27 equal equal JJ 42759 3325 28 in in IN 42759 3325 29 those those DT 42759 3325 30 respects respect NNS 42759 3325 31 in in IN 42759 3325 32 which which WDT 42759 3325 33 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3325 34 are be VBP 42759 3325 35 equal equal JJ 42759 3325 36 ; ; : 42759 3325 37 namely namely RB 42759 3325 38 , , , 42759 3325 39 as as IN 42759 3325 40 beings being NNS 42759 3325 41 endowed endow VBN 42759 3325 42 with with IN 42759 3325 43 the the DT 42759 3325 44 dignity dignity NN 42759 3325 45 and and CC 42759 3325 46 the the DT 42759 3325 47 potencies potency NNS 42759 3325 48 of of IN 42759 3325 49 personality personality NN 42759 3325 50 ; ; , 42759 3325 51 and and CC 42759 3325 52 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3325 53 would would MD 42759 3325 54 treat treat VB 42759 3325 55 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3325 56 as as IN 42759 3325 57 unequal unequal JJ 42759 3325 58 in in IN 42759 3325 59 those those DT 42759 3325 60 respects respect NNS 42759 3325 61 in in IN 42759 3325 62 which which WDT 42759 3325 63 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3325 64 are be VBP 42759 3325 65 unequal unequal JJ 42759 3325 66 ; ; : 42759 3325 67 that that RB 42759 3325 68 is is RB 42759 3325 69 , , , 42759 3325 70 in in IN 42759 3325 71 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3325 72 desires desire NNS 42759 3325 73 and and CC 42759 3325 74 capacities capacity NNS 42759 3325 75 . . . 42759 3326 1 But but CC 42759 3326 2 the the DT 42759 3326 3 relation relation NN 42759 3326 4 between between IN 42759 3326 5 distribution distribution NN 42759 3326 6 and and CC 42759 3326 7 production production NN 42759 3326 8 can can MD 42759 3326 9 not not RB 42759 3326 10 be be VB 42759 3326 11 left leave VBN 42759 3326 12 out out IN 42759 3326 13 of of IN 42759 3326 14 account account NN 42759 3326 15 . . . 42759 3327 1 The the DT 42759 3327 2 product product NN 42759 3327 3 is be VBZ 42759 3327 4 distributed distribute VBN 42759 3327 5 primarily primarily RB 42759 3327 6 among among IN 42759 3327 7 the the DT 42759 3327 8 agents agent NNS 42759 3327 9 of of IN 42759 3327 10 production production NN 42759 3327 11 only only RB 42759 3327 12 , , , 42759 3327 13 and and CC 42759 3327 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3327 15 must must MD 42759 3327 16 be be VB 42759 3327 17 so so RB 42759 3327 18 distributed distribute VBN 42759 3327 19 as as IN 42759 3327 20 to to TO 42759 3327 21 give give VB 42759 3327 22 due due JJ 42759 3327 23 consideration consideration NN 42759 3327 24 to to IN 42759 3327 25 the the DT 42759 3327 26 moral moral JJ 42759 3327 27 claims claim NNS 42759 3327 28 of of IN 42759 3327 29 the the DT 42759 3327 30 producer producer NN 42759 3327 31 as as IN 42759 3327 32 such such JJ 42759 3327 33 . . . 42759 3328 1 The the DT 42759 3328 2 latter latter NN 42759 3328 3 has have VBZ 42759 3328 4 to to TO 42759 3328 5 be be VB 42759 3328 6 considered consider VBN 42759 3328 7 not not RB 42759 3328 8 merely merely RB 42759 3328 9 as as IN 42759 3328 10 a a DT 42759 3328 11 person person NN 42759 3328 12 possessing possess VBG 42759 3328 13 needs need VBZ 42759 3328 14 , , , 42759 3328 15 but but CC 42759 3328 16 as as IN 42759 3328 17 a a DT 42759 3328 18 person person NN 42759 3328 19 who who WP 42759 3328 20 has have VBZ 42759 3328 21 contributed contribute VBN 42759 3328 22 something something NN 42759 3328 23 to to IN 42759 3328 24 the the DT 42759 3328 25 making making NN 42759 3328 26 of of IN 42759 3328 27 the the DT 42759 3328 28 product product NN 42759 3328 29 . . . 42759 3329 1 Whence whence NN 42759 3329 2 arise arise VBP 42759 3329 3 the the DT 42759 3329 4 questions question NNS 42759 3329 5 of of IN 42759 3329 6 relative relative JJ 42759 3329 7 efforts effort NNS 42759 3329 8 and and CC 42759 3329 9 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3329 10 , , , 42759 3329 11 and and CC 42759 3329 12 relative relative JJ 42759 3329 13 productivity productivity NN 42759 3329 14 . . . 42759 3330 1 Since since IN 42759 3330 2 only only RB 42759 3330 3 those those DT 42759 3330 4 who who WP 42759 3330 5 have have VBP 42759 3330 6 contributed contribute VBN 42759 3330 7 to to IN 42759 3330 8 the the DT 42759 3330 9 product product NN 42759 3330 10 participate participate VB 42759 3330 11 in in IN 42759 3330 12 the the DT 42759 3330 13 distribution distribution NN 42759 3330 14 thereof thereof RB 42759 3330 15 , , , 42759 3330 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3330 17 would would MD 42759 3330 18 seem seem VB 42759 3330 19 that that IN 42759 3330 20 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3330 21 should should MD 42759 3330 22 be be VB 42759 3330 23 rewarded reward VBN 42759 3330 24 in in IN 42759 3330 25 proportion proportion NN 42759 3330 26 to to IN 42759 3330 27 the the DT 42759 3330 28 efforts effort NNS 42759 3330 29 and and CC 42759 3330 30 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3330 31 that that WDT 42759 3330 32 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3330 33 exert exert VBP 42759 3330 34 and and CC 42759 3330 35 undergo undergo VBP 42759 3330 36 . . . 42759 3331 1 As as IN 42759 3331 2 an an DT 42759 3331 3 example example NN 42759 3331 4 of of IN 42759 3331 5 varying vary VBG 42759 3331 6 effort effort NN 42759 3331 7 , , , 42759 3331 8 let let VB 42759 3331 9 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3331 10 take take VB 42759 3331 11 two two CD 42759 3331 12 men man NNS 42759 3331 13 of of IN 42759 3331 14 equal equal JJ 42759 3331 15 needs need NNS 42759 3331 16 who who WP 42759 3331 17 perform perform VBP 42759 3331 18 the the DT 42759 3331 19 same same JJ 42759 3331 20 labour labour NN 42759 3331 21 in in IN 42759 3331 22 such such PDT 42759 3331 23 a a DT 42759 3331 24 way way NN 42759 3331 25 that that WDT 42759 3331 26 the the DT 42759 3331 27 first first JJ 42759 3331 28 expends expend VBZ 42759 3331 29 90 90 CD 42759 3331 30 per per NN 42759 3331 31 cent cent NN 42759 3331 32 . . . 42759 3332 1 of of IN 42759 3332 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3332 3 energy energy NN 42759 3332 4 , , , 42759 3332 5 while while IN 42759 3332 6 the the DT 42759 3332 7 second second JJ 42759 3332 8 expends expend VBZ 42759 3332 9 60 60 CD 42759 3332 10 per per NN 42759 3332 11 cent cent NN 42759 3332 12 . . . 42759 3333 1 As as IN 42759 3333 2 an an DT 42759 3333 3 example example NN 42759 3333 4 of of IN 42759 3333 5 varying vary VBG 42759 3333 6 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 3333 7 , , , 42759 3333 8 let let VB 42759 3333 9 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3333 10 take take VB 42759 3333 11 the the DT 42759 3333 12 ditch ditch NN 42759 3333 13 digger digger NN 42759 3333 14 , , , 42759 3333 15 and and CC 42759 3333 16 the the DT 42759 3333 17 driver driver NN 42759 3333 18 who who WP 42759 3333 19 sits sit VBZ 42759 3333 20 all all DT 42759 3333 21 day day NN 42759 3333 22 on on IN 42759 3333 23 the the DT 42759 3333 24 dump dump NN 42759 3333 25 wagon wagon NN 42759 3333 26 . . . 42759 3334 1 In in IN 42759 3334 2 both both PDT 42759 3334 3 these these DT 42759 3334 4 examples example NNS 42759 3334 5 the the DT 42759 3334 6 first first JJ 42759 3334 7 man man NN 42759 3334 8 expends expend VBZ 42759 3334 9 more more RBR 42759 3334 10 painful painful JJ 42759 3334 11 exertion exertion NN 42759 3334 12 than than IN 42759 3334 13 the the DT 42759 3334 14 second second JJ 42759 3334 15 . . . 42759 3335 1 This this DT 42759 3335 2 would would MD 42759 3335 3 seem seem VB 42759 3335 4 to to TO 42759 3335 5 make make VB 42759 3335 6 a a DT 42759 3335 7 difference difference NN 42759 3335 8 in in IN 42759 3335 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3335 10 moral moral JJ 42759 3335 11 desert desert NN 42759 3335 12 . . . 42759 3336 1 Justice Justice NNP 42759 3336 2 would would MD 42759 3336 3 seem seem VB 42759 3336 4 to to TO 42759 3336 5 require require VB 42759 3336 6 that that IN 42759 3336 7 in in IN 42759 3336 8 each each DT 42759 3336 9 case case NN 42759 3336 10 compensation compensation NN 42759 3336 11 should should MD 42759 3336 12 be be VB 42759 3336 13 proportionate proportionate JJ 42759 3336 14 to to IN 42759 3336 15 exertion exertion NN 42759 3336 16 rather rather RB 42759 3336 17 than than IN 42759 3336 18 to to TO 42759 3336 19 needs need NNS 42759 3336 20 . . . 42759 3337 1 At at IN 42759 3337 2 any any DT 42759 3337 3 rate rate NN 42759 3337 4 , , , 42759 3337 5 the the DT 42759 3337 6 claims claim NNS 42759 3337 7 of of IN 42759 3337 8 needs need NNS 42759 3337 9 should should MD 42759 3337 10 be be VB 42759 3337 11 modified modify VBN 42759 3337 12 to to IN 42759 3337 13 some some DT 42759 3337 14 extent extent NN 42759 3337 15 in in IN 42759 3337 16 favour favour NN 42759 3337 17 of of IN 42759 3337 18 the the DT 42759 3337 19 claims claim NNS 42759 3337 20 of of IN 42759 3337 21 exertion exertion NN 42759 3337 22 . . . 42759 3338 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3338 2 is be VBZ 42759 3338 3 upon upon IN 42759 3338 4 the the DT 42759 3338 5 principle principle NN 42759 3338 6 of of IN 42759 3338 7 efforts effort NNS 42759 3338 8 and and CC 42759 3338 9 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3338 10 that that WDT 42759 3338 11 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3338 12 expect expect VBP 42759 3338 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3338 14 eternal eternal JJ 42759 3338 15 rewards reward NNS 42759 3338 16 to to TO 42759 3338 17 be be VB 42759 3338 18 based base VBN 42759 3338 19 by by IN 42759 3338 20 the the DT 42759 3338 21 infinitely infinitely NN 42759 3338 22 just just RB 42759 3338 23 Rewarder Rewarder NNP 42759 3338 24 . . . 42759 3339 1 The the DT 42759 3339 2 principle principle NN 42759 3339 3 of of IN 42759 3339 4 needs need NNS 42759 3339 5 is be VBZ 42759 3339 6 likewise likewise RB 42759 3339 7 in in IN 42759 3339 8 conflict conflict NN 42759 3339 9 with with IN 42759 3339 10 the the DT 42759 3339 11 principle principle NN 42759 3339 12 of of IN 42759 3339 13 comparative comparative JJ 42759 3339 14 productivity productivity NN 42759 3339 15 . . . 42759 3340 1 Men man NNS 42759 3340 2 generally generally RB 42759 3340 3 demand demand VBP 42759 3340 4 rewards reward NNS 42759 3340 5 in in IN 42759 3340 6 proportion proportion NN 42759 3340 7 to to IN 42759 3340 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3340 9 products product NNS 42759 3340 10 . . . 42759 3341 1 The the DT 42759 3341 2 validity validity NN 42759 3341 3 of of IN 42759 3341 4 this this DT 42759 3341 5 demand demand NN 42759 3341 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3341 7 shall shall MD 42759 3341 8 examine examine VB 42759 3341 9 in in IN 42759 3341 10 a a DT 42759 3341 11 subsequent subsequent JJ 42759 3341 12 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 3341 13 . . . 42759 3342 1 Like like IN 42759 3342 2 the the DT 42759 3342 3 rule rule NN 42759 3342 4 of of IN 42759 3342 5 arithmetical arithmetical JJ 42759 3342 6 equality equality NN 42759 3342 7 , , , 42759 3342 8 the the DT 42759 3342 9 rule rule NN 42759 3342 10 of of IN 42759 3342 11 proportional proportional JJ 42759 3342 12 needs need NNS 42759 3342 13 is be VBZ 42759 3342 14 not not RB 42759 3342 15 only only RB 42759 3342 16 incomplete incomplete JJ 42759 3342 17 ethically ethically RB 42759 3342 18 but but CC 42759 3342 19 impossible impossible JJ 42759 3342 20 socially socially RB 42759 3342 21 . . . 42759 3343 1 Men man NNS 42759 3343 2 's 's POS 42759 3343 3 needs need NNS 42759 3343 4 vary vary VBP 42759 3343 5 so so RB 42759 3343 6 widely widely RB 42759 3343 7 and and CC 42759 3343 8 so so RB 42759 3343 9 imperceptibly imperceptibly RB 42759 3343 10 that that IN 42759 3343 11 no no DT 42759 3343 12 human human JJ 42759 3343 13 authority authority NN 42759 3343 14 could could MD 42759 3343 15 use use VB 42759 3343 16 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3343 17 as as IN 42759 3343 18 the the DT 42759 3343 19 basis basis NN 42759 3343 20 of of IN 42759 3343 21 even even RB 42759 3343 22 an an DT 42759 3343 23 approximately approximately RB 42759 3343 24 accurate accurate JJ 42759 3343 25 distribution distribution NN 42759 3343 26 . . . 42759 3344 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 3344 2 , , , 42759 3344 3 any any DT 42759 3344 4 attempt attempt NN 42759 3344 5 to to TO 42759 3344 6 distribute distribute VB 42759 3344 7 rewards reward NNS 42759 3344 8 on on IN 42759 3344 9 this this DT 42759 3344 10 basis basis NN 42759 3344 11 alone alone RB 42759 3344 12 would would MD 42759 3344 13 be be VB 42759 3344 14 injurious injurious JJ 42759 3344 15 to to IN 42759 3344 16 social social JJ 42759 3344 17 welfare welfare NN 42759 3344 18 . . . 42759 3345 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3345 2 would would MD 42759 3345 3 lead lead VB 42759 3345 4 to to IN 42759 3345 5 a a DT 42759 3345 6 great great JJ 42759 3345 7 diminution diminution NN 42759 3345 8 in in IN 42759 3345 9 the the DT 42759 3345 10 productivity productivity NN 42759 3345 11 of of IN 42759 3345 12 the the DT 42759 3345 13 more more RBR 42759 3345 14 honest honest JJ 42759 3345 15 , , , 42759 3345 16 the the DT 42759 3345 17 more more RBR 42759 3345 18 energetic energetic JJ 42759 3345 19 , , , 42759 3345 20 and and CC 42759 3345 21 the the DT 42759 3345 22 more more RBR 42759 3345 23 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3345 24 among among IN 42759 3345 25 the the DT 42759 3345 26 agents agent NNS 42759 3345 27 of of IN 42759 3345 28 production production NN 42759 3345 29 . . . 42759 3346 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3346 2 The the DT 42759 3346 3 Canon Canon NNP 42759 3346 4 of of IN 42759 3346 5 Efforts Efforts NNPS 42759 3346 6 and and CC 42759 3346 7 Sacrifice Sacrifice NNP 42759 3346 8 _ _ NNP 42759 3346 9 The the DT 42759 3346 10 third third JJ 42759 3346 11 canon canon NN 42759 3346 12 of of IN 42759 3346 13 distribution distribution NN 42759 3346 14 , , , 42759 3346 15 that that DT 42759 3346 16 of of IN 42759 3346 17 efforts effort NNS 42759 3346 18 and and CC 42759 3346 19 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3346 20 , , , 42759 3346 21 would would MD 42759 3346 22 be be VB 42759 3346 23 ideally ideally RB 42759 3346 24 just just RB 42759 3346 25 if if IN 42759 3346 26 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3346 27 could could MD 42759 3346 28 ignore ignore VB 42759 3346 29 the the DT 42759 3346 30 questions question NNS 42759 3346 31 of of IN 42759 3346 32 needs need NNS 42759 3346 33 and and CC 42759 3346 34 productivity productivity NN 42759 3346 35 . . . 42759 3347 1 But but CC 42759 3347 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3347 3 can can MD 42759 3347 4 not not RB 42759 3347 5 think think VB 42759 3347 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3347 7 just just RB 42759 3347 8 to to TO 42759 3347 9 reward reward VB 42759 3347 10 equally equally RB 42759 3347 11 two two CD 42759 3347 12 men man NNS 42759 3347 13 who who WP 42759 3347 14 have have VBP 42759 3347 15 expended expend VBN 42759 3347 16 the the DT 42759 3347 17 same same JJ 42759 3347 18 quantity quantity NN 42759 3347 19 of of IN 42759 3347 20 painful painful JJ 42759 3347 21 exertion exertion NN 42759 3347 22 , , , 42759 3347 23 but but CC 42759 3347 24 who who WP 42759 3347 25 differ differ VBP 42759 3347 26 in in IN 42759 3347 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3347 28 needs need NNS 42759 3347 29 and and CC 42759 3347 30 in in IN 42759 3347 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3347 32 capacities capacity NNS 42759 3347 33 of of IN 42759 3347 34 self self NN 42759 3347 35 development development NN 42759 3347 36 . . . 42759 3348 1 To to TO 42759 3348 2 do do VB 42759 3348 3 so so RB 42759 3348 4 would would MD 42759 3348 5 be be VB 42759 3348 6 to to TO 42759 3348 7 treat treat VB 42759 3348 8 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3348 9 unequally unequally RB 42759 3348 10 in in IN 42759 3348 11 the the DT 42759 3348 12 matter matter NN 42759 3348 13 of of IN 42759 3348 14 welfare welfare NN 42759 3348 15 , , , 42759 3348 16 which which WDT 42759 3348 17 is be VBZ 42759 3348 18 the the DT 42759 3348 19 end end NN 42759 3348 20 and and CC 42759 3348 21 reason reason NN 42759 3348 22 of of IN 42759 3348 23 all all DT 42759 3348 24 distribution distribution NN 42759 3348 25 . . . 42759 3349 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 3349 2 the the DT 42759 3349 3 principle principle NN 42759 3349 4 of of IN 42759 3349 5 efforts effort NNS 42759 3349 6 and and CC 42759 3349 7 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3349 8 must must MD 42759 3349 9 be be VB 42759 3349 10 modified modify VBN 42759 3349 11 by by IN 42759 3349 12 the the DT 42759 3349 13 principle principle NN 42759 3349 14 of of IN 42759 3349 15 needs need NNS 42759 3349 16 . . . 42759 3350 1 Apparently apparently RB 42759 3350 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3350 3 must must MD 42759 3350 4 also also RB 42759 3350 5 give give VB 42759 3350 6 way way NN 42759 3350 7 in in IN 42759 3350 8 some some DT 42759 3350 9 degree degree NN 42759 3350 10 to to IN 42759 3350 11 the the DT 42759 3350 12 principle principle NN 42759 3350 13 of of IN 42759 3350 14 comparative comparative JJ 42759 3350 15 productivity productivity NN 42759 3350 16 . . . 42759 3351 1 When when WRB 42759 3351 2 two two CD 42759 3351 3 men man NNS 42759 3351 4 of of IN 42759 3351 5 unequal unequal JJ 42759 3351 6 powers power NNS 42759 3351 7 make make VBP 42759 3351 8 equal equal JJ 42759 3351 9 efforts effort NNS 42759 3351 10 , , , 42759 3351 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3351 12 turn turn VBP 42759 3351 13 out out RP 42759 3351 14 unequal unequal JJ 42759 3351 15 amounts amount NNS 42759 3351 16 of of IN 42759 3351 17 product product NN 42759 3351 18 . . . 42759 3352 1 Almost almost RB 42759 3352 2 invariably invariably RB 42759 3352 3 the the DT 42759 3352 4 more more RBR 42759 3352 5 productive productive JJ 42759 3352 6 man man NN 42759 3352 7 believes believe VBZ 42759 3352 8 that that IN 42759 3352 9 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3352 10 should should MD 42759 3352 11 receive receive VB 42759 3352 12 a a DT 42759 3352 13 greater great JJR 42759 3352 14 share share NN 42759 3352 15 of of IN 42759 3352 16 the the DT 42759 3352 17 product product NN 42759 3352 18 than than IN 42759 3352 19 the the DT 42759 3352 20 other other JJ 42759 3352 21 . . . 42759 3353 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 3353 2 believes believe VBZ 42759 3353 3 that that IN 42759 3353 4 the the DT 42759 3353 5 rewards reward NNS 42759 3353 6 should should MD 42759 3353 7 be be VB 42759 3353 8 determined determine VBN 42759 3353 9 by by IN 42759 3353 10 productivity productivity NN 42759 3353 11 . . . 42759 3354 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3354 2 is be VBZ 42759 3354 3 evident evident JJ 42759 3354 4 that that IN 42759 3354 5 the the DT 42759 3354 6 rule rule NN 42759 3354 7 of of IN 42759 3354 8 efforts effort NNS 42759 3354 9 and and CC 42759 3354 10 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3354 11 , , , 42759 3354 12 like like IN 42759 3354 13 those those DT 42759 3354 14 of of IN 42759 3354 15 equality equality NN 42759 3354 16 and and CC 42759 3354 17 needs need NNS 42759 3354 18 , , , 42759 3354 19 could could MD 42759 3354 20 not not RB 42759 3354 21 be be VB 42759 3354 22 universally universally RB 42759 3354 23 enforced enforce VBN 42759 3354 24 in in IN 42759 3354 25 practice practice NN 42759 3354 26 . . . 42759 3355 1 With with IN 42759 3355 2 the the DT 42759 3355 3 exception exception NN 42759 3355 4 of of IN 42759 3355 5 cases case NNS 42759 3355 6 in in IN 42759 3355 7 which which WDT 42759 3355 8 the the DT 42759 3355 9 worker worker NN 42759 3355 10 is be VBZ 42759 3355 11 called call VBN 42759 3355 12 upon upon IN 42759 3355 13 regularly regularly RB 42759 3355 14 to to TO 42759 3355 15 make make VB 42759 3355 16 greater great JJR 42759 3355 17 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3355 18 owing owe VBG 42759 3355 19 to to IN 42759 3355 20 the the DT 42759 3355 21 disagreeable disagreeable JJ 42759 3355 22 nature nature NN 42759 3355 23 of of IN 42759 3355 24 the the DT 42759 3355 25 task task NN 42759 3355 26 , , , 42759 3355 27 attempts attempt VBZ 42759 3355 28 to to TO 42759 3355 29 measure measure VB 42759 3355 30 the the DT 42759 3355 31 amounts amount NNS 42759 3355 32 of of IN 42759 3355 33 effort effort NN 42759 3355 34 and and CC 42759 3355 35 painful painful JJ 42759 3355 36 exertion exertion NN 42759 3355 37 put put VBN 42759 3355 38 forth forth RP 42759 3355 39 by by IN 42759 3355 40 the the DT 42759 3355 41 different different JJ 42759 3355 42 agents agent NNS 42759 3355 43 of of IN 42759 3355 44 production production NN 42759 3355 45 would would MD 42759 3355 46 on on IN 42759 3355 47 the the DT 42759 3355 48 whole whole NN 42759 3355 49 be be VB 42759 3355 50 little little RB 42759 3355 51 more more JJR 42759 3355 52 than than IN 42759 3355 53 rough rough JJ 42759 3355 54 guesses guess NNS 42759 3355 55 . . . 42759 3356 1 These these DT 42759 3356 2 would would MD 42759 3356 3 probably probably RB 42759 3356 4 prove prove VB 42759 3356 5 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 42759 3356 6 to to IN 42759 3356 7 the the DT 42759 3356 8 majority majority NN 42759 3356 9 . . . 42759 3357 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 3357 2 , , , 42759 3357 3 the the DT 42759 3357 4 possessors possessor NNS 42759 3357 5 of of IN 42759 3357 6 superior superior NNP 42759 3357 7 productive productive JJ 42759 3357 8 power power NN 42759 3357 9 would would MD 42759 3357 10 in in IN 42759 3357 11 most most JJS 42759 3357 12 instances instance NNS 42759 3357 13 reject reject VBP 42759 3357 14 the the DT 42759 3357 15 principle principle NN 42759 3357 16 of of IN 42759 3357 17 efforts effort NNS 42759 3357 18 and and CC 42759 3357 19 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3357 20 as as IN 42759 3357 21 unfair unfair JJ 42759 3357 22 , , , 42759 3357 23 and and CC 42759 3357 24 refuse refuse VBP 42759 3357 25 to to TO 42759 3357 26 do do VB 42759 3357 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3357 28 best good JJS 42759 3357 29 work work NN 42759 3357 30 under under IN 42759 3357 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3357 32 operation operation NN 42759 3357 33 . . . 42759 3358 1 The the DT 42759 3358 2 three three CD 42759 3358 3 rules rule NNS 42759 3358 4 already already RB 42759 3358 5 considered consider VBN 42759 3358 6 are be VBP 42759 3358 7 formally formally RB 42759 3358 8 ethical ethical JJ 42759 3358 9 , , , 42759 3358 10 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 3358 11 as as IN 42759 3358 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3358 13 are be VBP 42759 3358 14 directly directly RB 42759 3358 15 based base VBN 42759 3358 16 upon upon IN 42759 3358 17 the the DT 42759 3358 18 dignity dignity NN 42759 3358 19 and and CC 42759 3358 20 claims claim NNS 42759 3358 21 of of IN 42759 3358 22 personality personality NN 42759 3358 23 . . . 42759 3359 1 The the DT 42759 3359 2 two two CD 42759 3359 3 following following NN 42759 3359 4 are be VBP 42759 3359 5 primarily primarily RB 42759 3359 6 physical physical JJ 42759 3359 7 and and CC 42759 3359 8 social social JJ 42759 3359 9 ; ; : 42759 3359 10 for for IN 42759 3359 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3359 12 measure measure VBP 42759 3359 13 economic economic JJ 42759 3359 14 value value NN 42759 3359 15 rather rather RB 42759 3359 16 than than IN 42759 3359 17 ethical ethical JJ 42759 3359 18 worth worth NN 42759 3359 19 . . . 42759 3360 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 3360 2 , , , 42759 3360 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3360 4 must must MD 42759 3360 5 have have VB 42759 3360 6 a a DT 42759 3360 7 large large JJ 42759 3360 8 place place NN 42759 3360 9 in in IN 42759 3360 10 any any DT 42759 3360 11 system system NN 42759 3360 12 which which WDT 42759 3360 13 includes include VBZ 42759 3360 14 the the DT 42759 3360 15 factor factor NN 42759 3360 16 of of IN 42759 3360 17 competition competition NN 42759 3360 18 . . . 42759 3361 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3361 2 The the DT 42759 3361 3 Canon Canon NNP 42759 3361 4 of of IN 42759 3361 5 Productivity Productivity NNP 42759 3361 6 _ _ NNP 42759 3361 7 According accord VBG 42759 3361 8 to to IN 42759 3361 9 this this DT 42759 3361 10 rule rule NN 42759 3361 11 , , , 42759 3361 12 men man NNS 42759 3361 13 should should MD 42759 3361 14 be be VB 42759 3361 15 rewarded reward VBN 42759 3361 16 in in IN 42759 3361 17 proportion proportion NN 42759 3361 18 to to IN 42759 3361 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3361 20 contributions contribution NNS 42759 3361 21 to to IN 42759 3361 22 the the DT 42759 3361 23 product product NN 42759 3361 24 . . . 42759 3362 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3362 2 is be VBZ 42759 3362 3 open open JJ 42759 3362 4 to to IN 42759 3362 5 the the DT 42759 3362 6 obvious obvious JJ 42759 3362 7 objection objection NN 42759 3362 8 that that WDT 42759 3362 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3362 10 ignores ignore VBZ 42759 3362 11 the the DT 42759 3362 12 moral moral JJ 42759 3362 13 claims claim NNS 42759 3362 14 of of IN 42759 3362 15 needs need NNS 42759 3362 16 and and CC 42759 3362 17 efforts effort NNS 42759 3362 18 . . . 42759 3363 1 The the DT 42759 3363 2 needs need NNS 42759 3363 3 and and CC 42759 3363 4 use use NN 42759 3363 5 - - HYPH 42759 3363 6 capacities capacity NNS 42759 3363 7 of of IN 42759 3363 8 men man NNS 42759 3363 9 do do VBP 42759 3363 10 , , , 42759 3363 11 indeed indeed RB 42759 3363 12 , , , 42759 3363 13 bear bear VB 42759 3363 14 some some DT 42759 3363 15 relation relation NN 42759 3363 16 to to IN 42759 3363 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3363 18 productive productive JJ 42759 3363 19 capacities capacity NNS 42759 3363 20 , , , 42759 3363 21 and and CC 42759 3363 22 the the DT 42759 3363 23 man man NN 42759 3363 24 who who WP 42759 3363 25 can can MD 42759 3363 26 produce produce VB 42759 3363 27 more more RBR 42759 3363 28 usually usually RB 42759 3363 29 needs need VBZ 42759 3363 30 more more JJR 42759 3363 31 ; ; : 42759 3363 32 but but CC 42759 3363 33 the the DT 42759 3363 34 differences difference NNS 42759 3363 35 between between IN 42759 3363 36 the the DT 42759 3363 37 two two CD 42759 3363 38 elements element NNS 42759 3363 39 are be VBP 42759 3363 40 so so RB 42759 3363 41 great great JJ 42759 3363 42 that that IN 42759 3363 43 distribution distribution NN 42759 3363 44 based base VBN 42759 3363 45 solely solely RB 42759 3363 46 upon upon IN 42759 3363 47 productivity productivity NN 42759 3363 48 would would MD 42759 3363 49 fall fall VB 42759 3363 50 far far RB 42759 3363 51 short short RB 42759 3363 52 of of IN 42759 3363 53 satisfying satisfy VBG 42759 3363 54 the the DT 42759 3363 55 demands demand NNS 42759 3363 56 of of IN 42759 3363 57 needs need NNS 42759 3363 58 . . . 42759 3364 1 Yet yet CC 42759 3364 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3364 3 have have VBP 42759 3364 4 seen see VBN 42759 3364 5 that that IN 42759 3364 6 needs need NNS 42759 3364 7 constitute constitute VB 42759 3364 8 one one CD 42759 3364 9 of of IN 42759 3364 10 the the DT 42759 3364 11 fundamentally fundamentally RB 42759 3364 12 valid valid JJ 42759 3364 13 principles principle NNS 42759 3364 14 of of IN 42759 3364 15 distribution distribution NN 42759 3364 16 . . . 42759 3365 1 Between between IN 42759 3365 2 productivity productivity NN 42759 3365 3 on on IN 42759 3365 4 the the DT 42759 3365 5 one one CD 42759 3365 6 hand hand NN 42759 3365 7 and and CC 42759 3365 8 efforts effort NNS 42759 3365 9 and and CC 42759 3365 10 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3365 11 on on IN 42759 3365 12 the the DT 42759 3365 13 other other JJ 42759 3365 14 , , , 42759 3365 15 there there EX 42759 3365 16 are be VBP 42759 3365 17 likewise likewise RB 42759 3365 18 important important JJ 42759 3365 19 differences difference NNS 42759 3365 20 . . . 42759 3366 1 When when WRB 42759 3366 2 men man NNS 42759 3366 3 of of IN 42759 3366 4 equal equal JJ 42759 3366 5 productive productive JJ 42759 3366 6 power power NN 42759 3366 7 are be VBP 42759 3366 8 performing perform VBG 42759 3366 9 the the DT 42759 3366 10 same same JJ 42759 3366 11 kind kind NN 42759 3366 12 of of IN 42759 3366 13 labour labour JJ 42759 3366 14 , , , 42759 3366 15 superior superior JJ 42759 3366 16 amounts amount NNS 42759 3366 17 of of IN 42759 3366 18 product product NN 42759 3366 19 do do VBP 42759 3366 20 represent represent VB 42759 3366 21 superior superior JJ 42759 3366 22 amounts amount NNS 42759 3366 23 of of IN 42759 3366 24 effort effort NN 42759 3366 25 ; ; : 42759 3366 26 when when WRB 42759 3366 27 the the DT 42759 3366 28 tasks task NNS 42759 3366 29 differ differ VBP 42759 3366 30 in in IN 42759 3366 31 irksomeness irksomeness NN 42759 3366 32 or or CC 42759 3366 33 disagreeableness disagreeableness NN 42759 3366 34 , , , 42759 3366 35 the the DT 42759 3366 36 larger large JJR 42759 3366 37 product product NN 42759 3366 38 may may MD 42759 3366 39 be be VB 42759 3366 40 brought bring VBN 42759 3366 41 into into IN 42759 3366 42 being be VBG 42759 3366 43 with with IN 42759 3366 44 a a DT 42759 3366 45 smaller small JJR 42759 3366 46 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 3366 47 of of IN 42759 3366 48 painful painful JJ 42759 3366 49 exertion exertion NN 42759 3366 50 . . . 42759 3367 1 If if IN 42759 3367 2 men man NNS 42759 3367 3 are be VBP 42759 3367 4 unequal unequal JJ 42759 3367 5 in in IN 42759 3367 6 productive productive JJ 42759 3367 7 power power NN 42759 3367 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3367 9 products product NNS 42759 3367 10 are be VBP 42759 3367 11 obviously obviously RB 42759 3367 12 not not RB 42759 3367 13 in in IN 42759 3367 14 proportion proportion NN 42759 3367 15 to to IN 42759 3367 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3367 17 efforts effort NNS 42759 3367 18 . . . 42759 3368 1 Consider consider VB 42759 3368 2 two two CD 42759 3368 3 men man NNS 42759 3368 4 whose whose WP$ 42759 3368 5 natural natural JJ 42759 3368 6 physical physical JJ 42759 3368 7 abilities ability NNS 42759 3368 8 are be VBP 42759 3368 9 so so RB 42759 3368 10 unequal unequal JJ 42759 3368 11 that that IN 42759 3368 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3368 13 can can MD 42759 3368 14 handle handle VB 42759 3368 15 with with IN 42759 3368 16 equal equal JJ 42759 3368 17 effort effort NN 42759 3368 18 shovels shovel NNS 42759 3368 19 differing differ VBG 42759 3368 20 in in IN 42759 3368 21 capacity capacity NN 42759 3368 22 by by IN 42759 3368 23 fifty fifty CD 42759 3368 24 per per IN 42759 3368 25 cent cent NN 42759 3368 26 . . . 42759 3369 1 Instances instance NNS 42759 3369 2 of of IN 42759 3369 3 this this DT 42759 3369 4 kind kind NN 42759 3369 5 are be VBP 42759 3369 6 innumerable innumerable JJ 42759 3369 7 in in IN 42759 3369 8 industry industry NN 42759 3369 9 . . . 42759 3370 1 If if IN 42759 3370 2 these these DT 42759 3370 3 two two CD 42759 3370 4 men man NNS 42759 3370 5 are be VBP 42759 3370 6 rewarded reward VBN 42759 3370 7 according accord VBG 42759 3370 8 to to IN 42759 3370 9 productivity productivity NN 42759 3370 10 , , , 42759 3370 11 one one PRP 42759 3370 12 will will MD 42759 3370 13 get get VB 42759 3370 14 fifty fifty CD 42759 3370 15 per per IN 42759 3370 16 cent cent NN 42759 3370 17 . . . 42759 3371 1 more more JJR 42759 3371 2 compensation compensation NN 42759 3371 3 than than IN 42759 3371 4 the the DT 42759 3371 5 other other JJ 42759 3371 6 . . . 42759 3372 1 Yet yet RB 42759 3372 2 the the DT 42759 3372 3 surplus surplus NN 42759 3372 4 received receive VBN 42759 3372 5 by by IN 42759 3372 6 the the DT 42759 3372 7 more more RBR 42759 3372 8 fortunate fortunate JJ 42759 3372 9 man man NN 42759 3372 10 does do VBZ 42759 3372 11 not not RB 42759 3372 12 represent represent VB 42759 3372 13 any any DT 42759 3372 14 action action NN 42759 3372 15 or or CC 42759 3372 16 quality quality NN 42759 3372 17 for for IN 42759 3372 18 which which WDT 42759 3372 19 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3372 20 is be VBZ 42759 3372 21 personally personally RB 42759 3372 22 responsible responsible JJ 42759 3372 23 . . . 42759 3373 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3373 2 corresponds correspond VBZ 42759 3373 3 to to IN 42759 3373 4 no no DT 42759 3373 5 larger large JJR 42759 3373 6 output output NN 42759 3373 7 of of IN 42759 3373 8 personal personal JJ 42759 3373 9 effort effort NN 42759 3373 10 , , , 42759 3373 11 no no DT 42759 3373 12 superior superior JJ 42759 3373 13 exercise exercise NN 42759 3373 14 of of IN 42759 3373 15 will will NN 42759 3373 16 , , , 42759 3373 17 no no DT 42759 3373 18 greater great JJR 42759 3373 19 personal personal JJ 42759 3373 20 desert desert NN 42759 3373 21 . . . 42759 3374 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3374 2 is be VBZ 42759 3374 3 based base VBN 42759 3374 4 solely solely RB 42759 3374 5 upon upon IN 42759 3374 6 a a DT 42759 3374 7 richer rich JJR 42759 3374 8 physical physical JJ 42759 3374 9 endowment endowment NN 42759 3374 10 by by IN 42759 3374 11 the the DT 42759 3374 12 Creator Creator NNP 42759 3374 13 . . . 42759 3375 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3375 2 is be VBZ 42759 3375 3 clear clear JJ 42759 3375 4 , , , 42759 3375 5 then then RB 42759 3375 6 , , , 42759 3375 7 that that IN 42759 3375 8 the the DT 42759 3375 9 canon canon NN 42759 3375 10 of of IN 42759 3375 11 productivity productivity NN 42759 3375 12 can can MD 42759 3375 13 not not RB 42759 3375 14 be be VB 42759 3375 15 accepted accept VBN 42759 3375 16 to to IN 42759 3375 17 the the DT 42759 3375 18 exclusion exclusion NN 42759 3375 19 of of IN 42759 3375 20 the the DT 42759 3375 21 principles principle NNS 42759 3375 22 of of IN 42759 3375 23 needs need NNS 42759 3375 24 and and CC 42759 3375 25 efforts effort NNS 42759 3375 26 . . . 42759 3376 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3376 2 is be VBZ 42759 3376 3 not not RB 42759 3376 4 the the DT 42759 3376 5 only only JJ 42759 3376 6 ethical ethical JJ 42759 3376 7 rule rule NN 42759 3376 8 of of IN 42759 3376 9 distribution distribution NN 42759 3376 10 . . . 42759 3377 1 Is be VBZ 42759 3377 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3377 3 a a DT 42759 3377 4 valid valid JJ 42759 3377 5 partial partial JJ 42759 3377 6 rule rule NN 42759 3377 7 ? ? . 42759 3378 1 Superior superior JJ 42759 3378 2 productivity productivity NN 42759 3378 3 is be VBZ 42759 3378 4 frequently frequently RB 42759 3378 5 due due JJ 42759 3378 6 to to IN 42759 3378 7 larger large JJR 42759 3378 8 effort effort NN 42759 3378 9 and and CC 42759 3378 10 expense expense NN 42759 3378 11 put put VBN 42759 3378 12 forth forth RP 42759 3378 13 in in IN 42759 3378 14 study study NN 42759 3378 15 and and CC 42759 3378 16 in in IN 42759 3378 17 other other JJ 42759 3378 18 forms form NNS 42759 3378 19 of of IN 42759 3378 20 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3378 21 preparation preparation NN 42759 3378 22 . . . 42759 3379 1 In in IN 42759 3379 2 such such JJ 42759 3379 3 cases case NNS 42759 3379 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3379 5 demands demand VBZ 42759 3379 6 superior superior JJ 42759 3379 7 rewards reward NNS 42759 3379 8 by by IN 42759 3379 9 the the DT 42759 3379 10 title title NN 42759 3379 11 of of IN 42759 3379 12 efforts effort NNS 42759 3379 13 and and CC 42759 3379 14 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3379 15 . . . 42759 3380 1 Where where WRB 42759 3380 2 , , , 42759 3380 3 however however RB 42759 3380 4 , , , 42759 3380 5 the the DT 42759 3380 6 greater great JJR 42759 3380 7 productivity productivity NN 42759 3380 8 is be VBZ 42759 3380 9 due due JJ 42759 3380 10 merely merely RB 42759 3380 11 to to IN 42759 3380 12 higher high JJR 42759 3380 13 native native JJ 42759 3380 14 qualities quality NNS 42759 3380 15 , , , 42759 3380 16 physical physical JJ 42759 3380 17 or or CC 42759 3380 18 mental mental JJ 42759 3380 19 , , , 42759 3380 20 the the DT 42759 3380 21 greater great JJR 42759 3380 22 reward reward NN 42759 3380 23 is be VBZ 42759 3380 24 not not RB 42759 3380 25 easily easily RB 42759 3380 26 justified justify VBN 42759 3380 27 on on IN 42759 3380 28 purely purely RB 42759 3380 29 ethical ethical JJ 42759 3380 30 grounds ground NNS 42759 3380 31 . . . 42759 3381 1 For for IN 42759 3381 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3381 3 represents represent VBZ 42759 3381 4 no no DT 42759 3381 5 personal personal JJ 42759 3381 6 responsibility responsibility NN 42759 3381 7 , , , 42759 3381 8 will will MD 42759 3381 9 - - HYPH 42759 3381 10 effort effort VB 42759 3381 11 , , , 42759 3381 12 or or CC 42759 3381 13 creativeness creativeness NN 42759 3381 14 . . . 42759 3382 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 3382 2 , , , 42759 3382 3 the the DT 42759 3382 4 great great JJ 42759 3382 5 majority majority NN 42759 3382 6 of of IN 42759 3382 7 the the DT 42759 3382 8 more more RBR 42759 3382 9 fortunately fortunately RB 42759 3382 10 endowed endowed JJ 42759 3382 11 think think VB 42759 3382 12 that that IN 42759 3382 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3382 14 are be VBP 42759 3382 15 unfairly unfairly RB 42759 3382 16 treated treat VBN 42759 3382 17 unless unless IN 42759 3382 18 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3382 19 are be VBP 42759 3382 20 recompensed recompense VBN 42759 3382 21 in in IN 42759 3382 22 proportion proportion NN 42759 3382 23 to to IN 42759 3382 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3382 25 products product NNS 42759 3382 26 . . . 42759 3383 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3383 2 this this DT 42759 3383 3 conviction conviction NN 42759 3383 4 is be VBZ 42759 3383 5 due due JJ 42759 3383 6 to to IN 42759 3383 7 the the DT 42759 3383 8 fact fact NN 42759 3383 9 that that IN 42759 3383 10 such such JJ 42759 3383 11 men man NNS 42759 3383 12 wrongly wrongly RB 42759 3383 13 attribute attribute VBP 42759 3383 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3383 15 larger large JJR 42759 3383 16 product product NN 42759 3383 17 to to IN 42759 3383 18 greater great JJR 42759 3383 19 efforts effort NNS 42759 3383 20 . . . 42759 3384 1 In in IN 42759 3384 2 very very RB 42759 3384 3 many many JJ 42759 3384 4 cases case NNS 42759 3384 5 , , , 42759 3384 6 however however RB 42759 3384 7 , , , 42759 3384 8 the the DT 42759 3384 9 possessors possessor NNS 42759 3384 10 of of IN 42759 3384 11 superior superior NNP 42759 3384 12 productive productive JJ 42759 3384 13 power power NN 42759 3384 14 believe believe VBP 42759 3384 15 that that IN 42759 3384 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3384 17 should should MD 42759 3384 18 be be VB 42759 3384 19 rewarded reward VBN 42759 3384 20 in in IN 42759 3384 21 proportion proportion NN 42759 3384 22 to to IN 42759 3384 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3384 24 products product NNS 42759 3384 25 , , , 42759 3384 26 regardless regardless RB 42759 3384 27 of of IN 42759 3384 28 any any DT 42759 3384 29 other other JJ 42759 3384 30 principle principle NN 42759 3384 31 or or CC 42759 3384 32 factor factor NN 42759 3384 33 . . . 42759 3385 1 Probably probably RB 42759 3385 2 the the DT 42759 3385 3 true true JJ 42759 3385 4 explanation explanation NN 42759 3385 5 of of IN 42759 3385 6 this this DT 42759 3385 7 belief belief NN 42759 3385 8 is be VBZ 42759 3385 9 to to TO 42759 3385 10 be be VB 42759 3385 11 found find VBN 42759 3385 12 in in IN 42759 3385 13 man man NN 42759 3385 14 's 's POS 42759 3385 15 innate innate JJ 42759 3385 16 laziness laziness NN 42759 3385 17 . . . 42759 3386 1 While while IN 42759 3386 2 the the DT 42759 3386 3 prevalence prevalence NN 42759 3386 4 of of IN 42759 3386 5 the the DT 42759 3386 6 conviction conviction NN 42759 3386 7 that that IN 42759 3386 8 superior superior JJ 42759 3386 9 productivity productivity NN 42759 3386 10 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 3386 11 a a DT 42759 3386 12 just just JJ 42759 3386 13 title title NN 42759 3386 14 to to IN 42759 3386 15 superior superior JJ 42759 3386 16 compensation compensation NN 42759 3386 17 , , , 42759 3386 18 does do VBZ 42759 3386 19 create create VB 42759 3386 20 some some DT 42759 3386 21 kind kind NN 42759 3386 22 of of IN 42759 3386 23 a a DT 42759 3386 24 presumption presumption NN 42759 3386 25 in in IN 42759 3386 26 favour favour NN 42759 3386 27 of of IN 42759 3386 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3386 29 correctness correctness NN 42759 3386 30 , , , 42759 3386 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3386 32 must must MD 42759 3386 33 be be VB 42759 3386 34 remembered remember VBN 42759 3386 35 that that IN 42759 3386 36 presumption presumption NN 42759 3386 37 is be VBZ 42759 3386 38 not not RB 42759 3386 39 proof proof JJ 42759 3386 40 . . . 42759 3387 1 Weighing weigh VBG 42759 3387 2 this this DT 42759 3387 3 presumption presumption NN 42759 3387 4 against against IN 42759 3387 5 the the DT 42759 3387 6 objective objective JJ 42759 3387 7 considerations consideration NNS 42759 3387 8 on on IN 42759 3387 9 the the DT 42759 3387 10 opposite opposite JJ 42759 3387 11 side side NN 42759 3387 12 of of IN 42759 3387 13 the the DT 42759 3387 14 argument argument NN 42759 3387 15 , , , 42759 3387 16 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3387 17 take take VBP 42759 3387 18 refuge refuge NN 42759 3387 19 in in IN 42759 3387 20 the the DT 42759 3387 21 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 3387 22 that that IN 42759 3387 23 the the DT 42759 3387 24 ethical ethical JJ 42759 3387 25 validity validity NN 42759 3387 26 of of IN 42759 3387 27 the the DT 42759 3387 28 canon canon NN 42759 3387 29 of of IN 42759 3387 30 comparative comparative JJ 42759 3387 31 productivity productivity NN 42759 3387 32 can can MD 42759 3387 33 neither neither CC 42759 3387 34 be be VB 42759 3387 35 certainly certainly RB 42759 3387 36 proved prove VBN 42759 3387 37 nor nor CC 42759 3387 38 certainly certainly RB 42759 3387 39 disproved disprove VBN 42759 3387 40 . . . 42759 3388 1 Like like IN 42759 3388 2 the the DT 42759 3388 3 rules rule NNS 42759 3388 4 of of IN 42759 3388 5 equality equality NN 42759 3388 6 , , , 42759 3388 7 needs need NNS 42759 3388 8 , , , 42759 3388 9 and and CC 42759 3388 10 efforts effort NNS 42759 3388 11 , , , 42759 3388 12 that that DT 42759 3388 13 of of IN 42759 3388 14 productivity productivity NN 42759 3388 15 can can MD 42759 3388 16 not not RB 42759 3388 17 be be VB 42759 3388 18 universally universally RB 42759 3388 19 enforced enforce VBN 42759 3388 20 in in IN 42759 3388 21 practice practice NN 42759 3388 22 . . . 42759 3389 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3389 2 is be VBZ 42759 3389 3 susceptible susceptible JJ 42759 3389 4 of of IN 42759 3389 5 accurate accurate JJ 42759 3389 6 application application NN 42759 3389 7 among among IN 42759 3389 8 producers producer NNS 42759 3389 9 who who WP 42759 3389 10 perform perform VBP 42759 3389 11 the the DT 42759 3389 12 same same JJ 42759 3389 13 kind kind NN 42759 3389 14 of of IN 42759 3389 15 work work NN 42759 3389 16 with with IN 42759 3389 17 the the DT 42759 3389 18 same same JJ 42759 3389 19 kind kind NN 42759 3389 20 of of IN 42759 3389 21 instruments instrument NNS 42759 3389 22 and and CC 42759 3389 23 equipment equipment NN 42759 3389 24 ; ; : 42759 3389 25 for for IN 42759 3389 26 example example NN 42759 3389 27 , , , 42759 3389 28 between between IN 42759 3389 29 two two CD 42759 3389 30 shovellers shoveller NNS 42759 3389 31 , , , 42759 3389 32 two two CD 42759 3389 33 machine machine NN 42759 3389 34 operators operator NNS 42759 3389 35 , , , 42759 3389 36 two two CD 42759 3389 37 bookkeepers bookkeeper NNS 42759 3389 38 , , , 42759 3389 39 two two CD 42759 3389 40 lawyers lawyer NNS 42759 3389 41 , , , 42759 3389 42 two two CD 42759 3389 43 physicians physician NNS 42759 3389 44 . . . 42759 3390 1 As as IN 42759 3390 2 a a DT 42759 3390 3 rule rule NN 42759 3390 4 , , , 42759 3390 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3390 6 can can MD 42759 3390 7 not not RB 42759 3390 8 be be VB 42759 3390 9 adequately adequately RB 42759 3390 10 applied apply VBN 42759 3390 11 to to IN 42759 3390 12 a a DT 42759 3390 13 product product NN 42759 3390 14 which which WDT 42759 3390 15 is be VBZ 42759 3390 16 brought bring VBN 42759 3390 17 into into IN 42759 3390 18 existence existence NN 42759 3390 19 through through IN 42759 3390 20 a a DT 42759 3390 21 combination combination NN 42759 3390 22 of of IN 42759 3390 23 different different JJ 42759 3390 24 processes process NNS 42759 3390 25 . . . 42759 3391 1 The the DT 42759 3391 2 engine engine NN 42759 3391 3 driver driver NN 42759 3391 4 and and CC 42759 3391 5 the the DT 42759 3391 6 track track NN 42759 3391 7 repairer repairer NN 42759 3391 8 contribute contribute NN 42759 3391 9 to to IN 42759 3391 10 the the DT 42759 3391 11 common common JJ 42759 3391 12 product product NN 42759 3391 13 , , , 42759 3391 14 railway railway NN 42759 3391 15 transportation transportation NN 42759 3391 16 ; ; : 42759 3391 17 the the DT 42759 3391 18 bookkeeper bookkeeper NN 42759 3391 19 and and CC 42759 3391 20 the the DT 42759 3391 21 machine machine NN 42759 3391 22 tender tender NN 42759 3391 23 co co NN 42759 3391 24 - - NN 42759 3391 25 operate operate NN 42759 3391 26 in in IN 42759 3391 27 the the DT 42759 3391 28 production production NN 42759 3391 29 of of IN 42759 3391 30 hats hat NNS 42759 3391 31 ; ; : 42759 3391 32 but but CC 42759 3391 33 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3391 34 can can MD 42759 3391 35 not not RB 42759 3391 36 tell tell VB 42759 3391 37 in in IN 42759 3391 38 either either DT 42759 3391 39 case case NN 42759 3391 40 whether whether IN 42759 3391 41 the the DT 42759 3391 42 first first JJ 42759 3391 43 contributes contribute NNS 42759 3391 44 more more RBR 42759 3391 45 or or CC 42759 3391 46 less less JJR 42759 3391 47 than than IN 42759 3391 48 the the DT 42759 3391 49 second second JJ 42759 3391 50 , , , 42759 3391 51 for for IN 42759 3391 52 the the DT 42759 3391 53 simple simple JJ 42759 3391 54 reason reason NN 42759 3391 55 that that IN 42759 3391 56 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3391 57 have have VBP 42759 3391 58 no no DT 42759 3391 59 common common JJ 42759 3391 60 measure measure NN 42759 3391 61 of of IN 42759 3391 62 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3391 63 contributions contribution NNS 42759 3391 64 . . . 42759 3392 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3392 2 , , , 42759 3392 3 however however RB 42759 3392 4 , , , 42759 3392 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3392 6 can can MD 42759 3392 7 compare compare VB 42759 3392 8 the the DT 42759 3392 9 productivity productivity NN 42759 3392 10 of of IN 42759 3392 11 _ _ NNP 42759 3392 12 individuals individual NNS 42759 3392 13 _ _ NNP 42759 3392 14 engaged engage VBD 42759 3392 15 in in IN 42759 3392 16 different different JJ 42759 3392 17 processes process NNS 42759 3392 18 ; ; : 42759 3392 19 that that RB 42759 3392 20 is is RB 42759 3392 21 , , , 42759 3392 22 when when WRB 42759 3392 23 both both DT 42759 3392 24 can can MD 42759 3392 25 be be VB 42759 3392 26 removed remove VBN 42759 3392 27 from from IN 42759 3392 28 the the DT 42759 3392 29 industry industry NN 42759 3392 30 without without IN 42759 3392 31 causing cause VBG 42759 3392 32 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3392 33 to to TO 42759 3392 34 come come VB 42759 3392 35 to to IN 42759 3392 36 a a DT 42759 3392 37 stop stop NN 42759 3392 38 . . . 42759 3393 1 Thus thus RB 42759 3393 2 , , , 42759 3393 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3393 4 can can MD 42759 3393 5 be be VB 42759 3393 6 shown show VBN 42759 3393 7 that that IN 42759 3393 8 a a DT 42759 3393 9 single single JJ 42759 3393 10 engine engine NN 42759 3393 11 driver driver NN 42759 3393 12 produces produce VBZ 42759 3393 13 more more JJR 42759 3393 14 railway railway NN 42759 3393 15 transportation transportation NN 42759 3393 16 than than IN 42759 3393 17 a a DT 42759 3393 18 single single JJ 42759 3393 19 track track NN 42759 3393 20 repairer repairer NN 42759 3393 21 , , , 42759 3393 22 because because IN 42759 3393 23 the the DT 42759 3393 24 labour labour NN 42759 3393 25 of of IN 42759 3393 26 the the DT 42759 3393 27 latter latter JJ 42759 3393 28 is be VBZ 42759 3393 29 not not RB 42759 3393 30 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 3393 31 to to IN 42759 3393 32 the the DT 42759 3393 33 hauling hauling NN 42759 3393 34 of of IN 42759 3393 35 a a DT 42759 3393 36 given give VBN 42759 3393 37 load load NN 42759 3393 38 of of IN 42759 3393 39 cars car NNS 42759 3393 40 . . . 42759 3394 1 But but CC 42759 3394 2 no no DT 42759 3394 3 such such JJ 42759 3394 4 comparison comparison NN 42759 3394 5 can can MD 42759 3394 6 be be VB 42759 3394 7 made make VBN 42759 3394 8 as as IN 42759 3394 9 between between IN 42759 3394 10 the the DT 42759 3394 11 whole whole JJ 42759 3394 12 body body NN 42759 3394 13 of of IN 42759 3394 14 engine engine NN 42759 3394 15 drivers driver NNS 42759 3394 16 and and CC 42759 3394 17 the the DT 42759 3394 18 whole whole JJ 42759 3394 19 body body NN 42759 3394 20 of of IN 42759 3394 21 track track NN 42759 3394 22 repairers repairer NNS 42759 3394 23 , , , 42759 3394 24 since since IN 42759 3394 25 both both DT 42759 3394 26 groups group NNS 42759 3394 27 are be VBP 42759 3394 28 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 3394 29 to to IN 42759 3394 30 the the DT 42759 3394 31 production production NN 42759 3394 32 of of IN 42759 3394 33 railway railway NN 42759 3394 34 transportation transportation NN 42759 3394 35 . . . 42759 3395 1 Again again RB 42759 3395 2 , , , 42759 3395 3 a a DT 42759 3395 4 man man NN 42759 3395 5 can can MD 42759 3395 6 be be VB 42759 3395 7 shown show VBN 42759 3395 8 to to TO 42759 3395 9 exert exert VB 42759 3395 10 superior superior JJ 42759 3395 11 productivity productivity NN 42759 3395 12 because because IN 42759 3395 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3395 14 affects affect VBZ 42759 3395 15 the the DT 42759 3395 16 productive productive JJ 42759 3395 17 process process NN 42759 3395 18 at at IN 42759 3395 19 more more JJR 42759 3395 20 points point NNS 42759 3395 21 and and CC 42759 3395 22 in in IN 42759 3395 23 a a DT 42759 3395 24 more more RBR 42759 3395 25 intimate intimate JJ 42759 3395 26 way way NN 42759 3395 27 than than IN 42759 3395 28 another another DT 42759 3395 29 who who WP 42759 3395 30 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 3395 31 to to IN 42759 3395 32 the the DT 42759 3395 33 product product NN 42759 3395 34 in in IN 42759 3395 35 a a DT 42759 3395 36 wholly wholly RB 42759 3395 37 different different JJ 42759 3395 38 manner manner NN 42759 3395 39 . . . 42759 3396 1 While while IN 42759 3396 2 the the DT 42759 3396 3 surgeon surgeon NN 42759 3396 4 and and CC 42759 3396 5 the the DT 42759 3396 6 attendant attendant JJ 42759 3396 7 nurse nurse NN 42759 3396 8 are be VBP 42759 3396 9 both both DT 42759 3396 10 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3396 11 to to IN 42759 3396 12 a a DT 42759 3396 13 surgical surgical JJ 42759 3396 14 operation operation NN 42759 3396 15 , , , 42759 3396 16 the the DT 42759 3396 17 former former JJ 42759 3396 18 is be VBZ 42759 3396 19 clearly clearly RB 42759 3396 20 more more RBR 42759 3396 21 productive productive JJ 42759 3396 22 than than IN 42759 3396 23 the the DT 42759 3396 24 latter latter JJ 42759 3396 25 . . . 42759 3397 1 When when WRB 42759 3397 2 due due JJ 42759 3397 3 allowance allowance NN 42759 3397 4 is be VBZ 42759 3397 5 made make VBN 42759 3397 6 for for IN 42759 3397 7 all all DT 42759 3397 8 such such JJ 42759 3397 9 cases case NNS 42759 3397 10 , , , 42759 3397 11 the the DT 42759 3397 12 fact fact NN 42759 3397 13 remains remain VBZ 42759 3397 14 that that IN 42759 3397 15 in in IN 42759 3397 16 a a DT 42759 3397 17 large large JJ 42759 3397 18 part part NN 42759 3397 19 of of IN 42759 3397 20 the the DT 42759 3397 21 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3397 22 field field NN 42759 3397 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3397 24 is be VBZ 42759 3397 25 simply simply RB 42759 3397 26 impossible impossible JJ 42759 3397 27 to to TO 42759 3397 28 determine determine VB 42759 3397 29 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 3397 30 by by IN 42759 3397 31 the the DT 42759 3397 32 rule rule NN 42759 3397 33 of of IN 42759 3397 34 comparative comparative JJ 42759 3397 35 productivity productivity NN 42759 3397 36 . . . 42759 3398 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3398 2 The the DT 42759 3398 3 Canon Canon NNP 42759 3398 4 of of IN 42759 3398 5 Scarcity Scarcity NNP 42759 3398 6 _ _ NNP 42759 3398 7 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3398 8 frequently frequently RB 42759 3398 9 happens happen VBZ 42759 3398 10 that that IN 42759 3398 11 men man NNS 42759 3398 12 attribute attribute VBP 42759 3398 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3398 14 larger large JJR 42759 3398 15 rewards reward NNS 42759 3398 16 to to IN 42759 3398 17 larger large JJR 42759 3398 18 productivity productivity NN 42759 3398 19 , , , 42759 3398 20 when when WRB 42759 3398 21 the the DT 42759 3398 22 true true JJ 42759 3398 23 determining determine VBG 42759 3398 24 element element NN 42759 3398 25 is be VBZ 42759 3398 26 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3398 27 . . . 42759 3399 1 The the DT 42759 3399 2 immediate immediate JJ 42759 3399 3 reason reason NN 42759 3399 4 why why WRB 42759 3399 5 the the DT 42759 3399 6 engine engine NN 42759 3399 7 driver driver NN 42759 3399 8 receives receive VBZ 42759 3399 9 more more JJR 42759 3399 10 than than IN 42759 3399 11 the the DT 42759 3399 12 track track NN 42759 3399 13 repairer repairer NN 42759 3399 14 , , , 42759 3399 15 the the DT 42759 3399 16 general general JJ 42759 3399 17 manager manager NN 42759 3399 18 more more JJR 42759 3399 19 than than IN 42759 3399 20 the the DT 42759 3399 21 section section NN 42759 3399 22 foreman foreman NN 42759 3399 23 , , , 42759 3399 24 the the DT 42759 3399 25 floorwalker floorwalker NN 42759 3399 26 more more RBR 42759 3399 27 than than IN 42759 3399 28 the the DT 42759 3399 29 salesgirl salesgirl NN 42759 3399 30 , , , 42759 3399 31 lies lie VBZ 42759 3399 32 in in IN 42759 3399 33 the the DT 42759 3399 34 fact fact NN 42759 3399 35 that that IN 42759 3399 36 the the DT 42759 3399 37 former former JJ 42759 3399 38 kinds kind NNS 42759 3399 39 of of IN 42759 3399 40 labour labour NN 42759 3399 41 are be VBP 42759 3399 42 not not RB 42759 3399 43 so so RB 42759 3399 44 plentiful plentiful JJ 42759 3399 45 as as IN 42759 3399 46 the the DT 42759 3399 47 latter latter JJ 42759 3399 48 . . . 42759 3400 1 Were be VBD 42759 3400 2 general general JJ 42759 3400 3 managers manager NNS 42759 3400 4 relatively relatively RB 42759 3400 5 as as RB 42759 3400 6 abundant abundant JJ 42759 3400 7 as as IN 42759 3400 8 section section NN 42759 3400 9 foremen foremen VBZ 42759 3400 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3400 11 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 3400 12 would would MD 42759 3400 13 be be VB 42759 3400 14 quite quite RB 42759 3400 15 as as RB 42759 3400 16 low low JJ 42759 3400 17 ; ; : 42759 3400 18 and and CC 42759 3400 19 the the DT 42759 3400 20 same same JJ 42759 3400 21 principle principle NN 42759 3400 22 holds hold VBZ 42759 3400 23 good good RB 42759 3400 24 of of IN 42759 3400 25 every every DT 42759 3400 26 pair pair NN 42759 3400 27 of of IN 42759 3400 28 men man NNS 42759 3400 29 whose whose WP$ 42759 3400 30 occupations occupation NNS 42759 3400 31 and and CC 42759 3400 32 products product NNS 42759 3400 33 are be VBP 42759 3400 34 different different JJ 42759 3400 35 in in IN 42759 3400 36 kind kind NN 42759 3400 37 . . . 42759 3401 1 Yet yet CC 42759 3401 2 the the DT 42759 3401 3 productivity productivity NN 42759 3401 4 of of IN 42759 3401 5 the the DT 42759 3401 6 general general JJ 42759 3401 7 managers manager NNS 42759 3401 8 would would MD 42759 3401 9 remain remain VB 42759 3401 10 as as RB 42759 3401 11 great great JJ 42759 3401 12 as as IN 42759 3401 13 before before RB 42759 3401 14 . . . 42759 3402 1 On on IN 42759 3402 2 the the DT 42759 3402 3 other other JJ 42759 3402 4 hand hand NN 42759 3402 5 , , , 42759 3402 6 no no RB 42759 3402 7 matter matter RB 42759 3402 8 how how WRB 42759 3402 9 plentiful plentiful JJ 42759 3402 10 the the DT 42759 3402 11 more more RBR 42759 3402 12 productive productive JJ 42759 3402 13 men man NNS 42759 3402 14 may may MD 42759 3402 15 become become VB 42759 3402 16 , , , 42759 3402 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3402 18 can can MD 42759 3402 19 always always RB 42759 3402 20 command command VB 42759 3402 21 higher high JJR 42759 3402 22 rewards reward NNS 42759 3402 23 than than IN 42759 3402 24 the the DT 42759 3402 25 less less RBR 42759 3402 26 productive productive JJ 42759 3402 27 men man NNS 42759 3402 28 in in IN 42759 3402 29 the the DT 42759 3402 30 same same JJ 42759 3402 31 occupation occupation NN 42759 3402 32 , , , 42759 3402 33 for for IN 42759 3402 34 the the DT 42759 3402 35 simple simple JJ 42759 3402 36 reason reason NN 42759 3402 37 that that IN 42759 3402 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3402 39 products product NNS 42759 3402 40 are be VBP 42759 3402 41 superior superior JJ 42759 3402 42 either either CC 42759 3402 43 in in IN 42759 3402 44 quantity quantity NN 42759 3402 45 or or CC 42759 3402 46 in in IN 42759 3402 47 quality quality NN 42759 3402 48 . . . 42759 3403 1 Men man NNS 42759 3403 2 engaged engage VBD 42759 3403 3 upon upon IN 42759 3403 4 the the DT 42759 3403 5 more more RBR 42759 3403 6 skilled skilled JJ 42759 3403 7 tasks task NNS 42759 3403 8 are be VBP 42759 3403 9 likewise likewise RB 42759 3403 10 mistaken mistaken JJ 42759 3403 11 when when WRB 42759 3403 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3403 13 attribute attribute VBP 42759 3403 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3403 15 greater great JJR 42759 3403 16 compensation compensation NN 42759 3403 17 to to IN 42759 3403 18 the the DT 42759 3403 19 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 3403 20 excellence excellence NN 42759 3403 21 of of IN 42759 3403 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3403 23 occupation occupation NN 42759 3403 24 . . . 42759 3404 1 The the DT 42759 3404 2 fact fact NN 42759 3404 3 is be VBZ 42759 3404 4 that that IN 42759 3404 5 the the DT 42759 3404 6 community community NN 42759 3404 7 cares care VBZ 42759 3404 8 nothing nothing NN 42759 3404 9 about about IN 42759 3404 10 the the DT 42759 3404 11 relative relative JJ 42759 3404 12 nobility nobility NN 42759 3404 13 , , , 42759 3404 14 or or CC 42759 3404 15 ingenuity ingenuity NN 42759 3404 16 , , , 42759 3404 17 or or CC 42759 3404 18 other other JJ 42759 3404 19 inherent inherent JJ 42759 3404 20 quality quality NN 42759 3404 21 of of IN 42759 3404 22 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3404 23 tasks task NNS 42759 3404 24 or or CC 42759 3404 25 functions function NNS 42759 3404 26 . . . 42759 3405 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3405 2 is be VBZ 42759 3405 3 concerned concern VBN 42759 3405 4 solely solely RB 42759 3405 5 with with IN 42759 3405 6 products product NNS 42759 3405 7 and and CC 42759 3405 8 results result NNS 42759 3405 9 . . . 42759 3406 1 As as IN 42759 3406 2 between between IN 42759 3406 3 two two CD 42759 3406 4 men man NNS 42759 3406 5 performing perform VBG 42759 3406 6 the the DT 42759 3406 7 same same JJ 42759 3406 8 task task NN 42759 3406 9 , , , 42759 3406 10 superior superior JJ 42759 3406 11 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3406 12 receives receive VBZ 42759 3406 13 a a DT 42759 3406 14 superior superior JJ 42759 3406 15 reward reward NN 42759 3406 16 because because IN 42759 3406 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3406 18 issues issue VBZ 42759 3406 19 in in IN 42759 3406 20 a a DT 42759 3406 21 larger large JJR 42759 3406 22 or or CC 42759 3406 23 better well JJR 42759 3406 24 product product NN 42759 3406 25 . . . 42759 3407 1 As as IN 42759 3407 2 between between IN 42759 3407 3 two two CD 42759 3407 4 men man NNS 42759 3407 5 performing perform VBG 42759 3407 6 different different JJ 42759 3407 7 tasks task NNS 42759 3407 8 , , , 42759 3407 9 superior superior JJ 42759 3407 10 skill skill NN 42759 3407 11 receives receive VBZ 42759 3407 12 superior superior JJ 42759 3407 13 compensation compensation NN 42759 3407 14 simply simply RB 42759 3407 15 because because IN 42759 3407 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3407 17 can can MD 42759 3407 18 command command VB 42759 3407 19 the the DT 42759 3407 20 greater great JJR 42759 3407 21 compensation compensation NN 42759 3407 22 ; ; , 42759 3407 23 and and CC 42759 3407 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3407 25 is be VBZ 42759 3407 26 able able JJ 42759 3407 27 to to TO 42759 3407 28 do do VB 42759 3407 29 this this DT 42759 3407 30 because because IN 42759 3407 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3407 32 is be VBZ 42759 3407 33 scarce scarce JJ 42759 3407 34 . . . 42759 3408 1 In in IN 42759 3408 2 most most JJS 42759 3408 3 cases case NNS 42759 3408 4 where where WRB 42759 3408 5 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3408 6 is be VBZ 42759 3408 7 the the DT 42759 3408 8 immediate immediate JJ 42759 3408 9 determinant determinant NN 42759 3408 10 of of IN 42759 3408 11 rewards reward NNS 42759 3408 12 , , , 42759 3408 13 the the DT 42759 3408 14 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 3408 15 determinant determinant NN 42759 3408 16 is be VBZ 42759 3408 17 , , , 42759 3408 18 partly partly RB 42759 3408 19 at at IN 42759 3408 20 least least JJS 42759 3408 21 , , , 42759 3408 22 some some DT 42759 3408 23 kind kind NN 42759 3408 24 of of IN 42759 3408 25 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 3408 26 . . . 42759 3409 1 One one CD 42759 3409 2 reason reason NN 42759 3409 3 why why WRB 42759 3409 4 chemists chemist NNS 42759 3409 5 and and CC 42759 3409 6 civil civil JJ 42759 3409 7 engineers engineer NNS 42759 3409 8 are be VBP 42759 3409 9 rarer rare JJR 42759 3409 10 than than IN 42759 3409 11 common common JJ 42759 3409 12 labourers labourer NNS 42759 3409 13 is be VBZ 42759 3409 14 to to TO 42759 3409 15 be be VB 42759 3409 16 found find VBN 42759 3409 17 in in IN 42759 3409 18 the the DT 42759 3409 19 greater great JJR 42759 3409 20 cost cost NN 42759 3409 21 of of IN 42759 3409 22 preparation preparation NN 42759 3409 23 . . . 42759 3410 1 The the DT 42759 3410 2 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3410 3 of of IN 42759 3410 4 workers worker NNS 42759 3410 5 in in IN 42759 3410 6 occupations occupation NNS 42759 3410 7 that that WDT 42759 3410 8 require require VBP 42759 3410 9 no no DT 42759 3410 10 special special JJ 42759 3410 11 degree degree NN 42759 3410 12 of of IN 42759 3410 13 skill skill NN 42759 3410 14 is be VBZ 42759 3410 15 due due JJ 42759 3410 16 to to IN 42759 3410 17 unusual unusual JJ 42759 3410 18 hazards hazard NNS 42759 3410 19 and and CC 42759 3410 20 unpleasantness unpleasantness NN 42759 3410 21 . . . 42759 3411 1 In in IN 42759 3411 2 so so RB 42759 3411 3 far far RB 42759 3411 4 as as IN 42759 3411 5 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3411 6 is be VBZ 42759 3411 7 caused cause VBN 42759 3411 8 by by IN 42759 3411 9 the the DT 42759 3411 10 uncommon uncommon JJ 42759 3411 11 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3411 12 preceding precede VBG 42759 3411 13 or or CC 42759 3411 14 involved involve VBN 42759 3411 15 in in IN 42759 3411 16 an an DT 42759 3411 17 occupation occupation NN 42759 3411 18 , , , 42759 3411 19 the the DT 42759 3411 20 resulting result VBG 42759 3411 21 higher high JJR 42759 3411 22 rewards reward NNS 42759 3411 23 obviously obviously RB 42759 3411 24 rest rest VBP 42759 3411 25 upon upon IN 42759 3411 26 most most JJS 42759 3411 27 solid solid JJ 42759 3411 28 ethical ethical JJ 42759 3411 29 grounds ground NNS 42759 3411 30 . . . 42759 3412 1 However however RB 42759 3412 2 , , , 42759 3412 3 some some DT 42759 3412 4 part part NN 42759 3412 5 of of IN 42759 3412 6 the the DT 42759 3412 7 differences difference NNS 42759 3412 8 in in IN 42759 3412 9 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3412 10 is be VBZ 42759 3412 11 the the DT 42759 3412 12 result result NN 42759 3412 13 of of IN 42759 3412 14 unequal unequal JJ 42759 3412 15 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 3412 16 . . . 42759 3413 1 If if IN 42759 3413 2 all all DT 42759 3413 3 young young JJ 42759 3413 4 persons person NNS 42759 3413 5 had have VBD 42759 3413 6 equal equal JJ 42759 3413 7 facilities facility NNS 42759 3413 8 of of IN 42759 3413 9 obtaining obtain VBG 42759 3413 10 college college NN 42759 3413 11 and and CC 42759 3413 12 technical technical JJ 42759 3413 13 training training NN 42759 3413 14 , , , 42759 3413 15 the the DT 42759 3413 16 supply supply NN 42759 3413 17 of of IN 42759 3413 18 the the DT 42759 3413 19 higher high JJR 42759 3413 20 kinds kind NNS 42759 3413 21 of of IN 42759 3413 22 labour labour NN 42759 3413 23 would would MD 42759 3413 24 be be VB 42759 3413 25 considerably considerably RB 42759 3413 26 larger large JJR 42759 3413 27 than than IN 42759 3413 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3413 29 now now RB 42759 3413 30 is be VBZ 42759 3413 31 , , , 42759 3413 32 and and CC 42759 3413 33 the the DT 42759 3413 34 compensation compensation NN 42759 3413 35 would would MD 42759 3413 36 be be VB 42759 3413 37 considerably considerably RB 42759 3413 38 smaller small JJR 42759 3413 39 . . . 42759 3414 1 Scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3414 2 would would MD 42759 3414 3 then then RB 42759 3414 4 be be VB 42759 3414 5 determined determine VBN 42759 3414 6 by by IN 42759 3414 7 only only RB 42759 3414 8 three three CD 42759 3414 9 factors factor NNS 42759 3414 10 ; ; : 42759 3414 11 namely namely RB 42759 3414 12 , , , 42759 3414 13 varying vary VBG 42759 3414 14 costs cost NNS 42759 3414 15 of of IN 42759 3414 16 training training NN 42759 3414 17 , , , 42759 3414 18 varying vary VBG 42759 3414 19 degrees degree NNS 42759 3414 20 of of IN 42759 3414 21 danger danger NN 42759 3414 22 and and CC 42759 3414 23 unattractiveness unattractiveness NN 42759 3414 24 among among IN 42759 3414 25 occupations occupation NNS 42759 3414 26 , , , 42759 3414 27 and and CC 42759 3414 28 inequalities inequality NNS 42759 3414 29 in in IN 42759 3414 30 the the DT 42759 3414 31 distribution distribution NN 42759 3414 32 of of IN 42759 3414 33 native native JJ 42759 3414 34 ability ability NN 42759 3414 35 . . . 42759 3415 1 As as IN 42759 3415 2 a a DT 42759 3415 3 consequence consequence NN 42759 3415 4 , , , 42759 3415 5 competition competition NN 42759 3415 6 would would MD 42759 3415 7 tend tend VB 42759 3415 8 to to IN 42759 3415 9 apportion apportion NN 42759 3415 10 rewards reward NNS 42759 3415 11 according accord VBG 42759 3415 12 to to IN 42759 3415 13 efforts effort NNS 42759 3415 14 , , , 42759 3415 15 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3415 16 , , , 42759 3415 17 and and CC 42759 3415 18 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3415 19 . . . 42759 3416 1 How how WRB 42759 3416 2 can can MD 42759 3416 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3416 4 justify justify VB 42759 3416 5 the the DT 42759 3416 6 superior superior JJ 42759 3416 7 rewards reward NNS 42759 3416 8 of of IN 42759 3416 9 that that DT 42759 3416 10 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3416 11 which which WDT 42759 3416 12 is be VBZ 42759 3416 13 not not RB 42759 3416 14 due due JJ 42759 3416 15 to to IN 42759 3416 16 unusual unusual JJ 42759 3416 17 costs cost NNS 42759 3416 18 of of IN 42759 3416 19 any any DT 42759 3416 20 sort sort NN 42759 3416 21 , , , 42759 3416 22 but but CC 42759 3416 23 merely merely RB 42759 3416 24 to to IN 42759 3416 25 restricted restrict VBN 42759 3416 26 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 3416 27 ? ? . 42759 3417 1 So so RB 42759 3417 2 far far RB 42759 3417 3 as as IN 42759 3417 4 society society NN 42759 3417 5 is be VBZ 42759 3417 6 concerned concern VBN 42759 3417 7 , , , 42759 3417 8 the the DT 42759 3417 9 answer answer NN 42759 3417 10 is be VBZ 42759 3417 11 simple simple JJ 42759 3417 12 : : : 42759 3417 13 the the DT 42759 3417 14 practice practice NN 42759 3417 15 pays pay VBZ 42759 3417 16 . . . 42759 3418 1 As as IN 42759 3418 2 to to IN 42759 3418 3 the the DT 42759 3418 4 possessors possessor NNS 42759 3418 5 of of IN 42759 3418 6 the the DT 42759 3418 7 rarer rare JJR 42759 3418 8 kinds kind NNS 42759 3418 9 of of IN 42759 3418 10 ability ability NN 42759 3418 11 , , , 42759 3418 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3418 13 are be VBP 42759 3418 14 in in IN 42759 3418 15 about about RB 42759 3418 16 the the DT 42759 3418 17 same same JJ 42759 3418 18 ethical ethical JJ 42759 3418 19 position position NN 42759 3418 20 as as IN 42759 3418 21 those those DT 42759 3418 22 persons person NNS 42759 3418 23 whose whose WP$ 42759 3418 24 superior superior JJ 42759 3418 25 productivity productivity NN 42759 3418 26 is be VBZ 42759 3418 27 derived derive VBN 42759 3418 28 entirely entirely RB 42759 3418 29 from from IN 42759 3418 30 superior superior NNP 42759 3418 31 native native NNP 42759 3418 32 endowment endowment NNP 42759 3418 33 . . . 42759 3419 1 In in IN 42759 3419 2 both both DT 42759 3419 3 cases case NNS 42759 3419 4 the the DT 42759 3419 5 unusual unusual JJ 42759 3419 6 rewards reward NNS 42759 3419 7 are be VBP 42759 3419 8 due due JJ 42759 3419 9 to to IN 42759 3419 10 factors factor NNS 42759 3419 11 outside outside IN 42759 3419 12 the the DT 42759 3419 13 control control NN 42759 3419 14 of of IN 42759 3419 15 the the DT 42759 3419 16 recipients recipient NNS 42759 3419 17 ; ; : 42759 3419 18 to to IN 42759 3419 19 advantages advantage NNS 42759 3419 20 which which WDT 42759 3419 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3419 22 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 3419 23 have have VBP 42759 3419 24 not not RB 42759 3419 25 brought bring VBN 42759 3419 26 into into IN 42759 3419 27 existence existence NN 42759 3419 28 . . . 42759 3420 1 In in IN 42759 3420 2 the the DT 42759 3420 3 former former JJ 42759 3420 4 case case NN 42759 3420 5 the the DT 42759 3420 6 decisive decisive JJ 42759 3420 7 factor factor NN 42759 3420 8 and and CC 42759 3420 9 advantage advantage NN 42759 3420 10 is be VBZ 42759 3420 11 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 3420 12 ; ; : 42759 3420 13 in in IN 42759 3420 14 the the DT 42759 3420 15 latter latter JJ 42759 3420 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3420 17 is be VBZ 42759 3420 18 a a DT 42759 3420 19 gift gift NN 42759 3420 20 of of IN 42759 3420 21 the the DT 42759 3420 22 Creator Creator NNP 42759 3420 23 . . . 42759 3421 1 Now now RB 42759 3421 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3421 3 have have VBP 42759 3421 4 seen see VBN 42759 3421 5 that that IN 42759 3421 6 this this DT 42759 3421 7 sort sort NN 42759 3421 8 of of IN 42759 3421 9 productivity productivity NN 42759 3421 10 can can MD 42759 3421 11 not not RB 42759 3421 12 be be VB 42759 3421 13 proved prove VBN 42759 3421 14 to to TO 42759 3421 15 be be VB 42759 3421 16 immoral immoral JJ 42759 3421 17 as as IN 42759 3421 18 a a DT 42759 3421 19 canon canon NN 42759 3421 20 of of IN 42759 3421 21 distribution distribution NN 42759 3421 22 ; ; : 42759 3421 23 consequently consequently RB 42759 3421 24 the the DT 42759 3421 25 same same JJ 42759 3421 26 statement statement NN 42759 3421 27 will will MD 42759 3421 28 hold hold VB 42759 3421 29 good good JJ 42759 3421 30 of of IN 42759 3421 31 this this DT 42759 3421 32 sort sort NN 42759 3421 33 of of IN 42759 3421 34 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3421 35 . . . 42759 3422 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3422 2 The the DT 42759 3422 3 Canon Canon NNP 42759 3422 4 of of IN 42759 3422 5 Human Human NNP 42759 3422 6 Welfare Welfare NNP 42759 3422 7 _ _ NNP 42759 3422 8 We -PRON- PRP 42759 3422 9 say say VBP 42759 3422 10 " " `` 42759 3422 11 human human JJ 42759 3422 12 " " '' 42759 3422 13 welfare welfare NN 42759 3422 14 rather rather RB 42759 3422 15 than than IN 42759 3422 16 " " `` 42759 3422 17 social social JJ 42759 3422 18 " " '' 42759 3422 19 welfare welfare NN 42759 3422 20 , , , 42759 3422 21 in in IN 42759 3422 22 order order NN 42759 3422 23 to to TO 42759 3422 24 make make VB 42759 3422 25 clear clear JJ 42759 3422 26 the the DT 42759 3422 27 fact fact NN 42759 3422 28 that that IN 42759 3422 29 this this DT 42759 3422 30 canon canon NN 42759 3422 31 considers consider VBZ 42759 3422 32 the the DT 42759 3422 33 well well JJ 42759 3422 34 being being NN 42759 3422 35 of of IN 42759 3422 36 men man NNS 42759 3422 37 not not RB 42759 3422 38 only only RB 42759 3422 39 as as IN 42759 3422 40 a a DT 42759 3422 41 social social JJ 42759 3422 42 group group NN 42759 3422 43 , , , 42759 3422 44 but but CC 42759 3422 45 also also RB 42759 3422 46 as as IN 42759 3422 47 individuals individual NNS 42759 3422 48 . . . 42759 3423 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3423 2 includes include VBZ 42759 3423 3 and and CC 42759 3423 4 summarises summarise VBZ 42759 3423 5 all all DT 42759 3423 6 that that WDT 42759 3423 7 is be VBZ 42759 3423 8 ethically ethically RB 42759 3423 9 and and CC 42759 3423 10 socially socially RB 42759 3423 11 feasible feasible JJ 42759 3423 12 in in IN 42759 3423 13 the the DT 42759 3423 14 five five CD 42759 3423 15 canons canon NNS 42759 3423 16 already already RB 42759 3423 17 reviewed review VBN 42759 3423 18 . . . 42759 3424 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3424 2 takes take VBZ 42759 3424 3 account account NN 42759 3424 4 of of IN 42759 3424 5 equality equality NN 42759 3424 6 , , , 42759 3424 7 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 3424 8 as as IN 42759 3424 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3424 10 regards regard VBZ 42759 3424 11 all all DT 42759 3424 12 men man NNS 42759 3424 13 as as IN 42759 3424 14 persons person NNS 42759 3424 15 , , , 42759 3424 16 as as IN 42759 3424 17 subjects subject NNS 42759 3424 18 of of IN 42759 3424 19 rights right NNS 42759 3424 20 ; ; : 42759 3424 21 and and CC 42759 3424 22 of of IN 42759 3424 23 needs need NNS 42759 3424 24 , , , 42759 3424 25 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 3424 26 as as IN 42759 3424 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3424 28 awards award VBZ 42759 3424 29 to to IN 42759 3424 30 all all PDT 42759 3424 31 the the DT 42759 3424 32 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3424 33 participants participant NNS 42759 3424 34 in in IN 42759 3424 35 the the DT 42759 3424 36 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3424 37 system system NN 42759 3424 38 at at IN 42759 3424 39 least least JJS 42759 3424 40 that that DT 42759 3424 41 amount amount NN 42759 3424 42 of of IN 42759 3424 43 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 3424 44 which which WDT 42759 3424 45 will will MD 42759 3424 46 meet meet VB 42759 3424 47 the the DT 42759 3424 48 elementary elementary JJ 42759 3424 49 demands demand NNS 42759 3424 50 of of IN 42759 3424 51 decent decent JJ 42759 3424 52 living living NN 42759 3424 53 and and CC 42759 3424 54 self self NN 42759 3424 55 development development NN 42759 3424 56 . . . 42759 3425 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3425 2 is be VBZ 42759 3425 3 governed govern VBN 42759 3425 4 by by IN 42759 3425 5 efforts effort NNS 42759 3425 6 and and CC 42759 3425 7 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3425 8 , , , 42759 3425 9 at at IN 42759 3425 10 least least JJS 42759 3425 11 in in RB 42759 3425 12 so so RB 42759 3425 13 far far RB 42759 3425 14 as as IN 42759 3425 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3425 16 are be VBP 42759 3425 17 reflected reflect VBN 42759 3425 18 in in IN 42759 3425 19 productivity productivity NN 42759 3425 20 and and CC 42759 3425 21 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3425 22 ; ; , 42759 3425 23 and and CC 42759 3425 24 by by IN 42759 3425 25 productivity productivity NN 42759 3425 26 and and CC 42759 3425 27 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3425 28 to to IN 42759 3425 29 whatever whatever WDT 42759 3425 30 extent extent NN 42759 3425 31 is be VBZ 42759 3425 32 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3425 33 in in IN 42759 3425 34 order order NN 42759 3425 35 to to TO 42759 3425 36 produce produce VB 42759 3425 37 the the DT 42759 3425 38 maximum maximum JJ 42759 3425 39 net net JJ 42759 3425 40 results result NNS 42759 3425 41 . . . 42759 3426 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3426 2 would would MD 42759 3426 3 give give VB 42759 3426 4 to to IN 42759 3426 5 every every DT 42759 3426 6 producer producer NN 42759 3426 7 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3426 8 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 3426 9 to to TO 42759 3426 10 evoke evoke VB 42759 3426 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3426 12 greatest great JJS 42759 3426 13 net net JJ 42759 3426 14 contribution contribution NN 42759 3426 15 to to IN 42759 3426 16 the the DT 42759 3426 17 productive productive JJ 42759 3426 18 process process NN 42759 3426 19 . . . 42759 3427 1 Greatest great JJS 42759 3427 2 " " `` 42759 3427 3 net net JJ 42759 3427 4 " " '' 42759 3427 5 contribution contribution NN 42759 3427 6 ; ; , 42759 3427 7 for for IN 42759 3427 8 a a DT 42759 3427 9 man man NN 42759 3427 10 's 's POS 42759 3427 11 _ _ NNP 42759 3427 12 absolute absolute JJ 42759 3427 13 _ _ NNP 42759 3427 14 maximum maximum JJ 42759 3427 15 product product NN 42759 3427 16 may may MD 42759 3427 17 not not RB 42759 3427 18 always always RB 42759 3427 19 be be VB 42759 3427 20 worth worth JJ 42759 3427 21 the the DT 42759 3427 22 required require VBN 42759 3427 23 price price NN 42759 3427 24 . . . 42759 3428 1 For for IN 42759 3428 2 example example NN 42759 3428 3 : : : 42759 3428 4 a a DT 42759 3428 5 man man NN 42759 3428 6 who who WP 42759 3428 7 for for IN 42759 3428 8 a a DT 42759 3428 9 salary salary NN 42759 3428 10 of of IN 42759 3428 11 2500 2500 CD 42759 3428 12 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3428 13 turns turn VBZ 42759 3428 14 out out RP 42759 3428 15 a a DT 42759 3428 16 product product NN 42759 3428 17 valued value VBN 42759 3428 18 at at IN 42759 3428 19 3000 3000 CD 42759 3428 20 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3428 21 , , , 42759 3428 22 should should MD 42759 3428 23 not not RB 42759 3428 24 be be VB 42759 3428 25 given give VBN 42759 3428 26 3000 3000 CD 42759 3428 27 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3428 28 in in IN 42759 3428 29 order order NN 42759 3428 30 to to TO 42759 3428 31 induce induce VB 42759 3428 32 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3428 33 to to TO 42759 3428 34 bring bring VB 42759 3428 35 forth forth RB 42759 3428 36 a a DT 42759 3428 37 product product NN 42759 3428 38 worth worth JJ 42759 3428 39 3300 3300 CD 42759 3428 40 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3428 41 . . . 42759 3429 1 In in IN 42759 3429 2 this this DT 42759 3429 3 case case NN 42759 3429 4 a a DT 42759 3429 5 salary salary NN 42759 3429 6 of of IN 42759 3429 7 2500 2500 CD 42759 3429 8 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3429 9 evokes evoke VBZ 42759 3429 10 the the DT 42759 3429 11 maximum maximum JJ 42759 3429 12 net net JJ 42759 3429 13 product product NN 42759 3429 14 , , , 42759 3429 15 and and CC 42759 3429 16 represents represent VBZ 42759 3429 17 the the DT 42759 3429 18 reward reward NN 42759 3429 19 which which WDT 42759 3429 20 would would MD 42759 3429 21 be be VB 42759 3429 22 assigned assign VBN 42759 3429 23 by by IN 42759 3429 24 the the DT 42759 3429 25 canon canon NN 42759 3429 26 of of IN 42759 3429 27 human human JJ 42759 3429 28 welfare welfare NN 42759 3429 29 . . . 42759 3430 1 Once once IN 42759 3430 2 the the DT 42759 3430 3 vital vital JJ 42759 3430 4 needs need NNS 42759 3430 5 of of IN 42759 3430 6 the the DT 42759 3430 7 individual individual NN 42759 3430 8 have have VBP 42759 3430 9 been be VBN 42759 3430 10 safeguarded safeguard VBN 42759 3430 11 , , , 42759 3430 12 the the DT 42759 3430 13 supreme supreme NNP 42759 3430 14 guide guide NNP 42759 3430 15 of of IN 42759 3430 16 the the DT 42759 3430 17 canon canon NN 42759 3430 18 of of IN 42759 3430 19 human human JJ 42759 3430 20 welfare welfare NN 42759 3430 21 is be VBZ 42759 3430 22 the the DT 42759 3430 23 principle principle NN 42759 3430 24 of of IN 42759 3430 25 maximum maximum JJ 42759 3430 26 net net JJ 42759 3430 27 results result NNS 42759 3430 28 , , , 42759 3430 29 or or CC 42759 3430 30 the the DT 42759 3430 31 greatest great JJS 42759 3430 32 product product NN 42759 3430 33 at at IN 42759 3430 34 the the DT 42759 3430 35 lowest low JJS 42759 3430 36 cost cost NN 42759 3430 37 . . . 42759 3431 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3431 2 is be VBZ 42759 3431 3 not not RB 42759 3431 4 contended contend VBN 42759 3431 5 here here RB 42759 3431 6 that that IN 42759 3431 7 this this DT 42759 3431 8 canon canon NN 42759 3431 9 ought ought MD 42759 3431 10 never never RB 42759 3431 11 to to TO 42759 3431 12 undergo undergo VB 42759 3431 13 modification modification NN 42759 3431 14 or or CC 42759 3431 15 exception exception NN 42759 3431 16 . . . 42759 3432 1 Owing owe VBG 42759 3432 2 to to IN 42759 3432 3 the the DT 42759 3432 4 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 3432 5 hazards hazard NNS 42759 3432 6 and and CC 42759 3432 7 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3432 8 of of IN 42759 3432 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3432 10 occupation occupation NN 42759 3432 11 , , , 42759 3432 12 a a DT 42759 3432 13 combination combination NN 42759 3432 14 of of IN 42759 3432 15 producers producer NNS 42759 3432 16 might may MD 42759 3432 17 be be VB 42759 3432 18 justified justify VBN 42759 3432 19 in in IN 42759 3432 20 exacting exact VBG 42759 3432 21 larger large JJR 42759 3432 22 compensation compensation NN 42759 3432 23 than than IN 42759 3432 24 would would MD 42759 3432 25 be be VB 42759 3432 26 accorded accord VBN 42759 3432 27 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3432 28 by by IN 42759 3432 29 the the DT 42759 3432 30 canon canon NN 42759 3432 31 of of IN 42759 3432 32 human human JJ 42759 3432 33 welfare welfare NN 42759 3432 34 on on IN 42759 3432 35 the the DT 42759 3432 36 basis basis NN 42759 3432 37 of of IN 42759 3432 38 net net JJ 42759 3432 39 results result NNS 42759 3432 40 in in IN 42759 3432 41 the the DT 42759 3432 42 present present JJ 42759 3432 43 conditions condition NNS 42759 3432 44 of of IN 42759 3432 45 supply supply NN 42759 3432 46 and and CC 42759 3432 47 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3432 48 . . . 42759 3433 1 Unusual unusual JJ 42759 3433 2 needs need NNS 42759 3433 3 and and CC 42759 3433 4 capacities capacity NNS 42759 3433 5 might may MD 42759 3433 6 also also RB 42759 3433 7 justify justify VB 42759 3433 8 a a DT 42759 3433 9 strong strong JJ 42759 3433 10 group group NN 42759 3433 11 in in IN 42759 3433 12 pursuing pursue VBG 42759 3433 13 the the DT 42759 3433 14 same same JJ 42759 3433 15 course course NN 42759 3433 16 . . . 42759 3434 1 All all DT 42759 3434 2 that that WDT 42759 3434 3 is be VBZ 42759 3434 4 asserted assert VBN 42759 3434 5 at at IN 42759 3434 6 present present JJ 42759 3434 7 is be VBZ 42759 3434 8 that that IN 42759 3434 9 in in IN 42759 3434 10 conditions condition NNS 42759 3434 11 of of IN 42759 3434 12 average average JJ 42759 3434 13 competition competition NN 42759 3434 14 the the DT 42759 3434 15 canon canon NN 42759 3434 16 of of IN 42759 3434 17 human human JJ 42759 3434 18 welfare welfare NN 42759 3434 19 is be VBZ 42759 3434 20 not not RB 42759 3434 21 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3434 22 . . . 42759 3435 1 And and CC 42759 3435 2 this this DT 42759 3435 3 is be VBZ 42759 3435 4 all all DT 42759 3435 5 that that WDT 42759 3435 6 is be VBZ 42759 3435 7 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3435 8 as as IN 42759 3435 9 a a DT 42759 3435 10 preliminary preliminary NN 42759 3435 11 to to IN 42759 3435 12 the the DT 42759 3435 13 discussion discussion NN 42759 3435 14 of of IN 42759 3435 15 just just JJ 42759 3435 16 profits profit NNS 42759 3435 17 . . . 42759 3436 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3436 2 162 162 CD 42759 3436 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3436 4 FOOTNOTE FOOTNOTE NNP 42759 3436 5 : : : 42759 3436 6 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3436 7 162 162 CD 42759 3436 8 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3436 9 A a DT 42759 3436 10 very very RB 42759 3436 11 suggestive suggestive JJ 42759 3436 12 discussion discussion NN 42759 3436 13 of of IN 42759 3436 14 the the DT 42759 3436 15 psychology psychology NN 42759 3436 16 , , , 42759 3436 17 the the DT 42759 3436 18 general general JJ 42759 3436 19 principles principle NNS 42759 3436 20 , , , 42759 3436 21 and and CC 42759 3436 22 the the DT 42759 3436 23 practical practical JJ 42759 3436 24 limitations limitation NNS 42759 3436 25 of of IN 42759 3436 26 distributive distributive JJ 42759 3436 27 justice justice NN 42759 3436 28 , , , 42759 3436 29 will will MD 42759 3436 30 be be VB 42759 3436 31 found find VBN 42759 3436 32 in in IN 42759 3436 33 an an DT 42759 3436 34 article article NN 42759 3436 35 by by IN 42759 3436 36 Gustav Gustav NNP 42759 3436 37 Schmoller Schmoller NNP 42759 3436 38 , , , 42759 3436 39 entitled entitle VBN 42759 3436 40 , , , 42759 3436 41 " " `` 42759 3436 42 The the DT 42759 3436 43 Idea Idea NNP 42759 3436 44 of of IN 42759 3436 45 Justice Justice NNP 42759 3436 46 in in IN 42759 3436 47 Political Political NNP 42759 3436 48 Economy Economy NNP 42759 3436 49 . . . 42759 3436 50 " " '' 42759 3437 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3437 2 is be VBZ 42759 3437 3 No no UH 42759 3437 4 . . . 42759 3438 1 113 113 CD 42759 3438 2 in in IN 42759 3438 3 the the DT 42759 3438 4 Publications Publications NNPS 42759 3438 5 of of IN 42759 3438 6 the the DT 42759 3438 7 American American NNP 42759 3438 8 Academy Academy NNP 42759 3438 9 of of IN 42759 3438 10 Political Political NNP 42759 3438 11 and and CC 42759 3438 12 Social Social NNP 42759 3438 13 Science Science NNP 42759 3438 14 . . . 42759 3439 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 42759 3439 2 XVII XVII NNP 42759 3439 3 JUST just RB 42759 3439 4 PROFITS profit VBZ 42759 3439 5 IN in IN 42759 3439 6 CONDITIONS conditions NN 42759 3439 7 OF of IN 42759 3439 8 COMPETITION competition NN 42759 3439 9 We -PRON- PRP 42759 3439 10 have have VBP 42759 3439 11 seen see VBN 42759 3439 12 that that IN 42759 3439 13 profits profit NNS 42759 3439 14 are be VBP 42759 3439 15 that that IN 42759 3439 16 share share NN 42759 3439 17 of of IN 42759 3439 18 the the DT 42759 3439 19 product product NN 42759 3439 20 of of IN 42759 3439 21 industry industry NN 42759 3439 22 which which WDT 42759 3439 23 goes go VBZ 42759 3439 24 to to IN 42759 3439 25 the the DT 42759 3439 26 business business NN 42759 3439 27 man man NN 42759 3439 28 . . . 42759 3440 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3440 2 comprise comprise VBP 42759 3440 3 that that DT 42759 3440 4 residual residual JJ 42759 3440 5 portion portion NN 42759 3440 6 which which WDT 42759 3440 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3440 8 finds find VBZ 42759 3440 9 in in IN 42759 3440 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3440 11 hands hand NNS 42759 3440 12 after after IN 42759 3440 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3440 14 has have VBZ 42759 3440 15 made make VBN 42759 3440 16 all all DT 42759 3440 17 expenditures expenditure NNS 42759 3440 18 and and CC 42759 3440 19 allowances allowance NNS 42759 3440 20 for for IN 42759 3440 21 wages wage NNS 42759 3440 22 , , , 42759 3440 23 salaries salary NNS 42759 3440 24 , , , 42759 3440 25 interest interest NN 42759 3440 26 at at IN 42759 3440 27 the the DT 42759 3440 28 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 3440 29 rate rate NN 42759 3440 30 on on IN 42759 3440 31 both both CC 42759 3440 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3440 33 own own JJ 42759 3440 34 and and CC 42759 3440 35 the the DT 42759 3440 36 borrowed borrow VBN 42759 3440 37 capital capital NN 42759 3440 38 , , , 42759 3440 39 and and CC 42759 3440 40 all all DT 42759 3440 41 other other JJ 42759 3440 42 proper proper JJ 42759 3440 43 charges charge NNS 42759 3440 44 . . . 42759 3441 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3441 2 constitute constitute VBP 42759 3441 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3441 4 compensation compensation NN 42759 3441 5 for for IN 42759 3441 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3441 7 labour labour NN 42759 3441 8 of of IN 42759 3441 9 direction direction NN 42759 3441 10 , , , 42759 3441 11 and and CC 42759 3441 12 for for IN 42759 3441 13 the the DT 42759 3441 14 risks risk NNS 42759 3441 15 of of IN 42759 3441 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3441 17 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3441 18 and and CC 42759 3441 19 capital capital NN 42759 3441 20 . . . 42759 3442 1 In in IN 42759 3442 2 the the DT 42759 3442 3 opinion opinion NN 42759 3442 4 of of IN 42759 3442 5 most most JJS 42759 3442 6 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 3442 7 , , , 42759 3442 8 profits profit NNS 42759 3442 9 are be VBP 42759 3442 10 immoral immoral JJ 42759 3442 11 because because IN 42759 3442 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3442 13 are be VBP 42759 3442 14 an an DT 42759 3442 15 essential essential JJ 42759 3442 16 element element NN 42759 3442 17 of of IN 42759 3442 18 an an DT 42759 3442 19 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3442 20 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3442 21 system system NN 42759 3442 22 , , , 42759 3442 23 and and CC 42759 3442 24 because because IN 42759 3442 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3442 26 are be VBP 42759 3442 27 not not RB 42759 3442 28 entirely entirely RB 42759 3442 29 based base VBN 42759 3442 30 upon upon IN 42759 3442 31 labour labour NN 42759 3442 32 . . . 42759 3443 1 Under under IN 42759 3443 2 Socialism socialism NN 42759 3443 3 the the DT 42759 3443 4 organising organising NN 42759 3443 5 and and CC 42759 3443 6 directing direct VBG 42759 3443 7 functions function NNS 42759 3443 8 that that WDT 42759 3443 9 are be VBP 42759 3443 10 now now RB 42759 3443 11 performed perform VBN 42759 3443 12 by by IN 42759 3443 13 the the DT 42759 3443 14 business business NN 42759 3443 15 man man NN 42759 3443 16 , , , 42759 3443 17 would would MD 42759 3443 18 be be VB 42759 3443 19 allotted allot VBN 42759 3443 20 to to IN 42759 3443 21 salaried salaried JJ 42759 3443 22 superintendents superintendent NNS 42759 3443 23 and and CC 42759 3443 24 managers manager NNS 42759 3443 25 . . . 42759 3444 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3444 2 compensation compensation NN 42759 3444 3 would would MD 42759 3444 4 include include VB 42759 3444 5 no no DT 42759 3444 6 payment payment NN 42759 3444 7 for for IN 42759 3444 8 the the DT 42759 3444 9 risks risk NNS 42759 3444 10 of of IN 42759 3444 11 capital capital NN 42759 3444 12 , , , 42759 3444 13 and and CC 42759 3444 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3444 15 would would MD 42759 3444 16 be be VB 42759 3444 17 fixed fix VBN 42759 3444 18 instead instead RB 42759 3444 19 of of IN 42759 3444 20 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 42759 3444 21 . . . 42759 3445 1 Hence hence RB 42759 3445 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3445 3 would would MD 42759 3445 4 differ differ VB 42759 3445 5 considerably considerably RB 42759 3445 6 from from IN 42759 3445 7 present present JJ 42759 3445 8 - - HYPH 42759 3445 9 day day NN 42759 3445 10 profits profit NNS 42759 3445 11 . . . 42759 3446 1 To to IN 42759 3446 2 the the DT 42759 3446 3 assertion assertion NN 42759 3446 4 that that IN 42759 3446 5 profits profit NNS 42759 3446 6 are be VBP 42759 3446 7 immoral immoral JJ 42759 3446 8 a a DT 42759 3446 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3446 10 reply reply NN 42759 3446 11 at at IN 42759 3446 12 this this DT 42759 3446 13 time time NN 42759 3446 14 is be VBZ 42759 3446 15 that that IN 42759 3446 16 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 3446 17 has have VBZ 42759 3446 18 already already RB 42759 3446 19 been be VBN 42759 3446 20 shown show VBN 42759 3446 21 to to TO 42759 3446 22 be be VB 42759 3446 23 impracticable impracticable JJ 42759 3446 24 and and CC 42759 3446 25 inequitable inequitable JJ 42759 3446 26 . . . 42759 3447 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 3447 2 the the DT 42759 3447 3 system system NN 42759 3447 4 of of IN 42759 3447 5 private private JJ 42759 3447 6 industry industry NN 42759 3447 7 is be VBZ 42759 3447 8 essentially essentially RB 42759 3447 9 just just RB 42759 3447 10 , , , 42759 3447 11 and and CC 42759 3447 12 profits profit NNS 42759 3447 13 , , , 42759 3447 14 being be VBG 42759 3447 15 a a DT 42759 3447 16 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3447 17 element element NN 42759 3447 18 of of IN 42759 3447 19 the the DT 42759 3447 20 system system NN 42759 3447 21 , , , 42759 3447 22 are be VBP 42759 3447 23 essentially essentially RB 42759 3447 24 legitimate legitimate JJ 42759 3447 25 . . . 42759 3448 1 The the DT 42759 3448 2 question question NN 42759 3448 3 of of IN 42759 3448 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3448 5 morality morality NN 42759 3448 6 is be VBZ 42759 3448 7 one one CD 42759 3448 8 of of IN 42759 3448 9 degree degree NN 42759 3448 10 not not RB 42759 3448 11 of of IN 42759 3448 12 kind kind NN 42759 3448 13 . . . 42759 3449 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3449 2 will will MD 42759 3449 3 be be VB 42759 3449 4 considered consider VBN 42759 3449 5 under under IN 42759 3449 6 two two CD 42759 3449 7 principal principal JJ 42759 3449 8 heads head NNS 42759 3449 9 : : : 42759 3449 10 the the DT 42759 3449 11 right right NN 42759 3449 12 of of IN 42759 3449 13 the the DT 42759 3449 14 business business NN 42759 3449 15 man man NN 42759 3449 16 to to TO 42759 3449 17 obtain obtain VB 42759 3449 18 indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 3449 19 large large JJ 42759 3449 20 profits profit NNS 42759 3449 21 ; ; : 42759 3449 22 and and CC 42759 3449 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3449 24 right right NN 42759 3449 25 to to IN 42759 3449 26 a a DT 42759 3449 27 certain certain JJ 42759 3449 28 minimum minimum NN 42759 3449 29 of of IN 42759 3449 30 profits profit NNS 42759 3449 31 . . . 42759 3450 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3450 2 The the DT 42759 3450 3 Question Question NNP 42759 3450 4 of of IN 42759 3450 5 Indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 3450 6 Large large JJ 42759 3450 7 Profits profit NNS 42759 3450 8 _ _ XX 42759 3450 9 As as IN 42759 3450 10 a a DT 42759 3450 11 general general JJ 42759 3450 12 rule rule NN 42759 3450 13 , , , 42759 3450 14 business business NN 42759 3450 15 men man NNS 42759 3450 16 who who WP 42759 3450 17 face face VBP 42759 3450 18 conditions condition NNS 42759 3450 19 of of IN 42759 3450 20 active active JJ 42759 3450 21 competition competition NN 42759 3450 22 have have VBP 42759 3450 23 a a DT 42759 3450 24 right right NN 42759 3450 25 to to IN 42759 3450 26 all all PDT 42759 3450 27 the the DT 42759 3450 28 profits profit NNS 42759 3450 29 that that IN 42759 3450 30 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3450 31 can can MD 42759 3450 32 get get VB 42759 3450 33 , , , 42759 3450 34 so so RB 42759 3450 35 long long RB 42759 3450 36 as as IN 42759 3450 37 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3450 38 use use VBP 42759 3450 39 fair fair JJ 42759 3450 40 business business NN 42759 3450 41 methods method NNS 42759 3450 42 . . . 42759 3451 1 This this DT 42759 3451 2 means mean VBZ 42759 3451 3 not not RB 42759 3451 4 merely merely RB 42759 3451 5 fair fair JJ 42759 3451 6 and and CC 42759 3451 7 honest honest JJ 42759 3451 8 conduct conduct NN 42759 3451 9 toward toward IN 42759 3451 10 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3451 11 , , , 42759 3451 12 and and CC 42759 3451 13 buyers buyer NNS 42759 3451 14 and and CC 42759 3451 15 sellers seller NNS 42759 3451 16 , , , 42759 3451 17 but but CC 42759 3451 18 also also RB 42759 3451 19 just just RB 42759 3451 20 and and CC 42759 3451 21 humane humane JJ 42759 3451 22 treatment treatment NN 42759 3451 23 of of IN 42759 3451 24 labour labour NN 42759 3451 25 in in IN 42759 3451 26 all all PDT 42759 3451 27 the the DT 42759 3451 28 conditions condition NNS 42759 3451 29 of of IN 42759 3451 30 employment employment NN 42759 3451 31 , , , 42759 3451 32 especially especially RB 42759 3451 33 in in IN 42759 3451 34 the the DT 42759 3451 35 matter matter NN 42759 3451 36 of of IN 42759 3451 37 wages wage NNS 42759 3451 38 . . . 42759 3452 1 When when WRB 42759 3452 2 these these DT 42759 3452 3 conditions condition NNS 42759 3452 4 are be VBP 42759 3452 5 fulfilled fulfil VBN 42759 3452 6 , , , 42759 3452 7 the the DT 42759 3452 8 freedom freedom NN 42759 3452 9 to to TO 42759 3452 10 take take VB 42759 3452 11 indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 3452 12 large large JJ 42759 3452 13 profits profit NNS 42759 3452 14 is be VBZ 42759 3452 15 justified justify VBN 42759 3452 16 by by IN 42759 3452 17 the the DT 42759 3452 18 canon canon NN 42759 3452 19 of of IN 42759 3452 20 human human JJ 42759 3452 21 welfare welfare NN 42759 3452 22 . . . 42759 3453 1 The the DT 42759 3453 2 great great JJ 42759 3453 3 majority majority NN 42759 3453 4 of of IN 42759 3453 5 business business NN 42759 3453 6 men man NNS 42759 3453 7 in in IN 42759 3453 8 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3453 9 industries industry NNS 42759 3453 10 do do VBP 42759 3453 11 not not RB 42759 3453 12 receive receive VB 42759 3453 13 incomes income NNS 42759 3453 14 in in IN 42759 3453 15 excess excess NN 42759 3453 16 of of IN 42759 3453 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3453 18 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3453 19 needs need NNS 42759 3453 20 . . . 42759 3454 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3454 2 profits profit NNS 42759 3454 3 do do VBP 42759 3454 4 not not RB 42759 3454 5 notably notably RB 42759 3454 6 exceed exceed VB 42759 3454 7 the the DT 42759 3454 8 salaries salary NNS 42759 3454 9 that that IN 42759 3454 10 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3454 11 could could MD 42759 3454 12 command command VB 42759 3454 13 as as IN 42759 3454 14 hired hire VBN 42759 3454 15 managers manager NNS 42759 3454 16 , , , 42759 3454 17 and and CC 42759 3454 18 generally generally RB 42759 3454 19 are be VBP 42759 3454 20 not not RB 42759 3454 21 more more JJR 42759 3454 22 than than IN 42759 3454 23 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3454 24 to to TO 42759 3454 25 reimburse reimburse VB 42759 3454 26 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3454 27 for for IN 42759 3454 28 the the DT 42759 3454 29 cost cost NN 42759 3454 30 of of IN 42759 3454 31 education education NN 42759 3454 32 and and CC 42759 3454 33 business business NN 42759 3454 34 training training NN 42759 3454 35 , , , 42759 3454 36 and and CC 42759 3454 37 to to TO 42759 3454 38 enable enable VB 42759 3454 39 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3454 40 to to TO 42759 3454 41 live live VB 42759 3454 42 in in IN 42759 3454 43 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3454 44 conformity conformity NN 42759 3454 45 with with IN 42759 3454 46 the the DT 42759 3454 47 standard standard NN 42759 3454 48 of of IN 42759 3454 49 living live VBG 42759 3454 50 to to IN 42759 3454 51 which which WDT 42759 3454 52 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3454 53 have have VBP 42759 3454 54 become become VBN 42759 3454 55 accustomed accustomed JJ 42759 3454 56 . . . 42759 3455 1 Efforts effort NNS 42759 3455 2 and and CC 42759 3455 3 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3455 4 are be VBP 42759 3455 5 reflected reflect VBN 42759 3455 6 to to IN 42759 3455 7 some some DT 42759 3455 8 extent extent NN 42759 3455 9 in in IN 42759 3455 10 the the DT 42759 3455 11 different different JJ 42759 3455 12 amounts amount NNS 42759 3455 13 of of IN 42759 3455 14 profits profit NNS 42759 3455 15 received receive VBN 42759 3455 16 by by IN 42759 3455 17 different different JJ 42759 3455 18 business business NN 42759 3455 19 men man NNS 42759 3455 20 . . . 42759 3456 1 When when WRB 42759 3456 2 all all DT 42759 3456 3 due due JJ 42759 3456 4 allowance allowance NN 42759 3456 5 is be VBZ 42759 3456 6 made make VBN 42759 3456 7 for for IN 42759 3456 8 chance chance NN 42759 3456 9 , , , 42759 3456 10 productivity productivity NN 42759 3456 11 , , , 42759 3456 12 and and CC 42759 3456 13 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3456 14 , , , 42759 3456 15 a a DT 42759 3456 16 considerable considerable JJ 42759 3456 17 proportion proportion NN 42759 3456 18 of of IN 42759 3456 19 profits profit NNS 42759 3456 20 is be VBZ 42759 3456 21 attributable attributable JJ 42759 3456 22 to to IN 42759 3456 23 harder hard JJR 42759 3456 24 labour labour NN 42759 3456 25 , , , 42759 3456 26 greater great JJR 42759 3456 27 risk risk NN 42759 3456 28 and and CC 42759 3456 29 worry worry NN 42759 3456 30 , , , 42759 3456 31 and and CC 42759 3456 32 larger large JJR 42759 3456 33 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3456 34 . . . 42759 3457 1 Like like IN 42759 3457 2 the the DT 42759 3457 3 principle principle NN 42759 3457 4 of of IN 42759 3457 5 needs need NNS 42759 3457 6 , , , 42759 3457 7 that that DT 42759 3457 8 of of IN 42759 3457 9 efforts effort NNS 42759 3457 10 and and CC 42759 3457 11 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3457 12 is be VBZ 42759 3457 13 a a DT 42759 3457 14 partial partial JJ 42759 3457 15 justification justification NN 42759 3457 16 of of IN 42759 3457 17 the the DT 42759 3457 18 business business NN 42759 3457 19 man man NN 42759 3457 20 's 's POS 42759 3457 21 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 3457 22 . . . 42759 3458 1 Those those DT 42759 3458 2 profits profit NNS 42759 3458 3 which which WDT 42759 3458 4 can can MD 42759 3458 5 not not RB 42759 3458 6 be be VB 42759 3458 7 justified justify VBN 42759 3458 8 by by IN 42759 3458 9 either either DT 42759 3458 10 of of IN 42759 3458 11 the the DT 42759 3458 12 titles title NNS 42759 3458 13 just just RB 42759 3458 14 mentioned mention VBN 42759 3458 15 , , , 42759 3458 16 are be VBP 42759 3458 17 ethically ethically RB 42759 3458 18 warranted warrant VBN 42759 3458 19 by by IN 42759 3458 20 the the DT 42759 3458 21 principles principle NNS 42759 3458 22 of of IN 42759 3458 23 productivity productivity NN 42759 3458 24 and and CC 42759 3458 25 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 3458 26 . . . 42759 3459 1 This this DT 42759 3459 2 is be VBZ 42759 3459 3 particularly particularly RB 42759 3459 4 true true JJ 42759 3459 5 of of IN 42759 3459 6 those those DT 42759 3459 7 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3459 8 large large JJ 42759 3459 9 profits profit NNS 42759 3459 10 which which WDT 42759 3459 11 can can MD 42759 3459 12 be be VB 42759 3459 13 traced trace VBN 42759 3459 14 specifically specifically RB 42759 3459 15 to to IN 42759 3459 16 that that DT 42759 3459 17 unusual unusual JJ 42759 3459 18 ability ability NN 42759 3459 19 which which WDT 42759 3459 20 is be VBZ 42759 3459 21 exemplified exemplify VBN 42759 3459 22 in in IN 42759 3459 23 the the DT 42759 3459 24 invention invention NN 42759 3459 25 and and CC 42759 3459 26 adoption adoption NN 42759 3459 27 of of IN 42759 3459 28 new new JJ 42759 3459 29 methods method NNS 42759 3459 30 and and CC 42759 3459 31 processes process NNS 42759 3459 32 in in IN 42759 3459 33 progressive progressive JJ 42759 3459 34 industries industry NNS 42759 3459 35 . . . 42759 3460 1 The the DT 42759 3460 2 receivers receiver NNS 42759 3460 3 of of IN 42759 3460 4 these these DT 42759 3460 5 large large JJ 42759 3460 6 rewards reward NNS 42759 3460 7 have have VBP 42759 3460 8 produced produce VBN 42759 3460 9 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3460 10 in in IN 42759 3460 11 competition competition NN 42759 3460 12 with with IN 42759 3460 13 less less RBR 42759 3460 14 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3460 15 business business NN 42759 3460 16 men man NNS 42759 3460 17 . . . 42759 3461 1 While while IN 42759 3461 2 the the DT 42759 3461 3 title title NN 42759 3461 4 of of IN 42759 3461 5 productivity productivity NN 42759 3461 6 does do VBZ 42759 3461 7 not not RB 42759 3461 8 entirely entirely RB 42759 3461 9 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 3461 10 the the DT 42759 3461 11 seeker seeker NN 42759 3461 12 for for IN 42759 3461 13 decisive decisive JJ 42759 3461 14 ethical ethical JJ 42759 3461 15 sanctions sanction NNS 42759 3461 16 , , , 42759 3461 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3461 18 is be VBZ 42759 3461 19 stronger strong JJR 42759 3461 20 morally morally RB 42759 3461 21 than than IN 42759 3461 22 any any DT 42759 3461 23 opposing oppose VBG 42759 3461 24 considerations consideration NNS 42759 3461 25 that that WDT 42759 3461 26 can can MD 42759 3461 27 be be VB 42759 3461 28 invoked invoke VBN 42759 3461 29 . . . 42759 3462 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3462 2 is be VBZ 42759 3462 3 probably probably RB 42759 3462 4 as as RB 42759 3462 5 strong strong JJ 42759 3462 6 as as IN 42759 3462 7 some some DT 42759 3462 8 other other JJ 42759 3462 9 principles principle NNS 42759 3462 10 that that WDT 42759 3462 11 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3462 12 have have VBP 42759 3462 13 to to TO 42759 3462 14 accept accept VB 42759 3462 15 as as IN 42759 3462 16 the the DT 42759 3462 17 best good JJS 42759 3462 18 attainable attainable JJ 42759 3462 19 in in IN 42759 3462 20 the the DT 42759 3462 21 very very RB 42759 3462 22 difficult difficult JJ 42759 3462 23 field field NN 42759 3462 24 of of IN 42759 3462 25 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3462 26 ethics ethic NNS 42759 3462 27 . . . 42759 3463 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 3463 2 , , , 42759 3463 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3463 4 would would MD 42759 3463 5 seem seem VB 42759 3463 6 that that IN 42759 3463 7 those those DT 42759 3463 8 business business NN 42759 3463 9 men man NNS 42759 3463 10 who who WP 42759 3463 11 obtain obtain VBP 42759 3463 12 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3463 13 large large JJ 42759 3463 14 profits profit NNS 42759 3463 15 could could MD 42759 3463 16 be be VB 42759 3463 17 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 3463 18 required require VBN 42759 3463 19 to to TO 42759 3463 20 transfer transfer VB 42759 3463 21 part part NN 42759 3463 22 of of IN 42759 3463 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3463 24 gains gain NNS 42759 3463 25 to to IN 42759 3463 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3463 27 employés employés NN 42759 3463 28 in in IN 42759 3463 29 the the DT 42759 3463 30 form form NN 42759 3463 31 of of IN 42759 3463 32 higher high JJR 42759 3463 33 wages wage NNS 42759 3463 34 , , , 42759 3463 35 or or CC 42759 3463 36 to to IN 42759 3463 37 the the DT 42759 3463 38 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3463 39 in in IN 42759 3463 40 the the DT 42759 3463 41 form form NN 42759 3463 42 of of IN 42759 3463 43 lower low JJR 42759 3463 44 prices price NNS 42759 3463 45 . . . 42759 3464 1 Both both DT 42759 3464 2 of of IN 42759 3464 3 these these DT 42759 3464 4 methods method NNS 42759 3464 5 have have VBP 42759 3464 6 been be VBN 42759 3464 7 followed follow VBN 42759 3464 8 by by IN 42759 3464 9 Henry Henry NNP 42759 3464 10 Ford Ford NNP 42759 3464 11 , , , 42759 3464 12 the the DT 42759 3464 13 automobile automobile NN 42759 3464 14 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 3464 15 . . . 42759 3465 1 Neither neither DT 42759 3465 2 of of IN 42759 3465 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3465 4 is be VBZ 42759 3465 5 certainly certainly RB 42759 3465 6 demanded demand VBN 42759 3465 7 by by IN 42759 3465 8 the the DT 42759 3465 9 principles principle NNS 42759 3465 10 of of IN 42759 3465 11 strict strict JJ 42759 3465 12 justice justice NN 42759 3465 13 ; ; : 42759 3465 14 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3465 15 rest rest VBP 42759 3465 16 upon upon IN 42759 3465 17 the the DT 42759 3465 18 feebler feebler NN 42759 3465 19 and and CC 42759 3465 20 less less RBR 42759 3465 21 decisive decisive JJ 42759 3465 22 principle principle NN 42759 3465 23 of of IN 42759 3465 24 general general JJ 42759 3465 25 equity equity NN 42759 3465 26 or or CC 42759 3465 27 fairness fairness NN 42759 3465 28 . . . 42759 3466 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3466 2 163 163 CD 42759 3466 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3466 4 This this DT 42759 3466 5 concept concept NN 42759 3466 6 is be VBZ 42759 3466 7 less less RBR 42759 3466 8 definite definite JJ 42759 3466 9 than than IN 42759 3466 10 those those DT 42759 3466 11 of of IN 42759 3466 12 charity charity NN 42759 3466 13 and and CC 42759 3466 14 justice justice NN 42759 3466 15 , , , 42759 3466 16 and and CC 42759 3466 17 stands stand VBZ 42759 3466 18 midway midway RB 42759 3466 19 between between IN 42759 3466 20 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3466 21 . . . 42759 3467 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3467 2 comes come VBZ 42759 3467 3 into into IN 42759 3467 4 operation operation NN 42759 3467 5 when when WRB 42759 3467 6 an an DT 42759 3467 7 action action NN 42759 3467 8 is be VBZ 42759 3467 9 obligatory obligatory JJ 42759 3467 10 on on IN 42759 3467 11 stricter strict JJR 42759 3467 12 grounds ground NNS 42759 3467 13 than than IN 42759 3467 14 those those DT 42759 3467 15 of of IN 42759 3467 16 charity charity NN 42759 3467 17 , , , 42759 3467 18 and and CC 42759 3467 19 yet yet RB 42759 3467 20 can can MD 42759 3467 21 not not RB 42759 3467 22 with with IN 42759 3467 23 certainty certainty NN 42759 3467 24 be be VB 42759 3467 25 required require VBN 42759 3467 26 on on IN 42759 3467 27 grounds ground NNS 42759 3467 28 of of IN 42759 3467 29 justice justice NN 42759 3467 30 . . . 42759 3468 1 Notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 42759 3468 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3468 3 vagueness vagueness NN 42759 3468 4 , , , 42759 3468 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3468 6 is be VBZ 42759 3468 7 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3468 8 strong strong JJ 42759 3468 9 to to TO 42759 3468 10 make make VB 42759 3468 11 the the DT 42759 3468 12 average average JJ 42759 3468 13 conscientious conscientious JJ 42759 3468 14 man man NN 42759 3468 15 feel feel VBP 42759 3468 16 uncomfortable uncomfortable JJ 42759 3468 17 if if IN 42759 3468 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3468 19 neglects neglect VBZ 42759 3468 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3468 21 prescriptions prescription NNS 42759 3468 22 entirely entirely RB 42759 3468 23 . . . 42759 3469 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3469 2 has have VBZ 42759 3469 3 , , , 42759 3469 4 therefore therefore RB 42759 3469 5 , , , 42759 3469 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3469 7 practical practical JJ 42759 3469 8 value value NN 42759 3469 9 to to TO 42759 3469 10 deserve deserve VB 42759 3469 11 a a DT 42759 3469 12 place place NN 42759 3469 13 in in IN 42759 3469 14 the the DT 42759 3469 15 ethics ethic NNS 42759 3469 16 of of IN 42759 3469 17 distribution distribution NN 42759 3469 18 . . . 42759 3470 1 And and CC 42759 3470 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3470 3 seems seem VBZ 42759 3470 4 to to TO 42759 3470 5 have have VB 42759 3470 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3470 7 application application NN 42759 3470 8 to to IN 42759 3470 9 the the DT 42759 3470 10 problem problem NN 42759 3470 11 before before IN 42759 3470 12 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3470 13 to to TO 42759 3470 14 justify justify VB 42759 3470 15 the the DT 42759 3470 16 statement statement NN 42759 3470 17 that that IN 42759 3470 18 the the DT 42759 3470 19 receivers receiver NNS 42759 3470 20 of of IN 42759 3470 21 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3470 22 large large JJ 42759 3470 23 profits profit NNS 42759 3470 24 are be VBP 42759 3470 25 bound bind VBN 42759 3470 26 in in IN 42759 3470 27 equity equity NN 42759 3470 28 to to TO 42759 3470 29 share share VB 42759 3470 30 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3470 31 with with IN 42759 3470 32 those those DT 42759 3470 33 persons person NNS 42759 3470 34 who who WP 42759 3470 35 have have VBP 42759 3470 36 co co VBN 42759 3470 37 - - VBN 42759 3470 38 operated operated JJ 42759 3470 39 in in IN 42759 3470 40 producing produce VBG 42759 3470 41 and and CC 42759 3470 42 providing provide VBG 42759 3470 43 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3470 44 , , , 42759 3470 45 namely namely RB 42759 3470 46 , , , 42759 3470 47 wage wage NN 42759 3470 48 earners earner NNS 42759 3470 49 and and CC 42759 3470 50 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3470 51 . . . 42759 3471 1 In in IN 42759 3471 2 the the DT 42759 3471 3 field field NN 42759 3471 4 of of IN 42759 3471 5 profits profit NNS 42759 3471 6 the the DT 42759 3471 7 canon canon NN 42759 3471 8 of of IN 42759 3471 9 human human JJ 42759 3471 10 welfare welfare NN 42759 3471 11 is be VBZ 42759 3471 12 not not RB 42759 3471 13 only only RB 42759 3471 14 sound sound NN 42759 3471 15 ethically ethically RB 42759 3471 16 but but CC 42759 3471 17 expedient expedient NN 42759 3471 18 socially socially RB 42759 3471 19 . . . 42759 3472 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3472 2 permits permit VBZ 42759 3472 3 the the DT 42759 3472 4 great great JJ 42759 3472 5 majority majority NN 42759 3472 6 of of IN 42759 3472 7 business business NN 42759 3472 8 men man NNS 42759 3472 9 to to TO 42759 3472 10 obtain obtain VB 42759 3472 11 , , , 42759 3472 12 if if IN 42759 3472 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3472 14 can can MD 42759 3472 15 , , , 42759 3472 16 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3472 17 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 3472 18 to to TO 42759 3472 19 meet meet VB 42759 3472 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3472 21 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3472 22 needs need NNS 42759 3472 23 . . . 42759 3473 1 Whether whether IN 42759 3473 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3473 3 requires require VBZ 42759 3473 4 society society NN 42759 3473 5 to to IN 42759 3473 6 _ _ NNP 42759 3473 7 guarantee guarantee NN 42759 3473 8 _ _ NNP 42759 3473 9 at at IN 42759 3473 10 least least JJS 42759 3473 11 this this DT 42759 3473 12 amount amount NN 42759 3473 13 of of IN 42759 3473 14 profit profit NN 42759 3473 15 - - HYPH 42759 3473 16 income income NN 42759 3473 17 is be VBZ 42759 3473 18 a a DT 42759 3473 19 question question NN 42759 3473 20 that that WDT 42759 3473 21 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3473 22 shall shall MD 42759 3473 23 examine examine VB 42759 3473 24 presently presently RB 42759 3473 25 . . . 42759 3474 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3474 2 encourages encourage VBZ 42759 3474 3 efforts effort NNS 42759 3474 4 , , , 42759 3474 5 and and CC 42759 3474 6 makes make VBZ 42759 3474 7 for for IN 42759 3474 8 the the DT 42759 3474 9 maximum maximum JJ 42759 3474 10 social social JJ 42759 3474 11 product product NN 42759 3474 12 by by IN 42759 3474 13 permitting permit VBG 42759 3474 14 business business NN 42759 3474 15 men man NNS 42759 3474 16 to to TO 42759 3474 17 retain retain VB 42759 3474 18 all all PDT 42759 3474 19 the the DT 42759 3474 20 profits profit NNS 42759 3474 21 that that IN 42759 3474 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3474 23 can can MD 42759 3474 24 get get VB 42759 3474 25 in in IN 42759 3474 26 conditions condition NNS 42759 3474 27 of of IN 42759 3474 28 fair fair JJ 42759 3474 29 competition competition NN 42759 3474 30 . . . 42759 3475 1 Does do VBZ 42759 3475 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3475 3 forbid forbid VB 42759 3475 4 any any DT 42759 3475 5 attempt attempt NN 42759 3475 6 by by IN 42759 3475 7 society society NN 42759 3475 8 to to TO 42759 3475 9 limit limit VB 42759 3475 10 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3475 11 large large JJ 42759 3475 12 profit profit NN 42759 3475 13 - - HYPH 42759 3475 14 incomes income NNS 42759 3475 15 ? ? . 42759 3476 1 If if IN 42759 3476 2 the the DT 42759 3476 3 limit limit NN 42759 3476 4 were be VBD 42759 3476 5 placed place VBN 42759 3476 6 very very RB 42759 3476 7 high high JJ 42759 3476 8 , , , 42759 3476 9 say say VB 42759 3476 10 , , , 42759 3476 11 at at IN 42759 3476 12 50,000 50,000 CD 42759 3476 13 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3476 14 per per IN 42759 3476 15 year year NN 42759 3476 16 , , , 42759 3476 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3476 18 would would MD 42759 3476 19 not not RB 42759 3476 20 apparently apparently RB 42759 3476 21 check check VB 42759 3476 22 the the DT 42759 3476 23 productive productive JJ 42759 3476 24 efforts effort NNS 42759 3476 25 of of IN 42759 3476 26 the the DT 42759 3476 27 great great JJ 42759 3476 28 majority majority NN 42759 3476 29 of of IN 42759 3476 30 business business NN 42759 3476 31 men man NNS 42759 3476 32 , , , 42759 3476 33 since since IN 42759 3476 34 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3476 35 never never RB 42759 3476 36 hope hope VBP 42759 3476 37 to to TO 42759 3476 38 pass pass VB 42759 3476 39 that that DT 42759 3476 40 figure figure NN 42759 3476 41 . . . 42759 3477 1 Whether whether IN 42759 3477 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3477 3 would would MD 42759 3477 4 have have VB 42759 3477 5 a a DT 42759 3477 6 seriously seriously RB 42759 3477 7 discouraging discouraging JJ 42759 3477 8 effect effect NN 42759 3477 9 upon upon IN 42759 3477 10 the the DT 42759 3477 11 activity activity NN 42759 3477 12 and and CC 42759 3477 13 ambition ambition NN 42759 3477 14 of of IN 42759 3477 15 those those DT 42759 3477 16 who who WP 42759 3477 17 do do VBP 42759 3477 18 hope hope VB 42759 3477 19 to to TO 42759 3477 20 reach reach VB 42759 3477 21 , , , 42759 3477 22 and and CC 42759 3477 23 of of IN 42759 3477 24 those those DT 42759 3477 25 who who WP 42759 3477 26 have have VBP 42759 3477 27 already already RB 42759 3477 28 reached reach VBN 42759 3477 29 that that DT 42759 3477 30 level level NN 42759 3477 31 , , , 42759 3477 32 is be VBZ 42759 3477 33 uncertain uncertain JJ 42759 3477 34 . . . 42759 3478 1 Among among IN 42759 3478 2 business business NN 42759 3478 3 men man NNS 42759 3478 4 who who WP 42759 3478 5 are be VBP 42759 3478 6 approaching approach VBG 42759 3478 7 or or CC 42759 3478 8 who who WP 42759 3478 9 have have VBP 42759 3478 10 passed pass VBN 42759 3478 11 the the DT 42759 3478 12 50,000 50,000 CD 42759 3478 13 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3478 14 annual annual JJ 42759 3478 15 profit profit NN 42759 3478 16 - - HYPH 42759 3478 17 income income NN 42759 3478 18 mark mark NN 42759 3478 19 , , , 42759 3478 20 the the DT 42759 3478 21 desire desire NN 42759 3478 22 to to TO 42759 3478 23 possess possess VB 42759 3478 24 more more JJR 42759 3478 25 money money NN 42759 3478 26 is be VBZ 42759 3478 27 frequently frequently RB 42759 3478 28 weaker weak JJR 42759 3478 29 as as IN 42759 3478 30 a a DT 42759 3478 31 motive motive NN 42759 3478 32 to to IN 42759 3478 33 business business NN 42759 3478 34 activity activity NN 42759 3478 35 than than IN 42759 3478 36 the the DT 42759 3478 37 longing longing NN 42759 3478 38 for for IN 42759 3478 39 power power NN 42759 3478 40 and and CC 42759 3478 41 the the DT 42759 3478 42 driving drive VBG 42759 3478 43 force force NN 42759 3478 44 of of IN 42759 3478 45 habit habit NN 42759 3478 46 . . . 42759 3479 1 At at IN 42759 3479 2 any any DT 42759 3479 3 rate rate NN 42759 3479 4 , , , 42759 3479 5 the the DT 42759 3479 6 question question NN 42759 3479 7 is be VBZ 42759 3479 8 not not RB 42759 3479 9 very very RB 42759 3479 10 practical practical JJ 42759 3479 11 . . . 42759 3480 1 Any any DT 42759 3480 2 sustained sustained JJ 42759 3480 3 attempt attempt NN 42759 3480 4 to to TO 42759 3480 5 limit limit VB 42759 3480 6 profits profit NNS 42759 3480 7 by by IN 42759 3480 8 law law NN 42759 3480 9 would would MD 42759 3480 10 require require VB 42759 3480 11 such such JJ 42759 3480 12 extensive extensive JJ 42759 3480 13 and and CC 42759 3480 14 minute minute JJ 42759 3480 15 supervision supervision NN 42759 3480 16 of of IN 42759 3480 17 business business NN 42759 3480 18 that that WDT 42759 3480 19 the the DT 42759 3480 20 policy policy NN 42759 3480 21 would would MD 42759 3480 22 prove prove VB 42759 3480 23 to to TO 42759 3480 24 be be VB 42759 3480 25 socially socially RB 42759 3480 26 intolerable intolerable JJ 42759 3480 27 and and CC 42759 3480 28 unprofitable unprofitable JJ 42759 3480 29 . . . 42759 3481 1 The the DT 42759 3481 2 espionage espionage NN 42759 3481 3 involved involve VBN 42759 3481 4 in in IN 42759 3481 5 the the DT 42759 3481 6 policy policy NN 42759 3481 7 would would MD 42759 3481 8 provoke provoke VB 42759 3481 9 general general JJ 42759 3481 10 resentment resentment NN 42759 3481 11 , , , 42759 3481 12 and and CC 42759 3481 13 the the DT 42759 3481 14 amount amount NN 42759 3481 15 of of IN 42759 3481 16 profits profit NNS 42759 3481 17 that that WDT 42759 3481 18 could could MD 42759 3481 19 be be VB 42759 3481 20 diverted divert VBN 42759 3481 21 either either RB 42759 3481 22 to to IN 42759 3481 23 the the DT 42759 3481 24 State state NN 42759 3481 25 or or CC 42759 3481 26 to to IN 42759 3481 27 private private JJ 42759 3481 28 persons person NNS 42759 3481 29 would would MD 42759 3481 30 be be VB 42759 3481 31 relatively relatively RB 42759 3481 32 insignificant insignificant JJ 42759 3481 33 . . . 42759 3482 1 Thus thus RB 42759 3482 2 far far RB 42759 3482 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3482 4 have have VBP 42759 3482 5 been be VBN 42759 3482 6 considering consider VBG 42759 3482 7 the the DT 42759 3482 8 independent independent JJ 42759 3482 9 business business NN 42759 3482 10 man man NN 42759 3482 11 and and CC 42759 3482 12 business business NN 42759 3482 13 firm firm NN 42759 3482 14 , , , 42759 3482 15 not not RB 42759 3482 16 the the DT 42759 3482 17 joint joint JJ 42759 3482 18 stock stock NN 42759 3482 19 company company NN 42759 3482 20 or or CC 42759 3482 21 corporation corporation NN 42759 3482 22 . . . 42759 3483 1 In in IN 42759 3483 2 the the DT 42759 3483 3 latter latter JJ 42759 3483 4 form form NN 42759 3483 5 of of IN 42759 3483 6 organisation organisation NN 42759 3483 7 , , , 42759 3483 8 the the DT 42759 3483 9 labour labour NN 42759 3483 10 of of IN 42759 3483 11 direction direction NN 42759 3483 12 is be VBZ 42759 3483 13 remunerated remunerate VBN 42759 3483 14 by by IN 42759 3483 15 fixed fix VBN 42759 3483 16 salaries salary NNS 42759 3483 17 to to IN 42759 3483 18 the the DT 42759 3483 19 executive executive JJ 42759 3483 20 officers officer NNS 42759 3483 21 , , , 42759 3483 22 while while IN 42759 3483 23 the the DT 42759 3483 24 risks risk NNS 42759 3483 25 of of IN 42759 3483 26 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3483 27 and and CC 42759 3483 28 capital capital NN 42759 3483 29 are be VBP 42759 3483 30 covered cover VBN 42759 3483 31 by by IN 42759 3483 32 the the DT 42759 3483 33 regular regular JJ 42759 3483 34 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3483 35 received receive VBN 42759 3483 36 by by IN 42759 3483 37 the the DT 42759 3483 38 whole whole JJ 42759 3483 39 body body NN 42759 3483 40 of of IN 42759 3483 41 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3483 42 . . . 42759 3484 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 3484 2 the the DT 42759 3484 3 only only JJ 42759 3484 4 revenues revenue NNS 42759 3484 5 comparable comparable JJ 42759 3484 6 to to IN 42759 3484 7 profits profit NNS 42759 3484 8 are be VBP 42759 3484 9 the the DT 42759 3484 10 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3484 11 gains gain NNS 42759 3484 12 that that WDT 42759 3484 13 remain remain VBP 42759 3484 14 after after IN 42759 3484 15 wages wage NNS 42759 3484 16 , , , 42759 3484 17 salaries salary NNS 42759 3484 18 , , , 42759 3484 19 interest interest NN 42759 3484 20 , , , 42759 3484 21 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3484 22 , , , 42759 3484 23 rent rent NN 42759 3484 24 , , , 42759 3484 25 and and CC 42759 3484 26 all all DT 42759 3484 27 other other JJ 42759 3484 28 expenses expense NNS 42759 3484 29 and and CC 42759 3484 30 charges charge NNS 42759 3484 31 have have VBP 42759 3484 32 been be VBN 42759 3484 33 met meet VBN 42759 3484 34 . . . 42759 3485 1 These these DT 42759 3485 2 are be VBP 42759 3485 3 apportioned apportion VBN 42759 3485 4 through through IN 42759 3485 5 one one CD 42759 3485 6 process process NN 42759 3485 7 or or CC 42759 3485 8 another another DT 42759 3485 9 among among IN 42759 3485 10 the the DT 42759 3485 11 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3485 12 . . . 42759 3486 1 On on IN 42759 3486 2 what what WDT 42759 3486 3 ethical ethical JJ 42759 3486 4 principle principle NN 42759 3486 5 can can MD 42759 3486 6 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3486 7 be be VB 42759 3486 8 thus thus RB 42759 3486 9 distributed distribute VBN 42759 3486 10 ? ? . 42759 3487 1 The the DT 42759 3487 2 general general JJ 42759 3487 3 principle principle NN 42759 3487 4 of of IN 42759 3487 5 productivity productivity NN 42759 3487 6 , , , 42759 3487 7 or or CC 42759 3487 8 superior superior JJ 42759 3487 9 productivity productivity NN 42759 3487 10 , , , 42759 3487 11 is be VBZ 42759 3487 12 the the DT 42759 3487 13 only only JJ 42759 3487 14 one one CD 42759 3487 15 available available JJ 42759 3487 16 . . . 42759 3488 1 If if IN 42759 3488 2 a a DT 42759 3488 3 corporation corporation NN 42759 3488 4 which which WDT 42759 3488 5 uses use VBZ 42759 3488 6 fair fair JJ 42759 3488 7 methods method NNS 42759 3488 8 of of IN 42759 3488 9 competition competition NN 42759 3488 10 can can MD 42759 3488 11 obtain obtain VB 42759 3488 12 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3488 13 gains gain NNS 42759 3488 14 , , , 42759 3488 15 while while IN 42759 3488 16 the the DT 42759 3488 17 majority majority NN 42759 3488 18 of of IN 42759 3488 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3488 20 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3488 21 fail fail VBP 42759 3488 22 to to TO 42759 3488 23 do do VB 42759 3488 24 so so RB 42759 3488 25 , , , 42759 3488 26 the the DT 42759 3488 27 cause cause NN 42759 3488 28 must must MD 42759 3488 29 be be VB 42759 3488 30 sought seek VBN 42759 3488 31 in in IN 42759 3488 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3488 33 superior superior JJ 42759 3488 34 business business NN 42759 3488 35 management management NN 42759 3488 36 . . . 42759 3489 1 This this DT 42759 3489 2 superiority superiority NN 42759 3489 3 must must MD 42759 3489 4 be be VB 42759 3489 5 credited credit VBN 42759 3489 6 to to IN 42759 3489 7 the the DT 42759 3489 8 whole whole JJ 42759 3489 9 body body NN 42759 3489 10 of of IN 42759 3489 11 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3489 12 , , , 42759 3489 13 even even RB 42759 3489 14 though though IN 42759 3489 15 the the DT 42759 3489 16 great great JJ 42759 3489 17 majority majority NN 42759 3489 18 of of IN 42759 3489 19 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3489 20 are be VBP 42759 3489 21 responsible responsible JJ 42759 3489 22 for for IN 42759 3489 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3489 24 only only RB 42759 3489 25 in in IN 42759 3489 26 a a DT 42759 3489 27 very very RB 42759 3489 28 remote remote JJ 42759 3489 29 way way NN 42759 3489 30 , , , 42759 3489 31 through through IN 42759 3489 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3489 33 selection selection NN 42759 3489 34 of of IN 42759 3489 35 the the DT 42759 3489 36 executive executive JJ 42759 3489 37 officers officer NNS 42759 3489 38 . . . 42759 3490 1 The the DT 42759 3490 2 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3490 3 surely surely RB 42759 3490 4 have have VBP 42759 3490 5 a a DT 42759 3490 6 better well JJR 42759 3490 7 claim claim NN 42759 3490 8 to to IN 42759 3490 9 these these DT 42759 3490 10 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3490 11 gains gain NNS 42759 3490 12 than than IN 42759 3490 13 any any DT 42759 3490 14 other other JJ 42759 3490 15 group group NN 42759 3490 16 in in IN 42759 3490 17 the the DT 42759 3490 18 community community NN 42759 3490 19 . . . 42759 3491 1 At at IN 42759 3491 2 the the DT 42759 3491 3 same same JJ 42759 3491 4 time time NN 42759 3491 5 , , , 42759 3491 6 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3491 7 are be VBP 42759 3491 8 , , , 42759 3491 9 like like IN 42759 3491 10 the the DT 42759 3491 11 independent independent JJ 42759 3491 12 business business NN 42759 3491 13 man man NN 42759 3491 14 , , , 42759 3491 15 bound bind VBN 42759 3491 16 by by IN 42759 3491 17 the the DT 42759 3491 18 principle principle NN 42759 3491 19 of of IN 42759 3491 20 equity equity NN 42759 3491 21 to to TO 42759 3491 22 share share VB 42759 3491 23 the the DT 42759 3491 24 surplus surplus NN 42759 3491 25 with with IN 42759 3491 26 the the DT 42759 3491 27 labourers labourer NNS 42759 3491 28 and and CC 42759 3491 29 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3491 30 . . . 42759 3492 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3492 2 The the DT 42759 3492 3 Question Question NNP 42759 3492 4 of of IN 42759 3492 5 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 3492 6 Profits Profits NNPS 42759 3492 7 _ _ NNP 42759 3492 8 Has have VBZ 42759 3492 9 the the DT 42759 3492 10 business business NN 42759 3492 11 man man NN 42759 3492 12 a a DT 42759 3492 13 strict strict JJ 42759 3492 14 right right NN 42759 3492 15 to to IN 42759 3492 16 a a DT 42759 3492 17 minimum minimum JJ 42759 3492 18 living living NN 42759 3492 19 profit profit NN 42759 3492 20 ? ? . 42759 3493 1 In in IN 42759 3493 2 other other JJ 42759 3493 3 words word NNS 42759 3493 4 , , , 42759 3493 5 have have VBP 42759 3493 6 all all DT 42759 3493 7 business business NN 42759 3493 8 men man NNS 42759 3493 9 a a DT 42759 3493 10 right right NN 42759 3493 11 to to IN 42759 3493 12 a a DT 42759 3493 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3493 14 volume volume NN 42759 3493 15 of of IN 42759 3493 16 sales sale NNS 42759 3493 17 at at IN 42759 3493 18 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3493 19 high high JJ 42759 3493 20 prices price NNS 42759 3493 21 to to TO 42759 3493 22 provide provide VB 42759 3493 23 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3493 24 with with IN 42759 3493 25 living living NN 42759 3493 26 profits profit NNS 42759 3493 27 or or CC 42759 3493 28 a a DT 42759 3493 29 decent decent JJ 42759 3493 30 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 3493 31 ? ? . 42759 3494 1 Such such PDT 42759 3494 2 a a DT 42759 3494 3 right right NN 42759 3494 4 would would MD 42759 3494 5 imply imply VB 42759 3494 6 a a DT 42759 3494 7 corresponding corresponding JJ 42759 3494 8 obligation obligation NN 42759 3494 9 upon upon IN 42759 3494 10 the the DT 42759 3494 11 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3494 12 , , , 42759 3494 13 or or CC 42759 3494 14 upon upon IN 42759 3494 15 society society NN 42759 3494 16 , , , 42759 3494 17 to to TO 42759 3494 18 furnish furnish VB 42759 3494 19 the the DT 42759 3494 20 requisite requisite JJ 42759 3494 21 amount amount NN 42759 3494 22 of of IN 42759 3494 23 demand demand NN 42759 3494 24 at at IN 42759 3494 25 the the DT 42759 3494 26 required require VBN 42759 3494 27 prices price NNS 42759 3494 28 . . . 42759 3495 1 Is be VBZ 42759 3495 2 there there EX 42759 3495 3 such such PDT 42759 3495 4 a a DT 42759 3495 5 right right NN 42759 3495 6 , , , 42759 3495 7 and and CC 42759 3495 8 such such PDT 42759 3495 9 an an DT 42759 3495 10 obligation obligation NN 42759 3495 11 ? ? . 42759 3496 1 No no DT 42759 3496 2 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3496 3 right right NN 42759 3496 4 is be VBZ 42759 3496 5 absolute absolute JJ 42759 3496 6 . . . 42759 3497 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3497 2 are be VBP 42759 3497 3 all all DT 42759 3497 4 conditioned condition VBN 42759 3497 5 by by IN 42759 3497 6 the the DT 42759 3497 7 possibilities possibility NNS 42759 3497 8 of of IN 42759 3497 9 the the DT 42759 3497 10 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3497 11 system system NN 42759 3497 12 , , , 42759 3497 13 and and CC 42759 3497 14 by by IN 42759 3497 15 the the DT 42759 3497 16 desires desire NNS 42759 3497 17 , , , 42759 3497 18 capacities capacity NNS 42759 3497 19 , , , 42759 3497 20 and and CC 42759 3497 21 actions action NNS 42759 3497 22 of of IN 42759 3497 23 the the DT 42759 3497 24 persons person NNS 42759 3497 25 who who WP 42759 3497 26 enter enter VBP 42759 3497 27 into into IN 42759 3497 28 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3497 29 relations relation NNS 42759 3497 30 with with IN 42759 3497 31 one one CD 42759 3497 32 another another DT 42759 3497 33 . . . 42759 3498 1 As as IN 42759 3498 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3498 3 shall shall MD 42759 3498 4 see see VB 42759 3498 5 later later RBR 42759 3498 6 , , , 42759 3498 7 this this DT 42759 3498 8 statement statement NN 42759 3498 9 is be VBZ 42759 3498 10 true true JJ 42759 3498 11 even even RB 42759 3498 12 of of IN 42759 3498 13 the the DT 42759 3498 14 right right NN 42759 3498 15 to to IN 42759 3498 16 a a DT 42759 3498 17 living living NN 42759 3498 18 wage wage NN 42759 3498 19 . . . 42759 3499 1 When when WRB 42759 3499 2 the the DT 42759 3499 3 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3499 4 resources resource NNS 42759 3499 5 are be VBP 42759 3499 6 adequate adequate JJ 42759 3499 7 , , , 42759 3499 8 all all DT 42759 3499 9 persons person NNS 42759 3499 10 of of IN 42759 3499 11 average average JJ 42759 3499 12 ability ability NN 42759 3499 13 who who WP 42759 3499 14 contribute contribute VBP 42759 3499 15 a a DT 42759 3499 16 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3499 17 amount amount NN 42759 3499 18 of of IN 42759 3499 19 labour labour NN 42759 3499 20 to to IN 42759 3499 21 the the DT 42759 3499 22 productive productive JJ 42759 3499 23 process process NN 42759 3499 24 have have VBP 42759 3499 25 a a DT 42759 3499 26 right right NN 42759 3499 27 to to IN 42759 3499 28 a a DT 42759 3499 29 decent decent JJ 42759 3499 30 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 3499 31 on on IN 42759 3499 32 two two CD 42759 3499 33 conditions condition NNS 42759 3499 34 : : : 42759 3499 35 first first RB 42759 3499 36 , , , 42759 3499 37 that that IN 42759 3499 38 such such JJ 42759 3499 39 labour labour NN 42759 3499 40 is be VBZ 42759 3499 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3499 42 only only JJ 42759 3499 43 means mean NNS 42759 3499 44 of of IN 42759 3499 45 sustenance sustenance NN 42759 3499 46 ; ; : 42759 3499 47 and and CC 42759 3499 48 , , , 42759 3499 49 second second RB 42759 3499 50 , , , 42759 3499 51 that that IN 42759 3499 52 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3499 53 labour labour NN 42759 3499 54 is be VBZ 42759 3499 55 economically economically RB 42759 3499 56 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 3499 57 to to IN 42759 3499 58 those those DT 42759 3499 59 who who WP 42759 3499 60 utilise utilise VBP 42759 3499 61 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3499 62 or or CC 42759 3499 63 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3499 64 product product NN 42759 3499 65 . . . 42759 3500 1 " " `` 42759 3500 2 Economically economically RB 42759 3500 3 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 3500 4 " " '' 42759 3500 5 means mean VBZ 42759 3500 6 that that IN 42759 3500 7 the the DT 42759 3500 8 beneficiary beneficiary NN 42759 3500 9 of of IN 42759 3500 10 the the DT 42759 3500 11 labour labour NN 42759 3500 12 would would MD 42759 3500 13 rather rather RB 42759 3500 14 give give VB 42759 3500 15 the the DT 42759 3500 16 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 3500 17 of of IN 42759 3500 18 a a DT 42759 3500 19 decent decent JJ 42759 3500 20 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 3500 21 for for IN 42759 3500 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3500 23 than than IN 42759 3500 24 go go VB 42759 3500 25 without without IN 42759 3500 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3500 27 . . . 42759 3501 1 While while IN 42759 3501 2 both both PDT 42759 3501 3 these these DT 42759 3501 4 conditions condition NNS 42759 3501 5 are be VBP 42759 3501 6 apparently apparently RB 42759 3501 7 fulfilled fulfil VBN 42759 3501 8 in in IN 42759 3501 9 the the DT 42759 3501 10 case case NN 42759 3501 11 of of IN 42759 3501 12 the the DT 42759 3501 13 great great JJ 42759 3501 14 majority majority NN 42759 3501 15 of of IN 42759 3501 16 wage wage NN 42759 3501 17 earners earner NNS 42759 3501 18 , , , 42759 3501 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3501 20 are be VBP 42759 3501 21 only only RB 42759 3501 22 rarely rarely RB 42759 3501 23 realised realise VBN 42759 3501 24 with with IN 42759 3501 25 regard regard NN 42759 3501 26 to to IN 42759 3501 27 business business NN 42759 3501 28 men man NNS 42759 3501 29 . . . 42759 3502 1 In in IN 42759 3502 2 most most JJS 42759 3502 3 instances instance NNS 42759 3502 4 the the DT 42759 3502 5 business business NN 42759 3502 6 man man NN 42759 3502 7 who who WP 42759 3502 8 is be VBZ 42759 3502 9 unable unable JJ 42759 3502 10 to to TO 42759 3502 11 make make VB 42759 3502 12 living living NN 42759 3502 13 profits profit NNS 42759 3502 14 could could MD 42759 3502 15 become become VB 42759 3502 16 an an DT 42759 3502 17 employé employé JJ 42759 3502 18 , , , 42759 3502 19 and and CC 42759 3502 20 thus thus RB 42759 3502 21 convert convert VB 42759 3502 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3502 23 right right NN 42759 3502 24 to to IN 42759 3502 25 a a DT 42759 3502 26 decent decent JJ 42759 3502 27 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 3502 28 into into IN 42759 3502 29 a a DT 42759 3502 30 right right NN 42759 3502 31 to to IN 42759 3502 32 a a DT 42759 3502 33 living living NN 42759 3502 34 wage wage NN 42759 3502 35 . . . 42759 3503 1 Even even RB 42759 3503 2 when when WRB 42759 3503 3 no no DT 42759 3503 4 such such JJ 42759 3503 5 alternative alternative NN 42759 3503 6 is be VBZ 42759 3503 7 open open JJ 42759 3503 8 to to IN 42759 3503 9 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3503 10 , , , 42759 3503 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3503 12 can can MD 42759 3503 13 not not RB 42759 3503 14 claim claim VB 42759 3503 15 a a DT 42759 3503 16 strict strict JJ 42759 3503 17 right right NN 42759 3503 18 to to IN 42759 3503 19 living living NN 42759 3503 20 profits profit NNS 42759 3503 21 , , , 42759 3503 22 for for IN 42759 3503 23 the the DT 42759 3503 24 second second JJ 42759 3503 25 condition condition NN 42759 3503 26 stated state VBN 42759 3503 27 above above RB 42759 3503 28 remains remain VBZ 42759 3503 29 unfulfilled unfulfilled JJ 42759 3503 30 . . . 42759 3504 1 The the DT 42759 3504 2 consuming consume VBG 42759 3504 3 public public NN 42759 3504 4 does do VBZ 42759 3504 5 not not RB 42759 3504 6 regard regard VB 42759 3504 7 the the DT 42759 3504 8 business business NN 42759 3504 9 function function NN 42759 3504 10 of of IN 42759 3504 11 such such JJ 42759 3504 12 men man NNS 42759 3504 13 as as IN 42759 3504 14 economically economically RB 42759 3504 15 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 3504 16 . . . 42759 3505 1 Rather rather RB 42759 3505 2 than than IN 42759 3505 3 pay pay VB 42759 3505 4 the the DT 42759 3505 5 higher high JJR 42759 3505 6 prices price NNS 42759 3505 7 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3505 8 to to TO 42759 3505 9 provide provide VB 42759 3505 10 living living NN 42759 3505 11 profits profit NNS 42759 3505 12 for for IN 42759 3505 13 the the DT 42759 3505 14 inefficient inefficient JJ 42759 3505 15 business business NN 42759 3505 16 men man NNS 42759 3505 17 , , , 42759 3505 18 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3505 19 will will MD 42759 3505 20 transfer transfer VB 42759 3505 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3505 22 patronage patronage NN 42759 3505 23 to to IN 42759 3505 24 the the DT 42759 3505 25 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3505 26 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3505 27 . . . 42759 3506 1 Should Should MD 42759 3506 2 the the DT 42759 3506 3 retail retail JJ 42759 3506 4 grocer grocer NN 42759 3506 5 , , , 42759 3506 6 for for IN 42759 3506 7 example example NN 42759 3506 8 , , , 42759 3506 9 raise raise VB 42759 3506 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3506 11 prices price NNS 42759 3506 12 in in IN 42759 3506 13 the the DT 42759 3506 14 effort effort NN 42759 3506 15 to to TO 42759 3506 16 get get VB 42759 3506 17 living living NN 42759 3506 18 profits profit NNS 42759 3506 19 , , , 42759 3506 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3506 21 sales sale NNS 42759 3506 22 would would MD 42759 3506 23 fall fall VB 42759 3506 24 off off RP 42759 3506 25 to to IN 42759 3506 26 such such PDT 42759 3506 27 an an DT 42759 3506 28 extent extent NN 42759 3506 29 as as IN 42759 3506 30 to to TO 42759 3506 31 reduce reduce VB 42759 3506 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3506 33 profits profit NNS 42759 3506 34 still still RB 42759 3506 35 lower low JJR 42759 3506 36 . . . 42759 3507 1 While while IN 42759 3507 2 the the DT 42759 3507 3 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3507 4 may may MD 42759 3507 5 be be VB 42759 3507 6 willing willing JJ 42759 3507 7 to to TO 42759 3507 8 fulfil fulfil VB 42759 3507 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3507 10 obligation obligation NN 42759 3507 11 of of IN 42759 3507 12 furnishing furnish VBG 42759 3507 13 living living NN 42759 3507 14 profits profit NNS 42759 3507 15 for for IN 42759 3507 16 all all DT 42759 3507 17 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3507 18 grocers grocer NNS 42759 3507 19 , , , 42759 3507 20 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3507 21 are be VBP 42759 3507 22 not not RB 42759 3507 23 willing willing JJ 42759 3507 24 , , , 42759 3507 25 nor nor CC 42759 3507 26 are be VBP 42759 3507 27 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3507 28 morally morally RB 42759 3507 29 bound bind VBN 42759 3507 30 , , , 42759 3507 31 to to TO 42759 3507 32 do do VB 42759 3507 33 so so RB 42759 3507 34 in in IN 42759 3507 35 the the DT 42759 3507 36 case case NN 42759 3507 37 of of IN 42759 3507 38 grocers grocer NNS 42759 3507 39 whose whose WP$ 42759 3507 40 inability inability NN 42759 3507 41 to to TO 42759 3507 42 command command VB 42759 3507 43 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3507 44 patronage patronage NN 42759 3507 45 at at IN 42759 3507 46 remunerative remunerative JJ 42759 3507 47 prices price NNS 42759 3507 48 shows show VBZ 42759 3507 49 that that IN 42759 3507 50 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3507 51 are be VBP 42759 3507 52 not not RB 42759 3507 53 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3507 54 to to IN 42759 3507 55 the the DT 42759 3507 56 community community NN 42759 3507 57 . . . 42759 3508 1 The the DT 42759 3508 2 consuming consume VBG 42759 3508 3 public public NN 42759 3508 4 does do VBZ 42759 3508 5 not not RB 42759 3508 6 want want VB 42759 3508 7 to to TO 42759 3508 8 employ employ VB 42759 3508 9 such such JJ 42759 3508 10 business business NN 42759 3508 11 men man NNS 42759 3508 12 at at IN 42759 3508 13 such such PDT 42759 3508 14 a a DT 42759 3508 15 cost cost NN 42759 3508 16 . . . 42759 3509 1 Nor nor CC 42759 3509 2 is be VBZ 42759 3509 3 the the DT 42759 3509 4 State State NNP 42759 3509 5 under under IN 42759 3509 6 obligation obligation NN 42759 3509 7 to to TO 42759 3509 8 ensure ensure VB 42759 3509 9 living living NN 42759 3509 10 profits profit NNS 42759 3509 11 for for IN 42759 3509 12 all all DT 42759 3509 13 business business NN 42759 3509 14 men man NNS 42759 3509 15 . . . 42759 3510 1 To to TO 42759 3510 2 carry carry VB 42759 3510 3 out out RP 42759 3510 4 such such JJ 42759 3510 5 a a DT 42759 3510 6 policy policy NN 42759 3510 7 , , , 42759 3510 8 either either CC 42759 3510 9 by by IN 42759 3510 10 enforcing enforce VBG 42759 3510 11 a a DT 42759 3510 12 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3510 13 high high JJ 42759 3510 14 level level NN 42759 3510 15 of of IN 42759 3510 16 prices price NNS 42759 3510 17 , , , 42759 3510 18 or or CC 42759 3510 19 by by IN 42759 3510 20 subsidising subsidise VBG 42759 3510 21 those those DT 42759 3510 22 who who WP 42759 3510 23 fail fail VBP 42759 3510 24 to to TO 42759 3510 25 obtain obtain VB 42759 3510 26 living living NN 42759 3510 27 profits profit NNS 42759 3510 28 , , , 42759 3510 29 would would MD 42759 3510 30 be be VB 42759 3510 31 to to TO 42759 3510 32 compel compel VB 42759 3510 33 the the DT 42759 3510 34 public public NN 42759 3510 35 to to TO 42759 3510 36 support support VB 42759 3510 37 inefficiency inefficiency NN 42759 3510 38 . . . 42759 3511 1 In in IN 42759 3511 2 the the DT 42759 3511 3 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 3511 4 paragraphs paragraph NNS 42759 3511 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3511 6 have have VBP 42759 3511 7 assumed assume VBN 42759 3511 8 that that IN 42759 3511 9 the the DT 42759 3511 10 inability inability NN 42759 3511 11 of of IN 42759 3511 12 the the DT 42759 3511 13 business business NN 42759 3511 14 men man NNS 42759 3511 15 under under IN 42759 3511 16 consideration consideration NN 42759 3511 17 to to TO 42759 3511 18 get get VB 42759 3511 19 living living NN 42759 3511 20 profits profit NNS 42759 3511 21 is be VBZ 42759 3511 22 due due JJ 42759 3511 23 to to IN 42759 3511 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3511 25 own own JJ 42759 3511 26 lack lack NN 42759 3511 27 of of IN 42759 3511 28 capacity capacity NN 42759 3511 29 as as IN 42759 3511 30 compared compare VBN 42759 3511 31 with with IN 42759 3511 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3511 33 more more RBR 42759 3511 34 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3511 35 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3511 36 . . . 42759 3512 1 When when WRB 42759 3512 2 , , , 42759 3512 3 however however RB 42759 3512 4 , , , 42759 3512 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3512 6 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3512 7 are be VBP 42759 3512 8 not not RB 42759 3512 9 more more RBR 42759 3512 10 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3512 11 , , , 42759 3512 12 but but CC 42759 3512 13 are be VBP 42759 3512 14 enabled enable VBN 42759 3512 15 to to TO 42759 3512 16 undersell undersell VB 42759 3512 17 through through IN 42759 3512 18 the the DT 42759 3512 19 use use NN 42759 3512 20 of of IN 42759 3512 21 unfair unfair JJ 42759 3512 22 methods method NNS 42759 3512 23 , , , 42759 3512 24 such such JJ 42759 3512 25 as as IN 42759 3512 26 adulteration adulteration NN 42759 3512 27 of of IN 42759 3512 28 goods good NNS 42759 3512 29 and and CC 42759 3512 30 oppression oppression NN 42759 3512 31 of of IN 42759 3512 32 labour labour NN 42759 3512 33 , , , 42759 3512 34 a a DT 42759 3512 35 different different JJ 42759 3512 36 moral moral JJ 42759 3512 37 situation situation NN 42759 3512 38 is be VBZ 42759 3512 39 presented present VBN 42759 3512 40 . . . 42759 3513 1 Honest honest JJ 42759 3513 2 and and CC 42759 3513 3 humane humane JJ 42759 3513 4 business business NN 42759 3513 5 men man NNS 42759 3513 6 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 3513 7 have have VBP 42759 3513 8 a a DT 42759 3513 9 claim claim NN 42759 3513 10 upon upon IN 42759 3513 11 society society NN 42759 3513 12 to to IN 42759 3513 13 protection protection NN 42759 3513 14 against against IN 42759 3513 15 such such JJ 42759 3513 16 unfair unfair JJ 42759 3513 17 competition competition NN 42759 3513 18 . . . 42759 3514 1 And and CC 42759 3514 2 the the DT 42759 3514 3 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3514 4 are be VBP 42759 3514 5 under under IN 42759 3514 6 obligation obligation NN 42759 3514 7 to to TO 42759 3514 8 make make VB 42759 3514 9 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3514 10 efforts effort NNS 42759 3514 11 to to TO 42759 3514 12 withhold withhold VB 42759 3514 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3514 14 patronage patronage NN 42759 3514 15 from from IN 42759 3514 16 those those DT 42759 3514 17 business business NN 42759 3514 18 men man NNS 42759 3514 19 who who WP 42759 3514 20 practise practise VBP 42759 3514 21 dishonesty dishonesty NN 42759 3514 22 and and CC 42759 3514 23 extortion extortion NN 42759 3514 24 . . . 42759 3515 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3515 2 The the DT 42759 3515 3 Question Question NNP 42759 3515 4 of of IN 42759 3515 5 Superfluous Superfluous NNP 42759 3515 6 Business Business NNP 42759 3515 7 Men Men NNPS 42759 3515 8 _ _ NNP 42759 3515 9 Although although IN 42759 3515 10 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3515 11 have have VBP 42759 3515 12 rejected reject VBN 42759 3515 13 as as RB 42759 3515 14 impractical impractical JJ 42759 3515 15 the the DT 42759 3515 16 proposal proposal NN 42759 3515 17 to to TO 42759 3515 18 set set VB 42759 3515 19 a a DT 42759 3515 20 legal legal JJ 42759 3515 21 limit limit NN 42759 3515 22 to to IN 42759 3515 23 profit profit NN 42759 3515 24 - - HYPH 42759 3515 25 incomes income NNS 42759 3515 26 , , , 42759 3515 27 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3515 28 have have VBP 42759 3515 29 to to TO 42759 3515 30 admit admit VB 42759 3515 31 that that IN 42759 3515 32 many many JJ 42759 3515 33 of of IN 42759 3515 34 the the DT 42759 3515 35 abler abler NN 42759 3515 36 business business NN 42759 3515 37 men man NNS 42759 3515 38 would would MD 42759 3515 39 continue continue VB 42759 3515 40 to to TO 42759 3515 41 do do VB 42759 3515 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3515 43 best good JJS 42759 3515 44 work work NN 42759 3515 45 even even RB 42759 3515 46 if if IN 42759 3515 47 the the DT 42759 3515 48 profits profit NNS 42759 3515 49 that that IN 42759 3515 50 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3515 51 could could MD 42759 3515 52 hope hope VB 42759 3515 53 to to TO 42759 3515 54 obtain obtain VB 42759 3515 55 were be VBD 42759 3515 56 considerably considerably RB 42759 3515 57 smaller small JJR 42759 3515 58 in in IN 42759 3515 59 volume volume NN 42759 3515 60 . . . 42759 3516 1 These these DT 42759 3516 2 men man NNS 42759 3516 3 hold hold VBP 42759 3516 4 a a DT 42759 3516 5 strategic strategic JJ 42759 3516 6 position position NN 42759 3516 7 in in IN 42759 3516 8 industry industry NN 42759 3516 9 , , , 42759 3516 10 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 3516 11 as as IN 42759 3516 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3516 13 are be VBP 42759 3516 14 not not RB 42759 3516 15 subject subject JJ 42759 3516 16 to to IN 42759 3516 17 the the DT 42759 3516 18 same same JJ 42759 3516 19 degree degree NN 42759 3516 20 of of IN 42759 3516 21 constant constant JJ 42759 3516 22 competition competition NN 42759 3516 23 as as IN 42759 3516 24 the the DT 42759 3516 25 other other JJ 42759 3516 26 agents agent NNS 42759 3516 27 of of IN 42759 3516 28 production production NN 42759 3516 29 . . . 42759 3517 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3517 2 164 164 CD 42759 3517 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3517 4 Were be VBD 42759 3517 5 the the DT 42759 3517 6 supply supply NN 42759 3517 7 of of IN 42759 3517 8 superior superior JJ 42759 3517 9 business business NN 42759 3517 10 capacity capacity NN 42759 3517 11 more more RBR 42759 3517 12 plentiful plentiful JJ 42759 3517 13 , , , 42759 3517 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3517 15 rewards reward NNS 42759 3517 16 would would MD 42759 3517 17 be be VB 42759 3517 18 automatically automatically RB 42759 3517 19 reduced reduce VBN 42759 3517 20 , , , 42759 3517 21 and and CC 42759 3517 22 the the DT 42759 3517 23 burden burden NN 42759 3517 24 of of IN 42759 3517 25 profits profit NNS 42759 3517 26 resting rest VBG 42759 3517 27 upon upon IN 42759 3517 28 society society NN 42759 3517 29 would would MD 42759 3517 30 be be VB 42759 3517 31 to to IN 42759 3517 32 that that DT 42759 3517 33 extent extent NN 42759 3517 34 diminished diminish VBN 42759 3517 35 . . . 42759 3518 1 On on IN 42759 3518 2 the the DT 42759 3518 3 other other JJ 42759 3518 4 hand hand NN 42759 3518 5 , , , 42759 3518 6 the the DT 42759 3518 7 number number NN 42759 3518 8 of of IN 42759 3518 9 mediocre mediocre JJ 42759 3518 10 business business NN 42759 3518 11 men man NNS 42759 3518 12 , , , 42759 3518 13 especially especially RB 42759 3518 14 in in IN 42759 3518 15 the the DT 42759 3518 16 distributive distributive JJ 42759 3518 17 industries industry NNS 42759 3518 18 , , , 42759 3518 19 is be VBZ 42759 3518 20 much much RB 42759 3518 21 larger large JJR 42759 3518 22 than than IN 42759 3518 23 is be VBZ 42759 3518 24 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3518 25 to to TO 42759 3518 26 supply supply VB 42759 3518 27 the the DT 42759 3518 28 wants want NNS 42759 3518 29 of of IN 42759 3518 30 the the DT 42759 3518 31 community community NN 42759 3518 32 . . . 42759 3519 1 This this DT 42759 3519 2 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 3519 3 a a DT 42759 3519 4 second second JJ 42759 3519 5 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 3519 6 volume volume NN 42759 3519 7 of of IN 42759 3519 8 payments payment NNS 42759 3519 9 under under IN 42759 3519 10 the the DT 42759 3519 11 head head NN 42759 3519 12 of of IN 42759 3519 13 profits profit NNS 42759 3519 14 . . . 42759 3520 1 Is be VBZ 42759 3520 2 there there EX 42759 3520 3 no no DT 42759 3520 4 way way NN 42759 3520 5 by by IN 42759 3520 6 which which WDT 42759 3520 7 these these DT 42759 3520 8 wastes waste NNS 42759 3520 9 can can MD 42759 3520 10 be be VB 42759 3520 11 reduced reduce VBN 42759 3520 12 ? ? . 42759 3521 1 The the DT 42759 3521 2 volume volume NN 42759 3521 3 of of IN 42759 3521 4 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3521 5 large large JJ 42759 3521 6 profits profit NNS 42759 3521 7 could could MD 42759 3521 8 be be VB 42759 3521 9 diminished diminish VBN 42759 3521 10 by by IN 42759 3521 11 an an DT 42759 3521 12 extension extension NN 42759 3521 13 of of IN 42759 3521 14 the the DT 42759 3521 15 facilities facility NNS 42759 3521 16 of of IN 42759 3521 17 technical technical JJ 42759 3521 18 and and CC 42759 3521 19 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3521 20 education education NN 42759 3521 21 . . . 42759 3522 1 Thus thus RB 42759 3522 2 the the DT 42759 3522 3 number number NN 42759 3522 4 of of IN 42759 3522 5 persons person NNS 42759 3522 6 qualifying qualify VBG 42759 3522 7 as as IN 42759 3522 8 superior superior JJ 42759 3522 9 business business NN 42759 3522 10 men man NNS 42759 3522 11 could could MD 42759 3522 12 be be VB 42759 3522 13 gradually gradually RB 42759 3522 14 increased increase VBN 42759 3522 15 , , , 42759 3522 16 competition competition NN 42759 3522 17 among among IN 42759 3522 18 this this DT 42759 3522 19 class class NN 42759 3522 20 of of IN 42759 3522 21 men man NNS 42759 3522 22 would would MD 42759 3522 23 be be VB 42759 3522 24 intensified intensify VBN 42759 3522 25 , , , 42759 3522 26 and and CC 42759 3522 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3522 28 rewards reward NNS 42759 3522 29 correspondingly correspondingly RB 42759 3522 30 diminished diminish VBN 42759 3522 31 . . . 42759 3523 1 The the DT 42759 3523 2 profits profit NNS 42759 3523 3 that that WDT 42759 3523 4 go go VBP 42759 3523 5 to to IN 42759 3523 6 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 3523 7 business business NN 42759 3523 8 men man NNS 42759 3523 9 , , , 42759 3523 10 especially especially RB 42759 3523 11 in in IN 42759 3523 12 the the DT 42759 3523 13 class class NN 42759 3523 14 known know VBN 42759 3523 15 as as IN 42759 3523 16 middlemen middleman NNS 42759 3523 17 , , , 42759 3523 18 can can MD 42759 3523 19 be be VB 42759 3523 20 largely largely RB 42759 3523 21 eliminated eliminate VBN 42759 3523 22 through through IN 42759 3523 23 combination combination NN 42759 3523 24 and and CC 42759 3523 25 co co NN 42759 3523 26 - - NN 42759 3523 27 operation operation NN 42759 3523 28 . . . 42759 3524 1 The the DT 42759 3524 2 tendency tendency NN 42759 3524 3 to to TO 42759 3524 4 unite unite VB 42759 3524 5 into into IN 42759 3524 6 a a DT 42759 3524 7 single single JJ 42759 3524 8 concern concern NN 42759 3524 9 a a DT 42759 3524 10 large large JJ 42759 3524 11 number number NN 42759 3524 12 of of IN 42759 3524 13 small small JJ 42759 3524 14 and and CC 42759 3524 15 inefficient inefficient JJ 42759 3524 16 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3524 17 should should MD 42759 3524 18 be be VB 42759 3524 19 encouraged encourage VBN 42759 3524 20 up up RP 42759 3524 21 to to IN 42759 3524 22 the the DT 42759 3524 23 point point NN 42759 3524 24 at at IN 42759 3524 25 which which WDT 42759 3524 26 the the DT 42759 3524 27 combination combination NN 42759 3524 28 threatens threaten VBZ 42759 3524 29 to to TO 42759 3524 30 become become VB 42759 3524 31 a a DT 42759 3524 32 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3524 33 . . . 42759 3525 1 That that IN 42759 3525 2 this this DT 42759 3525 3 process process NN 42759 3525 4 is be VBZ 42759 3525 5 capable capable JJ 42759 3525 6 of of IN 42759 3525 7 effecting effect VBG 42759 3525 8 a a DT 42759 3525 9 considerable considerable JJ 42759 3525 10 saving saving NN 42759 3525 11 in in IN 42759 3525 12 business business NN 42759 3525 13 profits profit NNS 42759 3525 14 as as RB 42759 3525 15 well well RB 42759 3525 16 as as IN 42759 3525 17 in in IN 42759 3525 18 capital capital NN 42759 3525 19 , , , 42759 3525 20 has have VBZ 42759 3525 21 been be VBN 42759 3525 22 amply amply RB 42759 3525 23 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 42759 3525 24 in in IN 42759 3525 25 several several JJ 42759 3525 26 different different JJ 42759 3525 27 lines line NNS 42759 3525 28 of of IN 42759 3525 29 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3525 30 . . . 42759 3526 1 As as IN 42759 3526 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3526 3 have have VBP 42759 3526 4 seen see VBN 42759 3526 5 in in IN 42759 3526 6 a a DT 42759 3526 7 preceding precede VBG 42759 3526 8 chapter chapter NN 42759 3526 9 , , , 42759 3526 10 the the DT 42759 3526 11 co co JJ 42759 3526 12 - - JJ 42759 3526 13 operative operative JJ 42759 3526 14 movement movement NN 42759 3526 15 , , , 42759 3526 16 whether whether IN 42759 3526 17 in in IN 42759 3526 18 banking banking NN 42759 3526 19 , , , 42759 3526 20 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 3526 21 , , , 42759 3526 22 or or CC 42759 3526 23 stores store NNS 42759 3526 24 , , , 42759 3526 25 has have VBZ 42759 3526 26 been be VBN 42759 3526 27 distinctly distinctly RB 42759 3526 28 successful successful JJ 42759 3526 29 in in IN 42759 3526 30 reducing reduce VBG 42759 3526 31 profits profit NNS 42759 3526 32 . . . 42759 3527 1 Millions million NNS 42759 3527 2 of of IN 42759 3527 3 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3527 4 are be VBP 42759 3527 5 thus thus RB 42759 3527 6 diverted divert VBN 42759 3527 7 every every DT 42759 3527 8 year year NN 42759 3527 9 from from IN 42759 3527 10 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 3527 11 profit profit NN 42759 3527 12 - - HYPH 42759 3527 13 receivers receiver NNS 42759 3527 14 to to IN 42759 3527 15 labourers labourer NNS 42759 3527 16 , , , 42759 3527 17 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3527 18 , , , 42759 3527 19 and and CC 42759 3527 20 to to IN 42759 3527 21 the the DT 42759 3527 22 man man NN 42759 3527 23 of of IN 42759 3527 24 small small JJ 42759 3527 25 resources resource NNS 42759 3527 26 generally generally RB 42759 3527 27 . . . 42759 3528 1 Yet yet CC 42759 3528 2 the the DT 42759 3528 3 co co JJ 42759 3528 4 - - JJ 42759 3528 5 operative operative JJ 42759 3528 6 movement movement NN 42759 3528 7 is be VBZ 42759 3528 8 only only RB 42759 3528 9 in in IN 42759 3528 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3528 11 infancy infancy NN 42759 3528 12 . . . 42759 3529 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3529 2 contains contain VBZ 42759 3529 3 the the DT 42759 3529 4 possibility possibility NN 42759 3529 5 of of IN 42759 3529 6 eliminating eliminate VBG 42759 3529 7 entirely entirely RB 42759 3529 8 the the DT 42759 3529 9 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 3529 10 business business NN 42759 3529 11 man man NN 42759 3529 12 , , , 42759 3529 13 and and CC 42759 3529 14 even even RB 42759 3529 15 of of IN 42759 3529 16 diminishing diminish VBG 42759 3529 17 considerably considerably RB 42759 3529 18 the the DT 42759 3529 19 excessive excessive JJ 42759 3529 20 profits profit NNS 42759 3529 21 of of IN 42759 3529 22 the the DT 42759 3529 23 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3529 24 able able JJ 42759 3529 25 business business NN 42759 3529 26 man man NN 42759 3529 27 . . . 42759 3530 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 3530 2 : : : 42759 3530 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3530 4 163 163 CD 42759 3530 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3530 6 Cf Cf NNP 42759 3530 7 . . . 42759 3531 1 pp pp NNP 42759 3531 2 . . . 42759 3532 1 212 212 CD 42759 3532 2 , , , 42759 3532 3 213 213 CD 42759 3532 4 of of IN 42759 3532 5 Castelein Castelein NNP 42759 3532 6 's 's POS 42759 3532 7 " " `` 42759 3532 8 Philosophia Philosophia NNP 42759 3532 9 Moralis Moralis NNP 42759 3532 10 et et NNP 42759 3532 11 Socialis Socialis NNP 42759 3532 12 . . . 42759 3532 13 " " '' 42759 3533 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3533 2 164 164 CD 42759 3533 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3533 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 3533 5 . . . 42759 3534 1 Hobson Hobson NNP 42759 3534 2 , , , 42759 3534 3 " " `` 42759 3534 4 The the DT 42759 3534 5 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 3534 6 System System NNP 42759 3534 7 , , , 42759 3534 8 " " '' 42759 3534 9 chapter chapter NN 42759 3534 10 on on IN 42759 3534 11 " " `` 42759 3534 12 Ability ability NN 42759 3534 13 . . . 42759 3534 14 " " '' 42759 3535 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 3535 2 XVIII xviii VBP 42759 3535 3 THE the DT 42759 3535 4 MORAL moral JJ 42759 3535 5 ASPECT ASPECT NNS 42759 3535 6 OF of IN 42759 3535 7 MONOPOLY monopoly NN 42759 3535 8 The the DT 42759 3535 9 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 3535 10 was be VBD 42759 3535 11 drawn draw VBN 42759 3535 12 in in IN 42759 3535 13 the the DT 42759 3535 14 last last JJ 42759 3535 15 chapter chapter NN 42759 3535 16 that that IN 42759 3535 17 the the DT 42759 3535 18 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3535 19 gains gain NNS 42759 3535 20 of of IN 42759 3535 21 corporations corporation NNS 42759 3535 22 operating operate VBG 42759 3535 23 in in IN 42759 3535 24 conditions condition NNS 42759 3535 25 of of IN 42759 3535 26 competition competition NN 42759 3535 27 , , , 42759 3535 28 can can MD 42759 3535 29 justly justly RB 42759 3535 30 be be VB 42759 3535 31 retained retain VBN 42759 3535 32 by by IN 42759 3535 33 the the DT 42759 3535 34 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3535 35 as as IN 42759 3535 36 the the DT 42759 3535 37 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 3535 38 of of IN 42759 3535 39 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 3535 40 productive productive JJ 42759 3535 41 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3535 42 . . . 42759 3536 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3536 2 is be VBZ 42759 3536 3 , , , 42759 3536 4 of of IN 42759 3536 5 course course NN 42759 3536 6 , , , 42759 3536 7 to to TO 42759 3536 8 be be VB 42759 3536 9 understood understand VBN 42759 3536 10 that that IN 42759 3536 11 the the DT 42759 3536 12 proper proper JJ 42759 3536 13 allowance allowance NN 42759 3536 14 for for IN 42759 3536 15 interest interest NN 42759 3536 16 on on IN 42759 3536 17 the the DT 42759 3536 18 capital capital NN 42759 3536 19 is be VBZ 42759 3536 20 not not RB 42759 3536 21 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 3536 22 the the DT 42759 3536 23 amount amount NN 42759 3536 24 authorised authorise VBN 42759 3536 25 by by IN 42759 3536 26 the the DT 42759 3536 27 stipulated stipulate VBN 42759 3536 28 rate rate NN 42759 3536 29 of of IN 42759 3536 30 dividend dividend NN 42759 3536 31 on on IN 42759 3536 32 the the DT 42759 3536 33 stock stock NN 42759 3536 34 , , , 42759 3536 35 but but CC 42759 3536 36 the the DT 42759 3536 37 prevailing prevailing JJ 42759 3536 38 or or CC 42759 3536 39 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3536 40 rate rate NN 42759 3536 41 of of IN 42759 3536 42 interest interest NN 42759 3536 43 plus plus CC 42759 3536 44 an an DT 42759 3536 45 adequate adequate JJ 42759 3536 46 rate rate NN 42759 3536 47 of of IN 42759 3536 48 insurance insurance NN 42759 3536 49 against against IN 42759 3536 50 the the DT 42759 3536 51 risks risk NNS 42759 3536 52 of of IN 42759 3536 53 the the DT 42759 3536 54 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3536 55 . . . 42759 3537 1 If if IN 42759 3537 2 the the DT 42759 3537 3 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 3537 4 rate rate NN 42759 3537 5 of of IN 42759 3537 6 interest interest NN 42759 3537 7 is be VBZ 42759 3537 8 five five CD 42759 3537 9 per per IN 42759 3537 10 cent cent NN 42759 3537 11 . . . 42759 3537 12 , , , 42759 3537 13 and and CC 42759 3537 14 the the DT 42759 3537 15 risk risk NN 42759 3537 16 is be VBZ 42759 3537 17 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3537 18 protected protect VBN 42759 3537 19 by by IN 42759 3537 20 an an DT 42759 3537 21 allowance allowance NN 42759 3537 22 of of IN 42759 3537 23 one one CD 42759 3537 24 per per IN 42759 3537 25 cent cent NN 42759 3537 26 . . . 42759 3537 27 , , , 42759 3537 28 the the DT 42759 3537 29 fair fair JJ 42759 3537 30 rate rate NN 42759 3537 31 of of IN 42759 3537 32 return return NN 42759 3537 33 on on IN 42759 3537 34 the the DT 42759 3537 35 investment investment NN 42759 3537 36 is be VBZ 42759 3537 37 six six CD 42759 3537 38 per per IN 42759 3537 39 cent cent NN 42759 3537 40 . . . 42759 3538 1 The the DT 42759 3538 2 fact fact NN 42759 3538 3 that that IN 42759 3538 4 a a DT 42759 3538 5 concern concern NN 42759 3538 6 may may MD 42759 3538 7 actually actually RB 42759 3538 8 award award VB 42759 3538 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3538 10 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3538 11 ten ten CD 42759 3538 12 per per IN 42759 3538 13 cent cent NN 42759 3538 14 . . . 42759 3539 1 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3539 2 , , , 42759 3539 3 has have VBZ 42759 3539 4 no no DT 42759 3539 5 bearing bearing NN 42759 3539 6 on on IN 42759 3539 7 the the DT 42759 3539 8 determination determination NN 42759 3539 9 of of IN 42759 3539 10 the the DT 42759 3539 11 genuine genuine JJ 42759 3539 12 surplus surplus NN 42759 3539 13 . . . 42759 3540 1 If if IN 42759 3540 2 the the DT 42759 3540 3 actual actual JJ 42759 3540 4 surplus surplus NN 42759 3540 5 that that WDT 42759 3540 6 remains remain VBZ 42759 3540 7 after after IN 42759 3540 8 paying pay VBG 42759 3540 9 all all DT 42759 3540 10 other other JJ 42759 3540 11 charges charge NNS 42759 3540 12 and and CC 42759 3540 13 allowing allow VBG 42759 3540 14 ten ten CD 42759 3540 15 per per IN 42759 3540 16 cent cent NN 42759 3540 17 . . . 42759 3541 1 on on IN 42759 3541 2 the the DT 42759 3541 3 stock stock NN 42759 3541 4 , , , 42759 3541 5 is be VBZ 42759 3541 6 only only RB 42759 3541 7 50,000 50,000 CD 42759 3541 8 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3541 9 , , , 42759 3541 10 whereas whereas IN 42759 3541 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3541 12 would would MD 42759 3541 13 be be VB 42759 3541 14 100,000 100,000 CD 42759 3541 15 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3541 16 with with IN 42759 3541 17 an an DT 42759 3541 18 allowance allowance NN 42759 3541 19 of of IN 42759 3541 20 only only RB 42759 3541 21 six six CD 42759 3541 22 per per IN 42759 3541 23 cent cent NN 42759 3541 24 . . . 42759 3541 25 , , , 42759 3541 26 then then RB 42759 3541 27 the the DT 42759 3541 28 true true JJ 42759 3541 29 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3541 30 gains gain NNS 42759 3541 31 , , , 42759 3541 32 or or CC 42759 3541 33 profits profit NNS 42759 3541 34 , , , 42759 3541 35 are be VBP 42759 3541 36 the the DT 42759 3541 37 latter latter JJ 42759 3541 38 amount amount NN 42759 3541 39 not not RB 42759 3541 40 the the DT 42759 3541 41 former former JJ 42759 3541 42 . . . 42759 3542 1 No no DT 42759 3542 2 part part NN 42759 3542 3 of of IN 42759 3542 4 the the DT 42759 3542 5 100,000 100,000 CD 42759 3542 6 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3542 7 can can MD 42759 3542 8 be be VB 42759 3542 9 justified justify VBN 42759 3542 10 as as IN 42759 3542 11 interest interest NN 42759 3542 12 on on IN 42759 3542 13 capital capital NN 42759 3542 14 . . . 42759 3543 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3543 2 must must MD 42759 3543 3 all all DT 42759 3543 4 find find VB 42759 3543 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3543 6 justification justification NN 42759 3543 7 as as IN 42759 3543 8 profits profit NNS 42759 3543 9 proceeding proceed VBG 42759 3543 10 from from IN 42759 3543 11 superior superior JJ 42759 3543 12 productivity productivity NN 42759 3543 13 . . . 42759 3544 1 Bearing bear VBG 42759 3544 2 in in IN 42759 3544 3 mind mind NN 42759 3544 4 this this DT 42759 3544 5 distinction distinction NN 42759 3544 6 between between IN 42759 3544 7 the the DT 42759 3544 8 actual actual JJ 42759 3544 9 rate rate NN 42759 3544 10 of of IN 42759 3544 11 dividend dividend NN 42759 3544 12 and and CC 42759 3544 13 the the DT 42759 3544 14 proper proper JJ 42759 3544 15 allowance allowance NN 42759 3544 16 for for IN 42759 3544 17 interest interest NN 42759 3544 18 on on IN 42759 3544 19 capital capital NN 42759 3544 20 , , , 42759 3544 21 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3544 22 take take VBP 42759 3544 23 up up RP 42759 3544 24 the the DT 42759 3544 25 question question NN 42759 3544 26 of of IN 42759 3544 27 the the DT 42759 3544 28 morality morality NN 42759 3544 29 of of IN 42759 3544 30 profits profit NNS 42759 3544 31 or or CC 42759 3544 32 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3544 33 gains gain NNS 42759 3544 34 in in IN 42759 3544 35 conditions condition NNS 42759 3544 36 of of IN 42759 3544 37 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3544 38 . . . 42759 3545 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3545 2 Surplus Surplus NNP 42759 3545 3 and and CC 42759 3545 4 Excessive Excessive NNP 42759 3545 5 Profits profit NNS 42759 3545 6 _ _ IN 42759 3545 7 Several Several NNP 42759 3545 8 of of IN 42759 3545 9 the the DT 42759 3545 10 great great JJ 42759 3545 11 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3545 12 combinations combination NNS 42759 3545 13 of of IN 42759 3545 14 the the DT 42759 3545 15 United United NNP 42759 3545 16 States States NNP 42759 3545 17 have have VBP 42759 3545 18 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3545 19 profits profit NNS 42759 3545 20 which which WDT 42759 3545 21 are be VBP 42759 3545 22 commonly commonly RB 42759 3545 23 stigmatised stigmatise VBN 42759 3545 24 as as IN 42759 3545 25 " " `` 42759 3545 26 excessive excessive JJ 42759 3545 27 . . . 42759 3545 28 " " '' 42759 3546 1 For for IN 42759 3546 2 example example NN 42759 3546 3 , , , 42759 3546 4 the the DT 42759 3546 5 Standard Standard NNP 42759 3546 6 Oil Oil NNP 42759 3546 7 Company Company NNP 42759 3546 8 paid pay VBD 42759 3546 9 , , , 42759 3546 10 from from IN 42759 3546 11 1882 1882 CD 42759 3546 12 to to IN 42759 3546 13 1906 1906 CD 42759 3546 14 , , , 42759 3546 15 an an DT 42759 3546 16 average average JJ 42759 3546 17 annual annual JJ 42759 3546 18 dividend dividend NN 42759 3546 19 of of IN 42759 3546 20 24.15 24.15 CD 42759 3546 21 per per NN 42759 3546 22 cent cent NN 42759 3546 23 . . . 42759 3547 1 on on IN 42759 3547 2 the the DT 42759 3547 3 capital capital NN 42759 3547 4 stock stock NN 42759 3547 5 , , , 42759 3547 6 and and CC 42759 3547 7 had have VBD 42759 3547 8 profits profit NNS 42759 3547 9 in in IN 42759 3547 10 addition addition NN 42759 3547 11 at at IN 42759 3547 12 the the DT 42759 3547 13 rate rate NN 42759 3547 14 of of IN 42759 3547 15 about about RB 42759 3547 16 8 8 CD 42759 3547 17 per per NN 42759 3547 18 cent cent NN 42759 3547 19 . . . 42759 3548 1 annually;[165 annually;[165 LS 42759 3548 2 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3548 3 from from IN 42759 3548 4 1904 1904 CD 42759 3548 5 to to IN 42759 3548 6 1908 1908 CD 42759 3548 7 the the DT 42759 3548 8 American American NNP 42759 3548 9 Tobacco Tobacco NNP 42759 3548 10 Company Company NNP 42759 3548 11 averaged average VBD 42759 3548 12 19 19 CD 42759 3548 13 per per IN 42759 3548 14 cent cent NN 42759 3548 15 . . . 42759 3549 1 on on IN 42759 3549 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3549 3 actual actual JJ 42759 3549 4 investment;[166 investment;[166 CD 42759 3549 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3549 6 and and CC 42759 3549 7 the the DT 42759 3549 8 United United NNP 42759 3549 9 States States NNP 42759 3549 10 Steel Steel NNP 42759 3549 11 Corporation Corporation NNP 42759 3549 12 obtained obtain VBD 42759 3549 13 an an DT 42759 3549 14 average average JJ 42759 3549 15 annual annual JJ 42759 3549 16 return return NN 42759 3549 17 of of IN 42759 3549 18 12 12 CD 42759 3549 19 per per NN 42759 3549 20 cent cent NN 42759 3549 21 . . . 42759 3550 1 on on IN 42759 3550 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3550 3 investment investment NN 42759 3550 4 from from IN 42759 3550 5 1901 1901 CD 42759 3550 6 to to IN 42759 3550 7 1910 1910 CD 42759 3550 8 . . . 42759 3551 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3551 2 167 167 CD 42759 3551 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3551 4 A a DT 42759 3551 5 complete complete JJ 42759 3551 6 list list NN 42759 3551 7 of of IN 42759 3551 8 the the DT 42759 3551 9 American american JJ 42759 3551 10 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3551 11 that that WDT 42759 3551 12 have have VBP 42759 3551 13 reaped reap VBN 42759 3551 14 more more JJR 42759 3551 15 than than IN 42759 3551 16 the the DT 42759 3551 17 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3551 18 rate rate NN 42759 3551 19 of of IN 42759 3551 20 return return NN 42759 3551 21 on on IN 42759 3551 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3551 23 capital capital NN 42759 3551 24 would would MD 42759 3551 25 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 3551 26 be be VB 42759 3551 27 a a DT 42759 3551 28 very very RB 42759 3551 29 long long JJ 42759 3551 30 one one CD 42759 3551 31 . . . 42759 3552 1 Is be VBZ 42759 3552 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3552 3 possible possible JJ 42759 3552 4 to to TO 42759 3552 5 justify justify VB 42759 3552 6 such such JJ 42759 3552 7 returns return NNS 42759 3552 8 ? ? . 42759 3553 1 Has have VBZ 42759 3553 2 a a DT 42759 3553 3 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3553 4 a a DT 42759 3553 5 right right NN 42759 3553 6 to to TO 42759 3553 7 take take VB 42759 3553 8 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3553 9 gains gain NNS 42759 3553 10 ? ? . 42759 3554 1 Let let VB 42759 3554 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3554 3 suppose suppose VB 42759 3554 4 a a DT 42759 3554 5 concern concern NN 42759 3554 6 which which WDT 42759 3554 7 is be VBZ 42759 3554 8 getting get VBG 42759 3554 9 15 15 CD 42759 3554 10 per per NN 42759 3554 11 cent cent NN 42759 3554 12 . . . 42759 3555 1 on on IN 42759 3555 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3555 3 investment investment NN 42759 3555 4 . . . 42759 3556 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 3556 2 as as IN 42759 3556 3 the the DT 42759 3556 4 risks risk NNS 42759 3556 5 are be VBP 42759 3556 6 smaller small JJR 42759 3556 7 than than IN 42759 3556 8 in in IN 42759 3556 9 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3556 10 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3556 11 , , , 42759 3556 12 six six CD 42759 3556 13 per per IN 42759 3556 14 cent cent NN 42759 3556 15 . . . 42759 3557 1 is be VBZ 42759 3557 2 an an DT 42759 3557 3 ample ample JJ 42759 3557 4 allowance allowance NN 42759 3557 5 for for IN 42759 3557 6 interest interest NN 42759 3557 7 . . . 42759 3558 1 Of of IN 42759 3558 2 the the DT 42759 3558 3 remaining remain VBG 42759 3558 4 9 9 CD 42759 3558 5 per per NN 42759 3558 6 cent cent NN 42759 3558 7 . . . 42759 3558 8 , , , 42759 3558 9 4 4 CD 42759 3558 10 per per NN 42759 3558 11 cent cent NN 42759 3558 12 . . . 42759 3558 13 , , , 42759 3558 14 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3558 15 shall shall MD 42759 3558 16 assume assume VB 42759 3558 17 , , , 42759 3558 18 is be VBZ 42759 3558 19 derived derive VBN 42759 3558 20 from from IN 42759 3558 21 economies economy NNS 42759 3558 22 of of IN 42759 3558 23 production production NN 42759 3558 24 as as IN 42759 3558 25 compared compare VBN 42759 3558 26 with with IN 42759 3558 27 the the DT 42759 3558 28 great great JJ 42759 3558 29 majority majority NN 42759 3558 30 of of IN 42759 3558 31 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3558 32 concerns concern NNS 42759 3558 33 . . . 42759 3559 1 This this DT 42759 3559 2 portion portion NN 42759 3559 3 of of IN 42759 3559 4 the the DT 42759 3559 5 surplus surplus NN 42759 3559 6 , , , 42759 3559 7 being be VBG 42759 3559 8 the the DT 42759 3559 9 reward reward NN 42759 3559 10 of of IN 42759 3559 11 superior superior JJ 42759 3559 12 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3559 13 , , , 42759 3559 14 may may MD 42759 3559 15 be be VB 42759 3559 16 retained retain VBN 42759 3559 17 by by IN 42759 3559 18 the the DT 42759 3559 19 owners owner NNS 42759 3559 20 of of IN 42759 3559 21 the the DT 42759 3559 22 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3559 23 quite quite RB 42759 3559 24 as as RB 42759 3559 25 justly justly RB 42759 3559 26 as as IN 42759 3559 27 similar similar JJ 42759 3559 28 gains gain NNS 42759 3559 29 are be VBP 42759 3559 30 taken take VBN 42759 3559 31 by by IN 42759 3559 32 the the DT 42759 3559 33 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3559 34 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3559 35 corporation corporation NN 42759 3559 36 in in IN 42759 3559 37 conditions condition NNS 42759 3559 38 of of IN 42759 3559 39 competition competition NN 42759 3559 40 . . . 42759 3560 1 The the DT 42759 3560 2 objection objection NN 42759 3560 3 that that WDT 42759 3560 4 the the DT 42759 3560 5 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3560 6 ought ought MD 42759 3560 7 to to TO 42759 3560 8 share share VB 42759 3560 9 these these DT 42759 3560 10 gains gain NNS 42759 3560 11 with with IN 42759 3560 12 the the DT 42759 3560 13 public public NN 42759 3560 14 , , , 42759 3560 15 since since IN 42759 3560 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3560 17 limits limit VBZ 42759 3560 18 individual individual JJ 42759 3560 19 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 3560 20 in in IN 42759 3560 21 a a DT 42759 3560 22 socially socially RB 42759 3560 23 undesirable undesirable JJ 42759 3560 24 way way NN 42759 3560 25 , , , 42759 3560 26 has have VBZ 42759 3560 27 some some DT 42759 3560 28 merit merit NN 42759 3560 29 , , , 42759 3560 30 but but CC 42759 3560 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3560 32 can can MD 42759 3560 33 scarcely scarcely RB 42759 3560 34 be be VB 42759 3560 35 urged urge VBN 42759 3560 36 on on IN 42759 3560 37 grounds ground NNS 42759 3560 38 of of IN 42759 3560 39 strict strict JJ 42759 3560 40 justice justice NN 42759 3560 41 . . . 42759 3561 1 At at IN 42759 3561 2 most most RBS 42759 3561 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3561 4 points point VBZ 42759 3561 5 only only RB 42759 3561 6 to to IN 42759 3561 7 an an DT 42759 3561 8 obligation obligation NN 42759 3561 9 in in IN 42759 3561 10 equity equity NN 42759 3561 11 . . . 42759 3562 1 By by IN 42759 3562 2 what what WDT 42759 3562 3 canon canon NN 42759 3562 4 of of IN 42759 3562 5 distribution distribution NN 42759 3562 6 can can MD 42759 3562 7 the the DT 42759 3562 8 retention retention NN 42759 3562 9 of of IN 42759 3562 10 the the DT 42759 3562 11 other other JJ 42759 3562 12 5 5 CD 42759 3562 13 per per NN 42759 3562 14 cent cent NN 42759 3562 15 . . . 42759 3563 1 of of IN 42759 3563 2 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3563 3 gain gain NN 42759 3563 4 be be VB 42759 3563 5 justified justify VBN 42759 3563 6 ? ? . 42759 3564 1 Not not RB 42759 3564 2 by by IN 42759 3564 3 the the DT 42759 3564 4 titles title NNS 42759 3564 5 of of IN 42759 3564 6 needs need NNS 42759 3564 7 and and CC 42759 3564 8 efforts effort NNS 42759 3564 9 , , , 42759 3564 10 for for IN 42759 3564 11 these these DT 42759 3564 12 have have VBP 42759 3564 13 already already RB 42759 3564 14 been be VBN 42759 3564 15 satisfied satisfied JJ 42759 3564 16 through through IN 42759 3564 17 the the DT 42759 3564 18 salaries salary NNS 42759 3564 19 paid pay VBN 42759 3564 20 to to IN 42759 3564 21 those those DT 42759 3564 22 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3564 23 who who WP 42759 3564 24 perform perform VBP 42759 3564 25 labour labour NN 42759 3564 26 in in IN 42759 3564 27 the the DT 42759 3564 28 management management NN 42759 3564 29 of of IN 42759 3564 30 the the DT 42759 3564 31 concern concern NN 42759 3564 32 . . . 42759 3565 1 These these DT 42759 3565 2 titles title NNS 42759 3565 3 afford afford VBP 42759 3565 4 no no DT 42759 3565 5 basis basis NN 42759 3565 6 for for IN 42759 3565 7 any any DT 42759 3565 8 other other JJ 42759 3565 9 claim claim NN 42759 3565 10 than than IN 42759 3565 11 that that DT 42759 3565 12 which which WDT 42759 3565 13 proceeds proceed VBZ 42759 3565 14 from from IN 42759 3565 15 labour labour NN 42759 3565 16 . . . 42759 3566 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3566 2 can can MD 42759 3566 3 not not RB 42759 3566 4 be be VB 42759 3566 5 made make VBN 42759 3566 6 to to TO 42759 3566 7 justify justify VB 42759 3566 8 claims claim NNS 42759 3566 9 made make VBN 42759 3566 10 on on IN 42759 3566 11 behalf behalf NN 42759 3566 12 of of IN 42759 3566 13 capital capital NN 42759 3566 14 . . . 42759 3567 1 Not not RB 42759 3567 2 by by IN 42759 3567 3 the the DT 42759 3567 4 title title NN 42759 3567 5 of of IN 42759 3567 6 productivity productivity NN 42759 3567 7 , , , 42759 3567 8 for for IN 42759 3567 9 this this DT 42759 3567 10 has have VBZ 42759 3567 11 already already RB 42759 3567 12 been be VBN 42759 3567 13 remunerated remunerate VBN 42759 3567 14 in in IN 42759 3567 15 the the DT 42759 3567 16 4 4 CD 42759 3567 17 per per NN 42759 3567 18 cent cent NN 42759 3567 19 . . . 42759 3568 1 just just RB 42759 3568 2 considered consider VBN 42759 3568 3 . . . 42759 3569 1 Not not RB 42759 3569 2 as as IN 42759 3569 3 interest interest NN 42759 3569 4 on on IN 42759 3569 5 capital capital NN 42759 3569 6 , , , 42759 3569 7 for for IN 42759 3569 8 ample ample JJ 42759 3569 9 allowance allowance NN 42759 3569 10 has have VBZ 42759 3569 11 already already RB 42759 3569 12 been be VBN 42759 3569 13 made make VBN 42759 3569 14 under under IN 42759 3569 15 this this DT 42759 3569 16 head head NN 42759 3569 17 in in IN 42759 3569 18 the the DT 42759 3569 19 original original JJ 42759 3569 20 6 6 CD 42759 3569 21 per per NN 42759 3569 22 cent cent NN 42759 3569 23 . . . 42759 3570 1 As as IN 42759 3570 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3570 3 have have VBP 42759 3570 4 seen see VBN 42759 3570 5 in in IN 42759 3570 6 an an DT 42759 3570 7 earlier early JJR 42759 3570 8 chapter chapter NN 42759 3570 9 , , , 42759 3570 10 the the DT 42759 3570 11 only only JJ 42759 3570 12 reasons reason NNS 42759 3570 13 that that WDT 42759 3570 14 give give VBP 42759 3570 15 ethical ethical JJ 42759 3570 16 support support NN 42759 3570 17 to to IN 42759 3570 18 interest interest NN 42759 3570 19 on on IN 42759 3570 20 capital capital NN 42759 3570 21 are be VBP 42759 3570 22 the the DT 42759 3570 23 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 3570 24 that that WDT 42759 3570 25 is be VBZ 42759 3570 26 involved involve VBN 42759 3570 27 in in IN 42759 3570 28 some some DT 42759 3570 29 kinds kind NNS 42759 3570 30 of of IN 42759 3570 31 saving saving NN 42759 3570 32 , , , 42759 3570 33 the the DT 42759 3570 34 possibility possibility NN 42759 3570 35 that that IN 42759 3570 36 interest interest NN 42759 3570 37 is be VBZ 42759 3570 38 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3570 39 in in IN 42759 3570 40 order order NN 42759 3570 41 to to TO 42759 3570 42 induce induce VB 42759 3570 43 the the DT 42759 3570 44 provision provision NN 42759 3570 45 of of IN 42759 3570 46 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3570 47 capital capital NN 42759 3570 48 , , , 42759 3570 49 the the DT 42759 3570 50 certainty certainty NN 42759 3570 51 that that IN 42759 3570 52 the the DT 42759 3570 53 State State NNP 42759 3570 54 would would MD 42759 3570 55 be be VB 42759 3570 56 unable unable JJ 42759 3570 57 to to TO 42759 3570 58 enforce enforce VB 42759 3570 59 the the DT 42759 3570 60 abolition abolition NN 42759 3570 61 of of IN 42759 3570 62 interest interest NN 42759 3570 63 , , , 42759 3570 64 and and CC 42759 3570 65 some some DT 42759 3570 66 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 3570 67 considerations consideration NNS 42759 3570 68 . . . 42759 3571 1 Since since IN 42759 3571 2 all all DT 42759 3571 3 of of IN 42759 3571 4 these these DT 42759 3571 5 reasons reason NNS 42759 3571 6 and and CC 42759 3571 7 ends end NNS 42759 3571 8 are be VBP 42759 3571 9 satisfied satisfied JJ 42759 3571 10 by by IN 42759 3571 11 the the DT 42759 3571 12 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3571 13 rate rate NN 42759 3571 14 of of IN 42759 3571 15 interest interest NN 42759 3571 16 , , , 42759 3571 17 none none NN 42759 3571 18 of of IN 42759 3571 19 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3571 20 will will MD 42759 3571 21 justify justify VB 42759 3571 22 the the DT 42759 3571 23 exaction exaction NN 42759 3571 24 of of IN 42759 3571 25 more more JJR 42759 3571 26 than than IN 42759 3571 27 the the DT 42759 3571 28 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3571 29 rate rate NN 42759 3571 30 . . . 42759 3572 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3572 2 is be VBZ 42759 3572 3 not not RB 42759 3572 4 possible possible JJ 42759 3572 5 to to TO 42759 3572 6 justify justify VB 42759 3572 7 a a DT 42759 3572 8 higher high JJR 42759 3572 9 rate rate NN 42759 3572 10 on on IN 42759 3572 11 either either CC 42759 3572 12 social social JJ 42759 3572 13 or or CC 42759 3572 14 individual individual JJ 42759 3572 15 grounds ground NNS 42759 3572 16 . . . 42759 3573 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 3573 2 , , , 42759 3573 3 the the DT 42759 3573 4 only only JJ 42759 3573 5 basis basis NN 42759 3573 6 that that WDT 42759 3573 7 is be VBZ 42759 3573 8 left leave VBN 42759 3573 9 upon upon IN 42759 3573 10 which which WDT 42759 3573 11 to to TO 42759 3573 12 defend defend VB 42759 3573 13 the the DT 42759 3573 14 retention retention NN 42759 3573 15 of of IN 42759 3573 16 the the DT 42759 3573 17 five five CD 42759 3573 18 per per NN 42759 3573 19 cent cent NN 42759 3573 20 . . . 42759 3574 1 surplus surplus NN 42759 3574 2 that that IN 42759 3574 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3574 4 are be VBP 42759 3574 5 discussing discuss VBG 42759 3574 6 , , , 42759 3574 7 is be VBZ 42759 3574 8 the the DT 42759 3574 9 power power NN 42759 3574 10 of of IN 42759 3574 11 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 3574 12 . . . 42759 3575 1 The the DT 42759 3575 2 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3575 3 possesses possess VBZ 42759 3575 4 the the DT 42759 3575 5 economic economic JJ 42759 3575 6 strength strength NN 42759 3575 7 to to TO 42759 3575 8 take take VB 42759 3575 9 this this DT 42759 3575 10 five five CD 42759 3575 11 per per IN 42759 3575 12 cent cent NN 42759 3575 13 . . . 42759 3576 1 because because IN 42759 3576 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3576 3 is be VBZ 42759 3576 4 able able JJ 42759 3576 5 to to TO 42759 3576 6 impose impose VB 42759 3576 7 higher high JJR 42759 3576 8 than than IN 42759 3576 9 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3576 10 prices price NNS 42759 3576 11 upon upon IN 42759 3576 12 the the DT 42759 3576 13 consumer consumer NN 42759 3576 14 . . . 42759 3577 1 Obviously obviously RB 42759 3577 2 such such JJ 42759 3577 3 power power NN 42759 3577 4 has have VBZ 42759 3577 5 no no DT 42759 3577 6 greater great JJR 42759 3577 7 ethical ethical JJ 42759 3577 8 sanction sanction NN 42759 3577 9 or or CC 42759 3577 10 validity validity NN 42759 3577 11 than than IN 42759 3577 12 the the DT 42759 3577 13 pistol pistol NN 42759 3577 14 of of IN 42759 3577 15 the the DT 42759 3577 16 highwayman highwayman NN 42759 3577 17 . . . 42759 3578 1 In in IN 42759 3578 2 both both DT 42759 3578 3 cases case NNS 42759 3578 4 the the DT 42759 3578 5 gains gain NNS 42759 3578 6 are be VBP 42759 3578 7 the the DT 42759 3578 8 product product NN 42759 3578 9 of of IN 42759 3578 10 extortion extortion NN 42759 3578 11 . . . 42759 3579 1 The the DT 42759 3579 2 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 3579 3 that that IN 42759 3579 4 men man NNS 42759 3579 5 have have VBP 42759 3579 6 no no DT 42759 3579 7 right right NN 42759 3579 8 to to IN 42759 3579 9 more more JJR 42759 3579 10 than than IN 42759 3579 11 the the DT 42759 3579 12 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3579 13 rate rate NN 42759 3579 14 of of IN 42759 3579 15 interest interest NN 42759 3579 16 , , , 42759 3579 17 as as IN 42759 3579 18 interest interest NN 42759 3579 19 , , , 42759 3579 20 on on IN 42759 3579 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3579 22 capital capital NN 42759 3579 23 , , , 42759 3579 24 and and CC 42759 3579 25 that that IN 42759 3579 26 a a DT 42759 3579 27 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3579 28 has have VBZ 42759 3579 29 consequently consequently RB 42759 3579 30 no no RB 42759 3579 31 right right NN 42759 3579 32 to to IN 42759 3579 33 those those DT 42759 3579 34 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3579 35 gains gain NNS 42759 3579 36 that that WDT 42759 3579 37 are be VBP 42759 3579 38 not not RB 42759 3579 39 produced produce VBN 42759 3579 40 by by IN 42759 3579 41 superior superior JJ 42759 3579 42 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3579 43 , , , 42759 3579 44 is be VBZ 42759 3579 45 confirmed confirm VBN 42759 3579 46 by by IN 42759 3579 47 public public JJ 42759 3579 48 opinion opinion NN 42759 3579 49 and and CC 42759 3579 50 by by IN 42759 3579 51 the the DT 42759 3579 52 decisions decision NNS 42759 3579 53 of of IN 42759 3579 54 the the DT 42759 3579 55 courts court NNS 42759 3579 56 . . . 42759 3580 1 The the DT 42759 3580 2 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3580 3 practice practice NN 42759 3580 4 of of IN 42759 3580 5 taking take VBG 42759 3580 6 more more JJR 42759 3580 7 than than IN 42759 3580 8 the the DT 42759 3580 9 usual usual JJ 42759 3580 10 rate rate NN 42759 3580 11 of of IN 42759 3580 12 returns return NNS 42759 3580 13 on on IN 42759 3580 14 capital capital NN 42759 3580 15 merely merely RB 42759 3580 16 because because IN 42759 3580 17 there there EX 42759 3580 18 exists exist VBZ 42759 3580 19 the the DT 42759 3580 20 power power NN 42759 3580 21 to to TO 42759 3580 22 take take VB 42759 3580 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3580 24 , , , 42759 3580 25 is be VBZ 42759 3580 26 universally universally RB 42759 3580 27 condemned condemn VBN 42759 3580 28 as as RB 42759 3580 29 inequitable inequitable JJ 42759 3580 30 . . . 42759 3581 1 In in IN 42759 3581 2 fixing fix VBG 42759 3581 3 the the DT 42759 3581 4 charges charge NNS 42759 3581 5 of of IN 42759 3581 6 public public JJ 42759 3581 7 service service NN 42759 3581 8 corporations corporation NNS 42759 3581 9 , , , 42759 3581 10 the the DT 42759 3581 11 courts court NNS 42759 3581 12 with with IN 42759 3581 13 practical practical JJ 42759 3581 14 unanimity unanimity NN 42759 3581 15 allow allow VBP 42759 3581 16 only only RB 42759 3581 17 the the DT 42759 3581 18 rate rate NN 42759 3581 19 of of IN 42759 3581 20 return return NN 42759 3581 21 that that WDT 42759 3581 22 is be VBZ 42759 3581 23 obtainable obtainable JJ 42759 3581 24 in in IN 42759 3581 25 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3581 26 conditions condition NNS 42759 3581 27 of of IN 42759 3581 28 investment investment NN 42759 3581 29 . . . 42759 3582 1 The the DT 42759 3582 2 statement statement NN 42759 3582 3 that that IN 42759 3582 4 the the DT 42759 3582 5 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3582 6 may may MD 42759 3582 7 retain retain VB 42759 3582 8 those those DT 42759 3582 9 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3582 10 gains gain NNS 42759 3582 11 which which WDT 42759 3582 12 are be VBP 42759 3582 13 derived derive VBN 42759 3582 14 from from IN 42759 3582 15 superior superior JJ 42759 3582 16 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3582 17 assumes assume VBZ 42759 3582 18 , , , 42759 3582 19 of of IN 42759 3582 20 course course NN 42759 3582 21 , , , 42759 3582 22 that that DT 42759 3582 23 fair fair JJ 42759 3582 24 wages wage NNS 42759 3582 25 have have VBP 42759 3582 26 been be VBN 42759 3582 27 paid pay VBN 42759 3582 28 to to IN 42759 3582 29 employés employés VB 42759 3582 30 , , , 42759 3582 31 and and CC 42759 3582 32 fair fair JJ 42759 3582 33 prices price NNS 42759 3582 34 to to IN 42759 3582 35 the the DT 42759 3582 36 sellers seller NNS 42759 3582 37 of of IN 42759 3582 38 materials material NNS 42759 3582 39 , , , 42759 3582 40 and and CC 42759 3582 41 that that IN 42759 3582 42 fair fair JJ 42759 3582 43 methods method NNS 42759 3582 44 have have VBP 42759 3582 45 been be VBN 42759 3582 46 used use VBN 42759 3582 47 toward toward IN 42759 3582 48 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3582 49 . . . 42759 3583 1 In in IN 42759 3583 2 so so RB 42759 3583 3 far far RB 42759 3583 4 as as IN 42759 3583 5 any any DT 42759 3583 6 of of IN 42759 3583 7 these these DT 42759 3583 8 conditions condition NNS 42759 3583 9 is be VBZ 42759 3583 10 not not RB 42759 3583 11 met meet VBN 42759 3583 12 , , , 42759 3583 13 the the DT 42759 3583 14 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3583 15 concern concern NN 42759 3583 16 has have VBZ 42759 3583 17 no no DT 42759 3583 18 right right NN 42759 3583 19 to to TO 42759 3583 20 surplus surplus VB 42759 3583 21 gains gain NNS 42759 3583 22 of of IN 42759 3583 23 any any DT 42759 3583 24 sort sort NN 42759 3583 25 . . . 42759 3584 1 All all DT 42759 3584 2 three three CD 42759 3584 3 of of IN 42759 3584 4 the the DT 42759 3584 5 claims claim NNS 42759 3584 6 just just RB 42759 3584 7 mentioned mention VBN 42759 3584 8 are be VBP 42759 3584 9 morally morally RB 42759 3584 10 stronger strong JJR 42759 3584 11 than than IN 42759 3584 12 the the DT 42759 3584 13 claim claim NN 42759 3584 14 to to IN 42759 3584 15 superior superior JJ 42759 3584 16 rewards reward NNS 42759 3584 17 because because IN 42759 3584 18 of of IN 42759 3584 19 superior superior JJ 42759 3584 20 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3584 21 . . . 42759 3585 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3585 2 The the DT 42759 3585 3 Question Question NNP 42759 3585 4 of of IN 42759 3585 5 Monopolistic Monopolistic NNP 42759 3585 6 Efficiency Efficiency NNP 42759 3585 7 _ _ NNP 42759 3585 8 So so RB 42759 3585 9 much much JJ 42759 3585 10 for for IN 42759 3585 11 the the DT 42759 3585 12 moral moral JJ 42759 3585 13 principle principle NN 42759 3585 14 . . . 42759 3586 1 What what WDT 42759 3586 2 proportion proportion NN 42759 3586 3 of of IN 42759 3586 4 the the DT 42759 3586 5 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3586 6 gains gain NNS 42759 3586 7 of of IN 42759 3586 8 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3586 9 are be VBP 42759 3586 10 due due JJ 42759 3586 11 to to IN 42759 3586 12 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3586 13 prices price NNS 42759 3586 14 rather rather RB 42759 3586 15 than than IN 42759 3586 16 to to IN 42759 3586 17 economies economy NNS 42759 3586 18 in in IN 42759 3586 19 production production NN 42759 3586 20 , , , 42759 3586 21 can can MD 42759 3586 22 not not RB 42759 3586 23 be be VB 42759 3586 24 known know VBN 42759 3586 25 even even RB 42759 3586 26 approximately approximately RB 42759 3586 27 . . . 42759 3587 1 According accord VBG 42759 3587 2 to to IN 42759 3587 3 Justice Justice NNP 42759 3587 4 Brandeis Brandeis NNP 42759 3587 5 , , , 42759 3587 6 who who WP 42759 3587 7 is be VBZ 42759 3587 8 one one CD 42759 3587 9 of of IN 42759 3587 10 the the DT 42759 3587 11 most most RBS 42759 3587 12 competent competent JJ 42759 3587 13 authorities authority NNS 42759 3587 14 in in IN 42759 3587 15 this this DT 42759 3587 16 field field NN 42759 3587 17 , , , 42759 3587 18 only only RB 42759 3587 19 a a DT 42759 3587 20 very very RB 42759 3587 21 small small JJ 42759 3587 22 part part NN 42759 3587 23 of of IN 42759 3587 24 these these DT 42759 3587 25 gains gain NNS 42759 3587 26 are be VBP 42759 3587 27 derived derive VBN 42759 3587 28 from from IN 42759 3587 29 superior superior JJ 42759 3587 30 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3587 31 . . . 42759 3588 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3588 2 168 168 CD 42759 3588 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3588 4 Professor Professor NNP 42759 3588 5 E. E. NNP 42759 3588 6 S. S. NNP 42759 3588 7 Meade Meade NNP 42759 3588 8 writes write VBZ 42759 3588 9 : : : 42759 3588 10 " " `` 42759 3588 11 During during IN 42759 3588 12 a a DT 42759 3588 13 decade decade NN 42759 3588 14 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3588 15 1902 1902 CD 42759 3588 16 - - SYM 42759 3588 17 1912 1912 CD 42759 3588 18 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3588 19 of of IN 42759 3588 20 unparalleled unparalleled JJ 42759 3588 21 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3588 22 development development NN 42759 3588 23 , , , 42759 3588 24 the the DT 42759 3588 25 trusts trust NNS 42759 3588 26 , , , 42759 3588 27 starting start VBG 42759 3588 28 with with IN 42759 3588 29 every every DT 42759 3588 30 advantage advantage NN 42759 3588 31 of of IN 42759 3588 32 large large JJ 42759 3588 33 capital capital NN 42759 3588 34 , , , 42759 3588 35 well well RB 42759 3588 36 - - HYPH 42759 3588 37 equipped equip VBN 42759 3588 38 plants plant NNS 42759 3588 39 , , , 42759 3588 40 financial financial JJ 42759 3588 41 connections connection NNS 42759 3588 42 , , , 42759 3588 43 and and CC 42759 3588 44 skilled skilled JJ 42759 3588 45 superintendence superintendence NN 42759 3588 46 , , , 42759 3588 47 have have VBP 42759 3588 48 not not RB 42759 3588 49 succeeded succeed VBN 42759 3588 50 . . . 42759 3589 1 " " `` 42759 3589 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3589 3 169 169 CD 42759 3589 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3589 5 On on IN 42759 3589 6 the the DT 42759 3589 7 other other JJ 42759 3589 8 hand hand NN 42759 3589 9 , , , 42759 3589 10 President President NNP 42759 3589 11 Van Van NNP 42759 3589 12 Hise Hise NNP 42759 3589 13 thinks think VBZ 42759 3589 14 that that IN 42759 3589 15 , , , 42759 3589 16 " " `` 42759 3589 17 the the DT 42759 3589 18 weight weight NN 42759 3589 19 of of IN 42759 3589 20 argument argument NN 42759 3589 21 is be VBZ 42759 3589 22 strongly strongly RB 42759 3589 23 in in IN 42759 3589 24 favour favour NN 42759 3589 25 of of IN 42759 3589 26 the the DT 42759 3589 27 increased increase VBN 42759 3589 28 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3589 29 of of IN 42759 3589 30 large large JJ 42759 3589 31 combinations combination NNS 42759 3589 32 of of IN 42759 3589 33 industry industry NN 42759 3589 34 on on IN 42759 3589 35 the the DT 42759 3589 36 average average NN 42759 3589 37 . . . 42759 3590 1 " " `` 42759 3590 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3590 3 170 170 CD 42759 3590 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3590 5 The the DT 42759 3590 6 difference difference NN 42759 3590 7 of of IN 42759 3590 8 opinion opinion NN 42759 3590 9 existing exist VBG 42759 3590 10 among among IN 42759 3590 11 students student NNS 42759 3590 12 of of IN 42759 3590 13 this this DT 42759 3590 14 subject subject NN 42759 3590 15 is be VBZ 42759 3590 16 due due JJ 42759 3590 17 to to IN 42759 3590 18 lack lack NN 42759 3590 19 of of IN 42759 3590 20 adequate adequate JJ 42759 3590 21 data datum NNS 42759 3590 22 , , , 42759 3590 23 particularly particularly RB 42759 3590 24 to to IN 42759 3590 25 the the DT 42759 3590 26 absence absence NN 42759 3590 27 of of IN 42759 3590 28 such such JJ 42759 3590 29 uniform uniform NN 42759 3590 30 and and CC 42759 3590 31 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 3590 32 systems system NNS 42759 3590 33 of of IN 42759 3590 34 accounting accounting NN 42759 3590 35 as as IN 42759 3590 36 would would MD 42759 3590 37 be be VB 42759 3590 38 required require VBN 42759 3590 39 to to TO 42759 3590 40 provide provide VB 42759 3590 41 a a DT 42759 3590 42 basis basis NN 42759 3590 43 for for IN 42759 3590 44 reliable reliable JJ 42759 3590 45 general general JJ 42759 3590 46 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 3590 47 . . . 42759 3591 1 Opposing oppose VBG 42759 3591 2 particular particular JJ 42759 3591 3 statements statement NNS 42759 3591 4 may may MD 42759 3591 5 be be VB 42759 3591 6 equally equally RB 42759 3591 7 true true JJ 42759 3591 8 , , , 42759 3591 9 because because IN 42759 3591 10 based base VBN 42759 3591 11 upon upon IN 42759 3591 12 different different JJ 42759 3591 13 instances instance NNS 42759 3591 14 ; ; : 42759 3591 15 but but CC 42759 3591 16 general general JJ 42759 3591 17 statements statement NNS 42759 3591 18 are be VBP 42759 3591 19 little little RB 42759 3591 20 better well JJR 42759 3591 21 than than IN 42759 3591 22 guesses guess NNS 42759 3591 23 . . . 42759 3592 1 Let let VB 42759 3592 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3592 3 approach approach VB 42759 3592 4 the the DT 42759 3592 5 question question NN 42759 3592 6 from from IN 42759 3592 7 another another DT 42759 3592 8 side side NN 42759 3592 9 , , , 42759 3592 10 that that DT 42759 3592 11 of of IN 42759 3592 12 prices price NNS 42759 3592 13 . . . 42759 3593 1 Whenever whenever WRB 42759 3593 2 the the DT 42759 3593 3 charges charge NNS 42759 3593 4 imposed impose VBN 42759 3593 5 by by IN 42759 3593 6 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3593 7 concerns concern NNS 42759 3593 8 upon upon IN 42759 3593 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3593 10 products product NNS 42759 3593 11 are be VBP 42759 3593 12 higher high JJR 42759 3593 13 than than IN 42759 3593 14 those those DT 42759 3593 15 that that WDT 42759 3593 16 would would MD 42759 3593 17 have have VB 42759 3593 18 prevailed prevail VBN 42759 3593 19 under under IN 42759 3593 20 competition competition NN 42759 3593 21 , , , 42759 3593 22 the the DT 42759 3593 23 surplus surplus NN 42759 3593 24 gains gain NNS 42759 3593 25 are be VBP 42759 3593 26 obviously obviously RB 42759 3593 27 to to IN 42759 3593 28 that that DT 42759 3593 29 extent extent NN 42759 3593 30 not not RB 42759 3593 31 due due JJ 42759 3593 32 to to IN 42759 3593 33 superior superior JJ 42759 3593 34 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3593 35 . . . 42759 3594 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3594 2 have have VBP 42759 3594 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3594 4 source source NN 42759 3594 5 in in IN 42759 3594 6 the the DT 42759 3594 7 arbitrarily arbitrarily RB 42759 3594 8 made make VBN 42759 3594 9 prices price NNS 42759 3594 10 . . . 42759 3595 1 The the DT 42759 3595 2 Final Final NNP 42759 3595 3 Report Report NNP 42759 3595 4 of of IN 42759 3595 5 the the DT 42759 3595 6 United United NNP 42759 3595 7 States States NNP 42759 3595 8 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 3595 9 Commission Commission NNP 42759 3595 10 , , , 42759 3595 11 which which WDT 42759 3595 12 was be VBD 42759 3595 13 made make VBN 42759 3595 14 at at IN 42759 3595 15 the the DT 42759 3595 16 beginning beginning NN 42759 3595 17 of of IN 42759 3595 18 the the DT 42759 3595 19 year year NN 42759 3595 20 1902 1902 CD 42759 3595 21 , , , 42759 3595 22 declared declare VBD 42759 3595 23 that that IN 42759 3595 24 , , , 42759 3595 25 " " `` 42759 3595 26 in in IN 42759 3595 27 most most JJS 42759 3595 28 cases case NNS 42759 3595 29 the the DT 42759 3595 30 combination combination NN 42759 3595 31 has have VBZ 42759 3595 32 exerted exert VBN 42759 3595 33 an an DT 42759 3595 34 appreciable appreciable JJ 42759 3595 35 power power NN 42759 3595 36 over over IN 42759 3595 37 prices price NNS 42759 3595 38 , , , 42759 3595 39 and and CC 42759 3595 40 in in IN 42759 3595 41 practically practically RB 42759 3595 42 all all DT 42759 3595 43 cases case NNS 42759 3595 44 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3595 45 has have VBZ 42759 3595 46 increased increase VBN 42759 3595 47 the the DT 42759 3595 48 margin margin NN 42759 3595 49 between between IN 42759 3595 50 raw raw JJ 42759 3595 51 materials material NNS 42759 3595 52 and and CC 42759 3595 53 finished finished JJ 42759 3595 54 products product NNS 42759 3595 55 . . . 42759 3596 1 " " `` 42759 3596 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3596 3 171 171 CD 42759 3596 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3596 5 Since since IN 42759 3596 6 the the DT 42759 3596 7 cost cost NN 42759 3596 8 of of IN 42759 3596 9 production production NN 42759 3596 10 had have VBD 42759 3596 11 decreased decrease VBN 42759 3596 12 during during IN 42759 3596 13 the the DT 42759 3596 14 preceding precede VBG 42759 3596 15 decade decade NN 42759 3596 16 , , , 42759 3596 17 this this DT 42759 3596 18 increase increase NN 42759 3596 19 in in IN 42759 3596 20 the the DT 42759 3596 21 margin margin NN 42759 3596 22 , , , 42759 3596 23 and and CC 42759 3596 24 the the DT 42759 3596 25 ensuing ensue VBG 42759 3596 26 increased increase VBN 42759 3596 27 profits profit NNS 42759 3596 28 , , , 42759 3596 29 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 3596 30 involved involve VBD 42759 3596 31 an an DT 42759 3596 32 increase increase NN 42759 3596 33 in in IN 42759 3596 34 prices price NNS 42759 3596 35 to to IN 42759 3596 36 the the DT 42759 3596 37 consumer consumer NN 42759 3596 38 . . . 42759 3597 1 Taking take VBG 42759 3597 2 the the DT 42759 3597 3 period period NN 42759 3597 4 of of IN 42759 3597 5 1897 1897 CD 42759 3597 6 - - SYM 42759 3597 7 1910 1910 CD 42759 3597 8 , , , 42759 3597 9 and and CC 42759 3597 10 comparing compare VBG 42759 3597 11 the the DT 42759 3597 12 movement movement NN 42759 3597 13 of of IN 42759 3597 14 prices price NNS 42759 3597 15 between between IN 42759 3597 16 eighteen eighteen CD 42759 3597 17 important important JJ 42759 3597 18 trust trust NN 42759 3597 19 - - HYPH 42759 3597 20 controlled control VBN 42759 3597 21 products product NNS 42759 3597 22 , , , 42759 3597 23 and and CC 42759 3597 24 the the DT 42759 3597 25 same same JJ 42759 3597 26 number number NN 42759 3597 27 of of IN 42759 3597 28 important important JJ 42759 3597 29 commodities commodity NNS 42759 3597 30 not not RB 42759 3597 31 produced produce VBN 42759 3597 32 by by IN 42759 3597 33 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3597 34 concerns concern NNS 42759 3597 35 , , , 42759 3597 36 Professor Professor NNP 42759 3597 37 Meade Meade NNP 42759 3597 38 concluded conclude VBD 42759 3597 39 that that IN 42759 3597 40 the the DT 42759 3597 41 former former JJ 42759 3597 42 were be VBD 42759 3597 43 sold sell VBN 42759 3597 44 at at IN 42759 3597 45 a a DT 42759 3597 46 " " `` 42759 3597 47 much much RB 42759 3597 48 lower low JJR 42759 3597 49 " " '' 42759 3597 50 relative relative JJ 42759 3597 51 level level NN 42759 3597 52 than than IN 42759 3597 53 the the DT 42759 3597 54 latter latter JJ 42759 3597 55 . . . 42759 3598 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3598 2 172 172 CD 42759 3598 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3598 4 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3598 5 computations computation NNS 42759 3598 6 were be VBD 42759 3598 7 based base VBN 42759 3598 8 upon upon IN 42759 3598 9 figures figure NNS 42759 3598 10 compiled compile VBN 42759 3598 11 by by IN 42759 3598 12 the the DT 42759 3598 13 Bureau Bureau NNP 42759 3598 14 of of IN 42759 3598 15 Labour Labour NNP 42759 3598 16 . . . 42759 3599 1 According accord VBG 42759 3599 2 to to IN 42759 3599 3 the the DT 42759 3599 4 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 3599 5 of of IN 42759 3599 6 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 3599 7 , , , 42759 3599 8 the the DT 42759 3599 9 Standard Standard NNP 42759 3599 10 Oil Oil NNP 42759 3599 11 Company Company NNP 42759 3599 12 " " '' 42759 3599 13 has have VBZ 42759 3599 14 taken take VBN 42759 3599 15 advantage advantage NN 42759 3599 16 of of IN 42759 3599 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3599 18 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3599 19 power power NN 42759 3599 20 to to TO 42759 3599 21 extort extort VB 42759 3599 22 prices price NNS 42759 3599 23 much much RB 42759 3599 24 higher high JJR 42759 3599 25 than than IN 42759 3599 26 would would MD 42759 3599 27 have have VB 42759 3599 28 existed exist VBN 42759 3599 29 under under IN 42759 3599 30 free free JJ 42759 3599 31 competition competition NN 42759 3599 32 . . . 42759 3600 1 " " `` 42759 3600 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3600 3 173 173 CD 42759 3600 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3600 5 The the DT 42759 3600 6 same same JJ 42759 3600 7 authority authority NN 42759 3600 8 shows show VBZ 42759 3600 9 that that IN 42759 3600 10 the the DT 42759 3600 11 American American NNP 42759 3600 12 Tobacco Tobacco NNP 42759 3600 13 Company Company NNP 42759 3600 14 used use VBD 42759 3600 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3600 16 power power NN 42759 3600 17 to to TO 42759 3600 18 obtain obtain VB 42759 3600 19 considerably considerably RB 42759 3600 20 more more JJR 42759 3600 21 than than IN 42759 3600 22 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3600 23 prices price NNS 42759 3600 24 on on IN 42759 3600 25 some some DT 42759 3600 26 of of IN 42759 3600 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3600 28 products product NNS 42759 3600 29 . . . 42759 3601 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3601 2 174 174 CD 42759 3601 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3601 4 Excessive excessive JJ 42759 3601 5 prices price NNS 42759 3601 6 , , , 42759 3601 7 as as IN 42759 3601 8 measured measure VBN 42759 3601 9 by by IN 42759 3601 10 the the DT 42759 3601 11 standards standard NNS 42759 3601 12 of of IN 42759 3601 13 competition competition NN 42759 3601 14 , , , 42759 3601 15 were be VBD 42759 3601 16 also also RB 42759 3601 17 established establish VBN 42759 3601 18 by by IN 42759 3601 19 the the DT 42759 3601 20 United United NNP 42759 3601 21 States States NNP 42759 3601 22 Steel Steel NNP 42759 3601 23 Corporation Corporation NNP 42759 3601 24 , , , 42759 3601 25 the the DT 42759 3601 26 American American NNP 42759 3601 27 Sugar Sugar NNP 42759 3601 28 Refining Refining NNP 42759 3601 29 Company Company NNP 42759 3601 30 , , , 42759 3601 31 and and CC 42759 3601 32 the the DT 42759 3601 33 combinations combination NNS 42759 3601 34 in in IN 42759 3601 35 meat meat NN 42759 3601 36 packing packing NN 42759 3601 37 and and CC 42759 3601 38 in in IN 42759 3601 39 lumber lumber NN 42759 3601 40 . . . 42759 3602 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3602 2 175 175 CD 42759 3602 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3602 4 A a DT 42759 3602 5 safe safe JJ 42759 3602 6 statement statement NN 42759 3602 7 would would MD 42759 3602 8 probably probably RB 42759 3602 9 be be VB 42759 3602 10 that that IN 42759 3602 11 the the DT 42759 3602 12 greater great JJR 42759 3602 13 part part NN 42759 3602 14 of of IN 42759 3602 15 the the DT 42759 3602 16 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3602 17 gains gain NNS 42759 3602 18 of of IN 42759 3602 19 the the DT 42759 3602 20 most most RBS 42759 3602 21 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 42759 3602 22 American american JJ 42759 3602 23 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3602 24 have have VBP 42759 3602 25 been be VBN 42759 3602 26 due due JJ 42759 3602 27 to to IN 42759 3602 28 excessive excessive JJ 42759 3602 29 prices price NNS 42759 3602 30 rather rather RB 42759 3602 31 than than IN 42759 3602 32 to to IN 42759 3602 33 economies economy NNS 42759 3602 34 of of IN 42759 3602 35 production production NN 42759 3602 36 . . . 42759 3603 1 Let let VB 42759 3603 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3603 3 turn turn VB 42759 3603 4 from from IN 42759 3603 5 the the DT 42759 3603 6 subject subject NN 42759 3603 7 of of IN 42759 3603 8 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3603 9 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3603 10 gains gain NNS 42759 3603 11 to to IN 42759 3603 12 that that DT 42759 3603 13 of of IN 42759 3603 14 unfair unfair JJ 42759 3603 15 methods method NNS 42759 3603 16 used use VBN 42759 3603 17 by by IN 42759 3603 18 the the DT 42759 3603 19 great great JJ 42759 3603 20 combinations combination NNS 42759 3603 21 toward toward IN 42759 3603 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3603 23 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3603 24 . . . 42759 3604 1 These these DT 42759 3604 2 methods method NNS 42759 3604 3 are be VBP 42759 3604 4 mainly mainly RB 42759 3604 5 three three CD 42759 3604 6 : : : 42759 3604 7 discriminative discriminative JJ 42759 3604 8 underselling underselling NN 42759 3604 9 , , , 42759 3604 10 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 3604 11 - - HYPH 42759 3604 12 selling sell VBG 42759 3604 13 contracts contract NNS 42759 3604 14 , , , 42759 3604 15 and and CC 42759 3604 16 advantages advantage NNS 42759 3604 17 in in IN 42759 3604 18 transportation transportation NN 42759 3604 19 . . . 42759 3605 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3605 2 Discriminative Discriminative NNP 42759 3605 3 Underselling Underselling NNP 42759 3605 4 _ _ NNP 42759 3605 5 The the DT 42759 3605 6 first first JJ 42759 3605 7 of of IN 42759 3605 8 these these DT 42759 3605 9 practices practice NNS 42759 3605 10 is be VBZ 42759 3605 11 exemplified exemplify VBN 42759 3605 12 when when WRB 42759 3605 13 a a DT 42759 3605 14 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3605 15 sells sell VBZ 42759 3605 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3605 17 goods good NNS 42759 3605 18 at at IN 42759 3605 19 unprofitably unprofitably JJ 42759 3605 20 low low JJ 42759 3605 21 rates rate NNS 42759 3605 22 in in IN 42759 3605 23 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3605 24 territory territory NN 42759 3605 25 , , , 42759 3605 26 while while IN 42759 3605 27 maintaining maintain VBG 42759 3605 28 higher high JJR 42759 3605 29 prices price NNS 42759 3605 30 elsewhere elsewhere RB 42759 3605 31 ; ; : 42759 3605 32 and and CC 42759 3605 33 when when WRB 42759 3605 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3605 35 offers offer VBZ 42759 3605 36 at at IN 42759 3605 37 very very RB 42759 3605 38 low low JJ 42759 3605 39 prices price NNS 42759 3605 40 those those DT 42759 3605 41 kinds kind NNS 42759 3605 42 of of IN 42759 3605 43 goods good NNS 42759 3605 44 which which WDT 42759 3605 45 are be VBP 42759 3605 46 handled handle VBN 42759 3605 47 by by IN 42759 3605 48 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3605 49 , , , 42759 3605 50 while while IN 42759 3605 51 holding hold VBG 42759 3605 52 at at IN 42759 3605 53 excessively excessively RB 42759 3605 54 high high JJ 42759 3605 55 prices price NNS 42759 3605 56 the the DT 42759 3605 57 kinds kind NNS 42759 3605 58 of of IN 42759 3605 59 commodities commodity NNS 42759 3605 60 over over IN 42759 3605 61 which which WDT 42759 3605 62 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3605 63 has have VBZ 42759 3605 64 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 3605 65 control control NN 42759 3605 66 . . . 42759 3606 1 Both both DT 42759 3606 2 forms form NNS 42759 3606 3 of of IN 42759 3606 4 the the DT 42759 3606 5 practice practice NN 42759 3606 6 seem seem VBP 42759 3606 7 to to TO 42759 3606 8 have have VB 42759 3606 9 been be VBN 42759 3606 10 extensively extensively RB 42759 3606 11 used use VBN 42759 3606 12 by by IN 42759 3606 13 most most JJS 42759 3606 14 of of IN 42759 3606 15 the the DT 42759 3606 16 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3606 17 concerns concern NNS 42759 3606 18 of of IN 42759 3606 19 America America NNP 42759 3606 20 . . . 42759 3607 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3607 2 176 176 CD 42759 3607 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3607 4 The the DT 42759 3607 5 Standard Standard NNP 42759 3607 6 Oil Oil NNP 42759 3607 7 Company Company NNP 42759 3607 8 has have VBZ 42759 3607 9 been be VBN 42759 3607 10 perhaps perhaps RB 42759 3607 11 the the DT 42759 3607 12 most most RBS 42759 3607 13 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 42759 3607 14 offender offender NN 42759 3607 15 in in IN 42759 3607 16 this this DT 42759 3607 17 field field NN 42759 3607 18 . . . 42759 3608 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3608 2 177 177 CD 42759 3608 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3608 4 This this DT 42759 3608 5 practice practice NN 42759 3608 6 is be VBZ 42759 3608 7 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3608 8 because because IN 42759 3608 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3608 10 violates violate VBZ 42759 3608 11 the the DT 42759 3608 12 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 3608 13 moral moral JJ 42759 3608 14 principle principle NN 42759 3608 15 that that IN 42759 3608 16 a a DT 42759 3608 17 man man NN 42759 3608 18 has have VBZ 42759 3608 19 a a DT 42759 3608 20 right right NN 42759 3608 21 to to TO 42759 3608 22 pursue pursue VB 42759 3608 23 a a DT 42759 3608 24 lawful lawful JJ 42759 3608 25 good good NN 42759 3608 26 without without IN 42759 3608 27 hindrance hindrance NN 42759 3608 28 through through IN 42759 3608 29 illicit illicit NN 42759 3608 30 means mean VBZ 42759 3608 31 . . . 42759 3609 1 Among among IN 42759 3609 2 the the DT 42759 3609 3 illicit illicit NN 42759 3609 4 means mean VBZ 42759 3609 5 enumerated enumerate VBN 42759 3609 6 by by IN 42759 3609 7 the the DT 42759 3609 8 moral moral JJ 42759 3609 9 theologians theologian NNS 42759 3609 10 are be VBP 42759 3609 11 force force NN 42759 3609 12 , , , 42759 3609 13 fraud fraud NN 42759 3609 14 , , , 42759 3609 15 deception deception NN 42759 3609 16 , , , 42759 3609 17 lying lying NN 42759 3609 18 , , , 42759 3609 19 slander slander NN 42759 3609 20 , , , 42759 3609 21 intimidation intimidation NN 42759 3609 22 , , , 42759 3609 23 and and CC 42759 3609 24 extortion extortion NN 42759 3609 25 . . . 42759 3610 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3610 2 178 178 CD 42759 3610 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3610 4 The the DT 42759 3610 5 illicit illicit NN 42759 3610 6 means mean VBZ 42759 3610 7 employed employ VBN 42759 3610 8 in in IN 42759 3610 9 discriminative discriminative JJ 42759 3610 10 underselling underselling NN 42759 3610 11 are be VBP 42759 3610 12 chiefly chiefly RB 42759 3610 13 extortion extortion NN 42759 3610 14 and and CC 42759 3610 15 deception deception NN 42759 3610 16 . . . 42759 3611 1 If if IN 42759 3611 2 the the DT 42759 3611 3 very very RB 42759 3611 4 low low JJ 42759 3611 5 prices price NNS 42759 3611 6 at at IN 42759 3611 7 which which WDT 42759 3611 8 the the DT 42759 3611 9 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3611 10 sells sell VBZ 42759 3611 11 in in IN 42759 3611 12 the the DT 42759 3611 13 field field NN 42759 3611 14 which which WDT 42759 3611 15 contains contain VBZ 42759 3611 16 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3611 17 were be VBD 42759 3611 18 maintained maintain VBN 42759 3611 19 outside outside IN 42759 3611 20 of of IN 42759 3611 21 that that DT 42759 3611 22 field field NN 42759 3611 23 also also RB 42759 3611 24 , , , 42759 3611 25 and and CC 42759 3611 26 if if IN 42759 3611 27 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3611 28 were be VBD 42759 3611 29 continued continue VBN 42759 3611 30 not not RB 42759 3611 31 merely merely RB 42759 3611 32 until until IN 42759 3611 33 the the DT 42759 3611 34 independent independent JJ 42759 3611 35 concerns concern NNS 42759 3611 36 were be VBD 42759 3611 37 driven drive VBN 42759 3611 38 out out IN 42759 3611 39 of of IN 42759 3611 40 business business NN 42759 3611 41 , , , 42759 3611 42 but but CC 42759 3611 43 indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 3611 44 afterward afterward RB 42759 3611 45 , , , 42759 3611 46 no no DT 42759 3611 47 injustice injustice NN 42759 3611 48 would would MD 42759 3611 49 be be VB 42759 3611 50 done do VBN 42759 3611 51 the the DT 42759 3611 52 latter latter JJ 42759 3611 53 . . . 42759 3612 1 For for IN 42759 3612 2 no no DT 42759 3612 3 man man NN 42759 3612 4 has have VBZ 42759 3612 5 a a DT 42759 3612 6 natural natural JJ 42759 3612 7 right right NN 42759 3612 8 to to IN 42759 3612 9 any any DT 42759 3612 10 particular particular JJ 42759 3612 11 business business NN 42759 3612 12 . . . 42759 3613 1 If if IN 42759 3613 2 a a DT 42759 3613 3 powerful powerful JJ 42759 3613 4 concern concern NN 42759 3613 5 can can MD 42759 3613 6 eliminate eliminate VB 42759 3613 7 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3613 8 through through IN 42759 3613 9 low low JJ 42759 3613 10 prices price NNS 42759 3613 11 made make VBN 42759 3613 12 possible possible JJ 42759 3613 13 by by IN 42759 3613 14 superior superior JJ 42759 3613 15 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3613 16 , , , 42759 3613 17 the the DT 42759 3613 18 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3613 19 are be VBP 42759 3613 20 not not RB 42759 3613 21 unjustly unjustly RB 42759 3613 22 treated treat VBN 42759 3613 23 . . . 42759 3614 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3614 2 have have VBP 42759 3614 3 no no DT 42759 3614 4 more more JJR 42759 3614 5 just just RB 42759 3614 6 cause cause NN 42759 3614 7 of of IN 42759 3614 8 complaint complaint NN 42759 3614 9 than than IN 42759 3614 10 the the DT 42759 3614 11 inefficient inefficient JJ 42759 3614 12 grocer grocer NN 42759 3614 13 whose whose WP$ 42759 3614 14 custom custom NN 42759 3614 15 is be VBZ 42759 3614 16 attracted attract VBN 42759 3614 17 from from IN 42759 3614 18 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3614 19 by by IN 42759 3614 20 other other JJ 42759 3614 21 and and CC 42759 3614 22 more more RBR 42759 3614 23 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3614 24 merchants merchant NNS 42759 3614 25 . . . 42759 3615 1 The the DT 42759 3615 2 offence offence NN 42759 3615 3 is be VBZ 42759 3615 4 at at IN 42759 3615 5 the the DT 42759 3615 6 worst bad JJS 42759 3615 7 contrary contrary NN 42759 3615 8 to to IN 42759 3615 9 charity charity NN 42759 3615 10 . . . 42759 3616 1 But but CC 42759 3616 2 when when WRB 42759 3616 3 the the DT 42759 3616 4 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3616 5 maintains maintain VBZ 42759 3616 6 the the DT 42759 3616 7 low low JJ 42759 3616 8 and and CC 42759 3616 9 competition competition NN 42759 3616 10 - - HYPH 42759 3616 11 eliminating eliminate VBG 42759 3616 12 prices price NNS 42759 3616 13 only only RB 42759 3616 14 locally locally RB 42759 3616 15 and and CC 42759 3616 16 temporarily temporarily RB 42759 3616 17 , , , 42759 3616 18 when when WRB 42759 3616 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3616 20 is be VBZ 42759 3616 21 enabled enable VBN 42759 3616 22 to to TO 42759 3616 23 establish establish VB 42759 3616 24 and and CC 42759 3616 25 continue continue VB 42759 3616 26 these these DT 42759 3616 27 prices price NNS 42759 3616 28 only only RB 42759 3616 29 because because IN 42759 3616 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3616 31 sells sell VBZ 42759 3616 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3616 33 goods good NNS 42759 3616 34 at at IN 42759 3616 35 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3616 36 rates rate NNS 42759 3616 37 elsewhere elsewhere RB 42759 3616 38 , , , 42759 3616 39 the the DT 42759 3616 40 latter latter JJ 42759 3616 41 prices price NNS 42759 3616 42 are be VBP 42759 3616 43 evidently evidently RB 42759 3616 44 the the DT 42759 3616 45 instrument instrument NN 42759 3616 46 or or CC 42759 3616 47 means mean VBZ 42759 3616 48 by by IN 42759 3616 49 which which WDT 42759 3616 50 the the DT 42759 3616 51 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3616 52 are be VBP 42759 3616 53 injured injure VBN 42759 3616 54 and and CC 42759 3616 55 eliminated eliminate VBN 42759 3616 56 . . . 42759 3617 1 In in IN 42759 3617 2 that that DT 42759 3617 3 case case NN 42759 3617 4 the the DT 42759 3617 5 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3617 6 violates violate VBZ 42759 3617 7 the the DT 42759 3617 8 right right NN 42759 3617 9 of of IN 42759 3617 10 the the DT 42759 3617 11 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3617 12 to to TO 42759 3617 13 pursue pursue VB 42759 3617 14 a a DT 42759 3617 15 lawful lawful JJ 42759 3617 16 good good NN 42759 3617 17 immune immune NN 42759 3617 18 from from IN 42759 3617 19 unfair unfair JJ 42759 3617 20 interference interference NN 42759 3617 21 . . . 42759 3618 1 The the DT 42759 3618 2 lawful lawful JJ 42759 3618 3 good good NN 42759 3618 4 is be VBZ 42759 3618 5 a a DT 42759 3618 6 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 3618 7 from from IN 42759 3618 8 this this DT 42759 3618 9 kind kind NN 42759 3618 10 of of IN 42759 3618 11 business business NN 42759 3618 12 ; ; : 42759 3618 13 and and CC 42759 3618 14 the the DT 42759 3618 15 illicit illicit JJ 42759 3618 16 interference interference NN 42759 3618 17 is be VBZ 42759 3618 18 the the DT 42759 3618 19 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3618 20 prices price NNS 42759 3618 21 maintained maintain VBD 42759 3618 22 outside outside IN 42759 3618 23 the the DT 42759 3618 24 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3618 25 field field NN 42759 3618 26 . . . 42759 3619 1 In in IN 42759 3619 2 the the DT 42759 3619 3 preceding precede VBG 42759 3619 4 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 3619 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3619 6 have have VBP 42759 3619 7 assumed assume VBN 42759 3619 8 that that IN 42759 3619 9 the the DT 42759 3619 10 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3619 11 prices price NNS 42759 3619 12 are be VBP 42759 3619 13 operative operative JJ 42759 3619 14 at at IN 42759 3619 15 the the DT 42759 3619 16 same same JJ 42759 3619 17 time time NN 42759 3619 18 as as IN 42759 3619 19 the the DT 42759 3619 20 excessively excessively RB 42759 3619 21 low low JJ 42759 3619 22 prices price NNS 42759 3619 23 , , , 42759 3619 24 but but CC 42759 3619 25 in in IN 42759 3619 26 a a DT 42759 3619 27 different different JJ 42759 3619 28 place place NN 42759 3619 29 . . . 42759 3620 1 Suppose suppose VB 42759 3620 2 that that IN 42759 3620 3 the the DT 42759 3620 4 former former JJ 42759 3620 5 are be VBP 42759 3620 6 imposed impose VBN 42759 3620 7 only only RB 42759 3620 8 after after IN 42759 3620 9 the the DT 42759 3620 10 independent independent JJ 42759 3620 11 concerns concern NNS 42759 3620 12 are be VBP 42759 3620 13 eliminated eliminate VBN 42759 3620 14 . . . 42759 3621 1 The the DT 42759 3621 2 injustice injustice NN 42759 3621 3 to to IN 42759 3621 4 the the DT 42759 3621 5 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3621 6 remains remain VBZ 42759 3621 7 the the DT 42759 3621 8 same same JJ 42759 3621 9 as as IN 42759 3621 10 in in IN 42759 3621 11 the the DT 42759 3621 12 preceding precede VBG 42759 3621 13 case case NN 42759 3621 14 . . . 42759 3622 1 Although although IN 42759 3622 2 the the DT 42759 3622 3 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3622 4 prices price NNS 42759 3622 5 are be VBP 42759 3622 6 later later RB 42759 3622 7 in in IN 42759 3622 8 time time NN 42759 3622 9 , , , 42759 3622 10 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3622 11 are be VBP 42759 3622 12 the the DT 42759 3622 13 instrumental instrumental JJ 42759 3622 14 cause cause NN 42759 3622 15 of of IN 42759 3622 16 the the DT 42759 3622 17 destructive destructive JJ 42759 3622 18 low low JJ 42759 3622 19 prices price NNS 42759 3622 20 through through IN 42759 3622 21 which which WDT 42759 3622 22 the the DT 42759 3622 23 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3622 24 were be VBD 42759 3622 25 driven drive VBN 42759 3622 26 out out IN 42759 3622 27 of of IN 42759 3622 28 business business NN 42759 3622 29 . . . 42759 3623 1 If if IN 42759 3623 2 the the DT 42759 3623 3 owners owner NNS 42759 3623 4 of of IN 42759 3623 5 the the DT 42759 3623 6 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3623 7 were be VBD 42759 3623 8 not not RB 42759 3623 9 certain certain JJ 42759 3623 10 of of IN 42759 3623 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3623 12 ability ability NN 42759 3623 13 to to TO 42759 3623 14 establish establish VB 42759 3623 15 the the DT 42759 3623 16 subsequent subsequent JJ 42759 3623 17 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3623 18 prices price NNS 42759 3623 19 , , , 42759 3623 20 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3623 21 would would MD 42759 3623 22 not not RB 42759 3623 23 have have VB 42759 3623 24 put put VBN 42759 3623 25 into into IN 42759 3623 26 effect effect NN 42759 3623 27 the the DT 42759 3623 28 unprofitably unprofitably JJ 42759 3623 29 low low JJ 42759 3623 30 prices price NNS 42759 3623 31 . . . 42759 3624 1 Hence hence RB 42759 3624 2 there there EX 42759 3624 3 is be VBZ 42759 3624 4 a a DT 42759 3624 5 true true JJ 42759 3624 6 causal causal JJ 42759 3624 7 connection connection NN 42759 3624 8 between between IN 42759 3624 9 the the DT 42759 3624 10 former former JJ 42759 3624 11 and and CC 42759 3624 12 the the DT 42759 3624 13 latter latter JJ 42759 3624 14 . . . 42759 3625 1 Although although IN 42759 3625 2 the the DT 42759 3625 3 connection connection NN 42759 3625 4 is be VBZ 42759 3625 5 mainly mainly RB 42759 3625 6 psychical psychical JJ 42759 3625 7 , , , 42759 3625 8 through through IN 42759 3625 9 the the DT 42759 3625 10 consciousness consciousness NN 42759 3625 11 of of IN 42759 3625 12 the the DT 42759 3625 13 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3625 14 owners owner NNS 42759 3625 15 , , , 42759 3625 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3625 17 is be VBZ 42759 3625 18 none none NN 42759 3625 19 the the DT 42759 3625 20 less less RBR 42759 3625 21 real real JJ 42759 3625 22 and and CC 42759 3625 23 effective effective JJ 42759 3625 24 . . . 42759 3626 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3626 2 practical practical JJ 42759 3626 3 effectiveness effectiveness NN 42759 3626 4 is be VBZ 42759 3626 5 seen see VBN 42759 3626 6 in in IN 42759 3626 7 the the DT 42759 3626 8 fact fact NN 42759 3626 9 that that IN 42759 3626 10 the the DT 42759 3626 11 subsequent subsequent JJ 42759 3626 12 possibility possibility NN 42759 3626 13 of of IN 42759 3626 14 imposing impose VBG 42759 3626 15 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3626 16 prices price NNS 42759 3626 17 will will MD 42759 3626 18 induce induce VB 42759 3626 19 men man NNS 42759 3626 20 to to TO 42759 3626 21 lend lend VB 42759 3626 22 the the DT 42759 3626 23 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3626 24 money money NN 42759 3626 25 to to TO 42759 3626 26 carry carry VB 42759 3626 27 on on RP 42759 3626 28 the the DT 42759 3626 29 process process NN 42759 3626 30 of of IN 42759 3626 31 exterminating exterminate VBG 42759 3626 32 competition competition NN 42759 3626 33 . . . 42759 3627 1 The the DT 42759 3627 2 process process NN 42759 3627 3 is be VBZ 42759 3627 4 maintained maintain VBN 42759 3627 5 by by IN 42759 3627 6 means mean NNS 42759 3627 7 of of IN 42759 3627 8 the the DT 42759 3627 9 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3627 10 prices price NNS 42759 3627 11 quite quite RB 42759 3627 12 as as RB 42759 3627 13 effectively effectively RB 42759 3627 14 as as IN 42759 3627 15 though though IN 42759 3627 16 the the DT 42759 3627 17 two two CD 42759 3627 18 things thing NNS 42759 3627 19 were be VBD 42759 3627 20 simultaneous simultaneous JJ 42759 3627 21 . . . 42759 3628 1 In in IN 42759 3628 2 so so RB 42759 3628 3 far far RB 42759 3628 4 as as IN 42759 3628 5 the the DT 42759 3628 6 patrons patron NNS 42759 3628 7 of of IN 42759 3628 8 the the DT 42759 3628 9 independent independent JJ 42759 3628 10 concerns concern NNS 42759 3628 11 are be VBP 42759 3628 12 deceived deceive VBN 42759 3628 13 into into IN 42759 3628 14 expecting expect VBG 42759 3628 15 that that IN 42759 3628 16 the the DT 42759 3628 17 very very RB 42759 3628 18 low low JJ 42759 3628 19 prices price NNS 42759 3628 20 will will MD 42759 3628 21 be be VB 42759 3628 22 permanent permanent JJ 42759 3628 23 , , , 42759 3628 24 and and CC 42759 3628 25 in in IN 42759 3628 26 so so RB 42759 3628 27 far far RB 42759 3628 28 as as IN 42759 3628 29 this this DT 42759 3628 30 impression impression NN 42759 3628 31 causes cause VBZ 42759 3628 32 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3628 33 to to TO 42759 3628 34 withdraw withdraw VB 42759 3628 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3628 36 patronage patronage NN 42759 3628 37 from from IN 42759 3628 38 the the DT 42759 3628 39 independents independent NNS 42759 3628 40 , , , 42759 3628 41 the the DT 42759 3628 42 latter latter JJ 42759 3628 43 are be VBP 42759 3628 44 injured injure VBN 42759 3628 45 through through IN 42759 3628 46 another another DT 42759 3628 47 illicit illicit NN 42759 3628 48 means mean VBZ 42759 3628 49 , , , 42759 3628 50 namely namely RB 42759 3628 51 , , , 42759 3628 52 deception deception NN 42759 3628 53 . . . 42759 3629 1 The the DT 42759 3629 2 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3629 3 have have VBP 42759 3629 4 a a DT 42759 3629 5 right right NN 42759 3629 6 not not RB 42759 3629 7 to to TO 42759 3629 8 be be VB 42759 3629 9 deprived deprive VBN 42759 3629 10 of of IN 42759 3629 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3629 12 customers customer NNS 42759 3629 13 through through IN 42759 3629 14 imposture imposture NN 42759 3629 15 . . . 42759 3630 1 What what WP 42759 3630 2 is be VBZ 42759 3630 3 the the DT 42759 3630 4 measure measure NN 42759 3630 5 of of IN 42759 3630 6 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3630 7 prices price NNS 42759 3630 8 in in IN 42759 3630 9 this this DT 42759 3630 10 connection connection NN 42759 3630 11 ? ? . 42759 3631 1 How how WRB 42759 3631 2 can can MD 42759 3631 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3631 4 know know VB 42759 3631 5 that that IN 42759 3631 6 the the DT 42759 3631 7 high high JJ 42759 3631 8 , , , 42759 3631 9 competition competition NN 42759 3631 10 - - HYPH 42759 3631 11 eliminating eliminate VBG 42759 3631 12 prices price NNS 42759 3631 13 are be VBP 42759 3631 14 really really RB 42759 3631 15 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3631 16 ? ? . 42759 3632 1 There there EX 42759 3632 2 are be VBP 42759 3632 3 only only RB 42759 3632 4 two two CD 42759 3632 5 possible possible JJ 42759 3632 6 tests test NNS 42759 3632 7 of of IN 42759 3632 8 just just JJ 42759 3632 9 price price NN 42759 3632 10 . . . 42759 3633 1 The the DT 42759 3633 2 first first JJ 42759 3633 3 is be VBZ 42759 3633 4 the the DT 42759 3633 5 proper proper JJ 42759 3633 6 cost cost NN 42759 3633 7 of of IN 42759 3633 8 production,--fair production,--fair NNP 42759 3633 9 wages wage NNS 42759 3633 10 to to IN 42759 3633 11 labour labour NN 42759 3633 12 , , , 42759 3633 13 fair fair JJ 42759 3633 14 prices price NNS 42759 3633 15 for for IN 42759 3633 16 materials material NNS 42759 3633 17 , , , 42759 3633 18 and and CC 42759 3633 19 fair fair JJ 42759 3633 20 interest interest NN 42759 3633 21 on on IN 42759 3633 22 capital capital NN 42759 3633 23 . . . 42759 3634 1 If if IN 42759 3634 2 the the DT 42759 3634 3 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3634 4 does do VBZ 42759 3634 5 not not RB 42759 3634 6 raise raise VB 42759 3634 7 prices price NNS 42759 3634 8 above above IN 42759 3634 9 this this DT 42759 3634 10 level level NN 42759 3634 11 , , , 42759 3634 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3634 13 obviously obviously RB 42759 3634 14 does do VBZ 42759 3634 15 not not RB 42759 3634 16 impose impose VB 42759 3634 17 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3634 18 prices price NNS 42759 3634 19 , , , 42759 3634 20 nor nor CC 42759 3634 21 inflict inflict VB 42759 3634 22 injustice injustice NN 42759 3634 23 upon upon IN 42759 3634 24 the the DT 42759 3634 25 eliminated eliminated JJ 42759 3634 26 competitor competitor NN 42759 3634 27 . . . 42759 3635 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 3635 2 , , , 42759 3635 3 if if IN 42759 3635 4 the the DT 42759 3635 5 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3635 6 has have VBZ 42759 3635 7 introduced introduce VBN 42759 3635 8 economies economy NNS 42759 3635 9 of of IN 42759 3635 10 production production NN 42759 3635 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3635 12 may may MD 42759 3635 13 , , , 42759 3635 14 as as IN 42759 3635 15 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3635 16 have have VBP 42759 3635 17 seen see VBN 42759 3635 18 , , , 42759 3635 19 justly justly RB 42759 3635 20 charge charge VB 42759 3635 21 prices price NNS 42759 3635 22 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 3635 23 above above IN 42759 3635 24 the the DT 42759 3635 25 cost cost NN 42759 3635 26 - - HYPH 42759 3635 27 of of IN 42759 3635 28 - - HYPH 42759 3635 29 production production NN 42759 3635 30 level level NN 42759 3635 31 . . . 42759 3636 1 But but CC 42759 3636 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3636 3 may may MD 42759 3636 4 not not RB 42759 3636 5 raise raise VB 42759 3636 6 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3636 7 above above IN 42759 3636 8 the the DT 42759 3636 9 level level NN 42759 3636 10 that that WDT 42759 3636 11 would would MD 42759 3636 12 have have VB 42759 3636 13 prevailed prevail VBN 42759 3636 14 under under IN 42759 3636 15 competition competition NN 42759 3636 16 . . . 42759 3637 1 This this DT 42759 3637 2 is be VBZ 42759 3637 3 the the DT 42759 3637 4 second second JJ 42759 3637 5 test test NN 42759 3637 6 of of IN 42759 3637 7 just just JJ 42759 3637 8 price price NN 42759 3637 9 . . . 42759 3638 1 No no DT 42759 3638 2 possible possible JJ 42759 3638 3 justification justification NN 42759 3638 4 can can MD 42759 3638 5 be be VB 42759 3638 6 found find VBN 42759 3638 7 , , , 42759 3638 8 except except IN 42759 3638 9 one one CD 42759 3638 10 to to TO 42759 3638 11 be be VB 42759 3638 12 mentioned mention VBN 42759 3638 13 presently presently RB 42759 3638 14 , , , 42759 3638 15 for for IN 42759 3638 16 charging charge VBG 42759 3638 17 the the DT 42759 3638 18 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3638 19 higher high JJR 42759 3638 20 prices price NNS 42759 3638 21 than than IN 42759 3638 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3638 23 could could MD 42759 3638 24 have have VB 42759 3638 25 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3638 26 under under IN 42759 3638 27 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3638 28 conditions condition NNS 42759 3638 29 . . . 42759 3639 1 At at IN 42759 3639 2 such such JJ 42759 3639 3 prices price NNS 42759 3639 4 the the DT 42759 3639 5 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3639 6 will will MD 42759 3639 7 be be VB 42759 3639 8 able able JJ 42759 3639 9 to to TO 42759 3639 10 secure secure VB 42759 3639 11 the the DT 42759 3639 12 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 3639 13 rate rate NN 42759 3639 14 of of IN 42759 3639 15 interest interest NN 42759 3639 16 on on IN 42759 3639 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3639 18 capital capital NN 42759 3639 19 , , , 42759 3639 20 and and CC 42759 3639 21 all all PDT 42759 3639 22 the the DT 42759 3639 23 surplus surplus NN 42759 3639 24 gains gain NNS 42759 3639 25 that that WDT 42759 3639 26 proceed proceed VBP 42759 3639 27 from from IN 42759 3639 28 superior superior JJ 42759 3639 29 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3639 30 . . . 42759 3640 1 A a DT 42759 3640 2 higher high JJR 42759 3640 3 scale scale NN 42759 3640 4 of of IN 42759 3640 5 prices price NNS 42759 3640 6 will will MD 42759 3640 7 be be VB 42759 3640 8 , , , 42759 3640 9 therefore therefore RB 42759 3640 10 , , , 42759 3640 11 extortionate extortionate NN 42759 3640 12 , , , 42759 3640 13 and and CC 42759 3640 14 the the DT 42759 3640 15 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3640 16 who who WP 42759 3640 17 are be VBP 42759 3640 18 eliminated eliminate VBN 42759 3640 19 through through IN 42759 3640 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3640 21 instrumentality instrumentality NN 42759 3640 22 will will MD 42759 3640 23 be be VB 42759 3640 24 the the DT 42759 3640 25 victims victim NNS 42759 3640 26 of of IN 42759 3640 27 injustice injustice NN 42759 3640 28 . . . 42759 3641 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3641 2 179 179 CD 42759 3641 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3641 4 The the DT 42759 3641 5 exception exception NN 42759 3641 6 alluded allude VBD 42759 3641 7 to to IN 42759 3641 8 above above RB 42759 3641 9 occurs occur VBZ 42759 3641 10 when when WRB 42759 3641 11 the the DT 42759 3641 12 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3641 13 uses use VBZ 42759 3641 14 the the DT 42759 3641 15 excess excess NN 42759 3641 16 which which WDT 42759 3641 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3641 18 obtains obtain VBZ 42759 3641 19 over over IN 42759 3641 20 the the DT 42759 3641 21 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3641 22 price price NN 42759 3641 23 to to TO 42759 3641 24 pay pay VB 42759 3641 25 fair fair JJ 42759 3641 26 wages wage NNS 42759 3641 27 to to IN 42759 3641 28 those those DT 42759 3641 29 labourers labourer NNS 42759 3641 30 who who WP 42759 3641 31 were be VBD 42759 3641 32 insufficiently insufficiently RB 42759 3641 33 compensated compensate VBN 42759 3641 34 in in IN 42759 3641 35 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3641 36 conditions condition NNS 42759 3641 37 . . . 42759 3642 1 In in IN 42759 3642 2 such such PDT 42759 3642 3 a a DT 42759 3642 4 case case NN 42759 3642 5 the the DT 42759 3642 6 eliminated eliminate VBN 42759 3642 7 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3642 8 would would MD 42759 3642 9 have have VB 42759 3642 10 no no DT 42759 3642 11 just just RB 42759 3642 12 claim claim NN 42759 3642 13 against against IN 42759 3642 14 the the DT 42759 3642 15 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3642 16 ; ; : 42759 3642 17 for for IN 42759 3642 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3642 19 elimination elimination NN 42759 3642 20 took take VBD 42759 3642 21 place place NN 42759 3642 22 in in IN 42759 3642 23 the the DT 42759 3642 24 just just JJ 42759 3642 25 interest interest NN 42759 3642 26 of of IN 42759 3642 27 the the DT 42759 3642 28 producers producer NNS 42759 3642 29 . . . 42759 3643 1 The the DT 42759 3643 2 case case NN 42759 3643 3 , , , 42759 3643 4 however however RB 42759 3643 5 , , , 42759 3643 6 is be VBZ 42759 3643 7 purely purely RB 42759 3643 8 academic academic JJ 42759 3643 9 , , , 42759 3643 10 since since IN 42759 3643 11 the the DT 42759 3643 12 discriminative discriminative JJ 42759 3643 13 underselling underselling NN 42759 3643 14 practised practise VBN 42759 3643 15 by by IN 42759 3643 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3643 17 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3643 18 concerns concern NNS 42759 3643 19 has have VBZ 42759 3643 20 not not RB 42759 3643 21 been be VBN 42759 3643 22 impelled impel VBN 42759 3643 23 by by IN 42759 3643 24 any any DT 42759 3643 25 such such JJ 42759 3643 26 motive motive NN 42759 3643 27 , , , 42759 3643 28 nor nor CC 42759 3643 29 has have VBZ 42759 3643 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3643 31 achieved achieve VBN 42759 3643 32 any any DT 42759 3643 33 such such JJ 42759 3643 34 result result NN 42759 3643 35 . . . 42759 3644 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3644 2 Exclusive Exclusive NNP 42759 3644 3 - - HYPH 42759 3644 4 Sales Sales NNP 42759 3644 5 Contracts contract NNS 42759 3644 6 _ _ NNP 42759 3644 7 The the DT 42759 3644 8 second second JJ 42759 3644 9 unfair unfair JJ 42759 3644 10 method method NN 42759 3644 11 employed employ VBN 42759 3644 12 by by IN 42759 3644 13 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3644 14 toward toward IN 42759 3644 15 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3644 16 is be VBZ 42759 3644 17 that that DT 42759 3644 18 of of IN 42759 3644 19 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 3644 20 - - HYPH 42759 3644 21 selling selling NN 42759 3644 22 contracts contract NNS 42759 3644 23 , , , 42759 3644 24 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3644 25 called call VBD 42759 3644 26 the the DT 42759 3644 27 " " `` 42759 3644 28 factor factor NN 42759 3644 29 's 's POS 42759 3644 30 agreement agreement NN 42759 3644 31 . . . 42759 3644 32 " " '' 42759 3645 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3645 2 requires require VBZ 42759 3645 3 the the DT 42759 3645 4 dealer dealer NN 42759 3645 5 , , , 42759 3645 6 merchant merchant NN 42759 3645 7 , , , 42759 3645 8 or or CC 42759 3645 9 jobber jobber NNP 42759 3645 10 to to TO 42759 3645 11 refrain refrain VB 42759 3645 12 from from IN 42759 3645 13 selling sell VBG 42759 3645 14 the the DT 42759 3645 15 goods good NNS 42759 3645 16 produced produce VBN 42759 3645 17 by by IN 42759 3645 18 independent independent JJ 42759 3645 19 concerns concern NNS 42759 3645 20 , , , 42759 3645 21 on on IN 42759 3645 22 penalty penalty NN 42759 3645 23 of of IN 42759 3645 24 being be VBG 42759 3645 25 refused refuse VBN 42759 3645 26 the the DT 42759 3645 27 goods good NNS 42759 3645 28 produced produce VBN 42759 3645 29 by by IN 42759 3645 30 the the DT 42759 3645 31 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3645 32 . . . 42759 3646 1 The the DT 42759 3646 2 merchant merchant NN 42759 3646 3 is be VBZ 42759 3646 4 compelled compel VBN 42759 3646 5 to to TO 42759 3646 6 choose choose VB 42759 3646 7 between between IN 42759 3646 8 the the DT 42759 3646 9 less less RBR 42759 3646 10 important important JJ 42759 3646 11 line line NN 42759 3646 12 of of IN 42759 3646 13 wares ware NNS 42759 3646 14 to to TO 42759 3646 15 be be VB 42759 3646 16 had have VBN 42759 3646 17 from from IN 42759 3646 18 the the DT 42759 3646 19 former former JJ 42759 3646 20 , , , 42759 3646 21 and and CC 42759 3646 22 the the DT 42759 3646 23 more more RBR 42759 3646 24 important important JJ 42759 3646 25 line line NN 42759 3646 26 obtainable obtainable JJ 42759 3646 27 from from IN 42759 3646 28 the the DT 42759 3646 29 latter latter JJ 42759 3646 30 . . . 42759 3647 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 3647 2 will will MD 42759 3647 3 not not RB 42759 3647 4 be be VB 42759 3647 5 permitted permit VBN 42759 3647 6 to to TO 42759 3647 7 handle handle VB 42759 3647 8 both both DT 42759 3647 9 . . . 42759 3648 1 " " `` 42759 3648 2 Here here RB 42759 3648 3 is be VBZ 42759 3648 4 somebody somebody NN 42759 3648 5 who who WP 42759 3648 6 has have VBZ 42759 3648 7 been be VBN 42759 3648 8 buying buy VBG 42759 3648 9 goods good NNS 42759 3648 10 , , , 42759 3648 11 let let VB 42759 3648 12 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3648 13 say say VB 42759 3648 14 , , , 42759 3648 15 by by IN 42759 3648 16 way way NN 42759 3648 17 of of IN 42759 3648 18 illustration illustration NN 42759 3648 19 , , , 42759 3648 20 from from IN 42759 3648 21 the the DT 42759 3648 22 American American NNP 42759 3648 23 Tobacco Tobacco NNP 42759 3648 24 Company Company NNP 42759 3648 25 , , , 42759 3648 26 and and CC 42759 3648 27 a a DT 42759 3648 28 rival rival JJ 42759 3648 29 producer producer NN 42759 3648 30 comes come VBZ 42759 3648 31 in in IN 42759 3648 32 whom whom WP 42759 3648 33 the the DT 42759 3648 34 merchant merchant NN 42759 3648 35 likes like VBZ 42759 3648 36 to to TO 42759 3648 37 patronise patronise VB 42759 3648 38 . . . 42759 3649 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 3649 2 buys buy VBZ 42759 3649 3 goods good NNS 42759 3649 4 for for IN 42759 3649 5 a a DT 42759 3649 6 time time NN 42759 3649 7 from from IN 42759 3649 8 the the DT 42759 3649 9 rival rival NN 42759 3649 10 , , , 42759 3649 11 and and CC 42759 3649 12 an an DT 42759 3649 13 agent agent NN 42759 3649 14 of of IN 42759 3649 15 the the DT 42759 3649 16 trust trust NN 42759 3649 17 sends send VBZ 42759 3649 18 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3649 19 a a DT 42759 3649 20 note note NN 42759 3649 21 to to IN 42759 3649 22 the the DT 42759 3649 23 effect effect NN 42759 3649 24 that that IN 42759 3649 25 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3649 26 must must MD 42759 3649 27 not not RB 42759 3649 28 buy buy VB 42759 3649 29 any any DT 42759 3649 30 more more RBR 42759 3649 31 from from IN 42759 3649 32 that that DT 42759 3649 33 rival rival JJ 42759 3649 34 corporation corporation NN 42759 3649 35 ; ; : 42759 3649 36 that that IN 42759 3649 37 , , , 42759 3649 38 if if IN 42759 3649 39 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3649 40 does do VBZ 42759 3649 41 so so RB 42759 3649 42 , , , 42759 3649 43 the the DT 42759 3649 44 trust trust NN 42759 3649 45 will will MD 42759 3649 46 give give VB 42759 3649 47 all all DT 42759 3649 48 of of IN 42759 3649 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3649 50 own own JJ 42759 3649 51 goods good NNS 42759 3649 52 , , , 42759 3649 53 some some DT 42759 3649 54 of of IN 42759 3649 55 which which WDT 42759 3649 56 the the DT 42759 3649 57 merchant merchant NN 42759 3649 58 is be VBZ 42759 3649 59 obliged oblige VBN 42759 3649 60 to to TO 42759 3649 61 have have VB 42759 3649 62 , , , 42759 3649 63 to to IN 42759 3649 64 another another DT 42759 3649 65 agent agent NN 42759 3649 66 . . . 42759 3650 1 That that DT 42759 3650 2 will will MD 42759 3650 3 probably probably RB 42759 3650 4 bring bring VB 42759 3650 5 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3650 6 to to IN 42759 3650 7 terms term NNS 42759 3650 8 . . . 42759 3651 1 " " `` 42759 3651 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3651 3 180 180 CD 42759 3651 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3651 5 By by IN 42759 3651 6 this this DT 42759 3651 7 method method NN 42759 3651 8 the the DT 42759 3651 9 independent independent JJ 42759 3651 10 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 3651 11 can can MD 42759 3651 12 be be VB 42759 3651 13 deprived deprive VBN 42759 3651 14 of of IN 42759 3651 15 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3651 16 patronage patronage NN 42759 3651 17 to to TO 42759 3651 18 injure injure VB 42759 3651 19 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3651 20 seriously seriously RB 42759 3651 21 , , , 42759 3651 22 and and CC 42759 3651 23 perhaps perhaps RB 42759 3651 24 to to TO 42759 3651 25 drive drive VB 42759 3651 26 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3651 27 out out IN 42759 3651 28 of of IN 42759 3651 29 business business NN 42759 3651 30 . . . 42759 3652 1 This this DT 42759 3652 2 process process NN 42759 3652 3 is be VBZ 42759 3652 4 one one CD 42759 3652 5 of of IN 42759 3652 6 intimidation intimidation NN 42759 3652 7 brought bring VBN 42759 3652 8 to to TO 42759 3652 9 bear bear VB 42759 3652 10 upon upon IN 42759 3652 11 the the DT 42759 3652 12 merchant merchant NN 42759 3652 13 . . . 42759 3653 1 Through through IN 42759 3653 2 fear fear NN 42759 3653 3 of of IN 42759 3653 4 loss loss NN 42759 3653 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3653 6 is be VBZ 42759 3653 7 compelled compel VBN 42759 3653 8 to to TO 42759 3653 9 discontinue discontinue VB 42759 3653 10 selling sell VBG 42759 3653 11 the the DT 42759 3653 12 goods good NNS 42759 3653 13 of of IN 42759 3653 14 the the DT 42759 3653 15 competing compete VBG 42759 3653 16 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 3653 17 . . . 42759 3654 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3654 2 is be VBZ 42759 3654 3 a a DT 42759 3654 4 kind kind NN 42759 3654 5 of of IN 42759 3654 6 secondary secondary JJ 42759 3654 7 boycott boycott NN 42759 3654 8 . . . 42759 3655 1 As as IN 42759 3655 2 such such JJ 42759 3655 3 , , , 42759 3655 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3655 5 is be VBZ 42759 3655 6 an an DT 42759 3655 7 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 3655 8 interference interference NN 42759 3655 9 with with IN 42759 3655 10 the the DT 42759 3655 11 liberty liberty NN 42759 3655 12 of of IN 42759 3655 13 the the DT 42759 3655 14 merchant merchant NN 42759 3655 15 unless unless IN 42759 3655 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3655 17 object object NN 42759 3655 18 is be VBZ 42759 3655 19 to to TO 42759 3655 20 compel compel VB 42759 3655 21 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3655 22 to to TO 42759 3655 23 do do VB 42759 3655 24 something something NN 42759 3655 25 that that WDT 42759 3655 26 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3655 27 may may MD 42759 3655 28 be be VB 42759 3655 29 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 3655 30 required require VBN 42759 3655 31 to to TO 42759 3655 32 do do VB 42759 3655 33 . . . 42759 3656 1 In in IN 42759 3656 2 the the DT 42759 3656 3 case case NN 42759 3656 4 that that IN 42759 3656 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3656 6 are be VBP 42759 3656 7 considering consider VBG 42759 3656 8 , , , 42759 3656 9 the the DT 42759 3656 10 object object NN 42759 3656 11 of of IN 42759 3656 12 the the DT 42759 3656 13 pressure pressure NN 42759 3656 14 is be VBZ 42759 3656 15 not not RB 42759 3656 16 of of IN 42759 3656 17 that that DT 42759 3656 18 character character NN 42759 3656 19 ; ; , 42759 3656 20 for for IN 42759 3656 21 to to TO 42759 3656 22 drive drive VB 42759 3656 23 the the DT 42759 3656 24 rival rival JJ 42759 3656 25 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 3656 26 out out IN 42759 3656 27 of of IN 42759 3656 28 business business NN 42759 3656 29 , , , 42759 3656 30 or or CC 42759 3656 31 to to TO 42759 3656 32 assist assist VB 42759 3656 33 in in IN 42759 3656 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3656 35 expulsion expulsion NN 42759 3656 36 , , , 42759 3656 37 is be VBZ 42759 3656 38 not not RB 42759 3656 39 a a DT 42759 3656 40 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3656 41 thing thing NN 42759 3656 42 . . . 42759 3657 1 The the DT 42759 3657 2 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 3657 3 - - HYPH 42759 3657 4 selling sell VBG 42759 3657 5 contract contract NN 42759 3657 6 which which WDT 42759 3657 7 is be VBZ 42759 3657 8 forced force VBN 42759 3657 9 upon upon IN 42759 3657 10 the the DT 42759 3657 11 merchant merchant NN 42759 3657 12 is be VBZ 42759 3657 13 quite quite RB 42759 3657 14 as as RB 42759 3657 15 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 3657 16 as as IN 42759 3657 17 though though IN 42759 3657 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3657 19 purpose purpose NN 42759 3657 20 were be VBD 42759 3657 21 to to TO 42759 3657 22 prevent prevent VB 42759 3657 23 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3657 24 from from IN 42759 3657 25 , , , 42759 3657 26 say say UH 42759 3657 27 , , , 42759 3657 28 patronising patronise VBG 42759 3657 29 manufacturers manufacturer NNS 42759 3657 30 having have VBG 42759 3657 31 red red JJ 42759 3657 32 hair hair NN 42759 3657 33 . . . 42759 3658 1 Being be VBG 42759 3658 2 thus thus RB 42759 3658 3 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 3658 4 , , , 42759 3658 5 thus thus RB 42759 3658 6 injurious injurious JJ 42759 3658 7 to to IN 42759 3658 8 individual individual JJ 42759 3658 9 liberty liberty NN 42759 3658 10 , , , 42759 3658 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3658 12 violates violate VBZ 42759 3658 13 not not RB 42759 3658 14 only only RB 42759 3658 15 the the DT 42759 3658 16 law law NN 42759 3658 17 of of IN 42759 3658 18 charity charity NN 42759 3658 19 but but CC 42759 3658 20 that that DT 42759 3658 21 of of IN 42759 3658 22 justice justice NN 42759 3658 23 . . . 42759 3659 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3659 2 transgresses transgress VBZ 42759 3659 3 the the DT 42759 3659 4 merchant merchant NN 42759 3659 5 's 's POS 42759 3659 6 right right NN 42759 3659 7 to to TO 42759 3659 8 enter enter VB 42759 3659 9 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3659 10 contracts contract NNS 42759 3659 11 with with IN 42759 3659 12 the the DT 42759 3659 13 rival rival JJ 42759 3659 14 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 3659 15 , , , 42759 3659 16 and and CC 42759 3659 17 if if IN 42759 3659 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3659 19 results result VBZ 42759 3659 20 in in IN 42759 3659 21 a a DT 42759 3659 22 pecuniary pecuniary JJ 42759 3659 23 loss loss NN 42759 3659 24 to to IN 42759 3659 25 the the DT 42759 3659 26 former former JJ 42759 3659 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3659 28 is be VBZ 42759 3659 29 an an DT 42759 3659 30 invasion invasion NN 42759 3659 31 of of IN 42759 3659 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3659 33 rights right NNS 42759 3659 34 of of IN 42759 3659 35 property property NN 42759 3659 36 . . . 42759 3660 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3660 2 likewise likewise RB 42759 3660 3 violates violate VBZ 42759 3660 4 the the DT 42759 3660 5 rights right NNS 42759 3660 6 of of IN 42759 3660 7 the the DT 42759 3660 8 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3660 9 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 3660 10 , , , 42759 3660 11 since since IN 42759 3660 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3660 13 is be VBZ 42759 3660 14 among among IN 42759 3660 15 the the DT 42759 3660 16 unfair unfair JJ 42759 3660 17 means mean NNS 42759 3660 18 which which WDT 42759 3660 19 may may MD 42759 3660 20 not not RB 42759 3660 21 be be VB 42759 3660 22 used use VBN 42759 3660 23 to to TO 42759 3660 24 prevent prevent VB 42759 3660 25 a a DT 42759 3660 26 man man NN 42759 3660 27 from from IN 42759 3660 28 pursuing pursue VBG 42759 3660 29 a a DT 42759 3660 30 legitimate legitimate JJ 42759 3660 31 good good NN 42759 3660 32 . . . 42759 3661 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3661 2 is be VBZ 42759 3661 3 an an DT 42759 3661 4 unfair unfair JJ 42759 3661 5 means mean NNS 42759 3661 6 because because IN 42759 3661 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3661 8 involves involve VBZ 42759 3661 9 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 3661 10 intimidation intimidation NN 42759 3661 11 , , , 42759 3661 12 uncharity uncharity NN 42759 3661 13 , , , 42759 3661 14 and and CC 42759 3661 15 injustice injustice NN 42759 3661 16 toward toward IN 42759 3661 17 the the DT 42759 3661 18 merchant merchant NN 42759 3661 19 . . . 42759 3662 1 When when WRB 42759 3662 2 the the DT 42759 3662 3 independent independent JJ 42759 3662 4 manufacturer manufacturer NN 42759 3662 5 is be VBZ 42759 3662 6 injured injure VBN 42759 3662 7 through through IN 42759 3662 8 such such PDT 42759 3662 9 an an DT 42759 3662 10 instrumentality instrumentality NN 42759 3662 11 , , , 42759 3662 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3662 13 suffers suffer VBZ 42759 3662 14 injustice injustice NN 42759 3662 15 quite quite RB 42759 3662 16 as as RB 42759 3662 17 certainly certainly RB 42759 3662 18 at at IN 42759 3662 19 the the DT 42759 3662 20 hands hand NNS 42759 3662 21 of of IN 42759 3662 22 the the DT 42759 3662 23 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3662 24 as as IN 42759 3662 25 though though IN 42759 3662 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3662 27 property property NN 42759 3662 28 were be VBD 42759 3662 29 destroyed destroy VBN 42759 3662 30 through through IN 42759 3662 31 the the DT 42759 3662 32 strong strong JJ 42759 3662 33 - - HYPH 42759 3662 34 arm arm NN 42759 3662 35 methods method NNS 42759 3662 36 of of IN 42759 3662 37 hired hire VBN 42759 3662 38 thugs thug NNS 42759 3662 39 . . . 42759 3663 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3663 2 Discriminative Discriminative NNP 42759 3663 3 Transportation Transportation NNP 42759 3663 4 Arrangements Arrangements NNPS 42759 3663 5 _ _ NNP 42759 3663 6 Concerning concern VBG 42759 3663 7 the the DT 42759 3663 8 third third JJ 42759 3663 9 unfair unfair JJ 42759 3663 10 method method NN 42759 3663 11 , , , 42759 3663 12 discriminative discriminative JJ 42759 3663 13 advantages advantage NNS 42759 3663 14 in in IN 42759 3663 15 transportation transportation NN 42759 3663 16 , , , 42759 3663 17 the the DT 42759 3663 18 United United NNP 42759 3663 19 States States NNP 42759 3663 20 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 3663 21 Commission Commission NNP 42759 3663 22 declared declare VBD 42759 3663 23 : : : 42759 3663 24 " " `` 42759 3663 25 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3663 26 is be VBZ 42759 3663 27 incontestable incontestable JJ 42759 3663 28 that that IN 42759 3663 29 many many JJ 42759 3663 30 of of IN 42759 3663 31 the the DT 42759 3663 32 great great JJ 42759 3663 33 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3663 34 combinations combination NNS 42759 3663 35 had have VBD 42759 3663 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3663 37 origin origin NN 42759 3663 38 in in IN 42759 3663 39 railroad railroad NN 42759 3663 40 discrimination discrimination NN 42759 3663 41 . . . 42759 3664 1 This this DT 42759 3664 2 has have VBZ 42759 3664 3 been be VBN 42759 3664 4 emphasised emphasise VBN 42759 3664 5 many many JJ 42759 3664 6 times time NNS 42759 3664 7 in in IN 42759 3664 8 the the DT 42759 3664 9 history history NN 42759 3664 10 of of IN 42759 3664 11 the the DT 42759 3664 12 Standard Standard NNP 42759 3664 13 Oil Oil NNP 42759 3664 14 Company Company NNP 42759 3664 15 , , , 42759 3664 16 and and CC 42759 3664 17 of of IN 42759 3664 18 the the DT 42759 3664 19 great great JJ 42759 3664 20 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3664 21 dealing deal VBG 42759 3664 22 in in IN 42759 3664 23 live live JJ 42759 3664 24 stock stock NN 42759 3664 25 , , , 42759 3664 26 dressed dressed JJ 42759 3664 27 beef beef NN 42759 3664 28 , , , 42759 3664 29 and and CC 42759 3664 30 other other JJ 42759 3664 31 products product NNS 42759 3664 32 . . . 42759 3665 1 " " `` 42759 3665 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3665 3 181 181 CD 42759 3665 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3665 5 The the DT 42759 3665 6 American American NNP 42759 3665 7 Sugar Sugar NNP 42759 3665 8 Refining Refining NNP 42759 3665 9 Company Company NNP 42759 3665 10 has have VBZ 42759 3665 11 been be VBN 42759 3665 12 several several JJ 42759 3665 13 times time NNS 42759 3665 14 convicted convict VBN 42759 3665 15 of of IN 42759 3665 16 receiving receive VBG 42759 3665 17 illegal illegal JJ 42759 3665 18 favours favour NNS 42759 3665 19 from from IN 42759 3665 20 railroads railroad NNS 42759 3665 21 , , , 42759 3665 22 and and CC 42759 3665 23 has have VBZ 42759 3665 24 paid pay VBN 42759 3665 25 in in IN 42759 3665 26 fines fine NNS 42759 3665 27 thousands thousand NNS 42759 3665 28 upon upon IN 42759 3665 29 thousands thousand NNS 42759 3665 30 of of IN 42759 3665 31 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3665 32 . . . 42759 3666 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3666 2 the the DT 42759 3666 3 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3666 4 has have VBZ 42759 3666 5 openly openly RB 42759 3666 6 been be VBN 42759 3666 7 accorded accord VBN 42759 3666 8 lower low JJR 42759 3666 9 freight freight NN 42759 3666 10 rates rate NNS 42759 3666 11 than than IN 42759 3666 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3666 13 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3666 14 , , , 42759 3666 15 and and CC 42759 3666 16 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3666 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3666 18 has have VBZ 42759 3666 19 paid pay VBN 42759 3666 20 the the DT 42759 3666 21 regular regular JJ 42759 3666 22 charges charge NNS 42759 3666 23 , , , 42759 3666 24 and and CC 42759 3666 25 then then RB 42759 3666 26 received receive VBD 42759 3666 27 back back RB 42759 3666 28 a a DT 42759 3666 29 part part NN 42759 3666 30 of of IN 42759 3666 31 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3666 32 as as IN 42759 3666 33 a a DT 42759 3666 34 refund refund NN 42759 3666 35 or or CC 42759 3666 36 rebate rebate NN 42759 3666 37 . . . 42759 3667 1 At at IN 42759 3667 2 one one CD 42759 3667 3 time time NN 42759 3667 4 the the DT 42759 3667 5 Standard Standard NNP 42759 3667 6 Oil Oil NNP 42759 3667 7 Company Company NNP 42759 3667 8 obtained obtain VBD 42759 3667 9 rebates rebate NNS 42759 3667 10 not not RB 42759 3667 11 only only RB 42759 3667 12 on on IN 42759 3667 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3667 14 own own JJ 42759 3667 15 shipments shipment NNS 42759 3667 16 , , , 42759 3667 17 but but CC 42759 3667 18 on on IN 42759 3667 19 those those DT 42759 3667 20 of of IN 42759 3667 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3667 22 rivals rival NNS 42759 3667 23 ! ! . 42759 3668 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3668 2 182 182 CD 42759 3668 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3668 4 Special special JJ 42759 3668 5 advantages advantage NNS 42759 3668 6 of of IN 42759 3668 7 this this DT 42759 3668 8 sort sort NN 42759 3668 9 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 3668 10 involve involve VBP 42759 3668 11 injustice injustice NN 42759 3668 12 to to IN 42759 3668 13 the the DT 42759 3668 14 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3668 15 of of IN 42759 3668 16 the the DT 42759 3668 17 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3668 18 . . . 42759 3669 1 If if IN 42759 3669 2 the the DT 42759 3669 3 low low JJ 42759 3669 4 rates rate NNS 42759 3669 5 given give VBN 42759 3669 6 to to IN 42759 3669 7 the the DT 42759 3669 8 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3669 9 concern concern NN 42759 3669 10 are be VBP 42759 3669 11 a a DT 42759 3669 12 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3669 13 high high JJ 42759 3669 14 price price NN 42759 3669 15 for for IN 42759 3669 16 the the DT 42759 3669 17 service service NN 42759 3669 18 of of IN 42759 3669 19 carrying carry VBG 42759 3669 20 freight freight NN 42759 3669 21 , , , 42759 3669 22 the the DT 42759 3669 23 higher high JJR 42759 3669 24 charges charge NNS 42759 3669 25 imposed impose VBN 42759 3669 26 upon upon IN 42759 3669 27 the the DT 42759 3669 28 competing compete VBG 42759 3669 29 concerns concern NNS 42759 3669 30 are be VBP 42759 3669 31 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3669 32 ; ; : 42759 3669 33 if if IN 42759 3669 34 the the DT 42759 3669 35 former former JJ 42759 3669 36 rates rate NNS 42759 3669 37 are be VBP 42759 3669 38 unprofitably unprofitably RB 42759 3669 39 low low JJ 42759 3669 40 , , , 42759 3669 41 the the DT 42759 3669 42 difference difference NN 42759 3669 43 between between IN 42759 3669 44 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3669 45 and and CC 42759 3669 46 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 3669 47 freight freight NN 42759 3669 48 charges charge NNS 42759 3669 49 is be VBZ 42759 3669 50 made make VBN 42759 3669 51 up up RP 42759 3669 52 by by IN 42759 3669 53 the the DT 42759 3669 54 independent independent JJ 42759 3669 55 concerns concern NNS 42759 3669 56 . . . 42759 3670 1 In in IN 42759 3670 2 the the DT 42759 3670 3 former former JJ 42759 3670 4 case case NN 42759 3670 5 the the DT 42759 3670 6 independents independent NNS 42759 3670 7 pay pay VB 42759 3670 8 the the DT 42759 3670 9 railroad railroad NN 42759 3670 10 too too RB 42759 3670 11 much much RB 42759 3670 12 ; ; : 42759 3670 13 in in IN 42759 3670 14 the the DT 42759 3670 15 latter latter JJ 42759 3670 16 case case NN 42759 3670 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3670 18 bear bear VBP 42759 3670 19 burdens burden NNS 42759 3670 20 that that WDT 42759 3670 21 should should MD 42759 3670 22 properly properly RB 42759 3670 23 rest rest VB 42759 3670 24 upon upon IN 42759 3670 25 the the DT 42759 3670 26 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3670 27 . . . 42759 3671 1 The the DT 42759 3671 2 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3671 3 concern concern NN 42759 3671 4 is be VBZ 42759 3671 5 partly partly RB 42759 3671 6 responsible responsible JJ 42759 3671 7 for for IN 42759 3671 8 this this DT 42759 3671 9 injustice injustice NN 42759 3671 10 inasmuch inasmuch NN 42759 3671 11 as as IN 42759 3671 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3671 13 urges urge VBZ 42759 3671 14 and and CC 42759 3671 15 often often RB 42759 3671 16 intimidates intimidate VBZ 42759 3671 17 the the DT 42759 3671 18 railroad railroad NN 42759 3671 19 to to TO 42759 3671 20 establish establish VB 42759 3671 21 the the DT 42759 3671 22 discriminating discriminate VBG 42759 3671 23 rates rate NNS 42759 3671 24 . . . 42759 3672 1 All all DT 42759 3672 2 three three CD 42759 3672 3 of of IN 42759 3672 4 the the DT 42759 3672 5 practices practice NNS 42759 3672 6 that that WDT 42759 3672 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3672 8 have have VBP 42759 3672 9 been be VBN 42759 3672 10 considering consider VBG 42759 3672 11 are be VBP 42759 3672 12 universally universally RB 42759 3672 13 condemned condemn VBN 42759 3672 14 by by IN 42759 3672 15 public public JJ 42759 3672 16 sentiment sentiment NN 42759 3672 17 . . . 42759 3673 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3673 2 are be VBP 42759 3673 3 all all RB 42759 3673 4 likewise likewise RB 42759 3673 5 under under IN 42759 3673 6 the the DT 42759 3673 7 ban ban NN 42759 3673 8 of of IN 42759 3673 9 statutory statutory JJ 42759 3673 10 law law NN 42759 3673 11 . . . 42759 3674 1 The the DT 42759 3674 2 first first JJ 42759 3674 3 two two CD 42759 3674 4 have have VBP 42759 3674 5 recently recently RB 42759 3674 6 received receive VBN 42759 3674 7 detailed detailed JJ 42759 3674 8 and and CC 42759 3674 9 explicit explicit JJ 42759 3674 10 prohibition prohibition NN 42759 3674 11 in in IN 42759 3674 12 the the DT 42759 3674 13 Clayton Clayton NNP 42759 3674 14 Anti Anti NNP 42759 3674 15 - - NNP 42759 3674 16 Trust Trust NNP 42759 3674 17 Act Act NNP 42759 3674 18 . . . 42759 3675 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3675 2 Natural Natural NNP 42759 3675 3 Monopolies Monopolies NNPS 42759 3675 4 _ _ NNP 42759 3675 5 Up up RP 42759 3675 6 to to IN 42759 3675 7 this this DT 42759 3675 8 point point NN 42759 3675 9 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3675 10 have have VBP 42759 3675 11 been be VBN 42759 3675 12 dealing deal VBG 42759 3675 13 with with IN 42759 3675 14 private private JJ 42759 3675 15 and and CC 42759 3675 16 artificial artificial JJ 42759 3675 17 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3675 18 . . . 42759 3676 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 3676 2 turn turn VBP 42759 3676 3 now now RB 42759 3676 4 to to TO 42759 3676 5 consider consider VB 42759 3676 6 briefly briefly RB 42759 3676 7 those those DT 42759 3676 8 natural natural JJ 42759 3676 9 and and CC 42759 3676 10 quasi quasi JJ 42759 3676 11 - - JJ 42759 3676 12 public public JJ 42759 3676 13 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3676 14 which which WDT 42759 3676 15 are be VBP 42759 3676 16 either either CC 42759 3676 17 tacitly tacitly RB 42759 3676 18 or or CC 42759 3676 19 explicitly explicitly RB 42759 3676 20 recognised recognise VBN 42759 3676 21 as as IN 42759 3676 22 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3676 23 by by IN 42759 3676 24 public public JJ 42759 3676 25 authority authority NN 42759 3676 26 , , , 42759 3676 27 and and CC 42759 3676 28 whose whose WP$ 42759 3676 29 charges charge NNS 42759 3676 30 are be VBP 42759 3676 31 to to IN 42759 3676 32 a a DT 42759 3676 33 greater great JJR 42759 3676 34 or or CC 42759 3676 35 less less RBR 42759 3676 36 extent extent NN 42759 3676 37 regulated regulate VBN 42759 3676 38 by by IN 42759 3676 39 some some DT 42759 3676 40 department department NN 42759 3676 41 of of IN 42759 3676 42 the the DT 42759 3676 43 State State NNP 42759 3676 44 . . . 42759 3677 1 Such such JJ 42759 3677 2 are be VBP 42759 3677 3 , , , 42759 3677 4 for for IN 42759 3677 5 example example NN 42759 3677 6 ; ; : 42759 3677 7 steam steam NN 42759 3677 8 railroads railroad NNS 42759 3677 9 and and CC 42759 3677 10 municipal municipal JJ 42759 3677 11 utilities utility NNS 42759 3677 12 . . . 42759 3678 1 When when WRB 42759 3678 2 the the DT 42759 3678 3 charges charge NNS 42759 3678 4 made make VBN 42759 3678 5 for for IN 42759 3678 6 the the DT 42759 3678 7 services service NNS 42759 3678 8 of of IN 42759 3678 9 these these DT 42759 3678 10 corporations corporation NNS 42759 3678 11 are be VBP 42759 3678 12 _ _ NNP 42759 3678 13 adequately adequately RB 42759 3678 14 _ _ NNP 42759 3678 15 regulated regulate VBN 42759 3678 16 by by IN 42759 3678 17 public public JJ 42759 3678 18 authority authority NN 42759 3678 19 , , , 42759 3678 20 the the DT 42759 3678 21 owners owner NNS 42759 3678 22 of of IN 42759 3678 23 such such JJ 42759 3678 24 concerns concern NNS 42759 3678 25 will will MD 42759 3678 26 have have VB 42759 3678 27 a a DT 42759 3678 28 right right NN 42759 3678 29 to to IN 42759 3678 30 all all PDT 42759 3678 31 the the DT 42759 3678 32 surplus surplus NN 42759 3678 33 gains gain NNS 42759 3678 34 that that IN 42759 3678 35 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3678 36 can can MD 42759 3678 37 obtain obtain VB 42759 3678 38 . . . 42759 3679 1 In in IN 42759 3679 2 that that DT 42759 3679 3 case case NN 42759 3679 4 a a DT 42759 3679 5 contract contract NN 42759 3679 6 is be VBZ 42759 3679 7 made make VBN 42759 3679 8 between between IN 42759 3679 9 the the DT 42759 3679 10 corporation corporation NN 42759 3679 11 and and CC 42759 3679 12 the the DT 42759 3679 13 public public NN 42759 3679 14 which which WDT 42759 3679 15 is be VBZ 42759 3679 16 presumably presumably RB 42759 3679 17 fair fair JJ 42759 3679 18 to to IN 42759 3679 19 both both DT 42759 3679 20 parties party NNS 42759 3679 21 , , , 42759 3679 22 and and CC 42759 3679 23 which which WDT 42759 3679 24 represents represent VBZ 42759 3679 25 the the DT 42759 3679 26 social social JJ 42759 3679 27 estimate estimate NN 42759 3679 28 of of IN 42759 3679 29 what what WP 42759 3679 30 is be VBZ 42759 3679 31 just just RB 42759 3679 32 . . . 42759 3680 1 If if IN 42759 3680 2 the the DT 42759 3680 3 public public JJ 42759 3680 4 authorities authority NNS 42759 3680 5 have have VBP 42759 3680 6 not not RB 42759 3680 7 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3680 8 safeguarded safeguard VBN 42759 3680 9 the the DT 42759 3680 10 interests interest NNS 42759 3680 11 of of IN 42759 3680 12 the the DT 42759 3680 13 people people NNS 42759 3680 14 , , , 42759 3680 15 if if IN 42759 3680 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3680 17 have have VBP 42759 3680 18 permitted permit VBN 42759 3680 19 the the DT 42759 3680 20 charges charge NNS 42759 3680 21 to to TO 42759 3680 22 be be VB 42759 3680 23 so so RB 42759 3680 24 high high JJ 42759 3680 25 as as IN 42759 3680 26 to to TO 42759 3680 27 provide provide VB 42759 3680 28 excessive excessive JJ 42759 3680 29 returns return NNS 42759 3680 30 for for IN 42759 3680 31 the the DT 42759 3680 32 corporation corporation NN 42759 3680 33 , , , 42759 3680 34 the the DT 42759 3680 35 latter latter JJ 42759 3680 36 is be VBZ 42759 3680 37 under under IN 42759 3680 38 no no DT 42759 3680 39 moral moral JJ 42759 3680 40 obligation obligation NN 42759 3680 41 to to TO 42759 3680 42 refrain refrain VB 42759 3680 43 from from IN 42759 3680 44 reaping reap VBG 42759 3680 45 the the DT 42759 3680 46 full full JJ 42759 3680 47 benefit benefit NN 42759 3680 48 of of IN 42759 3680 49 the the DT 42759 3680 50 State State NNP 42759 3680 51 's 's POS 42759 3680 52 negligence negligence NN 42759 3680 53 or or CC 42759 3680 54 incompetence incompetence NN 42759 3680 55 . . . 42759 3681 1 If if IN 42759 3681 2 , , , 42759 3681 3 however however RB 42759 3681 4 , , , 42759 3681 5 the the DT 42759 3681 6 unduly unduly RB 42759 3681 7 high high JJ 42759 3681 8 rates rate NNS 42759 3681 9 have have VBP 42759 3681 10 been be VBN 42759 3681 11 brought bring VBN 42759 3681 12 about about RP 42759 3681 13 through through IN 42759 3681 14 bribery bribery NN 42759 3681 15 , , , 42759 3681 16 extortion extortion NN 42759 3681 17 , , , 42759 3681 18 or or CC 42759 3681 19 deception deception NN 42759 3681 20 practised practise VBN 42759 3681 21 by by IN 42759 3681 22 the the DT 42759 3681 23 corporation corporation NN 42759 3681 24 , , , 42759 3681 25 the the DT 42759 3681 26 inequitable inequitable JJ 42759 3681 27 contract contract NN 42759 3681 28 thus thus RB 42759 3681 29 arranged arrange VBD 42759 3681 30 will will MD 42759 3681 31 not not RB 42759 3681 32 justify justify VB 42759 3681 33 the the DT 42759 3681 34 surplus surplus NN 42759 3681 35 gains gain NNS 42759 3681 36 thus thus RB 42759 3681 37 produced produce VBN 42759 3681 38 . . . 42759 3682 1 For for IN 42759 3682 2 example example NN 42759 3682 3 ; ; : 42759 3682 4 if if IN 42759 3682 5 the the DT 42759 3682 6 corporation corporation NN 42759 3682 7 deliberately deliberately RB 42759 3682 8 and and CC 42759 3682 9 effectively effectively RB 42759 3682 10 conceals conceal NNS 42759 3682 11 the the DT 42759 3682 12 real real JJ 42759 3682 13 value value NN 42759 3682 14 of of IN 42759 3682 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3682 16 property property NN 42759 3682 17 through through IN 42759 3682 18 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 3682 19 , , , 42759 3682 20 and and CC 42759 3682 21 thus thus RB 42759 3682 22 misleads mislead VBZ 42759 3682 23 the the DT 42759 3682 24 public public JJ 42759 3682 25 authority authority NN 42759 3682 26 into into IN 42759 3682 27 permitting permit VBG 42759 3682 28 charges charge NNS 42759 3682 29 which which WDT 42759 3682 30 return return VBP 42759 3682 31 twelve twelve NN 42759 3682 32 instead instead RB 42759 3682 33 of of IN 42759 3682 34 six six CD 42759 3682 35 per per IN 42759 3682 36 cent cent NN 42759 3682 37 . . . 42759 3683 1 on on IN 42759 3683 2 the the DT 42759 3683 3 actual actual JJ 42759 3683 4 investment investment NN 42759 3683 5 , , , 42759 3683 6 the the DT 42759 3683 7 corporation corporation NN 42759 3683 8 can can MD 42759 3683 9 not not RB 42759 3683 10 forthwith forthwith VB 42759 3683 11 justly justly RB 42759 3683 12 claim claim VB 42759 3683 13 the the DT 42759 3683 14 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3683 15 gain gain NN 42759 3683 16 represented represent VBN 42759 3683 17 by by IN 42759 3683 18 the the DT 42759 3683 19 extra extra JJ 42759 3683 20 six six CD 42759 3683 21 per per IN 42759 3683 22 cent cent NN 42759 3683 23 . . . 42759 3684 1 When when WRB 42759 3684 2 the the DT 42759 3684 3 public public JJ 42759 3684 4 authorities authority NNS 42759 3684 5 either either CC 42759 3684 6 fail fail VBP 42759 3684 7 entirely entirely RB 42759 3684 8 to to TO 42759 3684 9 regulate regulate VB 42759 3684 10 charges charge NNS 42759 3684 11 , , , 42759 3684 12 or or CC 42759 3684 13 do do VBP 42759 3684 14 so so RB 42759 3684 15 only only RB 42759 3684 16 spasmodically spasmodically RB 42759 3684 17 and and CC 42759 3684 18 partially partially RB 42759 3684 19 , , , 42759 3684 20 the the DT 42759 3684 21 quasi quasi JJ 42759 3684 22 - - JJ 42759 3684 23 public public JJ 42759 3684 24 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3684 25 will will MD 42759 3684 26 not not RB 42759 3684 27 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 3684 28 have have VB 42759 3684 29 a a DT 42759 3684 30 right right NN 42759 3684 31 to to IN 42759 3684 32 all all PDT 42759 3684 33 the the DT 42759 3684 34 obtainable obtainable JJ 42759 3684 35 surplus surplus NN 42759 3684 36 gains gain NNS 42759 3684 37 . . . 42759 3685 1 For for IN 42759 3685 2 a a DT 42759 3685 3 long long JJ 42759 3685 4 time time NN 42759 3685 5 the the DT 42759 3685 6 express express JJ 42759 3685 7 companies company NNS 42759 3685 8 of of IN 42759 3685 9 the the DT 42759 3685 10 United United NNP 42759 3685 11 States States NNP 42759 3685 12 were be VBD 42759 3685 13 permitted permit VBN 42759 3685 14 to to TO 42759 3685 15 exact exact VB 42759 3685 16 what what WP 42759 3685 17 charges charge NNS 42759 3685 18 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3685 19 pleased please VBD 42759 3685 20 , , , 42759 3685 21 and and CC 42759 3685 22 even even RB 42759 3685 23 yet yet RB 42759 3685 24 the the DT 42759 3685 25 rates rate NNS 42759 3685 26 on on IN 42759 3685 27 some some DT 42759 3685 28 of of IN 42759 3685 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3685 30 railroads railroad NNS 42759 3685 31 are be VBP 42759 3685 32 not not RB 42759 3685 33 adequately adequately RB 42759 3685 34 regulated regulate VBN 42759 3685 35 by by IN 42759 3685 36 the the DT 42759 3685 37 State State NNP 42759 3685 38 . . . 42759 3686 1 In in IN 42759 3686 2 such such JJ 42759 3686 3 cases case NNS 42759 3686 4 the the DT 42759 3686 5 charges charge NNS 42759 3686 6 imposed impose VBN 42759 3686 7 on on IN 42759 3686 8 the the DT 42759 3686 9 public public NN 42759 3686 10 are be VBP 42759 3686 11 not not RB 42759 3686 12 an an DT 42759 3686 13 adequate adequate JJ 42759 3686 14 expression expression NN 42759 3686 15 of of IN 42759 3686 16 the the DT 42759 3686 17 social social JJ 42759 3686 18 estimate estimate NN 42759 3686 19 of of IN 42759 3686 20 justice justice NN 42759 3686 21 , , , 42759 3686 22 nor nor CC 42759 3686 23 an an DT 42759 3686 24 adequate adequate JJ 42759 3686 25 basis basis NN 42759 3686 26 of of IN 42759 3686 27 legitimate legitimate JJ 42759 3686 28 surplus surplus NN 42759 3686 29 gains gain NNS 42759 3686 30 . . . 42759 3687 1 In in IN 42759 3687 2 the the DT 42759 3687 3 absence absence NN 42759 3687 4 of of IN 42759 3687 5 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3687 6 public public JJ 42759 3687 7 regulation regulation NN 42759 3687 8 , , , 42759 3687 9 a a DT 42759 3687 10 quasi quasi JJ 42759 3687 11 - - JJ 42759 3687 12 public public JJ 42759 3687 13 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3687 14 is be VBZ 42759 3687 15 morally morally RB 42759 3687 16 bound bind VBN 42759 3687 17 to to TO 42759 3687 18 fix fix VB 42759 3687 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3687 20 charges charge NNS 42759 3687 21 at at IN 42759 3687 22 such such PDT 42759 3687 23 a a DT 42759 3687 24 level level NN 42759 3687 25 as as IN 42759 3687 26 will will MD 42759 3687 27 enable enable VB 42759 3687 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3687 29 to to TO 42759 3687 30 obtain obtain VB 42759 3687 31 only only RB 42759 3687 32 the the DT 42759 3687 33 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 3687 34 rate rate NN 42759 3687 35 of of IN 42759 3687 36 interest interest NN 42759 3687 37 on on IN 42759 3687 38 the the DT 42759 3687 39 investment investment NN 42759 3687 40 , , , 42759 3687 41 and and CC 42759 3687 42 such such JJ 42759 3687 43 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3687 44 gains gain NNS 42759 3687 45 as as IN 42759 3687 46 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3687 47 can can MD 42759 3687 48 produce produce VB 42759 3687 49 through through IN 42759 3687 50 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 3687 51 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3687 52 . . . 42759 3688 1 In in IN 42759 3688 2 all all DT 42759 3688 3 such such JJ 42759 3688 4 cases case NNS 42759 3688 5 the the DT 42759 3688 6 public public JJ 42759 3688 7 service service NN 42759 3688 8 corporation corporation NN 42759 3688 9 is be VBZ 42759 3688 10 in in IN 42759 3688 11 the the DT 42759 3688 12 same same JJ 42759 3688 13 moral moral JJ 42759 3688 14 position position NN 42759 3688 15 as as IN 42759 3688 16 the the DT 42759 3688 17 artificial artificial JJ 42759 3688 18 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3688 19 : : : 42759 3688 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3688 21 has have VBZ 42759 3688 22 no no DT 42759 3688 23 possible possible JJ 42759 3688 24 basis basis NN 42759 3688 25 except except IN 42759 3688 26 superior superior JJ 42759 3688 27 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3688 28 for for IN 42759 3688 29 claiming claim VBG 42759 3688 30 or or CC 42759 3688 31 getting get VBG 42759 3688 32 any any DT 42759 3688 33 returns return NNS 42759 3688 34 above above IN 42759 3688 35 the the DT 42759 3688 36 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3688 37 rate rate NN 42759 3688 38 of of IN 42759 3688 39 interest interest NN 42759 3688 40 on on IN 42759 3688 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3688 42 capital capital NN 42759 3688 43 . . . 42759 3689 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3689 2 only only JJ 42759 3689 3 possible possible JJ 42759 3689 4 reason reason NN 42759 3689 5 for for IN 42759 3689 6 obtaining obtain VBG 42759 3689 7 more more JJR 42759 3689 8 is be VBZ 42759 3689 9 the the DT 42759 3689 10 fact fact NN 42759 3689 11 that that IN 42759 3689 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3689 13 has have VBZ 42759 3689 14 the the DT 42759 3689 15 power power NN 42759 3689 16 to to TO 42759 3689 17 take take VB 42759 3689 18 more more JJR 42759 3689 19 . . . 42759 3690 1 This this DT 42759 3690 2 fact fact NN 42759 3690 3 has have VBZ 42759 3690 4 obviously obviously RB 42759 3690 5 no no DT 42759 3690 6 moral moral JJ 42759 3690 7 validity validity NN 42759 3690 8 . . . 42759 3691 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3691 2 Methods Methods NNPS 42759 3691 3 of of IN 42759 3691 4 Preventing Preventing NNP 42759 3691 5 Monopolistic Monopolistic NNP 42759 3691 6 Injustice Injustice NNP 42759 3691 7 _ _ NNP 42759 3691 8 How how WRB 42759 3691 9 shall shall MD 42759 3691 10 the the DT 42759 3691 11 injustices injustice NNS 42759 3691 12 of of IN 42759 3691 13 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3691 14 be be VB 42759 3691 15 prevented prevent VBN 42759 3691 16 in in IN 42759 3691 17 the the DT 42759 3691 18 future future NN 42759 3691 19 ? ? . 42759 3692 1 So so RB 42759 3692 2 far far RB 42759 3692 3 as as IN 42759 3692 4 quasi quasi JJ 42759 3692 5 - - JJ 42759 3692 6 public public JJ 42759 3692 7 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3692 8 are be VBP 42759 3692 9 concerned concern VBN 42759 3692 10 , , , 42759 3692 11 all all DT 42759 3692 12 students student NNS 42759 3692 13 of of IN 42759 3692 14 the the DT 42759 3692 15 subject subject NN 42759 3692 16 are be VBP 42759 3692 17 now now RB 42759 3692 18 agreed agree VBN 42759 3692 19 that that IN 42759 3692 20 these these DT 42759 3692 21 should should MD 42759 3692 22 be be VB 42759 3692 23 permitted permit VBN 42759 3692 24 to to TO 42759 3692 25 exist exist VB 42759 3692 26 under under IN 42759 3692 27 adequate adequate JJ 42759 3692 28 governmental governmental JJ 42759 3692 29 regulation regulation NN 42759 3692 30 as as IN 42759 3692 31 to to IN 42759 3692 32 prices price NNS 42759 3692 33 and and CC 42759 3692 34 service service NN 42759 3692 35 . . . 42759 3693 1 The the DT 42759 3693 2 reason reason NN 42759 3693 3 is be VBZ 42759 3693 4 that that IN 42759 3693 5 in in IN 42759 3693 6 this this DT 42759 3693 7 field field NN 42759 3693 8 successful successful JJ 42759 3693 9 and and CC 42759 3693 10 useful useful JJ 42759 3693 11 competition competition NN 42759 3693 12 is be VBZ 42759 3693 13 impossible impossible JJ 42759 3693 14 . . . 42759 3694 1 Public public JJ 42759 3694 2 utility utility NN 42759 3694 3 corporations corporation NNS 42759 3694 4 are be VBP 42759 3694 5 natural natural JJ 42759 3694 6 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3694 7 , , , 42759 3694 8 and and CC 42759 3694 9 must must MD 42759 3694 10 be be VB 42759 3694 11 dealt deal VBN 42759 3694 12 with with IN 42759 3694 13 by by IN 42759 3694 14 the the DT 42759 3694 15 method method NN 42759 3694 16 of of IN 42759 3694 17 regulation regulation NN 42759 3694 18 until until IN 42759 3694 19 such such JJ 42759 3694 20 time time NN 42759 3694 21 as as IN 42759 3694 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3694 23 are be VBP 42759 3694 24 brought bring VBN 42759 3694 25 under under IN 42759 3694 26 the the DT 42759 3694 27 ownership ownership NN 42759 3694 28 and and CC 42759 3694 29 operation operation NN 42759 3694 30 of of IN 42759 3694 31 the the DT 42759 3694 32 State State NNP 42759 3694 33 . . . 42759 3695 1 With with IN 42759 3695 2 regard regard NN 42759 3695 3 to to IN 42759 3695 4 the the DT 42759 3695 5 great great JJ 42759 3695 6 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3695 7 combinations combination NNS 42759 3695 8 which which WDT 42759 3695 9 have have VBP 42759 3695 10 become become VBN 42759 3695 11 or or CC 42759 3695 12 threaten threaten VB 42759 3695 13 to to TO 42759 3695 14 become become VB 42759 3695 15 artificial artificial JJ 42759 3695 16 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3695 17 , , , 42759 3695 18 there there EX 42759 3695 19 exists exist VBZ 42759 3695 20 substantial substantial JJ 42759 3695 21 agreement agreement NN 42759 3695 22 among among IN 42759 3695 23 competent competent JJ 42759 3695 24 authorities authority NNS 42759 3695 25 on on IN 42759 3695 26 one one CD 42759 3695 27 point point NN 42759 3695 28 , , , 42759 3695 29 and and CC 42759 3695 30 disagreement disagreement NN 42759 3695 31 on on IN 42759 3695 32 another another DT 42759 3695 33 point point NN 42759 3695 34 . . . 42759 3696 1 All all DT 42759 3696 2 admit admit VBP 42759 3696 3 that that IN 42759 3696 4 the the DT 42759 3696 5 unfair unfair JJ 42759 3696 6 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3696 7 methods method NNS 42759 3696 8 described describe VBN 42759 3696 9 in in IN 42759 3696 10 an an DT 42759 3696 11 earlier early JJR 42759 3696 12 part part NN 42759 3696 13 of of IN 42759 3696 14 this this DT 42759 3696 15 chapter chapter NN 42759 3696 16 should should MD 42759 3696 17 be be VB 42759 3696 18 stringently stringently RB 42759 3696 19 prohibited prohibit VBN 42759 3696 20 . . . 42759 3697 1 No no DT 42759 3697 2 possible possible JJ 42759 3697 3 reason reason NN 42759 3697 4 can can MD 42759 3697 5 be be VB 42759 3697 6 found find VBN 42759 3697 7 for for IN 42759 3697 8 legal legal JJ 42759 3697 9 toleration toleration NN 42759 3697 10 of of IN 42759 3697 11 these these DT 42759 3697 12 or or CC 42759 3697 13 any any DT 42759 3697 14 other other JJ 42759 3697 15 discriminative discriminative JJ 42759 3697 16 , , , 42759 3697 17 uncharitable uncharitable JJ 42759 3697 18 , , , 42759 3697 19 or or CC 42759 3697 20 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3697 21 practices practice NNS 42759 3697 22 on on IN 42759 3697 23 the the DT 42759 3697 24 part part NN 42759 3697 25 of of IN 42759 3697 26 stronger strong JJR 42759 3697 27 toward toward IN 42759 3697 28 weaker weak JJR 42759 3697 29 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3697 30 . . . 42759 3698 1 The the DT 42759 3698 2 disagreement disagreement NN 42759 3698 3 among among IN 42759 3698 4 students student NNS 42759 3698 5 of of IN 42759 3698 6 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3698 7 relates relate VBZ 42759 3698 8 to to IN 42759 3698 9 the the DT 42759 3698 10 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 3698 11 question question NN 42759 3698 12 of of IN 42759 3698 13 permitting permit VBG 42759 3698 14 or or CC 42759 3698 15 not not RB 42759 3698 16 permitting permit VBG 42759 3698 17 these these DT 42759 3698 18 combinations combination NNS 42759 3698 19 to to TO 42759 3698 20 exist exist VB 42759 3698 21 . . . 42759 3699 1 According accord VBG 42759 3699 2 to to IN 42759 3699 3 the the DT 42759 3699 4 first first JJ 42759 3699 5 theory theory NN 42759 3699 6 , , , 42759 3699 7 of of IN 42759 3699 8 which which WDT 42759 3699 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 42759 3699 10 Justice Justice NNP 42759 3699 11 Brandeis Brandeis NNP 42759 3699 12 is be VBZ 42759 3699 13 the the DT 42759 3699 14 most most RBS 42759 3699 15 distinguished distinguished JJ 42759 3699 16 exponent exponent NN 42759 3699 17 , , , 42759 3699 18 no no DT 42759 3699 19 new new JJ 42759 3699 20 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3699 21 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3699 22 should should MD 42759 3699 23 be be VB 42759 3699 24 permitted permit VBN 42759 3699 25 , , , 42759 3699 26 and and CC 42759 3699 27 those those DT 42759 3699 28 that that WDT 42759 3699 29 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3699 30 have have VBP 42759 3699 31 should should MD 42759 3699 32 be be VB 42759 3699 33 dissolved dissolve VBN 42759 3699 34 . . . 42759 3700 1 The the DT 42759 3700 2 basis basis NN 42759 3700 3 of of IN 42759 3700 4 this this DT 42759 3700 5 theory theory NN 42759 3700 6 is be VBZ 42759 3700 7 the the DT 42759 3700 8 assumption assumption NN 42759 3700 9 that that IN 42759 3700 10 all all PDT 42759 3700 11 the the DT 42759 3700 12 economies economy NNS 42759 3700 13 and and CC 42759 3700 14 all all PDT 42759 3700 15 the the DT 42759 3700 16 productive productive JJ 42759 3700 17 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3700 18 found find VBN 42759 3700 19 in in IN 42759 3700 20 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3700 21 concerns concern NNS 42759 3700 22 can can MD 42759 3700 23 be be VB 42759 3700 24 developed develop VBN 42759 3700 25 and and CC 42759 3700 26 maintained maintain VBN 42759 3700 27 in in IN 42759 3700 28 smaller small JJR 42759 3700 29 business business NN 42759 3700 30 organisations organisation NNS 42759 3700 31 , , , 42759 3700 32 and and CC 42759 3700 33 that that IN 42759 3700 34 the the DT 42759 3700 35 method method NN 42759 3700 36 of of IN 42759 3700 37 prevention prevention NN 42759 3700 38 and and CC 42759 3700 39 dissolution dissolution NN 42759 3700 40 is be VBZ 42759 3700 41 the the DT 42759 3700 42 simplest simple JJS 42759 3700 43 means mean NNS 42759 3700 44 of of IN 42759 3700 45 protecting protect VBG 42759 3700 46 the the DT 42759 3700 47 public public NN 42759 3700 48 against against IN 42759 3700 49 the the DT 42759 3700 50 danger danger NN 42759 3700 51 of of IN 42759 3700 52 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3700 53 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3700 54 prices price NNS 42759 3700 55 . . . 42759 3701 1 Attention attention NN 42759 3701 2 has have VBZ 42759 3701 3 been be VBN 42759 3701 4 called call VBN 42759 3701 5 in in IN 42759 3701 6 a a DT 42759 3701 7 preceding precede VBG 42759 3701 8 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 3701 9 to to IN 42759 3701 10 the the DT 42759 3701 11 impossibility impossibility NN 42759 3701 12 of of IN 42759 3701 13 determining determine VBG 42759 3701 14 whether whether IN 42759 3701 15 the the DT 42759 3701 16 great great JJ 42759 3701 17 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3701 18 combinations combination NNS 42759 3701 19 have have VBP 42759 3701 20 on on IN 42759 3701 21 the the DT 42759 3701 22 average average NN 42759 3701 23 shown show VBN 42759 3701 24 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 3701 25 to to TO 42759 3701 26 be be VB 42759 3701 27 more more RBR 42759 3701 28 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3701 29 than than IN 42759 3701 30 concerns concern NNS 42759 3701 31 subject subject JJ 42759 3701 32 to to IN 42759 3701 33 active active JJ 42759 3701 34 and and CC 42759 3701 35 adequate adequate JJ 42759 3701 36 competition competition NN 42759 3701 37 . . . 42759 3702 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3702 2 is be VBZ 42759 3702 3 significant significant JJ 42759 3702 4 , , , 42759 3702 5 however however RB 42759 3702 6 , , , 42759 3702 7 that that IN 42759 3702 8 in in IN 42759 3702 9 the the DT 42759 3702 10 discussion discussion NN 42759 3702 11 of of IN 42759 3702 12 this this DT 42759 3702 13 subject subject NN 42759 3702 14 which which WDT 42759 3702 15 took take VBD 42759 3702 16 place place NN 42759 3702 17 at at IN 42759 3702 18 the the DT 42759 3702 19 twenty twenty CD 42759 3702 20 - - HYPH 42759 3702 21 sixth sixth JJ 42759 3702 22 annual annual JJ 42759 3702 23 meeting meeting NN 42759 3702 24 of of IN 42759 3702 25 the the DT 42759 3702 26 American American NNP 42759 3702 27 Economic Economic NNP 42759 3702 28 Association Association NNP 42759 3702 29 , , , 42759 3702 30 at at IN 42759 3702 31 Minneapolis Minneapolis NNP 42759 3702 32 in in IN 42759 3702 33 1913 1913 CD 42759 3702 34 , , , 42759 3702 35 the the DT 42759 3702 36 economists economist NNS 42759 3702 37 who who WP 42759 3702 38 participated participate VBD 42759 3702 39 were be VBD 42759 3702 40 practically practically RB 42759 3702 41 unanimous unanimous JJ 42759 3702 42 in in IN 42759 3702 43 holding hold VBG 42759 3702 44 that that IN 42759 3702 45 the the DT 42759 3702 46 superior superior JJ 42759 3702 47 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3702 48 of of IN 42759 3702 49 the the DT 42759 3702 50 trusts trust NNS 42759 3702 51 had have VBD 42759 3702 52 not not RB 42759 3702 53 been be VBN 42759 3702 54 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 42759 3702 55 , , , 42759 3702 56 but but CC 42759 3702 57 was be VBD 42759 3702 58 a a DT 42759 3702 59 matter matter NN 42759 3702 60 of of IN 42759 3702 61 serious serious JJ 42759 3702 62 doubt doubt NN 42759 3702 63 , , , 42759 3702 64 and and CC 42759 3702 65 that that IN 42759 3702 66 the the DT 42759 3702 67 burden burden NN 42759 3702 68 of of IN 42759 3702 69 proof proof NN 42759 3702 70 of of IN 42759 3702 71 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3702 72 alleged allege VBN 42759 3702 73 superiority superiority NN 42759 3702 74 had have VBD 42759 3702 75 been be VBN 42759 3702 76 definitely definitely RB 42759 3702 77 shifted shift VBN 42759 3702 78 upon upon IN 42759 3702 79 those those DT 42759 3702 80 who who WP 42759 3702 81 maintained maintain VBD 42759 3702 82 the the DT 42759 3702 83 affirmative affirmative NN 42759 3702 84 . . . 42759 3703 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3703 2 183 183 CD 42759 3703 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3703 4 Probably probably RB 42759 3703 5 the the DT 42759 3703 6 great great JJ 42759 3703 7 majority majority NN 42759 3703 8 of of IN 42759 3703 9 the the DT 42759 3703 10 whole whole JJ 42759 3703 11 body body NN 42759 3703 12 of of IN 42759 3703 13 American american JJ 42759 3703 14 economists economist NNS 42759 3703 15 would would MD 42759 3703 16 share share VB 42759 3703 17 these these DT 42759 3703 18 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 3703 19 . . . 42759 3704 1 On on IN 42759 3704 2 the the DT 42759 3704 3 other other JJ 42759 3704 4 hand hand NN 42759 3704 5 , , , 42759 3704 6 the the DT 42759 3704 7 opponents opponent NNS 42759 3704 8 of of IN 42759 3704 9 prevention prevention NN 42759 3704 10 and and CC 42759 3704 11 dissolution dissolution NN 42759 3704 12 , , , 42759 3704 13 of of IN 42759 3704 14 whom whom WP 42759 3704 15 Mr. Mr. NNP 42759 3704 16 George George NNP 42759 3704 17 W. W. NNP 42759 3704 18 Perkins Perkins NNP 42759 3704 19 is be VBZ 42759 3704 20 probably probably RB 42759 3704 21 the the DT 42759 3704 22 most most RBS 42759 3704 23 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 42759 3704 24 , , , 42759 3704 25 point point NN 42759 3704 26 to to IN 42759 3704 27 the the DT 42759 3704 28 obvious obvious JJ 42759 3704 29 economies economy NNS 42759 3704 30 of of IN 42759 3704 31 large large JJ 42759 3704 32 - - HYPH 42759 3704 33 scale scale NN 42759 3704 34 over over IN 42759 3704 35 small small JJ 42759 3704 36 - - HYPH 42759 3704 37 scale scale NN 42759 3704 38 production production NN 42759 3704 39 , , , 42759 3704 40 and and CC 42759 3704 41 contend contend VBP 42759 3704 42 that that IN 42759 3704 43 these these DT 42759 3704 44 are be VBP 42759 3704 45 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3704 46 reason reason NN 42759 3704 47 for for IN 42759 3704 48 permitting permit VBG 42759 3704 49 and and CC 42759 3704 50 even even RB 42759 3704 51 encouraging encourage VBG 42759 3704 52 the the DT 42759 3704 53 great great JJ 42759 3704 54 combinations combination NNS 42759 3704 55 . . . 42759 3705 1 The the DT 42759 3705 2 power power NN 42759 3705 3 to to TO 42759 3705 4 oppress oppress VB 42759 3705 5 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3705 6 by by IN 42759 3705 7 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3705 8 methods method NNS 42759 3705 9 of of IN 42759 3705 10 business business NN 42759 3705 11 , , , 42759 3705 12 and and CC 42759 3705 13 the the DT 42759 3705 14 public public NN 42759 3705 15 by by IN 42759 3705 16 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3705 17 prices price NNS 42759 3705 18 , , , 42759 3705 19 should should MD 42759 3705 20 be be VB 42759 3705 21 kept keep VBN 42759 3705 22 under under IN 42759 3705 23 rigid rigid JJ 42759 3705 24 control control NN 42759 3705 25 by by IN 42759 3705 26 supervision supervision NN 42759 3705 27 , , , 42759 3705 28 and and CC 42759 3705 29 government government NN 42759 3705 30 regulation regulation NN 42759 3705 31 of of IN 42759 3705 32 maximum maximum JJ 42759 3705 33 prices price NNS 42759 3705 34 . . . 42759 3706 1 But but CC 42759 3706 2 the the DT 42759 3706 3 arguments argument NNS 42759 3706 4 advanced advance VBD 42759 3706 5 in in IN 42759 3706 6 favour favour NN 42759 3706 7 of of IN 42759 3706 8 this this DT 42759 3706 9 position position NN 42759 3706 10 are be VBP 42759 3706 11 never never RB 42759 3706 12 conclusive conclusive JJ 42759 3706 13 . . . 42759 3707 1 Most Most JJS 42759 3707 2 of of IN 42759 3707 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3707 4 advocates advocate NNS 42759 3707 5 fail fail VBP 42759 3707 6 to to TO 42759 3707 7 realise realise VB 42759 3707 8 , , , 42759 3707 9 or or CC 42759 3707 10 at at IN 42759 3707 11 least least JJS 42759 3707 12 to to TO 42759 3707 13 take take VB 42759 3707 14 adequately adequately RB 42759 3707 15 into into IN 42759 3707 16 account account NN 42759 3707 17 , , , 42759 3707 18 the the DT 42759 3707 19 difference difference NN 42759 3707 20 between between IN 42759 3707 21 large large JJ 42759 3707 22 - - HYPH 42759 3707 23 scale scale NN 42759 3707 24 production production NN 42759 3707 25 and and CC 42759 3707 26 production production NN 42759 3707 27 by by IN 42759 3707 28 a a DT 42759 3707 29 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3707 30 . . . 42759 3708 1 While while IN 42759 3708 2 the the DT 42759 3708 3 large large JJ 42759 3708 4 plant plant NN 42759 3708 5 and and CC 42759 3708 6 the the DT 42759 3708 7 large large JJ 42759 3708 8 business business NN 42759 3708 9 organisation organisation NN 42759 3708 10 have have VBP 42759 3708 11 in in IN 42759 3708 12 many many JJ 42759 3708 13 lines line NNS 42759 3708 14 of of IN 42759 3708 15 manufacture manufacture NN 42759 3708 16 and and CC 42759 3708 17 trade trade NN 42759 3708 18 a a DT 42759 3708 19 considerable considerable JJ 42759 3708 20 advantage advantage NN 42759 3708 21 over over IN 42759 3708 22 the the DT 42759 3708 23 small small JJ 42759 3708 24 plant plant NN 42759 3708 25 and and CC 42759 3708 26 the the DT 42759 3708 27 small small JJ 42759 3708 28 organisation organisation NN 42759 3708 29 , , , 42759 3708 30 there there EX 42759 3708 31 is be VBZ 42759 3708 32 not not RB 42759 3708 33 a a DT 42759 3708 34 scintilla scintilla NN 42759 3708 35 of of IN 42759 3708 36 evidence evidence NN 42759 3708 37 to to TO 42759 3708 38 show show VB 42759 3708 39 that that IN 42759 3708 40 the the DT 42759 3708 41 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3708 42 of of IN 42759 3708 43 magnitude magnitude NN 42759 3708 44 increases increase VBZ 42759 3708 45 indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 3708 46 with with IN 42759 3708 47 magnitude magnitude NN 42759 3708 48 . . . 42759 3709 1 There there EX 42759 3709 2 is be VBZ 42759 3709 3 no no DT 42759 3709 4 proof proof NN 42759 3709 5 that that IN 42759 3709 6 the the DT 42759 3709 7 maximum maximum JJ 42759 3709 8 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3709 9 is be VBZ 42759 3709 10 reached reach VBN 42759 3709 11 only only RB 42759 3709 12 with with IN 42759 3709 13 the the DT 42759 3709 14 maximum maximum JJ 42759 3709 15 size size NN 42759 3709 16 of of IN 42759 3709 17 the the DT 42759 3709 18 business business NN 42759 3709 19 unit unit NN 42759 3709 20 . . . 42759 3710 1 On on IN 42759 3710 2 the the DT 42759 3710 3 contrary contrary NN 42759 3710 4 , , , 42759 3710 5 all all PDT 42759 3710 6 the the DT 42759 3710 7 evidence evidence NN 42759 3710 8 that that IN 42759 3710 9 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3710 10 have have VBP 42759 3710 11 points point NNS 42759 3710 12 to to IN 42759 3710 13 the the DT 42759 3710 14 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 3710 15 that that IN 42759 3710 16 in in IN 42759 3710 17 every every DT 42759 3710 18 field field NN 42759 3710 19 of of IN 42759 3710 20 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3710 21 and and CC 42759 3710 22 commercial commercial JJ 42759 3710 23 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3710 24 , , , 42759 3710 25 all all PDT 42759 3710 26 the the DT 42759 3710 27 economies economy NNS 42759 3710 28 of of IN 42759 3710 29 magnitude magnitude NN 42759 3710 30 and and CC 42759 3710 31 of of IN 42759 3710 32 combination combination NN 42759 3710 33 are be VBP 42759 3710 34 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3710 35 long long RB 42759 3710 36 before before IN 42759 3710 37 the the DT 42759 3710 38 concern concern NN 42759 3710 39 becomes become VBZ 42759 3710 40 a a DT 42759 3710 41 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3710 42 . . . 42759 3711 1 There there EX 42759 3711 2 is be VBZ 42759 3711 3 not not RB 42759 3711 4 an an DT 42759 3711 5 industry industry NN 42759 3711 6 of of IN 42759 3711 7 any any DT 42759 3711 8 importance importance NN 42759 3711 9 in in IN 42759 3711 10 the the DT 42759 3711 11 United United NNP 42759 3711 12 States States NNP 42759 3711 13 in in IN 42759 3711 14 which which WDT 42759 3711 15 all all PDT 42759 3711 16 the the DT 42759 3711 17 advantages advantage NNS 42759 3711 18 of of IN 42759 3711 19 bigness bigness NN 42759 3711 20 and and CC 42759 3711 21 concentration concentration NN 42759 3711 22 can can MD 42759 3711 23 not not RB 42759 3711 24 be be VB 42759 3711 25 made make VBN 42759 3711 26 operative operative JJ 42759 3711 27 in in IN 42759 3711 28 concerns concern NNS 42759 3711 29 that that DT 42759 3711 30 control control NN 42759 3711 31 as as RB 42759 3711 32 low low JJ 42759 3711 33 as as IN 42759 3711 34 twenty twenty CD 42759 3711 35 - - HYPH 42759 3711 36 five five CD 42759 3711 37 per per IN 42759 3711 38 cent cent NN 42759 3711 39 . . . 42759 3712 1 of of IN 42759 3712 2 the the DT 42759 3712 3 total total JJ 42759 3712 4 product product NN 42759 3712 5 . . . 42759 3713 1 The the DT 42759 3713 2 highest high JJS 42759 3713 3 economy economy NN 42759 3713 4 and and CC 42759 3713 5 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3713 6 can can MD 42759 3713 7 be be VB 42759 3713 8 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3713 9 without without IN 42759 3713 10 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3713 11 . . . 42759 3714 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 3714 2 , , , 42759 3714 3 this this DT 42759 3714 4 is be VBZ 42759 3714 5 admitted admit VBN 42759 3714 6 by by IN 42759 3714 7 the the DT 42759 3714 8 more more RBR 42759 3714 9 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3714 10 advocates advocate NNS 42759 3714 11 of of IN 42759 3714 12 the the DT 42759 3714 13 regulation regulation NN 42759 3714 14 and and CC 42759 3714 15 price price NN 42759 3714 16 - - HYPH 42759 3714 17 fixing fix VBG 42759 3714 18 policy policy NN 42759 3714 19 . . . 42759 3715 1 While while IN 42759 3715 2 maintaining maintain VBG 42759 3715 3 that that IN 42759 3715 4 " " `` 42759 3715 5 concentration concentration NN 42759 3715 6 must must MD 42759 3715 7 go go VB 42759 3715 8 far far RB 42759 3715 9 in in IN 42759 3715 10 order order NN 42759 3715 11 to to TO 42759 3715 12 give give VB 42759 3715 13 the the DT 42759 3715 14 maximum maximum NN 42759 3715 15 of of IN 42759 3715 16 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3715 17 , , , 42759 3715 18 " " '' 42759 3715 19 President President NNP 42759 3715 20 Van Van NNP 42759 3715 21 Hise Hise NNP 42759 3715 22 does do VBZ 42759 3715 23 not not RB 42759 3715 24 hold hold VB 42759 3715 25 " " `` 42759 3715 26 that that IN 42759 3715 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3715 28 should should MD 42759 3715 29 go go VB 42759 3715 30 to to IN 42759 3715 31 the the DT 42759 3715 32 extent extent NN 42759 3715 33 that that IN 42759 3715 34 the the DT 42759 3715 35 element element NN 42759 3715 36 of of IN 42759 3715 37 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3715 38 enters enter NNS 42759 3715 39 " " '' 42759 3715 40 ; ; : 42759 3715 41 and and CC 42759 3715 42 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3715 43 would would MD 42759 3715 44 have have VB 42759 3715 45 the the DT 42759 3715 46 law law NN 42759 3715 47 " " `` 42759 3715 48 declare declare NN 42759 3715 49 restraint restraint NN 42759 3715 50 of of IN 42759 3715 51 trade trade NN 42759 3715 52 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 3715 53 that that WDT 42759 3715 54 gets get VBZ 42759 3715 55 to to IN 42759 3715 56 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3715 57 , , , 42759 3715 58 " " '' 42759 3715 59 and and CC 42759 3715 60 fix fix VB 42759 3715 61 the the DT 42759 3715 62 definite definite NN 42759 3715 63 per per IN 42759 3715 64 cent cent NN 42759 3715 65 . . . 42759 3716 1 of of IN 42759 3716 2 business business NN 42759 3716 3 control control NN 42759 3716 4 which which WDT 42759 3716 5 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 3716 6 a a DT 42759 3716 7 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3716 8 . . . 42759 3717 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3717 2 184 184 CD 42759 3717 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3717 4 We -PRON- PRP 42759 3717 5 are be VBP 42759 3717 6 justified justified JJ 42759 3717 7 , , , 42759 3717 8 therefore therefore RB 42759 3717 9 , , , 42759 3717 10 in in IN 42759 3717 11 concluding conclude VBG 42759 3717 12 that that IN 42759 3717 13 the the DT 42759 3717 14 theory theory NN 42759 3717 15 of of IN 42759 3717 16 prevention prevention NN 42759 3717 17 and and CC 42759 3717 18 dissolution dissolution NN 42759 3717 19 ( ( -LRB- 42759 3717 20 provided provide VBN 42759 3717 21 that that IN 42759 3717 22 the the DT 42759 3717 23 competing compete VBG 42759 3717 24 units unit NNS 42759 3717 25 are be VBP 42759 3717 26 not not RB 42759 3717 27 made make VBN 42759 3717 28 so so RB 42759 3717 29 small small JJ 42759 3717 30 as as IN 42759 3717 31 to to TO 42759 3717 32 destroy destroy VB 42759 3717 33 the the DT 42759 3717 34 certain certain JJ 42759 3717 35 economies economy NNS 42759 3717 36 of of IN 42759 3717 37 magnitude magnitude NN 42759 3717 38 ) ) -RRB- 42759 3717 39 rather rather RB 42759 3717 40 than than IN 42759 3717 41 the the DT 42759 3717 42 theory theory NN 42759 3717 43 of of IN 42759 3717 44 permission permission NN 42759 3717 45 and and CC 42759 3717 46 regulation regulation NN 42759 3717 47 , , , 42759 3717 48 indicates indicate VBZ 42759 3717 49 the the DT 42759 3717 50 sound sound JJ 42759 3717 51 economic economic JJ 42759 3717 52 and and CC 42759 3717 53 social social JJ 42759 3717 54 policy policy NN 42759 3717 55 of of IN 42759 3717 56 dealing deal VBG 42759 3717 57 with with IN 42759 3717 58 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3717 59 . . . 42759 3718 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3718 2 Legalised Legalised NNP 42759 3718 3 Price Price NNP 42759 3718 4 Agreements Agreements NNPS 42759 3718 5 _ _ NNP 42759 3718 6 President President NNP 42759 3718 7 Van Van NNP 42759 3718 8 Hise Hise NNP 42759 3718 9 advocates advocate VBZ 42759 3718 10 the the DT 42759 3718 11 regulation regulation NN 42759 3718 12 policy policy NN 42759 3718 13 in in IN 42759 3718 14 a a DT 42759 3718 15 modified modify VBN 42759 3718 16 form form NN 42759 3718 17 . . . 42759 3719 1 In in IN 42759 3719 2 substance substance NN 42759 3719 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3719 4 view view NN 42759 3719 5 is be VBZ 42759 3719 6 that that IN 42759 3719 7 , , , 42759 3719 8 while while IN 42759 3719 9 no no DT 42759 3719 10 corporation corporation NN 42759 3719 11 should should MD 42759 3719 12 be be VB 42759 3719 13 permitted permit VBN 42759 3719 14 to to TO 42759 3719 15 control control VB 42759 3719 16 the the DT 42759 3719 17 greater great JJR 42759 3719 18 part part NN 42759 3719 19 of of IN 42759 3719 20 any any DT 42759 3719 21 product product NN 42759 3719 22 , , , 42759 3719 23 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3719 24 price price NN 42759 3719 25 - - HYPH 42759 3719 26 agreements agreement NNS 42759 3719 27 should should MD 42759 3719 28 be be VB 42759 3719 29 sanctioned sanction VBN 42759 3719 30 and and CC 42759 3719 31 regulated regulate VBN 42759 3719 32 by by IN 42759 3719 33 law law NN 42759 3719 34 . . . 42759 3720 1 No no DT 42759 3720 2 amount amount NN 42759 3720 3 of of IN 42759 3720 4 restrictive restrictive JJ 42759 3720 5 legislation legislation NN 42759 3720 6 , , , 42759 3720 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3720 8 maintains maintain VBZ 42759 3720 9 , , , 42759 3720 10 can can MD 42759 3720 11 secure secure VB 42759 3720 12 universal universal JJ 42759 3720 13 competition competition NN 42759 3720 14 in in IN 42759 3720 15 the the DT 42759 3720 16 matter matter NN 42759 3720 17 of of IN 42759 3720 18 prices price NNS 42759 3720 19 . . . 42759 3721 1 Experience experience NN 42759 3721 2 shows show VBZ 42759 3721 3 that that IN 42759 3721 4 the the DT 42759 3721 5 destructive destructive JJ 42759 3721 6 results result NNS 42759 3721 7 of of IN 42759 3721 8 cut cut JJ 42759 3721 9 - - HYPH 42759 3721 10 throat throat JJ 42759 3721 11 competition competition NN 42759 3721 12 compel compel NN 42759 3721 13 the the DT 42759 3721 14 more more RBR 42759 3721 15 powerful powerful JJ 42759 3721 16 competitors competitor NNS 42759 3721 17 to to TO 42759 3721 18 make make VB 42759 3721 19 price price NN 42759 3721 20 agreements agreement NNS 42759 3721 21 in in IN 42759 3721 22 some some DT 42759 3721 23 lines line NNS 42759 3721 24 of of IN 42759 3721 25 business business NN 42759 3721 26 . . . 42759 3722 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3722 2 185 185 CD 42759 3722 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3722 4 For for IN 42759 3722 5 example example NN 42759 3722 6 ; ; : 42759 3722 7 all all PDT 42759 3722 8 the the DT 42759 3722 9 retail retail JJ 42759 3722 10 grocers grocer NNS 42759 3722 11 in in IN 42759 3722 12 a a DT 42759 3722 13 city city NN 42759 3722 14 are be VBP 42759 3722 15 often often RB 42759 3722 16 found find VBN 42759 3722 17 selling sell VBG 42759 3722 18 certain certain JJ 42759 3722 19 staples staple NNS 42759 3722 20 at at IN 42759 3722 21 a a DT 42759 3722 22 uniform uniform JJ 42759 3722 23 price price NN 42759 3722 24 for for IN 42759 3722 25 long long JJ 42759 3722 26 periods period NNS 42759 3722 27 of of IN 42759 3722 28 time time NN 42759 3722 29 . . . 42759 3723 1 Agreements agreement NNS 42759 3723 2 of of IN 42759 3723 3 this this DT 42759 3723 4 sort sort NN 42759 3723 5 should should MD 42759 3723 6 , , , 42759 3723 7 in in IN 42759 3723 8 the the DT 42759 3723 9 opinion opinion NN 42759 3723 10 of of IN 42759 3723 11 President President NNP 42759 3723 12 Van Van NNP 42759 3723 13 Hise Hise NNP 42759 3723 14 , , , 42759 3723 15 be be VB 42759 3723 16 formally formally RB 42759 3723 17 permitted permit VBN 42759 3723 18 by by IN 42759 3723 19 law law NN 42759 3723 20 , , , 42759 3723 21 with with IN 42759 3723 22 the the DT 42759 3723 23 proviso proviso NN 42759 3723 24 that that WDT 42759 3723 25 a a DT 42759 3723 26 government government NN 42759 3723 27 commission commission NN 42759 3723 28 should should MD 42759 3723 29 fix fix VB 42759 3723 30 the the DT 42759 3723 31 maximum maximum NN 42759 3723 32 and and CC 42759 3723 33 possibly possibly RB 42759 3723 34 the the DT 42759 3723 35 minimum minimum JJ 42759 3723 36 limits limit NNS 42759 3723 37 . . . 42759 3724 1 And and CC 42759 3724 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3724 3 contends contend VBZ 42759 3724 4 that that IN 42759 3724 5 the the DT 42759 3724 6 task task NN 42759 3724 7 of of IN 42759 3724 8 fixing fix VBG 42759 3724 9 fair fair JJ 42759 3724 10 maximum maximum NN 42759 3724 11 and and CC 42759 3724 12 minimum minimum JJ 42759 3724 13 prices price NNS 42759 3724 14 would would MD 42759 3724 15 be be VB 42759 3724 16 much much RB 42759 3724 17 less less RBR 42759 3724 18 difficult difficult JJ 42759 3724 19 than than IN 42759 3724 20 is be VBZ 42759 3724 21 commonly commonly RB 42759 3724 22 supposed suppose VBN 42759 3724 23 , , , 42759 3724 24 and and CC 42759 3724 25 that that IN 42759 3724 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3724 27 would would MD 42759 3724 28 be be VB 42759 3724 29 much much RB 42759 3724 30 simpler simple JJR 42759 3724 31 and and CC 42759 3724 32 easier easy JJR 42759 3724 33 than than IN 42759 3724 34 the the DT 42759 3724 35 task task NN 42759 3724 36 of of IN 42759 3724 37 regulating regulate VBG 42759 3724 38 railway railway NN 42759 3724 39 freight freight NN 42759 3724 40 rates rate NNS 42759 3724 41 . . . 42759 3725 1 Whatever whatever WDT 42759 3725 2 may may MD 42759 3725 3 be be VB 42759 3725 4 the the DT 42759 3725 5 merits merit NNS 42759 3725 6 of of IN 42759 3725 7 this this DT 42759 3725 8 plan plan NN 42759 3725 9 , , , 42759 3725 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3725 11 is be VBZ 42759 3725 12 not not RB 42759 3725 13 likely likely JJ 42759 3725 14 to to TO 42759 3725 15 be be VB 42759 3725 16 embodied embody VBN 42759 3725 17 in in IN 42759 3725 18 legislation legislation NN 42759 3725 19 in in IN 42759 3725 20 the the DT 42759 3725 21 near near JJ 42759 3725 22 future future NN 42759 3725 23 . . . 42759 3726 1 So so RB 42759 3726 2 far far RB 42759 3726 3 as as IN 42759 3726 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3726 5 can can MD 42759 3726 6 see see VB 42759 3726 7 now now RB 42759 3726 8 , , , 42759 3726 9 the the DT 42759 3726 10 American american JJ 42759 3726 11 people people NNS 42759 3726 12 are be VBP 42759 3726 13 committed committed JJ 42759 3726 14 to to IN 42759 3726 15 the the DT 42759 3726 16 policy policy NN 42759 3726 17 of of IN 42759 3726 18 endeavouring endeavour VBG 42759 3726 19 to to TO 42759 3726 20 restore restore VB 42759 3726 21 genuine genuine JJ 42759 3726 22 competition competition NN 42759 3726 23 by by IN 42759 3726 24 prohibiting prohibit VBG 42759 3726 25 those those DT 42759 3726 26 predatory predatory NN 42759 3726 27 practices practice NNS 42759 3726 28 to to TO 42759 3726 29 which which WDT 42759 3726 30 the the DT 42759 3726 31 great great JJ 42759 3726 32 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3726 33 mainly mainly RB 42759 3726 34 owe owe VBP 42759 3726 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3726 36 existence existence NN 42759 3726 37 . . . 42759 3727 1 The the DT 42759 3727 2 attempt attempt NN 42759 3727 3 will will MD 42759 3727 4 be be VB 42759 3727 5 made make VBN 42759 3727 6 to to TO 42759 3727 7 give give VB 42759 3727 8 competition competition NN 42759 3727 9 a a DT 42759 3727 10 fair fair JJ 42759 3727 11 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 3727 12 to to TO 42759 3727 13 prevent prevent VB 42759 3727 14 both both CC 42759 3727 15 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3727 16 control control NN 42759 3727 17 of of IN 42759 3727 18 products product NNS 42759 3727 19 and and CC 42759 3727 20 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3727 21 fixing fixing NN 42759 3727 22 of of IN 42759 3727 23 prices price NNS 42759 3727 24 . . . 42759 3728 1 Competition competition NN 42759 3728 2 has have VBZ 42759 3728 3 not not RB 42759 3728 4 enjoyed enjoy VBN 42759 3728 5 any any DT 42759 3728 6 such such JJ 42759 3728 7 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 3728 8 during during IN 42759 3728 9 the the DT 42759 3728 10 last last JJ 42759 3728 11 quarter quarter NN 42759 3728 12 of of IN 42759 3728 13 a a DT 42759 3728 14 century century NN 42759 3728 15 . . . 42759 3729 1 If if IN 42759 3729 2 this this DT 42759 3729 3 attempt attempt NN 42759 3729 4 should should MD 42759 3729 5 fail fail VB 42759 3729 6 after after IN 42759 3729 7 a a DT 42759 3729 8 thorough thorough JJ 42759 3729 9 trial trial NN 42759 3729 10 , , , 42759 3729 11 the the DT 42759 3729 12 time time NN 42759 3729 13 will will MD 42759 3729 14 be be VB 42759 3729 15 at at IN 42759 3729 16 hand hand NN 42759 3729 17 for for IN 42759 3729 18 the the DT 42759 3729 19 regulation regulation NN 42759 3729 20 of of IN 42759 3729 21 prices price NNS 42759 3729 22 by by IN 42759 3729 23 the the DT 42759 3729 24 government government NN 42759 3729 25 . . . 42759 3730 1 Until until IN 42759 3730 2 that that DT 42759 3730 3 time time NN 42759 3730 4 has have VBZ 42759 3730 5 arrived arrive VBN 42759 3730 6 ( ( -LRB- 42759 3730 7 let let VB 42759 3730 8 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3730 9 hope hope VB 42759 3730 10 that that IN 42759 3730 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3730 12 never never RB 42759 3730 13 will will MD 42759 3730 14 arrive arrive VB 42759 3730 15 ) ) -RRB- 42759 3730 16 the the DT 42759 3730 17 State State NNP 42759 3730 18 will will MD 42759 3730 19 not not RB 42759 3730 20 , , , 42759 3730 21 and and CC 42759 3730 22 should should MD 42759 3730 23 not not RB 42759 3730 24 , , , 42759 3730 25 embark embark VB 42759 3730 26 upon upon IN 42759 3730 27 such such PDT 42759 3730 28 a a DT 42759 3730 29 large large JJ 42759 3730 30 and and CC 42759 3730 31 difficult difficult JJ 42759 3730 32 experiment experiment NN 42759 3730 33 . . . 42759 3731 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 3731 2 : : : 42759 3731 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3731 4 165 165 CD 42759 3731 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3731 6 Report Report NNP 42759 3731 7 of of IN 42759 3731 8 the the DT 42759 3731 9 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 3731 10 of of IN 42759 3731 11 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 3731 12 on on IN 42759 3731 13 the the DT 42759 3731 14 Petroleum Petroleum NNP 42759 3731 15 Industry Industry NNP 42759 3731 16 , , , 42759 3731 17 II II NNP 42759 3731 18 , , , 42759 3731 19 40 40 CD 42759 3731 20 , , , 42759 3731 21 41 41 CD 42759 3731 22 . . . 42759 3732 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3732 2 166 166 CD 42759 3732 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3732 4 Report Report NNP 42759 3732 5 of of IN 42759 3732 6 the the DT 42759 3732 7 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 3732 8 of of IN 42759 3732 9 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 3732 10 on on IN 42759 3732 11 the the DT 42759 3732 12 Tobacco Tobacco NNP 42759 3732 13 Industry Industry NNP 42759 3732 14 , , , 42759 3732 15 II II NNP 42759 3732 16 , , , 42759 3732 17 26 26 CD 42759 3732 18 - - SYM 42759 3732 19 34 34 CD 42759 3732 20 . . . 42759 3733 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3733 2 167 167 CD 42759 3733 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3733 4 Report Report NNP 42759 3733 5 of of IN 42759 3733 6 the the DT 42759 3733 7 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 3733 8 of of IN 42759 3733 9 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 3733 10 on on IN 42759 3733 11 the the DT 42759 3733 12 Steel Steel NNP 42759 3733 13 Industry Industry NNP 42759 3733 14 , , , 42759 3733 15 I -PRON- PRP 42759 3733 16 , , , 42759 3733 17 51 51 CD 42759 3733 18 . . . 42759 3734 1 According accord VBG 42759 3734 2 to to IN 42759 3734 3 F. F. NNP 42759 3734 4 J. J. NNP 42759 3734 5 McRae McRae NNP 42759 3734 6 , , , 42759 3734 7 the the DT 42759 3734 8 expert expert JJ 42759 3734 9 accountant accountant NN 42759 3734 10 for for IN 42759 3734 11 the the DT 42759 3734 12 Stanley Stanley NNP 42759 3734 13 congressional congressional JJ 42759 3734 14 investigating investigate VBG 42759 3734 15 committee committee NN 42759 3734 16 , , , 42759 3734 17 this this DT 42759 3734 18 concern concern NN 42759 3734 19 secured secure VBD 42759 3734 20 40 40 CD 42759 3734 21 per per NN 42759 3734 22 cent cent NN 42759 3734 23 . . . 42759 3735 1 on on IN 42759 3735 2 the the DT 42759 3735 3 _ _ NNP 42759 3735 4 cost cost NN 42759 3735 5 _ _ NNP 42759 3735 6 of of IN 42759 3735 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3735 8 property property NN 42759 3735 9 . . . 42759 3736 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3736 2 168 168 CD 42759 3736 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3736 4 Hearings hearing NNS 42759 3736 5 Before before IN 42759 3736 6 the the DT 42759 3736 7 Interstate Interstate NNP 42759 3736 8 Commerce Commerce NNP 42759 3736 9 Committee Committee NNP 42759 3736 10 , , , 42759 3736 11 U. U. NNP 42759 3736 12 S. S. NNP 42759 3736 13 Senate Senate NNP 42759 3736 14 , , , 42759 3736 15 Part Part NNP 42759 3736 16 XVI XVI NNP 42759 3736 17 , , , 42759 3736 18 pages page VBZ 42759 3736 19 1146 1146 CD 42759 3736 20 - - SYM 42759 3736 21 1166 1166 CD 42759 3736 22 . . . 42759 3737 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3737 2 169 169 CD 42759 3737 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3737 4 _ _ NNP 42759 3737 5 The the DT 42759 3737 6 Journal Journal NNP 42759 3737 7 of of IN 42759 3737 8 Political Political NNP 42759 3737 9 Economy Economy NNP 42759 3737 10 _ _ NNP 42759 3737 11 , , , 42759 3737 12 April April NNP 42759 3737 13 , , , 42759 3737 14 1912 1912 CD 42759 3737 15 , , , 42759 3737 16 p. p. NN 42759 3737 17 366 366 CD 42759 3737 18 . . . 42759 3738 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3738 2 170 170 CD 42759 3738 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3738 4 " " `` 42759 3738 5 Concentration Concentration NNP 42759 3738 6 and and CC 42759 3738 7 Control Control NNP 42759 3738 8 , , , 42759 3738 9 " " '' 42759 3738 10 p. p. NN 42759 3738 11 20 20 CD 42759 3738 12 . . . 42759 3739 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3739 2 171 171 CD 42759 3739 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3739 4 Page page NN 42759 3739 5 621 621 CD 42759 3739 6 . . . 42759 3740 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3740 2 172 172 CD 42759 3740 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3740 4 _ _ NNP 42759 3740 5 The the DT 42759 3740 6 Journal Journal NNP 42759 3740 7 of of IN 42759 3740 8 Political Political NNP 42759 3740 9 Economy Economy NNP 42759 3740 10 _ _ NNP 42759 3740 11 , , , 42759 3740 12 April April NNP 42759 3740 13 , , , 42759 3740 14 1912 1912 CD 42759 3740 15 , , , 42759 3740 16 p. p. NN 42759 3740 17 363 363 CD 42759 3740 18 . . . 42759 3741 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3741 2 173 173 CD 42759 3741 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3741 4 Report Report NNP 42759 3741 5 on on IN 42759 3741 6 the the DT 42759 3741 7 Petroleum Petroleum NNP 42759 3741 8 Industry Industry NNP 42759 3741 9 , , , 42759 3741 10 II II NNP 42759 3741 11 , , , 42759 3741 12 74 74 CD 42759 3741 13 . . . 42759 3742 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3742 2 174 174 CD 42759 3742 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3742 4 Report Report NNP 42759 3742 5 on on IN 42759 3742 6 the the DT 42759 3742 7 Tobacco Tobacco NNP 42759 3742 8 Industry Industry NNP 42759 3742 9 , , , 42759 3742 10 II II NNP 42759 3742 11 , , , 42759 3742 12 27 27 CD 42759 3742 13 . . . 42759 3743 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3743 2 175 175 CD 42759 3743 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3743 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 3743 5 . . . 42759 3744 1 Van Van NNP 42759 3744 2 Hise Hise NNP 42759 3744 3 , , , 42759 3744 4 op op NN 42759 3744 5 . . . 42759 3745 1 cit cit NNP 42759 3745 2 . . . 42759 3745 3 , , , 42759 3745 4 pp pp NNP 42759 3745 5 . . . 42759 3746 1 140 140 CD 42759 3746 2 , , , 42759 3746 3 149 149 CD 42759 3746 4 , , , 42759 3746 5 153 153 CD 42759 3746 6 , , , 42759 3746 7 159 159 CD 42759 3746 8 . . . 42759 3747 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3747 2 176 176 CD 42759 3747 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3747 4 Final Final NNP 42759 3747 5 Report Report NNP 42759 3747 6 of of IN 42759 3747 7 the the DT 42759 3747 8 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 3747 9 Commission Commission NNP 42759 3747 10 , , , 42759 3747 11 pp pp NNP 42759 3747 12 . . . 42759 3748 1 660 660 CD 42759 3748 2 - - SYM 42759 3748 3 662 662 CD 42759 3748 4 . . . 42759 3749 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3749 2 177 177 CD 42759 3749 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3749 4 Report report NN 42759 3749 5 on on IN 42759 3749 6 the the DT 42759 3749 7 Petroleum Petroleum NNP 42759 3749 8 Industry Industry NNP 42759 3749 9 , , , 42759 3749 10 I -PRON- PRP 42759 3749 11 , , , 42759 3749 12 328 328 CD 42759 3749 13 - - SYM 42759 3749 14 332 332 CD 42759 3749 15 . . . 42759 3750 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3750 2 178 178 CD 42759 3750 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3750 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 3750 5 . . . 42759 3751 1 Lehmkuhl Lehmkuhl NNP 42759 3751 2 , , , 42759 3751 3 " " `` 42759 3751 4 Theologia Theologia NNP 42759 3751 5 Moralis Moralis NNP 42759 3751 6 , , , 42759 3751 7 " " `` 42759 3751 8 I -PRON- PRP 42759 3751 9 , , , 42759 3751 10 No no UH 42759 3751 11 . . . 42759 3752 1 974 974 CD 42759 3752 2 . . . 42759 3753 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3753 2 179 179 CD 42759 3753 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3753 4 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3753 5 may may MD 42759 3753 6 be be VB 42759 3753 7 of of IN 42759 3753 8 interest interest NN 42759 3753 9 to to TO 42759 3753 10 recall recall VB 42759 3753 11 the the DT 42759 3753 12 mediæval mediæval JJ 42759 3753 13 attitude attitude NN 42759 3753 14 toward toward IN 42759 3753 15 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3753 16 exactions exaction NNS 42759 3753 17 , , , 42759 3753 18 as as RB 42759 3753 19 summarily summarily RB 42759 3753 20 stated state VBN 42759 3753 21 by by IN 42759 3753 22 St. St. NNP 42759 3753 23 Antoninus Antoninus NNP 42759 3753 24 , , , 42759 3753 25 who who WP 42759 3753 26 was be VBD 42759 3753 27 archbishop archbishop NN 42759 3753 28 of of IN 42759 3753 29 Florence Florence NNP 42759 3753 30 in in IN 42759 3753 31 the the DT 42759 3753 32 first first JJ 42759 3753 33 half half NN 42759 3753 34 of of IN 42759 3753 35 the the DT 42759 3753 36 fifteenth fifteenth JJ 42759 3753 37 century century NN 42759 3753 38 : : : 42759 3753 39 " " `` 42759 3753 40 When when WRB 42759 3753 41 monopolist monopolist JJ 42759 3753 42 merchants merchant NNS 42759 3753 43 agree agree VBP 42759 3753 44 together together RB 42759 3753 45 to to TO 42759 3753 46 preserve preserve VB 42759 3753 47 a a DT 42759 3753 48 fixed fix VBN 42759 3753 49 price price NN 42759 3753 50 , , , 42759 3753 51 so so IN 42759 3753 52 as as IN 42759 3753 53 to to TO 42759 3753 54 secure secure VB 42759 3753 55 an an DT 42759 3753 56 unlimited unlimited JJ 42759 3753 57 profit profit NN 42759 3753 58 , , , 42759 3753 59 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3753 60 are be VBP 42759 3753 61 guilty guilty JJ 42759 3753 62 of of IN 42759 3753 63 sinful sinful JJ 42759 3753 64 trading trading NN 42759 3753 65 . . . 42759 3753 66 " " '' 42759 3754 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 3754 2 maintained maintain VBD 42759 3754 3 that that IN 42759 3754 4 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3754 5 should should MD 42759 3754 6 not not RB 42759 3754 7 sell sell VB 42759 3754 8 above above IN 42759 3754 9 the the DT 42759 3754 10 market market NN 42759 3754 11 price price NN 42759 3754 12 , , , 42759 3754 13 and and CC 42759 3754 14 should should MD 42759 3754 15 be be VB 42759 3754 16 prevented prevent VBN 42759 3754 17 from from IN 42759 3754 18 so so RB 42759 3754 19 doing do VBG 42759 3754 20 by by IN 42759 3754 21 law law NN 42759 3754 22 . . . 42759 3755 1 See see VB 42759 3755 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3755 3 " " `` 42759 3755 4 Summa Summa NNP 42759 3755 5 Theologica Theologica NNP 42759 3755 6 , , , 42759 3755 7 " " '' 42759 3755 8 III iii CD 42759 3755 9 , , , 42759 3755 10 8 8 CD 42759 3755 11 , , , 42759 3755 12 3 3 CD 42759 3755 13 , , , 42759 3755 14 iv iv UH 42759 3755 15 , , , 42759 3755 16 and and CC 42759 3755 17 II II NNP 42759 3755 18 , , , 42759 3755 19 1 1 CD 42759 3755 20 , , , 42759 3755 21 16 16 CD 42759 3755 22 , , , 42759 3755 23 ii ii NNP 42759 3755 24 . . . 42759 3756 1 Present present JJ 42759 3756 2 day day NN 42759 3756 3 moral moral JJ 42759 3756 4 theologians theologian NNS 42759 3756 5 lay lie VBD 42759 3756 6 down down RP 42759 3756 7 the the DT 42759 3756 8 same same JJ 42759 3756 9 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 3756 10 , , , 42759 3756 11 and and CC 42759 3756 12 in in IN 42759 3756 13 addition addition NN 42759 3756 14 condemn condemn VBD 42759 3756 15 the the DT 42759 3756 16 characteristic characteristic JJ 42759 3756 17 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3756 18 methods method NNS 42759 3756 19 as as IN 42759 3756 20 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3756 21 . . . 42759 3757 1 See see VB 42759 3757 2 Tanquerey Tanquerey NNP 42759 3757 3 , , , 42759 3757 4 " " '' 42759 3757 5 De De NNP 42759 3757 6 Justitia Justitia NNP 42759 3757 7 , , , 42759 3757 8 " " '' 42759 3757 9 nos nos RB 42759 3757 10 . . . 42759 3758 1 776 776 CD 42759 3758 2 , , , 42759 3758 3 777 777 CD 42759 3758 4 ; ; : 42759 3758 5 Lehmkuhl Lehmkuhl NNP 42759 3758 6 , , , 42759 3758 7 " " `` 42759 3758 8 Theologia Theologia NNP 42759 3758 9 Moralis Moralis NNP 42759 3758 10 , , , 42759 3758 11 " " '' 42759 3758 12 vol vol NNP 42759 3758 13 . . . 42759 3759 1 I -PRON- PRP 42759 3759 2 , , , 42759 3759 3 no no UH 42759 3759 4 . . . 42759 3760 1 1119 1119 CD 42759 3760 2 . . . 42759 3761 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3761 2 180 180 CD 42759 3761 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3761 4 Clark Clark NNP 42759 3761 5 , , , 42759 3761 6 " " `` 42759 3761 7 The the DT 42759 3761 8 Problem problem NN 42759 3761 9 of of IN 42759 3761 10 Monopoly Monopoly NNP 42759 3761 11 , , , 42759 3761 12 " " '' 42759 3761 13 p. p. NN 42759 3761 14 35 35 CD 42759 3761 15 . . . 42759 3762 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3762 2 181 181 CD 42759 3762 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3762 4 Final Final NNP 42759 3762 5 Report Report NNP 42759 3762 6 , , , 42759 3762 7 p. p. NN 42759 3762 8 361 361 CD 42759 3762 9 . . . 42759 3763 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3763 2 182 182 CD 42759 3763 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3763 4 Report report NN 42759 3763 5 on on IN 42759 3763 6 the the DT 42759 3763 7 Petroleum Petroleum NNP 42759 3763 8 Industry Industry NNP 42759 3763 9 , , , 42759 3763 10 pp pp NNP 42759 3763 11 . . . 42759 3764 1 22 22 CD 42759 3764 2 , , , 42759 3764 3 23 23 CD 42759 3764 4 . . . 42759 3765 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3765 2 183 183 CD 42759 3765 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3765 4 " " `` 42759 3765 5 Papers Papers NNPS 42759 3765 6 and and CC 42759 3765 7 Proceedings Proceedings NNPS 42759 3765 8 , , , 42759 3765 9 " " '' 42759 3765 10 pp pp NNP 42759 3765 11 . . . 42759 3766 1 158 158 CD 42759 3766 2 - - SYM 42759 3766 3 194 194 CD 42759 3766 4 . . . 42759 3767 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3767 2 184 184 CD 42759 3767 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3767 4 Op Op NNP 42759 3767 5 . . . 42759 3768 1 cit cit NNP 42759 3768 2 . . . 42759 3768 3 , , , 42759 3768 4 pp pp NNP 42759 3768 5 . . . 42759 3769 1 20 20 CD 42759 3769 2 , , , 42759 3769 3 251 251 CD 42759 3769 4 . . . 42759 3770 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3770 2 185 185 CD 42759 3770 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3770 4 Op Op NNP 42759 3770 5 . . . 42759 3771 1 cit cit NNP 42759 3771 2 . . . 42759 3771 3 , , , 42759 3771 4 pp pp NNP 42759 3771 5 . . . 42759 3772 1 254 254 CD 42759 3772 2 - - SYM 42759 3772 3 265 265 CD 42759 3772 4 . . . 42759 3773 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 3773 2 XIX XIX NNP 42759 3773 3 THE the DT 42759 3773 4 MORAL moral JJ 42759 3773 5 ASPECT ASPECT NNS 42759 3773 6 OF of IN 42759 3773 7 STOCK stock NN 42759 3773 8 WATERING watering NN 42759 3773 9 In in IN 42759 3773 10 the the DT 42759 3773 11 last last JJ 42759 3773 12 chapter chapter NN 42759 3773 13 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3773 14 saw see VBD 42759 3773 15 that that IN 42759 3773 16 a a DT 42759 3773 17 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3773 18 has have VBZ 42759 3773 19 no no DT 42759 3773 20 right right NN 42759 3773 21 to to IN 42759 3773 22 gains gain NNS 42759 3773 23 in in IN 42759 3773 24 excess excess NN 42759 3773 25 of of IN 42759 3773 26 the the DT 42759 3773 27 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3773 28 rate rate NN 42759 3773 29 of of IN 42759 3773 30 interest interest NN 42759 3773 31 on on IN 42759 3773 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3773 33 capital capital NN 42759 3773 34 , , , 42759 3773 35 except except IN 42759 3773 36 in in IN 42759 3773 37 so so RB 42759 3773 38 far far RB 42759 3773 39 as as IN 42759 3773 40 these these DT 42759 3773 41 have have VBP 42759 3773 42 been be VBN 42759 3773 43 derived derive VBN 42759 3773 44 from from IN 42759 3773 45 superior superior JJ 42759 3773 46 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3773 47 . . . 42759 3774 1 Now now RB 42759 3774 2 superior superior JJ 42759 3774 3 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3774 4 is be VBZ 42759 3774 5 clearly clearly RB 42759 3774 6 present present JJ 42759 3774 7 whenever whenever WRB 42759 3774 8 the the DT 42759 3774 9 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3774 10 concern concern NN 42759 3774 11 obtains obtain NNS 42759 3774 12 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3774 13 gains gain NNS 42759 3774 14 by by IN 42759 3774 15 selling sell VBG 42759 3774 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3774 17 product product NN 42759 3774 18 at at IN 42759 3774 19 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3774 20 prices price NNS 42759 3774 21 , , , 42759 3774 22 or or CC 42759 3774 23 at at IN 42759 3774 24 the the DT 42759 3774 25 prices price NNS 42759 3774 26 that that WDT 42759 3774 27 would would MD 42759 3774 28 have have VB 42759 3774 29 prevailed prevail VBN 42759 3774 30 under under IN 42759 3774 31 competition competition NN 42759 3774 32 . . . 42759 3775 1 Evidently evidently RB 42759 3775 2 the the DT 42759 3775 3 surplus surplus NN 42759 3775 4 in in IN 42759 3775 5 such such PDT 42759 3775 6 a a DT 42759 3775 7 case case NN 42759 3775 8 is be VBZ 42759 3775 9 due due JJ 42759 3775 10 to to IN 42759 3775 11 the the DT 42759 3775 12 greater great JJR 42759 3775 13 productivity productivity NN 42759 3775 14 of of IN 42759 3775 15 the the DT 42759 3775 16 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3775 17 as as IN 42759 3775 18 compared compare VBN 42759 3775 19 with with IN 42759 3775 20 the the DT 42759 3775 21 average average JJ 42759 3775 22 productivity productivity NN 42759 3775 23 of of IN 42759 3775 24 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3775 25 concerns concern NNS 42759 3775 26 . . . 42759 3776 1 When when WRB 42759 3776 2 , , , 42759 3776 3 however however RB 42759 3776 4 , , , 42759 3776 5 the the DT 42759 3776 6 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3776 7 charges charge VBZ 42759 3776 8 prices price NNS 42759 3776 9 above above IN 42759 3776 10 the the DT 42759 3776 11 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3776 12 level level NN 42759 3776 13 , , , 42759 3776 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3776 15 surplus surplus NN 42759 3776 16 gains gain NNS 42759 3776 17 can can MD 42759 3776 18 not not RB 42759 3776 19 all all DT 42759 3776 20 be be VB 42759 3776 21 attributed attribute VBN 42759 3776 22 to to IN 42759 3776 23 unusual unusual JJ 42759 3776 24 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3776 25 . . . 42759 3777 1 A a DT 42759 3777 2 part part NN 42759 3777 3 if if IN 42759 3777 4 not not RB 42759 3777 5 all all DT 42759 3777 6 of of IN 42759 3777 7 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3777 8 are be VBP 42759 3777 9 the the DT 42759 3777 10 result result NN 42759 3777 11 simply simply RB 42759 3777 12 of of IN 42759 3777 13 the the DT 42759 3777 14 power power NN 42759 3777 15 to to TO 42759 3777 16 take take VB 42759 3777 17 ; ; : 42759 3777 18 consequently consequently RB 42759 3777 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3777 20 are be VBP 42759 3777 21 immoral immoral JJ 42759 3777 22 . . . 42759 3778 1 One one CD 42759 3778 2 of of IN 42759 3778 3 the the DT 42759 3778 4 means mean NNS 42759 3778 5 by by IN 42759 3778 6 which which WDT 42759 3778 7 some some DT 42759 3778 8 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3778 9 have have VBP 42759 3778 10 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3778 11 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3778 12 surplus surplus NN 42759 3778 13 gains gain NNS 42759 3778 14 is be VBZ 42759 3778 15 overcapitalisation overcapitalisation NN 42759 3778 16 , , , 42759 3778 17 or or CC 42759 3778 18 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 3778 19 . . . 42759 3779 1 This this DT 42759 3779 2 practice practice NN 42759 3779 3 is be VBZ 42759 3779 4 rarely rarely RB 42759 3779 5 found find VBN 42759 3779 6 in in IN 42759 3779 7 businesses business NNS 42759 3779 8 that that WDT 42759 3779 9 are be VBP 42759 3779 10 subject subject JJ 42759 3779 11 to to IN 42759 3779 12 normal normal JJ 42759 3779 13 competition competition NN 42759 3779 14 . . . 42759 3780 1 So so RB 42759 3780 2 far far RB 42759 3780 3 as as IN 42759 3780 4 the the DT 42759 3780 5 consumer consumer NN 42759 3780 6 is be VBZ 42759 3780 7 concerned concern VBN 42759 3780 8 , , , 42759 3780 9 a a DT 42759 3780 10 corporation corporation NN 42759 3780 11 that that WDT 42759 3780 12 can can MD 42759 3780 13 not not RB 42759 3780 14 fix fix VB 42759 3780 15 prices price NNS 42759 3780 16 arbitrarily arbitrarily RB 42759 3780 17 has have VBZ 42759 3780 18 nothing nothing NN 42759 3780 19 to to TO 42759 3780 20 gain gain VB 42759 3780 21 by by IN 42759 3780 22 inflating inflate VBG 42759 3780 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3780 24 capital capital NN 42759 3780 25 . . . 42759 3781 1 Unless unless IN 42759 3781 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3781 3 develops develop VBZ 42759 3781 4 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 3781 5 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3781 6 , , , 42759 3781 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3781 8 can can MD 42759 3781 9 not not RB 42759 3781 10 hope hope VB 42759 3781 11 to to TO 42759 3781 12 obtain obtain VB 42759 3781 13 more more JJR 42759 3781 14 than than IN 42759 3781 15 the the DT 42759 3781 16 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3781 17 rate rate NN 42759 3781 18 of of IN 42759 3781 19 interest interest NN 42759 3781 20 on on IN 42759 3781 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3781 22 capital capital NN 42759 3781 23 ; ; : 42759 3781 24 if if IN 42759 3781 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3781 26 does do VBZ 42759 3781 27 become become VB 42759 3781 28 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3781 29 efficient efficient JJ 42759 3781 30 , , , 42759 3781 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3781 32 can can MD 42759 3781 33 take take VB 42759 3781 34 the the DT 42759 3781 35 resulting result VBG 42759 3781 36 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3781 37 gains gain NNS 42759 3781 38 without without IN 42759 3781 39 arousing arouse VBG 42759 3781 40 public public JJ 42759 3781 41 resentment resentment NN 42759 3781 42 or or CC 42759 3781 43 criticism criticism NN 42759 3781 44 . . . 42759 3782 1 In in IN 42759 3782 2 either either DT 42759 3782 3 case case NN 42759 3782 4 , , , 42759 3782 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3782 6 will will MD 42759 3782 7 have have VB 42759 3782 8 no no DT 42759 3782 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3782 10 reason reason NN 42759 3782 11 to to TO 42759 3782 12 deceive deceive VB 42759 3782 13 the the DT 42759 3782 14 public public NN 42759 3782 15 by by IN 42759 3782 16 exaggerating exaggerate VBG 42759 3782 17 the the DT 42759 3782 18 amount amount NN 42759 3782 19 of of IN 42759 3782 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3782 21 capital capital NN 42759 3782 22 . . . 42759 3783 1 When when WRB 42759 3783 2 a a DT 42759 3783 3 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3783 4 concern concern NN 42759 3783 5 does do VBZ 42759 3783 6 water water VB 42759 3783 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3783 8 stock stock NN 42759 3783 9 , , , 42759 3783 10 the the DT 42759 3783 11 object object NN 42759 3783 12 will will MD 42759 3783 13 be be VB 42759 3783 14 to to TO 42759 3783 15 defraud defraud VB 42759 3783 16 investors investor NNS 42759 3783 17 . . . 42759 3784 1 If if IN 42759 3784 2 the the DT 42759 3784 3 scheme scheme NN 42759 3784 4 is be VBZ 42759 3784 5 successful successful JJ 42759 3784 6 the the DT 42759 3784 7 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3784 8 surplus surplus NN 42759 3784 9 gains gain NNS 42759 3784 10 are be VBP 42759 3784 11 taken take VBN 42759 3784 12 by by IN 42759 3784 13 one one CD 42759 3784 14 set set NN 42759 3784 15 of of IN 42759 3784 16 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3784 17 from from IN 42759 3784 18 another another DT 42759 3784 19 set set NN 42759 3784 20 of of IN 42759 3784 21 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3784 22 . . . 42759 3785 1 Whenever whenever WRB 42759 3785 2 anything anything NN 42759 3785 3 of of IN 42759 3785 4 this this DT 42759 3785 5 sort sort NN 42759 3785 6 occurs occur VBZ 42759 3785 7 , , , 42759 3785 8 the the DT 42759 3785 9 deceptive deceptive JJ 42759 3785 10 devices device NNS 42759 3785 11 employed employ VBN 42759 3785 12 are be VBP 42759 3785 13 so so RB 42759 3785 14 crude crude JJ 42759 3785 15 and and CC 42759 3785 16 obvious obvious JJ 42759 3785 17 that that IN 42759 3785 18 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3785 19 present present VBP 42759 3785 20 no no DT 42759 3785 21 special special JJ 42759 3785 22 problem problem NN 42759 3785 23 for for IN 42759 3785 24 the the DT 42759 3785 25 moralist moralist NN 42759 3785 26 . . . 42759 3786 1 Even even RB 42759 3786 2 as as IN 42759 3786 3 practised practise VBN 42759 3786 4 by by IN 42759 3786 5 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3786 6 , , , 42759 3786 7 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 3786 8 raises raise VBZ 42759 3786 9 no no DT 42759 3786 10 principle principle NN 42759 3786 11 that that WDT 42759 3786 12 has have VBZ 42759 3786 13 not not RB 42759 3786 14 been be VBN 42759 3786 15 already already RB 42759 3786 16 discussed discuss VBN 42759 3786 17 . . . 42759 3787 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3787 2 does do VBZ 42759 3787 3 , , , 42759 3787 4 however however RB 42759 3787 5 , , , 42759 3787 6 create create VB 42759 3787 7 some some DT 42759 3787 8 special special JJ 42759 3787 9 difficulties difficulty NNS 42759 3787 10 in in IN 42759 3787 11 the the DT 42759 3787 12 matter matter NN 42759 3787 13 of of IN 42759 3787 14 applying apply VBG 42759 3787 15 the the DT 42759 3787 16 moral moral JJ 42759 3787 17 principles principle NNS 42759 3787 18 involved involve VBN 42759 3787 19 . . . 42759 3788 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 3788 2 , , , 42759 3788 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3788 4 may may MD 42759 3788 5 with with IN 42759 3788 6 advantage advantage NN 42759 3788 7 be be VB 42759 3788 8 considered consider VBN 42759 3788 9 in in IN 42759 3788 10 a a DT 42759 3788 11 separate separate JJ 42759 3788 12 chapter chapter NN 42759 3788 13 . . . 42759 3789 1 The the DT 42759 3789 2 general general JJ 42759 3789 3 definition definition NN 42759 3789 4 of of IN 42759 3789 5 overcapitalisation overcapitalisation NN 42759 3789 6 is be VBZ 42759 3789 7 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3789 8 in in IN 42759 3789 9 excess excess NN 42759 3789 10 of of IN 42759 3789 11 the the DT 42759 3789 12 proper proper JJ 42759 3789 13 valuation valuation NN 42759 3789 14 of of IN 42759 3789 15 a a DT 42759 3789 16 business business NN 42759 3789 17 . . . 42759 3790 1 What what WP 42759 3790 2 is be VBZ 42759 3790 3 the the DT 42759 3790 4 measure measure NN 42759 3790 5 of of IN 42759 3790 6 proper proper JJ 42759 3790 7 valuation valuation NN 42759 3790 8 ? ? . 42759 3791 1 According accord VBG 42759 3791 2 to to IN 42759 3791 3 many many JJ 42759 3791 4 corporation corporation NN 42759 3791 5 directors director NNS 42759 3791 6 , , , 42759 3791 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3791 8 is be VBZ 42759 3791 9 earning earn VBG 42759 3791 10 power power NN 42759 3791 11 . . . 42759 3792 1 If if IN 42759 3792 2 a a DT 42759 3792 3 concern concern NN 42759 3792 4 is be VBZ 42759 3792 5 able able JJ 42759 3792 6 to to TO 42759 3792 7 get get VB 42759 3792 8 the the DT 42759 3792 9 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 3792 10 rate rate NN 42759 3792 11 of of IN 42759 3792 12 interest interest NN 42759 3792 13 on on IN 42759 3792 14 a a DT 42759 3792 15 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3792 16 of of IN 42759 3792 17 ten ten CD 42759 3792 18 million million CD 42759 3792 19 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3792 20 , , , 42759 3792 21 that that WDT 42759 3792 22 is be VBZ 42759 3792 23 the the DT 42759 3792 24 proper proper JJ 42759 3792 25 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3792 26 for for IN 42759 3792 27 that that DT 42759 3792 28 concern concern NN 42759 3792 29 , , , 42759 3792 30 even even RB 42759 3792 31 though though IN 42759 3792 32 the the DT 42759 3792 33 money money NN 42759 3792 34 actually actually RB 42759 3792 35 invested invest VBN 42759 3792 36 might may MD 42759 3792 37 not not RB 42759 3792 38 have have VB 42759 3792 39 exceeded exceed VBN 42759 3792 40 five five CD 42759 3792 41 million million CD 42759 3792 42 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3792 43 . . . 42759 3793 1 In in IN 42759 3793 2 the the DT 42759 3793 3 opinion opinion NN 42759 3793 4 of of IN 42759 3793 5 most most JJS 42759 3793 6 other other JJ 42759 3793 7 persons person NNS 42759 3793 8 , , , 42759 3793 9 however however RB 42759 3793 10 , , , 42759 3793 11 a a DT 42759 3793 12 company company NN 42759 3793 13 is be VBZ 42759 3793 14 overcapitalised overcapitalise VBN 42759 3793 15 when when WRB 42759 3793 16 the the DT 42759 3793 17 face face NN 42759 3793 18 value value NN 42759 3793 19 of of IN 42759 3793 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3793 21 securities security NNS 42759 3793 22 is be VBZ 42759 3793 23 greater great JJR 42759 3793 24 than than IN 42759 3793 25 the the DT 42759 3793 26 money money NN 42759 3793 27 put put VBD 42759 3793 28 into into IN 42759 3793 29 the the DT 42759 3793 30 business business NN 42759 3793 31 plus plus CC 42759 3793 32 the the DT 42759 3793 33 subsequent subsequent JJ 42759 3793 34 enhancement enhancement NN 42759 3793 35 in in IN 42759 3793 36 the the DT 42759 3793 37 value value NN 42759 3793 38 of of IN 42759 3793 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3793 40 land land NN 42759 3793 41 . . . 42759 3794 1 " " `` 42759 3794 2 The the DT 42759 3794 3 money money NN 42759 3794 4 put put VBD 42759 3794 5 into into IN 42759 3794 6 the the DT 42759 3794 7 business business NN 42759 3794 8 , , , 42759 3794 9 " " '' 42759 3794 10 means mean VBZ 42759 3794 11 that that DT 42759 3794 12 which which WDT 42759 3794 13 has have VBZ 42759 3794 14 been be VBN 42759 3794 15 expended expend VBN 42759 3794 16 for for IN 42759 3794 17 labour labour NN 42759 3794 18 , , , 42759 3794 19 materials material NNS 42759 3794 20 , , , 42759 3794 21 land land NN 42759 3794 22 , , , 42759 3794 23 equipment equipment NN 42759 3794 24 , , , 42759 3794 25 and and CC 42759 3794 26 all all DT 42759 3794 27 other other JJ 42759 3794 28 items item NNS 42759 3794 29 and and CC 42759 3794 30 costs cost NNS 42759 3794 31 of of IN 42759 3794 32 organising organise VBG 42759 3794 33 the the DT 42759 3794 34 concern concern NN 42759 3794 35 , , , 42759 3794 36 together together RB 42759 3794 37 with with IN 42759 3794 38 the the DT 42759 3794 39 sum sum NN 42759 3794 40 that that WDT 42759 3794 41 is be VBZ 42759 3794 42 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3794 43 to to TO 42759 3794 44 cover cover VB 42759 3794 45 the the DT 42759 3794 46 interest interest NN 42759 3794 47 not not RB 42759 3794 48 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3794 49 by by IN 42759 3794 50 the the DT 42759 3794 51 investors investor NNS 42759 3794 52 during during IN 42759 3794 53 the the DT 42759 3794 54 preparatory preparatory JJ 42759 3794 55 period period NN 42759 3794 56 before before IN 42759 3794 57 the the DT 42759 3794 58 business business NN 42759 3794 59 became become VBD 42759 3794 60 productively productively RB 42759 3794 61 operative operative JJ 42759 3794 62 . . . 42759 3795 1 The the DT 42759 3795 2 increase increase NN 42759 3795 3 in in IN 42759 3795 4 the the DT 42759 3795 5 value value NN 42759 3795 6 of of IN 42759 3795 7 the the DT 42759 3795 8 land land NN 42759 3795 9 after after IN 42759 3795 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3795 11 acquisition acquisition NN 42759 3795 12 by by IN 42759 3795 13 the the DT 42759 3795 14 company company NN 42759 3795 15 also also RB 42759 3795 16 deserves deserve VBZ 42759 3795 17 a a DT 42759 3795 18 place place NN 42759 3795 19 in in IN 42759 3795 20 the the DT 42759 3795 21 legitimate legitimate JJ 42759 3795 22 valuation valuation NN 42759 3795 23 , , , 42759 3795 24 and and CC 42759 3795 25 may may MD 42759 3795 26 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 3795 27 be be VB 42759 3795 28 represented represent VBN 42759 3795 29 by by IN 42759 3795 30 an an DT 42759 3795 31 appropriate appropriate JJ 42759 3795 32 amount amount NN 42759 3795 33 of of IN 42759 3795 34 securities security NNS 42759 3795 35 . . . 42759 3796 1 Monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3796 2 corporations corporation NNS 42759 3796 3 have have VBP 42759 3796 4 as as RB 42759 3796 5 good good JJ 42759 3796 6 a a DT 42759 3796 7 right right NN 42759 3796 8 , , , 42759 3796 9 generally generally RB 42759 3796 10 speaking speak VBG 42759 3796 11 , , , 42759 3796 12 to to TO 42759 3796 13 profit profit VB 42759 3796 14 by by IN 42759 3796 15 the the DT 42759 3796 16 " " `` 42759 3796 17 unearned unearned JJ 42759 3796 18 increment increment NN 42759 3796 19 " " '' 42759 3796 20 of of IN 42759 3796 21 land land NN 42759 3796 22 as as IN 42759 3796 23 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3796 24 concerns concern NNS 42759 3796 25 . . . 42759 3797 1 In in IN 42759 3797 2 brief brief NN 42759 3797 3 , , , 42759 3797 4 the the DT 42759 3797 5 proper proper JJ 42759 3797 6 measure measure NN 42759 3797 7 of of IN 42759 3797 8 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3797 9 is be VBZ 42759 3797 10 cost cost VBN 42759 3797 11 : : : 42759 3797 12 either either CC 42759 3797 13 the the DT 42759 3797 14 original original JJ 42759 3797 15 cost cost NN 42759 3797 16 , , , 42759 3797 17 as as RB 42759 3797 18 just just RB 42759 3797 19 explained explain VBN 42759 3797 20 and and CC 42759 3797 21 supplemented supplement VBD 42759 3797 22 ; ; : 42759 3797 23 or or CC 42759 3797 24 the the DT 42759 3797 25 present present JJ 42759 3797 26 cost cost NN 42759 3797 27 of of IN 42759 3797 28 reproducing reproduce VBG 42759 3797 29 the the DT 42759 3797 30 business business NN 42759 3797 31 . . . 42759 3798 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3798 2 Injurious injurious JJ 42759 3798 3 Effects Effects NNPS 42759 3798 4 of of IN 42759 3798 5 Stockwatering Stockwatering NNP 42759 3798 6 _ _ NNP 42759 3798 7 Stockwatering Stockwatering NNP 42759 3798 8 can can MD 42759 3798 9 become become VB 42759 3798 10 an an DT 42759 3798 11 instrument instrument NN 42759 3798 12 of of IN 42759 3798 13 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3798 14 gains gain NNS 42759 3798 15 in in IN 42759 3798 16 two two CD 42759 3798 17 ways way NNS 42759 3798 18 : : : 42759 3798 19 first first RB 42759 3798 20 , , , 42759 3798 21 through through IN 42759 3798 22 fraud fraud NN 42759 3798 23 inflicted inflict VBN 42759 3798 24 upon upon IN 42759 3798 25 some some DT 42759 3798 26 of of IN 42759 3798 27 the the DT 42759 3798 28 investors investor NNS 42759 3798 29 ; ; : 42759 3798 30 second second LS 42759 3798 31 , , , 42759 3798 32 through through IN 42759 3798 33 the the DT 42759 3798 34 imposition imposition NN 42759 3798 35 of of IN 42759 3798 36 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 42759 3798 37 prices price NNS 42759 3798 38 upon upon IN 42759 3798 39 the the DT 42759 3798 40 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3798 41 . . . 42759 3799 1 The the DT 42759 3799 2 former former JJ 42759 3799 3 can can MD 42759 3799 4 not not RB 42759 3799 5 occur occur VB 42759 3799 6 so so RB 42759 3799 7 long long RB 42759 3799 8 as as IN 42759 3799 9 the the DT 42759 3799 10 process process NN 42759 3799 11 of of IN 42759 3799 12 inflation inflation NN 42759 3799 13 does do VBZ 42759 3799 14 not not RB 42759 3799 15 go go VB 42759 3799 16 beyond beyond IN 42759 3799 17 earning earn VBG 42759 3799 18 power power NN 42759 3799 19 ; ; : 42759 3799 20 for for IN 42759 3799 21 in in IN 42759 3799 22 that that DT 42759 3799 23 case case NN 42759 3799 24 all all DT 42759 3799 25 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3799 26 , , , 42759 3799 27 barring bar VBG 42759 3799 28 dishonest dishonest JJ 42759 3799 29 manipulation manipulation NN 42759 3799 30 of of IN 42759 3799 31 the the DT 42759 3799 32 company company NN 42759 3799 33 's 's POS 42759 3799 34 receipts receipt NNS 42759 3799 35 , , , 42759 3799 36 will will MD 42759 3799 37 obtain obtain VB 42759 3799 38 the the DT 42759 3799 39 normal normal JJ 42759 3799 40 rate rate NN 42759 3799 41 of of IN 42759 3799 42 interest interest NN 42759 3799 43 on on IN 42759 3799 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3799 45 investment investment NN 42759 3799 46 . . . 42759 3800 1 If if IN 42759 3800 2 , , , 42759 3800 3 however however RB 42759 3800 4 , , , 42759 3800 5 stock stock NN 42759 3800 6 is be VBZ 42759 3800 7 sold sell VBN 42759 3800 8 in in IN 42759 3800 9 excess excess NN 42759 3800 10 of of IN 42759 3800 11 the the DT 42759 3800 12 earning earn VBG 42759 3800 13 power power NN 42759 3800 14 of of IN 42759 3800 15 the the DT 42759 3800 16 concern concern NN 42759 3800 17 , , , 42759 3800 18 those those DT 42759 3800 19 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3800 20 who who WP 42759 3800 21 fail fail VBP 42759 3800 22 to to TO 42759 3800 23 obtain obtain VB 42759 3800 24 the the DT 42759 3800 25 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 3800 26 rate rate NN 42759 3800 27 of of IN 42759 3800 28 interest interest NN 42759 3800 29 on on IN 42759 3800 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3800 31 money money NN 42759 3800 32 are be VBP 42759 3800 33 unjustly unjustly RB 42759 3800 34 treated treat VBN 42759 3800 35 in in IN 42759 3800 36 so so RB 42759 3800 37 far far RB 42759 3800 38 as as IN 42759 3800 39 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3800 40 have have VBP 42759 3800 41 been be VBN 42759 3800 42 deceived deceive VBN 42759 3800 43 . . . 42759 3801 1 And and CC 42759 3801 2 those those DT 42759 3801 3 officers officer NNS 42759 3801 4 or or CC 42759 3801 5 other other JJ 42759 3801 6 members member NNS 42759 3801 7 of of IN 42759 3801 8 the the DT 42759 3801 9 corporation corporation NN 42759 3801 10 who who WP 42759 3801 11 have have VBP 42759 3801 12 profited profit VBN 42759 3801 13 by by IN 42759 3801 14 the the DT 42759 3801 15 deception deception NN 42759 3801 16 of of IN 42759 3801 17 and and CC 42759 3801 18 injury injury NN 42759 3801 19 to to IN 42759 3801 20 these these DT 42759 3801 21 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3801 22 , , , 42759 3801 23 are be VBP 42759 3801 24 the the DT 42759 3801 25 recipients recipient NNS 42759 3801 26 of of IN 42759 3801 27 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3801 28 gains gain NNS 42759 3801 29 . . . 42759 3802 1 Daniel Daniel NNP 42759 3802 2 Drew Drew NNP 42759 3802 3 inflated inflate VBD 42759 3802 4 the the DT 42759 3802 5 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3802 6 of of IN 42759 3802 7 the the DT 42759 3802 8 Erie Erie NNP 42759 3802 9 Railroad Railroad NNP 42759 3802 10 from from IN 42759 3802 11 seventeen seventeen CD 42759 3802 12 millions million NNS 42759 3802 13 to to IN 42759 3802 14 seventy seventy CD 42759 3802 15 - - HYPH 42759 3802 16 eight eight CD 42759 3802 17 millions million NNS 42759 3802 18 within within IN 42759 3802 19 four four CD 42759 3802 20 years year NNS 42759 3802 21 for for IN 42759 3802 22 the the DT 42759 3802 23 purpose purpose NN 42759 3802 24 of of IN 42759 3802 25 manipulating manipulate VBG 42759 3802 26 the the DT 42759 3802 27 stock stock NN 42759 3802 28 market market NN 42759 3802 29 ; ; , 42759 3802 30 owing owe VBG 42759 3802 31 to to IN 42759 3802 32 excessive excessive JJ 42759 3802 33 issues issue NNS 42759 3802 34 of of IN 42759 3802 35 stock stock NN 42759 3802 36 , , , 42759 3802 37 the the DT 42759 3802 38 American American NNP 42759 3802 39 Shipbuilding Shipbuilding NNP 42759 3802 40 Company Company NNP 42759 3802 41 was be VBD 42759 3802 42 thrown throw VBN 42759 3802 43 into into IN 42759 3802 44 bankruptcy bankruptcy NN 42759 3802 45 to to IN 42759 3802 46 the the DT 42759 3802 47 great great JJ 42759 3802 48 injury injury NN 42759 3802 49 of of IN 42759 3802 50 all all DT 42759 3802 51 but but IN 42759 3802 52 one one CD 42759 3802 53 of of IN 42759 3802 54 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3802 55 stockholders;[186 stockholders;[186 NNS 42759 3802 56 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3802 57 because because IN 42759 3802 58 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3802 59 issued issue VBD 42759 3802 60 securities security NNS 42759 3802 61 to to TO 42759 3802 62 buy buy VB 42759 3802 63 subsidiary subsidiary NN 42759 3802 64 railway railway NN 42759 3802 65 lines line NNS 42759 3802 66 at at IN 42759 3802 67 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 42759 3802 68 prices price NNS 42759 3802 69 , , , 42759 3802 70 and and CC 42759 3802 71 to to TO 42759 3802 72 provide provide VB 42759 3802 73 extravagant extravagant JJ 42759 3802 74 commissions commission NNS 42759 3802 75 and and CC 42759 3802 76 discounts discount NNS 42759 3802 77 for for IN 42759 3802 78 bankers banker NNS 42759 3802 79 , , , 42759 3802 80 the the DT 42759 3802 81 directors director NNS 42759 3802 82 of of IN 42759 3802 83 the the DT 42759 3802 84 ' ' `` 42759 3802 85 Frisco Frisco NNP 42759 3802 86 System System NNP 42759 3802 87 forced force VBD 42759 3802 88 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3802 89 into into IN 42759 3802 90 a a DT 42759 3802 91 receivership receivership NN 42759 3802 92 , , , 42759 3802 93 after after IN 42759 3802 94 having have VBG 42759 3802 95 inflicted inflict VBN 42759 3802 96 a a DT 42759 3802 97 net net JJ 42759 3802 98 loss loss NN 42759 3802 99 of of IN 42759 3802 100 four four CD 42759 3802 101 million million CD 42759 3802 102 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3802 103 per per IN 42759 3802 104 year year NN 42759 3802 105 upon upon IN 42759 3802 106 the the DT 42759 3802 107 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3802 108 . . . 42759 3803 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3803 2 187 187 CD 42759 3803 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3803 4 Many many JJ 42759 3803 5 other other JJ 42759 3803 6 notable notable JJ 42759 3803 7 performances performance NNS 42759 3803 8 might may MD 42759 3803 9 be be VB 42759 3803 10 cited cite VBN 42759 3803 11 where where WRB 42759 3803 12 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 3803 13 , , , 42759 3803 14 both both CC 42759 3803 15 in in IN 42759 3803 16 railroads railroad NNS 42759 3803 17 and and CC 42759 3803 18 in in IN 42759 3803 19 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3803 20 concerns concern NNS 42759 3803 21 , , , 42759 3803 22 has have VBZ 42759 3803 23 defrauded defraud VBN 42759 3803 24 investors investor NNS 42759 3803 25 of of IN 42759 3803 26 millions million NNS 42759 3803 27 of of IN 42759 3803 28 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3803 29 , , , 42759 3803 30 and and CC 42759 3803 31 enabled enable VBD 42759 3803 32 a a DT 42759 3803 33 few few JJ 42759 3803 34 powerful powerful JJ 42759 3803 35 directors director NNS 42759 3803 36 to to TO 42759 3803 37 reap reap VB 42759 3803 38 corresponding corresponding JJ 42759 3803 39 enormous enormous JJ 42759 3803 40 profits profit NNS 42759 3803 41 . . . 42759 3804 1 At at IN 42759 3804 2 first first JJ 42759 3804 3 sight sight NN 42759 3804 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3804 5 would would MD 42759 3804 6 seem seem VB 42759 3804 7 that that IN 42759 3804 8 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 3804 9 is be VBZ 42759 3804 10 of of IN 42759 3804 11 little little JJ 42759 3804 12 or or CC 42759 3804 13 no no DT 42759 3804 14 importance importance NN 42759 3804 15 to to IN 42759 3804 16 the the DT 42759 3804 17 consumer consumer NN 42759 3804 18 . . . 42759 3805 1 Since since IN 42759 3805 2 a a DT 42759 3805 3 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3805 4 concern concern NN 42759 3805 5 endeavours endeavour NNS 42759 3805 6 to to TO 42759 3805 7 fix fix VB 42759 3805 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3805 9 prices price NNS 42759 3805 10 at at IN 42759 3805 11 the the DT 42759 3805 12 point point NN 42759 3805 13 that that WDT 42759 3805 14 will will MD 42759 3805 15 yield yield VB 42759 3805 16 the the DT 42759 3805 17 maximum maximum JJ 42759 3805 18 net net JJ 42759 3805 19 profit profit NN 42759 3805 20 in in IN 42759 3805 21 any any DT 42759 3805 22 case case NN 42759 3805 23 , , , 42759 3805 24 the the DT 42759 3805 25 amount amount NN 42759 3805 26 of of IN 42759 3805 27 stock stock NN 42759 3805 28 in in IN 42759 3805 29 existence existence NN 42759 3805 30 would would MD 42759 3805 31 seem seem VB 42759 3805 32 to to TO 42759 3805 33 be be VB 42759 3805 34 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 42759 3805 35 to to IN 42759 3805 36 the the DT 42759 3805 37 problem problem NN 42759 3805 38 . . . 42759 3806 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 3806 2 , , , 42759 3806 3 the the DT 42759 3806 4 presence presence NN 42759 3806 5 of of IN 42759 3806 6 a a DT 42759 3806 7 large large JJ 42759 3806 8 quantity quantity NN 42759 3806 9 of of IN 42759 3806 10 fictitious fictitious JJ 42759 3806 11 capital capital NN 42759 3806 12 whose whose WP$ 42759 3806 13 owners owner NNS 42759 3806 14 are be VBP 42759 3806 15 calling call VBG 42759 3806 16 for for IN 42759 3806 17 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3806 18 , , , 42759 3806 19 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3806 20 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 3806 21 a a DT 42759 3806 22 special special JJ 42759 3806 23 force force NN 42759 3806 24 impelling impel VBG 42759 3806 25 the the DT 42759 3806 26 imposition imposition NN 42759 3806 27 of of IN 42759 3806 28 higher high JJR 42759 3806 29 prices price NNS 42759 3806 30 and and CC 42759 3806 31 charges charge NNS 42759 3806 32 . . . 42759 3807 1 " " `` 42759 3807 2 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3807 3 will will MD 42759 3807 4 happen happen VB 42759 3807 5 at at IN 42759 3807 6 times time NNS 42759 3807 7 that that IN 42759 3807 8 overcapitalisation overcapitalisation NN 42759 3807 9 does do VBZ 42759 3807 10 at at IN 42759 3807 11 least least JJS 42759 3807 12 cause cause VB 42759 3807 13 a a DT 42759 3807 14 clinging clinging NN 42759 3807 15 to to IN 42759 3807 16 high high JJ 42759 3807 17 prices price NNS 42759 3807 18 . . . 42759 3808 1 The the DT 42759 3808 2 managers manager NNS 42759 3808 3 of of IN 42759 3808 4 an an DT 42759 3808 5 overcapitalised overcapitalised JJ 42759 3808 6 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3808 7 may may MD 42759 3808 8 have have VB 42759 3808 9 to to TO 42759 3808 10 face face VB 42759 3808 11 the the DT 42759 3808 12 fact fact NN 42759 3808 13 that that IN 42759 3808 14 great great JJ 42759 3808 15 blocks block NNS 42759 3808 16 of of IN 42759 3808 17 securities security NNS 42759 3808 18 are be VBP 42759 3808 19 outstanding outstanding JJ 42759 3808 20 , , , 42759 3808 21 very very RB 42759 3808 22 likely likely RB 42759 3808 23 issued issue VBN 42759 3808 24 by by IN 42759 3808 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3808 26 predecessors predecessor NNS 42759 3808 27 , , , 42759 3808 28 and and CC 42759 3808 29 now now RB 42759 3808 30 held hold VBN 42759 3808 31 by by IN 42759 3808 32 all all DT 42759 3808 33 sorts sort NNS 42759 3808 34 of of IN 42759 3808 35 investors investor NNS 42759 3808 36 . . . 42759 3809 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3809 2 are be VBP 42759 3809 3 then then RB 42759 3809 4 loath loath JJ 42759 3809 5 to to TO 42759 3809 6 let let VB 42759 3809 7 go go VB 42759 3809 8 any any DT 42759 3809 9 slice slice NN 42759 3809 10 of of IN 42759 3809 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3809 12 profits profit NNS 42759 3809 13 . . . 42759 3810 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 3810 2 have have VBP 42759 3810 3 seen see VBN 42759 3810 4 that that IN 42759 3810 5 often often RB 42759 3810 6 the the DT 42759 3810 7 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3810 8 principle principle NN 42759 3810 9 of of IN 42759 3810 10 maximum maximum JJ 42759 3810 11 net net JJ 42759 3810 12 profit profit NN 42759 3810 13 is be VBZ 42759 3810 14 not not RB 42759 3810 15 applied apply VBN 42759 3810 16 in in IN 42759 3810 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3810 18 full full JJ 42759 3810 19 sweep sweep NN 42759 3810 20 , , , 42759 3810 21 especially especially RB 42759 3810 22 in in IN 42759 3810 23 industries industry NNS 42759 3810 24 which which WDT 42759 3810 25 are be VBP 42759 3810 26 potentially potentially RB 42759 3810 27 subject subject JJ 42759 3810 28 to to IN 42759 3810 29 public public JJ 42759 3810 30 control control NN 42759 3810 31 . . . 42759 3811 1 Where where WRB 42759 3811 2 abnormal abnormal JJ 42759 3811 3 returns return NNS 42759 3811 4 on on IN 42759 3811 5 the the DT 42759 3811 6 original original JJ 42759 3811 7 investment investment NN 42759 3811 8 have have VBP 42759 3811 9 been be VBN 42759 3811 10 made make VBN 42759 3811 11 , , , 42759 3811 12 concessions concession NNS 42759 3811 13 to to IN 42759 3811 14 public public JJ 42759 3811 15 opinion opinion NN 42759 3811 16 in in IN 42759 3811 17 the the DT 42759 3811 18 way way NN 42759 3811 19 of of IN 42759 3811 20 low low JJ 42759 3811 21 rates rate NNS 42759 3811 22 and and CC 42759 3811 23 better well JJR 42759 3811 24 facilities facility NNS 42759 3811 25 are be VBP 42759 3811 26 more more RBR 42759 3811 27 likely likely JJ 42759 3811 28 to to TO 42759 3811 29 come come VB 42759 3811 30 when when WRB 42759 3811 31 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3811 32 has have VBZ 42759 3811 33 not not RB 42759 3811 34 been be VBN 42759 3811 35 inflated inflate VBN 42759 3811 36 . . . 42759 3812 1 " " `` 42759 3812 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3812 3 188 188 CD 42759 3812 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3812 5 The the DT 42759 3812 6 United United NNP 42759 3812 7 States States NNP 42759 3812 8 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 3812 9 Commission Commission NNP 42759 3812 10 found find VBD 42759 3812 11 that that IN 42759 3812 12 as as IN 42759 3812 13 regards regard VBZ 42759 3812 14 railroads railroad NNS 42759 3812 15 : : : 42759 3812 16 " " `` 42759 3812 17 In in IN 42759 3812 18 the the DT 42759 3812 19 long long JJ 42759 3812 20 run run NN 42759 3812 21 excessive excessive JJ 42759 3812 22 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3812 23 tends tend VBZ 42759 3812 24 to to TO 42759 3812 25 keep keep VB 42759 3812 26 rates rate NNS 42759 3812 27 high high JJ 42759 3812 28 ; ; : 42759 3812 29 conservative conservative JJ 42759 3812 30 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3812 31 tends tend VBZ 42759 3812 32 to to TO 42759 3812 33 make make VB 42759 3812 34 rates rate NNS 42759 3812 35 low low JJ 42759 3812 36 . . . 42759 3813 1 " " `` 42759 3813 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3813 3 189 189 CD 42759 3813 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3813 5 This this DT 42759 3813 6 indirect indirect JJ 42759 3813 7 influence influence NN 42759 3813 8 of of IN 42759 3813 9 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 3813 10 toward toward IN 42759 3813 11 excessive excessive JJ 42759 3813 12 rates rate NNS 42759 3813 13 and and CC 42759 3813 14 prices price NNS 42759 3813 15 becomes become VBZ 42759 3813 16 effective effective JJ 42759 3813 17 in in IN 42759 3813 18 two two CD 42759 3813 19 ways way NNS 42759 3813 20 . . . 42759 3814 1 The the DT 42759 3814 2 existence existence NN 42759 3814 3 of of IN 42759 3814 4 fictitious fictitious JJ 42759 3814 5 capital capital NN 42759 3814 6 conceals conceal NNS 42759 3814 7 from from IN 42759 3814 8 the the DT 42759 3814 9 public public NN 42759 3814 10 the the DT 42759 3814 11 high high JJ 42759 3814 12 rate rate NN 42759 3814 13 of of IN 42759 3814 14 return return NN 42759 3814 15 that that WDT 42759 3814 16 is be VBZ 42759 3814 17 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3814 18 on on IN 42759 3814 19 the the DT 42759 3814 20 true true JJ 42759 3814 21 valuation valuation NN 42759 3814 22 , , , 42759 3814 23 thus thus RB 42759 3814 24 preventing prevent VBG 42759 3814 25 effective effective JJ 42759 3814 26 action action NN 42759 3814 27 for for IN 42759 3814 28 a a DT 42759 3814 29 reduction reduction NN 42759 3814 30 in in IN 42759 3814 31 prices price NNS 42759 3814 32 and and CC 42759 3814 33 charges charge NNS 42759 3814 34 ; ; : 42759 3814 35 and and CC 42759 3814 36 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3814 37 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3814 38 causes cause VBZ 42759 3814 39 the the DT 42759 3814 40 rate rate NN 42759 3814 41 - - HYPH 42759 3814 42 making make VBG 42759 3814 43 authorities authority NNS 42759 3814 44 to to TO 42759 3814 45 allow allow VB 42759 3814 46 rates rate NNS 42759 3814 47 to to TO 42759 3814 48 be be VB 42759 3814 49 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3814 50 high high JJ 42759 3814 51 to to TO 42759 3814 52 yield yield VB 42759 3814 53 something something NN 42759 3814 54 to to IN 42759 3814 55 the the DT 42759 3814 56 investors investor NNS 42759 3814 57 in in IN 42759 3814 58 the the DT 42759 3814 59 inflated inflate VBN 42759 3814 60 capital capital NN 42759 3814 61 . . . 42759 3815 1 If if IN 42759 3815 2 a a DT 42759 3815 3 trust trust NN 42759 3815 4 or or CC 42759 3815 5 a a DT 42759 3815 6 railroad railroad NN 42759 3815 7 has have VBZ 42759 3815 8 issued issue VBN 42759 3815 9 stock stock NN 42759 3815 10 having have VBG 42759 3815 11 a a DT 42759 3815 12 par par NN 42759 3815 13 value value NN 42759 3815 14 of of IN 42759 3815 15 twice twice PDT 42759 3815 16 the the DT 42759 3815 17 capital capital NN 42759 3815 18 invested invest VBN 42759 3815 19 , , , 42759 3815 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3815 21 rate rate NN 42759 3815 22 of of IN 42759 3815 23 dividend dividend NN 42759 3815 24 on on IN 42759 3815 25 the the DT 42759 3815 26 entire entire JJ 42759 3815 27 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3815 28 will will MD 42759 3815 29 be be VB 42759 3815 30 only only RB 42759 3815 31 one one CD 42759 3815 32 - - HYPH 42759 3815 33 half half NN 42759 3815 34 the the DT 42759 3815 35 rate rate NN 42759 3815 36 of of IN 42759 3815 37 interest interest NN 42759 3815 38 that that IN 42759 3815 39 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3815 40 is be VBZ 42759 3815 41 receiving receive VBG 42759 3815 42 on on IN 42759 3815 43 the the DT 42759 3815 44 investment investment NN 42759 3815 45 . . . 42759 3816 1 If if IN 42759 3816 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3816 3 pays pay VBZ 42759 3816 4 , , , 42759 3816 5 for for IN 42759 3816 6 example example NN 42759 3816 7 , , , 42759 3816 8 seven seven CD 42759 3816 9 per per IN 42759 3816 10 cent cent NN 42759 3816 11 . . . 42759 3817 1 on on IN 42759 3817 2 all all DT 42759 3817 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3817 4 stock stock NN 42759 3817 5 , , , 42759 3817 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3817 7 will will MD 42759 3817 8 be be VB 42759 3817 9 getting get VBG 42759 3817 10 fourteen fourteen CD 42759 3817 11 per per IN 42759 3817 12 cent cent NN 42759 3817 13 . . . 42759 3818 1 on on IN 42759 3818 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3818 3 genuine genuine JJ 42759 3818 4 capital capital NN 42759 3818 5 . . . 42759 3819 1 While while IN 42759 3819 2 the the DT 42759 3819 3 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3819 4 of of IN 42759 3819 5 tobacco tobacco NN 42759 3819 6 , , , 42759 3819 7 or or CC 42759 3819 8 the the DT 42759 3819 9 patrons patron NNS 42759 3819 10 of of IN 42759 3819 11 a a DT 42759 3819 12 railroad railroad NN 42759 3819 13 , , , 42759 3819 14 would would MD 42759 3819 15 raise raise VB 42759 3819 16 no no DT 42759 3819 17 outcry outcry NN 42759 3819 18 against against IN 42759 3819 19 seven seven CD 42759 3819 20 per per IN 42759 3819 21 cent cent NN 42759 3819 22 . . . 42759 3820 1 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3820 2 , , , 42759 3820 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3820 4 would would MD 42759 3820 5 probably probably RB 42759 3820 6 begin begin VB 42759 3820 7 to to TO 42759 3820 8 agitate agitate VB 42759 3820 9 for for IN 42759 3820 10 an an DT 42759 3820 11 enforcement enforcement NN 42759 3820 12 of of IN 42759 3820 13 the the DT 42759 3820 14 anti anti JJ 42759 3820 15 - - JJ 42759 3820 16 trust trust JJ 42759 3820 17 laws law NNS 42759 3820 18 , , , 42759 3820 19 and and CC 42759 3820 20 for for IN 42759 3820 21 a a DT 42759 3820 22 reduction reduction NN 42759 3820 23 in in IN 42759 3820 24 freight freight NN 42759 3820 25 and and CC 42759 3820 26 passenger passenger NN 42759 3820 27 charges charge NNS 42759 3820 28 , , , 42759 3820 29 if if IN 42759 3820 30 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3820 31 realised realise VBD 42759 3820 32 that that IN 42759 3820 33 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3820 34 were be VBD 42759 3820 35 providing provide VBG 42759 3820 36 for for IN 42759 3820 37 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3820 38 of of IN 42759 3820 39 fourteen fourteen CD 42759 3820 40 per per IN 42759 3820 41 cent cent NN 42759 3820 42 . . . 42759 3821 1 Nor nor CC 42759 3821 2 is be VBZ 42759 3821 3 the the DT 42759 3821 4 public public NN 42759 3821 5 adequately adequately RB 42759 3821 6 protected protect VBN 42759 3821 7 by by IN 42759 3821 8 government government NN 42759 3821 9 investigations investigation NNS 42759 3821 10 of of IN 42759 3821 11 trusts trust NNS 42759 3821 12 and and CC 42759 3821 13 regulation regulation NN 42759 3821 14 of of IN 42759 3821 15 railway railway NN 42759 3821 16 rates rate NNS 42759 3821 17 . . . 42759 3822 1 Despite despite IN 42759 3822 2 the the DT 42759 3822 3 anti anti JJ 42759 3822 4 - - JJ 42759 3822 5 trust trust JJ 42759 3822 6 laws law NNS 42759 3822 7 , , , 42759 3822 8 many many JJ 42759 3822 9 American american JJ 42759 3822 10 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3822 11 have have VBP 42759 3822 12 for for IN 42759 3822 13 many many JJ 42759 3822 14 years year NNS 42759 3822 15 received receive VBD 42759 3822 16 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 42759 3822 17 profits profit NNS 42759 3822 18 through through IN 42759 3822 19 excessive excessive JJ 42759 3822 20 prices price NNS 42759 3822 21 imposed impose VBN 42759 3822 22 upon upon IN 42759 3822 23 the the DT 42759 3822 24 consumer consumer NN 42759 3822 25 ; ; : 42759 3822 26 and and CC 42759 3822 27 in in IN 42759 3822 28 many many JJ 42759 3822 29 of of IN 42759 3822 30 these these DT 42759 3822 31 instances instance NNS 42759 3822 32 overcapitalisation overcapitalisation NN 42759 3822 33 and and CC 42759 3822 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3822 35 resulting result VBG 42759 3822 36 concealment concealment NN 42759 3822 37 of of IN 42759 3822 38 real real JJ 42759 3822 39 profits profit NNS 42759 3822 40 have have VBP 42759 3822 41 been be VBN 42759 3822 42 of of IN 42759 3822 43 considerable considerable JJ 42759 3822 44 assistance assistance NN 42759 3822 45 to to IN 42759 3822 46 the the DT 42759 3822 47 extortionate extortionate JJ 42759 3822 48 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3822 49 . . . 42759 3823 1 In in IN 42759 3823 2 fixing fix VBG 42759 3823 3 railway railway NN 42759 3823 4 rates rate NNS 42759 3823 5 , , , 42759 3823 6 the the DT 42759 3823 7 Interstate Interstate NNP 42759 3823 8 Commerce Commerce NNP 42759 3823 9 Commission Commission NNP 42759 3823 10 , , , 42759 3823 11 and and CC 42759 3823 12 the the DT 42759 3823 13 various various JJ 42759 3823 14 state state NN 42759 3823 15 railroad railroad NN 42759 3823 16 commissions commission NNS 42759 3823 17 , , , 42759 3823 18 have have VBP 42759 3823 19 been be VBN 42759 3823 20 seriously seriously RB 42759 3823 21 hampered hamper VBN 42759 3823 22 by by IN 42759 3823 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3823 24 inability inability NN 42759 3823 25 to to TO 42759 3823 26 determine determine VB 42759 3823 27 the the DT 42759 3823 28 real real JJ 42759 3823 29 investment investment NN 42759 3823 30 of of IN 42759 3823 31 the the DT 42759 3823 32 roads road NNS 42759 3823 33 , , , 42759 3823 34 and and CC 42759 3823 35 to to TO 42759 3823 36 separate separate VB 42759 3823 37 the the DT 42759 3823 38 genuine genuine NN 42759 3823 39 from from IN 42759 3823 40 the the DT 42759 3823 41 fictitious fictitious JJ 42759 3823 42 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3823 43 . . . 42759 3824 1 Not not RB 42759 3824 2 until until IN 42759 3824 3 the the DT 42759 3824 4 year year NN 42759 3824 5 1913 1913 CD 42759 3824 6 did do VBD 42759 3824 7 the the DT 42759 3824 8 national national JJ 42759 3824 9 government government NN 42759 3824 10 begin begin VB 42759 3824 11 the the DT 42759 3824 12 task task NN 42759 3824 13 of of IN 42759 3824 14 making make VBG 42759 3824 15 a a DT 42759 3824 16 valuation valuation NN 42759 3824 17 of of IN 42759 3824 18 interstate interstate JJ 42759 3824 19 railroad railroad NN 42759 3824 20 property property NN 42759 3824 21 , , , 42759 3824 22 and and CC 42759 3824 23 the the DT 42759 3824 24 work work NN 42759 3824 25 will will MD 42759 3824 26 require require VB 42759 3824 27 several several JJ 42759 3824 28 years year NNS 42759 3824 29 . . . 42759 3825 1 Very very RB 42759 3825 2 few few JJ 42759 3825 3 of of IN 42759 3825 4 the the DT 42759 3825 5 states state NNS 42759 3825 6 have have VBP 42759 3825 7 made make VBN 42759 3825 8 valuations valuation NNS 42759 3825 9 of of IN 42759 3825 10 the the DT 42759 3825 11 railroads railroad NNS 42759 3825 12 within within IN 42759 3825 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3825 14 borders border NNS 42759 3825 15 . . . 42759 3826 1 In in IN 42759 3826 2 the the DT 42759 3826 3 meantime meantime NN 42759 3826 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3826 5 is be VBZ 42759 3826 6 certain certain JJ 42759 3826 7 that that IN 42759 3826 8 many many JJ 42759 3826 9 of of IN 42759 3826 10 the the DT 42759 3826 11 rates rate NNS 42759 3826 12 fixed fix VBN 42759 3826 13 by by IN 42759 3826 14 both both CC 42759 3826 15 the the DT 42759 3826 16 national national JJ 42759 3826 17 and and CC 42759 3826 18 the the DT 42759 3826 19 state state NN 42759 3826 20 bodies body NNS 42759 3826 21 will will MD 42759 3826 22 continue continue VB 42759 3826 23 , , , 42759 3826 24 as as IN 42759 3826 25 in in IN 42759 3826 26 the the DT 42759 3826 27 past past NN 42759 3826 28 , , , 42759 3826 29 to to TO 42759 3826 30 be be VB 42759 3826 31 higher high JJR 42759 3826 32 than than IN 42759 3826 33 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3826 34 would would MD 42759 3826 35 have have VB 42759 3826 36 been be VBN 42759 3826 37 if if IN 42759 3826 38 the the DT 42759 3826 39 true true JJ 42759 3826 40 value value NN 42759 3826 41 of of IN 42759 3826 42 the the DT 42759 3826 43 railroads railroad NNS 42759 3826 44 were be VBD 42759 3826 45 known know VBN 42759 3826 46 and and CC 42759 3826 47 accepted accept VBN 42759 3826 48 as as IN 42759 3826 49 the the DT 42759 3826 50 basis basis NN 42759 3826 51 of of IN 42759 3826 52 freight freight NN 42759 3826 53 and and CC 42759 3826 54 passenger passenger NN 42759 3826 55 charges charge NNS 42759 3826 56 . . . 42759 3827 1 The the DT 42759 3827 2 second second JJ 42759 3827 3 bad bad JJ 42759 3827 4 effect effect NN 42759 3827 5 of of IN 42759 3827 6 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 3827 7 on on IN 42759 3827 8 the the DT 42759 3827 9 consumer consumer NN 42759 3827 10 is be VBZ 42759 3827 11 seen see VBN 42759 3827 12 when when WRB 42759 3827 13 rate rate NN 42759 3827 14 - - HYPH 42759 3827 15 fixing fix VBG 42759 3827 16 bodies body NNS 42759 3827 17 deliberately deliberately RB 42759 3827 18 permit permit VBP 42759 3827 19 the the DT 42759 3827 20 charges charge NNS 42759 3827 21 of of IN 42759 3827 22 public public JJ 42759 3827 23 service service NN 42759 3827 24 corporations corporation NNS 42759 3827 25 to to TO 42759 3827 26 be be VB 42759 3827 27 high high JJ 42759 3827 28 enough enough RB 42759 3827 29 to to TO 42759 3827 30 include include VB 42759 3827 31 some some DT 42759 3827 32 returns return NNS 42759 3827 33 on on IN 42759 3827 34 that that DT 42759 3827 35 portion portion NN 42759 3827 36 of of IN 42759 3827 37 the the DT 42759 3827 38 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3827 39 which which WDT 42759 3827 40 is be VBZ 42759 3827 41 fictitious fictitious JJ 42759 3827 42 . . . 42759 3828 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3828 2 is be VBZ 42759 3828 3 very very RB 42759 3828 4 difficult difficult JJ 42759 3828 5 for for IN 42759 3828 6 such such JJ 42759 3828 7 authorities authority NNS 42759 3828 8 to to TO 42759 3828 9 resist resist VB 42759 3828 10 entirely entirely RB 42759 3828 11 the the DT 42759 3828 12 plea plea NN 42759 3828 13 of of IN 42759 3828 14 the the DT 42759 3828 15 " " `` 42759 3828 16 innocent innocent JJ 42759 3828 17 investor investor NN 42759 3828 18 . . . 42759 3828 19 " " '' 42759 3829 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 3829 2 , , , 42759 3829 3 railroad railroad NN 42759 3829 4 commissions commission NNS 42759 3829 5 and and CC 42759 3829 6 other other JJ 42759 3829 7 rate rate NN 42759 3829 8 making make VBG 42759 3829 9 authorities authority NNS 42759 3829 10 , , , 42759 3829 11 and and CC 42759 3829 12 even even RB 42759 3829 13 the the DT 42759 3829 14 courts court NNS 42759 3829 15 , , , 42759 3829 16 have have VBP 42759 3829 17 occasionally occasionally RB 42759 3829 18 made make VBN 42759 3829 19 some some DT 42759 3829 20 provision provision NN 42759 3829 21 for for IN 42759 3829 22 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3829 23 on on IN 42759 3829 24 the the DT 42759 3829 25 " " `` 42759 3829 26 water water NN 42759 3829 27 . . . 42759 3829 28 " " '' 42759 3830 1 Chairman Chairman NNP 42759 3830 2 Knapp Knapp NNP 42759 3830 3 of of IN 42759 3830 4 the the DT 42759 3830 5 Interstate Interstate NNP 42759 3830 6 Commerce Commerce NNP 42759 3830 7 Commission Commission NNP 42759 3830 8 admitted admit VBD 42759 3830 9 a a DT 42759 3830 10 few few JJ 42759 3830 11 years year NNS 42759 3830 12 ago ago RB 42759 3830 13 that that IN 42759 3830 14 , , , 42759 3830 15 in in IN 42759 3830 16 considering consider VBG 42759 3830 17 the the DT 42759 3830 18 reasonableness reasonableness NN 42759 3830 19 of of IN 42759 3830 20 a a DT 42759 3830 21 given give VBN 42759 3830 22 rate rate NN 42759 3830 23 , , , 42759 3830 24 this this DT 42759 3830 25 body body NN 42759 3830 26 took take VBD 42759 3830 27 into into IN 42759 3830 28 account account NN 42759 3830 29 the the DT 42759 3830 30 financial financial JJ 42759 3830 31 condition condition NN 42759 3830 32 , , , 42759 3830 33 and and CC 42759 3830 34 therefore therefore RB 42759 3830 35 the the DT 42759 3830 36 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3830 37 of of IN 42759 3830 38 the the DT 42759 3830 39 railroad railroad NN 42759 3830 40 . . . 42759 3831 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3831 2 190 190 CD 42759 3831 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3831 4 In in IN 42759 3831 5 1914 1914 CD 42759 3831 6 and and CC 42759 3831 7 1915 1915 CD 42759 3831 8 practically practically RB 42759 3831 9 all all PDT 42759 3831 10 the the DT 42759 3831 11 great great JJ 42759 3831 12 railway railway NN 42759 3831 13 systems system NNS 42759 3831 14 of of IN 42759 3831 15 the the DT 42759 3831 16 United United NNP 42759 3831 17 States States NNP 42759 3831 18 made make VBD 42759 3831 19 powerful powerful JJ 42759 3831 20 , , , 42759 3831 21 and and CC 42759 3831 22 in in IN 42759 3831 23 a a DT 42759 3831 24 measure measure NN 42759 3831 25 successful successful JJ 42759 3831 26 , , , 42759 3831 27 appeals appeal NNS 42759 3831 28 to to IN 42759 3831 29 the the DT 42759 3831 30 Interstate Interstate NNP 42759 3831 31 Commerce Commerce NNP 42759 3831 32 Commission Commission NNP 42759 3831 33 for for IN 42759 3831 34 a a DT 42759 3831 35 rise rise NN 42759 3831 36 in in IN 42759 3831 37 rates rate NNS 42759 3831 38 on on IN 42759 3831 39 the the DT 42759 3831 40 ground ground NN 42759 3831 41 that that IN 42759 3831 42 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3831 43 were be VBD 42759 3831 44 unable unable JJ 42759 3831 45 to to TO 42759 3831 46 pay pay VB 42759 3831 47 the the DT 42759 3831 48 normal normal JJ 42759 3831 49 rate rate NN 42759 3831 50 of of IN 42759 3831 51 interest interest NN 42759 3831 52 on on IN 42759 3831 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3831 54 securities security NNS 42759 3831 55 , , , 42759 3831 56 and and CC 42759 3831 57 hence hence RB 42759 3831 58 could could MD 42759 3831 59 not not RB 42759 3831 60 obtain obtain VB 42759 3831 61 on on IN 42759 3831 62 advantageous advantageous JJ 42759 3831 63 terms term NNS 42759 3831 64 new new JJ 42759 3831 65 capital capital NN 42759 3831 66 needed need VBN 42759 3831 67 for for IN 42759 3831 68 improvements improvement NNS 42759 3831 69 . . . 42759 3832 1 Had have VBD 42759 3832 2 the the DT 42759 3832 3 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3832 4 of of IN 42759 3832 5 the the DT 42759 3832 6 roads road NNS 42759 3832 7 been be VBN 42759 3832 8 kept keep VBN 42759 3832 9 down down RP 42759 3832 10 to to IN 42759 3832 11 the the DT 42759 3832 12 actual actual JJ 42759 3832 13 investment investment NN 42759 3832 14 , , , 42759 3832 15 most most JJS 42759 3832 16 of of IN 42759 3832 17 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3832 18 would would MD 42759 3832 19 have have VB 42759 3832 20 been be VBN 42759 3832 21 able able JJ 42759 3832 22 to to TO 42759 3832 23 pay pay VB 42759 3832 24 the the DT 42759 3832 25 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3832 26 rate rate NN 42759 3832 27 of of IN 42759 3832 28 interest interest NN 42759 3832 29 on on IN 42759 3832 30 all all DT 42759 3832 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3832 32 stock stock NN 42759 3832 33 , , , 42759 3832 34 and and CC 42759 3832 35 still still RB 42759 3832 36 have have VB 42759 3832 37 a a DT 42759 3832 38 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3832 39 surplus surplus NN 42759 3832 40 to to TO 42759 3832 41 command command VB 42759 3832 42 excellent excellent JJ 42759 3832 43 credit credit NN 42759 3832 44 . . . 42759 3833 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3833 2 The the DT 42759 3833 3 Moral Moral NNP 42759 3833 4 Wrong Wrong NNP 42759 3833 5 _ _ IN 42759 3833 6 When when WRB 42759 3833 7 prices price NNS 42759 3833 8 or or CC 42759 3833 9 charges charge NNS 42759 3833 10 are be VBP 42759 3833 11 made make VBN 42759 3833 12 high high JJ 42759 3833 13 enough enough RB 42759 3833 14 to to TO 42759 3833 15 provide provide VB 42759 3833 16 returns return NNS 42759 3833 17 on on IN 42759 3833 18 fictitious fictitious JJ 42759 3833 19 capital capital NN 42759 3833 20 , , , 42759 3833 21 the the DT 42759 3833 22 consumer consumer NN 42759 3833 23 is be VBZ 42759 3833 24 treated treat VBN 42759 3833 25 unjustly unjustly RB 42759 3833 26 . . . 42759 3834 1 As as IN 42759 3834 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3834 3 have have VBP 42759 3834 4 shown show VBN 42759 3834 5 more more JJR 42759 3834 6 than than IN 42759 3834 7 once once RB 42759 3834 8 , , , 42759 3834 9 the the DT 42759 3834 10 consumer consumer NN 42759 3834 11 can can MD 42759 3834 12 not not RB 42759 3834 13 rightfully rightfully RB 42759 3834 14 be be VB 42759 3834 15 required require VBN 42759 3834 16 to to TO 42759 3834 17 pay pay VB 42759 3834 18 for for IN 42759 3834 19 the the DT 42759 3834 20 products product NNS 42759 3834 21 of of IN 42759 3834 22 a a DT 42759 3834 23 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3834 24 at at IN 42759 3834 25 a a DT 42759 3834 26 greater great JJR 42759 3834 27 rate rate NN 42759 3834 28 than than IN 42759 3834 29 is be VBZ 42759 3834 30 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3834 31 to to TO 42759 3834 32 provide provide VB 42759 3834 33 the the DT 42759 3834 34 competitive competitive JJ 42759 3834 35 rate rate NN 42759 3834 36 of of IN 42759 3834 37 interest interest NN 42759 3834 38 on on IN 42759 3834 39 capital capital NN 42759 3834 40 in in IN 42759 3834 41 the the DT 42759 3834 42 average average JJ 42759 3834 43 conditions condition NNS 42759 3834 44 of of IN 42759 3834 45 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3834 46 . . . 42759 3835 1 If if IN 42759 3835 2 some some DT 42759 3835 3 concerns concern NNS 42759 3835 4 are be VBP 42759 3835 5 able able JJ 42759 3835 6 to to TO 42759 3835 7 sell sell VB 42759 3835 8 at at IN 42759 3835 9 this this DT 42759 3835 10 price price NN 42759 3835 11 , , , 42759 3835 12 and and CC 42759 3835 13 still still RB 42759 3835 14 obtain obtain VB 42759 3835 15 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3835 16 gains gain NNS 42759 3835 17 , , , 42759 3835 18 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3835 19 have have VBP 42759 3835 20 a a DT 42759 3835 21 right right JJ 42759 3835 22 thereto thereto NN 42759 3835 23 on on IN 42759 3835 24 account account NN 42759 3835 25 of of IN 42759 3835 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3835 27 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 3835 28 productivity productivity NN 42759 3835 29 . . . 42759 3836 1 But but CC 42759 3836 2 the the DT 42759 3836 3 capital capital NN 42759 3836 4 upon upon IN 42759 3836 5 which which WDT 42759 3836 6 a a DT 42759 3836 7 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3836 8 concern concern NN 42759 3836 9 has have VBZ 42759 3836 10 a a DT 42759 3836 11 claim claim NN 42759 3836 12 to to IN 42759 3836 13 the the DT 42759 3836 14 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 3836 15 rate rate NN 42759 3836 16 of of IN 42759 3836 17 interest interest NN 42759 3836 18 , , , 42759 3836 19 is be VBZ 42759 3836 20 genuine genuine JJ 42759 3836 21 capital capital NN 42759 3836 22 : : : 42759 3836 23 that that RB 42759 3836 24 is is RB 42759 3836 25 , , , 42759 3836 26 the the DT 42759 3836 27 actual actual JJ 42759 3836 28 investment investment NN 42759 3836 29 as as IN 42759 3836 30 interpreted interpret VBN 42759 3836 31 above above RB 42759 3836 32 , , , 42759 3836 33 not not RB 42759 3836 34 an an DT 42759 3836 35 inflated inflated JJ 42759 3836 36 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3836 37 . . . 42759 3837 1 The the DT 42759 3837 2 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3837 3 may may MD 42759 3837 4 justly justly RB 42759 3837 5 be be VB 42759 3837 6 required require VBN 42759 3837 7 to to TO 42759 3837 8 pay pay VB 42759 3837 9 for for IN 42759 3837 10 the the DT 42759 3837 11 use use NN 42759 3837 12 and and CC 42759 3837 13 benefit benefit NN 42759 3837 14 of of IN 42759 3837 15 actual actual JJ 42759 3837 16 productive productive JJ 42759 3837 17 goods good NNS 42759 3837 18 ; ; : 42759 3837 19 but but CC 42759 3837 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3837 21 is be VBZ 42759 3837 22 not not RB 42759 3837 23 just just RB 42759 3837 24 that that IN 42759 3837 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3837 26 should should MD 42759 3837 27 be be VB 42759 3837 28 compelled compel VBN 42759 3837 29 to to TO 42759 3837 30 pay pay VB 42759 3837 31 for for IN 42759 3837 32 the the DT 42759 3837 33 supposed suppose VBN 42759 3837 34 use use NN 42759 3837 35 of of IN 42759 3837 36 a a DT 42759 3837 37 capital capital NN 42759 3837 38 that that WDT 42759 3837 39 has have VBZ 42759 3837 40 no no DT 42759 3837 41 concrete concrete JJ 42759 3837 42 reality reality NN 42759 3837 43 . . . 42759 3838 1 The the DT 42759 3838 2 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3838 3 of of IN 42759 3838 4 the the DT 42759 3838 5 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 3838 6 corporation corporation NN 42759 3838 7 which which WDT 42759 3838 8 imposes impose VBZ 42759 3838 9 upon upon IN 42759 3838 10 the the DT 42759 3838 11 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3838 12 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 42759 3838 13 prices price NNS 42759 3838 14 or or CC 42759 3838 15 charges charge NNS 42759 3838 16 through through IN 42759 3838 17 the the DT 42759 3838 18 instrumentality instrumentality NN 42759 3838 19 of of IN 42759 3838 20 inflated inflated JJ 42759 3838 21 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3838 22 , , , 42759 3838 23 can can MD 42759 3838 24 become become VB 42759 3838 25 guilty guilty JJ 42759 3838 26 of of IN 42759 3838 27 this this DT 42759 3838 28 injustice injustice NN 42759 3838 29 in in IN 42759 3838 30 two two CD 42759 3838 31 ways way NNS 42759 3838 32 : : : 42759 3838 33 by by IN 42759 3838 34 promoting promote VBG 42759 3838 35 the the DT 42759 3838 36 improper improper JJ 42759 3838 37 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3838 38 ; ; : 42759 3838 39 and and CC 42759 3838 40 by by IN 42759 3838 41 getting get VBG 42759 3838 42 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3838 43 on on IN 42759 3838 44 stock stock NN 42759 3838 45 for for IN 42759 3838 46 which which WDT 42759 3838 47 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3838 48 have have VBP 42759 3838 49 not not RB 42759 3838 50 given give VBN 42759 3838 51 a a DT 42759 3838 52 fair fair JJ 42759 3838 53 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 3838 54 . . . 42759 3839 1 As as IN 42759 3839 2 a a DT 42759 3839 3 rule rule NN 42759 3839 4 , , , 42759 3839 5 the the DT 42759 3839 6 greater great JJR 42759 3839 7 part part NN 42759 3839 8 of of IN 42759 3839 9 such such JJ 42759 3839 10 guilt guilt NN 42759 3839 11 and and CC 42759 3839 12 responsibility responsibility NN 42759 3839 13 rests rest NNS 42759 3839 14 upon upon IN 42759 3839 15 certain certain JJ 42759 3839 16 special special JJ 42759 3839 17 and and CC 42759 3839 18 powerful powerful JJ 42759 3839 19 groups group NNS 42759 3839 20 among among IN 42759 3839 21 the the DT 42759 3839 22 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3839 23 . . . 42759 3840 1 For for IN 42759 3840 2 example example NN 42759 3840 3 ; ; : 42759 3840 4 the the DT 42759 3840 5 J.P. J.P. NNP 42759 3840 6 Morgan Morgan NNP 42759 3840 7 syndicate syndicate NN 42759 3840 8 which which WDT 42759 3840 9 organised organise VBD 42759 3840 10 the the DT 42759 3840 11 United United NNP 42759 3840 12 States States NNP 42759 3840 13 Steel Steel NNP 42759 3840 14 Corporation Corporation NNP 42759 3840 15 received receive VBD 42759 3840 16 for for IN 42759 3840 17 that that DT 42759 3840 18 service service NN 42759 3840 19 securities security NNS 42759 3840 20 to to IN 42759 3840 21 the the DT 42759 3840 22 value value NN 42759 3840 23 of of IN 42759 3840 24 $ $ $ 42759 3840 25 63,500,000 63,500,000 CD 42759 3840 26 . . . 42759 3841 1 " " `` 42759 3841 2 There there EX 42759 3841 3 can can MD 42759 3841 4 be be VB 42759 3841 5 no no DT 42759 3841 6 question question NN 42759 3841 7 , , , 42759 3841 8 " " '' 42759 3841 9 says say VBZ 42759 3841 10 the the DT 42759 3841 11 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 3841 12 of of IN 42759 3841 13 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 3841 14 , , , 42759 3841 15 " " '' 42759 3841 16 that that IN 42759 3841 17 this this DT 42759 3841 18 huge huge JJ 42759 3841 19 compensation compensation NN 42759 3841 20 to to IN 42759 3841 21 the the DT 42759 3841 22 syndicate syndicate NN 42759 3841 23 was be VBD 42759 3841 24 greatly greatly RB 42759 3841 25 in in IN 42759 3841 26 excess excess NN 42759 3841 27 of of IN 42759 3841 28 a a DT 42759 3841 29 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3841 30 payment payment NN 42759 3841 31 . . . 42759 3842 1 " " `` 42759 3842 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3842 3 191 191 CD 42759 3842 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3842 5 The the DT 42759 3842 6 syndicate syndicate NN 42759 3842 7 was be VBD 42759 3842 8 able able JJ 42759 3842 9 to to TO 42759 3842 10 exact exact VB 42759 3842 11 this this DT 42759 3842 12 stupendous stupendous JJ 42759 3842 13 sum sum NN 42759 3842 14 mainly mainly RB 42759 3842 15 because because IN 42759 3842 16 some some DT 42759 3842 17 of of IN 42759 3842 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3842 19 members member NNS 42759 3842 20 were be VBD 42759 3842 21 also also RB 42759 3842 22 in in IN 42759 3842 23 control control NN 42759 3842 24 of of IN 42759 3842 25 some some DT 42759 3842 26 of of IN 42759 3842 27 the the DT 42759 3842 28 companies company NNS 42759 3842 29 that that WDT 42759 3842 30 were be VBD 42759 3842 31 brought bring VBN 42759 3842 32 into into IN 42759 3842 33 the the DT 42759 3842 34 combination combination NN 42759 3842 35 . . . 42759 3843 1 " " `` 42759 3843 2 In in IN 42759 3843 3 other other JJ 42759 3843 4 words word NNS 42759 3843 5 , , , 42759 3843 6 as as IN 42759 3843 7 managers manager NNS 42759 3843 8 of of IN 42759 3843 9 the the DT 42759 3843 10 Steel Steel NNP 42759 3843 11 Corporation Corporation NNP 42759 3843 12 these these DT 42759 3843 13 various various JJ 42759 3843 14 interests interest NNS 42759 3843 15 virtually virtually RB 42759 3843 16 determined determine VBD 42759 3843 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3843 18 compensation compensation NN 42759 3843 19 as as IN 42759 3843 20 underwriters underwriter NNS 42759 3843 21 . . . 42759 3844 1 " " `` 42759 3844 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3844 3 192 192 CD 42759 3844 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3844 5 In in IN 42759 3844 6 the the DT 42759 3844 7 opinion opinion NN 42759 3844 8 of of IN 42759 3844 9 the the DT 42759 3844 10 minority minority NN 42759 3844 11 members member NNS 42759 3844 12 of of IN 42759 3844 13 the the DT 42759 3844 14 Stanley Stanley NNP 42759 3844 15 congressional congressional JJ 42759 3844 16 investigating investigate VBG 42759 3844 17 committee committee NN 42759 3844 18 , , , 42759 3844 19 " " '' 42759 3844 20 such such PDT 42759 3844 21 a a DT 42759 3844 22 sum sum NN 42759 3844 23 bore bear VBD 42759 3844 24 no no DT 42759 3844 25 relation relation NN 42759 3844 26 whatever whatever WDT 42759 3844 27 to to IN 42759 3844 28 the the DT 42759 3844 29 service service NN 42759 3844 30 rendered render VBN 42759 3844 31 , , , 42759 3844 32 the the DT 42759 3844 33 risk risk NN 42759 3844 34 run run VBD 42759 3844 35 , , , 42759 3844 36 and and CC 42759 3844 37 the the DT 42759 3844 38 capital capital NN 42759 3844 39 advanced advance VBD 42759 3844 40 . . . 42759 3845 1 " " `` 42759 3845 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3845 3 193 193 CD 42759 3845 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3845 5 The the DT 42759 3845 6 majority majority NN 42759 3845 7 of of IN 42759 3845 8 the the DT 42759 3845 9 committee committee NN 42759 3845 10 characterised characterise VBD 42759 3845 11 the the DT 42759 3845 12 transaction transaction NN 42759 3845 13 in in IN 42759 3845 14 even even RB 42759 3845 15 stronger strong JJR 42759 3845 16 language language NN 42759 3845 17 . . . 42759 3846 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3846 2 is be VBZ 42759 3846 3 clear clear JJ 42759 3846 4 , , , 42759 3846 5 therefore therefore RB 42759 3846 6 , , , 42759 3846 7 that that IN 42759 3846 8 the the DT 42759 3846 9 syndicate syndicate NN 42759 3846 10 committed commit VBD 42759 3846 11 injustice injustice NN 42759 3846 12 toward toward IN 42759 3846 13 the the DT 42759 3846 14 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3846 15 both both CC 42759 3846 16 by by IN 42759 3846 17 organising organise VBG 42759 3846 18 a a DT 42759 3846 19 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3846 20 which which WDT 42759 3846 21 afterward afterward RB 42759 3846 22 imposed impose VBD 42759 3846 23 unjust unjust JJ 42759 3846 24 prices price NNS 42759 3846 25 , , , 42759 3846 26 and and CC 42759 3846 27 by by IN 42759 3846 28 taking take VBG 42759 3846 29 millions million NNS 42759 3846 30 of of IN 42759 3846 31 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3846 32 in in IN 42759 3846 33 securities security NNS 42759 3846 34 which which WDT 42759 3846 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3846 36 members member NNS 42759 3846 37 did do VBD 42759 3846 38 not not RB 42759 3846 39 earn earn VB 42759 3846 40 , , , 42759 3846 41 and and CC 42759 3846 42 on on IN 42759 3846 43 which which WDT 42759 3846 44 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3846 45 received receive VBD 42759 3846 46 interest interest NN 42759 3846 47 through through IN 42759 3846 48 the the DT 42759 3846 49 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 42759 3846 50 prices price NNS 42759 3846 51 . . . 42759 3847 1 While while IN 42759 3847 2 this this DT 42759 3847 3 transaction transaction NN 42759 3847 4 is be VBZ 42759 3847 5 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3847 6 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 42759 3847 7 , , , 42759 3847 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3847 9 is be VBZ 42759 3847 10 substantially substantially RB 42759 3847 11 typical typical JJ 42759 3847 12 of of IN 42759 3847 13 the the DT 42759 3847 14 methods method NNS 42759 3847 15 by by IN 42759 3847 16 which which WDT 42759 3847 17 many many JJ 42759 3847 18 powerful powerful JJ 42759 3847 19 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3847 20 have have VBP 42759 3847 21 watered water VBN 42759 3847 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3847 23 stock stock NN 42759 3847 24 to to IN 42759 3847 25 the the DT 42759 3847 26 detriment detriment NN 42759 3847 27 of of IN 42759 3847 28 the the DT 42759 3847 29 public public NN 42759 3847 30 , , , 42759 3847 31 and and CC 42759 3847 32 the the DT 42759 3847 33 advantage advantage NN 42759 3847 34 of of IN 42759 3847 35 a a DT 42759 3847 36 small small JJ 42759 3847 37 group group NN 42759 3847 38 of of IN 42759 3847 39 directors director NNS 42759 3847 40 and and CC 42759 3847 41 financiers financier NNS 42759 3847 42 . . . 42759 3848 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3848 2 The the DT 42759 3848 3 " " `` 42759 3848 4 Innocent Innocent NNP 42759 3848 5 " " '' 42759 3848 6 Investor Investor NNP 42759 3848 7 _ _ NNP 42759 3848 8 Is be VBZ 42759 3848 9 the the DT 42759 3848 10 State State NNP 42759 3848 11 obliged oblige VBN 42759 3848 12 to to TO 42759 3848 13 protect protect VB 42759 3848 14 , , , 42759 3848 15 or or CC 42759 3848 16 is be VBZ 42759 3848 17 even even RB 42759 3848 18 justified justify VBN 42759 3848 19 in in IN 42759 3848 20 protecting protecting NN 42759 3848 21 , , , 42759 3848 22 the the DT 42759 3848 23 innocent innocent JJ 42759 3848 24 victims victim NNS 42759 3848 25 of of IN 42759 3848 26 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 3848 27 ? ? . 42759 3849 1 That that DT 42759 3849 2 is be VBZ 42759 3849 3 to to TO 42759 3849 4 say say VB 42759 3849 5 , , , 42759 3849 6 should should MD 42759 3849 7 rate rate VB 42759 3849 8 - - HYPH 42759 3849 9 making make VBG 42759 3849 10 authorities authority NNS 42759 3849 11 fix fix VBP 42759 3849 12 the the DT 42759 3849 13 charges charge NNS 42759 3849 14 of of IN 42759 3849 15 public public JJ 42759 3849 16 service service NN 42759 3849 17 corporations corporation NNS 42759 3849 18 high high JJ 42759 3849 19 enough enough RB 42759 3849 20 to to TO 42759 3849 21 return return VB 42759 3849 22 some some DT 42759 3849 23 interest interest NN 42759 3849 24 to to IN 42759 3849 25 the the DT 42759 3849 26 purchasers purchaser NNS 42759 3849 27 of of IN 42759 3849 28 fictitious fictitious JJ 42759 3849 29 securities security NNS 42759 3849 30 ? ? . 42759 3850 1 All all PDT 42759 3850 2 the the DT 42759 3850 3 facts fact NNS 42759 3850 4 and and CC 42759 3850 5 presumptions presumption NNS 42759 3850 6 of of IN 42759 3850 7 the the DT 42759 3850 8 case case NN 42759 3850 9 seem seem VBP 42759 3850 10 to to TO 42759 3850 11 demand demand VB 42759 3850 12 an an DT 42759 3850 13 answer answer NN 42759 3850 14 in in IN 42759 3850 15 the the DT 42759 3850 16 negative negative NN 42759 3850 17 . . . 42759 3851 1 In in IN 42759 3851 2 the the DT 42759 3851 3 first first JJ 42759 3851 4 place place NN 42759 3851 5 , , , 42759 3851 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3851 7 is be VBZ 42759 3851 8 impossible impossible JJ 42759 3851 9 to to TO 42759 3851 10 distinguish distinguish VB 42759 3851 11 the the DT 42759 3851 12 " " `` 42759 3851 13 innocent innocent JJ 42759 3851 14 " " '' 42759 3851 15 holders holder NNS 42759 3851 16 from from IN 42759 3851 17 those those DT 42759 3851 18 who who WP 42759 3851 19 were be VBD 42759 3851 20 fully fully RB 42759 3851 21 acquainted acquaint VBN 42759 3851 22 with with IN 42759 3851 23 the the DT 42759 3851 24 questionable questionable JJ 42759 3851 25 and and CC 42759 3851 26 speculative speculative JJ 42759 3851 27 nature nature NN 42759 3851 28 of of IN 42759 3851 29 the the DT 42759 3851 30 stock stock NN 42759 3851 31 at at IN 42759 3851 32 the the DT 42759 3851 33 time time NN 42759 3851 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3851 35 came come VBD 42759 3851 36 into into IN 42759 3851 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3851 38 possession possession NN 42759 3851 39 . . . 42759 3852 1 In in IN 42759 3852 2 the the DT 42759 3852 3 second second JJ 42759 3852 4 place place NN 42759 3852 5 , , , 42759 3852 6 the the DT 42759 3852 7 civil civil JJ 42759 3852 8 law law NN 42759 3852 9 has have VBZ 42759 3852 10 never never RB 42759 3852 11 formally formally RB 42759 3852 12 recognised recognise VBN 42759 3852 13 any any DT 42759 3852 14 such such JJ 42759 3852 15 claim claim NN 42759 3852 16 on on IN 42759 3852 17 the the DT 42759 3852 18 part part NN 42759 3852 19 of of IN 42759 3852 20 even even RB 42759 3852 21 innocent innocent JJ 42759 3852 22 investors investor NNS 42759 3852 23 , , , 42759 3852 24 nor nor CC 42759 3852 25 any any DT 42759 3852 26 such such JJ 42759 3852 27 obligation obligation NN 42759 3852 28 on on IN 42759 3852 29 the the DT 42759 3852 30 part part NN 42759 3852 31 of of IN 42759 3852 32 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 3852 33 . . . 42759 3853 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3853 2 has have VBZ 42759 3853 3 never never RB 42759 3853 4 laid lay VBN 42759 3853 5 down down RP 42759 3853 6 the the DT 42759 3853 7 principle principle NN 42759 3853 8 that that IN 42759 3853 9 any any DT 42759 3853 10 class class NN 42759 3853 11 of of IN 42759 3853 12 investors investor NNS 42759 3853 13 in in IN 42759 3853 14 fictitious fictitious JJ 42759 3853 15 stock stock NN 42759 3853 16 has have VBZ 42759 3853 17 a a DT 42759 3853 18 legal legal JJ 42759 3853 19 or or CC 42759 3853 20 moral moral JJ 42759 3853 21 right right NN 42759 3853 22 to to TO 42759 3853 23 obtain obtain VB 42759 3853 24 the the DT 42759 3853 25 normal normal JJ 42759 3853 26 rate rate NN 42759 3853 27 of of IN 42759 3853 28 interest interest NN 42759 3853 29 on on IN 42759 3853 30 such such JJ 42759 3853 31 stock stock NN 42759 3853 32 through through IN 42759 3853 33 the the DT 42759 3853 34 imposition imposition NN 42759 3853 35 of of IN 42759 3853 36 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3853 37 high high JJ 42759 3853 38 charges charge NNS 42759 3853 39 upon upon IN 42759 3853 40 the the DT 42759 3853 41 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3853 42 . . . 42759 3854 1 Nor nor CC 42759 3854 2 have have VBP 42759 3854 3 the the DT 42759 3854 4 courts court NNS 42759 3854 5 , , , 42759 3854 6 except except IN 42759 3854 7 in in IN 42759 3854 8 isolated isolated JJ 42759 3854 9 instances instance NNS 42759 3854 10 , , , 42759 3854 11 sanctioned sanction VBD 42759 3854 12 any any DT 42759 3854 13 such such JJ 42759 3854 14 principle principle NN 42759 3854 15 . . . 42759 3855 1 On on IN 42759 3855 2 the the DT 42759 3855 3 contrary contrary NN 42759 3855 4 , , , 42759 3855 5 the the DT 42759 3855 6 Supreme Supreme NNP 42759 3855 7 Court Court NNP 42759 3855 8 of of IN 42759 3855 9 the the DT 42759 3855 10 United United NNP 42759 3855 11 States States NNP 42759 3855 12 , , , 42759 3855 13 in in IN 42759 3855 14 the the DT 42759 3855 15 case case NN 42759 3855 16 of of IN 42759 3855 17 Smyth Smyth NNP 42759 3855 18 vs. vs. IN 42759 3855 19 Ames Ames NNP 42759 3855 20 , , , 42759 3855 21 declared declare VBD 42759 3855 22 that that IN 42759 3855 23 a a DT 42759 3855 24 railroad railroad NN 42759 3855 25 " " `` 42759 3855 26 may may MD 42759 3855 27 not not RB 42759 3855 28 impose impose VB 42759 3855 29 upon upon IN 42759 3855 30 the the DT 42759 3855 31 public public NN 42759 3855 32 the the DT 42759 3855 33 burden burden NN 42759 3855 34 of of IN 42759 3855 35 such such JJ 42759 3855 36 increased increased JJ 42759 3855 37 rates rate NNS 42759 3855 38 as as IN 42759 3855 39 may may MD 42759 3855 40 be be VB 42759 3855 41 required require VBN 42759 3855 42 for for IN 42759 3855 43 the the DT 42759 3855 44 purpose purpose NN 42759 3855 45 of of IN 42759 3855 46 realising realise VBG 42759 3855 47 profits profit NNS 42759 3855 48 upon upon IN 42759 3855 49 such such JJ 42759 3855 50 excessive excessive JJ 42759 3855 51 valuation valuation NN 42759 3855 52 or or CC 42759 3855 53 fictitious fictitious JJ 42759 3855 54 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3855 55 . . . 42759 3855 56 " " '' 42759 3856 1 In in IN 42759 3856 2 the the DT 42759 3856 3 third third JJ 42759 3856 4 place place NN 42759 3856 5 , , , 42759 3856 6 when when WRB 42759 3856 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3856 8 consider consider VBP 42759 3856 9 the the DT 42759 3856 10 matter matter NN 42759 3856 11 from from IN 42759 3856 12 the the DT 42759 3856 13 side side NN 42759 3856 14 of of IN 42759 3856 15 morals moral NNS 42759 3856 16 , , , 42759 3856 17 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3856 18 see see VBP 42759 3856 19 that that IN 42759 3856 20 the the DT 42759 3856 21 innocent innocent JJ 42759 3856 22 investors investor NNS 42759 3856 23 are be VBP 42759 3856 24 not not RB 42759 3856 25 the the DT 42759 3856 26 only only JJ 42759 3856 27 persons person NNS 42759 3856 28 whose whose WP$ 42759 3856 29 rights right NNS 42759 3856 30 are be VBP 42759 3856 31 involved involve VBN 42759 3856 32 . . . 42759 3857 1 If if IN 42759 3857 2 charges charge NNS 42759 3857 3 are be VBP 42759 3857 4 placed place VBN 42759 3857 5 high high RB 42759 3857 6 enough enough RB 42759 3857 7 to to TO 42759 3857 8 cover cover VB 42759 3857 9 interest interest NN 42759 3857 10 on on IN 42759 3857 11 fictitious fictitious JJ 42759 3857 12 capital capital NN 42759 3857 13 , , , 42759 3857 14 the the DT 42759 3857 15 cost cost NN 42759 3857 16 and and CC 42759 3857 17 the the DT 42759 3857 18 injury injury NN 42759 3857 19 fall fall NN 42759 3857 20 upon upon IN 42759 3857 21 the the DT 42759 3857 22 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3857 23 . . . 42759 3858 1 The the DT 42759 3858 2 latter latter JJ 42759 3858 3 have have VBP 42759 3858 4 a a DT 42759 3858 5 right right NN 42759 3858 6 to to IN 42759 3858 7 the the DT 42759 3858 8 services service NNS 42759 3858 9 of of IN 42759 3858 10 utility utility NN 42759 3858 11 corporations corporation NNS 42759 3858 12 , , , 42759 3858 13 such such JJ 42759 3858 14 as as IN 42759 3858 15 railways railway NNS 42759 3858 16 and and CC 42759 3858 17 gas gas NN 42759 3858 18 companies company NNS 42759 3858 19 , , , 42759 3858 20 at at IN 42759 3858 21 a a DT 42759 3858 22 fair fair JJ 42759 3858 23 price price NN 42759 3858 24 ; ; : 42759 3858 25 that that RB 42759 3858 26 is is RB 42759 3858 27 , , , 42759 3858 28 a a DT 42759 3858 29 price price NN 42759 3858 30 which which WDT 42759 3858 31 will will MD 42759 3858 32 return return VB 42759 3858 33 to to IN 42759 3858 34 the the DT 42759 3858 35 capital capital NN 42759 3858 36 put put VBN 42759 3858 37 into into IN 42759 3858 38 the the DT 42759 3858 39 concern concern NN 42759 3858 40 the the DT 42759 3858 41 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 3858 42 rate rate NN 42759 3858 43 of of IN 42759 3858 44 interest interest NN 42759 3858 45 , , , 42759 3858 46 plus plus CC 42759 3858 47 whatever whatever WDT 42759 3858 48 gains gain NNS 42759 3858 49 are be VBP 42759 3858 50 obtained obtain VBN 42759 3858 51 by by IN 42759 3858 52 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 3858 53 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 3858 54 . . . 42759 3859 1 To to TO 42759 3859 2 require require VB 42759 3859 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3859 4 to to TO 42759 3859 5 pay pay VB 42759 3859 6 more more JJR 42759 3859 7 than than IN 42759 3859 8 this this DT 42759 3859 9 , , , 42759 3859 10 is be VBZ 42759 3859 11 to to TO 42759 3859 12 compel compel VB 42759 3859 13 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3859 14 to to TO 42759 3859 15 give give VB 42759 3859 16 something something NN 42759 3859 17 for for IN 42759 3859 18 nothing nothing NN 42759 3859 19 ; ; : 42759 3859 20 namely namely RB 42759 3859 21 , , , 42759 3859 22 to to TO 42759 3859 23 provide provide VB 42759 3859 24 interest interest NN 42759 3859 25 on on IN 42759 3859 26 capital capital NN 42759 3859 27 which which WDT 42759 3859 28 does do VBZ 42759 3859 29 not not RB 42759 3859 30 exist exist VB 42759 3859 31 , , , 42759 3859 32 and and CC 42759 3859 33 from from IN 42759 3859 34 which which WDT 42759 3859 35 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3859 36 receive receive VBP 42759 3859 37 no no DT 42759 3859 38 benefit benefit NN 42759 3859 39 . . . 42759 3860 1 When when WRB 42759 3860 2 , , , 42759 3860 3 therefore therefore RB 42759 3860 4 , , , 42759 3860 5 the the DT 42759 3860 6 State State NNP 42759 3860 7 intervenes intervene VBZ 42759 3860 8 to to TO 42759 3860 9 secure secure VB 42759 3860 10 fair fair JJ 42759 3860 11 charges charge NNS 42759 3860 12 for for IN 42759 3860 13 the the DT 42759 3860 14 consumers consumer NNS 42759 3860 15 , , , 42759 3860 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3860 17 should should MD 42759 3860 18 base base VB 42759 3860 19 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3860 20 upon upon IN 42759 3860 21 the the DT 42759 3860 22 capital capital NN 42759 3860 23 actually actually RB 42759 3860 24 invested invest VBN 42759 3860 25 and and CC 42759 3860 26 used use VBN 42759 3860 27 in in IN 42759 3860 28 the the DT 42759 3860 29 business business NN 42759 3860 30 of of IN 42759 3860 31 public public JJ 42759 3860 32 service service NN 42759 3860 33 . . . 42759 3861 1 Frequently frequently RB 42759 3861 2 , , , 42759 3861 3 however however RB 42759 3861 4 , , , 42759 3861 5 the the DT 42759 3861 6 State State NNP 42759 3861 7 has have VBZ 42759 3861 8 permitted permit VBN 42759 3861 9 overcapitalisation overcapitalisation NN 42759 3861 10 , , , 42759 3861 11 and and CC 42759 3861 12 charges charge VBZ 42759 3861 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3861 14 to to TO 42759 3861 15 pay pay VB 42759 3861 16 normal normal JJ 42759 3861 17 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3861 18 thereon thereon NN 42759 3861 19 , , , 42759 3861 20 for for IN 42759 3861 21 long long JJ 42759 3861 22 periods period NNS 42759 3861 23 of of IN 42759 3861 24 years year NNS 42759 3861 25 . . . 42759 3862 1 Has have VBZ 42759 3862 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3862 3 not not RB 42759 3862 4 thereby thereby RB 42759 3862 5 encouraged encourage VBN 42759 3862 6 investors investor NNS 42759 3862 7 to to TO 42759 3862 8 cherish cherish VB 42759 3862 9 the the DT 42759 3862 10 expectation expectation NN 42759 3862 11 that that IN 42759 3862 12 these these DT 42759 3862 13 high high JJ 42759 3862 14 charges charge NNS 42759 3862 15 would would MD 42759 3862 16 be be VB 42759 3862 17 permitted permit VBN 42759 3862 18 to to TO 42759 3862 19 continue continue VB 42759 3862 20 , , , 42759 3862 21 and and CC 42759 3862 22 that that IN 42759 3862 23 the the DT 42759 3862 24 fictitious fictitious JJ 42759 3862 25 stock stock NN 42759 3862 26 would would MD 42759 3862 27 remain remain VB 42759 3862 28 indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 3862 29 as as RB 42759 3862 30 valuable valuable JJ 42759 3862 31 as as IN 42759 3862 32 when when WRB 42759 3862 33 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3862 34 came come VBD 42759 3862 35 into into IN 42759 3862 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3862 37 possession possession NN 42759 3862 38 ? ? . 42759 3863 1 Is be VBZ 42759 3863 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3863 3 not not RB 42759 3863 4 breaking break VBG 42759 3863 5 faith faith NN 42759 3863 6 with with IN 42759 3863 7 these these DT 42759 3863 8 investors investor NNS 42759 3863 9 when when WRB 42759 3863 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3863 11 reduces reduce VBZ 42759 3863 12 charges charge NNS 42759 3863 13 to to IN 42759 3863 14 the the DT 42759 3863 15 basis basis NN 42759 3863 16 of of IN 42759 3863 17 the the DT 42759 3863 18 actual actual JJ 42759 3863 19 investment investment NN 42759 3863 20 ? ? . 42759 3864 1 A a DT 42759 3864 2 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3864 3 answer answer NN 42759 3864 4 to to IN 42759 3864 5 these these DT 42759 3864 6 questions question NNS 42759 3864 7 is be VBZ 42759 3864 8 found find VBN 42759 3864 9 in in IN 42759 3864 10 the the DT 42759 3864 11 fact fact NN 42759 3864 12 that that IN 42759 3864 13 the the DT 42759 3864 14 State State NNP 42759 3864 15 has have VBZ 42759 3864 16 never never RB 42759 3864 17 officially officially RB 42759 3864 18 sanctioned sanction VBN 42759 3864 19 the the DT 42759 3864 20 practice practice NN 42759 3864 21 of of IN 42759 3864 22 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 3864 23 , , , 42759 3864 24 nor nor CC 42759 3864 25 in in IN 42759 3864 26 any any DT 42759 3864 27 way way NN 42759 3864 28 intimated intimate VBN 42759 3864 29 that that IN 42759 3864 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3864 31 would would MD 42759 3864 32 recognise recognise VB 42759 3864 33 the the DT 42759 3864 34 existence existence NN 42759 3864 35 of of IN 42759 3864 36 the the DT 42759 3864 37 fictitious fictitious JJ 42759 3864 38 stock stock NN 42759 3864 39 when when WRB 42759 3864 40 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3864 41 should should MD 42759 3864 42 take take VB 42759 3864 43 up up RP 42759 3864 44 the the DT 42759 3864 45 neglected neglected JJ 42759 3864 46 task task NN 42759 3864 47 of of IN 42759 3864 48 fixing fix VBG 42759 3864 49 fair fair JJ 42759 3864 50 rates rate NNS 42759 3864 51 and and CC 42759 3864 52 charges charge NNS 42759 3864 53 . . . 42759 3865 1 At at IN 42759 3865 2 the the DT 42759 3865 3 most most JJS 42759 3865 4 , , , 42759 3865 5 the the DT 42759 3865 6 civil civil JJ 42759 3865 7 law law NN 42759 3865 8 has have VBZ 42759 3865 9 merely merely RB 42759 3865 10 tolerated tolerate VBN 42759 3865 11 the the DT 42759 3865 12 practice practice NN 42759 3865 13 , , , 42759 3865 14 and and CC 42759 3865 15 the the DT 42759 3865 16 resulting result VBG 42759 3865 17 extortion extortion NN 42759 3865 18 upon upon IN 42759 3865 19 the the DT 42759 3865 20 public public NN 42759 3865 21 . . . 42759 3866 1 And and CC 42759 3866 2 there there EX 42759 3866 3 has have VBZ 42759 3866 4 never never RB 42759 3866 5 been be VBN 42759 3866 6 a a DT 42759 3866 7 time time NN 42759 3866 8 when when WRB 42759 3866 9 the the DT 42759 3866 10 greater great JJR 42759 3866 11 and and CC 42759 3866 12 saner saner JJ 42759 3866 13 part part NN 42759 3866 14 of of IN 42759 3866 15 public public JJ 42759 3866 16 opinion opinion NN 42759 3866 17 did do VBD 42759 3866 18 not not RB 42759 3866 19 look look VB 42759 3866 20 upon upon IN 42759 3866 21 overcapitalisation overcapitalisation NN 42759 3866 22 as as IN 42759 3866 23 at at IN 42759 3866 24 the the DT 42759 3866 25 least least JJS 42759 3866 26 abnormal abnormal JJ 42759 3866 27 and and CC 42759 3866 28 irregular irregular JJ 42759 3866 29 . . . 42759 3867 1 Neither neither CC 42759 3867 2 from from IN 42759 3867 3 the the DT 42759 3867 4 civil civil JJ 42759 3867 5 law law NN 42759 3867 6 nor nor CC 42759 3867 7 from from IN 42759 3867 8 public public JJ 42759 3867 9 sentiment sentiment NN 42759 3867 10 have have VBP 42759 3867 11 the the DT 42759 3867 12 devices device NNS 42759 3867 13 of of IN 42759 3867 14 inflating inflate VBG 42759 3867 15 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3867 16 received receive VBD 42759 3867 17 that that DT 42759 3867 18 measure measure NN 42759 3867 19 of of IN 42759 3867 20 approval approval NN 42759 3867 21 which which WDT 42759 3867 22 would would MD 42759 3867 23 confer confer VB 42759 3867 24 upon upon IN 42759 3867 25 investments investment NNS 42759 3867 26 therein therein RB 42759 3867 27 the the DT 42759 3867 28 legal legal JJ 42759 3867 29 or or CC 42759 3867 30 the the DT 42759 3867 31 moral moral JJ 42759 3867 32 status status NN 42759 3867 33 of of IN 42759 3867 34 vested vest VBN 42759 3867 35 rights right NNS 42759 3867 36 . . . 42759 3868 1 To to IN 42759 3868 2 the the DT 42759 3868 3 " " `` 42759 3868 4 innocent innocent JJ 42759 3868 5 investor investor NN 42759 3868 6 " " '' 42759 3868 7 in in IN 42759 3868 8 watered water VBN 42759 3868 9 stocks stock NNS 42759 3868 10 the the DT 42759 3868 11 maxim maxim NN 42759 3868 12 , , , 42759 3868 13 _ _ NNP 42759 3868 14 caveat caveat NN 42759 3868 15 emptor emptor NN 42759 3868 16 _ _ NNP 42759 3868 17 , , , 42759 3868 18 is be VBZ 42759 3868 19 as as RB 42759 3868 20 fairly fairly RB 42759 3868 21 applicable applicable JJ 42759 3868 22 as as IN 42759 3868 23 to to IN 42759 3868 24 the the DT 42759 3868 25 man man NN 42759 3868 26 who who WP 42759 3868 27 has have VBZ 42759 3868 28 been be VBN 42759 3868 29 deceived deceive VBN 42759 3868 30 into into IN 42759 3868 31 lending lend VBG 42759 3868 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3868 33 money money NN 42759 3868 34 on on IN 42759 3868 35 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 3868 36 security security NN 42759 3868 37 , , , 42759 3868 38 or or CC 42759 3868 39 the the DT 42759 3868 40 man man NN 42759 3868 41 who who WP 42759 3868 42 has have VBZ 42759 3868 43 been be VBN 42759 3868 44 induced induce VBN 42759 3868 45 by by IN 42759 3868 46 the the DT 42759 3868 47 asseverations asseveration NNS 42759 3868 48 of of IN 42759 3868 49 a a DT 42759 3868 50 highly highly RB 42759 3868 51 imaginative imaginative JJ 42759 3868 52 prospectus prospectus NN 42759 3868 53 to to TO 42759 3868 54 put put VB 42759 3868 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3868 56 money money NN 42759 3868 57 into into IN 42759 3868 58 a a DT 42759 3868 59 salted salted JJ 42759 3868 60 gold gold NN 42759 3868 61 mine mine NN 42759 3868 62 , , , 42759 3868 63 or or CC 42759 3868 64 the the DT 42759 3868 65 man man NN 42759 3868 66 who who WP 42759 3868 67 buys buy VBZ 42759 3868 68 stolen steal VBN 42759 3868 69 goods good NNS 42759 3868 70 from from IN 42759 3868 71 a a DT 42759 3868 72 pawn pawn NN 42759 3868 73 shop shop NN 42759 3868 74 , , , 42759 3868 75 or or CC 42759 3868 76 the the DT 42759 3868 77 man man NN 42759 3868 78 who who WP 42759 3868 79 because because IN 42759 3868 80 of of IN 42759 3868 81 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 3868 82 police police NN 42759 3868 83 protection protection NN 42759 3868 84 loses lose VBZ 42759 3868 85 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3868 86 purse purse NN 42759 3868 87 to to IN 42759 3868 88 a a DT 42759 3868 89 highwayman highwayman NN 42759 3868 90 . . . 42759 3869 1 In in IN 42759 3869 2 all all PDT 42759 3869 3 these these DT 42759 3869 4 cases case NNS 42759 3869 5 perfect perfect VBP 42759 3869 6 legal legal JJ 42759 3869 7 safeguards safeguard NNS 42759 3869 8 would would MD 42759 3869 9 have have VB 42759 3869 10 prevented prevent VBN 42759 3869 11 the the DT 42759 3869 12 loss loss NN 42759 3869 13 ; ; : 42759 3869 14 yet yet CC 42759 3869 15 in in IN 42759 3869 16 none none NN 42759 3869 17 of of IN 42759 3869 18 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3869 19 does do VBZ 42759 3869 20 the the DT 42759 3869 21 State state NN 42759 3869 22 undertake undertake VB 42759 3869 23 to to TO 42759 3869 24 make make VB 42759 3869 25 the the DT 42759 3869 26 loss loss NN 42759 3869 27 good good JJ 42759 3869 28 to to IN 42759 3869 29 the the DT 42759 3869 30 innocent innocent JJ 42759 3869 31 victim victim NN 42759 3869 32 . . . 42759 3870 1 Such such JJ 42759 3870 2 seems seem VBZ 42759 3870 3 to to TO 42759 3870 4 be be VB 42759 3870 5 the the DT 42759 3870 6 strict strict JJ 42759 3870 7 justice justice NN 42759 3870 8 of of IN 42759 3870 9 the the DT 42759 3870 10 situation situation NN 42759 3870 11 as as IN 42759 3870 12 between between IN 42759 3870 13 the the DT 42759 3870 14 consumer consumer NN 42759 3870 15 and and CC 42759 3870 16 the the DT 42759 3870 17 innocent innocent JJ 42759 3870 18 investor investor NN 42759 3870 19 . . . 42759 3871 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3871 2 may may MD 42759 3871 3 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3871 4 happen happen VB 42759 3871 5 that that IN 42759 3871 6 a a DT 42759 3871 7 particularly particularly RB 42759 3871 8 grave grave JJ 42759 3871 9 hardship hardship NN 42759 3871 10 can can MD 42759 3871 11 be be VB 42759 3871 12 averted avert VBN 42759 3871 13 from from IN 42759 3871 14 the the DT 42759 3871 15 latter latter JJ 42759 3871 16 at at IN 42759 3871 17 a a DT 42759 3871 18 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 3871 19 slight slight JJ 42759 3871 20 cost cost NN 42759 3871 21 to to IN 42759 3871 22 the the DT 42759 3871 23 former former JJ 42759 3871 24 . . . 42759 3872 1 In in IN 42759 3872 2 such such PDT 42759 3872 3 a a DT 42759 3872 4 case case NN 42759 3872 5 equity equity NN 42759 3872 6 would would MD 42759 3872 7 seem seem VB 42759 3872 8 to to TO 42759 3872 9 require require VB 42759 3872 10 that that IN 42759 3872 11 some some DT 42759 3872 12 concession concession NN 42759 3872 13 be be VB 42759 3872 14 made make VBN 42759 3872 15 to to IN 42759 3872 16 the the DT 42759 3872 17 investors investor NNS 42759 3872 18 through through IN 42759 3872 19 the the DT 42759 3872 20 imposition imposition NN 42759 3872 21 of of IN 42759 3872 22 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 3872 23 higher high JJR 42759 3872 24 charges charge NNS 42759 3872 25 upon upon IN 42759 3872 26 the the DT 42759 3872 27 consumer consumer NN 42759 3872 28 . . . 42759 3873 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3873 2 Magnitude Magnitude NNP 42759 3873 3 of of IN 42759 3873 4 Overcapitalisation Overcapitalisation NNP 42759 3873 5 _ _ NNP 42759 3873 6 Probably probably RB 42759 3873 7 the the DT 42759 3873 8 majority majority NN 42759 3873 9 of of IN 42759 3873 10 the the DT 42759 3873 11 great great JJ 42759 3873 12 steam steam NN 42759 3873 13 railroads railroad NNS 42759 3873 14 , , , 42759 3873 15 street street NN 42759 3873 16 railways railway NNS 42759 3873 17 , , , 42759 3873 18 and and CC 42759 3873 19 gas gas NN 42759 3873 20 companies company NNS 42759 3873 21 that that WDT 42759 3873 22 were be VBD 42759 3873 23 organised organise VBN 42759 3873 24 during during IN 42759 3873 25 the the DT 42759 3873 26 last last JJ 42759 3873 27 quarter quarter NN 42759 3873 28 of of IN 42759 3873 29 the the DT 42759 3873 30 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 42759 3873 31 century century NN 42759 3873 32 inflated inflate VBD 42759 3873 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3873 34 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3873 35 to to IN 42759 3873 36 a a DT 42759 3873 37 greater great JJR 42759 3873 38 or or CC 42759 3873 39 less less JJR 42759 3873 40 extent extent NN 42759 3873 41 . . . 42759 3874 1 Since since IN 42759 3874 2 the the DT 42759 3874 3 year year NN 42759 3874 4 1900 1900 CD 42759 3874 5 the the DT 42759 3874 6 trusts trust NNS 42759 3874 7 have have VBP 42759 3874 8 been be VBN 42759 3874 9 the the DT 42759 3874 10 chief chief JJ 42759 3874 11 exponents exponent NNS 42759 3874 12 and and CC 42759 3874 13 illustrations illustration NNS 42759 3874 14 of of IN 42759 3874 15 the the DT 42759 3874 16 practice practice NN 42759 3874 17 . . . 42759 3875 1 According accord VBG 42759 3875 2 to to IN 42759 3875 3 President President NNP 42759 3875 4 Van Van NNP 42759 3875 5 Hise Hise NNP 42759 3875 6 , , , 42759 3875 7 " " '' 42759 3875 8 the the DT 42759 3875 9 majority majority NN 42759 3875 10 of of IN 42759 3875 11 the the DT 42759 3875 12 great great JJ 42759 3875 13 concentrations concentration NNS 42759 3875 14 of of IN 42759 3875 15 industry industry NN 42759 3875 16 have have VBP 42759 3875 17 gone go VBN 42759 3875 18 through through IN 42759 3875 19 two two CD 42759 3875 20 or or CC 42759 3875 21 three three CD 42759 3875 22 stages stage NNS 42759 3875 23 of of IN 42759 3875 24 reorganisation reorganisation NN 42759 3875 25 , , , 42759 3875 26 the the DT 42759 3875 27 promoters promoter NNS 42759 3875 28 and and CC 42759 3875 29 financiers financier NNS 42759 3875 30 each each DT 42759 3875 31 time time NN 42759 3875 32 profiting profit VBG 42759 3875 33 greatly greatly RB 42759 3875 34 , , , 42759 3875 35 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3875 36 enormously enormously RB 42759 3875 37 . . . 42759 3876 1 " " `` 42759 3876 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3876 3 194 194 CD 42759 3876 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3876 5 For for IN 42759 3876 6 example example NN 42759 3876 7 ; ; : 42759 3876 8 in in IN 42759 3876 9 1908 1908 CD 42759 3876 10 the the DT 42759 3876 11 " " `` 42759 3876 12 water water NN 42759 3876 13 " " '' 42759 3876 14 in in IN 42759 3876 15 the the DT 42759 3876 16 American American NNP 42759 3876 17 Tobacco Tobacco NNP 42759 3876 18 Company Company NNP 42759 3876 19 was be VBD 42759 3876 20 estimated estimate VBN 42759 3876 21 by by IN 42759 3876 22 the the DT 42759 3876 23 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 3876 24 of of IN 42759 3876 25 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 3876 26 at at IN 42759 3876 27 $ $ $ 42759 3876 28 66,000,000 66,000,000 CD 42759 3876 29 ; ; : 42759 3876 30 the the DT 42759 3876 31 United United NNP 42759 3876 32 States States NNP 42759 3876 33 Shipbuilding Shipbuilding NNP 42759 3876 34 Company Company NNP 42759 3876 35 diluted dilute VBD 42759 3876 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3876 37 twelve twelve NN 42759 3876 38 and and CC 42759 3876 39 one one CD 42759 3876 40 - - HYPH 42759 3876 41 half half CD 42759 3876 42 million million CD 42759 3876 43 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3876 44 of of IN 42759 3876 45 capital capital NN 42759 3876 46 with with IN 42759 3876 47 more more JJR 42759 3876 48 than than IN 42759 3876 49 fifty fifty CD 42759 3876 50 - - HYPH 42759 3876 51 five five CD 42759 3876 52 millions million NNS 42759 3876 53 of of IN 42759 3876 54 " " `` 42759 3876 55 water water NN 42759 3876 56 " " '' 42759 3876 57 ; ; : 42759 3876 58 the the DT 42759 3876 59 United United NNP 42759 3876 60 States States NNP 42759 3876 61 Steel Steel NNP 42759 3876 62 Corporation Corporation NNP 42759 3876 63 contained contain VBD 42759 3876 64 at at IN 42759 3876 65 the the DT 42759 3876 66 time time NN 42759 3876 67 of of IN 42759 3876 68 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3876 69 organisation organisation NN 42759 3876 70 fictitious fictitious JJ 42759 3876 71 capital capital NN 42759 3876 72 to to IN 42759 3876 73 the the DT 42759 3876 74 amount amount NN 42759 3876 75 of of IN 42759 3876 76 $ $ $ 42759 3876 77 500,000,000 500,000,000 CD 42759 3876 78 ; ; : 42759 3876 79 and and CC 42759 3876 80 at at IN 42759 3876 81 least least JJS 42759 3876 82 fifty fifty CD 42759 3876 83 per per IN 42759 3876 84 cent cent NN 42759 3876 85 . . . 42759 3877 1 of of IN 42759 3877 2 the the DT 42759 3877 3 common common JJ 42759 3877 4 stock stock NN 42759 3877 5 of of IN 42759 3877 6 the the DT 42759 3877 7 American American NNP 42759 3877 8 Sugar Sugar NNP 42759 3877 9 Refining Refining NNP 42759 3877 10 Company Company NNP 42759 3877 11 represented represent VBD 42759 3877 12 no no DT 42759 3877 13 actual actual JJ 42759 3877 14 investment investment NN 42759 3877 15 . . . 42759 3878 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3878 2 195 195 CD 42759 3878 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3878 4 Owing owe VBG 42759 3878 5 to to IN 42759 3878 6 the the DT 42759 3878 7 penetrating penetrating NN 42759 3878 8 and and CC 42759 3878 9 widespread widespread JJ 42759 3878 10 criticism criticism NN 42759 3878 11 , , , 42759 3878 12 and and CC 42759 3878 13 the the DT 42759 3878 14 government government NN 42759 3878 15 investigations investigation NNS 42759 3878 16 and and CC 42759 3878 17 prosecutions prosecution NNS 42759 3878 18 of of IN 42759 3878 19 the the DT 42759 3878 20 last last JJ 42759 3878 21 few few JJ 42759 3878 22 years year NNS 42759 3878 23 , , , 42759 3878 24 the the DT 42759 3878 25 practice practice NN 42759 3878 26 of of IN 42759 3878 27 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 3878 28 has have VBZ 42759 3878 29 very very RB 42759 3878 30 greatly greatly RB 42759 3878 31 diminished diminish VBN 42759 3878 32 . . . 42759 3879 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 42759 3879 2 the the DT 42759 3879 3 most most RBS 42759 3879 4 flagrant flagrant JJ 42759 3879 5 recent recent JJ 42759 3879 6 example example NN 42759 3879 7 is be VBZ 42759 3879 8 that that DT 42759 3879 9 of of IN 42759 3879 10 the the DT 42759 3879 11 Pullman Pullman NNP 42759 3879 12 Company Company NNP 42759 3879 13 , , , 42759 3879 14 which which WDT 42759 3879 15 according accord VBG 42759 3879 16 to to IN 42759 3879 17 the the DT 42759 3879 18 testimony testimony NN 42759 3879 19 of of IN 42759 3879 20 R. R. NNP 42759 3879 21 T. T. NNP 42759 3879 22 Lincoln Lincoln NNP 42759 3879 23 before before IN 42759 3879 24 the the DT 42759 3879 25 Federal Federal NNP 42759 3879 26 Commission Commission NNP 42759 3879 27 on on IN 42759 3879 28 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 3879 29 Relations Relations NNPS 42759 3879 30 , , , 42759 3879 31 distributed distribute VBN 42759 3879 32 among among IN 42759 3879 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3879 34 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 3879 35 $ $ $ 42759 3879 36 100,000,000 100,000,000 CD 42759 3879 37 in in IN 42759 3879 38 stock stock NN 42759 3879 39 dividends dividend NNS 42759 3879 40 between between IN 42759 3879 41 1898 1898 CD 42759 3879 42 and and CC 42759 3879 43 1910 1910 CD 42759 3879 44 . . . 42759 3880 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 3880 2 the the DT 42759 3880 3 temptation temptation NN 42759 3880 4 to to TO 42759 3880 5 inflate inflate VB 42759 3880 6 capital capital NN 42759 3880 7 will will MD 42759 3880 8 exist exist VB 42759 3880 9 until until IN 42759 3880 10 the the DT 42759 3880 11 device device NN 42759 3880 12 is be VBZ 42759 3880 13 stringently stringently RB 42759 3880 14 prohibited prohibit VBN 42759 3880 15 by by IN 42759 3880 16 law law NN 42759 3880 17 . . . 42759 3881 1 Both both DT 42759 3881 2 the the DT 42759 3881 3 nation nation NN 42759 3881 4 and and CC 42759 3881 5 the the DT 42759 3881 6 states state NNS 42759 3881 7 ought ought MD 42759 3881 8 to to TO 42759 3881 9 adopt adopt VB 42759 3881 10 the the DT 42759 3881 11 policy policy NN 42759 3881 12 of of IN 42759 3881 13 forbidding forbid VBG 42759 3881 14 the the DT 42759 3881 15 sale sale NN 42759 3881 16 of of IN 42759 3881 17 stock stock NN 42759 3881 18 at at IN 42759 3881 19 less less JJR 42759 3881 20 than than IN 42759 3881 21 par par NN 42759 3881 22 value value NN 42759 3881 23 , , , 42759 3881 24 and and CC 42759 3881 25 restricting restrict VBG 42759 3881 26 issues issue NNS 42759 3881 27 of of IN 42759 3881 28 stock stock NN 42759 3881 29 to to IN 42759 3881 30 the the DT 42759 3881 31 amount amount NN 42759 3881 32 required require VBN 42759 3881 33 for for IN 42759 3881 34 the the DT 42759 3881 35 establishment establishment NN 42759 3881 36 , , , 42759 3881 37 equipment equipment NN 42759 3881 38 , , , 42759 3881 39 and and CC 42759 3881 40 permanent permanent JJ 42759 3881 41 betterment betterment NN 42759 3881 42 of of IN 42759 3881 43 a a DT 42759 3881 44 concern concern NN 42759 3881 45 , , , 42759 3881 46 including include VBG 42759 3881 47 a a DT 42759 3881 48 sum sum NN 42759 3881 49 to to TO 42759 3881 50 cover cover VB 42759 3881 51 the the DT 42759 3881 52 loss loss NN 42759 3881 53 of of IN 42759 3881 54 interest interest NN 42759 3881 55 to to IN 42759 3881 56 the the DT 42759 3881 57 investors investor NNS 42759 3881 58 during during IN 42759 3881 59 the the DT 42759 3881 60 early early JJ 42759 3881 61 period period NN 42759 3881 62 of of IN 42759 3881 63 the the DT 42759 3881 64 business business NN 42759 3881 65 . . . 42759 3882 1 Any any DT 42759 3882 2 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 42759 3882 3 risks risk NNS 42759 3882 4 to to TO 42759 3882 5 which which WDT 42759 3882 6 an an DT 42759 3882 7 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3882 8 is be VBZ 42759 3882 9 liable liable JJ 42759 3882 10 can can MD 42759 3882 11 be be VB 42759 3882 12 protected protect VBN 42759 3882 13 by by IN 42759 3882 14 the the DT 42759 3882 15 simple simple JJ 42759 3882 16 device device NN 42759 3882 17 of of IN 42759 3882 18 allowing allow VBG 42759 3882 19 a a DT 42759 3882 20 correspondingly correspondingly RB 42759 3882 21 high high JJ 42759 3882 22 rate rate NN 42759 3882 23 of of IN 42759 3882 24 interest interest NN 42759 3882 25 on on IN 42759 3882 26 the the DT 42759 3882 27 securities security NNS 42759 3882 28 . . . 42759 3883 1 With with IN 42759 3883 2 such such JJ 42759 3883 3 legislation legislation NN 42759 3883 4 enacted enact VBN 42759 3883 5 and and CC 42759 3883 6 enforced enforce VBN 42759 3883 7 , , , 42759 3883 8 neither neither CC 42759 3883 9 the the DT 42759 3883 10 investor investor NN 42759 3883 11 nor nor CC 42759 3883 12 the the DT 42759 3883 13 consumer consumer NN 42759 3883 14 could could MD 42759 3883 15 be be VB 42759 3883 16 deceived deceive VBN 42759 3883 17 or or CC 42759 3883 18 defrauded defraud VBN 42759 3883 19 ; ; : 42759 3883 20 and and CC 42759 3883 21 the the DT 42759 3883 22 financing financing NN 42759 3883 23 and and CC 42759 3883 24 management management NN 42759 3883 25 of of IN 42759 3883 26 corporations corporation NNS 42759 3883 27 would would MD 42759 3883 28 become become VB 42759 3883 29 less less RBR 42759 3883 30 speculative speculative JJ 42759 3883 31 , , , 42759 3883 32 and and CC 42759 3883 33 more more RBR 42759 3883 34 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 3883 35 to to IN 42759 3883 36 the the DT 42759 3883 37 community community NN 42759 3883 38 . . . 42759 3884 1 The the DT 42759 3884 2 present present JJ 42759 3884 3 chapter chapter NN 42759 3884 4 may may MD 42759 3884 5 be be VB 42759 3884 6 fittingly fittingly RB 42759 3884 7 closed close VBN 42759 3884 8 with with IN 42759 3884 9 a a DT 42759 3884 10 moderate moderate JJ 42759 3884 11 and and CC 42759 3884 12 significant significant JJ 42759 3884 13 statement statement NN 42759 3884 14 from from IN 42759 3884 15 the the DT 42759 3884 16 pen pen NN 42759 3884 17 of of IN 42759 3884 18 Professor Professor NNP 42759 3884 19 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 3884 20 : : : 42759 3884 21 " " `` 42759 3884 22 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3884 23 is be VBZ 42759 3884 24 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 3884 25 whether whether IN 42759 3884 26 the the DT 42759 3884 27 whole whole JJ 42759 3884 28 mechanism mechanism NN 42759 3884 29 of of IN 42759 3884 30 irregular irregular JJ 42759 3884 31 and and CC 42759 3884 32 swollen swollen JJ 42759 3884 33 capitalisation capitalisation NN 42759 3884 34 was be VBD 42759 3884 35 at at IN 42759 3884 36 any any DT 42759 3884 37 time time NN 42759 3884 38 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3884 39 or or CC 42759 3884 40 wise wise JJ 42759 3884 41 . . . 42759 3885 1 Why why WRB 42759 3885 2 not not RB 42759 3885 3 provide provide VB 42759 3885 4 once once RB 42759 3885 5 for for IN 42759 3885 6 all all PDT 42759 3885 7 that that WDT 42759 3885 8 securities security NNS 42759 3885 9 shall shall MD 42759 3885 10 be be VB 42759 3885 11 issued issue VBN 42759 3885 12 only only RB 42759 3885 13 to to TO 42759 3885 14 represent represent VB 42759 3885 15 what what WP 42759 3885 16 has have VBZ 42759 3885 17 been be VBN 42759 3885 18 invested invest VBN 42759 3885 19 ? ? . 42759 3885 20 ... ... . 42759 3886 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3886 2 is be VBZ 42759 3886 3 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3886 4 said say VBN 42759 3886 5 that that IN 42759 3886 6 freedom freedom NN 42759 3886 7 , , , 42759 3886 8 even even RB 42759 3886 9 recklessness recklessness JJ 42759 3886 10 , , , 42759 3886 11 in in IN 42759 3886 12 the the DT 42759 3886 13 issue issue NN 42759 3886 14 of of IN 42759 3886 15 securities security NNS 42759 3886 16 was be VBD 42759 3886 17 a a DT 42759 3886 18 useful useful JJ 42759 3886 19 device device NN 42759 3886 20 , , , 42759 3886 21 in in IN 42759 3886 22 that that IN 42759 3886 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3886 24 enabled enable VBD 42759 3886 25 the the DT 42759 3886 26 projectors projector NNS 42759 3886 27 to to TO 42759 3886 28 look look VB 42759 3886 29 forward forward RB 42759 3886 30 to to IN 42759 3886 31 returns return NNS 42759 3886 32 really really RB 42759 3886 33 tempting tempting JJ 42759 3886 34 , , , 42759 3886 35 and and CC 42759 3886 36 at at IN 42759 3886 37 the the DT 42759 3886 38 same same JJ 42759 3886 39 time time NN 42759 3886 40 concealed conceal VBD 42759 3886 41 these these DT 42759 3886 42 returns return NNS 42759 3886 43 from from IN 42759 3886 44 a a DT 42759 3886 45 grudging grudge VBG 42759 3886 46 public public NN 42759 3886 47 .... .... . 42759 3886 48 A a DT 42759 3886 49 more more RBR 42759 3886 50 simple simple JJ 42759 3886 51 and and CC 42759 3886 52 straightforward straightforward JJ 42759 3886 53 way way NN 42759 3886 54 of of IN 42759 3886 55 dealing deal VBG 42759 3886 56 with with IN 42759 3886 57 the the DT 42759 3886 58 issue issue NN 42759 3886 59 of of IN 42759 3886 60 securities security NNS 42759 3886 61 might may MD 42759 3886 62 thus thus RB 42759 3886 63 have have VB 42759 3886 64 dampened dampen VBN 42759 3886 65 in in IN 42759 3886 66 some some DT 42759 3886 67 degree degree NN 42759 3886 68 the the DT 42759 3886 69 feverish feverish JJ 42759 3886 70 speculation speculation NN 42759 3886 71 and and CC 42759 3886 72 restless restless JJ 42759 3886 73 progress progress NN 42759 3886 74 of of IN 42759 3886 75 railway railway NN 42759 3886 76 development development NN 42759 3886 77 . . . 42759 3887 1 But but CC 42759 3887 2 a a DT 42759 3887 3 slower slow JJR 42759 3887 4 pace pace NN 42759 3887 5 would would MD 42759 3887 6 have have VB 42759 3887 7 had have VBN 42759 3887 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3887 9 advantages advantage NNS 42759 3887 10 also also RB 42759 3887 11 , , , 42759 3887 12 and and CC 42759 3887 13 , , , 42759 3887 14 not not RB 42759 3887 15 least least JJS 42759 3887 16 , , , 42759 3887 17 restriction restriction NN 42759 3887 18 of of IN 42759 3887 19 securities security NNS 42759 3887 20 would would MD 42759 3887 21 have have VB 42759 3887 22 saved save VBN 42759 3887 23 great great JJ 42759 3887 24 complications complication NNS 42759 3887 25 in in IN 42759 3887 26 the the DT 42759 3887 27 later later JJ 42759 3887 28 stages stage NNS 42759 3887 29 of of IN 42759 3887 30 established establish VBN 42759 3887 31 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 3887 32 and and CC 42759 3887 33 needed need VBD 42759 3887 34 regulation regulation NN 42759 3887 35 . . . 42759 3888 1 " " `` 42759 3888 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3888 3 196 196 CD 42759 3888 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3888 5 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 3888 6 : : : 42759 3888 7 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3888 8 186 186 CD 42759 3888 9 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3888 10 Cf Cf NNP 42759 3888 11 . . . 42759 3889 1 Ripley Ripley NNP 42759 3889 2 , , , 42759 3889 3 " " `` 42759 3889 4 Trusts trust NNS 42759 3889 5 , , , 42759 3889 6 Pools pool NNS 42759 3889 7 , , , 42759 3889 8 and and CC 42759 3889 9 Corporations corporation NNS 42759 3889 10 , , , 42759 3889 11 " " '' 42759 3889 12 pp pp NNP 42759 3889 13 . . . 42759 3890 1 207 207 CD 42759 3890 2 - - HYPH 42759 3890 3 210 210 CD 42759 3890 4 . . . 42759 3891 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3891 2 187 187 CD 42759 3891 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3891 4 See See NNP 42759 3891 5 Report Report NNP 42759 3891 6 of of IN 42759 3891 7 the the DT 42759 3891 8 Interstate Interstate NNP 42759 3891 9 Commerce Commerce NNP 42759 3891 10 Commission Commission NNP 42759 3891 11 on on IN 42759 3891 12 these these DT 42759 3891 13 transactions transaction NNS 42759 3891 14 . . . 42759 3892 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3892 2 188 188 CD 42759 3892 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3892 4 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 3892 5 , , , 42759 3892 6 " " `` 42759 3892 7 Principles Principles NNPS 42759 3892 8 of of IN 42759 3892 9 Economics Economics NNP 42759 3892 10 , , , 42759 3892 11 " " '' 42759 3892 12 II ii CD 42759 3892 13 , , , 42759 3892 14 385 385 CD 42759 3892 15 , , , 42759 3892 16 386 386 CD 42759 3892 17 . . . 42759 3893 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3893 2 189 189 CD 42759 3893 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3893 4 Final Final NNP 42759 3893 5 Report Report NNP 42759 3893 6 , , , 42759 3893 7 p. p. NN 42759 3893 8 414 414 CD 42759 3893 9 . . . 42759 3894 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3894 2 190 190 CD 42759 3894 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3894 4 Final Final NNP 42759 3894 5 Report Report NNP 42759 3894 6 of of IN 42759 3894 7 the the DT 42759 3894 8 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 3894 9 Commission Commission NNP 42759 3894 10 , , , 42759 3894 11 p. p. NN 42759 3894 12 413 413 CD 42759 3894 13 . . . 42759 3895 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3895 2 191 191 CD 42759 3895 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3895 4 Report report NN 42759 3895 5 on on IN 42759 3895 6 the the DT 42759 3895 7 Steel Steel NNP 42759 3895 8 Industry Industry NNP 42759 3895 9 , , , 42759 3895 10 p. p. NN 42759 3895 11 38 38 CD 42759 3895 12 . . . 42759 3896 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3896 2 192 192 CD 42759 3896 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3896 4 Idem Idem NNP 42759 3896 5 , , , 42759 3896 6 p. p. NN 42759 3896 7 39 39 CD 42759 3896 8 . . . 42759 3897 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3897 2 193 193 CD 42759 3897 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3897 4 _ _ NNP 42759 3897 5 Chicago Chicago NNP 42759 3897 6 Record Record NNP 42759 3897 7 - - HYPH 42759 3897 8 Herald Herald NNP 42759 3897 9 _ _ NNP 42759 3897 10 , , , 42759 3897 11 July July NNP 42759 3897 12 29 29 CD 42759 3897 13 , , , 42759 3897 14 1912 1912 CD 42759 3897 15 . . . 42759 3898 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3898 2 194 194 CD 42759 3898 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3898 4 Op Op NNP 42759 3898 5 . . . 42759 3899 1 cit cit NNP 42759 3899 2 . . NNP 42759 3899 3 , , , 42759 3899 4 p. p. NN 42759 3899 5 28 28 CD 42759 3899 6 . . . 42759 3900 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3900 2 195 195 CD 42759 3900 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3900 4 Cf cf NN 42759 3900 5 . . . 42759 3901 1 Van Van NNP 42759 3901 2 Hise Hise NNP 42759 3901 3 , , , 42759 3901 4 op op NN 42759 3901 5 . . . 42759 3902 1 cit cit NNP 42759 3902 2 . . . 42759 3902 3 , , , 42759 3902 4 pp pp NNP 42759 3902 5 . . . 42759 3903 1 29 29 CD 42759 3903 2 , , , 42759 3903 3 142 142 CD 42759 3903 4 , , , 42759 3903 5 149 149 CD 42759 3903 6 . . . 42759 3904 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3904 2 196 196 CD 42759 3904 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3904 4 Op Op NNP 42759 3904 5 . . . 42759 3905 1 cit cit NNP 42759 3905 2 . . . 42759 3905 3 , , , 42759 3905 4 II II NNP 42759 3905 5 , , , 42759 3905 6 387 387 CD 42759 3905 7 , , , 42759 3905 8 388 388 CD 42759 3905 9 . . . 42759 3906 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 3906 2 XX XX NNP 42759 3906 3 THE the DT 42759 3906 4 LEGAL LEGAL NNP 42759 3906 5 LIMITATION limitation NN 42759 3906 6 OF of IN 42759 3906 7 FORTUNES FORTUNES NNP 42759 3906 8 If if IN 42759 3906 9 the the DT 42759 3906 10 taxation taxation NN 42759 3906 11 and and CC 42759 3906 12 other other JJ 42759 3906 13 measures measure NNS 42759 3906 14 of of IN 42759 3906 15 reform reform NN 42759 3906 16 suggested suggest VBD 42759 3906 17 in in IN 42759 3906 18 Section section NN 42759 3906 19 I -PRON- PRP 42759 3906 20 were be VBD 42759 3906 21 fully fully RB 42759 3906 22 applied apply VBN 42759 3906 23 to to IN 42759 3906 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3906 25 land land NN 42759 3906 26 system system NN 42759 3906 27 ; ; : 42759 3906 28 if if IN 42759 3906 29 co co JJ 42759 3906 30 - - JJ 42759 3906 31 operative operative JJ 42759 3906 32 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3906 33 were be VBD 42759 3906 34 extended extend VBN 42759 3906 35 to to IN 42759 3906 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3906 37 utmost utmost JJ 42759 3906 38 practicable practicable JJ 42759 3906 39 limits limit NNS 42759 3906 40 for for IN 42759 3906 41 the the DT 42759 3906 42 correction correction NN 42759 3906 43 of of IN 42759 3906 44 capitalism capitalism NN 42759 3906 45 ; ; , 42759 3906 46 and and CC 42759 3906 47 if if IN 42759 3906 48 the the DT 42759 3906 49 wide wide JJ 42759 3906 50 extension extension NN 42759 3906 51 of of IN 42759 3906 52 educational educational JJ 42759 3906 53 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 3906 54 , , , 42759 3906 55 and and CC 42759 3906 56 the the DT 42759 3906 57 elimination elimination NN 42759 3906 58 of of IN 42759 3906 59 the the DT 42759 3906 60 surplus surplus JJ 42759 3906 61 gains gain NNS 42759 3906 62 of of IN 42759 3906 63 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 3906 64 restricted restrict VBD 42759 3906 65 the the DT 42759 3906 66 profits profit NNS 42759 3906 67 of of IN 42759 3906 68 the the DT 42759 3906 69 business business NN 42759 3906 70 man man NN 42759 3906 71 to to IN 42759 3906 72 an an DT 42759 3906 73 amount amount NN 42759 3906 74 strictly strictly RB 42759 3906 75 commensurate commensurate JJ 42759 3906 76 with with IN 42759 3906 77 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3906 78 ability ability NN 42759 3906 79 and and CC 42759 3906 80 risks,--if risks,--if VB 42759 3906 81 all all PDT 42759 3906 82 these these DT 42759 3906 83 results result NNS 42759 3906 84 were be VBD 42759 3906 85 accomplished accomplish VBN 42759 3906 86 the the DT 42759 3906 87 number number NN 42759 3906 88 of of IN 42759 3906 89 men man NNS 42759 3906 90 who who WP 42759 3906 91 could could MD 42759 3906 92 become become VB 42759 3906 93 millionaires millionaire NNS 42759 3906 94 through through IN 42759 3906 95 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3906 96 own own JJ 42759 3906 97 efforts effort NNS 42759 3906 98 would would MD 42759 3906 99 be be VB 42759 3906 100 so so RB 42759 3906 101 small small JJ 42759 3906 102 that that IN 42759 3906 103 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3906 104 success success NN 42759 3906 105 would would MD 42759 3906 106 arouse arouse VB 42759 3906 107 popular popular JJ 42759 3906 108 applause applause NN 42759 3906 109 rather rather RB 42759 3906 110 than than IN 42759 3906 111 popular popular JJ 42759 3906 112 envy envy NN 42759 3906 113 . . . 42759 3907 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3907 2 claim claim NN 42759 3907 3 to to IN 42759 3907 4 whatever whatever WDT 42759 3907 5 wealth wealth NN 42759 3907 6 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3907 7 might may MD 42759 3907 8 accumulate accumulate VB 42759 3907 9 would would MD 42759 3907 10 be be VB 42759 3907 11 generally generally RB 42759 3907 12 looked look VBN 42759 3907 13 upon upon IN 42759 3907 14 as as IN 42759 3907 15 entirely entirely RB 42759 3907 16 valid valid JJ 42759 3907 17 and and CC 42759 3907 18 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3907 19 . . . 42759 3908 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3908 2 pecuniary pecuniary JJ 42759 3908 3 eminence eminence NN 42759 3908 4 would would MD 42759 3908 5 be be VB 42759 3908 6 pronounced pronounce VBN 42759 3908 7 quite quite RB 42759 3908 8 as as RB 42759 3908 9 deserved deserved JJ 42759 3908 10 as as IN 42759 3908 11 the the DT 42759 3908 12 literary literary JJ 42759 3908 13 eminence eminence NN 42759 3908 14 of of IN 42759 3908 15 a a DT 42759 3908 16 Lowell Lowell NNP 42759 3908 17 , , , 42759 3908 18 the the DT 42759 3908 19 scientific scientific JJ 42759 3908 20 eminence eminence NN 42759 3908 21 of of IN 42759 3908 22 a a DT 42759 3908 23 Pasteur Pasteur NNP 42759 3908 24 , , , 42759 3908 25 or or CC 42759 3908 26 the the DT 42759 3908 27 political political JJ 42759 3908 28 eminence eminence NN 42759 3908 29 of of IN 42759 3908 30 a a DT 42759 3908 31 Lincoln Lincoln NNP 42759 3908 32 . . . 42759 3909 1 In in IN 42759 3909 2 such such JJ 42759 3909 3 conditions condition NNS 42759 3909 4 there there EX 42759 3909 5 could could MD 42759 3909 6 be be VB 42759 3909 7 no no DT 42759 3909 8 disconcerting disconcert VBG 42759 3909 9 discussion discussion NN 42759 3909 10 of of IN 42759 3909 11 the the DT 42759 3909 12 menace menace NN 42759 3909 13 of of IN 42759 3909 14 great great JJ 42759 3909 15 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 3909 16 . . . 42759 3910 1 In in IN 42759 3910 2 the the DT 42759 3910 3 meantime meantime NN 42759 3910 4 , , , 42759 3910 5 these these DT 42759 3910 6 reforms reform NNS 42759 3910 7 are be VBP 42759 3910 8 not not RB 42759 3910 9 realised realise VBN 42759 3910 10 , , , 42759 3910 11 nor nor CC 42759 3910 12 are be VBP 42759 3910 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3910 14 likely likely JJ 42759 3910 15 to to TO 42759 3910 16 be be VB 42759 3910 17 even even RB 42759 3910 18 approximately approximately RB 42759 3910 19 established establish VBN 42759 3910 20 within within IN 42759 3910 21 the the DT 42759 3910 22 present present JJ 42759 3910 23 generation generation NN 42759 3910 24 . . . 42759 3911 1 For for IN 42759 3911 2 some some DT 42759 3911 3 time time NN 42759 3911 4 to to TO 42759 3911 5 come come VB 42759 3911 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3911 7 will will MD 42759 3911 8 be be VB 42759 3911 9 possible possible JJ 42759 3911 10 for for IN 42759 3911 11 the the DT 42759 3911 12 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3911 13 able able JJ 42759 3911 14 , , , 42759 3911 15 the the DT 42759 3911 16 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3911 17 cunning cunning JJ 42759 3911 18 , , , 42759 3911 19 and and CC 42759 3911 20 the the DT 42759 3911 21 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 3911 22 lucky lucky JJ 42759 3911 23 to to TO 42759 3911 24 accumulate accumulate VB 42759 3911 25 great great JJ 42759 3911 26 riches rich NNS 42759 3911 27 through through IN 42759 3911 28 clever clever JJ 42759 3911 29 and and CC 42759 3911 30 fortuitous fortuitous JJ 42759 3911 31 utilisation utilisation NN 42759 3911 32 of of IN 42759 3911 33 special special JJ 42759 3911 34 advantages advantage NNS 42759 3911 35 , , , 42759 3911 36 natural natural JJ 42759 3911 37 and and CC 42759 3911 38 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 3911 39 . . . 42759 3912 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 3912 2 , , , 42759 3912 3 a a DT 42759 3912 4 great great JJ 42759 3912 5 proportion proportion NN 42759 3912 6 of of IN 42759 3912 7 the the DT 42759 3912 8 large large JJ 42759 3912 9 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 3912 10 already already RB 42759 3912 11 in in IN 42759 3912 12 existence existence NN 42759 3912 13 will will MD 42759 3912 14 persist persist VB 42759 3912 15 , , , 42759 3912 16 and and CC 42759 3912 17 will will MD 42759 3912 18 be be VB 42759 3912 19 transmitted transmit VBN 42759 3912 20 to to IN 42759 3912 21 heirs heir NNS 42759 3912 22 who who WP 42759 3912 23 will will MD 42759 3912 24 in in IN 42759 3912 25 many many JJ 42759 3912 26 cases case NNS 42759 3912 27 cause cause VB 42759 3912 28 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3912 29 to to TO 42759 3912 30 increase increase VB 42759 3912 31 . . . 42759 3913 1 Can Can MD 42759 3913 2 nothing nothing NN 42759 3913 3 be be VB 42759 3913 4 done do VBN 42759 3913 5 to to TO 42759 3913 6 reduce reduce VB 42759 3913 7 the the DT 42759 3913 8 size size NN 42759 3913 9 and and CC 42759 3913 10 lessen lessen VB 42759 3913 11 the the DT 42759 3913 12 number number NN 42759 3913 13 of of IN 42759 3913 14 these these DT 42759 3913 15 great great JJ 42759 3913 16 accumulations accumulation NNS 42759 3913 17 ? ? . 42759 3914 1 If if IN 42759 3914 2 so so RB 42759 3914 3 , , , 42759 3914 4 is be VBZ 42759 3914 5 such such PDT 42759 3914 6 a a DT 42759 3914 7 proceeding proceeding NN 42759 3914 8 socially socially RB 42759 3914 9 and and CC 42759 3914 10 morally morally RB 42759 3914 11 desirable desirable JJ 42759 3914 12 ? ? . 42759 3915 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3915 2 The the DT 42759 3915 3 Method Method NNP 42759 3915 4 of of IN 42759 3915 5 Direct Direct NNP 42759 3915 6 Limitation Limitation NNP 42759 3915 7 _ _ NNP 42759 3915 8 The the DT 42759 3915 9 law law NN 42759 3915 10 might may MD 42759 3915 11 directly directly RB 42759 3915 12 limit limit VB 42759 3915 13 the the DT 42759 3915 14 amount amount NN 42759 3915 15 of of IN 42759 3915 16 property property NN 42759 3915 17 to to TO 42759 3915 18 be be VB 42759 3915 19 held hold VBN 42759 3915 20 by by IN 42759 3915 21 any any DT 42759 3915 22 individual individual NN 42759 3915 23 . . . 42759 3916 1 If if IN 42759 3916 2 the the DT 42759 3916 3 limit limit NN 42759 3916 4 were be VBD 42759 3916 5 placed place VBN 42759 3916 6 fairly fairly RB 42759 3916 7 high high JJ 42759 3916 8 , , , 42759 3916 9 say say VB 42759 3916 10 , , , 42759 3916 11 at at IN 42759 3916 12 one one CD 42759 3916 13 hundred hundred CD 42759 3916 14 thousand thousand CD 42759 3916 15 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3916 16 , , , 42759 3916 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3916 18 could could MD 42759 3916 19 scarcely scarcely RB 42759 3916 20 be be VB 42759 3916 21 regarded regard VBN 42759 3916 22 as as IN 42759 3916 23 an an DT 42759 3916 24 infringement infringement NN 42759 3916 25 on on IN 42759 3916 26 the the DT 42759 3916 27 right right NN 42759 3916 28 of of IN 42759 3916 29 property property NN 42759 3916 30 . . . 42759 3917 1 In in IN 42759 3917 2 the the DT 42759 3917 3 case case NN 42759 3917 4 of of IN 42759 3917 5 a a DT 42759 3917 6 family family NN 42759 3917 7 numbering number VBG 42759 3917 8 ten ten CD 42759 3917 9 members member NNS 42759 3917 10 , , , 42759 3917 11 this this DT 42759 3917 12 would would MD 42759 3917 13 mean mean VB 42759 3917 14 one one CD 42759 3917 15 million million CD 42759 3917 16 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3917 17 . . . 42759 3918 1 All all PDT 42759 3918 2 the the DT 42759 3918 3 essential essential JJ 42759 3918 4 objects object NNS 42759 3918 5 of of IN 42759 3918 6 private private JJ 42759 3918 7 ownership ownership NN 42759 3918 8 could could MD 42759 3918 9 be be VB 42759 3918 10 abundantly abundantly RB 42759 3918 11 met meet VBN 42759 3918 12 out out IN 42759 3918 13 of of IN 42759 3918 14 a a DT 42759 3918 15 sum sum NN 42759 3918 16 of of IN 42759 3918 17 one one CD 42759 3918 18 hundred hundred CD 42759 3918 19 thousand thousand CD 42759 3918 20 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3918 21 for for IN 42759 3918 22 each each DT 42759 3918 23 person person NN 42759 3918 24 . . . 42759 3919 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 3919 2 , , , 42759 3919 3 a a DT 42759 3919 4 restriction restriction NN 42759 3919 5 of of IN 42759 3919 6 this this DT 42759 3919 7 sort sort NN 42759 3919 8 need nee MD 42759 3919 9 not not RB 42759 3919 10 prevent prevent VB 42759 3919 11 a a DT 42759 3919 12 man man NN 42759 3919 13 from from IN 42759 3919 14 bestowing bestow VBG 42759 3919 15 unlimited unlimited JJ 42759 3919 16 amounts amount NNS 42759 3919 17 upon upon IN 42759 3919 18 charitable charitable JJ 42759 3919 19 , , , 42759 3919 20 religious religious JJ 42759 3919 21 , , , 42759 3919 22 educational educational JJ 42759 3919 23 , , , 42759 3919 24 or or CC 42759 3919 25 other other JJ 42759 3919 26 benevolent benevolent JJ 42759 3919 27 causes cause NNS 42759 3919 28 . . . 42759 3920 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3920 2 would would MD 42759 3920 3 , , , 42759 3920 4 indeed indeed RB 42759 3920 5 , , , 42759 3920 6 hinder hinder VB 42759 3920 7 some some DT 42759 3920 8 persons person NNS 42759 3920 9 from from IN 42759 3920 10 satisfying satisfy VBG 42759 3920 11 certain certain JJ 42759 3920 12 unessential unessential JJ 42759 3920 13 wants want NNS 42759 3920 14 , , , 42759 3920 15 such such JJ 42759 3920 16 as as IN 42759 3920 17 , , , 42759 3920 18 the the DT 42759 3920 19 desire desire NN 42759 3920 20 to to TO 42759 3920 21 enjoy enjoy VB 42759 3920 22 gross gross JJ 42759 3920 23 or or CC 42759 3920 24 refined refined JJ 42759 3920 25 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 3920 26 , , , 42759 3920 27 great great JJ 42759 3920 28 financial financial JJ 42759 3920 29 power power NN 42759 3920 30 , , , 42759 3920 31 and and CC 42759 3920 32 the the DT 42759 3920 33 control control NN 42759 3920 34 of of IN 42759 3920 35 immense immense JJ 42759 3920 36 industrial industrial JJ 42759 3920 37 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 3920 38 ; ; : 42759 3920 39 but but CC 42759 3920 40 none none NN 42759 3920 41 of of IN 42759 3920 42 these these DT 42759 3920 43 objects object NNS 42759 3920 44 is be VBZ 42759 3920 45 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3920 46 for for IN 42759 3920 47 any any DT 42759 3920 48 individual individual NN 42759 3920 49 's 's POS 42759 3920 50 genuine genuine JJ 42759 3920 51 welfare welfare NN 42759 3920 52 . . . 42759 3921 1 In in IN 42759 3921 2 the the DT 42759 3921 3 interest interest NN 42759 3921 4 of of IN 42759 3921 5 the the DT 42759 3921 6 social social JJ 42759 3921 7 good good JJ 42759 3921 8 such such JJ 42759 3921 9 private private JJ 42759 3921 10 and and CC 42759 3921 11 unimportant unimportant JJ 42759 3921 12 ends end NNS 42759 3921 13 may may MD 42759 3921 14 properly properly RB 42759 3921 15 be be VB 42759 3921 16 rendered render VBN 42759 3921 17 impossible impossible JJ 42759 3921 18 of of IN 42759 3921 19 realisation realisation NN 42759 3921 20 . . . 42759 3922 1 Such such PDT 42759 3922 2 a a DT 42759 3922 3 restriction restriction NN 42759 3922 4 would would MD 42759 3922 5 no no RB 42759 3922 6 more more RBR 42759 3922 7 constitute constitute VB 42759 3922 8 a a DT 42759 3922 9 direct direct JJ 42759 3922 10 attack attack NN 42759 3922 11 upon upon IN 42759 3922 12 private private JJ 42759 3922 13 ownership ownership NN 42759 3922 14 than than IN 42759 3922 15 limitations limitation NNS 42759 3922 16 upon upon IN 42759 3922 17 the the DT 42759 3922 18 use use NN 42759 3922 19 and and CC 42759 3922 20 kinds kind NNS 42759 3922 21 of of IN 42759 3922 22 property property NN 42759 3922 23 . . . 42759 3923 1 At at IN 42759 3923 2 present present JJ 42759 3923 3 a a DT 42759 3923 4 man man NN 42759 3923 5 may may MD 42759 3923 6 not not RB 42759 3923 7 do do VB 42759 3923 8 what what WP 42759 3923 9 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3923 10 pleases please VBZ 42759 3923 11 with with IN 42759 3923 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3923 13 gun gun NN 42759 3923 14 , , , 42759 3923 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3923 16 horse horse NN 42759 3923 17 , , , 42759 3923 18 or or CC 42759 3923 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3923 20 automobile automobile NN 42759 3923 21 , , , 42759 3923 22 nor nor CC 42759 3923 23 may may MD 42759 3923 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3923 25 invest invest VB 42759 3923 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3923 27 money money NN 42759 3923 28 in in IN 42759 3923 29 the the DT 42759 3923 30 business business NN 42759 3923 31 of of IN 42759 3923 32 carrying carry VBG 42759 3923 33 the the DT 42759 3923 34 mails mail NNS 42759 3923 35 . . . 42759 3924 1 The the DT 42759 3924 2 limitation limitation NN 42759 3924 3 of of IN 42759 3924 4 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 3924 5 is be VBZ 42759 3924 6 just just RB 42759 3924 7 what what WP 42759 3924 8 the the DT 42759 3924 9 word word NN 42759 3924 10 expresses express VBZ 42759 3924 11 , , , 42759 3924 12 a a DT 42759 3924 13 _ _ NNP 42759 3924 14 limitation limitation NN 42759 3924 15 _ _ NNP 42759 3924 16 of of IN 42759 3924 17 the the DT 42759 3924 18 right right NN 42759 3924 19 of of IN 42759 3924 20 property property NN 42759 3924 21 . . . 42759 3925 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3925 2 is be VBZ 42759 3925 3 not not RB 42759 3925 4 a a DT 42759 3925 5 denial denial NN 42759 3925 6 nor nor CC 42759 3925 7 _ _ NNP 42759 3925 8 destruction destruction NN 42759 3925 9 _ _ NNP 42759 3925 10 of of IN 42759 3925 11 that that DT 42759 3925 12 right right NN 42759 3925 13 . . . 42759 3926 1 As as IN 42759 3926 2 a a DT 42759 3926 3 limitation limitation NN 42759 3926 4 of of IN 42759 3926 5 the the DT 42759 3926 6 amount amount NN 42759 3926 7 to to TO 42759 3926 8 be be VB 42759 3926 9 held hold VBN 42759 3926 10 by by IN 42759 3926 11 an an DT 42759 3926 12 individual individual NN 42759 3926 13 , , , 42759 3926 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3926 15 does do VBZ 42759 3926 16 not not RB 42759 3926 17 differ differ VB 42759 3926 18 in in IN 42759 3926 19 principle principle NN 42759 3926 20 from from IN 42759 3926 21 a a DT 42759 3926 22 limitation limitation NN 42759 3926 23 of of IN 42759 3926 24 the the DT 42759 3926 25 kinds kind NNS 42759 3926 26 of of IN 42759 3926 27 goods good NNS 42759 3926 28 that that WDT 42759 3926 29 may may MD 42759 3926 30 become become VB 42759 3926 31 the the DT 42759 3926 32 subject subject NN 42759 3926 33 of of IN 42759 3926 34 private private JJ 42759 3926 35 ownership ownership NN 42759 3926 36 . . . 42759 3927 1 There there EX 42759 3927 2 is be VBZ 42759 3927 3 nothing nothing NN 42759 3927 4 in in IN 42759 3927 5 the the DT 42759 3927 6 nature nature NN 42759 3927 7 of of IN 42759 3927 8 things thing NNS 42759 3927 9 nor nor CC 42759 3927 10 in in IN 42759 3927 11 the the DT 42759 3927 12 reason reason NN 42759 3927 13 of of IN 42759 3927 14 property property NN 42759 3927 15 to to TO 42759 3927 16 indicate indicate VB 42759 3927 17 that that IN 42759 3927 18 the the DT 42759 3927 19 right right NN 42759 3927 20 of of IN 42759 3927 21 ownership ownership NN 42759 3927 22 is be VBZ 42759 3927 23 unlimited unlimited JJ 42759 3927 24 in in IN 42759 3927 25 quantity quantity NN 42759 3927 26 any any DT 42759 3927 27 more more RBR 42759 3927 28 than than IN 42759 3927 29 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3927 30 is be VBZ 42759 3927 31 in in IN 42759 3927 32 quality quality NN 42759 3927 33 . . . 42759 3928 1 The the DT 42759 3928 2 final final JJ 42759 3928 3 end end NN 42759 3928 4 and and CC 42759 3928 5 justification justification NN 42759 3928 6 of of IN 42759 3928 7 individual individual JJ 42759 3928 8 rights right NNS 42759 3928 9 of of IN 42759 3928 10 property property NN 42759 3928 11 is be VBZ 42759 3928 12 human human JJ 42759 3928 13 welfare welfare NN 42759 3928 14 ; ; : 42759 3928 15 that that RB 42759 3928 16 is is RB 42759 3928 17 , , , 42759 3928 18 the the DT 42759 3928 19 welfare welfare NN 42759 3928 20 of of IN 42759 3928 21 all all DT 42759 3928 22 individuals individual NNS 42759 3928 23 severally severally RB 42759 3928 24 and and CC 42759 3928 25 collectively collectively RB 42759 3928 26 . . . 42759 3929 1 Now now RB 42759 3929 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3929 3 is be VBZ 42759 3929 4 quite quite RB 42759 3929 5 within within IN 42759 3929 6 the the DT 42759 3929 7 bounds bound NNS 42759 3929 8 of of IN 42759 3929 9 physical physical JJ 42759 3929 10 possibility possibility NN 42759 3929 11 that that IN 42759 3929 12 the the DT 42759 3929 13 limitation limitation NN 42759 3929 14 under under IN 42759 3929 15 discussion discussion NN 42759 3929 16 might may MD 42759 3929 17 be be VB 42759 3929 18 conducive conducive JJ 42759 3929 19 to to IN 42759 3929 20 the the DT 42759 3929 21 welfare welfare NN 42759 3929 22 of of IN 42759 3929 23 human human JJ 42759 3929 24 beings being NNS 42759 3929 25 both both CC 42759 3929 26 as as IN 42759 3929 27 individuals individual NNS 42759 3929 28 and and CC 42759 3929 29 as as IN 42759 3929 30 constituting constitute VBG 42759 3929 31 society society NN 42759 3929 32 . . . 42759 3930 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 3930 2 the the DT 42759 3930 3 dangers danger NNS 42759 3930 4 and and CC 42759 3930 5 obstacles obstacle NNS 42759 3930 6 confronting confront VBG 42759 3930 7 any any DT 42759 3930 8 legal legal JJ 42759 3930 9 restriction restriction NN 42759 3930 10 of of IN 42759 3930 11 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 3930 12 are be VBP 42759 3930 13 so so RB 42759 3930 14 real real JJ 42759 3930 15 as as IN 42759 3930 16 to to TO 42759 3930 17 render render VB 42759 3930 18 the the DT 42759 3930 19 proposal proposal NN 42759 3930 20 socially socially RB 42759 3930 21 inexpedient inexpedient JJ 42759 3930 22 . . . 42759 3931 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3931 2 would would MD 42759 3931 3 easily easily RB 42759 3931 4 lend lend VB 42759 3931 5 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 3931 6 to to IN 42759 3931 7 grave grave JJ 42759 3931 8 abuse abuse NN 42759 3931 9 . . . 42759 3932 1 Once once IN 42759 3932 2 the the DT 42759 3932 3 community community NN 42759 3932 4 had have VBD 42759 3932 5 habituated habituate VBN 42759 3932 6 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 3932 7 to to IN 42759 3932 8 a a DT 42759 3932 9 direct direct JJ 42759 3932 10 limitation limitation NN 42759 3932 11 of of IN 42759 3932 12 any any DT 42759 3932 13 sort sort NN 42759 3932 14 , , , 42759 3932 15 the the DT 42759 3932 16 temptation temptation NN 42759 3932 17 to to TO 42759 3932 18 lower lower VB 42759 3932 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3932 20 in in IN 42759 3932 21 the the DT 42759 3932 22 interest interest NN 42759 3932 23 of of IN 42759 3932 24 better well JJR 42759 3932 25 distribution distribution NN 42759 3932 26 and and CC 42759 3932 27 simpler simple JJR 42759 3932 28 living living NN 42759 3932 29 would would MD 42759 3932 30 become become VB 42759 3932 31 exceedingly exceedingly RB 42759 3932 32 powerful powerful JJ 42759 3932 33 . . . 42759 3933 1 Eventually eventually RB 42759 3933 2 the the DT 42759 3933 3 right right NN 42759 3933 4 of of IN 42759 3933 5 property property NN 42759 3933 6 might may MD 42759 3933 7 take take VB 42759 3933 8 such such PDT 42759 3933 9 an an DT 42759 3933 10 attenuated attenuated JJ 42759 3933 11 and and CC 42759 3933 12 uncertain uncertain JJ 42759 3933 13 form form NN 42759 3933 14 in in IN 42759 3933 15 the the DT 42759 3933 16 public public JJ 42759 3933 17 mind mind NN 42759 3933 18 as as IN 42759 3933 19 to to TO 42759 3933 20 discourage discourage VB 42759 3933 21 labour labour NN 42759 3933 22 and and CC 42759 3933 23 initiative initiative NN 42759 3933 24 , , , 42759 3933 25 and and CC 42759 3933 26 thus thus RB 42759 3933 27 seriously seriously RB 42759 3933 28 to to TO 42759 3933 29 endanger endanger VB 42759 3933 30 human human JJ 42759 3933 31 welfare welfare NN 42759 3933 32 . . . 42759 3934 1 In in IN 42759 3934 2 the the DT 42759 3934 3 second second JJ 42759 3934 4 place place NN 42759 3934 5 , , , 42759 3934 6 the the DT 42759 3934 7 manifold manifold JJ 42759 3934 8 evasions evasion NNS 42759 3934 9 to to TO 42759 3934 10 which which WDT 42759 3934 11 the the DT 42759 3934 12 measure measure NN 42759 3934 13 would would MD 42759 3934 14 lend lend VB 42759 3934 15 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 3934 16 would would MD 42759 3934 17 make make VB 42759 3934 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3934 19 of of IN 42759 3934 20 very very RB 42759 3934 21 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 3934 22 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 3934 23 . . . 42759 3935 1 To to TO 42759 3935 2 be be VB 42759 3935 3 sure sure JJ 42759 3935 4 , , , 42759 3935 5 neither neither DT 42759 3935 6 of of IN 42759 3935 7 these these DT 42759 3935 8 objections objection NNS 42759 3935 9 is be VBZ 42759 3935 10 absolutely absolutely RB 42759 3935 11 conclusive conclusive JJ 42759 3935 12 , , , 42759 3935 13 but but CC 42759 3935 14 taken take VBN 42759 3935 15 together together RB 42759 3935 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3935 17 are be VBP 42759 3935 18 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3935 19 weighty weighty JJ 42759 3935 20 to to TO 42759 3935 21 dictate dictate VB 42759 3935 22 that that IN 42759 3935 23 such such PDT 42759 3935 24 a a DT 42759 3935 25 proposal proposal NN 42759 3935 26 should should MD 42759 3935 27 not not RB 42759 3935 28 be be VB 42759 3935 29 entertained entertain VBN 42759 3935 30 so so RB 42759 3935 31 long long RB 42759 3935 32 as as IN 42759 3935 33 other other JJ 42759 3935 34 and and CC 42759 3935 35 less less RBR 42759 3935 36 dangerous dangerous JJ 42759 3935 37 methods method NNS 42759 3935 38 are be VBP 42759 3935 39 available available JJ 42759 3935 40 to to TO 42759 3935 41 meet meet VB 42759 3935 42 the the DT 42759 3935 43 problem problem NN 42759 3935 44 of of IN 42759 3935 45 excessive excessive JJ 42759 3935 46 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 3935 47 . . . 42759 3936 1 Four four CD 42759 3936 2 of of IN 42759 3936 3 the the DT 42759 3936 4 nine nine CD 42759 3936 5 members member NNS 42759 3936 6 of of IN 42759 3936 7 the the DT 42759 3936 8 Federal Federal NNP 42759 3936 9 Commission Commission NNP 42759 3936 10 on on IN 42759 3936 11 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 3936 12 Relations Relations NNPS 42759 3936 13 have have VBP 42759 3936 14 suggested suggest VBN 42759 3936 15 that that IN 42759 3936 16 the the DT 42759 3936 17 amount amount NN 42759 3936 18 of of IN 42759 3936 19 property property NN 42759 3936 20 capable capable JJ 42759 3936 21 of of IN 42759 3936 22 being be VBG 42759 3936 23 received receive VBN 42759 3936 24 by by IN 42759 3936 25 the the DT 42759 3936 26 heirs heir NNS 42759 3936 27 of of IN 42759 3936 28 any any DT 42759 3936 29 person person NN 42759 3936 30 be be VB 42759 3936 31 limited limit VBN 42759 3936 32 to to IN 42759 3936 33 one one CD 42759 3936 34 million million CD 42759 3936 35 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3936 36 . . . 42759 3937 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3937 2 197 197 CD 42759 3937 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3937 4 If if IN 42759 3937 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3937 6 assume assume VBP 42759 3937 7 that that IN 42759 3937 8 by by IN 42759 3937 9 heirs heir NNS 42759 3937 10 the the DT 42759 3937 11 Commission Commission NNP 42759 3937 12 meant mean VBD 42759 3937 13 the the DT 42759 3937 14 natural natural JJ 42759 3937 15 persons person NNS 42759 3937 16 to to IN 42759 3937 17 whom whom WP 42759 3937 18 property property NN 42759 3937 19 might may MD 42759 3937 20 come come VB 42759 3937 21 by by IN 42759 3937 22 bequest bequest NN 42759 3937 23 or or CC 42759 3937 24 succession succession NN 42759 3937 25 , , , 42759 3937 26 this this DT 42759 3937 27 limitation limitation NN 42759 3937 28 would would MD 42759 3937 29 permit permit VB 42759 3937 30 a a DT 42759 3937 31 family family NN 42759 3937 32 of of IN 42759 3937 33 ten ten CD 42759 3937 34 persons person NNS 42759 3937 35 to to TO 42759 3937 36 inherit inherit VB 42759 3937 37 one one CD 42759 3937 38 hundred hundred CD 42759 3937 39 thousand thousand CD 42759 3937 40 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3937 41 each each DT 42759 3937 42 , , , 42759 3937 43 and and CC 42759 3937 44 a a DT 42759 3937 45 family family NN 42759 3937 46 of of IN 42759 3937 47 five five CD 42759 3937 48 persons person NNS 42759 3937 49 to to TO 42759 3937 50 obtain obtain VB 42759 3937 51 two two CD 42759 3937 52 hundred hundred CD 42759 3937 53 thousand thousand CD 42759 3937 54 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3937 55 apiece apiece RB 42759 3937 56 . . . 42759 3938 1 Would Would MD 42759 3938 2 such such PDT 42759 3938 3 a a DT 42759 3938 4 restriction restriction NN 42759 3938 5 be be VB 42759 3938 6 a a DT 42759 3938 7 violation violation NN 42759 3938 8 of of IN 42759 3938 9 the the DT 42759 3938 10 right right NN 42759 3938 11 of of IN 42759 3938 12 private private JJ 42759 3938 13 ownership ownership NN 42759 3938 14 ? ? . 42759 3939 1 The the DT 42759 3939 2 answer answer NN 42759 3939 3 depends depend VBZ 42759 3939 4 upon upon IN 42759 3939 5 the the DT 42759 3939 6 effects effect NNS 42759 3939 7 of of IN 42759 3939 8 the the DT 42759 3939 9 measure measure NN 42759 3939 10 on on IN 42759 3939 11 human human JJ 42759 3939 12 welfare welfare NN 42759 3939 13 . . . 42759 3940 1 The the DT 42759 3940 2 rights right NNS 42759 3940 3 of of IN 42759 3940 4 bequest bequest NN 42759 3940 5 and and CC 42759 3940 6 succession succession NN 42759 3940 7 are be VBP 42759 3940 8 integral integral JJ 42759 3940 9 elements element NNS 42759 3940 10 of of IN 42759 3940 11 the the DT 42759 3940 12 right right NN 42759 3940 13 of of IN 42759 3940 14 ownership ownership NN 42759 3940 15 ; ; : 42759 3940 16 hence hence RB 42759 3940 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3940 18 are be VBP 42759 3940 19 based base VBN 42759 3940 20 upon upon IN 42759 3940 21 human human JJ 42759 3940 22 needs need NNS 42759 3940 23 , , , 42759 3940 24 and and CC 42759 3940 25 designed design VBN 42759 3940 26 for for IN 42759 3940 27 the the DT 42759 3940 28 promotion promotion NN 42759 3940 29 of of IN 42759 3940 30 human human JJ 42759 3940 31 life life NN 42759 3940 32 and and CC 42759 3940 33 development development NN 42759 3940 34 . . . 42759 3941 1 A a DT 42759 3941 2 person person NN 42759 3941 3 needs need VBZ 42759 3941 4 private private JJ 42759 3941 5 property property NN 42759 3941 6 not not RB 42759 3941 7 only only RB 42759 3941 8 to to TO 42759 3941 9 provide provide VB 42759 3941 10 for for IN 42759 3941 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3941 12 personal personal JJ 42759 3941 13 wants want NNS 42759 3941 14 and and CC 42759 3941 15 those those DT 42759 3941 16 of of IN 42759 3941 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3941 18 family family NN 42759 3941 19 during during IN 42759 3941 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3941 21 lifetime lifetime NN 42759 3941 22 , , , 42759 3941 23 but but CC 42759 3941 24 also also RB 42759 3941 25 to to TO 42759 3941 26 safeguard safeguard VB 42759 3941 27 the the DT 42759 3941 28 welfare welfare NN 42759 3941 29 of of IN 42759 3941 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3941 31 dependents dependent NNS 42759 3941 32 and and CC 42759 3941 33 to to TO 42759 3941 34 assist assist VB 42759 3941 35 other other JJ 42759 3941 36 worthy worthy JJ 42759 3941 37 purposes purpose NNS 42759 3941 38 , , , 42759 3941 39 after after IN 42759 3941 40 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3941 41 has have VBZ 42759 3941 42 passed pass VBN 42759 3941 43 away away RB 42759 3941 44 . . . 42759 3942 1 Owing owe VBG 42759 3942 2 to to IN 42759 3942 3 the the DT 42759 3942 4 uncertainty uncertainty NN 42759 3942 5 of of IN 42759 3942 6 death death NN 42759 3942 7 , , , 42759 3942 8 the the DT 42759 3942 9 latter latter JJ 42759 3942 10 objects object NNS 42759 3942 11 can can MD 42759 3942 12 not not RB 42759 3942 13 be be VB 42759 3942 14 adequately adequately RB 42759 3942 15 realised realise VBN 42759 3942 16 without without IN 42759 3942 17 the the DT 42759 3942 18 institutions institution NNS 42759 3942 19 of of IN 42759 3942 20 bequest bequest NN 42759 3942 21 and and CC 42759 3942 22 succession succession NN 42759 3942 23 . . . 42759 3943 1 All all PDT 42759 3943 2 the the DT 42759 3943 3 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3943 4 and and CC 42759 3943 5 rational rational JJ 42759 3943 6 ends end NNS 42759 3943 7 of of IN 42759 3943 8 bequest bequest NN 42759 3943 9 and and CC 42759 3943 10 succession succession NN 42759 3943 11 could could MD 42759 3943 12 be be VB 42759 3943 13 attained attain VBN 42759 3943 14 in in IN 42759 3943 15 a a DT 42759 3943 16 society society NN 42759 3943 17 in in IN 42759 3943 18 which which WDT 42759 3943 19 no no DT 42759 3943 20 man man NN 42759 3943 21 's 's POS 42759 3943 22 heirs heir NNS 42759 3943 23 could could MD 42759 3943 24 inherit inherit VB 42759 3943 25 more more JJR 42759 3943 26 than than IN 42759 3943 27 one one CD 42759 3943 28 million million CD 42759 3943 29 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3943 30 . . . 42759 3944 1 Under under IN 42759 3944 2 such such PDT 42759 3944 3 an an DT 42759 3944 4 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 3944 5 very very RB 42759 3944 6 few few JJ 42759 3944 7 of of IN 42759 3944 8 the the DT 42759 3944 9 children child NNS 42759 3944 10 of of IN 42759 3944 11 millionaires millionaire NNS 42759 3944 12 would would MD 42759 3944 13 be be VB 42759 3944 14 prevented prevent VBN 42759 3944 15 from from IN 42759 3944 16 getting get VBG 42759 3944 17 at at RB 42759 3944 18 least least RBS 42759 3944 19 one one CD 42759 3944 20 hundred hundred CD 42759 3944 21 thousand thousand CD 42759 3944 22 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3944 23 . . . 42759 3945 1 That that DT 42759 3945 2 much much JJ 42759 3945 3 would would MD 42759 3945 4 be be VB 42759 3945 5 amply amply RB 42759 3945 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3945 7 for for IN 42759 3945 8 the the DT 42759 3945 9 essential essential JJ 42759 3945 10 and and CC 42759 3945 11 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3945 12 needs need NNS 42759 3945 13 of of IN 42759 3945 14 any any DT 42759 3945 15 human human JJ 42759 3945 16 being being NN 42759 3945 17 . . . 42759 3946 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 3946 2 , , , 42759 3946 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3946 4 may may MD 42759 3946 5 go go VB 42759 3946 6 further far RBR 42759 3946 7 , , , 42759 3946 8 and and CC 42759 3946 9 lay lie VBD 42759 3946 10 down down RP 42759 3946 11 the the DT 42759 3946 12 proposition proposition NN 42759 3946 13 that that IN 42759 3946 14 the the DT 42759 3946 15 overwhelming overwhelming JJ 42759 3946 16 majority majority NN 42759 3946 17 of of IN 42759 3946 18 persons person NNS 42759 3946 19 can can MD 42759 3946 20 lead lead VB 42759 3946 21 a a DT 42759 3946 22 more more RBR 42759 3946 23 virtuous virtuous JJ 42759 3946 24 and and CC 42759 3946 25 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3946 26 life life NN 42759 3946 27 on on IN 42759 3946 28 the the DT 42759 3946 29 basis basis NN 42759 3946 30 of of IN 42759 3946 31 a a DT 42759 3946 32 fortune fortune NN 42759 3946 33 of of IN 42759 3946 34 one one CD 42759 3946 35 hundred hundred CD 42759 3946 36 thousand thousand CD 42759 3946 37 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3946 38 than than IN 42759 3946 39 when when WRB 42759 3946 40 burdened burden VBN 42759 3946 41 with with IN 42759 3946 42 any any DT 42759 3946 43 larger large JJR 42759 3946 44 amount amount NN 42759 3946 45 . . . 42759 3947 1 The the DT 42759 3947 2 persons person NNS 42759 3947 3 who who WP 42759 3947 4 have have VBP 42759 3947 5 the the DT 42759 3947 6 desire desire NN 42759 3947 7 and and CC 42759 3947 8 the the DT 42759 3947 9 ability ability NN 42759 3947 10 to to TO 42759 3947 11 use use VB 42759 3947 12 a a DT 42759 3947 13 greater great JJR 42759 3947 14 sum sum NN 42759 3947 15 than than IN 42759 3947 16 this this DT 42759 3947 17 in in IN 42759 3947 18 a a DT 42759 3947 19 rational rational JJ 42759 3947 20 way way NN 42759 3947 21 are be VBP 42759 3947 22 so so RB 42759 3947 23 few few JJ 42759 3947 24 that that IN 42759 3947 25 a a DT 42759 3947 26 limitation limitation NN 42759 3947 27 law law NN 42759 3947 28 need nee MD 42759 3947 29 not not RB 42759 3947 30 take take VB 42759 3947 31 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3947 32 into into IN 42759 3947 33 account account NN 42759 3947 34 . . . 42759 3948 1 Corporate corporate JJ 42759 3948 2 persons person NNS 42759 3948 3 , , , 42759 3948 4 such such JJ 42759 3948 5 as as IN 42759 3948 6 hospitals hospital NNS 42759 3948 7 , , , 42759 3948 8 churches church NNS 42759 3948 9 , , , 42759 3948 10 schools school NNS 42759 3948 11 , , , 42759 3948 12 and and CC 42759 3948 13 other other JJ 42759 3948 14 helpful helpful JJ 42759 3948 15 institutions institution NNS 42759 3948 16 , , , 42759 3948 17 should should MD 42759 3948 18 not not RB 42759 3948 19 , , , 42759 3948 20 as as IN 42759 3948 21 a a DT 42759 3948 22 rule rule NN 42759 3948 23 , , , 42759 3948 24 be be VB 42759 3948 25 restricted restrict VBN 42759 3948 26 as as IN 42759 3948 27 to to IN 42759 3948 28 the the DT 42759 3948 29 amount amount NN 42759 3948 30 that that WDT 42759 3948 31 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3948 32 might may MD 42759 3948 33 inherit inherit VB 42759 3948 34 ; ; : 42759 3948 35 for for IN 42759 3948 36 many many JJ 42759 3948 37 of of IN 42759 3948 38 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3948 39 could could MD 42759 3948 40 make make VB 42759 3948 41 a a DT 42759 3948 42 good good JJ 42759 3948 43 use use NN 42759 3948 44 of of IN 42759 3948 45 more more JJR 42759 3948 46 than than IN 42759 3948 47 the the DT 42759 3948 48 amount amount NN 42759 3948 49 that that WDT 42759 3948 50 suffices suffice VBZ 42759 3948 51 for for IN 42759 3948 52 a a DT 42759 3948 53 natural natural JJ 42759 3948 54 person person NN 42759 3948 55 . . . 42759 3949 1 So so RB 42759 3949 2 much much JJ 42759 3949 3 for for IN 42759 3949 4 the the DT 42759 3949 5 welfare welfare NN 42759 3949 6 and and CC 42759 3949 7 rights right NNS 42759 3949 8 of of IN 42759 3949 9 the the DT 42759 3949 10 beneficiaries beneficiary NNS 42759 3949 11 of of IN 42759 3949 12 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 3949 13 . . . 42759 3950 1 The the DT 42759 3950 2 owners owner NNS 42759 3950 3 of of IN 42759 3950 4 estates estate NNS 42759 3950 5 would would MD 42759 3950 6 not not RB 42759 3950 7 be be VB 42759 3950 8 injured injure VBN 42759 3950 9 in in IN 42759 3950 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3950 11 rights right NNS 42759 3950 12 of of IN 42759 3950 13 property property NN 42759 3950 14 by by IN 42759 3950 15 the the DT 42759 3950 16 limitation limitation NN 42759 3950 17 that that IN 42759 3950 18 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3950 19 are be VBP 42759 3950 20 here here RB 42759 3950 21 considering consider VBG 42759 3950 22 . . . 42759 3951 1 In in IN 42759 3951 2 the the DT 42759 3951 3 first first JJ 42759 3951 4 place place NN 42759 3951 5 , , , 42759 3951 6 the the DT 42759 3951 7 number number NN 42759 3951 8 of of IN 42759 3951 9 persons person NNS 42759 3951 10 practically practically RB 42759 3951 11 affected affect VBN 42759 3951 12 by by IN 42759 3951 13 the the DT 42759 3951 14 limitation limitation NN 42759 3951 15 would would MD 42759 3951 16 be be VB 42759 3951 17 extremely extremely RB 42759 3951 18 small small JJ 42759 3951 19 . . . 42759 3952 1 Only only RB 42759 3952 2 an an DT 42759 3952 3 insignificant insignificant JJ 42759 3952 4 fraction fraction NN 42759 3952 5 of of IN 42759 3952 6 property property NN 42759 3952 7 owners owner NNS 42759 3952 8 ever ever RB 42759 3952 9 transmit transmit VBP 42759 3952 10 or or CC 42759 3952 11 expect expect VB 42759 3952 12 to to TO 42759 3952 13 be be VB 42759 3952 14 wealthy wealthy JJ 42759 3952 15 enough enough RB 42759 3952 16 to to TO 42759 3952 17 transmit transmit VB 42759 3952 18 to to IN 42759 3952 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3952 20 families family NNS 42759 3952 21 more more JJR 42759 3952 22 than than IN 42759 3952 23 one one CD 42759 3952 24 million million CD 42759 3952 25 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3952 26 . . . 42759 3953 1 Of of IN 42759 3953 2 these these DT 42759 3953 3 few few JJ 42759 3953 4 a a DT 42759 3953 5 considerable considerable JJ 42759 3953 6 proportion proportion NN 42759 3953 7 would would MD 42759 3953 8 not not RB 42759 3953 9 be be VB 42759 3953 10 deterred deter VBN 42759 3953 11 by by IN 42759 3953 12 the the DT 42759 3953 13 million million CD 42759 3953 14 dollar dollar NN 42759 3953 15 limitation limitation NN 42759 3953 16 from from IN 42759 3953 17 putting put VBG 42759 3953 18 forth forth RP 42759 3953 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3953 20 best good JJS 42759 3953 21 and and CC 42759 3953 22 greatest great JJS 42759 3953 23 efforts effort NNS 42759 3953 24 in in IN 42759 3953 25 a a DT 42759 3953 26 productive productive JJ 42759 3953 27 way way NN 42759 3953 28 . . . 42759 3954 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 3954 2 would would MD 42759 3954 3 continue continue VB 42759 3954 4 to to TO 42759 3954 5 work work VB 42759 3954 6 either either CC 42759 3954 7 from from IN 42759 3954 8 force force NN 42759 3954 9 of of IN 42759 3954 10 habit habit NN 42759 3954 11 and and CC 42759 3954 12 love love NN 42759 3954 13 of of IN 42759 3954 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3954 15 accustomed accustomed JJ 42759 3954 16 tasks task NNS 42759 3954 17 , , , 42759 3954 18 or or CC 42759 3954 19 from from IN 42759 3954 20 a a DT 42759 3954 21 desire desire NN 42759 3954 22 to to TO 42759 3954 23 make make VB 42759 3954 24 large large JJ 42759 3954 25 gifts gift NNS 42759 3954 26 to to IN 42759 3954 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3954 28 heirs heir NNS 42759 3954 29 during during IN 42759 3954 30 life life NN 42759 3954 31 , , , 42759 3954 32 or or CC 42759 3954 33 because because IN 42759 3954 34 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3954 35 wished wish VBD 42759 3954 36 to to TO 42759 3954 37 assist assist VB 42759 3954 38 some some DT 42759 3954 39 benevolent benevolent JJ 42759 3954 40 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 3954 41 . . . 42759 3955 1 The the DT 42759 3955 2 infinitesimally infinitesimally RB 42759 3955 3 small small JJ 42759 3955 4 number number NN 42759 3955 5 whose whose WP$ 42759 3955 6 energies energy NNS 42759 3955 7 would would MD 42759 3955 8 be be VB 42759 3955 9 diminished diminish VBN 42759 3955 10 by by IN 42759 3955 11 the the DT 42759 3955 12 limitation limitation NN 42759 3955 13 could could MD 42759 3955 14 very very RB 42759 3955 15 safely safely RB 42759 3955 16 be be VB 42759 3955 17 treated treat VBN 42759 3955 18 as as IN 42759 3955 19 a a DT 42759 3955 20 socially socially RB 42759 3955 21 negligible negligible JJ 42759 3955 22 element element NN 42759 3955 23 . . . 42759 3956 1 The the DT 42759 3956 2 community community NN 42759 3956 3 would would MD 42759 3956 4 be be VB 42759 3956 5 better well JJR 42759 3956 6 off off RP 42759 3956 7 without without IN 42759 3956 8 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3956 9 . . . 42759 3957 1 The the DT 42759 3957 2 limitation limitation NN 42759 3957 3 of of IN 42759 3957 4 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 3957 5 would would MD 42759 3957 6 , , , 42759 3957 7 indeed indeed RB 42759 3957 8 , , , 42759 3957 9 be be VB 42759 3957 10 liable liable JJ 42759 3957 11 to to IN 42759 3957 12 abuse abuse VB 42759 3957 13 . . . 42759 3958 1 Circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 3958 2 would would MD 42759 3958 3 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 3958 4 arise arise VB 42759 3958 5 in in IN 42759 3958 6 which which WDT 42759 3958 7 the the DT 42759 3958 8 community community NN 42759 3958 9 would would MD 42759 3958 10 be be VB 42759 3958 11 strongly strongly RB 42759 3958 12 tempted tempt VBN 42759 3958 13 to to TO 42759 3958 14 make make VB 42759 3958 15 the the DT 42759 3958 16 maximum maximum JJ 42759 3958 17 inheritable inheritable JJ 42759 3958 18 amount amount NN 42759 3958 19 so so RB 42759 3958 20 low low JJ 42759 3958 21 as as IN 42759 3958 22 to to TO 42759 3958 23 discourage discourage VB 42759 3958 24 the the DT 42759 3958 25 desire desire NN 42759 3958 26 of of IN 42759 3958 27 acquisition acquisition NN 42759 3958 28 , , , 42759 3958 29 and and CC 42759 3958 30 to to TO 42759 3958 31 deprive deprive VB 42759 3958 32 heirs heir NNS 42759 3958 33 of of IN 42759 3958 34 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3958 35 protection protection NN 42759 3958 36 . . . 42759 3959 1 While while IN 42759 3959 2 the the DT 42759 3959 3 bad bad JJ 42759 3959 4 effects effect NNS 42759 3959 5 of of IN 42759 3959 6 such such PDT 42759 3959 7 a a DT 42759 3959 8 limitation limitation NN 42759 3959 9 would would MD 42759 3959 10 not not RB 42759 3959 11 be be VB 42759 3959 12 as as RB 42759 3959 13 great great JJ 42759 3959 14 as as IN 42759 3959 15 those those DT 42759 3959 16 following follow VBG 42759 3959 17 a a DT 42759 3959 18 similar similar JJ 42759 3959 19 abuse abuse NN 42759 3959 20 with with IN 42759 3959 21 regard regard NN 42759 3959 22 to to IN 42759 3959 23 possessions possession NNS 42759 3959 24 , , , 42759 3959 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3959 26 are be VBP 42759 3959 27 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3959 28 grave grave JJ 42759 3959 29 and and CC 42759 3959 30 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3959 31 probable probable JJ 42759 3959 32 to to TO 42759 3959 33 suggest suggest VB 42759 3959 34 that that IN 42759 3959 35 the the DT 42759 3959 36 legal legal JJ 42759 3959 37 restriction restriction NN 42759 3959 38 of of IN 42759 3959 39 bequest bequest NN 42759 3959 40 and and CC 42759 3959 41 succession succession NN 42759 3959 42 should should MD 42759 3959 43 not not RB 42759 3959 44 be be VB 42759 3959 45 considered consider VBN 42759 3959 46 except except IN 42759 3959 47 as as IN 42759 3959 48 a a DT 42759 3959 49 last last JJ 42759 3959 50 resort resort NN 42759 3959 51 , , , 42759 3959 52 and and CC 42759 3959 53 when when WRB 42759 3959 54 the the DT 42759 3959 55 transmission transmission NN 42759 3959 56 of of IN 42759 3959 57 great great JJ 42759 3959 58 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 3959 59 had have VBD 42759 3959 60 become become VBN 42759 3959 61 a a DT 42759 3959 62 great great JJ 42759 3959 63 and and CC 42759 3959 64 certain certain JJ 42759 3959 65 public public JJ 42759 3959 66 evil evil NN 42759 3959 67 . . . 42759 3960 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 3960 2 seems seem VBZ 42759 3960 3 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 3960 4 to to TO 42759 3960 5 conclude conclude VB 42759 3960 6 , , , 42759 3960 7 then then RB 42759 3960 8 , , , 42759 3960 9 that that IN 42759 3960 10 neither neither CC 42759 3960 11 the the DT 42759 3960 12 limitation limitation NN 42759 3960 13 of of IN 42759 3960 14 possessions possession NNS 42759 3960 15 nor nor CC 42759 3960 16 the the DT 42759 3960 17 limitation limitation NN 42759 3960 18 of of IN 42759 3960 19 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 3960 20 is be VBZ 42759 3960 21 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 3960 22 a a DT 42759 3960 23 direct direct JJ 42759 3960 24 violation violation NN 42759 3960 25 of of IN 42759 3960 26 the the DT 42759 3960 27 right right NN 42759 3960 28 of of IN 42759 3960 29 property property NN 42759 3960 30 , , , 42759 3960 31 but but CC 42759 3960 32 that that IN 42759 3960 33 the the DT 42759 3960 34 possible possible JJ 42759 3960 35 and and CC 42759 3960 36 even even RB 42759 3960 37 probable probable JJ 42759 3960 38 evil evil JJ 42759 3960 39 consequences consequence NNS 42759 3960 40 of of IN 42759 3960 41 both both DT 42759 3960 42 are be VBP 42759 3960 43 so so RB 42759 3960 44 grave grave JJ 42759 3960 45 as as IN 42759 3960 46 to to TO 42759 3960 47 make make VB 42759 3960 48 these these DT 42759 3960 49 measures measure NNS 42759 3960 50 of of IN 42759 3960 51 very very RB 42759 3960 52 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 3960 53 benefit benefit NN 42759 3960 54 . . . 42759 3961 1 Whether whether IN 42759 3961 2 the the DT 42759 3961 3 dangers danger NNS 42759 3961 4 in in IN 42759 3961 5 question question NN 42759 3961 6 are be VBP 42759 3961 7 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3961 8 great great JJ 42759 3961 9 to to TO 42759 3961 10 render render VB 42759 3961 11 the the DT 42759 3961 12 adoption adoption NN 42759 3961 13 of of IN 42759 3961 14 either either DT 42759 3961 15 proposal proposal NN 42759 3961 16 morally morally RB 42759 3961 17 wrong wrong JJ 42759 3961 18 , , , 42759 3961 19 is be VBZ 42759 3961 20 a a DT 42759 3961 21 question question NN 42759 3961 22 that that WDT 42759 3961 23 can can MD 42759 3961 24 not not RB 42759 3961 25 be be VB 42759 3961 26 answered answer VBN 42759 3961 27 with with IN 42759 3961 28 any any DT 42759 3961 29 degree degree NN 42759 3961 30 of of IN 42759 3961 31 confidence confidence NN 42759 3961 32 . . . 42759 3962 1 What what WP 42759 3962 2 seems seem VBZ 42759 3962 3 to to TO 42759 3962 4 be be VB 42759 3962 5 fairly fairly RB 42759 3962 6 certain certain JJ 42759 3962 7 is be VBZ 42759 3962 8 that that IN 42759 3962 9 in in IN 42759 3962 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3962 11 present present JJ 42759 3962 12 conditions condition NNS 42759 3962 13 legislation legislation NN 42759 3962 14 of of IN 42759 3962 15 this this DT 42759 3962 16 sort sort NN 42759 3962 17 would would MD 42759 3962 18 be be VB 42759 3962 19 an an DT 42759 3962 20 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 3962 21 and and CC 42759 3962 22 unwise unwise JJ 42759 3962 23 experiment experiment NN 42759 3962 24 . . . 42759 3963 1 _ _ NNP 42759 3963 2 Limitation Limitation NNP 42759 3963 3 Through through IN 42759 3963 4 Progressive Progressive NNP 42759 3963 5 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 3963 6 _ _ NNP 42759 3963 7 Is be VBZ 42759 3963 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3963 9 legitimate legitimate JJ 42759 3963 10 and and CC 42759 3963 11 feasible feasible JJ 42759 3963 12 to to TO 42759 3963 13 reduce reduce VB 42759 3963 14 great great JJ 42759 3963 15 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 3963 16 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 3963 17 , , , 42759 3963 18 through through IN 42759 3963 19 taxation taxation NN 42759 3963 20 ? ? . 42759 3964 1 There there EX 42759 3964 2 is be VBZ 42759 3964 3 certainly certainly RB 42759 3964 4 no no DT 42759 3964 5 objection objection NN 42759 3964 6 to to IN 42759 3964 7 the the DT 42759 3964 8 method method NN 42759 3964 9 on on IN 42759 3964 10 moral moral JJ 42759 3964 11 or or CC 42759 3964 12 social social JJ 42759 3964 13 principles principle NNS 42759 3964 14 . . . 42759 3965 1 As as IN 42759 3965 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3965 3 have have VBP 42759 3965 4 seen see VBN 42759 3965 5 in in IN 42759 3965 6 chapter chapter NN 42759 3965 7 viii viii RB 42759 3965 8 , , , 42759 3965 9 taxes taxis NNS 42759 3965 10 are be VBP 42759 3965 11 not not RB 42759 3965 12 levied levy VBN 42759 3965 13 exclusively exclusively RB 42759 3965 14 for for IN 42759 3965 15 the the DT 42759 3965 16 purpose purpose NN 42759 3965 17 of of IN 42759 3965 18 raising raise VBG 42759 3965 19 revenue revenue NN 42759 3965 20 . . . 42759 3966 1 Some some DT 42759 3966 2 kinds kind NNS 42759 3966 3 of of IN 42759 3966 4 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3966 5 are be VBP 42759 3966 6 designed design VBN 42759 3966 7 to to TO 42759 3966 8 promote promote VB 42759 3966 9 social social JJ 42759 3966 10 rather rather RB 42759 3966 11 than than IN 42759 3966 12 fiscal fiscal JJ 42759 3966 13 ends end NNS 42759 3966 14 . . . 42759 3967 1 Now now RB 42759 3967 2 , , , 42759 3967 3 to to TO 42759 3967 4 prevent prevent VB 42759 3967 5 and and CC 42759 3967 6 diminish diminish VB 42759 3967 7 dangerous dangerous JJ 42759 3967 8 accumulations accumulation NNS 42759 3967 9 of of IN 42759 3967 10 wealth wealth NN 42759 3967 11 is be VBZ 42759 3967 12 a a DT 42759 3967 13 social social JJ 42759 3967 14 end end NN 42759 3967 15 which which WDT 42759 3967 16 is be VBZ 42759 3967 17 at at IN 42759 3967 18 least least JJS 42759 3967 19 as as RB 42759 3967 20 important important JJ 42759 3967 21 as as IN 42759 3967 22 most most JJS 42759 3967 23 of of IN 42759 3967 24 the the DT 42759 3967 25 objects object NNS 42759 3967 26 sought seek VBN 42759 3967 27 in in IN 42759 3967 28 license license NN 42759 3967 29 taxes taxis NNS 42759 3967 30 . . . 42759 3968 1 The the DT 42759 3968 2 propriety propriety NN 42759 3968 3 of of IN 42759 3968 4 attempting attempt VBG 42759 3968 5 to to TO 42759 3968 6 attain attain VB 42759 3968 7 this this DT 42759 3968 8 end end NN 42759 3968 9 by by IN 42759 3968 10 taxation taxation NN 42759 3968 11 is be VBZ 42759 3968 12 , , , 42759 3968 13 therefore therefore RB 42759 3968 14 , , , 42759 3968 15 to to TO 42759 3968 16 be be VB 42759 3968 17 determined determine VBN 42759 3968 18 entirely entirely RB 42759 3968 19 by by IN 42759 3968 20 reference reference NN 42759 3968 21 to to IN 42759 3968 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3968 23 probable probable JJ 42759 3968 24 effectiveness effectiveness NN 42759 3968 25 . . . 42759 3969 1 The the DT 42759 3969 2 precise precise JJ 42759 3969 3 method method NN 42759 3969 4 of of IN 42759 3969 5 taxation taxation NN 42759 3969 6 available available JJ 42759 3969 7 here here RB 42759 3969 8 is be VBZ 42759 3969 9 a a DT 42759 3969 10 progressive progressive JJ 42759 3969 11 tax tax NN 42759 3969 12 on on IN 42759 3969 13 incomes income NNS 42759 3969 14 and and CC 42759 3969 15 inheritances inheritance NNS 42759 3969 16 . . . 42759 3970 1 By by IN 42759 3970 2 a a DT 42759 3970 3 progressive progressive JJ 42759 3970 4 tax tax NN 42759 3970 5 is be VBZ 42759 3970 6 meant mean VBN 42759 3970 7 one one CD 42759 3970 8 whose whose WP$ 42759 3970 9 rate rate NN 42759 3970 10 advances advance NNS 42759 3970 11 in in IN 42759 3970 12 some some DT 42759 3970 13 definite definite JJ 42759 3970 14 proportion proportion NN 42759 3970 15 to to IN 42759 3970 16 the the DT 42759 3970 17 increases increase NNS 42759 3970 18 in in IN 42759 3970 19 the the DT 42759 3970 20 amount amount NN 42759 3970 21 taxed tax VBN 42759 3970 22 . . . 42759 3971 1 For for IN 42759 3971 2 example example NN 42759 3971 3 , , , 42759 3971 4 a a DT 42759 3971 5 bequest bequest NN 42759 3971 6 of of IN 42759 3971 7 100,000 100,000 CD 42759 3971 8 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3971 9 might may MD 42759 3971 10 pay pay VB 42759 3971 11 one one CD 42759 3971 12 per per IN 42759 3971 13 cent cent NN 42759 3971 14 . . . 42759 3972 1 ; ; : 42759 3972 2 200,000 200,000 CD 42759 3972 3 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3972 4 , , , 42759 3972 5 two two CD 42759 3972 6 per per NN 42759 3972 7 cent cent NN 42759 3972 8 . . . 42759 3973 1 ; ; : 42759 3973 2 300,000 300,000 CD 42759 3973 3 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3973 4 , , , 42759 3973 5 three three CD 42759 3973 6 per per IN 42759 3973 7 cent cent NN 42759 3973 8 . . . 42759 3973 9 , , , 42759 3973 10 and and CC 42759 3973 11 so so RB 42759 3973 12 forth forth RB 42759 3973 13 . . . 42759 3974 1 The the DT 42759 3974 2 reasonableness reasonableness NN 42759 3974 3 of of IN 42759 3974 4 the the DT 42759 3974 5 principle principle NN 42759 3974 6 of of IN 42759 3974 7 progression progression NN 42759 3974 8 in in IN 42759 3974 9 taxation taxation NN 42759 3974 10 has have VBZ 42759 3974 11 been be VBN 42759 3974 12 well well RB 42759 3974 13 stated state VBN 42759 3974 14 by by IN 42759 3974 15 Professor Professor NNP 42759 3974 16 Seligman Seligman NNP 42759 3974 17 : : : 42759 3974 18 " " `` 42759 3974 19 All all DT 42759 3974 20 individual individual NN 42759 3974 21 wants want VBZ 42759 3974 22 vary vary VBP 42759 3974 23 in in IN 42759 3974 24 intensity intensity NN 42759 3974 25 , , , 42759 3974 26 from from IN 42759 3974 27 the the DT 42759 3974 28 absolutely absolutely RB 42759 3974 29 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3974 30 wants want NNS 42759 3974 31 of of IN 42759 3974 32 mere mere JJ 42759 3974 33 subsistence subsistence NN 42759 3974 34 to to IN 42759 3974 35 the the DT 42759 3974 36 less less RBR 42759 3974 37 pressing pressing JJ 42759 3974 38 wants want VBZ 42759 3974 39 which which WDT 42759 3974 40 can can MD 42759 3974 41 be be VB 42759 3974 42 satisfied satisfy VBN 42759 3974 43 by by IN 42759 3974 44 pure pure JJ 42759 3974 45 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 3974 46 . . . 42759 3975 1 Taxes taxis NNS 42759 3975 2 , , , 42759 3975 3 in in RB 42759 3975 4 so so RB 42759 3975 5 far far RB 42759 3975 6 as as IN 42759 3975 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 3975 8 rob rob VBD 42759 3975 9 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3975 10 of of IN 42759 3975 11 the the DT 42759 3975 12 means mean NNS 42759 3975 13 of of IN 42759 3975 14 satisfying satisfy VBG 42759 3975 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3975 16 wants want NNS 42759 3975 17 , , , 42759 3975 18 impose impose VB 42759 3975 19 a a DT 42759 3975 20 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 3975 21 upon upon IN 42759 3975 22 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3975 23 . . . 42759 3976 1 But but CC 42759 3976 2 the the DT 42759 3976 3 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 3976 4 involved involve VBN 42759 3976 5 in in IN 42759 3976 6 giving give VBG 42759 3976 7 up up RP 42759 3976 8 a a DT 42759 3976 9 portion portion NN 42759 3976 10 of of IN 42759 3976 11 what what WP 42759 3976 12 enables enable VBZ 42759 3976 13 us -PRON- PRP 42759 3976 14 to to TO 42759 3976 15 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 3976 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3976 17 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3976 18 wants want VBZ 42759 3976 19 is be VBZ 42759 3976 20 very very RB 42759 3976 21 different different JJ 42759 3976 22 from from IN 42759 3976 23 the the DT 42759 3976 24 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 3976 25 involved involve VBN 42759 3976 26 in in IN 42759 3976 27 giving give VBG 42759 3976 28 up up RP 42759 3976 29 what what WP 42759 3976 30 is be VBZ 42759 3976 31 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3976 32 to to TO 42759 3976 33 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 3976 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3976 35 less less RBR 42759 3976 36 urgent urgent JJ 42759 3976 37 wants want NNS 42759 3976 38 . . . 42759 3977 1 If if IN 42759 3977 2 two two CD 42759 3977 3 men man NNS 42759 3977 4 have have VBP 42759 3977 5 incomes income NNS 42759 3977 6 of of IN 42759 3977 7 one one CD 42759 3977 8 thousand thousand CD 42759 3977 9 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3977 10 and and CC 42759 3977 11 one one CD 42759 3977 12 hundred hundred CD 42759 3977 13 thousand thousand CD 42759 3977 14 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3977 15 respectively respectively RB 42759 3977 16 , , , 42759 3977 17 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3977 18 impose impose VBP 42759 3977 19 upon upon IN 42759 3977 20 them -PRON- PRP 42759 3977 21 not not RB 42759 3977 22 equal equal JJ 42759 3977 23 but but CC 42759 3977 24 very very RB 42759 3977 25 unequal unequal JJ 42759 3977 26 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3977 27 if if IN 42759 3977 28 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3977 29 take take VBP 42759 3977 30 away away RB 42759 3977 31 from from IN 42759 3977 32 each each DT 42759 3977 33 the the DT 42759 3977 34 same same JJ 42759 3977 35 proportion proportion NN 42759 3977 36 , , , 42759 3977 37 say say VBP 42759 3977 38 ten ten CD 42759 3977 39 per per IN 42759 3977 40 cent cent NN 42759 3977 41 . . . 42759 3978 1 For for IN 42759 3978 2 the the DT 42759 3978 3 one one CD 42759 3978 4 thousand thousand CD 42759 3978 5 dollar dollar NN 42759 3978 6 individual individual NN 42759 3978 7 now now RB 42759 3978 8 has have VBZ 42759 3978 9 only only RB 42759 3978 10 nine nine CD 42759 3978 11 hundred hundred CD 42759 3978 12 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3978 13 , , , 42759 3978 14 and and CC 42759 3978 15 must must MD 42759 3978 16 deprive deprive VB 42759 3978 17 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 3978 18 and and CC 42759 3978 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3978 20 family family NN 42759 3978 21 of of IN 42759 3978 22 necessaries necessary NNS 42759 3978 23 of of IN 42759 3978 24 life life NN 42759 3978 25 ; ; : 42759 3978 26 the the DT 42759 3978 27 one one CD 42759 3978 28 hundred hundred CD 42759 3978 29 thousand thousand CD 42759 3978 30 dollar dollar NN 42759 3978 31 individual individual NN 42759 3978 32 has have VBZ 42759 3978 33 ninety ninety CD 42759 3978 34 thousand thousand CD 42759 3978 35 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3978 36 , , , 42759 3978 37 and and CC 42759 3978 38 if if IN 42759 3978 39 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3978 40 retrenches retrench VBZ 42759 3978 41 at at RB 42759 3978 42 all all RB 42759 3978 43 , , , 42759 3978 44 which which WDT 42759 3978 45 is be VBZ 42759 3978 46 very very RB 42759 3978 47 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 3978 48 , , , 42759 3978 49 he -PRON- PRP 42759 3978 50 will will MD 42759 3978 51 give give VB 42759 3978 52 up up RP 42759 3978 53 only only RB 42759 3978 54 great great JJ 42759 3978 55 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 3978 56 , , , 42759 3978 57 which which WDT 42759 3978 58 do do VBP 42759 3978 59 not not RB 42759 3978 60 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 3978 61 any any DT 42759 3978 62 pressing press VBG 42759 3978 63 wants want VBZ 42759 3978 64 . . . 42759 3979 1 The the DT 42759 3979 2 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 3979 3 imposed impose VBN 42759 3979 4 on on IN 42759 3979 5 the the DT 42759 3979 6 two two CD 42759 3979 7 individuals individual NNS 42759 3979 8 is be VBZ 42759 3979 9 not not RB 42759 3979 10 equal equal JJ 42759 3979 11 . . . 42759 3980 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 3980 2 are be VBP 42759 3980 3 laying lay VBG 42759 3980 4 on on IN 42759 3980 5 the the DT 42759 3980 6 one one CD 42759 3980 7 thousand thousand CD 42759 3980 8 dollar dollar NN 42759 3980 9 man man NN 42759 3980 10 a a DT 42759 3980 11 far far RB 42759 3980 12 heavier heavy JJR 42759 3980 13 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 3980 14 than than IN 42759 3980 15 on on IN 42759 3980 16 the the DT 42759 3980 17 one one CD 42759 3980 18 hundred hundred CD 42759 3980 19 thousand thousand CD 42759 3980 20 dollar dollar NN 42759 3980 21 man man NN 42759 3980 22 . . . 42759 3981 1 In in IN 42759 3981 2 order order NN 42759 3981 3 to to TO 42759 3981 4 impose impose VB 42759 3981 5 equal equal JJ 42759 3981 6 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3981 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 3981 8 must must MD 42759 3981 9 tax tax VB 42759 3981 10 the the DT 42759 3981 11 richer rich JJR 42759 3981 12 man man NN 42759 3981 13 not not RB 42759 3981 14 only only RB 42759 3981 15 absolutely absolutely RB 42759 3981 16 , , , 42759 3981 17 but but CC 42759 3981 18 relatively relatively RB 42759 3981 19 , , , 42759 3981 20 more more JJR 42759 3981 21 than than IN 42759 3981 22 the the DT 42759 3981 23 poor poor JJ 42759 3981 24 man man NN 42759 3981 25 . . . 42759 3982 1 The the DT 42759 3982 2 taxes taxis NNS 42759 3982 3 must must MD 42759 3982 4 be be VB 42759 3982 5 not not RB 42759 3982 6 proportional proportional JJ 42759 3982 7 , , , 42759 3982 8 but but CC 42759 3982 9 progressive progressive JJ 42759 3982 10 ; ; : 42759 3982 11 the the DT 42759 3982 12 rate rate NN 42759 3982 13 must must MD 42759 3982 14 be be VB 42759 3982 15 lower low JJR 42759 3982 16 in in IN 42759 3982 17 the the DT 42759 3982 18 one one CD 42759 3982 19 case case NN 42759 3982 20 than than IN 42759 3982 21 in in IN 42759 3982 22 the the DT 42759 3982 23 other other JJ 42759 3982 24 . . . 42759 3983 1 " " `` 42759 3983 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 3983 3 198 198 CD 42759 3983 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 3983 5 The the DT 42759 3983 6 principle principle NN 42759 3983 7 of of IN 42759 3983 8 equality equality NN 42759 3983 9 of of IN 42759 3983 10 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3983 11 which which WDT 42759 3983 12 underlies underlie VBZ 42759 3983 13 the the DT 42759 3983 14 progressive progressive JJ 42759 3983 15 theory theory NN 42759 3983 16 does do VBZ 42759 3983 17 not not RB 42759 3983 18 justify justify VB 42759 3983 19 the the DT 42759 3983 20 levelling levelling NN 42759 3983 21 and and CC 42759 3983 22 communistic communistic JJ 42759 3983 23 inferences inference NNS 42759 3983 24 that that WDT 42759 3983 25 have have VBP 42759 3983 26 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 3983 27 been be VBN 42759 3983 28 brought bring VBN 42759 3983 29 against against IN 42759 3983 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3983 31 . . . 42759 3984 1 Equality equality NN 42759 3984 2 of of IN 42759 3984 3 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 3984 4 does do VBZ 42759 3984 5 not not RB 42759 3984 6 mean mean VB 42759 3984 7 equality equality NN 42759 3984 8 of of IN 42759 3984 9 satisfied satisfied JJ 42759 3984 10 , , , 42759 3984 11 or or CC 42759 3984 12 unsatisfied unsatisfied JJ 42759 3984 13 , , , 42759 3984 14 wants want VBZ 42759 3984 15 after after IN 42759 3984 16 the the DT 42759 3984 17 tax tax NN 42759 3984 18 has have VBZ 42759 3984 19 been be VBN 42759 3984 20 collected collect VBN 42759 3984 21 . . . 42759 3985 1 If if IN 42759 3985 2 Brown Brown NNP 42759 3985 3 pays pay VBZ 42759 3985 4 a a DT 42759 3985 5 tax tax NN 42759 3985 6 of of IN 42759 3985 7 one one CD 42759 3985 8 per per IN 42759 3985 9 cent cent NN 42759 3985 10 . . . 42759 3986 1 on on IN 42759 3986 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 3986 3 income income NN 42759 3986 4 of of IN 42759 3986 5 two two CD 42759 3986 6 thousand thousand CD 42759 3986 7 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3986 8 , , , 42759 3986 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3986 10 does do VBZ 42759 3986 11 not not RB 42759 3986 12 follow follow VB 42759 3986 13 that that IN 42759 3986 14 Jones Jones NNP 42759 3986 15 with with IN 42759 3986 16 an an DT 42759 3986 17 income income NN 42759 3986 18 of of IN 42759 3986 19 ten ten CD 42759 3986 20 thousand thousand CD 42759 3986 21 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3986 22 should should MD 42759 3986 23 pay pay VB 42759 3986 24 a a DT 42759 3986 25 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 3986 26 high high JJ 42759 3986 27 rate rate NN 42759 3986 28 to to TO 42759 3986 29 leave leave VB 42759 3986 30 him -PRON- PRP 42759 3986 31 with with IN 42759 3986 32 only only RB 42759 3986 33 the the DT 42759 3986 34 net net JJ 42759 3986 35 amount amount NN 42759 3986 36 remaining remain VBG 42759 3986 37 to to IN 42759 3986 38 Brown Brown NNP 42759 3986 39 ; ; : 42759 3986 40 namely namely RB 42759 3986 41 , , , 42759 3986 42 1980 1980 CD 42759 3986 43 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3986 44 . . . 42759 3987 1 Equality equality NN 42759 3987 2 of of IN 42759 3987 3 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 3987 4 means mean VBZ 42759 3987 5 proportional proportional JJ 42759 3987 6 equality equality NN 42759 3987 7 of of IN 42759 3987 8 burden burden NN 42759 3987 9 , , , 42759 3987 10 not not RB 42759 3987 11 equality equality NN 42759 3987 12 of of IN 42759 3987 13 net net JJ 42759 3987 14 resources resource NNS 42759 3987 15 after after IN 42759 3987 16 the the DT 42759 3987 17 tax tax NN 42759 3987 18 has have VBZ 42759 3987 19 been be VBN 42759 3987 20 deducted deduct VBN 42759 3987 21 . . . 42759 3988 1 The the DT 42759 3988 2 object object NN 42759 3988 3 of of IN 42759 3988 4 the the DT 42759 3988 5 progressive progressive JJ 42759 3988 6 rate rate NN 42759 3988 7 is be VBZ 42759 3988 8 to to TO 42759 3988 9 make make VB 42759 3988 10 relatively relatively RB 42759 3988 11 equal equal JJ 42759 3988 12 the the DT 42759 3988 13 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 3988 14 _ _ NNP 42759 3988 15 caused cause VBN 42759 3988 16 by by IN 42759 3988 17 the the DT 42759 3988 18 tax tax NN 42759 3988 19 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 3988 20 _ _ NNP 42759 3988 21 , , , 42759 3988 22 not not RB 42759 3988 23 to to TO 42759 3988 24 equalise equalise VB 42759 3988 25 the the DT 42759 3988 26 sum sum NN 42759 3988 27 total total NN 42759 3988 28 of of IN 42759 3988 29 burdens burden NNS 42759 3988 30 or or CC 42759 3988 31 unsatisfied unsatisfied JJ 42759 3988 32 wants want VBZ 42759 3988 33 that that WDT 42759 3988 34 exist exist VBP 42759 3988 35 among among IN 42759 3988 36 men man NNS 42759 3988 37 . . . 42759 3989 1 Another another DT 42759 3989 2 objection objection NN 42759 3989 3 to to IN 42759 3989 4 progressive progressive JJ 42759 3989 5 taxation taxation NN 42759 3989 6 is be VBZ 42759 3989 7 that that IN 42759 3989 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3989 9 readily readily RB 42759 3989 10 lends lend VBZ 42759 3989 11 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 3989 12 to to IN 42759 3989 13 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 3989 14 of of IN 42759 3989 15 the the DT 42759 3989 16 largest large JJS 42759 3989 17 incomes income NNS 42759 3989 18 . . . 42759 3990 1 All all DT 42759 3990 2 that that WDT 42759 3990 3 is be VBZ 42759 3990 4 necessary necessary JJ 42759 3990 5 to to TO 42759 3990 6 produce produce VB 42759 3990 7 this this DT 42759 3990 8 result result NN 42759 3990 9 is be VBZ 42759 3990 10 to to TO 42759 3990 11 increase increase VB 42759 3990 12 the the DT 42759 3990 13 rate rate NN 42759 3990 14 with with IN 42759 3990 15 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 3990 16 rapidity rapidity NN 42759 3990 17 . . . 42759 3991 1 This this DT 42759 3991 2 could could MD 42759 3991 3 be be VB 42759 3991 4 accomplished accomplish VBN 42759 3991 5 either either CC 42759 3991 6 by by IN 42759 3991 7 large large JJ 42759 3991 8 steps step NNS 42759 3991 9 in in IN 42759 3991 10 the the DT 42759 3991 11 rate rate NN 42759 3991 12 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 3991 13 or or CC 42759 3991 14 by by IN 42759 3991 15 small small JJ 42759 3991 16 steps step NNS 42759 3991 17 in in IN 42759 3991 18 the the DT 42759 3991 19 income income NN 42759 3991 20 increases increase NNS 42759 3991 21 which which WDT 42759 3991 22 formed form VBD 42759 3991 23 the the DT 42759 3991 24 basis basis NN 42759 3991 25 of of IN 42759 3991 26 the the DT 42759 3991 27 advances advance NNS 42759 3991 28 in in IN 42759 3991 29 the the DT 42759 3991 30 rate rate NN 42759 3991 31 . . . 42759 3992 1 For for IN 42759 3992 2 example example NN 42759 3992 3 , , , 42759 3992 4 if if IN 42759 3992 5 the the DT 42759 3992 6 Federal Federal NNP 42759 3992 7 income income NN 42759 3992 8 tax tax NN 42759 3992 9 , , , 42759 3992 10 which which WDT 42759 3992 11 at at IN 42759 3992 12 present present JJ 42759 3992 13 levies levy NNS 42759 3992 14 two two CD 42759 3992 15 per per IN 42759 3992 16 cent cent NN 42759 3992 17 . . . 42759 3993 1 on on IN 42759 3993 2 incomes income NNS 42759 3993 3 of of IN 42759 3993 4 more more JJR 42759 3993 5 than than IN 42759 3993 6 three three CD 42759 3993 7 thousand thousand CD 42759 3993 8 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3993 9 , , , 42759 3993 10 and and CC 42759 3993 11 three three CD 42759 3993 12 per per IN 42759 3993 13 cent cent NN 42759 3993 14 . . . 42759 3994 1 on on IN 42759 3994 2 incomes income NNS 42759 3994 3 of of IN 42759 3994 4 over over IN 42759 3994 5 twenty twenty CD 42759 3994 6 thousand thousand CD 42759 3994 7 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3994 8 , , , 42759 3994 9 should should MD 42759 3994 10 thereafter thereafter RB 42759 3994 11 progress progress VB 42759 3994 12 geometrically geometrically RB 42759 3994 13 with with IN 42759 3994 14 every every DT 42759 3994 15 geometrically geometrically RB 42759 3994 16 progressive progressive JJ 42759 3994 17 increment increment NN 42759 3994 18 of of IN 42759 3994 19 income income NN 42759 3994 20 , , , 42759 3994 21 the the DT 42759 3994 22 rate rate NN 42759 3994 23 on on IN 42759 3994 24 incomes income NNS 42759 3994 25 above above IN 42759 3994 26 $ $ $ 42759 3994 27 640,000 640,000 CD 42759 3994 28 would would MD 42759 3994 29 be be VB 42759 3994 30 96 96 CD 42759 3994 31 per per IN 42759 3994 32 cent cent NN 42759 3994 33 . . . 42759 3994 34 ! ! . 42759 3995 1 Or or CC 42759 3995 2 if if IN 42759 3995 3 the the DT 42759 3995 4 rate rate NN 42759 3995 5 should should MD 42759 3995 6 progress progress VB 42759 3995 7 arithmetically arithmetically RB 42759 3995 8 with with IN 42759 3995 9 every every DT 42759 3995 10 ten ten CD 42759 3995 11 thousand thousand CD 42759 3995 12 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3995 13 of of IN 42759 3995 14 increase increase NN 42759 3995 15 above above IN 42759 3995 16 twenty twenty CD 42759 3995 17 thousand thousand CD 42759 3995 18 dollars dollar NNS 42759 3995 19 , , , 42759 3995 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3995 21 would would MD 42759 3995 22 be be VB 42759 3995 23 100 100 CD 42759 3995 24 per per IN 42759 3995 25 cent cent NN 42759 3995 26 . . . 42759 3996 1 on on IN 42759 3996 2 incomes income NNS 42759 3996 3 of of IN 42759 3996 4 over over IN 42759 3996 5 $ $ $ 42759 3996 6 990,000 990,000 CD 42759 3996 7 ! ! . 42759 3997 1 To to IN 42759 3997 2 this this DT 42759 3997 3 objection objection NN 42759 3997 4 there there EX 42759 3997 5 are be VBP 42759 3997 6 two two CD 42759 3997 7 valid valid JJ 42759 3997 8 answers answer NNS 42759 3997 9 . . . 42759 3998 1 Even even RB 42759 3998 2 if if IN 42759 3998 3 the the DT 42759 3998 4 rate rate NN 42759 3998 5 should should MD 42759 3998 6 ultimately ultimately RB 42759 3998 7 reach reach VB 42759 3998 8 one one CD 42759 3998 9 hundred hundred CD 42759 3998 10 per per IN 42759 3998 11 cent cent NN 42759 3998 12 . . . 42759 3999 1 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3999 2 need nee MD 42759 3999 3 not not RB 42759 3999 4 , , , 42759 3999 5 and and CC 42759 3999 6 on on IN 42759 3999 7 progressive progressive JJ 42759 3999 8 principles principle NNS 42759 3999 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 3999 10 should should MD 42759 3999 11 not not RB 42759 3999 12 , , , 42759 3999 13 effect effect VB 42759 3999 14 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 3999 15 of of IN 42759 3999 16 an an DT 42759 3999 17 entire entire JJ 42759 3999 18 income income NN 42759 3999 19 . . . 42759 4000 1 The the DT 42759 4000 2 progressive progressive JJ 42759 4000 3 theory theory NN 42759 4000 4 is be VBZ 42759 4000 5 satisfied satisfied JJ 42759 4000 6 when when WRB 42759 4000 7 the the DT 42759 4000 8 successive successive JJ 42759 4000 9 rates rate NNS 42759 4000 10 of of IN 42759 4000 11 the the DT 42759 4000 12 tax tax NN 42759 4000 13 apply apply NN 42759 4000 14 to to IN 42759 4000 15 successive successive JJ 42759 4000 16 increments increment NNS 42759 4000 17 of of IN 42759 4000 18 income income NN 42759 4000 19 , , , 42759 4000 20 instead instead RB 42759 4000 21 of of IN 42759 4000 22 to to IN 42759 4000 23 the the DT 42759 4000 24 entire entire JJ 42759 4000 25 income income NN 42759 4000 26 . . . 42759 4001 1 For for IN 42759 4001 2 example example NN 42759 4001 3 , , , 42759 4001 4 the the DT 42759 4001 5 rate rate NN 42759 4001 6 might may MD 42759 4001 7 begin begin VB 42759 4001 8 at at IN 42759 4001 9 one one CD 42759 4001 10 per per IN 42759 4001 11 cent cent NN 42759 4001 12 . . . 42759 4002 1 on on IN 42759 4002 2 incomes income NNS 42759 4002 3 of of IN 42759 4002 4 one one CD 42759 4002 5 thousand thousand CD 42759 4002 6 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4002 7 , , , 42759 4002 8 and and CC 42759 4002 9 increase increase VB 42759 4002 10 by by IN 42759 4002 11 one one CD 42759 4002 12 per per IN 42759 4002 13 cent cent NN 42759 4002 14 . . . 42759 4003 1 with with IN 42759 4003 2 every every DT 42759 4003 3 additional additional JJ 42759 4003 4 thousand thousand CD 42759 4003 5 , , , 42759 4003 6 and and CC 42759 4003 7 yet yet RB 42759 4003 8 leave leave VB 42759 4003 9 a a DT 42759 4003 10 very very RB 42759 4003 11 large large JJ 42759 4003 12 part part NN 42759 4003 13 of of IN 42759 4003 14 the the DT 42759 4003 15 income income NN 42759 4003 16 in in IN 42759 4003 17 the the DT 42759 4003 18 hands hand NNS 42759 4003 19 of of IN 42759 4003 20 the the DT 42759 4003 21 receiver receiver NN 42759 4003 22 . . . 42759 4004 1 Each each DT 42759 4004 2 one one CD 42759 4004 3 thousand thousand CD 42759 4004 4 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4004 5 would would MD 42759 4004 6 be be VB 42759 4004 7 taxed tax VBN 42759 4004 8 at at IN 42759 4004 9 a a DT 42759 4004 10 different different JJ 42759 4004 11 rate rate NN 42759 4004 12 , , , 42759 4004 13 the the DT 42759 4004 14 first first JJ 42759 4004 15 at at IN 42759 4004 16 one one CD 42759 4004 17 per per IN 42759 4004 18 cent cent NN 42759 4004 19 . . . 42759 4004 20 , , , 42759 4004 21 the the DT 42759 4004 22 fiftieth fiftieth NNP 42759 4004 23 at at IN 42759 4004 24 fifty fifty CD 42759 4004 25 per per IN 42759 4004 26 cent cent NN 42759 4004 27 . . . 42759 4004 28 , , , 42759 4004 29 and and CC 42759 4004 30 the the DT 42759 4004 31 last last JJ 42759 4004 32 at at IN 42759 4004 33 one one CD 42759 4004 34 hundred hundred CD 42759 4004 35 per per IN 42759 4004 36 cent cent NN 42759 4004 37 . . . 42759 4005 1 If if IN 42759 4005 2 the the DT 42759 4005 3 hundred hundred CD 42759 4005 4 per per IN 42759 4005 5 cent cent NN 42759 4005 6 . . . 42759 4006 1 rate rate NN 42759 4006 2 were be VBD 42759 4006 3 applied apply VBN 42759 4006 4 to to IN 42759 4006 5 the the DT 42759 4006 6 whole whole NN 42759 4006 7 of of IN 42759 4006 8 the the DT 42759 4006 9 higher high JJR 42759 4006 10 incomes income NNS 42759 4006 11 , , , 42759 4006 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4006 13 would would MD 42759 4006 14 be be VB 42759 4006 15 a a DT 42759 4006 16 direct direct JJ 42759 4006 17 violation violation NN 42759 4006 18 of of IN 42759 4006 19 the the DT 42759 4006 20 principle principle NN 42759 4006 21 of of IN 42759 4006 22 equality equality NN 42759 4006 23 of of IN 42759 4006 24 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 4006 25 . . . 42759 4007 1 In in IN 42759 4007 2 the the DT 42759 4007 3 second second JJ 42759 4007 4 place place NN 42759 4007 5 , , , 42759 4007 6 the the DT 42759 4007 7 progressive progressive JJ 42759 4007 8 theory theory NN 42759 4007 9 forbids forbid NNS 42759 4007 10 rather rather RB 42759 4007 11 than than IN 42759 4007 12 requires require VBZ 42759 4007 13 the the DT 42759 4007 14 rate rate NN 42759 4007 15 to to TO 42759 4007 16 go go VB 42759 4007 17 as as RB 42759 4007 18 high high JJ 42759 4007 19 as as IN 42759 4007 20 one one CD 42759 4007 21 hundred hundred CD 42759 4007 22 per per IN 42759 4007 23 cent cent NN 42759 4007 24 . . . 42759 4008 1 While while IN 42759 4008 2 the the DT 42759 4008 3 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 4008 4 imposed impose VBN 42759 4008 5 by by IN 42759 4008 6 a a DT 42759 4008 7 given give VBN 42759 4008 8 rate rate NN 42759 4008 9 are be VBP 42759 4008 10 greater great JJR 42759 4008 11 in in IN 42759 4008 12 the the DT 42759 4008 13 case case NN 42759 4008 14 of of IN 42759 4008 15 small small JJ 42759 4008 16 than than IN 42759 4008 17 of of IN 42759 4008 18 large large JJ 42759 4008 19 properties property NNS 42759 4008 20 , , , 42759 4008 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4008 22 become become VBP 42759 4008 23 approximately approximately RB 42759 4008 24 equal equal JJ 42759 4008 25 as as IN 42759 4008 26 between between IN 42759 4008 27 all all DT 42759 4008 28 properties property NNS 42759 4008 29 above above IN 42759 4008 30 a a DT 42759 4008 31 certain certain JJ 42759 4008 32 high high JJ 42759 4008 33 level level NN 42759 4008 34 . . . 42759 4009 1 After after IN 42759 4009 2 this this DT 42759 4009 3 level level NN 42759 4009 4 is be VBZ 42759 4009 5 reached reach VBN 42759 4009 6 , , , 42759 4009 7 additional additional JJ 42759 4009 8 increments increment NNS 42759 4009 9 of of IN 42759 4009 10 wealth wealth NN 42759 4009 11 will will MD 42759 4009 12 all all DT 42759 4009 13 be be VB 42759 4009 14 expended expend VBN 42759 4009 15 either either CC 42759 4009 16 for for IN 42759 4009 17 extreme extreme JJ 42759 4009 18 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 4009 19 , , , 42759 4009 20 or or CC 42759 4009 21 converted convert VBN 42759 4009 22 into into IN 42759 4009 23 new new JJ 42759 4009 24 investments investment NNS 42759 4009 25 . . . 42759 4010 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 4010 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4010 3 will will MD 42759 4010 4 supply supply VB 42759 4010 5 wants want VBZ 42759 4010 6 of of IN 42759 4010 7 approximately approximately RB 42759 4010 8 equal equal JJ 42759 4010 9 intensity intensity NN 42759 4010 10 . . . 42759 4011 1 For for IN 42759 4011 2 example example NN 42759 4011 3 , , , 42759 4011 4 the the DT 42759 4011 5 wants want VBZ 42759 4011 6 dependent dependent JJ 42759 4011 7 upon upon IN 42759 4011 8 a a DT 42759 4011 9 surplus surplus NN 42759 4011 10 of of IN 42759 4011 11 25,000 25,000 CD 42759 4011 12 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4011 13 in in IN 42759 4011 14 excess excess NN 42759 4011 15 of of IN 42759 4011 16 an an DT 42759 4011 17 income income NN 42759 4011 18 of of IN 42759 4011 19 100,000 100,000 CD 42759 4011 20 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4011 21 , , , 42759 4011 22 and and CC 42759 4011 23 the the DT 42759 4011 24 wants want VBZ 42759 4011 25 dependent dependent JJ 42759 4011 26 upon upon IN 42759 4011 27 a a DT 42759 4011 28 surplus surplus NN 42759 4011 29 of of IN 42759 4011 30 75,000 75,000 CD 42759 4011 31 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4011 32 above above IN 42759 4011 33 the the DT 42759 4011 34 same same JJ 42759 4011 35 level level NN 42759 4011 36 do do VBP 42759 4011 37 not not RB 42759 4011 38 differ differ VB 42759 4011 39 materially materially RB 42759 4011 40 in in IN 42759 4011 41 strength strength NN 42759 4011 42 . . . 42759 4012 1 To to TO 42759 4012 2 diminish diminish VB 42759 4012 3 these these DT 42759 4012 4 surpluses surplus NNS 42759 4012 5 by by IN 42759 4012 6 the the DT 42759 4012 7 same same JJ 42759 4012 8 per per IN 42759 4012 9 cent cent NN 42759 4012 10 . . . 42759 4012 11 , , , 42759 4012 12 say say UH 42759 4012 13 , , , 42759 4012 14 ten ten CD 42759 4012 15 , , , 42759 4012 16 would would MD 42759 4012 17 impose impose VB 42759 4012 18 proportionally proportionally RB 42759 4012 19 equal equal JJ 42759 4012 20 burdens burden NNS 42759 4012 21 . . . 42759 4013 1 Hence hence RB 42759 4013 2 the the DT 42759 4013 3 rate rate NN 42759 4013 4 of of IN 42759 4013 5 progression progression NN 42759 4013 6 should should MD 42759 4013 7 be be VB 42759 4013 8 degressive degressive JJ 42759 4013 9 ; ; : 42759 4013 10 that that RB 42759 4013 11 is is RB 42759 4013 12 , , , 42759 4013 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4013 14 should should MD 42759 4013 15 increase increase VB 42759 4013 16 at at IN 42759 4013 17 a a DT 42759 4013 18 constant constant JJ 42759 4013 19 pace pace NN 42759 4013 20 until until IN 42759 4013 21 a a DT 42759 4013 22 certain certain JJ 42759 4013 23 high high JJ 42759 4013 24 level level NN 42759 4013 25 of of IN 42759 4013 26 income income NN 42759 4013 27 is be VBZ 42759 4013 28 reached reach VBN 42759 4013 29 , , , 42759 4013 30 then then RB 42759 4013 31 increase increase VB 42759 4013 32 at at IN 42759 4013 33 a a DT 42759 4013 34 steadily steadily RB 42759 4013 35 diminishing diminish VBG 42759 4013 36 pace pace NN 42759 4013 37 , , , 42759 4013 38 and and CC 42759 4013 39 finally finally RB 42759 4013 40 become become VB 42759 4013 41 uniform uniform NN 42759 4013 42 on on IN 42759 4013 43 the the DT 42759 4013 44 very very RB 42759 4013 45 highest high JJS 42759 4013 46 incomes income NNS 42759 4013 47 . . . 42759 4014 1 For for IN 42759 4014 2 example example NN 42759 4014 3 ; ; : 42759 4014 4 if if IN 42759 4014 5 the the DT 42759 4014 6 rate rate NN 42759 4014 7 increased increase VBD 42759 4014 8 one one CD 42759 4014 9 per per IN 42759 4014 10 cent cent NN 42759 4014 11 . . . 42759 4015 1 with with IN 42759 4015 2 every every DT 42759 4015 3 additional additional JJ 42759 4015 4 five five CD 42759 4015 5 thousand thousand CD 42759 4015 6 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4015 7 , , , 42759 4015 8 reaching reach VBG 42759 4015 9 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 4015 10 per per IN 42759 4015 11 cent cent NN 42759 4015 12 . . . 42759 4016 1 on on IN 42759 4016 2 incomes income NNS 42759 4016 3 of of IN 42759 4016 4 seventy seventy CD 42759 4016 5 - - HYPH 42759 4016 6 five five CD 42759 4016 7 thousand thousand CD 42759 4016 8 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4016 9 , , , 42759 4016 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4016 11 should should MD 42759 4016 12 be be VB 42759 4016 13 on on IN 42759 4016 14 eighty eighty CD 42759 4016 15 thousand thousand CD 42759 4016 16 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4016 17 , , , 42759 4016 18 not not RB 42759 4016 19 sixteen sixteen CD 42759 4016 20 but but CC 42759 4016 21 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 4016 22 and and CC 42759 4016 23 one one CD 42759 4016 24 - - HYPH 42759 4016 25 half half NN 42759 4016 26 per per IN 42759 4016 27 cent cent NN 42759 4016 28 . . . 42759 4017 1 On on IN 42759 4017 2 85,000 85,000 CD 42759 4017 3 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4017 4 the the DT 42759 4017 5 rate rate NN 42759 4017 6 should should MD 42759 4017 7 be be VB 42759 4017 8 15 15 CD 42759 4017 9 - - HYPH 42759 4017 10 3/4 3/4 CD 42759 4017 11 per per IN 42759 4017 12 cent cent NN 42759 4017 13 . . . 42759 4018 1 ; ; : 42759 4018 2 on on IN 42759 4018 3 90,000 90,000 CD 42759 4018 4 , , , 42759 4018 5 15 15 CD 42759 4018 6 - - SYM 42759 4018 7 7/8 7/8 CD 42759 4018 8 per per NN 42759 4018 9 cent cent NN 42759 4018 10 . . . 42759 4019 1 ; ; : 42759 4019 2 on on IN 42759 4019 3 95,000 95,000 CD 42759 4019 4 , , , 42759 4019 5 15 15 CD 42759 4019 6 - - SYM 42759 4019 7 15/16 15/16 CD 42759 4019 8 per per IN 42759 4019 9 cent cent NN 42759 4019 10 . . . 42759 4020 1 ; ; : 42759 4020 2 and and CC 42759 4020 3 on on IN 42759 4020 4 all all DT 42759 4020 5 sums sum NNS 42759 4020 6 of of IN 42759 4020 7 100,000 100,000 CD 42759 4020 8 and and CC 42759 4020 9 over over RB 42759 4020 10 , , , 42759 4020 11 16 16 CD 42759 4020 12 per per NN 42759 4020 13 cent cent NN 42759 4020 14 . . . 42759 4021 1 The the DT 42759 4021 2 point point NN 42759 4021 3 at at IN 42759 4021 4 which which WDT 42759 4021 5 the the DT 42759 4021 6 increments increment NNS 42759 4021 7 in in IN 42759 4021 8 the the DT 42759 4021 9 rate rate NN 42759 4021 10 began begin VBD 42759 4021 11 to to TO 42759 4021 12 decline decline VB 42759 4021 13 would would MD 42759 4021 14 be be VB 42759 4021 15 that that IN 42759 4021 16 at at IN 42759 4021 17 which which WDT 42759 4021 18 differences difference NNS 42759 4021 19 in in IN 42759 4021 20 wants want VBZ 42759 4021 21 began begin VBD 42759 4021 22 to to TO 42759 4021 23 diminish diminish VB 42759 4021 24 , , , 42759 4021 25 and and CC 42759 4021 26 the the DT 42759 4021 27 point point NN 42759 4021 28 at at IN 42759 4021 29 which which WDT 42759 4021 30 the the DT 42759 4021 31 rate rate NN 42759 4021 32 became become VBD 42759 4021 33 stationary stationary JJ 42759 4021 34 would would MD 42759 4021 35 be be VB 42759 4021 36 that that IN 42759 4021 37 at at IN 42759 4021 38 which which WDT 42759 4021 39 wants want VBZ 42759 4021 40 fell fall VBD 42759 4021 41 to to IN 42759 4021 42 the the DT 42759 4021 43 same same JJ 42759 4021 44 level level NN 42759 4021 45 of of IN 42759 4021 46 intensity intensity NN 42759 4021 47 . . . 42759 4022 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4022 2 The the DT 42759 4022 3 Proper Proper NNP 42759 4022 4 Rate Rate NNP 42759 4022 5 of of IN 42759 4022 6 Income Income NNP 42759 4022 7 and and CC 42759 4022 8 Inheritance Inheritance NNP 42759 4022 9 Taxes Taxes NNPS 42759 4022 10 _ _ XX 42759 4022 11 While while IN 42759 4022 12 the the DT 42759 4022 13 principle principle NN 42759 4022 14 of of IN 42759 4022 15 equality equality NN 42759 4022 16 of of IN 42759 4022 17 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 4022 18 forbids forbid NNS 42759 4022 19 a a DT 42759 4022 20 rate rate NN 42759 4022 21 of of IN 42759 4022 22 tax tax NN 42759 4022 23 that that WDT 42759 4022 24 would would MD 42759 4022 25 reach reach VB 42759 4022 26 or or CC 42759 4022 27 approximate approximate JJ 42759 4022 28 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 4022 29 , , , 42759 4022 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4022 31 gives give VBZ 42759 4022 32 no no DT 42759 4022 33 definite definite JJ 42759 4022 34 indication indication NN 42759 4022 35 of of IN 42759 4022 36 the the DT 42759 4022 37 proper proper JJ 42759 4022 38 scale scale NN 42759 4022 39 of of IN 42759 4022 40 progression progression NN 42759 4022 41 , , , 42759 4022 42 or or CC 42759 4022 43 of of IN 42759 4022 44 the the DT 42759 4022 45 maximum maximum JJ 42759 4022 46 limit limit NN 42759 4022 47 that that IN 42759 4022 48 justice justice NN 42759 4022 49 would would MD 42759 4022 50 set set VB 42759 4022 51 to to IN 42759 4022 52 the the DT 42759 4022 53 rate rate NN 42759 4022 54 . . . 42759 4023 1 Under under IN 42759 4023 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4023 3 Federal Federal NNP 42759 4023 4 law law NN 42759 4023 5 the the DT 42759 4023 6 highest high JJS 42759 4023 7 rate rate NN 42759 4023 8 on on IN 42759 4023 9 incomes income NNS 42759 4023 10 is be VBZ 42759 4023 11 now now RB 42759 4023 12 13 13 CD 42759 4023 13 per per NN 42759 4023 14 cent cent NN 42759 4023 15 . . . 42759 4024 1 ; ; : 42759 4024 2 under under IN 42759 4024 3 the the DT 42759 4024 4 Wisconsin Wisconsin NNP 42759 4024 5 law law NN 42759 4024 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4024 7 is be VBZ 42759 4024 8 6 6 CD 42759 4024 9 per per NN 42759 4024 10 cent cent NN 42759 4024 11 . . . 42759 4025 1 ; ; : 42759 4025 2 under under IN 42759 4025 3 the the DT 42759 4025 4 law law NN 42759 4025 5 of of IN 42759 4025 6 Prussia Prussia NNP 42759 4025 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4025 8 is be VBZ 42759 4025 9 4 4 CD 42759 4025 10 per per NN 42759 4025 11 cent cent NN 42759 4025 12 . . . 42759 4026 1 ; ; : 42759 4026 2 and and CC 42759 4026 3 under under IN 42759 4026 4 the the DT 42759 4026 5 British british JJ 42759 4026 6 act act NN 42759 4026 7 of of IN 42759 4026 8 1909 1909 CD 42759 4026 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4026 10 is be VBZ 42759 4026 11 about about RB 42759 4026 12 8 8 CD 42759 4026 13 - - SYM 42759 4026 14 1/2 1/2 CD 42759 4026 15 per per IN 42759 4026 16 cent cent NN 42759 4026 17 . . . 42759 4027 1 Evidently evidently RB 42759 4027 2 a a DT 42759 4027 3 much much RB 42759 4027 4 higher high JJR 42759 4027 5 rate rate NN 42759 4027 6 than than IN 42759 4027 7 any any DT 42759 4027 8 of of IN 42759 4027 9 these these DT 42759 4027 10 would would MD 42759 4027 11 be be VB 42759 4027 12 required require VBN 42759 4027 13 to to TO 42759 4027 14 make make VB 42759 4027 15 any any DT 42759 4027 16 impression impression NN 42759 4027 17 upon upon IN 42759 4027 18 swollen swollen JJ 42759 4027 19 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 4027 20 . . . 42759 4028 1 The the DT 42759 4028 2 British british JJ 42759 4028 3 government government NN 42759 4028 4 recently recently RB 42759 4028 5 ( ( -LRB- 42759 4028 6 September September NNP 42759 4028 7 , , , 42759 4028 8 1915 1915 CD 42759 4028 9 ) ) -RRB- 42759 4028 10 made make VBD 42759 4028 11 the the DT 42759 4028 12 maximum maximum JJ 42759 4028 13 rate rate NN 42759 4028 14 about about RB 42759 4028 15 33 33 CD 42759 4028 16 - - SYM 42759 4028 17 1/3 1/3 CD 42759 4028 18 per per NN 42759 4028 19 cent cent NN 42759 4028 20 . . . 42759 4029 1 To to TO 42759 4029 2 be be VB 42759 4029 3 sure sure JJ 42759 4029 4 , , , 42759 4029 5 this this DT 42759 4029 6 is be VBZ 42759 4029 7 a a DT 42759 4029 8 war war NN 42759 4029 9 measure measure NN 42759 4029 10 which which WDT 42759 4029 11 probably probably RB 42759 4029 12 will will MD 42759 4029 13 not not RB 42759 4029 14 continue continue VB 42759 4029 15 after after IN 42759 4029 16 the the DT 42759 4029 17 restoration restoration NN 42759 4029 18 of of IN 42759 4029 19 peace peace NN 42759 4029 20 . . . 42759 4030 1 However however RB 42759 4030 2 , , , 42759 4030 3 if if IN 42759 4030 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4030 5 were be VBD 42759 4030 6 made make VBN 42759 4030 7 permanent permanent JJ 42759 4030 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4030 9 could could MD 42759 4030 10 not not RB 42759 4030 11 be be VB 42759 4030 12 proved prove VBN 42759 4030 13 to to TO 42759 4030 14 be be VB 42759 4030 15 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4030 16 , , , 42759 4030 17 provided provide VBN 42759 4030 18 that that IN 42759 4030 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4030 20 were be VBD 42759 4030 21 applied apply VBN 42759 4030 22 to to IN 42759 4030 23 the the DT 42759 4030 24 _ _ NNP 42759 4030 25 increments increment NNS 42759 4030 26 _ _ NNP 42759 4030 27 of of IN 42759 4030 28 income income NN 42759 4030 29 above above IN 42759 4030 30 a a DT 42759 4030 31 certain certain JJ 42759 4030 32 high high JJ 42759 4030 33 limit limit NN 42759 4030 34 , , , 42759 4030 35 but but CC 42759 4030 36 not not RB 42759 4030 37 to to IN 42759 4030 38 these these DT 42759 4030 39 incomes income NNS 42759 4030 40 in in IN 42759 4030 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4030 42 entirety entirety NN 42759 4030 43 . . . 42759 4031 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4031 2 present present JJ 42759 4031 3 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 4031 4 taxes taxis NNS 42759 4031 5 are be VBP 42759 4031 6 very very RB 42759 4031 7 low low JJ 42759 4031 8 , , , 42759 4031 9 averaging average VBG 42759 4031 10 less less JJR 42759 4031 11 than than IN 42759 4031 12 3 3 CD 42759 4031 13 per per NN 42759 4031 14 cent cent NN 42759 4031 15 . . . 42759 4032 1 throughout throughout IN 42759 4032 2 the the DT 42759 4032 3 United United NNP 42759 4032 4 States States NNP 42759 4032 5 . . . 42759 4033 1 Probably probably RB 42759 4033 2 the the DT 42759 4033 3 highest high JJS 42759 4033 4 rate rate NN 42759 4033 5 is be VBZ 42759 4033 6 to to TO 42759 4033 7 be be VB 42759 4033 8 found find VBN 42759 4033 9 in in IN 42759 4033 10 Wisconsin Wisconsin NNP 42759 4033 11 , , , 42759 4033 12 where where WRB 42759 4033 13 bequests bequest NNS 42759 4033 14 to to IN 42759 4033 15 non non JJ 42759 4033 16 relatives relative NNS 42759 4033 17 in in IN 42759 4033 18 excess excess NN 42759 4033 19 of of IN 42759 4033 20 half half PDT 42759 4033 21 a a DT 42759 4033 22 million million CD 42759 4033 23 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4033 24 are be VBP 42759 4033 25 subject subject JJ 42759 4033 26 to to IN 42759 4033 27 a a DT 42759 4033 28 tax tax NN 42759 4033 29 of of IN 42759 4033 30 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 4033 31 per per IN 42759 4033 32 cent cent NN 42759 4033 33 . . . 42759 4034 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4034 2 is be VBZ 42759 4034 3 clear clear JJ 42759 4034 4 that that IN 42759 4034 5 all all PDT 42759 4034 6 the the DT 42759 4034 7 existing exist VBG 42759 4034 8 rates rate NNS 42759 4034 9 could could MD 42759 4034 10 be be VB 42759 4034 11 raised raise VBN 42759 4034 12 very very RB 42759 4034 13 considerably considerably RB 42759 4034 14 without without IN 42759 4034 15 causing cause VBG 42759 4034 16 a a DT 42759 4034 17 violation violation NN 42759 4034 18 of of IN 42759 4034 19 justice justice NN 42759 4034 20 . . . 42759 4035 1 Some some DT 42759 4035 2 years year NNS 42759 4035 3 ago ago RB 42759 4035 4 Andrew Andrew NNP 42759 4035 5 Carnegie Carnegie NNP 42759 4035 6 recommended recommend VBD 42759 4035 7 a a DT 42759 4035 8 tax tax NN 42759 4035 9 of of IN 42759 4035 10 fifty fifty CD 42759 4035 11 per per IN 42759 4035 12 cent cent NN 42759 4035 13 . . . 42759 4036 1 on on IN 42759 4036 2 estates estate NNS 42759 4036 3 amounting amount VBG 42759 4036 4 to to IN 42759 4036 5 more more JJR 42759 4036 6 than than IN 42759 4036 7 one one CD 42759 4036 8 million million CD 42759 4036 9 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4036 10 . . . 42759 4037 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4037 2 199 199 CD 42759 4037 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4037 4 No no DT 42759 4037 5 country country NN 42759 4037 6 has have VBZ 42759 4037 7 yet yet RB 42759 4037 8 reached reach VBN 42759 4037 9 this this DT 42759 4037 10 high high JJ 42759 4037 11 level level NN 42759 4037 12 of of IN 42759 4037 13 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 4037 14 taxes taxis NNS 42759 4037 15 . . . 42759 4038 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 4038 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4038 3 can can MD 42759 4038 4 not not RB 42759 4038 5 certainly certainly RB 42759 4038 6 stigmatise stigmatise VB 42759 4038 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4038 8 as as IN 42759 4038 9 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4038 10 either either CC 42759 4038 11 to to IN 42759 4038 12 the the DT 42759 4038 13 testator testator NN 42759 4038 14 or or CC 42759 4038 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4038 16 heirs heir NNS 42759 4038 17 , , , 42759 4038 18 nor nor CC 42759 4038 19 can can MD 42759 4038 20 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4038 21 prove prove VB 42759 4038 22 that that IN 42759 4038 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4038 24 is be VBZ 42759 4038 25 in in IN 42759 4038 26 any any DT 42759 4038 27 other other JJ 42759 4038 28 manner manner NN 42759 4038 29 injurious injurious JJ 42759 4038 30 to to IN 42759 4038 31 human human JJ 42759 4038 32 welfare welfare NN 42759 4038 33 . . . 42759 4039 1 All all DT 42759 4039 2 that that WDT 42759 4039 3 can can MD 42759 4039 4 be be VB 42759 4039 5 said say VBN 42759 4039 6 with with IN 42759 4039 7 confidence confidence NN 42759 4039 8 concerning concern VBG 42759 4039 9 the the DT 42759 4039 10 just just JJ 42759 4039 11 rates rate NNS 42759 4039 12 of of IN 42759 4039 13 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 4039 14 taxation taxation NN 42759 4039 15 must must MD 42759 4039 16 take take VB 42759 4039 17 the the DT 42759 4039 18 form form NN 42759 4039 19 of of IN 42759 4039 20 generalisations generalisation NNS 42759 4039 21 . . . 42759 4040 1 The the DT 42759 4040 2 increments increment NNS 42759 4040 3 of of IN 42759 4040 4 the the DT 42759 4040 5 tax tax NN 42759 4040 6 should should MD 42759 4040 7 correspond correspond VB 42759 4040 8 as as RB 42759 4040 9 closely closely RB 42759 4040 10 as as IN 42759 4040 11 possible possible JJ 42759 4040 12 to to IN 42759 4040 13 the the DT 42759 4040 14 diminishing diminishing JJ 42759 4040 15 intensity intensity NN 42759 4040 16 of of IN 42759 4040 17 the the DT 42759 4040 18 wants want VBZ 42759 4040 19 which which WDT 42759 4040 20 the the DT 42759 4040 21 tax tax NN 42759 4040 22 deprives deprive NNS 42759 4040 23 of of IN 42759 4040 24 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 4040 25 ; ; : 42759 4040 26 in in IN 42759 4040 27 the the DT 42759 4040 28 case case NN 42759 4040 29 of of IN 42759 4040 30 each each DT 42759 4040 31 heir heir VB 42759 4040 32 a a DT 42759 4040 33 certain certain JJ 42759 4040 34 fairly fairly RB 42759 4040 35 high high JJ 42759 4040 36 minimum minimum NN 42759 4040 37 of of IN 42759 4040 38 property property NN 42759 4040 39 should should MD 42759 4040 40 be be VB 42759 4040 41 entirely entirely RB 42759 4040 42 exempt exempt JJ 42759 4040 43 ; ; : 42759 4040 44 on on IN 42759 4040 45 all all PDT 42759 4040 46 the the DT 42759 4040 47 highest high JJS 42759 4040 48 estates estate NNS 42759 4040 49 the the DT 42759 4040 50 rate rate NN 42759 4040 51 should should MD 42759 4040 52 be be VB 42759 4040 53 uniform uniform JJ 42759 4040 54 , , , 42759 4040 55 and and CC 42759 4040 56 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4040 57 should should MD 42759 4040 58 fall fall VB 42759 4040 59 a a DT 42759 4040 60 long long JJ 42759 4040 61 way way NN 42759 4040 62 short short JJ 42759 4040 63 of of IN 42759 4040 64 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 4040 65 ; ; : 42759 4040 66 and and CC 42759 4040 67 the the DT 42759 4040 68 tax tax NN 42759 4040 69 should should MD 42759 4040 70 at at IN 42759 4040 71 no no DT 42759 4040 72 point point NN 42759 4040 73 be be VB 42759 4040 74 such such JJ 42759 4040 75 as as IN 42759 4040 76 to to TO 42759 4040 77 discourage discourage VB 42759 4040 78 socially socially RB 42759 4040 79 useful useful JJ 42759 4040 80 activity activity NN 42759 4040 81 and and CC 42759 4040 82 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 4040 83 . . . 42759 4041 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4041 2 Effectiveness Effectiveness NNP 42759 4041 3 of of IN 42759 4041 4 Such Such NNP 42759 4041 5 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 4041 6 _ _ NNP 42759 4041 7 The the DT 42759 4041 8 essential essential JJ 42759 4041 9 justice justice NN 42759 4041 10 of of IN 42759 4041 11 the the DT 42759 4041 12 measures measure NNS 42759 4041 13 is be VBZ 42759 4041 14 not not RB 42759 4041 15 the the DT 42759 4041 16 only only JJ 42759 4041 17 consideration consideration NN 42759 4041 18 affecting affect VBG 42759 4041 19 high high JJ 42759 4041 20 income income NN 42759 4041 21 and and CC 42759 4041 22 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 4041 23 taxes taxis NNS 42759 4041 24 . . . 42759 4042 1 There there EX 42759 4042 2 remain remain VBP 42759 4042 3 the the DT 42759 4042 4 questions question NNS 42759 4042 5 of of IN 42759 4042 6 expediency expediency NN 42759 4042 7 and and CC 42759 4042 8 feasibility feasibility NN 42759 4042 9 . . . 42759 4043 1 Under under IN 42759 4043 2 the the DT 42759 4043 3 first first JJ 42759 4043 4 head head NN 42759 4043 5 the the DT 42759 4043 6 objection objection NN 42759 4043 7 is be VBZ 42759 4043 8 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 4043 9 raised raise VBN 42759 4043 10 that that IN 42759 4043 11 taxes taxis NNS 42759 4043 12 which which WDT 42759 4043 13 appropriated appropriate VBD 42759 4043 14 a a DT 42759 4043 15 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4043 16 portion portion NN 42759 4043 17 of of IN 42759 4043 18 the the DT 42759 4043 19 larger large JJR 42759 4043 20 incomes income NNS 42759 4043 21 and and CC 42759 4043 22 inheritances inheritance NNS 42759 4043 23 would would MD 42759 4043 24 diminish diminish VB 42759 4043 25 very very RB 42759 4043 26 materially materially RB 42759 4043 27 the the DT 42759 4043 28 social social JJ 42759 4043 29 supply supply NN 42759 4043 30 of of IN 42759 4043 31 capital capital NN 42759 4043 32 . . . 42759 4044 1 Immense immense JJ 42759 4044 2 sums sum NNS 42759 4044 3 of of IN 42759 4044 4 money money NN 42759 4044 5 would would MD 42759 4044 6 go go VB 42759 4044 7 into into IN 42759 4044 8 the the DT 42759 4044 9 public public JJ 42759 4044 10 treasury treasury NN 42759 4044 11 which which WDT 42759 4044 12 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 4044 13 would would MD 42759 4044 14 have have VB 42759 4044 15 been be VBN 42759 4044 16 invested invest VBN 42759 4044 17 in in IN 42759 4044 18 commerce commerce NN 42759 4044 19 and and CC 42759 4044 20 industry industry NN 42759 4044 21 . . . 42759 4045 1 Two two CD 42759 4045 2 questions question NNS 42759 4045 3 are be VBP 42759 4045 4 raised raise VBN 42759 4045 5 by by IN 42759 4045 6 this this DT 42759 4045 7 situation situation NN 42759 4045 8 : : : 42759 4045 9 first first RB 42759 4045 10 , , , 42759 4045 11 whether whether IN 42759 4045 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4045 13 might may MD 42759 4045 14 not not RB 42759 4045 15 be be VB 42759 4045 16 better well JJR 42759 4045 17 for for IN 42759 4045 18 society society NN 42759 4045 19 to to TO 42759 4045 20 have have VB 42759 4045 21 these these DT 42759 4045 22 sums sum NNS 42759 4045 23 devoted devote VBN 42759 4045 24 , , , 42759 4045 25 through through IN 42759 4045 26 public public JJ 42759 4045 27 works work NNS 42759 4045 28 of of IN 42759 4045 29 various various JJ 42759 4045 30 kinds kind NNS 42759 4045 31 , , , 42759 4045 32 to to IN 42759 4045 33 consumptive consumptive JJ 42759 4045 34 uses use VBZ 42759 4045 35 instead instead RB 42759 4045 36 of of IN 42759 4045 37 to to IN 42759 4045 38 an an DT 42759 4045 39 increase increase NN 42759 4045 40 in in IN 42759 4045 41 the the DT 42759 4045 42 supply supply NN 42759 4045 43 of of IN 42759 4045 44 capital capital NN 42759 4045 45 ; ; : 42759 4045 46 second second LS 42759 4045 47 , , , 42759 4045 48 whether whether IN 42759 4045 49 the the DT 42759 4045 50 reduction reduction NN 42759 4045 51 in in IN 42759 4045 52 the the DT 42759 4045 53 savings saving NNS 42759 4045 54 and and CC 42759 4045 55 capital capital NN 42759 4045 56 provided provide VBN 42759 4045 57 by by IN 42759 4045 58 the the DT 42759 4045 59 persons person NNS 42759 4045 60 paying pay VBG 42759 4045 61 the the DT 42759 4045 62 taxes taxis NNS 42759 4045 63 could could MD 42759 4045 64 be be VB 42759 4045 65 offset offset VBN 42759 4045 66 by by IN 42759 4045 67 increases increase NNS 42759 4045 68 in in IN 42759 4045 69 saving save VBG 42759 4045 70 among among IN 42759 4045 71 other other JJ 42759 4045 72 classes class NNS 42759 4045 73 . . . 42759 4046 1 Even even RB 42759 4046 2 if if IN 42759 4046 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4046 4 be be VBP 42759 4046 5 assumed assume VBN 42759 4046 6 that that IN 42759 4046 7 the the DT 42759 4046 8 first first JJ 42759 4046 9 question question NN 42759 4046 10 should should MD 42759 4046 11 receive receive VB 42759 4046 12 a a DT 42759 4046 13 negative negative JJ 42759 4046 14 answer answer NN 42759 4046 15 , , , 42759 4046 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4046 17 is be VBZ 42759 4046 18 not not RB 42759 4046 19 improbable improbable JJ 42759 4046 20 that that IN 42759 4046 21 the the DT 42759 4046 22 second second JJ 42759 4046 23 should should MD 42759 4046 24 be be VB 42759 4046 25 answered answer VBN 42759 4046 26 in in IN 42759 4046 27 the the DT 42759 4046 28 affirmative affirmative NN 42759 4046 29 . . . 42759 4047 1 In in IN 42759 4047 2 other other JJ 42759 4047 3 words word NNS 42759 4047 4 , , , 42759 4047 5 the the DT 42759 4047 6 increased increase VBN 42759 4047 7 saving saving NN 42759 4047 8 which which WDT 42759 4047 9 the the DT 42759 4047 10 poorer poor JJR 42759 4047 11 and and CC 42759 4047 12 middle middle JJ 42759 4047 13 classes class NNS 42759 4047 14 would would MD 42759 4047 15 be be VB 42759 4047 16 enabled enable VBN 42759 4047 17 to to TO 42759 4047 18 make make VB 42759 4047 19 as as IN 42759 4047 20 a a DT 42759 4047 21 result result NN 42759 4047 22 of of IN 42759 4047 23 the the DT 42759 4047 24 shifting shifting NN 42759 4047 25 of of IN 42759 4047 26 some some DT 42759 4047 27 of of IN 42759 4047 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4047 29 burden burden NN 42759 4047 30 of of IN 42759 4047 31 taxation taxation NN 42759 4047 32 to to IN 42759 4047 33 the the DT 42759 4047 34 large large JJ 42759 4047 35 incomes income NNS 42759 4047 36 and and CC 42759 4047 37 inheritances inheritance NNS 42759 4047 38 , , , 42759 4047 39 might may MD 42759 4047 40 very very RB 42759 4047 41 well well RB 42759 4047 42 counterbalance counterbalance VB 42759 4047 43 the the DT 42759 4047 44 curtailment curtailment NN 42759 4047 45 in in IN 42759 4047 46 the the DT 42759 4047 47 investments investment NNS 42759 4047 48 of of IN 42759 4047 49 the the DT 42759 4047 50 wealthy wealthy JJ 42759 4047 51 classes class NNS 42759 4047 52 . . . 42759 4048 1 Even even RB 42759 4048 2 if if IN 42759 4048 3 this this DT 42759 4048 4 possibility possibility NN 42759 4048 5 were be VBD 42759 4048 6 not not RB 42759 4048 7 fully fully RB 42759 4048 8 realised realise VBN 42759 4048 9 , , , 42759 4048 10 even even RB 42759 4048 11 if if IN 42759 4048 12 the the DT 42759 4048 13 net net JJ 42759 4048 14 volume volume NN 42759 4048 15 of of IN 42759 4048 16 capital capital NN 42759 4048 17 in in IN 42759 4048 18 the the DT 42759 4048 19 community community NN 42759 4048 20 were be VBD 42759 4048 21 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 4048 22 diminished diminish VBN 42759 4048 23 , , , 42759 4048 24 this this DT 42759 4048 25 disadvantage disadvantage NN 42759 4048 26 might may MD 42759 4048 27 be be VB 42759 4048 28 more more RBR 42759 4048 29 than than IN 42759 4048 30 neutralised neutralise VBN 42759 4048 31 by by IN 42759 4048 32 the the DT 42759 4048 33 wider wide JJR 42759 4048 34 social social JJ 42759 4048 35 benefits benefit NNS 42759 4048 36 of of IN 42759 4048 37 the the DT 42759 4048 38 taxation taxation NN 42759 4048 39 policy policy NN 42759 4048 40 . . . 42759 4049 1 With with IN 42759 4049 2 regard regard NN 42759 4049 3 to to IN 42759 4049 4 the the DT 42759 4049 5 feasibility feasibility NN 42759 4049 6 of of IN 42759 4049 7 very very RB 42759 4049 8 heavy heavy JJ 42759 4049 9 income income NN 42759 4049 10 and and CC 42759 4049 11 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 4049 12 taxes taxis NNS 42759 4049 13 , , , 42759 4049 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4049 15 is be VBZ 42759 4049 16 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 4049 17 contended contend VBN 42759 4049 18 that that IN 42759 4049 19 neither neither DT 42759 4049 20 of of IN 42759 4049 21 these these DT 42759 4049 22 measures measure NNS 42759 4049 23 can can MD 42759 4049 24 be be VB 42759 4049 25 made make VBN 42759 4049 26 effective effective JJ 42759 4049 27 toward toward IN 42759 4049 28 the the DT 42759 4049 29 reduction reduction NN 42759 4049 30 of of IN 42759 4049 31 abnormal abnormal JJ 42759 4049 32 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 4049 33 . . . 42759 4050 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4050 2 200 200 CD 42759 4050 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4050 4 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4050 5 is be VBZ 42759 4050 6 held hold VBN 42759 4050 7 that that IN 42759 4050 8 the the DT 42759 4050 9 successful successful JJ 42759 4050 10 collection collection NN 42759 4050 11 of of IN 42759 4050 12 these these DT 42759 4050 13 taxes taxis NNS 42759 4050 14 requires require VBZ 42759 4050 15 the the DT 42759 4050 16 co co NN 42759 4050 17 - - NN 42759 4050 18 operation operation NN 42759 4050 19 of of IN 42759 4050 20 the the DT 42759 4050 21 persons person NNS 42759 4050 22 affected affect VBN 42759 4050 23 by by IN 42759 4050 24 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4050 25 ; ; : 42759 4050 26 that that IN 42759 4050 27 if if IN 42759 4050 28 the the DT 42759 4050 29 rate rate NN 42759 4050 30 should should MD 42759 4050 31 go go VB 42759 4050 32 above above IN 42759 4050 33 ten ten CD 42759 4050 34 or or CC 42759 4050 35 twelve twelve CD 42759 4050 36 per per IN 42759 4050 37 cent cent NN 42759 4050 38 . . . 42759 4050 39 , , , 42759 4050 40 the the DT 42759 4050 41 income income NN 42759 4050 42 receiver receiver NN 42759 4050 43 would would MD 42759 4050 44 evade evade VB 42759 4050 45 the the DT 42759 4050 46 tax tax NN 42759 4050 47 in in IN 42759 4050 48 a a DT 42759 4050 49 great great JJ 42759 4050 50 variety variety NN 42759 4050 51 of of IN 42759 4050 52 ways way NNS 42759 4050 53 , , , 42759 4050 54 while while IN 42759 4050 55 the the DT 42759 4050 56 owner owner NN 42759 4050 57 of of IN 42759 4050 58 a a DT 42759 4050 59 large large JJ 42759 4050 60 estate estate NN 42759 4050 61 would would MD 42759 4050 62 transfer transfer VB 42759 4050 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4050 64 property property NN 42759 4050 65 outright outright RB 42759 4050 66 to to IN 42759 4050 67 a a DT 42759 4050 68 trust trust NN 42759 4050 69 company company NN 42759 4050 70 , , , 42759 4050 71 which which WDT 42759 4050 72 would would MD 42759 4050 73 after after IN 42759 4050 74 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4050 75 death death NN 42759 4050 76 make make VBP 42759 4050 77 the the DT 42759 4050 78 desired desire VBN 42759 4050 79 distribution distribution NN 42759 4050 80 . . . 42759 4051 1 The the DT 42759 4051 2 man man NN 42759 4051 3 who who WP 42759 4051 4 urges urge VBZ 42759 4051 5 these these DT 42759 4051 6 objections objection NNS 42759 4051 7 is be VBZ 42759 4051 8 a a DT 42759 4051 9 very very RB 42759 4051 10 high high JJ 42759 4051 11 authority authority NN 42759 4051 12 on on IN 42759 4051 13 taxation taxation NN 42759 4051 14 , , , 42759 4051 15 especially especially RB 42759 4051 16 on on IN 42759 4051 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4051 18 administrative administrative JJ 42759 4051 19 side side NN 42759 4051 20 ; ; : 42759 4051 21 nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 4051 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4051 23 contentions contention NNS 42759 4051 24 are be VBP 42759 4051 25 not not RB 42759 4051 26 absolutely absolutely RB 42759 4051 27 conclusive conclusive JJ 42759 4051 28 . . . 42759 4052 1 In in IN 42759 4052 2 particular particular JJ 42759 4052 3 , , , 42759 4052 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4052 5 does do VBZ 42759 4052 6 not not RB 42759 4052 7 seem seem VB 42759 4052 8 probable probable JJ 42759 4052 9 that that IN 42759 4052 10 high high JJ 42759 4052 11 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 4052 12 taxes taxis NNS 42759 4052 13 could could MD 42759 4052 14 be be VB 42759 4052 15 evaded evade VBN 42759 4052 16 by by IN 42759 4052 17 the the DT 42759 4052 18 simple simple JJ 42759 4052 19 devices device NNS 42759 4052 20 that that WDT 42759 4052 21 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4052 22 mentions mention VBZ 42759 4052 23 . . . 42759 4053 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4053 2 ought ought MD 42759 4053 3 not not RB 42759 4053 4 to to TO 42759 4053 5 be be VB 42759 4053 6 beyond beyond IN 42759 4053 7 the the DT 42759 4053 8 power power NN 42759 4053 9 of of IN 42759 4053 10 administrative administrative JJ 42759 4053 11 ingenuity ingenuity NN 42759 4053 12 to to TO 42759 4053 13 find find VB 42759 4053 14 methods method NNS 42759 4053 15 of of IN 42759 4053 16 defeating defeat VBG 42759 4053 17 such such JJ 42759 4053 18 subterfuges subterfuge NNS 42759 4053 19 . . . 42759 4054 1 However however RB 42759 4054 2 , , , 42759 4054 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4054 4 is be VBZ 42759 4054 5 altogether altogether RB 42759 4054 6 likely likely JJ 42759 4054 7 that that IN 42759 4054 8 the the DT 42759 4054 9 possibilities possibility NNS 42759 4054 10 of of IN 42759 4054 11 evasion evasion NN 42759 4054 12 would would MD 42759 4054 13 be be VB 42759 4054 14 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4054 15 to to TO 42759 4054 16 prevent prevent VB 42759 4054 17 the the DT 42759 4054 18 imposition imposition NN 42759 4054 19 of of IN 42759 4054 20 tax tax NN 42759 4054 21 rates rate NNS 42759 4054 22 that that WDT 42759 4054 23 approached approach VBD 42759 4054 24 within within IN 42759 4054 25 measurable measurable JJ 42759 4054 26 distance distance NN 42759 4054 27 of of IN 42759 4054 28 the the DT 42759 4054 29 borderland borderland NN 42759 4054 30 of of IN 42759 4054 31 confiscation confiscation NN 42759 4054 32 . . . 42759 4055 1 The the DT 42759 4055 2 sum sum NN 42759 4055 3 of of IN 42759 4055 4 the the DT 42759 4055 5 matter matter NN 42759 4055 6 seems seem VBZ 42759 4055 7 to to TO 42759 4055 8 be be VB 42759 4055 9 that that IN 42759 4055 10 the the DT 42759 4055 11 reduction reduction NN 42759 4055 12 and and CC 42759 4055 13 prevention prevention NN 42759 4055 14 of of IN 42759 4055 15 great great JJ 42759 4055 16 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 4055 17 can can MD 42759 4055 18 not not RB 42759 4055 19 prudently prudently RB 42759 4055 20 be be VB 42759 4055 21 accomplished accomplish VBN 42759 4055 22 by by IN 42759 4055 23 the the DT 42759 4055 24 method method NN 42759 4055 25 of of IN 42759 4055 26 direct direct JJ 42759 4055 27 limitation limitation NN 42759 4055 28 ; ; : 42759 4055 29 that that IN 42759 4055 30 these these DT 42759 4055 31 ends end NNS 42759 4055 32 may may MD 42759 4055 33 wisely wisely RB 42759 4055 34 and and CC 42759 4055 35 justly justly RB 42759 4055 36 be be VB 42759 4055 37 attained attain VBN 42759 4055 38 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 4055 39 , , , 42759 4055 40 through through IN 42759 4055 41 the the DT 42759 4055 42 imposition imposition NN 42759 4055 43 of of IN 42759 4055 44 progressive progressive JJ 42759 4055 45 income income NN 42759 4055 46 and and CC 42759 4055 47 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 4055 48 taxes taxis NNS 42759 4055 49 ; ; : 42759 4055 50 but but CC 42759 4055 51 that that IN 42759 4055 52 the the DT 42759 4055 53 extent extent NN 42759 4055 54 to to TO 42759 4055 55 which which WDT 42759 4055 56 these these DT 42759 4055 57 measures measure NNS 42759 4055 58 would would MD 42759 4055 59 be be VB 42759 4055 60 genuinely genuinely RB 42759 4055 61 effective effective JJ 42759 4055 62 can can MD 42759 4055 63 not not RB 42759 4055 64 be be VB 42759 4055 65 estimated estimate VBN 42759 4055 66 until until IN 42759 4055 67 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4055 68 have have VBP 42759 4055 69 been be VBN 42759 4055 70 given give VBN 42759 4055 71 a a DT 42759 4055 72 thorough thorough JJ 42759 4055 73 trial trial NN 42759 4055 74 . . . 42759 4056 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 4056 2 : : : 42759 4056 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4056 4 197 197 CD 42759 4056 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4056 6 " " `` 42759 4056 7 Final Final NNP 42759 4056 8 Report Report NNP 42759 4056 9 , , , 42759 4056 10 " " '' 42759 4056 11 p. p. NN 42759 4056 12 32 32 CD 42759 4056 13 . . . 42759 4057 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4057 2 198 198 CD 42759 4057 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4057 4 " " `` 42759 4057 5 Progressive Progressive NNP 42759 4057 6 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 4057 7 , , , 42759 4057 8 " " '' 42759 4057 9 pp pp NNP 42759 4057 10 . . . 42759 4058 1 210 210 CD 42759 4058 2 , , , 42759 4058 3 211 211 CD 42759 4058 4 ; ; : 42759 4058 5 cf cf NN 42759 4058 6 . . . 42759 4059 1 Vermeersch Vermeersch NNP 42759 4059 2 , , , 42759 4059 3 " " '' 42759 4059 4 Quaestiones Quaestiones NNP 42759 4059 5 de de NNP 42759 4059 6 Justitia Justitia NNP 42759 4059 7 , , , 42759 4059 8 " " '' 42759 4059 9 pp pp NNP 42759 4059 10 . . . 42759 4060 1 94 94 CD 42759 4060 2 - - SYM 42759 4060 3 126 126 CD 42759 4060 4 . . . 42759 4061 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4061 2 199 199 CD 42759 4061 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4061 4 " " `` 42759 4061 5 The the DT 42759 4061 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 42759 4061 7 of of IN 42759 4061 8 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 4061 9 , , , 42759 4061 10 " " '' 42759 4061 11 pp pp NNP 42759 4061 12 . . . 42759 4062 1 11 11 CD 42759 4062 2 , , , 42759 4062 3 12 12 CD 42759 4062 4 . . . 42759 4063 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4063 2 200 200 CD 42759 4063 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4063 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 4063 5 . . . 42759 4064 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 42759 4064 2 T. T. NNP 42759 4064 3 S. S. NNP 42759 4064 4 Adams Adams NNP 42759 4064 5 in in IN 42759 4064 6 " " `` 42759 4064 7 Papers Papers NNPS 42759 4064 8 and and CC 42759 4064 9 Proceedings Proceedings NNPS 42759 4064 10 of of IN 42759 4064 11 the the DT 42759 4064 12 27th 27th JJ 42759 4064 13 Annual Annual NNP 42759 4064 14 Meeting Meeting NNP 42759 4064 15 of of IN 42759 4064 16 the the DT 42759 4064 17 American American NNP 42759 4064 18 Economic Economic NNP 42759 4064 19 Association Association NNP 42759 4064 20 , , , 42759 4064 21 " " '' 42759 4064 22 pp pp NNP 42759 4064 23 . . . 42759 4065 1 234 234 CD 42759 4065 2 , , , 42759 4065 3 sq sq NNP 42759 4065 4 . . . 42759 4066 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 4066 2 XXI xxi VBP 42759 4066 3 THE the DT 42759 4066 4 DUTY DUTY NNS 42759 4066 5 OF of IN 42759 4066 6 DISTRIBUTING distribute VBG 42759 4066 7 SUPERFLUOUS SUPERFLUOUS NNP 42759 4066 8 WEALTH wealth VB 42759 4066 9 The the DT 42759 4066 10 correctives corrective NNS 42759 4066 11 of of IN 42759 4066 12 the the DT 42759 4066 13 present present JJ 42759 4066 14 distribution distribution NN 42759 4066 15 that that WDT 42759 4066 16 were be VBD 42759 4066 17 proposed propose VBN 42759 4066 18 before before IN 42759 4066 19 the the DT 42759 4066 20 beginning beginning NN 42759 4066 21 of of IN 42759 4066 22 the the DT 42759 4066 23 last last JJ 42759 4066 24 chapter chapter NN 42759 4066 25 related relate VBN 42759 4066 26 mainly mainly RB 42759 4066 27 to to IN 42759 4066 28 the the DT 42759 4066 29 apportionment apportionment NN 42759 4066 30 of of IN 42759 4066 31 the the DT 42759 4066 32 product product NN 42759 4066 33 among among IN 42759 4066 34 the the DT 42759 4066 35 agents agent NNS 42759 4066 36 of of IN 42759 4066 37 production production NN 42759 4066 38 . . . 42759 4067 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4067 2 would would MD 42759 4067 3 affect affect VB 42759 4067 4 that that DT 42759 4067 5 distribution distribution NN 42759 4067 6 which which WDT 42759 4067 7 takes take VBZ 42759 4067 8 place place NN 42759 4067 9 as as IN 42759 4067 10 an an DT 42759 4067 11 integral integral JJ 42759 4067 12 element element NN 42759 4067 13 of of IN 42759 4067 14 the the DT 42759 4067 15 productive productive JJ 42759 4067 16 process process NN 42759 4067 17 , , , 42759 4067 18 not not RB 42759 4067 19 any any DT 42759 4067 20 disposition disposition NN 42759 4067 21 which which WDT 42759 4067 22 the the DT 42759 4067 23 productive productive JJ 42759 4067 24 agents agent NNS 42759 4067 25 might may MD 42759 4067 26 desire desire VB 42759 4067 27 or or CC 42759 4067 28 be be VB 42759 4067 29 required require VBN 42759 4067 30 to to TO 42759 4067 31 make make VB 42759 4067 32 of of IN 42759 4067 33 the the DT 42759 4067 34 shares share NNS 42759 4067 35 that that WDT 42759 4067 36 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4067 37 had have VBD 42759 4067 38 acquired acquire VBN 42759 4067 39 from from IN 42759 4067 40 the the DT 42759 4067 41 productive productive JJ 42759 4067 42 process process NN 42759 4067 43 . . . 42759 4068 1 Such such JJ 42759 4068 2 were be VBD 42759 4068 3 many many JJ 42759 4068 4 of of IN 42759 4068 5 the the DT 42759 4068 6 proposals proposal NNS 42759 4068 7 regarding regard VBG 42759 4068 8 land land NN 42759 4068 9 tenure tenure NN 42759 4068 10 , , , 42759 4068 11 and and CC 42759 4068 12 all all DT 42759 4068 13 of of IN 42759 4068 14 those those DT 42759 4068 15 concerning concern VBG 42759 4068 16 co co JJ 42759 4068 17 - - JJ 42759 4068 18 operative operative JJ 42759 4068 19 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 4068 20 and and CC 42759 4068 21 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 4068 22 . . . 42759 4069 1 In in IN 42759 4069 2 the the DT 42759 4069 3 last last JJ 42759 4069 4 chapter chapter NN 42759 4069 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4069 6 considered consider VBD 42759 4069 7 the the DT 42759 4069 8 possibility possibility NN 42759 4069 9 of of IN 42759 4069 10 neutralising neutralise VBG 42759 4069 11 to to IN 42759 4069 12 some some DT 42759 4069 13 extent extent NN 42759 4069 14 the the DT 42759 4069 15 abuses abuse NNS 42759 4069 16 of of IN 42759 4069 17 the the DT 42759 4069 18 primary primary JJ 42759 4069 19 distribution distribution NN 42759 4069 20 by by IN 42759 4069 21 the the DT 42759 4069 22 action action NN 42759 4069 23 of of IN 42759 4069 24 government government NN 42759 4069 25 through through IN 42759 4069 26 the the DT 42759 4069 27 taxation taxation NN 42759 4069 28 of of IN 42759 4069 29 large large JJ 42759 4069 30 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 4069 31 . . . 42759 4070 1 These these DT 42759 4070 2 were be VBD 42759 4070 3 proposals proposal NNS 42759 4070 4 directly directly RB 42759 4070 5 affecting affect VBG 42759 4070 6 the the DT 42759 4070 7 secondary secondary JJ 42759 4070 8 distribution distribution NN 42759 4070 9 . . . 42759 4071 1 And and CC 42759 4071 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4071 3 involved involve VBD 42759 4071 4 the the DT 42759 4071 5 method method NN 42759 4071 6 of of IN 42759 4071 7 compulsion compulsion NN 42759 4071 8 . . . 42759 4072 1 In in IN 42759 4072 2 the the DT 42759 4072 3 present present JJ 42759 4072 4 chapter chapter NN 42759 4072 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4072 6 shall shall MD 42759 4072 7 inquire inquire VB 42759 4072 8 whether whether IN 42759 4072 9 desirable desirable JJ 42759 4072 10 changes change NNS 42759 4072 11 in in IN 42759 4072 12 the the DT 42759 4072 13 secondary secondary JJ 42759 4072 14 distribution distribution NN 42759 4072 15 may may MD 42759 4072 16 not not RB 42759 4072 17 be be VB 42759 4072 18 effected effect VBN 42759 4072 19 by by IN 42759 4072 20 voluntary voluntary JJ 42759 4072 21 action action NN 42759 4072 22 . . . 42759 4073 1 The the DT 42759 4073 2 specific specific JJ 42759 4073 3 questions question NNS 42759 4073 4 confronting confront VBG 42759 4073 5 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4073 6 here here RB 42759 4073 7 are be VBP 42759 4073 8 , , , 42759 4073 9 whether whether IN 42759 4073 10 and and CC 42759 4073 11 how how WRB 42759 4073 12 far far JJ 42759 4073 13 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 4073 14 are be VBP 42759 4073 15 morally morally RB 42759 4073 16 bound bind VBN 42759 4073 17 to to TO 42759 4073 18 distribute distribute VB 42759 4073 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4073 20 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4073 21 wealth wealth NN 42759 4073 22 among among IN 42759 4073 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4073 24 less less JJR 42759 4073 25 fortunate fortunate JJ 42759 4073 26 fellows fellow NNS 42759 4073 27 . . . 42759 4074 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4074 2 The the DT 42759 4074 3 Question Question NNP 42759 4074 4 of of IN 42759 4074 5 Distributing distribute VBG 42759 4074 6 Some some DT 42759 4074 7 _ _ NNP 42759 4074 8 The the DT 42759 4074 9 authority authority NN 42759 4074 10 of of IN 42759 4074 11 revealed revealed JJ 42759 4074 12 religion religion NN 42759 4074 13 returns return NNS 42759 4074 14 to to IN 42759 4074 15 the the DT 42759 4074 16 first first JJ 42759 4074 17 of of IN 42759 4074 18 these these DT 42759 4074 19 questions question NNS 42759 4074 20 a a DT 42759 4074 21 clear clear JJ 42759 4074 22 and and CC 42759 4074 23 emphatic emphatic JJ 42759 4074 24 answer answer NN 42759 4074 25 in in IN 42759 4074 26 the the DT 42759 4074 27 affirmative affirmative NN 42759 4074 28 . . . 42759 4075 1 The the DT 42759 4075 2 Old Old NNP 42759 4075 3 and and CC 42759 4075 4 the the DT 42759 4075 5 New New NNP 42759 4075 6 Testaments Testaments NNPS 42759 4075 7 abound abound VBP 42759 4075 8 in in IN 42759 4075 9 declarations declaration NNS 42759 4075 10 that that IN 42759 4075 11 possessors possessor NNS 42759 4075 12 are be VBP 42759 4075 13 under under IN 42759 4075 14 very very RB 42759 4075 15 strict strict JJ 42759 4075 16 obligation obligation NN 42759 4075 17 to to TO 42759 4075 18 give give VB 42759 4075 19 of of IN 42759 4075 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4075 21 surplus surplus NN 42759 4075 22 to to IN 42759 4075 23 the the DT 42759 4075 24 indigent indigent NN 42759 4075 25 . . . 42759 4076 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 42759 4076 2 the the DT 42759 4076 3 most most RBS 42759 4076 4 striking striking JJ 42759 4076 5 expression expression NN 42759 4076 6 of of IN 42759 4076 7 this this DT 42759 4076 8 teaching teaching NN 42759 4076 9 is be VBZ 42759 4076 10 that that DT 42759 4076 11 found find VBN 42759 4076 12 in in IN 42759 4076 13 the the DT 42759 4076 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 42759 4076 15 according accord VBG 42759 4076 16 to to IN 42759 4076 17 St. St. NNP 42759 4076 18 Matthew Matthew NNP 42759 4076 19 , , , 42759 4076 20 ch ch NN 42759 4076 21 . . . 42759 4077 1 25 25 CD 42759 4077 2 , , , 42759 4077 3 verses verses IN 42759 4077 4 32 32 CD 42759 4077 5 - - SYM 42759 4077 6 46 46 CD 42759 4077 7 , , , 42759 4077 8 where where WRB 42759 4077 9 eternal eternal JJ 42759 4077 10 happiness happiness NN 42759 4077 11 is be VBZ 42759 4077 12 awarded award VBN 42759 4077 13 to to IN 42759 4077 14 those those DT 42759 4077 15 who who WP 42759 4077 16 have have VBP 42759 4077 17 fed feed VBN 42759 4077 18 the the DT 42759 4077 19 hungry hungry JJ 42759 4077 20 , , , 42759 4077 21 given give VBN 42759 4077 22 drink drink NN 42759 4077 23 to to IN 42759 4077 24 the the DT 42759 4077 25 thirsty thirsty JJ 42759 4077 26 , , , 42759 4077 27 received receive VBD 42759 4077 28 the the DT 42759 4077 29 stranger stranger NN 42759 4077 30 , , , 42759 4077 31 covered cover VBD 42759 4077 32 the the DT 42759 4077 33 naked naked JJ 42759 4077 34 , , , 42759 4077 35 visited visit VBD 42759 4077 36 the the DT 42759 4077 37 sick sick JJ 42759 4077 38 , , , 42759 4077 39 and and CC 42759 4077 40 called call VBD 42759 4077 41 upon upon IN 42759 4077 42 the the DT 42759 4077 43 imprisoned imprison VBN 42759 4077 44 ; ; : 42759 4077 45 and and CC 42759 4077 46 eternal eternal JJ 42759 4077 47 damnation damnation NN 42759 4077 48 is be VBZ 42759 4077 49 meted mete VBN 42759 4077 50 out out RP 42759 4077 51 to to IN 42759 4077 52 those those DT 42759 4077 53 who who WP 42759 4077 54 have have VBP 42759 4077 55 failed fail VBN 42759 4077 56 in in IN 42759 4077 57 these these DT 42759 4077 58 respects respect NNS 42759 4077 59 . . . 42759 4078 1 The the DT 42759 4078 2 principle principle NN 42759 4078 3 that that DT 42759 4078 4 ownership ownership NN 42759 4078 5 is be VBZ 42759 4078 6 stewardship stewardship NN 42759 4078 7 , , , 42759 4078 8 that that IN 42759 4078 9 the the DT 42759 4078 10 man man NN 42759 4078 11 who who WP 42759 4078 12 possesses possess VBZ 42759 4078 13 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4078 14 goods good NNS 42759 4078 15 must must MD 42759 4078 16 regard regard VB 42759 4078 17 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4078 18 as as IN 42759 4078 19 a a DT 42759 4078 20 trustee trustee NN 42759 4078 21 for for IN 42759 4078 22 the the DT 42759 4078 23 needy needy NN 42759 4078 24 , , , 42759 4078 25 is be VBZ 42759 4078 26 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4078 27 and and CC 42759 4078 28 all all RB 42759 4078 29 - - HYPH 42759 4078 30 pervasive pervasive JJ 42759 4078 31 in in IN 42759 4078 32 the the DT 42759 4078 33 teaching teaching NN 42759 4078 34 of of IN 42759 4078 35 Christianity Christianity NNP 42759 4078 36 . . . 42759 4079 1 No no DT 42759 4079 2 more more RBR 42759 4079 3 clear clear JJ 42759 4079 4 or or CC 42759 4079 5 concise concise JJ 42759 4079 6 statement statement NN 42759 4079 7 of of IN 42759 4079 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4079 9 has have VBZ 42759 4079 10 ever ever RB 42759 4079 11 been be VBN 42759 4079 12 given give VBN 42759 4079 13 than than IN 42759 4079 14 that that DT 42759 4079 15 of of IN 42759 4079 16 St. St. NNP 42759 4079 17 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 4079 18 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 42759 4079 19 : : : 42759 4079 20 " " `` 42759 4079 21 As as IN 42759 4079 22 regards regard VBZ 42759 4079 23 the the DT 42759 4079 24 power power NN 42759 4079 25 of of IN 42759 4079 26 acquiring acquire VBG 42759 4079 27 and and CC 42759 4079 28 dispensing dispense VBG 42759 4079 29 material material NN 42759 4079 30 goods good NNS 42759 4079 31 , , , 42759 4079 32 man man NN 42759 4079 33 may may MD 42759 4079 34 lawfully lawfully RB 42759 4079 35 possess possess VB 42759 4079 36 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4079 37 as as IN 42759 4079 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4079 39 own own JJ 42759 4079 40 ; ; : 42759 4079 41 as as IN 42759 4079 42 regards regard VBZ 42759 4079 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4079 44 use use NN 42759 4079 45 , , , 42759 4079 46 however however RB 42759 4079 47 , , , 42759 4079 48 a a DT 42759 4079 49 man man NN 42759 4079 50 ought ought MD 42759 4079 51 not not RB 42759 4079 52 to to TO 42759 4079 53 look look VB 42759 4079 54 upon upon IN 42759 4079 55 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4079 56 as as IN 42759 4079 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4079 58 own own JJ 42759 4079 59 , , , 42759 4079 60 but but CC 42759 4079 61 as as RB 42759 4079 62 common common JJ 42759 4079 63 , , , 42759 4079 64 so so IN 42759 4079 65 that that IN 42759 4079 66 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4079 67 may may MD 42759 4079 68 readily readily RB 42759 4079 69 minister minister VB 42759 4079 70 to to IN 42759 4079 71 the the DT 42759 4079 72 needs need NNS 42759 4079 73 of of IN 42759 4079 74 others other NNS 42759 4079 75 . . . 42759 4080 1 " " `` 42759 4080 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4080 3 201 201 CD 42759 4080 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4080 5 Reason reason NN 42759 4080 6 likewise likewise RB 42759 4080 7 enjoins enjoin VBZ 42759 4080 8 the the DT 42759 4080 9 benevolent benevolent JJ 42759 4080 10 distribution distribution NN 42759 4080 11 of of IN 42759 4080 12 surplus surplus JJ 42759 4080 13 wealth wealth NN 42759 4080 14 . . . 42759 4081 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4081 2 reminds remind VBZ 42759 4081 3 the the DT 42759 4081 4 proprietor proprietor NN 42759 4081 5 that that WDT 42759 4081 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4081 7 needy needy JJ 42759 4081 8 neighbours neighbour NNS 42759 4081 9 have have VBP 42759 4081 10 the the DT 42759 4081 11 same same JJ 42759 4081 12 nature nature NN 42759 4081 13 , , , 42759 4081 14 the the DT 42759 4081 15 same same JJ 42759 4081 16 faculties faculty NNS 42759 4081 17 , , , 42759 4081 18 capacities capacity NNS 42759 4081 19 , , , 42759 4081 20 wants want VBZ 42759 4081 21 , , , 42759 4081 22 and and CC 42759 4081 23 destiny destiny NN 42759 4081 24 as as IN 42759 4081 25 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4081 26 . . . 42759 4082 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4082 2 are be VBP 42759 4082 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4082 4 equals equal NNS 42759 4082 5 and and CC 42759 4082 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4082 7 brothers brother NNS 42759 4082 8 . . . 42759 4083 1 Reason reason NN 42759 4083 2 , , , 42759 4083 3 therefore therefore RB 42759 4083 4 , , , 42759 4083 5 requires require VBZ 42759 4083 6 that that IN 42759 4083 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4083 8 should should MD 42759 4083 9 esteem esteem VB 42759 4083 10 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4083 11 as as IN 42759 4083 12 such such JJ 42759 4083 13 , , , 42759 4083 14 love love VB 42759 4083 15 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4083 16 as as IN 42759 4083 17 such such JJ 42759 4083 18 , , , 42759 4083 19 and and CC 42759 4083 20 treat treat VB 42759 4083 21 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4083 22 as as IN 42759 4083 23 such such JJ 42759 4083 24 ; ; : 42759 4083 25 that that IN 42759 4083 26 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4083 27 should should MD 42759 4083 28 love love VB 42759 4083 29 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4083 30 not not RB 42759 4083 31 merely merely RB 42759 4083 32 by by IN 42759 4083 33 well well RB 42759 4083 34 wishing wishing NN 42759 4083 35 , , , 42759 4083 36 but but CC 42759 4083 37 by by IN 42759 4083 38 well well RB 42759 4083 39 doing do VBG 42759 4083 40 . . . 42759 4084 1 Since since IN 42759 4084 2 the the DT 42759 4084 3 goods good NNS 42759 4084 4 of of IN 42759 4084 5 the the DT 42759 4084 6 earth earth NN 42759 4084 7 were be VBD 42759 4084 8 intended intend VBN 42759 4084 9 by by IN 42759 4084 10 the the DT 42759 4084 11 Creator Creator NNP 42759 4084 12 for for IN 42759 4084 13 the the DT 42759 4084 14 common common JJ 42759 4084 15 benefit benefit NN 42759 4084 16 of of IN 42759 4084 17 all all DT 42759 4084 18 mankind mankind NN 42759 4084 19 , , , 42759 4084 20 the the DT 42759 4084 21 possessor possessor NN 42759 4084 22 of of IN 42759 4084 23 a a DT 42759 4084 24 surplus surplus NN 42759 4084 25 is be VBZ 42759 4084 26 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 4084 27 required require VBN 42759 4084 28 to to TO 42759 4084 29 use use VB 42759 4084 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4084 31 in in IN 42759 4084 32 such such PDT 42759 4084 33 a a DT 42759 4084 34 way way NN 42759 4084 35 that that IN 42759 4084 36 this this DT 42759 4084 37 original original JJ 42759 4084 38 purpose purpose NN 42759 4084 39 of of IN 42759 4084 40 all all DT 42759 4084 41 created create VBN 42759 4084 42 goods good NNS 42759 4084 43 will will MD 42759 4084 44 be be VB 42759 4084 45 fulfilled fulfil VBN 42759 4084 46 . . . 42759 4085 1 To to TO 42759 4085 2 refuse refuse VB 42759 4085 3 is be VBZ 42759 4085 4 to to TO 42759 4085 5 treat treat VB 42759 4085 6 one one PRP 42759 4085 7 's 's POS 42759 4085 8 less less RBR 42759 4085 9 fortunate fortunate JJ 42759 4085 10 neighbour neighbour NN 42759 4085 11 as as IN 42759 4085 12 something something NN 42759 4085 13 different different JJ 42759 4085 14 from from IN 42759 4085 15 and and CC 42759 4085 16 less less JJR 42759 4085 17 than than IN 42759 4085 18 oneself oneself PRP 42759 4085 19 , , , 42759 4085 20 as as IN 42759 4085 21 a a DT 42759 4085 22 creature creature NN 42759 4085 23 whose whose WP$ 42759 4085 24 claim claim NN 42759 4085 25 upon upon IN 42759 4085 26 the the DT 42759 4085 27 common common JJ 42759 4085 28 bounty bounty NN 42759 4085 29 of of IN 42759 4085 30 nature nature NN 42759 4085 31 is be VBZ 42759 4085 32 something something NN 42759 4085 33 less less JJR 42759 4085 34 than than IN 42759 4085 35 one one PRP 42759 4085 36 's 's POS 42759 4085 37 own own JJ 42759 4085 38 . . . 42759 4086 1 Multiplying multiply VBG 42759 4086 2 words word NNS 42759 4086 3 will will MD 42759 4086 4 not not RB 42759 4086 5 make make VB 42759 4086 6 these these DT 42759 4086 7 truths truth NNS 42759 4086 8 plainer plainer NN 42759 4086 9 . . . 42759 4087 1 The the DT 42759 4087 2 man man NN 42759 4087 3 who who WP 42759 4087 4 does do VBZ 42759 4087 5 not not RB 42759 4087 6 admit admit VB 42759 4087 7 that that IN 42759 4087 8 the the DT 42759 4087 9 welfare welfare NN 42759 4087 10 of of IN 42759 4087 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4087 12 neighbour neighbour NN 42759 4087 13 is be VBZ 42759 4087 14 of of IN 42759 4087 15 equal equal JJ 42759 4087 16 moral moral JJ 42759 4087 17 worth worth NN 42759 4087 18 and and CC 42759 4087 19 importance importance NN 42759 4087 20 with with IN 42759 4087 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4087 22 own own JJ 42759 4087 23 welfare welfare NN 42759 4087 24 , , , 42759 4087 25 will will MD 42759 4087 26 logically logically RB 42759 4087 27 refuse refuse VB 42759 4087 28 to to TO 42759 4087 29 admit admit VB 42759 4087 30 that that IN 42759 4087 31 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4087 32 is be VBZ 42759 4087 33 under under IN 42759 4087 34 any any DT 42759 4087 35 obligation obligation NN 42759 4087 36 of of IN 42759 4087 37 distributing distribute VBG 42759 4087 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4087 39 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4087 40 goods good NNS 42759 4087 41 . . . 42759 4088 1 The the DT 42759 4088 2 man man NN 42759 4088 3 who who WP 42759 4088 4 does do VBZ 42759 4088 5 acknowledge acknowledge VB 42759 4088 6 this this DT 42759 4088 7 essential essential JJ 42759 4088 8 equality equality NN 42759 4088 9 will will MD 42759 4088 10 be be VB 42759 4088 11 unable unable JJ 42759 4088 12 to to TO 42759 4088 13 find find VB 42759 4088 14 any any DT 42759 4088 15 logical logical JJ 42759 4088 16 basis basis NN 42759 4088 17 for for IN 42759 4088 18 such such JJ 42759 4088 19 refusal refusal NN 42759 4088 20 . . . 42759 4089 1 Is be VBZ 42759 4089 2 this this DT 42759 4089 3 obligation obligation NN 42759 4089 4 one one CD 42759 4089 5 of of IN 42759 4089 6 charity charity NN 42759 4089 7 or or CC 42759 4089 8 one one CD 42759 4089 9 of of IN 42759 4089 10 justice justice NN 42759 4089 11 ? ? . 42759 4090 1 At at IN 42759 4090 2 the the DT 42759 4090 3 outset outset NN 42759 4090 4 a a DT 42759 4090 5 distinction distinction NN 42759 4090 6 must must MD 42759 4090 7 be be VB 42759 4090 8 made make VBN 42759 4090 9 between between IN 42759 4090 10 wealth wealth NN 42759 4090 11 that that WDT 42759 4090 12 has have VBZ 42759 4090 13 been be VBN 42759 4090 14 honestly honestly RB 42759 4090 15 acquired acquire VBN 42759 4090 16 and and CC 42759 4090 17 wealth wealth NN 42759 4090 18 that that WDT 42759 4090 19 has have VBZ 42759 4090 20 come come VBN 42759 4090 21 into into IN 42759 4090 22 one one PRP 42759 4090 23 's 's POS 42759 4090 24 possession possession NN 42759 4090 25 through through IN 42759 4090 26 some some DT 42759 4090 27 violation violation NN 42759 4090 28 of of IN 42759 4090 29 rights right NNS 42759 4090 30 . . . 42759 4091 1 The the DT 42759 4091 2 latter latter JJ 42759 4091 3 kind kind NN 42759 4091 4 must must MD 42759 4091 5 , , , 42759 4091 6 of of IN 42759 4091 7 course course NN 42759 4091 8 , , , 42759 4091 9 be be VB 42759 4091 10 restored restore VBN 42759 4091 11 to to IN 42759 4091 12 those those DT 42759 4091 13 persons person NNS 42759 4091 14 who who WP 42759 4091 15 have have VBP 42759 4091 16 been be VBN 42759 4091 17 wronged wrong VBN 42759 4091 18 . . . 42759 4092 1 If if IN 42759 4092 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4092 3 can can MD 42759 4092 4 not not RB 42759 4092 5 be be VB 42759 4092 6 found find VBN 42759 4092 7 or or CC 42759 4092 8 identified identify VBN 42759 4092 9 the the DT 42759 4092 10 ill ill RB 42759 4092 11 - - HYPH 42759 4092 12 gotten get VBN 42759 4092 13 gains gain NNS 42759 4092 14 must must MD 42759 4092 15 be be VB 42759 4092 16 turned turn VBN 42759 4092 17 over over RP 42759 4092 18 to to IN 42759 4092 19 charitable charitable JJ 42759 4092 20 or or CC 42759 4092 21 other other JJ 42759 4092 22 worthy worthy JJ 42759 4092 23 objects object NNS 42759 4092 24 . . . 42759 4093 1 Since since IN 42759 4093 2 the the DT 42759 4093 3 goods good NNS 42759 4093 4 do do VBP 42759 4093 5 not not RB 42759 4093 6 belong belong VB 42759 4093 7 to to IN 42759 4093 8 the the DT 42759 4093 9 present present JJ 42759 4093 10 holder holder NN 42759 4093 11 by by IN 42759 4093 12 any any DT 42759 4093 13 valid valid JJ 42759 4093 14 moral moral JJ 42759 4093 15 title title NN 42759 4093 16 , , , 42759 4093 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4093 18 should should MD 42759 4093 19 be be VB 42759 4093 20 given give VBN 42759 4093 21 to to IN 42759 4093 22 those those DT 42759 4093 23 persons person NNS 42759 4093 24 who who WP 42759 4093 25 are be VBP 42759 4093 26 qualified qualify VBN 42759 4093 27 by by IN 42759 4093 28 at at RB 42759 4093 29 least least JJS 42759 4093 30 the the DT 42759 4093 31 claim claim NN 42759 4093 32 and and CC 42759 4093 33 title title NN 42759 4093 34 of of IN 42759 4093 35 needs need NNS 42759 4093 36 . . . 42759 4094 1 Some some DT 42759 4094 2 of of IN 42759 4094 3 the the DT 42759 4094 4 Fathers father NNS 42759 4094 5 of of IN 42759 4094 6 the the DT 42759 4094 7 Church Church NNP 42759 4094 8 maintained maintain VBD 42759 4094 9 that that IN 42759 4094 10 all all DT 42759 4094 11 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4094 12 wealth wealth NN 42759 4094 13 , , , 42759 4094 14 whether whether IN 42759 4094 15 well well RB 42759 4094 16 or or CC 42759 4094 17 ill ill RB 42759 4094 18 gotten get VBN 42759 4094 19 , , , 42759 4094 20 ought ought MD 42759 4094 21 to to TO 42759 4094 22 be be VB 42759 4094 23 distributed distribute VBN 42759 4094 24 to to IN 42759 4094 25 those those DT 42759 4094 26 in in IN 42759 4094 27 want want NN 42759 4094 28 . . . 42759 4095 1 St. St. NNP 42759 4096 1 Basil Basil NNP 42759 4096 2 of of IN 42759 4096 3 Cæsarea Cæsarea NNP 42759 4096 4 : : : 42759 4096 5 " " `` 42759 4096 6 Will Will MD 42759 4096 7 not not RB 42759 4096 8 the the DT 42759 4096 9 man man NN 42759 4096 10 who who WP 42759 4096 11 robs rob VBZ 42759 4096 12 another another DT 42759 4096 13 of of IN 42759 4096 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4096 15 clothing clothing NN 42759 4096 16 be be VB 42759 4096 17 called call VBN 42759 4096 18 a a DT 42759 4096 19 thief thief NN 42759 4096 20 ? ? . 42759 4097 1 Is be VBZ 42759 4097 2 the the DT 42759 4097 3 man man NN 42759 4097 4 who who WP 42759 4097 5 is be VBZ 42759 4097 6 able able JJ 42759 4097 7 and and CC 42759 4097 8 refuses refuse VBZ 42759 4097 9 to to TO 42759 4097 10 clothe clothe VB 42759 4097 11 the the DT 42759 4097 12 naked naked JJ 42759 4097 13 deserving deserving NN 42759 4097 14 of of IN 42759 4097 15 any any DT 42759 4097 16 other other JJ 42759 4097 17 appellation appellation NN 42759 4097 18 ? ? . 42759 4098 1 The the DT 42759 4098 2 bread bread NN 42759 4098 3 that that WDT 42759 4098 4 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4098 5 withhold withhold VBP 42759 4098 6 belongs belong VBZ 42759 4098 7 to to IN 42759 4098 8 the the DT 42759 4098 9 hungry hungry JJ 42759 4098 10 ; ; : 42759 4098 11 the the DT 42759 4098 12 cloak cloak NN 42759 4098 13 that that WDT 42759 4098 14 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4098 15 retain retain VBP 42759 4098 16 in in IN 42759 4098 17 your -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4098 18 chest chest NN 42759 4098 19 belongs belong VBZ 42759 4098 20 to to IN 42759 4098 21 the the DT 42759 4098 22 naked naked JJ 42759 4098 23 ; ; : 42759 4098 24 the the DT 42759 4098 25 shoes shoe NNS 42759 4098 26 that that WDT 42759 4098 27 are be VBP 42759 4098 28 decaying decay VBG 42759 4098 29 in in IN 42759 4098 30 your -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4098 31 possession possession NN 42759 4098 32 belong belong VBP 42759 4098 33 to to IN 42759 4098 34 the the DT 42759 4098 35 shoeless shoeless NN 42759 4098 36 ; ; : 42759 4098 37 the the DT 42759 4098 38 gold gold NN 42759 4098 39 that that WDT 42759 4098 40 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4098 41 have have VBP 42759 4098 42 hidden hide VBN 42759 4098 43 in in IN 42759 4098 44 the the DT 42759 4098 45 ground ground NN 42759 4098 46 belongs belong VBZ 42759 4098 47 to to IN 42759 4098 48 the the DT 42759 4098 49 indigent indigent NN 42759 4098 50 . . . 42759 4099 1 Wherefore wherefore NN 42759 4099 2 , , , 42759 4099 3 as as RB 42759 4099 4 often often RB 42759 4099 5 as as IN 42759 4099 6 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4099 7 were be VBD 42759 4099 8 able able JJ 42759 4099 9 to to TO 42759 4099 10 help help VB 42759 4099 11 men man NNS 42759 4099 12 and and CC 42759 4099 13 refused refuse VBD 42759 4099 14 , , , 42759 4099 15 so so RB 42759 4099 16 often often RB 42759 4099 17 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4099 18 did do VBD 42759 4099 19 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4099 20 wrong wrong RB 42759 4099 21 . . . 42759 4100 1 " " `` 42759 4100 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4100 3 202 202 CD 42759 4100 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4100 5 St. St. NNP 42759 4100 6 Augustine Augustine NNP 42759 4100 7 of of IN 42759 4100 8 Hippo Hippo NNP 42759 4100 9 : : : 42759 4100 10 " " `` 42759 4100 11 The the DT 42759 4100 12 superfluities superfluity NNS 42759 4100 13 of of IN 42759 4100 14 the the DT 42759 4100 15 rich rich JJ 42759 4100 16 are be VBP 42759 4100 17 the the DT 42759 4100 18 necessities necessity NNS 42759 4100 19 of of IN 42759 4100 20 the the DT 42759 4100 21 poor poor JJ 42759 4100 22 . . . 42759 4101 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4101 2 who who WP 42759 4101 3 possess possess VBP 42759 4101 4 superfluities superfluity NNS 42759 4101 5 possess possess VBP 42759 4101 6 the the DT 42759 4101 7 goods good NNS 42759 4101 8 of of IN 42759 4101 9 others other NNS 42759 4101 10 . . . 42759 4102 1 " " `` 42759 4102 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4102 3 203 203 CD 42759 4102 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4102 5 St. St. NNP 42759 4102 6 Ambrose Ambrose NNP 42759 4102 7 of of IN 42759 4102 8 Milan Milan NNP 42759 4102 9 : : : 42759 4102 10 " " `` 42759 4102 11 The the DT 42759 4102 12 earth earth NN 42759 4102 13 belongs belong VBZ 42759 4102 14 to to IN 42759 4102 15 all all DT 42759 4102 16 ; ; : 42759 4102 17 not not RB 42759 4102 18 to to IN 42759 4102 19 the the DT 42759 4102 20 rich rich JJ 42759 4102 21 ; ; : 42759 4102 22 but but CC 42759 4102 23 those those DT 42759 4102 24 who who WP 42759 4102 25 possess possess VBP 42759 4102 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4102 27 shares share NNS 42759 4102 28 are be VBP 42759 4102 29 fewer few JJR 42759 4102 30 than than IN 42759 4102 31 those those DT 42759 4102 32 who who WP 42759 4102 33 do do VBP 42759 4102 34 not not RB 42759 4102 35 . . . 42759 4103 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 4103 2 , , , 42759 4103 3 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4103 4 are be VBP 42759 4103 5 paying pay VBG 42759 4103 6 a a DT 42759 4103 7 debt debt NN 42759 4103 8 , , , 42759 4103 9 not not RB 42759 4103 10 bestowing bestow VBG 42759 4103 11 a a DT 42759 4103 12 gift gift NN 42759 4103 13 . . . 42759 4104 1 " " `` 42759 4104 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4104 3 204 204 CD 42759 4104 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4104 5 Pope Pope NNP 42759 4104 6 Gregory Gregory NNP 42759 4104 7 the the DT 42759 4104 8 Great Great NNP 42759 4104 9 : : : 42759 4104 10 " " `` 42759 4104 11 When when WRB 42759 4104 12 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4104 13 give give VBP 42759 4104 14 necessaries necessary NNS 42759 4104 15 to to IN 42759 4104 16 the the DT 42759 4104 17 needy needy NN 42759 4104 18 , , , 42759 4104 19 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4104 20 do do VBP 42759 4104 21 not not RB 42759 4104 22 bestow bestow VB 42759 4104 23 upon upon IN 42759 4104 24 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4104 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4104 26 goods good NNS 42759 4104 27 ; ; : 42759 4104 28 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4104 29 return return VBP 42759 4104 30 to to IN 42759 4104 31 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4104 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4104 33 own own JJ 42759 4104 34 ; ; : 42759 4104 35 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4104 36 pay pay VBP 42759 4104 37 a a DT 42759 4104 38 debt debt NN 42759 4104 39 of of IN 42759 4104 40 justice justice NN 42759 4104 41 rather rather RB 42759 4104 42 than than IN 42759 4104 43 of of IN 42759 4104 44 mercy mercy NN 42759 4104 45 . . . 42759 4105 1 " " `` 42759 4105 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4105 3 205 205 CD 42759 4105 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4105 5 The the DT 42759 4105 6 great great JJ 42759 4105 7 systematiser systematiser NN 42759 4105 8 of of IN 42759 4105 9 theology theology NN 42759 4105 10 in in IN 42759 4105 11 the the DT 42759 4105 12 thirteenth thirteenth JJ 42759 4105 13 century century NN 42759 4105 14 , , , 42759 4105 15 St. St. NNP 42759 4105 16 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 4105 17 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 42759 4105 18 , , , 42759 4105 19 who who WP 42759 4105 20 is be VBZ 42759 4105 21 universally universally RB 42759 4105 22 recognised recognise VBN 42759 4105 23 as as IN 42759 4105 24 the the DT 42759 4105 25 most most RBS 42759 4105 26 authoritative authoritative JJ 42759 4105 27 private private JJ 42759 4105 28 teacher teacher NN 42759 4105 29 in in IN 42759 4105 30 the the DT 42759 4105 31 Church Church NNP 42759 4105 32 , , , 42759 4105 33 stated state VBD 42759 4105 34 the the DT 42759 4105 35 obligation obligation NN 42759 4105 36 of of IN 42759 4105 37 distribution distribution NN 42759 4105 38 in in IN 42759 4105 39 less less RBR 42759 4105 40 extreme extreme JJ 42759 4105 41 and and CC 42759 4105 42 more more RBR 42759 4105 43 scientific scientific JJ 42759 4105 44 terms term NNS 42759 4105 45 : : : 42759 4105 46 " " `` 42759 4105 47 According accord VBG 42759 4105 48 to to IN 42759 4105 49 the the DT 42759 4105 50 order order NN 42759 4105 51 of of IN 42759 4105 52 nature nature NN 42759 4105 53 instituted institute VBN 42759 4105 54 by by IN 42759 4105 55 Divine Divine NNP 42759 4105 56 Providence Providence NNP 42759 4105 57 , , , 42759 4105 58 the the DT 42759 4105 59 goods good NNS 42759 4105 60 of of IN 42759 4105 61 the the DT 42759 4105 62 earth earth NN 42759 4105 63 are be VBP 42759 4105 64 designed design VBN 42759 4105 65 to to TO 42759 4105 66 supply supply VB 42759 4105 67 the the DT 42759 4105 68 needs need NNS 42759 4105 69 of of IN 42759 4105 70 men man NNS 42759 4105 71 . . . 42759 4106 1 The the DT 42759 4106 2 division division NN 42759 4106 3 of of IN 42759 4106 4 goods good NNS 42759 4106 5 and and CC 42759 4106 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4106 7 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 4106 8 through through IN 42759 4106 9 human human JJ 42759 4106 10 law law NN 42759 4106 11 do do VBP 42759 4106 12 not not RB 42759 4106 13 thwart thwart VB 42759 4106 14 this this DT 42759 4106 15 purpose purpose NN 42759 4106 16 . . . 42759 4107 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 4107 2 , , , 42759 4107 3 the the DT 42759 4107 4 goods good NNS 42759 4107 5 which which WDT 42759 4107 6 a a DT 42759 4107 7 man man NN 42759 4107 8 has have VBZ 42759 4107 9 in in IN 42759 4107 10 superfluity superfluity NN 42759 4107 11 are be VBP 42759 4107 12 due due JJ 42759 4107 13 by by IN 42759 4107 14 the the DT 42759 4107 15 natural natural JJ 42759 4107 16 law law NN 42759 4107 17 to to IN 42759 4107 18 the the DT 42759 4107 19 sustenance sustenance NN 42759 4107 20 of of IN 42759 4107 21 the the DT 42759 4107 22 poor poor JJ 42759 4107 23 . . . 42759 4108 1 " " `` 42759 4108 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4108 3 206 206 CD 42759 4108 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4108 5 That that IN 42759 4108 6 this this DT 42759 4108 7 is be VBZ 42759 4108 8 the the DT 42759 4108 9 official official JJ 42759 4108 10 teaching teaching NN 42759 4108 11 of of IN 42759 4108 12 the the DT 42759 4108 13 Church Church NNP 42759 4108 14 to to IN 42759 4108 15 - - HYPH 42759 4108 16 day day NN 42759 4108 17 is be VBZ 42759 4108 18 evident evident JJ 42759 4108 19 from from IN 42759 4108 20 the the DT 42759 4108 21 words word NNS 42759 4108 22 of of IN 42759 4108 23 Pope Pope NNP 42759 4108 24 Leo Leo NNP 42759 4108 25 XIII XIII NNP 42759 4108 26 : : : 42759 4108 27 " " `` 42759 4108 28 When when WRB 42759 4108 29 one one PRP 42759 4108 30 has have VBZ 42759 4108 31 provided provide VBN 42759 4108 32 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 4108 33 for for IN 42759 4108 34 one one CD 42759 4108 35 's 's POS 42759 4108 36 necessities necessity NNS 42759 4108 37 and and CC 42759 4108 38 the the DT 42759 4108 39 demands demand NNS 42759 4108 40 of of IN 42759 4108 41 one one NN 42759 4108 42 's 's POS 42759 4108 43 state state NN 42759 4108 44 of of IN 42759 4108 45 life life NN 42759 4108 46 , , , 42759 4108 47 there there EX 42759 4108 48 is be VBZ 42759 4108 49 a a DT 42759 4108 50 duty duty NN 42759 4108 51 to to TO 42759 4108 52 give give VB 42759 4108 53 to to IN 42759 4108 54 the the DT 42759 4108 55 indigent indigent NN 42759 4108 56 out out IN 42759 4108 57 of of IN 42759 4108 58 what what WP 42759 4108 59 remains remain VBZ 42759 4108 60 . . . 42759 4109 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4109 2 is be VBZ 42759 4109 3 a a DT 42759 4109 4 duty duty NN 42759 4109 5 not not RB 42759 4109 6 of of IN 42759 4109 7 strict strict JJ 42759 4109 8 justice justice NN 42759 4109 9 , , , 42759 4109 10 save save VB 42759 4109 11 in in IN 42759 4109 12 case case NN 42759 4109 13 of of IN 42759 4109 14 extreme extreme JJ 42759 4109 15 necessity necessity NN 42759 4109 16 , , , 42759 4109 17 but but CC 42759 4109 18 of of IN 42759 4109 19 Christian christian JJ 42759 4109 20 charity charity NN 42759 4109 21 . . . 42759 4110 1 " " `` 42759 4110 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4110 3 207 207 CD 42759 4110 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4110 5 Nearly nearly RB 42759 4110 6 thirteen thirteen CD 42759 4110 7 years year NNS 42759 4110 8 earlier early RBR 42759 4110 9 , , , 42759 4110 10 the the DT 42759 4110 11 same same JJ 42759 4110 12 Pope Pope NNP 42759 4110 13 had have VBD 42759 4110 14 written write VBN 42759 4110 15 : : : 42759 4110 16 " " `` 42759 4110 17 The the DT 42759 4110 18 Church Church NNP 42759 4110 19 lays lay VBZ 42759 4110 20 the the DT 42759 4110 21 rich rich JJ 42759 4110 22 under under IN 42759 4110 23 strict strict JJ 42759 4110 24 command command NN 42759 4110 25 to to TO 42759 4110 26 give give VB 42759 4110 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4110 28 superfluity superfluity NN 42759 4110 29 to to IN 42759 4110 30 the the DT 42759 4110 31 poor poor JJ 42759 4110 32 . . . 42759 4111 1 " " `` 42759 4111 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4111 3 208 208 CD 42759 4111 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4111 5 The the DT 42759 4111 6 only only JJ 42759 4111 7 difference difference NN 42759 4111 8 between between IN 42759 4111 9 the the DT 42759 4111 10 Fathers Fathers NNPS 42759 4111 11 and and CC 42759 4111 12 Pope Pope NNP 42759 4111 13 Leo Leo NNP 42759 4111 14 XIII XIII NNP 42759 4111 15 and and CC 42759 4111 16 St. St. NNP 42759 4111 17 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 4111 18 on on IN 42759 4111 19 this this DT 42759 4111 20 question question NN 42759 4111 21 has have VBZ 42759 4111 22 reference reference NN 42759 4111 23 to to IN 42759 4111 24 the the DT 42759 4111 25 precise precise JJ 42759 4111 26 nature nature NN 42759 4111 27 of of IN 42759 4111 28 the the DT 42759 4111 29 obligation obligation NN 42759 4111 30 . . . 42759 4112 1 According accord VBG 42759 4112 2 to to IN 42759 4112 3 the the DT 42759 4112 4 Fathers father NNS 42759 4112 5 , , , 42759 4112 6 the the DT 42759 4112 7 duty duty NN 42759 4112 8 of of IN 42759 4112 9 distribution distribution NN 42759 4112 10 would would MD 42759 4112 11 seem seem VB 42759 4112 12 to to TO 42759 4112 13 be be VB 42759 4112 14 a a DT 42759 4112 15 duty duty NN 42759 4112 16 of of IN 42759 4112 17 justice justice NN 42759 4112 18 . . . 42759 4113 1 In in IN 42759 4113 2 the the DT 42759 4113 3 passage passage NN 42759 4113 4 quoted quote VBN 42759 4113 5 above above RB 42759 4113 6 from from IN 42759 4113 7 St. St. NNP 42759 4113 8 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 4113 9 , , , 42759 4113 10 superfluities superfluity NNS 42759 4113 11 are be VBP 42759 4113 12 said say VBN 42759 4113 13 to to TO 42759 4113 14 " " `` 42759 4113 15 belong belong VB 42759 4113 16 , , , 42759 4113 17 " " '' 42759 4113 18 or or CC 42759 4113 19 to to TO 42759 4113 20 be be VB 42759 4113 21 " " `` 42759 4113 22 due due JJ 42759 4113 23 " " '' 42759 4113 24 ( ( -LRB- 42759 4113 25 " " `` 42759 4113 26 debetur debetur NNP 42759 4113 27 " " '' 42759 4113 28 ) ) -RRB- 42759 4113 29 to to IN 42759 4113 30 the the DT 42759 4113 31 needy needy NN 42759 4113 32 ; ; : 42759 4113 33 but but CC 42759 4113 34 the the DT 42759 4113 35 particular particular JJ 42759 4113 36 moral moral NN 42759 4113 37 precept precept VBD 42759 4113 38 that that IN 42759 4113 39 applies apply VBZ 42759 4113 40 is be VBZ 42759 4113 41 not not RB 42759 4113 42 specified specify VBN 42759 4113 43 . . . 42759 4114 1 In in IN 42759 4114 2 another another DT 42759 4114 3 place place NN 42759 4114 4 , , , 42759 4114 5 however however RB 42759 4114 6 , , , 42759 4114 7 the the DT 42759 4114 8 Angelic Angelic NNP 42759 4114 9 Doctor Doctor NNP 42759 4114 10 declares declare VBZ 42759 4114 11 that that IN 42759 4114 12 almsgiving almsgiving NN 42759 4114 13 is be VBZ 42759 4114 14 an an DT 42759 4114 15 act act NN 42759 4114 16 of of IN 42759 4114 17 charity charity NN 42759 4114 18 . . . 42759 4115 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4115 2 209 209 CD 42759 4115 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4115 4 Pope Pope NNP 42759 4115 5 Leo Leo NNP 42759 4115 6 XIII XIII NNP 42759 4115 7 explicitly explicitly RB 42759 4115 8 says say VBZ 42759 4115 9 that that IN 42759 4115 10 the the DT 42759 4115 11 obligation obligation NN 42759 4115 12 of of IN 42759 4115 13 giving give VBG 42759 4115 14 is be VBZ 42759 4115 15 one one CD 42759 4115 16 of of IN 42759 4115 17 charity charity NN 42759 4115 18 , , , 42759 4115 19 " " '' 42759 4115 20 except except IN 42759 4115 21 in in IN 42759 4115 22 extreme extreme JJ 42759 4115 23 cases case NNS 42759 4115 24 . . . 42759 4115 25 " " '' 42759 4116 1 The the DT 42759 4116 2 latter latter JJ 42759 4116 3 phrase phrase NN 42759 4116 4 refers refer VBZ 42759 4116 5 to to IN 42759 4116 6 the the DT 42759 4116 7 traditional traditional JJ 42759 4116 8 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4116 9 that that IN 42759 4116 10 a a DT 42759 4116 11 person person NN 42759 4116 12 who who WP 42759 4116 13 is be VBZ 42759 4116 14 in in IN 42759 4116 15 extreme extreme JJ 42759 4116 16 need need NN 42759 4116 17 ; ; : 42759 4116 18 that that RB 42759 4116 19 is is RB 42759 4116 20 , , , 42759 4116 21 in in IN 42759 4116 22 immediate immediate JJ 42759 4116 23 danger danger NN 42759 4116 24 of of IN 42759 4116 25 losing lose VBG 42759 4116 26 life life NN 42759 4116 27 , , , 42759 4116 28 limb limb NN 42759 4116 29 , , , 42759 4116 30 or or CC 42759 4116 31 some some DT 42759 4116 32 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 4116 33 personal personal JJ 42759 4116 34 good good NN 42759 4116 35 , , , 42759 4116 36 is be VBZ 42759 4116 37 justified justify VBN 42759 4116 38 in in IN 42759 4116 39 the the DT 42759 4116 40 absence absence NN 42759 4116 41 of of IN 42759 4116 42 any any DT 42759 4116 43 other other JJ 42759 4116 44 means mean NNS 42759 4116 45 of of IN 42759 4116 46 succour succour NN 42759 4116 47 in in IN 42759 4116 48 taking take VBG 42759 4116 49 from from IN 42759 4116 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4116 51 neighbour neighbour NN 42759 4116 52 what what WP 42759 4116 53 is be VBZ 42759 4116 54 absolutely absolutely RB 42759 4116 55 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4116 56 . . . 42759 4117 1 Such such JJ 42759 4117 2 appropriation appropriation NN 42759 4117 3 , , , 42759 4117 4 says say VBZ 42759 4117 5 St. St. NNP 42759 4117 6 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 4117 7 , , , 42759 4117 8 is be VBZ 42759 4117 9 not not RB 42759 4117 10 properly properly RB 42759 4117 11 speaking speak VBG 42759 4117 12 theft theft NN 42759 4117 13 ; ; , 42759 4117 14 for for IN 42759 4117 15 the the DT 42759 4117 16 goods good NNS 42759 4117 17 seized seize VBN 42759 4117 18 belong belong VBP 42759 4117 19 to to IN 42759 4117 20 the the DT 42759 4117 21 needy needy JJ 42759 4117 22 person person NN 42759 4117 23 , , , 42759 4117 24 " " '' 42759 4117 25 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 4117 26 as as IN 42759 4117 27 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4117 28 must must MD 42759 4117 29 sustain sustain VB 42759 4117 30 life life NN 42759 4117 31 . . . 42759 4118 1 " " `` 42759 4118 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4118 3 210 210 CD 42759 4118 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4118 5 In in IN 42759 4118 6 a a DT 42759 4118 7 word word NN 42759 4118 8 , , , 42759 4118 9 the the DT 42759 4118 10 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 4118 11 and and CC 42759 4118 12 the the DT 42759 4118 13 modern modern JJ 42759 4118 14 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 4118 15 teaching teaching NN 42759 4118 16 would would MD 42759 4118 17 make make VB 42759 4118 18 distribution distribution NN 42759 4118 19 of of IN 42759 4118 20 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4118 21 goods good NNS 42759 4118 22 a a DT 42759 4118 23 duty duty NN 42759 4118 24 of of IN 42759 4118 25 justice justice NN 42759 4118 26 only only RB 42759 4118 27 in in IN 42759 4118 28 extreme extreme JJ 42759 4118 29 situations situation NNS 42759 4118 30 , , , 42759 4118 31 while while IN 42759 4118 32 the the DT 42759 4118 33 Fathers father NNS 42759 4118 34 laid lay VBD 42759 4118 35 down down RP 42759 4118 36 no no DT 42759 4118 37 such such JJ 42759 4118 38 specific specific JJ 42759 4118 39 limitation limitation NN 42759 4118 40 . . . 42759 4119 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 4119 2 , , , 42759 4119 3 the the DT 42759 4119 4 difference difference NN 42759 4119 5 is be VBZ 42759 4119 6 less less RBR 42759 4119 7 important important JJ 42759 4119 8 than than IN 42759 4119 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4119 10 appears appear VBZ 42759 4119 11 to to TO 42759 4119 12 be be VB 42759 4119 13 on on IN 42759 4119 14 the the DT 42759 4119 15 surface surface NN 42759 4119 16 . . . 42759 4120 1 When when WRB 42759 4120 2 the the DT 42759 4120 3 Fathers father NNS 42759 4120 4 lived live VBD 42759 4120 5 , , , 42759 4120 6 theology theology NN 42759 4120 7 had have VBD 42759 4120 8 not not RB 42759 4120 9 been be VBN 42759 4120 10 systematised systematise VBN 42759 4120 11 nor nor CC 42759 4120 12 given give VBN 42759 4120 13 a a DT 42759 4120 14 precise precise JJ 42759 4120 15 terminology terminology NN 42759 4120 16 ; ; : 42759 4120 17 consequently consequently RB 42759 4120 18 , , , 42759 4120 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4120 20 did do VBD 42759 4120 21 not not RB 42759 4120 22 always always RB 42759 4120 23 make make VB 42759 4120 24 exact exact JJ 42759 4120 25 distinctions distinction NNS 42759 4120 26 between between IN 42759 4120 27 the the DT 42759 4120 28 different different JJ 42759 4120 29 classes class NNS 42759 4120 30 of of IN 42759 4120 31 virtues virtue NNS 42759 4120 32 and and CC 42759 4120 33 obligations obligation NNS 42759 4120 34 . . . 42759 4121 1 In in IN 42759 4121 2 the the DT 42759 4121 3 second second JJ 42759 4121 4 place place NN 42759 4121 5 , , , 42759 4121 6 the the DT 42759 4121 7 Patristic patristic JJ 42759 4121 8 passages passage NNS 42759 4121 9 that that WDT 42759 4121 10 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4121 11 have have VBP 42759 4121 12 quoted quote VBN 42759 4121 13 , , , 42759 4121 14 and and CC 42759 4121 15 others other NNS 42759 4121 16 of of IN 42759 4121 17 like like IN 42759 4121 18 import import NN 42759 4121 19 , , , 42759 4121 20 were be VBD 42759 4121 21 mostly mostly RB 42759 4121 22 contained contain VBN 42759 4121 23 in in IN 42759 4121 24 sermons sermon NNS 42759 4121 25 addressed address VBN 42759 4121 26 to to IN 42759 4121 27 the the DT 42759 4121 28 rich rich JJ 42759 4121 29 , , , 42759 4121 30 and and CC 42759 4121 31 consequently consequently RB 42759 4121 32 were be VBD 42759 4121 33 expressed express VBN 42759 4121 34 in in IN 42759 4121 35 hortatory hortatory NN 42759 4121 36 rather rather RB 42759 4121 37 than than IN 42759 4121 38 scientific scientific JJ 42759 4121 39 terms term NNS 42759 4121 40 . . . 42759 4122 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4122 2 , , , 42759 4122 3 the the DT 42759 4122 4 needs need NNS 42759 4122 5 of of IN 42759 4122 6 the the DT 42759 4122 7 time time NN 42759 4122 8 which which WDT 42759 4122 9 the the DT 42759 4122 10 rich rich JJ 42759 4122 11 were be VBD 42759 4122 12 exhorted exhort VBN 42759 4122 13 to to TO 42759 4122 14 relieve relieve VB 42759 4122 15 were be VBD 42759 4122 16 probably probably RB 42759 4122 17 so so RB 42759 4122 18 urgent urgent JJ 42759 4122 19 that that IN 42759 4122 20 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4122 21 could could MD 42759 4122 22 correctly correctly RB 42759 4122 23 be be VB 42759 4122 24 classed class VBN 42759 4122 25 as as IN 42759 4122 26 extreme extreme JJ 42759 4122 27 , , , 42759 4122 28 and and CC 42759 4122 29 therefore therefore RB 42759 4122 30 would would MD 42759 4122 31 give give VB 42759 4122 32 rise rise NN 42759 4122 33 to to IN 42759 4122 34 an an DT 42759 4122 35 obligation obligation NN 42759 4122 36 of of IN 42759 4122 37 justice justice NN 42759 4122 38 on on IN 42759 4122 39 the the DT 42759 4122 40 part part NN 42759 4122 41 of of IN 42759 4122 42 those those DT 42759 4122 43 who who WP 42759 4122 44 possessed possess VBD 42759 4122 45 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4122 46 wealth wealth NN 42759 4122 47 . . . 42759 4123 1 The the DT 42759 4123 2 truly truly RB 42759 4123 3 important important JJ 42759 4123 4 fact fact NN 42759 4123 5 of of IN 42759 4123 6 the the DT 42759 4123 7 whole whole JJ 42759 4123 8 situation situation NN 42759 4123 9 is be VBZ 42759 4123 10 that that IN 42759 4123 11 both both CC 42759 4123 12 the the DT 42759 4123 13 Fathers father NNS 42759 4123 14 and and CC 42759 4123 15 the the DT 42759 4123 16 later later JJ 42759 4123 17 authorities authority NNS 42759 4123 18 of of IN 42759 4123 19 the the DT 42759 4123 20 Church Church NNP 42759 4123 21 regard regard VBP 42759 4123 22 the the DT 42759 4123 23 task task NN 42759 4123 24 of of IN 42759 4123 25 distributing distribute VBG 42759 4123 26 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4123 27 goods good NNS 42759 4123 28 as as IN 42759 4123 29 one one CD 42759 4123 30 of of IN 42759 4123 31 strict strict JJ 42759 4123 32 moral moral JJ 42759 4123 33 obligation obligation NN 42759 4123 34 , , , 42759 4123 35 which which WDT 42759 4123 36 in in IN 42759 4123 37 serious serious JJ 42759 4123 38 cases case NNS 42759 4123 39 is be VBZ 42759 4123 40 binding bind VBG 42759 4123 41 under under IN 42759 4123 42 pain pain NN 42759 4123 43 of of IN 42759 4123 44 grievous grievous JJ 42759 4123 45 sin sin NN 42759 4123 46 . . . 42759 4124 1 Whether whether IN 42759 4124 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4124 3 falls fall VBZ 42759 4124 4 under under IN 42759 4124 5 the the DT 42759 4124 6 head head NN 42759 4124 7 of of IN 42759 4124 8 justice justice NN 42759 4124 9 or or CC 42759 4124 10 under under IN 42759 4124 11 that that DT 42759 4124 12 of of IN 42759 4124 13 charity charity NN 42759 4124 14 , , , 42759 4124 15 is be VBZ 42759 4124 16 of of IN 42759 4124 17 no no DT 42759 4124 18 great great JJ 42759 4124 19 practical practical JJ 42759 4124 20 consequence consequence NN 42759 4124 21 . . . 42759 4125 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4125 2 The the DT 42759 4125 3 Question Question NNP 42759 4125 4 of of IN 42759 4125 5 Distributing Distributing NNP 42759 4125 6 All all DT 42759 4125 7 _ _ NNP 42759 4125 8 Is be VBZ 42759 4125 9 a a DT 42759 4125 10 man man NN 42759 4125 11 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4125 12 to to TO 42759 4125 13 distribute distribute VB 42759 4125 14 _ _ NNP 42759 4125 15 all all DT 42759 4125 16 _ _ IN 42759 4125 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4125 18 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4125 19 wealth wealth NN 42759 4125 20 ? ? . 42759 4126 1 As as IN 42759 4126 2 regards regard VBZ 42759 4126 3 the the DT 42759 4126 4 support support NN 42759 4126 5 of of IN 42759 4126 6 human human JJ 42759 4126 7 life life NN 42759 4126 8 , , , 42759 4126 9 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 4126 10 moral moral JJ 42759 4126 11 theologians theologian NNS 42759 4126 12 distinguish distinguish VBP 42759 4126 13 three three CD 42759 4126 14 classes class NNS 42759 4126 15 of of IN 42759 4126 16 goods good NNS 42759 4126 17 : : : 42759 4126 18 first first RB 42759 4126 19 , , , 42759 4126 20 the the DT 42759 4126 21 necessaries necessary NNS 42759 4126 22 of of IN 42759 4126 23 life life NN 42759 4126 24 , , , 42759 4126 25 those those DT 42759 4126 26 utilities utility NNS 42759 4126 27 which which WDT 42759 4126 28 are be VBP 42759 4126 29 essential essential JJ 42759 4126 30 to to IN 42759 4126 31 a a DT 42759 4126 32 healthy healthy JJ 42759 4126 33 and and CC 42759 4126 34 humane humane JJ 42759 4126 35 existence existence NN 42759 4126 36 for for IN 42759 4126 37 a a DT 42759 4126 38 man man NN 42759 4126 39 and and CC 42759 4126 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4126 41 family family NN 42759 4126 42 , , , 42759 4126 43 regardless regardless RB 42759 4126 44 of of IN 42759 4126 45 the the DT 42759 4126 46 social social JJ 42759 4126 47 position position NN 42759 4126 48 that that WDT 42759 4126 49 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4126 50 may may MD 42759 4126 51 occupy occupy VB 42759 4126 52 , , , 42759 4126 53 or or CC 42759 4126 54 the the DT 42759 4126 55 standard standard NN 42759 4126 56 of of IN 42759 4126 57 life life NN 42759 4126 58 to to TO 42759 4126 59 which which WDT 42759 4126 60 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4126 61 may may MD 42759 4126 62 have have VB 42759 4126 63 been be VBN 42759 4126 64 accustomed accustom VBN 42759 4126 65 ; ; : 42759 4126 66 second second LS 42759 4126 67 , , , 42759 4126 68 the the DT 42759 4126 69 conventional conventional JJ 42759 4126 70 necessities necessity NNS 42759 4126 71 and and CC 42759 4126 72 comforts comfort NNS 42759 4126 73 , , , 42759 4126 74 which which WDT 42759 4126 75 correspond correspond VBP 42759 4126 76 to to IN 42759 4126 77 the the DT 42759 4126 78 social social JJ 42759 4126 79 plane plane NN 42759 4126 80 upon upon IN 42759 4126 81 which which WDT 42759 4126 82 the the DT 42759 4126 83 individual individual NN 42759 4126 84 or or CC 42759 4126 85 family family NN 42759 4126 86 moves move NNS 42759 4126 87 ; ; : 42759 4126 88 third third RB 42759 4126 89 , , , 42759 4126 90 those those DT 42759 4126 91 goods good NNS 42759 4126 92 which which WDT 42759 4126 93 are be VBP 42759 4126 94 not not RB 42759 4126 95 required require VBN 42759 4126 96 to to TO 42759 4126 97 support support VB 42759 4126 98 either either CC 42759 4126 99 existence existence NN 42759 4126 100 or or CC 42759 4126 101 social social JJ 42759 4126 102 position position NN 42759 4126 103 . . . 42759 4127 1 Goods good NNS 42759 4127 2 of of IN 42759 4127 3 the the DT 42759 4127 4 second second JJ 42759 4127 5 class class NN 42759 4127 6 are be VBP 42759 4127 7 said say VBN 42759 4127 8 to to TO 42759 4127 9 be be VB 42759 4127 10 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4127 11 as as IN 42759 4127 12 regards regard VBZ 42759 4127 13 conventional conventional JJ 42759 4127 14 purposes purpose NNS 42759 4127 15 , , , 42759 4127 16 but but CC 42759 4127 17 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4127 18 as as IN 42759 4127 19 regards regard VBZ 42759 4127 20 the the DT 42759 4127 21 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 4127 22 of of IN 42759 4127 23 life life NN 42759 4127 24 , , , 42759 4127 25 while while IN 42759 4127 26 those those DT 42759 4127 27 of of IN 42759 4127 28 the the DT 42759 4127 29 third third JJ 42759 4127 30 class class NN 42759 4127 31 are be VBP 42759 4127 32 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4127 33 without without IN 42759 4127 34 qualification qualification NN 42759 4127 35 . . . 42759 4128 1 No no DT 42759 4128 2 obligation obligation NN 42759 4128 3 exists exist VBZ 42759 4128 4 to to TO 42759 4128 5 distribute distribute VB 42759 4128 6 the the DT 42759 4128 7 first first JJ 42759 4128 8 class class NN 42759 4128 9 of of IN 42759 4128 10 goods good NNS 42759 4128 11 ; ; : 42759 4128 12 for for IN 42759 4128 13 the the DT 42759 4128 14 possessor possessor NN 42759 4128 15 is be VBZ 42759 4128 16 justified justified JJ 42759 4128 17 in in IN 42759 4128 18 preferring prefer VBG 42759 4128 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4128 20 own own JJ 42759 4128 21 primary primary NN 42759 4128 22 and and CC 42759 4128 23 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4128 24 needs need NNS 42759 4128 25 to to IN 42759 4128 26 the the DT 42759 4128 27 equal equal JJ 42759 4128 28 or or CC 42759 4128 29 less less RBR 42759 4128 30 important important JJ 42759 4128 31 needs need NNS 42759 4128 32 of of IN 42759 4128 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4128 34 neighbours neighbour NNS 42759 4128 35 . . . 42759 4129 1 The the DT 42759 4129 2 owner owner NN 42759 4129 3 of of IN 42759 4129 4 goods good NNS 42759 4129 5 of of IN 42759 4129 6 the the DT 42759 4129 7 second second JJ 42759 4129 8 class class NN 42759 4129 9 is be VBZ 42759 4129 10 under under IN 42759 4129 11 obligation obligation NN 42759 4129 12 to to TO 42759 4129 13 dispense dispense VB 42759 4129 14 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4129 15 to to IN 42759 4129 16 persons person NNS 42759 4129 17 who who WP 42759 4129 18 are be VBP 42759 4129 19 in in IN 42759 4129 20 extreme extreme JJ 42759 4129 21 need need NN 42759 4129 22 , , , 42759 4129 23 since since IN 42759 4129 24 the the DT 42759 4129 25 preservation preservation NN 42759 4129 26 of of IN 42759 4129 27 the the DT 42759 4129 28 neighbour neighbour NN 42759 4129 29 's 's POS 42759 4129 30 life life NN 42759 4129 31 is be VBZ 42759 4129 32 more more RBR 42759 4129 33 important important JJ 42759 4129 34 morally morally RB 42759 4129 35 than than IN 42759 4129 36 the the DT 42759 4129 37 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 4129 38 of of IN 42759 4129 39 the the DT 42759 4129 40 owner owner NN 42759 4129 41 's 's POS 42759 4129 42 conventional conventional JJ 42759 4129 43 standard standard NN 42759 4129 44 of of IN 42759 4129 45 living living NN 42759 4129 46 . . . 42759 4130 1 On on IN 42759 4130 2 the the DT 42759 4130 3 other other JJ 42759 4130 4 hand hand NN 42759 4130 5 , , , 42759 4130 6 there there EX 42759 4130 7 is be VBZ 42759 4130 8 no no DT 42759 4130 9 obligation obligation NN 42759 4130 10 of of IN 42759 4130 11 giving give VBG 42759 4130 12 any any DT 42759 4130 13 of of IN 42759 4130 14 these these DT 42759 4130 15 goods good NNS 42759 4130 16 to to TO 42759 4130 17 meet meet VB 42759 4130 18 those those DT 42759 4130 19 needs need NNS 42759 4130 20 of of IN 42759 4130 21 the the DT 42759 4130 22 neighbour neighbour NN 42759 4130 23 which which WDT 42759 4130 24 are be VBP 42759 4130 25 social social JJ 42759 4130 26 or or CC 42759 4130 27 conventional conventional JJ 42759 4130 28 . . . 42759 4131 1 Here here RB 42759 4131 2 , , , 42759 4131 3 again again RB 42759 4131 4 , , , 42759 4131 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4131 6 is be VBZ 42759 4131 7 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4131 8 that that IN 42759 4131 9 the the DT 42759 4131 10 possessor possessor NN 42759 4131 11 should should MD 42759 4131 12 prefer prefer VB 42759 4131 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4131 14 own own JJ 42759 4131 15 interests interest NNS 42759 4131 16 to to IN 42759 4131 17 the the DT 42759 4131 18 equal equal JJ 42759 4131 19 interests interest NNS 42759 4131 20 of of IN 42759 4131 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4131 22 fellows fellow NNS 42759 4131 23 . . . 42759 4132 1 Still still RB 42759 4132 2 less less RBR 42759 4132 3 is be VBZ 42759 4132 4 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4132 5 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4132 6 to to TO 42759 4132 7 expend expend VB 42759 4132 8 any any DT 42759 4132 9 of of IN 42759 4132 10 the the DT 42759 4132 11 second second JJ 42759 4132 12 class class NN 42759 4132 13 of of IN 42759 4132 14 goods good NNS 42759 4132 15 for for IN 42759 4132 16 the the DT 42759 4132 17 relief relief NN 42759 4132 18 of of IN 42759 4132 19 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 4132 20 or or CC 42759 4132 21 common common JJ 42759 4132 22 distress distress NN 42759 4132 23 . . . 42759 4133 1 As as IN 42759 4133 2 regards regard VBZ 42759 4133 3 the the DT 42759 4133 4 third third JJ 42759 4133 5 class class NN 42759 4133 6 of of IN 42759 4133 7 goods good NNS 42759 4133 8 , , , 42759 4133 9 those those DT 42759 4133 10 which which WDT 42759 4133 11 are be VBP 42759 4133 12 absolutely absolutely RB 42759 4133 13 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4133 14 , , , 42759 4133 15 the the DT 42759 4133 16 proportion proportion NN 42759 4133 17 to to TO 42759 4133 18 be be VB 42759 4133 19 distributed distribute VBN 42759 4133 20 is be VBZ 42759 4133 21 indefinite indefinite JJ 42759 4133 22 , , , 42759 4133 23 depending depend VBG 42759 4133 24 upon upon IN 42759 4133 25 the the DT 42759 4133 26 volume volume NN 42759 4133 27 of of IN 42759 4133 28 need need NN 42759 4133 29 . . . 42759 4134 1 The the DT 42759 4134 2 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4134 3 of of IN 42759 4134 4 the the DT 42759 4134 5 moral moral JJ 42759 4134 6 theologians theologian NNS 42759 4134 7 on on IN 42759 4134 8 the the DT 42759 4134 9 subject subject NN 42759 4134 10 is be VBZ 42759 4134 11 summed sum VBN 42759 4134 12 up up RP 42759 4134 13 in in IN 42759 4134 14 the the DT 42759 4134 15 following follow VBG 42759 4134 16 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 4134 17 . . . 42759 4135 1 When when WRB 42759 4135 2 the the DT 42759 4135 3 needs need NNS 42759 4135 4 to to TO 42759 4135 5 be be VB 42759 4135 6 supplied supply VBN 42759 4135 7 are be VBP 42759 4135 8 " " `` 42759 4135 9 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 4135 10 , , , 42759 4135 11 " " '' 42759 4135 12 or or CC 42759 4135 13 " " `` 42759 4135 14 common common JJ 42759 4135 15 " " '' 42759 4135 16 ; ; : 42759 4135 17 that that RB 42759 4135 18 is is RB 42759 4135 19 , , , 42759 4135 20 when when WRB 42759 4135 21 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4135 22 merely merely RB 42759 4135 23 expose expose VBP 42759 4135 24 a a DT 42759 4135 25 person person NN 42759 4135 26 to to IN 42759 4135 27 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4135 28 and and CC 42759 4135 29 constant constant JJ 42759 4135 30 inconvenience inconvenience NN 42759 4135 31 , , , 42759 4135 32 without without IN 42759 4135 33 inflicting inflict VBG 42759 4135 34 serious serious JJ 42759 4135 35 physical physical JJ 42759 4135 36 , , , 42759 4135 37 mental mental JJ 42759 4135 38 , , , 42759 4135 39 or or CC 42759 4135 40 moral moral JJ 42759 4135 41 injury injury NN 42759 4135 42 , , , 42759 4135 43 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4135 44 do do VBP 42759 4135 45 not not RB 42759 4135 46 impose impose VB 42759 4135 47 upon upon IN 42759 4135 48 any any DT 42759 4135 49 man man NN 42759 4135 50 the the DT 42759 4135 51 obligation obligation NN 42759 4135 52 of of IN 42759 4135 53 giving give VBG 42759 4135 54 up up RP 42759 4135 55 all all PDT 42759 4135 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4135 57 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4135 58 goods good NNS 42759 4135 59 . . . 42759 4136 1 According accord VBG 42759 4136 2 to to IN 42759 4136 3 some some DT 42759 4136 4 moral moral JJ 42759 4136 5 theologians theologian NNS 42759 4136 6 , , , 42759 4136 7 the the DT 42759 4136 8 possessor possessor NN 42759 4136 9 fulfils fulfil VBZ 42759 4136 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4136 11 duty duty NN 42759 4136 12 in in IN 42759 4136 13 such such JJ 42759 4136 14 cases case NNS 42759 4136 15 if if IN 42759 4136 16 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4136 17 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 4136 18 that that IN 42759 4136 19 proportion proportion NN 42759 4136 20 of of IN 42759 4136 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4136 22 surplus surplus NN 42759 4136 23 which which WDT 42759 4136 24 would would MD 42759 4136 25 suffice suffice VB 42759 4136 26 for for IN 42759 4136 27 the the DT 42759 4136 28 removal removal NN 42759 4136 29 of of IN 42759 4136 30 all all DT 42759 4136 31 such such JJ 42759 4136 32 distress distress NN 42759 4136 33 , , , 42759 4136 34 provided provide VBN 42759 4136 35 that that IN 42759 4136 36 all all DT 42759 4136 37 other other JJ 42759 4136 38 possessors possessor NNS 42759 4136 39 were be VBD 42759 4136 40 equally equally RB 42759 4136 41 generous generous JJ 42759 4136 42 ; ; : 42759 4136 43 according accord VBG 42759 4136 44 to to IN 42759 4136 45 others other NNS 42759 4136 46 , , , 42759 4136 47 if if IN 42759 4136 48 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4136 49 gives give VBZ 42759 4136 50 two two CD 42759 4136 51 per per IN 42759 4136 52 cent cent NN 42759 4136 53 . . . 42759 4137 1 of of IN 42759 4137 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4137 3 superfluity superfluity NN 42759 4137 4 ; ; , 42759 4137 5 according accord VBG 42759 4137 6 to to IN 42759 4137 7 others other NNS 42759 4137 8 , , , 42759 4137 9 if if IN 42759 4137 10 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4137 11 contributes contribute VBZ 42759 4137 12 two two CD 42759 4137 13 per per IN 42759 4137 14 cent cent NN 42759 4137 15 . . . 42759 4138 1 of of IN 42759 4138 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4138 3 annual annual JJ 42759 4138 4 income income NN 42759 4138 5 . . . 42759 4139 1 These these DT 42759 4139 2 estimates estimate NNS 42759 4139 3 are be VBP 42759 4139 4 intended intend VBN 42759 4139 5 not not RB 42759 4139 6 so so RB 42759 4139 7 much much JJ 42759 4139 8 to to TO 42759 4139 9 define define VB 42759 4139 10 the the DT 42759 4139 11 exact exact JJ 42759 4139 12 measure measure NN 42759 4139 13 of of IN 42759 4139 14 obligation obligation NN 42759 4139 15 as as IN 42759 4139 16 to to TO 42759 4139 17 emphasise emphasise VB 42759 4139 18 the the DT 42759 4139 19 fact fact NN 42759 4139 20 that that IN 42759 4139 21 there there EX 42759 4139 22 exists exist VBZ 42759 4139 23 some some DT 42759 4139 24 degree degree NN 42759 4139 25 of of IN 42759 4139 26 obligation obligation NN 42759 4139 27 ; ; : 42759 4139 28 for for IN 42759 4139 29 all all PDT 42759 4139 30 the the DT 42759 4139 31 moral moral JJ 42759 4139 32 theologians theologian NNS 42759 4139 33 agree agree VBP 42759 4139 34 that that IN 42759 4139 35 some some DT 42759 4139 36 portion portion NN 42759 4139 37 of of IN 42759 4139 38 a a DT 42759 4139 39 man man NN 42759 4139 40 's 's POS 42759 4139 41 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4139 42 goods good NNS 42759 4139 43 ought ought MD 42759 4139 44 to to TO 42759 4139 45 be be VB 42759 4139 46 given give VBN 42759 4139 47 for for IN 42759 4139 48 the the DT 42759 4139 49 relief relief NN 42759 4139 50 of of IN 42759 4139 51 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 4139 52 or or CC 42759 4139 53 common common JJ 42759 4139 54 needs need NNS 42759 4139 55 . . . 42759 4140 1 When when WRB 42759 4140 2 , , , 42759 4140 3 however however RB 42759 4140 4 , , , 42759 4140 5 the the DT 42759 4140 6 distress distress NN 42759 4140 7 is be VBZ 42759 4140 8 grave grave JJ 42759 4140 9 ; ; : 42759 4140 10 that that RB 42759 4140 11 is is RB 42759 4140 12 , , , 42759 4140 13 when when WRB 42759 4140 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4140 15 is be VBZ 42759 4140 16 seriously seriously RB 42759 4140 17 detrimental detrimental JJ 42759 4140 18 to to TO 42759 4140 19 welfare welfare VB 42759 4140 20 ; ; : 42759 4140 21 for for IN 42759 4140 22 example example NN 42759 4140 23 , , , 42759 4140 24 when when WRB 42759 4140 25 a a DT 42759 4140 26 man man NN 42759 4140 27 or or CC 42759 4140 28 a a DT 42759 4140 29 family family NN 42759 4140 30 is be VBZ 42759 4140 31 in in IN 42759 4140 32 danger danger NN 42759 4140 33 of of IN 42759 4140 34 falling fall VBG 42759 4140 35 to to IN 42759 4140 36 a a DT 42759 4140 37 lower low JJR 42759 4140 38 social social JJ 42759 4140 39 plane plane NN 42759 4140 40 ; ; : 42759 4140 41 when when WRB 42759 4140 42 health health NN 42759 4140 43 , , , 42759 4140 44 morality morality NN 42759 4140 45 , , , 42759 4140 46 or or CC 42759 4140 47 the the DT 42759 4140 48 intellectual intellectual JJ 42759 4140 49 or or CC 42759 4140 50 religious religious JJ 42759 4140 51 life life NN 42759 4140 52 is be VBZ 42759 4140 53 menaced,--possessors menaced,--possessor NNS 42759 4140 54 are be VBP 42759 4140 55 required require VBN 42759 4140 56 to to TO 42759 4140 57 contribute contribute VB 42759 4140 58 as as RB 42759 4140 59 much much JJ 42759 4140 60 of of IN 42759 4140 61 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4140 62 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4140 63 goods good NNS 42759 4140 64 as as IN 42759 4140 65 is be VBZ 42759 4140 66 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4140 67 to to TO 42759 4140 68 meet meet VB 42759 4140 69 all all DT 42759 4140 70 such such JJ 42759 4140 71 cases case NNS 42759 4140 72 of of IN 42759 4140 73 distress distress NN 42759 4140 74 . . . 42759 4141 1 If if IN 42759 4141 2 all all DT 42759 4141 3 is be VBZ 42759 4141 4 needed need VBN 42759 4141 5 all all DT 42759 4141 6 must must MD 42759 4141 7 be be VB 42759 4141 8 given give VBN 42759 4141 9 . . . 42759 4142 1 In in IN 42759 4142 2 other other JJ 42759 4142 3 words word NNS 42759 4142 4 , , , 42759 4142 5 the the DT 42759 4142 6 entire entire JJ 42759 4142 7 mass mass NN 42759 4142 8 of of IN 42759 4142 9 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4142 10 wealth wealth NN 42759 4142 11 is be VBZ 42759 4142 12 morally morally RB 42759 4142 13 subject subject JJ 42759 4142 14 to to IN 42759 4142 15 the the DT 42759 4142 16 call call NN 42759 4142 17 of of IN 42759 4142 18 grave grave JJ 42759 4142 19 need need NN 42759 4142 20 . . . 42759 4143 1 This this DT 42759 4143 2 seems seem VBZ 42759 4143 3 to to TO 42759 4143 4 be be VB 42759 4143 5 the the DT 42759 4143 6 unanimous unanimous JJ 42759 4143 7 teaching teaching NN 42759 4143 8 of of IN 42759 4143 9 the the DT 42759 4143 10 moral moral JJ 42759 4143 11 theologians theologian NNS 42759 4143 12 . . . 42759 4144 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4144 2 211 211 CD 42759 4144 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4144 4 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4144 5 is be VBZ 42759 4144 6 also also RB 42759 4144 7 in in IN 42759 4144 8 harmony harmony NN 42759 4144 9 with with IN 42759 4144 10 the the DT 42759 4144 11 general general JJ 42759 4144 12 principle principle NN 42759 4144 13 of of IN 42759 4144 14 the the DT 42759 4144 15 moral moral JJ 42759 4144 16 law law NN 42759 4144 17 that that WDT 42759 4144 18 the the DT 42759 4144 19 goods good NNS 42759 4144 20 of of IN 42759 4144 21 the the DT 42759 4144 22 earth earth NN 42759 4144 23 should should MD 42759 4144 24 be be VB 42759 4144 25 enjoyed enjoy VBN 42759 4144 26 by by IN 42759 4144 27 the the DT 42759 4144 28 inhabitants inhabitant NNS 42759 4144 29 of of IN 42759 4144 30 the the DT 42759 4144 31 earth earth NN 42759 4144 32 in in IN 42759 4144 33 proportion proportion NN 42759 4144 34 to to IN 42759 4144 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4144 36 essential essential JJ 42759 4144 37 needs need NNS 42759 4144 38 . . . 42759 4145 1 In in IN 42759 4145 2 any any DT 42759 4145 3 rational rational JJ 42759 4145 4 distribution distribution NN 42759 4145 5 of of IN 42759 4145 6 a a DT 42759 4145 7 common common JJ 42759 4145 8 heritage heritage NN 42759 4145 9 , , , 42759 4145 10 the the DT 42759 4145 11 claims claim NNS 42759 4145 12 of of IN 42759 4145 13 health health NN 42759 4145 14 , , , 42759 4145 15 mind mind NN 42759 4145 16 , , , 42759 4145 17 and and CC 42759 4145 18 morals moral NNS 42759 4145 19 are be VBP 42759 4145 20 surely surely RB 42759 4145 21 superior superior JJ 42759 4145 22 to to IN 42759 4145 23 the the DT 42759 4145 24 demands demand NNS 42759 4145 25 of of IN 42759 4145 26 luxurious luxurious JJ 42759 4145 27 living living NN 42759 4145 28 , , , 42759 4145 29 or or CC 42759 4145 30 investment investment NN 42759 4145 31 , , , 42759 4145 32 or or CC 42759 4145 33 mere mere JJ 42759 4145 34 accumulation accumulation NN 42759 4145 35 . . . 42759 4146 1 What what WP 42759 4146 2 per per IN 42759 4146 3 cent cent NN 42759 4146 4 . . . 42759 4147 1 of of IN 42759 4147 2 the the DT 42759 4147 3 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4147 4 incomes income NNS 42759 4147 5 in in IN 42759 4147 6 the the DT 42759 4147 7 United United NNP 42759 4147 8 States States NNP 42759 4147 9 would would MD 42759 4147 10 suffice suffice VB 42759 4147 11 to to TO 42759 4147 12 alleviate alleviate VB 42759 4147 13 all all PDT 42759 4147 14 the the DT 42759 4147 15 existing exist VBG 42759 4147 16 grave grave NN 42759 4147 17 and and CC 42759 4147 18 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 4147 19 distress distress NN 42759 4147 20 ? ? . 42759 4148 1 Nothing nothing NN 42759 4148 2 like like IN 42759 4148 3 an an DT 42759 4148 4 exact exact JJ 42759 4148 5 answer answer NN 42759 4148 6 is be VBZ 42759 4148 7 possible possible JJ 42759 4148 8 , , , 42759 4148 9 but but CC 42759 4148 10 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4148 11 can can MD 42759 4148 12 get get VB 42759 4148 13 an an DT 42759 4148 14 approximation approximation NN 42759 4148 15 that that WDT 42759 4148 16 will will MD 42759 4148 17 have have VB 42759 4148 18 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4148 19 practical practical JJ 42759 4148 20 value value NN 42759 4148 21 . . . 42759 4149 1 From from IN 42759 4149 2 the the DT 42759 4149 3 estimates estimate NNS 42759 4149 4 of of IN 42759 4149 5 family family NN 42759 4149 6 incomes income NNS 42759 4149 7 given give VBN 42759 4149 8 by by IN 42759 4149 9 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4149 10 W. W. NNP 42759 4149 11 I. I. NNP 42759 4150 1 King King NNP 42759 4150 2 , , , 42759 4150 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4150 4 appears appear VBZ 42759 4150 5 that that IN 42759 4150 6 in in IN 42759 4150 7 1910 1910 CD 42759 4150 8 the the DT 42759 4150 9 number number NN 42759 4150 10 of of IN 42759 4150 11 families family NNS 42759 4150 12 with with IN 42759 4150 13 annual annual JJ 42759 4150 14 incomes income NNS 42759 4150 15 of of IN 42759 4150 16 less less JJR 42759 4150 17 than than IN 42759 4150 18 one one CD 42759 4150 19 thousand thousand CD 42759 4150 20 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4150 21 was be VBD 42759 4150 22 a a DT 42759 4150 23 little little JJ 42759 4150 24 more more JJR 42759 4150 25 than than IN 42759 4150 26 ten ten CD 42759 4150 27 and and CC 42759 4150 28 three three CD 42759 4150 29 quarter quarter NN 42759 4150 30 millions million NNS 42759 4150 31 , , , 42759 4150 32 and and CC 42759 4150 33 that that IN 42759 4150 34 the the DT 42759 4150 35 total total JJ 42759 4150 36 incomes income NNS 42759 4150 37 of of IN 42759 4150 38 those those DT 42759 4150 39 families family NNS 42759 4150 40 receiving receive VBG 42759 4150 41 more more JJR 42759 4150 42 than than IN 42759 4150 43 ten ten CD 42759 4150 44 thousand thousand CD 42759 4150 45 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4150 46 a a DT 42759 4150 47 year year NN 42759 4150 48 amounted amount VBD 42759 4150 49 to to IN 42759 4150 50 a a DT 42759 4150 51 little little JJ 42759 4150 52 more more JJR 42759 4150 53 than than IN 42759 4150 54 three three CD 42759 4150 55 and and CC 42759 4150 56 three three CD 42759 4150 57 quarter quarter NN 42759 4150 58 billions billion NNS 42759 4150 59 . . . 42759 4151 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4151 2 212 212 CD 42759 4151 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4151 4 If if IN 42759 4151 5 each each DT 42759 4151 6 of of IN 42759 4151 7 the the DT 42759 4151 8 latter latter JJ 42759 4151 9 class class NN 42759 4151 10 of of IN 42759 4151 11 families family NNS 42759 4151 12 should should MD 42759 4151 13 expend expend VB 42759 4151 14 ten ten CD 42759 4151 15 thousand thousand CD 42759 4151 16 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4151 17 per per IN 42759 4151 18 year year NN 42759 4151 19 for for IN 42759 4151 20 the the DT 42759 4151 21 needs need NNS 42759 4151 22 of of IN 42759 4151 23 life life NN 42759 4151 24 and and CC 42759 4151 25 social social JJ 42759 4151 26 position position NN 42759 4151 27 , , , 42759 4151 28 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4151 29 would would MD 42759 4151 30 have have VB 42759 4151 31 left leave VBN 42759 4151 32 nearly nearly RB 42759 4151 33 two two CD 42759 4151 34 and and CC 42759 4151 35 three three CD 42759 4151 36 quarter quarter NN 42759 4151 37 billions billion NNS 42759 4151 38 for for IN 42759 4151 39 distribution distribution NN 42759 4151 40 among among IN 42759 4151 41 the the DT 42759 4151 42 ten ten CD 42759 4151 43 and and CC 42759 4151 44 three three CD 42759 4151 45 quarter quarter NN 42759 4151 46 million million CD 42759 4151 47 families family NNS 42759 4151 48 who who WP 42759 4151 49 are be VBP 42759 4151 50 below below IN 42759 4151 51 the the DT 42759 4151 52 one one CD 42759 4151 53 thousand thousand CD 42759 4151 54 dollar dollar NN 42759 4151 55 level level NN 42759 4151 56 . . . 42759 4152 1 So so RB 42759 4152 2 far far RB 42759 4152 3 as as IN 42759 4152 4 the the DT 42759 4152 5 figures figure NNS 42759 4152 6 of of IN 42759 4152 7 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4152 8 King King NNP 42759 4152 9 's 's POS 42759 4152 10 table table NN 42759 4152 11 enable enable VBP 42759 4152 12 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4152 13 to to TO 42759 4152 14 judge judge VB 42759 4152 15 , , , 42759 4152 16 the the DT 42759 4152 17 greater great JJR 42759 4152 18 part part NN 42759 4152 19 if if IN 42759 4152 20 not not RB 42759 4152 21 all all DT 42759 4152 22 of of IN 42759 4152 23 this this DT 42759 4152 24 sum sum NN 42759 4152 25 would would MD 42759 4152 26 be be VB 42759 4152 27 required require VBN 42759 4152 28 to to TO 42759 4152 29 bring bring VB 42759 4152 30 this this DT 42759 4152 31 group group NN 42759 4152 32 of of IN 42759 4152 33 families family NNS 42759 4152 34 up up IN 42759 4152 35 to to IN 42759 4152 36 that that DT 42759 4152 37 standard standard NN 42759 4152 38 . . . 42759 4153 1 Possibly possibly RB 42759 4153 2 an an DT 42759 4153 3 income income NN 42759 4153 4 of of IN 42759 4153 5 one one CD 42759 4153 6 thousand thousand CD 42759 4153 7 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4153 8 per per IN 42759 4153 9 family family NN 42759 4153 10 is be VBZ 42759 4153 11 not not RB 42759 4153 12 required require VBN 42759 4153 13 to to TO 42759 4153 14 remove remove VB 42759 4153 15 all all DT 42759 4153 16 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 4153 17 and and CC 42759 4153 18 grave grave JJ 42759 4153 19 distress distress NN 42759 4153 20 ; ; : 42759 4153 21 and and CC 42759 4153 22 possibly possibly RB 42759 4153 23 ten ten CD 42759 4153 24 thousand thousand CD 42759 4153 25 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4153 26 is be VBZ 42759 4153 27 not not RB 42759 4153 28 enough enough JJ 42759 4153 29 for for IN 42759 4153 30 the the DT 42759 4153 31 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4153 32 requirements requirement NNS 42759 4153 33 of of IN 42759 4153 34 some some DT 42759 4153 35 families family NNS 42759 4153 36 . . . 42759 4154 1 If if IN 42759 4154 2 both both PDT 42759 4154 3 these these DT 42759 4154 4 suppositions supposition NNS 42759 4154 5 are be VBP 42759 4154 6 true true JJ 42759 4154 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4154 8 will will MD 42759 4154 9 tend tend VB 42759 4154 10 to to TO 42759 4154 11 cancel cancel VB 42759 4154 12 each each DT 42759 4154 13 other other JJ 42759 4154 14 : : : 42759 4154 15 the the DT 42759 4154 16 needs need NNS 42759 4154 17 to to TO 42759 4154 18 be be VB 42759 4154 19 met meet VBN 42759 4154 20 will will MD 42759 4154 21 be be VB 42759 4154 22 less less JJR 42759 4154 23 , , , 42759 4154 24 but but CC 42759 4154 25 the the DT 42759 4154 26 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4154 27 income income NN 42759 4154 28 to to TO 42759 4154 29 be be VB 42759 4154 30 distributed distribute VBN 42759 4154 31 will will MD 42759 4154 32 be be VB 42759 4154 33 less less JJR 42759 4154 34 also also RB 42759 4154 35 . . . 42759 4155 1 Whatever whatever WDT 42759 4155 2 be be VB 42759 4155 3 the the DT 42759 4155 4 minimum minimum JJ 42759 4155 5 and and CC 42759 4155 6 maximum maximum JJ 42759 4155 7 limits limit NNS 42759 4155 8 of of IN 42759 4155 9 family family NN 42759 4155 10 income income NN 42759 4155 11 that that WDT 42759 4155 12 approve approve VBP 42759 4155 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 4155 14 to to IN 42759 4155 15 competent competent JJ 42759 4155 16 students student NNS 42759 4155 17 , , , 42759 4155 18 the the DT 42759 4155 19 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 4155 20 will will MD 42759 4155 21 probably probably RB 42759 4155 22 be be VB 42759 4155 23 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 4155 24 that that IN 42759 4155 25 the the DT 42759 4155 26 greater great JJR 42759 4155 27 part part NN 42759 4155 28 of of IN 42759 4155 29 the the DT 42759 4155 30 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4155 31 income income NN 42759 4155 32 of of IN 42759 4155 33 the the DT 42759 4155 34 well well RB 42759 4155 35 - - HYPH 42759 4155 36 to to TO 42759 4155 37 - - HYPH 42759 4155 38 do do VB 42759 4155 39 and and CC 42759 4155 40 the the DT 42759 4155 41 rich rich JJ 42759 4155 42 would would MD 42759 4155 43 be be VB 42759 4155 44 required require VBN 42759 4155 45 to to TO 42759 4155 46 abolish abolish VB 42759 4155 47 all all DT 42759 4155 48 grave grave NN 42759 4155 49 and and CC 42759 4155 50 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 4155 51 need need NN 42759 4155 52 . . . 42759 4156 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4156 2 Some some DT 42759 4156 3 Objections objection NNS 42759 4156 4 _ _ IN 42759 4156 5 The the DT 42759 4156 6 desirability desirability NN 42759 4156 7 of of IN 42759 4156 8 such such PDT 42759 4156 9 a a DT 42759 4156 10 thoroughgoing thoroughgoing JJ 42759 4156 11 distribution distribution NN 42759 4156 12 of of IN 42759 4156 13 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4156 14 incomes income NNS 42759 4156 15 appears appear VBZ 42759 4156 16 to to TO 42759 4156 17 be be VB 42759 4156 18 refuted refute VBN 42759 4156 19 by by IN 42759 4156 20 the the DT 42759 4156 21 fact fact NN 42759 4156 22 that that IN 42759 4156 23 a a DT 42759 4156 24 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4156 25 part part NN 42759 4156 26 of of IN 42759 4156 27 the the DT 42759 4156 28 capital capital NN 42759 4156 29 and and CC 42759 4156 30 organising organising NN 42759 4156 31 ability ability NN 42759 4156 32 that that WDT 42759 4156 33 function function VBP 42759 4156 34 in in IN 42759 4156 35 industry industry NN 42759 4156 36 is be VBZ 42759 4156 37 dependent dependent JJ 42759 4156 38 upon upon IN 42759 4156 39 the the DT 42759 4156 40 possession possession NN 42759 4156 41 of of IN 42759 4156 42 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4156 43 goods good NNS 42759 4156 44 by by IN 42759 4156 45 the the DT 42759 4156 46 richer rich JJR 42759 4156 47 classes class NNS 42759 4156 48 . . . 42759 4157 1 That that DT 42759 4157 2 surplus surplus NN 42759 4157 3 of of IN 42759 4157 4 the the DT 42759 4157 5 larger large JJR 42759 4157 6 incomes income NNS 42759 4157 7 which which WDT 42759 4157 8 is be VBZ 42759 4157 9 not not RB 42759 4157 10 consumed consume VBN 42759 4157 11 or or CC 42759 4157 12 given give VBN 42759 4157 13 away away RP 42759 4157 14 by by IN 42759 4157 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4157 16 receivers receiver NNS 42759 4157 17 at at IN 42759 4157 18 present present NN 42759 4157 19 , , , 42759 4157 20 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 4157 21 no no DT 42759 4157 22 small small JJ 42759 4157 23 portion portion NN 42759 4157 24 of of IN 42759 4157 25 the the DT 42759 4157 26 whole whole JJ 42759 4157 27 supply supply NN 42759 4157 28 of of IN 42759 4157 29 savings saving NNS 42759 4157 30 annually annually RB 42759 4157 31 converted convert VBN 42759 4157 32 into into IN 42759 4157 33 capital capital NN 42759 4157 34 . . . 42759 4158 1 Were be VBD 42759 4158 2 all all DT 42759 4158 3 of of IN 42759 4158 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4158 5 to to TO 42759 4158 6 be be VB 42759 4158 7 withdrawn withdraw VBN 42759 4158 8 from from IN 42759 4158 9 industry industry NN 42759 4158 10 and and CC 42759 4158 11 distributed distribute VBN 42759 4158 12 among among IN 42759 4158 13 the the DT 42759 4158 14 needy needy NN 42759 4158 15 , , , 42759 4158 16 the the DT 42759 4158 17 process process NN 42759 4158 18 might may MD 42759 4158 19 involve involve VB 42759 4158 20 more more JJR 42759 4158 21 harm harm NN 42759 4158 22 than than IN 42759 4158 23 good good JJ 42759 4158 24 . . . 42759 4159 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4159 2 , , , 42759 4159 3 the the DT 42759 4159 4 very very RB 42759 4159 5 large large JJ 42759 4159 6 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4159 7 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 4159 8 are be VBP 42759 4159 9 initiated initiate VBN 42759 4159 10 and and CC 42759 4159 11 carried carry VBN 42759 4159 12 on on RP 42759 4159 13 by by IN 42759 4159 14 men man NNS 42759 4159 15 who who WP 42759 4159 16 have have VBP 42759 4159 17 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 4159 18 provided provide VBN 42759 4159 19 a a DT 42759 4159 20 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4159 21 share share NN 42759 4159 22 of of IN 42759 4159 23 the the DT 42759 4159 24 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4159 25 funds fund NNS 42759 4159 26 . . . 42759 4160 1 Without without IN 42759 4160 2 these these DT 42759 4160 3 large large JJ 42759 4160 4 masses masse NNS 42759 4160 5 of of IN 42759 4160 6 personal personal JJ 42759 4160 7 capital capital NN 42759 4160 8 , , , 42759 4160 9 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4160 10 would would MD 42759 4160 11 have have VB 42759 4160 12 much much RB 42759 4160 13 more more JJR 42759 4160 14 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 4160 15 in in IN 42759 4160 16 organising organise VBG 42759 4160 17 these these DT 42759 4160 18 great great JJ 42759 4160 19 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 4160 20 , , , 42759 4160 21 and and CC 42759 4160 22 would would MD 42759 4160 23 be be VB 42759 4160 24 unable unable JJ 42759 4160 25 to to TO 42759 4160 26 exercise exercise VB 42759 4160 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4160 28 present present JJ 42759 4160 29 dominating dominating JJ 42759 4160 30 control control NN 42759 4160 31 . . . 42759 4161 1 To to IN 42759 4161 2 the the DT 42759 4161 3 first first JJ 42759 4161 4 part part NN 42759 4161 5 of of IN 42759 4161 6 this this DT 42759 4161 7 objection objection NN 42759 4161 8 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4161 9 may may MD 42759 4161 10 reply reply VB 42759 4161 11 that that IN 42759 4161 12 the the DT 42759 4161 13 distribution distribution NN 42759 4161 14 of of IN 42759 4161 15 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4161 16 goods good NNS 42759 4161 17 need nee MD 42759 4161 18 not not RB 42759 4161 19 involve involve VB 42759 4161 20 any any DT 42759 4161 21 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4161 22 withdrawal withdrawal NN 42759 4161 23 of of IN 42759 4161 24 existing exist VBG 42759 4161 25 capital capital NN 42759 4161 26 from from IN 42759 4161 27 industry industry NN 42759 4161 28 . . . 42759 4162 1 The the DT 42759 4162 2 giving giving NN 42759 4162 3 of of IN 42759 4162 4 large large JJ 42759 4162 5 amounts amount NNS 42759 4162 6 to to IN 42759 4162 7 institutions institution NNS 42759 4162 8 and and CC 42759 4162 9 organisations organisation NNS 42759 4162 10 , , , 42759 4162 11 as as IN 42759 4162 12 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 4162 13 from from IN 42759 4162 14 needy needy JJ 42759 4162 15 individuals individual NNS 42759 4162 16 , , , 42759 4162 17 might may MD 42759 4162 18 mean mean VB 42759 4162 19 merely merely RB 42759 4162 20 a a DT 42759 4162 21 transfer transfer NN 42759 4162 22 of of IN 42759 4162 23 capital capital NN 42759 4162 24 from from IN 42759 4162 25 one one CD 42759 4162 26 holder holder NN 42759 4162 27 to to IN 42759 4162 28 another another DT 42759 4162 29 ; ; : 42759 4162 30 for for IN 42759 4162 31 example example NN 42759 4162 32 , , , 42759 4162 33 the the DT 42759 4162 34 stocks stock NNS 42759 4162 35 and and CC 42759 4162 36 bonds bond NNS 42759 4162 37 of of IN 42759 4162 38 corporations corporation NNS 42759 4162 39 . . . 42759 4163 1 The the DT 42759 4163 2 capital capital NN 42759 4163 3 would would MD 42759 4163 4 be be VB 42759 4163 5 left leave VBN 42759 4163 6 intact intact JJ 42759 4163 7 , , , 42759 4163 8 the the DT 42759 4163 9 only only JJ 42759 4163 10 change change NN 42759 4163 11 being be VBG 42759 4163 12 in in IN 42759 4163 13 the the DT 42759 4163 14 persons person NNS 42759 4163 15 that that WDT 42759 4163 16 would would MD 42759 4163 17 thenceforth thenceforth NN 42759 4163 18 receive receive VB 42759 4163 19 the the DT 42759 4163 20 interest interest NN 42759 4163 21 . . . 42759 4164 1 Small small JJ 42759 4164 2 donations donation NNS 42759 4164 3 could could MD 42759 4164 4 come come VB 42759 4164 5 out out IN 42759 4164 6 of of IN 42759 4164 7 the the DT 42759 4164 8 possessor possessor NN 42759 4164 9 's 's POS 42759 4164 10 income income NN 42759 4164 11 . . . 42759 4165 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4165 2 , , , 42759 4165 3 there there EX 42759 4165 4 is be VBZ 42759 4165 5 no no DT 42759 4165 6 reason reason NN 42759 4165 7 why why WRB 42759 4165 8 the the DT 42759 4165 9 whole whole NN 42759 4165 10 of of IN 42759 4165 11 the the DT 42759 4165 12 distribution distribution NN 42759 4165 13 could could MD 42759 4165 14 not not RB 42759 4165 15 be be VB 42759 4165 16 made make VBN 42759 4165 17 out out IN 42759 4165 18 of of IN 42759 4165 19 income income NN 42759 4165 20 rather rather RB 42759 4165 21 than than IN 42759 4165 22 out out IN 42759 4165 23 of of IN 42759 4165 24 capital capital NN 42759 4165 25 . . . 42759 4166 1 While while IN 42759 4166 2 the the DT 42759 4166 3 givers giver NNS 42759 4166 4 would would MD 42759 4166 5 still still RB 42759 4166 6 remain remain VB 42759 4166 7 possessed possessed JJ 42759 4166 8 of of IN 42759 4166 9 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4166 10 wealth wealth NN 42759 4166 11 , , , 42759 4166 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4166 13 would would MD 42759 4166 14 have have VB 42759 4166 15 handed hand VBN 42759 4166 16 over over RP 42759 4166 17 to to IN 42759 4166 18 needy needy JJ 42759 4166 19 objects object NNS 42759 4166 20 , , , 42759 4166 21 persons person NNS 42759 4166 22 , , , 42759 4166 23 and and CC 42759 4166 24 causes cause VBZ 42759 4166 25 the the DT 42759 4166 26 thing thing NN 42759 4166 27 that that WDT 42759 4166 28 in in IN 42759 4166 29 modern modern JJ 42759 4166 30 times time NNS 42759 4166 31 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 4166 32 the the DT 42759 4166 33 soul soul NN 42759 4166 34 and and CC 42759 4166 35 essence essence NN 42759 4166 36 of of IN 42759 4166 37 wealth wealth NN 42759 4166 38 ; ; : 42759 4166 39 namely namely RB 42759 4166 40 , , , 42759 4166 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4166 42 annual annual JJ 42759 4166 43 revenues revenue NNS 42759 4166 44 . . . 42759 4167 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 4167 2 , , , 42759 4167 3 the the DT 42759 4167 4 distribution distribution NN 42759 4167 5 from from IN 42759 4167 6 income income NN 42759 4167 7 would would MD 42759 4167 8 apparently apparently RB 42759 4167 9 check check VB 42759 4167 10 the the DT 42759 4167 11 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4167 12 increase increase NN 42759 4167 13 of of IN 42759 4167 14 capital capital NN 42759 4167 15 , , , 42759 4167 16 lessen lessen VBD 42759 4167 17 unduly unduly RB 42759 4167 18 the the DT 42759 4167 19 supply supply NN 42759 4167 20 of of IN 42759 4167 21 capital capital NN 42759 4167 22 for for IN 42759 4167 23 the the DT 42759 4167 24 future future NN 42759 4167 25 . . . 42759 4168 1 Were be VBD 42759 4168 2 all all DT 42759 4168 3 , , , 42759 4168 4 or or CC 42759 4168 5 the the DT 42759 4168 6 greater great JJR 42759 4168 7 part part NN 42759 4168 8 of of IN 42759 4168 9 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4168 10 incomes income NNS 42759 4168 11 devoted devote VBN 42759 4168 12 to to IN 42759 4168 13 benevolent benevolent JJ 42759 4168 14 objects object NNS 42759 4168 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4168 16 would would MD 42759 4168 17 be be VB 42759 4168 18 used use VBN 42759 4168 19 up up RP 42759 4168 20 for for IN 42759 4168 21 consumption consumption NN 42759 4168 22 goods good NNS 42759 4168 23 ; ; , 42759 4168 24 such such JJ 42759 4168 25 as as IN 42759 4168 26 , , , 42759 4168 27 food food NN 42759 4168 28 , , , 42759 4168 29 clothing clothing NN 42759 4168 30 , , , 42759 4168 31 housing housing NN 42759 4168 32 , , , 42759 4168 33 hospitals hospital NNS 42759 4168 34 , , , 42759 4168 35 churches church NNS 42759 4168 36 , , , 42759 4168 37 schools school NNS 42759 4168 38 . . . 42759 4169 1 Would Would MD 42759 4169 2 not not RB 42759 4169 3 this this DT 42759 4169 4 check check VB 42759 4169 5 to to IN 42759 4169 6 the the DT 42759 4169 7 increase increase NN 42759 4169 8 of of IN 42759 4169 9 capital capital NN 42759 4169 10 cause cause VB 42759 4169 11 serious serious JJ 42759 4169 12 injury injury NN 42759 4169 13 to to IN 42759 4169 14 society society NN 42759 4169 15 ? ? . 42759 4170 1 New new JJ 42759 4170 2 investment investment NN 42759 4170 3 would would MD 42759 4170 4 not not RB 42759 4170 5 be be VB 42759 4170 6 diminished diminish VBN 42759 4170 7 by by IN 42759 4170 8 an an DT 42759 4170 9 amount amount NN 42759 4170 10 equal equal JJ 42759 4170 11 to to IN 42759 4170 12 the the DT 42759 4170 13 whole whole JJ 42759 4170 14 amount amount NN 42759 4170 15 of of IN 42759 4170 16 income income NN 42759 4170 17 transferred transfer VBN 42759 4170 18 to to IN 42759 4170 19 objects object NNS 42759 4170 20 of of IN 42759 4170 21 benevolence benevolence NN 42759 4170 22 . . . 42759 4171 1 For for IN 42759 4171 2 the the DT 42759 4171 3 improved improved JJ 42759 4171 4 position position NN 42759 4171 5 of of IN 42759 4171 6 the the DT 42759 4171 7 poorer poor JJR 42759 4171 8 classes class NNS 42759 4171 9 that that WDT 42759 4171 10 had have VBD 42759 4171 11 shared share VBN 42759 4171 12 in in IN 42759 4171 13 the the DT 42759 4171 14 distribution distribution NN 42759 4171 15 would would MD 42759 4171 16 enable enable VB 42759 4171 17 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4171 18 to to TO 42759 4171 19 increase increase VB 42759 4171 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4171 21 productive productive JJ 42759 4171 22 power power NN 42759 4171 23 and and CC 42759 4171 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4171 25 resources resource NNS 42759 4171 26 , , , 42759 4171 27 and and CC 42759 4171 28 therefore therefore RB 42759 4171 29 to to TO 42759 4171 30 save save VB 42759 4171 31 money money NN 42759 4171 32 and and CC 42759 4171 33 convert convert VB 42759 4171 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4171 35 into into IN 42759 4171 36 capital capital NN 42759 4171 37 . . . 42759 4172 1 Again again RB 42759 4172 2 , , , 42759 4172 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4172 4 increased increase VBN 42759 4172 5 consuming consume VBG 42759 4172 6 power power NN 42759 4172 7 would would MD 42759 4172 8 augment augment VB 42759 4172 9 the the DT 42759 4172 10 demand demand NN 42759 4172 11 for for IN 42759 4172 12 goods good NNS 42759 4172 13 , , , 42759 4172 14 bring bring VB 42759 4172 15 about about RP 42759 4172 16 a a DT 42759 4172 17 larger large JJR 42759 4172 18 use use NN 42759 4172 19 of of IN 42759 4172 20 existing exist VBG 42759 4172 21 capital capital NN 42759 4172 22 instruments instrument NNS 42759 4172 23 , , , 42759 4172 24 and and CC 42759 4172 25 therefore therefore RB 42759 4172 26 lead lead VBP 42759 4172 27 to to IN 42759 4172 28 an an DT 42759 4172 29 enlargement enlargement NN 42759 4172 30 of of IN 42759 4172 31 the the DT 42759 4172 32 community community NN 42759 4172 33 's 's POS 42759 4172 34 capacity capacity NN 42759 4172 35 for for IN 42759 4172 36 saving saving NN 42759 4172 37 . . . 42759 4173 1 Thus thus RB 42759 4173 2 , , , 42759 4173 3 the the DT 42759 4173 4 new new JJ 42759 4173 5 saving saving NN 42759 4173 6 and and CC 42759 4173 7 capital capital NN 42759 4173 8 would would MD 42759 4173 9 , , , 42759 4173 10 partially partially RB 42759 4173 11 at at IN 42759 4173 12 least least JJS 42759 4173 13 , , , 42759 4173 14 take take VB 42759 4173 15 the the DT 42759 4173 16 place place NN 42759 4173 17 of of IN 42759 4173 18 that that DT 42759 4173 19 which which WDT 42759 4173 20 was be VBD 42759 4173 21 formerly formerly RB 42759 4173 22 provided provide VBN 42759 4173 23 by by IN 42759 4173 24 the the DT 42759 4173 25 possessors possessor NNS 42759 4173 26 of of IN 42759 4173 27 surplus surplus JJ 42759 4173 28 income income NN 42759 4173 29 . . . 42759 4174 1 In in IN 42759 4174 2 so so RB 42759 4174 3 far far RB 42759 4174 4 as as IN 42759 4174 5 a a DT 42759 4174 6 net net JJ 42759 4174 7 diminution diminution NN 42759 4174 8 occurred occur VBD 42759 4174 9 in in IN 42759 4174 10 the the DT 42759 4174 11 community community NN 42759 4174 12 's 's POS 42759 4174 13 supply supply NN 42759 4174 14 of of IN 42759 4174 15 capital capital NN 42759 4174 16 , , , 42759 4174 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4174 18 would would MD 42759 4174 19 probably probably RB 42759 4174 20 be be VB 42759 4174 21 more more JJR 42759 4174 22 than than IN 42759 4174 23 offset offset VBN 42759 4174 24 , , , 42759 4174 25 from from IN 42759 4174 26 the the DT 42759 4174 27 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 4174 28 of of IN 42759 4174 29 social social JJ 42759 4174 30 welfare welfare NN 42759 4174 31 , , , 42759 4174 32 by by IN 42759 4174 33 the the DT 42759 4174 34 better well JJR 42759 4174 35 diffusion diffusion NN 42759 4174 36 of of IN 42759 4174 37 goods good NNS 42759 4174 38 and and CC 42759 4174 39 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 4174 40 among among IN 42759 4174 41 the the DT 42759 4174 42 masses masse NNS 42759 4174 43 of of IN 42759 4174 44 the the DT 42759 4174 45 population population NN 42759 4174 46 . . . 42759 4175 1 The the DT 42759 4175 2 second second JJ 42759 4175 3 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 4175 4 noted note VBD 42759 4175 5 above above RB 42759 4175 6 , , , 42759 4175 7 that that IN 42759 4175 8 such such PDT 42759 4175 9 a a DT 42759 4175 10 thorough thorough JJ 42759 4175 11 distribution distribution NN 42759 4175 12 of of IN 42759 4175 13 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4175 14 goods good NNS 42759 4175 15 would would MD 42759 4175 16 lessen lessen VB 42759 4175 17 considerably considerably RB 42759 4175 18 the the DT 42759 4175 19 power power NN 42759 4175 20 of of IN 42759 4175 21 the the DT 42759 4175 22 captains captain NNS 42759 4175 23 of of IN 42759 4175 24 industry industry NN 42759 4175 25 to to TO 42759 4175 26 organise organise VB 42759 4175 27 and and CC 42759 4175 28 operate operate VB 42759 4175 29 great great JJ 42759 4175 30 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 4175 31 , , , 42759 4175 32 can can MD 42759 4175 33 be be VB 42759 4175 34 disposed dispose VBN 42759 4175 35 of of IN 42759 4175 36 very very RB 42759 4175 37 briefly briefly NN 42759 4175 38 . . . 42759 4176 1 Those those DT 42759 4176 2 who who WP 42759 4176 3 made make VBD 42759 4176 4 the the DT 42759 4176 5 distribution distribution NN 42759 4176 6 from from IN 42759 4176 7 income income NN 42759 4176 8 rather rather RB 42759 4176 9 than than IN 42759 4176 10 from from IN 42759 4176 11 invested invest VBN 42759 4176 12 wealth wealth NN 42759 4176 13 , , , 42759 4176 14 would would MD 42759 4176 15 still still RB 42759 4176 16 retain retain VB 42759 4176 17 control control NN 42759 4176 18 of of IN 42759 4176 19 large large JJ 42759 4176 20 masses masse NNS 42759 4176 21 of of IN 42759 4176 22 capital capital NN 42759 4176 23 . . . 42759 4177 1 All all DT 42759 4177 2 , , , 42759 4177 3 however however RB 42759 4177 4 , , , 42759 4177 5 would would MD 42759 4177 6 have have VB 42759 4177 7 deprived deprive VBN 42759 4177 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 4177 9 of of IN 42759 4177 10 the the DT 42759 4177 11 power power NN 42759 4177 12 to to TO 42759 4177 13 enlarge enlarge VB 42759 4177 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4177 15 business business NN 42759 4177 16 ventures venture NNS 42759 4177 17 by by IN 42759 4177 18 turning turn VBG 42759 4177 19 great great JJ 42759 4177 20 quantities quantity NNS 42759 4177 21 of of IN 42759 4177 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4177 23 own own JJ 42759 4177 24 income income NN 42759 4177 25 back back RB 42759 4177 26 into into IN 42759 4177 27 industry industry NN 42759 4177 28 . . . 42759 4178 1 But but CC 42759 4178 2 if if IN 42759 4178 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4178 4 ability ability NN 42759 4178 5 and and CC 42759 4178 6 character character NN 42759 4178 7 were be VBD 42759 4178 8 such such JJ 42759 4178 9 as as IN 42759 4178 10 to to TO 42759 4178 11 command command VB 42759 4178 12 the the DT 42759 4178 13 confidence confidence NN 42759 4178 14 of of IN 42759 4178 15 investors investor NNS 42759 4178 16 , , , 42759 4178 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4178 18 would would MD 42759 4178 19 be be VB 42759 4178 20 able able JJ 42759 4178 21 to to TO 42759 4178 22 find find VB 42759 4178 23 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4178 24 capital capital NN 42759 4178 25 elsewhere elsewhere RB 42759 4178 26 to to TO 42759 4178 27 equip equip VB 42759 4178 28 and and CC 42759 4178 29 carry carry VB 42759 4178 30 on on RP 42759 4178 31 any any DT 42759 4178 32 sound sound JJ 42759 4178 33 and and CC 42759 4178 34 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4178 35 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 4178 36 . . . 42759 4179 1 In in IN 42759 4179 2 this this DT 42759 4179 3 case case NN 42759 4179 4 the the DT 42759 4179 5 process process NN 42759 4179 6 of of IN 42759 4179 7 accumulating accumulate VBG 42759 4179 8 the the DT 42759 4179 9 required require VBN 42759 4179 10 funds fund NNS 42759 4179 11 would would MD 42759 4179 12 , , , 42759 4179 13 indeed indeed RB 42759 4179 14 , , , 42759 4179 15 be be VB 42759 4179 16 slower slow JJR 42759 4179 17 than than IN 42759 4179 18 when when WRB 42759 4179 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4179 20 used use VBD 42759 4179 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4179 22 own own JJ 42759 4179 23 , , , 42759 4179 24 but but CC 42759 4179 25 that that DT 42759 4179 26 would would MD 42759 4179 27 not not RB 42759 4179 28 be be VB 42759 4179 29 an an DT 42759 4179 30 unmixed unmixed JJ 42759 4179 31 disadvantage disadvantage NN 42759 4179 32 . . . 42759 4180 1 When when WRB 42759 4180 2 the the DT 42759 4180 3 business business NN 42759 4180 4 was be VBD 42759 4180 5 finally finally RB 42759 4180 6 established establish VBN 42759 4180 7 , , , 42759 4180 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4180 9 would would MD 42759 4180 10 probably probably RB 42759 4180 11 be be VB 42759 4180 12 more more RBR 42759 4180 13 stable stable JJ 42759 4180 14 , , , 42759 4180 15 would would MD 42759 4180 16 respond respond VB 42759 4180 17 to to IN 42759 4180 18 a a DT 42759 4180 19 more more RBR 42759 4180 20 definite definite JJ 42759 4180 21 and and CC 42759 4180 22 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4180 23 need need NN 42759 4180 24 , , , 42759 4180 25 and and CC 42759 4180 26 would would MD 42759 4180 27 be be VB 42759 4180 28 more more RBR 42759 4180 29 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 4180 30 socially socially RB 42759 4180 31 , , , 42759 4180 32 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 4180 33 as as IN 42759 4180 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4180 35 would would MD 42759 4180 36 include include VB 42759 4180 37 a a DT 42759 4180 38 larger large JJR 42759 4180 39 proportion proportion NN 42759 4180 40 of of IN 42759 4180 41 the the DT 42759 4180 42 population population NN 42759 4180 43 among among IN 42759 4180 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4180 45 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 4180 46 . . . 42759 4181 1 And and CC 42759 4181 2 the the DT 42759 4181 3 diminished diminished JJ 42759 4181 4 authority authority NN 42759 4181 5 and and CC 42759 4181 6 control control NN 42759 4181 7 exercised exercise VBN 42759 4181 8 by by IN 42759 4181 9 the the DT 42759 4181 10 great great JJ 42759 4181 11 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4181 12 , , , 42759 4181 13 on on IN 42759 4181 14 account account NN 42759 4181 15 of of IN 42759 4181 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4181 17 diminished diminished JJ 42759 4181 18 ownership ownership NN 42759 4181 19 of of IN 42759 4181 20 the the DT 42759 4181 21 stock stock NN 42759 4181 22 , , , 42759 4181 23 would would MD 42759 4181 24 in in IN 42759 4181 25 the the DT 42759 4181 26 long long JJ 42759 4181 27 run run NN 42759 4181 28 be be VB 42759 4181 29 a a DT 42759 4181 30 good good JJ 42759 4181 31 thing thing NN 42759 4181 32 for for IN 42759 4181 33 society society NN 42759 4181 34 . . . 42759 4182 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4182 2 would would MD 42759 4182 3 mean mean VB 42759 4182 4 the the DT 42759 4182 5 curtailment curtailment NN 42759 4182 6 of of IN 42759 4182 7 a a DT 42759 4182 8 species species NN 42759 4182 9 of of IN 42759 4182 10 power power NN 42759 4182 11 that that WDT 42759 4182 12 is be VBZ 42759 4182 13 easily easily RB 42759 4182 14 liable liable JJ 42759 4182 15 to to TO 42759 4182 16 abuse abuse VB 42759 4182 17 , , , 42759 4182 18 wider wide JJR 42759 4182 19 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 4182 20 of of IN 42759 4182 21 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4182 22 leadership leadership NN 42759 4182 23 , , , 42759 4182 24 and and CC 42759 4182 25 a a DT 42759 4182 26 more more RBR 42759 4182 27 democratic democratic JJ 42759 4182 28 and and CC 42759 4182 29 stable stable JJ 42759 4182 30 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4182 31 system system NN 42759 4182 32 . . . 42759 4183 1 Only only RB 42759 4183 2 a a DT 42759 4183 3 comparatively comparatively RB 42759 4183 4 small small JJ 42759 4183 5 portion portion NN 42759 4183 6 of of IN 42759 4183 7 the the DT 42759 4183 8 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4183 9 goods good NNS 42759 4183 10 of of IN 42759 4183 11 the the DT 42759 4183 12 country country NN 42759 4183 13 could could MD 42759 4183 14 with with IN 42759 4183 15 advantage advantage NN 42759 4183 16 be be VB 42759 4183 17 immediately immediately RB 42759 4183 18 and and CC 42759 4183 19 directly directly RB 42759 4183 20 distributed distribute VBN 42759 4183 21 among among IN 42759 4183 22 needy needy JJ 42759 4183 23 individuals individual NNS 42759 4183 24 . . . 42759 4184 1 The the DT 42759 4184 2 greater great JJR 42759 4184 3 part part NN 42759 4184 4 would would MD 42759 4184 5 do do VB 42759 4184 6 more more RBR 42759 4184 7 good good JJ 42759 4184 8 if if IN 42759 4184 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4184 10 were be VBD 42759 4184 11 given give VBN 42759 4184 12 to to IN 42759 4184 13 religious religious JJ 42759 4184 14 and and CC 42759 4184 15 benevolent benevolent JJ 42759 4184 16 institutions institution NNS 42759 4184 17 and and CC 42759 4184 18 enterprises enterprise NNS 42759 4184 19 . . . 42759 4185 1 Churches church NNS 42759 4185 2 , , , 42759 4185 3 schools school NNS 42759 4185 4 , , , 42759 4185 5 scholarships scholarship NNS 42759 4185 6 , , , 42759 4185 7 hospitals hospital NNS 42759 4185 8 , , , 42759 4185 9 asylums asylum NNS 42759 4185 10 , , , 42759 4185 11 housing housing NN 42759 4185 12 projects project NNS 42759 4185 13 , , , 42759 4185 14 insurance insurance NN 42759 4185 15 against against IN 42759 4185 16 unemployment unemployment NN 42759 4185 17 , , , 42759 4185 18 sickness sickness NN 42759 4185 19 , , , 42759 4185 20 and and CC 42759 4185 21 old old JJ 42759 4185 22 age age NN 42759 4185 23 , , , 42759 4185 24 and and CC 42759 4185 25 benevolent benevolent JJ 42759 4185 26 and and CC 42759 4185 27 scientific scientific JJ 42759 4185 28 purposes purpose NNS 42759 4185 29 generally,--constitute generally,--constitute ADD 42759 4185 30 the the DT 42759 4185 31 best good JJS 42759 4185 32 objects object NNS 42759 4185 33 and and CC 42759 4185 34 agencies agency NNS 42759 4185 35 of of IN 42759 4185 36 effective effective JJ 42759 4185 37 distribution distribution NN 42759 4185 38 . . . 42759 4186 1 By by IN 42759 4186 2 these these DT 42759 4186 3 means mean VBZ 42759 4186 4 social social JJ 42759 4186 5 and and CC 42759 4186 6 individual individual JJ 42759 4186 7 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 4186 8 would would MD 42759 4186 9 be be VB 42759 4186 10 so so RB 42759 4186 11 improved improve VBN 42759 4186 12 within within IN 42759 4186 13 a a DT 42759 4186 14 few few JJ 42759 4186 15 years year NNS 42759 4186 16 that that IN 42759 4186 17 the the DT 42759 4186 18 distress distress NN 42759 4186 19 due due JJ 42759 4186 20 to to IN 42759 4186 21 economic economic JJ 42759 4186 22 causes cause NNS 42759 4186 23 would would MD 42759 4186 24 for for IN 42759 4186 25 the the DT 42759 4186 26 most most JJS 42759 4186 27 part part NN 42759 4186 28 have have VBP 42759 4186 29 disappeared disappear VBN 42759 4186 30 . . . 42759 4187 1 The the DT 42759 4187 2 proposition proposition NN 42759 4187 3 that that IN 42759 4187 4 men man NNS 42759 4187 5 are be VBP 42759 4187 6 under under IN 42759 4187 7 moral moral JJ 42759 4187 8 obligation obligation NN 42759 4187 9 to to TO 42759 4187 10 give give VB 42759 4187 11 away away RP 42759 4187 12 the the DT 42759 4187 13 greater great JJR 42759 4187 14 portion portion NN 42759 4187 15 of of IN 42759 4187 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4187 17 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4187 18 goods good NNS 42759 4187 19 or or CC 42759 4187 20 income income NN 42759 4187 21 is be VBZ 42759 4187 22 , , , 42759 4187 23 indeed indeed RB 42759 4187 24 , , , 42759 4187 25 a a DT 42759 4187 26 " " `` 42759 4187 27 hard hard JJ 42759 4187 28 saying saying NN 42759 4187 29 . . . 42759 4187 30 " " '' 42759 4188 1 Not not RB 42759 4188 2 improbably improbably RB 42759 4188 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4188 4 will will MD 42759 4188 5 strike strike VB 42759 4188 6 the the DT 42759 4188 7 majority majority NN 42759 4188 8 of of IN 42759 4188 9 persons person NNS 42759 4188 10 who who WP 42759 4188 11 read read VBP 42759 4188 12 these these DT 42759 4188 13 pages page NNS 42759 4188 14 as as IN 42759 4188 15 extreme extreme JJ 42759 4188 16 and and CC 42759 4188 17 fantastic fantastic JJ 42759 4188 18 . . . 42759 4189 1 No no DT 42759 4189 2 Catholic Catholic NNP 42759 4189 3 , , , 42759 4189 4 however however RB 42759 4189 5 , , , 42759 4189 6 who who WP 42759 4189 7 knows know VBZ 42759 4189 8 the the DT 42759 4189 9 traditional traditional JJ 42759 4189 10 teaching teaching NN 42759 4189 11 of of IN 42759 4189 12 the the DT 42759 4189 13 Church Church NNP 42759 4189 14 on on IN 42759 4189 15 the the DT 42759 4189 16 right right JJ 42759 4189 17 use use NN 42759 4189 18 of of IN 42759 4189 19 wealth wealth NN 42759 4189 20 , , , 42759 4189 21 and and CC 42759 4189 22 who who WP 42759 4189 23 considers consider VBZ 42759 4189 24 patiently patiently RB 42759 4189 25 and and CC 42759 4189 26 seriously seriously RB 42759 4189 27 the the DT 42759 4189 28 magnitude magnitude NN 42759 4189 29 and and CC 42759 4189 30 the the DT 42759 4189 31 meaning meaning NN 42759 4189 32 of of IN 42759 4189 33 human human JJ 42759 4189 34 distress distress NN 42759 4189 35 , , , 42759 4189 36 will will MD 42759 4189 37 be be VB 42759 4189 38 able able JJ 42759 4189 39 to to TO 42759 4189 40 refute refute VB 42759 4189 41 the the DT 42759 4189 42 proposition proposition NN 42759 4189 43 by by IN 42759 4189 44 reasoned reasoned JJ 42759 4189 45 arguments argument NNS 42759 4189 46 . . . 42759 4190 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 4190 2 , , , 42759 4190 3 no no DT 42759 4190 4 man man NN 42759 4190 5 can can MD 42759 4190 6 logically logically RB 42759 4190 7 deny deny VB 42759 4190 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4190 9 who who WP 42759 4190 10 admits admit VBZ 42759 4190 11 that that IN 42759 4190 12 men man NNS 42759 4190 13 are be VBP 42759 4190 14 intrinsically intrinsically RB 42759 4190 15 sacred sacred JJ 42759 4190 16 , , , 42759 4190 17 and and CC 42759 4190 18 essentially essentially RB 42759 4190 19 equal equal JJ 42759 4190 20 by by IN 42759 4190 21 nature nature NN 42759 4190 22 and and CC 42759 4190 23 in in IN 42759 4190 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4190 25 claims claim NNS 42759 4190 26 to to IN 42759 4190 27 a a DT 42759 4190 28 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4190 29 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4190 30 from from IN 42759 4190 31 the the DT 42759 4190 32 common common JJ 42759 4190 33 heritage heritage NN 42759 4190 34 of of IN 42759 4190 35 the the DT 42759 4190 36 earth earth NN 42759 4190 37 . . . 42759 4191 1 The the DT 42759 4191 2 wants want VBZ 42759 4191 3 that that IN 42759 4191 4 a a DT 42759 4191 5 man man NN 42759 4191 6 supplies supply VBZ 42759 4191 7 out out IN 42759 4191 8 of of IN 42759 4191 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4191 10 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4191 11 goods good NNS 42759 4191 12 are be VBP 42759 4191 13 not not RB 42759 4191 14 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4191 15 for for IN 42759 4191 16 rational rational JJ 42759 4191 17 existence existence NN 42759 4191 18 . . . 42759 4192 1 For for IN 42759 4192 2 the the DT 42759 4192 3 most most JJS 42759 4192 4 part part NN 42759 4192 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4192 6 bring bring VBP 42759 4192 7 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4192 8 merely merely RB 42759 4192 9 irrational irrational JJ 42759 4192 10 enjoyment enjoyment NN 42759 4192 11 , , , 42759 4192 12 greater great JJR 42759 4192 13 social social JJ 42759 4192 14 prestige prestige NN 42759 4192 15 , , , 42759 4192 16 or or CC 42759 4192 17 increased increase VBN 42759 4192 18 domination domination NN 42759 4192 19 over over IN 42759 4192 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4192 21 fellows fellow NNS 42759 4192 22 . . . 42759 4193 1 Judged judge VBN 42759 4193 2 by by IN 42759 4193 3 any any DT 42759 4193 4 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4193 5 standard standard NN 42759 4193 6 , , , 42759 4193 7 these these DT 42759 4193 8 are be VBP 42759 4193 9 surely surely RB 42759 4193 10 less less RBR 42759 4193 11 important important JJ 42759 4193 12 than than IN 42759 4193 13 those those DT 42759 4193 14 needs need NNS 42759 4193 15 of of IN 42759 4193 16 the the DT 42759 4193 17 neighbour neighbour NN 42759 4193 18 which which WDT 42759 4193 19 are be VBP 42759 4193 20 connected connect VBN 42759 4193 21 with with IN 42759 4193 22 humane humane JJ 42759 4193 23 living living NN 42759 4193 24 . . . 42759 4194 1 If if IN 42759 4194 2 any any DT 42759 4194 3 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4194 4 part part NN 42759 4194 5 of of IN 42759 4194 6 the the DT 42759 4194 7 community community NN 42759 4194 8 rejects reject VBZ 42759 4194 9 these these DT 42759 4194 10 propositions proposition NNS 42759 4194 11 the the DT 42759 4194 12 explanation explanation NN 42759 4194 13 will will MD 42759 4194 14 be be VB 42759 4194 15 found find VBN 42759 4194 16 not not RB 42759 4194 17 in in IN 42759 4194 18 a a DT 42759 4194 19 reasoned reason VBN 42759 4194 20 theory theory NN 42759 4194 21 , , , 42759 4194 22 but but CC 42759 4194 23 in in IN 42759 4194 24 the the DT 42759 4194 25 conventional conventional JJ 42759 4194 26 assumption assumption NN 42759 4194 27 that that IN 42759 4194 28 a a DT 42759 4194 29 man man NN 42759 4194 30 may may MD 42759 4194 31 do do VB 42759 4194 32 what what WP 42759 4194 33 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4194 34 likes like VBZ 42759 4194 35 with with IN 42759 4194 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4194 37 own own JJ 42759 4194 38 . . . 42759 4195 1 This this DT 42759 4195 2 assumption assumption NN 42759 4195 3 is be VBZ 42759 4195 4 adopted adopt VBN 42759 4195 5 without without IN 42759 4195 6 examination examination NN 42759 4195 7 , , , 42759 4195 8 without without IN 42759 4195 9 criticism criticism NN 42759 4195 10 , , , 42759 4195 11 without without IN 42759 4195 12 any any DT 42759 4195 13 serious serious JJ 42759 4195 14 advertence advertence NN 42759 4195 15 to to IN 42759 4195 16 the the DT 42759 4195 17 great great JJ 42759 4195 18 moral moral JJ 42759 4195 19 facts fact NNS 42759 4195 20 that that WDT 42759 4195 21 ownership ownership NN 42759 4195 22 is be VBZ 42759 4195 23 stewardship stewardship NN 42759 4195 24 , , , 42759 4195 25 and and CC 42759 4195 26 that that IN 42759 4195 27 the the DT 42759 4195 28 Creator Creator NNP 42759 4195 29 intended intend VBD 42759 4195 30 the the DT 42759 4195 31 earth earth NN 42759 4195 32 for for IN 42759 4195 33 the the DT 42759 4195 34 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4195 35 support support NN 42759 4195 36 of of IN 42759 4195 37 all all PDT 42759 4195 38 the the DT 42759 4195 39 children child NNS 42759 4195 40 of of IN 42759 4195 41 men man NNS 42759 4195 42 . . . 42759 4196 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4196 2 A a DT 42759 4196 3 False False NNP 42759 4196 4 Conception Conception NNP 42759 4196 5 of of IN 42759 4196 6 Welfare Welfare NNP 42759 4196 7 and and CC 42759 4196 8 Superfluous Superfluous NNP 42759 4196 9 Goods Goods NNPS 42759 4196 10 _ _ XX 42759 4196 11 If if IN 42759 4196 12 all all PDT 42759 4196 13 the the DT 42759 4196 14 present present JJ 42759 4196 15 owners owner NNS 42759 4196 16 of of IN 42759 4196 17 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4196 18 goods good NNS 42759 4196 19 were be VBD 42759 4196 20 to to TO 42759 4196 21 carry carry VB 42759 4196 22 out out RP 42759 4196 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4196 24 own own JJ 42759 4196 25 conception conception NN 42759 4196 26 of of IN 42759 4196 27 the the DT 42759 4196 28 obligation obligation NN 42759 4196 29 , , , 42759 4196 30 the the DT 42759 4196 31 amount amount NN 42759 4196 32 distributed distribute VBN 42759 4196 33 would would MD 42759 4196 34 be be VB 42759 4196 35 only only RB 42759 4196 36 a a DT 42759 4196 37 fraction fraction NN 42759 4196 38 of of IN 42759 4196 39 the the DT 42759 4196 40 real real JJ 42759 4196 41 superabundance superabundance NN 42759 4196 42 . . . 42759 4197 1 Let let VB 42759 4197 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4197 3 recall recall VB 42759 4197 4 the the DT 42759 4197 5 definition definition NN 42759 4197 6 of of IN 42759 4197 7 absolute absolute JJ 42759 4197 8 superfluity superfluity NN 42759 4197 9 as as IN 42759 4197 10 , , , 42759 4197 11 that that DT 42759 4197 12 portion portion NN 42759 4197 13 of of IN 42759 4197 14 individual individual NN 42759 4197 15 or or CC 42759 4197 16 family family NN 42759 4197 17 income income NN 42759 4197 18 which which WDT 42759 4197 19 is be VBZ 42759 4197 20 not not RB 42759 4197 21 required require VBN 42759 4197 22 for for IN 42759 4197 23 the the DT 42759 4197 24 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4197 25 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 4197 26 of of IN 42759 4197 27 life life NN 42759 4197 28 and and CC 42759 4197 29 social social JJ 42759 4197 30 position position NN 42759 4197 31 . . . 42759 4198 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4198 2 allows allow VBZ 42759 4198 3 , , , 42759 4198 4 of of IN 42759 4198 5 course course NN 42759 4198 6 , , , 42759 4198 7 a a DT 42759 4198 8 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4198 9 provision provision NN 42759 4198 10 for for IN 42759 4198 11 the the DT 42759 4198 12 future future NN 42759 4198 13 . . . 42759 4199 1 But but CC 42759 4199 2 the the DT 42759 4199 3 great great JJ 42759 4199 4 majority majority NN 42759 4199 5 of of IN 42759 4199 6 possessors possessor NNS 42759 4199 7 , , , 42759 4199 8 as as RB 42759 4199 9 well well RB 42759 4199 10 as as IN 42759 4199 11 perhaps perhaps RB 42759 4199 12 the the DT 42759 4199 13 majority majority NN 42759 4199 14 of of IN 42759 4199 15 others other NNS 42759 4199 16 , , , 42759 4199 17 do do VB 42759 4199 18 not not RB 42759 4199 19 interpret interpret VB 42759 4199 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4199 21 needs need NNS 42759 4199 22 , , , 42759 4199 23 whether whether IN 42759 4199 24 of of IN 42759 4199 25 life life NN 42759 4199 26 or or CC 42759 4199 27 social social JJ 42759 4199 28 position position NN 42759 4199 29 , , , 42759 4199 30 in in IN 42759 4199 31 any any DT 42759 4199 32 such such JJ 42759 4199 33 strict strict JJ 42759 4199 34 fashion fashion NN 42759 4199 35 . . . 42759 4200 1 Those those DT 42759 4200 2 who who WP 42759 4200 3 acquire acquire VBP 42759 4200 4 a a DT 42759 4200 5 surplus surplus NN 42759 4200 6 over over IN 42759 4200 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4200 8 present present JJ 42759 4200 9 absolute absolute JJ 42759 4200 10 and and CC 42759 4200 11 conventional conventional JJ 42759 4200 12 needs need NNS 42759 4200 13 , , , 42759 4200 14 generally generally RB 42759 4200 15 devote devote VB 42759 4200 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4200 17 to to IN 42759 4200 18 an an DT 42759 4200 19 expansion expansion NN 42759 4200 20 of of IN 42759 4200 21 social social JJ 42759 4200 22 position position NN 42759 4200 23 . . . 42759 4201 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4201 2 move move VBP 42759 4201 3 into into IN 42759 4201 4 larger large JJR 42759 4201 5 and and CC 42759 4201 6 more more RBR 42759 4201 7 expensive expensive JJ 42759 4201 8 houses house NNS 42759 4201 9 , , , 42759 4201 10 thereby thereby RB 42759 4201 11 increasing increase VBG 42759 4201 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4201 13 assumed assume VBN 42759 4201 14 requirements requirement NNS 42759 4201 15 , , , 42759 4201 16 not not RB 42759 4201 17 merely merely RB 42759 4201 18 in in IN 42759 4201 19 the the DT 42759 4201 20 matter matter NN 42759 4201 21 of of IN 42759 4201 22 housing housing NN 42759 4201 23 , , , 42759 4201 24 but but CC 42759 4201 25 as as IN 42759 4201 26 regards regard VBZ 42759 4201 27 food food NN 42759 4201 28 , , , 42759 4201 29 clothing clothing NN 42759 4201 30 , , , 42759 4201 31 amusements amusement NNS 42759 4201 32 , , , 42759 4201 33 and and CC 42759 4201 34 the the DT 42759 4201 35 conventions convention NNS 42759 4201 36 of of IN 42759 4201 37 the the DT 42759 4201 38 social social JJ 42759 4201 39 group group NN 42759 4201 40 with with IN 42759 4201 41 which which WDT 42759 4201 42 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4201 43 are be VBP 42759 4201 44 affiliated affiliate VBN 42759 4201 45 . . . 42759 4202 1 In in IN 42759 4202 2 this this DT 42759 4202 3 way way NN 42759 4202 4 the the DT 42759 4202 5 surplus surplus NN 42759 4202 6 which which WDT 42759 4202 7 ought ought MD 42759 4202 8 to to TO 42759 4202 9 have have VB 42759 4202 10 been be VBN 42759 4202 11 distributed distribute VBN 42759 4202 12 is be VBZ 42759 4202 13 all all DT 42759 4202 14 absorbed absorb VBN 42759 4202 15 in in IN 42759 4202 16 the the DT 42759 4202 17 acquisition acquisition NN 42759 4202 18 and and CC 42759 4202 19 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 4202 20 of of IN 42759 4202 21 more more RBR 42759 4202 22 expensive expensive JJ 42759 4202 23 standards standard NNS 42759 4202 24 . . . 42759 4203 1 All all DT 42759 4203 2 classes class NNS 42759 4203 3 of of IN 42759 4203 4 possessors possessor NNS 42759 4203 5 adopt adopt VBP 42759 4203 6 and and CC 42759 4203 7 act act VB 42759 4203 8 upon upon IN 42759 4203 9 an an DT 42759 4203 10 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 42759 4203 11 conception conception NN 42759 4203 12 of of IN 42759 4203 13 both both CC 42759 4203 14 the the DT 42759 4203 15 strict strict JJ 42759 4203 16 and and CC 42759 4203 17 the the DT 42759 4203 18 conventional conventional JJ 42759 4203 19 necessities necessity NNS 42759 4203 20 . . . 42759 4204 1 In in IN 42759 4204 2 taking take VBG 42759 4204 3 this this DT 42759 4204 4 course course NN 42759 4204 5 , , , 42759 4204 6 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4204 7 are be VBP 42759 4204 8 merely merely RB 42759 4204 9 subscribing subscribe VBG 42759 4204 10 to to IN 42759 4204 11 the the DT 42759 4204 12 current current JJ 42759 4204 13 theory theory NN 42759 4204 14 of of IN 42759 4204 15 life life NN 42759 4204 16 and and CC 42759 4204 17 welfare welfare NN 42759 4204 18 . . . 42759 4205 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4205 2 is be VBZ 42759 4205 3 commonly commonly RB 42759 4205 4 assumed assume VBN 42759 4205 5 that that DT 42759 4205 6 to to TO 42759 4205 7 be be VB 42759 4205 8 worth worth JJ 42759 4205 9 while while IN 42759 4205 10 life life NN 42759 4205 11 must must MD 42759 4205 12 include include VB 42759 4205 13 the the DT 42759 4205 14 continuous continuous JJ 42759 4205 15 and and CC 42759 4205 16 indefinite indefinite JJ 42759 4205 17 increase increase NN 42759 4205 18 of of IN 42759 4205 19 the the DT 42759 4205 20 number number NN 42759 4205 21 and and CC 42759 4205 22 variety variety NN 42759 4205 23 of of IN 42759 4205 24 wants want NNS 42759 4205 25 , , , 42759 4205 26 and and CC 42759 4205 27 a a DT 42759 4205 28 corresponding correspond VBG 42759 4205 29 growth growth NN 42759 4205 30 and and CC 42759 4205 31 variation variation NN 42759 4205 32 in in IN 42759 4205 33 the the DT 42759 4205 34 means mean NNS 42759 4205 35 of of IN 42759 4205 36 satisfying satisfy VBG 42759 4205 37 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4205 38 . . . 42759 4206 1 Very very RB 42759 4206 2 little little JJ 42759 4206 3 endeavour endeavour NN 42759 4206 4 is be VBZ 42759 4206 5 made make VBN 42759 4206 6 to to TO 42759 4206 7 distinguish distinguish VB 42759 4206 8 between between IN 42759 4206 9 kinds kind NNS 42759 4206 10 of of IN 42759 4206 11 wants want NNS 42759 4206 12 , , , 42759 4206 13 or or CC 42759 4206 14 to to TO 42759 4206 15 arrange arrange VB 42759 4206 16 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4206 17 in in IN 42759 4206 18 any any DT 42759 4206 19 definite definite JJ 42759 4206 20 scale scale NN 42759 4206 21 of of IN 42759 4206 22 moral moral JJ 42759 4206 23 importance importance NN 42759 4206 24 . . . 42759 4207 1 Desires desire NNS 42759 4207 2 for for IN 42759 4207 3 purely purely RB 42759 4207 4 physical physical JJ 42759 4207 5 goods good NNS 42759 4207 6 , , , 42759 4207 7 such such JJ 42759 4207 8 as as IN 42759 4207 9 , , , 42759 4207 10 food food NN 42759 4207 11 , , , 42759 4207 12 drink drink NN 42759 4207 13 , , , 42759 4207 14 adornment adornment NN 42759 4207 15 , , , 42759 4207 16 and and CC 42759 4207 17 sense sense NN 42759 4207 18 gratifications gratification NNS 42759 4207 19 generally generally RB 42759 4207 20 , , , 42759 4207 21 are be VBP 42759 4207 22 put put VBN 42759 4207 23 on on IN 42759 4207 24 the the DT 42759 4207 25 same same JJ 42759 4207 26 level level NN 42759 4207 27 with with IN 42759 4207 28 the the DT 42759 4207 29 demands demand NNS 42759 4207 30 of of IN 42759 4207 31 the the DT 42759 4207 32 spiritual spiritual JJ 42759 4207 33 , , , 42759 4207 34 moral moral JJ 42759 4207 35 , , , 42759 4207 36 and and CC 42759 4207 37 intellectual intellectual JJ 42759 4207 38 faculties faculty NNS 42759 4207 39 . . . 42759 4208 1 The the DT 42759 4208 2 value value NN 42759 4208 3 and and CC 42759 4208 4 importance importance NN 42759 4208 5 of of IN 42759 4208 6 any any DT 42759 4208 7 and and CC 42759 4208 8 all all DT 42759 4208 9 wants want VBZ 42759 4208 10 is be VBZ 42759 4208 11 determined determine VBN 42759 4208 12 mainly mainly RB 42759 4208 13 by by IN 42759 4208 14 the the DT 42759 4208 15 criterion criterion NN 42759 4208 16 of of IN 42759 4208 17 enjoyment enjoyment NN 42759 4208 18 . . . 42759 4209 1 In in IN 42759 4209 2 the the DT 42759 4209 3 great great JJ 42759 4209 4 majority majority NN 42759 4209 5 of of IN 42759 4209 6 cases case NNS 42759 4209 7 this this DT 42759 4209 8 means mean VBZ 42759 4209 9 a a DT 42759 4209 10 preference preference NN 42759 4209 11 for for IN 42759 4209 12 the the DT 42759 4209 13 goods good NNS 42759 4209 14 and and CC 42759 4209 15 experiences experience NNS 42759 4209 16 that that WDT 42759 4209 17 minister minister VBP 42759 4209 18 to to IN 42759 4209 19 the the DT 42759 4209 20 senses sense NNS 42759 4209 21 . . . 42759 4210 1 Since since IN 42759 4210 2 these these DT 42759 4210 3 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 42759 4210 4 are be VBP 42759 4210 5 susceptible susceptible JJ 42759 4210 6 of of IN 42759 4210 7 indefinite indefinite JJ 42759 4210 8 increase increase NN 42759 4210 9 , , , 42759 4210 10 variety variety NN 42759 4210 11 , , , 42759 4210 12 and and CC 42759 4210 13 cost cost NN 42759 4210 14 , , , 42759 4210 15 the the DT 42759 4210 16 believer believer NN 42759 4210 17 in in IN 42759 4210 18 this this DT 42759 4210 19 theory theory NN 42759 4210 20 of of IN 42759 4210 21 life life NN 42759 4210 22 - - HYPH 42759 4210 23 values value NNS 42759 4210 24 readily readily RB 42759 4210 25 assumes assume VBZ 42759 4210 26 that that IN 42759 4210 27 no no DT 42759 4210 28 practical practical JJ 42759 4210 29 limit limit NN 42759 4210 30 can can MD 42759 4210 31 be be VB 42759 4210 32 set set VBN 42759 4210 33 to to IN 42759 4210 34 the the DT 42759 4210 35 amount amount NN 42759 4210 36 of of IN 42759 4210 37 goods good NNS 42759 4210 38 or or CC 42759 4210 39 income income NN 42759 4210 40 that that WDT 42759 4210 41 will will MD 42759 4210 42 be be VB 42759 4210 43 required require VBN 42759 4210 44 to to TO 42759 4210 45 make make VB 42759 4210 46 life life NN 42759 4210 47 continuously continuously RB 42759 4210 48 and and CC 42759 4210 49 progressively progressively RB 42759 4210 50 worth worth JJ 42759 4210 51 living live VBG 42759 4210 52 . . . 42759 4211 1 Hence hence RB 42759 4211 2 the the DT 42759 4211 3 question question NN 42759 4211 4 whether whether IN 42759 4211 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4211 6 has have VBZ 42759 4211 7 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4211 8 goods good NNS 42759 4211 9 , , , 42759 4211 10 how how WRB 42759 4211 11 much much JJ 42759 4211 12 of of IN 42759 4211 13 a a DT 42759 4211 14 surplus surplus NN 42759 4211 15 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4211 16 has have VBZ 42759 4211 17 , , , 42759 4211 18 or or CC 42759 4211 19 how how WRB 42759 4211 20 much much JJ 42759 4211 21 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4211 22 is be VBZ 42759 4211 23 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4211 24 to to TO 42759 4211 25 distribute distribute VB 42759 4211 26 , , , 42759 4211 27 scarcely scarcely RB 42759 4211 28 occurs occur VBZ 42759 4211 29 to to IN 42759 4211 30 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4211 31 at at RB 42759 4211 32 all all RB 42759 4211 33 . . . 42759 4212 1 Everything everything NN 42759 4212 2 that that WDT 42759 4212 3 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4212 4 possesses possess VBZ 42759 4212 5 or or CC 42759 4212 6 is be VBZ 42759 4212 7 likely likely JJ 42759 4212 8 to to TO 42759 4212 9 possess possess VB 42759 4212 10 , , , 42759 4212 11 is be VBZ 42759 4212 12 included include VBN 42759 4212 13 among among IN 42759 4212 14 the the DT 42759 4212 15 necessaries necessary NNS 42759 4212 16 of of IN 42759 4212 17 life life NN 42759 4212 18 and and CC 42759 4212 19 social social JJ 42759 4212 20 position position NN 42759 4212 21 . . . 42759 4213 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4213 2 adopts adopt VBZ 42759 4213 3 as as IN 42759 4213 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4213 5 working work VBG 42759 4213 6 theory theory NN 42759 4213 7 of of IN 42759 4213 8 life life NN 42759 4213 9 those those DT 42759 4213 10 propositions proposition NNS 42759 4213 11 which which WDT 42759 4213 12 were be VBD 42759 4213 13 condemned condemn VBN 42759 4213 14 as as IN 42759 4213 15 " " `` 42759 4213 16 scandalous scandalous JJ 42759 4213 17 and and CC 42759 4213 18 pernicious pernicious JJ 42759 4213 19 " " '' 42759 4213 20 by by IN 42759 4213 21 Pope Pope NNP 42759 4213 22 Innocent Innocent NNP 42759 4213 23 XI XI NNP 42759 4213 24 in in IN 42759 4213 25 1679 1679 CD 42759 4213 26 : : : 42759 4213 27 " " `` 42759 4213 28 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4213 29 is be VBZ 42759 4213 30 scarcely scarcely RB 42759 4213 31 possible possible JJ 42759 4213 32 to to TO 42759 4213 33 find find VB 42759 4213 34 among among IN 42759 4213 35 people people NNS 42759 4213 36 engaged engage VBN 42759 4213 37 in in IN 42759 4213 38 worldly worldly JJ 42759 4213 39 pursuits pursuit NNS 42759 4213 40 , , , 42759 4213 41 even even RB 42759 4213 42 among among IN 42759 4213 43 kings king NNS 42759 4213 44 , , , 42759 4213 45 goods good NNS 42759 4213 46 that that WDT 42759 4213 47 are be VBP 42759 4213 48 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4213 49 to to IN 42759 4213 50 social social JJ 42759 4213 51 position position NN 42759 4213 52 . . . 42759 4214 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 4214 2 , , , 42759 4214 3 hardly hardly RB 42759 4214 4 any any DT 42759 4214 5 one one NN 42759 4214 6 is be VBZ 42759 4214 7 bound bind VBN 42759 4214 8 to to TO 42759 4214 9 give give VB 42759 4214 10 alms alm NNS 42759 4214 11 from from IN 42759 4214 12 this this DT 42759 4214 13 source source NN 42759 4214 14 . . . 42759 4214 15 " " '' 42759 4215 1 The the DT 42759 4215 2 practical practical JJ 42759 4215 3 consequences consequence NNS 42759 4215 4 of of IN 42759 4215 5 this this DT 42759 4215 6 false false JJ 42759 4215 7 conception conception NN 42759 4215 8 of of IN 42759 4215 9 welfare welfare NN 42759 4215 10 are be VBP 42759 4215 11 naturally naturally RB 42759 4215 12 most most RBS 42759 4215 13 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 42759 4215 14 among among IN 42759 4215 15 the the DT 42759 4215 16 rich rich JJ 42759 4215 17 , , , 42759 4215 18 especially especially RB 42759 4215 19 the the DT 42759 4215 20 very very RB 42759 4215 21 rich rich JJ 42759 4215 22 , , , 42759 4215 23 but but CC 42759 4215 24 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4215 25 are be VBP 42759 4215 26 also also RB 42759 4215 27 manifest manifest JJ 42759 4215 28 among among IN 42759 4215 29 the the DT 42759 4215 30 comfortable comfortable JJ 42759 4215 31 and and CC 42759 4215 32 middle middle JJ 42759 4215 33 classes class NNS 42759 4215 34 . . . 42759 4216 1 In in IN 42759 4216 2 every every DT 42759 4216 3 social social JJ 42759 4216 4 group group NN 42759 4216 5 above above IN 42759 4216 6 the the DT 42759 4216 7 limit limit NN 42759 4216 8 of of IN 42759 4216 9 very very RB 42759 4216 10 moderate moderate JJ 42759 4216 11 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 4216 12 , , , 42759 4216 13 too too RB 42759 4216 14 much much JJ 42759 4216 15 money money NN 42759 4216 16 is be VBZ 42759 4216 17 spent spend VBN 42759 4216 18 for for IN 42759 4216 19 material material JJ 42759 4216 20 goods good NNS 42759 4216 21 and and CC 42759 4216 22 enjoyments enjoyment NNS 42759 4216 23 , , , 42759 4216 24 and and CC 42759 4216 25 too too RB 42759 4216 26 little little JJ 42759 4216 27 for for IN 42759 4216 28 the the DT 42759 4216 29 intellectual intellectual JJ 42759 4216 30 , , , 42759 4216 31 religious religious JJ 42759 4216 32 , , , 42759 4216 33 and and CC 42759 4216 34 altruistic altruistic JJ 42759 4216 35 things thing NNS 42759 4216 36 of of IN 42759 4216 37 life life NN 42759 4216 38 . . . 42759 4217 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4217 2 The the DT 42759 4217 3 True True NNP 42759 4217 4 Conception Conception NNP 42759 4217 5 of of IN 42759 4217 6 Welfare Welfare NNP 42759 4217 7 _ _ NNP 42759 4217 8 This this DT 42759 4217 9 working work VBG 42759 4217 10 creed creed NN 42759 4217 11 of of IN 42759 4217 12 materialism materialism NN 42759 4217 13 is be VBZ 42759 4217 14 condemned condemn VBN 42759 4217 15 by by IN 42759 4217 16 right right JJ 42759 4217 17 reason reason NN 42759 4217 18 , , , 42759 4217 19 as as RB 42759 4217 20 well well RB 42759 4217 21 as as IN 42759 4217 22 by by IN 42759 4217 23 Christianity Christianity NNP 42759 4217 24 . . . 42759 4218 1 The the DT 42759 4218 2 teaching teaching NN 42759 4218 3 of of IN 42759 4218 4 Christ Christ NNP 42759 4218 5 on on IN 42759 4218 6 the the DT 42759 4218 7 worth worth NN 42759 4218 8 of of IN 42759 4218 9 material material JJ 42759 4218 10 goods good NNS 42759 4218 11 is be VBZ 42759 4218 12 expressed express VBN 42759 4218 13 substantially substantially RB 42759 4218 14 in in IN 42759 4218 15 the the DT 42759 4218 16 following following JJ 42759 4218 17 texts text NNS 42759 4218 18 : : : 42759 4218 19 " " `` 42759 4218 20 Woe woe NN 42759 4218 21 to to IN 42759 4218 22 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4218 23 rich rich JJ 42759 4218 24 . . . 42759 4218 25 " " '' 42759 4219 1 " " `` 42759 4219 2 Blessed bless VBN 42759 4219 3 are be VBP 42759 4219 4 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4219 5 poor poor JJ 42759 4219 6 . . . 42759 4219 7 " " '' 42759 4220 1 " " `` 42759 4220 2 Lay lay VB 42759 4220 3 not not RB 42759 4220 4 up up IN 42759 4220 5 for for IN 42759 4220 6 yourselves yourself NNS 42759 4220 7 treasures treasure NNS 42759 4220 8 on on IN 42759 4220 9 earth earth NN 42759 4220 10 . . . 42759 4220 11 " " '' 42759 4221 1 " " `` 42759 4221 2 For for IN 42759 4221 3 a a DT 42759 4221 4 man man NN 42759 4221 5 's 's POS 42759 4221 6 life life NN 42759 4221 7 consisteth consisteth NN 42759 4221 8 not not RB 42759 4221 9 in in IN 42759 4221 10 the the DT 42759 4221 11 abundance abundance NN 42759 4221 12 of of IN 42759 4221 13 things thing NNS 42759 4221 14 that that WDT 42759 4221 15 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4221 16 possesseth possesseth VBZ 42759 4221 17 . . . 42759 4221 18 " " '' 42759 4222 1 " " `` 42759 4222 2 Be be VB 42759 4222 3 not not RB 42759 4222 4 solicitous solicitous JJ 42759 4222 5 as as IN 42759 4222 6 to to IN 42759 4222 7 what what WP 42759 4222 8 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4222 9 shall shall MD 42759 4222 10 eat eat VB 42759 4222 11 , , , 42759 4222 12 or or CC 42759 4222 13 what what WP 42759 4222 14 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4222 15 shall shall MD 42759 4222 16 drink drink VB 42759 4222 17 , , , 42759 4222 18 or or CC 42759 4222 19 what what WP 42759 4222 20 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4222 21 shall shall MD 42759 4222 22 put put VB 42759 4222 23 on on RP 42759 4222 24 . . . 42759 4222 25 " " '' 42759 4223 1 " " `` 42759 4223 2 Seek seek VB 42759 4223 3 ye ye NN 42759 4223 4 first first RB 42759 4223 5 the the DT 42759 4223 6 kingdom kingdom NN 42759 4223 7 of of IN 42759 4223 8 God God NNP 42759 4223 9 and and CC 42759 4223 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4223 11 justice justice NN 42759 4223 12 , , , 42759 4223 13 and and CC 42759 4223 14 all all PDT 42759 4223 15 these these DT 42759 4223 16 things thing NNS 42759 4223 17 shall shall MD 42759 4223 18 be be VB 42759 4223 19 added add VBN 42759 4223 20 unto unto IN 42759 4223 21 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4223 22 . . . 42759 4223 23 " " '' 42759 4224 1 " " `` 42759 4224 2 You -PRON- PRP 42759 4224 3 can can MD 42759 4224 4 not not RB 42759 4224 5 serve serve VB 42759 4224 6 God God NNP 42759 4224 7 and and CC 42759 4224 8 Mammon Mammon NNP 42759 4224 9 . . . 42759 4224 10 " " '' 42759 4225 1 " " `` 42759 4225 2 If if IN 42759 4225 3 thou thou NNP 42759 4225 4 wouldst wouldst NNS 42759 4225 5 be be VB 42759 4225 6 perfect perfect JJ 42759 4225 7 , , , 42759 4225 8 go go VB 42759 4225 9 , , , 42759 4225 10 sell sell VB 42759 4225 11 what what WP 42759 4225 12 thou thou NNP 42759 4225 13 hast hast NNP 42759 4225 14 and and CC 42759 4225 15 give give VB 42759 4225 16 to to IN 42759 4225 17 the the DT 42759 4225 18 poor poor JJ 42759 4225 19 , , , 42759 4225 20 and and CC 42759 4225 21 come come VB 42759 4225 22 follow follow VB 42759 4225 23 me -PRON- PRP 42759 4225 24 . . . 42759 4225 25 " " '' 42759 4226 1 Reason reason NN 42759 4226 2 informs inform VBZ 42759 4226 3 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4226 4 that that IN 42759 4226 5 neither neither CC 42759 4226 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4226 7 faculties faculty NNS 42759 4226 8 nor nor CC 42759 4226 9 the the DT 42759 4226 10 goods good NNS 42759 4226 11 that that WDT 42759 4226 12 satisfy satisfy VBP 42759 4226 13 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4226 14 are be VBP 42759 4226 15 of of IN 42759 4226 16 equal equal JJ 42759 4226 17 moral moral JJ 42759 4226 18 worth worth NN 42759 4226 19 or or CC 42759 4226 20 importance importance NN 42759 4226 21 . . . 42759 4227 1 The the DT 42759 4227 2 intellectual intellectual JJ 42759 4227 3 and and CC 42759 4227 4 spiritual spiritual JJ 42759 4227 5 faculties faculty NNS 42759 4227 6 are be VBP 42759 4227 7 essentially essentially RB 42759 4227 8 and and CC 42759 4227 9 intrinsically intrinsically RB 42759 4227 10 higher high JJR 42759 4227 11 than than IN 42759 4227 12 the the DT 42759 4227 13 sense sense NN 42759 4227 14 faculties faculty NNS 42759 4227 15 . . . 42759 4228 1 Only only RB 42759 4228 2 in in IN 42759 4228 3 so so RB 42759 4228 4 far far RB 42759 4228 5 as as IN 42759 4228 6 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4228 7 promote promote VBP 42759 4228 8 , , , 42759 4228 9 either either CC 42759 4228 10 negatively negatively RB 42759 4228 11 or or CC 42759 4228 12 positively positively RB 42759 4228 13 , , , 42759 4228 14 the the DT 42759 4228 15 development development NN 42759 4228 16 of of IN 42759 4228 17 the the DT 42759 4228 18 mind mind NN 42759 4228 19 and and CC 42759 4228 20 soul soul NN 42759 4228 21 have have VBP 42759 4228 22 the the DT 42759 4228 23 senses sense NNS 42759 4228 24 any any DT 42759 4228 25 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4228 26 claim claim NN 42759 4228 27 to to IN 42759 4228 28 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 4228 29 . . . 42759 4229 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4229 2 have have VBP 42759 4229 3 no no DT 42759 4229 4 value value NN 42759 4229 5 in in IN 42759 4229 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 4229 7 ; ; : 42759 4229 8 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4229 9 are be VBP 42759 4229 10 merely merely RB 42759 4229 11 instruments instrument NNS 42759 4229 12 to to IN 42759 4229 13 the the DT 42759 4229 14 welfare welfare NN 42759 4229 15 of of IN 42759 4229 16 the the DT 42759 4229 17 spirit spirit NNP 42759 4229 18 , , , 42759 4229 19 the the DT 42759 4229 20 intellect intellect NN 42759 4229 21 , , , 42759 4229 22 and and CC 42759 4229 23 the the DT 42759 4229 24 disinterested disinterested NN 42759 4229 25 will will NN 42759 4229 26 . . . 42759 4230 1 Right right JJ 42759 4230 2 life life NN 42759 4230 3 consists consist VBZ 42759 4230 4 , , , 42759 4230 5 not not RB 42759 4230 6 in in IN 42759 4230 7 the the DT 42759 4230 8 indefinite indefinite JJ 42759 4230 9 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 4230 10 of of IN 42759 4230 11 material material NN 42759 4230 12 wants want VBZ 42759 4230 13 , , , 42759 4230 14 but but CC 42759 4230 15 in in IN 42759 4230 16 the the DT 42759 4230 17 progressive progressive JJ 42759 4230 18 endeavour endeavour NN 42759 4230 19 to to TO 42759 4230 20 know know VB 42759 4230 21 the the DT 42759 4230 22 best good JJS 42759 4230 23 that that WDT 42759 4230 24 is be VBZ 42759 4230 25 to to TO 42759 4230 26 be be VB 42759 4230 27 known know VBN 42759 4230 28 , , , 42759 4230 29 and and CC 42759 4230 30 to to TO 42759 4230 31 love love VB 42759 4230 32 the the DT 42759 4230 33 best good JJS 42759 4230 34 that that WDT 42759 4230 35 is be VBZ 42759 4230 36 to to TO 42759 4230 37 be be VB 42759 4230 38 loved love VBN 42759 4230 39 ; ; : 42759 4230 40 that that RB 42759 4230 41 is is RB 42759 4230 42 , , , 42759 4230 43 God God NNP 42759 4230 44 and and CC 42759 4230 45 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4230 46 creatures creature NNS 42759 4230 47 in in IN 42759 4230 48 the the DT 42759 4230 49 order order NN 42759 4230 50 of of IN 42759 4230 51 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4230 52 importance importance NN 42759 4230 53 . . . 42759 4231 1 The the DT 42759 4231 2 man man NN 42759 4231 3 who who WP 42759 4231 4 denies deny VBZ 42759 4231 5 the the DT 42759 4231 6 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 4231 7 superiority superiority NN 42759 4231 8 of of IN 42759 4231 9 the the DT 42759 4231 10 soul soul NN 42759 4231 11 to to IN 42759 4231 12 the the DT 42759 4231 13 senses sense NNS 42759 4231 14 , , , 42759 4231 15 who who WP 42759 4231 16 puts put VBZ 42759 4231 17 sense sense NN 42759 4231 18 gratifications gratification NNS 42759 4231 19 on on IN 42759 4231 20 the the DT 42759 4231 21 same same JJ 42759 4231 22 level level NN 42759 4231 23 of of IN 42759 4231 24 importance importance NN 42759 4231 25 as as IN 42759 4231 26 the the DT 42759 4231 27 activities activity NNS 42759 4231 28 of of IN 42759 4231 29 mind mind NN 42759 4231 30 , , , 42759 4231 31 and and CC 42759 4231 32 spirit spirit NN 42759 4231 33 , , , 42759 4231 34 and and CC 42759 4231 35 disinterested disintereste VBD 42759 4231 36 will will MD 42759 4231 37 , , , 42759 4231 38 logically logically RB 42759 4231 39 holds hold VBZ 42759 4231 40 that that IN 42759 4231 41 the the DT 42759 4231 42 most most JJS 42759 4231 43 degrading degrading JJ 42759 4231 44 actions action NNS 42759 4231 45 are be VBP 42759 4231 46 equally equally RB 42759 4231 47 good good JJ 42759 4231 48 and and CC 42759 4231 49 commendable commendable JJ 42759 4231 50 with with IN 42759 4231 51 those those DT 42759 4231 52 which which WDT 42759 4231 53 mankind mankind NN 42759 4231 54 approves approve NNS 42759 4231 55 as as IN 42759 4231 56 the the DT 42759 4231 57 noblest noble JJS 42759 4231 58 . . . 42759 4232 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4232 2 moral moral JJ 42759 4232 3 standard standard NN 42759 4232 4 does do VBZ 42759 4232 5 not not RB 42759 4232 6 differ differ VB 42759 4232 7 from from IN 42759 4232 8 that that DT 42759 4232 9 of of IN 42759 4232 10 the the DT 42759 4232 11 pig pig NN 42759 4232 12 , , , 42759 4232 13 and and CC 42759 4232 14 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4232 15 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4232 16 is be VBZ 42759 4232 17 on on IN 42759 4232 18 no no DT 42759 4232 19 higher high JJR 42759 4232 20 moral moral JJ 42759 4232 21 level level NN 42759 4232 22 than than IN 42759 4232 23 the the DT 42759 4232 24 pig pig NN 42759 4232 25 . . . 42759 4233 1 Those those DT 42759 4233 2 who who WP 42759 4233 3 accept accept VBP 42759 4233 4 the the DT 42759 4233 5 view view NN 42759 4233 6 of of IN 42759 4233 7 life life NN 42759 4233 8 and and CC 42759 4233 9 welfare welfare NN 42759 4233 10 taught teach VBN 42759 4233 11 by by IN 42759 4233 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 42759 4233 13 and and CC 42759 4233 14 reason reason NN 42759 4233 15 can can MD 42759 4233 16 not not RB 42759 4233 17 , , , 42759 4233 18 if if IN 42759 4233 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4233 20 take take VBP 42759 4233 21 the the DT 42759 4233 22 trouble trouble NN 42759 4233 23 to to TO 42759 4233 24 consider consider VB 42759 4233 25 the the DT 42759 4233 26 matter matter NN 42759 4233 27 , , , 42759 4233 28 avoid avoid VB 42759 4233 29 the the DT 42759 4233 30 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 4233 31 that that IN 42759 4233 32 the the DT 42759 4233 33 amount amount NN 42759 4233 34 of of IN 42759 4233 35 material material NN 42759 4233 36 goods good NNS 42759 4233 37 which which WDT 42759 4233 38 can can MD 42759 4233 39 be be VB 42759 4233 40 expended expend VBN 42759 4233 41 in in IN 42759 4233 42 the the DT 42759 4233 43 rational rational JJ 42759 4233 44 and and CC 42759 4233 45 justifiable justifiable JJ 42759 4233 46 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 4233 47 of of IN 42759 4233 48 the the DT 42759 4233 49 senses sense NNS 42759 4233 50 , , , 42759 4233 51 is be VBZ 42759 4233 52 very very RB 42759 4233 53 much much RB 42759 4233 54 smaller small JJR 42759 4233 55 than than IN 42759 4233 56 is be VBZ 42759 4233 57 to to IN 42759 4233 58 - - HYPH 42759 4233 59 day day NN 42759 4233 60 assumed assume VBN 42759 4233 61 by by IN 42759 4233 62 the the DT 42759 4233 63 great great JJ 42759 4233 64 majority majority NN 42759 4233 65 of of IN 42759 4233 66 persons person NNS 42759 4233 67 . . . 42759 4234 1 Somewhere somewhere RB 42759 4234 2 between between IN 42759 4234 3 five five CD 42759 4234 4 and and CC 42759 4234 5 ten ten CD 42759 4234 6 thousand thousand CD 42759 4234 7 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4234 8 a a DT 42759 4234 9 year year NN 42759 4234 10 lies lie VBZ 42759 4234 11 the the DT 42759 4234 12 maximum maximum JJ 42759 4234 13 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 4234 14 that that WDT 42759 4234 15 any any DT 42759 4234 16 family family NN 42759 4234 17 can can MD 42759 4234 18 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 4234 19 devote devote VB 42759 4234 20 to to IN 42759 4234 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4234 22 material material NN 42759 4234 23 wants want VBZ 42759 4234 24 . . . 42759 4235 1 This this DT 42759 4235 2 is be VBZ 42759 4235 3 independent independent JJ 42759 4235 4 of of IN 42759 4235 5 the the DT 42759 4235 6 outlay outlay NN 42759 4235 7 for for IN 42759 4235 8 education education NN 42759 4235 9 , , , 42759 4235 10 religion religion NN 42759 4235 11 , , , 42759 4235 12 and and CC 42759 4235 13 charity charity NN 42759 4235 14 , , , 42759 4235 15 and and CC 42759 4235 16 the the DT 42759 4235 17 things thing NNS 42759 4235 18 of of IN 42759 4235 19 the the DT 42759 4235 20 mind mind NN 42759 4235 21 generally generally RB 42759 4235 22 . . . 42759 4236 1 In in IN 42759 4236 2 the the DT 42759 4236 3 overwhelming overwhelming JJ 42759 4236 4 majority majority NN 42759 4236 5 of of IN 42759 4236 6 cases case NNS 42759 4236 7 in in IN 42759 4236 8 which which WDT 42759 4236 9 more more JJR 42759 4236 10 than than IN 42759 4236 11 five five CD 42759 4236 12 to to TO 42759 4236 13 ten ten CD 42759 4236 14 thousand thousand CD 42759 4236 15 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4236 16 are be VBP 42759 4236 17 expended expend VBN 42759 4236 18 for for IN 42759 4236 19 the the DT 42759 4236 20 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 4236 21 of of IN 42759 4236 22 material material NN 42759 4236 23 needs need NNS 42759 4236 24 , , , 42759 4236 25 some some DT 42759 4236 26 injury injury NN 42759 4236 27 is be VBZ 42759 4236 28 done do VBN 42759 4236 29 to to IN 42759 4236 30 the the DT 42759 4236 31 higher high JJR 42759 4236 32 life life NN 42759 4236 33 . . . 42759 4237 1 The the DT 42759 4237 2 interests interest NNS 42759 4237 3 of of IN 42759 4237 4 health health NN 42759 4237 5 , , , 42759 4237 6 intellect intellect NN 42759 4237 7 , , , 42759 4237 8 spirit spirit NN 42759 4237 9 , , , 42759 4237 10 or or CC 42759 4237 11 morals moral NNS 42759 4237 12 would would MD 42759 4237 13 be be VB 42759 4237 14 better well RBR 42759 4237 15 promoted promote VBN 42759 4237 16 if if IN 42759 4237 17 the the DT 42759 4237 18 outlay outlay NN 42759 4237 19 for for IN 42759 4237 20 material material JJ 42759 4237 21 things thing NNS 42759 4237 22 were be VBD 42759 4237 23 kept keep VBN 42759 4237 24 below below IN 42759 4237 25 the the DT 42759 4237 26 specified specify VBN 42759 4237 27 limit limit NN 42759 4237 28 . . . 42759 4238 1 The the DT 42759 4238 2 distribution distribution NN 42759 4238 3 advocated advocate VBN 42759 4238 4 in in IN 42759 4238 5 this this DT 42759 4238 6 chapter chapter NN 42759 4238 7 is be VBZ 42759 4238 8 obviously obviously RB 42759 4238 9 no no DT 42759 4238 10 substitute substitute NN 42759 4238 11 for for IN 42759 4238 12 justice justice NN 42759 4238 13 or or CC 42759 4238 14 the the DT 42759 4238 15 deeds deed NNS 42759 4238 16 of of IN 42759 4238 17 justice justice NN 42759 4238 18 . . . 42759 4239 1 Inasmuch inasmuch RB 42759 4239 2 , , , 42759 4239 3 however however RB 42759 4239 4 , , , 42759 4239 5 as as IN 42759 4239 6 complete complete JJ 42759 4239 7 justice justice NN 42759 4239 8 is be VBZ 42759 4239 9 a a DT 42759 4239 10 long long JJ 42759 4239 11 way way NN 42759 4239 12 from from IN 42759 4239 13 realisation realisation NN 42759 4239 14 , , , 42759 4239 15 a a DT 42759 4239 16 serious serious JJ 42759 4239 17 attempt attempt NN 42759 4239 18 by by IN 42759 4239 19 the the DT 42759 4239 20 possessors possessor NNS 42759 4239 21 of of IN 42759 4239 22 true true JJ 42759 4239 23 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4239 24 goods good NNS 42759 4239 25 to to TO 42759 4239 26 fulfil fulfil VB 42759 4239 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4239 28 obligations obligation NNS 42759 4239 29 of of IN 42759 4239 30 distribution distribution NN 42759 4239 31 would would MD 42759 4239 32 greatly greatly RB 42759 4239 33 counteract counteract VB 42759 4239 34 and and CC 42759 4239 35 soften soften VB 42759 4239 36 existing exist VBG 42759 4239 37 injustice injustice NN 42759 4239 38 , , , 42759 4239 39 inequality inequality NN 42759 4239 40 , , , 42759 4239 41 and and CC 42759 4239 42 suffering suffering NN 42759 4239 43 . . . 42759 4240 1 Hence hence RB 42759 4240 2 , , , 42759 4240 3 benevolent benevolent JJ 42759 4240 4 giving giving NN 42759 4240 5 deserves deserve VBZ 42759 4240 6 a a DT 42759 4240 7 place place NN 42759 4240 8 in in IN 42759 4240 9 any any DT 42759 4240 10 complete complete JJ 42759 4240 11 statement statement NN 42759 4240 12 of of IN 42759 4240 13 proposals proposal NNS 42759 4240 14 for for IN 42759 4240 15 a a DT 42759 4240 16 better well JJR 42759 4240 17 distribution distribution NN 42759 4240 18 of of IN 42759 4240 19 wealth wealth NN 42759 4240 20 . . . 42759 4241 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4241 2 , , , 42759 4241 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4241 4 are be VBP 42759 4241 5 not not RB 42759 4241 6 likely likely JJ 42759 4241 7 to to TO 42759 4241 8 make make VB 42759 4241 9 great great JJ 42759 4241 10 advances advance NNS 42759 4241 11 on on IN 42759 4241 12 the the DT 42759 4241 13 road road NN 42759 4241 14 of of IN 42759 4241 15 strict strict JJ 42759 4241 16 justice justice NN 42759 4241 17 until until IN 42759 4241 18 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4241 19 acquire acquire VBP 42759 4241 20 saner saner JJ 42759 4241 21 conceptions conception NNS 42759 4241 22 of of IN 42759 4241 23 welfare welfare NN 42759 4241 24 , , , 42759 4241 25 and and CC 42759 4241 26 a a DT 42759 4241 27 more more RBR 42759 4241 28 effective effective JJ 42759 4241 29 notion notion NN 42759 4241 30 of of IN 42759 4241 31 brotherly brotherly JJ 42759 4241 32 love love NN 42759 4241 33 . . . 42759 4242 1 So so RB 42759 4242 2 long long RB 42759 4242 3 as as IN 42759 4242 4 men man NNS 42759 4242 5 put put VBD 42759 4242 6 the the DT 42759 4242 7 senses sense NNS 42759 4242 8 above above IN 42759 4242 9 the the DT 42759 4242 10 soul soul NN 42759 4242 11 , , , 42759 4242 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4242 13 will will MD 42759 4242 14 be be VB 42759 4242 15 unable unable JJ 42759 4242 16 to to TO 42759 4242 17 see see VB 42759 4242 18 clearly clearly RB 42759 4242 19 what what WP 42759 4242 20 is be VBZ 42759 4242 21 justice justice NN 42759 4242 22 , , , 42759 4242 23 and and CC 42759 4242 24 unwilling unwilling JJ 42759 4242 25 to to TO 42759 4242 26 practise practise VB 42759 4242 27 the the DT 42759 4242 28 little little JJ 42759 4242 29 that that IN 42759 4242 30 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4242 31 are be VBP 42759 4242 32 able able JJ 42759 4242 33 to to TO 42759 4242 34 see see VB 42759 4242 35 . . . 42759 4243 1 Those those DT 42759 4243 2 who who WP 42759 4243 3 exaggerate exaggerate VBP 42759 4243 4 the the DT 42759 4243 5 value value NN 42759 4243 6 of of IN 42759 4243 7 sense sense NN 42759 4243 8 gratifications gratification NNS 42759 4243 9 can can MD 42759 4243 10 not not RB 42759 4243 11 be be VB 42759 4243 12 truly truly RB 42759 4243 13 charitable charitable JJ 42759 4243 14 , , , 42759 4243 15 and and CC 42759 4243 16 those those DT 42759 4243 17 who who WP 42759 4243 18 are be VBP 42759 4243 19 not not RB 42759 4243 20 truly truly RB 42759 4243 21 charitable charitable JJ 42759 4243 22 can can MD 42759 4243 23 not not RB 42759 4243 24 perform perform VB 42759 4243 25 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4243 26 justice justice NN 42759 4243 27 . . . 42759 4244 1 The the DT 42759 4244 2 achievement achievement NN 42759 4244 3 of of IN 42759 4244 4 social social JJ 42759 4244 5 justice justice NN 42759 4244 6 requires require VBZ 42759 4244 7 not not RB 42759 4244 8 merely merely RB 42759 4244 9 changes change NNS 42759 4244 10 in in IN 42759 4244 11 the the DT 42759 4244 12 social social JJ 42759 4244 13 mechanism mechanism NN 42759 4244 14 , , , 42759 4244 15 but but CC 42759 4244 16 a a DT 42759 4244 17 change change NN 42759 4244 18 in in IN 42759 4244 19 the the DT 42759 4244 20 social social NNP 42759 4244 21 spirit spirit NNP 42759 4244 22 , , , 42759 4244 23 a a DT 42759 4244 24 reformation reformation NN 42759 4244 25 in in IN 42759 4244 26 men man NNS 42759 4244 27 's 's POS 42759 4244 28 hearts heart NNS 42759 4244 29 . . . 42759 4245 1 To to IN 42759 4245 2 this this DT 42759 4245 3 end end NN 42759 4245 4 nothing nothing NN 42759 4245 5 could could MD 42759 4245 6 be be VB 42759 4245 7 more more RBR 42759 4245 8 immediately immediately RB 42759 4245 9 helpful helpful JJ 42759 4245 10 than than IN 42759 4245 11 a a DT 42759 4245 12 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 4245 13 recognition recognition NN 42759 4245 14 of of IN 42759 4245 15 the the DT 42759 4245 16 stewardship stewardship NN 42759 4245 17 of of IN 42759 4245 18 wealth wealth NN 42759 4245 19 , , , 42759 4245 20 and and CC 42759 4245 21 the the DT 42759 4245 22 duty duty NN 42759 4245 23 of of IN 42759 4245 24 distributing distribute VBG 42759 4245 25 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4245 26 goods good NNS 42759 4245 27 . . . 42759 4246 1 REFERENCES reference NNS 42759 4246 2 ON on IN 42759 4246 3 SECTION section NN 42759 4246 4 III iii CD 42759 4246 5 ELY ELY NNP 42759 4246 6 : : : 42759 4246 7 Monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 4246 8 and and CC 42759 4246 9 Trusts Trusts NNPS 42759 4246 10 . . . 42759 4247 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 4247 2 ; ; : 42759 4247 3 1900 1900 CD 42759 4247 4 . . . 42759 4248 1 VAN VAN NNP 42759 4248 2 HISE HISE NNP 42759 4248 3 : : : 42759 4248 4 Concentration Concentration NNP 42759 4248 5 and and CC 42759 4248 6 Control Control NNP 42759 4248 7 . . . 42759 4249 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 4249 2 ; ; : 42759 4249 3 1912 1912 CD 42759 4249 4 . . . 42759 4250 1 STEVENS STEVENS NNP 42759 4250 2 : : : 42759 4250 3 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 4250 4 Combinations Combinations NNPS 42759 4250 5 and and CC 42759 4250 6 Trusts Trusts NNPS 42759 4250 7 . . . 42759 4251 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 4251 2 ; ; : 42759 4251 3 1913 1913 CD 42759 4251 4 . . . 42759 4252 1 RUSSELL RUSSELL NNP 42759 4252 2 : : : 42759 4252 3 Business business NN 42759 4252 4 , , , 42759 4252 5 the the DT 42759 4252 6 Heart heart NN 42759 4252 7 of of IN 42759 4252 8 the the DT 42759 4252 9 Nation nation NN 42759 4252 10 . . . 42759 4253 1 John John NNP 42759 4253 2 Lane Lane NNP 42759 4253 3 ; ; : 42759 4253 4 1911 1911 CD 42759 4253 5 . . . 42759 4254 1 GARRIGUET GARRIGUET NNS 42759 4254 2 : : : 42759 4254 3 Régime Régime NNP 42759 4254 4 du du VB 42759 4254 5 Travail Travail NNP 42759 4254 6 . . . 42759 4255 1 Paris Paris NNP 42759 4255 2 ; ; : 42759 4255 3 1909 1909 CD 42759 4255 4 . . . 42759 4256 1 The the DT 42759 4256 2 Social Social NNP 42759 4256 3 Value Value NNP 42759 4256 4 of of IN 42759 4256 5 the the DT 42759 4256 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 42759 4256 7 . . . 42759 4257 1 St. St. NNP 42759 4257 2 Louis Louis NNP 42759 4257 3 ; ; : 42759 4257 4 1911 1911 CD 42759 4257 5 . . . 42759 4258 1 HOBSON HOBSON NNP 42759 4258 2 : : : 42759 4258 3 Work work NN 42759 4258 4 and and CC 42759 4258 5 Wealth wealth NN 42759 4258 6 , , , 42759 4258 7 a a DT 42759 4258 8 Human Human NNP 42759 4258 9 Valuation valuation NN 42759 4258 10 . . . 42759 4259 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 4259 2 ; ; : 42759 4259 3 1914 1914 CD 42759 4259 4 . . . 42759 4260 1 WEST WEST NNP 42759 4260 2 : : : 42759 4260 3 The the DT 42759 4260 4 Inheritance Inheritance NNP 42759 4260 5 Tax Tax NNP 42759 4260 6 . . . 42759 4261 1 New New NNP 42759 4261 2 York York NNP 42759 4261 3 ; ; : 42759 4261 4 1908 1908 CD 42759 4261 5 . . . 42759 4262 1 SELIGMAN SELIGMAN NNP 42759 4262 2 : : : 42759 4262 3 Progressive Progressive NNP 42759 4262 4 Taxation Taxation NNP 42759 4262 5 . . . 42759 4263 1 Princeton Princeton NNP 42759 4263 2 ; ; : 42759 4263 3 1908 1908 CD 42759 4263 4 . . . 42759 4264 1 The the DT 42759 4264 2 Income Income NNP 42759 4264 3 Tax Tax NNP 42759 4264 4 . . . 42759 4265 1 New New NNP 42759 4265 2 York York NNP 42759 4265 3 ; ; : 42759 4265 4 1913 1913 CD 42759 4265 5 . . . 42759 4266 1 BOUQUILLON BOUQUILLON NNP 42759 4266 2 : : : 42759 4266 3 De De NNP 42759 4266 4 Virtutibus Virtutibus NNP 42759 4266 5 Theologicis Theologicis NNP 42759 4266 6 . . . 42759 4267 1 Brugis brugi NNS 42759 4267 2 ; ; : 42759 4267 3 1890 1890 CD 42759 4267 4 . . . 42759 4268 1 Also also RB 42759 4268 2 , , , 42759 4268 3 the the DT 42759 4268 4 works work NNS 42759 4268 5 of of IN 42759 4268 6 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 4268 7 , , , 42759 4268 8 Devas Devas NNP 42759 4268 9 , , , 42759 4268 10 Hobson Hobson NNP 42759 4268 11 , , , 42759 4268 12 Antoine Antoine NNP 42759 4268 13 , , , 42759 4268 14 Pesch Pesch NNP 42759 4268 15 , , , 42759 4268 16 Carver Carver NNP 42759 4268 17 , , , 42759 4268 18 Vermeersch Vermeersch NNP 42759 4268 19 , , , 42759 4268 20 Nearing Nearing NNP 42759 4268 21 , , , 42759 4268 22 and and CC 42759 4268 23 King King NNP 42759 4268 24 which which WDT 42759 4268 25 are be VBP 42759 4268 26 cited cite VBN 42759 4268 27 in in IN 42759 4268 28 connection connection NN 42759 4268 29 with with IN 42759 4268 30 the the DT 42759 4268 31 introductory introductory JJ 42759 4268 32 chapter chapter NN 42759 4268 33 . . . 42759 4269 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 4269 2 : : : 42759 4269 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4269 4 201 201 CD 42759 4269 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4269 6 " " `` 42759 4269 7 Summa Summa NNP 42759 4269 8 Theologica Theologica NNP 42759 4269 9 , , , 42759 4269 10 " " '' 42759 4269 11 2a 2a CD 42759 4269 12 . . . 42759 4270 1 2ae 2ae NNP 42759 4270 2 . . NNP 42759 4270 3 , , , 42759 4270 4 q. q. NNP 42759 4271 1 66 66 CD 42759 4271 2 , , , 42759 4271 3 a. a. NN 42759 4272 1 3 3 LS 42759 4272 2 . . . 42759 4273 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4273 2 202 202 CD 42759 4273 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4273 4 " " `` 42759 4273 5 Patrologia Patrologia NNP 42759 4273 6 Graeca Graeca NNP 42759 4273 7 , , , 42759 4273 8 " " '' 42759 4273 9 vol vol NNP 42759 4273 10 . . . 42759 4274 1 31 31 CD 42759 4274 2 , , , 42759 4274 3 cols col NNS 42759 4274 4 . . . 42759 4275 1 275 275 CD 42759 4275 2 , , , 42759 4275 3 278 278 CD 42759 4275 4 . . . 42759 4276 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4276 2 203 203 CD 42759 4276 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4276 4 " " `` 42759 4276 5 Patrologia Patrologia NNP 42759 4276 6 Latina Latina NNP 42759 4276 7 , , , 42759 4276 8 " " '' 42759 4276 9 vol vol NNP 42759 4276 10 . . . 42759 4277 1 37 37 CD 42759 4277 2 , , , 42759 4277 3 col col NNP 42759 4277 4 . . NNP 42759 4277 5 1922 1922 CD 42759 4277 6 . . . 42759 4278 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4278 2 204 204 CD 42759 4278 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4278 4 " " `` 42759 4278 5 Patrologia Patrologia NNP 42759 4278 6 Latina Latina NNP 42759 4278 7 , , , 42759 4278 8 " " '' 42759 4278 9 vol vol NNP 42759 4278 10 . . . 42759 4279 1 14 14 CD 42759 4279 2 , , , 42759 4279 3 col col NNP 42759 4279 4 . . NNP 42759 4279 5 747 747 CD 42759 4279 6 . . . 42759 4280 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4280 2 205 205 CD 42759 4280 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4280 4 " " `` 42759 4280 5 Patrologia Patrologia NNP 42759 4280 6 Latina Latina NNP 42759 4280 7 , , , 42759 4280 8 " " '' 42759 4280 9 vol vol NNP 42759 4280 10 . . . 42759 4281 1 77 77 CD 42759 4281 2 , , , 42759 4281 3 col col NNP 42759 4281 4 . . NNP 42759 4281 5 87 87 CD 42759 4281 6 . . . 42759 4282 1 These these DT 42759 4282 2 and and CC 42759 4282 3 several several JJ 42759 4282 4 other other JJ 42759 4282 5 extracts extract NNS 42759 4282 6 of of IN 42759 4282 7 like like IN 42759 4282 8 tenor tenor NN 42759 4282 9 may may MD 42759 4282 10 be be VB 42759 4282 11 found find VBN 42759 4282 12 in in IN 42759 4282 13 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 4282 14 's 's POS 42759 4282 15 " " `` 42759 4282 16 Alleged alleged JJ 42759 4282 17 Socialism socialism NN 42759 4282 18 of of IN 42759 4282 19 the the DT 42759 4282 20 Church Church NNP 42759 4282 21 Fathers Fathers NNPS 42759 4282 22 , , , 42759 4282 23 " " '' 42759 4282 24 ch ch NN 42759 4282 25 . . . 42759 4283 1 i i PRP 42759 4283 2 ; ; : 42759 4283 3 St. St. NNP 42759 4283 4 Louis Louis NNP 42759 4283 5 , , , 42759 4283 6 1913 1913 CD 42759 4283 7 . . . 42759 4284 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4284 2 206 206 CD 42759 4284 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4284 4 Op Op NNP 42759 4284 5 . . . 42759 4285 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4285 2 . . NNP 42759 4285 3 , , , 42759 4285 4 2a 2a CD 42759 4285 5 . . . 42759 4286 1 2ae 2ae NNP 42759 4286 2 . . NNP 42759 4286 3 , , , 42759 4286 4 q. q. NNP 42759 4287 1 66 66 CD 42759 4287 2 , , , 42759 4287 3 a. a. NN 42759 4288 1 7 7 LS 42759 4288 2 . . . 42759 4289 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4289 2 207 207 CD 42759 4289 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4289 4 Encyclical encyclical JJ 42759 4289 5 , , , 42759 4289 6 " " '' 42759 4289 7 On on IN 42759 4289 8 the the DT 42759 4289 9 Condition Condition NNP 42759 4289 10 of of IN 42759 4289 11 Labour Labour NNP 42759 4289 12 , , , 42759 4289 13 " " '' 42759 4289 14 May May MD 42759 4289 15 15 15 CD 42759 4289 16 , , , 42759 4289 17 1891 1891 CD 42759 4289 18 . . . 42759 4290 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4290 2 208 208 CD 42759 4290 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4290 4 Encyclical encyclical JJ 42759 4290 5 , , , 42759 4290 6 " " '' 42759 4290 7 On on IN 42759 4290 8 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 4290 9 , , , 42759 4290 10 Communism Communism NNP 42759 4290 11 , , , 42759 4290 12 Nihilism Nihilism NNP 42759 4290 13 , , , 42759 4290 14 " " '' 42759 4290 15 Dec. December NNP 42759 4290 16 28 28 CD 42759 4290 17 , , , 42759 4290 18 1878 1878 CD 42759 4290 19 . . . 42759 4291 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4291 2 209 209 CD 42759 4291 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4291 4 Op Op NNP 42759 4291 5 . . . 42759 4292 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4292 2 . . NNP 42759 4292 3 , , , 42759 4292 4 2a 2a CD 42759 4292 5 . . . 42759 4293 1 2ae 2ae NNP 42759 4293 2 . . NNP 42759 4293 3 , , , 42759 4293 4 q. q. NNP 42759 4294 1 32 32 CD 42759 4294 2 , , , 42759 4294 3 a. a. NN 42759 4295 1 1 1 LS 42759 4295 2 . . . 42759 4296 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4296 2 210 210 CD 42759 4296 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4296 4 Idem Idem NNP 42759 4296 5 , , , 42759 4296 6 q. q. NN 42759 4297 1 66 66 CD 42759 4297 2 , , , 42759 4297 3 a. a. NN 42759 4298 1 7 7 LS 42759 4298 2 . . . 42759 4299 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4299 2 211 211 CD 42759 4299 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4299 4 A a DT 42759 4299 5 comprehensive comprehensive NN 42759 4299 6 , , , 42759 4299 7 though though IN 42759 4299 8 brief brief NN 42759 4299 9 , , , 42759 4299 10 discussion discussion NN 42759 4299 11 of of IN 42759 4299 12 this this DT 42759 4299 13 question question NN 42759 4299 14 and and CC 42759 4299 15 numerous numerous JJ 42759 4299 16 references reference NNS 42759 4299 17 are be VBP 42759 4299 18 contained contain VBN 42759 4299 19 in in IN 42759 4299 20 Bouquillon Bouquillon NNP 42759 4299 21 , , , 42759 4299 22 " " `` 42759 4299 23 De De NNP 42759 4299 24 Virtutibus Virtutibus NNP 42759 4299 25 Theologicis Theologicis NNP 42759 4299 26 , , , 42759 4299 27 " " '' 42759 4299 28 pp pp NNP 42759 4299 29 . . . 42759 4300 1 332 332 CD 42759 4300 2 - - SYM 42759 4300 3 348 348 CD 42759 4300 4 . . . 42759 4301 1 When when WRB 42759 4301 2 Pope Pope NNP 42759 4301 3 Leo Leo NNP 42759 4301 4 XIII XIII NNP 42759 4301 5 declared declare VBD 42759 4301 6 that that IN 42759 4301 7 the the DT 42759 4301 8 rich rich JJ 42759 4301 9 are be VBP 42759 4301 10 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4301 11 to to TO 42759 4301 12 distribute distribute VB 42759 4301 13 " " `` 42759 4301 14 out out IN 42759 4301 15 of of IN 42759 4301 16 " " `` 42759 4301 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4301 18 superfluity superfluity NN 42759 4301 19 , , , 42759 4301 20 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4301 21 did do VBD 42759 4301 22 not not RB 42759 4301 23 mean mean VB 42759 4301 24 that that IN 42759 4301 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4301 26 are be VBP 42759 4301 27 free free JJ 42759 4301 28 to to TO 42759 4301 29 give give VB 42759 4301 30 only only RB 42759 4301 31 a a DT 42759 4301 32 portion portion NN 42759 4301 33 thereof thereof RB 42759 4301 34 . . . 42759 4302 1 The the DT 42759 4302 2 particle particle NN 42759 4302 3 " " `` 42759 4302 4 de de FW 42759 4302 5 " " '' 42759 4302 6 in in IN 42759 4302 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4302 8 statement statement NN 42759 4302 9 , , , 42759 4302 10 " " '' 42759 4302 11 officium officium NN 42759 4302 12 est est NNP 42759 4302 13 de de NNP 42759 4302 14 eo eo NNP 42759 4302 15 quod quod NNP 42759 4302 16 superat superat NNP 42759 4302 17 gratificari gratificari NNP 42759 4302 18 indigentibus indigentibus NNP 42759 4302 19 , , , 42759 4302 20 " " `` 42759 4302 21 is be VBZ 42759 4302 22 not not RB 42759 4302 23 correctly correctly RB 42759 4302 24 translated translate VBN 42759 4302 25 by by IN 42759 4302 26 " " `` 42759 4302 27 some some DT 42759 4302 28 . . . 42759 4302 29 " " '' 42759 4303 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4303 2 means mean VBZ 42759 4303 3 rather rather RB 42759 4303 4 " " `` 42759 4303 5 out out IN 42759 4303 6 of of IN 42759 4303 7 , , , 42759 4303 8 " " '' 42759 4303 9 " " `` 42759 4303 10 from from IN 42759 4303 11 , , , 42759 4303 12 " " '' 42759 4303 13 or or CC 42759 4303 14 " " `` 42759 4303 15 with with IN 42759 4303 16 " " '' 42759 4303 17 ; ; : 42759 4303 18 so so IN 42759 4303 19 that that IN 42759 4303 20 the the DT 42759 4303 21 affluent affluent JJ 42759 4303 22 are be VBP 42759 4303 23 commanded command VBN 42759 4303 24 to to TO 42759 4303 25 devote devote VB 42759 4303 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4303 27 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4303 28 goods good NNS 42759 4303 29 indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 4303 30 to to IN 42759 4303 31 the the DT 42759 4303 32 relief relief NN 42759 4303 33 of of IN 42759 4303 34 the the DT 42759 4303 35 needy needy NN 42759 4303 36 . . . 42759 4304 1 In in IN 42759 4304 2 the the DT 42759 4304 3 Encyclical Encyclical NNP 42759 4304 4 , , , 42759 4304 5 " " '' 42759 4304 6 Quot Quot NNP 42759 4304 7 Apostolici Apostolici NNP 42759 4304 8 Muneris Muneris NNP 42759 4304 9 , , , 42759 4304 10 " " '' 42759 4304 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4304 12 used use VBD 42759 4304 13 the the DT 42759 4304 14 expression expression NN 42759 4304 15 , , , 42759 4304 16 " " `` 42759 4304 17 gravissimo gravissimo NNP 42759 4304 18 divites divite NNS 42759 4304 19 urget urget VBP 42759 4304 20 praecepto praecepto NN 42759 4304 21 ut ut NNP 42759 4304 22 quod quod NN 42759 4304 23 superest superest IN 42759 4304 24 pauperibus pauperibus NN 42759 4304 25 tribuant tribuant NN 42759 4304 26 , , , 42759 4304 27 " " '' 42759 4304 28 which which WDT 42759 4304 29 clearly clearly RB 42759 4304 30 declares declare VBZ 42759 4304 31 the the DT 42759 4304 32 duty duty NN 42759 4304 33 of of IN 42759 4304 34 distributing distribute VBG 42759 4304 35 all all DT 42759 4304 36 . . . 42759 4305 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4305 2 212 212 CD 42759 4305 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4305 4 " " `` 42759 4305 5 The the DT 42759 4305 6 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 4305 7 and and CC 42759 4305 8 Income Income NNP 42759 4305 9 of of IN 42759 4305 10 the the DT 42759 4305 11 People People NNS 42759 4305 12 of of IN 42759 4305 13 the the DT 42759 4305 14 United United NNP 42759 4305 15 States States NNP 42759 4305 16 , , , 42759 4305 17 " " '' 42759 4305 18 pp pp NNP 42759 4305 19 . . . 42759 4306 1 224 224 CD 42759 4306 2 - - SYM 42759 4306 3 226 226 CD 42759 4306 4 . . . 42759 4307 1 SECTION SECTION NNP 42759 4307 2 IV IV NNP 42759 4307 3 THE the DT 42759 4307 4 MORAL moral JJ 42759 4307 5 ASPECT ASPECT NNS 42759 4307 6 OF of IN 42759 4307 7 WAGES wages NN 42759 4307 8 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 4307 9 XXII XXII NNS 42759 4307 10 SOME some NN 42759 4307 11 UNACCEPTABLE unacceptable VBP 42759 4307 12 THEORIES theory NNS 42759 4307 13 OF of IN 42759 4307 14 WAGE wage NN 42759 4307 15 - - HYPH 42759 4307 16 JUSTICE justice NN 42759 4307 17 " " '' 42759 4307 18 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4307 19 may may MD 42759 4307 20 be be VB 42759 4307 21 that that IN 42759 4307 22 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4307 23 are be VBP 42759 4307 24 not not RB 42759 4307 25 merely merely RB 42759 4307 26 chasing chase VBG 42759 4307 27 a a DT 42759 4307 28 will will NN 42759 4307 29 - - HYPH 42759 4307 30 o'-the o'-the VBN 42759 4307 31 - - HYPH 42759 4307 32 wisp wisp RB 42759 4307 33 when when WRB 42759 4307 34 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4307 35 are be VBP 42759 4307 36 hunting hunt VBG 42759 4307 37 for for IN 42759 4307 38 a a DT 42759 4307 39 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4307 40 wage wage NN 42759 4307 41 , , , 42759 4307 42 but but CC 42759 4307 43 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4307 44 are be VBP 42759 4307 45 at at IN 42759 4307 46 any any DT 42759 4307 47 rate rate NN 42759 4307 48 seeking seek VBG 42759 4307 49 the the DT 42759 4307 50 unattainable unattainable JJ 42759 4307 51 . . . 42759 4307 52 " " '' 42759 4308 1 Thus thus RB 42759 4308 2 wrote write VBD 42759 4308 3 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4308 4 Frank Frank NNP 42759 4308 5 Haight Haight NNP 42759 4308 6 Dixon Dixon NNP 42759 4308 7 in in IN 42759 4308 8 a a DT 42759 4308 9 paper paper NN 42759 4308 10 read read NN 42759 4308 11 at at IN 42759 4308 12 the the DT 42759 4308 13 twenty twenty CD 42759 4308 14 - - HYPH 42759 4308 15 seventh seventh JJ 42759 4308 16 annual annual JJ 42759 4308 17 meeting meeting NN 42759 4308 18 of of IN 42759 4308 19 the the DT 42759 4308 20 American American NNP 42759 4308 21 Economic Economic NNP 42759 4308 22 Association Association NNP 42759 4308 23 , , , 42759 4308 24 December December NNP 42759 4308 25 , , , 42759 4308 26 1914 1914 CD 42759 4308 27 . . . 42759 4309 1 Whether whether IN 42759 4309 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4309 3 reflected reflect VBD 42759 4309 4 the the DT 42759 4309 5 opinion opinion NN 42759 4309 6 of of IN 42759 4309 7 the the DT 42759 4309 8 majority majority NN 42759 4309 9 of of IN 42759 4309 10 the the DT 42759 4309 11 economists economist NNS 42759 4309 12 , , , 42759 4309 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4309 14 at at IN 42759 4309 15 least least JJS 42759 4309 16 gave give VBD 42759 4309 17 expression expression NN 42759 4309 18 to to IN 42759 4309 19 a a DT 42759 4309 20 thought thought NN 42759 4309 21 that that WDT 42759 4309 22 has have VBZ 42759 4309 23 frequently frequently RB 42759 4309 24 suggested suggest VBN 42759 4309 25 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 4309 26 to to IN 42759 4309 27 every every DT 42759 4309 28 one one NN 42759 4309 29 who who WP 42759 4309 30 has have VBZ 42759 4309 31 gone go VBN 42759 4309 32 into into IN 42759 4309 33 the the DT 42759 4309 34 wage wage NN 42759 4309 35 question question NN 42759 4309 36 free free JJ 42759 4309 37 from from IN 42759 4309 38 prejudices prejudice NNS 42759 4309 39 and and CC 42759 4309 40 preconceived preconceive VBN 42759 4309 41 theories theory NNS 42759 4309 42 . . . 42759 4310 1 One one CD 42759 4310 2 of of IN 42759 4310 3 the the DT 42759 4310 4 most most RBS 42759 4310 5 palpable palpable JJ 42759 4310 6 indications indication NNS 42759 4310 7 of of IN 42759 4310 8 the the DT 42759 4310 9 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 4310 10 to to TO 42759 4310 11 which which WDT 42759 4310 12 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4310 13 Dixon Dixon NNP 42759 4310 14 refers refer VBZ 42759 4310 15 is be VBZ 42759 4310 16 the the DT 42759 4310 17 number number NN 42759 4310 18 of of IN 42759 4310 19 doctrines doctrine NNS 42759 4310 20 concerning concern VBG 42759 4310 21 wage wage NN 42759 4310 22 justice justice NN 42759 4310 23 that that WDT 42759 4310 24 have have VBP 42759 4310 25 been be VBN 42759 4310 26 laboriously laboriously RB 42759 4310 27 built build VBN 42759 4310 28 up up RP 42759 4310 29 during during IN 42759 4310 30 the the DT 42759 4310 31 Christian christian JJ 42759 4310 32 era era NN 42759 4310 33 , , , 42759 4310 34 and and CC 42759 4310 35 that that WDT 42759 4310 36 have have VBP 42759 4310 37 failed fail VBN 42759 4310 38 to to TO 42759 4310 39 approve approve VB 42759 4310 40 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 4310 41 to to IN 42759 4310 42 the the DT 42759 4310 43 majority majority NN 42759 4310 44 of of IN 42759 4310 45 students student NNS 42759 4310 46 and and CC 42759 4310 47 thinkers thinker NNS 42759 4310 48 . . . 42759 4311 1 In in IN 42759 4311 2 the the DT 42759 4311 3 present present JJ 42759 4311 4 chapter chapter NN 42759 4311 5 the the DT 42759 4311 6 attempt attempt NN 42759 4311 7 is be VBZ 42759 4311 8 made make VBN 42759 4311 9 to to TO 42759 4311 10 set set VB 42759 4311 11 forth forth RP 42759 4311 12 some some DT 42759 4311 13 of of IN 42759 4311 14 the the DT 42759 4311 15 most most RBS 42759 4311 16 important important JJ 42759 4311 17 of of IN 42759 4311 18 these these DT 42759 4311 19 doctrines doctrine NNS 42759 4311 20 , , , 42759 4311 21 and and CC 42759 4311 22 to to TO 42759 4311 23 show show VB 42759 4311 24 wherein wherein WRB 42759 4311 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4311 26 are be VBP 42759 4311 27 defective defective JJ 42759 4311 28 . . . 42759 4312 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4312 2 can can MD 42759 4312 3 all all RB 42759 4312 4 be be VB 42759 4312 5 grouped group VBN 42759 4312 6 under under IN 42759 4312 7 the the DT 42759 4312 8 following follow VBG 42759 4312 9 heads head NNS 42759 4312 10 : : : 42759 4312 11 The the DT 42759 4312 12 Prevailing Prevailing NNP 42759 4312 13 - - HYPH 42759 4312 14 Rate Rate NNP 42759 4312 15 Theory Theory NNP 42759 4312 16 ; ; : 42759 4312 17 Exchange Exchange NNP 42759 4312 18 - - HYPH 42759 4312 19 Equivalence Equivalence NNP 42759 4312 20 Theories theory NNS 42759 4312 21 ; ; : 42759 4312 22 and and CC 42759 4312 23 the the DT 42759 4312 24 Productivity Productivity NNP 42759 4312 25 Theories Theories NNPS 42759 4312 26 . . . 42759 4313 1 I. I. NNP 42759 4314 1 THE the DT 42759 4314 2 PREVAILING prevailing NN 42759 4314 3 - - HYPH 42759 4314 4 RATE rate NN 42759 4314 5 THEORY theory NN 42759 4314 6 This this DT 42759 4314 7 is be VBZ 42759 4314 8 not not RB 42759 4314 9 so so RB 42759 4314 10 much much JJ 42759 4314 11 a a DT 42759 4314 12 systematic systematic JJ 42759 4314 13 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4314 14 as as IN 42759 4314 15 a a DT 42759 4314 16 rule rule NN 42759 4314 17 of of IN 42759 4314 18 expediency expediency NN 42759 4314 19 devised devise VBN 42759 4314 20 to to TO 42759 4314 21 meet meet VB 42759 4314 22 concrete concrete JJ 42759 4314 23 situations situation NNS 42759 4314 24 in in IN 42759 4314 25 the the DT 42759 4314 26 absence absence NN 42759 4314 27 of of IN 42759 4314 28 any any DT 42759 4314 29 better well RBR 42759 4314 30 guiding guide VBG 42759 4314 31 principle principle NN 42759 4314 32 . . . 42759 4315 1 Both both DT 42759 4315 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4315 3 basis basis NN 42759 4315 4 and and CC 42759 4315 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4315 6 nature nature NN 42759 4315 7 are be VBP 42759 4315 8 well well RB 42759 4315 9 exemplified exemplify VBN 42759 4315 10 in in IN 42759 4315 11 the the DT 42759 4315 12 following follow VBG 42759 4315 13 extract extract NN 42759 4315 14 from from IN 42759 4315 15 the the DT 42759 4315 16 " " `` 42759 4315 17 Report Report NNP 42759 4315 18 of of IN 42759 4315 19 the the DT 42759 4315 20 Board Board NNP 42759 4315 21 of of IN 42759 4315 22 Arbitration Arbitration NNP 42759 4315 23 in in IN 42759 4315 24 the the DT 42759 4315 25 Matter Matter NNP 42759 4315 26 of of IN 42759 4315 27 the the DT 42759 4315 28 Controversy Controversy NNP 42759 4315 29 Between between IN 42759 4315 30 the the DT 42759 4315 31 Eastern Eastern NNP 42759 4315 32 Railroads Railroads NNPS 42759 4315 33 and and CC 42759 4315 34 the the DT 42759 4315 35 Brotherhood Brotherhood NNP 42759 4315 36 of of IN 42759 4315 37 Locomotive Locomotive NNP 42759 4315 38 Engineers:"[213 Engineers:"[213 NNP 42759 4315 39 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4315 40 " " `` 42759 4315 41 Possibly possibly RB 42759 4315 42 there there EX 42759 4315 43 should should MD 42759 4315 44 be be VB 42759 4315 45 some some DT 42759 4315 46 theoretical theoretical JJ 42759 4315 47 relation relation NN 42759 4315 48 for for IN 42759 4315 49 a a DT 42759 4315 50 given give VBN 42759 4315 51 branch branch NN 42759 4315 52 of of IN 42759 4315 53 industry industry NN 42759 4315 54 between between IN 42759 4315 55 the the DT 42759 4315 56 amount amount NN 42759 4315 57 of of IN 42759 4315 58 the the DT 42759 4315 59 income income NN 42759 4315 60 that that WDT 42759 4315 61 should should MD 42759 4315 62 go go VB 42759 4315 63 to to IN 42759 4315 64 labour labour NN 42759 4315 65 and and CC 42759 4315 66 the the DT 42759 4315 67 amount amount NN 42759 4315 68 that that WDT 42759 4315 69 should should MD 42759 4315 70 go go VB 42759 4315 71 to to IN 42759 4315 72 capital capital NN 42759 4315 73 ; ; : 42759 4315 74 and and CC 42759 4315 75 if if IN 42759 4315 76 this this DT 42759 4315 77 question question NN 42759 4315 78 were be VBD 42759 4315 79 decided decide VBN 42759 4315 80 , , , 42759 4315 81 a a DT 42759 4315 82 scale scale NN 42759 4315 83 of of IN 42759 4315 84 wages wage NNS 42759 4315 85 might may MD 42759 4315 86 be be VB 42759 4315 87 devised devise VBN 42759 4315 88 for for IN 42759 4315 89 the the DT 42759 4315 90 different different JJ 42759 4315 91 classes class NNS 42759 4315 92 of of IN 42759 4315 93 employés employés NN 42759 4315 94 which which WDT 42759 4315 95 would would MD 42759 4315 96 determine determine VB 42759 4315 97 the the DT 42759 4315 98 amount amount NN 42759 4315 99 rightly rightly RB 42759 4315 100 absorbed absorb VBN 42759 4315 101 by by IN 42759 4315 102 labour labour NN 42759 4315 103 .... .... . 42759 4316 1 Thus thus RB 42759 4316 2 far far RB 42759 4316 3 , , , 42759 4316 4 however however RB 42759 4316 5 , , , 42759 4316 6 political political JJ 42759 4316 7 economy economy NN 42759 4316 8 is be VBZ 42759 4316 9 unable unable JJ 42759 4316 10 to to TO 42759 4316 11 furnish furnish VB 42759 4316 12 such such PDT 42759 4316 13 a a DT 42759 4316 14 principle principle NN 42759 4316 15 as as IN 42759 4316 16 that that DT 42759 4316 17 suggested suggest VBD 42759 4316 18 . . . 42759 4317 1 There there EX 42759 4317 2 is be VBZ 42759 4317 3 no no DT 42759 4317 4 generally generally RB 42759 4317 5 accepted accept VBN 42759 4317 6 theory theory NN 42759 4317 7 of of IN 42759 4317 8 the the DT 42759 4317 9 division division NN 42759 4317 10 between between IN 42759 4317 11 capital capital NN 42759 4317 12 and and CC 42759 4317 13 labour labour NN 42759 4317 14 .... .... NFP 42759 4317 15 " " '' 42759 4317 16 What what WP 42759 4317 17 , , , 42759 4317 18 then then RB 42759 4317 19 , , , 42759 4317 20 is be VBZ 42759 4317 21 the the DT 42759 4317 22 basis basis NN 42759 4317 23 upon upon IN 42759 4317 24 which which WDT 42759 4317 25 a a DT 42759 4317 26 judgment judgment NN 42759 4317 27 may may MD 42759 4317 28 be be VB 42759 4317 29 passed pass VBN 42759 4317 30 as as IN 42759 4317 31 to to IN 42759 4317 32 whether whether IN 42759 4317 33 the the DT 42759 4317 34 existing exist VBG 42759 4317 35 wage wage NN 42759 4317 36 scale scale NN 42759 4317 37 of of IN 42759 4317 38 the the DT 42759 4317 39 engineers engineer NNS 42759 4317 40 in in IN 42759 4317 41 the the DT 42759 4317 42 Eastern Eastern NNP 42759 4317 43 District District NNP 42759 4317 44 is be VBZ 42759 4317 45 fair fair JJ 42759 4317 46 and and CC 42759 4317 47 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4317 48 ? ? . 42759 4318 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4318 2 seems seem VBZ 42759 4318 3 to to IN 42759 4318 4 the the DT 42759 4318 5 Board Board NNP 42759 4318 6 that that IN 42759 4318 7 the the DT 42759 4318 8 only only JJ 42759 4318 9 practicable practicable JJ 42759 4318 10 basis basis NN 42759 4318 11 is be VBZ 42759 4318 12 to to TO 42759 4318 13 compare compare VB 42759 4318 14 the the DT 42759 4318 15 rates rate NNS 42759 4318 16 and and CC 42759 4318 17 earnings earning NNS 42759 4318 18 of of IN 42759 4318 19 engineers engineer NNS 42759 4318 20 in in IN 42759 4318 21 the the DT 42759 4318 22 Eastern Eastern NNP 42759 4318 23 District District NNP 42759 4318 24 with with IN 42759 4318 25 those those DT 42759 4318 26 of of IN 42759 4318 27 engineers engineer NNS 42759 4318 28 in in IN 42759 4318 29 the the DT 42759 4318 30 Western western JJ 42759 4318 31 and and CC 42759 4318 32 Southern Southern NNP 42759 4318 33 Districts Districts NNPS 42759 4318 34 , , , 42759 4318 35 and and CC 42759 4318 36 with with IN 42759 4318 37 those those DT 42759 4318 38 of of IN 42759 4318 39 other other JJ 42759 4318 40 classes class NNS 42759 4318 41 of of IN 42759 4318 42 railway railway NN 42759 4318 43 employés employés NN 42759 4318 44 . . . 42759 4318 45 " " '' 42759 4319 1 Six six CD 42759 4319 2 of of IN 42759 4319 3 the the DT 42759 4319 4 seven seven CD 42759 4319 5 men man NNS 42759 4319 6 composing compose VBG 42759 4319 7 this this DT 42759 4319 8 board board NN 42759 4319 9 of of IN 42759 4319 10 arbitration arbitration NN 42759 4319 11 subscribed subscribe VBD 42759 4319 12 to to IN 42759 4319 13 this this DT 42759 4319 14 statement statement NN 42759 4319 15 . . . 42759 4320 1 Of of IN 42759 4320 2 the the DT 42759 4320 3 six six CD 42759 4320 4 one one CD 42759 4320 5 is be VBZ 42759 4320 6 the the DT 42759 4320 7 president president NN 42759 4320 8 of of IN 42759 4320 9 a a DT 42759 4320 10 great great JJ 42759 4320 11 state state NNP 42759 4320 12 university university NNP 42759 4320 13 , , , 42759 4320 14 another another DT 42759 4320 15 is be VBZ 42759 4320 16 a a DT 42759 4320 17 successful successful JJ 42759 4320 18 and and CC 42759 4320 19 large large JJ 42759 4320 20 - - HYPH 42759 4320 21 minded minded JJ 42759 4320 22 merchant merchant NN 42759 4320 23 , , , 42759 4320 24 the the DT 42759 4320 25 third third JJ 42759 4320 26 is be VBZ 42759 4320 27 a a DT 42759 4320 28 great great JJ 42759 4320 29 building building NN 42759 4320 30 contractor contractor NN 42759 4320 31 , , , 42759 4320 32 the the DT 42759 4320 33 fourth fourth JJ 42759 4320 34 is be VBZ 42759 4320 35 a a DT 42759 4320 36 distinguished distinguished JJ 42759 4320 37 lawyer lawyer NN 42759 4320 38 , , , 42759 4320 39 the the DT 42759 4320 40 fifth fifth JJ 42759 4320 41 is be VBZ 42759 4320 42 a a DT 42759 4320 43 prominent prominent JJ 42759 4320 44 magazine magazine NN 42759 4320 45 editor editor NN 42759 4320 46 , , , 42759 4320 47 and and CC 42759 4320 48 the the DT 42759 4320 49 sixth sixth JJ 42759 4320 50 is be VBZ 42759 4320 51 a a DT 42759 4320 52 railway railway NN 42759 4320 53 president president NN 42759 4320 54 . . . 42759 4321 1 The the DT 42759 4321 2 dissenting dissent VBG 42759 4321 3 member member NN 42759 4321 4 represented represent VBD 42759 4321 5 the the DT 42759 4321 6 employés employés NN 42759 4321 7 . . . 42759 4322 1 Since since IN 42759 4322 2 the the DT 42759 4322 3 majority majority NN 42759 4322 4 could could MD 42759 4322 5 not not RB 42759 4322 6 find find VB 42759 4322 7 in in IN 42759 4322 8 any any DT 42759 4322 9 generally generally RB 42759 4322 10 accepted accept VBN 42759 4322 11 theory theory NN 42759 4322 12 a a DT 42759 4322 13 principle principle NN 42759 4322 14 to to TO 42759 4322 15 determine determine VB 42759 4322 16 the the DT 42759 4322 17 proper proper JJ 42759 4322 18 division division NN 42759 4322 19 of of IN 42759 4322 20 the the DT 42759 4322 21 product product NN 42759 4322 22 between between IN 42759 4322 23 capital capital NN 42759 4322 24 and and CC 42759 4322 25 labour labour NN 42759 4322 26 , , , 42759 4322 27 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4322 28 were be VBD 42759 4322 29 perhaps perhaps RB 42759 4322 30 justified justify VBN 42759 4322 31 in in IN 42759 4322 32 falling fall VBG 42759 4322 33 back back RB 42759 4322 34 upon upon IN 42759 4322 35 the the DT 42759 4322 36 practical practical JJ 42759 4322 37 rule rule NN 42759 4322 38 that that IN 42759 4322 39 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4322 40 adopted adopt VBD 42759 4322 41 . . . 42759 4323 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4323 2 Not not RB 42759 4323 3 in in IN 42759 4323 4 Harmony harmony NN 42759 4323 5 with with IN 42759 4323 6 Justice Justice NNP 42759 4323 7 _ _ NNP 42759 4323 8 From from IN 42759 4323 9 the the DT 42759 4323 10 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 4323 11 of of IN 42759 4323 12 justice justice NN 42759 4323 13 , , , 42759 4323 14 however however RB 42759 4323 15 , , , 42759 4323 16 this this DT 42759 4323 17 rule rule NN 42759 4323 18 or or CC 42759 4323 19 standard standard NN 42759 4323 20 is be VBZ 42759 4323 21 utterly utterly RB 42759 4323 22 inadequate inadequate JJ 42759 4323 23 . . . 42759 4324 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4324 2 is be VBZ 42759 4324 3 susceptible susceptible JJ 42759 4324 4 of of IN 42759 4324 5 two two CD 42759 4324 6 interpretations interpretation NNS 42759 4324 7 . . . 42759 4325 1 " " `` 42759 4325 2 Wages wage NNS 42759 4325 3 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 4325 4 elsewhere elsewhere RB 42759 4325 5 , , , 42759 4325 6 " " `` 42759 4325 7 may may MD 42759 4325 8 mean mean VB 42759 4325 9 either either CC 42759 4325 10 the the DT 42759 4325 11 highest high JJS 42759 4325 12 rates rate NNS 42759 4325 13 or or CC 42759 4325 14 those those DT 42759 4325 15 most most RBS 42759 4325 16 frequently frequently RB 42759 4325 17 occurring occur VBG 42759 4325 18 . . . 42759 4326 1 According accord VBG 42759 4326 2 to to IN 42759 4326 3 the the DT 42759 4326 4 latter latter JJ 42759 4326 5 understanding understanding NN 42759 4326 6 , , , 42759 4326 7 only only RB 42759 4326 8 those those DT 42759 4326 9 wages wage NNS 42759 4326 10 which which WDT 42759 4326 11 were be VBD 42759 4326 12 below below IN 42759 4326 13 the the DT 42759 4326 14 majority majority NN 42759 4326 15 rates rate NNS 42759 4326 16 should should MD 42759 4326 17 be be VB 42759 4326 18 raised raise VBN 42759 4326 19 , , , 42759 4326 20 while while IN 42759 4326 21 all all PDT 42759 4326 22 those those DT 42759 4326 23 above above IN 42759 4326 24 that that DT 42759 4326 25 level level NN 42759 4326 26 ought ought MD 42759 4326 27 to to TO 42759 4326 28 be be VB 42759 4326 29 lowered lower VBN 42759 4326 30 . . . 42759 4327 1 In in IN 42759 4327 2 almost almost RB 42759 4327 3 all all DT 42759 4327 4 cases case NNS 42759 4327 5 this this DT 42759 4327 6 would would MD 42759 4327 7 mean mean VB 42759 4327 8 a a DT 42759 4327 9 reduction reduction NN 42759 4327 10 of of IN 42759 4327 11 the the DT 42759 4327 12 highest high JJS 42759 4327 13 wages wage NNS 42759 4327 14 , , , 42759 4327 15 as as IN 42759 4327 16 these these DT 42759 4327 17 are be VBP 42759 4327 18 usually usually RB 42759 4327 19 paid pay VBN 42759 4327 20 only only RB 42759 4327 21 to to IN 42759 4327 22 a a DT 42759 4327 23 minority minority NN 42759 4327 24 of of IN 42759 4327 25 the the DT 42759 4327 26 workers worker NNS 42759 4327 27 of of IN 42759 4327 28 any any DT 42759 4327 29 grade grade NN 42759 4327 30 . . . 42759 4328 1 The the DT 42759 4328 2 adoption adoption NN 42759 4328 3 of of IN 42759 4328 4 the the DT 42759 4328 5 highest high JJS 42759 4328 6 existing exist VBG 42759 4328 7 rates rate NNS 42759 4328 8 as as IN 42759 4328 9 a a DT 42759 4328 10 standard standard NN 42759 4328 11 would would MD 42759 4328 12 involve involve VB 42759 4328 13 no no DT 42759 4328 14 positive positive JJ 42759 4328 15 losses loss NNS 42759 4328 16 , , , 42759 4328 17 but but CC 42759 4328 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4328 19 would would MD 42759 4328 20 set set VB 42759 4328 21 a a DT 42759 4328 22 rigid rigid JJ 42759 4328 23 limit limit NN 42759 4328 24 to to IN 42759 4328 25 all all DT 42759 4328 26 possible possible JJ 42759 4328 27 gains gain NNS 42759 4328 28 in in IN 42759 4328 29 the the DT 42759 4328 30 future future NN 42759 4328 31 . . . 42759 4329 1 According accord VBG 42759 4329 2 to to IN 42759 4329 3 either either DT 42759 4329 4 interpretation interpretation NN 42759 4329 5 of of IN 42759 4329 6 the the DT 42759 4329 7 prevailing prevailing NN 42759 4329 8 rate rate NN 42759 4329 9 , , , 42759 4329 10 the the DT 42759 4329 11 increases increase NNS 42759 4329 12 in in IN 42759 4329 13 wages wage NNS 42759 4329 14 which which WDT 42759 4329 15 a a DT 42759 4329 16 powerful powerful JJ 42759 4329 17 labour labour NN 42759 4329 18 union union NN 42759 4329 19 seeks seek VBZ 42759 4329 20 to to TO 42759 4329 21 obtain obtain VB 42759 4329 22 are be VBP 42759 4329 23 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4329 24 until until IN 42759 4329 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4329 26 have have VBP 42759 4329 27 been be VBN 42759 4329 28 established establish VBN 42759 4329 29 as as IN 42759 4329 30 the the DT 42759 4329 31 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 4329 32 rates rate NNS 42759 4329 33 . . . 42759 4330 1 Thus thus RB 42759 4330 2 , , , 42759 4330 3 the the DT 42759 4330 4 attorney attorney NN 42759 4330 5 for for IN 42759 4330 6 the the DT 42759 4330 7 street street NN 42759 4330 8 railways railway NNS 42759 4330 9 of of IN 42759 4330 10 Chicago Chicago NNP 42759 4330 11 dissented dissent VBD 42759 4330 12 from from IN 42759 4330 13 the the DT 42759 4330 14 increases increase NNS 42759 4330 15 in in IN 42759 4330 16 wages wage NNS 42759 4330 17 awarded award VBN 42759 4330 18 to to IN 42759 4330 19 the the DT 42759 4330 20 employés employés NN 42759 4330 21 by by IN 42759 4330 22 the the DT 42759 4330 23 majority majority NN 42759 4330 24 of of IN 42759 4330 25 the the DT 42759 4330 26 board board NN 42759 4330 27 of of IN 42759 4330 28 arbitration arbitration NN 42759 4330 29 in in IN 42759 4330 30 the the DT 42759 4330 31 summer summer NN 42759 4330 32 of of IN 42759 4330 33 1915 1915 CD 42759 4330 34 because because IN 42759 4330 35 , , , 42759 4330 36 " " `` 42759 4330 37 these these DT 42759 4330 38 men man NNS 42759 4330 39 are be VBP 42759 4330 40 already already RB 42759 4330 41 paid pay VBN 42759 4330 42 not not RB 42759 4330 43 only only RB 42759 4330 44 a a DT 42759 4330 45 fair fair JJ 42759 4330 46 wage wage NN 42759 4330 47 but but CC 42759 4330 48 a a DT 42759 4330 49 liberal liberal JJ 42759 4330 50 wage wage NN 42759 4330 51 , , , 42759 4330 52 when when WRB 42759 4330 53 the the DT 42759 4330 54 wages wage NNS 42759 4330 55 in in IN 42759 4330 56 the the DT 42759 4330 57 same same JJ 42759 4330 58 employment employment NN 42759 4330 59 and and CC 42759 4330 60 the the DT 42759 4330 61 living living NN 42759 4330 62 conditions condition NNS 42759 4330 63 in in IN 42759 4330 64 other other JJ 42759 4330 65 large large JJ 42759 4330 66 cities city NNS 42759 4330 67 are be VBP 42759 4330 68 taken take VBN 42759 4330 69 into into IN 42759 4330 70 consideration consideration NN 42759 4330 71 , , , 42759 4330 72 or or CC 42759 4330 73 when when WRB 42759 4330 74 comparison comparison NN 42759 4330 75 is be VBZ 42759 4330 76 made make VBN 42759 4330 77 of of IN 42759 4330 78 these these DT 42759 4330 79 men man NNS 42759 4330 80 's 's POS 42759 4330 81 annual annual JJ 42759 4330 82 earnings earning NNS 42759 4330 83 with with IN 42759 4330 84 the the DT 42759 4330 85 earnings earning NNS 42759 4330 86 in in IN 42759 4330 87 any any DT 42759 4330 88 comparable comparable JJ 42759 4330 89 line line NN 42759 4330 90 of of IN 42759 4330 91 work work NN 42759 4330 92 in in IN 42759 4330 93 the the DT 42759 4330 94 city city NN 42759 4330 95 of of IN 42759 4330 96 Chicago Chicago NNP 42759 4330 97 . . . 42759 4331 1 " " `` 42759 4331 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4331 3 214 214 CD 42759 4331 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4331 5 In in IN 42759 4331 6 other other JJ 42759 4331 7 words word NNS 42759 4331 8 , , , 42759 4331 9 the the DT 42759 4331 10 dominant dominant JJ 42759 4331 11 thing thing NN 42759 4331 12 is be VBZ 42759 4331 13 always always RB 42759 4331 14 the the DT 42759 4331 15 right right JJ 42759 4331 16 thing thing NN 42759 4331 17 . . . 42759 4332 1 Justice justice NN 42759 4332 2 is be VBZ 42759 4332 3 determined determine VBN 42759 4332 4 by by IN 42759 4332 5 the the DT 42759 4332 6 preponderance preponderance NN 42759 4332 7 of of IN 42759 4332 8 economic economic JJ 42759 4332 9 force force NN 42759 4332 10 . . . 42759 4333 1 Now now RB 42759 4333 2 , , , 42759 4333 3 a a DT 42759 4333 4 rule rule NN 42759 4333 5 such such JJ 42759 4333 6 as as IN 42759 4333 7 this this DT 42759 4333 8 , , , 42759 4333 9 which which WDT 42759 4333 10 condemns condemn VBZ 42759 4333 11 improvement improvement NN 42759 4333 12 until until IN 42759 4333 13 improvement improvement NN 42759 4333 14 has have VBZ 42759 4333 15 somehow somehow RB 42759 4333 16 become become VBN 42759 4333 17 general general JJ 42759 4333 18 , , , 42759 4333 19 which which WDT 42759 4333 20 puts put VBZ 42759 4333 21 a a DT 42759 4333 22 premium premium NN 42759 4333 23 upon upon IN 42759 4333 24 physical physical JJ 42759 4333 25 and and CC 42759 4333 26 intellectual intellectual JJ 42759 4333 27 strength strength NN 42759 4333 28 , , , 42759 4333 29 and and CC 42759 4333 30 which which WDT 42759 4333 31 disregards disregard VBZ 42759 4333 32 entirely entirely RB 42759 4333 33 the the DT 42759 4333 34 moral moral JJ 42759 4333 35 claims claim NNS 42759 4333 36 of of IN 42759 4333 37 human human JJ 42759 4333 38 needs need NNS 42759 4333 39 , , , 42759 4333 40 efforts effort NNS 42759 4333 41 , , , 42759 4333 42 and and CC 42759 4333 43 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 4333 44 , , , 42759 4333 45 is be VBZ 42759 4333 46 obviously obviously RB 42759 4333 47 not not RB 42759 4333 48 an an DT 42759 4333 49 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4333 50 measure measure NN 42759 4333 51 of of IN 42759 4333 52 either either DT 42759 4333 53 reason reason NN 42759 4333 54 or or CC 42759 4333 55 justice justice NN 42759 4333 56 . . . 42759 4334 1 And and CC 42759 4334 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4334 3 may may MD 42759 4334 4 well well RB 42759 4334 5 doubt doubt VB 42759 4334 6 that that IN 42759 4334 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4334 8 would would MD 42759 4334 9 be be VB 42759 4334 10 formally formally RB 42759 4334 11 accepted accept VBN 42759 4334 12 as as IN 42759 4334 13 such such JJ 42759 4334 14 by by IN 42759 4334 15 any any DT 42759 4334 16 competent competent JJ 42759 4334 17 and and CC 42759 4334 18 disinterested disinterested JJ 42759 4334 19 student student NN 42759 4334 20 of of IN 42759 4334 21 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4334 22 relations relation NNS 42759 4334 23 . . . 42759 4335 1 II ii CD 42759 4335 2 . . . 42759 4336 1 EXCHANGE EXCHANGE NNP 42759 4336 2 - - HYPH 42759 4336 3 EQUIVALENCE equivalence NN 42759 4336 4 THEORIES theory NNS 42759 4336 5 According accord VBG 42759 4336 6 to to IN 42759 4336 7 these these DT 42759 4336 8 theories theory NNS 42759 4336 9 , , , 42759 4336 10 the the DT 42759 4336 11 determining determine VBG 42759 4336 12 factor factor NN 42759 4336 13 of of IN 42759 4336 14 wage wage NN 42759 4336 15 justice justice NN 42759 4336 16 is be VBZ 42759 4336 17 to to TO 42759 4336 18 be be VB 42759 4336 19 found find VBN 42759 4336 20 in in IN 42759 4336 21 the the DT 42759 4336 22 wage wage NN 42759 4336 23 contract contract NN 42759 4336 24 . . . 42759 4337 1 The the DT 42759 4337 2 basic basic JJ 42759 4337 3 idea idea NN 42759 4337 4 is be VBZ 42759 4337 5 the the DT 42759 4337 6 idea idea NN 42759 4337 7 of of IN 42759 4337 8 equality equality NN 42759 4337 9 , , , 42759 4337 10 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 4337 11 as as IN 42759 4337 12 equality equality NN 42759 4337 13 is be VBZ 42759 4337 14 the the DT 42759 4337 15 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4337 16 element element NN 42759 4337 17 in in IN 42759 4337 18 the the DT 42759 4337 19 concept concept NN 42759 4337 20 of of IN 42759 4337 21 justice justice NN 42759 4337 22 . . . 42759 4338 1 The the DT 42759 4338 2 principle principle NN 42759 4338 3 of of IN 42759 4338 4 justice justice NN 42759 4338 5 requires require VBZ 42759 4338 6 that that IN 42759 4338 7 equality equality NN 42759 4338 8 should should MD 42759 4338 9 be be VB 42759 4338 10 maintained maintain VBN 42759 4338 11 between between IN 42759 4338 12 what what WP 42759 4338 13 is be VBZ 42759 4338 14 owed owe VBN 42759 4338 15 to to IN 42759 4338 16 a a DT 42759 4338 17 person person NN 42759 4338 18 and and CC 42759 4338 19 what what WP 42759 4338 20 is be VBZ 42759 4338 21 returned return VBN 42759 4338 22 to to IN 42759 4338 23 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4338 24 , , , 42759 4338 25 between between IN 42759 4338 26 the the DT 42759 4338 27 kinds kind NNS 42759 4338 28 of of IN 42759 4338 29 treatment treatment NN 42759 4338 30 accorded accord VBN 42759 4338 31 to to IN 42759 4338 32 different different JJ 42759 4338 33 persons person NNS 42759 4338 34 in in IN 42759 4338 35 the the DT 42759 4338 36 same same JJ 42759 4338 37 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 4338 38 . . . 42759 4339 1 Similarly similarly RB 42759 4339 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4339 3 requires require VBZ 42759 4339 4 that that IN 42759 4339 5 equality equality NN 42759 4339 6 should should MD 42759 4339 7 obtain obtain VB 42759 4339 8 between between IN 42759 4339 9 the the DT 42759 4339 10 things thing NNS 42759 4339 11 that that WDT 42759 4339 12 are be VBP 42759 4339 13 exchanged exchange VBN 42759 4339 14 in in IN 42759 4339 15 onerous onerous JJ 42759 4339 16 contracts contract NNS 42759 4339 17 . . . 42759 4340 1 An an DT 42759 4340 2 onerous onerous JJ 42759 4340 3 contract contract NN 42759 4340 4 is be VBZ 42759 4340 5 one one CD 42759 4340 6 in in IN 42759 4340 7 which which WDT 42759 4340 8 both both DT 42759 4340 9 parties party NNS 42759 4340 10 undergo undergo VBP 42759 4340 11 some some DT 42759 4340 12 privation privation NN 42759 4340 13 , , , 42759 4340 14 and and CC 42759 4340 15 neither neither DT 42759 4340 16 intends intend VBZ 42759 4340 17 to to TO 42759 4340 18 confer confer VB 42759 4340 19 a a DT 42759 4340 20 gratuity gratuity NN 42759 4340 21 upon upon IN 42759 4340 22 the the DT 42759 4340 23 other other JJ 42759 4340 24 . . . 42759 4341 1 Each each DT 42759 4341 2 exchanger exchanger NN 42759 4341 3 desires desire NNS 42759 4341 4 to to TO 42759 4341 5 obtain obtain VB 42759 4341 6 the the DT 42759 4341 7 full full JJ 42759 4341 8 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4341 9 of of IN 42759 4341 10 the the DT 42759 4341 11 thing thing NN 42759 4341 12 that that WDT 42759 4341 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4341 14 transfers transfer VBZ 42759 4341 15 . . . 42759 4342 1 Since since IN 42759 4342 2 each each DT 42759 4342 3 is be VBZ 42759 4342 4 equal equal JJ 42759 4342 5 in in IN 42759 4342 6 personal personal JJ 42759 4342 7 dignity dignity NN 42759 4342 8 an an DT 42759 4342 9 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 4342 10 worth worth NN 42759 4342 11 to to IN 42759 4342 12 the the DT 42759 4342 13 other other JJ 42759 4342 14 , , , 42759 4342 15 each each DT 42759 4342 16 has have VBZ 42759 4342 17 a a DT 42759 4342 18 strict strict JJ 42759 4342 19 right right NN 42759 4342 20 to to IN 42759 4342 21 this this DT 42759 4342 22 full full JJ 42759 4342 23 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4342 24 . . . 42759 4343 1 Owing owe VBG 42759 4343 2 to to IN 42759 4343 3 the the DT 42759 4343 4 essential essential JJ 42759 4343 5 moral moral JJ 42759 4343 6 equality equality NN 42759 4343 7 of of IN 42759 4343 8 all all DT 42759 4343 9 men man NNS 42759 4343 10 , , , 42759 4343 11 no no DT 42759 4343 12 man man NN 42759 4343 13 has have VBZ 42759 4343 14 a a DT 42759 4343 15 right right NN 42759 4343 16 to to TO 42759 4343 17 make make VB 42759 4343 18 of of IN 42759 4343 19 another another DT 42759 4343 20 a a DT 42759 4343 21 mere mere JJ 42759 4343 22 instrument instrument NN 42759 4343 23 to to IN 42759 4343 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4343 25 own own JJ 42759 4343 26 interests interest NNS 42759 4343 27 through through IN 42759 4343 28 physical physical JJ 42759 4343 29 force force NN 42759 4343 30 or or CC 42759 4343 31 through through IN 42759 4343 32 an an DT 42759 4343 33 onerous onerous JJ 42759 4343 34 contract contract NN 42759 4343 35 . . . 42759 4344 1 Men man NNS 42759 4344 2 have have VBP 42759 4344 3 equal equal JJ 42759 4344 4 rights right NNS 42759 4344 5 not not RB 42759 4344 6 only only RB 42759 4344 7 to to TO 42759 4344 8 subsist subsist VB 42759 4344 9 upon upon IN 42759 4344 10 the the DT 42759 4344 11 earth earth NN 42759 4344 12 , , , 42759 4344 13 but but CC 42759 4344 14 to to TO 42759 4344 15 receive receive VB 42759 4344 16 benefits benefit NNS 42759 4344 17 from from IN 42759 4344 18 the the DT 42759 4344 19 exchange exchange NN 42759 4344 20 of of IN 42759 4344 21 goods good NNS 42759 4344 22 . . . 42759 4345 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4345 2 The the DT 42759 4345 3 Rule Rule NNP 42759 4345 4 of of IN 42759 4345 5 Equal Equal NNP 42759 4345 6 Gains Gains NNPS 42759 4345 7 _ _ IN 42759 4345 8 The the DT 42759 4345 9 agreement agreement NN 42759 4345 10 between between IN 42759 4345 11 employer employer NN 42759 4345 12 and and CC 42759 4345 13 employé employé NNP 42759 4345 14 is be VBZ 42759 4345 15 an an DT 42759 4345 16 onerous onerous JJ 42759 4345 17 contract contract NN 42759 4345 18 ; ; : 42759 4345 19 hence hence RB 42759 4345 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4345 21 ought ought MD 42759 4345 22 to to TO 42759 4345 23 be be VB 42759 4345 24 made make VBN 42759 4345 25 in in IN 42759 4345 26 such such JJ 42759 4345 27 terms term NNS 42759 4345 28 that that IN 42759 4345 29 the the DT 42759 4345 30 things thing NNS 42759 4345 31 exchanged exchange VBD 42759 4345 32 will will MD 42759 4345 33 be be VB 42759 4345 34 equal equal JJ 42759 4345 35 , , , 42759 4345 36 that that IN 42759 4345 37 the the DT 42759 4345 38 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 4345 39 will will MD 42759 4345 40 be be VB 42759 4345 41 equal equal JJ 42759 4345 42 to to IN 42759 4345 43 the the DT 42759 4345 44 labour labour NN 42759 4345 45 . . . 42759 4346 1 How how WRB 42759 4346 2 can can MD 42759 4346 3 this this DT 42759 4346 4 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4346 5 be be VB 42759 4346 6 determined determine VBN 42759 4346 7 and and CC 42759 4346 8 ascertained ascertain VBN 42759 4346 9 ? ? . 42759 4347 1 Not not RB 42759 4347 2 by by IN 42759 4347 3 a a DT 42759 4347 4 direct direct JJ 42759 4347 5 comparison comparison NN 42759 4347 6 of of IN 42759 4347 7 the the DT 42759 4347 8 two two CD 42759 4347 9 objects object NNS 42759 4347 10 , , , 42759 4347 11 work work VB 42759 4347 12 and and CC 42759 4347 13 pay pay VB 42759 4347 14 , , , 42759 4347 15 for for IN 42759 4347 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4347 17 differences difference NNS 42759 4347 18 render render VBP 42759 4347 19 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4347 20 obviously obviously RB 42759 4347 21 incommensurable incommensurable JJ 42759 4347 22 . . . 42759 4348 1 Some some DT 42759 4348 2 third third JJ 42759 4348 3 term term NN 42759 4348 4 , , , 42759 4348 5 or or CC 42759 4348 6 standard standard JJ 42759 4348 7 , , , 42759 4348 8 of of IN 42759 4348 9 comparison comparison NN 42759 4348 10 is be VBZ 42759 4348 11 required require VBN 42759 4348 12 in in IN 42759 4348 13 which which WDT 42759 4348 14 both both DT 42759 4348 15 objects object NNS 42759 4348 16 can can MD 42759 4348 17 find find VB 42759 4348 18 expression expression NN 42759 4348 19 . . . 42759 4349 1 One one CD 42759 4349 2 such such JJ 42759 4349 3 standard standard NN 42759 4349 4 is be VBZ 42759 4349 5 individual individual JJ 42759 4349 6 net net JJ 42759 4349 7 advantage advantage NN 42759 4349 8 . . . 42759 4350 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 4350 2 as as IN 42759 4350 3 the the DT 42759 4350 4 aim aim NN 42759 4350 5 of of IN 42759 4350 6 the the DT 42759 4350 7 labour labour JJ 42759 4350 8 contract contract NN 42759 4350 9 is be VBZ 42759 4350 10 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 42759 4350 11 gain gain NN 42759 4350 12 , , , 42759 4350 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4350 14 is be VBZ 42759 4350 15 natural natural JJ 42759 4350 16 to to TO 42759 4350 17 infer infer VB 42759 4350 18 that that IN 42759 4350 19 the the DT 42759 4350 20 gains gain NNS 42759 4350 21 ought ought MD 42759 4350 22 to to TO 42759 4350 23 be be VB 42759 4350 24 equal equal JJ 42759 4350 25 for for IN 42759 4350 26 the the DT 42759 4350 27 two two CD 42759 4350 28 parties party NNS 42759 4350 29 . . . 42759 4351 1 Net net JJ 42759 4351 2 gain gain NN 42759 4351 3 is be VBZ 42759 4351 4 ascertained ascertain VBN 42759 4351 5 by by IN 42759 4351 6 deducting deduct VBG 42759 4351 7 in in IN 42759 4351 8 each each DT 42759 4351 9 case case NN 42759 4351 10 the the DT 42759 4351 11 utility utility NN 42759 4351 12 transferred transfer VBN 42759 4351 13 from from IN 42759 4351 14 the the DT 42759 4351 15 utility utility NN 42759 4351 16 received receive VBD 42759 4351 17 ; ; : 42759 4351 18 in in IN 42759 4351 19 other other JJ 42759 4351 20 words word NNS 42759 4351 21 , , , 42759 4351 22 by by IN 42759 4351 23 deducting deduct VBG 42759 4351 24 the the DT 42759 4351 25 privation privation NN 42759 4351 26 from from IN 42759 4351 27 the the DT 42759 4351 28 gross gross JJ 42759 4351 29 return return NN 42759 4351 30 . . . 42759 4352 1 The the DT 42759 4352 2 good good JJ 42759 4352 3 received receive VBN 42759 4352 4 by by IN 42759 4352 5 the the DT 42759 4352 6 employer employer NN 42759 4352 7 when when WRB 42759 4352 8 diminished diminish VBN 42759 4352 9 by by IN 42759 4352 10 or or CC 42759 4352 11 weighed weigh VBN 42759 4352 12 against against IN 42759 4352 13 the the DT 42759 4352 14 amount amount NN 42759 4352 15 that that WDT 42759 4352 16 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4352 17 pays pay VBZ 42759 4352 18 in in IN 42759 4352 19 wages wage NNS 42759 4352 20 should should MD 42759 4352 21 be be VB 42759 4352 22 equal equal JJ 42759 4352 23 to to IN 42759 4352 24 the the DT 42759 4352 25 good good JJ 42759 4352 26 received receive VBN 42759 4352 27 by by IN 42759 4352 28 the the DT 42759 4352 29 labourer labourer NN 42759 4352 30 when when WRB 42759 4352 31 diminished diminish VBN 42759 4352 32 by by IN 42759 4352 33 or or CC 42759 4352 34 weighed weigh VBN 42759 4352 35 against against IN 42759 4352 36 the the DT 42759 4352 37 inconvenience inconvenience NN 42759 4352 38 that that IN 42759 4352 39 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4352 40 undergoes undergo VBZ 42759 4352 41 through through IN 42759 4352 42 the the DT 42759 4352 43 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 4352 44 of of IN 42759 4352 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4352 46 time time NN 42759 4352 47 and and CC 42759 4352 48 energy energy NN 42759 4352 49 . . . 42759 4353 1 Hence hence RB 42759 4353 2 the the DT 42759 4353 3 contract contract NN 42759 4353 4 should should MD 42759 4353 5 bring bring VB 42759 4353 6 to to IN 42759 4353 7 employer employer NN 42759 4353 8 and and CC 42759 4353 9 employé employé VBD 42759 4353 10 equal equal JJ 42759 4353 11 amounts amount NNS 42759 4353 12 of of IN 42759 4353 13 net net JJ 42759 4353 14 advantage advantage NN 42759 4353 15 or or CC 42759 4353 16 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 4353 17 . . . 42759 4354 1 Plausible plausible JJ 42759 4354 2 as as IN 42759 4354 3 this this DT 42759 4354 4 rule rule NN 42759 4354 5 may may MD 42759 4354 6 appear appear VB 42759 4354 7 , , , 42759 4354 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4354 9 is be VBZ 42759 4354 10 impracticable impracticable JJ 42759 4354 11 , , , 42759 4354 12 inequitable inequitable JJ 42759 4354 13 , , , 42759 4354 14 and and CC 42759 4354 15 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4354 16 . . . 42759 4355 1 In in IN 42759 4355 2 the the DT 42759 4355 3 vast vast JJ 42759 4355 4 majority majority NN 42759 4355 5 of of IN 42759 4355 6 labour labour NN 42759 4355 7 contracts contract NNS 42759 4355 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4355 9 is be VBZ 42759 4355 10 impossible impossible JJ 42759 4355 11 to to TO 42759 4355 12 know know VB 42759 4355 13 whether whether IN 42759 4355 14 both both DT 42759 4355 15 parties party NNS 42759 4355 16 obtain obtain VBP 42759 4355 17 the the DT 42759 4355 18 same same JJ 42759 4355 19 quantity quantity NN 42759 4355 20 of of IN 42759 4355 21 net net JJ 42759 4355 22 advantage advantage NN 42759 4355 23 . . . 42759 4356 1 The the DT 42759 4356 2 gains gain NNS 42759 4356 3 of of IN 42759 4356 4 the the DT 42759 4356 5 employer employer NN 42759 4356 6 can can MD 42759 4356 7 , , , 42759 4356 8 indeed indeed RB 42759 4356 9 , , , 42759 4356 10 be be VB 42759 4356 11 frequently frequently RB 42759 4356 12 measured measure VBN 42759 4356 13 in in IN 42759 4356 14 terms term NNS 42759 4356 15 of of IN 42759 4356 16 money money NN 42759 4356 17 , , , 42759 4356 18 being be VBG 42759 4356 19 the the DT 42759 4356 20 difference difference NN 42759 4356 21 between between IN 42759 4356 22 the the DT 42759 4356 23 wages wage NNS 42759 4356 24 paid pay VBN 42759 4356 25 to to IN 42759 4356 26 and and CC 42759 4356 27 the the DT 42759 4356 28 specific specific JJ 42759 4356 29 product product NN 42759 4356 30 turned turn VBD 42759 4356 31 out out RP 42759 4356 32 by by IN 42759 4356 33 the the DT 42759 4356 34 labourer labourer NN 42759 4356 35 . . . 42759 4357 1 In in IN 42759 4357 2 the the DT 42759 4357 3 case case NN 42759 4357 4 of of IN 42759 4357 5 the the DT 42759 4357 6 labourer labourer NN 42759 4357 7 no no DT 42759 4357 8 such such JJ 42759 4357 9 process process NN 42759 4357 10 of of IN 42759 4357 11 deduction deduction NN 42759 4357 12 is be VBZ 42759 4357 13 possible possible JJ 42759 4357 14 ; ; : 42759 4357 15 for for IN 42759 4357 16 advantage advantage NN 42759 4357 17 and and CC 42759 4357 18 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 4357 19 are be VBP 42759 4357 20 incommensurable incommensurable JJ 42759 4357 21 . . . 42759 4358 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 4358 2 can can MD 42759 4358 3 not not RB 42759 4358 4 subtract subtract VB 42759 4358 5 the the DT 42759 4358 6 labourer labourer NN 42759 4358 7 's 's POS 42759 4358 8 privation privation NN 42759 4358 9 , , , 42759 4358 10 that that RB 42759 4358 11 is is RB 42759 4358 12 , , , 42759 4358 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4358 14 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 4358 15 of of IN 42759 4358 16 time time NN 42759 4358 17 and and CC 42759 4358 18 energy energy NN 42759 4358 19 , , , 42759 4358 20 from from IN 42759 4358 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4358 22 gross gross JJ 42759 4358 23 advantage advantage NN 42759 4358 24 , , , 42759 4358 25 that that RB 42759 4358 26 is is RB 42759 4358 27 , , , 42759 4358 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4358 29 wages wage NNS 42759 4358 30 . . . 42759 4359 1 How how WRB 42759 4359 2 can can MD 42759 4359 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4359 4 know know VB 42759 4359 5 or or CC 42759 4359 6 measure measure VB 42759 4359 7 the the DT 42759 4359 8 net net JJ 42759 4359 9 benefit benefit NN 42759 4359 10 obtained obtain VBN 42759 4359 11 by by IN 42759 4359 12 a a DT 42759 4359 13 man man NN 42759 4359 14 who who WP 42759 4359 15 shovels shovel VBZ 42759 4359 16 sand sand NN 42759 4359 17 ten ten CD 42759 4359 18 hours hour NNS 42759 4359 19 for for IN 42759 4359 20 a a DT 42759 4359 21 wage wage NN 42759 4359 22 of of IN 42759 4359 23 two two CD 42759 4359 24 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4359 25 ? ? . 42759 4360 1 How how WRB 42759 4360 2 can can MD 42759 4360 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4360 4 deduct deduct VB 42759 4360 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4360 6 pain pain NN 42759 4360 7 - - HYPH 42759 4360 8 cost cost NN 42759 4360 9 from from IN 42759 4360 10 or or CC 42759 4360 11 weigh weigh VB 42759 4360 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4360 13 against against IN 42759 4360 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4360 15 compensation compensation NN 42759 4360 16 ? ? . 42759 4361 1 So so RB 42759 4361 2 far far RB 42759 4361 3 as as IN 42759 4361 4 the the DT 42759 4361 5 two two CD 42759 4361 6 sets set NNS 42759 4361 7 of of IN 42759 4361 8 advantages advantage NNS 42759 4361 9 are be VBP 42759 4361 10 comparable comparable JJ 42759 4361 11 at at RB 42759 4361 12 all all RB 42759 4361 13 , , , 42759 4361 14 those those DT 42759 4361 15 of of IN 42759 4361 16 the the DT 42759 4361 17 employé employé NNS 42759 4361 18 would would MD 42759 4361 19 seem seem VB 42759 4361 20 to to TO 42759 4361 21 be be VB 42759 4361 22 always always RB 42759 4361 23 greater great JJR 42759 4361 24 than than IN 42759 4361 25 those those DT 42759 4361 26 of of IN 42759 4361 27 the the DT 42759 4361 28 employer employer NN 42759 4361 29 . . . 42759 4362 1 A a DT 42759 4362 2 wage wage NN 42759 4362 3 of of IN 42759 4362 4 seventy seventy CD 42759 4362 5 - - HYPH 42759 4362 6 five five CD 42759 4362 7 cents cent NNS 42759 4362 8 a a DT 42759 4362 9 day day NN 42759 4362 10 enables enable VBZ 42759 4362 11 the the DT 42759 4362 12 labourer labourer NN 42759 4362 13 to to TO 42759 4362 14 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 4362 15 the the DT 42759 4362 16 most most RBS 42759 4362 17 important important JJ 42759 4362 18 wants want NNS 42759 4362 19 of of IN 42759 4362 20 life life NN 42759 4362 21 . . . 42759 4363 1 Weighed weigh VBN 42759 4363 2 against against IN 42759 4363 3 this this DT 42759 4363 4 gross gross JJ 42759 4363 5 advantage advantage NN 42759 4363 6 , , , 42759 4363 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4363 8 pain pain NN 42759 4363 9 - - HYPH 42759 4363 10 cost cost NN 42759 4363 11 of of IN 42759 4363 12 toil toil NN 42759 4363 13 is be VBZ 42759 4363 14 relatively relatively RB 42759 4363 15 insignificant insignificant JJ 42759 4363 16 . . . 42759 4364 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4364 2 net net JJ 42759 4364 3 advantage advantage NN 42759 4364 4 is be VBZ 42759 4364 5 the the DT 42759 4364 6 greatest great JJS 42759 4364 7 that that WDT 42759 4364 8 a a DT 42759 4364 9 man man NN 42759 4364 10 can can MD 42759 4364 11 enjoy enjoy VB 42759 4364 12 , , , 42759 4364 13 the the DT 42759 4364 14 continuation continuation NN 42759 4364 15 of of IN 42759 4364 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4364 17 existence existence NN 42759 4364 18 . . . 42759 4365 1 The the DT 42759 4365 2 net net JJ 42759 4365 3 advantage advantage NN 42759 4365 4 received receive VBN 42759 4365 5 by by IN 42759 4365 6 the the DT 42759 4365 7 employer employer NN 42759 4365 8 from from IN 42759 4365 9 such such PDT 42759 4365 10 a a DT 42759 4365 11 wage wage NN 42759 4365 12 contract contract NN 42759 4365 13 is be VBZ 42759 4365 14 but but CC 42759 4365 15 a a DT 42759 4365 16 few few JJ 42759 4365 17 cents cent NNS 42759 4365 18 , , , 42759 4365 19 the the DT 42759 4365 20 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4365 21 of of IN 42759 4365 22 a a DT 42759 4365 23 cigar cigar NN 42759 4365 24 or or CC 42759 4365 25 two two CD 42759 4365 26 . . . 42759 4366 1 Even even RB 42759 4366 2 if if IN 42759 4366 3 the the DT 42759 4366 4 wage wage NN 42759 4366 5 be be VB 42759 4366 6 raised raise VBN 42759 4366 7 to to IN 42759 4366 8 the the DT 42759 4366 9 highest high JJS 42759 4366 10 level level NN 42759 4366 11 yet yet RB 42759 4366 12 reached reach VBN 42759 4366 13 by by IN 42759 4366 14 any any DT 42759 4366 15 wage wage NN 42759 4366 16 earner earner NN 42759 4366 17 , , , 42759 4366 18 the the DT 42759 4366 19 net net JJ 42759 4366 20 advantage advantage NN 42759 4366 21 to to IN 42759 4366 22 the the DT 42759 4366 23 labourer labourer NN 42759 4366 24 , , , 42759 4366 25 namely namely RB 42759 4366 26 , , , 42759 4366 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4366 28 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4366 29 , , , 42759 4366 30 will will MD 42759 4366 31 be be VB 42759 4366 32 greater great JJR 42759 4366 33 than than IN 42759 4366 34 the the DT 42759 4366 35 net net JJ 42759 4366 36 advantage advantage NN 42759 4366 37 to to IN 42759 4366 38 the the DT 42759 4366 39 employer employer NN 42759 4366 40 from from IN 42759 4366 41 that that DT 42759 4366 42 single single JJ 42759 4366 43 contract contract NN 42759 4366 44 . . . 42759 4367 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4367 2 , , , 42759 4367 3 the the DT 42759 4367 4 sum sum NN 42759 4367 5 total total NN 42759 4367 6 of of IN 42759 4367 7 an an DT 42759 4367 8 employer employer NN 42759 4367 9 's 's POS 42759 4367 10 gains gain NNS 42759 4367 11 from from IN 42759 4367 12 all all PDT 42759 4367 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4367 14 labour labour JJ 42759 4367 15 contracts contract NNS 42759 4367 16 is be VBZ 42759 4367 17 less less RBR 42759 4367 18 quantitatively quantitatively RB 42759 4367 19 than than IN 42759 4367 20 the the DT 42759 4367 21 sum sum NN 42759 4367 22 total total NN 42759 4367 23 of of IN 42759 4367 24 the the DT 42759 4367 25 gains gain NNS 42759 4367 26 obtained obtain VBN 42759 4367 27 by by IN 42759 4367 28 all all DT 42759 4367 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4367 30 employés employés NN 42759 4367 31 . . . 42759 4368 1 The the DT 42759 4368 2 latter latter JJ 42759 4368 3 gains gain NNS 42759 4368 4 provide provide VBP 42759 4368 5 for for IN 42759 4368 6 many many JJ 42759 4368 7 livelihoods livelihood NNS 42759 4368 8 , , , 42759 4368 9 the the DT 42759 4368 10 former former JJ 42759 4368 11 for for IN 42759 4368 12 only only RB 42759 4368 13 one one CD 42759 4368 14 . . . 42759 4369 1 Again again RB 42759 4369 2 , , , 42759 4369 3 no no DT 42759 4369 4 general general JJ 42759 4369 5 rate rate NN 42759 4369 6 of of IN 42759 4369 7 wages wage NNS 42759 4369 8 could could MD 42759 4369 9 be be VB 42759 4369 10 devised devise VBN 42759 4369 11 which which WDT 42759 4369 12 would would MD 42759 4369 13 enable enable VB 42759 4369 14 all all PDT 42759 4369 15 the the DT 42759 4369 16 members member NNS 42759 4369 17 of of IN 42759 4369 18 a a DT 42759 4369 19 labour labour JJ 42759 4369 20 group group NN 42759 4369 21 to to TO 42759 4369 22 gain gain VB 42759 4369 23 equally equally RB 42759 4369 24 . . . 42759 4370 1 Differences difference NNS 42759 4370 2 in in IN 42759 4370 3 health health NN 42759 4370 4 , , , 42759 4370 5 strength strength NN 42759 4370 6 , , , 42759 4370 7 and and CC 42759 4370 8 intelligence intelligence NN 42759 4370 9 would would MD 42759 4370 10 cause cause VB 42759 4370 11 differences difference NNS 42759 4370 12 in in IN 42759 4370 13 the the DT 42759 4370 14 pain pain NN 42759 4370 15 - - HYPH 42759 4370 16 cost cost NN 42759 4370 17 involved involve VBN 42759 4370 18 in in IN 42759 4370 19 a a DT 42759 4370 20 given give VBN 42759 4370 21 amount amount NN 42759 4370 22 of of IN 42759 4370 23 labour labour NN 42759 4370 24 ; ; : 42759 4370 25 while while IN 42759 4370 26 differences difference NNS 42759 4370 27 in in IN 42759 4370 28 desires desire NNS 42759 4370 29 , , , 42759 4370 30 standards standard NNS 42759 4370 31 of of IN 42759 4370 32 living living NN 42759 4370 33 , , , 42759 4370 34 and and CC 42759 4370 35 skill skill NN 42759 4370 36 in in IN 42759 4370 37 spending spending NN 42759 4370 38 would would MD 42759 4370 39 bring bring VB 42759 4370 40 about about RP 42759 4370 41 differences difference NNS 42759 4370 42 in in IN 42759 4370 43 the the DT 42759 4370 44 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 42759 4370 45 derived derive VBN 42759 4370 46 from from IN 42759 4370 47 the the DT 42759 4370 48 same same JJ 42759 4370 49 compensation compensation NN 42759 4370 50 . . . 42759 4371 1 Finally finally RB 42759 4371 2 , , , 42759 4371 3 various various JJ 42759 4371 4 employers employer NNS 42759 4371 5 would would MD 42759 4371 6 obtain obtain VB 42759 4371 7 various various JJ 42759 4371 8 money money NN 42759 4371 9 gains gain NNS 42759 4371 10 from from IN 42759 4371 11 the the DT 42759 4371 12 same same JJ 42759 4371 13 wage wage NN 42759 4371 14 outlay outlay NN 42759 4371 15 , , , 42759 4371 16 and and CC 42759 4371 17 various various JJ 42759 4371 18 advantages advantage NNS 42759 4371 19 from from IN 42759 4371 20 the the DT 42759 4371 21 same same JJ 42759 4371 22 money money NN 42759 4371 23 gains gain NNS 42759 4371 24 . . . 42759 4372 1 Hence hence RB 42759 4372 2 if if IN 42759 4372 3 the the DT 42759 4372 4 rule rule NN 42759 4372 5 of of IN 42759 4372 6 equality equality NN 42759 4372 7 of of IN 42759 4372 8 net net JJ 42759 4372 9 advantages advantage NNS 42759 4372 10 were be VBD 42759 4372 11 practicable practicable JJ 42759 4372 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4372 13 would would MD 42759 4372 14 be be VB 42759 4372 15 inequitable inequitable JJ 42759 4372 16 . . . 42759 4373 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4373 2 is be VBZ 42759 4373 3 also also RB 42759 4373 4 fundamentally fundamentally RB 42759 4373 5 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4373 6 because because IN 42759 4373 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4373 8 ignores ignore VBZ 42759 4373 9 the the DT 42759 4373 10 moral moral JJ 42759 4373 11 claims claim NNS 42759 4373 12 of of IN 42759 4373 13 needs need NNS 42759 4373 14 , , , 42759 4373 15 efforts effort NNS 42759 4373 16 , , , 42759 4373 17 and and CC 42759 4373 18 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 4373 19 as as IN 42759 4373 20 regards regard VBZ 42759 4373 21 the the DT 42759 4373 22 labourer labourer NN 42759 4373 23 . . . 42759 4374 1 As as IN 42759 4374 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4374 3 have have VBP 42759 4374 4 seen see VBN 42759 4374 5 in in IN 42759 4374 6 the the DT 42759 4374 7 chapter chapter NN 42759 4374 8 on on IN 42759 4374 9 profits profit NNS 42759 4374 10 in in IN 42759 4374 11 competitive competitive JJ 42759 4374 12 conditions condition NNS 42759 4374 13 , , , 42759 4374 14 and and CC 42759 4374 15 as as IN 42759 4374 16 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4374 17 shall shall MD 42759 4374 18 have have VB 42759 4374 19 occasion occasion NN 42759 4374 20 to to TO 42759 4374 21 recognise recognise VB 42759 4374 22 again again RB 42759 4374 23 in in IN 42759 4374 24 a a DT 42759 4374 25 later later JJ 42759 4374 26 chapter chapter NN 42759 4374 27 , , , 42759 4374 28 no no DT 42759 4374 29 canon canon NN 42759 4374 30 or or CC 42759 4374 31 scheme scheme NN 42759 4374 32 of of IN 42759 4374 33 distributive distributive JJ 42759 4374 34 justice justice NN 42759 4374 35 is be VBZ 42759 4374 36 acceptable acceptable JJ 42759 4374 37 that that WDT 42759 4374 38 does do VBZ 42759 4374 39 not not RB 42759 4374 40 give give VB 42759 4374 41 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4374 42 consideration consideration NN 42759 4374 43 to to IN 42759 4374 44 these these DT 42759 4374 45 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4374 46 attributes attribute NNS 42759 4374 47 of of IN 42759 4374 48 human human JJ 42759 4374 49 personality personality NN 42759 4374 50 . . . 42759 4375 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4375 2 The the DT 42759 4375 3 Rule Rule NNP 42759 4375 4 of of IN 42759 4375 5 Free Free NNP 42759 4375 6 Contract Contract NNP 42759 4375 7 _ _ IN 42759 4375 8 Another another DT 42759 4375 9 form form NN 42759 4375 10 of of IN 42759 4375 11 the the DT 42759 4375 12 exchange exchange NN 42759 4375 13 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4375 14 theory theory NN 42759 4375 15 would would MD 42759 4375 16 disregard disregard VB 42759 4375 17 the the DT 42759 4375 18 problem problem NN 42759 4375 19 of of IN 42759 4375 20 _ _ NNP 42759 4375 21 equality equality NN 42759 4375 22 _ _ NNP 42759 4375 23 of of IN 42759 4375 24 gains gain NNS 42759 4375 25 , , , 42759 4375 26 and and CC 42759 4375 27 assume assume VB 42759 4375 28 that that IN 42759 4375 29 justice justice NN 42759 4375 30 is be VBZ 42759 4375 31 realised realise VBN 42759 4375 32 whenever whenever WRB 42759 4375 33 the the DT 42759 4375 34 contract contract NN 42759 4375 35 is be VBZ 42759 4375 36 free free JJ 42759 4375 37 from from IN 42759 4375 38 force force NN 42759 4375 39 or or CC 42759 4375 40 fraud fraud NN 42759 4375 41 . . . 42759 4376 1 In in IN 42759 4376 2 such such JJ 42759 4376 3 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 4376 4 both both DT 42759 4376 5 parties party NNS 42759 4376 6 gain gain VBP 42759 4376 7 something something NN 42759 4376 8 , , , 42759 4376 9 and and CC 42759 4376 10 presumably presumably RB 42759 4376 11 are be VBP 42759 4376 12 satisfied satisfied JJ 42759 4376 13 ; ; : 42759 4376 14 otherwise otherwise RB 42759 4376 15 , , , 42759 4376 16 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4376 17 would would MD 42759 4376 18 not not RB 42759 4376 19 enter enter VB 42759 4376 20 the the DT 42759 4376 21 contract contract NN 42759 4376 22 . . . 42759 4377 1 Probably probably RB 42759 4377 2 the the DT 42759 4377 3 majority majority NN 42759 4377 4 of of IN 42759 4377 5 employers employer NNS 42759 4377 6 regard regard VBP 42759 4377 7 this this DT 42759 4377 8 rule rule NN 42759 4377 9 as as IN 42759 4377 10 the the DT 42759 4377 11 only only JJ 42759 4377 12 available available JJ 42759 4377 13 measure measure NN 42759 4377 14 of of IN 42759 4377 15 practicable practicable JJ 42759 4377 16 justice justice NN 42759 4377 17 . . . 42759 4378 1 The the DT 42759 4378 2 majority majority NN 42759 4378 3 of of IN 42759 4378 4 economists economist NNS 42759 4378 5 likewise likewise RB 42759 4378 6 subscribed subscribe VBD 42759 4378 7 to to IN 42759 4378 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4378 9 during during IN 42759 4378 10 the the DT 42759 4378 11 first first JJ 42759 4378 12 half half NN 42759 4378 13 of of IN 42759 4378 14 the the DT 42759 4378 15 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 42759 4378 16 century century NN 42759 4378 17 . . . 42759 4379 1 In in IN 42759 4379 2 the the DT 42759 4379 3 words word NNS 42759 4379 4 of of IN 42759 4379 5 Henry Henry NNP 42759 4379 6 Sidgwick Sidgwick NNP 42759 4379 7 , , , 42759 4379 8 " " '' 42759 4379 9 the the DT 42759 4379 10 teaching teaching NN 42759 4379 11 of of IN 42759 4379 12 the the DT 42759 4379 13 political political JJ 42759 4379 14 economists economist NNS 42759 4379 15 pointed point VBD 42759 4379 16 to to IN 42759 4379 17 the the DT 42759 4379 18 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 4379 19 that that IN 42759 4379 20 a a DT 42759 4379 21 free free JJ 42759 4379 22 exchange exchange NN 42759 4379 23 , , , 42759 4379 24 without without IN 42759 4379 25 fraud fraud NN 42759 4379 26 or or CC 42759 4379 27 coercion coercion NN 42759 4379 28 , , , 42759 4379 29 is be VBZ 42759 4379 30 also also RB 42759 4379 31 a a DT 42759 4379 32 fair fair JJ 42759 4379 33 exchange exchange NN 42759 4379 34 . . . 42759 4380 1 " " `` 42759 4380 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4380 3 215 215 CD 42759 4380 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4380 5 Apparently apparently RB 42759 4380 6 the the DT 42759 4380 7 economists economist NNS 42759 4380 8 based base VBN 42759 4380 9 this this DT 42759 4380 10 teaching teaching NN 42759 4380 11 on on IN 42759 4380 12 the the DT 42759 4380 13 assumption assumption NN 42759 4380 14 that that IN 42759 4380 15 competition competition NN 42759 4380 16 was be VBD 42759 4380 17 free free JJ 42759 4380 18 and and CC 42759 4380 19 general general JJ 42759 4380 20 among among IN 42759 4380 21 both both DT 42759 4380 22 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4380 23 and and CC 42759 4380 24 employers employer NNS 42759 4380 25 . . . 42759 4381 1 In in IN 42759 4381 2 other other JJ 42759 4381 3 words word NNS 42759 4381 4 , , , 42759 4381 5 the the DT 42759 4381 6 rule rule NN 42759 4381 7 as as IN 42759 4381 8 understood understand VBN 42759 4381 9 by by IN 42759 4381 10 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4381 11 was be VBD 42759 4381 12 probably probably RB 42759 4381 13 identical identical JJ 42759 4381 14 with with IN 42759 4381 15 the the DT 42759 4381 16 rule rule NN 42759 4381 17 of of IN 42759 4381 18 the the DT 42759 4381 19 market market NN 42759 4381 20 rate rate NN 42759 4381 21 , , , 42759 4381 22 which which WDT 42759 4381 23 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4381 24 shall shall MD 42759 4381 25 examine examine VB 42759 4381 26 presently presently RB 42759 4381 27 . . . 42759 4382 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4382 2 is be VBZ 42759 4382 3 not not RB 42759 4382 4 at at RB 42759 4382 5 all all RB 42759 4382 6 likely likely JJ 42759 4382 7 that that IN 42759 4382 8 the the DT 42759 4382 9 economists economist NNS 42759 4382 10 here here RB 42759 4382 11 referred refer VBD 42759 4382 12 to to TO 42759 4382 13 would would MD 42759 4382 14 have have VB 42759 4382 15 given give VBN 42759 4382 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4382 17 moral moral JJ 42759 4382 18 approval approval NN 42759 4382 19 to to IN 42759 4382 20 those those DT 42759 4382 21 " " `` 42759 4382 22 free free JJ 42759 4382 23 " " '' 42759 4382 24 contracts contract NNS 42759 4382 25 in in IN 42759 4382 26 which which WDT 42759 4382 27 the the DT 42759 4382 28 employer employer NN 42759 4382 29 pays pay VBZ 42759 4382 30 starvation starvation NN 42759 4382 31 wages wage NNS 42759 4382 32 because because IN 42759 4382 33 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4382 34 takes take VBZ 42759 4382 35 advantage advantage NN 42759 4382 36 of of IN 42759 4382 37 the the DT 42759 4382 38 ignorance ignorance NN 42759 4382 39 of of IN 42759 4382 40 the the DT 42759 4382 41 labourer labourer NN 42759 4382 42 , , , 42759 4382 43 or or CC 42759 4382 44 because because IN 42759 4382 45 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4382 46 exercises exercise VBZ 42759 4382 47 the the DT 42759 4382 48 power power NN 42759 4382 49 of of IN 42759 4382 50 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 4382 51 . . . 42759 4383 1 No no RB 42759 4383 2 matter matter RB 42759 4383 3 by by IN 42759 4383 4 whom whom WP 42759 4383 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4383 6 is be VBZ 42759 4383 7 or or CC 42759 4383 8 has have VBZ 42759 4383 9 been be VBN 42759 4383 10 held hold VBN 42759 4383 11 , , , 42759 4383 12 the the DT 42759 4383 13 rule rule NN 42759 4383 14 of of IN 42759 4383 15 free free JJ 42759 4383 16 contract contract NN 42759 4383 17 is be VBZ 42759 4383 18 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4383 19 . . . 42759 4384 1 In in IN 42759 4384 2 the the DT 42759 4384 3 first first JJ 42759 4384 4 place place NN 42759 4384 5 , , , 42759 4384 6 many many JJ 42759 4384 7 labour labour JJ 42759 4384 8 contracts contract NNS 42759 4384 9 are be VBP 42759 4384 10 not not RB 42759 4384 11 free free JJ 42759 4384 12 in in IN 42759 4384 13 any any DT 42759 4384 14 genuine genuine JJ 42759 4384 15 sense sense NN 42759 4384 16 . . . 42759 4385 1 When when WRB 42759 4385 2 a a DT 42759 4385 3 labourer labourer NN 42759 4385 4 is be VBZ 42759 4385 5 compelled compel VBN 42759 4385 6 by by IN 42759 4385 7 dire dire JJ 42759 4385 8 necessity necessity NN 42759 4385 9 to to TO 42759 4385 10 accept accept VB 42759 4385 11 a a DT 42759 4385 12 wage wage NN 42759 4385 13 that that WDT 42759 4385 14 is be VBZ 42759 4385 15 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 4385 16 for for IN 42759 4385 17 a a DT 42759 4385 18 decent decent JJ 42759 4385 19 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4385 20 , , , 42759 4385 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4385 22 consent consent NN 42759 4385 23 to to IN 42759 4385 24 the the DT 42759 4385 25 contract contract NN 42759 4385 26 is be VBZ 42759 4385 27 free free JJ 42759 4385 28 only only RB 42759 4385 29 in in IN 42759 4385 30 a a DT 42759 4385 31 limited limited JJ 42759 4385 32 and and CC 42759 4385 33 relative relative JJ 42759 4385 34 way way NN 42759 4385 35 . . . 42759 4386 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4386 2 is be VBZ 42759 4386 3 what what WP 42759 4386 4 the the DT 42759 4386 5 moralists moralist NNS 42759 4386 6 call call VBP 42759 4386 7 " " `` 42759 4386 8 _ _ NNP 42759 4386 9 voluntarium voluntarium NN 42759 4386 10 imperfectum imperfectum NN 42759 4386 11 _ _ NNP 42759 4386 12 . . . 42759 4386 13 " " '' 42759 4387 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4387 2 is be VBZ 42759 4387 3 vitiated vitiate VBN 42759 4387 4 to to IN 42759 4387 5 a a DT 42759 4387 6 substantial substantial JJ 42759 4387 7 extent extent NN 42759 4387 8 by by IN 42759 4387 9 the the DT 42759 4387 10 element element NN 42759 4387 11 of of IN 42759 4387 12 fear fear NN 42759 4387 13 , , , 42759 4387 14 by by IN 42759 4387 15 the the DT 42759 4387 16 apprehension apprehension NN 42759 4387 17 of of IN 42759 4387 18 a a DT 42759 4387 19 cruelly cruelly RB 42759 4387 20 evil evil JJ 42759 4387 21 alternative alternative NN 42759 4387 22 . . . 42759 4388 1 The the DT 42759 4388 2 labourer labourer NN 42759 4388 3 does do VBZ 42759 4388 4 not not RB 42759 4388 5 agree agree VB 42759 4388 6 to to IN 42759 4388 7 this this DT 42759 4388 8 wage wage NN 42759 4388 9 because because IN 42759 4388 10 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4388 11 prefers prefer VBZ 42759 4388 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4388 13 to to IN 42759 4388 14 any any DT 42759 4388 15 other other JJ 42759 4388 16 , , , 42759 4388 17 but but CC 42759 4388 18 merely merely RB 42759 4388 19 because because IN 42759 4388 20 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4388 21 prefers prefer VBZ 42759 4388 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4388 23 to to IN 42759 4388 24 unemployment unemployment NN 42759 4388 25 , , , 42759 4388 26 hunger hunger NN 42759 4388 27 , , , 42759 4388 28 and and CC 42759 4388 29 starvation starvation NN 42759 4388 30 . . . 42759 4389 1 The the DT 42759 4389 2 agreement agreement NN 42759 4389 3 to to TO 42759 4389 4 which which WDT 42759 4389 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4389 6 submits submit VBZ 42759 4389 7 in in IN 42759 4389 8 these these DT 42759 4389 9 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 4389 10 is be VBZ 42759 4389 11 no no DT 42759 4389 12 more more RBR 42759 4389 13 free free JJ 42759 4389 14 than than IN 42759 4389 15 the the DT 42759 4389 16 contract contract NN 42759 4389 17 by by IN 42759 4389 18 which which WDT 42759 4389 19 the the DT 42759 4389 20 helpless helpless JJ 42759 4389 21 wayfarer wayfarer NN 42759 4389 22 gives give VBZ 42759 4389 23 up up RP 42759 4389 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4389 25 purse purse NN 42759 4389 26 to to TO 42759 4389 27 escape escape VB 42759 4389 28 the the DT 42759 4389 29 pistol pistol NN 42759 4389 30 of of IN 42759 4389 31 the the DT 42759 4389 32 robber robber NN 42759 4389 33 . . . 42759 4390 1 While while IN 42759 4390 2 the the DT 42759 4390 3 latter latter JJ 42759 4390 4 action action NN 42759 4390 5 is be VBZ 42759 4390 6 free free JJ 42759 4390 7 in in IN 42759 4390 8 the the DT 42759 4390 9 sense sense NN 42759 4390 10 that that IN 42759 4390 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4390 12 is be VBZ 42759 4390 13 chosen choose VBN 42759 4390 14 in in IN 42759 4390 15 preference preference NN 42759 4390 16 to to IN 42759 4390 17 a a DT 42759 4390 18 violent violent JJ 42759 4390 19 death death NN 42759 4390 20 , , , 42759 4390 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4390 22 does do VBZ 42759 4390 23 not not RB 42759 4390 24 mean mean VB 42759 4390 25 that that IN 42759 4390 26 the the DT 42759 4390 27 wayfarer wayfarer NN 42759 4390 28 gives give VBZ 42759 4390 29 , , , 42759 4390 30 or or CC 42759 4390 31 intends intend VBZ 42759 4390 32 to to TO 42759 4390 33 give give VB 42759 4390 34 , , , 42759 4390 35 the the DT 42759 4390 36 robber robber NN 42759 4390 37 the the DT 42759 4390 38 right right NN 42759 4390 39 of of IN 42759 4390 40 ownership ownership NN 42759 4390 41 in in IN 42759 4390 42 the the DT 42759 4390 43 purse purse NN 42759 4390 44 . . . 42759 4391 1 Neither neither CC 42759 4391 2 should should MD 42759 4391 3 the the DT 42759 4391 4 labourer labourer NN 42759 4391 5 who who WP 42759 4391 6 from from IN 42759 4391 7 fear fear NN 42759 4391 8 of of IN 42759 4391 9 a a DT 42759 4391 10 worse bad JJR 42759 4391 11 evil evil NN 42759 4391 12 enters enter VBZ 42759 4391 13 a a DT 42759 4391 14 contract contract NN 42759 4391 15 to to TO 42759 4391 16 work work VB 42759 4391 17 for for IN 42759 4391 18 starvation starvation NN 42759 4391 19 wages wage NNS 42759 4391 20 , , , 42759 4391 21 be be VB 42759 4391 22 regarded regard VBN 42759 4391 23 as as IN 42759 4391 24 transferring transfer VBG 42759 4391 25 to to IN 42759 4391 26 the the DT 42759 4391 27 employer employer NN 42759 4391 28 the the DT 42759 4391 29 full full JJ 42759 4391 30 moral moral JJ 42759 4391 31 right right NN 42759 4391 32 to to IN 42759 4391 33 the the DT 42759 4391 34 services service NNS 42759 4391 35 which which WDT 42759 4391 36 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4391 37 agrees agree VBZ 42759 4391 38 to to TO 42759 4391 39 render render VB 42759 4391 40 . . . 42759 4392 1 Like like IN 42759 4392 2 the the DT 42759 4392 3 wayfarer wayfarer NN 42759 4392 4 , , , 42759 4392 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4392 6 merely merely RB 42759 4392 7 submits submit VBZ 42759 4392 8 to to IN 42759 4392 9 superior superior JJ 42759 4392 10 force force NN 42759 4392 11 . . . 42759 4393 1 The the DT 42759 4393 2 fact fact NN 42759 4393 3 that that IN 42759 4393 4 the the DT 42759 4393 5 force force NN 42759 4393 6 imposed impose VBN 42759 4393 7 upon upon IN 42759 4393 8 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4393 9 is be VBZ 42759 4393 10 economic economic JJ 42759 4393 11 instead instead RB 42759 4393 12 of of IN 42759 4393 13 physical physical JJ 42759 4393 14 does do VBZ 42759 4393 15 not not RB 42759 4393 16 affect affect VB 42759 4393 17 the the DT 42759 4393 18 morality morality NN 42759 4393 19 of of IN 42759 4393 20 the the DT 42759 4393 21 transaction transaction NN 42759 4393 22 . . . 42759 4394 1 To to TO 42759 4394 2 put put VB 42759 4394 3 the the DT 42759 4394 4 matter matter NN 42759 4394 5 in in IN 42759 4394 6 another another DT 42759 4394 7 way way NN 42759 4394 8 , , , 42759 4394 9 the the DT 42759 4394 10 equality equality NN 42759 4394 11 which which WDT 42759 4394 12 justice justice NN 42759 4394 13 requires require VBZ 42759 4394 14 is be VBZ 42759 4394 15 wanting want VBG 42759 4394 16 in in IN 42759 4394 17 an an DT 42759 4394 18 oppressive oppressive JJ 42759 4394 19 labour labour NN 42759 4394 20 contract contract NN 42759 4394 21 because because IN 42759 4394 22 of of IN 42759 4394 23 the the DT 42759 4394 24 inequality inequality NN 42759 4394 25 existing exist VBG 42759 4394 26 between between IN 42759 4394 27 the the DT 42759 4394 28 contracting contract VBG 42759 4394 29 parties party NNS 42759 4394 30 . . . 42759 4395 1 In in IN 42759 4395 2 the the DT 42759 4395 3 words word NNS 42759 4395 4 of of IN 42759 4395 5 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4395 6 Ely Ely NNP 42759 4395 7 : : : 42759 4395 8 " " `` 42759 4395 9 Free free JJ 42759 4395 10 contract contract NN 42759 4395 11 supposes suppose VBZ 42759 4395 12 equals equal NNS 42759 4395 13 behind behind IN 42759 4395 14 the the DT 42759 4395 15 contract contract NN 42759 4395 16 in in IN 42759 4395 17 order order NN 42759 4395 18 that that IN 42759 4395 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4395 20 may may MD 42759 4395 21 produce produce VB 42759 4395 22 equality equality NN 42759 4395 23 . . . 42759 4396 1 " " `` 42759 4396 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4396 3 216 216 CD 42759 4396 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4396 5 Again again RB 42759 4396 6 , , , 42759 4396 7 the the DT 42759 4396 8 rule rule NN 42759 4396 9 of of IN 42759 4396 10 free free JJ 42759 4396 11 contract contract NN 42759 4396 12 is be VBZ 42759 4396 13 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4396 14 because because IN 42759 4396 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4396 16 takes take VBZ 42759 4396 17 no no DT 42759 4396 18 account account NN 42759 4396 19 of of IN 42759 4396 20 the the DT 42759 4396 21 moral moral JJ 42759 4396 22 claims claim NNS 42759 4396 23 of of IN 42759 4396 24 needs need NNS 42759 4396 25 . . . 42759 4397 1 A a DT 42759 4397 2 man man NN 42759 4397 3 whose whose WP$ 42759 4397 4 only only JJ 42759 4397 5 source source NN 42759 4397 6 of of IN 42759 4397 7 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4397 8 is be VBZ 42759 4397 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4397 10 labour labour NN 42759 4397 11 does do VBZ 42759 4397 12 wrong wrong NN 42759 4397 13 if if IN 42759 4397 14 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4397 15 accepts accept VBZ 42759 4397 16 a a DT 42759 4397 17 starvation starvation NN 42759 4397 18 wage wage NN 42759 4397 19 willingly willingly RB 42759 4397 20 . . . 42759 4398 1 Such such PDT 42759 4398 2 a a DT 42759 4398 3 contract contract NN 42759 4398 4 , , , 42759 4398 5 however however RB 42759 4398 6 free free JJ 42759 4398 7 , , , 42759 4398 8 is be VBZ 42759 4398 9 not not RB 42759 4398 10 according accord VBG 42759 4398 11 to to IN 42759 4398 12 justice justice NN 42759 4398 13 because because IN 42759 4398 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4398 15 disregards disregard VBZ 42759 4398 16 the the DT 42759 4398 17 requirements requirement NNS 42759 4398 18 of of IN 42759 4398 19 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4398 20 life life NN 42759 4398 21 . . . 42759 4399 1 No no DT 42759 4399 2 man man NN 42759 4399 3 has have VBZ 42759 4399 4 a a DT 42759 4399 5 right right NN 42759 4399 6 to to TO 42759 4399 7 do do VB 42759 4399 8 this this DT 42759 4399 9 , , , 42759 4399 10 any any DT 42759 4399 11 more more RBR 42759 4399 12 than than IN 42759 4399 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4399 14 has have VBZ 42759 4399 15 a a DT 42759 4399 16 right right NN 42759 4399 17 to to TO 42759 4399 18 perpetrate perpetrate VB 42759 4399 19 self self NN 42759 4399 20 mutilation mutilation NN 42759 4399 21 or or CC 42759 4399 22 suicide suicide NN 42759 4399 23 . . . 42759 4400 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4400 2 The the DT 42759 4400 3 Rule Rule NNP 42759 4400 4 of of IN 42759 4400 5 Market Market NNP 42759 4400 6 Value Value NNP 42759 4400 7 _ _ NNP 42759 4400 8 A a DT 42759 4400 9 third third JJ 42759 4400 10 method method NN 42759 4400 11 of of IN 42759 4400 12 interpreting interpret VBG 42759 4400 13 exchange exchange NN 42759 4400 14 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4400 15 is be VBZ 42759 4400 16 based base VBN 42759 4400 17 upon upon IN 42759 4400 18 the the DT 42759 4400 19 concept concept NN 42759 4400 20 of of IN 42759 4400 21 value value NN 42759 4400 22 . . . 42759 4401 1 Labour labour NN 42759 4401 2 and and CC 42759 4401 3 compensation compensation NN 42759 4401 4 are be VBP 42759 4401 5 thought think VBN 42759 4401 6 to to TO 42759 4401 7 be be VB 42759 4401 8 equal equal JJ 42759 4401 9 when when WRB 42759 4401 10 the the DT 42759 4401 11 value value NN 42759 4401 12 of of IN 42759 4401 13 one one CD 42759 4401 14 is be VBZ 42759 4401 15 equal equal JJ 42759 4401 16 to to IN 42759 4401 17 the the DT 42759 4401 18 value value NN 42759 4401 19 of of IN 42759 4401 20 the the DT 42759 4401 21 other other JJ 42759 4401 22 . . . 42759 4402 1 Then then RB 42759 4402 2 the the DT 42759 4402 3 contract contract NN 42759 4402 4 is be VBZ 42759 4402 5 just just RB 42759 4402 6 and and CC 42759 4402 7 the the DT 42759 4402 8 compensation compensation NN 42759 4402 9 is be VBZ 42759 4402 10 just just RB 42759 4402 11 . . . 42759 4403 1 The the DT 42759 4403 2 only only JJ 42759 4403 3 objection objection NN 42759 4403 4 to to IN 42759 4403 5 these these DT 42759 4403 6 propositions proposition NNS 42759 4403 7 is be VBZ 42759 4403 8 that that IN 42759 4403 9 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4403 10 are be VBP 42759 4403 11 mere mere JJ 42759 4403 12 truisms truism NNS 42759 4403 13 . . . 42759 4404 1 What what WP 42759 4404 2 does do VBZ 42759 4404 3 value value NN 42759 4404 4 mean mean VB 42759 4404 5 , , , 42759 4404 6 and and CC 42759 4404 7 how how WRB 42759 4404 8 is be VBZ 42759 4404 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4404 10 to to TO 42759 4404 11 be be VB 42759 4404 12 determined determine VBN 42759 4404 13 ? ? . 42759 4405 1 If if IN 42759 4405 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4405 3 is be VBZ 42759 4405 4 to to TO 42759 4405 5 receive receive VB 42759 4405 6 an an DT 42759 4405 7 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4405 8 signification signification NN 42759 4405 9 ; ; : 42759 4405 10 if if IN 42759 4405 11 the the DT 42759 4405 12 value value NN 42759 4405 13 of of IN 42759 4405 14 labour labour NN 42759 4405 15 is be VBZ 42759 4405 16 to to TO 42759 4405 17 be be VB 42759 4405 18 understood understand VBN 42759 4405 19 as as IN 42759 4405 20 denoting denote VBG 42759 4405 21 not not RB 42759 4405 22 merely merely RB 42759 4405 23 the the DT 42759 4405 24 value value NN 42759 4405 25 that that WDT 42759 4405 26 labour labour NN 42759 4405 27 will will MD 42759 4405 28 command command VB 42759 4405 29 in in IN 42759 4405 30 a a DT 42759 4405 31 market market NN 42759 4405 32 , , , 42759 4405 33 but but CC 42759 4405 34 the the DT 42759 4405 35 value value NN 42759 4405 36 that that WDT 42759 4405 37 labour labour NN 42759 4405 38 ought ought MD 42759 4405 39 to to IN 42759 4405 40 have,--the have,--the PRP$ 42759 4405 41 statement statement NN 42759 4405 42 that that IN 42759 4405 43 wages wage NNS 42759 4405 44 should should MD 42759 4405 45 equal equal VB 42759 4405 46 the the DT 42759 4405 47 value value NN 42759 4405 48 of of IN 42759 4405 49 labour labour NN 42759 4405 50 becomes become VBZ 42759 4405 51 merely merely RB 42759 4405 52 an an DT 42759 4405 53 identical identical JJ 42759 4405 54 proposition proposition NN 42759 4405 55 . . . 42759 4406 1 All all DT 42759 4406 2 that that WDT 42759 4406 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4406 4 tells tell VBZ 42759 4406 5 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4406 6 is be VBZ 42759 4406 7 that that IN 42759 4406 8 wages wage NNS 42759 4406 9 ought ought MD 42759 4406 10 to to TO 42759 4406 11 be be VB 42759 4406 12 what what WP 42759 4406 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4406 14 ought ought MD 42759 4406 15 to to TO 42759 4406 16 be be VB 42759 4406 17 . . . 42759 4407 1 In in IN 42759 4407 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4407 3 simplest simple JJS 42759 4407 4 economic economic JJ 42759 4407 5 sense sense NN 42759 4407 6 value value NN 42759 4407 7 denotes denote VBZ 42759 4407 8 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 4407 9 power power NN 42759 4407 10 , , , 42759 4407 11 or or CC 42759 4407 12 importance importance NN 42759 4407 13 in in IN 42759 4407 14 exchange exchange NN 42759 4407 15 . . . 42759 4408 1 As as IN 42759 4408 2 such such JJ 42759 4408 3 , , , 42759 4408 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4408 5 may may MD 42759 4408 6 be be VB 42759 4408 7 either either CC 42759 4408 8 individual individual JJ 42759 4408 9 or or CC 42759 4408 10 social social JJ 42759 4408 11 ; ; : 42759 4408 12 that that RB 42759 4408 13 is is RB 42759 4408 14 , , , 42759 4408 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4408 16 may may MD 42759 4408 17 mean mean VB 42759 4408 18 the the DT 42759 4408 19 exchange exchange NN 42759 4408 20 importance importance NN 42759 4408 21 attributed attribute VBN 42759 4408 22 to to IN 42759 4408 23 a a DT 42759 4408 24 commodity commodity NN 42759 4408 25 by by IN 42759 4408 26 an an DT 42759 4408 27 individual individual NN 42759 4408 28 , , , 42759 4408 29 or or CC 42759 4408 30 that that IN 42759 4408 31 attributed attribute VBN 42759 4408 32 by by IN 42759 4408 33 a a DT 42759 4408 34 social social JJ 42759 4408 35 group group NN 42759 4408 36 . . . 42759 4409 1 In in IN 42759 4409 2 a a DT 42759 4409 3 competitive competitive JJ 42759 4409 4 society society NN 42759 4409 5 social social JJ 42759 4409 6 value value NN 42759 4409 7 is be VBZ 42759 4409 8 formed form VBN 42759 4409 9 through through IN 42759 4409 10 the the DT 42759 4409 11 higgling higgling NN 42759 4409 12 of of IN 42759 4409 13 the the DT 42759 4409 14 market market NN 42759 4409 15 , , , 42759 4409 16 and and CC 42759 4409 17 is be VBZ 42759 4409 18 expressed express VBN 42759 4409 19 in in IN 42759 4409 20 market market NN 42759 4409 21 price price NN 42759 4409 22 . . . 42759 4410 1 Now now RB 42759 4410 2 individual individual JJ 42759 4410 3 value value NN 42759 4410 4 is be VBZ 42759 4410 5 utterly utterly RB 42759 4410 6 impracticable impracticable JJ 42759 4410 7 as as IN 42759 4410 8 a a DT 42759 4410 9 measure measure NN 42759 4410 10 of of IN 42759 4410 11 exchange exchange NN 42759 4410 12 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4410 13 in in IN 42759 4410 14 the the DT 42759 4410 15 wage wage NN 42759 4410 16 contract contract NN 42759 4410 17 . . . 42759 4411 1 Since since IN 42759 4411 2 the the DT 42759 4411 3 value value NN 42759 4411 4 attributed attribute VBN 42759 4411 5 to to IN 42759 4411 6 labour labour NN 42759 4411 7 by by IN 42759 4411 8 the the DT 42759 4411 9 employer employer NN 42759 4411 10 differs differ NNS 42759 4411 11 in in IN 42759 4411 12 the the DT 42759 4411 13 great great JJ 42759 4411 14 majority majority NN 42759 4411 15 of of IN 42759 4411 16 instances instance NNS 42759 4411 17 from from IN 42759 4411 18 that that DT 42759 4411 19 estimated estimate VBN 42759 4411 20 by by IN 42759 4411 21 the the DT 42759 4411 22 labourer labourer NN 42759 4411 23 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4411 24 , , , 42759 4411 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4411 26 is be VBZ 42759 4411 27 impossible impossible JJ 42759 4411 28 to to TO 42759 4411 29 determine determine VB 42759 4411 30 which which WDT 42759 4411 31 is be VBZ 42759 4411 32 the the DT 42759 4411 33 true true JJ 42759 4411 34 value value NN 42759 4411 35 , , , 42759 4411 36 and and CC 42759 4411 37 the the DT 42759 4411 38 proper proper JJ 42759 4411 39 measure measure NN 42759 4411 40 of of IN 42759 4411 41 just just JJ 42759 4411 42 wages wage NNS 42759 4411 43 . . . 42759 4412 1 The the DT 42759 4412 2 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4412 3 that that IN 42759 4412 4 the the DT 42759 4412 5 social social JJ 42759 4412 6 value value NN 42759 4412 7 or or CC 42759 4412 8 market market NN 42759 4412 9 price price NN 42759 4412 10 of of IN 42759 4412 11 labour labour NN 42759 4412 12 is be VBZ 42759 4412 13 also also RB 42759 4412 14 the the DT 42759 4412 15 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4412 16 value value NN 42759 4412 17 or or CC 42759 4412 18 just just JJ 42759 4412 19 price price NN 42759 4412 20 , , , 42759 4412 21 is be VBZ 42759 4412 22 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 4412 23 called call VBN 42759 4412 24 the the DT 42759 4412 25 classical classical JJ 42759 4412 26 theory theory NN 42759 4412 27 , , , 42759 4412 28 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 4412 29 as as IN 42759 4412 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4412 31 was be VBD 42759 4412 32 held hold VBN 42759 4412 33 , , , 42759 4412 34 at at IN 42759 4412 35 least least JJS 42759 4412 36 implicitly implicitly RB 42759 4412 37 , , , 42759 4412 38 by by IN 42759 4412 39 the the DT 42759 4412 40 majority majority NN 42759 4412 41 of of IN 42759 4412 42 the the DT 42759 4412 43 early early JJ 42759 4412 44 economists economist NNS 42759 4412 45 of of IN 42759 4412 46 both both CC 42759 4412 47 France France NNP 42759 4412 48 and and CC 42759 4412 49 England England NNP 42759 4412 50 . . . 42759 4413 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4413 2 217 217 CD 42759 4413 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4413 4 Under under IN 42759 4413 5 competitive competitive JJ 42759 4413 6 conditions condition NNS 42759 4413 7 , , , 42759 4413 8 said say VBD 42759 4413 9 the the DT 42759 4413 10 Physiocrats Physiocrats NNP 42759 4413 11 , , , 42759 4413 12 the the DT 42759 4413 13 price price NN 42759 4413 14 of of IN 42759 4413 15 labour labour NN 42759 4413 16 as as IN 42759 4413 17 of of IN 42759 4413 18 all all DT 42759 4413 19 other other JJ 42759 4413 20 things thing NNS 42759 4413 21 corresponds correspond VBZ 42759 4413 22 to to IN 42759 4413 23 the the DT 42759 4413 24 cost cost NN 42759 4413 25 of of IN 42759 4413 26 production production NN 42759 4413 27 ; ; : 42759 4413 28 that that RB 42759 4413 29 is is RB 42759 4413 30 , , , 42759 4413 31 to to IN 42759 4413 32 the the DT 42759 4413 33 cost cost NN 42759 4413 34 of of IN 42759 4413 35 subsistence subsistence NN 42759 4413 36 for for IN 42759 4413 37 the the DT 42759 4413 38 labourer labourer NN 42759 4413 39 and and CC 42759 4413 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4413 41 family family NN 42759 4413 42 . . . 42759 4414 1 This this DT 42759 4414 2 is be VBZ 42759 4414 3 the the DT 42759 4414 4 natural natural JJ 42759 4414 5 law law NN 42759 4414 6 of of IN 42759 4414 7 wages wage NNS 42759 4414 8 , , , 42759 4414 9 and and CC 42759 4414 10 being be VBG 42759 4414 11 natural natural JJ 42759 4414 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4414 13 is be VBZ 42759 4414 14 also also RB 42759 4414 15 just just RB 42759 4414 16 . . . 42759 4415 1 Adam Adam NNP 42759 4415 2 Smith Smith NNP 42759 4415 3 likewise likewise RB 42759 4415 4 declared declare VBD 42759 4415 5 that that IN 42759 4415 6 competitive competitive JJ 42759 4415 7 wages wage NNS 42759 4415 8 were be VBD 42759 4415 9 natural natural JJ 42759 4415 10 wages wage NNS 42759 4415 11 , , , 42759 4415 12 but but CC 42759 4415 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4415 14 refrained refrain VBD 42759 4415 15 from from IN 42759 4415 16 the the DT 42759 4415 17 explicit explicit JJ 42759 4415 18 assertion assertion NN 42759 4415 19 that that IN 42759 4415 20 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4415 21 were be VBD 42759 4415 22 just just RB 42759 4415 23 wages wage NNS 42759 4415 24 . . . 42759 4416 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 4416 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4416 3 abiding abiding JJ 42759 4416 4 and and CC 42759 4416 5 oft oft RB 42759 4416 6 - - HYPH 42759 4416 7 expressed express VBN 42759 4416 8 faith faith NN 42759 4416 9 in in IN 42759 4416 10 the the DT 42759 4416 11 theory theory NN 42759 4416 12 that that IN 42759 4416 13 men man NNS 42759 4416 14 's 's POS 42759 4416 15 powers power NNS 42759 4416 16 were be VBD 42759 4416 17 substantially substantially RB 42759 4416 18 equal equal JJ 42759 4416 19 , , , 42759 4416 20 and and CC 42759 4416 21 in in IN 42759 4416 22 the the DT 42759 4416 23 social social JJ 42759 4416 24 beneficence beneficence NN 42759 4416 25 of of IN 42759 4416 26 free free JJ 42759 4416 27 competition competition NN 42759 4416 28 , , , 42759 4416 29 implied imply VBD 42759 4416 30 that that DT 42759 4416 31 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 4416 32 . . . 42759 4417 1 Although although IN 42759 4417 2 the the DT 42759 4417 3 great great JJ 42759 4417 4 majority majority NN 42759 4417 5 of of IN 42759 4417 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4417 7 followers follower NNS 42759 4417 8 denied deny VBD 42759 4417 9 that that IN 42759 4417 10 economics economic NNS 42759 4417 11 had have VBD 42759 4417 12 moral moral JJ 42759 4417 13 aspects aspect NNS 42759 4417 14 , , , 42759 4417 15 and and CC 42759 4417 16 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 4417 17 asserted assert VBD 42759 4417 18 that that IN 42759 4417 19 there there EX 42759 4417 20 was be VBD 42759 4417 21 no no DT 42759 4417 22 such such JJ 42759 4417 23 thing thing NN 42759 4417 24 as as IN 42759 4417 25 just just RB 42759 4417 26 or or CC 42759 4417 27 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4417 28 wages wage NNS 42759 4417 29 , , , 42759 4417 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4417 31 teaching teaching NN 42759 4417 32 tended tend VBD 42759 4417 33 to to TO 42759 4417 34 convey convey VB 42759 4417 35 the the DT 42759 4417 36 thought thought NN 42759 4417 37 that that WDT 42759 4417 38 competitively competitively RB 42759 4417 39 fixed fix VBN 42759 4417 40 wages wage NNS 42759 4417 41 were be VBD 42759 4417 42 more more RBR 42759 4417 43 or or CC 42759 4417 44 less less RBR 42759 4417 45 in in IN 42759 4417 46 accordance accordance NN 42759 4417 47 with with IN 42759 4417 48 justice justice NN 42759 4417 49 . . . 42759 4418 1 As as IN 42759 4418 2 noted note VBN 42759 4418 3 above above RB 42759 4418 4 , , , 42759 4418 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4418 6 belief belief NN 42759 4418 7 in in IN 42759 4418 8 the the DT 42759 4418 9 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 4418 10 of of IN 42759 4418 11 competition competition NN 42759 4418 12 led lead VBD 42759 4418 13 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4418 14 to to IN 42759 4418 15 the the DT 42759 4418 16 inference inference NN 42759 4418 17 that that IN 42759 4418 18 a a DT 42759 4418 19 free free JJ 42759 4418 20 contract contract NN 42759 4418 21 is be VBZ 42759 4418 22 also also RB 42759 4418 23 a a DT 42759 4418 24 fair fair JJ 42759 4418 25 contract contract NN 42759 4418 26 . . . 42759 4419 1 By by IN 42759 4419 2 a a DT 42759 4419 3 free free JJ 42759 4419 4 contract contract NN 42759 4419 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4419 6 meant mean VBD 42759 4419 7 for for IN 42759 4419 8 the the DT 42759 4419 9 most most JJS 42759 4419 10 part part NN 42759 4419 11 one one NN 42759 4419 12 that that WDT 42759 4419 13 is be VBZ 42759 4419 14 made make VBN 42759 4419 15 in in IN 42759 4419 16 the the DT 42759 4419 17 open open JJ 42759 4419 18 market market NN 42759 4419 19 , , , 42759 4419 20 that that WDT 42759 4419 21 is be VBZ 42759 4419 22 governed govern VBN 42759 4419 23 by by IN 42759 4419 24 the the DT 42759 4419 25 forces force NNS 42759 4419 26 of of IN 42759 4419 27 supply supply NN 42759 4419 28 and and CC 42759 4419 29 demand demand NN 42759 4419 30 , , , 42759 4419 31 and and CC 42759 4419 32 that that IN 42759 4419 33 , , , 42759 4419 34 consequently consequently RB 42759 4419 35 , , , 42759 4419 36 expresses express VBZ 42759 4419 37 the the DT 42759 4419 38 social social JJ 42759 4419 39 economic economic JJ 42759 4419 40 value value NN 42759 4419 41 of of IN 42759 4419 42 the the DT 42759 4419 43 things thing NNS 42759 4419 44 exchanged exchange VBD 42759 4419 45 . . . 42759 4420 1 All all PDT 42759 4420 2 the the DT 42759 4420 3 objections objection NNS 42759 4420 4 that that WDT 42759 4420 5 have have VBP 42759 4420 6 been be VBN 42759 4420 7 brought bring VBN 42759 4420 8 against against IN 42759 4420 9 the the DT 42759 4420 10 rule rule NN 42759 4420 11 of of IN 42759 4420 12 the the DT 42759 4420 13 prevailing prevailing NN 42759 4420 14 rate rate NN 42759 4420 15 apply apply VBP 42759 4420 16 even even RB 42759 4420 17 more more RBR 42759 4420 18 strongly strongly RB 42759 4420 19 to to IN 42759 4420 20 the the DT 42759 4420 21 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4420 22 of of IN 42759 4420 23 the the DT 42759 4420 24 market market NN 42759 4420 25 rate rate NN 42759 4420 26 . . . 42759 4421 1 The the DT 42759 4421 2 former former JJ 42759 4421 3 takes take VBZ 42759 4421 4 as as IN 42759 4421 5 a a DT 42759 4421 6 standard standard NN 42759 4421 7 the the DT 42759 4421 8 scale scale NN 42759 4421 9 of of IN 42759 4421 10 wages wage NNS 42759 4421 11 most most RBS 42759 4421 12 frequently frequently RB 42759 4421 13 paid pay VBN 42759 4421 14 in in IN 42759 4421 15 the the DT 42759 4421 16 market market NN 42759 4421 17 , , , 42759 4421 18 while while IN 42759 4421 19 the the DT 42759 4421 20 latter latter NN 42759 4421 21 approves approve VBZ 42759 4421 22 any any DT 42759 4421 23 scale scale NN 42759 4421 24 that that WDT 42759 4421 25 obtains obtain VBZ 42759 4421 26 in in IN 42759 4421 27 any any DT 42759 4421 28 group group NN 42759 4421 29 of of IN 42759 4421 30 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4421 31 or or CC 42759 4421 32 section section NN 42759 4421 33 of of IN 42759 4421 34 the the DT 42759 4421 35 market market NN 42759 4421 36 . . . 42759 4422 1 Both both DT 42759 4422 2 accept accept VB 42759 4422 3 as as IN 42759 4422 4 the the DT 42759 4422 5 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 4422 6 determinant determinant NN 42759 4422 7 of of IN 42759 4422 8 wage wage NN 42759 4422 9 justice justice NN 42759 4422 10 the the DT 42759 4422 11 preponderance preponderance NN 42759 4422 12 of of IN 42759 4422 13 economic economic JJ 42759 4422 14 force force NN 42759 4422 15 . . . 42759 4423 1 Neither neither DT 42759 4423 2 gives give VBZ 42759 4423 3 any any DT 42759 4423 4 consideration consideration NN 42759 4423 5 to to IN 42759 4423 6 the the DT 42759 4423 7 moral moral JJ 42759 4423 8 claims claim NNS 42759 4423 9 of of IN 42759 4423 10 needs need NNS 42759 4423 11 , , , 42759 4423 12 efforts effort NNS 42759 4423 13 , , , 42759 4423 14 or or CC 42759 4423 15 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 4423 16 . . . 42759 4424 1 Unless unless IN 42759 4424 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4424 3 are be VBP 42759 4424 4 to to TO 42759 4424 5 identify identify VB 42759 4424 6 justice justice NN 42759 4424 7 with with IN 42759 4424 8 power power NN 42759 4424 9 , , , 42759 4424 10 might may MD 42759 4424 11 with with IN 42759 4424 12 right right UH 42759 4424 13 , , , 42759 4424 14 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4424 15 must must MD 42759 4424 16 regard regard VB 42759 4424 17 these these DT 42759 4424 18 objections objection NNS 42759 4424 19 as as IN 42759 4424 20 irrefutable irrefutable JJ 42759 4424 21 , , , 42759 4424 22 and and CC 42759 4424 23 the the DT 42759 4424 24 market market NN 42759 4424 25 value value NN 42759 4424 26 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4424 27 as as IN 42759 4424 28 untenable untenable JJ 42759 4424 29 . . . 42759 4425 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4425 2 The the DT 42759 4425 3 Mediæval Mediæval NNP 42759 4425 4 Theory Theory NNP 42759 4425 5 _ _ NNP 42759 4425 6 Another another DT 42759 4425 7 exchange exchange NN 42759 4425 8 - - HYPH 42759 4425 9 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4425 10 theory theory NN 42759 4425 11 which which WDT 42759 4425 12 turns turn VBZ 42759 4425 13 upon upon IN 42759 4425 14 the the DT 42759 4425 15 concept concept NN 42759 4425 16 of of IN 42759 4425 17 value value NN 42759 4425 18 is be VBZ 42759 4425 19 that that DT 42759 4425 20 found find VBN 42759 4425 21 in in IN 42759 4425 22 the the DT 42759 4425 23 pages page NNS 42759 4425 24 of of IN 42759 4425 25 the the DT 42759 4425 26 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 4425 27 canonists canonist NNS 42759 4425 28 and and CC 42759 4425 29 theologians theologian NNS 42759 4425 30 . . . 42759 4426 1 But but CC 42759 4426 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4426 3 interprets interpret VBZ 42759 4426 4 value value NN 42759 4426 5 in in IN 42759 4426 6 a a DT 42759 4426 7 different different JJ 42759 4426 8 sense sense NN 42759 4426 9 from from IN 42759 4426 10 that that DT 42759 4426 11 which which WDT 42759 4426 12 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4426 13 have have VBP 42759 4426 14 just just RB 42759 4426 15 considered consider VBN 42759 4426 16 . . . 42759 4427 1 As as IN 42759 4427 2 the the DT 42759 4427 3 measure measure NN 42759 4427 4 of of IN 42759 4427 5 exchange exchange NN 42759 4427 6 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4427 7 the the DT 42759 4427 8 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 4427 9 theory theory NN 42759 4427 10 takes take VBZ 42759 4427 11 objective objective JJ 42759 4427 12 value value NN 42759 4427 13 , , , 42759 4427 14 or or CC 42759 4427 15 true true JJ 42759 4427 16 value value NN 42759 4427 17 . . . 42759 4428 1 However however RB 42759 4428 2 , , , 42759 4428 3 the the DT 42759 4428 4 proponents proponent NNS 42759 4428 5 of of IN 42759 4428 6 this this DT 42759 4428 7 view view NN 42759 4428 8 did do VBD 42759 4428 9 not not RB 42759 4428 10 formally formally RB 42759 4428 11 apply apply VB 42759 4428 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4428 13 to to TO 42759 4428 14 wage wage VB 42759 4428 15 contracts contract NNS 42759 4428 16 , , , 42759 4428 17 nor nor CC 42759 4428 18 did do VBD 42759 4428 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4428 20 discuss discuss VB 42759 4428 21 systematically systematically RB 42759 4428 22 the the DT 42759 4428 23 question question NN 42759 4428 24 of of IN 42759 4428 25 just just RB 42759 4428 26 wages wage NNS 42759 4428 27 . . . 42759 4429 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4429 2 were be VBD 42759 4429 3 not not RB 42759 4429 4 called call VBN 42759 4429 5 upon upon IN 42759 4429 6 to to TO 42759 4429 7 do do VB 42759 4429 8 this this DT 42759 4429 9 ; ; : 42759 4429 10 for for IN 42759 4429 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4429 12 were be VBD 42759 4429 13 not not RB 42759 4429 14 confronted confront VBN 42759 4429 15 by by IN 42759 4429 16 any any DT 42759 4429 17 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4429 18 class class NN 42759 4429 19 of of IN 42759 4429 20 wage wage NN 42759 4429 21 earners earner NNS 42759 4429 22 . . . 42759 4430 1 In in IN 42759 4430 2 the the DT 42759 4430 3 country country NN 42759 4430 4 the the DT 42759 4430 5 number number NN 42759 4430 6 of of IN 42759 4430 7 persons person NNS 42759 4430 8 who who WP 42759 4430 9 got get VBD 42759 4430 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4430 11 living live VBG 42759 4430 12 exclusively exclusively RB 42759 4430 13 as as IN 42759 4430 14 employés employés NNP 42759 4430 15 was be VBD 42759 4430 16 extremely extremely RB 42759 4430 17 small small JJ 42759 4430 18 , , , 42759 4430 19 while while IN 42759 4430 20 in in IN 42759 4430 21 the the DT 42759 4430 22 towns town NNS 42759 4430 23 the the DT 42759 4430 24 working working NN 42759 4430 25 class class NN 42759 4430 26 was be VBD 42759 4430 27 composed compose VBN 42759 4430 28 of of IN 42759 4430 29 independent independent JJ 42759 4430 30 producers producer NNS 42759 4430 31 who who WP 42759 4430 32 sold sell VBD 42759 4430 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4430 34 wares ware NNS 42759 4430 35 instead instead RB 42759 4430 36 of of IN 42759 4430 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4430 38 labour labour NN 42759 4430 39 . . . 42759 4431 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4431 2 218 218 CD 42759 4431 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4431 4 The the DT 42759 4431 5 question question NN 42759 4431 6 of of IN 42759 4431 7 fair fair JJ 42759 4431 8 compensation compensation NN 42759 4431 9 for for IN 42759 4431 10 the the DT 42759 4431 11 town town NN 42759 4431 12 workers worker NNS 42759 4431 13 was be VBD 42759 4431 14 , , , 42759 4431 15 therefore therefore RB 42759 4431 16 , , , 42759 4431 17 the the DT 42759 4431 18 question question NN 42759 4431 19 of of IN 42759 4431 20 a a DT 42759 4431 21 fair fair JJ 42759 4431 22 price price NN 42759 4431 23 for for IN 42759 4431 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4431 25 products product NNS 42759 4431 26 . . . 42759 4432 1 The the DT 42759 4432 2 latter latter JJ 42759 4432 3 question question NN 42759 4432 4 was be VBD 42759 4432 5 discussed discuss VBN 42759 4432 6 by by IN 42759 4432 7 the the DT 42759 4432 8 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 4432 9 writers writer NNS 42759 4432 10 formally formally RB 42759 4432 11 , , , 42759 4432 12 and and CC 42759 4432 13 in in IN 42759 4432 14 great great JJ 42759 4432 15 detail detail NN 42759 4432 16 . . . 42759 4433 1 Things thing NNS 42759 4433 2 exchanged exchange VBD 42759 4433 3 should should MD 42759 4433 4 have have VB 42759 4433 5 equal equal JJ 42759 4433 6 values value NNS 42759 4433 7 , , , 42759 4433 8 and and CC 42759 4433 9 commodities commodity NNS 42759 4433 10 should should MD 42759 4433 11 always always RB 42759 4433 12 sell sell VB 42759 4433 13 for for IN 42759 4433 14 the the DT 42759 4433 15 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4433 16 of of IN 42759 4433 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4433 18 values value NNS 42759 4433 19 . . . 42759 4434 1 By by IN 42759 4434 2 what what WDT 42759 4434 3 rule rule NN 42759 4434 4 was be VBD 42759 4434 5 equality equality NN 42759 4434 6 to to TO 42759 4434 7 be be VB 42759 4434 8 measured measure VBN 42759 4434 9 and and CC 42759 4434 10 value value NN 42759 4434 11 determined determine VBN 42759 4434 12 ? ? . 42759 4435 1 Not not RB 42759 4435 2 by by IN 42759 4435 3 the the DT 42759 4435 4 subjective subjective JJ 42759 4435 5 appreciations appreciation NNS 42759 4435 6 of of IN 42759 4435 7 the the DT 42759 4435 8 exchangers exchanger NNS 42759 4435 9 , , , 42759 4435 10 for for IN 42759 4435 11 these these DT 42759 4435 12 would would MD 42759 4435 13 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 4435 14 sanction sanction VB 42759 4435 15 the the DT 42759 4435 16 most most RBS 42759 4435 17 flagrant flagrant JJ 42759 4435 18 extortion extortion NN 42759 4435 19 . . . 42759 4436 1 Were be VBD 42759 4436 2 no no DT 42759 4436 3 other other JJ 42759 4436 4 help help NN 42759 4436 5 available available JJ 42759 4436 6 , , , 42759 4436 7 the the DT 42759 4436 8 starving starve VBG 42759 4436 9 man man NN 42759 4436 10 would would MD 42759 4436 11 give give VB 42759 4436 12 all all DT 42759 4436 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4436 14 possessed possess VBD 42759 4436 15 for for IN 42759 4436 16 a a DT 42759 4436 17 loaf loaf NN 42759 4436 18 of of IN 42759 4436 19 bread bread NN 42759 4436 20 . . . 42759 4437 1 The the DT 42759 4437 2 unscrupulous unscrupulous JJ 42759 4437 3 speculator speculator NN 42759 4437 4 could could MD 42759 4437 5 monopolise monopolise VB 42759 4437 6 the the DT 42759 4437 7 supply supply NN 42759 4437 8 of of IN 42759 4437 9 foodstuffs foodstuff NNS 42759 4437 10 , , , 42759 4437 11 and and CC 42759 4437 12 give give VB 42759 4437 13 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4437 14 an an DT 42759 4437 15 exorbitantly exorbitantly RB 42759 4437 16 high high JJ 42759 4437 17 value value NN 42759 4437 18 which which WDT 42759 4437 19 purchasers purchaser NNS 42759 4437 20 would would MD 42759 4437 21 accept accept VB 42759 4437 22 and and CC 42759 4437 23 pay pay VB 42759 4437 24 for for IN 42759 4437 25 rather rather RB 42759 4437 26 than than IN 42759 4437 27 go go VB 42759 4437 28 hungry hungry JJ 42759 4437 29 . . . 42759 4438 1 Hence hence RB 42759 4438 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4438 3 find find VBP 42759 4438 4 the the DT 42759 4438 5 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 4438 6 writers writer NNS 42759 4438 7 seeking seek VBG 42759 4438 8 a a DT 42759 4438 9 standard standard NN 42759 4438 10 of of IN 42759 4438 11 _ _ NNP 42759 4438 12 objective objective NN 42759 4438 13 _ _ NNP 42759 4438 14 value value NN 42759 4438 15 which which WDT 42759 4438 16 should should MD 42759 4438 17 attach attach VB 42759 4438 18 to to IN 42759 4438 19 the the DT 42759 4438 20 commodity commodity NN 42759 4438 21 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 4438 22 , , , 42759 4438 23 not not RB 42759 4438 24 to to IN 42759 4438 25 the the DT 42759 4438 26 varying varying NN 42759 4438 27 opinions opinion NNS 42759 4438 28 of of IN 42759 4438 29 buyers buyer NNS 42759 4438 30 and and CC 42759 4438 31 sellers seller NNS 42759 4438 32 . . . 42759 4439 1 In in IN 42759 4439 2 the the DT 42759 4439 3 thirteenth thirteenth JJ 42759 4439 4 century century NN 42759 4439 5 Albertus Albertus NNP 42759 4439 6 Magnus[219 Magnus[219 NNP 42759 4439 7 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4439 8 and and CC 42759 4439 9 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 4439 10 Aquinas[220 Aquinas[220 NNP 42759 4439 11 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4439 12 declared declare VBD 42759 4439 13 that that IN 42759 4439 14 the the DT 42759 4439 15 proper proper JJ 42759 4439 16 standard standard NN 42759 4439 17 was be VBD 42759 4439 18 to to TO 42759 4439 19 be be VB 42759 4439 20 found find VBN 42759 4439 21 in in IN 42759 4439 22 labour labour NN 42759 4439 23 . . . 42759 4440 1 A a DT 42759 4440 2 house house NN 42759 4440 3 is be VBZ 42759 4440 4 worth worth JJ 42759 4440 5 as as IN 42759 4440 6 many many JJ 42759 4440 7 shoes shoe NNS 42759 4440 8 as as IN 42759 4440 9 the the DT 42759 4440 10 labour labour NN 42759 4440 11 embodied embody VBD 42759 4440 12 in in IN 42759 4440 13 the the DT 42759 4440 14 latter latter NN 42759 4440 15 is be VBZ 42759 4440 16 contained contain VBN 42759 4440 17 in in IN 42759 4440 18 the the DT 42759 4440 19 labour labour NN 42759 4440 20 embodied embody VBN 42759 4440 21 in in IN 42759 4440 22 the the DT 42759 4440 23 former former JJ 42759 4440 24 . . . 42759 4441 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4441 2 is be VBZ 42759 4441 3 worthy worthy JJ 42759 4441 4 of of IN 42759 4441 5 note note NN 42759 4441 6 that that IN 42759 4441 7 the the DT 42759 4441 8 diagram diagram NN 42759 4441 9 which which WDT 42759 4441 10 Albertus Albertus NNP 42759 4441 11 Magnus Magnus NNP 42759 4441 12 presents present VBZ 42759 4441 13 to to TO 42759 4441 14 illustrate illustrate VB 42759 4441 15 this this DT 42759 4441 16 formula formula NN 42759 4441 17 of of IN 42759 4441 18 value value NN 42759 4441 19 and and CC 42759 4441 20 exchange exchange NN 42759 4441 21 had have VBD 42759 4441 22 been be VBN 42759 4441 23 used use VBN 42759 4441 24 centuries century NNS 42759 4441 25 before before RB 42759 4441 26 by by IN 42759 4441 27 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 42759 4441 28 . . . 42759 4442 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4442 2 is be VBZ 42759 4442 3 likewise likewise RB 42759 4442 4 noteworthy noteworthy JJ 42759 4442 5 that that IN 42759 4442 6 this this DT 42759 4442 7 conception conception NN 42759 4442 8 of of IN 42759 4442 9 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4442 10 value value NN 42759 4442 11 bears bear VBZ 42759 4442 12 a a DT 42759 4442 13 striking striking JJ 42759 4442 14 resemblance resemblance NN 42759 4442 15 to to IN 42759 4442 16 the the DT 42759 4442 17 theory theory NN 42759 4442 18 of of IN 42759 4442 19 economic economic JJ 42759 4442 20 value value NN 42759 4442 21 upheld uphold VBN 42759 4442 22 by by IN 42759 4442 23 Marxian Marxian NNP 42759 4442 24 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 4442 25 . . . 42759 4443 1 However however RB 42759 4443 2 , , , 42759 4443 3 neither neither CC 42759 4443 4 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 42759 4443 5 nor nor CC 42759 4443 6 the the DT 42759 4443 7 Schoolmen Schoolmen NNP 42759 4443 8 asserted assert VBD 42759 4443 9 that that IN 42759 4443 10 all all DT 42759 4443 11 kinds kind NNS 42759 4443 12 of of IN 42759 4443 13 labour labour NN 42759 4443 14 had have VBD 42759 4443 15 equal equal JJ 42759 4443 16 value value NN 42759 4443 17 . . . 42759 4444 1 Now now RB 42759 4444 2 this this DT 42759 4444 3 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 4444 4 labour labour NN 42759 4444 5 - - HYPH 42759 4444 6 measure measure NN 42759 4444 7 of of IN 42759 4444 8 value value NN 42759 4444 9 could could MD 42759 4444 10 be be VB 42759 4444 11 readily readily RB 42759 4444 12 applied apply VBN 42759 4444 13 only only RB 42759 4444 14 to to IN 42759 4444 15 cases case NNS 42759 4444 16 of of IN 42759 4444 17 barter barter NN 42759 4444 18 , , , 42759 4444 19 and and CC 42759 4444 20 even even RB 42759 4444 21 then then RB 42759 4444 22 only only RB 42759 4444 23 when when WRB 42759 4444 24 the the DT 42759 4444 25 value value NN 42759 4444 26 of of IN 42759 4444 27 different different JJ 42759 4444 28 kinds kind NNS 42759 4444 29 of of IN 42759 4444 30 labour labour NN 42759 4444 31 had have VBD 42759 4444 32 already already RB 42759 4444 33 been be VBN 42759 4444 34 determined determine VBN 42759 4444 35 by by IN 42759 4444 36 some some DT 42759 4444 37 other other JJ 42759 4444 38 standard standard NN 42759 4444 39 . . . 42759 4445 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 42759 4445 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4445 3 find find VBP 42759 4445 4 the the DT 42759 4445 5 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 4445 6 writers writer NNS 42759 4445 7 expounding expound VBG 42759 4445 8 and and CC 42759 4445 9 defending defend VBG 42759 4445 10 a a DT 42759 4445 11 more more RBR 42759 4445 12 general general JJ 42759 4445 13 interpretation interpretation NN 42759 4445 14 of of IN 42759 4445 15 objective objective JJ 42759 4445 16 or or CC 42759 4445 17 true true JJ 42759 4445 18 value value NN 42759 4445 19 . . . 42759 4446 1 This this DT 42759 4446 2 was be VBD 42759 4446 3 the the DT 42759 4446 4 concept concept NN 42759 4446 5 of of IN 42759 4446 6 normal normal JJ 42759 4446 7 value value NN 42759 4446 8 ; ; : 42759 4446 9 that that RB 42759 4446 10 is is RB 42759 4446 11 , , , 42759 4446 12 the the DT 42759 4446 13 average average JJ 42759 4446 14 or or CC 42759 4446 15 medium medium JJ 42759 4446 16 amount amount NN 42759 4446 17 of of IN 42759 4446 18 utility utility NN 42759 4446 19 attributed attribute VBN 42759 4446 20 to to IN 42759 4446 21 goods good NNS 42759 4446 22 in in IN 42759 4446 23 the the DT 42759 4446 24 average average JJ 42759 4446 25 conditions condition NNS 42759 4446 26 of of IN 42759 4446 27 life life NN 42759 4446 28 and and CC 42759 4446 29 exchange exchange NN 42759 4446 30 . . . 42759 4447 1 On on IN 42759 4447 2 the the DT 42759 4447 3 one one CD 42759 4447 4 hand hand NN 42759 4447 5 , , , 42759 4447 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4447 7 avoided avoid VBD 42759 4447 8 the the DT 42759 4447 9 excesses excess NNS 42759 4447 10 and and CC 42759 4447 11 the the DT 42759 4447 12 arbitrariness arbitrariness NN 42759 4447 13 of of IN 42759 4447 14 individual individual JJ 42759 4447 15 estimates estimate NNS 42759 4447 16 ; ; : 42759 4447 17 on on IN 42759 4447 18 the the DT 42759 4447 19 other other JJ 42759 4447 20 hand hand NN 42759 4447 21 , , , 42759 4447 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4447 23 did do VBD 42759 4447 24 not not RB 42759 4447 25 attribute attribute VB 42759 4447 26 to to TO 42759 4447 27 value value VB 42759 4447 28 the the DT 42759 4447 29 characters character NNS 42759 4447 30 of of IN 42759 4447 31 immutability immutability NN 42759 4447 32 and and CC 42759 4447 33 rigidity rigidity NN 42759 4447 34 . . . 42759 4448 1 Contrary contrary JJ 42759 4448 2 to to IN 42759 4448 3 the the DT 42759 4448 4 assumptions assumption NNS 42759 4448 5 of of IN 42759 4448 6 some some DT 42759 4448 7 modern modern JJ 42759 4448 8 writers writer NNS 42759 4448 9 , , , 42759 4448 10 the the DT 42759 4448 11 Schoolmen Schoolmen NNP 42759 4448 12 never never RB 42759 4448 13 said say VBD 42759 4448 14 that that IN 42759 4448 15 value value NN 42759 4448 16 was be VBD 42759 4448 17 something something NN 42759 4448 18 as as RB 42759 4448 19 fixedly fixedly RB 42759 4448 20 inherent inherent JJ 42759 4448 21 in in IN 42759 4448 22 goods good NNS 42759 4448 23 as as IN 42759 4448 24 physical physical JJ 42759 4448 25 and and CC 42759 4448 26 chemical chemical JJ 42759 4448 27 qualities quality NNS 42759 4448 28 . . . 42759 4449 1 When when WRB 42759 4449 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4449 3 spoke speak VBD 42759 4449 4 of of IN 42759 4449 5 " " `` 42759 4449 6 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 4449 7 " " '' 42759 4449 8 value value NN 42759 4449 9 , , , 42759 4449 10 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4449 11 had have VBD 42759 4449 12 in in IN 42759 4449 13 mind mind NN 42759 4449 14 merely merely RB 42759 4449 15 the the DT 42759 4449 16 constant constant JJ 42759 4449 17 capacity capacity NN 42759 4449 18 of of IN 42759 4449 19 certain certain JJ 42759 4449 20 commodities commodity NNS 42759 4449 21 to to TO 42759 4449 22 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 4449 23 human human JJ 42759 4449 24 wants want NNS 42759 4449 25 . . . 42759 4450 1 Even even RB 42759 4450 2 to to IN 42759 4450 3 - - HYPH 42759 4450 4 day day NN 42759 4450 5 bread bread NN 42759 4450 6 has have VBZ 42759 4450 7 always always RB 42759 4450 8 the the DT 42759 4450 9 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 4450 10 potency potency NN 42759 4450 11 of of IN 42759 4450 12 alleviating alleviate VBG 42759 4450 13 hunger hunger NN 42759 4450 14 , , , 42759 4450 15 regardless regardless RB 42759 4450 16 of of IN 42759 4450 17 all all PDT 42759 4450 18 the the DT 42759 4450 19 fluctuations fluctuation NNS 42759 4450 20 of of IN 42759 4450 21 human human JJ 42759 4450 22 appraisement appraisement NN 42759 4450 23 . . . 42759 4451 1 The the DT 42759 4451 2 objectivity objectivity NN 42759 4451 3 that that IN 42759 4451 4 the the DT 42759 4451 5 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 4451 6 writers writer NNS 42759 4451 7 ascribed ascribe VBN 42759 4451 8 to to IN 42759 4451 9 value value NN 42759 4451 10 was be VBD 42759 4451 11 relative relative JJ 42759 4451 12 . . . 42759 4452 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4452 2 assumed assume VBD 42759 4452 3 normal normal JJ 42759 4452 4 conditions condition NNS 42759 4452 5 as as IN 42759 4452 6 against against IN 42759 4452 7 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 4452 8 conditions condition NNS 42759 4452 9 . . . 42759 4453 1 To to TO 42759 4453 2 say say VB 42759 4453 3 that that DT 42759 4453 4 value value NN 42759 4453 5 was be VBD 42759 4453 6 objective objective JJ 42759 4453 7 merely merely RB 42759 4453 8 meant mean VBD 42759 4453 9 that that IN 42759 4453 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4453 11 was be VBD 42759 4453 12 not not RB 42759 4453 13 wholly wholly RB 42759 4453 14 determined determine VBN 42759 4453 15 by by IN 42759 4453 16 the the DT 42759 4453 17 interplay interplay NN 42759 4453 18 of of IN 42759 4453 19 supply supply NN 42759 4453 20 and and CC 42759 4453 21 demand demand NN 42759 4453 22 , , , 42759 4453 23 but but CC 42759 4453 24 was be VBD 42759 4453 25 based base VBN 42759 4453 26 upon upon IN 42759 4453 27 the the DT 42759 4453 28 stable stable JJ 42759 4453 29 and and CC 42759 4453 30 universally universally RB 42759 4453 31 recognised recognise VBN 42759 4453 32 use use NN 42759 4453 33 - - HYPH 42759 4453 34 qualities quality NNS 42759 4453 35 of of IN 42759 4453 36 commodities commodity NNS 42759 4453 37 in in IN 42759 4453 38 a a DT 42759 4453 39 society society NN 42759 4453 40 where where WRB 42759 4453 41 desires desire NNS 42759 4453 42 , , , 42759 4453 43 needs need NNS 42759 4453 44 , , , 42759 4453 45 and and CC 42759 4453 46 tastes taste NNS 42759 4453 47 were be VBD 42759 4453 48 simple simple JJ 42759 4453 49 and and CC 42759 4453 50 fairly fairly RB 42759 4453 51 constant constant JJ 42759 4453 52 from from IN 42759 4453 53 one one CD 42759 4453 54 generation generation NN 42759 4453 55 to to IN 42759 4453 56 another another DT 42759 4453 57 . . . 42759 4454 1 How how WRB 42759 4454 2 or or CC 42759 4454 3 where where WRB 42759 4454 4 was be VBD 42759 4454 5 this this DT 42759 4454 6 relatively relatively RB 42759 4454 7 objective objective JJ 42759 4454 8 value value NN 42759 4454 9 of of IN 42759 4454 10 goods good NNS 42759 4454 11 to to TO 42759 4454 12 find find VB 42759 4454 13 concrete concrete JJ 42759 4454 14 expression expression NN 42759 4454 15 ? ? . 42759 4455 1 In in IN 42759 4455 2 the the DT 42759 4455 3 " " `` 42759 4455 4 communis communis NN 42759 4455 5 aestimatio aestimatio RB 42759 4455 6 , , , 42759 4455 7 " " '' 42759 4455 8 or or CC 42759 4455 9 social social JJ 42759 4455 10 estimate estimate NN 42759 4455 11 , , , 42759 4455 12 declared declare VBD 42759 4455 13 the the DT 42759 4455 14 canonists canonist NNS 42759 4455 15 . . . 42759 4456 1 Objective objective JJ 42759 4456 2 value value NN 42759 4456 3 and and CC 42759 4456 4 just just JJ 42759 4456 5 price price NN 42759 4456 6 would would MD 42759 4456 7 be be VB 42759 4456 8 ascertained ascertain VBN 42759 4456 9 practically practically RB 42759 4456 10 through through IN 42759 4456 11 the the DT 42759 4456 12 judgment judgment NN 42759 4456 13 of of IN 42759 4456 14 upright upright JJ 42759 4456 15 and and CC 42759 4456 16 competent competent JJ 42759 4456 17 men man NNS 42759 4456 18 , , , 42759 4456 19 or or CC 42759 4456 20 preferably preferably RB 42759 4456 21 through through IN 42759 4456 22 legally legally RB 42759 4456 23 fixed fix VBN 42759 4456 24 prices price NNS 42759 4456 25 . . . 42759 4457 1 But but CC 42759 4457 2 neither neither CC 42759 4457 3 the the DT 42759 4457 4 social social JJ 42759 4457 5 estimate estimate NN 42759 4457 6 nor nor CC 42759 4457 7 the the DT 42759 4457 8 ordinances ordinance NNS 42759 4457 9 of of IN 42759 4457 10 lawmakers lawmaker NNS 42759 4457 11 were be VBD 42759 4457 12 authorised authorise VBN 42759 4457 13 to to TO 42759 4457 14 determine determine VB 42759 4457 15 values value NNS 42759 4457 16 and and CC 42759 4457 17 prices price NNS 42759 4457 18 arbitrarily arbitrarily RB 42759 4457 19 . . . 42759 4458 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4458 2 were be VBD 42759 4458 3 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4458 4 to to TO 42759 4458 5 take take VB 42759 4458 6 into into IN 42759 4458 7 account account NN 42759 4458 8 certain certain JJ 42759 4458 9 objective objective JJ 42759 4458 10 factors factor NNS 42759 4458 11 . . . 42759 4459 1 In in IN 42759 4459 2 the the DT 42759 4459 3 thirteenth thirteenth JJ 42759 4459 4 and and CC 42759 4459 5 fourteenth fourteenth JJ 42759 4459 6 centuries century NNS 42759 4459 7 , , , 42759 4459 8 the the DT 42759 4459 9 factors factor NNS 42759 4459 10 universally universally RB 42759 4459 11 recognised recognise VBD 42759 4459 12 as as IN 42759 4459 13 determinative determinative JJ 42759 4459 14 were be VBD 42759 4459 15 the the DT 42759 4459 16 utility utility NN 42759 4459 17 or or CC 42759 4459 18 use use NN 42759 4459 19 - - HYPH 42759 4459 20 qualities quality NNS 42759 4459 21 of of IN 42759 4459 22 goods good NNS 42759 4459 23 , , , 42759 4459 24 but but CC 42759 4459 25 especially especially RB 42759 4459 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4459 27 cost cost NN 42759 4459 28 of of IN 42759 4459 29 production production NN 42759 4459 30 . . . 42759 4460 1 Later later RB 42759 4460 2 on on RB 42759 4460 3 , , , 42759 4460 4 in in IN 42759 4460 5 the the DT 42759 4460 6 sixteenth sixteenth JJ 42759 4460 7 and and CC 42759 4460 8 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 42759 4460 9 centuries century NNS 42759 4460 10 , , , 42759 4460 11 risk risk NN 42759 4460 12 and and CC 42759 4460 13 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 4460 14 were be VBD 42759 4460 15 given give VBN 42759 4460 16 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4460 17 prominence prominence NN 42759 4460 18 as as IN 42759 4460 19 value value NN 42759 4460 20 determinants determinant NNS 42759 4460 21 . . . 42759 4461 1 Now now RB 42759 4461 2 cost cost NN 42759 4461 3 of of IN 42759 4461 4 production production NN 42759 4461 5 in in IN 42759 4461 6 the the DT 42759 4461 7 Middle Middle NNP 42759 4461 8 Ages Ages NNPS 42759 4461 9 was be VBD 42759 4461 10 mainly mainly RB 42759 4461 11 labour labour JJ 42759 4461 12 cost cost NN 42759 4461 13 ; ; : 42759 4461 14 hence hence RB 42759 4461 15 the the DT 42759 4461 16 standard standard NN 42759 4461 17 of of IN 42759 4461 18 value value NN 42759 4461 19 was be VBD 42759 4461 20 chiefly chiefly RB 42759 4461 21 a a DT 42759 4461 22 labour labour JJ 42759 4461 23 standard standard NN 42759 4461 24 . . . 42759 4462 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4462 2 , , , 42759 4462 3 this this DT 42759 4462 4 labour labour JJ 42759 4462 5 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4462 6 of of IN 42759 4462 7 true true JJ 42759 4462 8 value value NN 42759 4462 9 and and CC 42759 4462 10 equality equality NN 42759 4462 11 in in IN 42759 4462 12 exchanges exchange NNS 42759 4462 13 was be VBD 42759 4462 14 strongly strongly RB 42759 4462 15 reinforced reinforce VBN 42759 4462 16 by by IN 42759 4462 17 another another DT 42759 4462 18 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 4462 19 principle principle NN 42759 4462 20 , , , 42759 4462 21 according accord VBG 42759 4462 22 to to IN 42759 4462 23 which which WDT 42759 4462 24 labour labour NN 42759 4462 25 was be VBD 42759 4462 26 the the DT 42759 4462 27 supreme supreme NN 42759 4462 28 if if IN 42759 4462 29 not not RB 42759 4462 30 the the DT 42759 4462 31 only only JJ 42759 4462 32 just just RB 42759 4462 33 title title NN 42759 4462 34 to to IN 42759 4462 35 rewards reward NNS 42759 4462 36 . . . 42759 4463 1 How how WRB 42759 4463 2 was be VBD 42759 4463 3 labour labour JJ 42759 4463 4 cost cost NN 42759 4463 5 to to TO 42759 4463 6 be be VB 42759 4463 7 measured measure VBN 42759 4463 8 , , , 42759 4463 9 and and CC 42759 4463 10 the the DT 42759 4463 11 different different JJ 42759 4463 12 kinds kind NNS 42759 4463 13 of of IN 42759 4463 14 labour labour NN 42759 4463 15 evaluated evaluate VBN 42759 4463 16 ? ? . 42759 4464 1 By by IN 42759 4464 2 the the DT 42759 4464 3 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4464 4 and and CC 42759 4464 5 customary customary JJ 42759 4464 6 expenditures expenditure NNS 42759 4464 7 of of IN 42759 4464 8 the the DT 42759 4464 9 class class NN 42759 4464 10 to to TO 42759 4464 11 which which WDT 42759 4464 12 the the DT 42759 4464 13 labourer labourer NN 42759 4464 14 belonged belong VBD 42759 4464 15 . . . 42759 4465 1 Mediæval mediæval JJ 42759 4465 2 society society NN 42759 4465 3 was be VBD 42759 4465 4 composed compose VBN 42759 4465 5 of of IN 42759 4465 6 a a DT 42759 4465 7 few few JJ 42759 4465 8 definite definite JJ 42759 4465 9 , , , 42759 4465 10 easily easily RB 42759 4465 11 recognised recognise VBN 42759 4465 12 , , , 42759 4465 13 and and CC 42759 4465 14 relatively relatively RB 42759 4465 15 fixed fix VBN 42759 4465 16 orders order NNS 42759 4465 17 or or CC 42759 4465 18 grades grade NNS 42759 4465 19 , , , 42759 4465 20 each each DT 42759 4465 21 of of IN 42759 4465 22 which which WDT 42759 4465 23 had have VBD 42759 4465 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4465 25 own own JJ 42759 4465 26 function function NN 42759 4465 27 in in IN 42759 4465 28 the the DT 42759 4465 29 social social JJ 42759 4465 30 hierarchy hierarchy NN 42759 4465 31 , , , 42759 4465 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4465 33 own own JJ 42759 4465 34 standard standard NN 42759 4465 35 of of IN 42759 4465 36 living living NN 42759 4465 37 , , , 42759 4465 38 and and CC 42759 4465 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4465 40 moral moral JJ 42759 4465 41 right right NN 42759 4465 42 to to IN 42759 4465 43 a a DT 42759 4465 44 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4465 45 in in IN 42759 4465 46 accordance accordance NN 42759 4465 47 with with IN 42759 4465 48 that that DT 42759 4465 49 standard standard NN 42759 4465 50 . . . 42759 4466 1 Like like IN 42759 4466 2 the the DT 42759 4466 3 members member NNS 42759 4466 4 of of IN 42759 4466 5 the the DT 42759 4466 6 other other JJ 42759 4466 7 orders order NNS 42759 4466 8 , , , 42759 4466 9 the the DT 42759 4466 10 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4466 11 were be VBD 42759 4466 12 conceived conceive VBN 42759 4466 13 as as IN 42759 4466 14 entitled entitle VBN 42759 4466 15 to to TO 42759 4466 16 live live VB 42759 4466 17 in in IN 42759 4466 18 conformity conformity NN 42759 4466 19 with with IN 42759 4466 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4466 21 customary customary JJ 42759 4466 22 class class NN 42759 4466 23 - - HYPH 42759 4466 24 requirements requirement NNS 42759 4466 25 . . . 42759 4467 1 From from IN 42759 4467 2 this this DT 42759 4467 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4467 4 followed follow VBD 42759 4467 5 that that IN 42759 4467 6 the the DT 42759 4467 7 needs need NNS 42759 4467 8 of of IN 42759 4467 9 the the DT 42759 4467 10 labourer labourer NN 42759 4467 11 became become VBD 42759 4467 12 the the DT 42759 4467 13 main main JJ 42759 4467 14 determinant determinant NN 42759 4467 15 of of IN 42759 4467 16 the the DT 42759 4467 17 cost cost NN 42759 4467 18 of of IN 42759 4467 19 production production NN 42759 4467 20 , , , 42759 4467 21 and and CC 42759 4467 22 of of IN 42759 4467 23 the the DT 42759 4467 24 value value NN 42759 4467 25 and and CC 42759 4467 26 just just JJ 42759 4467 27 price price NN 42759 4467 28 of of IN 42759 4467 29 goods good NNS 42759 4467 30 . . . 42759 4468 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 4468 2 as as IN 42759 4468 3 the the DT 42759 4468 4 standards standard NNS 42759 4468 5 of of IN 42759 4468 6 living living NN 42759 4468 7 of of IN 42759 4468 8 the the DT 42759 4468 9 various various JJ 42759 4468 10 divisions division NNS 42759 4468 11 of of IN 42759 4468 12 the the DT 42759 4468 13 workers worker NNS 42759 4468 14 were be VBD 42759 4468 15 fixed fix VBN 42759 4468 16 by by IN 42759 4468 17 custom custom NN 42759 4468 18 , , , 42759 4468 19 and and CC 42759 4468 20 limited limit VBN 42759 4468 21 by by IN 42759 4468 22 the the DT 42759 4468 23 restricted restrict VBN 42759 4468 24 possibilities possibility NNS 42759 4468 25 of of IN 42759 4468 26 the the DT 42759 4468 27 time time NN 42759 4468 28 , , , 42759 4468 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4468 30 afforded afford VBD 42759 4468 31 a a DT 42759 4468 32 fairly fairly RB 42759 4468 33 definite definite JJ 42759 4468 34 measure measure NN 42759 4468 35 of of IN 42759 4468 36 value value NN 42759 4468 37 and and CC 42759 4468 38 price,--much price,--much NN 42759 4468 39 more more RBR 42759 4468 40 definite definite JJ 42759 4468 41 than than IN 42759 4468 42 the the DT 42759 4468 43 standard standard NN 42759 4468 44 of of IN 42759 4468 45 general general JJ 42759 4468 46 utility utility NN 42759 4468 47 . . . 42759 4469 1 To to IN 42759 4469 2 Langenstein Langenstein NNP 42759 4469 3 , , , 42759 4469 4 vice vice NN 42759 4469 5 chancellor chancellor NN 42759 4469 6 of of IN 42759 4469 7 the the DT 42759 4469 8 University University NNP 42759 4469 9 of of IN 42759 4469 10 Paris Paris NNP 42759 4469 11 in in IN 42759 4469 12 the the DT 42759 4469 13 latter latter JJ 42759 4469 14 half half NN 42759 4469 15 of of IN 42759 4469 16 the the DT 42759 4469 17 fourteenth fourteenth JJ 42759 4469 18 century century NN 42759 4469 19 , , , 42759 4469 20 the the DT 42759 4469 21 matter matter NN 42759 4469 22 seemed seem VBD 42759 4469 23 quite quite RB 42759 4469 24 simple simple JJ 42759 4469 25 ; ; : 42759 4469 26 for for IN 42759 4469 27 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4469 28 declared declare VBD 42759 4469 29 that that IN 42759 4469 30 every every DT 42759 4469 31 one one NN 42759 4469 32 could could MD 42759 4469 33 determine determine VB 42759 4469 34 for for IN 42759 4469 35 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4469 36 the the DT 42759 4469 37 just just JJ 42759 4469 38 price price NN 42759 4469 39 of of IN 42759 4469 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4469 41 wares ware NNS 42759 4469 42 by by IN 42759 4469 43 referring refer VBG 42759 4469 44 to to IN 42759 4469 45 the the DT 42759 4469 46 customary customary JJ 42759 4469 47 needs need NNS 42759 4469 48 of of IN 42759 4469 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4469 50 rank rank NN 42759 4469 51 of of IN 42759 4469 52 life life NN 42759 4469 53 . . . 42759 4470 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4470 2 221 221 CD 42759 4470 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4470 4 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 4470 5 , , , 42759 4470 6 class class NN 42759 4470 7 needs need NNS 42759 4470 8 are be VBP 42759 4470 9 not not RB 42759 4470 10 and and CC 42759 4470 11 can can MD 42759 4470 12 not not RB 42759 4470 13 be be VB 42759 4470 14 a a DT 42759 4470 15 standard standard NN 42759 4470 16 of of IN 42759 4470 17 exchange exchange NN 42759 4470 18 - - HYPH 42759 4470 19 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4470 20 . . . 42759 4471 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4471 2 can can MD 42759 4471 3 not not RB 42759 4471 4 become become VB 42759 4471 5 a a DT 42759 4471 6 criterion criterion NN 42759 4471 7 of of IN 42759 4471 8 equality equality NN 42759 4471 9 , , , 42759 4471 10 a a DT 42759 4471 11 common common JJ 42759 4471 12 denominator denominator NN 42759 4471 13 , , , 42759 4471 14 a a DT 42759 4471 15 third third JJ 42759 4471 16 term term NN 42759 4471 17 of of IN 42759 4471 18 comparison comparison NN 42759 4471 19 , , , 42759 4471 20 between between IN 42759 4471 21 labour labour NN 42759 4471 22 and and CC 42759 4471 23 wages wage NNS 42759 4471 24 . . . 42759 4472 1 When when WRB 42759 4472 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4472 3 say say VBP 42759 4472 4 that that IN 42759 4472 5 a a DT 42759 4472 6 given give VBN 42759 4472 7 amount amount NN 42759 4472 8 of of IN 42759 4472 9 wages wage NNS 42759 4472 10 is be VBZ 42759 4472 11 equal equal JJ 42759 4472 12 to to IN 42759 4472 13 a a DT 42759 4472 14 given give VBN 42759 4472 15 content content NN 42759 4472 16 of of IN 42759 4472 17 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4472 18 , , , 42759 4472 19 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4472 20 express express VBP 42759 4472 21 a a DT 42759 4472 22 purely purely RB 42759 4472 23 economic economic JJ 42759 4472 24 , , , 42759 4472 25 positive positive JJ 42759 4472 26 , , , 42759 4472 27 and and CC 42759 4472 28 mathematical mathematical JJ 42759 4472 29 relation relation NN 42759 4472 30 : : : 42759 4472 31 when when WRB 42759 4472 32 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4472 33 say say VBP 42759 4472 34 that that IN 42759 4472 35 a a DT 42759 4472 36 given give VBN 42759 4472 37 amount amount NN 42759 4472 38 of of IN 42759 4472 39 labour labour NN 42759 4472 40 is be VBZ 42759 4472 41 equal equal JJ 42759 4472 42 to to IN 42759 4472 43 a a DT 42759 4472 44 given give VBN 42759 4472 45 content content NN 42759 4472 46 of of IN 42759 4472 47 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4472 48 , , , 42759 4472 49 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4472 50 are be VBP 42759 4472 51 either either CC 42759 4472 52 talking talk VBG 42759 4472 53 nonsense nonsense NN 42759 4472 54 or or CC 42759 4472 55 expressing express VBG 42759 4472 56 a a DT 42759 4472 57 purely purely RB 42759 4472 58 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4472 59 relation relation NN 42759 4472 60 ; ; : 42759 4472 61 that that RB 42759 4472 62 is is RB 42759 4472 63 , , , 42759 4472 64 declaring declare VBG 42759 4472 65 that that IN 42759 4472 66 this this DT 42759 4472 67 labour labour NN 42759 4472 68 _ _ NNP 42759 4472 69 ought ought MD 42759 4472 70 to to TO 42759 4472 71 _ _ NNP 42759 4472 72 equal equal VB 42759 4472 73 this this DT 42759 4472 74 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4472 75 . . . 42759 4473 1 In in IN 42759 4473 2 other other JJ 42759 4473 3 words word NNS 42759 4473 4 , , , 42759 4473 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4473 6 are be VBP 42759 4473 7 introducing introduce VBG 42759 4473 8 a a DT 42759 4473 9 fourth fourth JJ 42759 4473 10 term term NN 42759 4473 11 of of IN 42759 4473 12 comparison comparison NN 42759 4473 13 ; ; : 42759 4473 14 namely namely RB 42759 4473 15 , , , 42759 4473 16 the the DT 42759 4473 17 moral moral JJ 42759 4473 18 worth worth JJ 42759 4473 19 or or CC 42759 4473 20 personal personal JJ 42759 4473 21 dignity dignity NN 42759 4473 22 of of IN 42759 4473 23 the the DT 42759 4473 24 labourer labourer NN 42759 4473 25 . . . 42759 4474 1 Thus thus RB 42759 4474 2 , , , 42759 4474 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4474 4 have have VBP 42759 4474 5 not not RB 42759 4474 6 a a DT 42759 4474 7 single single JJ 42759 4474 8 and and CC 42759 4474 9 common common JJ 42759 4474 10 standard standard NN 42759 4474 11 to to TO 42759 4474 12 measure measure VB 42759 4474 13 both both DT 42759 4474 14 labour labour NN 42759 4474 15 and and CC 42759 4474 16 wages wage NNS 42759 4474 17 , , , 42759 4474 18 and and CC 42759 4474 19 to to TO 42759 4474 20 indicate indicate VB 42759 4474 21 a a DT 42759 4474 22 relation relation NN 42759 4474 23 of of IN 42759 4474 24 equality equality NN 42759 4474 25 between between IN 42759 4474 26 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4474 27 . . . 42759 4475 1 While while IN 42759 4475 2 class class NN 42759 4475 3 needs need NNS 42759 4475 4 directly directly RB 42759 4475 5 measure measure VBP 42759 4475 6 wages wage NNS 42759 4475 7 , , , 42759 4475 8 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4475 9 do do VBP 42759 4475 10 not not RB 42759 4475 11 measure measure VB 42759 4475 12 labour labour NN 42759 4475 13 , , , 42759 4475 14 either either CC 42759 4475 15 quantitatively quantitatively RB 42759 4475 16 , , , 42759 4475 17 or or CC 42759 4475 18 qualitatively qualitatively RB 42759 4475 19 , , , 42759 4475 20 or or CC 42759 4475 21 under under IN 42759 4475 22 any any DT 42759 4475 23 other other JJ 42759 4475 24 aspect aspect NN 42759 4475 25 or or CC 42759 4475 26 category category NN 42759 4475 27 . . . 42759 4476 1 Aside aside RB 42759 4476 2 from from IN 42759 4476 3 this this DT 42759 4476 4 purely purely RB 42759 4476 5 theoretical theoretical JJ 42759 4476 6 defect defect NN 42759 4476 7 , , , 42759 4476 8 the the DT 42759 4476 9 canonist canonist NN 42759 4476 10 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4476 11 of of IN 42759 4476 12 wage wage NN 42759 4476 13 justice justice NN 42759 4476 14 was be VBD 42759 4476 15 fairly fairly RB 42759 4476 16 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 4476 17 as as IN 42759 4476 18 applied apply VBN 42759 4476 19 to to IN 42759 4476 20 the the DT 42759 4476 21 conditions condition NNS 42759 4476 22 of of IN 42759 4476 23 the the DT 42759 4476 24 Middle Middle NNP 42759 4476 25 Ages Ages NNPS 42759 4476 26 . . . 42759 4477 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4477 2 assured assure VBD 42759 4477 3 to to IN 42759 4477 4 the the DT 42759 4477 5 labourer labourer NN 42759 4477 6 of of IN 42759 4477 7 that that DT 42759 4477 8 day day NN 42759 4477 9 a a DT 42759 4477 10 certain certain JJ 42759 4477 11 rude rude JJ 42759 4477 12 comfort comfort NN 42759 4477 13 , , , 42759 4477 14 and and CC 42759 4477 15 probably probably RB 42759 4477 16 as as RB 42759 4477 17 large large JJ 42759 4477 18 a a DT 42759 4477 19 proportion proportion NN 42759 4477 20 of of IN 42759 4477 21 the the DT 42759 4477 22 product product NN 42759 4477 23 of of IN 42759 4477 24 industry industry NN 42759 4477 25 as as IN 42759 4477 26 was be VBD 42759 4477 27 practically practically RB 42759 4477 28 attainable attainable JJ 42759 4477 29 . . . 42759 4478 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 4478 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4478 3 is be VBZ 42759 4478 4 not not RB 42759 4478 5 a a DT 42759 4478 6 universally universally RB 42759 4478 7 valid valid JJ 42759 4478 8 criterion criterion NN 42759 4478 9 of of IN 42759 4478 10 justice justice NN 42759 4478 11 in in IN 42759 4478 12 the the DT 42759 4478 13 matter matter NN 42759 4478 14 of of IN 42759 4478 15 wages wage NNS 42759 4478 16 ; ; : 42759 4478 17 for for IN 42759 4478 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4478 19 makes make VBZ 42759 4478 20 no no DT 42759 4478 21 provision provision NN 42759 4478 22 for for IN 42759 4478 23 those those DT 42759 4478 24 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4478 25 who who WP 42759 4478 26 deserve deserve VBP 42759 4478 27 a a DT 42759 4478 28 wage wage NN 42759 4478 29 in in IN 42759 4478 30 excess excess NN 42759 4478 31 of of IN 42759 4478 32 the the DT 42759 4478 33 cost cost NN 42759 4478 34 of of IN 42759 4478 35 living live VBG 42759 4478 36 of of IN 42759 4478 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4478 38 class class NN 42759 4478 39 ; ; : 42759 4478 40 nor nor CC 42759 4478 41 does do VBZ 42759 4478 42 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4478 43 furnish furnish VB 42759 4478 44 a a DT 42759 4478 45 principle principle NN 42759 4478 46 by by IN 42759 4478 47 which which WDT 42759 4478 48 a a DT 42759 4478 49 whole whole JJ 42759 4478 50 class class NN 42759 4478 51 of of IN 42759 4478 52 workers worker NNS 42759 4478 53 can can MD 42759 4478 54 justify justify VB 42759 4478 55 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4478 56 advance advance NN 42759 4478 57 to to IN 42759 4478 58 a a DT 42759 4478 59 higher high JJR 42759 4478 60 standard standard NN 42759 4478 61 of of IN 42759 4478 62 living living NN 42759 4478 63 . . . 42759 4479 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4479 2 is be VBZ 42759 4479 3 not not RB 42759 4479 4 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 4479 5 elastic elastic JJ 42759 4479 6 and and CC 42759 4479 7 dynamic dynamic JJ 42759 4479 8 . . . 42759 4480 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4480 2 A a DT 42759 4480 3 Modern Modern NNP 42759 4480 4 Variation Variation NNP 42759 4480 5 of of IN 42759 4480 6 the the DT 42759 4480 7 Mediæval Mediæval NNP 42759 4480 8 Theory Theory NNP 42759 4480 9 _ _ NNP 42759 4480 10 In in IN 42759 4480 11 spite spite NN 42759 4480 12 of of IN 42759 4480 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4480 14 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4480 15 impossibility impossibility NN 42759 4480 16 , , , 42759 4480 17 the the DT 42759 4480 18 concept concept NN 42759 4480 19 of of IN 42759 4480 20 exchange exchange NN 42759 4480 21 - - HYPH 42759 4480 22 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4480 23 still still RB 42759 4480 24 haunts haunt VBZ 42759 4480 25 the the DT 42759 4480 26 minds mind NNS 42759 4480 27 of of IN 42759 4480 28 certain certain JJ 42759 4480 29 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 4480 30 writers writer NNS 42759 4480 31 . . . 42759 4481 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4481 2 222 222 CD 42759 4481 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4481 4 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4481 5 still still RB 42759 4481 6 strive strive VBP 42759 4481 7 to to TO 42759 4481 8 get get VB 42759 4481 9 a a DT 42759 4481 10 formula formula NN 42759 4481 11 to to TO 42759 4481 12 express express VB 42759 4481 13 equality equality NN 42759 4481 14 between between IN 42759 4481 15 labour labour NN 42759 4481 16 and and CC 42759 4481 17 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 4481 18 . . . 42759 4482 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 42759 4482 2 the the DT 42759 4482 3 best well RBS 42759 4482 4 known know VBN 42759 4482 5 and and CC 42759 4482 6 least least RBS 42759 4482 7 vulnerable vulnerable JJ 42759 4482 8 of of IN 42759 4482 9 the the DT 42759 4482 10 attempts attempt NNS 42759 4482 11 made make VBN 42759 4482 12 along along IN 42759 4482 13 this this DT 42759 4482 14 line line NN 42759 4482 15 is be VBZ 42759 4482 16 that that DT 42759 4482 17 defended defend VBN 42759 4482 18 by by IN 42759 4482 19 Charles Charles NNP 42759 4482 20 Antoine Antoine NNP 42759 4482 21 , , , 42759 4482 22 S.J. S.J. NNP 42759 4483 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4483 2 223 223 CD 42759 4483 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4483 4 Justice Justice NNP 42759 4483 5 , , , 42759 4483 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4483 7 declares declare VBZ 42759 4483 8 , , , 42759 4483 9 demands demand VBZ 42759 4483 10 an an DT 42759 4483 11 objective objective JJ 42759 4483 12 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4483 13 between between IN 42759 4483 14 wages wage NNS 42759 4483 15 and and CC 42759 4483 16 labour labour NN 42759 4483 17 ; ; : 42759 4483 18 and and CC 42759 4483 19 objective objective JJ 42759 4483 20 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4483 21 is be VBZ 42759 4483 22 determined determine VBN 42759 4483 23 and and CC 42759 4483 24 measured measure VBN 42759 4483 25 by by IN 42759 4483 26 two two CD 42759 4483 27 factors factor NNS 42759 4483 28 . . . 42759 4484 1 The the DT 42759 4484 2 remote remote JJ 42759 4484 3 factor factor NN 42759 4484 4 is be VBZ 42759 4484 5 the the DT 42759 4484 6 cost cost NN 42759 4484 7 of of IN 42759 4484 8 decent decent JJ 42759 4484 9 living live VBG 42759 4484 10 for for IN 42759 4484 11 the the DT 42759 4484 12 labourer labourer NN 42759 4484 13 ; ; : 42759 4484 14 the the DT 42759 4484 15 proximate proximate NN 42759 4484 16 factor factor NN 42759 4484 17 is be VBZ 42759 4484 18 the the DT 42759 4484 19 economic economic JJ 42759 4484 20 value value NN 42759 4484 21 of of IN 42759 4484 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4484 23 labour labour NN 42759 4484 24 . . . 42759 4485 1 The the DT 42759 4485 2 former former JJ 42759 4485 3 describes describe VBZ 42759 4485 4 the the DT 42759 4485 5 _ _ NNP 42759 4485 6 minimum minimum NN 42759 4485 7 _ _ NNP 42759 4485 8 to to TO 42759 4485 9 which which WDT 42759 4485 10 the the DT 42759 4485 11 worker worker NN 42759 4485 12 is be VBZ 42759 4485 13 entitled entitle VBN 42759 4485 14 ; ; : 42759 4485 15 the the DT 42759 4485 16 latter latter JJ 42759 4485 17 comprises comprise VBZ 42759 4485 18 perfect perfect JJ 42759 4485 19 and and CC 42759 4485 20 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4485 21 justice justice NN 42759 4485 22 . . . 42759 4486 1 In in IN 42759 4486 2 case case NN 42759 4486 3 of of IN 42759 4486 4 conflict conflict NN 42759 4486 5 between between IN 42759 4486 6 the the DT 42759 4486 7 two two CD 42759 4486 8 factors factor NNS 42759 4486 9 , , , 42759 4486 10 the the DT 42759 4486 11 first first JJ 42759 4486 12 is be VBZ 42759 4486 13 determinative determinative JJ 42759 4486 14 of of IN 42759 4486 15 and and CC 42759 4486 16 morally morally RB 42759 4486 17 superior superior JJ 42759 4486 18 to to IN 42759 4486 19 the the DT 42759 4486 20 second second JJ 42759 4486 21 ; ; : 42759 4486 22 that that DT 42759 4486 23 is be VBZ 42759 4486 24 to to TO 42759 4486 25 say say VB 42759 4486 26 , , , 42759 4486 27 no no RB 42759 4486 28 matter matter RB 42759 4486 29 how how WRB 42759 4486 30 small small JJ 42759 4486 31 the the DT 42759 4486 32 economic economic JJ 42759 4486 33 value value NN 42759 4486 34 of of IN 42759 4486 35 labour labour NN 42759 4486 36 may may MD 42759 4486 37 _ _ NNP 42759 4486 38 seem seem VB 42759 4486 39 _ _ NNP 42759 4486 40 to to TO 42759 4486 41 be be VB 42759 4486 42 , , , 42759 4486 43 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4486 44 never never RB 42759 4486 45 can can MD 42759 4486 46 descend descend VB 42759 4486 47 below below IN 42759 4486 48 the the DT 42759 4486 49 requisites requisite NNS 42759 4486 50 of of IN 42759 4486 51 a a DT 42759 4486 52 decent decent JJ 42759 4486 53 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4486 54 . . . 42759 4487 1 Now now RB 42759 4487 2 , , , 42759 4487 3 neither neither DT 42759 4487 4 of of IN 42759 4487 5 these these DT 42759 4487 6 standards standard NNS 42759 4487 7 is be VBZ 42759 4487 8 in in IN 42759 4487 9 harmony harmony NN 42759 4487 10 with with IN 42759 4487 11 the the DT 42759 4487 12 principle principle NN 42759 4487 13 of of IN 42759 4487 14 exchange exchange NN 42759 4487 15 - - HYPH 42759 4487 16 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4487 17 , , , 42759 4487 18 nor nor CC 42759 4487 19 capable capable JJ 42759 4487 20 of of IN 42759 4487 21 serving serve VBG 42759 4487 22 as as IN 42759 4487 23 a a DT 42759 4487 24 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 4487 25 criterion criterion NN 42759 4487 26 of of IN 42759 4487 27 wage wage NN 42759 4487 28 justice justice NN 42759 4487 29 . . . 42759 4488 1 Father Father NNP 42759 4488 2 Antoine Antoine NNP 42759 4488 3 argues argue VBZ 42759 4488 4 that that IN 42759 4488 5 labour labour NN 42759 4488 6 is be VBZ 42759 4488 7 always always RB 42759 4488 8 the the DT 42759 4488 9 moral moral JJ 42759 4488 10 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4488 11 of of IN 42759 4488 12 a a DT 42759 4488 13 decent decent JJ 42759 4488 14 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4488 15 because because IN 42759 4488 16 the the DT 42759 4488 17 worker worker NN 42759 4488 18 expends expend VBZ 42759 4488 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4488 20 energies energy NNS 42759 4488 21 , , , 42759 4488 22 and and CC 42759 4488 23 gives give VBZ 42759 4488 24 out out RP 42759 4488 25 a a DT 42759 4488 26 part part NN 42759 4488 27 of of IN 42759 4488 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4488 29 life life NN 42759 4488 30 in in IN 42759 4488 31 the the DT 42759 4488 32 service service NN 42759 4488 33 of of IN 42759 4488 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4488 35 employer employer NN 42759 4488 36 . . . 42759 4489 1 Unless unless IN 42759 4489 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4489 3 wage wage NN 42759 4489 4 enables enable VBZ 42759 4489 5 the the DT 42759 4489 6 labourer labourer NN 42759 4489 7 to to TO 42759 4489 8 replace replace VB 42759 4489 9 these these DT 42759 4489 10 energies energy NNS 42759 4489 11 and and CC 42759 4489 12 conserve conserve VB 42759 4489 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4489 14 life life NN 42759 4489 15 , , , 42759 4489 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4489 17 is be VBZ 42759 4489 18 not not RB 42759 4489 19 the the DT 42759 4489 20 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4489 21 of of IN 42759 4489 22 the the DT 42759 4489 23 service service NN 42759 4489 24 . . . 42759 4490 1 If if IN 42759 4490 2 the the DT 42759 4490 3 wage wage NN 42759 4490 4 falls fall VBZ 42759 4490 5 short short JJ 42759 4490 6 of of IN 42759 4490 7 this this DT 42759 4490 8 standard standard NN 42759 4490 9 the the DT 42759 4490 10 labourer labourer NN 42759 4490 11 gives give VBZ 42759 4490 12 more more JJR 42759 4490 13 than than IN 42759 4490 14 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4490 15 receives receive VBZ 42759 4490 16 , , , 42759 4490 17 and and CC 42759 4490 18 the the DT 42759 4490 19 contract contract NN 42759 4490 20 is be VBZ 42759 4490 21 essentially essentially RB 42759 4490 22 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4490 23 . . . 42759 4491 1 In in IN 42759 4491 2 this this DT 42759 4491 3 conception conception NN 42759 4491 4 of of IN 42759 4491 5 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4491 6 , , , 42759 4491 7 energy energy NN 42759 4491 8 expended expend VBN 42759 4491 9 , , , 42759 4491 10 instead instead RB 42759 4491 11 of of IN 42759 4491 12 cost cost NN 42759 4491 13 of of IN 42759 4491 14 living living NN 42759 4491 15 , , , 42759 4491 16 becomes become VBZ 42759 4491 17 the the DT 42759 4491 18 term term NN 42759 4491 19 of of IN 42759 4491 20 comparison comparison NN 42759 4491 21 and and CC 42759 4491 22 the the DT 42759 4491 23 common common JJ 42759 4491 24 measure measure NN 42759 4491 25 of of IN 42759 4491 26 labour labour NN 42759 4491 27 and and CC 42759 4491 28 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 4491 29 . . . 42759 4492 1 Energy energy NN 42759 4492 2 expended expend VBN 42759 4492 3 is be VBZ 42759 4492 4 , , , 42759 4492 5 however however RB 42759 4492 6 , , , 42759 4492 7 technically technically RB 42759 4492 8 incapable incapable JJ 42759 4492 9 of of IN 42759 4492 10 providing provide VBG 42759 4492 11 such such PDT 42759 4492 12 a a DT 42759 4492 13 common common JJ 42759 4492 14 standard standard NN 42759 4492 15 ; ; : 42759 4492 16 for for IN 42759 4492 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4492 18 does do VBZ 42759 4492 19 not not RB 42759 4492 20 measure measure VB 42759 4492 21 both both DT 42759 4492 22 related relate VBN 42759 4492 23 terms term NNS 42759 4492 24 in in IN 42759 4492 25 the the DT 42759 4492 26 same same JJ 42759 4492 27 way way NN 42759 4492 28 . . . 42759 4493 1 The the DT 42759 4493 2 service service NN 42759 4493 3 rendered render VBN 42759 4493 4 to to IN 42759 4493 5 the the DT 42759 4493 6 employer employer NN 42759 4493 7 is be VBZ 42759 4493 8 the the DT 42759 4493 9 _ _ NNP 42759 4493 10 effect effect NN 42759 4493 11 _ _ IN 42759 4493 12 rather rather RB 42759 4493 13 than than IN 42759 4493 14 the the DT 42759 4493 15 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4493 16 of of IN 42759 4493 17 the the DT 42759 4493 18 energy energy NN 42759 4493 19 expended expend VBN 42759 4493 20 ; ; : 42759 4493 21 and and CC 42759 4493 22 the the DT 42759 4493 23 compensation compensation NN 42759 4493 24 is be VBZ 42759 4493 25 a a DT 42759 4493 26 _ _ NNP 42759 4493 27 means mean VBZ 42759 4493 28 _ _ NNP 42759 4493 29 to to IN 42759 4493 30 the the DT 42759 4493 31 replacement replacement NN 42759 4493 32 of of IN 42759 4493 33 this this DT 42759 4493 34 energy energy NN 42759 4493 35 rather rather RB 42759 4493 36 than than IN 42759 4493 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4493 38 formal formal JJ 42759 4493 39 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4493 40 . . . 42759 4494 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4494 2 , , , 42759 4494 3 the the DT 42759 4494 4 formula formula NN 42759 4494 5 does do VBZ 42759 4494 6 not not RB 42759 4494 7 even even RB 42759 4494 8 furnish furnish VB 42759 4494 9 an an DT 42759 4494 10 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4494 11 rational rational JJ 42759 4494 12 basis basis NN 42759 4494 13 for for IN 42759 4494 14 the the DT 42759 4494 15 claim claim NN 42759 4494 16 to to IN 42759 4494 17 a a DT 42759 4494 18 decent decent JJ 42759 4494 19 minimum minimum NN 42759 4494 20 wage wage NN 42759 4494 21 . . . 42759 4495 1 A a DT 42759 4495 2 wage wage NN 42759 4495 3 which which WDT 42759 4495 4 is be VBZ 42759 4495 5 merely merely RB 42759 4495 6 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4495 7 to to IN 42759 4495 8 the the DT 42759 4495 9 replacement replacement NN 42759 4495 10 of of IN 42759 4495 11 expended expended JJ 42759 4495 12 energy energy NN 42759 4495 13 and and CC 42759 4495 14 the the DT 42759 4495 15 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 4495 16 of of IN 42759 4495 17 life life NN 42759 4495 18 , , , 42759 4495 19 is be VBZ 42759 4495 20 really really RB 42759 4495 21 inadequate inadequate JJ 42759 4495 22 to to IN 42759 4495 23 a a DT 42759 4495 24 decent decent JJ 42759 4495 25 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4495 26 . . . 42759 4496 1 Such such JJ 42759 4496 2 compensation compensation NN 42759 4496 3 would would MD 42759 4496 4 cover cover VB 42759 4496 5 only only JJ 42759 4496 6 physical physical JJ 42759 4496 7 health health NN 42759 4496 8 and and CC 42759 4496 9 strength strength NN 42759 4496 10 , , , 42759 4496 11 leaving leave VBG 42759 4496 12 nothing nothing NN 42759 4496 13 for for IN 42759 4496 14 intellectual intellectual JJ 42759 4496 15 , , , 42759 4496 16 spiritual spiritual JJ 42759 4496 17 , , , 42759 4496 18 and and CC 42759 4496 19 moral moral JJ 42759 4496 20 needs need NNS 42759 4496 21 . . . 42759 4497 1 As as IN 42759 4497 2 Father Father NNP 42759 4497 3 Antoine Antoine NNP 42759 4497 4 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4497 5 admits admit VBZ 42759 4497 6 and and CC 42759 4497 7 contends contend VBZ 42759 4497 8 , , , 42759 4497 9 the the DT 42759 4497 10 latter latter JJ 42759 4497 11 needs need NNS 42759 4497 12 are be VBP 42759 4497 13 among among IN 42759 4497 14 the the DT 42759 4497 15 elements element NNS 42759 4497 16 of of IN 42759 4497 17 a a DT 42759 4497 18 decent decent JJ 42759 4497 19 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4497 20 , , , 42759 4497 21 and and CC 42759 4497 22 a a DT 42759 4497 23 wage wage NN 42759 4497 24 which which WDT 42759 4497 25 does do VBZ 42759 4497 26 not not RB 42759 4497 27 make make VB 42759 4497 28 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4497 29 provision provision NN 42759 4497 30 for for IN 42759 4497 31 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4497 32 fails fail VBZ 42759 4497 33 to to TO 42759 4497 34 comply comply VB 42759 4497 35 with with IN 42759 4497 36 the the DT 42759 4497 37 minimum minimum JJ 42759 4497 38 requirements requirement NNS 42759 4497 39 of of IN 42759 4497 40 justice justice NN 42759 4497 41 . . . 42759 4498 1 The the DT 42759 4498 2 second second JJ 42759 4498 3 factor factor NN 42759 4498 4 of of IN 42759 4498 5 " " `` 42759 4498 6 objective objective JJ 42759 4498 7 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4498 8 " " '' 42759 4498 9 is be VBZ 42759 4498 10 even even RB 42759 4498 11 more more RBR 42759 4498 12 questionable questionable JJ 42759 4498 13 than than IN 42759 4498 14 the the DT 42759 4498 15 first first JJ 42759 4498 16 . . . 42759 4499 1 To to TO 42759 4499 2 be be VB 42759 4499 3 _ _ NNP 42759 4499 4 completely completely RB 42759 4499 5 _ _ NNP 42759 4499 6 just just RB 42759 4499 7 , , , 42759 4499 8 says say VBZ 42759 4499 9 Father Father NNP 42759 4499 10 Antoine Antoine NNP 42759 4499 11 , , , 42759 4499 12 wages wage NNS 42759 4499 13 must must MD 42759 4499 14 be be VB 42759 4499 15 not not RB 42759 4499 16 merely merely RB 42759 4499 17 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4499 18 to to IN 42759 4499 19 a a DT 42759 4499 20 decent decent JJ 42759 4499 21 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4499 22 , , , 42759 4499 23 but but CC 42759 4499 24 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 4499 25 to to IN 42759 4499 26 the the DT 42759 4499 27 " " `` 42759 4499 28 economic economic JJ 42759 4499 29 value value NN 42759 4499 30 of of IN 42759 4499 31 the the DT 42759 4499 32 labour labour NN 42759 4499 33 " " '' 42759 4499 34 ( ( -LRB- 42759 4499 35 " " `` 42759 4499 36 la la FW 42759 4499 37 valeur valeur NNP 42759 4499 38 économique économique NNP 42759 4499 39 du du NNP 42759 4499 40 travail travail NNP 42759 4499 41 " " '' 42759 4499 42 ) ) -RRB- 42759 4499 43 . . . 42759 4500 1 This this DT 42759 4500 2 " " `` 42759 4500 3 economic economic JJ 42759 4500 4 value value NN 42759 4500 5 " " '' 42759 4500 6 is be VBZ 42759 4500 7 determined determine VBN 42759 4500 8 objectively objectively RB 42759 4500 9 by by IN 42759 4500 10 the the DT 42759 4500 11 cost cost NN 42759 4500 12 of of IN 42759 4500 13 production production NN 42759 4500 14 , , , 42759 4500 15 the the DT 42759 4500 16 utility utility NN 42759 4500 17 of of IN 42759 4500 18 the the DT 42759 4500 19 product product NN 42759 4500 20 , , , 42759 4500 21 and and CC 42759 4500 22 the the DT 42759 4500 23 movement movement NN 42759 4500 24 of of IN 42759 4500 25 supply supply NN 42759 4500 26 and and CC 42759 4500 27 demand demand NN 42759 4500 28 ; ; : 42759 4500 29 subjectively subjectively RB 42759 4500 30 , , , 42759 4500 31 by by IN 42759 4500 32 the the DT 42759 4500 33 judgment judgment NN 42759 4500 34 of of IN 42759 4500 35 employers employer NNS 42759 4500 36 and and CC 42759 4500 37 employés employés NNP 42759 4500 38 . . . 42759 4501 1 In in IN 42759 4501 2 case case NN 42759 4501 3 of of IN 42759 4501 4 conflict conflict NN 42759 4501 5 between between IN 42759 4501 6 these these DT 42759 4501 7 two two CD 42759 4501 8 measures measure NNS 42759 4501 9 of of IN 42759 4501 10 value value NN 42759 4501 11 , , , 42759 4501 12 and and CC 42759 4501 13 in in IN 42759 4501 14 case case NN 42759 4501 15 of of IN 42759 4501 16 uncertainty uncertainty NN 42759 4501 17 concerning concern VBG 42759 4501 18 the the DT 42759 4501 19 objective objective JJ 42759 4501 20 measure measure NN 42759 4501 21 , , , 42759 4501 22 the the DT 42759 4501 23 decision decision NN 42759 4501 24 of of IN 42759 4501 25 the the DT 42759 4501 26 subjective subjective JJ 42759 4501 27 determinant determinant NN 42759 4501 28 must must MD 42759 4501 29 always always RB 42759 4501 30 prevail prevail VB 42759 4501 31 . . . 42759 4502 1 These these DT 42759 4502 2 statements statement NNS 42759 4502 3 are be VBP 42759 4502 4 hopelessly hopelessly RB 42759 4502 5 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 42759 4502 6 and and CC 42759 4502 7 confusing confusing JJ 42759 4502 8 . . . 42759 4503 1 If if IN 42759 4503 2 the the DT 42759 4503 3 objective objective JJ 42759 4503 4 measure measure NN 42759 4503 5 of of IN 42759 4503 6 " " `` 42759 4503 7 economic economic JJ 42759 4503 8 value value NN 42759 4503 9 " " '' 42759 4503 10 is be VBZ 42759 4503 11 to to TO 42759 4503 12 be be VB 42759 4503 13 understood understand VBN 42759 4503 14 in in IN 42759 4503 15 a a DT 42759 4503 16 purely purely RB 42759 4503 17 positive positive JJ 42759 4503 18 way way NN 42759 4503 19 , , , 42759 4503 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4503 21 merely merely RB 42759 4503 22 means mean VBZ 42759 4503 23 the the DT 42759 4503 24 wages wage NNS 42759 4503 25 that that WDT 42759 4503 26 actually actually RB 42759 4503 27 obtain obtain VBP 42759 4503 28 in in IN 42759 4503 29 a a DT 42759 4503 30 competitive competitive JJ 42759 4503 31 market market NN 42759 4503 32 . . . 42759 4504 1 In in IN 42759 4504 2 the the DT 42759 4504 3 purely purely RB 42759 4504 4 positive positive JJ 42759 4504 5 or or CC 42759 4504 6 economic economic JJ 42759 4504 7 sense sense NN 42759 4504 8 , , , 42759 4504 9 the the DT 42759 4504 10 utility utility NN 42759 4504 11 of of IN 42759 4504 12 labour labour NN 42759 4504 13 is be VBZ 42759 4504 14 measured measure VBN 42759 4504 15 by by IN 42759 4504 16 what what WP 42759 4504 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4504 18 will will MD 42759 4504 19 command command VB 42759 4504 20 in in IN 42759 4504 21 the the DT 42759 4504 22 market market NN 42759 4504 23 , , , 42759 4504 24 the the DT 42759 4504 25 movement movement NN 42759 4504 26 of of IN 42759 4504 27 supply supply NN 42759 4504 28 and and CC 42759 4504 29 demand demand NN 42759 4504 30 is be VBZ 42759 4504 31 likewise likewise RB 42759 4504 32 reflected reflect VBN 42759 4504 33 in in IN 42759 4504 34 market market NN 42759 4504 35 wages wage NNS 42759 4504 36 , , , 42759 4504 37 and and CC 42759 4504 38 the the DT 42759 4504 39 determining determine VBG 42759 4504 40 effect effect NN 42759 4504 41 of of IN 42759 4504 42 cost cost NN 42759 4504 43 of of IN 42759 4504 44 production production NN 42759 4504 45 is be VBZ 42759 4504 46 also also RB 42759 4504 47 seen see VBN 42759 4504 48 in in IN 42759 4504 49 the the DT 42759 4504 50 share share NN 42759 4504 51 that that IN 42759 4504 52 the the DT 42759 4504 53 market market NN 42759 4504 54 awards award NNS 42759 4504 55 to to IN 42759 4504 56 labour labour NN 42759 4504 57 after after IN 42759 4504 58 the the DT 42759 4504 59 other other JJ 42759 4504 60 factors factor NNS 42759 4504 61 of of IN 42759 4504 62 production production NN 42759 4504 63 have have VBP 42759 4504 64 taken take VBN 42759 4504 65 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4504 66 portions portion NNS 42759 4504 67 of of IN 42759 4504 68 the the DT 42759 4504 69 product product NN 42759 4504 70 . . . 42759 4505 1 In in IN 42759 4505 2 other other JJ 42759 4505 3 words word NNS 42759 4505 4 , , , 42759 4505 5 the the DT 42759 4505 6 " " `` 42759 4505 7 economic economic JJ 42759 4505 8 value value NN 42759 4505 9 " " '' 42759 4505 10 of of IN 42759 4505 11 labour labour NN 42759 4505 12 is be VBZ 42759 4505 13 simply simply RB 42759 4505 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4505 15 market market NN 42759 4505 16 value value NN 42759 4505 17 . . . 42759 4506 1 This this DT 42759 4506 2 , , , 42759 4506 3 however however RB 42759 4506 4 , , , 42759 4506 5 is be VBZ 42759 4506 6 not not RB 42759 4506 7 Father Father NNP 42759 4506 8 Antoine Antoine NNP 42759 4506 9 's 's POS 42759 4506 10 meaning meaning NN 42759 4506 11 ; ; : 42759 4506 12 for for IN 42759 4506 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4506 14 has have VBZ 42759 4506 15 already already RB 42759 4506 16 declared declare VBN 42759 4506 17 that that IN 42759 4506 18 the the DT 42759 4506 19 " " `` 42759 4506 20 economic economic JJ 42759 4506 21 value value NN 42759 4506 22 " " '' 42759 4506 23 of of IN 42759 4506 24 labour labour NN 42759 4506 25 is be VBZ 42759 4506 26 never never RB 42759 4506 27 less less JJR 42759 4506 28 than than IN 42759 4506 29 the the DT 42759 4506 30 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4506 31 of of IN 42759 4506 32 a a DT 42759 4506 33 decent decent JJ 42759 4506 34 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4506 35 , , , 42759 4506 36 whereas whereas IN 42759 4506 37 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4506 38 know know VBP 42759 4506 39 that that IN 42759 4506 40 the the DT 42759 4506 41 market market NN 42759 4506 42 value value NN 42759 4506 43 often often RB 42759 4506 44 falls fall VBZ 42759 4506 45 below below IN 42759 4506 46 that that DT 42759 4506 47 level level NN 42759 4506 48 . . . 42759 4507 1 In in IN 42759 4507 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4507 3 mind mind NN 42759 4507 4 , , , 42759 4507 5 therefore therefore RB 42759 4507 6 , , , 42759 4507 7 " " `` 42759 4507 8 economic economic JJ 42759 4507 9 value value NN 42759 4507 10 " " '' 42759 4507 11 has have VBZ 42759 4507 12 an an DT 42759 4507 13 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4507 14 signification signification NN 42759 4507 15 . . . 42759 4508 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4508 2 indicates indicate VBZ 42759 4508 3 at at IN 42759 4508 4 least least JJS 42759 4508 5 the the DT 42759 4508 6 requisites requisite NNS 42759 4508 7 of of IN 42759 4508 8 decent decent JJ 42759 4508 9 living living NN 42759 4508 10 , , , 42759 4508 11 and and CC 42759 4508 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4508 13 embraces embrace VBZ 42759 4508 14 more more JJR 42759 4508 15 than than IN 42759 4508 16 this this DT 42759 4508 17 in in IN 42759 4508 18 some some DT 42759 4508 19 cases case NNS 42759 4508 20 . . . 42759 4509 1 When when WRB 42759 4509 2 ? ? . 42759 4510 1 and and CC 42759 4510 2 how how WRB 42759 4510 3 much much RB 42759 4510 4 more more JJR 42759 4510 5 ? ? . 42759 4511 1 Let let VB 42759 4511 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4511 3 suppose suppose VB 42759 4511 4 a a DT 42759 4511 5 business business NN 42759 4511 6 so so RB 42759 4511 7 prosperous prosperous JJ 42759 4511 8 that that IN 42759 4511 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4511 10 returns return VBZ 42759 4511 11 liberal liberal JJ 42759 4511 12 profits profit NNS 42759 4511 13 to to IN 42759 4511 14 the the DT 42759 4511 15 employer employer NN 42759 4511 16 and and CC 42759 4511 17 the the DT 42759 4511 18 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 4511 19 rate rate NN 42759 4511 20 of of IN 42759 4511 21 interest interest NN 42759 4511 22 on on IN 42759 4511 23 the the DT 42759 4511 24 capital capital NN 42759 4511 25 , , , 42759 4511 26 and and CC 42759 4511 27 yet yet RB 42759 4511 28 shows show VBZ 42759 4511 29 a a DT 42759 4511 30 surplus surplus JJ 42759 4511 31 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4511 32 to to TO 42759 4511 33 give give VB 42759 4511 34 all all PDT 42759 4511 35 the the DT 42759 4511 36 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4511 37 ten ten CD 42759 4511 38 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4511 39 a a DT 42759 4511 40 day day NN 42759 4511 41 . . . 42759 4512 1 Is be VBZ 42759 4512 2 " " `` 42759 4512 3 cost cost NN 42759 4512 4 of of IN 42759 4512 5 production production NN 42759 4512 6 " " '' 42759 4512 7 to to TO 42759 4512 8 be be VB 42759 4512 9 interpreted interpret VBN 42759 4512 10 here here RB 42759 4512 11 as as IN 42759 4512 12 allowing allow VBG 42759 4512 13 only only RB 42759 4512 14 the the DT 42759 4512 15 normal normal JJ 42759 4512 16 rate rate NN 42759 4512 17 of of IN 42759 4512 18 profits profit NNS 42759 4512 19 and and CC 42759 4512 20 interest interest NN 42759 4512 21 to to IN 42759 4512 22 the the DT 42759 4512 23 business business NN 42759 4512 24 man man NN 42759 4512 25 and and CC 42759 4512 26 the the DT 42759 4512 27 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4512 28 , , , 42759 4512 29 leaving leave VBG 42759 4512 30 the the DT 42759 4512 31 residue residue NN 42759 4512 32 to to IN 42759 4512 33 labour labour NN 42759 4512 34 ? ? . 42759 4513 1 Or or CC 42759 4513 2 is be VBZ 42759 4513 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4513 4 to to TO 42759 4513 5 be be VB 42759 4513 6 understood understand VBN 42759 4513 7 as as IN 42759 4513 8 requiring require VBG 42759 4513 9 that that IN 42759 4513 10 the the DT 42759 4513 11 surplus surplus NN 42759 4513 12 be be VB 42759 4513 13 divided divide VBN 42759 4513 14 among among IN 42759 4513 15 the the DT 42759 4513 16 three three CD 42759 4513 17 agents agent NNS 42759 4513 18 of of IN 42759 4513 19 production production NN 42759 4513 20 ? ? . 42759 4514 1 In in IN 42759 4514 2 other other JJ 42759 4514 3 words word NNS 42759 4514 4 , , , 42759 4514 5 is be VBZ 42759 4514 6 the the DT 42759 4514 7 " " `` 42759 4514 8 economic economic JJ 42759 4514 9 value value NN 42759 4514 10 " " '' 42759 4514 11 of of IN 42759 4514 12 labour labour NN 42759 4514 13 in in IN 42759 4514 14 such such JJ 42759 4514 15 cases case NNS 42759 4514 16 to to TO 42759 4514 17 be be VB 42759 4514 18 determined determine VBN 42759 4514 19 by by IN 42759 4514 20 some some DT 42759 4514 21 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4514 22 principle principle NN 42759 4514 23 which which WDT 42759 4514 24 tells tell VBZ 42759 4514 25 beforehand beforehand RB 42759 4514 26 how how WRB 42759 4514 27 much much JJ 42759 4514 28 the the DT 42759 4514 29 other other JJ 42759 4514 30 agents agent NNS 42759 4514 31 than than IN 42759 4514 32 labour labour NN 42759 4514 33 ought ought MD 42759 4514 34 to to TO 42759 4514 35 receive receive VB 42759 4514 36 ? ? . 42759 4515 1 If if IN 42759 4515 2 so so RB 42759 4515 3 , , , 42759 4515 4 what what WP 42759 4515 5 is be VBZ 42759 4515 6 this this DT 42759 4515 7 principle principle NN 42759 4515 8 or or CC 42759 4515 9 formula formula NN 42759 4515 10 ? ? . 42759 4516 1 None none NN 42759 4516 2 of of IN 42759 4516 3 these these DT 42759 4516 4 questions question NNS 42759 4516 5 is be VBZ 42759 4516 6 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 42759 4516 7 answered answer VBN 42759 4516 8 in in IN 42759 4516 9 Father Father NNP 42759 4516 10 Antoine Antoine NNP 42759 4516 11 's 's POS 42759 4516 12 pages page NNS 42759 4516 13 . . . 42759 4517 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4517 2 are be VBP 42759 4517 3 all all DT 42759 4517 4 to to TO 42759 4517 5 be be VB 42759 4517 6 solved solve VBN 42759 4517 7 by by IN 42759 4517 8 having have VBG 42759 4517 9 recourse recourse NN 42759 4517 10 to to IN 42759 4517 11 the the DT 42759 4517 12 subjective subjective JJ 42759 4517 13 determinant determinant NN 42759 4517 14 of of IN 42759 4517 15 " " `` 42759 4517 16 economic economic JJ 42759 4517 17 value value NN 42759 4517 18 " " '' 42759 4517 19 ; ; : 42759 4517 20 namely namely RB 42759 4517 21 , , , 42759 4517 22 the the DT 42759 4517 23 judgment judgment NN 42759 4517 24 of of IN 42759 4517 25 employers employer NNS 42759 4517 26 and and CC 42759 4517 27 employés employés NNP 42759 4517 28 . . . 42759 4518 1 Thus thus RB 42759 4518 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4518 3 proximate proximate NN 42759 4518 4 factor factor NN 42759 4518 5 of of IN 42759 4518 6 justice justice NN 42759 4518 7 in in IN 42759 4518 8 wages wage NNS 42759 4518 9 , , , 42759 4518 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4518 11 formula formula NN 42759 4518 12 of of IN 42759 4518 13 complete complete JJ 42759 4518 14 as as IN 42759 4518 15 against against IN 42759 4518 16 minimum minimum NN 42759 4518 17 just just JJ 42759 4518 18 wages wage NNS 42759 4518 19 , , , 42759 4518 20 turns turn VBZ 42759 4518 21 out out RP 42759 4518 22 to to TO 42759 4518 23 be be VB 42759 4518 24 something something NN 42759 4518 25 entirely entirely RB 42759 4518 26 subjective subjective JJ 42759 4518 27 , , , 42759 4518 28 and and CC 42759 4518 29 more more RBR 42759 4518 30 or or CC 42759 4518 31 less less RBR 42759 4518 32 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 42759 4518 33 . . . 42759 4519 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4519 2 is be VBZ 42759 4519 3 in in IN 42759 4519 4 no no DT 42759 4519 5 sense sense NN 42759 4519 6 a a DT 42759 4519 7 measure measure NN 42759 4519 8 of of IN 42759 4519 9 the the DT 42759 4519 10 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4519 11 between between IN 42759 4519 12 work work NN 42759 4519 13 and and CC 42759 4519 14 pay pay NN 42759 4519 15 . . . 42759 4520 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4520 2 , , , 42759 4520 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4520 4 is be VBZ 42759 4520 5 inadequate inadequate JJ 42759 4520 6 as as IN 42759 4520 7 a a DT 42759 4520 8 measure measure NN 42759 4520 9 of of IN 42759 4520 10 justice justice NN 42759 4520 11 . . . 42759 4521 1 Should Should MD 42759 4521 2 the the DT 42759 4521 3 majority majority NN 42759 4521 4 of of IN 42759 4521 5 both both DT 42759 4521 6 employers employer NNS 42759 4521 7 and and CC 42759 4521 8 employés employés NNP 42759 4521 9 fix fix NN 42759 4521 10 the the DT 42759 4521 11 " " `` 42759 4521 12 economic economic JJ 42759 4521 13 value value NN 42759 4521 14 " " '' 42759 4521 15 of of IN 42759 4521 16 the the DT 42759 4521 17 labour labour NN 42759 4521 18 of of IN 42759 4521 19 carpenters carpenter NNS 42759 4521 20 at at IN 42759 4521 21 five five CD 42759 4521 22 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4521 23 a a DT 42759 4521 24 day day NN 42759 4521 25 , , , 42759 4521 26 there there EX 42759 4521 27 would would MD 42759 4521 28 be be VB 42759 4521 29 no no DT 42759 4521 30 certainty certainty NN 42759 4521 31 that that IN 42759 4521 32 this this DT 42759 4521 33 decision decision NN 42759 4521 34 was be VBD 42759 4521 35 correct correct JJ 42759 4521 36 , , , 42759 4521 37 and and CC 42759 4521 38 that that IN 42759 4521 39 this this DT 42759 4521 40 figure figure NN 42759 4521 41 represented represent VBD 42759 4521 42 just just RB 42759 4521 43 wages wage NNS 42759 4521 44 . . . 42759 4522 1 Should Should MD 42759 4522 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4522 3 determine determine VB 42759 4522 4 upon upon IN 42759 4522 5 a a DT 42759 4522 6 rate rate NN 42759 4522 7 of of IN 42759 4522 8 fifty fifty CD 42759 4522 9 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4522 10 a a DT 42759 4522 11 day day NN 42759 4522 12 , , , 42759 4522 13 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4522 14 could could MD 42759 4522 15 not not RB 42759 4522 16 be be VB 42759 4522 17 sure sure JJ 42759 4522 18 that that IN 42759 4522 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4522 20 decision decision NN 42759 4522 21 was be VBD 42759 4522 22 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4522 23 . . . 42759 4523 1 Undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 4523 2 the the DT 42759 4523 3 combined combined JJ 42759 4523 4 judgment judgment NN 42759 4523 5 of of IN 42759 4523 6 employers employer NNS 42759 4523 7 and and CC 42759 4523 8 employés employés NNP 42759 4523 9 will will MD 42759 4523 10 set set VB 42759 4523 11 a a DT 42759 4523 12 fairer fair JJR 42759 4523 13 wage wage NN 42759 4523 14 than than IN 42759 4523 15 one one CD 42759 4523 16 fixed fix VBN 42759 4523 17 by by IN 42759 4523 18 either either DT 42759 4523 19 party party NN 42759 4523 20 alone alone RB 42759 4523 21 , , , 42759 4523 22 since since IN 42759 4523 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4523 24 will will MD 42759 4523 25 be be VB 42759 4523 26 less less RBR 42759 4523 27 one one CD 42759 4523 28 - - HYPH 42759 4523 29 sided sided JJ 42759 4523 30 ; ; : 42759 4523 31 but but CC 42759 4523 32 there there EX 42759 4523 33 is be VBZ 42759 4523 34 no no DT 42759 4523 35 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4523 36 reason reason NN 42759 4523 37 for for IN 42759 4523 38 concluding conclude VBG 42759 4523 39 that that IN 42759 4523 40 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4523 41 will will MD 42759 4523 42 be be VB 42759 4523 43 in in IN 42759 4523 44 all all DT 42759 4523 45 cases case NNS 42759 4523 46 completely completely RB 42759 4523 47 just just RB 42759 4523 48 . . . 42759 4524 1 Undoubtedly undoubtedly JJ 42759 4524 2 employers employer NNS 42759 4524 3 and and CC 42759 4524 4 employés employés NNP 42759 4524 5 know know VB 42759 4524 6 what what WP 42759 4524 7 wages wage NNS 42759 4524 8 an an DT 42759 4524 9 industry industry NN 42759 4524 10 can can MD 42759 4524 11 afford afford VB 42759 4524 12 at at IN 42759 4524 13 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 4524 14 prices price NNS 42759 4524 15 , , , 42759 4524 16 on on IN 42759 4524 17 the the DT 42759 4524 18 assumption assumption NN 42759 4524 19 that that IN 42759 4524 20 business business NN 42759 4524 21 ability ability NN 42759 4524 22 and and CC 42759 4524 23 capital capital NN 42759 4524 24 are be VBP 42759 4524 25 to to TO 42759 4524 26 have have VB 42759 4524 27 a a DT 42759 4524 28 certain certain JJ 42759 4524 29 rate rate NN 42759 4524 30 of of IN 42759 4524 31 return return NN 42759 4524 32 ; ; : 42759 4524 33 but but CC 42759 4524 34 there there EX 42759 4524 35 is be VBZ 42759 4524 36 no no DT 42759 4524 37 certainty certainty NN 42759 4524 38 that that IN 42759 4524 39 the the DT 42759 4524 40 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 4524 41 prices price NNS 42759 4524 42 are be VBP 42759 4524 43 fair fair JJ 42759 4524 44 , , , 42759 4524 45 or or CC 42759 4524 46 that that IN 42759 4524 47 the the DT 42759 4524 48 assumed assumed JJ 42759 4524 49 rates rate NNS 42759 4524 50 of of IN 42759 4524 51 profits profit NNS 42759 4524 52 and and CC 42759 4524 53 interest interest NN 42759 4524 54 are be VBP 42759 4524 55 fair fair JJ 42759 4524 56 . . . 42759 4525 1 In in IN 42759 4525 2 a a DT 42759 4525 3 word word NN 42759 4525 4 , , , 42759 4525 5 the the DT 42759 4525 6 device device NN 42759 4525 7 is be VBZ 42759 4525 8 too too RB 42759 4525 9 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 42759 4525 10 . . . 42759 4526 1 To to TO 42759 4526 2 sum sum VB 42759 4526 3 up up RP 42759 4526 4 the the DT 42759 4526 5 entire entire JJ 42759 4526 6 discussion discussion NN 42759 4526 7 of of IN 42759 4526 8 exchange exchange NN 42759 4526 9 - - HYPH 42759 4526 10 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4526 11 theories theory NNS 42759 4526 12 : : : 42759 4526 13 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4526 14 underlying underlie VBG 42759 4526 15 concept concept NN 42759 4526 16 is be VBZ 42759 4526 17 fundamentally fundamentally RB 42759 4526 18 unsound unsound JJ 42759 4526 19 and and CC 42759 4526 20 impracticable impracticable JJ 42759 4526 21 . . . 42759 4527 1 All all DT 42759 4527 2 of of IN 42759 4527 3 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4527 4 involve involve VBP 42759 4527 5 an an DT 42759 4527 6 attempt attempt NN 42759 4527 7 to to TO 42759 4527 8 compare compare VB 42759 4527 9 two two CD 42759 4527 10 entities entity NNS 42759 4527 11 which which WDT 42759 4527 12 are be VBP 42759 4527 13 utterly utterly RB 42759 4527 14 incommensurate incommensurate JJ 42759 4527 15 . . . 42759 4528 1 There there EX 42759 4528 2 exists exist VBZ 42759 4528 3 no no DT 42759 4528 4 third third JJ 42759 4528 5 term term NN 42759 4528 6 , , , 42759 4528 7 or or CC 42759 4528 8 standard standard JJ 42759 4528 9 , , , 42759 4528 10 or or CC 42759 4528 11 objective objective JJ 42759 4528 12 fact fact NN 42759 4528 13 , , , 42759 4528 14 which which WDT 42759 4528 15 will will MD 42759 4528 16 inform inform VB 42759 4528 17 men man NNS 42759 4528 18 whether whether IN 42759 4528 19 any any DT 42759 4528 20 rate rate NN 42759 4528 21 of of IN 42759 4528 22 wages wage NNS 42759 4528 23 is be VBZ 42759 4528 24 the the DT 42759 4528 25 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4528 26 of of IN 42759 4528 27 any any DT 42759 4528 28 quantity quantity NN 42759 4528 29 of of IN 42759 4528 30 labour labour NN 42759 4528 31 . . . 42759 4529 1 III iii CD 42759 4529 2 . . . 42759 4530 1 PRODUCTIVITY PRODUCTIVITY NNP 42759 4530 2 THEORIES theory NNS 42759 4530 3 The the DT 42759 4530 4 productivity productivity NN 42759 4530 5 concept concept NN 42759 4530 6 of of IN 42759 4530 7 wage wage NN 42759 4530 8 justice justice NN 42759 4530 9 appears appear VBZ 42759 4530 10 in in IN 42759 4530 11 a a DT 42759 4530 12 great great JJ 42759 4530 13 variety variety NN 42759 4530 14 of of IN 42759 4530 15 forms form NNS 42759 4530 16 . . . 42759 4531 1 The the DT 42759 4531 2 first first JJ 42759 4531 3 of of IN 42759 4531 4 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4531 5 that that IN 42759 4531 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4531 7 shall shall MD 42759 4531 8 consider consider VB 42759 4531 9 is be VBZ 42759 4531 10 advocated advocate VBN 42759 4531 11 mainly mainly RB 42759 4531 12 by by IN 42759 4531 13 the the DT 42759 4531 14 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 4531 15 , , , 42759 4531 16 and and CC 42759 4531 17 is be VBZ 42759 4531 18 usually usually RB 42759 4531 19 referred refer VBN 42759 4531 20 to to IN 42759 4531 21 as as IN 42759 4531 22 the the DT 42759 4531 23 theory theory NN 42759 4531 24 of of IN 42759 4531 25 the the DT 42759 4531 26 " " `` 42759 4531 27 right right NN 42759 4531 28 to to IN 42759 4531 29 the the DT 42759 4531 30 whole whole JJ 42759 4531 31 product product NN 42759 4531 32 of of IN 42759 4531 33 labour labour NN 42759 4531 34 . . . 42759 4532 1 " " `` 42759 4532 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4532 3 224 224 CD 42759 4532 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4532 5 _ _ NNP 42759 4532 6 Labour Labour NNP 42759 4532 7 's 's POS 42759 4532 8 Right right NN 42759 4532 9 to to IN 42759 4532 10 the the DT 42759 4532 11 Whole Whole NNP 42759 4532 12 Product Product NNP 42759 4532 13 _ _ IN 42759 4532 14 We -PRON- PRP 42759 4532 15 have have VBP 42759 4532 16 seen see VBN 42759 4532 17 that that IN 42759 4532 18 Adam Adam NNP 42759 4532 19 Smith Smith NNP 42759 4532 20 's 's POS 42759 4532 21 belief belief NN 42759 4532 22 in in IN 42759 4532 23 the the DT 42759 4532 24 normality normality NN 42759 4532 25 and and CC 42759 4532 26 beneficence beneficence NN 42759 4532 27 of of IN 42759 4532 28 free free JJ 42759 4532 29 competition competition NN 42759 4532 30 would would MD 42759 4532 31 have have VB 42759 4532 32 logically logically RB 42759 4532 33 led lead VBN 42759 4532 34 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4532 35 to to IN 42759 4532 36 the the DT 42759 4532 37 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 4532 38 that that IN 42759 4532 39 competitive competitive JJ 42759 4532 40 wages wage NNS 42759 4532 41 were be VBD 42759 4532 42 just just RB 42759 4532 43 ; ; : 42759 4532 44 and and CC 42759 4532 45 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4532 46 know know VBP 42759 4532 47 that that IN 42759 4532 48 this this DT 42759 4532 49 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4532 50 is be VBZ 42759 4532 51 implicit implicit JJ 42759 4532 52 in in IN 42759 4532 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4532 54 writings writing NNS 42759 4532 55 . . . 42759 4533 1 On on IN 42759 4533 2 the the DT 42759 4533 3 other other JJ 42759 4533 4 hand hand NN 42759 4533 5 , , , 42759 4533 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4533 7 theory theory NN 42759 4533 8 that that IN 42759 4533 9 all all DT 42759 4533 10 value value NN 42759 4533 11 is be VBZ 42759 4533 12 determined determine VBN 42759 4533 13 by by IN 42759 4533 14 labour labour NN 42759 4533 15 would would MD 42759 4533 16 seem seem VB 42759 4533 17 to to TO 42759 4533 18 involve involve VB 42759 4533 19 the the DT 42759 4533 20 inference inference NN 42759 4533 21 that that IN 42759 4533 22 all all PDT 42759 4533 23 the the DT 42759 4533 24 value value NN 42759 4533 25 of of IN 42759 4533 26 the the DT 42759 4533 27 product product NN 42759 4533 28 belongs belong VBZ 42759 4533 29 to to IN 42759 4533 30 the the DT 42759 4533 31 labourer labourer NN 42759 4533 32 . . . 42759 4534 1 As as IN 42759 4534 2 a a DT 42759 4534 3 matter matter NN 42759 4534 4 of of IN 42759 4534 5 fact fact NN 42759 4534 6 , , , 42759 4534 7 Smith Smith NNP 42759 4534 8 restricted restrict VBD 42759 4534 9 this this DT 42759 4534 10 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 4534 11 to to IN 42759 4534 12 primitive primitive JJ 42759 4534 13 and and CC 42759 4534 14 pre pre JJ 42759 4534 15 - - JJ 42759 4534 16 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 4534 17 societies society NNS 42759 4534 18 . . . 42759 4535 1 Apparently apparently RB 42759 4535 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4535 3 , , , 42759 4535 4 and and CC 42759 4535 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4535 6 disciples disciple NNS 42759 4535 7 in in IN 42759 4535 8 an an DT 42759 4535 9 even even RB 42759 4535 10 larger large JJR 42759 4535 11 degree degree NN 42759 4535 12 , , , 42759 4535 13 was be VBD 42759 4535 14 more more RBR 42759 4535 15 interested interested JJ 42759 4535 16 in in IN 42759 4535 17 describing describe VBG 42759 4535 18 the the DT 42759 4535 19 supposed suppose VBN 42759 4535 20 beneficence beneficence NN 42759 4535 21 of of IN 42759 4535 22 competition competition NN 42759 4535 23 than than IN 42759 4535 24 in in IN 42759 4535 25 justifying justify VBG 42759 4535 26 the the DT 42759 4535 27 distribution distribution NN 42759 4535 28 that that WDT 42759 4535 29 resulted result VBD 42759 4535 30 from from IN 42759 4535 31 the the DT 42759 4535 32 competitive competitive JJ 42759 4535 33 process process NN 42759 4535 34 . . . 42759 4536 1 The the DT 42759 4536 2 early early JJ 42759 4536 3 English English NNP 42759 4536 4 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 4536 5 were be VBD 42759 4536 6 more more RBR 42759 4536 7 consistent consistent JJ 42759 4536 8 . . . 42759 4537 1 In in IN 42759 4537 2 1793 1793 CD 42759 4537 3 William William NNP 42759 4537 4 Godwin Godwin NNP 42759 4537 5 , , , 42759 4537 6 whom whom WP 42759 4537 7 Anton Anton NNP 42759 4537 8 Menger Menger NNP 42759 4537 9 calls call VBZ 42759 4537 10 " " `` 42759 4537 11 the the DT 42759 4537 12 first first JJ 42759 4537 13 scientific scientific JJ 42759 4537 14 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 4537 15 of of IN 42759 4537 16 modern modern JJ 42759 4537 17 times time NNS 42759 4537 18 , , , 42759 4537 19 " " '' 42759 4537 20 laid lay VBN 42759 4537 21 down down RP 42759 4537 22 in in IN 42759 4537 23 substance substance NN 42759 4537 24 the the DT 42759 4537 25 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4537 26 that that IN 42759 4537 27 the the DT 42759 4537 28 labourer labourer NN 42759 4537 29 has have VBZ 42759 4537 30 a a DT 42759 4537 31 right right NN 42759 4537 32 to to IN 42759 4537 33 the the DT 42759 4537 34 whole whole JJ 42759 4537 35 product product NN 42759 4537 36 . . . 42759 4538 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4538 2 225 225 CD 42759 4538 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4538 4 In in IN 42759 4538 5 1805 1805 CD 42759 4538 6 Charles Charles NNP 42759 4538 7 Hall Hall NNP 42759 4538 8 formulated formulate VBD 42759 4538 9 and and CC 42759 4538 10 defended defend VBD 42759 4538 11 the the DT 42759 4538 12 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4538 13 with with IN 42759 4538 14 greater great JJR 42759 4538 15 precision precision NN 42759 4538 16 and and CC 42759 4538 17 consistency consistency NN 42759 4538 18 . . . 42759 4539 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4539 2 226 226 CD 42759 4539 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4539 4 In in IN 42759 4539 5 1824 1824 CD 42759 4539 6 the the DT 42759 4539 7 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4539 8 was be VBD 42759 4539 9 stated state VBN 42759 4539 10 more more RBR 42759 4539 11 fundamentally fundamentally RB 42759 4539 12 , , , 42759 4539 13 systematically systematically RB 42759 4539 14 , , , 42759 4539 15 and and CC 42759 4539 16 completely completely RB 42759 4539 17 by by IN 42759 4539 18 William William NNP 42759 4539 19 Thompson Thompson NNP 42759 4539 20 . . . 42759 4540 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4540 2 227 227 CD 42759 4540 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4540 4 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4540 5 accepted accept VBD 42759 4540 6 the the DT 42759 4540 7 labour labour NN 42759 4540 8 theory theory NN 42759 4540 9 of of IN 42759 4540 10 value value NN 42759 4540 11 laid lay VBN 42759 4540 12 down down RP 42759 4540 13 by by IN 42759 4540 14 Adam Adam NNP 42759 4540 15 Smith Smith NNP 42759 4540 16 , , , 42759 4540 17 and and CC 42759 4540 18 formally formally RB 42759 4540 19 derived derive VBD 42759 4540 20 therefrom therefrom IN 42759 4540 21 the the DT 42759 4540 22 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4540 23 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 4540 24 that that IN 42759 4540 25 the the DT 42759 4540 26 labourer labourer NN 42759 4540 27 has have VBZ 42759 4540 28 a a DT 42759 4540 29 right right NN 42759 4540 30 to to IN 42759 4540 31 the the DT 42759 4540 32 whole whole JJ 42759 4540 33 product product NN 42759 4540 34 . . . 42759 4541 1 " " `` 42759 4541 2 Thompson Thompson NNP 42759 4541 3 and and CC 42759 4541 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4541 5 followers follower NNS 42759 4541 6 are be VBP 42759 4541 7 only only RB 42759 4541 8 original original JJ 42759 4541 9 in in IN 42759 4541 10 so so RB 42759 4541 11 far far RB 42759 4541 12 as as IN 42759 4541 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4541 14 consider consider VBP 42759 4541 15 rent rent NN 42759 4541 16 and and CC 42759 4541 17 interest interest NN 42759 4541 18 to to TO 42759 4541 19 be be VB 42759 4541 20 _ _ NNP 42759 4541 21 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4541 22 _ _ NNP 42759 4541 23 deductions deduction NNS 42759 4541 24 , , , 42759 4541 25 which which WDT 42759 4541 26 violate violate VBP 42759 4541 27 the the DT 42759 4541 28 right right NN 42759 4541 29 of of IN 42759 4541 30 the the DT 42759 4541 31 labourer labourer NN 42759 4541 32 to to IN 42759 4541 33 the the DT 42759 4541 34 whole whole JJ 42759 4541 35 product product NN 42759 4541 36 of of IN 42759 4541 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4541 38 labour labour NN 42759 4541 39 . . . 42759 4542 1 " " `` 42759 4542 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4542 3 228 228 CD 42759 4542 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4542 5 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4542 6 denounced denounce VBD 42759 4542 7 the the DT 42759 4542 8 laws law NNS 42759 4542 9 which which WDT 42759 4542 10 empowered empower VBD 42759 4542 11 the the DT 42759 4542 12 land land NN 42759 4542 13 owner owner NN 42759 4542 14 and and CC 42759 4542 15 the the DT 42759 4542 16 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4542 17 to to TO 42759 4542 18 appropriate appropriate JJ 42759 4542 19 value value NN 42759 4542 20 not not RB 42759 4542 21 created create VBN 42759 4542 22 by by IN 42759 4542 23 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4542 24 , , , 42759 4542 25 and and CC 42759 4542 26 gave give VBD 42759 4542 27 to to IN 42759 4542 28 the the DT 42759 4542 29 value value NN 42759 4542 30 thus thus RB 42759 4542 31 appropriated appropriate VBD 42759 4542 32 the the DT 42759 4542 33 name name NN 42759 4542 34 , , , 42759 4542 35 " " `` 42759 4542 36 surplus surplus NN 42759 4542 37 value value NN 42759 4542 38 . . . 42759 4542 39 " " '' 42759 4543 1 In in IN 42759 4543 2 the the DT 42759 4543 3 use use NN 42759 4543 4 of of IN 42759 4543 5 this this DT 42759 4543 6 term term NN 42759 4543 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4543 8 anticipated anticipate VBD 42759 4543 9 Karl Karl NNP 42759 4543 10 Marx Marx NNP 42759 4543 11 by by IN 42759 4543 12 several several JJ 42759 4543 13 years year NNS 42759 4543 14 . . . 42759 4544 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4544 2 doctrines doctrine NNS 42759 4544 3 were be VBD 42759 4544 4 adopted adopt VBN 42759 4544 5 and and CC 42759 4544 6 defended defend VBN 42759 4544 7 by by IN 42759 4544 8 many many JJ 42759 4544 9 other other JJ 42759 4544 10 English english JJ 42759 4544 11 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 4544 12 writers writer NNS 42759 4544 13 , , , 42759 4544 14 and and CC 42759 4544 15 were be VBD 42759 4544 16 introduced introduce VBN 42759 4544 17 into into IN 42759 4544 18 France France NNP 42759 4544 19 by by IN 42759 4544 20 the the DT 42759 4544 21 followers follower NNS 42759 4544 22 of of IN 42759 4544 23 Saint Saint NNP 42759 4544 24 - - HYPH 42759 4544 25 Simon Simon NNP 42759 4544 26 . . . 42759 4545 1 " " `` 42759 4545 2 From from IN 42759 4545 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4545 4 works work NNS 42759 4545 5 , , , 42759 4545 6 " " '' 42759 4545 7 says say VBZ 42759 4545 8 Menger Menger NNP 42759 4545 9 , , , 42759 4545 10 " " `` 42759 4545 11 the the DT 42759 4545 12 later later JJ 42759 4545 13 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 4545 14 , , , 42759 4545 15 the the DT 42759 4545 16 Saint Saint NNP 42759 4545 17 - - HYPH 42759 4545 18 Simonians Simonians NNPS 42759 4545 19 , , , 42759 4545 20 Proudhon Proudhon NNP 42759 4545 21 , , , 42759 4545 22 and and CC 42759 4545 23 above above IN 42759 4545 24 all all DT 42759 4545 25 , , , 42759 4545 26 Marx Marx NNP 42759 4545 27 and and CC 42759 4545 28 Rodbertus Rodbertus NNP 42759 4545 29 , , , 42759 4545 30 have have VBP 42759 4545 31 directly directly RB 42759 4545 32 or or CC 42759 4545 33 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 4545 34 drawn draw VBD 42759 4545 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4545 36 opinions opinion NNS 42759 4545 37 . . . 42759 4546 1 " " `` 42759 4546 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4546 3 229 229 CD 42759 4546 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4546 5 Although Although NNP 42759 4546 6 Saint Saint NNP 42759 4546 7 - - HYPH 42759 4546 8 Simon Simon NNP 42759 4546 9 never never RB 42759 4546 10 accepted accept VBD 42759 4546 11 the the DT 42759 4546 12 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4546 13 of of IN 42759 4546 14 the the DT 42759 4546 15 labourer labourer NN 42759 4546 16 's 's POS 42759 4546 17 right right NN 42759 4546 18 to to IN 42759 4546 19 the the DT 42759 4546 20 whole whole JJ 42759 4546 21 product product NN 42759 4546 22 , , , 42759 4546 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4546 24 disciples disciple NNS 42759 4546 25 , , , 42759 4546 26 particularly particularly RB 42759 4546 27 Enfantin Enfantin NNP 42759 4546 28 and and CC 42759 4546 29 Bazard Bazard NNP 42759 4546 30 , , , 42759 4546 31 taught teach VBD 42759 4546 32 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4546 33 implicitly implicitly RB 42759 4546 34 . . . 42759 4547 1 In in IN 42759 4547 2 a a DT 42759 4547 3 just just RB 42759 4547 4 social social JJ 42759 4547 5 state state NN 42759 4547 6 , , , 42759 4547 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4547 8 maintained maintain VBD 42759 4547 9 , , , 42759 4547 10 every every DT 42759 4547 11 one one NN 42759 4547 12 would would MD 42759 4547 13 be be VB 42759 4547 14 expected expect VBN 42759 4547 15 to to IN 42759 4547 16 labour labour NN 42759 4547 17 according accord VBG 42759 4547 18 to to IN 42759 4547 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4547 20 capacity capacity NN 42759 4547 21 , , , 42759 4547 22 and and CC 42759 4547 23 would would MD 42759 4547 24 be be VB 42759 4547 25 rewarded reward VBN 42759 4547 26 according accord VBG 42759 4547 27 to to IN 42759 4547 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4547 29 product product NN 42759 4547 30 . . . 42759 4548 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4548 2 230 230 CD 42759 4548 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4548 4 Perhaps perhaps RB 42759 4548 5 the the DT 42759 4548 6 most most RBS 42759 4548 7 theoretical theoretical JJ 42759 4548 8 and and CC 42759 4548 9 extreme extreme JJ 42759 4548 10 statement statement NN 42759 4548 11 of of IN 42759 4548 12 the the DT 42759 4548 13 theory theory NN 42759 4548 14 that that IN 42759 4548 15 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4548 16 are be VBP 42759 4548 17 considering consider VBG 42759 4548 18 is be VBZ 42759 4548 19 found find VBN 42759 4548 20 in in IN 42759 4548 21 the the DT 42759 4548 22 writings writing NNS 42759 4548 23 of of IN 42759 4548 24 P. P. NNP 42759 4548 25 J. J. NNP 42759 4549 1 Proudhon Proudhon NNP 42759 4549 2 . . . 42759 4550 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4550 2 231 231 CD 42759 4550 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4550 4 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4550 5 maintained maintain VBD 42759 4550 6 that that IN 42759 4550 7 the the DT 42759 4550 8 real real JJ 42759 4550 9 value value NN 42759 4550 10 of of IN 42759 4550 11 products product NNS 42759 4550 12 was be VBD 42759 4550 13 determined determine VBN 42759 4550 14 by by IN 42759 4550 15 labour labour NN 42759 4550 16 time time NN 42759 4550 17 , , , 42759 4550 18 and and CC 42759 4550 19 that that IN 42759 4550 20 all all DT 42759 4550 21 kinds kind NNS 42759 4550 22 of of IN 42759 4550 23 labour labour NN 42759 4550 24 should should MD 42759 4550 25 be be VB 42759 4550 26 regarded regard VBN 42759 4550 27 as as IN 42759 4550 28 equally equally RB 42759 4550 29 effective effective JJ 42759 4550 30 in in IN 42759 4550 31 the the DT 42759 4550 32 value value NN 42759 4550 33 - - HYPH 42759 4550 34 creating create VBG 42759 4550 35 process process NN 42759 4550 36 , , , 42759 4550 37 and and CC 42759 4550 38 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4550 39 advocated advocate VBD 42759 4550 40 therefore therefore RB 42759 4550 41 equality equality NN 42759 4550 42 of of IN 42759 4550 43 wages wage NNS 42759 4550 44 and and CC 42759 4550 45 salaries salary NNS 42759 4550 46 . . . 42759 4551 1 For for IN 42759 4551 2 the the DT 42759 4551 3 realisation realisation NN 42759 4551 4 of of IN 42759 4551 5 this this DT 42759 4551 6 ideal ideal NN 42759 4551 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4551 8 drew draw VBD 42759 4551 9 the the DT 42759 4551 10 outlines outline NNS 42759 4551 11 of of IN 42759 4551 12 a a DT 42759 4551 13 semi semi JJ 42759 4551 14 - - JJ 42759 4551 15 anarchic anarchic JJ 42759 4551 16 social social JJ 42759 4551 17 order order NN 42759 4551 18 , , , 42759 4551 19 of of IN 42759 4551 20 which which WDT 42759 4551 21 the the DT 42759 4551 22 main main JJ 42759 4551 23 feature feature NN 42759 4551 24 was be VBD 42759 4551 25 gratuitous gratuitous JJ 42759 4551 26 public public JJ 42759 4551 27 credit credit NN 42759 4551 28 . . . 42759 4552 1 Neither neither CC 42759 4552 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4552 3 theories theory NNS 42759 4552 4 nor nor CC 42759 4552 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4552 6 proposals proposal NNS 42759 4552 7 ever ever RB 42759 4552 8 obtained obtain VBD 42759 4552 9 any any DT 42759 4552 10 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4552 11 number number NN 42759 4552 12 of of IN 42759 4552 13 adherents adherent NNS 42759 4552 14 . . . 42759 4553 1 A a DT 42759 4553 2 milder milder NN 42759 4553 3 and and CC 42759 4553 4 better well JJR 42759 4553 5 reasoned reason VBN 42759 4553 6 form form NN 42759 4553 7 of of IN 42759 4553 8 the the DT 42759 4553 9 theory theory NN 42759 4553 10 was be VBD 42759 4553 11 set set VBN 42759 4553 12 forth forth RP 42759 4553 13 by by IN 42759 4553 14 Karl Karl NNP 42759 4553 15 J. J. NNP 42759 4554 1 Rodbertus Rodbertus NNP 42759 4554 2 . . . 42759 4555 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4555 2 232 232 CD 42759 4555 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4555 4 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4555 5 Wagner Wagner NNP 42759 4555 6 calls call VBZ 42759 4555 7 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4555 8 , , , 42759 4555 9 " " `` 42759 4555 10 the the DT 42759 4555 11 first first JJ 42759 4555 12 , , , 42759 4555 13 the the DT 42759 4555 14 most most RBS 42759 4555 15 original original JJ 42759 4555 16 , , , 42759 4555 17 and and CC 42759 4555 18 the the DT 42759 4555 19 boldest bold JJS 42759 4555 20 representative representative NN 42759 4555 21 of of IN 42759 4555 22 scientific scientific JJ 42759 4555 23 Socialism socialism NN 42759 4555 24 in in IN 42759 4555 25 Germany Germany NNP 42759 4555 26 . . . 42759 4555 27 " " '' 42759 4556 1 Yet yet RB 42759 4556 2 , , , 42759 4556 3 as as IN 42759 4556 4 Menger Menger NNP 42759 4556 5 points point VBZ 42759 4556 6 out out RP 42759 4556 7 , , , 42759 4556 8 Rodbertus Rodbertus NNP 42759 4556 9 derived derive VBD 42759 4556 10 many many JJ 42759 4556 11 of of IN 42759 4556 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4556 13 doctrines doctrine NNS 42759 4556 14 from from IN 42759 4556 15 Proudhon Proudhon NNP 42759 4556 16 and and CC 42759 4556 17 the the DT 42759 4556 18 Saint Saint NNP 42759 4556 19 - - HYPH 42759 4556 20 Simonians Simonians NNPS 42759 4556 21 . . . 42759 4557 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4557 2 admitted admit VBD 42759 4557 3 that that IN 42759 4557 4 in in IN 42759 4557 5 a a DT 42759 4557 6 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 4557 7 society society NN 42759 4557 8 the the DT 42759 4557 9 value value NN 42759 4557 10 of of IN 42759 4557 11 commodities commodity NNS 42759 4557 12 does do VBZ 42759 4557 13 not not RB 42759 4557 14 always always RB 42759 4557 15 correspond correspond VB 42759 4557 16 to to IN 42759 4557 17 the the DT 42759 4557 18 labour labour NN 42759 4557 19 embodied embody VBN 42759 4557 20 in in IN 42759 4557 21 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4557 22 , , , 42759 4557 23 and and CC 42759 4557 24 that that IN 42759 4557 25 different different JJ 42759 4557 26 kinds kind NNS 42759 4557 27 of of IN 42759 4557 28 labour labour NN 42759 4557 29 are be VBP 42759 4557 30 productive productive JJ 42759 4557 31 in in IN 42759 4557 32 different different JJ 42759 4557 33 degrees degree NNS 42759 4557 34 . . . 42759 4558 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 4558 2 , , , 42759 4558 3 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4558 4 had have VBD 42759 4558 5 recourse recourse JJ 42759 4558 6 to to IN 42759 4558 7 the the DT 42759 4558 8 concept concept NN 42759 4558 9 of of IN 42759 4558 10 a a DT 42759 4558 11 normal normal JJ 42759 4558 12 , , , 42759 4558 13 or or CC 42759 4558 14 average average JJ 42759 4558 15 , , , 42759 4558 16 day day NN 42759 4558 17 's 's POS 42759 4558 18 labour labour NN 42759 4558 19 in in IN 42759 4558 20 any any DT 42759 4558 21 group group NN 42759 4558 22 , , , 42759 4558 23 and and CC 42759 4558 24 would would MD 42759 4558 25 have have VB 42759 4558 26 the the DT 42759 4558 27 various various JJ 42759 4558 28 members member NNS 42759 4558 29 of of IN 42759 4558 30 the the DT 42759 4558 31 group group NN 42759 4558 32 remunerated remunerate VBN 42759 4558 33 with with IN 42759 4558 34 reference reference NN 42759 4558 35 to to IN 42759 4558 36 this this DT 42759 4558 37 standard standard NN 42759 4558 38 . . . 42759 4559 1 This this DT 42759 4559 2 was be VBD 42759 4559 3 to to TO 42759 4559 4 be be VB 42759 4559 5 brought bring VBN 42759 4559 6 about about RP 42759 4559 7 by by IN 42759 4559 8 a a DT 42759 4559 9 centralised centralise VBN 42759 4559 10 organisation organisation NN 42759 4559 11 of of IN 42759 4559 12 industry industry NN 42759 4559 13 in in IN 42759 4559 14 which which WDT 42759 4559 15 the the DT 42759 4559 16 whole whole JJ 42759 4559 17 product product NN 42759 4559 18 would would MD 42759 4559 19 ultimately ultimately RB 42759 4559 20 go go VB 42759 4559 21 to to IN 42759 4559 22 labour labour NN 42759 4559 23 , , , 42759 4559 24 and and CC 42759 4559 25 the the DT 42759 4559 26 share share NN 42759 4559 27 of of IN 42759 4559 28 the the DT 42759 4559 29 individual individual JJ 42759 4559 30 worker worker NN 42759 4559 31 would would MD 42759 4559 32 be be VB 42759 4559 33 determined determine VBN 42759 4559 34 by by IN 42759 4559 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4559 36 contribution contribution NN 42759 4559 37 of of IN 42759 4559 38 socially socially RB 42759 4559 39 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4559 40 labour labour NN 42759 4559 41 . . . 42759 4560 1 Although although IN 42759 4560 2 Karl Karl NNP 42759 4560 3 Marx Marx NNP 42759 4560 4 adopted adopt VBD 42759 4560 5 and and CC 42759 4560 6 formulated formulate VBN 42759 4560 7 in in IN 42759 4560 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4560 9 own own JJ 42759 4560 10 terms term NNS 42759 4560 11 the the DT 42759 4560 12 theory theory NN 42759 4560 13 that that IN 42759 4560 14 value value NN 42759 4560 15 is be VBZ 42759 4560 16 determined determine VBN 42759 4560 17 by by IN 42759 4560 18 labour labour NN 42759 4560 19 , , , 42759 4560 20 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4560 21 did do VBD 42759 4560 22 not not RB 42759 4560 23 thence thence NN 42759 4560 24 deduce deduce VB 42759 4560 25 the the DT 42759 4560 26 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 4560 27 that that IN 42759 4560 28 labour labour NN 42759 4560 29 has have VBZ 42759 4560 30 a a DT 42759 4560 31 right right NN 42759 4560 32 to to IN 42759 4560 33 the the DT 42759 4560 34 whole whole JJ 42759 4560 35 product product NN 42759 4560 36 . . . 42759 4561 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4561 2 233 233 CD 42759 4561 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4561 4 Being be VBG 42759 4561 5 a a DT 42759 4561 6 materialist materialist NN 42759 4561 7 , , , 42759 4561 8 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4561 9 consistently consistently RB 42759 4561 10 rejected reject VBD 42759 4561 11 conceptions conception NNS 42759 4561 12 of of IN 42759 4561 13 abstract abstract JJ 42759 4561 14 justice justice NN 42759 4561 15 or or CC 42759 4561 16 injustice injustice NN 42759 4561 17 , , , 42759 4561 18 rights right NNS 42759 4561 19 or or CC 42759 4561 20 wrongs wrong NNS 42759 4561 21 . . . 42759 4562 1 In in IN 42759 4562 2 opposition opposition NN 42759 4562 3 to to IN 42759 4562 4 the the DT 42759 4562 5 methods method NNS 42759 4562 6 of of IN 42759 4562 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4562 8 predecessors predecessor NNS 42759 4562 9 , , , 42759 4562 10 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4562 11 endeavoured endeavour VBD 42759 4562 12 to to TO 42759 4562 13 discover discover VB 42759 4562 14 the the DT 42759 4562 15 historical historical JJ 42759 4562 16 and and CC 42759 4562 17 positive positive JJ 42759 4562 18 forces force NNS 42759 4562 19 which which WDT 42759 4562 20 determined determine VBD 42759 4562 21 the the DT 42759 4562 22 actual actual JJ 42759 4562 23 distribution distribution NN 42759 4562 24 , , , 42759 4562 25 and and CC 42759 4562 26 to to TO 42759 4562 27 derive derive VB 42759 4562 28 therefrom therefrom NN 42759 4562 29 the the DT 42759 4562 30 laws law NNS 42759 4562 31 that that WDT 42759 4562 32 were be VBD 42759 4562 33 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 4562 34 preparing prepare VBG 42759 4562 35 the the DT 42759 4562 36 way way NN 42759 4562 37 for for IN 42759 4562 38 a a DT 42759 4562 39 new new JJ 42759 4562 40 social social JJ 42759 4562 41 order order NN 42759 4562 42 . . . 42759 4563 1 While while IN 42759 4563 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4563 3 contended contend VBD 42759 4563 4 that that IN 42759 4563 5 rent rent NN 42759 4563 6 receivers receiver NNS 42759 4563 7 and and CC 42759 4563 8 interest interest NN 42759 4563 9 receivers receiver NNS 42759 4563 10 appropriated appropriate VBD 42759 4563 11 the the DT 42759 4563 12 surplus surplus NN 42759 4563 13 value value NN 42759 4563 14 created create VBN 42759 4563 15 by by IN 42759 4563 16 labour labour NN 42759 4563 17 , , , 42759 4563 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4563 19 refrained refrain VBD 42759 4563 20 from from IN 42759 4563 21 stigmatising stigmatise VBG 42759 4563 22 this this DT 42759 4563 23 process process NN 42759 4563 24 as as RB 42759 4563 25 morally morally RB 42759 4563 26 wrong wrong JJ 42759 4563 27 . . . 42759 4564 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4564 2 was be VBD 42759 4564 3 merely merely RB 42759 4564 4 a a DT 42759 4564 5 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4564 6 element element NN 42759 4564 7 of of IN 42759 4564 8 the the DT 42759 4564 9 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 4564 10 system system NN 42759 4564 11 . . . 42759 4565 1 To to TO 42759 4565 2 call call VB 42759 4565 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4565 4 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4565 5 was be VBD 42759 4565 6 in in IN 42759 4565 7 Marx Marx NNP 42759 4565 8 ' ' POS 42759 4565 9 view view NN 42759 4565 10 to to TO 42759 4565 11 use use VB 42759 4565 12 language language NN 42759 4565 13 without without IN 42759 4565 14 meaning meaning NN 42759 4565 15 . . . 42759 4566 1 As as IN 42759 4566 2 well well RB 42759 4566 3 might may MD 42759 4566 4 one one PRP 42759 4566 5 speak speak VB 42759 4566 6 of of IN 42759 4566 7 the the DT 42759 4566 8 injustice injustice NN 42759 4566 9 of of IN 42759 4566 10 a a DT 42759 4566 11 hurricane hurricane NN 42759 4566 12 or or CC 42759 4566 13 an an DT 42759 4566 14 avalanche avalanche NN 42759 4566 15 . . . 42759 4567 1 Not not RB 42759 4567 2 the the DT 42759 4567 3 preaching preaching NN 42759 4567 4 of of IN 42759 4567 5 abstract abstract JJ 42759 4567 6 justice justice NN 42759 4567 7 , , , 42759 4567 8 but but CC 42759 4567 9 the the DT 42759 4567 10 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 4567 11 transformation transformation NN 42759 4567 12 of of IN 42759 4567 13 the the DT 42759 4567 14 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4567 15 into into IN 42759 4567 16 the the DT 42759 4567 17 collectivist collectivist JJ 42759 4567 18 organisation organisation NN 42759 4567 19 of of IN 42759 4567 20 industry industry NN 42759 4567 21 , , , 42759 4567 22 would would MD 42759 4567 23 enable enable VB 42759 4567 24 labour labour NN 42759 4567 25 to to TO 42759 4567 26 obtain obtain VB 42759 4567 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4567 28 full full JJ 42759 4567 29 product product NN 42759 4567 30 . . . 42759 4568 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 4568 2 , , , 42759 4568 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4568 4 is be VBZ 42759 4568 5 probably probably RB 42759 4568 6 true true JJ 42759 4568 7 that that IN 42759 4568 8 a a DT 42759 4568 9 majority majority NN 42759 4568 10 of of IN 42759 4568 11 the the DT 42759 4568 12 followers follower NNS 42759 4568 13 of of IN 42759 4568 14 Marx Marx NNP 42759 4568 15 have have VBP 42759 4568 16 drawn draw VBN 42759 4568 17 from from IN 42759 4568 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4568 19 labour labour NN 42759 4568 20 theory theory NN 42759 4568 21 of of IN 42759 4568 22 value value NN 42759 4568 23 the the DT 42759 4568 24 inference inference NN 42759 4568 25 that that IN 42759 4568 26 all all PDT 42759 4568 27 the the DT 42759 4568 28 value value NN 42759 4568 29 of of IN 42759 4568 30 the the DT 42759 4568 31 product product NN 42759 4568 32 belongs belong VBZ 42759 4568 33 by by IN 42759 4568 34 a a DT 42759 4568 35 moral moral JJ 42759 4568 36 right right NN 42759 4568 37 to to IN 42759 4568 38 the the DT 42759 4568 39 labourer labourer NN 42759 4568 40 . . . 42759 4569 1 So so RB 42759 4569 2 deeply deeply RB 42759 4569 3 fixed fix VBN 42759 4569 4 in in IN 42759 4569 5 the the DT 42759 4569 6 human human JJ 42759 4569 7 conscience conscience NN 42759 4569 8 is be VBZ 42759 4569 9 the the DT 42759 4569 10 conception conception NN 42759 4569 11 of of IN 42759 4569 12 justice justice NN 42759 4569 13 , , , 42759 4569 14 and and CC 42759 4569 15 so so RB 42759 4569 16 general general JJ 42759 4569 17 is be VBZ 42759 4569 18 the the DT 42759 4569 19 conviction conviction NN 42759 4569 20 of of IN 42759 4569 21 the the DT 42759 4569 22 labourer labourer NN 42759 4569 23 's 's POS 42759 4569 24 right right NN 42759 4569 25 to to IN 42759 4569 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4569 27 product product NN 42759 4569 28 , , , 42759 4569 29 that that IN 42759 4569 30 most most JJS 42759 4569 31 Socialists socialist NNS 42759 4569 32 have have VBP 42759 4569 33 not not RB 42759 4569 34 been be VBN 42759 4569 35 able able JJ 42759 4569 36 to to TO 42759 4569 37 maintain maintain VB 42759 4569 38 a a DT 42759 4569 39 position position NN 42759 4569 40 of of IN 42759 4569 41 consistent consistent JJ 42759 4569 42 economic economic JJ 42759 4569 43 materialism materialism NN 42759 4569 44 . . . 42759 4570 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 4570 2 , , , 42759 4570 3 Marx Marx NNP 42759 4570 4 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4570 5 did do VBD 42759 4570 6 not not RB 42759 4570 7 always always RB 42759 4570 8 succeed succeed VB 42759 4570 9 in in IN 42759 4570 10 evading evade VBG 42759 4570 11 the the DT 42759 4570 12 influence influence NN 42759 4570 13 and and CC 42759 4570 14 the the DT 42759 4570 15 terminology terminology NN 42759 4570 16 of of IN 42759 4570 17 idealistic idealistic JJ 42759 4570 18 conceptions conception NNS 42759 4570 19 . . . 42759 4571 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4571 2 frequently frequently RB 42759 4571 3 thought think VBD 42759 4571 4 and and CC 42759 4571 5 spoke speak VBD 42759 4571 6 of of IN 42759 4571 7 the the DT 42759 4571 8 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 4571 9 régime régime NN 42759 4571 10 as as IN 42759 4571 11 not not RB 42759 4571 12 only only RB 42759 4571 13 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 4571 14 but but CC 42759 4571 15 as as RB 42759 4571 16 morally morally RB 42759 4571 17 right right JJ 42759 4571 18 , , , 42759 4571 19 and and CC 42759 4571 20 of of IN 42759 4571 21 the the DT 42759 4571 22 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 4571 23 system system NN 42759 4571 24 as as RB 42759 4571 25 morally morally RB 42759 4571 26 wrong wrong JJ 42759 4571 27 . . . 42759 4572 1 Despite despite IN 42759 4572 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4572 3 rigid rigid JJ 42759 4572 4 , , , 42759 4572 5 materialistic materialistic JJ 42759 4572 6 theorising theorising NN 42759 4572 7 , , , 42759 4572 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4572 9 writings writing NNS 42759 4572 10 abound abound VBP 42759 4572 11 in in IN 42759 4572 12 passionate passionate JJ 42759 4572 13 denunciation denunciation NN 42759 4572 14 of of IN 42759 4572 15 existing exist VBG 42759 4572 16 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4572 17 evils evil NNS 42759 4572 18 , , , 42759 4572 19 and and CC 42759 4572 20 in in IN 42759 4572 21 many many JJ 42759 4572 22 sorts sort NNS 42759 4572 23 of of IN 42759 4572 24 " " `` 42759 4572 25 unscientific unscientific JJ 42759 4572 26 " " '' 42759 4572 27 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4572 28 judgments judgment NNS 42759 4572 29 . . . 42759 4573 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4573 2 234 234 CD 42759 4573 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4573 4 In in IN 42759 4573 5 so so RB 42759 4573 6 far far RB 42759 4573 7 as as IN 42759 4573 8 the the DT 42759 4573 9 right right NN 42759 4573 10 to to IN 42759 4573 11 the the DT 42759 4573 12 whole whole JJ 42759 4573 13 product product NN 42759 4573 14 of of IN 42759 4573 15 labour labour NN 42759 4573 16 has have VBZ 42759 4573 17 been be VBN 42759 4573 18 based base VBN 42759 4573 19 upon upon IN 42759 4573 20 the the DT 42759 4573 21 labour labour NN 42759 4573 22 theory theory NN 42759 4573 23 of of IN 42759 4573 24 value value NN 42759 4573 25 , , , 42759 4573 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4573 27 may may MD 42759 4573 28 be be VB 42759 4573 29 summarily summarily RB 42759 4573 30 dismissed dismiss VBN 42759 4573 31 from from IN 42759 4573 32 consideration consideration NN 42759 4573 33 . . . 42759 4574 1 The the DT 42759 4574 2 value value NN 42759 4574 3 of of IN 42759 4574 4 products product NNS 42759 4574 5 is be VBZ 42759 4574 6 neither neither CC 42759 4574 7 created create VBN 42759 4574 8 nor nor CC 42759 4574 9 adequately adequately RB 42759 4574 10 measured measure VBN 42759 4574 11 by by IN 42759 4574 12 labour labour NN 42759 4574 13 ; ; : 42759 4574 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4574 15 is be VBZ 42759 4574 16 determined determine VBN 42759 4574 17 by by IN 42759 4574 18 utility utility NN 42759 4574 19 and and CC 42759 4574 20 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 4574 21 . . . 42759 4575 1 Labour labour NN 42759 4575 2 does do VBZ 42759 4575 3 , , , 42759 4575 4 indeed indeed RB 42759 4575 5 , , , 42759 4575 6 affect affect VB 42759 4575 7 value value NN 42759 4575 8 , , , 42759 4575 9 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 4575 10 as as IN 42759 4575 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4575 12 increases increase VBZ 42759 4575 13 utility utility NN 42759 4575 14 and and CC 42759 4575 15 diminishes diminish VBZ 42759 4575 16 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 4575 17 , , , 42759 4575 18 but but CC 42759 4575 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4575 20 is be VBZ 42759 4575 21 not not RB 42759 4575 22 the the DT 42759 4575 23 only only JJ 42759 4575 24 factor factor NN 42759 4575 25 that that WDT 42759 4575 26 influences influence VBZ 42759 4575 27 these these DT 42759 4575 28 categories category NNS 42759 4575 29 . . . 42759 4576 1 Natural natural JJ 42759 4576 2 resources resource NNS 42759 4576 3 , , , 42759 4576 4 the the DT 42759 4576 5 desires desire NNS 42759 4576 6 and and CC 42759 4576 7 the the DT 42759 4576 8 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 4576 9 power power NN 42759 4576 10 of of IN 42759 4576 11 consumers consumer NNS 42759 4576 12 determine determine VBP 42759 4576 13 value value NN 42759 4576 14 quite quite RB 42759 4576 15 as as RB 42759 4576 16 fundamentally fundamentally RB 42759 4576 17 as as IN 42759 4576 18 does do VBZ 42759 4576 19 labour labour NN 42759 4576 20 , , , 42759 4576 21 and and CC 42759 4576 22 cause cause VB 42759 4576 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4576 24 to to TO 42759 4576 25 vary vary VB 42759 4576 26 out out IN 42759 4576 27 of of IN 42759 4576 28 proportion proportion NN 42759 4576 29 to to IN 42759 4576 30 the the DT 42759 4576 31 labour labour NN 42759 4576 32 expended expend VBN 42759 4576 33 upon upon IN 42759 4576 34 a a DT 42759 4576 35 commodity commodity NN 42759 4576 36 . . . 42759 4577 1 To to NN 42759 4577 2 - - HYPH 42759 4577 3 day day NN 42759 4577 4 there there EX 42759 4577 5 are be VBP 42759 4577 6 probably probably RB 42759 4577 7 not not RB 42759 4577 8 many many JJ 42759 4577 9 adherents adherent NNS 42759 4577 10 of of IN 42759 4577 11 the the DT 42759 4577 12 right right NN 42759 4577 13 - - HYPH 42759 4577 14 to to IN 42759 4577 15 - - HYPH 42759 4577 16 the the DT 42759 4577 17 - - HYPH 42759 4577 18 whole whole JJ 42759 4577 19 - - HYPH 42759 4577 20 product product NN 42759 4577 21 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4577 22 who who WP 42759 4577 23 attempt attempt VBP 42759 4577 24 to to TO 42759 4577 25 base base VB 42759 4577 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4577 27 upon upon IN 42759 4577 28 any any DT 42759 4577 29 theory theory NN 42759 4577 30 of of IN 42759 4577 31 value value NN 42759 4577 32 . . . 42759 4578 1 The the DT 42759 4578 2 majority majority NN 42759 4578 3 appeal appeal VBP 42759 4578 4 to to IN 42759 4578 5 the the DT 42759 4578 6 simple simple JJ 42759 4578 7 and and CC 42759 4578 8 obvious obvious JJ 42759 4578 9 fact fact NN 42759 4578 10 that that IN 42759 4578 11 the the DT 42759 4578 12 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4578 13 , , , 42759 4578 14 together together RB 42759 4578 15 with with IN 42759 4578 16 the the DT 42759 4578 17 active active JJ 42759 4578 18 directors director NNS 42759 4578 19 of of IN 42759 4578 20 industry industry NN 42759 4578 21 , , , 42759 4578 22 are be VBP 42759 4578 23 the the DT 42759 4578 24 only only JJ 42759 4578 25 human human JJ 42759 4578 26 beings being NNS 42759 4578 27 who who WP 42759 4578 28 expend expend VBP 42759 4578 29 energy energy NN 42759 4578 30 in in IN 42759 4578 31 the the DT 42759 4578 32 productive productive JJ 42759 4578 33 process process NN 42759 4578 34 . . . 42759 4579 1 The the DT 42759 4579 2 only only JJ 42759 4579 3 labour labour NN 42759 4579 4 that that WDT 42759 4579 5 the the DT 42759 4579 6 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4579 7 and and CC 42759 4579 8 the the DT 42759 4579 9 landowner landowner NN 42759 4579 10 perform perform VBP 42759 4579 11 in in IN 42759 4579 12 return return NN 42759 4579 13 for for IN 42759 4579 14 the the DT 42759 4579 15 interest interest NN 42759 4579 16 and and CC 42759 4579 17 rent rent VB 42759 4579 18 that that IN 42759 4579 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4579 20 respectively respectively RB 42759 4579 21 receive receive VBP 42759 4579 22 , , , 42759 4579 23 consists consist VBZ 42759 4579 24 in in IN 42759 4579 25 choosing choose VBG 42759 4579 26 the the DT 42759 4579 27 particular particular JJ 42759 4579 28 goods good NNS 42759 4579 29 in in IN 42759 4579 30 which which WDT 42759 4579 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4579 32 money money NN 42759 4579 33 is be VBZ 42759 4579 34 to to TO 42759 4579 35 be be VB 42759 4579 36 invested invest VBN 42759 4579 37 . . . 42759 4580 1 As as IN 42759 4580 2 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 4580 3 and and CC 42759 4580 4 landowner landowner JJ 42759 4580 5 , , , 42759 4580 6 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4580 7 do do VBP 42759 4580 8 not not RB 42759 4580 9 participate participate VB 42759 4580 10 in in IN 42759 4580 11 the the DT 42759 4580 12 turning turning NN 42759 4580 13 out out IN 42759 4580 14 of of IN 42759 4580 15 products product NNS 42759 4580 16 . . . 42759 4581 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4581 2 are be VBP 42759 4581 3 owners owner NNS 42759 4581 4 but but CC 42759 4581 5 not not RB 42759 4581 6 operators operator NNS 42759 4581 7 of of IN 42759 4581 8 the the DT 42759 4581 9 factors factor NNS 42759 4581 10 of of IN 42759 4581 11 production production NN 42759 4581 12 . . . 42759 4582 1 In in IN 42759 4582 2 the the DT 42759 4582 3 sense sense NN 42759 4582 4 , , , 42759 4582 5 therefore therefore RB 42759 4582 6 , , , 42759 4582 7 of of IN 42759 4582 8 active active JJ 42759 4582 9 agents agent NNS 42759 4582 10 the the DT 42759 4582 11 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4582 12 and and CC 42759 4582 13 the the DT 42759 4582 14 business business NN 42759 4582 15 men man NNS 42759 4582 16 are be VBP 42759 4582 17 the the DT 42759 4582 18 only only JJ 42759 4582 19 producers producer NNS 42759 4582 20 . . . 42759 4583 1 Whether whether IN 42759 4583 2 land land NN 42759 4583 3 and and CC 42759 4583 4 capital capital NN 42759 4583 5 should should MD 42759 4583 6 be be VB 42759 4583 7 called call VBN 42759 4583 8 _ _ NNP 42759 4583 9 productive productive JJ 42759 4583 10 _ _ NNP 42759 4583 11 , , , 42759 4583 12 whether whether IN 42759 4583 13 the the DT 42759 4583 14 product product NN 42759 4583 15 should should MD 42759 4583 16 be be VB 42759 4583 17 regarded regard VBN 42759 4583 18 as as IN 42759 4583 19 _ _ NNP 42759 4583 20 produced produce VBN 42759 4583 21 _ _ NNP 42759 4583 22 by by IN 42759 4583 23 land land NN 42759 4583 24 and and CC 42759 4583 25 capital capital NN 42759 4583 26 as as RB 42759 4583 27 well well RB 42759 4583 28 as as IN 42759 4583 29 by by IN 42759 4583 30 labour labour NN 42759 4583 31 and and CC 42759 4583 32 undertaking undertaking NN 42759 4583 33 activity activity NN 42759 4583 34 , , , 42759 4583 35 is be VBZ 42759 4583 36 mostly mostly RB 42759 4583 37 a a DT 42759 4583 38 matter matter NN 42759 4583 39 of of IN 42759 4583 40 terminology terminology NN 42759 4583 41 . . . 42759 4584 1 Inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 4584 2 as as IN 42759 4584 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4584 4 are be VBP 42759 4584 5 instrumental instrumental JJ 42759 4584 6 in in IN 42759 4584 7 bringing bring VBG 42759 4584 8 forth forth RP 42759 4584 9 the the DT 42759 4584 10 product product NN 42759 4584 11 , , , 42759 4584 12 land land NN 42759 4584 13 and and CC 42759 4584 14 capital capital NN 42759 4584 15 may may MD 42759 4584 16 properly properly RB 42759 4584 17 be be VB 42759 4584 18 designated designate VBN 42759 4584 19 as as IN 42759 4584 20 productive productive JJ 42759 4584 21 , , , 42759 4584 22 but but CC 42759 4584 23 not not RB 42759 4584 24 in in IN 42759 4584 25 the the DT 42759 4584 26 same same JJ 42759 4584 27 sense sense NN 42759 4584 28 as as IN 42759 4584 29 labour labour NN 42759 4584 30 and and CC 42759 4584 31 business business NN 42759 4584 32 energy energy NN 42759 4584 33 . . . 42759 4585 1 The the DT 42759 4585 2 former former JJ 42759 4585 3 are be VBP 42759 4585 4 passive passive JJ 42759 4585 5 factors factor NNS 42759 4585 6 and and CC 42759 4585 7 instrumental instrumental JJ 42759 4585 8 causes cause NNS 42759 4585 9 of of IN 42759 4585 10 the the DT 42759 4585 11 product product NN 42759 4585 12 , , , 42759 4585 13 while while IN 42759 4585 14 the the DT 42759 4585 15 latter latter JJ 42759 4585 16 are be VBP 42759 4585 17 active active JJ 42759 4585 18 factors factor NNS 42759 4585 19 and and CC 42759 4585 20 original original JJ 42759 4585 21 causes cause NNS 42759 4585 22 . . . 42759 4586 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4586 2 , , , 42759 4586 3 the the DT 42759 4586 4 former former JJ 42759 4586 5 are be VBP 42759 4586 6 non non JJ 42759 4586 7 - - JJ 42759 4586 8 rational rational JJ 42759 4586 9 entities entity NNS 42759 4586 10 , , , 42759 4586 11 while while IN 42759 4586 12 the the DT 42759 4586 13 latter latter JJ 42759 4586 14 are be VBP 42759 4586 15 attributes attribute NNS 42759 4586 16 of of IN 42759 4586 17 human human JJ 42759 4586 18 beings being NNS 42759 4586 19 . . . 42759 4587 1 As as IN 42759 4587 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4587 3 have have VBP 42759 4587 4 seen see VBN 42759 4587 5 in in IN 42759 4587 6 former former JJ 42759 4587 7 chapters chapter NNS 42759 4587 8 , , , 42759 4587 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4587 10 is be VBZ 42759 4587 11 impossible impossible JJ 42759 4587 12 to to TO 42759 4587 13 prove prove VB 42759 4587 14 that that IN 42759 4587 15 mere mere JJ 42759 4587 16 ownership ownership NN 42759 4587 17 of of IN 42759 4587 18 a a DT 42759 4587 19 productive productive JJ 42759 4587 20 thing thing NN 42759 4587 21 , , , 42759 4587 22 such such JJ 42759 4587 23 as as IN 42759 4587 24 a a DT 42759 4587 25 cow cow NN 42759 4587 26 , , , 42759 4587 27 a a DT 42759 4587 28 piece piece NN 42759 4587 29 of of IN 42759 4587 30 land land NN 42759 4587 31 , , , 42759 4587 32 or or CC 42759 4587 33 a a DT 42759 4587 34 machine machine NN 42759 4587 35 , , , 42759 4587 36 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 4587 37 creates create VBZ 42759 4587 38 a a DT 42759 4587 39 right right NN 42759 4587 40 to to IN 42759 4587 41 either either CC 42759 4587 42 the the DT 42759 4587 43 concrete concrete NN 42759 4587 44 or or CC 42759 4587 45 the the DT 42759 4587 46 conventional conventional JJ 42759 4587 47 product product NN 42759 4587 48 . . . 42759 4588 1 The the DT 42759 4588 2 formula formula NN 42759 4588 3 , , , 42759 4588 4 " " '' 42759 4588 5 _ _ NNP 42759 4588 6 res re VBZ 42759 4588 7 fructificat fructificat NNP 42759 4588 8 domino domino NNP 42759 4588 9 _ _ NNP 42759 4588 10 , , , 42759 4588 11 " " `` 42759 4588 12 is be VBZ 42759 4588 13 not not RB 42759 4588 14 a a DT 42759 4588 15 self self NN 42759 4588 16 evident evident JJ 42759 4588 17 proposition proposition NN 42759 4588 18 . . . 42759 4589 1 Nor nor CC 42759 4589 2 are be VBP 42759 4589 3 there there EX 42759 4589 4 any any DT 42759 4589 5 premises premise NNS 42759 4589 6 available available JJ 42759 4589 7 from from IN 42759 4589 8 which which WDT 42759 4589 9 the the DT 42759 4589 10 formula formula NN 42759 4589 11 can can MD 42759 4589 12 be be VB 42759 4589 13 logically logically RB 42759 4589 14 and and CC 42759 4589 15 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 4589 16 deduced deduce VBN 42759 4589 17 . . . 42759 4590 1 On on IN 42759 4590 2 the the DT 42759 4590 3 other other JJ 42759 4590 4 hand hand NN 42759 4590 5 , , , 42759 4590 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4590 7 can can MD 42759 4590 8 not not RB 42759 4590 9 prove prove VB 42759 4590 10 conclusively conclusively RB 42759 4590 11 that that DT 42759 4590 12 ownership ownership NN 42759 4590 13 of of IN 42759 4590 14 productive productive JJ 42759 4590 15 property property NN 42759 4590 16 does do VBZ 42759 4590 17 _ _ NNP 42759 4590 18 not not RB 42759 4590 19 _ _ NNP 42759 4590 20 give give VB 42759 4590 21 a a DT 42759 4590 22 right right NN 42759 4590 23 to to IN 42759 4590 24 the the DT 42759 4590 25 product product NN 42759 4590 26 . . . 42759 4591 1 Whence whence IN 42759 4591 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4591 3 follows follow VBZ 42759 4591 4 that that IN 42759 4591 5 the the DT 42759 4591 6 owners owner NNS 42759 4591 7 of of IN 42759 4591 8 land land NN 42759 4591 9 and and CC 42759 4591 10 capital capital NN 42759 4591 11 have have VBP 42759 4591 12 at at IN 42759 4591 13 least least JJS 42759 4591 14 a a DT 42759 4591 15 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 4591 16 claim claim NN 42759 4591 17 to to TO 42759 4591 18 take take VB 42759 4591 19 rent rent NN 42759 4591 20 and and CC 42759 4591 21 interest interest NN 42759 4591 22 from from IN 42759 4591 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4591 24 possessions possession NNS 42759 4591 25 . . . 42759 4592 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4592 2 , , , 42759 4592 3 those those DT 42759 4592 4 owners owner NNS 42759 4592 5 of of IN 42759 4592 6 capital capital NN 42759 4592 7 who who WP 42759 4592 8 would would MD 42759 4592 9 not not RB 42759 4592 10 have have VB 42759 4592 11 saved save VBN 42759 4592 12 money money NN 42759 4592 13 without without IN 42759 4592 14 the the DT 42759 4592 15 hope hope NN 42759 4592 16 of of IN 42759 4592 17 interest interest NN 42759 4592 18 have have VBP 42759 4592 19 a a DT 42759 4592 20 just just RB 42759 4592 21 claim claim NN 42759 4592 22 thereto thereto NN 42759 4592 23 on on IN 42759 4592 24 account account NN 42759 4592 25 of of IN 42759 4592 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4592 27 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 4592 28 in in IN 42759 4592 29 saving saving NN 42759 4592 30 . . . 42759 4593 1 Would Would MD 42759 4593 2 the the DT 42759 4593 3 State state NN 42759 4593 4 be be VB 42759 4593 5 justified justify VBN 42759 4593 6 in in IN 42759 4593 7 abolishing abolish VBG 42759 4593 8 rent rent NN 42759 4593 9 and and CC 42759 4593 10 interest interest NN 42759 4593 11 , , , 42759 4593 12 and and CC 42759 4593 13 thus thus RB 42759 4593 14 enabling enable VBG 42759 4593 15 labour labour NN 42759 4593 16 to to TO 42759 4593 17 obtain obtain VB 42759 4593 18 the the DT 42759 4593 19 whole whole JJ 42759 4593 20 product product NN 42759 4593 21 ? ? . 42759 4594 1 Conceivably conceivably RB 42759 4594 2 this this DT 42759 4594 3 result result NN 42759 4594 4 might may MD 42759 4594 5 be be VB 42759 4594 6 brought bring VBN 42759 4594 7 about about RP 42759 4594 8 under under IN 42759 4594 9 the the DT 42759 4594 10 present present JJ 42759 4594 11 system system NN 42759 4594 12 of of IN 42759 4594 13 private private JJ 42759 4594 14 ownership ownership NN 42759 4594 15 , , , 42759 4594 16 or or CC 42759 4594 17 through through IN 42759 4594 18 the the DT 42759 4594 19 substitution substitution NN 42759 4594 20 of of IN 42759 4594 21 collectivism collectivism NN 42759 4594 22 . . . 42759 4595 1 Were be VBD 42759 4595 2 the the DT 42759 4595 3 change change NN 42759 4595 4 made make VBN 42759 4595 5 by by IN 42759 4595 6 the the DT 42759 4595 7 former former JJ 42759 4595 8 method method NN 42759 4595 9 land land NN 42759 4595 10 and and CC 42759 4595 11 capital capital NN 42759 4595 12 would would MD 42759 4595 13 no no RB 42759 4595 14 longer longer RB 42759 4595 15 be be VB 42759 4595 16 sought seek VBN 42759 4595 17 or or CC 42759 4595 18 have have VB 42759 4595 19 value value NN 42759 4595 20 on on IN 42759 4595 21 account account NN 42759 4595 22 of of IN 42759 4595 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4595 24 annual annual JJ 42759 4595 25 revenues revenue NNS 42759 4595 26 , , , 42759 4595 27 but but CC 42759 4595 28 only only RB 42759 4595 29 as as IN 42759 4595 30 receptacles receptacle NNS 42759 4595 31 of of IN 42759 4595 32 saving saving NN 42759 4595 33 . . . 42759 4596 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4596 2 would would MD 42759 4596 3 be be VB 42759 4596 4 desired desire VBN 42759 4596 5 solely solely RB 42759 4596 6 as as IN 42759 4596 7 means mean NNS 42759 4596 8 of of IN 42759 4596 9 accumulating accumulate VBG 42759 4596 10 stores store NNS 42759 4596 11 of of IN 42759 4596 12 goods good NNS 42759 4596 13 which which WDT 42759 4596 14 might may MD 42759 4596 15 be be VB 42759 4596 16 exchanged exchange VBN 42759 4596 17 for for IN 42759 4596 18 articles article NNS 42759 4596 19 of of IN 42759 4596 20 consumption consumption NN 42759 4596 21 some some DT 42759 4596 22 time time NN 42759 4596 23 in in IN 42759 4596 24 the the DT 42759 4596 25 future future NN 42759 4596 26 . . . 42759 4597 1 While while IN 42759 4597 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4597 3 can can MD 42759 4597 4 not not RB 42759 4597 5 estimate estimate VB 42759 4597 6 even even RB 42759 4597 7 approximately approximately RB 42759 4597 8 the the DT 42759 4597 9 decline decline NN 42759 4597 10 that that WDT 42759 4597 11 would would MD 42759 4597 12 thus thus RB 42759 4597 13 occur occur VB 42759 4597 14 in in IN 42759 4597 15 the the DT 42759 4597 16 value value NN 42759 4597 17 of of IN 42759 4597 18 land land NN 42759 4597 19 and and CC 42759 4597 20 capital capital NN 42759 4597 21 , , , 42759 4597 22 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4597 23 may may MD 42759 4597 24 safely safely RB 42759 4597 25 assert assert VB 42759 4597 26 that that IN 42759 4597 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4597 28 would would MD 42759 4597 29 be be VB 42759 4597 30 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4597 31 . . . 42759 4598 1 Unless unless IN 42759 4598 2 the the DT 42759 4598 3 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 4598 4 received receive VBD 42759 4598 5 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4598 6 compensation compensation NN 42759 4598 7 for for IN 42759 4598 8 this this DT 42759 4598 9 loss loss NN 42759 4598 10 , , , 42759 4598 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4598 12 would would MD 42759 4598 13 be be VB 42759 4598 14 compelled compel VBN 42759 4598 15 to to TO 42759 4598 16 suffer suffer VB 42759 4598 17 obvious obvious JJ 42759 4598 18 and and CC 42759 4598 19 grave grave JJ 42759 4598 20 injustice injustice NN 42759 4598 21 . . . 42759 4599 1 Any any DT 42759 4599 2 attempt attempt NN 42759 4599 3 , , , 42759 4599 4 however however RB 42759 4599 5 , , , 42759 4599 6 to to TO 42759 4599 7 carry carry VB 42759 4599 8 out out RP 42759 4599 9 such such PDT 42759 4599 10 a a DT 42759 4599 11 scheme scheme NN 42759 4599 12 , , , 42759 4599 13 either either CC 42759 4599 14 with with IN 42759 4599 15 or or CC 42759 4599 16 without without IN 42759 4599 17 compensation compensation NN 42759 4599 18 , , , 42759 4599 19 would would MD 42759 4599 20 inevitably inevitably RB 42759 4599 21 fail fail VB 42759 4599 22 . . . 42759 4600 1 Rent rent NN 42759 4600 2 might may MD 42759 4600 3 be be VB 42759 4600 4 terminated terminate VBN 42759 4600 5 through through IN 42759 4600 6 the the DT 42759 4600 7 Single Single NNP 42759 4600 8 Tax Tax NNP 42759 4600 9 , , , 42759 4600 10 but but CC 42759 4600 11 interest interest NN 42759 4600 12 could could MD 42759 4600 13 not not RB 42759 4600 14 be be VB 42759 4600 15 abolished abolish VBN 42759 4600 16 by by IN 42759 4600 17 any any DT 42759 4600 18 mere mere JJ 42759 4600 19 legal legal JJ 42759 4600 20 prohibition prohibition NN 42759 4600 21 . . . 42759 4601 1 Nor nor CC 42759 4601 2 does do VBZ 42759 4601 3 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 4601 4 afford afford VB 42759 4601 5 a a DT 42759 4601 6 way way NN 42759 4601 7 out out RB 42759 4601 8 ; ; : 42759 4601 9 for for IN 42759 4601 10 , , , 42759 4601 11 as as IN 42759 4601 12 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4601 13 have have VBP 42759 4601 14 seen see VBN 42759 4601 15 in in IN 42759 4601 16 a a DT 42759 4601 17 former former JJ 42759 4601 18 chapter chapter NN 42759 4601 19 , , , 42759 4601 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4601 21 is be VBZ 42759 4601 22 an an DT 42759 4601 23 impracticable impracticable JJ 42759 4601 24 system system NN 42759 4601 25 . . . 42759 4602 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 4602 2 the the DT 42759 4602 3 theory theory NN 42759 4602 4 of of IN 42759 4602 5 the the DT 42759 4602 6 right right NN 42759 4602 7 to to IN 42759 4602 8 the the DT 42759 4602 9 whole whole JJ 42759 4602 10 product product NN 42759 4602 11 of of IN 42759 4602 12 labour labour NN 42759 4602 13 is be VBZ 42759 4602 14 confronted confront VBN 42759 4602 15 by by IN 42759 4602 16 the the DT 42759 4602 17 final final JJ 42759 4602 18 objection objection NN 42759 4602 19 that that IN 42759 4602 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4602 21 realisation realisation NN 42759 4602 22 would would MD 42759 4602 23 involve involve VB 42759 4602 24 greater great JJR 42759 4602 25 evils evil NNS 42759 4602 26 and and CC 42759 4602 27 injustices injustice NNS 42759 4602 28 than than IN 42759 4602 29 those those DT 42759 4602 30 which which WDT 42759 4602 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4602 32 seeks seek VBZ 42759 4602 33 to to TO 42759 4602 34 abolish abolish VB 42759 4602 35 . . . 42759 4603 1 Finally finally RB 42759 4603 2 , , , 42759 4603 3 the the DT 42759 4603 4 theory theory NN 42759 4603 5 is be VBZ 42759 4603 6 radically radically RB 42759 4603 7 incomplete incomplete JJ 42759 4603 8 . . . 42759 4604 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4604 2 professes profess VBZ 42759 4604 3 to to TO 42759 4604 4 describe describe VB 42759 4604 5 the the DT 42759 4604 6 requirements requirement NNS 42759 4604 7 of of IN 42759 4604 8 justice justice NN 42759 4604 9 as as IN 42759 4604 10 between between IN 42759 4604 11 the the DT 42759 4604 12 landowners landowner NNS 42759 4604 13 and and CC 42759 4604 14 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 4604 15 on on IN 42759 4604 16 the the DT 42759 4604 17 one one CD 42759 4604 18 side side NN 42759 4604 19 , , , 42759 4604 20 and and CC 42759 4604 21 the the DT 42759 4604 22 wage wage NN 42759 4604 23 earners earner NNS 42759 4604 24 on on IN 42759 4604 25 the the DT 42759 4604 26 other other JJ 42759 4604 27 ; ; : 42759 4604 28 but but CC 42759 4604 29 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4604 30 provides provide VBZ 42759 4604 31 no no DT 42759 4604 32 rule rule NN 42759 4604 33 for for IN 42759 4604 34 determining determine VBG 42759 4604 35 distributive distributive JJ 42759 4604 36 justice justice NN 42759 4604 37 as as IN 42759 4604 38 between between IN 42759 4604 39 different different JJ 42759 4604 40 classes class NNS 42759 4604 41 of of IN 42759 4604 42 labour labour NN 42759 4604 43 . . . 42759 4605 1 In in IN 42759 4605 2 none none NN 42759 4605 3 of of IN 42759 4605 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4605 5 forms form NNS 42759 4605 6 does do VBZ 42759 4605 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4605 8 provide provide VB 42759 4605 9 any any DT 42759 4605 10 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 4605 11 rule rule NN 42759 4605 12 or or CC 42759 4605 13 principle principle NN 42759 4605 14 to to TO 42759 4605 15 ascertain ascertain VB 42759 4605 16 the the DT 42759 4605 17 difference difference NN 42759 4605 18 between between IN 42759 4605 19 the the DT 42759 4605 20 products product NNS 42759 4605 21 of of IN 42759 4605 22 different different JJ 42759 4605 23 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4605 24 , , , 42759 4605 25 and and CC 42759 4605 26 to to TO 42759 4605 27 decide decide VB 42759 4605 28 how how WRB 42759 4605 29 the the DT 42759 4605 30 product product NN 42759 4605 31 belonging belong VBG 42759 4605 32 to to IN 42759 4605 33 any any DT 42759 4605 34 group group NN 42759 4605 35 of of IN 42759 4605 36 men man NNS 42759 4605 37 as as IN 42759 4605 38 a a DT 42759 4605 39 whole whole NN 42759 4605 40 should should MD 42759 4605 41 be be VB 42759 4605 42 divided divide VBN 42759 4605 43 among among IN 42759 4605 44 the the DT 42759 4605 45 individual individual JJ 42759 4605 46 members member NNS 42759 4605 47 . . . 42759 4606 1 Does do VBZ 42759 4606 2 the the DT 42759 4606 3 locomotive locomotive JJ 42759 4606 4 engineer engineer NN 42759 4606 5 produce produce VB 42759 4606 6 more more JJR 42759 4606 7 than than IN 42759 4606 8 the the DT 42759 4606 9 section section NN 42759 4606 10 hand hand NN 42759 4606 11 , , , 42759 4606 12 the the DT 42759 4606 13 bookkeeper bookkeeper NN 42759 4606 14 more more JJR 42759 4606 15 than than IN 42759 4606 16 the the DT 42759 4606 17 salesman salesman NN 42759 4606 18 , , , 42759 4606 19 the the DT 42759 4606 20 ditch ditch NN 42759 4606 21 digger digger NN 42759 4606 22 more more JJR 42759 4606 23 than than IN 42759 4606 24 the the DT 42759 4606 25 teamster teamster NN 42759 4606 26 ? ? . 42759 4607 1 These these DT 42759 4607 2 and and CC 42759 4607 3 countless countless JJ 42759 4607 4 similar similar JJ 42759 4607 5 questions question NNS 42759 4607 6 are be VBP 42759 4607 7 , , , 42759 4607 8 from from IN 42759 4607 9 the the DT 42759 4607 10 nature nature NN 42759 4607 11 of of IN 42759 4607 12 the the DT 42759 4607 13 productive productive JJ 42759 4607 14 process process NN 42759 4607 15 , , , 42759 4607 16 unanswerable unanswerable JJ 42759 4607 17 . . . 42759 4608 1 Even even RB 42759 4608 2 if if IN 42759 4608 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4608 4 were be VBD 42759 4608 5 ethically ethically RB 42759 4608 6 acceptable acceptable JJ 42759 4608 7 , , , 42759 4608 8 the the DT 42759 4608 9 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4608 10 of of IN 42759 4608 11 the the DT 42759 4608 12 right right NN 42759 4608 13 to to IN 42759 4608 14 the the DT 42759 4608 15 whole whole JJ 42759 4608 16 product product NN 42759 4608 17 is be VBZ 42759 4608 18 hopelessly hopelessly RB 42759 4608 19 inadequate inadequate JJ 42759 4608 20 . . . 42759 4609 1 As as IN 42759 4609 2 intimated intimate VBN 42759 4609 3 above above RB 42759 4609 4 , , , 42759 4609 5 the the DT 42759 4609 6 notion notion NN 42759 4609 7 that that IN 42759 4609 8 if if IN 42759 4609 9 the the DT 42759 4609 10 labourer labourer NN 42759 4609 11 receives receive VBZ 42759 4609 12 compensation compensation NN 42759 4609 13 according accord VBG 42759 4609 14 to to IN 42759 4609 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4609 16 product product NN 42759 4609 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4609 18 receives receive VBZ 42759 4609 19 just just RB 42759 4609 20 compensation compensation NN 42759 4609 21 , , , 42759 4609 22 is be VBZ 42759 4609 23 one one CD 42759 4609 24 of of IN 42759 4609 25 the the DT 42759 4609 26 most most RBS 42759 4609 27 prevalent prevalent JJ 42759 4609 28 and and CC 42759 4609 29 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4609 30 concepts concept NNS 42759 4609 31 in in IN 42759 4609 32 the the DT 42759 4609 33 controversy controversy NN 42759 4609 34 about about IN 42759 4609 35 wage wage NN 42759 4609 36 justice justice NN 42759 4609 37 . . . 42759 4610 1 Hence hence RB 42759 4610 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4610 3 find find VBP 42759 4610 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4610 5 in in IN 42759 4610 6 certain certain JJ 42759 4610 7 theories theory NNS 42759 4610 8 which which WDT 42759 4610 9 reject reject VBP 42759 4610 10 the the DT 42759 4610 11 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4610 12 of of IN 42759 4610 13 the the DT 42759 4610 14 right right NN 42759 4610 15 to to IN 42759 4610 16 the the DT 42759 4610 17 whole whole JJ 42759 4610 18 product product NN 42759 4610 19 . . . 42759 4611 1 According accord VBG 42759 4611 2 to to IN 42759 4611 3 these these DT 42759 4611 4 theories theory NNS 42759 4611 5 , , , 42759 4611 6 not not RB 42759 4611 7 only only RB 42759 4611 8 the the DT 42759 4611 9 labourer labourer NN 42759 4611 10 but but CC 42759 4611 11 all all PDT 42759 4611 12 the the DT 42759 4611 13 agents agent NNS 42759 4611 14 of of IN 42759 4611 15 production production NN 42759 4611 16 should should MD 42759 4611 17 be be VB 42759 4611 18 rewarded reward VBN 42759 4611 19 in in IN 42759 4611 20 proportion proportion NN 42759 4611 21 to to IN 42759 4611 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4611 23 productive productive JJ 42759 4611 24 contributions contribution NNS 42759 4611 25 . . . 42759 4612 1 Instead instead RB 42759 4612 2 of of IN 42759 4612 3 the the DT 42759 4612 4 whole whole JJ 42759 4612 5 product product NN 42759 4612 6 , , , 42759 4612 7 the the DT 42759 4612 8 worker worker NN 42759 4612 9 ought ought MD 42759 4612 10 to to TO 42759 4612 11 receive receive VB 42759 4612 12 that that DT 42759 4612 13 portion portion NN 42759 4612 14 of of IN 42759 4612 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4612 16 which which WDT 42759 4612 17 corresponds correspond VBZ 42759 4612 18 to to IN 42759 4612 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4612 20 specific specific JJ 42759 4612 21 productivity productivity NN 42759 4612 22 , , , 42759 4612 23 that that RB 42759 4612 24 is is RB 42759 4612 25 , , , 42759 4612 26 that that DT 42759 4612 27 portion portion NN 42759 4612 28 of of IN 42759 4612 29 the the DT 42759 4612 30 product product NN 42759 4612 31 which which WDT 42759 4612 32 represents represent VBZ 42759 4612 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4612 34 productive productive JJ 42759 4612 35 influence influence NN 42759 4612 36 as as IN 42759 4612 37 compared compare VBN 42759 4612 38 with with IN 42759 4612 39 the the DT 42759 4612 40 productive productive JJ 42759 4612 41 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 4612 42 of of IN 42759 4612 43 land land NN 42759 4612 44 , , , 42759 4612 45 capital capital NN 42759 4612 46 , , , 42759 4612 47 and and CC 42759 4612 48 business business NN 42759 4612 49 energy energy NN 42759 4612 50 . . . 42759 4613 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4613 2 Clark Clark NNP 42759 4613 3 's 's POS 42759 4613 4 Theory Theory NNP 42759 4613 5 of of IN 42759 4613 6 Specific Specific NNP 42759 4613 7 Productivity Productivity NNP 42759 4613 8 _ _ NNP 42759 4613 9 One one CD 42759 4613 10 of of IN 42759 4613 11 the the DT 42759 4613 12 theories theory NNS 42759 4613 13 referred refer VBD 42759 4613 14 to to IN 42759 4613 15 in in IN 42759 4613 16 the the DT 42759 4613 17 last last JJ 42759 4613 18 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 4613 19 is be VBZ 42759 4613 20 that that DT 42759 4613 21 which which WDT 42759 4613 22 has have VBZ 42759 4613 23 been be VBN 42759 4613 24 elaborated elaborate VBN 42759 4613 25 in in IN 42759 4613 26 great great JJ 42759 4613 27 detail detail NN 42759 4613 28 and and CC 42759 4613 29 with with IN 42759 4613 30 great great JJ 42759 4613 31 ingenuity ingenuity NN 42759 4613 32 by by IN 42759 4613 33 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4613 34 John John NNP 42759 4613 35 Bates Bates NNP 42759 4613 36 Clark Clark NNP 42759 4613 37 . . . 42759 4614 1 As as IN 42759 4614 2 stated state VBN 42759 4614 3 by by IN 42759 4614 4 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4614 5 in in IN 42759 4614 6 the the DT 42759 4614 7 opening open VBG 42759 4614 8 sentence sentence NN 42759 4614 9 of of IN 42759 4614 10 the the DT 42759 4614 11 preface preface NN 42759 4614 12 to to IN 42759 4614 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4614 14 " " `` 42759 4614 15 Distribution distribution NN 42759 4614 16 of of IN 42759 4614 17 Wealth wealth NN 42759 4614 18 , , , 42759 4614 19 " " '' 42759 4614 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4614 21 main main JJ 42759 4614 22 tenet tenet NN 42759 4614 23 is be VBZ 42759 4614 24 , , , 42759 4614 25 " " `` 42759 4614 26 that that IN 42759 4614 27 the the DT 42759 4614 28 distribution distribution NN 42759 4614 29 of of IN 42759 4614 30 the the DT 42759 4614 31 income income NN 42759 4614 32 of of IN 42759 4614 33 society society NN 42759 4614 34 is be VBZ 42759 4614 35 controlled control VBN 42759 4614 36 by by IN 42759 4614 37 a a DT 42759 4614 38 natural natural JJ 42759 4614 39 law law NN 42759 4614 40 , , , 42759 4614 41 and and CC 42759 4614 42 that that IN 42759 4614 43 this this DT 42759 4614 44 law law NN 42759 4614 45 , , , 42759 4614 46 if if IN 42759 4614 47 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4614 48 worked work VBD 42759 4614 49 without without IN 42759 4614 50 friction friction NN 42759 4614 51 , , , 42759 4614 52 would would MD 42759 4614 53 give give VB 42759 4614 54 to to IN 42759 4614 55 every every DT 42759 4614 56 agent agent NN 42759 4614 57 of of IN 42759 4614 58 production production NN 42759 4614 59 the the DT 42759 4614 60 amount amount NN 42759 4614 61 of of IN 42759 4614 62 wealth wealth NN 42759 4614 63 which which WDT 42759 4614 64 that that IN 42759 4614 65 agent agent NN 42759 4614 66 creates create VBZ 42759 4614 67 . . . 42759 4614 68 " " '' 42759 4615 1 In in IN 42759 4615 2 a a DT 42759 4615 3 régime régime NN 42759 4615 4 of of IN 42759 4615 5 perfect perfect JJ 42759 4615 6 competition competition NN 42759 4615 7 , , , 42759 4615 8 therefore therefore RB 42759 4615 9 , , , 42759 4615 10 the the DT 42759 4615 11 labourer labourer NN 42759 4615 12 would would MD 42759 4615 13 get get VB 42759 4615 14 , , , 42759 4615 15 not not RB 42759 4615 16 the the DT 42759 4615 17 whole whole JJ 42759 4615 18 product product NN 42759 4615 19 of of IN 42759 4615 20 industry industry NN 42759 4615 21 , , , 42759 4615 22 but but CC 42759 4615 23 the the DT 42759 4615 24 whole whole JJ 42759 4615 25 product product NN 42759 4615 26 due due IN 42759 4615 27 to to IN 42759 4615 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4615 29 own own JJ 42759 4615 30 exertions exertion NNS 42759 4615 31 . . . 42759 4616 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4616 2 is be VBZ 42759 4616 3 impossible impossible JJ 42759 4616 4 , , , 42759 4616 5 and and CC 42759 4616 6 indeed indeed RB 42759 4616 7 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 4616 8 , , , 42759 4616 9 to to TO 42759 4616 10 enter enter VB 42759 4616 11 upon upon IN 42759 4616 12 an an DT 42759 4616 13 extended extended JJ 42759 4616 14 examination examination NN 42759 4616 15 of of IN 42759 4616 16 this this DT 42759 4616 17 contention contention NN 42759 4616 18 . . . 42759 4617 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4617 2 will will MD 42759 4617 3 be be VB 42759 4617 4 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4617 5 to to TO 42759 4617 6 state state VB 42759 4617 7 in in IN 42759 4617 8 a a DT 42759 4617 9 summary summary NN 42759 4617 10 way way NN 42759 4617 11 the the DT 42759 4617 12 most most RBS 42759 4617 13 obvious obvious JJ 42759 4617 14 and and CC 42759 4617 15 cogent cogent JJ 42759 4617 16 objections objection NNS 42759 4617 17 . . . 42759 4618 1 Without without IN 42759 4618 2 making make VBG 42759 4618 3 any any DT 42759 4618 4 examination examination NN 42759 4618 5 of of IN 42759 4618 6 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4618 7 Clark Clark NNP 42759 4618 8 's 's POS 42759 4618 9 theory theory NN 42759 4618 10 , , , 42759 4618 11 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4618 12 should should MD 42759 4618 13 expect expect VB 42759 4618 14 to to TO 42759 4618 15 find find VB 42759 4618 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4618 17 unconvincing unconvincing JJ 42759 4618 18 . . . 42759 4619 1 For for IN 42759 4619 2 the the DT 42759 4619 3 productive productive JJ 42759 4619 4 process process NN 42759 4619 5 is be VBZ 42759 4619 6 by by IN 42759 4619 7 analogy analogy NN 42759 4619 8 an an DT 42759 4619 9 organic organic JJ 42759 4619 10 process process NN 42759 4619 11 , , , 42759 4619 12 in in IN 42759 4619 13 which which WDT 42759 4619 14 every every DT 42759 4619 15 factor factor NN 42759 4619 16 requires require VBZ 42759 4619 17 the the DT 42759 4619 18 co co NN 42759 4619 19 - - NN 42759 4619 20 operation operation NN 42759 4619 21 of of IN 42759 4619 22 every every DT 42759 4619 23 other other JJ 42759 4619 24 factor factor NN 42759 4619 25 in in IN 42759 4619 26 order order NN 42759 4619 27 to to TO 42759 4619 28 turn turn VB 42759 4619 29 out out RP 42759 4619 30 even even RB 42759 4619 31 the the DT 42759 4619 32 smallest small JJS 42759 4619 33 portion portion NN 42759 4619 34 of of IN 42759 4619 35 the the DT 42759 4619 36 product product NN 42759 4619 37 . . . 42759 4620 1 Each each DT 42759 4620 2 factor factor NN 42759 4620 3 is be VBZ 42759 4620 4 in in IN 42759 4620 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4620 6 own own JJ 42759 4620 7 order order NN 42759 4620 8 the the DT 42759 4620 9 cause cause NN 42759 4620 10 of of IN 42759 4620 11 the the DT 42759 4620 12 whole whole JJ 42759 4620 13 product product NN 42759 4620 14 . . . 42759 4621 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 4621 2 no no DT 42759 4621 3 physical physical JJ 42759 4621 4 portion portion NN 42759 4621 5 of of IN 42759 4621 6 the the DT 42759 4621 7 product product NN 42759 4621 8 can can MD 42759 4621 9 be be VB 42759 4621 10 set set VBN 42759 4621 11 aside aside RB 42759 4621 12 and and CC 42759 4621 13 designated designate VBN 42759 4621 14 as as IN 42759 4621 15 wholly wholly RB 42759 4621 16 due due JJ 42759 4621 17 to to IN 42759 4621 18 any any DT 42759 4621 19 one one CD 42759 4621 20 factor factor NN 42759 4621 21 . . . 42759 4622 1 Can Can MD 42759 4622 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4622 3 not not RB 42759 4622 4 , , , 42759 4622 5 however however RB 42759 4622 6 , , , 42759 4622 7 distinguish distinguish VB 42759 4622 8 the the DT 42759 4622 9 _ _ NNP 42759 4622 10 proportionate proportionate NN 42759 4622 11 productive productive JJ 42759 4622 12 influence influence NN 42759 4622 13 _ _ NNP 42759 4622 14 exerted exert VBN 42759 4622 15 by by IN 42759 4622 16 each each DT 42759 4622 17 factor factor NN 42759 4622 18 , , , 42759 4622 19 and and CC 42759 4622 20 the the DT 42759 4622 21 proportion proportion NN 42759 4622 22 of of IN 42759 4622 23 the the DT 42759 4622 24 product product NN 42759 4622 25 which which WDT 42759 4622 26 represents represent VBZ 42759 4622 27 such such JJ 42759 4622 28 productive productive JJ 42759 4622 29 influence influence NN 42759 4622 30 ? ? . 42759 4623 1 This this DT 42759 4623 2 is be VBZ 42759 4623 3 the the DT 42759 4623 4 question question NN 42759 4623 5 to to TO 42759 4623 6 which which WDT 42759 4623 7 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4623 8 Clark Clark NNP 42759 4623 9 addresses address VBZ 42759 4623 10 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4623 11 with with IN 42759 4623 12 much much JJ 42759 4623 13 ingenuity ingenuity NN 42759 4623 14 , , , 42759 4623 15 subtlety subtlety NN 42759 4623 16 , , , 42759 4623 17 and and CC 42759 4623 18 labour labour NN 42759 4623 19 , , , 42759 4623 20 and and CC 42759 4623 21 to to TO 42759 4623 22 which which WDT 42759 4623 23 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4623 24 returns return VBZ 42759 4623 25 an an DT 42759 4623 26 affirmative affirmative JJ 42759 4623 27 answer answer NN 42759 4623 28 . . . 42759 4624 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4624 2 235 235 CD 42759 4624 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4624 4 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4624 5 contends contend VBZ 42759 4624 6 that that IN 42759 4624 7 the the DT 42759 4624 8 amount amount NN 42759 4624 9 of of IN 42759 4624 10 product product NN 42759 4624 11 added add VBN 42759 4624 12 by by IN 42759 4624 13 the the DT 42759 4624 14 presence presence NN 42759 4624 15 of of IN 42759 4624 16 the the DT 42759 4624 17 least least JJS 42759 4624 18 productive productive JJ 42759 4624 19 labourer labourer NN 42759 4624 20 in in IN 42759 4624 21 a a DT 42759 4624 22 group group NN 42759 4624 23 or or CC 42759 4624 24 establishment establishment NN 42759 4624 25 describes describe VBZ 42759 4624 26 the the DT 42759 4624 27 productivity productivity NN 42759 4624 28 of of IN 42759 4624 29 that that DT 42759 4624 30 and and CC 42759 4624 31 every every DT 42759 4624 32 other other JJ 42759 4624 33 labourer labourer NN 42759 4624 34 for for IN 42759 4624 35 whom whom WP 42759 4624 36 the the DT 42759 4624 37 man man NN 42759 4624 38 in in IN 42759 4624 39 question question NN 42759 4624 40 can can MD 42759 4624 41 be be VB 42759 4624 42 substituted substitute VBN 42759 4624 43 . . . 42759 4625 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 4625 2 this this DT 42759 4625 3 marginal marginal JJ 42759 4625 4 labourer labourer NN 42759 4625 5 had have VBD 42759 4625 6 the the DT 42759 4625 7 use use NN 42759 4625 8 of of IN 42759 4625 9 _ _ NNP 42759 4625 10 some some DT 42759 4625 11 _ _ NNP 42759 4625 12 capital capital NN 42759 4625 13 , , , 42759 4625 14 no no RB 42759 4625 15 matter matter RB 42759 4625 16 how how WRB 42759 4625 17 little little JJ 42759 4625 18 or or CC 42759 4625 19 how how WRB 42759 4625 20 poor poor JJ 42759 4625 21 ; ; : 42759 4625 22 consequently consequently RB 42759 4625 23 the the DT 42759 4625 24 increment increment NN 42759 4625 25 of of IN 42759 4625 26 product product NN 42759 4625 27 which which WDT 42759 4625 28 follows follow VBZ 42759 4625 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4625 30 activity activity NN 42759 4625 31 is be VBZ 42759 4625 32 partly partly RB 42759 4625 33 due due JJ 42759 4625 34 to to IN 42759 4625 35 capital capital NN 42759 4625 36 . . . 42759 4626 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4626 2 represents represent VBZ 42759 4626 3 something something NN 42759 4626 4 other other JJ 42759 4626 5 than than IN 42759 4626 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4626 7 own own JJ 42759 4626 8 productive productive JJ 42759 4626 9 power power NN 42759 4626 10 . . . 42759 4627 1 If if IN 42759 4627 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4627 3 wage wage NN 42759 4627 4 equals equal VBZ 42759 4627 5 the the DT 42759 4627 6 value value NN 42759 4627 7 of of IN 42759 4627 8 this this DT 42759 4627 9 increment increment NN 42759 4627 10 of of IN 42759 4627 11 product product NN 42759 4627 12 , , , 42759 4627 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4627 14 is be VBZ 42759 4627 15 receiving receive VBG 42759 4627 16 something something NN 42759 4627 17 more more JJR 42759 4627 18 than than IN 42759 4627 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4627 20 specific specific JJ 42759 4627 21 product product NN 42759 4627 22 . . . 42759 4628 1 In in IN 42759 4628 2 the the DT 42759 4628 3 second second JJ 42759 4628 4 place place NN 42759 4628 5 , , , 42759 4628 6 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4628 7 Clark Clark NNP 42759 4628 8 maintains maintain VBZ 42759 4628 9 that that IN 42759 4628 10 the the DT 42759 4628 11 difference difference NN 42759 4628 12 between between IN 42759 4628 13 what what WP 42759 4628 14 a a DT 42759 4628 15 labourer labourer NN 42759 4628 16 produces produce VBZ 42759 4628 17 when when WRB 42759 4628 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4628 19 uses use VBZ 42759 4628 20 the the DT 42759 4628 21 whole whole NN 42759 4628 22 of of IN 42759 4628 23 a a DT 42759 4628 24 certain certain JJ 42759 4628 25 supply supply NN 42759 4628 26 of of IN 42759 4628 27 capital capital NN 42759 4628 28 and and CC 42759 4628 29 what what WP 42759 4628 30 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4628 31 produces produce VBZ 42759 4628 32 when when WRB 42759 4628 33 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4628 34 has have VBZ 42759 4628 35 shared share VBN 42759 4628 36 that that DT 42759 4628 37 capital capital NN 42759 4628 38 with with IN 42759 4628 39 another another DT 42759 4628 40 labourer labourer NN 42759 4628 41 , , , 42759 4628 42 represents represent VBZ 42759 4628 43 the the DT 42759 4628 44 specific specific JJ 42759 4628 45 productivity productivity NN 42759 4628 46 of of IN 42759 4628 47 the the DT 42759 4628 48 relinquished relinquish VBN 42759 4628 49 capital capital NN 42759 4628 50 . . . 42759 4629 1 Let let VB 42759 4629 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4629 3 assume assume VB 42759 4629 4 that that IN 42759 4629 5 in in IN 42759 4629 6 a a DT 42759 4629 7 given give VBN 42759 4629 8 case case NN 42759 4629 9 the the DT 42759 4629 10 difference difference NN 42759 4629 11 is be VBZ 42759 4629 12 ten ten CD 42759 4629 13 units unit NNS 42759 4629 14 of of IN 42759 4629 15 product product NN 42759 4629 16 . . . 42759 4630 1 When when WRB 42759 4630 2 the the DT 42759 4630 3 first first JJ 42759 4630 4 man man NN 42759 4630 5 had have VBD 42759 4630 6 the the DT 42759 4630 7 whole whole JJ 42759 4630 8 capital capital NN 42759 4630 9 to to IN 42759 4630 10 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4630 11 , , , 42759 4630 12 the the DT 42759 4630 13 product product NN 42759 4630 14 was be VBD 42759 4630 15 one one CD 42759 4630 16 hundred hundred CD 42759 4630 17 units unit NNS 42759 4630 18 ; ; : 42759 4630 19 when when WRB 42759 4630 20 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4630 21 shares share VBZ 42759 4630 22 the the DT 42759 4630 23 use use NN 42759 4630 24 of of IN 42759 4630 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4630 26 with with IN 42759 4630 27 another another DT 42759 4630 28 , , , 42759 4630 29 the the DT 42759 4630 30 total total JJ 42759 4630 31 product product NN 42759 4630 32 is be VBZ 42759 4630 33 one one CD 42759 4630 34 hundred hundred CD 42759 4630 35 and and CC 42759 4630 36 eighty eighty CD 42759 4630 37 units unit NNS 42759 4630 38 . . . 42759 4631 1 As as IN 42759 4631 2 the the DT 42759 4631 3 two two CD 42759 4631 4 men man NNS 42759 4631 5 are be VBP 42759 4631 6 assumed assume VBN 42759 4631 7 to to TO 42759 4631 8 be be VB 42759 4631 9 equally equally RB 42759 4631 10 productive productive JJ 42759 4631 11 , , , 42759 4631 12 each each DT 42759 4631 13 has have VBZ 42759 4631 14 to to IN 42759 4631 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4631 16 credit credit NN 42759 4631 17 ninety ninety CD 42759 4631 18 units unit NNS 42759 4631 19 of of IN 42759 4631 20 product product NN 42759 4631 21 . . . 42759 4632 1 Working work VBG 42759 4632 2 with with IN 42759 4632 3 half half PDT 42759 4632 4 the the DT 42759 4632 5 capital capital NN 42759 4632 6 , , , 42759 4632 7 the the DT 42759 4632 8 first first JJ 42759 4632 9 man man NN 42759 4632 10 finds find VBZ 42759 4632 11 that that IN 42759 4632 12 the the DT 42759 4632 13 resulting result VBG 42759 4632 14 product product NN 42759 4632 15 is be VBZ 42759 4632 16 ten ten CD 42759 4632 17 units unit NNS 42759 4632 18 less less JJR 42759 4632 19 than than IN 42759 4632 20 when when WRB 42759 4632 21 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4632 22 was be VBD 42759 4632 23 using use VBG 42759 4632 24 the the DT 42759 4632 25 whole whole JJ 42759 4632 26 capital capital NN 42759 4632 27 . . . 42759 4633 1 Hence hence RB 42759 4633 2 these these DT 42759 4633 3 ten ten CD 42759 4633 4 units unit NNS 42759 4633 5 represent represent VBP 42759 4633 6 the the DT 42759 4633 7 portion portion NN 42759 4633 8 that that WDT 42759 4633 9 the the DT 42759 4633 10 relinquished relinquish VBN 42759 4633 11 capital capital NN 42759 4633 12 contributed contribute VBD 42759 4633 13 to to IN 42759 4633 14 the the DT 42759 4633 15 product product NN 42759 4633 16 ; ; : 42759 4633 17 and and CC 42759 4633 18 if if IN 42759 4633 19 the the DT 42759 4633 20 productivity productivity NN 42759 4633 21 of of IN 42759 4633 22 half half PDT 42759 4633 23 the the DT 42759 4633 24 capital capital NN 42759 4633 25 is be VBZ 42759 4633 26 ten ten CD 42759 4633 27 units unit NNS 42759 4633 28 , , , 42759 4633 29 that that DT 42759 4633 30 of of IN 42759 4633 31 the the DT 42759 4633 32 whole whole JJ 42759 4633 33 capital capital NN 42759 4633 34 must must MD 42759 4633 35 be be VB 42759 4633 36 twenty twenty CD 42759 4633 37 units unit NNS 42759 4633 38 . . . 42759 4634 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 4634 2 , , , 42759 4634 3 the the DT 42759 4634 4 ten ten CD 42759 4634 5 units unit NNS 42759 4634 6 by by IN 42759 4634 7 which which WDT 42759 4634 8 the the DT 42759 4634 9 product product NN 42759 4634 10 was be VBD 42759 4634 11 enlarged enlarge VBN 42759 4634 12 when when WRB 42759 4634 13 the the DT 42759 4634 14 man man NN 42759 4634 15 had have VBD 42759 4634 16 the the DT 42759 4634 17 whole whole JJ 42759 4634 18 capital capital NN 42759 4634 19 , , , 42759 4634 20 did do VBD 42759 4634 21 not not RB 42759 4634 22 come come VB 42759 4634 23 into into IN 42759 4634 24 being being NN 42759 4634 25 without without IN 42759 4634 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4634 27 co co NN 42759 4634 28 - - NN 42759 4634 29 operation operation NN 42759 4634 30 ; ; : 42759 4634 31 hence hence RB 42759 4634 32 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4634 33 can can MD 42759 4634 34 not not RB 42759 4634 35 be be VB 42759 4634 36 entirely entirely RB 42759 4634 37 attributed attribute VBN 42759 4634 38 to to IN 42759 4634 39 the the DT 42759 4634 40 one one CD 42759 4634 41 - - HYPH 42759 4634 42 half half NN 42759 4634 43 share share NN 42759 4634 44 of of IN 42759 4634 45 the the DT 42759 4634 46 capital capital NN 42759 4634 47 . . . 42759 4635 1 In in IN 42759 4635 2 other other JJ 42759 4635 3 words word NNS 42759 4635 4 , , , 42759 4635 5 the the DT 42759 4635 6 productivity productivity NN 42759 4635 7 of of IN 42759 4635 8 the the DT 42759 4635 9 relinquished relinquish VBN 42759 4635 10 capital capital NN 42759 4635 11 seems seem VBZ 42759 4635 12 to to TO 42759 4635 13 be be VB 42759 4635 14 less less JJR 42759 4635 15 than than IN 42759 4635 16 ten ten CD 42759 4635 17 units unit NNS 42759 4635 18 . . . 42759 4636 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4636 2 also also RB 42759 4636 3 seems seem VBZ 42759 4636 4 to to TO 42759 4636 5 be be VB 42759 4636 6 more more JJR 42759 4636 7 than than IN 42759 4636 8 ten ten CD 42759 4636 9 units unit NNS 42759 4636 10 ; ; : 42759 4636 11 for for IN 42759 4636 12 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4636 13 may may MD 42759 4636 14 assume assume VB 42759 4636 15 that that IN 42759 4636 16 if if IN 42759 4636 17 each each DT 42759 4636 18 man man NN 42759 4636 19 were be VBD 42759 4636 20 to to TO 42759 4636 21 use use VB 42759 4636 22 one one CD 42759 4636 23 - - HYPH 42759 4636 24 half half NN 42759 4636 25 the the DT 42759 4636 26 capital capital NN 42759 4636 27 independently independently RB 42759 4636 28 of of IN 42759 4636 29 the the DT 42759 4636 30 other other JJ 42759 4636 31 , , , 42759 4636 32 the the DT 42759 4636 33 resulting result VBG 42759 4636 34 total total JJ 42759 4636 35 product product NN 42759 4636 36 would would MD 42759 4636 37 be be VB 42759 4636 38 less less JJR 42759 4636 39 than than IN 42759 4636 40 one one CD 42759 4636 41 hundred hundred CD 42759 4636 42 and and CC 42759 4636 43 eighty eighty CD 42759 4636 44 units unit NNS 42759 4636 45 , , , 42759 4636 46 or or CC 42759 4636 47 less less JJR 42759 4636 48 than than IN 42759 4636 49 ninety ninety CD 42759 4636 50 units unit NNS 42759 4636 51 for for IN 42759 4636 52 each each DT 42759 4636 53 . . . 42759 4637 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 4637 2 the the DT 42759 4637 3 difference difference NN 42759 4637 4 between between IN 42759 4637 5 the the DT 42759 4637 6 product product NN 42759 4637 7 resulting result VBG 42759 4637 8 from from IN 42759 4637 9 the the DT 42759 4637 10 first first JJ 42759 4637 11 man man NN 42759 4637 12 's 's POS 42759 4637 13 use use NN 42759 4637 14 of of IN 42759 4637 15 the the DT 42759 4637 16 whole whole JJ 42759 4637 17 capital capital NN 42759 4637 18 and and CC 42759 4637 19 that that IN 42759 4637 20 resulting result VBG 42759 4637 21 from from IN 42759 4637 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4637 23 use use NN 42759 4637 24 of of IN 42759 4637 25 half half PDT 42759 4637 26 the the DT 42759 4637 27 capital capital NN 42759 4637 28 would would MD 42759 4637 29 be be VB 42759 4637 30 more more JJR 42759 4637 31 than than IN 42759 4637 32 ten ten CD 42759 4637 33 units unit NNS 42759 4637 34 ; ; : 42759 4637 35 and and CC 42759 4637 36 this this DT 42759 4637 37 difference difference NN 42759 4637 38 is be VBZ 42759 4637 39 specifically specifically RB 42759 4637 40 attributable attributable JJ 42759 4637 41 to to IN 42759 4637 42 half half PDT 42759 4637 43 the the DT 42759 4637 44 capital capital NN 42759 4637 45 . . . 42759 4638 1 Who who WP 42759 4638 2 can can MD 42759 4638 3 say say VB 42759 4638 4 which which WDT 42759 4638 5 of of IN 42759 4638 6 these these DT 42759 4638 7 calculations calculation NNS 42759 4638 8 is be VBZ 42759 4638 9 correct correct JJ 42759 4638 10 , , , 42759 4638 11 or or CC 42759 4638 12 whether whether IN 42759 4638 13 either either DT 42759 4638 14 of of IN 42759 4638 15 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4638 16 is be VBZ 42759 4638 17 correct correct JJ 42759 4638 18 ? ? . 42759 4639 1 The the DT 42759 4639 2 method method NN 42759 4639 3 of of IN 42759 4639 4 ascertaining ascertain VBG 42759 4639 5 specific specific JJ 42759 4639 6 productivity productivity NN 42759 4639 7 which which WDT 42759 4639 8 has have VBZ 42759 4639 9 been be VBN 42759 4639 10 described describe VBN 42759 4639 11 in in IN 42759 4639 12 the the DT 42759 4639 13 last last JJ 42759 4639 14 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 4639 15 is be VBZ 42759 4639 16 thought think VBN 42759 4639 17 by by IN 42759 4639 18 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4639 19 Clark Clark NNP 42759 4639 20 to to TO 42759 4639 21 receive receive VB 42759 4639 22 confirmation confirmation NN 42759 4639 23 from from IN 42759 4639 24 the the DT 42759 4639 25 fact fact NN 42759 4639 26 that that IN 42759 4639 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4639 28 leads lead VBZ 42759 4639 29 to to IN 42759 4639 30 the the DT 42759 4639 31 same same JJ 42759 4639 32 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 4639 33 as as IN 42759 4639 34 the the DT 42759 4639 35 first first JJ 42759 4639 36 and and CC 42759 4639 37 more more RBR 42759 4639 38 direct direct JJ 42759 4639 39 method method NN 42759 4639 40 ; ; : 42759 4639 41 namely namely RB 42759 4639 42 , , , 42759 4639 43 that that IN 42759 4639 44 the the DT 42759 4639 45 specific specific JJ 42759 4639 46 productivity productivity NN 42759 4639 47 of of IN 42759 4639 48 labour labour NN 42759 4639 49 is be VBZ 42759 4639 50 expressed express VBN 42759 4639 51 in in IN 42759 4639 52 the the DT 42759 4639 53 product product NN 42759 4639 54 of of IN 42759 4639 55 the the DT 42759 4639 56 marginal marginal JJ 42759 4639 57 labourer labourer NN 42759 4639 58 . . . 42759 4640 1 As as IN 42759 4640 2 a a DT 42759 4640 3 matter matter NN 42759 4640 4 of of IN 42759 4640 5 fact fact NN 42759 4640 6 , , , 42759 4640 7 this this DT 42759 4640 8 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 4640 9 is be VBZ 42759 4640 10 yielded yield VBN 42759 4640 11 by by IN 42759 4640 12 both both DT 42759 4640 13 methods method NNS 42759 4640 14 ; ; , 42759 4640 15 for for IN 42759 4640 16 the the DT 42759 4640 17 specific specific JJ 42759 4640 18 productivity productivity NN 42759 4640 19 of of IN 42759 4640 20 the the DT 42759 4640 21 first first JJ 42759 4640 22 labourer labourer NN 42759 4640 23 appeared appear VBD 42759 4640 24 as as IN 42759 4640 25 eighty eighty CD 42759 4640 26 units unit NNS 42759 4640 27 , , , 42759 4640 28 which which WDT 42759 4640 29 was be VBD 42759 4640 30 also also RB 42759 4640 31 the the DT 42759 4640 32 specific specific JJ 42759 4640 33 productivity productivity NN 42759 4640 34 of of IN 42759 4640 35 the the DT 42759 4640 36 second second JJ 42759 4640 37 labourer labourer NN 42759 4640 38 , , , 42759 4640 39 who who WP 42759 4640 40 was be VBD 42759 4640 41 the the DT 42759 4640 42 marginal marginal JJ 42759 4640 43 labourer labourer NN 42759 4640 44 . . . 42759 4641 1 As as IN 42759 4641 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4641 3 saw see VBD 42759 4641 4 in in IN 42759 4641 5 the the DT 42759 4641 6 second second JJ 42759 4641 7 last last JJ 42759 4641 8 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 4641 9 , , , 42759 4641 10 however however RB 42759 4641 11 , , , 42759 4641 12 the the DT 42759 4641 13 marginal marginal JJ 42759 4641 14 product product NN 42759 4641 15 is be VBZ 42759 4641 16 not not RB 42759 4641 17 due due JJ 42759 4641 18 to to IN 42759 4641 19 labour labour NN 42759 4641 20 alone alone RB 42759 4641 21 ; ; : 42759 4641 22 hence hence RB 42759 4641 23 the the DT 42759 4641 24 verification verification NN 42759 4641 25 provided provide VBN 42759 4641 26 by by IN 42759 4641 27 the the DT 42759 4641 28 second second JJ 42759 4641 29 method method NN 42759 4641 30 is be VBZ 42759 4641 31 in in IN 42759 4641 32 reality reality NN 42759 4641 33 a a DT 42759 4641 34 refutation refutation NN 42759 4641 35 . . . 42759 4642 1 Apparently apparently RB 42759 4642 2 the the DT 42759 4642 3 majority majority NN 42759 4642 4 of of IN 42759 4642 5 economists economist NNS 42759 4642 6 do do VBP 42759 4642 7 not not RB 42759 4642 8 accept accept VB 42759 4642 9 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4642 10 Clark Clark NNP 42759 4642 11 's 's POS 42759 4642 12 theory theory NN 42759 4642 13 ; ; , 42759 4642 14 for for IN 42759 4642 15 of of IN 42759 4642 16 the the DT 42759 4642 17 nine nine CD 42759 4642 18 who who WP 42759 4642 19 discussed discuss VBD 42759 4642 20 certain certain JJ 42759 4642 21 applications application NNS 42759 4642 22 of of IN 42759 4642 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4642 24 at at IN 42759 4642 25 the the DT 42759 4642 26 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 42759 4642 27 annual annual JJ 42759 4642 28 meeting meeting NN 42759 4642 29 of of IN 42759 4642 30 the the DT 42759 4642 31 American American NNP 42759 4642 32 Economic Economic NNP 42759 4642 33 Association Association NNP 42759 4642 34 only only RB 42759 4642 35 one one CD 42759 4642 36 approved approve VBD 42759 4642 37 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4642 38 , , , 42759 4642 39 three three CD 42759 4642 40 were be VBD 42759 4642 41 non non JJ 42759 4642 42 - - JJ 42759 4642 43 committal committal JJ 42759 4642 44 , , , 42759 4642 45 and and CC 42759 4642 46 five five CD 42759 4642 47 expressed express VBD 42759 4642 48 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4642 49 dissent dissent NN 42759 4642 50 . . . 42759 4643 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4643 2 236 236 CD 42759 4643 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4643 4 Even even RB 42759 4643 5 if if IN 42759 4643 6 the the DT 42759 4643 7 theory theory NN 42759 4643 8 were be VBD 42759 4643 9 true true JJ 42759 4643 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4643 11 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 42759 4643 12 character character NN 42759 4643 13 would would MD 42759 4643 14 deprive deprive VB 42759 4643 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4643 16 of of IN 42759 4643 17 any any DT 42759 4643 18 practical practical JJ 42759 4643 19 value value NN 42759 4643 20 . . . 42759 4644 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4644 2 assumes assume VBZ 42759 4644 3 a a DT 42759 4644 4 régime régime NN 42759 4644 5 of of IN 42759 4644 6 perfect perfect JJ 42759 4644 7 competition competition NN 42759 4644 8 , , , 42759 4644 9 but but CC 42759 4644 10 this this DT 42759 4644 11 assumption assumption NN 42759 4644 12 is be VBZ 42759 4644 13 so so RB 42759 4644 14 seldom seldom RB 42759 4644 15 realised realise VBN 42759 4644 16 that that IN 42759 4644 17 no no DT 42759 4644 18 rule rule NN 42759 4644 19 based base VBN 42759 4644 20 upon upon IN 42759 4644 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4644 22 can can MD 42759 4644 23 throw throw VB 42759 4644 24 much much JJ 42759 4644 25 light light NN 42759 4644 26 on on IN 42759 4644 27 the the DT 42759 4644 28 question question NN 42759 4644 29 of of IN 42759 4644 30 the the DT 42759 4644 31 productivity productivity NN 42759 4644 32 of of IN 42759 4644 33 present present JJ 42759 4644 34 day day NN 42759 4644 35 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4644 36 . . . 42759 4645 1 Even even RB 42759 4645 2 if if IN 42759 4645 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4645 4 were be VBD 42759 4645 5 exactly exactly RB 42759 4645 6 applicable applicable JJ 42759 4645 7 to to IN 42759 4645 8 existing exist VBG 42759 4645 9 conditions condition NNS 42759 4645 10 , , , 42759 4645 11 that that RB 42759 4645 12 is is RB 42759 4645 13 , , , 42759 4645 14 if if IN 42759 4645 15 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4645 16 were be VBD 42759 4645 17 actually actually RB 42759 4645 18 getting get VBG 42759 4645 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4645 20 specific specific JJ 42759 4645 21 products product NNS 42759 4645 22 , , , 42759 4645 23 the the DT 42759 4645 24 theory theory NN 42759 4645 25 would would MD 42759 4645 26 not not RB 42759 4645 27 provide provide VB 42759 4645 28 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4645 29 with with IN 42759 4645 30 a a DT 42759 4645 31 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 4645 32 of of IN 42759 4645 33 just just JJ 42759 4645 34 wages wage NNS 42759 4645 35 . . . 42759 4646 1 As as IN 42759 4646 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4646 3 have have VBP 42759 4646 4 seen see VBN 42759 4646 5 in in IN 42759 4646 6 former former JJ 42759 4646 7 chapters chapter NNS 42759 4646 8 , , , 42759 4646 9 productivity productivity NN 42759 4646 10 is be VBZ 42759 4646 11 neither neither CC 42759 4646 12 the the DT 42759 4646 13 only only JJ 42759 4646 14 nor nor CC 42759 4646 15 the the DT 42759 4646 16 highest high JJS 42759 4646 17 canon canon NN 42759 4646 18 of of IN 42759 4646 19 justice justice NN 42759 4646 20 , , , 42759 4646 21 whether whether IN 42759 4646 22 as as IN 42759 4646 23 regards regard VBZ 42759 4646 24 the the DT 42759 4646 25 comparative comparative JJ 42759 4646 26 claims claim NNS 42759 4646 27 of of IN 42759 4646 28 capital capital NN 42759 4646 29 and and CC 42759 4646 30 labour labour NN 42759 4646 31 , , , 42759 4646 32 or or CC 42759 4646 33 as as IN 42759 4646 34 regards regard VBZ 42759 4646 35 the the DT 42759 4646 36 claims claim NNS 42759 4646 37 of of IN 42759 4646 38 different different JJ 42759 4646 39 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4646 40 . . . 42759 4647 1 The the DT 42759 4647 2 contention contention NN 42759 4647 3 that that IN 42759 4647 4 capital capital NN 42759 4647 5 ought ought MD 42759 4647 6 to to TO 42759 4647 7 command command VB 42759 4647 8 interest interest NN 42759 4647 9 because because IN 42759 4647 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4647 11 aids aid VBZ 42759 4647 12 in in IN 42759 4647 13 bringing bring VBG 42759 4647 14 forth forth RP 42759 4647 15 the the DT 42759 4647 16 product product NN 42759 4647 17 , , , 42759 4647 18 is be VBZ 42759 4647 19 neither neither DT 42759 4647 20 self self NN 42759 4647 21 evident evident JJ 42759 4647 22 nor nor CC 42759 4647 23 demonstrable demonstrable JJ 42759 4647 24 by by IN 42759 4647 25 any any DT 42759 4647 26 process process NN 42759 4647 27 of of IN 42759 4647 28 reasoning reason VBG 42759 4647 29 . . . 42759 4648 1 Even even RB 42759 4648 2 if if IN 42759 4648 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4648 4 should should MD 42759 4648 5 concede concede VB 42759 4648 6 that that IN 42759 4648 7 the the DT 42759 4648 8 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4648 9 has have VBZ 42759 4648 10 a a DT 42759 4648 11 right right NN 42759 4648 12 to to IN 42759 4648 13 interest interest NN 42759 4648 14 by by IN 42759 4648 15 virtue virtue NN 42759 4648 16 of of IN 42759 4648 17 the the DT 42759 4648 18 productivity productivity NN 42759 4648 19 of of IN 42759 4648 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4648 21 capital capital NN 42759 4648 22 , , , 42759 4648 23 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4648 24 should should MD 42759 4648 25 not not RB 42759 4648 26 therefore therefore RB 42759 4648 27 conclude conclude VB 42759 4648 28 that that IN 42759 4648 29 this this DT 42759 4648 30 right right NN 42759 4648 31 is be VBZ 42759 4648 32 as as RB 42759 4648 33 cogent cogent JJ 42759 4648 34 as as IN 42759 4648 35 the the DT 42759 4648 36 corresponding correspond VBG 42759 4648 37 right right NN 42759 4648 38 of of IN 42759 4648 39 the the DT 42759 4648 40 labourer labourer NN 42759 4648 41 . . . 42759 4649 1 In in IN 42759 4649 2 the the DT 42759 4649 3 former former JJ 42759 4649 4 case case NN 42759 4649 5 the the DT 42759 4649 6 productive productive JJ 42759 4649 7 agency agency NN 42759 4649 8 is be VBZ 42759 4649 9 not not RB 42759 4649 10 human human JJ 42759 4649 11 nor nor CC 42759 4649 12 active active JJ 42759 4649 13 , , , 42759 4649 14 but but CC 42759 4649 15 only only RB 42759 4649 16 material material NN 42759 4649 17 and and CC 42759 4649 18 passive passive JJ 42759 4649 19 ; ; : 42759 4649 20 and and CC 42759 4649 21 the the DT 42759 4649 22 recipient recipient NN 42759 4649 23 of of IN 42759 4649 24 the the DT 42759 4649 25 product product NN 42759 4649 26 performs perform VBZ 42759 4649 27 no no DT 42759 4649 28 labour labour NN 42759 4649 29 as as IN 42759 4649 30 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 4649 31 , , , 42759 4649 32 but but CC 42759 4649 33 is be VBZ 42759 4649 34 left leave VBN 42759 4649 35 free free JJ 42759 4649 36 to to TO 42759 4649 37 get get VB 42759 4649 38 a a DT 42759 4649 39 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4649 40 by by IN 42759 4649 41 personal personal JJ 42759 4649 42 activity activity NN 42759 4649 43 . . . 42759 4650 1 The the DT 42759 4650 2 productivity productivity NN 42759 4650 3 of of IN 42759 4650 4 labour labour JJ 42759 4650 5 differs differ NNS 42759 4650 6 in in IN 42759 4650 7 all all PDT 42759 4650 8 these these DT 42759 4650 9 respects respect NNS 42759 4650 10 , , , 42759 4650 11 and and CC 42759 4650 12 the the DT 42759 4650 13 difference difference NN 42759 4650 14 is be VBZ 42759 4650 15 ethically ethically RB 42759 4650 16 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4650 17 to to TO 42759 4650 18 justify justify VB 42759 4650 19 the the DT 42759 4650 20 claim claim NN 42759 4650 21 that that IN 42759 4650 22 the the DT 42759 4650 23 labourer labourer NN 42759 4650 24 may may MD 42759 4650 25 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 4650 26 have have VB 42759 4650 27 a a DT 42759 4650 28 right right NN 42759 4650 29 to to IN 42759 4650 30 a a DT 42759 4650 31 part part NN 42759 4650 32 of of IN 42759 4650 33 the the DT 42759 4650 34 specific specific JJ 42759 4650 35 product product NN 42759 4650 36 of of IN 42759 4650 37 capital capital NN 42759 4650 38 . . . 42759 4651 1 To to TO 42759 4651 2 sum sum VB 42759 4651 3 up up RP 42759 4651 4 the the DT 42759 4651 5 matter matter NN 42759 4651 6 in in IN 42759 4651 7 the the DT 42759 4651 8 words word NNS 42759 4651 9 of of IN 42759 4651 10 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4651 11 Wicker Wicker NNP 42759 4651 12 : : : 42759 4651 13 " " `` 42759 4651 14 To to TO 42759 4651 15 have have VB 42759 4651 16 proved prove VBN 42759 4651 17 that that IN 42759 4651 18 the the DT 42759 4651 19 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4651 20 gets get VBZ 42759 4651 21 in in IN 42759 4651 22 interest interest NN 42759 4651 23 what what WP 42759 4651 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4651 25 capital capital NN 42759 4651 26 produces produce VBZ 42759 4651 27 is be VBZ 42759 4651 28 not not RB 42759 4651 29 to to TO 42759 4651 30 have have VB 42759 4651 31 proved prove VBN 42759 4651 32 that that IN 42759 4651 33 the the DT 42759 4651 34 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4651 35 gets get VBZ 42759 4651 36 what what WP 42759 4651 37 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4651 38 has have VBZ 42759 4651 39 earned earn VBN 42759 4651 40 . . . 42759 4652 1 To to TO 42759 4652 2 have have VB 42759 4652 3 proved prove VBN 42759 4652 4 that that IN 42759 4652 5 the the DT 42759 4652 6 landlord landlord NN 42759 4652 7 gets get VBZ 42759 4652 8 what what WP 42759 4652 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4652 10 land land NN 42759 4652 11 produces produce VBZ 42759 4652 12 is be VBZ 42759 4652 13 not not RB 42759 4652 14 to to TO 42759 4652 15 have have VB 42759 4652 16 proved prove VBN 42759 4652 17 that that IN 42759 4652 18 the the DT 42759 4652 19 landlord landlord NN 42759 4652 20 earns earn VBZ 42759 4652 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4652 22 distributive distributive JJ 42759 4652 23 share share NN 42759 4652 24 .... .... NFP 42759 4652 25 Economics economics NN 42759 4652 26 is be VBZ 42759 4652 27 not not RB 42759 4652 28 ethics ethic NNS 42759 4652 29 ; ; : 42759 4652 30 explanation explanation NN 42759 4652 31 is be VBZ 42759 4652 32 not not RB 42759 4652 33 justification justification NN 42759 4652 34 . . . 42759 4653 1 " " `` 42759 4653 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4653 3 237 237 CD 42759 4653 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4653 5 Indeed indeed RB 42759 4653 6 , , , 42759 4653 7 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4653 8 Clark Clark NNP 42759 4653 9 nowhere nowhere RB 42759 4653 10 explicitly explicitly RB 42759 4653 11 asserts assert VBZ 42759 4653 12 that that IN 42759 4653 13 productivity productivity NN 42759 4653 14 is be VBZ 42759 4653 15 an an DT 42759 4653 16 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4653 17 rule rule NN 42759 4653 18 of of IN 42759 4653 19 justice justice NN 42759 4653 20 . . . 42759 4654 1 " " `` 42759 4654 2 We -PRON- PRP 42759 4654 3 might may MD 42759 4654 4 raise raise VB 42759 4654 5 the the DT 42759 4654 6 question question NN 42759 4654 7 , , , 42759 4654 8 " " '' 42759 4654 9 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4654 10 says say VBZ 42759 4654 11 , , , 42759 4654 12 " " `` 42759 4654 13 whether whether IN 42759 4654 14 a a DT 42759 4654 15 rule rule NN 42759 4654 16 that that WDT 42759 4654 17 gives give VBZ 42759 4654 18 to to IN 42759 4654 19 a a DT 42759 4654 20 man man NN 42759 4654 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4654 22 product product NN 42759 4654 23 is be VBZ 42759 4654 24 in in IN 42759 4654 25 the the DT 42759 4654 26 highest high JJS 42759 4654 27 sense sense NN 42759 4654 28 just just RB 42759 4654 29 . . . 42759 4655 1 " " `` 42759 4655 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4655 3 238 238 CD 42759 4655 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4655 5 Scattered scatter VBN 42759 4655 6 throughout throughout IN 42759 4655 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4655 8 volume volume NN 42759 4655 9 , , , 42759 4655 10 however however RB 42759 4655 11 , , , 42759 4655 12 are be VBP 42759 4655 13 many many JJ 42759 4655 14 expressions expression NNS 42759 4655 15 which which WDT 42759 4655 16 might may MD 42759 4655 17 fairly fairly RB 42759 4655 18 be be VB 42759 4655 19 interpreted interpret VBN 42759 4655 20 as as IN 42759 4655 21 answering answer VBG 42759 4655 22 this this DT 42759 4655 23 question question NN 42759 4655 24 in in IN 42759 4655 25 the the DT 42759 4655 26 affirmative affirmative NN 42759 4655 27 . . . 42759 4656 1 The the DT 42759 4656 2 statements statement NNS 42759 4656 3 that that WDT 42759 4656 4 distribution distribution NN 42759 4656 5 according accord VBG 42759 4656 6 to to IN 42759 4656 7 product product NN 42759 4656 8 is be VBZ 42759 4656 9 a a DT 42759 4656 10 " " `` 42759 4656 11 natural natural JJ 42759 4656 12 law law NN 42759 4656 13 , , , 42759 4656 14 " " '' 42759 4656 15 and and CC 42759 4656 16 that that IN 42759 4656 17 if if IN 42759 4656 18 the the DT 42759 4656 19 labourer labourer NN 42759 4656 20 does do VBZ 42759 4656 21 not not RB 42759 4656 22 get get VB 42759 4656 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4656 24 full full JJ 42759 4656 25 specific specific JJ 42759 4656 26 product product NN 42759 4656 27 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4656 28 is be VBZ 42759 4656 29 " " `` 42759 4656 30 despoiled despoil VBN 42759 4656 31 , , , 42759 4656 32 " " '' 42759 4656 33 suggest suggest VBP 42759 4656 34 if if IN 42759 4656 35 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4656 36 do do VBP 42759 4656 37 not not RB 42759 4656 38 imply imply VB 42759 4656 39 that that IN 42759 4656 40 wages wage NNS 42759 4656 41 according accord VBG 42759 4656 42 to to IN 42759 4656 43 productivity productivity NN 42759 4656 44 is be VBZ 42759 4656 45 not not RB 42759 4656 46 merely merely RB 42759 4656 47 the the DT 42759 4656 48 economic economic JJ 42759 4656 49 but but CC 42759 4656 50 the the DT 42759 4656 51 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4656 52 norm norm NN 42759 4656 53 . . . 42759 4657 1 At at IN 42759 4657 2 any any DT 42759 4657 3 rate rate NN 42759 4657 4 , , , 42759 4657 5 the the DT 42759 4657 6 assumption assumption NN 42759 4657 7 of of IN 42759 4657 8 productivity productivity NN 42759 4657 9 as as IN 42759 4657 10 the the DT 42759 4657 11 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4657 12 canon canon NN 42759 4657 13 of of IN 42759 4657 14 wage wage NN 42759 4657 15 justice justice NN 42759 4657 16 , , , 42759 4657 17 is be VBZ 42759 4657 18 very very RB 42759 4657 19 widely widely RB 42759 4657 20 adopted adopt VBN 42759 4657 21 , , , 42759 4657 22 and and CC 42759 4657 23 is be VBZ 42759 4657 24 frequently frequently RB 42759 4657 25 brought bring VBN 42759 4657 26 forward forward RB 42759 4657 27 to to TO 42759 4657 28 give give VB 42759 4657 29 sanction sanction NN 42759 4657 30 to to IN 42759 4657 31 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 4657 32 rates rate NNS 42759 4657 33 of of IN 42759 4657 34 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 4657 35 . . . 42759 4658 1 Hence hence RB 42759 4658 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4658 3 has have VBZ 42759 4658 4 been be VBN 42759 4658 5 thought think VBN 42759 4658 6 well well RB 42759 4658 7 to to TO 42759 4658 8 show show VB 42759 4658 9 that that IN 42759 4658 10 the the DT 42759 4658 11 economic economic JJ 42759 4658 12 basis basis NN 42759 4658 13 of of IN 42759 4658 14 the the DT 42759 4658 15 assumption assumption NN 42759 4658 16 , , , 42759 4658 17 i.e. i.e. FW 42759 4658 18 , , , 42759 4658 19 that that IN 42759 4658 20 the the DT 42759 4658 21 labourer labourer NN 42759 4658 22 gets get VBZ 42759 4658 23 what what WP 42759 4658 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4658 25 produces produce VBZ 42759 4658 26 , , , 42759 4658 27 is be VBZ 42759 4658 28 unproved unproved JJ 42759 4658 29 and and CC 42759 4658 30 unprovable unprovable JJ 42759 4658 31 . . . 42759 4659 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4659 2 Carver Carver NNP 42759 4659 3 's 's POS 42759 4659 4 Modified Modified NNP 42759 4659 5 Version Version NNP 42759 4659 6 of of IN 42759 4659 7 Productivity Productivity NNP 42759 4659 8 _ _ NNP 42759 4659 9 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4659 10 Carver Carver NNP 42759 4659 11 makes make VBZ 42759 4659 12 no no DT 42759 4659 13 attempt attempt NN 42759 4659 14 to to TO 42759 4659 15 ascertain ascertain VB 42759 4659 16 or or CC 42759 4659 17 state state VB 42759 4659 18 the the DT 42759 4659 19 exact exact JJ 42759 4659 20 physical physical JJ 42759 4659 21 productivity productivity NN 42759 4659 22 of of IN 42759 4659 23 labour labour NN 42759 4659 24 as as IN 42759 4659 25 compared compare VBN 42759 4659 26 with with IN 42759 4659 27 that that DT 42759 4659 28 of of IN 42759 4659 29 capital capital NN 42759 4659 30 , , , 42759 4659 31 but but CC 42759 4659 32 confines confine VBZ 42759 4659 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4659 34 attention attention NN 42759 4659 35 to to IN 42759 4659 36 what what WP 42759 4659 37 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4659 38 calls call VBZ 42759 4659 39 the the DT 42759 4659 40 " " `` 42759 4659 41 economic economic JJ 42759 4659 42 " " '' 42759 4659 43 productivity productivity NN 42759 4659 44 of of IN 42759 4659 45 a a DT 42759 4659 46 given give VBN 42759 4659 47 unit unit NN 42759 4659 48 of of IN 42759 4659 49 labour labour NN 42759 4659 50 in in IN 42759 4659 51 a a DT 42759 4659 52 given give VBN 42759 4659 53 productive productive JJ 42759 4659 54 process process NN 42759 4659 55 . . . 42759 4660 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4660 2 239 239 CD 42759 4660 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4660 4 " " `` 42759 4660 5 Find find VB 42759 4660 6 out out RP 42759 4660 7 accurately accurately RB 42759 4660 8 how how WRB 42759 4660 9 much much JJ 42759 4660 10 the the DT 42759 4660 11 community community NN 42759 4660 12 produces produce VBZ 42759 4660 13 with with IN 42759 4660 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4660 15 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4660 16 the the DT 42759 4660 17 labourer labourer NN 42759 4660 18 's 's POS 42759 4660 19 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4660 20 help help NN 42759 4660 21 , , , 42759 4660 22 over over RB 42759 4660 23 and and CC 42759 4660 24 above above IN 42759 4660 25 what what WP 42759 4660 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4660 27 produces produce VBZ 42759 4660 28 without without IN 42759 4660 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4660 30 help help NN 42759 4660 31 , , , 42759 4660 32 and and CC 42759 4660 33 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4660 34 have have VBP 42759 4660 35 an an DT 42759 4660 36 exact exact JJ 42759 4660 37 measure measure NN 42759 4660 38 of of IN 42759 4660 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4660 40 productivity productivity NN 42759 4660 41 . . . 42759 4661 1 " " `` 42759 4661 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4661 3 240 240 CD 42759 4661 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4661 5 By by IN 42759 4661 6 this this DT 42759 4661 7 rule rule NN 42759 4661 8 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4661 9 can can MD 42759 4661 10 determine determine VB 42759 4661 11 a a DT 42759 4661 12 man man NN 42759 4661 13 's 's POS 42759 4661 14 productivity productivity NN 42759 4661 15 not not RB 42759 4661 16 only only RB 42759 4661 17 as as IN 42759 4661 18 compared compare VBN 42759 4661 19 with with IN 42759 4661 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4661 21 inactivity inactivity NN 42759 4661 22 in in IN 42759 4661 23 relation relation NN 42759 4661 24 to to IN 42759 4661 25 a a DT 42759 4661 26 given give VBN 42759 4661 27 industry industry NN 42759 4661 28 or or CC 42759 4661 29 establishment establishment NN 42759 4661 30 , , , 42759 4661 31 but but CC 42759 4661 32 as as IN 42759 4661 33 compared compare VBN 42759 4661 34 with with IN 42759 4661 35 the the DT 42759 4661 36 productivity productivity NN 42759 4661 37 of of IN 42759 4661 38 some some DT 42759 4661 39 other other JJ 42759 4661 40 man man NN 42759 4661 41 who who WP 42759 4661 42 might may MD 42759 4661 43 be be VB 42759 4661 44 substituted substitute VBN 42759 4661 45 for for IN 42759 4661 46 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4661 47 . . . 42759 4662 1 Thus thus RB 42759 4662 2 understood understand VBN 42759 4662 3 , , , 42759 4662 4 productivity productivity NN 42759 4662 5 expresses express VBZ 42759 4662 6 the the DT 42759 4662 7 economic economic JJ 42759 4662 8 value value NN 42759 4662 9 of of IN 42759 4662 10 a a DT 42759 4662 11 man man NN 42759 4662 12 to to IN 42759 4662 13 the the DT 42759 4662 14 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4662 15 process process NN 42759 4662 16 in in IN 42759 4662 17 which which WDT 42759 4662 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4662 19 participates participate VBZ 42759 4662 20 . . . 42759 4663 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4663 2 " " `` 42759 4663 3 determines determine VBZ 42759 4663 4 how how WRB 42759 4663 5 much much JJ 42759 4663 6 a a DT 42759 4663 7 man man NN 42759 4663 8 is be VBZ 42759 4663 9 worth worth JJ 42759 4663 10 , , , 42759 4663 11 and and CC 42759 4663 12 consequently consequently RB 42759 4663 13 , , , 42759 4663 14 according accord VBG 42759 4663 15 to to IN 42759 4663 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4663 17 criterion criterion NN 42759 4663 18 of of IN 42759 4663 19 justice justice NN 42759 4663 20 , , , 42759 4663 21 how how WRB 42759 4663 22 much much JJ 42759 4663 23 a a DT 42759 4663 24 man man NN 42759 4663 25 ought ought MD 42759 4663 26 to to TO 42759 4663 27 have have VB 42759 4663 28 as as IN 42759 4663 29 a a DT 42759 4663 30 reward reward NN 42759 4663 31 for for IN 42759 4663 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4663 33 work work NN 42759 4663 34 . . . 42759 4664 1 " " `` 42759 4664 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4664 3 241 241 CD 42759 4664 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4664 5 While while IN 42759 4664 6 this this DT 42759 4664 7 conception conception NN 42759 4664 8 of of IN 42759 4664 9 productivity productivity NN 42759 4664 10 is be VBZ 42759 4664 11 relatively relatively RB 42759 4664 12 simple simple JJ 42759 4664 13 , , , 42759 4664 14 and and CC 42759 4664 15 the the DT 42759 4664 16 canon canon NN 42759 4664 17 of of IN 42759 4664 18 justice justice NN 42759 4664 19 based base VBN 42759 4664 20 upon upon IN 42759 4664 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4664 22 is be VBZ 42759 4664 23 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 4664 24 plausible plausible JJ 42759 4664 25 , , , 42759 4664 26 neither neither CC 42759 4664 27 is be VBZ 42759 4664 28 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4664 29 . . . 42759 4665 1 To to IN 42759 4665 2 many many JJ 42759 4665 3 situations situation NNS 42759 4665 4 the the DT 42759 4665 5 productivity productivity NN 42759 4665 6 test test NN 42759 4665 7 is be VBZ 42759 4665 8 substantially substantially RB 42759 4665 9 inapplicable inapplicable JJ 42759 4665 10 . . . 42759 4666 1 The the DT 42759 4666 2 removal removal NN 42759 4666 3 from from IN 42759 4666 4 industry industry NN 42759 4666 5 of of IN 42759 4666 6 the the DT 42759 4666 7 man man NN 42759 4666 8 who who WP 42759 4666 9 works work VBZ 42759 4666 10 alone alone RB 42759 4666 11 ; ; : 42759 4666 12 for for IN 42759 4666 13 example example NN 42759 4666 14 , , , 42759 4666 15 the the DT 42759 4666 16 independent independent JJ 42759 4666 17 shoemaker shoemaker NN 42759 4666 18 , , , 42759 4666 19 blacksmith blacksmith NN 42759 4666 20 , , , 42759 4666 21 tailor tailor NN 42759 4666 22 , , , 42759 4666 23 or or CC 42759 4666 24 farmer farmer NN 42759 4666 25 , , , 42759 4666 26 would would MD 42759 4666 27 result result VB 42759 4666 28 not not RB 42759 4666 29 in in IN 42759 4666 30 a a DT 42759 4666 31 certain certain JJ 42759 4666 32 diminution diminution NN 42759 4666 33 , , , 42759 4666 34 but but CC 42759 4666 35 in in IN 42759 4666 36 the the DT 42759 4666 37 entire entire JJ 42759 4666 38 non non JJ 42759 4666 39 - - JJ 42759 4666 40 appearance appearance NN 42759 4666 41 of of IN 42759 4666 42 the the DT 42759 4666 43 product product NN 42759 4666 44 ; ; : 42759 4666 45 and and CC 42759 4666 46 the the DT 42759 4666 47 removal removal NN 42759 4666 48 of of IN 42759 4666 49 the the DT 42759 4666 50 capital capital NN 42759 4666 51 or or CC 42759 4666 52 tools tool NNS 42759 4666 53 would would MD 42759 4666 54 have have VB 42759 4666 55 precisely precisely RB 42759 4666 56 the the DT 42759 4666 57 same same JJ 42759 4666 58 effect effect NN 42759 4666 59 . . . 42759 4667 1 According accord VBG 42759 4667 2 to to IN 42759 4667 3 the the DT 42759 4667 4 former former JJ 42759 4667 5 method method NN 42759 4667 6 , , , 42759 4667 7 the the DT 42759 4667 8 labourer labourer NN 42759 4667 9 is be VBZ 42759 4667 10 to to TO 42759 4667 11 be be VB 42759 4667 12 credited credit VBN 42759 4667 13 with with IN 42759 4667 14 the the DT 42759 4667 15 whole whole JJ 42759 4667 16 product product NN 42759 4667 17 , , , 42759 4667 18 and and CC 42759 4667 19 capital capital NN 42759 4667 20 with with IN 42759 4667 21 nothing nothing NN 42759 4667 22 ; ; : 42759 4667 23 according accord VBG 42759 4667 24 to to IN 42759 4667 25 the the DT 42759 4667 26 latter latter JJ 42759 4667 27 method method NN 42759 4667 28 , , , 42759 4667 29 capital capital NN 42759 4667 30 produces produce VBZ 42759 4667 31 everything everything NN 42759 4667 32 , , , 42759 4667 33 and and CC 42759 4667 34 labour labour NN 42759 4667 35 nothing nothing NN 42759 4667 36 . . . 42759 4668 1 Even even RB 42759 4668 2 when when WRB 42759 4668 3 several several JJ 42759 4668 4 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4668 5 are be VBP 42759 4668 6 employed employ VBN 42759 4668 7 in in IN 42759 4668 8 an an DT 42759 4668 9 establishment establishment NN 42759 4668 10 , , , 42759 4668 11 the the DT 42759 4668 12 test test NN 42759 4668 13 is be VBZ 42759 4668 14 inapplicable inapplicable JJ 42759 4668 15 to to IN 42759 4668 16 those those DT 42759 4668 17 who who WP 42759 4668 18 are be VBP 42759 4668 19 engaged engage VBN 42759 4668 20 upon upon IN 42759 4668 21 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 4668 22 tasks task NNS 42759 4668 23 ; ; : 42759 4668 24 for for IN 42759 4668 25 example example NN 42759 4668 26 , , , 42759 4668 27 the the DT 42759 4668 28 engineer engineer NN 42759 4668 29 in in IN 42759 4668 30 the the DT 42759 4668 31 boiler boiler NN 42759 4668 32 room room NN 42759 4668 33 of of IN 42759 4668 34 a a DT 42759 4668 35 small small JJ 42759 4668 36 factory factory NN 42759 4668 37 , , , 42759 4668 38 and and CC 42759 4668 39 the the DT 42759 4668 40 bookkeeper bookkeeper NN 42759 4668 41 in in IN 42759 4668 42 a a DT 42759 4668 43 small small JJ 42759 4668 44 store store NN 42759 4668 45 . . . 42759 4669 1 Remove remove VB 42759 4669 2 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4669 3 , , , 42759 4669 4 and and CC 42759 4669 5 you -PRON- PRP 42759 4669 6 have have VBP 42759 4669 7 no no DT 42759 4669 8 product product NN 42759 4669 9 at at RB 42759 4669 10 all all RB 42759 4669 11 ; ; : 42759 4669 12 hence hence RB 42759 4669 13 a a DT 42759 4669 14 rigid rigid JJ 42759 4669 15 enforcement enforcement NN 42759 4669 16 of of IN 42759 4669 17 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4669 18 Carver Carver NNP 42759 4669 19 's 's POS 42759 4669 20 test test NN 42759 4669 21 would would MD 42759 4669 22 award award VB 42759 4669 23 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4669 24 the the DT 42759 4669 25 whole whole JJ 42759 4669 26 product product NN 42759 4669 27 . . . 42759 4670 1 To to TO 42759 4670 2 be be VB 42759 4670 3 sure sure JJ 42759 4670 4 , , , 42759 4670 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4670 6 can can MD 42759 4670 7 get get VB 42759 4670 8 some some DT 42759 4670 9 measure measure NN 42759 4670 10 of of IN 42759 4670 11 the the DT 42759 4670 12 productivity productivity NN 42759 4670 13 of of IN 42759 4670 14 these these DT 42759 4670 15 men man NNS 42759 4670 16 by by IN 42759 4670 17 observing observe VBG 42759 4670 18 the the DT 42759 4670 19 effect effect NN 42759 4670 20 on on IN 42759 4670 21 the the DT 42759 4670 22 product product NN 42759 4670 23 when when WRB 42759 4670 24 inferior inferior JJ 42759 4670 25 men man NNS 42759 4670 26 are be VBP 42759 4670 27 put put VBN 42759 4670 28 in in IN 42759 4670 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4670 30 places place NNS 42759 4670 31 ; ; : 42759 4670 32 but but CC 42759 4670 33 this this DT 42759 4670 34 merely merely RB 42759 4670 35 enables enable VBZ 42759 4670 36 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4670 37 to to TO 42759 4670 38 tell tell VB 42759 4670 39 how how WRB 42759 4670 40 much much RB 42759 4670 41 more more JJR 42759 4670 42 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4670 43 are be VBP 42759 4670 44 worth worth JJ 42759 4670 45 than than IN 42759 4670 46 other other JJ 42759 4670 47 men man NNS 42759 4670 48 , , , 42759 4670 49 not not RB 42759 4670 50 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4670 51 total total JJ 42759 4670 52 worth worth NN 42759 4670 53 . . . 42759 4671 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4671 2 , , , 42759 4671 3 even even RB 42759 4671 4 the the DT 42759 4671 5 substitution substitution NN 42759 4671 6 test test NN 42759 4671 7 is be VBZ 42759 4671 8 not not RB 42759 4671 9 always always RB 42759 4671 10 practicable practicable JJ 42759 4671 11 . . . 42759 4672 1 The the DT 42759 4672 2 attempt attempt NN 42759 4672 3 to to TO 42759 4672 4 ascertain ascertain VB 42759 4672 5 the the DT 42759 4672 6 productivity productivity NN 42759 4672 7 of of IN 42759 4672 8 a a DT 42759 4672 9 workman workman NN 42759 4672 10 of of IN 42759 4672 11 high high JJ 42759 4672 12 technical technical JJ 42759 4672 13 skill skill NN 42759 4672 14 by by IN 42759 4672 15 putting put VBG 42759 4672 16 in in RP 42759 4672 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4672 18 place place NN 42759 4672 19 an an DT 42759 4672 20 utterly utterly RB 42759 4672 21 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 4672 22 labourer labourer NN 42759 4672 23 , , , 42759 4672 24 would would MD 42759 4672 25 not not RB 42759 4672 26 yield yield VB 42759 4672 27 very very RB 42759 4672 28 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 4672 29 results result NNS 42759 4672 30 , , , 42759 4672 31 either either CC 42759 4672 32 to to IN 42759 4672 33 the the DT 42759 4672 34 inquiry inquiry NN 42759 4672 35 or or CC 42759 4672 36 to to IN 42759 4672 37 the the DT 42759 4672 38 industry industry NN 42759 4672 39 . . . 42759 4673 1 In in IN 42759 4673 2 the the DT 42759 4673 3 majority majority NN 42759 4673 4 of of IN 42759 4673 5 such such JJ 42759 4673 6 cases case NNS 42759 4673 7 , , , 42759 4673 8 the the DT 42759 4673 9 difference difference NN 42759 4673 10 in in IN 42759 4673 11 the the DT 42759 4673 12 resulting result VBG 42759 4673 13 product product NN 42759 4673 14 would would MD 42759 4673 15 probably probably RB 42759 4673 16 far far RB 42759 4673 17 exceed exceed VB 42759 4673 18 the the DT 42759 4673 19 difference difference NN 42759 4673 20 in in IN 42759 4673 21 the the DT 42759 4673 22 existing exist VBG 42759 4673 23 wage wage NN 42759 4673 24 rates rate NNS 42759 4673 25 of of IN 42759 4673 26 the the DT 42759 4673 27 two two CD 42759 4673 28 men man NNS 42759 4673 29 , , , 42759 4673 30 thus thus RB 42759 4673 31 showing show VBG 42759 4673 32 that that IN 42759 4673 33 the the DT 42759 4673 34 skilled skilled JJ 42759 4673 35 worker worker NN 42759 4673 36 is be VBZ 42759 4673 37 getting get VBG 42759 4673 38 considerably considerably RB 42759 4673 39 less less JJR 42759 4673 40 than than IN 42759 4673 41 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4673 42 is be VBZ 42759 4673 43 " " `` 42759 4673 44 economically economically RB 42759 4673 45 worth worth JJ 42759 4673 46 . . . 42759 4673 47 " " '' 42759 4674 1 In in IN 42759 4674 2 the the DT 42759 4674 3 field field NN 42759 4674 4 to to TO 42759 4674 5 which which WDT 42759 4674 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4674 7 is be VBZ 42759 4674 8 applicable applicable JJ 42759 4674 9 , , , 42759 4674 10 namely namely RB 42759 4674 11 , , , 42759 4674 12 that that DT 42759 4674 13 of of IN 42759 4674 14 more more RBR 42759 4674 15 or or CC 42759 4674 16 less less RBR 42759 4674 17 unspecialised unspecialised JJ 42759 4674 18 labour labour NN 42759 4674 19 in in IN 42759 4674 20 large large JJ 42759 4674 21 establishments establishment NNS 42759 4674 22 , , , 42759 4674 23 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4674 24 Carver Carver NNP 42759 4674 25 's 's POS 42759 4674 26 theory theory NN 42759 4674 27 violates violate VBZ 42759 4674 28 some some DT 42759 4674 29 of of IN 42759 4674 30 the the DT 42759 4674 31 most most RBS 42759 4674 32 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4674 33 conceptions conception NNS 42759 4674 34 of of IN 42759 4674 35 justice justice NN 42759 4674 36 and and CC 42759 4674 37 humanity humanity NN 42759 4674 38 . . . 42759 4675 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4675 2 admits admit VBZ 42759 4675 3 that that IN 42759 4675 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4675 5 takes take VBZ 42759 4675 6 no no DT 42759 4675 7 account account NN 42759 4675 8 of of IN 42759 4675 9 the the DT 42759 4675 10 labourer labourer NN 42759 4675 11 's 's POS 42759 4675 12 efforts effort NNS 42759 4675 13 , , , 42759 4675 14 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 4675 15 , , , 42759 4675 16 or or CC 42759 4675 17 needs need VBZ 42759 4675 18 , , , 42759 4675 19 and and CC 42759 4675 20 that that IN 42759 4675 21 when when WRB 42759 4675 22 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 4675 23 labour labour NN 42759 4675 24 becomes become VBZ 42759 4675 25 too too RB 42759 4675 26 plentiful plentiful JJ 42759 4675 27 , , , 42759 4675 28 the the DT 42759 4675 29 value value NN 42759 4675 30 of of IN 42759 4675 31 the the DT 42759 4675 32 product product NN 42759 4675 33 may may MD 42759 4675 34 fall fall VB 42759 4675 35 below below IN 42759 4675 36 the the DT 42759 4675 37 cost cost NN 42759 4675 38 of of IN 42759 4675 39 supporting support VBG 42759 4675 40 a a DT 42759 4675 41 decent decent JJ 42759 4675 42 standard standard NN 42759 4675 43 of of IN 42759 4675 44 living living NN 42759 4675 45 . . . 42759 4676 1 While while IN 42759 4676 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4676 3 looks look VBZ 42759 4676 4 with with IN 42759 4676 5 some some DT 42759 4676 6 sympathy sympathy NN 42759 4676 7 upon upon IN 42759 4676 8 the the DT 42759 4676 9 demand demand NN 42759 4676 10 for for IN 42759 4676 11 a a DT 42759 4676 12 minimum minimum JJ 42759 4676 13 wage wage NN 42759 4676 14 of of IN 42759 4676 15 two two CD 42759 4676 16 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4676 17 per per IN 42759 4676 18 day day NN 42759 4676 19 , , , 42759 4676 20 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4676 21 contends contend VBZ 42759 4676 22 that that IN 42759 4676 23 unless unless IN 42759 4676 24 the the DT 42759 4676 25 labourer labourer NN 42759 4676 26 really really RB 42759 4676 27 _ _ NNP 42759 4676 28 earns earn VBZ 42759 4676 29 _ _ NNP 42759 4676 30 that that DT 42759 4676 31 amount amount NN 42759 4676 32 , , , 42759 4676 33 some some DT 42759 4676 34 other other JJ 42759 4676 35 man man NN 42759 4676 36 will will MD 42759 4676 37 be be VB 42759 4676 38 paid pay VBN 42759 4676 39 less less JJR 42759 4676 40 than than IN 42759 4676 41 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4676 42 earns earn VBZ 42759 4676 43 , , , 42759 4676 44 " " '' 42759 4676 45 which which WDT 42759 4676 46 would would MD 42759 4676 47 be be VB 42759 4676 48 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4676 49 . . . 42759 4676 50 " " '' 42759 4677 1 To to TO 42759 4677 2 " " `` 42759 4677 3 earn earn VB 42759 4677 4 " " '' 42759 4677 5 two two CD 42759 4677 6 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4677 7 a a DT 42759 4677 8 day day NN 42759 4677 9 means mean VBZ 42759 4677 10 , , , 42759 4677 11 in in IN 42759 4677 12 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4677 13 Carver Carver NNP 42759 4677 14 's 's POS 42759 4677 15 terminology terminology NN 42759 4677 16 , , , 42759 4677 17 to to TO 42759 4677 18 add add VB 42759 4677 19 that that DT 42759 4677 20 much much JJ 42759 4677 21 value value NN 42759 4677 22 to to IN 42759 4677 23 the the DT 42759 4677 24 product product NN 42759 4677 25 of of IN 42759 4677 26 the the DT 42759 4677 27 establishment establishment NN 42759 4677 28 in in IN 42759 4677 29 which which WDT 42759 4677 30 the the DT 42759 4677 31 labourer labourer NN 42759 4677 32 is be VBZ 42759 4677 33 employed employ VBN 42759 4677 34 ; ; : 42759 4677 35 for for IN 42759 4677 36 this this DT 42759 4677 37 is be VBZ 42759 4677 38 the the DT 42759 4677 39 measure measure NN 42759 4677 40 of of IN 42759 4677 41 the the DT 42759 4677 42 labourer labourer NN 42759 4677 43 's 's POS 42759 4677 44 productivity productivity NN 42759 4677 45 . . . 42759 4678 1 If if IN 42759 4678 2 all all PDT 42759 4678 3 the the DT 42759 4678 4 men man NNS 42759 4678 5 who who WP 42759 4678 6 are be VBP 42759 4678 7 now now RB 42759 4678 8 getting get VBG 42759 4678 9 less less JJR 42759 4678 10 than than IN 42759 4678 11 two two CD 42759 4678 12 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4678 13 a a DT 42759 4678 14 day day NN 42759 4678 15 are be VBP 42759 4678 16 receiving receive VBG 42759 4678 17 the the DT 42759 4678 18 full full JJ 42759 4678 19 value value NN 42759 4678 20 of of IN 42759 4678 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4678 22 product product NN 42759 4678 23 , , , 42759 4678 24 and and CC 42759 4678 25 if if IN 42759 4678 26 all all PDT 42759 4678 27 the the DT 42759 4678 28 other other JJ 42759 4678 29 workers worker NNS 42759 4678 30 are be VBP 42759 4678 31 likewise likewise RB 42759 4678 32 given give VBN 42759 4678 33 the the DT 42759 4678 34 full full JJ 42759 4678 35 value value NN 42759 4678 36 of of IN 42759 4678 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4678 38 product product NN 42759 4678 39 , , , 42759 4678 40 an an DT 42759 4678 41 increase increase NN 42759 4678 42 in in IN 42759 4678 43 the the DT 42759 4678 44 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 4678 45 of of IN 42759 4678 46 the the DT 42759 4678 47 former former JJ 42759 4678 48 will will MD 42759 4678 49 mean mean VB 42759 4678 50 a a DT 42759 4678 51 deduction deduction NN 42759 4678 52 from from IN 42759 4678 53 the the DT 42759 4678 54 compensation compensation NN 42759 4678 55 of of IN 42759 4678 56 the the DT 42759 4678 57 latter latter JJ 42759 4678 58 . . . 42759 4679 1 These these DT 42759 4679 2 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 4679 3 of of IN 42759 4679 4 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4679 5 pessimism pessimism NN 42759 4679 6 are be VBP 42759 4679 7 extremely extremely RB 42759 4679 8 vulnerable vulnerable JJ 42759 4679 9 . . . 42759 4680 1 As as IN 42759 4680 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4680 3 have have VBP 42759 4680 4 shown show VBN 42759 4680 5 in in IN 42759 4680 6 chapter chapter NN 42759 4680 7 xvi xvi NNP 42759 4680 8 , , , 42759 4680 9 efforts effort NNS 42759 4680 10 , , , 42759 4680 11 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 4680 12 , , , 42759 4680 13 and and CC 42759 4680 14 needs need NNS 42759 4680 15 are be VBP 42759 4680 16 superior superior JJ 42759 4680 17 to to IN 42759 4680 18 productivity productivity NN 42759 4680 19 as as IN 42759 4680 20 claims claim NNS 42759 4680 21 to to TO 42759 4680 22 reward reward VB 42759 4680 23 , , , 42759 4680 24 and and CC 42759 4680 25 must must MD 42759 4680 26 be be VB 42759 4680 27 given give VBN 42759 4680 28 due due JJ 42759 4680 29 consideration consideration NN 42759 4680 30 in in IN 42759 4680 31 any any DT 42759 4680 32 just just JJ 42759 4680 33 scheme scheme NN 42759 4680 34 of of IN 42759 4680 35 distribution distribution NN 42759 4680 36 . . . 42759 4681 1 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4681 2 Carver Carver NNP 42759 4681 3 would would MD 42759 4681 4 leave leave VB 42759 4681 5 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4681 6 out out IN 42759 4681 7 of of IN 42759 4681 8 account account NN 42759 4681 9 entirely entirely RB 42759 4681 10 . . . 42759 4682 1 In in IN 42759 4682 2 the the DT 42759 4682 3 second second JJ 42759 4682 4 place place NN 42759 4682 5 , , , 42759 4682 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4682 7 is be VBZ 42759 4682 8 not not RB 42759 4682 9 always always RB 42759 4682 10 nor nor CC 42759 4682 11 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 4682 12 ever ever RB 42759 4682 13 true true JJ 42759 4682 14 that that DT 42759 4682 15 to to TO 42759 4682 16 raise raise VB 42759 4682 17 the the DT 42759 4682 18 wages wage NNS 42759 4682 19 of of IN 42759 4682 20 the the DT 42759 4682 21 poorest poor JJS 42759 4682 22 paid pay VBN 42759 4682 23 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4682 24 will will MD 42759 4682 25 mean mean VB 42759 4682 26 to to TO 42759 4682 27 lower lower VB 42759 4682 28 the the DT 42759 4682 29 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 4682 30 of of IN 42759 4682 31 those those DT 42759 4682 32 who who WP 42759 4682 33 are be VBP 42759 4682 34 better well RBR 42759 4682 35 paid pay VBN 42759 4682 36 . . . 42759 4683 1 Many many JJ 42759 4683 2 workers worker NNS 42759 4683 3 , , , 42759 4683 4 particularly particularly RB 42759 4683 5 women woman NNS 42759 4683 6 , , , 42759 4683 7 are be VBP 42759 4683 8 now now RB 42759 4683 9 receiving receive VBG 42759 4683 10 less less JJR 42759 4683 11 than than IN 42759 4683 12 the the DT 42759 4683 13 measure measure NN 42759 4683 14 of of IN 42759 4683 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4683 16 " " `` 42759 4683 17 productivity productivity NN 42759 4683 18 , , , 42759 4683 19 " " '' 42759 4683 20 less less JJR 42759 4683 21 than than IN 42759 4683 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4683 23 " " `` 42759 4683 24 earn earn VBP 42759 4683 25 , , , 42759 4683 26 " " '' 42759 4683 27 less less JJR 42759 4683 28 than than IN 42759 4683 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4683 30 worth worth NN 42759 4683 31 to to IN 42759 4683 32 the the DT 42759 4683 33 employer employer NN 42759 4683 34 , , , 42759 4683 35 less less JJR 42759 4683 36 than than IN 42759 4683 37 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4683 38 would would MD 42759 4683 39 be be VB 42759 4683 40 willing willing JJ 42759 4683 41 to to TO 42759 4683 42 pay pay VB 42759 4683 43 rather rather RB 42759 4683 44 than than IN 42759 4683 45 go go VB 42759 4683 46 without without IN 42759 4683 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4683 48 services service NNS 42759 4683 49 . . . 42759 4684 1 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4684 2 Carver Carver NNP 42759 4684 3 would would MD 42759 4684 4 , , , 42759 4684 5 of of IN 42759 4684 6 course course NN 42759 4684 7 , , , 42759 4684 8 not not RB 42759 4684 9 deny deny VB 42759 4684 10 that that IN 42759 4684 11 the the DT 42759 4684 12 wages wage NNS 42759 4684 13 of of IN 42759 4684 14 all all DT 42759 4684 15 such such JJ 42759 4684 16 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4684 17 could could MD 42759 4684 18 be be VB 42759 4684 19 raised raise VBN 42759 4684 20 without without IN 42759 4684 21 affecting affect VBG 42759 4684 22 the the DT 42759 4684 23 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 4684 24 of of IN 42759 4684 25 other other JJ 42759 4684 26 workers worker NNS 42759 4684 27 . . . 42759 4685 1 Even even RB 42759 4685 2 when when WRB 42759 4685 3 the the DT 42759 4685 4 poorest poor JJS 42759 4685 5 paid pay VBN 42759 4685 6 class class NN 42759 4685 7 is be VBZ 42759 4685 8 receiving receive VBG 42759 4685 9 all all DT 42759 4685 10 that that WDT 42759 4685 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4685 12 members member NNS 42759 4685 13 are be VBP 42759 4685 14 at at IN 42759 4685 15 present present JJ 42759 4685 16 worth worth NN 42759 4685 17 to to IN 42759 4685 18 the the DT 42759 4685 19 employer employer NN 42759 4685 20 , , , 42759 4685 21 an an DT 42759 4685 22 increase increase NN 42759 4685 23 in in IN 42759 4685 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4685 25 compensation compensation NN 42759 4685 26 would would MD 42759 4685 27 not not RB 42759 4685 28 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 4685 29 come come VB 42759 4685 30 out out IN 42759 4685 31 of of IN 42759 4685 32 the the DT 42759 4685 33 fund fund NN 42759 4685 34 available available JJ 42759 4685 35 for for IN 42759 4685 36 the the DT 42759 4685 37 better well JJR 42759 4685 38 paid pay VBN 42759 4685 39 . . . 42759 4686 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4686 2 could could MD 42759 4686 3 be be VB 42759 4686 4 deducted deduct VBN 42759 4686 5 from from IN 42759 4686 6 excessive excessive JJ 42759 4686 7 profits profit NNS 42759 4686 8 and and CC 42759 4686 9 interest interest NN 42759 4686 10 ; ; : 42759 4686 11 for for CC 42759 4686 12 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4686 13 know know VBP 42759 4686 14 well well RB 42759 4686 15 that that IN 42759 4686 16 in in IN 42759 4686 17 many many JJ 42759 4686 18 industries industry NNS 42759 4686 19 competition competition NN 42759 4686 20 does do VBZ 42759 4686 21 not not RB 42759 4686 22 automatically automatically RB 42759 4686 23 keep keep VB 42759 4686 24 down down RP 42759 4686 25 these these DT 42759 4686 26 shares share NNS 42759 4686 27 to to IN 42759 4686 28 the the DT 42759 4686 29 minimum minimum NN 42759 4686 30 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4686 31 to to TO 42759 4686 32 retain retain VB 42759 4686 33 the the DT 42759 4686 34 services service NNS 42759 4686 35 of of IN 42759 4686 36 business business NN 42759 4686 37 ability ability NN 42759 4686 38 and and CC 42759 4686 39 capital capital NN 42759 4686 40 . . . 42759 4687 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4687 2 could could MD 42759 4687 3 be be VB 42759 4687 4 provided provide VBN 42759 4687 5 to to IN 42759 4687 6 some some DT 42759 4687 7 extent extent NN 42759 4687 8 out out IN 42759 4687 9 of of IN 42759 4687 10 the the DT 42759 4687 11 enlarged enlarged JJ 42759 4687 12 product product NN 42759 4687 13 that that WDT 42759 4687 14 would would MD 42759 4687 15 result result VB 42759 4687 16 from from IN 42759 4687 17 improvements improvement NNS 42759 4687 18 in in IN 42759 4687 19 the the DT 42759 4687 20 productive productive JJ 42759 4687 21 process process NN 42759 4687 22 , , , 42759 4687 23 and and CC 42759 4687 24 from from IN 42759 4687 25 the the DT 42759 4687 26 increased increase VBN 42759 4687 27 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 4687 28 of of IN 42759 4687 29 those those DT 42759 4687 30 workers worker NNS 42759 4687 31 whose whose WP$ 42759 4687 32 wages wage NNS 42759 4687 33 had have VBD 42759 4687 34 been be VBN 42759 4687 35 raised raise VBN 42759 4687 36 . . . 42759 4688 1 Finally finally RB 42759 4688 2 , , , 42759 4688 3 the the DT 42759 4688 4 increased increase VBN 42759 4688 5 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 4688 6 could could MD 42759 4688 7 be be VB 42759 4688 8 derived derive VBN 42759 4688 9 from from IN 42759 4688 10 increased increase VBN 42759 4688 11 prices price NNS 42759 4688 12 . . . 42759 4689 1 When when WRB 42759 4689 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4689 3 speak speak VBP 42759 4689 4 of of IN 42759 4689 5 the the DT 42759 4689 6 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 4689 7 labourer labourer NN 42759 4689 8 as as IN 42759 4689 9 getting get VBG 42759 4689 10 all all DT 42759 4689 11 that that WDT 42759 4689 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4689 13 produces produce VBZ 42759 4689 14 , , , 42759 4689 15 or or CC 42759 4689 16 all all DT 42759 4689 17 that that WDT 42759 4689 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4689 19 earns earn VBZ 42759 4689 20 , , , 42759 4689 21 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4689 22 refer refer VBP 42759 4689 23 not not RB 42759 4689 24 to to IN 42759 4689 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4689 26 concrete concrete JJ 42759 4689 27 product product NN 42759 4689 28 , , , 42759 4689 29 but but CC 42759 4689 30 to to IN 42759 4689 31 the the DT 42759 4689 32 value value NN 42759 4689 33 of of IN 42759 4689 34 that that DT 42759 4689 35 product product NN 42759 4689 36 , , , 42759 4689 37 to to IN 42759 4689 38 the the DT 42759 4689 39 selling selling NN 42759 4689 40 price price NN 42759 4689 41 of of IN 42759 4689 42 the the DT 42759 4689 43 product product NN 42759 4689 44 . . . 42759 4690 1 Neither neither CC 42759 4690 2 this this DT 42759 4690 3 price price NN 42759 4690 4 , , , 42759 4690 5 nor nor CC 42759 4690 6 any any DT 42759 4690 7 other other JJ 42759 4690 8 existing exist VBG 42759 4690 9 price price NN 42759 4690 10 , , , 42759 4690 11 has have VBZ 42759 4690 12 anything anything NN 42759 4690 13 about about IN 42759 4690 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4690 15 that that WDT 42759 4690 16 is be VBZ 42759 4690 17 either either CC 42759 4690 18 economically economically RB 42759 4690 19 or or CC 42759 4690 20 ethically ethically RB 42759 4690 21 sacred sacred JJ 42759 4690 22 . . . 42759 4691 1 In in IN 42759 4691 2 a a DT 42759 4691 3 competitive competitive JJ 42759 4691 4 market market NN 42759 4691 5 current current JJ 42759 4691 6 prices price NNS 42759 4691 7 are be VBP 42759 4691 8 fixed fix VBN 42759 4691 9 by by IN 42759 4691 10 the the DT 42759 4691 11 forces force NNS 42759 4691 12 of of IN 42759 4691 13 supply supply NN 42759 4691 14 and and CC 42759 4691 15 demand demand NN 42759 4691 16 , , , 42759 4691 17 which which WDT 42759 4691 18 often often RB 42759 4691 19 involve involve VBP 42759 4691 20 the the DT 42759 4691 21 exploitation exploitation NN 42759 4691 22 of of IN 42759 4691 23 the the DT 42759 4691 24 weak weak JJ 42759 4691 25 ; ; : 42759 4691 26 in in IN 42759 4691 27 a a DT 42759 4691 28 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 4691 29 market market NN 42759 4691 30 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4691 31 are be VBP 42759 4691 32 set set VBN 42759 4691 33 by by IN 42759 4691 34 the the DT 42759 4691 35 desires desire NNS 42759 4691 36 of of IN 42759 4691 37 the the DT 42759 4691 38 monopolist monopolist NN 42759 4691 39 , , , 42759 4691 40 which which WDT 42759 4691 41 are be VBP 42759 4691 42 likewise likewise RB 42759 4691 43 destitute destitute NN 42759 4691 44 of of IN 42759 4691 45 moral moral JJ 42759 4691 46 validity validity NN 42759 4691 47 . . . 42759 4692 1 Hence hence RB 42759 4692 2 a a DT 42759 4692 3 minimum minimum JJ 42759 4692 4 wage wage NN 42759 4692 5 law law NN 42759 4692 6 which which WDT 42759 4692 7 would would MD 42759 4692 8 raise raise VB 42759 4692 9 the the DT 42759 4692 10 price price NN 42759 4692 11 and and CC 42759 4692 12 value value NN 42759 4692 13 of of IN 42759 4692 14 the the DT 42759 4692 15 product product NN 42759 4692 16 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 4692 17 to to TO 42759 4692 18 provide provide VB 42759 4692 19 living live VBG 42759 4692 20 wages wage NNS 42759 4692 21 for for IN 42759 4692 22 the the DT 42759 4692 23 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 4692 24 workers worker NNS 42759 4692 25 , , , 42759 4692 26 thus thus RB 42759 4692 27 increasing increase VBG 42759 4692 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4692 29 " " `` 42759 4692 30 productivity productivity NN 42759 4692 31 " " '' 42759 4692 32 and and CC 42759 4692 33 enabling enable VBG 42759 4692 34 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4692 35 to to TO 42759 4692 36 " " `` 42759 4692 37 earn earn VB 42759 4692 38 " " '' 42759 4692 39 the the DT 42759 4692 40 legal legal JJ 42759 4692 41 wage wage NN 42759 4692 42 , , , 42759 4692 43 would would MD 42759 4692 44 neither neither CC 42759 4692 45 violate violate VB 42759 4692 46 the the DT 42759 4692 47 principles principle NNS 42759 4692 48 of of IN 42759 4692 49 justice justice NN 42759 4692 50 , , , 42759 4692 51 nor nor CC 42759 4692 52 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 4692 53 diminish diminish VBP 42759 4692 54 the the DT 42759 4692 55 compensation compensation NN 42759 4692 56 of of IN 42759 4692 57 any any DT 42759 4692 58 other other JJ 42759 4692 59 labouring labour VBG 42759 4692 60 group group NN 42759 4692 61 . . . 42759 4693 1 To to TO 42759 4693 2 be be VB 42759 4693 3 sure sure JJ 42759 4693 4 , , , 42759 4693 5 the the DT 42759 4693 6 increased increase VBN 42759 4693 7 prices price NNS 42759 4693 8 might may MD 42759 4693 9 be be VB 42759 4693 10 followed follow VBN 42759 4693 11 by by IN 42759 4693 12 such such PDT 42759 4693 13 a a DT 42759 4693 14 lessening lessening NN 42759 4693 15 of of IN 42759 4693 16 demand demand NN 42759 4693 17 for for IN 42759 4693 18 the the DT 42759 4693 19 product product NN 42759 4693 20 as as IN 42759 4693 21 to to TO 42759 4693 22 diminish diminish JJ 42759 4693 23 employment employment NN 42759 4693 24 ; ; : 42759 4693 25 but but CC 42759 4693 26 this this DT 42759 4693 27 is be VBZ 42759 4693 28 another another DT 42759 4693 29 matter matter NN 42759 4693 30 which which WDT 42759 4693 31 has have VBZ 42759 4693 32 no no DT 42759 4693 33 direct direct JJ 42759 4693 34 bearing bearing NN 42759 4693 35 on on IN 42759 4693 36 either either CC 42759 4693 37 the the DT 42759 4693 38 economic economic JJ 42759 4693 39 or or CC 42759 4693 40 the the DT 42759 4693 41 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4693 42 phases phase NNS 42759 4693 43 of of IN 42759 4693 44 productivity productivity NN 42759 4693 45 and and CC 42759 4693 46 earning earn VBG 42759 4693 47 power power NN 42759 4693 48 . . . 42759 4694 1 And and CC 42759 4694 2 the the DT 42759 4694 3 disadvantages disadvantage NNS 42759 4694 4 involved involve VBN 42759 4694 5 in in IN 42759 4694 6 the the DT 42759 4694 7 supposition supposition NN 42759 4694 8 of of IN 42759 4694 9 a a DT 42759 4694 10 reduced reduced JJ 42759 4694 11 volume volume NN 42759 4694 12 of of IN 42759 4694 13 employment employment NN 42759 4694 14 may may MD 42759 4694 15 possibly possibly RB 42759 4694 16 be be VB 42759 4694 17 not not RB 42759 4694 18 so so RB 42759 4694 19 formidable formidable JJ 42759 4694 20 socially socially RB 42759 4694 21 as as IN 42759 4694 22 those those DT 42759 4694 23 which which WDT 42759 4694 24 accompany accompany VBP 42759 4694 25 a a DT 42759 4694 26 large large JJ 42759 4694 27 volume volume NN 42759 4694 28 of of IN 42759 4694 29 insufficiently insufficiently RB 42759 4694 30 paid pay VBN 42759 4694 31 occupations occupation NNS 42759 4694 32 . . . 42759 4695 1 This this DT 42759 4695 2 question question NN 42759 4695 3 will will MD 42759 4695 4 receive receive VB 42759 4695 5 further further JJ 42759 4695 6 consideration consideration NN 42759 4695 7 in in IN 42759 4695 8 a a DT 42759 4695 9 later later JJ 42759 4695 10 chapter chapter NN 42759 4695 11 . . . 42759 4696 1 In in IN 42759 4696 2 the the DT 42759 4696 3 meantime meantime NN 42759 4696 4 , , , 42759 4696 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4696 6 conclude conclude VBP 42759 4696 7 that that IN 42759 4696 8 Professor Professor NNP 42759 4696 9 Carver Carver NNP 42759 4696 10 's 's POS 42759 4696 11 theory theory NN 42759 4696 12 or or CC 42759 4696 13 rule rule NN 42759 4696 14 is be VBZ 42759 4696 15 inapplicable inapplicable JJ 42759 4696 16 to to IN 42759 4696 17 a a DT 42759 4696 18 large large JJ 42759 4696 19 part part NN 42759 4696 20 of of IN 42759 4696 21 the the DT 42759 4696 22 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4696 23 field field NN 42759 4696 24 , , , 42759 4696 25 and and CC 42759 4696 26 that that IN 42759 4696 27 where where WRB 42759 4696 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4696 29 does do VBZ 42759 4696 30 apply apply VB 42759 4696 31 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4696 32 frequently frequently RB 42759 4696 33 runs run VBZ 42759 4696 34 counter counter RB 42759 4696 35 to to IN 42759 4696 36 some some DT 42759 4696 37 of of IN 42759 4696 38 the the DT 42759 4696 39 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4696 40 principles principle NNS 42759 4696 41 of of IN 42759 4696 42 distributive distributive JJ 42759 4696 43 justice justice NN 42759 4696 44 . . . 42759 4697 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 4697 2 : : : 42759 4697 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4697 4 213 213 CD 42759 4697 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4697 6 Page page NN 42759 4697 7 47 47 CD 42759 4697 8 . . . 42759 4698 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4698 2 214 214 CD 42759 4698 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4698 4 _ _ NNP 42759 4698 5 The the DT 42759 4698 6 Chicago Chicago NNP 42759 4698 7 Daily Daily NNP 42759 4698 8 Tribune Tribune NNP 42759 4698 9 _ _ NNP 42759 4698 10 , , , 42759 4698 11 July July NNP 42759 4698 12 17 17 CD 42759 4698 13 , , , 42759 4698 14 1915 1915 CD 42759 4698 15 . . . 42759 4699 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4699 2 215 215 CD 42759 4699 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4699 4 Article article NN 42759 4699 5 on on IN 42759 4699 6 " " `` 42759 4699 7 Political Political NNP 42759 4699 8 Economy Economy NNP 42759 4699 9 and and CC 42759 4699 10 Ethics Ethics NNP 42759 4699 11 , , , 42759 4699 12 " " '' 42759 4699 13 in in IN 42759 4699 14 Palgrave Palgrave NNP 42759 4699 15 's 's POS 42759 4699 16 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 42759 4699 17 of of IN 42759 4699 18 Political Political NNP 42759 4699 19 Economy Economy NNP 42759 4699 20 . . . 42759 4700 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4700 2 216 216 CD 42759 4700 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4700 4 " " `` 42759 4700 5 Property Property NNP 42759 4700 6 and and CC 42759 4700 7 Contract Contract NNP 42759 4700 8 , , , 42759 4700 9 " " `` 42759 4700 10 II ii CD 42759 4700 11 , , , 42759 4700 12 603 603 CD 42759 4700 13 . . . 42759 4701 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4701 2 217 217 CD 42759 4701 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4701 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 4701 5 . . . 42759 4702 1 " " `` 42759 4702 2 L'Idée L'Idée NNP 42759 4702 3 du du NNP 42759 4702 4 Juste Juste NNP 42759 4702 5 Salaire Salaire NNP 42759 4702 6 , , , 42759 4702 7 " " '' 42759 4702 8 by by IN 42759 4702 9 Léon Léon NNP 42759 4702 10 Polier Polier NNP 42759 4702 11 , , , 42759 4702 12 ch ch NN 42759 4702 13 . . . 42759 4703 1 iii iii NNP 42759 4703 2 . . . 42759 4704 1 Paris Paris NNP 42759 4704 2 ; ; : 42759 4704 3 1903 1903 CD 42759 4704 4 . . . 42759 4705 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4705 2 218 218 CD 42759 4705 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4705 4 Polier polier NN 42759 4705 5 , , , 42759 4705 6 op op NN 42759 4705 7 . . . 42759 4706 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4706 2 . . . 42759 4706 3 , , , 42759 4706 4 pp pp NNP 42759 4706 5 . . . 42759 4707 1 33 33 CD 42759 4707 2 , , , 42759 4707 3 sq sq NNP 42759 4707 4 . . . 42759 4708 1 ; ; : 42759 4708 2 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 4708 3 , , , 42759 4708 4 " " `` 42759 4708 5 A a DT 42759 4708 6 Living live VBG 42759 4708 7 Wage wage NN 42759 4708 8 , , , 42759 4708 9 " " '' 42759 4708 10 pp pp NNP 42759 4708 11 . . . 42759 4709 1 26 26 CD 42759 4709 2 , , , 42759 4709 3 sq sq NNP 42759 4709 4 . . . 42759 4710 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4710 2 219 219 CD 42759 4710 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4710 4 " " `` 42759 4710 5 Ethica Ethica NNP 42759 4710 6 , , , 42759 4710 7 " " '' 42759 4710 8 lib lib NNP 42759 4710 9 . . . 42759 4711 1 5 5 CD 42759 4711 2 , , , 42759 4711 3 tr tr JJ 42759 4711 4 . . . 42759 4712 1 2 2 CD 42759 4712 2 , , , 42759 4712 3 cap cap NN 42759 4712 4 . . . 42759 4713 1 5 5 CD 42759 4713 2 . . . 42759 4714 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4714 2 220 220 CD 42759 4714 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4714 4 " " `` 42759 4714 5 Comment comment NN 42759 4714 6 . . . 42759 4715 1 ad ad NNP 42759 4715 2 Eth Eth NNP 42759 4715 3 . . . 42759 4715 4 , , , 42759 4715 5 " " `` 42759 4715 6 XXI XXI NNP 42759 4715 7 , , , 42759 4715 8 172 172 CD 42759 4715 9 . . . 42759 4716 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4716 2 221 221 CD 42759 4716 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4716 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 4716 5 . . . 42759 4717 1 Polier polier NN 42759 4717 2 , , , 42759 4717 3 op op NN 42759 4717 4 . . . 42759 4718 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4718 2 . . . 42759 4718 3 , , , 42759 4718 4 pp pp NNP 42759 4718 5 . . . 42759 4719 1 66 66 CD 42759 4719 2 - - SYM 42759 4719 3 75 75 CD 42759 4719 4 ; ; : 42759 4719 5 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 4719 6 , , , 42759 4719 7 op op NN 42759 4719 8 . . . 42759 4720 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4720 2 , , , 42759 4720 3 pp pp NNP 42759 4720 4 . . . 42759 4721 1 93 93 CD 42759 4721 2 , , , 42759 4721 3 94 94 CD 42759 4721 4 . . . 42759 4722 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4722 2 222 222 CD 42759 4722 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4722 4 Cf cf NN 42759 4722 5 . . . 42759 4723 1 Polier polier NN 42759 4723 2 , , , 42759 4723 3 op op NN 42759 4723 4 . . . 42759 4724 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4724 2 . . . 42759 4724 3 , , , 42759 4724 4 pp pp NNP 42759 4724 5 . . . 42759 4725 1 92 92 CD 42759 4725 2 - - SYM 42759 4725 3 95 95 CD 42759 4725 4 . . . 42759 4726 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4726 2 223 223 CD 42759 4726 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4726 4 " " `` 42759 4726 5 Cours Cours NNP 42759 4726 6 d'Économie d'Économie NNP 42759 4726 7 Sociale Sociale NNP 42759 4726 8 , , , 42759 4726 9 " " '' 42759 4726 10 pp pp NNP 42759 4726 11 . . . 42759 4727 1 598 598 CD 42759 4727 2 , , , 42759 4727 3 sq sq NNP 42759 4727 4 . . . 42759 4728 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4728 2 224 224 CD 42759 4728 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4728 4 Polier polier NN 42759 4728 5 , , , 42759 4728 6 op op NN 42759 4728 7 . . . 42759 4729 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4729 2 . . . 42759 4729 3 , , , 42759 4729 4 pp pp NNP 42759 4729 5 . . . 42759 4730 1 219 219 CD 42759 4730 2 - - SYM 42759 4730 3 359 359 CD 42759 4730 4 ; ; : 42759 4730 5 Menger Menger NNP 42759 4730 6 , , , 42759 4730 7 " " `` 42759 4730 8 The the DT 42759 4730 9 Right right UH 42759 4730 10 to to IN 42759 4730 11 the the DT 42759 4730 12 Whole whole JJ 42759 4730 13 Produce Produce NNP 42759 4730 14 of of IN 42759 4730 15 Labour Labour NNP 42759 4730 16 " " '' 42759 4730 17 ; ; : 42759 4730 18 English English NNP 42759 4730 19 Translation Translation NNP 42759 4730 20 . . . 42759 4731 1 London London NNP 42759 4731 2 ; ; : 42759 4731 3 1899 1899 CD 42759 4731 4 . . . 42759 4732 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4732 2 225 225 CD 42759 4732 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4732 4 " " `` 42759 4732 5 Enquiry Enquiry NNP 42759 4732 6 Concerning concern VBG 42759 4732 7 Political Political NNP 42759 4732 8 Justice Justice NNP 42759 4732 9 . . . 42759 4732 10 " " '' 42759 4733 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4733 2 226 226 CD 42759 4733 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4733 4 " " `` 42759 4733 5 On on IN 42759 4733 6 the the DT 42759 4733 7 Effects Effects NNPS 42759 4733 8 of of IN 42759 4733 9 Civilisation civilisation NN 42759 4733 10 on on IN 42759 4733 11 the the DT 42759 4733 12 People People NNS 42759 4733 13 of of IN 42759 4733 14 European European NNP 42759 4733 15 States States NNP 42759 4733 16 . . . 42759 4733 17 " " '' 42759 4734 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4734 2 227 227 CD 42759 4734 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4734 4 " " `` 42759 4734 5 An an DT 42759 4734 6 Inquiry inquiry NN 42759 4734 7 Into into IN 42759 4734 8 the the DT 42759 4734 9 Principles principle NNS 42759 4734 10 of of IN 42759 4734 11 the the DT 42759 4734 12 Distribution distribution NN 42759 4734 13 of of IN 42759 4734 14 Wealth wealth NN 42759 4734 15 Most most RBS 42759 4734 16 Conducive conducive JJ 42759 4734 17 to to IN 42759 4734 18 Human Human NNP 42759 4734 19 Happiness Happiness NNP 42759 4734 20 . . . 42759 4734 21 " " '' 42759 4735 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4735 2 228 228 CD 42759 4735 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4735 4 Menger Menger NNP 42759 4735 5 , , , 42759 4735 6 op op NN 42759 4735 7 . . . 42759 4736 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4736 2 . . NNP 42759 4736 3 , , , 42759 4736 4 p. p. NN 42759 4736 5 56 56 CD 42759 4736 6 . . . 42759 4737 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4737 2 229 229 CD 42759 4737 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4737 4 Op Op NNP 42759 4737 5 . . . 42759 4738 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4738 2 . . NNP 42759 4738 3 , , , 42759 4738 4 p. p. NN 42759 4738 5 51 51 CD 42759 4738 6 . . . 42759 4739 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4739 2 230 230 CD 42759 4739 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4739 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 4739 5 . . . 42759 4740 1 Menger Menger NNP 42759 4740 2 , , , 42759 4740 3 op op NN 42759 4740 4 . . . 42759 4741 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4741 2 . . . 42759 4741 3 , , , 42759 4741 4 pp pp NNP 42759 4741 5 . . . 42759 4742 1 62 62 CD 42759 4742 2 - - SYM 42759 4742 3 73 73 CD 42759 4742 4 . . . 42759 4743 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4743 2 231 231 CD 42759 4743 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4743 4 " " `` 42759 4743 5 Qu Qu NNP 42759 4743 6 ' ' '' 42759 4743 7 est e JJS 42759 4743 8 - - HYPH 42759 4743 9 ce ce NN 42759 4743 10 que que FW 42759 4743 11 la la FW 42759 4743 12 propriété propriété FW 42759 4743 13 ou ou NNP 42759 4743 14 recherches recherche NNS 42759 4743 15 sur sur NNP 42759 4743 16 la la NNP 42759 4743 17 principe principe NN 42759 4743 18 du du NNP 42759 4743 19 droit droit NNP 42759 4743 20 et et NNP 42759 4743 21 du du NNP 42759 4743 22 gouvernment gouvernment NN 42759 4743 23 . . . 42759 4743 24 " " '' 42759 4744 1 1840 1840 CD 42759 4744 2 . . . 42759 4745 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4745 2 232 232 CD 42759 4745 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4745 4 " " `` 42759 4745 5 Zur Zur NNP 42759 4745 6 Erkentniss Erkentniss NNP 42759 4745 7 unserer unserer NN 42759 4745 8 staatswirthschaftlichen staatswirthschaftlichen VBP 42759 4745 9 Zustande Zustande NNP 42759 4745 10 , , , 42759 4745 11 " " '' 42759 4745 12 1842 1842 CD 42759 4745 13 . . . 42759 4746 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4746 2 233 233 CD 42759 4746 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4746 4 " " `` 42759 4746 5 Das Das NNP 42759 4746 6 Kapital Kapital NNP 42759 4746 7 , , , 42759 4746 8 " " '' 42759 4746 9 1867 1867 CD 42759 4746 10 . . . 42759 4747 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4747 2 234 234 CD 42759 4747 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4747 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 4747 5 . . . 42759 4748 1 Polier polier NN 42759 4748 2 , , , 42759 4748 3 op op NN 42759 4748 4 . . . 42759 4749 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4749 2 . . . 42759 4749 3 , , , 42759 4749 4 pp pp NNP 42759 4749 5 . . . 42759 4750 1 352 352 CD 42759 4750 2 , , , 42759 4750 3 sq sq NNP 42759 4750 4 . . . 42759 4751 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4751 2 235 235 CD 42759 4751 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4751 4 Cf Cf NNP 42759 4751 5 . . . 42759 4752 1 especially especially RB 42759 4752 2 chap chap NNP 42759 4752 3 . . . 42759 4753 1 xxi xxi NNP 42759 4753 2 , , , 42759 4753 3 " " `` 42759 4753 4 The the DT 42759 4753 5 Theory Theory NNP 42759 4753 6 of of IN 42759 4753 7 Economic Economic NNP 42759 4753 8 Causation Causation NNP 42759 4753 9 . . . 42759 4753 10 " " '' 42759 4754 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4754 2 236 236 CD 42759 4754 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4754 4 " " `` 42759 4754 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNPS 42759 4754 6 , , , 42759 4754 7 " " '' 42759 4754 8 pp pp NNP 42759 4754 9 . . . 42759 4755 1 23 23 CD 42759 4755 2 - - SYM 42759 4755 3 54 54 CD 42759 4755 4 . . . 42759 4756 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4756 2 237 237 CD 42759 4756 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4756 4 " " `` 42759 4756 5 Proceedings proceeding NNS 42759 4756 6 of of IN 42759 4756 7 the the DT 42759 4756 8 22d 22d NNS 42759 4756 9 Annual Annual NNP 42759 4756 10 Meeting Meeting NNP 42759 4756 11 of of IN 42759 4756 12 the the DT 42759 4756 13 American American NNP 42759 4756 14 Economic Economic NNP 42759 4756 15 Association Association NNP 42759 4756 16 , , , 42759 4756 17 " " '' 42759 4756 18 pp pp NNP 42759 4756 19 . . . 42759 4757 1 160 160 CD 42759 4757 2 , , , 42759 4757 3 161 161 CD 42759 4757 4 . . . 42759 4758 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4758 2 238 238 CD 42759 4758 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4758 4 Op Op NNP 42759 4758 5 . . . 42759 4759 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4759 2 . . NNP 42759 4759 3 , , , 42759 4759 4 p. p. NN 42759 4759 5 8 8 CD 42759 4759 6 . . . 42759 4760 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4760 2 239 239 CD 42759 4760 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4760 4 " " `` 42759 4760 5 Essays essay NNS 42759 4760 6 in in IN 42759 4760 7 Social Social NNP 42759 4760 8 Justice Justice NNP 42759 4760 9 " " '' 42759 4760 10 ; ; : 42759 4760 11 especially especially RB 42759 4760 12 ch ch NN 42759 4760 13 . . . 42759 4761 1 vii vii NN 42759 4761 2 . . . 42759 4762 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4762 2 240 240 CD 42759 4762 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4762 4 Op Op NNP 42759 4762 5 . . . 42759 4763 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4763 2 . . . 42759 4763 3 , , , 42759 4763 4 pp pp NNP 42759 4763 5 . . . 42759 4764 1 187 187 CD 42759 4764 2 , , , 42759 4764 3 188 188 CD 42759 4764 4 . . . 42759 4765 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4765 2 241 241 CD 42759 4765 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4765 4 Op Op NNP 42759 4765 5 . . . 42759 4766 1 cit cit NNP 42759 4766 2 . . . 42759 4766 3 , , , 42759 4766 4 p. p. NN 42759 4766 5 201 201 CD 42759 4766 6 . . . 42759 4767 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 4767 2 XXIII xxiii NN 42759 4767 3 THE the DT 42759 4767 4 MINIMUM MINIMUM NNP 42759 4767 5 OF of IN 42759 4767 6 JUSTICE justice NN 42759 4767 7 : : : 42759 4767 8 A a DT 42759 4767 9 LIVING live VBG 42759 4767 10 WAGE wage NN 42759 4767 11 Although although IN 42759 4767 12 the the DT 42759 4767 13 principle principle NN 42759 4767 14 of of IN 42759 4767 15 needs need NNS 42759 4767 16 is be VBZ 42759 4767 17 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 4767 18 prominent prominent JJ 42759 4767 19 among among IN 42759 4767 20 the the DT 42759 4767 21 theories theory NNS 42759 4767 22 of of IN 42759 4767 23 wage wage NN 42759 4767 24 justice justice NN 42759 4767 25 , , , 42759 4767 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4767 27 received receive VBD 42759 4767 28 only only RB 42759 4767 29 incidental incidental JJ 42759 4767 30 mention mention NN 42759 4767 31 in in IN 42759 4767 32 the the DT 42759 4767 33 last last JJ 42759 4767 34 chapter chapter NN 42759 4767 35 . . . 42759 4768 1 Considered consider VBN 42759 4768 2 as as IN 42759 4768 3 a a DT 42759 4768 4 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 4768 5 rule rule NN 42759 4768 6 , , , 42759 4768 7 this this DT 42759 4768 8 principle principle NN 42759 4768 9 has have VBZ 42759 4768 10 been be VBN 42759 4768 11 defended defend VBN 42759 4768 12 with with IN 42759 4768 13 less less JJR 42759 4768 14 energy energy NN 42759 4768 15 and and CC 42759 4768 16 definiteness definiteness NN 42759 4768 17 than than IN 42759 4768 18 most most JJS 42759 4768 19 of of IN 42759 4768 20 the the DT 42759 4768 21 other other JJ 42759 4768 22 canons canon NNS 42759 4768 23 . . . 42759 4769 1 Considered consider VBN 42759 4769 2 as as IN 42759 4769 3 a a DT 42759 4769 4 partial partial JJ 42759 4769 5 rule rule NN 42759 4769 6 , , , 42759 4769 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4769 8 is be VBZ 42759 4769 9 sound sound JJ 42759 4769 10 and and CC 42759 4769 11 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4769 12 , , , 42759 4769 13 and and CC 42759 4769 14 therefore therefore RB 42759 4769 15 could could MD 42759 4769 16 not not RB 42759 4769 17 have have VB 42759 4769 18 been be VBN 42759 4769 19 classed class VBN 42759 4769 20 among among IN 42759 4769 21 theories theory NNS 42759 4769 22 that that WDT 42759 4769 23 are be VBP 42759 4769 24 unacceptable unacceptable JJ 42759 4769 25 . . . 42759 4770 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4770 2 The the DT 42759 4770 3 Principle Principle NNP 42759 4770 4 of of IN 42759 4770 5 Needs Needs NNPS 42759 4770 6 _ _ IN 42759 4770 7 Many many JJ 42759 4770 8 of of IN 42759 4770 9 the the DT 42759 4770 10 early early JJ 42759 4770 11 French french JJ 42759 4770 12 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 4770 13 of of IN 42759 4770 14 the the DT 42759 4770 15 Utopian utopian JJ 42759 4770 16 school school NN 42759 4770 17 advanced advance VBD 42759 4770 18 this this DT 42759 4770 19 formula formula NN 42759 4770 20 of of IN 42759 4770 21 distribution distribution NN 42759 4770 22 : : : 42759 4770 23 " " `` 42759 4770 24 From from IN 42759 4770 25 each each DT 42759 4770 26 according accord VBG 42759 4770 27 to to IN 42759 4770 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4770 29 powers power NNS 42759 4770 30 ; ; : 42759 4770 31 to to IN 42759 4770 32 each each DT 42759 4770 33 according accord VBG 42759 4770 34 to to IN 42759 4770 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4770 36 needs need NNS 42759 4770 37 . . . 42759 4770 38 " " '' 42759 4771 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4771 2 was be VBD 42759 4771 3 also also RB 42759 4771 4 put put VBN 42759 4771 5 forward forward RP 42759 4771 6 by by IN 42759 4771 7 the the DT 42759 4771 8 German german JJ 42759 4771 9 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 4771 10 in in IN 42759 4771 11 the the DT 42759 4771 12 Gotha Gotha NNP 42759 4771 13 Program Program NNP 42759 4771 14 in in IN 42759 4771 15 1875 1875 CD 42759 4771 16 . . . 42759 4772 1 While while IN 42759 4772 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4772 3 have have VBP 42759 4772 4 not not RB 42759 4772 5 given give VBN 42759 4772 6 to to IN 42759 4772 7 this this DT 42759 4772 8 standard standard JJ 42759 4772 9 formal formal JJ 42759 4772 10 recognition recognition NN 42759 4772 11 in in IN 42759 4772 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4772 13 more more JJR 42759 4772 14 recent recent JJ 42759 4772 15 platforms platform NNS 42759 4772 16 , , , 42759 4772 17 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 4772 18 generally generally RB 42759 4772 19 regard regard VBP 42759 4772 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4772 21 as as IN 42759 4772 22 the the DT 42759 4772 23 ideal ideal JJ 42759 4772 24 rule rule NN 42759 4772 25 for for IN 42759 4772 26 the the DT 42759 4772 27 distant distant JJ 42759 4772 28 future future NN 42759 4772 29 . . . 42759 4773 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4773 2 242 242 CD 42759 4773 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4773 4 The the DT 42759 4773 5 difficulties difficulty NNS 42759 4773 6 confronting confront VBG 42759 4773 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4773 8 are be VBP 42759 4773 9 so so RB 42759 4773 10 great great JJ 42759 4773 11 and and CC 42759 4773 12 so so RB 42759 4773 13 obvious obvious JJ 42759 4773 14 that that IN 42759 4773 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4773 16 would would MD 42759 4773 17 defer defer VB 42759 4773 18 the the DT 42759 4773 19 introduction introduction NN 42759 4773 20 of of IN 42759 4773 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4773 22 to to IN 42759 4773 23 a a DT 42759 4773 24 time time NN 42759 4773 25 when when WRB 42759 4773 26 the the DT 42759 4773 27 operation operation NN 42759 4773 28 of of IN 42759 4773 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4773 30 system system NN 42759 4773 31 will will MD 42759 4773 32 , , , 42759 4773 33 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4773 34 hope hope VBP 42759 4773 35 , , , 42759 4773 36 have have VBP 42759 4773 37 eradicated eradicate VBN 42759 4773 38 the the DT 42759 4773 39 historical historical JJ 42759 4773 40 human human JJ 42759 4773 41 qualities quality NNS 42759 4773 42 of of IN 42759 4773 43 laziness laziness NN 42759 4773 44 and and CC 42759 4773 45 selfishness selfishness NN 42759 4773 46 . . . 42759 4774 1 To to TO 42759 4774 2 adopt adopt VB 42759 4774 3 needs need NNS 42759 4774 4 as as IN 42759 4774 5 the the DT 42759 4774 6 sole sole JJ 42759 4774 7 rule rule NN 42759 4774 8 of of IN 42759 4774 9 distribution distribution NN 42759 4774 10 would would MD 42759 4774 11 mean mean VB 42759 4774 12 , , , 42759 4774 13 of of IN 42759 4774 14 course course NN 42759 4774 15 , , , 42759 4774 16 that that IN 42759 4774 17 each each DT 42759 4774 18 person person NN 42759 4774 19 should should MD 42759 4774 20 be be VB 42759 4774 21 rewarded reward VBN 42759 4774 22 in in IN 42759 4774 23 proportion proportion NN 42759 4774 24 to to IN 42759 4774 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4774 26 wants want NNS 42759 4774 27 and and CC 42759 4774 28 desires desire NNS 42759 4774 29 , , , 42759 4774 30 regardless regardless RB 42759 4774 31 of of IN 42759 4774 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4774 33 efforts effort NNS 42759 4774 34 or or CC 42759 4774 35 of of IN 42759 4774 36 the the DT 42759 4774 37 amount amount NN 42759 4774 38 that that WDT 42759 4774 39 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4774 40 had have VBD 42759 4774 41 produced produce VBN 42759 4774 42 . . . 42759 4775 1 The the DT 42759 4775 2 mere mere JJ 42759 4775 3 statement statement NN 42759 4775 4 of of IN 42759 4775 5 the the DT 42759 4775 6 proposal proposal NN 42759 4775 7 is be VBZ 42759 4775 8 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4775 9 to to TO 42759 4775 10 refute refute VB 42759 4775 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4775 12 as as IN 42759 4775 13 regards regard VBZ 42759 4775 14 the the DT 42759 4775 15 men man NNS 42759 4775 16 and and CC 42759 4775 17 women woman NNS 42759 4775 18 of of IN 42759 4775 19 whom whom WP 42759 4775 20 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4775 21 have have VBP 42759 4775 22 any any DT 42759 4775 23 knowledge knowledge NN 42759 4775 24 . . . 42759 4776 1 In in IN 42759 4776 2 addition addition NN 42759 4776 3 to to IN 42759 4776 4 this this DT 42759 4776 5 objection objection NN 42759 4776 6 , , , 42759 4776 7 there there EX 42759 4776 8 is be VBZ 42759 4776 9 the the DT 42759 4776 10 insuperable insuperable JJ 42759 4776 11 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 4776 12 of of IN 42759 4776 13 measuring measure VBG 42759 4776 14 fairly fairly RB 42759 4776 15 or or CC 42759 4776 16 accurately accurately RB 42759 4776 17 the the DT 42759 4776 18 relative relative JJ 42759 4776 19 needs need NNS 42759 4776 20 of of IN 42759 4776 21 any any DT 42759 4776 22 group group NN 42759 4776 23 composed compose VBN 42759 4776 24 of of IN 42759 4776 25 men man NNS 42759 4776 26 , , , 42759 4776 27 women woman NNS 42759 4776 28 , , , 42759 4776 29 and and CC 42759 4776 30 children child NNS 42759 4776 31 . . . 42759 4777 1 Were be VBD 42759 4777 2 the the DT 42759 4777 3 members member NNS 42759 4777 4 ' ' POS 42759 4777 5 own own JJ 42759 4777 6 estimates estimate NNS 42759 4777 7 of of IN 42759 4777 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4777 9 needs need NNS 42759 4777 10 accepted accept VBN 42759 4777 11 by by IN 42759 4777 12 the the DT 42759 4777 13 distributing distribute VBG 42759 4777 14 authority authority NN 42759 4777 15 , , , 42759 4777 16 the the DT 42759 4777 17 social social JJ 42759 4777 18 product product NN 42759 4777 19 would would MD 42759 4777 20 no no RB 42759 4777 21 doubt doubt RB 42759 4777 22 fall fall VB 42759 4777 23 far far RB 42759 4777 24 short short RB 42759 4777 25 of of IN 42759 4777 26 supplying supply VBG 42759 4777 27 all all DT 42759 4777 28 . . . 42759 4778 1 If if IN 42759 4778 2 the the DT 42759 4778 3 measurement measurement NN 42759 4778 4 were be VBD 42759 4778 5 made make VBN 42759 4778 6 by by IN 42759 4778 7 some some DT 42759 4778 8 official official JJ 42759 4778 9 person person NN 42759 4778 10 or or CC 42759 4778 11 persons person NNS 42759 4778 12 , , , 42759 4778 13 " " '' 42759 4778 14 the the DT 42759 4778 15 prospect prospect NN 42759 4778 16 of of IN 42759 4778 17 jobbery jobbery NN 42759 4778 18 and and CC 42759 4778 19 tyranny tyranny NN 42759 4778 20 opened open VBD 42759 4778 21 up up RP 42759 4778 22 must must MD 42759 4778 23 give give VB 42759 4778 24 the the DT 42759 4778 25 most most RBS 42759 4778 26 fanatical fanatical JJ 42759 4778 27 pause pause NN 42759 4778 28 . . . 42759 4778 29 " " '' 42759 4779 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 4779 2 , , , 42759 4779 3 the the DT 42759 4779 4 standard standard NN 42759 4779 5 of of IN 42759 4779 6 needs need NNS 42759 4779 7 should should MD 42759 4779 8 be be VB 42759 4779 9 regarded regard VBN 42759 4779 10 as as IN 42759 4779 11 a a DT 42759 4779 12 canon canon NN 42759 4779 13 of of IN 42759 4779 14 Communism Communism NNP 42759 4779 15 rather rather RB 42759 4779 16 than than IN 42759 4779 17 of of IN 42759 4779 18 Socialism socialism NN 42759 4779 19 ; ; : 42759 4779 20 for for IN 42759 4779 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4779 22 implies imply VBZ 42759 4779 23 a a DT 42759 4779 24 large large JJ 42759 4779 25 measure measure NN 42759 4779 26 of of IN 42759 4779 27 common common JJ 42759 4779 28 life life NN 42759 4779 29 as as RB 42759 4779 30 well well RB 42759 4779 31 as as IN 42759 4779 32 of of IN 42759 4779 33 common common JJ 42759 4779 34 ownership ownership NN 42759 4779 35 , , , 42759 4779 36 and and CC 42759 4779 37 paternalistic paternalistic JJ 42759 4779 38 supervision supervision NN 42759 4779 39 of of IN 42759 4779 40 consumption consumption NN 42759 4779 41 as as RB 42759 4779 42 well well RB 42759 4779 43 as as IN 42759 4779 44 collectivist collectivist JJ 42759 4779 45 management management NN 42759 4779 46 of of IN 42759 4779 47 production production NN 42759 4779 48 . . . 42759 4780 1 While while IN 42759 4780 2 the the DT 42759 4780 3 formula formula NN 42759 4780 4 of of IN 42759 4780 5 needs need NNS 42759 4780 6 must must MD 42759 4780 7 be be VB 42759 4780 8 flatly flatly RB 42759 4780 9 rejected reject VBN 42759 4780 10 as as IN 42759 4780 11 complete complete JJ 42759 4780 12 rule rule NN 42759 4780 13 of of IN 42759 4780 14 distributive distributive JJ 42759 4780 15 justice justice NN 42759 4780 16 , , , 42759 4780 17 or or CC 42759 4780 18 of of IN 42759 4780 19 wage wage NN 42759 4780 20 justice justice NN 42759 4780 21 , , , 42759 4780 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4780 23 is be VBZ 42759 4780 24 valid valid JJ 42759 4780 25 and and CC 42759 4780 26 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 4780 27 as as IN 42759 4780 28 a a DT 42759 4780 29 partial partial JJ 42759 4780 30 standard standard NN 42759 4780 31 . . . 42759 4781 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4781 2 is be VBZ 42759 4781 3 a a DT 42759 4781 4 partial partial JJ 42759 4781 5 measure measure NN 42759 4781 6 of of IN 42759 4781 7 justice justice NN 42759 4781 8 in in IN 42759 4781 9 two two CD 42759 4781 10 senses sense NNS 42759 4781 11 : : : 42759 4781 12 first first RB 42759 4781 13 , , , 42759 4781 14 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 4781 15 as as IN 42759 4781 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4781 17 is be VBZ 42759 4781 18 consistent consistent JJ 42759 4781 19 with with IN 42759 4781 20 the the DT 42759 4781 21 admission admission NN 42759 4781 22 and and CC 42759 4781 23 operation operation NN 42759 4781 24 of of IN 42759 4781 25 other other JJ 42759 4781 26 principles principle NNS 42759 4781 27 , , , 42759 4781 28 such such JJ 42759 4781 29 as as IN 42759 4781 30 productivity productivity NN 42759 4781 31 and and CC 42759 4781 32 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 4781 33 ; ; : 42759 4781 34 second second RB 42759 4781 35 , , , 42759 4781 36 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 4781 37 as as IN 42759 4781 38 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4781 39 can can MD 42759 4781 40 be be VB 42759 4781 41 restricted restrict VBN 42759 4781 42 to to IN 42759 4781 43 certain certain JJ 42759 4781 44 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4781 45 requisites requisite NNS 42759 4781 46 of of IN 42759 4781 47 life life NN 42759 4781 48 , , , 42759 4781 49 instead instead RB 42759 4781 50 of of IN 42759 4781 51 being be VBG 42759 4781 52 applied apply VBN 42759 4781 53 to to IN 42759 4781 54 all all DT 42759 4781 55 possible possible JJ 42759 4781 56 human human JJ 42759 4781 57 needs need NNS 42759 4781 58 . . . 42759 4782 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4782 2 can can MD 42759 4782 3 be be VB 42759 4782 4 made make VBN 42759 4782 5 to to TO 42759 4782 6 safeguard safeguard VB 42759 4782 7 the the DT 42759 4782 8 minimum minimum JJ 42759 4782 9 demands demand NNS 42759 4782 10 of of IN 42759 4782 11 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4782 12 life life NN 42759 4782 13 , , , 42759 4782 14 and and CC 42759 4782 15 therefore therefore RB 42759 4782 16 to to TO 42759 4782 17 function function VB 42759 4782 18 as as IN 42759 4782 19 a a DT 42759 4782 20 minimum minimum JJ 42759 4782 21 standard standard NN 42759 4782 22 of of IN 42759 4782 23 wage wage NN 42759 4782 24 justice justice NN 42759 4782 25 . . . 42759 4783 1 Human human JJ 42759 4783 2 needs need NNS 42759 4783 3 constitute constitute VBP 42759 4783 4 the the DT 42759 4783 5 primary primary JJ 42759 4783 6 title title NN 42759 4783 7 or or CC 42759 4783 8 claim claim NN 42759 4783 9 to to IN 42759 4783 10 material material NN 42759 4783 11 goods good NNS 42759 4783 12 . . . 42759 4784 1 None none NN 42759 4784 2 of of IN 42759 4784 3 the the DT 42759 4784 4 other other JJ 42759 4784 5 recognised recognise VBN 42759 4784 6 titles title NNS 42759 4784 7 , , , 42759 4784 8 such such JJ 42759 4784 9 as as IN 42759 4784 10 productivity productivity NN 42759 4784 11 , , , 42759 4784 12 effort effort NN 42759 4784 13 , , , 42759 4784 14 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 4784 15 , , , 42759 4784 16 purchase purchase NN 42759 4784 17 , , , 42759 4784 18 gift gift NN 42759 4784 19 , , , 42759 4784 20 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 4784 21 , , , 42759 4784 22 or or CC 42759 4784 23 first first JJ 42759 4784 24 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 4784 25 , , , 42759 4784 26 is be VBZ 42759 4784 27 a a DT 42759 4784 28 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4784 29 reason reason NN 42759 4784 30 or or CC 42759 4784 31 justification justification NN 42759 4784 32 of of IN 42759 4784 33 either either DT 42759 4784 34 rewards reward NNS 42759 4784 35 or or CC 42759 4784 36 possessions possession NNS 42759 4784 37 . . . 42759 4785 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4785 2 all all DT 42759 4785 3 assume assume VBP 42759 4785 4 the the DT 42759 4785 5 existence existence NN 42759 4785 6 of of IN 42759 4785 7 needs need NNS 42759 4785 8 as as IN 42759 4785 9 a a DT 42759 4785 10 prerequisite prerequisite NN 42759 4785 11 to to IN 42759 4785 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4785 13 validity validity NN 42759 4785 14 . . . 42759 4786 1 If if IN 42759 4786 2 men man NNS 42759 4786 3 did do VBD 42759 4786 4 not not RB 42759 4786 5 need need VB 42759 4786 6 goods good NNS 42759 4786 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4786 8 could could MD 42759 4786 9 not not RB 42759 4786 10 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 4786 11 lay lay VB 42759 4786 12 claim claim NN 42759 4786 13 to to IN 42759 4786 14 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4786 15 by by IN 42759 4786 16 any any DT 42759 4786 17 of of IN 42759 4786 18 the the DT 42759 4786 19 specific specific JJ 42759 4786 20 titles title NNS 42759 4786 21 just just RB 42759 4786 22 enumerated enumerate VBD 42759 4786 23 . . . 42759 4787 1 First first RB 42759 4787 2 comes come VBZ 42759 4787 3 the the DT 42759 4787 4 general general JJ 42759 4787 5 claim claim NN 42759 4787 6 or or CC 42759 4787 7 fact fact NN 42759 4787 8 of of IN 42759 4787 9 needs need NNS 42759 4787 10 ; ; : 42759 4787 11 then then RB 42759 4787 12 the the DT 42759 4787 13 particular particular JJ 42759 4787 14 title title NN 42759 4787 15 or or CC 42759 4787 16 method method NN 42759 4787 17 by by IN 42759 4787 18 which which WDT 42759 4787 19 the the DT 42759 4787 20 needs need NNS 42759 4787 21 may may MD 42759 4787 22 be be VB 42759 4787 23 conveniently conveniently RB 42759 4787 24 supplied supply VBN 42759 4787 25 . . . 42759 4788 1 While while IN 42759 4788 2 these these DT 42759 4788 3 statements statement NNS 42759 4788 4 may may MD 42759 4788 5 seem seem VB 42759 4788 6 elementary elementary JJ 42759 4788 7 and and CC 42759 4788 8 platitudinous platitudinous JJ 42759 4788 9 , , , 42759 4788 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4788 11 practical practical JJ 42759 4788 12 value value NN 42759 4788 13 will will MD 42759 4788 14 be be VB 42759 4788 15 quite quite RB 42759 4788 16 evident evident JJ 42759 4788 17 when when WRB 42759 4788 18 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4788 19 come come VBP 42759 4788 20 to to TO 42759 4788 21 consider consider VB 42759 4788 22 the the DT 42759 4788 23 conflicting conflict VBG 42759 4788 24 claims claim NNS 42759 4788 25 that that WDT 42759 4788 26 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 4788 27 arise arise VBP 42759 4788 28 out out IN 42759 4788 29 of of IN 42759 4788 30 the the DT 42759 4788 31 clash clash NN 42759 4788 32 between between IN 42759 4788 33 needs need NNS 42759 4788 34 and and CC 42759 4788 35 some some DT 42759 4788 36 of of IN 42759 4788 37 the the DT 42759 4788 38 other other JJ 42759 4788 39 titles title NNS 42759 4788 40 . . . 42759 4789 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 4789 2 shall shall MD 42759 4789 3 see see VB 42759 4789 4 that that IN 42759 4789 5 needs need NNS 42759 4789 6 are be VBP 42759 4789 7 not not RB 42759 4789 8 merely merely RB 42759 4789 9 a a DT 42759 4789 10 physical physical JJ 42759 4789 11 reason reason NN 42759 4789 12 or or CC 42759 4789 13 impulse impulse NN 42759 4789 14 toward toward IN 42759 4789 15 acquisition acquisition NN 42759 4789 16 and and CC 42759 4789 17 possession possession NN 42759 4789 18 , , , 42759 4789 19 but but CC 42759 4789 20 a a DT 42759 4789 21 moral moral JJ 42759 4789 22 title title NN 42759 4789 23 which which WDT 42759 4789 24 rationalises rationalise VBZ 42759 4789 25 the the DT 42759 4789 26 claim claim NN 42759 4789 27 to to IN 42759 4789 28 a a DT 42759 4789 29 certain certain JJ 42759 4789 30 amount amount NN 42759 4789 31 of of IN 42759 4789 32 goods good NNS 42759 4789 33 . . . 42759 4790 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4790 2 243 243 CD 42759 4790 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4790 4 _ _ NNP 42759 4790 5 Three Three NNP 42759 4790 6 Fundamental Fundamental NNP 42759 4790 7 Principles Principles NNPS 42759 4790 8 _ _ VBP 42759 4790 9 The the DT 42759 4790 10 validity validity NN 42759 4790 11 of of IN 42759 4790 12 needs need NNS 42759 4790 13 as as IN 42759 4790 14 a a DT 42759 4790 15 partial partial JJ 42759 4790 16 rule rule NN 42759 4790 17 of of IN 42759 4790 18 wage wage NN 42759 4790 19 justice justice NN 42759 4790 20 rests rest NNS 42759 4790 21 ultimately ultimately RB 42759 4790 22 upon upon IN 42759 4790 23 three three CD 42759 4790 24 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4790 25 principles principle NNS 42759 4790 26 regarding regard VBG 42759 4790 27 man man NN 42759 4790 28 's 's POS 42759 4790 29 position position NN 42759 4790 30 in in IN 42759 4790 31 the the DT 42759 4790 32 universe universe NN 42759 4790 33 . . . 42759 4791 1 The the DT 42759 4791 2 first first JJ 42759 4791 3 is be VBZ 42759 4791 4 that that IN 42759 4791 5 God God NNP 42759 4791 6 created create VBD 42759 4791 7 the the DT 42759 4791 8 earth earth NN 42759 4791 9 for for IN 42759 4791 10 the the DT 42759 4791 11 sustenance sustenance NN 42759 4791 12 of of IN 42759 4791 13 _ _ NNP 42759 4791 14 all all DT 42759 4791 15 _ _ IN 42759 4791 16 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4791 17 children child NNS 42759 4791 18 ; ; : 42759 4791 19 therefore therefore RB 42759 4791 20 , , , 42759 4791 21 that that IN 42759 4791 22 all all DT 42759 4791 23 persons person NNS 42759 4791 24 are be VBP 42759 4791 25 equal equal JJ 42759 4791 26 in in IN 42759 4791 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4791 28 inherent inherent JJ 42759 4791 29 claims claim NNS 42759 4791 30 upon upon IN 42759 4791 31 the the DT 42759 4791 32 bounty bounty NN 42759 4791 33 of of IN 42759 4791 34 nature nature NN 42759 4791 35 . . . 42759 4792 1 As as IN 42759 4792 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4792 3 is be VBZ 42759 4792 4 impossible impossible JJ 42759 4792 5 to to TO 42759 4792 6 demonstrate demonstrate VB 42759 4792 7 that that IN 42759 4792 8 any any DT 42759 4792 9 class class NN 42759 4792 10 of of IN 42759 4792 11 persons person NNS 42759 4792 12 is be VBZ 42759 4792 13 less less RBR 42759 4792 14 important important JJ 42759 4792 15 than than IN 42759 4792 16 another another DT 42759 4792 17 in in IN 42759 4792 18 the the DT 42759 4792 19 eyes eye NNS 42759 4792 20 of of IN 42759 4792 21 God God NNP 42759 4792 22 , , , 42759 4792 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4792 24 is be VBZ 42759 4792 25 logically logically RB 42759 4792 26 impossible impossible JJ 42759 4792 27 for for IN 42759 4792 28 any any DT 42759 4792 29 believer believer NN 42759 4792 30 in in IN 42759 4792 31 Divine Divine NNP 42759 4792 32 Providence Providence NNP 42759 4792 33 to to TO 42759 4792 34 reject reject VB 42759 4792 35 this this DT 42759 4792 36 proposition proposition NN 42759 4792 37 . . . 42759 4793 1 The the DT 42759 4793 2 man man NN 42759 4793 3 who who WP 42759 4793 4 denies deny VBZ 42759 4793 5 God God NNP 42759 4793 6 or or CC 42759 4793 7 Providence Providence NNP 42759 4793 8 can can MD 42759 4793 9 refuse refuse VB 42759 4793 10 assent assent NN 42759 4793 11 to to IN 42759 4793 12 the the DT 42759 4793 13 second second JJ 42759 4793 14 part part NN 42759 4793 15 of of IN 42759 4793 16 the the DT 42759 4793 17 proposition proposition NN 42759 4793 18 only only RB 42759 4793 19 by by IN 42759 4793 20 refusing refuse VBG 42759 4793 21 to to TO 42759 4793 22 acknowledge acknowledge VB 42759 4793 23 the the DT 42759 4793 24 personal personal JJ 42759 4793 25 dignity dignity NN 42759 4793 26 of of IN 42759 4793 27 the the DT 42759 4793 28 human human JJ 42759 4793 29 individual individual NN 42759 4793 30 , , , 42759 4793 31 and and CC 42759 4793 32 the the DT 42759 4793 33 equal equal JJ 42759 4793 34 dignity dignity NN 42759 4793 35 of of IN 42759 4793 36 all all DT 42759 4793 37 persons person NNS 42759 4793 38 . . . 42759 4794 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 4794 2 as as IN 42759 4794 3 the the DT 42759 4794 4 human human JJ 42759 4794 5 person person NN 42759 4794 6 is be VBZ 42759 4794 7 intrinsically intrinsically RB 42759 4794 8 sacred sacred JJ 42759 4794 9 and and CC 42759 4794 10 morally morally RB 42759 4794 11 independent independent JJ 42759 4794 12 , , , 42759 4794 13 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4794 14 is be VBZ 42759 4794 15 endowed endow VBN 42759 4794 16 with with IN 42759 4794 17 those those DT 42759 4794 18 inherent inherent JJ 42759 4794 19 prerogatives prerogative NNS 42759 4794 20 , , , 42759 4794 21 immunities immunity NNS 42759 4794 22 , , , 42759 4794 23 and and CC 42759 4794 24 claims claim VBZ 42759 4794 25 that that IN 42759 4794 26 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4794 27 call call VBP 42759 4794 28 rights right NNS 42759 4794 29 . . . 42759 4795 1 Every every DT 42759 4795 2 person person NN 42759 4795 3 is be VBZ 42759 4795 4 an an DT 42759 4795 5 end end NN 42759 4795 6 in in IN 42759 4795 7 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4795 8 ; ; : 42759 4795 9 none none NN 42759 4795 10 is be VBZ 42759 4795 11 a a DT 42759 4795 12 mere mere JJ 42759 4795 13 instrument instrument NN 42759 4795 14 to to IN 42759 4795 15 the the DT 42759 4795 16 convenience convenience NN 42759 4795 17 or or CC 42759 4795 18 welfare welfare NN 42759 4795 19 of of IN 42759 4795 20 any any DT 42759 4795 21 other other JJ 42759 4795 22 human human JJ 42759 4795 23 being being NN 42759 4795 24 . . . 42759 4796 1 The the DT 42759 4796 2 worth worth NN 42759 4796 3 of of IN 42759 4796 4 a a DT 42759 4796 5 person person NN 42759 4796 6 is be VBZ 42759 4796 7 something something NN 42759 4796 8 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 4796 9 , , , 42759 4796 10 derived derive VBN 42759 4796 11 from from IN 42759 4796 12 within within IN 42759 4796 13 , , , 42759 4796 14 not not RB 42759 4796 15 determined determined JJ 42759 4796 16 or or CC 42759 4796 17 measurable measurable JJ 42759 4796 18 by by IN 42759 4796 19 reference reference NN 42759 4796 20 to to IN 42759 4796 21 any any DT 42759 4796 22 earthly earthly JJ 42759 4796 23 object object NN 42759 4796 24 or or CC 42759 4796 25 purpose purpose NN 42759 4796 26 without without IN 42759 4796 27 . . . 42759 4797 1 In in IN 42759 4797 2 this this DT 42759 4797 3 respect respect NN 42759 4797 4 the the DT 42759 4797 5 human human JJ 42759 4797 6 being being NN 42759 4797 7 differs differ NNS 42759 4797 8 infinitely infinitely RB 42759 4797 9 from from IN 42759 4797 10 , , , 42759 4797 11 is be VBZ 42759 4797 12 infinitely infinitely RB 42759 4797 13 superior superior JJ 42759 4797 14 to to IN 42759 4797 15 , , , 42759 4797 16 a a DT 42759 4797 17 stone stone NN 42759 4797 18 , , , 42759 4797 19 a a DT 42759 4797 20 rose rose NN 42759 4797 21 , , , 42759 4797 22 or or CC 42759 4797 23 a a DT 42759 4797 24 horse horse NN 42759 4797 25 . . . 42759 4798 1 While while IN 42759 4798 2 these these DT 42759 4798 3 statements statement NNS 42759 4798 4 help help VBP 42759 4798 5 to to TO 42759 4798 6 illustrate illustrate VB 42759 4798 7 what what WP 42759 4798 8 is be VBZ 42759 4798 9 meant mean VBN 42759 4798 10 by by IN 42759 4798 11 the the DT 42759 4798 12 dignity dignity NN 42759 4798 13 of of IN 42759 4798 14 personality personality NN 42759 4798 15 , , , 42759 4798 16 by by IN 42759 4798 17 the the DT 42759 4798 18 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 4798 19 worth worth NN 42759 4798 20 , , , 42759 4798 21 importance importance NN 42759 4798 22 , , , 42759 4798 23 sacredness sacredness NN 42759 4798 24 of of IN 42759 4798 25 the the DT 42759 4798 26 human human JJ 42759 4798 27 being being NN 42759 4798 28 , , , 42759 4798 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4798 30 do do VBP 42759 4798 31 not not RB 42759 4798 32 prove prove VB 42759 4798 33 the the DT 42759 4798 34 existence existence NN 42759 4798 35 of of IN 42759 4798 36 this this DT 42759 4798 37 inherent inherent JJ 42759 4798 38 juridical juridical JJ 42759 4798 39 quality quality NN 42759 4798 40 . . . 42759 4799 1 Proof proof NN 42759 4799 2 in in IN 42759 4799 3 the the DT 42759 4799 4 strict strict JJ 42759 4799 5 sense sense NN 42759 4799 6 is be VBZ 42759 4799 7 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 42759 4799 8 and and CC 42759 4799 9 impossible impossible JJ 42759 4799 10 . . . 42759 4800 1 If if IN 42759 4800 2 the the DT 42759 4800 3 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 4800 4 and and CC 42759 4800 5 equal equal JJ 42759 4800 6 moral moral JJ 42759 4800 7 worth worth NN 42759 4800 8 of of IN 42759 4800 9 all all DT 42759 4800 10 persons person NNS 42759 4800 11 be be VB 42759 4800 12 not not RB 42759 4800 13 self self NN 42759 4800 14 evident evident JJ 42759 4800 15 to to IN 42759 4800 16 a a DT 42759 4800 17 man man NN 42759 4800 18 , , , 42759 4800 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4800 20 will will MD 42759 4800 21 not not RB 42759 4800 22 approve approve VB 42759 4800 23 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 4800 24 to to IN 42759 4800 25 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4800 26 through through IN 42759 4800 27 any any DT 42759 4800 28 process process NN 42759 4800 29 of of IN 42759 4800 30 argumentation argumentation NN 42759 4800 31 . . . 42759 4801 1 Whosoever whosoever WP 42759 4801 2 denies deny VBZ 42759 4801 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4801 4 can can MD 42759 4801 5 also also RB 42759 4801 6 logically logically RB 42759 4801 7 deny deny VB 42759 4801 8 men man NNS 42759 4801 9 's 's POS 42759 4801 10 equal equal JJ 42759 4801 11 claims claim NNS 42759 4801 12 of of IN 42759 4801 13 access access NN 42759 4801 14 to to IN 42759 4801 15 the the DT 42759 4801 16 bounty bounty NN 42759 4801 17 of of IN 42759 4801 18 the the DT 42759 4801 19 earth earth NN 42759 4801 20 ; ; : 42759 4801 21 but but CC 42759 4801 22 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4801 23 can can MD 42759 4801 24 not not RB 42759 4801 25 escape escape VB 42759 4801 26 the the DT 42759 4801 27 alternative alternative JJ 42759 4801 28 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 4801 29 that that IN 42759 4801 30 brute brute JJ 42759 4801 31 force force NN 42759 4801 32 , , , 42759 4801 33 exercised exercise VBN 42759 4801 34 either either CC 42759 4801 35 by by IN 42759 4801 36 the the DT 42759 4801 37 State state NN 42759 4801 38 or or CC 42759 4801 39 by by IN 42759 4801 40 individuals individual NNS 42759 4801 41 , , , 42759 4801 42 is be VBZ 42759 4801 43 the the DT 42759 4801 44 only only JJ 42759 4801 45 proper proper JJ 42759 4801 46 determinant determinant NN 42759 4801 47 of of IN 42759 4801 48 possessions possession NNS 42759 4801 49 and and CC 42759 4801 50 of of IN 42759 4801 51 property property NN 42759 4801 52 . . . 42759 4802 1 Against against IN 42759 4802 2 this this DT 42759 4802 3 monstrous monstrous JJ 42759 4802 4 contention contention NN 42759 4802 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4802 6 is be VBZ 42759 4802 7 not not RB 42759 4802 8 worth worth JJ 42759 4802 9 while while IN 42759 4802 10 to to TO 42759 4802 11 offer offer VB 42759 4802 12 a a DT 42759 4802 13 formal formal JJ 42759 4802 14 argument argument NN 42759 4802 15 . . . 42759 4803 1 The the DT 42759 4803 2 second second JJ 42759 4803 3 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4803 4 principle principle NN 42759 4803 5 is be VBZ 42759 4803 6 that that IN 42759 4803 7 the the DT 42759 4803 8 inherent inherent JJ 42759 4803 9 right right NN 42759 4803 10 of of IN 42759 4803 11 access access NN 42759 4803 12 to to IN 42759 4803 13 the the DT 42759 4803 14 earth earth NN 42759 4803 15 is be VBZ 42759 4803 16 conditioned condition VBN 42759 4803 17 upon upon IN 42759 4803 18 , , , 42759 4803 19 and and CC 42759 4803 20 becomes become VBZ 42759 4803 21 actually actually RB 42759 4803 22 valid valid JJ 42759 4803 23 through through IN 42759 4803 24 , , , 42759 4803 25 the the DT 42759 4803 26 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 4803 27 of of IN 42759 4803 28 useful useful JJ 42759 4803 29 labour labour NN 42759 4803 30 . . . 42759 4804 1 Generally generally RB 42759 4804 2 speaking speak VBG 42759 4804 3 the the DT 42759 4804 4 fruits fruit NNS 42759 4804 5 and and CC 42759 4804 6 potentialities potentiality NNS 42759 4804 7 of of IN 42759 4804 8 the the DT 42759 4804 9 earth earth NN 42759 4804 10 do do VBP 42759 4804 11 not not RB 42759 4804 12 become become VB 42759 4804 13 available available JJ 42759 4804 14 to to IN 42759 4804 15 men man NNS 42759 4804 16 without without IN 42759 4804 17 previous previous JJ 42759 4804 18 exertion exertion NN 42759 4804 19 . . . 42759 4805 1 " " `` 42759 4805 2 In in IN 42759 4805 3 the the DT 42759 4805 4 sweat sweat NN 42759 4805 5 of of IN 42759 4805 6 thy thy PRP$ 42759 4805 7 brow brow NNP 42759 4805 8 thou thou NNP 42759 4805 9 shalt shalt NNP 42759 4805 10 eat eat VB 42759 4805 11 thy thy PRP$ 42759 4805 12 bread bread NN 42759 4805 13 , , , 42759 4805 14 " " '' 42759 4805 15 is be VBZ 42759 4805 16 a a DT 42759 4805 17 physical physical JJ 42759 4805 18 no no DT 42759 4805 19 less less JJR 42759 4805 20 than than IN 42759 4805 21 a a DT 42759 4805 22 moral moral JJ 42759 4805 23 commandment commandment NN 42759 4805 24 . . . 42759 4806 1 There there EX 42759 4806 2 are be VBP 42759 4806 3 , , , 42759 4806 4 indeed indeed RB 42759 4806 5 , , , 42759 4806 6 exceptions exception NNS 42759 4806 7 : : : 42759 4806 8 the the DT 42759 4806 9 very very RB 42759 4806 10 young young JJ 42759 4806 11 , , , 42759 4806 12 the the DT 42759 4806 13 infirm infirm NN 42759 4806 14 , , , 42759 4806 15 and and CC 42759 4806 16 the the DT 42759 4806 17 possessors possessor NNS 42759 4806 18 of of IN 42759 4806 19 a a DT 42759 4806 20 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4806 21 amount amount NN 42759 4806 22 of of IN 42759 4806 23 property property NN 42759 4806 24 . . . 42759 4807 1 The the DT 42759 4807 2 two two CD 42759 4807 3 former former JJ 42759 4807 4 classes class NNS 42759 4807 5 have have VBP 42759 4807 6 claims claim NNS 42759 4807 7 to to IN 42759 4807 8 a a DT 42759 4807 9 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4807 10 through through IN 42759 4807 11 piety piety NN 42759 4807 12 and and CC 42759 4807 13 charity charity NN 42759 4807 14 , , , 42759 4807 15 while while IN 42759 4807 16 the the DT 42759 4807 17 third third JJ 42759 4807 18 group group NN 42759 4807 19 has have VBZ 42759 4807 20 at at IN 42759 4807 21 least least JJS 42759 4807 22 a a DT 42759 4807 23 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 4807 24 claim claim NN 42759 4807 25 of of IN 42759 4807 26 justice justice NN 42759 4807 27 to to TO 42759 4807 28 rent rent VB 42759 4807 29 and and CC 42759 4807 30 interest interest NN 42759 4807 31 , , , 42759 4807 32 and and CC 42759 4807 33 a a DT 42759 4807 34 certain certain JJ 42759 4807 35 claim claim NN 42759 4807 36 of of IN 42759 4807 37 justice justice NN 42759 4807 38 to to IN 42759 4807 39 the the DT 42759 4807 40 money money NN 42759 4807 41 value value NN 42759 4807 42 of of IN 42759 4807 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4807 44 goods good NNS 42759 4807 45 . . . 42759 4808 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 4808 2 , , , 42759 4808 3 the the DT 42759 4808 4 general general JJ 42759 4808 5 condition condition NN 42759 4808 6 is be VBZ 42759 4808 7 that that IN 42759 4808 8 men man NNS 42759 4808 9 must must MD 42759 4808 10 work work VB 42759 4808 11 in in IN 42759 4808 12 order order NN 42759 4808 13 to to TO 42759 4808 14 live live VB 42759 4808 15 . . . 42759 4809 1 " " `` 42759 4809 2 If if IN 42759 4809 3 a a DT 42759 4809 4 man man NN 42759 4809 5 will will MD 42759 4809 6 not not RB 42759 4809 7 work work VB 42759 4809 8 neither neither CC 42759 4809 9 shall shall MD 42759 4809 10 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4809 11 eat eat VB 42759 4809 12 . . . 42759 4809 13 " " '' 42759 4810 1 For for IN 42759 4810 2 those those DT 42759 4810 3 who who WP 42759 4810 4 refuse refuse VBP 42759 4810 5 to to TO 42759 4810 6 comply comply VB 42759 4810 7 with with IN 42759 4810 8 this this DT 42759 4810 9 condition condition NN 42759 4810 10 the the DT 42759 4810 11 inherent inherent JJ 42759 4810 12 right right NN 42759 4810 13 of of IN 42759 4810 14 access access NN 42759 4810 15 to to IN 42759 4810 16 the the DT 42759 4810 17 earth earth NN 42759 4810 18 remains remain VBZ 42759 4810 19 only only RB 42759 4810 20 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 42759 4810 21 and and CC 42759 4810 22 suspended suspend VBN 42759 4810 23 . . . 42759 4811 1 The the DT 42759 4811 2 two two CD 42759 4811 3 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 4811 4 principles principle NNS 42759 4811 5 involve involve VBP 42759 4811 6 as as IN 42759 4811 7 a a DT 42759 4811 8 corollary corollary JJ 42759 4811 9 a a DT 42759 4811 10 third third JJ 42759 4811 11 principle principle NN 42759 4811 12 ; ; : 42759 4811 13 the the DT 42759 4811 14 men man NNS 42759 4811 15 who who WP 42759 4811 16 are be VBP 42759 4811 17 in in IN 42759 4811 18 present present JJ 42759 4811 19 control control NN 42759 4811 20 of of IN 42759 4811 21 the the DT 42759 4811 22 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 4811 23 of of IN 42759 4811 24 the the DT 42759 4811 25 earth earth NN 42759 4811 26 are be VBP 42759 4811 27 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4811 28 to to TO 42759 4811 29 permit permit VB 42759 4811 30 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4811 31 access access NN 42759 4811 32 to to IN 42759 4811 33 these these DT 42759 4811 34 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 4811 35 by by IN 42759 4811 36 persons person NNS 42759 4811 37 who who WP 42759 4811 38 are be VBP 42759 4811 39 willing willing JJ 42759 4811 40 to to TO 42759 4811 41 work work VB 42759 4811 42 . . . 42759 4812 1 In in IN 42759 4812 2 other other JJ 42759 4812 3 words word NNS 42759 4812 4 , , , 42759 4812 5 possessors possessor NNS 42759 4812 6 must must MD 42759 4812 7 so so RB 42759 4812 8 administer administer VB 42759 4812 9 the the DT 42759 4812 10 common common JJ 42759 4812 11 bounty bounty NN 42759 4812 12 of of IN 42759 4812 13 nature nature NN 42759 4812 14 that that IN 42759 4812 15 non non JJ 42759 4812 16 - - NNS 42759 4812 17 owners owner NNS 42759 4812 18 will will MD 42759 4812 19 not not RB 42759 4812 20 find find VB 42759 4812 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4812 22 unreasonably unreasonably RB 42759 4812 23 difficult difficult JJ 42759 4812 24 to to TO 42759 4812 25 get get VB 42759 4812 26 a a DT 42759 4812 27 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4812 28 . . . 42759 4813 1 To to TO 42759 4813 2 put put VB 42759 4813 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4813 4 still still RB 42759 4813 5 in in IN 42759 4813 6 other other JJ 42759 4813 7 terms term NNS 42759 4813 8 , , , 42759 4813 9 the the DT 42759 4813 10 right right NN 42759 4813 11 to to TO 42759 4813 12 subsist subsist VB 42759 4813 13 from from IN 42759 4813 14 the the DT 42759 4813 15 earth earth NN 42759 4813 16 implies imply VBZ 42759 4813 17 the the DT 42759 4813 18 right right NN 42759 4813 19 to to TO 42759 4813 20 access access VB 42759 4813 21 thereto thereto NN 42759 4813 22 on on IN 42759 4813 23 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4813 24 terms term NNS 42759 4813 25 . . . 42759 4814 1 When when WRB 42759 4814 2 any any DT 42759 4814 3 man man NN 42759 4814 4 who who WP 42759 4814 5 is be VBZ 42759 4814 6 willing willing JJ 42759 4814 7 to to TO 42759 4814 8 work work VB 42759 4814 9 is be VBZ 42759 4814 10 denied deny VBN 42759 4814 11 the the DT 42759 4814 12 exercise exercise NN 42759 4814 13 of of IN 42759 4814 14 this this DT 42759 4814 15 right right NN 42759 4814 16 , , , 42759 4814 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4814 18 is be VBZ 42759 4814 19 no no DT 42759 4814 20 longer long RBR 42759 4814 21 treated treat VBN 42759 4814 22 as as IN 42759 4814 23 the the DT 42759 4814 24 moral moral JJ 42759 4814 25 and and CC 42759 4814 26 juridical juridical JJ 42759 4814 27 equal equal JJ 42759 4814 28 of of IN 42759 4814 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4814 30 fellows fellow NNS 42759 4814 31 . . . 42759 4815 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4815 2 is be VBZ 42759 4815 3 regarded regard VBN 42759 4815 4 as as IN 42759 4815 5 inherently inherently RB 42759 4815 6 inferior inferior JJ 42759 4815 7 to to IN 42759 4815 8 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4815 9 , , , 42759 4815 10 as as IN 42759 4815 11 a a DT 42759 4815 12 mere mere JJ 42759 4815 13 instrument instrument NN 42759 4815 14 to to IN 42759 4815 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4815 16 convenience convenience NN 42759 4815 17 ; ; : 42759 4815 18 and and CC 42759 4815 19 those those DT 42759 4815 20 who who WP 42759 4815 21 exclude exclude VBP 42759 4815 22 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4815 23 are be VBP 42759 4815 24 virtually virtually RB 42759 4815 25 taking take VBG 42759 4815 26 the the DT 42759 4815 27 position position NN 42759 4815 28 that that IN 42759 4815 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4815 30 rights right NNS 42759 4815 31 to to IN 42759 4815 32 the the DT 42759 4815 33 common common JJ 42759 4815 34 gifts gift NNS 42759 4815 35 of of IN 42759 4815 36 the the DT 42759 4815 37 Creator Creator NNP 42759 4815 38 are be VBP 42759 4815 39 inherently inherently RB 42759 4815 40 superior superior JJ 42759 4815 41 to to IN 42759 4815 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4815 43 birthright birthright NN 42759 4815 44 . . . 42759 4816 1 Obviously obviously RB 42759 4816 2 this this DT 42759 4816 3 position position NN 42759 4816 4 can can MD 42759 4816 5 not not RB 42759 4816 6 be be VB 42759 4816 7 defended defend VBN 42759 4816 8 on on IN 42759 4816 9 grounds ground NNS 42759 4816 10 of of IN 42759 4816 11 reason reason NN 42759 4816 12 . . . 42759 4817 1 Possessors possessor NNS 42759 4817 2 are be VBP 42759 4817 3 no no RB 42759 4817 4 more more RBR 42759 4817 5 justified justified JJ 42759 4817 6 in in IN 42759 4817 7 excluding exclude VBG 42759 4817 8 a a DT 42759 4817 9 man man NN 42759 4817 10 from from IN 42759 4817 11 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4817 12 access access NN 42759 4817 13 to to IN 42759 4817 14 the the DT 42759 4817 15 goods good NNS 42759 4817 16 of of IN 42759 4817 17 the the DT 42759 4817 18 earth earth NN 42759 4817 19 than than IN 42759 4817 20 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4817 21 would would MD 42759 4817 22 be be VB 42759 4817 23 in in IN 42759 4817 24 depriving deprive VBG 42759 4817 25 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4817 26 of of IN 42759 4817 27 the the DT 42759 4817 28 liberty liberty NN 42759 4817 29 to to TO 42759 4817 30 move move VB 42759 4817 31 from from IN 42759 4817 32 place place NN 42759 4817 33 to to IN 42759 4817 34 place place NN 42759 4817 35 . . . 42759 4818 1 The the DT 42759 4818 2 community community NN 42759 4818 3 that that WDT 42759 4818 4 should should MD 42759 4818 5 arbitrarily arbitrarily RB 42759 4818 6 shut shut VB 42759 4818 7 a a DT 42759 4818 8 man man NN 42759 4818 9 up up RP 42759 4818 10 in in IN 42759 4818 11 prison prison NN 42759 4818 12 would would MD 42759 4818 13 not not RB 42759 4818 14 violate violate VB 42759 4818 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4818 16 rights right NNS 42759 4818 17 more more RBR 42759 4818 18 fundamentally fundamentally RB 42759 4818 19 than than IN 42759 4818 20 the the DT 42759 4818 21 community community NN 42759 4818 22 or or CC 42759 4818 23 the the DT 42759 4818 24 proprietors proprietor NNS 42759 4818 25 who who WP 42759 4818 26 should should MD 42759 4818 27 shut shut VB 42759 4818 28 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4818 29 out out RP 42759 4818 30 from from IN 42759 4818 31 the the DT 42759 4818 32 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 4818 33 of of IN 42759 4818 34 getting get VBG 42759 4818 35 a a DT 42759 4818 36 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4818 37 from from IN 42759 4818 38 the the DT 42759 4818 39 bounty bounty NN 42759 4818 40 of of IN 42759 4818 41 the the DT 42759 4818 42 earth earth NN 42759 4818 43 . . . 42759 4819 1 In in IN 42759 4819 2 both both DT 42759 4819 3 cases case NNS 42759 4819 4 the the DT 42759 4819 5 man man NN 42759 4819 6 demands demand VBZ 42759 4819 7 and and CC 42759 4819 8 has have VBZ 42759 4819 9 a a DT 42759 4819 10 right right NN 42759 4819 11 to to IN 42759 4819 12 a a DT 42759 4819 13 common common JJ 42759 4819 14 gift gift NN 42759 4819 15 of of IN 42759 4819 16 God God NNP 42759 4819 17 . . . 42759 4820 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4820 2 moral moral JJ 42759 4820 3 claim claim NN 42759 4820 4 is be VBZ 42759 4820 5 as as RB 42759 4820 6 valid valid JJ 42759 4820 7 to to IN 42759 4820 8 the the DT 42759 4820 9 one one CD 42759 4820 10 good good NN 42759 4820 11 as as IN 42759 4820 12 to to IN 42759 4820 13 the the DT 42759 4820 14 other other JJ 42759 4820 15 , , , 42759 4820 16 and and CC 42759 4820 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4820 18 is be VBZ 42759 4820 19 as as RB 42759 4820 20 valid valid JJ 42759 4820 21 to to IN 42759 4820 22 both both DT 42759 4820 23 goods good NNS 42759 4820 24 as as IN 42759 4820 25 is be VBZ 42759 4820 26 the the DT 42759 4820 27 claim claim NN 42759 4820 28 of of IN 42759 4820 29 any any DT 42759 4820 30 of of IN 42759 4820 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4820 32 fellows fellow NNS 42759 4820 33 . . . 42759 4821 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4821 2 The the DT 42759 4821 3 Right Right NNP 42759 4821 4 to to IN 42759 4821 5 a a DT 42759 4821 6 Decent Decent NNP 42759 4821 7 Livelihood Livelihood NNP 42759 4821 8 _ _ NNP 42759 4821 9 Every every DT 42759 4821 10 man man NN 42759 4821 11 who who WP 42759 4821 12 is be VBZ 42759 4821 13 willing willing JJ 42759 4821 14 to to TO 42759 4821 15 work work VB 42759 4821 16 has have VBZ 42759 4821 17 , , , 42759 4821 18 therefore therefore RB 42759 4821 19 , , , 42759 4821 20 an an DT 42759 4821 21 inborn inborn JJ 42759 4821 22 right right NN 42759 4821 23 to to TO 42759 4821 24 sustenance sustenance VB 42759 4821 25 from from IN 42759 4821 26 the the DT 42759 4821 27 earth earth NN 42759 4821 28 on on IN 42759 4821 29 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4821 30 terms term NNS 42759 4821 31 or or CC 42759 4821 32 conditions condition NNS 42759 4821 33 . . . 42759 4822 1 This this DT 42759 4822 2 can can MD 42759 4822 3 not not RB 42759 4822 4 mean mean VB 42759 4822 5 that that IN 42759 4822 6 all all DT 42759 4822 7 persons person NNS 42759 4822 8 have have VBP 42759 4822 9 a a DT 42759 4822 10 right right NN 42759 4822 11 to to TO 42759 4822 12 equal equal JJ 42759 4822 13 amounts amount NNS 42759 4822 14 of of IN 42759 4822 15 sustenance sustenance NN 42759 4822 16 or or CC 42759 4822 17 income income NN 42759 4822 18 ; ; : 42759 4822 19 for for IN 42759 4822 20 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4822 21 have have VBP 42759 4822 22 seen see VBN 42759 4822 23 on on IN 42759 4822 24 a a DT 42759 4822 25 preceding precede VBG 42759 4822 26 page page NN 42759 4822 27 that that IN 42759 4822 28 men man NNS 42759 4822 29 's 's POS 42759 4822 30 needs need NNS 42759 4822 31 , , , 42759 4822 32 the the DT 42759 4822 33 primary primary JJ 42759 4822 34 title title NN 42759 4822 35 to to IN 42759 4822 36 property property NN 42759 4822 37 , , , 42759 4822 38 are be VBP 42759 4822 39 not not RB 42759 4822 40 equal equal JJ 42759 4822 41 , , , 42759 4822 42 and and CC 42759 4822 43 that that IN 42759 4822 44 other other JJ 42759 4822 45 canons canon NNS 42759 4822 46 and and CC 42759 4822 47 factors factor NNS 42759 4822 48 of of IN 42759 4822 49 distribution distribution NN 42759 4822 50 have have VBP 42759 4822 51 to to TO 42759 4822 52 be be VB 42759 4822 53 allowed allow VBN 42759 4822 54 some some DT 42759 4822 55 weight weight NN 42759 4822 56 in in IN 42759 4822 57 determining determine VBG 42759 4822 58 the the DT 42759 4822 59 division division NN 42759 4822 60 of of IN 42759 4822 61 goods good NNS 42759 4822 62 and and CC 42759 4822 63 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 4822 64 . . . 42759 4823 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 4823 2 , , , 42759 4823 3 there there EX 42759 4823 4 is be VBZ 42759 4823 5 a a DT 42759 4823 6 certain certain JJ 42759 4823 7 minimum minimum NN 42759 4823 8 of of IN 42759 4823 9 goods good NNS 42759 4823 10 to to TO 42759 4823 11 which which WDT 42759 4823 12 every every DT 42759 4823 13 worker worker NN 42759 4823 14 is be VBZ 42759 4823 15 entitled entitle VBN 42759 4823 16 by by IN 42759 4823 17 reason reason NN 42759 4823 18 of of IN 42759 4823 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4823 20 inherent inherent JJ 42759 4823 21 right right NN 42759 4823 22 of of IN 42759 4823 23 access access NN 42759 4823 24 to to IN 42759 4823 25 the the DT 42759 4823 26 earth earth NN 42759 4823 27 . . . 42759 4824 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4824 2 has have VBZ 42759 4824 3 a a DT 42759 4824 4 right right NN 42759 4824 5 to to IN 42759 4824 6 at at RB 42759 4824 7 least least JJS 42759 4824 8 a a DT 42759 4824 9 _ _ NNP 42759 4824 10 decent decent JJ 42759 4824 11 _ _ NNP 42759 4824 12 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4824 13 . . . 42759 4825 1 That that DT 42759 4825 2 is is RB 42759 4825 3 ; ; : 42759 4825 4 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4825 5 has have VBZ 42759 4825 6 a a DT 42759 4825 7 right right NN 42759 4825 8 to to IN 42759 4825 9 so so RB 42759 4825 10 much much JJ 42759 4825 11 of of IN 42759 4825 12 the the DT 42759 4825 13 requisites requisite NNS 42759 4825 14 of of IN 42759 4825 15 sustenance sustenance NN 42759 4825 16 as as IN 42759 4825 17 will will MD 42759 4825 18 enable enable VB 42759 4825 19 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4825 20 to to TO 42759 4825 21 live live VB 42759 4825 22 in in IN 42759 4825 23 a a DT 42759 4825 24 manner manner NN 42759 4825 25 worthy worthy JJ 42759 4825 26 of of IN 42759 4825 27 a a DT 42759 4825 28 human human JJ 42759 4825 29 being being NN 42759 4825 30 . . . 42759 4826 1 The the DT 42759 4826 2 elements element NNS 42759 4826 3 of of IN 42759 4826 4 a a DT 42759 4826 5 decent decent JJ 42759 4826 6 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4826 7 may may MD 42759 4826 8 be be VB 42759 4826 9 summarily summarily RB 42759 4826 10 described describe VBN 42759 4826 11 as as IN 42759 4826 12 : : : 42759 4826 13 food food NN 42759 4826 14 , , , 42759 4826 15 clothing clothing NN 42759 4826 16 , , , 42759 4826 17 and and CC 42759 4826 18 housing housing NN 42759 4826 19 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4826 20 in in IN 42759 4826 21 quantity quantity NN 42759 4826 22 and and CC 42759 4826 23 quality quality NN 42759 4826 24 to to TO 42759 4826 25 maintain maintain VB 42759 4826 26 the the DT 42759 4826 27 worker worker NN 42759 4826 28 in in IN 42759 4826 29 normal normal JJ 42759 4826 30 health health NN 42759 4826 31 , , , 42759 4826 32 in in IN 42759 4826 33 elementary elementary JJ 42759 4826 34 comfort comfort NN 42759 4826 35 , , , 42759 4826 36 and and CC 42759 4826 37 in in IN 42759 4826 38 an an DT 42759 4826 39 environment environment NN 42759 4826 40 suitable suitable JJ 42759 4826 41 to to IN 42759 4826 42 the the DT 42759 4826 43 protection protection NN 42759 4826 44 of of IN 42759 4826 45 morality morality NN 42759 4826 46 and and CC 42759 4826 47 religion religion NN 42759 4826 48 ; ; , 42759 4826 49 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4826 50 provision provision NN 42759 4826 51 for for IN 42759 4826 52 the the DT 42759 4826 53 future future NN 42759 4826 54 to to TO 42759 4826 55 bring bring VB 42759 4826 56 elementary elementary JJ 42759 4826 57 contentment contentment NN 42759 4826 58 , , , 42759 4826 59 and and CC 42759 4826 60 security security NN 42759 4826 61 against against IN 42759 4826 62 sickness sickness NN 42759 4826 63 , , , 42759 4826 64 accident accident NN 42759 4826 65 , , , 42759 4826 66 and and CC 42759 4826 67 invalidity invalidity NN 42759 4826 68 ; ; , 42759 4826 69 and and CC 42759 4826 70 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4826 71 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 4826 72 of of IN 42759 4826 73 recreation recreation NN 42759 4826 74 , , , 42759 4826 75 social social JJ 42759 4826 76 intercourse intercourse NN 42759 4826 77 , , , 42759 4826 78 education education NN 42759 4826 79 , , , 42759 4826 80 and and CC 42759 4826 81 church church NN 42759 4826 82 - - HYPH 42759 4826 83 membership membership NN 42759 4826 84 to to TO 42759 4826 85 conserve conserve VB 42759 4826 86 health health NN 42759 4826 87 and and CC 42759 4826 88 strength strength NN 42759 4826 89 , , , 42759 4826 90 and and CC 42759 4826 91 to to TO 42759 4826 92 render render VB 42759 4826 93 possible possible JJ 42759 4826 94 in in IN 42759 4826 95 some some DT 42759 4826 96 degree degree NN 42759 4826 97 the the DT 42759 4826 98 exercise exercise NN 42759 4826 99 of of IN 42759 4826 100 the the DT 42759 4826 101 higher high JJR 42759 4826 102 faculties faculty NNS 42759 4826 103 . . . 42759 4827 1 On on IN 42759 4827 2 what what WDT 42759 4827 3 ground ground NN 42759 4827 4 is be VBZ 42759 4827 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4827 6 contended contend VBN 42759 4827 7 that that IN 42759 4827 8 a a DT 42759 4827 9 worker worker NN 42759 4827 10 has have VBZ 42759 4827 11 a a DT 42759 4827 12 right right NN 42759 4827 13 to to IN 42759 4827 14 a a DT 42759 4827 15 decent decent JJ 42759 4827 16 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4827 17 , , , 42759 4827 18 as as IN 42759 4827 19 thus thus RB 42759 4827 20 defined define VBN 42759 4827 21 , , , 42759 4827 22 rather rather RB 42759 4827 23 than than IN 42759 4827 24 to to IN 42759 4827 25 a a DT 42759 4827 26 bare bare JJ 42759 4827 27 subsistence subsistence NN 42759 4827 28 ? ? . 42759 4828 1 On on IN 42759 4828 2 the the DT 42759 4828 3 same same JJ 42759 4828 4 ground ground NN 42759 4828 5 that that WDT 42759 4828 6 validates validate VBZ 42759 4828 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4828 8 right right NN 42759 4828 9 to to IN 42759 4828 10 life life NN 42759 4828 11 , , , 42759 4828 12 marriage marriage NN 42759 4828 13 , , , 42759 4828 14 or or CC 42759 4828 15 any any DT 42759 4828 16 of of IN 42759 4828 17 the the DT 42759 4828 18 other other JJ 42759 4828 19 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4828 20 goods good NNS 42759 4828 21 of of IN 42759 4828 22 human human JJ 42759 4828 23 existence existence NN 42759 4828 24 . . . 42759 4829 1 On on IN 42759 4829 2 the the DT 42759 4829 3 dignity dignity NN 42759 4829 4 of of IN 42759 4829 5 personality personality NN 42759 4829 6 . . . 42759 4830 1 Why why WRB 42759 4830 2 is be VBZ 42759 4830 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4830 4 wrong wrong JJ 42759 4830 5 and and CC 42759 4830 6 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4830 7 to to TO 42759 4830 8 kill kill VB 42759 4830 9 or or CC 42759 4830 10 maim maim VB 42759 4830 11 an an DT 42759 4830 12 innocent innocent JJ 42759 4830 13 man man NN 42759 4830 14 ? ? . 42759 4831 1 Because because IN 42759 4831 2 human human JJ 42759 4831 3 life life NN 42759 4831 4 and and CC 42759 4831 5 the the DT 42759 4831 6 human human JJ 42759 4831 7 person person NN 42759 4831 8 possess possess VBP 42759 4831 9 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 4831 10 worth worth NN 42759 4831 11 ; ; : 42759 4831 12 because because IN 42759 4831 13 personality personality NN 42759 4831 14 is be VBZ 42759 4831 15 sacred sacred JJ 42759 4831 16 . . . 42759 4832 1 But but CC 42759 4832 2 the the DT 42759 4832 3 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 4832 4 worth worth NN 42759 4832 5 and and CC 42759 4832 6 sacredness sacredness NN 42759 4832 7 of of IN 42759 4832 8 personality personality NN 42759 4832 9 imply imply VB 42759 4832 10 something something NN 42759 4832 11 more more JJR 42759 4832 12 than than IN 42759 4832 13 security security NN 42759 4832 14 of of IN 42759 4832 15 life life NN 42759 4832 16 and and CC 42759 4832 17 limb limb NN 42759 4832 18 , , , 42759 4832 19 and and CC 42759 4832 20 the the DT 42759 4832 21 material material NN 42759 4832 22 means mean NNS 42759 4832 23 of of IN 42759 4832 24 bare bare JJ 42759 4832 25 existence existence NN 42759 4832 26 . . . 42759 4833 1 The the DT 42759 4833 2 man man NN 42759 4833 3 who who WP 42759 4833 4 is be VBZ 42759 4833 5 not not RB 42759 4833 6 provided provide VBN 42759 4833 7 with with IN 42759 4833 8 the the DT 42759 4833 9 requisites requisite NNS 42759 4833 10 of of IN 42759 4833 11 normal normal JJ 42759 4833 12 health health NN 42759 4833 13 , , , 42759 4833 14 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 4833 15 , , , 42759 4833 16 and and CC 42759 4833 17 contentment contentment NN 42759 4833 18 lives live VBZ 42759 4833 19 a a DT 42759 4833 20 maimed maim VBN 42759 4833 21 life life NN 42759 4833 22 , , , 42759 4833 23 not not RB 42759 4833 24 a a DT 42759 4833 25 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4833 26 life life NN 42759 4833 27 . . . 42759 4834 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4834 2 physical physical JJ 42759 4834 3 condition condition NN 42759 4834 4 is be VBZ 42759 4834 5 not not RB 42759 4834 6 worthy worthy JJ 42759 4834 7 of of IN 42759 4834 8 a a DT 42759 4834 9 human human JJ 42759 4834 10 being being NN 42759 4834 11 . . . 42759 4835 1 Furthermore furthermore RB 42759 4835 2 , , , 42759 4835 3 man man NN 42759 4835 4 's 's POS 42759 4835 5 personal personal JJ 42759 4835 6 dignity dignity NN 42759 4835 7 demands demand VBZ 42759 4835 8 not not RB 42759 4835 9 merely merely RB 42759 4835 10 the the DT 42759 4835 11 conditions condition NNS 42759 4835 12 of of IN 42759 4835 13 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4835 14 physical physical JJ 42759 4835 15 existence existence NN 42759 4835 16 , , , 42759 4835 17 but but CC 42759 4835 18 the the DT 42759 4835 19 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 4835 20 of of IN 42759 4835 21 pursuing pursue VBG 42759 4835 22 self self NN 42759 4835 23 perfection perfection NN 42759 4835 24 through through IN 42759 4835 25 the the DT 42759 4835 26 harmonious harmonious JJ 42759 4835 27 development development NN 42759 4835 28 of of IN 42759 4835 29 all all PDT 42759 4835 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4835 31 faculties faculty NNS 42759 4835 32 . . . 42759 4836 1 Unlike unlike IN 42759 4836 2 the the DT 42759 4836 3 brutes brute NNS 42759 4836 4 , , , 42759 4836 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4836 6 is be VBZ 42759 4836 7 endowed endow VBN 42759 4836 8 with with IN 42759 4836 9 a a DT 42759 4836 10 rational rational JJ 42759 4836 11 soul soul NN 42759 4836 12 , , , 42759 4836 13 and and CC 42759 4836 14 the the DT 42759 4836 15 capacity capacity NN 42759 4836 16 of of IN 42759 4836 17 indefinite indefinite JJ 42759 4836 18 self self NN 42759 4836 19 improvement improvement NN 42759 4836 20 . . . 42759 4837 1 A a DT 42759 4837 2 due due JJ 42759 4837 3 regard regard NN 42759 4837 4 to to IN 42759 4837 5 these these DT 42759 4837 6 endowments endowment NNS 42759 4837 7 requires require VBZ 42759 4837 8 that that DT 42759 4837 9 man man NN 42759 4837 10 shall shall MD 42759 4837 11 have have VB 42759 4837 12 the the DT 42759 4837 13 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 4837 14 of of IN 42759 4837 15 becoming become VBG 42759 4837 16 not not RB 42759 4837 17 only only RB 42759 4837 18 physically physically RB 42759 4837 19 stronger strong JJR 42759 4837 20 , , , 42759 4837 21 but but CC 42759 4837 22 intellectually intellectually RB 42759 4837 23 wiser wise JJR 42759 4837 24 , , , 42759 4837 25 morally morally RB 42759 4837 26 better well JJR 42759 4837 27 , , , 42759 4837 28 and and CC 42759 4837 29 spiritually spiritually RB 42759 4837 30 nearer nearer IN 42759 4837 31 to to IN 42759 4837 32 God God NNP 42759 4837 33 . . . 42759 4838 1 If if IN 42759 4838 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4838 3 is be VBZ 42759 4838 4 deprived deprive VBN 42759 4838 5 of of IN 42759 4838 6 these these DT 42759 4838 7 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 4838 8 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4838 9 can can MD 42759 4838 10 not not RB 42759 4838 11 realise realise VB 42759 4838 12 the the DT 42759 4838 13 potentialities potentiality NNS 42759 4838 14 of of IN 42759 4838 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4838 16 nature nature NN 42759 4838 17 nor nor CC 42759 4838 18 attain attain VBP 42759 4838 19 the the DT 42759 4838 20 divinely divinely RB 42759 4838 21 appointed appoint VBN 42759 4838 22 end end NN 42759 4838 23 of of IN 42759 4838 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4838 25 nature nature NN 42759 4838 26 . . . 42759 4839 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4839 2 remains remain VBZ 42759 4839 3 on on IN 42759 4839 4 the the DT 42759 4839 5 plane plane NN 42759 4839 6 of of IN 42759 4839 7 the the DT 42759 4839 8 lower low JJR 42759 4839 9 animals animal NNS 42759 4839 10 . . . 42759 4840 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4840 2 personality personality NN 42759 4840 3 is be VBZ 42759 4840 4 violated violate VBN 42759 4840 5 quite quite RB 42759 4840 6 as as RB 42759 4840 7 fundamentally fundamentally RB 42759 4840 8 as as IN 42759 4840 9 when when WRB 42759 4840 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4840 11 body body NN 42759 4840 12 is be VBZ 42759 4840 13 injured injure VBN 42759 4840 14 or or CC 42759 4840 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4840 16 life life NN 42759 4840 17 destroyed destroy VBD 42759 4840 18 . . . 42759 4841 1 While while IN 42759 4841 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4841 3 is be VBZ 42759 4841 4 impossible impossible JJ 42759 4841 5 to to TO 42759 4841 6 define define VB 42759 4841 7 with with IN 42759 4841 8 mathematical mathematical JJ 42759 4841 9 precision precision NN 42759 4841 10 the the DT 42759 4841 11 degree degree NN 42759 4841 12 of of IN 42759 4841 13 personal personal JJ 42759 4841 14 development development NN 42759 4841 15 that that WDT 42759 4841 16 is be VBZ 42759 4841 17 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4841 18 to to TO 42759 4841 19 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 4841 20 the the DT 42759 4841 21 claims claim NNS 42759 4841 22 of of IN 42759 4841 23 personal personal JJ 42759 4841 24 dignity dignity NN 42759 4841 25 , , , 42759 4841 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4841 27 is be VBZ 42759 4841 28 entirely entirely RB 42759 4841 29 practicable practicable JJ 42759 4841 30 to to IN 42759 4841 31 state state NN 42759 4841 32 with with IN 42759 4841 33 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4841 34 definiteness definiteness NN 42759 4841 35 the the DT 42759 4841 36 minimum minimum JJ 42759 4841 37 conditions condition NNS 42759 4841 38 of of IN 42759 4841 39 such such JJ 42759 4841 40 development development NN 42759 4841 41 . . . 42759 4842 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4842 2 are be VBP 42759 4842 3 that that DT 42759 4842 4 quantity quantity NN 42759 4842 5 of of IN 42759 4842 6 goods good NNS 42759 4842 7 and and CC 42759 4842 8 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 4842 9 which which WDT 42759 4842 10 fair fair JJ 42759 4842 11 - - HYPH 42759 4842 12 minded minded JJ 42759 4842 13 men man NNS 42759 4842 14 would would MD 42759 4842 15 regard regard VB 42759 4842 16 as as IN 42759 4842 17 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 4842 18 to to IN 42759 4842 19 humane humane JJ 42759 4842 20 , , , 42759 4842 21 efficient efficient JJ 42759 4842 22 , , , 42759 4842 23 and and CC 42759 4842 24 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4842 25 life life NN 42759 4842 26 . . . 42759 4843 1 The the DT 42759 4843 2 summary summary NN 42759 4843 3 description description NN 42759 4843 4 of of IN 42759 4843 5 a a DT 42759 4843 6 decent decent JJ 42759 4843 7 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4843 8 at at IN 42759 4843 9 the the DT 42759 4843 10 end end NN 42759 4843 11 of of IN 42759 4843 12 the the DT 42759 4843 13 second second JJ 42759 4843 14 last last JJ 42759 4843 15 paragraph paragraph NN 42759 4843 16 , , , 42759 4843 17 would would MD 42759 4843 18 probably probably RB 42759 4843 19 be be VB 42759 4843 20 accepted accept VBN 42759 4843 21 by by IN 42759 4843 22 all all DT 42759 4843 23 men man NNS 42759 4843 24 who who WP 42759 4843 25 really really RB 42759 4843 26 believe believe VBP 42759 4843 27 in in IN 42759 4843 28 the the DT 42759 4843 29 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 4843 30 worth worth NN 42759 4843 31 of of IN 42759 4843 32 personality personality NN 42759 4843 33 . . . 42759 4844 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4844 2 The the DT 42759 4844 3 Claim Claim NNP 42759 4844 4 to to IN 42759 4844 5 a a DT 42759 4844 6 Decent Decent NNP 42759 4844 7 Livelihood Livelihood NNP 42759 4844 8 from from IN 42759 4844 9 a a DT 42759 4844 10 Present Present NNP 42759 4844 11 Occupation Occupation NNP 42759 4844 12 _ _ NNP 42759 4844 13 The the DT 42759 4844 14 claim claim NN 42759 4844 15 of of IN 42759 4844 16 a a DT 42759 4844 17 worker worker NN 42759 4844 18 to to IN 42759 4844 19 a a DT 42759 4844 20 decent decent JJ 42759 4844 21 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4844 22 from from IN 42759 4844 23 the the DT 42759 4844 24 goods good NNS 42759 4844 25 of of IN 42759 4844 26 the the DT 42759 4844 27 earth earth NN 42759 4844 28 does do VBZ 42759 4844 29 not not RB 42759 4844 30 always always RB 42759 4844 31 imply imply VB 42759 4844 32 a a DT 42759 4844 33 strict strict JJ 42759 4844 34 right right NN 42759 4844 35 to to IN 42759 4844 36 a a DT 42759 4844 37 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4844 38 from from IN 42759 4844 39 one one PRP 42759 4844 40 's 's POS 42759 4844 41 present present JJ 42759 4844 42 occupation occupation NN 42759 4844 43 . . . 42759 4845 1 To to TO 42759 4845 2 demand demand VB 42759 4845 3 this this DT 42759 4845 4 would would MD 42759 4845 5 in in IN 42759 4845 6 some some DT 42759 4845 7 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 4845 8 be be VB 42759 4845 9 to to TO 42759 4845 10 demand demand VB 42759 4845 11 a a DT 42759 4845 12 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4845 13 not not RB 42759 4845 14 on on IN 42759 4845 15 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4845 16 but but CC 42759 4845 17 on on IN 42759 4845 18 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 4845 19 terms term NNS 42759 4845 20 ; ; : 42759 4845 21 for for IN 42759 4845 22 the the DT 42759 4845 23 persons person NNS 42759 4845 24 in in IN 42759 4845 25 control control NN 42759 4845 26 of of IN 42759 4845 27 the the DT 42759 4845 28 sources source NNS 42759 4845 29 could could MD 42759 4845 30 not not RB 42759 4845 31 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 4845 32 be be VB 42759 4845 33 required require VBN 42759 4845 34 to to TO 42759 4845 35 provide provide VB 42759 4845 36 a a DT 42759 4845 37 decent decent JJ 42759 4845 38 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4845 39 . . . 42759 4846 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4846 2 failure failure NN 42759 4846 3 to to TO 42759 4846 4 do do VB 42759 4846 5 so so RB 42759 4846 6 would would MD 42759 4846 7 not not RB 42759 4846 8 constitute constitute VB 42759 4846 9 an an DT 42759 4846 10 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 4846 11 hindrance hindrance NN 42759 4846 12 to to IN 42759 4846 13 the the DT 42759 4846 14 worker worker NN 42759 4846 15 's 's POS 42759 4846 16 access access NN 42759 4846 17 to to IN 42759 4846 18 the the DT 42759 4846 19 earth earth NN 42759 4846 20 in in IN 42759 4846 21 such such JJ 42759 4846 22 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 4846 23 . . . 42759 4847 1 In in IN 42759 4847 2 chapter chapter NN 42759 4847 3 xvi xvi NNP 42759 4847 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4847 5 saw see VBD 42759 4847 6 that that IN 42759 4847 7 not not RB 42759 4847 8 all all DT 42759 4847 9 business business NN 42759 4847 10 men man NNS 42759 4847 11 have have VBP 42759 4847 12 a a DT 42759 4847 13 strict strict JJ 42759 4847 14 right right NN 42759 4847 15 to to IN 42759 4847 16 that that DT 42759 4847 17 minimum minimum NN 42759 4847 18 of of IN 42759 4847 19 profits profit NNS 42759 4847 20 which which WDT 42759 4847 21 is be VBZ 42759 4847 22 required require VBN 42759 4847 23 to to TO 42759 4847 24 yield yield VB 42759 4847 25 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4847 26 a a DT 42759 4847 27 decent decent JJ 42759 4847 28 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4847 29 : : : 42759 4847 30 first first RB 42759 4847 31 , , , 42759 4847 32 because because IN 42759 4847 33 the the DT 42759 4847 34 direction direction NN 42759 4847 35 of of IN 42759 4847 36 industry industry NN 42759 4847 37 is be VBZ 42759 4847 38 not not RB 42759 4847 39 generally generally RB 42759 4847 40 the the DT 42759 4847 41 business business NN 42759 4847 42 man man NN 42759 4847 43 's 's POS 42759 4847 44 only only JJ 42759 4847 45 means mean NNS 42759 4847 46 of of IN 42759 4847 47 getting get VBG 42759 4847 48 a a DT 42759 4847 49 living living NN 42759 4847 50 ; ; : 42759 4847 51 second second LS 42759 4847 52 , , , 42759 4847 53 because because IN 42759 4847 54 the the DT 42759 4847 55 community community NN 42759 4847 56 , , , 42759 4847 57 the the DT 42759 4847 58 consumers consumer NNS 42759 4847 59 , , , 42759 4847 60 do do VB 42759 4847 61 not not RB 42759 4847 62 regard regard VB 42759 4847 63 the the DT 42759 4847 64 presence presence NN 42759 4847 65 and and CC 42759 4847 66 activity activity NN 42759 4847 67 of of IN 42759 4847 68 all all DT 42759 4847 69 existing exist VBG 42759 4847 70 business business NN 42759 4847 71 men man NNS 42759 4847 72 as as IN 42759 4847 73 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 4847 74 . . . 42759 4848 1 Of of RB 42759 4848 2 course course RB 42759 4848 3 , , , 42759 4848 4 the the DT 42759 4848 5 community community NN 42759 4848 6 is be VBZ 42759 4848 7 morally morally RB 42759 4848 8 bound bind VBN 42759 4848 9 to to TO 42759 4848 10 pay pay VB 42759 4848 11 such such JJ 42759 4848 12 prices price NNS 42759 4848 13 for for IN 42759 4848 14 goods good NNS 42759 4848 15 as as IN 42759 4848 16 will will MD 42759 4848 17 enable enable VB 42759 4848 18 all all PDT 42759 4848 19 the the DT 42759 4848 20 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4848 21 business business NN 42759 4848 22 men man NNS 42759 4848 23 , , , 42759 4848 24 whether whether IN 42759 4848 25 manufacturers manufacturer NNS 42759 4848 26 or or CC 42759 4848 27 traders trader NNS 42759 4848 28 , , , 42759 4848 29 to to TO 42759 4848 30 obtain obtain VB 42759 4848 31 a a DT 42759 4848 32 decent decent JJ 42759 4848 33 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4848 34 in in IN 42759 4848 35 return return NN 42759 4848 36 for for IN 42759 4848 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4848 38 directive directive JJ 42759 4848 39 functions function NNS 42759 4848 40 ; ; : 42759 4848 41 but but CC 42759 4848 42 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4848 43 is be VBZ 42759 4848 44 not not RB 42759 4848 45 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4848 46 to to TO 42759 4848 47 provide provide VB 42759 4848 48 a a DT 42759 4848 49 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4848 50 for for IN 42759 4848 51 those those DT 42759 4848 52 business business NN 42759 4848 53 men man NNS 42759 4848 54 whose whose WP$ 42759 4848 55 presence presence NN 42759 4848 56 is be VBZ 42759 4848 57 not not RB 42759 4848 58 required require VBN 42759 4848 59 , , , 42759 4848 60 who who WP 42759 4848 61 could could MD 42759 4848 62 vanish vanish VB 42759 4848 63 from from IN 42759 4848 64 the the DT 42759 4848 65 field field NN 42759 4848 66 of of IN 42759 4848 67 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4848 68 direction direction NN 42759 4848 69 without without IN 42759 4848 70 affecting affect VBG 42759 4848 71 either either CC 42759 4848 72 the the DT 42759 4848 73 supply supply NN 42759 4848 74 or or CC 42759 4848 75 the the DT 42759 4848 76 price price NN 42759 4848 77 of of IN 42759 4848 78 goods good NNS 42759 4848 79 , , , 42759 4848 80 and and CC 42759 4848 81 whose whose WP$ 42759 4848 82 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 4848 83 character character NN 42759 4848 84 is be VBZ 42759 4848 85 proved prove VBN 42759 4848 86 by by IN 42759 4848 87 the the DT 42759 4848 88 fact fact NN 42759 4848 89 that that IN 42759 4848 90 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4848 91 can can MD 42759 4848 92 not not RB 42759 4848 93 make make VB 42759 4848 94 a a DT 42759 4848 95 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4848 96 at at IN 42759 4848 97 the the DT 42759 4848 98 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 4848 99 prices price NNS 42759 4848 100 . . . 42759 4849 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 4849 2 are be VBP 42759 4849 3 in in IN 42759 4849 4 the the DT 42759 4849 5 position position NN 42759 4849 6 of of IN 42759 4849 7 persons person NNS 42759 4849 8 whom whom WP 42759 4849 9 the the DT 42759 4849 10 community community NN 42759 4849 11 does do VBZ 42759 4849 12 not not RB 42759 4849 13 desire desire VB 42759 4849 14 to to TO 42759 4849 15 employ employ VB 42759 4849 16 as as IN 42759 4849 17 business business NN 42759 4849 18 men man NNS 42759 4849 19 . . . 42759 4850 1 In in IN 42759 4850 2 refusing refuse VBG 42759 4850 3 to to TO 42759 4850 4 pay pay VB 42759 4850 5 prices price NNS 42759 4850 6 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 4850 7 high high JJ 42759 4850 8 to to TO 42759 4850 9 provide provide VB 42759 4850 10 these these DT 42759 4850 11 inefficient inefficient JJ 42759 4850 12 business business NN 42759 4850 13 men man NNS 42759 4850 14 with with IN 42759 4850 15 a a DT 42759 4850 16 decent decent JJ 42759 4850 17 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4850 18 , , , 42759 4850 19 the the DT 42759 4850 20 community community NN 42759 4850 21 is be VBZ 42759 4850 22 not not RB 42759 4850 23 unreasonably unreasonably RB 42759 4850 24 hindering hinder VBG 42759 4850 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4850 26 access access NN 42759 4850 27 to to IN 42759 4850 28 the the DT 42759 4850 29 common common JJ 42759 4850 30 goods good NNS 42759 4850 31 of of IN 42759 4850 32 the the DT 42759 4850 33 earth earth NN 42759 4850 34 . . . 42759 4851 1 Such such JJ 42759 4851 2 men man NNS 42759 4851 3 are be VBP 42759 4851 4 really really RB 42759 4851 5 demanding demand VBG 42759 4851 6 a a DT 42759 4851 7 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4851 8 on on IN 42759 4851 9 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 4851 10 terms term NNS 42759 4851 11 . . . 42759 4852 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4852 2 The the DT 42759 4852 3 Labourer Labourer NNP 42759 4852 4 's 's POS 42759 4852 5 Right right NN 42759 4852 6 to to IN 42759 4852 7 a a DT 42759 4852 8 Living live VBG 42759 4852 9 Wage Wage NNP 42759 4852 10 _ _ NNP 42759 4852 11 On on IN 42759 4852 12 the the DT 42759 4852 13 other other JJ 42759 4852 14 hand hand NN 42759 4852 15 , , , 42759 4852 16 the the DT 42759 4852 17 wage wage NN 42759 4852 18 earner earner NN 42759 4852 19 's 's POS 42759 4852 20 claim claim NN 42759 4852 21 to to IN 42759 4852 22 a a DT 42759 4852 23 decent decent JJ 42759 4852 24 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4852 25 is be VBZ 42759 4852 26 valid valid JJ 42759 4852 27 , , , 42759 4852 28 generally generally RB 42759 4852 29 speaking speak VBG 42759 4852 30 , , , 42759 4852 31 in in IN 42759 4852 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4852 33 present present JJ 42759 4852 34 occupation occupation NN 42759 4852 35 . . . 42759 4853 1 In in IN 42759 4853 2 other other JJ 42759 4853 3 words word NNS 42759 4853 4 , , , 42759 4853 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4853 6 right right NN 42759 4853 7 to to IN 42759 4853 8 a a DT 42759 4853 9 decent decent JJ 42759 4853 10 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4853 11 in in IN 42759 4853 12 the the DT 42759 4853 13 abstract abstract JJ 42759 4853 14 means mean NNS 42759 4853 15 in in IN 42759 4853 16 the the DT 42759 4853 17 concrete concrete NN 42759 4853 18 a a DT 42759 4853 19 right right NN 42759 4853 20 to to IN 42759 4853 21 a a DT 42759 4853 22 living living NN 42759 4853 23 wage wage NN 42759 4853 24 . . . 42759 4854 1 To to TO 42759 4854 2 present present VB 42759 4854 3 the the DT 42759 4854 4 matter matter NN 42759 4854 5 in in IN 42759 4854 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4854 7 simplest simple JJS 42759 4854 8 terms term NNS 42759 4854 9 , , , 42759 4854 10 let let VB 42759 4854 11 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4854 12 consider consider VB 42759 4854 13 first first RB 42759 4854 14 the the DT 42759 4854 15 adult adult NN 42759 4854 16 male male JJ 42759 4854 17 labourer labourer NN 42759 4854 18 of of IN 42759 4854 19 average average JJ 42759 4854 20 physical physical JJ 42759 4854 21 and and CC 42759 4854 22 mental mental JJ 42759 4854 23 ability ability NN 42759 4854 24 who who WP 42759 4854 25 is be VBZ 42759 4854 26 charged charge VBN 42759 4854 27 with with IN 42759 4854 28 the the DT 42759 4854 29 support support NN 42759 4854 30 of of IN 42759 4854 31 no no DT 42759 4854 32 one one NN 42759 4854 33 but but IN 42759 4854 34 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4854 35 , , , 42759 4854 36 and and CC 42759 4854 37 let let VB 42759 4854 38 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4854 39 assume assume VB 42759 4854 40 that that IN 42759 4854 41 the the DT 42759 4854 42 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4854 43 resources resource NNS 42759 4854 44 are be VBP 42759 4854 45 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4854 46 to to IN 42759 4854 47 such such PDT 42759 4854 48 a a DT 42759 4854 49 wage wage NN 42759 4854 50 for for IN 42759 4854 51 all all PDT 42759 4854 52 the the DT 42759 4854 53 members member NNS 42759 4854 54 of of IN 42759 4854 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4854 56 class class NN 42759 4854 57 . . . 42759 4855 1 Those those DT 42759 4855 2 who who WP 42759 4855 3 are be VBP 42759 4855 4 in in IN 42759 4855 5 control control NN 42759 4855 6 of of IN 42759 4855 7 the the DT 42759 4855 8 resources resource NNS 42759 4855 9 of of IN 42759 4855 10 the the DT 42759 4855 11 community community NN 42759 4855 12 are be VBP 42759 4855 13 morally morally RB 42759 4855 14 bound bind VBN 42759 4855 15 to to TO 42759 4855 16 give give VB 42759 4855 17 such such PDT 42759 4855 18 a a DT 42759 4855 19 labourer labourer NN 42759 4855 20 a a DT 42759 4855 21 living living NN 42759 4855 22 wage wage NN 42759 4855 23 . . . 42759 4856 1 If if IN 42759 4856 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4856 3 fail fail VBP 42759 4856 4 to to TO 42759 4856 5 do do VB 42759 4856 6 so so RB 42759 4856 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4856 8 are be VBP 42759 4856 9 unreasonably unreasonably RB 42759 4856 10 hindering hinder VBG 42759 4856 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4856 12 access access NN 42759 4856 13 to to IN 42759 4856 14 a a DT 42759 4856 15 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4856 16 on on IN 42759 4856 17 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4856 18 terms term NNS 42759 4856 19 ; ; : 42759 4856 20 and and CC 42759 4856 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4856 22 right right NN 42759 4856 23 to to IN 42759 4856 24 a a DT 42759 4856 25 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4856 26 on on IN 42759 4856 27 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4856 28 terms term NNS 42759 4856 29 is be VBZ 42759 4856 30 violated violate VBN 42759 4856 31 . . . 42759 4857 1 The the DT 42759 4857 2 central central JJ 42759 4857 3 consideration consideration NN 42759 4857 4 here here RB 42759 4857 5 is be VBZ 42759 4857 6 evidently evidently RB 42759 4857 7 the the DT 42759 4857 8 _ _ NNP 42759 4857 9 reasonableness reasonableness NN 42759 4857 10 _ _ NNP 42759 4857 11 of of IN 42759 4857 12 the the DT 42759 4857 13 process process NN 42759 4857 14 . . . 42759 4858 1 Unlike unlike IN 42759 4858 2 the the DT 42759 4858 3 business business NN 42759 4858 4 man man NN 42759 4858 5 , , , 42759 4858 6 the the DT 42759 4858 7 rent rent NN 42759 4858 8 receiver receiver NN 42759 4858 9 , , , 42759 4858 10 and and CC 42759 4858 11 the the DT 42759 4858 12 interest interest NN 42759 4858 13 receiver receiver NN 42759 4858 14 , , , 42759 4858 15 the the DT 42759 4858 16 labourer labourer NN 42759 4858 17 has have VBZ 42759 4858 18 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 4858 19 no no DT 42759 4858 20 other other JJ 42759 4858 21 means mean NNS 42759 4858 22 of of IN 42759 4858 23 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4858 24 than than IN 42759 4858 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4858 26 wages wage NNS 42759 4858 27 . . . 42759 4859 1 If if IN 42759 4859 2 these these DT 42759 4859 3 do do VBP 42759 4859 4 not not RB 42759 4859 5 furnish furnish VB 42759 4859 6 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4859 7 with with IN 42759 4859 8 a a DT 42759 4859 9 decent decent JJ 42759 4859 10 subsistence subsistence NN 42759 4859 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4859 12 is be VBZ 42759 4859 13 deprived deprive VBN 42759 4859 14 of of IN 42759 4859 15 a a DT 42759 4859 16 decent decent JJ 42759 4859 17 subsistence subsistence NN 42759 4859 18 . . . 42759 4860 1 When when WRB 42759 4860 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4860 3 has have VBZ 42759 4860 4 performed perform VBN 42759 4860 5 an an DT 42759 4860 6 average average JJ 42759 4860 7 day day NN 42759 4860 8 's 's POS 42759 4860 9 work work NN 42759 4860 10 , , , 42759 4860 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4860 12 has have VBZ 42759 4860 13 done do VBN 42759 4860 14 all all DT 42759 4860 15 that that WDT 42759 4860 16 is be VBZ 42759 4860 17 within within IN 42759 4860 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4860 19 power power NN 42759 4860 20 to to TO 42759 4860 21 make make VB 42759 4860 22 good good JJ 42759 4860 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4860 24 claim claim NN 42759 4860 25 to to IN 42759 4860 26 a a DT 42759 4860 27 decent decent JJ 42759 4860 28 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4860 29 . . . 42759 4861 1 On on IN 42759 4861 2 the the DT 42759 4861 3 other other JJ 42759 4861 4 hand hand NN 42759 4861 5 , , , 42759 4861 6 the the DT 42759 4861 7 community community NN 42759 4861 8 is be VBZ 42759 4861 9 the the DT 42759 4861 10 beneficiary beneficiary NN 42759 4861 11 of of IN 42759 4861 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4861 13 labour labour NN 42759 4861 14 , , , 42759 4861 15 and and CC 42759 4861 16 desires desire VBZ 42759 4861 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4861 18 services service NNS 42759 4861 19 . . . 42759 4862 1 If if IN 42759 4862 2 , , , 42759 4862 3 indeed indeed RB 42759 4862 4 , , , 42759 4862 5 the the DT 42759 4862 6 community community NN 42759 4862 7 would would MD 42759 4862 8 rather rather RB 42759 4862 9 do do VB 42759 4862 10 without without IN 42759 4862 11 the the DT 42759 4862 12 services service NNS 42759 4862 13 of of IN 42759 4862 14 an an DT 42759 4862 15 individual individual JJ 42759 4862 16 labourer labourer NN 42759 4862 17 than than IN 42759 4862 18 pay pay VB 42759 4862 19 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4862 20 a a DT 42759 4862 21 living living NN 42759 4862 22 wage wage NN 42759 4862 23 , , , 42759 4862 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4862 25 is be VBZ 42759 4862 26 morally morally RB 42759 4862 27 free free JJ 42759 4862 28 to to TO 42759 4862 29 choose choose VB 42759 4862 30 the the DT 42759 4862 31 former former JJ 42759 4862 32 alternative alternative NN 42759 4862 33 , , , 42759 4862 34 precisely precisely RB 42759 4862 35 as as IN 42759 4862 36 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4862 37 is be VBZ 42759 4862 38 justified justify VBN 42759 4862 39 in in IN 42759 4862 40 refusing refuse VBG 42759 4862 41 to to TO 42759 4862 42 pay pay VB 42759 4862 43 a a DT 42759 4862 44 price price NN 42759 4862 45 for for IN 42759 4862 46 groceries grocery NNS 42759 4862 47 that that WDT 42759 4862 48 will will MD 42759 4862 49 enable enable VB 42759 4862 50 an an DT 42759 4862 51 inefficient inefficient JJ 42759 4862 52 grocer grocer NN 42759 4862 53 to to TO 42759 4862 54 obtain obtain VB 42759 4862 55 living living NN 42759 4862 56 profits profit NNS 42759 4862 57 . . . 42759 4863 1 Whatever whatever WDT 42759 4863 2 concrete concrete JJ 42759 4863 3 form form NN 42759 4863 4 the the DT 42759 4863 5 right right NN 42759 4863 6 of of IN 42759 4863 7 such such JJ 42759 4863 8 persons person NNS 42759 4863 9 to to IN 42759 4863 10 a a DT 42759 4863 11 decent decent JJ 42759 4863 12 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4863 13 may may MD 42759 4863 14 take take VB 42759 4863 15 , , , 42759 4863 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4863 17 is be VBZ 42759 4863 18 not not RB 42759 4863 19 the the DT 42759 4863 20 right right NN 42759 4863 21 to to IN 42759 4863 22 living live VBG 42759 4863 23 wages wage NNS 42759 4863 24 or or CC 42759 4863 25 living living NN 42759 4863 26 profits profit NNS 42759 4863 27 from from IN 42759 4863 28 the the DT 42759 4863 29 occupations occupation NNS 42759 4863 30 in in IN 42759 4863 31 question question NN 42759 4863 32 . . . 42759 4864 1 Here here RB 42759 4864 2 , , , 42759 4864 3 however however RB 42759 4864 4 , , , 42759 4864 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4864 6 are be VBP 42759 4864 7 discussing discuss VBG 42759 4864 8 the the DT 42759 4864 9 labourer labourer NN 42759 4864 10 to to IN 42759 4864 11 whom whom WP 42759 4864 12 the the DT 42759 4864 13 community community NN 42759 4864 14 would would MD 42759 4864 15 rather rather RB 42759 4864 16 pay pay VB 42759 4864 17 a a DT 42759 4864 18 living living NN 42759 4864 19 wage wage NN 42759 4864 20 than than IN 42759 4864 21 not not RB 42759 4864 22 employ employ VB 42759 4864 23 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4864 24 at at RB 42759 4864 25 all all RB 42759 4864 26 . . . 42759 4865 1 To to TO 42759 4865 2 refuse refuse VB 42759 4865 3 such such PDT 42759 4865 4 a a DT 42759 4865 5 one one NN 42759 4865 6 a a DT 42759 4865 7 living living NN 42759 4865 8 wage wage NN 42759 4865 9 merely merely RB 42759 4865 10 because because IN 42759 4865 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4865 12 can can MD 42759 4865 13 be be VB 42759 4865 14 constrained constrain VBN 42759 4865 15 by by IN 42759 4865 16 economic economic JJ 42759 4865 17 pressure pressure NN 42759 4865 18 to to TO 42759 4865 19 work work VB 42759 4865 20 for for IN 42759 4865 21 less less JJR 42759 4865 22 , , , 42759 4865 23 is be VBZ 42759 4865 24 to to TO 42759 4865 25 treat treat VB 42759 4865 26 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4865 27 unreasonably unreasonably RB 42759 4865 28 , , , 42759 4865 29 is be VBZ 42759 4865 30 to to TO 42759 4865 31 deprive deprive VB 42759 4865 32 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4865 33 of of IN 42759 4865 34 access access NN 42759 4865 35 to to IN 42759 4865 36 a a DT 42759 4865 37 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4865 38 on on IN 42759 4865 39 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4865 40 terms term NNS 42759 4865 41 . . . 42759 4866 1 Such such JJ 42759 4866 2 treatment treatment NN 42759 4866 3 regards regard VBZ 42759 4866 4 the the DT 42759 4866 5 labourer labourer NN 42759 4866 6 as as RB 42759 4866 7 inferior inferior JJ 42759 4866 8 to to IN 42759 4866 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4866 10 fellows fellow NNS 42759 4866 11 in in IN 42759 4866 12 personal personal JJ 42759 4866 13 worth worth NN 42759 4866 14 , , , 42759 4866 15 as as IN 42759 4866 16 a a DT 42759 4866 17 mere mere JJ 42759 4866 18 instrument instrument NN 42759 4866 19 to to IN 42759 4866 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4866 21 convenience convenience NN 42759 4866 22 . . . 42759 4867 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4867 2 is be VBZ 42759 4867 3 an an DT 42759 4867 4 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 4867 5 distribution distribution NN 42759 4867 6 of of IN 42759 4867 7 the the DT 42759 4867 8 goods good NNS 42759 4867 9 and and CC 42759 4867 10 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 4867 11 of of IN 42759 4867 12 the the DT 42759 4867 13 earth earth NN 42759 4867 14 . . . 42759 4868 1 Obviously obviously RB 42759 4868 2 there there EX 42759 4868 3 is be VBZ 42759 4868 4 no no DT 42759 4868 5 formula formula NN 42759 4868 6 by by IN 42759 4868 7 which which WDT 42759 4868 8 such such JJ 42759 4868 9 conduct conduct NN 42759 4868 10 can can MD 42759 4868 11 be be VB 42759 4868 12 mathematically mathematically RB 42759 4868 13 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 42759 4868 14 as as IN 42759 4868 15 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 4868 16 ; ; : 42759 4868 17 but but CC 42759 4868 18 the the DT 42759 4868 19 proposition proposition NN 42759 4868 20 is be VBZ 42759 4868 21 as as RB 42759 4868 22 certain certain JJ 42759 4868 23 morally morally RB 42759 4868 24 as as IN 42759 4868 25 any any DT 42759 4868 26 other other JJ 42759 4868 27 proposition proposition NN 42759 4868 28 that that WDT 42759 4868 29 is be VBZ 42759 4868 30 susceptible susceptible JJ 42759 4868 31 of of IN 42759 4868 32 rational rational JJ 42759 4868 33 defence defence NN 42759 4868 34 in in IN 42759 4868 35 the the DT 42759 4868 36 field field NN 42759 4868 37 of of IN 42759 4868 38 distribution distribution NN 42759 4868 39 . . . 42759 4869 1 No no DT 42759 4869 2 man man NN 42759 4869 3 who who WP 42759 4869 4 accepts accept VBZ 42759 4869 5 the the DT 42759 4869 6 three three CD 42759 4869 7 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4869 8 principles principle NNS 42759 4869 9 stated state VBD 42759 4869 10 some some DT 42759 4869 11 pages page NNS 42759 4869 12 back back RP 42759 4869 13 , , , 42759 4869 14 can can MD 42759 4869 15 deny deny VB 42759 4869 16 the the DT 42759 4869 17 right right NN 42759 4869 18 of of IN 42759 4869 19 the the DT 42759 4869 20 labourer labourer NN 42759 4869 21 to to IN 42759 4869 22 a a DT 42759 4869 23 living living NN 42759 4869 24 wage wage NN 42759 4869 25 . . . 42759 4870 1 The the DT 42759 4870 2 man man NN 42759 4870 3 who who WP 42759 4870 4 does do VBZ 42759 4870 5 not not RB 42759 4870 6 accept accept VB 42759 4870 7 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4870 8 must must MD 42759 4870 9 hold hold VB 42759 4870 10 that that IN 42759 4870 11 all all DT 42759 4870 12 property property NN 42759 4870 13 rights right NNS 42759 4870 14 are be VBP 42759 4870 15 the the DT 42759 4870 16 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 42759 4870 17 creation creation NN 42759 4870 18 of of IN 42759 4870 19 the the DT 42759 4870 20 State State NNP 42759 4870 21 , , , 42759 4870 22 or or CC 42759 4870 23 that that IN 42759 4870 24 there there EX 42759 4870 25 is be VBZ 42759 4870 26 no no DT 42759 4870 27 such such JJ 42759 4870 28 thing thing NN 42759 4870 29 as as IN 42759 4870 30 a a DT 42759 4870 31 moral moral JJ 42759 4870 32 right right NN 42759 4870 33 to to IN 42759 4870 34 material material JJ 42759 4870 35 goods good NNS 42759 4870 36 . . . 42759 4871 1 In in IN 42759 4871 2 either either DT 42759 4871 3 supposition supposition NN 42759 4871 4 the the DT 42759 4871 5 distribution distribution NN 42759 4871 6 and and CC 42759 4871 7 possession possession NN 42759 4871 8 of of IN 42759 4871 9 the the DT 42759 4871 10 earth earth NN 42759 4871 11 's 's POS 42759 4871 12 bounty bounty NN 42759 4871 13 are be VBP 42759 4871 14 subject subject JJ 42759 4871 15 entirely entirely RB 42759 4871 16 to to IN 42759 4871 17 the the DT 42759 4871 18 arbitrament arbitrament NN 42759 4871 19 of of IN 42759 4871 20 might might NN 42759 4871 21 . . . 42759 4872 1 There there EX 42759 4872 2 is be VBZ 42759 4872 3 nothing nothing NN 42759 4872 4 to to TO 42759 4872 5 be be VB 42759 4872 6 gained gain VBN 42759 4872 7 by by IN 42759 4872 8 a a DT 42759 4872 9 formal formal JJ 42759 4872 10 criticism criticism NN 42759 4872 11 of of IN 42759 4872 12 this this DT 42759 4872 13 assumption assumption NN 42759 4872 14 . . . 42759 4873 1 What what WDT 42759 4873 2 persons person NNS 42759 4873 3 , , , 42759 4873 4 or or CC 42759 4873 5 group group NN 42759 4873 6 , , , 42759 4873 7 or or CC 42759 4873 8 authority authority NN 42759 4873 9 is be VBZ 42759 4873 10 charged charge VBN 42759 4873 11 with with IN 42759 4873 12 the the DT 42759 4873 13 obligation obligation NN 42759 4873 14 which which WDT 42759 4873 15 corresponds correspond VBZ 42759 4873 16 to to IN 42759 4873 17 the the DT 42759 4873 18 right right NN 42759 4873 19 to to IN 42759 4873 20 a a DT 42759 4873 21 living living NN 42759 4873 22 wage wage NN 42759 4873 23 ? ? . 42759 4874 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 4874 2 have have VBP 42759 4874 3 referred refer VBN 42759 4874 4 to to IN 42759 4874 5 " " `` 42759 4874 6 the the DT 42759 4874 7 community community NN 42759 4874 8 " " '' 42759 4874 9 in in IN 42759 4874 10 this this DT 42759 4874 11 connection connection NN 42759 4874 12 , , , 42759 4874 13 but but CC 42759 4874 14 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4874 15 do do VBP 42759 4874 16 not not RB 42759 4874 17 mean mean VB 42759 4874 18 the the DT 42759 4874 19 community community NN 42759 4874 20 in in IN 42759 4874 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4874 22 corporate corporate JJ 42759 4874 23 capacity capacity NN 42759 4874 24 , , , 42759 4874 25 i.e. i.e. FW 42759 4874 26 , , , 42759 4874 27 the the DT 42759 4874 28 State State NNP 42759 4874 29 . . . 42759 4875 1 As as IN 42759 4875 2 regards regard VBZ 42759 4875 3 private private JJ 42759 4875 4 employments employment NNS 42759 4875 5 , , , 42759 4875 6 the the DT 42759 4875 7 State State NNP 42759 4875 8 is be VBZ 42759 4875 9 not not RB 42759 4875 10 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4875 11 to to TO 42759 4875 12 pay pay VB 42759 4875 13 a a DT 42759 4875 14 living living NN 42759 4875 15 wage wage NN 42759 4875 16 , , , 42759 4875 17 nor nor CC 42759 4875 18 any any DT 42759 4875 19 other other JJ 42759 4875 20 kind kind NN 42759 4875 21 of of IN 42759 4875 22 wage wage NN 42759 4875 23 , , , 42759 4875 24 since since IN 42759 4875 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4875 26 has have VBZ 42759 4875 27 not not RB 42759 4875 28 assumed assume VBN 42759 4875 29 the the DT 42759 4875 30 wage wage NN 42759 4875 31 - - HYPH 42759 4875 32 paying pay VBG 42759 4875 33 function function NN 42759 4875 34 with with IN 42759 4875 35 respect respect NN 42759 4875 36 to to IN 42759 4875 37 these these DT 42759 4875 38 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4875 39 . . . 42759 4876 1 As as IN 42759 4876 2 protector protector NN 42759 4876 3 of of IN 42759 4876 4 natural natural JJ 42759 4876 5 rights right NNS 42759 4876 6 , , , 42759 4876 7 and and CC 42759 4876 8 as as IN 42759 4876 9 the the DT 42759 4876 10 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4876 11 determiner determiner NN 42759 4876 12 of of IN 42759 4876 13 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4876 14 institutions institution NNS 42759 4876 15 , , , 42759 4876 16 the the DT 42759 4876 17 State State NNP 42759 4876 18 is be VBZ 42759 4876 19 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4876 20 to to TO 42759 4876 21 enact enact VB 42759 4876 22 laws law NNS 42759 4876 23 which which WDT 42759 4876 24 will will MD 42759 4876 25 enable enable VB 42759 4876 26 the the DT 42759 4876 27 labourer labourer NN 42759 4876 28 to to TO 42759 4876 29 obtain obtain VB 42759 4876 30 a a DT 42759 4876 31 living living NN 42759 4876 32 wage wage NN 42759 4876 33 ; ; : 42759 4876 34 but but CC 42759 4876 35 the the DT 42759 4876 36 duty duty NN 42759 4876 37 of of IN 42759 4876 38 actually actually RB 42759 4876 39 providing provide VBG 42759 4876 40 this this DT 42759 4876 41 measure measure NN 42759 4876 42 of of IN 42759 4876 43 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 4876 44 rests rest VBZ 42759 4876 45 upon upon IN 42759 4876 46 that that DT 42759 4876 47 class class NN 42759 4876 48 which which WDT 42759 4876 49 has have VBZ 42759 4876 50 assumed assume VBN 42759 4876 51 the the DT 42759 4876 52 wage wage NN 42759 4876 53 - - HYPH 42759 4876 54 paying pay VBG 42759 4876 55 function function NN 42759 4876 56 . . . 42759 4877 1 This this DT 42759 4877 2 is be VBZ 42759 4877 3 the the DT 42759 4877 4 employers employer NNS 42759 4877 5 . . . 42759 4878 1 In in IN 42759 4878 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4878 3 present present JJ 42759 4878 4 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4878 5 system system NN 42759 4878 6 , , , 42759 4878 7 the the DT 42759 4878 8 employer employer NN 42759 4878 9 is be VBZ 42759 4878 10 society society NN 42759 4878 11 's 's POS 42759 4878 12 paymaster paymaster NN 42759 4878 13 . . . 42759 4879 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4879 2 , , , 42759 4879 3 not not RB 42759 4879 4 the the DT 42759 4879 5 State State NNP 42759 4879 6 , , , 42759 4879 7 receives receive VBZ 42759 4879 8 the the DT 42759 4879 9 product product NN 42759 4879 10 out out IN 42759 4879 11 of of IN 42759 4879 12 which which WDT 42759 4879 13 all all PDT 42759 4879 14 the the DT 42759 4879 15 agents agent NNS 42759 4879 16 of of IN 42759 4879 17 production production NN 42759 4879 18 must must MD 42759 4879 19 be be VB 42759 4879 20 rewarded reward VBN 42759 4879 21 . . . 42759 4880 1 Where where WRB 42759 4880 2 the the DT 42759 4880 3 labourer labourer NN 42759 4880 4 is be VBZ 42759 4880 5 engaged engage VBN 42759 4880 6 in in IN 42759 4880 7 rendering render VBG 42759 4880 8 personal personal JJ 42759 4880 9 services service NNS 42759 4880 10 to to IN 42759 4880 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4880 12 employer employer NN 42759 4880 13 , , , 42759 4880 14 the the DT 42759 4880 15 latter latter NN 42759 4880 16 is be VBZ 42759 4880 17 the the DT 42759 4880 18 only only JJ 42759 4880 19 beneficiary beneficiary NN 42759 4880 20 of of IN 42759 4880 21 the the DT 42759 4880 22 labourer labourer NN 42759 4880 23 's 's POS 42759 4880 24 activity activity NN 42759 4880 25 . . . 42759 4881 1 In in IN 42759 4881 2 either either DT 42759 4881 3 case case NN 42759 4881 4 the the DT 42759 4881 5 employer employer NN 42759 4881 6 is be VBZ 42759 4881 7 the the DT 42759 4881 8 only only JJ 42759 4881 9 person person NN 42759 4881 10 upon upon IN 42759 4881 11 whom whom WP 42759 4881 12 the the DT 42759 4881 13 obligation obligation NN 42759 4881 14 of of IN 42759 4881 15 paying pay VBG 42759 4881 16 a a DT 42759 4881 17 living living NN 42759 4881 18 wage wage NN 42759 4881 19 can can MD 42759 4881 20 primarily primarily RB 42759 4881 21 fall fall VB 42759 4881 22 . . . 42759 4882 1 If if IN 42759 4882 2 the the DT 42759 4882 3 State State NNP 42759 4882 4 were be VBD 42759 4882 5 in in IN 42759 4882 6 receipt receipt NN 42759 4882 7 of of IN 42759 4882 8 the the DT 42759 4882 9 product product NN 42759 4882 10 of of IN 42759 4882 11 industry industry NN 42759 4882 12 , , , 42759 4882 13 the the DT 42759 4882 14 wage wage NN 42759 4882 15 - - HYPH 42759 4882 16 paying pay VBG 42759 4882 17 fund fund NN 42759 4882 18 , , , 42759 4882 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4882 20 would would MD 42759 4882 21 naturally naturally RB 42759 4882 22 be be VB 42759 4882 23 charged charge VBN 42759 4882 24 with with IN 42759 4882 25 the the DT 42759 4882 26 obligation obligation NN 42759 4882 27 that that WDT 42759 4882 28 now now RB 42759 4882 29 rests rest VBZ 42759 4882 30 immediately immediately RB 42759 4882 31 upon upon IN 42759 4882 32 the the DT 42759 4882 33 employer employer NN 42759 4882 34 . . . 42759 4883 1 If if IN 42759 4883 2 any any DT 42759 4883 3 other other JJ 42759 4883 4 class class NN 42759 4883 5 in in IN 42759 4883 6 the the DT 42759 4883 7 community community NN 42759 4883 8 were be VBD 42759 4883 9 the the DT 42759 4883 10 owners owner NNS 42759 4883 11 of of IN 42759 4883 12 the the DT 42759 4883 13 product product NN 42759 4883 14 that that DT 42759 4883 15 class class NN 42759 4883 16 would would MD 42759 4883 17 be be VB 42759 4883 18 under under IN 42759 4883 19 this this DT 42759 4883 20 specific specific JJ 42759 4883 21 obligation obligation NN 42759 4883 22 . . . 42759 4884 1 As as IN 42759 4884 2 things thing NNS 42759 4884 3 are be VBP 42759 4884 4 , , , 42759 4884 5 the the DT 42759 4884 6 employer employer NN 42759 4884 7 is be VBZ 42759 4884 8 in in IN 42759 4884 9 possession possession NN 42759 4884 10 of of IN 42759 4884 11 the the DT 42759 4884 12 product product NN 42759 4884 13 , , , 42759 4884 14 and and CC 42759 4884 15 discharges discharge VBZ 42759 4884 16 the the DT 42759 4884 17 function function NN 42759 4884 18 of of IN 42759 4884 19 wage wage NN 42759 4884 20 payer payer NN 42759 4884 21 ; ; : 42759 4884 22 consequently consequently RB 42759 4884 23 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4884 24 is be VBZ 42759 4884 25 the the DT 42759 4884 26 person person NN 42759 4884 27 who who WP 42759 4884 28 is be VBZ 42759 4884 29 required require VBN 42759 4884 30 to to TO 42759 4884 31 perform perform VB 42759 4884 32 this this DT 42759 4884 33 function function NN 42759 4884 34 in in IN 42759 4884 35 a a DT 42759 4884 36 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4884 37 manner manner NN 42759 4884 38 . . . 42759 4885 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4885 2 When when WRB 42759 4885 3 the the DT 42759 4885 4 Employer Employer NNP 42759 4885 5 Is be VBZ 42759 4885 6 Unable unable JJ 42759 4885 7 to to TO 42759 4885 8 Pay pay VB 42759 4885 9 a a DT 42759 4885 10 Living Living NNP 42759 4885 11 Wage Wage NNP 42759 4885 12 _ _ NNP 42759 4885 13 Evidently evidently RB 42759 4885 14 the the DT 42759 4885 15 employer employer NN 42759 4885 16 who who WP 42759 4885 17 can can MD 42759 4885 18 not not RB 42759 4885 19 pay pay VB 42759 4885 20 a a DT 42759 4885 21 living living NN 42759 4885 22 wage wage NN 42759 4885 23 is be VBZ 42759 4885 24 not not RB 42759 4885 25 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4885 26 to to TO 42759 4885 27 do do VB 42759 4885 28 so so RB 42759 4885 29 , , , 42759 4885 30 since since IN 42759 4885 31 moral moral JJ 42759 4885 32 duties duty NNS 42759 4885 33 suppose suppose VBP 42759 4885 34 a a DT 42759 4885 35 corresponding correspond VBG 42759 4885 36 physical physical JJ 42759 4885 37 capacity capacity NN 42759 4885 38 . . . 42759 4886 1 In in IN 42759 4886 2 such such JJ 42759 4886 3 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 4886 4 the the DT 42759 4886 5 labourer labourer NN 42759 4886 6 's 's POS 42759 4886 7 right right NN 42759 4886 8 to to IN 42759 4886 9 a a DT 42759 4886 10 living living NN 42759 4886 11 wage wage NN 42759 4886 12 becomes become VBZ 42759 4886 13 suspended suspended JJ 42759 4886 14 and and CC 42759 4886 15 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 42759 4886 16 , , , 42759 4886 17 just just RB 42759 4886 18 as as IN 42759 4886 19 the the DT 42759 4886 20 claim claim NN 42759 4886 21 of of IN 42759 4886 22 a a DT 42759 4886 23 creditor creditor NN 42759 4886 24 when when WRB 42759 4886 25 the the DT 42759 4886 26 debtor debtor NN 42759 4886 27 becomes become VBZ 42759 4886 28 insolvent insolvent JJ 42759 4886 29 . . . 42759 4887 1 Let let VB 42759 4887 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4887 3 see see VB 42759 4887 4 , , , 42759 4887 5 however however RB 42759 4887 6 , , , 42759 4887 7 precisely precisely RB 42759 4887 8 what what WP 42759 4887 9 meaning meaning NN 42759 4887 10 should should MD 42759 4887 11 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 4887 12 be be VB 42759 4887 13 given give VBN 42759 4887 14 to to IN 42759 4887 15 the the DT 42759 4887 16 phrase phrase NN 42759 4887 17 , , , 42759 4887 18 " " `` 42759 4887 19 inability inability NN 42759 4887 20 to to TO 42759 4887 21 pay pay VB 42759 4887 22 a a DT 42759 4887 23 living living NN 42759 4887 24 wage wage NN 42759 4887 25 . . . 42759 4887 26 " " '' 42759 4888 1 An an DT 42759 4888 2 employer employer NN 42759 4888 3 is be VBZ 42759 4888 4 not not RB 42759 4888 5 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4888 6 to to TO 42759 4888 7 pay pay VB 42759 4888 8 a a DT 42759 4888 9 full full JJ 42759 4888 10 living living NN 42759 4888 11 wage wage NN 42759 4888 12 to to IN 42759 4888 13 all all DT 42759 4888 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4888 15 employés employés NN 42759 4888 16 so so RB 42759 4888 17 long long RB 42759 4888 18 as as IN 42759 4888 19 that that DT 42759 4888 20 action action NN 42759 4888 21 would would MD 42759 4888 22 deprive deprive VB 42759 4888 23 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4888 24 and and CC 42759 4888 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4888 26 family family NN 42759 4888 27 of of IN 42759 4888 28 a a DT 42759 4888 29 decent decent JJ 42759 4888 30 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4888 31 . . . 42759 4889 1 As as IN 42759 4889 2 active active JJ 42759 4889 3 director director NN 42759 4889 4 of of IN 42759 4889 5 a a DT 42759 4889 6 business business NN 42759 4889 7 , , , 42759 4889 8 the the DT 42759 4889 9 employer employer NN 42759 4889 10 has have VBZ 42759 4889 11 quite quite RB 42759 4889 12 as as RB 42759 4889 13 good good JJ 42759 4889 14 a a DT 42759 4889 15 right right NN 42759 4889 16 as as IN 42759 4889 17 the the DT 42759 4889 18 labourer labourer NN 42759 4889 19 to to IN 42759 4889 20 a a DT 42759 4889 21 decent decent JJ 42759 4889 22 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4889 23 from from IN 42759 4889 24 the the DT 42759 4889 25 product product NN 42759 4889 26 , , , 42759 4889 27 and and CC 42759 4889 28 in in IN 42759 4889 29 case case NN 42759 4889 30 of of IN 42759 4889 31 conflict conflict NN 42759 4889 32 between between IN 42759 4889 33 the the DT 42759 4889 34 two two CD 42759 4889 35 rights right NNS 42759 4889 36 , , , 42759 4889 37 the the DT 42759 4889 38 employer employer NN 42759 4889 39 may may MD 42759 4889 40 take take VB 42759 4889 41 advantage advantage NN 42759 4889 42 of of IN 42759 4889 43 that that DT 42759 4889 44 principle principle NN 42759 4889 45 of of IN 42759 4889 46 charity charity NN 42759 4889 47 which which WDT 42759 4889 48 permits permit VBZ 42759 4889 49 a a DT 42759 4889 50 man man NN 42759 4889 51 to to TO 42759 4889 52 prefer prefer VB 42759 4889 53 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4889 54 to to IN 42759 4889 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4889 56 neighbour neighbour NN 42759 4889 57 , , , 42759 4889 58 when when WRB 42759 4889 59 the the DT 42759 4889 60 choice choice NN 42759 4889 61 refers refer VBZ 42759 4889 62 to to IN 42759 4889 63 goods good NNS 42759 4889 64 of of IN 42759 4889 65 the the DT 42759 4889 66 same same JJ 42759 4889 67 order order NN 42759 4889 68 of of IN 42759 4889 69 importance importance NN 42759 4889 70 . . . 42759 4890 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4890 2 , , , 42759 4890 3 the the DT 42759 4890 4 employer employer NN 42759 4890 5 is be VBZ 42759 4890 6 justified justify VBN 42759 4890 7 in in IN 42759 4890 8 taking take VBG 42759 4890 9 from from IN 42759 4890 10 the the DT 42759 4890 11 product product NN 42759 4890 12 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4890 13 to to TO 42759 4890 14 support support VB 42759 4890 15 a a DT 42759 4890 16 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 4890 17 higher high JJR 42759 4890 18 scale scale NN 42759 4890 19 of of IN 42759 4890 20 living living NN 42759 4890 21 than than IN 42759 4890 22 generally generally RB 42759 4890 23 prevails prevail VBZ 42759 4890 24 among among IN 42759 4890 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4890 26 employés employés NN 42759 4890 27 ; ; : 42759 4890 28 for for IN 42759 4890 29 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4890 30 has have VBZ 42759 4890 31 become become VBN 42759 4890 32 accustomed accustomed JJ 42759 4890 33 to to IN 42759 4890 34 this this DT 42759 4890 35 higher high JJR 42759 4890 36 standard standard NN 42759 4890 37 , , , 42759 4890 38 and and CC 42759 4890 39 would would MD 42759 4890 40 suffer suffer VB 42759 4890 41 a a DT 42759 4890 42 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4890 43 hardship hardship NN 42759 4890 44 if if IN 42759 4890 45 compelled compel VBN 42759 4890 46 to to TO 42759 4890 47 fall fall VB 42759 4890 48 notably notably RB 42759 4890 49 below below IN 42759 4890 50 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4890 51 . . . 42759 4891 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4891 2 is be VBZ 42759 4891 3 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4891 4 , , , 42759 4891 5 therefore therefore RB 42759 4891 6 , , , 42759 4891 7 that that IN 42759 4891 8 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4891 9 should should MD 42759 4891 10 have have VB 42759 4891 11 the the DT 42759 4891 12 means mean NNS 42759 4891 13 of of IN 42759 4891 14 maintaining maintain VBG 42759 4891 15 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4891 16 and and CC 42759 4891 17 family family NN 42759 4891 18 in in IN 42759 4891 19 moderate moderate JJ 42759 4891 20 conformity conformity NN 42759 4891 21 with with IN 42759 4891 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4891 23 customary customary JJ 42759 4891 24 standard standard NN 42759 4891 25 of of IN 42759 4891 26 living living NN 42759 4891 27 ; ; : 42759 4891 28 but but CC 42759 4891 29 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4891 30 is be VBZ 42759 4891 31 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 4891 32 that that IN 42759 4891 33 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4891 34 should should MD 42759 4891 35 indulge indulge VB 42759 4891 36 in in IN 42759 4891 37 anything anything NN 42759 4891 38 like like IN 42759 4891 39 luxurious luxurious JJ 42759 4891 40 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 4891 41 , , , 42759 4891 42 so so RB 42759 4891 43 long long RB 42759 4891 44 as as IN 42759 4891 45 any any DT 42759 4891 46 of of IN 42759 4891 47 the the DT 42759 4891 48 employés employés NN 42759 4891 49 fail fail VBP 42759 4891 50 to to TO 42759 4891 51 receive receive VB 42759 4891 52 living live VBG 42759 4891 53 wages wage NNS 42759 4891 54 . . . 42759 4892 1 Suppose suppose VB 42759 4892 2 that that IN 42759 4892 3 an an DT 42759 4892 4 employer employer NN 42759 4892 5 can can MD 42759 4892 6 not not RB 42759 4892 7 pay pay VB 42759 4892 8 all all PDT 42759 4892 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4892 10 employés employés NN 42759 4892 11 living live VBG 42759 4892 12 wages wage NNS 42759 4892 13 and and CC 42759 4892 14 at at IN 42759 4892 15 the the DT 42759 4892 16 same same JJ 42759 4892 17 time time NN 42759 4892 18 provide provide VB 42759 4892 19 the the DT 42759 4892 20 normal normal JJ 42759 4892 21 rate rate NN 42759 4892 22 of of IN 42759 4892 23 interest interest NN 42759 4892 24 on on IN 42759 4892 25 the the DT 42759 4892 26 capital capital NN 42759 4892 27 in in IN 42759 4892 28 the the DT 42759 4892 29 business business NN 42759 4892 30 . . . 42759 4893 1 So so RB 42759 4893 2 far far RB 42759 4893 3 as as IN 42759 4893 4 the the DT 42759 4893 5 borrowed borrow VBN 42759 4893 6 capital capital NN 42759 4893 7 is be VBZ 42759 4893 8 concerned concern VBN 42759 4893 9 , , , 42759 4893 10 the the DT 42759 4893 11 business business NN 42759 4893 12 man man NN 42759 4893 13 has have VBZ 42759 4893 14 no no DT 42759 4893 15 choice choice NN 42759 4893 16 ; ; : 42759 4893 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4893 18 must must MD 42759 4893 19 pay pay VB 42759 4893 20 the the DT 42759 4893 21 stipulated stipulate VBN 42759 4893 22 rate rate NN 42759 4893 23 of of IN 42759 4893 24 interest interest NN 42759 4893 25 , , , 42759 4893 26 even even RB 42759 4893 27 though though IN 42759 4893 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4893 29 prevents prevent VBZ 42759 4893 30 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4893 31 from from IN 42759 4893 32 giving give VBG 42759 4893 33 a a DT 42759 4893 34 living living NN 42759 4893 35 wage wage NN 42759 4893 36 to to IN 42759 4893 37 all all DT 42759 4893 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4893 39 employés employés NN 42759 4893 40 . . . 42759 4894 1 Nor nor CC 42759 4894 2 can can MD 42759 4894 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4894 4 be be VB 42759 4894 5 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 4894 6 contended contend VBN 42759 4894 7 that that IN 42759 4894 8 the the DT 42759 4894 9 loan loan NN 42759 4894 10 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4894 11 in in IN 42759 4894 12 that that DT 42759 4894 13 case case NN 42759 4894 14 is be VBZ 42759 4894 15 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4894 16 to to TO 42759 4894 17 forego forego VB 42759 4894 18 the the DT 42759 4894 19 interest interest NN 42759 4894 20 due due VB 42759 4894 21 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4894 22 . . . 42759 4895 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4895 2 can can MD 42759 4895 3 not not RB 42759 4895 4 be be VB 42759 4895 5 certain certain JJ 42759 4895 6 that that IN 42759 4895 7 this this DT 42759 4895 8 interest interest NN 42759 4895 9 payment payment NN 42759 4895 10 , , , 42759 4895 11 or or CC 42759 4895 12 any any DT 42759 4895 13 part part NN 42759 4895 14 of of IN 42759 4895 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4895 16 , , , 42759 4895 17 is be VBZ 42759 4895 18 really really RB 42759 4895 19 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4895 20 to to TO 42759 4895 21 make make VB 42759 4895 22 up up RP 42759 4895 23 what what WP 42759 4895 24 is be VBZ 42759 4895 25 wanting want VBG 42759 4895 26 to to IN 42759 4895 27 a a DT 42759 4895 28 complete complete JJ 42759 4895 29 scale scale NN 42759 4895 30 of of IN 42759 4895 31 living living NN 42759 4895 32 wages wage NNS 42759 4895 33 . . . 42759 4896 1 The the DT 42759 4896 2 employer employer NN 42759 4896 3 would would MD 42759 4896 4 be be VB 42759 4896 5 under under IN 42759 4896 6 great great JJ 42759 4896 7 temptation temptation NN 42759 4896 8 to to TO 42759 4896 9 defraud defraud VB 42759 4896 10 the the DT 42759 4896 11 loan loan NN 42759 4896 12 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4896 13 on on IN 42759 4896 14 the the DT 42759 4896 15 pretext pretext NN 42759 4896 16 of of IN 42759 4896 17 doing do VBG 42759 4896 18 justice justice NN 42759 4896 19 to to IN 42759 4896 20 the the DT 42759 4896 21 labourer labourer NN 42759 4896 22 , , , 42759 4896 23 or or CC 42759 4896 24 to to TO 42759 4896 25 conduct conduct VB 42759 4896 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4896 27 business business NN 42759 4896 28 inefficiently inefficiently RB 42759 4896 29 at at IN 42759 4896 30 the the DT 42759 4896 31 expense expense NN 42759 4896 32 of of IN 42759 4896 33 the the DT 42759 4896 34 loan loan NN 42759 4896 35 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4896 36 . . . 42759 4897 1 Anyhow anyhow RB 42759 4897 2 , , , 42759 4897 3 the the DT 42759 4897 4 latter latter NN 42759 4897 5 is be VBZ 42759 4897 6 under under IN 42759 4897 7 no no DT 42759 4897 8 obligation obligation NN 42759 4897 9 to to TO 42759 4897 10 leave leave VB 42759 4897 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4897 12 money money NN 42759 4897 13 in in IN 42759 4897 14 a a DT 42759 4897 15 concern concern NN 42759 4897 16 that that WDT 42759 4897 17 is be VBZ 42759 4897 18 unable unable JJ 42759 4897 19 to to TO 42759 4897 20 pay pay VB 42759 4897 21 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4897 22 interest interest NN 42759 4897 23 regularly regularly RB 42759 4897 24 . . . 42759 4898 1 The the DT 42759 4898 2 general general JJ 42759 4898 3 rule rule NN 42759 4898 4 , , , 42759 4898 5 then then RB 42759 4898 6 , , , 42759 4898 7 would would MD 42759 4898 8 seem seem VB 42759 4898 9 to to TO 42759 4898 10 be be VB 42759 4898 11 that that IN 42759 4898 12 the the DT 42759 4898 13 loan loan NN 42759 4898 14 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4898 15 is be VBZ 42759 4898 16 not not RB 42759 4898 17 obliged oblige VBN 42759 4898 18 to to TO 42759 4898 19 refrain refrain VB 42759 4898 20 from from IN 42759 4898 21 taking take VBG 42759 4898 22 interest interest NN 42759 4898 23 in in IN 42759 4898 24 order order NN 42759 4898 25 that that IN 42759 4898 26 the the DT 42759 4898 27 employés employés NN 42759 4898 28 may may MD 42759 4898 29 have have VB 42759 4898 30 living live VBG 42759 4898 31 wages wage NNS 42759 4898 32 . . . 42759 4899 1 Is be VBZ 42759 4899 2 the the DT 42759 4899 3 employer employer NN 42759 4899 4 justified justify VBN 42759 4899 5 in in IN 42759 4899 6 withholding withhold VBG 42759 4899 7 the the DT 42759 4899 8 full full JJ 42759 4899 9 living living NN 42759 4899 10 wage wage NN 42759 4899 11 from from IN 42759 4899 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4899 13 employés employés NN 42759 4899 14 to to TO 42759 4899 15 provide provide VB 42759 4899 16 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4899 17 with with IN 42759 4899 18 the the DT 42759 4899 19 normal normal JJ 42759 4899 20 rate rate NN 42759 4899 21 of of IN 42759 4899 22 interest interest NN 42759 4899 23 on on IN 42759 4899 24 the the DT 42759 4899 25 capital capital NN 42759 4899 26 that that WDT 42759 4899 27 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4899 28 has have VBZ 42759 4899 29 invested invest VBN 42759 4899 30 in in IN 42759 4899 31 the the DT 42759 4899 32 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 4899 33 ? ? . 42759 4900 1 Speaking speak VBG 42759 4900 2 generally generally RB 42759 4900 3 , , , 42759 4900 4 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4900 5 is be VBZ 42759 4900 6 not not RB 42759 4900 7 . . . 42759 4901 1 In in IN 42759 4901 2 the the DT 42759 4901 3 first first JJ 42759 4901 4 place place NN 42759 4901 5 , , , 42759 4901 6 the the DT 42759 4901 7 right right NN 42759 4901 8 to to IN 42759 4901 9 any any DT 42759 4901 10 interest interest NN 42759 4901 11 at at RB 42759 4901 12 all all RB 42759 4901 13 , , , 42759 4901 14 except except IN 42759 4901 15 as as IN 42759 4901 16 a a DT 42759 4901 17 return return NN 42759 4901 18 for for IN 42759 4901 19 genuine genuine JJ 42759 4901 20 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 4901 21 in in IN 42759 4901 22 saving saving NN 42759 4901 23 , , , 42759 4901 24 is be VBZ 42759 4901 25 not not RB 42759 4901 26 certain certain JJ 42759 4901 27 but but CC 42759 4901 28 only only RB 42759 4901 29 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 4901 30 . . . 42759 4902 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4902 2 244 244 CD 42759 4902 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4902 4 Consequently consequently RB 42759 4902 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4902 6 has have VBZ 42759 4902 7 no no DT 42759 4902 8 such such JJ 42759 4902 9 firm firm JJ 42759 4902 10 and and CC 42759 4902 11 definite definite JJ 42759 4902 12 basis basis NN 42759 4902 13 as as IN 42759 4902 14 the the DT 42759 4902 15 right right NN 42759 4902 16 to to IN 42759 4902 17 a a DT 42759 4902 18 living living NN 42759 4902 19 wage wage NN 42759 4902 20 . . . 42759 4903 1 In in IN 42759 4903 2 the the DT 42759 4903 3 second second JJ 42759 4903 4 place place NN 42759 4903 5 , , , 42759 4903 6 the the DT 42759 4903 7 right right NN 42759 4903 8 to to IN 42759 4903 9 interest interest NN 42759 4903 10 , , , 42759 4903 11 be be VB 42759 4903 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4903 13 ever ever RB 42759 4903 14 so so RB 42759 4903 15 definite definite JJ 42759 4903 16 and and CC 42759 4903 17 certain certain JJ 42759 4903 18 , , , 42759 4903 19 is be VBZ 42759 4903 20 greatly greatly RB 42759 4903 21 inferior inferior JJ 42759 4903 22 in in IN 42759 4903 23 force force NN 42759 4903 24 and and CC 42759 4903 25 urgency urgency NN 42759 4903 26 . . . 42759 4904 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4904 2 is be VBZ 42759 4904 3 an an DT 42759 4904 4 axiom axiom NN 42759 4904 5 of of IN 42759 4904 6 ethics ethic NNS 42759 4904 7 that that IN 42759 4904 8 when when WRB 42759 4904 9 two two CD 42759 4904 10 rights right NNS 42759 4904 11 conflict conflict NN 42759 4904 12 , , , 42759 4904 13 the the DT 42759 4904 14 less less RBR 42759 4904 15 important important JJ 42759 4904 16 must must MD 42759 4904 17 give give VB 42759 4904 18 way way NN 42759 4904 19 to to IN 42759 4904 20 the the DT 42759 4904 21 more more RBR 42759 4904 22 important important JJ 42759 4904 23 . . . 42759 4905 1 Since since IN 42759 4905 2 all all DT 42759 4905 3 property property NN 42759 4905 4 rights right NNS 42759 4905 5 are be VBP 42759 4905 6 but but CC 42759 4905 7 means mean VBZ 42759 4905 8 to to IN 42759 4905 9 the the DT 42759 4905 10 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 4905 11 of of IN 42759 4905 12 human human JJ 42759 4905 13 needs need NNS 42759 4905 14 , , , 42759 4905 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4905 16 relative relative JJ 42759 4905 17 importance importance NN 42759 4905 18 is be VBZ 42759 4905 19 determined determine VBN 42759 4905 20 by by IN 42759 4905 21 the the DT 42759 4905 22 relative relative JJ 42759 4905 23 importance importance NN 42759 4905 24 of of IN 42759 4905 25 the the DT 42759 4905 26 ends end NNS 42759 4905 27 that that WDT 42759 4905 28 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4905 29 serve serve VBP 42759 4905 30 ; ; : 42759 4905 31 that that RB 42759 4905 32 is is RB 42759 4905 33 , , , 42759 4905 34 by by IN 42759 4905 35 the the DT 42759 4905 36 relative relative JJ 42759 4905 37 importance importance NN 42759 4905 38 of of IN 42759 4905 39 the the DT 42759 4905 40 dependent dependent JJ 42759 4905 41 needs need NNS 42759 4905 42 . . . 42759 4906 1 Now now RB 42759 4906 2 the the DT 42759 4906 3 needs need NNS 42759 4906 4 that that WDT 42759 4906 5 are be VBP 42759 4906 6 supplied supply VBN 42759 4906 7 through through IN 42759 4906 8 interest interest NN 42759 4906 9 on on IN 42759 4906 10 the the DT 42759 4906 11 employer employer NN 42759 4906 12 's 's POS 42759 4906 13 capital capital NN 42759 4906 14 are be VBP 42759 4906 15 slight slight JJ 42759 4906 16 and and CC 42759 4906 17 not not RB 42759 4906 18 essential essential JJ 42759 4906 19 to to IN 42759 4906 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4906 21 welfare welfare NN 42759 4906 22 ; ; : 42759 4906 23 the the DT 42759 4906 24 needs need NNS 42759 4906 25 that that WDT 42759 4906 26 are be VBP 42759 4906 27 supplied supply VBN 42759 4906 28 through through IN 42759 4906 29 a a DT 42759 4906 30 living living NN 42759 4906 31 wage wage NN 42759 4906 32 are be VBP 42759 4906 33 essential essential JJ 42759 4906 34 to to IN 42759 4906 35 a a DT 42759 4906 36 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4906 37 life life NN 42759 4906 38 for for IN 42759 4906 39 the the DT 42759 4906 40 labourer labourer NN 42759 4906 41 . . . 42759 4907 1 On on IN 42759 4907 2 the the DT 42759 4907 3 assumption assumption NN 42759 4907 4 that that IN 42759 4907 5 the the DT 42759 4907 6 employer employer NN 42759 4907 7 has have VBZ 42759 4907 8 already already RB 42759 4907 9 taken take VBN 42759 4907 10 from from IN 42759 4907 11 the the DT 42759 4907 12 product product NN 42759 4907 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4907 14 to to TO 42759 4907 15 provide provide VB 42759 4907 16 a a DT 42759 4907 17 decent decent JJ 42759 4907 18 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4907 19 , , , 42759 4907 20 interest interest NN 42759 4907 21 on on IN 42759 4907 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4907 23 capital capital NN 42759 4907 24 will will MD 42759 4907 25 be be VB 42759 4907 26 expended expend VBN 42759 4907 27 for for IN 42759 4907 28 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 4907 29 or or CC 42759 4907 30 converted convert VBN 42759 4907 31 into into IN 42759 4907 32 new new JJ 42759 4907 33 investments investment NNS 42759 4907 34 ; ; : 42759 4907 35 a a DT 42759 4907 36 living living NN 42759 4907 37 wage wage NN 42759 4907 38 for for IN 42759 4907 39 the the DT 42759 4907 40 labourer labourer NN 42759 4907 41 will will MD 42759 4907 42 all all DT 42759 4907 43 be be VB 42759 4907 44 required require VBN 42759 4907 45 for for IN 42759 4907 46 the the DT 42759 4907 47 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4907 48 goods good NNS 42759 4907 49 of of IN 42759 4907 50 life life NN 42759 4907 51 , , , 42759 4907 52 physical physical JJ 42759 4907 53 , , , 42759 4907 54 mental mental JJ 42759 4907 55 , , , 42759 4907 56 or or CC 42759 4907 57 moral moral JJ 42759 4907 58 . . . 42759 4908 1 Evidently evidently RB 42759 4908 2 , , , 42759 4908 3 then then RB 42759 4908 4 , , , 42759 4908 5 the the DT 42759 4908 6 right right NN 42759 4908 7 to to IN 42759 4908 8 interest interest NN 42759 4908 9 is be VBZ 42759 4908 10 inferior inferior JJ 42759 4908 11 to to IN 42759 4908 12 the the DT 42759 4908 13 right right NN 42759 4908 14 to to IN 42759 4908 15 a a DT 42759 4908 16 living living NN 42759 4908 17 wage wage NN 42759 4908 18 . . . 42759 4909 1 To to TO 42759 4909 2 proceed proceed VB 42759 4909 3 on on IN 42759 4909 4 the the DT 42759 4909 5 contrary contrary JJ 42759 4909 6 theory theory NN 42759 4909 7 is be VBZ 42759 4909 8 to to TO 42759 4909 9 reverse reverse VB 42759 4909 10 the the DT 42759 4909 11 order order NN 42759 4909 12 of of IN 42759 4909 13 nature nature NN 42759 4909 14 and and CC 42759 4909 15 reason reason NN 42759 4909 16 , , , 42759 4909 17 and and CC 42759 4909 18 to to TO 42759 4909 19 subordinate subordinate VB 42759 4909 20 essential essential JJ 42759 4909 21 needs need NNS 42759 4909 22 and and CC 42759 4909 23 welfare welfare NN 42759 4909 24 to to IN 42759 4909 25 unessential unessential JJ 42759 4909 26 needs need NNS 42759 4909 27 and and CC 42759 4909 28 welfare welfare NN 42759 4909 29 . . . 42759 4910 1 Nor nor CC 42759 4910 2 can can MD 42759 4910 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4910 4 be be VB 42759 4910 5 maintained maintain VBN 42759 4910 6 that that IN 42759 4910 7 the the DT 42759 4910 8 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 4910 9 - - HYPH 42759 4910 10 employer employer NN 42759 4910 11 's 's POS 42759 4910 12 claim claim NN 42759 4910 13 to to IN 42759 4910 14 interest interest NN 42759 4910 15 is be VBZ 42759 4910 16 a a DT 42759 4910 17 claim claim NN 42759 4910 18 upon upon IN 42759 4910 19 the the DT 42759 4910 20 product product NN 42759 4910 21 prior prior RB 42759 4910 22 to to IN 42759 4910 23 and and CC 42759 4910 24 independent independent JJ 42759 4910 25 of of IN 42759 4910 26 the the DT 42759 4910 27 claim claim NN 42759 4910 28 of of IN 42759 4910 29 the the DT 42759 4910 30 labourer labourer NN 42759 4910 31 to to IN 42759 4910 32 a a DT 42759 4910 33 living living NN 42759 4910 34 wage wage NN 42759 4910 35 . . . 42759 4911 1 That that DT 42759 4911 2 would would MD 42759 4911 3 be be VB 42759 4911 4 begging beg VBG 42759 4911 5 the the DT 42759 4911 6 question question NN 42759 4911 7 . . . 42759 4912 1 The the DT 42759 4912 2 product product NN 42759 4912 3 is be VBZ 42759 4912 4 in in IN 42759 4912 5 a a DT 42759 4912 6 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 4912 7 sense sense NN 42759 4912 8 the the DT 42759 4912 9 common common JJ 42759 4912 10 property property NN 42759 4912 11 of of IN 42759 4912 12 employer employer NN 42759 4912 13 and and CC 42759 4912 14 employés employés NNP 42759 4912 15 . . . 42759 4913 1 Both both DT 42759 4913 2 parties party NNS 42759 4913 3 have have VBP 42759 4913 4 co co VBN 42759 4913 5 - - VBN 42759 4913 6 operated operated JJ 42759 4913 7 in in IN 42759 4913 8 turning turn VBG 42759 4913 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4913 10 out out RP 42759 4913 11 , , , 42759 4913 12 and and CC 42759 4913 13 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4913 14 have have VBP 42759 4913 15 equal equal JJ 42759 4913 16 claims claim NNS 42759 4913 17 upon upon IN 42759 4913 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4913 19 , , , 42759 4913 20 in in IN 42759 4913 21 so so RB 42759 4913 22 far far RB 42759 4913 23 as as IN 42759 4913 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4913 25 is be VBZ 42759 4913 26 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4913 27 to to TO 42759 4913 28 yield yield VB 42759 4913 29 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4913 30 a a DT 42759 4913 31 decent decent JJ 42759 4913 32 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4913 33 . . . 42759 4914 1 Having have VBG 42759 4914 2 taken take VBN 42759 4914 3 therefrom therefrom IN 42759 4914 4 the the DT 42759 4914 5 requisites requisite NNS 42759 4914 6 of of IN 42759 4914 7 a a DT 42759 4914 8 decent decent JJ 42759 4914 9 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4914 10 for for IN 42759 4914 11 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4914 12 , , , 42759 4914 13 the the DT 42759 4914 14 employer employer NN 42759 4914 15 who who WP 42759 4914 16 appropriates appropriate VBZ 42759 4914 17 interest interest NN 42759 4914 18 at at IN 42759 4914 19 the the DT 42759 4914 20 expense expense NN 42759 4914 21 of of IN 42759 4914 22 a a DT 42759 4914 23 decent decent JJ 42759 4914 24 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4914 25 for for IN 42759 4914 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4914 27 employés employés NN 42759 4914 28 , , , 42759 4914 29 in in IN 42759 4914 30 effect effect NN 42759 4914 31 treats treat VBZ 42759 4914 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4914 33 claims claim NNS 42759 4914 34 upon upon IN 42759 4914 35 the the DT 42759 4914 36 common common JJ 42759 4914 37 and and CC 42759 4914 38 joint joint JJ 42759 4914 39 product product NN 42759 4914 40 as as IN 42759 4914 41 essentially essentially RB 42759 4914 42 inferior inferior JJ 42759 4914 43 to to IN 42759 4914 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4914 45 own own JJ 42759 4914 46 . . . 42759 4915 1 If if IN 42759 4915 2 this this DT 42759 4915 3 assumption assumption NN 42759 4915 4 were be VBD 42759 4915 5 correct correct JJ 42759 4915 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4915 7 would would MD 42759 4915 8 mean mean VB 42759 4915 9 that that IN 42759 4915 10 the the DT 42759 4915 11 primary primary JJ 42759 4915 12 and and CC 42759 4915 13 essential essential JJ 42759 4915 14 needs need NNS 42759 4915 15 of of IN 42759 4915 16 the the DT 42759 4915 17 employés employés NN 42759 4915 18 are be VBP 42759 4915 19 of of IN 42759 4915 20 less less JJR 42759 4915 21 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 4915 22 importance importance NN 42759 4915 23 than than IN 42759 4915 24 the the DT 42759 4915 25 superficial superficial JJ 42759 4915 26 needs need NNS 42759 4915 27 of of IN 42759 4915 28 the the DT 42759 4915 29 employer employer NN 42759 4915 30 , , , 42759 4915 31 and and CC 42759 4915 32 that that IN 42759 4915 33 the the DT 42759 4915 34 employés employés NN 42759 4915 35 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 4915 36 are be VBP 42759 4915 37 a a DT 42759 4915 38 lower low JJR 42759 4915 39 order order NN 42759 4915 40 of of IN 42759 4915 41 being be VBG 42759 4915 42 than than IN 42759 4915 43 the the DT 42759 4915 44 employer employer NN 42759 4915 45 . . . 42759 4916 1 The the DT 42759 4916 2 incontestable incontestable JJ 42759 4916 3 fact fact NN 42759 4916 4 is be VBZ 42759 4916 5 that that IN 42759 4916 6 such such PDT 42759 4916 7 an an DT 42759 4916 8 employer employer NN 42759 4916 9 deprives deprive VBZ 42759 4916 10 the the DT 42759 4916 11 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4916 12 of of IN 42759 4916 13 access access NN 42759 4916 14 to to IN 42759 4916 15 the the DT 42759 4916 16 goods good NNS 42759 4916 17 of of IN 42759 4916 18 the the DT 42759 4916 19 earth earth NN 42759 4916 20 on on IN 42759 4916 21 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4916 22 terms term NNS 42759 4916 23 , , , 42759 4916 24 and and CC 42759 4916 25 gives give VBZ 42759 4916 26 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4916 27 an an DT 42759 4916 28 access access NN 42759 4916 29 thereto thereto NN 42759 4916 30 that that WDT 42759 4916 31 is be VBZ 42759 4916 32 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 4916 33 . . . 42759 4917 1 Suppose suppose VB 42759 4917 2 that that IN 42759 4917 3 all all DT 42759 4917 4 employers employer NNS 42759 4917 5 who who WP 42759 4917 6 found find VBD 42759 4917 7 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 4917 8 unable unable JJ 42759 4917 9 to to TO 42759 4917 10 pay pay VB 42759 4917 11 full full JJ 42759 4917 12 living living NN 42759 4917 13 wages wage NNS 42759 4917 14 and and CC 42759 4917 15 obtain obtain VB 42759 4917 16 the the DT 42759 4917 17 normal normal JJ 42759 4917 18 rate rate NN 42759 4917 19 of of IN 42759 4917 20 interest interest NN 42759 4917 21 , , , 42759 4917 22 should should MD 42759 4917 23 dispose dispose VB 42759 4917 24 of of IN 42759 4917 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4917 26 businesses business NNS 42759 4917 27 and and CC 42759 4917 28 become become VB 42759 4917 29 mere mere JJ 42759 4917 30 loan loan NN 42759 4917 31 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 4917 32 , , , 42759 4917 33 would would MD 42759 4917 34 the the DT 42759 4917 35 condition condition NN 42759 4917 36 of of IN 42759 4917 37 the the DT 42759 4917 38 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 4917 39 workers worker NNS 42759 4917 40 be be VB 42759 4917 41 improved improve VBN 42759 4917 42 ? ? . 42759 4918 1 Two two CD 42759 4918 2 effects effect NNS 42759 4918 3 would would MD 42759 4918 4 be be VB 42759 4918 5 certain certain JJ 42759 4918 6 : : : 42759 4918 7 an an DT 42759 4918 8 increase increase NN 42759 4918 9 in in IN 42759 4918 10 the the DT 42759 4918 11 supply supply NN 42759 4918 12 of of IN 42759 4918 13 loan loan NN 42759 4918 14 capital capital NN 42759 4918 15 relatively relatively RB 42759 4918 16 to to IN 42759 4918 17 the the DT 42759 4918 18 demand demand NN 42759 4918 19 , , , 42759 4918 20 and and CC 42759 4918 21 a a DT 42759 4918 22 decrease decrease NN 42759 4918 23 in in IN 42759 4918 24 the the DT 42759 4918 25 number number NN 42759 4918 26 of of IN 42759 4918 27 active active JJ 42759 4918 28 business business NN 42759 4918 29 men man NNS 42759 4918 30 . . . 42759 4919 1 The the DT 42759 4919 2 first first JJ 42759 4919 3 would would MD 42759 4919 4 probably probably RB 42759 4919 5 lead lead VB 42759 4919 6 to to IN 42759 4919 7 a a DT 42759 4919 8 decline decline NN 42759 4919 9 in in IN 42759 4919 10 the the DT 42759 4919 11 rate rate NN 42759 4919 12 of of IN 42759 4919 13 interest interest NN 42759 4919 14 , , , 42759 4919 15 while while IN 42759 4919 16 the the DT 42759 4919 17 second second JJ 42759 4919 18 might might NN 42759 4919 19 or or CC 42759 4919 20 might may MD 42759 4919 21 not not RB 42759 4919 22 result result VB 42759 4919 23 in in IN 42759 4919 24 a a DT 42759 4919 25 diminution diminution NN 42759 4919 26 of of IN 42759 4919 27 the the DT 42759 4919 28 volume volume NN 42759 4919 29 of of IN 42759 4919 30 products product NNS 42759 4919 31 . . . 42759 4920 1 If if IN 42759 4920 2 the the DT 42759 4920 3 rate rate NN 42759 4920 4 of of IN 42759 4920 5 interest interest NN 42759 4920 6 were be VBD 42759 4920 7 lowered lower VBN 42759 4920 8 the the DT 42759 4920 9 employing employ VBG 42759 4920 10 business business NN 42759 4920 11 men man NNS 42759 4920 12 would would MD 42759 4920 13 be be VB 42759 4920 14 able able JJ 42759 4920 15 to to TO 42759 4920 16 raise raise VB 42759 4920 17 wages wage NNS 42759 4920 18 ; ; : 42759 4920 19 if if IN 42759 4920 20 the the DT 42759 4920 21 prices price NNS 42759 4920 22 of of IN 42759 4920 23 products product NNS 42759 4920 24 rose rise VBD 42759 4920 25 a a DT 42759 4920 26 further further JJ 42759 4920 27 increase increase NN 42759 4920 28 of of IN 42759 4920 29 wages wage NNS 42759 4920 30 would would MD 42759 4920 31 become become VB 42759 4920 32 possible possible JJ 42759 4920 33 . . . 42759 4921 1 However however RB 42759 4921 2 , , , 42759 4921 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4921 4 is be VBZ 42759 4921 5 not not RB 42759 4921 6 certain certain JJ 42759 4921 7 that that IN 42759 4921 8 prices price NNS 42759 4921 9 would would MD 42759 4921 10 rise rise VB 42759 4921 11 ; ; : 42759 4921 12 for for IN 42759 4921 13 the the DT 42759 4921 14 business business NN 42759 4921 15 men man NNS 42759 4921 16 who who WP 42759 4921 17 remained remain VBD 42759 4921 18 would would MD 42759 4921 19 be be VB 42759 4921 20 the the DT 42759 4921 21 more more RBR 42759 4921 22 efficient efficient JJ 42759 4921 23 in in IN 42759 4921 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4921 25 respective respective JJ 42759 4921 26 classes class NNS 42759 4921 27 , , , 42759 4921 28 and and CC 42759 4921 29 might may MD 42759 4921 30 well well RB 42759 4921 31 be be VB 42759 4921 32 capable capable JJ 42759 4921 33 of of IN 42759 4921 34 producing produce VBG 42759 4921 35 all all PDT 42759 4921 36 the the DT 42759 4921 37 goods good NNS 42759 4921 38 that that WDT 42759 4921 39 had have VBD 42759 4921 40 been be VBN 42759 4921 41 previously previously RB 42759 4921 42 supplied supply VBN 42759 4921 43 by by IN 42759 4921 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4921 45 eliminated eliminate VBN 42759 4921 46 competitors competitor NNS 42759 4921 47 . . . 42759 4922 1 Owing owe VBG 42759 4922 2 to to IN 42759 4922 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4922 4 superior superior JJ 42759 4922 5 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 4922 6 and and CC 42759 4922 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4922 8 larger large JJR 42759 4922 9 output output NN 42759 4922 10 , , , 42759 4922 11 the the DT 42759 4922 12 existing exist VBG 42759 4922 13 business business NN 42759 4922 14 men man NNS 42759 4922 15 would would MD 42759 4922 16 be be VB 42759 4922 17 able able JJ 42759 4922 18 to to TO 42759 4922 19 pay pay VB 42759 4922 20 considerably considerably RB 42759 4922 21 higher high JJR 42759 4922 22 wages wage NNS 42759 4922 23 than than IN 42759 4922 24 those those DT 42759 4922 25 who who WP 42759 4922 26 had have VBD 42759 4922 27 disappeared disappear VBN 42759 4922 28 from from IN 42759 4922 29 the the DT 42759 4922 30 field field NN 42759 4922 31 of of IN 42759 4922 32 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4922 33 direction direction NN 42759 4922 34 . . . 42759 4923 1 As as IN 42759 4923 2 things thing NNS 42759 4923 3 are be VBP 42759 4923 4 to to IN 42759 4923 5 - - HYPH 42759 4923 6 day day NN 42759 4923 7 , , , 42759 4923 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4923 9 is be VBZ 42759 4923 10 the the DT 42759 4923 11 less less RBR 42759 4923 12 efficient efficient JJ 42759 4923 13 business business NN 42759 4923 14 men man NNS 42759 4923 15 who who WP 42759 4923 16 are be VBP 42759 4923 17 unable unable JJ 42759 4923 18 to to TO 42759 4923 19 pay pay VB 42759 4923 20 living living NN 42759 4923 21 wages wage NNS 42759 4923 22 and and CC 42759 4923 23 at at IN 42759 4923 24 the the DT 42759 4923 25 same same JJ 42759 4923 26 time time NN 42759 4923 27 obtain obtain VB 42759 4923 28 the the DT 42759 4923 29 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 4923 30 rate rate NN 42759 4923 31 of of IN 42759 4923 32 interest interest NN 42759 4923 33 on on IN 42759 4923 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4923 35 capital capital NN 42759 4923 36 . . . 42759 4924 1 The the DT 42759 4924 2 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 4924 3 result result NN 42759 4924 4 , , , 42759 4924 5 therefore therefore RB 42759 4924 6 , , , 42759 4924 7 of of IN 42759 4924 8 the the DT 42759 4924 9 withdrawal withdrawal NN 42759 4924 10 from from IN 42759 4924 11 business business NN 42759 4924 12 of of IN 42759 4924 13 those those DT 42759 4924 14 who who WP 42759 4924 15 could could MD 42759 4924 16 not not RB 42759 4924 17 pay pay VB 42759 4924 18 a a DT 42759 4924 19 living living NN 42759 4924 20 wage wage NN 42759 4924 21 , , , 42759 4924 22 would would MD 42759 4924 23 probably probably RB 42759 4924 24 be be VB 42759 4924 25 the the DT 42759 4924 26 universal universal JJ 42759 4924 27 establishment establishment NN 42759 4924 28 of of IN 42759 4924 29 a a DT 42759 4924 30 living living NN 42759 4924 31 wage wage NN 42759 4924 32 . . . 42759 4925 1 Of of RB 42759 4925 2 course course RB 42759 4925 3 , , , 42759 4925 4 this this DT 42759 4925 5 supposition supposition NN 42759 4925 6 is be VBZ 42759 4925 7 purely purely RB 42759 4925 8 fanciful fanciful JJ 42759 4925 9 . . . 42759 4926 1 Only only RB 42759 4926 2 a a DT 42759 4926 3 small small JJ 42759 4926 4 minority minority NN 42759 4926 5 of of IN 42759 4926 6 the the DT 42759 4926 7 business business NN 42759 4926 8 men man NNS 42759 4926 9 of of IN 42759 4926 10 to to IN 42759 4926 11 - - HYPH 42759 4926 12 day day NN 42759 4926 13 are be VBP 42759 4926 14 likely likely JJ 42759 4926 15 to to TO 42759 4926 16 be be VB 42759 4926 17 driven drive VBN 42759 4926 18 by by IN 42759 4926 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4926 20 consciences conscience NNS 42759 4926 21 either either CC 42759 4926 22 to to TO 42759 4926 23 pay pay VB 42759 4926 24 a a DT 42759 4926 25 living living NN 42759 4926 26 wage wage NN 42759 4926 27 at at IN 42759 4926 28 the the DT 42759 4926 29 cost cost NN 42759 4926 30 of of IN 42759 4926 31 interest interest NN 42759 4926 32 on on IN 42759 4926 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4926 34 capital capital NN 42759 4926 35 , , , 42759 4926 36 or or CC 42759 4926 37 to to TO 42759 4926 38 withdraw withdraw VB 42759 4926 39 from from IN 42759 4926 40 business business NN 42759 4926 41 when when WRB 42759 4926 42 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4926 43 are be VBP 42759 4926 44 confronted confront VBN 42759 4926 45 with with IN 42759 4926 46 such such PDT 42759 4926 47 a a DT 42759 4926 48 situation situation NN 42759 4926 49 . . . 42759 4927 1 Is be VBZ 42759 4927 2 this this DT 42759 4927 3 small small JJ 42759 4927 4 minority minority NN 42759 4927 5 under under IN 42759 4927 6 moral moral JJ 42759 4927 7 obligation obligation NN 42759 4927 8 to to TO 42759 4927 9 adopt adopt VB 42759 4927 10 either either DT 42759 4927 11 of of IN 42759 4927 12 these these DT 42759 4927 13 alternatives alternative NNS 42759 4927 14 , , , 42759 4927 15 when when WRB 42759 4927 16 the the DT 42759 4927 17 effect effect NN 42759 4927 18 of of IN 42759 4927 19 such such JJ 42759 4927 20 action action NN 42759 4927 21 upon upon IN 42759 4927 22 the the DT 42759 4927 23 great great JJ 42759 4927 24 mass mass NN 42759 4927 25 of of IN 42759 4927 26 the the DT 42759 4927 27 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 4927 28 workers worker NNS 42759 4927 29 is be VBZ 42759 4927 30 likely likely JJ 42759 4927 31 to to TO 42759 4927 32 be be VB 42759 4927 33 very very RB 42759 4927 34 slight slight JJ 42759 4927 35 ? ? . 42759 4928 1 The the DT 42759 4928 2 question question NN 42759 4928 3 would would MD 42759 4928 4 seem seem VB 42759 4928 5 to to TO 42759 4928 6 demand demand VB 42759 4928 7 an an DT 42759 4928 8 answer answer NN 42759 4928 9 in in IN 42759 4928 10 the the DT 42759 4928 11 affirmative affirmative NN 42759 4928 12 . . . 42759 4929 1 Those those DT 42759 4929 2 employers employer NNS 42759 4929 3 who who WP 42759 4929 4 paid pay VBD 42759 4929 5 a a DT 42759 4929 6 living living NN 42759 4929 7 wage wage NN 42759 4929 8 at at IN 42759 4929 9 the the DT 42759 4929 10 expense expense NN 42759 4929 11 of of IN 42759 4929 12 interest interest NN 42759 4929 13 would would MD 42759 4929 14 confer confer VB 42759 4929 15 a a DT 42759 4929 16 concrete concrete JJ 42759 4929 17 benefit benefit NN 42759 4929 18 of of IN 42759 4929 19 great great JJ 42759 4929 20 value value NN 42759 4929 21 upon upon IN 42759 4929 22 a a DT 42759 4929 23 group group NN 42759 4929 24 of of IN 42759 4929 25 human human JJ 42759 4929 26 beings being NNS 42759 4929 27 . . . 42759 4930 1 Those those DT 42759 4930 2 who who WP 42759 4930 3 shrank shrink VBD 42759 4930 4 from from IN 42759 4930 5 this this DT 42759 4930 6 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 4930 7 , , , 42759 4930 8 and and CC 42759 4930 9 preferred prefer VBD 42759 4930 10 to to TO 42759 4930 11 go go VB 42759 4930 12 out out IN 42759 4930 13 of of IN 42759 4930 14 business business NN 42759 4930 15 , , , 42759 4930 16 would would MD 42759 4930 17 at at IN 42759 4930 18 least least JJS 42759 4930 19 have have VBP 42759 4930 20 ceased cease VBN 42759 4930 21 to to TO 42759 4930 22 co co VB 42759 4930 23 - - VB 42759 4930 24 operate operate VB 42759 4930 25 in in IN 42759 4930 26 an an DT 42759 4930 27 unjust unjust JJ 42759 4930 28 distribution distribution NN 42759 4930 29 of of IN 42759 4930 30 wealth wealth NN 42759 4930 31 , , , 42759 4930 32 and and CC 42759 4930 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4930 34 example example NN 42759 4930 35 would would MD 42759 4930 36 not not RB 42759 4930 37 be be VB 42759 4930 38 entirely entirely RB 42759 4930 39 without without IN 42759 4930 40 effect effect NN 42759 4930 41 upon upon IN 42759 4930 42 the the DT 42759 4930 43 views view NNS 42759 4930 44 of of IN 42759 4930 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4930 46 fellow fellow JJ 42759 4930 47 employers employer NNS 42759 4930 48 . . . 42759 4931 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4931 2 An an DT 42759 4931 3 Objection Objection NNP 42759 4931 4 and and CC 42759 4931 5 Some some DT 42759 4931 6 Difficulties difficulty NNS 42759 4931 7 _ _ XX 42759 4931 8 Against against IN 42759 4931 9 the the DT 42759 4931 10 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 4931 11 argument argument NN 42759 4931 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4931 13 may may MD 42759 4931 14 be be VB 42759 4931 15 objected object VBN 42759 4931 16 that that IN 42759 4931 17 the the DT 42759 4931 18 employer employer NN 42759 4931 19 does do VBZ 42759 4931 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4931 21 full full JJ 42759 4931 22 duty duty NN 42759 4931 23 when when WRB 42759 4931 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4931 25 pays pay VBZ 42759 4931 26 the the DT 42759 4931 27 labourer labourer NN 42759 4931 28 the the DT 42759 4931 29 full full JJ 42759 4931 30 value value NN 42759 4931 31 of of IN 42759 4931 32 the the DT 42759 4931 33 product product NN 42759 4931 34 or or CC 42759 4931 35 service service NN 42759 4931 36 . . . 42759 4932 1 Labour labour NN 42759 4932 2 is be VBZ 42759 4932 3 a a DT 42759 4932 4 commodity commodity NN 42759 4932 5 of of IN 42759 4932 6 which which WDT 42759 4932 7 wages wage NNS 42759 4932 8 are be VBP 42759 4932 9 the the DT 42759 4932 10 price price NN 42759 4932 11 ; ; : 42759 4932 12 and and CC 42759 4932 13 the the DT 42759 4932 14 price price NN 42759 4932 15 is be VBZ 42759 4932 16 just just RB 42759 4932 17 if if IN 42759 4932 18 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4932 19 is be VBZ 42759 4932 20 the the DT 42759 4932 21 fair fair JJ 42759 4932 22 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4932 23 of of IN 42759 4932 24 the the DT 42759 4932 25 labour labour NN 42759 4932 26 . . . 42759 4933 1 Like like IN 42759 4933 2 any any DT 42759 4933 3 other other JJ 42759 4933 4 onerous onerous JJ 42759 4933 5 contract contract NN 42759 4933 6 , , , 42759 4933 7 the the DT 42759 4933 8 sale sale NN 42759 4933 9 of of IN 42759 4933 10 labour labour NN 42759 4933 11 is be VBZ 42759 4933 12 governed govern VBN 42759 4933 13 by by IN 42759 4933 14 the the DT 42759 4933 15 requirements requirement NNS 42759 4933 16 of of IN 42759 4933 17 commutative commutative JJ 42759 4933 18 justice justice NN 42759 4933 19 ; ; : 42759 4933 20 and and CC 42759 4933 21 these these DT 42759 4933 22 are be VBP 42759 4933 23 satisfied satisfied JJ 42759 4933 24 when when WRB 42759 4933 25 labour labour NN 42759 4933 26 is be VBZ 42759 4933 27 sold sell VBN 42759 4933 28 for for IN 42759 4933 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4933 30 moral moral JJ 42759 4933 31 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4933 32 . . . 42759 4934 1 What what WP 42759 4934 2 the the DT 42759 4934 3 employer employer NN 42759 4934 4 is be VBZ 42759 4934 5 interested interested JJ 42759 4934 6 in in IN 42759 4934 7 and and CC 42759 4934 8 pays pay VBZ 42759 4934 9 for for IN 42759 4934 10 , , , 42759 4934 11 is be VBZ 42759 4934 12 the the DT 42759 4934 13 labourer labourer NN 42759 4934 14 's 's POS 42759 4934 15 activity activity NN 42759 4934 16 . . . 42759 4935 1 There there EX 42759 4935 2 is be VBZ 42759 4935 3 no no DT 42759 4935 4 reason reason NN 42759 4935 5 why why WRB 42759 4935 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4935 7 should should MD 42759 4935 8 take take VB 42759 4935 9 into into IN 42759 4935 10 account account NN 42759 4935 11 such such PDT 42759 4935 12 an an DT 42759 4935 13 extrinsic extrinsic JJ 42759 4935 14 consideration consideration NN 42759 4935 15 as as IN 42759 4935 16 the the DT 42759 4935 17 labourer labourer NN 42759 4935 18 's 's POS 42759 4935 19 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4935 20 . . . 42759 4936 1 Most Most JJS 42759 4936 2 of of IN 42759 4936 3 these these DT 42759 4936 4 assertions assertion NNS 42759 4936 5 are be VBP 42759 4936 6 correct correct JJ 42759 4936 7 , , , 42759 4936 8 platitudinously platitudinously RB 42759 4936 9 correct correct JJ 42759 4936 10 , , , 42759 4936 11 but but CC 42759 4936 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4936 13 yield yield VBP 42759 4936 14 us -PRON- PRP 42759 4936 15 no no DT 42759 4936 16 specific specific JJ 42759 4936 17 guidance guidance NN 42759 4936 18 because because IN 42759 4936 19 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4936 20 use use VBP 42759 4936 21 language language NN 42759 4936 22 vaguely vaguely RB 42759 4936 23 and and CC 42759 4936 24 even even RB 42759 4936 25 ambiguously ambiguously RB 42759 4936 26 . . . 42759 4937 1 The the DT 42759 4937 2 contention contention NN 42759 4937 3 underlying underlie VBG 42759 4937 4 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4937 5 was be VBD 42759 4937 6 adequately adequately RB 42759 4937 7 refuted refute VBN 42759 4937 8 in in IN 42759 4937 9 the the DT 42759 4937 10 last last JJ 42759 4937 11 chapter chapter NN 42759 4937 12 , , , 42759 4937 13 under under IN 42759 4937 14 the the DT 42759 4937 15 heads head NNS 42759 4937 16 of of IN 42759 4937 17 theories theory NNS 42759 4937 18 of of IN 42759 4937 19 value value NN 42759 4937 20 and and CC 42759 4937 21 theories theory NNS 42759 4937 22 of of IN 42759 4937 23 exchange exchange NN 42759 4937 24 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4937 25 . . . 42759 4938 1 At at IN 42759 4938 2 present present NN 42759 4938 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4938 4 will will MD 42759 4938 5 be be VB 42759 4938 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4938 7 to to TO 42759 4938 8 repeat repeat VB 42759 4938 9 summarily summarily RB 42759 4938 10 the the DT 42759 4938 11 following follow VBG 42759 4938 12 points point NNS 42759 4938 13 : : : 42759 4938 14 if if IN 42759 4938 15 the the DT 42759 4938 16 value value NN 42759 4938 17 of of IN 42759 4938 18 labour labour NN 42759 4938 19 is be VBZ 42759 4938 20 to to TO 42759 4938 21 be be VB 42759 4938 22 understood understand VBN 42759 4938 23 in in IN 42759 4938 24 a a DT 42759 4938 25 purely purely RB 42759 4938 26 economic economic JJ 42759 4938 27 sense sense NN 42759 4938 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4938 29 means mean VBZ 42759 4938 30 market market NN 42759 4938 31 value value NN 42759 4938 32 , , , 42759 4938 33 which which WDT 42759 4938 34 is be VBZ 42759 4938 35 obviously obviously RB 42759 4938 36 not not RB 42759 4938 37 a a DT 42759 4938 38 universal universal JJ 42759 4938 39 measure measure NN 42759 4938 40 of of IN 42759 4938 41 justice justice NN 42759 4938 42 ; ; : 42759 4938 43 if if IN 42759 4938 44 by by IN 42759 4938 45 the the DT 42759 4938 46 value value NN 42759 4938 47 of of IN 42759 4938 48 labour labour NN 42759 4938 49 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4938 50 mean mean VBP 42759 4938 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4938 52 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4938 53 value value NN 42759 4938 54 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4938 55 can can MD 42759 4938 56 not not RB 42759 4938 57 determine determine VB 42759 4938 58 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4938 59 in in IN 42759 4938 60 any any DT 42759 4938 61 particular particular JJ 42759 4938 62 case case NN 42759 4938 63 merely merely RB 42759 4938 64 by by IN 42759 4938 65 comparing compare VBG 42759 4938 66 labour labour NN 42759 4938 67 and and CC 42759 4938 68 compensation compensation NN 42759 4938 69 ; ; : 42759 4938 70 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4938 71 are be VBP 42759 4938 72 compelled compel VBN 42759 4938 73 to to TO 42759 4938 74 have have VB 42759 4938 75 recourse recourse VBN 42759 4938 76 to to IN 42759 4938 77 some some DT 42759 4938 78 extrinsic extrinsic JJ 42759 4938 79 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4938 80 principle principle NN 42759 4938 81 ; ; : 42759 4938 82 such such PDT 42759 4938 83 an an DT 42759 4938 84 extrinsic extrinsic JJ 42759 4938 85 principle principle NN 42759 4938 86 is be VBZ 42759 4938 87 found find VBN 42759 4938 88 in in IN 42759 4938 89 the the DT 42759 4938 90 proposition proposition NN 42759 4938 91 that that IN 42759 4938 92 the the DT 42759 4938 93 personal personal JJ 42759 4938 94 dignity dignity NN 42759 4938 95 of of IN 42759 4938 96 the the DT 42759 4938 97 labourer labourer NN 42759 4938 98 entitles entitle VBZ 42759 4938 99 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4938 100 to to IN 42759 4938 101 a a DT 42759 4938 102 wage wage NN 42759 4938 103 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4938 104 to to IN 42759 4938 105 a a DT 42759 4938 106 decent decent JJ 42759 4938 107 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4938 108 ; ; : 42759 4938 109 therefore therefore RB 42759 4938 110 , , , 42759 4938 111 the the DT 42759 4938 112 ethical ethical JJ 42759 4938 113 value value NN 42759 4938 114 of of IN 42759 4938 115 labour labour NN 42759 4938 116 is be VBZ 42759 4938 117 always always RB 42759 4938 118 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 4938 119 to to IN 42759 4938 120 at at IN 42759 4938 121 least least JJS 42759 4938 122 a a DT 42759 4938 123 living living NN 42759 4938 124 wage wage NN 42759 4938 125 , , , 42759 4938 126 and and CC 42759 4938 127 the the DT 42759 4938 128 employer employer NN 42759 4938 129 is be VBZ 42759 4938 130 morally morally RB 42759 4938 131 bound bind VBN 42759 4938 132 to to TO 42759 4938 133 give give VB 42759 4938 134 this this DT 42759 4938 135 much much JJ 42759 4938 136 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 4938 137 . . . 42759 4939 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4939 2 , , , 42759 4939 3 the the DT 42759 4939 4 habit habit NN 42759 4939 5 of of IN 42759 4939 6 looking look VBG 42759 4939 7 at at IN 42759 4939 8 the the DT 42759 4939 9 wage wage NN 42759 4939 10 contract contract NN 42759 4939 11 as as IN 42759 4939 12 a a DT 42759 4939 13 matter matter NN 42759 4939 14 of of IN 42759 4939 15 commutative commutative JJ 42759 4939 16 justice justice NN 42759 4939 17 in in IN 42759 4939 18 the the DT 42759 4939 19 mere mere JJ 42759 4939 20 sense sense NN 42759 4939 21 of of IN 42759 4939 22 contractual contractual JJ 42759 4939 23 justice justice NN 42759 4939 24 , , , 42759 4939 25 is be VBZ 42759 4939 26 radically radically RB 42759 4939 27 defective defective JJ 42759 4939 28 . . . 42759 4940 1 The the DT 42759 4940 2 transaction transaction NN 42759 4940 3 between between IN 42759 4940 4 employé employé NNP 42759 4940 5 and and CC 42759 4940 6 employer employer NN 42759 4940 7 involves involve VBZ 42759 4940 8 other other JJ 42759 4940 9 questions question NNS 42759 4940 10 of of IN 42759 4940 11 justice justice NN 42759 4940 12 than than IN 42759 4940 13 that that DT 42759 4940 14 which which WDT 42759 4940 15 arises arise VBZ 42759 4940 16 immediately immediately RB 42759 4940 17 out out IN 42759 4940 18 of of IN 42759 4940 19 the the DT 42759 4940 20 relation relation NN 42759 4940 21 between between IN 42759 4940 22 the the DT 42759 4940 23 things thing NNS 42759 4940 24 exchanged exchange VBD 42759 4940 25 . . . 42759 4941 1 When when WRB 42759 4941 2 a a DT 42759 4941 3 borrower borrower NN 42759 4941 4 repays repay VBZ 42759 4941 5 a a DT 42759 4941 6 loan loan NN 42759 4941 7 of of IN 42759 4941 8 ten ten CD 42759 4941 9 dollars dollar NNS 42759 4941 10 , , , 42759 4941 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4941 12 fulfils fulfil VBZ 42759 4941 13 the the DT 42759 4941 14 obligation obligation NN 42759 4941 15 of of IN 42759 4941 16 justice justice NN 42759 4941 17 because because IN 42759 4941 18 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4941 19 returns return VBZ 42759 4941 20 the the DT 42759 4941 21 full full JJ 42759 4941 22 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4941 23 of of IN 42759 4941 24 the the DT 42759 4941 25 article article NN 42759 4941 26 that that IN 42759 4941 27 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4941 28 received receive VBD 42759 4941 29 . . . 42759 4942 1 Nothing nothing NN 42759 4942 2 else else RB 42759 4942 3 is be VBZ 42759 4942 4 pertinent pertinent JJ 42759 4942 5 to to IN 42759 4942 6 the the DT 42759 4942 7 question question NN 42759 4942 8 of of IN 42759 4942 9 justice justice NN 42759 4942 10 in in IN 42759 4942 11 this this DT 42759 4942 12 transaction transaction NN 42759 4942 13 . . . 42759 4943 1 Neither neither CC 42759 4943 2 the the DT 42759 4943 3 wealth wealth NN 42759 4943 4 nor nor CC 42759 4943 5 the the DT 42759 4943 6 poverty poverty NN 42759 4943 7 , , , 42759 4943 8 the the DT 42759 4943 9 goodness goodness NN 42759 4943 10 nor nor CC 42759 4943 11 the the DT 42759 4943 12 badness badness NN 42759 4943 13 , , , 42759 4943 14 nor nor CC 42759 4943 15 any any DT 42759 4943 16 other other JJ 42759 4943 17 quality quality NN 42759 4943 18 of of IN 42759 4943 19 either either DT 42759 4943 20 lender lender NN 42759 4943 21 or or CC 42759 4943 22 borrower borrower NN 42759 4943 23 , , , 42759 4943 24 has have VBZ 42759 4943 25 a a DT 42759 4943 26 bearing bearing NN 42759 4943 27 on on IN 42759 4943 28 the the DT 42759 4943 29 justice justice NN 42759 4943 30 of of IN 42759 4943 31 the the DT 42759 4943 32 act act NN 42759 4943 33 of of IN 42759 4943 34 repayment repayment NN 42759 4943 35 . . . 42759 4944 1 In in IN 42759 4944 2 the the DT 42759 4944 3 wage wage NN 42759 4944 4 contract contract NN 42759 4944 5 , , , 42759 4944 6 and and CC 42759 4944 7 in in IN 42759 4944 8 every every DT 42759 4944 9 other other JJ 42759 4944 10 contract contract NN 42759 4944 11 that that WDT 42759 4944 12 involves involve VBZ 42759 4944 13 the the DT 42759 4944 14 distribution distribution NN 42759 4944 15 of of IN 42759 4944 16 the the DT 42759 4944 17 common common JJ 42759 4944 18 bounty bounty NN 42759 4944 19 of of IN 42759 4944 20 nature nature NN 42759 4944 21 , , , 42759 4944 22 or or CC 42759 4944 23 of of IN 42759 4944 24 the the DT 42759 4944 25 social social JJ 42759 4944 26 product product NN 42759 4944 27 , , , 42759 4944 28 the the DT 42759 4944 29 juridical juridical JJ 42759 4944 30 situation situation NN 42759 4944 31 is be VBZ 42759 4944 32 vitally vitally RB 42759 4944 33 different different JJ 42759 4944 34 from from IN 42759 4944 35 the the DT 42759 4944 36 transaction transaction NN 42759 4944 37 that that WDT 42759 4944 38 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4944 39 have have VBP 42759 4944 40 just just RB 42759 4944 41 considered consider VBN 42759 4944 42 . . . 42759 4945 1 The the DT 42759 4945 2 employer employer NN 42759 4945 3 has have VBZ 42759 4945 4 obligations obligation NNS 42759 4945 5 of of IN 42759 4945 6 justice justice NN 42759 4945 7 , , , 42759 4945 8 not not RB 42759 4945 9 merely merely RB 42759 4945 10 as as IN 42759 4945 11 the the DT 42759 4945 12 receiver receiver NN 42759 4945 13 of of IN 42759 4945 14 a a DT 42759 4945 15 valuable valuable JJ 42759 4945 16 thing thing NN 42759 4945 17 through through IN 42759 4945 18 an an DT 42759 4945 19 onerous onerous JJ 42759 4945 20 contract contract NN 42759 4945 21 , , , 42759 4945 22 but but CC 42759 4945 23 as as IN 42759 4945 24 the the DT 42759 4945 25 _ _ NNP 42759 4945 26 distributor distributor NN 42759 4945 27 _ _ NNP 42759 4945 28 of of IN 42759 4945 29 the the DT 42759 4945 30 common common JJ 42759 4945 31 heritage heritage NN 42759 4945 32 of of IN 42759 4945 33 nature nature NN 42759 4945 34 . . . 42759 4946 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4946 2 duty duty NN 42759 4946 3 is be VBZ 42759 4946 4 not not RB 42759 4946 5 merely merely RB 42759 4946 6 contractual contractual JJ 42759 4946 7 , , , 42759 4946 8 but but CC 42759 4946 9 social social JJ 42759 4946 10 . . . 42759 4947 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 4947 2 fulfils fulfil VBZ 42759 4947 3 not not RB 42759 4947 4 only only RB 42759 4947 5 an an DT 42759 4947 6 individual individual JJ 42759 4947 7 contract contract NN 42759 4947 8 , , , 42759 4947 9 but but CC 42759 4947 10 a a DT 42759 4947 11 social social JJ 42759 4947 12 function function NN 42759 4947 13 . . . 42759 4948 1 Unless unless IN 42759 4948 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4948 3 performs perform VBZ 42759 4948 4 this this DT 42759 4948 5 social social JJ 42759 4948 6 and and CC 42759 4948 7 distributive distributive JJ 42759 4948 8 function function NN 42759 4948 9 in in IN 42759 4948 10 accordance accordance NN 42759 4948 11 with with IN 42759 4948 12 justice justice NN 42759 4948 13 , , , 42759 4948 14 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4948 15 does do VBZ 42759 4948 16 not not RB 42759 4948 17 adequately adequately RB 42759 4948 18 discharge discharge VB 42759 4948 19 the the DT 42759 4948 20 obligation obligation NN 42759 4948 21 of of IN 42759 4948 22 the the DT 42759 4948 23 wage wage NN 42759 4948 24 contract contract NN 42759 4948 25 . . . 42759 4949 1 For for IN 42759 4949 2 the the DT 42759 4949 3 product product NN 42759 4949 4 out out IN 42759 4949 5 of of IN 42759 4949 6 which which WDT 42759 4949 7 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4949 8 pays pay VBZ 42759 4949 9 wages wage NNS 42759 4949 10 is be VBZ 42759 4949 11 not not RB 42759 4949 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4949 13 in in IN 42759 4949 14 the the DT 42759 4949 15 same same JJ 42759 4949 16 sense sense NN 42759 4949 17 as as IN 42759 4949 18 the the DT 42759 4949 19 personal personal JJ 42759 4949 20 income income NN 42759 4949 21 out out IN 42759 4949 22 of of IN 42759 4949 23 which which WDT 42759 4949 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4949 25 repays repay VBZ 42759 4949 26 a a DT 42759 4949 27 loan loan NN 42759 4949 28 . . . 42759 4950 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4950 2 claim claim NN 42759 4950 3 upon upon IN 42759 4950 4 the the DT 42759 4950 5 product product NN 42759 4950 6 is be VBZ 42759 4950 7 subject subject JJ 42759 4950 8 to to IN 42759 4950 9 the the DT 42759 4950 10 obligation obligation NN 42759 4950 11 of of IN 42759 4950 12 just just JJ 42759 4950 13 distribution distribution NN 42759 4950 14 ; ; : 42759 4950 15 the the DT 42759 4950 16 obligation obligation NN 42759 4950 17 of of IN 42759 4950 18 so so RB 42759 4950 19 distributing distribute VBG 42759 4950 20 the the DT 42759 4950 21 product product NN 42759 4950 22 that that IN 42759 4950 23 the the DT 42759 4950 24 labourers labourer NNS 42759 4950 25 who who WP 42759 4950 26 have have VBP 42759 4950 27 contributed contribute VBN 42759 4950 28 to to IN 42759 4950 29 the the DT 42759 4950 30 product product NN 42759 4950 31 shall shall MD 42759 4950 32 not not RB 42759 4950 33 be be VB 42759 4950 34 denied deny VBN 42759 4950 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4950 36 right right NN 42759 4950 37 to to IN 42759 4950 38 a a DT 42759 4950 39 decent decent JJ 42759 4950 40 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4950 41 on on IN 42759 4950 42 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4950 43 terms term NNS 42759 4950 44 from from IN 42759 4950 45 the the DT 42759 4950 46 bounty bounty NN 42759 4950 47 of of IN 42759 4950 48 the the DT 42759 4950 49 earth earth NN 42759 4950 50 . . . 42759 4951 1 On on IN 42759 4951 2 the the DT 42759 4951 3 other other JJ 42759 4951 4 hand hand NN 42759 4951 5 , , , 42759 4951 6 the the DT 42759 4951 7 activity activity NN 42759 4951 8 of of IN 42759 4951 9 the the DT 42759 4951 10 labourer labourer NN 42759 4951 11 is be VBZ 42759 4951 12 not not RB 42759 4951 13 a a DT 42759 4951 14 mere mere JJ 42759 4951 15 commodity commodity NN 42759 4951 16 , , , 42759 4951 17 as as IN 42759 4951 18 money money NN 42759 4951 19 or or CC 42759 4951 20 pork pork NN 42759 4951 21 ; ; : 42759 4951 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4951 23 is be VBZ 42759 4951 24 the the DT 42759 4951 25 output output NN 42759 4951 26 of of IN 42759 4951 27 a a DT 42759 4951 28 _ _ NNP 42759 4951 29 person person NN 42759 4951 30 _ _ NNP 42759 4951 31 , , , 42759 4951 32 and and CC 42759 4951 33 a a DT 42759 4951 34 person person NN 42759 4951 35 who who WP 42759 4951 36 has have VBZ 42759 4951 37 no no DT 42759 4951 38 other other JJ 42759 4951 39 means mean NNS 42759 4951 40 of of IN 42759 4951 41 realising realise VBG 42759 4951 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4951 43 inherent inherent JJ 42759 4951 44 right right NN 42759 4951 45 to to IN 42759 4951 46 a a DT 42759 4951 47 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4951 48 . . . 42759 4952 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 4952 2 , , , 42759 4952 3 both both DT 42759 4952 4 terms term NNS 42759 4952 5 of of IN 42759 4952 6 the the DT 42759 4952 7 contract contract NN 42759 4952 8 , , , 42759 4952 9 the the DT 42759 4952 10 labour labour NN 42759 4952 11 and and CC 42759 4952 12 the the DT 42759 4952 13 compensation compensation NN 42759 4952 14 , , , 42759 4952 15 involve involve VBP 42759 4952 16 other other JJ 42759 4952 17 elements element NNS 42759 4952 18 of of IN 42759 4952 19 justice justice NN 42759 4952 20 than than IN 42759 4952 21 that that DT 42759 4952 22 which which WDT 42759 4952 23 arises arise VBZ 42759 4952 24 out out IN 42759 4952 25 of of IN 42759 4952 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4952 27 assumed assume VBN 42759 4952 28 mutual mutual JJ 42759 4952 29 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4952 30 . . . 42759 4953 1 In in IN 42759 4953 2 a a DT 42759 4953 3 word word NN 42759 4953 4 , , , 42759 4953 5 justice justice NN 42759 4953 6 requires require VBZ 42759 4953 7 the the DT 42759 4953 8 employer employer NN 42759 4953 9 not not RB 42759 4953 10 merely merely RB 42759 4953 11 to to TO 42759 4953 12 give give VB 42759 4953 13 an an DT 42759 4953 14 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 4953 15 for for IN 42759 4953 16 labour labour NN 42759 4953 17 ( ( -LRB- 42759 4953 18 an an DT 42759 4953 19 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 4953 20 which which WDT 42759 4953 21 is be VBZ 42759 4953 22 determined determine VBN 42759 4953 23 by by IN 42759 4953 24 some some DT 42759 4953 25 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 42759 4953 26 , , , 42759 4953 27 conventional conventional JJ 42759 4953 28 , , , 42759 4953 29 fantastic fantastic JJ 42759 4953 30 , , , 42759 4953 31 or or CC 42759 4953 32 impossible impossible JJ 42759 4953 33 attempt attempt NN 42759 4953 34 to to TO 42759 4953 35 compare compare VB 42759 4953 36 work work NN 42759 4953 37 and and CC 42759 4953 38 pay pay VB 42759 4953 39 ) ) -RRB- 42759 4953 40 but but CC 42759 4953 41 to to TO 42759 4953 42 fulfil fulfil VB 42759 4953 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4953 44 obligation obligation NN 42759 4953 45 of of IN 42759 4953 46 justly justly RB 42759 4953 47 distributing distribute VBG 42759 4953 48 that that DT 42759 4953 49 part part NN 42759 4953 50 of of IN 42759 4953 51 the the DT 42759 4953 52 common common JJ 42759 4953 53 bounty bounty NN 42759 4953 54 of of IN 42759 4953 55 the the DT 42759 4953 56 earth earth NN 42759 4953 57 which which WDT 42759 4953 58 comes come VBZ 42759 4953 59 into into IN 42759 4953 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4953 61 hands hand NNS 42759 4953 62 by by IN 42759 4953 63 virtue virtue NN 42759 4953 64 of of IN 42759 4953 65 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4953 66 social social JJ 42759 4953 67 function function NN 42759 4953 68 in in IN 42759 4953 69 the the DT 42759 4953 70 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4953 71 process process NN 42759 4953 72 . . . 42759 4954 1 How how WRB 42759 4954 2 futile futile JJ 42759 4954 3 , , , 42759 4954 4 then then RB 42759 4954 5 , , , 42759 4954 6 to to TO 42759 4954 7 endeavour endeavour VB 42759 4954 8 by by IN 42759 4954 9 word word NN 42759 4954 10 juggling juggling NN 42759 4954 11 to to TO 42759 4954 12 describe describe VB 42759 4954 13 the the DT 42759 4954 14 employer employer NN 42759 4954 15 's 's POS 42759 4954 16 obligation obligation NN 42759 4954 17 in in IN 42759 4954 18 terms term NNS 42759 4954 19 of of IN 42759 4954 20 mere mere JJ 42759 4954 21 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 4954 22 and and CC 42759 4954 23 contractual contractual JJ 42759 4954 24 justice justice NN 42759 4954 25 ! ! . 42759 4955 1 Some some DT 42759 4955 2 difficulties difficulty NNS 42759 4955 3 occur occur VBP 42759 4955 4 in in IN 42759 4955 5 connection connection NN 42759 4955 6 with with IN 42759 4955 7 the the DT 42759 4955 8 wage wage NN 42759 4955 9 rights right NNS 42759 4955 10 of of IN 42759 4955 11 adult adult NN 42759 4955 12 males male NNS 42759 4955 13 whose whose WP$ 42759 4955 14 ability ability NN 42759 4955 15 is be VBZ 42759 4955 16 below below IN 42759 4955 17 the the DT 42759 4955 18 average average NN 42759 4955 19 , , , 42759 4955 20 and and CC 42759 4955 21 female female JJ 42759 4955 22 and and CC 42759 4955 23 child child NN 42759 4955 24 workers worker NNS 42759 4955 25 . . . 42759 4956 1 Since since IN 42759 4956 2 the the DT 42759 4956 3 dignity dignity NN 42759 4956 4 and and CC 42759 4956 5 the the DT 42759 4956 6 needs need NNS 42759 4956 7 of of IN 42759 4956 8 personality personality NN 42759 4956 9 constitute constitute VB 42759 4956 10 the the DT 42759 4956 11 moral moral JJ 42759 4956 12 basis basis NN 42759 4956 13 of of IN 42759 4956 14 the the DT 42759 4956 15 claim claim NN 42759 4956 16 to to IN 42759 4956 17 a a DT 42759 4956 18 decent decent JJ 42759 4956 19 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4956 20 , , , 42759 4956 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4956 22 would would MD 42759 4956 23 seem seem VB 42759 4956 24 that that IN 42759 4956 25 the the DT 42759 4956 26 inefficient inefficient JJ 42759 4956 27 worker worker NN 42759 4956 28 who who WP 42759 4956 29 does do VBZ 42759 4956 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4956 31 best good JJS 42759 4956 32 is be VBZ 42759 4956 33 entitled entitle VBN 42759 4956 34 to to IN 42759 4956 35 a a DT 42759 4956 36 living living NN 42759 4956 37 wage wage NN 42759 4956 38 . . . 42759 4957 1 Undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 4957 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4957 3 has have VBZ 42759 4957 4 such such PDT 42759 4957 5 a a DT 42759 4957 6 right right NN 42759 4957 7 if if IN 42759 4957 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4957 9 can can MD 42759 4957 10 be be VB 42759 4957 11 effectuated effectuate VBN 42759 4957 12 in in IN 42759 4957 13 the the DT 42759 4957 14 existing exist VBG 42759 4957 15 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4957 16 organisation organisation NN 42759 4957 17 . . . 42759 4958 1 As as IN 42759 4958 2 already already RB 42759 4958 3 noted note VBN 42759 4958 4 , , , 42759 4958 5 the the DT 42759 4958 6 right right NN 42759 4958 7 of of IN 42759 4958 8 the the DT 42759 4958 9 workman workman NN 42759 4958 10 of of IN 42759 4958 11 average average JJ 42759 4958 12 ability ability NN 42759 4958 13 to to IN 42759 4958 14 a a DT 42759 4958 15 living living NN 42759 4958 16 wage wage NN 42759 4958 17 does do VBZ 42759 4958 18 not not RB 42759 4958 19 become become VB 42759 4958 20 actual actual JJ 42759 4958 21 until until IN 42759 4958 22 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4958 23 finds find VBZ 42759 4958 24 an an DT 42759 4958 25 employer employer NN 42759 4958 26 who who WP 42759 4958 27 would would MD 42759 4958 28 rather rather RB 42759 4958 29 give give VB 42759 4958 30 him -PRON- PRP 42759 4958 31 that that IN 42759 4958 32 much much JJ 42759 4958 33 pay pay NN 42759 4958 34 than than IN 42759 4958 35 do do VB 42759 4958 36 without without IN 42759 4958 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4958 38 services service NNS 42759 4958 39 . . . 42759 4959 1 Since since IN 42759 4959 2 the the DT 42759 4959 3 obligation obligation NN 42759 4959 4 of of IN 42759 4959 5 paying pay VBG 42759 4959 6 a a DT 42759 4959 7 living live VBG 42759 4959 8 wage wage NN 42759 4959 9 is be VBZ 42759 4959 10 not not RB 42759 4959 11 an an DT 42759 4959 12 obligation obligation NN 42759 4959 13 to to TO 42759 4959 14 employ employ VB 42759 4959 15 any any DT 42759 4959 16 particular particular JJ 42759 4959 17 worker worker NN 42759 4959 18 , , , 42759 4959 19 an an DT 42759 4959 20 employer employer NN 42759 4959 21 may may MD 42759 4959 22 refrain refrain VB 42759 4959 23 from from IN 42759 4959 24 hiring hire VBG 42759 4959 25 or or CC 42759 4959 26 may may MD 42759 4959 27 discharge discharge VB 42759 4959 28 any any DT 42759 4959 29 labourer labourer NN 42759 4959 30 who who WP 42759 4959 31 does do VBZ 42759 4959 32 not not RB 42759 4959 33 add add VB 42759 4959 34 to to IN 42759 4959 35 the the DT 42759 4959 36 product product NN 42759 4959 37 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4959 38 value value NN 42759 4959 39 to to TO 42759 4959 40 provide provide VB 42759 4959 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4959 42 wages wage NNS 42759 4959 43 . . . 42759 4960 1 For for IN 42759 4960 2 the the DT 42759 4960 3 employer employer NN 42759 4960 4 can can MD 42759 4960 5 not not RB 42759 4960 6 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 4960 7 be be VB 42759 4960 8 expected expect VBN 42759 4960 9 to to TO 42759 4960 10 employ employ VB 42759 4960 11 any any DT 42759 4960 12 one one CD 42759 4960 13 at at IN 42759 4960 14 a a DT 42759 4960 15 positive positive JJ 42759 4960 16 loss loss NN 42759 4960 17 to to IN 42759 4960 18 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4960 19 . . . 42759 4961 1 Whence whence IN 42759 4961 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4961 3 follows follow VBZ 42759 4961 4 that that IN 42759 4961 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4961 6 may may MD 42759 4961 7 pay pay VB 42759 4961 8 less less JJR 42759 4961 9 than than IN 42759 4961 10 living live VBG 42759 4961 11 wages wage NNS 42759 4961 12 to to IN 42759 4961 13 any any DT 42759 4961 14 worker worker NN 42759 4961 15 whose whose WP$ 42759 4961 16 services service NNS 42759 4961 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4961 18 would would MD 42759 4961 19 rather rather RB 42759 4961 20 dispense dispense VB 42759 4961 21 with with IN 42759 4961 22 than than IN 42759 4961 23 remunerate remunerate VB 42759 4961 24 at at IN 42759 4961 25 that that DT 42759 4961 26 figure figure NN 42759 4961 27 . . . 42759 4962 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 4962 2 245 245 CD 42759 4962 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 4962 4 Women woman NNS 42759 4962 5 and and CC 42759 4962 6 young young JJ 42759 4962 7 persons person NNS 42759 4962 8 who who WP 42759 4962 9 regularly regularly RB 42759 4962 10 perform perform VBP 42759 4962 11 a a DT 42759 4962 12 full full JJ 42759 4962 13 day day NN 42759 4962 14 's 's POS 42759 4962 15 work work NN 42759 4962 16 , , , 42759 4962 17 have have VBP 42759 4962 18 a a DT 42759 4962 19 right right NN 42759 4962 20 to to IN 42759 4962 21 compensation compensation NN 42759 4962 22 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4962 23 to to IN 42759 4962 24 a a DT 42759 4962 25 decent decent JJ 42759 4962 26 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4962 27 . . . 42759 4963 1 In in IN 42759 4963 2 the the DT 42759 4963 3 case case NN 42759 4963 4 of of IN 42759 4963 5 minors minor NNS 42759 4963 6 , , , 42759 4963 7 this this DT 42759 4963 8 means mean VBZ 42759 4963 9 living live VBG 42759 4963 10 at at IN 42759 4963 11 home home NN 42759 4963 12 , , , 42759 4963 13 since since IN 42759 4963 14 this this DT 42759 4963 15 is be VBZ 42759 4963 16 the the DT 42759 4963 17 normal normal JJ 42759 4963 18 condition condition NN 42759 4963 19 of of IN 42759 4963 20 all all DT 42759 4963 21 , , , 42759 4963 22 and and CC 42759 4963 23 the the DT 42759 4963 24 actual actual JJ 42759 4963 25 condition condition NN 42759 4963 26 of of IN 42759 4963 27 almost almost RB 42759 4963 28 all all DT 42759 4963 29 . . . 42759 4964 1 Adult adult JJ 42759 4964 2 females female NNS 42759 4964 3 have have VBP 42759 4964 4 a a DT 42759 4964 5 right right NN 42759 4964 6 to to IN 42759 4964 7 a a DT 42759 4964 8 wage wage NN 42759 4964 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4964 10 to to TO 42759 4964 11 maintain maintain VB 42759 4964 12 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4964 13 away away RB 42759 4964 14 from from IN 42759 4964 15 home home NN 42759 4964 16 , , , 42759 4964 17 because because IN 42759 4964 18 a a DT 42759 4964 19 considerable considerable JJ 42759 4964 20 proportion proportion NN 42759 4964 21 of of IN 42759 4964 22 them -PRON- PRP 42759 4964 23 live live VBP 42759 4964 24 in in IN 42759 4964 25 this this DT 42759 4964 26 condition condition NN 42759 4964 27 . . . 42759 4965 1 If if IN 42759 4965 2 employers employer NNS 42759 4965 3 were be VBD 42759 4965 4 morally morally RB 42759 4965 5 free free JJ 42759 4965 6 to to TO 42759 4965 7 pay pay VB 42759 4965 8 home home NN 42759 4965 9 - - HYPH 42759 4965 10 dwelling dwell VBG 42759 4965 11 women woman NNS 42759 4965 12 less less JJR 42759 4965 13 than than IN 42759 4965 14 those those DT 42759 4965 15 adrift adrift JJ 42759 4965 16 , , , 42759 4965 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4965 18 would would MD 42759 4965 19 endeavour endeavour VB 42759 4965 20 to to TO 42759 4965 21 employ employ VB 42759 4965 22 only only RB 42759 4965 23 the the DT 42759 4965 24 former former JJ 42759 4965 25 . . . 42759 4966 1 This this DT 42759 4966 2 would would MD 42759 4966 3 create create VB 42759 4966 4 a a DT 42759 4966 5 very very RB 42759 4966 6 undesirable undesirable JJ 42759 4966 7 social social JJ 42759 4966 8 situation situation NN 42759 4966 9 . . . 42759 4967 1 The the DT 42759 4967 2 number number NN 42759 4967 3 of of IN 42759 4967 4 women woman NNS 42759 4967 5 away away RB 42759 4967 6 from from IN 42759 4967 7 home home NN 42759 4967 8 who who WP 42759 4967 9 are be VBP 42759 4967 10 forced force VBN 42759 4967 11 to to TO 42759 4967 12 earn earn VB 42759 4967 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4967 14 own own JJ 42759 4967 15 living living NN 42759 4967 16 is be VBZ 42759 4967 17 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 4967 18 large large JJ 42759 4967 19 ( ( -LRB- 42759 4967 20 20 20 CD 42759 4967 21 to to TO 42759 4967 22 25 25 CD 42759 4967 23 per per NN 42759 4967 24 cent cent NN 42759 4967 25 . . . 42759 4968 1 of of IN 42759 4968 2 the the DT 42759 4968 3 whole whole NN 42759 4968 4 ) ) -RRB- 42759 4968 5 to to TO 42759 4968 6 make make VB 42759 4968 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4968 8 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4968 9 that that IN 42759 4968 10 for for IN 42759 4968 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4968 12 sakes sake NNS 42759 4968 13 the the DT 42759 4968 14 wage wage NN 42759 4968 15 of of IN 42759 4968 16 all all DT 42759 4968 17 working work VBG 42759 4968 18 women woman NNS 42759 4968 19 should should MD 42759 4968 20 be be VB 42759 4968 21 determined determine VBN 42759 4968 22 by by IN 42759 4968 23 the the DT 42759 4968 24 cost cost NN 42759 4968 25 of of IN 42759 4968 26 living live VBG 42759 4968 27 outside outside IN 42759 4968 28 the the DT 42759 4968 29 parental parental JJ 42759 4968 30 precincts precinct NNS 42759 4968 31 . . . 42759 4969 1 This this DT 42759 4969 2 is be VBZ 42759 4969 3 one one CD 42759 4969 4 of of IN 42759 4969 5 the the DT 42759 4969 6 social social JJ 42759 4969 7 obligations obligation NNS 42759 4969 8 that that WDT 42759 4969 9 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 4969 10 falls fall VBZ 42759 4969 11 upon upon IN 42759 4969 12 the the DT 42759 4969 13 employer employer NN 42759 4969 14 on on IN 42759 4969 15 account account NN 42759 4969 16 of of IN 42759 4969 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4969 18 function function NN 42759 4969 19 in in IN 42759 4969 20 the the DT 42759 4969 21 present present JJ 42759 4969 22 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4969 23 system system NN 42759 4969 24 . . . 42759 4970 1 In in IN 42759 4970 2 all all PDT 42759 4970 3 the the DT 42759 4970 4 American american JJ 42759 4970 5 minimum minimum JJ 42759 4970 6 wage wage NN 42759 4970 7 laws law NNS 42759 4970 8 , , , 42759 4970 9 the the DT 42759 4970 10 standard standard NN 42759 4970 11 of of IN 42759 4970 12 payment payment NN 42759 4970 13 is be VBZ 42759 4970 14 determined determine VBN 42759 4970 15 by by IN 42759 4970 16 the the DT 42759 4970 17 cost cost NN 42759 4970 18 of of IN 42759 4970 19 living live VBG 42759 4970 20 away away RB 42759 4970 21 from from IN 42759 4970 22 home home NN 42759 4970 23 . . . 42759 4971 1 Besides besides RB 42759 4971 2 , , , 42759 4971 3 the the DT 42759 4971 4 difference difference NN 42759 4971 5 between between IN 42759 4971 6 the the DT 42759 4971 7 living live VBG 42759 4971 8 costs cost NNS 42759 4971 9 of of IN 42759 4971 10 women woman NNS 42759 4971 11 in in IN 42759 4971 12 the the DT 42759 4971 13 two two CD 42759 4971 14 conditions condition NNS 42759 4971 15 is be VBZ 42759 4971 16 not not RB 42759 4971 17 nearly nearly RB 42759 4971 18 as as RB 42759 4971 19 great great JJ 42759 4971 20 as as IN 42759 4971 21 is be VBZ 42759 4971 22 commonly commonly RB 42759 4971 23 assumed assume VBN 42759 4971 24 . . . 42759 4972 1 Probably probably RB 42759 4972 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4972 3 never never RB 42759 4972 4 amounts amount VBZ 42759 4972 5 to to IN 42759 4972 6 a a DT 42759 4972 7 dollar dollar NN 42759 4972 8 a a DT 42759 4972 9 week week NN 42759 4972 10 . . . 42759 4973 1 _ _ NNP 42759 4973 2 The the DT 42759 4973 3 Family Family NNP 42759 4973 4 Living live VBG 42759 4973 5 Wage Wage NNP 42759 4973 6 _ _ NNP 42759 4973 7 Up up IN 42759 4973 8 to to IN 42759 4973 9 the the DT 42759 4973 10 present present NN 42759 4973 11 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4973 12 have have VBP 42759 4973 13 been be VBN 42759 4973 14 considering consider VBG 42759 4973 15 the the DT 42759 4973 16 right right NN 42759 4973 17 of of IN 42759 4973 18 the the DT 42759 4973 19 labourer labourer NN 42759 4973 20 to to IN 42759 4973 21 a a DT 42759 4973 22 wage wage NN 42759 4973 23 adequate adequate JJ 42759 4973 24 to to IN 42759 4973 25 a a DT 42759 4973 26 decent decent JJ 42759 4973 27 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4973 28 for for IN 42759 4973 29 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4973 30 as as IN 42759 4973 31 an an DT 42759 4973 32 individual individual NN 42759 4973 33 . . . 42759 4974 1 In in IN 42759 4974 2 the the DT 42759 4974 3 case case NN 42759 4974 4 of of IN 42759 4974 5 an an DT 42759 4974 6 adult adult NN 42759 4974 7 male male NN 42759 4974 8 , , , 42759 4974 9 however however RB 42759 4974 10 , , , 42759 4974 11 this this DT 42759 4974 12 is be VBZ 42759 4974 13 not not RB 42759 4974 14 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4974 15 for for IN 42759 4974 16 normal normal JJ 42759 4974 17 life life NN 42759 4974 18 , , , 42759 4974 19 nor nor CC 42759 4974 20 for for IN 42759 4974 21 the the DT 42759 4974 22 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4974 23 development development NN 42759 4974 24 of of IN 42759 4974 25 personality personality NN 42759 4974 26 . . . 42759 4975 1 The the DT 42759 4975 2 great great JJ 42759 4975 3 majority majority NN 42759 4975 4 of of IN 42759 4975 5 men man NNS 42759 4975 6 can can MD 42759 4975 7 not not RB 42759 4975 8 live live VB 42759 4975 9 well well RB 42759 4975 10 balanced balanced JJ 42759 4975 11 lives life NNS 42759 4975 12 , , , 42759 4975 13 can can MD 42759 4975 14 not not RB 42759 4975 15 attain attain VB 42759 4975 16 a a DT 42759 4975 17 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4975 18 degree degree NN 42759 4975 19 of of IN 42759 4975 20 self self NN 42759 4975 21 development development NN 42759 4975 22 outside outside IN 42759 4975 23 the the DT 42759 4975 24 married married JJ 42759 4975 25 state state NN 42759 4975 26 . . . 42759 4976 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 4976 2 , , , 42759 4976 3 family family NN 42759 4976 4 life life NN 42759 4976 5 is be VBZ 42759 4976 6 among among IN 42759 4976 7 the the DT 42759 4976 8 essential essential JJ 42759 4976 9 needs need NNS 42759 4976 10 of of IN 42759 4976 11 a a DT 42759 4976 12 normal normal JJ 42759 4976 13 and and CC 42759 4976 14 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4976 15 existence existence NN 42759 4976 16 . . . 42759 4977 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4977 2 is be VBZ 42759 4977 3 not not RB 42759 4977 4 , , , 42759 4977 5 indeed indeed RB 42759 4977 6 , , , 42759 4977 7 so so RB 42759 4977 8 vitally vitally RB 42759 4977 9 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4977 10 as as IN 42759 4977 11 the the DT 42759 4977 12 primary primary JJ 42759 4977 13 requisites requisite NNS 42759 4977 14 of of IN 42759 4977 15 individual individual JJ 42759 4977 16 life life NN 42759 4977 17 , , , 42759 4977 18 such such JJ 42759 4977 19 as as IN 42759 4977 20 food food NN 42759 4977 21 , , , 42759 4977 22 clothing clothing NN 42759 4977 23 , , , 42759 4977 24 and and CC 42759 4977 25 shelter shelter NN 42759 4977 26 , , , 42759 4977 27 but but CC 42759 4977 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4977 29 is be VBZ 42759 4977 30 second second JJ 42759 4977 31 only only RB 42759 4977 32 to to IN 42759 4977 33 these these DT 42759 4977 34 . . . 42759 4978 1 Outside outside IN 42759 4978 2 the the DT 42759 4978 3 family family NN 42759 4978 4 man man NN 42759 4978 5 can can MD 42759 4978 6 not not RB 42759 4978 7 , , , 42759 4978 8 as as IN 42759 4978 9 a a DT 42759 4978 10 rule rule NN 42759 4978 11 , , , 42759 4978 12 command command NN 42759 4978 13 that that DT 42759 4978 14 degree degree NN 42759 4978 15 of of IN 42759 4978 16 contentment contentment NN 42759 4978 17 , , , 42759 4978 18 moral moral JJ 42759 4978 19 strength strength NN 42759 4978 20 , , , 42759 4978 21 and and CC 42759 4978 22 moral moral JJ 42759 4978 23 safety safety NN 42759 4978 24 which which WDT 42759 4978 25 are be VBP 42759 4978 26 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4978 27 for for IN 42759 4978 28 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4978 29 and and CC 42759 4978 30 efficient efficient JJ 42759 4978 31 living living NN 42759 4978 32 . . . 42759 4979 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4979 2 is be VBZ 42759 4979 3 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 4979 4 to to TO 42759 4979 5 labour labour NN 42759 4979 6 this this DT 42759 4979 7 point point NN 42759 4979 8 further far RBR 42759 4979 9 , , , 42759 4979 10 as as IN 42759 4979 11 very very RB 42759 4979 12 few few JJ 42759 4979 13 would would MD 42759 4979 14 assert assert VB 42759 4979 15 that that IN 42759 4979 16 the the DT 42759 4979 17 average average JJ 42759 4979 18 man man NN 42759 4979 19 can can MD 42759 4979 20 live live VB 42759 4979 21 a a DT 42759 4979 22 normal normal JJ 42759 4979 23 and and CC 42759 4979 24 complete complete JJ 42759 4979 25 human human JJ 42759 4979 26 life life NN 42759 4979 27 without without IN 42759 4979 28 marriage marriage NN 42759 4979 29 . . . 42759 4980 1 Now now RB 42759 4980 2 , , , 42759 4980 3 the the DT 42759 4980 4 support support NN 42759 4980 5 of of IN 42759 4980 6 the the DT 42759 4980 7 family family NN 42759 4980 8 falls fall VBZ 42759 4980 9 properly properly RB 42759 4980 10 upon upon IN 42759 4980 11 the the DT 42759 4980 12 husband husband NN 42759 4980 13 and and CC 42759 4980 14 father father NN 42759 4980 15 , , , 42759 4980 16 not not RB 42759 4980 17 upon upon IN 42759 4980 18 the the DT 42759 4980 19 wife wife NN 42759 4980 20 and and CC 42759 4980 21 mother mother NN 42759 4980 22 . . . 42759 4981 1 The the DT 42759 4981 2 obligation obligation NN 42759 4981 3 of of IN 42759 4981 4 the the DT 42759 4981 5 father father NN 42759 4981 6 to to TO 42759 4981 7 provide provide VB 42759 4981 8 a a DT 42759 4981 9 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4981 10 for for IN 42759 4981 11 the the DT 42759 4981 12 wife wife NN 42759 4981 13 and and CC 42759 4981 14 young young JJ 42759 4981 15 children child NNS 42759 4981 16 is be VBZ 42759 4981 17 quite quite RB 42759 4981 18 as as RB 42759 4981 19 definite definite JJ 42759 4981 20 as as IN 42759 4981 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4981 22 obligation obligation NN 42759 4981 23 to to TO 42759 4981 24 maintain maintain VB 42759 4981 25 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 4981 26 . . . 42759 4982 1 If if IN 42759 4982 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4982 3 has have VBZ 42759 4982 4 not not RB 42759 4982 5 the the DT 42759 4982 6 means mean NNS 42759 4982 7 to to TO 42759 4982 8 discharge discharge VB 42759 4982 9 this this DT 42759 4982 10 obligation obligation NN 42759 4982 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4982 12 is be VBZ 42759 4982 13 not not RB 42759 4982 14 justified justify VBN 42759 4982 15 in in IN 42759 4982 16 getting get VBG 42759 4982 17 married marry VBN 42759 4982 18 . . . 42759 4983 1 Yet yet RB 42759 4983 2 , , , 42759 4983 3 as as IN 42759 4983 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 4983 5 have have VBP 42759 4983 6 just just RB 42759 4983 7 seen see VBN 42759 4983 8 , , , 42759 4983 9 marriage marriage NN 42759 4983 10 is be VBZ 42759 4983 11 essential essential JJ 42759 4983 12 to to IN 42759 4983 13 normal normal JJ 42759 4983 14 life life NN 42759 4983 15 for for IN 42759 4983 16 the the DT 42759 4983 17 great great JJ 42759 4983 18 majority majority NN 42759 4983 19 of of IN 42759 4983 20 men man NNS 42759 4983 21 . . . 42759 4984 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 4984 2 , , , 42759 4984 3 the the DT 42759 4984 4 material material NN 42759 4984 5 requisites requisite NNS 42759 4984 6 of of IN 42759 4984 7 normal normal JJ 42759 4984 8 life life NN 42759 4984 9 for for IN 42759 4984 10 the the DT 42759 4984 11 average average JJ 42759 4984 12 adult adult NN 42759 4984 13 male male NN 42759 4984 14 , , , 42759 4984 15 include include VBP 42759 4984 16 provision provision NN 42759 4984 17 for for IN 42759 4984 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4984 19 family family NN 42759 4984 20 . . . 42759 4985 1 In in IN 42759 4985 2 other other JJ 42759 4985 3 words word NNS 42759 4985 4 , , , 42759 4985 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4985 6 decent decent JJ 42759 4985 7 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4985 8 means mean VBZ 42759 4985 9 a a DT 42759 4985 10 family family NN 42759 4985 11 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4985 12 . . . 42759 4986 1 Consequently consequently RB 42759 4986 2 , , , 42759 4986 3 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4986 4 has have VBZ 42759 4986 5 a a DT 42759 4986 6 right right NN 42759 4986 7 to to TO 42759 4986 8 obtain obtain VB 42759 4986 9 such such PDT 42759 4986 10 a a DT 42759 4986 11 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 4986 12 on on IN 42759 4986 13 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4986 14 terms term NNS 42759 4986 15 from from IN 42759 4986 16 the the DT 42759 4986 17 bounty bounty NN 42759 4986 18 of of IN 42759 4986 19 the the DT 42759 4986 20 earth earth NN 42759 4986 21 . . . 42759 4987 1 In in IN 42759 4987 2 the the DT 42759 4987 3 case case NN 42759 4987 4 of of IN 42759 4987 5 the the DT 42759 4987 6 wage wage NN 42759 4987 7 earner earner NN 42759 4987 8 , , , 42759 4987 9 this this DT 42759 4987 10 right right NN 42759 4987 11 can can MD 42759 4987 12 be be VB 42759 4987 13 effectuated effectuate VBN 42759 4987 14 only only RB 42759 4987 15 through through IN 42759 4987 16 wages wage NNS 42759 4987 17 ; ; : 42759 4987 18 therefore therefore RB 42759 4987 19 , , , 42759 4987 20 the the DT 42759 4987 21 adult adult NN 42759 4987 22 male male JJ 42759 4987 23 labourer labourer NN 42759 4987 24 has have VBZ 42759 4987 25 a a DT 42759 4987 26 right right NN 42759 4987 27 to to IN 42759 4987 28 a a DT 42759 4987 29 family family NN 42759 4987 30 living living NN 42759 4987 31 wage wage NN 42759 4987 32 . . . 42759 4988 1 If if IN 42759 4988 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4988 3 does do VBZ 42759 4988 4 not not RB 42759 4988 5 get get VB 42759 4988 6 this this DT 42759 4988 7 measure measure NN 42759 4988 8 of of IN 42759 4988 9 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 4988 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4988 11 personal personal JJ 42759 4988 12 dignity dignity NN 42759 4988 13 is be VBZ 42759 4988 14 violated violate VBN 42759 4988 15 , , , 42759 4988 16 and and CC 42759 4988 17 he -PRON- PRP 42759 4988 18 is be VBZ 42759 4988 19 deprived deprive VBN 42759 4988 20 of of IN 42759 4988 21 access access NN 42759 4988 22 to to IN 42759 4988 23 the the DT 42759 4988 24 goods good NNS 42759 4988 25 of of IN 42759 4988 26 the the DT 42759 4988 27 earth earth NN 42759 4988 28 , , , 42759 4988 29 quite quite RB 42759 4988 30 as as RB 42759 4988 31 certainly certainly RB 42759 4988 32 as as IN 42759 4988 33 when when WRB 42759 4988 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4988 35 wage wage NN 42759 4988 36 is be VBZ 42759 4988 37 inadequate inadequate JJ 42759 4988 38 to to IN 42759 4988 39 personal personal JJ 42759 4988 40 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 4988 41 . . . 42759 4989 1 The the DT 42759 4989 2 difference difference NN 42759 4989 3 between between IN 42759 4989 4 family family NN 42759 4989 5 needs need NNS 42759 4989 6 and and CC 42759 4989 7 personal personal JJ 42759 4989 8 needs need NNS 42759 4989 9 is be VBZ 42759 4989 10 a a DT 42759 4989 11 difference difference NN 42759 4989 12 only only RB 42759 4989 13 of of IN 42759 4989 14 degree degree NN 42759 4989 15 . . . 42759 4990 1 The the DT 42759 4990 2 satisfaction satisfaction NN 42759 4990 3 of of IN 42759 4990 4 both both DT 42759 4990 5 is be VBZ 42759 4990 6 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 4990 7 to to IN 42759 4990 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4990 9 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4990 10 life life NN 42759 4990 11 . . . 42759 4991 1 Just just RB 42759 4991 2 as as IN 42759 4991 3 the the DT 42759 4991 4 woman woman NN 42759 4991 5 worker worker NN 42759 4991 6 who who WP 42759 4991 7 lives live VBZ 42759 4991 8 with with IN 42759 4991 9 her -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4991 10 parents parent NNS 42759 4991 11 has have VBZ 42759 4991 12 a a DT 42759 4991 13 right right NN 42759 4991 14 to to IN 42759 4991 15 a a DT 42759 4991 16 wage wage NN 42759 4991 17 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4991 18 to to TO 42759 4991 19 maintain maintain VB 42759 4991 20 her -PRON- PRP 42759 4991 21 away away RB 42759 4991 22 from from IN 42759 4991 23 home home NN 42759 4991 24 , , , 42759 4991 25 so so CC 42759 4991 26 the the DT 42759 4991 27 unmarried unmarried JJ 42759 4991 28 adult adult NN 42759 4991 29 male male NN 42759 4991 30 has have VBZ 42759 4991 31 a a DT 42759 4991 32 right right NN 42759 4991 33 to to IN 42759 4991 34 a a DT 42759 4991 35 family family NN 42759 4991 36 living living NN 42759 4991 37 wage wage NN 42759 4991 38 . . . 42759 4992 1 If if IN 42759 4992 2 only only RB 42759 4992 3 married married JJ 42759 4992 4 men man NNS 42759 4992 5 get get VBP 42759 4992 6 the the DT 42759 4992 7 latter latter JJ 42759 4992 8 wage wage NN 42759 4992 9 they -PRON- PRP 42759 4992 10 will will MD 42759 4992 11 be be VB 42759 4992 12 discriminated discriminate VBN 42759 4992 13 against against IN 42759 4992 14 in in IN 42759 4992 15 the the DT 42759 4992 16 matter matter NN 42759 4992 17 of of IN 42759 4992 18 employment employment NN 42759 4992 19 . . . 42759 4993 1 To to TO 42759 4993 2 prevent prevent VB 42759 4993 3 this this DT 42759 4993 4 obviously obviously RB 42759 4993 5 undesirable undesirable JJ 42759 4993 6 condition condition NN 42759 4993 7 , , , 42759 4993 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 4993 9 is be VBZ 42759 4993 10 necessary necessary JJ 42759 4993 11 that that IN 42759 4993 12 a a DT 42759 4993 13 family family NN 42759 4993 14 living living NN 42759 4993 15 wage wage NN 42759 4993 16 be be VB 42759 4993 17 recognised recognise VBN 42759 4993 18 as as IN 42759 4993 19 the the DT 42759 4993 20 right right NN 42759 4993 21 of of IN 42759 4993 22 all all DT 42759 4993 23 adult adult NN 42759 4993 24 male male JJ 42759 4993 25 workers worker NNS 42759 4993 26 . . . 42759 4994 1 No no DT 42759 4994 2 other other JJ 42759 4994 3 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 4994 4 is be VBZ 42759 4994 5 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 4994 6 in in IN 42759 4994 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 4994 8 present present JJ 42759 4994 9 industrial industrial JJ 42759 4994 10 system system NN 42759 4994 11 . . . 42759 4995 1 In in IN 42759 4995 2 a a DT 42759 4995 3 competitive competitive JJ 42759 4995 4 régime régime NN 42759 4995 5 the the DT 42759 4995 6 standard standard JJ 42759 4995 7 wage wage NN 42759 4995 8 for for IN 42759 4995 9 both both CC 42759 4995 10 the the DT 42759 4995 11 married married JJ 42759 4995 12 and and CC 42759 4995 13 the the DT 42759 4995 14 unmarried unmarried JJ 42759 4995 15 men man NNS 42759 4995 16 is be VBZ 42759 4995 17 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 4995 18 the the DT 42759 4995 19 same same JJ 42759 4995 20 . . . 42759 4996 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 4996 2 will will MD 42759 4996 3 be be VB 42759 4996 4 determined determine VBN 42759 4996 5 by by IN 42759 4996 6 the the DT 42759 4996 7 living living NN 42759 4996 8 costs cost NNS 42759 4996 9 of of IN 42759 4996 10 either either CC 42759 4996 11 the the DT 42759 4996 12 one one CD 42759 4996 13 class class NN 42759 4996 14 or or CC 42759 4996 15 the the DT 42759 4996 16 other other JJ 42759 4996 17 . . . 42759 4997 1 At at IN 42759 4997 2 present present JJ 42759 4997 3 the the DT 42759 4997 4 wage wage NN 42759 4997 5 of of IN 42759 4997 6 the the DT 42759 4997 7 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 4997 8 is be VBZ 42759 4997 9 unfortunately unfortunately RB 42759 4997 10 adjusted adjust VBN 42759 4997 11 to to IN 42759 4997 12 the the DT 42759 4997 13 subsistence subsistence NN 42759 4997 14 cost cost NN 42759 4997 15 of of IN 42759 4997 16 the the DT 42759 4997 17 man man NN 42759 4997 18 who who WP 42759 4997 19 is be VBZ 42759 4997 20 not not RB 42759 4997 21 married married JJ 42759 4997 22 . . . 42759 4998 1 Since since IN 42759 4998 2 two two CD 42759 4998 3 prevailing prevailing JJ 42759 4998 4 scales scale NNS 42759 4998 5 of of IN 42759 4998 6 wages wage NNS 42759 4998 7 are be VBP 42759 4998 8 impossible impossible JJ 42759 4998 9 , , , 42759 4998 10 the the DT 42759 4998 11 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 4998 12 of of IN 42759 4998 13 the the DT 42759 4998 14 unmarried unmarried JJ 42759 4998 15 must must NN 42759 4998 16 in in IN 42759 4998 17 the the DT 42759 4998 18 interests interest NNS 42759 4998 19 of of IN 42759 4998 20 justice justice NN 42759 4998 21 to to IN 42759 4998 22 the the DT 42759 4998 23 married married JJ 42759 4998 24 be be VB 42759 4998 25 raised raise VBN 42759 4998 26 to to IN 42759 4998 27 the the DT 42759 4998 28 living live VBG 42759 4998 29 costs cost NNS 42759 4998 30 of of IN 42759 4998 31 the the DT 42759 4998 32 latter latter JJ 42759 4998 33 . . . 42759 4999 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 4999 2 , , , 42759 4999 3 the the DT 42759 4999 4 unmarried unmarried JJ 42759 4999 5 labourer labourer NN 42759 4999 6 needs need VBZ 42759 4999 7 more more JJR 42759 4999 8 than than IN 42759 4999 9 an an DT 42759 4999 10 individual individual JJ 42759 4999 11 living live VBG 42759 4999 12 wage wage NN 42759 4999 13 in in IN 42759 4999 14 order order NN 42759 4999 15 to to TO 42759 4999 16 save save VB 42759 4999 17 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 4999 18 money money NN 42759 4999 19 to to TO 42759 4999 20 enter enter VB 42759 4999 21 upon upon IN 42759 4999 22 the the DT 42759 4999 23 responsibilities responsibility NNS 42759 4999 24 of of IN 42759 4999 25 matrimony matrimony NN 42759 4999 26 . . . 42759 5000 1 Only only RB 42759 5000 2 two two CD 42759 5000 3 objections objection NNS 42759 5000 4 of of IN 42759 5000 5 any any DT 42759 5000 6 importance importance NN 42759 5000 7 can can MD 42759 5000 8 be be VB 42759 5000 9 brought bring VBN 42759 5000 10 against against IN 42759 5000 11 the the DT 42759 5000 12 male male JJ 42759 5000 13 labourer labourer NN 42759 5000 14 's 's POS 42759 5000 15 claim claim NN 42759 5000 16 to to IN 42759 5000 17 a a DT 42759 5000 18 family family NN 42759 5000 19 living living NN 42759 5000 20 wage wage NN 42759 5000 21 . . . 42759 5001 1 The the DT 42759 5001 2 first first JJ 42759 5001 3 is be VBZ 42759 5001 4 that that IN 42759 5001 5 just just RB 42759 5001 6 wages wage NNS 42759 5001 7 are be VBP 42759 5001 8 to to TO 42759 5001 9 be be VB 42759 5001 10 measured measure VBN 42759 5001 11 by by IN 42759 5001 12 the the DT 42759 5001 13 value value NN 42759 5001 14 of of IN 42759 5001 15 the the DT 42759 5001 16 labour labour NN 42759 5001 17 performed perform VBN 42759 5001 18 , , , 42759 5001 19 and and CC 42759 5001 20 not not RB 42759 5001 21 by by IN 42759 5001 22 such such PDT 42759 5001 23 an an DT 42759 5001 24 extrinsic extrinsic JJ 42759 5001 25 consideration consideration NN 42759 5001 26 as as IN 42759 5001 27 the the DT 42759 5001 28 needs need NNS 42759 5001 29 of of IN 42759 5001 30 a a DT 42759 5001 31 family family NN 42759 5001 32 . . . 42759 5002 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5002 2 has have VBZ 42759 5002 3 already already RB 42759 5002 4 been be VBN 42759 5002 5 answered answer VBN 42759 5002 6 in in IN 42759 5002 7 this this DT 42759 5002 8 and and CC 42759 5002 9 the the DT 42759 5002 10 preceding precede VBG 42759 5002 11 chapters chapter NNS 42759 5002 12 . . . 42759 5003 1 Not not RB 42759 5003 2 the the DT 42759 5003 3 economic economic JJ 42759 5003 4 but but CC 42759 5003 5 the the DT 42759 5003 6 ethical ethical JJ 42759 5003 7 value value NN 42759 5003 8 of of IN 42759 5003 9 the the DT 42759 5003 10 service service NN 42759 5003 11 rendered render VBN 42759 5003 12 , , , 42759 5003 13 is be VBZ 42759 5003 14 the the DT 42759 5003 15 proper proper JJ 42759 5003 16 determinant determinant NN 42759 5003 17 of of IN 42759 5003 18 justice justice NN 42759 5003 19 in in IN 42759 5003 20 the the DT 42759 5003 21 matter matter NN 42759 5003 22 of of IN 42759 5003 23 wages wage NNS 42759 5003 24 ; ; : 42759 5003 25 and and CC 42759 5003 26 this this DT 42759 5003 27 ethical ethical JJ 42759 5003 28 value value NN 42759 5003 29 is be VBZ 42759 5003 30 always always RB 42759 5003 31 the the DT 42759 5003 32 equivalent equivalent NN 42759 5003 33 of of IN 42759 5003 34 at at IN 42759 5003 35 least least JJS 42759 5003 36 a a DT 42759 5003 37 decent decent JJ 42759 5003 38 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5003 39 for for IN 42759 5003 40 the the DT 42759 5003 41 labourer labourer NN 42759 5003 42 and and CC 42759 5003 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5003 44 family family NN 42759 5003 45 . . . 42759 5004 1 According accord VBG 42759 5004 2 to to IN 42759 5004 3 the the DT 42759 5004 4 second second JJ 42759 5004 5 objection objection NN 42759 5004 6 , , , 42759 5004 7 the the DT 42759 5004 8 members member NNS 42759 5004 9 of of IN 42759 5004 10 the the DT 42759 5004 11 labourer labourer NN 42759 5004 12 's 's POS 42759 5004 13 family family NN 42759 5004 14 have have VBP 42759 5004 15 no no DT 42759 5004 16 claim claim NN 42759 5004 17 upon upon IN 42759 5004 18 the the DT 42759 5004 19 employer employer NN 42759 5004 20 , , , 42759 5004 21 since since IN 42759 5004 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5004 23 do do VBP 42759 5004 24 not not RB 42759 5004 25 participate participate VB 42759 5004 26 in in IN 42759 5004 27 the the DT 42759 5004 28 work work NN 42759 5004 29 that that WDT 42759 5004 30 is be VBZ 42759 5004 31 remunerated remunerate VBN 42759 5004 32 . . . 42759 5005 1 This this DT 42759 5005 2 contention contention NN 42759 5005 3 is be VBZ 42759 5005 4 valid valid JJ 42759 5005 5 , , , 42759 5005 6 but but CC 42759 5005 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5005 8 is be VBZ 42759 5005 9 also also RB 42759 5005 10 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 42759 5005 11 . . . 42759 5006 1 The the DT 42759 5006 2 claim claim NN 42759 5006 3 of of IN 42759 5006 4 the the DT 42759 5006 5 labourer labourer NN 42759 5006 6 's 's POS 42759 5006 7 family family NN 42759 5006 8 to to TO 42759 5006 9 sustenance sustenance NN 42759 5006 10 is be VBZ 42759 5006 11 directly directly RB 42759 5006 12 upon upon IN 42759 5006 13 him -PRON- PRP 42759 5006 14 , , , 42759 5006 15 not not RB 42759 5006 16 upon upon IN 42759 5006 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5006 18 employer employer NN 42759 5006 19 ; ; : 42759 5006 20 but but CC 42759 5006 21 the the DT 42759 5006 22 labourer labourer NN 42759 5006 23 has have VBZ 42759 5006 24 a a DT 42759 5006 25 just just RB 42759 5006 26 claim claim NN 42759 5006 27 upon upon IN 42759 5006 28 the the DT 42759 5006 29 employer employer NN 42759 5006 30 for for IN 42759 5006 31 the the DT 42759 5006 32 means mean NNS 42759 5006 33 of of IN 42759 5006 34 meeting meet VBG 42759 5006 35 the the DT 42759 5006 36 claims claim NNS 42759 5006 37 of of IN 42759 5006 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5006 39 family family NN 42759 5006 40 . . . 42759 5007 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5007 2 right right NN 42759 5007 3 to to IN 42759 5007 4 this this DT 42759 5007 5 amount amount NN 42759 5007 6 of of IN 42759 5007 7 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5007 8 is be VBZ 42759 5007 9 directly directly RB 42759 5007 10 based base VBN 42759 5007 11 neither neither CC 42759 5007 12 upon upon IN 42759 5007 13 the the DT 42759 5007 14 needs need NNS 42759 5007 15 nor nor CC 42759 5007 16 the the DT 42759 5007 17 rights right NNS 42759 5007 18 of of IN 42759 5007 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5007 20 family family NN 42759 5007 21 , , , 42759 5007 22 but but CC 42759 5007 23 upon upon IN 42759 5007 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5007 25 own own JJ 42759 5007 26 needs need NNS 42759 5007 27 , , , 42759 5007 28 upon upon IN 42759 5007 29 the the DT 42759 5007 30 fact fact NN 42759 5007 31 that that IN 42759 5007 32 family family NN 42759 5007 33 conditions condition NNS 42759 5007 34 are be VBP 42759 5007 35 indispensable indispensable JJ 42759 5007 36 to to IN 42759 5007 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5007 38 own own JJ 42759 5007 39 normal normal JJ 42759 5007 40 life life NN 42759 5007 41 . . . 42759 5008 1 If if IN 42759 5008 2 the the DT 42759 5008 3 wife wife NN 42759 5008 4 and and CC 42759 5008 5 young young JJ 42759 5008 6 children child NNS 42759 5008 7 were be VBD 42759 5008 8 self self NN 42759 5008 9 supporting support VBG 42759 5008 10 , , , 42759 5008 11 or or CC 42759 5008 12 were be VBD 42759 5008 13 maintained maintain VBN 42759 5008 14 by by IN 42759 5008 15 the the DT 42759 5008 16 State State NNP 42759 5008 17 , , , 42759 5008 18 the the DT 42759 5008 19 wage wage NN 42759 5008 20 rights right NNS 42759 5008 21 of of IN 42759 5008 22 the the DT 42759 5008 23 father father NN 42759 5008 24 would would MD 42759 5008 25 not not RB 42759 5008 26 include include VB 42759 5008 27 provision provision NN 42759 5008 28 for for IN 42759 5008 29 the the DT 42759 5008 30 family family NN 42759 5008 31 . . . 42759 5009 1 Since since IN 42759 5009 2 , , , 42759 5009 3 however however RB 42759 5009 4 , , , 42759 5009 5 family family NN 42759 5009 6 life life NN 42759 5009 7 involves involve VBZ 42759 5009 8 support support NN 42759 5009 9 by by IN 42759 5009 10 the the DT 42759 5009 11 father father NNP 42759 5009 12 , , , 42759 5009 13 the the DT 42759 5009 14 labourer labourer NN 42759 5009 15 's 's POS 42759 5009 16 right right NN 42759 5009 17 to to IN 42759 5009 18 such such PDT 42759 5009 19 a a DT 42759 5009 20 life life NN 42759 5009 21 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 5009 22 includes include VBZ 42759 5009 23 the the DT 42759 5009 24 right right NN 42759 5009 25 to to IN 42759 5009 26 a a DT 42759 5009 27 wage wage NN 42759 5009 28 adequate adequate JJ 42759 5009 29 to to IN 42759 5009 30 family family NN 42759 5009 31 support support NN 42759 5009 32 . . . 42759 5010 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5010 2 Other other JJ 42759 5010 3 Arguments Arguments NNPS 42759 5010 4 in in IN 42759 5010 5 Favour favour NN 42759 5010 6 of of IN 42759 5010 7 a a DT 42759 5010 8 Living Living NNP 42759 5010 9 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5010 10 _ _ NNP 42759 5010 11 Thus thus RB 42759 5010 12 far far RB 42759 5010 13 , , , 42759 5010 14 the the DT 42759 5010 15 argument argument NN 42759 5010 16 has have VBZ 42759 5010 17 been be VBN 42759 5010 18 based base VBN 42759 5010 19 upon upon IN 42759 5010 20 individual individual JJ 42759 5010 21 natural natural JJ 42759 5010 22 rights right NNS 42759 5010 23 . . . 42759 5011 1 If if IN 42759 5011 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5011 3 give give VBP 42759 5011 4 up up RP 42759 5011 5 the the DT 42759 5011 6 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 5011 7 of of IN 42759 5011 8 natural natural JJ 42759 5011 9 rights right NNS 42759 5011 10 , , , 42759 5011 11 and and CC 42759 5011 12 assume assume VBP 42759 5011 13 that that IN 42759 5011 14 all all PDT 42759 5011 15 the the DT 42759 5011 16 rights right NNS 42759 5011 17 of of IN 42759 5011 18 the the DT 42759 5011 19 individual individual NN 42759 5011 20 come come VBP 42759 5011 21 to to IN 42759 5011 22 him -PRON- PRP 42759 5011 23 from from IN 42759 5011 24 the the DT 42759 5011 25 State State NNP 42759 5011 26 , , , 42759 5011 27 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5011 28 must must MD 42759 5011 29 admit admit VB 42759 5011 30 that that IN 42759 5011 31 the the DT 42759 5011 32 State State NNP 42759 5011 33 has have VBZ 42759 5011 34 the the DT 42759 5011 35 power power NN 42759 5011 36 to to TO 42759 5011 37 withhold withhold VB 42759 5011 38 and and CC 42759 5011 39 withdraw withdraw VB 42759 5011 40 all all DT 42759 5011 41 rights right NNS 42759 5011 42 from from IN 42759 5011 43 any any DT 42759 5011 44 and and CC 42759 5011 45 all all DT 42759 5011 46 persons person NNS 42759 5011 47 . . . 42759 5012 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5012 2 grant grant NN 42759 5012 3 of of IN 42759 5012 4 rights right NNS 42759 5012 5 will will MD 42759 5012 6 be be VB 42759 5012 7 determined determine VBN 42759 5012 8 solely solely RB 42759 5012 9 by by IN 42759 5012 10 considerations consideration NNS 42759 5012 11 of of IN 42759 5012 12 social social JJ 42759 5012 13 utility utility NN 42759 5012 14 . . . 42759 5013 1 In in IN 42759 5013 2 the the DT 42759 5013 3 concrete concrete NN 42759 5013 4 this this DT 42759 5013 5 means mean VBZ 42759 5013 6 that that IN 42759 5013 7 some some DT 42759 5013 8 citizens citizen NNS 42759 5013 9 may may MD 42759 5013 10 be be VB 42759 5013 11 regarded regard VBN 42759 5013 12 as as IN 42759 5013 13 essentially essentially RB 42759 5013 14 inferior inferior JJ 42759 5013 15 to to IN 42759 5013 16 other other JJ 42759 5013 17 citizens citizen NNS 42759 5013 18 , , , 42759 5013 19 that that IN 42759 5013 20 some some DT 42759 5013 21 may may MD 42759 5013 22 properly properly RB 42759 5013 23 be be VB 42759 5013 24 treated treat VBN 42759 5013 25 as as IN 42759 5013 26 mere mere JJ 42759 5013 27 instruments instrument NNS 42759 5013 28 to to IN 42759 5013 29 the the DT 42759 5013 30 convenience convenience NN 42759 5013 31 of of IN 42759 5013 32 others other NNS 42759 5013 33 . . . 42759 5014 1 Or or CC 42759 5014 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5014 3 means mean VBZ 42759 5014 4 that that IN 42759 5014 5 all all DT 42759 5014 6 citizens citizen NNS 42759 5014 7 may may MD 42759 5014 8 be be VB 42759 5014 9 completely completely RB 42759 5014 10 subordinated subordinate VBN 42759 5014 11 to to IN 42759 5014 12 the the DT 42759 5014 13 aggrandisement aggrandisement NN 42759 5014 14 of of IN 42759 5014 15 an an DT 42759 5014 16 abstract abstract JJ 42759 5014 17 entity entity NN 42759 5014 18 , , , 42759 5014 19 called call VBN 42759 5014 20 the the DT 42759 5014 21 State State NNP 42759 5014 22 . . . 42759 5015 1 Neither neither DT 42759 5015 2 of of IN 42759 5015 3 these these DT 42759 5015 4 positions position NNS 42759 5015 5 is be VBZ 42759 5015 6 logically logically RB 42759 5015 7 defensible defensible JJ 42759 5015 8 . . . 42759 5016 1 No no DT 42759 5016 2 group group NN 42759 5016 3 of of IN 42759 5016 4 persons person NNS 42759 5016 5 has have VBZ 42759 5016 6 less less JJR 42759 5016 7 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 5016 8 worth worth NN 42759 5016 9 than than IN 42759 5016 10 another another DT 42759 5016 11 ; ; : 42759 5016 12 and and CC 42759 5016 13 the the DT 42759 5016 14 State State NNP 42759 5016 15 has have VBZ 42759 5016 16 no no DT 42759 5016 17 rational rational JJ 42759 5016 18 significance significance NN 42759 5016 19 apart apart RB 42759 5016 20 from from IN 42759 5016 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5016 22 component component NN 42759 5016 23 individuals individual NNS 42759 5016 24 . . . 42759 5017 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 5017 2 , , , 42759 5017 3 a a DT 42759 5017 4 valid valid JJ 42759 5017 5 argument argument NN 42759 5017 6 for for IN 42759 5017 7 the the DT 42759 5017 8 living living NN 42759 5017 9 wage wage NN 42759 5017 10 can can MD 42759 5017 11 be be VB 42759 5017 12 set set VBN 42759 5017 13 up up RP 42759 5017 14 on on IN 42759 5017 15 grounds ground NNS 42759 5017 16 of of IN 42759 5017 17 social social JJ 42759 5017 18 welfare welfare NN 42759 5017 19 . . . 42759 5018 1 A a DT 42759 5018 2 careful careful JJ 42759 5018 3 and and CC 42759 5018 4 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 5018 5 examination examination NN 42759 5018 6 of of IN 42759 5018 7 the the DT 42759 5018 8 evil evil JJ 42759 5018 9 consequences consequence NNS 42759 5018 10 to to IN 42759 5018 11 society society NN 42759 5018 12 and and CC 42759 5018 13 the the DT 42759 5018 14 State state NN 42759 5018 15 from from IN 42759 5018 16 the the DT 42759 5018 17 under under NN 42759 5018 18 - - HYPH 42759 5018 19 payment payment NN 42759 5018 20 of of IN 42759 5018 21 any any DT 42759 5018 22 group group NN 42759 5018 23 of of IN 42759 5018 24 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5018 25 , , , 42759 5018 26 would would MD 42759 5018 27 show show VB 42759 5018 28 that that IN 42759 5018 29 a a DT 42759 5018 30 universal universal JJ 42759 5018 31 living living NN 42759 5018 32 wage wage NN 42759 5018 33 is be VBZ 42759 5018 34 the the DT 42759 5018 35 only only JJ 42759 5018 36 sound sound JJ 42759 5018 37 social social JJ 42759 5018 38 policy policy NN 42759 5018 39 . . . 42759 5019 1 Among among IN 42759 5019 2 competent competent JJ 42759 5019 3 social social JJ 42759 5019 4 students student NNS 42759 5019 5 , , , 42759 5019 6 this this DT 42759 5019 7 proposition proposition NN 42759 5019 8 has have VBZ 42759 5019 9 become become VBN 42759 5019 10 a a DT 42759 5019 11 commonplace commonplace NN 42759 5019 12 . . . 42759 5020 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5020 2 will will MD 42759 5020 3 not not RB 42759 5020 4 be be VB 42759 5020 5 denied deny VBN 42759 5020 6 by by IN 42759 5020 7 any any DT 42759 5020 8 intelligent intelligent JJ 42759 5020 9 person person NN 42759 5020 10 who who WP 42759 5020 11 considers consider VBZ 42759 5020 12 seriously seriously RB 42759 5020 13 the the DT 42759 5020 14 influence influence NN 42759 5020 15 of of IN 42759 5020 16 low low JJ 42759 5020 17 wages wage NNS 42759 5020 18 in in IN 42759 5020 19 diminishing diminish VBG 42759 5020 20 the the DT 42759 5020 21 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5020 22 , , , 42759 5020 23 physical physical JJ 42759 5020 24 , , , 42759 5020 25 mental mental JJ 42759 5020 26 , , , 42759 5020 27 and and CC 42759 5020 28 moral moral JJ 42759 5020 29 , , , 42759 5020 30 of of IN 42759 5020 31 the the DT 42759 5020 32 workers worker NNS 42759 5020 33 ; ; : 42759 5020 34 in in IN 42759 5020 35 increasing increase VBG 42759 5020 36 the the DT 42759 5020 37 volume volume NN 42759 5020 38 of of IN 42759 5020 39 crime crime NN 42759 5020 40 , , , 42759 5020 41 and and CC 42759 5020 42 the the DT 42759 5020 43 social social JJ 42759 5020 44 cost cost NN 42759 5020 45 of of IN 42759 5020 46 meeting meet VBG 42759 5020 47 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5020 48 ; ; : 42759 5020 49 in in IN 42759 5020 50 the the DT 42759 5020 51 immense immense JJ 42759 5020 52 social social JJ 42759 5020 53 outlay outlay NN 42759 5020 54 for for IN 42759 5020 55 the the DT 42759 5020 56 relief relief NN 42759 5020 57 of of IN 42759 5020 58 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 5020 59 poverty poverty NN 42759 5020 60 , , , 42759 5020 61 sickness sickness NN 42759 5020 62 , , , 42759 5020 63 and and CC 42759 5020 64 other other JJ 42759 5020 65 forms form NNS 42759 5020 66 of of IN 42759 5020 67 distress distress NN 42759 5020 68 ; ; : 42759 5020 69 and and CC 42759 5020 70 in in IN 42759 5020 71 the the DT 42759 5020 72 formation formation NN 42759 5020 73 of of IN 42759 5020 74 a a DT 42759 5020 75 large large JJ 42759 5020 76 and and CC 42759 5020 77 discontented discontented JJ 42759 5020 78 proletariat proletariat NN 42759 5020 79 . . . 42759 5021 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5021 2 246 246 CD 42759 5021 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5021 4 The the DT 42759 5021 5 living living NN 42759 5021 6 wage wage NN 42759 5021 7 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 5021 8 also also RB 42759 5021 9 receives receive VBZ 42759 5021 10 strong strong JJ 42759 5021 11 support support NN 42759 5021 12 from from IN 42759 5021 13 various various JJ 42759 5021 14 kinds kind NNS 42759 5021 15 of of IN 42759 5021 16 authority authority NN 42759 5021 17 . . . 42759 5022 1 Of of IN 42759 5022 2 these these DT 42759 5022 3 the the DT 42759 5022 4 most most RBS 42759 5022 5 important important JJ 42759 5022 6 and and CC 42759 5022 7 best good JJS 42759 5022 8 known know VBN 42759 5022 9 is be VBZ 42759 5022 10 the the DT 42759 5022 11 famous famous JJ 42759 5022 12 encyclical encyclical NN 42759 5022 13 , , , 42759 5022 14 " " '' 42759 5022 15 On on IN 42759 5022 16 the the DT 42759 5022 17 Condition Condition NNP 42759 5022 18 of of IN 42759 5022 19 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5022 20 , , , 42759 5022 21 " " '' 42759 5022 22 May May MD 42759 5022 23 15 15 CD 42759 5022 24 , , , 42759 5022 25 1891 1891 CD 42759 5022 26 , , , 42759 5022 27 by by IN 42759 5022 28 Pope Pope NNP 42759 5022 29 Leo Leo NNP 42759 5022 30 XIII XIII NNP 42759 5022 31 . . . 42759 5023 1 " " `` 42759 5023 2 Let let VB 42759 5023 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5023 4 then then RB 42759 5023 5 be be VB 42759 5023 6 granted grant VBN 42759 5023 7 that that IN 42759 5023 8 workman workman NN 42759 5023 9 and and CC 42759 5023 10 employer employer NN 42759 5023 11 should should MD 42759 5023 12 , , , 42759 5023 13 as as IN 42759 5023 14 a a DT 42759 5023 15 rule rule NN 42759 5023 16 , , , 42759 5023 17 make make VB 42759 5023 18 free free JJ 42759 5023 19 agreements agreement NNS 42759 5023 20 , , , 42759 5023 21 and and CC 42759 5023 22 in in IN 42759 5023 23 particular particular JJ 42759 5023 24 should should MD 42759 5023 25 agree agree VB 42759 5023 26 freely freely RB 42759 5023 27 as as IN 42759 5023 28 to to IN 42759 5023 29 wages wage NNS 42759 5023 30 ; ; : 42759 5023 31 nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 5023 32 , , , 42759 5023 33 there there EX 42759 5023 34 is be VBZ 42759 5023 35 a a DT 42759 5023 36 dictate dictate NN 42759 5023 37 of of IN 42759 5023 38 natural natural JJ 42759 5023 39 justice justice NN 42759 5023 40 more more RBR 42759 5023 41 imperious imperious JJ 42759 5023 42 and and CC 42759 5023 43 ancient ancient JJ 42759 5023 44 than than IN 42759 5023 45 any any DT 42759 5023 46 bargain bargain NN 42759 5023 47 between between IN 42759 5023 48 man man NN 42759 5023 49 and and CC 42759 5023 50 man man NN 42759 5023 51 ; ; : 42759 5023 52 namely namely RB 42759 5023 53 , , , 42759 5023 54 that that IN 42759 5023 55 the the DT 42759 5023 56 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5023 57 should should MD 42759 5023 58 be be VB 42759 5023 59 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5023 60 to to TO 42759 5023 61 maintain maintain VB 42759 5023 62 the the DT 42759 5023 63 wage wage NN 42759 5023 64 earner earner NN 42759 5023 65 and and CC 42759 5023 66 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5023 67 and and CC 42759 5023 68 frugal frugal JJ 42759 5023 69 comfort comfort NN 42759 5023 70 . . . 42759 5023 71 " " '' 42759 5024 1 Although although IN 42759 5024 2 the the DT 42759 5024 3 Pope Pope NNP 42759 5024 4 refrained refrain VBD 42759 5024 5 from from IN 42759 5024 6 specifying specify VBG 42759 5024 7 whether whether IN 42759 5024 8 the the DT 42759 5024 9 living living NN 42759 5024 10 wage wage NN 42759 5024 11 that that WDT 42759 5024 12 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5024 13 had have VBD 42759 5024 14 in in IN 42759 5024 15 mind mind NN 42759 5024 16 was be VBD 42759 5024 17 one one CD 42759 5024 18 adequate adequate NN 42759 5024 19 merely merely RB 42759 5024 20 to to IN 42759 5024 21 an an DT 42759 5024 22 individual individual JJ 42759 5024 23 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5024 24 , , , 42759 5024 25 or or CC 42759 5024 26 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5024 27 to to TO 42759 5024 28 support support VB 42759 5024 29 a a DT 42759 5024 30 family family NN 42759 5024 31 , , , 42759 5024 32 other other JJ 42759 5024 33 passages passage NNS 42759 5024 34 in in IN 42759 5024 35 the the DT 42759 5024 36 Encyclical Encyclical NNP 42759 5024 37 leave leave VBP 42759 5024 38 no no DT 42759 5024 39 room room NN 42759 5024 40 for for IN 42759 5024 41 doubt doubt NN 42759 5024 42 that that IN 42759 5024 43 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5024 44 regarded regard VBD 42759 5024 45 the the DT 42759 5024 46 latter latter JJ 42759 5024 47 as as IN 42759 5024 48 the the DT 42759 5024 49 normal normal JJ 42759 5024 50 and and CC 42759 5024 51 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5024 52 measure measure NN 42759 5024 53 of of IN 42759 5024 54 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5024 55 . . . 42759 5025 1 Within within IN 42759 5025 2 a a DT 42759 5025 3 dozen dozen NN 42759 5025 4 lines line NNS 42759 5025 5 of of IN 42759 5025 6 the the DT 42759 5025 7 sentence sentence NN 42759 5025 8 quoted quote VBN 42759 5025 9 above above RB 42759 5025 10 , , , 42759 5025 11 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5025 12 made make VBD 42759 5025 13 this this DT 42759 5025 14 statement statement NN 42759 5025 15 : : : 42759 5025 16 " " `` 42759 5025 17 If if IN 42759 5025 18 the the DT 42759 5025 19 workman workman NN 42759 5025 20 's 's POS 42759 5025 21 wages wage NNS 42759 5025 22 be be VB 42759 5025 23 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5025 24 to to TO 42759 5025 25 maintain maintain VB 42759 5025 26 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 5025 27 , , , 42759 5025 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5025 29 wife wife NN 42759 5025 30 , , , 42759 5025 31 and and CC 42759 5025 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5025 33 children child NNS 42759 5025 34 in in IN 42759 5025 35 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5025 36 comfort comfort NN 42759 5025 37 , , , 42759 5025 38 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5025 39 will will MD 42759 5025 40 not not RB 42759 5025 41 find find VB 42759 5025 42 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5025 43 difficult difficult JJ 42759 5025 44 , , , 42759 5025 45 if if IN 42759 5025 46 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5025 47 be be VB 42759 5025 48 a a DT 42759 5025 49 sensible sensible JJ 42759 5025 50 man man NN 42759 5025 51 , , , 42759 5025 52 to to TO 42759 5025 53 practise practise VB 42759 5025 54 thrift thrift NN 42759 5025 55 ; ; : 42759 5025 56 and and CC 42759 5025 57 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5025 58 will will MD 42759 5025 59 not not RB 42759 5025 60 fail fail VB 42759 5025 61 , , , 42759 5025 62 by by IN 42759 5025 63 cutting cut VBG 42759 5025 64 down down RP 42759 5025 65 expenses expense NNS 42759 5025 66 , , , 42759 5025 67 to to TO 42759 5025 68 put put VB 42759 5025 69 by by IN 42759 5025 70 some some DT 42759 5025 71 little little JJ 42759 5025 72 savings saving NNS 42759 5025 73 and and CC 42759 5025 74 thus thus RB 42759 5025 75 secure secure VB 42759 5025 76 a a DT 42759 5025 77 small small JJ 42759 5025 78 income income NN 42759 5025 79 . . . 42759 5025 80 " " '' 42759 5026 1 All all DT 42759 5026 2 lesser less JJR 42759 5026 3 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 5026 4 authorities authority NNS 42759 5026 5 hold hold VBP 42759 5026 6 that that IN 42759 5026 7 the the DT 42759 5026 8 adult adult NN 42759 5026 9 male male JJ 42759 5026 10 labourer labourer NN 42759 5026 11 has have VBZ 42759 5026 12 some some DT 42759 5026 13 kind kind NN 42759 5026 14 of of IN 42759 5026 15 moral moral JJ 42759 5026 16 claim claim NN 42759 5026 17 to to IN 42759 5026 18 a a DT 42759 5026 19 family family NN 42759 5026 20 living living NN 42759 5026 21 wage wage NN 42759 5026 22 . . . 42759 5027 1 In in IN 42759 5027 2 all all DT 42759 5027 3 probability probability NN 42759 5027 4 the the DT 42759 5027 5 majority majority NN 42759 5027 6 of of IN 42759 5027 7 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5027 8 regard regard VBP 42759 5027 9 this this DT 42759 5027 10 claim claim NN 42759 5027 11 as as IN 42759 5027 12 one one CD 42759 5027 13 of of IN 42759 5027 14 strict strict JJ 42759 5027 15 justice justice NN 42759 5027 16 , , , 42759 5027 17 while while IN 42759 5027 18 the the DT 42759 5027 19 minority minority NN 42759 5027 20 would would MD 42759 5027 21 put put VB 42759 5027 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5027 23 under under IN 42759 5027 24 the the DT 42759 5027 25 head head NN 42759 5027 26 of of IN 42759 5027 27 legal legal JJ 42759 5027 28 justice justice NN 42759 5027 29 , , , 42759 5027 30 or or CC 42759 5027 31 natural natural JJ 42759 5027 32 equity equity NN 42759 5027 33 , , , 42759 5027 34 or or CC 42759 5027 35 charity charity NN 42759 5027 36 . . . 42759 5028 1 The the DT 42759 5028 2 differences difference NNS 42759 5028 3 between between IN 42759 5028 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5028 5 views view NNS 42759 5028 6 are be VBP 42759 5028 7 not not RB 42759 5028 8 as as RB 42759 5028 9 important important JJ 42759 5028 10 as as IN 42759 5028 11 the the DT 42759 5028 12 agreements agreement NNS 42759 5028 13 ; ; : 42759 5028 14 for for IN 42759 5028 15 all all PDT 42759 5028 16 the the DT 42759 5028 17 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 5028 18 writers writer NNS 42759 5028 19 maintain maintain VBP 42759 5028 20 that that IN 42759 5028 21 the the DT 42759 5028 22 worker worker NN 42759 5028 23 's 's POS 42759 5028 24 claim claim NN 42759 5028 25 is be VBZ 42759 5028 26 strictly strictly RB 42759 5028 27 moral moral JJ 42759 5028 28 in in IN 42759 5028 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5028 30 nature nature NN 42759 5028 31 , , , 42759 5028 32 and and CC 42759 5028 33 that that IN 42759 5028 34 the the DT 42759 5028 35 corresponding corresponding JJ 42759 5028 36 obligation obligation NN 42759 5028 37 upon upon IN 42759 5028 38 the the DT 42759 5028 39 employer employer NN 42759 5028 40 is be VBZ 42759 5028 41 likewise likewise RB 42759 5028 42 of of IN 42759 5028 43 a a DT 42759 5028 44 moral moral JJ 42759 5028 45 character character NN 42759 5028 46 . . . 42759 5029 1 The the DT 42759 5029 2 Federal Federal NNP 42759 5029 3 Council Council NNP 42759 5029 4 of of IN 42759 5029 5 the the DT 42759 5029 6 Churches Churches NNPS 42759 5029 7 of of IN 42759 5029 8 Christ Christ NNP 42759 5029 9 in in IN 42759 5029 10 America America NNP 42759 5029 11 , , , 42759 5029 12 representing represent VBG 42759 5029 13 the the DT 42759 5029 14 principal principal JJ 42759 5029 15 Protestant protestant JJ 42759 5029 16 denominations denomination NNS 42759 5029 17 , , , 42759 5029 18 has have VBZ 42759 5029 19 formally formally RB 42759 5029 20 declared declare VBN 42759 5029 21 in in IN 42759 5029 22 favour favour NN 42759 5029 23 of of IN 42759 5029 24 " " `` 42759 5029 25 a a DT 42759 5029 26 living living NN 42759 5029 27 wage wage NN 42759 5029 28 as as IN 42759 5029 29 a a DT 42759 5029 30 minimum minimum NN 42759 5029 31 in in IN 42759 5029 32 every every DT 42759 5029 33 industry industry NN 42759 5029 34 . . . 42759 5029 35 " " '' 42759 5030 1 Public public JJ 42759 5030 2 opinion opinion NN 42759 5030 3 likewise likewise RB 42759 5030 4 accepts accept VBZ 42759 5030 5 the the DT 42759 5030 6 principle principle NN 42759 5030 7 of of IN 42759 5030 8 a a DT 42759 5030 9 living living NN 42759 5030 10 wage wage NN 42759 5030 11 as as IN 42759 5030 12 the the DT 42759 5030 13 irreducible irreducible JJ 42759 5030 14 minimum minimum NN 42759 5030 15 of of IN 42759 5030 16 fair fair JJ 42759 5030 17 treatment treatment NN 42759 5030 18 for for IN 42759 5030 19 all all DT 42759 5030 20 workers worker NNS 42759 5030 21 . . . 42759 5031 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 5031 2 , , , 42759 5031 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5031 4 would would MD 42759 5031 5 be be VB 42759 5031 6 difficult difficult JJ 42759 5031 7 to to TO 42759 5031 8 find find VB 42759 5031 9 any any DT 42759 5031 10 important important JJ 42759 5031 11 person person NN 42759 5031 12 in in IN 42759 5031 13 any any DT 42759 5031 14 walk walk NN 42759 5031 15 of of IN 42759 5031 16 life life NN 42759 5031 17 to to IN 42759 5031 18 - - HYPH 42759 5031 19 day day NN 42759 5031 20 who who WP 42759 5031 21 would would MD 42759 5031 22 have have VB 42759 5031 23 the the DT 42759 5031 24 temerity temerity NN 42759 5031 25 to to TO 42759 5031 26 deny deny VB 42759 5031 27 that that IN 42759 5031 28 the the DT 42759 5031 29 labourer labourer NN 42759 5031 30 is be VBZ 42759 5031 31 entitled entitle VBN 42759 5031 32 to to IN 42759 5031 33 a a DT 42759 5031 34 wage wage NN 42759 5031 35 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5031 36 for for IN 42759 5031 37 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5031 38 family family NN 42759 5031 39 life life NN 42759 5031 40 . . . 42759 5032 1 Among among IN 42759 5032 2 employers employer NNS 42759 5032 3 the the DT 42759 5032 4 opinion opinion NN 42759 5032 5 is be VBZ 42759 5032 6 fairly fairly RB 42759 5032 7 general general JJ 42759 5032 8 that that IN 42759 5032 9 the the DT 42759 5032 10 narrow narrow JJ 42759 5032 11 margin margin NN 42759 5032 12 of of IN 42759 5032 13 profit profit NN 42759 5032 14 in in IN 42759 5032 15 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5032 16 industries industry NNS 42759 5032 17 renders render VBZ 42759 5032 18 the the DT 42759 5032 19 burden burden NN 42759 5032 20 of of IN 42759 5032 21 paying pay VBG 42759 5032 22 a a DT 42759 5032 23 family family NN 42759 5032 24 living live VBG 42759 5032 25 wage wage NN 42759 5032 26 to to IN 42759 5032 27 all all DT 42759 5032 28 adult adult NN 42759 5032 29 males male NNS 42759 5032 30 unfairly unfairly RB 42759 5032 31 heavy heavy JJ 42759 5032 32 ; ; : 42759 5032 33 but but CC 42759 5032 34 the the DT 42759 5032 35 assertion assertion NN 42759 5032 36 that that IN 42759 5032 37 the the DT 42759 5032 38 wage wage NN 42759 5032 39 contract contract NN 42759 5032 40 is be VBZ 42759 5032 41 merely merely RB 42759 5032 42 an an DT 42759 5032 43 economic economic JJ 42759 5032 44 transaction transaction NN 42759 5032 45 , , , 42759 5032 46 having have VBG 42759 5032 47 no no DT 42759 5032 48 relation relation NN 42759 5032 49 to to IN 42759 5032 50 justice justice NN 42759 5032 51 , , , 42759 5032 52 is be VBZ 42759 5032 53 scarcely scarcely RB 42759 5032 54 ever ever RB 42759 5032 55 uttered utter VBN 42759 5032 56 publicly publicly RB 42759 5032 57 . . . 42759 5033 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5033 2 The the DT 42759 5033 3 Money Money NNP 42759 5033 4 Measure measure NN 42759 5033 5 of of IN 42759 5033 6 a a DT 42759 5033 7 Living live VBG 42759 5033 8 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5033 9 _ _ NNP 42759 5033 10 For for IN 42759 5033 11 self self NN 42759 5033 12 - - HYPH 42759 5033 13 supporting support VBG 42759 5033 14 women woman NNS 42759 5033 15 a a DT 42759 5033 16 living living NN 42759 5033 17 wage wage NN 42759 5033 18 is be VBZ 42759 5033 19 not not RB 42759 5033 20 less less JJR 42759 5033 21 than than IN 42759 5033 22 eight eight CD 42759 5033 23 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5033 24 per per IN 42759 5033 25 week week NN 42759 5033 26 in in IN 42759 5033 27 any any DT 42759 5033 28 city city NN 42759 5033 29 of of IN 42759 5033 30 the the DT 42759 5033 31 United United NNP 42759 5033 32 States States NNP 42759 5033 33 , , , 42759 5033 34 and and CC 42759 5033 35 in in IN 42759 5033 36 some some DT 42759 5033 37 of of IN 42759 5033 38 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5033 39 larger large JJR 42759 5033 40 cities city NNS 42759 5033 41 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5033 42 is be VBZ 42759 5033 43 from from IN 42759 5033 44 one one CD 42759 5033 45 to to IN 42759 5033 46 two two CD 42759 5033 47 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5033 48 above above IN 42759 5033 49 this this DT 42759 5033 50 figure figure NN 42759 5033 51 . . . 42759 5034 1 The the DT 42759 5034 2 state state NN 42759 5034 3 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5034 4 wage wage NN 42759 5034 5 commissions commission NNS 42759 5034 6 that that WDT 42759 5034 7 have have VBP 42759 5034 8 acted act VBN 42759 5034 9 in in IN 42759 5034 10 the the DT 42759 5034 11 matter matter NN 42759 5034 12 , , , 42759 5034 13 have have VBP 42759 5034 14 fixed fix VBN 42759 5034 15 the the DT 42759 5034 16 rates rate NNS 42759 5034 17 not not RB 42759 5034 18 lower low JJR 42759 5034 19 than than IN 42759 5034 20 eight eight CD 42759 5034 21 nor nor CC 42759 5034 22 higher high JJR 42759 5034 23 than than IN 42759 5034 24 ten ten CD 42759 5034 25 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5034 26 per per IN 42759 5034 27 week week NN 42759 5034 28 . . . 42759 5035 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5035 2 247 247 CD 42759 5035 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5035 4 These these DT 42759 5035 5 determinations determination NNS 42759 5035 6 are be VBP 42759 5035 7 in in IN 42759 5035 8 substantial substantial JJ 42759 5035 9 agreement agreement NN 42759 5035 10 with with IN 42759 5035 11 a a DT 42759 5035 12 large large JJ 42759 5035 13 number number NN 42759 5035 14 of of IN 42759 5035 15 other other JJ 42759 5035 16 estimates estimate NNS 42759 5035 17 , , , 42759 5035 18 both both DT 42759 5035 19 official official JJ 42759 5035 20 and and CC 42759 5035 21 unofficial unofficial JJ 42759 5035 22 . . . 42759 5036 1 When when WRB 42759 5036 2 the the DT 42759 5036 3 present present JJ 42759 5036 4 writer writer NN 42759 5036 5 was be VBD 42759 5036 6 making make VBG 42759 5036 7 an an DT 42759 5036 8 estimate estimate NN 42759 5036 9 of of IN 42759 5036 10 the the DT 42759 5036 11 cost cost NN 42759 5036 12 of of IN 42759 5036 13 decent decent JJ 42759 5036 14 living live VBG 42759 5036 15 for for IN 42759 5036 16 a a DT 42759 5036 17 family family NN 42759 5036 18 about about RB 42759 5036 19 eleven eleven CD 42759 5036 20 years year NNS 42759 5036 21 ago ago RB 42759 5036 22 , , , 42759 5036 23 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5036 24 came come VBD 42759 5036 25 to to IN 42759 5036 26 the the DT 42759 5036 27 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 5036 28 that that IN 42759 5036 29 six six CD 42759 5036 30 hundred hundred CD 42759 5036 31 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5036 32 per per IN 42759 5036 33 year year NN 42759 5036 34 was be VBD 42759 5036 35 the the DT 42759 5036 36 lowest low JJS 42759 5036 37 amount amount NN 42759 5036 38 that that WDT 42759 5036 39 would would MD 42759 5036 40 maintain maintain VB 42759 5036 41 a a DT 42759 5036 42 man man NN 42759 5036 43 and and CC 42759 5036 44 wife wife NN 42759 5036 45 and and CC 42759 5036 46 four four CD 42759 5036 47 or or CC 42759 5036 48 five five CD 42759 5036 49 small small JJ 42759 5036 50 children child NNS 42759 5036 51 in in IN 42759 5036 52 any any DT 42759 5036 53 American american JJ 42759 5036 54 city city NN 42759 5036 55 , , , 42759 5036 56 and and CC 42759 5036 57 that that IN 42759 5036 58 this this DT 42759 5036 59 sum sum NN 42759 5036 60 was be VBD 42759 5036 61 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 5036 62 in in IN 42759 5036 63 some some DT 42759 5036 64 of of IN 42759 5036 65 the the DT 42759 5036 66 larger large JJR 42759 5036 67 cities city NNS 42759 5036 68 . . . 42759 5037 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5037 2 248 248 CD 42759 5037 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5037 4 Since since IN 42759 5037 5 that that DT 42759 5037 6 time time NN 42759 5037 7 retail retail JJ 42759 5037 8 prices price NNS 42759 5037 9 seem seem VBP 42759 5037 10 to to TO 42759 5037 11 have have VB 42759 5037 12 risen rise VBN 42759 5037 13 at at IN 42759 5037 14 least least JJS 42759 5037 15 twenty twenty CD 42759 5037 16 - - HYPH 42759 5037 17 five five CD 42759 5037 18 and and CC 42759 5037 19 possibly possibly RB 42759 5037 20 forty forty CD 42759 5037 21 - - HYPH 42759 5037 22 five five CD 42759 5037 23 per per IN 42759 5037 24 cent cent NN 42759 5037 25 . . . 42759 5038 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5038 2 249 249 CD 42759 5038 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5038 4 If if IN 42759 5038 5 the the DT 42759 5038 6 six six CD 42759 5038 7 hundred hundred CD 42759 5038 8 dollar dollar NN 42759 5038 9 minimum minimum NN 42759 5038 10 were be VBD 42759 5038 11 correct correct JJ 42759 5038 12 in in IN 42759 5038 13 1905 1905 CD 42759 5038 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5038 15 should should MD 42759 5038 16 , , , 42759 5038 17 therefore therefore RB 42759 5038 18 , , , 42759 5038 19 be be VB 42759 5038 20 increased increase VBN 42759 5038 21 to to IN 42759 5038 22 seven seven CD 42759 5038 23 hundred hundred CD 42759 5038 24 and and CC 42759 5038 25 fifty fifty CD 42759 5038 26 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5038 27 to to TO 42759 5038 28 meet meet VB 42759 5038 29 the the DT 42759 5038 30 present present JJ 42759 5038 31 range range NN 42759 5038 32 of of IN 42759 5038 33 prices price NNS 42759 5038 34 . . . 42759 5039 1 That that IN 42759 5039 2 this this DT 42759 5039 3 estimate estimate NN 42759 5039 4 is be VBZ 42759 5039 5 too too RB 42759 5039 6 low low JJ 42759 5039 7 for for IN 42759 5039 8 some some DT 42759 5039 9 of of IN 42759 5039 10 the the DT 42759 5039 11 more more RBR 42759 5039 12 populous populous JJ 42759 5039 13 cities city NNS 42759 5039 14 , , , 42759 5039 15 has have VBZ 42759 5039 16 been be VBN 42759 5039 17 fully fully RB 42759 5039 18 proved prove VBN 42759 5039 19 by by IN 42759 5039 20 several several JJ 42759 5039 21 recent recent JJ 42759 5039 22 investigations investigation NNS 42759 5039 23 . . . 42759 5040 1 In in IN 42759 5040 2 1915 1915 CD 42759 5040 3 the the DT 42759 5040 4 Bureau Bureau NNP 42759 5040 5 of of IN 42759 5040 6 Standards Standards NNPS 42759 5040 7 put put VBD 42759 5040 8 the the DT 42759 5040 9 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5040 10 cost cost NN 42759 5040 11 of of IN 42759 5040 12 living live VBG 42759 5040 13 for for IN 42759 5040 14 a a DT 42759 5040 15 family family NN 42759 5040 16 of of IN 42759 5040 17 five five CD 42759 5040 18 in in IN 42759 5040 19 New New NNP 42759 5040 20 York York NNP 42759 5040 21 City City NNP 42759 5040 22 at at IN 42759 5040 23 $ $ $ 42759 5040 24 840.18 840.18 CD 42759 5040 25 . . . 42759 5041 1 About about RB 42759 5041 2 the the DT 42759 5041 3 same same JJ 42759 5041 4 time time NN 42759 5041 5 the the DT 42759 5041 6 New New NNP 42759 5041 7 York York NNP 42759 5041 8 Factory Factory NNP 42759 5041 9 Investigating Investigating NNP 42759 5041 10 Commission Commission NNP 42759 5041 11 gave give VBD 42759 5041 12 the the DT 42759 5041 13 estimate estimate NN 42759 5041 14 of of IN 42759 5041 15 $ $ $ 42759 5041 16 876.43 876.43 CD 42759 5041 17 for for IN 42759 5041 18 New New NNP 42759 5041 19 York York NNP 42759 5041 20 City City NNP 42759 5041 21 , , , 42759 5041 22 and and CC 42759 5041 23 $ $ $ 42759 5041 24 772.43 772.43 CD 42759 5041 25 for for IN 42759 5041 26 Buffalo Buffalo NNP 42759 5041 27 . . . 42759 5042 1 In in IN 42759 5042 2 1908 1908 CD 42759 5042 3 , , , 42759 5042 4 when when WRB 42759 5042 5 the the DT 42759 5042 6 cost cost NN 42759 5042 7 of of IN 42759 5042 8 living living NN 42759 5042 9 was be VBD 42759 5042 10 from from IN 42759 5042 11 ten ten CD 42759 5042 12 to to IN 42759 5042 13 thirty thirty CD 42759 5042 14 per per IN 42759 5042 15 cent cent NN 42759 5042 16 . . . 42759 5043 1 cheaper cheap JJR 42759 5043 2 than than IN 42759 5043 3 to to IN 42759 5043 4 - - HYPH 42759 5043 5 day day NN 42759 5043 6 , , , 42759 5043 7 the the DT 42759 5043 8 United United NNP 42759 5043 9 States States NNP 42759 5043 10 Bureau Bureau NNP 42759 5043 11 of of IN 42759 5043 12 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5043 13 found find VBD 42759 5043 14 that that IN 42759 5043 15 , , , 42759 5043 16 " " '' 42759 5043 17 according accord VBG 42759 5043 18 to to IN 42759 5043 19 the the DT 42759 5043 20 customs custom NNS 42759 5043 21 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 5043 22 in in IN 42759 5043 23 the the DT 42759 5043 24 communities community NNS 42759 5043 25 selected select VBN 42759 5043 26 for for IN 42759 5043 27 study study NN 42759 5043 28 , , , 42759 5043 29 " " '' 42759 5043 30 a a DT 42759 5043 31 fair fair JJ 42759 5043 32 standard standard NN 42759 5043 33 of of IN 42759 5043 34 living live VBG 42759 5043 35 for for IN 42759 5043 36 a a DT 42759 5043 37 family family NN 42759 5043 38 of of IN 42759 5043 39 five five CD 42759 5043 40 persons person NNS 42759 5043 41 among among IN 42759 5043 42 mill mill NN 42759 5043 43 workers worker NNS 42759 5043 44 , , , 42759 5043 45 was be VBD 42759 5043 46 $ $ $ 42759 5043 47 600.74 600.74 CD 42759 5043 48 in in IN 42759 5043 49 the the DT 42759 5043 50 South South NNP 42759 5043 51 , , , 42759 5043 52 and and CC 42759 5043 53 from from IN 42759 5043 54 $ $ $ 42759 5043 55 690.60 690.60 CD 42759 5043 56 to to IN 42759 5043 57 $ $ $ 42759 5043 58 731.64 731.64 CD 42759 5043 59 in in IN 42759 5043 60 Fall Fall NNP 42759 5043 61 River River NNP 42759 5043 62 , , , 42759 5043 63 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 42759 5043 64 . . . 42759 5044 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5044 2 250 250 CD 42759 5044 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5044 4 According accord VBG 42759 5044 5 to to IN 42759 5044 6 the the DT 42759 5044 7 " " `` 42759 5044 8 Manly Manly NNP 42759 5044 9 Report Report NNP 42759 5044 10 " " '' 42759 5044 11 of of IN 42759 5044 12 the the DT 42759 5044 13 Federal Federal NNP 42759 5044 14 Commission Commission NNP 42759 5044 15 on on IN 42759 5044 16 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 5044 17 Relations Relations NNPS 42759 5044 18 , , , 42759 5044 19 between between IN 42759 5044 20 two two CD 42759 5044 21 - - HYPH 42759 5044 22 thirds third NNS 42759 5044 23 and and CC 42759 5044 24 three three CD 42759 5044 25 - - HYPH 42759 5044 26 fourths fourth NNS 42759 5044 27 of of IN 42759 5044 28 the the DT 42759 5044 29 adult adult NN 42759 5044 30 male male JJ 42759 5044 31 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5044 32 of of IN 42759 5044 33 the the DT 42759 5044 34 United United NNP 42759 5044 35 States States NNP 42759 5044 36 receive receive VBP 42759 5044 37 less less JJR 42759 5044 38 than than IN 42759 5044 39 $ $ $ 42759 5044 40 750.00 750.00 CD 42759 5044 41 a a DT 42759 5044 42 year year NN 42759 5044 43 , , , 42759 5044 44 and and CC 42759 5044 45 the the DT 42759 5044 46 same same JJ 42759 5044 47 proportion proportion NN 42759 5044 48 of of IN 42759 5044 49 women woman NNS 42759 5044 50 workers worker NNS 42759 5044 51 are be VBP 42759 5044 52 paid pay VBN 42759 5044 53 under under IN 42759 5044 54 eight eight CD 42759 5044 55 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5044 56 a a DT 42759 5044 57 week week NN 42759 5044 58 . . . 42759 5045 1 A a DT 42759 5045 2 considerable considerable JJ 42759 5045 3 majority majority NN 42759 5045 4 , , , 42759 5045 5 therefore therefore RB 42759 5045 6 , , , 42759 5045 7 of of IN 42759 5045 8 both both CC 42759 5045 9 male male JJ 42759 5045 10 and and CC 42759 5045 11 female female JJ 42759 5045 12 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5045 13 fail fail VBP 42759 5045 14 to to TO 42759 5045 15 obtain obtain VB 42759 5045 16 living live VBG 42759 5045 17 wages wage NNS 42759 5045 18 . . . 42759 5046 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 5046 2 are be VBP 42759 5046 3 still still RB 42759 5046 4 very very RB 42759 5046 5 far far RB 42759 5046 6 from from IN 42759 5046 7 having have VBG 42759 5046 8 actualised actualise VBN 42759 5046 9 even even RB 42759 5046 10 the the DT 42759 5046 11 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5046 12 measure measure NN 42759 5046 13 of of IN 42759 5046 14 wage wage NN 42759 5046 15 justice justice NN 42759 5046 16 . . . 42759 5047 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 5047 2 : : : 42759 5047 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5047 4 242 242 CD 42759 5047 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5047 6 Cf cf NN 42759 5047 7 . . . 42759 5048 1 Skelton Skelton NNP 42759 5048 2 , , , 42759 5048 3 " " `` 42759 5048 4 Socialism socialism NN 42759 5048 5 : : : 42759 5048 6 A a DT 42759 5048 7 Critical Critical NNP 42759 5048 8 Analysis Analysis NNP 42759 5048 9 , , , 42759 5048 10 " " '' 42759 5048 11 p. p. NN 42759 5048 12 202 202 CD 42759 5048 13 ; ; : 42759 5048 14 Menger Menger NNP 42759 5048 15 , , , 42759 5048 16 " " `` 42759 5048 17 The the DT 42759 5048 18 Right right UH 42759 5048 19 to to IN 42759 5048 20 the the DT 42759 5048 21 Whole Whole NNP 42759 5048 22 Produce Produce NNP 42759 5048 23 of of IN 42759 5048 24 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5048 25 , , , 42759 5048 26 " " '' 42759 5048 27 pp pp NNP 42759 5048 28 . . . 42759 5049 1 8 8 CD 42759 5049 2 , , , 42759 5049 3 sq sq NNP 42759 5049 4 . . . 42759 5050 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5050 2 243 243 CD 42759 5050 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5050 4 All all PDT 42759 5050 5 the the DT 42759 5050 6 questions question NNS 42759 5050 7 treated treat VBN 42759 5050 8 in in IN 42759 5050 9 this this DT 42759 5050 10 chapter chapter NN 42759 5050 11 are be VBP 42759 5050 12 discussed discuss VBN 42759 5050 13 at at IN 42759 5050 14 much much RB 42759 5050 15 greater great JJR 42759 5050 16 length length NN 42759 5050 17 in in IN 42759 5050 18 the the DT 42759 5050 19 author author NN 42759 5050 20 's 's POS 42759 5050 21 work work NN 42759 5050 22 , , , 42759 5050 23 " " `` 42759 5050 24 A a DT 42759 5050 25 Living live VBG 42759 5050 26 Wage wage NN 42759 5050 27 " " '' 42759 5050 28 ; ; : 42759 5050 29 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 5050 30 ; ; : 42759 5050 31 1906 1906 CD 42759 5050 32 . . . 42759 5051 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5051 2 244 244 CD 42759 5051 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5051 4 See see VB 42759 5051 5 chapters chapter NNS 42759 5051 6 xii xii NNP 42759 5051 7 and and CC 42759 5051 8 xiii xiii NNP 42759 5051 9 . . . 42759 5052 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5052 2 245 245 CD 42759 5052 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5052 4 While while IN 42759 5052 5 the the DT 42759 5052 6 statement statement NN 42759 5052 7 in in IN 42759 5052 8 the the DT 42759 5052 9 text text NN 42759 5052 10 applies apply VBZ 42759 5052 11 to to IN 42759 5052 12 _ _ NNP 42759 5052 13 all all DT 42759 5052 14 _ _ NNP 42759 5052 15 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5052 16 of of IN 42759 5052 17 less less JJR 42759 5052 18 than than IN 42759 5052 19 average average JJ 42759 5052 20 ability ability NN 42759 5052 21 , , , 42759 5052 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5052 23 obviously obviously RB 42759 5052 24 is be VBZ 42759 5052 25 applicable applicable JJ 42759 5052 26 only only RB 42759 5052 27 to to IN 42759 5052 28 individual individual JJ 42759 5052 29 cases case NNS 42759 5052 30 among among IN 42759 5052 31 those those DT 42759 5052 32 who who WP 42759 5052 33 are be VBP 42759 5052 34 up up IN 42759 5052 35 to to IN 42759 5052 36 the the DT 42759 5052 37 average average NN 42759 5052 38 . . . 42759 5053 1 These these DT 42759 5053 2 are be VBP 42759 5053 3 the the DT 42759 5053 4 workers worker NNS 42759 5053 5 at at IN 42759 5053 6 the the DT 42759 5053 7 " " `` 42759 5053 8 margin margin NN 42759 5053 9 " " '' 42759 5053 10 of of IN 42759 5053 11 the the DT 42759 5053 12 labour labour JJ 42759 5053 13 force force NN 42759 5053 14 in in IN 42759 5053 15 an an DT 42759 5053 16 establishment establishment NN 42759 5053 17 , , , 42759 5053 18 those those DT 42759 5053 19 who who WP 42759 5053 20 could could MD 42759 5053 21 be be VB 42759 5053 22 discharged discharge VBN 42759 5053 23 without without IN 42759 5053 24 causing cause VBG 42759 5053 25 the the DT 42759 5053 26 industry industry NN 42759 5053 27 to to TO 42759 5053 28 shut shut VB 42759 5053 29 down down RP 42759 5053 30 . . . 42759 5054 1 If if IN 42759 5054 2 an an DT 42759 5054 3 employer employer NN 42759 5054 4 would would MD 42759 5054 5 rather rather RB 42759 5054 6 go go VB 42759 5054 7 out out IN 42759 5054 8 of of IN 42759 5054 9 business business NN 42759 5054 10 than than IN 42759 5054 11 pay pay VB 42759 5054 12 a a DT 42759 5054 13 living living NN 42759 5054 14 wage wage NN 42759 5054 15 to to IN 42759 5054 16 all all DT 42759 5054 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5054 18 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5054 19 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5054 20 of of IN 42759 5054 21 average average JJ 42759 5054 22 ability ability NN 42759 5054 23 , , , 42759 5054 24 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5054 25 is be VBZ 42759 5054 26 morally morally RB 42759 5054 27 free free JJ 42759 5054 28 to to TO 42759 5054 29 do do VB 42759 5054 30 so so RB 42759 5054 31 ; ; : 42759 5054 32 but but CC 42759 5054 33 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5054 34 may may MD 42759 5054 35 not not RB 42759 5054 36 employ employ VB 42759 5054 37 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5054 38 at at IN 42759 5054 39 less less RBR 42759 5054 40 than than IN 42759 5054 41 living live VBG 42759 5054 42 wages wage NNS 42759 5054 43 in in IN 42759 5054 44 order order NN 42759 5054 45 to to TO 42759 5054 46 obtain obtain VB 42759 5054 47 interest interest NN 42759 5054 48 on on IN 42759 5054 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5054 50 capital capital NN 42759 5054 51 . . . 42759 5055 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5055 2 246 246 CD 42759 5055 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5055 4 One one CD 42759 5055 5 of of IN 42759 5055 6 the the DT 42759 5055 7 best good JJS 42759 5055 8 statements statement NNS 42759 5055 9 of of IN 42759 5055 10 the the DT 42759 5055 11 evil evil JJ 42759 5055 12 social social JJ 42759 5055 13 results result NNS 42759 5055 14 of of IN 42759 5055 15 low low JJ 42759 5055 16 wages wage NNS 42759 5055 17 will will MD 42759 5055 18 be be VB 42759 5055 19 found find VBN 42759 5055 20 in in IN 42759 5055 21 Webb Webb NNP 42759 5055 22 's 's POS 42759 5055 23 " " `` 42759 5055 24 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 5055 25 Democracy Democracy NNP 42759 5055 26 , , , 42759 5055 27 " " '' 42759 5055 28 vol vol NNP 42759 5055 29 . . . 42759 5056 1 II II NNP 42759 5056 2 , , , 42759 5056 3 pp pp NNP 42759 5056 4 . . . 42759 5057 1 749 749 CD 42759 5057 2 - - HYPH 42759 5057 3 766 766 CD 42759 5057 4 . . . 42759 5058 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5058 2 247 247 CD 42759 5058 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5058 4 See see VB 42759 5058 5 reports report NNS 42759 5058 6 of of IN 42759 5058 7 these these DT 42759 5058 8 commissions commission NNS 42759 5058 9 in in IN 42759 5058 10 Oregon Oregon NNP 42759 5058 11 , , , 42759 5058 12 Washington Washington NNP 42759 5058 13 , , , 42759 5058 14 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 42759 5058 15 , , , 42759 5058 16 Minnesota Minnesota NNP 42759 5058 17 , , , 42759 5058 18 and and CC 42759 5058 19 California California NNP 42759 5058 20 . . . 42759 5059 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5059 2 248 248 CD 42759 5059 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5059 4 " " `` 42759 5059 5 A a DT 42759 5059 6 Living live VBG 42759 5059 7 Wage wage NN 42759 5059 8 , , , 42759 5059 9 " " '' 42759 5059 10 p. p. NN 42759 5059 11 150 150 CD 42759 5059 12 . . . 42759 5060 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5060 2 249 249 CD 42759 5060 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5060 4 See see VB 42759 5060 5 Bulletins bulletin NNS 42759 5060 6 of of IN 42759 5060 7 the the DT 42759 5060 8 Federal Federal NNP 42759 5060 9 Bureau Bureau NNP 42759 5060 10 of of IN 42759 5060 11 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5060 12 Statistics Statistics NNP 42759 5060 13 on on IN 42759 5060 14 " " `` 42759 5060 15 Retail Retail NNP 42759 5060 16 Prices Prices NNPS 42759 5060 17 " " '' 42759 5060 18 ; ; : 42759 5060 19 and and CC 42759 5060 20 Nearing Nearing NNP 42759 5060 21 , , , 42759 5060 22 " " `` 42759 5060 23 Reducing reduce VBG 42759 5060 24 the the DT 42759 5060 25 Cost cost NN 42759 5060 26 of of IN 42759 5060 27 Living living NN 42759 5060 28 . . . 42759 5060 29 " " '' 42759 5061 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5061 2 250 250 CD 42759 5061 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5061 4 " " `` 42759 5061 5 Summary Summary NNP 42759 5061 6 of of IN 42759 5061 7 the the DT 42759 5061 8 Report Report NNP 42759 5061 9 on on IN 42759 5061 10 Condition Condition NNP 42759 5061 11 of of IN 42759 5061 12 Woman Woman NNP 42759 5061 13 and and CC 42759 5061 14 Child Child NNP 42759 5061 15 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5061 16 Earners Earners NNPS 42759 5061 17 in in IN 42759 5061 18 the the DT 42759 5061 19 United United NNP 42759 5061 20 States States NNP 42759 5061 21 , , , 42759 5061 22 " " '' 42759 5061 23 pp pp NNP 42759 5061 24 . . . 42759 5062 1 383 383 CD 42759 5062 2 , , , 42759 5062 3 384 384 CD 42759 5062 4 . . . 42759 5063 1 The the DT 42759 5063 2 best good JJS 42759 5063 3 intensive intensive JJ 42759 5063 4 study study NN 42759 5063 5 of of IN 42759 5063 6 family family NN 42759 5063 7 cost cost NN 42759 5063 8 of of IN 42759 5063 9 living living NN 42759 5063 10 is be VBZ 42759 5063 11 that that DT 42759 5063 12 published publish VBN 42759 5063 13 in in IN 42759 5063 14 the the DT 42759 5063 15 volume volume NN 42759 5063 16 edited edit VBN 42759 5063 17 by by IN 42759 5063 18 Robert Robert NNP 42759 5063 19 C. C. NNP 42759 5063 20 Chapin Chapin NNP 42759 5063 21 , , , 42759 5063 22 " " `` 42759 5063 23 The the DT 42759 5063 24 Standard standard NN 42759 5063 25 of of IN 42759 5063 26 Living live VBG 42759 5063 27 Among among IN 42759 5063 28 Workingmen Workingmen NNPS 42759 5063 29 's 's POS 42759 5063 30 Families Families NNPS 42759 5063 31 in in IN 42759 5063 32 New New NNP 42759 5063 33 York York NNP 42759 5063 34 City City NNP 42759 5063 35 " " '' 42759 5063 36 ; ; : 42759 5063 37 1909 1909 CD 42759 5063 38 . . . 42759 5064 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5064 2 led lead VBD 42759 5064 3 to to IN 42759 5064 4 the the DT 42759 5064 5 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 5064 6 that that IN 42759 5064 7 anything anything NN 42759 5064 8 less less JJR 42759 5064 9 than than IN 42759 5064 10 eight eight CD 42759 5064 11 hundred hundred CD 42759 5064 12 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5064 13 was be VBD 42759 5064 14 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 5064 15 for for IN 42759 5064 16 the the DT 42759 5064 17 yearly yearly JJ 42759 5064 18 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 5064 19 of of IN 42759 5064 20 a a DT 42759 5064 21 husband husband NN 42759 5064 22 and and CC 42759 5064 23 wife wife NN 42759 5064 24 and and CC 42759 5064 25 three three CD 42759 5064 26 small small JJ 42759 5064 27 children child NNS 42759 5064 28 in in IN 42759 5064 29 Manhattan Manhattan NNP 42759 5064 30 . . . 42759 5065 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 5065 2 XXIV XXIV NNP 42759 5065 3 THE the DT 42759 5065 4 PROBLEM problem NN 42759 5065 5 OF of IN 42759 5065 6 COMPLETE complete NN 42759 5065 7 WAGE wage NN 42759 5065 8 JUSTICE justice NN 42759 5065 9 A a DT 42759 5065 10 living living NN 42759 5065 11 wage wage NN 42759 5065 12 for for IN 42759 5065 13 all all DT 42759 5065 14 workers worker NNS 42759 5065 15 is be VBZ 42759 5065 16 merely merely RB 42759 5065 17 the the DT 42759 5065 18 _ _ NNP 42759 5065 19 minimum minimum NN 42759 5065 20 _ _ NNP 42759 5065 21 measure measure NN 42759 5065 22 of of IN 42759 5065 23 just just JJ 42759 5065 24 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5065 25 . . . 42759 5066 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5066 2 is be VBZ 42759 5066 3 not not RB 42759 5066 4 in in IN 42759 5066 5 every every DT 42759 5066 6 case case NN 42759 5066 7 complete complete JJ 42759 5066 8 justice justice NN 42759 5066 9 . . . 42759 5067 1 Possibly possibly RB 42759 5067 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5067 3 is be VBZ 42759 5067 4 not not RB 42759 5067 5 the the DT 42759 5067 6 full full JJ 42759 5067 7 measure measure NN 42759 5067 8 of of IN 42759 5067 9 justice justice NN 42759 5067 10 in in IN 42759 5067 11 any any DT 42759 5067 12 case case NN 42759 5067 13 . . . 42759 5068 1 How how WRB 42759 5068 2 much much RB 42759 5068 3 more more JJR 42759 5068 4 than than IN 42759 5068 5 a a DT 42759 5068 6 living living NN 42759 5068 7 wage wage NN 42759 5068 8 is be VBZ 42759 5068 9 due due JJ 42759 5068 10 to to IN 42759 5068 11 any any DT 42759 5068 12 or or CC 42759 5068 13 all all DT 42759 5068 14 of of IN 42759 5068 15 the the DT 42759 5068 16 various various JJ 42759 5068 17 classes class NNS 42759 5068 18 of of IN 42759 5068 19 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5068 20 ? ? . 42759 5069 1 How how WRB 42759 5069 2 much much RB 42759 5069 3 more more JJR 42759 5069 4 may may MD 42759 5069 5 any any DT 42759 5069 6 group group NN 42759 5069 7 of of IN 42759 5069 8 workers worker NNS 42759 5069 9 demand demand NN 42759 5069 10 without without IN 42759 5069 11 exposing expose VBG 42759 5069 12 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 5069 13 to to IN 42759 5069 14 the the DT 42759 5069 15 sin sin NN 42759 5069 16 of of IN 42759 5069 17 extortion extortion NN 42759 5069 18 ? ? . 42759 5070 1 By by IN 42759 5070 2 what what WDT 42759 5070 3 principles principle NNS 42759 5070 4 shall shall MD 42759 5070 5 these these DT 42759 5070 6 questions question NNS 42759 5070 7 be be VB 42759 5070 8 answered answer VBN 42759 5070 9 ? ? . 42759 5071 1 The the DT 42759 5071 2 problem problem NN 42759 5071 3 of of IN 42759 5071 4 complete complete JJ 42759 5071 5 wage wage NN 42759 5071 6 justice justice NN 42759 5071 7 can can MD 42759 5071 8 be be VB 42759 5071 9 conveniently conveniently RB 42759 5071 10 and and CC 42759 5071 11 logically logically RB 42759 5071 12 considered consider VBN 42759 5071 13 in in IN 42759 5071 14 four four CD 42759 5071 15 distinct distinct JJ 42759 5071 16 relations relation NNS 42759 5071 17 , , , 42759 5071 18 as as IN 42759 5071 19 regards regard NNS 42759 5071 20 : : : 42759 5071 21 the the DT 42759 5071 22 respective respective JJ 42759 5071 23 claims claim NNS 42759 5071 24 of of IN 42759 5071 25 the the DT 42759 5071 26 different different JJ 42759 5071 27 classes class NNS 42759 5071 28 of of IN 42759 5071 29 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5071 30 to to IN 42759 5071 31 a a DT 42759 5071 32 given give VBN 42759 5071 33 amount amount NN 42759 5071 34 of of IN 42759 5071 35 money money NN 42759 5071 36 available available JJ 42759 5071 37 for for IN 42759 5071 38 wage wage NN 42759 5071 39 payments payment NNS 42759 5071 40 ; ; : 42759 5071 41 the the DT 42759 5071 42 claims claim NNS 42759 5071 43 of of IN 42759 5071 44 the the DT 42759 5071 45 whole whole JJ 42759 5071 46 body body NN 42759 5071 47 of of IN 42759 5071 48 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5071 49 , , , 42759 5071 50 or or CC 42759 5071 51 any any DT 42759 5071 52 group group NN 42759 5071 53 thereof thereof RB 42759 5071 54 , , , 42759 5071 55 to to IN 42759 5071 56 higher high JJR 42759 5071 57 wages wage NNS 42759 5071 58 at at IN 42759 5071 59 the the DT 42759 5071 60 expense expense NN 42759 5071 61 of of IN 42759 5071 62 profits profit NNS 42759 5071 63 ; ; : 42759 5071 64 at at IN 42759 5071 65 the the DT 42759 5071 66 expense expense NN 42759 5071 67 of of IN 42759 5071 68 interest interest NN 42759 5071 69 ; ; : 42759 5071 70 and and CC 42759 5071 71 at at IN 42759 5071 72 the the DT 42759 5071 73 expense expense NN 42759 5071 74 of of IN 42759 5071 75 the the DT 42759 5071 76 consumer consumer NN 42759 5071 77 . . . 42759 5072 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5072 2 Comparative comparative JJ 42759 5072 3 Claims Claims NNPS 42759 5072 4 of of IN 42759 5072 5 Different Different NNP 42759 5072 6 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5072 7 Groups Groups NNPS 42759 5072 8 _ _ XX 42759 5072 9 In in IN 42759 5072 10 the the DT 42759 5072 11 division division NN 42759 5072 12 of of IN 42759 5072 13 a a DT 42759 5072 14 common common JJ 42759 5072 15 wage wage NN 42759 5072 16 fund fund NN 42759 5072 17 , , , 42759 5072 18 no no DT 42759 5072 19 section section NN 42759 5072 20 of of IN 42759 5072 21 the the DT 42759 5072 22 workers worker NNS 42759 5072 23 is be VBZ 42759 5072 24 entitled entitle VBN 42759 5072 25 to to IN 42759 5072 26 anything anything NN 42759 5072 27 in in IN 42759 5072 28 excess excess NN 42759 5072 29 of of IN 42759 5072 30 living live VBG 42759 5072 31 wages wage NNS 42759 5072 32 until until IN 42759 5072 33 all all PDT 42759 5072 34 the the DT 42759 5072 35 other other JJ 42759 5072 36 sections section NNS 42759 5072 37 have have VBP 42759 5072 38 received receive VBN 42759 5072 39 that that DT 42759 5072 40 amount amount NN 42759 5072 41 of of IN 42759 5072 42 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5072 43 . . . 42759 5073 1 The the DT 42759 5073 2 need need NN 42759 5073 3 of of IN 42759 5073 4 a a DT 42759 5073 5 decent decent JJ 42759 5073 6 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5073 7 constitutes constitute VBZ 42759 5073 8 a a DT 42759 5073 9 more more RBR 42759 5073 10 urgent urgent JJ 42759 5073 11 claim claim NN 42759 5073 12 than than IN 42759 5073 13 any any DT 42759 5073 14 other other JJ 42759 5073 15 that that WDT 42759 5073 16 can can MD 42759 5073 17 be be VB 42759 5073 18 brought bring VBN 42759 5073 19 forward forward RB 42759 5073 20 . . . 42759 5074 1 Neither neither DT 42759 5074 2 efforts effort NNS 42759 5074 3 , , , 42759 5074 4 nor nor CC 42759 5074 5 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5074 6 , , , 42759 5074 7 nor nor CC 42759 5074 8 productivity productivity NN 42759 5074 9 , , , 42759 5074 10 nor nor CC 42759 5074 11 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5074 12 can can MD 42759 5074 13 justify justify VB 42759 5074 14 the the DT 42759 5074 15 payment payment NN 42759 5074 16 of of IN 42759 5074 17 more more JJR 42759 5074 18 than than IN 42759 5074 19 living live VBG 42759 5074 20 wages wage NNS 42759 5074 21 to to IN 42759 5074 22 any any DT 42759 5074 23 group group NN 42759 5074 24 , , , 42759 5074 25 so so RB 42759 5074 26 long long RB 42759 5074 27 as as IN 42759 5074 28 any any DT 42759 5074 29 other other JJ 42759 5074 30 group group NN 42759 5074 31 in in IN 42759 5074 32 the the DT 42759 5074 33 industry industry NN 42759 5074 34 remains remain VBZ 42759 5074 35 below below IN 42759 5074 36 that that DT 42759 5074 37 level level NN 42759 5074 38 ; ; : 42759 5074 39 for for IN 42759 5074 40 the the DT 42759 5074 41 extra extra JJ 42759 5074 42 compensation compensation NN 42759 5074 43 will will MD 42759 5074 44 supply supply VB 42759 5074 45 the the DT 42759 5074 46 nonessential nonessential JJ 42759 5074 47 needs need NNS 42759 5074 48 of of IN 42759 5074 49 the the DT 42759 5074 50 former former JJ 42759 5074 51 by by IN 42759 5074 52 denying deny VBG 42759 5074 53 the the DT 42759 5074 54 essential essential JJ 42759 5074 55 needs need NNS 42759 5074 56 of of IN 42759 5074 57 the the DT 42759 5074 58 latter latter JJ 42759 5074 59 . . . 42759 5075 1 The the DT 42759 5075 2 two two CD 42759 5075 3 groups group NNS 42759 5075 4 of of IN 42759 5075 5 men man NNS 42759 5075 6 will will MD 42759 5075 7 be be VB 42759 5075 8 treated treat VBN 42759 5075 9 unequally unequally RB 42759 5075 10 in in IN 42759 5075 11 respect respect NN 42759 5075 12 of of IN 42759 5075 13 those those DT 42759 5075 14 qualities quality NNS 42759 5075 15 in in IN 42759 5075 16 which which WDT 42759 5075 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5075 18 are be VBP 42759 5075 19 equal equal JJ 42759 5075 20 ; ; : 42759 5075 21 namely namely RB 42759 5075 22 , , , 42759 5075 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5075 24 personal personal JJ 42759 5075 25 dignity dignity NN 42759 5075 26 and and CC 42759 5075 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5075 28 claims claim NNS 42759 5075 29 to to IN 42759 5075 30 the the DT 42759 5075 31 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5075 32 requisites requisite NNS 42759 5075 33 of of IN 42759 5075 34 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5075 35 life life NN 42759 5075 36 and and CC 42759 5075 37 self self NN 42759 5075 38 development development NN 42759 5075 39 . . . 42759 5076 1 This this DT 42759 5076 2 is be VBZ 42759 5076 3 a a DT 42759 5076 4 violation violation NN 42759 5076 5 of of IN 42759 5076 6 justice justice NN 42759 5076 7 . . . 42759 5077 1 Let let VB 42759 5077 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 5077 3 suppose suppose VB 42759 5077 4 that that IN 42759 5077 5 all all PDT 42759 5077 6 the the DT 42759 5077 7 workers worker NNS 42759 5077 8 among among IN 42759 5077 9 whom whom WP 42759 5077 10 a a DT 42759 5077 11 given give VBN 42759 5077 12 amount amount NN 42759 5077 13 of of IN 42759 5077 14 compensation compensation NN 42759 5077 15 is be VBZ 42759 5077 16 to to TO 42759 5077 17 be be VB 42759 5077 18 distributed distribute VBN 42759 5077 19 , , , 42759 5077 20 have have VBP 42759 5077 21 already already RB 42759 5077 22 received receive VBN 42759 5077 23 living live VBG 42759 5077 24 wages wage NNS 42759 5077 25 , , , 42759 5077 26 and and CC 42759 5077 27 that that IN 42759 5077 28 there there EX 42759 5077 29 remains remain VBZ 42759 5077 30 a a DT 42759 5077 31 considerable considerable JJ 42759 5077 32 surplus surplus NN 42759 5077 33 . . . 42759 5078 1 On on IN 42759 5078 2 what what WDT 42759 5078 3 principles principle NNS 42759 5078 4 should should MD 42759 5078 5 the the DT 42759 5078 6 surplus surplus NN 42759 5078 7 be be VB 42759 5078 8 apportioned apportion VBN 42759 5078 9 ? ? . 42759 5079 1 For for IN 42759 5079 2 answer answer NN 42759 5079 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5079 4 turn turn VBP 42759 5079 5 to to IN 42759 5079 6 the the DT 42759 5079 7 canons canon NNS 42759 5079 8 of of IN 42759 5079 9 distribution distribution NN 42759 5079 10 , , , 42759 5079 11 as as IN 42759 5079 12 explained explain VBN 42759 5079 13 in in IN 42759 5079 14 chapter chapter NN 42759 5079 15 xvi xvi NNP 42759 5079 16 . . . 42759 5080 1 When when WRB 42759 5080 2 the the DT 42759 5080 3 elementary elementary JJ 42759 5080 4 needs need NNS 42759 5080 5 of of IN 42759 5080 6 life life NN 42759 5080 7 and and CC 42759 5080 8 development development NN 42759 5080 9 have have VBP 42759 5080 10 been be VBN 42759 5080 11 supplied supply VBN 42759 5080 12 , , , 42759 5080 13 the the DT 42759 5080 14 next next JJ 42759 5080 15 consideration consideration NN 42759 5080 16 might may MD 42759 5080 17 seem seem VB 42759 5080 18 to to TO 42759 5080 19 be be VB 42759 5080 20 the the DT 42759 5080 21 higher high JJR 42759 5080 22 or or CC 42759 5080 23 nonessential nonessential JJ 42759 5080 24 needs need NNS 42759 5080 25 and and CC 42759 5080 26 capacities capacity NNS 42759 5080 27 . . . 42759 5081 1 Proportional proportional JJ 42759 5081 2 justice justice NN 42759 5081 3 would would MD 42759 5081 4 seem seem VB 42759 5081 5 to to TO 42759 5081 6 suggest suggest VB 42759 5081 7 that that IN 42759 5081 8 the the DT 42759 5081 9 surplus surplus NN 42759 5081 10 ought ought MD 42759 5081 11 to to TO 42759 5081 12 be be VB 42759 5081 13 distributed distribute VBN 42759 5081 14 in in IN 42759 5081 15 accordance accordance NN 42759 5081 16 with with IN 42759 5081 17 the the DT 42759 5081 18 varying varying NN 42759 5081 19 needs need NNS 42759 5081 20 and and CC 42759 5081 21 capacities capacity NNS 42759 5081 22 of of IN 42759 5081 23 men man NNS 42759 5081 24 to to TO 42759 5081 25 develop develop VB 42759 5081 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5081 27 faculties faculty NNS 42759 5081 28 beyond beyond IN 42759 5081 29 the the DT 42759 5081 30 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5081 31 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5081 32 degree degree NN 42759 5081 33 . . . 42759 5082 1 As as IN 42759 5082 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5082 3 have have VBP 42759 5082 4 already already RB 42759 5082 5 pointed point VBN 42759 5082 6 out out RP 42759 5082 7 , , , 42759 5082 8 this this DT 42759 5082 9 would would MD 42759 5082 10 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 5082 11 be be VB 42759 5082 12 the the DT 42759 5082 13 proper proper JJ 42759 5082 14 rule rule NN 42759 5082 15 if if IN 42759 5082 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5082 17 were be VBD 42759 5082 18 susceptible susceptible JJ 42759 5082 19 of of IN 42759 5082 20 anything anything NN 42759 5082 21 like like IN 42759 5082 22 accurate accurate JJ 42759 5082 23 application application NN 42759 5082 24 , , , 42759 5082 25 and and CC 42759 5082 26 if if IN 42759 5082 27 the the DT 42759 5082 28 sum sum NN 42759 5082 29 to to TO 42759 5082 30 be be VB 42759 5082 31 distributed distribute VBN 42759 5082 32 were be VBD 42759 5082 33 not not RB 42759 5082 34 produced produce VBN 42759 5082 35 by by IN 42759 5082 36 and and CC 42759 5082 37 dependent dependent JJ 42759 5082 38 upon upon IN 42759 5082 39 those those DT 42759 5082 40 who who WP 42759 5082 41 were be VBD 42759 5082 42 to to TO 42759 5082 43 participate participate VB 42759 5082 44 in in IN 42759 5082 45 the the DT 42759 5082 46 distribution distribution NN 42759 5082 47 . . . 42759 5083 1 However however RB 42759 5083 2 , , , 42759 5083 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5083 4 know know VBP 42759 5083 5 that that IN 42759 5083 6 the the DT 42759 5083 7 first first JJ 42759 5083 8 condition condition NN 42759 5083 9 is be VBZ 42759 5083 10 impracticable impracticable JJ 42759 5083 11 , , , 42759 5083 12 while while IN 42759 5083 13 the the DT 42759 5083 14 second second JJ 42759 5083 15 is be VBZ 42759 5083 16 non non JJ 42759 5083 17 - - JJ 42759 5083 18 existent existent NN 42759 5083 19 . . . 42759 5084 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 5084 2 as as IN 42759 5084 3 the the DT 42759 5084 4 sharers sharer NNS 42759 5084 5 in in IN 42759 5084 6 the the DT 42759 5084 7 distribution distribution NN 42759 5084 8 have have VBP 42759 5084 9 produced produce VBN 42759 5084 10 and and CC 42759 5084 11 constantly constantly RB 42759 5084 12 determine determine VB 42759 5084 13 the the DT 42759 5084 14 amount amount NN 42759 5084 15 to to TO 42759 5084 16 be be VB 42759 5084 17 apportioned apportion VBN 42759 5084 18 , , , 42759 5084 19 the the DT 42759 5084 20 distributive distributive JJ 42759 5084 21 process process NN 42759 5084 22 must must MD 42759 5084 23 disregard disregard VB 42759 5084 24 nonessential nonessential JJ 42759 5084 25 needs need NNS 42759 5084 26 , , , 42759 5084 27 and and CC 42759 5084 28 govern govern VB 42759 5084 29 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 5084 30 by by IN 42759 5084 31 other other JJ 42759 5084 32 canons canon NNS 42759 5084 33 of of IN 42759 5084 34 justice justice NN 42759 5084 35 . . . 42759 5085 1 The the DT 42759 5085 2 most most RBS 42759 5085 3 urgent urgent JJ 42759 5085 4 of of IN 42759 5085 5 these these DT 42759 5085 6 is be VBZ 42759 5085 7 the the DT 42759 5085 8 canon canon NN 42759 5085 9 of of IN 42759 5085 10 efforts effort NNS 42759 5085 11 and and CC 42759 5085 12 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5085 13 . . . 42759 5086 1 Superior superior JJ 42759 5086 2 effort effort NN 42759 5086 3 , , , 42759 5086 4 as as IN 42759 5086 5 measured measure VBN 42759 5086 6 by by IN 42759 5086 7 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5086 8 will will NN 42759 5086 9 - - HYPH 42759 5086 10 exertion exertion NN 42759 5086 11 , , , 42759 5086 12 is be VBZ 42759 5086 13 a a DT 42759 5086 14 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 5086 15 rule rule NN 42759 5086 16 of of IN 42759 5086 17 justice justice NN 42759 5086 18 , , , 42759 5086 19 and and CC 42759 5086 20 a a DT 42759 5086 21 valid valid JJ 42759 5086 22 title title NN 42759 5086 23 to to IN 42759 5086 24 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5086 25 reward reward NN 42759 5086 26 . . . 42759 5087 1 Men man NNS 42759 5087 2 who who WP 42759 5087 3 strive strive VBP 42759 5087 4 harder hard RBR 42759 5087 5 than than IN 42759 5087 6 the the DT 42759 5087 7 majority majority NN 42759 5087 8 of of IN 42759 5087 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5087 10 fellows fellow NNS 42759 5087 11 are be VBP 42759 5087 12 ethically ethically RB 42759 5087 13 deserving deserving JJ 42759 5087 14 of of IN 42759 5087 15 extra extra JJ 42759 5087 16 compensation compensation NN 42759 5087 17 . . . 42759 5088 1 At at RB 42759 5088 2 least least RBS 42759 5088 3 , , , 42759 5088 4 this this DT 42759 5088 5 is be VBZ 42759 5088 6 the the DT 42759 5088 7 pure pure JJ 42759 5088 8 theory theory NN 42759 5088 9 of of IN 42759 5088 10 the the DT 42759 5088 11 matter matter NN 42759 5088 12 . . . 42759 5089 1 In in IN 42759 5089 2 practice practice NN 42759 5089 3 , , , 42759 5089 4 the the DT 42759 5089 5 situation situation NN 42759 5089 6 is be VBZ 42759 5089 7 complicated complicate VBN 42759 5089 8 by by IN 42759 5089 9 the the DT 42759 5089 10 fact fact NN 42759 5089 11 that that IN 42759 5089 12 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5089 13 effort effort NN 42759 5089 14 can can MD 42759 5089 15 not not RB 42759 5089 16 always always RB 42759 5089 17 be be VB 42759 5089 18 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 5089 19 , , , 42759 5089 20 and and CC 42759 5089 21 by by IN 42759 5089 22 the the DT 42759 5089 23 further further JJ 42759 5089 24 fact fact NN 42759 5089 25 that that IN 42759 5089 26 some some DT 42759 5089 27 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5089 28 efforts effort NNS 42759 5089 29 do do VBP 42759 5089 30 not not RB 42759 5089 31 fructify fructify VB 42759 5089 32 in in IN 42759 5089 33 correspondingly correspondingly RB 42759 5089 34 useful useful JJ 42759 5089 35 results result NNS 42759 5089 36 . . . 42759 5090 1 Among among IN 42759 5090 2 men man NNS 42759 5090 3 engaged engage VBD 42759 5090 4 at at IN 42759 5090 5 the the DT 42759 5090 6 same same JJ 42759 5090 7 kind kind NN 42759 5090 8 of of IN 42759 5090 9 work work NN 42759 5090 10 , , , 42759 5090 11 superior superior JJ 42759 5090 12 effort effort NN 42759 5090 13 is be VBZ 42759 5090 14 to to IN 42759 5090 15 a a DT 42759 5090 16 great great JJ 42759 5090 17 extent extent NN 42759 5090 18 discernible discernible JJ 42759 5090 19 in in IN 42759 5090 20 the the DT 42759 5090 21 unusually unusually RB 42759 5090 22 large large JJ 42759 5090 23 product product NN 42759 5090 24 . . . 42759 5091 1 As as IN 42759 5091 2 such such JJ 42759 5091 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5091 4 actually actually RB 42759 5091 5 receives receive VBZ 42759 5091 6 an an DT 42759 5091 7 extra extra JJ 42759 5091 8 reward reward NN 42759 5091 9 in in IN 42759 5091 10 accordance accordance NN 42759 5091 11 with with IN 42759 5091 12 the the DT 42759 5091 13 canon canon NN 42759 5091 14 of of IN 42759 5091 15 productivity productivity NN 42759 5091 16 . . . 42759 5092 1 When when WRB 42759 5092 2 men man NNS 42759 5092 3 are be VBP 42759 5092 4 employed employ VBN 42759 5092 5 at at IN 42759 5092 6 different different JJ 42759 5092 7 tasks task NNS 42759 5092 8 , , , 42759 5092 9 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5092 10 efforts effort NNS 42759 5092 11 can can MD 42759 5092 12 not not RB 42759 5092 13 generally generally RB 42759 5092 14 be be VB 42759 5092 15 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 5092 16 and and CC 42759 5092 17 compensated compensate VBN 42759 5092 18 . . . 42759 5093 1 Hence hence RB 42759 5093 2 the the DT 42759 5093 3 general general JJ 42759 5093 4 principle principle NN 42759 5093 5 is be VBZ 42759 5093 6 that that IN 42759 5093 7 superior superior JJ 42759 5093 8 efforts effort NNS 42759 5093 9 put put VBN 42759 5093 10 forth forth RB 42759 5093 11 in in IN 42759 5093 12 the the DT 42759 5093 13 production production NN 42759 5093 14 of of IN 42759 5093 15 utilities utility NNS 42759 5093 16 , , , 42759 5093 17 entitle entitle NN 42759 5093 18 men man NNS 42759 5093 19 to to IN 42759 5093 20 something something NN 42759 5093 21 more more JJR 42759 5093 22 than than IN 42759 5093 23 living live VBG 42759 5093 24 wages wage NNS 42759 5093 25 , , , 42759 5093 26 but but CC 42759 5093 27 that that IN 42759 5093 28 the the DT 42759 5093 29 enforcement enforcement NN 42759 5093 30 of of IN 42759 5093 31 this this DT 42759 5093 32 principle principle NN 42759 5093 33 is be VBZ 42759 5093 34 considerably considerably RB 42759 5093 35 hindered hinder VBN 42759 5093 36 by by IN 42759 5093 37 the the DT 42759 5093 38 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 5093 39 of of IN 42759 5093 40 discerning discern VBG 42759 5093 41 such such JJ 42759 5093 42 efforts effort NNS 42759 5093 43 . . . 42759 5094 1 The the DT 42759 5094 2 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5094 3 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5094 4 that that WDT 42759 5094 5 deserve deserve VBP 42759 5094 6 extra extra JJ 42759 5094 7 compensation compensation NN 42759 5094 8 are be VBP 42759 5094 9 connected connect VBN 42759 5094 10 with with IN 42759 5094 11 the the DT 42759 5094 12 costs cost NNS 42759 5094 13 of of IN 42759 5094 14 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5094 15 functions function NNS 42759 5094 16 and and CC 42759 5094 17 the the DT 42759 5094 18 disagreeable disagreeable JJ 42759 5094 19 character character NN 42759 5094 20 of of IN 42759 5094 21 occupations occupation NNS 42759 5094 22 . . . 42759 5095 1 Under under IN 42759 5095 2 the the DT 42759 5095 3 first first JJ 42759 5095 4 head head NN 42759 5095 5 are be VBP 42759 5095 6 included include VBN 42759 5095 7 the the DT 42759 5095 8 expense expense NN 42759 5095 9 of of IN 42759 5095 10 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5095 11 training training NN 42759 5095 12 and and CC 42759 5095 13 the the DT 42759 5095 14 debilitating debilitate VBG 42759 5095 15 effects effect NNS 42759 5095 16 of of IN 42759 5095 17 the the DT 42759 5095 18 work work NN 42759 5095 19 . . . 42759 5096 1 Not not RB 42759 5096 2 only only RB 42759 5096 3 justice justice NN 42759 5096 4 to to IN 42759 5096 5 the the DT 42759 5096 6 worker worker NN 42759 5096 7 but but CC 42759 5096 8 a a DT 42759 5096 9 farsighted farsighted JJ 42759 5096 10 view view NN 42759 5096 11 of of IN 42759 5096 12 social social JJ 42759 5096 13 welfare welfare NN 42759 5096 14 , , , 42759 5096 15 dictate dictate VBP 42759 5096 16 that that IN 42759 5096 17 all all DT 42759 5096 18 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5096 19 costs cost NNS 42759 5096 20 of of IN 42759 5096 21 preparation preparation NN 42759 5096 22 for for IN 42759 5096 23 an an DT 42759 5096 24 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5096 25 craft craft NN 42759 5096 26 or or CC 42759 5096 27 profession profession NN 42759 5096 28 should should MD 42759 5096 29 be be VB 42759 5096 30 repaid repay VBN 42759 5096 31 in in IN 42759 5096 32 the the DT 42759 5096 33 form form NN 42759 5096 34 of of IN 42759 5096 35 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5096 36 compensation compensation NN 42759 5096 37 . . . 42759 5097 1 This this DT 42759 5097 2 means mean VBZ 42759 5097 3 something something NN 42759 5097 4 more more JJR 42759 5097 5 than than IN 42759 5097 6 a a DT 42759 5097 7 living living NN 42759 5097 8 wage wage NN 42759 5097 9 . . . 42759 5098 1 For for IN 42759 5098 2 the the DT 42759 5098 3 same same JJ 42759 5098 4 reasons reason NNS 42759 5098 5 the the DT 42759 5098 6 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5098 7 hazards hazard NNS 42759 5098 8 and and CC 42759 5098 9 disability disability NN 42759 5098 10 resulting result VBG 42759 5098 11 from from IN 42759 5098 12 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5098 13 accidents accident NNS 42759 5098 14 and and CC 42759 5098 15 diseases disease NNS 42759 5098 16 should should MD 42759 5098 17 be be VB 42759 5098 18 provided provide VBN 42759 5098 19 for for IN 42759 5098 20 by by IN 42759 5098 21 higher high JJR 42759 5098 22 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5098 23 . . . 42759 5099 1 In in IN 42759 5099 2 the the DT 42759 5099 3 absence absence NN 42759 5099 4 of of IN 42759 5099 5 such such JJ 42759 5099 6 provision provision NN 42759 5099 7 , , , 42759 5099 8 these these DT 42759 5099 9 costs cost NNS 42759 5099 10 will will MD 42759 5099 11 have have VB 42759 5099 12 to to TO 42759 5099 13 be be VB 42759 5099 14 borne bear VBN 42759 5099 15 by by IN 42759 5099 16 parents parent NNS 42759 5099 17 , , , 42759 5099 18 by by IN 42759 5099 19 society society NN 42759 5099 20 in in IN 42759 5099 21 the the DT 42759 5099 22 form form NN 42759 5099 23 of of IN 42759 5099 24 charitable charitable JJ 42759 5099 25 relief relief NN 42759 5099 26 , , , 42759 5099 27 or or CC 42759 5099 28 by by IN 42759 5099 29 the the DT 42759 5099 30 worker worker NN 42759 5099 31 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 5099 32 through through IN 42759 5099 33 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 42759 5099 34 suffering suffering NN 42759 5099 35 and and CC 42759 5099 36 incapacity incapacity NN 42759 5099 37 . . . 42759 5100 1 The the DT 42759 5100 2 industry industry NN 42759 5100 3 that that WDT 42759 5100 4 does do VBZ 42759 5100 5 not not RB 42759 5100 6 provide provide VB 42759 5100 7 for for IN 42759 5100 8 all all PDT 42759 5100 9 these these DT 42759 5100 10 costs cost NNS 42759 5100 11 is be VBZ 42759 5100 12 a a DT 42759 5100 13 social social JJ 42759 5100 14 parasite parasite NN 42759 5100 15 , , , 42759 5100 16 the the DT 42759 5100 17 workers worker NNS 42759 5100 18 in in IN 42759 5100 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5100 20 are be VBP 42759 5100 21 deprived deprive VBN 42759 5100 22 of of IN 42759 5100 23 just just RB 42759 5100 24 compensation compensation NN 42759 5100 25 for for IN 42759 5100 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5100 27 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5100 28 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5100 29 , , , 42759 5100 30 and and CC 42759 5100 31 society society NN 42759 5100 32 suffers suffer VBZ 42759 5100 33 a a DT 42759 5100 34 considerable considerable JJ 42759 5100 35 loss loss NN 42759 5100 36 through through IN 42759 5100 37 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5100 38 friction friction NN 42759 5100 39 and and CC 42759 5100 40 diminished diminish VBD 42759 5100 41 productive productive JJ 42759 5100 42 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5100 43 . . . 42759 5101 1 In in IN 42759 5101 2 so so RB 42759 5101 3 far far RB 42759 5101 4 , , , 42759 5101 5 however however RB 42759 5101 6 , , , 42759 5101 7 as as IN 42759 5101 8 any any DT 42759 5101 9 of of IN 42759 5101 10 the the DT 42759 5101 11 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 5101 12 occupational occupational JJ 42759 5101 13 costs cost NNS 42759 5101 14 are be VBP 42759 5101 15 borne bear VBN 42759 5101 16 by by IN 42759 5101 17 society society NN 42759 5101 18 , , , 42759 5101 19 as as IN 42759 5101 20 in in IN 42759 5101 21 the the DT 42759 5101 22 matter matter NN 42759 5101 23 of of IN 42759 5101 24 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5101 25 education education NN 42759 5101 26 , , , 42759 5101 27 or or CC 42759 5101 28 by by IN 42759 5101 29 the the DT 42759 5101 30 employer employer NN 42759 5101 31 , , , 42759 5101 32 as as IN 42759 5101 33 by by IN 42759 5101 34 the the DT 42759 5101 35 devices device NNS 42759 5101 36 of of IN 42759 5101 37 accident accident NN 42759 5101 38 compensation compensation NN 42759 5101 39 or or CC 42759 5101 40 sickness sickness NN 42759 5101 41 insurance insurance NN 42759 5101 42 , , , 42759 5101 43 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5101 44 do do VBP 42759 5101 45 not not RB 42759 5101 46 demand demand VB 42759 5101 47 provision provision NN 42759 5101 48 in in IN 42759 5101 49 the the DT 42759 5101 50 form form NN 42759 5101 51 of of IN 42759 5101 52 extra extra JJ 42759 5101 53 wages wage NNS 42759 5101 54 . . . 42759 5102 1 Other other JJ 42759 5102 2 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5102 3 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5102 4 that that WDT 42759 5102 5 entitle entitle VBP 42759 5102 6 the the DT 42759 5102 7 worker worker NN 42759 5102 8 to to IN 42759 5102 9 more more JJR 42759 5102 10 than than IN 42759 5102 11 living live VBG 42759 5102 12 wages wage NNS 42759 5102 13 , , , 42759 5102 14 are be VBP 42759 5102 15 inherent inherent JJ 42759 5102 16 in in IN 42759 5102 17 disagreeable disagreeable JJ 42759 5102 18 or or CC 42759 5102 19 despised despised JJ 42759 5102 20 occupations occupation NNS 42759 5102 21 . . . 42759 5103 1 The the DT 42759 5103 2 scavenger scavenger NN 42759 5103 3 and and CC 42759 5103 4 the the DT 42759 5103 5 bootblack bootblack NN 42759 5103 6 ought ought MD 42759 5103 7 to to TO 42759 5103 8 get get VB 42759 5103 9 more more JJR 42759 5103 10 than than IN 42759 5103 11 the the DT 42759 5103 12 performers performer NNS 42759 5103 13 of of IN 42759 5103 14 most most JJS 42759 5103 15 other other JJ 42759 5103 16 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 5103 17 tasks task NNS 42759 5103 18 . . . 42759 5104 1 On on IN 42759 5104 2 the the DT 42759 5104 3 principles principle NNS 42759 5104 4 of of IN 42759 5104 5 comparative comparative JJ 42759 5104 6 individual individual JJ 42759 5104 7 desert desert NN 42759 5104 8 , , , 42759 5104 9 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5104 10 should should MD 42759 5104 11 receive receive VB 42759 5104 12 larger large JJR 42759 5104 13 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5104 14 than than IN 42759 5104 15 many many JJ 42759 5104 16 persons person NNS 42759 5104 17 who who WP 42759 5104 18 are be VBP 42759 5104 19 engaged engage VBN 42759 5104 20 upon upon IN 42759 5104 21 skilled skilled JJ 42759 5104 22 but but CC 42759 5104 23 relatively relatively RB 42759 5104 24 pleasant pleasant JJ 42759 5104 25 kinds kind NNS 42759 5104 26 of of IN 42759 5104 27 work work NN 42759 5104 28 . . . 42759 5105 1 For for IN 42759 5105 2 if if IN 42759 5105 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5105 4 were be VBD 42759 5105 5 given give VBN 42759 5105 6 the the DT 42759 5105 7 choice choice NN 42759 5105 8 of of IN 42759 5105 9 expending expend VBG 42759 5105 10 the the DT 42759 5105 11 time time NN 42759 5105 12 and and CC 42759 5105 13 money money NN 42759 5105 14 required require VBN 42759 5105 15 to to TO 42759 5105 16 fit fit VB 42759 5105 17 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5105 18 for for IN 42759 5105 19 the the DT 42759 5105 20 latter latter JJ 42759 5105 21 tasks task NNS 42759 5105 22 , , , 42759 5105 23 or or CC 42759 5105 24 of of IN 42759 5105 25 taking take VBG 42759 5105 26 up up RP 42759 5105 27 immediately immediately RB 42759 5105 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5105 29 present present JJ 42759 5105 30 disagreeable disagreeable JJ 42759 5105 31 labour labour NN 42759 5105 32 , , , 42759 5105 33 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5105 34 would would MD 42759 5105 35 select select VB 42759 5105 36 the the DT 42759 5105 37 more more RBR 42759 5105 38 pleasant pleasant JJ 42759 5105 39 occupations occupation NNS 42759 5105 40 , , , 42759 5105 41 for for IN 42759 5105 42 the the DT 42759 5105 43 same same JJ 42759 5105 44 or or CC 42759 5105 45 even even RB 42759 5105 46 a a DT 42759 5105 47 smaller small JJR 42759 5105 48 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5105 49 . . . 42759 5106 1 And and CC 42759 5106 2 the the DT 42759 5106 3 majority majority NN 42759 5106 4 of of IN 42759 5106 5 those those DT 42759 5106 6 who who WP 42759 5106 7 are be VBP 42759 5106 8 now now RB 42759 5106 9 in in IN 42759 5106 10 the the DT 42759 5106 11 more more RBR 42759 5106 12 skilled skilled JJ 42759 5106 13 occupations occupation NNS 42759 5106 14 would would MD 42759 5106 15 make make VB 42759 5106 16 the the DT 42759 5106 17 same same JJ 42759 5106 18 choice choice NN 42759 5106 19 . . . 42759 5107 1 Hence hence RB 42759 5107 2 the the DT 42759 5107 3 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5107 4 inherent inherent JJ 42759 5107 5 in in IN 42759 5107 6 disagreeable disagreeable JJ 42759 5107 7 kinds kind NNS 42759 5107 8 of of IN 42759 5107 9 work work NN 42759 5107 10 are be VBP 42759 5107 11 in in IN 42759 5107 12 many many JJ 42759 5107 13 cases case NNS 42759 5107 14 as as RB 42759 5107 15 great great JJ 42759 5107 16 as as IN 42759 5107 17 or or CC 42759 5107 18 greater great JJR 42759 5107 19 than than IN 42759 5107 20 the the DT 42759 5107 21 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5107 22 of of IN 42759 5107 23 preparation preparation NN 42759 5107 24 for for IN 42759 5107 25 the the DT 42759 5107 26 more more RBR 42759 5107 27 pleasant pleasant JJ 42759 5107 28 tasks task NNS 42759 5107 29 ; ; : 42759 5107 30 consequently consequently RB 42759 5107 31 the the DT 42759 5107 32 doers doer NNS 42759 5107 33 of of IN 42759 5107 34 the the DT 42759 5107 35 former former JJ 42759 5107 36 are be VBP 42759 5107 37 relatively relatively RB 42759 5107 38 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5107 39 . . . 42759 5108 1 If if IN 42759 5108 2 all all DT 42759 5108 3 wages wage NNS 42759 5108 4 were be VBD 42759 5108 5 regulated regulate VBN 42759 5108 6 by by IN 42759 5108 7 some some DT 42759 5108 8 supreme supreme NNP 42759 5108 9 authority authority NNP 42759 5108 10 according accord VBG 42759 5108 11 to to IN 42759 5108 12 the the DT 42759 5108 13 principles principle NNS 42759 5108 14 of of IN 42759 5108 15 complete complete JJ 42759 5108 16 justice justice NN 42759 5108 17 , , , 42759 5108 18 the the DT 42759 5108 19 workers worker NNS 42759 5108 20 in in IN 42759 5108 21 disagreeable disagreeable JJ 42759 5108 22 occupations occupation NNS 42759 5108 23 would would MD 42759 5108 24 receive receive VB 42759 5108 25 something something NN 42759 5108 26 more more JJR 42759 5108 27 than than IN 42759 5108 28 living live VBG 42759 5108 29 wages wage NNS 42759 5108 30 . . . 42759 5109 1 Nor nor CC 42759 5109 2 would would MD 42759 5109 3 this this DT 42759 5109 4 determination determination NN 42759 5109 5 of of IN 42759 5109 6 rewards reward NNS 42759 5109 7 be be VB 42759 5109 8 in in IN 42759 5109 9 any any DT 42759 5109 10 way way NN 42759 5109 11 contrary contrary JJ 42759 5109 12 to to IN 42759 5109 13 social social JJ 42759 5109 14 welfare welfare NN 42759 5109 15 or or CC 42759 5109 16 the the DT 42759 5109 17 principle principle NN 42759 5109 18 of of IN 42759 5109 19 maximum maximum JJ 42759 5109 20 net net JJ 42759 5109 21 results result NNS 42759 5109 22 ; ; : 42759 5109 23 for for IN 42759 5109 24 the the DT 42759 5109 25 superior superior JJ 42759 5109 26 attractiveness attractiveness NN 42759 5109 27 of of IN 42759 5109 28 the the DT 42759 5109 29 other other JJ 42759 5109 30 kinds kind NNS 42759 5109 31 of of IN 42759 5109 32 work work NN 42759 5109 33 would would MD 42759 5109 34 draw draw VB 42759 5109 35 a a DT 42759 5109 36 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5109 37 supply supply NN 42759 5109 38 of of IN 42759 5109 39 labour labour NN 42759 5109 40 to to TO 42759 5109 41 offset offset VB 42759 5109 42 the the DT 42759 5109 43 advantage advantage NN 42759 5109 44 conferred confer VBN 42759 5109 45 by by IN 42759 5109 46 higher high JJR 42759 5109 47 wages wage NNS 42759 5109 48 upon upon IN 42759 5109 49 the the DT 42759 5109 50 disagreeable disagreeable JJ 42759 5109 51 occupations occupation NNS 42759 5109 52 . . . 42759 5110 1 The the DT 42759 5110 2 main main JJ 42759 5110 3 reason reason NN 42759 5110 4 why why WRB 42759 5110 5 the the DT 42759 5110 6 latter latter JJ 42759 5110 7 kind kind NN 42759 5110 8 of of IN 42759 5110 9 labour labour NN 42759 5110 10 is be VBZ 42759 5110 11 so so RB 42759 5110 12 poorly poorly RB 42759 5110 13 paid pay VBN 42759 5110 14 now now RB 42759 5110 15 is be VBZ 42759 5110 16 the the DT 42759 5110 17 fact fact NN 42759 5110 18 that that IN 42759 5110 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5110 20 is be VBZ 42759 5110 21 very very RB 42759 5110 22 plentiful plentiful JJ 42759 5110 23 , , , 42759 5110 24 a a DT 42759 5110 25 condition condition NN 42759 5110 26 which which WDT 42759 5110 27 is be VBZ 42759 5110 28 in in IN 42759 5110 29 turn turn NN 42759 5110 30 due due IN 42759 5110 31 to to IN 42759 5110 32 the the DT 42759 5110 33 unequal unequal JJ 42759 5110 34 division division NN 42759 5110 35 of of IN 42759 5110 36 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5110 37 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 5110 38 . . . 42759 5111 1 Were be VBD 42759 5111 2 the the DT 42759 5111 3 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 5111 4 of of IN 42759 5111 5 technical technical JJ 42759 5111 6 education education NN 42759 5111 7 and and CC 42759 5111 8 of of IN 42759 5111 9 entrance entrance NN 42759 5111 10 to to IN 42759 5111 11 the the DT 42759 5111 12 higher high JJR 42759 5111 13 crafts craft NNS 42759 5111 14 and and CC 42759 5111 15 professions profession NNS 42759 5111 16 more more RBR 42759 5111 17 widely widely RB 42759 5111 18 diffused diffuse VBN 42759 5111 19 , , , 42759 5111 20 the the DT 42759 5111 21 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5111 22 offering offer VBG 42759 5111 23 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 5111 24 for for IN 42759 5111 25 the the DT 42759 5111 26 disagreeable disagreeable JJ 42759 5111 27 tasks task NNS 42759 5111 28 would would MD 42759 5111 29 be be VB 42759 5111 30 scarcer scarcer NN 42759 5111 31 and and CC 42759 5111 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5111 33 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5111 34 correspondingly correspondingly RB 42759 5111 35 larger large JJR 42759 5111 36 . . . 42759 5112 1 This this DT 42759 5112 2 would would MD 42759 5112 3 be be VB 42759 5112 4 not not RB 42759 5112 5 only only RB 42759 5112 6 more more RBR 42759 5112 7 comfortable comfortable JJ 42759 5112 8 to to IN 42759 5112 9 the the DT 42759 5112 10 abstract abstract JJ 42759 5112 11 principles principle NNS 42759 5112 12 of of IN 42759 5112 13 justice justice NN 42759 5112 14 , , , 42759 5112 15 but but CC 42759 5112 16 more more RBR 42759 5112 17 conducive conducive JJ 42759 5112 18 to to IN 42759 5112 19 social social JJ 42759 5112 20 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5112 21 . . . 42759 5113 1 To to TO 42759 5113 2 sum sum VB 42759 5113 3 up up RP 42759 5113 4 the the DT 42759 5113 5 discussion discussion NN 42759 5113 6 concerning concern VBG 42759 5113 7 the the DT 42759 5113 8 canon canon NN 42759 5113 9 of of IN 42759 5113 10 efforts effort NNS 42759 5113 11 and and CC 42759 5113 12 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5113 13 : : : 42759 5113 14 Labourers labourer NNS 42759 5113 15 have have VBP 42759 5113 16 a a DT 42759 5113 17 just just RB 42759 5113 18 claim claim NN 42759 5113 19 to to IN 42759 5113 20 more more JJR 42759 5113 21 than than IN 42759 5113 22 living live VBG 42759 5113 23 wages wage NNS 42759 5113 24 whenever whenever WRB 42759 5113 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5113 26 put put VBD 42759 5113 27 forth forth RB 42759 5113 28 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5113 29 efforts effort NNS 42759 5113 30 , , , 42759 5113 31 and and CC 42759 5113 32 whenever whenever WRB 42759 5113 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5113 34 occupations occupation NNS 42759 5113 35 involve involve VBP 42759 5113 36 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5113 37 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5113 38 , , , 42759 5113 39 either either CC 42759 5113 40 through through IN 42759 5113 41 costs cost NNS 42759 5113 42 of of IN 42759 5113 43 preparation preparation NN 42759 5113 44 , , , 42759 5113 45 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5113 46 hazards hazard NNS 42759 5113 47 , , , 42759 5113 48 or or CC 42759 5113 49 inherent inherent JJ 42759 5113 50 disagreeableness disagreeableness NN 42759 5113 51 . . . 42759 5114 1 The the DT 42759 5114 2 precise precise JJ 42759 5114 3 amount amount NN 42759 5114 4 of of IN 42759 5114 5 extra extra JJ 42759 5114 6 compensation compensation NN 42759 5114 7 due due JJ 42759 5114 8 under under IN 42759 5114 9 any any DT 42759 5114 10 of of IN 42759 5114 11 these these DT 42759 5114 12 heads head NNS 42759 5114 13 can can MD 42759 5114 14 be be VB 42759 5114 15 determined determine VBN 42759 5114 16 , , , 42759 5114 17 as as IN 42759 5114 18 a a DT 42759 5114 19 rule rule NN 42759 5114 20 , , , 42759 5114 21 only only RB 42759 5114 22 approximately approximately RB 42759 5114 23 . . . 42759 5115 1 The the DT 42759 5115 2 next next JJ 42759 5115 3 canon canon NN 42759 5115 4 to to TO 42759 5115 5 be be VB 42759 5115 6 considered consider VBN 42759 5115 7 as as IN 42759 5115 8 a a DT 42759 5115 9 reason reason NN 42759 5115 10 for for IN 42759 5115 11 more more JJR 42759 5115 12 than than IN 42759 5115 13 living live VBG 42759 5115 14 wages wage NNS 42759 5115 15 is be VBZ 42759 5115 16 that that DT 42759 5115 17 of of IN 42759 5115 18 productivity productivity NN 42759 5115 19 . . . 42759 5116 1 This this DT 42759 5116 2 offers offer VBZ 42759 5116 3 little little JJ 42759 5116 4 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 5116 5 ; ; : 42759 5116 6 for for IN 42759 5116 7 the the DT 42759 5116 8 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5116 9 product product NN 42759 5116 10 is be VBZ 42759 5116 11 always always RB 42759 5116 12 visible visible JJ 42759 5116 13 among among IN 42759 5116 14 men man NNS 42759 5116 15 who who WP 42759 5116 16 are be VBP 42759 5116 17 performing perform VBG 42759 5116 18 the the DT 42759 5116 19 same same JJ 42759 5116 20 kind kind NN 42759 5116 21 of of IN 42759 5116 22 work work NN 42759 5116 23 , , , 42759 5116 24 and and CC 42759 5116 25 the the DT 42759 5116 26 employer employer NN 42759 5116 27 is be VBZ 42759 5116 28 always always RB 42759 5116 29 willing willing JJ 42759 5116 30 to to TO 42759 5116 31 give give VB 42759 5116 32 the the DT 42759 5116 33 producer producer NN 42759 5116 34 of of IN 42759 5116 35 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5116 36 extra extra JJ 42759 5116 37 compensation compensation NN 42759 5116 38 . . . 42759 5117 1 While while IN 42759 5117 2 superior superior JJ 42759 5117 3 productive productive JJ 42759 5117 4 power power NN 42759 5117 5 which which WDT 42759 5117 6 is be VBZ 42759 5117 7 based base VBN 42759 5117 8 solely solely RB 42759 5117 9 upon upon IN 42759 5117 10 superior superior JJ 42759 5117 11 native native JJ 42759 5117 12 ability ability NN 42759 5117 13 has have VBZ 42759 5117 14 only only RB 42759 5117 15 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 5117 16 validity validity NN 42759 5117 17 as as IN 42759 5117 18 a a DT 42759 5117 19 canon canon NN 42759 5117 20 of of IN 42759 5117 21 justice justice NN 42759 5117 22 , , , 42759 5117 23 that that WDT 42759 5117 24 is be VBZ 42759 5117 25 ethically ethically RB 42759 5117 26 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5117 27 in in IN 42759 5117 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5117 29 workaday workaday NNP 42759 5117 30 world world NN 42759 5117 31 . . . 42759 5118 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 5118 2 , , , 42759 5118 3 the the DT 42759 5118 4 canon canon NN 42759 5118 5 of of IN 42759 5118 6 human human JJ 42759 5118 7 welfare welfare NN 42759 5118 8 demands demand NNS 42759 5118 9 that that IN 42759 5118 10 superior superior JJ 42759 5118 11 productivity productivity NN 42759 5118 12 receive receive VBP 42759 5118 13 superior superior JJ 42759 5118 14 rewards reward NNS 42759 5118 15 , , , 42759 5118 16 so so RB 42759 5118 17 long long RB 42759 5118 18 as as IN 42759 5118 19 these these DT 42759 5118 20 are be VBP 42759 5118 21 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5118 22 to to TO 42759 5118 23 evoke evoke VB 42759 5118 24 the the DT 42759 5118 25 maximum maximum JJ 42759 5118 26 net net JJ 42759 5118 27 product product NN 42759 5118 28 . . . 42759 5119 1 The the DT 42759 5119 2 canon canon NN 42759 5119 3 of of IN 42759 5119 4 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5119 5 has have VBZ 42759 5119 6 exactly exactly RB 42759 5119 7 the the DT 42759 5119 8 same same JJ 42759 5119 9 value value NN 42759 5119 10 as as IN 42759 5119 11 that that DT 42759 5119 12 of of IN 42759 5119 13 productivity productivity NN 42759 5119 14 . . . 42759 5120 1 Society society NN 42759 5120 2 and and CC 42759 5120 3 the the DT 42759 5120 4 employer employer NN 42759 5120 5 are be VBP 42759 5120 6 well well RB 42759 5120 7 advised advised JJ 42759 5120 8 and and CC 42759 5120 9 are be VBP 42759 5120 10 justified justify VBN 42759 5120 11 in in IN 42759 5120 12 giving give VBG 42759 5120 13 extra extra JJ 42759 5120 14 compensation compensation NN 42759 5120 15 to to IN 42759 5120 16 scarce scarce JJ 42759 5120 17 forms form NNS 42759 5120 18 of of IN 42759 5120 19 labour labour NN 42759 5120 20 when when WRB 42759 5120 21 the the DT 42759 5120 22 product product NN 42759 5120 23 is be VBZ 42759 5120 24 regarded regard VBN 42759 5120 25 as as IN 42759 5120 26 worth worth JJ 42759 5120 27 the the DT 42759 5120 28 corresponding corresponding JJ 42759 5120 29 price price NN 42759 5120 30 . . . 42759 5121 1 This this DT 42759 5121 2 remains remain VBZ 42759 5121 3 true true JJ 42759 5121 4 even even RB 42759 5121 5 when when WRB 42759 5121 6 the the DT 42759 5121 7 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5121 8 is be VBZ 42759 5121 9 due due JJ 42759 5121 10 to to IN 42759 5121 11 restricted restrict VBN 42759 5121 12 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 5121 13 of of IN 42759 5121 14 preparation preparation NN 42759 5121 15 , , , 42759 5121 16 rather rather RB 42759 5121 17 than than IN 42759 5121 18 to to IN 42759 5121 19 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5121 20 of of IN 42759 5121 21 any any DT 42759 5121 22 sort sort NN 42759 5121 23 . . . 42759 5122 1 In in IN 42759 5122 2 that that DT 42759 5122 3 case case NN 42759 5122 4 the the DT 42759 5122 5 higher high JJR 42759 5122 6 rewards reward NNS 42759 5122 7 are be VBP 42759 5122 8 as as RB 42759 5122 9 fully fully RB 42759 5122 10 justified justify VBN 42759 5122 11 as as IN 42759 5122 12 the the DT 42759 5122 13 superior superior JJ 42759 5122 14 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5122 15 of of IN 42759 5122 16 that that DT 42759 5122 17 superior superior JJ 42759 5122 18 productivity productivity NN 42759 5122 19 which which WDT 42759 5122 20 is be VBZ 42759 5122 21 based base VBN 42759 5122 22 upon upon IN 42759 5122 23 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5122 24 native native JJ 42759 5122 25 endowments endowment NNS 42759 5122 26 . . . 42759 5123 1 The the DT 42759 5123 2 amount amount NN 42759 5123 3 of of IN 42759 5123 4 extra extra JJ 42759 5123 5 compensation compensation NN 42759 5123 6 which which WDT 42759 5123 7 may may MD 42759 5123 8 properly properly RB 42759 5123 9 be be VB 42759 5123 10 given give VBN 42759 5123 11 on on IN 42759 5123 12 account account NN 42759 5123 13 of of IN 42759 5123 14 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5123 15 is be VBZ 42759 5123 16 determined determine VBN 42759 5123 17 either either CC 42759 5123 18 by by IN 42759 5123 19 the the DT 42759 5123 20 degree degree NN 42759 5123 21 of of IN 42759 5123 22 sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 5123 23 involved involve VBN 42759 5123 24 or or CC 42759 5123 25 by by IN 42759 5123 26 the the DT 42759 5123 27 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 5123 28 operation operation NN 42759 5123 29 of of IN 42759 5123 30 competition competition NN 42759 5123 31 . . . 42759 5124 1 When when WRB 42759 5124 2 men man NNS 42759 5124 3 are be VBP 42759 5124 4 scarce scarce JJ 42759 5124 5 because because IN 42759 5124 6 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5124 7 have have VBP 42759 5124 8 made make VBN 42759 5124 9 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5124 10 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5124 11 of of IN 42759 5124 12 preparation preparation NN 42759 5124 13 , , , 42759 5124 14 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5124 15 ought ought MD 42759 5124 16 to to TO 42759 5124 17 be be VB 42759 5124 18 rewarded reward VBN 42759 5124 19 in in IN 42759 5124 20 full full JJ 42759 5124 21 proportion proportion NN 42759 5124 22 to to IN 42759 5124 23 these these DT 42759 5124 24 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5124 25 . . . 42759 5125 1 When when WRB 42759 5125 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5125 3 are be VBP 42759 5125 4 scarce scarce JJ 42759 5125 5 merely merely RB 42759 5125 6 because because IN 42759 5125 7 of of IN 42759 5125 8 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5125 9 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 5125 10 , , , 42759 5125 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5125 12 extra extra JJ 42759 5125 13 compensation compensation NN 42759 5125 14 should should MD 42759 5125 15 not not RB 42759 5125 16 exceed exceed VB 42759 5125 17 the the DT 42759 5125 18 amount amount NN 42759 5125 19 that that WDT 42759 5125 20 automatically automatically RB 42759 5125 21 comes come VBZ 42759 5125 22 to to IN 42759 5125 23 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5125 24 through through IN 42759 5125 25 the the DT 42759 5125 26 interplay interplay NN 42759 5125 27 of of IN 42759 5125 28 supply supply NN 42759 5125 29 and and CC 42759 5125 30 demand demand NN 42759 5125 31 . . . 42759 5126 1 The the DT 42759 5126 2 canon canon NN 42759 5126 3 of of IN 42759 5126 4 human human JJ 42759 5126 5 welfare welfare NN 42759 5126 6 has have VBZ 42759 5126 7 already already RB 42759 5126 8 received receive VBN 42759 5126 9 implicit implicit JJ 42759 5126 10 application application NN 42759 5126 11 . . . 42759 5127 1 When when WRB 42759 5127 2 due due JJ 42759 5127 3 regard regard NN 42759 5127 4 is be VBZ 42759 5127 5 given give VBN 42759 5127 6 to to IN 42759 5127 7 efforts effort NNS 42759 5127 8 , , , 42759 5127 9 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5127 10 , , , 42759 5127 11 productivity productivity NN 42759 5127 12 , , , 42759 5127 13 and and CC 42759 5127 14 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5127 15 , , , 42759 5127 16 the the DT 42759 5127 17 demands demand NNS 42759 5127 18 of of IN 42759 5127 19 human human JJ 42759 5127 20 welfare welfare NN 42759 5127 21 , , , 42759 5127 22 both both CC 42759 5127 23 in in IN 42759 5127 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5127 25 individual individual NN 42759 5127 26 and and CC 42759 5127 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5127 28 social social JJ 42759 5127 29 aspects aspect NNS 42759 5127 30 , , , 42759 5127 31 are be VBP 42759 5127 32 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 5127 33 safeguarded safeguarded JJ 42759 5127 34 . . . 42759 5128 1 In in IN 42759 5128 2 the the DT 42759 5128 3 foregoing foregoing NN 42759 5128 4 pages page NNS 42759 5128 5 the the DT 42759 5128 6 attempt attempt NN 42759 5128 7 has have VBZ 42759 5128 8 been be VBN 42759 5128 9 made make VBN 42759 5128 10 to to TO 42759 5128 11 describe describe VB 42759 5128 12 the the DT 42759 5128 13 proportions proportion NNS 42759 5128 14 in in IN 42759 5128 15 which which WDT 42759 5128 16 a a DT 42759 5128 17 given give VBN 42759 5128 18 wage wage NN 42759 5128 19 fund fund NN 42759 5128 20 ought ought MD 42759 5128 21 to to TO 42759 5128 22 be be VB 42759 5128 23 distributed distribute VBN 42759 5128 24 among among IN 42759 5128 25 the the DT 42759 5128 26 various various JJ 42759 5128 27 classes class NNS 42759 5128 28 of of IN 42759 5128 29 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5128 30 who who WP 42759 5128 31 have have VBP 42759 5128 32 claims claim NNS 42759 5128 33 upon upon IN 42759 5128 34 the the DT 42759 5128 35 fund fund NN 42759 5128 36 . . . 42759 5129 1 The the DT 42759 5129 2 first first JJ 42759 5129 3 requisite requisite NN 42759 5129 4 of of IN 42759 5129 5 justice justice NN 42759 5129 6 is be VBZ 42759 5129 7 that that IN 42759 5129 8 all all DT 42759 5129 9 should should MD 42759 5129 10 receive receive VB 42759 5129 11 living live VBG 42759 5129 12 wages wage NNS 42759 5129 13 . . . 42759 5130 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5130 2 applies apply VBZ 42759 5130 3 to to IN 42759 5130 4 all all DT 42759 5130 5 workers worker NNS 42759 5130 6 of of IN 42759 5130 7 average average JJ 42759 5130 8 ability ability NN 42759 5130 9 , , , 42759 5130 10 even even RB 42759 5130 11 to to IN 42759 5130 12 those those DT 42759 5130 13 who who WP 42759 5130 14 have have VBP 42759 5130 15 no no DT 42759 5130 16 special special JJ 42759 5130 17 qualifications qualification NNS 42759 5130 18 of of IN 42759 5130 19 any any DT 42759 5130 20 sort sort NN 42759 5130 21 . . . 42759 5131 1 When when WRB 42759 5131 2 this this DT 42759 5131 3 general general JJ 42759 5131 4 claim claim NN 42759 5131 5 has have VBZ 42759 5131 6 been be VBN 42759 5131 7 universally universally RB 42759 5131 8 satisfied satisfied JJ 42759 5131 9 , , , 42759 5131 10 those those DT 42759 5131 11 groups group NNS 42759 5131 12 of of IN 42759 5131 13 workers worker NNS 42759 5131 14 who who WP 42759 5131 15 are be VBP 42759 5131 16 in in IN 42759 5131 17 any any DT 42759 5131 18 wise wise JJ 42759 5131 19 special special NN 42759 5131 20 , , , 42759 5131 21 whose whose WP$ 42759 5131 22 qualifications qualification NNS 42759 5131 23 for for IN 42759 5131 24 any any DT 42759 5131 25 reason reason NN 42759 5131 26 differentiate differentiate VB 42759 5131 27 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5131 28 from from IN 42759 5131 29 and and CC 42759 5131 30 place place VB 42759 5131 31 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5131 32 above above IN 42759 5131 33 the the DT 42759 5131 34 average average NN 42759 5131 35 , , , 42759 5131 36 will will MD 42759 5131 37 have have VB 42759 5131 38 a a DT 42759 5131 39 right right NN 42759 5131 40 to to IN 42759 5131 41 something something NN 42759 5131 42 more more JJR 42759 5131 43 than than IN 42759 5131 44 living live VBG 42759 5131 45 wages wage NNS 42759 5131 46 . . . 42759 5132 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 5132 2 will will MD 42759 5132 3 have have VB 42759 5132 4 the the DT 42759 5132 5 first first JJ 42759 5132 6 claim claim NN 42759 5132 7 upon upon IN 42759 5132 8 the the DT 42759 5132 9 surplus surplus NN 42759 5132 10 that that WDT 42759 5132 11 remains remain VBZ 42759 5132 12 in in IN 42759 5132 13 the the DT 42759 5132 14 wage wage NN 42759 5132 15 fund fund NN 42759 5132 16 . . . 42759 5133 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5133 2 claims claim NNS 42759 5133 3 will will MD 42759 5133 4 be be VB 42759 5133 5 based base VBN 42759 5133 6 upon upon IN 42759 5133 7 the the DT 42759 5133 8 various various JJ 42759 5133 9 canons canon NNS 42759 5133 10 of of IN 42759 5133 11 distribution distribution NN 42759 5133 12 explained explain VBN 42759 5133 13 in in IN 42759 5133 14 detail detail NN 42759 5133 15 above above RB 42759 5133 16 ; ; : 42759 5133 17 and and CC 42759 5133 18 the the DT 42759 5133 19 amounts amount NNS 42759 5133 20 of of IN 42759 5133 21 extra extra JJ 42759 5133 22 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5133 23 to to TO 42759 5133 24 which which WDT 42759 5133 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5133 26 will will MD 42759 5133 27 be be VB 42759 5133 28 entitled entitle VBN 42759 5133 29 , , , 42759 5133 30 will will MD 42759 5133 31 be be VB 42759 5133 32 determined determine VBN 42759 5133 33 by by IN 42759 5133 34 the the DT 42759 5133 35 extent extent NN 42759 5133 36 to to TO 42759 5133 37 which which WDT 42759 5133 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5133 39 special special JJ 42759 5133 40 qualifications qualification NNS 42759 5133 41 differentiate differentiate VBP 42759 5133 42 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5133 43 from from IN 42759 5133 44 the the DT 42759 5133 45 average average JJ 42759 5133 46 and and CC 42759 5133 47 unspecialised unspecialised JJ 42759 5133 48 workers worker NNS 42759 5133 49 . . . 42759 5134 1 If if IN 42759 5134 2 the the DT 42759 5134 3 total total JJ 42759 5134 4 available available JJ 42759 5134 5 wage wage NN 42759 5134 6 fund fund NN 42759 5134 7 is be VBZ 42759 5134 8 merely merely RB 42759 5134 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5134 10 to to TO 42759 5134 11 provide provide VB 42759 5134 12 universal universal JJ 42759 5134 13 living living NN 42759 5134 14 wages wage NNS 42759 5134 15 and and CC 42759 5134 16 the the DT 42759 5134 17 extra extra JJ 42759 5134 18 compensation compensation NN 42759 5134 19 due due IN 42759 5134 20 to to IN 42759 5134 21 the the DT 42759 5134 22 specialised specialise VBN 42759 5134 23 groups group NNS 42759 5134 24 , , , 42759 5134 25 no no DT 42759 5134 26 section section NN 42759 5134 27 of of IN 42759 5134 28 the the DT 42759 5134 29 labour labour JJ 42759 5134 30 force force NN 42759 5134 31 will will MD 42759 5134 32 be be VB 42759 5134 33 justified justify VBN 42759 5134 34 in in IN 42759 5134 35 exacting exact VBG 42759 5134 36 a a DT 42759 5134 37 larger large JJR 42759 5134 38 share share NN 42759 5134 39 . . . 42759 5135 1 Even even RB 42759 5135 2 though though IN 42759 5135 3 the the DT 42759 5135 4 employer employer NN 42759 5135 5 should should MD 42759 5135 6 withhold withhold VB 42759 5135 7 a a DT 42759 5135 8 part part NN 42759 5135 9 of of IN 42759 5135 10 the the DT 42759 5135 11 amount amount NN 42759 5135 12 due due JJ 42759 5135 13 to to IN 42759 5135 14 some some DT 42759 5135 15 weaker weak JJR 42759 5135 16 group group NN 42759 5135 17 , , , 42759 5135 18 a a DT 42759 5135 19 stronger strong JJR 42759 5135 20 group group NN 42759 5135 21 that that WDT 42759 5135 22 is be VBZ 42759 5135 23 already already RB 42759 5135 24 getting get VBG 42759 5135 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5135 26 proper proper JJ 42759 5135 27 proportion proportion NN 42759 5135 28 would would MD 42759 5135 29 have have VB 42759 5135 30 no no DT 42759 5135 31 right right NN 42759 5135 32 to to TO 42759 5135 33 demand demand VB 42759 5135 34 the the DT 42759 5135 35 unjustly unjustly RB 42759 5135 36 withheld withhold VBN 42759 5135 37 portion portion NN 42759 5135 38 . . . 42759 5136 1 For for IN 42759 5136 2 this this DT 42759 5136 3 belongs belong VBZ 42759 5136 4 neither neither CC 42759 5136 5 to to IN 42759 5136 6 the the DT 42759 5136 7 employer employer NN 42759 5136 8 nor nor CC 42759 5136 9 to to IN 42759 5136 10 the the DT 42759 5136 11 powerful powerful JJ 42759 5136 12 labour labour NN 42759 5136 13 group group NN 42759 5136 14 , , , 42759 5136 15 but but CC 42759 5136 16 to to IN 42759 5136 17 the the DT 42759 5136 18 weaker weak JJR 42759 5136 19 section section NN 42759 5136 20 of of IN 42759 5136 21 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5136 22 . . . 42759 5137 1 This this DT 42759 5137 2 does do VBZ 42759 5137 3 not not RB 42759 5137 4 mean mean VB 42759 5137 5 that that IN 42759 5137 6 a a DT 42759 5137 7 powerful powerful JJ 42759 5137 8 body body NN 42759 5137 9 of of IN 42759 5137 10 workers worker NNS 42759 5137 11 who who WP 42759 5137 12 are be VBP 42759 5137 13 already already RB 42759 5137 14 receiving receive VBG 42759 5137 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5137 16 due due JJ 42759 5137 17 proportion proportion NN 42759 5137 18 as as IN 42759 5137 19 compared compare VBN 42759 5137 20 with with IN 42759 5137 21 other other JJ 42759 5137 22 labour labour JJ 42759 5137 23 groups group NNS 42759 5137 24 , , , 42759 5137 25 would would MD 42759 5137 26 not not RB 42759 5137 27 be be VB 42759 5137 28 justified justify VBN 42759 5137 29 in in IN 42759 5137 30 seeking seek VBG 42759 5137 31 any any DT 42759 5137 32 increase increase NN 42759 5137 33 in in IN 42759 5137 34 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5137 35 whatever whatever WDT 42759 5137 36 . . . 42759 5138 1 The the DT 42759 5138 2 increase increase NN 42759 5138 3 might may MD 42759 5138 4 come come VB 42759 5138 5 out out IN 42759 5138 6 of of IN 42759 5138 7 profits profit NNS 42759 5138 8 , , , 42759 5138 9 or or CC 42759 5138 10 interest interest NN 42759 5138 11 , , , 42759 5138 12 or or CC 42759 5138 13 the the DT 42759 5138 14 consumer consumer NN 42759 5138 15 , , , 42759 5138 16 and and CC 42759 5138 17 thus thus RB 42759 5138 18 be be VB 42759 5138 19 in in IN 42759 5138 20 no no DT 42759 5138 21 sense sense NN 42759 5138 22 detrimental detrimental JJ 42759 5138 23 to to IN 42759 5138 24 the the DT 42759 5138 25 rights right NNS 42759 5138 26 of of IN 42759 5138 27 the the DT 42759 5138 28 other other JJ 42759 5138 29 sections section NNS 42759 5138 30 of of IN 42759 5138 31 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5138 32 . . . 42759 5139 1 This this DT 42759 5139 2 problem problem NN 42759 5139 3 will will MD 42759 5139 4 be be VB 42759 5139 5 considered consider VBN 42759 5139 6 a a DT 42759 5139 7 little little JJ 42759 5139 8 later later RB 42759 5139 9 . . . 42759 5140 1 At at IN 42759 5140 2 present present JJ 42759 5140 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5140 4 confine confine VBP 42759 5140 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5140 6 attention attention NN 42759 5140 7 to to IN 42759 5140 8 the the DT 42759 5140 9 relative relative JJ 42759 5140 10 claims claim NNS 42759 5140 11 of of IN 42759 5140 12 different different JJ 42759 5140 13 labour labour JJ 42759 5140 14 groups group NNS 42759 5140 15 to to IN 42759 5140 16 a a DT 42759 5140 17 definite definite JJ 42759 5140 18 wage wage NN 42759 5140 19 fund fund NN 42759 5140 20 . . . 42759 5141 1 Suppose suppose VB 42759 5141 2 , , , 42759 5141 3 however however RB 42759 5141 4 , , , 42759 5141 5 that that IN 42759 5141 6 after after IN 42759 5141 7 all all DT 42759 5141 8 workers worker NNS 42759 5141 9 have have VBP 42759 5141 10 received receive VBN 42759 5141 11 living live VBG 42759 5141 12 wages wage NNS 42759 5141 13 , , , 42759 5141 14 and and CC 42759 5141 15 all all PDT 42759 5141 16 the the DT 42759 5141 17 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5141 18 groups group NNS 42759 5141 19 have have VBP 42759 5141 20 obtained obtain VBN 42759 5141 21 those those DT 42759 5141 22 extra extra JJ 42759 5141 23 amounts amount NNS 42759 5141 24 which which WDT 42759 5141 25 are be VBP 42759 5141 26 due due JJ 42759 5141 27 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5141 28 on on IN 42759 5141 29 account account NN 42759 5141 30 of of IN 42759 5141 31 efforts effort NNS 42759 5141 32 , , , 42759 5141 33 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5141 34 , , , 42759 5141 35 productivity productivity NN 42759 5141 36 , , , 42759 5141 37 and and CC 42759 5141 38 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5141 39 , , , 42759 5141 40 there there EX 42759 5141 41 remains remain VBZ 42759 5141 42 a a DT 42759 5141 43 further further JJ 42759 5141 44 surplus surplus NN 42759 5141 45 in in IN 42759 5141 46 the the DT 42759 5141 47 wage wage NN 42759 5141 48 fund fund NN 42759 5141 49 . . . 42759 5142 1 In in IN 42759 5142 2 what what WDT 42759 5142 3 proportions proportion NNS 42759 5142 4 should should MD 42759 5142 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5142 6 be be VB 42759 5142 7 distributed distribute VBN 42759 5142 8 ? ? . 42759 5143 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5143 2 should should MD 42759 5143 3 be be VB 42759 5143 4 equally equally RB 42759 5143 5 divided divide VBN 42759 5143 6 among among IN 42759 5143 7 all all PDT 42759 5143 8 the the DT 42759 5143 9 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5143 10 . . . 42759 5144 1 The the DT 42759 5144 2 proportional proportional JJ 42759 5144 3 justice justice NN 42759 5144 4 which which WDT 42759 5144 5 has have VBZ 42759 5144 6 been be VBN 42759 5144 7 already already RB 42759 5144 8 established establish VBN 42759 5144 9 can can MD 42759 5144 10 be be VB 42759 5144 11 maintained maintain VBN 42759 5144 12 only only RB 42759 5144 13 by by IN 42759 5144 14 raising raise VBG 42759 5144 15 the the DT 42759 5144 16 present present JJ 42759 5144 17 rates rate NNS 42759 5144 18 of of IN 42759 5144 19 payment payment NN 42759 5144 20 equally equally RB 42759 5144 21 in in IN 42759 5144 22 all all DT 42759 5144 23 cases case NNS 42759 5144 24 . . . 42759 5145 1 All all PDT 42759 5145 2 the the DT 42759 5145 3 average average JJ 42759 5145 4 or or CC 42759 5145 5 unspecialised unspecialised JJ 42759 5145 6 groups group NNS 42759 5145 7 would would MD 42759 5145 8 get get VB 42759 5145 9 something something NN 42759 5145 10 more more JJR 42759 5145 11 than than IN 42759 5145 12 living live VBG 42759 5145 13 wages wage NNS 42759 5145 14 , , , 42759 5145 15 and and CC 42759 5145 16 all all PDT 42759 5145 17 the the DT 42759 5145 18 other other JJ 42759 5145 19 groups group NNS 42759 5145 20 would would MD 42759 5145 21 have have VB 42759 5145 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5145 23 extra extra JJ 42759 5145 24 compensation compensation NN 42759 5145 25 augmented augment VBN 42759 5145 26 by by IN 42759 5145 27 the the DT 42759 5145 28 same same JJ 42759 5145 29 amount amount NN 42759 5145 30 . . . 42759 5146 1 Of of RB 42759 5146 2 course course RB 42759 5146 3 , , , 42759 5146 4 the the DT 42759 5146 5 wage wage NN 42759 5146 6 - - HYPH 42759 5146 7 fund fund NN 42759 5146 8 hypothesis hypothesis NN 42759 5146 9 which which WDT 42759 5146 10 underlies underlie VBZ 42759 5146 11 the the DT 42759 5146 12 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 5146 13 discussion discussion NN 42759 5146 14 is be VBZ 42759 5146 15 not not RB 42759 5146 16 realised realise VBN 42759 5146 17 in in IN 42759 5146 18 actual actual JJ 42759 5146 19 life life NN 42759 5146 20 , , , 42759 5146 21 any any DT 42759 5146 22 more more RBR 42759 5146 23 than than IN 42759 5146 24 was be VBD 42759 5146 25 the the DT 42759 5146 26 " " `` 42759 5146 27 wage wage NN 42759 5146 28 fund fund NN 42759 5146 29 " " '' 42759 5146 30 of of IN 42759 5146 31 the the DT 42759 5146 32 classical classical JJ 42759 5146 33 economists economist NNS 42759 5146 34 . . . 42759 5147 1 Better well RBR 42759 5147 2 than than IN 42759 5147 3 any any DT 42759 5147 4 other other JJ 42759 5147 5 device device NN 42759 5147 6 , , , 42759 5147 7 however however RB 42759 5147 8 , , , 42759 5147 9 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5147 10 enables enable VBZ 42759 5147 11 us -PRON- PRP 42759 5147 12 to to TO 42759 5147 13 describe describe VB 42759 5147 14 and and CC 42759 5147 15 visualise visualise VB 42759 5147 16 the the DT 42759 5147 17 comparative comparative JJ 42759 5147 18 claims claim NNS 42759 5147 19 of of IN 42759 5147 20 different different JJ 42759 5147 21 groups group NNS 42759 5147 22 of of IN 42759 5147 23 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5147 24 who who WP 42759 5147 25 have have VBP 42759 5147 26 a a DT 42759 5147 27 right right NN 42759 5147 28 to to IN 42759 5147 29 unequal unequal JJ 42759 5147 30 amounts amount NNS 42759 5147 31 in in IN 42759 5147 32 excess excess NN 42759 5147 33 of of IN 42759 5147 34 living live VBG 42759 5147 35 wages wage NNS 42759 5147 36 . . . 42759 5148 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5148 2 Wages Wages NNP 42759 5148 3 Versus Versus NNP 42759 5148 4 Profits Profits NNPS 42759 5148 5 _ _ NNP 42759 5148 6 Let let VBP 42759 5148 7 us -PRON- PRP 42759 5148 8 suppose suppose VB 42759 5148 9 that that IN 42759 5148 10 the the DT 42759 5148 11 wage wage NN 42759 5148 12 fund fund NN 42759 5148 13 is be VBZ 42759 5148 14 properly properly RB 42759 5148 15 apportioned apportion VBN 42759 5148 16 among among IN 42759 5148 17 the the DT 42759 5148 18 different different JJ 42759 5148 19 classes class NNS 42759 5148 20 of of IN 42759 5148 21 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5148 22 , , , 42759 5148 23 according accord VBG 42759 5148 24 to to IN 42759 5148 25 the the DT 42759 5148 26 specified specify VBN 42759 5148 27 canons canon NNS 42759 5148 28 of of IN 42759 5148 29 distribution distribution NN 42759 5148 30 . . . 42759 5149 1 May May MD 42759 5149 2 not not RB 42759 5149 3 one one CD 42759 5149 4 or or CC 42759 5149 5 all all DT 42759 5149 6 of of IN 42759 5149 7 the the DT 42759 5149 8 labour labour NN 42759 5149 9 groups group NNS 42759 5149 10 demand demand VBP 42759 5149 11 an an DT 42759 5149 12 increase increase NN 42759 5149 13 in in IN 42759 5149 14 wages wage NNS 42759 5149 15 on on IN 42759 5149 16 the the DT 42759 5149 17 ground ground NN 42759 5149 18 that that IN 42759 5149 19 the the DT 42759 5149 20 employer employer NN 42759 5149 21 is be VBZ 42759 5149 22 retaining retain VBG 42759 5149 23 for for IN 42759 5149 24 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 5149 25 an an DT 42759 5149 26 undue undue JJ 42759 5149 27 share share NN 42759 5149 28 of of IN 42759 5149 29 the the DT 42759 5149 30 product product NN 42759 5149 31 ? ? . 42759 5150 1 As as IN 42759 5150 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5150 3 have have VBP 42759 5150 4 seen see VBN 42759 5150 5 in in IN 42759 5150 6 the the DT 42759 5150 7 last last JJ 42759 5150 8 chapter chapter NN 42759 5150 9 , , , 42759 5150 10 the the DT 42759 5150 11 right right NN 42759 5150 12 of of IN 42759 5150 13 the the DT 42759 5150 14 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5150 15 to to IN 42759 5150 16 living live VBG 42759 5150 17 wages wage NNS 42759 5150 18 is be VBZ 42759 5150 19 superior superior JJ 42759 5150 20 to to IN 42759 5150 21 the the DT 42759 5150 22 right right NN 42759 5150 23 of of IN 42759 5150 24 the the DT 42759 5150 25 employer employer NN 42759 5150 26 or or CC 42759 5150 27 business business NN 42759 5150 28 man man NN 42759 5150 29 to to IN 42759 5150 30 anything anything NN 42759 5150 31 in in IN 42759 5150 32 excess excess NN 42759 5150 33 of of IN 42759 5150 34 that that DT 42759 5150 35 amount amount NN 42759 5150 36 of of IN 42759 5150 37 profits profit NNS 42759 5150 38 which which WDT 42759 5150 39 will will MD 42759 5150 40 insure insure VB 42759 5150 41 him -PRON- PRP 42759 5150 42 against against IN 42759 5150 43 risks risk NNS 42759 5150 44 , , , 42759 5150 45 and and CC 42759 5150 46 afford afford VB 42759 5150 47 him -PRON- PRP 42759 5150 48 a a DT 42759 5150 49 decent decent JJ 42759 5150 50 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5150 51 in in IN 42759 5150 52 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5150 53 conformity conformity NN 42759 5150 54 with with IN 42759 5150 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5150 56 accustomed accustomed JJ 42759 5150 57 plane plane NN 42759 5150 58 of of IN 42759 5150 59 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 5150 60 . . . 42759 5151 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5151 2 is be VBZ 42759 5151 3 also also RB 42759 5151 4 evident evident JJ 42759 5151 5 that that IN 42759 5151 6 those those DT 42759 5151 7 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5151 8 who who WP 42759 5151 9 undergo undergo VBP 42759 5151 10 more more JJR 42759 5151 11 than than IN 42759 5151 12 average average JJ 42759 5151 13 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5151 14 have have VBP 42759 5151 15 a a DT 42759 5151 16 claim claim NN 42759 5151 17 to to IN 42759 5151 18 extra extra JJ 42759 5151 19 compensation compensation NN 42759 5151 20 which which WDT 42759 5151 21 is be VBZ 42759 5151 22 quite quite RB 42759 5151 23 as as RB 42759 5151 24 valid valid JJ 42759 5151 25 as as IN 42759 5151 26 the the DT 42759 5151 27 similarly similarly RB 42759 5151 28 based base VBN 42759 5151 29 claim claim NN 42759 5151 30 of of IN 42759 5151 31 the the DT 42759 5151 32 employer employer NN 42759 5151 33 to to IN 42759 5151 34 more more JJR 42759 5151 35 than than IN 42759 5151 36 living living NN 42759 5151 37 profits profit NNS 42759 5151 38 . . . 42759 5152 1 In in IN 42759 5152 2 case case NN 42759 5152 3 the the DT 42759 5152 4 business business NN 42759 5152 5 does do VBZ 42759 5152 6 not not RB 42759 5152 7 provide provide VB 42759 5152 8 a a DT 42759 5152 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5152 10 amount amount NN 42759 5152 11 to to TO 42759 5152 12 remunerate remunerate VB 42759 5152 13 both both DT 42759 5152 14 classes class NNS 42759 5152 15 of of IN 42759 5152 16 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5152 17 , , , 42759 5152 18 the the DT 42759 5152 19 employer employer NN 42759 5152 20 may may MD 42759 5152 21 prefer prefer VB 42759 5152 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5152 23 own own JJ 42759 5152 24 to to IN 42759 5152 25 those those DT 42759 5152 26 of of IN 42759 5152 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5152 28 employés employés NN 42759 5152 29 , , , 42759 5152 30 on on IN 42759 5152 31 the the DT 42759 5152 32 same same JJ 42759 5152 33 principle principle NN 42759 5152 34 that that IN 42759 5152 35 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5152 36 may may MD 42759 5152 37 prefer prefer VB 42759 5152 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5152 39 own own JJ 42759 5152 40 claim claim NN 42759 5152 41 to to IN 42759 5152 42 a a DT 42759 5152 43 decent decent JJ 42759 5152 44 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5152 45 . . . 42759 5153 1 The the DT 42759 5153 2 law law NN 42759 5153 3 of of IN 42759 5153 4 charity charity NN 42759 5153 5 permits permit VBZ 42759 5153 6 a a DT 42759 5153 7 man man NN 42759 5153 8 to to TO 42759 5153 9 satisfy satisfy VB 42759 5153 10 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 5153 11 rather rather RB 42759 5153 12 than than IN 42759 5153 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5153 14 neighbour neighbour NN 42759 5153 15 , , , 42759 5153 16 when when WRB 42759 5153 17 the the DT 42759 5153 18 needs need NNS 42759 5153 19 in in IN 42759 5153 20 question question NN 42759 5153 21 are be VBP 42759 5153 22 of of IN 42759 5153 23 the the DT 42759 5153 24 same same JJ 42759 5153 25 degree degree NN 42759 5153 26 of of IN 42759 5153 27 urgency urgency NN 42759 5153 28 or or CC 42759 5153 29 importance importance NN 42759 5153 30 . . . 42759 5154 1 As as IN 42759 5154 2 to to IN 42759 5154 3 those those DT 42759 5154 4 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5154 5 who who WP 42759 5154 6 turn turn VBP 42759 5154 7 out out RP 42759 5154 8 larger large JJR 42759 5154 9 products product NNS 42759 5154 10 than than IN 42759 5154 11 the the DT 42759 5154 12 average average NN 42759 5154 13 , , , 42759 5154 14 or or CC 42759 5154 15 whose whose WP$ 42759 5154 16 ability ability NN 42759 5154 17 is be VBZ 42759 5154 18 unusually unusually RB 42759 5154 19 scarce scarce JJ 42759 5154 20 , , , 42759 5154 21 there there EX 42759 5154 22 is be VBZ 42759 5154 23 no no DT 42759 5154 24 practical practical JJ 42759 5154 25 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 5154 26 ; ; : 42759 5154 27 for for IN 42759 5154 28 the the DT 42759 5154 29 employer employer NN 42759 5154 30 will will MD 42759 5154 31 find find VB 42759 5154 32 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5154 33 profitable profitable JJ 42759 5154 34 to to TO 42759 5154 35 give give VB 42759 5154 36 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5154 37 the the DT 42759 5154 38 corresponding correspond VBG 42759 5154 39 extra extra JJ 42759 5154 40 compensation compensation NN 42759 5154 41 . . . 42759 5155 1 The the DT 42759 5155 2 precise precise JJ 42759 5155 3 question question NN 42759 5155 4 before before IN 42759 5155 5 us -PRON- PRP 42759 5155 6 , , , 42759 5155 7 then then RB 42759 5155 8 , , , 42759 5155 9 is be VBZ 42759 5155 10 the the DT 42759 5155 11 claims claim NNS 42759 5155 12 of of IN 42759 5155 13 the the DT 42759 5155 14 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5155 15 upon upon IN 42759 5155 16 profits profit NNS 42759 5155 17 for for IN 42759 5155 18 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5155 19 above above IN 42759 5155 20 universal universal JJ 42759 5155 21 living living NN 42759 5155 22 wages wage NNS 42759 5155 23 and and CC 42759 5155 24 above above IN 42759 5155 25 the the DT 42759 5155 26 extra extra JJ 42759 5155 27 compensation compensation NN 42759 5155 28 due due JJ 42759 5155 29 on on IN 42759 5155 30 account account NN 42759 5155 31 of of IN 42759 5155 32 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5155 33 efforts effort NNS 42759 5155 34 , , , 42759 5155 35 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5155 36 , , , 42759 5155 37 productivity productivity NN 42759 5155 38 , , , 42759 5155 39 and and CC 42759 5155 40 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5155 41 . . . 42759 5156 1 Let let VB 42759 5156 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 5156 3 call call VB 42759 5156 4 the the DT 42759 5156 5 wage wage NN 42759 5156 6 that that WDT 42759 5156 7 merely merely RB 42759 5156 8 includes include VBZ 42759 5156 9 all all PDT 42759 5156 10 these these DT 42759 5156 11 factors factor NNS 42759 5156 12 " " `` 42759 5156 13 the the DT 42759 5156 14 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5156 15 minimum minimum NN 42759 5156 16 . . . 42759 5156 17 " " '' 42759 5157 1 In in IN 42759 5157 2 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5157 3 conditions condition NNS 42759 5157 4 this this DT 42759 5157 5 question question NN 42759 5157 6 becomes become VBZ 42759 5157 7 practical practical JJ 42759 5157 8 only only RB 42759 5157 9 with with IN 42759 5157 10 reference reference NN 42759 5157 11 to to IN 42759 5157 12 the the DT 42759 5157 13 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 5157 14 efficient efficient JJ 42759 5157 15 and and CC 42759 5157 16 productive productive JJ 42759 5157 17 business business NN 42759 5157 18 men man NNS 42759 5157 19 . . . 42759 5158 1 The the DT 42759 5158 2 great great JJ 42759 5158 3 majority majority NN 42759 5158 4 have have VBP 42759 5158 5 no no DT 42759 5158 6 surplus surplus NN 42759 5158 7 available available JJ 42759 5158 8 for for IN 42759 5158 9 wage wage NN 42759 5158 10 payments payment NNS 42759 5158 11 in in IN 42759 5158 12 excess excess NN 42759 5158 13 of of IN 42759 5158 14 the the DT 42759 5158 15 " " `` 42759 5158 16 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5158 17 minimum minimum NN 42759 5158 18 . . . 42759 5158 19 " " '' 42759 5159 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 5159 2 , , , 42759 5159 3 the the DT 42759 5159 4 majority majority NN 42759 5159 5 do do VBP 42759 5159 6 not not RB 42759 5159 7 now now RB 42759 5159 8 pay pay VB 42759 5159 9 the the DT 42759 5159 10 full full JJ 42759 5159 11 " " `` 42759 5159 12 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5159 13 minimum minimum NN 42759 5159 14 " " '' 42759 5159 15 ; ; : 42759 5159 16 yet yet CC 42759 5159 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5159 18 profits profit NNS 42759 5159 19 do do VBP 42759 5159 20 not not RB 42759 5159 21 provide provide VB 42759 5159 22 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5159 23 more more JJR 42759 5159 24 than than IN 42759 5159 25 a a DT 42759 5159 26 decent decent JJ 42759 5159 27 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5159 28 . . . 42759 5160 1 The the DT 42759 5160 2 relatively relatively RB 42759 5160 3 small small JJ 42759 5160 4 number number NN 42759 5160 5 of of IN 42759 5160 6 establishments establishment NNS 42759 5160 7 that that WDT 42759 5160 8 show show VBP 42759 5160 9 such such PDT 42759 5160 10 a a DT 42759 5160 11 surplus surplus NN 42759 5160 12 as as IN 42759 5160 13 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5160 14 are be VBP 42759 5160 15 considering consider VBG 42759 5160 16 have have VBP 42759 5160 17 been be VBN 42759 5160 18 brought bring VBN 42759 5160 19 to to IN 42759 5160 20 that that DT 42759 5160 21 condition condition NN 42759 5160 22 of of IN 42759 5160 23 prosperity prosperity NN 42759 5160 24 by by IN 42759 5160 25 the the DT 42759 5160 26 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5160 27 ability ability NN 42759 5160 28 of of IN 42759 5160 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5160 30 directors director NNS 42759 5160 31 , , , 42759 5160 32 rather rather RB 42759 5160 33 than than IN 42759 5160 34 by by IN 42759 5160 35 the the DT 42759 5160 36 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5160 37 productivity productivity NN 42759 5160 38 of of IN 42759 5160 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5160 40 employés employés NN 42759 5160 41 . . . 42759 5161 1 In in IN 42759 5161 2 so so RB 42759 5161 3 far far RB 42759 5161 4 as as IN 42759 5161 5 this this DT 42759 5161 6 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5161 7 directive directive NN 42759 5161 8 ability ability NN 42759 5161 9 is be VBZ 42759 5161 10 due due JJ 42759 5161 11 to to IN 42759 5161 12 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5161 13 efforts effort NNS 42759 5161 14 and and CC 42759 5161 15 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5161 16 , , , 42759 5161 17 the the DT 42759 5161 18 surplus surplus NN 42759 5161 19 returns return NNS 42759 5161 20 which which WDT 42759 5161 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5161 22 produces produce VBZ 42759 5161 23 may may MD 42759 5161 24 be be VB 42759 5161 25 claimed claim VBN 42759 5161 26 with with IN 42759 5161 27 justice justice NN 42759 5161 28 by by IN 42759 5161 29 the the DT 42759 5161 30 employer employer NN 42759 5161 31 . . . 42759 5162 1 In in IN 42759 5162 2 so so RB 42759 5162 3 far far RB 42759 5162 4 as as IN 42759 5162 5 the the DT 42759 5162 6 surplus surplus NN 42759 5162 7 is be VBZ 42759 5162 8 the the DT 42759 5162 9 outcome outcome NN 42759 5162 10 of of IN 42759 5162 11 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5162 12 native native JJ 42759 5162 13 endowments endowment NNS 42759 5162 14 , , , 42759 5162 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5162 16 may may MD 42759 5162 17 still still RB 42759 5162 18 be be VB 42759 5162 19 justly justly RB 42759 5162 20 retained retain VBN 42759 5162 21 by by IN 42759 5162 22 him -PRON- PRP 42759 5162 23 in in IN 42759 5162 24 accordance accordance NN 42759 5162 25 with with IN 42759 5162 26 the the DT 42759 5162 27 canon canon NN 42759 5162 28 of of IN 42759 5162 29 productivity productivity NN 42759 5162 30 . . . 42759 5163 1 In in IN 42759 5163 2 other other JJ 42759 5163 3 words word NNS 42759 5163 4 , , , 42759 5163 5 when when WRB 42759 5163 6 the the DT 42759 5163 7 various various JJ 42759 5163 8 groups group NNS 42759 5163 9 of of IN 42759 5163 10 workers worker NNS 42759 5163 11 are be VBP 42759 5163 12 already already RB 42759 5163 13 receiving receive VBG 42759 5163 14 the the DT 42759 5163 15 " " `` 42759 5163 16 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5163 17 minimum minimum NN 42759 5163 18 , , , 42759 5163 19 " " '' 42759 5163 20 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5163 21 have have VBP 42759 5163 22 no no DT 42759 5163 23 strict strict JJ 42759 5163 24 right right NN 42759 5163 25 to to IN 42759 5163 26 any any DT 42759 5163 27 additional additional JJ 42759 5163 28 compensation compensation NN 42759 5163 29 out out IN 42759 5163 30 of of IN 42759 5163 31 those those DT 42759 5163 32 rare rare JJ 42759 5163 33 surplus surplus NN 42759 5163 34 profits profit NNS 42759 5163 35 which which WDT 42759 5163 36 come come VBP 42759 5163 37 into into IN 42759 5163 38 existence existence NN 42759 5163 39 in in IN 42759 5163 40 conditions condition NNS 42759 5163 41 of of IN 42759 5163 42 competition competition NN 42759 5163 43 . . . 42759 5164 1 This this DT 42759 5164 2 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 5164 3 is be VBZ 42759 5164 4 confirmed confirm VBN 42759 5164 5 by by IN 42759 5164 6 reference reference NN 42759 5164 7 to to IN 42759 5164 8 the the DT 42759 5164 9 canon canon NN 42759 5164 10 of of IN 42759 5164 11 human human JJ 42759 5164 12 welfare welfare NN 42759 5164 13 . . . 42759 5165 1 If if IN 42759 5165 2 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 5165 3 able able JJ 42759 5165 4 business business NN 42759 5165 5 men man NNS 42759 5165 6 were be VBD 42759 5165 7 not not RB 42759 5165 8 permitted permit VBN 42759 5165 9 to to TO 42759 5165 10 retain retain VB 42759 5165 11 the the DT 42759 5165 12 surplus surplus NN 42759 5165 13 in in IN 42759 5165 14 question question NN 42759 5165 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5165 16 would would MD 42759 5165 17 not not RB 42759 5165 18 exert exert VB 42759 5165 19 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 5165 20 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 5165 21 to to TO 42759 5165 22 produce produce VB 42759 5165 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5165 24 ; ; : 42759 5165 25 labour labour NNP 42759 5165 26 would would MD 42759 5165 27 gain gain VB 42759 5165 28 nothing nothing NN 42759 5165 29 ; ; : 42759 5165 30 and and CC 42759 5165 31 the the DT 42759 5165 32 community community NN 42759 5165 33 would would MD 42759 5165 34 be be VB 42759 5165 35 deprived deprive VBN 42759 5165 36 of of IN 42759 5165 37 the the DT 42759 5165 38 larger large JJR 42759 5165 39 product product NN 42759 5165 40 . . . 42759 5166 1 When when WRB 42759 5166 2 the the DT 42759 5166 3 employer employer NN 42759 5166 4 is be VBZ 42759 5166 5 a a DT 42759 5166 6 corporation corporation NN 42759 5166 7 instead instead RB 42759 5166 8 of of IN 42759 5166 9 an an DT 42759 5166 10 individual individual NN 42759 5166 11 or or CC 42759 5166 12 a a DT 42759 5166 13 partnership partnership NN 42759 5166 14 , , , 42759 5166 15 and and CC 42759 5166 16 when when WRB 42759 5166 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5166 18 is be VBZ 42759 5166 19 operating operate VBG 42759 5166 20 in in IN 42759 5166 21 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5166 22 conditions condition NNS 42759 5166 23 , , , 42759 5166 24 the the DT 42759 5166 25 same same JJ 42759 5166 26 principles principle NNS 42759 5166 27 are be VBP 42759 5166 28 applicable applicable JJ 42759 5166 29 , , , 42759 5166 30 and and CC 42759 5166 31 the the DT 42759 5166 32 same same JJ 42759 5166 33 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 5166 34 justified justify VBN 42759 5166 35 . . . 42759 5167 1 The the DT 42759 5167 2 officers officer NNS 42759 5167 3 and and CC 42759 5167 4 the the DT 42759 5167 5 whole whole JJ 42759 5167 6 body body NN 42759 5167 7 of of IN 42759 5167 8 stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 5167 9 will will MD 42759 5167 10 have have VB 42759 5167 11 a a DT 42759 5167 12 right right NN 42759 5167 13 to to IN 42759 5167 14 those those DT 42759 5167 15 surplus surplus NN 42759 5167 16 profits profit NNS 42759 5167 17 that that WDT 42759 5167 18 remain remain VBP 42759 5167 19 after after IN 42759 5167 20 the the DT 42759 5167 21 " " `` 42759 5167 22 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5167 23 minimum minimum NN 42759 5167 24 " " '' 42759 5167 25 has have VBZ 42759 5167 26 been be VBN 42759 5167 27 paid pay VBN 42759 5167 28 to to IN 42759 5167 29 the the DT 42759 5167 30 employés employés NN 42759 5167 31 . . . 42759 5168 1 Every every DT 42759 5168 2 consideration consideration NN 42759 5168 3 that that WDT 42759 5168 4 urges urge VBZ 42759 5168 5 such such PDT 42759 5168 6 a a DT 42759 5168 7 distribution distribution NN 42759 5168 8 in in IN 42759 5168 9 the the DT 42759 5168 10 case case NN 42759 5168 11 of of IN 42759 5168 12 the the DT 42759 5168 13 individual individual JJ 42759 5168 14 business business NN 42759 5168 15 holds hold VBZ 42759 5168 16 good good JJ 42759 5168 17 for for IN 42759 5168 18 the the DT 42759 5168 19 corporation corporation NN 42759 5168 20 . . . 42759 5169 1 The the DT 42759 5169 2 corporation corporation NN 42759 5169 3 that that WDT 42759 5169 4 is be VBZ 42759 5169 5 a a DT 42759 5169 6 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 5169 7 will will MD 42759 5169 8 have have VB 42759 5169 9 the the DT 42759 5169 10 same same JJ 42759 5169 11 right right NN 42759 5169 12 as as IN 42759 5169 13 the the DT 42759 5169 14 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5169 15 concern concern NN 42759 5169 16 to to TO 42759 5169 17 retain retain VB 42759 5169 18 for for IN 42759 5169 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5169 20 owners owner NNS 42759 5169 21 those those DT 42759 5169 22 surplus surplus JJ 42759 5169 23 profits profit NNS 42759 5169 24 which which WDT 42759 5169 25 are be VBP 42759 5169 26 due due JJ 42759 5169 27 to to IN 42759 5169 28 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5169 29 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5169 30 on on IN 42759 5169 31 the the DT 42759 5169 32 part part NN 42759 5169 33 of of IN 42759 5169 34 the the DT 42759 5169 35 managers manager NNS 42759 5169 36 of of IN 42759 5169 37 the the DT 42759 5169 38 business business NN 42759 5169 39 . . . 42759 5170 1 That that DT 42759 5170 2 part part NN 42759 5170 3 of of IN 42759 5170 4 the the DT 42759 5170 5 surplus surplus NN 42759 5170 6 which which WDT 42759 5170 7 is be VBZ 42759 5170 8 derived derive VBN 42759 5170 9 from from IN 42759 5170 10 the the DT 42759 5170 11 extortion extortion NN 42759 5170 12 of of IN 42759 5170 13 higher high JJR 42759 5170 14 than than IN 42759 5170 15 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5170 16 prices price NNS 42759 5170 17 can can MD 42759 5170 18 not not RB 42759 5170 19 be be VB 42759 5170 20 justly justly RB 42759 5170 21 retained retain VBN 42759 5170 22 , , , 42759 5170 23 since since IN 42759 5170 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5170 25 rests rest VBZ 42759 5170 26 upon upon IN 42759 5170 27 no no DT 42759 5170 28 definite definite JJ 42759 5170 29 moral moral JJ 42759 5170 30 title title NN 42759 5170 31 . . . 42759 5171 1 As as IN 42759 5171 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5171 3 saw see VBD 42759 5171 4 in in IN 42759 5171 5 the the DT 42759 5171 6 chapter chapter NN 42759 5171 7 on on IN 42759 5171 8 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 5171 9 , , , 42759 5171 10 the the DT 42759 5171 11 owners owner NNS 42759 5171 12 have have VBP 42759 5171 13 no no DT 42759 5171 14 right right NN 42759 5171 15 to to IN 42759 5171 16 anything anything NN 42759 5171 17 more more JJR 42759 5171 18 than than IN 42759 5171 19 the the DT 42759 5171 20 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 5171 21 rate rate NN 42759 5171 22 of of IN 42759 5171 23 interest interest NN 42759 5171 24 , , , 42759 5171 25 together together RB 42759 5171 26 with with IN 42759 5171 27 a a DT 42759 5171 28 fair fair JJ 42759 5171 29 return return NN 42759 5171 30 for for IN 42759 5171 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5171 32 labour labour NN 42759 5171 33 and and CC 42759 5171 34 for for IN 42759 5171 35 any any DT 42759 5171 36 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5171 37 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5171 38 that that IN 42759 5171 39 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5171 40 may may MD 42759 5171 41 exercise exercise VB 42759 5171 42 . . . 42759 5172 1 Should Should MD 42759 5172 2 the the DT 42759 5172 3 surplus surplus NN 42759 5172 4 in in IN 42759 5172 5 question question NN 42759 5172 6 be be VB 42759 5172 7 discontinued discontinue VBN 42759 5172 8 by by IN 42759 5172 9 lowering lower VBG 42759 5172 10 prices price NNS 42759 5172 11 , , , 42759 5172 12 or or CC 42759 5172 13 should should MD 42759 5172 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5172 15 be be VB 42759 5172 16 continued continue VBN 42759 5172 17 and and CC 42759 5172 18 distributed distribute VBN 42759 5172 19 among among IN 42759 5172 20 the the DT 42759 5172 21 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5172 22 ? ? . 42759 5173 1 As as IN 42759 5173 2 a a DT 42759 5173 3 rule rule NN 42759 5173 4 , , , 42759 5173 5 the the DT 42759 5173 6 former former JJ 42759 5173 7 course course NN 42759 5173 8 would would MD 42759 5173 9 seem seem VB 42759 5173 10 morally morally RB 42759 5173 11 preferable preferable JJ 42759 5173 12 . . . 42759 5174 1 While while IN 42759 5174 2 the the DT 42759 5174 3 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5174 4 , , , 42759 5174 5 as as IN 42759 5174 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5174 7 shall shall MD 42759 5174 8 see see VB 42759 5174 9 presently presently RB 42759 5174 10 , , , 42759 5174 11 are be VBP 42759 5174 12 justified justify VBN 42759 5174 13 in in IN 42759 5174 14 contending contend VBG 42759 5174 15 for for IN 42759 5174 16 more more JJR 42759 5174 17 than than IN 42759 5174 18 the the DT 42759 5174 19 " " `` 42759 5174 20 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5174 21 minimum minimum NN 42759 5174 22 " " '' 42759 5174 23 at at IN 42759 5174 24 the the DT 42759 5174 25 expense expense NN 42759 5174 26 of of IN 42759 5174 27 the the DT 42759 5174 28 consumer consumer NN 42759 5174 29 , , , 42759 5174 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5174 31 right right NN 42759 5174 32 to to TO 42759 5174 33 do do VB 42759 5174 34 so so RB 42759 5174 35 through through IN 42759 5174 36 the the DT 42759 5174 37 exercise exercise NN 42759 5174 38 of of IN 42759 5174 39 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 5174 40 power power NN 42759 5174 41 is be VBZ 42759 5174 42 extremely extremely RB 42759 5174 43 doubtful doubtful JJ 42759 5174 44 . . . 42759 5175 1 Whether whether IN 42759 5175 2 this this DT 42759 5175 3 power power NN 42759 5175 4 is be VBZ 42759 5175 5 exerted exert VBN 42759 5175 6 by by IN 42759 5175 7 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 5175 8 or or CC 42759 5175 9 by by IN 42759 5175 10 the the DT 42759 5175 11 employer employer NN 42759 5175 12 on on IN 42759 5175 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5175 14 behalf behalf NN 42759 5175 15 , , , 42759 5175 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5175 17 remains remain VBZ 42759 5175 18 a a DT 42759 5175 19 weapon weapon NN 42759 5175 20 which which WDT 42759 5175 21 human human JJ 42759 5175 22 nature nature NN 42759 5175 23 seems seem VBZ 42759 5175 24 incapable incapable JJ 42759 5175 25 of of IN 42759 5175 26 using use VBG 42759 5175 27 justly justly RB 42759 5175 28 . . . 42759 5176 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5176 2 Wages Wages NNP 42759 5176 3 Versus Versus NNP 42759 5176 4 Interest Interest NNP 42759 5176 5 _ _ NNP 42759 5176 6 Turning turn VBG 42759 5176 7 now now RB 42759 5176 8 to to IN 42759 5176 9 the the DT 42759 5176 10 claims claim NNS 42759 5176 11 of of IN 42759 5176 12 the the DT 42759 5176 13 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5176 14 as as IN 42759 5176 15 against against IN 42759 5176 16 the the DT 42759 5176 17 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 5176 18 , , , 42759 5176 19 or or CC 42759 5176 20 interest interest NN 42759 5176 21 receivers receiver NNS 42759 5176 22 , , , 42759 5176 23 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5176 24 perceive perceive VBP 42759 5176 25 that that IN 42759 5176 26 the the DT 42759 5176 27 right right NN 42759 5176 28 to to IN 42759 5176 29 any any DT 42759 5176 30 interest interest NN 42759 5176 31 at at RB 42759 5176 32 all all RB 42759 5176 33 is be VBZ 42759 5176 34 morally morally RB 42759 5176 35 inferior inferior JJ 42759 5176 36 to to IN 42759 5176 37 the the DT 42759 5176 38 right right NN 42759 5176 39 of of IN 42759 5176 40 all all PDT 42759 5176 41 the the DT 42759 5176 42 workers worker NNS 42759 5176 43 to to IN 42759 5176 44 the the DT 42759 5176 45 " " `` 42759 5176 46 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5176 47 minimum minimum NN 42759 5176 48 . . . 42759 5176 49 " " '' 42759 5177 1 As as IN 42759 5177 2 heretofore heretofore RB 42759 5177 3 pointed point VBD 42759 5177 4 out out RP 42759 5177 5 more more RBR 42759 5177 6 than than IN 42759 5177 7 once once RB 42759 5177 8 , , , 42759 5177 9 the the DT 42759 5177 10 former former JJ 42759 5177 11 right right NN 42759 5177 12 is be VBZ 42759 5177 13 only only RB 42759 5177 14 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 5177 15 and and CC 42759 5177 16 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 42759 5177 17 , , , 42759 5177 18 and and CC 42759 5177 19 interest interest NN 42759 5177 20 is be VBZ 42759 5177 21 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 5177 22 utilised utilise VBN 42759 5177 23 to to TO 42759 5177 24 meet meet VB 42759 5177 25 less less RBR 42759 5177 26 important important JJ 42759 5177 27 needs need NNS 42759 5177 28 than than IN 42759 5177 29 those those DT 42759 5177 30 supplied supply VBN 42759 5177 31 by by IN 42759 5177 32 wages wage NNS 42759 5177 33 . . . 42759 5178 1 Through through IN 42759 5178 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5178 3 labour labour NN 42759 5178 4 power power NN 42759 5178 5 the the DT 42759 5178 6 interest interest NN 42759 5178 7 receiver receiver NN 42759 5178 8 can can MD 42759 5178 9 supply supply VB 42759 5178 10 all all PDT 42759 5178 11 those those DT 42759 5178 12 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 5178 13 needs need NNS 42759 5178 14 which which WDT 42759 5178 15 are be VBP 42759 5178 16 satisfied satisfy VBN 42759 5178 17 by by IN 42759 5178 18 wages wage NNS 42759 5178 19 in in IN 42759 5178 20 the the DT 42759 5178 21 case case NN 42759 5178 22 of of IN 42759 5178 23 the the DT 42759 5178 24 labourer labourer NN 42759 5178 25 . . . 42759 5179 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 5179 2 , , , 42759 5179 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5179 4 seems seem VBZ 42759 5179 5 clear clear JJ 42759 5179 6 that that IN 42759 5179 7 the the DT 42759 5179 8 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5179 9 has have VBZ 42759 5179 10 no no DT 42759 5179 11 right right NN 42759 5179 12 to to IN 42759 5179 13 interest interest NN 42759 5179 14 until until IN 42759 5179 15 all all DT 42759 5179 16 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5179 17 have have VBP 42759 5179 18 received receive VBN 42759 5179 19 the the DT 42759 5179 20 " " `` 42759 5179 21 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5179 22 minimum minimum NN 42759 5179 23 . . . 42759 5179 24 " " '' 42759 5180 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5180 2 must must MD 42759 5180 3 be be VB 42759 5180 4 borne bear VBN 42759 5180 5 in in IN 42759 5180 6 mind mind NN 42759 5180 7 , , , 42759 5180 8 however however RB 42759 5180 9 , , , 42759 5180 10 that that IN 42759 5180 11 any any DT 42759 5180 12 claim claim NN 42759 5180 13 of of IN 42759 5180 14 the the DT 42759 5180 15 labourer labourer NN 42759 5180 16 against against IN 42759 5180 17 interest interest NN 42759 5180 18 falls fall VBZ 42759 5180 19 upon upon IN 42759 5180 20 the the DT 42759 5180 21 owners owner NNS 42759 5180 22 of of IN 42759 5180 23 the the DT 42759 5180 24 productive productive JJ 42759 5180 25 capital capital NN 42759 5180 26 in in IN 42759 5180 27 a a DT 42759 5180 28 business business NN 42759 5180 29 , , , 42759 5180 30 upon upon IN 42759 5180 31 the the DT 42759 5180 32 undertaker undertaker NN 42759 5180 33 - - HYPH 42759 5180 34 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 5180 35 , , , 42759 5180 36 not not RB 42759 5180 37 upon upon IN 42759 5180 38 the the DT 42759 5180 39 loan loan NN 42759 5180 40 - - HYPH 42759 5180 41 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5180 42 . . . 42759 5181 1 When when WRB 42759 5181 2 all all PDT 42759 5181 3 the the DT 42759 5181 4 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5181 5 in in IN 42759 5181 6 an an DT 42759 5181 7 industry industry NN 42759 5181 8 are be VBP 42759 5181 9 receiving receive VBG 42759 5181 10 the the DT 42759 5181 11 " " `` 42759 5181 12 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5181 13 minimum minimum NN 42759 5181 14 , , , 42759 5181 15 " " '' 42759 5181 16 have have VBP 42759 5181 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5181 18 a a DT 42759 5181 19 right right NN 42759 5181 20 to to TO 42759 5181 21 exact exact VB 42759 5181 22 anything anything NN 42759 5181 23 more more JJR 42759 5181 24 at at IN 42759 5181 25 the the DT 42759 5181 26 expense expense NN 42759 5181 27 of of IN 42759 5181 28 interest interest NN 42759 5181 29 ? ? . 42759 5182 1 By by IN 42759 5182 2 interest interest NN 42759 5182 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5182 4 mean mean VBP 42759 5182 5 , , , 42759 5182 6 of of IN 42759 5182 7 course course NN 42759 5182 8 , , , 42759 5182 9 the the DT 42759 5182 10 prevailing prevailing JJ 42759 5182 11 or or CC 42759 5182 12 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5182 13 rate rate NN 42759 5182 14 that that WDT 42759 5182 15 is be VBZ 42759 5182 16 received receive VBN 42759 5182 17 on on IN 42759 5182 18 productive productive JJ 42759 5182 19 capital capital NN 42759 5182 20 -- -- : 42759 5182 21 five five CD 42759 5182 22 or or CC 42759 5182 23 six six CD 42759 5182 24 per per IN 42759 5182 25 cent cent NN 42759 5182 26 . . . 42759 5183 1 Any any DT 42759 5183 2 return return NN 42759 5183 3 to to IN 42759 5183 4 the the DT 42759 5183 5 owners owner NNS 42759 5183 6 of of IN 42759 5183 7 capital capital NN 42759 5183 8 in in IN 42759 5183 9 excess excess NN 42759 5183 10 of of IN 42759 5183 11 this this DT 42759 5183 12 rate rate NN 42759 5183 13 is be VBZ 42759 5183 14 properly properly RB 42759 5183 15 called call VBN 42759 5183 16 profits profit NNS 42759 5183 17 rather rather RB 42759 5183 18 than than IN 42759 5183 19 interest interest NN 42759 5183 20 , , , 42759 5183 21 and and CC 42759 5183 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5183 23 relation relation NN 42759 5183 24 to to IN 42759 5183 25 the the DT 42759 5183 26 claims claim NNS 42759 5183 27 of of IN 42759 5183 28 the the DT 42759 5183 29 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5183 30 has have VBZ 42759 5183 31 received receive VBN 42759 5183 32 consideration consideration NN 42759 5183 33 in in IN 42759 5183 34 the the DT 42759 5183 35 immediately immediately RB 42759 5183 36 preceding precede VBG 42759 5183 37 section section NN 42759 5183 38 of of IN 42759 5183 39 this this DT 42759 5183 40 chapter chapter NN 42759 5183 41 . . . 42759 5184 1 The the DT 42759 5184 2 question question NN 42759 5184 3 , , , 42759 5184 4 then then RB 42759 5184 5 , , , 42759 5184 6 is be VBZ 42759 5184 7 whether whether IN 42759 5184 8 the the DT 42759 5184 9 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5184 10 who who WP 42759 5184 11 are be VBP 42759 5184 12 already already RB 42759 5184 13 getting get VBG 42759 5184 14 the the DT 42759 5184 15 " " `` 42759 5184 16 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5184 17 minimum minimum NN 42759 5184 18 " " '' 42759 5184 19 would would MD 42759 5184 20 act act VB 42759 5184 21 justly justly RB 42759 5184 22 in in IN 42759 5184 23 demanding demand VBG 42759 5184 24 and and CC 42759 5184 25 using use VBG 42759 5184 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5184 27 economic economic JJ 42759 5184 28 power power NN 42759 5184 29 to to TO 42759 5184 30 obtain obtain VB 42759 5184 31 a a DT 42759 5184 32 part part NN 42759 5184 33 or or CC 42759 5184 34 all all DT 42759 5184 35 of of IN 42759 5184 36 the the DT 42759 5184 37 pure pure JJ 42759 5184 38 interest interest NN 42759 5184 39 . . . 42759 5185 1 No no DT 42759 5185 2 conclusive conclusive JJ 42759 5185 3 reason reason NN 42759 5185 4 is be VBZ 42759 5185 5 available available JJ 42759 5185 6 to to TO 42759 5185 7 justify justify VB 42759 5185 8 a a DT 42759 5185 9 negative negative JJ 42759 5185 10 answer answer NN 42759 5185 11 . . . 42759 5186 1 The the DT 42759 5186 2 title title NN 42759 5186 3 of of IN 42759 5186 4 the the DT 42759 5186 5 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5186 6 is be VBZ 42759 5186 7 only only RB 42759 5186 8 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 5186 9 and and CC 42759 5186 10 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 42759 5186 11 , , , 42759 5186 12 not not RB 42759 5186 13 certain certain JJ 42759 5186 14 and and CC 42759 5186 15 unconditional unconditional JJ 42759 5186 16 . . . 42759 5187 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5187 2 is be VBZ 42759 5187 3 , , , 42759 5187 4 indeed indeed RB 42759 5187 5 , , , 42759 5187 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5187 7 to to TO 42759 5187 8 justify justify VB 42759 5187 9 him -PRON- PRP 42759 5187 10 in in IN 42759 5187 11 retaining retain VBG 42759 5187 12 interest interest NN 42759 5187 13 that that WDT 42759 5187 14 comes come VBZ 42759 5187 15 to to IN 42759 5187 16 him -PRON- PRP 42759 5187 17 through through IN 42759 5187 18 the the DT 42759 5187 19 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 5187 20 processes process NNS 42759 5187 21 of of IN 42759 5187 22 competition competition NN 42759 5187 23 and and CC 42759 5187 24 bargaining bargaining NN 42759 5187 25 ; ; : 42759 5187 26 but but CC 42759 5187 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5187 28 is be VBZ 42759 5187 29 not not RB 42759 5187 30 of of IN 42759 5187 31 such such JJ 42759 5187 32 definite definite JJ 42759 5187 33 and and CC 42759 5187 34 compelling compelling JJ 42759 5187 35 moral moral JJ 42759 5187 36 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 5187 37 as as IN 42759 5187 38 to to TO 42759 5187 39 render render VB 42759 5187 40 the the DT 42759 5187 41 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5187 42 guilty guilty JJ 42759 5187 43 of of IN 42759 5187 44 injustice injustice NN 42759 5187 45 when when WRB 42759 5187 46 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5187 47 employ employ VBP 42759 5187 48 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5187 49 economic economic JJ 42759 5187 50 power power NN 42759 5187 51 to to TO 42759 5187 52 divert divert VB 42759 5187 53 further further JJ 42759 5187 54 interest interest NN 42759 5187 55 from from IN 42759 5187 56 the the DT 42759 5187 57 coffers coffer NNS 42759 5187 58 of of IN 42759 5187 59 the the DT 42759 5187 60 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5187 61 to to IN 42759 5187 62 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5187 63 own own JJ 42759 5187 64 pockets pocket NNS 42759 5187 65 . . . 42759 5188 1 The the DT 42759 5188 2 interest interest NN 42759 5188 3 - - HYPH 42759 5188 4 share share NN 42759 5188 5 of of IN 42759 5188 6 the the DT 42759 5188 7 product product NN 42759 5188 8 is be VBZ 42759 5188 9 morally morally RB 42759 5188 10 debatable debatable JJ 42759 5188 11 as as IN 42759 5188 12 to to IN 42759 5188 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5188 14 ownership ownership NN 42759 5188 15 . . . 42759 5189 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5189 2 is be VBZ 42759 5189 3 a a DT 42759 5189 4 sort sort NN 42759 5189 5 of of IN 42759 5189 6 no no DT 42759 5189 7 - - HYPH 42759 5189 8 man man NN 42759 5189 9 's 's POS 42759 5189 10 property property NN 42759 5189 11 ( ( -LRB- 42759 5189 12 like like IN 42759 5189 13 the the DT 42759 5189 14 rent rent NN 42759 5189 15 of of IN 42759 5189 16 land land NN 42759 5189 17 antecedently antecedently RB 42759 5189 18 to to IN 42759 5189 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5189 20 legal legal JJ 42759 5189 21 assignment assignment NN 42759 5189 22 through through IN 42759 5189 23 the the DT 42759 5189 24 institution institution NN 42759 5189 25 of of IN 42759 5189 26 private private JJ 42759 5189 27 landownership landownership NN 42759 5189 28 ) ) -RRB- 42759 5189 29 which which WDT 42759 5189 30 properly properly RB 42759 5189 31 goes go VBZ 42759 5189 32 to to IN 42759 5189 33 the the DT 42759 5189 34 first first JJ 42759 5189 35 occupant occupant NN 42759 5189 36 as as IN 42759 5189 37 determined determine VBN 42759 5189 38 by by IN 42759 5189 39 the the DT 42759 5189 40 processes process NNS 42759 5189 41 of of IN 42759 5189 42 bargaining bargaining NN 42759 5189 43 between between IN 42759 5189 44 employers employer NNS 42759 5189 45 and and CC 42759 5189 46 employés employés NNP 42759 5189 47 . . . 42759 5190 1 If if IN 42759 5190 2 the the DT 42759 5190 3 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 5190 4 get get VBP 42759 5190 5 the the DT 42759 5190 6 interest interest NN 42759 5190 7 - - HYPH 42759 5190 8 share share NN 42759 5190 9 through through IN 42759 5190 10 these these DT 42759 5190 11 processes process NNS 42759 5190 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5190 13 rightfully rightfully RB 42759 5190 14 belongs belong VBZ 42759 5190 15 to to IN 42759 5190 16 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5190 17 ; ; : 42759 5190 18 if if IN 42759 5190 19 the the DT 42759 5190 20 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5190 21 who who WP 42759 5190 22 are be VBP 42759 5190 23 already already RB 42759 5190 24 in in IN 42759 5190 25 possession possession NN 42759 5190 26 of of IN 42759 5190 27 the the DT 42759 5190 28 " " `` 42759 5190 29 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5190 30 minimum minimum NN 42759 5190 31 " " '' 42759 5190 32 develop develop VB 42759 5190 33 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5190 34 economic economic JJ 42759 5190 35 strength strength NN 42759 5190 36 to to TO 42759 5190 37 get get VB 42759 5190 38 this this DT 42759 5190 39 debatable debatable JJ 42759 5190 40 share share NN 42759 5190 41 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5190 42 may may MD 42759 5190 43 justly justly RB 42759 5190 44 retain retain VB 42759 5190 45 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5190 46 as as IN 42759 5190 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5190 48 own own JJ 42759 5190 49 . . . 42759 5191 1 The the DT 42759 5191 2 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 5191 3 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 5191 4 may may MD 42759 5191 5 seem seem VB 42759 5191 6 to to TO 42759 5191 7 be be VB 42759 5191 8 a a DT 42759 5191 9 very very RB 42759 5191 10 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 42759 5191 11 solution solution NN 42759 5191 12 of of IN 42759 5191 13 a a DT 42759 5191 14 problem problem NN 42759 5191 15 of of IN 42759 5191 16 justice justice NN 42759 5191 17 . . . 42759 5192 1 However however RB 42759 5192 2 , , , 42759 5192 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5192 4 is be VBZ 42759 5192 5 the the DT 42759 5192 6 only only JJ 42759 5192 7 one one NN 42759 5192 8 that that WDT 42759 5192 9 is be VBZ 42759 5192 10 practically practically RB 42759 5192 11 defensible defensible JJ 42759 5192 12 . . . 42759 5193 1 If if IN 42759 5193 2 the the DT 42759 5193 3 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5193 4 's 's POS 42759 5193 5 claim claim NN 42759 5193 6 to to IN 42759 5193 7 interest interest NN 42759 5193 8 were be VBD 42759 5193 9 as as RB 42759 5193 10 definite definite JJ 42759 5193 11 and and CC 42759 5193 12 certain certain JJ 42759 5193 13 as as IN 42759 5193 14 the the DT 42759 5193 15 labourer labourer NN 42759 5193 16 's 's POS 42759 5193 17 right right NN 42759 5193 18 to to IN 42759 5193 19 a a DT 42759 5193 20 living living NN 42759 5193 21 wage wage NN 42759 5193 22 , , , 42759 5193 23 or or CC 42759 5193 24 as as IN 42759 5193 25 the the DT 42759 5193 26 creditor creditor NN 42759 5193 27 's 's POS 42759 5193 28 right right NN 42759 5193 29 to to IN 42759 5193 30 the the DT 42759 5193 31 money money NN 42759 5193 32 that that WDT 42759 5193 33 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5193 34 has have VBZ 42759 5193 35 loaned loan VBN 42759 5193 36 , , , 42759 5193 37 the the DT 42759 5193 38 solution solution NN 42759 5193 39 would would MD 42759 5193 40 be be VB 42759 5193 41 very very RB 42759 5193 42 simple simple JJ 42759 5193 43 : : : 42759 5193 44 the the DT 42759 5193 45 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5193 46 that that WDT 42759 5193 47 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5193 48 are be VBP 42759 5193 49 discussing discuss VBG 42759 5193 50 would would MD 42759 5193 51 have have VB 42759 5193 52 no no DT 42759 5193 53 right right NN 42759 5193 54 to to TO 42759 5193 55 strive strive VB 42759 5193 56 for for IN 42759 5193 57 any any DT 42759 5193 58 of of IN 42759 5193 59 the the DT 42759 5193 60 interest interest NN 42759 5193 61 . . . 42759 5194 1 But but CC 42759 5194 2 the the DT 42759 5194 3 claim claim NN 42759 5194 4 of of IN 42759 5194 5 the the DT 42759 5194 6 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 5194 7 is be VBZ 42759 5194 8 not not RB 42759 5194 9 of of IN 42759 5194 10 this this DT 42759 5194 11 clear clear JJ 42759 5194 12 and and CC 42759 5194 13 conclusive conclusive JJ 42759 5194 14 nature nature NN 42759 5194 15 . . . 42759 5195 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5195 2 is be VBZ 42759 5195 3 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5195 4 when when WRB 42759 5195 5 combined combine VBN 42759 5195 6 with with IN 42759 5195 7 actual actual JJ 42759 5195 8 possession possession NN 42759 5195 9 ; ; : 42759 5195 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5195 11 is be VBZ 42759 5195 12 not not RB 42759 5195 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5195 14 when when WRB 42759 5195 15 the the DT 42759 5195 16 question question NN 42759 5195 17 is be VBZ 42759 5195 18 of of IN 42759 5195 19 future future JJ 42759 5195 20 possession possession NN 42759 5195 21 . . . 42759 5196 1 The the DT 42759 5196 2 title title NN 42759 5196 3 of of IN 42759 5196 4 first first JJ 42759 5196 5 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 5196 6 as as IN 42759 5196 7 regards regard VBZ 42759 5196 8 land land NN 42759 5196 9 is be VBZ 42759 5196 10 not not RB 42759 5196 11 valid valid JJ 42759 5196 12 until until IN 42759 5196 13 the the DT 42759 5196 14 land land NN 42759 5196 15 has have VBZ 42759 5196 16 been be VBN 42759 5196 17 actually actually RB 42759 5196 18 occupied occupy VBN 42759 5196 19 ; ; : 42759 5196 20 and and CC 42759 5196 21 similarly similarly RB 42759 5196 22 the the DT 42759 5196 23 claim claim NN 42759 5196 24 of of IN 42759 5196 25 the the DT 42759 5196 26 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5196 27 to to IN 42759 5196 28 interest interest NN 42759 5196 29 is be VBZ 42759 5196 30 not not RB 42759 5196 31 valid valid JJ 42759 5196 32 until until IN 42759 5196 33 the the DT 42759 5196 34 interest interest NN 42759 5196 35 has have VBZ 42759 5196 36 been be VBN 42759 5196 37 received receive VBN 42759 5196 38 . . . 42759 5197 1 If if IN 42759 5197 2 the the DT 42759 5197 3 economic economic JJ 42759 5197 4 forces force NNS 42759 5197 5 which which WDT 42759 5197 6 determine determine VBP 42759 5197 7 actual actual JJ 42759 5197 8 possession possession NN 42759 5197 9 operate operate VB 42759 5197 10 in in IN 42759 5197 11 such such PDT 42759 5197 12 a a DT 42759 5197 13 way way NN 42759 5197 14 as as IN 42759 5197 15 to to TO 42759 5197 16 divert divert VB 42759 5197 17 the the DT 42759 5197 18 interest interest NN 42759 5197 19 - - HYPH 42759 5197 20 share share NN 42759 5197 21 to to IN 42759 5197 22 the the DT 42759 5197 23 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5197 24 , , , 42759 5197 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5197 26 , , , 42759 5197 27 not not RB 42759 5197 28 the the DT 42759 5197 29 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 5197 30 , , , 42759 5197 31 will will MD 42759 5197 32 have have VB 42759 5197 33 the the DT 42759 5197 34 valid valid JJ 42759 5197 35 moral moral JJ 42759 5197 36 title title NN 42759 5197 37 , , , 42759 5197 38 just just RB 42759 5197 39 as as IN 42759 5197 40 Brown Brown NNP 42759 5197 41 with with IN 42759 5197 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5197 43 automobile automobile NN 42759 5197 44 rather rather RB 42759 5197 45 than than IN 42759 5197 46 Jones Jones NNP 42759 5197 47 with with IN 42759 5197 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5197 49 spavined spavined JJ 42759 5197 50 nag nag NNP 42759 5197 51 will will MD 42759 5197 52 enjoy enjoy VB 42759 5197 53 the the DT 42759 5197 54 valid valid JJ 42759 5197 55 title title NN 42759 5197 56 of of IN 42759 5197 57 first first JJ 42759 5197 58 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 5197 59 to to IN 42759 5197 60 a a DT 42759 5197 61 piece piece NN 42759 5197 62 of of IN 42759 5197 63 ownerless ownerless JJ 42759 5197 64 land land NN 42759 5197 65 which which WDT 42759 5197 66 both both DT 42759 5197 67 have have VBP 42759 5197 68 coveted covet VBN 42759 5197 69 . . . 42759 5198 1 This this DT 42759 5198 2 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 5198 3 is be VBZ 42759 5198 4 confirmed confirm VBN 42759 5198 5 by by IN 42759 5198 6 reference reference NN 42759 5198 7 to to IN 42759 5198 8 the the DT 42759 5198 9 rationally rationally RB 42759 5198 10 and and CC 42759 5198 11 morally morally RB 42759 5198 12 impossible impossible JJ 42759 5198 13 situation situation NN 42759 5198 14 that that WDT 42759 5198 15 would would MD 42759 5198 16 follow follow VB 42759 5198 17 from from IN 42759 5198 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5198 19 rejection rejection NN 42759 5198 20 . . . 42759 5199 1 If if IN 42759 5199 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5199 3 deny deny VBP 42759 5199 4 to to IN 42759 5199 5 the the DT 42759 5199 6 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5199 7 the the DT 42759 5199 8 moral moral JJ 42759 5199 9 freedom freedom NN 42759 5199 10 to to TO 42759 5199 11 strive strive VB 42759 5199 12 for for IN 42759 5199 13 higher high JJR 42759 5199 14 wages wage NNS 42759 5199 15 at at IN 42759 5199 16 the the DT 42759 5199 17 expense expense NN 42759 5199 18 of of IN 42759 5199 19 the the DT 42759 5199 20 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5199 21 , , , 42759 5199 22 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5199 23 must must MD 42759 5199 24 also also RB 42759 5199 25 forbid forbid VB 42759 5199 26 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5199 27 to to TO 42759 5199 28 follow follow VB 42759 5199 29 this this DT 42759 5199 30 course course NN 42759 5199 31 at at IN 42759 5199 32 the the DT 42759 5199 33 expense expense NN 42759 5199 34 of of IN 42759 5199 35 the the DT 42759 5199 36 consumer consumer NN 42759 5199 37 . . . 42759 5200 1 For for IN 42759 5200 2 the the DT 42759 5200 3 great great JJ 42759 5200 4 majority majority NN 42759 5200 5 of of IN 42759 5200 6 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5200 7 would would MD 42759 5200 8 stand stand VB 42759 5200 9 to to TO 42759 5200 10 lose lose VB 42759 5200 11 advantages advantage NNS 42759 5200 12 to to TO 42759 5200 13 which which WDT 42759 5200 14 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5200 15 have have VBP 42759 5200 16 as as RB 42759 5200 17 good good JJ 42759 5200 18 a a DT 42759 5200 19 moral moral JJ 42759 5200 20 claim claim NN 42759 5200 21 as as IN 42759 5200 22 the the DT 42759 5200 23 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 5200 24 have have VBP 42759 5200 25 to to TO 42759 5200 26 interest interest NN 42759 5200 27 . . . 42759 5201 1 Practically practically RB 42759 5201 2 this this DT 42759 5201 3 would would MD 42759 5201 4 mean mean VB 42759 5201 5 that that IN 42759 5201 6 the the DT 42759 5201 7 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5201 8 have have VBP 42759 5201 9 no no DT 42759 5201 10 right right NN 42759 5201 11 to to TO 42759 5201 12 seek seek VB 42759 5201 13 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5201 14 in in IN 42759 5201 15 excess excess NN 42759 5201 16 of of IN 42759 5201 17 the the DT 42759 5201 18 " " `` 42759 5201 19 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5201 20 minimum minimum NN 42759 5201 21 " " '' 42759 5201 22 ; ; : 42759 5201 23 for for IN 42759 5201 24 such such JJ 42759 5201 25 excess excess NN 42759 5201 26 must must MD 42759 5201 27 in in IN 42759 5201 28 substantially substantially RB 42759 5201 29 all all DT 42759 5201 30 cases case NNS 42759 5201 31 come come VBP 42759 5201 32 from from IN 42759 5201 33 either either CC 42759 5201 34 the the DT 42759 5201 35 consumer consumer NN 42759 5201 36 or or CC 42759 5201 37 the the DT 42759 5201 38 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5201 39 . . . 42759 5202 1 On on IN 42759 5202 2 what what WDT 42759 5202 3 principle principle NN 42759 5202 4 can can MD 42759 5202 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5202 6 defend defend VB 42759 5202 7 the the DT 42759 5202 8 proposition proposition NN 42759 5202 9 that that IN 42759 5202 10 the the DT 42759 5202 11 great great JJ 42759 5202 12 majority majority NN 42759 5202 13 of of IN 42759 5202 14 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5202 15 are be VBP 42759 5202 16 forever forever RB 42759 5202 17 restrained restrain VBN 42759 5202 18 by by IN 42759 5202 19 the the DT 42759 5202 20 moral moral JJ 42759 5202 21 law law NN 42759 5202 22 from from IN 42759 5202 23 seeking seek VBG 42759 5202 24 more more RBR 42759 5202 25 than than IN 42759 5202 26 bare bare JJ 42759 5202 27 living live VBG 42759 5202 28 wages wage NNS 42759 5202 29 , , , 42759 5202 30 and and CC 42759 5202 31 the the DT 42759 5202 32 specialised specialised JJ 42759 5202 33 minority minority NN 42759 5202 34 from from IN 42759 5202 35 demanding demand VBG 42759 5202 36 more more RBR 42759 5202 37 than than IN 42759 5202 38 that that DT 42759 5202 39 extra extra JJ 42759 5202 40 compensation compensation NN 42759 5202 41 which which WDT 42759 5202 42 corresponds correspond VBZ 42759 5202 43 to to IN 42759 5202 44 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5202 45 efforts effort NNS 42759 5202 46 , , , 42759 5202 47 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5202 48 , , , 42759 5202 49 productivity productivity NN 42759 5202 50 , , , 42759 5202 51 and and CC 42759 5202 52 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5202 53 ? ? . 42759 5203 1 Who who WP 42759 5203 2 has have VBZ 42759 5203 3 authorised authorise VBN 42759 5203 4 us -PRON- PRP 42759 5203 5 to to TO 42759 5203 6 shut shut VB 42759 5203 7 against against IN 42759 5203 8 these these DT 42759 5203 9 classes class NNS 42759 5203 10 the the DT 42759 5203 11 doors door NNS 42759 5203 12 of of IN 42759 5203 13 a a DT 42759 5203 14 more more RBR 42759 5203 15 liberal liberal JJ 42759 5203 16 standard standard NN 42759 5203 17 of of IN 42759 5203 18 living living NN 42759 5203 19 , , , 42759 5203 20 and and CC 42759 5203 21 a a DT 42759 5203 22 more more RBR 42759 5203 23 ample ample JJ 42759 5203 24 measure measure NN 42759 5203 25 of of IN 42759 5203 26 self self NN 42759 5203 27 development development NN 42759 5203 28 ? ? . 42759 5204 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5204 2 Wages Wages NNP 42759 5204 3 Versus Versus NNP 42759 5204 4 Prices Prices NNPS 42759 5204 5 _ _ NNP 42759 5204 6 The the DT 42759 5204 7 right right NN 42759 5204 8 of of IN 42759 5204 9 the the DT 42759 5204 10 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5204 11 to to IN 42759 5204 12 the the DT 42759 5204 13 " " `` 42759 5204 14 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5204 15 minimum minimum NN 42759 5204 16 " " '' 42759 5204 17 implies imply VBZ 42759 5204 18 obviously obviously RB 42759 5204 19 the the DT 42759 5204 20 right right NN 42759 5204 21 to to TO 42759 5204 22 impose impose VB 42759 5204 23 adequate adequate JJ 42759 5204 24 prices price NNS 42759 5204 25 upon upon IN 42759 5204 26 the the DT 42759 5204 27 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5204 28 of of IN 42759 5204 29 the the DT 42759 5204 30 labourer labourer NN 42759 5204 31 's 's POS 42759 5204 32 products product NNS 42759 5204 33 . . . 42759 5205 1 This this DT 42759 5205 2 is be VBZ 42759 5205 3 the the DT 42759 5205 4 ultimate ultimate JJ 42759 5205 5 source source NN 42759 5205 6 of of IN 42759 5205 7 the the DT 42759 5205 8 rewards reward NNS 42759 5205 9 of of IN 42759 5205 10 all all PDT 42759 5205 11 the the DT 42759 5205 12 agents agent NNS 42759 5205 13 of of IN 42759 5205 14 production production NN 42759 5205 15 . . . 42759 5206 1 Suppose suppose VB 42759 5206 2 that that IN 42759 5206 3 the the DT 42759 5206 4 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5206 5 are be VBP 42759 5206 6 already already RB 42759 5206 7 receiving receive VBG 42759 5206 8 the the DT 42759 5206 9 " " `` 42759 5206 10 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5206 11 minimum minimum NN 42759 5206 12 . . . 42759 5206 13 " " '' 42759 5207 1 Are be VBP 42759 5207 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5207 3 justified justify VBN 42759 5207 4 in in IN 42759 5207 5 seeking seek VBG 42759 5207 6 any any DT 42759 5207 7 more more JJR 42759 5207 8 at at IN 42759 5207 9 the the DT 42759 5207 10 cost cost NN 42759 5207 11 of of IN 42759 5207 12 the the DT 42759 5207 13 consumer consumer NN 42759 5207 14 ? ? . 42759 5208 1 If if IN 42759 5208 2 all all PDT 42759 5208 3 the the DT 42759 5208 4 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5208 5 were be VBD 42759 5208 6 also also RB 42759 5208 7 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5208 8 the the DT 42759 5208 9 answer answer NN 42759 5208 10 would would MD 42759 5208 11 be be VB 42759 5208 12 simple simple JJ 42759 5208 13 , , , 42759 5208 14 at at IN 42759 5208 15 least least JJS 42759 5208 16 in in IN 42759 5208 17 principle principle NN 42759 5208 18 : : : 42759 5208 19 rises rise NNS 42759 5208 20 in in IN 42759 5208 21 wages wage NNS 42759 5208 22 and and CC 42759 5208 23 prices price NNS 42759 5208 24 ought ought MD 42759 5208 25 to to TO 42759 5208 26 be be VB 42759 5208 27 so so RB 42759 5208 28 adjusted adjusted JJ 42759 5208 29 as as IN 42759 5208 30 to to TO 42759 5208 31 bring bring VB 42759 5208 32 equal equal JJ 42759 5208 33 gains gain NNS 42759 5208 34 to to IN 42759 5208 35 all all DT 42759 5208 36 individuals individual NNS 42759 5208 37 . . . 42759 5209 1 The the DT 42759 5209 2 " " `` 42759 5209 3 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5209 4 minimum minimum NN 42759 5209 5 " " '' 42759 5209 6 is be VBZ 42759 5209 7 adjusted adjust VBN 42759 5209 8 to to IN 42759 5209 9 the the DT 42759 5209 10 varying vary VBG 42759 5209 11 moral moral JJ 42759 5209 12 claims claim NNS 42759 5209 13 of of IN 42759 5209 14 the the DT 42759 5209 15 different different JJ 42759 5209 16 classes class NNS 42759 5209 17 of of IN 42759 5209 18 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5209 19 ; ; : 42759 5209 20 therefore therefore RB 42759 5209 21 , , , 42759 5209 22 any any DT 42759 5209 23 rise rise NN 42759 5209 24 in in IN 42759 5209 25 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5209 26 must must MD 42759 5209 27 be be VB 42759 5209 28 equally equally RB 42759 5209 29 distributed distribute VBN 42759 5209 30 in in IN 42759 5209 31 order order NN 42759 5209 32 to to TO 42759 5209 33 leave leave VB 42759 5209 34 this this DT 42759 5209 35 adjustment adjustment NN 42759 5209 36 undisturbed undisturbed JJ 42759 5209 37 . . . 42759 5210 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5210 2 is be VBZ 42759 5210 3 a a DT 42759 5210 4 fact fact NN 42759 5210 5 , , , 42759 5210 6 however however RB 42759 5210 7 , , , 42759 5210 8 that that IN 42759 5210 9 a a DT 42759 5210 10 large large JJ 42759 5210 11 part part NN 42759 5210 12 of of IN 42759 5210 13 the the DT 42759 5210 14 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5210 15 are be VBP 42759 5210 16 not not RB 42759 5210 17 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5210 18 ; ; : 42759 5210 19 consequently consequently RB 42759 5210 20 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5210 21 can can MD 42759 5210 22 not not RB 42759 5210 23 look look VB 42759 5210 24 to to IN 42759 5210 25 rises rise NNS 42759 5210 26 in in IN 42759 5210 27 wages wage NNS 42759 5210 28 as as IN 42759 5210 29 an an DT 42759 5210 30 offset offset NN 42759 5210 31 to to IN 42759 5210 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5210 33 losses loss NNS 42759 5210 34 through through IN 42759 5210 35 rises rise NNS 42759 5210 36 in in IN 42759 5210 37 prices price NNS 42759 5210 38 . . . 42759 5211 1 Can Can MD 42759 5211 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5211 3 be be VB 42759 5211 4 justly justly RB 42759 5211 5 required require VBN 42759 5211 6 to to TO 42759 5211 7 undergo undergo VB 42759 5211 8 this this DT 42759 5211 9 inconvenience inconvenience NN 42759 5211 10 for for IN 42759 5211 11 the the DT 42759 5211 12 benefit benefit NN 42759 5211 13 of of IN 42759 5211 14 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5211 15 who who WP 42759 5211 16 are be VBP 42759 5211 17 already already RB 42759 5211 18 getting get VBG 42759 5211 19 the the DT 42759 5211 20 " " `` 42759 5211 21 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5211 22 minimum minimum NN 42759 5211 23 " " '' 42759 5211 24 ? ? . 42759 5212 1 Let let VB 42759 5212 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 5212 3 consider consider VB 42759 5212 4 first first RB 42759 5212 5 the the DT 42759 5212 6 case case NN 42759 5212 7 of of IN 42759 5212 8 higher high JJR 42759 5212 9 wages wage NNS 42759 5212 10 versus versus IN 42759 5212 11 lower low JJR 42759 5212 12 prices price NNS 42759 5212 13 . . . 42759 5213 1 A a DT 42759 5213 2 few few JJ 42759 5213 3 progressive progressive JJ 42759 5213 4 and and CC 42759 5213 5 efficient efficient JJ 42759 5213 6 manufacturers manufacturer NNS 42759 5213 7 of of IN 42759 5213 8 shoes shoe NNS 42759 5213 9 find find VBP 42759 5213 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 5213 11 receiving receive VBG 42759 5213 12 large large JJ 42759 5213 13 surplus surplus NN 42759 5213 14 profits profit NNS 42759 5213 15 which which WDT 42759 5213 16 are be VBP 42759 5213 17 likely likely JJ 42759 5213 18 to to TO 42759 5213 19 continue continue VB 42759 5213 20 . . . 42759 5214 1 So so RB 42759 5214 2 far far RB 42759 5214 3 as as IN 42759 5214 4 the the DT 42759 5214 5 presumptions presumption NNS 42759 5214 6 of of IN 42759 5214 7 strict strict JJ 42759 5214 8 justice justice NN 42759 5214 9 are be VBP 42759 5214 10 concerned concern VBN 42759 5214 11 , , , 42759 5214 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5214 13 may may MD 42759 5214 14 , , , 42759 5214 15 owing owe VBG 42759 5214 16 to to IN 42759 5214 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5214 18 superior superior JJ 42759 5214 19 productivity productivity NN 42759 5214 20 , , , 42759 5214 21 retain retain VB 42759 5214 22 these these DT 42759 5214 23 profits profit NNS 42759 5214 24 for for IN 42759 5214 25 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 5214 26 . . . 42759 5215 1 Seized seize VBN 42759 5215 2 , , , 42759 5215 3 however however RB 42759 5215 4 , , , 42759 5215 5 with with IN 42759 5215 6 a a DT 42759 5215 7 feeling feeling NN 42759 5215 8 of of IN 42759 5215 9 benevolence benevolence NN 42759 5215 10 , , , 42759 5215 11 or or CC 42759 5215 12 a a DT 42759 5215 13 scruple scruple NN 42759 5215 14 of of IN 42759 5215 15 conscience conscience NN 42759 5215 16 , , , 42759 5215 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5215 18 determine determine VBP 42759 5215 19 to to TO 42759 5215 20 divide divide VB 42759 5215 21 future future JJ 42759 5215 22 profits profit NNS 42759 5215 23 of of IN 42759 5215 24 this this DT 42759 5215 25 class class NN 42759 5215 26 among among IN 42759 5215 27 either either CC 42759 5215 28 the the DT 42759 5215 29 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5215 30 or or CC 42759 5215 31 the the DT 42759 5215 32 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5215 33 . . . 42759 5216 1 If if IN 42759 5216 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5216 3 reduce reduce VBP 42759 5216 4 prices price NNS 42759 5216 5 the the DT 42759 5216 6 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5216 7 will will MD 42759 5216 8 gain gain VB 42759 5216 9 something something NN 42759 5216 10 as as IN 42759 5216 11 users user NNS 42759 5216 12 of of IN 42759 5216 13 shoes shoe NNS 42759 5216 14 , , , 42759 5216 15 but but CC 42759 5216 16 the the DT 42759 5216 17 other other JJ 42759 5216 18 wearers wearer NNS 42759 5216 19 of of IN 42759 5216 20 shoes shoe NNS 42759 5216 21 will will MD 42759 5216 22 also also RB 42759 5216 23 be be VB 42759 5216 24 beneficiaries beneficiary NNS 42759 5216 25 . . . 42759 5217 1 If if IN 42759 5217 2 the the DT 42759 5217 3 surplus surplus NN 42759 5217 4 profits profit NNS 42759 5217 5 are be VBP 42759 5217 6 all all DT 42759 5217 7 diverted divert VBN 42759 5217 8 to to IN 42759 5217 9 the the DT 42759 5217 10 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5217 11 in in IN 42759 5217 12 the the DT 42759 5217 13 form form NN 42759 5217 14 of of IN 42759 5217 15 higher high JJR 42759 5217 16 wages wage NNS 42759 5217 17 the the DT 42759 5217 18 other other JJ 42759 5217 19 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5217 20 of of IN 42759 5217 21 shoes shoe NNS 42759 5217 22 will will MD 42759 5217 23 gain gain VB 42759 5217 24 nothing nothing NN 42759 5217 25 . . . 42759 5218 1 Now now RB 42759 5218 2 there there EX 42759 5218 3 does do VBZ 42759 5218 4 not not RB 42759 5218 5 seem seem VB 42759 5218 6 to to TO 42759 5218 7 be be VB 42759 5218 8 any any DT 42759 5218 9 compelling compelling JJ 42759 5218 10 reason reason NN 42759 5218 11 , , , 42759 5218 12 any any DT 42759 5218 13 certain certain JJ 42759 5218 14 moral moral JJ 42759 5218 15 basis basis NN 42759 5218 16 , , , 42759 5218 17 for for IN 42759 5218 18 requiring require VBG 42759 5218 19 the the DT 42759 5218 20 shoe shoe NN 42759 5218 21 manufacturers manufacturer NNS 42759 5218 22 to to TO 42759 5218 23 take take VB 42759 5218 24 one one CD 42759 5218 25 course course NN 42759 5218 26 rather rather RB 42759 5218 27 than than IN 42759 5218 28 the the DT 42759 5218 29 other other JJ 42759 5218 30 . . . 42759 5219 1 Either either CC 42759 5219 2 will will MD 42759 5219 3 be be VB 42759 5219 4 correct correct JJ 42759 5219 5 morally morally RB 42759 5219 6 . . . 42759 5220 1 Possibly possibly RB 42759 5220 2 the the DT 42759 5220 3 most most RBS 42759 5220 4 perfect perfect JJ 42759 5220 5 plan plan NN 42759 5220 6 would would MD 42759 5220 7 be be VB 42759 5220 8 to to TO 42759 5220 9 effect effect VB 42759 5220 10 a a DT 42759 5220 11 compromise compromise NN 42759 5220 12 by by IN 42759 5220 13 lowering lower VBG 42759 5220 14 prices price NNS 42759 5220 15 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 5220 16 and and CC 42759 5220 17 giving give VBG 42759 5220 18 some some DT 42759 5220 19 rise rise NN 42759 5220 20 in in IN 42759 5220 21 wages wage NNS 42759 5220 22 ; ; : 42759 5220 23 but but CC 42759 5220 24 there there EX 42759 5220 25 is be VBZ 42759 5220 26 no no DT 42759 5220 27 strict strict JJ 42759 5220 28 obligation obligation NN 42759 5220 29 to to TO 42759 5220 30 follow follow VB 42759 5220 31 this this DT 42759 5220 32 course course NN 42759 5220 33 . . . 42759 5221 1 To to TO 42759 5221 2 be be VB 42759 5221 3 sure sure JJ 42759 5221 4 , , , 42759 5221 5 since since IN 42759 5221 6 the the DT 42759 5221 7 manufacturers manufacturer NNS 42759 5221 8 have have VBP 42759 5221 9 a a DT 42759 5221 10 right right NN 42759 5221 11 to to TO 42759 5221 12 retain retain VB 42759 5221 13 the the DT 42759 5221 14 surplus surplus NN 42759 5221 15 profits profit NNS 42759 5221 16 , , , 42759 5221 17 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5221 18 have have VBP 42759 5221 19 also also RB 42759 5221 20 a a DT 42759 5221 21 right right NN 42759 5221 22 to to TO 42759 5221 23 distribute distribute VB 42759 5221 24 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5221 25 as as IN 42759 5221 26 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5221 27 prefer prefer VBP 42759 5221 28 . . . 42759 5222 1 Let let VB 42759 5222 2 us -PRON- PRP 42759 5222 3 get get VB 42759 5222 4 rid rid VBN 42759 5222 5 of of IN 42759 5222 6 this this DT 42759 5222 7 complication complication NN 42759 5222 8 by by IN 42759 5222 9 assuming assume VBG 42759 5222 10 that that IN 42759 5222 11 the the DT 42759 5222 12 manufacturers manufacturer NNS 42759 5222 13 are be VBP 42759 5222 14 indifferent indifferent JJ 42759 5222 15 concerning concern VBG 42759 5222 16 the the DT 42759 5222 17 disposition disposition NN 42759 5222 18 of of IN 42759 5222 19 the the DT 42759 5222 20 surplus surplus NN 42759 5222 21 , , , 42759 5222 22 leaving leave VBG 42759 5222 23 the the DT 42759 5222 24 matter matter NN 42759 5222 25 to to TO 42759 5222 26 be be VB 42759 5222 27 determined determine VBN 42759 5222 28 by by IN 42759 5222 29 the the DT 42759 5222 30 comparative comparative JJ 42759 5222 31 economic economic JJ 42759 5222 32 strength strength NN 42759 5222 33 of of IN 42759 5222 34 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5222 35 and and CC 42759 5222 36 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5222 37 . . . 42759 5223 1 In in IN 42759 5223 2 such such PDT 42759 5223 3 a a DT 42759 5223 4 situation situation NN 42759 5223 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5223 6 is be VBZ 42759 5223 7 still still RB 42759 5223 8 clear clear JJ 42759 5223 9 that that IN 42759 5223 10 either either DT 42759 5223 11 of of IN 42759 5223 12 the the DT 42759 5223 13 two two CD 42759 5223 14 classes class NNS 42759 5223 15 would would MD 42759 5223 16 be be VB 42759 5223 17 justified justify VBN 42759 5223 18 in in IN 42759 5223 19 striving strive VBG 42759 5223 20 to to TO 42759 5223 21 secure secure VB 42759 5223 22 any any DT 42759 5223 23 or or CC 42759 5223 24 all all DT 42759 5223 25 of of IN 42759 5223 26 the the DT 42759 5223 27 surplus surplus NN 42759 5223 28 . . . 42759 5224 1 No no DT 42759 5224 2 definite definite JJ 42759 5224 3 moral moral JJ 42759 5224 4 principle principle NN 42759 5224 5 can can MD 42759 5224 6 be be VB 42759 5224 7 adduced adduce VBN 42759 5224 8 to to IN 42759 5224 9 the the DT 42759 5224 10 contrary contrary NN 42759 5224 11 . . . 42759 5225 1 To to TO 42759 5225 2 put put VB 42759 5225 3 the the DT 42759 5225 4 case case NN 42759 5225 5 in in IN 42759 5225 6 more more JJR 42759 5225 7 general general JJ 42759 5225 8 terms term NNS 42759 5225 9 : : : 42759 5225 10 there there EX 42759 5225 11 exists exist VBZ 42759 5225 12 no no DT 42759 5225 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5225 14 reason reason NN 42759 5225 15 for for IN 42759 5225 16 maintaining maintain VBG 42759 5225 17 that that IN 42759 5225 18 the the DT 42759 5225 19 gains gain NNS 42759 5225 20 of of IN 42759 5225 21 cheaper cheap JJR 42759 5225 22 production production NN 42759 5225 23 should should MD 42759 5225 24 go go VB 42759 5225 25 to to IN 42759 5225 26 the the DT 42759 5225 27 consumer consumer NN 42759 5225 28 rather rather RB 42759 5225 29 than than IN 42759 5225 30 to to IN 42759 5225 31 the the DT 42759 5225 32 labourer labourer NN 42759 5225 33 , , , 42759 5225 34 or or CC 42759 5225 35 to to IN 42759 5225 36 the the DT 42759 5225 37 labourer labourer NN 42759 5225 38 rather rather RB 42759 5225 39 than than IN 42759 5225 40 to to IN 42759 5225 41 the the DT 42759 5225 42 consumer consumer NN 42759 5225 43 , , , 42759 5225 44 so so RB 42759 5225 45 long long RB 42759 5225 46 as as IN 42759 5225 47 the the DT 42759 5225 48 labourer labourer NN 42759 5225 49 is be VBZ 42759 5225 50 already already RB 42759 5225 51 in in IN 42759 5225 52 receipt receipt NN 42759 5225 53 of of IN 42759 5225 54 the the DT 42759 5225 55 " " `` 42759 5225 56 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5225 57 minimum minimum NN 42759 5225 58 . . . 42759 5225 59 " " '' 42759 5226 1 Turning turn VBG 42759 5226 2 now now RB 42759 5226 3 to to IN 42759 5226 4 the the DT 42759 5226 5 question question NN 42759 5226 6 of of IN 42759 5226 7 higher high JJR 42759 5226 8 wages wage NNS 42759 5226 9 at at IN 42759 5226 10 the the DT 42759 5226 11 cost cost NN 42759 5226 12 of of IN 42759 5226 13 higher high JJR 42759 5226 14 prices price NNS 42759 5226 15 , , , 42759 5226 16 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5226 17 note note VBP 42759 5226 18 that that IN 42759 5226 19 this this DT 42759 5226 20 would would MD 42759 5226 21 result result VB 42759 5226 22 in in IN 42759 5226 23 at at RB 42759 5226 24 least least JJS 42759 5226 25 temporary temporary JJ 42759 5226 26 hardship hardship NN 42759 5226 27 to to IN 42759 5226 28 four four CD 42759 5226 29 classes class NNS 42759 5226 30 of of IN 42759 5226 31 persons person NNS 42759 5226 32 : : : 42759 5226 33 the the DT 42759 5226 34 weaker weak JJR 42759 5226 35 groups group NNS 42759 5226 36 of of IN 42759 5226 37 wage wage NN 42759 5226 38 earners earner NNS 42759 5226 39 ; ; : 42759 5226 40 all all DT 42759 5226 41 self self NN 42759 5226 42 employing employ VBG 42759 5226 43 persons person NNS 42759 5226 44 , , , 42759 5226 45 such such JJ 42759 5226 46 as as IN 42759 5226 47 farmers farmer NNS 42759 5226 48 , , , 42759 5226 49 merchants merchant NNS 42759 5226 50 , , , 42759 5226 51 and and CC 42759 5226 52 manufacturers manufacturer NNS 42759 5226 53 ; ; : 42759 5226 54 the the DT 42759 5226 55 professional professional JJ 42759 5226 56 classes class NNS 42759 5226 57 ; ; , 42759 5226 58 and and CC 42759 5226 59 persons person NNS 42759 5226 60 whose whose WP$ 42759 5226 61 principal principal JJ 42759 5226 62 income income NN 42759 5226 63 was be VBD 42759 5226 64 derived derive VBN 42759 5226 65 from from IN 42759 5226 66 rent rent NN 42759 5226 67 or or CC 42759 5226 68 interest interest NN 42759 5226 69 . . . 42759 5227 1 All all PDT 42759 5227 2 these these DT 42759 5227 3 groups group NNS 42759 5227 4 would would MD 42759 5227 5 have have VB 42759 5227 6 to to TO 42759 5227 7 pay pay VB 42759 5227 8 more more JJR 42759 5227 9 for for IN 42759 5227 10 the the DT 42759 5227 11 necessaries necessary NNS 42759 5227 12 , , , 42759 5227 13 comforts comfort NNS 42759 5227 14 , , , 42759 5227 15 and and CC 42759 5227 16 luxuries luxury NNS 42759 5227 17 of of IN 42759 5227 18 living living NN 42759 5227 19 , , , 42759 5227 20 without without IN 42759 5227 21 being be VBG 42759 5227 22 immediately immediately RB 42759 5227 23 able able JJ 42759 5227 24 to to TO 42759 5227 25 raise raise VB 42759 5227 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5227 27 own own JJ 42759 5227 28 incomes income NNS 42759 5227 29 correspondingly correspondingly RB 42759 5227 30 . . . 42759 5228 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 5228 2 , , , 42759 5228 3 the the DT 42759 5228 4 first first JJ 42759 5228 5 three three CD 42759 5228 6 classes class NNS 42759 5228 7 could could MD 42759 5228 8 in in IN 42759 5228 9 the the DT 42759 5228 10 course course NN 42759 5228 11 of of IN 42759 5228 12 time time NN 42759 5228 13 force force VB 42759 5228 14 an an DT 42759 5228 15 increase increase NN 42759 5228 16 in in IN 42759 5228 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5228 18 revenues revenue NNS 42759 5228 19 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5228 20 to to TO 42759 5228 21 offset offset VB 42759 5228 22 at at IN 42759 5228 23 least least JJS 42759 5228 24 the the DT 42759 5228 25 more more RBR 42759 5228 26 serious serious JJ 42759 5228 27 inconveniences inconvenience NNS 42759 5228 28 of of IN 42759 5228 29 the the DT 42759 5228 30 increase increase NN 42759 5228 31 in in IN 42759 5228 32 prices price NNS 42759 5228 33 . . . 42759 5229 1 So so RB 42759 5229 2 far far RB 42759 5229 3 as as IN 42759 5229 4 the the DT 42759 5229 5 wage wage NN 42759 5229 6 earners earner NNS 42759 5229 7 are be VBP 42759 5229 8 concerned concern VBN 42759 5229 9 , , , 42759 5229 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5229 11 is be VBZ 42759 5229 12 understood understand VBN 42759 5229 13 that that IN 42759 5229 14 all all PDT 42759 5229 15 these these DT 42759 5229 16 would would MD 42759 5229 17 have have VB 42759 5229 18 a a DT 42759 5229 19 right right NN 42759 5229 20 to to IN 42759 5229 21 whatever whatever WDT 42759 5229 22 advance advance NN 42759 5229 23 in in IN 42759 5229 24 the the DT 42759 5229 25 money money NN 42759 5229 26 measure measure NN 42759 5229 27 of of IN 42759 5229 28 the the DT 42759 5229 29 " " `` 42759 5229 30 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5229 31 minimum minimum NN 42759 5229 32 " " '' 42759 5229 33 was be VBD 42759 5229 34 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5229 35 to to TO 42759 5229 36 neutralise neutralise VB 42759 5229 37 the the DT 42759 5229 38 higher high JJR 42759 5229 39 cost cost NN 42759 5229 40 of of IN 42759 5229 41 living live VBG 42759 5229 42 resulting result VBG 42759 5229 43 from from IN 42759 5229 44 the the DT 42759 5229 45 success success NN 42759 5229 46 of of IN 42759 5229 47 the the DT 42759 5229 48 more more RBR 42759 5229 49 powerful powerful JJ 42759 5229 50 groups group NNS 42759 5229 51 in in IN 42759 5229 52 obtaining obtain VBG 42759 5229 53 higher high JJR 42759 5229 54 wages wage NNS 42759 5229 55 . . . 42759 5230 1 The the DT 42759 5230 2 right right NN 42759 5230 3 of of IN 42759 5230 4 a a DT 42759 5230 5 group group NN 42759 5230 6 to to IN 42759 5230 7 the the DT 42759 5230 8 " " `` 42759 5230 9 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5230 10 minimum minimum NN 42759 5230 11 " " '' 42759 5230 12 of of IN 42759 5230 13 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5230 14 is be VBZ 42759 5230 15 obviously obviously RB 42759 5230 16 superior superior JJ 42759 5230 17 to to IN 42759 5230 18 the the DT 42759 5230 19 right right NN 42759 5230 20 of of IN 42759 5230 21 another another DT 42759 5230 22 group group NN 42759 5230 23 to to TO 42759 5230 24 more more JJR 42759 5230 25 than than IN 42759 5230 26 that that DT 42759 5230 27 amount amount NN 42759 5230 28 . . . 42759 5231 1 And and CC 42759 5231 2 a a DT 42759 5231 3 supreme supreme JJ 42759 5231 4 wage wage NN 42759 5231 5 - - HYPH 42759 5231 6 determining determine VBG 42759 5231 7 authority authority NN 42759 5231 8 would would MD 42759 5231 9 act act VB 42759 5231 10 on on IN 42759 5231 11 this this DT 42759 5231 12 principle principle NN 42759 5231 13 . . . 42759 5232 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5232 2 can can MD 42759 5232 3 not not RB 42759 5232 4 be be VB 42759 5232 5 shown show VBN 42759 5232 6 , , , 42759 5232 7 however however RB 42759 5232 8 , , , 42759 5232 9 that that IN 42759 5232 10 in in IN 42759 5232 11 the the DT 42759 5232 12 absence absence NN 42759 5232 13 of of IN 42759 5232 14 any any DT 42759 5232 15 such such JJ 42759 5232 16 authority authority NN 42759 5232 17 empowered empower VBN 42759 5232 18 to to TO 42759 5232 19 protect protect VB 42759 5232 20 the the DT 42759 5232 21 " " `` 42759 5232 22 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5232 23 minimum minimum NN 42759 5232 24 " " '' 42759 5232 25 of of IN 42759 5232 26 the the DT 42759 5232 27 weaker weak JJR 42759 5232 28 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5232 29 , , , 42759 5232 30 the the DT 42759 5232 31 more more RBR 42759 5232 32 powerful powerful JJ 42759 5232 33 groups group NNS 42759 5232 34 are be VBP 42759 5232 35 obliged oblige VBN 42759 5232 36 to to TO 42759 5232 37 refrain refrain VB 42759 5232 38 from from IN 42759 5232 39 demanding demand VBG 42759 5232 40 extra extra JJ 42759 5232 41 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5232 42 . . . 42759 5233 1 The the DT 42759 5233 2 reason reason NN 42759 5233 3 of of IN 42759 5233 4 this this DT 42759 5233 5 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5233 6 shall shall MD 42759 5233 7 see see VB 42759 5233 8 presently presently RB 42759 5233 9 . . . 42759 5234 1 In in IN 42759 5234 2 the the DT 42759 5234 3 meantime meantime NN 42759 5234 4 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5234 5 call call VBP 42759 5234 6 attention attention NN 42759 5234 7 to to IN 42759 5234 8 the the DT 42759 5234 9 fact fact NN 42759 5234 10 that that IN 42759 5234 11 , , , 42759 5234 12 owing owe VBG 42759 5234 13 to to IN 42759 5234 14 the the DT 42759 5234 15 greater great JJR 42759 5234 16 economic economic JJ 42759 5234 17 opportunity opportunity NN 42759 5234 18 resulting result VBG 42759 5234 19 from from IN 42759 5234 20 the the DT 42759 5234 21 universal universal JJ 42759 5234 22 prevalence prevalence NN 42759 5234 23 of of IN 42759 5234 24 the the DT 42759 5234 25 " " `` 42759 5234 26 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5234 27 minimum minimum NN 42759 5234 28 " " '' 42759 5234 29 and and CC 42759 5234 30 of of IN 42759 5234 31 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5234 32 education education NN 42759 5234 33 , , , 42759 5234 34 even even RB 42759 5234 35 the the DT 42759 5234 36 weaker weak JJR 42759 5234 37 groups group NNS 42759 5234 38 of of IN 42759 5234 39 wage wage NN 42759 5234 40 earners earner NNS 42759 5234 41 would would MD 42759 5234 42 be be VB 42759 5234 43 able able JJ 42759 5234 44 to to TO 42759 5234 45 obtain obtain VB 42759 5234 46 some some DT 42759 5234 47 increases increase NNS 42759 5234 48 in in IN 42759 5234 49 wages wage NNS 42759 5234 50 . . . 42759 5235 1 In in IN 42759 5235 2 the the DT 42759 5235 3 long long JJ 42759 5235 4 run run NN 42759 5235 5 the the DT 42759 5235 6 more more RBR 42759 5235 7 powerful powerful JJ 42759 5235 8 groups group NNS 42759 5235 9 would would MD 42759 5235 10 enjoy enjoy VB 42759 5235 11 only only RB 42759 5235 12 those those DT 42759 5235 13 advantages advantage NNS 42759 5235 14 which which WDT 42759 5235 15 arise arise VBP 42759 5235 16 out out IN 42759 5235 17 of of IN 42759 5235 18 superior superior JJ 42759 5235 19 productivity productivity NN 42759 5235 20 and and CC 42759 5235 21 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5235 22 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5235 23 . . . 42759 5236 1 These these DT 42759 5236 2 two two CD 42759 5236 3 factors factor NNS 42759 5236 4 are be VBP 42759 5236 5 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 5236 6 , , , 42759 5236 7 and and CC 42759 5236 8 could could MD 42759 5236 9 not not RB 42759 5236 10 in in IN 42759 5236 11 any any DT 42759 5236 12 system system NN 42759 5236 13 of of IN 42759 5236 14 industry industry NN 42759 5236 15 be be VB 42759 5236 16 prevented prevent VBN 42759 5236 17 from from IN 42759 5236 18 conferring confer VBG 42759 5236 19 advantages advantage NNS 42759 5236 20 upon upon IN 42759 5236 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5236 22 possessors possessor NNS 42759 5236 23 . . . 42759 5237 1 As as IN 42759 5237 2 regards regard VBZ 42759 5237 3 the the DT 42759 5237 4 self self NN 42759 5237 5 employing employing NN 42759 5237 6 classes class NNS 42759 5237 7 , , , 42759 5237 8 the the DT 42759 5237 9 remedy remedy NN 42759 5237 10 for for IN 42759 5237 11 any any DT 42759 5237 12 undue undue JJ 42759 5237 13 hardship hardship NN 42759 5237 14 suffered suffer VBD 42759 5237 15 through through IN 42759 5237 16 the the DT 42759 5237 17 higher high JJR 42759 5237 18 prices price NNS 42759 5237 19 of of IN 42759 5237 20 commodities commodity NNS 42759 5237 21 would would MD 42759 5237 22 be be VB 42759 5237 23 found find VBN 42759 5237 24 in in IN 42759 5237 25 a a DT 42759 5237 26 discontinuance discontinuance NN 42759 5237 27 of of IN 42759 5237 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5237 29 present present JJ 42759 5237 30 functions function NNS 42759 5237 31 until until IN 42759 5237 32 a a DT 42759 5237 33 corresponding correspond VBG 42759 5237 34 rise rise NN 42759 5237 35 had have VBD 42759 5237 36 occurred occur VBN 42759 5237 37 in in IN 42759 5237 38 the the DT 42759 5237 39 prices price NNS 42759 5237 40 of of IN 42759 5237 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5237 42 own own JJ 42759 5237 43 products product NNS 42759 5237 44 . . . 42759 5238 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 5238 2 could could MD 42759 5238 3 do do VB 42759 5238 4 this this DT 42759 5238 5 partly partly RB 42759 5238 6 by by IN 42759 5238 7 organisation organisation NN 42759 5238 8 , , , 42759 5238 9 and and CC 42759 5238 10 partly partly RB 42759 5238 11 by by IN 42759 5238 12 entering enter VBG 42759 5238 13 into into IN 42759 5238 14 competition competition NN 42759 5238 15 with with IN 42759 5238 16 the the DT 42759 5238 17 wage wage NN 42759 5238 18 earners earner NNS 42759 5238 19 . . . 42759 5239 1 Substantially substantially RB 42759 5239 2 the the DT 42759 5239 3 same same JJ 42759 5239 4 recourse recourse NN 42759 5239 5 would would MD 42759 5239 6 be be VB 42759 5239 7 open open JJ 42759 5239 8 to to IN 42759 5239 9 the the DT 42759 5239 10 professional professional JJ 42759 5239 11 classes class NNS 42759 5239 12 . . . 42759 5240 1 In in IN 42759 5240 2 due due JJ 42759 5240 3 course course NN 42759 5240 4 of of IN 42759 5240 5 time time NN 42759 5240 6 , , , 42759 5240 7 therefore therefore RB 42759 5240 8 , , , 42759 5240 9 the the DT 42759 5240 10 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5240 11 of of IN 42759 5240 12 all all DT 42759 5240 13 workers worker NNS 42759 5240 14 , , , 42759 5240 15 whether whether IN 42759 5240 16 employés employés NN 42759 5240 17 or or CC 42759 5240 18 self self NN 42759 5240 19 employed employ VBN 42759 5240 20 or or CC 42759 5240 21 professional professional JJ 42759 5240 22 , , , 42759 5240 23 would would MD 42759 5240 24 tend tend VB 42759 5240 25 to to TO 42759 5240 26 be be VB 42759 5240 27 in in IN 42759 5240 28 harmony harmony NN 42759 5240 29 with with IN 42759 5240 30 the the DT 42759 5240 31 canons canon NNS 42759 5240 32 of of IN 42759 5240 33 efforts effort NNS 42759 5240 34 , , , 42759 5240 35 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5240 36 , , , 42759 5240 37 productivity productivity NN 42759 5240 38 , , , 42759 5240 39 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5240 40 , , , 42759 5240 41 and and CC 42759 5240 42 human human JJ 42759 5240 43 welfare welfare NN 42759 5240 44 . . . 42759 5241 1 Since since IN 42759 5241 2 the the DT 42759 5241 3 level level NN 42759 5241 4 of of IN 42759 5241 5 rent rent NN 42759 5241 6 is be VBZ 42759 5241 7 fixed fix VBN 42759 5241 8 by by IN 42759 5241 9 forces force NNS 42759 5241 10 outside outside IN 42759 5241 11 the the DT 42759 5241 12 control control NN 42759 5241 13 of of IN 42759 5241 14 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5241 15 , , , 42759 5241 16 employers employer NNS 42759 5241 17 , , , 42759 5241 18 or or CC 42759 5241 19 landowners landowner NNS 42759 5241 20 , , , 42759 5241 21 the the DT 42759 5241 22 receivers receiver NNS 42759 5241 23 thereof thereof RB 42759 5241 24 would would MD 42759 5241 25 be be VB 42759 5241 26 unable unable JJ 42759 5241 27 to to TO 42759 5241 28 offset offset VB 42759 5241 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5241 30 decreased decreased JJ 42759 5241 31 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 5241 32 power power NN 42759 5241 33 by by IN 42759 5241 34 increasing increase VBG 42759 5241 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5241 36 amount amount NN 42759 5241 37 . . . 42759 5242 1 However however RB 42759 5242 2 , , , 42759 5242 3 this this DT 42759 5242 4 situation situation NN 42759 5242 5 would would MD 42759 5242 6 not not RB 42759 5242 7 be be VB 42759 5242 8 inherently inherently RB 42759 5242 9 unjust unjust JJ 42759 5242 10 , , , 42759 5242 11 nor nor CC 42759 5242 12 even even RB 42759 5242 13 inequitable inequitable JJ 42759 5242 14 . . . 42759 5243 1 Like like IN 42759 5243 2 interest interest NN 42759 5243 3 , , , 42759 5243 4 rent rent NN 42759 5243 5 is be VBZ 42759 5243 6 a a DT 42759 5243 7 " " `` 42759 5243 8 workless workless NN 42759 5243 9 " " '' 42759 5243 10 income income NN 42759 5243 11 , , , 42759 5243 12 and and CC 42759 5243 13 has have VBZ 42759 5243 14 only only RB 42759 5243 15 a a DT 42759 5243 16 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 5243 17 and and CC 42759 5243 18 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 42759 5243 19 justification justification NN 42759 5243 20 . . . 42759 5244 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 5244 2 , , , 42759 5244 3 the the DT 42759 5244 4 moral moral JJ 42759 5244 5 claim claim NN 42759 5244 6 of of IN 42759 5244 7 the the DT 42759 5244 8 rent rent NN 42759 5244 9 receiver receiver NN 42759 5244 10 to to TO 42759 5244 11 be be VB 42759 5244 12 protected protect VBN 42759 5244 13 against against IN 42759 5244 14 a a DT 42759 5244 15 decrease decrease NN 42759 5244 16 in in IN 42759 5244 17 the the DT 42759 5244 18 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 5244 19 power power NN 42759 5244 20 of of IN 42759 5244 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5244 22 income income NN 42759 5244 23 , , , 42759 5244 24 is be VBZ 42759 5244 25 inferior inferior JJ 42759 5244 26 to to IN 42759 5244 27 the the DT 42759 5244 28 moral moral JJ 42759 5244 29 claim claim NN 42759 5244 30 of of IN 42759 5244 31 the the DT 42759 5244 32 labourer labourer NN 42759 5244 33 to to TO 42759 5244 34 use use VB 42759 5244 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5244 36 economic economic JJ 42759 5244 37 power power NN 42759 5244 38 for for IN 42759 5244 39 the the DT 42759 5244 40 purpose purpose NN 42759 5244 41 of of IN 42759 5244 42 improving improve VBG 42759 5244 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5244 44 condition condition NN 42759 5244 45 beyond beyond IN 42759 5244 46 the the DT 42759 5244 47 limits limit NNS 42759 5244 48 of of IN 42759 5244 49 welfare welfare NN 42759 5244 50 fixed fix VBN 42759 5244 51 by by IN 42759 5244 52 the the DT 42759 5244 53 " " `` 42759 5244 54 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5244 55 minimum minimum NN 42759 5244 56 . . . 42759 5244 57 " " '' 42759 5245 1 What what WP 42759 5245 2 is be VBZ 42759 5245 3 true true JJ 42759 5245 4 of of IN 42759 5245 5 the the DT 42759 5245 6 rent rent NN 42759 5245 7 receiver receiver NN 42759 5245 8 in in IN 42759 5245 9 this this DT 42759 5245 10 respect respect NN 42759 5245 11 applies apply VBZ 42759 5245 12 likewise likewise RB 42759 5245 13 to to IN 42759 5245 14 the the DT 42759 5245 15 case case NN 42759 5245 16 of of IN 42759 5245 17 the the DT 42759 5245 18 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5245 19 . . . 42759 5246 1 As as IN 42759 5246 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5246 3 saw see VBD 42759 5246 4 a a DT 42759 5246 5 few few JJ 42759 5246 6 pages page NNS 42759 5246 7 back back RB 42759 5246 8 , , , 42759 5246 9 the the DT 42759 5246 10 wage wage NN 42759 5246 11 earners earner NNS 42759 5246 12 are be VBP 42759 5246 13 morally morally RB 42759 5246 14 free free JJ 42759 5246 15 to to TO 42759 5246 16 take take VB 42759 5246 17 this this DT 42759 5246 18 course course NN 42759 5246 19 at at IN 42759 5246 20 the the DT 42759 5246 21 expense expense NN 42759 5246 22 of of IN 42759 5246 23 interest interest NN 42759 5246 24 . . . 42759 5247 1 Evidently evidently RB 42759 5247 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5247 3 may may MD 42759 5247 4 do do VB 42759 5247 5 the the DT 42759 5247 6 same same JJ 42759 5247 7 thing thing NN 42759 5247 8 when when WRB 42759 5247 9 the the DT 42759 5247 10 consequence consequence NN 42759 5247 11 is be VBZ 42759 5247 12 merely merely RB 42759 5247 13 a a DT 42759 5247 14 diminution diminution NN 42759 5247 15 in in IN 42759 5247 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5247 17 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 5247 18 power power NN 42759 5247 19 . . . 42759 5248 1 To to TO 42759 5248 2 be be VB 42759 5248 3 sure sure JJ 42759 5248 4 , , , 42759 5248 5 if if IN 42759 5248 6 capital capital NN 42759 5248 7 owners owner NNS 42759 5248 8 should should MD 42759 5248 9 regard regard VB 42759 5248 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5248 11 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5248 12 in in IN 42759 5248 13 saving save VBG 42759 5248 14 as as IN 42759 5248 15 not not RB 42759 5248 16 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 5248 17 rewarded reward VBN 42759 5248 18 , , , 42759 5248 19 owing owe VBG 42759 5248 20 either either CC 42759 5248 21 to to IN 42759 5248 22 the the DT 42759 5248 23 low low JJ 42759 5248 24 rate rate NN 42759 5248 25 or or CC 42759 5248 26 the the DT 42759 5248 27 low low JJ 42759 5248 28 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 5248 29 power power NN 42759 5248 30 of of IN 42759 5248 31 interest interest NN 42759 5248 32 , , , 42759 5248 33 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5248 34 would would MD 42759 5248 35 be be VB 42759 5248 36 free free JJ 42759 5248 37 to to TO 42759 5248 38 diminish diminish VB 42759 5248 39 or or CC 42759 5248 40 discontinue discontinue VB 42759 5248 41 saving saving NN 42759 5248 42 until until IN 42759 5248 43 the the DT 42759 5248 44 reduced reduced JJ 42759 5248 45 supply supply NN 42759 5248 46 of of IN 42759 5248 47 capital capital NN 42759 5248 48 had have VBD 42759 5248 49 brought bring VBN 42759 5248 50 about about RP 42759 5248 51 a a DT 42759 5248 52 rise rise NN 42759 5248 53 in in IN 42759 5248 54 the the DT 42759 5248 55 rate rate NN 42759 5248 56 of of IN 42759 5248 57 interest interest NN 42759 5248 58 . . . 42759 5249 1 Should Should MD 42759 5249 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5249 3 refrain refrain VB 42759 5249 4 from from IN 42759 5249 5 this this DT 42759 5249 6 course course NN 42759 5249 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5249 8 would would MD 42759 5249 9 show show VB 42759 5249 10 that that IN 42759 5249 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5249 12 were be VBD 42759 5249 13 satisfied satisfied JJ 42759 5249 14 with with IN 42759 5249 15 the the DT 42759 5249 16 existing exist VBG 42759 5249 17 situation situation NN 42759 5249 18 . . . 42759 5250 1 Hence hence RB 42759 5250 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5250 3 would would MD 42759 5250 4 suffer suffer VB 42759 5250 5 no no DT 42759 5250 6 wrong wrong NN 42759 5250 7 at at IN 42759 5250 8 the the DT 42759 5250 9 hands hand NNS 42759 5250 10 of of IN 42759 5250 11 the the DT 42759 5250 12 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5250 13 who who WP 42759 5250 14 forced force VBD 42759 5250 15 up up RP 42759 5250 16 wages wage NNS 42759 5250 17 at at IN 42759 5250 18 the the DT 42759 5250 19 expense expense NN 42759 5250 20 of of IN 42759 5250 21 prices price NNS 42759 5250 22 . . . 42759 5251 1 Two two CD 42759 5251 2 objections objection NNS 42759 5251 3 come come VBP 42759 5251 4 readily readily RB 42759 5251 5 to to TO 42759 5251 6 mind mind VB 42759 5251 7 against against IN 42759 5251 8 the the DT 42759 5251 9 foregoing foregoing JJ 42759 5251 10 paragraphs paragraph NNS 42759 5251 11 . . . 42759 5252 1 The the DT 42759 5252 2 more more RBR 42759 5252 3 skilled skilled JJ 42759 5252 4 labour labour JJ 42759 5252 5 groups group NNS 42759 5252 6 might may MD 42759 5252 7 organise organise VB 42759 5252 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 5252 9 into into IN 42759 5252 10 a a DT 42759 5252 11 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 5252 12 , , , 42759 5252 13 and and CC 42759 5252 14 raise raise VB 42759 5252 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5252 16 wages wage NNS 42759 5252 17 so so RB 42759 5252 18 high high RB 42759 5252 19 as as IN 42759 5252 20 to to TO 42759 5252 21 inflict inflict VB 42759 5252 22 the the DT 42759 5252 23 same same JJ 42759 5252 24 degree degree NN 42759 5252 25 of of IN 42759 5252 26 extortion extortion NN 42759 5252 27 upon upon IN 42759 5252 28 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5252 29 as as IN 42759 5252 30 that that DT 42759 5252 31 accomplished accomplish VBN 42759 5252 32 by by IN 42759 5252 33 a a DT 42759 5252 34 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 5252 35 of of IN 42759 5252 36 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 5252 37 . . . 42759 5253 1 This this DT 42759 5253 2 is be VBZ 42759 5253 3 , , , 42759 5253 4 indeed indeed RB 42759 5253 5 , , , 42759 5253 6 possible possible JJ 42759 5253 7 . . . 42759 5254 1 The the DT 42759 5254 2 remedy remedy NN 42759 5254 3 would would MD 42759 5254 4 be be VB 42759 5254 5 intervention intervention NN 42759 5254 6 by by IN 42759 5254 7 the the DT 42759 5254 8 State State NNP 42759 5254 9 to to TO 42759 5254 10 fix fix VB 42759 5254 11 maximum maximum JJ 42759 5254 12 wages wage NNS 42759 5254 13 . . . 42759 5255 1 Just just RB 42759 5255 2 where where WRB 42759 5255 3 the the DT 42759 5255 4 maximum maximum JJ 42759 5255 5 limit limit NN 42759 5255 6 ought ought MD 42759 5255 7 to to TO 42759 5255 8 be be VB 42759 5255 9 placed place VBN 42759 5255 10 is be VBZ 42759 5255 11 a a DT 42759 5255 12 problem problem NN 42759 5255 13 that that WDT 42759 5255 14 could could MD 42759 5255 15 be be VB 42759 5255 16 solved solve VBN 42759 5255 17 only only RB 42759 5255 18 through through IN 42759 5255 19 study study NN 42759 5255 20 of of IN 42759 5255 21 the the DT 42759 5255 22 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 5255 23 of of IN 42759 5255 24 the the DT 42759 5255 25 case case NN 42759 5255 26 , , , 42759 5255 27 on on IN 42759 5255 28 the the DT 42759 5255 29 basis basis NN 42759 5255 30 of of IN 42759 5255 31 the the DT 42759 5255 32 canons canon NNS 42759 5255 33 of of IN 42759 5255 34 efforts effort NNS 42759 5255 35 , , , 42759 5255 36 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5255 37 , , , 42759 5255 38 productivity productivity NN 42759 5255 39 , , , 42759 5255 40 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5255 41 , , , 42759 5255 42 and and CC 42759 5255 43 human human JJ 42759 5255 44 welfare welfare NN 42759 5255 45 . . . 42759 5256 1 The the DT 42759 5256 2 second second JJ 42759 5256 3 objection objection NN 42759 5256 4 calls call VBZ 42759 5256 5 attention attention NN 42759 5256 6 to to IN 42759 5256 7 the the DT 42759 5256 8 fact fact NN 42759 5256 9 that that IN 42759 5256 10 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5256 11 have have VBP 42759 5256 12 already already RB 42759 5256 13 declared declare VBN 42759 5256 14 that that IN 42759 5256 15 the the DT 42759 5256 16 more more RBR 42759 5256 17 powerful powerful JJ 42759 5256 18 labour labour JJ 42759 5256 19 groups group NNS 42759 5256 20 would would MD 42759 5256 21 not not RB 42759 5256 22 be be VB 42759 5256 23 justified justify VBN 42759 5256 24 in in IN 42759 5256 25 exacting exact VBG 42759 5256 26 more more JJR 42759 5256 27 than than IN 42759 5256 28 the the DT 42759 5256 29 " " `` 42759 5256 30 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5256 31 minimum minimum NN 42759 5256 32 " " '' 42759 5256 33 out out IN 42759 5256 34 of of IN 42759 5256 35 a a DT 42759 5256 36 common common JJ 42759 5256 37 wage wage NN 42759 5256 38 fund fund NN 42759 5256 39 , , , 42759 5256 40 so so RB 42759 5256 41 long long RB 42759 5256 42 as as IN 42759 5256 43 any any DT 42759 5256 44 weaker weak JJR 42759 5256 45 group group NN 42759 5256 46 was be VBD 42759 5256 47 below below IN 42759 5256 48 that that DT 42759 5256 49 level level NN 42759 5256 50 ; ; : 42759 5256 51 yet yet CC 42759 5256 52 this this DT 42759 5256 53 is be VBZ 42759 5256 54 virtually virtually RB 42759 5256 55 what what WP 42759 5256 56 would would MD 42759 5256 57 happen happen VB 42759 5256 58 when when WRB 42759 5256 59 the the DT 42759 5256 60 former former JJ 42759 5256 61 caused cause VBD 42759 5256 62 prices price NNS 42759 5256 63 to to TO 42759 5256 64 rise rise VB 42759 5256 65 to to IN 42759 5256 66 such such PDT 42759 5256 67 an an DT 42759 5256 68 extent extent NN 42759 5256 69 that that IN 42759 5256 70 the the DT 42759 5256 71 weaker weak JJR 42759 5256 72 workers worker NNS 42759 5256 73 would would MD 42759 5256 74 be be VB 42759 5256 75 forced force VBN 42759 5256 76 below below IN 42759 5256 77 the the DT 42759 5256 78 " " `` 42759 5256 79 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5256 80 minimum minimum NN 42759 5256 81 " " '' 42759 5256 82 through through IN 42759 5256 83 the the DT 42759 5256 84 increased increase VBN 42759 5256 85 cost cost NN 42759 5256 86 of of IN 42759 5256 87 living living NN 42759 5256 88 . . . 42759 5257 1 While while IN 42759 5257 2 this this DT 42759 5257 3 contingency contingency NN 42759 5257 4 is be VBZ 42759 5257 5 likewise likewise RB 42759 5257 6 possible possible JJ 42759 5257 7 , , , 42759 5257 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5257 9 is be VBZ 42759 5257 10 not not RB 42759 5257 11 a a DT 42759 5257 12 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5257 13 reason reason NN 42759 5257 14 for for IN 42759 5257 15 preventing prevent VBG 42759 5257 16 any any DT 42759 5257 17 group group NN 42759 5257 18 of of IN 42759 5257 19 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5257 20 from from IN 42759 5257 21 raising raise VBG 42759 5257 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5257 23 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5257 24 at at IN 42759 5257 25 the the DT 42759 5257 26 expense expense NN 42759 5257 27 of of IN 42759 5257 28 prices price NNS 42759 5257 29 . . . 42759 5258 1 Not not RB 42759 5258 2 every every DT 42759 5258 3 rise rise NN 42759 5258 4 in in IN 42759 5258 5 prices price NNS 42759 5258 6 would would MD 42759 5258 7 effect effect VB 42759 5258 8 the the DT 42759 5258 9 expenditures expenditure NNS 42759 5258 10 of of IN 42759 5258 11 the the DT 42759 5258 12 weaker weak JJR 42759 5258 13 sections section NNS 42759 5258 14 of of IN 42759 5258 15 the the DT 42759 5258 16 wage wage NN 42759 5258 17 earners earner NNS 42759 5258 18 . . . 42759 5259 1 In in IN 42759 5259 2 some some DT 42759 5259 3 cases case NNS 42759 5259 4 the the DT 42759 5259 5 burden burden NN 42759 5259 6 would would MD 42759 5259 7 be be VB 42759 5259 8 substantially substantially RB 42759 5259 9 all all DT 42759 5259 10 borne bear VBN 42759 5259 11 by by IN 42759 5259 12 the the DT 42759 5259 13 better well JJR 42759 5259 14 paid pay VBN 42759 5259 15 workers worker NNS 42759 5259 16 and and CC 42759 5259 17 the the DT 42759 5259 18 self self NN 42759 5259 19 employing employ VBG 42759 5259 20 , , , 42759 5259 21 professional professional JJ 42759 5259 22 , , , 42759 5259 23 and and CC 42759 5259 24 propertied propertie VBN 42759 5259 25 classes class NNS 42759 5259 26 . . . 42759 5260 1 When when WRB 42759 5260 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5260 3 did do VBD 42759 5260 4 fall fall VB 42759 5260 5 to to IN 42759 5260 6 any any DT 42759 5260 7 extent extent NN 42759 5260 8 upon upon IN 42759 5260 9 the the DT 42759 5260 10 weaker weak JJR 42759 5260 11 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5260 12 , , , 42759 5260 13 causing cause VBG 42759 5260 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5260 15 real real JJ 42759 5260 16 wages wage NNS 42759 5260 17 to to TO 42759 5260 18 fall fall VB 42759 5260 19 below below IN 42759 5260 20 the the DT 42759 5260 21 " " `` 42759 5260 22 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5260 23 minimum minimum NN 42759 5260 24 , , , 42759 5260 25 " " '' 42759 5260 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5260 27 could could MD 42759 5260 28 be be VB 42759 5260 29 removed remove VBN 42759 5260 30 within within IN 42759 5260 31 a a DT 42759 5260 32 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5260 33 time time NN 42759 5260 34 by by IN 42759 5260 35 organisation organisation NN 42759 5260 36 or or CC 42759 5260 37 by by IN 42759 5260 38 legislation legislation NN 42759 5260 39 . . . 42759 5261 1 Even even RB 42759 5261 2 if if IN 42759 5261 3 these these DT 42759 5261 4 measures measure NNS 42759 5261 5 were be VBD 42759 5261 6 found find VBN 42759 5261 7 ineffective ineffective JJ 42759 5261 8 , , , 42759 5261 9 if if IN 42759 5261 10 some some DT 42759 5261 11 of of IN 42759 5261 12 the the DT 42759 5261 13 weaker weak JJR 42759 5261 14 groups group NNS 42759 5261 15 of of IN 42759 5261 16 workers worker NNS 42759 5261 17 should should MD 42759 5261 18 suffer suffer VB 42759 5261 19 through through IN 42759 5261 20 the the DT 42759 5261 21 establishment establishment NN 42759 5261 22 of of IN 42759 5261 23 the the DT 42759 5261 24 higher high JJR 42759 5261 25 prices price NNS 42759 5261 26 , , , 42759 5261 27 this this DT 42759 5261 28 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 5261 29 would would MD 42759 5261 30 be be VB 42759 5261 31 preferable preferable JJ 42759 5261 32 on on IN 42759 5261 33 the the DT 42759 5261 34 whole whole NN 42759 5261 35 to to IN 42759 5261 36 one one CD 42759 5261 37 in in IN 42759 5261 38 which which WDT 42759 5261 39 no no DT 42759 5261 40 class class NN 42759 5261 41 of of IN 42759 5261 42 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5261 43 was be VBD 42759 5261 44 permitted permit VBN 42759 5261 45 to to TO 42759 5261 46 raise raise VB 42759 5261 47 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5261 48 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5261 49 above above IN 42759 5261 50 the the DT 42759 5261 51 " " `` 42759 5261 52 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5261 53 minimum minimum NN 42759 5261 54 " " '' 42759 5261 55 at at IN 42759 5261 56 the the DT 42759 5261 57 expense expense NN 42759 5261 58 of of IN 42759 5261 59 prices price NNS 42759 5261 60 . . . 42759 5262 1 A a DT 42759 5262 2 restriction restriction NN 42759 5262 3 of of IN 42759 5262 4 this this DT 42759 5262 5 sort sort NN 42759 5262 6 , , , 42759 5262 7 whether whether IN 42759 5262 8 by by IN 42759 5262 9 the the DT 42759 5262 10 moral moral JJ 42759 5262 11 law law NN 42759 5262 12 or or CC 42759 5262 13 by by IN 42759 5262 14 civil civil JJ 42759 5262 15 regulation regulation NN 42759 5262 16 , , , 42759 5262 17 would would MD 42759 5262 18 tend tend VB 42759 5262 19 to to TO 42759 5262 20 make make VB 42759 5262 21 wage wage NN 42759 5262 22 labour labour NN 42759 5262 23 a a DT 42759 5262 24 status status NN 42759 5262 25 with with IN 42759 5262 26 no no DT 42759 5262 27 hope hope NN 42759 5262 28 of of IN 42759 5262 29 pecuniary pecuniary JJ 42759 5262 30 progress progress NN 42759 5262 31 . . . 42759 5263 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5263 2 is be VBZ 42759 5263 3 true true JJ 42759 5263 4 that that IN 42759 5263 5 a a DT 42759 5263 6 universal universal JJ 42759 5263 7 and and CC 42759 5263 8 indefinite indefinite JJ 42759 5263 9 increase increase NN 42759 5263 10 of of IN 42759 5263 11 wages wage NNS 42759 5263 12 at at IN 42759 5263 13 the the DT 42759 5263 14 expense expense NN 42759 5263 15 of of IN 42759 5263 16 prices price NNS 42759 5263 17 might may MD 42759 5263 18 at at IN 42759 5263 19 length length NN 42759 5263 20 leave leave NN 42759 5263 21 the the DT 42759 5263 22 great great JJ 42759 5263 23 majority majority NN 42759 5263 24 of of IN 42759 5263 25 the the DT 42759 5263 26 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5263 27 no no RB 42759 5263 28 better well RBR 42759 5263 29 off off RP 42759 5263 30 than than IN 42759 5263 31 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5263 32 were be VBD 42759 5263 33 when when WRB 42759 5263 34 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5263 35 had have VBD 42759 5263 36 merely merely RB 42759 5263 37 the the DT 42759 5263 38 " " `` 42759 5263 39 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5263 40 minimum minimum NN 42759 5263 41 . . . 42759 5263 42 " " '' 42759 5264 1 Such such JJ 42759 5264 2 would would MD 42759 5264 3 certainly certainly RB 42759 5264 4 be be VB 42759 5264 5 the the DT 42759 5264 6 result result NN 42759 5264 7 if if IN 42759 5264 8 the the DT 42759 5264 9 national national JJ 42759 5264 10 product product NN 42759 5264 11 were be VBD 42759 5264 12 only only RB 42759 5264 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5264 14 to to TO 42759 5264 15 provide provide VB 42759 5264 16 the the DT 42759 5264 17 " " `` 42759 5264 18 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5264 19 minimum minimum NN 42759 5264 20 " " '' 42759 5264 21 for for IN 42759 5264 22 all all DT 42759 5264 23 workers worker NNS 42759 5264 24 , , , 42759 5264 25 and and CC 42759 5264 26 that that DT 42759 5264 27 volume volume NN 42759 5264 28 of of IN 42759 5264 29 incomes income NNS 42759 5264 30 for for IN 42759 5264 31 the the DT 42759 5264 32 other other JJ 42759 5264 33 agents agent NNS 42759 5264 34 of of IN 42759 5264 35 production production NN 42759 5264 36 which which WDT 42759 5264 37 was be VBD 42759 5264 38 required require VBN 42759 5264 39 to to TO 42759 5264 40 evoke evoke VB 42759 5264 41 from from IN 42759 5264 42 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5264 43 a a DT 42759 5264 44 fair fair JJ 42759 5264 45 degree degree NN 42759 5264 46 of of IN 42759 5264 47 productive productive JJ 42759 5264 48 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5264 49 . . . 42759 5265 1 In in IN 42759 5265 2 that that DT 42759 5265 3 case case NN 42759 5265 4 the the DT 42759 5265 5 higher high JJR 42759 5265 6 wages wage NNS 42759 5265 7 would would MD 42759 5265 8 be be VB 42759 5265 9 an an DT 42759 5265 10 illusion illusion NN 42759 5265 11 . . . 42759 5266 1 The the DT 42759 5266 2 gain gain NN 42759 5266 3 in in IN 42759 5266 4 the the DT 42759 5266 5 amount amount NN 42759 5266 6 of of IN 42759 5266 7 money money NN 42759 5266 8 would would MD 42759 5266 9 be be VB 42759 5266 10 offset offset VBN 42759 5266 11 by by IN 42759 5266 12 the the DT 42759 5266 13 loss loss NN 42759 5266 14 in in IN 42759 5266 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5266 16 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 5266 17 power power NN 42759 5266 18 . . . 42759 5267 1 Even even RB 42759 5267 2 so so RB 42759 5267 3 , , , 42759 5267 4 this this DT 42759 5267 5 condition condition NN 42759 5267 6 would would MD 42759 5267 7 be be VB 42759 5267 8 greatly greatly RB 42759 5267 9 superior superior JJ 42759 5267 10 to to IN 42759 5267 11 a a DT 42759 5267 12 régime régime NN 42759 5267 13 in in IN 42759 5267 14 which which WDT 42759 5267 15 the the DT 42759 5267 16 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5267 17 were be VBD 42759 5267 18 universally universally RB 42759 5267 19 prevented prevent VBN 42759 5267 20 from from IN 42759 5267 21 making make VBG 42759 5267 22 any any DT 42759 5267 23 effort effort NN 42759 5267 24 to to TO 42759 5267 25 raise raise VB 42759 5267 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5267 27 wages wage NNS 42759 5267 28 above above IN 42759 5267 29 a a DT 42759 5267 30 fixed fix VBN 42759 5267 31 maximum maximum NN 42759 5267 32 . . . 42759 5268 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5268 2 Concluding Concluding NNP 42759 5268 3 Remarks Remarks NNPS 42759 5268 4 _ _ NNP 42759 5268 5 All all PDT 42759 5268 6 the the DT 42759 5268 7 principles principle NNS 42759 5268 8 and and CC 42759 5268 9 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 5268 10 defended defend VBN 42759 5268 11 in in IN 42759 5268 12 this this DT 42759 5268 13 chapter chapter NN 42759 5268 14 have have VBP 42759 5268 15 been be VBN 42759 5268 16 stated state VBN 42759 5268 17 with with IN 42759 5268 18 reference reference NN 42759 5268 19 to to IN 42759 5268 20 the the DT 42759 5268 21 present present JJ 42759 5268 22 distributive distributive JJ 42759 5268 23 system system NN 42759 5268 24 , , , 42759 5268 25 with with IN 42759 5268 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5268 27 free free JJ 42759 5268 28 competition competition NN 42759 5268 29 and and CC 42759 5268 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5268 31 lack lack NN 42759 5268 32 of of IN 42759 5268 33 legal legal JJ 42759 5268 34 regulation regulation NN 42759 5268 35 . . . 42759 5269 1 Were be VBD 42759 5269 2 all all DT 42759 5269 3 incomes income NNS 42759 5269 4 and and CC 42759 5269 5 rewards reward NNS 42759 5269 6 fixed fix VBN 42759 5269 7 by by IN 42759 5269 8 some some DT 42759 5269 9 supreme supreme NNP 42759 5269 10 authority authority NNP 42759 5269 11 , , , 42759 5269 12 the the DT 42759 5269 13 same same JJ 42759 5269 14 canons canon NNS 42759 5269 15 of of IN 42759 5269 16 justice justice NN 42759 5269 17 would would MD 42759 5269 18 be be VB 42759 5269 19 applicable applicable JJ 42759 5269 20 , , , 42759 5269 21 and and CC 42759 5269 22 the the DT 42759 5269 23 application application NN 42759 5269 24 would would MD 42759 5269 25 have have VB 42759 5269 26 to to TO 42759 5269 27 be be VB 42759 5269 28 made make VBN 42759 5269 29 in in IN 42759 5269 30 substantially substantially RB 42759 5269 31 the the DT 42759 5269 32 same same JJ 42759 5269 33 way way NN 42759 5269 34 , , , 42759 5269 35 if if IN 42759 5269 36 the the DT 42759 5269 37 authority authority NN 42759 5269 38 were be VBD 42759 5269 39 desirous desirous JJ 42759 5269 40 of of IN 42759 5269 41 establishing establish VBG 42759 5269 42 the the DT 42759 5269 43 greatest great JJS 42759 5269 44 possible possible JJ 42759 5269 45 measure measure NN 42759 5269 46 of of IN 42759 5269 47 distributive distributive JJ 42759 5269 48 justice justice NN 42759 5269 49 . . . 42759 5270 1 The the DT 42759 5270 2 main main JJ 42759 5270 3 exception exception NN 42759 5270 4 to to IN 42759 5270 5 this this DT 42759 5270 6 statement statement NN 42759 5270 7 would would MD 42759 5270 8 occur occur VB 42759 5270 9 in in IN 42759 5270 10 relation relation NN 42759 5270 11 to to IN 42759 5270 12 the the DT 42759 5270 13 problem problem NN 42759 5270 14 of of IN 42759 5270 15 raising raise VBG 42759 5270 16 wages wage NNS 42759 5270 17 above above IN 42759 5270 18 the the DT 42759 5270 19 " " `` 42759 5270 20 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5270 21 minimum minimum NN 42759 5270 22 " " '' 42759 5270 23 at at IN 42759 5270 24 the the DT 42759 5270 25 expense expense NN 42759 5270 26 of of IN 42759 5270 27 prices price NNS 42759 5270 28 . . . 42759 5271 1 In in IN 42759 5271 2 making make VBG 42759 5271 3 any any DT 42759 5271 4 such such JJ 42759 5271 5 increase increase NN 42759 5271 6 , , , 42759 5271 7 the the DT 42759 5271 8 wage wage NN 42759 5271 9 - - HYPH 42759 5271 10 fixing fix VBG 42759 5271 11 authority authority NN 42759 5271 12 would would MD 42759 5271 13 be be VB 42759 5271 14 obliged oblige VBN 42759 5271 15 to to TO 42759 5271 16 take take VB 42759 5271 17 into into IN 42759 5271 18 account account NN 42759 5271 19 the the DT 42759 5271 20 effects effect NNS 42759 5271 21 upon upon IN 42759 5271 22 the the DT 42759 5271 23 other other JJ 42759 5271 24 classes class NNS 42759 5271 25 of of IN 42759 5271 26 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5271 27 , , , 42759 5271 28 and and CC 42759 5271 29 upon upon IN 42759 5271 30 all all PDT 42759 5271 31 the the DT 42759 5271 32 non non JJ 42759 5271 33 - - JJ 42759 5271 34 wage wage NN 42759 5271 35 - - HYPH 42759 5271 36 earning earn VBG 42759 5271 37 classes class NNS 42759 5271 38 . . . 42759 5272 1 Substantially substantially RB 42759 5272 2 the the DT 42759 5272 3 same same JJ 42759 5272 4 difficulties difficulty NNS 42759 5272 5 would would MD 42759 5272 6 confront confront VB 42759 5272 7 the the DT 42759 5272 8 government government NN 42759 5272 9 in in IN 42759 5272 10 a a DT 42759 5272 11 collectivist collectivist JJ 42759 5272 12 organisation organisation NN 42759 5272 13 of of IN 42759 5272 14 industry industry NN 42759 5272 15 . . . 42759 5273 1 The the DT 42759 5273 2 effect effect NN 42759 5273 3 that that WDT 42759 5273 4 a a DT 42759 5273 5 rise rise NN 42759 5273 6 in in IN 42759 5273 7 the the DT 42759 5273 8 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5273 9 of of IN 42759 5273 10 any any DT 42759 5273 11 class class NN 42759 5273 12 would would MD 42759 5273 13 produce produce VB 42759 5273 14 , , , 42759 5273 15 through through IN 42759 5273 16 a a DT 42759 5273 17 rise rise NN 42759 5273 18 in in IN 42759 5273 19 the the DT 42759 5273 20 prices price NNS 42759 5273 21 of of IN 42759 5273 22 commodities commodity NNS 42759 5273 23 , , , 42759 5273 24 upon upon IN 42759 5273 25 the the DT 42759 5273 26 purchasing purchase VBG 42759 5273 27 power power NN 42759 5273 28 of of IN 42759 5273 29 the the DT 42759 5273 30 incomes income NNS 42759 5273 31 of of IN 42759 5273 32 other other JJ 42759 5273 33 classes class NNS 42759 5273 34 , , , 42759 5273 35 would would MD 42759 5273 36 have have VB 42759 5273 37 to to TO 42759 5273 38 be be VB 42759 5273 39 considered consider VBN 42759 5273 40 and and CC 42759 5273 41 as as RB 42759 5273 42 nearly nearly RB 42759 5273 43 as as IN 42759 5273 44 possible possible JJ 42759 5273 45 ascertained ascertained JJ 42759 5273 46 . . . 42759 5274 1 This this DT 42759 5274 2 would would MD 42759 5274 3 be be VB 42759 5274 4 no no DT 42759 5274 5 simple simple JJ 42759 5274 6 task task NN 42759 5274 7 . . . 42759 5275 1 Simple simple JJ 42759 5275 2 or or CC 42759 5275 3 not not RB 42759 5275 4 , , , 42759 5275 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5275 6 would would MD 42759 5275 7 have have VB 42759 5275 8 to to TO 42759 5275 9 be be VB 42759 5275 10 faced face VBN 42759 5275 11 ; ; : 42759 5275 12 and and CC 42759 5275 13 the the DT 42759 5275 14 guiding guide VBG 42759 5275 15 ethical ethical JJ 42759 5275 16 principles principle NNS 42759 5275 17 would would MD 42759 5275 18 always always RB 42759 5275 19 remain remain VB 42759 5275 20 efforts effort NNS 42759 5275 21 , , , 42759 5275 22 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5275 23 , , , 42759 5275 24 productivity productivity NN 42759 5275 25 , , , 42759 5275 26 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5275 27 , , , 42759 5275 28 and and CC 42759 5275 29 human human JJ 42759 5275 30 welfare welfare NN 42759 5275 31 . . . 42759 5276 1 The the DT 42759 5276 2 greater great JJR 42759 5276 3 part part NN 42759 5276 4 of of IN 42759 5276 5 the the DT 42759 5276 6 discussion discussion NN 42759 5276 7 carried carry VBN 42759 5276 8 on on RP 42759 5276 9 in in IN 42759 5276 10 this this DT 42759 5276 11 chapter chapter NN 42759 5276 12 has have VBZ 42759 5276 13 a a DT 42759 5276 14 highly highly RB 42759 5276 15 theoretical theoretical JJ 42759 5276 16 aspect aspect NN 42759 5276 17 . . . 42759 5277 1 From from IN 42759 5277 2 the the DT 42759 5277 3 nature nature NN 42759 5277 4 of of IN 42759 5277 5 the the DT 42759 5277 6 subject subject JJ 42759 5277 7 matter matter NN 42759 5277 8 this this DT 42759 5277 9 was be VBD 42759 5277 10 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 5277 11 . . . 42759 5278 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 5278 2 the the DT 42759 5278 3 principles principle NNS 42759 5278 4 that that WDT 42759 5278 5 have have VBP 42759 5278 6 been be VBN 42759 5278 7 enunciated enunciate VBN 42759 5278 8 and and CC 42759 5278 9 applied apply VBN 42759 5278 10 seem seem VBP 42759 5278 11 to to TO 42759 5278 12 be be VB 42759 5278 13 incontestable incontestable JJ 42759 5278 14 . . . 42759 5279 1 In in IN 42759 5279 2 so so RB 42759 5279 3 far far RB 42759 5279 4 as as IN 42759 5279 5 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5279 6 are be VBP 42759 5279 7 enforcible enforcible JJ 42759 5279 8 in in IN 42759 5279 9 actual actual JJ 42759 5279 10 life life NN 42759 5279 11 , , , 42759 5279 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5279 13 seem seem VBP 42759 5279 14 capable capable JJ 42759 5279 15 of of IN 42759 5279 16 bringing bring VBG 42759 5279 17 about about RP 42759 5279 18 a a DT 42759 5279 19 wider wide JJR 42759 5279 20 measure measure NN 42759 5279 21 of of IN 42759 5279 22 justice justice NN 42759 5279 23 than than IN 42759 5279 24 any any DT 42759 5279 25 other other JJ 42759 5279 26 ethical ethical JJ 42759 5279 27 rules rule NNS 42759 5279 28 that that WDT 42759 5279 29 are be VBP 42759 5279 30 available available JJ 42759 5279 31 . . . 42759 5280 1 Possibly possibly RB 42759 5280 2 the the DT 42759 5280 3 applications application NNS 42759 5280 4 and and CC 42759 5280 5 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 5280 6 have have VBP 42759 5280 7 been be VBN 42759 5280 8 laid lay VBN 42759 5280 9 down down RP 42759 5280 10 with with IN 42759 5280 11 too too RB 42759 5280 12 much much JJ 42759 5280 13 definiteness definiteness NN 42759 5280 14 and and CC 42759 5280 15 dogmatism dogmatism NN 42759 5280 16 , , , 42759 5280 17 and and CC 42759 5280 18 the the DT 42759 5280 19 whole whole JJ 42759 5280 20 matter matter NN 42759 5280 21 has have VBZ 42759 5280 22 been be VBN 42759 5280 23 made make VBN 42759 5280 24 too too RB 42759 5280 25 simple simple JJ 42759 5280 26 . . . 42759 5281 1 On on IN 42759 5281 2 the the DT 42759 5281 3 other other JJ 42759 5281 4 hand hand NN 42759 5281 5 , , , 42759 5281 6 neither neither CC 42759 5281 7 honesty honesty NN 42759 5281 8 nor nor CC 42759 5281 9 expediency expediency NN 42759 5281 10 is be VBZ 42759 5281 11 furthered further VBN 42759 5281 12 by by IN 42759 5281 13 an an DT 42759 5281 14 attitude attitude NN 42759 5281 15 of of IN 42759 5281 16 intellectual intellectual JJ 42759 5281 17 helplessness helplessness NN 42759 5281 18 , , , 42759 5281 19 academic academic JJ 42759 5281 20 hyper hyper JJ 42759 5281 21 - - NN 42759 5281 22 modesty modesty JJ 42759 5281 23 , , , 42759 5281 24 or or CC 42759 5281 25 practical practical JJ 42759 5281 26 agnosticism agnosticism NN 42759 5281 27 . . . 42759 5282 1 If if IN 42759 5282 2 there there EX 42759 5282 3 exist exist VBP 42759 5282 4 moral moral JJ 42759 5282 5 rules rule NNS 42759 5282 6 and and CC 42759 5282 7 rational rational JJ 42759 5282 8 principles principle NNS 42759 5282 9 applicable applicable JJ 42759 5282 10 to to IN 42759 5282 11 the the DT 42759 5282 12 problem problem NN 42759 5282 13 of of IN 42759 5282 14 wage wage NN 42759 5282 15 justice justice NN 42759 5282 16 , , , 42759 5282 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5282 18 is be VBZ 42759 5282 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5282 20 duty duty NN 42759 5282 21 to to IN 42759 5282 22 state state VB 42759 5282 23 and and CC 42759 5282 24 apply apply VB 42759 5282 25 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5282 26 as as RB 42759 5282 27 fully fully RB 42759 5282 28 as as IN 42759 5282 29 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5282 30 can can MD 42759 5282 31 . . . 42759 5283 1 Obviously obviously RB 42759 5283 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5283 3 shall shall MD 42759 5283 4 make make VB 42759 5283 5 mistakes mistake NNS 42759 5283 6 in in IN 42759 5283 7 the the DT 42759 5283 8 process process NN 42759 5283 9 ; ; : 42759 5283 10 but but CC 42759 5283 11 until until IN 42759 5283 12 the the DT 42759 5283 13 attempt attempt NN 42759 5283 14 is be VBZ 42759 5283 15 made make VBN 42759 5283 16 , , , 42759 5283 17 and and CC 42759 5283 18 a a DT 42759 5283 19 certain certain JJ 42759 5283 20 ( ( -LRB- 42759 5283 21 and and CC 42759 5283 22 very very RB 42759 5283 23 large large JJ 42759 5283 24 ) ) -RRB- 42759 5283 25 number number NN 42759 5283 26 of of IN 42759 5283 27 mistakes mistake NNS 42759 5283 28 are be VBP 42759 5283 29 made make VBN 42759 5283 30 , , , 42759 5283 31 there there EX 42759 5283 32 will will MD 42759 5283 33 be be VB 42759 5283 34 no no DT 42759 5283 35 progress progress NN 42759 5283 36 . . . 42759 5284 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 5284 2 have have VBP 42759 5284 3 no no DT 42759 5284 4 right right NN 42759 5284 5 to to TO 42759 5284 6 expect expect VB 42759 5284 7 that that IN 42759 5284 8 ready ready JJ 42759 5284 9 - - HYPH 42759 5284 10 made make VBN 42759 5284 11 applications application NNS 42759 5284 12 of of IN 42759 5284 13 the the DT 42759 5284 14 principles principle NNS 42759 5284 15 will will MD 42759 5284 16 drop drop VB 42759 5284 17 from from IN 42759 5284 18 Heaven Heaven NNP 42759 5284 19 . . . 42759 5285 1 For for IN 42759 5285 2 a a DT 42759 5285 3 long long JJ 42759 5285 4 time time NN 42759 5285 5 to to TO 42759 5285 6 come come VB 42759 5285 7 , , , 42759 5285 8 however however RB 42759 5285 9 , , , 42759 5285 10 many many JJ 42759 5285 11 of of IN 42759 5285 12 the the DT 42759 5285 13 questions question NNS 42759 5285 14 discussed discuss VBN 42759 5285 15 in in IN 42759 5285 16 this this DT 42759 5285 17 chapter chapter NN 42759 5285 18 will will MD 42759 5285 19 be be VB 42759 5285 20 devoid devoid JJ 42759 5285 21 of of IN 42759 5285 22 large large JJ 42759 5285 23 practical practical JJ 42759 5285 24 interest interest NN 42759 5285 25 . . . 42759 5286 1 The the DT 42759 5286 2 problem problem NN 42759 5286 3 immediately immediately RB 42759 5286 4 confronting confront VBG 42759 5286 5 society society NN 42759 5286 6 is be VBZ 42759 5286 7 that that DT 42759 5286 8 of of IN 42759 5286 9 raising raise VBG 42759 5286 10 the the DT 42759 5286 11 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5286 12 and and CC 42759 5286 13 strengthening strengthen VBG 42759 5286 14 generally generally RB 42759 5286 15 the the DT 42759 5286 16 economic economic JJ 42759 5286 17 position position NN 42759 5286 18 of of IN 42759 5286 19 those those DT 42759 5286 20 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5286 21 who who WP 42759 5286 22 are be VBP 42759 5286 23 now now RB 42759 5286 24 below below IN 42759 5286 25 the the DT 42759 5286 26 level level NN 42759 5286 27 , , , 42759 5286 28 not not RB 42759 5286 29 merely merely RB 42759 5286 30 of of IN 42759 5286 31 the the DT 42759 5286 32 " " `` 42759 5286 33 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5286 34 minimum minimum NN 42759 5286 35 , , , 42759 5286 36 " " '' 42759 5286 37 but but CC 42759 5286 38 of of IN 42759 5286 39 a a DT 42759 5286 40 decent decent JJ 42759 5286 41 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5286 42 . . . 42759 5287 1 This this DT 42759 5287 2 problem problem NN 42759 5287 3 will will MD 42759 5287 4 be be VB 42759 5287 5 the the DT 42759 5287 6 subject subject NN 42759 5287 7 of of IN 42759 5287 8 the the DT 42759 5287 9 next next JJ 42759 5287 10 chapter chapter NN 42759 5287 11 . . . 42759 5288 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 42759 5288 2 XXV XXV NNP 42759 5288 3 METHODS METHODS NNP 42759 5288 4 OF of IN 42759 5288 5 INCREASING increase VBG 42759 5288 6 WAGES WAGES NNP 42759 5288 7 Proposals Proposals NNPS 42759 5288 8 for for IN 42759 5288 9 the the DT 42759 5288 10 reform reform NN 42759 5288 11 of of IN 42759 5288 12 social social JJ 42759 5288 13 conditions condition NNS 42759 5288 14 are be VBP 42759 5288 15 important important JJ 42759 5288 16 in in IN 42759 5288 17 proportion proportion NN 42759 5288 18 to to IN 42759 5288 19 the the DT 42759 5288 20 magnitude magnitude NN 42759 5288 21 of of IN 42759 5288 22 the the DT 42759 5288 23 evils evil NNS 42759 5288 24 which which WDT 42759 5288 25 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5288 26 are be VBP 42759 5288 27 designed design VBN 42759 5288 28 to to TO 42759 5288 29 remove remove VB 42759 5288 30 , , , 42759 5288 31 and and CC 42759 5288 32 are be VBP 42759 5288 33 desirable desirable JJ 42759 5288 34 in in IN 42759 5288 35 proportion proportion NN 42759 5288 36 to to IN 42759 5288 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5288 38 probable probable JJ 42759 5288 39 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 5288 40 . . . 42759 5289 1 Applying apply VBG 42759 5289 2 these these DT 42759 5289 3 principles principle NNS 42759 5289 4 to to IN 42759 5289 5 the the DT 42759 5289 6 labour labour NN 42759 5289 7 situation situation NN 42759 5289 8 , , , 42759 5289 9 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5289 10 find find VBP 42759 5289 11 that that IN 42759 5289 12 among among IN 42759 5289 13 the the DT 42759 5289 14 remedies remedy NNS 42759 5289 15 proposed propose VBD 42759 5289 16 the the DT 42759 5289 17 primacy primacy NN 42759 5289 18 must must MD 42759 5289 19 be be VB 42759 5289 20 accorded accord VBN 42759 5289 21 to to IN 42759 5289 22 a a DT 42759 5289 23 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5289 24 wage wage NN 42759 5289 25 . . . 42759 5290 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5290 2 is be VBZ 42759 5290 3 the the DT 42759 5290 4 most most RBS 42759 5290 5 important important JJ 42759 5290 6 project project NN 42759 5290 7 for for IN 42759 5290 8 improving improve VBG 42759 5290 9 the the DT 42759 5290 10 condition condition NN 42759 5290 11 of of IN 42759 5290 12 labour labour NN 42759 5290 13 because because IN 42759 5290 14 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5290 15 would would MD 42759 5290 16 increase increase VB 42759 5290 17 the the DT 42759 5290 18 compensation compensation NN 42759 5290 19 of of IN 42759 5290 20 some some DT 42759 5290 21 two two CD 42759 5290 22 - - HYPH 42759 5290 23 thirds third NNS 42759 5290 24 of of IN 42759 5290 25 the the DT 42759 5290 26 wage wage NN 42759 5290 27 earners earner NNS 42759 5290 28 , , , 42759 5290 29 and and CC 42759 5290 30 because because IN 42759 5290 31 the the DT 42759 5290 32 needs need NNS 42759 5290 33 of of IN 42759 5290 34 this this DT 42759 5290 35 group group NN 42759 5290 36 are be VBP 42759 5290 37 greater great JJR 42759 5290 38 and and CC 42759 5290 39 more more RBR 42759 5290 40 urgent urgent JJ 42759 5290 41 than than IN 42759 5290 42 the the DT 42759 5290 43 needs need NNS 42759 5290 44 of of IN 42759 5290 45 the the DT 42759 5290 46 better well RBR 42759 5290 47 - - HYPH 42759 5290 48 paid pay VBN 42759 5290 49 one one CD 42759 5290 50 - - HYPH 42759 5290 51 third third NN 42759 5290 52 . . . 42759 5291 1 The the DT 42759 5291 2 former former JJ 42759 5291 3 are be VBP 42759 5291 4 below below IN 42759 5291 5 the the DT 42759 5291 6 level level NN 42759 5291 7 of of IN 42759 5291 8 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5291 9 living living NN 42759 5291 10 , , , 42759 5291 11 while while IN 42759 5291 12 the the DT 42759 5291 13 latter latter JJ 42759 5291 14 are be VBP 42759 5291 15 merely merely RB 42759 5291 16 deprived deprive VBN 42759 5291 17 of of IN 42759 5291 18 the the DT 42759 5291 19 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 5291 20 of of IN 42759 5291 21 a a DT 42759 5291 22 more more RBR 42759 5291 23 ample ample JJ 42759 5291 24 and and CC 42759 5291 25 liberal liberal JJ 42759 5291 26 scale scale NN 42759 5291 27 of of IN 42759 5291 28 living living NN 42759 5291 29 . . . 42759 5292 1 Hence hence RB 42759 5292 2 the the DT 42759 5292 3 degree degree NN 42759 5292 4 of of IN 42759 5292 5 injustice injustice NN 42759 5292 6 suffered suffer VBN 42759 5292 7 by by IN 42759 5292 8 the the DT 42759 5292 9 former former JJ 42759 5292 10 is be VBZ 42759 5292 11 much much RB 42759 5292 12 greater great JJR 42759 5292 13 than than IN 42759 5292 14 in in IN 42759 5292 15 the the DT 42759 5292 16 case case NN 42759 5292 17 of of IN 42759 5292 18 the the DT 42759 5292 19 latter latter JJ 42759 5292 20 . . . 42759 5293 1 A a DT 42759 5293 2 legal legal JJ 42759 5293 3 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5293 4 wage wage NN 42759 5293 5 is be VBZ 42759 5293 6 the the DT 42759 5293 7 most most RBS 42759 5293 8 desirable desirable JJ 42759 5293 9 single single JJ 42759 5293 10 measure measure NN 42759 5293 11 of of IN 42759 5293 12 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5293 13 reform reform NN 42759 5293 14 because because IN 42759 5293 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5293 16 promises promise VBZ 42759 5293 17 a a DT 42759 5293 18 more more RBR 42759 5293 19 rapid rapid JJ 42759 5293 20 and and CC 42759 5293 21 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 5293 22 increase increase NN 42759 5293 23 in in IN 42759 5293 24 the the DT 42759 5293 25 wages wage NNS 42759 5293 26 of of IN 42759 5293 27 the the DT 42759 5293 28 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5293 29 than than IN 42759 5293 30 any any DT 42759 5293 31 alternative alternative JJ 42759 5293 32 device device NN 42759 5293 33 that that WDT 42759 5293 34 is be VBZ 42759 5293 35 now now RB 42759 5293 36 available available JJ 42759 5293 37 . . . 42759 5294 1 The the DT 42759 5294 2 superior superior JJ 42759 5294 3 importance importance NN 42759 5294 4 of of IN 42759 5294 5 a a DT 42759 5294 6 legally legally RB 42759 5294 7 established establish VBN 42759 5294 8 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5294 9 wage wage NN 42759 5294 10 is be VBZ 42759 5294 11 obvious obvious JJ 42759 5294 12 ; ; : 42759 5294 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5294 14 superior superior JJ 42759 5294 15 desirability desirability NN 42759 5294 16 will will MD 42759 5294 17 form form VB 42759 5294 18 the the DT 42759 5294 19 subject subject NN 42759 5294 20 of of IN 42759 5294 21 the the DT 42759 5294 22 pages page NNS 42759 5294 23 that that WDT 42759 5294 24 are be VBP 42759 5294 25 immediately immediately RB 42759 5294 26 to to TO 42759 5294 27 follow follow VB 42759 5294 28 . . . 42759 5295 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5295 2 The the DT 42759 5295 3 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 5295 4 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5295 5 in in IN 42759 5295 6 Operation Operation NNP 42759 5295 7 _ _ NNP 42759 5295 8 Happily happily RB 42759 5295 9 the the DT 42759 5295 10 advocate advocate NN 42759 5295 11 of of IN 42759 5295 12 this this DT 42759 5295 13 measure measure NN 42759 5295 14 is be VBZ 42759 5295 15 no no RB 42759 5295 16 longer long RBR 42759 5295 17 required require VBN 42759 5295 18 to to TO 42759 5295 19 meet meet VB 42759 5295 20 the the DT 42759 5295 21 objection objection NN 42759 5295 22 that that IN 42759 5295 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5295 24 is be VBZ 42759 5295 25 novel novel JJ 42759 5295 26 and and CC 42759 5295 27 utterly utterly RB 42759 5295 28 uncertain uncertain JJ 42759 5295 29 . . . 42759 5296 1 For for IN 42759 5296 2 more more JJR 42759 5296 3 than than IN 42759 5296 4 twenty twenty CD 42759 5296 5 years year NNS 42759 5296 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5296 7 has have VBZ 42759 5296 8 been be VBN 42759 5296 9 in in IN 42759 5296 10 operation operation NN 42759 5296 11 in in IN 42759 5296 12 Australasia Australasia NNP 42759 5296 13 . . . 42759 5297 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5297 2 was be VBD 42759 5297 3 implicit implicit JJ 42759 5297 4 in in IN 42759 5297 5 the the DT 42759 5297 6 compulsory compulsory NNP 42759 5297 7 arbitration arbitration NNP 42759 5297 8 act act NN 42759 5297 9 of of IN 42759 5297 10 New New NNP 42759 5297 11 Zealand Zealand NNP 42759 5297 12 , , , 42759 5297 13 passed pass VBD 42759 5297 14 in in IN 42759 5297 15 1894 1894 CD 42759 5297 16 ; ; : 42759 5297 17 for for IN 42759 5297 18 the the DT 42759 5297 19 wages wage NNS 42759 5297 20 which which WDT 42759 5297 21 the the DT 42759 5297 22 arbitration arbitration NN 42759 5297 23 boards board NNS 42759 5297 24 enforce enforce NN 42759 5297 25 are be VBP 42759 5297 26 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 5297 27 the the DT 42759 5297 28 lowest low JJS 42759 5297 29 that that IN 42759 5297 30 the the DT 42759 5297 31 affected affect VBN 42759 5297 32 employers employer NNS 42759 5297 33 are be VBP 42759 5297 34 permitted permit VBN 42759 5297 35 to to TO 42759 5297 36 pay pay VB 42759 5297 37 ; ; : 42759 5297 38 besides besides RB 42759 5297 39 , , , 42759 5297 40 the the DT 42759 5297 41 district district NN 42759 5297 42 conciliation conciliation NN 42759 5297 43 boards board NNS 42759 5297 44 are be VBP 42759 5297 45 empowered empower VBN 42759 5297 46 by by IN 42759 5297 47 the the DT 42759 5297 48 law law NN 42759 5297 49 to to TO 42759 5297 50 fix fix VB 42759 5297 51 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5297 52 wages wage NNS 42759 5297 53 on on IN 42759 5297 54 complaint complaint NN 42759 5297 55 of of IN 42759 5297 56 any any DT 42759 5297 57 group group NN 42759 5297 58 of of IN 42759 5297 59 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5297 60 workers worker NNS 42759 5297 61 . . . 42759 5298 1 The the DT 42759 5298 2 first first JJ 42759 5298 3 formal formal JJ 42759 5298 4 and and CC 42759 5298 5 explicit explicit JJ 42759 5298 6 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5298 7 wage wage NN 42759 5298 8 law law NN 42759 5298 9 of of IN 42759 5298 10 modern modern JJ 42759 5298 11 times time NNS 42759 5298 12 was be VBD 42759 5298 13 enacted enact VBN 42759 5298 14 by by IN 42759 5298 15 the the DT 42759 5298 16 state state NN 42759 5298 17 of of IN 42759 5298 18 Victoria Victoria NNP 42759 5298 19 in in IN 42759 5298 20 1896 1896 CD 42759 5298 21 . . . 42759 5299 1 In in IN 42759 5299 2 the the DT 42759 5299 3 beginning beginning NN 42759 5299 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5299 5 applied apply VBD 42759 5299 6 to to IN 42759 5299 7 only only RB 42759 5299 8 six six CD 42759 5299 9 trades trade NNS 42759 5299 10 , , , 42759 5299 11 but but CC 42759 5299 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5299 13 has have VBZ 42759 5299 14 been be VBN 42759 5299 15 extended extend VBN 42759 5299 16 at at IN 42759 5299 17 various various JJ 42759 5299 18 legislative legislative JJ 42759 5299 19 sessions session NNS 42759 5299 20 , , , 42759 5299 21 so so IN 42759 5299 22 that that IN 42759 5299 23 to to IN 42759 5299 24 - - HYPH 42759 5299 25 day day NN 42759 5299 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5299 27 protects protect VBZ 42759 5299 28 substantially substantially RB 42759 5299 29 all all PDT 42759 5299 30 the the DT 42759 5299 31 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5299 32 of of IN 42759 5299 33 the the DT 42759 5299 34 state state NN 42759 5299 35 , , , 42759 5299 36 except except IN 42759 5299 37 those those DT 42759 5299 38 employed employ VBN 42759 5299 39 in in IN 42759 5299 40 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 5299 41 . . . 42759 5300 1 Since since IN 42759 5300 2 the the DT 42759 5300 3 year year NN 42759 5300 4 1900 1900 CD 42759 5300 5 all all PDT 42759 5300 6 the the DT 42759 5300 7 other other JJ 42759 5300 8 states state NNS 42759 5300 9 of of IN 42759 5300 10 Australia Australia NNP 42759 5300 11 have have VBP 42759 5300 12 made make VBN 42759 5300 13 provision provision NN 42759 5300 14 for for IN 42759 5300 15 the the DT 42759 5300 16 establishment establishment NN 42759 5300 17 of of IN 42759 5300 18 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5300 19 wages wage NNS 42759 5300 20 . . . 42759 5301 1 At at IN 42759 5301 2 present present JJ 42759 5301 3 , , , 42759 5301 4 therefore therefore RB 42759 5301 5 , , , 42759 5301 6 the the DT 42759 5301 7 legal legal JJ 42759 5301 8 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5301 9 wage wage NN 42759 5301 10 in in IN 42759 5301 11 some some DT 42759 5301 12 form form NN 42759 5301 13 prevails prevail VBZ 42759 5301 14 throughout throughout IN 42759 5301 15 the the DT 42759 5301 16 whole whole NN 42759 5301 17 of of IN 42759 5301 18 Australasia Australasia NNP 42759 5301 19 . . . 42759 5302 1 In in IN 42759 5302 2 1909 1909 CD 42759 5302 3 the the DT 42759 5302 4 Trade Trade NNP 42759 5302 5 Boards Boards NNPS 42759 5302 6 Act Act NNP 42759 5302 7 authorised authorise VBD 42759 5302 8 the the DT 42759 5302 9 application application NN 42759 5302 10 of of IN 42759 5302 11 this this DT 42759 5302 12 device device NN 42759 5302 13 to to IN 42759 5302 14 four four CD 42759 5302 15 trades trade NNS 42759 5302 16 in in IN 42759 5302 17 Great Great NNP 42759 5302 18 Britain Britain NNP 42759 5302 19 . . . 42759 5303 1 In in IN 42759 5303 2 1913 1913 CD 42759 5303 3 the the DT 42759 5303 4 provisions provision NNS 42759 5303 5 of of IN 42759 5303 6 the the DT 42759 5303 7 Act Act NNP 42759 5303 8 were be VBD 42759 5303 9 made make VBN 42759 5303 10 applicable applicable JJ 42759 5303 11 to to IN 42759 5303 12 four four CD 42759 5303 13 other other JJ 42759 5303 14 trades trade NNS 42759 5303 15 , , , 42759 5303 16 and and CC 42759 5303 17 in in IN 42759 5303 18 1914 1914 CD 42759 5303 19 to to IN 42759 5303 20 a a DT 42759 5303 21 third third JJ 42759 5303 22 group group NN 42759 5303 23 of of IN 42759 5303 24 four four CD 42759 5303 25 industries industry NNS 42759 5303 26 . . . 42759 5304 1 A a DT 42759 5304 2 special special JJ 42759 5304 3 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5304 4 wage wage NN 42759 5304 5 law law NN 42759 5304 6 was be VBD 42759 5304 7 in in IN 42759 5304 8 1912 1912 CD 42759 5304 9 enacted enact VBN 42759 5304 10 to to TO 42759 5304 11 govern govern VB 42759 5304 12 the the DT 42759 5304 13 entire entire JJ 42759 5304 14 coal coal NN 42759 5304 15 mining mining NN 42759 5304 16 industry industry NN 42759 5304 17 of of IN 42759 5304 18 the the DT 42759 5304 19 country country NN 42759 5304 20 . . . 42759 5305 1 The the DT 42759 5305 2 first first JJ 42759 5305 3 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5305 4 wage wage NN 42759 5305 5 law law NN 42759 5305 6 in in IN 42759 5305 7 the the DT 42759 5305 8 United United NNP 42759 5305 9 States States NNP 42759 5305 10 was be VBD 42759 5305 11 passed pass VBN 42759 5305 12 in in IN 42759 5305 13 1912 1912 CD 42759 5305 14 by by IN 42759 5305 15 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 42759 5305 16 . . . 42759 5306 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5306 2 has have VBZ 42759 5306 3 been be VBN 42759 5306 4 followed follow VBN 42759 5306 5 by by IN 42759 5306 6 similar similar JJ 42759 5306 7 legislation legislation NN 42759 5306 8 in in IN 42759 5306 9 ten ten CD 42759 5306 10 other other JJ 42759 5306 11 states state NNS 42759 5306 12 ; ; : 42759 5306 13 namely namely RB 42759 5306 14 , , , 42759 5306 15 Arkansas Arkansas NNP 42759 5306 16 , , , 42759 5306 17 California California NNP 42759 5306 18 , , , 42759 5306 19 Colorado Colorado NNP 42759 5306 20 , , , 42759 5306 21 Kansas Kansas NNP 42759 5306 22 , , , 42759 5306 23 Minnesota Minnesota NNP 42759 5306 24 , , , 42759 5306 25 Nebraska Nebraska NNP 42759 5306 26 , , , 42759 5306 27 Oregon Oregon NNP 42759 5306 28 , , , 42759 5306 29 Utah Utah NNP 42759 5306 30 , , , 42759 5306 31 Washington Washington NNP 42759 5306 32 , , , 42759 5306 33 and and CC 42759 5306 34 Wisconsin Wisconsin NNP 42759 5306 35 . . . 42759 5307 1 California California NNP 42759 5307 2 has have VBZ 42759 5307 3 adopted adopt VBN 42759 5307 4 a a DT 42759 5307 5 constitutional constitutional JJ 42759 5307 6 amendment amendment NN 42759 5307 7 which which WDT 42759 5307 8 specifically specifically RB 42759 5307 9 authorises authorise VBZ 42759 5307 10 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5307 11 wage wage NN 42759 5307 12 legislation legislation NN 42759 5307 13 for for IN 42759 5307 14 women woman NNS 42759 5307 15 and and CC 42759 5307 16 minors minor NNS 42759 5307 17 , , , 42759 5307 18 and and CC 42759 5307 19 Ohio Ohio NNP 42759 5307 20 added add VBD 42759 5307 21 a a DT 42759 5307 22 similar similar JJ 42759 5307 23 provision provision NN 42759 5307 24 to to IN 42759 5307 25 her -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5307 26 constitution constitution NN 42759 5307 27 which which WDT 42759 5307 28 applies apply VBZ 42759 5307 29 to to IN 42759 5307 30 men man NNS 42759 5307 31 as as RB 42759 5307 32 well well RB 42759 5307 33 . . . 42759 5308 1 The the DT 42759 5308 2 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5308 3 wage wage NN 42759 5308 4 statutes statute NNS 42759 5308 5 of of IN 42759 5308 6 Australasia Australasia NNP 42759 5308 7 and and CC 42759 5308 8 Great Great NNP 42759 5308 9 Britain Britain NNP 42759 5308 10 cover cover VBP 42759 5308 11 all all DT 42759 5308 12 classes class NNS 42759 5308 13 of of IN 42759 5308 14 workers worker NNS 42759 5308 15 , , , 42759 5308 16 but but CC 42759 5308 17 those those DT 42759 5308 18 of of IN 42759 5308 19 the the DT 42759 5308 20 United United NNP 42759 5308 21 States States NNP 42759 5308 22 are be VBP 42759 5308 23 restricted restrict VBN 42759 5308 24 to to IN 42759 5308 25 minors minor NNS 42759 5308 26 and and CC 42759 5308 27 women woman NNS 42759 5308 28 . . . 42759 5309 1 With with IN 42759 5309 2 the the DT 42759 5309 3 exception exception NN 42759 5309 4 of of IN 42759 5309 5 the the DT 42759 5309 6 Utah Utah NNP 42759 5309 7 act act NN 42759 5309 8 , , , 42759 5309 9 all all PDT 42759 5309 10 the the DT 42759 5309 11 important important JJ 42759 5309 12 laws law NNS 42759 5309 13 on on IN 42759 5309 14 this this DT 42759 5309 15 subject subject NN 42759 5309 16 in in IN 42759 5309 17 all all DT 42759 5309 18 three three CD 42759 5309 19 regions region NNS 42759 5309 20 establish establish VBP 42759 5309 21 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5309 22 wages wage NNS 42759 5309 23 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 5309 24 , , , 42759 5309 25 by by IN 42759 5309 26 authorising authorise VBG 42759 5309 27 commissions commission NNS 42759 5309 28 and and CC 42759 5309 29 wage wage NN 42759 5309 30 boards board NNS 42759 5309 31 to to TO 42759 5309 32 determine determine VB 42759 5309 33 the the DT 42759 5309 34 actual actual JJ 42759 5309 35 rates rate NNS 42759 5309 36 . . . 42759 5310 1 In in IN 42759 5310 2 Australasia Australasia NNP 42759 5310 3 and and CC 42759 5310 4 Great Great NNP 42759 5310 5 Britain Britain NNP 42759 5310 6 the the DT 42759 5310 7 statutes statute NNS 42759 5310 8 do do VBP 42759 5310 9 not not RB 42759 5310 10 attempt attempt VB 42759 5310 11 to to TO 42759 5310 12 specify specify VB 42759 5310 13 any any DT 42759 5310 14 standard standard NN 42759 5310 15 to to TO 42759 5310 16 which which WDT 42759 5310 17 the the DT 42759 5310 18 wage wage NN 42759 5310 19 determinations determination NNS 42759 5310 20 of of IN 42759 5310 21 the the DT 42759 5310 22 boards board NNS 42759 5310 23 must must MD 42759 5310 24 conform conform VB 42759 5310 25 , , , 42759 5310 26 but but CC 42759 5310 27 the the DT 42759 5310 28 tendency tendency NN 42759 5310 29 in in IN 42759 5310 30 the the DT 42759 5310 31 former former JJ 42759 5310 32 country country NN 42759 5310 33 in in IN 42759 5310 34 recent recent JJ 42759 5310 35 years year NNS 42759 5310 36 has have VBZ 42759 5310 37 been be VBN 42759 5310 38 to to TO 42759 5310 39 enforce enforce VB 42759 5310 40 a a DT 42759 5310 41 living living NN 42759 5310 42 wage wage NN 42759 5310 43 as as IN 42759 5310 44 the the DT 42759 5310 45 minimum minimum NN 42759 5310 46 ; ; : 42759 5310 47 that that RB 42759 5310 48 is is RB 42759 5310 49 , , , 42759 5310 50 wage wage NN 42759 5310 51 rates rate NNS 42759 5310 52 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 5310 53 high high JJ 42759 5310 54 to to TO 42759 5310 55 provide provide VB 42759 5310 56 a a DT 42759 5310 57 decent decent JJ 42759 5310 58 family family NN 42759 5310 59 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5310 60 for for IN 42759 5310 61 men man NNS 42759 5310 62 , , , 42759 5310 63 and and CC 42759 5310 64 a a DT 42759 5310 65 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5310 66 personal personal JJ 42759 5310 67 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5310 68 for for IN 42759 5310 69 women woman NNS 42759 5310 70 and and CC 42759 5310 71 minors minor NNS 42759 5310 72 . . . 42759 5311 1 All all PDT 42759 5311 2 the the DT 42759 5311 3 laws law NNS 42759 5311 4 in in IN 42759 5311 5 America America NNP 42759 5311 6 but but CC 42759 5311 7 one one CD 42759 5311 8 require require VBP 42759 5311 9 the the DT 42759 5311 10 commissions commission NNS 42759 5311 11 to to TO 42759 5311 12 establish establish VB 42759 5311 13 living live VBG 42759 5311 14 wages wage NNS 42759 5311 15 . . . 42759 5312 1 In in IN 42759 5312 2 Utah Utah NNP 42759 5312 3 no no DT 42759 5312 4 commission commission NN 42759 5312 5 is be VBZ 42759 5312 6 provided provide VBN 42759 5312 7 for for IN 42759 5312 8 , , , 42759 5312 9 as as IN 42759 5312 10 the the DT 42759 5312 11 law law NN 42759 5312 12 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 5312 13 specifies specify VBZ 42759 5312 14 in in IN 42759 5312 15 terms term NNS 42759 5312 16 of of IN 42759 5312 17 money money NN 42759 5312 18 the the DT 42759 5312 19 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5312 20 rates rate NNS 42759 5312 21 of of IN 42759 5312 22 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5312 23 that that IN 42759 5312 24 the the DT 42759 5312 25 employers employer NNS 42759 5312 26 of of IN 42759 5312 27 women woman NNS 42759 5312 28 are be VBP 42759 5312 29 permitted permit VBN 42759 5312 30 to to TO 42759 5312 31 pay pay VB 42759 5312 32 . . . 42759 5313 1 The the DT 42759 5313 2 effectiveness effectiveness NN 42759 5313 3 of of IN 42759 5313 4 the the DT 42759 5313 5 laws law NNS 42759 5313 6 that that WDT 42759 5313 7 have have VBP 42759 5313 8 been be VBN 42759 5313 9 put put VBN 42759 5313 10 into into IN 42759 5313 11 operation operation NN 42759 5313 12 is be VBZ 42759 5313 13 at at IN 42759 5313 14 least least JJS 42759 5313 15 as as RB 42759 5313 16 great great JJ 42759 5313 17 as as IN 42759 5313 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5313 19 friends friend NNS 42759 5313 20 had have VBD 42759 5313 21 dared dare VBN 42759 5313 22 to to TO 42759 5313 23 hope hope VB 42759 5313 24 . . . 42759 5314 1 According accord VBG 42759 5314 2 to to IN 42759 5314 3 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5314 4 M. M. NNP 42759 5314 5 B. B. NNP 42759 5314 6 Hammond Hammond NNP 42759 5314 7 of of IN 42759 5314 8 Ohio Ohio NNP 42759 5314 9 , , , 42759 5314 10 who who WP 42759 5314 11 investigated investigate VBD 42759 5314 12 the the DT 42759 5314 13 situation situation NN 42759 5314 14 on on IN 42759 5314 15 the the DT 42759 5314 16 spot spot NN 42759 5314 17 in in IN 42759 5314 18 the the DT 42759 5314 19 winter winter NN 42759 5314 20 of of IN 42759 5314 21 1911 1911 CD 42759 5314 22 - - SYM 42759 5314 23 1912 1912 CD 42759 5314 24 , , , 42759 5314 25 the the DT 42759 5314 26 people people NNS 42759 5314 27 of of IN 42759 5314 28 Australasia Australasia NNP 42759 5314 29 have have VBP 42759 5314 30 accepted accept VBN 42759 5314 31 the the DT 42759 5314 32 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5314 33 wage wage NN 42759 5314 34 " " '' 42759 5314 35 as as IN 42759 5314 36 a a DT 42759 5314 37 permanent permanent JJ 42759 5314 38 policy policy NN 42759 5314 39 in in IN 42759 5314 40 the the DT 42759 5314 41 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5314 42 legislation legislation NN 42759 5314 43 of of IN 42759 5314 44 that that DT 42759 5314 45 part part NN 42759 5314 46 of of IN 42759 5314 47 the the DT 42759 5314 48 world world NN 42759 5314 49 . . . 42759 5314 50 " " '' 42759 5315 1 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5315 2 Hammond Hammond NNP 42759 5315 3 's 's POS 42759 5315 4 observations observation NNS 42759 5315 5 , , , 42759 5315 6 and and CC 42759 5315 7 the the DT 42759 5315 8 replies reply NNS 42759 5315 9 of of IN 42759 5315 10 the the DT 42759 5315 11 Chief Chief NNP 42759 5315 12 Factory Factory NNP 42759 5315 13 Inspector Inspector NNP 42759 5315 14 of of IN 42759 5315 15 Melbourne Melbourne NNP 42759 5315 16 to to IN 42759 5315 17 the the DT 42759 5315 18 New New NNP 42759 5315 19 York York NNP 42759 5315 20 Factory Factory NNP 42759 5315 21 Investigating Investigating NNP 42759 5315 22 Commission Commission NNP 42759 5315 23 , , , 42759 5315 24 show show VB 42759 5315 25 the the DT 42759 5315 26 main main JJ 42759 5315 27 effects effect NNS 42759 5315 28 of of IN 42759 5315 29 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5315 30 wage wage NN 42759 5315 31 legislation legislation NN 42759 5315 32 to to TO 42759 5315 33 be be VB 42759 5315 34 as as IN 42759 5315 35 follows follow VBZ 42759 5315 36 : : : 42759 5315 37 sweating sweating NN 42759 5315 38 and and CC 42759 5315 39 strikes strike NNS 42759 5315 40 have have VBP 42759 5315 41 all all DT 42759 5315 42 but but RB 42759 5315 43 disappeared disappear VBD 42759 5315 44 ; ; : 42759 5315 45 the the DT 42759 5315 46 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5315 47 of of IN 42759 5315 48 the the DT 42759 5315 49 workers worker NNS 42759 5315 50 has have VBZ 42759 5315 51 on on IN 42759 5315 52 the the DT 42759 5315 53 whole whole JJ 42759 5315 54 increased increase VBD 42759 5315 55 ; ; : 42759 5315 56 the the DT 42759 5315 57 number number NN 42759 5315 58 of of IN 42759 5315 59 workers worker NNS 42759 5315 60 unable unable JJ 42759 5315 61 to to TO 42759 5315 62 earn earn VB 42759 5315 63 the the DT 42759 5315 64 legal legal JJ 42759 5315 65 minimum minimum NN 42759 5315 66 has have VBZ 42759 5315 67 not not RB 42759 5315 68 been be VBN 42759 5315 69 as as RB 42759 5315 70 great great JJ 42759 5315 71 as as IN 42759 5315 72 most most JJS 42759 5315 73 persons person NNS 42759 5315 74 had have VBD 42759 5315 75 feared fear VBN 42759 5315 76 , , , 42759 5315 77 and and CC 42759 5315 78 almost almost RB 42759 5315 79 all all DT 42759 5315 80 of of IN 42759 5315 81 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5315 82 have have VBP 42759 5315 83 obtained obtain VBN 42759 5315 84 employment employment NN 42759 5315 85 at at IN 42759 5315 86 lower low JJR 42759 5315 87 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5315 88 through through IN 42759 5315 89 special special JJ 42759 5315 90 permits permit NNS 42759 5315 91 ; ; : 42759 5315 92 the the DT 42759 5315 93 legal legal JJ 42759 5315 94 minimum minimum NN 42759 5315 95 has have VBZ 42759 5315 96 not not RB 42759 5315 97 only only RB 42759 5315 98 not not RB 42759 5315 99 become become VBN 42759 5315 100 the the DT 42759 5315 101 actual actual JJ 42759 5315 102 maximum maximum NN 42759 5315 103 , , , 42759 5315 104 but but CC 42759 5315 105 is be VBZ 42759 5315 106 exceeded exceed VBN 42759 5315 107 in in IN 42759 5315 108 the the DT 42759 5315 109 case case NN 42759 5315 110 of of IN 42759 5315 111 the the DT 42759 5315 112 majority majority NN 42759 5315 113 of of IN 42759 5315 114 workers worker NNS 42759 5315 115 ; ; : 42759 5315 116 no no DT 42759 5315 117 evidence evidence NN 42759 5315 118 exists exist VBZ 42759 5315 119 to to TO 42759 5315 120 show show VB 42759 5315 121 that that IN 42759 5315 122 any any DT 42759 5315 123 industry industry NN 42759 5315 124 has have VBZ 42759 5315 125 been be VBN 42759 5315 126 crippled cripple VBN 42759 5315 127 , , , 42759 5315 128 or or CC 42759 5315 129 forced force VBN 42759 5315 130 to to TO 42759 5315 131 move move VB 42759 5315 132 out out IN 42759 5315 133 of of IN 42759 5315 134 the the DT 42759 5315 135 country country NN 42759 5315 136 ; ; : 42759 5315 137 with with IN 42759 5315 138 the the DT 42759 5315 139 exception exception NN 42759 5315 140 of of IN 42759 5315 141 a a DT 42759 5315 142 very very RB 42759 5315 143 few few JJ 42759 5315 144 instances instance NNS 42759 5315 145 , , , 42759 5315 146 the the DT 42759 5315 147 prices price NNS 42759 5315 148 of of IN 42759 5315 149 commodities commodity NNS 42759 5315 150 have have VBP 42759 5315 151 not not RB 42759 5315 152 been be VBN 42759 5315 153 raised raise VBN 42759 5315 154 by by IN 42759 5315 155 the the DT 42759 5315 156 law law NN 42759 5315 157 . . . 42759 5316 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5316 2 251 251 CD 42759 5316 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5316 4 In in IN 42759 5316 5 the the DT 42759 5316 6 four four CD 42759 5316 7 trades trade NNS 42759 5316 8 of of IN 42759 5316 9 Great Great NNP 42759 5316 10 Britain Britain NNP 42759 5316 11 which which WDT 42759 5316 12 were be VBD 42759 5316 13 first first RB 42759 5316 14 brought bring VBN 42759 5316 15 under under IN 42759 5316 16 the the DT 42759 5316 17 operation operation NN 42759 5316 18 of of IN 42759 5316 19 the the DT 42759 5316 20 Trade Trade NNP 42759 5316 21 Boards Boards NNPS 42759 5316 22 Act Act NNP 42759 5316 23 , , , 42759 5316 24 and and CC 42759 5316 25 which which WDT 42759 5316 26 presented present VBD 42759 5316 27 some some DT 42759 5316 28 of of IN 42759 5316 29 the the DT 42759 5316 30 worst bad JJS 42759 5316 31 examples example NNS 42759 5316 32 of of IN 42759 5316 33 economic economic JJ 42759 5316 34 oppression oppression NN 42759 5316 35 , , , 42759 5316 36 the the DT 42759 5316 37 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 5316 38 effects effect NNS 42759 5316 39 of of IN 42759 5316 40 the the DT 42759 5316 41 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5316 42 wage wage NN 42759 5316 43 have have VBP 42759 5316 44 been be VBN 42759 5316 45 even even RB 42759 5316 46 more more RBR 42759 5316 47 striking striking JJ 42759 5316 48 than than IN 42759 5316 49 in in IN 42759 5316 50 Australasia Australasia NNP 42759 5316 51 . . . 42759 5317 1 Wages wage NNS 42759 5317 2 have have VBP 42759 5317 3 been be VBN 42759 5317 4 considerably considerably RB 42759 5317 5 raised raise VBN 42759 5317 6 , , , 42759 5317 7 in in IN 42759 5317 8 some some DT 42759 5317 9 cases case NNS 42759 5317 10 as as RB 42759 5317 11 high high JJ 42759 5317 12 as as IN 42759 5317 13 one one CD 42759 5317 14 hundred hundred CD 42759 5317 15 per per IN 42759 5317 16 cent cent NN 42759 5317 17 . . . 42759 5318 1 ; ; : 42759 5318 2 dispirited dispirited JJ 42759 5318 3 and and CC 42759 5318 4 helpless helpless JJ 42759 5318 5 workers worker NNS 42759 5318 6 have have VBP 42759 5318 7 gained gain VBN 42759 5318 8 courage courage NN 42759 5318 9 , , , 42759 5318 10 power power NN 42759 5318 11 , , , 42759 5318 12 and and CC 42759 5318 13 self self NN 42759 5318 14 - - HYPH 42759 5318 15 respect respect NN 42759 5318 16 to to IN 42759 5318 17 such such PDT 42759 5318 18 an an DT 42759 5318 19 extent extent NN 42759 5318 20 as as IN 42759 5318 21 to to TO 42759 5318 22 increase increase VB 42759 5318 23 considerably considerably RB 42759 5318 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5318 25 membership membership NN 42759 5318 26 in in IN 42759 5318 27 trade trade NN 42759 5318 28 unions union NNS 42759 5318 29 , , , 42759 5318 30 and and CC 42759 5318 31 to to TO 42759 5318 32 obtain obtain VB 42759 5318 33 in in IN 42759 5318 34 several several JJ 42759 5318 35 instances instance NNS 42759 5318 36 further further JJ 42759 5318 37 increases increase NNS 42759 5318 38 in in IN 42759 5318 39 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5318 40 beyond beyond IN 42759 5318 41 the the DT 42759 5318 42 legal legal JJ 42759 5318 43 minimum minimum NN 42759 5318 44 ; ; : 42759 5318 45 the the DT 42759 5318 46 compensation compensation NN 42759 5318 47 of of IN 42759 5318 48 the the DT 42759 5318 49 better well JJR 42759 5318 50 paid pay VBN 42759 5318 51 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5318 52 has have VBZ 42759 5318 53 not not RB 42759 5318 54 been be VBN 42759 5318 55 reduced reduce VBN 42759 5318 56 to to IN 42759 5318 57 the the DT 42759 5318 58 level level NN 42759 5318 59 fixed fix VBN 42759 5318 60 by by IN 42759 5318 61 the the DT 42759 5318 62 trade trade NN 42759 5318 63 boards board NNS 42759 5318 64 ; ; : 42759 5318 65 the the DT 42759 5318 66 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5318 67 of of IN 42759 5318 68 both both CC 42759 5318 69 employés employés JJ 42759 5318 70 and and CC 42759 5318 71 productive productive JJ 42759 5318 72 processes process NNS 42759 5318 73 has have VBZ 42759 5318 74 been be VBN 42759 5318 75 on on IN 42759 5318 76 the the DT 42759 5318 77 whole whole JJ 42759 5318 78 increased increase VBD 42759 5318 79 ; ; : 42759 5318 80 the the DT 42759 5318 81 number number NN 42759 5318 82 of of IN 42759 5318 83 persons person NNS 42759 5318 84 forced force VBN 42759 5318 85 out out IN 42759 5318 86 of of IN 42759 5318 87 employment employment NN 42759 5318 88 by by IN 42759 5318 89 the the DT 42759 5318 90 law law NN 42759 5318 91 is be VBZ 42759 5318 92 negligible negligible JJ 42759 5318 93 ; ; : 42759 5318 94 no no DT 42759 5318 95 important important JJ 42759 5318 96 rise rise NN 42759 5318 97 of of IN 42759 5318 98 prices price NNS 42759 5318 99 is be VBZ 42759 5318 100 traceable traceable JJ 42759 5318 101 to to IN 42759 5318 102 the the DT 42759 5318 103 law law NN 42759 5318 104 ; ; : 42759 5318 105 and and CC 42759 5318 106 the the DT 42759 5318 107 number number NN 42759 5318 108 of of IN 42759 5318 109 business business NN 42759 5318 110 concerns concern NNS 42759 5318 111 unable unable JJ 42759 5318 112 to to TO 42759 5318 113 pay pay VB 42759 5318 114 the the DT 42759 5318 115 increase increase NN 42759 5318 116 in in IN 42759 5318 117 wages wage NNS 42759 5318 118 is be VBZ 42759 5318 119 too too RB 42759 5318 120 small small JJ 42759 5318 121 to to TO 42759 5318 122 deserve deserve VB 42759 5318 123 serious serious JJ 42759 5318 124 consideration consideration NN 42759 5318 125 . . . 42759 5319 1 All all PDT 42759 5319 2 these these DT 42759 5319 3 results result NNS 42759 5319 4 had have VBD 42759 5319 5 been be VBN 42759 5319 6 established establish VBN 42759 5319 7 before before IN 42759 5319 8 the the DT 42759 5319 9 outbreak outbreak NN 42759 5319 10 of of IN 42759 5319 11 the the DT 42759 5319 12 war war NN 42759 5319 13 . . . 42759 5320 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5320 2 252 252 CD 42759 5320 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5320 4 The the DT 42759 5320 5 legal legal JJ 42759 5320 6 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5320 7 wage wage NN 42759 5320 8 has have VBZ 42759 5320 9 been be VBN 42759 5320 10 carried carry VBN 42759 5320 11 into into IN 42759 5320 12 effect effect NN 42759 5320 13 in in IN 42759 5320 14 only only RB 42759 5320 15 four four CD 42759 5320 16 states state NNS 42759 5320 17 of of IN 42759 5320 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5320 19 own own JJ 42759 5320 20 country country NN 42759 5320 21 . . . 42759 5321 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5321 2 covers cover VBZ 42759 5321 3 practically practically RB 42759 5321 4 all all PDT 42759 5321 5 the the DT 42759 5321 6 industries industry NNS 42759 5321 7 employing employ VBG 42759 5321 8 women woman NNS 42759 5321 9 and and CC 42759 5321 10 minors minor NNS 42759 5321 11 in in IN 42759 5321 12 Oregon Oregon NNP 42759 5321 13 and and CC 42759 5321 14 Washington Washington NNP 42759 5321 15 , , , 42759 5321 16 all all PDT 42759 5321 17 the the DT 42759 5321 18 working work VBG 42759 5321 19 women woman NNS 42759 5321 20 and and CC 42759 5321 21 girls girl NNS 42759 5321 22 of of IN 42759 5321 23 Utah Utah NNP 42759 5321 24 , , , 42759 5321 25 and and CC 42759 5321 26 the the DT 42759 5321 27 women woman NNS 42759 5321 28 and and CC 42759 5321 29 minors minor NNS 42759 5321 30 of of IN 42759 5321 31 a a DT 42759 5321 32 few few JJ 42759 5321 33 trades trade NNS 42759 5321 34 in in IN 42759 5321 35 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 42759 5321 36 . . . 42759 5322 1 The the DT 42759 5322 2 rates rate NNS 42759 5322 3 established establish VBN 42759 5322 4 for for IN 42759 5322 5 experienced experienced JJ 42759 5322 6 women woman NNS 42759 5322 7 vary vary VBP 42759 5322 8 from from IN 42759 5322 9 $ $ $ 42759 5322 10 7.50 7.50 CD 42759 5322 11 per per IN 42759 5322 12 week week NN 42759 5322 13 in in IN 42759 5322 14 Utah Utah NNP 42759 5322 15 to to IN 42759 5322 16 ten ten CD 42759 5322 17 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5322 18 a a DT 42759 5322 19 week week NN 42759 5322 20 for for IN 42759 5322 21 some some DT 42759 5322 22 classes class NNS 42759 5322 23 in in IN 42759 5322 24 Washington Washington NNP 42759 5322 25 . . . 42759 5323 1 As as IN 42759 5323 2 the the DT 42759 5323 3 first first JJ 42759 5323 4 wage wage NN 42759 5323 5 determinations determination NNS 42759 5323 6 were be VBD 42759 5323 7 put put VBN 42759 5323 8 into into IN 42759 5323 9 effect effect NN 42759 5323 10 only only RB 42759 5323 11 in in IN 42759 5323 12 1913 1913 CD 42759 5323 13 , , , 42759 5323 14 American american JJ 42759 5323 15 experience experience NN 42759 5323 16 has have VBZ 42759 5323 17 been be VBN 42759 5323 18 too too RB 42759 5323 19 short short JJ 42759 5323 20 as as RB 42759 5323 21 well well RB 42759 5323 22 as as IN 42759 5323 23 too too RB 42759 5323 24 narrow narrow JJ 42759 5323 25 to to TO 42759 5323 26 warrant warrant VB 42759 5323 27 certain certain JJ 42759 5323 28 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 5323 29 . . . 42759 5324 1 So so RB 42759 5324 2 far far RB 42759 5324 3 as as IN 42759 5324 4 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5324 5 has have VBZ 42759 5324 6 been be VBN 42759 5324 7 applied apply VBN 42759 5324 8 , , , 42759 5324 9 however however RB 42759 5324 10 , , , 42759 5324 11 the the DT 42759 5324 12 legal legal JJ 42759 5324 13 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5324 14 wage wage NN 42759 5324 15 has have VBZ 42759 5324 16 been be VBN 42759 5324 17 as as RB 42759 5324 18 successful successful JJ 42759 5324 19 in in IN 42759 5324 20 the the DT 42759 5324 21 United United NNP 42759 5324 22 States States NNP 42759 5324 23 as as IN 42759 5324 24 in in IN 42759 5324 25 Australasia Australasia NNP 42759 5324 26 or or CC 42759 5324 27 Great Great NNP 42759 5324 28 Britain Britain NNP 42759 5324 29 . . . 42759 5325 1 All all DT 42759 5325 2 competent competent JJ 42759 5325 3 witnesses witness NNS 42759 5325 4 agree agree VBP 42759 5325 5 that that IN 42759 5325 6 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5325 7 has have VBZ 42759 5325 8 brought bring VBN 42759 5325 9 a a DT 42759 5325 10 considerable considerable JJ 42759 5325 11 increase increase NN 42759 5325 12 in in IN 42759 5325 13 wages wage NNS 42759 5325 14 to to IN 42759 5325 15 a a DT 42759 5325 16 considerable considerable JJ 42759 5325 17 proportion proportion NN 42759 5325 18 of of IN 42759 5325 19 the the DT 42759 5325 20 women woman NNS 42759 5325 21 and and CC 42759 5325 22 minors minor NNS 42759 5325 23 in in IN 42759 5325 24 the the DT 42759 5325 25 industries industry NNS 42759 5325 26 in in IN 42759 5325 27 which which WDT 42759 5325 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5325 29 is be VBZ 42759 5325 30 operative operative JJ 42759 5325 31 , , , 42759 5325 32 and and CC 42759 5325 33 that that IN 42759 5325 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5325 35 has have VBZ 42759 5325 36 neither neither CC 42759 5325 37 thrown throw VBN 42759 5325 38 any any DT 42759 5325 39 important important JJ 42759 5325 40 number number NN 42759 5325 41 of of IN 42759 5325 42 workers worker NNS 42759 5325 43 out out IN 42759 5325 44 of of IN 42759 5325 45 employment employment NN 42759 5325 46 nor nor CC 42759 5325 47 forced force VBD 42759 5325 48 any any DT 42759 5325 49 important important JJ 42759 5325 50 concern concern NN 42759 5325 51 out out IN 42759 5325 52 of of IN 42759 5325 53 business business NN 42759 5325 54 . . . 42759 5326 1 Speaking speak VBG 42759 5326 2 of of IN 42759 5326 3 the the DT 42759 5326 4 three three CD 42759 5326 5 leading lead VBG 42759 5326 6 industries industry NNS 42759 5326 7 in in IN 42759 5326 8 which which WDT 42759 5326 9 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5326 10 wages wage NNS 42759 5326 11 were be VBD 42759 5326 12 first first RB 42759 5326 13 established establish VBN 42759 5326 14 in in IN 42759 5326 15 Washington Washington NNP 42759 5326 16 , , , 42759 5326 17 the the DT 42759 5326 18 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 5326 19 Welfare Welfare NNP 42759 5326 20 Commission Commission NNP 42759 5326 21 of of IN 42759 5326 22 that that DT 42759 5326 23 state state NN 42759 5326 24 testifies testify VBZ 42759 5326 25 : : : 42759 5326 26 " " `` 42759 5326 27 Seldom seldom RB 42759 5326 28 has have VBZ 42759 5326 29 any any DT 42759 5326 30 piece piece NN 42759 5326 31 of of IN 42759 5326 32 legislation legislation NN 42759 5326 33 , , , 42759 5326 34 in in IN 42759 5326 35 prospect prospect NNP 42759 5326 36 , , , 42759 5326 37 engendered engender VBD 42759 5326 38 so so RB 42759 5326 39 much much JJ 42759 5326 40 discussion discussion NN 42759 5326 41 and and CC 42759 5326 42 so so RB 42759 5326 43 much much JJ 42759 5326 44 criticism criticism NN 42759 5326 45 , , , 42759 5326 46 as as IN 42759 5326 47 did do VBD 42759 5326 48 the the DT 42759 5326 49 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5326 50 wage wage NN 42759 5326 51 law law NN 42759 5326 52 , , , 42759 5326 53 with with IN 42759 5326 54 the the DT 42759 5326 55 intricacies intricacy NNS 42759 5326 56 of of IN 42759 5326 57 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5326 58 ramifications ramification NNS 42759 5326 59 touching touch VBG 42759 5326 60 almost almost RB 42759 5326 61 every every DT 42759 5326 62 industry industry NN 42759 5326 63 in in IN 42759 5326 64 the the DT 42759 5326 65 state state NN 42759 5326 66 , , , 42759 5326 67 large large JJ 42759 5326 68 or or CC 42759 5326 69 small small JJ 42759 5326 70 , , , 42759 5326 71 and and CC 42759 5326 72 the the DT 42759 5326 73 family family NN 42759 5326 74 of of IN 42759 5326 75 nearly nearly RB 42759 5326 76 every every DT 42759 5326 77 wage wage NN 42759 5326 78 earner earner NN 42759 5326 79 ; ; : 42759 5326 80 seldom seldom RB 42759 5326 81 , , , 42759 5326 82 too too RB 42759 5326 83 , , , 42759 5326 84 has have VBZ 42759 5326 85 any any DT 42759 5326 86 law law NN 42759 5326 87 , , , 42759 5326 88 in in IN 42759 5326 89 actuality actuality NN 42759 5326 90 , , , 42759 5326 91 been be VBN 42759 5326 92 so so RB 42759 5326 93 well well RB 42759 5326 94 received receive VBN 42759 5326 95 , , , 42759 5326 96 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5326 97 application application NN 42759 5326 98 been be VBN 42759 5326 99 accomplished accomplish VBN 42759 5326 100 with with IN 42759 5326 101 so so RB 42759 5326 102 little little JJ 42759 5326 103 open open JJ 42759 5326 104 opposition opposition NN 42759 5326 105 , , , 42759 5326 106 and and CC 42759 5326 107 , , , 42759 5326 108 for for IN 42759 5326 109 a a DT 42759 5326 110 law law NN 42759 5326 111 of of IN 42759 5326 112 this this DT 42759 5326 113 character character NN 42759 5326 114 , , , 42759 5326 115 has have VBZ 42759 5326 116 been be VBN 42759 5326 117 attended attend VBN 42759 5326 118 with with IN 42759 5326 119 so so RB 42759 5326 120 little little JJ 42759 5326 121 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5326 122 disturbance disturbance NN 42759 5326 123 as as IN 42759 5326 124 that that DT 42759 5326 125 same same JJ 42759 5326 126 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5326 127 wage wage NN 42759 5326 128 law law NN 42759 5326 129 . . . 42759 5327 1 None none NN 42759 5327 2 of of IN 42759 5327 3 the the DT 42759 5327 4 dire dire JJ 42759 5327 5 predictions prediction NNS 42759 5327 6 made make VBN 42759 5327 7 prior prior RB 42759 5327 8 to to IN 42759 5327 9 the the DT 42759 5327 10 passage passage NN 42759 5327 11 of of IN 42759 5327 12 the the DT 42759 5327 13 law law NN 42759 5327 14 have have VBP 42759 5327 15 come come VBN 42759 5327 16 about about RP 42759 5327 17 to to IN 42759 5327 18 an an DT 42759 5327 19 extent extent NN 42759 5327 20 that that WDT 42759 5327 21 questions question VBZ 42759 5327 22 the the DT 42759 5327 23 general general JJ 42759 5327 24 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5327 25 of of IN 42759 5327 26 the the DT 42759 5327 27 law law NN 42759 5327 28 . . . 42759 5328 1 There there EX 42759 5328 2 has have VBZ 42759 5328 3 been be VBN 42759 5328 4 no no DT 42759 5328 5 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 5328 6 discharge discharge NN 42759 5328 7 of of IN 42759 5328 8 women woman NNS 42759 5328 9 employés employés NNP 42759 5328 10 , , , 42759 5328 11 no no DT 42759 5328 12 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 5328 13 levelling levelling NN 42759 5328 14 of of IN 42759 5328 15 wages wage NNS 42759 5328 16 , , , 42759 5328 17 no no DT 42759 5328 18 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 5328 19 replacing replacing NN 42759 5328 20 of of IN 42759 5328 21 higher high JJR 42759 5328 22 paid pay VBN 42759 5328 23 workers worker NNS 42759 5328 24 by by IN 42759 5328 25 cheaper cheap JJR 42759 5328 26 help help NN 42759 5328 27 , , , 42759 5328 28 no no DT 42759 5328 29 tendency tendency NN 42759 5328 30 to to TO 42759 5328 31 make make VB 42759 5328 32 the the DT 42759 5328 33 minimum minimum NN 42759 5328 34 the the DT 42759 5328 35 maximum maximum NN 42759 5328 36 , , , 42759 5328 37 while while IN 42759 5328 38 the the DT 42759 5328 39 employers employer NNS 42759 5328 40 of of IN 42759 5328 41 the the DT 42759 5328 42 state state NN 42759 5328 43 in in IN 42759 5328 44 general general JJ 42759 5328 45 have have VBP 42759 5328 46 been be VBN 42759 5328 47 following follow VBG 42759 5328 48 the the DT 42759 5328 49 letter letter NN 42759 5328 50 and and CC 42759 5328 51 spirit spirit NN 42759 5328 52 of of IN 42759 5328 53 the the DT 42759 5328 54 law law NN 42759 5328 55 , , , 42759 5328 56 and and CC 42759 5328 57 aiding aid VBG 42759 5328 58 greatly greatly RB 42759 5328 59 in in IN 42759 5328 60 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5328 61 application application NN 42759 5328 62 .... .... . 42759 5329 1 The the DT 42759 5329 2 law law NN 42759 5329 3 , , , 42759 5329 4 in in IN 42759 5329 5 other other JJ 42759 5329 6 words word NNS 42759 5329 7 , , , 42759 5329 8 has have VBZ 42759 5329 9 advanced advance VBN 42759 5329 10 the the DT 42759 5329 11 wages wage NNS 42759 5329 12 of of IN 42759 5329 13 practically practically RB 42759 5329 14 sixty sixty CD 42759 5329 15 per per IN 42759 5329 16 cent cent NN 42759 5329 17 . . . 42759 5330 1 of of IN 42759 5330 2 the the DT 42759 5330 3 workers worker NNS 42759 5330 4 in in IN 42759 5330 5 these these DT 42759 5330 6 industries industry NNS 42759 5330 7 , , , 42759 5330 8 and and CC 42759 5330 9 has have VBZ 42759 5330 10 done do VBN 42759 5330 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5330 12 without without IN 42759 5330 13 serious serious JJ 42759 5330 14 opposition opposition NN 42759 5330 15 at at IN 42759 5330 16 a a DT 42759 5330 17 time time NN 42759 5330 18 when when WRB 42759 5330 19 business business NN 42759 5330 20 conditions condition NNS 42759 5330 21 were be VBD 42759 5330 22 none none NN 42759 5330 23 too too RB 42759 5330 24 good good JJ 42759 5330 25 . . . 42759 5331 1 " " `` 42759 5331 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5331 3 253 253 CD 42759 5331 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5331 5 The the DT 42759 5331 6 Bureau Bureau NNP 42759 5331 7 of of IN 42759 5331 8 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5331 9 Statistics Statistics NNPS 42759 5331 10 of of IN 42759 5331 11 the the DT 42759 5331 12 United United NNP 42759 5331 13 States States NNP 42759 5331 14 investigated investigate VBD 42759 5331 15 the the DT 42759 5331 16 operation operation NN 42759 5331 17 of of IN 42759 5331 18 the the DT 42759 5331 19 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5331 20 wage wage NN 42759 5331 21 in in IN 42759 5331 22 the the DT 42759 5331 23 mercantile mercantile JJ 42759 5331 24 establishments establishment NNS 42759 5331 25 of of IN 42759 5331 26 Oregon Oregon NNP 42759 5331 27 at at IN 42759 5331 28 the the DT 42759 5331 29 end end NN 42759 5331 30 of of IN 42759 5331 31 the the DT 42759 5331 32 first first JJ 42759 5331 33 year year NN 42759 5331 34 . . . 42759 5332 1 The the DT 42759 5332 2 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 5332 3 of of IN 42759 5332 4 the the DT 42759 5332 5 investigators investigator NNS 42759 5332 6 were be VBD 42759 5332 7 in in IN 42759 5332 8 brief brief NN 42759 5332 9 that that IN 42759 5332 10 both both CC 42759 5332 11 the the DT 42759 5332 12 number number NN 42759 5332 13 and and CC 42759 5332 14 the the DT 42759 5332 15 proportion proportion NN 42759 5332 16 of of IN 42759 5332 17 women woman NNS 42759 5332 18 getting get VBG 42759 5332 19 the the DT 42759 5332 20 legal legal JJ 42759 5332 21 minimum minimum NN 42759 5332 22 ( ( -LRB- 42759 5332 23 $ $ $ 42759 5332 24 9.25 9.25 CD 42759 5332 25 per per IN 42759 5332 26 week week NN 42759 5332 27 ) ) -RRB- 42759 5332 28 for for IN 42759 5332 29 adults adult NNS 42759 5332 30 had have VBD 42759 5332 31 increased increase VBN 42759 5332 32 , , , 42759 5332 33 that that IN 42759 5332 34 the the DT 42759 5332 35 proportion proportion NN 42759 5332 36 obtaining obtain VBG 42759 5332 37 more more JJR 42759 5332 38 than than IN 42759 5332 39 this this DT 42759 5332 40 rate rate NN 42759 5332 41 had have VBD 42759 5332 42 likewise likewise RB 42759 5332 43 increased increase VBN 42759 5332 44 , , , 42759 5332 45 that that IN 42759 5332 46 those those DT 42759 5332 47 who who WP 42759 5332 48 had have VBD 42759 5332 49 received receive VBN 42759 5332 50 a a DT 42759 5332 51 rise rise NN 42759 5332 52 in in IN 42759 5332 53 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5332 54 did do VBD 42759 5332 55 not not RB 42759 5332 56 show show VB 42759 5332 57 any any DT 42759 5332 58 decline decline NN 42759 5332 59 in in IN 42759 5332 60 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5332 61 , , , 42759 5332 62 that that IN 42759 5332 63 women woman NNS 42759 5332 64 had have VBD 42759 5332 65 not not RB 42759 5332 66 been be VBN 42759 5332 67 displaced displace VBN 42759 5332 68 by by IN 42759 5332 69 men man NNS 42759 5332 70 , , , 42759 5332 71 and and CC 42759 5332 72 that that IN 42759 5332 73 the the DT 42759 5332 74 average average JJ 42759 5332 75 increase increase NN 42759 5332 76 in in IN 42759 5332 77 the the DT 42759 5332 78 labour labour JJ 42759 5332 79 cost cost NN 42759 5332 80 resulting result VBG 42759 5332 81 from from IN 42759 5332 82 the the DT 42759 5332 83 advance advance NN 42759 5332 84 in in IN 42759 5332 85 wages wage NNS 42759 5332 86 was be VBD 42759 5332 87 only only RB 42759 5332 88 three three CD 42759 5332 89 mills mill NNS 42759 5332 90 on on IN 42759 5332 91 each each DT 42759 5332 92 dollar dollar NN 42759 5332 93 of of IN 42759 5332 94 sales sale NNS 42759 5332 95 . . . 42759 5333 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5333 2 254 254 CD 42759 5333 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5333 4 The the DT 42759 5333 5 effects effect NNS 42759 5333 6 of of IN 42759 5333 7 the the DT 42759 5333 8 Utah Utah NNP 42759 5333 9 law law NN 42759 5333 10 during during IN 42759 5333 11 the the DT 42759 5333 12 first first JJ 42759 5333 13 year year NN 42759 5333 14 of of IN 42759 5333 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5333 16 operation operation NN 42759 5333 17 were be VBD 42759 5333 18 summarised summarise VBN 42759 5333 19 by by IN 42759 5333 20 the the DT 42759 5333 21 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5333 22 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 5333 23 , , , 42759 5333 24 Mr. Mr. NNP 42759 5333 25 H. H. NNP 42759 5333 26 T. T. NNP 42759 5333 27 Haines Haines NNP 42759 5333 28 , , , 42759 5333 29 as as IN 42759 5333 30 follows follow VBZ 42759 5333 31 : : : 42759 5333 32 a a DT 42759 5333 33 rise rise NN 42759 5333 34 in in IN 42759 5333 35 the the DT 42759 5333 36 wages wage NNS 42759 5333 37 of of IN 42759 5333 38 a a DT 42759 5333 39 " " `` 42759 5333 40 number number NN 42759 5333 41 of of IN 42759 5333 42 women woman NNS 42759 5333 43 and and CC 42759 5333 44 girls girl NNS 42759 5333 45 who who WP 42759 5333 46 most most RBS 42759 5333 47 needed need VBD 42759 5333 48 the the DT 42759 5333 49 additional additional JJ 42759 5333 50 sums sum NNS 42759 5333 51 of of IN 42759 5333 52 money money NN 42759 5333 53 " " '' 42759 5333 54 ; ; , 42759 5333 55 increased increase VBN 42759 5333 56 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5333 57 of of IN 42759 5333 58 female female JJ 42759 5333 59 workers worker NNS 42759 5333 60 admitted admit VBN 42759 5333 61 by by IN 42759 5333 62 most most JJS 42759 5333 63 employers employer NNS 42759 5333 64 ; ; : 42759 5333 65 but but CC 42759 5333 66 few few JJ 42759 5333 67 cases case NNS 42759 5333 68 of of IN 42759 5333 69 women woman NNS 42759 5333 70 or or CC 42759 5333 71 girls girl NNS 42759 5333 72 utterly utterly RB 42759 5333 73 deprived deprive VBN 42759 5333 74 of of IN 42759 5333 75 employment employment NN 42759 5333 76 by by IN 42759 5333 77 the the DT 42759 5333 78 law law NN 42759 5333 79 ; ; : 42759 5333 80 none none NN 42759 5333 81 of of IN 42759 5333 82 the the DT 42759 5333 83 higher high JJR 42759 5333 84 paid pay VBN 42759 5333 85 women woman NNS 42759 5333 86 suffered suffer VBD 42759 5333 87 a a DT 42759 5333 88 reduction reduction NN 42759 5333 89 in in IN 42759 5333 90 wages wage NNS 42759 5333 91 ; ; : 42759 5333 92 and and CC 42759 5333 93 ninety ninety CD 42759 5333 94 per per IN 42759 5333 95 cent cent NN 42759 5333 96 . . . 42759 5334 1 of of IN 42759 5334 2 the the DT 42759 5334 3 employers employer NNS 42759 5334 4 are be VBP 42759 5334 5 satisfied satisfied JJ 42759 5334 6 with with IN 42759 5334 7 the the DT 42759 5334 8 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5334 9 wage wage NN 42759 5334 10 statute statute NN 42759 5334 11 . . . 42759 5335 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5335 2 255 255 CD 42759 5335 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5335 4 So so RB 42759 5335 5 far far RB 42759 5335 6 as as IN 42759 5335 7 the the DT 42759 5335 8 law law NN 42759 5335 9 has have VBZ 42759 5335 10 been be VBN 42759 5335 11 applied apply VBN 42759 5335 12 in in IN 42759 5335 13 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 42759 5335 14 , , , 42759 5335 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5335 16 seems seem VBZ 42759 5335 17 to to TO 42759 5335 18 be be VB 42759 5335 19 relatively relatively RB 42759 5335 20 as as RB 42759 5335 21 successful successful JJ 42759 5335 22 as as IN 42759 5335 23 in in IN 42759 5335 24 the the DT 42759 5335 25 other other JJ 42759 5335 26 three three CD 42759 5335 27 states state NNS 42759 5335 28 . . . 42759 5336 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5336 2 256 256 CD 42759 5336 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5336 4 _ _ NNP 42759 5336 5 The the DT 42759 5336 6 Question Question NNP 42759 5336 7 of of IN 42759 5336 8 Constitutionality Constitutionality NNP 42759 5336 9 _ _ NNP 42759 5336 10 The the DT 42759 5336 11 principal principal JJ 42759 5336 12 reason reason NN 42759 5336 13 why why WRB 42759 5336 14 the the DT 42759 5336 15 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5336 16 wage wage NN 42759 5336 17 laws law NNS 42759 5336 18 on on IN 42759 5336 19 the the DT 42759 5336 20 statute statute NN 42759 5336 21 books book NNS 42759 5336 22 of of IN 42759 5336 23 the the DT 42759 5336 24 other other JJ 42759 5336 25 seven seven CD 42759 5336 26 states state NNS 42759 5336 27 have have VBP 42759 5336 28 not not RB 42759 5336 29 been be VBN 42759 5336 30 carried carry VBN 42759 5336 31 into into IN 42759 5336 32 effect effect NN 42759 5336 33 , , , 42759 5336 34 is be VBZ 42759 5336 35 the the DT 42759 5336 36 uncertainty uncertainty NN 42759 5336 37 of of IN 42759 5336 38 the the DT 42759 5336 39 validity validity NN 42759 5336 40 of of IN 42759 5336 41 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5336 42 wage wage NN 42759 5336 43 legislation legislation NN 42759 5336 44 in in IN 42759 5336 45 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5336 46 constitutional constitutional JJ 42759 5336 47 system system NN 42759 5336 48 . . . 42759 5337 1 In in IN 42759 5337 2 November November NNP 42759 5337 3 , , , 42759 5337 4 1914 1914 CD 42759 5337 5 , , , 42759 5337 6 a a DT 42759 5337 7 district district NN 42759 5337 8 judge judge NN 42759 5337 9 granted grant VBD 42759 5337 10 a a DT 42759 5337 11 writ writ NN 42759 5337 12 of of IN 42759 5337 13 injunction injunction NN 42759 5337 14 , , , 42759 5337 15 restraining restrain VBG 42759 5337 16 the the DT 42759 5337 17 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 5337 18 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5337 19 Commission Commission NNP 42759 5337 20 of of IN 42759 5337 21 Minnesota Minnesota NNP 42759 5337 22 from from IN 42759 5337 23 enforcing enforce VBG 42759 5337 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5337 25 wage wage NN 42759 5337 26 determinations determination NNS 42759 5337 27 , , , 42759 5337 28 on on IN 42759 5337 29 the the DT 42759 5337 30 ground ground NN 42759 5337 31 that that IN 42759 5337 32 the the DT 42759 5337 33 law law NN 42759 5337 34 attempted attempt VBD 42759 5337 35 to to TO 42759 5337 36 delegate delegate VB 42759 5337 37 legislative legislative JJ 42759 5337 38 power power NN 42759 5337 39 , , , 42759 5337 40 and and CC 42759 5337 41 that that IN 42759 5337 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5337 43 provisions provision NNS 42759 5337 44 violated violate VBD 42759 5337 45 that that IN 42759 5337 46 section section NN 42759 5337 47 of of IN 42759 5337 48 the the DT 42759 5337 49 fourteenth fourteenth NNP 42759 5337 50 amendment amendment NN 42759 5337 51 to to IN 42759 5337 52 the the DT 42759 5337 53 United United NNP 42759 5337 54 States States NNP 42759 5337 55 Constitution Constitution NNP 42759 5337 56 which which WDT 42759 5337 57 forbids forbid VBZ 42759 5337 58 any any DT 42759 5337 59 state state NN 42759 5337 60 to to TO 42759 5337 61 deprive deprive VB 42759 5337 62 a a DT 42759 5337 63 person person NN 42759 5337 64 of of IN 42759 5337 65 life life NN 42759 5337 66 , , , 42759 5337 67 liberty liberty NN 42759 5337 68 , , , 42759 5337 69 or or CC 42759 5337 70 property property NN 42759 5337 71 without without IN 42759 5337 72 due due JJ 42759 5337 73 process process NN 42759 5337 74 of of IN 42759 5337 75 law law NN 42759 5337 76 . . . 42759 5338 1 One one CD 42759 5338 2 of of IN 42759 5338 3 the the DT 42759 5338 4 courts court NNS 42759 5338 5 of of IN 42759 5338 6 Arkansas Arkansas NNP 42759 5338 7 has have VBZ 42759 5338 8 taken take VBN 42759 5338 9 substantially substantially RB 42759 5338 10 the the DT 42759 5338 11 same same JJ 42759 5338 12 position position NN 42759 5338 13 . . . 42759 5339 1 The the DT 42759 5339 2 second second JJ 42759 5339 3 objection objection NN 42759 5339 4 urged urge VBN 42759 5339 5 by by IN 42759 5339 6 the the DT 42759 5339 7 Minnesota Minnesota NNP 42759 5339 8 judge judge NN 42759 5339 9 is be VBZ 42759 5339 10 probably probably RB 42759 5339 11 much much RB 42759 5339 12 the the DT 42759 5339 13 more more RBR 42759 5339 14 serious serious JJ 42759 5339 15 of of IN 42759 5339 16 the the DT 42759 5339 17 two two CD 42759 5339 18 , , , 42759 5339 19 and and CC 42759 5339 20 is be VBZ 42759 5339 21 the the DT 42759 5339 22 one one NN 42759 5339 23 upon upon IN 42759 5339 24 which which WDT 42759 5339 25 chief chief JJ 42759 5339 26 emphasis emphasis NN 42759 5339 27 has have VBZ 42759 5339 28 been be VBN 42759 5339 29 laid lay VBN 42759 5339 30 in in IN 42759 5339 31 the the DT 42759 5339 32 briefs brief NNS 42759 5339 33 filed file VBN 42759 5339 34 in in IN 42759 5339 35 various various JJ 42759 5339 36 courts court NNS 42759 5339 37 by by IN 42759 5339 38 the the DT 42759 5339 39 opponents opponent NNS 42759 5339 40 of of IN 42759 5339 41 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5339 42 wage wage NN 42759 5339 43 legislation legislation NN 42759 5339 44 . . . 42759 5340 1 As as IN 42759 5340 2 regards regard VBZ 42759 5340 3 labour labour JJ 42759 5340 4 legislation legislation NN 42759 5340 5 , , , 42759 5340 6 " " '' 42759 5340 7 due due JJ 42759 5340 8 process process NN 42759 5340 9 of of IN 42759 5340 10 law law NN 42759 5340 11 " " '' 42759 5340 12 may may MD 42759 5340 13 be be VB 42759 5340 14 practically practically RB 42759 5340 15 translated translate VBN 42759 5340 16 , , , 42759 5340 17 " " `` 42759 5340 18 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5340 19 and and CC 42759 5340 20 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5340 21 exercise exercise NN 42759 5340 22 of of IN 42759 5340 23 the the DT 42759 5340 24 State State NNP 42759 5340 25 's 's POS 42759 5340 26 police police NN 42759 5340 27 power power NN 42759 5340 28 . . . 42759 5340 29 " " '' 42759 5341 1 And and CC 42759 5341 2 the the DT 42759 5341 3 police police NN 42759 5341 4 power power NN 42759 5341 5 means mean VBZ 42759 5341 6 that that IN 42759 5341 7 indefinite indefinite JJ 42759 5341 8 power power NN 42759 5341 9 of of IN 42759 5341 10 the the DT 42759 5341 11 State State NNP 42759 5341 12 to to TO 42759 5341 13 legislate legislate VB 42759 5341 14 for for IN 42759 5341 15 the the DT 42759 5341 16 health health NN 42759 5341 17 , , , 42759 5341 18 safety safety NN 42759 5341 19 , , , 42759 5341 20 morals moral NNS 42759 5341 21 , , , 42759 5341 22 and and CC 42759 5341 23 welfare welfare NN 42759 5341 24 of of IN 42759 5341 25 the the DT 42759 5341 26 community community NN 42759 5341 27 . . . 42759 5342 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5342 2 257 257 CD 42759 5342 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5342 4 Now now RB 42759 5342 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5342 6 is be VBZ 42759 5342 7 obvious obvious JJ 42759 5342 8 that that IN 42759 5342 9 a a DT 42759 5342 10 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5342 11 wage wage NN 42759 5342 12 law law NN 42759 5342 13 deprives deprive VBZ 42759 5342 14 both both DT 42759 5342 15 employer employer NN 42759 5342 16 and and CC 42759 5342 17 employé employé NNS 42759 5342 18 of of IN 42759 5342 19 some some DT 42759 5342 20 liberty liberty NN 42759 5342 21 of of IN 42759 5342 22 contract contract NN 42759 5342 23 , , , 42759 5342 24 and and CC 42759 5342 25 also also RB 42759 5342 26 that that IN 42759 5342 27 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5342 28 virtually virtually RB 42759 5342 29 deprives deprive VBZ 42759 5342 30 the the DT 42759 5342 31 former former JJ 42759 5342 32 of of IN 42759 5342 33 some some DT 42759 5342 34 property property NN 42759 5342 35 , , , 42759 5342 36 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 5342 37 as as IN 42759 5342 38 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5342 39 generally generally RB 42759 5342 40 increases increase VBZ 42759 5342 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5342 42 outlay outlay NN 42759 5342 43 for for IN 42759 5342 44 wages wage NNS 42759 5342 45 . . . 42759 5343 1 On on IN 42759 5343 2 the the DT 42759 5343 3 other other JJ 42759 5343 4 hand hand NN 42759 5343 5 , , , 42759 5343 6 this this DT 42759 5343 7 restriction restriction NN 42759 5343 8 of of IN 42759 5343 9 liberty liberty NN 42759 5343 10 and and CC 42759 5343 11 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 5343 12 diminution diminution NN 42759 5343 13 of of IN 42759 5343 14 property property NN 42759 5343 15 seem seem VBP 42759 5343 16 to to TO 42759 5343 17 be be VB 42759 5343 18 carried carry VBN 42759 5343 19 out out RP 42759 5343 20 in in IN 42759 5343 21 harmony harmony NN 42759 5343 22 with with IN 42759 5343 23 due due JJ 42759 5343 24 process process NN 42759 5343 25 of of IN 42759 5343 26 law law NN 42759 5343 27 , , , 42759 5343 28 since since IN 42759 5343 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5343 30 constitute constitute VBP 42759 5343 31 an an DT 42759 5343 32 exercise exercise NN 42759 5343 33 of of IN 42759 5343 34 the the DT 42759 5343 35 police police NN 42759 5343 36 power power NN 42759 5343 37 of of IN 42759 5343 38 the the DT 42759 5343 39 State State NNP 42759 5343 40 on on IN 42759 5343 41 behalf behalf NN 42759 5343 42 of of IN 42759 5343 43 the the DT 42759 5343 44 general general JJ 42759 5343 45 welfare welfare NN 42759 5343 46 . . . 42759 5344 1 Some some DT 42759 5344 2 months month NNS 42759 5344 3 before before IN 42759 5344 4 the the DT 42759 5344 5 Minnesota Minnesota NNP 42759 5344 6 judge judge NN 42759 5344 7 granted grant VBD 42759 5344 8 the the DT 42759 5344 9 writ writ NN 42759 5344 10 of of IN 42759 5344 11 injunction injunction NN 42759 5344 12 against against IN 42759 5344 13 the the DT 42759 5344 14 enforcement enforcement NN 42759 5344 15 of of IN 42759 5344 16 the the DT 42759 5344 17 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5344 18 wage wage NN 42759 5344 19 law law NN 42759 5344 20 of of IN 42759 5344 21 that that DT 42759 5344 22 state state NN 42759 5344 23 , , , 42759 5344 24 a a DT 42759 5344 25 lower low JJR 42759 5344 26 court court NN 42759 5344 27 and and CC 42759 5344 28 the the DT 42759 5344 29 Supreme Supreme NNP 42759 5344 30 Court Court NNP 42759 5344 31 of of IN 42759 5344 32 Oregon Oregon NNP 42759 5344 33 had have VBD 42759 5344 34 pronounced pronounce VBN 42759 5344 35 the the DT 42759 5344 36 Oregon Oregon NNP 42759 5344 37 statute statute NN 42759 5344 38 constitutional constitutional JJ 42759 5344 39 , , , 42759 5344 40 as as IN 42759 5344 41 a a DT 42759 5344 42 legitimate legitimate JJ 42759 5344 43 exercise exercise NN 42759 5344 44 of of IN 42759 5344 45 the the DT 42759 5344 46 police police NN 42759 5344 47 power power NN 42759 5344 48 . . . 42759 5345 1 An an DT 42759 5345 2 appeal appeal NN 42759 5345 3 from from IN 42759 5345 4 this this DT 42759 5345 5 judgment judgment NN 42759 5345 6 was be VBD 42759 5345 7 argued argue VBN 42759 5345 8 in in IN 42759 5345 9 the the DT 42759 5345 10 Supreme Supreme NNP 42759 5345 11 Court Court NNP 42759 5345 12 of of IN 42759 5345 13 the the DT 42759 5345 14 United United NNP 42759 5345 15 States States NNP 42759 5345 16 , , , 42759 5345 17 Dec. December NNP 42759 5345 18 17 17 CD 42759 5345 19 , , , 42759 5345 20 1914 1914 CD 42759 5345 21 , , , 42759 5345 22 but but CC 42759 5345 23 no no DT 42759 5345 24 decision decision NN 42759 5345 25 has have VBZ 42759 5345 26 yet yet RB 42759 5345 27 ( ( -LRB- 42759 5345 28 October October NNP 42759 5345 29 , , , 42759 5345 30 1916 1916 CD 42759 5345 31 ) ) -RRB- 42759 5345 32 been be VBN 42759 5345 33 rendered render VBN 42759 5345 34 . . . 42759 5346 1 Until until IN 42759 5346 2 the the DT 42759 5346 3 highest high JJS 42759 5346 4 court court NN 42759 5346 5 has have VBZ 42759 5346 6 spoken speak VBN 42759 5346 7 on on IN 42759 5346 8 the the DT 42759 5346 9 question question NN 42759 5346 10 of of IN 42759 5346 11 constitutionality constitutionality NN 42759 5346 12 , , , 42759 5346 13 no no DT 42759 5346 14 state state NN 42759 5346 15 is be VBZ 42759 5346 16 likely likely JJ 42759 5346 17 to to TO 42759 5346 18 take take VB 42759 5346 19 any any DT 42759 5346 20 further further JJ 42759 5346 21 step step NN 42759 5346 22 toward toward IN 42759 5346 23 establishing establish VBG 42759 5346 24 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5346 25 wages wage NNS 42759 5346 26 . . . 42759 5347 1 Should Should MD 42759 5347 2 the the DT 42759 5347 3 decision decision NN 42759 5347 4 of of IN 42759 5347 5 the the DT 42759 5347 6 Supreme Supreme NNP 42759 5347 7 Court Court NNP 42759 5347 8 be be VB 42759 5347 9 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 42759 5347 10 valid valid JJ 42759 5347 11 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5347 12 wage wage NN 42759 5347 13 legislation legislation NN 42759 5347 14 will will MD 42759 5347 15 be be VB 42759 5347 16 impossible impossible JJ 42759 5347 17 without without IN 42759 5347 18 an an DT 42759 5347 19 amendment amendment NN 42759 5347 20 of of IN 42759 5347 21 the the DT 42759 5347 22 United United NNP 42759 5347 23 States States NNP 42759 5347 24 Constitution Constitution NNP 42759 5347 25 . . . 42759 5348 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5348 2 258 258 CD 42759 5348 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5348 4 _ _ NNP 42759 5348 5 The the DT 42759 5348 6 Ethical Ethical NNP 42759 5348 7 and and CC 42759 5348 8 Political Political NNP 42759 5348 9 Aspects Aspects NNPS 42759 5348 10 _ _ IN 42759 5348 11 Whether whether IN 42759 5348 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5348 13 be be VB 42759 5348 14 considered consider VBN 42759 5348 15 from from IN 42759 5348 16 the the DT 42759 5348 17 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 5348 18 of of IN 42759 5348 19 ethics ethic NNS 42759 5348 20 , , , 42759 5348 21 politics politic NNS 42759 5348 22 , , , 42759 5348 23 or or CC 42759 5348 24 economics economics NN 42759 5348 25 , , , 42759 5348 26 the the DT 42759 5348 27 principle principle NN 42759 5348 28 of of IN 42759 5348 29 the the DT 42759 5348 30 legal legal JJ 42759 5348 31 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5348 32 wage wage NN 42759 5348 33 is be VBZ 42759 5348 34 impregnable impregnable JJ 42759 5348 35 . . . 42759 5349 1 The the DT 42759 5349 2 State State NNP 42759 5349 3 has have VBZ 42759 5349 4 not not RB 42759 5349 5 only only RB 42759 5349 6 the the DT 42759 5349 7 moral moral JJ 42759 5349 8 right right NN 42759 5349 9 but but CC 42759 5349 10 the the DT 42759 5349 11 moral moral JJ 42759 5349 12 duty duty NN 42759 5349 13 to to TO 42759 5349 14 enact enact VB 42759 5349 15 legislation legislation NN 42759 5349 16 of of IN 42759 5349 17 this this DT 42759 5349 18 sort sort NN 42759 5349 19 , , , 42759 5349 20 whenever whenever WRB 42759 5349 21 any any DT 42759 5349 22 important important JJ 42759 5349 23 group group NN 42759 5349 24 of of IN 42759 5349 25 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5349 26 are be VBP 42759 5349 27 receiving receive VBG 42759 5349 28 less less RBR 42759 5349 29 than than IN 42759 5349 30 living live VBG 42759 5349 31 wages wage NNS 42759 5349 32 . . . 42759 5350 1 One one CD 42759 5350 2 of of IN 42759 5350 3 the the DT 42759 5350 4 elementary elementary JJ 42759 5350 5 functions function NNS 42759 5350 6 and and CC 42759 5350 7 obligations obligation NNS 42759 5350 8 of of IN 42759 5350 9 the the DT 42759 5350 10 State State NNP 42759 5350 11 is be VBZ 42759 5350 12 to to TO 42759 5350 13 protect protect VB 42759 5350 14 citizens citizen NNS 42759 5350 15 in in IN 42759 5350 16 the the DT 42759 5350 17 enjoyment enjoyment NN 42759 5350 18 of of IN 42759 5350 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5350 20 natural natural JJ 42759 5350 21 rights right NNS 42759 5350 22 ; ; : 42759 5350 23 and and CC 42759 5350 24 the the DT 42759 5350 25 claim claim NN 42759 5350 26 to to IN 42759 5350 27 a a DT 42759 5350 28 living living NN 42759 5350 29 wage wage NN 42759 5350 30 is be VBZ 42759 5350 31 , , , 42759 5350 32 as as IN 42759 5350 33 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5350 34 have have VBP 42759 5350 35 seen see VBN 42759 5350 36 , , , 42759 5350 37 one one CD 42759 5350 38 of of IN 42759 5350 39 the the DT 42759 5350 40 natural natural JJ 42759 5350 41 rights right NNS 42759 5350 42 of of IN 42759 5350 43 the the DT 42759 5350 44 person person NN 42759 5350 45 whose whose WP$ 42759 5350 46 wages wage NNS 42759 5350 47 are be VBP 42759 5350 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5350 49 only only JJ 42759 5350 50 means mean NNS 42759 5350 51 of of IN 42759 5350 52 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5350 53 . . . 42759 5351 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 5351 2 , , , 42759 5351 3 the the DT 42759 5351 4 establishment establishment NN 42759 5351 5 of of IN 42759 5351 6 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5351 7 living living NN 42759 5351 8 wages wage NNS 42759 5351 9 is be VBZ 42759 5351 10 not not RB 42759 5351 11 among among IN 42759 5351 12 the the DT 42759 5351 13 so so RB 42759 5351 14 - - HYPH 42759 5351 15 called call VBN 42759 5351 16 " " `` 42759 5351 17 optional optional JJ 42759 5351 18 functions function NNS 42759 5351 19 " " '' 42759 5351 20 of of IN 42759 5351 21 the the DT 42759 5351 22 State State NNP 42759 5351 23 in in IN 42759 5351 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5351 25 present present JJ 42759 5351 26 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5351 27 society society NN 42759 5351 28 . . . 42759 5352 1 Whenever whenever WRB 42759 5352 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5352 3 can can MD 42759 5352 4 be be VB 42759 5352 5 successfully successfully RB 42759 5352 6 performed perform VBN 42759 5352 7 , , , 42759 5352 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5352 9 is be VBZ 42759 5352 10 a a DT 42759 5352 11 primary primary JJ 42759 5352 12 and and CC 42759 5352 13 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5352 14 function function NN 42759 5352 15 . . . 42759 5353 1 So so RB 42759 5353 2 far far RB 42759 5353 3 as as IN 42759 5353 4 political political JJ 42759 5353 5 propriety propriety NN 42759 5353 6 is be VBZ 42759 5353 7 concerned concern VBN 42759 5353 8 , , , 42759 5353 9 the the DT 42759 5353 10 State State NNP 42759 5353 11 may may MD 42759 5353 12 as as RB 42759 5353 13 reasonably reasonably RB 42759 5353 14 be be VB 42759 5353 15 expected expect VBN 42759 5353 16 to to TO 42759 5353 17 protect protect VB 42759 5353 18 the the DT 42759 5353 19 citizen citizen NN 42759 5353 20 against against IN 42759 5353 21 the the DT 42759 5353 22 physical physical JJ 42759 5353 23 , , , 42759 5353 24 mental mental JJ 42759 5353 25 , , , 42759 5353 26 and and CC 42759 5353 27 moral moral JJ 42759 5353 28 injury injury NN 42759 5353 29 resulting result VBG 42759 5353 30 from from IN 42759 5353 31 an an DT 42759 5353 32 unjust unjust JJ 42759 5353 33 wage wage NN 42759 5353 34 contract contract NN 42759 5353 35 , , , 42759 5353 36 as as IN 42759 5353 37 to to TO 42759 5353 38 safeguard safeguard VB 42759 5353 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5353 40 money money NN 42759 5353 41 against against IN 42759 5353 42 the the DT 42759 5353 43 thief thief NN 42759 5353 44 , , , 42759 5353 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5353 46 body body NN 42759 5353 47 against against IN 42759 5353 48 the the DT 42759 5353 49 bully bully NN 42759 5353 50 , , , 42759 5353 51 or or CC 42759 5353 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5353 53 life life NN 42759 5353 54 against against IN 42759 5353 55 the the DT 42759 5353 56 assassin assassin NN 42759 5353 57 . . . 42759 5354 1 In in IN 42759 5354 2 all all DT 42759 5354 3 four four CD 42759 5354 4 cases case NNS 42759 5354 5 the the DT 42759 5354 6 essential essential JJ 42759 5354 7 welfare welfare NN 42759 5354 8 of of IN 42759 5354 9 the the DT 42759 5354 10 individual individual NN 42759 5354 11 is be VBZ 42759 5354 12 injured injure VBN 42759 5354 13 or or CC 42759 5354 14 threatened threaten VBN 42759 5354 15 through through IN 42759 5354 16 the the DT 42759 5354 17 abuse abuse NN 42759 5354 18 of of IN 42759 5354 19 superior superior JJ 42759 5354 20 force force NN 42759 5354 21 and and CC 42759 5354 22 cunning cunning JJ 42759 5354 23 . . . 42759 5355 1 Inasmuch inasmuch IN 42759 5355 2 as as IN 42759 5355 3 the the DT 42759 5355 4 legal legal JJ 42759 5355 5 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5355 6 wage wage NN 42759 5355 7 is be VBZ 42759 5355 8 ethically ethically RB 42759 5355 9 legitimate legitimate JJ 42759 5355 10 , , , 42759 5355 11 the the DT 42759 5355 12 question question NN 42759 5355 13 of of IN 42759 5355 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5355 15 enactment enactment NN 42759 5355 16 is be VBZ 42759 5355 17 , , , 42759 5355 18 politically politically RB 42759 5355 19 speaking speak VBG 42759 5355 20 , , , 42759 5355 21 entirely entirely RB 42759 5355 22 a a DT 42759 5355 23 question question NN 42759 5355 24 of of IN 42759 5355 25 expediency expediency NN 42759 5355 26 . . . 42759 5356 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5356 2 The the DT 42759 5356 3 Economic Economic NNP 42759 5356 4 Aspect Aspect NNP 42759 5356 5 _ _ NNP 42759 5356 6 Now now RB 42759 5356 7 the the DT 42759 5356 8 question question NN 42759 5356 9 of of IN 42759 5356 10 expediency expediency NN 42759 5356 11 is be VBZ 42759 5356 12 mainly mainly RB 42759 5356 13 economic economic JJ 42759 5356 14 . . . 42759 5357 1 A a DT 42759 5357 2 great great JJ 42759 5357 3 deal deal NN 42759 5357 4 of of IN 42759 5357 5 nonsense nonsense NN 42759 5357 6 has have VBZ 42759 5357 7 been be VBN 42759 5357 8 written write VBN 42759 5357 9 and and CC 42759 5357 10 spoken speak VBN 42759 5357 11 about about IN 42759 5357 12 the the DT 42759 5357 13 alleged alleged JJ 42759 5357 14 conflict conflict NN 42759 5357 15 between between IN 42759 5357 16 the the DT 42759 5357 17 legal legal JJ 42759 5357 18 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5357 19 wage wage NN 42759 5357 20 and and CC 42759 5357 21 " " `` 42759 5357 22 economic economic JJ 42759 5357 23 law law NN 42759 5357 24 . . . 42759 5357 25 " " '' 42759 5358 1 Economists economist NNS 42759 5358 2 have have VBP 42759 5358 3 used use VBN 42759 5358 4 no no DT 42759 5358 5 such such JJ 42759 5358 6 language language NN 42759 5358 7 , , , 42759 5358 8 indeed indeed RB 42759 5358 9 ; ; : 42759 5358 10 for for IN 42759 5358 11 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5358 12 know know VBP 42759 5358 13 that that IN 42759 5358 14 economic economic JJ 42759 5358 15 laws law NNS 42759 5358 16 are be VBP 42759 5358 17 merely merely RB 42759 5358 18 the the DT 42759 5358 19 expected expected JJ 42759 5358 20 uniformities uniformity NNS 42759 5358 21 of of IN 42759 5358 22 social social JJ 42759 5358 23 action action NN 42759 5358 24 in in IN 42759 5358 25 given give VBN 42759 5358 26 circumstances circumstance NNS 42759 5358 27 . . . 42759 5359 1 The the DT 42759 5359 2 economists economist NNS 42759 5359 3 know know VBP 42759 5359 4 that that IN 42759 5359 5 economic economic JJ 42759 5359 6 laws law NNS 42759 5359 7 are be VBP 42759 5359 8 no no RB 42759 5359 9 more more RBR 42759 5359 10 opposed opposed JJ 42759 5359 11 to to IN 42759 5359 12 a a DT 42759 5359 13 legal legal JJ 42759 5359 14 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5359 15 wage wage NN 42759 5359 16 than than IN 42759 5359 17 to to IN 42759 5359 18 a a DT 42759 5359 19 legal legal JJ 42759 5359 20 eight eight CD 42759 5359 21 hour hour NN 42759 5359 22 day day NN 42759 5359 23 , , , 42759 5359 24 or or CC 42759 5359 25 legal legal JJ 42759 5359 26 regulations regulation NNS 42759 5359 27 of of IN 42759 5359 28 safety safety NN 42759 5359 29 and and CC 42759 5359 30 sanitation sanitation NN 42759 5359 31 in in IN 42759 5359 32 work work NN 42759 5359 33 places place NNS 42759 5359 34 . . . 42759 5360 1 All all DT 42759 5360 2 three three CD 42759 5360 3 of of IN 42759 5360 4 these these DT 42759 5360 5 measures measure NNS 42759 5360 6 tend tend VBP 42759 5360 7 to to TO 42759 5360 8 increase increase VB 42759 5360 9 the the DT 42759 5360 10 cost cost NN 42759 5360 11 of of IN 42759 5360 12 production production NN 42759 5360 13 , , , 42759 5360 14 and and CC 42759 5360 15 sometimes sometimes RB 42759 5360 16 carry carry VBP 42759 5360 17 the the DT 42759 5360 18 tendency tendency NN 42759 5360 19 into into IN 42759 5360 20 reality reality NN 42759 5360 21 . . . 42759 5361 1 A a DT 42759 5361 2 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5361 3 wage wage NN 42759 5361 4 law law NN 42759 5361 5 is be VBZ 42759 5361 6 difficult difficult JJ 42759 5361 7 to to TO 42759 5361 8 enforce enforce VB 42759 5361 9 , , , 42759 5361 10 but but CC 42759 5361 11 not not RB 42759 5361 12 much much RB 42759 5361 13 more more RBR 42759 5361 14 so so RB 42759 5361 15 than than IN 42759 5361 16 most most JJS 42759 5361 17 other other JJ 42759 5361 18 labour labour JJ 42759 5361 19 regulations regulation NNS 42759 5361 20 . . . 42759 5362 1 At at IN 42759 5362 2 any any DT 42759 5362 3 rate rate NN 42759 5362 4 , , , 42759 5362 5 the the DT 42759 5362 6 practical practical JJ 42759 5362 7 consideration consideration NN 42759 5362 8 is be VBZ 42759 5362 9 whether whether IN 42759 5362 10 even even RB 42759 5362 11 a a DT 42759 5362 12 partial partial JJ 42759 5362 13 enforcement enforcement NN 42759 5362 14 of of IN 42759 5362 15 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5362 16 will will MD 42759 5362 17 not not RB 42759 5362 18 result result VB 42759 5362 19 in in IN 42759 5362 20 a a DT 42759 5362 21 marked marked JJ 42759 5362 22 benefit benefit NN 42759 5362 23 to to IN 42759 5362 24 great great JJ 42759 5362 25 numbers number NNS 42759 5362 26 of of IN 42759 5362 27 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5362 28 workers worker NNS 42759 5362 29 . . . 42759 5363 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5363 2 may may MD 42759 5363 3 throw throw VB 42759 5363 4 some some DT 42759 5363 5 persons person NNS 42759 5363 6 , , , 42759 5363 7 the the DT 42759 5363 8 slower slow JJR 42759 5363 9 workers worker NNS 42759 5363 10 , , , 42759 5363 11 out out IN 42759 5363 12 of of IN 42759 5363 13 employment employment NN 42759 5363 14 ; ; : 42759 5363 15 but but CC 42759 5363 16 here here RB 42759 5363 17 , , , 42759 5363 18 again again RB 42759 5363 19 , , , 42759 5363 20 the the DT 42759 5363 21 important important JJ 42759 5363 22 question question NN 42759 5363 23 relates relate VBZ 42759 5363 24 to to IN 42759 5363 25 the the DT 42759 5363 26 balance balance NN 42759 5363 27 of of IN 42759 5363 28 good good JJ 42759 5363 29 over over IN 42759 5363 30 evil evil NN 42759 5363 31 for for IN 42759 5363 32 the the DT 42759 5363 33 majority majority NN 42759 5363 34 of of IN 42759 5363 35 those those DT 42759 5363 36 who who WP 42759 5363 37 are be VBP 42759 5363 38 below below IN 42759 5363 39 the the DT 42759 5363 40 level level NN 42759 5363 41 of of IN 42759 5363 42 decent decent JJ 42759 5363 43 living living NN 42759 5363 44 . . . 42759 5364 1 At at IN 42759 5364 2 every every DT 42759 5364 3 point point NN 42759 5364 4 , , , 42759 5364 5 therefore therefore RB 42759 5364 6 , , , 42759 5364 7 the the DT 42759 5364 8 problem problem NN 42759 5364 9 is be VBZ 42759 5364 10 one one CD 42759 5364 11 of of IN 42759 5364 12 concrete concrete JJ 42759 5364 13 expediency expediency NN 42759 5364 14 , , , 42759 5364 15 not not RB 42759 5364 16 of of IN 42759 5364 17 agreement agreement NN 42759 5364 18 or or CC 42759 5364 19 disagreement disagreement NN 42759 5364 20 with with IN 42759 5364 21 a a DT 42759 5364 22 real real JJ 42759 5364 23 or or CC 42759 5364 24 imaginary imaginary JJ 42759 5364 25 economic economic JJ 42759 5364 26 law law NN 42759 5364 27 . . . 42759 5365 1 Some some DT 42759 5365 2 of of IN 42759 5365 3 those those DT 42759 5365 4 who who WP 42759 5365 5 oppose oppose VBP 42759 5365 6 the the DT 42759 5365 7 device device NN 42759 5365 8 on on IN 42759 5365 9 the the DT 42759 5365 10 ground ground NN 42759 5365 11 of of IN 42759 5365 12 expediency expediency NN 42759 5365 13 set set VBN 42759 5365 14 up up RP 42759 5365 15 an an DT 42759 5365 16 argument argument NN 42759 5365 17 which which WDT 42759 5365 18 runs run VBZ 42759 5365 19 about about IN 42759 5365 20 as as IN 42759 5365 21 follows follow VBZ 42759 5365 22 : : : 42759 5365 23 the the DT 42759 5365 24 increase increase NN 42759 5365 25 in in IN 42759 5365 26 wages wage NNS 42759 5365 27 caused cause VBN 42759 5365 28 by by IN 42759 5365 29 a a DT 42759 5365 30 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5365 31 wage wage NN 42759 5365 32 law law NN 42759 5365 33 will will MD 42759 5365 34 be be VB 42759 5365 35 shifted shift VBN 42759 5365 36 to to IN 42759 5365 37 the the DT 42759 5365 38 consumer consumer NN 42759 5365 39 in in IN 42759 5365 40 the the DT 42759 5365 41 form form NN 42759 5365 42 of of IN 42759 5365 43 higher high JJR 42759 5365 44 prices price NNS 42759 5365 45 ; ; : 42759 5365 46 this this DT 42759 5365 47 result result NN 42759 5365 48 will will MD 42759 5365 49 in in IN 42759 5365 50 turn turn NN 42759 5365 51 lead lead RB 42759 5365 52 to to IN 42759 5365 53 a a DT 42759 5365 54 falling fall VBG 42759 5365 55 off off RP 42759 5365 56 in in IN 42759 5365 57 the the DT 42759 5365 58 demand demand NN 42759 5365 59 for for IN 42759 5365 60 products product NNS 42759 5365 61 ; ; : 42759 5365 62 a a DT 42759 5365 63 lessened lessen VBN 42759 5365 64 demand demand NN 42759 5365 65 for for IN 42759 5365 66 goods good NNS 42759 5365 67 means mean VBZ 42759 5365 68 a a DT 42759 5365 69 reduced reduce VBN 42759 5365 70 demand demand NN 42759 5365 71 for for IN 42759 5365 72 labour labour NN 42759 5365 73 ; ; : 42759 5365 74 and and CC 42759 5365 75 this this DT 42759 5365 76 implies imply VBZ 42759 5365 77 a a DT 42759 5365 78 diminished diminished JJ 42759 5365 79 volume volume NN 42759 5365 80 of of IN 42759 5365 81 employment employment NN 42759 5365 82 , , , 42759 5365 83 so so IN 42759 5365 84 that that IN 42759 5365 85 the the DT 42759 5365 86 last last JJ 42759 5365 87 state state NN 42759 5365 88 of of IN 42759 5365 89 the the DT 42759 5365 90 workers worker NNS 42759 5365 91 becomes become VBZ 42759 5365 92 worse bad JJR 42759 5365 93 than than IN 42759 5365 94 the the DT 42759 5365 95 first first JJ 42759 5365 96 . . . 42759 5366 1 Not not RB 42759 5366 2 only only RB 42759 5366 3 is be VBZ 42759 5366 4 this this DT 42759 5366 5 conception conception NN 42759 5366 6 too too RB 42759 5366 7 simple simple JJ 42759 5366 8 , , , 42759 5366 9 but but CC 42759 5366 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5366 11 proves prove VBZ 42759 5366 12 too too RB 42759 5366 13 much much JJ 42759 5366 14 . . . 42759 5367 1 If if IN 42759 5367 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5367 3 were be VBD 42759 5367 4 correct correct JJ 42759 5367 5 every every DT 42759 5367 6 rise rise NN 42759 5367 7 in in IN 42759 5367 8 wages wage NNS 42759 5367 9 , , , 42759 5367 10 howsoever howsoever NN 42759 5367 11 brought bring VBN 42759 5367 12 about about RP 42759 5367 13 , , , 42759 5367 14 would would MD 42759 5367 15 be be VB 42759 5367 16 ill ill RB 42759 5367 17 advised advise VBN 42759 5367 18 ; ; : 42759 5367 19 for for IN 42759 5367 20 every every DT 42759 5367 21 rise rise NN 42759 5367 22 would would MD 42759 5367 23 set set VB 42759 5367 24 in in IN 42759 5367 25 motion motion NN 42759 5367 26 the the DT 42759 5367 27 same same JJ 42759 5367 28 fatal fatal JJ 42759 5367 29 chain chain NN 42759 5367 30 of of IN 42759 5367 31 events event NNS 42759 5367 32 . . . 42759 5368 1 Voluntary voluntary JJ 42759 5368 2 increases increase NNS 42759 5368 3 of of IN 42759 5368 4 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5368 5 by by IN 42759 5368 6 employers employer NNS 42759 5368 7 would would MD 42759 5368 8 be be VB 42759 5368 9 quite quite RB 42759 5368 10 as as RB 42759 5368 11 futile futile JJ 42759 5368 12 as as IN 42759 5368 13 the the DT 42759 5368 14 efforts effort NNS 42759 5368 15 of of IN 42759 5368 16 a a DT 42759 5368 17 labour labour JJ 42759 5368 18 union union NN 42759 5368 19 . . . 42759 5369 1 This this DT 42759 5369 2 is be VBZ 42759 5369 3 little little RB 42759 5369 4 more more JJR 42759 5369 5 than than IN 42759 5369 6 the the DT 42759 5369 7 old old JJ 42759 5369 8 wages wage NNS 42759 5369 9 fund fund NN 42759 5369 10 theory theory NN 42759 5369 11 in in IN 42759 5369 12 a a DT 42759 5369 13 new new JJ 42759 5369 14 dress dress NN 42759 5369 15 . . . 42759 5370 1 And and CC 42759 5370 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5370 3 is be VBZ 42759 5370 4 no no DT 42759 5370 5 less less RBR 42759 5370 6 contrary contrary JJ 42759 5370 7 to to IN 42759 5370 8 experience experience VB 42759 5370 9 . . . 42759 5371 1 The the DT 42759 5371 2 argument argument NN 42759 5371 3 is be VBZ 42759 5371 4 too too RB 42759 5371 5 simple simple JJ 42759 5371 6 because because IN 42759 5371 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5371 8 is be VBZ 42759 5371 9 based base VBN 42759 5371 10 upon upon IN 42759 5371 11 an an DT 42759 5371 12 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 5371 13 analysis analysis NN 42759 5371 14 of of IN 42759 5371 15 the the DT 42759 5371 16 facts fact NNS 42759 5371 17 . . . 42759 5372 1 There there EX 42759 5372 2 are be VBP 42759 5372 3 no no RB 42759 5372 4 less less JJR 42759 5372 5 than than IN 42759 5372 6 four four CD 42759 5372 7 sources source NNS 42759 5372 8 from from IN 42759 5372 9 which which WDT 42759 5372 10 the the DT 42759 5372 11 increased increase VBN 42759 5372 12 wages wage NNS 42759 5372 13 required require VBN 42759 5372 14 by by IN 42759 5372 15 a a DT 42759 5372 16 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5372 17 wage wage NN 42759 5372 18 law law NN 42759 5372 19 might may MD 42759 5372 20 in in IN 42759 5372 21 whole whole NN 42759 5372 22 or or CC 42759 5372 23 in in IN 42759 5372 24 part part NN 42759 5372 25 be be VB 42759 5372 26 obtained obtain VBN 42759 5372 27 . . . 42759 5373 1 In in IN 42759 5373 2 the the DT 42759 5373 3 first first JJ 42759 5373 4 place place NN 42759 5373 5 , , , 42759 5373 6 higher high JJR 42759 5373 7 wages wage NNS 42759 5373 8 will will MD 42759 5373 9 often often RB 42759 5373 10 give give VB 42759 5373 11 the the DT 42759 5373 12 workers worker NNS 42759 5373 13 both both CC 42759 5373 14 the the DT 42759 5373 15 physical physical JJ 42759 5373 16 capacity capacity NN 42759 5373 17 and and CC 42759 5373 18 the the DT 42759 5373 19 spirit spirit NN 42759 5373 20 that that WDT 42759 5373 21 make make VBP 42759 5373 22 possible possible JJ 42759 5373 23 a a DT 42759 5373 24 larger large JJR 42759 5373 25 output output NN 42759 5373 26 . . . 42759 5374 1 Thus thus RB 42759 5374 2 , , , 42759 5374 3 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5374 4 could could MD 42759 5374 5 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 5374 6 equivalently equivalently RB 42759 5374 7 provide provide VB 42759 5374 8 a a DT 42759 5374 9 part part NN 42759 5374 10 at at IN 42759 5374 11 least least JJS 42759 5374 12 of of IN 42759 5374 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5374 14 additional additional JJ 42759 5374 15 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5374 16 . . . 42759 5375 1 When when WRB 42759 5375 2 , , , 42759 5375 3 secondly secondly RB 42759 5375 4 , , , 42759 5375 5 the the DT 42759 5375 6 employer employer NN 42759 5375 7 finds find VBZ 42759 5375 8 that that IN 42759 5375 9 labour labour NN 42759 5375 10 is be VBZ 42759 5375 11 no no RB 42759 5375 12 longer long RBR 42759 5375 13 so so RB 42759 5375 14 cheap cheap JJ 42759 5375 15 that that IN 42759 5375 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5375 17 can can MD 42759 5375 18 be be VB 42759 5375 19 profitably profitably RB 42759 5375 20 used use VBN 42759 5375 21 as as IN 42759 5375 22 a a DT 42759 5375 23 substitute substitute NN 42759 5375 24 for for IN 42759 5375 25 intelligent intelligent JJ 42759 5375 26 management management NN 42759 5375 27 , , , 42759 5375 28 better well JJR 42759 5375 29 methods method NNS 42759 5375 30 of of IN 42759 5375 31 production production NN 42759 5375 32 , , , 42759 5375 33 and and CC 42759 5375 34 up up IN 42759 5375 35 to to IN 42759 5375 36 date date NN 42759 5375 37 machinery machinery NN 42759 5375 38 , , , 42759 5375 39 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5375 40 will will MD 42759 5375 41 be be VB 42759 5375 42 compelled compel VBN 42759 5375 43 to to TO 42759 5375 44 introduce introduce VB 42759 5375 45 one one CD 42759 5375 46 or or CC 42759 5375 47 more more JJR 42759 5375 48 of of IN 42759 5375 49 these these DT 42759 5375 50 improvements improvement NNS 42759 5375 51 , , , 42759 5375 52 and and CC 42759 5375 53 to to TO 42759 5375 54 offset offset VB 42759 5375 55 increased increase VBN 42759 5375 56 labour labour NN 42759 5375 57 cost cost NN 42759 5375 58 by by IN 42759 5375 59 increased increase VBN 42759 5375 60 managerial managerial JJ 42759 5375 61 and and CC 42759 5375 62 mechanical mechanical JJ 42759 5375 63 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5375 64 . . . 42759 5376 1 This this DT 42759 5376 2 is be VBZ 42759 5376 3 what what WP 42759 5376 4 seems seem VBZ 42759 5376 5 to to TO 42759 5376 6 have have VB 42759 5376 7 happened happen VBN 42759 5376 8 in in IN 42759 5376 9 the the DT 42759 5376 10 tailoring tailoring NN 42759 5376 11 industry industry NN 42759 5376 12 of of IN 42759 5376 13 England England NNP 42759 5376 14 . . . 42759 5377 1 According accord VBG 42759 5377 2 to to IN 42759 5377 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 42759 5377 4 Tawney Tawney NNP 42759 5377 5 , , , 42759 5377 6 " " '' 42759 5377 7 the the DT 42759 5377 8 increased increase VBN 42759 5377 9 costs cost NNS 42759 5377 10 of of IN 42759 5377 11 production production NN 42759 5377 12 have have VBP 42759 5377 13 , , , 42759 5377 14 on on IN 42759 5377 15 the the DT 42759 5377 16 whole whole NN 42759 5377 17 , , , 42759 5377 18 been be VBN 42759 5377 19 met meet VBN 42759 5377 20 by by IN 42759 5377 21 better well JJR 42759 5377 22 organisation organisation NN 42759 5377 23 of of IN 42759 5377 24 work work NN 42759 5377 25 and and CC 42759 5377 26 by by IN 42759 5377 27 better well JJR 42759 5377 28 machinery machinery NN 42759 5377 29 . . . 42759 5378 1 " " `` 42759 5378 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5378 3 259 259 CD 42759 5378 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5378 5 In in IN 42759 5378 6 the the DT 42759 5378 7 third third JJ 42759 5378 8 place place NN 42759 5378 9 , , , 42759 5378 10 a a DT 42759 5378 11 part part NN 42759 5378 12 of of IN 42759 5378 13 the the DT 42759 5378 14 increased increased JJ 42759 5378 15 wage wage NN 42759 5378 16 cost cost NN 42759 5378 17 can can MD 42759 5378 18 be be VB 42759 5378 19 defrayed defray VBN 42759 5378 20 out out IN 42759 5378 21 of of IN 42759 5378 22 profits profit NNS 42759 5378 23 , , , 42759 5378 24 in in IN 42759 5378 25 two two CD 42759 5378 26 ways way NNS 42759 5378 27 : : : 42759 5378 28 through through IN 42759 5378 29 a a DT 42759 5378 30 reduction reduction NN 42759 5378 31 in in IN 42759 5378 32 the the DT 42759 5378 33 profits profit NNS 42759 5378 34 of of IN 42759 5378 35 the the DT 42759 5378 36 majority majority NN 42759 5378 37 of of IN 42759 5378 38 business business NN 42759 5378 39 concerns concern NNS 42759 5378 40 in in IN 42759 5378 41 an an DT 42759 5378 42 industry industry NN 42759 5378 43 ; ; : 42759 5378 44 but but CC 42759 5378 45 more more RBR 42759 5378 46 frequently frequently RB 42759 5378 47 through through IN 42759 5378 48 the the DT 42759 5378 49 elimination elimination NN 42759 5378 50 of of IN 42759 5378 51 the the DT 42759 5378 52 less less RBR 42759 5378 53 efficient efficient JJ 42759 5378 54 , , , 42759 5378 55 and and CC 42759 5378 56 the the DT 42759 5378 57 consequent consequent JJ 42759 5378 58 increase increase NN 42759 5378 59 in in IN 42759 5378 60 the the DT 42759 5378 61 volume volume NN 42759 5378 62 of of IN 42759 5378 63 business business NN 42759 5378 64 done do VBN 42759 5378 65 by by IN 42759 5378 66 the the DT 42759 5378 67 more more RBR 42759 5378 68 efficient efficient JJ 42759 5378 69 . . . 42759 5379 1 In in IN 42759 5379 2 the the DT 42759 5379 3 latter latter JJ 42759 5379 4 establishments establishment NNS 42759 5379 5 the the DT 42759 5379 6 additional additional JJ 42759 5379 7 outlay outlay NN 42759 5379 8 for for IN 42759 5379 9 wages wage NNS 42759 5379 10 might may MD 42759 5379 11 be be VB 42759 5379 12 fully fully RB 42759 5379 13 neutralised neutralise VBN 42759 5379 14 by by IN 42759 5379 15 the the DT 42759 5379 16 diminished diminished JJ 42759 5379 17 managerial managerial JJ 42759 5379 18 expenses expense NNS 42759 5379 19 and and CC 42759 5379 20 fixed fix VBN 42759 5379 21 charges charge NNS 42759 5379 22 per per IN 42759 5379 23 unit unit NN 42759 5379 24 of of IN 42759 5379 25 product product NN 42759 5379 26 . . . 42759 5380 1 This this DT 42759 5380 2 elimination elimination NN 42759 5380 3 of of IN 42759 5380 4 unfit unfit JJ 42759 5380 5 undertakers undertaker NNS 42759 5380 6 would would MD 42759 5380 7 not not RB 42759 5380 8 only only RB 42759 5380 9 be be VB 42759 5380 10 in in IN 42759 5380 11 the the DT 42759 5380 12 direction direction NN 42759 5380 13 of of IN 42759 5380 14 greater great JJR 42759 5380 15 social social JJ 42759 5380 16 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5380 17 , , , 42759 5380 18 but but CC 42759 5380 19 in in IN 42759 5380 20 the the DT 42759 5380 21 interest interest NN 42759 5380 22 of of IN 42759 5380 23 better well JJR 42759 5380 24 employment employment NN 42759 5380 25 conditions condition NNS 42759 5380 26 generally generally RB 42759 5380 27 ; ; : 42759 5380 28 for for IN 42759 5380 29 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5380 30 is be VBZ 42759 5380 31 the the DT 42759 5380 32 less less RBR 42759 5380 33 competent competent JJ 42759 5380 34 employers employer NNS 42759 5380 35 who who WP 42759 5380 36 are be VBP 42759 5380 37 mainly mainly RB 42759 5380 38 responsible responsible JJ 42759 5380 39 for for IN 42759 5380 40 the the DT 42759 5380 41 evil evil NN 42759 5380 42 of of IN 42759 5380 43 " " `` 42759 5380 44 sweating sweat VBG 42759 5380 45 , , , 42759 5380 46 " " '' 42759 5380 47 when when WRB 42759 5380 48 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5380 49 strive strive VBP 42759 5380 50 to to TO 42759 5380 51 reduce reduce VB 42759 5380 52 the the DT 42759 5380 53 cost cost NN 42759 5380 54 of of IN 42759 5380 55 production production NN 42759 5380 56 by by IN 42759 5380 57 the the DT 42759 5380 58 only only JJ 42759 5380 59 method method NN 42759 5380 60 that that WDT 42759 5380 61 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5380 62 know know VBP 42759 5380 63 ; ; : 42759 5380 64 that that RB 42759 5380 65 is is RB 42759 5380 66 , , , 42759 5380 67 the the DT 42759 5380 68 oppression oppression NN 42759 5380 69 of of IN 42759 5380 70 labour labour NN 42759 5380 71 . . . 42759 5381 1 Should Should MD 42759 5381 2 the the DT 42759 5381 3 three three CD 42759 5381 4 foregoing foregoing NN 42759 5381 5 factors factor NNS 42759 5381 6 fall fall VBP 42759 5381 7 short short RB 42759 5381 8 of of IN 42759 5381 9 providing provide VBG 42759 5381 10 or or CC 42759 5381 11 neutralising neutralise VBG 42759 5381 12 the the DT 42759 5381 13 increased increase VBN 42759 5381 14 wages wage NNS 42759 5381 15 , , , 42759 5381 16 the the DT 42759 5381 17 recourse recourse NN 42759 5381 18 would would MD 42759 5381 19 necessarily necessarily RB 42759 5381 20 be be VB 42759 5381 21 to to IN 42759 5381 22 the the DT 42759 5381 23 fourth fourth JJ 42759 5381 24 source source NN 42759 5381 25 ; ; : 42759 5381 26 namely namely RB 42759 5381 27 , , , 42759 5381 28 a a DT 42759 5381 29 rise rise NN 42759 5381 30 in in IN 42759 5381 31 the the DT 42759 5381 32 price price NN 42759 5381 33 of of IN 42759 5381 34 products product NNS 42759 5381 35 . . . 42759 5382 1 However however RB 42759 5382 2 , , , 42759 5382 3 there there EX 42759 5382 4 is be VBZ 42759 5382 5 no no DT 42759 5382 6 definite definite JJ 42759 5382 7 reason reason NN 42759 5382 8 for for IN 42759 5382 9 assuming assume VBG 42759 5382 10 that that IN 42759 5382 11 the the DT 42759 5382 12 rise rise NN 42759 5382 13 will will MD 42759 5382 14 in in IN 42759 5382 15 any any DT 42759 5382 16 case case NN 42759 5382 17 be be VB 42759 5382 18 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5382 19 to to TO 42759 5382 20 cause cause VB 42759 5382 21 a a DT 42759 5382 22 net net JJ 42759 5382 23 decrease decrease NN 42759 5382 24 of of IN 42759 5382 25 demand demand NN 42759 5382 26 . . . 42759 5383 1 In in IN 42759 5383 2 Oregon Oregon NNP 42759 5383 3 the the DT 42759 5383 4 increased increase VBN 42759 5383 5 labour labour NN 42759 5383 6 cost cost NN 42759 5383 7 due due IN 42759 5383 8 to to IN 42759 5383 9 the the DT 42759 5383 10 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5383 11 wage wage NN 42759 5383 12 law law NN 42759 5383 13 amounted amount VBD 42759 5383 14 , , , 42759 5383 15 as as IN 42759 5383 16 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5383 17 have have VBP 42759 5383 18 seen see VBN 42759 5383 19 , , , 42759 5383 20 to to IN 42759 5383 21 only only RB 42759 5383 22 three three CD 42759 5383 23 mills mill NNS 42759 5383 24 per per IN 42759 5383 25 dollar dollar NN 42759 5383 26 of of IN 42759 5383 27 sales sale NNS 42759 5383 28 in in IN 42759 5383 29 mercantile mercantile JJ 42759 5383 30 establishments establishment NNS 42759 5383 31 . . . 42759 5384 1 Even even RB 42759 5384 2 if if IN 42759 5384 3 this this DT 42759 5384 4 were be VBD 42759 5384 5 all all DT 42759 5384 6 shifted shift VBN 42759 5384 7 to to IN 42759 5384 8 the the DT 42759 5384 9 consumer consumer NN 42759 5384 10 -- -- : 42759 5384 11 something something NN 42759 5384 12 that that WDT 42759 5384 13 is be VBZ 42759 5384 14 practically practically RB 42759 5384 15 impossible impossible JJ 42759 5384 16 -- -- : 42759 5384 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5384 18 would would MD 42759 5384 19 be be VB 42759 5384 20 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 5384 21 to to IN 42759 5384 22 an an DT 42759 5384 23 increase increase NN 42759 5384 24 of of IN 42759 5384 25 only only RB 42759 5384 26 three three CD 42759 5384 27 cents cent NNS 42759 5384 28 on on IN 42759 5384 29 each each DT 42759 5384 30 ten ten CD 42759 5384 31 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5384 32 ' ' POS 42759 5384 33 worth worth NN 42759 5384 34 of of IN 42759 5384 35 purchases purchase NNS 42759 5384 36 , , , 42759 5384 37 and and CC 42759 5384 38 thirty thirty CD 42759 5384 39 cents cent NNS 42759 5384 40 on on IN 42759 5384 41 each each DT 42759 5384 42 hundred hundred CD 42759 5384 43 . . . 42759 5385 1 The the DT 42759 5385 2 reduction reduction NN 42759 5385 3 in in IN 42759 5385 4 sales sale NNS 42759 5385 5 on on IN 42759 5385 6 account account NN 42759 5385 7 of of IN 42759 5385 8 such such PDT 42759 5385 9 a a DT 42759 5385 10 slight slight JJ 42759 5385 11 rise rise NN 42759 5385 12 in in IN 42759 5385 13 prices price NNS 42759 5385 14 would would MD 42759 5385 15 be be VB 42759 5385 16 infinitesimal infinitesimal JJ 42759 5385 17 . . . 42759 5386 1 In in IN 42759 5386 2 the the DT 42759 5386 3 case case NN 42759 5386 4 of of IN 42759 5386 5 possibly possibly RB 42759 5386 6 the the DT 42759 5386 7 majority majority NN 42759 5386 8 of of IN 42759 5386 9 products product NNS 42759 5386 10 , , , 42759 5386 11 the the DT 42759 5386 12 lessened lessen VBN 42759 5386 13 demand demand NN 42759 5386 14 on on IN 42759 5386 15 the the DT 42759 5386 16 part part NN 42759 5386 17 of of IN 42759 5386 18 the the DT 42759 5386 19 other other JJ 42759 5386 20 classes class NNS 42759 5386 21 might may MD 42759 5386 22 be be VB 42759 5386 23 entirely entirely RB 42759 5386 24 counterbalanced counterbalance VBN 42759 5386 25 by by IN 42759 5386 26 the the DT 42759 5386 27 increased increase VBN 42759 5386 28 demand demand NN 42759 5386 29 at at IN 42759 5386 30 the the DT 42759 5386 31 hands hand NNS 42759 5386 32 of of IN 42759 5386 33 the the DT 42759 5386 34 workers worker NNS 42759 5386 35 whose whose WP$ 42759 5386 36 purchasing purchasing NN 42759 5386 37 power power NN 42759 5386 38 had have VBD 42759 5386 39 been be VBN 42759 5386 40 raised raise VBN 42759 5386 41 through through IN 42759 5386 42 the the DT 42759 5386 43 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5386 44 wage wage NN 42759 5386 45 law law NN 42759 5386 46 . . . 42759 5387 1 The the DT 42759 5387 2 effect effect NN 42759 5387 3 upon upon IN 42759 5387 4 sales sale NNS 42759 5387 5 , , , 42759 5387 6 and and CC 42759 5387 7 hence hence RB 42759 5387 8 upon upon IN 42759 5387 9 business business NN 42759 5387 10 and and CC 42759 5387 11 production production NN 42759 5387 12 , , , 42759 5387 13 which which WDT 42759 5387 14 follows follow VBZ 42759 5387 15 from from IN 42759 5387 16 an an DT 42759 5387 17 increase increase NN 42759 5387 18 in in IN 42759 5387 19 the the DT 42759 5387 20 effective effective JJ 42759 5387 21 consuming consume VBG 42759 5387 22 power power NN 42759 5387 23 of of IN 42759 5387 24 the the DT 42759 5387 25 labouring labour VBG 42759 5387 26 classes class NNS 42759 5387 27 is be VBZ 42759 5387 28 frequently frequently RB 42759 5387 29 ignored ignore VBN 42759 5387 30 or or CC 42759 5387 31 underestimated underestimate VBN 42759 5387 32 . . . 42759 5388 1 So so RB 42759 5388 2 far far RB 42759 5388 3 as as IN 42759 5388 4 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5388 5 ' ' POS 42759 5388 6 goods good NNS 42759 5388 7 are be VBP 42759 5388 8 concerned concern VBN 42759 5388 9 , , , 42759 5388 10 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5388 11 seems seem VBZ 42759 5388 12 certain certain JJ 42759 5388 13 that that IN 42759 5388 14 a a DT 42759 5388 15 given give VBN 42759 5388 16 addition addition NN 42759 5388 17 to to IN 42759 5388 18 the the DT 42759 5388 19 income income NN 42759 5388 20 of of IN 42759 5388 21 the the DT 42759 5388 22 wage wage NN 42759 5388 23 - - HYPH 42759 5388 24 earning earn VBG 42759 5388 25 classes class NNS 42759 5388 26 will will MD 42759 5388 27 lead lead VB 42759 5388 28 to to IN 42759 5388 29 a a DT 42759 5388 30 greater great JJR 42759 5388 31 increase increase NN 42759 5388 32 in in IN 42759 5388 33 the the DT 42759 5388 34 demand demand NN 42759 5388 35 for for IN 42759 5388 36 products product NNS 42759 5388 37 than than IN 42759 5388 38 an an DT 42759 5388 39 equal equal JJ 42759 5388 40 addition addition NN 42759 5388 41 to to IN 42759 5388 42 the the DT 42759 5388 43 income income NN 42759 5388 44 of of IN 42759 5388 45 any any DT 42759 5388 46 other other JJ 42759 5388 47 section section NN 42759 5388 48 of of IN 42759 5388 49 the the DT 42759 5388 50 people people NNS 42759 5388 51 . . . 42759 5389 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 5389 2 , , , 42759 5389 3 the the DT 42759 5389 4 possibility possibility NN 42759 5389 5 must must MD 42759 5389 6 be be VB 42759 5389 7 admitted admit VBN 42759 5389 8 of of IN 42759 5389 9 some some DT 42759 5389 10 diminution diminution NN 42759 5389 11 of of IN 42759 5389 12 employment employment NN 42759 5389 13 , , , 42759 5389 14 owing owe VBG 42759 5389 15 to to IN 42759 5389 16 higher high JJR 42759 5389 17 prices price NNS 42759 5389 18 and and CC 42759 5389 19 decreased decrease VBN 42759 5389 20 demand demand NN 42759 5389 21 . . . 42759 5390 1 And and CC 42759 5390 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5390 3 is be VBZ 42759 5390 4 certain certain JJ 42759 5390 5 that that IN 42759 5390 6 some some DT 42759 5390 7 workers worker NNS 42759 5390 8 would would MD 42759 5390 9 not not RB 42759 5390 10 be be VB 42759 5390 11 worth worth JJ 42759 5390 12 the the DT 42759 5390 13 legal legal JJ 42759 5390 14 minimum minimum NN 42759 5390 15 to to IN 42759 5390 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5390 17 employers employer NNS 42759 5390 18 . . . 42759 5391 1 A a DT 42759 5391 2 part part NN 42759 5391 3 , , , 42759 5391 4 but but CC 42759 5391 5 probably probably RB 42759 5391 6 not not RB 42759 5391 7 all all DT 42759 5391 8 , , , 42759 5391 9 of of IN 42759 5391 10 these these DT 42759 5391 11 could could MD 42759 5391 12 find find VB 42759 5391 13 employment employment NN 42759 5391 14 at at IN 42759 5391 15 a a DT 42759 5391 16 lower low JJR 42759 5391 17 wage wage NN 42759 5391 18 , , , 42759 5391 19 through through IN 42759 5391 20 a a DT 42759 5391 21 system system NN 42759 5391 22 of of IN 42759 5391 23 permits permit NNS 42759 5391 24 for for IN 42759 5391 25 " " `` 42759 5391 26 slow slow JJ 42759 5391 27 workers worker NNS 42759 5391 28 . . . 42759 5391 29 " " '' 42759 5392 1 Whatever whatever WDT 42759 5392 2 the the DT 42759 5392 3 amount amount NN 42759 5392 4 of of IN 42759 5392 5 unemployment unemployment NN 42759 5392 6 resulting result VBG 42759 5392 7 from from IN 42759 5392 8 both both PDT 42759 5392 9 these these DT 42759 5392 10 causes cause NNS 42759 5392 11 , , , 42759 5392 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5392 13 would would MD 42759 5392 14 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 42759 5392 15 be be VB 42759 5392 16 an an DT 42759 5392 17 evil evil NN 42759 5392 18 of of IN 42759 5392 19 lesser less JJR 42759 5392 20 magnitude magnitude NN 42759 5392 21 than than IN 42759 5392 22 that that DT 42759 5392 23 which which WDT 42759 5392 24 at at IN 42759 5392 25 present present NN 42759 5392 26 follows follow VBZ 42759 5392 27 from from IN 42759 5392 28 the the DT 42759 5392 29 under under JJ 42759 5392 30 - - HYPH 42759 5392 31 payment payment NN 42759 5392 32 of of IN 42759 5392 33 a a DT 42759 5392 34 majority majority NN 42759 5392 35 of of IN 42759 5392 36 the the DT 42759 5392 37 labouring labour VBG 42759 5392 38 population population NN 42759 5392 39 . . . 42759 5393 1 And and CC 42759 5393 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5393 3 could could MD 42759 5393 4 be be VB 42759 5393 5 remedied remedie VBN 42759 5393 6 by by IN 42759 5393 7 two two CD 42759 5393 8 measures measure NNS 42759 5393 9 which which WDT 42759 5393 10 are be VBP 42759 5393 11 in in IN 42759 5393 12 any any DT 42759 5393 13 case case NN 42759 5393 14 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5393 15 for for IN 42759 5393 16 social social JJ 42759 5393 17 welfare welfare NN 42759 5393 18 , , , 42759 5393 19 and and CC 42759 5393 20 which which WDT 42759 5393 21 would would MD 42759 5393 22 be be VB 42759 5393 23 hastened hasten VBN 42759 5393 24 by by IN 42759 5393 25 the the DT 42759 5393 26 establishment establishment NN 42759 5393 27 of of IN 42759 5393 28 a a DT 42759 5393 29 legal legal JJ 42759 5393 30 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5393 31 wage wage NN 42759 5393 32 . . . 42759 5394 1 These these DT 42759 5394 2 are be VBP 42759 5394 3 adequate adequate JJ 42759 5394 4 and and CC 42759 5394 5 scientific scientific JJ 42759 5394 6 laws law NNS 42759 5394 7 and and CC 42759 5394 8 institutions institution NNS 42759 5394 9 to to TO 42759 5394 10 deal deal VB 42759 5394 11 with with IN 42759 5394 12 the the DT 42759 5394 13 general general JJ 42759 5394 14 problem problem NN 42759 5394 15 of of IN 42759 5394 16 unemployment unemployment NN 42759 5394 17 , , , 42759 5394 18 and and CC 42759 5394 19 a a DT 42759 5394 20 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 5394 21 system system NN 42759 5394 22 of of IN 42759 5394 23 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5394 24 and and CC 42759 5394 25 vocational vocational JJ 42759 5394 26 training training NN 42759 5394 27 . . . 42759 5395 1 These these DT 42759 5395 2 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 5395 3 , , , 42759 5395 4 then then RB 42759 5395 5 , , , 42759 5395 6 seem seem VBP 42759 5395 7 to to TO 42759 5395 8 be be VB 42759 5395 9 justified justify VBN 42759 5395 10 : : : 42759 5395 11 the the DT 42759 5395 12 economic economic JJ 42759 5395 13 objections objection NNS 42759 5395 14 to to IN 42759 5395 15 a a DT 42759 5395 16 legal legal JJ 42759 5395 17 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5395 18 wage wage NN 42759 5395 19 are be VBP 42759 5395 20 not not RB 42759 5395 21 essentially essentially RB 42759 5395 22 different different JJ 42759 5395 23 from from IN 42759 5395 24 those those DT 42759 5395 25 that that WDT 42759 5395 26 may may MD 42759 5395 27 be be VB 42759 5395 28 urged urge VBN 42759 5395 29 against against IN 42759 5395 30 any any DT 42759 5395 31 other other JJ 42759 5395 32 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 5395 33 labour labour NN 42759 5395 34 legislation legislation NN 42759 5395 35 ; ; : 42759 5395 36 and and CC 42759 5395 37 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5395 38 have have VBP 42759 5395 39 been be VBN 42759 5395 40 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 5395 41 refuted refute VBN 42759 5395 42 by by IN 42759 5395 43 experience experience NN 42759 5395 44 to to TO 42759 5395 45 throw throw VB 42759 5395 46 the the DT 42759 5395 47 burden burden NN 42759 5395 48 of of IN 42759 5395 49 proof proof NN 42759 5395 50 upon upon IN 42759 5395 51 the the DT 42759 5395 52 objectors objector NNS 42759 5395 53 . . . 42759 5396 1 Expediency expediency NN 42759 5396 2 suggests suggest VBZ 42759 5396 3 , , , 42759 5396 4 however however RB 42759 5396 5 , , , 42759 5396 6 that that IN 42759 5396 7 in in IN 42759 5396 8 the the DT 42759 5396 9 United United NNP 42759 5396 10 States States NNP 42759 5396 11 the the DT 42759 5396 12 device device NN 42759 5396 13 should should MD 42759 5396 14 be be VB 42759 5396 15 applied apply VBN 42759 5396 16 gradually gradually RB 42759 5396 17 in in IN 42759 5396 18 two two CD 42759 5396 19 respects respect NNS 42759 5396 20 : : : 42759 5396 21 for for IN 42759 5396 22 a a DT 42759 5396 23 few few JJ 42759 5396 24 years year NNS 42759 5396 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5396 26 ought ought MD 42759 5396 27 to to TO 42759 5396 28 be be VB 42759 5396 29 confined confine VBN 42759 5396 30 to to IN 42759 5396 31 women woman NNS 42759 5396 32 and and CC 42759 5396 33 minors minor NNS 42759 5396 34 ; ; : 42759 5396 35 and and CC 42759 5396 36 when when WRB 42759 5396 37 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5396 38 is be VBZ 42759 5396 39 extended extend VBN 42759 5396 40 to to IN 42759 5396 41 men man NNS 42759 5396 42 , , , 42759 5396 43 the the DT 42759 5396 44 rates rate NNS 42759 5396 45 should should MD 42759 5396 46 approach approach VB 42759 5396 47 the the DT 42759 5396 48 level level NN 42759 5396 49 of of IN 42759 5396 50 a a DT 42759 5396 51 complete complete JJ 42759 5396 52 family family NN 42759 5396 53 living living NN 42759 5396 54 wage wage NN 42759 5396 55 by by IN 42759 5396 56 stages stage NNS 42759 5396 57 , , , 42759 5396 58 covering covering NN 42759 5396 59 , , , 42759 5396 60 say say UH 42759 5396 61 , , , 42759 5396 62 three three CD 42759 5396 63 or or CC 42759 5396 64 four four CD 42759 5396 65 years year NNS 42759 5396 66 . . . 42759 5397 1 The the DT 42759 5397 2 former former JJ 42759 5397 3 restriction restriction NN 42759 5397 4 would would MD 42759 5397 5 enable enable VB 42759 5397 6 the the DT 42759 5397 7 law law NN 42759 5397 8 to to TO 42759 5397 9 be be VB 42759 5397 10 carried carry VBN 42759 5397 11 through through IN 42759 5397 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5397 13 experimental experimental JJ 42759 5397 14 stages stage NNS 42759 5397 15 with with IN 42759 5397 16 a a DT 42759 5397 17 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5397 18 disturbance disturbance NN 42759 5397 19 to to IN 42759 5397 20 industry industry NN 42759 5397 21 as as IN 42759 5397 22 a a DT 42759 5397 23 whole whole NN 42759 5397 24 , , , 42759 5397 25 and and CC 42759 5397 26 with with IN 42759 5397 27 a a DT 42759 5397 28 minimum minimum NN 42759 5397 29 of of IN 42759 5397 30 opposition opposition NN 42759 5397 31 , , , 42759 5397 32 and and CC 42759 5397 33 the the DT 42759 5397 34 latter latter JJ 42759 5397 35 would would MD 42759 5397 36 greatly greatly RB 42759 5397 37 reduce reduce VB 42759 5397 38 the the DT 42759 5397 39 danger danger NN 42759 5397 40 of of IN 42759 5397 41 male male JJ 42759 5397 42 unemployment unemployment NN 42759 5397 43 . . . 42759 5398 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5398 2 260 260 CD 42759 5398 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5398 4 _ _ NNP 42759 5398 5 Opinions Opinions NNPS 42759 5398 6 of of IN 42759 5398 7 Economists Economists NNPS 42759 5398 8 _ _ NNP 42759 5398 9 When when WRB 42759 5398 10 the the DT 42759 5398 11 present present JJ 42759 5398 12 writer writer NN 42759 5398 13 made make VBD 42759 5398 14 an an DT 42759 5398 15 argument argument NN 42759 5398 16 for for IN 42759 5398 17 the the DT 42759 5398 18 legal legal JJ 42759 5398 19 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5398 20 wage wage NN 42759 5398 21 something something NN 42759 5398 22 more more JJR 42759 5398 23 than than IN 42759 5398 24 ten ten CD 42759 5398 25 years year NNS 42759 5398 26 ago ago RB 42759 5398 27 , , , 42759 5398 28 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5398 29 was be VBD 42759 5398 30 able able JJ 42759 5398 31 to to TO 42759 5398 32 find find VB 42759 5398 33 only only RB 42759 5398 34 one one CD 42759 5398 35 American american JJ 42759 5398 36 economist economist NN 42759 5398 37 who who WP 42759 5398 38 had have VBD 42759 5398 39 touched touch VBN 42759 5398 40 the the DT 42759 5398 41 subject subject NN 42759 5398 42 , , , 42759 5398 43 and and CC 42759 5398 44 the the DT 42759 5398 45 verdict verdict NN 42759 5398 46 of of IN 42759 5398 47 that that DT 42759 5398 48 one one NN 42759 5398 49 was be VBD 42759 5398 50 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 42759 5398 51 . . . 42759 5399 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5399 2 261 261 CD 42759 5399 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5399 4 A a DT 42759 5399 5 little little JJ 42759 5399 6 over over IN 42759 5399 7 a a DT 42759 5399 8 year year NN 42759 5399 9 ago ago RB 42759 5399 10 , , , 42759 5399 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 42759 5399 12 John John NNP 42759 5399 13 O'Grady O'Grady NNP 42759 5399 14 sent send VBD 42759 5399 15 an an DT 42759 5399 16 inquiry inquiry NN 42759 5399 17 to to IN 42759 5399 18 one one CD 42759 5399 19 hundred hundred CD 42759 5399 20 and and CC 42759 5399 21 sixty sixty CD 42759 5399 22 economists economist NNS 42759 5399 23 of of IN 42759 5399 24 the the DT 42759 5399 25 United United NNP 42759 5399 26 States States NNP 42759 5399 27 to to TO 42759 5399 28 ascertain ascertain VB 42759 5399 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5399 30 opinions opinion NNS 42759 5399 31 on on IN 42759 5399 32 the the DT 42759 5399 33 same same JJ 42759 5399 34 subject subject NN 42759 5399 35 . . . 42759 5400 1 Of of IN 42759 5400 2 the the DT 42759 5400 3 ninety ninety CD 42759 5400 4 - - HYPH 42759 5400 5 four four CD 42759 5400 6 who who WP 42759 5400 7 replied reply VBD 42759 5400 8 seventy seventy CD 42759 5400 9 were be VBD 42759 5400 10 in in IN 42759 5400 11 favour favour NN 42759 5400 12 of of IN 42759 5400 13 a a DT 42759 5400 14 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5400 15 wage wage NN 42759 5400 16 law law NN 42759 5400 17 for for IN 42759 5400 18 women woman NNS 42759 5400 19 and and CC 42759 5400 20 minors minor NNS 42759 5400 21 , , , 42759 5400 22 thirteen thirteen CD 42759 5400 23 were be VBD 42759 5400 24 opposed oppose VBN 42759 5400 25 , , , 42759 5400 26 and and CC 42759 5400 27 eleven eleven CD 42759 5400 28 were be VBD 42759 5400 29 non non JJ 42759 5400 30 - - JJ 42759 5400 31 committal committal JJ 42759 5400 32 ; ; : 42759 5400 33 fifty fifty CD 42759 5400 34 - - HYPH 42759 5400 35 five five CD 42759 5400 36 favoured favour VBD 42759 5400 37 such such JJ 42759 5400 38 legislation legislation NN 42759 5400 39 for for IN 42759 5400 40 men man NNS 42759 5400 41 , , , 42759 5400 42 twenty twenty CD 42759 5400 43 were be VBD 42759 5400 44 against against IN 42759 5400 45 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5400 46 , , , 42759 5400 47 and and CC 42759 5400 48 nineteen nineteen CD 42759 5400 49 were be VBD 42759 5400 50 disinclined disinclined JJ 42759 5400 51 to to TO 42759 5400 52 give give VB 42759 5400 53 a a DT 42759 5400 54 categorical categorical JJ 42759 5400 55 answer answer NN 42759 5400 56 . . . 42759 5401 1 About about RB 42759 5401 2 three three CD 42759 5401 3 - - HYPH 42759 5401 4 fourths fourth NNS 42759 5401 5 of of IN 42759 5401 6 those those DT 42759 5401 7 who who WP 42759 5401 8 responded respond VBD 42759 5401 9 expressed express VBD 42759 5401 10 the the DT 42759 5401 11 opinion opinion NN 42759 5401 12 that that IN 42759 5401 13 the the DT 42759 5401 14 measure measure NN 42759 5401 15 would would MD 42759 5401 16 tend tend VB 42759 5401 17 to to TO 42759 5401 18 increase increase VB 42759 5401 19 the the DT 42759 5401 20 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5401 21 both both DT 42759 5401 22 of of IN 42759 5401 23 the the DT 42759 5401 24 workers worker NNS 42759 5401 25 and and CC 42759 5401 26 of of IN 42759 5401 27 methods method NNS 42759 5401 28 of of IN 42759 5401 29 production production NN 42759 5401 30 . . . 42759 5402 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5402 2 262 262 CD 42759 5402 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5402 4 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5402 5 is be VBZ 42759 5402 6 worthy worthy JJ 42759 5402 7 of of IN 42759 5402 8 note note NN 42759 5402 9 that that IN 42759 5402 10 the the DT 42759 5402 11 nine nine CD 42759 5402 12 members member NNS 42759 5402 13 of of IN 42759 5402 14 the the DT 42759 5402 15 late late JJ 42759 5402 16 Federal Federal NNP 42759 5402 17 Commission Commission NNP 42759 5402 18 on on IN 42759 5402 19 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 5402 20 Relations Relations NNPS 42759 5402 21 , , , 42759 5402 22 although although IN 42759 5402 23 disagreeing disagreeing NN 42759 5402 24 widely widely RB 42759 5402 25 and and CC 42759 5402 26 variously variously RB 42759 5402 27 on on IN 42759 5402 28 most most JJS 42759 5402 29 other other JJ 42759 5402 30 important important JJ 42759 5402 31 questions question NNS 42759 5402 32 and and CC 42759 5402 33 proposals proposal NNS 42759 5402 34 , , , 42759 5402 35 were be VBD 42759 5402 36 all all DT 42759 5402 37 favourable favourable JJ 42759 5402 38 to to IN 42759 5402 39 a a DT 42759 5402 40 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5402 41 wage wage NN 42759 5402 42 law law NN 42759 5402 43 for for IN 42759 5402 44 women woman NNS 42759 5402 45 and and CC 42759 5402 46 minors minor NNS 42759 5402 47 . . . 42759 5403 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5403 2 263 263 CD 42759 5403 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5403 4 The the DT 42759 5403 5 most most RBS 42759 5403 6 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 5403 7 and and CC 42759 5403 8 most most RBS 42759 5403 9 searching searching JJ 42759 5403 10 criticism criticism NN 42759 5403 11 of of IN 42759 5403 12 the the DT 42759 5403 13 legal legal JJ 42759 5403 14 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5403 15 wage wage NN 42759 5403 16 from from IN 42759 5403 17 the the DT 42759 5403 18 viewpoint viewpoint NN 42759 5403 19 of of IN 42759 5403 20 economic economic JJ 42759 5403 21 theory theory NN 42759 5403 22 has have VBZ 42759 5403 23 been be VBN 42759 5403 24 made make VBN 42759 5403 25 by by IN 42759 5403 26 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5403 27 F. F. NNP 42759 5403 28 W. W. NNP 42759 5404 1 Taussig Taussig NNS 42759 5404 2 . . . 42759 5405 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5405 2 264 264 CD 42759 5405 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5405 4 While while IN 42759 5405 5 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5405 6 does do VBZ 42759 5405 7 not not RB 42759 5405 8 commit commit VB 42759 5405 9 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 5405 10 definitely definitely RB 42759 5405 11 to to IN 42759 5405 12 the the DT 42759 5405 13 assertion assertion NN 42759 5405 14 that that IN 42759 5405 15 a a DT 42759 5405 16 universal universal JJ 42759 5405 17 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5405 18 wage wage NN 42759 5405 19 of of IN 42759 5405 20 , , , 42759 5405 21 say say UH 42759 5405 22 , , , 42759 5405 23 eight eight CD 42759 5405 24 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5405 25 per per IN 42759 5405 26 week week NN 42759 5405 27 , , , 42759 5405 28 would would MD 42759 5405 29 cause cause VB 42759 5405 30 a a DT 42759 5405 31 notable notable JJ 42759 5405 32 amount amount NN 42759 5405 33 of of IN 42759 5405 34 unemployment unemployment NN 42759 5405 35 among among IN 42759 5405 36 women woman NNS 42759 5405 37 , , , 42759 5405 38 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5405 39 regards regard VBZ 42759 5405 40 this this DT 42759 5405 41 consequence consequence NN 42759 5405 42 as as IN 42759 5405 43 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 5405 44 probable probable JJ 42759 5405 45 to to TO 42759 5405 46 indicate indicate VB 42759 5405 47 the the DT 42759 5405 48 " " `` 42759 5405 49 need need NN 42759 5405 50 of of IN 42759 5405 51 going go VBG 42759 5405 52 slow slow RB 42759 5405 53 in in IN 42759 5405 54 the the DT 42759 5405 55 regulation regulation NN 42759 5405 56 of of IN 42759 5405 57 women woman NNS 42759 5405 58 's 's POS 42759 5405 59 wages wage NNS 42759 5405 60 . . . 42759 5405 61 " " '' 42759 5406 1 Specifically specifically RB 42759 5406 2 , , , 42759 5406 3 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5406 4 would would MD 42759 5406 5 have have VB 42759 5406 6 public public JJ 42759 5406 7 wage wage NN 42759 5406 8 boards board NNS 42759 5406 9 refrain refrain VBP 42759 5406 10 from from IN 42759 5406 11 fixing fix VBG 42759 5406 12 the the DT 42759 5406 13 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5406 14 rates rate NNS 42759 5406 15 high high JJ 42759 5406 16 enough enough RB 42759 5406 17 to to TO 42759 5406 18 maintain maintain VB 42759 5406 19 women woman NNS 42759 5406 20 living live VBG 42759 5406 21 away away RB 42759 5406 22 from from IN 42759 5406 23 home home NN 42759 5406 24 . . . 42759 5407 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5407 2 final final JJ 42759 5407 3 and and CC 42759 5407 4 only only JJ 42759 5407 5 serious serious JJ 42759 5407 6 argument argument NN 42759 5407 7 for for IN 42759 5407 8 this this DT 42759 5407 9 position position NN 42759 5407 10 relates relate VBZ 42759 5407 11 to to IN 42759 5407 12 the the DT 42759 5407 13 marginal marginal JJ 42759 5407 14 effectiveness effectiveness NN 42759 5407 15 of of IN 42759 5407 16 women woman NNS 42759 5407 17 workers worker NNS 42759 5407 18 . . . 42759 5408 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 5408 2 assumes assume VBZ 42759 5408 3 that that IN 42759 5408 4 all all DT 42759 5408 5 " " `` 42759 5408 6 the the DT 42759 5408 7 fitful fitful JJ 42759 5408 8 , , , 42759 5408 9 untrained untrained JJ 42759 5408 10 , , , 42759 5408 11 indifferent indifferent JJ 42759 5408 12 women woman NNS 42759 5408 13 are be VBP 42759 5408 14 got get VBN 42759 5408 15 rid rid VBN 42759 5408 16 of of IN 42759 5408 17 ; ; : 42759 5408 18 that that IN 42759 5408 19 all all DT 42759 5408 20 who who WP 42759 5408 21 offer offer VBP 42759 5408 22 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 5408 23 for for IN 42759 5408 24 work work NN 42759 5408 25 at at IN 42759 5408 26 the the DT 42759 5408 27 age age NN 42759 5408 28 of of IN 42759 5408 29 ( ( -LRB- 42759 5408 30 say say VB 42759 5408 31 ) ) -RRB- 42759 5408 32 eighteen eighteen CD 42759 5408 33 years year NNS 42759 5408 34 have have VBP 42759 5408 35 had have VBN 42759 5408 36 an an DT 42759 5408 37 industrially industrially RB 42759 5408 38 helpful helpful JJ 42759 5408 39 education,-- education,-- '' 42759 5408 40 " " '' 42759 5408 41 and and CC 42759 5408 42 then then RB 42759 5408 43 raises raise VBZ 42759 5408 44 the the DT 42759 5408 45 question question NN 42759 5408 46 whether whether IN 42759 5408 47 all all DT 42759 5408 48 of of IN 42759 5408 49 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5408 50 will will MD 42759 5408 51 be be VB 42759 5408 52 " " `` 42759 5408 53 able able JJ 42759 5408 54 to to TO 42759 5408 55 get get VB 42759 5408 56 distinctly distinctly RB 42759 5408 57 higher high JJR 42759 5408 58 wages wage NNS 42759 5408 59 than than IN 42759 5408 60 are be VBP 42759 5408 61 now now RB 42759 5408 62 current current JJ 42759 5408 63 . . . 42759 5409 1 " " `` 42759 5409 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5409 3 265 265 CD 42759 5409 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5409 5 Obviously obviously RB 42759 5409 6 the the DT 42759 5409 7 question question NN 42759 5409 8 is be VBZ 42759 5409 9 not not RB 42759 5409 10 serious serious JJ 42759 5409 11 unless unless IN 42759 5409 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5409 13 contemplates contemplate VBZ 42759 5409 14 the the DT 42759 5409 15 probability probability NN 42759 5409 16 of of IN 42759 5409 17 unemployment unemployment NN 42759 5409 18 for for IN 42759 5409 19 a a DT 42759 5409 20 _ _ NNP 42759 5409 21 considerable considerable JJ 42759 5409 22 proportion proportion NN 42759 5409 23 _ _ NNP 42759 5409 24 . . . 42759 5410 1 If if IN 42759 5410 2 only only RB 42759 5410 3 one one CD 42759 5410 4 per per IN 42759 5410 5 cent cent NN 42759 5410 6 . . . 42759 5411 1 or or CC 42759 5411 2 less less JJR 42759 5411 3 of of IN 42759 5411 4 the the DT 42759 5411 5 women woman NNS 42759 5411 6 should should MD 42759 5411 7 be be VB 42759 5411 8 unable unable JJ 42759 5411 9 to to TO 42759 5411 10 find find VB 42759 5411 11 employment employment NN 42759 5411 12 at at IN 42759 5411 13 the the DT 42759 5411 14 higher high JJR 42759 5411 15 wages wage NNS 42759 5411 16 , , , 42759 5411 17 the the DT 42759 5411 18 net net JJ 42759 5411 19 social social JJ 42759 5411 20 advantage advantage NN 42759 5411 21 of of IN 42759 5411 22 the the DT 42759 5411 23 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5411 24 wage wage NN 42759 5411 25 device device NN 42759 5411 26 would would MD 42759 5411 27 be be VB 42759 5411 28 so so RB 42759 5411 29 obvious obvious JJ 42759 5411 30 as as IN 42759 5411 31 to to TO 42759 5411 32 render render VB 42759 5411 33 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5411 34 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 5411 35 's 's POS 42759 5411 36 opposition opposition NN 42759 5411 37 quite quite RB 42759 5411 38 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 42759 5411 39 . . . 42759 5412 1 Making make VBG 42759 5412 2 the the DT 42759 5412 3 assumptions assumption NNS 42759 5412 4 quoted quote VBN 42759 5412 5 above above RB 42759 5412 6 from from IN 42759 5412 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5412 8 pages page NNS 42759 5412 9 , , , 42759 5412 10 let let VB 42759 5412 11 us -PRON- PRP 42759 5412 12 try try VB 42759 5412 13 to to TO 42759 5412 14 see see VB 42759 5412 15 whether whether IN 42759 5412 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5412 17 apprehensions apprehension NNS 42759 5412 18 are be VBP 42759 5412 19 economically economically RB 42759 5412 20 justifiable justifiable JJ 42759 5412 21 . . . 42759 5413 1 If if IN 42759 5413 2 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5413 3 are be VBP 42759 5413 4 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5413 5 or or CC 42759 5413 6 probable probable JJ 42759 5413 7 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5413 8 must must MD 42759 5413 9 rest rest VB 42759 5413 10 on on IN 42759 5413 11 one one CD 42759 5413 12 of of IN 42759 5413 13 two two CD 42759 5413 14 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 5413 15 conditions condition NNS 42759 5413 16 : : : 42759 5413 17 the the DT 42759 5413 18 occupations occupation NNS 42759 5413 19 available available JJ 42759 5413 20 to to IN 42759 5413 21 women woman NNS 42759 5413 22 are be VBP 42759 5413 23 too too RB 42759 5413 24 few few JJ 42759 5413 25 to to TO 42759 5413 26 absorb absorb VB 42759 5413 27 all all DT 42759 5413 28 that that WDT 42759 5413 29 would would MD 42759 5413 30 seek seek VB 42759 5413 31 to to TO 42759 5413 32 become become VB 42759 5413 33 wage wage NN 42759 5413 34 earners earner NNS 42759 5413 35 at at IN 42759 5413 36 eight eight CD 42759 5413 37 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5413 38 per per IN 42759 5413 39 week week NN 42759 5413 40 ; ; : 42759 5413 41 or or CC 42759 5413 42 a a DT 42759 5413 43 considerable considerable JJ 42759 5413 44 section section NN 42759 5413 45 of of IN 42759 5413 46 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5413 47 would would MD 42759 5413 48 be be VB 42759 5413 49 unable unable JJ 42759 5413 50 to to TO 42759 5413 51 produce produce VB 42759 5413 52 such such PDT 42759 5413 53 a a DT 42759 5413 54 high high JJ 42759 5413 55 wage wage NN 42759 5413 56 . . . 42759 5414 1 Possibly possibly RB 42759 5414 2 the the DT 42759 5414 3 first first JJ 42759 5414 4 of of IN 42759 5414 5 these these DT 42759 5414 6 assumptions assumption NNS 42759 5414 7 is be VBZ 42759 5414 8 true true JJ 42759 5414 9 , , , 42759 5414 10 but but CC 42759 5414 11 neither neither CC 42759 5414 12 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5414 13 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 5414 14 nor nor CC 42759 5414 15 any any DT 42759 5414 16 other other JJ 42759 5414 17 authority authority NN 42759 5414 18 has have VBZ 42759 5414 19 presented present VBN 42759 5414 20 evidence evidence NN 42759 5414 21 to to TO 42759 5414 22 support support VB 42759 5414 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5414 24 , , , 42759 5414 25 and and CC 42759 5414 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5414 27 is be VBZ 42759 5414 28 on on IN 42759 5414 29 the the DT 42759 5414 30 face face NN 42759 5414 31 of of IN 42759 5414 32 things thing NNS 42759 5414 33 not not RB 42759 5414 34 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 5414 35 probable probable JJ 42759 5414 36 to to TO 42759 5414 37 justify justify VB 42759 5414 38 hesitation hesitation NN 42759 5414 39 in in IN 42759 5414 40 the the DT 42759 5414 41 advocacy advocacy NN 42759 5414 42 of of IN 42759 5414 43 a a DT 42759 5414 44 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5414 45 living living NN 42759 5414 46 wage wage NN 42759 5414 47 . . . 42759 5415 1 If if IN 42759 5415 2 the the DT 42759 5415 3 second second JJ 42759 5415 4 assumption assumption NN 42759 5415 5 be be VB 42759 5415 6 correct correct JJ 42759 5415 7 , , , 42759 5415 8 if if IN 42759 5415 9 the the DT 42759 5415 10 product product NN 42759 5415 11 of of IN 42759 5415 12 a a DT 42759 5415 13 considerable considerable JJ 42759 5415 14 section section NN 42759 5415 15 of of IN 42759 5415 16 women woman NNS 42759 5415 17 ( ( -LRB- 42759 5415 18 all all DT 42759 5415 19 adequately adequately RB 42759 5415 20 trained train VBN 42759 5415 21 ) ) -RRB- 42759 5415 22 would would MD 42759 5415 23 be be VB 42759 5415 24 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 5415 25 to to TO 42759 5415 26 yield yield VB 42759 5415 27 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5415 28 eight eight CD 42759 5415 29 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5415 30 per per IN 42759 5415 31 week week NN 42759 5415 32 , , , 42759 5415 33 in in IN 42759 5415 34 addition addition NN 42759 5415 35 to to IN 42759 5415 36 the the DT 42759 5415 37 other other JJ 42759 5415 38 costs cost NNS 42759 5415 39 of of IN 42759 5415 40 production production NN 42759 5415 41 , , , 42759 5415 42 the the DT 42759 5415 43 conclusion conclusion NN 42759 5415 44 is be VBZ 42759 5415 45 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 5415 46 that that IN 42759 5415 47 the the DT 42759 5415 48 same same JJ 42759 5415 49 result result NN 42759 5415 50 would would MD 42759 5415 51 follow follow VB 42759 5415 52 the the DT 42759 5415 53 attempt attempt NN 42759 5415 54 to to TO 42759 5415 55 pay pay VB 42759 5415 56 all all DT 42759 5415 57 male male JJ 42759 5415 58 adults adult NNS 42759 5415 59 ( ( -LRB- 42759 5415 60 likewise likewise RB 42759 5415 61 adequately adequately RB 42759 5415 62 trained train VBN 42759 5415 63 ) ) -RRB- 42759 5415 64 a a DT 42759 5415 65 family family NN 42759 5415 66 living live VBG 42759 5415 67 wage wage NN 42759 5415 68 of of IN 42759 5415 69 , , , 42759 5415 70 say say UH 42759 5415 71 , , , 42759 5415 72 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 5415 73 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5415 74 per per IN 42759 5415 75 week week NN 42759 5415 76 . . . 42759 5416 1 For for IN 42759 5416 2 the the DT 42759 5416 3 product product NN 42759 5416 4 of of IN 42759 5416 5 the the DT 42759 5416 6 average average JJ 42759 5416 7 man man NN 42759 5416 8 does do VBZ 42759 5416 9 not not RB 42759 5416 10 exceed exceed VB 42759 5416 11 that that DT 42759 5416 12 of of IN 42759 5416 13 the the DT 42759 5416 14 average average JJ 42759 5416 15 woman woman NN 42759 5416 16 by by IN 42759 5416 17 even even RB 42759 5416 18 as as RB 42759 5416 19 great great JJ 42759 5416 20 a a DT 42759 5416 21 ratio ratio NN 42759 5416 22 as as IN 42759 5416 23 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 5416 24 to to IN 42759 5416 25 eight eight CD 42759 5416 26 . . . 42759 5417 1 If if IN 42759 5417 2 the the DT 42759 5417 3 average average JJ 42759 5417 4 woman woman NN 42759 5417 5 is be VBZ 42759 5417 6 not not RB 42759 5417 7 worth worth JJ 42759 5417 8 eight eight CD 42759 5417 9 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5417 10 a a DT 42759 5417 11 week week NN 42759 5417 12 to to IN 42759 5417 13 an an DT 42759 5417 14 employer employer NN 42759 5417 15 in in IN 42759 5417 16 any any DT 42759 5417 17 kind kind NN 42759 5417 18 of of IN 42759 5417 19 woman woman NN 42759 5417 20 's 's POS 42759 5417 21 occupation occupation NN 42759 5417 22 , , , 42759 5417 23 the the DT 42759 5417 24 average average JJ 42759 5417 25 man man NN 42759 5417 26 is be VBZ 42759 5417 27 not not RB 42759 5417 28 worth worth JJ 42759 5417 29 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 5417 30 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5417 31 . . . 42759 5418 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 5418 2 , , , 42759 5418 3 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5418 4 can can MD 42759 5418 5 not not RB 42759 5418 6 hope hope VB 42759 5418 7 , , , 42759 5418 8 even even RB 42759 5418 9 with with IN 42759 5418 10 the the DT 42759 5418 11 aid aid NN 42759 5418 12 of of IN 42759 5418 13 a a DT 42759 5418 14 thorough thorough JJ 42759 5418 15 system system NN 42759 5418 16 of of IN 42759 5418 17 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5418 18 and and CC 42759 5418 19 vocational vocational JJ 42759 5418 20 training training NN 42759 5418 21 , , , 42759 5418 22 to to TO 42759 5418 23 provide provide VB 42759 5418 24 all all DT 42759 5418 25 adult adult NN 42759 5418 26 males male NNS 42759 5418 27 of of IN 42759 5418 28 average average JJ 42759 5418 29 capacity capacity NN 42759 5418 30 with with IN 42759 5418 31 a a DT 42759 5418 32 family family NN 42759 5418 33 living live VBG 42759 5418 34 wage wage NN 42759 5418 35 and and CC 42759 5418 36 the the DT 42759 5418 37 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5418 38 means mean NNS 42759 5418 39 of of IN 42759 5418 40 living live VBG 42759 5418 41 a a DT 42759 5418 42 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5418 43 life life NN 42759 5418 44 . . . 42759 5419 1 This this DT 42759 5419 2 is be VBZ 42759 5419 3 a a DT 42759 5419 4 veritable veritable JJ 42759 5419 5 counsel counsel NN 42759 5419 6 of of IN 42759 5419 7 despair despair NN 42759 5419 8 . . . 42759 5420 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5420 2 implies imply VBZ 42759 5420 3 either either CC 42759 5420 4 that that IN 42759 5420 5 the the DT 42759 5420 6 law law NN 42759 5420 7 of of IN 42759 5420 8 diminishing diminishing JJ 42759 5420 9 returns return NNS 42759 5420 10 is be VBZ 42759 5420 11 already already RB 42759 5420 12 operating operate VBG 42759 5420 13 in in IN 42759 5420 14 this this DT 42759 5420 15 country country NN 42759 5420 16 in in IN 42759 5420 17 such such PDT 42759 5420 18 a a DT 42759 5420 19 way way NN 42759 5420 20 as as IN 42759 5420 21 to to TO 42759 5420 22 prevent prevent VB 42759 5420 23 the the DT 42759 5420 24 national national JJ 42759 5420 25 product product NN 42759 5420 26 from from IN 42759 5420 27 being be VBG 42759 5420 28 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 5420 29 large large JJ 42759 5420 30 to to TO 42759 5420 31 provide provide VB 42759 5420 32 a a DT 42759 5420 33 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5420 34 wage wage NN 42759 5420 35 of of IN 42759 5420 36 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 5420 37 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5420 38 a a DT 42759 5420 39 week week NN 42759 5420 40 for for IN 42759 5420 41 men man NNS 42759 5420 42 , , , 42759 5420 43 and and CC 42759 5420 44 eight eight CD 42759 5420 45 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5420 46 a a DT 42759 5420 47 week week NN 42759 5420 48 for for IN 42759 5420 49 women woman NNS 42759 5420 50 ; ; : 42759 5420 51 or or CC 42759 5420 52 that that IN 42759 5420 53 the the DT 42759 5420 54 product product NN 42759 5420 55 , , , 42759 5420 56 though though IN 42759 5420 57 ample ample NN 42759 5420 58 for for IN 42759 5420 59 this this DT 42759 5420 60 purpose purpose NN 42759 5420 61 , , , 42759 5420 62 and and CC 42759 5420 63 for for IN 42759 5420 64 all all PDT 42759 5420 65 the the DT 42759 5420 66 other other JJ 42759 5420 67 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5420 68 payments payment NNS 42759 5420 69 to to IN 42759 5420 70 the the DT 42759 5420 71 higher high JJR 42759 5420 72 priced price VBN 42759 5420 73 workers worker NNS 42759 5420 74 and and CC 42759 5420 75 to to IN 42759 5420 76 the the DT 42759 5420 77 other other JJ 42759 5420 78 agents agent NNS 42759 5420 79 of of IN 42759 5420 80 production production NN 42759 5420 81 , , , 42759 5420 82 can can MD 42759 5420 83 not not RB 42759 5420 84 under under IN 42759 5420 85 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5420 86 present present JJ 42759 5420 87 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5420 88 system system NN 42759 5420 89 be be VB 42759 5420 90 so so RB 42759 5420 91 distributed distributed JJ 42759 5420 92 as as IN 42759 5420 93 to to TO 42759 5420 94 attain attain VB 42759 5420 95 the the DT 42759 5420 96 desired desire VBN 42759 5420 97 end end NN 42759 5420 98 . . . 42759 5421 1 For for IN 42759 5421 2 the the DT 42759 5421 3 first first JJ 42759 5421 4 of of IN 42759 5421 5 these these DT 42759 5421 6 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 42759 5421 7 there there EX 42759 5421 8 is be VBZ 42759 5421 9 no no DT 42759 5421 10 evidence evidence NN 42759 5421 11 worthy worthy JJ 42759 5421 12 of of IN 42759 5421 13 the the DT 42759 5421 14 name name NN 42759 5421 15 . . . 42759 5422 1 If if IN 42759 5422 2 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5422 3 King King NNP 42759 5422 4 is be VBZ 42759 5422 5 right right JJ 42759 5422 6 in in IN 42759 5422 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5422 8 estimate estimate NN 42759 5422 9 of of IN 42759 5422 10 an an DT 42759 5422 11 average average JJ 42759 5422 12 family family NN 42759 5422 13 income income NN 42759 5422 14 of of IN 42759 5422 15 1494 1494 CD 42759 5422 16 dollars dollar NNS 42759 5422 17 annually[266 annually[266 IN 42759 5422 18 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5422 19 the the DT 42759 5422 20 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 5422 21 before before IN 42759 5422 22 us -PRON- PRP 42759 5422 23 does do VBZ 42759 5422 24 not not RB 42759 5422 25 lie lie VB 42759 5422 26 in in IN 42759 5422 27 the the DT 42759 5422 28 field field NN 42759 5422 29 of of IN 42759 5422 30 production production NN 42759 5422 31 . . . 42759 5423 1 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5423 2 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 5423 3 seems seem VBZ 42759 5423 4 to to TO 42759 5423 5 rest rest VB 42759 5423 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5423 7 fears fear NNS 42759 5423 8 on on IN 42759 5423 9 the the DT 42759 5423 10 second second JJ 42759 5423 11 hypothesis hypothesis NN 42759 5423 12 , , , 42759 5423 13 on on IN 42759 5423 14 the the DT 42759 5423 15 assumed assumed JJ 42759 5423 16 impossibility impossibility NN 42759 5423 17 of of IN 42759 5423 18 bringing bring VBG 42759 5423 19 about about RP 42759 5423 20 the the DT 42759 5423 21 required require VBN 42759 5423 22 distribution distribution NN 42759 5423 23 ; ; , 42759 5423 24 for for IN 42759 5423 25 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5423 26 points point VBZ 42759 5423 27 out out RP 42759 5423 28 that that IN 42759 5423 29 increased increase VBN 42759 5423 30 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5423 31 of of IN 42759 5423 32 the the DT 42759 5423 33 workers worker NNS 42759 5423 34 may may MD 42759 5423 35 , , , 42759 5423 36 like like IN 42759 5423 37 increased increase VBN 42759 5423 38 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5423 39 of of IN 42759 5423 40 the the DT 42759 5423 41 material material JJ 42759 5423 42 instrumentalities instrumentality NNS 42759 5423 43 of of IN 42759 5423 44 production production NN 42759 5423 45 , , , 42759 5423 46 in in IN 42759 5423 47 the the DT 42759 5423 48 long long JJ 42759 5423 49 run run NN 42759 5423 50 redound redound NN 42759 5423 51 mainly mainly RB 42759 5423 52 to to IN 42759 5423 53 the the DT 42759 5423 54 benefit benefit NN 42759 5423 55 of of IN 42759 5423 56 the the DT 42759 5423 57 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5423 58 , , , 42759 5423 59 while while IN 42759 5423 60 wages wage NNS 42759 5423 61 may may MD 42759 5423 62 be be VB 42759 5423 63 little little JJ 42759 5423 64 if if IN 42759 5423 65 any any DT 42759 5423 66 above above IN 42759 5423 67 the the DT 42759 5423 68 old old JJ 42759 5423 69 level level NN 42759 5423 70 . . . 42759 5424 1 If if IN 42759 5424 2 these these DT 42759 5424 3 fears fear NNS 42759 5424 4 are be VBP 42759 5424 5 justified justify VBN 42759 5424 6 , , , 42759 5424 7 if if IN 42759 5424 8 the the DT 42759 5424 9 difficulty difficulty NN 42759 5424 10 is be VBZ 42759 5424 11 entirely entirely RB 42759 5424 12 one one CD 42759 5424 13 of of IN 42759 5424 14 the the DT 42759 5424 15 mechanism mechanism NN 42759 5424 16 of of IN 42759 5424 17 distribution distribution NN 42759 5424 18 , , , 42759 5424 19 and and CC 42759 5424 20 if if IN 42759 5424 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5424 22 can can MD 42759 5424 23 not not RB 42759 5424 24 be be VB 42759 5424 25 overcome overcome VBN 42759 5424 26 by by IN 42759 5424 27 legal legal JJ 42759 5424 28 enactment enactment NN 42759 5424 29 , , , 42759 5424 30 then then RB 42759 5424 31 is be VBZ 42759 5424 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5424 33 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5424 34 organisation organisation NN 42759 5424 35 of of IN 42759 5424 36 industry industry NN 42759 5424 37 bankrupt bankrupt JJ 42759 5424 38 , , , 42759 5424 39 and and CC 42759 5424 40 the the DT 42759 5424 41 sooner soon RBR 42759 5424 42 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5424 43 find find VBP 42759 5424 44 out out RP 42759 5424 45 that that IN 42759 5424 46 fact fact NN 42759 5424 47 definitely definitely RB 42759 5424 48 the the DT 42759 5424 49 better well JJR 42759 5424 50 . . . 42759 5425 1 If if IN 42759 5425 2 the the DT 42759 5425 3 legal legal JJ 42759 5425 4 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5425 5 wage wage NN 42759 5425 6 will will MD 42759 5425 7 help help VB 42759 5425 8 to to TO 42759 5425 9 expose expose VB 42759 5425 10 such such PDT 42759 5425 11 a a DT 42759 5425 12 situation situation NN 42759 5425 13 , , , 42759 5425 14 will will MD 42759 5425 15 show show VB 42759 5425 16 that that IN 42759 5425 17 , , , 42759 5425 18 no no RB 42759 5425 19 matter matter RB 42759 5425 20 how how WRB 42759 5425 21 much much JJ 42759 5425 22 the the DT 42759 5425 23 productivity productivity NN 42759 5425 24 of of IN 42759 5425 25 the the DT 42759 5425 26 workers worker NNS 42759 5425 27 may may MD 42759 5425 28 be be VB 42759 5425 29 increased increase VBN 42759 5425 30 , , , 42759 5425 31 a a DT 42759 5425 32 large large JJ 42759 5425 33 proportion proportion NN 42759 5425 34 of of IN 42759 5425 35 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5425 36 must must MD 42759 5425 37 by by IN 42759 5425 38 the the DT 42759 5425 39 very very JJ 42759 5425 40 nature nature NN 42759 5425 41 of of IN 42759 5425 42 the the DT 42759 5425 43 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5425 44 system system NN 42759 5425 45 be be VB 42759 5425 46 forever forever RB 42759 5425 47 condemned condemn VBN 42759 5425 48 to to TO 42759 5425 49 live live VB 42759 5425 50 below below IN 42759 5425 51 the the DT 42759 5425 52 level level NN 42759 5425 53 of of IN 42759 5425 54 decent decent JJ 42759 5425 55 existence existence NN 42759 5425 56 , , , 42759 5425 57 then then RB 42759 5425 58 the the DT 42759 5425 59 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5425 60 wage wage NN 42759 5425 61 is be VBZ 42759 5425 62 worth worth JJ 42759 5425 63 having have VBG 42759 5425 64 merely merely RB 42759 5425 65 as as IN 42759 5425 66 an an DT 42759 5425 67 instrument instrument NN 42759 5425 68 of of IN 42759 5425 69 economic economic JJ 42759 5425 70 enlightenment enlightenment NN 42759 5425 71 . . . 42759 5426 1 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5426 2 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 5426 3 's 's POS 42759 5426 4 argument argument NN 42759 5426 5 and and CC 42759 5426 6 illustrations[267 illustrations[267 NN 42759 5426 7 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5426 8 seem seem VB 42759 5426 9 to to TO 42759 5426 10 contemplate contemplate VB 42759 5426 11 a a DT 42759 5426 12 condition condition NN 42759 5426 13 in in IN 42759 5426 14 which which WDT 42759 5426 15 the the DT 42759 5426 16 number number NN 42759 5426 17 of of IN 42759 5426 18 women woman NNS 42759 5426 19 who who WP 42759 5426 20 become become VBP 42759 5426 21 fitted fit VBN 42759 5426 22 for for IN 42759 5426 23 a a DT 42759 5426 24 certain certain JJ 42759 5426 25 trade trade NN 42759 5426 26 is be VBZ 42759 5426 27 excessive excessive JJ 42759 5426 28 relatively relatively RB 42759 5426 29 to to IN 42759 5426 30 the the DT 42759 5426 31 demand demand NN 42759 5426 32 for for IN 42759 5426 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5426 34 products product NNS 42759 5426 35 , , , 42759 5426 36 and and CC 42759 5426 37 to to IN 42759 5426 38 the the DT 42759 5426 39 supply supply NN 42759 5426 40 of of IN 42759 5426 41 women woman NNS 42759 5426 42 in in IN 42759 5426 43 other other JJ 42759 5426 44 industries industry NNS 42759 5426 45 . . . 42759 5427 1 Were be VBD 42759 5427 2 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5427 3 training training NN 42759 5427 4 thus thus RB 42759 5427 5 misdirected misdirect VBD 42759 5427 6 , , , 42759 5427 7 and and CC 42759 5427 8 were be VBD 42759 5427 9 the the DT 42759 5427 10 trained train VBN 42759 5427 11 persons person NNS 42759 5427 12 unable unable JJ 42759 5427 13 or or CC 42759 5427 14 unwilling unwilling JJ 42759 5427 15 to to TO 42759 5427 16 distribute distribute VB 42759 5427 17 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 5427 18 over over IN 42759 5427 19 other other JJ 42759 5427 20 occupations occupation NNS 42759 5427 21 , , , 42759 5427 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5427 23 would would MD 42759 5427 24 , , , 42759 5427 25 indeed indeed RB 42759 5427 26 , , , 42759 5427 27 face face VBP 42759 5427 28 precisely precisely RB 42759 5427 29 the the DT 42759 5427 30 same same JJ 42759 5427 31 dilemma dilemma NN 42759 5427 32 as as IN 42759 5427 33 do do VBP 42759 5427 34 the the DT 42759 5427 35 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 5427 36 workers worker NNS 42759 5427 37 to to IN 42759 5427 38 - - HYPH 42759 5427 39 day day NN 42759 5427 40 . . . 42759 5428 1 That that DT 42759 5428 2 is is RB 42759 5428 3 ; ; : 42759 5428 4 a a DT 42759 5428 5 majority majority NN 42759 5428 6 would would MD 42759 5428 7 be be VB 42759 5428 8 condemned condemn VBN 42759 5428 9 to to IN 42759 5428 10 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 5428 11 wages wage NNS 42759 5428 12 , , , 42759 5428 13 or or CC 42759 5428 14 a a DT 42759 5428 15 minority minority NN 42759 5428 16 to to IN 42759 5428 17 unemployment unemployment NN 42759 5428 18 . . . 42759 5429 1 But but CC 42759 5429 2 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5429 3 have have VBP 42759 5429 4 been be VBN 42759 5429 5 assuming assume VBG 42759 5429 6 an an DT 42759 5429 7 _ _ NNP 42759 5429 8 adequate adequate JJ 42759 5429 9 _ _ NNP 42759 5429 10 system system NN 42759 5429 11 of of IN 42759 5429 12 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5429 13 and and CC 42759 5429 14 vocational vocational JJ 42759 5429 15 training training NN 42759 5429 16 , , , 42759 5429 17 a a DT 42759 5429 18 well well RB 42759 5429 19 - - HYPH 42759 5429 20 balanced balance VBN 42759 5429 21 system system NN 42759 5429 22 , , , 42759 5429 23 one one NN 42759 5429 24 that that WDT 42759 5429 25 would would MD 42759 5429 26 enable enable VB 42759 5429 27 the the DT 42759 5429 28 workers worker NNS 42759 5429 29 to to TO 42759 5429 30 adjust adjust VB 42759 5429 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5429 32 supply supply NN 42759 5429 33 to to IN 42759 5429 34 the the DT 42759 5429 35 demand demand NN 42759 5429 36 throughout throughout IN 42759 5429 37 the the DT 42759 5429 38 various various JJ 42759 5429 39 occupations occupation NNS 42759 5429 40 . . . 42759 5430 1 In in IN 42759 5430 2 these these DT 42759 5430 3 conditions condition NNS 42759 5430 4 the the DT 42759 5430 5 economic economic JJ 42759 5430 6 axiom axiom NN 42759 5430 7 that that IN 42759 5430 8 a a DT 42759 5430 9 supply supply NN 42759 5430 10 of of IN 42759 5430 11 goods good NNS 42759 5430 12 is be VBZ 42759 5430 13 a a DT 42759 5430 14 demand demand NN 42759 5430 15 for for IN 42759 5430 16 goods good NNS 42759 5430 17 should should MD 42759 5430 18 become become VB 42759 5430 19 beneficently beneficently RB 42759 5430 20 effective effective JJ 42759 5430 21 : : : 42759 5430 22 the the DT 42759 5430 23 workers worker NNS 42759 5430 24 should should MD 42759 5430 25 all all DT 42759 5430 26 be be VB 42759 5430 27 able able JJ 42759 5430 28 to to TO 42759 5430 29 find find VB 42759 5430 30 employment employment NN 42759 5430 31 , , , 42759 5430 32 and and CC 42759 5430 33 to to TO 42759 5430 34 obtain obtain VB 42759 5430 35 the the DT 42759 5430 36 greater great JJR 42759 5430 37 part part NN 42759 5430 38 of of IN 42759 5430 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5430 40 increased increase VBN 42759 5430 41 product product NN 42759 5430 42 . . . 42759 5431 1 Surely surely RB 42759 5431 2 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5431 3 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 5431 4 does do VBZ 42759 5431 5 not not RB 42759 5431 6 mean mean VB 42759 5431 7 to to TO 42759 5431 8 commit commit VB 42759 5431 9 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 5431 10 to to IN 42759 5431 11 the the DT 42759 5431 12 view view NN 42759 5431 13 that that IN 42759 5431 14 every every DT 42759 5431 15 increase increase NN 42759 5431 16 in in IN 42759 5431 17 the the DT 42759 5431 18 productive productive JJ 42759 5431 19 power power NN 42759 5431 20 of of IN 42759 5431 21 the the DT 42759 5431 22 workers worker NNS 42759 5431 23 will will MD 42759 5431 24 in in IN 42759 5431 25 the the DT 42759 5431 26 long long JJ 42759 5431 27 run run NN 42759 5431 28 help help NN 42759 5431 29 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5431 30 only only RB 42759 5431 31 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 5431 32 as as IN 42759 5431 33 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5431 34 are be VBP 42759 5431 35 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5431 36 , , , 42759 5431 37 the the DT 42759 5431 38 lion lion NN 42759 5431 39 's 's POS 42759 5431 40 share share NN 42759 5431 41 of of IN 42759 5431 42 the the DT 42759 5431 43 additional additional JJ 42759 5431 44 product product NN 42759 5431 45 being be VBG 42759 5431 46 taken take VBN 42759 5431 47 by by IN 42759 5431 48 other other JJ 42759 5431 49 classes class NNS 42759 5431 50 . . . 42759 5432 1 Probably probably RB 42759 5432 2 such such JJ 42759 5432 3 is be VBZ 42759 5432 4 the the DT 42759 5432 5 usual usual JJ 42759 5432 6 result result NN 42759 5432 7 in in IN 42759 5432 8 a a DT 42759 5432 9 régime régime NN 42759 5432 10 of of IN 42759 5432 11 unregulated unregulated JJ 42759 5432 12 competition competition NN 42759 5432 13 , , , 42759 5432 14 and and CC 42759 5432 15 unlimited unlimited JJ 42759 5432 16 freedom freedom NN 42759 5432 17 as as IN 42759 5432 18 regards regard VBZ 42759 5432 19 the the DT 42759 5432 20 wage wage NN 42759 5432 21 contract contract NN 42759 5432 22 . . . 42759 5433 1 But but CC 42759 5433 2 this this DT 42759 5433 3 is be VBZ 42759 5433 4 precisely precisely RB 42759 5433 5 what what WP 42759 5433 6 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5433 7 expect expect VBP 42759 5433 8 a a DT 42759 5433 9 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5433 10 wage wage NN 42759 5433 11 law law NN 42759 5433 12 to to TO 42759 5433 13 correct correct VB 42759 5433 14 and and CC 42759 5433 15 prevent prevent VB 42759 5433 16 . . . 42759 5434 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 5434 2 rely rely VBP 42759 5434 3 upon upon IN 42759 5434 4 this this DT 42759 5434 5 device device NN 42759 5434 6 to to TO 42759 5434 7 enable enable VB 42759 5434 8 the the DT 42759 5434 9 workers worker NNS 42759 5434 10 to to TO 42759 5434 11 retain retain VB 42759 5434 12 for for IN 42759 5434 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 5434 14 that that DT 42759 5434 15 share share NN 42759 5434 16 of of IN 42759 5434 17 the the DT 42759 5434 18 product product NN 42759 5434 19 which which WDT 42759 5434 20 under under IN 42759 5434 21 free free JJ 42759 5434 22 competition competition NN 42759 5434 23 would would MD 42759 5434 24 automatically automatically RB 42759 5434 25 go go VB 42759 5434 26 to to IN 42759 5434 27 the the DT 42759 5434 28 non non JJ 42759 5434 29 - - JJ 42759 5434 30 labouring labouring JJ 42759 5434 31 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5434 32 . . . 42759 5435 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 5435 2 hope hope VBP 42759 5435 3 that that IN 42759 5435 4 blind blind JJ 42759 5435 5 and and CC 42759 5435 6 destructive destructive JJ 42759 5435 7 economic economic JJ 42759 5435 8 force force NN 42759 5435 9 can can MD 42759 5435 10 be be VB 42759 5435 11 held hold VBN 42759 5435 12 in in IN 42759 5435 13 check check NN 42759 5435 14 by by IN 42759 5435 15 deliberate deliberate JJ 42759 5435 16 and and CC 42759 5435 17 beneficent beneficent JJ 42759 5435 18 social social JJ 42759 5435 19 control control NN 42759 5435 20 . . . 42759 5436 1 The the DT 42759 5436 2 fact fact NN 42759 5436 3 of of IN 42759 5436 4 the the DT 42759 5436 5 matter matter NN 42759 5436 6 seems seem VBZ 42759 5436 7 to to TO 42759 5436 8 be be VB 42759 5436 9 that that IN 42759 5436 10 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5436 11 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 5436 12 's 's POS 42759 5436 13 argument argument NN 42759 5436 14 is be VBZ 42759 5436 15 too too RB 42759 5436 16 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 42759 5436 17 and and CC 42759 5436 18 conjectural conjectural JJ 42759 5436 19 to to TO 42759 5436 20 justify justify VB 42759 5436 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5436 22 pessimistic pessimistic JJ 42759 5436 23 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 5436 24 . . . 42759 5437 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5437 2 is be VBZ 42759 5437 3 unpleasantly unpleasantly RB 42759 5437 4 suggestive suggestive JJ 42759 5437 5 of of IN 42759 5437 6 the the DT 42759 5437 7 reasoning reasoning NN 42759 5437 8 by by IN 42759 5437 9 which which WDT 42759 5437 10 the the DT 42759 5437 11 classical classical JJ 42759 5437 12 economists economist NNS 42759 5437 13 tried try VBD 42759 5437 14 to to TO 42759 5437 15 show show VB 42759 5437 16 the the DT 42759 5437 17 English English NNP 42759 5437 18 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5437 19 the the DT 42759 5437 20 folly folly NN 42759 5437 21 and and CC 42759 5437 22 futility futility NN 42759 5437 23 of of IN 42759 5437 24 trade trade NN 42759 5437 25 unionism unionism NN 42759 5437 26 . . . 42759 5438 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5438 2 Other Other NNP 42759 5438 3 Legislative Legislative NNP 42759 5438 4 Proposals Proposals NNPS 42759 5438 5 _ _ NNP 42759 5438 6 The the DT 42759 5438 7 ideal ideal JJ 42759 5438 8 standard standard NN 42759 5438 9 of of IN 42759 5438 10 a a DT 42759 5438 11 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5438 12 wage wage NN 42759 5438 13 law law NN 42759 5438 14 is be VBZ 42759 5438 15 a a DT 42759 5438 16 scale scale NN 42759 5438 17 of of IN 42759 5438 18 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5438 19 adequate adequate JJ 42759 5438 20 not not RB 42759 5438 21 only only RB 42759 5438 22 to to IN 42759 5438 23 the the DT 42759 5438 24 present present JJ 42759 5438 25 needs need NNS 42759 5438 26 of of IN 42759 5438 27 individuals individual NNS 42759 5438 28 and and CC 42759 5438 29 families family NNS 42759 5438 30 , , , 42759 5438 31 but but CC 42759 5438 32 to to IN 42759 5438 33 savings saving NNS 42759 5438 34 for for IN 42759 5438 35 the the DT 42759 5438 36 contingencies contingency NNS 42759 5438 37 of of IN 42759 5438 38 the the DT 42759 5438 39 future future NN 42759 5438 40 . . . 42759 5439 1 Until until IN 42759 5439 2 such such JJ 42759 5439 3 time time NN 42759 5439 4 as as IN 42759 5439 5 the the DT 42759 5439 6 compensation compensation NN 42759 5439 7 of of IN 42759 5439 8 all all DT 42759 5439 9 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5439 10 has have VBZ 42759 5439 11 been be VBN 42759 5439 12 brought bring VBN 42759 5439 13 up up RP 42759 5439 14 to to IN 42759 5439 15 this this DT 42759 5439 16 level level NN 42759 5439 17 , , , 42759 5439 18 the the DT 42759 5439 19 State state NN 42759 5439 20 should should MD 42759 5439 21 make make VB 42759 5439 22 provision provision NN 42759 5439 23 for for IN 42759 5439 24 cheap cheap JJ 42759 5439 25 housing housing NN 42759 5439 26 , , , 42759 5439 27 and and CC 42759 5439 28 for for IN 42759 5439 29 insurance insurance NN 42759 5439 30 against against IN 42759 5439 31 accidents accident NNS 42759 5439 32 , , , 42759 5439 33 sickness sickness NN 42759 5439 34 , , , 42759 5439 35 invalidity invalidity NN 42759 5439 36 , , , 42759 5439 37 old old JJ 42759 5439 38 age age NN 42759 5439 39 , , , 42759 5439 40 and and CC 42759 5439 41 unemployment unemployment NN 42759 5439 42 . . . 42759 5440 1 The the DT 42759 5440 2 theory theory NN 42759 5440 3 underlying underlie VBG 42759 5440 4 such such JJ 42759 5440 5 measures measure NNS 42759 5440 6 is be VBZ 42759 5440 7 that that IN 42759 5440 8 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5440 9 would would MD 42759 5440 10 merely merely RB 42759 5440 11 supplement supplement VB 42759 5440 12 insufficient insufficient JJ 42759 5440 13 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5440 14 , , , 42759 5440 15 and and CC 42759 5440 16 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 5440 17 contribute contribute VB 42759 5440 18 to to IN 42759 5440 19 the the DT 42759 5440 20 establishment establishment NN 42759 5440 21 of of IN 42759 5440 22 genuine genuine JJ 42759 5440 23 living living NN 42759 5440 24 wages wage NNS 42759 5440 25 . . . 42759 5441 1 In in IN 42759 5441 2 Europe Europe NNP 42759 5441 3 , , , 42759 5441 4 housing housing NN 42759 5441 5 and and CC 42759 5441 6 insurance insurance NN 42759 5441 7 legislation legislation NN 42759 5441 8 is be VBZ 42759 5441 9 so so RB 42759 5441 10 common common JJ 42759 5441 11 that that IN 42759 5441 12 no no DT 42759 5441 13 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5441 14 and and CC 42759 5441 15 intelligent intelligent JJ 42759 5441 16 person person NN 42759 5441 17 any any RB 42759 5441 18 longer long JJR 42759 5441 19 questions question NNS 42759 5441 20 the the DT 42759 5441 21 competency competency NN 42759 5441 22 or or CC 42759 5441 23 propriety propriety NN 42759 5441 24 of of IN 42759 5441 25 such such JJ 42759 5441 26 action action NN 42759 5441 27 by by IN 42759 5441 28 the the DT 42759 5441 29 State State NNP 42759 5441 30 . . . 42759 5442 1 If if IN 42759 5442 2 an an DT 42759 5442 3 adequate adequate JJ 42759 5442 4 legal legal JJ 42759 5442 5 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5442 6 wage wage NN 42759 5442 7 , , , 42759 5442 8 in in IN 42759 5442 9 the the DT 42759 5442 10 sense sense NN 42759 5442 11 just just RB 42759 5442 12 defined define VBN 42759 5442 13 , , , 42759 5442 14 were be VBD 42759 5442 15 universally universally RB 42759 5442 16 established establish VBN 42759 5442 17 , , , 42759 5442 18 the the DT 42759 5442 19 State State NNP 42759 5442 20 would would MD 42759 5442 21 not not RB 42759 5442 22 be be VB 42759 5442 23 required require VBN 42759 5442 24 to to TO 42759 5442 25 do do VB 42759 5442 26 anything anything NN 42759 5442 27 further further RB 42759 5442 28 to to TO 42759 5442 29 effectuate effectuate VB 42759 5442 30 wage wage NN 42759 5442 31 justice justice NN 42759 5442 32 , , , 42759 5442 33 except except IN 42759 5442 34 in in IN 42759 5442 35 the the DT 42759 5442 36 matter matter NN 42759 5442 37 of of IN 42759 5442 38 vocational vocational JJ 42759 5442 39 and and CC 42759 5442 40 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5442 41 education education NN 42759 5442 42 . . . 42759 5443 1 This this DT 42759 5443 2 would would MD 42759 5443 3 qualify qualify VB 42759 5443 4 practically practically RB 42759 5443 5 all all DT 42759 5443 6 persons person NNS 42759 5443 7 to to TO 42759 5443 8 earn earn VB 42759 5443 9 at at IN 42759 5443 10 least least JJS 42759 5443 11 a a DT 42759 5443 12 living living NN 42759 5443 13 wage wage NN 42759 5443 14 , , , 42759 5443 15 and and CC 42759 5443 16 would would MD 42759 5443 17 enable enable VB 42759 5443 18 those those DT 42759 5443 19 who who WP 42759 5443 20 underwent undergo VBD 42759 5443 21 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5443 22 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5443 23 either either CC 42759 5443 24 before before IN 42759 5443 25 or or CC 42759 5443 26 during during IN 42759 5443 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5443 28 employment employment NN 42759 5443 29 to to TO 42759 5443 30 command command VB 42759 5443 31 something something NN 42759 5443 32 over over IN 42759 5443 33 and and CC 42759 5443 34 above above RB 42759 5443 35 . . . 42759 5444 1 In in IN 42759 5444 2 other other JJ 42759 5444 3 words word NNS 42759 5444 4 , , , 42759 5444 5 all all DT 42759 5444 6 workers worker NNS 42759 5444 7 would would MD 42759 5444 8 then then RB 42759 5444 9 be be VB 42759 5444 10 able able JJ 42759 5444 11 to to TO 42759 5444 12 obtain obtain VB 42759 5444 13 what what WP 42759 5444 14 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5444 15 have have VBP 42759 5444 16 called call VBN 42759 5444 17 " " `` 42759 5444 18 the the DT 42759 5444 19 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5444 20 minimum minimum NN 42759 5444 21 . . . 42759 5444 22 " " '' 42759 5445 1 And and CC 42759 5445 2 the the DT 42759 5445 3 labouring labour VBG 42759 5445 4 class class NN 42759 5445 5 as as IN 42759 5445 6 a a DT 42759 5445 7 whole whole NN 42759 5445 8 would would MD 42759 5445 9 possess possess VB 42759 5445 10 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5445 11 economic economic JJ 42759 5445 12 power power NN 42759 5445 13 to to TO 42759 5445 14 secure secure VB 42759 5445 15 substantially substantially RB 42759 5445 16 all all DT 42759 5445 17 that that WDT 42759 5445 18 was be VBD 42759 5445 19 due due JJ 42759 5445 20 by by IN 42759 5445 21 any any DT 42759 5445 22 of of IN 42759 5445 23 the the DT 42759 5445 24 canons canon NNS 42759 5445 25 of of IN 42759 5445 26 distributive distributive JJ 42759 5445 27 justice justice NN 42759 5445 28 . . . 42759 5446 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5446 2 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5446 3 Unions Unions NNPS 42759 5446 4 _ _ NNP 42759 5446 5 The the DT 42759 5446 6 general general JJ 42759 5446 7 benefits benefit NNS 42759 5446 8 and and CC 42759 5446 9 achievements achievement NNS 42759 5446 10 of of IN 42759 5446 11 labour labour JJ 42759 5446 12 organisations organisation NNS 42759 5446 13 in in IN 42759 5446 14 the the DT 42759 5446 15 United United NNP 42759 5446 16 States States NNP 42759 5446 17 down down RP 42759 5446 18 to to IN 42759 5446 19 the the DT 42759 5446 20 beginning beginning NN 42759 5446 21 of of IN 42759 5446 22 the the DT 42759 5446 23 present present JJ 42759 5446 24 century century NN 42759 5446 25 , , , 42759 5446 26 can can MD 42759 5446 27 not not RB 42759 5446 28 be be VB 42759 5446 29 more more RBR 42759 5446 30 succinctly succinctly RB 42759 5446 31 nor nor CC 42759 5446 32 more more RBR 42759 5446 33 authoritatively authoritatively RB 42759 5446 34 stated state VBN 42759 5446 35 than than IN 42759 5446 36 in in IN 42759 5446 37 the the DT 42759 5446 38 words word NNS 42759 5446 39 of of IN 42759 5446 40 the the DT 42759 5446 41 United United NNP 42759 5446 42 States States NNP 42759 5446 43 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 5446 44 Commission Commission NNP 42759 5446 45 : : : 42759 5446 46 " " `` 42759 5446 47 An an DT 42759 5446 48 overwhelming overwhelming JJ 42759 5446 49 preponderance preponderance NN 42759 5446 50 of of IN 42759 5446 51 testimony testimony NN 42759 5446 52 before before IN 42759 5446 53 the the DT 42759 5446 54 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 5446 55 Commission Commission NNP 42759 5446 56 indicates indicate VBZ 42759 5446 57 that that IN 42759 5446 58 the the DT 42759 5446 59 organisation organisation NNP 42759 5446 60 of of IN 42759 5446 61 labour labour NNP 42759 5446 62 has have VBZ 42759 5446 63 resulted result VBN 42759 5446 64 in in IN 42759 5446 65 a a DT 42759 5446 66 marked marked JJ 42759 5446 67 improvement improvement NN 42759 5446 68 in in IN 42759 5446 69 the the DT 42759 5446 70 economic economic JJ 42759 5446 71 condition condition NN 42759 5446 72 of of IN 42759 5446 73 the the DT 42759 5446 74 workers worker NNS 42759 5446 75 . . . 42759 5447 1 " " `` 42759 5447 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5447 3 268 268 CD 42759 5447 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5447 5 Some some DT 42759 5447 6 of of IN 42759 5447 7 the the DT 42759 5447 8 most most RBS 42759 5447 9 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 42759 5447 10 and and CC 42759 5447 11 unquestionable unquestionable JJ 42759 5447 12 proofs proof NNS 42759 5447 13 of of IN 42759 5447 14 rises rise NNS 42759 5447 15 in in IN 42759 5447 16 wages wage NNS 42759 5447 17 effected effect VBN 42759 5447 18 by by IN 42759 5447 19 the the DT 42759 5447 20 unions union NNS 42759 5447 21 are be VBP 42759 5447 22 afforded afford VBN 42759 5447 23 by by IN 42759 5447 24 the the DT 42759 5447 25 building building NN 42759 5447 26 trades trade NNS 42759 5447 27 , , , 42759 5447 28 the the DT 42759 5447 29 printing printing NN 42759 5447 30 trades trade NNS 42759 5447 31 , , , 42759 5447 32 the the DT 42759 5447 33 coal coal NN 42759 5447 34 mining mining NN 42759 5447 35 industry industry NN 42759 5447 36 , , , 42759 5447 37 and and CC 42759 5447 38 the the DT 42759 5447 39 more more RBR 42759 5447 40 skilled skilled JJ 42759 5447 41 occupations occupation NNS 42759 5447 42 on on IN 42759 5447 43 the the DT 42759 5447 44 railroads railroad NNS 42759 5447 45 . . . 42759 5448 1 Between between IN 42759 5448 2 1890 1890 CD 42759 5448 3 and and CC 42759 5448 4 1907 1907 CD 42759 5448 5 wages wage NNS 42759 5448 6 increased increase VBD 42759 5448 7 considerably considerably RB 42759 5448 8 more more RBR 42759 5448 9 in in IN 42759 5448 10 the the DT 42759 5448 11 organised organised JJ 42759 5448 12 than than IN 42759 5448 13 in in IN 42759 5448 14 the the DT 42759 5448 15 unorganised unorganised JJ 42759 5448 16 trades trade NNS 42759 5448 17 . . . 42759 5449 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5449 2 269 269 CD 42759 5449 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5449 4 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 5449 5 , , , 42759 5449 6 when when WRB 42759 5449 7 all all DT 42759 5449 8 due due JJ 42759 5449 9 credit credit NN 42759 5449 10 is be VBZ 42759 5449 11 given give VBN 42759 5449 12 to to IN 42759 5449 13 the the DT 42759 5449 14 unions union NNS 42759 5449 15 for for IN 42759 5449 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5449 17 part part NN 42759 5449 18 in in IN 42759 5449 19 augmenting augment VBG 42759 5449 20 the the DT 42759 5449 21 share share NN 42759 5449 22 of of IN 42759 5449 23 the the DT 42759 5449 24 product product NN 42759 5449 25 received receive VBN 42759 5449 26 by by IN 42759 5449 27 labour labour NN 42759 5449 28 , , , 42759 5449 29 there there EX 42759 5449 30 remain remain VBP 42759 5449 31 two two CD 42759 5449 32 important important JJ 42759 5449 33 obstacles obstacle NNS 42759 5449 34 which which WDT 42759 5449 35 seriously seriously RB 42759 5449 36 lessen lessen VBD 42759 5449 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5449 38 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 5449 39 as as IN 42759 5449 40 a a DT 42759 5449 41 means means NN 42759 5449 42 of of IN 42759 5449 43 raising raise VBG 42759 5449 44 the the DT 42759 5449 45 wages wage NNS 42759 5449 46 of of IN 42759 5449 47 the the DT 42759 5449 48 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5449 49 . . . 42759 5450 1 The the DT 42759 5450 2 first first JJ 42759 5450 3 is be VBZ 42759 5450 4 the the DT 42759 5450 5 fact fact NN 42759 5450 6 that that IN 42759 5450 7 the the DT 42759 5450 8 unions union NNS 42759 5450 9 still still RB 42759 5450 10 embrace embrace VBP 42759 5450 11 only only RB 42759 5450 12 a a DT 42759 5450 13 small small JJ 42759 5450 14 portion portion NN 42759 5450 15 of of IN 42759 5450 16 the the DT 42759 5450 17 total total JJ 42759 5450 18 number number NN 42759 5450 19 of of IN 42759 5450 20 wage wage NN 42759 5450 21 earners earner NNS 42759 5450 22 . . . 42759 5451 1 According accord VBG 42759 5451 2 to to IN 42759 5451 3 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5451 4 Leo Leo NNP 42759 5451 5 Wolman Wolman NNP 42759 5451 6 , , , 42759 5451 7 a a DT 42759 5451 8 little little JJ 42759 5451 9 more more JJR 42759 5451 10 than than IN 42759 5451 11 twenty twenty CD 42759 5451 12 - - HYPH 42759 5451 13 seven seven CD 42759 5451 14 million million CD 42759 5451 15 of of IN 42759 5451 16 the the DT 42759 5451 17 thirty thirty CD 42759 5451 18 - - HYPH 42759 5451 19 eight eight CD 42759 5451 20 million million CD 42759 5451 21 persons person NNS 42759 5451 22 engaged engage VBN 42759 5451 23 in in IN 42759 5451 24 " " `` 42759 5451 25 gainful gainful JJ 42759 5451 26 occupations occupation NNS 42759 5451 27 " " '' 42759 5451 28 in in IN 42759 5451 29 the the DT 42759 5451 30 United United NNP 42759 5451 31 States States NNP 42759 5451 32 in in IN 42759 5451 33 1910 1910 CD 42759 5451 34 were be VBD 42759 5451 35 wage wage NN 42759 5451 36 earners earner NNS 42759 5451 37 in in IN 42759 5451 38 the the DT 42759 5451 39 ordinary ordinary JJ 42759 5451 40 sense sense NN 42759 5451 41 of of IN 42759 5451 42 that that DT 42759 5451 43 phrase phrase NN 42759 5451 44 , , , 42759 5451 45 and and CC 42759 5451 46 of of IN 42759 5451 47 these these DT 42759 5451 48 twenty twenty CD 42759 5451 49 - - HYPH 42759 5451 50 seven seven CD 42759 5451 51 million million CD 42759 5451 52 only only RB 42759 5451 53 2,116,317 2,116,317 CD 42759 5451 54 , , , 42759 5451 55 or or CC 42759 5451 56 7.7 7.7 CD 42759 5451 57 per per IN 42759 5451 58 cent cent NN 42759 5451 59 . . . 42759 5451 60 , , , 42759 5451 61 were be VBD 42759 5451 62 members member NNS 42759 5451 63 of of IN 42759 5451 64 labour labour JJ 42759 5451 65 organisations organisation NNS 42759 5451 66 . . . 42759 5452 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5452 2 270 270 CD 42759 5452 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5452 4 The the DT 42759 5452 5 membership membership NN 42759 5452 6 to to NN 42759 5452 7 - - HYPH 42759 5452 8 day day NN 42759 5452 9 is be VBZ 42759 5452 10 about about RB 42759 5452 11 two two CD 42759 5452 12 and and CC 42759 5452 13 three three CD 42759 5452 14 quarter quarter NN 42759 5452 15 millions million NNS 42759 5452 16 . . . 42759 5453 1 If if IN 42759 5453 2 the the DT 42759 5453 3 total total JJ 42759 5453 4 number number NN 42759 5453 5 of of IN 42759 5453 6 wage wage NN 42759 5453 7 earners earner NNS 42759 5453 8 increased increase VBD 42759 5453 9 between between IN 42759 5453 10 1910 1910 CD 42759 5453 11 and and CC 42759 5453 12 1916 1916 CD 42759 5453 13 at at IN 42759 5453 14 the the DT 42759 5453 15 same same JJ 42759 5453 16 rate rate NN 42759 5453 17 as as IN 42759 5453 18 during during IN 42759 5453 19 the the DT 42759 5453 20 preceding precede VBG 42759 5453 21 decade decade NN 42759 5453 22 , , , 42759 5453 23 the the DT 42759 5453 24 organised organise VBN 42759 5453 25 portion portion NN 42759 5453 26 is be VBZ 42759 5453 27 now now RB 42759 5453 28 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 5453 29 less less JJR 42759 5453 30 than than IN 42759 5453 31 7.7 7.7 CD 42759 5453 32 per per IN 42759 5453 33 cent cent NN 42759 5453 34 . . . 42759 5454 1 of of IN 42759 5454 2 the the DT 42759 5454 3 whole whole NN 42759 5454 4 . . . 42759 5455 1 Evidently evidently RB 42759 5455 2 the the DT 42759 5455 3 labour labour JJ 42759 5455 4 unions union NNS 42759 5455 5 have have VBP 42759 5455 6 not not RB 42759 5455 7 grown grow VBN 42759 5455 8 with with IN 42759 5455 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5455 10 rapidity rapidity NN 42759 5455 11 , , , 42759 5455 12 nor nor CC 42759 5455 13 are be VBP 42759 5455 14 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5455 15 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 5455 16 powerful powerful JJ 42759 5455 17 to to TO 42759 5455 18 warrant warrant VB 42759 5455 19 the the DT 42759 5455 20 hope hope NN 42759 5455 21 that that IN 42759 5455 22 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5455 23 will will MD 42759 5455 24 be be VB 42759 5455 25 soon soon RB 42759 5455 26 able able JJ 42759 5455 27 to to TO 42759 5455 28 lift lift VB 42759 5455 29 even even RB 42759 5455 30 a a DT 42759 5455 31 majority majority NN 42759 5455 32 of of IN 42759 5455 33 the the DT 42759 5455 34 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5455 35 workers worker NNS 42759 5455 36 to to IN 42759 5455 37 the the DT 42759 5455 38 level level NN 42759 5455 39 of of IN 42759 5455 40 living live VBG 42759 5455 41 wage wage NN 42759 5455 42 conditions condition NNS 42759 5455 43 . . . 42759 5456 1 The the DT 42759 5456 2 second second JJ 42759 5456 3 obstacle obstacle NN 42759 5456 4 is be VBZ 42759 5456 5 the the DT 42759 5456 6 fact fact NN 42759 5456 7 that that IN 42759 5456 8 only only RB 42759 5456 9 a a DT 42759 5456 10 small small JJ 42759 5456 11 minority minority NN 42759 5456 12 of of IN 42759 5456 13 the the DT 42759 5456 14 members member NNS 42759 5456 15 of of IN 42759 5456 16 labour labour JJ 42759 5456 17 unions union NNS 42759 5456 18 are be VBP 42759 5456 19 drawn draw VBN 42759 5456 20 from from IN 42759 5456 21 the the DT 42759 5456 22 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 5456 23 and and CC 42759 5456 24 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5456 25 classes class NNS 42759 5456 26 , , , 42759 5456 27 who who WP 42759 5456 28 stand stand VBP 42759 5456 29 most most RBS 42759 5456 30 in in IN 42759 5456 31 need need NN 42759 5456 32 of of IN 42759 5456 33 organisation organisation NN 42759 5456 34 . . . 42759 5457 1 The the DT 42759 5457 2 per per IN 42759 5457 3 cent cent NN 42759 5457 4 . . . 42759 5458 1 of of IN 42759 5458 2 those those DT 42759 5458 3 getting get VBG 42759 5458 4 less less JJR 42759 5458 5 than than IN 42759 5458 6 living live VBG 42759 5458 7 wages wage NNS 42759 5458 8 that that WDT 42759 5458 9 is be VBZ 42759 5458 10 in in IN 42759 5458 11 the the DT 42759 5458 12 unions union NNS 42759 5458 13 is be VBZ 42759 5458 14 almost almost RB 42759 5458 15 negligible negligible JJ 42759 5458 16 . . . 42759 5459 1 With with IN 42759 5459 2 the the DT 42759 5459 3 exception exception NN 42759 5459 4 of of IN 42759 5459 5 a a DT 42759 5459 6 few few JJ 42759 5459 7 industries industry NNS 42759 5459 8 , , , 42759 5459 9 the the DT 42759 5459 10 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 5459 11 and and CC 42759 5459 12 the the DT 42759 5459 13 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5459 14 show show VBP 42759 5459 15 very very RB 42759 5459 16 little little JJ 42759 5459 17 tendency tendency NN 42759 5459 18 to to TO 42759 5459 19 increase increase VB 42759 5459 20 notably notably RB 42759 5459 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5459 22 organised organised JJ 42759 5459 23 proportion proportion NN 42759 5459 24 . . . 42759 5460 1 The the DT 42759 5460 2 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 5460 3 reason reason NN 42759 5460 4 of of IN 42759 5460 5 this this DT 42759 5460 6 condition condition NN 42759 5460 7 has have VBZ 42759 5460 8 been be VBN 42759 5460 9 well well RB 42759 5460 10 stated state VBN 42759 5460 11 by by IN 42759 5460 12 John John NNP 42759 5460 13 A. A. NNP 42759 5460 14 Hobson Hobson NNP 42759 5460 15 : : : 42759 5460 16 " " `` 42759 5460 17 The the DT 42759 5460 18 great great JJ 42759 5460 19 problem problem NN 42759 5460 20 of of IN 42759 5460 21 poverty poverty NN 42759 5460 22 ... ... : 42759 5460 23 resides reside NNS 42759 5460 24 in in IN 42759 5460 25 the the DT 42759 5460 26 conditions condition NNS 42759 5460 27 of of IN 42759 5460 28 the the DT 42759 5460 29 low low JJ 42759 5460 30 - - HYPH 42759 5460 31 skilled skilled JJ 42759 5460 32 workman workman NN 42759 5460 33 . . . 42759 5461 1 To to TO 42759 5461 2 live live VB 42759 5461 3 industrially industrially RB 42759 5461 4 under under IN 42759 5461 5 the the DT 42759 5461 6 new new JJ 42759 5461 7 order order NN 42759 5461 8 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5461 9 must must MD 42759 5461 10 organise organise VB 42759 5461 11 . . . 42759 5462 1 He -PRON- PRP 42759 5462 2 can can MD 42759 5462 3 not not RB 42759 5462 4 organise organise VB 42759 5462 5 because because IN 42759 5462 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5462 7 is be VBZ 42759 5462 8 so so RB 42759 5462 9 poor poor JJ 42759 5462 10 , , , 42759 5462 11 so so RB 42759 5462 12 ignorant ignorant JJ 42759 5462 13 , , , 42759 5462 14 so so RB 42759 5462 15 weak weak JJ 42759 5462 16 . . . 42759 5463 1 Because because IN 42759 5463 2 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5463 3 is be VBZ 42759 5463 4 not not RB 42759 5463 5 organised organise VBN 42759 5463 6 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5463 7 continues continue VBZ 42759 5463 8 to to TO 42759 5463 9 be be VB 42759 5463 10 poor poor JJ 42759 5463 11 , , , 42759 5463 12 ignorant ignorant JJ 42759 5463 13 , , , 42759 5463 14 weak weak JJ 42759 5463 15 . . . 42759 5464 1 Here here RB 42759 5464 2 is be VBZ 42759 5464 3 a a DT 42759 5464 4 great great JJ 42759 5464 5 dilemma dilemma NN 42759 5464 6 , , , 42759 5464 7 of of IN 42759 5464 8 which which WDT 42759 5464 9 whoever whoever WP 42759 5464 10 shall shall MD 42759 5464 11 have have VB 42759 5464 12 found find VBN 42759 5464 13 the the DT 42759 5464 14 key key NN 42759 5464 15 will will MD 42759 5464 16 have have VB 42759 5464 17 done do VBN 42759 5464 18 much much RB 42759 5464 19 to to TO 42759 5464 20 solve solve VB 42759 5464 21 the the DT 42759 5464 22 problem problem NN 42759 5464 23 of of IN 42759 5464 24 poverty poverty NN 42759 5464 25 . . . 42759 5465 1 " " `` 42759 5465 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5465 3 271 271 CD 42759 5465 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5465 5 The the DT 42759 5465 6 most most RBS 42759 5465 7 effective effective JJ 42759 5465 8 and and CC 42759 5465 9 expeditious expeditious JJ 42759 5465 10 method method NN 42759 5465 11 of of IN 42759 5465 12 raising raise VBG 42759 5465 13 the the DT 42759 5465 14 wages wage NNS 42759 5465 15 of of IN 42759 5465 16 the the DT 42759 5465 17 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5465 18 through through IN 42759 5465 19 organisation organisation NN 42759 5465 20 is be VBZ 42759 5465 21 by by IN 42759 5465 22 means mean NNS 42759 5465 23 of of IN 42759 5465 24 the the DT 42759 5465 25 " " `` 42759 5465 26 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5465 27 , , , 42759 5465 28 " " '' 42759 5465 29 as as IN 42759 5465 30 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 5465 31 from from IN 42759 5465 32 the the DT 42759 5465 33 " " `` 42759 5465 34 trade trade NN 42759 5465 35 , , , 42759 5465 36 " " '' 42759 5465 37 or or CC 42759 5465 38 " " `` 42759 5465 39 craft craft NN 42759 5465 40 , , , 42759 5465 41 " " '' 42759 5465 42 union union NN 42759 5465 43 . . . 42759 5466 1 In in IN 42759 5466 2 the the DT 42759 5466 3 former former JJ 42759 5466 4 all all PDT 42759 5466 5 the the DT 42759 5466 6 trades trade NNS 42759 5466 7 of of IN 42759 5466 8 a a DT 42759 5466 9 given give VBN 42759 5466 10 industry industry NN 42759 5466 11 are be VBP 42759 5466 12 united united JJ 42759 5466 13 in in IN 42759 5466 14 one one CD 42759 5466 15 compact compact JJ 42759 5466 16 organisation organisation NN 42759 5466 17 , , , 42759 5466 18 while while IN 42759 5466 19 the the DT 42759 5466 20 latter latter NN 42759 5466 21 includes include VBZ 42759 5466 22 only only RB 42759 5466 23 those those DT 42759 5466 24 who who WP 42759 5466 25 work work VBP 42759 5466 26 at at IN 42759 5466 27 a a DT 42759 5466 28 certain certain JJ 42759 5466 29 trade trade NN 42759 5466 30 or or CC 42759 5466 31 occupation occupation NN 42759 5466 32 . . . 42759 5467 1 For for IN 42759 5467 2 example example NN 42759 5467 3 : : : 42759 5467 4 the the DT 42759 5467 5 United United NNP 42759 5467 6 Mine Mine NNP 42759 5467 7 Workers Workers NNPS 42759 5467 8 embrace embrace VBP 42759 5467 9 all all DT 42759 5467 10 persons person NNS 42759 5467 11 employed employ VBN 42759 5467 12 in in IN 42759 5467 13 coal coal NN 42759 5467 14 mines mine NNS 42759 5467 15 , , , 42759 5467 16 from from IN 42759 5467 17 the the DT 42759 5467 18 most most RBS 42759 5467 19 highly highly RB 42759 5467 20 skilled skilled JJ 42759 5467 21 to to IN 42759 5467 22 the the DT 42759 5467 23 lowest low JJS 42759 5467 24 grade grade NN 42759 5467 25 of of IN 42759 5467 26 unspecialised unspecialised JJ 42759 5467 27 labour labour NN 42759 5467 28 ; ; : 42759 5467 29 while while IN 42759 5467 30 the the DT 42759 5467 31 craft craft NNP 42759 5467 32 union union NNP 42759 5467 33 is be VBZ 42759 5467 34 exemplified exemplify VBN 42759 5467 35 in in IN 42759 5467 36 the the DT 42759 5467 37 engineers engineer NNS 42759 5467 38 , , , 42759 5467 39 firemen fireman NNS 42759 5467 40 , , , 42759 5467 41 conductors conductor NNS 42759 5467 42 , , , 42759 5467 43 switchmen switchman NNS 42759 5467 44 , , , 42759 5467 45 and and CC 42759 5467 46 other other JJ 42759 5467 47 groups group NNS 42759 5467 48 having have VBG 42759 5467 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5467 50 separate separate JJ 42759 5467 51 organisations organisation NNS 42759 5467 52 in in IN 42759 5467 53 the the DT 42759 5467 54 railroad railroad NN 42759 5467 55 industry industry NN 42759 5467 56 . . . 42759 5468 1 The the DT 42759 5468 2 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5468 3 union union NN 42759 5468 4 is be VBZ 42759 5468 5 as as RB 42759 5468 6 much much JJ 42759 5468 7 concerned concern VBN 42759 5468 8 with with IN 42759 5468 9 the the DT 42759 5468 10 welfare welfare NN 42759 5468 11 of of IN 42759 5468 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5468 13 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 5468 14 as as IN 42759 5468 15 of of IN 42759 5468 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5468 17 skilled skilled JJ 42759 5468 18 members member NNS 42759 5468 19 , , , 42759 5468 20 and and CC 42759 5468 21 exerts exert VBZ 42759 5468 22 the the DT 42759 5468 23 whole whole NN 42759 5468 24 of of IN 42759 5468 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5468 26 organised organised JJ 42759 5468 27 force force NN 42759 5468 28 on on IN 42759 5468 29 behalf behalf NN 42759 5468 30 of of IN 42759 5468 31 each each DT 42759 5468 32 and and CC 42759 5468 33 every every DT 42759 5468 34 group group NN 42759 5468 35 of of IN 42759 5468 36 workers worker NNS 42759 5468 37 throughout throughout IN 42759 5468 38 the the DT 42759 5468 39 industry industry NN 42759 5468 40 which which WDT 42759 5468 41 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5468 42 covers cover VBZ 42759 5468 43 . . . 42759 5469 1 The the DT 42759 5469 2 superior superior JJ 42759 5469 3 suitability suitability NN 42759 5469 4 of of IN 42759 5469 5 the the DT 42759 5469 6 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5469 7 type type NN 42759 5469 8 of of IN 42759 5469 9 union union NN 42759 5469 10 to to IN 42759 5469 11 the the DT 42759 5469 12 needs need NNS 42759 5469 13 of of IN 42759 5469 14 the the DT 42759 5469 15 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 5469 16 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5469 17 is be VBZ 42759 5469 18 seen see VBN 42759 5469 19 in in IN 42759 5469 20 the the DT 42759 5469 21 fact fact NN 42759 5469 22 that that IN 42759 5469 23 more more JJR 42759 5469 24 of of IN 42759 5469 25 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5469 26 are be VBP 42759 5469 27 organised organise VBN 42759 5469 28 in in IN 42759 5469 29 the the DT 42759 5469 30 coal coal NN 42759 5469 31 mining mining NN 42759 5469 32 than than IN 42759 5469 33 in in IN 42759 5469 34 any any DT 42759 5469 35 other other JJ 42759 5469 36 industry industry NN 42759 5469 37 , , , 42759 5469 38 and and CC 42759 5469 39 have have VBP 42759 5469 40 received receive VBN 42759 5469 41 greater great JJR 42759 5469 42 benefits benefit NNS 42759 5469 43 from from IN 42759 5469 44 organisation organisation NN 42759 5469 45 than than IN 42759 5469 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5469 47 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 5469 48 fellow fellow JJ 42759 5469 49 workers worker NNS 42759 5469 50 in in IN 42759 5469 51 any any DT 42759 5469 52 other other JJ 42759 5469 53 industry industry NN 42759 5469 54 . . . 42759 5470 1 Were be VBD 42759 5470 2 the the DT 42759 5470 3 various various JJ 42759 5470 4 classes class NNS 42759 5470 5 of of IN 42759 5470 6 railway railway NN 42759 5470 7 employés employés NN 42759 5470 8 combined combine VBN 42759 5470 9 in in IN 42759 5470 10 one one CD 42759 5470 11 union union NN 42759 5470 12 , , , 42759 5470 13 instead instead RB 42759 5470 14 of of IN 42759 5470 15 being be VBG 42759 5470 16 organised organise VBN 42759 5470 17 along along IN 42759 5470 18 the the DT 42759 5470 19 lines line NNS 42759 5470 20 of of IN 42759 5470 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5470 22 separate separate JJ 42759 5470 23 crafts craft NNS 42759 5470 24 , , , 42759 5470 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5470 26 is be VBZ 42759 5470 27 quite quite RB 42759 5470 28 improbable improbable JJ 42759 5470 29 that that IN 42759 5470 30 the the DT 42759 5470 31 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 5470 32 majority majority NN 42759 5470 33 would would MD 42759 5470 34 be be VB 42759 5470 35 getting get VBG 42759 5470 36 , , , 42759 5470 37 as as IN 42759 5470 38 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5470 39 now now RB 42759 5470 40 are be VBP 42759 5470 41 getting get VBG 42759 5470 42 , , , 42759 5470 43 less less JJR 42759 5470 44 than than IN 42759 5470 45 living live VBG 42759 5470 46 wages wage NNS 42759 5470 47 . . . 42759 5471 1 While while IN 42759 5471 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5471 3 is be VBZ 42759 5471 4 true true JJ 42759 5471 5 that that IN 42759 5471 6 the the DT 42759 5471 7 various various JJ 42759 5471 8 craft craft NN 42759 5471 9 unions union NNS 42759 5471 10 in in IN 42759 5471 11 an an DT 42759 5471 12 industry industry NN 42759 5471 13 are be VBP 42759 5471 14 often often RB 42759 5471 15 federated federate VBN 42759 5471 16 into into IN 42759 5471 17 a a DT 42759 5471 18 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 5471 19 association association NN 42759 5471 20 , , , 42759 5471 21 the the DT 42759 5471 22 bond bond NN 42759 5471 23 uniting unite VBG 42759 5471 24 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5471 25 is be VBZ 42759 5471 26 not not RB 42759 5471 27 nearly nearly RB 42759 5471 28 so so RB 42759 5471 29 close close JJ 42759 5471 30 , , , 42759 5471 31 nor nor CC 42759 5471 32 so so RB 42759 5471 33 helpful helpful JJ 42759 5471 34 to to IN 42759 5471 35 the the DT 42759 5471 36 weaker weak JJR 42759 5471 37 groups group NNS 42759 5471 38 of of IN 42759 5471 39 workers worker NNS 42759 5471 40 as as IN 42759 5471 41 in in IN 42759 5471 42 the the DT 42759 5471 43 case case NN 42759 5471 44 of of IN 42759 5471 45 the the DT 42759 5471 46 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5471 47 unions union NNS 42759 5471 48 . . . 42759 5472 1 Human human JJ 42759 5472 2 nature nature NN 42759 5472 3 being be VBG 42759 5472 4 what what WP 42759 5472 5 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5472 6 is be VBZ 42759 5472 7 , , , 42759 5472 8 however however RB 42759 5472 9 , , , 42759 5472 10 the the DT 42759 5472 11 members member NNS 42759 5472 12 of of IN 42759 5472 13 the the DT 42759 5472 14 skilled skilled JJ 42759 5472 15 crafts craft NNS 42759 5472 16 can can MD 42759 5472 17 not not RB 42759 5472 18 all all DT 42759 5472 19 be be VB 42759 5472 20 induced induce VBN 42759 5472 21 or or CC 42759 5472 22 compelled compel VBN 42759 5472 23 to to TO 42759 5472 24 adopt adopt VB 42759 5472 25 the the DT 42759 5472 26 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5472 27 type type NN 42759 5472 28 of of IN 42759 5472 29 organisation organisation NN 42759 5472 30 . . . 42759 5473 1 The the DT 42759 5473 2 Knights Knights NNPS 42759 5473 3 of of IN 42759 5473 4 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5473 5 attempted attempt VBD 42759 5473 6 to to TO 42759 5473 7 accomplish accomplish VB 42759 5473 8 this this DT 42759 5473 9 , , , 42759 5473 10 and and CC 42759 5473 11 for for IN 42759 5473 12 a a DT 42759 5473 13 time time NN 42759 5473 14 enjoyed enjoy VBD 42759 5473 15 a a DT 42759 5473 16 considerable considerable JJ 42759 5473 17 measure measure NN 42759 5473 18 of of IN 42759 5473 19 success success NN 42759 5473 20 , , , 42759 5473 21 but but CC 42759 5473 22 in in IN 42759 5473 23 the the DT 42759 5473 24 end end NN 42759 5473 25 the the DT 42759 5473 26 organisation organisation NN 42759 5473 27 was be VBD 42759 5473 28 unable unable JJ 42759 5473 29 to to TO 42759 5473 30 withstand withstand VB 42759 5473 31 those those DT 42759 5473 32 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 5473 33 inclinations inclination NNS 42759 5473 34 which which WDT 42759 5473 35 impel impel NN 42759 5473 36 men man NNS 42759 5473 37 to to TO 42759 5473 38 prefer prefer VB 42759 5473 39 the the DT 42759 5473 40 more more RBR 42759 5473 41 narrow narrow JJ 42759 5473 42 , , , 42759 5473 43 homogeneous homogeneous JJ 42759 5473 44 , , , 42759 5473 45 and and CC 42759 5473 46 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 5473 47 type type NN 42759 5473 48 of of IN 42759 5473 49 association association NN 42759 5473 50 . . . 42759 5474 1 The the DT 42759 5474 2 skilled skilled JJ 42759 5474 3 workers worker NNS 42759 5474 4 refused refuse VBD 42759 5474 5 to to TO 42759 5474 6 merge merge VB 42759 5474 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5474 8 local local JJ 42759 5474 9 and and CC 42759 5474 10 craft craft NN 42759 5474 11 interests interest NNS 42759 5474 12 in in IN 42759 5474 13 the the DT 42759 5474 14 wider wide JJR 42759 5474 15 interests interest NNS 42759 5474 16 of of IN 42759 5474 17 men man NNS 42759 5474 18 with with IN 42759 5474 19 whom whom WP 42759 5474 20 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5474 21 had have VBD 42759 5474 22 no no DT 42759 5474 23 strong strong JJ 42759 5474 24 nor nor CC 42759 5474 25 immediate immediate JJ 42759 5474 26 bonds bond NNS 42759 5474 27 of of IN 42759 5474 28 sympathy sympathy NN 42759 5474 29 . . . 42759 5475 1 Among among IN 42759 5475 2 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5475 3 , , , 42759 5475 4 as as RB 42759 5475 5 well well RB 42759 5475 6 as as IN 42759 5475 7 among among IN 42759 5475 8 other other JJ 42759 5475 9 persons person NNS 42759 5475 10 , , , 42759 5475 11 the the DT 42759 5475 12 capacity capacity NN 42759 5475 13 for for IN 42759 5475 14 altruism altruism NN 42759 5475 15 is be VBZ 42759 5475 16 limited limit VBN 42759 5475 17 by by IN 42759 5475 18 distance distance NN 42759 5475 19 in in IN 42759 5475 20 space space NN 42759 5475 21 and and CC 42759 5475 22 occupational occupational JJ 42759 5475 23 condition condition NN 42759 5475 24 . . . 42759 5476 1 The the DT 42759 5476 2 passion passion NN 42759 5476 3 for for IN 42759 5476 4 distinction distinction NN 42759 5476 5 likewise likewise RB 42759 5476 6 affects affect VBZ 42759 5476 7 the the DT 42759 5476 8 wage wage NN 42759 5476 9 earner earner NN 42759 5476 10 , , , 42759 5476 11 impelling impel VBG 42759 5476 12 the the DT 42759 5476 13 higher high JJR 42759 5476 14 groups group NNS 42759 5476 15 consciously consciously RB 42759 5476 16 or or CC 42759 5476 17 unconsciously unconsciously RB 42759 5476 18 to to TO 42759 5476 19 oppose oppose VB 42759 5476 20 association association NN 42759 5476 21 that that WDT 42759 5476 22 tends tend VBZ 42759 5476 23 to to TO 42759 5476 24 break break VB 42759 5476 25 down down RP 42759 5476 26 the the DT 42759 5476 27 barrier barrier NN 42759 5476 28 of of IN 42759 5476 29 superiority superiority NN 42759 5476 30 . . . 42759 5477 1 Owing owe VBG 42759 5477 2 to to IN 42759 5477 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5477 4 greater great JJR 42759 5477 5 resources resource NNS 42759 5477 6 and and CC 42759 5477 7 greater great JJR 42759 5477 8 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5477 9 , , , 42759 5477 10 the the DT 42759 5477 11 skilled skilled JJ 42759 5477 12 members member NNS 42759 5477 13 of of IN 42759 5477 14 an an DT 42759 5477 15 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5477 16 union union NN 42759 5477 17 are be VBP 42759 5477 18 less less RBR 42759 5477 19 dependent dependent JJ 42759 5477 20 upon upon IN 42759 5477 21 the the DT 42759 5477 22 assistance assistance NN 42759 5477 23 of of IN 42759 5477 24 the the DT 42759 5477 25 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 5477 26 than than IN 42759 5477 27 the the DT 42759 5477 28 latter latter JJ 42759 5477 29 are be VBP 42759 5477 30 dependent dependent JJ 42759 5477 31 upon upon IN 42759 5477 32 the the DT 42759 5477 33 former former JJ 42759 5477 34 ; ; : 42759 5477 35 yet yet CC 42759 5477 36 the the DT 42759 5477 37 skilled skilled JJ 42759 5477 38 membership membership NN 42759 5477 39 is be VBZ 42759 5477 40 always always RB 42759 5477 41 in in IN 42759 5477 42 a a DT 42759 5477 43 minority minority NN 42759 5477 44 , , , 42759 5477 45 and and CC 42759 5477 46 therefore therefore RB 42759 5477 47 in in IN 42759 5477 48 danger danger NN 42759 5477 49 of of IN 42759 5477 50 being be VBG 42759 5477 51 subordinated subordinate VBN 42759 5477 52 to to IN 42759 5477 53 the the DT 42759 5477 54 interests interest NNS 42759 5477 55 of of IN 42759 5477 56 the the DT 42759 5477 57 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 5477 58 majority majority NN 42759 5477 59 . . . 42759 5478 1 For for IN 42759 5478 2 these these DT 42759 5478 3 and and CC 42759 5478 4 many many JJ 42759 5478 5 other other JJ 42759 5478 6 reasons reason NNS 42759 5478 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5478 8 is be VBZ 42759 5478 9 quite quite RB 42759 5478 10 improbable improbable JJ 42759 5478 11 that that IN 42759 5478 12 the the DT 42759 5478 13 majority majority NN 42759 5478 14 of of IN 42759 5478 15 union union NN 42759 5478 16 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5478 17 can can MD 42759 5478 18 be be VB 42759 5478 19 amalgamated amalgamate VBN 42759 5478 20 into into IN 42759 5478 21 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5478 22 unions union NNS 42759 5478 23 in in IN 42759 5478 24 the the DT 42759 5478 25 near near JJ 42759 5478 26 future future NN 42759 5478 27 . . . 42759 5479 1 The the DT 42759 5479 2 most most JJS 42759 5479 3 that that WDT 42759 5479 4 can can MD 42759 5479 5 be be VB 42759 5479 6 expected expect VBN 42759 5479 7 is be VBZ 42759 5479 8 that that IN 42759 5479 9 the the DT 42759 5479 10 various various JJ 42759 5479 11 occupational occupational JJ 42759 5479 12 unions union NNS 42759 5479 13 within within IN 42759 5479 14 each each DT 42759 5479 15 industry industry NN 42759 5479 16 should should MD 42759 5479 17 become become VB 42759 5479 18 federated federate VBN 42759 5479 19 in in IN 42759 5479 20 a a DT 42759 5479 21 more more RBR 42759 5479 22 compact compact JJ 42759 5479 23 and and CC 42759 5479 24 effective effective JJ 42759 5479 25 way way NN 42759 5479 26 than than IN 42759 5479 27 now now RB 42759 5479 28 prevails prevail VBZ 42759 5479 29 , , , 42759 5479 30 thus thus RB 42759 5479 31 conserving conserve VBG 42759 5479 32 the the DT 42759 5479 33 main main JJ 42759 5479 34 advantages advantage NNS 42759 5479 35 of of IN 42759 5479 36 the the DT 42759 5479 37 local local JJ 42759 5479 38 and and CC 42759 5479 39 craft craft NNP 42759 5479 40 association association NNP 42759 5479 41 , , , 42759 5479 42 while while IN 42759 5479 43 assuring assure VBG 42759 5479 44 to to IN 42759 5479 45 the the DT 42759 5479 46 unskilled unskilled JJ 42759 5479 47 workers worker NNS 42759 5479 48 some some DT 42759 5479 49 of of IN 42759 5479 50 the the DT 42759 5479 51 benefits benefit NNS 42759 5479 52 of of IN 42759 5479 53 the the DT 42759 5479 54 industrial industrial NNP 42759 5479 55 union union NNP 42759 5479 56 . . . 42759 5480 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5480 2 Organisation Organisation NNP 42759 5480 3 Versus Versus NNP 42759 5480 4 Legislation Legislation NNP 42759 5480 5 _ _ NNP 42759 5480 6 In in IN 42759 5480 7 the the DT 42759 5480 8 opinion opinion NN 42759 5480 9 of of IN 42759 5480 10 some some DT 42759 5480 11 labour labour JJ 42759 5480 12 leaders leader NNS 42759 5480 13 , , , 42759 5480 14 the the DT 42759 5480 15 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5480 16 workers worker NNS 42759 5480 17 should should MD 42759 5480 18 place place VB 42759 5480 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5480 20 entire entire JJ 42759 5480 21 reliance reliance NN 42759 5480 22 upon upon IN 42759 5480 23 organisation organisation NN 42759 5480 24 . . . 42759 5481 1 The the DT 42759 5481 2 arguments argument NNS 42759 5481 3 for for IN 42759 5481 4 this this DT 42759 5481 5 position position NN 42759 5481 6 are be VBP 42759 5481 7 mainly mainly RB 42759 5481 8 based base VBN 42759 5481 9 upon upon IN 42759 5481 10 three three CD 42759 5481 11 contentions contention NNS 42759 5481 12 : : : 42759 5481 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5481 14 is be VBZ 42759 5481 15 better well JJR 42759 5481 16 that that IN 42759 5481 17 men man NNS 42759 5481 18 should should MD 42759 5481 19 do do VB 42759 5481 20 things thing NNS 42759 5481 21 for for IN 42759 5481 22 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 5481 23 than than IN 42759 5481 24 to to TO 42759 5481 25 call call VB 42759 5481 26 in in IN 42759 5481 27 the the DT 42759 5481 28 intervention intervention NN 42759 5481 29 of of IN 42759 5481 30 the the DT 42759 5481 31 State State NNP 42759 5481 32 ; ; : 42759 5481 33 if if IN 42759 5481 34 the the DT 42759 5481 35 workers worker NNS 42759 5481 36 secure secure VBP 42759 5481 37 living live VBG 42759 5481 38 wages wage NNS 42759 5481 39 by by IN 42759 5481 40 law law NN 42759 5481 41 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5481 42 will will MD 42759 5481 43 be be VB 42759 5481 44 less less RBR 42759 5481 45 likely likely JJ 42759 5481 46 to to TO 42759 5481 47 organise organise VB 42759 5481 48 , , , 42759 5481 49 or or CC 42759 5481 50 to to TO 42759 5481 51 remain remain VB 42759 5481 52 efficiently efficiently RB 42759 5481 53 organised organised JJ 42759 5481 54 ; ; : 42759 5481 55 and and CC 42759 5481 56 if if IN 42759 5481 57 the the DT 42759 5481 58 State State NNP 42759 5481 59 fixes fix VBZ 42759 5481 60 a a DT 42759 5481 61 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5481 62 wage wage NN 42759 5481 63 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5481 64 may may MD 42759 5481 65 some some DT 42759 5481 66 day day NN 42759 5481 67 decide decide VB 42759 5481 68 to to TO 42759 5481 69 fix fix VB 42759 5481 70 a a DT 42759 5481 71 maximum maximum NN 42759 5481 72 . . . 42759 5482 1 Within within IN 42759 5482 2 certain certain JJ 42759 5482 3 limits limit NNS 42759 5482 4 the the DT 42759 5482 5 first first JJ 42759 5482 6 of of IN 42759 5482 7 these these DT 42759 5482 8 propositions proposition NNS 42759 5482 9 is be VBZ 42759 5482 10 incontestable incontestable JJ 42759 5482 11 . . . 42759 5483 1 The the DT 42759 5483 2 self self NN 42759 5483 3 education education NN 42759 5483 4 , , , 42759 5483 5 self self NN 42759 5483 6 reliance reliance NN 42759 5483 7 , , , 42759 5483 8 and and CC 42759 5483 9 other other JJ 42759 5483 10 experiences experience NNS 42759 5483 11 obtained obtain VBN 42759 5483 12 by by IN 42759 5483 13 the the DT 42759 5483 14 workers worker NNS 42759 5483 15 through through IN 42759 5483 16 an an DT 42759 5483 17 organised organise VBN 42759 5483 18 struggle struggle NN 42759 5483 19 for for IN 42759 5483 20 improvements improvement NNS 42759 5483 21 of of IN 42759 5483 22 any any DT 42759 5483 23 kind kind NN 42759 5483 24 , , , 42759 5483 25 are be VBP 42759 5483 26 too too RB 42759 5483 27 valuable valuable JJ 42759 5483 28 to to TO 42759 5483 29 be be VB 42759 5483 30 lightly lightly RB 42759 5483 31 passed pass VBN 42759 5483 32 over over RP 42759 5483 33 for for IN 42759 5483 34 the the DT 42759 5483 35 sake sake NN 42759 5483 36 of of IN 42759 5483 37 the the DT 42759 5483 38 easier easy JJR 42759 5483 39 method method NN 42759 5483 40 of of IN 42759 5483 41 State State NNP 42759 5483 42 assistance assistance NN 42759 5483 43 . . . 42759 5484 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 5484 2 , , , 42759 5484 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5484 4 would would MD 42759 5484 5 be be VB 42759 5484 6 better well JJR 42759 5484 7 to to TO 42759 5484 8 accept accept VB 42759 5484 9 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 5484 10 less less JJR 42759 5484 11 , , , 42759 5484 12 or or CC 42759 5484 13 to to TO 42759 5484 14 wait wait VB 42759 5484 15 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 5484 16 longer long RBR 42759 5484 17 , , , 42759 5484 18 in in IN 42759 5484 19 order order NN 42759 5484 20 that that IN 42759 5484 21 the the DT 42759 5484 22 advantages advantage NNS 42759 5484 23 might may MD 42759 5484 24 be be VB 42759 5484 25 secured secure VBN 42759 5484 26 through through IN 42759 5484 27 organisation organisation NN 42759 5484 28 . . . 42759 5485 1 However however RB 42759 5485 2 , , , 42759 5485 3 these these DT 42759 5485 4 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 42759 5485 5 are be VBP 42759 5485 6 not not RB 42759 5485 7 verified verify VBN 42759 5485 8 as as IN 42759 5485 9 regards regard VBZ 42759 5485 10 the the DT 42759 5485 11 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5485 12 wage wage NN 42759 5485 13 problem problem NN 42759 5485 14 . . . 42759 5486 1 The the DT 42759 5486 2 legal legal JJ 42759 5486 3 method method NN 42759 5486 4 promises promise VBZ 42759 5486 5 with with IN 42759 5486 6 a a DT 42759 5486 7 high high JJ 42759 5486 8 degree degree NN 42759 5486 9 of of IN 42759 5486 10 probability probability NN 42759 5486 11 to to TO 42759 5486 12 bring bring VB 42759 5486 13 about about RP 42759 5486 14 universal universal JJ 42759 5486 15 living live VBG 42759 5486 16 wages wage NNS 42759 5486 17 within within IN 42759 5486 18 ten ten CD 42759 5486 19 or or CC 42759 5486 20 fifteen fifteen CD 42759 5486 21 years year NNS 42759 5486 22 . . . 42759 5487 1 The the DT 42759 5487 2 champions champion NNS 42759 5487 3 of of IN 42759 5487 4 organisation organisation NN 42759 5487 5 can can MD 42759 5487 6 point point VB 42759 5487 7 to to IN 42759 5487 8 no no DT 42759 5487 9 solid solid JJ 42759 5487 10 reasons reason NNS 42759 5487 11 for for IN 42759 5487 12 indulging indulge VBG 42759 5487 13 the the DT 42759 5487 14 hope hope NN 42759 5487 15 that that IN 42759 5487 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5487 17 method method NN 42759 5487 18 would would MD 42759 5487 19 achieve achieve VB 42759 5487 20 the the DT 42759 5487 21 same same JJ 42759 5487 22 result result NN 42759 5487 23 within within IN 42759 5487 24 a a DT 42759 5487 25 half half PDT 42759 5487 26 a a DT 42759 5487 27 century century NN 42759 5487 28 . . . 42759 5488 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 5488 2 , , , 42759 5488 3 the the DT 42759 5488 4 advantages advantage NNS 42759 5488 5 of of IN 42759 5488 6 the the DT 42759 5488 7 device device NN 42759 5488 8 of of IN 42759 5488 9 organisation organisation NN 42759 5488 10 are be VBP 42759 5488 11 much much RB 42759 5488 12 more more JJR 42759 5488 13 than than IN 42759 5488 14 neutralised neutralise VBN 42759 5488 15 by by IN 42759 5488 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5488 17 disadvantages disadvantage NNS 42759 5488 18 . . . 42759 5489 1 The the DT 42759 5489 2 fear fear NN 42759 5489 3 that that IN 42759 5489 4 the the DT 42759 5489 5 devotion devotion NN 42759 5489 6 of of IN 42759 5489 7 the the DT 42759 5489 8 workers worker NNS 42759 5489 9 to to IN 42759 5489 10 the the DT 42759 5489 11 union union NN 42759 5489 12 would would MD 42759 5489 13 decline decline VB 42759 5489 14 as as RB 42759 5489 15 soon soon RB 42759 5489 16 as as IN 42759 5489 17 living live VBG 42759 5489 18 wages wage NNS 42759 5489 19 had have VBD 42759 5489 20 been be VBN 42759 5489 21 secured secure VBN 42759 5489 22 by by IN 42759 5489 23 law law NN 42759 5489 24 , , , 42759 5489 25 seems seem VBZ 42759 5489 26 to to TO 42759 5489 27 have have VB 42759 5489 28 no no DT 42759 5489 29 adequate adequate JJ 42759 5489 30 basis basis NN 42759 5489 31 either either CC 42759 5489 32 in in IN 42759 5489 33 experience experience NN 42759 5489 34 or or CC 42759 5489 35 in in IN 42759 5489 36 probability probability NN 42759 5489 37 . . . 42759 5490 1 Speaking speak VBG 42759 5490 2 of of IN 42759 5490 3 the the DT 42759 5490 4 establishment establishment NN 42759 5490 5 of of IN 42759 5490 6 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5490 7 wages wage NNS 42759 5490 8 in in IN 42759 5490 9 the the DT 42759 5490 10 tailoring tailoring NN 42759 5490 11 industry industry NN 42759 5490 12 of of IN 42759 5490 13 Great Great NNP 42759 5490 14 Britain Britain NNP 42759 5490 15 , , , 42759 5490 16 Mr. Mr. NNP 42759 5490 17 Tawney Tawney NNP 42759 5490 18 declares declare VBZ 42759 5490 19 that that IN 42759 5490 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5490 21 " " `` 42759 5490 22 has have VBZ 42759 5490 23 given give VBN 42759 5490 24 an an DT 42759 5490 25 impetus impetus NN 42759 5490 26 to to TO 42759 5490 27 trade trade VB 42759 5490 28 unionism unionism NN 42759 5490 29 among among IN 42759 5490 30 both both DT 42759 5490 31 men man NNS 42759 5490 32 and and CC 42759 5490 33 women woman NNS 42759 5490 34 . . . 42759 5491 1 The the DT 42759 5491 2 membership membership NN 42759 5491 3 of of IN 42759 5491 4 the the DT 42759 5491 5 societies society NNS 42759 5491 6 connected connect VBN 42759 5491 7 with with IN 42759 5491 8 the the DT 42759 5491 9 tailoring tailor VBG 42759 5491 10 trade trade NN 42759 5491 11 has have VBZ 42759 5491 12 increased increase VBN 42759 5491 13 , , , 42759 5491 14 and and CC 42759 5491 15 in in IN 42759 5491 16 several several JJ 42759 5491 17 districts district NNS 42759 5491 18 the the DT 42759 5491 19 trade trade NN 42759 5491 20 unions union NNS 42759 5491 21 have have VBP 42759 5491 22 secured secure VBN 42759 5491 23 agreements agreement NNS 42759 5491 24 fixing fix VBG 42759 5491 25 the the DT 42759 5491 26 standard standard JJ 42759 5491 27 rate rate NN 42759 5491 28 considerably considerably RB 42759 5491 29 above above IN 42759 5491 30 the the DT 42759 5491 31 minimum minimum NN 42759 5491 32 contained contain VBN 42759 5491 33 in in IN 42759 5491 34 the the DT 42759 5491 35 Trade Trade NNP 42759 5491 36 Board Board NNP 42759 5491 37 's 's POS 42759 5491 38 determination determination NN 42759 5491 39 . . . 42759 5492 1 " " `` 42759 5492 2 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5492 3 272 272 CD 42759 5492 4 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5492 5 Similar similar JJ 42759 5492 6 testimony testimony NN 42759 5492 7 comes come VBZ 42759 5492 8 from from IN 42759 5492 9 Australasia Australasia NNP 42759 5492 10 . . . 42759 5493 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 5493 2 , , , 42759 5493 3 this this DT 42759 5493 4 is be VBZ 42759 5493 5 precisely precisely RB 42759 5493 6 what what WP 42759 5493 7 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5493 8 should should MD 42759 5493 9 be be VB 42759 5493 10 inclined incline VBN 42759 5493 11 to to TO 42759 5493 12 expect expect VB 42759 5493 13 ; ; : 42759 5493 14 for for IN 42759 5493 15 the the DT 42759 5493 16 workers worker NNS 42759 5493 17 whose whose WP$ 42759 5493 18 wages wage NNS 42759 5493 19 had have VBD 42759 5493 20 been be VBN 42759 5493 21 raised raise VBN 42759 5493 22 would would MD 42759 5493 23 for for IN 42759 5493 24 the the DT 42759 5493 25 first first JJ 42759 5493 26 time time NN 42759 5493 27 possess possess VB 42759 5493 28 the the DT 42759 5493 29 money money NN 42759 5493 30 and and CC 42759 5493 31 the the DT 42759 5493 32 courage courage NN 42759 5493 33 to to TO 42759 5493 34 support support VB 42759 5493 35 unions union NNS 42759 5493 36 ; ; : 42759 5493 37 and and CC 42759 5493 38 would would MD 42759 5493 39 have have VB 42759 5493 40 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5493 41 incentives incentive NNS 42759 5493 42 thereto thereto NN 42759 5493 43 in in IN 42759 5493 44 the the DT 42759 5493 45 natural natural JJ 42759 5493 46 desire desire NN 42759 5493 47 to to TO 42759 5493 48 obtain obtain VB 42759 5493 49 something something NN 42759 5493 50 more more JJR 42759 5493 51 than than IN 42759 5493 52 the the DT 42759 5493 53 legal legal JJ 42759 5493 54 minimum minimum NN 42759 5493 55 , , , 42759 5493 56 and and CC 42759 5493 57 in in IN 42759 5493 58 the the DT 42759 5493 59 realisation realisation NN 42759 5493 60 that that IN 42759 5493 61 organisation organisation NN 42759 5493 62 was be VBD 42759 5493 63 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5493 64 to to TO 42759 5493 65 give give VB 42759 5493 66 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5493 67 a a DT 42759 5493 68 voice voice NN 42759 5493 69 in in IN 42759 5493 70 the the DT 42759 5493 71 determination determination NN 42759 5493 72 of of IN 42759 5493 73 the the DT 42759 5493 74 minimum minimum NN 42759 5493 75 , , , 42759 5493 76 and and CC 42759 5493 77 to to TO 42759 5493 78 enable enable VB 42759 5493 79 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5493 80 to to TO 42759 5493 81 co co VB 42759 5493 82 - - VB 42759 5493 83 operate operate VB 42759 5493 84 in in IN 42759 5493 85 compelling compel VBG 42759 5493 86 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5493 87 enforcement enforcement NN 42759 5493 88 . . . 42759 5494 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 5494 2 , , , 42759 5494 3 general general JJ 42759 5494 4 experience experience NN 42759 5494 5 shows show VBZ 42759 5494 6 that that IN 42759 5494 7 organisation organisation NN 42759 5494 8 becomes become VBZ 42759 5494 9 normally normally RB 42759 5494 10 efficient efficient JJ 42759 5494 11 and and CC 42759 5494 12 produces produce VBZ 42759 5494 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5494 14 best good JJS 42759 5494 15 results result NNS 42759 5494 16 only only RB 42759 5494 17 among among IN 42759 5494 18 workers worker NNS 42759 5494 19 who who WP 42759 5494 20 have have VBP 42759 5494 21 already already RB 42759 5494 22 approximated approximate VBN 42759 5494 23 the the DT 42759 5494 24 level level NN 42759 5494 25 of of IN 42759 5494 26 living living NN 42759 5494 27 wages wage NNS 42759 5494 28 . . . 42759 5495 1 To to TO 42759 5495 2 be be VB 42759 5495 3 sure sure JJ 42759 5495 4 , , , 42759 5495 5 the the DT 42759 5495 6 State State NNP 42759 5495 7 could could MD 42759 5495 8 set set VB 42759 5495 9 up up RP 42759 5495 10 maximum maximum JJ 42759 5495 11 instead instead RB 42759 5495 12 of of IN 42759 5495 13 minimum minimum NN 42759 5495 14 wages,--if wages,--if CC 42759 5495 15 the the DT 42759 5495 16 employing employ VBG 42759 5495 17 classes class NNS 42759 5495 18 were be VBD 42759 5495 19 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 5495 20 powerful powerful JJ 42759 5495 21 . . . 42759 5496 1 But but CC 42759 5496 2 all all DT 42759 5496 3 indications indication NNS 42759 5496 4 point point VBP 42759 5496 5 to to IN 42759 5496 6 a a DT 42759 5496 7 decline decline NN 42759 5496 8 rather rather RB 42759 5496 9 than than IN 42759 5496 10 an an DT 42759 5496 11 increase increase NN 42759 5496 12 in in IN 42759 5496 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5496 14 political political JJ 42759 5496 15 influence influence NN 42759 5496 16 , , , 42759 5496 17 and and CC 42759 5496 18 to to IN 42759 5496 19 a a DT 42759 5496 20 corresponding corresponding JJ 42759 5496 21 expansion expansion NN 42759 5496 22 in in IN 42759 5496 23 the the DT 42759 5496 24 governmental governmental JJ 42759 5496 25 influence influence NN 42759 5496 26 of of IN 42759 5496 27 the the DT 42759 5496 28 labouring labour VBG 42759 5496 29 classes class NNS 42759 5496 30 and and CC 42759 5496 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5496 32 sympathisers sympathiser NNS 42759 5496 33 . . . 42759 5497 1 Moreover moreover RB 42759 5497 2 , , , 42759 5497 3 the the DT 42759 5497 4 labour labour JJ 42759 5497 5 leaders leader NNS 42759 5497 6 who who WP 42759 5497 7 urge urge VBP 42759 5497 8 this this DT 42759 5497 9 objection objection NN 42759 5497 10 are be VBP 42759 5497 11 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 42759 5497 12 , , , 42759 5497 13 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 5497 14 as as IN 42759 5497 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5497 16 advocate advocate VBP 42759 5497 17 other other JJ 42759 5497 18 beneficial beneficial JJ 42759 5497 19 labour labour NN 42759 5497 20 legislation legislation NN 42759 5497 21 . . . 42759 5498 1 The the DT 42759 5498 2 distinction distinction NN 42759 5498 3 which which WDT 42759 5498 4 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5498 5 profess profess VBP 42759 5498 6 to to TO 42759 5498 7 find find VB 42759 5498 8 between between IN 42759 5498 9 laws law NNS 42759 5498 10 that that WDT 42759 5498 11 merely merely RB 42759 5498 12 remove remove VBP 42759 5498 13 unfair unfair JJ 42759 5498 14 legal legal JJ 42759 5498 15 and and CC 42759 5498 16 judicial judicial JJ 42759 5498 17 disabilities disability NNS 42759 5498 18 and and CC 42759 5498 19 laws law NNS 42759 5498 20 that that WDT 42759 5498 21 reduce reduce VBP 42759 5498 22 the the DT 42759 5498 23 length length NN 42759 5498 24 of of IN 42759 5498 25 the the DT 42759 5498 26 working work VBG 42759 5498 27 day day NN 42759 5498 28 or or CC 42759 5498 29 fix fix VB 42759 5498 30 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5498 31 wages wage NNS 42759 5498 32 , , , 42759 5498 33 has have VBZ 42759 5498 34 no no DT 42759 5498 35 importance importance NN 42759 5498 36 in in IN 42759 5498 37 practical practical JJ 42759 5498 38 politics politic NNS 42759 5498 39 or or CC 42759 5498 40 in in IN 42759 5498 41 the the DT 42759 5498 42 mind mind NN 42759 5498 43 of of IN 42759 5498 44 the the DT 42759 5498 45 average average JJ 42759 5498 46 legislature legislature NN 42759 5498 47 . . . 42759 5499 1 If if IN 42759 5499 2 the the DT 42759 5499 3 political political JJ 42759 5499 4 influence influence NN 42759 5499 5 of of IN 42759 5499 6 labour labour NN 42759 5499 7 should should MD 42759 5499 8 ever ever RB 42759 5499 9 become become VB 42759 5499 10 so so RB 42759 5499 11 weak weak JJ 42759 5499 12 and and CC 42759 5499 13 that that DT 42759 5499 14 of of IN 42759 5499 15 capital capital NN 42759 5499 16 so so RB 42759 5499 17 strong strong JJ 42759 5499 18 as as IN 42759 5499 19 to to TO 42759 5499 20 make make VB 42759 5499 21 restrictive restrictive JJ 42759 5499 22 labour labour NN 42759 5499 23 legislation legislation NN 42759 5499 24 generally generally RB 42759 5499 25 feasible feasible JJ 42759 5499 26 , , , 42759 5499 27 legislators legislator NNS 42759 5499 28 would would MD 42759 5499 29 not not RB 42759 5499 30 confine confine VB 42759 5499 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5499 32 unfriendly unfriendly JJ 42759 5499 33 action action NN 42759 5499 34 to to IN 42759 5499 35 the the DT 42759 5499 36 field field NN 42759 5499 37 of of IN 42759 5499 38 positive positive JJ 42759 5499 39 measures measure NNS 42759 5499 40 . . . 42759 5500 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 5500 2 would would MD 42759 5500 3 be be VB 42759 5500 4 quite quite RB 42759 5500 5 as as RB 42759 5500 6 ready ready JJ 42759 5500 7 to to TO 42759 5500 8 pass pass VB 42759 5500 9 a a DT 42759 5500 10 law law NN 42759 5500 11 prohibiting prohibiting NN 42759 5500 12 strikes strike NNS 42759 5500 13 as as IN 42759 5500 14 to to TO 42759 5500 15 enact enact VB 42759 5500 16 a a DT 42759 5500 17 statute statute NN 42759 5500 18 fixing fix VBG 42759 5500 19 maximum maximum JJ 42759 5500 20 wages wage NNS 42759 5500 21 . . . 42759 5501 1 The the DT 42759 5501 2 formal formal JJ 42759 5501 3 legalisation legalisation NN 42759 5501 4 of of IN 42759 5501 5 strikes strike NNS 42759 5501 6 , , , 42759 5501 7 picketing picket VBG 42759 5501 8 , , , 42759 5501 9 and and CC 42759 5501 10 the the DT 42759 5501 11 primary primary JJ 42759 5501 12 boycott boycott NN 42759 5501 13 which which WDT 42759 5501 14 is be VBZ 42759 5501 15 contained contain VBN 42759 5501 16 in in IN 42759 5501 17 the the DT 42759 5501 18 Clayton Clayton NNP 42759 5501 19 Act Act NNP 42759 5501 20 , , , 42759 5501 21 and and CC 42759 5501 22 for for IN 42759 5501 23 which which WDT 42759 5501 24 the the DT 42759 5501 25 labour labour NN 42759 5501 26 unions union NNS 42759 5501 27 worked work VBD 42759 5501 28 long long RB 42759 5501 29 and and CC 42759 5501 30 patiently patiently RB 42759 5501 31 , , , 42759 5501 32 could could MD 42759 5501 33 conceivably conceivably RB 42759 5501 34 be be VB 42759 5501 35 seized seize VBN 42759 5501 36 upon upon IN 42759 5501 37 by by IN 42759 5501 38 some some DT 42759 5501 39 future future NN 42759 5501 40 unfriendly unfriendly JJ 42759 5501 41 Congress Congress NNP 42759 5501 42 as as IN 42759 5501 43 a a DT 42759 5501 44 precedent precedent NN 42759 5501 45 and and CC 42759 5501 46 provocation provocation NN 42759 5501 47 for for IN 42759 5501 48 legislation legislation NN 42759 5501 49 which which WDT 42759 5501 50 would would MD 42759 5501 51 not not RB 42759 5501 52 only only RB 42759 5501 53 repeal repeal VB 42759 5501 54 all all PDT 42759 5501 55 the the DT 42759 5501 56 favourable favourable JJ 42759 5501 57 provisions provision NNS 42759 5501 58 of of IN 42759 5501 59 the the DT 42759 5501 60 Clayton Clayton NNP 42759 5501 61 Act Act NNP 42759 5501 62 , , , 42759 5501 63 but but CC 42759 5501 64 subject subject JJ 42759 5501 65 labour labour NN 42759 5501 66 to to IN 42759 5501 67 entirely entirely RB 42759 5501 68 new new JJ 42759 5501 69 and and CC 42759 5501 70 far far RB 42759 5501 71 more more RBR 42759 5501 72 odious odious JJ 42759 5501 73 restraints restraint NNS 42759 5501 74 and and CC 42759 5501 75 interferences interference NNS 42759 5501 76 . . . 42759 5502 1 The the DT 42759 5502 2 fact fact NN 42759 5502 3 that that IN 42759 5502 4 governments government NNS 42759 5502 5 passed pass VBD 42759 5502 6 maximum maximum JJ 42759 5502 7 wage wage NN 42759 5502 8 laws law NNS 42759 5502 9 in in IN 42759 5502 10 the the DT 42759 5502 11 past past NN 42759 5502 12 is be VBZ 42759 5502 13 utterly utterly RB 42759 5502 14 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 42759 5502 15 to to IN 42759 5502 16 the the DT 42759 5502 17 question question NN 42759 5502 18 of of IN 42759 5502 19 wage wage NN 42759 5502 20 legislation legislation NN 42759 5502 21 to to IN 42759 5502 22 - - HYPH 42759 5502 23 day day NN 42759 5502 24 . . . 42759 5503 1 A a DT 42759 5503 2 legal legal JJ 42759 5503 3 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5503 4 wage wage NN 42759 5503 5 , , , 42759 5503 6 and and CC 42759 5503 7 a a DT 42759 5503 8 multitude multitude NN 42759 5503 9 of of IN 42759 5503 10 other other JJ 42759 5503 11 protective protective JJ 42759 5503 12 labour labour NN 42759 5503 13 laws law NNS 42759 5503 14 are be VBP 42759 5503 15 desirable desirable JJ 42759 5503 16 and and CC 42759 5503 17 wise wise JJ 42759 5503 18 in in IN 42759 5503 19 the the DT 42759 5503 20 twentieth twentieth JJ 42759 5503 21 century century NN 42759 5503 22 for for IN 42759 5503 23 the the DT 42759 5503 24 simple simple JJ 42759 5503 25 reason reason NN 42759 5503 26 that that IN 42759 5503 27 labour labour NN 42759 5503 28 and and CC 42759 5503 29 the the DT 42759 5503 30 friends friend NNS 42759 5503 31 of of IN 42759 5503 32 labour labour NN 42759 5503 33 are be VBP 42759 5503 34 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 5503 35 powerful powerful JJ 42759 5503 36 to to TO 42759 5503 37 utilise utilise VB 42759 5503 38 this this DT 42759 5503 39 method method NN 42759 5503 40 , , , 42759 5503 41 and and CC 42759 5503 42 because because IN 42759 5503 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5503 44 influence influence NN 42759 5503 45 seems seem VBZ 42759 5503 46 destined destine VBN 42759 5503 47 to to TO 42759 5503 48 increase increase VB 42759 5503 49 rather rather RB 42759 5503 50 than than IN 42759 5503 51 decrease decrease VB 42759 5503 52 . . . 42759 5504 1 The the DT 42759 5504 2 contrary contrary JJ 42759 5504 3 hypothesis hypothesis NN 42759 5504 4 is be VBZ 42759 5504 5 too too RB 42759 5504 6 improbable improbable JJ 42759 5504 7 for for IN 42759 5504 8 serious serious JJ 42759 5504 9 consideration consideration NN 42759 5504 10 . . . 42759 5505 1 The the DT 42759 5505 2 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 5505 3 that that WDT 42759 5505 4 seem seem VBP 42759 5505 5 justified justify VBN 42759 5505 6 by by IN 42759 5505 7 a a DT 42759 5505 8 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 5505 9 and and CC 42759 5505 10 critical critical JJ 42759 5505 11 view view NN 42759 5505 12 of of IN 42759 5505 13 all all PDT 42759 5505 14 the the DT 42759 5505 15 facts fact NNS 42759 5505 16 of of IN 42759 5505 17 the the DT 42759 5505 18 situation situation NN 42759 5505 19 , , , 42759 5505 20 are be VBP 42759 5505 21 that that IN 42759 5505 22 organisation organisation NN 42759 5505 23 is be VBZ 42759 5505 24 not not RB 42759 5505 25 of of IN 42759 5505 26 itself -PRON- PRP 42759 5505 27 an an DT 42759 5505 28 adequate adequate JJ 42759 5505 29 means mean NNS 42759 5505 30 of of IN 42759 5505 31 bringing bring VBG 42759 5505 32 about about RP 42759 5505 33 living live VBG 42759 5505 34 wages wage NNS 42759 5505 35 for for IN 42759 5505 36 the the DT 42759 5505 37 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5505 38 , , , 42759 5505 39 but but CC 42759 5505 40 that that IN 42759 5505 41 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5505 42 ought ought MD 42759 5505 43 nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 5505 44 to to TO 42759 5505 45 be be VB 42759 5505 46 promoted promote VBN 42759 5505 47 and and CC 42759 5505 48 extended extend VBN 42759 5505 49 among among IN 42759 5505 50 these these DT 42759 5505 51 classes class NNS 42759 5505 52 , , , 42759 5505 53 not not RB 42759 5505 54 only only RB 42759 5505 55 for for IN 42759 5505 56 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5505 57 direct direct JJ 42759 5505 58 effect effect NN 42759 5505 59 upon upon IN 42759 5505 60 wages wage NNS 42759 5505 61 , , , 42759 5505 62 but but CC 42759 5505 63 for for IN 42759 5505 64 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5505 65 bearing bearing NN 42759 5505 66 upon upon IN 42759 5505 67 legislation legislation NN 42759 5505 68 . . . 42759 5506 1 The the DT 42759 5506 2 method method NN 42759 5506 3 of of IN 42759 5506 4 organisation organisation NN 42759 5506 5 and and CC 42759 5506 6 the the DT 42759 5506 7 method method NN 42759 5506 8 of of IN 42759 5506 9 legislation legislation NN 42759 5506 10 are be VBP 42759 5506 11 not not RB 42759 5506 12 only only RB 42759 5506 13 not not RB 42759 5506 14 mutually mutually RB 42759 5506 15 opposed opposed JJ 42759 5506 16 , , , 42759 5506 17 but but CC 42759 5506 18 are be VBP 42759 5506 19 in in IN 42759 5506 20 a a DT 42759 5506 21 very very RB 42759 5506 22 natural natural JJ 42759 5506 23 and and CC 42759 5506 24 practical practical JJ 42759 5506 25 manner manner NN 42759 5506 26 complementary complementary JJ 42759 5506 27 . . . 42759 5507 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5507 2 Participation Participation NNP 42759 5507 3 in in IN 42759 5507 4 Capital Capital NNP 42759 5507 5 Ownership Ownership NNP 42759 5507 6 _ _ NNP 42759 5507 7 While while IN 42759 5507 8 those those DT 42759 5507 9 workers worker NNS 42759 5507 10 whose whose WP$ 42759 5507 11 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5507 12 is be VBZ 42759 5507 13 below below IN 42759 5507 14 the the DT 42759 5507 15 level level NN 42759 5507 16 of of IN 42759 5507 17 decent decent JJ 42759 5507 18 maintenance maintenance NN 42759 5507 19 are be VBP 42759 5507 20 not not RB 42759 5507 21 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 5507 22 in in IN 42759 5507 23 a a DT 42759 5507 24 position position NN 42759 5507 25 to to TO 42759 5507 26 become become VB 42759 5507 27 owners owner NNS 42759 5507 28 of of IN 42759 5507 29 any any DT 42759 5507 30 kind kind NN 42759 5507 31 of of IN 42759 5507 32 capital capital NN 42759 5507 33 , , , 42759 5507 34 many many JJ 42759 5507 35 of of IN 42759 5507 36 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5507 37 , , , 42759 5507 38 especially especially RB 42759 5507 39 among among IN 42759 5507 40 the the DT 42759 5507 41 unmarried unmarried JJ 42759 5507 42 men man NNS 42759 5507 43 , , , 42759 5507 44 can can MD 42759 5507 45 accumulate accumulate VB 42759 5507 46 savings saving NNS 42759 5507 47 by by IN 42759 5507 48 making make VBG 42759 5507 49 large large JJ 42759 5507 50 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5507 51 . . . 42759 5508 1 As as IN 42759 5508 2 a a DT 42759 5508 3 matter matter NN 42759 5508 4 of of IN 42759 5508 5 fact fact NN 42759 5508 6 , , , 42759 5508 7 hundreds hundred NNS 42759 5508 8 of of IN 42759 5508 9 thousands thousand NNS 42759 5508 10 of of IN 42759 5508 11 the the DT 42759 5508 12 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5508 13 have have VBP 42759 5508 14 become become VBN 42759 5508 15 interest interest NN 42759 5508 16 receivers receiver NNS 42759 5508 17 through through IN 42759 5508 18 the the DT 42759 5508 19 medium medium NN 42759 5508 20 of of IN 42759 5508 21 savings saving NNS 42759 5508 22 banks bank NNS 42759 5508 23 , , , 42759 5508 24 real real JJ 42759 5508 25 estate estate NN 42759 5508 26 possessions possession NNS 42759 5508 27 , , , 42759 5508 28 and and CC 42759 5508 29 insurance insurance NN 42759 5508 30 policies policy NNS 42759 5508 31 . . . 42759 5509 1 Every every DT 42759 5509 2 effort effort NN 42759 5509 3 in in IN 42759 5509 4 this this DT 42759 5509 5 direction direction NN 42759 5509 6 is be VBZ 42759 5509 7 distinctly distinctly RB 42759 5509 8 worth worth JJ 42759 5509 9 while while IN 42759 5509 10 , , , 42759 5509 11 and and CC 42759 5509 12 deserving deserving NN 42759 5509 13 of of IN 42759 5509 14 encouragement encouragement NN 42759 5509 15 . . . 42759 5510 1 Labourers labourer NNS 42759 5510 2 who who WP 42759 5510 3 are be VBP 42759 5510 4 above above IN 42759 5510 5 the the DT 42759 5510 6 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5510 7 wage wage NN 42759 5510 8 level level NN 42759 5510 9 can can MD 42759 5510 10 , , , 42759 5510 11 of of IN 42759 5510 12 course course NN 42759 5510 13 , , , 42759 5510 14 save save VB 42759 5510 15 much much RB 42759 5510 16 larger large JJR 42759 5510 17 amounts amount NNS 42759 5510 18 , , , 42759 5510 19 and and CC 42759 5510 20 with with IN 42759 5510 21 less less JJR 42759 5510 22 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5510 23 than than IN 42759 5510 24 the the DT 42759 5510 25 underpaid underpaid JJ 42759 5510 26 classes class NNS 42759 5510 27 . . . 42759 5511 1 In in IN 42759 5511 2 all all DT 42759 5511 3 cases case NNS 42759 5511 4 the the DT 42759 5511 5 main main JJ 42759 5511 6 desideratum desideratum NN 42759 5511 7 is be VBZ 42759 5511 8 that that IN 42759 5511 9 the the DT 42759 5511 10 workers worker NNS 42759 5511 11 should should MD 42759 5511 12 derive derive VB 42759 5511 13 some some DT 42759 5511 14 income income NN 42759 5511 15 from from IN 42759 5511 16 capital capital NN 42759 5511 17 ; ; : 42759 5511 18 but but CC 42759 5511 19 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5511 20 is be VBZ 42759 5511 21 almost almost RB 42759 5511 22 equally equally RB 42759 5511 23 important important JJ 42759 5511 24 that that IN 42759 5511 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5511 26 capital capital NN 42759 5511 27 ownership ownership NN 42759 5511 28 should should MD 42759 5511 29 wherever wherever WRB 42759 5511 30 possible possible JJ 42759 5511 31 take take VB 42759 5511 32 the the DT 42759 5511 33 form form NN 42759 5511 34 of of IN 42759 5511 35 shares share NNS 42759 5511 36 in in IN 42759 5511 37 the the DT 42759 5511 38 industry industry NN 42759 5511 39 in in IN 42759 5511 40 which which WDT 42759 5511 41 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5511 42 are be VBP 42759 5511 43 employed employ VBN 42759 5511 44 , , , 42759 5511 45 or or CC 42759 5511 46 the the DT 42759 5511 47 store store NN 42759 5511 48 at at IN 42759 5511 49 which which WDT 42759 5511 50 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5511 51 buy buy VBP 42759 5511 52 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5511 53 goods good NNS 42759 5511 54 . . . 42759 5512 1 This this DT 42759 5512 2 means mean VBZ 42759 5512 3 co co JJ 42759 5512 4 - - JJ 42759 5512 5 operative operative JJ 42759 5512 6 production production NN 42759 5512 7 and and CC 42759 5512 8 co co JJ 42759 5512 9 - - JJ 42759 5512 10 operative operative JJ 42759 5512 11 distribution distribution NN 42759 5512 12 . . . 42759 5513 1 The the DT 42759 5513 2 general general JJ 42759 5513 3 benefits benefit NNS 42759 5513 4 of of IN 42759 5513 5 the the DT 42759 5513 6 co co JJ 42759 5513 7 - - JJ 42759 5513 8 operative operative JJ 42759 5513 9 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 5513 10 have have VBP 42759 5513 11 already already RB 42759 5513 12 been be VBN 42759 5513 13 described describe VBN 42759 5513 14 in in IN 42759 5513 15 chapter chapter NN 42759 5513 16 xiv xiv NNP 42759 5513 17 . . . 42759 5514 1 For for IN 42759 5514 2 the the DT 42759 5514 3 wage wage NN 42759 5514 4 earner earner NN 42759 5514 5 proprietorship proprietorship NN 42759 5514 6 in in IN 42759 5514 7 a a DT 42759 5514 8 co co JJ 42759 5514 9 - - JJ 42759 5514 10 operative operative JJ 42759 5514 11 concern concern NN 42759 5514 12 is be VBZ 42759 5514 13 preferable preferable JJ 42759 5514 14 to to IN 42759 5514 15 any any DT 42759 5514 16 other other JJ 42759 5514 17 kind kind NN 42759 5514 18 of of IN 42759 5514 19 capital capital NN 42759 5514 20 ownership ownership NN 42759 5514 21 because because IN 42759 5514 22 of of IN 42759 5514 23 the the DT 42759 5514 24 training training NN 42759 5514 25 that that WDT 42759 5514 26 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5514 27 affords afford VBZ 42759 5514 28 in in IN 42759 5514 29 business business NN 42759 5514 30 management management NN 42759 5514 31 and and CC 42759 5514 32 responsibility responsibility NN 42759 5514 33 , , , 42759 5514 34 in in IN 42759 5514 35 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5514 36 democracy democracy NN 42759 5514 37 , , , 42759 5514 38 and and CC 42759 5514 39 in in IN 42759 5514 40 the the DT 42759 5514 41 capacity capacity NN 42759 5514 42 to to TO 42759 5514 43 subordinate subordinate VB 42759 5514 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5514 45 immediate immediate JJ 42759 5514 46 and and CC 42759 5514 47 selfish selfish JJ 42759 5514 48 interests interest NNS 42759 5514 49 to to IN 42759 5514 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5514 51 more more RBR 42759 5514 52 remote remote JJ 42759 5514 53 and and CC 42759 5514 54 larger large JJR 42759 5514 55 welfare welfare NN 42759 5514 56 . . . 42759 5515 1 Co co JJ 42759 5515 2 - - JJ 42759 5515 3 operative operative JJ 42759 5515 4 ownership ownership NN 42759 5515 5 of of IN 42759 5515 6 the the DT 42759 5515 7 tools tool NNS 42759 5515 8 with with IN 42759 5515 9 which which WDT 42759 5515 10 men man NNS 42759 5515 11 work work VBP 42759 5515 12 has have VBZ 42759 5515 13 advantages advantage NNS 42759 5515 14 of of IN 42759 5515 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5515 16 own own JJ 42759 5515 17 over over IN 42759 5515 18 co co JJ 42759 5515 19 - - JJ 42759 5515 20 operative operative JJ 42759 5515 21 ownership ownership NN 42759 5515 22 of of IN 42759 5515 23 the the DT 42759 5515 24 stores store NNS 42759 5515 25 from from IN 42759 5515 26 which which WDT 42759 5515 27 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5515 28 made make VBD 42759 5515 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5515 30 purchases purchase NNS 42759 5515 31 , , , 42759 5515 32 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 5515 33 as as IN 42759 5515 34 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5515 35 increases increase VBZ 42759 5515 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5515 37 control control NN 42759 5515 38 over over IN 42759 5515 39 the the DT 42759 5515 40 conditions condition NNS 42759 5515 41 of of IN 42759 5515 42 employment employment NN 42759 5515 43 , , , 42759 5515 44 and and CC 42759 5515 45 gives give VBZ 42759 5515 46 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5515 47 incentives incentive NNS 42759 5515 48 to to IN 42759 5515 49 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5515 50 which which WDT 42759 5515 51 results result VBZ 42759 5515 52 in in IN 42759 5515 53 a a DT 42759 5515 54 larger large JJR 42759 5515 55 social social JJ 42759 5515 56 product product NN 42759 5515 57 and and CC 42759 5515 58 a a DT 42759 5515 59 larger large JJR 42759 5515 60 share share NN 42759 5515 61 thereof thereof RB 42759 5515 62 for for IN 42759 5515 63 themselves -PRON- PRP 42759 5515 64 . . . 42759 5516 1 As as IN 42759 5516 2 already already RB 42759 5516 3 pointed point VBN 42759 5516 4 out out RP 42759 5516 5 in in IN 42759 5516 6 chapter chapter NN 42759 5516 7 xiv xiv NNP 42759 5516 8 , , , 42759 5516 9 the the DT 42759 5516 10 ideal ideal JJ 42759 5516 11 type type NN 42759 5516 12 of of IN 42759 5516 13 productive productive JJ 42759 5516 14 co co NN 42759 5516 15 - - NN 42759 5516 16 operation operation NN 42759 5516 17 is be VBZ 42759 5516 18 that that DT 42759 5516 19 known know VBN 42759 5516 20 as as IN 42759 5516 21 the the DT 42759 5516 22 " " `` 42759 5516 23 perfect perfect JJ 42759 5516 24 " " '' 42759 5516 25 form form NN 42759 5516 26 , , , 42759 5516 27 in in IN 42759 5516 28 which which WDT 42759 5516 29 the the DT 42759 5516 30 workers worker NNS 42759 5516 31 are be VBP 42759 5516 32 the the DT 42759 5516 33 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 5516 34 owners owner NNS 42759 5516 35 of of IN 42759 5516 36 the the DT 42759 5516 37 concern concern NN 42759 5516 38 where where WRB 42759 5516 39 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5516 40 exercise exercise VBP 42759 5516 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5516 42 labour labour NN 42759 5516 43 . . . 42759 5517 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 5517 2 , , , 42759 5517 3 the the DT 42759 5517 4 " " `` 42759 5517 5 federal federal JJ 42759 5517 6 " " '' 42759 5517 7 type type NN 42759 5517 8 , , , 42759 5517 9 in in IN 42759 5517 10 which which WDT 42759 5517 11 the the DT 42759 5517 12 productive productive JJ 42759 5517 13 concern concern NN 42759 5517 14 is be VBZ 42759 5517 15 directly directly RB 42759 5517 16 owned own VBN 42759 5517 17 by by IN 42759 5517 18 a a DT 42759 5517 19 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 5517 20 co co JJ 42759 5517 21 - - NN 42759 5517 22 operative operative JJ 42759 5517 23 , , , 42759 5517 24 indirectly indirectly RB 42759 5517 25 by by IN 42759 5517 26 the the DT 42759 5517 27 retail retail JJ 42759 5517 28 co co JJ 42759 5517 29 - - JJ 42759 5517 30 operative operative JJ 42759 5517 31 store store NN 42759 5517 32 , , , 42759 5517 33 and and CC 42759 5517 34 ultimately ultimately RB 42759 5517 35 by by IN 42759 5517 36 the the DT 42759 5517 37 co co JJ 42759 5517 38 - - JJ 42759 5517 39 operative operative JJ 42759 5517 40 consumers,--presents consumers,--presents ADD 42759 5517 41 one one CD 42759 5517 42 important important JJ 42759 5517 43 advantage advantage NN 42759 5517 44 . . . 42759 5518 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5518 2 could could MD 42759 5518 3 be be VB 42759 5518 4 so so RB 42759 5518 5 modified modified JJ 42759 5518 6 as as IN 42759 5518 7 to to TO 42759 5518 8 enable enable VB 42759 5518 9 the the DT 42759 5518 10 employés employés NN 42759 5518 11 of of IN 42759 5518 12 the the DT 42759 5518 13 productive productive JJ 42759 5518 14 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 5518 15 to to TO 42759 5518 16 share share VB 42759 5518 17 the the DT 42759 5518 18 ownership ownership NN 42759 5518 19 of of IN 42759 5518 20 the the DT 42759 5518 21 latter latter JJ 42759 5518 22 with with IN 42759 5518 23 the the DT 42759 5518 24 wholesale wholesale JJ 42759 5518 25 establishment establishment NN 42759 5518 26 . . . 42759 5519 1 Such such PDT 42759 5519 2 an an DT 42759 5519 3 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 5519 4 would would MD 42759 5519 5 at at IN 42759 5519 6 once once RB 42759 5519 7 give give VB 42759 5519 8 the the DT 42759 5519 9 workers worker NNS 42759 5519 10 the the DT 42759 5519 11 benefits benefit NNS 42759 5519 12 of of IN 42759 5519 13 productive productive JJ 42759 5519 14 co co NN 42759 5519 15 - - NN 42759 5519 16 operation operation NN 42759 5519 17 mentioned mention VBN 42759 5519 18 above above RB 42759 5519 19 , , , 42759 5519 20 and and CC 42759 5519 21 render render VB 42759 5519 22 probable probable JJ 42759 5519 23 a a DT 42759 5519 24 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 5519 25 adjustment adjustment NN 42759 5519 26 of of IN 42759 5519 27 the the DT 42759 5519 28 conflicting conflict VBG 42759 5519 29 claims claim NNS 42759 5519 30 of of IN 42759 5519 31 producers producer NNS 42759 5519 32 and and CC 42759 5519 33 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5519 34 . . . 42759 5520 1 As as IN 42759 5520 2 intimated intimate VBN 42759 5520 3 in in IN 42759 5520 4 chapter chapter NN 42759 5520 5 xxiv xxiv NNP 42759 5520 6 , , , 42759 5520 7 such such PDT 42759 5520 8 a a DT 42759 5520 9 conflict conflict NN 42759 5520 10 is be VBZ 42759 5520 11 inherent inherent JJ 42759 5520 12 in in IN 42759 5520 13 every every DT 42759 5520 14 system system NN 42759 5520 15 of of IN 42759 5520 16 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5520 17 organisation organisation NN 42759 5520 18 , , , 42759 5520 19 and and CC 42759 5520 20 will will MD 42759 5520 21 become become VB 42759 5520 22 more more RBR 42759 5520 23 evident evident JJ 42759 5520 24 and and CC 42759 5520 25 more more RBR 42759 5520 26 acute acute JJ 42759 5520 27 in in IN 42759 5520 28 proportion proportion NN 42759 5520 29 to to IN 42759 5520 30 the the DT 42759 5520 31 strengthening strengthening NN 42759 5520 32 of of IN 42759 5520 33 the the DT 42759 5520 34 position position NN 42759 5520 35 of of IN 42759 5520 36 labour labour NN 42759 5520 37 . . . 42759 5521 1 A a DT 42759 5521 2 final final JJ 42759 5521 3 reason reason NN 42759 5521 4 for for IN 42759 5521 5 ownership ownership NN 42759 5521 6 of of IN 42759 5521 7 capital capital NN 42759 5521 8 by by IN 42759 5521 9 labour labour NN 42759 5521 10 deserves deserve NNS 42759 5521 11 mention mention VBP 42759 5521 12 here here RB 42759 5521 13 , , , 42759 5521 14 even even RB 42759 5521 15 though though IN 42759 5521 16 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5521 17 has have VBZ 42759 5521 18 no no DT 42759 5521 19 immediate immediate JJ 42759 5521 20 bearing bearing NN 42759 5521 21 upon upon IN 42759 5521 22 the the DT 42759 5521 23 question question NN 42759 5521 24 of of IN 42759 5521 25 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5521 26 . . . 42759 5522 1 Were be VBD 42759 5522 2 all all DT 42759 5522 3 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5522 4 receiving receive VBG 42759 5522 5 the the DT 42759 5522 6 full full JJ 42759 5522 7 measure measure NN 42759 5522 8 of of IN 42759 5522 9 wages wage NNS 42759 5522 10 to to TO 42759 5522 11 which which WDT 42759 5522 12 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5522 13 are be VBP 42759 5522 14 entitled entitle VBN 42759 5522 15 by by IN 42759 5522 16 the the DT 42759 5522 17 canons canon NNS 42759 5522 18 of of IN 42759 5522 19 distributive distributive JJ 42759 5522 20 justice justice NN 42759 5522 21 , , , 42759 5522 22 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5522 23 would would MD 42759 5522 24 still still RB 42759 5522 25 be be VB 42759 5522 26 highly highly RB 42759 5522 27 desirable desirable JJ 42759 5522 28 that that IN 42759 5522 29 the the DT 42759 5522 30 majority majority NN 42759 5522 31 if if IN 42759 5522 32 not not RB 42759 5522 33 all all DT 42759 5522 34 of of IN 42759 5522 35 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5522 36 should should MD 42759 5522 37 possess possess VB 42759 5522 38 some some DT 42759 5522 39 capital capital NN 42759 5522 40 , , , 42759 5522 41 preferably preferably RB 42759 5522 42 in in IN 42759 5522 43 the the DT 42759 5522 44 productive productive JJ 42759 5522 45 and and CC 42759 5522 46 distributive distributive JJ 42759 5522 47 concerns concern NNS 42759 5522 48 in in IN 42759 5522 49 which which WDT 42759 5522 50 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5522 51 were be VBD 42759 5522 52 immediately immediately RB 42759 5522 53 interested interested JJ 42759 5522 54 . . . 42759 5523 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5523 2 does do VBZ 42759 5523 3 not not RB 42759 5523 4 seem seem VB 42759 5523 5 probable probable JJ 42759 5523 6 that that IN 42759 5523 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5523 8 economic economic JJ 42759 5523 9 system system NN 42759 5523 10 as as IN 42759 5523 11 now now RB 42759 5523 12 constituted constituted JJ 42759 5523 13 , , , 42759 5523 14 with with IN 42759 5523 15 the the DT 42759 5523 16 capital capital NN 42759 5523 17 owners owner NNS 42759 5523 18 and and CC 42759 5523 19 the the DT 42759 5523 20 capital capital NN 42759 5523 21 operators operator NNS 42759 5523 22 for for IN 42759 5523 23 the the DT 42759 5523 24 most most JJS 42759 5523 25 part part NN 42759 5523 26 in in IN 42759 5523 27 two two CD 42759 5523 28 distinct distinct JJ 42759 5523 29 classes class NNS 42759 5523 30 , , , 42759 5523 31 will will MD 42759 5523 32 be be VB 42759 5523 33 the the DT 42759 5523 34 final final JJ 42759 5523 35 form form NN 42759 5523 36 of of IN 42759 5523 37 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5523 38 organisation organisation NN 42759 5523 39 . . . 42759 5524 1 Particularly particularly RB 42759 5524 2 does do VBZ 42759 5524 3 this this DT 42759 5524 4 arrangement arrangement NN 42759 5524 5 seem seem VB 42759 5524 6 undesirable undesirable JJ 42759 5524 7 , , , 42759 5524 8 incongruous incongruous JJ 42759 5524 9 , , , 42759 5524 10 and and CC 42759 5524 11 unstable unstable JJ 42759 5524 12 in in IN 42759 5524 13 a a DT 42759 5524 14 society society NN 42759 5524 15 whose whose WP$ 42759 5524 16 political political JJ 42759 5524 17 form form NN 42759 5524 18 is be VBZ 42759 5524 19 that that DT 42759 5524 20 of of IN 42759 5524 21 democracy democracy NN 42759 5524 22 . . . 42759 5525 1 Ultimately ultimately RB 42759 5525 2 the the DT 42759 5525 3 workers worker NNS 42759 5525 4 must must MD 42759 5525 5 become become VB 42759 5525 6 not not RB 42759 5525 7 merely merely RB 42759 5525 8 wage wage NN 42759 5525 9 earners earner NNS 42759 5525 10 but but CC 42759 5525 11 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 5525 12 . . . 42759 5526 1 Any any DT 42759 5526 2 other other JJ 42759 5526 3 system system NN 42759 5526 4 will will MD 42759 5526 5 always always RB 42759 5526 6 contain contain VB 42759 5526 7 and and CC 42759 5526 8 develop develop VB 42759 5526 9 the the DT 42759 5526 10 seeds seed NNS 42759 5526 11 of of IN 42759 5526 12 social social JJ 42759 5526 13 discontent discontent NN 42759 5526 14 and and CC 42759 5526 15 social social JJ 42759 5526 16 disorder disorder NN 42759 5526 17 . . . 42759 5527 1 REFERENCES reference NNS 42759 5527 2 ON on IN 42759 5527 3 SECTION section NN 42759 5527 4 IV IV NNP 42759 5527 5 ADAMS ADAMS NNP 42759 5527 6 AND and CC 42759 5527 7 SUMNER SUMNER NNP 42759 5527 8 : : : 42759 5527 9 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5527 10 Problems Problems NNPS 42759 5527 11 . . . 42759 5528 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 5528 2 ; ; : 42759 5528 3 1905 1905 CD 42759 5528 4 . . . 42759 5529 1 COMMONS commons JJ 42759 5529 2 AND and CC 42759 5529 3 ANDREWS andrew NNS 42759 5529 4 : : : 42759 5529 5 Principles principle NNS 42759 5529 6 of of IN 42759 5529 7 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5529 8 Legislation Legislation NNP 42759 5529 9 . . . 42759 5530 1 Harpers harper NNS 42759 5530 2 ; ; : 42759 5530 3 1916 1916 CD 42759 5530 4 . . . 42759 5531 1 WALKER WALKER NNP 42759 5531 2 : : : 42759 5531 3 The the DT 42759 5531 4 Wages Wages NNPS 42759 5531 5 Question Question NNP 42759 5531 6 . . . 42759 5532 1 New New NNP 42759 5532 2 York York NNP 42759 5532 3 ; ; : 42759 5532 4 1876 1876 CD 42759 5532 5 . . . 42759 5533 1 RYAN RYAN NNS 42759 5533 2 : : : 42759 5533 3 A a DT 42759 5533 4 Living live VBG 42759 5533 5 Wage wage NN 42759 5533 6 . . . 42759 5534 1 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 5534 2 ; ; : 42759 5534 3 1906 1906 CD 42759 5534 4 . . . 42759 5535 1 SNOWDEN SNOWDEN NNP 42759 5535 2 : : : 42759 5535 3 The the DT 42759 5535 4 Living Living NNP 42759 5535 5 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5535 6 . . . 42759 5536 1 London London NNP 42759 5536 2 ; ; : 42759 5536 3 Hodder Hodder NNP 42759 5536 4 & & CC 42759 5536 5 Stoughton Stoughton NNP 42759 5536 6 . . . 42759 5537 1 O'GRADY O'GRADY NNS 42759 5537 2 : : : 42759 5537 3 A a DT 42759 5537 4 Legal Legal NNP 42759 5537 5 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 5537 6 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5537 7 . . . 42759 5538 1 Washington Washington NNP 42759 5538 2 ; ; : 42759 5538 3 1915 1915 CD 42759 5538 4 . . . 42759 5539 1 BRODA broda NN 42759 5539 2 : : : 42759 5539 3 La La NNP 42759 5539 4 Fixation Fixation NNP 42759 5539 5 Légale Légale NNP 42759 5539 6 des des NNP 42759 5539 7 Salaires Salaires NNP 42759 5539 8 . . . 42759 5540 1 Paris Paris NNP 42759 5540 2 ; ; : 42759 5540 3 1912 1912 CD 42759 5540 4 . . . 42759 5541 1 N. N. NNP 42759 5541 2 Y. Y. NNP 42759 5542 1 FACTORY FACTORY NNP 42759 5542 2 INVESTIGATING INVESTIGATING NNP 42759 5542 3 COMMISSION COMMISSION NNP 42759 5542 4 . . . 42759 5543 1 Appendix Appendix NNP 42759 5543 2 to to IN 42759 5543 3 Vol Vol NNP 42759 5543 4 . . . 42759 5544 1 III iii CD 42759 5544 2 . . . 42759 5545 1 TAWNEY tawney NN 42759 5545 2 : : : 42759 5545 3 Minimum minimum JJ 42759 5545 4 Rates rate NNS 42759 5545 5 in in IN 42759 5545 6 the the DT 42759 5545 7 Chain chain NN 42759 5545 8 - - HYPH 42759 5545 9 Making make VBG 42759 5545 10 Industry Industry NNP 42759 5545 11 . . . 42759 5546 1 London London NNP 42759 5546 2 ; ; : 42759 5546 3 1914 1914 CD 42759 5546 4 . . . 42759 5547 1 Minimum minimum JJ 42759 5547 2 Rates rate NNS 42759 5547 3 in in IN 42759 5547 4 the the DT 42759 5547 5 Tailoring Tailoring NNP 42759 5547 6 Industry industry NN 42759 5547 7 . . . 42759 5548 1 London London NNP 42759 5548 2 ; ; : 42759 5548 3 1915 1915 CD 42759 5548 4 . . . 42759 5549 1 TURMAN TURMAN NNP 42759 5549 2 : : : 42759 5549 3 Le Le NNP 42759 5549 4 Catholicisme Catholicisme NNP 42759 5549 5 Social Social NNP 42759 5549 6 . . . 42759 5550 1 Paris Paris NNP 42759 5550 2 ; ; : 42759 5550 3 1900 1900 CD 42759 5550 4 . . . 42759 5551 1 POTTIER POTTIER NNP 42759 5551 2 : : : 42759 5551 3 De De NNP 42759 5551 4 Jure Jure NNP 42759 5551 5 et et NNP 42759 5551 6 Justitia Justitia NNP 42759 5551 7 . . . 42759 5552 1 Liege Liege NNP 42759 5552 2 ; ; : 42759 5552 3 1900 1900 CD 42759 5552 4 . . . 42759 5553 1 POLIER POLIER NNP 42759 5553 2 : : : 42759 5553 3 L'Idée L'Idée NNP 42759 5553 4 du du NNP 42759 5553 5 Juste Juste NNP 42759 5553 6 Salaire Salaire NNP 42759 5553 7 . . . 42759 5554 1 Paris Paris NNP 42759 5554 2 ; ; : 42759 5554 3 1903 1903 CD 42759 5554 4 . . . 42759 5555 1 MENGER MENGER NNP 42759 5555 2 : : : 42759 5555 3 The the DT 42759 5555 4 Right right UH 42759 5555 5 to to IN 42759 5555 6 the the DT 42759 5555 7 Whole Whole NNP 42759 5555 8 Produce Produce NNP 42759 5555 9 of of IN 42759 5555 10 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5555 11 . . . 42759 5556 1 London London NNP 42759 5556 2 ; ; : 42759 5556 3 1899 1899 CD 42759 5556 4 . . . 42759 5557 1 GARRIGUET GARRIGUET NNS 42759 5557 2 : : : 42759 5557 3 Régime Régime NNP 42759 5557 4 du du VB 42759 5557 5 Travail Travail NNP 42759 5557 6 . . . 42759 5558 1 Paris Paris NNP 42759 5558 2 ; ; : 42759 5558 3 1908 1908 CD 42759 5558 4 . . . 42759 5559 1 NEARING nearing NN 42759 5559 2 : : : 42759 5559 3 Reducing reduce VBG 42759 5559 4 the the DT 42759 5559 5 Cost cost NN 42759 5559 6 of of IN 42759 5559 7 Living live VBG 42759 5559 8 . . . 42759 5560 1 Philadelphia Philadelphia NNP 42759 5560 2 ; ; : 42759 5560 3 1914 1914 CD 42759 5560 4 . . . 42759 5561 1 CHAPIN chapin NN 42759 5561 2 : : : 42759 5561 3 The the DT 42759 5561 4 Standard Standard NNP 42759 5561 5 of of IN 42759 5561 6 Living live VBG 42759 5561 7 in in IN 42759 5561 8 New New NNP 42759 5561 9 York York NNP 42759 5561 10 City City NNP 42759 5561 11 . . . 42759 5562 1 New New NNP 42759 5562 2 York York NNP 42759 5562 3 ; ; : 42759 5562 4 1909 1909 CD 42759 5562 5 . . . 42759 5563 1 Also also RB 42759 5563 2 the the DT 42759 5563 3 works work NNS 42759 5563 4 on on IN 42759 5563 5 co co NN 42759 5563 6 - - NN 42759 5563 7 operation operation NN 42759 5563 8 cited cite VBN 42759 5563 9 in in IN 42759 5563 10 connection connection NN 42759 5563 11 with with IN 42759 5563 12 Section Section NNP 42759 5563 13 II II NNP 42759 5563 14 , , , 42759 5563 15 and and CC 42759 5563 16 those those DT 42759 5563 17 of of IN 42759 5563 18 Hobson Hobson NNP 42759 5563 19 , , , 42759 5563 20 Carver Carver NNP 42759 5563 21 , , , 42759 5563 22 Nearing Nearing NNP 42759 5563 23 and and CC 42759 5563 24 Streightoff Streightoff NNP 42759 5563 25 . . . 42759 5564 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 42759 5564 2 : : : 42759 5564 3 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5564 4 251 251 CD 42759 5564 5 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5564 6 See see VB 42759 5564 7 articles article NNS 42759 5564 8 by by IN 42759 5564 9 Hammond Hammond NNP 42759 5564 10 in in IN 42759 5564 11 the the DT 42759 5564 12 _ _ NNP 42759 5564 13 American American NNP 42759 5564 14 Economic Economic NNP 42759 5564 15 Review Review NNP 42759 5564 16 _ _ NNP 42759 5564 17 , , , 42759 5564 18 June June NNP 42759 5564 19 , , , 42759 5564 20 1913 1913 CD 42759 5564 21 , , , 42759 5564 22 and and CC 42759 5564 23 in in IN 42759 5564 24 the the DT 42759 5564 25 _ _ NNP 42759 5564 26 Annals Annals NNPS 42759 5564 27 of of IN 42759 5564 28 the the DT 42759 5564 29 American American NNP 42759 5564 30 Academy Academy NNP 42759 5564 31 of of IN 42759 5564 32 Political Political NNP 42759 5564 33 and and CC 42759 5564 34 Social Social NNP 42759 5564 35 Science Science NNP 42759 5564 36 _ _ NNP 42759 5564 37 , , , 42759 5564 38 July July NNP 42759 5564 39 , , , 42759 5564 40 1913 1913 CD 42759 5564 41 ; ; : 42759 5564 42 and and CC 42759 5564 43 page page NN 42759 5564 44 62 62 CD 42759 5564 45 of of IN 42759 5564 46 the the DT 42759 5564 47 Appendix Appendix NNP 42759 5564 48 to to IN 42759 5564 49 the the DT 42759 5564 50 third third JJ 42759 5564 51 volume volume NN 42759 5564 52 of of IN 42759 5564 53 the the DT 42759 5564 54 Report Report NNP 42759 5564 55 of of IN 42759 5564 56 the the DT 42759 5564 57 New New NNP 42759 5564 58 York York NNP 42759 5564 59 State State NNP 42759 5564 60 Factory Factory NNP 42759 5564 61 Investigating Investigating NNP 42759 5564 62 Commission Commission NNP 42759 5564 63 . . . 42759 5565 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5565 2 252 252 CD 42759 5565 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5565 4 See see VB 42759 5565 5 the the DT 42759 5565 6 replies reply NNS 42759 5565 7 of of IN 42759 5565 8 the the DT 42759 5565 9 London London NNP 42759 5565 10 Board Board NNP 42759 5565 11 of of IN 42759 5565 12 Trade Trade NNP 42759 5565 13 to to IN 42759 5565 14 the the DT 42759 5565 15 N. n. NN 42759 5565 16 Y. y. NN 42759 5566 1 Factory factory NN 42759 5566 2 Investigating Investigating NNP 42759 5566 3 Commission Commission NNP 42759 5566 4 , , , 42759 5566 5 on on IN 42759 5566 6 pages page NNS 42759 5566 7 77 77 CD 42759 5566 8 , , , 42759 5566 9 78 78 CD 42759 5566 10 of of IN 42759 5566 11 the the DT 42759 5566 12 volume volume NN 42759 5566 13 cited cite VBN 42759 5566 14 above above RB 42759 5566 15 ; ; : 42759 5566 16 and and CC 42759 5566 17 especially especially RB 42759 5566 18 the the DT 42759 5566 19 two two CD 42759 5566 20 monographs monographs NN 42759 5566 21 by by IN 42759 5566 22 R. R. NNP 42759 5566 23 H. H. NNP 42759 5566 24 Tawney Tawney NNP 42759 5566 25 , , , 42759 5566 26 " " `` 42759 5566 27 The the DT 42759 5566 28 Establishment Establishment NNP 42759 5566 29 of of IN 42759 5566 30 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 5566 31 Rates Rates NNPS 42759 5566 32 in in IN 42759 5566 33 the the DT 42759 5566 34 Chain chain NN 42759 5566 35 - - HYPH 42759 5566 36 Making make VBG 42759 5566 37 Industry industry NN 42759 5566 38 , , , 42759 5566 39 " " '' 42759 5566 40 and and CC 42759 5566 41 " " `` 42759 5566 42 The the DT 42759 5566 43 Establishment Establishment NNP 42759 5566 44 of of IN 42759 5566 45 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 5566 46 Rates Rates NNPS 42759 5566 47 in in IN 42759 5566 48 the the DT 42759 5566 49 Tailoring Tailoring NNP 42759 5566 50 Industry industry NN 42759 5566 51 . . . 42759 5566 52 " " '' 42759 5567 1 London London NNP 42759 5567 2 ; ; : 42759 5567 3 1914 1914 CD 42759 5567 4 and and CC 42759 5567 5 1915 1915 CD 42759 5567 6 . . . 42759 5568 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5568 2 253 253 CD 42759 5568 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5568 4 " " `` 42759 5568 5 First First NNP 42759 5568 6 Biennial Biennial NNP 42759 5568 7 Report Report NNP 42759 5568 8 of of IN 42759 5568 9 the the DT 42759 5568 10 Industrial Industrial NNP 42759 5568 11 Welfare Welfare NNP 42759 5568 12 Commission Commission NNP 42759 5568 13 of of IN 42759 5568 14 Washington Washington NNP 42759 5568 15 , , , 42759 5568 16 " " '' 42759 5568 17 pp pp NNP 42759 5568 18 . . . 42759 5569 1 13 13 CD 42759 5569 2 , , , 42759 5569 3 15 15 CD 42759 5569 4 . . . 42759 5570 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5570 2 254 254 CD 42759 5570 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5570 4 " " `` 42759 5570 5 Effect Effect NNP 42759 5570 6 of of IN 42759 5570 7 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 5570 8 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5570 9 Determinations Determinations NNPS 42759 5570 10 in in IN 42759 5570 11 Oregon Oregon NNP 42759 5570 12 . . . 42759 5570 13 " " '' 42759 5571 1 Bulletin bulletin NN 42759 5571 2 No no UH 42759 5571 3 . . . 42759 5572 1 176 176 CD 42759 5572 2 of of IN 42759 5572 3 United United NNP 42759 5572 4 States States NNP 42759 5572 5 Bureau Bureau NNP 42759 5572 6 of of IN 42759 5572 7 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5572 8 Statistics Statistics NNP 42759 5572 9 . . . 42759 5573 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5573 2 255 255 CD 42759 5573 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5573 4 From from IN 42759 5573 5 a a DT 42759 5573 6 paper paper NN 42759 5573 7 read read NN 42759 5573 8 before before IN 42759 5573 9 the the DT 42759 5573 10 National National NNP 42759 5573 11 Convention Convention NNP 42759 5573 12 of of IN 42759 5573 13 the the DT 42759 5573 14 Association Association NNP 42759 5573 15 of of IN 42759 5573 16 Government Government NNP 42759 5573 17 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5573 18 Officials Officials NNP 42759 5573 19 , , , 42759 5573 20 Nashville Nashville NNP 42759 5573 21 , , , 42759 5573 22 Tenn. Tennessee NNP 42759 5573 23 , , , 42759 5573 24 June June NNP 42759 5573 25 9 9 CD 42759 5573 26 , , , 42759 5573 27 1914 1914 CD 42759 5573 28 . . . 42759 5574 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5574 2 256 256 CD 42759 5574 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5574 4 See see VB 42759 5574 5 Bulletins bulletin NNS 42759 5574 6 of of IN 42759 5574 7 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 42759 5574 8 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 5574 9 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5574 10 Commission Commission NNP 42759 5574 11 . . . 42759 5575 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5575 2 257 257 CD 42759 5575 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5575 4 See see VB 42759 5575 5 the the DT 42759 5575 6 excellent excellent JJ 42759 5575 7 and and CC 42759 5575 8 varied varied JJ 42759 5575 9 series series NN 42759 5575 10 of of IN 42759 5575 11 papers paper NNS 42759 5575 12 on on IN 42759 5575 13 the the DT 42759 5575 14 subject subject NN 42759 5575 15 in in IN 42759 5575 16 Orth Orth NNP 42759 5575 17 's 's POS 42759 5575 18 " " `` 42759 5575 19 The the DT 42759 5575 20 Relation Relation NNP 42759 5575 21 of of IN 42759 5575 22 Government Government NNP 42759 5575 23 to to IN 42759 5575 24 Property Property NNP 42759 5575 25 and and CC 42759 5575 26 Industry Industry NNP 42759 5575 27 , , , 42759 5575 28 " " '' 42759 5575 29 pp pp NNP 42759 5575 30 . . . 42759 5576 1 103 103 CD 42759 5576 2 - - SYM 42759 5576 3 178 178 CD 42759 5576 4 . . . 42759 5577 1 Ginn Ginn NNP 42759 5577 2 & & CC 42759 5577 3 Company Company NNP 42759 5577 4 ; ; : 42759 5577 5 1915 1915 CD 42759 5577 6 . . . 42759 5578 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5578 2 258 258 CD 42759 5578 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5578 4 The the DT 42759 5578 5 arguments argument NNS 42759 5578 6 for for IN 42759 5578 7 and and CC 42759 5578 8 against against IN 42759 5578 9 the the DT 42759 5578 10 constitutionality constitutionality NN 42759 5578 11 of of IN 42759 5578 12 a a DT 42759 5578 13 legal legal JJ 42759 5578 14 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5578 15 wage wage NN 42759 5578 16 are be VBP 42759 5578 17 adequately adequately RB 42759 5578 18 presented present VBN 42759 5578 19 in in IN 42759 5578 20 the the DT 42759 5578 21 briefs brief NNS 42759 5578 22 , , , 42759 5578 23 respectively respectively RB 42759 5578 24 , , , 42759 5578 25 of of IN 42759 5578 26 Louis Louis NNP 42759 5578 27 D. D. NNP 42759 5578 28 Brandeis Brandeis NNP 42759 5578 29 and and CC 42759 5578 30 Rome Rome NNP 42759 5578 31 G. G. NNP 42759 5578 32 Brown Brown NNP 42759 5578 33 , , , 42759 5578 34 in in IN 42759 5578 35 the the DT 42759 5578 36 cases case NNS 42759 5578 37 of of IN 42759 5578 38 Stettler Stettler NNP 42759 5578 39 _ _ NNP 42759 5578 40 vs. vs. IN 42759 5578 41 _ _ NNP 42759 5578 42 O'Hara O'Hara NNP 42759 5578 43 and and CC 42759 5578 44 Simpson Simpson NNP 42759 5578 45 _ _ NNP 42759 5578 46 vs. vs. IN 42759 5578 47 _ _ NNP 42759 5578 48 O'Hara O'Hara NNP 42759 5578 49 . . . 42759 5579 1 The the DT 42759 5579 2 former former JJ 42759 5579 3 is be VBZ 42759 5579 4 published publish VBN 42759 5579 5 by by IN 42759 5579 6 the the DT 42759 5579 7 National National NNP 42759 5579 8 Consumers Consumers NNPS 42759 5579 9 ' ' POS 42759 5579 10 League League NNP 42759 5579 11 , , , 42759 5579 12 New New NNP 42759 5579 13 York York NNP 42759 5579 14 , , , 42759 5579 15 and and CC 42759 5579 16 the the DT 42759 5579 17 latter latter JJ 42759 5579 18 by by IN 42759 5579 19 the the DT 42759 5579 20 Review Review NNP 42759 5579 21 Publishing Publishing NNP 42759 5579 22 Company Company NNP 42759 5579 23 , , , 42759 5579 24 Minneapolis Minneapolis NNP 42759 5579 25 . . . 42759 5580 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5580 2 259 259 CD 42759 5580 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5580 4 " " `` 42759 5580 5 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 5580 6 Rates rate NNS 42759 5580 7 in in IN 42759 5580 8 the the DT 42759 5580 9 Tailoring Tailoring NNP 42759 5580 10 Industry industry NN 42759 5580 11 , , , 42759 5580 12 " " '' 42759 5580 13 p. p. NN 42759 5580 14 161 161 CD 42759 5580 15 . . . 42759 5581 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5581 2 260 260 CD 42759 5581 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5581 4 One one CD 42759 5581 5 of of IN 42759 5581 6 the the DT 42759 5581 7 best good JJS 42759 5581 8 statements statement NNS 42759 5581 9 of of IN 42759 5581 10 the the DT 42759 5581 11 economic economic JJ 42759 5581 12 aspect aspect NN 42759 5581 13 of of IN 42759 5581 14 the the DT 42759 5581 15 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5581 16 wage wage NN 42759 5581 17 is be VBZ 42759 5581 18 that that IN 42759 5581 19 by by IN 42759 5581 20 Sidney Sidney NNP 42759 5581 21 Webb Webb NNP 42759 5581 22 , , , 42759 5581 23 in in IN 42759 5581 24 the the DT 42759 5581 25 _ _ NNP 42759 5581 26 Journal Journal NNP 42759 5581 27 of of IN 42759 5581 28 Political Political NNP 42759 5581 29 Economy Economy NNP 42759 5581 30 _ _ NNP 42759 5581 31 , , , 42759 5581 32 Dec. December NNP 42759 5581 33 , , , 42759 5581 34 1912 1912 CD 42759 5581 35 . . . 42759 5582 1 Probably probably RB 42759 5582 2 the the DT 42759 5582 3 most most RBS 42759 5582 4 varied varied JJ 42759 5582 5 and and CC 42759 5582 6 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 5582 7 general general JJ 42759 5582 8 discussion discussion NN 42759 5582 9 is be VBZ 42759 5582 10 the the DT 42759 5582 11 symposium symposium NN 42759 5582 12 in in IN 42759 5582 13 the the DT 42759 5582 14 _ _ NNP 42759 5582 15 Survey Survey NNP 42759 5582 16 _ _ NNP 42759 5582 17 , , , 42759 5582 18 Feb. February NNP 42759 5582 19 6 6 CD 42759 5582 20 , , , 42759 5582 21 1915 1915 CD 42759 5582 22 . . . 42759 5583 1 See see VB 42759 5583 2 especially especially RB 42759 5583 3 the the DT 42759 5583 4 excellent excellent JJ 42759 5583 5 presentation presentation NN 42759 5583 6 in in IN 42759 5583 7 Commons Commons NNP 42759 5583 8 and and CC 42759 5583 9 Andrews Andrews NNP 42759 5583 10 ' ' POS 42759 5583 11 " " `` 42759 5583 12 Principles Principles NNPS 42759 5583 13 of of IN 42759 5583 14 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5583 15 Legislation Legislation NNP 42759 5583 16 , , , 42759 5583 17 " " '' 42759 5583 18 pp pp NNP 42759 5583 19 . . . 42759 5584 1 167 167 CD 42759 5584 2 - - SYM 42759 5584 3 200 200 CD 42759 5584 4 . . . 42759 5585 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5585 2 261 261 CD 42759 5585 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5585 4 See see VB 42759 5585 5 pages page NNS 42759 5585 6 303 303 CD 42759 5585 7 , , , 42759 5585 8 304 304 CD 42759 5585 9 of of IN 42759 5585 10 " " `` 42759 5585 11 A a DT 42759 5585 12 Living live VBG 42759 5585 13 Wage wage NN 42759 5585 14 " " '' 42759 5585 15 ; ; : 42759 5585 16 Macmillan Macmillan NNP 42759 5585 17 , , , 42759 5585 18 1906 1906 CD 42759 5585 19 . . . 42759 5586 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5586 2 262 262 CD 42759 5586 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5586 4 O'Grady O'Grady NNP 42759 5586 5 , , , 42759 5586 6 " " `` 42759 5586 7 A a DT 42759 5586 8 Legal Legal NNP 42759 5586 9 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 5586 10 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5586 11 " " '' 42759 5586 12 ; ; : 42759 5586 13 Washington Washington NNP 42759 5586 14 , , , 42759 5586 15 1915 1915 CD 42759 5586 16 . . . 42759 5587 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5587 2 263 263 CD 42759 5587 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5587 4 " " `` 42759 5587 5 Final Final NNP 42759 5587 6 Report Report NNP 42759 5587 7 , , , 42759 5587 8 " " '' 42759 5587 9 pp pp NNP 42759 5587 10 . . . 42759 5588 1 101 101 CD 42759 5588 2 , , , 42759 5588 3 255 255 CD 42759 5588 4 , , , 42759 5588 5 364 364 CD 42759 5588 6 . . . 42759 5589 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5589 2 264 264 CD 42759 5589 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5589 4 _ _ NNP 42759 5589 5 The the DT 42759 5589 6 Quarterly Quarterly NNP 42759 5589 7 Journal Journal NNP 42759 5589 8 of of IN 42759 5589 9 Economics Economics NNP 42759 5589 10 _ _ NNP 42759 5589 11 , , , 42759 5589 12 May May NNP 42759 5589 13 , , , 42759 5589 14 1916 1916 CD 42759 5589 15 . . . 42759 5590 1 A a DT 42759 5590 2 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 5590 3 less less RBR 42759 5590 4 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 42759 5590 5 criticism criticism NN 42759 5590 6 is be VBZ 42759 5590 7 contained contain VBN 42759 5590 8 in in IN 42759 5590 9 the the DT 42759 5590 10 paper paper NN 42759 5590 11 by by IN 42759 5590 12 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5590 13 John John NNP 42759 5590 14 Bates Bates NNP 42759 5590 15 Clark Clark NNP 42759 5590 16 in in IN 42759 5590 17 the the DT 42759 5590 18 _ _ NNP 42759 5590 19 Atlantic Atlantic NNP 42759 5590 20 Monthly Monthly NNP 42759 5590 21 _ _ NNP 42759 5590 22 , , , 42759 5590 23 September September NNP 42759 5590 24 , , , 42759 5590 25 1913 1913 CD 42759 5590 26 . . . 42759 5591 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5591 2 265 265 CD 42759 5591 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5591 4 Page page NN 42759 5591 5 436 436 CD 42759 5591 6 . . . 42759 5592 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5592 2 266 266 CD 42759 5592 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5592 4 " " `` 42759 5592 5 The the DT 42759 5592 6 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 5592 7 and and CC 42759 5592 8 Income Income NNP 42759 5592 9 of of IN 42759 5592 10 the the DT 42759 5592 11 People People NNS 42759 5592 12 of of IN 42759 5592 13 the the DT 42759 5592 14 United United NNP 42759 5592 15 States States NNP 42759 5592 16 , , , 42759 5592 17 " " '' 42759 5592 18 p. p. NN 42759 5592 19 129 129 CD 42759 5592 20 . . . 42759 5593 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5593 2 267 267 CD 42759 5593 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5593 4 Page Page NNP 42759 5593 5 437 437 CD 42759 5593 6 . . . 42759 5594 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5594 2 268 268 CD 42759 5594 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5594 4 " " `` 42759 5594 5 Final Final NNP 42759 5594 6 Report Report NNP 42759 5594 7 , , , 42759 5594 8 " " '' 42759 5594 9 p. p. NN 42759 5594 10 802 802 CD 42759 5594 11 . . . 42759 5595 1 Washington Washington NNP 42759 5595 2 , , , 42759 5595 3 1902 1902 CD 42759 5595 4 . . . 42759 5596 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5596 2 269 269 CD 42759 5596 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5596 4 See see VB 42759 5596 5 article article NN 42759 5596 6 by by IN 42759 5596 7 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5596 8 Commons Commons NNP 42759 5596 9 in in IN 42759 5596 10 " " `` 42759 5596 11 The the DT 42759 5596 12 New New NNP 42759 5596 13 Encyclopedia Encyclopedia NNP 42759 5596 14 of of IN 42759 5596 15 Social Social NNP 42759 5596 16 Reform Reform NNP 42759 5596 17 , , , 42759 5596 18 " " '' 42759 5596 19 p. p. NN 42759 5596 20 1233 1233 CD 42759 5596 21 . . . 42759 5597 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5597 2 270 270 CD 42759 5597 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5597 4 _ _ NNP 42759 5597 5 The the DT 42759 5597 6 Quarterly Quarterly NNP 42759 5597 7 Journal Journal NNP 42759 5597 8 of of IN 42759 5597 9 Economics Economics NNP 42759 5597 10 _ _ NNP 42759 5597 11 , , , 42759 5597 12 May May NNP 42759 5597 13 , , , 42759 5597 14 1916 1916 CD 42759 5597 15 , , , 42759 5597 16 p. p. NN 42759 5597 17 502 502 CD 42759 5597 18 . . . 42759 5598 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5598 2 271 271 CD 42759 5598 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5598 4 " " `` 42759 5598 5 Problems Problems NNPS 42759 5598 6 of of IN 42759 5598 7 Poverty poverty NN 42759 5598 8 , , , 42759 5598 9 " " '' 42759 5598 10 p. p. NN 42759 5598 11 227 227 CD 42759 5598 12 . . . 42759 5599 1 London London NNP 42759 5599 2 , , , 42759 5599 3 1891 1891 CD 42759 5599 4 . . . 42759 5600 1 [ [ -LRB- 42759 5600 2 272 272 CD 42759 5600 3 ] ] -RRB- 42759 5600 4 " " `` 42759 5600 5 Minimum Minimum NNP 42759 5600 6 Rates rate NNS 42759 5600 7 in in IN 42759 5600 8 the the DT 42759 5600 9 Tailoring Tailoring NNP 42759 5600 10 Industry industry NN 42759 5600 11 , , , 42759 5600 12 " " '' 42759 5600 13 p. p. NN 42759 5600 14 96 96 CD 42759 5600 15 . . . 42759 5601 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 42759 5601 2 XXVI XXVI NNP 42759 5601 3 SUMMARY summary NN 42759 5601 4 AND and CC 42759 5601 5 CONCLUSION conclusion NN 42759 5601 6 Throughout throughout IN 42759 5601 7 this this DT 42759 5601 8 book book NN 42759 5601 9 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5601 10 have have VBP 42759 5601 11 been be VBN 42759 5601 12 concerned concern VBN 42759 5601 13 with with IN 42759 5601 14 a a DT 42759 5601 15 two two CD 42759 5601 16 - - HYPH 42759 5601 17 fold fold NN 42759 5601 18 problem problem NN 42759 5601 19 : : : 42759 5601 20 to to TO 42759 5601 21 apply apply VB 42759 5601 22 the the DT 42759 5601 23 principles principle NNS 42759 5601 24 of of IN 42759 5601 25 justice justice NN 42759 5601 26 to to IN 42759 5601 27 the the DT 42759 5601 28 workings working NNS 42759 5601 29 of of IN 42759 5601 30 the the DT 42759 5601 31 present present JJ 42759 5601 32 distributive distributive JJ 42759 5601 33 system system NN 42759 5601 34 , , , 42759 5601 35 and and CC 42759 5601 36 to to TO 42759 5601 37 point point VB 42759 5601 38 out out RP 42759 5601 39 the the DT 42759 5601 40 modifications modification NNS 42759 5601 41 of of IN 42759 5601 42 the the DT 42759 5601 43 system system NN 42759 5601 44 that that WDT 42759 5601 45 seemed seem VBD 42759 5601 46 to to TO 42759 5601 47 promise promise VB 42759 5601 48 a a DT 42759 5601 49 larger large JJR 42759 5601 50 measure measure NN 42759 5601 51 of of IN 42759 5601 52 actual actual JJ 42759 5601 53 justice justice NN 42759 5601 54 . . . 42759 5602 1 The the DT 42759 5602 2 mechanism mechanism NN 42759 5602 3 of of IN 42759 5602 4 distribution distribution NN 42759 5602 5 was be VBD 42759 5602 6 described describe VBN 42759 5602 7 in in IN 42759 5602 8 the the DT 42759 5602 9 introductory introductory JJ 42759 5602 10 chapter chapter NN 42759 5602 11 as as IN 42759 5602 12 apportioning apportion VBG 42759 5602 13 the the DT 42759 5602 14 national national JJ 42759 5602 15 product product NN 42759 5602 16 among among IN 42759 5602 17 the the DT 42759 5602 18 four four CD 42759 5602 19 classes class NNS 42759 5602 20 that that WDT 42759 5602 21 contribute contribute VBP 42759 5602 22 the the DT 42759 5602 23 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5602 24 factors factor NNS 42759 5602 25 to to IN 42759 5602 26 the the DT 42759 5602 27 process process NN 42759 5602 28 of of IN 42759 5602 29 production production NN 42759 5602 30 , , , 42759 5602 31 and and CC 42759 5602 32 the the DT 42759 5602 33 first first JJ 42759 5602 34 part part NN 42759 5602 35 of of IN 42759 5602 36 the the DT 42759 5602 37 problem problem NN 42759 5602 38 was be VBD 42759 5602 39 stated state VBN 42759 5602 40 as as IN 42759 5602 41 that that DT 42759 5602 42 of of IN 42759 5602 43 ascertaining ascertain VBG 42759 5602 44 the the DT 42759 5602 45 size size NN 42759 5602 46 of of IN 42759 5602 47 the the DT 42759 5602 48 share share NN 42759 5602 49 which which WDT 42759 5602 50 ought ought MD 42759 5602 51 to to TO 42759 5602 52 go go VB 42759 5602 53 to to IN 42759 5602 54 each each DT 42759 5602 55 of of IN 42759 5602 56 these these DT 42759 5602 57 classes class NNS 42759 5602 58 . . . 42759 5603 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5603 2 The the DT 42759 5603 3 Landowner Landowner NNP 42759 5603 4 and and CC 42759 5603 5 Rent Rent NNP 42759 5603 6 _ _ NNP 42759 5603 7 We -PRON- PRP 42759 5603 8 began begin VBD 42759 5603 9 this this DT 42759 5603 10 inquiry inquiry NN 42759 5603 11 with with IN 42759 5603 12 the the DT 42759 5603 13 landowner landowner NN 42759 5603 14 and and CC 42759 5603 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5603 16 share share NN 42759 5603 17 of of IN 42759 5603 18 the the DT 42759 5603 19 product product NN 42759 5603 20 , , , 42759 5603 21 i.e. i.e. FW 42759 5603 22 , , , 42759 5603 23 rent rent NN 42759 5603 24 . . . 42759 5604 1 We -PRON- PRP 42759 5604 2 found find VBD 42759 5604 3 that that IN 42759 5604 4 private private JJ 42759 5604 5 ownership ownership NN 42759 5604 6 of of IN 42759 5604 7 land land NN 42759 5604 8 has have VBZ 42759 5604 9 prevailed prevail VBN 42759 5604 10 throughout throughout IN 42759 5604 11 the the DT 42759 5604 12 world world NN 42759 5604 13 with with IN 42759 5604 14 practical practical JJ 42759 5604 15 universality universality NN 42759 5604 16 ever ever RB 42759 5604 17 since since IN 42759 5604 18 men man NNS 42759 5604 19 began begin VBD 42759 5604 20 to to TO 42759 5604 21 till till VB 42759 5604 22 the the DT 42759 5604 23 soil soil NN 42759 5604 24 in in IN 42759 5604 25 settled settle VBN 42759 5604 26 communities community NNS 42759 5604 27 . . . 42759 5605 1 The the DT 42759 5605 2 arguments argument NNS 42759 5605 3 of of IN 42759 5605 4 Henry Henry NNP 42759 5605 5 George George NNP 42759 5605 6 against against IN 42759 5605 7 the the DT 42759 5605 8 justice justice NN 42759 5605 9 of of IN 42759 5605 10 the the DT 42759 5605 11 institution institution NN 42759 5605 12 are be VBP 42759 5605 13 invalid invalid JJ 42759 5605 14 because because IN 42759 5605 15 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5605 16 do do VBP 42759 5605 17 not not RB 42759 5605 18 prove prove VB 42759 5605 19 that that IN 42759 5605 20 labour labour NN 42759 5605 21 is be VBZ 42759 5605 22 the the DT 42759 5605 23 only only JJ 42759 5605 24 title title NN 42759 5605 25 of of IN 42759 5605 26 property property NN 42759 5605 27 , , , 42759 5605 28 nor nor CC 42759 5605 29 that that IN 42759 5605 30 men man NNS 42759 5605 31 's 's POS 42759 5605 32 equal equal JJ 42759 5605 33 rights right NNS 42759 5605 34 to to IN 42759 5605 35 the the DT 42759 5605 36 earth earth NN 42759 5605 37 are be VBP 42759 5605 38 incompatible incompatible JJ 42759 5605 39 with with IN 42759 5605 40 private private JJ 42759 5605 41 landownership landownership NN 42759 5605 42 , , , 42759 5605 43 nor nor CC 42759 5605 44 that that IN 42759 5605 45 the the DT 42759 5605 46 so so RB 42759 5605 47 - - HYPH 42759 5605 48 called call VBN 42759 5605 49 social social JJ 42759 5605 50 production production NN 42759 5605 51 of of IN 42759 5605 52 land land NN 42759 5605 53 values value NNS 42759 5605 54 confers confer NNS 42759 5605 55 upon upon IN 42759 5605 56 the the DT 42759 5605 57 community community NN 42759 5605 58 a a DT 42759 5605 59 right right NN 42759 5605 60 to to TO 42759 5605 61 rent rent VB 42759 5605 62 . . . 42759 5606 1 Private private JJ 42759 5606 2 ownership ownership NN 42759 5606 3 is be VBZ 42759 5606 4 not not RB 42759 5606 5 only only RB 42759 5606 6 socially socially RB 42759 5606 7 preferable preferable JJ 42759 5606 8 to to IN 42759 5606 9 the the DT 42759 5606 10 Socialist Socialist NNP 42759 5606 11 and and CC 42759 5606 12 the the DT 42759 5606 13 Single Single NNP 42759 5606 14 Tax Tax NNP 42759 5606 15 systems system NNS 42759 5606 16 of of IN 42759 5606 17 land land NN 42759 5606 18 tenure tenure NN 42759 5606 19 , , , 42759 5606 20 but but CC 42759 5606 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5606 22 is be VBZ 42759 5606 23 , , , 42759 5606 24 as as IN 42759 5606 25 compared compare VBN 42759 5606 26 with with IN 42759 5606 27 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 5606 28 certainly certainly RB 42759 5606 29 , , , 42759 5606 30 and and CC 42759 5606 31 as as IN 42759 5606 32 compared compare VBN 42759 5606 33 with with IN 42759 5606 34 the the DT 42759 5606 35 Single Single NNP 42759 5606 36 Tax Tax NNP 42759 5606 37 probably probably RB 42759 5606 38 , , , 42759 5606 39 among among IN 42759 5606 40 man man NN 42759 5606 41 's 's POS 42759 5606 42 natural natural JJ 42759 5606 43 rights right NNS 42759 5606 44 . . . 42759 5607 1 On on IN 42759 5607 2 the the DT 42759 5607 3 other other JJ 42759 5607 4 hand hand NN 42759 5607 5 , , , 42759 5607 6 the the DT 42759 5607 7 landowner landowner NN 42759 5607 8 's 's POS 42759 5607 9 right right NN 42759 5607 10 to to TO 42759 5607 11 take take VB 42759 5607 12 rent rent NN 42759 5607 13 is be VBZ 42759 5607 14 no no RB 42759 5607 15 stronger strong JJR 42759 5607 16 than than IN 42759 5607 17 the the DT 42759 5607 18 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5607 19 's 's POS 42759 5607 20 right right NN 42759 5607 21 to to TO 42759 5607 22 take take VB 42759 5607 23 interest interest NN 42759 5607 24 ; ; : 42759 5607 25 and and CC 42759 5607 26 in in IN 42759 5607 27 any any DT 42759 5607 28 case case NN 42759 5607 29 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5607 30 is be VBZ 42759 5607 31 inferior inferior JJ 42759 5607 32 to to IN 42759 5607 33 the the DT 42759 5607 34 right right NN 42759 5607 35 of of IN 42759 5607 36 the the DT 42759 5607 37 tenant tenant NN 42759 5607 38 to to IN 42759 5607 39 a a DT 42759 5607 40 decent decent JJ 42759 5607 41 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5607 42 , , , 42759 5607 43 and and CC 42759 5607 44 of of IN 42759 5607 45 the the DT 42759 5607 46 employé employé NNS 42759 5607 47 to to IN 42759 5607 48 a a DT 42759 5607 49 living living NN 42759 5607 50 wage wage NN 42759 5607 51 . . . 42759 5608 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 5608 2 , , , 42759 5608 3 the the DT 42759 5608 4 present present JJ 42759 5608 5 system system NN 42759 5608 6 of of IN 42759 5608 7 land land NN 42759 5608 8 tenure tenure NN 42759 5608 9 is be VBZ 42759 5608 10 not not RB 42759 5608 11 perfect perfect JJ 42759 5608 12 . . . 42759 5609 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5609 2 principal principal JJ 42759 5609 3 defects defect NNS 42759 5609 4 are be VBP 42759 5609 5 : : : 42759 5609 6 the the DT 42759 5609 7 promotion promotion NN 42759 5609 8 of of IN 42759 5609 9 certain certain JJ 42759 5609 10 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 5609 11 , , , 42759 5609 12 as as IN 42759 5609 13 , , , 42759 5609 14 anthracite anthracite NN 42759 5609 15 coal coal NN 42759 5609 16 , , , 42759 5609 17 steel steel NN 42759 5609 18 , , , 42759 5609 19 natural natural JJ 42759 5609 20 gas gas NN 42759 5609 21 , , , 42759 5609 22 petroleum petroleum NN 42759 5609 23 , , , 42759 5609 24 water water NN 42759 5609 25 power power NN 42759 5609 26 , , , 42759 5609 27 and and CC 42759 5609 28 lumber lumber NN 42759 5609 29 ; ; : 42759 5609 30 the the DT 42759 5609 31 diversion diversion NN 42759 5609 32 of of IN 42759 5609 33 excessive excessive JJ 42759 5609 34 gains gain NNS 42759 5609 35 to to IN 42759 5609 36 landowners landowner NNS 42759 5609 37 , , , 42759 5609 38 as as IN 42759 5609 39 indicated indicate VBN 42759 5609 40 by by IN 42759 5609 41 the the DT 42759 5609 42 recent recent JJ 42759 5609 43 great great JJ 42759 5609 44 increases increase NNS 42759 5609 45 in in IN 42759 5609 46 the the DT 42759 5609 47 value value NN 42759 5609 48 of of IN 42759 5609 49 land land NN 42759 5609 50 , , , 42759 5609 51 and and CC 42759 5609 52 the the DT 42759 5609 53 very very RB 42759 5609 54 large large JJ 42759 5609 55 holdings holding NNS 42759 5609 56 by by IN 42759 5609 57 individuals individual NNS 42759 5609 58 and and CC 42759 5609 59 corporations corporation NNS 42759 5609 60 ; ; : 42759 5609 61 and and CC 42759 5609 62 the the DT 42759 5609 63 exclusion exclusion NN 42759 5609 64 of of IN 42759 5609 65 large large JJ 42759 5609 66 masses masse NNS 42759 5609 67 of of IN 42759 5609 68 men man NNS 42759 5609 69 from from IN 42759 5609 70 the the DT 42759 5609 71 land land NN 42759 5609 72 because because IN 42759 5609 73 the the DT 42759 5609 74 owners owner NNS 42759 5609 75 will will MD 42759 5609 76 not not RB 42759 5609 77 sell sell VB 42759 5609 78 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5609 79 at at IN 42759 5609 80 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5609 81 present present JJ 42759 5609 82 economic economic JJ 42759 5609 83 value value NN 42759 5609 84 . . . 42759 5610 1 The the DT 42759 5610 2 remedies remedy NNS 42759 5610 3 for for IN 42759 5610 4 these these DT 42759 5610 5 evils evil NNS 42759 5610 6 fall fall VBP 42759 5610 7 mainly mainly RB 42759 5610 8 under under IN 42759 5610 9 the the DT 42759 5610 10 heads head NNS 42759 5610 11 of of IN 42759 5610 12 ownership ownership NN 42759 5610 13 and and CC 42759 5610 14 taxation taxation NN 42759 5610 15 . . . 42759 5611 1 All all DT 42759 5611 2 mineral mineral NN 42759 5611 3 , , , 42759 5611 4 timber timber NN 42759 5611 5 , , , 42759 5611 6 gas gas NN 42759 5611 7 , , , 42759 5611 8 oil oil NN 42759 5611 9 , , , 42759 5611 10 grazing grazing NN 42759 5611 11 , , , 42759 5611 12 and and CC 42759 5611 13 water water NN 42759 5611 14 - - HYPH 42759 5611 15 power power NN 42759 5611 16 lands land NNS 42759 5611 17 that that WDT 42759 5611 18 are be VBP 42759 5611 19 now now RB 42759 5611 20 publicly publicly RB 42759 5611 21 owned own VBN 42759 5611 22 , , , 42759 5611 23 should should MD 42759 5611 24 remain remain VB 42759 5611 25 the the DT 42759 5611 26 property property NN 42759 5611 27 of of IN 42759 5611 28 the the DT 42759 5611 29 states state NNS 42759 5611 30 and and CC 42759 5611 31 the the DT 42759 5611 32 nation nation NN 42759 5611 33 , , , 42759 5611 34 and and CC 42759 5611 35 be be VB 42759 5611 36 brought bring VBN 42759 5611 37 into into IN 42759 5611 38 use use NN 42759 5611 39 through through IN 42759 5611 40 a a DT 42759 5611 41 system system NN 42759 5611 42 of of IN 42759 5611 43 leases lease NNS 42759 5611 44 to to IN 42759 5611 45 private private JJ 42759 5611 46 individuals individual NNS 42759 5611 47 and and CC 42759 5611 48 corporations corporation NNS 42759 5611 49 . . . 42759 5612 1 Cities city NNS 42759 5612 2 should should MD 42759 5612 3 purchase purchase VB 42759 5612 4 land land NN 42759 5612 5 , , , 42759 5612 6 and and CC 42759 5612 7 lease lease VB 42759 5612 8 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5612 9 for for IN 42759 5612 10 long long JJ 42759 5612 11 periods period NNS 42759 5612 12 to to IN 42759 5612 13 persons person NNS 42759 5612 14 who who WP 42759 5612 15 wish wish VBP 42759 5612 16 to to TO 42759 5612 17 erect erect VB 42759 5612 18 business business NN 42759 5612 19 buildings building NNS 42759 5612 20 and and CC 42759 5612 21 dwellings dwelling NNS 42759 5612 22 . . . 42759 5613 1 By by IN 42759 5613 2 means mean NNS 42759 5613 3 of of IN 42759 5613 4 taxation taxation NN 42759 5613 5 the the DT 42759 5613 6 State state NN 42759 5613 7 might may MD 42759 5613 8 appropriate appropriate VB 42759 5613 9 the the DT 42759 5613 10 future future JJ 42759 5613 11 increases increase NNS 42759 5613 12 of of IN 42759 5613 13 land land NN 42759 5613 14 values value NNS 42759 5613 15 , , , 42759 5613 16 subject subject JJ 42759 5613 17 to to IN 42759 5613 18 the the DT 42759 5613 19 reimbursement reimbursement NN 42759 5613 20 of of IN 42759 5613 21 private private JJ 42759 5613 22 owners owner NNS 42759 5613 23 for for IN 42759 5613 24 resulting result VBG 42759 5613 25 decreases decrease NNS 42759 5613 26 in in IN 42759 5613 27 value value NN 42759 5613 28 ; ; : 42759 5613 29 and and CC 42759 5613 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5613 31 could could MD 42759 5613 32 transfer transfer VB 42759 5613 33 the the DT 42759 5613 34 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5613 35 on on IN 42759 5613 36 improvements improvement NNS 42759 5613 37 and and CC 42759 5613 38 personal personal JJ 42759 5613 39 property property NN 42759 5613 40 to to IN 42759 5613 41 land land NN 42759 5613 42 , , , 42759 5613 43 provided provide VBN 42759 5613 44 that that IN 42759 5613 45 the the DT 42759 5613 46 process process NN 42759 5613 47 were be VBD 42759 5613 48 sufficiently sufficiently RB 42759 5613 49 gradual gradual JJ 42759 5613 50 to to TO 42759 5613 51 prevent prevent VB 42759 5613 52 any any DT 42759 5613 53 substantial substantial JJ 42759 5613 54 decline decline NN 42759 5613 55 in in IN 42759 5613 56 land land NN 42759 5613 57 values value NNS 42759 5613 58 . . . 42759 5614 1 In in IN 42759 5614 2 some some DT 42759 5614 3 cases case NNS 42759 5614 4 the the DT 42759 5614 5 State state NN 42759 5614 6 might may MD 42759 5614 7 hasten hasten VB 42759 5614 8 the the DT 42759 5614 9 dissolution dissolution NN 42759 5614 10 of of IN 42759 5614 11 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 5614 12 large large JJ 42759 5614 13 and and CC 42759 5614 14 valuable valuable JJ 42759 5614 15 estates estate NNS 42759 5614 16 through through IN 42759 5614 17 the the DT 42759 5614 18 imposition imposition NN 42759 5614 19 of of IN 42759 5614 20 a a DT 42759 5614 21 supertax supertax NN 42759 5614 22 . . . 42759 5615 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5615 2 The the DT 42759 5615 3 Capitalist Capitalist NNP 42759 5615 4 and and CC 42759 5615 5 Interest Interest NNP 42759 5615 6 _ _ NNP 42759 5615 7 The the DT 42759 5615 8 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 5615 9 contention contention NN 42759 5615 10 that that IN 42759 5615 11 the the DT 42759 5615 12 labourer labourer NN 42759 5615 13 has have VBZ 42759 5615 14 a a DT 42759 5615 15 right right NN 42759 5615 16 to to IN 42759 5615 17 the the DT 42759 5615 18 entire entire JJ 42759 5615 19 product product NN 42759 5615 20 of of IN 42759 5615 21 industry industry NN 42759 5615 22 , , , 42759 5615 23 and and CC 42759 5615 24 therefore therefore RB 42759 5615 25 that that IN 42759 5615 26 the the DT 42759 5615 27 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5615 28 has have VBZ 42759 5615 29 no no DT 42759 5615 30 right right NN 42759 5615 31 to to IN 42759 5615 32 interest interest NN 42759 5615 33 , , , 42759 5615 34 is be VBZ 42759 5615 35 invalid invalid JJ 42759 5615 36 unless unless IN 42759 5615 37 the the DT 42759 5615 38 former former JJ 42759 5615 39 alleged alleged JJ 42759 5615 40 right right NN 42759 5615 41 can can MD 42759 5615 42 be be VB 42759 5615 43 effectuated effectuate VBN 42759 5615 44 in in IN 42759 5615 45 a a DT 42759 5615 46 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5615 47 scheme scheme NN 42759 5615 48 of of IN 42759 5615 49 distribution distribution NN 42759 5615 50 ; ; : 42759 5615 51 and and CC 42759 5615 52 we -PRON- PRP 42759 5615 53 know know VBP 42759 5615 54 that that IN 42759 5615 55 the the DT 42759 5615 56 contemplated contemplate VBN 42759 5615 57 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 5615 58 scheme scheme NN 42759 5615 59 is be VBZ 42759 5615 60 impracticable impracticable JJ 42759 5615 61 . . . 42759 5616 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 42759 5616 2 , , , 42759 5616 3 the the DT 42759 5616 4 refutation refutation NN 42759 5616 5 of of IN 42759 5616 6 the the DT 42759 5616 7 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 5616 8 position position NN 42759 5616 9 does do VBZ 42759 5616 10 not not RB 42759 5616 11 automatically automatically RB 42759 5616 12 prove prove VB 42759 5616 13 that that IN 42759 5616 14 the the DT 42759 5616 15 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5616 16 has have VBZ 42759 5616 17 a a DT 42759 5616 18 right right NN 42759 5616 19 to to TO 42759 5616 20 take take VB 42759 5616 21 interest interest NN 42759 5616 22 . . . 42759 5617 1 Of of IN 42759 5617 2 the the DT 42759 5617 3 titles title NNS 42759 5617 4 ordinarily ordinarily RB 42759 5617 5 alleged allege VBN 42759 5617 6 in in IN 42759 5617 7 support support NN 42759 5617 8 of of IN 42759 5617 9 such such PDT 42759 5617 10 a a DT 42759 5617 11 right right NN 42759 5617 12 , , , 42759 5617 13 productivity productivity NN 42759 5617 14 and and CC 42759 5617 15 service service NN 42759 5617 16 are be VBP 42759 5617 17 inconclusive inconclusive JJ 42759 5617 18 , , , 42759 5617 19 while while IN 42759 5617 20 abstinence abstinence NN 42759 5617 21 is be VBZ 42759 5617 22 valid valid JJ 42759 5617 23 only only RB 42759 5617 24 in in IN 42759 5617 25 the the DT 42759 5617 26 case case NN 42759 5617 27 of of IN 42759 5617 28 those those DT 42759 5617 29 capital capital NN 42759 5617 30 owners owner NNS 42759 5617 31 to to TO 42759 5617 32 whom whom WP 42759 5617 33 interest interest NN 42759 5617 34 was be VBD 42759 5617 35 a a DT 42759 5617 36 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5617 37 inducement inducement NN 42759 5617 38 for for IN 42759 5617 39 saving saving NN 42759 5617 40 . . . 42759 5618 1 Since since IN 42759 5618 2 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5618 3 is be VBZ 42759 5618 4 uncertain uncertain JJ 42759 5618 5 whether whether IN 42759 5618 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5618 7 capital capital NN 42759 5618 8 would would MD 42759 5618 9 be be VB 42759 5618 10 provided provide VBN 42759 5618 11 without without IN 42759 5618 12 interest interest NN 42759 5618 13 , , , 42759 5618 14 and and CC 42759 5618 15 since since IN 42759 5618 16 the the DT 42759 5618 17 legal legal JJ 42759 5618 18 suppression suppression NN 42759 5618 19 of of IN 42759 5618 20 interest interest NN 42759 5618 21 is be VBZ 42759 5618 22 impracticable impracticable JJ 42759 5618 23 , , , 42759 5618 24 the the DT 42759 5618 25 State State NNP 42759 5618 26 is be VBZ 42759 5618 27 justified justify VBN 42759 5618 28 in in IN 42759 5618 29 permitting permit VBG 42759 5618 30 the the DT 42759 5618 31 practice practice NN 42759 5618 32 of of IN 42759 5618 33 taking take VBG 42759 5618 34 interest interest NN 42759 5618 35 . . . 42759 5619 1 But but CC 42759 5619 2 this this DT 42759 5619 3 legal legal JJ 42759 5619 4 permission permission NN 42759 5619 5 does do VBZ 42759 5619 6 not not RB 42759 5619 7 justify justify VB 42759 5619 8 the the DT 42759 5619 9 individual individual JJ 42759 5619 10 interest interest NN 42759 5619 11 - - HYPH 42759 5619 12 receiver receiver NN 42759 5619 13 . . . 42759 5620 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5620 2 main main JJ 42759 5620 3 and and CC 42759 5620 4 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5620 5 justification justification NN 42759 5620 6 is be VBZ 42759 5620 7 to to TO 42759 5620 8 be be VB 42759 5620 9 found find VBN 42759 5620 10 in in IN 42759 5620 11 the the DT 42759 5620 12 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 5620 13 title title NN 42759 5620 14 which which WDT 42759 5620 15 arises arise VBZ 42759 5620 16 out out IN 42759 5620 17 of of IN 42759 5620 18 possession possession NN 42759 5620 19 , , , 42759 5620 20 in in IN 42759 5620 21 the the DT 42759 5620 22 absence absence NN 42759 5620 23 of of IN 42759 5620 24 any any DT 42759 5620 25 adverse adverse JJ 42759 5620 26 claimant claimant NN 42759 5620 27 with with IN 42759 5620 28 a a DT 42759 5620 29 stronger strong JJR 42759 5620 30 title title NN 42759 5620 31 to to IN 42759 5620 32 this this DT 42759 5620 33 particular particular JJ 42759 5620 34 share share NN 42759 5620 35 of of IN 42759 5620 36 the the DT 42759 5620 37 product product NN 42759 5620 38 . . . 42759 5621 1 The the DT 42759 5621 2 only only JJ 42759 5621 3 available available JJ 42759 5621 4 methods method NNS 42759 5621 5 of of IN 42759 5621 6 lessening lessen VBG 42759 5621 7 the the DT 42759 5621 8 burden burden NN 42759 5621 9 of of IN 42759 5621 10 interest interest NN 42759 5621 11 are be VBP 42759 5621 12 a a DT 42759 5621 13 reduction reduction NN 42759 5621 14 in in IN 42759 5621 15 the the DT 42759 5621 16 rate rate NN 42759 5621 17 , , , 42759 5621 18 and and CC 42759 5621 19 a a DT 42759 5621 20 wider wide JJR 42759 5621 21 diffusion diffusion NN 42759 5621 22 of of IN 42759 5621 23 capital capital NN 42759 5621 24 through through IN 42759 5621 25 co co JJ 42759 5621 26 - - JJ 42759 5621 27 operative operative JJ 42759 5621 28 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 5621 29 . . . 42759 5622 1 Of of IN 42759 5622 2 these these DT 42759 5622 3 the the DT 42759 5622 4 former former JJ 42759 5622 5 presents present NNS 42759 5622 6 no no DT 42759 5622 7 definite definite JJ 42759 5622 8 or or CC 42759 5622 9 considerable considerable JJ 42759 5622 10 reasons reason NNS 42759 5622 11 for for IN 42759 5622 12 hope hope NN 42759 5622 13 , , , 42759 5622 14 either either CC 42759 5622 15 through through IN 42759 5622 16 the the DT 42759 5622 17 rapid rapid JJ 42759 5622 18 increase increase NN 42759 5622 19 of of IN 42759 5622 20 capital capital NN 42759 5622 21 or or CC 42759 5622 22 the the DT 42759 5622 23 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 5622 24 extension extension NN 42759 5622 25 of of IN 42759 5622 26 the the DT 42759 5622 27 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5622 28 function function NN 42759 5622 29 of of IN 42759 5622 30 government government NN 42759 5622 31 . . . 42759 5623 1 The the DT 42759 5623 2 second second JJ 42759 5623 3 proposal proposal NN 42759 5623 4 contains contain VBZ 42759 5623 5 great great JJ 42759 5623 6 possibilities possibility NNS 42759 5623 7 of of IN 42759 5623 8 betterment betterment NN 42759 5623 9 in in IN 42759 5623 10 the the DT 42759 5623 11 fields field NNS 42759 5623 12 of of IN 42759 5623 13 banking banking NN 42759 5623 14 , , , 42759 5623 15 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 5623 16 , , , 42759 5623 17 stores store NNS 42759 5623 18 , , , 42759 5623 19 and and CC 42759 5623 20 manufacture manufacture VB 42759 5623 21 . . . 42759 5624 1 Through through IN 42759 5624 2 co co NN 42759 5624 3 - - NN 42759 5624 4 operation operation VB 42759 5624 5 the the DT 42759 5624 6 weaker weak JJR 42759 5624 7 farmers farmer NNS 42759 5624 8 , , , 42759 5624 9 merchants merchant NNS 42759 5624 10 , , , 42759 5624 11 and and CC 42759 5624 12 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5624 13 can can MD 42759 5624 14 do do VB 42759 5624 15 business business NN 42759 5624 16 and and CC 42759 5624 17 obtain obtain VB 42759 5624 18 goods good NNS 42759 5624 19 at at IN 42759 5624 20 lower low JJR 42759 5624 21 costs cost NNS 42759 5624 22 , , , 42759 5624 23 and and CC 42759 5624 24 save save VB 42759 5624 25 money money NN 42759 5624 26 for for IN 42759 5624 27 investment investment NN 42759 5624 28 with with IN 42759 5624 29 greater great JJR 42759 5624 30 facility facility NN 42759 5624 31 , , , 42759 5624 32 while while IN 42759 5624 33 the the DT 42759 5624 34 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5624 35 can can MD 42759 5624 36 slowly slowly RB 42759 5624 37 but but CC 42759 5624 38 surely surely RB 42759 5624 39 become become VBP 42759 5624 40 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 5624 41 and and CC 42759 5624 42 interest interest NN 42759 5624 43 - - HYPH 42759 5624 44 receivers receiver NNS 42759 5624 45 , , , 42759 5624 46 as as RB 42759 5624 47 well well RB 42759 5624 48 as as IN 42759 5624 49 employés employés NN 42759 5624 50 and and CC 42759 5624 51 wage wage NN 42759 5624 52 - - HYPH 42759 5624 53 receivers receiver NNS 42759 5624 54 . . . 42759 5625 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5625 2 The the DT 42759 5625 3 Business Business NNP 42759 5625 4 Man Man NNP 42759 5625 5 and and CC 42759 5625 6 Profits Profits NNPS 42759 5625 7 _ _ NNP 42759 5625 8 Just just RB 42759 5625 9 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5625 10 for for IN 42759 5625 11 the the DT 42759 5625 12 active active JJ 42759 5625 13 agents agent NNS 42759 5625 14 of of IN 42759 5625 15 production production NN 42759 5625 16 , , , 42759 5625 17 whether whether IN 42759 5625 18 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5625 19 be be VBP 42759 5625 20 directors director NNS 42759 5625 21 of of IN 42759 5625 22 industry industry NN 42759 5625 23 or or CC 42759 5625 24 employés employés NNP 42759 5625 25 , , , 42759 5625 26 depends depend VBZ 42759 5625 27 fundamentally fundamentally RB 42759 5625 28 upon upon IN 42759 5625 29 five five CD 42759 5625 30 canons canon NNS 42759 5625 31 of of IN 42759 5625 32 distribution distribution NN 42759 5625 33 ; ; : 42759 5625 34 namely namely RB 42759 5625 35 , , , 42759 5625 36 needs need NNS 42759 5625 37 , , , 42759 5625 38 efforts effort NNS 42759 5625 39 and and CC 42759 5625 40 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5625 41 , , , 42759 5625 42 productivity productivity NN 42759 5625 43 , , , 42759 5625 44 scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5625 45 , , , 42759 5625 46 and and CC 42759 5625 47 human human JJ 42759 5625 48 welfare welfare NN 42759 5625 49 . . . 42759 5626 1 In in IN 42759 5626 2 the the DT 42759 5626 3 light light NN 42759 5626 4 of of IN 42759 5626 5 these these DT 42759 5626 6 principles principle NNS 42759 5626 7 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5626 8 is be VBZ 42759 5626 9 evident evident JJ 42759 5626 10 that that IN 42759 5626 11 business business NN 42759 5626 12 men man NNS 42759 5626 13 who who WP 42759 5626 14 use use VBP 42759 5626 15 fair fair JJ 42759 5626 16 methods method NNS 42759 5626 17 in in IN 42759 5626 18 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5626 19 conditions condition NNS 42759 5626 20 , , , 42759 5626 21 have have VBP 42759 5626 22 a a DT 42759 5626 23 right right NN 42759 5626 24 to to IN 42759 5626 25 all all PDT 42759 5626 26 the the DT 42759 5626 27 profits profit NNS 42759 5626 28 that that IN 42759 5626 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5626 30 can can MD 42759 5626 31 obtain obtain VB 42759 5626 32 . . . 42759 5627 1 On on IN 42759 5627 2 the the DT 42759 5627 3 other other JJ 42759 5627 4 hand hand NN 42759 5627 5 , , , 42759 5627 6 no no DT 42759 5627 7 business business NN 42759 5627 8 man man NN 42759 5627 9 has have VBZ 42759 5627 10 a a DT 42759 5627 11 strict strict JJ 42759 5627 12 right right NN 42759 5627 13 to to IN 42759 5627 14 a a DT 42759 5627 15 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5627 16 living living NN 42759 5627 17 profit profit NN 42759 5627 18 , , , 42759 5627 19 since since IN 42759 5627 20 that that DT 42759 5627 21 would would MD 42759 5627 22 imply imply VB 42759 5627 23 an an DT 42759 5627 24 obligation obligation NN 42759 5627 25 on on IN 42759 5627 26 the the DT 42759 5627 27 part part NN 42759 5627 28 of of IN 42759 5627 29 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5627 30 to to TO 42759 5627 31 support support VB 42759 5627 32 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 5627 33 and and CC 42759 5627 34 inefficient inefficient JJ 42759 5627 35 directors director NNS 42759 5627 36 of of IN 42759 5627 37 industry industry NN 42759 5627 38 . . . 42759 5628 1 Those those DT 42759 5628 2 who who WP 42759 5628 3 possess possess VBP 42759 5628 4 a a DT 42759 5628 5 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 5628 6 of of IN 42759 5628 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5628 8 products product NNS 42759 5628 9 or or CC 42759 5628 10 commodities commodity NNS 42759 5628 11 have have VBP 42759 5628 12 no no DT 42759 5628 13 right right NN 42759 5628 14 to to IN 42759 5628 15 more more JJR 42759 5628 16 than than IN 42759 5628 17 the the DT 42759 5628 18 prevailing prevailing JJ 42759 5628 19 or or CC 42759 5628 20 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5628 21 rate rate NN 42759 5628 22 of of IN 42759 5628 23 interest interest NN 42759 5628 24 on on IN 42759 5628 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5628 26 capital capital NN 42759 5628 27 , , , 42759 5628 28 though though IN 42759 5628 29 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5628 30 have have VBP 42759 5628 31 the the DT 42759 5628 32 same same JJ 42759 5628 33 right right NN 42759 5628 34 as as IN 42759 5628 35 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5628 36 business business NN 42759 5628 37 men man NNS 42759 5628 38 to to IN 42759 5628 39 any any DT 42759 5628 40 surplus surplus NN 42759 5628 41 gains gain NNS 42759 5628 42 that that WDT 42759 5628 43 may may MD 42759 5628 44 be be VB 42759 5628 45 due due IN 42759 5628 46 to to IN 42759 5628 47 superior superior JJ 42759 5628 48 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5628 49 . . . 42759 5629 1 The the DT 42759 5629 2 principal principal JJ 42759 5629 3 unfair unfair JJ 42759 5629 4 methods method NNS 42759 5629 5 of of IN 42759 5629 6 competition competition NN 42759 5629 7 ; ; : 42759 5629 8 that that RB 42759 5629 9 is is RB 42759 5629 10 , , , 42759 5629 11 discriminative discriminative JJ 42759 5629 12 underselling underselling NN 42759 5629 13 , , , 42759 5629 14 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 5629 15 - - HYPH 42759 5629 16 selling sell VBG 42759 5629 17 contracts contract NNS 42759 5629 18 , , , 42759 5629 19 and and CC 42759 5629 20 discrimination discrimination NN 42759 5629 21 in in IN 42759 5629 22 transportation transportation NN 42759 5629 23 , , , 42759 5629 24 are be VBP 42759 5629 25 all all RB 42759 5629 26 unjust unjust JJ 42759 5629 27 . . . 42759 5630 1 The the DT 42759 5630 2 remedies remedy NNS 42759 5630 3 for for IN 42759 5630 4 unjust unjust JJ 42759 5630 5 profits profit NNS 42759 5630 6 are be VBP 42759 5630 7 to to TO 42759 5630 8 be be VB 42759 5630 9 found find VBN 42759 5630 10 mainly mainly RB 42759 5630 11 in in IN 42759 5630 12 the the DT 42759 5630 13 action action NN 42759 5630 14 of of IN 42759 5630 15 government government NN 42759 5630 16 . . . 42759 5631 1 The the DT 42759 5631 2 State state NN 42759 5631 3 should should MD 42759 5631 4 either either CC 42759 5631 5 own own VB 42759 5631 6 and and CC 42759 5631 7 operate operate VBP 42759 5631 8 all all DT 42759 5631 9 natural natural JJ 42759 5631 10 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 5631 11 , , , 42759 5631 12 or or CC 42759 5631 13 so so RB 42759 5631 14 regulate regulate VB 42759 5631 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5631 16 charges charge NNS 42759 5631 17 that that IN 42759 5631 18 the the DT 42759 5631 19 owners owner NNS 42759 5631 20 would would MD 42759 5631 21 obtain obtain VB 42759 5631 22 only only RB 42759 5631 23 the the DT 42759 5631 24 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5631 25 rate rate NN 42759 5631 26 of of IN 42759 5631 27 interest interest NN 42759 5631 28 on on IN 42759 5631 29 the the DT 42759 5631 30 actual actual JJ 42759 5631 31 investment investment NN 42759 5631 32 , , , 42759 5631 33 and and CC 42759 5631 34 only only RB 42759 5631 35 such such JJ 42759 5631 36 surplus surplus JJ 42759 5631 37 gains gain NNS 42759 5631 38 as as IN 42759 5631 39 are be VBP 42759 5631 40 clearly clearly RB 42759 5631 41 due due JJ 42759 5631 42 to to IN 42759 5631 43 superior superior JJ 42759 5631 44 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5631 45 . . . 42759 5632 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5632 2 should should MD 42759 5632 3 prevent prevent VB 42759 5632 4 artificial artificial JJ 42759 5632 5 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 5632 6 from from IN 42759 5632 7 practising practise VBG 42759 5632 8 extortion extortion NN 42759 5632 9 toward toward IN 42759 5632 10 either either DT 42759 5632 11 consumers consumer NNS 42759 5632 12 or or CC 42759 5632 13 competitors competitor NNS 42759 5632 14 . . . 42759 5633 1 Should Should MD 42759 5633 2 the the DT 42759 5633 3 method method NN 42759 5633 4 of of IN 42759 5633 5 dissolution dissolution NN 42759 5633 6 prove prove VBP 42759 5633 7 inadequate inadequate JJ 42759 5633 8 to to IN 42759 5633 9 this this DT 42759 5633 10 end end NN 42759 5633 11 , , , 42759 5633 12 the the DT 42759 5633 13 State state NN 42759 5633 14 ought ought MD 42759 5633 15 to to TO 42759 5633 16 fix fix VB 42759 5633 17 maximum maximum JJ 42759 5633 18 prices price NNS 42759 5633 19 . . . 42759 5634 1 Inasmuch inasmuch JJ 42759 5634 2 as as IN 42759 5634 3 overcapitalisation overcapitalisation NN 42759 5634 4 has have VBZ 42759 5634 5 frequently frequently RB 42759 5634 6 enabled enable VBN 42759 5634 7 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 5634 8 concerns concern NNS 42759 5634 9 to to TO 42759 5634 10 obtain obtain VB 42759 5634 11 unjust unjust JJ 42759 5634 12 profits profit NNS 42759 5634 13 , , , 42759 5634 14 and and CC 42759 5634 15 always always RB 42759 5634 16 presents present VBZ 42759 5634 17 a a DT 42759 5634 18 strong strong JJ 42759 5634 19 temptation temptation NN 42759 5634 20 in in IN 42759 5634 21 this this DT 42759 5634 22 direction direction NN 42759 5634 23 , , , 42759 5634 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5634 25 should should MD 42759 5634 26 be be VB 42759 5634 27 legally legally RB 42759 5634 28 prohibited prohibit VBN 42759 5634 29 . . . 42759 5635 1 A a DT 42759 5635 2 considerable considerable JJ 42759 5635 3 part part NN 42759 5635 4 of of IN 42759 5635 5 the the DT 42759 5635 6 excessive excessive JJ 42759 5635 7 profits profit NNS 42759 5635 8 already already RB 42759 5635 9 accumulated accumulate VBN 42759 5635 10 can can MD 42759 5635 11 be be VB 42759 5635 12 subjected subject VBN 42759 5635 13 to to IN 42759 5635 14 a a DT 42759 5635 15 better well JJR 42759 5635 16 distribution distribution NN 42759 5635 17 by by IN 42759 5635 18 progressive progressive JJ 42759 5635 19 income income NN 42759 5635 20 and and CC 42759 5635 21 inheritance inheritance NN 42759 5635 22 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5635 23 . . . 42759 5636 1 Finally finally RB 42759 5636 2 , , , 42759 5636 3 the the DT 42759 5636 4 possessors possessor NNS 42759 5636 5 of of IN 42759 5636 6 large large JJ 42759 5636 7 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 5636 8 and and CC 42759 5636 9 incomes income NNS 42759 5636 10 could could MD 42759 5636 11 help help VB 42759 5636 12 to to TO 42759 5636 13 bring bring VB 42759 5636 14 about about RP 42759 5636 15 a a DT 42759 5636 16 more more RBR 42759 5636 17 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5636 18 distribution distribution NN 42759 5636 19 by by IN 42759 5636 20 voluntarily voluntarily RB 42759 5636 21 complying comply VBG 42759 5636 22 with with IN 42759 5636 23 the the DT 42759 5636 24 Christian christian JJ 42759 5636 25 duty duty NN 42759 5636 26 of of IN 42759 5636 27 bestowing bestow VBG 42759 5636 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5636 29 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 5636 30 goods good NNS 42759 5636 31 upon upon IN 42759 5636 32 needy needy JJ 42759 5636 33 persons person NNS 42759 5636 34 and and CC 42759 5636 35 objects object NNS 42759 5636 36 . . . 42759 5637 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5637 2 The the DT 42759 5637 3 Labourer Labourer NNP 42759 5637 4 and and CC 42759 5637 5 Wages Wages NNPS 42759 5637 6 _ _ NNP 42759 5637 7 None None NNP 42759 5637 8 of of IN 42759 5637 9 the the DT 42759 5637 10 theories theory NNS 42759 5637 11 of of IN 42759 5637 12 fair fair JJ 42759 5637 13 wages wage NNS 42759 5637 14 that that WDT 42759 5637 15 have have VBP 42759 5637 16 been be VBN 42759 5637 17 examined examine VBN 42759 5637 18 under under IN 42759 5637 19 the the DT 42759 5637 20 heads head NNS 42759 5637 21 of of IN 42759 5637 22 " " `` 42759 5637 23 the the DT 42759 5637 24 prevailing prevailing NN 42759 5637 25 rate rate NN 42759 5637 26 , , , 42759 5637 27 " " '' 42759 5637 28 " " `` 42759 5637 29 exchange exchange NN 42759 5637 30 - - HYPH 42759 5637 31 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 5637 32 , , , 42759 5637 33 " " '' 42759 5637 34 or or CC 42759 5637 35 " " `` 42759 5637 36 productivity productivity NN 42759 5637 37 " " '' 42759 5637 38 is be VBZ 42759 5637 39 in in IN 42759 5637 40 full full JJ 42759 5637 41 harmony harmony NN 42759 5637 42 with with IN 42759 5637 43 the the DT 42759 5637 44 principles principle NNS 42759 5637 45 of of IN 42759 5637 46 justice justice NN 42759 5637 47 . . . 42759 5638 1 The the DT 42759 5638 2 minimum minimum NN 42759 5638 3 of of IN 42759 5638 4 wage wage NN 42759 5638 5 justice justice NN 42759 5638 6 can can MD 42759 5638 7 , , , 42759 5638 8 however however RB 42759 5638 9 , , , 42759 5638 10 be be VB 42759 5638 11 described describe VBN 42759 5638 12 with with IN 42759 5638 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5638 14 definiteness definiteness NN 42759 5638 15 and and CC 42759 5638 16 certainty certainty NN 42759 5638 17 . . . 42759 5639 1 The the DT 42759 5639 2 adult adult NN 42759 5639 3 male male JJ 42759 5639 4 labourer labourer NN 42759 5639 5 has have VBZ 42759 5639 6 a a DT 42759 5639 7 right right NN 42759 5639 8 to to IN 42759 5639 9 a a DT 42759 5639 10 wage wage NN 42759 5639 11 sufficient sufficient JJ 42759 5639 12 to to TO 42759 5639 13 provide provide VB 42759 5639 14 himself -PRON- PRP 42759 5639 15 and and CC 42759 5639 16 family family NN 42759 5639 17 with with IN 42759 5639 18 a a DT 42759 5639 19 decent decent JJ 42759 5639 20 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5639 21 , , , 42759 5639 22 and and CC 42759 5639 23 the the DT 42759 5639 24 adult adult NN 42759 5639 25 female female NN 42759 5639 26 has have VBZ 42759 5639 27 a a DT 42759 5639 28 right right NN 42759 5639 29 to to IN 42759 5639 30 remuneration remuneration NN 42759 5639 31 that that WDT 42759 5639 32 will will MD 42759 5639 33 enable enable VB 42759 5639 34 her -PRON- PRP 42759 5639 35 to to TO 42759 5639 36 live live VB 42759 5639 37 decently decently RB 42759 5639 38 as as IN 42759 5639 39 a a DT 42759 5639 40 self self NN 42759 5639 41 supporting support VBG 42759 5639 42 individual individual JJ 42759 5639 43 . . . 42759 5640 1 At at IN 42759 5640 2 the the DT 42759 5640 3 basis basis NN 42759 5640 4 of of IN 42759 5640 5 this this DT 42759 5640 6 right right NN 42759 5640 7 are be VBP 42759 5640 8 three three CD 42759 5640 9 ethical ethical JJ 42759 5640 10 principles principle NNS 42759 5640 11 : : : 42759 5640 12 all all DT 42759 5640 13 persons person NNS 42759 5640 14 are be VBP 42759 5640 15 equal equal JJ 42759 5640 16 in in IN 42759 5640 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5640 18 inherent inherent JJ 42759 5640 19 claims claim NNS 42759 5640 20 upon upon IN 42759 5640 21 the the DT 42759 5640 22 bounty bounty NN 42759 5640 23 of of IN 42759 5640 24 nature nature NN 42759 5640 25 ; ; : 42759 5640 26 this this DT 42759 5640 27 general general JJ 42759 5640 28 right right NN 42759 5640 29 of of IN 42759 5640 30 access access NN 42759 5640 31 to to IN 42759 5640 32 the the DT 42759 5640 33 earth earth NN 42759 5640 34 becomes become VBZ 42759 5640 35 concretely concretely RB 42759 5640 36 valid valid JJ 42759 5640 37 through through IN 42759 5640 38 the the DT 42759 5640 39 expenditure expenditure NN 42759 5640 40 of of IN 42759 5640 41 useful useful JJ 42759 5640 42 labour labour NN 42759 5640 43 ; ; : 42759 5640 44 and and CC 42759 5640 45 those those DT 42759 5640 46 persons person NNS 42759 5640 47 who who WP 42759 5640 48 are be VBP 42759 5640 49 in in IN 42759 5640 50 control control NN 42759 5640 51 of of IN 42759 5640 52 the the DT 42759 5640 53 goods good NNS 42759 5640 54 and and CC 42759 5640 55 opportunities opportunity NNS 42759 5640 56 of of IN 42759 5640 57 the the DT 42759 5640 58 earth earth NN 42759 5640 59 are be VBP 42759 5640 60 morally morally RB 42759 5640 61 bound bind VBN 42759 5640 62 to to TO 42759 5640 63 permit permit VB 42759 5640 64 access access NN 42759 5640 65 thereto thereto NN 42759 5640 66 on on IN 42759 5640 67 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5640 68 terms term NNS 42759 5640 69 by by IN 42759 5640 70 all all DT 42759 5640 71 who who WP 42759 5640 72 are be VBP 42759 5640 73 willing willing JJ 42759 5640 74 to to TO 42759 5640 75 work work VB 42759 5640 76 . . . 42759 5641 1 In in IN 42759 5641 2 the the DT 42759 5641 3 case case NN 42759 5641 4 of of IN 42759 5641 5 the the DT 42759 5641 6 labourer labourer NN 42759 5641 7 , , , 42759 5641 8 this this DT 42759 5641 9 right right NN 42759 5641 10 of of IN 42759 5641 11 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5641 12 access access NN 42759 5641 13 can can MD 42759 5641 14 be be VB 42759 5641 15 effectuated effectuate VBN 42759 5641 16 only only RB 42759 5641 17 through through IN 42759 5641 18 a a DT 42759 5641 19 living living NN 42759 5641 20 wage wage NN 42759 5641 21 . . . 42759 5642 1 The the DT 42759 5642 2 obligation obligation NN 42759 5642 3 of of IN 42759 5642 4 paying pay VBG 42759 5642 5 this this DT 42759 5642 6 wage wage NN 42759 5642 7 falls fall VBZ 42759 5642 8 upon upon IN 42759 5642 9 the the DT 42759 5642 10 employer employer NN 42759 5642 11 because because IN 42759 5642 12 of of IN 42759 5642 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5642 14 function function NN 42759 5642 15 in in IN 42759 5642 16 the the DT 42759 5642 17 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5642 18 organism organism NN 42759 5642 19 . . . 42759 5643 1 And and CC 42759 5643 2 the the DT 42759 5643 3 labourer labourer NN 42759 5643 4 's 's POS 42759 5643 5 right right NN 42759 5643 6 to to IN 42759 5643 7 a a DT 42759 5643 8 living living NN 42759 5643 9 wage wage NN 42759 5643 10 is be VBZ 42759 5643 11 morally morally RB 42759 5643 12 superior superior JJ 42759 5643 13 to to IN 42759 5643 14 the the DT 42759 5643 15 employer employer NN 42759 5643 16 's 's POS 42759 5643 17 right right NN 42759 5643 18 to to IN 42759 5643 19 interest interest NN 42759 5643 20 on on IN 42759 5643 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5643 22 capital capital NN 42759 5643 23 . . . 42759 5644 1 Labourers labourer NNS 42759 5644 2 who who WP 42759 5644 3 put put VBD 42759 5644 4 forth forth RP 42759 5644 5 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5644 6 efforts effort NNS 42759 5644 7 or or CC 42759 5644 8 make make VB 42759 5644 9 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5644 10 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5644 11 have have VB 42759 5644 12 a a DT 42759 5644 13 right right NN 42759 5644 14 to to IN 42759 5644 15 a a DT 42759 5644 16 proportionate proportionate NN 42759 5644 17 excess excess NN 42759 5644 18 over over IN 42759 5644 19 living live VBG 42759 5644 20 wages wage NNS 42759 5644 21 , , , 42759 5644 22 and and CC 42759 5644 23 those those DT 42759 5644 24 who who WP 42759 5644 25 are be VBP 42759 5644 26 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 5644 27 productive productive JJ 42759 5644 28 or or CC 42759 5644 29 exceptionally exceptionally RB 42759 5644 30 scarce scarce JJ 42759 5644 31 have have VB 42759 5644 32 a a DT 42759 5644 33 right right NN 42759 5644 34 to to IN 42759 5644 35 the the DT 42759 5644 36 extra extra JJ 42759 5644 37 compensation compensation NN 42759 5644 38 that that WDT 42759 5644 39 goes go VBZ 42759 5644 40 to to IN 42759 5644 41 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5644 42 under under IN 42759 5644 43 the the DT 42759 5644 44 operation operation NN 42759 5644 45 of of IN 42759 5644 46 competition competition NN 42759 5644 47 . . . 42759 5645 1 Labourers labourer NNS 42759 5645 2 who who WP 42759 5645 3 are be VBP 42759 5645 4 receiving receive VBG 42759 5645 5 the the DT 42759 5645 6 " " `` 42759 5645 7 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5645 8 minimum minimum NN 42759 5645 9 " " '' 42759 5645 10 described describe VBN 42759 5645 11 in in IN 42759 5645 12 the the DT 42759 5645 13 last last JJ 42759 5645 14 sentence sentence NN 42759 5645 15 have have VBP 42759 5645 16 a a DT 42759 5645 17 right right NN 42759 5645 18 to to TO 42759 5645 19 still still RB 42759 5645 20 higher high JJR 42759 5645 21 wages wage NNS 42759 5645 22 at at IN 42759 5645 23 the the DT 42759 5645 24 expense expense NN 42759 5645 25 of of IN 42759 5645 26 the the DT 42759 5645 27 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5645 28 and and CC 42759 5645 29 the the DT 42759 5645 30 consumer consumer NN 42759 5645 31 , , , 42759 5645 32 if if IN 42759 5645 33 they -PRON- PRP 42759 5645 34 can can MD 42759 5645 35 secure secure VB 42759 5645 36 them -PRON- PRP 42759 5645 37 through through IN 42759 5645 38 the the DT 42759 5645 39 processes process NNS 42759 5645 40 of of IN 42759 5645 41 competition competition NN 42759 5645 42 ; ; : 42759 5645 43 for for IN 42759 5645 44 the the DT 42759 5645 45 additional additional JJ 42759 5645 46 amount amount NN 42759 5645 47 is be VBZ 42759 5645 48 an an DT 42759 5645 49 ethically ethically RB 42759 5645 50 unassigned unassigned JJ 42759 5645 51 or or CC 42759 5645 52 ownerless ownerless JJ 42759 5645 53 property property NN 42759 5645 54 which which WDT 42759 5645 55 may may MD 42759 5645 56 be be VB 42759 5645 57 taken take VBN 42759 5645 58 by by IN 42759 5645 59 either either DT 42759 5645 60 labourer labourer NN 42759 5645 61 , , , 42759 5645 62 capitalist capitalist JJ 42759 5645 63 , , , 42759 5645 64 or or CC 42759 5645 65 consumer consumer NN 42759 5645 66 , , , 42759 5645 67 provided provide VBN 42759 5645 68 that that IN 42759 5645 69 there there EX 42759 5645 70 is be VBZ 42759 5645 71 no no DT 42759 5645 72 artificial artificial JJ 42759 5645 73 limitation limitation NN 42759 5645 74 of of IN 42759 5645 75 supply supply NN 42759 5645 76 . . . 42759 5646 1 The the DT 42759 5646 2 methods method NNS 42759 5646 3 of of IN 42759 5646 4 increasing increase VBG 42759 5646 5 wages wage NNS 42759 5646 6 are be VBP 42759 5646 7 mainly mainly RB 42759 5646 8 three three CD 42759 5646 9 : : : 42759 5646 10 a a DT 42759 5646 11 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5646 12 wage wage NN 42759 5646 13 by by IN 42759 5646 14 law law NN 42759 5646 15 , , , 42759 5646 16 labour labour NN 42759 5646 17 unions union NNS 42759 5646 18 , , , 42759 5646 19 and and CC 42759 5646 20 co co JJ 42759 5646 21 - - JJ 42759 5646 22 operative operative JJ 42759 5646 23 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 5646 24 . . . 42759 5647 1 The the DT 42759 5647 2 first first JJ 42759 5647 3 has have VBZ 42759 5647 4 been be VBN 42759 5647 5 fairly fairly RB 42759 5647 6 well well RB 42759 5647 7 approved approve VBN 42759 5647 8 by by IN 42759 5647 9 experience experience NN 42759 5647 10 , , , 42759 5647 11 and and CC 42759 5647 12 is be VBZ 42759 5647 13 in in IN 42759 5647 14 no no DT 42759 5647 15 wise wise JJ 42759 5647 16 contrary contrary NN 42759 5647 17 to to IN 42759 5647 18 the the DT 42759 5647 19 principles principle NNS 42759 5647 20 of of IN 42759 5647 21 either either DT 42759 5647 22 ethics ethic NNS 42759 5647 23 , , , 42759 5647 24 politics politic NNS 42759 5647 25 , , , 42759 5647 26 or or CC 42759 5647 27 economics economic NNS 42759 5647 28 . . . 42759 5648 1 The the DT 42759 5648 2 second second NN 42759 5648 3 has have VBZ 42759 5648 4 likewise likewise RB 42759 5648 5 been be VBN 42759 5648 6 vindicated vindicate VBN 42759 5648 7 in in IN 42759 5648 8 practice practice NN 42759 5648 9 , , , 42759 5648 10 though though IN 42759 5648 11 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5648 12 is be VBZ 42759 5648 13 of of IN 42759 5648 14 only only JJ 42759 5648 15 small small JJ 42759 5648 16 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 5648 17 in in IN 42759 5648 18 the the DT 42759 5648 19 case case NN 42759 5648 20 of of IN 42759 5648 21 those those DT 42759 5648 22 workers worker NNS 42759 5648 23 who who WP 42759 5648 24 are be VBP 42759 5648 25 receiving receive VBG 42759 5648 26 less less RBR 42759 5648 27 than than IN 42759 5648 28 living live VBG 42759 5648 29 wages wage NNS 42759 5648 30 . . . 42759 5649 1 The the DT 42759 5649 2 third third JJ 42759 5649 3 would would MD 42759 5649 4 enable enable VB 42759 5649 5 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5649 6 to to TO 42759 5649 7 supplement supplement VB 42759 5649 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5649 9 wage wage NN 42759 5649 10 incomes income NNS 42759 5649 11 by by IN 42759 5649 12 interest interest NN 42759 5649 13 incomes income NNS 42759 5649 14 , , , 42759 5649 15 and and CC 42759 5649 16 would would MD 42759 5649 17 render render VB 42759 5649 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5649 19 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5649 20 system system NN 42759 5649 21 more more RBR 42759 5649 22 stable stable JJ 42759 5649 23 by by IN 42759 5649 24 giving give VBG 42759 5649 25 the the DT 42759 5649 26 workers worker NNS 42759 5649 27 an an DT 42759 5649 28 influential influential JJ 42759 5649 29 voice voice NN 42759 5649 30 in in IN 42759 5649 31 the the DT 42759 5649 32 conditions condition NNS 42759 5649 33 of of IN 42759 5649 34 employment employment NN 42759 5649 35 , , , 42759 5649 36 and and CC 42759 5649 37 laying lay VBG 42759 5649 38 the the DT 42759 5649 39 foundation foundation NN 42759 5649 40 of of IN 42759 5649 41 that that DT 42759 5649 42 contentment contentment NN 42759 5649 43 and and CC 42759 5649 44 conservatism conservatism NN 42759 5649 45 which which WDT 42759 5649 46 arise arise VBP 42759 5649 47 naturally naturally RB 42759 5649 48 out out IN 42759 5649 49 of of IN 42759 5649 50 the the DT 42759 5649 51 possession possession NN 42759 5649 52 of of IN 42759 5649 53 property property NN 42759 5649 54 . . . 42759 5650 1 As as IN 42759 5650 2 a a DT 42759 5650 3 matter matter NN 42759 5650 4 of of IN 42759 5650 5 convenience convenience NN 42759 5650 6 , , , 42759 5650 7 the the DT 42759 5650 8 foregoing forego VBG 42759 5650 9 paragraphs paragraph NNS 42759 5650 10 may may MD 42759 5650 11 be be VB 42759 5650 12 further further RB 42759 5650 13 summarised summarise VBN 42759 5650 14 in in IN 42759 5650 15 the the DT 42759 5650 16 following following JJ 42759 5650 17 abridgment abridgment NN 42759 5650 18 : : : 42759 5650 19 The the DT 42759 5650 20 landowner landowner NN 42759 5650 21 has have VBZ 42759 5650 22 a a DT 42759 5650 23 right right NN 42759 5650 24 to to IN 42759 5650 25 all all PDT 42759 5650 26 the the DT 42759 5650 27 economic economic JJ 42759 5650 28 rent rent NN 42759 5650 29 , , , 42759 5650 30 modified modify VBN 42759 5650 31 by by IN 42759 5650 32 the the DT 42759 5650 33 right right NN 42759 5650 34 of of IN 42759 5650 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5650 36 tenants tenant NNS 42759 5650 37 and and CC 42759 5650 38 employés employés VB 42759 5650 39 to to IN 42759 5650 40 a a DT 42759 5650 41 decent decent JJ 42759 5650 42 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5650 43 , , , 42759 5650 44 and and CC 42759 5650 45 by by IN 42759 5650 46 the the DT 42759 5650 47 right right NN 42759 5650 48 of of IN 42759 5650 49 the the DT 42759 5650 50 State State NNP 42759 5650 51 to to TO 42759 5650 52 levy levy VB 42759 5650 53 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5650 54 which which WDT 42759 5650 55 do do VBP 42759 5650 56 not not RB 42759 5650 57 substantially substantially RB 42759 5650 58 lower lower VB 42759 5650 59 the the DT 42759 5650 60 value value NN 42759 5650 61 of of IN 42759 5650 62 the the DT 42759 5650 63 land land NN 42759 5650 64 . . . 42759 5651 1 The the DT 42759 5651 2 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5651 3 has have VBZ 42759 5651 4 a a DT 42759 5651 5 right right NN 42759 5651 6 to to IN 42759 5651 7 the the DT 42759 5651 8 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 5651 9 rate rate NN 42759 5651 10 of of IN 42759 5651 11 interest interest NN 42759 5651 12 , , , 42759 5651 13 modified modify VBN 42759 5651 14 by by IN 42759 5651 15 the the DT 42759 5651 16 right right NN 42759 5651 17 of of IN 42759 5651 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5651 19 employés employés NN 42759 5651 20 to to IN 42759 5651 21 the the DT 42759 5651 22 " " `` 42759 5651 23 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5651 24 minimum minimum NN 42759 5651 25 " " '' 42759 5651 26 of of IN 42759 5651 27 wages wage NNS 42759 5651 28 . . . 42759 5652 1 The the DT 42759 5652 2 business business NN 42759 5652 3 man man NN 42759 5652 4 in in IN 42759 5652 5 competitive competitive JJ 42759 5652 6 conditions condition NNS 42759 5652 7 has have VBZ 42759 5652 8 a a DT 42759 5652 9 right right NN 42759 5652 10 to to IN 42759 5652 11 all all PDT 42759 5652 12 the the DT 42759 5652 13 profits profit NNS 42759 5652 14 that that WDT 42759 5652 15 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5652 16 can can MD 42759 5652 17 obtain obtain VB 42759 5652 18 , , , 42759 5652 19 but but CC 42759 5652 20 corporations corporation NNS 42759 5652 21 possessing possess VBG 42759 5652 22 a a DT 42759 5652 23 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 5652 24 have have VBP 42759 5652 25 no no DT 42759 5652 26 right right NN 42759 5652 27 to to IN 42759 5652 28 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5652 29 gains gain NNS 42759 5652 30 except except IN 42759 5652 31 those those DT 42759 5652 32 due due IN 42759 5652 33 to to IN 42759 5652 34 unusual unusual JJ 42759 5652 35 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5652 36 . . . 42759 5653 1 The the DT 42759 5653 2 labourer labourer NN 42759 5653 3 has have VBZ 42759 5653 4 a a DT 42759 5653 5 right right NN 42759 5653 6 to to IN 42759 5653 7 living live VBG 42759 5653 8 wages wage NNS 42759 5653 9 , , , 42759 5653 10 and and CC 42759 5653 11 to to IN 42759 5653 12 as as RB 42759 5653 13 much much RB 42759 5653 14 more more JJR 42759 5653 15 as as IN 42759 5653 16 he -PRON- PRP 42759 5653 17 can can MD 42759 5653 18 get get VB 42759 5653 19 by by IN 42759 5653 20 competition competition NN 42759 5653 21 with with IN 42759 5653 22 the the DT 42759 5653 23 other other JJ 42759 5653 24 agents agent NNS 42759 5653 25 of of IN 42759 5653 26 production production NN 42759 5653 27 and and CC 42759 5653 28 with with IN 42759 5653 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5653 30 fellow fellow JJ 42759 5653 31 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5653 32 . . . 42759 5654 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5654 2 Concluding Concluding NNP 42759 5654 3 Observations Observations NNPS 42759 5654 4 _ _ NNP 42759 5654 5 No no RB 42759 5654 6 doubt doubt RB 42759 5654 7 many many JJ 42759 5654 8 of of IN 42759 5654 9 those those DT 42759 5654 10 who who WP 42759 5654 11 have have VBP 42759 5654 12 taken take VBN 42759 5654 13 up up RP 42759 5654 14 this this DT 42759 5654 15 volume volume NN 42759 5654 16 with with IN 42759 5654 17 the the DT 42759 5654 18 expectation expectation NN 42759 5654 19 of of IN 42759 5654 20 finding find VBG 42759 5654 21 therein therein RB 42759 5654 22 a a DT 42759 5654 23 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 5654 24 formula formula NN 42759 5654 25 of of IN 42759 5654 26 distributive distributive JJ 42759 5654 27 justice justice NN 42759 5654 28 , , , 42759 5654 29 and and CC 42759 5654 30 who who WP 42759 5654 31 have have VBP 42759 5654 32 patiently patiently RB 42759 5654 33 followed follow VBN 42759 5654 34 the the DT 42759 5654 35 discussion discussion NN 42759 5654 36 to to IN 42759 5654 37 the the DT 42759 5654 38 end end NN 42759 5654 39 , , , 42759 5654 40 are be VBP 42759 5654 41 disappointed disappoint VBN 42759 5654 42 and and CC 42759 5654 43 dissatisfied dissatisfied JJ 42759 5654 44 at at IN 42759 5654 45 the the DT 42759 5654 46 final final JJ 42759 5654 47 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 5654 48 . . . 42759 5655 1 Both both DT 42759 5655 2 the the DT 42759 5655 3 particular particular JJ 42759 5655 4 applications application NNS 42759 5655 5 of of IN 42759 5655 6 the the DT 42759 5655 7 rules rule NNS 42759 5655 8 of of IN 42759 5655 9 justice justice NN 42759 5655 10 and and CC 42759 5655 11 the the DT 42759 5655 12 proposals proposal NNS 42759 5655 13 for for IN 42759 5655 14 reform reform NN 42759 5655 15 , , , 42759 5655 16 must must MD 42759 5655 17 have have VB 42759 5655 18 seemed seem VBN 42759 5655 19 complex complex JJ 42759 5655 20 and and CC 42759 5655 21 indefinite indefinite JJ 42759 5655 22 . . . 42759 5656 1 They -PRON- PRP 42759 5656 2 are be VBP 42759 5656 3 not not RB 42759 5656 4 nearly nearly RB 42759 5656 5 so so RB 42759 5656 6 simple simple JJ 42759 5656 7 and and CC 42759 5656 8 definite definite JJ 42759 5656 9 as as IN 42759 5656 10 the the DT 42759 5656 11 principles principle NNS 42759 5656 12 of of IN 42759 5656 13 Socialism socialism NN 42759 5656 14 or or CC 42759 5656 15 the the DT 42759 5656 16 Single Single NNP 42759 5656 17 Tax Tax NNP 42759 5656 18 . . . 42759 5657 1 And and CC 42759 5657 2 yet yet RB 42759 5657 3 , , , 42759 5657 4 there there EX 42759 5657 5 is be VBZ 42759 5657 6 no no DT 42759 5657 7 escape escape NN 42759 5657 8 from from IN 42759 5657 9 these these DT 42759 5657 10 limitations limitation NNS 42759 5657 11 . . . 42759 5658 1 Neither neither CC 42759 5658 2 the the DT 42759 5658 3 principles principle NNS 42759 5658 4 of of IN 42759 5658 5 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5658 6 justice justice NN 42759 5658 7 nor nor CC 42759 5658 8 the the DT 42759 5658 9 constitution constitution NN 42759 5658 10 of of IN 42759 5658 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5658 12 socio socio JJ 42759 5658 13 - - HYPH 42759 5658 14 economic economic JJ 42759 5658 15 system system NN 42759 5658 16 is be VBZ 42759 5658 17 simple simple JJ 42759 5658 18 . . . 42759 5659 1 Therefore therefore RB 42759 5659 2 , , , 42759 5659 3 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5659 4 is be VBZ 42759 5659 5 impossible impossible JJ 42759 5659 6 to to TO 42759 5659 7 give give VB 42759 5659 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5659 9 ethical ethical JJ 42759 5659 10 conclusions conclusion NNS 42759 5659 11 anything anything NN 42759 5659 12 like like IN 42759 5659 13 mathematical mathematical JJ 42759 5659 14 accuracy accuracy NN 42759 5659 15 . . . 42759 5660 1 The the DT 42759 5660 2 only only JJ 42759 5660 3 claim claim NN 42759 5660 4 that that WDT 42759 5660 5 is be VBZ 42759 5660 6 made make VBN 42759 5660 7 for for IN 42759 5660 8 the the DT 42759 5660 9 discussion discussion NN 42759 5660 10 is be VBZ 42759 5660 11 that that IN 42759 5660 12 the the DT 42759 5660 13 moral moral JJ 42759 5660 14 judgments judgment NNS 42759 5660 15 are be VBP 42759 5660 16 fairly fairly RB 42759 5660 17 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5660 18 , , , 42759 5660 19 and and CC 42759 5660 20 the the DT 42759 5660 21 proposed propose VBN 42759 5660 22 remedies remedy NNS 42759 5660 23 fairly fairly RB 42759 5660 24 efficacious efficacious JJ 42759 5660 25 . . . 42759 5661 1 When when WRB 42759 5661 2 both both DT 42759 5661 3 have have VBP 42759 5661 4 been be VBN 42759 5661 5 realised realise VBN 42759 5661 6 in in IN 42759 5661 7 practice practice NN 42759 5661 8 , , , 42759 5661 9 the the DT 42759 5661 10 next next JJ 42759 5661 11 step step NN 42759 5661 12 in in IN 42759 5661 13 the the DT 42759 5661 14 direction direction NN 42759 5661 15 of of IN 42759 5661 16 wider wide JJR 42759 5661 17 distributive distributive JJ 42759 5661 18 justice justice NN 42759 5661 19 will will MD 42759 5661 20 be be VB 42759 5661 21 much much RB 42759 5661 22 clearer clear JJR 42759 5661 23 than than IN 42759 5661 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5661 25 is be VBZ 42759 5661 26 to to IN 42759 5661 27 - - HYPH 42759 5661 28 day day NN 42759 5661 29 . . . 42759 5662 1 Although although IN 42759 5662 2 the the DT 42759 5662 3 attainment attainment NN 42759 5662 4 of of IN 42759 5662 5 greater great JJR 42759 5662 6 justice justice NN 42759 5662 7 in in IN 42759 5662 8 distribution distribution NN 42759 5662 9 is be VBZ 42759 5662 10 the the DT 42759 5662 11 primary primary JJ 42759 5662 12 and and CC 42759 5662 13 most most RBS 42759 5662 14 urgent urgent JJ 42759 5662 15 need need NN 42759 5662 16 of of IN 42759 5662 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5662 18 time time NN 42759 5662 19 , , , 42759 5662 20 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5662 21 is be VBZ 42759 5662 22 not not RB 42759 5662 23 the the DT 42759 5662 24 only only JJ 42759 5662 25 one one NN 42759 5662 26 that that WDT 42759 5662 27 is be VBZ 42759 5662 28 of of IN 42759 5662 29 great great JJ 42759 5662 30 importance importance NN 42759 5662 31 . . . 42759 5663 1 No no DT 42759 5663 2 conceivable conceivable JJ 42759 5663 3 method method NN 42759 5663 4 of of IN 42759 5663 5 distributing distribute VBG 42759 5663 6 the the DT 42759 5663 7 present present JJ 42759 5663 8 national national JJ 42759 5663 9 product product NN 42759 5663 10 would would MD 42759 5663 11 provide provide VB 42759 5663 12 every every DT 42759 5663 13 family family NN 42759 5663 14 with with IN 42759 5663 15 the the DT 42759 5663 16 means mean NNS 42759 5663 17 of of IN 42759 5663 18 supporting support VBG 42759 5663 19 an an DT 42759 5663 20 automobile automobile NN 42759 5663 21 , , , 42759 5663 22 or or CC 42759 5663 23 any any DT 42759 5663 24 equivalent equivalent JJ 42759 5663 25 symbol symbol NN 42759 5663 26 of of IN 42759 5663 27 comfort comfort NN 42759 5663 28 . . . 42759 5664 1 Indeed indeed RB 42759 5664 2 , , , 42759 5664 3 there there EX 42759 5664 4 are be VBP 42759 5664 5 indications indication NNS 42759 5664 6 that that IN 42759 5664 7 the the DT 42759 5664 8 present present JJ 42759 5664 9 amount amount NN 42759 5664 10 of of IN 42759 5664 11 product product NN 42759 5664 12 per per IN 42759 5664 13 capita capita NN 42759 5664 14 can can MD 42759 5664 15 not not RB 42759 5664 16 long long RB 42759 5664 17 be be VB 42759 5664 18 maintained maintain VBN 42759 5664 19 without without IN 42759 5664 20 better well JJR 42759 5664 21 conservation conservation NN 42759 5664 22 of of IN 42759 5664 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5664 24 natural natural JJ 42759 5664 25 resources resource NNS 42759 5664 26 , , , 42759 5664 27 the the DT 42759 5664 28 abandonment abandonment NN 42759 5664 29 of of IN 42759 5664 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5664 31 national national JJ 42759 5664 32 habits habit NNS 42759 5664 33 of of IN 42759 5664 34 wastefulness wastefulness NN 42759 5664 35 , , , 42759 5664 36 more more RBR 42759 5664 37 scientific scientific JJ 42759 5664 38 methods method NNS 42759 5664 39 of of IN 42759 5664 40 soil soil NN 42759 5664 41 cultivation cultivation NN 42759 5664 42 , , , 42759 5664 43 and and CC 42759 5664 44 vastly vastly RB 42759 5664 45 greater great JJR 42759 5664 46 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5664 47 on on IN 42759 5664 48 the the DT 42759 5664 49 part part NN 42759 5664 50 of of IN 42759 5664 51 both both DT 42759 5664 52 capital capital NN 42759 5664 53 and and CC 42759 5664 54 labour labour NN 42759 5664 55 . . . 42759 5665 1 Nor nor CC 42759 5665 2 is be VBZ 42759 5665 3 this this DT 42759 5665 4 all all DT 42759 5665 5 . . . 42759 5666 1 Neither neither DT 42759 5666 2 just just RB 42759 5666 3 distribution distribution NN 42759 5666 4 , , , 42759 5666 5 nor nor CC 42759 5666 6 increased increase VBN 42759 5666 7 production production NN 42759 5666 8 , , , 42759 5666 9 nor nor CC 42759 5666 10 both both DT 42759 5666 11 combined combine VBN 42759 5666 12 , , , 42759 5666 13 will will MD 42759 5666 14 insure insure VB 42759 5666 15 a a DT 42759 5666 16 stable stable JJ 42759 5666 17 and and CC 42759 5666 18 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 5666 19 social social JJ 42759 5666 20 order order NN 42759 5666 21 without without IN 42759 5666 22 a a DT 42759 5666 23 considerable considerable JJ 42759 5666 24 change change NN 42759 5666 25 in in IN 42759 5666 26 human human JJ 42759 5666 27 hearts heart NNS 42759 5666 28 and and CC 42759 5666 29 ideals ideal NNS 42759 5666 30 . . . 42759 5667 1 The the DT 42759 5667 2 rich rich JJ 42759 5667 3 must must MD 42759 5667 4 cease cease VB 42759 5667 5 to to TO 42759 5667 6 put put VB 42759 5667 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5667 8 faith faith NN 42759 5667 9 in in IN 42759 5667 10 material material JJ 42759 5667 11 things thing NNS 42759 5667 12 , , , 42759 5667 13 and and CC 42759 5667 14 rise rise VB 42759 5667 15 to to IN 42759 5667 16 a a DT 42759 5667 17 simpler simple JJR 42759 5667 18 and and CC 42759 5667 19 saner saner JJ 42759 5667 20 plane plane NN 42759 5667 21 of of IN 42759 5667 22 living living NN 42759 5667 23 ; ; : 42759 5667 24 the the DT 42759 5667 25 middle middle JJ 42759 5667 26 classes class NNS 42759 5667 27 and and CC 42759 5667 28 the the DT 42759 5667 29 poor poor JJ 42759 5667 30 must must MD 42759 5667 31 give give VB 42759 5667 32 up up RP 42759 5667 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5667 34 envy envy NN 42759 5667 35 and and CC 42759 5667 36 snobbish snobbish JJ 42759 5667 37 imitation imitation NN 42759 5667 38 of of IN 42759 5667 39 the the DT 42759 5667 40 false false JJ 42759 5667 41 and and CC 42759 5667 42 degrading degrading JJ 42759 5667 43 standards standard NNS 42759 5667 44 of of IN 42759 5667 45 the the DT 42759 5667 46 opulent opulent JJ 42759 5667 47 classes class NNS 42759 5667 48 ; ; , 42759 5667 49 and and CC 42759 5667 50 all all DT 42759 5667 51 must must MD 42759 5667 52 learn learn VB 42759 5667 53 the the DT 42759 5667 54 elementary elementary JJ 42759 5667 55 lesson lesson NN 42759 5667 56 that that WDT 42759 5667 57 the the DT 42759 5667 58 path path NN 42759 5667 59 to to IN 42759 5667 60 achievements achievement NNS 42759 5667 61 worth worth JJ 42759 5667 62 while while IN 42759 5667 63 leads lead VBZ 42759 5667 64 through through IN 42759 5667 65 the the DT 42759 5667 66 field field NN 42759 5667 67 of of IN 42759 5667 68 hard hard JJ 42759 5667 69 and and CC 42759 5667 70 honest honest JJ 42759 5667 71 labour labour NN 42759 5667 72 , , , 42759 5667 73 not not RB 42759 5667 74 of of IN 42759 5667 75 lucky lucky JJ 42759 5667 76 " " `` 42759 5667 77 deals deal NNS 42759 5667 78 " " '' 42759 5667 79 or or CC 42759 5667 80 gouging gouging NN 42759 5667 81 of of IN 42759 5667 82 the the DT 42759 5667 83 neighbour neighbour NN 42759 5667 84 , , , 42759 5667 85 and and CC 42759 5667 86 that that IN 42759 5667 87 the the DT 42759 5667 88 only only JJ 42759 5667 89 life life NN 42759 5667 90 worth worth JJ 42759 5667 91 living live VBG 42759 5667 92 is be VBZ 42759 5667 93 that that IN 42759 5667 94 in in IN 42759 5667 95 which which WDT 42759 5667 96 one one NN 42759 5667 97 's 's POS 42759 5667 98 cherished cherish VBN 42759 5667 99 wants want VBZ 42759 5667 100 are be VBP 42759 5667 101 few few JJ 42759 5667 102 , , , 42759 5667 103 simple simple JJ 42759 5667 104 , , , 42759 5667 105 and and CC 42759 5667 106 noble noble JJ 42759 5667 107 . . . 42759 5668 1 For for IN 42759 5668 2 the the DT 42759 5668 3 adoption adoption NN 42759 5668 4 and and CC 42759 5668 5 pursuit pursuit NN 42759 5668 6 of of IN 42759 5668 7 these these DT 42759 5668 8 ideals ideal NNS 42759 5668 9 the the DT 42759 5668 10 most most RBS 42759 5668 11 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5668 12 requisite requisite NN 42759 5668 13 is be VBZ 42759 5668 14 a a DT 42759 5668 15 revival revival NN 42759 5668 16 of of IN 42759 5668 17 genuine genuine JJ 42759 5668 18 religion religion NN 42759 5668 19 . . . 42759 5669 1 INDEX INDEX NNP 42759 5669 2 Abstinence Abstinence NNP 42759 5669 3 : : : 42759 5669 4 as as IN 42759 5669 5 a a DT 42759 5669 6 title title NN 42759 5669 7 to to IN 42759 5669 8 interest interest NN 42759 5669 9 , , , 42759 5669 10 182 182 CD 42759 5669 11 - - SYM 42759 5669 12 186 186 CD 42759 5669 13 . . . 42759 5670 1 Adams Adams NNP 42759 5670 2 , , , 42759 5670 3 T. T. NNP 42759 5670 4 S. S. NNP 42759 5670 5 : : : 42759 5670 6 301 301 CD 42759 5670 7 , , , 42759 5670 8 302 302 CD 42759 5670 9 . . . 42759 5671 1 Adam Adam NNP 42759 5671 2 Smith Smith NNP 42759 5671 3 : : : 42759 5671 4 331 331 CD 42759 5671 5 , , , 42759 5671 6 341 341 CD 42759 5671 7 . . . 42759 5672 1 Agriculture agriculture NN 42759 5672 2 : : : 42759 5672 3 co co NN 42759 5672 4 - - NN 42759 5672 5 operation operation NN 42759 5672 6 in in IN 42759 5672 7 , , , 42759 5672 8 217 217 CD 42759 5672 9 - - SYM 42759 5672 10 220 220 CD 42759 5672 11 . . . 42759 5673 1 Alaska Alaska NNP 42759 5673 2 : : : 42759 5673 3 leasing leasing NN 42759 5673 4 system system NN 42759 5673 5 in in IN 42759 5673 6 , , , 42759 5673 7 96 96 CD 42759 5673 8 . . . 42759 5674 1 Altruism altruism NN 42759 5674 2 : : : 42759 5674 3 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 5674 4 of of IN 42759 5674 5 under under IN 42759 5674 6 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 5674 7 , , , 42759 5674 8 165 165 CD 42759 5674 9 - - SYM 42759 5674 10 167 167 CD 42759 5674 11 ; ; , 42759 5674 12 promoted promote VBN 42759 5674 13 by by IN 42759 5674 14 co co NN 42759 5674 15 - - NN 42759 5674 16 operation operation NN 42759 5674 17 , , , 42759 5674 18 229 229 CD 42759 5674 19 . . . 42759 5675 1 Ambrose Ambrose NNP 42759 5675 2 , , , 42759 5675 3 Saint Saint NNP 42759 5675 4 : : : 42759 5675 5 305 305 CD 42759 5675 6 . . . 42759 5676 1 American American NNP 42759 5676 2 Sugar Sugar NNP 42759 5676 3 Refining Refining NNP 42759 5676 4 Company Company NNP 42759 5676 5 : : : 42759 5676 6 267 267 CD 42759 5676 7 , , , 42759 5676 8 272 272 CD 42759 5676 9 , , , 42759 5676 10 289 289 CD 42759 5676 11 . . . 42759 5677 1 American American NNP 42759 5677 2 Tobacco Tobacco NNP 42759 5677 3 Company Company NNP 42759 5677 4 : : : 42759 5677 5 263 263 CD 42759 5677 6 , , , 42759 5677 7 267 267 CD 42759 5677 8 , , , 42759 5677 9 288 288 CD 42759 5677 10 . . . 42759 5678 1 Analogy analogy NN 42759 5678 2 : : : 42759 5678 3 economic economic JJ 42759 5678 4 , , , 42759 5678 5 as as IN 42759 5678 6 justifying justify VBG 42759 5678 7 interest interest NN 42759 5678 8 , , , 42759 5678 9 205 205 CD 42759 5678 10 , , , 42759 5678 11 206 206 CD 42759 5678 12 . . . 42759 5679 1 Anthracite anthracite NN 42759 5679 2 coal coal NN 42759 5679 3 : : : 42759 5679 4 a a DT 42759 5679 5 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 5679 6 , , , 42759 5679 7 75 75 CD 42759 5679 8 , , , 42759 5679 9 78 78 CD 42759 5679 10 , , , 42759 5679 11 95 95 CD 42759 5679 12 , , , 42759 5679 13 132 132 CD 42759 5679 14 . . . 42759 5680 1 Antoine Antoine NNP 42759 5680 2 , , , 42759 5680 3 Charles Charles NNP 42759 5680 4 : : : 42759 5680 5 337 337 CD 42759 5680 6 - - SYM 42759 5680 7 340 340 CD 42759 5680 8 . . . 42759 5681 1 Antoninus Antoninus NNP 42759 5681 2 , , , 42759 5681 3 Saint Saint NNP 42759 5681 4 : : : 42759 5681 5 270 270 CD 42759 5681 6 . . . 42759 5682 1 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 42759 5682 2 , , , 42759 5682 3 Saint Saint NNP 42759 5682 4 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 5682 5 : : : 42759 5682 6 63 63 CD 42759 5682 7 , , , 42759 5682 8 64 64 CD 42759 5682 9 , , , 42759 5682 10 175 175 CD 42759 5682 11 , , , 42759 5682 12 181 181 CD 42759 5682 13 , , , 42759 5682 14 208 208 CD 42759 5682 15 , , , 42759 5682 16 304 304 CD 42759 5682 17 , , , 42759 5682 18 306 306 CD 42759 5682 19 , , , 42759 5682 20 307 307 CD 42759 5682 21 , , , 42759 5682 22 333 333 CD 42759 5682 23 . . . 42759 5683 1 Arbitration arbitration NN 42759 5683 2 : : : 42759 5683 3 failure failure NN 42759 5683 4 of of IN 42759 5683 5 , , , 42759 5683 6 324 324 CD 42759 5683 7 . . . 42759 5684 1 Ashley Ashley NNP 42759 5684 2 , , , 42759 5684 3 W. W. NNP 42759 5684 4 J. J. NNP 42759 5684 5 : : : 42759 5684 6 9 9 CD 42759 5684 7 . . . 42759 5685 1 Astor Astor NNP 42759 5685 2 estate estate NN 42759 5685 3 : : : 42759 5685 4 88 88 CD 42759 5685 5 , , , 42759 5685 6 89 89 CD 42759 5685 7 . . . 42759 5686 1 Augustine Augustine NNP 42759 5686 2 , , , 42759 5686 3 Saint Saint NNP 42759 5686 4 : : : 42759 5686 5 305 305 CD 42759 5686 6 . . . 42759 5687 1 Australasia Australasia NNP 42759 5687 2 : : : 42759 5687 3 special special JJ 42759 5687 4 land land NN 42759 5687 5 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5687 6 in in IN 42759 5687 7 , , , 42759 5687 8 118 118 CD 42759 5687 9 - - SYM 42759 5687 10 120 120 CD 42759 5687 11 , , , 42759 5687 12 131 131 CD 42759 5687 13 ; ; : 42759 5687 14 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5687 15 wage wage NN 42759 5687 16 in in IN 42759 5687 17 , , , 42759 5687 18 401 401 CD 42759 5687 19 , , , 42759 5687 20 402 402 CD 42759 5687 21 . . . 42759 5688 1 Authorities authority NNS 42759 5688 2 : : : 42759 5688 3 Catholic Catholic NNP 42759 5688 4 and and CC 42759 5688 5 Protestant Protestant NNP 42759 5688 6 , , , 42759 5688 7 on on IN 42759 5688 8 living living NN 42759 5688 9 wage wage NN 42759 5688 10 , , , 42759 5688 11 277 277 CD 42759 5688 12 , , , 42759 5688 13 278 278 CD 42759 5688 14 . . . 42759 5689 1 Basil Basil NNP 42759 5689 2 , , , 42759 5689 3 Saint Saint NNP 42759 5689 4 : : : 42759 5689 5 305 305 CD 42759 5689 6 . . . 42759 5690 1 Bible Bible NNP 42759 5690 2 , , , 42759 5690 3 the the DT 42759 5690 4 : : : 42759 5690 5 on on IN 42759 5690 6 the the DT 42759 5690 7 duty duty NN 42759 5690 8 of of IN 42759 5690 9 benevolence benevolence NN 42759 5690 10 , , , 42759 5690 11 303 303 CD 42759 5690 12 , , , 42759 5690 13 304 304 CD 42759 5690 14 , , , 42759 5690 15 316 316 CD 42759 5690 16 , , , 42759 5690 17 317 317 CD 42759 5690 18 . . . 42759 5691 1 Brandeis Brandeis NNP 42759 5691 2 , , , 42759 5691 3 Louis Louis NNP 42759 5691 4 D. D. NNP 42759 5691 5 : : : 42759 5691 6 265 265 CD 42759 5691 7 , , , 42759 5691 8 275 275 CD 42759 5691 9 . . . 42759 5691 10 Business business NN 42759 5691 11 man man NN 42759 5691 12 : : : 42759 5691 13 functions function NNS 42759 5691 14 and and CC 42759 5691 15 rewards reward NNS 42759 5691 16 of of IN 42759 5691 17 , , , 42759 5691 18 237 237 CD 42759 5691 19 - - SYM 42759 5691 20 239 239 CD 42759 5691 21 , , , 42759 5691 22 255 255 CD 42759 5691 23 - - SYM 42759 5691 24 258 258 CD 42759 5691 25 ; ; : 42759 5691 26 no no UH 42759 5691 27 right right NN 42759 5691 28 of of IN 42759 5691 29 to to IN 42759 5691 30 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5691 31 profits profit NNS 42759 5691 32 , , , 42759 5691 33 258 258 CD 42759 5691 34 - - SYM 42759 5691 35 260 260 CD 42759 5691 36 , , , 42759 5691 37 362 362 CD 42759 5691 38 , , , 42759 5691 39 363 363 CD 42759 5691 40 ; ; : 42759 5691 41 the the DT 42759 5691 42 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 5691 43 , , , 42759 5691 44 260 260 CD 42759 5691 45 , , , 42759 5691 46 261 261 CD 42759 5691 47 . . . 42759 5692 1 Canada Canada NNP 42759 5692 2 : : : 42759 5692 3 special special JJ 42759 5692 4 land land NN 42759 5692 5 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5692 6 in in IN 42759 5692 7 , , , 42759 5692 8 117 117 CD 42759 5692 9 - - SYM 42759 5692 10 120 120 CD 42759 5692 11 . . . 42759 5693 1 Canonist canonist NN 42759 5693 2 : : : 42759 5693 3 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 5693 4 of of IN 42759 5693 5 wage wage NN 42759 5693 6 justice justice NN 42759 5693 7 , , , 42759 5693 8 333 333 CD 42759 5693 9 - - SYM 42759 5693 10 336 336 CD 42759 5693 11 . . . 42759 5694 1 Canons canon NNS 42759 5694 2 of of IN 42759 5694 3 distributive distributive JJ 42759 5694 4 justice justice NN 42759 5694 5 : : : 42759 5694 6 243 243 CD 42759 5694 7 - - SYM 42759 5694 8 253 253 CD 42759 5694 9 . . . 42759 5695 1 Capital capital NN 42759 5695 2 : : : 42759 5695 3 meaning meaning NN 42759 5695 4 of of IN 42759 5695 5 , , , 42759 5695 6 137 137 CD 42759 5695 7 , , , 42759 5695 8 138 138 CD 42759 5695 9 ; ; : 42759 5695 10 power power NN 42759 5695 11 of of IN 42759 5695 12 to to TO 42759 5695 13 create create VB 42759 5695 14 value value NN 42759 5695 15 , , , 42759 5695 16 146 146 CD 42759 5695 17 - - SYM 42759 5695 18 148 148 CD 42759 5695 19 ; ; : 42759 5695 20 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 5695 21 teaching teaching NN 42759 5695 22 concerning concern VBG 42759 5695 23 interest interest NN 42759 5695 24 on on IN 42759 5695 25 , , , 42759 5695 26 175 175 CD 42759 5695 27 - - SYM 42759 5695 28 177 177 CD 42759 5695 29 ; ; : 42759 5695 30 titles title NNS 42759 5695 31 of of IN 42759 5695 32 to to IN 42759 5695 33 interest interest NN 42759 5695 34 , , , 42759 5695 35 177 177 CD 42759 5695 36 - - SYM 42759 5695 37 186 186 CD 42759 5695 38 ; ; : 42759 5695 39 value value NN 42759 5695 40 of of IN 42759 5695 41 in in IN 42759 5695 42 a a DT 42759 5695 43 no no DT 42759 5695 44 - - HYPH 42759 5695 45 interest interest NN 42759 5695 46 régime régime NN 42759 5695 47 , , , 42759 5695 48 188 188 CD 42759 5695 49 - - SYM 42759 5695 50 190 190 CD 42759 5695 51 ; ; : 42759 5695 52 need need VBP 42759 5695 53 for for IN 42759 5695 54 a a DT 42759 5695 55 wider wide JJR 42759 5695 56 distribution distribution NN 42759 5695 57 of of IN 42759 5695 58 , , , 42759 5695 59 213 213 CD 42759 5695 60 , , , 42759 5695 61 214 214 CD 42759 5695 62 ; ; : 42759 5695 63 need need VBP 42759 5695 64 for for IN 42759 5695 65 ownership ownership NN 42759 5695 66 of of IN 42759 5695 67 by by IN 42759 5695 68 labour labour NN 42759 5695 69 , , , 42759 5695 70 214 214 CD 42759 5695 71 , , , 42759 5695 72 229 229 CD 42759 5695 73 , , , 42759 5695 74 230 230 CD 42759 5695 75 . . . 42759 5696 1 Capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 5696 2 : : : 42759 5696 3 two two CD 42759 5696 4 kinds kind NNS 42759 5696 5 of of IN 42759 5696 6 , , , 42759 5696 7 138 138 CD 42759 5696 8 ; ; : 42759 5696 9 expropriation expropriation NN 42759 5696 10 of of IN 42759 5696 11 , , , 42759 5696 12 154 154 CD 42759 5696 13 - - SYM 42759 5696 14 158 158 CD 42759 5696 15 ; ; : 42759 5696 16 right right RB 42759 5696 17 of of IN 42759 5696 18 to to TO 42759 5696 19 take take VB 42759 5696 20 interest interest NN 42759 5696 21 , , , 42759 5696 22 201 201 CD 42759 5696 23 - - SYM 42759 5696 24 209 209 CD 42759 5696 25 ; ; : 42759 5696 26 claims claim NNS 42759 5696 27 of of IN 42759 5696 28 , , , 42759 5696 29 versus versus IN 42759 5696 30 claims claim NNS 42759 5696 31 of of IN 42759 5696 32 labourers labourer NNS 42759 5696 33 , , , 42759 5696 34 367 367 CD 42759 5696 35 - - SYM 42759 5696 36 369 369 CD 42759 5696 37 , , , 42759 5696 38 390 390 CD 42759 5696 39 - - HYPH 42759 5696 40 393 393 CD 42759 5696 41 , , , 42759 5696 42 396 396 CD 42759 5696 43 . . . 42759 5697 1 Carnegie Carnegie NNP 42759 5697 2 , , , 42759 5697 3 Andrew Andrew NNP 42759 5697 4 : : : 42759 5697 5 300 300 CD 42759 5697 6 . . . 42759 5698 1 Carver carver NN 42759 5698 2 , , , 42759 5698 3 T. t. NN 42759 5698 4 N. n. NN 42759 5698 5 : : : 42759 5698 6 351 351 CD 42759 5698 7 - - SYM 42759 5698 8 355 355 CD 42759 5698 9 . . . 42759 5699 1 Catholic Catholic NNP 42759 5699 2 Church Church NNP 42759 5699 3 : : : 42759 5699 4 attitude attitude NN 42759 5699 5 of of IN 42759 5699 6 toward toward IN 42759 5699 7 interest interest NN 42759 5699 8 , , , 42759 5699 9 172 172 CD 42759 5699 10 - - SYM 42759 5699 11 176 176 CD 42759 5699 12 . . . 42759 5700 1 Child child NN 42759 5700 2 workers worker NNS 42759 5700 3 : : : 42759 5700 4 right right RB 42759 5700 5 of of IN 42759 5700 6 to to IN 42759 5700 7 a a DT 42759 5700 8 living living NN 42759 5700 9 wage wage NN 42759 5700 10 , , , 42759 5700 11 373 373 CD 42759 5700 12 . . . 42759 5701 1 Christian christian JJ 42759 5701 2 conception conception NN 42759 5701 3 of of IN 42759 5701 4 welfare welfare NN 42759 5701 5 : : : 42759 5701 6 316 316 CD 42759 5701 7 - - SYM 42759 5701 8 318 318 CD 42759 5701 9 . . . 42759 5702 1 Clark Clark NNP 42759 5702 2 , , , 42759 5702 3 J. J. NNP 42759 5703 1 B. B. NNP 42759 5703 2 : : : 42759 5703 3 271 271 CD 42759 5703 4 , , , 42759 5703 5 347 347 CD 42759 5703 6 - - SYM 42759 5703 7 351 351 CD 42759 5703 8 . . . 42759 5704 1 Compensation compensation NN 42759 5704 2 : : : 42759 5704 3 to to IN 42759 5704 4 landowners landowner NNS 42759 5704 5 , , , 42759 5704 6 34 34 CD 42759 5704 7 - - SYM 42759 5704 8 39 39 CD 42759 5704 9 ; ; : 42759 5704 10 to to IN 42759 5704 11 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 5704 12 under under IN 42759 5704 13 Socialism socialism NN 42759 5704 14 , , , 42759 5704 15 154 154 CD 42759 5704 16 - - SYM 42759 5704 17 158 158 CD 42759 5704 18 . . . 42759 5705 1 Competition competition NN 42759 5705 2 : : : 42759 5705 3 alleged allege VBN 42759 5705 4 failure failure NN 42759 5705 5 of of IN 42759 5705 6 , , , 42759 5705 7 275 275 CD 42759 5705 8 - - SYM 42759 5705 9 278 278 CD 42759 5705 10 . . . 42759 5706 1 Confiscation confiscation NN 42759 5706 2 : : : 42759 5706 3 of of IN 42759 5706 4 land land NN 42759 5706 5 values value NNS 42759 5706 6 under under IN 42759 5706 7 the the DT 42759 5706 8 Single Single NNP 42759 5706 9 Tax Tax NNP 42759 5706 10 , , , 42759 5706 11 34 34 CD 42759 5706 12 - - SYM 42759 5706 13 39 39 CD 42759 5706 14 ; ; : 42759 5706 15 of of IN 42759 5706 16 capital capital NN 42759 5706 17 under under IN 42759 5706 18 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 5706 19 , , , 42759 5706 20 154 154 CD 42759 5706 21 - - SYM 42759 5706 22 158 158 CD 42759 5706 23 ; ; : 42759 5706 24 of of IN 42759 5706 25 wealth wealth NN 42759 5706 26 by by IN 42759 5706 27 taxation taxation NN 42759 5706 28 , , , 42759 5706 29 297 297 CD 42759 5706 30 , , , 42759 5706 31 298 298 CD 42759 5706 32 . . . 42759 5707 1 Constitutionality constitutionality NN 42759 5707 2 of of IN 42759 5707 3 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5707 4 wage wage NN 42759 5707 5 laws law NNS 42759 5707 6 : : : 42759 5707 7 405 405 CD 42759 5707 8 - - SYM 42759 5707 9 407 407 CD 42759 5707 10 . . . 42759 5708 1 Consumer consumer NN 42759 5708 2 : : : 42759 5708 3 injury injury NN 42759 5708 4 to to IN 42759 5708 5 through through IN 42759 5708 6 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 5708 7 , , , 42759 5708 8 282 282 CD 42759 5708 9 - - SYM 42759 5708 10 288 288 CD 42759 5708 11 ; ; : 42759 5708 12 obligations obligation NNS 42759 5708 13 of of IN 42759 5708 14 to to IN 42759 5708 15 business business NN 42759 5708 16 man man NN 42759 5708 17 , , , 42759 5708 18 258 258 CD 42759 5708 19 , , , 42759 5708 20 259 259 CD 42759 5708 21 , , , 42759 5708 22 362 362 CD 42759 5708 23 , , , 42759 5708 24 363 363 CD 42759 5708 25 ; ; : 42759 5708 26 versus versus IN 42759 5708 27 labourer labourer NNP 42759 5708 28 , , , 42759 5708 29 393 393 CD 42759 5708 30 - - SYM 42759 5708 31 398 398 CD 42759 5708 32 . . . 42759 5709 1 Contract contract NN 42759 5709 2 : : : 42759 5709 3 onerous onerous JJ 42759 5709 4 , , , 42759 5709 5 326 326 CD 42759 5709 6 ; ; : 42759 5709 7 free free JJ 42759 5709 8 , , , 42759 5709 9 as as IN 42759 5709 10 a a DT 42759 5709 11 rule rule NN 42759 5709 12 of of IN 42759 5709 13 wage wage NN 42759 5709 14 justice justice NN 42759 5709 15 , , , 42759 5709 16 328 328 CD 42759 5709 17 - - SYM 42759 5709 18 330 330 CD 42759 5709 19 , , , 42759 5709 20 370 370 CD 42759 5709 21 - - SYM 42759 5709 22 372 372 CD 42759 5709 23 . . . 42759 5710 1 Co co NN 42759 5710 2 - - NN 42759 5710 3 operation operation NN 42759 5710 4 : : : 42759 5710 5 as as IN 42759 5710 6 a a DT 42759 5710 7 partial partial JJ 42759 5710 8 solvent solvent NN 42759 5710 9 of of IN 42759 5710 10 capitalism capitalism NN 42759 5710 11 , , , 42759 5710 12 210 210 CD 42759 5710 13 - - SYM 42759 5710 14 233 233 CD 42759 5710 15 ; ; : 42759 5710 16 essence essence NN 42759 5710 17 and and CC 42759 5710 18 kinds kind NNS 42759 5710 19 of of IN 42759 5710 20 , , , 42759 5710 21 214 214 CD 42759 5710 22 , , , 42759 5710 23 215 215 CD 42759 5710 24 ; ; : 42759 5710 25 in in IN 42759 5710 26 banking banking NN 42759 5710 27 , , , 42759 5710 28 216 216 CD 42759 5710 29 , , , 42759 5710 30 217 217 CD 42759 5710 31 ; ; : 42759 5710 32 in in IN 42759 5710 33 agriculture agriculture NN 42759 5710 34 , , , 42759 5710 35 217 217 CD 42759 5710 36 - - SYM 42759 5710 37 220 220 CD 42759 5710 38 ; ; : 42759 5710 39 in in IN 42759 5710 40 stores store NNS 42759 5710 41 , , , 42759 5710 42 220 220 CD 42759 5710 43 - - SYM 42759 5710 44 222 222 CD 42759 5710 45 ; ; : 42759 5710 46 in in IN 42759 5710 47 production production NN 42759 5710 48 , , , 42759 5710 49 222 222 CD 42759 5710 50 - - SYM 42759 5710 51 228 228 CD 42759 5710 52 ; ; : 42759 5710 53 effect effect NN 42759 5710 54 of of IN 42759 5710 55 on on IN 42759 5710 56 social social JJ 42759 5710 57 stability stability NN 42759 5710 58 , , , 42759 5710 59 229 229 CD 42759 5710 60 , , , 42759 5710 61 230 230 CD 42759 5710 62 ; ; : 42759 5710 63 as as IN 42759 5710 64 compared compare VBN 42759 5710 65 with with IN 42759 5710 66 individualism individualism NN 42759 5710 67 and and CC 42759 5710 68 Socialism socialism NN 42759 5710 69 , , , 42759 5710 70 230 230 CD 42759 5710 71 , , , 42759 5710 72 231 231 CD 42759 5710 73 ; ; : 42759 5710 74 province province NN 42759 5710 75 and and CC 42759 5710 76 limitations limitation NNS 42759 5710 77 of of IN 42759 5710 78 , , , 42759 5710 79 231 231 CD 42759 5710 80 - - SYM 42759 5710 81 233 233 CD 42759 5710 82 ; ; : 42759 5710 83 bearing bear VBG 42759 5710 84 of of RP 42759 5710 85 on on IN 42759 5710 86 the the DT 42759 5710 87 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 5710 88 business business NN 42759 5710 89 man man NN 42759 5710 90 , , , 42759 5710 91 260 260 CD 42759 5710 92 , , , 42759 5710 93 261 261 CD 42759 5710 94 ; ; : 42759 5710 95 and and CC 42759 5710 96 on on IN 42759 5710 97 the the DT 42759 5710 98 labouring labour VBG 42759 5710 99 classes class NNS 42759 5710 100 , , , 42759 5710 101 423 423 CD 42759 5710 102 - - SYM 42759 5710 103 425 425 CD 42759 5710 104 . . . 42759 5711 1 Co co NN 42759 5711 2 - - NN 42759 5711 3 partnership partnership NN 42759 5711 4 : : : 42759 5711 5 223 223 CD 42759 5711 6 , , , 42759 5711 7 224 224 CD 42759 5711 8 . . . 42759 5712 1 Corporation corporation NN 42759 5712 2 : : : 42759 5712 3 profits profit NNS 42759 5712 4 of of IN 42759 5712 5 a a DT 42759 5712 6 , , , 42759 5712 7 241 241 CD 42759 5712 8 , , , 42759 5712 9 242 242 CD 42759 5712 10 , , , 42759 5712 11 257 257 CD 42759 5712 12 , , , 42759 5712 13 258 258 CD 42759 5712 14 , , , 42759 5712 15 262 262 CD 42759 5712 16 , , , 42759 5712 17 389 389 CD 42759 5712 18 . . . 42759 5713 1 Cost cost NN 42759 5713 2 of of IN 42759 5713 3 living living NN 42759 5713 4 : : : 42759 5713 5 378 378 CD 42759 5713 6 , , , 42759 5713 7 379 379 CD 42759 5713 8 . . . 42759 5714 1 Cost cost NN 42759 5714 2 of of IN 42759 5714 3 production production NN 42759 5714 4 : : : 42759 5714 5 of of IN 42759 5714 6 capital capital NN 42759 5714 7 , , , 42759 5714 8 188 188 CD 42759 5714 9 , , , 42759 5714 10 189 189 CD 42759 5714 11 . . . 42759 5714 12 Credit credit NN 42759 5714 13 societies society NNS 42759 5714 14 : : : 42759 5714 15 co co NN 42759 5714 16 - - NN 42759 5714 17 operative operative JJ 42759 5714 18 , , , 42759 5714 19 216 216 CD 42759 5714 20 , , , 42759 5714 21 217 217 CD 42759 5714 22 . . . 42759 5715 1 Defects defect NNS 42759 5715 2 of of IN 42759 5715 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5715 4 land land NN 42759 5715 5 system system NN 42759 5715 6 : : : 42759 5715 7 74 74 CD 42759 5715 8 - - SYM 42759 5715 9 93 93 CD 42759 5715 10 ; ; : 42759 5715 11 monopoly monopoly NN 42759 5715 12 , , , 42759 5715 13 75 75 CD 42759 5715 14 - - SYM 42759 5715 15 80 80 CD 42759 5715 16 ; ; : 42759 5715 17 excessive excessive JJ 42759 5715 18 gains gain NNS 42759 5715 19 , , , 42759 5715 20 80 80 CD 42759 5715 21 - - SYM 42759 5715 22 89 89 CD 42759 5715 23 ; ; , 42759 5715 24 exclusion exclusion NN 42759 5715 25 , , , 42759 5715 26 90 90 CD 42759 5715 27 - - SYM 42759 5715 28 93 93 CD 42759 5715 29 . . . 42759 5716 1 Devas Devas NNP 42759 5716 2 , , , 42759 5716 3 Charles Charles NNP 42759 5716 4 : : : 42759 5716 5 184 184 CD 42759 5716 6 . . . 42759 5717 1 Disagreeable disagreeable JJ 42759 5717 2 tasks task NNS 42759 5717 3 : : : 42759 5717 4 384 384 CD 42759 5717 5 , , , 42759 5717 6 385 385 CD 42759 5717 7 . . . 42759 5718 1 Dixon Dixon NNP 42759 5718 2 , , , 42759 5718 3 F. F. NNP 42759 5718 4 H. H. NNP 42759 5718 5 : : : 42759 5718 6 323 323 CD 42759 5718 7 . . . 42759 5719 1 Discriminative discriminative JJ 42759 5719 2 transportation transportation NN 42759 5719 3 contracts contract NNS 42759 5719 4 : : : 42759 5719 5 272 272 CD 42759 5719 6 , , , 42759 5719 7 273 273 CD 42759 5719 8 . . . 42759 5720 1 Discriminative discriminative JJ 42759 5720 2 underselling underselling NN 42759 5720 3 : : : 42759 5720 4 267 267 CD 42759 5720 5 - - SYM 42759 5720 6 270 270 CD 42759 5720 7 . . . 42759 5721 1 Distribution distribution NN 42759 5721 2 of of IN 42759 5721 3 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 5721 4 wealth wealth NN 42759 5721 5 : : : 42759 5721 6 303 303 CD 42759 5721 7 - - SYM 42759 5721 8 319 319 CD 42759 5721 9 . . . 42759 5722 1 Distributive distributive JJ 42759 5722 2 justice justice NN 42759 5722 3 : : : 42759 5722 4 canons canon NNS 42759 5722 5 of of IN 42759 5722 6 , , , 42759 5722 7 243 243 CD 42759 5722 8 - - SYM 42759 5722 9 253 253 CD 42759 5722 10 , , , 42759 5722 11 381 381 CD 42759 5722 12 , , , 42759 5722 13 382 382 CD 42759 5722 14 . . . 42759 5723 1 Earth earth NN 42759 5723 2 : : : 42759 5723 3 right right NN 42759 5723 4 of of IN 42759 5723 5 access access NN 42759 5723 6 to to IN 42759 5723 7 , , , 42759 5723 8 358 358 CD 42759 5723 9 - - SYM 42759 5723 10 360 360 CD 42759 5723 11 . . . 42759 5724 1 Economic economic JJ 42759 5724 2 determinism determinism NN 42759 5724 3 : : : 42759 5724 4 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 42759 5724 5 with with IN 42759 5724 6 ethical ethical JJ 42759 5724 7 judgments judgment NNS 42759 5724 8 , , , 42759 5724 9 20 20 CD 42759 5724 10 , , , 42759 5724 11 145 145 CD 42759 5724 12 , , , 42759 5724 13 146 146 CD 42759 5724 14 , , , 42759 5724 15 343 343 CD 42759 5724 16 , , , 42759 5724 17 344 344 CD 42759 5724 18 . . . 42759 5725 1 Efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5725 2 : : : 42759 5725 3 monopolistic monopolistic JJ 42759 5725 4 , , , 42759 5725 5 265 265 CD 42759 5725 6 - - SYM 42759 5725 7 267 267 CD 42759 5725 8 , , , 42759 5725 9 275 275 CD 42759 5725 10 - - SYM 42759 5725 11 277 277 CD 42759 5725 12 , , , 42759 5725 13 279 279 CD 42759 5725 14 ; ; : 42759 5725 15 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5725 16 , , , 42759 5725 17 388 388 CD 42759 5725 18 - - SYM 42759 5725 19 390 390 CD 42759 5725 20 . . . 42759 5726 1 Efforts effort NNS 42759 5726 2 : : : 42759 5726 3 exceptional exceptional JJ 42759 5726 4 , , , 42759 5726 5 as as IN 42759 5726 6 claim claim NN 42759 5726 7 to to IN 42759 5726 8 rewards reward NNS 42759 5726 9 , , , 42759 5726 10 382 382 CD 42759 5726 11 - - SYM 42759 5726 12 383 383 CD 42759 5726 13 . . . 42759 5727 1 Efforts effort NNS 42759 5727 2 and and CC 42759 5727 3 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 42759 5727 4 : : : 42759 5727 5 as as IN 42759 5727 6 canons canon NNS 42759 5727 7 of of IN 42759 5727 8 distribution distribution NN 42759 5727 9 , , , 42759 5727 10 245 245 CD 42759 5727 11 - - SYM 42759 5727 12 247 247 CD 42759 5727 13 . . . 42759 5728 1 Ely Ely NNP 42759 5728 2 , , , 42759 5728 3 R. R. NNP 42759 5728 4 T. T. NNP 42759 5728 5 : : : 42759 5728 6 330 330 CD 42759 5728 7 . . . 42759 5729 1 Employer employer NN 42759 5729 2 : : : 42759 5729 3 gains gain NNS 42759 5729 4 of of IN 42759 5729 5 from from IN 42759 5729 6 wage wage NN 42759 5729 7 contract contract NN 42759 5729 8 , , , 42759 5729 9 327 327 CD 42759 5729 10 , , , 42759 5729 11 328 328 CD 42759 5729 12 ; ; : 42759 5729 13 obligation obligation NN 42759 5729 14 of of IN 42759 5729 15 to to TO 42759 5729 16 pay pay VB 42759 5729 17 a a DT 42759 5729 18 living living NN 42759 5729 19 wage wage NN 42759 5729 20 , , , 42759 5729 21 365 365 CD 42759 5729 22 - - SYM 42759 5729 23 372 372 CD 42759 5729 24 . . . 42759 5730 1 Engels Engels NNP 42759 5730 2 , , , 42759 5730 3 F. F. NNP 42759 5730 4 : : : 42759 5730 5 20 20 CD 42759 5730 6 . . . 42759 5731 1 Ensor Ensor NNP 42759 5731 2 , , , 42759 5731 3 E. E. NNP 42759 5731 4 K. K. NNP 42759 5731 5 : : : 42759 5731 6 50 50 CD 42759 5731 7 . . . 42759 5732 1 Equal equal JJ 42759 5732 2 gains gain NNS 42759 5732 3 : : : 42759 5732 4 as as IN 42759 5732 5 a a DT 42759 5732 6 canon canon NN 42759 5732 7 of of IN 42759 5732 8 wage wage NN 42759 5732 9 justice justice NN 42759 5732 10 , , , 42759 5732 11 326 326 CD 42759 5732 12 - - SYM 42759 5732 13 328 328 CD 42759 5732 14 . . . 42759 5733 1 Equality equality NN 42759 5733 2 : : : 42759 5733 3 as as IN 42759 5733 4 a a DT 42759 5733 5 canon canon NN 42759 5733 6 of of IN 42759 5733 7 justice justice NN 42759 5733 8 , , , 42759 5733 9 243 243 CD 42759 5733 10 , , , 42759 5733 11 244 244 CD 42759 5733 12 ; ; : 42759 5733 13 of of IN 42759 5733 14 men man NNS 42759 5733 15 's 's POS 42759 5733 16 claims claim NNS 42759 5733 17 to to IN 42759 5733 18 the the DT 42759 5733 19 bounty bounty NN 42759 5733 20 of of IN 42759 5733 21 nature nature NN 42759 5733 22 , , , 42759 5733 23 358 358 CD 42759 5733 24 , , , 42759 5733 25 359 359 CD 42759 5733 26 ; ; : 42759 5733 27 of of IN 42759 5733 28 rights right NNS 42759 5733 29 to to IN 42759 5733 30 a a DT 42759 5733 31 decent decent JJ 42759 5733 32 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5733 33 , , , 42759 5733 34 360 360 CD 42759 5733 35 - - SYM 42759 5733 36 363 363 CD 42759 5733 37 . . . 42759 5734 1 " " `` 42759 5734 2 Equitable equitable JJ 42759 5734 3 minimum minimum NN 42759 5734 4 " " '' 42759 5734 5 : : : 42759 5734 6 of of IN 42759 5734 7 wages wage NNS 42759 5734 8 , , , 42759 5734 9 388 388 CD 42759 5734 10 , , , 42759 5734 11 390 390 CD 42759 5734 12 , , , 42759 5734 13 392 392 CD 42759 5734 14 , , , 42759 5734 15 393 393 CD 42759 5734 16 , , , 42759 5734 17 395 395 CD 42759 5734 18 , , , 42759 5734 19 397 397 CD 42759 5734 20 , , , 42759 5734 21 398 398 CD 42759 5734 22 , , , 42759 5734 23 399 399 CD 42759 5734 24 , , , 42759 5734 25 417 417 CD 42759 5734 26 . . . 42759 5735 1 Equity equity NN 42759 5735 2 : : : 42759 5735 3 meaning meaning NN 42759 5735 4 of of IN 42759 5735 5 , , , 42759 5735 6 256 256 CD 42759 5735 7 . . . 42759 5736 1 Exchange exchange NN 42759 5736 2 - - HYPH 42759 5736 3 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 5736 4 : : : 42759 5736 5 theories theory NNS 42759 5736 6 of of IN 42759 5736 7 , , , 42759 5736 8 326 326 CD 42759 5736 9 - - SYM 42759 5736 10 340 340 CD 42759 5736 11 ; ; : 42759 5736 12 equal equal JJ 42759 5736 13 gains gain NNS 42759 5736 14 , , , 42759 5736 15 326 326 CD 42759 5736 16 - - SYM 42759 5736 17 328 328 CD 42759 5736 18 ; ; : 42759 5736 19 free free JJ 42759 5736 20 contract contract NN 42759 5736 21 , , , 42759 5736 22 328 328 CD 42759 5736 23 - - SYM 42759 5736 24 330 330 CD 42759 5736 25 ; ; : 42759 5736 26 market market NN 42759 5736 27 value value NN 42759 5736 28 , , , 42759 5736 29 330 330 CD 42759 5736 30 - - SYM 42759 5736 31 332 332 CD 42759 5736 32 ; ; : 42759 5736 33 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 5736 34 , , , 42759 5736 35 332 332 CD 42759 5736 36 - - SYM 42759 5736 37 336 336 CD 42759 5736 38 ; ; : 42759 5736 39 modern modern JJ 42759 5736 40 , , , 42759 5736 41 336 336 CD 42759 5736 42 - - SYM 42759 5736 43 340 340 CD 42759 5736 44 . . . 42759 5737 1 Exclusion exclusion NN 42759 5737 2 from from IN 42759 5737 3 the the DT 42759 5737 4 land land NN 42759 5737 5 : : : 42759 5737 6 90 90 CD 42759 5737 7 - - SYM 42759 5737 8 93 93 CD 42759 5737 9 . . . 42759 5738 1 Exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 5738 2 - - HYPH 42759 5738 3 sales sale NNS 42759 5738 4 contracts contract NNS 42759 5738 5 : : : 42759 5738 6 270 270 CD 42759 5738 7 - - SYM 42759 5738 8 272 272 CD 42759 5738 9 . . . 42759 5739 1 Expropriation expropriation NN 42759 5739 2 : : : 42759 5739 3 of of IN 42759 5739 4 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 5739 5 under under IN 42759 5739 6 Socialism socialism NN 42759 5739 7 , , , 42759 5739 8 154 154 CD 42759 5739 9 - - SYM 42759 5739 10 158 158 CD 42759 5739 11 . . . 42759 5740 1 Extrinsic extrinsic NN 42759 5740 2 titles title NNS 42759 5740 3 : : : 42759 5740 4 of of IN 42759 5740 5 interest interest NN 42759 5740 6 , , , 42759 5740 7 172 172 CD 42759 5740 8 . . . 42759 5741 1 Family family NN 42759 5741 2 living living NN 42759 5741 3 wage wage NN 42759 5741 4 : : : 42759 5741 5 373 373 CD 42759 5741 6 - - SYM 42759 5741 7 376 376 CD 42759 5741 8 . . . 42759 5742 1 Fathers father NNS 42759 5742 2 of of IN 42759 5742 3 the the DT 42759 5742 4 Church Church NNP 42759 5742 5 : : : 42759 5742 6 on on IN 42759 5742 7 private private JJ 42759 5742 8 property property NN 42759 5742 9 in in IN 42759 5742 10 land land NN 42759 5742 11 , , , 42759 5742 12 62 62 CD 42759 5742 13 ; ; : 42759 5742 14 on on IN 42759 5742 15 duty duty NN 42759 5742 16 of of IN 42759 5742 17 beneficence beneficence NN 42759 5742 18 , , , 42759 5742 19 305 305 CD 42759 5742 20 , , , 42759 5742 21 306 306 CD 42759 5742 22 . . . 42759 5743 1 Fay Fay NNP 42759 5743 2 , , , 42759 5743 3 C. C. NNP 42759 5743 4 R. R. NNP 42759 5743 5 : : : 42759 5743 6 214 214 CD 42759 5743 7 , , , 42759 5743 8 221 221 CD 42759 5743 9 , , , 42759 5743 10 227 227 CD 42759 5743 11 . . . 42759 5744 1 Fisher Fisher NNP 42759 5744 2 , , , 42759 5744 3 Irving Irving NNP 42759 5744 4 : : : 42759 5744 5 196 196 CD 42759 5744 6 . . . 42759 5745 1 Fortunes fortune NNS 42759 5745 2 : : : 42759 5745 3 legal legal JJ 42759 5745 4 limitation limitation NN 42759 5745 5 of of IN 42759 5745 6 , , , 42759 5745 7 291 291 CD 42759 5745 8 - - SYM 42759 5745 9 302 302 CD 42759 5745 10 ; ; : 42759 5745 11 directly directly RB 42759 5745 12 , , , 42759 5745 13 292 292 CD 42759 5745 14 - - SYM 42759 5745 15 295 295 CD 42759 5745 16 ; ; : 42759 5745 17 by by IN 42759 5745 18 taxation taxation NN 42759 5745 19 , , , 42759 5745 20 296 296 CD 42759 5745 21 - - SYM 42759 5745 22 302 302 CD 42759 5745 23 . . . 42759 5746 1 France France NNP 42759 5746 2 : : : 42759 5746 3 co co JJ 42759 5746 4 - - JJ 42759 5746 5 operative operative JJ 42759 5746 6 production production NN 42759 5746 7 in in IN 42759 5746 8 , , , 42759 5746 9 223 223 CD 42759 5746 10 . . . 42759 5747 1 Fustel Fustel NNP 42759 5747 2 de de NNP 42759 5747 3 Coulanges Coulanges NNP 42759 5747 4 : : : 42759 5747 5 9 9 CD 42759 5747 6 . . . 42759 5748 1 Gains gain NNS 42759 5748 2 : : : 42759 5748 3 excessive excessive JJ 42759 5748 4 from from IN 42759 5748 5 land land NN 42759 5748 6 , , , 42759 5748 7 80 80 CD 42759 5748 8 - - SYM 42759 5748 9 89 89 CD 42759 5748 10 ; ; : 42759 5748 11 from from IN 42759 5748 12 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 5748 13 , , , 42759 5748 14 263 263 CD 42759 5748 15 - - SYM 42759 5748 16 265 265 CD 42759 5748 17 . . . 42759 5749 1 Germany Germany NNP 42759 5749 2 : : : 42759 5749 3 co co NN 42759 5749 4 - - NN 42759 5749 5 operation operation NN 42759 5749 6 in in IN 42759 5749 7 , , , 42759 5749 8 216 216 CD 42759 5749 9 . . . 42759 5750 1 Giffen Giffen NNP 42759 5750 2 , , , 42759 5750 3 Sir Sir NNP 42759 5750 4 Robert Robert NNP 42759 5750 5 : : : 42759 5750 6 189 189 CD 42759 5750 7 . . . 42759 5751 1 Godwin Godwin NNP 42759 5751 2 , , , 42759 5751 3 W. W. NNP 42759 5751 4 : : : 42759 5751 5 341 341 CD 42759 5751 6 . . . 42759 5752 1 Government government NN 42759 5752 2 ownership ownership NN 42759 5752 3 : : : 42759 5752 4 93 93 CD 42759 5752 5 - - SYM 42759 5752 6 95 95 CD 42759 5752 7 ; ; : 42759 5752 8 limitations limitation NNS 42759 5752 9 of of IN 42759 5752 10 , , , 42759 5752 11 163 163 CD 42759 5752 12 - - SYM 42759 5752 13 165 165 CD 42759 5752 14 ; ; : 42759 5752 15 and and CC 42759 5752 16 rate rate NN 42759 5752 17 of of IN 42759 5752 18 interest interest NN 42759 5752 19 , , , 42759 5752 20 212 212 CD 42759 5752 21 . . . 42759 5753 1 Great Great NNP 42759 5753 2 Britain Britain NNP 42759 5753 3 : : : 42759 5753 4 co co NN 42759 5753 5 - - NN 42759 5753 6 operation operation NN 42759 5753 7 in in IN 42759 5753 8 , , , 42759 5753 9 220 220 CD 42759 5753 10 - - SYM 42759 5753 11 222 222 CD 42759 5753 12 ; ; : 42759 5753 13 income income NN 42759 5753 14 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5753 15 in in IN 42759 5753 16 , , , 42759 5753 17 299 299 CD 42759 5753 18 - - SYM 42759 5753 19 300 300 CD 42759 5753 20 ; ; : 42759 5753 21 minimum minimum NN 42759 5753 22 wage wage NN 42759 5753 23 in in IN 42759 5753 24 , , , 42759 5753 25 401 401 CD 42759 5753 26 , , , 42759 5753 27 402 402 CD 42759 5753 28 . . . 42759 5754 1 Haines Haines NNP 42759 5754 2 , , , 42759 5754 3 H. H. NNP 42759 5754 4 T. t. NN 42759 5754 5 : : : 42759 5754 6 405 405 CD 42759 5754 7 . . . 42759 5755 1 Hammond Hammond NNP 42759 5755 2 , , , 42759 5755 3 M. M. NNP 42759 5755 4 B. B. NNP 42759 5755 5 : : : 42759 5755 6 402 402 CD 42759 5755 7 . . . 42759 5756 1 Henry Henry NNP 42759 5756 2 George George NNP 42759 5756 3 : : : 42759 5756 4 on on IN 42759 5756 5 primitive primitive JJ 42759 5756 6 common common JJ 42759 5756 7 ownership ownership NN 42759 5756 8 , , , 42759 5756 9 17 17 CD 42759 5756 10 ; ; : 42759 5756 11 on on IN 42759 5756 12 first first JJ 42759 5756 13 occupancy occupancy NN 42759 5756 14 , , , 42759 5756 15 21 21 CD 42759 5756 16 - - SYM 42759 5756 17 24 24 CD 42759 5756 18 ; ; : 42759 5756 19 on on IN 42759 5756 20 title title NN 42759 5756 21 of of IN 42759 5756 22 labour labour NN 42759 5756 23 , , , 42759 5756 24 24 24 CD 42759 5756 25 - - SYM 42759 5756 26 29 29 CD 42759 5756 27 ; ; : 42759 5756 28 on on IN 42759 5756 29 natural natural JJ 42759 5756 30 right right NN 42759 5756 31 to to IN 42759 5756 32 land land NN 42759 5756 33 , , , 42759 5756 34 30 30 CD 42759 5756 35 - - SYM 42759 5756 36 39 39 CD 42759 5756 37 ; ; : 42759 5756 38 on on IN 42759 5756 39 right right NN 42759 5756 40 of of IN 42759 5756 41 community community NN 42759 5756 42 to to TO 42759 5756 43 land land VB 42759 5756 44 values value NNS 42759 5756 45 and and CC 42759 5756 46 rent rent NN 42759 5756 47 , , , 42759 5756 48 39 39 CD 42759 5756 49 - - SYM 42759 5756 50 47 47 CD 42759 5756 51 ; ; : 42759 5756 52 on on IN 42759 5756 53 Single Single NNP 42759 5756 54 Tax Tax NNP 42759 5756 55 , , , 42759 5756 56 51 51 CD 42759 5756 57 , , , 42759 5756 58 52 52 CD 42759 5756 59 . . . 42759 5757 1 Hillquit Hillquit NNP 42759 5757 2 , , , 42759 5757 3 Morris Morris NNP 42759 5757 4 : : : 42759 5757 5 159 159 CD 42759 5757 6 . . . 42759 5758 1 Hobson Hobson NNP 42759 5758 2 , , , 42759 5758 3 J. J. NNP 42759 5759 1 A. a. NN 42759 5759 2 : : : 42759 5759 3 418 418 CD 42759 5759 4 . . . 42759 5760 1 Howe Howe NNP 42759 5760 2 , , , 42759 5760 3 F. F. NNP 42759 5760 4 C. C. NNP 42759 5760 5 : : : 42759 5760 6 76 76 CD 42759 5760 7 - - SYM 42759 5760 8 78 78 CD 42759 5760 9 . . . 42759 5761 1 Human human JJ 42759 5761 2 welfare welfare NN 42759 5761 3 : : : 42759 5761 4 the the DT 42759 5761 5 test test NN 42759 5761 6 of of IN 42759 5761 7 property property NN 42759 5761 8 rights right NNS 42759 5761 9 in in IN 42759 5761 10 land land NN 42759 5761 11 , , , 42759 5761 12 36 36 CD 42759 5761 13 - - SYM 42759 5761 14 38 38 CD 42759 5761 15 ; ; : 42759 5761 16 and and CC 42759 5761 17 of of IN 42759 5761 18 a a DT 42759 5761 19 system system NN 42759 5761 20 of of IN 42759 5761 21 land land NN 42759 5761 22 tenure tenure NN 42759 5761 23 , , , 42759 5761 24 74 74 CD 42759 5761 25 ; ; : 42759 5761 26 and and CC 42759 5761 27 of of IN 42759 5761 28 increment increment JJ 42759 5761 29 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5761 30 , , , 42759 5761 31 109 109 CD 42759 5761 32 - - SYM 42759 5761 33 111 111 CD 42759 5761 34 ; ; : 42759 5761 35 and and CC 42759 5761 36 of of IN 42759 5761 37 titles title NNS 42759 5761 38 of of IN 42759 5761 39 property property NN 42759 5761 40 , , , 42759 5761 41 150 150 CD 42759 5761 42 , , , 42759 5761 43 151 151 CD 42759 5761 44 , , , 42759 5761 45 244 244 CD 42759 5761 46 , , , 42759 5761 47 293 293 CD 42759 5761 48 - - SYM 42759 5761 49 295 295 CD 42759 5761 50 ; ; : 42759 5761 51 as as IN 42759 5761 52 a a DT 42759 5761 53 canon canon NN 42759 5761 54 of of IN 42759 5761 55 distributive distributive JJ 42759 5761 56 justice justice NN 42759 5761 57 , , , 42759 5761 58 252 252 CD 42759 5761 59 , , , 42759 5761 60 253 253 CD 42759 5761 61 ; ; : 42759 5761 62 as as IN 42759 5761 63 justifying justify VBG 42759 5761 64 profits profit NNS 42759 5761 65 , , , 42759 5761 66 256 256 CD 42759 5761 67 , , , 42759 5761 68 257 257 CD 42759 5761 69 , , , 42759 5761 70 389 389 CD 42759 5761 71 ; ; : 42759 5761 72 as as IN 42759 5761 73 justifying justify VBG 42759 5761 74 higher higher RBR 42759 5761 75 than than IN 42759 5761 76 living live VBG 42759 5761 77 wages wage NNS 42759 5761 78 , , , 42759 5761 79 386 386 CD 42759 5761 80 . . . 42759 5762 1 Hyndman Hyndman NNP 42759 5762 2 and and CC 42759 5762 3 Morris Morris NNP 42759 5762 4 : : : 42759 5762 5 20 20 CD 42759 5762 6 . . . 42759 5763 1 Income income NN 42759 5763 2 : : : 42759 5763 3 distribution distribution NN 42759 5763 4 of of IN 42759 5763 5 national national JJ 42759 5763 6 , , , 42759 5763 7 81 81 CD 42759 5763 8 - - SYM 42759 5763 9 83 83 CD 42759 5763 10 . . . 42759 5764 1 Incomes income NNS 42759 5764 2 : : : 42759 5764 3 injustice injustice NN 42759 5764 4 of of IN 42759 5764 5 equal equal JJ 42759 5764 6 , , , 42759 5764 7 244 244 CD 42759 5764 8 ; ; : 42759 5764 9 progressive progressive JJ 42759 5764 10 taxation taxation NN 42759 5764 11 of of IN 42759 5764 12 , , , 42759 5764 13 297 297 CD 42759 5764 14 - - SYM 42759 5764 15 302 302 CD 42759 5764 16 . . . 42759 5765 1 Increment increment NN 42759 5765 2 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5765 3 : : : 42759 5765 4 102 102 CD 42759 5765 5 - - SYM 42759 5765 6 117 117 CD 42759 5765 7 . . . 42759 5766 1 Inefficiency inefficiency NN 42759 5766 2 : : : 42759 5766 3 of of IN 42759 5766 4 leadership leadership NN 42759 5766 5 and and CC 42759 5766 6 labour labour NN 42759 5766 7 under under IN 42759 5766 8 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 5766 9 , , , 42759 5766 10 158 158 CD 42759 5766 11 - - SYM 42759 5766 12 168 168 CD 42759 5766 13 . . . 42759 5767 1 Inheritance inheritance NN 42759 5767 2 : : : 42759 5767 3 legal legal JJ 42759 5767 4 limitation limitation NN 42759 5767 5 of of IN 42759 5767 6 , , , 42759 5767 7 293 293 CD 42759 5767 8 - - SYM 42759 5767 9 295 295 CD 42759 5767 10 ; ; : 42759 5767 11 progressive progressive JJ 42759 5767 12 taxation taxation NN 42759 5767 13 of of IN 42759 5767 14 , , , 42759 5767 15 296 296 CD 42759 5767 16 - - SYM 42759 5767 17 302 302 CD 42759 5767 18 . . . 42759 5768 1 Interest interest NN 42759 5768 2 : : : 42759 5768 3 nature nature NN 42759 5768 4 of of IN 42759 5768 5 , , , 42759 5768 6 137 137 CD 42759 5768 7 - - SYM 42759 5768 8 140 140 CD 42759 5768 9 ; ; : 42759 5768 10 rate rate NN 42759 5768 11 of of IN 42759 5768 12 , , , 42759 5768 13 141 141 CD 42759 5768 14 - - SYM 42759 5768 15 144 144 CD 42759 5768 16 ; ; , 42759 5768 17 alleged allege VBN 42759 5768 18 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 42759 5768 19 justifications justification NNS 42759 5768 20 of of IN 42759 5768 21 , , , 42759 5768 22 171 171 CD 42759 5768 23 - - SYM 42759 5768 24 186 186 CD 42759 5768 25 ; ; : 42759 5768 26 attitude attitude NN 42759 5768 27 of of IN 42759 5768 28 Church Church NNP 42759 5768 29 toward toward IN 42759 5768 30 , , , 42759 5768 31 172 172 CD 42759 5768 32 - - SYM 42759 5768 33 176 176 CD 42759 5768 34 ; ; : 42759 5768 35 extrinsic extrinsic NN 42759 5768 36 titles title NNS 42759 5768 37 of of IN 42759 5768 38 , , , 42759 5768 39 172 172 CD 42759 5768 40 ; ; : 42759 5768 41 and and CC 42759 5768 42 the the DT 42759 5768 43 title title NN 42759 5768 44 of of IN 42759 5768 45 productivity productivity NN 42759 5768 46 , , , 42759 5768 47 176 176 CD 42759 5768 48 - - SYM 42759 5768 49 181 181 CD 42759 5768 50 ; ; : 42759 5768 51 and and CC 42759 5768 52 the the DT 42759 5768 53 title title NN 42759 5768 54 of of IN 42759 5768 55 service service NN 42759 5768 56 , , , 42759 5768 57 181 181 CD 42759 5768 58 , , , 42759 5768 59 182 182 CD 42759 5768 60 ; ; : 42759 5768 61 and and CC 42759 5768 62 the the DT 42759 5768 63 title title NN 42759 5768 64 of of IN 42759 5768 65 abstinence abstinence NN 42759 5768 66 , , , 42759 5768 67 182 182 CD 42759 5768 68 - - SYM 42759 5768 69 186 186 CD 42759 5768 70 ; ; : 42759 5768 71 social social JJ 42759 5768 72 and and CC 42759 5768 73 presumptive presumptive JJ 42759 5768 74 justifications justification NNS 42759 5768 75 of of IN 42759 5768 76 , , , 42759 5768 77 187 187 CD 42759 5768 78 - - SYM 42759 5768 79 209 209 CD 42759 5768 80 ; ; : 42759 5768 81 necessity necessity NN 42759 5768 82 of of IN 42759 5768 83 , , , 42759 5768 84 191 191 CD 42759 5768 85 - - SYM 42759 5768 86 199 199 CD 42759 5768 87 ; ; : 42759 5768 88 civil civil JJ 42759 5768 89 authorization authorization NN 42759 5768 90 , , , 42759 5768 91 201 201 CD 42759 5768 92 - - SYM 42759 5768 93 204 204 CD 42759 5768 94 ; ; : 42759 5768 95 how how WRB 42759 5768 96 justified justified JJ 42759 5768 97 , , , 42759 5768 98 204 204 CD 42759 5768 99 - - SYM 42759 5768 100 209 209 CD 42759 5768 101 , , , 42759 5768 102 a a DT 42759 5768 103 " " `` 42759 5768 104 workless workless NN 42759 5768 105 " " '' 42759 5768 106 income income NN 42759 5768 107 , , , 42759 5768 108 210 210 CD 42759 5768 109 ; ; : 42759 5768 110 possibility possibility NN 42759 5768 111 of of IN 42759 5768 112 reducing reduce VBG 42759 5768 113 rate rate NN 42759 5768 114 , , , 42759 5768 115 211 211 CD 42759 5768 116 - - SYM 42759 5768 117 213 213 CD 42759 5768 118 ; ; : 42759 5768 119 distinguished distinguish VBN 42759 5768 120 from from IN 42759 5768 121 profits profit NNS 42759 5768 122 , , , 42759 5768 123 238 238 CD 42759 5768 124 , , , 42759 5768 125 239 239 CD 42759 5768 126 ; ; : 42759 5768 127 versus versus IN 42759 5768 128 wages wage NNS 42759 5768 129 , , , 42759 5768 130 390 390 CD 42759 5768 131 - - HYPH 42759 5768 132 393 393 CD 42759 5768 133 . . . 42759 5769 1 Investor investor NN 42759 5769 2 : : : 42759 5769 3 the the DT 42759 5769 4 " " `` 42759 5769 5 innocent innocent JJ 42759 5769 6 , , , 42759 5769 7 " " '' 42759 5769 8 286 286 CD 42759 5769 9 , , , 42759 5769 10 287 287 CD 42759 5769 11 . . . 42759 5770 1 Ireland Ireland NNP 42759 5770 2 : : : 42759 5770 3 reduction reduction NN 42759 5770 4 of of IN 42759 5770 5 rents rent NNS 42759 5770 6 in in IN 42759 5770 7 , , , 42759 5770 8 69 69 CD 42759 5770 9 - - SYM 42759 5770 10 71 71 CD 42759 5770 11 ; ; : 42759 5770 12 compulsory compulsory JJ 42759 5770 13 sale sale NN 42759 5770 14 of of IN 42759 5770 15 land land NN 42759 5770 16 in in RB 42759 5770 17 , , , 42759 5770 18 110 110 CD 42759 5770 19 ; ; : 42759 5770 20 co co NN 42759 5770 21 - - NN 42759 5770 22 operation operation NN 42759 5770 23 in in IN 42759 5770 24 , , , 42759 5770 25 217 217 CD 42759 5770 26 - - SYM 42759 5770 27 219 219 CD 42759 5770 28 . . . 42759 5771 1 Italy Italy NNP 42759 5771 2 : : : 42759 5771 3 co co NN 42759 5771 4 - - NN 42759 5771 5 operation operation NN 42759 5771 6 in in IN 42759 5771 7 , , , 42759 5771 8 223 223 CD 42759 5771 9 . . . 42759 5772 1 Justice justice NN 42759 5772 2 : : : 42759 5772 3 dependence dependence NN 42759 5772 4 of of IN 42759 5772 5 on on IN 42759 5772 6 charity charity NN 42759 5772 7 , , , 42759 5772 8 318 318 CD 42759 5772 9 ; ; : 42759 5772 10 not not RB 42759 5772 11 found find VBN 42759 5772 12 in in IN 42759 5772 13 prevailing prevailing JJ 42759 5772 14 - - HYPH 42759 5772 15 rate rate NN 42759 5772 16 theory theory NN 42759 5772 17 , , , 42759 5772 18 325 325 CD 42759 5772 19 ; ; : 42759 5772 20 nor nor CC 42759 5772 21 in in IN 42759 5772 22 exchange exchange NN 42759 5772 23 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 5772 24 theories theory NNS 42759 5772 25 , , , 42759 5772 26 326 326 CD 42759 5772 27 - - SYM 42759 5772 28 340 340 CD 42759 5772 29 ; ; : 42759 5772 30 nor nor CC 42759 5772 31 in in IN 42759 5772 32 productivity productivity NN 42759 5772 33 theories theory NNS 42759 5772 34 , , , 42759 5772 35 340 340 CD 42759 5772 36 - - SYM 42759 5772 37 355 355 CD 42759 5772 38 ; ; : 42759 5772 39 and and CC 42759 5772 40 the the DT 42759 5772 41 wage wage NN 42759 5772 42 contract contract NN 42759 5772 43 , , , 42759 5772 44 370 370 CD 42759 5772 45 - - SYM 42759 5772 46 372 372 CD 42759 5772 47 ; ; : 42759 5772 48 and and CC 42759 5772 49 the the DT 42759 5772 50 legal legal JJ 42759 5772 51 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5772 52 wage wage NN 42759 5772 53 , , , 42759 5772 54 407 407 CD 42759 5772 55 . . . 42759 5773 1 Kautsky Kautsky NNP 42759 5773 2 , , , 42759 5773 3 Karl Karl NNP 42759 5773 4 : : : 42759 5773 5 153 153 CD 42759 5773 6 . . . 42759 5774 1 King King NNP 42759 5774 2 , , , 42759 5774 3 W. W. NNP 42759 5774 4 I -PRON- PRP 42759 5774 5 : : : 42759 5774 6 82 82 CD 42759 5774 7 , , , 42759 5774 8 83 83 CD 42759 5774 9 , , , 42759 5774 10 122 122 CD 42759 5774 11 , , , 42759 5774 12 123 123 CD 42759 5774 13 , , , 42759 5774 14 155 155 CD 42759 5774 15 , , , 42759 5774 16 240 240 CD 42759 5774 17 , , , 42759 5774 18 310 310 CD 42759 5774 19 , , , 42759 5774 20 414 414 CD 42759 5774 21 . . . 42759 5775 1 Labour labour NN 42759 5775 2 : : : 42759 5775 3 as as IN 42759 5775 4 a a DT 42759 5775 5 title title NN 42759 5775 6 to to TO 42759 5775 7 land land NN 42759 5775 8 , , , 42759 5775 9 24 24 CD 42759 5775 10 - - SYM 42759 5775 11 29 29 CD 42759 5775 12 ; ; : 42759 5775 13 and and CC 42759 5775 14 to to IN 42759 5775 15 products product NNS 42759 5775 16 , , , 42759 5775 17 45 45 CD 42759 5775 18 ; ; : 42759 5775 19 and and CC 42759 5775 20 to to IN 42759 5775 21 the the DT 42759 5775 22 entire entire JJ 42759 5775 23 product product NN 42759 5775 24 of of IN 42759 5775 25 industry industry NN 42759 5775 26 , , , 42759 5775 27 145 145 CD 42759 5775 28 - - SYM 42759 5775 29 152 152 CD 42759 5775 30 ; ; : 42759 5775 31 341 341 CD 42759 5775 32 - - SYM 42759 5775 33 347 347 CD 42759 5775 34 ; ; : 42759 5775 35 productivity productivity NN 42759 5775 36 of of IN 42759 5775 37 , , , 42759 5775 38 178 178 CD 42759 5775 39 , , , 42759 5775 40 179 179 CD 42759 5775 41 ; ; , 42759 5775 42 inefficiency inefficiency NN 42759 5775 43 of of IN 42759 5775 44 under under IN 42759 5775 45 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 5775 46 , , , 42759 5775 47 162 162 CD 42759 5775 48 - - SYM 42759 5775 49 167 167 CD 42759 5775 50 ; ; : 42759 5775 51 mediæval mediæval NN 42759 5775 52 measure measure NN 42759 5775 53 of of IN 42759 5775 54 cost cost NN 42759 5775 55 of of IN 42759 5775 56 , , , 42759 5775 57 336 336 CD 42759 5775 58 , , , 42759 5775 59 337 337 CD 42759 5775 60 ; ; : 42759 5775 61 claims claim NNS 42759 5775 62 of of IN 42759 5775 63 different different JJ 42759 5775 64 groups group NNS 42759 5775 65 of of IN 42759 5775 66 , , , 42759 5775 67 381 381 CD 42759 5775 68 - - SYM 42759 5775 69 387 387 CD 42759 5775 70 ; ; : 42759 5775 71 legislative legislative JJ 42759 5775 72 proposals proposal NNS 42759 5775 73 for for IN 42759 5775 74 , , , 42759 5775 75 416 416 CD 42759 5775 76 , , , 42759 5775 77 417 417 CD 42759 5775 78 . . . 42759 5776 1 Labour labour NN 42759 5776 2 unions union NNS 42759 5776 3 : : : 42759 5776 4 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 5776 5 and and CC 42759 5776 6 limitations limitation NNS 42759 5776 7 of of IN 42759 5776 8 , , , 42759 5776 9 417 417 CD 42759 5776 10 - - SYM 42759 5776 11 420 420 CD 42759 5776 12 ; ; : 42759 5776 13 and and CC 42759 5776 14 legislation legislation NN 42759 5776 15 , , , 42759 5776 16 420 420 CD 42759 5776 17 - - SYM 42759 5776 18 423 423 CD 42759 5776 19 . . . 42759 5777 1 Labourer Labourer NNP 42759 5777 2 , , , 42759 5777 3 the the DT 42759 5777 4 : : : 42759 5777 5 claim claim NN 42759 5777 6 of of IN 42759 5777 7 to to TO 42759 5777 8 rent rent VB 42759 5777 9 , , , 42759 5777 10 71 71 CD 42759 5777 11 - - SYM 42759 5777 12 73 73 CD 42759 5777 13 ; ; : 42759 5777 14 right right RB 42759 5777 15 of of IN 42759 5777 16 to to IN 42759 5777 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5777 18 product product NN 42759 5777 19 , , , 42759 5777 20 25 25 CD 42759 5777 21 , , , 42759 5777 22 26 26 CD 42759 5777 23 , , , 42759 5777 24 28 28 CD 42759 5777 25 , , , 42759 5777 26 43 43 CD 42759 5777 27 , , , 42759 5777 28 45 45 CD 42759 5777 29 , , , 42759 5777 30 149 149 CD 42759 5777 31 , , , 42759 5777 32 150 150 CD 42759 5777 33 , , , 42759 5777 34 179 179 CD 42759 5777 35 , , , 42759 5777 36 180 180 CD 42759 5777 37 ; ; : 42759 5777 38 gains gain NNS 42759 5777 39 of of IN 42759 5777 40 from from IN 42759 5777 41 wage wage NN 42759 5777 42 contract contract NN 42759 5777 43 , , , 42759 5777 44 327 327 CD 42759 5777 45 , , , 42759 5777 46 328 328 CD 42759 5777 47 ; ; : 42759 5777 48 right right RB 42759 5777 49 of of IN 42759 5777 50 to to IN 42759 5777 51 a a DT 42759 5777 52 living living NN 42759 5777 53 wage wage NN 42759 5777 54 , , , 42759 5777 55 363 363 CD 42759 5777 56 - - SYM 42759 5777 57 369 369 CD 42759 5777 58 , , , 42759 5777 59 373 373 CD 42759 5777 60 ; ; : 42759 5777 61 versus versus IN 42759 5777 62 the the DT 42759 5777 63 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5777 64 , , , 42759 5777 65 390 390 CD 42759 5777 66 - - SYM 42759 5777 67 393 393 CD 42759 5777 68 , , , 42759 5777 69 396 396 CD 42759 5777 70 ; ; : 42759 5777 71 versus versus IN 42759 5777 72 the the DT 42759 5777 73 consumer consumer NN 42759 5777 74 , , , 42759 5777 75 393 393 CD 42759 5777 76 - - SYM 42759 5777 77 398 398 CD 42759 5777 78 ; ; : 42759 5777 79 and and CC 42759 5777 80 co co JJ 42759 5777 81 - - JJ 42759 5777 82 operative operative JJ 42759 5777 83 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 5777 84 , , , 42759 5777 85 423 423 CD 42759 5777 86 - - SYM 42759 5777 87 425 425 CD 42759 5777 88 . . . 42759 5778 1 Land land NN 42759 5778 2 : : : 42759 5778 3 distribution distribution NN 42759 5778 4 of of IN 42759 5778 5 , , , 42759 5778 6 16 16 CD 42759 5778 7 , , , 42759 5778 8 17 17 CD 42759 5778 9 , , , 42759 5778 10 87 87 CD 42759 5778 11 - - SYM 42759 5778 12 89 89 CD 42759 5778 13 ; ; : 42759 5778 14 large large JJ 42759 5778 15 holdings holding NNS 42759 5778 16 of of IN 42759 5778 17 , , , 42759 5778 18 89 89 CD 42759 5778 19 , , , 42759 5778 20 90 90 CD 42759 5778 21 ; ; : 42759 5778 22 accessibility accessibility NN 42759 5778 23 to to IN 42759 5778 24 , , , 42759 5778 25 91 91 CD 42759 5778 26 - - HYPH 42759 5778 27 95 95 CD 42759 5778 28 ; ; : 42759 5778 29 the the DT 42759 5778 30 leasing leasing NN 42759 5778 31 system system NN 42759 5778 32 , , , 42759 5778 33 95 95 CD 42759 5778 34 - - SYM 42759 5778 35 97 97 CD 42759 5778 36 ; ; : 42759 5778 37 public public JJ 42759 5778 38 ownership ownership NN 42759 5778 39 of of IN 42759 5778 40 , , , 42759 5778 41 98 98 CD 42759 5778 42 - - SYM 42759 5778 43 100 100 CD 42759 5778 44 . . . 42759 5779 1 Landowner landowner NN 42759 5779 2 : : : 42759 5779 3 right right NN 42759 5779 4 of of IN 42759 5779 5 to to TO 42759 5779 6 rent rent VB 42759 5779 7 , , , 42759 5779 8 67 67 CD 42759 5779 9 - - SYM 42759 5779 10 73 73 CD 42759 5779 11 ; ; : 42759 5779 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5779 13 share share NN 42759 5779 14 of of IN 42759 5779 15 product product NN 42759 5779 16 , , , 42759 5779 17 80 80 CD 42759 5779 18 - - SYM 42759 5779 19 89 89 CD 42759 5779 20 . . . 42759 5780 1 Landownership landownership NN 42759 5780 2 : : : 42759 5780 3 in in IN 42759 5780 4 history history NN 42759 5780 5 , , , 42759 5780 6 8 8 CD 42759 5780 7 - - SYM 42759 5780 8 18 18 CD 42759 5780 9 ; ; : 42759 5780 10 two two CD 42759 5780 11 theories theory NNS 42759 5780 12 of of IN 42759 5780 13 , , , 42759 5780 14 8 8 CD 42759 5780 15 , , , 42759 5780 16 9 9 CD 42759 5780 17 ; ; : 42759 5780 18 in in IN 42759 5780 19 pre pre JJ 42759 5780 20 - - JJ 42759 5780 21 agricultural agricultural JJ 42759 5780 22 conditions condition NNS 42759 5780 23 , , , 42759 5780 24 10 10 CD 42759 5780 25 - - SYM 42759 5780 26 12 12 CD 42759 5780 27 ; ; : 42759 5780 28 origin origin NN 42759 5780 29 of of IN 42759 5780 30 private private JJ 42759 5780 31 , , , 42759 5780 32 12 12 CD 42759 5780 33 - - SYM 42759 5780 34 14 14 CD 42759 5780 35 ; ; : 42759 5780 36 prevalence prevalence NN 42759 5780 37 and and CC 42759 5780 38 benefits benefit NNS 42759 5780 39 of of IN 42759 5780 40 , , , 42759 5780 41 15 15 CD 42759 5780 42 - - SYM 42759 5780 43 18 18 CD 42759 5780 44 ; ; : 42759 5780 45 arguments argument NNS 42759 5780 46 against against IN 42759 5780 47 private private JJ 42759 5780 48 , , , 42759 5780 49 19 19 CD 42759 5780 50 - - SYM 42759 5780 51 47 47 CD 42759 5780 52 , , , 42759 5780 53 by by IN 42759 5780 54 Socialists Socialists NNPS 42759 5780 55 , , , 42759 5780 56 19 19 CD 42759 5780 57 - - SYM 42759 5780 58 21 21 CD 42759 5780 59 , , , 42759 5780 60 by by IN 42759 5780 61 Henry Henry NNP 42759 5780 62 George George NNP 42759 5780 63 , , , 42759 5780 64 21 21 CD 42759 5780 65 - - SYM 42759 5780 66 47 47 CD 42759 5780 67 ; ; : 42759 5780 68 private private JJ 42759 5780 69 , , , 42759 5780 70 the the DT 42759 5780 71 best good JJS 42759 5780 72 system system NN 42759 5780 73 of of IN 42759 5780 74 tenure tenure NN 42759 5780 75 , , , 42759 5780 76 48 48 CD 42759 5780 77 - - SYM 42759 5780 78 55 55 CD 42759 5780 79 ; ; : 42759 5780 80 four four CD 42759 5780 81 elements element NNS 42759 5780 82 of of IN 42759 5780 83 , , , 42759 5780 84 48 48 CD 42759 5780 85 ; ; : 42759 5780 86 a a DT 42759 5780 87 natural natural JJ 42759 5780 88 right right NN 42759 5780 89 , , , 42759 5780 90 55 55 CD 42759 5780 91 - - SYM 42759 5780 92 56 56 CD 42759 5780 93 . . . 42759 5781 1 See see VB 42759 5781 2 Henry Henry NNP 42759 5781 3 George George NNP 42759 5781 4 , , , 42759 5781 5 Occupancy Occupancy NNP 42759 5781 6 , , , 42759 5781 7 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5781 8 , , , 42759 5781 9 Right right UH 42759 5781 10 , , , 42759 5781 11 Compensation Compensation NNP 42759 5781 12 , , , 42759 5781 13 Confiscation Confiscation NNP 42759 5781 14 , , , 42759 5781 15 Defects Defects NNPS 42759 5781 16 , , , 42759 5781 17 Rent Rent NNP 42759 5781 18 . . . 42759 5782 1 Land land NN 42759 5782 2 System system NN 42759 5782 3 : : : 42759 5782 4 defects defect NNS 42759 5782 5 of of IN 42759 5782 6 the the DT 42759 5782 7 existing exist VBG 42759 5782 8 , , , 42759 5782 9 74 74 CD 42759 5782 10 - - SYM 42759 5782 11 93 93 CD 42759 5782 12 . . . 42759 5783 1 Land land NN 42759 5783 2 values value NNS 42759 5783 3 : : : 42759 5783 4 how how WRB 42759 5783 5 created create VBN 42759 5783 6 by by IN 42759 5783 7 the the DT 42759 5783 8 community community NN 42759 5783 9 , , , 42759 5783 10 40 40 CD 42759 5783 11 - - SYM 42759 5783 12 47 47 CD 42759 5783 13 ; ; : 42759 5783 14 increase increase NN 42759 5783 15 of of IN 42759 5783 16 , , , 42759 5783 17 83 83 CD 42759 5783 18 - - SYM 42759 5783 19 86 86 CD 42759 5783 20 ; ; : 42759 5783 21 taxation taxation NN 42759 5783 22 of of IN 42759 5783 23 , , , 42759 5783 24 117 117 CD 42759 5783 25 - - SYM 42759 5783 26 130 130 CD 42759 5783 27 . . . 42759 5784 1 Langenstein Langenstein NNP 42759 5784 2 : : : 42759 5784 3 335 335 CD 42759 5784 4 . . . 42759 5785 1 Lassalle Lassalle NNP 42759 5785 2 , , , 42759 5785 3 F. F. NNP 42759 5785 4 : : : 42759 5785 5 183 183 CD 42759 5785 6 . . . 42759 5786 1 Large large JJ 42759 5786 2 estates estate NNS 42759 5786 3 : : : 42759 5786 4 special special JJ 42759 5786 5 taxation taxation NN 42759 5786 6 of of IN 42759 5786 7 , , , 42759 5786 8 130 130 CD 42759 5786 9 - - SYM 42759 5786 10 132 132 CD 42759 5786 11 . . . 42759 5787 1 Leadership leadership NN 42759 5787 2 : : : 42759 5787 3 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5787 4 , , , 42759 5787 5 under under IN 42759 5787 6 Socialism socialism NN 42759 5787 7 , , , 42759 5787 8 158 158 CD 42759 5787 9 - - SYM 42759 5787 10 167 167 CD 42759 5787 11 . . . 42759 5788 1 Leasing leasing NN 42759 5788 2 system system NN 42759 5788 3 : : : 42759 5788 4 95 95 CD 42759 5788 5 - - SYM 42759 5788 6 97 97 CD 42759 5788 7 . . . 42759 5789 1 Legislation legislation NN 42759 5789 2 : : : 42759 5789 3 for for IN 42759 5789 4 labour labour NN 42759 5789 5 , , , 42759 5789 6 120 120 CD 42759 5789 7 - - SYM 42759 5789 8 123 123 CD 42759 5789 9 , , , 42759 5789 10 416 416 CD 42759 5789 11 . . . 42759 5790 1 Liberty liberty NN 42759 5790 2 : : : 42759 5790 3 under under IN 42759 5790 4 Socialism socialism NN 42759 5790 5 , , , 42759 5790 6 168 168 CD 42759 5790 7 - - SYM 42759 5790 8 170 170 CD 42759 5790 9 . . . 42759 5791 1 Liebknecht Liebknecht NNP 42759 5791 2 , , , 42759 5791 3 W. w. NN 42759 5791 4 : : : 42759 5791 5 152 152 CD 42759 5791 6 . . . 42759 5792 1 Life life NN 42759 5792 2 : : : 42759 5792 3 right right JJ 42759 5792 4 to to IN 42759 5792 5 , , , 42759 5792 6 57 57 CD 42759 5792 7 ; ; : 42759 5792 8 true true JJ 42759 5792 9 conception conception NN 42759 5792 10 of of IN 42759 5792 11 , , , 42759 5792 12 317 317 CD 42759 5792 13 . . . 42759 5793 1 Limitation limitation NN 42759 5793 2 of of IN 42759 5793 3 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 5793 4 : : : 42759 5793 5 291 291 CD 42759 5793 6 - - SYM 42759 5793 7 302 302 CD 42759 5793 8 ; ; : 42759 5793 9 directly directly RB 42759 5793 10 , , , 42759 5793 11 292 292 CD 42759 5793 12 - - SYM 42759 5793 13 295 295 CD 42759 5793 14 ; ; : 42759 5793 15 by by IN 42759 5793 16 taxation taxation NN 42759 5793 17 , , , 42759 5793 18 296 296 CD 42759 5793 19 - - SYM 42759 5793 20 302 302 CD 42759 5793 21 . . . 42759 5794 1 Livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5794 2 , , , 42759 5794 3 decent decent NN 42759 5794 4 : : : 42759 5794 5 360 360 CD 42759 5794 6 - - SYM 42759 5794 7 363 363 CD 42759 5794 8 ; ; : 42759 5794 9 the the DT 42759 5794 10 labourer labourer NN 42759 5794 11 's 's POS 42759 5794 12 right right NN 42759 5794 13 to to IN 42759 5794 14 , , , 42759 5794 15 363 363 CD 42759 5794 16 - - SYM 42759 5794 17 365 365 CD 42759 5794 18 ; ; : 42759 5794 19 the the DT 42759 5794 20 employer employer NN 42759 5794 21 's 's POS 42759 5794 22 , , , 42759 5794 23 366 366 CD 42759 5794 24 . . . 42759 5795 1 Living live VBG 42759 5795 2 wage wage NN 42759 5795 3 : : : 42759 5795 4 the the DT 42759 5795 5 minimum minimum NN 42759 5795 6 of of IN 42759 5795 7 wage wage NN 42759 5795 8 justice justice NN 42759 5795 9 , , , 42759 5795 10 356 356 CD 42759 5795 11 - - SYM 42759 5795 12 380 380 CD 42759 5795 13 ; ; : 42759 5795 14 three three CD 42759 5795 15 fundamental fundamental JJ 42759 5795 16 principles principle NNS 42759 5795 17 , , , 42759 5795 18 358 358 CD 42759 5795 19 - - SYM 42759 5795 20 360 360 CD 42759 5795 21 ; ; : 42759 5795 22 and and CC 42759 5795 23 a a DT 42759 5795 24 decent decent JJ 42759 5795 25 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5795 26 , , , 42759 5795 27 360 360 CD 42759 5795 28 - - SYM 42759 5795 29 363 363 CD 42759 5795 30 ; ; : 42759 5795 31 right right NN 42759 5795 32 of of IN 42759 5795 33 labourer labourer NN 42759 5795 34 to to IN 42759 5795 35 , , , 42759 5795 36 363 363 CD 42759 5795 37 - - SYM 42759 5795 38 369 369 CD 42759 5795 39 ; ; : 42759 5795 40 obligation obligation NN 42759 5795 41 of of IN 42759 5795 42 employer employer NN 42759 5795 43 to to TO 42759 5795 44 pay pay VB 42759 5795 45 , , , 42759 5795 46 365 365 CD 42759 5795 47 - - SYM 42759 5795 48 372 372 CD 42759 5795 49 ; ; : 42759 5795 50 for for IN 42759 5795 51 a a DT 42759 5795 52 family family NN 42759 5795 53 , , , 42759 5795 54 373 373 CD 42759 5795 55 - - SYM 42759 5795 56 376 376 CD 42759 5795 57 ; ; : 42759 5795 58 and and CC 42759 5795 59 social social JJ 42759 5795 60 welfare welfare NN 42759 5795 61 , , , 42759 5795 62 376 376 CD 42759 5795 63 , , , 42759 5795 64 377 377 CD 42759 5795 65 ; ; : 42759 5795 66 authorities authority NNS 42759 5795 67 for for IN 42759 5795 68 , , , 42759 5795 69 377 377 CD 42759 5795 70 , , , 42759 5795 71 378 378 CD 42759 5795 72 ; ; : 42759 5795 73 money money NN 42759 5795 74 measure measure NN 42759 5795 75 of of IN 42759 5795 76 , , , 42759 5795 77 378 378 CD 42759 5795 78 - - SYM 42759 5795 79 380 380 CD 42759 5795 80 ; ; : 42759 5795 81 versus versus IN 42759 5795 82 other other JJ 42759 5795 83 titles title NNS 42759 5795 84 of of IN 42759 5795 85 reward reward NN 42759 5795 86 , , , 42759 5795 87 381 381 CD 42759 5795 88 , , , 42759 5795 89 382 382 CD 42759 5795 90 , , , 42759 5795 91 386 386 CD 42759 5795 92 . . . 42759 5796 1 Loan loan NN 42759 5796 2 capitalist capitalist NN 42759 5796 3 : : : 42759 5796 4 and and CC 42759 5796 5 the the DT 42759 5796 6 claims claim NNS 42759 5796 7 of of IN 42759 5796 8 the the DT 42759 5796 9 labourer labourer NN 42759 5796 10 , , , 42759 5796 11 366 366 CD 42759 5796 12 , , , 42759 5796 13 367 367 CD 42759 5796 14 , , , 42759 5796 15 390 390 CD 42759 5796 16 , , , 42759 5796 17 391 391 CD 42759 5796 18 . . . 42759 5797 1 Loans loan NNS 42759 5797 2 : : : 42759 5797 3 attitude attitude NN 42759 5797 4 of of IN 42759 5797 5 Church Church NNP 42759 5797 6 toward toward IN 42759 5797 7 interest interest NN 42759 5797 8 on on IN 42759 5797 9 , , , 42759 5797 10 172 172 CD 42759 5797 11 - - SYM 42759 5797 12 174 174 CD 42759 5797 13 ; ; : 42759 5797 14 and and CC 42759 5797 15 productive productive JJ 42759 5797 16 capital capital NN 42759 5797 17 , , , 42759 5797 18 174 174 CD 42759 5797 19 , , , 42759 5797 20 175 175 CD 42759 5797 21 . . . 42759 5798 1 Maine Maine NNP 42759 5798 2 , , , 42759 5798 3 Sir Sir NNP 42759 5798 4 Henry Henry NNP 42759 5798 5 : : : 42759 5798 6 17 17 CD 42759 5798 7 . . . 42759 5799 1 Market market NN 42759 5799 2 value value NN 42759 5799 3 : : : 42759 5799 4 and and CC 42759 5799 5 wage wage VB 42759 5799 6 justice justice NN 42759 5799 7 , , , 42759 5799 8 330 330 CD 42759 5799 9 - - SYM 42759 5799 10 332 332 CD 42759 5799 11 , , , 42759 5799 12 370 370 CD 42759 5799 13 , , , 42759 5799 14 375 375 CD 42759 5799 15 . . . 42759 5800 1 Marriage marriage NN 42759 5800 2 : : : 42759 5800 3 right right JJ 42759 5800 4 to to IN 42759 5800 5 , , , 42759 5800 6 57 57 CD 42759 5800 7 , , , 42759 5800 8 58 58 CD 42759 5800 9 ; ; : 42759 5800 10 and and CC 42759 5800 11 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5800 12 life life NN 42759 5800 13 , , , 42759 5800 14 374 374 CD 42759 5800 15 . . . 42759 5801 1 Marx Marx NNP 42759 5801 2 , , , 42759 5801 3 Karl Karl NNP 42759 5801 4 : : : 42759 5801 5 145 145 CD 42759 5801 6 - - SYM 42759 5801 7 148 148 CD 42759 5801 8 , , , 42759 5801 9 342 342 CD 42759 5801 10 , , , 42759 5801 11 343 343 CD 42759 5801 12 , , , 42759 5801 13 374 374 CD 42759 5801 14 . . . 42759 5802 1 Materialism materialism NN 42759 5802 2 : : : 42759 5802 3 in in IN 42759 5802 4 current current JJ 42759 5802 5 conception conception NN 42759 5802 6 of of IN 42759 5802 7 welfare welfare NN 42759 5802 8 , , , 42759 5802 9 314 314 CD 42759 5802 10 - - SYM 42759 5802 11 318 318 CD 42759 5802 12 . . . 42759 5803 1 Meade Meade NNP 42759 5803 2 , , , 42759 5803 3 E. E. NNP 42759 5803 4 S. S. NNP 42759 5803 5 : : : 42759 5803 6 265 265 CD 42759 5803 7 , , , 42759 5803 8 266 266 CD 42759 5803 9 . . . 42759 5804 1 Menger Menger NNP 42759 5804 2 , , , 42759 5804 3 A. a. NN 42759 5804 4 : : : 42759 5804 5 342 342 CD 42759 5804 6 . . . 42759 5805 1 Middle Middle NNP 42759 5805 2 Ages Ages NNP 42759 5805 3 , , , 42759 5805 4 doctrines doctrine NNS 42759 5805 5 of of IN 42759 5805 6 : : : 42759 5805 7 on on IN 42759 5805 8 interest interest NN 42759 5805 9 , , , 42759 5805 10 172 172 CD 42759 5805 11 , , , 42759 5805 12 175 175 CD 42759 5805 13 , , , 42759 5805 14 176 176 CD 42759 5805 15 , , , 42759 5805 16 201 201 CD 42759 5805 17 ; ; : 42759 5805 18 on on IN 42759 5805 19 titles title NNS 42759 5805 20 of of IN 42759 5805 21 gain gain NN 42759 5805 22 , , , 42759 5805 23 175 175 CD 42759 5805 24 ; ; : 42759 5805 25 on on IN 42759 5805 26 wage wage NN 42759 5805 27 justice justice NN 42759 5805 28 , , , 42759 5805 29 332 332 CD 42759 5805 30 - - SYM 42759 5805 31 336 336 CD 42759 5805 32 . . . 42759 5806 1 Minimum minimum JJ 42759 5806 2 : : : 42759 5806 3 of of IN 42759 5806 4 wage wage NN 42759 5806 5 justice justice NN 42759 5806 6 , , , 42759 5806 7 356 356 CD 42759 5806 8 - - SYM 42759 5806 9 380 380 CD 42759 5806 10 . . . 42759 5807 1 Minimum minimum JJ 42759 5807 2 profits profit NNS 42759 5807 3 : : : 42759 5807 4 question question NN 42759 5807 5 of of IN 42759 5807 6 right right NN 42759 5807 7 to to IN 42759 5807 8 , , , 42759 5807 9 258 258 CD 42759 5807 10 - - SYM 42759 5807 11 260 260 CD 42759 5807 12 . . . 42759 5808 1 Minimum minimum JJ 42759 5808 2 wage wage NN 42759 5808 3 : : : 42759 5808 4 353 353 CD 42759 5808 5 - - SYM 42759 5808 6 355 355 CD 42759 5808 7 , , , 42759 5808 8 400 400 CD 42759 5808 9 - - SYM 42759 5808 10 423 423 CD 42759 5808 11 ; ; : 42759 5808 12 in in IN 42759 5808 13 operation operation NN 42759 5808 14 , , , 42759 5808 15 400 400 CD 42759 5808 16 - - SYM 42759 5808 17 405 405 CD 42759 5808 18 ; ; : 42759 5808 19 ethical ethical JJ 42759 5808 20 and and CC 42759 5808 21 political political JJ 42759 5808 22 aspects aspect NNS 42759 5808 23 of of IN 42759 5808 24 , , , 42759 5808 25 407 407 CD 42759 5808 26 , , , 42759 5808 27 408 408 CD 42759 5808 28 ; ; : 42759 5808 29 economic economic JJ 42759 5808 30 aspect aspect NN 42759 5808 31 of of IN 42759 5808 32 , , , 42759 5808 33 408 408 CD 42759 5808 34 - - SYM 42759 5808 35 416 416 CD 42759 5808 36 ; ; : 42759 5808 37 opinions opinion NNS 42759 5808 38 of of IN 42759 5808 39 economists economist NNS 42759 5808 40 on on IN 42759 5808 41 , , , 42759 5808 42 412 412 CD 42759 5808 43 - - SYM 42759 5808 44 416 416 CD 42759 5808 45 , , , 42759 5808 46 420 420 CD 42759 5808 47 - - SYM 42759 5808 48 423 423 CD 42759 5808 49 . . . 42759 5809 1 Modern modern JJ 42759 5809 2 : : : 42759 5809 3 version version NN 42759 5809 4 of of IN 42759 5809 5 exchange exchange NN 42759 5809 6 - - HYPH 42759 5809 7 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 5809 8 , , , 42759 5809 9 336 336 CD 42759 5809 10 - - SYM 42759 5809 11 340 340 CD 42759 5809 12 . . . 42759 5810 1 Monopoly monopoly NN 42759 5810 2 : : : 42759 5810 3 in in IN 42759 5810 4 relation relation NN 42759 5810 5 to to IN 42759 5810 6 land land NN 42759 5810 7 , , , 42759 5810 8 75 75 CD 42759 5810 9 - - SYM 42759 5810 10 80 80 CD 42759 5810 11 ; ; : 42759 5810 12 moral moral JJ 42759 5810 13 aspect aspect NN 42759 5810 14 of of IN 42759 5810 15 , , , 42759 5810 16 262 262 CD 42759 5810 17 - - SYM 42759 5810 18 278 278 CD 42759 5810 19 ; ; : 42759 5810 20 excessive excessive JJ 42759 5810 21 gains gain NNS 42759 5810 22 of of IN 42759 5810 23 , , , 42759 5810 24 263 263 CD 42759 5810 25 - - SYM 42759 5810 26 265 265 CD 42759 5810 27 ; ; : 42759 5810 28 efficiency efficiency NN 42759 5810 29 of of IN 42759 5810 30 , , , 42759 5810 31 265 265 CD 42759 5810 32 - - SYM 42759 5810 33 267 267 CD 42759 5810 34 , , , 42759 5810 35 275 275 CD 42759 5810 36 - - SYM 42759 5810 37 277 277 CD 42759 5810 38 ; ; : 42759 5810 39 discriminative discriminative JJ 42759 5810 40 underselling underselling NN 42759 5810 41 by by RB 42759 5810 42 , , , 42759 5810 43 267 267 CD 42759 5810 44 - - SYM 42759 5810 45 270 270 CD 42759 5810 46 ; ; : 42759 5810 47 favors favor NNS 42759 5810 48 to to IN 42759 5810 49 by by IN 42759 5810 50 railroads railroad NNS 42759 5810 51 , , , 42759 5810 52 262 262 CD 42759 5810 53 , , , 42759 5810 54 273 273 CD 42759 5810 55 ; ; , 42759 5810 56 natural natural JJ 42759 5810 57 , , , 42759 5810 58 273 273 CD 42759 5810 59 - - SYM 42759 5810 60 275 275 CD 42759 5810 61 ; ; : 42759 5810 62 suppression suppression NN 42759 5810 63 versus versus IN 42759 5810 64 regulation regulation NN 42759 5810 65 of of IN 42759 5810 66 , , , 42759 5810 67 275 275 CD 42759 5810 68 - - SYM 42759 5810 69 278 278 CD 42759 5810 70 ; ; : 42759 5810 71 by by IN 42759 5810 72 labour labour NN 42759 5810 73 , , , 42759 5810 74 390 390 CD 42759 5810 75 , , , 42759 5810 76 397 397 CD 42759 5810 77 . . . 42759 5811 1 Natural natural JJ 42759 5811 2 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 5811 3 : : : 42759 5811 4 273 273 CD 42759 5811 5 - - SYM 42759 5811 6 275 275 CD 42759 5811 7 . . . 42759 5812 1 Natural natural JJ 42759 5812 2 rights right NNS 42759 5812 3 : : : 42759 5812 4 57 57 CD 42759 5812 5 - - SYM 42759 5812 6 59 59 CD 42759 5812 7 . . . 42759 5813 1 See See NNP 42759 5813 2 Rights Rights NNPS 42759 5813 3 . . . 42759 5814 1 Nearing Nearing NNP 42759 5814 2 , , , 42759 5814 3 Scott Scott NNP 42759 5814 4 : : : 42759 5814 5 83 83 CD 42759 5814 6 - - SYM 42759 5814 7 85 85 CD 42759 5814 8 ; ; SYM 42759 5814 9 154 154 CD 42759 5814 10 , , , 42759 5814 11 210 210 CD 42759 5814 12 , , , 42759 5814 13 footnote footnote NN 42759 5814 14 . . . 42759 5815 1 Needs need NNS 42759 5815 2 : : : 42759 5815 3 as as IN 42759 5815 4 a a DT 42759 5815 5 canon canon NN 42759 5815 6 of of IN 42759 5815 7 justice justice NN 42759 5815 8 , , , 42759 5815 9 244 244 CD 42759 5815 10 , , , 42759 5815 11 246 246 CD 42759 5815 12 , , , 42759 5815 13 356 356 CD 42759 5815 14 - - SYM 42759 5815 15 358 358 CD 42759 5815 16 ; ; : 42759 5815 17 classification classification NN 42759 5815 18 of of IN 42759 5815 19 , , , 42759 5815 20 308 308 CD 42759 5815 21 , , , 42759 5815 22 309 309 CD 42759 5815 23 ; ; : 42759 5815 24 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 42759 5815 25 conception conception NN 42759 5815 26 of of IN 42759 5815 27 , , , 42759 5815 28 314 314 CD 42759 5815 29 - - HYPH 42759 5815 30 318 318 CD 42759 5815 31 ; ; : 42759 5815 32 a a DT 42759 5815 33 standard standard NN 42759 5815 34 of of IN 42759 5815 35 wage wage NN 42759 5815 36 justice justice NN 42759 5815 37 in in IN 42759 5815 38 Middle Middle NNP 42759 5815 39 Ages Ages NNP 42759 5815 40 , , , 42759 5815 41 335 335 CD 42759 5815 42 , , , 42759 5815 43 336 336 CD 42759 5815 44 . . . 42759 5816 1 Occupancy Occupancy NNP 42759 5816 2 , , , 42759 5816 3 first first RB 42759 5816 4 : : : 42759 5816 5 as as IN 42759 5816 6 a a DT 42759 5816 7 title title NN 42759 5816 8 to to TO 42759 5816 9 land land NN 42759 5816 10 , , , 42759 5816 11 21 21 CD 42759 5816 12 - - SYM 42759 5816 13 24 24 CD 42759 5816 14 ; ; : 42759 5816 15 as as IN 42759 5816 16 exemplified exemplify VBN 42759 5816 17 in in IN 42759 5816 18 increment increment JJ 42759 5816 19 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5816 20 , , , 42759 5816 21 109 109 CD 42759 5816 22 . . . 42759 5817 1 Occupation occupation NN 42759 5817 2 : : : 42759 5817 3 question question NN 42759 5817 4 of of IN 42759 5817 5 right right NN 42759 5817 6 to to IN 42759 5817 7 a a DT 42759 5817 8 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5817 9 from from IN 42759 5817 10 a a DT 42759 5817 11 present present NN 42759 5817 12 , , , 42759 5817 13 362 362 CD 42759 5817 14 , , , 42759 5817 15 363 363 CD 42759 5817 16 . . . 42759 5818 1 Original original JJ 42759 5818 2 titles title NNS 42759 5818 3 : : : 42759 5818 4 See see VB 42759 5818 5 Occupancy Occupancy NNP 42759 5818 6 , , , 42759 5818 7 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5818 8 . . . 42759 5819 1 Overcapitalization overcapitalization NN 42759 5819 2 : : : 42759 5819 3 279 279 CD 42759 5819 4 - - SYM 42759 5819 5 290 290 CD 42759 5819 6 . . . 42759 5820 1 See see VB 42759 5820 2 Stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 5820 3 . . . 42759 5821 1 Ownership ownership NN 42759 5821 2 : : : 42759 5821 3 titles title NNS 42759 5821 4 of of IN 42759 5821 5 determined determine VBN 42759 5821 6 by by IN 42759 5821 7 reasonable reasonable JJ 42759 5821 8 distribution distribution NN 42759 5821 9 , , , 42759 5821 10 150 150 CD 42759 5821 11 , , , 42759 5821 12 151 151 CD 42759 5821 13 . . . 42759 5822 1 Perkins Perkins NNP 42759 5822 2 , , , 42759 5822 3 G. G. NNP 42759 5822 4 W. W. NNP 42759 5822 5 : : : 42759 5822 6 276 276 CD 42759 5822 7 . . . 42759 5823 1 Personality personality NN 42759 5823 2 : : : 42759 5823 3 as as IN 42759 5823 4 basis basis NN 42759 5823 5 of of IN 42759 5823 6 industrial industrial JJ 42759 5823 7 rights right NNS 42759 5823 8 , , , 42759 5823 9 358 358 CD 42759 5823 10 - - SYM 42759 5823 11 371 371 CD 42759 5823 12 , , , 42759 5823 13 374 374 CD 42759 5823 14 . . . 42759 5824 1 Pesch Pesch NNP 42759 5824 2 , , , 42759 5824 3 H. H. NNP 42759 5824 4 : : : 42759 5824 5 215 215 CD 42759 5824 6 . . . 42759 5825 1 Pope Pope NNP 42759 5825 2 Benedict Benedict NNP 42759 5825 3 XIV XIV NNP 42759 5825 4 : : : 42759 5825 5 173 173 CD 42759 5825 6 . . . 42759 5826 1 Clement Clement NNP 42759 5826 2 IV IV NNP 42759 5826 3 : : : 42759 5826 4 23 23 CD 42759 5826 5 . . . 42759 5827 1 Gregory Gregory NNP 42759 5827 2 the the DT 42759 5827 3 Great great JJ 42759 5827 4 : : : 42759 5827 5 306 306 CD 42759 5827 6 . . . 42759 5828 1 Innocent innocent JJ 42759 5828 2 XI XI NNP 42759 5828 3 : : : 42759 5828 4 316 316 CD 42759 5828 5 . . . 42759 5829 1 Leo leo NN 42759 5829 2 XIII xiii NN 42759 5829 3 : : : 42759 5829 4 64 64 CD 42759 5829 5 - - SYM 42759 5829 6 66 66 CD 42759 5829 7 , , , 42759 5829 8 306 306 CD 42759 5829 9 , , , 42759 5829 10 309 309 CD 42759 5829 11 , , , 42759 5829 12 377 377 CD 42759 5829 13 . . . 42759 5830 1 Sixtus Sixtus NNP 42759 5830 2 V V NNP 42759 5830 3 : : : 42759 5830 4 176 176 CD 42759 5830 5 . . . 42759 5831 1 Population population NN 42759 5831 2 : : : 42759 5831 3 excessive excessive JJ 42759 5831 4 increase increase NN 42759 5831 5 of of IN 42759 5831 6 urban urban JJ 42759 5831 7 , , , 42759 5831 8 86 86 CD 42759 5831 9 . . . 42759 5832 1 Possession possession NN 42759 5832 2 : : : 42759 5832 3 as as IN 42759 5832 4 a a DT 42759 5832 5 partial partial JJ 42759 5832 6 justification justification NN 42759 5832 7 of of IN 42759 5832 8 interest interest NN 42759 5832 9 : : : 42759 5832 10 205 205 CD 42759 5832 11 , , , 42759 5832 12 206 206 CD 42759 5832 13 . . . 42759 5833 1 Possessors possessor NNS 42759 5833 2 : : : 42759 5833 3 obligation obligation NN 42759 5833 4 of of IN 42759 5833 5 to to IN 42759 5833 6 non non JJ 42759 5833 7 - - NNS 42759 5833 8 possessors possessor NNS 42759 5833 9 , , , 42759 5833 10 359 359 CD 42759 5833 11 , , , 42759 5833 12 360 360 CD 42759 5833 13 . . . 42759 5834 1 Presumption presumption NN 42759 5834 2 : : : 42759 5834 3 as as IN 42759 5834 4 a a DT 42759 5834 5 partial partial JJ 42759 5834 6 justification justification NN 42759 5834 7 of of IN 42759 5834 8 interest interest NN 42759 5834 9 , , , 42759 5834 10 205 205 CD 42759 5834 11 ; ; : 42759 5834 12 and and CC 42759 5834 13 the the DT 42759 5834 14 canon canon NN 42759 5834 15 of of IN 42759 5834 16 productivity productivity NN 42759 5834 17 , , , 42759 5834 18 248 248 CD 42759 5834 19 . . . 42759 5835 1 Prevailing prevail VBG 42759 5835 2 rate rate NN 42759 5835 3 theory theory NN 42759 5835 4 : : : 42759 5835 5 of of IN 42759 5835 6 wage wage NN 42759 5835 7 justice justice NN 42759 5835 8 , , , 42759 5835 9 323 323 NNP 42759 5835 10 - - SYM 42759 5835 11 325 325 CD 42759 5835 12 . . . 42759 5836 1 Prices price NNS 42759 5836 2 : : : 42759 5836 3 test test NN 42759 5836 4 of of IN 42759 5836 5 extortionate extortionate NNP 42759 5836 6 , , , 42759 5836 7 269 269 CD 42759 5836 8 , , , 42759 5836 9 270 270 CD 42759 5836 10 ; ; : 42759 5836 11 legalized legalize VBN 42759 5836 12 agreements agreement NNS 42759 5836 13 fixing fix VBG 42759 5836 14 , , , 42759 5836 15 277 277 CD 42759 5836 16 , , , 42759 5836 17 278 278 CD 42759 5836 18 ; ; : 42759 5836 19 versus versus IN 42759 5836 20 wages wage NNS 42759 5836 21 , , , 42759 5836 22 393 393 CD 42759 5836 23 - - SYM 42759 5836 24 399 399 CD 42759 5836 25 . . . 42759 5837 1 Principles principle NNS 42759 5837 2 : : : 42759 5837 3 three three CD 42759 5837 4 fundamental fundamental NN 42759 5837 5 to to IN 42759 5837 6 living live VBG 42759 5837 7 wage wage NN 42759 5837 8 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 5837 9 , , , 42759 5837 10 358 358 CD 42759 5837 11 - - SYM 42759 5837 12 360 360 CD 42759 5837 13 . . . 42759 5838 1 Product product NN 42759 5838 2 : : : 42759 5838 3 distribution distribution NN 42759 5838 4 of of IN 42759 5838 5 national national JJ 42759 5838 6 , , , 42759 5838 7 181 181 CD 42759 5838 8 - - SYM 42759 5838 9 183 183 CD 42759 5838 10 . . . 42759 5839 1 See see VB 42759 5839 2 Labour Labour NNP 42759 5839 3 , , , 42759 5839 4 Labourer Labourer NNP 42759 5839 5 , , , 42759 5839 6 Right right UH 42759 5839 7 . . . 42759 5840 1 Production production NN 42759 5840 2 : : : 42759 5840 3 of of IN 42759 5840 4 land land NN 42759 5840 5 values value NNS 42759 5840 6 by by IN 42759 5840 7 the the DT 42759 5840 8 community community NN 42759 5840 9 , , , 42759 5840 10 39 39 CD 42759 5840 11 - - SYM 42759 5840 12 47 47 CD 42759 5840 13 ; ; : 42759 5840 14 co co NN 42759 5840 15 - - NN 42759 5840 16 operation operation NN 42759 5840 17 in in IN 42759 5840 18 , , , 42759 5840 19 222 222 CD 42759 5840 20 - - SYM 42759 5840 21 228 228 CD 42759 5840 22 . . . 42759 5841 1 Productivity productivity NN 42759 5841 2 : : : 42759 5841 3 as as IN 42759 5841 4 a a DT 42759 5841 5 title title NN 42759 5841 6 to to IN 42759 5841 7 the the DT 42759 5841 8 product product NN 42759 5841 9 , , , 42759 5841 10 25 25 CD 42759 5841 11 , , , 42759 5841 12 26 26 CD 42759 5841 13 , , , 42759 5841 14 28 28 CD 42759 5841 15 , , , 42759 5841 16 43 43 CD 42759 5841 17 , , , 42759 5841 18 45 45 CD 42759 5841 19 , , , 42759 5841 20 149 149 CD 42759 5841 21 , , , 42759 5841 22 150 150 CD 42759 5841 23 , , , 42759 5841 24 179 179 CD 42759 5841 25 ; ; : 42759 5841 26 as as IN 42759 5841 27 a a DT 42759 5841 28 title title NN 42759 5841 29 to to IN 42759 5841 30 interest interest NN 42759 5841 31 , , , 42759 5841 32 172 172 CD 42759 5841 33 , , , 42759 5841 34 173 173 CD 42759 5841 35 , , , 42759 5841 36 176 176 CD 42759 5841 37 - - SYM 42759 5841 38 181 181 CD 42759 5841 39 , , , 42759 5841 40 204 204 CD 42759 5841 41 , , , 42759 5841 42 205 205 CD 42759 5841 43 ; ; : 42759 5841 44 of of IN 42759 5841 45 labour labour NN 42759 5841 46 and and CC 42759 5841 47 capital capital NN 42759 5841 48 , , , 42759 5841 49 178 178 CD 42759 5841 50 - - SYM 42759 5841 51 180 180 CD 42759 5841 52 ; ; : 42759 5841 53 as as IN 42759 5841 54 a a DT 42759 5841 55 canon canon NN 42759 5841 56 of of IN 42759 5841 57 distribution distribution NN 42759 5841 58 , , , 42759 5841 59 246 246 CD 42759 5841 60 - - SYM 42759 5841 61 249 249 CD 42759 5841 62 , , , 42759 5841 63 350 350 CD 42759 5841 64 , , , 42759 5841 65 351 351 CD 42759 5841 66 ; ; : 42759 5841 67 as as IN 42759 5841 68 justifying justify VBG 42759 5841 69 large large JJ 42759 5841 70 profits profit NNS 42759 5841 71 , , , 42759 5841 72 255 255 CD 42759 5841 73 - - SYM 42759 5841 74 258 258 CD 42759 5841 75 , , , 42759 5841 76 262 262 CD 42759 5841 77 , , , 42759 5841 78 388 388 CD 42759 5841 79 , , , 42759 5841 80 389 389 CD 42759 5841 81 ; ; : 42759 5841 82 as as IN 42759 5841 83 a a DT 42759 5841 84 title title NN 42759 5841 85 to to IN 42759 5841 86 wages wage NNS 42759 5841 87 , , , 42759 5841 88 341 341 CD 42759 5841 89 - - SYM 42759 5841 90 355 355 CD 42759 5841 91 , , , 42759 5841 92 385 385 CD 42759 5841 93 ; ; : 42759 5841 94 Clark Clark NNP 42759 5841 95 's 's POS 42759 5841 96 theory theory NN 42759 5841 97 of of IN 42759 5841 98 , , , 42759 5841 99 347 347 CD 42759 5841 100 - - SYM 42759 5841 101 351 351 CD 42759 5841 102 ; ; : 42759 5841 103 Carver Carver NNP 42759 5841 104 's 's POS 42759 5841 105 theory theory NN 42759 5841 106 of of IN 42759 5841 107 , , , 42759 5841 108 351 351 CD 42759 5841 109 - - SYM 42759 5841 110 355 355 CD 42759 5841 111 . . . 42759 5842 1 Profits profit NNS 42759 5842 2 : : : 42759 5842 3 nature nature NN 42759 5842 4 of of IN 42759 5842 5 , , , 42759 5842 6 237 237 CD 42759 5842 7 - - SYM 42759 5842 8 242 242 CD 42759 5842 9 ; ; : 42759 5842 10 as as IN 42759 5842 11 compared compare VBN 42759 5842 12 with with IN 42759 5842 13 interest interest NN 42759 5842 14 and and CC 42759 5842 15 rent rent NN 42759 5842 16 , , , 42759 5842 17 139 139 CD 42759 5842 18 , , , 42759 5842 19 140 140 CD 42759 5842 20 , , , 42759 5842 21 238 238 CD 42759 5842 22 , , , 42759 5842 23 239 239 CD 42759 5842 24 ; ; : 42759 5842 25 amount amount NN 42759 5842 26 of of IN 42759 5842 27 , , , 42759 5842 28 239 239 CD 42759 5842 29 , , , 42759 5842 30 240 240 CD 42759 5842 31 ; ; : 42759 5842 32 in in IN 42759 5842 33 a a DT 42759 5842 34 corporation corporation NN 42759 5842 35 , , , 42759 5842 36 241 241 CD 42759 5842 37 , , , 42759 5842 38 242 242 CD 42759 5842 39 ; ; : 42759 5842 40 in in IN 42759 5842 41 conditions condition NNS 42759 5842 42 of of IN 42759 5842 43 competition competition NN 42759 5842 44 , , , 42759 5842 45 254 254 CD 42759 5842 46 - - SYM 42759 5842 47 261 261 CD 42759 5842 48 ; ; : 42759 5842 49 indefinitely indefinitely RB 42759 5842 50 large large JJ 42759 5842 51 , , , 42759 5842 52 255 255 CD 42759 5842 53 - - SYM 42759 5842 54 258 258 CD 42759 5842 55 ; ; : 42759 5842 56 minimum minimum NN 42759 5842 57 , , , 42759 5842 58 258 258 CD 42759 5842 59 - - SYM 42759 5842 60 260 260 CD 42759 5842 61 ; ; : 42759 5842 62 surplus surplus NN 42759 5842 63 and and CC 42759 5842 64 excessive excessive JJ 42759 5842 65 , , , 42759 5842 66 263 263 CD 42759 5842 67 - - SYM 42759 5842 68 265 265 CD 42759 5842 69 ; ; : 42759 5842 70 in in IN 42759 5842 71 natural natural JJ 42759 5842 72 monopolies monopoly NNS 42759 5842 73 , , , 42759 5842 74 273 273 CD 42759 5842 75 , , , 42759 5842 76 274 274 CD 42759 5842 77 ; ; : 42759 5842 78 versus versus IN 42759 5842 79 wages wage NNS 42759 5842 80 , , , 42759 5842 81 388 388 CD 42759 5842 82 - - SYM 42759 5842 83 390 390 CD 42759 5842 84 . . . 42759 5843 1 " " `` 42759 5843 2 Progress Progress NNP 42759 5843 3 and and CC 42759 5843 4 Poverty Poverty NNP 42759 5843 5 " " '' 42759 5843 6 : : : 42759 5843 7 21 21 CD 42759 5843 8 , , , 42759 5843 9 22 22 CD 42759 5843 10 , , , 42759 5843 11 24 24 CD 42759 5843 12 , , , 42759 5843 13 25 25 CD 42759 5843 14 , , , 42759 5843 15 30 30 CD 42759 5843 16 , , , 42759 5843 17 34 34 CD 42759 5843 18 , , , 42759 5843 19 39 39 CD 42759 5843 20 , , , 42759 5843 21 51 51 CD 42759 5843 22 , , , 42759 5843 23 52 52 CD 42759 5843 24 . . . 42759 5844 1 Proudhon Proudhon NNP 42759 5844 2 : : : 42759 5844 3 342 342 CD 42759 5844 4 . . . 42759 5845 1 Public public JJ 42759 5845 2 honour honour NN 42759 5845 3 : : : 42759 5845 4 efficacy efficacy NN 42759 5845 5 of of IN 42759 5845 6 under under IN 42759 5845 7 Socialism socialism NN 42759 5845 8 : : : 42759 5845 9 165 165 CD 42759 5845 10 - - SYM 42759 5845 11 167 167 CD 42759 5845 12 . . . 42759 5846 1 Pullman Pullman NNP 42759 5846 2 Company Company NNP 42759 5846 3 : : : 42759 5846 4 289 289 CD 42759 5846 5 . . . 42759 5847 1 Reform reform NN 42759 5847 2 : : : 42759 5847 3 versus versus IN 42759 5847 4 revolution revolution NN 42759 5847 5 , , , 42759 5847 6 94 94 CD 42759 5847 7 . . . 42759 5848 1 Rent rent NN 42759 5848 2 : : : 42759 5848 3 economic economic JJ 42759 5848 4 , , , 42759 5848 5 3 3 CD 42759 5848 6 - - SYM 42759 5848 7 7 7 CD 42759 5848 8 ; ; : 42759 5848 9 commercial commercial JJ 42759 5848 10 , , , 42759 5848 11 5 5 CD 42759 5848 12 ; ; : 42759 5848 13 how how WRB 42759 5848 14 produced produce VBN 42759 5848 15 by by IN 42759 5848 16 society society NN 42759 5848 17 , , , 42759 5848 18 39 39 CD 42759 5848 19 - - SYM 42759 5848 20 47 47 CD 42759 5848 21 ; ; : 42759 5848 22 right right RB 42759 5848 23 of of IN 42759 5848 24 landowner landowner NN 42759 5848 25 to to IN 42759 5848 26 , , , 42759 5848 27 67 67 CD 42759 5848 28 - - SYM 42759 5848 29 75 75 CD 42759 5848 30 ; ; : 42759 5848 31 right right JJ 42759 5848 32 of of IN 42759 5848 33 tenant tenant NN 42759 5848 34 and and CC 42759 5848 35 labourer labourer NN 42759 5848 36 to to IN 42759 5848 37 , , , 42759 5848 38 69 69 CD 42759 5848 39 - - SYM 42759 5848 40 73 73 CD 42759 5848 41 , , , 42759 5848 42 396 396 CD 42759 5848 43 ; ; : 42759 5848 44 increase increase NN 42759 5848 45 and and CC 42759 5848 46 amount amount NN 42759 5848 47 of of IN 42759 5848 48 , , , 42759 5848 49 80 80 CD 42759 5848 50 - - SYM 42759 5848 51 87 87 CD 42759 5848 52 ; ; : 42759 5848 53 distribution distribution NN 42759 5848 54 of of IN 42759 5848 55 , , , 42759 5848 56 87 87 CD 42759 5848 57 - - SYM 42759 5848 58 89 89 CD 42759 5848 59 ; ; : 42759 5848 60 in in IN 42759 5848 61 United United NNP 42759 5848 62 States States NNP 42759 5848 63 , , , 42759 5848 64 122 122 CD 42759 5848 65 . . . 42759 5849 1 Rent rent NN 42759 5849 2 charges charge NNS 42759 5849 3 : : : 42759 5849 4 attitude attitude NN 42759 5849 5 of of IN 42759 5849 6 theologians theologian NNS 42759 5849 7 toward toward IN 42759 5849 8 , , , 42759 5849 9 175 175 CD 42759 5849 10 , , , 42759 5849 11 176 176 CD 42759 5849 12 . . . 42759 5850 1 " " `` 42759 5850 2 Res res VB 42759 5850 3 fructificat fructificat NNP 42759 5850 4 domina domina NN 42759 5850 5 " " '' 42759 5850 6 : : : 42759 5850 7 limitations limitation NNS 42759 5850 8 of of IN 42759 5850 9 this this DT 42759 5850 10 formula formula NN 42759 5850 11 , , , 42759 5850 12 60 60 CD 42759 5850 13 , , , 42759 5850 14 61 61 CD 42759 5850 15 , , , 42759 5850 16 104 104 CD 42759 5850 17 , , , 42759 5850 18 105 105 CD 42759 5850 19 , , , 42759 5850 20 111 111 CD 42759 5850 21 , , , 42759 5850 22 180 180 CD 42759 5850 23 , , , 42759 5850 24 345 345 CD 42759 5850 25 . . . 42759 5851 1 Revolution revolution NN 42759 5851 2 : : : 42759 5851 3 versus versus IN 42759 5851 4 reform reform NN 42759 5851 5 , , , 42759 5851 6 94 94 CD 42759 5851 7 . . . 42759 5852 1 Riches rich NNS 42759 5852 2 : : : 42759 5852 3 from from IN 42759 5852 4 land land NN 42759 5852 5 , , , 42759 5852 6 88 88 CD 42759 5852 7 , , , 42759 5852 8 89 89 CD 42759 5852 9 . . . 42759 5853 1 Right right UH 42759 5853 2 : : : 42759 5853 3 of of IN 42759 5853 4 the the DT 42759 5853 5 individual individual NN 42759 5853 6 to to IN 42759 5853 7 land land NN 42759 5853 8 , , , 42759 5853 9 30 30 CD 42759 5853 10 - - SYM 42759 5853 11 39 39 CD 42759 5853 12 ; ; : 42759 5853 13 of of IN 42759 5853 14 the the DT 42759 5853 15 community community NN 42759 5853 16 to to TO 42759 5853 17 land land VB 42759 5853 18 values value NNS 42759 5853 19 and and CC 42759 5853 20 rent rent NN 42759 5853 21 , , , 42759 5853 22 39 39 CD 42759 5853 23 - - SYM 42759 5853 24 47 47 CD 42759 5853 25 ; ; : 42759 5853 26 of of IN 42759 5853 27 the the DT 42759 5853 28 producer producer NN 42759 5853 29 to to IN 42759 5853 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5853 31 product product NN 42759 5853 32 , , , 42759 5853 33 see see VB 42759 5853 34 productivity productivity NN 42759 5853 35 ; ; , 42759 5853 36 of of IN 42759 5853 37 private private JJ 42759 5853 38 landownership landownership NN 42759 5853 39 , , , 42759 5853 40 56 56 CD 42759 5853 41 - - SYM 42759 5853 42 66 66 CD 42759 5853 43 ; ; : 42759 5853 44 to to TO 42759 5853 45 take take VB 42759 5853 46 rent rent NN 42759 5853 47 , , , 42759 5853 48 67 67 CD 42759 5853 49 - - SYM 42759 5853 50 73 73 CD 42759 5853 51 ; ; : 42759 5853 52 of of IN 42759 5853 53 access access NN 42759 5853 54 to to IN 42759 5853 55 the the DT 42759 5853 56 earth earth NN 42759 5853 57 , , , 42759 5853 58 358 358 CD 42759 5853 59 - - SYM 42759 5853 60 360 360 CD 42759 5853 61 ; ; : 42759 5853 62 to to IN 42759 5853 63 a a DT 42759 5853 64 decent decent JJ 42759 5853 65 livelihood livelihood NN 42759 5853 66 , , , 42759 5853 67 360 360 CD 42759 5853 68 - - SYM 42759 5853 69 363 363 CD 42759 5853 70 ; ; : 42759 5853 71 to to IN 42759 5853 72 a a DT 42759 5853 73 living living NN 42759 5853 74 wage wage NN 42759 5853 75 , , , 42759 5853 76 363 363 CD 42759 5853 77 - - SYM 42759 5853 78 369 369 CD 42759 5853 79 , , , 42759 5853 80 372 372 CD 42759 5853 81 , , , 42759 5853 82 376 376 CD 42759 5853 83 . . . 42759 5854 1 Rights right NNS 42759 5854 2 : : : 42759 5854 3 three three CD 42759 5854 4 principal principal JJ 42759 5854 5 kinds kind NNS 42759 5854 6 of of IN 42759 5854 7 natural natural JJ 42759 5854 8 , , , 42759 5854 9 57 57 CD 42759 5854 10 - - SYM 42759 5854 11 59 59 CD 42759 5854 12 ; ; : 42759 5854 13 of of IN 42759 5854 14 property property NN 42759 5854 15 , , , 42759 5854 16 as as IN 42759 5854 17 created create VBN 42759 5854 18 by by IN 42759 5854 19 the the DT 42759 5854 20 State State NNP 42759 5854 21 , , , 42759 5854 22 202 202 CD 42759 5854 23 . . . 42759 5855 1 Rodbertus Rodbertus NNP 42759 5855 2 , , , 42759 5855 3 K. K. NNP 42759 5855 4 : : : 42759 5855 5 342 342 CD 42759 5855 6 . . . 42759 5856 1 Roman Roman NNP 42759 5856 2 Congregations Congregations NNPS 42759 5856 3 : : : 42759 5856 4 on on IN 42759 5856 5 lawfulness lawfulness NN 42759 5856 6 of of IN 42759 5856 7 interest interest NN 42759 5856 8 taking taking NN 42759 5856 9 , , , 42759 5856 10 173 173 CD 42759 5856 11 , , , 42759 5856 12 174 174 CD 42759 5856 13 . . . 42759 5857 1 Saint Saint NNP 42759 5857 2 - - HYPH 42759 5857 3 Simon Simon NNP 42759 5857 4 : : : 42759 5857 5 342 342 CD 42759 5857 6 . . . 42759 5858 1 Sacrifice sacrifice NN 42759 5858 2 : : : 42759 5858 3 principle principle NN 42759 5858 4 of of IN 42759 5858 5 in in IN 42759 5858 6 taxation taxation NN 42759 5858 7 , , , 42759 5858 8 131 131 CD 42759 5858 9 , , , 42759 5858 10 297 297 CD 42759 5858 11 ; ; : 42759 5858 12 as as IN 42759 5858 13 a a DT 42759 5858 14 title title NN 42759 5858 15 to to IN 42759 5858 16 interest interest NN 42759 5858 17 , , , 42759 5858 18 185 185 CD 42759 5858 19 - - SYM 42759 5858 20 188 188 CD 42759 5858 21 ; ; : 42759 5858 22 as as IN 42759 5858 23 a a DT 42759 5858 24 title title NN 42759 5858 25 of of IN 42759 5858 26 reward reward NN 42759 5858 27 , , , 42759 5858 28 383 383 CD 42759 5858 29 - - SYM 42759 5858 30 385 385 CD 42759 5858 31 . . . 42759 5859 1 Savers saver NNS 42759 5859 2 : : : 42759 5859 3 three three CD 42759 5859 4 kinds kind NNS 42759 5859 5 of of IN 42759 5859 6 , , , 42759 5859 7 183 183 CD 42759 5859 8 - - SYM 42759 5859 9 185 185 CD 42759 5859 10 . . . 42759 5860 1 Scarcity scarcity NN 42759 5860 2 : : : 42759 5860 3 effect effect NN 42759 5860 4 of of IN 42759 5860 5 on on IN 42759 5860 6 rewards reward NNS 42759 5860 7 of of IN 42759 5860 8 productive productive JJ 42759 5860 9 agents agent NNS 42759 5860 10 , , , 42759 5860 11 80 80 CD 42759 5860 12 ; ; : 42759 5860 13 as as IN 42759 5860 14 a a DT 42759 5860 15 canon canon NN 42759 5860 16 of of IN 42759 5860 17 distributive distributive JJ 42759 5860 18 justice justice NN 42759 5860 19 , , , 42759 5860 20 250 250 CD 42759 5860 21 , , , 42759 5860 22 251 251 CD 42759 5860 23 ; ; : 42759 5860 24 as as IN 42759 5860 25 justifying justify VBG 42759 5860 26 very very RB 42759 5860 27 large large JJ 42759 5860 28 profits profit NNS 42759 5860 29 , , , 42759 5860 30 and and CC 42759 5860 31 more more JJR 42759 5860 32 than than IN 42759 5860 33 a a DT 42759 5860 34 living living NN 42759 5860 35 wage wage NN 42759 5860 36 , , , 42759 5860 37 255 255 CD 42759 5860 38 - - SYM 42759 5860 39 258 258 CD 42759 5860 40 . . . 42759 5861 1 Schmoller Schmoller NNP 42759 5861 2 : : : 42759 5861 3 253 253 CD 42759 5861 4 . . . 42759 5862 1 Schoolmen schoolman NNS 42759 5862 2 : : : 42759 5862 3 doctrines doctrine NNS 42759 5862 4 of of IN 42759 5862 5 on on IN 42759 5862 6 wage wage NN 42759 5862 7 justice justice NN 42759 5862 8 , , , 42759 5862 9 333 333 CD 42759 5862 10 - - SYM 42759 5862 11 336 336 CD 42759 5862 12 . . . 42759 5863 1 Seligman Seligman NNP 42759 5863 2 , , , 42759 5863 3 E. E. NNP 42759 5863 4 R. R. NNP 42759 5863 5 A. a. NN 42759 5863 6 : : : 42759 5863 7 101 101 CD 42759 5863 8 , , , 42759 5863 9 296 296 CD 42759 5863 10 , , , 42759 5863 11 297 297 CD 42759 5863 12 . . . 42759 5864 1 Service service NN 42759 5864 2 : : : 42759 5864 3 as as IN 42759 5864 4 a a DT 42759 5864 5 title title NN 42759 5864 6 to to IN 42759 5864 7 interest interest NN 42759 5864 8 , , , 42759 5864 9 181 181 CD 42759 5864 10 , , , 42759 5864 11 182 182 CD 42759 5864 12 , , , 42759 5864 13 204 204 CD 42759 5864 14 , , , 42759 5864 15 205 205 CD 42759 5864 16 . . . 42759 5865 1 Shifting shifting NN 42759 5865 2 : : : 42759 5865 3 of of IN 42759 5865 4 land land NN 42759 5865 5 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5865 6 , , , 42759 5865 7 102 102 CD 42759 5865 8 , , , 42759 5865 9 103 103 CD 42759 5865 10 . . . 42759 5866 1 Sidgwick Sidgwick NNP 42759 5866 2 , , , 42759 5866 3 H. H. NNP 42759 5866 4 : : : 42759 5866 5 329 329 CD 42759 5866 6 . . . 42759 5867 1 Single single JJ 42759 5867 2 Tax tax NN 42759 5867 3 : : : 42759 5867 4 injustice injustice NN 42759 5867 5 of of IN 42759 5867 6 , , , 42759 5867 7 33 33 CD 42759 5867 8 - - SYM 42759 5867 9 39 39 CD 42759 5867 10 , , , 42759 5867 11 100 100 CD 42759 5867 12 ; ; : 42759 5867 13 proposals proposal NNS 42759 5867 14 and and CC 42759 5867 15 defects defect NNS 42759 5867 16 of of IN 42759 5867 17 , , , 42759 5867 18 51 51 CD 42759 5867 19 , , , 42759 5867 20 54 54 CD 42759 5867 21 , , , 42759 5867 22 108 108 CD 42759 5867 23 . . . 42759 5868 1 Skelton Skelton NNP 42759 5868 2 , , , 42759 5868 3 O. O. NNP 42759 5868 4 D. D. NNP 42759 5868 5 : : : 42759 5868 6 165 165 CD 42759 5868 7 . . . 42759 5869 1 Small small JJ 42759 5869 2 , , , 42759 5869 3 A. a. NN 42759 5869 4 W. w. NN 42759 5869 5 : : : 42759 5869 6 171 171 CD 42759 5869 7 . . . 42759 5870 1 Social social JJ 42759 5870 2 benefits benefit NNS 42759 5870 3 : : : 42759 5870 4 of of IN 42759 5870 5 special special JJ 42759 5870 6 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5870 7 on on IN 42759 5870 8 land land NN 42759 5870 9 , , , 42759 5870 10 127 127 CD 42759 5870 11 - - SYM 42759 5870 12 130 130 CD 42759 5870 13 . . . 42759 5871 1 Socialism socialism NN 42759 5871 2 : : : 42759 5871 3 as as IN 42759 5871 4 regards regard VBZ 42759 5871 5 land land NN 42759 5871 6 , , , 42759 5871 7 49 49 CD 42759 5871 8 , , , 42759 5871 9 51 51 CD 42759 5871 10 ; ; : 42759 5871 11 not not RB 42759 5871 12 inevitable inevitable JJ 42759 5871 13 , , , 42759 5871 14 153 153 CD 42759 5871 15 ; ; : 42759 5871 16 expropriation expropriation NN 42759 5871 17 of of IN 42759 5871 18 capitalists capitalist NNS 42759 5871 19 by by IN 42759 5871 20 , , , 42759 5871 21 154 154 CD 42759 5871 22 - - SYM 42759 5871 23 158 158 CD 42759 5871 24 ; ; : 42759 5871 25 inefficiency inefficiency NN 42759 5871 26 of of IN 42759 5871 27 , , , 42759 5871 28 158 158 CD 42759 5871 29 - - SYM 42759 5871 30 168 168 CD 42759 5871 31 ; ; : 42759 5871 32 hostile hostile JJ 42759 5871 33 to to IN 42759 5871 34 individual individual JJ 42759 5871 35 liberty liberty NN 42759 5871 36 , , , 42759 5871 37 168 168 CD 42759 5871 38 - - SYM 42759 5871 39 170 170 CD 42759 5871 40 ; ; : 42759 5871 41 not not RB 42759 5871 42 co co NN 42759 5871 43 - - NN 42759 5871 44 operation operation NN 42759 5871 45 , , , 42759 5871 46 230 230 CD 42759 5871 47 , , , 42759 5871 48 231 231 CD 42759 5871 49 . . . 42759 5872 1 Socialists socialist NNS 42759 5872 2 : : : 42759 5872 3 on on IN 42759 5872 4 private private JJ 42759 5872 5 landownership landownership NN 42759 5872 6 , , , 42759 5872 7 19 19 CD 42759 5872 8 - - SYM 42759 5872 9 21 21 CD 42759 5872 10 ; ; : 42759 5872 11 on on IN 42759 5872 12 interest interest NN 42759 5872 13 , , , 42759 5872 14 value value NN 42759 5872 15 , , , 42759 5872 16 and and CC 42759 5872 17 labour labour NN 42759 5872 18 , , , 42759 5872 19 145 145 CD 42759 5872 20 - - SYM 42759 5872 21 148 148 CD 42759 5872 22 ; ; : 42759 5872 23 on on IN 42759 5872 24 the the DT 42759 5872 25 collectivist collectivist JJ 42759 5872 26 State State NNP 42759 5872 27 , , , 42759 5872 28 152 152 CD 42759 5872 29 , , , 42759 5872 30 153 153 CD 42759 5872 31 ; ; : 42759 5872 32 on on IN 42759 5872 33 morality morality NN 42759 5872 34 of of IN 42759 5872 35 profits profit NNS 42759 5872 36 , , , 42759 5872 37 254 254 CD 42759 5872 38 ; ; : 42759 5872 39 on on IN 42759 5872 40 wage wage NN 42759 5872 41 justice justice NN 42759 5872 42 , , , 42759 5872 43 341 341 CD 42759 5872 44 - - SYM 42759 5872 45 347 347 CD 42759 5872 46 ; ; : 42759 5872 47 on on IN 42759 5872 48 the the DT 42759 5872 49 principle principle NN 42759 5872 50 of of IN 42759 5872 51 needs need NNS 42759 5872 52 , , , 42759 5872 53 356 356 CD 42759 5872 54 . . . 42759 5873 1 Socialist socialist JJ 42759 5873 2 party party NN 42759 5873 3 : : : 42759 5873 4 of of IN 42759 5873 5 the the DT 42759 5873 6 United United NNP 42759 5873 7 States States NNP 42759 5873 8 , , , 42759 5873 9 on on IN 42759 5873 10 landownership landownership NN 42759 5873 11 , , , 42759 5873 12 51 51 CD 42759 5873 13 . . . 42759 5874 1 Spargo Spargo NNP 42759 5874 2 , , , 42759 5874 3 John John NNP 42759 5874 4 : : : 42759 5874 5 51 51 CD 42759 5874 6 . . . 42759 5875 1 Specific specific JJ 42759 5875 2 productivity productivity NN 42759 5875 3 : : : 42759 5875 4 as as IN 42759 5875 5 a a DT 42759 5875 6 measure measure NN 42759 5875 7 of of IN 42759 5875 8 wage wage NN 42759 5875 9 justice justice NN 42759 5875 10 , , , 42759 5875 11 347 347 CD 42759 5875 12 - - SYM 42759 5875 13 351 351 CD 42759 5875 14 . . . 42759 5876 1 Speculation speculation NN 42759 5876 2 : : : 42759 5876 3 effect effect NN 42759 5876 4 of of IN 42759 5876 5 on on IN 42759 5876 6 land land NN 42759 5876 7 values value NNS 42759 5876 8 , , , 42759 5876 9 92 92 CD 42759 5876 10 , , , 42759 5876 11 93 93 CD 42759 5876 12 , , , 42759 5876 13 103 103 CD 42759 5876 14 . . . 42759 5877 1 Spencer Spencer NNP 42759 5877 2 , , , 42759 5877 3 Herbert Herbert NNP 42759 5877 4 : : : 42759 5877 5 23 23 CD 42759 5877 6 . . . 42759 5878 1 Standard Standard NNP 42759 5878 2 Oil Oil NNP 42759 5878 3 Company Company NNP 42759 5878 4 : : : 42759 5878 5 76 76 CD 42759 5878 6 , , , 42759 5878 7 263 263 CD 42759 5878 8 , , , 42759 5878 9 267 267 CD 42759 5878 10 . . . 42759 5879 1 State state NN 42759 5879 2 , , , 42759 5879 3 the the DT 42759 5879 4 : : : 42759 5879 5 should should MD 42759 5879 6 permit permit VB 42759 5879 7 interest interest NN 42759 5879 8 , , , 42759 5879 9 199 199 CD 42759 5879 10 - - SYM 42759 5879 11 201 201 CD 42759 5879 12 ; ; : 42759 5879 13 power power NN 42759 5879 14 of of IN 42759 5879 15 to to TO 42759 5879 16 create create VB 42759 5879 17 property property NN 42759 5879 18 rights right NNS 42759 5879 19 , , , 42759 5879 20 202 202 CD 42759 5879 21 - - SYM 42759 5879 22 204 204 CD 42759 5879 23 ; ; : 42759 5879 24 not not RB 42759 5879 25 obliged oblige VBN 42759 5879 26 to to TO 42759 5879 27 guarantee guarantee VB 42759 5879 28 living living NN 42759 5879 29 profits profit NNS 42759 5879 30 , , , 42759 5879 31 259 259 CD 42759 5879 32 ; ; : 42759 5879 33 fixing fix VBG 42759 5879 34 of of IN 42759 5879 35 maximum maximum JJ 42759 5879 36 prices price NNS 42759 5879 37 by by IN 42759 5879 38 , , , 42759 5879 39 275 275 CD 42759 5879 40 - - SYM 42759 5879 41 278 278 CD 42759 5879 42 ; ; : 42759 5879 43 and and CC 42759 5879 44 the the DT 42759 5879 45 " " `` 42759 5879 46 innocent innocent JJ 42759 5879 47 " " '' 42759 5879 48 investor investor NN 42759 5879 49 , , , 42759 5879 50 286 286 CD 42759 5879 51 , , , 42759 5879 52 287 287 CD 42759 5879 53 ; ; : 42759 5879 54 and and CC 42759 5879 55 the the DT 42759 5879 56 prevention prevention NN 42759 5879 57 of of IN 42759 5879 58 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 5879 59 , , , 42759 5879 60 289 289 CD 42759 5879 61 , , , 42759 5879 62 290 290 CD 42759 5879 63 ; ; : 42759 5879 64 and and CC 42759 5879 65 the the DT 42759 5879 66 limitation limitation NN 42759 5879 67 of of IN 42759 5879 68 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 5879 69 , , , 42759 5879 70 291 291 CD 42759 5879 71 - - SYM 42759 5879 72 302 302 CD 42759 5879 73 ; ; : 42759 5879 74 and and CC 42759 5879 75 payment payment NN 42759 5879 76 of of IN 42759 5879 77 living living NN 42759 5879 78 wages wage NNS 42759 5879 79 , , , 42759 5879 80 365 365 CD 42759 5879 81 ; ; : 42759 5879 82 and and CC 42759 5879 83 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5879 84 wage wage NN 42759 5879 85 , , , 42759 5879 86 407 407 CD 42759 5879 87 , , , 42759 5879 88 408 408 CD 42759 5879 89 , , , 42759 5879 90 420 420 CD 42759 5879 91 - - SYM 42759 5879 92 423 423 CD 42759 5879 93 ; ; : 42759 5879 94 and and CC 42759 5879 95 other other JJ 42759 5879 96 labour labour NN 42759 5879 97 legislation legislation NN 42759 5879 98 , , , 42759 5879 99 416 416 CD 42759 5879 100 , , , 42759 5879 101 417 417 CD 42759 5879 102 . . . 42759 5880 1 Stockholders stockholder NNS 42759 5880 2 : : : 42759 5880 3 claim claim NN 42759 5880 4 of of IN 42759 5880 5 to to TO 42759 5880 6 surplus surplus VB 42759 5880 7 gains gain NNS 42759 5880 8 , , , 42759 5880 9 257 257 CD 42759 5880 10 , , , 42759 5880 11 258 258 CD 42759 5880 12 , , , 42759 5880 13 262 262 CD 42759 5880 14 ; ; : 42759 5880 15 as as IN 42759 5880 16 related relate VBN 42759 5880 17 to to IN 42759 5880 18 stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 5880 19 , , , 42759 5880 20 279 279 CD 42759 5880 21 - - SYM 42759 5880 22 281 281 CD 42759 5880 23 , , , 42759 5880 24 285 285 CD 42759 5880 25 . . . 42759 5881 1 Stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 5881 2 : : : 42759 5881 3 moral moral JJ 42759 5881 4 aspect aspect NN 42759 5881 5 of of IN 42759 5881 6 , , , 42759 5881 7 279 279 CD 42759 5881 8 - - SYM 42759 5881 9 290 290 CD 42759 5881 10 ; ; : 42759 5881 11 definition definition NN 42759 5881 12 of of IN 42759 5881 13 , , , 42759 5881 14 280 280 CD 42759 5881 15 ; ; : 42759 5881 16 injurious injurious JJ 42759 5881 17 effects effect NNS 42759 5881 18 of of IN 42759 5881 19 , , , 42759 5881 20 281 281 CD 42759 5881 21 - - SYM 42759 5881 22 286 286 CD 42759 5881 23 and and CC 42759 5881 24 the the DT 42759 5881 25 " " `` 42759 5881 26 innocent innocent JJ 42759 5881 27 " " '' 42759 5881 28 investor investor NN 42759 5881 29 , , , 42759 5881 30 286 286 CD 42759 5881 31 , , , 42759 5881 32 287 287 CD 42759 5881 33 ; ; : 42759 5881 34 magnitude magnitude NN 42759 5881 35 of of IN 42759 5881 36 , , , 42759 5881 37 288 288 CD 42759 5881 38 , , , 42759 5881 39 289 289 CD 42759 5881 40 ; ; : 42759 5881 41 prevention prevention NN 42759 5881 42 of of IN 42759 5881 43 , , , 42759 5881 44 289 289 CD 42759 5881 45 , , , 42759 5881 46 290 290 CD 42759 5881 47 . . . 42759 5882 1 Stores store NNS 42759 5882 2 : : : 42759 5882 3 co co NN 42759 5882 4 - - NN 42759 5882 5 operation operation NN 42759 5882 6 in in IN 42759 5882 7 , , , 42759 5882 8 220 220 CD 42759 5882 9 - - SYM 42759 5882 10 222 222 CD 42759 5882 11 . . . 42759 5883 1 Superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 5883 2 wealth wealth NN 42759 5883 3 : : : 42759 5883 4 duty duty NN 42759 5883 5 of of IN 42759 5883 6 distributing distribute VBG 42759 5883 7 , , , 42759 5883 8 303 303 CD 42759 5883 9 - - SYM 42759 5883 10 319 319 CD 42759 5883 11 ; ; : 42759 5883 12 kinds kind NNS 42759 5883 13 of of IN 42759 5883 14 , , , 42759 5883 15 308 308 CD 42759 5883 16 , , , 42759 5883 17 309 309 CD 42759 5883 18 ; ; : 42759 5883 19 a a DT 42759 5883 20 false false JJ 42759 5883 21 conception conception NN 42759 5883 22 of of IN 42759 5883 23 , , , 42759 5883 24 314 314 CD 42759 5883 25 - - SYM 42759 5883 26 316 316 CD 42759 5883 27 ; ; : 42759 5883 28 true true JJ 42759 5883 29 conception conception NN 42759 5883 30 of of IN 42759 5883 31 , , , 42759 5883 32 318 318 CD 42759 5883 33 , , , 42759 5883 34 319 319 CD 42759 5883 35 . . . 42759 5884 1 See see VB 42759 5884 2 Wealth wealth NN 42759 5884 3 . . . 42759 5885 1 Supertax supertax JJ 42759 5885 2 : : : 42759 5885 3 on on IN 42759 5885 4 large large JJ 42759 5885 5 landed landed JJ 42759 5885 6 estates estate NNS 42759 5885 7 , , , 42759 5885 8 130 130 CD 42759 5885 9 - - SYM 42759 5885 10 132 132 CD 42759 5885 11 . . . 42759 5886 1 Supply supply NN 42759 5886 2 and and CC 42759 5886 3 demand demand NN 42759 5886 4 : : : 42759 5886 5 as as IN 42759 5886 6 determining determine VBG 42759 5886 7 rent rent NN 42759 5886 8 , , , 42759 5886 9 80 80 CD 42759 5886 10 ; ; : 42759 5886 11 as as IN 42759 5886 12 determining determine VBG 42759 5886 13 interest interest NN 42759 5886 14 , , , 42759 5886 15 143 143 CD 42759 5886 16 , , , 42759 5886 17 144 144 CD 42759 5886 18 . . . 42759 5887 1 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 5887 2 , , , 42759 5887 3 F. F. NNP 42759 5887 4 W. W. NNP 42759 5887 5 : : : 42759 5887 6 198 198 CD 42759 5887 7 , , , 42759 5887 8 214 214 CD 42759 5887 9 , , , 42759 5887 10 282 282 CD 42759 5887 11 , , , 42759 5887 12 289 289 CD 42759 5887 13 , , , 42759 5887 14 290 290 CD 42759 5887 15 ; ; : 42759 5887 16 on on IN 42759 5887 17 minimum minimum NN 42759 5887 18 wage wage NN 42759 5887 19 , , , 42759 5887 20 412 412 CD 42759 5887 21 - - SYM 42759 5887 22 416 416 CD 42759 5887 23 . . . 42759 5888 1 Tawney Tawney NNP 42759 5888 2 , , , 42759 5888 3 R. R. NNP 42759 5888 4 H. H. NNP 42759 5888 5 : : : 42759 5888 6 421 421 CD 42759 5888 7 . . . 42759 5889 1 Taxation taxation NN 42759 5889 2 : : : 42759 5889 3 as as IN 42759 5889 4 a a DT 42759 5889 5 social social JJ 42759 5889 6 instrument instrument NN 42759 5889 7 , , , 42759 5889 8 101 101 CD 42759 5889 9 , , , 42759 5889 10 102 102 CD 42759 5889 11 ; ; : 42759 5889 12 of of IN 42759 5889 13 increases increase NNS 42759 5889 14 in in IN 42759 5889 15 land land NN 42759 5889 16 value value NN 42759 5889 17 , , , 42759 5889 18 102 102 CD 42759 5889 19 - - SYM 42759 5889 20 117 117 CD 42759 5889 21 ; ; : 42759 5889 22 faculty faculty NN 42759 5889 23 theory theory NN 42759 5889 24 of of IN 42759 5889 25 , , , 42759 5889 26 107 107 CD 42759 5889 27 , , , 42759 5889 28 108 108 CD 42759 5889 29 ; ; : 42759 5889 30 progressive progressive JJ 42759 5889 31 , , , 42759 5889 32 as as IN 42759 5889 33 a a DT 42759 5889 34 method method NN 42759 5889 35 of of IN 42759 5889 36 limiting limit VBG 42759 5889 37 fortunes fortune NNS 42759 5889 38 , , , 42759 5889 39 296 296 CD 42759 5889 40 - - SYM 42759 5889 41 302 302 CD 42759 5889 42 . . . 42759 5890 1 Taxes taxis NNS 42759 5890 2 : : : 42759 5890 3 shifting shift VBG 42759 5890 4 of of IN 42759 5890 5 to to IN 42759 5890 6 land land NN 42759 5890 7 , , , 42759 5890 8 117 117 CD 42759 5890 9 - - SYM 42759 5890 10 130 130 CD 42759 5890 11 ; ; : 42759 5890 12 social social JJ 42759 5890 13 benefits benefit NNS 42759 5890 14 of of IN 42759 5890 15 , , , 42759 5890 16 127 127 CD 42759 5890 17 - - SYM 42759 5890 18 130 130 CD 42759 5890 19 . . . 42759 5891 1 Tenant tenant NN 42759 5891 2 : : : 42759 5891 3 claim claim NN 42759 5891 4 of of IN 42759 5891 5 to to TO 42759 5891 6 rent rent VB 42759 5891 7 , , , 42759 5891 8 69 69 CD 42759 5891 9 - - SYM 42759 5891 10 71 71 CD 42759 5891 11 . . . 42759 5892 1 Theologians theologian NNS 42759 5892 2 : : : 42759 5892 3 on on IN 42759 5892 4 private private JJ 42759 5892 5 landownership landownership NN 42759 5892 6 , , , 42759 5892 7 62 62 CD 42759 5892 8 - - SYM 42759 5892 9 64 64 CD 42759 5892 10 ; ; : 42759 5892 11 on on IN 42759 5892 12 interest interest NN 42759 5892 13 , , , 42759 5892 14 172 172 CD 42759 5892 15 - - SYM 42759 5892 16 176 176 CD 42759 5892 17 , , , 42759 5892 18 202 202 CD 42759 5892 19 - - SYM 42759 5892 20 204 204 CD 42759 5892 21 ; ; : 42759 5892 22 on on IN 42759 5892 23 civil civil JJ 42759 5892 24 creation creation NN 42759 5892 25 of of IN 42759 5892 26 property property NN 42759 5892 27 rights right NNS 42759 5892 28 , , , 42759 5892 29 202 202 CD 42759 5892 30 ; ; , 42759 5892 31 on on IN 42759 5892 32 duty duty NN 42759 5892 33 of of IN 42759 5892 34 benevolent benevolent JJ 42759 5892 35 distribution distribution NN 42759 5892 36 , , , 42759 5892 37 308 308 CD 42759 5892 38 , , , 42759 5892 39 309 309 CD 42759 5892 40 . . . 42759 5893 1 Thompson Thompson NNP 42759 5893 2 , , , 42759 5893 3 W. W. NNP 42759 5893 4 : : : 42759 5893 5 341 341 CD 42759 5893 6 . . . 42759 5894 1 Undertaker undertaker NN 42759 5894 2 : : : 42759 5894 3 See See NNP 42759 5894 4 Business Business NNP 42759 5894 5 man man NN 42759 5894 6 . . . 42759 5895 1 United United NNP 42759 5895 2 States States NNP 42759 5895 3 : : : 42759 5895 4 special special JJ 42759 5895 5 land land NN 42759 5895 6 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5895 7 in in RP 42759 5895 8 , , , 42759 5895 9 119 119 CD 42759 5895 10 ; ; : 42759 5895 11 co co NN 42759 5895 12 - - NN 42759 5895 13 operation operation NN 42759 5895 14 in in IN 42759 5895 15 , , , 42759 5895 16 218 218 CD 42759 5895 17 , , , 42759 5895 18 263 263 CD 42759 5895 19 ; ; : 42759 5895 20 minimum minimum JJ 42759 5895 21 wage wage NN 42759 5895 22 in in IN 42759 5895 23 , , , 42759 5895 24 401 401 CD 42759 5895 25 , , , 42759 5895 26 403 403 CD 42759 5895 27 - - SYM 42759 5895 28 407 407 CD 42759 5895 29 . . . 42759 5896 1 United United NNP 42759 5896 2 States States NNP 42759 5896 3 Commissioner Commissioner NNP 42759 5896 4 of of IN 42759 5896 5 Corporations Corporations NNPS 42759 5896 6 , , , 42759 5896 7 reports report NNS 42759 5896 8 of of IN 42759 5896 9 : : : 42759 5896 10 on on IN 42759 5896 11 Standard Standard NNP 42759 5896 12 Oil Oil NNP 42759 5896 13 Company Company NNP 42759 5896 14 , , , 42759 5896 15 76 76 CD 42759 5896 16 , , , 42759 5896 17 263 263 CD 42759 5896 18 , , , 42759 5896 19 267 267 CD 42759 5896 20 , , , 42759 5896 21 268 268 CD 42759 5896 22 , , , 42759 5896 23 272 272 CD 42759 5896 24 ; ; : 42759 5896 25 on on IN 42759 5896 26 Steel Steel NNP 42759 5896 27 Corporation Corporation NNP 42759 5896 28 , , , 42759 5896 29 79 79 CD 42759 5896 30 , , , 42759 5896 31 89 89 CD 42759 5896 32 , , , 42759 5896 33 263 263 CD 42759 5896 34 , , , 42759 5896 35 267 267 CD 42759 5896 36 , , , 42759 5896 37 285 285 CD 42759 5896 38 ; ; : 42759 5896 39 on on IN 42759 5896 40 water water NN 42759 5896 41 power power NN 42759 5896 42 ownership ownership NN 42759 5896 43 , , , 42759 5896 44 79 79 CD 42759 5896 45 , , , 42759 5896 46 95 95 CD 42759 5896 47 ; ; : 42759 5896 48 on on IN 42759 5896 49 the the DT 42759 5896 50 lumber lumber NN 42759 5896 51 industry industry NN 42759 5896 52 , , , 42759 5896 53 85 85 CD 42759 5896 54 , , , 42759 5896 55 89 89 CD 42759 5896 56 , , , 42759 5896 57 94 94 CD 42759 5896 58 , , , 42759 5896 59 132 132 CD 42759 5896 60 ; ; : 42759 5896 61 on on IN 42759 5896 62 American American NNP 42759 5896 63 Tobacco Tobacco NNP 42759 5896 64 Company Company NNP 42759 5896 65 , , , 42759 5896 66 263 263 CD 42759 5896 67 , , , 42759 5896 68 267 267 CD 42759 5896 69 , , , 42759 5896 70 288 288 CD 42759 5896 71 ; ; : 42759 5896 72 on on IN 42759 5896 73 American American NNP 42759 5896 74 Sugar Sugar NNP 42759 5896 75 Refining Refining NNP 42759 5896 76 Company Company NNP 42759 5896 77 , , , 42759 5896 78 267 267 CD 42759 5896 79 , , , 42759 5896 80 272 272 CD 42759 5896 81 , , , 42759 5896 82 289 289 CD 42759 5896 83 . . . 42759 5897 1 United United NNP 42759 5897 2 States States NNP 42759 5897 3 Shipbuilding Shipbuilding NNP 42759 5897 4 Company Company NNP 42759 5897 5 : : : 42759 5897 6 288 288 CD 42759 5897 7 , , , 42759 5897 8 289 289 CD 42759 5897 9 . . . 42759 5898 1 United United NNP 42759 5898 2 States States NNP 42759 5898 3 Steel Steel NNP 42759 5898 4 Corporation Corporation NNP 42759 5898 5 : : : 42759 5898 6 79 79 CD 42759 5898 7 , , , 42759 5898 8 89 89 CD 42759 5898 9 , , , 42759 5898 10 267 267 CD 42759 5898 11 , , , 42759 5898 12 285 285 CD 42759 5898 13 , , , 42759 5898 14 289 289 CD 42759 5898 15 . . . 42759 5899 1 Use use NN 42759 5899 2 : : : 42759 5899 3 right right UH 42759 5899 4 , , , 42759 5899 5 as as IN 42759 5899 6 a a DT 42759 5899 7 confirmatory confirmatory JJ 42759 5899 8 justification justification NN 42759 5899 9 of of IN 42759 5899 10 interest interest NN 42759 5899 11 taking taking NN 42759 5899 12 , , , 42759 5899 13 206 206 CD 42759 5899 14 - - SYM 42759 5899 15 208 208 CD 42759 5899 16 . . . 42759 5900 1 Value value NN 42759 5900 2 : : : 42759 5900 3 Marxian marxian JJ 42759 5900 4 theory theory NN 42759 5900 5 of of IN 42759 5900 6 , , , 42759 5900 7 145 145 CD 42759 5900 8 - - SYM 42759 5900 9 148 148 CD 42759 5900 10 , , , 42759 5900 11 333 333 CD 42759 5900 12 , , , 42759 5900 13 343 343 CD 42759 5900 14 , , , 42759 5900 15 344 344 CD 42759 5900 16 ; ; : 42759 5900 17 relation relation NN 42759 5900 18 of of IN 42759 5900 19 to to TO 42759 5900 20 wage wage VB 42759 5900 21 justice justice NN 42759 5900 22 , , , 42759 5900 23 330 330 CD 42759 5900 24 - - SYM 42759 5900 25 340 340 CD 42759 5900 26 ; ; : 42759 5900 27 and and CC 42759 5900 28 to to IN 42759 5900 29 a a DT 42759 5900 30 living living NN 42759 5900 31 wage wage NN 42759 5900 32 , , , 42759 5900 33 370 370 CD 42759 5900 34 , , , 42759 5900 35 375 375 CD 42759 5900 36 . . . 42759 5901 1 Van Van NNP 42759 5901 2 Hise Hise NNP 42759 5901 3 , , , 42759 5901 4 C. C. NNP 42759 5901 5 R. R. NNP 42759 5901 6 : : : 42759 5901 7 266 266 CD 42759 5901 8 , , , 42759 5901 9 267 267 CD 42759 5901 10 , , , 42759 5901 11 277 277 CD 42759 5901 12 , , , 42759 5901 13 278 278 CD 42759 5901 14 , , , 42759 5901 15 288 288 CD 42759 5901 16 . . . 42759 5902 1 Wage wage NN 42759 5902 2 justice justice NN 42759 5902 3 : : : 42759 5902 4 unacceptable unacceptable JJ 42759 5902 5 theories theory NNS 42759 5902 6 of of IN 42759 5902 7 , , , 42759 5902 8 323 323 CD 42759 5902 9 - - SYM 42759 5902 10 355 355 CD 42759 5902 11 ; ; : 42759 5902 12 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 5902 13 rate rate NN 42759 5902 14 theory theory NN 42759 5902 15 , , , 42759 5902 16 323 323 CD 42759 5902 17 - - SYM 42759 5902 18 325 325 CD 42759 5902 19 ; ; : 42759 5902 20 exchange exchange NN 42759 5902 21 equivalence equivalence NN 42759 5902 22 theory theory NN 42759 5902 23 , , , 42759 5902 24 326 326 CD 42759 5902 25 - - SYM 42759 5902 26 340 340 CD 42759 5902 27 ; ; : 42759 5902 28 productivity productivity NN 42759 5902 29 theories theory NNS 42759 5902 30 , , , 42759 5902 31 341 341 CD 42759 5902 32 - - SYM 42759 5902 33 355 355 CD 42759 5902 34 ; ; : 42759 5902 35 the the DT 42759 5902 36 minimum minimum NN 42759 5902 37 of of IN 42759 5902 38 , , , 42759 5902 39 356 356 CD 42759 5902 40 - - SYM 42759 5902 41 380 380 CD 42759 5902 42 ; ; : 42759 5902 43 problem problem NN 42759 5902 44 of of IN 42759 5902 45 complete complete JJ 42759 5902 46 , , , 42759 5902 47 381 381 CD 42759 5902 48 - - SYM 42759 5902 49 399 399 CD 42759 5902 50 ; ; : 42759 5902 51 claims claim NNS 42759 5902 52 of of IN 42759 5902 53 different different JJ 42759 5902 54 labour labour JJ 42759 5902 55 groups group NNS 42759 5902 56 , , , 42759 5902 57 381 381 CD 42759 5902 58 - - SYM 42759 5902 59 387 387 CD 42759 5902 60 ; ; : 42759 5902 61 wages wage NNS 42759 5902 62 versus versus IN 42759 5902 63 profits profit NNS 42759 5902 64 , , , 42759 5902 65 388 388 CD 42759 5902 66 - - SYM 42759 5902 67 390 390 CD 42759 5902 68 ; ; : 42759 5902 69 wages wage NNS 42759 5902 70 versus versus IN 42759 5902 71 interest interest NN 42759 5902 72 , , , 42759 5902 73 390 390 CD 42759 5902 74 - - HYPH 42759 5902 75 393 393 CD 42759 5902 76 ; ; , 42759 5902 77 wages wage NNS 42759 5902 78 versus versus IN 42759 5902 79 prices price NNS 42759 5902 80 , , , 42759 5902 81 393 393 CD 42759 5902 82 - - SYM 42759 5902 83 399 399 CD 42759 5902 84 . . . 42759 5903 1 Wages wage NNS 42759 5903 2 : : : 42759 5903 3 versus versus IN 42759 5903 4 profits profit NNS 42759 5903 5 , , , 42759 5903 6 388 388 CD 42759 5903 7 - - SYM 42759 5903 8 390 390 CD 42759 5903 9 ; ; : 42759 5903 10 " " `` 42759 5903 11 equitable equitable JJ 42759 5903 12 minimum minimum NN 42759 5903 13 " " '' 42759 5903 14 of of IN 42759 5903 15 , , , 42759 5903 16 388 388 CD 42759 5903 17 ; ; : 42759 5903 18 versus versus IN 42759 5903 19 interest interest NN 42759 5903 20 , , , 42759 5903 21 390 390 CD 42759 5903 22 - - SYM 42759 5903 23 393 393 CD 42759 5903 24 ; ; : 42759 5903 25 versus versus IN 42759 5903 26 prices price NNS 42759 5903 27 , , , 42759 5903 28 393 393 CD 42759 5903 29 - - SYM 42759 5903 30 399 399 CD 42759 5903 31 ; ; : 42759 5903 32 methods method NNS 42759 5903 33 of of IN 42759 5903 34 increasing increase VBG 42759 5903 35 , , , 42759 5903 36 400 400 CD 42759 5903 37 - - SYM 42759 5903 38 425 425 CD 42759 5903 39 ; ; : 42759 5903 40 legal legal JJ 42759 5903 41 minimum minimum NN 42759 5903 42 , , , 42759 5903 43 400 400 CD 42759 5903 44 - - SYM 42759 5903 45 416 416 CD 42759 5903 46 ; ; : 42759 5903 47 other other JJ 42759 5903 48 legislation legislation NN 42759 5903 49 for for IN 42759 5903 50 , , , 42759 5903 51 416 416 CD 42759 5903 52 , , , 42759 5903 53 417 417 CD 42759 5903 54 ; ; : 42759 5903 55 labour labour NN 42759 5903 56 unions union NNS 42759 5903 57 , , , 42759 5903 58 417 417 CD 42759 5903 59 - - SYM 42759 5903 60 423 423 CD 42759 5903 61 ; ; : 42759 5903 62 co co JJ 42759 5903 63 - - JJ 42759 5903 64 operative operative JJ 42759 5903 65 enterprise enterprise NN 42759 5903 66 , , , 42759 5903 67 423 423 CD 42759 5903 68 - - SYM 42759 5903 69 425 425 CD 42759 5903 70 . . . 42759 5904 1 Wagner Wagner NNP 42759 5904 2 , , , 42759 5904 3 A. a. NN 42759 5904 4 : : : 42759 5904 5 342 342 CD 42759 5904 6 . . . 42759 5905 1 Watered water VBN 42759 5905 2 stock stock NN 42759 5905 3 : : : 42759 5905 4 279 279 CD 42759 5905 5 - - SYM 42759 5905 6 290 290 CD 42759 5905 7 . . . 42759 5906 1 See see VB 42759 5906 2 Stockwatering stockwatering NN 42759 5906 3 . . . 42759 5907 1 Water water NN 42759 5907 2 power power NN 42759 5907 3 : : : 42759 5907 4 in in IN 42759 5907 5 the the DT 42759 5907 6 United United NNP 42759 5907 7 States States NNP 42759 5907 8 , , , 42759 5907 9 79 79 CD 42759 5907 10 , , , 42759 5907 11 95 95 CD 42759 5907 12 . . . 42759 5908 1 Wealth wealth NN 42759 5908 2 , , , 42759 5908 3 superfluous superfluous JJ 42759 5908 4 : : : 42759 5908 5 duty duty NN 42759 5908 6 of of IN 42759 5908 7 distributing distribute VBG 42759 5908 8 , , , 42759 5908 9 303 303 CD 42759 5908 10 - - SYM 42759 5908 11 319 319 CD 42759 5908 12 ; ; : 42759 5908 13 as as IN 42759 5908 14 regards regard VBZ 42759 5908 15 a a DT 42759 5908 16 part part NN 42759 5908 17 , , , 42759 5908 18 303 303 CD 42759 5908 19 - - SYM 42759 5908 20 307 307 CD 42759 5908 21 ; ; : 42759 5908 22 as as IN 42759 5908 23 regards regard VBZ 42759 5908 24 the the DT 42759 5908 25 whole whole JJ 42759 5908 26 , , , 42759 5908 27 308 308 CD 42759 5908 28 - - SYM 42759 5908 29 314 314 CD 42759 5908 30 ; ; : 42759 5908 31 a a DT 42759 5908 32 duty duty NN 42759 5908 33 of of IN 42759 5908 34 charity charity NN 42759 5908 35 or or CC 42759 5908 36 of of IN 42759 5908 37 justice justice NN 42759 5908 38 , , , 42759 5908 39 305 305 CD 42759 5908 40 - - SYM 42759 5908 41 307 307 CD 42759 5908 42 ; ; : 42759 5908 43 the the DT 42759 5908 44 supply supply NN 42759 5908 45 of of IN 42759 5908 46 capital capital NN 42759 5908 47 and and CC 42759 5908 48 business business NN 42759 5908 49 ability ability NN 42759 5908 50 , , , 42759 5908 51 311 311 CD 42759 5908 52 - - SYM 42759 5908 53 313 313 CD 42759 5908 54 ; ; : 42759 5908 55 false false JJ 42759 5908 56 and and CC 42759 5908 57 true true JJ 42759 5908 58 conceptions conception NNS 42759 5908 59 of of IN 42759 5908 60 , , , 42759 5908 61 314 314 CD 42759 5908 62 - - SYM 42759 5908 63 316 316 CD 42759 5908 64 . . . 42759 5909 1 Welfare welfare NN 42759 5909 2 : : : 42759 5909 3 a a DT 42759 5909 4 false false JJ 42759 5909 5 conception conception NN 42759 5909 6 of of IN 42759 5909 7 , , , 42759 5909 8 314 314 CD 42759 5909 9 - - SYM 42759 5909 10 316 316 CD 42759 5909 11 ; ; : 42759 5909 12 true true JJ 42759 5909 13 conception conception NN 42759 5909 14 of of IN 42759 5909 15 , , , 42759 5909 16 316 316 CD 42759 5909 17 - - SYM 42759 5909 18 318 318 CD 42759 5909 19 ; ; : 42759 5909 20 social social JJ 42759 5909 21 , , , 42759 5909 22 demands demand VBZ 42759 5909 23 a a DT 42759 5909 24 living living NN 42759 5909 25 wage wage NN 42759 5909 26 for for IN 42759 5909 27 all all DT 42759 5909 28 , , , 42759 5909 29 376 376 CD 42759 5909 30 , , , 42759 5909 31 377 377 CD 42759 5909 32 . . . 42759 5910 1 See see VB 42759 5910 2 Human human JJ 42759 5910 3 welfare welfare NN 42759 5910 4 . . . 42759 5911 1 Whittaker Whittaker NNP 42759 5911 2 , , , 42759 5911 3 Sir Sir NNP 42759 5911 4 Thomas Thomas NNP 42759 5911 5 : : : 42759 5911 6 10 10 CD 42759 5911 7 , , , 42759 5911 8 14 14 CD 42759 5911 9 , , , 42759 5911 10 28 28 CD 42759 5911 11 . . . 42759 5912 1 Wicker Wicker NNP 42759 5912 2 , , , 42759 5912 3 G. G. NNP 42759 5912 4 R. R. NNP 42759 5912 5 : : : 42759 5912 6 350 350 CD 42759 5912 7 , , , 42759 5912 8 351 351 CD 42759 5912 9 . . . 42759 5913 1 Williams Williams NNP 42759 5913 2 , , , 42759 5913 3 A. a. NN 42759 5913 4 : : : 42759 5913 5 232 232 CD 42759 5913 6 . . . 42759 5914 1 Wolman Wolman NNP 42759 5914 2 , , , 42759 5914 3 L. L. NNP 42759 5914 4 : : : 42759 5914 5 417 417 CD 42759 5914 6 , , , 42759 5914 7 418 418 CD 42759 5914 8 . . . 42759 5915 1 Women woman NNS 42759 5915 2 : : : 42759 5915 3 right right RB 42759 5915 4 of of IN 42759 5915 5 to to IN 42759 5915 6 a a DT 42759 5915 7 living living NN 42759 5915 8 wage wage NN 42759 5915 9 , , , 42759 5915 10 373 373 CD 42759 5915 11 . . . 42759 5916 1 PRINTED PRINTED NNP 42759 5916 2 IN in IN 42759 5916 3 THE the DT 42759 5916 4 UNITED UNITED NNP 42759 5916 5 STATES state NNS 42759 5916 6 OF of IN 42759 5916 7 AMERICA AMERICA NNP 42759 5916 8 * * NFP 42759 5916 9 * * NFP 42759 5916 10 * * NFP 42759 5916 11 * * NFP 42759 5916 12 * * NFP 42759 5916 13 The the DT 42759 5916 14 following follow VBG 42759 5916 15 pages page NNS 42759 5916 16 contain contain VBP 42759 5916 17 advertisements advertisement NNS 42759 5916 18 of of IN 42759 5916 19 books book NNS 42759 5916 20 by by IN 42759 5916 21 the the DT 42759 5916 22 same same JJ 42759 5916 23 author author NN 42759 5916 24 or or CC 42759 5916 25 on on IN 42759 5916 26 kindred kindred JJ 42759 5916 27 subjects subject NNS 42759 5916 28 . . . 42759 5917 1 * * NFP 42759 5917 2 * * NFP 42759 5917 3 * * NFP 42759 5917 4 * * NFP 42759 5917 5 * * NFP 42759 5917 6 Socialism socialism NN 42759 5917 7 : : : 42759 5917 8 Promise promise NN 42759 5917 9 or or CC 42759 5917 10 Menace menace NN 42759 5917 11 BY by IN 42759 5917 12 MORRIS MORRIS NNP 42759 5917 13 HILLQUIT HILLQUIT NNP 42759 5917 14 and and CC 42759 5917 15 JOHN JOHN NNP 42759 5917 16 A. a. NN 42759 5917 17 RYAN RYAN NNP 42759 5917 18 , , , 42759 5917 19 D.D. D.D. NNP 42759 5918 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5918 2 270 270 CD 42759 5918 3 pp pp NNP 42759 5918 4 . . NNP 42759 5918 5 , , , 42759 5918 6 12mo 12mo JJ 42759 5918 7 , , , 42759 5918 8 $ $ $ 42759 5918 9 1.25 1.25 CD 42759 5918 10 _ _ NNP 42759 5918 11 A a DT 42759 5918 12 debate debate NN 42759 5918 13 on on IN 42759 5918 14 the the DT 42759 5918 15 right right NN 42759 5918 16 or or CC 42759 5918 17 wrong wrong NN 42759 5918 18 of of IN 42759 5918 19 the the DT 42759 5918 20 movement movement NN 42759 5918 21 in in IN 42759 5918 22 which which WDT 42759 5918 23 opposing oppose VBG 42759 5918 24 arguments argument NNS 42759 5918 25 are be VBP 42759 5918 26 presented present VBN 42759 5918 27 dealing deal VBG 42759 5918 28 with with IN 42759 5918 29 various various JJ 42759 5918 30 phases phase NNS 42759 5918 31 of of IN 42759 5918 32 the the DT 42759 5918 33 subject subject NN 42759 5918 34 . . . 42759 5919 1 The the DT 42759 5919 2 attack attack NN 42759 5919 3 is be VBZ 42759 5919 4 made make VBN 42759 5919 5 by by IN 42759 5919 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 42759 5919 7 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 5919 8 , , , 42759 5919 9 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5919 10 of of IN 42759 5919 11 Moral Moral NNP 42759 5919 12 Theology Theology NNP 42759 5919 13 and and CC 42759 5919 14 Economics Economics NNP 42759 5919 15 in in IN 42759 5919 16 St. St. NNP 42759 5919 17 Paul Paul NNP 42759 5919 18 Seminary Seminary NNP 42759 5919 19 and and CC 42759 5919 20 author author NN 42759 5919 21 of of IN 42759 5919 22 _ _ NNP 42759 5919 23 A A NNP 42759 5919 24 Living Living NNP 42759 5919 25 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5919 26 _ _ NNP 42759 5919 27 . . . 42759 5920 1 The the DT 42759 5920 2 defender defender NN 42759 5920 3 , , , 42759 5920 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 42759 5920 5 Hillquit Hillquit NNP 42759 5920 6 , , , 42759 5920 7 is be VBZ 42759 5920 8 a a DT 42759 5920 9 practising practise VBG 42759 5920 10 lawyer lawyer NN 42759 5920 11 and and CC 42759 5920 12 has have VBZ 42759 5920 13 been be VBN 42759 5920 14 a a DT 42759 5920 15 delegate delegate NN 42759 5920 16 to to IN 42759 5920 17 national national JJ 42759 5920 18 and and CC 42759 5920 19 international international JJ 42759 5920 20 socialist socialist JJ 42759 5920 21 conferences conference NNS 42759 5920 22 for for IN 42759 5920 23 several several JJ 42759 5920 24 years year NNS 42759 5920 25 . . . 42759 5921 1 " " `` 42759 5921 2 One one CD 42759 5921 3 of of IN 42759 5921 4 the the DT 42759 5921 5 most most RBS 42759 5921 6 important important JJ 42759 5921 7 books book NNS 42759 5921 8 ever ever RB 42759 5921 9 published publish VBN 42759 5921 10 , , , 42759 5921 11 bearing bear VBG 42759 5921 12 on on IN 42759 5921 13 the the DT 42759 5921 14 issue issue NN 42759 5921 15 of of IN 42759 5921 16 Socialism socialism NN 42759 5921 17 . . . 42759 5921 18 " " '' 42759 5922 1 --_Ohio --_Ohio : 42759 5922 2 State State NNP 42759 5922 3 Journal Journal NNP 42759 5922 4 . . . 42759 5922 5 _ _ NNP 42759 5922 6 " " `` 42759 5922 7 Many many JJ 42759 5922 8 books book NNS 42759 5922 9 have have VBP 42759 5922 10 been be VBN 42759 5922 11 written write VBN 42759 5922 12 on on IN 42759 5922 13 the the DT 42759 5922 14 subject subject NN 42759 5922 15 , , , 42759 5922 16 but but CC 42759 5922 17 no no DT 42759 5922 18 better well JJR 42759 5922 19 presentation presentation NN 42759 5922 20 of of IN 42759 5922 21 both both DT 42759 5922 22 sides side NNS 42759 5922 23 in in IN 42759 5922 24 one one CD 42759 5922 25 volume volume NN 42759 5922 26 can can MD 42759 5922 27 be be VB 42759 5922 28 found find VBN 42759 5922 29 than than IN 42759 5922 30 in in IN 42759 5922 31 _ _ NNP 42759 5922 32 Socialism Socialism NNP 42759 5922 33 , , , 42759 5922 34 Promise Promise NNP 42759 5922 35 or or CC 42759 5922 36 Menace Menace NNP 42759 5922 37 _ _ NNP 42759 5922 38 .... .... . 42759 5923 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5923 2 is be VBZ 42759 5923 3 a a DT 42759 5923 4 fine fine JJ 42759 5923 5 , , , 42759 5923 6 fair fair JJ 42759 5923 7 and and CC 42759 5923 8 square square JJ 42759 5923 9 discussion discussion NN 42759 5923 10 . . . 42759 5923 11 " " '' 42759 5924 1 --_Congregationalist --_Congregationalist : 42759 5924 2 . . . 42759 5924 3 _ _ NNP 42759 5924 4 " " `` 42759 5924 5 Nowhere nowhere RB 42759 5924 6 else else RB 42759 5924 7 within within IN 42759 5924 8 the the DT 42759 5924 9 covers cover NNS 42759 5924 10 of of IN 42759 5924 11 a a DT 42759 5924 12 single single JJ 42759 5924 13 volume volume NN 42759 5924 14 can can MD 42759 5924 15 be be VB 42759 5924 16 found find VBN 42759 5924 17 such such PDT 42759 5924 18 a a DT 42759 5924 19 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 42759 5924 20 presentation presentation NN 42759 5924 21 of of IN 42759 5924 22 the the DT 42759 5924 23 leading lead VBG 42759 5924 24 arguments argument NNS 42759 5924 25 and and CC 42759 5924 26 counter counter NNS 42759 5924 27 - - NNS 42759 5924 28 arguments argument NNS 42759 5924 29 on on IN 42759 5924 30 a a DT 42759 5924 31 great great JJ 42759 5924 32 question question NN 42759 5924 33 , , , 42759 5924 34 for for IN 42759 5924 35 each each DT 42759 5924 36 debater debater NN 42759 5924 37 is be VBZ 42759 5924 38 amply amply RB 42759 5924 39 qualified qualified JJ 42759 5924 40 to to TO 42759 5924 41 present present VB 42759 5924 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5924 43 case case NN 42759 5924 44 . . . 42759 5924 45 " " '' 42759 5925 1 --Boston --Boston : 42759 5925 2 _ _ NNP 42759 5925 3 Globe Globe NNP 42759 5925 4 _ _ NNP 42759 5925 5 . . . 42759 5926 1 * * NFP 42759 5926 2 * * NFP 42759 5926 3 * * NFP 42759 5926 4 * * NFP 42759 5926 5 * * NFP 42759 5926 6 _ _ NNP 42759 5926 7 A a DT 42759 5926 8 Living Living NNP 42759 5926 9 Wage wage NN 42759 5926 10 , , , 42759 5926 11 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5926 12 Ethical Ethical NNP 42759 5926 13 and and CC 42759 5926 14 Economic Economic NNP 42759 5926 15 Aspects Aspects NNPS 42759 5926 16 _ _ XX 42759 5926 17 By by IN 42759 5926 18 JOHN JOHN NNP 42759 5926 19 A a DT 42759 5926 20 RYAN RYAN NNPS 42759 5926 21 , , , 42759 5926 22 S.T.L. S.T.L. NNP 42759 5927 1 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5927 2 of of IN 42759 5927 3 Ethics Ethics NNP 42759 5927 4 and and CC 42759 5927 5 Economics Economics NNP 42759 5927 6 in in IN 42759 5927 7 St. St. NNP 42759 5927 8 Paul Paul NNP 42759 5927 9 's 's POS 42759 5927 10 Seminary Seminary NNP 42759 5927 11 . . . 42759 5928 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5928 2 Cloth Cloth NNP 42759 5928 3 , , , 42759 5928 4 12mo 12mo JJ 42759 5928 5 , , , 42759 5928 6 $ $ $ 42759 5928 7 1.00 1.00 CD 42759 5928 8 ; ; : 42759 5928 9 Standard Standard NNP 42759 5928 10 Library Library NNP 42759 5928 11 Edition Edition NNP 42759 5928 12 , , , 42759 5928 13 $ $ $ 42759 5928 14 .50 .50 CD 42759 5928 15 _ _ NNP 42759 5928 16 " " `` 42759 5928 17 Father Father NNP 42759 5928 18 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 5928 19 's 's POS 42759 5928 20 work work NN 42759 5928 21 on on IN 42759 5928 22 the the DT 42759 5928 23 Living Living NNP 42759 5928 24 Wage wage NN 42759 5928 25 is be VBZ 42759 5928 26 perhaps perhaps RB 42759 5928 27 the the DT 42759 5928 28 best good JJS 42759 5928 29 exposition exposition NN 42759 5928 30 of of IN 42759 5928 31 the the DT 42759 5928 32 labor labor NN 42759 5928 33 phase phase NN 42759 5928 34 of of IN 42759 5928 35 the the DT 42759 5928 36 social social JJ 42759 5928 37 problem problem NN 42759 5928 38 . . . 42759 5929 1 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5929 2 has have VBZ 42759 5929 3 taken take VBN 42759 5929 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5929 5 place place NN 42759 5929 6 on on IN 42759 5929 7 the the DT 42759 5929 8 shelves shelf NNS 42759 5929 9 of of IN 42759 5929 10 public public JJ 42759 5929 11 and and CC 42759 5929 12 private private JJ 42759 5929 13 libraries library NNS 42759 5929 14 beside beside IN 42759 5929 15 other other JJ 42759 5929 16 standard standard JJ 42759 5929 17 works work NNS 42759 5929 18 , , , 42759 5929 19 while while IN 42759 5929 20 the the DT 42759 5929 21 name name NN 42759 5929 22 of of IN 42759 5929 23 the the DT 42759 5929 24 author author NN 42759 5929 25 is be VBZ 42759 5929 26 associated associate VBN 42759 5929 27 with with IN 42759 5929 28 the the DT 42759 5929 29 leading lead VBG 42759 5929 30 American american JJ 42759 5929 31 sociologists sociologist NNS 42759 5929 32 . . . 42759 5930 1 " " `` 42759 5930 2 The the DT 42759 5930 3 volume volume NN 42759 5930 4 is be VBZ 42759 5930 5 prefaced preface VBN 42759 5930 6 by by IN 42759 5930 7 an an DT 42759 5930 8 introduction introduction NN 42759 5930 9 by by IN 42759 5930 10 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5930 11 Richard Richard NNP 42759 5930 12 T. T. NNP 42759 5930 13 Ely Ely NNP 42759 5930 14 , , , 42759 5930 15 the the DT 42759 5930 16 noted note VBN 42759 5930 17 American american JJ 42759 5930 18 economist economist NN 42759 5930 19 . . . 42759 5931 1 As as IN 42759 5931 2 the the DT 42759 5931 3 title title NN 42759 5931 4 indicates indicate VBZ 42759 5931 5 , , , 42759 5931 6 the the DT 42759 5931 7 subject subject NN 42759 5931 8 is be VBZ 42759 5931 9 not not RB 42759 5931 10 merely merely RB 42759 5931 11 treated treat VBN 42759 5931 12 from from IN 42759 5931 13 an an DT 42759 5931 14 economic economic JJ 42759 5931 15 point point NN 42759 5931 16 of of IN 42759 5931 17 view view NN 42759 5931 18 , , , 42759 5931 19 but but CC 42759 5931 20 also also RB 42759 5931 21 in in IN 42759 5931 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5931 23 economic economic JJ 42759 5931 24 aspects aspect NNS 42759 5931 25 -- -- : 42759 5931 26 a a DT 42759 5931 27 course course NN 42759 5931 28 of of IN 42759 5931 29 procedure procedure NN 42759 5931 30 that that WDT 42759 5931 31 is be VBZ 42759 5931 32 somewhat somewhat RB 42759 5931 33 of of IN 42759 5931 34 a a DT 42759 5931 35 departure departure NN 42759 5931 36 from from IN 42759 5931 37 prevailing prevail VBG 42759 5931 38 discussions discussion NNS 42759 5931 39 of of IN 42759 5931 40 economic economic JJ 42759 5931 41 subjects subject NNS 42759 5931 42 . . . 42759 5932 1 There there EX 42759 5932 2 is be VBZ 42759 5932 3 a a DT 42759 5932 4 tendency tendency NN 42759 5932 5 to to TO 42759 5932 6 treat treat VB 42759 5932 7 political political JJ 42759 5932 8 economy economy NN 42759 5932 9 as as IN 42759 5932 10 a a DT 42759 5932 11 subject subject NN 42759 5932 12 related relate VBN 42759 5932 13 to to IN 42759 5932 14 mathematics mathematic NNS 42759 5932 15 . . . 42759 5933 1 Statistics statistic NNS 42759 5933 2 and and CC 42759 5933 3 axioms axiom NNS 42759 5933 4 are be VBP 42759 5933 5 the the DT 42759 5933 6 predominating predominate VBG 42759 5933 7 features feature NNS 42759 5933 8 . . . 42759 5934 1 However however RB 42759 5934 2 , , , 42759 5934 3 the the DT 42759 5934 4 science science NN 42759 5934 5 of of IN 42759 5934 6 political political JJ 42759 5934 7 economy economy NN 42759 5934 8 can can MD 42759 5934 9 not not RB 42759 5934 10 disregard disregard VB 42759 5934 11 the the DT 42759 5934 12 origin origin NN 42759 5934 13 and and CC 42759 5934 14 destiny destiny NN 42759 5934 15 of of IN 42759 5934 16 man man NN 42759 5934 17 . . . 42759 5935 1 " " `` 42759 5935 2 ' ' `` 42759 5935 3 The the DT 42759 5935 4 Living Living NNP 42759 5935 5 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5935 6 ' ' '' 42759 5935 7 is be VBZ 42759 5935 8 based base VBN 42759 5935 9 on on IN 42759 5935 10 the the DT 42759 5935 11 principles principle NNS 42759 5935 12 of of IN 42759 5935 13 Christian christian JJ 42759 5935 14 philosophy philosophy NN 42759 5935 15 . . . 42759 5936 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5936 2 logic logic NN 42759 5936 3 proceeds proceed VBZ 42759 5936 4 from from IN 42759 5936 5 the the DT 42759 5936 6 Christian christian JJ 42759 5936 7 conception conception NN 42759 5936 8 of of IN 42759 5936 9 the the DT 42759 5936 10 dignity dignity NN 42759 5936 11 of of IN 42759 5936 12 man man NN 42759 5936 13 . . . 42759 5937 1 Father Father NNP 42759 5937 2 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 5937 3 's 's POS 42759 5937 4 book book NN 42759 5937 5 is be VBZ 42759 5937 6 thus thus RB 42759 5937 7 a a DT 42759 5937 8 most most RBS 42759 5937 9 timely timely JJ 42759 5937 10 and and CC 42759 5937 11 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5937 12 contribution contribution NN 42759 5937 13 to to IN 42759 5937 14 sociological sociological JJ 42759 5937 15 literature literature NN 42759 5937 16 . . . 42759 5938 1 That that IN 42759 5938 2 ' ' `` 42759 5938 3 The the DT 42759 5938 4 Living Living NNP 42759 5938 5 Wage Wage NNP 42759 5938 6 ' ' '' 42759 5938 7 has have VBZ 42759 5938 8 met meet VBN 42759 5938 9 the the DT 42759 5938 10 popularity popularity NN 42759 5938 11 that that IN 42759 5938 12 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5938 13 has have VBZ 42759 5938 14 , , , 42759 5938 15 is be VBZ 42759 5938 16 evidence evidence NN 42759 5938 17 of of IN 42759 5938 18 the the DT 42759 5938 19 growing grow VBG 42759 5938 20 conviction conviction NN 42759 5938 21 that that IN 42759 5938 22 the the DT 42759 5938 23 social social JJ 42759 5938 24 problem problem NN 42759 5938 25 can can MD 42759 5938 26 not not RB 42759 5938 27 be be VB 42759 5938 28 solved solve VBN 42759 5938 29 except except IN 42759 5938 30 on on IN 42759 5938 31 Christian christian JJ 42759 5938 32 principles principle NNS 42759 5938 33 . . . 42759 5938 34 " " '' 42759 5939 1 --_Common --_Common NFP 42759 5939 2 Cause cause VBP 42759 5939 3 . . . 42759 5939 4 _ _ NNP 42759 5939 5 " " `` 42759 5939 6 It -PRON- PRP 42759 5939 7 is be VBZ 42759 5939 8 refreshing refreshing JJ 42759 5939 9 to to TO 42759 5939 10 pick pick VB 42759 5939 11 up up RP 42759 5939 12 a a DT 42759 5939 13 book book NN 42759 5939 14 by by IN 42759 5939 15 Dr. Dr. NNP 42759 5939 16 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 5939 17 , , , 42759 5939 18 who who WP 42759 5939 19 is be VBZ 42759 5939 20 always always RB 42759 5939 21 so so RB 42759 5939 22 sane sane JJ 42759 5939 23 and and CC 42759 5939 24 so so RB 42759 5939 25 convincing convincing JJ 42759 5939 26 . . . 42759 5939 27 " " '' 42759 5940 1 --_North --_North : 42759 5940 2 Western Western NNP 42759 5940 3 Chronicle Chronicle NNP 42759 5940 4 . . . 42759 5940 5 _ _ NNP 42759 5940 6 " " `` 42759 5940 7 The the DT 42759 5940 8 book book NN 42759 5940 9 is be VBZ 42759 5940 10 considered consider VBN 42759 5940 11 the the DT 42759 5940 12 best good JJS 42759 5940 13 presentation presentation NN 42759 5940 14 of of IN 42759 5940 15 Catholic catholic JJ 42759 5940 16 economic economic JJ 42759 5940 17 thought thought NN 42759 5940 18 at at IN 42759 5940 19 the the DT 42759 5940 20 disposal disposal NN 42759 5940 21 of of IN 42759 5940 22 the the DT 42759 5940 23 general general JJ 42759 5940 24 reader reader NN 42759 5940 25 . . . 42759 5940 26 " " '' 42759 5941 1 --_Albany --_Albany : 42759 5941 2 Times Times NNP 42759 5941 3 - - HYPH 42759 5941 4 Union Union NNP 42759 5941 5 . . . 42759 5941 6 _ _ NNP 42759 5941 7 " " `` 42759 5941 8 That that IN 42759 5941 9 this this DT 42759 5941 10 economic economic JJ 42759 5941 11 study study NN 42759 5941 12 by by IN 42759 5941 13 Father Father NNP 42759 5941 14 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 5941 15 is be VBZ 42759 5941 16 a a DT 42759 5941 17 solid solid JJ 42759 5941 18 work work NN 42759 5941 19 is be VBZ 42759 5941 20 evidenced evidence VBN 42759 5941 21 by by IN 42759 5941 22 the the DT 42759 5941 23 fact fact NN 42759 5941 24 that that IN 42759 5941 25 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5941 26 was be VBD 42759 5941 27 first first RB 42759 5941 28 published publish VBN 42759 5941 29 in in IN 42759 5941 30 1906 1906 CD 42759 5941 31 , , , 42759 5941 32 and and CC 42759 5941 33 was be VBD 42759 5941 34 reprinted reprint VBN 42759 5941 35 in in IN 42759 5941 36 1908 1908 CD 42759 5941 37 , , , 42759 5941 38 1910 1910 CD 42759 5941 39 , , , 42759 5941 40 and and CC 42759 5941 41 1912 1912 CD 42759 5941 42 .... .... . 42759 5942 1 Instead instead RB 42759 5942 2 of of IN 42759 5942 3 appeals appeal NNS 42759 5942 4 to to IN 42759 5942 5 sentiment sentiment NN 42759 5942 6 or or CC 42759 5942 7 glittering glitter VBG 42759 5942 8 generalities generality NNS 42759 5942 9 , , , 42759 5942 10 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5942 11 Ryan Ryan NNP 42759 5942 12 offers offer VBZ 42759 5942 13 seasoned seasoned JJ 42759 5942 14 arguments argument NNS 42759 5942 15 and and CC 42759 5942 16 precise precise JJ 42759 5942 17 doctrine doctrine NN 42759 5942 18 . . . 42759 5942 19 " " '' 42759 5943 1 --_Portland --_Portland : 42759 5943 2 Evening Evening NNP 42759 5943 3 Telegram Telegram NNP 42759 5943 4 . . . 42759 5943 5 _ _ NNP 42759 5943 6 " " `` 42759 5943 7 The the DT 42759 5943 8 most most RBS 42759 5943 9 judicious judicious JJ 42759 5943 10 and and CC 42759 5943 11 balanced balanced JJ 42759 5943 12 discussion discussion NN 42759 5943 13 at at IN 42759 5943 14 the the DT 42759 5943 15 disposal disposal NN 42759 5943 16 of of IN 42759 5943 17 the the DT 42759 5943 18 general general JJ 42759 5943 19 reader reader NN 42759 5943 20 . . . 42759 5943 21 " " '' 42759 5944 1 --_World --_World : 42759 5944 2 To to NN 42759 5944 3 - - HYPH 42759 5944 4 day day NN 42759 5944 5 . . . 42759 5944 6 _ _ NNP 42759 5944 7 * * NFP 42759 5944 8 * * NFP 42759 5944 9 * * NFP 42759 5944 10 * * NFP 42759 5944 11 * * NFP 42759 5944 12 Property Property NNP 42759 5944 13 and and CC 42759 5944 14 Contract Contract NNP 42759 5944 15 in in IN 42759 5944 16 Their -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5944 17 Relations Relations NNPS 42759 5944 18 to to IN 42759 5944 19 the the DT 42759 5944 20 Distribution distribution NN 42759 5944 21 of of IN 42759 5944 22 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 5944 23 By by IN 42759 5944 24 RICHARD RICHARD NNP 42759 5944 25 T. T. NNP 42759 5944 26 ELY ELY NNP 42759 5944 27 , , , 42759 5944 28 Ph.D. ph.d. NN 42759 5944 29 , , , 42759 5944 30 LL.D. LL.D. NNP 42759 5945 1 Of of IN 42759 5945 2 the the DT 42759 5945 3 University University NNP 42759 5945 4 of of IN 42759 5945 5 Wisconsin Wisconsin NNP 42759 5945 6 , , , 42759 5945 7 Author author NN 42759 5945 8 of of IN 42759 5945 9 " " `` 42759 5945 10 Outlines Outlines NNPS 42759 5945 11 of of IN 42759 5945 12 Economics Economics NNP 42759 5945 13 , , , 42759 5945 14 " " '' 42759 5945 15 Editor Editor NNP 42759 5945 16 of of IN 42759 5945 17 the the DT 42759 5945 18 " " `` 42759 5945 19 Citizens Citizens NNPS 42759 5945 20 ' ' POS 42759 5945 21 Library library NN 42759 5945 22 , , , 42759 5945 23 " " '' 42759 5945 24 etc etc FW 42759 5945 25 . . . 42759 5946 1 _ _ NNP 42759 5946 2 In in IN 42759 5946 3 two two CD 42759 5946 4 volumes volume NNS 42759 5946 5 , , , 42759 5946 6 $ $ $ 42759 5946 7 4.00 4.00 CD 42759 5946 8 . . . 42759 5947 1 Special Special NNP 42759 5947 2 Law Law NNP 42759 5947 3 Library Library NNP 42759 5947 4 Edition Edition NNP 42759 5947 5 , , , 42759 5947 6 Sheep Sheep NNP 42759 5947 7 , , , 42759 5947 8 8vo 8vo NN 42759 5947 9 , , , 42759 5947 10 $ $ $ 42759 5947 11 7.50 7.50 CD 42759 5947 12 _ _ IN 42759 5947 13 In in IN 42759 5947 14 this this DT 42759 5947 15 work work NN 42759 5947 16 , , , 42759 5947 17 which which WDT 42759 5947 18 is be VBZ 42759 5947 19 based base VBN 42759 5947 20 upon upon IN 42759 5947 21 legal legal JJ 42759 5947 22 decisions decision NNS 42759 5947 23 as as RB 42759 5947 24 well well RB 42759 5947 25 as as IN 42759 5947 26 upon upon IN 42759 5947 27 economic economic JJ 42759 5947 28 principles principle NNS 42759 5947 29 , , , 42759 5947 30 a a DT 42759 5947 31 leading lead VBG 42759 5947 32 authority authority NN 42759 5947 33 on on IN 42759 5947 34 political political JJ 42759 5947 35 economy economy NN 42759 5947 36 considers consider VBZ 42759 5947 37 simply simply RB 42759 5947 38 and and CC 42759 5947 39 concisely concisely RB 42759 5947 40 one one CD 42759 5947 41 of of IN 42759 5947 42 the the DT 42759 5947 43 greatest great JJS 42759 5947 44 problems problem NNS 42759 5947 45 now now RB 42759 5947 46 before before IN 42759 5947 47 the the DT 42759 5947 48 American american JJ 42759 5947 49 people people NNS 42759 5947 50 . . . 42759 5948 1 Much much JJ 42759 5948 2 has have VBZ 42759 5948 3 been be VBN 42759 5948 4 heard hear VBN 42759 5948 5 and and CC 42759 5948 6 written write VBN 42759 5948 7 of of IN 42759 5948 8 late late RB 42759 5948 9 about about IN 42759 5948 10 judicial judicial JJ 42759 5948 11 readjustment readjustment NN 42759 5948 12 and and CC 42759 5948 13 direct direct JJ 42759 5948 14 government government NN 42759 5948 15 , , , 42759 5948 16 but but CC 42759 5948 17 few few JJ 42759 5948 18 who who WP 42759 5948 19 have have VBP 42759 5948 20 discussed discuss VBN 42759 5948 21 the the DT 42759 5948 22 subject subject NN 42759 5948 23 have have VBP 42759 5948 24 seen see VBN 42759 5948 25 the the DT 42759 5948 26 heart heart NN 42759 5948 27 of of IN 42759 5948 28 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5948 29 as as RB 42759 5948 30 clearly clearly RB 42759 5948 31 as as IN 42759 5948 32 does do VBZ 42759 5948 33 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5948 34 Ely Ely NNP 42759 5948 35 . . . 42759 5949 1 Of of IN 42759 5949 2 special special JJ 42759 5949 3 importance importance NN 42759 5949 4 is be VBZ 42759 5949 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5949 6 treatment treatment NN 42759 5949 7 of of IN 42759 5949 8 the the DT 42759 5949 9 police police NN 42759 5949 10 power power NN 42759 5949 11 , , , 42759 5949 12 a a DT 42759 5949 13 burning burn VBG 42759 5949 14 question question NN 42759 5949 15 in in IN 42759 5949 16 American american JJ 42759 5949 17 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 42759 5949 18 . . . 42759 5950 1 An an DT 42759 5950 2 idea idea NN 42759 5950 3 of of IN 42759 5950 4 the the DT 42759 5950 5 scope scope NN 42759 5950 6 and and CC 42759 5950 7 comprehensiveness comprehensiveness NN 42759 5950 8 of of IN 42759 5950 9 the the DT 42759 5950 10 work work NN 42759 5950 11 may may MD 42759 5950 12 be be VB 42759 5950 13 gained gain VBN 42759 5950 14 from from IN 42759 5950 15 the the DT 42759 5950 16 following follow VBG 42759 5950 17 condensed condense VBN 42759 5950 18 table table NN 42759 5950 19 of of IN 42759 5950 20 contents content NNS 42759 5950 21 : : : 42759 5950 22 Introduction introduction NN 42759 5950 23 ; ; : 42759 5950 24 Book Book NNP 42759 5950 25 I -PRON- PRP 42759 5950 26 , , , 42759 5950 27 The the DT 42759 5950 28 Fundamentals fundamental NNS 42759 5950 29 in in IN 42759 5950 30 the the DT 42759 5950 31 Existing Existing NNP 42759 5950 32 Socio Socio NNP 42759 5950 33 - - HYPH 42759 5950 34 Economic Economic NNP 42759 5950 35 Order order NN 42759 5950 36 Treated treat VBN 42759 5950 37 from from IN 42759 5950 38 the the DT 42759 5950 39 Standpoint standpoint NN 42759 5950 40 of of IN 42759 5950 41 Distribution Distribution NNP 42759 5950 42 ; ; : 42759 5950 43 Part Part NNP 42759 5950 44 I I NNP 42759 5950 45 , , , 42759 5950 46 Property Property NNP 42759 5950 47 , , , 42759 5950 48 Public Public NNP 42759 5950 49 and and CC 42759 5950 50 Private private JJ 42759 5950 51 : : : 42759 5950 52 I -PRON- PRP 42759 5950 53 , , , 42759 5950 54 Property Property NNP 42759 5950 55 , , , 42759 5950 56 Public Public NNP 42759 5950 57 and and CC 42759 5950 58 Private Private NNP 42759 5950 59 , , , 42759 5950 60 The the DT 42759 5950 61 First First NNP 42759 5950 62 Fundamental Fundamental NNP 42759 5950 63 Institution Institution NNP 42759 5950 64 in in IN 42759 5950 65 the the DT 42759 5950 66 Distribution distribution NN 42759 5950 67 of of IN 42759 5950 68 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 5950 69 ; ; : 42759 5950 70 II II NNP 42759 5950 71 , , , 42759 5950 72 Illustrations illustration NNS 42759 5950 73 Showing show VBG 42759 5950 74 the the DT 42759 5950 75 Importance Importance NNP 42759 5950 76 of of IN 42759 5950 77 Property Property NNP 42759 5950 78 in in IN 42759 5950 79 Wealth Wealth NNP 42759 5950 80 Distribution distribution NN 42759 5950 81 ; ; : 42759 5950 82 III III NNP 42759 5950 83 , , , 42759 5950 84 Property Property NNP 42759 5950 85 Defined Defined NNP 42759 5950 86 and and CC 42759 5950 87 Described describe VBN 42759 5950 88 ; ; : 42759 5950 89 IV IV NNP 42759 5950 90 , , , 42759 5950 91 Property Property NNP 42759 5950 92 , , , 42759 5950 93 Possession Possession NNP 42759 5950 94 , , , 42759 5950 95 Estate Estate NNP 42759 5950 96 , , , 42759 5950 97 Resources Resources NNPS 42759 5950 98 ; ; : 42759 5950 99 V V NNP 42759 5950 100 , , , 42759 5950 101 The the DT 42759 5950 102 Attribute Attribute NNP 42759 5950 103 and and CC 42759 5950 104 Characteristic Characteristic NNP 42759 5950 105 of of IN 42759 5950 106 Property Property NNP 42759 5950 107 ; ; : 42759 5950 108 VI VI NNP 42759 5950 109 , , , 42759 5950 110 The the DT 42759 5950 111 Social Social NNP 42759 5950 112 Theory Theory NNP 42759 5950 113 of of IN 42759 5950 114 Private Private NNP 42759 5950 115 Property Property NNP 42759 5950 116 ; ; , 42759 5950 117 VII VII NNP 42759 5950 118 , , , 42759 5950 119 Property Property NNP 42759 5950 120 and and CC 42759 5950 121 the the DT 42759 5950 122 Police Police NNP 42759 5950 123 Power Power NNP 42759 5950 124 ; ; : 42759 5950 125 VIII viii NN 42759 5950 126 , , , 42759 5950 127 What what WP 42759 5950 128 May May MD 42759 5950 129 I -PRON- PRP 42759 5950 130 Own own VB 42759 5950 131 ? ? . 42759 5951 1 IX ix NN 42759 5951 2 , , , 42759 5951 3 The the DT 42759 5951 4 Conservative conservative JJ 42759 5951 5 Nature Nature NNP 42759 5951 6 of of IN 42759 5951 7 the the DT 42759 5951 8 Social Social NNP 42759 5951 9 Theory Theory NNP 42759 5951 10 of of IN 42759 5951 11 Property Property NNP 42759 5951 12 ; ; , 42759 5951 13 X X NNP 42759 5951 14 , , , 42759 5951 15 XI XI NNP 42759 5951 16 , , , 42759 5951 17 A a DT 42759 5951 18 Discussion Discussion NNP 42759 5951 19 of of IN 42759 5951 20 the the DT 42759 5951 21 Kinds Kinds NNPS 42759 5951 22 of of IN 42759 5951 23 Property Property NNP 42759 5951 24 ; ; : 42759 5951 25 XII XII NNP 42759 5951 26 , , , 42759 5951 27 The the DT 42759 5951 28 General General NNP 42759 5951 29 Grounds Grounds NNPS 42759 5951 30 for for IN 42759 5951 31 the the DT 42759 5951 32 Maintenance Maintenance NNP 42759 5951 33 of of IN 42759 5951 34 Private private JJ 42759 5951 35 Property property NN 42759 5951 36 ; ; : 42759 5951 37 XIII XIII NNP 42759 5951 38 , , , 42759 5951 39 A a DT 42759 5951 40 Critical Critical NNP 42759 5951 41 Examination examination NN 42759 5951 42 of of IN 42759 5951 43 the the DT 42759 5951 44 General General NNP 42759 5951 45 Grounds Grounds NNPS 42759 5951 46 for for IN 42759 5951 47 the the DT 42759 5951 48 Maintenance Maintenance NNP 42759 5951 49 of of IN 42759 5951 50 Private Private NNP 42759 5951 51 Property property NN 42759 5951 52 ; ; : 42759 5951 53 XIV XIV NNP 42759 5951 54 , , , 42759 5951 55 XV XV NNP 42759 5951 56 , , , 42759 5951 57 XVI XVI NNP 42759 5951 58 , , , 42759 5951 59 XVII XVII NNP 42759 5951 60 , , , 42759 5951 61 XVIII xviii NN 42759 5951 62 , , , 42759 5951 63 XIX xix NN 42759 5951 64 , , , 42759 5951 65 The the DT 42759 5951 66 Present Present NNP 42759 5951 67 and and CC 42759 5951 68 Future Future NNP 42759 5951 69 Development Development NNP 42759 5951 70 of of IN 42759 5951 71 Private Private NNP 42759 5951 72 Property Property NNP 42759 5951 73 ; ; : 42759 5951 74 XX XX NNP 42759 5951 75 , , , 42759 5951 76 The the DT 42759 5951 77 Transformation Transformation NNP 42759 5951 78 of of IN 42759 5951 79 Public Public NNP 42759 5951 80 Property Property NNP 42759 5951 81 into into IN 42759 5951 82 Private Private NNP 42759 5951 83 Property Property NNP 42759 5951 84 and and CC 42759 5951 85 of of IN 42759 5951 86 Private Private NNP 42759 5951 87 Property Property NNP 42759 5951 88 into into IN 42759 5951 89 Public Public NNP 42759 5951 90 Property Property NNP 42759 5951 91 ; ; : 42759 5951 92 XXI XXI NNP 42759 5951 93 , , , 42759 5951 94 The the DT 42759 5951 95 Management Management NNP 42759 5951 96 of of IN 42759 5951 97 Public Public NNP 42759 5951 98 Property Property NNP 42759 5951 99 with with IN 42759 5951 100 Reference Reference NNP 42759 5951 101 to to IN 42759 5951 102 Distribution distribution NN 42759 5951 103 ; ; : 42759 5951 104 XXII XXII NNP 42759 5951 105 , , , 42759 5951 106 Theories theory NNS 42759 5951 107 of of IN 42759 5951 108 the the DT 42759 5951 109 Origin Origin NNP 42759 5951 110 of of IN 42759 5951 111 Private Private NNP 42759 5951 112 Property Property NNP 42759 5951 113 ; ; : 42759 5951 114 Part Part NNP 42759 5951 115 II II NNP 42759 5951 116 , , , 42759 5951 117 Contract Contract NNP 42759 5951 118 and and CC 42759 5951 119 Its -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5951 120 Conditions condition NNS 42759 5951 121 : : : 42759 5951 122 I -PRON- PRP 42759 5951 123 , , , 42759 5951 124 Introductory Introductory NNP 42759 5951 125 Observations Observations NNPS 42759 5951 126 ; ; : 42759 5951 127 II II NNP 42759 5951 128 , , , 42759 5951 129 Contract Contract NNP 42759 5951 130 Defined define VBN 42759 5951 131 and and CC 42759 5951 132 Described describe VBN 42759 5951 133 ; ; : 42759 5951 134 III III NNP 42759 5951 135 , , , 42759 5951 136 The the DT 42759 5951 137 Economic Economic NNP 42759 5951 138 Significance Significance NNP 42759 5951 139 of of IN 42759 5951 140 Contract Contract NNP 42759 5951 141 ; ; : 42759 5951 142 IV IV NNP 42759 5951 143 , , , 42759 5951 144 Contract Contract NNP 42759 5951 145 and and CC 42759 5951 146 Individualism individualism NN 42759 5951 147 ; ; , 42759 5951 148 V V NNP 42759 5951 149 , , , 42759 5951 150 Criticism criticism NN 42759 5951 151 of of IN 42759 5951 152 the the DT 42759 5951 153 Individualistic Individualistic NNP 42759 5951 154 Theory Theory NNP 42759 5951 155 of of IN 42759 5951 156 Contract Contract NNP 42759 5951 157 and and CC 42759 5951 158 the the DT 42759 5951 159 Social Social NNP 42759 5951 160 Theory Theory NNP 42759 5951 161 ; ; : 42759 5951 162 VI VI NNP 42759 5951 163 , , , 42759 5951 164 Contracts Contracts NNP 42759 5951 165 for for IN 42759 5951 166 Personal Personal NNP 42759 5951 167 Services Services NNPS 42759 5951 168 ; ; : 42759 5951 169 VII VII NNP 42759 5951 170 , , , 42759 5951 171 Class Class NNP 42759 5951 172 Legislation Legislation NNP 42759 5951 173 ; ; : 42759 5951 174 VIII VIII NNP 42759 5951 175 , , , 42759 5951 176 Facts fact NNS 42759 5951 177 as as IN 42759 5951 178 to to IN 42759 5951 179 Impairment Impairment NNP 42759 5951 180 of of IN 42759 5951 181 Liberty Liberty NNP 42759 5951 182 ; ; : 42759 5951 183 IX IX NNP 42759 5951 184 , , , 42759 5951 185 The the DT 42759 5951 186 Courts Courts NNPS 42759 5951 187 and and CC 42759 5951 188 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 42759 5951 189 ; ; , 42759 5951 190 X X NNP 42759 5951 191 , , , 42759 5951 192 Concluding Concluding NNP 42759 5951 193 Observations observation NNS 42759 5951 194 ; ; : 42759 5951 195 Appendix Appendix NNP 42759 5951 196 I I NNP 42759 5951 197 , , , 42759 5951 198 Part Part NNP 42759 5951 199 III III NNP 42759 5951 200 , , , 42759 5951 201 Vested Vested NNP 42759 5951 202 Interests Interests NNPS 42759 5951 203 ; ; : 42759 5951 204 Appendix Appendix NNP 42759 5951 205 II II NNP 42759 5951 206 , , , 42759 5951 207 Part Part NNP 42759 5951 208 IV IV NNP 42759 5951 209 , , , 42759 5951 210 Personal Personal NNP 42759 5951 211 Conditions Conditions NNPS 42759 5951 212 ; ; : 42759 5951 213 Appendix Appendix NNP 42759 5951 214 III III NNP 42759 5951 215 , , , 42759 5951 216 Production Production NNP 42759 5951 217 , , , 42759 5951 218 Present Present NNP 42759 5951 219 and and CC 42759 5951 220 Future Future NNP 42759 5951 221 , , , 42759 5951 222 by by IN 42759 5951 223 W. W. NNP 42759 5951 224 I. I. NNP 42759 5952 1 King King NNP 42759 5952 2 , , , 42759 5952 3 Ph.D. ph.d. NN 42759 5952 4 , , , 42759 5952 5 Instructor Instructor NNP 42759 5952 6 in in IN 42759 5952 7 Statistics Statistics NNP 42759 5952 8 , , , 42759 5952 9 University University NNP 42759 5952 10 of of IN 42759 5952 11 Wisconsin Wisconsin NNP 42759 5952 12 ; ; : 42759 5952 13 Appendix Appendix NNP 42759 5952 14 IV IV NNP 42759 5952 15 , , , 42759 5952 16 List List NNP 42759 5952 17 of of IN 42759 5952 18 Cases Cases NNPS 42759 5952 19 Illustrating illustrate VBG 42759 5952 20 the the DT 42759 5952 21 Attitude attitude NN 42759 5952 22 of of IN 42759 5952 23 the the DT 42759 5952 24 Courts Courts NNPS 42759 5952 25 Toward toward IN 42759 5952 26 Property Property NNP 42759 5952 27 and and CC 42759 5952 28 Contract Contract NNP 42759 5952 29 Rights Rights NNPS 42759 5952 30 and and CC 42759 5952 31 the the DT 42759 5952 32 Consequent Consequent NNP 42759 5952 33 Evolution Evolution NNP 42759 5952 34 of of IN 42759 5952 35 These these DT 42759 5952 36 Rights Rights NNPS 42759 5952 37 , , , 42759 5952 38 by by IN 42759 5952 39 Samuel Samuel NNP 42759 5952 40 P. P. NNP 42759 5952 41 Orth Orth NNP 42759 5952 42 , , , 42759 5952 43 Ph.D. ph.d. NN 42759 5952 44 , , , 42759 5952 45 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5952 46 of of IN 42759 5952 47 Political Political NNP 42759 5952 48 Science Science NNP 42759 5952 49 , , , 42759 5952 50 Cornell Cornell NNP 42759 5952 51 University University NNP 42759 5952 52 . . . 42759 5953 1 * * NFP 42759 5953 2 * * NFP 42759 5953 3 * * NFP 42759 5953 4 * * NFP 42759 5953 5 * * NFP 42759 5953 6 Principles principle NNS 42759 5953 7 of of IN 42759 5953 8 Economics Economics NNP 42759 5953 9 BY by IN 42759 5953 10 F. F. NNP 42759 5953 11 W. W. NNP 42759 5953 12 TAUSSIG TAUSSIG NNP 42759 5953 13 Henry Henry NNP 42759 5953 14 Lee Lee NNP 42759 5953 15 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5953 16 of of IN 42759 5953 17 Economics Economics NNP 42759 5953 18 in in IN 42759 5953 19 Harvard Harvard NNP 42759 5953 20 University University NNP 42759 5953 21 _ _ NNP 42759 5953 22 New New NNP 42759 5953 23 edition edition NN 42759 5953 24 . . . 42759 5954 1 Cloth cloth JJ 42759 5954 2 , , , 42759 5954 3 8vo 8vo JJ 42759 5954 4 , , , 42759 5954 5 2 2 CD 42759 5954 6 vols vol NNS 42759 5954 7 . . . 42759 5954 8 , , , 42759 5954 9 each each DT 42759 5954 10 $ $ $ 42759 5954 11 2.00 2.00 CD 42759 5954 12 _ _ IN 42759 5954 13 Volume Volume NNP 42759 5954 14 I I NNP 42759 5954 15 , , , 42759 5954 16 547 547 CD 42759 5954 17 pages page NNS 42759 5954 18 Volume volume NN 42759 5954 19 II II NNP 42759 5954 20 , , , 42759 5954 21 573 573 CD 42759 5954 22 pages page NNS 42759 5954 23 The the DT 42759 5954 24 present present JJ 42759 5954 25 edition edition NN 42759 5954 26 of of IN 42759 5954 27 Professor Professor NNP 42759 5954 28 Taussig Taussig NNP 42759 5954 29 's 's POS 42759 5954 30 standard standard JJ 42759 5954 31 work work NN 42759 5954 32 embodies embody VBZ 42759 5954 33 many many JJ 42759 5954 34 changes change NNS 42759 5954 35 throughout throughout IN 42759 5954 36 the the DT 42759 5954 37 text text NN 42759 5954 38 , , , 42759 5954 39 thus thus RB 42759 5954 40 bringing bring VBG 42759 5954 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 42759 5954 42 work work NN 42759 5954 43 abreast abreast IN 42759 5954 44 of of IN 42759 5954 45 the the DT 42759 5954 46 most most RBS 42759 5954 47 recent recent JJ 42759 5954 48 developments development NNS 42759 5954 49 . . . 42759 5955 1 The the DT 42759 5955 2 chapter chapter NN 42759 5955 3 on on IN 42759 5955 4 banking banking NN 42759 5955 5 in in IN 42759 5955 6 the the DT 42759 5955 7 United United NNP 42759 5955 8 States States NNP 42759 5955 9 has have VBZ 42759 5955 10 been be VBN 42759 5955 11 entirely entirely RB 42759 5955 12 re re VBN 42759 5955 13 - - VBN 42759 5955 14 written write VBN 42759 5955 15 ; ; : 42759 5955 16 as as IN 42759 5955 17 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5955 18 now now RB 42759 5955 19 stands stand VBZ 42759 5955 20 , , , 42759 5955 21 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5955 22 includes include VBZ 42759 5955 23 a a DT 42759 5955 24 description description NN 42759 5955 25 of of IN 42759 5955 26 the the DT 42759 5955 27 Federal Federal NNP 42759 5955 28 Reserve Reserve NNP 42759 5955 29 Bank Bank NNP 42759 5955 30 system system NN 42759 5955 31 and and CC 42759 5955 32 a a DT 42759 5955 33 consideration consideration NN 42759 5955 34 of of IN 42759 5955 35 the the DT 42759 5955 36 principles principle NNS 42759 5955 37 underlying underlie VBG 42759 5955 38 the the DT 42759 5955 39 new new JJ 42759 5955 40 legislation legislation NN 42759 5955 41 . . . 42759 5956 1 The the DT 42759 5956 2 chapter chapter NN 42759 5956 3 on on IN 42759 5956 4 trusts trust NNS 42759 5956 5 and and CC 42759 5956 6 combinations combination NNS 42759 5956 7 has have VBZ 42759 5956 8 been be VBN 42759 5956 9 largely largely RB 42759 5956 10 re re JJ 42759 5956 11 - - VBN 42759 5956 12 written write VBN 42759 5956 13 , , , 42759 5956 14 with with IN 42759 5956 15 reference reference NN 42759 5956 16 to to IN 42759 5956 17 the the DT 42759 5956 18 laws law NNS 42759 5956 19 enacted enact VBN 42759 5956 20 in in IN 42759 5956 21 1914 1914 CD 42759 5956 22 . . . 42759 5957 1 Considerable considerable JJ 42759 5957 2 addition addition NN 42759 5957 3 and and CC 42759 5957 4 revision revision NN 42759 5957 5 has have VBZ 42759 5957 6 been be VBN 42759 5957 7 made make VBN 42759 5957 8 in in IN 42759 5957 9 the the DT 42759 5957 10 chapter chapter NN 42759 5957 11 on on IN 42759 5957 12 workmen workman NNS 42759 5957 13 's 's POS 42759 5957 14 insurance insurance NN 42759 5957 15 , , , 42759 5957 16 calling call VBG 42759 5957 17 attention attention NN 42759 5957 18 to to IN 42759 5957 19 the the DT 42759 5957 20 noteworthy noteworthy JJ 42759 5957 21 steps step NNS 42759 5957 22 taken take VBN 42759 5957 23 of of IN 42759 5957 24 late late JJ 42759 5957 25 years year NNS 42759 5957 26 in in IN 42759 5957 27 England England NNP 42759 5957 28 and and CC 42759 5957 29 the the DT 42759 5957 30 United United NNP 42759 5957 31 States States NNP 42759 5957 32 . . . 42759 5958 1 The the DT 42759 5958 2 chapters chapter NNS 42759 5958 3 on on IN 42759 5958 4 taxation taxation NN 42759 5958 5 and and CC 42759 5958 6 especially especially RB 42759 5958 7 on on IN 42759 5958 8 income income NN 42759 5958 9 taxes taxis NNS 42759 5958 10 , , , 42759 5958 11 and and CC 42759 5958 12 on on IN 42759 5958 13 some some DT 42759 5958 14 other other JJ 42759 5958 15 topics topic NNS 42759 5958 16 , , , 42759 5958 17 have have VBP 42759 5958 18 been be VBN 42759 5958 19 similarly similarly RB 42759 5958 20 brought bring VBN 42759 5958 21 to to IN 42759 5958 22 date date NN 42759 5958 23 . . . 42759 5959 1 A a DT 42759 5959 2 remarkable remarkable JJ 42759 5959 3 tribute tribute NN 42759 5959 4 to to IN 42759 5959 5 the the DT 42759 5959 6 merit merit NN 42759 5959 7 of of IN 42759 5959 8 this this DT 42759 5959 9 book book NN 42759 5959 10 is be VBZ 42759 5959 11 that that IN 42759 5959 12 while while IN 42759 5959 13 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5959 14 was be VBD 42759 5959 15 not not RB 42759 5959 16 intended intend VBN 42759 5959 17 primarily primarily RB 42759 5959 18 as as IN 42759 5959 19 a a DT 42759 5959 20 class class NN 42759 5959 21 text text NN 42759 5959 22 , , , 42759 5959 23 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5959 24 has have VBZ 42759 5959 25 been be VBN 42759 5959 26 adopted adopt VBN 42759 5959 27 for for IN 42759 5959 28 exclusive exclusive JJ 42759 5959 29 use use NN 42759 5959 30 as as IN 42759 5959 31 a a DT 42759 5959 32 text text NN 42759 5959 33 in in IN 42759 5959 34 many many JJ 42759 5959 35 of of IN 42759 5959 36 the the DT 42759 5959 37 colleges college NNS 42759 5959 38 and and CC 42759 5959 39 universities university NNS 42759 5959 40 , , , 42759 5959 41 both both CC 42759 5959 42 large large JJ 42759 5959 43 and and CC 42759 5959 44 small small JJ 42759 5959 45 . . . 42759 5960 1 Experience experience NN 42759 5960 2 has have VBZ 42759 5960 3 shown show VBN 42759 5960 4 conclusively conclusively RB 42759 5960 5 that that IN 42759 5960 6 the the DT 42759 5960 7 book book NN 42759 5960 8 's 's POS 42759 5960 9 clarity clarity NN 42759 5960 10 of of IN 42759 5960 11 expression expression NN 42759 5960 12 and and CC 42759 5960 13 freedom freedom NN 42759 5960 14 from from IN 42759 5960 15 the the DT 42759 5960 16 usual usual JJ 42759 5960 17 technical technical JJ 42759 5960 18 treatment treatment NN 42759 5960 19 of of IN 42759 5960 20 the the DT 42759 5960 21 subject subject NN 42759 5960 22 has have VBZ 42759 5960 23 made make VBN 42759 5960 24 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5960 25 an an DT 42759 5960 26 especially especially RB 42759 5960 27 suitable suitable JJ 42759 5960 28 text text NN 42759 5960 29 for for IN 42759 5960 30 all all DT 42759 5960 31 colleges college NNS 42759 5960 32 . . . 42759 5961 1 For for IN 42759 5961 2 the the DT 42759 5961 3 smaller small JJR 42759 5961 4 institutions institution NNS 42759 5961 5 , , , 42759 5961 6 the the DT 42759 5961 7 book book NN 42759 5961 8 has have VBZ 42759 5961 9 the the DT 42759 5961 10 additional additional JJ 42759 5961 11 advantage advantage NN 42759 5961 12 of of IN 42759 5961 13 containing contain VBG 42759 5961 14 all all PDT 42759 5961 15 the the DT 42759 5961 16 necessary necessary JJ 42759 5961 17 material material NN 42759 5961 18 required require VBN 42759 5961 19 in in IN 42759 5961 20 the the DT 42759 5961 21 usual usual JJ 42759 5961 22 course course NN 42759 5961 23 in in IN 42759 5961 24 economics economic NNS 42759 5961 25 , , , 42759 5961 26 and and CC 42759 5961 27 thus thus RB 42759 5961 28 avoids avoid VBZ 42759 5961 29 the the DT 42759 5961 30 extra extra JJ 42759 5961 31 expense expense NN 42759 5961 32 and and CC 42759 5961 33 trouble trouble NN 42759 5961 34 of of IN 42759 5961 35 using use VBG 42759 5961 36 several several JJ 42759 5961 37 other other JJ 42759 5961 38 books book NNS 42759 5961 39 to to TO 42759 5961 40 supplement supplement VB 42759 5961 41 the the DT 42759 5961 42 basic basic JJ 42759 5961 43 text text NN 42759 5961 44 . . . 42759 5962 1 In in IN 42759 5962 2 fact fact NN 42759 5962 3 , , , 42759 5962 4 the the DT 42759 5962 5 value value NN 42759 5962 6 and and CC 42759 5962 7 the the DT 42759 5962 8 extended extended JJ 42759 5962 9 use use NN 42759 5962 10 of of IN 42759 5962 11 this this DT 42759 5962 12 work work NN 42759 5962 13 as as IN 42759 5962 14 a a DT 42759 5962 15 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 42759 5962 16 , , , 42759 5962 17 untechnical untechnical JJ 42759 5962 18 treatment treatment NN 42759 5962 19 of of IN 42759 5962 20 the the DT 42759 5962 21 subject subject NN 42759 5962 22 , , , 42759 5962 23 have have VBP 42759 5962 24 led lead VBN 42759 5962 25 many many JJ 42759 5962 26 eminent eminent JJ 42759 5962 27 economists economist NNS 42759 5962 28 to to TO 42759 5962 29 regard regard VB 42759 5962 30 it -PRON- PRP 42759 5962 31 as as IN 42759 5962 32 the the DT 42759 5962 33 most most RBS 42759 5962 34 notable notable JJ 42759 5962 35 contribution contribution NN 42759 5962 36 to to IN 42759 5962 37 the the DT 42759 5962 38 subject subject NN 42759 5962 39 of of IN 42759 5962 40 economics economic NNS 42759 5962 41 since since IN 42759 5962 42 the the DT 42759 5962 43 time time NN 42759 5962 44 of of IN 42759 5962 45 John John NNP 42759 5962 46 Stuart Stuart NNP 42759 5962 47 Mill Mill NNP 42759 5962 48 . . . 42759 5963 1 THE the DT 42759 5963 2 MACMILLAN MACMILLAN NNP 42759 5963 3 COMPANY COMPANY NNP 42759 5963 4 Publishers Publishers NNP 42759 5963 5 64 64 CD 42759 5963 6 - - SYM 42759 5963 7 66 66 CD 42759 5963 8 Fifth Fifth NNP 42759 5963 9 Avenue Avenue NNP 42759 5963 10 New New NNP 42759 5963 11 York York NNP 42759 5963 12 * * NFP 42759 5963 13 * * NFP 42759 5963 14 * * NFP 42759 5963 15 * * NFP 42759 5963 16 * * NFP 42759 5963 17 Transcriber Transcriber NNP 42759 5963 18 's 's POS 42759 5963 19 Notes note NNS 42759 5963 20 : : : 42759 5963 21 Obvious obvious JJ 42759 5963 22 typographical typographical JJ 42759 5963 23 errors error NNS 42759 5963 24 were be VBD 42759 5963 25 corrected correct VBN 42759 5963 26 . . . 42759 5964 1 Hyphenation hyphenation NN 42759 5964 2 inconsistency inconsistency NN 42759 5964 3 between between IN 42759 5964 4 " " `` 42759 5964 5 co co NN 42759 5964 6 - - NN 42759 5964 7 partnership partnership NN 42759 5964 8 " " '' 42759 5964 9 as as IN 42759 5964 10 used use VBN 42759 5964 11 by by IN 42759 5964 12 the the DT 42759 5964 13 author author NN 42759 5964 14 , , , 42759 5964 15 and and CC 42759 5964 16 " " `` 42759 5964 17 Copartnership Copartnership NNP 42759 5964 18 " " '' 42759 5964 19 as as IN 42759 5964 20 in in IN 42759 5964 21 the the DT 42759 5964 22 title title NN 42759 5964 23 of of IN 42759 5964 24 a a DT 42759 5964 25 quoted quote VBN 42759 5964 26 reference reference NN 42759 5964 27 , , , 42759 5964 28 was be VBD 42759 5964 29 retained retain VBN 42759 5964 30 as as IN 42759 5964 31 in in IN 42759 5964 32 the the DT 42759 5964 33 original original NN 42759 5964 34 . . . 42759 5965 1 A a DT 42759 5965 2 few few JJ 42759 5965 3 out out JJ 42759 5965 4 - - HYPH 42759 5965 5 of of IN 42759 5965 6 - - HYPH 42759 5965 7 order order NN 42759 5965 8 index index NN 42759 5965 9 entries entry NNS 42759 5965 10 were be VBD 42759 5965 11 relocated relocate VBN 42759 5965 12 . . . 42759 5966 1 Advertisements advertisement NNS 42759 5966 2 : : : 42759 5966 3 " " `` 42759 5966 4 THE the DT 42759 5966 5 MACMILLAN MACMILLAN NNP 42759 5966 6 COMPANY COMPANY NNP 42759 5966 7 Publishers Publishers NNP 42759 5966 8 64 64 CD 42759 5966 9 - - SYM 42759 5966 10 66 66 CD 42759 5966 11 Fifth Fifth NNP 42759 5966 12 Avenue Avenue NNP 42759 5966 13 New New NNP 42759 5966 14 York York NNP 42759 5966 15 " " '' 42759 5966 16 appeared appear VBD 42759 5966 17 at at IN 42759 5966 18 the the DT 42759 5966 19 bottom bottom NN 42759 5966 20 of of IN 42759 5966 21 each each DT 42759 5966 22 ad ad NN 42759 5966 23 page page NN 42759 5966 24 in in IN 42759 5966 25 the the DT 42759 5966 26 original original NN 42759 5966 27 . . . 42759 5967 1 This this DT 42759 5967 2 has have VBZ 42759 5967 3 been be VBN 42759 5967 4 reduced reduce VBN 42759 5967 5 to to IN 42759 5967 6 one one CD 42759 5967 7 occurrence occurrence NN 42759 5967 8 after after IN 42759 5967 9 the the DT 42759 5967 10 final final JJ 42759 5967 11 ad ad NN 42759 5967 12 . . .