Obseruations concerning the present affaires of Holland and the Vnited Prouinces, made by an English gentleman there lately resident, & since written by himselfe from Paris, to his friend in England Spiegel der Nederlandsche elenden. English Verstegan, Richard, ca. 1550-1640. 1621 Approx. 125 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 67 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2008-09 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A03452 STC 13576 ESTC S116935 99852150 99852150 17459 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A03452) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 17459) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1475-1640 ; 1382:12) Obseruations concerning the present affaires of Holland and the Vnited Prouinces, made by an English gentleman there lately resident, & since written by himselfe from Paris, to his friend in England Spiegel der Nederlandsche elenden. English Verstegan, Richard, ca. 1550-1640. 131, [1] p. English College Press], [Saint-Omer : Printed Anno M. DC. XXI [1621] English gentleman = Richard Verstegan. Place of publication and name of press from STC. A translation, possibly by Richard Verstegan, of his: De spiegel der Nederlandsche elenden. Running title reads: Obseruations concerning the affayres of Holland. Reproduction of the original in the Cambridge University Library. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Netherlands -- History -- Wars of Independence, 1556-1648 -- Early works to 1800. 2007-07 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2007-08 Apex CoVantage Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2007-10 Jonathan Blaney Sampled and proofread 2007-10 Jonathan Blaney Text and markup reviewed and edited 2008-02 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion OBSERVATIO●● CONCERNING THE PRESENT AFFAIRES . OF HOLLAND AND THE VNITED PROVINCES , Made by an English Gentleman there lately resident , & since written by himselfe from Paris , to his friend in ENGLAND . Printed Anno M.DC. ●●● THE AVTHORS EPISTLE TO HIS FRIEND . WORTHY , & welbeloued Friend , you shal please to vnderstand , that at my late being at the Hage in Holland , I receaued your leter , wherin you desire me to describe vnto you the Countrey ; & condition of the people , as also to know my opinion of their cause and quarrell against the King of Spayne , about which they haue so long troubled the world : Moreouer how I find thē in their thankefulnes vnto our State , for so longe sticking vnto them , and ayding them : And what those differences are which are lately risen vp among them about matters of Religion . This letter of yours I had no tyme to answere frō thence , neither would the answering it there haue beene conuenient ; I therefore deserred the answere , vntill my comming into France , to which iourney I was resolued before the receit of your letter ; because ( to deale truely with you ) I could not any longer endure to heare the lauish and vile speaches , which a sort of base vnbridled people dayly disgorged against the Maiesty of our King , whereof in the ensuing discourse somwhat more shal be spoken . And indeed this intollerable demeanour of theirs toward the Maiesty of so great and so bountifull a Prince , and to whome they are so much beholding , hath giuen me good cause aswell to looke into the iustnesse of their wars against the King of Spaine , as into their in gratitude vnto the King and State of England , and therby to become the more able to giue you satisfaction to the demands in your letter . I must notwithstāding confesse , that since my aryuall heer in Paris , I haue for some whyle deferred it : for as on the one side I had a great desyre thereunto , so on the other syde , I found in my selfe a kind of vnwillingnes to begin it ; which vnwillingnes I protest vnto you , proceeded of a conceaued feare to offend you , when in deliuering you the very true and playne truthe of thinges as they are , you might fynd me altered in mynd and iudgment from what I was when I was cōuersant with you in England . But considering that the true duety of a friend is , with his friend to deale vnfaignedly , I haue now at last vndertaken the taske so to do . And in such regard must intreate you , to excuse me , and not to let my ignorance of the time when I cōuersed with you be put in opposition against the better knowledge which experience of ryper years hath yielded me ; for you must think that by trauailing abroad in other Countryes , & conuersing with men of vnderstanding of diuers nations , who in these parts are accustomed to frenesse of speach ; by reading the iudicious writings of such credible Authors , as haue noted downe the actions of State of this time ; as also by the obseruatiōs which myselfe haue made , I haue seen as it were a mist wip●d away frō before myne eyes , and thereby am come to discerne that , which truth & reason hath made manifest vnto me , as I make no doubt you also will become to do , when with vnpartial patiēce you will haue pleased to read , what heere for your satisfaction I haue written ; that thereby we may agre aswel in mind & iudgment , as we do in ancient amity . And thus leauing you to God , in all kind affection I take of you my leaue . You know the hand . From Paris the 20. of March , after this stile & computation . THE CONTENTS OF THE CHAPTERS . A Briefe description o● the Country , & People of Holland ; with a true relation of the beginning of their rebellion against their ●lawfu●l Soueraigne Lord , King Philip the second of Spayne . Chap. I. How dishonora●le it was , for Queene Elizabeth of England , to take the Hollanders parts against the King of Spayn : how she oppressed and impouerished her subiects for th●ir sakes , and endangered her owne Crowne and Kingdome . Chap. II. Whether England hath receaued any benefite by defending the quarrell of the Hollanders ; or whether the Hollanders haue endeauoured to deserue the friendship they haue receaued from thence , or haue any way shewed themselues gratefull for it . Chap. III. Whether England can expect any benefite by continuing to take the Hollanders parts ; and whether the Hollanders do deserue the same , by wishing , or desiring the continuance of the State and Gouernement of England as now it standeth . Cha. IIII. Of the present state of the Hollanders ; & of the diuision among them about matters of Religion : and whether respect of Religion may vrge England still to assist them . Chap. V. CHAP. I. A briefe description of the Countrey and People of Holland ; with a t●u● Relation of the beginning of their rebellion , against their lawfull Soueraigne Lord , King Philip the second of Spayne . HOLLAND at the creation of the world was no Land at all , and therefore not at the first intended by God or nature for a dwelling place of men , for it was then & long after a sea , and consequently the habitation of fishes . Had it been meant for a habitatiō of men , it had not only been such high ground , that it should not haue beene continually subiect to the inundation of the ●ea , but also haue beene able to haue yeelded the inhabitants bread to eate , & wood , or stone to build witha●l ; and the foure elements would not haue conspired together to be there all naught , & by being naught vnto men , to shew their disl●ke of vsu●pers that depriue fishes of ●heir due dwelling places . Being then at the first wholy sea , by reason of the fla●s & shallows thereof , ●t was partly by ban●kes raised of 〈◊〉 and earth , through the labour of m●n , and partely by sandy down●s o● 〈◊〉 driuen together by the r●ge of the waues , encroached vpon & gotten from the sea , by the old Ancest●urs of the now Inhabitantes . The Co●n●rey then except these ban●kes and do●●nes , lyeth all as low and leuel as water hath made it . In it are neither mountaynes nor fountaynes , nor hath nature affoarded them within the earth the meanest of the seauen mettalles , or any mineral matter at al. But what shal I speak of their want of mynes in the earth , when they haue want of earth it self ; and yet notwithstanding their want therof , are faigne to make vse of that litle they haue for their fuell , and so begin to burne vp their Countrey before the day of Iudgement . Grasse they haue , and that is all the greatest good that their ground can affoard them , and heerof butter and cheese are the wittnesses : but for this one benefit , they want many which other Countries haue that haue this as wel as they . To say the truth , I do not know any benefits peculiar to themselues whereof they may boast , except only two : the one is their hauing of a Country which is the fittest for rebelliō in all Christendome ; and the other is , that by reason of the great lownesse of their dwelling , they are the neerest neighbours to the Diuel , of any nation liuing vpon earth . For other singularities among the people , I haue noted , that they are generally so bred vp to the Bible , that almost euery Cob●er is a Dut●h Doctor of diuinity , and by inward illumination of spirit vnderstadeth the Scripture as wel as they that wrote it . Yet fal those inward illumination● so different , that so mety mes seauen religions are found together in one family ; the man of the house being of one religion , the wyfe of another , and the children and seruants of others : but many more may there be in one house if the family be greater , by reason of the great store of religions that are there dayly increasing & currant ; for there were not more differēt languages at the tower of Bah●l , then ther are differēt beliefs in Holland ; vpon which plurality of Sects a friend of myne made this Epigramme : The first confusion that the VVorld besell , VVas in the many speaches variation , VVhen men had sought , ●igh vnto Heauen to dwel , By making on a Towre their habitation . But to the VVorlds astonishment and griese , A new confusion now is falne agayne , Consisting not in language , but beliefe , And far exceeding seauenty sorts and twayne : VVhich make their choice in this low Land to dwel , VVhere they are neerest neighbours vnto hell . Those of Holland & the ad●acent partes rerme thēselues of the Vnited Prouinces ; but neuer people in this world liued in a more disunited vnity ; so great a confusion hath this freedome brought amongst them of euery Idiots babling out of the Bible . Hell is nothing so odious vnto this people , as is the Spanish Inquisitiō , albeit they liue in more danger of hell then of it . The reason why they so much hate it , is because it hateth the Babel of their belief But notwithstāding their professed freedom of al Religions , they can finde meanes without vsing the name of ●n Inquisition , to depresse two Religions , to wit , the Oldest , and the Newest , that is to say , the Catholike Religion , and the Arminian Religion : these they let not to puni●h in body and in goodes , with imprisonment also , and banishment . They had rather heare blasphemy vttered against God , then any word of the abridging of any their priuiledges , which they conserue so inuiolably , that they haue quite broken the best , and abused all the others : so as the reason why they stand so much vpon them , appeareth to be , because they would haue no body to be the breakers of them , but The high powersull Lords the States themselues . The words of Soueraigne authority Sic volo , sic iubeo , are in tollerable in their eares , for their taking place before right and reason , as Langenes telleth vs , in his booke of Mappes printed at Amsterdam 1599. It seemeth they much affect the Storke , because , as they say , she seeketh not to liue in any Countrey that is gouerned by a King , and therefore when she coms into Europe , she holds her residence most in Switzerland , and Holland . The regiment of a Beast with seauen heades pleaseth them best , because it is a monster that ryseth out of the sea , and because possibility giueth hope that any Beer-brewer , or Basket-maker by vulgar cōmendation of his friends , may at one tyme or other be raised to the dignity of one of The powerfull Lords the States . One great prerogatiue I must confesse this people to haue , which they do not bragge of , and this is , that when at the day of Iudgement the wicked shall say vnto the Mountaines fall vpon vs , & vnto the hills couer vs ; those that be wicked in Holland because they haue no hills , shall but need to cut their bankes through , & the sea of it self wil straight wayes ouer whelme them . I am verily perswaded , that if this people had been the rebels of any other King or Prince in the world then of th● King of Spain , he would as well haue made the sea to haue holpen him to reuenge his quarell vpon them , as they haue made it to assist them in their rebellion against him : and that this by the sea might be brought to passe is apparent inough , and the sea it selfe gaue proofe therof , when not forty yeares before this their great rebellion , it drowned foure hundred & foure of their villages . Nor would themselues omit to do the same , if they might therby haue the like aduantage against the King of Spayne : for in sundry places both of Flanders and Brabant , they haue long since begon some practise of it , to the disaduantage of the sayd King , and the detriment of such of his subiects as liued vnder him in their due obedience . But now to be no longer tedious vnto you in this Countrey and peoples description , I wil come vnto the beginning and originall cause of their rebellion . Yo● shall therefore vnderstand , that King Philippe the second before-named , departed out of these Netherlands towards Spayne in the yeare of our Lord 1559. then being in full possession of all the seauenteene Prouinces , to wit , of the seauen now vnited in rebelon , whereof Holl●nd is the chiefe , and the ten others . The Soueraignty of all which Prouinces , he receaued as true and sole heyre successiuely from his Father the Emperor ●harle the fifth , who in like manner had them successiuely frō his Father , to whome they likewise were descended from his Ancestours . At his departure , he left all these Countryes in peace & plenty , hauing no ciuill broyles amongst themselues , nor warres with other Nations . Their religion was the same wherunto aboue eight hundred yeares before they were brought , when first they were conuerted from Paganisme to Christianity : to the maintenance of which Religion , as also of the Ecclesiasticall state in all her rig●ts and priuiledges , the sayd King was sworne , as to one of the chiefest of all other priuiledges . He left for supreme Gouernesse vnder him in these Prouinces the Lady Margaret Duchesse of Parma his natural sister by the Fathers side : but neither left he any Spanish Lifetenant Gouernour of any of these Prouinces vnder her , nor had he any army or troopes of Spanish souldiers in al the Country , but left ech particuler gouernement to the Nobility of the Country it selfe , with other benefits bestowed vpon euery of them . And besides the sundry benefits both in titles of honour , and in riches which the aforesayd Emperour Charles had bestowed vpon William of Nassaw , Prince of Orange ; this King Philip his sonne , not diminishing but much augmenting them , left him also Lifetenant Gouernour of some of these Prouinces . Thus departed the sayd king Philip into Spayne , without giuing the least cause of discontentment to any of the Nobility or people of these Countries , leauing them all in obligation of loue & loyalty , & in more florishing estate thē euer they were before . But as prodigall seruants are wont to beare themselues in the absence of their maisters , so some of this forsayd Nobility bearing themselues far aboue the limits of their meanes , became greatly behind hand , and indebted , & thereupon attendant for some one or other remedy ( now in the absence of their Soueraigne Lord ) which might keep their estates from declyning wholy to ruine . And amongst these , there lurcked in the hart of the aforsaid William of Nassaw Prince of Orange , as well a desyre of reuenge , as of remedy for the vnderpropping of his decayed estate . This desire of reuenge was not for any wronges or iniuries donne or suffred to be donne vnto him by the king of Spayne , but a reuenge forsooth , because the greedy appetit of his insatiable ambition was not fully satisfyed . For knowing that the King of Spayne after he had receaued possessiō of these Netherland Prouinces , must needs returne agayne into Spayne , and leaue some generall Gouernour thereof behind him , he laboured by what meanes he might both by himselfe and such of the Nobility as were of his faction , that this authority might be giuen vnto the Lady Christierna Duchesse of Lorayne , & daughter vnto the sister of the Emperour Charles the fifth , who was maryed vnto Chri●●iernus the third , King of Denmarcke ; and this Duchesse had a daughter called the Lady Dorothy , and with this Lady the aforesayd Prince of Orange meant to haue maryed , that by this meanes after the death of the Duchesse Christierna he might haue come to haue beene Supreme gouernour of the whole low Countries . But by reason of the Duchesse of Parma her being preferred vnto this dignity , & his designment broken , he out of cōceaued reuenge went and maryed with a daughter of Mauritius Duke of Saxony being in religion a Lutheran ; and with her returned agayne into the Netherlandes , retayning still in his hart the mali●e which he had cōceaued , & the expectation of some occasiō of further reueng , with reparation of his decayed estate . Now is it to be noted , that albeit Martin Luther the New-Religiō-maker of Germany , dyed not past three years before king Philip departed out of these Netherlandes , yet were there already , by meanes of him and his disciples six seueral religions risen vp in these Coūtries , to wit , The religion which Luther himselfe had first begune , The religion of the Anabapstists , The religiō of the Caluinists , The religion of the Loyistes , The religion of the family of loue , and the religion of the Georgists : of which six , for your more satisfactiō I will heere giue you ( though briefly ) some particuler relation . Martin Luther when he had made his reuolt from the Catholike Roman Church , fynding that there were some thinges taught , and obserued in the same Church , that were thereto descended by ancient tradition , and also deduced from the scriptures , though not expressly therein mentioned , thought with himself that the only way for him to draw many disciples after him , was , to proclayme in all his sermons and writings , that we ought not to belieue or do nay thing concerning faith & religion , but that which was expressly comaunded and set downe in the written Word of God. By this deuyce in the beginning he found great applause , especially among the vulgar sort , into whose handes he had thrust Bibles and Testaments translated by himself into Dutche , to the best aduantage of his doctrine . But it was not long after that some of these his disciples grew so subtile , as to examine his doctrine by his owne rule , and to see if all that he had taught them were expressly to be found in the written Word of God. In which examination , they found that the Christening of yonge children was not there to be found ; and thereupon esteeming the baptisme of children to be of no force , they reuolted from him and rebaptized themselues , and so began the sect of the Anabaptists . After these , Andrew Carolostadius , one of the first and greatest disciples of Luther , who with him allowed the baptisme of children , although not expressed in Scripture , began to dissent frō 〈◊〉 in opiniō of the real presence of Christ in the Sacrament , albeit expressed in Scripture ; which opinion being imbraced by Zuinglius and others , and afterward p●●lished by Iohn Caluin , left vnto his followers the name of Caluinists . The Loyists tooke their name of one Lo● , by occupation a Slater , and a townseman of Antwerp , who was so confident in his right vnderstanding of Scripture by inward illumination from heauen , that being furnished of money by certayne rich Merchantes of that citty whom he had brought to be of his Sect , trauailed to Wittemberge to dispute with Luther , and to conuert him to his religion : but Luther finding him so to interpret the Scripture as to deny the resurrection of the dead , to hold that the soules of the good are immortal and do go to God , and that the soules of the euill do consume away and come to nothing , and consequently that there is neither Diuel , nor Hell , except the hell of this world , and the Men-diuels in it ; Luther offered rather to dispute with him with fistes , then with Scripture : wherupon Loy finding such harsh entertaynment returned to Antwerp again , & left Luther vnconuerted . But hauing in Antwerp seduced and brought many to be of his opinion , after he had recanted his doctrine and fallen to it againe , he was finally burnt . The family of Loue began by one Henry Nicholas a Mercer , or Seller of Silks , also of Antwerp , who held among other thinges , that man ought to be Deifyed in God , and God ho●●●fyed in man ; and that men may haue their heauen first heer in this world by liuing in that deifyed loue they ought to do , and heereafter in Heauen also . The last of these six was the sect of Dauid George a Glasse painter of Delft in Holland . This monster secretly taught his disciples , that in himselfe was infused the soule of the true Messias and Sauiour of the World , that he was more then Elias , more then S. Iohn Baptist , yea more then Christ . These six sects beginning now to grow and spread themselues in sundry parts of the Countrey , though some increased more then some , the Georgistes keeping themselues more secret then any of the others ; there was now no remedy for the preseruation of the subiects from so great confusion in religion , as also from the dayly increase of more Sects , & the great inconueniences iustly feared thereby to arise , then by putting in practise the Placarts or Ordinances of the Emperour , being no other then consonant vnto the ancient lawes of all other Countryes in Christendome , as also for the preseruation of the Oath which the Emperour , and his Son the King of Spayne had take in this Country , for maintenance of the ancient established Religion and Clergy . These lawes then being now begun to be put in execution , and diuers of those that were of these Sects put to death , but of none more then of that of the Anabaptists ; certain of the decayed Nobility aforesayd , of which faction William of Nassaw was the chiefe , seeing that all this made for them , & that somthing must needes come of it , whereby they might fall to fishing in a troubled water , sought by all meanes to get themselues beloued of all these Sectes , that in the end they might benefite themselues by that which most preuailed . Wherupon in the Moneth of April in the yeare of our Lord 1566. in the Towne of Bruxells they exhibited vnto the L● . Margaret aforsaid a supplication , wherin they requyred a repeale or moderation of all rigorous Placartes , or Lawes made concerning Religion . Let now any man of reason or iudgment consider of the lawfullnes of this demaund , and whether themselues that demaunded it , could with good conscience moue the same , the very mouing of the demaund it selfe plainely arguing little respect or conscience in the demaunders , & declaring plainely , that the thing they sought was for their owne endes ; and that taking part at the last with that Sect which came to domimere aboue the rest , as in the end one must needes doe , they might sticke thereunto , and so by flatte and open rebellion make vp their mouthes by the ouerthrowe of the ancient Clergy that was in possession of good 〈◊〉 and huinges , to which all these new Sects did beare equal hatred , albeit ech or them did neuerthelesse hate one another . This request being as is aforesayd presented vnto the Lady Margaret in the moneth of April , she promised them to send it into Spaine , and to require from thence , resolution and answere t●ereof . The request she sent , but the answere they attended not , but gaue f●●thwith such hart and encouragment vnto the Sectaryes , that within few weeks after the request was sent away , they began to preach publikely in sundry Townes and Cittyes , vpon a selfe assumed authority , euen in despite of all Lawes and Magistrates ; and thereupon fell to robbing and spoyling of Churches throughout al the Countrey . Vpon this the King of Spayne as a Prince most carefull of his Oath , and of the good of his subiects , was enforced to send into these Netherlands the Duke of Alua , to take vpon him the generall gouernment , which in so troublesome a world was too great a charge to be menaged by a woman . This Duke ariuing in these partes in the moneth of August , in the yeare 1●67 . which was the yeare following ; the Lady Margaret resigned vnto him the gouernement , and departed out of the Countrey . The Duke now being placed in the gouernement , began to learne out , and informe himselfe what persons they were that had conspired togeather in this busines , and had giuen the onset and countenance vnto these rebellious Sectaryes , and Sacrilegious Church-robbers ; & finding the Earles of Egmont and Horne , and some other Gentlemen to be culpable of this crime , they were apprehended , and beheaded in Bruxels But VVilliam of Nassaw Prince of Orange , the chiefest Ring leader of this sedition , so soone as he heard of the ariuall of the Duke , got him away into Germany , and by his flight declared himselfe to be guilty , as by experience afterward it proued . Heere now it is to be considered , whether in the sight and iudgement of the whole World , the King of Spaine had not all right and reason on his side , to vse such meanes as he did for the punishment of such capitall offenders , and to imploy the subiects of one Countrey , for the chastisement of the Rebells of another , when he had no other remedy . And whether any King or Prince liuing in the world , could in honour , or iustice winke at , & put vp such great and capital crymes and insolencyes committed by his subiects , as is a generall and publique sacrilegious Church-robbery , and the spoyling of the Clergy , for the preseruation of whose priuiledges he had so solemnely taken his oath , and to suffer the dooers quietly to passe vnpunished , & to let euery man openly professe & follow such new and neuer heard of doctrine , as his owne fancy should inuent , or of his owne choice he should best like ; which euen those themselues that are at this day the successours of these first rebells in some of these Netherlands , doe find so inconuenient , for gouernement , that notwithstanding their first profession , that euery man ought to haue his free exercise or Religion according to his owne conscience , they do prohibite to such , as they like not . The Duke of Alua hauing caused iustice to be executed , first vpon some of the principall conspiratours , and after vpon other inferiour offenders , did at last in the yeare of our Lord 1570. by order from the King of Spaine , cause a general pardon to be proclaimed , wherof if VVilliam of Nassaw Prince of O●ange and his adherents had taken the offered benefite , all further troubles had ceased : but to the contrary they laboured , both by secret seditious preachers , as by other such like agents to spread abroad that the King of Spayne had broken the Countrey priuiledges ; as thogh the Countrey had had priuiledges that churches might forsooth be robbed , & no man called in question for it , & that euery man might professe what religion he listed , were it neuer so naught , or new , the prohibiting whereof and the conseruation of Ecclesiasticall priuiledges , to which the King was sworne , being the only cause , as to all the world was apparent , why the sayd King was constrayned to send the Duke of Alua , and Spaniardes into the Countrey , which els had neuer beene thought of . So as the true blame which the King of Spayne hath deserued , is not for breach of priuileges , but for seeking to restore priuiledges which his disobedient subiects had broken ; the which if he had not done , then might he haue beene thought negligent and carelesse of his Oath : but this , the equity of his conscience would neuer permit . I am not ignorant that some fooles haue made other fooles belieue , that the King of Spayne at his departure out of these Netherlands , did promise euery seauen yeare to returne thither againe , and that the breach of his promise gaue cause sufficient for these his subiects to rebell . This foolish allegation deserneth no answere . Yet least some wiser people might be abused by fooles , I ●ill leaue them to consider , that there was no cause why his Maiesty should bind himselfe to any such condition , his predecessors before him hauing beene free , and the Countrey comming vnto him by right of succession , as it did to them : Experience hauing also shewed the inclination of the people to rebellion , being grown proud by reason of their Wealth , and new-fangled also by reason of the choyce of Religions ; in so much that the Duke of Alua saw it necessary to mayntayne certayne garisons of soldiers in castles & conuenient fortifyed frontier places in the Countrey ; which he made known vnto the King of Spayne , & sent vnto him for prouision of money , because he found the sayd King vnwilling to haue his subiects of this Countrey burdened with any more taxations thereabout . But what successe heereof ensued , shall appeare in the next Chapter . CHAP. II. How dishonourable it was , for Queene Elizabeth of England , to take the Hollāders parts , against the King of Spayn : How she oppressed , and impouerished her subiects for their sakes ; and endangered her owne Crowne and Kingdome . BEFORE I begin to speake of Queen Elizabeth of England her assisting the rebelled subiects of Holland against the King of Spayne , it is not impertinent to the purpose , to call to mind whether there were any cause of emnity giuen vnto her by meanes of any wronges or iniuryes offred her by the King of Spayne , in former tyme , in regard wherof she might now take the oportunity of reuenge . This King Philip the second of Spayne hauing beene maryed in England to Queen Mary , was neuer known to haue beene disaffected to the Lady Elizabeth , for so was she then called ; but cōtrary wise did shew himself to be the greatest freind ●he had in the world : which hee●e in briefe to declare , you must nore , that this Lady E●izabeth , being then a subiect vnto her sayd sister Queen Mary , chaunced to fall into sundry troubles , for which she was imprisoned in the Tower of ●on●on , and retayned in durance at Woodsto●k ▪ and other places . M. Fox the Author of the English Protestant Martyrologe , wryting of this Ladies inprisonment , declareth not any cause why ; but because he putteth her in his history of others that suffred for protestant religiō he intendeth to haue his reader imagine her to haue suffred some persecutiō also for the same cause , whereby he thinketh not a little to honour her . But had her troubles beene for Religion indeed , Fox would then neuer haue omitted to set down her examinations about the same , and her answeres thereunto , in defence of some such poin●s as are in controuersy betwen Catholiks & Protestan●s ; as about the real presence of Christ in the Sacrament , or about prayer to Saints , or prayer for the Dead , or some one or other point , as wel as he hath set down , the examinations and answeres of so many others , to their great glory , as he takes it : but heer is nothing found , Fox in this in silent , and leaues his reader to imagine of himself that it was for religiō . For something it was , but that it was for religiō be could not make manifest , for that this Lady in al the tyme of the raigne or her sister , dayly did heare Masse , went vsually to Confession , and in all points shewed her selfe a Catholike ; yea three weekes after she was proclaymed Queene she had Masse in her own Chappell in the Court , and permitted it to be sayd in all Churches throughout the whole realme for the space of seauen monethes after , which is no signe of being so resolue da Protestant as that she would suffer imprisonment for that religion . Her troubles , in very deed , were for sundry offences against Queene Mary her sister ; which being found to be such , as might perhaps haue cost her her life , if they had come vnto publique triall of Iustice ; the King of Spayne was so greatly her freind that he stayed the proceeding thereof , and so not only saued her life , but quit her also from the publike blot and stayne of treason : and heerin he was so earnest , that on a time , when she was to haue come to her answere , he did so importune Queene Mary his wyfe , to let the matter passe in sylence , that she sayd vnto him , My Lord , You speake very earnestly now for her , but I pray God she do not one day make you repent it . A certaine Spainsh Author wryteth that the King was therevnto also moued vpon some consideration of state : for Queen Mary of Scotland being then maryed vnto the french king Francis the second if the Lady Elizabeth had dyed , there had in apparence byn great possibility that the Kingdomes of England , Scotland and Ir●land might come to haue beene annexed vnto France , the sayd Queene of Scotland being the next heyre in bloud vnto them all . Queene Mary of England at last hapning to dy , King Philip her husband , notwithstanding the caueat giuen him by his late deceased Queen , did so cōtinue his good affection vnto the now Queene Elizabeth , that being then in the Netherlands , he sent ouer vnto her Monsieur de Assonuile , to congratulate her aduancement , and to signify his gift vnto her of all Queen Maries Iewells , which being his owne , he might iustly haue detayned vnto himselfe , if he would . These Iewells she seemed very thankfully to receaue , and sayd vnto this Monsieur de Assonuile , that she thought her brother the King of Spayne might thinke much in her for change of religion ; but , quoth she , there is but little difference betweene his religion and ours , almost all that he hath in Latin we haue in English : and we do not as others do , for we mayntayne a clergy of Bishops and other Prelates , so vs we are in effect , as before . And whereas there was held a treaty of peace between the Spanish & French Kings vpon the taking of S. Quintins , the king of Spayn would yield vnto no agreement with the French , vnlesse it were also conditioned that Callis should be restored backe vnto Queen Elizabeth of England ▪ and heerin were his commissioners that treate● with the French so earnest , that in the end the french to be rid of their importunity were faygne to confesse vnto them , that they knew that they tooke more paynes then they were desyred to do ; for that the English had playnly told them that they had not set them on work in any such busynes ; which was a signe that they desired not to be beholding vnto the king their maister . Of which whē the king had knowledg , he stood no more vpon the rendring of Callis , but concluded his peace with the french without it , which as thinges did afterward fall out , proued a happy turne to himself . These proofes of this Kings good will vnto Queene Elizabeth being thus made manifest to the world , who would haue thought that she would not only haue omitted all signes of gratitude , but within a litle after , become an enemy to such a friend , yea and so great and capitall a one , as seldome any History can giue witnes of the like . Seeing then that no acts of gratitude are to be sought after ; let vs then see what effectes of emnity ensued insteed thereof . First then to begin withall ( omitting her refusall of the King of Spaynes kind endeauours for getting the French to restore vnto her the Towne of Callis ) we will returne vnto the duke of Alua & his expected prouisiō of money from Spayne , mentioned in the former Chapter . This prouision be●ng the summe of six hundred tho●sand Ducates , comming out of Spayne 〈◊〉 the Netherlands in the moneth of D●cember in the yeare 15●1 . was on the West coast of ●ngland seized vpon , and a●rested by the English . By meanes of which wrongfully detayning this money of the King of Spaynes , the D●ke of Alua was forced to demaund the tenth pennv of euery mans goods , that was of ability for his supply ; ●ut this demand of his ( caused chiefly thorough the said English arrest ) was cause of a far greater detriment vnto the King of Spayne , then that wrongfully deta●ned money came vnto : so as the one great wrong was the cause of another far greater . For heereupon all the Netherland people began to mutter , to shew a generall vnwillingnes vnto the so wide stretching of their purses ; the sediously affected took Occasion by her Forelockes , and to the feare of this taxe added the faygned feare of the bringing in of a Spanish Inquisition . One Monsieur de Lymmay , vnderstanding by detayning of the K. of Spaynes money in England , what hatred that Queen began to beare him , posteth out of France into ●ngland , where shewing his readynes to any rebellious attempt , receaued such encouragement by promise of ayde from thence , and such fit instructions , that he came ouer into Holland , and there on the first day of April in the yeare 1572. he surprised the towne of Briel , the first in all the Low Countryes , that set it selfe in open rebellion ; after whose example , Flushing , Enchusen , and others followed . Heereupon was made ouer out by England vnto these rebells by meanes of Syr Thomas Gressam threescore thousand pounds sterling to begin withall ; and presently after followed ouer with troopes of English forces , Morgan , Gilbert , and Che●●er ; and after these againe North , 〈◊〉 Ca●aish , and Norris , all made Coronels ; and comming thither with whole regiments , receaued from tyme to tyme great supplyes of money and forces from England , which grew afterward so heauy that for some ease in the sustayning of the whole ●urthen , it was deuised to draw the Duke of Alancon Brother vnto the French King Henry the third , into E●gland , vnder colour of treaty of a match betweene him and Queene Elizabeth : but in the end it proued an infortuna●e match betweene him , and the Lady Belgica ▪ for he was sent ouer into the N●therlands , & there made Anti ▪ Duke of Brabant , where his successe was such , as ret●ring from thence into France with dishonour , he there not long after , dyed of griefe . In this designement , the English saw their expectation greatly deceaued . For albeit K. Henry the third of France had refused to take the Hollanders parts , hating them for that cause which no Kinges can loue such people ; yet they thought by getting his owne brother aforesayd inuested in the Duchy of Brabant , he must then of necessity take his part . But the matter now falling out otherwise , the burden returned and remayned heauyer vpon the Queene and Realme of England then before . And the Prince of Orange soon after the death of the Duke of Alan●on being slayne , the Hollāders remayned as a body without a head , vntill the Queen of England sent ouer vnto them the Earle of Leycester , with great prouision both of men , and money , accompanyed with diuers Noblemen and Gentlemen of good accompt . And albeit this Earle afterward returned into England againe , yet continued she her ayding the Hollanders , both with men and money vnto her dying day . And it is thought by such as haue made calculation of this great and long continued charge , that she so oppressed and burthened her subiects for the Hollanders wars , that she had more money from them by Graunts & Subsides , & such other meanes , then had all the Kings of England from the tyme of the Conquest vnto her dayes , who had the greatest warres with France . And I haue heard some Lawyers affirme , that she did extremly wrong her poore Subiects , by sometymes pressing them , and sending them perforce to her seruice out of the Realme ; seeing , as they say , no Prince by the Lawes of the Realme can compell any of his subiectes to serue in warre , vnles it be for the defence of the Realme at home ▪ or for the recouery of some lost Patrimony of the Crowne abroad ; & seeing now that Holland was neuer knowne to haue beene any part of the patrimony of the Crowne of England , nor any pretence of iust war could be made by England to that end , it was the greater wrong and iniustice . And heere by the way I must also note vnto you , that at the beginning , for a long time of her ayding the Holland●rs , though she did disguisedly make shew of friendship & amity with Spayn , and had not only her Embassadour in Spayne , as the King of Spayne had his also in England ; and in all her publike Proclamations , wherein any mention happened to be made of Holland and the adiacent partes , she did alwayes call them , The Low Countreyes of her louing Brother the King of Spayne , & therby acknowledged that which she could not deny : yet euen at this very time she imployed Syr Francis Drake to robbe him of his treasure in the West Indyes , Don Bernardino de Mendoca remayning Ambassadour Ledger for the King of Spayne in England , both then and long after , yea euen at the very tyme when Drak was arriued home with his booty , ( which was in Nouember in the yeare 1580. ) and being all this while an eye witnesse not only of the sayd Queenes oppressing and impouerishing her own subiects at home , for the ayding of the foresayd Hollanders abroad , & rebellious subiectes of the King his Maister ; but of her sending forth also to robbe him , in his owne dominions , therby to ayde them vnlawfully with their Lords own treasure . If now from the first to the last , the deportement of the Queene of England towards the King of Spayne in the long continuance of so many great wronges and iniuryes , be but indifferently considered ; what man , though but of meane capacity can iudge , but in the end , he must needes be prouoked to do something against her , were it but in regard of Honour , he being a King so great and potent . And therefore it was no wonder , that after so many former yeares patience , he was in the end ( and that also with an addition of eight yeares forbearance ) after the taking of his aforsayd treasure ( in which tyme al detriments that could be done him , both by Sea & Land , besides the ayding also of Don Antonio ( the pretended King of Portugall ) being put in practise ) forced to prepare that great Armada against Englād by sea , which he did in the yeare 1588. though with no successe . And therefore , as I haue heard Strangers that are indifferent to both Nations , wonder very much , why there should be more hatred discouered now in a tyme of peace and amity , betweene England and Spayne , in the English Natiō to the Spanish , then in the Spanish to the English ( the English hauing giuen more cause a great deale for Spaniardes to hate them , then the Spainards haue giuen to Englishmen : ) So haue they likewise noted , that notwithstanding the misusage in England of the Spanish Ambassadour himselfe in his own person ; yet the Spanish in Spayne doe not for all this misuse the Ambassadour of England ; the cause whereof is the discreet consideration of the Spanish Nation , who can discerne this misusage to proceed from such pure-strayned Ministers , as are possessed with the fury of the spirit , or from the common debaushed people , that doe not consider , or haue not so much wit , as to think when they see a Spanish Ambassadour in England , that his Maiesty likewise hath an English Ambassadour in Spayne : Nor yet to set before their eyes the example of the carriage of the chiefe Nobility , and of the better and wiser sort towardes the sayd Ambassadour and Nation ; nor chiefly and aboue all his Maiestyes amity & friendship with the King of Spayne , and the feare of his indignation and punishment due vnto such barbarous insolencyes . CHAP. III. Whether England hath receaued any benefite by defending the quarrell of the Hollanders ; or whether the Hollanders haue endeauoured to deserue the friendship they haue receaued frō thence , or haue any way shewed themselues gratefull for it . TO examine and search out the benefits which England may haue receaued by meanes of the Hollanders , I know not whereor which way to begin . The Hollanders , or their friends may perhaps say , that it was a benefit great inough for the English to assist them , in reason of state , because thereby they kept out warre from their own Country . But what an excuse this is ? when as the English neuer needed to haue feared warre in their own country , but for their cause , and for taking their partes : for it was for their cause that the English seized vpon the six hundred thousand ducates which were sent out of Spayne to the Duke of Alua ; which was a capital cause of enmity , and indeed the only cause that enforced the sayd Duke to demand the tenth penny of the peoples goods , whereby the whole common multitude became disposed the sooner to rebellion . For the king of Spaynes money , was not detayned by the English vpon any couetous desire to haue it for themselues , but because the Duke Alua should not haue it to employ against the Hollanders , and that it might be transported from England vnto the Hollanders , & so come to be vsed by them against the sayd Duke , to whom it was sent to haue byn imployed against them for their Rebellion . But it may be further alleaged in excuse of the Hollanders , that they were so gratefull , as they offred vnto the Queen of England the Soueraignty of the Netherlandes , which benefit she would not accept of , and therefore it was not their fault that if she obtayned it not . To this may be sayd , that the Diuel offred to haue giuen Christ all the kingdoms of the world if he would haue worshipped him , and so was more liberall of giuing that which was none of his own , then were the Hollanders . But the Queen well knowing that by accepting this guift whereunto they had no right , she should haue been sure to haue drawn a perpetual warre , and the whole charge thereof vpon her shoulders , and therefore refused this their liberality ; yet was she willing notwithstanding to ayde them , without this obligation . And the reason was ; because she still retayned a hop to be wholy disburdned , or at least much holpen in the bearing this charge by France , or Germany , or by bringing the Hollanders to the full possession of the whole seuenteen Prouinces , wherby they might depend vpon themselues . It may also be alleaged , that she had the Cautionary Townes of Briel , Flushing & the other places , deliuered into her handes . True it is , she had so , and thereby enioyed the benefit of being at more expence both of men and money . Other benefits can I remember none ; nor can there be any found , & so will spare the labor to look any further after them : yet because ill turnes , and domages may more readily be discouered to haue heereby happened to the Queene and state of England , I shall set downe what in this kind I haue obserued . First then to begin with the afore mentioned Cautionary Townes , it appeareth , that because the Hollanders would so soone as they could , be the freer to set the English at naught , hauing by meanes of the Truce with the King of Spayne , and the Archduke Albert , gotten togeather some spared money ; they so laboured with their feed freind Sir Raph Winwood ( a better Hollander then an Englishman ) that for paltry payment they got their brydle out of the English handes , and thereupō began straightwayes to shew their gratitude in forbidding the bringing of English dyed , and dressed clothes into Holland , and their adioyned Prouinces , without euer making the king or his Ambassador Ledger at the Hage priuy thereunto . Soon after , to make amendes for this their saucy and vnmannerly carriage , they came to offer the Kings Maiesty himself a more insolent affront . For whereas the Duke of Lennox , as Admirall of Scotland , by order from the King , had sent one M. Brown in the yeare 1616. to demaund of the said Hollanders , then fishing vpon the coast of Scotland , a certayne ancient duty , called Size herring ; with much a do they payd it , as in former tymes it was accustomed ; but yet withsome speaches that it was the last tyme , that it should be payed . The same M. Browne cōming the yeare following with the same authority and commaundement , with one ship of the Kinges only to demaund the duty afo●esayd , and with order , that if it were denyed , he should take witnes of the refusal in writing , and so peaceably depart ; being come aboard one of their ships , and demanding the aforesayd duty , he was by the Maister therof denyed it , who told him playnly that he was commaunded by the States of Holland not to pay it vnto the King any more , of which he tooke witnes according to his order from his Maiesty . Whyles this was a doing , there comes aboard that ship , the Maister of of another ship of Holland , & demaunding of M. Brown his name , he replyed that his name was Browne : Why then ( quoth he ) if you be the man , I haue order to arrest you , and to carry you into Holland : whereof M. Brown gaue notice to the Maister of the Kings ship , requyring him to aduertise his Maiesty of this insolency , and so M. Brown was arested and carryed away prisoner into Holland . About this tyme , as I also haue heard it credibly reported , one M. Archibald Rantkin a Scottish gentleman residing at Stockholme in Sweden , & there soliciting for the payment of certayne money due vnto some Londō Merchāts ; one Van ▪ dyke lying there also as Agent for the States of Holland , sayd vnto some principal persons of the Swedians , that they needed not be to hasty in paying the king of Englands subiects any money , or to giue them any respect , for that the sayd Kinges promises , were not to be belieued , nor his threates to be feared . For which villanous and insolent speaches , being afterward challenged by Rantkin , he had no better excuse then to say , he was drunke when he spake them ( for deny them he could not ) and so his excuse of playing the beast , excused him for playing the man. But now from these insolent affronts and speaches , let vs come to deeds , and see how they haue vsed our English Nation in the North seas , on the coast of Groonland & those partes , about the trayn-oyle fishing , where they haue offred them sundry abuses by giuing them blowes , chasing them away , and doing vnto them diuers oth●● detriments ; not admitting to vnderstand that the sea fishing is free for euery man , where it is not vpon the coast of any Countrey , vnto which the benefit belongeth by ancient prerogatiue . And yet is all this but little in regard of their vsage of our Nation in the East Indyes , wher they haue as fiercely set vpon them with open hostility , as if before their meeting there , they had of long continuance beene mortall enemyes , hauing slaine many of our men , and sunke sundry of our shipps . And when moreouer they haue taken some of our men prisoners , they haue vsed them , in the sight of the Indians , in such contemptible and disdainefull manner , as if at home in their owne Countryes , the English in respect of them were but an abiect and a slauish Nation ; and that the Hollanders were either their Superiours , & might vse them at their pleasure , or the English so base and vnpowerfull , as they durst not be reuenged , but quietly put vp any iniury at their handes . And indeed the Indians might in reason coniecture that the Hollanders would neuer haue dared so to domineer ouer the English abroad , if they had not had the maistery of them at home ; after which accounpt & reckoning such actions abroad are wont to be looked into . What thinke you now of our English Prouerbe ? Haue we not brauely set beggers on horsbacke ? Nay haue not Englishmen ( the premises considered ) great reason to loue the Hollanders , and to hate Spaniards ? Yea , and to hate Spaniards only for the loue of such courteous & gratefull Hollanders ? And as for the commodious trade which the English haue had in Muscouy for more then threescore and ten years , and which the Hollanders haue now quite gotten from the●● , and spoyled , what shall I say ? Seeing they are about to make recompence for the same by doing the like with our English Merchants in Turky . And it is a thing so naturall & notorious for them to spoile the trade of other Nations , that when they cannot find occasion to do it , they will not sticke to spoile one another , so great is their auaricious and insatiable desire of gayne ; and yet all this proceedeth but out of a certain couetous wretchednes ; for , let any of them arriue to what riches he will , he knoweth not how to be Noble or Generous . CHAP. IIII. Whether England can expect any benefite by continuing to take the Hollanders parts ; and whether the Hollanders doe deserue the same , by wishing , or desiring the continuance of the State and Gouernement of England , as now it standeth . THE end and scope whereunto the rebellious wars of the Hollanders haue tended , hath beene to bring themselues into as free and qu●et a State as is the Republique of the Switzers , which they might haue easily done by the help they haue had from England & France , if the King of Spayne had wanted the meanes or the will to haue continued warre against them . But admit they had arriued vnto this their designe and had freely and quietly gotten the full possession of all the seauenteene Netherland Prouinces , is it not like that they would then haue gotten into their clawes the Duchyes of Cleue , & Iuliers , with the other parts theron dependant , seeing they haue already gotten fotting therin ? And hauing once incorporated these , is it like , that they would haue suffered the Countrey of Liege to haue remained in quiet , vnder the Rule of a Bishop ? When as the colour of reformation of Religion had also beene sufficient for the taking away of the Countrey from the true owner ? Or may a man thinke , that they would stand vpon titles of right , who hold not the least place they possesse by any right at all ? Or that they would make a conscience to detayne from their Neighbour , when they make none to detayne from their true Lord , and Maister ? Surely there is no reason to think other wayes : and yet if any man should , let him but looke into their attempt vpon Huys , & also vpon Liege the principall Citty of that Countrey , not long since put in practise . Put the case then , that they had arriued vnto their desired greatnes , that is to say , to haue gotten the whole seauenteene Netherland Prouinces with the Duchyes of Cleue and Iuliers , & the rest thereunto dependant , as also the Countrey of Liege ; how would they thē haue borne themselues towards England and France ? How had they then beene able to haue giuen law to both these kingdomes ; to the one by land , from the Countrey of Liege cōfining vpon it , and to the other by sea , by being able to ouertop it in shipping ? what doubt may be made heereof , considering what a correspondent party they would haue found in France by their most confident friends the Huguenots , and in England by no lesse friendes the Puritans ? Who cannot now discerne that the King of Spayne , by continuance of war against the Hollanders , hath highly benefited both England and France ; and that England and France by assisting the Hollanders against the King of Spayne , haue laboured to their owne cost . What policy might it then haue proued for England and France , if the Hollanders had by their help preuayled against the King of Spayne , when they should therby haue prepared an irremediable scourge for themselues . Let it then be truely considered , whether it had not been greater policy , more honorable , & more profitable , for both those Nations , and more for the tranquility of Christendome , that they had suffred the King of Spayne to haue brought these his rebellious subiects to obedience , and so to haue gouerned them in peace , to the end he might haue imployed so many millions , as he hath beene forced to spend in the Netherlād warres , against the Turke . And that so he would haue done , if he might heere haue inioyed rest and quiet , who can doubt ? Seeing notwithstanding these his long wars , and all other wars therby occasioned , both by sea and land , he hath , to his euerlasting prayse and honour , neuer made either peace or Truce with that capitall enemy of Christendome . And if those forsayd many millions might haue bin implo●ed against this common enemy , who can make doubt , but he might thereby not only haue beene driuen out of Europe , but that Hierusalem , and all Palestine might haue beene recouered ? England , as hath beene sayd in the precedent Chapter , hath already receaued proofe of the ingratitude of her costly Holland friends ; and France no lesse , by hauing not long since discouered them to be more ready to take their partes that were in armes against the now regnant King , then the Kinges part against them . And if they had been so wary as to haue dissembled som what longer their ingratitude & insolencyes towards England and France , yet their audacious brauing of the King of Denmark ( notwithstanding they must passe with all their corne from Danske throgh his Sownd ) were inough to haue discouered their proud contempt of the maiesty of Kinges ; and what Neighbours they would haue proued to England & France , when they should haue arriued to their expected freedome of an absolute Republike . Let it then be considered , whether England or France , could euer feare to be so much endomaged by Spayne , as by them ; or that Spayne could haue so ready meanes to endomage thē , as the Hollanders ; or could haue correspondence in either Countrey with two such turbulent factions . Thus may England as well by example of the Hollanders ingratitude to France , as by the deere purchased experience in it selfe , cleerely behould what apparence there may be of expectation of any least benefite by their meanes ; since none can be found , none be looked for , albeit they were sought after with the lanterne of Diogenes . If therefore no benefits can appeare , either past or to be expected , let vs then see what good fortune hath otherwise betyded such as haue beene the gretest actors in this rebellious busines , whereby it may appeare to the World , how their endeauours haue beene pleasing to God. The first man that began the surprize and open rebellion of Townes in Holland , was the aforenamed Monsieur de Lymmay . This man amongst other presents which were giuen him , when he was in England , one was a very faire great mastiffe Dog , which he much esteemed ; and on a tyme playing with him , he bitte him so soare in the arme , that he could by no meanes be cured , but in the end dyed thereof , starcke mad , and raging , in the Towne of Liege . And thus came he to his death by being bitten of a Dog , that had beene a wolfe vnto many Ecclesiasticall persons , whose bloud without all forme of lustice , or any offence by them committed , he had caused to be shed , aswell in the Towne of Briel which he surpryzed , as in other places . The next great Actor in this ill busynes was the Duke of Alancon also before mentioned . This Duke after he had in the Citty of Antwerp beene inuested in the Duchy of Brabant , as absolute Soueraigne ; fynding not withstanding that he was to be limitted & gouerned by such as he accompted his subiects ; & seeking thereupon to make his authority more absolute , drew certayne troopes of his souldiers into the Town to haue surpryzed it , himself being with his whole army hard without , who , through the resistance of the Townesmen , were all put to the sword . Whereupon he with his whole army ( the Artillery from the walles of the Towne playing vpon him ) was forced to retyre thence in extreme disgrace , and melancholy , as a defeated enemy ; and in the end to returne into France , where considering the tricks that had by n put vpon him in England , and what disgrace he had therby receaued in Flanders , on the 10. day of Iune in the yeare 1584. he dyed of conceaued griefe , in the town of Chastea● Theiry , and so lost his faire possibility of wearing the crown of France , vnto which he was the apparent Heyre . The next and chiefest styrrer in this busynes , was William of Nassaw , Prince of Orāge , who because he was the Arch-rebell , or principall Actor in this great rebellion of all other , I hold it not vnfit , before I come to speak of his death , briefly to run ouer the thinges of most note in his life . This Prince , as in the first Chapter hath byn sayd , retyred himself into Germany so soone as he heard of the Duk● of Alua his aryuall in the Netherlandes ; and albeit he came afterwards backe agayne to push forward his begun rebellion ; yet was he fayne to fly the second tyme into Germany , from whence when he heard that the Town of Briel , and one or two more were openly rebelled , he came secretly backe into Holland , and being in very poore and bare estate , he took vp his lodging in the Town of Tergow , in the howse of one Kegeling an Apothecary , keeping himselfe very secret , because this town as yet held for the king of Spayn , as also did all the other Townes of the Country except two or three . But the Duke of Alua his demaunding the tenth penny aforesayd , hauing bred a generall disgust and auersion in the myndes of the people ; certayne scouts of rebellion were secretly imployed abroad in the Country to sound the people about their forwardnes to reuolt . Which being done , answere was returned that they were found to be the●unto ready inough , so they might haue a head , but who this head should be , that knew they not . The Prince of Orange heerupō , in whose behalfe these scouts had beene imployed , called a consultation of some fyue or six irreligicus Politikes ( for such best fitted to be his counsellours ) to consider what religion he were best to be of , for of all the religions now currant he could not be ; and not declaring himself to be of one , all might hold him to be of none . For he had so caryed himself vntil this day , that the Catholikes held him affected to them ; The Lutherans to them ; The Anabaptists to them ; And the Caluinists also to them . The Catholikes tooke him for their freind , because they thought him not to hate their religion , but indifferently well to affect it , in regard that he had beene brought vp in it , long professed it , and had made as yet no open opposition or profession against it ; and for that he protested to vndergo this busynes for the mayntayning of their rightes and priuiledges , and to free the Countrey from that terrible exaction of the tenth penny aforesayd . The Lutherans tooke him for their frend , because they held him in hart to be of their religion , since he had maryed the daughter of the Duke of Saxony , who was now a Lutheran , in publique profession ; and that he must in reason keep good correspondence with the Lutherans of Germany , in hope of hauing ayde from them . The Anabaptists tooke him as greatly to fauor their religion , because his Chamberlayne being the chiefest man about him , was an Anabaptist , ( called of his fellow Anabaptists by the name of Mardochaeus ) by whose meanes this Prince became greatly beholding vnto them , for the loane of sundry good summes of money , which he had receaued of them . The Caluinists thought him assuredly their friend , because he was an enemy vnto Spayne & Spaniards , and because he could not but see them more forward in action of Rebellion , then any of the others ; seeing Briel and other Townes were already surpryzed by those of their Nation and Religion . The aforesayd Counselours considering that this indifferent carriage of the Prince , could but argue a dispersed affection , & might breed many iealousies and factions , and wherby he could not procure to himselfe the assured affection of any one syde to sticke fast vnto him ; their resolution must now be taken without longer delay , of which of these he would declare himself absotely to be , albeit he might promise fauour and protection to the rest . There was no great need of learned Deuins to dispute the matter , Scriptures and ancient Fathers were not important to be looked after , Faith and Conscience had heerin no clayme , and Reason of State did put the Holy Ghost to silence . It was therfore first debated whether it were best & most for this Prince his aduantage to declare himselfe a Catholike , because the face of the State was yet Catholike . To this was alleaged , that if he should so do by fauouring all opposite to the Catholikes , the Catholikes would therfore disfauour him , seeing the other through his fauour would insult vpon them : and so might there be danger of their returning to the obedience of the King of Spayne , whom thev were sure was of their religion , and would mayntayne them in it . All which considered , it was not thought fitting for him to declare himself to be a Catholike To declare himself a Lutheran , was also thought vnsit , because the Duke of Saxony , albeit a Lutheran , was yet a freind vnto the Emperour , and the howse of Austria ; and besides the Lutherans were but flegmatike & cold fellowes , and too farre offto giue him assistance , if need should require . To declare himselfe an Anabaptist , was held lesse fitting , for albeit they had shewed more heat of zeale , in their greater number that had suffred for their religion , then any of the others ; yet were they but of the meaner sort of people , not hauing any potent persons among them , nor any forrayne Prince or State to take their partes . In fine it was resolued that it was most conuenient for him to declare himself a Caluinist , in regard of their stirring spirits , whereof they had giuen greater proof then any of the others , & that there was apparence of assistance from England , and of good correspondence with the Huguenots of France . Vpon this resolution , followed straight-wayes the conuersion of this Prince of Orange vnto Caluinian-Protestant religion ; and his new gayned greatest friendes so bestirred themselues , that Town vpon Town rebelled especially after he had by solemne Oath sworne to mayntayne the Catholike Clergy in all their rights and priuiledges , and in publike exercise of their Religion ▪ about which point yet the town of Amsterdam amongst others , very precysely capitulated with him , and he very seriously also protested and swore performance of the conditions : which Oath notwithstanding he made no more conscience soone after to breake , then he had done sundry oathes before ; as the great and solemne Oath which he tooke of Fidelity to the King of Spayne , when he receaued the Order of Knight-hood of the golden Fleece ; the Oath of fidelity , which he also tooke at the sayd Kings making him Lieftenant Gouernour of Holland &c. besydes his sundry other perfidious breaches both of oaths and promises . And because there is not any fidelity or honest dealing to be expected , where there is layd no ground of Religion and vertue it is the lesse wonder that this irreligious Noble Man so caryed himself in choyce of religion . Certayne it is , that he was at the first a Catholike ; and notwithstanding that his malice had transported him so farre , as to protect and shelter some most sacrylegious Church-robbers ; yet vpon the aryuall of the Duke of Alua , and before his flight into Germany , he sent for his eldest some Philip ( who was Prince of Orange next after him ) at that tyme a student in the Vniuersity of Louayne , and most straightly charged him , to liue and dye in the Catholike Roman Religion , as the sayd Prince hath at sundry tymes to diuers persons yet lyuing protested ; wherby it may seem , that at that tyme he had yet retayned some regard of religion ; and holding that for the best , commaunded his sonne to remayne still therin . Foure wyues he had , the first was a Catholyke , the second was a Lutheran , the third and fourth were Caluinists ; which perchance was because he found no noble woman fit for him to match withall that was an Anabaptist , that so he might haue had foure wyues of foure seuerall Religions ; yet to shew his great good wil vnto the Anabaptists ( albeit he could not match amongst them ) he gaue them vnder his hand wryting the priuiledge & freedome for exercise of their religion in their own howses , which they yet in Holland enioy . When I consider the life and actiōs of this man , I wonder in my self , that the blyndnes of the popular multitude , could be so great , as to honor and extol him so highly , and to accompt him the great Patron and Protectour of their Country , that was the greatest enemy therof that euer it had ; and who was the cause of spilling so much bloud , aswell of the people of his owne Country , as of other Nations ; and such an one as was the betrayer , & transporter also thereof , vnto another Nation , as much as in him lay , who had no right or clay me thereunto . To come now to touch the end of this man , when I cōsider , I say , what it was , there commeth to my remembrance this saying of a Pagan Poet : Tyraennous Lords , that cause Landes to rebell , VVithout some blow , can hardly come to Hell. About some foure yeares before the death of this Prince , he was for his offences depriued by the sayd King of Spayne his soueraigne Lord , of all the authority and power which in former tymes the sayd King had giuen him , & proclaymed for a publike enemy vnto the King , the peace , and Weal-publike of the Countrey ; and his goods & person exposed to open violence by publique sentence . In the end after some attempts to that effect , the Prince perceauing , what victorious successe the Duke of Parma ( that then vnder the King of Spayne commanded in the Netherlands ) now began to haue in Flaunders , and Brabant , he fled secretly , from Antwerp ( where he had layne lurcking for a time ) vnto Delft in Holland , in his Armour ; for it was the greatest prayse ( forsooth ) that this valiant Captayne atchieued in these warres , that he did commonly put on his Armour when he was eight or ten leagues from any place of danger . Being arriued at Delft , where he thought himselfe in greatest safety , he was vpon the tenth day of Iuly in the same yeare 1584. slayne with the shot of a Pistoll , by one Ealtazar Gerard ( aliâs Serach ) a Burgundian , of the age of fiue and twenty yeares , a moneth after that the Duke of Alancon dyed at Chasteau-Theiry ; for the Duke dyed on the tenth of Iune , & this Prince was slayne on the tenth of Iuly next following , as though his life had beene limitted by lease , to last but iust one moneth after the death of the other . The next of the greatest Actors in this rebellious Tragedy , was Robert Dudley Earle of ●eycester , who after he had beene the chiefe Commaunder of Holland , in these broyles ( in which wa● slaine his sisters Sonne Syr Philip Sidney , a Knight worthy to haue deserued more Honour , if he had serued in an honourable cause ) he grew weary of the Hollanders , and they of him ; in so much , that by a iustification of his worthlesse actions published in Print , he was driuen to accuse & blame them of breach of promise and performance of couenants made vnto him , that so by laying the fault vpon thē , he might repaire his owne reputation , and excuse of gayning so little honour among them as he had . Returning therefore with great discontentment into England , he soone after sickned and dyed , and as it is reported was poysoned , and preuented by one whome himselfe had thought by such a meanes to haue made away . He dyed without any signe of a Christian ; and being dead seemed so vgly a corse , as euen amazed the beholders . His body was opened and in his stomake were great holes eaten through with the poyson . His Landes were all presently seized on for his debts to the Queene , whereby he was now , as much disgraced being dead , as he would perhaps haue beene , if he had liued but a little longer ; and as his life was not much laudable , so was his death not greatly lamented . The next in this ●anke must be Queene Elizabeth her selfe , by whose meanes , as this rebellion at the first began , so was it by her ayd ( euen to her last end ) continued . And if a happy death be the true happynes of the precedent life , she cannot be sayd to haue had it , neither in regard of the good of her selfe , nor yet of her subiects ; for she sought not the one , and she had not the other . She sought not the good of her subiects , which in all reason and right she was bound to do , both before God mā , because she prohibited both speach , and euen the knowledge as it were , of any successor to her Crowne , as all the world well knoweth . In so much , that if some of the Nobility , presently vpon her death , had not resolued to receaue vnto her Crowne & dignity the true & lawfull Heyre that now raigneth , the bloud of many thousandes of her subiects might haue beene spilt , for ought she did to preuent it . Some do report her to haue sayd , that whyles she liued no Heyre apparent should be de●lared ; and after her death , she wished that she might for a while remayne betweene heauen & earth , to see how they would tugge for the Crown . Surely the desire of seeing such a sport could litle deserue the loue that her subiects bo●e vnto her ; and heerby may we see , vpon how little cause and reason , vulgar affection is oftentymes grounded . That her death was not happy , appeareth , in that it is no happynes to dye distracted , and not to haue had , from the beginning to the end of her sicknes , the perfect vse of reason , and consequently not to haue beene able most earnestly to call vpon God ; which as it is most fit that at their end , a●l men should doe , so is it most requisite , that in the end of a life which hath been entertayned with all the pleasures that the World could affoard , it should be done with the greatest compunction & contrition of hart that may be ▪ And I haue heard it confidently reported , that Syr Thomas Gressam , more then thirty yeares before Queene Eliza●eths death , did in priuate discourse , tell vnto some friends of his , and namely vnto Syr Philip Scidamore ( then not Knight ) that at the death of Queene Mary , he then being in the Citty of Antwerp , a woman comming into a house where he was , sayd vnto him : Your Queene Mary is now dead and Queene ●lizabeth that succeedeth her , shall in the end come to dye mad . Whether this woman had the spirit of prophesy , or no , I cannot say ; but certaine it is that she seemed not in her sicknes , nor at her death to be in her perfect senses , whe●eby she could neither be carefull for the future good of her subiects , by not then declaring that which she needed not any longer to haue concealed ; nor in calling vpon Almighty God , for mercy , for a soule that so greatly had need thereof . Let vs now lastly come vnto the great Statesman , and Menager of this State composed of States , the Holland-aduocate Berneuelt . This man after the death of the Prince of O●ange aforesayd , when his sonne Count Mauri●e , and his other children were but young , and the State and gouernment wholy raw and out of order , deuised and set down the plot and meanes for the mayntayning of it in the forme of a Republike : he made the alliances between it , and other Princes and States abroad , and became a most careful Tut or for the bringing vp of the Prince of Orange his children ; yet in the end about realousies and wranglings grown vp among themselues , this great Aduocate of Holland , and Sterne-holder of that whole State , hauing deserued so well thereof as any man could , came to dye on a scaffold , as a criminall malefactor , by the handes of the hangman ; whereby the King of Spayne , and their Highnesses the Princes of the Netherlands , whome he had most offended , and had not the meanes to punish him , did see him punished by those whome himself had most serued in offending them . Some may heer a●leage that the Archduke Matthias , who afterward came to be Emperor , had beene a chief Commaunder and gouernour also ouer this rebellious faction , and yet came not to any vnfortunate end . To this I answere , that true it is , this Prince had such a charge layed vpon him , when by reason of his youth he wanted iudgment perfectl● to descern what he did , William of Nassaw the vnhappy Prince of Orange before mentioned , being his chief Lieftenant vnder him , and the only man that disposed of al. And yet escaped this yong Archduk not without disgrace among thē , when they neither cared for him , nor much respected him ; & in their ordinary speaches gaue him the name of their Foster chyld , esteeming him but as a chyld , or as a cipher that only serued to supply a place . But in the end this noble Prince discouering their vniust courses & his own errour , left thē , and gaue ouer that mistaken gouernment , and retyring himselfe into Germany , sought , and found meanes to reconcile himself vnto his Cousin the King of Spayne , whose grace and fauour he obtayned , which none of the former that came to vnfortunate endes , euer sought for . And by this meanes all former soars were salued , & this Prince by leauing to follow this wrong course , was not only freed from comming to an vnfortunate or disgracefull end , but came to dy as a good Christian Prince , and in the most high estate of an Emperour . Thus haue I heere briefly related vnto you , how ill they haue sped , who haue beene the chiefest Actors in so ill a busines as is rebellion , & the assisting of rebels against their most iust and lawfull Soueraigne ; what may succeed to others , that do , or intend to continue the same vniust course , must be reserued to the manifestation of tyme ; but apparent it is , by that which heere hath been shewed , that the most high and supreme Ruler of all , hath , by permitting these their disgracefull endes , shewed his dislike of their actions ; & contrarywise to such as haue beene obedient to his will , his benediction hath been manifest in a copious manner . The benefits then which England might expect by continuing to take the Hollanders partes , must be vnderstood to be , endles Charges , great Dishonour , and the high Displeasure of Almighty God , togeather with the Hollanders recompensing the same with contemptuous ingratitude ; which are motiues to mooue mad men to be their friendes . Some may perhaps suppose the Hollanders to deserue the same in regard of a kind of loue and affection which they beare vnto that State , albeit no effect or shew of good deeds to proue it , doth anv way breake out . This inuisible affection , must then be imagined to consist in a true desire they haue to the countiuuance of the present State & Gouernement as now it standeth . Les vs then see how likely it is , by first of al calling into consideration the affection they manifest themselues to beare vnto our Kings Maiesty of England ; for this ought to giue the first and best light vnto this great obscurity . Surely , if I should relate vnto you what myne owne eares haue heard in this point , you would stand amazed . Respect of conscience and duty , doth not permit me to repeate those most odious Epithets which without any r●spect of Maiesty , are euery where common in these rebellious Hollanders mouthes And I protest vnto you , that I verily thinke , they did neuer more spytefully raile against the King of Spayne , whome they hold for their greatest enemy . Their wordes , as I sayd , I will not repeate , for feare least an alleadger of the calumnyes of others , might be taken for a subtil calumniator himselfe : but if you doubt of the truth heerof , make further enquiry of such , as since the late famous battaile fought in Bohemia , haue come out of Holland into England ; for there want no witnesses to affirme this to be true . And if you shall chance to meet with One who for affection to the Hollanders , will rather dissemble then confesse the truth , especially being demaunded therof in Englād ; I doubt not but you wil meet with Two , who will affirme it , and withall confesse that there is not any remedy to ●h●rme their durty mouthes , and much lesse to any purpose for an Englishman to oppose himselfe against the lauish tongues of such an vnbridled multitude of cocks crowing vpon their own dunghil . And who can otherwise imagine , but that they who are in authority amongst them , be content that the common sort doe speake that which themselues also thinke , and in priuate speake the same , as well as they , seeing in publike they shew no dislike therof . That the Hollanders do desire the continuance of the present State , and Gouernement of the Realme , as now it standeth , by wishing the long raigne of his Maiesty of England , and of the Prince his Highnes after him , who can imagine ; since all their dri●ts do wholy tend to their owne ends ; and that the Count Pa●atine , by his Mothers side is of the house of Nassaw , to which house of all othe● vpon earth they are most deuoted : and that by the sayd Count Palatine his attayning to the Crown of Englād , diuers of the same house that want liuings as wel in Holland , as in the Duchy of Bullion , as also in other places , might come to be aduāced in England . And no doubt , since the Count Palatine hath already had the tast of one Crowne , they will the more desire the pleasing of hi● appetite with another . The religion of England they also like not , and therefore in regard of a more pure and perfect Reformation , they do out of zeale and conscience the lesse desyre the continuāce of the State , as it is . Their freindes the Puritanes , haue long since giuen them to vnderstand how ilfauour●dly the Religion of England is now reformed ; and what great want they haue of a Holland-discipline , and such a worshipfall Consistory of Church-counsellours as they h●ue there in euery of their Townes . They haue also enformed them of the great lyuings that certayne men in England do possesse , who beare the name of Bishopes , and whose large reuenewes would fall out very fit for sundry poore Countes of the aforesayd howse of Nassaw , to begin withall , til confiscation of English Noblemens lyuinges might be able to make them the more capable of the titles of Dukes and Princes . And this being matter to reflect vpon , I will so leaue it vnto your further ponderation , and proceed to giue you satisfaction according to your demaund in the rest . CHAP. V. Of the present state of the Hollanders ; and of the diuision among them about matters of Religion : and whether respect of Religion may vrge England still to assist them . THAT the Hollanders haue a will to continue their warres , to the end that at last they might in quiet possession attayne to their wished great Republike , of the whole seauenteene Netherland Prouinces , with such adiacent and Anseaitcke places as they could come to incorporate and annexe vnto them , there is no doubt : but their want of meanes to vndergoe this charge , wherof no end can be determined , is also out of doubt . It is now about some two yeares ago that I saw a note of calculation made of their debts , which then appeared to be about six millions of florins , for the which they payed , & do yet yearly pay interest . It is not lyke that this debt is diminished , but that it is rather , since that tyme , much augmented ; besydes theyr yearely ch●rge of mayntayning their presidies , and fortifications , they haue beene at a great deale of lost cost in their monethly great summes of money disbursed for the ayding of the Count ▪ Palatine . Their meanes and trafficke of marchandize is well known to be nothing so good as it hath beene , and dayly to declyne to worse and worse ; for they haue not only had ex●reme losses by pirates , but haue shewed themselues so vnpartiall , that because the English Merchants should not thinke them only bent to spoyle their trade ▪ they spoyle their trading amongst them selues ; in so much that Holland doth not only spoile the trading of Zeland , but euen in Holland they dayly study to spoile the trade one of another : so as it hath beene noted , that when in Amsterdam it selfe , some Merchant hauing gotten priuate aduice from his correspondent els where , that in such or such a place , such and such a commodity will be well vented , and that this Merchant thereupon fraighteth a ship with wares accordingly ; another that perceaueth him to be fraighting , though not knowing whither his voyage is intended , will straight wayes , and with all diligence fraight a ship also with the self same wares , and follow and dogge him by sea , till he arriue to the same Hauen vnto which the other is bound ; and so by hindering of his gaine catch away the bread out of his mouth . And as by this , so by all other wayes and meanes , ●ch one seeks to spoyke and hinder another ; for all will be Merchants , aswell the Boores in the Villages , as the Burgers in the Towne . This then trading then thus hindred what by Pyrats , what by the multitude of Merchants , and other wayes spoyled , they cannot draw sufficient meanes for the maintenance of warre only out of toles and customes ; neither can it be raysed by taxes and impositions layd vpon the people , they being already more heauily burdened that way , then they are able to beare ; and farre beyond the tenth penny which the Dulde of 〈◊〉 demaunded . What remedy then ? 〈◊〉 loanes and borrowings be requyred of the best monyed Merchants ▪ 〈◊〉 . The Catholikes , the Arminians , & the Anabaptists , which haue the best purses , haue little reason for it . The Catholikes and the Arminians are forbidden the exercise of their religion , and they will rather goe and reside out of the Countrey . The Anabaptists that haue exercise in their houses cannot beare the burden alone ; and if all these th●ee would be willing to lend , how could ●bis lending continue , when they shall see their money still cast into a bottomles pit of expences , where there can be no hope of getting it out againe ; and so shall they be sure to find , who doe assist thē , if after the now approaching expiration of the Truce , warres do begin againe . Thus hauing briefly deliuered vnto you my conceyt of their present meanes ; I will now also endeauour to giue you satisfaction to your demaund about their so great difference in Religion . I do not meane the great difference that is between Sect and Sect , for that is beyould all calculation ; but the late great difference risen vp among the Holland-Protestants themselues . You shall then vnderstand that about the yeare 1607. one Iacobus Arminius a Doctor and professor of Protestant Religion at Leyden ( according as it is there professed ) did , after that he had , diuers yeares belieued and taught as they did , begin to fall into further consideration then before he had done of certayne points of their doctrine , and especially their doctrine of Predestination , which is , That God hath absolutely and precysely chosen and ordayned some people to saluation , and some to damnation , before themselues haue either done good or euill : And that to those whome God , of an absolute will , hath ordayned to pe●dition , he hath determyned to deny , and actually doth deny , the grace which is needfull and sufficient for Saluation , so as they neither can , nor may belieue or be saued . Against this doctrine Arminius opposed himself , affirming the same to be contrary to the Nature of God , as repugnant to his Wisdome , to his Iustice , and to his Goodnes . That it also is against the Ghospel , which commaundeth conuersion and beliefe , and promiseth the grace of the holy Ghost , Remission of sinnes , and euerlasting Lyfe . And that which is more , it impugneth Free will , with which , and in the which , man was by God created . Moreouer it hindreth the diligence vnto the doing of good workes ; for ( sayth he ) man being driuen ( as these mayntayners of this Predestination affirme ) by meanes of the safe-making grace , then must he worke , and cannot leaue so to do ; but not being driuen by the same grace , he cannot so do , but must leaue it vndon . Thus doth Arminius refute the commō Caluinian opinion in the doctrin of Predestination , and teacheth playnly , that man hath Free-wil , and sheweth that good works are needfull to Saluation ; affirming also that the contrary doctrine to these points , doth ouerthrow and quyte destroy the foundatiō of Religion , as further may be seen in his declaration printed at Leyden in the yeare 1610. Arminius himselfe dyed , before this his declaration came forth in print ; but certayne Ministers that imbraced his doctrine , did after his decease cause it to be printed ; and these men proceeding forward in the same doctrine , and fynding many of the most learned ministers to imbrace it , and many thousandes of people , which dayly more and more increase , ready to receaue it ; they wrote sundry Books in defence thereof , wherin they gaue themselues the name of Remonstrantes . Heerupon some of the Ministers that remayned in the former and direct Caluinian opinion , writing against them , called themselues the Contra-Remonstrants : but because the common people called those that followed the opinion of Arminius aforesayd , by the name of Arminians , the otherside gaue vnto the Contra-Remonstr●nts , the name of Gomarists ; because of all other who opposed themselues against the opinion of Arminius , one Franciscus Gomarus was the first and chiefest . And albeit the sayd Gomarus taught not otherwise then did Caluin , or do other Caluinists ; yet are those of his side called by many in Holand , and generally in all the Netherlands by the name of Gomarists , except by themselues ; for they call not themselues Protestants , but The Reformed , as they did before this discord fell out . About this difference in Religiō there hath beene between them very many bickeringes , and virulent bookes and pamphlets haue beene written on both sydes , the one against the other . But because it would perhaps be too tedious to make but recitall of their titles in ●his place , I wil therfore heere only set down vn to you , what I haue translated out of a certayne printed table , concerning three of the pointes of Religion which are in controuersy between them , wherby you may see what places of Scripture are alleaged abou● these pointes by the Armintans ; and what Caluin and the Gomarian Caluinists alleage to the contryry . The first point is , Whether God hath created any people vnto damnation . Places of Scripture alleaged by the Arminians to proue that he hath not . Genes . 1. vers . 27. And God created man to his owne Image ; to the Image of God he created him . And vers . 31. And God saw al things that he had made , and they were all very good ▪ Psal . 145 vers . 9. The Lord is louing vnto euery man , and his mercy is aboue all his workes . Isay 45. vers . 22. Turne you vnto me , so shall you be saued , all yee ends of the earth . Ezech. 33. vers . 11. As true as I liue , sayth the Lord , I haue no pleasure in the death of the vngodly , but that the vngodly do turn from his wickednes & liue . Turne you therefore now from your wickednes ; why will you then dye , you of the house of Israel ? Ioan. 4. vers . 10. 11. You pitty the stalke of the wild grape , whereon you haue not laboured , nor haue nourished it , which is growne vp in one night , & is againe withered : And should not I then take pitty on the great Citty of Niniue , in which are more then one hūdred and twenty thousand soules , who know no difference betweene the right hand and the left . Matth. 11. vers 28. Come yee to me all that labour , and are burdened , and I will refresh you . Marc. 16. vers . 15. 16 Going into the whole world , preach the Ghospell to al creatures ; he that belieueth , and is baptized , shall be saued ; and he that belieueth not , shal be condemned . Luc. 2. vers 30. 31. Myne eyes ( sayth Simeon ) haue seen thy saluation : which thou hast prepared before the face of all people . Ibid cap. 9. vers . 56. The sonne of man came not to destroy soules , but to saue them . Ioan. 3. vers . 16. For God so loued the world that he gaue his only begotten sonne , that euery one who belieueth in him perish not . Ibid. cap. 12. vers . 47. I am not come ( sayth Christ ) to condemne the world , but to saue the world . Act 17. vers 30. God denounceth vnto men , that al , euery where do pennance . Rom. 11. vers . 32. For God hath concluded all into incredulity , that he may haue mercy vpon all . 1. Tim. 2. vers . 4. God will that all men be saued , and to come to the knowledge of the Truth . Tit. 2. vers . 12. For the grace of God our Sauiour hath appeared vnto al men . ● . Pet. 3. vers . 9. God is not willing that any perish , but that all returne to pennance . 1. Ioan. 2. vers . 2. He ( to wit Christ ) is the propitiation for our sinnes , & not for ours alone , but also for the whole worlds . These are the places of Scripture alleadged by the Arminians for their opinion in this point . Now followeth the doctrine of the Gomarian-Caluinists to the contrary , to wit , That God hath created some to damnation . Iohn Caluin Instit l. 3. cap. 23. b. Seeing the disposition of all things is in the hand of God , and seeing he hath the power of death & of saluatiō , he ordayneth then with his counsell and will , that some are borne , who from thei● Mothers wombe are certainly deliuered ouer vnto death , to the end that by their destruction the name of God should be praysed . The same Caluin vpon the 18. vers . of the 9. cap. to the Romans . The destructiō of the vngodly is not only foreknown , but they are also purposely created , to the end they should come to destruction or perdition . Idem in his booke ad ●alumn . Nebulon. pag. 867. Say you , that it is not permitted vnto God to damne any body , but such as haue done euill ? There are taken away out of this life an infinite nūber of yong children . Cast now out your poyson against God , who taketh away innocent childrē from the brestes of their Mothers , and casteth them into the depth of hell , in eternall death and damnation . The● . Beza in his little Annot vpon the Romans 9. vers . 22. Let vs then againe be licensed to say with Paul , that some men are of God the workmaister , created vnto destruction . Amandus Polanus on the 9 vers of the 13. of Osee . Those whom God hath predestinated to eternall perdition , he hath also created vnto eternal perdition ; & al those thinges strengthen them to ●●●●nall perdition , that strengthen the elect vnto saluation . The same Polanus in his doctrine of the t●uth of Predestination , pag. 139. sayth : Abiection is an inward , and eternall worke of God , which in truth differeth not from the essence of God it selfe . Fr Gomarus in his translated dispute of Predestination Thes . 23. sayth : Abiection is Gods predestination , through which out of reasonable creations , he hath in grosse , and without fore-knowne limits , according to his priuiledge and pleasure , from eternity , reiected some f●om eternall life , an● hath also before hand orda●ned them to eternall death , and con●empt . The Contra-Remonstrants in the conference at the Hage , pag. 53. ●he cause why God hath determined to elect some and not others , is only his pleasure & grace ; and not , that he hath forseene that one should belieue in Christ , & not another . The second point . Whether God necessarily causeth man to sinne . Places of Scripture alleadged by the Arminians for the negatiue . Genes . caD. 4. vers . 6. The Lord sayd to Cayn , why art thou angry , and why is thy countenance fallen ? If thou do well , shalt thou not receaue agayne ? but if thou doest ill , shall not thy sin be present at the dore ? but , the lust thereof shal be vnder thee , and thou shalt haue dominion ouer it . Psal 5. vers . 5. 6. 7. Thou art no God that hath pleasure in wickednes : the euill shall not conuerse with thee . The foolish shal not stand in thy sight : thou hatest all those that worke iniquity . Thou shalt destroy them that speake lyes : the lord abhorreth both the bloud-thirsty and the deceytfull man. Psal . 45. vers . 8. Thou hast loued righteousnes , and hated iniquity : Therfore hath God , thy God , annoynted the with the oyle of gladnes , aboue thy fellowes . Isa . 59. vers . 2. Thy iniquities do separate thee & thy God , one from another ; and thy sinnes do hyde his face from thee , that thou canst not be heard . Ose . 13 vers . 9. Israel , thou bringest thy selfe into vnhappynes , for thy saluation standeth only with me . Matt. 1 v●rs 21. Thou shalt ( sayth the Angel to Ioseph ) call his name Iesus , for he shall saue his people from their sins . Luc. 1. vers . 74. 75. That without feare being deliuered out of the hands of our enemyes , wee may serue him , in holynes and iustice before him , all our dayes . Ioan 8. vers . 44. The diuell when he speaketh a lye , he speaketh of his own , because he is a lyer , & the father therof . Rom. 1. vers . 18. The wrath of God from heauen is reuealed vpon all impiety , and iniustice of Men. Galat. 5. vers . 16 Walke in the spirit , and the workes of the flesh you shal not accomplish . Iac. 1 vers . 13. 14. 15. Let no man when he is tempted , say that he is tempted of God , for God is not a tempter of euill ; and he tempteth no man. But euery one is tempted of his own concupiscence , abstracted and allured . Afterward concupiscence when it hath conceaued , bringeth forth sin , but sin when it is consummate engendreth death . 1. Pet. 3. vers . 12. 13. The face of the Lord is vpon them that do euill things ; but who is he that can hurt you , if you be emulators of good . 1. Ioan 2. vers . 16. All that is in the world is the concupiscence of the flesh , and the concupiscence of the eyes , and the pryde of lyfe , which is not of the Father , but is of the world . Ibid. cap. 3. vers . 8. He that comitteth sin is of the diuell , because the diuell sinneth from the beginning ; for this appeareth the Son of God , that he might di●●olue the works of the diuell . The affirmatiue doctrine of the Gomarian-Caluinists , to wit , that God doth necessarily cause man to sinne . Caluin Instit. lib. 1. cap 18. 2. I do confesse , that God in the abiect doth worke through the seruice of the diuel ; but so , as Sathan through Gods prouocation doth his worke . Ibid. lib. 3 cap. 23. 9. The abiect sinning will be excused , because they cannot auoyd the necessity of sinning , seeing through the ordinance of God such necessity is layd vpon them ; But we feare that they are not therby rightly excused , for the ordinance of God , by which they complaine to be ordayned to perdition , hath her iustice , which albeit vnknowne vnto vs , yet it is very certaine . Theod. Beza against Castalio . We confesse to be true , that God hath predestinated all such as he listeth , not only vnto damnation , but also vnto the causes of damnation . Zuinglius de prouid . tom . 1. cap 6. pag. 366. No man can say , that the murtherer is excused , because he hath killed through Gods prouocation , for he hath sinned against the lawes . But you will , say ; he was prouoked to sinne : I agree heereunto that he was prouoked to sin , howbeit to the end , that one should be saued , and another hanged &c. Ibid. pag. 365. One & the selfe same wickednes , as for example either Adultery , or Murther , if the same come from God , as the Author , moouer , and prouoker , is a worke , but no misdeed ; but if so be it proceed from man , then it is sinne . Zanchius de Natura Dei lib. 5. pag. 172. We acknowledge that the abiect ( with a necessity to sinne , and consequently to perish ) do through the disposition of God lye constrayned and bound , yea do so ly constrayned and bound , that they cannot leaue to sinne , and to perish . Ibid. Thes . 4. de reprobat . The elect as well as the reprobate , are vnto sinne ( as being sinne , in as much as the honour of God thereby is aduanced ) before ordayned . Io. Piscator praefat . disput contra . Schafman . pag. 7. The fifth principall point that we are charged withal , is that God doth secretly inforce a man to doe the sinne that he forbiddeth ; but the same , being well vnderstood , the Scripture teacheth . In the Treatise of Predestination published by D. Pezelius , Lichae , Anno 1604. If for an Author you vnderstand such an one , as giueth counsell , vrgeth forward or inforceth , or in any sort giueth cause to doe ought , then may you assuredly name God to be the Author of sinne . Nicasius Vander-scheuren in his briefe Institution , pag. 15. sayth : God ruleth not only the body ▪ but also the hart and mind of his creatures , as wel vnto good as vnto euill . Ibid pag. 16. If so be God hath power to ordayne man to damnation before he be borne , & being borne then presently , before he haue committed any euill , to cast him into the bottomlesse pit of hell ; wherfore should he not then haue much more power to moue the hart of man to sinne , and to direct it ? For whether is more , to damne him that hath done no euill , or to moue & direct him to sinne ? And seeing God will damne the abiect , is it not all one how he damneth him , whether after that he hath moued & directed him to sin , or before ? The third point . Whether God do inuite any man to saluation whome he hath resolued in any case not to saue . Places of Scripture alleadged by the Arminians to proue , That God inuiteth all men to saluation . Deuter. cap. 30 vers . 19. I call for witnesse this day Heauen and Earth , that I haue proposed to you life and death , blessing and cursing : chuse therefore life , that thou mayst liue , and thy seed . Psal . 95 vers . 8. This day if you heare my voyce , harden not your harts . Prouerb . 1. vers . 24. 25. 26. Seeing I call and you refuse , I stretch forth my hand , and no man regards it , & you let passe all my counsels , and will not accept of my correction : So will I also laugh in your mish●p , and deryde you , when that hapneth vnto you that you feare . Isay 5. vers . 4. What might more be done vnto my vineyard , that I haue not done vnto it ? Wherefore hath it then brought forth wyld grapes , when I expected it should haue broght wyne-grapes . Matth. 23. vers . 37. Hierusalem , Hierusalem which killest the Prophets , and stonest them that were sent vnto thee . How often would I gather thy children as the Henne doth gather togeathe● h●r chickins , vnder her winges , and thou wouldest not . Marc. 1. vers . 15. The tyme is fullfilled , and the kingdom of God is at hand , be penitent , and belieue the Ghospell . Luc. 7. vers . 29 30. And al the people hearing , and the Publicans iustifyed God , being baptized with Iohns Baptisme : but the Pharisees and the Scribes despysed the counsell of God against themselues , being not baptized of him . Ioan. 5 vers 40. You will not come to me , that you may haue life . Act. 7. vers . 5. You stif-necked , and men of vncircumcised harts and eares , you alwayes resist the holy Ghost . Rom. 10 vers . 21. out of Isay 65 vers . 2. Al the day haue I held out my hands , to a people that belieueth not , and contradicteth me . Apec . 3. vers . 20. Behold I stand at the doore and knocke , if any man shal heare my voyce , and open the gate , I will enter in vnto him , and will sup with him , and he with me . Ibid. cap. 22. vers . 17. He that thirsteth , let him come , and he that will , let him take the water of life gratis . The doctrine of the Gomarian Cal●inists to the contrary , to wit , That God inuiteth not all men to saluation . Caluin . In●tit . lib. 3. cap. 24. vers . 12. Those whome God hath created vnto eternall death , to the end they should be instruments of his anger , & become examples of his seuerity ; those bereaueth he sometims of the power to heare his word ; sometyms he doth blind them , & maketh them more ignorant through the manifestation of his word , because they should come vnto their end . Ibid. cap. 13. Behould he speaketh vnto them , but to the end they should become more deafe ; he kindleth his light , to the end they should be the blinder ; he declareth his doctrine , but to the end they should thereby become vnintelligible ; he vseth meanes , but to the end they should not be saued . Caluin . lib. ad calum . Nebulon. pag. 858. Why doth God willingly let erre , ( yea through a secret resolution hath ordayned to erre ) such as himselfe commaundeth to go the right way . Not to know this becommeth measured modesty , but saucely to be prying into it ( as you do ) is a foolish boldnes . Theo. Beza against Castalio pag. 398. God sendeth forth his seruants , because they should declare the Ghospell of saluation to all people , yet keepeth he secret to himselfe , in whome he will that the preaching of the Ghospell shal be of force , and in what moment ; and also , who he hath resolued by the same preaching to blind , and to obdurate . 10. Piscator in disput . aduersus Schafman . Pag. 7. It is manifest out of Gods word that God doth also call some out-casts vnto saluation , and that he notwithstanding will not that any of those outcasts be saued , as being such as he with an vnchangeable resolution , hath ordavned altogeather to perdition . Ibid Pag 143. God acknowlegeth , or witnesseth with tongue by the ministers of the Ghospel , that he will that the outcasts which he speaketh vnto in the number of the elect , shall belieue the Ghospell , in asmuch as he commaundeth it ; and yet wil he not that they belieue ; for were it that he so would , then should he affoard them the grace to belieue , without the which no man can belieue . Aug. Marloratus in his Annot. Ioan. 15. So standeth then this sentēce firme , that he whome God hath elected before the creation of the world , cannot perish , and that he whome he hath reiected can not be saued , although he do all the workes of the Saintes ; So irreuocable is the sentence of God. And now hauing truely translated and layd downe the different opinions vpon these points , I will leaue you to iudge of them according as piety and reason shall direct you . There was a Synode held , about the controuersies betweene these two sydes , at Dort in Holland , in the yeare 1619. gathered togeather from sundry forreyne partes , aswel as out of Holland it self , as other Prouinces ; but the Synod refusing to heare the Arminians , as dilinquentes condēned them & their doctrine , being reduced into fyue capitall articles ; and heerupon , by a seuere Proclamation were the Arminiās forbidden to preach , or hold assemblies for the exercise of their religion ; some hauing been killed for attempting the contrary , some banished , some sustayned confiscation of their goodes , and some imprysonment , where they yet remayne ; though in the meane tyme their number doth not diminish , but dayly more and more increase throughout all the Countrey , aswel in villages , as in citties . Thus haue you the beginning and ground of this great controuersy wherof no end can be determined . It resteth now for Con●lusion of my intended discourse , that heere I set downe , whether in respect of Religion , the State of England may be moued to continue their help and assistance to the Hollanders . The religion therfore of Holland is first to be rightly known and conceaued , and then wel to be considered : I meane that which hath beene , and yet is principally mantayned by the States therof , to wit , that which is opposit ▪ vnto the Arminians , and doth now vulgarly beare the name of Caluinian or Gomarian doctrine , as hath beene sa●d . The Arminians against whome they of this religion do contend , did in the tyme of their formamed Aduocate Berneue't , sollicite and ●abour , that the States might haue the authority giuen them of Supreme Headship of the Church ; and some affirme that they also sought to haue Bishops after the manner of England ; but herunto the Caluinian Gomarists , in all earnestnes , opposed themselues , and especially against the hauing of supremacy or superinten●ēcy in their Churches ; wherein they went so farre , that they published openly in their printed bookes , that whatsoeuer they were that went about to make men the heades of Churches , would make of men Idolls , and of themselues by so doing , Idolaters . What think you now of the conformity of this religion , to that of England , where by established Actes of Parlament it is death to deny the Temporall Prince to be supreme Head of th● Church ? He that denyeth this in England is by the law to 〈◊〉 as a traytour : he that affirmeth it in Holland is by their doctrine to be held for an Idolater . Our Bishops in England were wont to persecu●e Puritanes for denying their authority ; what would they say to these professors of Reformation that make them Idolaters ? These be purer then Puritanes , being distilled into a farre purer strayne or quin● essence Is not this a religion , trow you , that deserueth by English Protestants to be foug●ten for , & to haue the wealth of England cōsumed for vpholding the cause and quarrel thereof ? What may we think of our most Royall Kinges expresse Commaundement to haue the Communion receaued kneeling ? They would shew themselues to haue leggs as st●●fe as the legges of Elephants , rather then they would fynd an● knees to bow thereunto , let it be commaunded by what authority it would . And I do verily belieue , they would be without communion all the dayes of their life , rather then to receaue it with so much vnease , as of not sitting . And as for the Crosse , which his Maiesty hath likewise commaunded to be vsed in Baptism● ; how is it possible they would endure it , seing they sticke not to say , It is the marke of t●e 〈◊〉 ? By which saying the world may ma●ke that themselues are beasts indeed . And England may thinke it self very ill aduised , and very vnhappy , to a first the quarrel of a people in regard of religiō , whose Religion is so opposite to theirs as this is ; and the professour● wherof , if they were subiects of England and there resident , would by the lawes of the Realme be seuerely punished . But much more vnhappy should England be , if heerafter by the fayling of his Maiesty , & the Prince his Highnesse ( both whome God long preserue ) such a Sect should come to be set vp and aduanced there . Doubtlesse most wellcome to their Puritan Brethren , who then would triumph and ium●e with them to the full , and with them beare the only sw●y in persecuting the P●ot●stants in England , as the others now do the Armintans in Holland . One conceyte more commeth to my mynd , to note vnto you , before I take my leaue ; and this 〈◊〉 that wheras in the late Synode of Dort , some of our English and Scot●ish d●uines , being sent thither to assist the Ca●uinian-Comarists , about the condemnation of the opinion of the Arm●nta●s , they could so notwithstanding piettily put to sylence the ●omarists , for making of them Idolaters , as though there had beene no such matter euer by them thought vpon ; and that on other syde the Gomarists could be so kynd , as to sit in the company of English Idolaters , and quietly hold their peace from challenging them to be such : yea and without all scruple of conscience , to eate and drinke with them ; and to parte very good friends . Surely heere is in this case a great moderation and suspension of spi●it to be noted in both , seeing the one knowing what the other kept in his bosome , no reproach of being traytours or Idolaters did burst forth between them . Thus hauing giuen you a briefe , and true Relation , according vnto your demannd , I will not be further tedious vnto you , but with respectfull remembrance , and of as great desyre of your good , as of my own , recommend you vnto him , from whome only all good proceedeth . FINIS . Faults escaped in the Printing . Page Line Fault Correction . 17. 17. from all from him Ibid. 22. published polished 29. 8. honorified homofied . IFany other faults haue escaped , it is desired of the Gentle Reader , to correct them of his courtesy , the Author being farre absent from the Print .