id sid tid token lemma pos 31504 1 1 generously generously RB 31504 1 2 made make VBN 31504 1 3 available available JJ 31504 1 4 by by IN 31504 1 5 The the DT 31504 1 6 Internet Internet NNP 31504 1 7 Archive Archive NNP 31504 1 8 / / SYM 31504 1 9 Canadian Canadian NNP 31504 1 10 Libraries Libraries NNPS 31504 1 11 ) ) -RRB- 31504 1 12 CONCERNING concern VBG 31504 1 13 JUSTICE justice NN 31504 1 14 BY by IN 31504 1 15 LUCILIUS LUCILIUS NNP 31504 1 16 A. a. NN 31504 1 17 EMERY EMERY NNP 31504 1 18 NEW NEW NNP 31504 1 19 HAVEN HAVEN NNS 31504 1 20 : : : 31504 1 21 YALE YALE NNP 31504 1 22 UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY NNP 31504 1 23 PRESS PRESS NNP 31504 1 24 LONDON LONDON NNP 31504 1 25 : : : 31504 1 26 HUMPHREY HUMPHREY NNP 31504 1 27 MILFORD MILFORD NNP 31504 1 28 OXFORD OXFORD NNP 31504 1 29 UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY NNP 31504 1 30 PRESS press NN 31504 1 31 MDCCCCXIV mdccccxiv NN 31504 1 32 COPYRIGHT COPYRIGHT NNS 31504 1 33 , , , 31504 1 34 1914 1914 CD 31504 1 35 BY by IN 31504 1 36 YALE YALE NNP 31504 1 37 UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY NNP 31504 1 38 PRESS PRESS NNP 31504 1 39 First first RB 31504 1 40 printed print VBN 31504 1 41 August August NNP 31504 1 42 , , , 31504 1 43 1914 1914 CD 31504 1 44 , , , 31504 1 45 1000 1000 CD 31504 1 46 copies copy NNS 31504 1 47 TO to IN 31504 1 48 MY my PRP$ 31504 1 49 CHILDREN child NNS 31504 1 50 HENRY henry NN 31504 1 51 CROSBY CROSBY NNS 31504 1 52 EMERY emery NN 31504 1 53 ANNE anne NN 31504 1 54 CROSBY CROSBY NNS 31504 1 55 EMERY emery VBP 31504 1 56 ALLINSON allinson PDT 31504 1 57 THE the DT 31504 1 58 ADDRESSES addresses NN 31504 1 59 CONTAINED contained NN 31504 1 60 IN in IN 31504 1 61 THIS this DT 31504 1 62 BOOK BOOK NNS 31504 1 63 WERE be VBD 31504 1 64 DELIVERED deliver VBN 31504 1 65 IN in IN 31504 1 66 THE the DT 31504 1 67 WILLIAM WILLIAM NNPS 31504 1 68 L. L. NNP 31504 1 69 STORRS STORRS NNP 31504 1 70 LECTURE LECTURE NNP 31504 1 71 SERIES serie NNS 31504 1 72 , , , 31504 1 73 1914 1914 CD 31504 1 74 , , , 31504 1 75 BEFORE before IN 31504 1 76 THE the DT 31504 1 77 LAW law NN 31504 1 78 SCHOOL SCHOOL NNP 31504 1 79 OF of IN 31504 1 80 YALE YALE NNP 31504 1 81 UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY NNP 31504 1 82 , , , 31504 1 83 NEW NEW NNP 31504 1 84 HAVEN HAVEN NNP 31504 1 85 , , , 31504 1 86 CONNECTICUT CONNECTICUT NNP 31504 1 87 . . . 31504 2 1 CONTENTS content NNS 31504 2 2 CHAPTER chapter NN 31504 2 3 PAGE page NN 31504 2 4 I. i. NN 31504 3 1 THE the DT 31504 3 2 PROBLEM problem NN 31504 3 3 STATED state VBD 31504 3 4 . . . 31504 4 1 THEORIES theory NNS 31504 4 2 AS as IN 31504 4 3 TO to IN 31504 4 4 THE the DT 31504 4 5 SOURCE SOURCE NNP 31504 4 6 OF of IN 31504 4 7 JUSTICE JUSTICE NNP 31504 4 8 . . . 31504 5 1 DEFINITIONS definition NNS 31504 5 2 OF of IN 31504 5 3 JUSTICE JUSTICE NNP 31504 5 4 3 3 CD 31504 5 5 II II NNP 31504 5 6 . . . 31504 6 1 THE the DT 31504 6 2 PROBLEM problem NN 31504 6 3 OF of IN 31504 6 4 RIGHTS right NNS 31504 6 5 . . . 31504 7 1 DIFFERENT DIFFERENT NNP 31504 7 2 THEORIES theory NNS 31504 7 3 AS as IN 31504 7 4 TO to IN 31504 7 5 THE the DT 31504 7 6 SOURCE SOURCE NNP 31504 7 7 OF of IN 31504 7 8 RIGHTS RIGHTS NNP 31504 7 9 31 31 CD 31504 7 10 III iii CD 31504 7 11 . . . 31504 8 1 THE the DT 31504 8 2 PROBLEM problem NN 31504 8 3 OF of IN 31504 8 4 RIGHTS right NNS 31504 8 5 CONTINUED CONTINUED NNS 31504 8 6 . . . 31504 9 1 THE the DT 31504 9 2 NEED NEED NNP 31504 9 3 OF of IN 31504 9 4 LIBERTY liberty NN 31504 9 5 OF of IN 31504 9 6 ACTION action NN 31504 9 7 FOR for IN 31504 9 8 THE the DT 31504 9 9 INDIVIDUAL INDIVIDUAL NNP 31504 9 10 43 43 CD 31504 9 11 IV iv NN 31504 9 12 . . . 31504 10 1 JUSTICE JUSTICE NNP 31504 10 2 THE the DT 31504 10 3 EQUILIBRIUM EQUILIBRIUM NNP 31504 10 4 BETWEEN between IN 31504 10 5 THE the DT 31504 10 6 FREEDOM freedom NN 31504 10 7 OF of IN 31504 10 8 THE the DT 31504 10 9 INDIVIDUAL INDIVIDUAL NNPS 31504 10 10 AND and CC 31504 10 11 THE the DT 31504 10 12 SAFETY safety NN 31504 10 13 OF of IN 31504 10 14 SOCIETY SOCIETY NNP 31504 10 15 56 56 CD 31504 10 16 V. v. NN 31504 10 17 JUSTICE justice NN 31504 10 18 CAN CAN MD 31504 10 19 BE be VB 31504 10 20 SECURED secured JJ 31504 10 21 ONLY only RB 31504 10 22 THROUGH through IN 31504 10 23 GOVERNMENTAL GOVERNMENTAL NNP 31504 10 24 ACTION action NN 31504 10 25 . . . 31504 11 1 THE the DT 31504 11 2 BEST best NN 31504 11 3 FORM form NN 31504 11 4 OF of IN 31504 11 5 GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT NNP 31504 11 6 77 77 CD 31504 11 7 VI VI NNP 31504 11 8 . . . 31504 12 1 THE the DT 31504 12 2 NECESSITY NECESSITY NNP 31504 12 3 OF of IN 31504 12 4 CONSTITUTIONAL constitutional JJ 31504 12 5 LIMITATIONS limitation NNS 31504 12 6 UPON upon IN 31504 12 7 THE the DT 31504 12 8 POWERS power NNS 31504 12 9 OF of IN 31504 12 10 THE the DT 31504 12 11 GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT NNP 31504 12 12 . . . 31504 13 1 BILLS bill NNS 31504 13 2 OF of IN 31504 13 3 RIGHTS RIGHTS NNP 31504 13 4 95 95 CD 31504 13 5 VII vii NN 31504 13 6 . . . 31504 14 1 THE the DT 31504 14 2 INTERPRETATION INTERPRETATION NNS 31504 14 3 AND and CC 31504 14 4 ENFORCEMENT enforcement NN 31504 14 5 OF of IN 31504 14 6 CONSTITUTIONAL constitutional JJ 31504 14 7 LIMITATIONS limitation NNS 31504 14 8 NECESSARILY necessarily NN 31504 14 9 A a DT 31504 14 10 FUNCTION function NN 31504 14 11 OF of IN 31504 14 12 THE the DT 31504 14 13 JUDICIARY judiciary NN 31504 14 14 110 110 CD 31504 14 15 VIII viii NN 31504 14 16 . . . 31504 15 1 AN an DT 31504 15 2 INDEPENDENT INDEPENDENT NNP 31504 15 3 AND and CC 31504 15 4 IMPARTIAL IMPARTIAL NNP 31504 15 5 JUDICIARY judiciary NN 31504 15 6 ESSENTIAL essential NN 31504 15 7 FOR for IN 31504 15 8 JUSTICE justice NN 31504 15 9 121 121 CD 31504 15 10 IX IX NNP 31504 15 11 . . . 31504 16 1 THE the DT 31504 16 2 NECESSITY NECESSITY NNP 31504 16 3 OF of IN 31504 16 4 MAINTAINING maintain VBG 31504 16 5 UNDIMINISHED UNDIMINISHED NNS 31504 16 6 THE the DT 31504 16 7 CONSTITUTIONAL constitutional JJ 31504 16 8 LIMITATIONS limitations NN 31504 16 9 AND and CC 31504 16 10 THE the DT 31504 16 11 POWER power NN 31504 16 12 OF of IN 31504 16 13 THE the DT 31504 16 14 COURTS court NNS 31504 16 15 TO to IN 31504 16 16 ENFORCE ENFORCE NNP 31504 16 17 THEM.--CONCLUSION them.--conclusion NN 31504 16 18 146 146 CD 31504 16 19 CONCERNING concern VBG 31504 16 20 JUSTICE JUSTICE NNP 31504 16 21 CHAPTER chapter NN 31504 16 22 I -PRON- PRP 31504 16 23 THE the DT 31504 16 24 PROBLEM problem NN 31504 16 25 STATED state VBD 31504 16 26 . . . 31504 17 1 THEORIES theory NNS 31504 17 2 AS as IN 31504 17 3 TO to IN 31504 17 4 THE the DT 31504 17 5 SOURCE SOURCE NNP 31504 17 6 OF of IN 31504 17 7 JUSTICE JUSTICE NNP 31504 17 8 . . . 31504 18 1 DEFINITIONS definition NNS 31504 18 2 OF of IN 31504 18 3 JUSTICE justice NN 31504 18 4 For for IN 31504 18 5 centuries century NNS 31504 18 6 now now RB 31504 18 7 much much JJ 31504 18 8 has have VBZ 31504 18 9 been be VBN 31504 18 10 written write VBN 31504 18 11 and and CC 31504 18 12 proclaimed proclaim VBN 31504 18 13 concerning concern VBG 31504 18 14 justice justice NN 31504 18 15 and and CC 31504 18 16 today today NN 31504 18 17 the the DT 31504 18 18 word word NN 31504 18 19 seems seem VBZ 31504 18 20 to to TO 31504 18 21 be be VB 31504 18 22 more more JJR 31504 18 23 than than IN 31504 18 24 ever ever RB 31504 18 25 upon upon IN 31504 18 26 the the DT 31504 18 27 lips lip NNS 31504 18 28 of of IN 31504 18 29 men man NNS 31504 18 30 , , , 31504 18 31 more more RBR 31504 18 32 than than IN 31504 18 33 ever ever RB 31504 18 34 used use VBN 31504 18 35 , , , 31504 18 36 but but CC 31504 18 37 not not RB 31504 18 38 always always RB 31504 18 39 appositely appositely RB 31504 18 40 , , , 31504 18 41 in in IN 31504 18 42 arguments argument NNS 31504 18 43 for for IN 31504 18 44 proposed propose VBN 31504 18 45 political political JJ 31504 18 46 action action NN 31504 18 47 . . . 31504 19 1 Hence hence RB 31504 19 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 19 3 may may MD 31504 19 4 not not RB 31504 19 5 be be VB 31504 19 6 inappropriate inappropriate JJ 31504 19 7 to to IN 31504 19 8 the the DT 31504 19 9 time time NN 31504 19 10 and and CC 31504 19 11 occasion occasion NN 31504 19 12 to to TO 31504 19 13 venture venture VB 31504 19 14 , , , 31504 19 15 not not RB 31504 19 16 answers answer NNS 31504 19 17 to to IN 31504 19 18 , , , 31504 19 19 but but CC 31504 19 20 some some DT 31504 19 21 observations observation NNS 31504 19 22 upon upon IN 31504 19 23 the the DT 31504 19 24 questions question NNS 31504 19 25 , , , 31504 19 26 what what WP 31504 19 27 is be VBZ 31504 19 28 justice justice NN 31504 19 29 , , , 31504 19 30 and and CC 31504 19 31 how how WRB 31504 19 32 can can MD 31504 19 33 it -PRON- PRP 31504 19 34 be be VB 31504 19 35 secured secure VBN 31504 19 36 . . . 31504 20 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 20 2 was be VBD 31504 20 3 declared declare VBN 31504 20 4 by by IN 31504 20 5 the the DT 31504 20 6 Roman roman JJ 31504 20 7 jurist jurist NN 31504 20 8 Ulpian Ulpian NNP 31504 20 9 , , , 31504 20 10 centuries century NNS 31504 20 11 ago ago RB 31504 20 12 , , , 31504 20 13 that that IN 31504 20 14 students student NNS 31504 20 15 of of IN 31504 20 16 law law NN 31504 20 17 should should MD 31504 20 18 also also RB 31504 20 19 be be VB 31504 20 20 students student NNS 31504 20 21 of of IN 31504 20 22 justice justice NN 31504 20 23 . . . 31504 21 1 By by IN 31504 21 2 way way NN 31504 21 3 of of IN 31504 21 4 prelude prelude NN 31504 21 5 , , , 31504 21 6 however however RB 31504 21 7 , , , 31504 21 8 and and CC 31504 21 9 in in IN 31504 21 10 the the DT 31504 21 11 hope hope NN 31504 21 12 of of IN 31504 21 13 accentuating accentuate VBG 31504 21 14 the the DT 31504 21 15 main main JJ 31504 21 16 question question NN 31504 21 17 and and CC 31504 21 18 presenting present VBG 31504 21 19 the the DT 31504 21 20 subject subject NN 31504 21 21 more more RBR 31504 21 22 vividly vividly RB 31504 21 23 by by IN 31504 21 24 comparison comparison NN 31504 21 25 and and CC 31504 21 26 contrast contrast NN 31504 21 27 , , , 31504 21 28 I -PRON- PRP 31504 21 29 would would MD 31504 21 30 recall recall VB 31504 21 31 to to IN 31504 21 32 your -PRON- PRP$ 31504 21 33 minds mind NNS 31504 21 34 another another DT 31504 21 35 and and CC 31504 21 36 even even RB 31504 21 37 more more RBR 31504 21 38 fundamental fundamental JJ 31504 21 39 question question NN 31504 21 40 asked ask VBD 31504 21 41 twenty twenty CD 31504 21 42 centuries century NNS 31504 21 43 ago ago RB 31504 21 44 in in IN 31504 21 45 a a DT 31504 21 46 judicial judicial JJ 31504 21 47 proceeding proceeding NN 31504 21 48 in in IN 31504 21 49 distant distant JJ 31504 21 50 Judea Judea NNP 31504 21 51 . . . 31504 22 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 22 2 is be VBZ 31504 22 3 related relate VBN 31504 22 4 that that IN 31504 22 5 when when WRB 31504 22 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 31504 22 7 , , , 31504 22 8 upon upon IN 31504 22 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 22 10 accusation accusation NN 31504 22 11 before before IN 31504 22 12 Pilate Pilate NNP 31504 22 13 , , , 31504 22 14 claimed claim VBD 31504 22 15 in in IN 31504 22 16 defense defense NN 31504 22 17 that that IN 31504 22 18 he -PRON- PRP 31504 22 19 had have VBD 31504 22 20 " " `` 31504 22 21 come come VBN 31504 22 22 into into IN 31504 22 23 the the DT 31504 22 24 world world NN 31504 22 25 to to TO 31504 22 26 bear bear VB 31504 22 27 witness witness NN 31504 22 28 unto unto IN 31504 22 29 the the DT 31504 22 30 truth truth NN 31504 22 31 , , , 31504 22 32 " " '' 31504 22 33 Pilate Pilate NNP 31504 22 34 inquired inquire VBD 31504 22 35 of of IN 31504 22 36 him -PRON- PRP 31504 22 37 " " `` 31504 22 38 What what WP 31504 22 39 is be VBZ 31504 22 40 truth truth NN 31504 22 41 ? ? . 31504 23 1 " " `` 31504 23 2 ; ; : 31504 23 3 but but CC 31504 23 4 it -PRON- PRP 31504 23 5 is be VBZ 31504 23 6 further further RB 31504 23 7 related relate VBN 31504 23 8 that that IN 31504 23 9 when when WRB 31504 23 10 Pilate Pilate NNP 31504 23 11 " " '' 31504 23 12 had have VBD 31504 23 13 said say VBN 31504 23 14 this this DT 31504 23 15 he -PRON- PRP 31504 23 16 went go VBD 31504 23 17 out out RP 31504 23 18 again again RB 31504 23 19 unto unto IN 31504 23 20 the the DT 31504 23 21 Jews Jews NNPS 31504 23 22 . . . 31504 23 23 " " '' 31504 24 1 Apparently apparently RB 31504 24 2 he -PRON- PRP 31504 24 3 did do VBD 31504 24 4 not not RB 31504 24 5 wait wait VB 31504 24 6 for for IN 31504 24 7 an an DT 31504 24 8 answer answer NN 31504 24 9 . . . 31504 25 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 31504 25 2 he -PRON- PRP 31504 25 3 repented repent VBD 31504 25 4 of of IN 31504 25 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 25 6 question question NN 31504 25 7 as as RB 31504 25 8 soon soon RB 31504 25 9 as as IN 31504 25 10 asked ask VBD 31504 25 11 and and CC 31504 25 12 went go VBD 31504 25 13 out out RP 31504 25 14 to to TO 31504 25 15 escape escape VB 31504 25 16 an an DT 31504 25 17 answer answer NN 31504 25 18 . . . 31504 26 1 Men man NNS 31504 26 2 before before IN 31504 26 3 and and CC 31504 26 4 since since IN 31504 26 5 Pilate Pilate NNP 31504 26 6 have have VBP 31504 26 7 sought seek VBN 31504 26 8 to to TO 31504 26 9 avoid avoid VB 31504 26 10 hearing hear VBG 31504 26 11 the the DT 31504 26 12 truth truth NN 31504 26 13 . . . 31504 27 1 Indeed indeed RB 31504 27 2 , , , 31504 27 3 however however RB 31504 27 4 grave grave VB 31504 27 5 the the DT 31504 27 6 question question NN 31504 27 7 , , , 31504 27 8 however however RB 31504 27 9 essential essential JJ 31504 27 10 the the DT 31504 27 11 answer answer NN 31504 27 12 to to IN 31504 27 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 27 14 well well NN 31504 27 15 - - HYPH 31504 27 16 being being NN 31504 27 17 , , , 31504 27 18 there there EX 31504 27 19 does do VBZ 31504 27 20 not not RB 31504 27 21 seem seem VB 31504 27 22 to to TO 31504 27 23 be be VB 31504 27 24 even even RB 31504 27 25 now now RB 31504 27 26 on on IN 31504 27 27 the the DT 31504 27 28 part part NN 31504 27 29 of of IN 31504 27 30 the the DT 31504 27 31 multitude multitude NNP 31504 27 32 an an DT 31504 27 33 earnest earnest JJ 31504 27 34 desire desire NN 31504 27 35 for for IN 31504 27 36 the the DT 31504 27 37 truth truth NN 31504 27 38 . . . 31504 28 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 28 2 wishes wish NNS 31504 28 3 and and CC 31504 28 4 emotions emotion NNS 31504 28 5 cloud cloud VBP 31504 28 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 28 7 vision vision NN 31504 28 8 and and CC 31504 28 9 they -PRON- PRP 31504 28 10 are be VBP 31504 28 11 reluctant reluctant JJ 31504 28 12 to to TO 31504 28 13 have have VB 31504 28 14 those those DT 31504 28 15 clouds cloud NNS 31504 28 16 brushed brush VBN 31504 28 17 aside aside RB 31504 28 18 lest lest IN 31504 28 19 the the DT 31504 28 20 truth truth NN 31504 28 21 thus thus RB 31504 28 22 revealed reveal VBD 31504 28 23 be be VB 31504 28 24 harsh harsh JJ 31504 28 25 and and CC 31504 28 26 condemnatory condemnatory JJ 31504 28 27 . . . 31504 29 1 The the DT 31504 29 2 truth truth NN 31504 29 3 often often RB 31504 29 4 causes cause VBZ 31504 29 5 pain pain NN 31504 29 6 . . . 31504 30 1 As as IN 31504 30 2 said say VBN 31504 30 3 by by IN 31504 30 4 the the DT 31504 30 5 Preacher Preacher NNP 31504 30 6 , , , 31504 30 7 " " '' 31504 30 8 He -PRON- PRP 31504 30 9 that that IN 31504 30 10 increaseth increaseth NNP 31504 30 11 knowledge knowledge NNP 31504 30 12 increaseth increaseth NNP 31504 30 13 sorrow sorrow NN 31504 30 14 . . . 31504 30 15 " " '' 31504 31 1 People People NNS 31504 31 2 generally generally RB 31504 31 3 give give VBP 31504 31 4 much much JJ 31504 31 5 the the DT 31504 31 6 greater great JJR 31504 31 7 welcome welcome NN 31504 31 8 and and CC 31504 31 9 heed heed VBP 31504 31 10 to to IN 31504 31 11 him -PRON- PRP 31504 31 12 who who WP 31504 31 13 tells tell VBZ 31504 31 14 them -PRON- PRP 31504 31 15 that that IN 31504 31 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 31 17 desires desire NNS 31504 31 18 and and CC 31504 31 19 schemes scheme NNS 31504 31 20 are be VBP 31504 31 21 righteous righteous JJ 31504 31 22 and and CC 31504 31 23 can can MD 31504 31 24 be be VB 31504 31 25 realized realize VBN 31504 31 26 , , , 31504 31 27 than than IN 31504 31 28 to to IN 31504 31 29 him -PRON- PRP 31504 31 30 who who WP 31504 31 31 tells tell VBZ 31504 31 32 them -PRON- PRP 31504 31 33 that that IN 31504 31 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 31 35 desires desire NNS 31504 31 36 are be VBP 31504 31 37 selfish selfish JJ 31504 31 38 or or CC 31504 31 39 that that IN 31504 31 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 31 41 schemes scheme NNS 31504 31 42 are be VBP 31504 31 43 impracticable impracticable JJ 31504 31 44 . . . 31504 32 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 32 2 has have VBZ 31504 32 3 always always RB 31504 32 4 been be VBN 31504 32 5 the the DT 31504 32 6 few few JJ 31504 32 7 who who WP 31504 32 8 have have VBP 31504 32 9 sought seek VBN 31504 32 10 the the DT 31504 32 11 truth truth NN 31504 32 12 , , , 31504 32 13 resolute resolute VB 31504 32 14 to to TO 31504 32 15 find find VB 31504 32 16 it -PRON- PRP 31504 32 17 and and CC 31504 32 18 declare declare VB 31504 32 19 it -PRON- PRP 31504 32 20 , , , 31504 32 21 whether whether IN 31504 32 22 pleasant pleasant JJ 31504 32 23 or or CC 31504 32 24 unpleasant unpleasant JJ 31504 32 25 , , , 31504 32 26 in in IN 31504 32 27 accord accord NN 31504 32 28 with with IN 31504 32 29 the the DT 31504 32 30 wishes wish NNS 31504 32 31 of of IN 31504 32 32 mankind mankind NN 31504 32 33 or or CC 31504 32 34 otherwise otherwise RB 31504 32 35 . . . 31504 33 1 Such such JJ 31504 33 2 men man NNS 31504 33 3 have have VBP 31504 33 4 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 33 5 suffered suffer VBN 31504 33 6 martyrdom martyrdom NN 31504 33 7 in in IN 31504 33 8 the the DT 31504 33 9 past past NN 31504 33 10 , , , 31504 33 11 and and CC 31504 33 12 often often RB 31504 33 13 incur incur VBP 31504 33 14 hostility hostility NN 31504 33 15 in in IN 31504 33 16 the the DT 31504 33 17 present present NN 31504 33 18 , , , 31504 33 19 even even RB 31504 33 20 when when WRB 31504 33 21 seeking seek VBG 31504 33 22 that that IN 31504 33 23 truth truth NN 31504 33 24 on on IN 31504 33 25 which which WDT 31504 33 26 alone alone JJ 31504 33 27 justice justice NN 31504 33 28 can can MD 31504 33 29 securely securely RB 31504 33 30 rest rest VB 31504 33 31 . . . 31504 34 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 31504 34 2 , , , 31504 34 3 so so RB 31504 34 4 closely closely RB 31504 34 5 linked link VBN 31504 34 6 are be VBP 31504 34 7 truth truth NN 31504 34 8 and and CC 31504 34 9 justice justice NN 31504 34 10 in in IN 31504 34 11 the the DT 31504 34 12 speech speech NN 31504 34 13 , , , 31504 34 14 if if IN 31504 34 15 not not RB 31504 34 16 the the DT 31504 34 17 minds mind NNS 31504 34 18 , , , 31504 34 19 of of IN 31504 34 20 men man NNS 31504 34 21 , , , 31504 34 22 there there EX 31504 34 23 should should MD 31504 34 24 be be VB 31504 34 25 some some DT 31504 34 26 consideration consideration NN 31504 34 27 of of IN 31504 34 28 Pilate Pilate NNP 31504 34 29 's 's POS 31504 34 30 question question NN 31504 34 31 . . . 31504 35 1 Whether whether IN 31504 35 2 truth truth NN 31504 35 3 is be VBZ 31504 35 4 absolute absolute JJ 31504 35 5 or or CC 31504 35 6 only only JJ 31504 35 7 relative relative NN 31504 35 8 has have VBZ 31504 35 9 been be VBN 31504 35 10 perhaps perhaps RB 31504 35 11 the the DT 31504 35 12 most most RBS 31504 35 13 actively actively RB 31504 35 14 discussed discuss VBN 31504 35 15 topic topic NN 31504 35 16 in in IN 31504 35 17 the the DT 31504 35 18 field field NN 31504 35 19 of of IN 31504 35 20 philosophy philosophy NN 31504 35 21 for for IN 31504 35 22 the the DT 31504 35 23 last last JJ 31504 35 24 decade decade NN 31504 35 25 . . . 31504 36 1 Into into IN 31504 36 2 this this DT 31504 36 3 discussion discussion NN 31504 36 4 , , , 31504 36 5 however however RB 31504 36 6 , , , 31504 36 7 we -PRON- PRP 31504 36 8 need need VBP 31504 36 9 not not RB 31504 36 10 enter enter VB 31504 36 11 , , , 31504 36 12 for for IN 31504 36 13 such such JJ 31504 36 14 discussion discussion NN 31504 36 15 is be VBZ 31504 36 16 really really RB 31504 36 17 over over IN 31504 36 18 the the DT 31504 36 19 problem problem NN 31504 36 20 of of IN 31504 36 21 determining determine VBG 31504 36 22 the the DT 31504 36 23 proper proper JJ 31504 36 24 criterion criterion NN 31504 36 25 of of IN 31504 36 26 truth truth NN 31504 36 27 . . . 31504 37 1 Wherever wherever WRB 31504 37 2 be be VB 31504 37 3 this this DT 31504 37 4 criterion criterion NN 31504 37 5 , , , 31504 37 6 whether whether IN 31504 37 7 in in IN 31504 37 8 some some DT 31504 37 9 quality quality NN 31504 37 10 of of IN 31504 37 11 inherent inherent JJ 31504 37 12 rationality rationality NN 31504 37 13 or or CC 31504 37 14 in in IN 31504 37 15 some some DT 31504 37 16 utilitarian utilitarian JJ 31504 37 17 test test NN 31504 37 18 of of IN 31504 37 19 practicability practicability NN 31504 37 20 , , , 31504 37 21 the the DT 31504 37 22 truth truth NN 31504 37 23 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 37 24 has have VBZ 31504 37 25 some some DT 31504 37 26 attributes attribute NNS 31504 37 27 so so RB 31504 37 28 far far RB 31504 37 29 unquestioned unquestioned JJ 31504 37 30 and and CC 31504 37 31 of of IN 31504 37 32 which which WDT 31504 37 33 we -PRON- PRP 31504 37 34 may may MD 31504 37 35 feel feel VB 31504 37 36 certain certain JJ 31504 37 37 as as IN 31504 37 38 being be VBG 31504 37 39 inherent inherent JJ 31504 37 40 , , , 31504 37 41 necessary necessary JJ 31504 37 42 , , , 31504 37 43 and and CC 31504 37 44 self self NN 31504 37 45 - - HYPH 31504 37 46 evident evident JJ 31504 37 47 . . . 31504 38 1 Truth truth NN 31504 38 2 is be VBZ 31504 38 3 uncompromising uncompromise VBG 31504 38 4 . . . 31504 39 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 39 2 is be VBZ 31504 39 3 unadaptable unadaptable JJ 31504 39 4 ; ; : 31504 39 5 all all DT 31504 39 6 else else RB 31504 39 7 must must MD 31504 39 8 be be VB 31504 39 9 adapted adapt VBN 31504 39 10 to to IN 31504 39 11 it -PRON- PRP 31504 39 12 . . . 31504 40 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 40 2 is be VBZ 31504 40 3 not not RB 31504 40 4 a a DT 31504 40 5 matter matter NN 31504 40 6 of of IN 31504 40 7 convention convention NN 31504 40 8 among among IN 31504 40 9 men man NNS 31504 40 10 , , , 31504 40 11 is be VBZ 31504 40 12 not not RB 31504 40 13 established establish VBN 31504 40 14 even even RB 31504 40 15 by by IN 31504 40 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 40 17 unanimous unanimous JJ 31504 40 18 assent assent NN 31504 40 19 , , , 31504 40 20 and and CC 31504 40 21 it -PRON- PRP 31504 40 22 does do VBZ 31504 40 23 not not RB 31504 40 24 change change VB 31504 40 25 with with IN 31504 40 26 changes change NNS 31504 40 27 of of IN 31504 40 28 opinion opinion NN 31504 40 29 . . . 31504 41 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 41 2 is be VBZ 31504 41 3 identical identical JJ 31504 41 4 throughout throughout IN 31504 41 5 time time NN 31504 41 6 and and CC 31504 41 7 space space NN 31504 41 8 . . . 31504 42 1 If if IN 31504 42 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 42 3 be be VB 31504 42 4 true true JJ 31504 42 5 now now RB 31504 42 6 that that IN 31504 42 7 since since IN 31504 42 8 creation creation NN 31504 42 9 the the DT 31504 42 10 earth earth NN 31504 42 11 has have VBZ 31504 42 12 swung swing VBN 31504 42 13 in in IN 31504 42 14 an an DT 31504 42 15 orbit orbit NN 31504 42 16 round round IN 31504 42 17 the the DT 31504 42 18 sun sun NN 31504 42 19 , , , 31504 42 20 it -PRON- PRP 31504 42 21 was be VBD 31504 42 22 true true JJ 31504 42 23 before before IN 31504 42 24 the the DT 31504 42 25 birth birth NN 31504 42 26 of of IN 31504 42 27 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 31504 42 28 and and CC 31504 42 29 Galileo Galileo NNP 31504 42 30 . . . 31504 43 1 If if IN 31504 43 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 43 3 be be VB 31504 43 4 true true JJ 31504 43 5 now now RB 31504 43 6 that that IN 31504 43 7 the the DT 31504 43 8 sum sum NN 31504 43 9 of of IN 31504 43 10 the the DT 31504 43 11 three three CD 31504 43 12 angles angle NNS 31504 43 13 of of IN 31504 43 14 a a DT 31504 43 15 triangle triangle NN 31504 43 16 is be VBZ 31504 43 17 equal equal JJ 31504 43 18 to to IN 31504 43 19 the the DT 31504 43 20 sum sum NN 31504 43 21 of of IN 31504 43 22 two two CD 31504 43 23 right right JJ 31504 43 24 angles angle NNS 31504 43 25 , , , 31504 43 26 it -PRON- PRP 31504 43 27 was be VBD 31504 43 28 always always RB 31504 43 29 true true JJ 31504 43 30 and and CC 31504 43 31 always always RB 31504 43 32 will will MD 31504 43 33 be be VB 31504 43 34 true true JJ 31504 43 35 , , , 31504 43 36 true true JJ 31504 43 37 at at IN 31504 43 38 the the DT 31504 43 39 poles pole NNS 31504 43 40 and and CC 31504 43 41 at at IN 31504 43 42 the the DT 31504 43 43 equator equator NN 31504 43 44 , , , 31504 43 45 true true JJ 31504 43 46 among among IN 31504 43 47 all all DT 31504 43 48 peoples people NNS 31504 43 49 and and CC 31504 43 50 in in IN 31504 43 51 all all DT 31504 43 52 countries country NNS 31504 43 53 , , , 31504 43 54 true true JJ 31504 43 55 alike alike RB 31504 43 56 in in IN 31504 43 57 monarchies monarchy NNS 31504 43 58 , , , 31504 43 59 oligarchies oligarchy NNS 31504 43 60 , , , 31504 43 61 and and CC 31504 43 62 democracies democracy NNS 31504 43 63 . . . 31504 44 1 Truth truth NN 31504 44 2 is be VBZ 31504 44 3 also also RB 31504 44 4 single single JJ 31504 44 5 . . . 31504 45 1 There there EX 31504 45 2 are be VBP 31504 45 3 no no DT 31504 45 4 different different JJ 31504 45 5 kinds kind NNS 31504 45 6 of of IN 31504 45 7 truth truth NN 31504 45 8 , , , 31504 45 9 though though IN 31504 45 10 there there EX 31504 45 11 may may MD 31504 45 12 be be VB 31504 45 13 innumerable innumerable JJ 31504 45 14 kinds kind NNS 31504 45 15 of of IN 31504 45 16 propositions proposition NNS 31504 45 17 of of IN 31504 45 18 which which WDT 31504 45 19 truth truth NN 31504 45 20 may may MD 31504 45 21 or or CC 31504 45 22 may may MD 31504 45 23 not not RB 31504 45 24 be be VB 31504 45 25 predicated predicate VBN 31504 45 26 . . . 31504 46 1 Whichever whichever WDT 31504 46 2 criterion criterion NN 31504 46 3 the the DT 31504 46 4 philosophers philosopher NNS 31504 46 5 may may MD 31504 46 6 finally finally RB 31504 46 7 agree agree VB 31504 46 8 upon upon IN 31504 46 9 , , , 31504 46 10 it -PRON- PRP 31504 46 11 will will MD 31504 46 12 hold hold VB 31504 46 13 in in RP 31504 46 14 all all DT 31504 46 15 propositions proposition NNS 31504 46 16 alike alike RB 31504 46 17 . . . 31504 47 1 The the DT 31504 47 2 truth truth NN 31504 47 3 of of IN 31504 47 4 a a DT 31504 47 5 proposition proposition NN 31504 47 6 in in IN 31504 47 7 mathematics mathematic NNS 31504 47 8 is be VBZ 31504 47 9 the the DT 31504 47 10 same same JJ 31504 47 11 as as IN 31504 47 12 the the DT 31504 47 13 truth truth NN 31504 47 14 of of IN 31504 47 15 a a DT 31504 47 16 proposition proposition NN 31504 47 17 in in IN 31504 47 18 any any DT 31504 47 19 other other JJ 31504 47 20 science science NN 31504 47 21 , , , 31504 47 22 physical physical JJ 31504 47 23 , , , 31504 47 24 social social JJ 31504 47 25 , , , 31504 47 26 political political JJ 31504 47 27 , , , 31504 47 28 or or CC 31504 47 29 theological theological JJ 31504 47 30 . . . 31504 48 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 48 2 can can MD 31504 48 3 be be VB 31504 48 4 no no DT 31504 48 5 more more RBR 31504 48 6 nor nor CC 31504 48 7 less less RBR 31504 48 8 true true JJ 31504 48 9 in in IN 31504 48 10 each each DT 31504 48 11 and and CC 31504 48 12 all all DT 31504 48 13 . . . 31504 49 1 Again again RB 31504 49 2 , , , 31504 49 3 in in IN 31504 49 4 every every DT 31504 49 5 science science NN 31504 49 6 , , , 31504 49 7 social social JJ 31504 49 8 and and CC 31504 49 9 political political JJ 31504 49 10 as as RB 31504 49 11 well well RB 31504 49 12 as as IN 31504 49 13 others other NNS 31504 49 14 , , , 31504 49 15 and and CC 31504 49 16 as as IN 31504 49 17 to to IN 31504 49 18 every every DT 31504 49 19 proposition proposition NN 31504 49 20 in in IN 31504 49 21 any any DT 31504 49 22 science science NN 31504 49 23 , , , 31504 49 24 the the DT 31504 49 25 truth truth NN 31504 49 26 is be VBZ 31504 49 27 to to TO 31504 49 28 be be VB 31504 49 29 discovered discover VBN 31504 49 30 , , , 31504 49 31 not not RB 31504 49 32 assumed assume VBN 31504 49 33 by by IN 31504 49 34 mere mere JJ 31504 49 35 convention convention NN 31504 49 36 ; ; , 31504 49 37 and and CC 31504 49 38 men man NNS 31504 49 39 must must MD 31504 49 40 discover discover VB 31504 49 41 it -PRON- PRP 31504 49 42 and and CC 31504 49 43 discover discover VB 31504 49 44 it -PRON- PRP 31504 49 45 fully fully RB 31504 49 46 at at IN 31504 49 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 49 48 peril peril NN 31504 49 49 . . . 31504 50 1 Failure failure NN 31504 50 2 even even RB 31504 50 3 after after IN 31504 50 4 the the DT 31504 50 5 utmost utmost JJ 31504 50 6 effort effort NN 31504 50 7 will will MD 31504 50 8 not not RB 31504 50 9 be be VB 31504 50 10 forgiven forgive VBN 31504 50 11 . . . 31504 51 1 If if IN 31504 51 2 the the DT 31504 51 3 truth truth NN 31504 51 4 be be VB 31504 51 5 found find VBN 31504 51 6 it -PRON- PRP 31504 51 7 will will MD 31504 51 8 be be VB 31504 51 9 a a DT 31504 51 10 sure sure JJ 31504 51 11 guide guide NN 31504 51 12 in in IN 31504 51 13 life life NN 31504 51 14 . . . 31504 52 1 If if IN 31504 52 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 52 3 be be VBP 31504 52 4 not not RB 31504 52 5 found find VBN 31504 52 6 the the DT 31504 52 7 lives life NNS 31504 52 8 of of IN 31504 52 9 men man NNS 31504 52 10 will will MD 31504 52 11 so so RB 31504 52 12 far far RB 31504 52 13 go go VB 31504 52 14 awry awry JJ 31504 52 15 . . . 31504 53 1 That that IN 31504 53 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 53 3 may may MD 31504 53 4 be be VB 31504 53 5 difficult difficult JJ 31504 53 6 to to TO 31504 53 7 find find VB 31504 53 8 , , , 31504 53 9 that that IN 31504 53 10 we -PRON- PRP 31504 53 11 may may MD 31504 53 12 never never RB 31504 53 13 be be VB 31504 53 14 sure sure JJ 31504 53 15 we -PRON- PRP 31504 53 16 have have VBP 31504 53 17 found find VBN 31504 53 18 it -PRON- PRP 31504 53 19 , , , 31504 53 20 makes make VBZ 31504 53 21 no no DT 31504 53 22 difference difference NN 31504 53 23 . . . 31504 54 1 Are be VBP 31504 54 2 there there EX 31504 54 3 any any DT 31504 54 4 attributes attribute NNS 31504 54 5 of of IN 31504 54 6 justice justice NN 31504 54 7 of of IN 31504 54 8 which which WDT 31504 54 9 we -PRON- PRP 31504 54 10 can can MD 31504 54 11 speak speak VB 31504 54 12 so so RB 31504 54 13 confidently confidently RB 31504 54 14 as as IN 31504 54 15 being be VBG 31504 54 16 necessary necessary JJ 31504 54 17 , , , 31504 54 18 inherent inherent JJ 31504 54 19 , , , 31504 54 20 and and CC 31504 54 21 self self NN 31504 54 22 - - HYPH 31504 54 23 evident evident JJ 31504 54 24 ? ? . 31504 55 1 That that DT 31504 55 2 justice justice NN 31504 55 3 ranks rank VBZ 31504 55 4 next next RB 31504 55 5 to to IN 31504 55 6 truth truth NN 31504 55 7 , , , 31504 55 8 if if IN 31504 55 9 not not RB 31504 55 10 with with IN 31504 55 11 it -PRON- PRP 31504 55 12 , , , 31504 55 13 seems seem VBZ 31504 55 14 to to TO 31504 55 15 have have VB 31504 55 16 been be VBN 31504 55 17 , , , 31504 55 18 and and CC 31504 55 19 to to TO 31504 55 20 be be VB 31504 55 21 , , , 31504 55 22 the the DT 31504 55 23 general general JJ 31504 55 24 judgment judgment NN 31504 55 25 of of IN 31504 55 26 mankind mankind NN 31504 55 27 . . . 31504 56 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 56 2 has have VBZ 31504 56 3 engaged engage VBN 31504 56 4 the the DT 31504 56 5 thought thought NN 31504 56 6 and and CC 31504 56 7 fired fire VBD 31504 56 8 the the DT 31504 56 9 imagination imagination NN 31504 56 10 of of IN 31504 56 11 the the DT 31504 56 12 greatest great JJS 31504 56 13 minds mind NNS 31504 56 14 . . . 31504 57 1 A a DT 31504 57 2 few few JJ 31504 57 3 quotations quotation NNS 31504 57 4 from from IN 31504 57 5 such such JJ 31504 57 6 , , , 31504 57 7 ranging range VBG 31504 57 8 from from IN 31504 57 9 ancient ancient JJ 31504 57 10 to to IN 31504 57 11 modern modern JJ 31504 57 12 times time NNS 31504 57 13 , , , 31504 57 14 will will MD 31504 57 15 illustrate illustrate VB 31504 57 16 this this DT 31504 57 17 . . . 31504 58 1 The the DT 31504 58 2 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 31504 58 3 Psalmist Psalmist NNP 31504 58 4 gloried glory VBD 31504 58 5 that that IN 31504 58 6 " " `` 31504 58 7 justice justice NN 31504 58 8 and and CC 31504 58 9 judgment judgment NN 31504 58 10 " " '' 31504 58 11 were be VBD 31504 58 12 the the DT 31504 58 13 habitation habitation NN 31504 58 14 of of IN 31504 58 15 Jehovah Jehovah NNP 31504 58 16 's 's POS 31504 58 17 throne throne NN 31504 58 18 . . . 31504 59 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 31504 59 2 wrote write VBD 31504 59 3 , , , 31504 59 4 " " `` 31504 59 5 political political JJ 31504 59 6 science science NN 31504 59 7 is be VBZ 31504 59 8 the the DT 31504 59 9 most most RBS 31504 59 10 excellent excellent JJ 31504 59 11 of of IN 31504 59 12 all all PDT 31504 59 13 the the DT 31504 59 14 arts art NNS 31504 59 15 and and CC 31504 59 16 sciences science NNS 31504 59 17 , , , 31504 59 18 and and CC 31504 59 19 the the DT 31504 59 20 end end NN 31504 59 21 sought seek VBN 31504 59 22 for for IN 31504 59 23 in in IN 31504 59 24 political political JJ 31504 59 25 science science NN 31504 59 26 is be VBZ 31504 59 27 the the DT 31504 59 28 greatest great JJS 31504 59 29 good good NN 31504 59 30 for for IN 31504 59 31 man man NN 31504 59 32 , , , 31504 59 33 which which WDT 31504 59 34 is be VBZ 31504 59 35 justice justice NN 31504 59 36 , , , 31504 59 37 for for IN 31504 59 38 justice justice NN 31504 59 39 is be VBZ 31504 59 40 the the DT 31504 59 41 interest interest NN 31504 59 42 of of IN 31504 59 43 all all DT 31504 59 44 . . . 31504 59 45 " " '' 31504 60 1 Early early RB 31504 60 2 in in IN 31504 60 3 the the DT 31504 60 4 12th 12th JJ 31504 60 5 century century NN 31504 60 6 the the DT 31504 60 7 jurist jurist NN 31504 60 8 Irnerius Irnerius NNP 31504 60 9 , , , 31504 60 10 distinguished distinguish VBN 31504 60 11 for for IN 31504 60 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 60 13 learning learning NN 31504 60 14 and and CC 31504 60 15 for for IN 31504 60 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 60 17 zeal zeal NN 31504 60 18 in in IN 31504 60 19 promoting promote VBG 31504 60 20 the the DT 31504 60 21 revival revival NN 31504 60 22 of of IN 31504 60 23 the the DT 31504 60 24 study study NN 31504 60 25 of of IN 31504 60 26 law law NN 31504 60 27 and and CC 31504 60 28 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 31504 60 29 , , , 31504 60 30 and and CC 31504 60 31 also also RB 31504 60 32 as as IN 31504 60 33 the the DT 31504 60 34 reputed repute VBN 31504 60 35 founder founder NN 31504 60 36 of of IN 31504 60 37 the the DT 31504 60 38 famous famous JJ 31504 60 39 Law Law NNP 31504 60 40 School School NNP 31504 60 41 at at IN 31504 60 42 Bologna Bologna NNP 31504 60 43 , , , 31504 60 44 imaged imaged JJ 31504 60 45 justice justice NN 31504 60 46 as as IN 31504 60 47 " " `` 31504 60 48 clothed clothe VBN 31504 60 49 with with IN 31504 60 50 dignity dignity NN 31504 60 51 ineffable ineffable JJ 31504 60 52 , , , 31504 60 53 shining shine VBG 31504 60 54 with with IN 31504 60 55 reason reason NN 31504 60 56 and and CC 31504 60 57 equity equity NN 31504 60 58 , , , 31504 60 59 and and CC 31504 60 60 supported support VBN 31504 60 61 by by IN 31504 60 62 Religion Religion NNP 31504 60 63 , , , 31504 60 64 Loyalty Loyalty NNP 31504 60 65 , , , 31504 60 66 Charity Charity NNP 31504 60 67 , , , 31504 60 68 Retribution Retribution NNP 31504 60 69 , , , 31504 60 70 Reverence Reverence NNP 31504 60 71 , , , 31504 60 72 and and CC 31504 60 73 Truth truth NN 31504 60 74 . . . 31504 60 75 " " '' 31504 61 1 Six six CD 31504 61 2 centuries century NNS 31504 61 3 later later RB 31504 61 4 Addison Addison NNP 31504 61 5 , , , 31504 61 6 famed fame VBN 31504 61 7 as as IN 31504 61 8 a a DT 31504 61 9 clear clear JJ 31504 61 10 thinker thinker NN 31504 61 11 and and CC 31504 61 12 writer writer NN 31504 61 13 , , , 31504 61 14 thus thus RB 31504 61 15 wrote write VBD 31504 61 16 of of IN 31504 61 17 justice justice NN 31504 61 18 : : : 31504 61 19 " " `` 31504 61 20 There there EX 31504 61 21 is be VBZ 31504 61 22 no no DT 31504 61 23 virtue virtue NN 31504 61 24 so so RB 31504 61 25 truly truly RB 31504 61 26 great great JJ 31504 61 27 and and CC 31504 61 28 godlike godlike VBP 31504 61 29 as as IN 31504 61 30 justice justice NN 31504 61 31 .... .... . 31504 61 32 Omniscience omniscience NN 31504 61 33 and and CC 31504 61 34 omnipotence omnipotence NN 31504 61 35 are be VBP 31504 61 36 requisites requisite NNS 31504 61 37 for for IN 31504 61 38 the the DT 31504 61 39 full full JJ 31504 61 40 exercise exercise NN 31504 61 41 of of IN 31504 61 42 it -PRON- PRP 31504 61 43 . . . 31504 61 44 " " '' 31504 62 1 Almost almost RB 31504 62 2 in in IN 31504 62 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 62 4 own own JJ 31504 62 5 time time NN 31504 62 6 Daniel Daniel NNP 31504 62 7 Webster Webster NNP 31504 62 8 , , , 31504 62 9 called call VBD 31504 62 10 in in IN 31504 62 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 62 12 day day NN 31504 62 13 the the DT 31504 62 14 great great JJ 31504 62 15 expounder expounder NN 31504 62 16 and and CC 31504 62 17 even even RB 31504 62 18 now now RB 31504 62 19 reckoned reckon VBN 31504 62 20 among among IN 31504 62 21 the the DT 31504 62 22 greatest great JJS 31504 62 23 of of IN 31504 62 24 men man NNS 31504 62 25 intellectually intellectually RB 31504 62 26 , , , 31504 62 27 in in IN 31504 62 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 62 29 eulogy eulogy NN 31504 62 30 upon upon IN 31504 62 31 Justice Justice NNP 31504 62 32 Story Story NNP 31504 62 33 thus thus RB 31504 62 34 apostrophized apostrophize VBD 31504 62 35 justice justice NN 31504 62 36 : : : 31504 62 37 " " `` 31504 62 38 Justice justice NN 31504 62 39 is be VBZ 31504 62 40 the the DT 31504 62 41 great great JJ 31504 62 42 interest interest NN 31504 62 43 of of IN 31504 62 44 man man NN 31504 62 45 on on IN 31504 62 46 earth earth NN 31504 62 47 . . . 31504 63 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 63 2 is be VBZ 31504 63 3 the the DT 31504 63 4 ligament ligament NN 31504 63 5 which which WDT 31504 63 6 holds hold VBZ 31504 63 7 civilized civilized JJ 31504 63 8 beings being NNS 31504 63 9 and and CC 31504 63 10 civilized civilized JJ 31504 63 11 nations nation NNS 31504 63 12 together together RB 31504 63 13 . . . 31504 64 1 Wherever wherever WRB 31504 64 2 her -PRON- PRP$ 31504 64 3 temple temple NN 31504 64 4 stands stand VBZ 31504 64 5 and and CC 31504 64 6 so so RB 31504 64 7 long long RB 31504 64 8 as as IN 31504 64 9 it -PRON- PRP 31504 64 10 is be VBZ 31504 64 11 duly duly RB 31504 64 12 honored honor VBN 31504 64 13 , , , 31504 64 14 there there EX 31504 64 15 is be VBZ 31504 64 16 a a DT 31504 64 17 foundation foundation NN 31504 64 18 for for IN 31504 64 19 social social NNP 31504 64 20 security security NNP 31504 64 21 , , , 31504 64 22 general general JJ 31504 64 23 happiness happiness NN 31504 64 24 , , , 31504 64 25 and and CC 31504 64 26 the the DT 31504 64 27 improvement improvement NN 31504 64 28 and and CC 31504 64 29 progress progress NN 31504 64 30 of of IN 31504 64 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 64 32 race race NN 31504 64 33 . . . 31504 64 34 " " '' 31504 65 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 31504 65 2 , , , 31504 65 3 however however RB 31504 65 4 , , , 31504 65 5 none none NN 31504 65 6 of of IN 31504 65 7 these these DT 31504 65 8 laudations laudation NNS 31504 65 9 is be VBZ 31504 65 10 so so RB 31504 65 11 vividly vividly RB 31504 65 12 impressive impressive JJ 31504 65 13 as as IN 31504 65 14 is be VBZ 31504 65 15 the the DT 31504 65 16 pithy pithy JJ 31504 65 17 remark remark NN 31504 65 18 of of IN 31504 65 19 an an DT 31504 65 20 old old JJ 31504 65 21 English english JJ 31504 65 22 judge judge NN 31504 65 23 that that IN 31504 65 24 " " `` 31504 65 25 injustice injustice NN 31504 65 26 cuts cut NNS 31504 65 27 to to IN 31504 65 28 the the DT 31504 65 29 bone bone NN 31504 65 30 . . . 31504 65 31 " " '' 31504 66 1 But but CC 31504 66 2 what what WP 31504 66 3 is be VBZ 31504 66 4 this this DT 31504 66 5 justice justice NN 31504 66 6 , , , 31504 66 7 declared declare VBD 31504 66 8 to to TO 31504 66 9 be be VB 31504 66 10 so so RB 31504 66 11 great great JJ 31504 66 12 a a DT 31504 66 13 virtue virtue NN 31504 66 14 , , , 31504 66 15 so so RB 31504 66 16 ineffable ineffable JJ 31504 66 17 , , , 31504 66 18 so so RB 31504 66 19 supremely supremely RB 31504 66 20 important important JJ 31504 66 21 ? ? . 31504 67 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 67 2 have have VBP 31504 67 3 said say VBN 31504 67 4 we -PRON- PRP 31504 67 5 feel feel VBP 31504 67 6 certain certain JJ 31504 67 7 of of IN 31504 67 8 some some DT 31504 67 9 attributes attribute NNS 31504 67 10 of of IN 31504 67 11 truth truth NN 31504 67 12 . . . 31504 68 1 Do do VBP 31504 68 2 we -PRON- PRP 31504 68 3 know know VB 31504 68 4 or or CC 31504 68 5 can can MD 31504 68 6 we -PRON- PRP 31504 68 7 know know VB 31504 68 8 anything anything NN 31504 68 9 certain certain JJ 31504 68 10 about about IN 31504 68 11 justice justice NN 31504 68 12 ? ? . 31504 69 1 Is be VBZ 31504 69 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 69 3 something something NN 31504 69 4 above above IN 31504 69 5 and and CC 31504 69 6 apart apart RB 31504 69 7 from from IN 31504 69 8 the the DT 31504 69 9 will will NN 31504 69 10 of of IN 31504 69 11 men man NNS 31504 69 12 , , , 31504 69 13 or or CC 31504 69 14 is be VBZ 31504 69 15 it -PRON- PRP 31504 69 16 simply simply RB 31504 69 17 a a DT 31504 69 18 matter matter NN 31504 69 19 of of IN 31504 69 20 convention convention NN 31504 69 21 among among IN 31504 69 22 men man NNS 31504 69 23 ? ? . 31504 70 1 Is be VBZ 31504 70 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 70 3 immutable immutable JJ 31504 70 4 , , , 31504 70 5 or or CC 31504 70 6 does do VBZ 31504 70 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 70 8 nature nature NN 31504 70 9 change change NN 31504 70 10 with with IN 31504 70 11 changing change VBG 31504 70 12 times time NNS 31504 70 13 and and CC 31504 70 14 conditions condition NNS 31504 70 15 ? ? . 31504 71 1 If if IN 31504 71 2 mutable mutable JJ 31504 71 3 , , , 31504 71 4 does do VBZ 31504 71 5 it -PRON- PRP 31504 71 6 change change VB 31504 71 7 of of IN 31504 71 8 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 71 9 or or CC 31504 71 10 do do VBP 31504 71 11 men man NNS 31504 71 12 change change VB 31504 71 13 it -PRON- PRP 31504 71 14 ? ? . 31504 72 1 Is be VBZ 31504 72 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 72 3 universal universal JJ 31504 72 4 or or CC 31504 72 5 local local JJ 31504 72 6 , , , 31504 72 7 the the DT 31504 72 8 same same JJ 31504 72 9 everywhere everywhere RB 31504 72 10 or or CC 31504 72 11 is be VBZ 31504 72 12 it -PRON- PRP 31504 72 13 different different JJ 31504 72 14 in in IN 31504 72 15 different different JJ 31504 72 16 localities locality NNS 31504 72 17 ? ? . 31504 73 1 Is be VBZ 31504 73 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 73 3 the the DT 31504 73 4 same same JJ 31504 73 5 for for IN 31504 73 6 all all DT 31504 73 7 men man NNS 31504 73 8 and and CC 31504 73 9 races race NNS 31504 73 10 of of IN 31504 73 11 men man NNS 31504 73 12 or or CC 31504 73 13 does do VBZ 31504 73 14 it -PRON- PRP 31504 73 15 differ differ VB 31504 73 16 according accord VBG 31504 73 17 to to IN 31504 73 18 classes class NNS 31504 73 19 and and CC 31504 73 20 races race NNS 31504 73 21 ? ? . 31504 74 1 Again again RB 31504 74 2 , , , 31504 74 3 is be VBZ 31504 74 4 it -PRON- PRP 31504 74 5 single single JJ 31504 74 6 or or CC 31504 74 7 diverse diverse JJ 31504 74 8 in in IN 31504 74 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 74 10 nature nature NN 31504 74 11 ? ? . 31504 75 1 Is be VBZ 31504 75 2 there there EX 31504 75 3 more more JJR 31504 75 4 than than IN 31504 75 5 one one CD 31504 75 6 kind kind NN 31504 75 7 of of IN 31504 75 8 justice justice NN 31504 75 9 ? ? . 31504 76 1 We -PRON- PRP 31504 76 2 hear hear VBP 31504 76 3 of of IN 31504 76 4 natural natural JJ 31504 76 5 justice justice NN 31504 76 6 , , , 31504 76 7 social social JJ 31504 76 8 justice justice NN 31504 76 9 , , , 31504 76 10 industrial industrial JJ 31504 76 11 justice justice NN 31504 76 12 , , , 31504 76 13 political political JJ 31504 76 14 justice justice NN 31504 76 15 . . . 31504 77 1 What what WP 31504 77 2 do do VBP 31504 77 3 they -PRON- PRP 31504 77 4 who who WP 31504 77 5 use use VBP 31504 77 6 those those DT 31504 77 7 terms term NNS 31504 77 8 mean mean VBP 31504 77 9 by by IN 31504 77 10 them -PRON- PRP 31504 77 11 ? ? . 31504 78 1 Do do VBP 31504 78 2 nature nature NN 31504 78 3 , , , 31504 78 4 society society NN 31504 78 5 , , , 31504 78 6 industry industry NN 31504 78 7 , , , 31504 78 8 politics politic NNS 31504 78 9 , , , 31504 78 10 each each DT 31504 78 11 have have VBP 31504 78 12 a a DT 31504 78 13 different different JJ 31504 78 14 criterion criterion NN 31504 78 15 ? ? . 31504 79 1 Still still RB 31504 79 2 again again RB 31504 79 3 , , , 31504 79 4 and and CC 31504 79 5 briefly briefly RB 31504 79 6 , , , 31504 79 7 is be VBZ 31504 79 8 justice justice NN 31504 79 9 an an DT 31504 79 10 inexorable inexorable JJ 31504 79 11 law law NN 31504 79 12 like like IN 31504 79 13 the the DT 31504 79 14 law law NN 31504 79 15 of of IN 31504 79 16 gravitation gravitation NN 31504 79 17 or or CC 31504 79 18 can can MD 31504 79 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 79 20 operation operation NN 31504 79 21 have have VB 31504 79 22 exceptions exception NNS 31504 79 23 ? ? . 31504 80 1 Is be VBZ 31504 80 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 80 3 simply simply RB 31504 80 4 a a DT 31504 80 5 quality quality NN 31504 80 6 of of IN 31504 80 7 action action NN 31504 80 8 or or CC 31504 80 9 conduct conduct NN 31504 80 10 , , , 31504 80 11 or or CC 31504 80 12 , , , 31504 80 13 as as IN 31504 80 14 stated state VBN 31504 80 15 by by IN 31504 80 16 Ulpian Ulpian NNP 31504 80 17 , , , 31504 80 18 is be VBZ 31504 80 19 it -PRON- PRP 31504 80 20 a a DT 31504 80 21 disposition disposition NN 31504 80 22 or or CC 31504 80 23 state state NN 31504 80 24 of of IN 31504 80 25 mind mind NN 31504 80 26 ? ? . 31504 81 1 Finally finally RB 31504 81 2 , , , 31504 81 3 is be VBZ 31504 81 4 it -PRON- PRP 31504 81 5 a a DT 31504 81 6 reality reality NN 31504 81 7 or or CC 31504 81 8 , , , 31504 81 9 as as IN 31504 81 10 Falstaff Falstaff NNP 31504 81 11 said say VBD 31504 81 12 of of IN 31504 81 13 honor honor NN 31504 81 14 , , , 31504 81 15 is be VBZ 31504 81 16 it -PRON- PRP 31504 81 17 after after RB 31504 81 18 all all RB 31504 81 19 " " `` 31504 81 20 a a DT 31504 81 21 word word NN 31504 81 22 , , , 31504 81 23 " " '' 31504 81 24 " " `` 31504 81 25 a a DT 31504 81 26 mere mere JJ 31504 81 27 scutcheon scutcheon NN 31504 81 28 ? ? . 31504 81 29 " " '' 31504 82 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 82 2 am be VBP 31504 82 3 not not RB 31504 82 4 so so RB 31504 82 5 presumptuous presumptuous JJ 31504 82 6 as as IN 31504 82 7 to to TO 31504 82 8 venture venture VB 31504 82 9 an an DT 31504 82 10 answer answer NN 31504 82 11 to to IN 31504 82 12 any any DT 31504 82 13 of of IN 31504 82 14 these these DT 31504 82 15 questions question NNS 31504 82 16 except except IN 31504 82 17 perhaps perhaps RB 31504 82 18 the the DT 31504 82 19 last last JJ 31504 82 20 . . . 31504 83 1 As as IN 31504 83 2 to to IN 31504 83 3 that that DT 31504 83 4 , , , 31504 83 5 I -PRON- PRP 31504 83 6 appeal appeal VBP 31504 83 7 to to IN 31504 83 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 83 9 consciousness consciousness NN 31504 83 10 , , , 31504 83 11 to to IN 31504 83 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 83 13 innate innate JJ 31504 83 14 conviction conviction NN 31504 83 15 that that IN 31504 83 16 there there EX 31504 83 17 does do VBZ 31504 83 18 exist exist VB 31504 83 19 something something NN 31504 83 20 , , , 31504 83 21 some some DT 31504 83 22 virtue virtue NN 31504 83 23 , , , 31504 83 24 some some DT 31504 83 25 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 83 26 , , , 31504 83 27 however however RB 31504 83 28 undefinable undefinable JJ 31504 83 29 in in IN 31504 83 30 terms term NNS 31504 83 31 , , , 31504 83 32 holding hold VBG 31504 83 33 men man NNS 31504 83 34 together together RB 31504 83 35 in in IN 31504 83 36 society society NN 31504 83 37 despite despite IN 31504 83 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 83 39 natural natural JJ 31504 83 40 selfishness selfishness NN 31504 83 41 , , , 31504 83 42 and and CC 31504 83 43 without without IN 31504 83 44 which which WDT 31504 83 45 they -PRON- PRP 31504 83 46 would would MD 31504 83 47 fall fall VB 31504 83 48 apart apart RB 31504 83 49 . . . 31504 84 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 84 2 is be VBZ 31504 84 3 this this DT 31504 84 4 virtue virtue NN 31504 84 5 , , , 31504 84 6 this this DT 31504 84 7 ligament ligament NN 31504 84 8 of of IN 31504 84 9 society society NN 31504 84 10 , , , 31504 84 11 that that IN 31504 84 12 we -PRON- PRP 31504 84 13 call call VBP 31504 84 14 justice justice NN 31504 84 15 . . . 31504 85 1 We -PRON- PRP 31504 85 2 feel feel VBP 31504 85 3 that that IN 31504 85 4 the the DT 31504 85 5 word word NN 31504 85 6 is be VBZ 31504 85 7 not not RB 31504 85 8 a a DT 31504 85 9 mere mere JJ 31504 85 10 word word NN 31504 85 11 , , , 31504 85 12 but but CC 31504 85 13 that that IN 31504 85 14 it -PRON- PRP 31504 85 15 connotes connote VBZ 31504 85 16 a a DT 31504 85 17 vital vital JJ 31504 85 18 reality reality NN 31504 85 19 in in IN 31504 85 20 human human JJ 31504 85 21 relationship relationship NN 31504 85 22 . . . 31504 86 1 If if IN 31504 86 2 this this DT 31504 86 3 reality reality NN 31504 86 4 be be VB 31504 86 5 ignored ignore VBN 31504 86 6 , , , 31504 86 7 men man NNS 31504 86 8 can can MD 31504 86 9 not not RB 31504 86 10 be be VB 31504 86 11 held hold VBN 31504 86 12 together together RB 31504 86 13 in in IN 31504 86 14 any any DT 31504 86 15 society society NN 31504 86 16 . . . 31504 87 1 If if IN 31504 87 2 justice justice NN 31504 87 3 be be VBP 31504 87 4 the the DT 31504 87 5 greatest great JJS 31504 87 6 good good JJ 31504 87 7 , , , 31504 87 8 as as IN 31504 87 9 so so RB 31504 87 10 generally generally RB 31504 87 11 asserted assert VBN 31504 87 12 , , , 31504 87 13 then then RB 31504 87 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 87 15 negative negative JJ 31504 87 16 , , , 31504 87 17 or or CC 31504 87 18 injustice injustice NN 31504 87 19 , , , 31504 87 20 must must MD 31504 87 21 be be VB 31504 87 22 the the DT 31504 87 23 greatest great JJS 31504 87 24 evil evil NN 31504 87 25 . . . 31504 88 1 Hence hence RB 31504 88 2 error error NN 31504 88 3 in in IN 31504 88 4 men man NNS 31504 88 5 's 's POS 31504 88 6 opinions opinion NNS 31504 88 7 of of IN 31504 88 8 what what WP 31504 88 9 is be VBZ 31504 88 10 justice justice NN 31504 88 11 will will MD 31504 88 12 work work VB 31504 88 13 that that DT 31504 88 14 greatest great JJS 31504 88 15 evil evil NN 31504 88 16 . . . 31504 89 1 Society society NN 31504 89 2 as as IN 31504 89 3 a a DT 31504 89 4 whole whole NN 31504 89 5 is be VBZ 31504 89 6 liable liable JJ 31504 89 7 to to TO 31504 89 8 error error VB 31504 89 9 in in IN 31504 89 10 respect respect NN 31504 89 11 to to IN 31504 89 12 justice justice NN 31504 89 13 ; ; : 31504 89 14 has have VBZ 31504 89 15 often often RB 31504 89 16 been be VBN 31504 89 17 mistaken mistaken JJ 31504 89 18 in in IN 31504 89 19 the the DT 31504 89 20 past past NN 31504 89 21 and and CC 31504 89 22 may may MD 31504 89 23 be be VB 31504 89 24 mistaken mistaken JJ 31504 89 25 today today NN 31504 89 26 . . . 31504 90 1 The the DT 31504 90 2 individuals individual NNS 31504 90 3 composing compose VBG 31504 90 4 society society NN 31504 90 5 are be VBP 31504 90 6 seldom seldom JJ 31504 90 7 , , , 31504 90 8 if if IN 31504 90 9 ever ever RB 31504 90 10 , , , 31504 90 11 wholly wholly RB 31504 90 12 disinterested disintereste VBN 31504 90 13 and and CC 31504 90 14 dispassionate dispassionate VB 31504 90 15 in in IN 31504 90 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 90 17 judgments judgment NNS 31504 90 18 . . . 31504 91 1 Each each DT 31504 91 2 individual individual NN 31504 91 3 is be VBZ 31504 91 4 prone prone JJ 31504 91 5 to to TO 31504 91 6 believe believe VB 31504 91 7 that that IN 31504 91 8 what what WP 31504 91 9 is be VBZ 31504 91 10 apparently apparently RB 31504 91 11 good good JJ 31504 91 12 for for IN 31504 91 13 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 91 14 or or CC 31504 91 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 91 16 group group NN 31504 91 17 or or CC 31504 91 18 class class NN 31504 91 19 , , , 31504 91 20 is be VBZ 31504 91 21 in in IN 31504 91 22 accord accord NN 31504 91 23 with with IN 31504 91 24 justice justice NN 31504 91 25 . . . 31504 92 1 Himself -PRON- PRP 31504 92 2 persuaded persuade VBD 31504 92 3 that that IN 31504 92 4 he -PRON- PRP 31504 92 5 is be VBZ 31504 92 6 battling battle VBG 31504 92 7 for for IN 31504 92 8 justice justice NN 31504 92 9 , , , 31504 92 10 he -PRON- PRP 31504 92 11 does do VBZ 31504 92 12 not not RB 31504 92 13 see see VB 31504 92 14 that that IN 31504 92 15 he -PRON- PRP 31504 92 16 may may MD 31504 92 17 be be VB 31504 92 18 battling battle VBG 31504 92 19 only only RB 31504 92 20 for for IN 31504 92 21 some some DT 31504 92 22 advantage advantage NN 31504 92 23 over over IN 31504 92 24 others other NNS 31504 92 25 , , , 31504 92 26 for for IN 31504 92 27 some some DT 31504 92 28 individual individual JJ 31504 92 29 relief relief NN 31504 92 30 from from IN 31504 92 31 common common JJ 31504 92 32 burdens burden NNS 31504 92 33 , , , 31504 92 34 for for IN 31504 92 35 some some DT 31504 92 36 privilege privilege NN 31504 92 37 not not RB 31504 92 38 to to TO 31504 92 39 be be VB 31504 92 40 accorded accord VBN 31504 92 41 to to IN 31504 92 42 others other NNS 31504 92 43 ; ; : 31504 92 44 does do VBZ 31504 92 45 not not RB 31504 92 46 see see VB 31504 92 47 that that IN 31504 92 48 what what WP 31504 92 49 he -PRON- PRP 31504 92 50 is be VBZ 31504 92 51 battling battle VBG 31504 92 52 for for IN 31504 92 53 may may MD 31504 92 54 cause cause VB 31504 92 55 injustice injustice NN 31504 92 56 to to IN 31504 92 57 others other NNS 31504 92 58 . . . 31504 93 1 Through through IN 31504 93 2 ignorance ignorance NN 31504 93 3 of of IN 31504 93 4 the the DT 31504 93 5 real real JJ 31504 93 6 nature nature NN 31504 93 7 of of IN 31504 93 8 justice justice NN 31504 93 9 , , , 31504 93 10 the the DT 31504 93 11 grant grant NN 31504 93 12 to to IN 31504 93 13 one one CD 31504 93 14 of of IN 31504 93 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 93 16 plea plea NN 31504 93 17 for for IN 31504 93 18 what what WP 31504 93 19 he -PRON- PRP 31504 93 20 calls call VBZ 31504 93 21 justice justice NN 31504 93 22 may may MD 31504 93 23 work work VB 31504 93 24 grievous grievous JJ 31504 93 25 injustice injustice NN 31504 93 26 to to IN 31504 93 27 others other NNS 31504 93 28 . . . 31504 94 1 So so RB 31504 94 2 when when WRB 31504 94 3 altruists altruist NNS 31504 94 4 , , , 31504 94 5 warm warm JJ 31504 94 6 with with IN 31504 94 7 sympathy sympathy NN 31504 94 8 , , , 31504 94 9 obtain obtain VB 31504 94 10 the the DT 31504 94 11 enactment enactment NN 31504 94 12 of of IN 31504 94 13 laws law NNS 31504 94 14 intended intend VBN 31504 94 15 for for IN 31504 94 16 the the DT 31504 94 17 betterment betterment NN 31504 94 18 of of IN 31504 94 19 the the DT 31504 94 20 less less RBR 31504 94 21 fortunate fortunate JJ 31504 94 22 , , , 31504 94 23 they -PRON- PRP 31504 94 24 may may MD 31504 94 25 at at IN 31504 94 26 times time NNS 31504 94 27 do do VB 31504 94 28 injustice injustice NN 31504 94 29 to to IN 31504 94 30 others other NNS 31504 94 31 and and CC 31504 94 32 even even RB 31504 94 33 to to IN 31504 94 34 those those DT 31504 94 35 they -PRON- PRP 31504 94 36 hoped hope VBD 31504 94 37 to to TO 31504 94 38 benefit benefit VB 31504 94 39 . . . 31504 95 1 History history NN 31504 95 2 records record VBZ 31504 95 3 many many JJ 31504 95 4 instances instance NNS 31504 95 5 where where WRB 31504 95 6 laws law NNS 31504 95 7 intended intend VBN 31504 95 8 to to TO 31504 95 9 insure insure VB 31504 95 10 justice justice NN 31504 95 11 had have VBD 31504 95 12 the the DT 31504 95 13 contrary contrary JJ 31504 95 14 effect effect NN 31504 95 15 . . . 31504 96 1 Many many JJ 31504 96 2 a a DT 31504 96 3 statute statute NN 31504 96 4 designed design VBN 31504 96 5 to to TO 31504 96 6 prevent prevent VB 31504 96 7 oppression oppression NN 31504 96 8 has have VBZ 31504 96 9 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 96 10 proved prove VBN 31504 96 11 oppressive oppressive JJ 31504 96 12 in in IN 31504 96 13 operation operation NN 31504 96 14 . . . 31504 97 1 Many many JJ 31504 97 2 a a DT 31504 97 3 theory theory NN 31504 97 4 of of IN 31504 97 5 justice justice NN 31504 97 6 has have VBZ 31504 97 7 been be VBN 31504 97 8 found find VBN 31504 97 9 to to TO 31504 97 10 work work VB 31504 97 11 injustice injustice NN 31504 97 12 . . . 31504 98 1 A a DT 31504 98 2 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 31504 98 3 and and CC 31504 98 4 familiar familiar JJ 31504 98 5 instance instance NN 31504 98 6 is be VBZ 31504 98 7 found find VBN 31504 98 8 in in IN 31504 98 9 the the DT 31504 98 10 history history NN 31504 98 11 of of IN 31504 98 12 the the DT 31504 98 13 French French NNP 31504 98 14 Revolution Revolution NNP 31504 98 15 . . . 31504 99 1 The the DT 31504 99 2 Jacobins Jacobins NNP 31504 99 3 believed believe VBD 31504 99 4 that that IN 31504 99 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 99 6 theories theory NNS 31504 99 7 if if IN 31504 99 8 given give VBN 31504 99 9 effect effect NN 31504 99 10 would would MD 31504 99 11 usher usher VB 31504 99 12 in in IN 31504 99 13 the the DT 31504 99 14 reign reign NN 31504 99 15 of of IN 31504 99 16 justice justice NN 31504 99 17 in in IN 31504 99 18 France France NNP 31504 99 19 . . . 31504 100 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 100 2 obtained obtain VBD 31504 100 3 power power NN 31504 100 4 and and CC 31504 100 5 exploited exploit VBD 31504 100 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 100 7 theories theory NNS 31504 100 8 only only RB 31504 100 9 to to TO 31504 100 10 bring bring VB 31504 100 11 in in RP 31504 100 12 the the DT 31504 100 13 Reign Reign NNP 31504 100 14 of of IN 31504 100 15 Terror Terror NNP 31504 100 16 , , , 31504 100 17 that that DT 31504 100 18 reign reign NN 31504 100 19 of of IN 31504 100 20 terrible terrible JJ 31504 100 21 injustice injustice NN 31504 100 22 . . . 31504 101 1 As as IN 31504 101 2 mistakes mistake NNS 31504 101 3 and and CC 31504 101 4 grievous grievous JJ 31504 101 5 mistakes mistake NNS 31504 101 6 have have VBP 31504 101 7 been be VBN 31504 101 8 made make VBN 31504 101 9 in in IN 31504 101 10 the the DT 31504 101 11 past past NN 31504 101 12 as as IN 31504 101 13 to to IN 31504 101 14 what what WP 31504 101 15 is be VBZ 31504 101 16 justice justice NN 31504 101 17 , , , 31504 101 18 so so RB 31504 101 19 they -PRON- PRP 31504 101 20 will will MD 31504 101 21 be be VB 31504 101 22 made make VBN 31504 101 23 now now RB 31504 101 24 and and CC 31504 101 25 in in IN 31504 101 26 the the DT 31504 101 27 future future NN 31504 101 28 , , , 31504 101 29 and and CC 31504 101 30 can can MD 31504 101 31 be be VB 31504 101 32 lessened lessen VBN 31504 101 33 only only RB 31504 101 34 by by IN 31504 101 35 greater great JJR 31504 101 36 wisdom wisdom NN 31504 101 37 and and CC 31504 101 38 forethought forethought NN 31504 101 39 , , , 31504 101 40 by by IN 31504 101 41 greater great JJR 31504 101 42 effort effort NN 31504 101 43 to to TO 31504 101 44 consider consider VB 31504 101 45 justice justice NN 31504 101 46 apart apart RB 31504 101 47 by by IN 31504 101 48 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 101 49 , , , 31504 101 50 with with IN 31504 101 51 philosophical philosophical JJ 31504 101 52 detachment detachment NN 31504 101 53 , , , 31504 101 54 with with IN 31504 101 55 minds mind NNS 31504 101 56 unclouded uncloude VBN 31504 101 57 by by IN 31504 101 58 pity pity NN 31504 101 59 , , , 31504 101 60 sympathy sympathy NN 31504 101 61 , , , 31504 101 62 charity charity NN 31504 101 63 , , , 31504 101 64 and and CC 31504 101 65 other other JJ 31504 101 66 like like JJ 31504 101 67 virtues virtue NNS 31504 101 68 , , , 31504 101 69 on on IN 31504 101 70 the the DT 31504 101 71 one one CD 31504 101 72 hand hand NN 31504 101 73 , , , 31504 101 74 or or CC 31504 101 75 by by IN 31504 101 76 envy envy NN 31504 101 77 , , , 31504 101 78 hate hate NN 31504 101 79 , , , 31504 101 80 prejudice prejudice NN 31504 101 81 , , , 31504 101 82 and and CC 31504 101 83 like like IN 31504 101 84 evil evil JJ 31504 101 85 sentiments sentiment NNS 31504 101 86 , , , 31504 101 87 on on IN 31504 101 88 the the DT 31504 101 89 other other JJ 31504 101 90 . . . 31504 102 1 True true JJ 31504 102 2 , , , 31504 102 3 men man NNS 31504 102 4 are be VBP 31504 102 5 more more RBR 31504 102 6 enlightened enlightened JJ 31504 102 7 now now RB 31504 102 8 and and CC 31504 102 9 education education NN 31504 102 10 is be VBZ 31504 102 11 more more RBR 31504 102 12 general general JJ 31504 102 13 , , , 31504 102 14 but but CC 31504 102 15 society society NN 31504 102 16 is be VBZ 31504 102 17 more more RBR 31504 102 18 complex complex JJ 31504 102 19 , , , 31504 102 20 with with IN 31504 102 21 more more RBR 31504 102 22 diverse diverse JJ 31504 102 23 and and CC 31504 102 24 conflicting conflicting JJ 31504 102 25 interests interest NNS 31504 102 26 , , , 31504 102 27 than than IN 31504 102 28 formerly formerly RB 31504 102 29 . . . 31504 103 1 The the DT 31504 103 2 social social JJ 31504 103 3 mechanism mechanism NN 31504 103 4 is be VBZ 31504 103 5 now now RB 31504 103 6 so so RB 31504 103 7 intricate intricate JJ 31504 103 8 that that IN 31504 103 9 even even RB 31504 103 10 a a DT 31504 103 11 slight slight JJ 31504 103 12 disturbance disturbance NN 31504 103 13 in in IN 31504 103 14 one one CD 31504 103 15 part part NN 31504 103 16 may may MD 31504 103 17 disarrange disarrange VB 31504 103 18 the the DT 31504 103 19 whole whole NN 31504 103 20 . . . 31504 104 1 Injustice Injustice NNP 31504 104 2 to to IN 31504 104 3 one one PRP 31504 104 4 may may MD 31504 104 5 injure injure VB 31504 104 6 the the DT 31504 104 7 many many JJ 31504 104 8 . . . 31504 105 1 Hence hence RB 31504 105 2 the the DT 31504 105 3 duty duty NN 31504 105 4 of of IN 31504 105 5 ascertaining ascertaining NN 31504 105 6 as as RB 31504 105 7 completely completely RB 31504 105 8 as as IN 31504 105 9 possible possible JJ 31504 105 10 the the DT 31504 105 11 real real JJ 31504 105 12 nature nature NN 31504 105 13 of of IN 31504 105 14 justice justice NN 31504 105 15 is be VBZ 31504 105 16 as as RB 31504 105 17 imperative imperative JJ 31504 105 18 today today NN 31504 105 19 as as IN 31504 105 20 ever ever RB 31504 105 21 . . . 31504 106 1 As as IN 31504 106 2 declared declare VBN 31504 106 3 by by IN 31504 106 4 Ulpian Ulpian NNP 31504 106 5 , , , 31504 106 6 this this DT 31504 106 7 duty duty NN 31504 106 8 is be VBZ 31504 106 9 especially especially RB 31504 106 10 incumbent incumbent JJ 31504 106 11 upon upon IN 31504 106 12 those those DT 31504 106 13 who who WP 31504 106 14 have have VBP 31504 106 15 to to TO 31504 106 16 do do VB 31504 106 17 with with IN 31504 106 18 the the DT 31504 106 19 framing framing NN 31504 106 20 or or CC 31504 106 21 administration administration NN 31504 106 22 of of IN 31504 106 23 the the DT 31504 106 24 laws law NNS 31504 106 25 , , , 31504 106 26 since since IN 31504 106 27 justice justice NN 31504 106 28 can can MD 31504 106 29 be be VB 31504 106 30 enforced enforce VBN 31504 106 31 only only RB 31504 106 32 by by IN 31504 106 33 law law NN 31504 106 34 . . . 31504 107 1 In in IN 31504 107 2 any any DT 31504 107 3 inquiry inquiry NN 31504 107 4 into into IN 31504 107 5 the the DT 31504 107 6 nature nature NN 31504 107 7 of of IN 31504 107 8 justice justice NN 31504 107 9 we -PRON- PRP 31504 107 10 get get VBP 31504 107 11 little little JJ 31504 107 12 help help NN 31504 107 13 from from IN 31504 107 14 the the DT 31504 107 15 wisdom wisdom NN 31504 107 16 of of IN 31504 107 17 the the DT 31504 107 18 ancients ancient NNS 31504 107 19 . . . 31504 108 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 108 2 wrestled wrestle VBD 31504 108 3 with with IN 31504 108 4 the the DT 31504 108 5 question question NN 31504 108 6 but but CC 31504 108 7 seem seem VBP 31504 108 8 to to TO 31504 108 9 have have VB 31504 108 10 been be VBN 31504 108 11 as as RB 31504 108 12 puzzled puzzle VBN 31504 108 13 as as IN 31504 108 14 we -PRON- PRP 31504 108 15 of of IN 31504 108 16 today today NN 31504 108 17 . . . 31504 109 1 Indeed indeed RB 31504 109 2 , , , 31504 109 3 Plato Plato NNP 31504 109 4 represents represent VBZ 31504 109 5 the the DT 31504 109 6 sage sage NN 31504 109 7 Socrates Socrates NNP 31504 109 8 as as IN 31504 109 9 frankly frankly RB 31504 109 10 confessing confess VBG 31504 109 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 109 12 inability inability NN 31504 109 13 to to TO 31504 109 14 answer answer VB 31504 109 15 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 31504 109 16 the the DT 31504 109 17 persistent persistent JJ 31504 109 18 question question NN 31504 109 19 " " `` 31504 109 20 What what WP 31504 109 21 is be VBZ 31504 109 22 justice justice NN 31504 109 23 ? ? . 31504 109 24 " " '' 31504 110 1 The the DT 31504 110 2 question question NN 31504 110 3 comes come VBZ 31504 110 4 up up RP 31504 110 5 for for IN 31504 110 6 discussion discussion NN 31504 110 7 by by IN 31504 110 8 Socrates Socrates NNP 31504 110 9 and and CC 31504 110 10 some some DT 31504 110 11 friends friend NNS 31504 110 12 at at IN 31504 110 13 the the DT 31504 110 14 home home NN 31504 110 15 of of IN 31504 110 16 Cephalus Cephalus NNP 31504 110 17 at at IN 31504 110 18 the the DT 31504 110 19 Piræus Piræus NNP 31504 110 20 . . . 31504 111 1 Socrates socrate NNS 31504 111 2 criticizes criticize NNS 31504 111 3 and and CC 31504 111 4 punctures puncture VBZ 31504 111 5 the the DT 31504 111 6 definitions definition NNS 31504 111 7 advanced advance VBN 31504 111 8 by by IN 31504 111 9 the the DT 31504 111 10 others other NNS 31504 111 11 until until IN 31504 111 12 Thrasymachus Thrasymachus NNP 31504 111 13 , , , 31504 111 14 apparently apparently RB 31504 111 15 with with IN 31504 111 16 some some DT 31504 111 17 heat heat NN 31504 111 18 , , , 31504 111 19 challenges challenge VBZ 31504 111 20 Socrates Socrates NNPS 31504 111 21 to to TO 31504 111 22 give give VB 31504 111 23 an an DT 31504 111 24 answer answer NN 31504 111 25 of of IN 31504 111 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 111 27 own own JJ 31504 111 28 to to IN 31504 111 29 the the DT 31504 111 30 question question NN 31504 111 31 " " `` 31504 111 32 what what WP 31504 111 33 is be VBZ 31504 111 34 justice justice NN 31504 111 35 ? ? . 31504 111 36 " " '' 31504 112 1 and and CC 31504 112 2 not not RB 31504 112 3 to to TO 31504 112 4 content content VB 31504 112 5 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 112 6 , , , 31504 112 7 nor nor CC 31504 112 8 to to TO 31504 112 9 consume consume VB 31504 112 10 time time NN 31504 112 11 , , , 31504 112 12 with with IN 31504 112 13 merely merely RB 31504 112 14 refuting refute VBG 31504 112 15 others other NNS 31504 112 16 . . . 31504 113 1 After after IN 31504 113 2 some some DT 31504 113 3 further further JJ 31504 113 4 discussion discussion NN 31504 113 5 of of IN 31504 113 6 various various JJ 31504 113 7 aspects aspect NNS 31504 113 8 of of IN 31504 113 9 the the DT 31504 113 10 question question NN 31504 113 11 , , , 31504 113 12 Socrates Socrates NNP 31504 113 13 finally finally RB 31504 113 14 says say VBZ 31504 113 15 , , , 31504 113 16 " " `` 31504 113 17 I -PRON- PRP 31504 113 18 have have VBP 31504 113 19 gone go VBN 31504 113 20 from from IN 31504 113 21 one one CD 31504 113 22 subject subject NN 31504 113 23 to to IN 31504 113 24 another another DT 31504 113 25 without without IN 31504 113 26 having have VBG 31504 113 27 discovered discover VBN 31504 113 28 what what WP 31504 113 29 I -PRON- PRP 31504 113 30 sought seek VBD 31504 113 31 at at IN 31504 113 32 first first RB 31504 113 33 , , , 31504 113 34 the the DT 31504 113 35 nature nature NN 31504 113 36 of of IN 31504 113 37 justice justice NN 31504 113 38 . . . 31504 114 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 114 2 left leave VBD 31504 114 3 the the DT 31504 114 4 inquiry inquiry NN 31504 114 5 and and CC 31504 114 6 turned turn VBD 31504 114 7 away away RB 31504 114 8 to to TO 31504 114 9 consider consider VB 31504 114 10 whether whether IN 31504 114 11 justice justice NN 31504 114 12 is be VBZ 31504 114 13 virtue virtue NN 31504 114 14 and and CC 31504 114 15 wisdom wisdom NN 31504 114 16 , , , 31504 114 17 or or CC 31504 114 18 evil evil NN 31504 114 19 and and CC 31504 114 20 folly folly NN 31504 114 21 , , , 31504 114 22 and and CC 31504 114 23 when when WRB 31504 114 24 there there EX 31504 114 25 arose arise VBD 31504 114 26 a a DT 31504 114 27 further further JJ 31504 114 28 question question NN 31504 114 29 about about IN 31504 114 30 the the DT 31504 114 31 comparative comparative JJ 31504 114 32 advantages advantage NNS 31504 114 33 of of IN 31504 114 34 justice justice NN 31504 114 35 and and CC 31504 114 36 injustice injustice NN 31504 114 37 I -PRON- PRP 31504 114 38 could could MD 31504 114 39 not not RB 31504 114 40 refrain refrain VB 31504 114 41 from from IN 31504 114 42 passing pass VBG 31504 114 43 on on RP 31504 114 44 to to IN 31504 114 45 that that DT 31504 114 46 . . . 31504 115 1 The the DT 31504 115 2 result result NN 31504 115 3 of of IN 31504 115 4 the the DT 31504 115 5 whole whole JJ 31504 115 6 discussion discussion NN 31504 115 7 has have VBZ 31504 115 8 been be VBN 31504 115 9 that that IN 31504 115 10 I -PRON- PRP 31504 115 11 know know VBP 31504 115 12 nothing nothing NN 31504 115 13 at at RB 31504 115 14 all all RB 31504 115 15 . . . 31504 116 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 116 2 know know VBP 31504 116 3 not not RB 31504 116 4 what what WP 31504 116 5 justice justice NN 31504 116 6 is be VBZ 31504 116 7 and and CC 31504 116 8 therefore therefore RB 31504 116 9 am be VBP 31504 116 10 not not RB 31504 116 11 likely likely JJ 31504 116 12 to to TO 31504 116 13 know know VB 31504 116 14 whether whether IN 31504 116 15 or or CC 31504 116 16 not not RB 31504 116 17 it -PRON- PRP 31504 116 18 is be VBZ 31504 116 19 a a DT 31504 116 20 virtue virtue NN 31504 116 21 , , , 31504 116 22 nor nor CC 31504 116 23 can can MD 31504 116 24 I -PRON- PRP 31504 116 25 say say VB 31504 116 26 whether whether IN 31504 116 27 the the DT 31504 116 28 just just JJ 31504 116 29 man man NN 31504 116 30 is be VBZ 31504 116 31 happy happy JJ 31504 116 32 or or CC 31504 116 33 unhappy unhappy JJ 31504 116 34 . . . 31504 116 35 " " '' 31504 117 1 Granting grant VBG 31504 117 2 that that IN 31504 117 3 the the DT 31504 117 4 confession confession NN 31504 117 5 may may MD 31504 117 6 have have VB 31504 117 7 been be VBN 31504 117 8 intended intend VBN 31504 117 9 ironically ironically RB 31504 117 10 , , , 31504 117 11 the the DT 31504 117 12 further further JJ 31504 117 13 discussion discussion NN 31504 117 14 did do VBD 31504 117 15 not not RB 31504 117 16 result result VB 31504 117 17 in in IN 31504 117 18 any any DT 31504 117 19 practical practical JJ 31504 117 20 solution solution NN 31504 117 21 , , , 31504 117 22 even even RB 31504 117 23 if if IN 31504 117 24 in in IN 31504 117 25 one one CD 31504 117 26 possible possible JJ 31504 117 27 in in IN 31504 117 28 Plato Plato NNP 31504 117 29 's 's POS 31504 117 30 ideal ideal NN 31504 117 31 , , , 31504 117 32 but but CC 31504 117 33 impossible impossible JJ 31504 117 34 , , , 31504 117 35 state state NN 31504 117 36 . . . 31504 118 1 Indeed indeed RB 31504 118 2 , , , 31504 118 3 the the DT 31504 118 4 inquiry inquiry NN 31504 118 5 is be VBZ 31504 118 6 not not RB 31504 118 7 yet yet RB 31504 118 8 closed closed JJ 31504 118 9 and and CC 31504 118 10 will will MD 31504 118 11 not not RB 31504 118 12 be be VB 31504 118 13 until until IN 31504 118 14 the the DT 31504 118 15 millennium millennium NN 31504 118 16 . . . 31504 119 1 Still still RB 31504 119 2 , , , 31504 119 3 upon upon IN 31504 119 4 a a DT 31504 119 5 question question NN 31504 119 6 so so RB 31504 119 7 old old JJ 31504 119 8 , , , 31504 119 9 so so RB 31504 119 10 important important JJ 31504 119 11 , , , 31504 119 12 so so RB 31504 119 13 persistent persistent JJ 31504 119 14 , , , 31504 119 15 so so RB 31504 119 16 ingrained ingrained JJ 31504 119 17 in in IN 31504 119 18 human human JJ 31504 119 19 society society NN 31504 119 20 , , , 31504 119 21 and and CC 31504 119 22 even even RB 31504 119 23 now now RB 31504 119 24 receiving receive VBG 31504 119 25 such such JJ 31504 119 26 diverse diverse JJ 31504 119 27 and and CC 31504 119 28 conflicting conflicting JJ 31504 119 29 answers answer NNS 31504 119 30 , , , 31504 119 31 a a DT 31504 119 32 brief brief JJ 31504 119 33 consideration consideration NN 31504 119 34 of of IN 31504 119 35 the the DT 31504 119 36 earlier early JJR 31504 119 37 beliefs belief NNS 31504 119 38 and and CC 31504 119 39 theories theory NNS 31504 119 40 may may MD 31504 119 41 not not RB 31504 119 42 be be VB 31504 119 43 useless useless JJ 31504 119 44 . . . 31504 120 1 As as IN 31504 120 2 said say VBN 31504 120 3 by by IN 31504 120 4 Bishop Bishop NNP 31504 120 5 Stubbs Stubbs NNP 31504 120 6 , , , 31504 120 7 the the DT 31504 120 8 historian historian NN 31504 120 9 , , , 31504 120 10 " " `` 31504 120 11 The the DT 31504 120 12 roots root NNS 31504 120 13 of of IN 31504 120 14 the the DT 31504 120 15 present present JJ 31504 120 16 lie lie NN 31504 120 17 deep deep RB 31504 120 18 in in IN 31504 120 19 the the DT 31504 120 20 past past NN 31504 120 21 and and CC 31504 120 22 nothing nothing NN 31504 120 23 in in IN 31504 120 24 the the DT 31504 120 25 past past NN 31504 120 26 is be VBZ 31504 120 27 dead dead JJ 31504 120 28 to to IN 31504 120 29 him -PRON- PRP 31504 120 30 who who WP 31504 120 31 would would MD 31504 120 32 learn learn VB 31504 120 33 how how WRB 31504 120 34 the the DT 31504 120 35 present present NN 31504 120 36 came come VBD 31504 120 37 to to TO 31504 120 38 be be VB 31504 120 39 what what WP 31504 120 40 it -PRON- PRP 31504 120 41 is be VBZ 31504 120 42 . . . 31504 120 43 " " '' 31504 121 1 The the DT 31504 121 2 roots root NNS 31504 121 3 should should MD 31504 121 4 be be VB 31504 121 5 examined examine VBN 31504 121 6 by by IN 31504 121 7 him -PRON- PRP 31504 121 8 who who WP 31504 121 9 would would MD 31504 121 10 understand understand VB 31504 121 11 the the DT 31504 121 12 tree tree NN 31504 121 13 . . . 31504 122 1 In in IN 31504 122 2 Homer Homer NNP 31504 122 3 we -PRON- PRP 31504 122 4 get get VBP 31504 122 5 a a DT 31504 122 6 glimpse glimpse NN 31504 122 7 of of IN 31504 122 8 a a DT 31504 122 9 theory theory NN 31504 122 10 of of IN 31504 122 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 122 12 time time NN 31504 122 13 , , , 31504 122 14 to to IN 31504 122 15 wit wit NN 31504 122 16 , , , 31504 122 17 that that IN 31504 122 18 each each DT 31504 122 19 separate separate JJ 31504 122 20 decision decision NN 31504 122 21 given give VBN 31504 122 22 by by IN 31504 122 23 the the DT 31504 122 24 magistrate magistrate NN 31504 122 25 in in IN 31504 122 26 any any DT 31504 122 27 litigated litigated JJ 31504 122 28 controversy controversy NN 31504 122 29 was be VBD 31504 122 30 furnished furnish VBN 31504 122 31 to to IN 31504 122 32 him -PRON- PRP 31504 122 33 by by IN 31504 122 34 Zeus Zeus NNP 31504 122 35 specially specially RB 31504 122 36 for for IN 31504 122 37 that that DT 31504 122 38 case case NN 31504 122 39 . . . 31504 123 1 The the DT 31504 123 2 Greek greek JJ 31504 123 3 word word NN 31504 123 4 for for IN 31504 123 5 such such PDT 31504 123 6 a a DT 31504 123 7 decision decision NN 31504 123 8 was be VBD 31504 123 9 _ _ NNP 31504 123 10 themis themis NNP 31504 123 11 _ _ NNP 31504 123 12 , , , 31504 123 13 and and CC 31504 123 14 it -PRON- PRP 31504 123 15 was be VBD 31504 123 16 supposed suppose VBN 31504 123 17 that that IN 31504 123 18 somewhere somewhere RB 31504 123 19 in in IN 31504 123 20 the the DT 31504 123 21 Pantheon Pantheon NNP 31504 123 22 was be VBD 31504 123 23 a a DT 31504 123 24 corresponding corresponding JJ 31504 123 25 deity deity NN 31504 123 26 whose whose WP$ 31504 123 27 special special JJ 31504 123 28 function function NN 31504 123 29 was be VBD 31504 123 30 to to TO 31504 123 31 furnish furnish VB 31504 123 32 the the DT 31504 123 33 appropriate appropriate JJ 31504 123 34 themis themis NN 31504 123 35 for for IN 31504 123 36 each each DT 31504 123 37 case case NN 31504 123 38 . . . 31504 124 1 This this DT 31504 124 2 deity deity NN 31504 124 3 was be VBD 31504 124 4 shadowily shadowily RB 31504 124 5 personified personify VBN 31504 124 6 as as IN 31504 124 7 the the DT 31504 124 8 goddess goddess NN 31504 124 9 Themis Themis NNP 31504 124 10 , , , 31504 124 11 the the DT 31504 124 12 daughter daughter NN 31504 124 13 of of IN 31504 124 14 heaven heaven NNP 31504 124 15 and and CC 31504 124 16 earth earth NN 31504 124 17 , , , 31504 124 18 the the DT 31504 124 19 companion companion NN 31504 124 20 and and CC 31504 124 21 counselor counselor NN 31504 124 22 of of IN 31504 124 23 Zeus Zeus NNP 31504 124 24 . . . 31504 125 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 125 2 was be VBD 31504 125 3 she -PRON- PRP 31504 125 4 who who WP 31504 125 5 summoned summon VBD 31504 125 6 gods god NNS 31504 125 7 and and CC 31504 125 8 men man NNS 31504 125 9 to to IN 31504 125 10 council council NN 31504 125 11 and and CC 31504 125 12 presided preside VBD 31504 125 13 unseen unseen JJ 31504 125 14 over over IN 31504 125 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 125 16 deliberations deliberation NNS 31504 125 17 . . . 31504 126 1 Hence hence RB 31504 126 2 she -PRON- PRP 31504 126 3 came come VBD 31504 126 4 to to TO 31504 126 5 be be VB 31504 126 6 regarded regard VBN 31504 126 7 as as IN 31504 126 8 also also RB 31504 126 9 the the DT 31504 126 10 spirit spirit NN 31504 126 11 of of IN 31504 126 12 order order NN 31504 126 13 without without IN 31504 126 14 which which WDT 31504 126 15 the the DT 31504 126 16 Greek greek JJ 31504 126 17 philosophers philosopher NNS 31504 126 18 , , , 31504 126 19 notably notably RB 31504 126 20 Plato Plato NNP 31504 126 21 , , , 31504 126 22 held hold VBN 31504 126 23 there there EX 31504 126 24 could could MD 31504 126 25 be be VB 31504 126 26 no no DT 31504 126 27 justice justice NN 31504 126 28 . . . 31504 127 1 This this DT 31504 127 2 theory theory NN 31504 127 3 that that IN 31504 127 4 justice justice NN 31504 127 5 and and CC 31504 127 6 even even RB 31504 127 7 the the DT 31504 127 8 laws law NNS 31504 127 9 were be VBD 31504 127 10 but but CC 31504 127 11 the the DT 31504 127 12 will will NN 31504 127 13 of of IN 31504 127 14 deity deity NN 31504 127 15 , , , 31504 127 16 revealed reveal VBN 31504 127 17 in in IN 31504 127 18 various various JJ 31504 127 19 ways way NNS 31504 127 20 , , , 31504 127 21 was be VBD 31504 127 22 long long RB 31504 127 23 generally generally RB 31504 127 24 accepted accept VBN 31504 127 25 . . . 31504 128 1 In in IN 31504 128 2 Rome Rome NNP 31504 128 3 , , , 31504 128 4 in in IN 31504 128 5 the the DT 31504 128 6 time time NN 31504 128 7 of of IN 31504 128 8 the the DT 31504 128 9 kings king NNS 31504 128 10 , , , 31504 128 11 the the DT 31504 128 12 king king NN 31504 128 13 was be VBD 31504 128 14 the the DT 31504 128 15 Pontifex Pontifex NNP 31504 128 16 Maximus Maximus NNP 31504 128 17 , , , 31504 128 18 and and CC 31504 128 19 as as IN 31504 128 20 such such JJ 31504 128 21 , , , 31504 128 22 with with IN 31504 128 23 the the DT 31504 128 24 help help NN 31504 128 25 of of IN 31504 128 26 the the DT 31504 128 27 College College NNP 31504 128 28 of of IN 31504 128 29 Priests Priests NNP 31504 128 30 , , , 31504 128 31 declared declare VBD 31504 128 32 the the DT 31504 128 33 laws law NNS 31504 128 34 and and CC 31504 128 35 decided decide VBN 31504 128 36 lawsuits lawsuit NNS 31504 128 37 . . . 31504 129 1 For for IN 31504 129 2 some some DT 31504 129 3 time time NN 31504 129 4 also also RB 31504 129 5 under under IN 31504 129 6 the the DT 31504 129 7 Republic Republic NNP 31504 129 8 , , , 31504 129 9 when when WRB 31504 129 10 a a DT 31504 129 11 vote vote NN 31504 129 12 was be VBD 31504 129 13 to to TO 31504 129 14 be be VB 31504 129 15 taken take VBN 31504 129 16 in in IN 31504 129 17 the the DT 31504 129 18 Comitia Comitia NNP 31504 129 19 upon upon IN 31504 129 20 a a DT 31504 129 21 proposed propose VBN 31504 129 22 law law NN 31504 129 23 , , , 31504 129 24 the the DT 31504 129 25 question question NN 31504 129 26 was be VBD 31504 129 27 thus thus RB 31504 129 28 put put VBN 31504 129 29 : : : 31504 129 30 " " `` 31504 129 31 Is be VBZ 31504 129 32 this this DT 31504 129 33 your -PRON- PRP$ 31504 129 34 pleasure pleasure NN 31504 129 35 , , , 31504 129 36 O o UH 31504 129 37 Quirites Quirites NNPS 31504 129 38 , , , 31504 129 39 and and CC 31504 129 40 do do VBP 31504 129 41 you -PRON- PRP 31504 129 42 hold hold VB 31504 129 43 it -PRON- PRP 31504 129 44 to to TO 31504 129 45 be be VB 31504 129 46 the the DT 31504 129 47 will will NN 31504 129 48 of of IN 31504 129 49 the the DT 31504 129 50 gods god NNS 31504 129 51 ? ? . 31504 129 52 " " '' 31504 130 1 Under under IN 31504 130 2 the the DT 31504 130 3 Empire empire NN 31504 130 4 , , , 31504 130 5 despite despite IN 31504 130 6 the the DT 31504 130 7 reasoning reasoning NN 31504 130 8 of of IN 31504 130 9 many many JJ 31504 130 10 philosophers philosopher NNS 31504 130 11 and and CC 31504 130 12 lawyers lawyer NNS 31504 130 13 that that IN 31504 130 14 the the DT 31504 130 15 Emperor Emperor NNP 31504 130 16 derived derive VBD 31504 130 17 from from IN 31504 130 18 the the DT 31504 130 19 people people NNS 31504 130 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 130 21 power power NN 31504 130 22 to to TO 31504 130 23 make make VB 31504 130 24 laws law NNS 31504 130 25 and and CC 31504 130 26 declare declare VB 31504 130 27 the the DT 31504 130 28 law law NN 31504 130 29 in in IN 31504 130 30 any any DT 31504 130 31 given give VBN 31504 130 32 case case NN 31504 130 33 , , , 31504 130 34 he -PRON- PRP 31504 130 35 assumed assume VBD 31504 130 36 and and CC 31504 130 37 was be VBD 31504 130 38 assumed assume VBN 31504 130 39 to to TO 31504 130 40 have have VB 31504 130 41 derived derive VBN 31504 130 42 the the DT 31504 130 43 power power NN 31504 130 44 and and CC 31504 130 45 inspiration inspiration NN 31504 130 46 solely solely RB 31504 130 47 from from IN 31504 130 48 the the DT 31504 130 49 gods god NNS 31504 130 50 . . . 31504 131 1 The the DT 31504 131 2 early early JJ 31504 131 3 Christian Christian NNP 31504 131 4 Church Church NNP 31504 131 5 also also RB 31504 131 6 preached preach VBD 31504 131 7 the the DT 31504 131 8 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 131 9 that that IN 31504 131 10 the the DT 31504 131 11 ruling rule VBG 31504 131 12 power power NN 31504 131 13 in in IN 31504 131 14 the the DT 31504 131 15 state state NN 31504 131 16 , , , 31504 131 17 however however RB 31504 131 18 established establish VBN 31504 131 19 , , , 31504 131 20 was be VBD 31504 131 21 ordained ordain VBN 31504 131 22 of of IN 31504 131 23 God God NNP 31504 131 24 and and CC 31504 131 25 as as IN 31504 131 26 such such JJ 31504 131 27 was be VBD 31504 131 28 entitled entitle VBN 31504 131 29 to to IN 31504 131 30 the the DT 31504 131 31 obedience obedience NN 31504 131 32 of of IN 31504 131 33 the the DT 31504 131 34 pious pious JJ 31504 131 35 . . . 31504 132 1 This this DT 31504 132 2 belief belief NN 31504 132 3 that that IN 31504 132 4 justice justice NN 31504 132 5 and and CC 31504 132 6 judgment judgment NN 31504 132 7 were be VBD 31504 132 8 simply simply RB 31504 132 9 the the DT 31504 132 10 will will NN 31504 132 11 of of IN 31504 132 12 God God NNP 31504 132 13 , , , 31504 132 14 to to TO 31504 132 15 be be VB 31504 132 16 ascertained ascertain VBN 31504 132 17 , , , 31504 132 18 not not RB 31504 132 19 by by IN 31504 132 20 reason reason NN 31504 132 21 but but CC 31504 132 22 by by IN 31504 132 23 other other JJ 31504 132 24 means mean NNS 31504 132 25 , , , 31504 132 26 was be VBD 31504 132 27 so so RB 31504 132 28 general general JJ 31504 132 29 and and CC 31504 132 30 deep deep JJ 31504 132 31 that that IN 31504 132 32 such such JJ 31504 132 33 crude crude JJ 31504 132 34 devices device NNS 31504 132 35 as as IN 31504 132 36 trials trial NNS 31504 132 37 by by IN 31504 132 38 ordeal ordeal NN 31504 132 39 and and CC 31504 132 40 battle battle NN 31504 132 41 were be VBD 31504 132 42 often often RB 31504 132 43 resorted resort VBN 31504 132 44 to to IN 31504 132 45 for for IN 31504 132 46 determining determine VBG 31504 132 47 guilt guilt NN 31504 132 48 or or CC 31504 132 49 innocence innocence NN 31504 132 50 and and CC 31504 132 51 other other JJ 31504 132 52 questions question NNS 31504 132 53 of of IN 31504 132 54 fact fact NN 31504 132 55 . . . 31504 133 1 Indeed indeed RB 31504 133 2 , , , 31504 133 3 resort resort VB 31504 133 4 to to IN 31504 133 5 such such JJ 31504 133 6 expedients expedient NNS 31504 133 7 for for IN 31504 133 8 determining determine VBG 31504 133 9 questions question NNS 31504 133 10 of of IN 31504 133 11 law law NN 31504 133 12 , , , 31504 133 13 as as RB 31504 133 14 well well RB 31504 133 15 as as IN 31504 133 16 questions question NNS 31504 133 17 of of IN 31504 133 18 fact fact NN 31504 133 19 , , , 31504 133 20 was be VBD 31504 133 21 not not RB 31504 133 22 unknown unknown JJ 31504 133 23 . . . 31504 134 1 In in IN 31504 134 2 the the DT 31504 134 3 tenth tenth JJ 31504 134 4 century century NN 31504 134 5 under under IN 31504 134 6 the the DT 31504 134 7 Saxon Saxon NNP 31504 134 8 King King NNP 31504 134 9 Otto Otto NNP 31504 134 10 a a DT 31504 134 11 question question NN 31504 134 12 arose arise VBD 31504 134 13 whether whether IN 31504 134 14 upon upon IN 31504 134 15 the the DT 31504 134 16 death death NN 31504 134 17 of of IN 31504 134 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 134 19 grandfather grandfather NN 31504 134 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 134 21 grandchildren grandchild NNS 31504 134 22 by by IN 31504 134 23 a a DT 31504 134 24 prior prior JJ 31504 134 25 deceased deceased JJ 31504 134 26 son son NN 31504 134 27 should should MD 31504 134 28 share share VB 31504 134 29 in in IN 31504 134 30 the the DT 31504 134 31 inheritance inheritance NN 31504 134 32 along along IN 31504 134 33 with with IN 31504 134 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 134 35 surviving survive VBG 31504 134 36 uncles uncle NNS 31504 134 37 . . . 31504 135 1 The the DT 31504 135 2 king king NN 31504 135 3 ordered order VBD 31504 135 4 a a DT 31504 135 5 trial trial NN 31504 135 6 by by IN 31504 135 7 battle battle NN 31504 135 8 , , , 31504 135 9 which which WDT 31504 135 10 being be VBG 31504 135 11 had have VBN 31504 135 12 , , , 31504 135 13 the the DT 31504 135 14 champions champion NNS 31504 135 15 for for IN 31504 135 16 the the DT 31504 135 17 grandchildren grandchild NNS 31504 135 18 were be VBD 31504 135 19 the the DT 31504 135 20 victors victor NNS 31504 135 21 . . . 31504 136 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 136 2 was be VBD 31504 136 3 therefore therefore RB 31504 136 4 held hold VBN 31504 136 5 to to TO 31504 136 6 be be VB 31504 136 7 the the DT 31504 136 8 divine divine JJ 31504 136 9 will will NN 31504 136 10 that that IN 31504 136 11 grandchildren grandchild NNS 31504 136 12 by by IN 31504 136 13 a a DT 31504 136 14 prior prior JJ 31504 136 15 deceased deceased JJ 31504 136 16 child child NN 31504 136 17 should should MD 31504 136 18 inherit inherit VB 31504 136 19 direct direct RB 31504 136 20 from from IN 31504 136 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 136 22 grandfather grandfather NN 31504 136 23 . . . 31504 137 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 137 2 may may MD 31504 137 3 here here RB 31504 137 4 remind remind VB 31504 137 5 you -PRON- PRP 31504 137 6 that that IN 31504 137 7 trial trial NN 31504 137 8 by by IN 31504 137 9 battle battle NN 31504 137 10 was be VBD 31504 137 11 not not RB 31504 137 12 formally formally RB 31504 137 13 abolished abolish VBN 31504 137 14 in in IN 31504 137 15 England England NNP 31504 137 16 until until IN 31504 137 17 well well RB 31504 137 18 into into IN 31504 137 19 the the DT 31504 137 20 19th 19th JJ 31504 137 21 century century NN 31504 137 22 . . . 31504 138 1 And and CC 31504 138 2 there there EX 31504 138 3 is be VBZ 31504 138 4 even even RB 31504 138 5 now now RB 31504 138 6 professed profess VBN 31504 138 7 a a DT 31504 138 8 belief belief NN 31504 138 9 that that IN 31504 138 10 the the DT 31504 138 11 will will NN 31504 138 12 of of IN 31504 138 13 God God NNP 31504 138 14 can can MD 31504 138 15 be be VB 31504 138 16 ascertained ascertain VBN 31504 138 17 by by IN 31504 138 18 counting count VBG 31504 138 19 ballots ballot NNS 31504 138 20 . . . 31504 139 1 " " `` 31504 139 2 Vox Vox NNP 31504 139 3 Populi Populi NNP 31504 139 4 Vox Vox NNP 31504 139 5 Dei Dei NNP 31504 139 6 " " '' 31504 139 7 is be VBZ 31504 139 8 still still RB 31504 139 9 a a DT 31504 139 10 shibboleth shibboleth NN 31504 139 11 . . . 31504 140 1 But but CC 31504 140 2 the the DT 31504 140 3 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 140 4 that that IN 31504 140 5 justice justice NN 31504 140 6 is be VBZ 31504 140 7 heaven heaven NNP 31504 140 8 born bear VBN 31504 140 9 , , , 31504 140 10 superior superior JJ 31504 140 11 to to IN 31504 140 12 and and CC 31504 140 13 controlling control VBG 31504 140 14 the the DT 31504 140 15 opinions opinion NNS 31504 140 16 and and CC 31504 140 17 wills will NNS 31504 140 18 of of IN 31504 140 19 men man NNS 31504 140 20 , , , 31504 140 21 did do VBD 31504 140 22 not not RB 31504 140 23 escape escape VB 31504 140 24 challenge challenge NN 31504 140 25 even even RB 31504 140 26 in in IN 31504 140 27 ancient ancient JJ 31504 140 28 times time NNS 31504 140 29 . . . 31504 141 1 Those those DT 31504 141 2 sects sect NNS 31504 141 3 of of IN 31504 141 4 philosophers philosopher NNS 31504 141 5 known know VBN 31504 141 6 as as IN 31504 141 7 Epicureans Epicureans NNPS 31504 141 8 and and CC 31504 141 9 Sophists Sophists NNPS 31504 141 10 , , , 31504 141 11 consistently consistently RB 31504 141 12 with with IN 31504 141 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 141 14 theory theory NN 31504 141 15 of of IN 31504 141 16 the the DT 31504 141 17 nature nature NN 31504 141 18 of of IN 31504 141 19 virtue virtue NN 31504 141 20 in in IN 31504 141 21 general general JJ 31504 141 22 , , , 31504 141 23 maintained maintain VBD 31504 141 24 that that IN 31504 141 25 justice justice NN 31504 141 26 was be VBD 31504 141 27 merely merely RB 31504 141 28 a a DT 31504 141 29 name name NN 31504 141 30 for for IN 31504 141 31 such such JJ 31504 141 32 conventions convention NNS 31504 141 33 among among IN 31504 141 34 men man NNS 31504 141 35 as as IN 31504 141 36 they -PRON- PRP 31504 141 37 should should MD 31504 141 38 adjudge adjudge VB 31504 141 39 best well RBS 31504 141 40 for for IN 31504 141 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 141 42 own own JJ 31504 141 43 utility utility NN 31504 141 44 and and CC 31504 141 45 happiness happiness NN 31504 141 46 . . . 31504 142 1 The the DT 31504 142 2 most most RBS 31504 142 3 vigorous vigorous JJ 31504 142 4 champion champion NN 31504 142 5 of of IN 31504 142 6 this this DT 31504 142 7 latter latter JJ 31504 142 8 theory theory NN 31504 142 9 appears appear VBZ 31504 142 10 to to TO 31504 142 11 have have VB 31504 142 12 been be VBN 31504 142 13 one one CD 31504 142 14 Carneades Carneades NNPS 31504 142 15 , , , 31504 142 16 a a DT 31504 142 17 Greek greek JJ 31504 142 18 philosopher philosopher NN 31504 142 19 of of IN 31504 142 20 the the DT 31504 142 21 second second JJ 31504 142 22 century century NN 31504 142 23 B.C. B.C. NNP 31504 142 24 , , , 31504 142 25 said say VBD 31504 142 26 to to TO 31504 142 27 have have VB 31504 142 28 been be VBN 31504 142 29 the the DT 31504 142 30 founder founder NN 31504 142 31 of of IN 31504 142 32 the the DT 31504 142 33 third third JJ 31504 142 34 Academy Academy NNP 31504 142 35 and and CC 31504 142 36 expounder expounder DT 31504 142 37 of of IN 31504 142 38 the the DT 31504 142 39 philosophy philosophy NN 31504 142 40 of of IN 31504 142 41 probabilities probability NNS 31504 142 42 and and CC 31504 142 43 to to TO 31504 142 44 have have VB 31504 142 45 possessed possess VBN 31504 142 46 the the DT 31504 142 47 acutest acute JJS 31504 142 48 mind mind NN 31504 142 49 of of IN 31504 142 50 antiquity antiquity NN 31504 142 51 . . . 31504 143 1 In in IN 31504 143 2 a a DT 31504 143 3 course course NN 31504 143 4 of of IN 31504 143 5 lectures lecture NNS 31504 143 6 at at IN 31504 143 7 Rome Rome NNP 31504 143 8 he -PRON- PRP 31504 143 9 stated state VBD 31504 143 10 the the DT 31504 143 11 arguments argument NNS 31504 143 12 for for IN 31504 143 13 the the DT 31504 143 14 orthodox orthodox JJ 31504 143 15 view view NN 31504 143 16 of of IN 31504 143 17 justice justice NN 31504 143 18 and and CC 31504 143 19 then then RB 31504 143 20 boldly boldly RB 31504 143 21 assumed assume VBD 31504 143 22 to to TO 31504 143 23 answer answer VB 31504 143 24 them -PRON- PRP 31504 143 25 and and CC 31504 143 26 demonstrate demonstrate VBP 31504 143 27 that that IN 31504 143 28 justice justice NN 31504 143 29 was be VBD 31504 143 30 not not RB 31504 143 31 a a DT 31504 143 32 virtue virtue NN 31504 143 33 at at RB 31504 143 34 all all RB 31504 143 35 as as IN 31504 143 36 virtue virtue NN 31504 143 37 was be VBD 31504 143 38 defined define VBN 31504 143 39 by by IN 31504 143 40 the the DT 31504 143 41 philosophers philosopher NNS 31504 143 42 , , , 31504 143 43 but but CC 31504 143 44 was be VBD 31504 143 45 merely merely RB 31504 143 46 a a DT 31504 143 47 convention convention NN 31504 143 48 ; ; : 31504 143 49 was be VBD 31504 143 50 what what WP 31504 143 51 men man NNS 31504 143 52 should should MD 31504 143 53 agree agree VB 31504 143 54 to to TO 31504 143 55 be be VB 31504 143 56 a a DT 31504 143 57 sound sound JJ 31504 143 58 basis basis NN 31504 143 59 for for IN 31504 143 60 the the DT 31504 143 61 maintenance maintenance NN 31504 143 62 of of IN 31504 143 63 civil civil JJ 31504 143 64 society society NN 31504 143 65 , , , 31504 143 66 and and CC 31504 143 67 hence hence RB 31504 143 68 that that IN 31504 143 69 it -PRON- PRP 31504 143 70 varied vary VBD 31504 143 71 with with IN 31504 143 72 times time NNS 31504 143 73 , , , 31504 143 74 places place NNS 31504 143 75 , , , 31504 143 76 circumstances circumstance NNS 31504 143 77 , , , 31504 143 78 and and CC 31504 143 79 even even RB 31504 143 80 opinions opinion NNS 31504 143 81 . . . 31504 144 1 This this DT 31504 144 2 argument argument NN 31504 144 3 evidently evidently RB 31504 144 4 had have VBD 31504 144 5 much much JJ 31504 144 6 effect effect NN 31504 144 7 upon upon IN 31504 144 8 public public JJ 31504 144 9 opinion opinion NN 31504 144 10 , , , 31504 144 11 for for IN 31504 144 12 Cato Cato NNP 31504 144 13 urged urge VBD 31504 144 14 in in IN 31504 144 15 the the DT 31504 144 16 Senate Senate NNP 31504 144 17 that that WDT 31504 144 18 Carneades Carneades NNP 31504 144 19 be be VB 31504 144 20 banished banish VBN 31504 144 21 because because IN 31504 144 22 dangerous dangerous JJ 31504 144 23 to to IN 31504 144 24 the the DT 31504 144 25 state state NN 31504 144 26 . . . 31504 145 1 So so RB 31504 145 2 great great JJ 31504 145 3 was be VBD 31504 145 4 the the DT 31504 145 5 influence influence NN 31504 145 6 of of IN 31504 145 7 Carneades Carneades NNPS 31504 145 8 that that IN 31504 145 9 a a DT 31504 145 10 century century NN 31504 145 11 later late JJR 31504 145 12 Cicero Cicero NNP 31504 145 13 , , , 31504 145 14 a a DT 31504 145 15 disciple disciple NN 31504 145 16 of of IN 31504 145 17 the the DT 31504 145 18 Stoic Stoic NNP 31504 145 19 school school NN 31504 145 20 of of IN 31504 145 21 philosophy philosophy NN 31504 145 22 , , , 31504 145 23 thought think VBD 31504 145 24 it -PRON- PRP 31504 145 25 necessary necessary JJ 31504 145 26 to to TO 31504 145 27 refute refute VB 31504 145 28 him -PRON- PRP 31504 145 29 specifically specifically RB 31504 145 30 as as IN 31504 145 31 the the DT 31504 145 32 chief chief JJ 31504 145 33 heretic heretic NN 31504 145 34 , , , 31504 145 35 and and CC 31504 145 36 to to TO 31504 145 37 uphold uphold VB 31504 145 38 the the DT 31504 145 39 orthodox orthodox JJ 31504 145 40 theory theory NN 31504 145 41 against against IN 31504 145 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 145 43 arguments argument NNS 31504 145 44 . . . 31504 146 1 Cicero Cicero NNP 31504 146 2 denounced denounce VBD 31504 146 3 with with IN 31504 146 4 eloquent eloquent JJ 31504 146 5 warmth warmth NN 31504 146 6 the the DT 31504 146 7 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 146 8 that that DT 31504 146 9 utility utility NN 31504 146 10 was be VBD 31504 146 11 the the DT 31504 146 12 foundation foundation NN 31504 146 13 of of IN 31504 146 14 justice justice NN 31504 146 15 . . . 31504 147 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 147 2 declared declare VBD 31504 147 3 that that IN 31504 147 4 , , , 31504 147 5 not not RB 31504 147 6 utility utility NN 31504 147 7 , , , 31504 147 8 but but CC 31504 147 9 nature nature NN 31504 147 10 , , , 31504 147 11 was be VBD 31504 147 12 the the DT 31504 147 13 source source NN 31504 147 14 of of IN 31504 147 15 justice justice NN 31504 147 16 , , , 31504 147 17 that that DT 31504 147 18 justice justice NN 31504 147 19 was be VBD 31504 147 20 a a DT 31504 147 21 principle principle NN 31504 147 22 of of IN 31504 147 23 nature nature NN 31504 147 24 , , , 31504 147 25 the the DT 31504 147 26 ultimate ultimate JJ 31504 147 27 principle principle NN 31504 147 28 behind behind IN 31504 147 29 all all DT 31504 147 30 law law NN 31504 147 31 . . . 31504 148 1 To to TO 31504 148 2 abridge abridge VB 31504 148 3 the the DT 31504 148 4 familiar familiar JJ 31504 148 5 quotation quotation NN 31504 148 6 from from IN 31504 148 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 148 8 " " `` 31504 148 9 De De NNP 31504 148 10 Republica Republica NNP 31504 148 11 , , , 31504 148 12 " " '' 31504 148 13 " " `` 31504 148 14 There there EX 31504 148 15 is be VBZ 31504 148 16 a a DT 31504 148 17 law law NN 31504 148 18 which which WDT 31504 148 19 is be VBZ 31504 148 20 the the DT 31504 148 21 same same JJ 31504 148 22 as as IN 31504 148 23 true true JJ 31504 148 24 reason reason NN 31504 148 25 , , , 31504 148 26 accordant accordant JJ 31504 148 27 with with IN 31504 148 28 nature nature NN 31504 148 29 , , , 31504 148 30 a a DT 31504 148 31 law law NN 31504 148 32 which which WDT 31504 148 33 is be VBZ 31504 148 34 constant constant JJ 31504 148 35 and and CC 31504 148 36 eternal eternal JJ 31504 148 37 , , , 31504 148 38 which which WDT 31504 148 39 calls call VBZ 31504 148 40 and and CC 31504 148 41 commands command NNS 31504 148 42 to to IN 31504 148 43 duty duty NN 31504 148 44 , , , 31504 148 45 which which WDT 31504 148 46 warns warn VBZ 31504 148 47 and and CC 31504 148 48 terrifies terrify VBZ 31504 148 49 men man NNS 31504 148 50 from from IN 31504 148 51 the the DT 31504 148 52 practice practice NN 31504 148 53 of of IN 31504 148 54 deceit deceit NN 31504 148 55 . . . 31504 149 1 This this DT 31504 149 2 law law NN 31504 149 3 is be VBZ 31504 149 4 not not RB 31504 149 5 one one CD 31504 149 6 thing thing NN 31504 149 7 at at IN 31504 149 8 Rome Rome NNP 31504 149 9 , , , 31504 149 10 another another DT 31504 149 11 at at IN 31504 149 12 Athens Athens NNP 31504 149 13 , , , 31504 149 14 but but CC 31504 149 15 is be VBZ 31504 149 16 eternal eternal JJ 31504 149 17 and and CC 31504 149 18 immutable immutable JJ 31504 149 19 , , , 31504 149 20 the the DT 31504 149 21 expression expression NN 31504 149 22 and and CC 31504 149 23 command command NN 31504 149 24 of of IN 31504 149 25 Deity deity NN 31504 149 26 . . . 31504 149 27 " " '' 31504 150 1 In in IN 31504 150 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 150 3 treatise treatise NN 31504 150 4 " " `` 31504 150 5 De De NNP 31504 150 6 Legibus Legibus NNP 31504 150 7 " " '' 31504 150 8 he -PRON- PRP 31504 150 9 declared declare VBD 31504 150 10 that that IN 31504 150 11 men man NNS 31504 150 12 are be VBP 31504 150 13 born bear VBN 31504 150 14 to to IN 31504 150 15 justice justice NN 31504 150 16 ; ; : 31504 150 17 that that DT 31504 150 18 right right NN 31504 150 19 is be VBZ 31504 150 20 established establish VBN 31504 150 21 not not RB 31504 150 22 by by IN 31504 150 23 opinion opinion NN 31504 150 24 but but CC 31504 150 25 by by IN 31504 150 26 nature nature NN 31504 150 27 ; ; : 31504 150 28 that that IN 31504 150 29 all all DT 31504 150 30 civil civil JJ 31504 150 31 law law NN 31504 150 32 is be VBZ 31504 150 33 but but CC 31504 150 34 the the DT 31504 150 35 expression expression NN 31504 150 36 or or CC 31504 150 37 application application NN 31504 150 38 of of IN 31504 150 39 this this DT 31504 150 40 eternal eternal JJ 31504 150 41 law law NN 31504 150 42 of of IN 31504 150 43 nature nature NN 31504 150 44 ; ; : 31504 150 45 that that IN 31504 150 46 the the DT 31504 150 47 people people NNS 31504 150 48 or or CC 31504 150 49 the the DT 31504 150 50 prince prince NN 31504 150 51 may may MD 31504 150 52 make make VB 31504 150 53 laws law NNS 31504 150 54 but but CC 31504 150 55 these these DT 31504 150 56 have have VBP 31504 150 57 not not RB 31504 150 58 the the DT 31504 150 59 true true JJ 31504 150 60 character character NN 31504 150 61 of of IN 31504 150 62 law law NN 31504 150 63 unless unless IN 31504 150 64 they -PRON- PRP 31504 150 65 be be VB 31504 150 66 derived derive VBN 31504 150 67 from from IN 31504 150 68 the the DT 31504 150 69 ultimate ultimate JJ 31504 150 70 law law NN 31504 150 71 ; ; : 31504 150 72 that that IN 31504 150 73 the the DT 31504 150 74 source source NN 31504 150 75 and and CC 31504 150 76 foundation foundation NN 31504 150 77 of of IN 31504 150 78 right right JJ 31504 150 79 law law NN 31504 150 80 must must MD 31504 150 81 be be VB 31504 150 82 looked look VBN 31504 150 83 for for IN 31504 150 84 in in IN 31504 150 85 that that DT 31504 150 86 supreme supreme NNP 31504 150 87 law law NNP 31504 150 88 which which WDT 31504 150 89 came come VBD 31504 150 90 into into IN 31504 150 91 being be VBG 31504 150 92 ages age NNS 31504 150 93 before before IN 31504 150 94 any any DT 31504 150 95 state state NN 31504 150 96 was be VBD 31504 150 97 formed form VBN 31504 150 98 . . . 31504 151 1 This this DT 31504 151 2 theory theory NN 31504 151 3 of of IN 31504 151 4 the the DT 31504 151 5 Stoics Stoics NNPS 31504 151 6 so so RB 31504 151 7 eloquently eloquently RB 31504 151 8 urged urge VBN 31504 151 9 by by IN 31504 151 10 Cicero Cicero NNP 31504 151 11 was be VBD 31504 151 12 practically practically RB 31504 151 13 the the DT 31504 151 14 _ _ NNP 31504 151 15 jus jus NNP 31504 151 16 naturale naturale NNP 31504 151 17 _ _ NNP 31504 151 18 of of IN 31504 151 19 the the DT 31504 151 20 Roman roman JJ 31504 151 21 jurists jurist NNS 31504 151 22 of of IN 31504 151 23 classical classical JJ 31504 151 24 times time NNS 31504 151 25 , , , 31504 151 26 though though IN 31504 151 27 more more RBR 31504 151 28 moderately moderately RB 31504 151 29 expressed express VBN 31504 151 30 by by IN 31504 151 31 them -PRON- PRP 31504 151 32 . . . 31504 152 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 152 2 does do VBZ 31504 152 3 not not RB 31504 152 4 seem seem VB 31504 152 5 to to TO 31504 152 6 have have VB 31504 152 7 been be VBN 31504 152 8 wholly wholly RB 31504 152 9 academic academic JJ 31504 152 10 , , , 31504 152 11 but but CC 31504 152 12 to to TO 31504 152 13 have have VB 31504 152 14 been be VBN 31504 152 15 actually actually RB 31504 152 16 applied apply VBN 31504 152 17 at at IN 31504 152 18 times time NNS 31504 152 19 . . . 31504 153 1 In in IN 31504 153 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 153 3 history history NN 31504 153 4 of of IN 31504 153 5 Rome Rome NNP 31504 153 6 , , , 31504 153 7 Mommsen Mommsen NNP 31504 153 8 relates relate VBZ 31504 153 9 that that IN 31504 153 10 even even RB 31504 153 11 during during IN 31504 153 12 the the DT 31504 153 13 nearly nearly RB 31504 153 14 absolute absolute JJ 31504 153 15 sway sway NN 31504 153 16 of of IN 31504 153 17 Sulla Sulla NNP 31504 153 18 , , , 31504 153 19 after after IN 31504 153 20 the the DT 31504 153 21 fall fall NN 31504 153 22 of of IN 31504 153 23 Marius Marius NNP 31504 153 24 , , , 31504 153 25 the the DT 31504 153 26 Cornelian Cornelian NNP 31504 153 27 Laws Laws NNPS 31504 153 28 enacted enact VBN 31504 153 29 to to TO 31504 153 30 deprive deprive VB 31504 153 31 various various JJ 31504 153 32 Italian italian JJ 31504 153 33 communities community NNS 31504 153 34 of of IN 31504 153 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 153 36 Roman roman JJ 31504 153 37 franchise franchise NN 31504 153 38 were be VBD 31504 153 39 ignored ignore VBN 31504 153 40 in in IN 31504 153 41 judicial judicial JJ 31504 153 42 proceedings proceeding NNS 31504 153 43 as as IN 31504 153 44 null null JJ 31504 153 45 and and CC 31504 153 46 void void JJ 31504 153 47 ; ; : 31504 153 48 also also RB 31504 153 49 that that IN 31504 153 50 , , , 31504 153 51 contrary contrary JJ 31504 153 52 to to IN 31504 153 53 Sulla Sulla NNP 31504 153 54 's 's POS 31504 153 55 decree decree NN 31504 153 56 , , , 31504 153 57 the the DT 31504 153 58 jurists jurist NNS 31504 153 59 held hold VBD 31504 153 60 that that IN 31504 153 61 the the DT 31504 153 62 franchise franchise NN 31504 153 63 of of IN 31504 153 64 citizenship citizenship NN 31504 153 65 was be VBD 31504 153 66 not not RB 31504 153 67 forfeited forfeit VBN 31504 153 68 by by IN 31504 153 69 capture capture NN 31504 153 70 and and CC 31504 153 71 sale sale NN 31504 153 72 into into IN 31504 153 73 slavery slavery NN 31504 153 74 during during IN 31504 153 75 the the DT 31504 153 76 civil civil JJ 31504 153 77 war war NN 31504 153 78 with with IN 31504 153 79 Marius Marius NNP 31504 153 80 . . . 31504 154 1 Later later RBR 31504 154 2 , , , 31504 154 3 when when WRB 31504 154 4 the the DT 31504 154 5 church church NN 31504 154 6 became become VBD 31504 154 7 a a DT 31504 154 8 power power NN 31504 154 9 in in IN 31504 154 10 the the DT 31504 154 11 state state NN 31504 154 12 there there EX 31504 154 13 are be VBP 31504 154 14 instances instance NNS 31504 154 15 where where WRB 31504 154 16 laws law NNS 31504 154 17 adjudged adjudge VBD 31504 154 18 to to TO 31504 154 19 be be VB 31504 154 20 contrary contrary JJ 31504 154 21 to to IN 31504 154 22 the the DT 31504 154 23 laws law NNS 31504 154 24 of of IN 31504 154 25 God God NNP 31504 154 26 were be VBD 31504 154 27 refused refuse VBN 31504 154 28 effect effect NN 31504 154 29 . . . 31504 155 1 In in IN 31504 155 2 England England NNP 31504 155 3 as as RB 31504 155 4 late late RB 31504 155 5 as as IN 31504 155 6 the the DT 31504 155 7 middle middle NN 31504 155 8 of of IN 31504 155 9 the the DT 31504 155 10 17th 17th JJ 31504 155 11 century century NN 31504 155 12 Chief Chief NNP 31504 155 13 Justice Justice NNP 31504 155 14 Hobart Hobart NNP 31504 155 15 , , , 31504 155 16 a a DT 31504 155 17 judge judge NN 31504 155 18 of of IN 31504 155 19 high high JJ 31504 155 20 repute repute NN 31504 155 21 , , , 31504 155 22 asserted assert VBD 31504 155 23 that that IN 31504 155 24 " " `` 31504 155 25 even even RB 31504 155 26 an an DT 31504 155 27 act act NN 31504 155 28 of of IN 31504 155 29 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 155 30 made make VBD 31504 155 31 against against IN 31504 155 32 natural natural JJ 31504 155 33 equity equity NN 31504 155 34 , , , 31504 155 35 as as IN 31504 155 36 to to TO 31504 155 37 make make VB 31504 155 38 a a DT 31504 155 39 man man NN 31504 155 40 judge judge VB 31504 155 41 in in IN 31504 155 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 155 43 own own JJ 31504 155 44 case case NN 31504 155 45 , , , 31504 155 46 is be VBZ 31504 155 47 void void JJ 31504 155 48 in in IN 31504 155 49 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 155 50 for for IN 31504 155 51 the the DT 31504 155 52 laws law NNS 31504 155 53 of of IN 31504 155 54 nature nature NN 31504 155 55 are be VBP 31504 155 56 immutable immutable JJ 31504 155 57 and and CC 31504 155 58 they -PRON- PRP 31504 155 59 are be VBP 31504 155 60 the the DT 31504 155 61 laws law NNS 31504 155 62 of of IN 31504 155 63 laws law NNS 31504 155 64 . . . 31504 155 65 " " '' 31504 156 1 In in IN 31504 156 2 the the DT 31504 156 3 18th 18th JJ 31504 156 4 century century NN 31504 156 5 Blackstone Blackstone NNP 31504 156 6 assented assent VBD 31504 156 7 to to IN 31504 156 8 the the DT 31504 156 9 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 156 10 of of IN 31504 156 11 a a DT 31504 156 12 _ _ NNP 31504 156 13 jus jus NNP 31504 156 14 naturale naturale JJ 31504 156 15 _ _ NNP 31504 156 16 and and CC 31504 156 17 wrote write VBD 31504 156 18 of of IN 31504 156 19 it -PRON- PRP 31504 156 20 : : : 31504 156 21 " " `` 31504 156 22 This this DT 31504 156 23 law law NN 31504 156 24 of of IN 31504 156 25 nature nature NN 31504 156 26 being be VBG 31504 156 27 coeval coeval NN 31504 156 28 with with IN 31504 156 29 mankind mankind NN 31504 156 30 and and CC 31504 156 31 dictated dictate VBN 31504 156 32 by by IN 31504 156 33 God God NNP 31504 156 34 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 156 35 is be VBZ 31504 156 36 of of IN 31504 156 37 course course NN 31504 156 38 superior superior JJ 31504 156 39 in in IN 31504 156 40 obligation obligation NN 31504 156 41 to to IN 31504 156 42 any any DT 31504 156 43 other other JJ 31504 156 44 .... .... . 31504 156 45 No no DT 31504 156 46 human human JJ 31504 156 47 laws law NNS 31504 156 48 are be VBP 31504 156 49 of of IN 31504 156 50 any any DT 31504 156 51 validity validity NN 31504 156 52 if if IN 31504 156 53 contrary contrary RB 31504 156 54 to to IN 31504 156 55 this this DT 31504 156 56 , , , 31504 156 57 and and CC 31504 156 58 such such JJ 31504 156 59 of of IN 31504 156 60 them -PRON- PRP 31504 156 61 as as IN 31504 156 62 are be VBP 31504 156 63 valid valid JJ 31504 156 64 derive derive VBP 31504 156 65 all all DT 31504 156 66 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 156 67 force force NN 31504 156 68 and and CC 31504 156 69 all all DT 31504 156 70 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 156 71 authority authority NN 31504 156 72 , , , 31504 156 73 mediately mediately RB 31504 156 74 or or CC 31504 156 75 immediately immediately RB 31504 156 76 , , , 31504 156 77 from from IN 31504 156 78 this this DT 31504 156 79 original original NN 31504 156 80 . . . 31504 156 81 " " '' 31504 157 1 True true JJ 31504 157 2 , , , 31504 157 3 Blackstone Blackstone NNP 31504 157 4 combated combat VBD 31504 157 5 the the DT 31504 157 6 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 157 7 that that WDT 31504 157 8 duly duly RB 31504 157 9 enacted enact VBN 31504 157 10 statutes statute NNS 31504 157 11 were be VBD 31504 157 12 to to TO 31504 157 13 be be VB 31504 157 14 held hold VBN 31504 157 15 void void JJ 31504 157 16 if if IN 31504 157 17 the the DT 31504 157 18 judges judge NNS 31504 157 19 thought think VBD 31504 157 20 them -PRON- PRP 31504 157 21 contrary contrary RB 31504 157 22 to to IN 31504 157 23 reason reason NN 31504 157 24 , , , 31504 157 25 but but CC 31504 157 26 he -PRON- PRP 31504 157 27 admitted admit VBD 31504 157 28 that that IN 31504 157 29 that that IN 31504 157 30 extreme extreme JJ 31504 157 31 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 157 32 was be VBD 31504 157 33 more more RBR 31504 157 34 generally generally RB 31504 157 35 held hold VBN 31504 157 36 . . . 31504 158 1 In in IN 31504 158 2 this this DT 31504 158 3 country country NN 31504 158 4 the the DT 31504 158 5 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 158 6 of of IN 31504 158 7 a a DT 31504 158 8 higher high JJR 31504 158 9 law law NN 31504 158 10 than than IN 31504 158 11 the the DT 31504 158 12 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 158 13 even even RB 31504 158 14 , , , 31504 158 15 and and CC 31504 158 16 to to TO 31504 158 17 be be VB 31504 158 18 obeyed obey VBN 31504 158 19 rather rather RB 31504 158 20 than than IN 31504 158 21 the the DT 31504 158 22 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 158 23 and and CC 31504 158 24 laws law NNS 31504 158 25 enacted enact VBN 31504 158 26 in in IN 31504 158 27 accordance accordance NN 31504 158 28 therewith therewith NNP 31504 158 29 , , , 31504 158 30 has have VBZ 31504 158 31 had have VBN 31504 158 32 and and CC 31504 158 33 even even RB 31504 158 34 now now RB 31504 158 35 has have VBZ 31504 158 36 earnest earnest JJ 31504 158 37 advocates advocate NNS 31504 158 38 . . . 31504 159 1 But but CC 31504 159 2 the the DT 31504 159 3 contrary contrary JJ 31504 159 4 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 159 5 of of IN 31504 159 6 Carneades Carneades NNPS 31504 159 7 and and CC 31504 159 8 the the DT 31504 159 9 Sophists Sophists NNPS 31504 159 10 would would MD 31504 159 11 not not RB 31504 159 12 down down RB 31504 159 13 . . . 31504 160 1 After after IN 31504 160 2 Cicero Cicero NNP 31504 160 3 and and CC 31504 160 4 the the DT 31504 160 5 civilians civilian NNS 31504 160 6 , , , 31504 160 7 after after IN 31504 160 8 Hobart Hobart NNP 31504 160 9 and and CC 31504 160 10 Blackstone Blackstone NNP 31504 160 11 , , , 31504 160 12 came come VBD 31504 160 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 160 14 modern modern JJ 31504 160 15 utilitarians utilitarian NNS 31504 160 16 , , , 31504 160 17 or or CC 31504 160 18 sophists sophist NNS 31504 160 19 , , , 31504 160 20 Bentham Bentham NNP 31504 160 21 , , , 31504 160 22 Mill Mill NNP 31504 160 23 , , , 31504 160 24 Austin Austin NNP 31504 160 25 , , , 31504 160 26 and and CC 31504 160 27 others other NNS 31504 160 28 , , , 31504 160 29 who who WP 31504 160 30 have have VBP 31504 160 31 vigorously vigorously RB 31504 160 32 maintained maintain VBN 31504 160 33 with with IN 31504 160 34 weighty weighty JJ 31504 160 35 arguments argument NNS 31504 160 36 the the DT 31504 160 37 utilitarian utilitarian JJ 31504 160 38 theory theory NN 31504 160 39 of of IN 31504 160 40 justice justice NN 31504 160 41 ; ; : 31504 160 42 and and CC 31504 160 43 that that IN 31504 160 44 theory theory NN 31504 160 45 is be VBZ 31504 160 46 now now RB 31504 160 47 generally generally RB 31504 160 48 accepted accept VBN 31504 160 49 by by IN 31504 160 50 lawyers lawyer NNS 31504 160 51 and and CC 31504 160 52 statesmen statesman NNS 31504 160 53 as as IN 31504 160 54 at at IN 31504 160 55 least least JJS 31504 160 56 the the DT 31504 160 57 most most RBS 31504 160 58 workable workable JJ 31504 160 59 theory theory NN 31504 160 60 in in IN 31504 160 61 human human JJ 31504 160 62 affairs affair NNS 31504 160 63 . . . 31504 161 1 There there EX 31504 161 2 still still RB 31504 161 3 exists exist VBZ 31504 161 4 , , , 31504 161 5 however however RB 31504 161 6 , , , 31504 161 7 in in IN 31504 161 8 the the DT 31504 161 9 minds mind NNS 31504 161 10 of of IN 31504 161 11 many many JJ 31504 161 12 the the DT 31504 161 13 belief belief NN 31504 161 14 that that IN 31504 161 15 above above IN 31504 161 16 and and CC 31504 161 17 behind behind IN 31504 161 18 all all PDT 31504 161 19 the the DT 31504 161 20 turmoil turmoil NN 31504 161 21 and and CC 31504 161 22 strife strife NN 31504 161 23 of of IN 31504 161 24 politics politic NNS 31504 161 25 , , , 31504 161 26 all all PDT 31504 161 27 the the DT 31504 161 28 flux flux NN 31504 161 29 and and CC 31504 161 30 reflux reflux NN 31504 161 31 of of IN 31504 161 32 social social JJ 31504 161 33 movements movement NNS 31504 161 34 and and CC 31504 161 35 public public JJ 31504 161 36 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 161 37 , , , 31504 161 38 the the DT 31504 161 39 confusion confusion NN 31504 161 40 of of IN 31504 161 41 enactments enactment NNS 31504 161 42 , , , 31504 161 43 amendments amendment NNS 31504 161 44 , , , 31504 161 45 and and CC 31504 161 46 repeals repeal NNS 31504 161 47 of of IN 31504 161 48 statutes statute NNS 31504 161 49 , , , 31504 161 50 the the DT 31504 161 51 swaying swaying NN 31504 161 52 of of IN 31504 161 53 judicial judicial JJ 31504 161 54 opinion opinion NN 31504 161 55 , , , 31504 161 56 there there EX 31504 161 57 is be VBZ 31504 161 58 some some DT 31504 161 59 law law NN 31504 161 60 of of IN 31504 161 61 nature nature NN 31504 161 62 or or CC 31504 161 63 in in IN 31504 161 64 nature nature NN 31504 161 65 , , , 31504 161 66 some some DT 31504 161 67 criterion criterion NN 31504 161 68 , , , 31504 161 69 which which WDT 31504 161 70 if if IN 31504 161 71 ascertained ascertain VBN 31504 161 72 and and CC 31504 161 73 obeyed obeyed NNP 31504 161 74 would would MD 31504 161 75 be be VB 31504 161 76 perfect perfect JJ 31504 161 77 justice justice NN 31504 161 78 . . . 31504 162 1 This this DT 31504 162 2 question question NN 31504 162 3 of of IN 31504 162 4 the the DT 31504 162 5 origin origin NN 31504 162 6 , , , 31504 162 7 the the DT 31504 162 8 foundation foundation NN 31504 162 9 of of IN 31504 162 10 justice justice NN 31504 162 11 , , , 31504 162 12 whether whether IN 31504 162 13 it -PRON- PRP 31504 162 14 be be VB 31504 162 15 of of IN 31504 162 16 God God NNP 31504 162 17 or or CC 31504 162 18 of of IN 31504 162 19 men man NNS 31504 162 20 , , , 31504 162 21 seems seem VBZ 31504 162 22 to to TO 31504 162 23 have have VB 31504 162 24 been be VBN 31504 162 25 much much RB 31504 162 26 more more RBR 31504 162 27 debated debate VBN 31504 162 28 than than IN 31504 162 29 the the DT 31504 162 30 question question NN 31504 162 31 what what WP 31504 162 32 is be VBZ 31504 162 33 the the DT 31504 162 34 nature nature NN 31504 162 35 of of IN 31504 162 36 justice justice NN 31504 162 37 whatever whatever WDT 31504 162 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 162 39 origin origin NN 31504 162 40 or or CC 31504 162 41 foundation foundation NN 31504 162 42 . . . 31504 163 1 Yet yet CC 31504 163 2 some some DT 31504 163 3 attempts attempt NNS 31504 163 4 , , , 31504 163 5 other other JJ 31504 163 6 than than IN 31504 163 7 those those DT 31504 163 8 attributed attribute VBN 31504 163 9 to to IN 31504 163 10 Socrates Socrates NNP 31504 163 11 , , , 31504 163 12 have have VBP 31504 163 13 been be VBN 31504 163 14 made make VBN 31504 163 15 of of IN 31504 163 16 old old JJ 31504 163 17 to to TO 31504 163 18 give give VB 31504 163 19 a a DT 31504 163 20 definition definition NN 31504 163 21 of of IN 31504 163 22 justice justice NN 31504 163 23 . . . 31504 164 1 The the DT 31504 164 2 earliest early JJS 31504 164 3 description description NN 31504 164 4 I -PRON- PRP 31504 164 5 have have VBP 31504 164 6 found find VBN 31504 164 7 is be VBZ 31504 164 8 that that DT 31504 164 9 of of IN 31504 164 10 the the DT 31504 164 11 early early JJ 31504 164 12 Pythagoreans Pythagoreans NNPS 31504 164 13 , , , 31504 164 14 who who WP 31504 164 15 , , , 31504 164 16 in in IN 31504 164 17 accordance accordance NN 31504 164 18 with with IN 31504 164 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 164 20 practise practise NN 31504 164 21 of of IN 31504 164 22 symbolizing symbolize VBG 31504 164 23 the the DT 31504 164 24 virtues virtue NNS 31504 164 25 by by IN 31504 164 26 geometrical geometrical JJ 31504 164 27 figures figure NNS 31504 164 28 , , , 31504 164 29 designated designate VBN 31504 164 30 justice justice NN 31504 164 31 by by IN 31504 164 32 the the DT 31504 164 33 square square NN 31504 164 34 , , , 31504 164 35 and and CC 31504 164 36 the the DT 31504 164 37 just just JJ 31504 164 38 man man NN 31504 164 39 by by IN 31504 164 40 the the DT 31504 164 41 cube cube NN 31504 164 42 . . . 31504 165 1 Plato Plato NNP 31504 165 2 seems seem VBZ 31504 165 3 to to TO 31504 165 4 have have VB 31504 165 5 had have VBN 31504 165 6 a a DT 31504 165 7 theory theory NN 31504 165 8 of of IN 31504 165 9 justice justice NN 31504 165 10 when when WRB 31504 165 11 he -PRON- PRP 31504 165 12 wrote write VBD 31504 165 13 in in IN 31504 165 14 the the DT 31504 165 15 " " `` 31504 165 16 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 31504 165 17 , , , 31504 165 18 " " '' 31504 165 19 " " `` 31504 165 20 Nature nature VB 31504 165 21 herself -PRON- PRP 31504 165 22 intimates intimate VBZ 31504 165 23 that that IN 31504 165 24 it -PRON- PRP 31504 165 25 is be VBZ 31504 165 26 just just RB 31504 165 27 for for IN 31504 165 28 the the DT 31504 165 29 better well JJR 31504 165 30 to to TO 31504 165 31 have have VB 31504 165 32 more more JJR 31504 165 33 than than IN 31504 165 34 the the DT 31504 165 35 worse bad JJR 31504 165 36 , , , 31504 165 37 the the DT 31504 165 38 stronger strong JJR 31504 165 39 than than IN 31504 165 40 the the DT 31504 165 41 weaker weak JJR 31504 165 42 , , , 31504 165 43 and and CC 31504 165 44 in in IN 31504 165 45 many many JJ 31504 165 46 ways way NNS 31504 165 47 she -PRON- PRP 31504 165 48 shows show VBZ 31504 165 49 that that IN 31504 165 50 among among IN 31504 165 51 men man NNS 31504 165 52 as as RB 31504 165 53 well well RB 31504 165 54 as as IN 31504 165 55 among among IN 31504 165 56 animals animal NNS 31504 165 57 justice justice NN 31504 165 58 consists consist VBZ 31504 165 59 in in IN 31504 165 60 the the DT 31504 165 61 superior superior JJ 31504 165 62 ruling ruling NN 31504 165 63 over over RP 31504 165 64 and and CC 31504 165 65 having have VBG 31504 165 66 more more JJR 31504 165 67 than than IN 31504 165 68 the the DT 31504 165 69 inferior inferior JJ 31504 165 70 . . . 31504 165 71 " " '' 31504 166 1 In in IN 31504 166 2 these these DT 31504 166 3 days day NNS 31504 166 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 166 5 first first JJ 31504 166 6 impulse impulse NN 31504 166 7 may may MD 31504 166 8 be be VB 31504 166 9 to to TO 31504 166 10 denounce denounce VB 31504 166 11 Plato Plato NNP 31504 166 12 's 's POS 31504 166 13 statement statement NN 31504 166 14 as as IN 31504 166 15 altogether altogether RB 31504 166 16 wrong wrong JJ 31504 166 17 if if IN 31504 166 18 not not RB 31504 166 19 worse bad JJR 31504 166 20 . . . 31504 167 1 We -PRON- PRP 31504 167 2 should should MD 31504 167 3 remember remember VB 31504 167 4 , , , 31504 167 5 however however RB 31504 167 6 , , , 31504 167 7 that that IN 31504 167 8 Plato Plato NNP 31504 167 9 was be VBD 31504 167 10 not not RB 31504 167 11 considering consider VBG 31504 167 12 any any DT 31504 167 13 altruistic altruistic JJ 31504 167 14 virtue virtue NN 31504 167 15 such such JJ 31504 167 16 as as IN 31504 167 17 kindness kindness NN 31504 167 18 , , , 31504 167 19 sympathy sympathy NN 31504 167 20 , , , 31504 167 21 benevolence benevolence NN 31504 167 22 , , , 31504 167 23 generosity generosity NN 31504 167 24 and and CC 31504 167 25 the the DT 31504 167 26 like like JJ 31504 167 27 , , , 31504 167 28 but but CC 31504 167 29 only only RB 31504 167 30 what what WP 31504 167 31 nature nature NN 31504 167 32 indicates indicate VBZ 31504 167 33 to to TO 31504 167 34 be be VB 31504 167 35 the the DT 31504 167 36 essential essential JJ 31504 167 37 condition condition NN 31504 167 38 of of IN 31504 167 39 successful successful JJ 31504 167 40 association association NN 31504 167 41 . . . 31504 168 1 Thus thus RB 31504 168 2 interpreted interpret VBN 31504 168 3 , , , 31504 168 4 are be VBP 31504 168 5 we -PRON- PRP 31504 168 6 prepared prepared JJ 31504 168 7 to to TO 31504 168 8 confute confute VB 31504 168 9 the the DT 31504 168 10 statement statement NN 31504 168 11 ? ? . 31504 169 1 Do do VBP 31504 169 2 we -PRON- PRP 31504 169 3 know know VB 31504 169 4 of of IN 31504 169 5 any any DT 31504 169 6 state state NN 31504 169 7 of of IN 31504 169 8 society society NN 31504 169 9 in in IN 31504 169 10 human human JJ 31504 169 11 or or CC 31504 169 12 animal animal NN 31504 169 13 life life NN 31504 169 14 at at IN 31504 169 15 any any DT 31504 169 16 time time NN 31504 169 17 , , , 31504 169 18 past past JJ 31504 169 19 or or CC 31504 169 20 present present JJ 31504 169 21 , , , 31504 169 22 of of IN 31504 169 23 which which WDT 31504 169 24 the the DT 31504 169 25 contrary contrary NN 31504 169 26 of of IN 31504 169 27 Plato Plato NNP 31504 169 28 's 's POS 31504 169 29 statement statement NN 31504 169 30 is be VBZ 31504 169 31 true true JJ 31504 169 32 ? ? . 31504 170 1 But but CC 31504 170 2 passing pass VBG 31504 170 3 over over RP 31504 170 4 all all DT 31504 170 5 other other JJ 31504 170 6 attempts attempt NNS 31504 170 7 of of IN 31504 170 8 the the DT 31504 170 9 ancients ancient NNS 31504 170 10 to to TO 31504 170 11 define define VB 31504 170 12 justice justice NN 31504 170 13 , , , 31504 170 14 none none NN 31504 170 15 of of IN 31504 170 16 which which WDT 31504 170 17 seems seem VBZ 31504 170 18 to to TO 31504 170 19 have have VB 31504 170 20 been be VBN 31504 170 21 much much RB 31504 170 22 regarded regard VBN 31504 170 23 by by IN 31504 170 24 contemporary contemporary JJ 31504 170 25 opinion opinion NN 31504 170 26 , , , 31504 170 27 I -PRON- PRP 31504 170 28 will will MD 31504 170 29 only only RB 31504 170 30 cite cite VB 31504 170 31 the the DT 31504 170 32 most most RBS 31504 170 33 famous famous JJ 31504 170 34 , , , 31504 170 35 that that IN 31504 170 36 by by IN 31504 170 37 Ulpian Ulpian NNP 31504 170 38 , , , 31504 170 39 the the DT 31504 170 40 renowned renowned JJ 31504 170 41 jurist jurist NN 31504 170 42 of of IN 31504 170 43 the the DT 31504 170 44 best good JJS 31504 170 45 period period NN 31504 170 46 of of IN 31504 170 47 Roman roman JJ 31504 170 48 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 31504 170 49 , , , 31504 170 50 whose whose WP$ 31504 170 51 writings writing NNS 31504 170 52 were be VBD 31504 170 53 most most RBS 31504 170 54 drawn draw VBN 31504 170 55 upon upon IN 31504 170 56 by by IN 31504 170 57 the the DT 31504 170 58 learned learn VBN 31504 170 59 compilers compiler NNS 31504 170 60 of of IN 31504 170 61 the the DT 31504 170 62 Institutes Institutes NNPS 31504 170 63 and and CC 31504 170 64 Digest Digest NNP 31504 170 65 of of IN 31504 170 66 Justinian Justinian NNP 31504 170 67 ; ; : 31504 170 68 viz viz NNP 31504 170 69 . . NNP 31504 170 70 , , , 31504 170 71 " " '' 31504 170 72 Justitia Justitia NNP 31504 170 73 est est NNP 31504 170 74 constans constans NNPS 31504 170 75 et et NNP 31504 170 76 perpetua perpetua NNP 31504 170 77 voluntas voluntas NNP 31504 170 78 jus jus NNP 31504 170 79 suum suum NNP 31504 170 80 cuique cuique NNP 31504 170 81 tribuendi tribuendi NNP 31504 170 82 , , , 31504 170 83 " " '' 31504 170 84 or or CC 31504 170 85 " " `` 31504 170 86 Justice Justice NNP 31504 170 87 is be VBZ 31504 170 88 the the DT 31504 170 89 constant constant JJ 31504 170 90 and and CC 31504 170 91 perpetual perpetual JJ 31504 170 92 will will MD 31504 170 93 to to TO 31504 170 94 render render VB 31504 170 95 to to IN 31504 170 96 every every DT 31504 170 97 one one NN 31504 170 98 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 170 99 right right NN 31504 170 100 . . . 31504 170 101 " " '' 31504 171 1 This this DT 31504 171 2 definition definition NN 31504 171 3 was be VBD 31504 171 4 adopted adopt VBN 31504 171 5 by by IN 31504 171 6 the the DT 31504 171 7 compilers compiler NNS 31504 171 8 as as IN 31504 171 9 correct correct JJ 31504 171 10 and and CC 31504 171 11 made make VBD 31504 171 12 the the DT 31504 171 13 introduction introduction NN 31504 171 14 to to IN 31504 171 15 the the DT 31504 171 16 Institutes Institutes NNPS 31504 171 17 . . . 31504 172 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 172 2 thus thus RB 31504 172 3 received receive VBD 31504 172 4 the the DT 31504 172 5 imperial imperial JJ 31504 172 6 sanction sanction NN 31504 172 7 and and CC 31504 172 8 was be VBD 31504 172 9 quoted quote VBN 31504 172 10 wherever wherever WRB 31504 172 11 the the DT 31504 172 12 law law NN 31504 172 13 of of IN 31504 172 14 Rome Rome NNP 31504 172 15 prevailed prevail VBD 31504 172 16 , , , 31504 172 17 down down RB 31504 172 18 through through IN 31504 172 19 medieval medieval JJ 31504 172 20 times time NNS 31504 172 21 and and CC 31504 172 22 later later RB 31504 172 23 , , , 31504 172 24 almost almost RB 31504 172 25 as as IN 31504 172 26 if if IN 31504 172 27 it -PRON- PRP 31504 172 28 were be VBD 31504 172 29 an an DT 31504 172 30 inspired inspire VBN 31504 172 31 or or CC 31504 172 32 at at IN 31504 172 33 least least JJS 31504 172 34 authoritative authoritative JJ 31504 172 35 definition definition NN 31504 172 36 not not RB 31504 172 37 to to TO 31504 172 38 be be VB 31504 172 39 questioned question VBN 31504 172 40 . . . 31504 173 1 But but CC 31504 173 2 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 31504 173 3 the the DT 31504 173 4 acclaim acclaim NN 31504 173 5 with with IN 31504 173 6 which which WDT 31504 173 7 this this DT 31504 173 8 definition definition NN 31504 173 9 was be VBD 31504 173 10 hailed hail VBN 31504 173 11 , , , 31504 173 12 I -PRON- PRP 31504 173 13 question question VBP 31504 173 14 that that IN 31504 173 15 it -PRON- PRP 31504 173 16 was be VBD 31504 173 17 any any DT 31504 173 18 improvement improvement NN 31504 173 19 on on IN 31504 173 20 that that DT 31504 173 21 of of IN 31504 173 22 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 31504 173 23 , , , 31504 173 24 who who WP 31504 173 25 tersely tersely RB 31504 173 26 defined define VBD 31504 173 27 justice justice NN 31504 173 28 as as IN 31504 173 29 " " `` 31504 173 30 that that DT 31504 173 31 virtue virtue NN 31504 173 32 of of IN 31504 173 33 the the DT 31504 173 34 soul soul NN 31504 173 35 which which WDT 31504 173 36 is be VBZ 31504 173 37 distributive distributive JJ 31504 173 38 according accord VBG 31504 173 39 to to IN 31504 173 40 desert desert NN 31504 173 41 . . . 31504 173 42 " " '' 31504 174 1 Indeed indeed RB 31504 174 2 , , , 31504 174 3 I -PRON- PRP 31504 174 4 think think VBP 31504 174 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 31504 174 6 was be VBD 31504 174 7 nearer nearer IN 31504 174 8 the the DT 31504 174 9 mark mark NN 31504 174 10 . . . 31504 175 1 Upon upon IN 31504 175 2 the the DT 31504 175 3 revival revival NN 31504 175 4 of of IN 31504 175 5 the the DT 31504 175 6 study study NN 31504 175 7 of of IN 31504 175 8 law law NN 31504 175 9 and and CC 31504 175 10 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 31504 175 11 in in IN 31504 175 12 the the DT 31504 175 13 11th 11th JJ 31504 175 14 and and CC 31504 175 15 12th 12th JJ 31504 175 16 centuries century NNS 31504 175 17 several several JJ 31504 175 18 of of IN 31504 175 19 the the DT 31504 175 20 more more RBR 31504 175 21 famous famous JJ 31504 175 22 jurists jurist NNS 31504 175 23 of of IN 31504 175 24 that that DT 31504 175 25 time time NN 31504 175 26 , , , 31504 175 27 Azo Azo NNP 31504 175 28 , , , 31504 175 29 Irnerius Irnerius NNP 31504 175 30 , , , 31504 175 31 Placentinus Placentinus NNP 31504 175 32 and and CC 31504 175 33 others other NNS 31504 175 34 , , , 31504 175 35 essayed essayed JJ 31504 175 36 definitions definition NNS 31504 175 37 of of IN 31504 175 38 justice justice NN 31504 175 39 , , , 31504 175 40 but but CC 31504 175 41 they -PRON- PRP 31504 175 42 do do VBP 31504 175 43 not not RB 31504 175 44 seem seem VB 31504 175 45 to to TO 31504 175 46 have have VB 31504 175 47 improved improve VBN 31504 175 48 upon upon IN 31504 175 49 Ulpian Ulpian NNP 31504 175 50 . . . 31504 176 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 176 2 definitions definition NNS 31504 176 3 were be VBD 31504 176 4 vitiated vitiate VBN 31504 176 5 by by IN 31504 176 6 theological theological JJ 31504 176 7 assumptions assumption NNS 31504 176 8 and and CC 31504 176 9 none none NN 31504 176 10 of of IN 31504 176 11 them -PRON- PRP 31504 176 12 has have VBZ 31504 176 13 become become VBN 31504 176 14 a a DT 31504 176 15 text text NN 31504 176 16 for for IN 31504 176 17 commentators commentator NNS 31504 176 18 or or CC 31504 176 19 students student NNS 31504 176 20 . . . 31504 177 1 Neither neither CC 31504 177 2 in in IN 31504 177 3 modern modern JJ 31504 177 4 times time NNS 31504 177 5 has have VBZ 31504 177 6 any any DT 31504 177 7 definition definition NN 31504 177 8 of of IN 31504 177 9 justice justice NN 31504 177 10 been be VBN 31504 177 11 suggested suggest VBN 31504 177 12 which which WDT 31504 177 13 has have VBZ 31504 177 14 received receive VBN 31504 177 15 such such JJ 31504 177 16 universal universal JJ 31504 177 17 assent assent NN 31504 177 18 as as IN 31504 177 19 did do VBD 31504 177 20 that that DT 31504 177 21 of of IN 31504 177 22 Ulpian Ulpian NNP 31504 177 23 in in IN 31504 177 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 177 25 time time NN 31504 177 26 and and CC 31504 177 27 for for IN 31504 177 28 centuries century NNS 31504 177 29 afterward afterward RB 31504 177 30 . . . 31504 178 1 We -PRON- PRP 31504 178 2 may may MD 31504 178 3 therefore therefore RB 31504 178 4 return return VB 31504 178 5 to to IN 31504 178 6 Ulpian Ulpian NNP 31504 178 7 's 's POS 31504 178 8 definition definition NN 31504 178 9 as as IN 31504 178 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 178 11 point point NN 31504 178 12 of of IN 31504 178 13 departure departure NN 31504 178 14 , , , 31504 178 15 since since IN 31504 178 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 178 17 definition definition NN 31504 178 18 is be VBZ 31504 178 19 substantially substantially RB 31504 178 20 that that WDT 31504 178 21 suggested suggest VBN 31504 178 22 earlier early RBR 31504 178 23 by by IN 31504 178 24 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 31504 178 25 , , , 31504 178 26 and and CC 31504 178 27 observations observation NNS 31504 178 28 on on IN 31504 178 29 the the DT 31504 178 30 later later RB 31504 178 31 will will MD 31504 178 32 also also RB 31504 178 33 apply apply VB 31504 178 34 in in IN 31504 178 35 many many JJ 31504 178 36 respects respect NNS 31504 178 37 to to IN 31504 178 38 the the DT 31504 178 39 earlier early JJR 31504 178 40 . . . 31504 179 1 Ulpian Ulpian NNP 31504 179 2 's 's POS 31504 179 3 definition definition NN 31504 179 4 is be VBZ 31504 179 5 elegant elegant JJ 31504 179 6 in in IN 31504 179 7 style style NN 31504 179 8 , , , 31504 179 9 but but CC 31504 179 10 it -PRON- PRP 31504 179 11 does do VBZ 31504 179 12 not not RB 31504 179 13 carry carry VB 31504 179 14 us -PRON- PRP 31504 179 15 very very RB 31504 179 16 far far RB 31504 179 17 in in IN 31504 179 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 179 19 inquiry inquiry NN 31504 179 20 . . . 31504 180 1 We -PRON- PRP 31504 180 2 are be VBP 31504 180 3 told tell VBN 31504 180 4 indeed indeed RB 31504 180 5 that that DT 31504 180 6 justice justice NN 31504 180 7 is be VBZ 31504 180 8 a a DT 31504 180 9 state state NN 31504 180 10 or or CC 31504 180 11 disposition disposition NN 31504 180 12 of of IN 31504 180 13 the the DT 31504 180 14 mind mind NN 31504 180 15 , , , 31504 180 16 the the DT 31504 180 17 disposition disposition NN 31504 180 18 to to TO 31504 180 19 render render VB 31504 180 20 to to IN 31504 180 21 everyone everyone NN 31504 180 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 180 23 right right NN 31504 180 24 or or CC 31504 180 25 , , , 31504 180 26 as as IN 31504 180 27 put put VBN 31504 180 28 by by IN 31504 180 29 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 31504 180 30 , , , 31504 180 31 is be VBZ 31504 180 32 the the DT 31504 180 33 disposition disposition NN 31504 180 34 to to TO 31504 180 35 distribute distribute VB 31504 180 36 according accord VBG 31504 180 37 to to IN 31504 180 38 desert desert NN 31504 180 39 . . . 31504 181 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 181 2 was be VBD 31504 181 3 this this DT 31504 181 4 statement statement NN 31504 181 5 that that WDT 31504 181 6 captured capture VBD 31504 181 7 the the DT 31504 181 8 medieval medieval JJ 31504 181 9 jurists jurist NNS 31504 181 10 and and CC 31504 181 11 which which WDT 31504 181 12 they -PRON- PRP 31504 181 13 made make VBD 31504 181 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 181 15 text text NN 31504 181 16 , , , 31504 181 17 but but CC 31504 181 18 it -PRON- PRP 31504 181 19 is be VBZ 31504 181 20 now now RB 31504 181 21 regarded regard VBN 31504 181 22 as as IN 31504 181 23 incomplete incomplete JJ 31504 181 24 and and CC 31504 181 25 even even RB 31504 181 26 inaccurate inaccurate JJ 31504 181 27 . . . 31504 182 1 One one PRP 31504 182 2 may may MD 31504 182 3 have have VB 31504 182 4 the the DT 31504 182 5 disposition disposition NN 31504 182 6 , , , 31504 182 7 the the DT 31504 182 8 desire desire NN 31504 182 9 , , , 31504 182 10 the the DT 31504 182 11 will will NN 31504 182 12 , , , 31504 182 13 to to TO 31504 182 14 render render VB 31504 182 15 to to IN 31504 182 16 every every DT 31504 182 17 one one NN 31504 182 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 182 19 right right NN 31504 182 20 , , , 31504 182 21 but but CC 31504 182 22 unless unless IN 31504 182 23 he -PRON- PRP 31504 182 24 can can MD 31504 182 25 know know VB 31504 182 26 what what WP 31504 182 27 is be VBZ 31504 182 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 182 29 fellow fellow NN 31504 182 30 's 's POS 31504 182 31 right right NN 31504 182 32 he -PRON- PRP 31504 182 33 may may MD 31504 182 34 unwittingly unwittingly RB 31504 182 35 fail fail VB 31504 182 36 to to TO 31504 182 37 accord accord VB 31504 182 38 it -PRON- PRP 31504 182 39 to to IN 31504 182 40 him -PRON- PRP 31504 182 41 and and CC 31504 182 42 thus thus RB 31504 182 43 unwittingly unwittingly RB 31504 182 44 do do VBP 31504 182 45 injustice injustice NN 31504 182 46 . . . 31504 183 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 183 2 evidently evidently RB 31504 183 3 is be VBZ 31504 183 4 not not RB 31504 183 5 enough enough JJ 31504 183 6 to to TO 31504 183 7 have have VB 31504 183 8 the the DT 31504 183 9 disposition disposition NN 31504 183 10 or or CC 31504 183 11 will will MD 31504 183 12 ; ; : 31504 183 13 hence hence RB 31504 183 14 the the DT 31504 183 15 definition definition NN 31504 183 16 is be VBZ 31504 183 17 incomplete incomplete JJ 31504 183 18 , , , 31504 183 19 and and CC 31504 183 20 any any DT 31504 183 21 definition definition NN 31504 183 22 is be VBZ 31504 183 23 incomplete incomplete JJ 31504 183 24 which which WDT 31504 183 25 does do VBZ 31504 183 26 not not RB 31504 183 27 furnish furnish VB 31504 183 28 a a DT 31504 183 29 criterion criterion NN 31504 183 30 for for IN 31504 183 31 determining determine VBG 31504 183 32 what what WP 31504 183 33 is be VBZ 31504 183 34 the the DT 31504 183 35 given given JJ 31504 183 36 man man NN 31504 183 37 's 's POS 31504 183 38 right right JJ 31504 183 39 . . . 31504 184 1 But but CC 31504 184 2 the the DT 31504 184 3 definition definition NN 31504 184 4 as as RB 31504 184 5 far far RB 31504 184 6 as as IN 31504 184 7 it -PRON- PRP 31504 184 8 does do VBZ 31504 184 9 go go VB 31504 184 10 is be VBZ 31504 184 11 not not RB 31504 184 12 strictly strictly RB 31504 184 13 accurate accurate JJ 31504 184 14 . . . 31504 185 1 The the DT 31504 185 2 man man NN 31504 185 3 of of IN 31504 185 4 malevolent malevolent JJ 31504 185 5 disposition disposition NN 31504 185 6 who who WP 31504 185 7 would would MD 31504 185 8 wrong wrong VB 31504 185 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 185 10 fellow fellow NN 31504 185 11 if if IN 31504 185 12 he -PRON- PRP 31504 185 13 dared dare VBD 31504 185 14 , , , 31504 185 15 may may MD 31504 185 16 yet yet RB 31504 185 17 , , , 31504 185 18 to to TO 31504 185 19 avoid avoid VB 31504 185 20 unpleasant unpleasant JJ 31504 185 21 consequences consequence NNS 31504 185 22 to to IN 31504 185 23 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 185 24 , , , 31504 185 25 render render VB 31504 185 26 fully fully RB 31504 185 27 to to IN 31504 185 28 every every DT 31504 185 29 other other JJ 31504 185 30 man man NN 31504 185 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 185 32 right right NN 31504 185 33 . . . 31504 186 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 186 2 would would MD 31504 186 3 seem seem VB 31504 186 4 , , , 31504 186 5 therefore therefore RB 31504 186 6 , , , 31504 186 7 that that DT 31504 186 8 justice justice NN 31504 186 9 is be VBZ 31504 186 10 an an DT 31504 186 11 attribute attribute NN 31504 186 12 or or CC 31504 186 13 quality quality NN 31504 186 14 of of IN 31504 186 15 conduct conduct NN 31504 186 16 rather rather RB 31504 186 17 than than IN 31504 186 18 a a DT 31504 186 19 disposition disposition NN 31504 186 20 or or CC 31504 186 21 state state NN 31504 186 22 of of IN 31504 186 23 mind mind NN 31504 186 24 , , , 31504 186 25 and and CC 31504 186 26 of of IN 31504 186 27 conduct conduct NN 31504 186 28 toward toward IN 31504 186 29 others other NNS 31504 186 30 rather rather RB 31504 186 31 than than IN 31504 186 32 of of IN 31504 186 33 conduct conduct NN 31504 186 34 toward toward IN 31504 186 35 one one PRP 31504 186 36 's 's POS 31504 186 37 self self NN 31504 186 38 . . . 31504 187 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 187 2 is be VBZ 31504 187 3 only only RB 31504 187 4 of of IN 31504 187 5 the the DT 31504 187 6 conduct conduct NN 31504 187 7 of of IN 31504 187 8 men man NNS 31504 187 9 in in IN 31504 187 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 187 11 relations relation NNS 31504 187 12 to to IN 31504 187 13 other other JJ 31504 187 14 men man NNS 31504 187 15 that that IN 31504 187 16 we -PRON- PRP 31504 187 17 can can MD 31504 187 18 predicate predicate VB 31504 187 19 justice justice NN 31504 187 20 or or CC 31504 187 21 injustice injustice NN 31504 187 22 . . . 31504 188 1 One one PRP 31504 188 2 's 's POS 31504 188 3 conduct conduct NN 31504 188 4 may may MD 31504 188 5 result result VB 31504 188 6 in in IN 31504 188 7 good good JJ 31504 188 8 or or CC 31504 188 9 evil evil NN 31504 188 10 to to IN 31504 188 11 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 188 12 and and CC 31504 188 13 so so RB 31504 188 14 be be VB 31504 188 15 wise wise JJ 31504 188 16 or or CC 31504 188 17 unwise unwise JJ 31504 188 18 , , , 31504 188 19 but but CC 31504 188 20 assuming assume VBG 31504 188 21 , , , 31504 188 22 what what WP 31504 188 23 probably probably RB 31504 188 24 is be VBZ 31504 188 25 never never RB 31504 188 26 the the DT 31504 188 27 fact fact NN 31504 188 28 , , , 31504 188 29 that that IN 31504 188 30 it -PRON- PRP 31504 188 31 affects affect VBZ 31504 188 32 only only RB 31504 188 33 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 188 34 , , , 31504 188 35 in in IN 31504 188 36 no no DT 31504 188 37 way way NN 31504 188 38 affects affect VBZ 31504 188 39 any any DT 31504 188 40 other other JJ 31504 188 41 , , , 31504 188 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 188 43 conduct conduct NN 31504 188 44 is be VBZ 31504 188 45 neither neither CC 31504 188 46 just just RB 31504 188 47 nor nor CC 31504 188 48 unjust unjust JJ 31504 188 49 . . . 31504 189 1 Robinson Robinson NNP 31504 189 2 Crusoe Crusoe NNP 31504 189 3 , , , 31504 189 4 until until IN 31504 189 5 the the DT 31504 189 6 arrival arrival NN 31504 189 7 of of IN 31504 189 8 the the DT 31504 189 9 man man NN 31504 189 10 Friday Friday NNP 31504 189 11 , , , 31504 189 12 had have VBD 31504 189 13 no no DT 31504 189 14 occasion occasion NN 31504 189 15 to to TO 31504 189 16 consider consider VB 31504 189 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 189 18 problem problem NN 31504 189 19 . . . 31504 190 1 But but CC 31504 190 2 , , , 31504 190 3 admitting admit VBG 31504 190 4 that that IN 31504 190 5 each each DT 31504 190 6 man man NN 31504 190 7 's 's POS 31504 190 8 conduct conduct NN 31504 190 9 , , , 31504 190 10 whether whether IN 31504 190 11 active active JJ 31504 190 12 or or CC 31504 190 13 passive passive JJ 31504 190 14 , , , 31504 190 15 does do VBZ 31504 190 16 affect affect VB 31504 190 17 some some DT 31504 190 18 other other JJ 31504 190 19 person person NN 31504 190 20 , , , 31504 190 21 what what WP 31504 190 22 is be VBZ 31504 190 23 the the DT 31504 190 24 criterion criterion NN 31504 190 25 by by IN 31504 190 26 which which WDT 31504 190 27 to to TO 31504 190 28 determine determine VB 31504 190 29 the the DT 31504 190 30 justice justice NN 31504 190 31 or or CC 31504 190 32 injustice injustice NN 31504 190 33 of of IN 31504 190 34 that that DT 31504 190 35 conduct conduct NN 31504 190 36 ? ? . 31504 191 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 191 2 is be VBZ 31504 191 3 not not RB 31504 191 4 enough enough JJ 31504 191 5 to to TO 31504 191 6 say say VB 31504 191 7 that that IN 31504 191 8 if if IN 31504 191 9 the the DT 31504 191 10 conduct conduct NN 31504 191 11 in in IN 31504 191 12 any any DT 31504 191 13 degree degree NN 31504 191 14 impedes impede VBZ 31504 191 15 the the DT 31504 191 16 other other JJ 31504 191 17 person person NN 31504 191 18 in in IN 31504 191 19 the the DT 31504 191 20 enjoyment enjoyment NN 31504 191 21 of of IN 31504 191 22 any any DT 31504 191 23 of of IN 31504 191 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 191 25 rights right NNS 31504 191 26 it -PRON- PRP 31504 191 27 is be VBZ 31504 191 28 unjust unjust JJ 31504 191 29 , , , 31504 191 30 otherwise otherwise RB 31504 191 31 not not RB 31504 191 32 ; ; : 31504 191 33 for for IN 31504 191 34 then then RB 31504 191 35 the the DT 31504 191 36 question question NN 31504 191 37 comes come VBZ 31504 191 38 to to IN 31504 191 39 the the DT 31504 191 40 front front NN 31504 191 41 , , , 31504 191 42 what what WP 31504 191 43 is be VBZ 31504 191 44 the the DT 31504 191 45 right right NN 31504 191 46 of of IN 31504 191 47 that that DT 31504 191 48 other other JJ 31504 191 49 in in IN 31504 191 50 the the DT 31504 191 51 given give VBN 31504 191 52 case case NN 31504 191 53 ? ? . 31504 192 1 Indeed indeed RB 31504 192 2 , , , 31504 192 3 this this DT 31504 192 4 latter latter JJ 31504 192 5 question question NN 31504 192 6 is be VBZ 31504 192 7 the the DT 31504 192 8 crux crux NN 31504 192 9 of of IN 31504 192 10 the the DT 31504 192 11 problem problem NN 31504 192 12 of of IN 31504 192 13 justice justice NN 31504 192 14 . . . 31504 193 1 The the DT 31504 193 2 derivation derivation NN 31504 193 3 of of IN 31504 193 4 the the DT 31504 193 5 word word NN 31504 193 6 " " `` 31504 193 7 justice justice NN 31504 193 8 " " '' 31504 193 9 also also RB 31504 193 10 shows show VBZ 31504 193 11 this this DT 31504 193 12 . . . 31504 194 1 The the DT 31504 194 2 Latin Latin NNP 31504 194 3 _ _ NNP 31504 194 4 justitia justitia NN 31504 194 5 _ _ NNP 31504 194 6 or or CC 31504 194 7 _ _ NNP 31504 194 8 justitium justitium NN 31504 194 9 _ _ NNP 31504 194 10 according accord VBG 31504 194 11 to to IN 31504 194 12 some some DT 31504 194 13 scholars scholar NNS 31504 194 14 is be VBZ 31504 194 15 compounded compound VBN 31504 194 16 of of IN 31504 194 17 _ _ NNP 31504 194 18 jus jus NNP 31504 194 19 _ _ NNP 31504 194 20 , , , 31504 194 21 right right UH 31504 194 22 , , , 31504 194 23 and and CC 31504 194 24 _ _ NNP 31504 194 25 sisto sisto NN 31504 194 26 _ _ NNP 31504 194 27 or or CC 31504 194 28 _ _ NNP 31504 194 29 steti steti NN 31504 194 30 _ _ NNP 31504 194 31 , , , 31504 194 32 to to IN 31504 194 33 place place VB 31504 194 34 , , , 31504 194 35 or or CC 31504 194 36 to to TO 31504 194 37 cause cause VB 31504 194 38 to to TO 31504 194 39 stand stand VB 31504 194 40 , , , 31504 194 41 and and CC 31504 194 42 hence hence RB 31504 194 43 the the DT 31504 194 44 whole whole JJ 31504 194 45 word word NN 31504 194 46 may may MD 31504 194 47 be be VB 31504 194 48 held hold VBN 31504 194 49 to to TO 31504 194 50 signify signify VB 31504 194 51 the the DT 31504 194 52 maintenance maintenance NN 31504 194 53 of of IN 31504 194 54 _ _ NNP 31504 194 55 jus jus NNP 31504 194 56 _ _ NNP 31504 194 57 or or CC 31504 194 58 right right JJ 31504 194 59 . . . 31504 195 1 With with IN 31504 195 2 the the DT 31504 195 3 question question NN 31504 195 4 of of IN 31504 195 5 _ _ NNP 31504 195 6 jus jus NNP 31504 195 7 _ _ NNP 31504 195 8 or or CC 31504 195 9 right right RB 31504 195 10 correctly correctly RB 31504 195 11 answered answer VBD 31504 195 12 , , , 31504 195 13 the the DT 31504 195 14 problem problem NN 31504 195 15 of of IN 31504 195 16 justice justice NN 31504 195 17 is be VBZ 31504 195 18 practically practically RB 31504 195 19 solved solve VBN 31504 195 20 . . . 31504 196 1 The the DT 31504 196 2 right right NN 31504 196 3 of of IN 31504 196 4 the the DT 31504 196 5 one one NN 31504 196 6 being be VBG 31504 196 7 known know VBN 31504 196 8 , , , 31504 196 9 the the DT 31504 196 10 effect effect NN 31504 196 11 of of IN 31504 196 12 any any DT 31504 196 13 particular particular JJ 31504 196 14 conduct conduct NN 31504 196 15 of of IN 31504 196 16 another another DT 31504 196 17 on on IN 31504 196 18 that that DT 31504 196 19 right right NN 31504 196 20 , , , 31504 196 21 and and CC 31504 196 22 consequently consequently RB 31504 196 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 196 24 justice justice NN 31504 196 25 or or CC 31504 196 26 injustice injustice NN 31504 196 27 , , , 31504 196 28 is be VBZ 31504 196 29 determinable determinable JJ 31504 196 30 with with IN 31504 196 31 comparative comparative JJ 31504 196 32 ease ease NN 31504 196 33 . . . 31504 197 1 Hence hence RB 31504 197 2 to to TO 31504 197 3 make make VB 31504 197 4 progress progress NN 31504 197 5 in in IN 31504 197 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 197 7 inquiry inquiry NN 31504 197 8 we -PRON- PRP 31504 197 9 must must MD 31504 197 10 consider consider VB 31504 197 11 the the DT 31504 197 12 problem problem NN 31504 197 13 of of IN 31504 197 14 rights right NNS 31504 197 15 , , , 31504 197 16 for for IN 31504 197 17 we -PRON- PRP 31504 197 18 almost almost RB 31504 197 19 instinctively instinctively RB 31504 197 20 accept accept VBP 31504 197 21 as as IN 31504 197 22 correct correct JJ 31504 197 23 so so RB 31504 197 24 much much JJ 31504 197 25 of of IN 31504 197 26 Ulpian Ulpian NNP 31504 197 27 's 's POS 31504 197 28 definition definition NN 31504 197 29 as as IN 31504 197 30 implies imply VBZ 31504 197 31 that that IN 31504 197 32 justice justice NN 31504 197 33 is be VBZ 31504 197 34 to to TO 31504 197 35 be be VB 31504 197 36 predicated predicate VBN 31504 197 37 of of IN 31504 197 38 the the DT 31504 197 39 act act NN 31504 197 40 of of IN 31504 197 41 rendering render VBG 31504 197 42 to to IN 31504 197 43 everyone everyone NN 31504 197 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 197 45 right right NN 31504 197 46 . . . 31504 198 1 We -PRON- PRP 31504 198 2 instinctively instinctively RB 31504 198 3 feel feel VBP 31504 198 4 that that IN 31504 198 5 if if IN 31504 198 6 we -PRON- PRP 31504 198 7 render render VBP 31504 198 8 to to IN 31504 198 9 another another DT 31504 198 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 198 11 full full JJ 31504 198 12 right right NN 31504 198 13 we -PRON- PRP 31504 198 14 do do VBP 31504 198 15 him -PRON- PRP 31504 198 16 full full JJ 31504 198 17 justice justice NN 31504 198 18 , , , 31504 198 19 and and CC 31504 198 20 that that IN 31504 198 21 if if IN 31504 198 22 we -PRON- PRP 31504 198 23 ourselves -PRON- PRP 31504 198 24 are be VBP 31504 198 25 deprived deprive VBN 31504 198 26 of of IN 31504 198 27 any any DT 31504 198 28 right right NN 31504 198 29 we -PRON- PRP 31504 198 30 suffer suffer VBP 31504 198 31 injustice injustice NN 31504 198 32 . . . 31504 199 1 What what WP 31504 199 2 is be VBZ 31504 199 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 199 4 or or CC 31504 199 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 199 6 right right NN 31504 199 7 is be VBZ 31504 199 8 therefore therefore RB 31504 199 9 the the DT 31504 199 10 real real JJ 31504 199 11 question question NN 31504 199 12 . . . 31504 200 1 This this DT 31504 200 2 will will MD 31504 200 3 be be VB 31504 200 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 200 5 next next JJ 31504 200 6 subject subject NN 31504 200 7 for for IN 31504 200 8 consideration consideration NN 31504 200 9 . . . 31504 201 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31504 201 2 II II NNP 31504 201 3 THE the DT 31504 201 4 PROBLEM problem NN 31504 201 5 OF of IN 31504 201 6 RIGHTS right NNS 31504 201 7 . . . 31504 202 1 DIFFERENT DIFFERENT NNP 31504 202 2 THEORIES theory NNS 31504 202 3 AS as IN 31504 202 4 TO to IN 31504 202 5 THE the DT 31504 202 6 SOURCE SOURCE NNP 31504 202 7 OF of IN 31504 202 8 RIGHTS RIGHTS NNP 31504 202 9 The the DT 31504 202 10 problem problem NN 31504 202 11 of of IN 31504 202 12 Rights right NNS 31504 202 13 is be VBZ 31504 202 14 also also RB 31504 202 15 centuries century NNS 31504 202 16 old old JJ 31504 202 17 . . . 31504 203 1 There there EX 31504 203 2 have have VBP 31504 203 3 been be VBN 31504 203 4 in in IN 31504 203 5 later later JJ 31504 203 6 years year NNS 31504 203 7 glowing glow VBG 31504 203 8 tributes tribute NNS 31504 203 9 to to IN 31504 203 10 human human JJ 31504 203 11 rights right NNS 31504 203 12 even even RB 31504 203 13 more more RBR 31504 203 14 than than IN 31504 203 15 to to IN 31504 203 16 justice justice NN 31504 203 17 , , , 31504 203 18 though though IN 31504 203 19 the the DT 31504 203 20 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 203 21 of of IN 31504 203 22 rights right NNS 31504 203 23 is be VBZ 31504 203 24 egoistic egoistic JJ 31504 203 25 , , , 31504 203 26 while while IN 31504 203 27 that that DT 31504 203 28 of of IN 31504 203 29 justice justice NN 31504 203 30 is be VBZ 31504 203 31 in in IN 31504 203 32 some some DT 31504 203 33 measure measure NN 31504 203 34 altruistic altruistic JJ 31504 203 35 . . . 31504 204 1 There there EX 31504 204 2 have have VBP 31504 204 3 also also RB 31504 204 4 been be VBN 31504 204 5 diverse diverse JJ 31504 204 6 opinions opinion NNS 31504 204 7 in in IN 31504 204 8 the the DT 31504 204 9 past past NN 31504 204 10 , , , 31504 204 11 as as RB 31504 204 12 now now RB 31504 204 13 , , , 31504 204 14 as as IN 31504 204 15 to to IN 31504 204 16 the the DT 31504 204 17 source source NN 31504 204 18 , , , 31504 204 19 foundation foundation NN 31504 204 20 , , , 31504 204 21 and and CC 31504 204 22 nature nature NN 31504 204 23 of of IN 31504 204 24 what what WP 31504 204 25 are be VBP 31504 204 26 called call VBN 31504 204 27 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 204 28 , , , 31504 204 29 as as IN 31504 204 30 there there EX 31504 204 31 were be VBD 31504 204 32 and and CC 31504 204 33 are be VBP 31504 204 34 of of IN 31504 204 35 justice justice NN 31504 204 36 . . . 31504 205 1 A a DT 31504 205 2 brief brief JJ 31504 205 3 review review NN 31504 205 4 of of IN 31504 205 5 these these DT 31504 205 6 opinions opinion NNS 31504 205 7 and and CC 31504 205 8 of of IN 31504 205 9 the the DT 31504 205 10 changes change NNS 31504 205 11 in in IN 31504 205 12 them -PRON- PRP 31504 205 13 may may MD 31504 205 14 present present VB 31504 205 15 the the DT 31504 205 16 problem problem NN 31504 205 17 more more RBR 31504 205 18 vividly vividly RB 31504 205 19 . . . 31504 206 1 In in IN 31504 206 2 patriarchal patriarchal JJ 31504 206 3 times time NNS 31504 206 4 there there EX 31504 206 5 could could MD 31504 206 6 be be VB 31504 206 7 no no DT 31504 206 8 political political JJ 31504 206 9 questions question NNS 31504 206 10 about about IN 31504 206 11 rights right NNS 31504 206 12 . . . 31504 207 1 The the DT 31504 207 2 head head NN 31504 207 3 of of IN 31504 207 4 the the DT 31504 207 5 family family NN 31504 207 6 was be VBD 31504 207 7 supreme supreme NNP 31504 207 8 and and CC 31504 207 9 sole sole JJ 31504 207 10 ruler ruler NN 31504 207 11 and and CC 31504 207 12 judge judge NN 31504 207 13 . . . 31504 208 1 Even even RB 31504 208 2 in in IN 31504 208 3 Rome Rome NNP 31504 208 4 under under IN 31504 208 5 an an DT 31504 208 6 organized organize VBN 31504 208 7 civil civil JJ 31504 208 8 government government NN 31504 208 9 the the DT 31504 208 10 pater pater NN 31504 208 11 familias familias NNP 31504 208 12 was be VBD 31504 208 13 long long RB 31504 208 14 left leave VBN 31504 208 15 the the DT 31504 208 16 power power NN 31504 208 17 of of IN 31504 208 18 life life NN 31504 208 19 and and CC 31504 208 20 death death NN 31504 208 21 over over IN 31504 208 22 the the DT 31504 208 23 members member NNS 31504 208 24 of of IN 31504 208 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 208 26 family family NN 31504 208 27 . . . 31504 209 1 When when WRB 31504 209 2 families family NNS 31504 209 3 and and CC 31504 209 4 tribes tribe NNS 31504 209 5 were be VBD 31504 209 6 combined combine VBN 31504 209 7 in in IN 31504 209 8 states state NNS 31504 209 9 , , , 31504 209 10 government government NN 31504 209 11 was be VBD 31504 209 12 long long RB 31504 209 13 conducted conduct VBN 31504 209 14 on on IN 31504 209 15 the the DT 31504 209 16 theory theory NN 31504 209 17 that that IN 31504 209 18 as as IN 31504 209 19 the the DT 31504 209 20 individual individual NN 31504 209 21 had have VBD 31504 209 22 belonged belong VBN 31504 209 23 to to IN 31504 209 24 the the DT 31504 209 25 family family NN 31504 209 26 or or CC 31504 209 27 tribe tribe NN 31504 209 28 into into IN 31504 209 29 which which WDT 31504 209 30 he -PRON- PRP 31504 209 31 was be VBD 31504 209 32 born bear VBN 31504 209 33 or or CC 31504 209 34 adopted adopt VBN 31504 209 35 , , , 31504 209 36 so so RB 31504 209 37 he -PRON- PRP 31504 209 38 now now RB 31504 209 39 belonged belong VBD 31504 209 40 to to IN 31504 209 41 the the DT 31504 209 42 state state NN 31504 209 43 , , , 31504 209 44 to to TO 31504 209 45 be be VB 31504 209 46 directed direct VBN 31504 209 47 and and CC 31504 209 48 disposed dispose VBN 31504 209 49 of of IN 31504 209 50 as as IN 31504 209 51 the the DT 31504 209 52 state state NN 31504 209 53 might may MD 31504 209 54 order order VB 31504 209 55 . . . 31504 210 1 What what WP 31504 210 2 he -PRON- PRP 31504 210 3 might may MD 31504 210 4 enjoy enjoy VB 31504 210 5 of of IN 31504 210 6 life life NN 31504 210 7 , , , 31504 210 8 liberty liberty NN 31504 210 9 , , , 31504 210 10 or or CC 31504 210 11 property property NN 31504 210 12 was be VBD 31504 210 13 the the DT 31504 210 14 gift gift NN 31504 210 15 of of IN 31504 210 16 the the DT 31504 210 17 state state NN 31504 210 18 , , , 31504 210 19 subject subject JJ 31504 210 20 to to IN 31504 210 21 revocation revocation NN 31504 210 22 at at IN 31504 210 23 will will NN 31504 210 24 . . . 31504 211 1 Plato Plato NNP 31504 211 2 reflects reflect VBZ 31504 211 3 this this DT 31504 211 4 theory theory NN 31504 211 5 in in IN 31504 211 6 making make VBG 31504 211 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 31504 211 8 declare declare VB 31504 211 9 that that IN 31504 211 10 the the DT 31504 211 11 measure measure NN 31504 211 12 of of IN 31504 211 13 man man NN 31504 211 14 's 's POS 31504 211 15 right right NN 31504 211 16 is be VBZ 31504 211 17 what what WP 31504 211 18 the the DT 31504 211 19 state state NN 31504 211 20 commands command VBZ 31504 211 21 . . . 31504 212 1 The the DT 31504 212 2 total total JJ 31504 212 3 abolition abolition NN 31504 212 4 of of IN 31504 212 5 the the DT 31504 212 6 liberty liberty NN 31504 212 7 of of IN 31504 212 8 innocent innocent JJ 31504 212 9 persons person NNS 31504 212 10 by by IN 31504 212 11 holding hold VBG 31504 212 12 them -PRON- PRP 31504 212 13 in in IN 31504 212 14 slavery slavery NN 31504 212 15 was be VBD 31504 212 16 not not RB 31504 212 17 deemed deem VBN 31504 212 18 any any DT 31504 212 19 infringement infringement NN 31504 212 20 of of IN 31504 212 21 any any DT 31504 212 22 right right NN 31504 212 23 of of IN 31504 212 24 theirs -PRON- PRP 31504 212 25 . . . 31504 213 1 This this DT 31504 213 2 theory theory NN 31504 213 3 was be VBD 31504 213 4 acted act VBN 31504 213 5 upon upon IN 31504 213 6 in in IN 31504 213 7 democratic democratic JJ 31504 213 8 as as RB 31504 213 9 well well RB 31504 213 10 as as IN 31504 213 11 in in IN 31504 213 12 monarchical monarchical JJ 31504 213 13 states state NNS 31504 213 14 . . . 31504 214 1 Slavery Slavery NNP 31504 214 2 was be VBD 31504 214 3 as as RB 31504 214 4 lawful lawful JJ 31504 214 5 in in IN 31504 214 6 Athens Athens NNP 31504 214 7 , , , 31504 214 8 Sparta Sparta NNP 31504 214 9 , , , 31504 214 10 and and CC 31504 214 11 republican republican NNP 31504 214 12 Rome Rome NNP 31504 214 13 as as IN 31504 214 14 in in IN 31504 214 15 Persia Persia NNP 31504 214 16 or or CC 31504 214 17 Egypt Egypt NNP 31504 214 18 . . . 31504 215 1 True true JJ 31504 215 2 , , , 31504 215 3 there there EX 31504 215 4 were be VBD 31504 215 5 rebellions rebellion NNS 31504 215 6 and and CC 31504 215 7 revolutions revolution NNS 31504 215 8 at at IN 31504 215 9 times time NNS 31504 215 10 , , , 31504 215 11 but but CC 31504 215 12 , , , 31504 215 13 though though IN 31504 215 14 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 215 15 provoked provoke VBN 31504 215 16 by by IN 31504 215 17 oppression oppression NN 31504 215 18 , , , 31504 215 19 they -PRON- PRP 31504 215 20 were be VBD 31504 215 21 usually usually RB 31504 215 22 to to TO 31504 215 23 acquire acquire VB 31504 215 24 the the DT 31504 215 25 power power NN 31504 215 26 of of IN 31504 215 27 government government NN 31504 215 28 and and CC 31504 215 29 not not RB 31504 215 30 in in IN 31504 215 31 defense defense NN 31504 215 32 of of IN 31504 215 33 individual individual JJ 31504 215 34 rights right NNS 31504 215 35 . . . 31504 216 1 The the DT 31504 216 2 Plebeians Plebeians NNPS 31504 216 3 revolted revolt VBD 31504 216 4 to to TO 31504 216 5 obtain obtain VB 31504 216 6 a a DT 31504 216 7 greater great JJR 31504 216 8 share share NN 31504 216 9 in in IN 31504 216 10 the the DT 31504 216 11 governing govern VBG 31504 216 12 power power NN 31504 216 13 . . . 31504 217 1 The the DT 31504 217 2 civil civil JJ 31504 217 3 wars war NNS 31504 217 4 of of IN 31504 217 5 Marius Marius NNP 31504 217 6 and and CC 31504 217 7 Sulla Sulla NNP 31504 217 8 were be VBD 31504 217 9 not not RB 31504 217 10 waged wage VBN 31504 217 11 for for IN 31504 217 12 liberty liberty NN 31504 217 13 but but CC 31504 217 14 for for IN 31504 217 15 power power NN 31504 217 16 . . . 31504 218 1 In in IN 31504 218 2 Sicily Sicily NNP 31504 218 3 , , , 31504 218 4 where where WRB 31504 218 5 the the DT 31504 218 6 slaves slave NNS 31504 218 7 under under IN 31504 218 8 Eunus Eunus NNP 31504 218 9 had have VBD 31504 218 10 for for IN 31504 218 11 a a DT 31504 218 12 time time NN 31504 218 13 wrested wrest VBD 31504 218 14 the the DT 31504 218 15 governing govern VBG 31504 218 16 power power NN 31504 218 17 from from IN 31504 218 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 218 19 masters master NNS 31504 218 20 , , , 31504 218 21 they -PRON- PRP 31504 218 22 did do VBD 31504 218 23 not not RB 31504 218 24 hesitate hesitate VB 31504 218 25 to to TO 31504 218 26 enslave enslave VB 31504 218 27 in in IN 31504 218 28 turn turn NN 31504 218 29 . . . 31504 219 1 The the DT 31504 219 2 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 219 3 that that IN 31504 219 4 the the DT 31504 219 5 individual individual JJ 31504 219 6 man man NN 31504 219 7 has have VBZ 31504 219 8 some some DT 31504 219 9 rights right NNS 31504 219 10 by by IN 31504 219 11 nature nature NN 31504 219 12 which which WDT 31504 219 13 the the DT 31504 219 14 state state NN 31504 219 15 ought ought MD 31504 219 16 not not RB 31504 219 17 to to TO 31504 219 18 disregard disregard VB 31504 219 19 had have VBD 31504 219 20 no no DT 31504 219 21 place place NN 31504 219 22 in in IN 31504 219 23 ancient ancient JJ 31504 219 24 nor nor CC 31504 219 25 medieval medieval JJ 31504 219 26 governments government NNS 31504 219 27 . . . 31504 220 1 The the DT 31504 220 2 English English NNP 31504 220 3 Magna Magna NNPS 31504 220 4 Charta Charta NNP 31504 220 5 purports purport VBZ 31504 220 6 to to TO 31504 220 7 be be VB 31504 220 8 a a DT 31504 220 9 grant grant NN 31504 220 10 from from IN 31504 220 11 the the DT 31504 220 12 king king NN 31504 220 13 and and CC 31504 220 14 , , , 31504 220 15 though though IN 31504 220 16 framed frame VBN 31504 220 17 by by IN 31504 220 18 the the DT 31504 220 19 barons baron NNS 31504 220 20 and and CC 31504 220 21 forced force VBN 31504 220 22 upon upon IN 31504 220 23 the the DT 31504 220 24 king king NN 31504 220 25 , , , 31504 220 26 it -PRON- PRP 31504 220 27 contains contain VBZ 31504 220 28 no no DT 31504 220 29 assertion assertion NN 31504 220 30 of of IN 31504 220 31 rights right NNS 31504 220 32 by by IN 31504 220 33 nature nature NN 31504 220 34 . . . 31504 221 1 The the DT 31504 221 2 rights right NNS 31504 221 3 claimed claim VBD 31504 221 4 were be VBD 31504 221 5 claimed claim VBN 31504 221 6 as as IN 31504 221 7 accustomed accustomed JJ 31504 221 8 rights right NNS 31504 221 9 previously previously RB 31504 221 10 conferred confer VBN 31504 221 11 and and CC 31504 221 12 enjoyed enjoy VBD 31504 221 13 , , , 31504 221 14 such such JJ 31504 221 15 as as IN 31504 221 16 the the DT 31504 221 17 laws law NNS 31504 221 18 and and CC 31504 221 19 customs custom NNS 31504 221 20 of of IN 31504 221 21 the the DT 31504 221 22 time time NN 31504 221 23 of of IN 31504 221 24 Henry Henry NNP 31504 221 25 I. I. NNP 31504 222 1 Apart apart RB 31504 222 2 from from IN 31504 222 3 provisions provision NNS 31504 222 4 as as IN 31504 222 5 to to IN 31504 222 6 improved improve VBN 31504 222 7 methods method NNS 31504 222 8 of of IN 31504 222 9 administration administration NN 31504 222 10 , , , 31504 222 11 the the DT 31504 222 12 language language NN 31504 222 13 of of IN 31504 222 14 the the DT 31504 222 15 Charter Charter NNP 31504 222 16 implies imply VBZ 31504 222 17 restoration restoration NN 31504 222 18 rather rather RB 31504 222 19 than than IN 31504 222 20 revolution revolution NN 31504 222 21 . . . 31504 223 1 So so RB 31504 223 2 in in IN 31504 223 3 the the DT 31504 223 4 Petition Petition NNP 31504 223 5 of of IN 31504 223 6 Right Right NNP 31504 223 7 in in IN 31504 223 8 the the DT 31504 223 9 reign reign NN 31504 223 10 of of IN 31504 223 11 Charles Charles NNP 31504 223 12 I I NNP 31504 223 13 , , , 31504 223 14 no no DT 31504 223 15 appeal appeal NN 31504 223 16 was be VBD 31504 223 17 made make VBN 31504 223 18 to to IN 31504 223 19 natural natural JJ 31504 223 20 rights right NNS 31504 223 21 , , , 31504 223 22 but but CC 31504 223 23 the the DT 31504 223 24 demand demand NN 31504 223 25 was be VBD 31504 223 26 for for IN 31504 223 27 accustomed accustomed JJ 31504 223 28 privileges privilege NNS 31504 223 29 , , , 31504 223 30 for for IN 31504 223 31 the the DT 31504 223 32 observance observance NN 31504 223 33 by by IN 31504 223 34 the the DT 31504 223 35 king king NN 31504 223 36 of of IN 31504 223 37 the the DT 31504 223 38 old old JJ 31504 223 39 laws law NNS 31504 223 40 and and CC 31504 223 41 customs custom NNS 31504 223 42 of of IN 31504 223 43 the the DT 31504 223 44 realm realm NN 31504 223 45 , , , 31504 223 46 especially especially RB 31504 223 47 those those DT 31504 223 48 in in IN 31504 223 49 force force NN 31504 223 50 under under IN 31504 223 51 Edward Edward NNP 31504 223 52 I I NNP 31504 223 53 and and CC 31504 223 54 Edward Edward NNP 31504 223 55 III III NNP 31504 223 56 . . . 31504 224 1 In in IN 31504 224 2 the the DT 31504 224 3 Petition Petition NNP 31504 224 4 , , , 31504 224 5 the the DT 31504 224 6 Charter Charter NNP 31504 224 7 of of IN 31504 224 8 King King NNP 31504 224 9 John John NNP 31504 224 10 is be VBZ 31504 224 11 cited cite VBN 31504 224 12 , , , 31504 224 13 not not RB 31504 224 14 as as IN 31504 224 15 a a DT 31504 224 16 schedule schedule NN 31504 224 17 of of IN 31504 224 18 the the DT 31504 224 19 rights right NNS 31504 224 20 of of IN 31504 224 21 man man NN 31504 224 22 in in IN 31504 224 23 the the DT 31504 224 24 abstract abstract NN 31504 224 25 , , , 31504 224 26 but but CC 31504 224 27 as as IN 31504 224 28 " " `` 31504 224 29 The the DT 31504 224 30 Great Great NNP 31504 224 31 Charter Charter NNP 31504 224 32 of of IN 31504 224 33 the the DT 31504 224 34 Liberties Liberties NNPS 31504 224 35 of of IN 31504 224 36 England England NNP 31504 224 37 , , , 31504 224 38 " " '' 31504 224 39 implying imply VBG 31504 224 40 that that IN 31504 224 41 the the DT 31504 224 42 liberties liberty NNS 31504 224 43 therein therein RB 31504 224 44 named name VBN 31504 224 45 were be VBD 31504 224 46 not not RB 31504 224 47 the the DT 31504 224 48 natural natural JJ 31504 224 49 heritage heritage NN 31504 224 50 of of IN 31504 224 51 men man NNS 31504 224 52 in in IN 31504 224 53 general general JJ 31504 224 54 but but CC 31504 224 55 the the DT 31504 224 56 peculiar peculiar JJ 31504 224 57 heritage heritage NN 31504 224 58 of of IN 31504 224 59 Englishmen Englishmen NNP 31504 224 60 , , , 31504 224 61 under under IN 31504 224 62 English english JJ 31504 224 63 law law NN 31504 224 64 . . . 31504 225 1 The the DT 31504 225 2 prayer prayer NN 31504 225 3 of of IN 31504 225 4 the the DT 31504 225 5 Petition Petition NNP 31504 225 6 is be VBZ 31504 225 7 simply simply RB 31504 225 8 that that IN 31504 225 9 the the DT 31504 225 10 king king NN 31504 225 11 shall shall MD 31504 225 12 accord accord VB 31504 225 13 the the DT 31504 225 14 people people NNS 31504 225 15 of of IN 31504 225 16 England England NNP 31504 225 17 " " '' 31504 225 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 225 19 rights right NNS 31504 225 20 and and CC 31504 225 21 liberties liberty NNS 31504 225 22 according accord VBG 31504 225 23 to to IN 31504 225 24 the the DT 31504 225 25 laws law NNS 31504 225 26 and and CC 31504 225 27 statutes statute NNS 31504 225 28 of of IN 31504 225 29 the the DT 31504 225 30 realm realm NN 31504 225 31 . . . 31504 225 32 " " '' 31504 226 1 So so RB 31504 226 2 in in IN 31504 226 3 the the DT 31504 226 4 Bill Bill NNP 31504 226 5 of of IN 31504 226 6 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 226 7 framed frame VBN 31504 226 8 by by IN 31504 226 9 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 226 10 and and CC 31504 226 11 approved approve VBN 31504 226 12 by by IN 31504 226 13 William William NNP 31504 226 14 and and CC 31504 226 15 Mary Mary NNP 31504 226 16 upon upon IN 31504 226 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 226 18 accession accession NN 31504 226 19 to to IN 31504 226 20 the the DT 31504 226 21 throne throne NN 31504 226 22 , , , 31504 226 23 it -PRON- PRP 31504 226 24 was be VBD 31504 226 25 not not RB 31504 226 26 asserted assert VBN 31504 226 27 that that IN 31504 226 28 the the DT 31504 226 29 acts act NNS 31504 226 30 of of IN 31504 226 31 James James NNP 31504 226 32 II II NNP 31504 226 33 complained complain VBD 31504 226 34 of of IN 31504 226 35 were be VBD 31504 226 36 contrary contrary JJ 31504 226 37 to to IN 31504 226 38 any any DT 31504 226 39 natural natural JJ 31504 226 40 right right NN 31504 226 41 of of IN 31504 226 42 the the DT 31504 226 43 subject subject NN 31504 226 44 , , , 31504 226 45 but but CC 31504 226 46 that that IN 31504 226 47 they -PRON- PRP 31504 226 48 " " `` 31504 226 49 were be VBD 31504 226 50 utterly utterly RB 31504 226 51 and and CC 31504 226 52 directly directly RB 31504 226 53 contrary contrary JJ 31504 226 54 to to IN 31504 226 55 the the DT 31504 226 56 known know VBN 31504 226 57 laws law NNS 31504 226 58 and and CC 31504 226 59 statutes statute NNS 31504 226 60 and and CC 31504 226 61 freedom freedom NN 31504 226 62 of of IN 31504 226 63 this this DT 31504 226 64 realm realm NN 31504 226 65 . . . 31504 226 66 " " '' 31504 227 1 The the DT 31504 227 2 purpose purpose NN 31504 227 3 of of IN 31504 227 4 the the DT 31504 227 5 Bill Bill NNP 31504 227 6 of of IN 31504 227 7 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 227 8 was be VBD 31504 227 9 declared declare VBN 31504 227 10 by by IN 31504 227 11 the the DT 31504 227 12 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 227 13 in in IN 31504 227 14 behalf behalf NN 31504 227 15 of of IN 31504 227 16 the the DT 31504 227 17 people people NNS 31504 227 18 to to TO 31504 227 19 be be VB 31504 227 20 " " `` 31504 227 21 for for IN 31504 227 22 the the DT 31504 227 23 vindicating vindicate VBG 31504 227 24 and and CC 31504 227 25 asserting assert VBG 31504 227 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 227 27 ancient ancient JJ 31504 227 28 rights right NNS 31504 227 29 and and CC 31504 227 30 liberties liberty NNS 31504 227 31 . . . 31504 227 32 " " '' 31504 228 1 In in IN 31504 228 2 the the DT 31504 228 3 earlier early JJR 31504 228 4 remonstrances remonstrance NNS 31504 228 5 of of IN 31504 228 6 the the DT 31504 228 7 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 228 8 of of IN 31504 228 9 the the DT 31504 228 10 English english JJ 31504 228 11 colonies colony NNS 31504 228 12 in in IN 31504 228 13 America America NNP 31504 228 14 against against IN 31504 228 15 various various JJ 31504 228 16 acts act NNS 31504 228 17 of of IN 31504 228 18 the the DT 31504 228 19 king king NN 31504 228 20 and and CC 31504 228 21 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 228 22 , , , 31504 228 23 only only RB 31504 228 24 the the DT 31504 228 25 accustomed accustomed JJ 31504 228 26 rights right NNS 31504 228 27 of of IN 31504 228 28 Englishmen englishman NNS 31504 228 29 were be VBD 31504 228 30 claimed claim VBN 31504 228 31 to to TO 31504 228 32 be be VB 31504 228 33 violated violate VBN 31504 228 34 . . . 31504 229 1 The the DT 31504 229 2 colonists colonist NNS 31504 229 3 , , , 31504 229 4 at at IN 31504 229 5 first first RB 31504 229 6 , , , 31504 229 7 claimed claim VBD 31504 229 8 as as IN 31504 229 9 against against IN 31504 229 10 king king NN 31504 229 11 and and CC 31504 229 12 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 229 13 no no DT 31504 229 14 rights right NNS 31504 229 15 not not RB 31504 229 16 accorded accord VBN 31504 229 17 to to IN 31504 229 18 Englishmen Englishmen NNP 31504 229 19 in in IN 31504 229 20 England England NNP 31504 229 21 . . . 31504 230 1 But but CC 31504 230 2 though though IN 31504 230 3 the the DT 31504 230 4 notion notion NN 31504 230 5 that that IN 31504 230 6 man man NN 31504 230 7 has have VBZ 31504 230 8 rights right NNS 31504 230 9 by by IN 31504 230 10 nature nature NN 31504 230 11 , , , 31504 230 12 not not RB 31504 230 13 granted grant VBN 31504 230 14 by by IN 31504 230 15 the the DT 31504 230 16 state state NN 31504 230 17 and and CC 31504 230 18 which which WDT 31504 230 19 the the DT 31504 230 20 state state NN 31504 230 21 should should MD 31504 230 22 respect respect VB 31504 230 23 as as IN 31504 230 24 such such JJ 31504 230 25 , , , 31504 230 26 did do VBD 31504 230 27 not not RB 31504 230 28 for for IN 31504 230 29 centuries century NNS 31504 230 30 find find VBP 31504 230 31 expression expression NN 31504 230 32 in in IN 31504 230 33 state state NN 31504 230 34 papers paper NNS 31504 230 35 or or CC 31504 230 36 state state NN 31504 230 37 action action NN 31504 230 38 , , , 31504 230 39 it -PRON- PRP 31504 230 40 was be VBD 31504 230 41 by by IN 31504 230 42 no no DT 31504 230 43 means means NN 31504 230 44 non non JJ 31504 230 45 - - JJ 31504 230 46 existent existent NN 31504 230 47 . . . 31504 231 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 231 2 was be VBD 31504 231 3 early early JJ 31504 231 4 in in IN 31504 231 5 the the DT 31504 231 6 minds mind NNS 31504 231 7 of of IN 31504 231 8 many many JJ 31504 231 9 and and CC 31504 231 10 found find VBD 31504 231 11 some some DT 31504 231 12 expression expression NN 31504 231 13 in in IN 31504 231 14 the the DT 31504 231 15 writings writing NNS 31504 231 16 of of IN 31504 231 17 jurists jurist NNS 31504 231 18 and and CC 31504 231 19 philosophers philosopher NNS 31504 231 20 . . . 31504 232 1 In in IN 31504 232 2 Rome Rome NNP 31504 232 3 it -PRON- PRP 31504 232 4 was be VBD 31504 232 5 a a DT 31504 232 6 corollary corollary NN 31504 232 7 of of IN 31504 232 8 the the DT 31504 232 9 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 232 10 of of IN 31504 232 11 the the DT 31504 232 12 existence existence NN 31504 232 13 of of IN 31504 232 14 a a DT 31504 232 15 _ _ NNP 31504 232 16 jus jus NNP 31504 232 17 naturale naturale JJ 31504 232 18 _ _ NNP 31504 232 19 . . . 31504 233 1 The the DT 31504 233 2 statement statement NN 31504 233 3 of of IN 31504 233 4 that that DT 31504 233 5 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 233 6 by by IN 31504 233 7 Ulpian Ulpian NNP 31504 233 8 incorporated incorporate VBD 31504 233 9 in in IN 31504 233 10 the the DT 31504 233 11 Digest Digest NNP 31504 233 12 implies imply VBZ 31504 233 13 a a DT 31504 233 14 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 233 15 that that DT 31504 233 16 man man NN 31504 233 17 does do VBZ 31504 233 18 have have VB 31504 233 19 some some DT 31504 233 20 rights right NNS 31504 233 21 anterior anterior NN 31504 233 22 to to IN 31504 233 23 and and CC 31504 233 24 independent independent JJ 31504 233 25 of of IN 31504 233 26 the the DT 31504 233 27 state state NN 31504 233 28 . . . 31504 234 1 So so RB 31504 234 2 far far RB 31504 234 3 , , , 31504 234 4 however however RB 31504 234 5 , , , 31504 234 6 as as IN 31504 234 7 the the DT 31504 234 8 statement statement NN 31504 234 9 was be VBD 31504 234 10 susceptible susceptible JJ 31504 234 11 of of IN 31504 234 12 that that DT 31504 234 13 construction construction NN 31504 234 14 it -PRON- PRP 31504 234 15 was be VBD 31504 234 16 not not RB 31504 234 17 generally generally RB 31504 234 18 acted act VBN 31504 234 19 upon upon IN 31504 234 20 and and CC 31504 234 21 remained remain VBD 31504 234 22 practically practically RB 31504 234 23 a a DT 31504 234 24 dead dead JJ 31504 234 25 letter letter NN 31504 234 26 . . . 31504 235 1 The the DT 31504 235 2 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 235 3 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 235 4 survived survive VBD 31504 235 5 , , , 31504 235 6 however however RB 31504 235 7 , , , 31504 235 8 engaging engage VBG 31504 235 9 the the DT 31504 235 10 attention attention NN 31504 235 11 and and CC 31504 235 12 receiving receive VBG 31504 235 13 the the DT 31504 235 14 support support NN 31504 235 15 of of IN 31504 235 16 various various JJ 31504 235 17 writers writer NNS 31504 235 18 . . . 31504 236 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 236 2 gradually gradually RB 31504 236 3 gained gain VBD 31504 236 4 ground ground NN 31504 236 5 among among IN 31504 236 6 students student NNS 31504 236 7 of of IN 31504 236 8 politics politic NNS 31504 236 9 and and CC 31504 236 10 spread spread VBD 31504 236 11 rapidly rapidly RB 31504 236 12 after after IN 31504 236 13 the the DT 31504 236 14 Protestant Protestant NNP 31504 236 15 Reformation Reformation NNP 31504 236 16 , , , 31504 236 17 so so RB 31504 236 18 - - HYPH 31504 236 19 called call VBN 31504 236 20 , , , 31504 236 21 because because IN 31504 236 22 of of IN 31504 236 23 the the DT 31504 236 24 impetus impetus NN 31504 236 25 given give VBN 31504 236 26 by by IN 31504 236 27 that that DT 31504 236 28 event event NN 31504 236 29 to to IN 31504 236 30 the the DT 31504 236 31 exercise exercise NN 31504 236 32 of of IN 31504 236 33 private private JJ 31504 236 34 judgment judgment NN 31504 236 35 . . . 31504 237 1 As as RB 31504 237 2 early early RB 31504 237 3 as as IN 31504 237 4 the the DT 31504 237 5 17th 17th JJ 31504 237 6 century century NN 31504 237 7 , , , 31504 237 8 though though IN 31504 237 9 finding find VBG 31504 237 10 little little JJ 31504 237 11 or or CC 31504 237 12 no no DT 31504 237 13 expression expression NN 31504 237 14 in in IN 31504 237 15 the the DT 31504 237 16 Petition Petition NNP 31504 237 17 of of IN 31504 237 18 Right Right NNP 31504 237 19 or or CC 31504 237 20 Bill Bill NNP 31504 237 21 of of IN 31504 237 22 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 237 23 , , , 31504 237 24 the the DT 31504 237 25 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 237 26 that that IN 31504 237 27 individual individual JJ 31504 237 28 rights right NNS 31504 237 29 were be VBD 31504 237 30 derived derive VBN 31504 237 31 from from IN 31504 237 32 nature nature NN 31504 237 33 rather rather RB 31504 237 34 than than IN 31504 237 35 from from IN 31504 237 36 the the DT 31504 237 37 state state NN 31504 237 38 was be VBD 31504 237 39 generally generally RB 31504 237 40 entertained entertain VBN 31504 237 41 by by IN 31504 237 42 the the DT 31504 237 43 Puritans Puritans NNPS 31504 237 44 and and CC 31504 237 45 other other JJ 31504 237 46 dissenters dissenter NNS 31504 237 47 from from IN 31504 237 48 the the DT 31504 237 49 Established Established NNP 31504 237 50 Church Church NNP 31504 237 51 , , , 31504 237 52 and and CC 31504 237 53 was be VBD 31504 237 54 invoked invoke VBN 31504 237 55 by by IN 31504 237 56 them -PRON- PRP 31504 237 57 to to IN 31504 237 58 some some DT 31504 237 59 extent extent NN 31504 237 60 as as IN 31504 237 61 justifying justify VBG 31504 237 62 the the DT 31504 237 63 revolution revolution NN 31504 237 64 of of IN 31504 237 65 1640 1640 CD 31504 237 66 . . . 31504 238 1 The the DT 31504 238 2 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 238 3 also also RB 31504 238 4 passed pass VBD 31504 238 5 over over RP 31504 238 6 to to IN 31504 238 7 the the DT 31504 238 8 Puritan Puritan NNP 31504 238 9 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 238 10 in in IN 31504 238 11 America America NNP 31504 238 12 and and CC 31504 238 13 early early RB 31504 238 14 found find VBD 31504 238 15 some some DT 31504 238 16 expression expression NN 31504 238 17 there there RB 31504 238 18 . . . 31504 239 1 In in IN 31504 239 2 the the DT 31504 239 3 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 239 4 " " `` 31504 239 5 Body Body NNP 31504 239 6 of of IN 31504 239 7 Liberties Liberties NNPS 31504 239 8 " " '' 31504 239 9 of of IN 31504 239 10 1641 1641 CD 31504 239 11 there there EX 31504 239 12 is be VBZ 31504 239 13 a a DT 31504 239 14 suggestion suggestion NN 31504 239 15 that that IN 31504 239 16 the the DT 31504 239 17 liberties liberty NNS 31504 239 18 , , , 31504 239 19 etc etc FW 31504 239 20 . . FW 31504 239 21 , , , 31504 239 22 therein therein RB 31504 239 23 recited recite VBN 31504 239 24 , , , 31504 239 25 were be VBD 31504 239 26 those those DT 31504 239 27 demanded demand VBN 31504 239 28 by by IN 31504 239 29 " " `` 31504 239 30 humanity humanity NN 31504 239 31 , , , 31504 239 32 civility civility NN 31504 239 33 and and CC 31504 239 34 christianity christianity NN 31504 239 35 " " '' 31504 239 36 rather rather RB 31504 239 37 than than IN 31504 239 38 " " `` 31504 239 39 accustomed accustomed JJ 31504 239 40 " " '' 31504 239 41 liberties liberty NNS 31504 239 42 . . . 31504 240 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 240 2 was be VBD 31504 240 3 further further RB 31504 240 4 asserted assert VBN 31504 240 5 that that IN 31504 240 6 these these DT 31504 240 7 liberties liberty NNS 31504 240 8 were be VBD 31504 240 9 to to TO 31504 240 10 be be VB 31504 240 11 enjoyed enjoy VBN 31504 240 12 by by IN 31504 240 13 the the DT 31504 240 14 people people NNS 31504 240 15 of of IN 31504 240 16 the the DT 31504 240 17 Colony Colony NNP 31504 240 18 and and CC 31504 240 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 240 20 posterity posterity NN 31504 240 21 forever forever RB 31504 240 22 . . . 31504 241 1 The the DT 31504 241 2 later later JJ 31504 241 3 disputes dispute NNS 31504 241 4 as as IN 31504 241 5 to to IN 31504 241 6 the the DT 31504 241 7 proper proper JJ 31504 241 8 limits limit NNS 31504 241 9 of of IN 31504 241 10 the the DT 31504 241 11 power power NN 31504 241 12 of of IN 31504 241 13 the the DT 31504 241 14 British british JJ 31504 241 15 King King NNP 31504 241 16 and and CC 31504 241 17 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 241 18 over over IN 31504 241 19 the the DT 31504 241 20 American American NNP 31504 241 21 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 241 22 led lead VBD 31504 241 23 the the DT 31504 241 24 colonial colonial JJ 31504 241 25 lawyers lawyer NNS 31504 241 26 and and CC 31504 241 27 politicians politician NNS 31504 241 28 to to IN 31504 241 29 a a DT 31504 241 30 study study NN 31504 241 31 of of IN 31504 241 32 the the DT 31504 241 33 theory theory NN 31504 241 34 of of IN 31504 241 35 natural natural JJ 31504 241 36 rights right NNS 31504 241 37 advanced advance VBN 31504 241 38 by by IN 31504 241 39 various various JJ 31504 241 40 political political JJ 31504 241 41 writers writer NNS 31504 241 42 , , , 31504 241 43 English English NNP 31504 241 44 and and CC 31504 241 45 Continental Continental NNP 31504 241 46 . . . 31504 242 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 242 2 has have VBZ 31504 242 3 been be VBN 31504 242 4 said say VBN 31504 242 5 , , , 31504 242 6 I -PRON- PRP 31504 242 7 think think VBP 31504 242 8 with with IN 31504 242 9 truth truth NN 31504 242 10 , , , 31504 242 11 that that IN 31504 242 12 the the DT 31504 242 13 writings writing NNS 31504 242 14 of of IN 31504 242 15 Locke Locke NNP 31504 242 16 , , , 31504 242 17 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 31504 242 18 , , , 31504 242 19 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 31504 242 20 , , , 31504 242 21 Montesquieu Montesquieu NNP 31504 242 22 , , , 31504 242 23 and and CC 31504 242 24 even even RB 31504 242 25 of of IN 31504 242 26 Blackstone Blackstone NNP 31504 242 27 , , , 31504 242 28 were be VBD 31504 242 29 more more RBR 31504 242 30 widely widely RB 31504 242 31 read read VBN 31504 242 32 and and CC 31504 242 33 studied study VBD 31504 242 34 in in IN 31504 242 35 America America NNP 31504 242 36 than than IN 31504 242 37 in in IN 31504 242 38 Europe Europe NNP 31504 242 39 . . . 31504 243 1 The the DT 31504 243 2 brilliant brilliant JJ 31504 243 3 writings writing NNS 31504 243 4 of of IN 31504 243 5 Tom Tom NNP 31504 243 6 Paine Paine NNP 31504 243 7 also also RB 31504 243 8 had have VBD 31504 243 9 great great JJ 31504 243 10 influence influence NN 31504 243 11 . . . 31504 244 1 The the DT 31504 244 2 result result NN 31504 244 3 was be VBD 31504 244 4 that that IN 31504 244 5 the the DT 31504 244 6 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 244 7 of of IN 31504 244 8 natural natural JJ 31504 244 9 rights right NNS 31504 244 10 came come VBD 31504 244 11 to to TO 31504 244 12 be be VB 31504 244 13 generally generally RB 31504 244 14 accepted accept VBN 31504 244 15 by by IN 31504 244 16 the the DT 31504 244 17 people people NNS 31504 244 18 of of IN 31504 244 19 the the DT 31504 244 20 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 244 21 as as IN 31504 244 22 the the DT 31504 244 23 real real JJ 31504 244 24 foundation foundation NN 31504 244 25 of of IN 31504 244 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 244 27 claims claim NNS 31504 244 28 and and CC 31504 244 29 the the DT 31504 244 30 real real JJ 31504 244 31 justification justification NN 31504 244 32 for for IN 31504 244 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 244 34 resistance resistance NN 31504 244 35 to to IN 31504 244 36 the the DT 31504 244 37 objectionable objectionable JJ 31504 244 38 acts act NNS 31504 244 39 of of IN 31504 244 40 the the DT 31504 244 41 King King NNP 31504 244 42 and and CC 31504 244 43 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 244 44 . . . 31504 245 1 In in IN 31504 245 2 1774 1774 CD 31504 245 3 the the DT 31504 245 4 first first JJ 31504 245 5 Continental Continental NNP 31504 245 6 Congress Congress NNP 31504 245 7 in in IN 31504 245 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 245 9 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 245 10 of of IN 31504 245 11 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 245 12 declared declare VBD 31504 245 13 that that IN 31504 245 14 the the DT 31504 245 15 people people NNS 31504 245 16 of of IN 31504 245 17 the the DT 31504 245 18 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 245 19 had have VBD 31504 245 20 those those DT 31504 245 21 rights right NNS 31504 245 22 by by IN 31504 245 23 " " `` 31504 245 24 the the DT 31504 245 25 immutable immutable JJ 31504 245 26 laws law NNS 31504 245 27 of of IN 31504 245 28 nature nature NN 31504 245 29 " " '' 31504 245 30 as as RB 31504 245 31 well well RB 31504 245 32 as as IN 31504 245 33 by by IN 31504 245 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 245 35 charters charter NNS 31504 245 36 and and CC 31504 245 37 the the DT 31504 245 38 principles principle NNS 31504 245 39 of of IN 31504 245 40 the the DT 31504 245 41 English English NNP 31504 245 42 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 245 43 . . . 31504 246 1 Two two CD 31504 246 2 years year NNS 31504 246 3 later later RB 31504 246 4 in in IN 31504 246 5 the the DT 31504 246 6 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 246 7 of of IN 31504 246 8 Independence Independence NNP 31504 246 9 the the DT 31504 246 10 representatives representative NNS 31504 246 11 of of IN 31504 246 12 the the DT 31504 246 13 people people NNS 31504 246 14 made make VBD 31504 246 15 no no DT 31504 246 16 reference reference NN 31504 246 17 to to IN 31504 246 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 246 19 charters charter NNS 31504 246 20 nor nor CC 31504 246 21 to to IN 31504 246 22 the the DT 31504 246 23 principles principle NNS 31504 246 24 of of IN 31504 246 25 the the DT 31504 246 26 English English NNP 31504 246 27 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 246 28 as as IN 31504 246 29 the the DT 31504 246 30 foundation foundation NN 31504 246 31 of of IN 31504 246 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 246 33 claims claim NNS 31504 246 34 , , , 31504 246 35 but but CC 31504 246 36 based base VBD 31504 246 37 them -PRON- PRP 31504 246 38 exclusively exclusively RB 31504 246 39 on on IN 31504 246 40 the the DT 31504 246 41 theory theory NN 31504 246 42 of of IN 31504 246 43 natural natural JJ 31504 246 44 rights right NNS 31504 246 45 . . . 31504 247 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 247 2 declared declare VBD 31504 247 3 : : : 31504 247 4 " " `` 31504 247 5 We -PRON- PRP 31504 247 6 hold hold VBP 31504 247 7 these these DT 31504 247 8 truths truth NNS 31504 247 9 to to TO 31504 247 10 be be VB 31504 247 11 self self NN 31504 247 12 - - HYPH 31504 247 13 evident evident JJ 31504 247 14 , , , 31504 247 15 that that IN 31504 247 16 all all DT 31504 247 17 men man NNS 31504 247 18 are be VBP 31504 247 19 created create VBN 31504 247 20 equal equal JJ 31504 247 21 ; ; : 31504 247 22 that that IN 31504 247 23 they -PRON- PRP 31504 247 24 are be VBP 31504 247 25 endowed endow VBN 31504 247 26 by by IN 31504 247 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 247 28 Creator Creator NNP 31504 247 29 with with IN 31504 247 30 certain certain JJ 31504 247 31 unalienable unalienable JJ 31504 247 32 rights right NNS 31504 247 33 ; ; : 31504 247 34 that that IN 31504 247 35 among among IN 31504 247 36 these these DT 31504 247 37 are be VBP 31504 247 38 life life NN 31504 247 39 , , , 31504 247 40 liberty liberty NN 31504 247 41 and and CC 31504 247 42 the the DT 31504 247 43 pursuit pursuit NN 31504 247 44 of of IN 31504 247 45 happiness happiness NN 31504 247 46 . . . 31504 247 47 " " '' 31504 248 1 The the DT 31504 248 2 same same JJ 31504 248 3 influences influence NNS 31504 248 4 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 31504 248 5 contributed contribute VBD 31504 248 6 to to TO 31504 248 7 bring bring VB 31504 248 8 about about RP 31504 248 9 the the DT 31504 248 10 French French NNP 31504 248 11 Revolution Revolution NNP 31504 248 12 of of IN 31504 248 13 1789 1789 CD 31504 248 14 , , , 31504 248 15 and and CC 31504 248 16 the the DT 31504 248 17 theory theory NN 31504 248 18 of of IN 31504 248 19 natural natural JJ 31504 248 20 rights right NNS 31504 248 21 again again RB 31504 248 22 found find VBD 31504 248 23 expression expression NN 31504 248 24 in in IN 31504 248 25 the the DT 31504 248 26 French french JJ 31504 248 27 state state NN 31504 248 28 papers paper NNS 31504 248 29 of of IN 31504 248 30 that that DT 31504 248 31 period period NN 31504 248 32 . . . 31504 249 1 In in IN 31504 249 2 August August NNP 31504 249 3 of of IN 31504 249 4 that that DT 31504 249 5 year year NN 31504 249 6 , , , 31504 249 7 in in IN 31504 249 8 the the DT 31504 249 9 early early JJ 31504 249 10 stages stage NNS 31504 249 11 of of IN 31504 249 12 the the DT 31504 249 13 Revolution Revolution NNP 31504 249 14 , , , 31504 249 15 the the DT 31504 249 16 following follow VBG 31504 249 17 " " `` 31504 249 18 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 249 19 of of IN 31504 249 20 the the DT 31504 249 21 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 249 22 of of IN 31504 249 23 Man Man NNP 31504 249 24 and and CC 31504 249 25 Citizen Citizen NNP 31504 249 26 " " '' 31504 249 27 was be VBD 31504 249 28 put put VBN 31504 249 29 forth forth RP 31504 249 30 by by IN 31504 249 31 the the DT 31504 249 32 National National NNP 31504 249 33 Assembly Assembly NNP 31504 249 34 and and CC 31504 249 35 afterwards afterwards RB 31504 249 36 made make VBD 31504 249 37 the the DT 31504 249 38 first first JJ 31504 249 39 two two CD 31504 249 40 articles article NNS 31504 249 41 of of IN 31504 249 42 the the DT 31504 249 43 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 249 44 of of IN 31504 249 45 1791 1791 CD 31504 249 46 , , , 31504 249 47 viz viz NNP 31504 249 48 . . NNP 31504 249 49 , , , 31504 249 50 " " `` 31504 249 51 Art art NN 31504 249 52 . . . 31504 250 1 1 1 LS 31504 250 2 . . . 31504 251 1 Men man NNS 31504 251 2 are be VBP 31504 251 3 born bear VBN 31504 251 4 and and CC 31504 251 5 remain remain VB 31504 251 6 free free JJ 31504 251 7 and and CC 31504 251 8 equal equal JJ 31504 251 9 in in IN 31504 251 10 rights right NNS 31504 251 11 . . . 31504 252 1 Social social JJ 31504 252 2 distinctions distinction NNS 31504 252 3 can can MD 31504 252 4 be be VB 31504 252 5 based base VBN 31504 252 6 only only RB 31504 252 7 upon upon IN 31504 252 8 public public JJ 31504 252 9 utility utility NN 31504 252 10 . . . 31504 253 1 Art art NN 31504 253 2 . . . 31504 254 1 2 2 LS 31504 254 2 . . . 31504 255 1 The the DT 31504 255 2 aim aim NN 31504 255 3 of of IN 31504 255 4 every every DT 31504 255 5 political political JJ 31504 255 6 association association NN 31504 255 7 is be VBZ 31504 255 8 the the DT 31504 255 9 preservation preservation NN 31504 255 10 of of IN 31504 255 11 the the DT 31504 255 12 natural natural JJ 31504 255 13 and and CC 31504 255 14 imprescriptible imprescriptible JJ 31504 255 15 rights right NNS 31504 255 16 of of IN 31504 255 17 man man NN 31504 255 18 . . . 31504 256 1 These these DT 31504 256 2 rights right NNS 31504 256 3 are be VBP 31504 256 4 liberty liberty NN 31504 256 5 , , , 31504 256 6 property property NN 31504 256 7 , , , 31504 256 8 security security NN 31504 256 9 and and CC 31504 256 10 resistance resistance NN 31504 256 11 to to IN 31504 256 12 oppression oppression NN 31504 256 13 . . . 31504 256 14 " " '' 31504 257 1 Thus thus RB 31504 257 2 in in IN 31504 257 3 the the DT 31504 257 4 latter latter JJ 31504 257 5 part part NN 31504 257 6 of of IN 31504 257 7 the the DT 31504 257 8 18th 18th JJ 31504 257 9 century century NN 31504 257 10 the the DT 31504 257 11 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 257 12 that that DT 31504 257 13 man man NN 31504 257 14 has have VBZ 31504 257 15 some some DT 31504 257 16 individual individual JJ 31504 257 17 rights right NNS 31504 257 18 by by IN 31504 257 19 nature nature NN 31504 257 20 , , , 31504 257 21 not not RB 31504 257 22 by by IN 31504 257 23 grant grant NN 31504 257 24 or or CC 31504 257 25 prescription prescription NN 31504 257 26 , , , 31504 257 27 and and CC 31504 257 28 not not RB 31504 257 29 alienable alienable JJ 31504 257 30 , , , 31504 257 31 obtained obtain VBD 31504 257 32 official official JJ 31504 257 33 recognition recognition NN 31504 257 34 in in IN 31504 257 35 two two CD 31504 257 36 great great JJ 31504 257 37 nations nation NNS 31504 257 38 . . . 31504 258 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 258 2 has have VBZ 31504 258 3 since since IN 31504 258 4 been be VBN 31504 258 5 formally formally RB 31504 258 6 and and CC 31504 258 7 officially officially RB 31504 258 8 iterated iterate VBD 31504 258 9 in in IN 31504 258 10 the the DT 31504 258 11 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 31504 258 12 of of IN 31504 258 13 many many JJ 31504 258 14 American american JJ 31504 258 15 States States NNPS 31504 258 16 and and CC 31504 258 17 has have VBZ 31504 258 18 been be VBN 31504 258 19 proclaimed proclaim VBN 31504 258 20 and and CC 31504 258 21 invoked invoke VBD 31504 258 22 as as IN 31504 258 23 an an DT 31504 258 24 impregnably impregnably RB 31504 258 25 established establish VBN 31504 258 26 political political JJ 31504 258 27 truth truth NN 31504 258 28 . . . 31504 259 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 31504 259 2 the the DT 31504 259 3 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 259 4 is be VBZ 31504 259 5 only only RB 31504 259 6 a a DT 31504 259 7 theory theory NN 31504 259 8 , , , 31504 259 9 not not RB 31504 259 10 yet yet RB 31504 259 11 demonstrated demonstrated JJ 31504 259 12 nor nor CC 31504 259 13 undoubted undoubted JJ 31504 259 14 . . . 31504 260 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 260 2 has have VBZ 31504 260 3 been be VBN 31504 260 4 assailed assail VBN 31504 260 5 and and CC 31504 260 6 in in IN 31504 260 7 the the DT 31504 260 8 opinion opinion NN 31504 260 9 of of IN 31504 260 10 many many JJ 31504 260 11 refuted refute VBN 31504 260 12 , , , 31504 260 13 by by IN 31504 260 14 Bentham Bentham NNP 31504 260 15 , , , 31504 260 16 Mill Mill NNP 31504 260 17 , , , 31504 260 18 and and CC 31504 260 19 other other JJ 31504 260 20 utilitarian utilitarian JJ 31504 260 21 writers writer NNS 31504 260 22 , , , 31504 260 23 the the DT 31504 260 24 successors successor NNS 31504 260 25 of of IN 31504 260 26 Epicurus Epicurus NNP 31504 260 27 , , , 31504 260 28 Carneades Carneades NNPS 31504 260 29 and and CC 31504 260 30 the the DT 31504 260 31 Sophists Sophists NNPS 31504 260 32 . . . 31504 261 1 Even even RB 31504 261 2 in in IN 31504 261 3 France France NNP 31504 261 4 and and CC 31504 261 5 America America NNP 31504 261 6 it -PRON- PRP 31504 261 7 is be VBZ 31504 261 8 now now RB 31504 261 9 repudiated repudiate VBN 31504 261 10 by by IN 31504 261 11 many many JJ 31504 261 12 and and CC 31504 261 13 declared declare VBD 31504 261 14 to to TO 31504 261 15 be be VB 31504 261 16 an an DT 31504 261 17 obstacle obstacle NN 31504 261 18 to to IN 31504 261 19 social social JJ 31504 261 20 and and CC 31504 261 21 political political JJ 31504 261 22 improvement improvement NN 31504 261 23 . . . 31504 262 1 Still still RB 31504 262 2 , , , 31504 262 3 despite despite IN 31504 262 4 the the DT 31504 262 5 vigorous vigorous JJ 31504 262 6 arguments argument NNS 31504 262 7 against against IN 31504 262 8 the the DT 31504 262 9 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 262 10 , , , 31504 262 11 there there EX 31504 262 12 remains remain VBZ 31504 262 13 the the DT 31504 262 14 innate innate JJ 31504 262 15 feeling feeling NN 31504 262 16 and and CC 31504 262 17 a a DT 31504 262 18 general general JJ 31504 262 19 belief belief NN 31504 262 20 that that IN 31504 262 21 society society NN 31504 262 22 abridges abridge VBZ 31504 262 23 individual individual JJ 31504 262 24 rights right NNS 31504 262 25 instead instead RB 31504 262 26 of of IN 31504 262 27 conferring confer VBG 31504 262 28 them -PRON- PRP 31504 262 29 . . . 31504 263 1 In in IN 31504 263 2 support support NN 31504 263 3 of of IN 31504 263 4 this this DT 31504 263 5 notion notion NN 31504 263 6 may may MD 31504 263 7 be be VB 31504 263 8 cited cite VBN 31504 263 9 the the DT 31504 263 10 fact fact NN 31504 263 11 that that IN 31504 263 12 the the DT 31504 263 13 statutes statute NNS 31504 263 14 of of IN 31504 263 15 any any DT 31504 263 16 state state NN 31504 263 17 or or CC 31504 263 18 nation nation NN 31504 263 19 are be VBP 31504 263 20 almost almost RB 31504 263 21 wholly wholly RB 31504 263 22 restrictive restrictive JJ 31504 263 23 or or CC 31504 263 24 compulsory compulsory JJ 31504 263 25 in in IN 31504 263 26 character character NN 31504 263 27 , , , 31504 263 28 and and CC 31504 263 29 rarely rarely RB 31504 263 30 , , , 31504 263 31 if if IN 31504 263 32 ever ever RB 31504 263 33 , , , 31504 263 34 permissive permissive JJ 31504 263 35 . . . 31504 264 1 From from IN 31504 264 2 the the DT 31504 264 3 Decalogue Decalogue NNP 31504 264 4 down down RP 31504 264 5 , , , 31504 264 6 the the DT 31504 264 7 language language NN 31504 264 8 of of IN 31504 264 9 the the DT 31504 264 10 law law NN 31504 264 11 has have VBZ 31504 264 12 been be VBN 31504 264 13 compulsive compulsive JJ 31504 264 14 , , , 31504 264 15 " " '' 31504 264 16 Thou Thou NNP 31504 264 17 shalt shalt NN 31504 264 18 " " '' 31504 264 19 and and CC 31504 264 20 " " `` 31504 264 21 Thou Thou NNP 31504 264 22 shalt shalt NN 31504 264 23 not not RB 31504 264 24 " " '' 31504 264 25 ; ; : 31504 264 26 and and CC 31504 264 27 men man NNS 31504 264 28 generally generally RB 31504 264 29 act act VBP 31504 264 30 upon upon IN 31504 264 31 the the DT 31504 264 32 theory theory NN 31504 264 33 that that IN 31504 264 34 what what WDT 31504 264 35 society society NN 31504 264 36 does do VBZ 31504 264 37 not not RB 31504 264 38 forbid forbid VB 31504 264 39 by by IN 31504 264 40 statute statute NN 31504 264 41 or or CC 31504 264 42 custom custom NN 31504 264 43 the the DT 31504 264 44 individual individual NN 31504 264 45 may may MD 31504 264 46 do do VB 31504 264 47 . . . 31504 265 1 In in IN 31504 265 2 passing pass VBG 31504 265 3 now now RB 31504 265 4 from from IN 31504 265 5 the the DT 31504 265 6 region region NN 31504 265 7 of of IN 31504 265 8 theory theory NN 31504 265 9 , , , 31504 265 10 of of IN 31504 265 11 speculative speculative JJ 31504 265 12 opinion opinion NN 31504 265 13 , , , 31504 265 14 to to IN 31504 265 15 what what WP 31504 265 16 seems seem VBZ 31504 265 17 to to IN 31504 265 18 me -PRON- PRP 31504 265 19 the the DT 31504 265 20 region region NN 31504 265 21 of of IN 31504 265 22 facts fact NNS 31504 265 23 , , , 31504 265 24 of of IN 31504 265 25 actual actual JJ 31504 265 26 conditions condition NNS 31504 265 27 , , , 31504 265 28 of of IN 31504 265 29 actual actual JJ 31504 265 30 traits trait NNS 31504 265 31 of of IN 31504 265 32 human human JJ 31504 265 33 nature nature NN 31504 265 34 , , , 31504 265 35 I -PRON- PRP 31504 265 36 wish wish VBP 31504 265 37 it -PRON- PRP 31504 265 38 to to TO 31504 265 39 be be VB 31504 265 40 understood understand VBN 31504 265 41 distinctly distinctly RB 31504 265 42 that that IN 31504 265 43 in in IN 31504 265 44 what what WP 31504 265 45 I -PRON- PRP 31504 265 46 may may MD 31504 265 47 say say VB 31504 265 48 about about IN 31504 265 49 rights right NNS 31504 265 50 I -PRON- PRP 31504 265 51 am be VBP 31504 265 52 considering consider VBG 31504 265 53 only only RB 31504 265 54 the the DT 31504 265 55 precepts precept NNS 31504 265 56 of of IN 31504 265 57 justice justice NN 31504 265 58 , , , 31504 265 59 and and CC 31504 265 60 that that IN 31504 265 61 I -PRON- PRP 31504 265 62 differentiate differentiate VBP 31504 265 63 those those DT 31504 265 64 precepts precept NNS 31504 265 65 from from IN 31504 265 66 the the DT 31504 265 67 precepts precept NNS 31504 265 68 of of IN 31504 265 69 religion religion NN 31504 265 70 , , , 31504 265 71 charity charity NN 31504 265 72 , , , 31504 265 73 philanthropy philanthropy NN 31504 265 74 , , , 31504 265 75 benevolence benevolence NN 31504 265 76 , , , 31504 265 77 and and CC 31504 265 78 other other JJ 31504 265 79 similar similar JJ 31504 265 80 virtues virtue NNS 31504 265 81 , , , 31504 265 82 and and CC 31504 265 83 even even RB 31504 265 84 those those DT 31504 265 85 of of IN 31504 265 86 what what WP 31504 265 87 is be VBZ 31504 265 88 loosely loosely RB 31504 265 89 called call VBN 31504 265 90 humanity humanity NN 31504 265 91 . . . 31504 266 1 If if IN 31504 266 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 266 3 be be VB 31504 266 4 true true JJ 31504 266 5 as as IN 31504 266 6 asserted assert VBN 31504 266 7 by by IN 31504 266 8 Addison Addison NNP 31504 266 9 that that IN 31504 266 10 justice justice NN 31504 266 11 is be VBZ 31504 266 12 the the DT 31504 266 13 greatest great JJS 31504 266 14 and and CC 31504 266 15 most most RBS 31504 266 16 godlike godlike JJ 31504 266 17 of of IN 31504 266 18 the the DT 31504 266 19 virtues virtue NNS 31504 266 20 , , , 31504 266 21 it -PRON- PRP 31504 266 22 does do VBZ 31504 266 23 not not RB 31504 266 24 follow follow VB 31504 266 25 that that IN 31504 266 26 the the DT 31504 266 27 just just JJ 31504 266 28 man man NN 31504 266 29 , , , 31504 266 30 to to TO 31504 266 31 be be VB 31504 266 32 just just RB 31504 266 33 , , , 31504 266 34 must must MD 31504 266 35 possess possess VB 31504 266 36 all all DT 31504 266 37 or or CC 31504 266 38 any any DT 31504 266 39 of of IN 31504 266 40 the the DT 31504 266 41 other other JJ 31504 266 42 virtues virtue NNS 31504 266 43 . . . 31504 267 1 One one PRP 31504 267 2 can can MD 31504 267 3 be be VB 31504 267 4 just just RB 31504 267 5 without without IN 31504 267 6 being be VBG 31504 267 7 religious religious JJ 31504 267 8 , , , 31504 267 9 charitable charitable JJ 31504 267 10 , , , 31504 267 11 or or CC 31504 267 12 philanthropic philanthropic NN 31504 267 13 , , , 31504 267 14 and and CC 31504 267 15 even even RB 31504 267 16 without without IN 31504 267 17 earning earn VBG 31504 267 18 the the DT 31504 267 19 reputation reputation NN 31504 267 20 of of IN 31504 267 21 being be VBG 31504 267 22 humane humane JJ 31504 267 23 . . . 31504 268 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 268 2 wish wish VBP 31504 268 3 further further RB 31504 268 4 to to TO 31504 268 5 premise premise VB 31504 268 6 that that IN 31504 268 7 I -PRON- PRP 31504 268 8 am be VBP 31504 268 9 considering consider VBG 31504 268 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 268 11 subject subject NN 31504 268 12 only only RB 31504 268 13 with with IN 31504 268 14 reference reference NN 31504 268 15 to to IN 31504 268 16 those those DT 31504 268 17 who who WP 31504 268 18 have have VBP 31504 268 19 grown grow VBN 31504 268 20 to to IN 31504 268 21 the the DT 31504 268 22 age age NN 31504 268 23 of of IN 31504 268 24 self self NN 31504 268 25 - - HYPH 31504 268 26 maintenance maintenance NN 31504 268 27 and and CC 31504 268 28 consequent consequent NN 31504 268 29 freedom freedom NN 31504 268 30 . . . 31504 269 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 269 2 do do VBP 31504 269 3 not not RB 31504 269 4 take take VB 31504 269 5 into into IN 31504 269 6 account account NN 31504 269 7 the the DT 31504 269 8 rights right NNS 31504 269 9 of of IN 31504 269 10 children child NNS 31504 269 11 under under IN 31504 269 12 that that DT 31504 269 13 age age NN 31504 269 14 . . . 31504 270 1 With with IN 31504 270 2 these these DT 31504 270 3 premises premise NNS 31504 270 4 borne bear VBN 31504 270 5 in in IN 31504 270 6 mind mind NN 31504 270 7 , , , 31504 270 8 I -PRON- PRP 31504 270 9 would would MD 31504 270 10 now now RB 31504 270 11 in in IN 31504 270 12 the the DT 31504 270 13 next next JJ 31504 270 14 chapter chapter NN 31504 270 15 call call VBP 31504 270 16 attention attention NN 31504 270 17 to to IN 31504 270 18 some some DT 31504 270 19 propositions proposition NNS 31504 270 20 of of IN 31504 270 21 fact fact NN 31504 270 22 , , , 31504 270 23 which which WDT 31504 270 24 I -PRON- PRP 31504 270 25 shall shall MD 31504 270 26 assume assume VB 31504 270 27 to to TO 31504 270 28 be be VB 31504 270 29 established establish VBN 31504 270 30 by by IN 31504 270 31 science science NN 31504 270 32 and and CC 31504 270 33 history history NN 31504 270 34 and and CC 31504 270 35 by by IN 31504 270 36 the the DT 31504 270 37 reader reader NN 31504 270 38 's 's POS 31504 270 39 own own JJ 31504 270 40 experience experience NN 31504 270 41 and and CC 31504 270 42 observation observation NN 31504 270 43 , , , 31504 270 44 and and CC 31504 270 45 which which WDT 31504 270 46 I -PRON- PRP 31504 270 47 think think VBP 31504 270 48 bear bear VBP 31504 270 49 more more RBR 31504 270 50 or or CC 31504 270 51 less less RBR 31504 270 52 directly directly RB 31504 270 53 on on IN 31504 270 54 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 270 55 subject subject NN 31504 270 56 . . . 31504 271 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31504 271 2 III III NNP 31504 271 3 THE the DT 31504 271 4 PROBLEM problem NN 31504 271 5 OF of IN 31504 271 6 RIGHTS right NNS 31504 271 7 CONTINUED CONTINUED NNS 31504 271 8 . . . 31504 272 1 THE the DT 31504 272 2 NEED NEED NNP 31504 272 3 OF of IN 31504 272 4 LIBERTY liberty NN 31504 272 5 OF of IN 31504 272 6 ACTION action NN 31504 272 7 FOR for IN 31504 272 8 THE the DT 31504 272 9 INDIVIDUAL INDIVIDUAL NNP 31504 272 10 Men Men NNPS 31504 272 11 are be VBP 31504 272 12 endowed endow VBN 31504 272 13 by by IN 31504 272 14 nature nature NN 31504 272 15 with with IN 31504 272 16 sundry sundry JJ 31504 272 17 powers power NNS 31504 272 18 , , , 31504 272 19 faculties faculty NNS 31504 272 20 , , , 31504 272 21 capacities capacity NNS 31504 272 22 , , , 31504 272 23 physical physical JJ 31504 272 24 and and CC 31504 272 25 mental mental JJ 31504 272 26 . . . 31504 273 1 These these DT 31504 273 2 , , , 31504 273 3 however however RB 31504 273 4 , , , 31504 273 5 are be VBP 31504 273 6 not not RB 31504 273 7 at at RB 31504 273 8 all all RB 31504 273 9 uniform uniform NN 31504 273 10 , , , 31504 273 11 but but CC 31504 273 12 are be VBP 31504 273 13 diverse diverse JJ 31504 273 14 in in IN 31504 273 15 kind kind NN 31504 273 16 and and CC 31504 273 17 degree degree NN 31504 273 18 in in IN 31504 273 19 different different JJ 31504 273 20 races race NNS 31504 273 21 of of IN 31504 273 22 men man NNS 31504 273 23 and and CC 31504 273 24 in in IN 31504 273 25 different different JJ 31504 273 26 individuals individual NNS 31504 273 27 of of IN 31504 273 28 the the DT 31504 273 29 same same JJ 31504 273 30 race race NN 31504 273 31 . . . 31504 274 1 Nature nature NN 31504 274 2 seems seem VBZ 31504 274 3 to to TO 31504 274 4 work work VB 31504 274 5 through through IN 31504 274 6 diversity diversity NN 31504 274 7 rather rather RB 31504 274 8 than than IN 31504 274 9 through through IN 31504 274 10 uniformity uniformity NN 31504 274 11 , , , 31504 274 12 indeed indeed RB 31504 274 13 through through IN 31504 274 14 inequality inequality NN 31504 274 15 rather rather RB 31504 274 16 than than IN 31504 274 17 through through IN 31504 274 18 equality equality NN 31504 274 19 . . . 31504 275 1 Not not RB 31504 275 2 all all DT 31504 275 3 men man NNS 31504 275 4 are be VBP 31504 275 5 born bear VBN 31504 275 6 poets poet NNS 31504 275 7 , , , 31504 275 8 nor nor CC 31504 275 9 are be VBP 31504 275 10 all all DT 31504 275 11 poets poet NNS 31504 275 12 equally equally RB 31504 275 13 good good JJ 31504 275 14 poets poet NNS 31504 275 15 . . . 31504 276 1 Not not RB 31504 276 2 all all DT 31504 276 3 men man NNS 31504 276 4 are be VBP 31504 276 5 by by IN 31504 276 6 nature nature NN 31504 276 7 adapted adapt VBN 31504 276 8 for for IN 31504 276 9 intellectual intellectual JJ 31504 276 10 pursuits pursuit NNS 31504 276 11 , , , 31504 276 12 and and CC 31504 276 13 those those DT 31504 276 14 who who WP 31504 276 15 are be VBP 31504 276 16 so so RB 31504 276 17 adapted adapted JJ 31504 276 18 are be VBP 31504 276 19 not not RB 31504 276 20 in in IN 31504 276 21 that that DT 31504 276 22 respect respect NN 31504 276 23 equally equally RB 31504 276 24 favored favor VBN 31504 276 25 by by IN 31504 276 26 nature nature NN 31504 276 27 . . . 31504 277 1 Even even RB 31504 277 2 in in IN 31504 277 3 the the DT 31504 277 4 field field NN 31504 277 5 of of IN 31504 277 6 the the DT 31504 277 7 simplest simple JJS 31504 277 8 manual manual JJ 31504 277 9 labor labor NN 31504 277 10 there there EX 31504 277 11 is be VBZ 31504 277 12 great great JJ 31504 277 13 diversity diversity NN 31504 277 14 of of IN 31504 277 15 natural natural JJ 31504 277 16 capacity capacity NN 31504 277 17 . . . 31504 278 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 278 2 seems seem VBZ 31504 278 3 to to TO 31504 278 4 be be VB 31504 278 5 nature nature NN 31504 278 6 's 's POS 31504 278 7 theory theory NN 31504 278 8 that that IN 31504 278 9 mankind mankind NN 31504 278 10 , , , 31504 278 11 the the DT 31504 278 12 human human JJ 31504 278 13 race race NN 31504 278 14 as as IN 31504 278 15 a a DT 31504 278 16 whole whole NN 31504 278 17 , , , 31504 278 18 will will MD 31504 278 19 be be VB 31504 278 20 better well RBR 31504 278 21 served serve VBN 31504 278 22 by by IN 31504 278 23 diversities diversity NNS 31504 278 24 , , , 31504 278 25 by by IN 31504 278 26 differences difference NNS 31504 278 27 in in IN 31504 278 28 kinds kind NNS 31504 278 29 and and CC 31504 278 30 degrees degree NNS 31504 278 31 of of IN 31504 278 32 powers power NNS 31504 278 33 , , , 31504 278 34 than than IN 31504 278 35 by by IN 31504 278 36 uniformity uniformity NN 31504 278 37 and and CC 31504 278 38 equality equality NN 31504 278 39 . . . 31504 279 1 Further further RB 31504 279 2 , , , 31504 279 3 normal normal JJ 31504 279 4 men man NNS 31504 279 5 are be VBP 31504 279 6 also also RB 31504 279 7 by by IN 31504 279 8 nature nature NN 31504 279 9 endowed endow VBN 31504 279 10 , , , 31504 279 11 if if IN 31504 279 12 not not RB 31504 279 13 with with IN 31504 279 14 rights right NNS 31504 279 15 , , , 31504 279 16 yet yet CC 31504 279 17 with with IN 31504 279 18 sundry sundry JJ 31504 279 19 instincts instinct NNS 31504 279 20 , , , 31504 279 21 desires desire NNS 31504 279 22 , , , 31504 279 23 passions passion NNS 31504 279 24 ; ; , 31504 279 25 also also RB 31504 279 26 with with IN 31504 279 27 sundry sundry JJ 31504 279 28 feelings feeling NNS 31504 279 29 , , , 31504 279 30 emotions emotion NNS 31504 279 31 , , , 31504 279 32 sentiments sentiment NNS 31504 279 33 ; ; : 31504 279 34 and and CC 31504 279 35 also also RB 31504 279 36 with with IN 31504 279 37 some some DT 31504 279 38 degree degree NN 31504 279 39 of of IN 31504 279 40 reason reason NN 31504 279 41 and and CC 31504 279 42 power power NN 31504 279 43 of of IN 31504 279 44 choice choice NN 31504 279 45 . . . 31504 280 1 Some some DT 31504 280 2 of of IN 31504 280 3 these these DT 31504 280 4 may may MD 31504 280 5 not not RB 31504 280 6 be be VB 31504 280 7 apparent apparent JJ 31504 280 8 in in IN 31504 280 9 infancy infancy NN 31504 280 10 , , , 31504 280 11 but but CC 31504 280 12 they -PRON- PRP 31504 280 13 appear appear VBP 31504 280 14 in in IN 31504 280 15 a a DT 31504 280 16 greater great JJR 31504 280 17 or or CC 31504 280 18 less less JJR 31504 280 19 degree degree NN 31504 280 20 of of IN 31504 280 21 intensity intensity NN 31504 280 22 as as IN 31504 280 23 the the DT 31504 280 24 individual individual JJ 31504 280 25 develops develop VBZ 31504 280 26 . . . 31504 281 1 Among among IN 31504 281 2 these these DT 31504 281 3 instincts instinct NNS 31504 281 4 or or CC 31504 281 5 desires desire NNS 31504 281 6 is be VBZ 31504 281 7 the the DT 31504 281 8 desire desire NN 31504 281 9 to to TO 31504 281 10 live live VB 31504 281 11 , , , 31504 281 12 the the DT 31504 281 13 desire desire NN 31504 281 14 to to TO 31504 281 15 serve serve VB 31504 281 16 each each DT 31504 281 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 281 18 own own JJ 31504 281 19 welfare welfare NN 31504 281 20 and and CC 31504 281 21 that that DT 31504 281 22 of of IN 31504 281 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 281 24 offspring offspring NN 31504 281 25 , , , 31504 281 26 and and CC 31504 281 27 the the DT 31504 281 28 desire desire NN 31504 281 29 to to TO 31504 281 30 decide decide VB 31504 281 31 for for IN 31504 281 32 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 281 33 what what WP 31504 281 34 will will MD 31504 281 35 best well RBS 31504 281 36 serve serve VB 31504 281 37 that that DT 31504 281 38 welfare welfare NN 31504 281 39 . . . 31504 282 1 As as IN 31504 282 2 a a DT 31504 282 3 corollary corollary NN 31504 282 4 , , , 31504 282 5 he -PRON- PRP 31504 282 6 also also RB 31504 282 7 has have VBZ 31504 282 8 by by IN 31504 282 9 birth birth NN 31504 282 10 the the DT 31504 282 11 desire desire NN 31504 282 12 for for IN 31504 282 13 freedom freedom NN 31504 282 14 to to TO 31504 282 15 exercise exercise VB 31504 282 16 any any DT 31504 282 17 and and CC 31504 282 18 all all DT 31504 282 19 of of IN 31504 282 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 282 21 talents talent NNS 31504 282 22 and and CC 31504 282 23 powers power NNS 31504 282 24 in in IN 31504 282 25 such such JJ 31504 282 26 manner manner NN 31504 282 27 , , , 31504 282 28 to to IN 31504 282 29 such such JJ 31504 282 30 extent extent NN 31504 282 31 , , , 31504 282 32 and and CC 31504 282 33 in in IN 31504 282 34 pursuit pursuit NN 31504 282 35 of of IN 31504 282 36 such such JJ 31504 282 37 objects object NNS 31504 282 38 as as IN 31504 282 39 he -PRON- PRP 31504 282 40 prefers prefer VBZ 31504 282 41 , , , 31504 282 42 or or CC 31504 282 43 to to TO 31504 282 44 be be VB 31504 282 45 idle idle JJ 31504 282 46 if if IN 31504 282 47 he -PRON- PRP 31504 282 48 prefers prefer VBZ 31504 282 49 idleness idleness JJ 31504 282 50 . . . 31504 283 1 Further further RB 31504 283 2 , , , 31504 283 3 he -PRON- PRP 31504 283 4 has have VBZ 31504 283 5 the the DT 31504 283 6 instinct instinct NN 31504 283 7 of of IN 31504 283 8 acquisitiveness acquisitiveness NN 31504 283 9 , , , 31504 283 10 the the DT 31504 283 11 desire desire NN 31504 283 12 to to TO 31504 283 13 appropriate appropriate VB 31504 283 14 to to IN 31504 283 15 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 283 16 and and CC 31504 283 17 retain retain VB 31504 283 18 control control NN 31504 283 19 of of IN 31504 283 20 such such JJ 31504 283 21 material material NN 31504 283 22 objects object NNS 31504 283 23 as as IN 31504 283 24 he -PRON- PRP 31504 283 25 thinks think VBZ 31504 283 26 may may MD 31504 283 27 serve serve VB 31504 283 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 283 29 welfare welfare NN 31504 283 30 and and CC 31504 283 31 that that DT 31504 283 32 of of IN 31504 283 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 283 34 offspring offspring NN 31504 283 35 , , , 31504 283 36 and and CC 31504 283 37 especially especially RB 31504 283 38 does do VBZ 31504 283 39 he -PRON- PRP 31504 283 40 have have VB 31504 283 41 a a DT 31504 283 42 natural natural JJ 31504 283 43 instinct instinct NN 31504 283 44 and and CC 31504 283 45 desire desire NN 31504 283 46 to to TO 31504 283 47 possess possess VB 31504 283 48 and and CC 31504 283 49 control control VB 31504 283 50 exclusively exclusively RB 31504 283 51 for for IN 31504 283 52 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 283 53 whatever whatever WDT 31504 283 54 , , , 31504 283 55 much much JJ 31504 283 56 or or CC 31504 283 57 little little JJ 31504 283 58 , , , 31504 283 59 he -PRON- PRP 31504 283 60 has have VBZ 31504 283 61 wrenched wrench VBN 31504 283 62 from from IN 31504 283 63 nature nature NN 31504 283 64 or or CC 31504 283 65 otherwise otherwise RB 31504 283 66 obtained obtain VBN 31504 283 67 by by IN 31504 283 68 the the DT 31504 283 69 exercise exercise NN 31504 283 70 of of IN 31504 283 71 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 283 72 various various JJ 31504 283 73 powers power NNS 31504 283 74 . . . 31504 284 1 This this DT 31504 284 2 instinct instinct NN 31504 284 3 is be VBZ 31504 284 4 also also RB 31504 284 5 observable observable JJ 31504 284 6 in in IN 31504 284 7 some some DT 31504 284 8 animals animal NNS 31504 284 9 . . . 31504 285 1 A a DT 31504 285 2 dog dog NN 31504 285 3 will will MD 31504 285 4 hide hide VB 31504 285 5 a a DT 31504 285 6 bone bone NN 31504 285 7 for for IN 31504 285 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 285 9 own own JJ 31504 285 10 exclusive exclusive JJ 31504 285 11 future future JJ 31504 285 12 use use NN 31504 285 13 . . . 31504 286 1 Man man NN 31504 286 2 also also RB 31504 286 3 instinctively instinctively RB 31504 286 4 claims claim VBZ 31504 286 5 for for IN 31504 286 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 286 7 own own JJ 31504 286 8 the the DT 31504 286 9 natural natural JJ 31504 286 10 increase increase NN 31504 286 11 of of IN 31504 286 12 what what WP 31504 286 13 he -PRON- PRP 31504 286 14 has have VBZ 31504 286 15 acquired acquire VBN 31504 286 16 , , , 31504 286 17 the the DT 31504 286 18 young young JJ 31504 286 19 of of IN 31504 286 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 286 21 beasts beast NNS 31504 286 22 , , , 31504 286 23 the the DT 31504 286 24 fruits fruit NNS 31504 286 25 of of IN 31504 286 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 286 27 orchard orchard NN 31504 286 28 . . . 31504 287 1 This this DT 31504 287 2 desire desire NN 31504 287 3 for for IN 31504 287 4 control control NN 31504 287 5 includes include VBZ 31504 287 6 the the DT 31504 287 7 desire desire NN 31504 287 8 to to TO 31504 287 9 store store VB 31504 287 10 up up RP 31504 287 11 , , , 31504 287 12 to to TO 31504 287 13 use use VB 31504 287 14 , , , 31504 287 15 to to TO 31504 287 16 consume consume VB 31504 287 17 , , , 31504 287 18 to to TO 31504 287 19 transfer transfer VB 31504 287 20 , , , 31504 287 21 and and CC 31504 287 22 even even RB 31504 287 23 to to TO 31504 287 24 destroy destroy VB 31504 287 25 at at IN 31504 287 26 will will NN 31504 287 27 . . . 31504 288 1 This this DT 31504 288 2 desire desire NN 31504 288 3 is be VBZ 31504 288 4 seen see VBN 31504 288 5 in in IN 31504 288 6 young young JJ 31504 288 7 children child NNS 31504 288 8 , , , 31504 288 9 who who WP 31504 288 10 will will MD 31504 288 11 try try VB 31504 288 12 to to TO 31504 288 13 clutch clutch VB 31504 288 14 and and CC 31504 288 15 hold hold VB 31504 288 16 whatever whatever WDT 31504 288 17 attracts attract VBZ 31504 288 18 them -PRON- PRP 31504 288 19 , , , 31504 288 20 and and CC 31504 288 21 who who WP 31504 288 22 will will MD 31504 288 23 hoard hoard VB 31504 288 24 or or CC 31504 288 25 break break VB 31504 288 26 toys toy NNS 31504 288 27 or or CC 31504 288 28 throw throw VB 31504 288 29 them -PRON- PRP 31504 288 30 away away RB 31504 288 31 as as IN 31504 288 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 288 33 whims whim NNS 31504 288 34 may may MD 31504 288 35 be be VB 31504 288 36 . . . 31504 289 1 As as IN 31504 289 2 they -PRON- PRP 31504 289 3 get get VBP 31504 289 4 older old JJR 31504 289 5 the the DT 31504 289 6 desire desire NN 31504 289 7 to to TO 31504 289 8 control control VB 31504 289 9 grows grow VBZ 31504 289 10 stronger strong JJR 31504 289 11 , , , 31504 289 12 for for IN 31504 289 13 they -PRON- PRP 31504 289 14 destroy destroy VBP 31504 289 15 less less JJR 31504 289 16 and and CC 31504 289 17 preserve preserve VB 31504 289 18 more more RBR 31504 289 19 in in IN 31504 289 20 order order NN 31504 289 21 to to TO 31504 289 22 have have VB 31504 289 23 greater great JJR 31504 289 24 measure measure NN 31504 289 25 of of IN 31504 289 26 control control NN 31504 289 27 ; ; : 31504 289 28 but but CC 31504 289 29 still still RB 31504 289 30 they -PRON- PRP 31504 289 31 desire desire VBP 31504 289 32 freedom freedom NN 31504 289 33 to to TO 31504 289 34 consume consume VB 31504 289 35 or or CC 31504 289 36 destroy destroy VB 31504 289 37 at at IN 31504 289 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 289 39 own own JJ 31504 289 40 will will NN 31504 289 41 . . . 31504 290 1 So so RB 31504 290 2 strong strong JJ 31504 290 3 is be VBZ 31504 290 4 this this DT 31504 290 5 desire desire NN 31504 290 6 of of IN 31504 290 7 control control NN 31504 290 8 that that IN 31504 290 9 men man NNS 31504 290 10 wish wish VBP 31504 290 11 to to TO 31504 290 12 direct direct VB 31504 290 13 what what WP 31504 290 14 shall shall MD 31504 290 15 be be VB 31504 290 16 done do VBN 31504 290 17 with with IN 31504 290 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 290 19 property property NN 31504 290 20 after after IN 31504 290 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 290 22 death death NN 31504 290 23 . . . 31504 291 1 If if IN 31504 291 2 one one CD 31504 291 3 is be VBZ 31504 291 4 balked balk VBN 31504 291 5 or or CC 31504 291 6 hindered hinder VBN 31504 291 7 in in IN 31504 291 8 the the DT 31504 291 9 gratification gratification NN 31504 291 10 of of IN 31504 291 11 any any DT 31504 291 12 of of IN 31504 291 13 these these DT 31504 291 14 desires desire NNS 31504 291 15 , , , 31504 291 16 there there EX 31504 291 17 is be VBZ 31504 291 18 excited excited JJ 31504 291 19 in in IN 31504 291 20 him -PRON- PRP 31504 291 21 a a DT 31504 291 22 feeling feeling NN 31504 291 23 of of IN 31504 291 24 resentment resentment NN 31504 291 25 against against IN 31504 291 26 the the DT 31504 291 27 cause cause NN 31504 291 28 , , , 31504 291 29 even even RB 31504 291 30 if if IN 31504 291 31 it -PRON- PRP 31504 291 32 be be VBP 31504 291 33 only only RB 31504 291 34 some some DT 31504 291 35 force force NN 31504 291 36 of of IN 31504 291 37 nature nature NN 31504 291 38 . . . 31504 292 1 There there EX 31504 292 2 is be VBZ 31504 292 3 a a DT 31504 292 4 note note NN 31504 292 5 of of IN 31504 292 6 anger anger NN 31504 292 7 in in IN 31504 292 8 the the DT 31504 292 9 cries cry NNS 31504 292 10 of of IN 31504 292 11 a a DT 31504 292 12 child child NN 31504 292 13 over over IN 31504 292 14 interference interference NN 31504 292 15 with with IN 31504 292 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 292 17 play play NN 31504 292 18 , , , 31504 292 19 the the DT 31504 292 20 deprivation deprivation NN 31504 292 21 of of IN 31504 292 22 any any DT 31504 292 23 toy toy NN 31504 292 24 or or CC 31504 292 25 other other JJ 31504 292 26 thing thing NN 31504 292 27 he -PRON- PRP 31504 292 28 may may MD 31504 292 29 have have VB 31504 292 30 or or CC 31504 292 31 desire desire VB 31504 292 32 . . . 31504 293 1 That that IN 31504 293 2 the the DT 31504 293 3 wind wind NN 31504 293 4 or or CC 31504 293 5 the the DT 31504 293 6 rain rain NN 31504 293 7 was be VBD 31504 293 8 the the DT 31504 293 9 cause cause NN 31504 293 10 does do VBZ 31504 293 11 not not RB 31504 293 12 sooth sooth VB 31504 293 13 him -PRON- PRP 31504 293 14 . . . 31504 294 1 In in IN 31504 294 2 the the DT 31504 294 3 mature mature JJ 31504 294 4 man man NN 31504 294 5 also also RB 31504 294 6 , , , 31504 294 7 anger anger NN 31504 294 8 adds add VBZ 31504 294 9 some some DT 31504 294 10 force force NN 31504 294 11 to to IN 31504 294 12 the the DT 31504 294 13 kick kick NN 31504 294 14 he -PRON- PRP 31504 294 15 gives give VBZ 31504 294 16 even even RB 31504 294 17 inanimate inanimate JJ 31504 294 18 objects object NNS 31504 294 19 unexpectedly unexpectedly RB 31504 294 20 impeding impede VBG 31504 294 21 him -PRON- PRP 31504 294 22 . . . 31504 295 1 Who who WP 31504 295 2 of of IN 31504 295 3 us -PRON- PRP 31504 295 4 has have VBZ 31504 295 5 ever ever RB 31504 295 6 fallen fall VBN 31504 295 7 over over IN 31504 295 8 a a DT 31504 295 9 chair chair NN 31504 295 10 in in IN 31504 295 11 the the DT 31504 295 12 dark dark NN 31504 295 13 without without IN 31504 295 14 mentally mentally RB 31504 295 15 , , , 31504 295 16 at at IN 31504 295 17 least least JJS 31504 295 18 , , , 31504 295 19 consigning consign VBG 31504 295 20 it -PRON- PRP 31504 295 21 to to IN 31504 295 22 perdition perdition NN 31504 295 23 ? ? . 31504 296 1 The the DT 31504 296 2 old old JJ 31504 296 3 law law NN 31504 296 4 of of IN 31504 296 5 Deodand Deodand NNP 31504 296 6 was be VBD 31504 296 7 an an DT 31504 296 8 expression expression NN 31504 296 9 of of IN 31504 296 10 this this DT 31504 296 11 feeling feeling NN 31504 296 12 of of IN 31504 296 13 resentment resentment NN 31504 296 14 against against IN 31504 296 15 inanimate inanimate JJ 31504 296 16 objects object NNS 31504 296 17 even even RB 31504 296 18 . . . 31504 297 1 By by IN 31504 297 2 that that DT 31504 297 3 law law NN 31504 297 4 , , , 31504 297 5 according accord VBG 31504 297 6 to to IN 31504 297 7 Blackstone Blackstone NNP 31504 297 8 , , , 31504 297 9 whatever whatever WDT 31504 297 10 chattel chattel NNP 31504 297 11 was be VBD 31504 297 12 the the DT 31504 297 13 immediate immediate JJ 31504 297 14 cause cause NN 31504 297 15 of of IN 31504 297 16 the the DT 31504 297 17 death death NN 31504 297 18 of of IN 31504 297 19 a a DT 31504 297 20 reasonable reasonable JJ 31504 297 21 creature creature NN 31504 297 22 was be VBD 31504 297 23 forfeited forfeit VBN 31504 297 24 to to IN 31504 297 25 the the DT 31504 297 26 crown crown NN 31504 297 27 , , , 31504 297 28 as as IN 31504 297 29 when when WRB 31504 297 30 a a DT 31504 297 31 cart cart NN 31504 297 32 ran run VBD 31504 297 33 over over IN 31504 297 34 a a DT 31504 297 35 man man NN 31504 297 36 . . . 31504 298 1 By by IN 31504 298 2 the the DT 31504 298 3 laws law NNS 31504 298 4 of of IN 31504 298 5 Draco Draco NNP 31504 298 6 whatever whatever WDT 31504 298 7 caused cause VBD 31504 298 8 a a DT 31504 298 9 man man NN 31504 298 10 's 's POS 31504 298 11 death death NN 31504 298 12 by by IN 31504 298 13 falling fall VBG 31504 298 14 upon upon IN 31504 298 15 him -PRON- PRP 31504 298 16 was be VBD 31504 298 17 to to TO 31504 298 18 be be VB 31504 298 19 destroyed destroy VBN 31504 298 20 or or CC 31504 298 21 cast cast VBN 31504 298 22 out out IN 31504 298 23 of of IN 31504 298 24 the the DT 31504 298 25 community community NN 31504 298 26 . . . 31504 299 1 Thus thus RB 31504 299 2 a a DT 31504 299 3 statue statue NN 31504 299 4 having have VBG 31504 299 5 fallen fall VBN 31504 299 6 upon upon IN 31504 299 7 a a DT 31504 299 8 man man NN 31504 299 9 , , , 31504 299 10 it -PRON- PRP 31504 299 11 was be VBD 31504 299 12 thrown throw VBN 31504 299 13 into into IN 31504 299 14 the the DT 31504 299 15 sea sea NN 31504 299 16 . . . 31504 300 1 The the DT 31504 300 2 Mosaic Mosaic NNP 31504 300 3 law law NN 31504 300 4 savagely savagely RB 31504 300 5 declared declare VBD 31504 300 6 : : : 31504 300 7 " " `` 31504 300 8 If if IN 31504 300 9 an an DT 31504 300 10 ox ox FW 31504 300 11 gore gore NNP 31504 300 12 a a DT 31504 300 13 man man NN 31504 300 14 that that WDT 31504 300 15 he -PRON- PRP 31504 300 16 die die VBP 31504 300 17 , , , 31504 300 18 the the DT 31504 300 19 ox ox NN 31504 300 20 shall shall MD 31504 300 21 be be VB 31504 300 22 stoned stone VBN 31504 300 23 and and CC 31504 300 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 300 25 flesh flesh NN 31504 300 26 shall shall MD 31504 300 27 not not RB 31504 300 28 be be VB 31504 300 29 eaten eat VBN 31504 300 30 . . . 31504 300 31 " " '' 31504 301 1 Is be VBZ 31504 301 2 not not RB 31504 301 3 this this DT 31504 301 4 instinctive instinctive JJ 31504 301 5 feeling feeling NN 31504 301 6 of of IN 31504 301 7 resentment resentment NN 31504 301 8 at at IN 31504 301 9 interference interference NN 31504 301 10 with with IN 31504 301 11 one one NN 31504 301 12 's 's POS 31504 301 13 person person NN 31504 301 14 , , , 31504 301 15 liberty liberty NN 31504 301 16 , , , 31504 301 17 or or CC 31504 301 18 property property NN 31504 301 19 , , , 31504 301 20 the the DT 31504 301 21 rudiment rudiment NN 31504 301 22 of of IN 31504 301 23 a a DT 31504 301 24 later later RB 31504 301 25 developed developed JJ 31504 301 26 idea idea NN 31504 301 27 , , , 31504 301 28 or or CC 31504 301 29 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 301 30 , , , 31504 301 31 of of IN 31504 301 32 rights right NNS 31504 301 33 possessed possess VBN 31504 301 34 ? ? . 31504 302 1 Resentment Resentment NNP 31504 302 2 is be VBZ 31504 302 3 felt feel VBN 31504 302 4 only only RB 31504 302 5 when when WRB 31504 302 6 one one PRP 31504 302 7 is be VBZ 31504 302 8 deprived deprive VBN 31504 302 9 of of IN 31504 302 10 something something NN 31504 302 11 he -PRON- PRP 31504 302 12 feels feel VBZ 31504 302 13 he -PRON- PRP 31504 302 14 is be VBZ 31504 302 15 entitled entitle VBN 31504 302 16 to to IN 31504 302 17 . . . 31504 303 1 Granting grant VBG 31504 303 2 that that IN 31504 303 3 nature nature NN 31504 303 4 has have VBZ 31504 303 5 not not RB 31504 303 6 endowed endow VBN 31504 303 7 man man NN 31504 303 8 with with IN 31504 303 9 rights right NNS 31504 303 10 , , , 31504 303 11 it -PRON- PRP 31504 303 12 has have VBZ 31504 303 13 imbued imbue VBN 31504 303 14 him -PRON- PRP 31504 303 15 with with IN 31504 303 16 a a DT 31504 303 17 belief belief NN 31504 303 18 that that IN 31504 303 19 he -PRON- PRP 31504 303 20 has have VBZ 31504 303 21 rights right NNS 31504 303 22 , , , 31504 303 23 and and CC 31504 303 24 also also RB 31504 303 25 with with IN 31504 303 26 a a DT 31504 303 27 disposition disposition NN 31504 303 28 to to TO 31504 303 29 defend defend VB 31504 303 30 them -PRON- PRP 31504 303 31 . . . 31504 304 1 Man man NN 31504 304 2 is be VBZ 31504 304 3 also also RB 31504 304 4 born bear VBN 31504 304 5 into into IN 31504 304 6 a a DT 31504 304 7 material material JJ 31504 304 8 world world NN 31504 304 9 of of IN 31504 304 10 natural natural JJ 31504 304 11 forces force NNS 31504 304 12 , , , 31504 304 13 and and CC 31504 304 14 hence hence RB 31504 304 15 to to TO 31504 304 16 gratify gratify VB 31504 304 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 304 18 desire desire NN 31504 304 19 to to TO 31504 304 20 live live VB 31504 304 21 and and CC 31504 304 22 serve serve VB 31504 304 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 304 24 own own JJ 31504 304 25 welfare welfare NN 31504 304 26 and and CC 31504 304 27 that that DT 31504 304 28 of of IN 31504 304 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 304 30 offspring offspring NN 31504 304 31 , , , 31504 304 32 he -PRON- PRP 31504 304 33 must must MD 31504 304 34 adapt adapt VB 31504 304 35 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 304 36 to to IN 31504 304 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 304 38 environment environment NN 31504 304 39 , , , 31504 304 40 fit fit VB 31504 304 41 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 304 42 to to TO 31504 304 43 withstand withstand VB 31504 304 44 heat heat NN 31504 304 45 and and CC 31504 304 46 cold cold JJ 31504 304 47 , , , 31504 304 48 provide provide VB 31504 304 49 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 304 50 with with IN 31504 304 51 food food NN 31504 304 52 and and CC 31504 304 53 shelter shelter NN 31504 304 54 . . . 31504 305 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 305 2 not not RB 31504 305 3 only only RB 31504 305 4 desires desire VBZ 31504 305 5 to to IN 31504 305 6 , , , 31504 305 7 but but CC 31504 305 8 he -PRON- PRP 31504 305 9 must must MD 31504 305 10 , , , 31504 305 11 exercise exercise VB 31504 305 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 305 13 powers power NNS 31504 305 14 of of IN 31504 305 15 mind mind NN 31504 305 16 and and CC 31504 305 17 body body NN 31504 305 18 and and CC 31504 305 19 hence hence RB 31504 305 20 should should MD 31504 305 21 be be VB 31504 305 22 free free JJ 31504 305 23 to to TO 31504 305 24 exercise exercise VB 31504 305 25 them -PRON- PRP 31504 305 26 to to IN 31504 305 27 that that DT 31504 305 28 extent extent NN 31504 305 29 at at IN 31504 305 30 least least JJS 31504 305 31 . . . 31504 306 1 Nature nature NN 31504 306 2 does do VBZ 31504 306 3 not not RB 31504 306 4 feed feed VB 31504 306 5 , , , 31504 306 6 clothe clothe VB 31504 306 7 and and CC 31504 306 8 shelter shelter NN 31504 306 9 man man NN 31504 306 10 . . . 31504 307 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 307 2 only only RB 31504 307 3 provides provide VBZ 31504 307 4 the the DT 31504 307 5 raw raw JJ 31504 307 6 material material NN 31504 307 7 which which WDT 31504 307 8 man man NN 31504 307 9 must must MD 31504 307 10 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 307 11 find find VB 31504 307 12 , , , 31504 307 13 take take VB 31504 307 14 , , , 31504 307 15 and and CC 31504 307 16 convert convert VB 31504 307 17 by by IN 31504 307 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 307 19 labor labor NN 31504 307 20 , , , 31504 307 21 manual manual JJ 31504 307 22 and and CC 31504 307 23 intellectual intellectual JJ 31504 307 24 , , , 31504 307 25 into into IN 31504 307 26 food food NN 31504 307 27 , , , 31504 307 28 clothing clothing NN 31504 307 29 , , , 31504 307 30 shelter shelter NN 31504 307 31 , , , 31504 307 32 and and CC 31504 307 33 whatever whatever WDT 31504 307 34 else else RB 31504 307 35 he -PRON- PRP 31504 307 36 desires desire VBZ 31504 307 37 . . . 31504 308 1 But but CC 31504 308 2 man man NN 31504 308 3 is be VBZ 31504 308 4 also also RB 31504 308 5 born bear VBN 31504 308 6 into into IN 31504 308 7 association association NN 31504 308 8 with with IN 31504 308 9 other other JJ 31504 308 10 men man NNS 31504 308 11 , , , 31504 308 12 into into IN 31504 308 13 some some DT 31504 308 14 sort sort NN 31504 308 15 of of IN 31504 308 16 social social JJ 31504 308 17 organization organization NN 31504 308 18 , , , 31504 308 19 and and CC 31504 308 20 well well RB 31504 308 21 for for IN 31504 308 22 him -PRON- PRP 31504 308 23 that that IN 31504 308 24 he -PRON- PRP 31504 308 25 is be VBZ 31504 308 26 . . . 31504 309 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 309 2 is be VBZ 31504 309 3 not not RB 31504 309 4 society society NN 31504 309 5 , , , 31504 309 6 however however RB 31504 309 7 ill ill RB 31504 309 8 organized organize VBN 31504 309 9 , , , 31504 309 10 that that WDT 31504 309 11 has have VBZ 31504 309 12 caused cause VBN 31504 309 13 , , , 31504 309 14 or or CC 31504 309 15 today today NN 31504 309 16 causes cause NNS 31504 309 17 , , , 31504 309 18 poverty poverty NN 31504 309 19 . . . 31504 310 1 That that DT 31504 310 2 is be VBZ 31504 310 3 the the DT 31504 310 4 primitive primitive JJ 31504 310 5 condition condition NN 31504 310 6 of of IN 31504 310 7 the the DT 31504 310 8 human human JJ 31504 310 9 race race NN 31504 310 10 . . . 31504 311 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 311 2 is be VBZ 31504 311 3 only only RB 31504 311 4 through through IN 31504 311 5 some some DT 31504 311 6 social social JJ 31504 311 7 organization organization NN 31504 311 8 ensuring ensure VBG 31504 311 9 to to IN 31504 311 10 man man VB 31504 311 11 freedom freedom NN 31504 311 12 for for IN 31504 311 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 311 14 labor labor NN 31504 311 15 and and CC 31504 311 16 security security NN 31504 311 17 for for IN 31504 311 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 311 19 savings saving NNS 31504 311 20 that that IN 31504 311 21 he -PRON- PRP 31504 311 22 can can MD 31504 311 23 escape escape VB 31504 311 24 poverty poverty NN 31504 311 25 . . . 31504 312 1 If if IN 31504 312 2 each each DT 31504 312 3 individual individual JJ 31504 312 4 by by IN 31504 312 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 312 6 own own JJ 31504 312 7 unaided unaided JJ 31504 312 8 efforts effort NNS 31504 312 9 had have VBD 31504 312 10 to to TO 31504 312 11 find find VB 31504 312 12 the the DT 31504 312 13 raw raw JJ 31504 312 14 material material NN 31504 312 15 , , , 31504 312 16 mold mold NN 31504 312 17 it -PRON- PRP 31504 312 18 to to TO 31504 312 19 serve serve VB 31504 312 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 312 21 needs need NNS 31504 312 22 and and CC 31504 312 23 desires desire NNS 31504 312 24 , , , 31504 312 25 and and CC 31504 312 26 also also RB 31504 312 27 defend defend VB 31504 312 28 it -PRON- PRP 31504 312 29 from from IN 31504 312 30 attacks attack NNS 31504 312 31 by by IN 31504 312 32 others other NNS 31504 312 33 , , , 31504 312 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 312 35 life life NN 31504 312 36 would would MD 31504 312 37 be be VB 31504 312 38 one one CD 31504 312 39 of of IN 31504 312 40 dire dire JJ 31504 312 41 poverty poverty NN 31504 312 42 , , , 31504 312 43 scarcely scarcely RB 31504 312 44 above above IN 31504 312 45 that that DT 31504 312 46 of of IN 31504 312 47 the the DT 31504 312 48 higher high JJR 31504 312 49 animals animal NNS 31504 312 50 . . . 31504 313 1 Further further RB 31504 313 2 , , , 31504 313 3 nature nature NN 31504 313 4 has have VBZ 31504 313 5 so so RB 31504 313 6 formed form VBN 31504 313 7 man man NN 31504 313 8 that that IN 31504 313 9 he -PRON- PRP 31504 313 10 not not RB 31504 313 11 only only RB 31504 313 12 needs need VBZ 31504 313 13 but but IN 31504 313 14 desires desire NNS 31504 313 15 association association NNP 31504 313 16 with with IN 31504 313 17 other other JJ 31504 313 18 men man NNS 31504 313 19 . . . 31504 314 1 Children child NNS 31504 314 2 instinctively instinctively RB 31504 314 3 flock flock VBP 31504 314 4 together together RB 31504 314 5 for for IN 31504 314 6 common common JJ 31504 314 7 play play NN 31504 314 8 , , , 31504 314 9 and and CC 31504 314 10 this this DT 31504 314 11 social social JJ 31504 314 12 instinct instinct NN 31504 314 13 continues continue VBZ 31504 314 14 through through IN 31504 314 15 life life NN 31504 314 16 and and CC 31504 314 17 extends extend VBZ 31504 314 18 to to TO 31504 314 19 work work VB 31504 314 20 as as RB 31504 314 21 well well RB 31504 314 22 as as IN 31504 314 23 play play NN 31504 314 24 . . . 31504 315 1 We -PRON- PRP 31504 315 2 find find VBP 31504 315 3 men man NNS 31504 315 4 everywhere everywhere RB 31504 315 5 in in IN 31504 315 6 the the DT 31504 315 7 civilized civilized JJ 31504 315 8 world world NN 31504 315 9 voluntarily voluntarily RB 31504 315 10 entering enter VBG 31504 315 11 into into IN 31504 315 12 associations association NNS 31504 315 13 for for IN 31504 315 14 various various JJ 31504 315 15 purposes purpose NNS 31504 315 16 thought think VBN 31504 315 17 by by IN 31504 315 18 the the DT 31504 315 19 members member NNS 31504 315 20 to to TO 31504 315 21 be be VB 31504 315 22 of of IN 31504 315 23 service service NN 31504 315 24 to to IN 31504 315 25 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 315 26 or or CC 31504 315 27 others other NNS 31504 315 28 . . . 31504 316 1 But but CC 31504 316 2 there there EX 31504 316 3 is be VBZ 31504 316 4 over over RB 31504 316 5 and and CC 31504 316 6 surrounding surround VBG 31504 316 7 these these DT 31504 316 8 associations association NNS 31504 316 9 that that WDT 31504 316 10 larger large JJR 31504 316 11 association association NN 31504 316 12 , , , 31504 316 13 racial racial JJ 31504 316 14 or or CC 31504 316 15 territorial territorial JJ 31504 316 16 , , , 31504 316 17 which which WDT 31504 316 18 we -PRON- PRP 31504 316 19 call call VBP 31504 316 20 society society NN 31504 316 21 . . . 31504 317 1 This this DT 31504 317 2 is be VBZ 31504 317 3 the the DT 31504 317 4 necessary necessary JJ 31504 317 5 association association NN 31504 317 6 into into IN 31504 317 7 which which WDT 31504 317 8 man man NN 31504 317 9 is be VBZ 31504 317 10 born bear VBN 31504 317 11 and and CC 31504 317 12 in in IN 31504 317 13 which which WDT 31504 317 14 he -PRON- PRP 31504 317 15 must must MD 31504 317 16 live live VB 31504 317 17 if if IN 31504 317 18 he -PRON- PRP 31504 317 19 desires desire VBZ 31504 317 20 other other JJ 31504 317 21 than than IN 31504 317 22 mere mere JJ 31504 317 23 animal animal NN 31504 317 24 life life NN 31504 317 25 . . . 31504 318 1 This this DT 31504 318 2 society society NN 31504 318 3 must must MD 31504 318 4 be be VB 31504 318 5 maintained maintain VBN 31504 318 6 if if IN 31504 318 7 the the DT 31504 318 8 race race NN 31504 318 9 of of IN 31504 318 10 men man NNS 31504 318 11 , , , 31504 318 12 as as IN 31504 318 13 men man NNS 31504 318 14 and and CC 31504 318 15 not not RB 31504 318 16 as as IN 31504 318 17 mere mere JJ 31504 318 18 animals animal NNS 31504 318 19 , , , 31504 318 20 is be VBZ 31504 318 21 to to TO 31504 318 22 continue continue VB 31504 318 23 . . . 31504 319 1 Indeed indeed RB 31504 319 2 , , , 31504 319 3 society society NN 31504 319 4 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 319 5 has have VBZ 31504 319 6 a a DT 31504 319 7 sort sort NN 31504 319 8 of of IN 31504 319 9 instinct instinct NN 31504 319 10 for for IN 31504 319 11 self self NN 31504 319 12 - - HYPH 31504 319 13 preservation preservation NN 31504 319 14 . . . 31504 320 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 320 2 is be VBZ 31504 320 3 not not RB 31504 320 4 a a DT 31504 320 5 mere mere JJ 31504 320 6 aggregation aggregation NN 31504 320 7 of of IN 31504 320 8 individual individual JJ 31504 320 9 units unit NNS 31504 320 10 but but CC 31504 320 11 is be VBZ 31504 320 12 an an DT 31504 320 13 association association NN 31504 320 14 of of IN 31504 320 15 sentient sentient NNP 31504 320 16 correlated correlate VBD 31504 320 17 beings being NNS 31504 320 18 with with IN 31504 320 19 a a DT 31504 320 20 resultant resultant JJ 31504 320 21 life life NN 31504 320 22 and and CC 31504 320 23 movement movement NN 31504 320 24 of of IN 31504 320 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 320 26 own own JJ 31504 320 27 . . . 31504 321 1 Association Association NNP 31504 321 2 , , , 31504 321 3 however however RB 31504 321 4 , , , 31504 321 5 does do VBZ 31504 321 6 not not RB 31504 321 7 extinguish extinguish VB 31504 321 8 nor nor CC 31504 321 9 appreciably appreciably RB 31504 321 10 lessen lessen VBD 31504 321 11 the the DT 31504 321 12 natural natural JJ 31504 321 13 instincts instinct NNS 31504 321 14 , , , 31504 321 15 desires desire NNS 31504 321 16 , , , 31504 321 17 feelings feeling NNS 31504 321 18 , , , 31504 321 19 sentiments sentiment NNS 31504 321 20 , , , 31504 321 21 etc etc FW 31504 321 22 . . . 31504 321 23 , , , 31504 321 24 of of IN 31504 321 25 the the DT 31504 321 26 individual individual NN 31504 321 27 , , , 31504 321 28 though though IN 31504 321 29 they -PRON- PRP 31504 321 30 may may MD 31504 321 31 be be VB 31504 321 32 made make VBN 31504 321 33 less less RBR 31504 321 34 active active JJ 31504 321 35 by by IN 31504 321 36 continued continued JJ 31504 321 37 restraint restraint NN 31504 321 38 . . . 31504 322 1 Association Association NNP 31504 322 2 even even RB 31504 322 3 extends extend VBZ 31504 322 4 the the DT 31504 322 5 scope scope NN 31504 322 6 of of IN 31504 322 7 man man NN 31504 322 8 's 's POS 31504 322 9 individual individual JJ 31504 322 10 desires desire NNS 31504 322 11 and and CC 31504 322 12 activities activity NNS 31504 322 13 . . . 31504 323 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 323 2 now now RB 31504 323 3 desires desire VBZ 31504 323 4 freedom freedom NN 31504 323 5 to to TO 31504 323 6 make make VB 31504 323 7 arrangements arrangement NNS 31504 323 8 with with IN 31504 323 9 other other JJ 31504 323 10 men man NNS 31504 323 11 of of IN 31504 323 12 such such JJ 31504 323 13 nature nature NN 31504 323 14 and and CC 31504 323 15 for for IN 31504 323 16 such such JJ 31504 323 17 purposes purpose NNS 31504 323 18 as as IN 31504 323 19 he -PRON- PRP 31504 323 20 and and CC 31504 323 21 they -PRON- PRP 31504 323 22 may may MD 31504 323 23 agree agree VB 31504 323 24 upon upon IN 31504 323 25 . . . 31504 324 1 If if IN 31504 324 2 he -PRON- PRP 31504 324 3 is be VBZ 31504 324 4 prevented prevent VBN 31504 324 5 by by IN 31504 324 6 authority authority NN 31504 324 7 from from IN 31504 324 8 making make VBG 31504 324 9 such such JJ 31504 324 10 arrangements arrangement NNS 31504 324 11 he -PRON- PRP 31504 324 12 feels feel VBZ 31504 324 13 some some DT 31504 324 14 resentment resentment NN 31504 324 15 , , , 31504 324 16 feels feel VBZ 31504 324 17 that that IN 31504 324 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 324 19 right right NN 31504 324 20 is be VBZ 31504 324 21 infringed infringe VBN 31504 324 22 . . . 31504 325 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 325 2 also also RB 31504 325 3 comes come VBZ 31504 325 4 to to TO 31504 325 5 desire desire VB 31504 325 6 that that IN 31504 325 7 those those DT 31504 325 8 who who WP 31504 325 9 have have VBP 31504 325 10 entered enter VBN 31504 325 11 into into IN 31504 325 12 arrangements arrangement NNS 31504 325 13 or or CC 31504 325 14 contracts contract NNS 31504 325 15 with with IN 31504 325 16 him -PRON- PRP 31504 325 17 should should MD 31504 325 18 perform perform VB 31504 325 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 325 20 part part NN 31504 325 21 , , , 31504 325 22 and and CC 31504 325 23 he -PRON- PRP 31504 325 24 instinctively instinctively RB 31504 325 25 feels feel VBZ 31504 325 26 resentment resentment NN 31504 325 27 at at IN 31504 325 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 325 29 neglect neglect NN 31504 325 30 or or CC 31504 325 31 refusal refusal NN 31504 325 32 to to TO 31504 325 33 do do VB 31504 325 34 so so RB 31504 325 35 . . . 31504 326 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 326 2 feels feel VBZ 31504 326 3 that that IN 31504 326 4 he -PRON- PRP 31504 326 5 has have VBZ 31504 326 6 a a DT 31504 326 7 right right NN 31504 326 8 to to IN 31504 326 9 the the DT 31504 326 10 performance performance NN 31504 326 11 of of IN 31504 326 12 the the DT 31504 326 13 contract contract NN 31504 326 14 . . . 31504 327 1 Another another DT 31504 327 2 desire desire NN 31504 327 3 is be VBZ 31504 327 4 developed develop VBN 31504 327 5 or or CC 31504 327 6 given give VBN 31504 327 7 play play NN 31504 327 8 by by IN 31504 327 9 society,--the society,--the DT 31504 327 10 desire desire NN 31504 327 11 to to TO 31504 327 12 equal equal VB 31504 327 13 one one PRP 31504 327 14 's 's POS 31504 327 15 fellows fellow NNS 31504 327 16 in in IN 31504 327 17 the the DT 31504 327 18 race race NN 31504 327 19 for for IN 31504 327 20 benefits benefit NNS 31504 327 21 , , , 31504 327 22 and and CC 31504 327 23 , , , 31504 327 24 that that DT 31504 327 25 accomplished accomplish VBN 31504 327 26 , , , 31504 327 27 to to TO 31504 327 28 excel excel VB 31504 327 29 them -PRON- PRP 31504 327 30 . . . 31504 328 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 328 2 desires desire VBZ 31504 328 3 to to TO 31504 328 4 win win VB 31504 328 5 in in IN 31504 328 6 every every DT 31504 328 7 game game NN 31504 328 8 , , , 31504 328 9 to to TO 31504 328 10 be be VB 31504 328 11 the the DT 31504 328 12 victor victor NN 31504 328 13 in in IN 31504 328 14 every every DT 31504 328 15 contest contest NN 31504 328 16 of of IN 31504 328 17 physical physical JJ 31504 328 18 or or CC 31504 328 19 mental mental JJ 31504 328 20 powers power NNS 31504 328 21 , , , 31504 328 22 and and CC 31504 328 23 in in IN 31504 328 24 business business NN 31504 328 25 as as RB 31504 328 26 well well RB 31504 328 27 as as IN 31504 328 28 in in IN 31504 328 29 sports sport NNS 31504 328 30 . . . 31504 329 1 If if IN 31504 329 2 he -PRON- PRP 31504 329 3 is be VBZ 31504 329 4 held hold VBN 31504 329 5 back back RP 31504 329 6 he -PRON- PRP 31504 329 7 feels feel VBZ 31504 329 8 resentment resentment NN 31504 329 9 against against IN 31504 329 10 the the DT 31504 329 11 power power NN 31504 329 12 assuming assume VBG 31504 329 13 to to TO 31504 329 14 restrain restrain VB 31504 329 15 him -PRON- PRP 31504 329 16 . . . 31504 330 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 330 2 thus thus RB 31504 330 3 feels feel VBZ 31504 330 4 he -PRON- PRP 31504 330 5 has have VBZ 31504 330 6 a a DT 31504 330 7 right right NN 31504 330 8 to to TO 31504 330 9 equal equal VB 31504 330 10 and and CC 31504 330 11 to to TO 31504 330 12 excel excel VB 31504 330 13 if if IN 31504 330 14 he -PRON- PRP 31504 330 15 can can MD 31504 330 16 . . . 31504 331 1 Whether whether IN 31504 331 2 competition competition NN 31504 331 3 should should MD 31504 331 4 be be VB 31504 331 5 enforced enforce VBN 31504 331 6 or or CC 31504 331 7 stimulated stimulate VBN 31504 331 8 by by IN 31504 331 9 society society NN 31504 331 10 is be VBZ 31504 331 11 a a DT 31504 331 12 question question NN 31504 331 13 in in IN 31504 331 14 economics economic NNS 31504 331 15 . . . 31504 332 1 What what WP 31504 332 2 affects affect VBZ 31504 332 3 the the DT 31504 332 4 question question NN 31504 332 5 of of IN 31504 332 6 rights right NNS 31504 332 7 and and CC 31504 332 8 hence hence RB 31504 332 9 of of IN 31504 332 10 justice justice NN 31504 332 11 is be VBZ 31504 332 12 whether whether IN 31504 332 13 this this DT 31504 332 14 desire desire NN 31504 332 15 to to TO 31504 332 16 excel excel VB 31504 332 17 should should MD 31504 332 18 be be VB 31504 332 19 impeded impede VBN 31504 332 20 . . . 31504 333 1 In in IN 31504 333 2 this this DT 31504 333 3 association association NN 31504 333 4 , , , 31504 333 5 however however RB 31504 333 6 , , , 31504 333 7 each each DT 31504 333 8 individual individual JJ 31504 333 9 man man NN 31504 333 10 finds find VBZ 31504 333 11 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 333 12 in in IN 31504 333 13 close close JJ 31504 333 14 contact contact NN 31504 333 15 all all RB 31504 333 16 through through IN 31504 333 17 life life NN 31504 333 18 with with IN 31504 333 19 other other JJ 31504 333 20 men man NNS 31504 333 21 having have VBG 31504 333 22 like like IN 31504 333 23 instincts instinct NNS 31504 333 24 , , , 31504 333 25 desires desire NNS 31504 333 26 , , , 31504 333 27 feelings feeling NNS 31504 333 28 , , , 31504 333 29 emotions emotion NNS 31504 333 30 , , , 31504 333 31 etc etc FW 31504 333 32 . . FW 31504 333 33 , , , 31504 333 34 as as IN 31504 333 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 333 36 own own JJ 31504 333 37 ; ; : 31504 333 38 and and CC 31504 333 39 who who WP 31504 333 40 also also RB 31504 333 41 feel feel VBP 31504 333 42 like like IN 31504 333 43 resentments resentment NNS 31504 333 44 and and CC 31504 333 45 have have VBP 31504 333 46 like like IN 31504 333 47 notions notion NNS 31504 333 48 of of IN 31504 333 49 rights right NNS 31504 333 50 possessed possess VBD 31504 333 51 . . . 31504 334 1 If if IN 31504 334 2 each each DT 31504 334 3 is be VBZ 31504 334 4 left leave VBN 31504 334 5 by by IN 31504 334 6 society society NN 31504 334 7 free free JJ 31504 334 8 to to TO 31504 334 9 gratify gratify VB 31504 334 10 these these DT 31504 334 11 desires desire NNS 31504 334 12 or or CC 31504 334 13 to to TO 31504 334 14 enforce enforce VB 31504 334 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 334 16 claims claim NNS 31504 334 17 of of IN 31504 334 18 rights right NNS 31504 334 19 in in IN 31504 334 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 334 21 own own JJ 31504 334 22 way way NN 31504 334 23 unmindful unmindful JJ 31504 334 24 how how WRB 31504 334 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 334 26 action action NN 31504 334 27 may may MD 31504 334 28 affect affect VB 31504 334 29 others other NNS 31504 334 30 ; ; : 31504 334 31 if if IN 31504 334 32 they -PRON- PRP 31504 334 33 be be VB 31504 334 34 left leave VBN 31504 334 35 free free JJ 31504 334 36 to to TO 31504 334 37 " " `` 31504 334 38 take take VB 31504 334 39 who who WP 31504 334 40 have have VBP 31504 334 41 the the DT 31504 334 42 power power NN 31504 334 43 " " '' 31504 334 44 and and CC 31504 334 45 only only RB 31504 334 46 they -PRON- PRP 31504 334 47 may may MD 31504 334 48 " " `` 31504 334 49 keep keep VB 31504 334 50 who who WP 31504 334 51 can can MD 31504 334 52 , , , 31504 334 53 " " `` 31504 334 54 society society NN 31504 334 55 could could MD 31504 334 56 not not RB 31504 334 57 exist exist VB 31504 334 58 and and CC 31504 334 59 civilization civilization NN 31504 334 60 , , , 31504 334 61 if if IN 31504 334 62 not not RB 31504 334 63 the the DT 31504 334 64 race race NN 31504 334 65 , , , 31504 334 66 would would MD 31504 334 67 perish perish VB 31504 334 68 . . . 31504 335 1 Society society NN 31504 335 2 , , , 31504 335 3 therefore therefore RB 31504 335 4 , , , 31504 335 5 must must MD 31504 335 6 frame frame VB 31504 335 7 and and CC 31504 335 8 enforce enforce VB 31504 335 9 rules rule NNS 31504 335 10 for for IN 31504 335 11 the the DT 31504 335 12 regulation regulation NN 31504 335 13 and and CC 31504 335 14 control control NN 31504 335 15 of of IN 31504 335 16 the the DT 31504 335 17 conduct conduct NN 31504 335 18 of of IN 31504 335 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 335 20 individual individual JJ 31504 335 21 members member NNS 31504 335 22 , , , 31504 335 23 must must MD 31504 335 24 even even RB 31504 335 25 restrain restrain VB 31504 335 26 them -PRON- PRP 31504 335 27 to to IN 31504 335 28 some some DT 31504 335 29 extent extent NN 31504 335 30 from from IN 31504 335 31 the the DT 31504 335 32 gratification gratification NN 31504 335 33 of of IN 31504 335 34 some some DT 31504 335 35 of of IN 31504 335 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 335 37 desires desire NNS 31504 335 38 . . . 31504 336 1 On on IN 31504 336 2 the the DT 31504 336 3 other other JJ 31504 336 4 hand hand NN 31504 336 5 , , , 31504 336 6 these these DT 31504 336 7 instincts instinct NNS 31504 336 8 , , , 31504 336 9 desires desire NNS 31504 336 10 , , , 31504 336 11 etc etc FW 31504 336 12 . . FW 31504 336 13 , , , 31504 336 14 must must MD 31504 336 15 still still RB 31504 336 16 be be VB 31504 336 17 reckoned reckon VBN 31504 336 18 with with IN 31504 336 19 . . . 31504 337 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 337 2 can can MD 31504 337 3 not not RB 31504 337 4 be be VB 31504 337 5 wholly wholly RB 31504 337 6 suppressed suppress VBN 31504 337 7 nor nor CC 31504 337 8 even even RB 31504 337 9 very very RB 31504 337 10 much much RB 31504 337 11 reduced reduce VBN 31504 337 12 or or CC 31504 337 13 impeded impede VBN 31504 337 14 if if IN 31504 337 15 society society NN 31504 337 16 is be VBZ 31504 337 17 to to TO 31504 337 18 progress progress VB 31504 337 19 or or CC 31504 337 20 even even RB 31504 337 21 exist exist VB 31504 337 22 . . . 31504 338 1 There there EX 31504 338 2 must must MD 31504 338 3 be be VB 31504 338 4 left leave VBN 31504 338 5 to to IN 31504 338 6 the the DT 31504 338 7 individual individual NN 31504 338 8 some some DT 31504 338 9 degree degree NN 31504 338 10 of of IN 31504 338 11 liberty liberty NN 31504 338 12 of of IN 31504 338 13 choice choice NN 31504 338 14 and and CC 31504 338 15 action action NN 31504 338 16 . . . 31504 339 1 An an DT 31504 339 2 eminent eminent JJ 31504 339 3 American american JJ 31504 339 4 jurist jurist NN 31504 339 5 , , , 31504 339 6 James James NNP 31504 339 7 C. C. NNP 31504 339 8 Carter Carter NNP 31504 339 9 , , , 31504 339 10 vividly vividly RB 31504 339 11 stated state VBD 31504 339 12 this this DT 31504 339 13 , , , 31504 339 14 though though IN 31504 339 15 perhaps perhaps RB 31504 339 16 in in IN 31504 339 17 the the DT 31504 339 18 extreme extreme NN 31504 339 19 , , , 31504 339 20 when when WRB 31504 339 21 he -PRON- PRP 31504 339 22 wrote write VBD 31504 339 23 that that IN 31504 339 24 the the DT 31504 339 25 sole sole JJ 31504 339 26 function function NN 31504 339 27 of of IN 31504 339 28 law law NN 31504 339 29 and and CC 31504 339 30 legislation legislation NN 31504 339 31 is be VBZ 31504 339 32 to to TO 31504 339 33 secure secure VB 31504 339 34 to to IN 31504 339 35 each each DT 31504 339 36 individual individual NN 31504 339 37 the the DT 31504 339 38 utmost utmost JJ 31504 339 39 liberty liberty NN 31504 339 40 which which WDT 31504 339 41 he -PRON- PRP 31504 339 42 can can MD 31504 339 43 enjoy enjoy VB 31504 339 44 consistently consistently RB 31504 339 45 with with IN 31504 339 46 the the DT 31504 339 47 preservation preservation NN 31504 339 48 of of IN 31504 339 49 the the DT 31504 339 50 like like JJ 31504 339 51 liberty liberty NN 31504 339 52 to to IN 31504 339 53 all all DT 31504 339 54 others other NNS 31504 339 55 . . . 31504 340 1 " " `` 31504 340 2 Liberty Liberty NNP 31504 340 3 ( ( -LRB- 31504 340 4 he -PRON- PRP 31504 340 5 wrote write VBD 31504 340 6 ) ) -RRB- 31504 340 7 , , , 31504 340 8 the the DT 31504 340 9 first first JJ 31504 340 10 of of IN 31504 340 11 blessings blessing NNS 31504 340 12 , , , 31504 340 13 the the DT 31504 340 14 aspiration aspiration NN 31504 340 15 of of IN 31504 340 16 every every DT 31504 340 17 human human JJ 31504 340 18 soul soul NN 31504 340 19 , , , 31504 340 20 is be VBZ 31504 340 21 the the DT 31504 340 22 supreme supreme JJ 31504 340 23 object object NN 31504 340 24 . . . 31504 341 1 Every every DT 31504 341 2 abridgment abridgment NN 31504 341 3 of of IN 31504 341 4 it -PRON- PRP 31504 341 5 demands demand VBZ 31504 341 6 an an DT 31504 341 7 excuse excuse NN 31504 341 8 , , , 31504 341 9 and and CC 31504 341 10 the the DT 31504 341 11 only only JJ 31504 341 12 good good JJ 31504 341 13 excuse excuse NN 31504 341 14 is be VBZ 31504 341 15 the the DT 31504 341 16 necessity necessity NN 31504 341 17 of of IN 31504 341 18 preserving preserve VBG 31504 341 19 it -PRON- PRP 31504 341 20 . . . 31504 341 21 " " '' 31504 342 1 ( ( -LRB- 31504 342 2 Carter Carter NNP 31504 342 3 's 's POS 31504 342 4 " " `` 31504 342 5 Law Law NNP 31504 342 6 . . . 31504 343 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 343 2 origin origin NN 31504 343 3 and and CC 31504 343 4 growth growth NN 31504 343 5 , , , 31504 343 6 " " '' 31504 343 7 page page NN 31504 343 8 337 337 CD 31504 343 9 . . . 31504 343 10 ) ) -RRB- 31504 344 1 There there EX 31504 344 2 must must MD 31504 344 3 also also RB 31504 344 4 be be VB 31504 344 5 left leave VBN 31504 344 6 to to IN 31504 344 7 the the DT 31504 344 8 individual individual NN 31504 344 9 some some DT 31504 344 10 personal personal JJ 31504 344 11 motives motive NNS 31504 344 12 for for IN 31504 344 13 labor labor NN 31504 344 14 and and CC 31504 344 15 thrift thrift NN 31504 344 16 , , , 31504 344 17 for for IN 31504 344 18 , , , 31504 344 19 after after RB 31504 344 20 all all RB 31504 344 21 , , , 31504 344 22 it -PRON- PRP 31504 344 23 is be VBZ 31504 344 24 the the DT 31504 344 25 toil toil NN 31504 344 26 of of IN 31504 344 27 individuals individual NNS 31504 344 28 that that WDT 31504 344 29 supports support VBZ 31504 344 30 society society NN 31504 344 31 and and CC 31504 344 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 344 33 members member NNS 31504 344 34 . . . 31504 345 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 345 2 is be VBZ 31504 345 3 the the DT 31504 345 4 surplus surplus NN 31504 345 5 products product NNS 31504 345 6 , , , 31504 345 7 not not RB 31504 345 8 consumed consume VBN 31504 345 9 , , , 31504 345 10 but but CC 31504 345 11 stored store VBN 31504 345 12 up up RP 31504 345 13 by by IN 31504 345 14 the the DT 31504 345 15 economy economy NN 31504 345 16 of of IN 31504 345 17 individuals individual NNS 31504 345 18 that that WDT 31504 345 19 constitutes constitute VBZ 31504 345 20 the the DT 31504 345 21 energy energy NN 31504 345 22 of of IN 31504 345 23 society society NN 31504 345 24 . . . 31504 346 1 However however RB 31504 346 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 346 3 may may MD 31504 346 4 be be VB 31504 346 5 improved improve VBN 31504 346 6 in in IN 31504 346 7 the the DT 31504 346 8 future future NN 31504 346 9 , , , 31504 346 10 the the DT 31504 346 11 nature nature NN 31504 346 12 of of IN 31504 346 13 the the DT 31504 346 14 average average JJ 31504 346 15 man man NN 31504 346 16 today today NN 31504 346 17 is be VBZ 31504 346 18 such such JJ 31504 346 19 that that IN 31504 346 20 he -PRON- PRP 31504 346 21 will will MD 31504 346 22 not not RB 31504 346 23 toil toil VB 31504 346 24 and and CC 31504 346 25 deny deny VB 31504 346 26 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 346 27 without without IN 31504 346 28 prospect prospect NN 31504 346 29 of of IN 31504 346 30 rewards reward NNS 31504 346 31 to to TO 31504 346 32 accrue accrue VB 31504 346 33 to to IN 31504 346 34 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 346 35 for for IN 31504 346 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 346 37 own own JJ 31504 346 38 personal personal JJ 31504 346 39 use use NN 31504 346 40 . . . 31504 347 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 347 2 will will MD 31504 347 3 not not RB 31504 347 4 strive strive VB 31504 347 5 to to TO 31504 347 6 earn earn VB 31504 347 7 and and CC 31504 347 8 then then RB 31504 347 9 conserve conserve VB 31504 347 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 347 11 earnings earning NNS 31504 347 12 unless unless IN 31504 347 13 he -PRON- PRP 31504 347 14 can can MD 31504 347 15 have have VB 31504 347 16 them -PRON- PRP 31504 347 17 for for IN 31504 347 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 347 19 own own JJ 31504 347 20 , , , 31504 347 21 to to TO 31504 347 22 control control VB 31504 347 23 , , , 31504 347 24 use use VB 31504 347 25 and and CC 31504 347 26 dispose dispose NN 31504 347 27 of of IN 31504 347 28 at at IN 31504 347 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 347 30 pleasure pleasure NN 31504 347 31 . . . 31504 348 1 However however RB 31504 348 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 348 3 may may MD 31504 348 4 be be VB 31504 348 5 with with IN 31504 348 6 a a DT 31504 348 7 few few JJ 31504 348 8 unselfish unselfish NN 31504 348 9 , , , 31504 348 10 devoted devoted JJ 31504 348 11 souls soul NNS 31504 348 12 , , , 31504 348 13 men man NNS 31504 348 14 as as IN 31504 348 15 a a DT 31504 348 16 rule rule NN 31504 348 17 are be VBP 31504 348 18 not not RB 31504 348 19 yet yet RB 31504 348 20 so so RB 31504 348 21 altruistic altruistic JJ 31504 348 22 as as IN 31504 348 23 to to TO 31504 348 24 devote devote VB 31504 348 25 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 348 26 exclusively exclusively RB 31504 348 27 to to IN 31504 348 28 the the DT 31504 348 29 good good NN 31504 348 30 of of IN 31504 348 31 others other NNS 31504 348 32 , , , 31504 348 33 of of IN 31504 348 34 society society NN 31504 348 35 . . . 31504 349 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 349 2 think think VBP 31504 349 3 it -PRON- PRP 31504 349 4 evident evident JJ 31504 349 5 that that IN 31504 349 6 if if IN 31504 349 7 the the DT 31504 349 8 impelling impelling JJ 31504 349 9 natural natural JJ 31504 349 10 desire desire NN 31504 349 11 to to TO 31504 349 12 serve serve VB 31504 349 13 one one PRP 31504 349 14 's 's POS 31504 349 15 self self NN 31504 349 16 be be VB 31504 349 17 wholly wholly RB 31504 349 18 or or CC 31504 349 19 even even RB 31504 349 20 largely largely RB 31504 349 21 disregarded disregard VBN 31504 349 22 by by IN 31504 349 23 society society NN 31504 349 24 , , , 31504 349 25 little little JJ 31504 349 26 would would MD 31504 349 27 be be VB 31504 349 28 produced produce VBN 31504 349 29 or or CC 31504 349 30 saved save VBN 31504 349 31 by by IN 31504 349 32 voluntary voluntary JJ 31504 349 33 labor labor NN 31504 349 34 and and CC 31504 349 35 self self NN 31504 349 36 - - HYPH 31504 349 37 denial denial NN 31504 349 38 . . . 31504 350 1 The the DT 31504 350 2 alternative alternative NN 31504 350 3 would would MD 31504 350 4 be be VB 31504 350 5 the the DT 31504 350 6 restoration restoration NN 31504 350 7 of of IN 31504 350 8 some some DT 31504 350 9 system system NN 31504 350 10 of of IN 31504 350 11 enforced enforce VBN 31504 350 12 labor labor NN 31504 350 13 , , , 31504 350 14 of of IN 31504 350 15 slavery slavery NN 31504 350 16 , , , 31504 350 17 for for IN 31504 350 18 the the DT 31504 350 19 vast vast JJ 31504 350 20 majority majority NN 31504 350 21 of of IN 31504 350 22 men man NNS 31504 350 23 . . . 31504 351 1 At at IN 31504 351 2 this this DT 31504 351 3 day day NN 31504 351 4 , , , 31504 351 5 after after IN 31504 351 6 centuries century NNS 31504 351 7 of of IN 31504 351 8 exhortation exhortation NN 31504 351 9 to to TO 31504 351 10 practise practise VB 31504 351 11 the the DT 31504 351 12 virtues virtue NNS 31504 351 13 of of IN 31504 351 14 benevolence benevolence NN 31504 351 15 , , , 31504 351 16 of of IN 31504 351 17 brotherly brotherly JJ 31504 351 18 love love NN 31504 351 19 , , , 31504 351 20 of of IN 31504 351 21 self self NN 31504 351 22 - - HYPH 31504 351 23 sacrifice sacrifice NN 31504 351 24 for for IN 31504 351 25 the the DT 31504 351 26 good good NN 31504 351 27 of of IN 31504 351 28 others other NNS 31504 351 29 , , , 31504 351 30 men man NNS 31504 351 31 do do VBP 31504 351 32 not not RB 31504 351 33 from from IN 31504 351 34 pure pure JJ 31504 351 35 love love NN 31504 351 36 of of IN 31504 351 37 humanity humanity NN 31504 351 38 voluntarily voluntarily RB 31504 351 39 endure endure VBP 31504 351 40 heat heat NN 31504 351 41 and and CC 31504 351 42 cold cold JJ 31504 351 43 , , , 31504 351 44 expend expend VBP 31504 351 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 351 46 labor labor NN 31504 351 47 and and CC 31504 351 48 savings saving NNS 31504 351 49 in in IN 31504 351 50 working work VBG 31504 351 51 mines mine NNS 31504 351 52 , , , 31504 351 53 in in IN 31504 351 54 braving brave VBG 31504 351 55 seas sea NNS 31504 351 56 , , , 31504 351 57 in in IN 31504 351 58 building building NN 31504 351 59 and and CC 31504 351 60 operating operating NN 31504 351 61 factories factory NNS 31504 351 62 , , , 31504 351 63 railroads railroad NNS 31504 351 64 and and CC 31504 351 65 steamships steamship NNS 31504 351 66 , , , 31504 351 67 in in IN 31504 351 68 growing grow VBG 31504 351 69 corn corn NN 31504 351 70 and and CC 31504 351 71 cotton cotton NN 31504 351 72 . . . 31504 352 1 Even even RB 31504 352 2 those those DT 31504 352 3 public public JJ 31504 352 4 offices office NNS 31504 352 5 , , , 31504 352 6 in in IN 31504 352 7 which which WDT 31504 352 8 the the DT 31504 352 9 altruist altruist NN 31504 352 10 might may MD 31504 352 11 find find VB 31504 352 12 the the DT 31504 352 13 best good JJS 31504 352 14 opportunities opportunity NNS 31504 352 15 for for IN 31504 352 16 serving serve VBG 31504 352 17 the the DT 31504 352 18 people people NNS 31504 352 19 , , , 31504 352 20 are be VBP 31504 352 21 not not RB 31504 352 22 much much RB 31504 352 23 sought seek VBN 31504 352 24 for for IN 31504 352 25 unless unless IN 31504 352 26 some some DT 31504 352 27 personal personal JJ 31504 352 28 honor honor NN 31504 352 29 or or CC 31504 352 30 pecuniary pecuniary JJ 31504 352 31 profit profit NN 31504 352 32 be be VB 31504 352 33 attached attach VBN 31504 352 34 to to IN 31504 352 35 them -PRON- PRP 31504 352 36 . . . 31504 353 1 Should Should MD 31504 353 2 society society NN 31504 353 3 decree decree NN 31504 353 4 that that IN 31504 353 5 the the DT 31504 353 6 laborer laborer NN 31504 353 7 , , , 31504 353 8 whether whether IN 31504 353 9 with with IN 31504 353 10 hands hand NNS 31504 353 11 or or CC 31504 353 12 brain brain NN 31504 353 13 , , , 31504 353 14 should should MD 31504 353 15 have have VB 31504 353 16 no no DT 31504 353 17 individual individual JJ 31504 353 18 reward reward NN 31504 353 19 proportionate proportionate NN 31504 353 20 to to IN 31504 353 21 the the DT 31504 353 22 efficiency efficiency NN 31504 353 23 of of IN 31504 353 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 353 25 labor labor NN 31504 353 26 , , , 31504 353 27 but but CC 31504 353 28 only only RB 31504 353 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 353 30 numerical numerical JJ 31504 353 31 proportion proportion NN 31504 353 32 of of IN 31504 353 33 the the DT 31504 353 34 product product NN 31504 353 35 of of IN 31504 353 36 all all DT 31504 353 37 laborers laborer NNS 31504 353 38 , , , 31504 353 39 I -PRON- PRP 31504 353 40 fear fear VBP 31504 353 41 the the DT 31504 353 42 efficiency efficiency NN 31504 353 43 of of IN 31504 353 44 all all DT 31504 353 45 classes class NNS 31504 353 46 of of IN 31504 353 47 laborers laborer NNS 31504 353 48 , , , 31504 353 49 manual manual NN 31504 353 50 and and CC 31504 353 51 mental mental JJ 31504 353 52 , , , 31504 353 53 would would MD 31504 353 54 fall fall VB 31504 353 55 to to IN 31504 353 56 the the DT 31504 353 57 " " `` 31504 353 58 irreducible irreducible JJ 31504 353 59 minimum minimum NN 31504 353 60 . . . 31504 353 61 " " '' 31504 354 1 The the DT 31504 354 2 foregoing foregoing NN 31504 354 3 statements statement NNS 31504 354 4 and and CC 31504 354 5 inferences inference NNS 31504 354 6 lead lead VBP 31504 354 7 to to IN 31504 354 8 the the DT 31504 354 9 question question NN 31504 354 10 , , , 31504 354 11 how how WRB 31504 354 12 far far RB 31504 354 13 should should MD 31504 354 14 society society NN 31504 354 15 go go VB 31504 354 16 in in IN 31504 354 17 undertaking undertake VBG 31504 354 18 to to TO 31504 354 19 regulate regulate VB 31504 354 20 the the DT 31504 354 21 conduct conduct NN 31504 354 22 and and CC 31504 354 23 restrict restrict VB 31504 354 24 the the DT 31504 354 25 freedom freedom NN 31504 354 26 of of IN 31504 354 27 the the DT 31504 354 28 individual,--that individual,--that NNP 31504 354 29 freedom freedom NN 31504 354 30 which which WDT 31504 354 31 would would MD 31504 354 32 be be VB 31504 354 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 354 34 if if IN 31504 354 35 he -PRON- PRP 31504 354 36 were be VBD 31504 354 37 alone alone JJ 31504 354 38 in in IN 31504 354 39 the the DT 31504 354 40 world world NN 31504 354 41 ? ? . 31504 355 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 355 2 may may MD 31504 355 3 be be VB 31504 355 4 thought think VBN 31504 355 5 that that IN 31504 355 6 this this DT 31504 355 7 is be VBZ 31504 355 8 a a DT 31504 355 9 question question NN 31504 355 10 of of IN 31504 355 11 expediency expediency NN 31504 355 12 for for IN 31504 355 13 economists economist NNS 31504 355 14 and and CC 31504 355 15 sociologists sociologist NNS 31504 355 16 , , , 31504 355 17 and and CC 31504 355 18 so so RB 31504 355 19 it -PRON- PRP 31504 355 20 is be VBZ 31504 355 21 largely largely RB 31504 355 22 , , , 31504 355 23 but but CC 31504 355 24 it -PRON- PRP 31504 355 25 is be VBZ 31504 355 26 also also RB 31504 355 27 a a DT 31504 355 28 question question NN 31504 355 29 of of IN 31504 355 30 rights right NNS 31504 355 31 and and CC 31504 355 32 hence hence RB 31504 355 33 of of IN 31504 355 34 justice justice NN 31504 355 35 , , , 31504 355 36 since since IN 31504 355 37 every every DT 31504 355 38 action action NN 31504 355 39 or or CC 31504 355 40 non non NN 31504 355 41 - - NN 31504 355 42 action action NN 31504 355 43 of of IN 31504 355 44 society society NN 31504 355 45 affects affect VBZ 31504 355 46 the the DT 31504 355 47 freedom freedom NN 31504 355 48 of of IN 31504 355 49 the the DT 31504 355 50 individual individual NN 31504 355 51 in in IN 31504 355 52 the the DT 31504 355 53 gratification gratification NN 31504 355 54 of of IN 31504 355 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 355 56 desires desire NNS 31504 355 57 or or CC 31504 355 58 , , , 31504 355 59 in in IN 31504 355 60 other other JJ 31504 355 61 words word NNS 31504 355 62 , , , 31504 355 63 in in IN 31504 355 64 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 355 65 pursuit pursuit NN 31504 355 66 of of IN 31504 355 67 happiness happiness NN 31504 355 68 . . . 31504 356 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31504 356 2 IV IV NNP 31504 356 3 JUSTICE JUSTICE VBD 31504 356 4 THE the DT 31504 356 5 EQUILIBRIUM EQUILIBRIUM NNP 31504 356 6 BETWEEN between IN 31504 356 7 THE the DT 31504 356 8 FREEDOM freedom NN 31504 356 9 OF of IN 31504 356 10 THE the DT 31504 356 11 INDIVIDUAL INDIVIDUAL NNPS 31504 356 12 AND and CC 31504 356 13 THE the DT 31504 356 14 SAFETY safety NN 31504 356 15 OF of IN 31504 356 16 SOCIETY SOCIETY NNP 31504 356 17 The the DT 31504 356 18 question question NN 31504 356 19 stated state VBN 31504 356 20 at at IN 31504 356 21 the the DT 31504 356 22 close close NN 31504 356 23 of of IN 31504 356 24 the the DT 31504 356 25 last last JJ 31504 356 26 chapter chapter NN 31504 356 27 is be VBZ 31504 356 28 most most RBS 31504 356 29 important important JJ 31504 356 30 and and CC 31504 356 31 , , , 31504 356 32 in in IN 31504 356 33 a a DT 31504 356 34 sense sense NN 31504 356 35 , , , 31504 356 36 is be VBZ 31504 356 37 perhaps perhaps RB 31504 356 38 the the DT 31504 356 39 crux crux NN 31504 356 40 of of IN 31504 356 41 the the DT 31504 356 42 whole whole JJ 31504 356 43 matter matter NN 31504 356 44 . . . 31504 357 1 Not not RB 31504 357 2 only only RB 31504 357 3 may may MD 31504 357 4 error error VB 31504 357 5 in in IN 31504 357 6 the the DT 31504 357 7 solution solution NN 31504 357 8 of of IN 31504 357 9 the the DT 31504 357 10 question question NN 31504 357 11 injuriously injuriously RB 31504 357 12 affect affect VB 31504 357 13 the the DT 31504 357 14 material material JJ 31504 357 15 interests interest NNS 31504 357 16 of of IN 31504 357 17 individuals individual NNS 31504 357 18 and and CC 31504 357 19 hence hence RB 31504 357 20 of of IN 31504 357 21 society society NN 31504 357 22 as as IN 31504 357 23 a a DT 31504 357 24 whole whole NN 31504 357 25 , , , 31504 357 26 but but CC 31504 357 27 it -PRON- PRP 31504 357 28 may may MD 31504 357 29 cause cause VB 31504 357 30 unhappiness unhappiness NN 31504 357 31 far far RB 31504 357 32 greater great JJR 31504 357 33 than than IN 31504 357 34 that that DT 31504 357 35 caused cause VBN 31504 357 36 by by IN 31504 357 37 any any DT 31504 357 38 material material JJ 31504 357 39 loss loss NN 31504 357 40 , , , 31504 357 41 viz viz NNP 31504 357 42 . . NNP 31504 357 43 , , , 31504 357 44 a a DT 31504 357 45 sense sense NN 31504 357 46 of of IN 31504 357 47 injustice injustice NN 31504 357 48 . . . 31504 358 1 As as IN 31504 358 2 said say VBN 31504 358 3 by by IN 31504 358 4 the the DT 31504 358 5 English english JJ 31504 358 6 judge judge NN 31504 358 7 , , , 31504 358 8 " " `` 31504 358 9 Injustice Injustice NNP 31504 358 10 cuts cut VBZ 31504 358 11 to to IN 31504 358 12 the the DT 31504 358 13 bone bone NN 31504 358 14 . . . 31504 358 15 " " '' 31504 359 1 At at IN 31504 359 2 the the DT 31504 359 3 outset outset NN 31504 359 4 I -PRON- PRP 31504 359 5 accept accept VBP 31504 359 6 Herbert Herbert NNP 31504 359 7 Spencer Spencer NNP 31504 359 8 's 's POS 31504 359 9 theory theory NN 31504 359 10 that that IN 31504 359 11 the the DT 31504 359 12 idea idea NN 31504 359 13 of of IN 31504 359 14 justice justice NN 31504 359 15 contains contain VBZ 31504 359 16 two two CD 31504 359 17 sentiments sentiment NNS 31504 359 18 , , , 31504 359 19 positive positive JJ 31504 359 20 and and CC 31504 359 21 negative negative JJ 31504 359 22 ; ; : 31504 359 23 the the DT 31504 359 24 one one NN 31504 359 25 the the DT 31504 359 26 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 359 27 of of IN 31504 359 28 the the DT 31504 359 29 individual individual NN 31504 359 30 that that WDT 31504 359 31 he -PRON- PRP 31504 359 32 has have VBZ 31504 359 33 the the DT 31504 359 34 right right NN 31504 359 35 by by IN 31504 359 36 nature nature NN 31504 359 37 to to IN 31504 359 38 the the DT 31504 359 39 unimpeded unimpeded JJ 31504 359 40 use use NN 31504 359 41 of of IN 31504 359 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 359 43 faculties faculty NNS 31504 359 44 and and CC 31504 359 45 to to IN 31504 359 46 the the DT 31504 359 47 benefits benefit NNS 31504 359 48 he -PRON- PRP 31504 359 49 acquires acquire VBZ 31504 359 50 by by IN 31504 359 51 such such JJ 31504 359 52 use use NN 31504 359 53 ; ; : 31504 359 54 the the DT 31504 359 55 other other JJ 31504 359 56 the the DT 31504 359 57 consciousness consciousness NN 31504 359 58 that that WDT 31504 359 59 the the DT 31504 359 60 presence presence NN 31504 359 61 of of IN 31504 359 62 other other JJ 31504 359 63 individuals individual NNS 31504 359 64 with with IN 31504 359 65 similar similar JJ 31504 359 66 claims claim NNS 31504 359 67 of of IN 31504 359 68 rights right NNS 31504 359 69 necessitates necessitate VBZ 31504 359 70 some some DT 31504 359 71 limitation limitation NN 31504 359 72 of of IN 31504 359 73 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 359 74 own own JJ 31504 359 75 claims claim NNS 31504 359 76 . . . 31504 360 1 Out out IN 31504 360 2 of of IN 31504 360 3 those those DT 31504 360 4 two two CD 31504 360 5 sentiments sentiment NNS 31504 360 6 is be VBZ 31504 360 7 evolved evolve VBN 31504 360 8 , , , 31504 360 9 I -PRON- PRP 31504 360 10 think think VBP 31504 360 11 , , , 31504 360 12 the the DT 31504 360 13 idea idea NN 31504 360 14 of of IN 31504 360 15 justice justice NN 31504 360 16 or or CC 31504 360 17 injustice injustice NN 31504 360 18 according accord VBG 31504 360 19 as as IN 31504 360 20 they -PRON- PRP 31504 360 21 are be VBP 31504 360 22 or or CC 31504 360 23 are be VBP 31504 360 24 not not RB 31504 360 25 in in IN 31504 360 26 equilibrium equilibrium NN 31504 360 27 . . . 31504 361 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 361 2 suggest suggest VBP 31504 361 3 the the DT 31504 361 4 definition definition NN 31504 361 5 that that IN 31504 361 6 justice justice NN 31504 361 7 is be VBZ 31504 361 8 the the DT 31504 361 9 equilibrium equilibrium NN 31504 361 10 between between IN 31504 361 11 the the DT 31504 361 12 full full JJ 31504 361 13 freedom freedom NN 31504 361 14 of of IN 31504 361 15 the the DT 31504 361 16 individual individual NN 31504 361 17 and and CC 31504 361 18 the the DT 31504 361 19 restrictions restriction NNS 31504 361 20 thereon thereon NN 31504 361 21 necessary necessary JJ 31504 361 22 for for IN 31504 361 23 the the DT 31504 361 24 safety safety NN 31504 361 25 of of IN 31504 361 26 society society NN 31504 361 27 . . . 31504 362 1 The the DT 31504 362 2 restraint restraint NN 31504 362 3 of of IN 31504 362 4 personal personal JJ 31504 362 5 conduct conduct NN 31504 362 6 within within IN 31504 362 7 too too RB 31504 362 8 narrow narrow JJ 31504 362 9 limits limit NNS 31504 362 10 , , , 31504 362 11 the the DT 31504 362 12 necessity necessity NN 31504 362 13 of of IN 31504 362 14 which which WDT 31504 362 15 can can MD 31504 362 16 not not RB 31504 362 17 be be VB 31504 362 18 made make VBN 31504 362 19 clear clear JJ 31504 362 20 , , , 31504 362 21 excites excite VBZ 31504 362 22 resentment resentment NN 31504 362 23 , , , 31504 362 24 stimulates stimulate VBZ 31504 362 25 angry angry JJ 31504 362 26 passions passion NNS 31504 362 27 , , , 31504 362 28 and and CC 31504 362 29 hence hence RB 31504 362 30 causes cause VBZ 31504 362 31 unhappiness unhappiness NN 31504 362 32 through through IN 31504 362 33 a a DT 31504 362 34 sense sense NN 31504 362 35 of of IN 31504 362 36 injustice injustice NN 31504 362 37 . . . 31504 363 1 Restraint restraint NN 31504 363 2 within within IN 31504 363 3 necessary necessary JJ 31504 363 4 limits limit NNS 31504 363 5 only only RB 31504 363 6 , , , 31504 363 7 the the DT 31504 363 8 necessity necessity NN 31504 363 9 of of IN 31504 363 10 which which WDT 31504 363 11 can can MD 31504 363 12 be be VB 31504 363 13 seen see VBN 31504 363 14 , , , 31504 363 15 arouses arouse VBZ 31504 363 16 no no DT 31504 363 17 resentment resentment NN 31504 363 18 ; ; , 31504 363 19 on on IN 31504 363 20 the the DT 31504 363 21 contrary contrary NN 31504 363 22 , , , 31504 363 23 it -PRON- PRP 31504 363 24 satisfies satisfy VBZ 31504 363 25 the the DT 31504 363 26 individual individual NN 31504 363 27 , , , 31504 363 28 favors favor VBZ 31504 363 29 harmonious harmonious JJ 31504 363 30 cooperation cooperation NN 31504 363 31 , , , 31504 363 32 profits profit VBZ 31504 363 33 society society NN 31504 363 34 and and CC 31504 363 35 increases increase VBZ 31504 363 36 the the DT 31504 363 37 happiness happiness NN 31504 363 38 of of IN 31504 363 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 363 40 members member NNS 31504 363 41 , , , 31504 363 42 through through IN 31504 363 43 the the DT 31504 363 44 appreciation appreciation NN 31504 363 45 of of IN 31504 363 46 that that DT 31504 363 47 necessity necessity NN 31504 363 48 . . . 31504 364 1 But but CC 31504 364 2 for for IN 31504 364 3 the the DT 31504 364 4 fixing fixing NN 31504 364 5 of of IN 31504 364 6 the the DT 31504 364 7 boundary boundary JJ 31504 364 8 line line NN 31504 364 9 between between IN 31504 364 10 necessary necessary JJ 31504 364 11 and and CC 31504 364 12 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 31504 364 13 restraints restraint NNS 31504 364 14 upon upon IN 31504 364 15 personal personal JJ 31504 364 16 conduct conduct NN 31504 364 17 , , , 31504 364 18 some some DT 31504 364 19 other other JJ 31504 364 20 matters matter NNS 31504 364 21 still still RB 31504 364 22 are be VBP 31504 364 23 to to TO 31504 364 24 be be VB 31504 364 25 considered consider VBN 31504 364 26 . . . 31504 365 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 365 2 have have VBP 31504 365 3 said say VBN 31504 365 4 that that DT 31504 365 5 man man NN 31504 365 6 instinctively instinctively RB 31504 365 7 feels feel VBZ 31504 365 8 resentment resentment NN 31504 365 9 at at IN 31504 365 10 interference interference NN 31504 365 11 with with IN 31504 365 12 whatever whatever WDT 31504 365 13 he -PRON- PRP 31504 365 14 may may MD 31504 365 15 think think VB 31504 365 16 is be VBZ 31504 365 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 365 18 right right NN 31504 365 19 to to TO 31504 365 20 do do VB 31504 365 21 , , , 31504 365 22 or or CC 31504 365 23 get get VB 31504 365 24 , , , 31504 365 25 or or CC 31504 365 26 keep keep VB 31504 365 27 . . . 31504 366 1 If if IN 31504 366 2 this this DT 31504 366 3 interference interference NN 31504 366 4 is be VBZ 31504 366 5 from from IN 31504 366 6 any any DT 31504 366 7 of of IN 31504 366 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 366 9 fellow fellow JJ 31504 366 10 men man NNS 31504 366 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 366 12 resentment resentment NN 31504 366 13 is be VBZ 31504 366 14 greater great JJR 31504 366 15 than than IN 31504 366 16 when when WRB 31504 366 17 it -PRON- PRP 31504 366 18 is be VBZ 31504 366 19 from from IN 31504 366 20 natural natural JJ 31504 366 21 forces force NNS 31504 366 22 . . . 31504 367 1 There there EX 31504 367 2 arises arise VBZ 31504 367 3 the the DT 31504 367 4 desire desire NN 31504 367 5 for for IN 31504 367 6 vengeance vengeance NN 31504 367 7 , , , 31504 367 8 the the DT 31504 367 9 desire desire NN 31504 367 10 to to TO 31504 367 11 " " `` 31504 367 12 get get VB 31504 367 13 even,"--to even,"--to NNP 31504 367 14 use use VB 31504 367 15 a a DT 31504 367 16 common common JJ 31504 367 17 phrase,--by phrase,--by NN 31504 367 18 inflicting inflict VBG 31504 367 19 a a DT 31504 367 20 corresponding corresponding JJ 31504 367 21 injury injury NN 31504 367 22 on on IN 31504 367 23 the the DT 31504 367 24 offender offender NN 31504 367 25 . . . 31504 368 1 An an DT 31504 368 2 eye eye NN 31504 368 3 for for IN 31504 368 4 an an DT 31504 368 5 eye eye NN 31504 368 6 , , , 31504 368 7 a a DT 31504 368 8 tooth tooth NN 31504 368 9 for for IN 31504 368 10 a a DT 31504 368 11 tooth tooth NN 31504 368 12 , , , 31504 368 13 is be VBZ 31504 368 14 instinctively instinctively RB 31504 368 15 demanded demand VBN 31504 368 16 now now RB 31504 368 17 as as IN 31504 368 18 of of IN 31504 368 19 old old JJ 31504 368 20 . . . 31504 369 1 If if IN 31504 369 2 unable unable JJ 31504 369 3 to to TO 31504 369 4 inflict inflict VB 31504 369 5 a a DT 31504 369 6 corresponding corresponding JJ 31504 369 7 injury injury NN 31504 369 8 there there EX 31504 369 9 is be VBZ 31504 369 10 the the DT 31504 369 11 desire desire NN 31504 369 12 to to TO 31504 369 13 inflict inflict VB 31504 369 14 an an DT 31504 369 15 equivalent equivalent JJ 31504 369 16 injury injury NN 31504 369 17 . . . 31504 370 1 To to TO 31504 370 2 paraphrase paraphrase VB 31504 370 3 Bacon Bacon NNP 31504 370 4 , , , 31504 370 5 revenge revenge NN 31504 370 6 is be VBZ 31504 370 7 justice justice NN 31504 370 8 running run VBG 31504 370 9 wild wild JJ 31504 370 10 . . . 31504 371 1 This this DT 31504 371 2 instinct instinct NN 31504 371 3 should should MD 31504 371 4 be be VB 31504 371 5 heeded heed VBN 31504 371 6 by by IN 31504 371 7 society society NN 31504 371 8 . . . 31504 372 1 If if IN 31504 372 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 372 3 be be VBP 31504 372 4 necessary necessary JJ 31504 372 5 for for IN 31504 372 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 372 7 own own JJ 31504 372 8 preservation preservation NN 31504 372 9 that that IN 31504 372 10 society society NN 31504 372 11 restrain restrain VB 31504 372 12 this this DT 31504 372 13 instinct instinct NN 31504 372 14 , , , 31504 372 15 prohibit prohibit VB 31504 372 16 private private JJ 31504 372 17 vengeance vengeance NN 31504 372 18 , , , 31504 372 19 then then RB 31504 372 20 it -PRON- PRP 31504 372 21 must must MD 31504 372 22 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 372 23 provide provide VB 31504 372 24 for for IN 31504 372 25 satisfaction satisfaction NN 31504 372 26 of of IN 31504 372 27 the the DT 31504 372 28 instinct instinct NN 31504 372 29 ; ; : 31504 372 30 the the DT 31504 372 31 offender offender NN 31504 372 32 must must MD 31504 372 33 be be VB 31504 372 34 compelled compel VBN 31504 372 35 to to TO 31504 372 36 make make VB 31504 372 37 full full JJ 31504 372 38 compensation compensation NN 31504 372 39 or or CC 31504 372 40 else else RB 31504 372 41 be be VB 31504 372 42 made make VBN 31504 372 43 to to TO 31504 372 44 suffer suffer VB 31504 372 45 in in IN 31504 372 46 turn turn NN 31504 372 47 some some DT 31504 372 48 deprivation deprivation NN 31504 372 49 of of IN 31504 372 50 rights right NNS 31504 372 51 claimed claim VBN 31504 372 52 by by IN 31504 372 53 him -PRON- PRP 31504 372 54 that that WDT 31504 372 55 shall shall MD 31504 372 56 be be VB 31504 372 57 commensurate commensurate JJ 31504 372 58 with with IN 31504 372 59 the the DT 31504 372 60 offense offense NN 31504 372 61 . . . 31504 373 1 This this DT 31504 373 2 should should MD 31504 373 3 be be VB 31504 373 4 done do VBN 31504 373 5 speedily speedily RB 31504 373 6 and and CC 31504 373 7 gratuitously gratuitously RB 31504 373 8 so so RB 31504 373 9 far far RB 31504 373 10 as as IN 31504 373 11 possible possible JJ 31504 373 12 . . . 31504 374 1 Delay delay NN 31504 374 2 and and CC 31504 374 3 expense expense NN 31504 374 4 cause cause NN 31504 374 5 resentment resentment NN 31504 374 6 in in IN 31504 374 7 the the DT 31504 374 8 suitor suitor NN 31504 374 9 for for IN 31504 374 10 justice justice NN 31504 374 11 and and CC 31504 374 12 so so RB 31504 374 13 cause cause VB 31504 374 14 injustice injustice NN 31504 374 15 . . . 31504 375 1 In in IN 31504 375 2 doing do VBG 31504 375 3 this this DT 31504 375 4 , , , 31504 375 5 society society NN 31504 375 6 not not RB 31504 375 7 only only RB 31504 375 8 protects protect VBZ 31504 375 9 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 375 10 but but CC 31504 375 11 it -PRON- PRP 31504 375 12 restores restore VBZ 31504 375 13 an an DT 31504 375 14 equilibrium equilibrium NN 31504 375 15 of of IN 31504 375 16 rights right NNS 31504 375 17 disturbed disturb VBN 31504 375 18 by by IN 31504 375 19 the the DT 31504 375 20 offender offender NN 31504 375 21 . . . 31504 376 1 This this DT 31504 376 2 restoration restoration NN 31504 376 3 of of IN 31504 376 4 equilibrium equilibrium NN 31504 376 5 is be VBZ 31504 376 6 an an DT 31504 376 7 essential essential JJ 31504 376 8 element element NN 31504 376 9 in in IN 31504 376 10 the the DT 31504 376 11 concept concept NN 31504 376 12 of of IN 31504 376 13 justice justice NN 31504 376 14 . . . 31504 377 1 Of of RB 31504 377 2 course course RB 31504 377 3 , , , 31504 377 4 as as IN 31504 377 5 society society NN 31504 377 6 progresses progress NNS 31504 377 7 and and CC 31504 377 8 human human JJ 31504 377 9 nature nature NN 31504 377 10 improves improve VBZ 31504 377 11 , , , 31504 377 12 this this DT 31504 377 13 desire desire NN 31504 377 14 of of IN 31504 377 15 the the DT 31504 377 16 injured injure VBN 31504 377 17 for for IN 31504 377 18 vengeance vengeance NN 31504 377 19 on on IN 31504 377 20 the the DT 31504 377 21 offender offender NN 31504 377 22 becomes become VBZ 31504 377 23 weaker weak JJR 31504 377 24 . . . 31504 378 1 The the DT 31504 378 2 virtues virtue NNS 31504 378 3 of of IN 31504 378 4 mercy mercy NN 31504 378 5 , , , 31504 378 6 forgiveness forgiveness NN 31504 378 7 , , , 31504 378 8 or or CC 31504 378 9 willingness willingness NN 31504 378 10 to to TO 31504 378 11 forego forego VB 31504 378 12 the the DT 31504 378 13 demand demand NN 31504 378 14 for for IN 31504 378 15 punishment punishment NN 31504 378 16 , , , 31504 378 17 come come VB 31504 378 18 into into IN 31504 378 19 play play NN 31504 378 20 and and CC 31504 378 21 society society NN 31504 378 22 is be VBZ 31504 378 23 allowed allow VBN 31504 378 24 to to TO 31504 378 25 attempt attempt VB 31504 378 26 to to TO 31504 378 27 reform reform VB 31504 378 28 rather rather RB 31504 378 29 than than IN 31504 378 30 to to TO 31504 378 31 punish punish VB 31504 378 32 , , , 31504 378 33 or or CC 31504 378 34 is be VBZ 31504 378 35 allowed allow VBN 31504 378 36 to to TO 31504 378 37 pardon pardon VB 31504 378 38 altogether altogether RB 31504 378 39 . . . 31504 379 1 These these DT 31504 379 2 virtues virtue NNS 31504 379 3 , , , 31504 379 4 however however RB 31504 379 5 , , , 31504 379 6 are be VBP 31504 379 7 not not RB 31504 379 8 part part NN 31504 379 9 of of IN 31504 379 10 the the DT 31504 379 11 concept concept NN 31504 379 12 of of IN 31504 379 13 justice justice NN 31504 379 14 . . . 31504 380 1 If if IN 31504 380 2 the the DT 31504 380 3 punishment punishment NN 31504 380 4 seems seem VBZ 31504 380 5 inadequate inadequate JJ 31504 380 6 , , , 31504 380 7 or or CC 31504 380 8 the the DT 31504 380 9 pardon pardon NN 31504 380 10 seems seem VBZ 31504 380 11 undeserved undeserved JJ 31504 380 12 , , , 31504 380 13 there there EX 31504 380 14 remains remain VBZ 31504 380 15 , , , 31504 380 16 or or CC 31504 380 17 is be VBZ 31504 380 18 again again RB 31504 380 19 excited excited JJ 31504 380 20 , , , 31504 380 21 the the DT 31504 380 22 feeling feeling NN 31504 380 23 of of IN 31504 380 24 resentment resentment NN 31504 380 25 . . . 31504 381 1 The the DT 31504 381 2 equilibrium equilibrium NN 31504 381 3 is be VBZ 31504 381 4 not not RB 31504 381 5 restored restore VBN 31504 381 6 . . . 31504 382 1 Another another DT 31504 382 2 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 382 3 or or CC 31504 382 4 feeling feeling NN 31504 382 5 is be VBZ 31504 382 6 to to TO 31504 382 7 be be VB 31504 382 8 reckoned reckon VBN 31504 382 9 with with IN 31504 382 10 in in IN 31504 382 11 order order NN 31504 382 12 to to TO 31504 382 13 secure secure VB 31504 382 14 this this DT 31504 382 15 equilibrium equilibrium NN 31504 382 16 in in IN 31504 382 17 society society NN 31504 382 18 . . . 31504 383 1 The the DT 31504 383 2 young young JJ 31504 383 3 , , , 31504 383 4 untrained untrained JJ 31504 383 5 child child NN 31504 383 6 is be VBZ 31504 383 7 impatient impatient JJ 31504 383 8 of of IN 31504 383 9 all all DT 31504 383 10 restraint restraint NN 31504 383 11 . . . 31504 384 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 384 2 is be VBZ 31504 384 3 only only RB 31504 384 4 by by IN 31504 384 5 experience experience NN 31504 384 6 that that IN 31504 384 7 he -PRON- PRP 31504 384 8 learns learn VBZ 31504 384 9 he -PRON- PRP 31504 384 10 must must MD 31504 384 11 submit submit VB 31504 384 12 to to TO 31504 384 13 restraint restraint NN 31504 384 14 if if IN 31504 384 15 he -PRON- PRP 31504 384 16 would would MD 31504 384 17 have have VB 31504 384 18 any any DT 31504 384 19 sort sort NN 31504 384 20 of of IN 31504 384 21 association association NN 31504 384 22 with with IN 31504 384 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 384 24 fellows fellow NNS 31504 384 25 . . . 31504 385 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 385 2 learns learn VBZ 31504 385 3 that that IN 31504 385 4 he -PRON- PRP 31504 385 5 must must MD 31504 385 6 submit submit VB 31504 385 7 to to IN 31504 385 8 the the DT 31504 385 9 rules rule NNS 31504 385 10 of of IN 31504 385 11 the the DT 31504 385 12 game game NN 31504 385 13 if if IN 31504 385 14 he -PRON- PRP 31504 385 15 would would MD 31504 385 16 have have VB 31504 385 17 a a DT 31504 385 18 part part NN 31504 385 19 in in IN 31504 385 20 the the DT 31504 385 21 game game NN 31504 385 22 . . . 31504 386 1 As as IN 31504 386 2 he -PRON- PRP 31504 386 3 comes come VBZ 31504 386 4 to to IN 31504 386 5 maturity maturity NN 31504 386 6 he -PRON- PRP 31504 386 7 becomes become VBZ 31504 386 8 conscious conscious JJ 31504 386 9 that that IN 31504 386 10 society society NN 31504 386 11 must must MD 31504 386 12 impose impose VB 31504 386 13 restraint restraint NN 31504 386 14 upon upon IN 31504 386 15 him -PRON- PRP 31504 386 16 and and CC 31504 386 17 hence hence RB 31504 386 18 feels feel VBZ 31504 386 19 no no DT 31504 386 20 resentment resentment NN 31504 386 21 against against IN 31504 386 22 all all DT 31504 386 23 restraint restraint NN 31504 386 24 , , , 31504 386 25 as as IN 31504 386 26 does do VBZ 31504 386 27 the the DT 31504 386 28 untrained untrained JJ 31504 386 29 child child NN 31504 386 30 . . . 31504 387 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 387 2 does do VBZ 31504 387 3 , , , 31504 387 4 however however RB 31504 387 5 , , , 31504 387 6 feel feel VBP 31504 387 7 resentment resentment NN 31504 387 8 if if IN 31504 387 9 restraints restraint NNS 31504 387 10 are be VBP 31504 387 11 imposed impose VBN 31504 387 12 upon upon IN 31504 387 13 him -PRON- PRP 31504 387 14 in in IN 31504 387 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 387 16 pursuit pursuit NN 31504 387 17 of of IN 31504 387 18 happiness happiness NN 31504 387 19 which which WDT 31504 387 20 are be VBP 31504 387 21 not not RB 31504 387 22 imposed impose VBN 31504 387 23 upon upon IN 31504 387 24 others other NNS 31504 387 25 in in IN 31504 387 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 387 27 pursuit pursuit NN 31504 387 28 . . . 31504 388 1 Similarly similarly RB 31504 388 2 he -PRON- PRP 31504 388 3 feels feel VBZ 31504 388 4 resentment resentment NN 31504 388 5 if if IN 31504 388 6 exemptions exemption NNS 31504 388 7 from from IN 31504 388 8 restraint restraint NN 31504 388 9 are be VBP 31504 388 10 allowed allow VBN 31504 388 11 some some DT 31504 388 12 others other NNS 31504 388 13 and and CC 31504 388 14 not not RB 31504 388 15 allowed allow VBN 31504 388 16 him -PRON- PRP 31504 388 17 also also RB 31504 388 18 . . . 31504 389 1 Furthermore furthermore RB 31504 389 2 , , , 31504 389 3 he -PRON- PRP 31504 389 4 is be VBZ 31504 389 5 quick quick JJ 31504 389 6 to to TO 31504 389 7 note note VB 31504 389 8 any any DT 31504 389 9 discrimination discrimination NN 31504 389 10 against against IN 31504 389 11 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 389 12 and and CC 31504 389 13 prone prone JJ 31504 389 14 to to TO 31504 389 15 imagine imagine VB 31504 389 16 it -PRON- PRP 31504 389 17 when when WRB 31504 389 18 in in IN 31504 389 19 fact fact NN 31504 389 20 there there EX 31504 389 21 is be VBZ 31504 389 22 none none NN 31504 389 23 . . . 31504 390 1 Almost almost RB 31504 390 2 as as RB 31504 390 3 soon soon RB 31504 390 4 as as IN 31504 390 5 the the DT 31504 390 6 average average JJ 31504 390 7 child child NN 31504 390 8 is be VBZ 31504 390 9 placed place VBN 31504 390 10 with with IN 31504 390 11 others other NNS 31504 390 12 under under IN 31504 390 13 a a DT 31504 390 14 common common JJ 31504 390 15 authority authority NN 31504 390 16 , , , 31504 390 17 as as IN 31504 390 18 in in IN 31504 390 19 a a DT 31504 390 20 public public JJ 31504 390 21 school school NN 31504 390 22 , , , 31504 390 23 he -PRON- PRP 31504 390 24 begins begin VBZ 31504 390 25 to to TO 31504 390 26 complain complain VB 31504 390 27 of of IN 31504 390 28 the the DT 31504 390 29 teacher teacher NN 31504 390 30 's 's POS 31504 390 31 partiality partiality NN 31504 390 32 to to IN 31504 390 33 other other JJ 31504 390 34 pupils pupil NNS 31504 390 35 . . . 31504 391 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 391 2 will will MD 31504 391 3 stay stay VB 31504 391 4 in in IN 31504 391 5 no no DT 31504 391 6 game game NN 31504 391 7 where where WRB 31504 391 8 the the DT 31504 391 9 rules rule NNS 31504 391 10 operate operate VBP 31504 391 11 unequally unequally RB 31504 391 12 against against IN 31504 391 13 him -PRON- PRP 31504 391 14 . . . 31504 392 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 392 2 insists insist VBZ 31504 392 3 on on IN 31504 392 4 an an DT 31504 392 5 even even JJ 31504 392 6 chance chance NN 31504 392 7 with with IN 31504 392 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 392 9 fellow fellow JJ 31504 392 10 players player NNS 31504 392 11 . . . 31504 393 1 When when WRB 31504 393 2 later later RB 31504 393 3 in in IN 31504 393 4 life life NN 31504 393 5 he -PRON- PRP 31504 393 6 engages engage VBZ 31504 393 7 in in IN 31504 393 8 business business NN 31504 393 9 he -PRON- PRP 31504 393 10 resents resent VBZ 31504 393 11 any any DT 31504 393 12 favoritism favoritism NN 31504 393 13 shown show VBN 31504 393 14 by by IN 31504 393 15 the the DT 31504 393 16 government government NN 31504 393 17 of of IN 31504 393 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 393 19 state state NN 31504 393 20 or or CC 31504 393 21 town town NN 31504 393 22 to to IN 31504 393 23 others other NNS 31504 393 24 in in IN 31504 393 25 the the DT 31504 393 26 same same JJ 31504 393 27 or or CC 31504 393 28 a a DT 31504 393 29 similar similar JJ 31504 393 30 business business NN 31504 393 31 . . . 31504 394 1 This this DT 31504 394 2 feeling feeling NN 31504 394 3 is be VBZ 31504 394 4 especially especially RB 31504 394 5 noticeable noticeable JJ 31504 394 6 in in IN 31504 394 7 the the DT 31504 394 8 matter matter NN 31504 394 9 of of IN 31504 394 10 taxation taxation NN 31504 394 11 . . . 31504 395 1 If if IN 31504 395 2 one one PRP 31504 395 3 believes believe VBZ 31504 395 4 the the DT 31504 395 5 taxes taxis NNS 31504 395 6 imposed impose VBN 31504 395 7 by by IN 31504 395 8 the the DT 31504 395 9 government government NN 31504 395 10 are be VBP 31504 395 11 unnecessarily unnecessarily RB 31504 395 12 heavy heavy JJ 31504 395 13 he -PRON- PRP 31504 395 14 may may MD 31504 395 15 feel feel VB 31504 395 16 some some DT 31504 395 17 resentment resentment NN 31504 395 18 , , , 31504 395 19 but but CC 31504 395 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 395 21 resentment resentment NN 31504 395 22 is be VBZ 31504 395 23 much much RB 31504 395 24 greater great JJR 31504 395 25 if if IN 31504 395 26 he -PRON- PRP 31504 395 27 believes believe VBZ 31504 395 28 he -PRON- PRP 31504 395 29 is be VBZ 31504 395 30 overtaxed overtax VBN 31504 395 31 in in IN 31504 395 32 comparison comparison NN 31504 395 33 with with IN 31504 395 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 395 35 fellows fellow NNS 31504 395 36 , , , 31504 395 37 that that IN 31504 395 38 they -PRON- PRP 31504 395 39 are be VBP 31504 395 40 escaping escape VBG 31504 395 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 395 42 proportionate proportionate NN 31504 395 43 share share NN 31504 395 44 of of IN 31504 395 45 the the DT 31504 395 46 burden burden NN 31504 395 47 , , , 31504 395 48 or or CC 31504 395 49 that that IN 31504 395 50 taxes taxis NNS 31504 395 51 are be VBP 31504 395 52 imposed impose VBN 31504 395 53 on on IN 31504 395 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 395 55 products product NNS 31504 395 56 in in IN 31504 395 57 order order NN 31504 395 58 to to TO 31504 395 59 favor favor VB 31504 395 60 the the DT 31504 395 61 products product NNS 31504 395 62 of of IN 31504 395 63 others other NNS 31504 395 64 , , , 31504 395 65 as as IN 31504 395 66 when when WRB 31504 395 67 oleomargarine oleomargarine NN 31504 395 68 was be VBD 31504 395 69 taxed tax VBN 31504 395 70 to to TO 31504 395 71 handicap handicap VB 31504 395 72 it -PRON- PRP 31504 395 73 in in IN 31504 395 74 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 395 75 competition competition NN 31504 395 76 with with IN 31504 395 77 butter butter NN 31504 395 78 . . . 31504 396 1 This this DT 31504 396 2 feeling feeling NN 31504 396 3 of of IN 31504 396 4 resentment resentment NN 31504 396 5 at at IN 31504 396 6 inequality inequality NN 31504 396 7 of of IN 31504 396 8 restraints restraint NNS 31504 396 9 and and CC 31504 396 10 burdens burden NNS 31504 396 11 imposed impose VBN 31504 396 12 and and CC 31504 396 13 exemptions exemption NNS 31504 396 14 granted grant VBN 31504 396 15 is be VBZ 31504 396 16 not not RB 31504 396 17 ignoble ignoble JJ 31504 396 18 , , , 31504 396 19 is be VBZ 31504 396 20 not not RB 31504 396 21 a a DT 31504 396 22 feeling feeling NN 31504 396 23 to to TO 31504 396 24 be be VB 31504 396 25 suppressed suppress VBN 31504 396 26 or or CC 31504 396 27 even even RB 31504 396 28 concealed conceal VBN 31504 396 29 . . . 31504 397 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 397 2 is be VBZ 31504 397 3 far far RB 31504 397 4 different different JJ 31504 397 5 from from IN 31504 397 6 the the DT 31504 397 7 feeling feeling NN 31504 397 8 of of IN 31504 397 9 envy envy NN 31504 397 10 . . . 31504 398 1 If if IN 31504 398 2 I -PRON- PRP 31504 398 3 can can MD 31504 398 4 only only RB 31504 398 5 afford afford VB 31504 398 6 to to TO 31504 398 7 ride ride VB 31504 398 8 in in IN 31504 398 9 a a DT 31504 398 10 trolley trolley NN 31504 398 11 car car NN 31504 398 12 I -PRON- PRP 31504 398 13 may may MD 31504 398 14 envy envy VB 31504 398 15 the the DT 31504 398 16 man man NN 31504 398 17 who who WP 31504 398 18 can can MD 31504 398 19 afford afford VB 31504 398 20 to to TO 31504 398 21 ride ride VB 31504 398 22 in in IN 31504 398 23 a a DT 31504 398 24 luxurious luxurious JJ 31504 398 25 motor motor NN 31504 398 26 car car NN 31504 398 27 and and CC 31504 398 28 yet yet CC 31504 398 29 not not RB 31504 398 30 feel feel VB 31504 398 31 wronged wrong VBN 31504 398 32 . . . 31504 399 1 But but CC 31504 399 2 if if IN 31504 399 3 I -PRON- PRP 31504 399 4 am be VBP 31504 399 5 excluded exclude VBN 31504 399 6 from from IN 31504 399 7 a a DT 31504 399 8 public public JJ 31504 399 9 street street NN 31504 399 10 car car NN 31504 399 11 to to TO 31504 399 12 which which WDT 31504 399 13 he -PRON- PRP 31504 399 14 is be VBZ 31504 399 15 admitted admit VBN 31504 399 16 I -PRON- PRP 31504 399 17 have have VBP 31504 399 18 a a DT 31504 399 19 different different JJ 31504 399 20 feeling feeling NN 31504 399 21 , , , 31504 399 22 that that DT 31504 399 23 of of IN 31504 399 24 resentment resentment NN 31504 399 25 . . . 31504 400 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 400 2 may may MD 31504 400 3 be be VB 31504 400 4 perfectly perfectly RB 31504 400 5 willing willing JJ 31504 400 6 that that IN 31504 400 7 all all DT 31504 400 8 others other NNS 31504 400 9 , , , 31504 400 10 rich rich JJ 31504 400 11 or or CC 31504 400 12 poor poor JJ 31504 400 13 , , , 31504 400 14 shall shall MD 31504 400 15 use use VB 31504 400 16 the the DT 31504 400 17 streets street NNS 31504 400 18 to to IN 31504 400 19 the the DT 31504 400 20 full full JJ 31504 400 21 extent extent NN 31504 400 22 that that WDT 31504 400 23 I -PRON- PRP 31504 400 24 do do VBP 31504 400 25 , , , 31504 400 26 but but CC 31504 400 27 if if IN 31504 400 28 it -PRON- PRP 31504 400 29 be be VB 31504 400 30 proposed propose VBN 31504 400 31 that that IN 31504 400 32 my -PRON- PRP$ 31504 400 33 use use NN 31504 400 34 shall shall MD 31504 400 35 be be VB 31504 400 36 limited limit VBN 31504 400 37 in in IN 31504 400 38 order order NN 31504 400 39 that that IN 31504 400 40 some some DT 31504 400 41 others other NNS 31504 400 42 may may MD 31504 400 43 for for IN 31504 400 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 400 45 private private JJ 31504 400 46 purposes purpose NNS 31504 400 47 have have VBP 31504 400 48 more more JJR 31504 400 49 than than IN 31504 400 50 an an DT 31504 400 51 equal equal JJ 31504 400 52 use use NN 31504 400 53 with with IN 31504 400 54 me -PRON- PRP 31504 400 55 , , , 31504 400 56 my -PRON- PRP$ 31504 400 57 feeling feeling NN 31504 400 58 is be VBZ 31504 400 59 not not RB 31504 400 60 one one CD 31504 400 61 of of IN 31504 400 62 envy envy NN 31504 400 63 but but CC 31504 400 64 of of IN 31504 400 65 indignation indignation NN 31504 400 66 . . . 31504 401 1 So so RB 31504 401 2 I -PRON- PRP 31504 401 3 can can MD 31504 401 4 appreciate appreciate VB 31504 401 5 that that IN 31504 401 6 if if IN 31504 401 7 I -PRON- PRP 31504 401 8 wilfully wilfully RB 31504 401 9 or or CC 31504 401 10 through through IN 31504 401 11 carelessness carelessness NN 31504 401 12 injure injure NN 31504 401 13 another another DT 31504 401 14 I -PRON- PRP 31504 401 15 should should MD 31504 401 16 make make VB 31504 401 17 full full JJ 31504 401 18 compensation compensation NN 31504 401 19 , , , 31504 401 20 and and CC 31504 401 21 hence hence RB 31504 401 22 can can MD 31504 401 23 cheerfully cheerfully RB 31504 401 24 submit submit VB 31504 401 25 to to IN 31504 401 26 the the DT 31504 401 27 law law NN 31504 401 28 compelling compel VBG 31504 401 29 me -PRON- PRP 31504 401 30 to to TO 31504 401 31 do do VB 31504 401 32 so so RB 31504 401 33 ; ; : 31504 401 34 but but CC 31504 401 35 if if IN 31504 401 36 the the DT 31504 401 37 law law NN 31504 401 38 undertakes undertake VBZ 31504 401 39 to to TO 31504 401 40 exempt exempt VB 31504 401 41 any any DT 31504 401 42 other other JJ 31504 401 43 person person NN 31504 401 44 from from IN 31504 401 45 a a DT 31504 401 46 similar similar JJ 31504 401 47 liability liability NN 31504 401 48 , , , 31504 401 49 I -PRON- PRP 31504 401 50 feel feel VBP 31504 401 51 a a DT 31504 401 52 keen keen JJ 31504 401 53 sense sense NN 31504 401 54 of of IN 31504 401 55 wrong wrong NN 31504 401 56 . . . 31504 402 1 Conversely conversely RB 31504 402 2 , , , 31504 402 3 the the DT 31504 402 4 most most RBS 31504 402 5 strict strict JJ 31504 402 6 disciplinarian disciplinarian NN 31504 402 7 , , , 31504 402 8 the the DT 31504 402 9 martinet martinet NN 31504 402 10 even even RB 31504 402 11 , , , 31504 402 12 if if IN 31504 402 13 otherwise otherwise RB 31504 402 14 competent competent JJ 31504 402 15 receives receive VBZ 31504 402 16 ready ready JJ 31504 402 17 obedience obedience NN 31504 402 18 and and CC 31504 402 19 respect respect NN 31504 402 20 if if IN 31504 402 21 it -PRON- PRP 31504 402 22 is be VBZ 31504 402 23 seen see VBN 31504 402 24 that that IN 31504 402 25 he -PRON- PRP 31504 402 26 treats treat VBZ 31504 402 27 alike alike RB 31504 402 28 , , , 31504 402 29 according accord VBG 31504 402 30 to to IN 31504 402 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 402 32 merits merit NNS 31504 402 33 , , , 31504 402 34 all all DT 31504 402 35 subject subject JJ 31504 402 36 to to IN 31504 402 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 402 38 authority authority NN 31504 402 39 . . . 31504 403 1 This this DT 31504 403 2 feeling feeling NN 31504 403 3 is be VBZ 31504 403 4 natural natural JJ 31504 403 5 . . . 31504 404 1 Nature nature NN 31504 404 2 is be VBZ 31504 404 3 impartial impartial JJ 31504 404 4 in in IN 31504 404 5 the the DT 31504 404 6 application application NN 31504 404 7 of of IN 31504 404 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 404 9 laws law NNS 31504 404 10 . . . 31504 405 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 405 2 allows allow VBZ 31504 405 3 no no DT 31504 405 4 exemption exemption NN 31504 405 5 . . . 31504 406 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 406 2 fires fire NNS 31504 406 3 burn burn VBP 31504 406 4 the the DT 31504 406 5 weak weak JJ 31504 406 6 as as RB 31504 406 7 well well RB 31504 406 8 as as IN 31504 406 9 the the DT 31504 406 10 strong strong JJ 31504 406 11 , , , 31504 406 12 the the DT 31504 406 13 child child NN 31504 406 14 as as RB 31504 406 15 well well RB 31504 406 16 as as IN 31504 406 17 the the DT 31504 406 18 man man NN 31504 406 19 , , , 31504 406 20 the the DT 31504 406 21 poor poor JJ 31504 406 22 as as RB 31504 406 23 well well RB 31504 406 24 as as IN 31504 406 25 the the DT 31504 406 26 rich rich JJ 31504 406 27 . . . 31504 407 1 One one CD 31504 407 2 star star NN 31504 407 3 differs differ VBZ 31504 407 4 from from IN 31504 407 5 another another DT 31504 407 6 star star NN 31504 407 7 in in IN 31504 407 8 glory glory NN 31504 407 9 , , , 31504 407 10 but but CC 31504 407 11 no no DT 31504 407 12 one one NN 31504 407 13 of of IN 31504 407 14 all all PDT 31504 407 15 the the DT 31504 407 16 millions million NNS 31504 407 17 of of IN 31504 407 18 stars star NNS 31504 407 19 is be VBZ 31504 407 20 exempt exempt JJ 31504 407 21 from from IN 31504 407 22 any any DT 31504 407 23 of of IN 31504 407 24 the the DT 31504 407 25 laws law NNS 31504 407 26 set set VBN 31504 407 27 by by IN 31504 407 28 nature nature NN 31504 407 29 for for IN 31504 407 30 stars star NNS 31504 407 31 . . . 31504 408 1 This this DT 31504 408 2 feeling feeling NN 31504 408 3 of of IN 31504 408 4 right right NN 31504 408 5 to to IN 31504 408 6 impartiality impartiality NN 31504 408 7 of of IN 31504 408 8 treatment treatment NN 31504 408 9 had have VBD 31504 408 10 some some DT 31504 408 11 faint faint JJ 31504 408 12 expression expression NN 31504 408 13 in in IN 31504 408 14 the the DT 31504 408 15 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 408 16 " " `` 31504 408 17 Body Body NNP 31504 408 18 of of IN 31504 408 19 Liberties Liberties NNPS 31504 408 20 " " '' 31504 408 21 of of IN 31504 408 22 1641 1641 CD 31504 408 23 , , , 31504 408 24 in in IN 31504 408 25 which which WDT 31504 408 26 it -PRON- PRP 31504 408 27 was be VBD 31504 408 28 declared declare VBN 31504 408 29 that that IN 31504 408 30 the the DT 31504 408 31 liberties liberty NNS 31504 408 32 , , , 31504 408 33 etc etc FW 31504 408 34 . . FW 31504 408 35 , , , 31504 408 36 therein therein RB 31504 408 37 enumerated enumerate VBN 31504 408 38 should should MD 31504 408 39 be be VB 31504 408 40 enjoyed enjoy VBN 31504 408 41 " " `` 31504 408 42 impartially impartially RB 31504 408 43 " " '' 31504 408 44 by by IN 31504 408 45 all all DT 31504 408 46 persons person NNS 31504 408 47 within within IN 31504 408 48 the the DT 31504 408 49 jurisdiction jurisdiction NN 31504 408 50 of of IN 31504 408 51 the the DT 31504 408 52 colony colony NN 31504 408 53 . . . 31504 409 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 409 2 was be VBD 31504 409 3 more more RBR 31504 409 4 distinctly distinctly RB 31504 409 5 recognized recognize VBN 31504 409 6 in in IN 31504 409 7 the the DT 31504 409 8 Connecticut Connecticut NNP 31504 409 9 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 409 10 of of IN 31504 409 11 1818 1818 CD 31504 409 12 and and CC 31504 409 13 a a DT 31504 409 14 part part NN 31504 409 15 of of IN 31504 409 16 the the DT 31504 409 17 Connecticut Connecticut NNP 31504 409 18 Bill Bill NNP 31504 409 19 of of IN 31504 409 20 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 409 21 today today NN 31504 409 22 , , , 31504 409 23 " " `` 31504 409 24 That that IN 31504 409 25 all all DT 31504 409 26 men man NNS 31504 409 27 when when WRB 31504 409 28 they -PRON- PRP 31504 409 29 form form VBP 31504 409 30 a a DT 31504 409 31 social social JJ 31504 409 32 compact compact NN 31504 409 33 are be VBP 31504 409 34 equal equal JJ 31504 409 35 in in IN 31504 409 36 rights right NNS 31504 409 37 and and CC 31504 409 38 that that IN 31504 409 39 no no DT 31504 409 40 man man NN 31504 409 41 or or CC 31504 409 42 set set NN 31504 409 43 of of IN 31504 409 44 men man NNS 31504 409 45 are be VBP 31504 409 46 entitled entitle VBN 31504 409 47 to to IN 31504 409 48 exclusive exclusive JJ 31504 409 49 public public JJ 31504 409 50 emoluments emolument NNS 31504 409 51 or or CC 31504 409 52 privileges privilege NNS 31504 409 53 from from IN 31504 409 54 the the DT 31504 409 55 community community NN 31504 409 56 . . . 31504 409 57 " " '' 31504 410 1 Again again RB 31504 410 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 410 3 appears appear VBZ 31504 410 4 in in IN 31504 410 5 the the DT 31504 410 6 federal federal JJ 31504 410 7 and and CC 31504 410 8 some some DT 31504 410 9 state state NN 31504 410 10 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 410 11 in in IN 31504 410 12 the the DT 31504 410 13 provision provision NN 31504 410 14 against against IN 31504 410 15 the the DT 31504 410 16 granting granting NN 31504 410 17 of of IN 31504 410 18 titles title NNS 31504 410 19 of of IN 31504 410 20 nobility nobility NN 31504 410 21 . . . 31504 411 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 411 2 seems seem VBZ 31504 411 3 to to TO 31504 411 4 be be VB 31504 411 5 at at IN 31504 411 6 least least JJS 31504 411 7 impliedly impliedly RB 31504 411 8 recognized recognize VBN 31504 411 9 in in IN 31504 411 10 the the DT 31504 411 11 XIVth XIVth NNP 31504 411 12 amendment amendment NN 31504 411 13 to to IN 31504 411 14 the the DT 31504 411 15 United United NNP 31504 411 16 States States NNP 31504 411 17 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 411 18 in in IN 31504 411 19 the the DT 31504 411 20 clause clause NN 31504 411 21 that that WDT 31504 411 22 no no DT 31504 411 23 state state NN 31504 411 24 " " '' 31504 411 25 shall shall MD 31504 411 26 deny deny VB 31504 411 27 any any DT 31504 411 28 person person NN 31504 411 29 within within IN 31504 411 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 411 31 jurisdiction jurisdiction NN 31504 411 32 the the DT 31504 411 33 equal equal JJ 31504 411 34 protection protection NN 31504 411 35 of of IN 31504 411 36 the the DT 31504 411 37 laws law NNS 31504 411 38 , , , 31504 411 39 " " '' 31504 411 40 since since IN 31504 411 41 " " `` 31504 411 42 the the DT 31504 411 43 equal equal JJ 31504 411 44 protection protection NN 31504 411 45 of of IN 31504 411 46 the the DT 31504 411 47 laws law NNS 31504 411 48 " " `` 31504 411 49 necessarily necessarily RB 31504 411 50 implies imply VBZ 31504 411 51 protection protection NN 31504 411 52 against against IN 31504 411 53 unequal unequal JJ 31504 411 54 laws law NNS 31504 411 55 , , , 31504 411 56 laws law NNS 31504 411 57 favoring favor VBG 31504 411 58 some some DT 31504 411 59 at at IN 31504 411 60 the the DT 31504 411 61 expense expense NN 31504 411 62 of of IN 31504 411 63 others other NNS 31504 411 64 or or CC 31504 411 65 of of IN 31504 411 66 the the DT 31504 411 67 whole whole NN 31504 411 68 . . . 31504 412 1 If if IN 31504 412 2 the the DT 31504 412 3 state state NN 31504 412 4 favors favor VBZ 31504 412 5 one one CD 31504 412 6 more more JJR 31504 412 7 than than IN 31504 412 8 another another DT 31504 412 9 it -PRON- PRP 31504 412 10 does do VBZ 31504 412 11 deny deny VB 31504 412 12 that that IN 31504 412 13 other other JJ 31504 412 14 equal equal JJ 31504 412 15 protection protection NN 31504 412 16 . . . 31504 413 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 413 2 do do VBP 31504 413 3 not not RB 31504 413 4 subscribe subscribe VB 31504 413 5 to to IN 31504 413 6 the the DT 31504 413 7 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 413 8 that that IN 31504 413 9 " " `` 31504 413 10 the the DT 31504 413 11 greatest great JJS 31504 413 12 good good NN 31504 413 13 of of IN 31504 413 14 the the DT 31504 413 15 greatest great JJS 31504 413 16 number number NN 31504 413 17 " " '' 31504 413 18 is be VBZ 31504 413 19 to to TO 31504 413 20 be be VB 31504 413 21 sought seek VBN 31504 413 22 . . . 31504 414 1 The the DT 31504 414 2 only only JJ 31504 414 3 legitimate legitimate JJ 31504 414 4 search search NN 31504 414 5 is be VBZ 31504 414 6 for for IN 31504 414 7 the the DT 31504 414 8 good good NN 31504 414 9 of of IN 31504 414 10 the the DT 31504 414 11 whole whole JJ 31504 414 12 number number NN 31504 414 13 without without IN 31504 414 14 discrimination discrimination NN 31504 414 15 for for IN 31504 414 16 or or CC 31504 414 17 against against IN 31504 414 18 any any DT 31504 414 19 one one CD 31504 414 20 . . . 31504 415 1 This this DT 31504 415 2 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 415 3 found find VBD 31504 415 4 expression expression NN 31504 415 5 in in IN 31504 415 6 the the DT 31504 415 7 once once RB 31504 415 8 popular popular JJ 31504 415 9 slogan slogan NN 31504 415 10 , , , 31504 415 11 " " `` 31504 415 12 Equal equal JJ 31504 415 13 rights right NNS 31504 415 14 for for IN 31504 415 15 all all DT 31504 415 16 . . . 31504 416 1 Special special JJ 31504 416 2 privileges privilege NNS 31504 416 3 for for IN 31504 416 4 none none NN 31504 416 5 . . . 31504 416 6 " " '' 31504 417 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 417 2 say say VBP 31504 417 3 once once RB 31504 417 4 popular popular JJ 31504 417 5 , , , 31504 417 6 for for IN 31504 417 7 today today NN 31504 417 8 it -PRON- PRP 31504 417 9 would would MD 31504 417 10 seem seem VB 31504 417 11 not not RB 31504 417 12 popular popular JJ 31504 417 13 in in IN 31504 417 14 practice practice NN 31504 417 15 . . . 31504 418 1 True true JJ 31504 418 2 , , , 31504 418 3 special special JJ 31504 418 4 privileges privilege NNS 31504 418 5 are be VBP 31504 418 6 still still RB 31504 418 7 loudly loudly RB 31504 418 8 denounced denounce VBN 31504 418 9 , , , 31504 418 10 but but CC 31504 418 11 under under IN 31504 418 12 the the DT 31504 418 13 name name NN 31504 418 14 of of IN 31504 418 15 special special JJ 31504 418 16 exemptions exemption NNS 31504 418 17 , , , 31504 418 18 they -PRON- PRP 31504 418 19 are be VBP 31504 418 20 still still RB 31504 418 21 demanded demand VBN 31504 418 22 by by IN 31504 418 23 those those DT 31504 418 24 who who WP 31504 418 25 denounce denounce VBP 31504 418 26 them -PRON- PRP 31504 418 27 most most RBS 31504 418 28 loudly loudly RB 31504 418 29 . . . 31504 419 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 419 2 is be VBZ 31504 419 3 not not RB 31504 419 4 inequality inequality NN 31504 419 5 of of IN 31504 419 6 natural natural JJ 31504 419 7 powers power NNS 31504 419 8 of of IN 31504 419 9 body body NN 31504 419 10 or or CC 31504 419 11 mind mind NN 31504 419 12 , , , 31504 419 13 nor nor CC 31504 419 14 inequality inequality NN 31504 419 15 in in IN 31504 419 16 natural natural JJ 31504 419 17 conditions condition NNS 31504 419 18 , , , 31504 419 19 that that WDT 31504 419 20 excites excite VBZ 31504 419 21 this this DT 31504 419 22 feeling feeling NN 31504 419 23 of of IN 31504 419 24 resentment resentment NN 31504 419 25 I -PRON- PRP 31504 419 26 have have VBP 31504 419 27 noted note VBN 31504 419 28 . . . 31504 420 1 The the DT 31504 420 2 man man NN 31504 420 3 of of IN 31504 420 4 feeble feeble JJ 31504 420 5 natural natural JJ 31504 420 6 powers power NNS 31504 420 7 may may MD 31504 420 8 envy envy VB 31504 420 9 him -PRON- PRP 31504 420 10 of of IN 31504 420 11 strong strong JJ 31504 420 12 natural natural JJ 31504 420 13 powers power NNS 31504 420 14 , , , 31504 420 15 but but CC 31504 420 16 he -PRON- PRP 31504 420 17 can can MD 31504 420 18 see see VB 31504 420 19 that that DT 31504 420 20 society society NN 31504 420 21 , , , 31504 420 22 that that DT 31504 420 23 law law NN 31504 420 24 , , , 31504 420 25 is be VBZ 31504 420 26 not not RB 31504 420 27 responsible responsible JJ 31504 420 28 for for IN 31504 420 29 that that DT 31504 420 30 inequality inequality NN 31504 420 31 . . . 31504 421 1 If if IN 31504 421 2 one one PRP 31504 421 3 finds find VBZ 31504 421 4 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 421 5 from from IN 31504 421 6 lack lack NN 31504 421 7 of of IN 31504 421 8 natural natural JJ 31504 421 9 ability ability NN 31504 421 10 or or CC 31504 421 11 adaptiveness adaptiveness NN 31504 421 12 unable unable JJ 31504 421 13 to to TO 31504 421 14 accomplish accomplish VB 31504 421 15 what what WP 31504 421 16 others other NNS 31504 421 17 of of IN 31504 421 18 superior superior JJ 31504 421 19 ability ability NN 31504 421 20 or or CC 31504 421 21 adaptiveness adaptiveness NN 31504 421 22 easily easily RB 31504 421 23 accomplish accomplish VBP 31504 421 24 , , , 31504 421 25 and and CC 31504 421 26 hence hence RB 31504 421 27 he -PRON- PRP 31504 421 28 fails fail VBZ 31504 421 29 to to TO 31504 421 30 receive receive VB 31504 421 31 the the DT 31504 421 32 prize prize NN 31504 421 33 they -PRON- PRP 31504 421 34 so so RB 31504 421 35 easily easily RB 31504 421 36 win win VBP 31504 421 37 , , , 31504 421 38 he -PRON- PRP 31504 421 39 may may MD 31504 421 40 feel feel VB 31504 421 41 great great JJ 31504 421 42 disappointment disappointment NN 31504 421 43 and and CC 31504 421 44 regret regret NN 31504 421 45 , , , 31504 421 46 but but CC 31504 421 47 if if IN 31504 421 48 honest honest JJ 31504 421 49 with with IN 31504 421 50 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 421 51 will will MD 31504 421 52 not not RB 31504 421 53 attribute attribute VB 31504 421 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 421 55 failure failure NN 31504 421 56 to to IN 31504 421 57 the the DT 31504 421 58 injustice injustice NN 31504 421 59 of of IN 31504 421 60 society society NN 31504 421 61 . . . 31504 422 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 422 2 is be VBZ 31504 422 3 not not RB 31504 422 4 essential essential JJ 31504 422 5 to to IN 31504 422 6 the the DT 31504 422 7 preservation preservation NN 31504 422 8 of of IN 31504 422 9 society society NN 31504 422 10 and and CC 31504 422 11 the the DT 31504 422 12 race race NN 31504 422 13 that that IN 31504 422 14 such such JJ 31504 422 15 inequalities inequality NNS 31504 422 16 should should MD 31504 422 17 be be VB 31504 422 18 removed remove VBN 31504 422 19 , , , 31504 422 20 that that IN 31504 422 21 all all DT 31504 422 22 men man NNS 31504 422 23 should should MD 31504 422 24 be be VB 31504 422 25 reduced reduce VBN 31504 422 26 to to IN 31504 422 27 a a DT 31504 422 28 dead dead JJ 31504 422 29 level level NN 31504 422 30 of of IN 31504 422 31 capacity capacity NN 31504 422 32 , , , 31504 422 33 that that IN 31504 422 34 human human JJ 31504 422 35 nature nature NN 31504 422 36 should should MD 31504 422 37 be be VB 31504 422 38 ignored ignore VBN 31504 422 39 . . . 31504 423 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 423 2 is be VBZ 31504 423 3 strongly strongly RB 31504 423 4 felt feel VBN 31504 423 5 , , , 31504 423 6 however however RB 31504 423 7 , , , 31504 423 8 that that IN 31504 423 9 society society NN 31504 423 10 should should MD 31504 423 11 not not RB 31504 423 12 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 423 13 create create VB 31504 423 14 artificial artificial JJ 31504 423 15 inequalities inequality NNS 31504 423 16 , , , 31504 423 17 should should MD 31504 423 18 not not RB 31504 423 19 allow allow VB 31504 423 20 one one CD 31504 423 21 man man NN 31504 423 22 or or CC 31504 423 23 set set NN 31504 423 24 of of IN 31504 423 25 men man NNS 31504 423 26 a a DT 31504 423 27 liberty liberty NN 31504 423 28 it -PRON- PRP 31504 423 29 will will MD 31504 423 30 not not RB 31504 423 31 allow allow VB 31504 423 32 to to IN 31504 423 33 others other NNS 31504 423 34 , , , 31504 423 35 should should MD 31504 423 36 not not RB 31504 423 37 impose impose VB 31504 423 38 burdens burden NNS 31504 423 39 on on IN 31504 423 40 one one CD 31504 423 41 man man NN 31504 423 42 or or CC 31504 423 43 set set NN 31504 423 44 of of IN 31504 423 45 men man NNS 31504 423 46 to to TO 31504 423 47 be be VB 31504 423 48 borne bear VBN 31504 423 49 by by IN 31504 423 50 them -PRON- PRP 31504 423 51 alone alone RB 31504 423 52 while while IN 31504 423 53 others other NNS 31504 423 54 are be VBP 31504 423 55 exempt exempt JJ 31504 423 56 ; ; : 31504 423 57 or or CC 31504 423 58 if if IN 31504 423 59 it -PRON- PRP 31504 423 60 does do VBZ 31504 423 61 undertake undertake VB 31504 423 62 to to TO 31504 423 63 do do VB 31504 423 64 so so RB 31504 423 65 it -PRON- PRP 31504 423 66 should should MD 31504 423 67 be be VB 31504 423 68 able able JJ 31504 423 69 to to TO 31504 423 70 demonstrate demonstrate VB 31504 423 71 that that IN 31504 423 72 such such JJ 31504 423 73 artificial artificial JJ 31504 423 74 inequality inequality NN 31504 423 75 is be VBZ 31504 423 76 necessary necessary JJ 31504 423 77 for for IN 31504 423 78 the the DT 31504 423 79 safety safety NN 31504 423 80 of of IN 31504 423 81 all all DT 31504 423 82 . . . 31504 424 1 The the DT 31504 424 2 intensity intensity NN 31504 424 3 of of IN 31504 424 4 this this DT 31504 424 5 feeling feeling NN 31504 424 6 against against IN 31504 424 7 artificial artificial JJ 31504 424 8 inequalities inequality NNS 31504 424 9 is be VBZ 31504 424 10 so so RB 31504 424 11 great great JJ 31504 424 12 that that IN 31504 424 13 men man NNS 31504 424 14 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 424 15 prefer prefer VBP 31504 424 16 equality equality NN 31504 424 17 before before IN 31504 424 18 the the DT 31504 424 19 law law NN 31504 424 20 even even RB 31504 424 21 to to IN 31504 424 22 liberty liberty NN 31504 424 23 . . . 31504 425 1 When when WRB 31504 425 2 the the DT 31504 425 3 British british JJ 31504 425 4 ambassador ambassador NN 31504 425 5 said say VBD 31504 425 6 to to IN 31504 425 7 Madam Madam NNP 31504 425 8 De De NNP 31504 425 9 Stael Stael NNP 31504 425 10 that that IN 31504 425 11 Frenchmen Frenchmen NNP 31504 425 12 had have VBD 31504 425 13 no no DT 31504 425 14 more more JJR 31504 425 15 liberty liberty NN 31504 425 16 after after IN 31504 425 17 the the DT 31504 425 18 Revolution Revolution NNP 31504 425 19 than than IN 31504 425 20 before before RB 31504 425 21 , , , 31504 425 22 she -PRON- PRP 31504 425 23 answered answer VBD 31504 425 24 that that IN 31504 425 25 they -PRON- PRP 31504 425 26 had have VBD 31504 425 27 acquired acquire VBN 31504 425 28 equality equality NN 31504 425 29 before before IN 31504 425 30 the the DT 31504 425 31 law law NN 31504 425 32 and and CC 31504 425 33 they -PRON- PRP 31504 425 34 preferred prefer VBD 31504 425 35 that that DT 31504 425 36 to to IN 31504 425 37 more more JJR 31504 425 38 liberty liberty NN 31504 425 39 . . . 31504 426 1 This this DT 31504 426 2 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 426 3 was be VBD 31504 426 4 tersely tersely RB 31504 426 5 and and CC 31504 426 6 well well RB 31504 426 7 expressed express VBN 31504 426 8 in in IN 31504 426 9 the the DT 31504 426 10 French French NNP 31504 426 11 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 426 12 of of IN 31504 426 13 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 426 14 of of IN 31504 426 15 1795 1795 CD 31504 426 16 . . . 31504 427 1 " " `` 31504 427 2 Equality equality NN 31504 427 3 consists consist VBZ 31504 427 4 in in IN 31504 427 5 this this DT 31504 427 6 , , , 31504 427 7 that that IN 31504 427 8 the the DT 31504 427 9 law law NN 31504 427 10 is be VBZ 31504 427 11 the the DT 31504 427 12 same same JJ 31504 427 13 for for IN 31504 427 14 all all DT 31504 427 15 whether whether IN 31504 427 16 it -PRON- PRP 31504 427 17 protects protect VBZ 31504 427 18 or or CC 31504 427 19 punishes punishe NNS 31504 427 20 . . . 31504 427 21 " " '' 31504 428 1 Of of RB 31504 428 2 course course RB 31504 428 3 , , , 31504 428 4 no no DT 31504 428 5 assertion assertion NN 31504 428 6 of of IN 31504 428 7 rights right NNS 31504 428 8 can can MD 31504 428 9 be be VB 31504 428 10 carried carry VBN 31504 428 11 to to IN 31504 428 12 the the DT 31504 428 13 extent extent NN 31504 428 14 of of IN 31504 428 15 the the DT 31504 428 16 dictum dictum NN 31504 428 17 , , , 31504 428 18 " " '' 31504 428 19 Fiat Fiat NNP 31504 428 20 Justitia Justitia NNP 31504 428 21 ruat ruat NNP 31504 428 22 Respublica Respublica NNP 31504 428 23 , , , 31504 428 24 " " `` 31504 428 25 for for IN 31504 428 26 if if IN 31504 428 27 the the DT 31504 428 28 state state NN 31504 428 29 fall fall NN 31504 428 30 , , , 31504 428 31 all all DT 31504 428 32 hopes hope NNS 31504 428 33 of of IN 31504 428 34 justice justice NN 31504 428 35 fall fall VBP 31504 428 36 with with IN 31504 428 37 it -PRON- PRP 31504 428 38 . . . 31504 429 1 When when WRB 31504 429 2 the the DT 31504 429 3 alternative alternative NN 31504 429 4 is be VBZ 31504 429 5 the the DT 31504 429 6 conquest conquest NN 31504 429 7 of of IN 31504 429 8 the the DT 31504 429 9 particular particular JJ 31504 429 10 society society NN 31504 429 11 by by IN 31504 429 12 invasion invasion NN 31504 429 13 or or CC 31504 429 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 429 15 disorganization disorganization NN 31504 429 16 by by IN 31504 429 17 rebellion rebellion NN 31504 429 18 or or CC 31504 429 19 rioting rioting NN 31504 429 20 or or CC 31504 429 21 otherwise otherwise RB 31504 429 22 , , , 31504 429 23 some some DT 31504 429 24 of of IN 31504 429 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 429 26 members member NNS 31504 429 27 must must MD 31504 429 28 submit submit VB 31504 429 29 to to IN 31504 429 30 the the DT 31504 429 31 sacrifice sacrifice NN 31504 429 32 of of IN 31504 429 33 some some DT 31504 429 34 or or CC 31504 429 35 all all DT 31504 429 36 of of IN 31504 429 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 429 38 rights right NNS 31504 429 39 . . . 31504 430 1 Nature nature NN 31504 430 2 will will MD 31504 430 3 sacrifice sacrifice VB 31504 430 4 individuals individual NNS 31504 430 5 for for IN 31504 430 6 the the DT 31504 430 7 preservation preservation NN 31504 430 8 of of IN 31504 430 9 the the DT 31504 430 10 race race NN 31504 430 11 . . . 31504 431 1 Society society NN 31504 431 2 must must MD 31504 431 3 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 431 4 do do VB 31504 431 5 the the DT 31504 431 6 same same JJ 31504 431 7 . . . 31504 432 1 " " `` 31504 432 2 Inter Inter NNP 31504 432 3 arma arma VBP 31504 432 4 silent silent JJ 31504 432 5 leges lex NNS 31504 432 6 . . . 31504 432 7 " " '' 31504 433 1 But but CC 31504 433 2 such such JJ 31504 433 3 times time NNS 31504 433 4 are be VBP 31504 433 5 exceptional exceptional JJ 31504 433 6 and and CC 31504 433 7 not not RB 31504 433 8 within within IN 31504 433 9 the the DT 31504 433 10 scope scope NN 31504 433 11 of of IN 31504 433 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 433 13 inquiry inquiry NN 31504 433 14 . . . 31504 434 1 To to TO 31504 434 2 sum sum VB 31504 434 3 up up RP 31504 434 4 the the DT 31504 434 5 matter matter NN 31504 434 6 , , , 31504 434 7 justice justice NN 31504 434 8 is be VBZ 31504 434 9 the the DT 31504 434 10 according accord VBG 31504 434 11 to to IN 31504 434 12 every every DT 31504 434 13 one one NN 31504 434 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 434 15 right right NN 31504 434 16 , , , 31504 434 17 and and CC 31504 434 18 that that IN 31504 434 19 right right NN 31504 434 20 is be VBZ 31504 434 21 such such JJ 31504 434 22 freedom freedom NN 31504 434 23 of of IN 31504 434 24 action action NN 31504 434 25 in in IN 31504 434 26 gratifying gratify VBG 31504 434 27 one one PRP 31504 434 28 's 's POS 31504 434 29 desires desire NNS 31504 434 30 as as IN 31504 434 31 can can MD 31504 434 32 be be VB 31504 434 33 exercised exercise VBN 31504 434 34 in in IN 31504 434 35 harmony harmony NN 31504 434 36 with with IN 31504 434 37 like like JJ 31504 434 38 freedom freedom NN 31504 434 39 by by IN 31504 434 40 others other NNS 31504 434 41 . . . 31504 435 1 In in IN 31504 435 2 other other JJ 31504 435 3 words word NNS 31504 435 4 , , , 31504 435 5 it -PRON- PRP 31504 435 6 is be VBZ 31504 435 7 equal equal JJ 31504 435 8 freedom freedom NN 31504 435 9 , , , 31504 435 10 equal equal JJ 31504 435 11 restraint restraint NN 31504 435 12 . . . 31504 436 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 436 2 is be VBZ 31504 436 3 order order NN 31504 436 4 and and CC 31504 436 5 harmony harmony NN 31504 436 6 . . . 31504 437 1 Plato Plato NNP 31504 437 2 and and CC 31504 437 3 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 31504 437 4 were be VBD 31504 437 5 right right JJ 31504 437 6 in in IN 31504 437 7 teaching teaching NN 31504 437 8 that that DT 31504 437 9 order order NN 31504 437 10 is be VBZ 31504 437 11 an an DT 31504 437 12 essential essential JJ 31504 437 13 element element NN 31504 437 14 of of IN 31504 437 15 justice justice NN 31504 437 16 . . . 31504 438 1 But but CC 31504 438 2 who who WP 31504 438 3 is be VBZ 31504 438 4 to to TO 31504 438 5 determine determine VB 31504 438 6 the the DT 31504 438 7 matter matter NN 31504 438 8 ? ? . 31504 439 1 Who who WP 31504 439 2 is be VBZ 31504 439 3 to to TO 31504 439 4 determine determine VB 31504 439 5 what what WDT 31504 439 6 degree degree NN 31504 439 7 of of IN 31504 439 8 restraint restraint NN 31504 439 9 or or CC 31504 439 10 liberty liberty NN 31504 439 11 is be VBZ 31504 439 12 necessary necessary JJ 31504 439 13 to to TO 31504 439 14 secure secure VB 31504 439 15 this this DT 31504 439 16 order order NN 31504 439 17 and and CC 31504 439 18 harmony harmony NN 31504 439 19 , , , 31504 439 20 this this DT 31504 439 21 justice justice NN 31504 439 22 ? ? . 31504 440 1 Obviously obviously RB 31504 440 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 440 3 is be VBZ 31504 440 4 society society NN 31504 440 5 , , , 31504 440 6 or or CC 31504 440 7 rather rather RB 31504 440 8 , , , 31504 440 9 individuals individual NNS 31504 440 10 acting act VBG 31504 440 11 as as IN 31504 440 12 a a DT 31504 440 13 whole whole NN 31504 440 14 through through IN 31504 440 15 society society NN 31504 440 16 and and CC 31504 440 17 not not RB 31504 440 18 each each DT 31504 440 19 individual individual JJ 31504 440 20 acting act VBG 31504 440 21 for for IN 31504 440 22 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 440 23 , , , 31504 440 24 that that WDT 31504 440 25 must must MD 31504 440 26 determine determine VB 31504 440 27 such such JJ 31504 440 28 questions question NNS 31504 440 29 . . . 31504 441 1 Society society NN 31504 441 2 has have VBZ 31504 441 3 the the DT 31504 441 4 responsibility responsibility NN 31504 441 5 . . . 31504 442 1 If if IN 31504 442 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 442 3 imposes impose VBZ 31504 442 4 too too RB 31504 442 5 many many JJ 31504 442 6 restraints restraint NNS 31504 442 7 or or CC 31504 442 8 imposes impose VBZ 31504 442 9 them -PRON- PRP 31504 442 10 unequally unequally RB 31504 442 11 it -PRON- PRP 31504 442 12 excites excite VBZ 31504 442 13 , , , 31504 442 14 as as IN 31504 442 15 said say VBD 31504 442 16 before before RB 31504 442 17 , , , 31504 442 18 resentment resentment NN 31504 442 19 and and CC 31504 442 20 antagonism antagonism NN 31504 442 21 , , , 31504 442 22 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 442 23 to to IN 31504 442 24 the the DT 31504 442 25 extent extent NN 31504 442 26 of of IN 31504 442 27 resistance resistance NN 31504 442 28 . . . 31504 443 1 If if IN 31504 443 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 443 3 imposes impose VBZ 31504 443 4 no no DT 31504 443 5 more more JJR 31504 443 6 restraints restraint NNS 31504 443 7 than than IN 31504 443 8 are be VBP 31504 443 9 necessary necessary JJ 31504 443 10 and and CC 31504 443 11 imposes impose VBZ 31504 443 12 them -PRON- PRP 31504 443 13 equally equally RB 31504 443 14 , , , 31504 443 15 order order NN 31504 443 16 and and CC 31504 443 17 harmony harmony NN 31504 443 18 are be VBP 31504 443 19 secured secure VBN 31504 443 20 . . . 31504 444 1 And and CC 31504 444 2 when when WRB 31504 444 3 we -PRON- PRP 31504 444 4 have have VBP 31504 444 5 this this DT 31504 444 6 equal equal JJ 31504 444 7 freedom freedom NN 31504 444 8 with with IN 31504 444 9 equal equal JJ 31504 444 10 and and CC 31504 444 11 only only JJ 31504 444 12 necessary necessary JJ 31504 444 13 restraints restraint NNS 31504 444 14 we -PRON- PRP 31504 444 15 have have VBP 31504 444 16 order order NN 31504 444 17 and and CC 31504 444 18 harmony,--in harmony,--in VBN 31504 444 19 other other JJ 31504 444 20 words word NNS 31504 444 21 , , , 31504 444 22 justice justice NN 31504 444 23 . . . 31504 445 1 Indeed indeed RB 31504 445 2 , , , 31504 445 3 to to TO 31504 445 4 repeat repeat VB 31504 445 5 , , , 31504 445 6 justice justice NN 31504 445 7 in in IN 31504 445 8 some some DT 31504 445 9 of of IN 31504 445 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 445 11 aspects aspect NNS 31504 445 12 may may MD 31504 445 13 be be VB 31504 445 14 considered consider VBN 31504 445 15 as as IN 31504 445 16 the the DT 31504 445 17 desired desire VBN 31504 445 18 equilibrium equilibrium NN 31504 445 19 between between IN 31504 445 20 the the DT 31504 445 21 needs need NNS 31504 445 22 of of IN 31504 445 23 society society NN 31504 445 24 and and CC 31504 445 25 the the DT 31504 445 26 interests interest NNS 31504 445 27 of of IN 31504 445 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 445 29 individual individual JJ 31504 445 30 members member NNS 31504 445 31 . . . 31504 446 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 446 2 have have VBP 31504 446 3 left leave VBN 31504 446 4 out out IN 31504 446 5 of of IN 31504 446 6 the the DT 31504 446 7 account account NN 31504 446 8 various various JJ 31504 446 9 virtues,--pity virtues,--pity NNP 31504 446 10 , , , 31504 446 11 sympathy sympathy NN 31504 446 12 , , , 31504 446 13 philanthropy philanthropy NN 31504 446 14 , , , 31504 446 15 generosity generosity NN 31504 446 16 and and CC 31504 446 17 the the DT 31504 446 18 like like JJ 31504 446 19 . . . 31504 447 1 Though though IN 31504 447 2 these these DT 31504 447 3 make make VBP 31504 447 4 social social JJ 31504 447 5 life life NN 31504 447 6 more more RBR 31504 447 7 agreeable agreeable JJ 31504 447 8 and and CC 31504 447 9 contribute contribute VBP 31504 447 10 much much RB 31504 447 11 to to IN 31504 447 12 the the DT 31504 447 13 sum sum NN 31504 447 14 of of IN 31504 447 15 human human JJ 31504 447 16 happiness happiness NN 31504 447 17 , , , 31504 447 18 they -PRON- PRP 31504 447 19 are be VBP 31504 447 20 not not RB 31504 447 21 essential essential JJ 31504 447 22 to to IN 31504 447 23 the the DT 31504 447 24 existence existence NN 31504 447 25 of of IN 31504 447 26 the the DT 31504 447 27 race race NN 31504 447 28 or or CC 31504 447 29 society society NN 31504 447 30 . . . 31504 448 1 Society society NN 31504 448 2 as as IN 31504 448 3 an an DT 31504 448 4 organization organization NN 31504 448 5 is be VBZ 31504 448 6 not not RB 31504 448 7 held hold VBN 31504 448 8 together together RB 31504 448 9 by by IN 31504 448 10 these these DT 31504 448 11 virtues virtue NNS 31504 448 12 , , , 31504 448 13 though though IN 31504 448 14 many many JJ 31504 448 15 of of IN 31504 448 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 448 17 weaker weak JJR 31504 448 18 members member NNS 31504 448 19 might may MD 31504 448 20 suffer suffer VB 31504 448 21 and and CC 31504 448 22 perish perish VB 31504 448 23 if if IN 31504 448 24 they -PRON- PRP 31504 448 25 were be VBD 31504 448 26 non non JJ 31504 448 27 - - JJ 31504 448 28 existent existent NN 31504 448 29 . . . 31504 449 1 Allow allow JJ 31504 449 2 men man NNS 31504 449 3 as as RB 31504 449 4 much much JJ 31504 449 5 freedom freedom NN 31504 449 6 of of IN 31504 449 7 thought thought NN 31504 449 8 and and CC 31504 449 9 action action NN 31504 449 10 as as IN 31504 449 11 can can MD 31504 449 12 be be VB 31504 449 13 exercised exercise VBN 31504 449 14 without without IN 31504 449 15 interference interference NN 31504 449 16 with with IN 31504 449 17 like like JJ 31504 449 18 freedom freedom NN 31504 449 19 of of IN 31504 449 20 others other NNS 31504 449 21 , , , 31504 449 22 but but CC 31504 449 23 restrain restrain VB 31504 449 24 them -PRON- PRP 31504 449 25 from from IN 31504 449 26 exercising exercise VBG 31504 449 27 any any DT 31504 449 28 greater great JJR 31504 449 29 freedom freedom NN 31504 449 30 , , , 31504 449 31 and and CC 31504 449 32 they -PRON- PRP 31504 449 33 can can MD 31504 449 34 and and CC 31504 449 35 will will MD 31504 449 36 live live VB 31504 449 37 together together RB 31504 449 38 in in IN 31504 449 39 society society NN 31504 449 40 though though IN 31504 449 41 they -PRON- PRP 31504 449 42 may may MD 31504 449 43 be be VB 31504 449 44 wholly wholly RB 31504 449 45 selfish selfish JJ 31504 449 46 in in IN 31504 449 47 feeling feeling NN 31504 449 48 and and CC 31504 449 49 conduct conduct NN 31504 449 50 . . . 31504 450 1 What what WP 31504 450 2 is be VBZ 31504 450 3 called call VBN 31504 450 4 the the DT 31504 450 5 golden golden JJ 31504 450 6 rule rule NN 31504 450 7 , , , 31504 450 8 that that IN 31504 450 9 we -PRON- PRP 31504 450 10 should should MD 31504 450 11 do do VB 31504 450 12 to to IN 31504 450 13 others other NNS 31504 450 14 as as IN 31504 450 15 we -PRON- PRP 31504 450 16 would would MD 31504 450 17 have have VB 31504 450 18 them -PRON- PRP 31504 450 19 do do VB 31504 450 20 to to IN 31504 450 21 us -PRON- PRP 31504 450 22 , , , 31504 450 23 is be VBZ 31504 450 24 a a DT 31504 450 25 precept precept NN 31504 450 26 of of IN 31504 450 27 philanthropy philanthropy NN 31504 450 28 , , , 31504 450 29 of of IN 31504 450 30 charity charity NN 31504 450 31 , , , 31504 450 32 not not RB 31504 450 33 of of IN 31504 450 34 justice justice NN 31504 450 35 . . . 31504 451 1 The the DT 31504 451 2 rule rule NN 31504 451 3 enunciated enunciate VBN 31504 451 4 by by IN 31504 451 5 Confucius Confucius NNP 31504 451 6 five five CD 31504 451 7 hundred hundred CD 31504 451 8 years year NNS 31504 451 9 before before IN 31504 451 10 Christ Christ NNP 31504 451 11 , , , 31504 451 12 the the DT 31504 451 13 rule rule NN 31504 451 14 that that IN 31504 451 15 we -PRON- PRP 31504 451 16 should should MD 31504 451 17 not not RB 31504 451 18 do do VB 31504 451 19 to to IN 31504 451 20 others other NNS 31504 451 21 what what WP 31504 451 22 we -PRON- PRP 31504 451 23 would would MD 31504 451 24 not not RB 31504 451 25 have have VB 31504 451 26 them -PRON- PRP 31504 451 27 do do VB 31504 451 28 to to IN 31504 451 29 us -PRON- PRP 31504 451 30 , , , 31504 451 31 is be VBZ 31504 451 32 sufficient sufficient JJ 31504 451 33 for for IN 31504 451 34 the the DT 31504 451 35 existence existence NN 31504 451 36 of of IN 31504 451 37 society society NN 31504 451 38 . . . 31504 452 1 The the DT 31504 452 2 French French NNP 31504 452 3 Convention Convention NNP 31504 452 4 of of IN 31504 452 5 1793 1793 CD 31504 452 6 stated state VBD 31504 452 7 the the DT 31504 452 8 proposition proposition NN 31504 452 9 in in IN 31504 452 10 these these DT 31504 452 11 words word NNS 31504 452 12 : : : 31504 452 13 " " `` 31504 452 14 Liberty Liberty NNP 31504 452 15 is be VBZ 31504 452 16 the the DT 31504 452 17 power power NN 31504 452 18 that that WDT 31504 452 19 belongs belong VBZ 31504 452 20 to to TO 31504 452 21 man man VB 31504 452 22 to to TO 31504 452 23 do do VB 31504 452 24 whatever whatever WDT 31504 452 25 is be VBZ 31504 452 26 not not RB 31504 452 27 injurious injurious JJ 31504 452 28 to to IN 31504 452 29 the the DT 31504 452 30 rights right NNS 31504 452 31 of of IN 31504 452 32 others other NNS 31504 452 33 ; ; : 31504 452 34 it -PRON- PRP 31504 452 35 has have VBZ 31504 452 36 nature nature NN 31504 452 37 for for IN 31504 452 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 452 39 principle principle NN 31504 452 40 , , , 31504 452 41 justice justice NN 31504 452 42 for for IN 31504 452 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 452 44 rule rule NN 31504 452 45 , , , 31504 452 46 law law NN 31504 452 47 for for IN 31504 452 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 452 49 defense defense NN 31504 452 50 : : : 31504 452 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 452 52 normal normal JJ 31504 452 53 limit limit NN 31504 452 54 is be VBZ 31504 452 55 the the DT 31504 452 56 maxim maxim NN 31504 452 57 , , , 31504 452 58 Do do VB 31504 452 59 not not RB 31504 452 60 to to IN 31504 452 61 another another DT 31504 452 62 that that IN 31504 452 63 which which WDT 31504 452 64 you -PRON- PRP 31504 452 65 do do VBP 31504 452 66 not not RB 31504 452 67 wish wish VB 31504 452 68 to to TO 31504 452 69 be be VB 31504 452 70 done do VBN 31504 452 71 to to IN 31504 452 72 you -PRON- PRP 31504 452 73 . . . 31504 452 74 " " '' 31504 453 1 This this DT 31504 453 2 order order NN 31504 453 3 and and CC 31504 453 4 harmony harmony NN 31504 453 5 , , , 31504 453 6 however however RB 31504 453 7 , , , 31504 453 8 are be VBP 31504 453 9 not not RB 31504 453 10 easily easily RB 31504 453 11 secured secure VBN 31504 453 12 . . . 31504 454 1 Not not RB 31504 454 2 only only RB 31504 454 3 are be VBP 31504 454 4 there there EX 31504 454 5 honest honest JJ 31504 454 6 differences difference NNS 31504 454 7 of of IN 31504 454 8 opinion opinion NN 31504 454 9 as as IN 31504 454 10 to to IN 31504 454 11 what what WDT 31504 454 12 restraints restraint NNS 31504 454 13 are be VBP 31504 454 14 necessary necessary JJ 31504 454 15 and and CC 31504 454 16 how how WRB 31504 454 17 and and CC 31504 454 18 on on IN 31504 454 19 whom whom WP 31504 454 20 they -PRON- PRP 31504 454 21 should should MD 31504 454 22 be be VB 31504 454 23 imposed impose VBN 31504 454 24 , , , 31504 454 25 but but CC 31504 454 26 society society NN 31504 454 27 is be VBZ 31504 454 28 divided divide VBN 31504 454 29 into into IN 31504 454 30 groups group NNS 31504 454 31 or or CC 31504 454 32 classes class NNS 31504 454 33 with with IN 31504 454 34 interests interest NNS 31504 454 35 conflicting conflict VBG 31504 454 36 , , , 31504 454 37 or or CC 31504 454 38 thought think VBD 31504 454 39 to to TO 31504 454 40 be be VB 31504 454 41 conflicting conflict VBG 31504 454 42 , , , 31504 454 43 and and CC 31504 454 44 each each DT 31504 454 45 seeking seek VBG 31504 454 46 to to TO 31504 454 47 impose impose VB 31504 454 48 restraints restraint NNS 31504 454 49 on on IN 31504 454 50 others other NNS 31504 454 51 while while IN 31504 454 52 retaining retain VBG 31504 454 53 freedom freedom NN 31504 454 54 for for IN 31504 454 55 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 454 56 . . . 31504 455 1 While while IN 31504 455 2 professing profess VBG 31504 455 3 to to TO 31504 455 4 demand demand VB 31504 455 5 more more JJR 31504 455 6 liberty liberty NN 31504 455 7 and and CC 31504 455 8 equality equality NN 31504 455 9 , , , 31504 455 10 they -PRON- PRP 31504 455 11 are be VBP 31504 455 12 often often RB 31504 455 13 really really RB 31504 455 14 insisting insist VBG 31504 455 15 on on IN 31504 455 16 greater great JJR 31504 455 17 restraint restraint NN 31504 455 18 and and CC 31504 455 19 inequality inequality NN 31504 455 20 . . . 31504 456 1 The the DT 31504 456 2 successful successful JJ 31504 456 3 insistence insistence NN 31504 456 4 of of IN 31504 456 5 the the DT 31504 456 6 trades trade NNS 31504 456 7 - - HYPH 31504 456 8 unions union NNS 31504 456 9 of of IN 31504 456 10 England England NNP 31504 456 11 in in IN 31504 456 12 securing secure VBG 31504 456 13 from from IN 31504 456 14 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 456 15 a a DT 31504 456 16 statute statute NN 31504 456 17 exempting exempt VBG 31504 456 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 456 19 funds fund NNS 31504 456 20 from from IN 31504 456 21 answering answer VBG 31504 456 22 in in IN 31504 456 23 damages damage NNS 31504 456 24 for for IN 31504 456 25 injuries injury NNS 31504 456 26 caused cause VBN 31504 456 27 by by IN 31504 456 28 them -PRON- PRP 31504 456 29 is be VBZ 31504 456 30 a a DT 31504 456 31 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 31504 456 32 instance instance NN 31504 456 33 . . . 31504 457 1 Another another DT 31504 457 2 and and CC 31504 457 3 equally equally RB 31504 457 4 glaring glare VBG 31504 457 5 example example NN 31504 457 6 is be VBZ 31504 457 7 the the DT 31504 457 8 effort effort NN 31504 457 9 in in IN 31504 457 10 this this DT 31504 457 11 country country NN 31504 457 12 to to TO 31504 457 13 exempt exempt VB 31504 457 14 from from IN 31504 457 15 the the DT 31504 457 16 law law NN 31504 457 17 against against IN 31504 457 18 combinations combination NNS 31504 457 19 in in IN 31504 457 20 restraint restraint NN 31504 457 21 of of IN 31504 457 22 trade trade NN 31504 457 23 , , , 31504 457 24 combinations combination NNS 31504 457 25 to to TO 31504 457 26 increase increase VB 31504 457 27 the the DT 31504 457 28 cost cost NN 31504 457 29 of of IN 31504 457 30 living live VBG 31504 457 31 by by IN 31504 457 32 increasing increase VBG 31504 457 33 the the DT 31504 457 34 prices price NNS 31504 457 35 of of IN 31504 457 36 agricultural agricultural JJ 31504 457 37 products product NNS 31504 457 38 and and CC 31504 457 39 the the DT 31504 457 40 prices price NNS 31504 457 41 to to TO 31504 457 42 be be VB 31504 457 43 paid pay VBN 31504 457 44 for for IN 31504 457 45 labor labor NN 31504 457 46 . . . 31504 458 1 The the DT 31504 458 2 effort effort NN 31504 458 3 seems seem VBZ 31504 458 4 to to TO 31504 458 5 be be VB 31504 458 6 to to TO 31504 458 7 compel compel VB 31504 458 8 men man NNS 31504 458 9 to to TO 31504 458 10 compete compete VB 31504 458 11 in in IN 31504 458 12 the the DT 31504 458 13 use use NN 31504 458 14 of of IN 31504 458 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 458 16 savings saving NNS 31504 458 17 no no RB 31504 458 18 matter matter RB 31504 458 19 how how WRB 31504 458 20 wasteful wasteful JJ 31504 458 21 the the DT 31504 458 22 competition competition NN 31504 458 23 , , , 31504 458 24 and and CC 31504 458 25 to to TO 31504 458 26 forbid forbid VB 31504 458 27 men man NNS 31504 458 28 competing compete VBG 31504 458 29 in in IN 31504 458 30 the the DT 31504 458 31 use use NN 31504 458 32 of of IN 31504 458 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 458 34 labor labor NN 31504 458 35 , , , 31504 458 36 no no RB 31504 458 37 matter matter RB 31504 458 38 what what WP 31504 458 39 the the DT 31504 458 40 idleness idleness JJ 31504 458 41 thereby thereby RB 31504 458 42 caused cause VBN 31504 458 43 . . . 31504 459 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 459 2 think think VBP 31504 459 3 it -PRON- PRP 31504 459 4 a a DT 31504 459 5 truism truism NN 31504 459 6 that that WDT 31504 459 7 whoever whoever WP 31504 459 8 seeks seek VBZ 31504 459 9 to to TO 31504 459 10 be be VB 31504 459 11 exempted exempt VBN 31504 459 12 from from IN 31504 459 13 the the DT 31504 459 14 restrictions restriction NNS 31504 459 15 or or CC 31504 459 16 liabilities liability NNS 31504 459 17 he -PRON- PRP 31504 459 18 would would MD 31504 459 19 impose impose VB 31504 459 20 on on IN 31504 459 21 others other NNS 31504 459 22 , , , 31504 459 23 seeks seek VBZ 31504 459 24 not not RB 31504 459 25 justice justice NN 31504 459 26 , , , 31504 459 27 but but CC 31504 459 28 to to TO 31504 459 29 do do VB 31504 459 30 injustice injustice NN 31504 459 31 . . . 31504 460 1 Another another DT 31504 460 2 hindrance hindrance NN 31504 460 3 arises arise VBZ 31504 460 4 out out IN 31504 460 5 of of IN 31504 460 6 the the DT 31504 460 7 very very JJ 31504 460 8 virtues virtue NNS 31504 460 9 of of IN 31504 460 10 pity pity NN 31504 460 11 and and CC 31504 460 12 sympathy sympathy NN 31504 460 13 . . . 31504 461 1 These these DT 31504 461 2 impel impel NN 31504 461 3 many many JJ 31504 461 4 to to TO 31504 461 5 endeavor endeavor VB 31504 461 6 , , , 31504 461 7 not not RB 31504 461 8 to to TO 31504 461 9 persuade persuade VB 31504 461 10 , , , 31504 461 11 but but CC 31504 461 12 to to TO 31504 461 13 compel compel VB 31504 461 14 the the DT 31504 461 15 more more RBR 31504 461 16 efficient efficient JJ 31504 461 17 and and CC 31504 461 18 prudent prudent JJ 31504 461 19 who who WP 31504 461 20 have have VBP 31504 461 21 by by IN 31504 461 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 461 23 farsightedness farsightedness NN 31504 461 24 , , , 31504 461 25 courage courage NN 31504 461 26 , , , 31504 461 27 industry industry NN 31504 461 28 and and CC 31504 461 29 thrift thrift NN 31504 461 30 made make VBD 31504 461 31 good good JJ 31504 461 32 provision provision NN 31504 461 33 for for IN 31504 461 34 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 461 35 and and CC 31504 461 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 461 37 offspring offspring NN 31504 461 38 , , , 31504 461 39 to to TO 31504 461 40 provide provide VB 31504 461 41 also also RB 31504 461 42 for for IN 31504 461 43 the the DT 31504 461 44 inefficient inefficient JJ 31504 461 45 and and CC 31504 461 46 the the DT 31504 461 47 improvident improvident JJ 31504 461 48 . . . 31504 462 1 To to TO 31504 462 2 be be VB 31504 462 3 asked ask VBN 31504 462 4 to to TO 31504 462 5 give give VB 31504 462 6 to to IN 31504 462 7 these these DT 31504 462 8 does do VBZ 31504 462 9 not not RB 31504 462 10 offend offend VB 31504 462 11 any any DT 31504 462 12 sense sense NN 31504 462 13 of of IN 31504 462 14 right right NN 31504 462 15 , , , 31504 462 16 but but CC 31504 462 17 if if IN 31504 462 18 one one CD 31504 462 19 be be VB 31504 462 20 told tell VBN 31504 462 21 he -PRON- PRP 31504 462 22 must must MD 31504 462 23 give give VB 31504 462 24 he -PRON- PRP 31504 462 25 feels feel VBZ 31504 462 26 resentful resentful JJ 31504 462 27 at at IN 31504 462 28 once once RB 31504 462 29 . . . 31504 463 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 463 2 feels feel VBZ 31504 463 3 he -PRON- PRP 31504 463 4 has have VBZ 31504 463 5 a a DT 31504 463 6 right right NN 31504 463 7 to to TO 31504 463 8 decide decide VB 31504 463 9 for for IN 31504 463 10 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 463 11 to to IN 31504 463 12 whom whom WP 31504 463 13 and and CC 31504 463 14 to to TO 31504 463 15 what what WDT 31504 463 16 extent extent NN 31504 463 17 he -PRON- PRP 31504 463 18 shall shall MD 31504 463 19 give give VB 31504 463 20 of of IN 31504 463 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 463 22 savings saving NNS 31504 463 23 . . . 31504 464 1 Society society NN 31504 464 2 did do VBD 31504 464 3 not not RB 31504 464 4 come come VB 31504 464 5 into into IN 31504 464 6 existence existence NN 31504 464 7 nor nor CC 31504 464 8 does do VBZ 31504 464 9 it -PRON- PRP 31504 464 10 now now RB 31504 464 11 exist exist VB 31504 464 12 to to TO 31504 464 13 correct correct VB 31504 464 14 the the DT 31504 464 15 inequalities inequality NNS 31504 464 16 of of IN 31504 464 17 nature nature NN 31504 464 18 , , , 31504 464 19 the the DT 31504 464 20 inequalities inequality NNS 31504 464 21 of of IN 31504 464 22 natural natural JJ 31504 464 23 powers power NNS 31504 464 24 , , , 31504 464 25 nor nor CC 31504 464 26 to to TO 31504 464 27 prevent prevent VB 31504 464 28 the the DT 31504 464 29 efficient efficient JJ 31504 464 30 and and CC 31504 464 31 prudent prudent JJ 31504 464 32 receiving receiving NN 31504 464 33 and and CC 31504 464 34 enjoying enjoy VBG 31504 464 35 the the DT 31504 464 36 results result NNS 31504 464 37 of of IN 31504 464 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 464 39 efficiency efficiency NN 31504 464 40 and and CC 31504 464 41 prudence prudence NN 31504 464 42 . . . 31504 465 1 Nature nature NN 31504 465 2 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 465 3 makes make VBZ 31504 465 4 no no DT 31504 465 5 such such JJ 31504 465 6 effort effort NN 31504 465 7 . . . 31504 466 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 466 2 rather rather RB 31504 466 3 tends tend VBZ 31504 466 4 to to TO 31504 466 5 eliminate eliminate VB 31504 466 6 the the DT 31504 466 7 less less RBR 31504 466 8 efficient efficient JJ 31504 466 9 and and CC 31504 466 10 preserve preserve VB 31504 466 11 the the DT 31504 466 12 more more RBR 31504 466 13 efficient efficient JJ 31504 466 14 . . . 31504 467 1 Even even RB 31504 467 2 if if IN 31504 467 3 society society NN 31504 467 4 may may MD 31504 467 5 strive strive VB 31504 467 6 to to TO 31504 467 7 preserve preserve VB 31504 467 8 the the DT 31504 467 9 inefficient inefficient JJ 31504 467 10 and and CC 31504 467 11 improvident improvident JJ 31504 467 12 , , , 31504 467 13 should should MD 31504 467 14 it -PRON- PRP 31504 467 15 do do VB 31504 467 16 so so RB 31504 467 17 by by IN 31504 467 18 hampering hamper VBG 31504 467 19 and and CC 31504 467 20 restraining restrain VBG 31504 467 21 those those DT 31504 467 22 wiser wise JJR 31504 467 23 and and CC 31504 467 24 more more RBR 31504 467 25 capable capable JJ 31504 467 26 ? ? . 31504 468 1 We -PRON- PRP 31504 468 2 must must MD 31504 468 3 expect expect VB 31504 468 4 nature nature NN 31504 468 5 to to TO 31504 468 6 deal deal VB 31504 468 7 with with IN 31504 468 8 society society NN 31504 468 9 , , , 31504 468 10 with with IN 31504 468 11 states state NNS 31504 468 12 and and CC 31504 468 13 nations nation NNS 31504 468 14 , , , 31504 468 15 as as IN 31504 468 16 it -PRON- PRP 31504 468 17 does do VBZ 31504 468 18 with with IN 31504 468 19 individuals individual NNS 31504 468 20 . . . 31504 469 1 If if IN 31504 469 2 a a DT 31504 469 3 state state NN 31504 469 4 by by IN 31504 469 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 469 6 laws law NNS 31504 469 7 discourages discourage VBZ 31504 469 8 the the DT 31504 469 9 exercise exercise NN 31504 469 10 to to IN 31504 469 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 469 12 full full JJ 31504 469 13 extent extent NN 31504 469 14 of of IN 31504 469 15 the the DT 31504 469 16 efficiency efficiency NN 31504 469 17 of of IN 31504 469 18 the the DT 31504 469 19 few few JJ 31504 469 20 and and CC 31504 469 21 renders render VBZ 31504 469 22 less less RBR 31504 469 23 severe severe JJ 31504 469 24 the the DT 31504 469 25 penalties penalty NNS 31504 469 26 for for IN 31504 469 27 the the DT 31504 469 28 inefficiency inefficiency NN 31504 469 29 and and CC 31504 469 30 imprudence imprudence NN 31504 469 31 of of IN 31504 469 32 the the DT 31504 469 33 many many JJ 31504 469 34 , , , 31504 469 35 it -PRON- PRP 31504 469 36 can can MD 31504 469 37 not not RB 31504 469 38 long long RB 31504 469 39 maintain maintain VB 31504 469 40 any any DT 31504 469 41 advantageous advantageous JJ 31504 469 42 position position NN 31504 469 43 among among IN 31504 469 44 other other JJ 31504 469 45 nations nation NNS 31504 469 46 . . . 31504 470 1 Whatever whatever WDT 31504 470 2 the the DT 31504 470 3 precepts precept NNS 31504 470 4 of of IN 31504 470 5 religion religion NN 31504 470 6 , , , 31504 470 7 of of IN 31504 470 8 philanthropy philanthropy NN 31504 470 9 , , , 31504 470 10 or or CC 31504 470 11 of of IN 31504 470 12 other other JJ 31504 470 13 virtues virtue NNS 31504 470 14 may may MD 31504 470 15 require require VB 31504 470 16 , , , 31504 470 17 the the DT 31504 470 18 precepts precept NNS 31504 470 19 of of IN 31504 470 20 justice justice NN 31504 470 21 do do VBP 31504 470 22 not not RB 31504 470 23 require require VB 31504 470 24 society society NN 31504 470 25 to to TO 31504 470 26 support support VB 31504 470 27 men man NNS 31504 470 28 in in IN 31504 470 29 idleness idleness JJ 31504 470 30 nor nor CC 31504 470 31 even even RB 31504 470 32 to to TO 31504 470 33 furnish furnish VB 31504 470 34 them -PRON- PRP 31504 470 35 with with IN 31504 470 36 employment employment NN 31504 470 37 . . . 31504 471 1 Neither neither CC 31504 471 2 do do VBP 31504 471 3 the the DT 31504 471 4 precepts precept NNS 31504 471 5 of of IN 31504 471 6 justice justice NN 31504 471 7 require require VBP 31504 471 8 the the DT 31504 471 9 state state NN 31504 471 10 to to TO 31504 471 11 furnish furnish VB 31504 471 12 opportunities opportunity NNS 31504 471 13 , , , 31504 471 14 nor nor CC 31504 471 15 even even RB 31504 471 16 to to TO 31504 471 17 establish establish VB 31504 471 18 equality equality NN 31504 471 19 of of IN 31504 471 20 opportunity opportunity NN 31504 471 21 , , , 31504 471 22 but but CC 31504 471 23 only only RB 31504 471 24 equality equality NN 31504 471 25 of of IN 31504 471 26 right right NN 31504 471 27 to to TO 31504 471 28 take take VB 31504 471 29 advantage advantage NN 31504 471 30 of of IN 31504 471 31 opportunity opportunity NN 31504 471 32 . . . 31504 472 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 472 2 is be VBZ 31504 472 3 a a DT 31504 472 4 saying saying NN 31504 472 5 , , , 31504 472 6 but but CC 31504 472 7 not not RB 31504 472 8 a a DT 31504 472 9 fact fact NN 31504 472 10 , , , 31504 472 11 that that DT 31504 472 12 opportunity opportunity NN 31504 472 13 knocks knock VBZ 31504 472 14 once once RB 31504 472 15 at at IN 31504 472 16 every every DT 31504 472 17 man man NN 31504 472 18 's 's POS 31504 472 19 door door NN 31504 472 20 . . . 31504 473 1 Nature nature NN 31504 473 2 does do VBZ 31504 473 3 not not RB 31504 473 4 bring bring VB 31504 473 5 opportunities opportunity NNS 31504 473 6 , , , 31504 473 7 much much RB 31504 473 8 less less RBR 31504 473 9 equal equal JJ 31504 473 10 opportunities opportunity NNS 31504 473 11 , , , 31504 473 12 to to IN 31504 473 13 men man NNS 31504 473 14 's 's POS 31504 473 15 doors door NNS 31504 473 16 . . . 31504 474 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 474 2 requires require VBZ 31504 474 3 men man NNS 31504 474 4 to to TO 31504 474 5 go go VB 31504 474 6 out out RB 31504 474 7 and and CC 31504 474 8 search search VB 31504 474 9 for for IN 31504 474 10 opportunities opportunity NNS 31504 474 11 , , , 31504 474 12 or or CC 31504 474 13 at at IN 31504 474 14 least least JJS 31504 474 15 to to TO 31504 474 16 be be VB 31504 474 17 on on IN 31504 474 18 the the DT 31504 474 19 watch watch NN 31504 474 20 for for IN 31504 474 21 them -PRON- PRP 31504 474 22 , , , 31504 474 23 as as IN 31504 474 24 it -PRON- PRP 31504 474 25 requires require VBZ 31504 474 26 men man NNS 31504 474 27 to to TO 31504 474 28 search search VB 31504 474 29 or or CC 31504 474 30 watch watch VB 31504 474 31 for for IN 31504 474 32 other other JJ 31504 474 33 things thing NNS 31504 474 34 they -PRON- PRP 31504 474 35 desire desire VBP 31504 474 36 ; ; : 31504 474 37 and and CC 31504 474 38 he -PRON- PRP 31504 474 39 of of IN 31504 474 40 the the DT 31504 474 41 quickest quick JJS 31504 474 42 perception perception NN 31504 474 43 and and CC 31504 474 44 most most RBS 31504 474 45 farsighted farsighte VBN 31504 474 46 will will MD 31504 474 47 soonest soon RBS 31504 474 48 see see VB 31504 474 49 them -PRON- PRP 31504 474 50 , , , 31504 474 51 and and CC 31504 474 52 when when WRB 31504 474 53 seen see VBN 31504 474 54 he -PRON- PRP 31504 474 55 does do VBZ 31504 474 56 not not RB 31504 474 57 feel feel VB 31504 474 58 any any DT 31504 474 59 obligation obligation NN 31504 474 60 to to TO 31504 474 61 share share VB 31504 474 62 them -PRON- PRP 31504 474 63 with with IN 31504 474 64 others other NNS 31504 474 65 less less RBR 31504 474 66 vigilant vigilant JJ 31504 474 67 or or CC 31504 474 68 even even RB 31504 474 69 less less RBR 31504 474 70 fortunate fortunate JJ 31504 474 71 . . . 31504 475 1 Society society NN 31504 475 2 does do VBZ 31504 475 3 not not RB 31504 475 4 support support VB 31504 475 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 475 6 members member NNS 31504 475 7 , , , 31504 475 8 they -PRON- PRP 31504 475 9 support support VBP 31504 475 10 it -PRON- PRP 31504 475 11 and and CC 31504 475 12 must must MD 31504 475 13 support support VB 31504 475 14 it -PRON- PRP 31504 475 15 and and CC 31504 475 16 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 475 17 by by IN 31504 475 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 475 19 own own JJ 31504 475 20 exertions exertion NNS 31504 475 21 , , , 31504 475 22 find find VB 31504 475 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 475 24 own own JJ 31504 475 25 place place NN 31504 475 26 , , , 31504 475 27 find find VB 31504 475 28 employment employment NN 31504 475 29 for for IN 31504 475 30 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 475 31 , , , 31504 475 32 so so RB 31504 475 33 far far RB 31504 475 34 as as IN 31504 475 35 the the DT 31504 475 36 precepts precept NNS 31504 475 37 of of IN 31504 475 38 justice justice NN 31504 475 39 are be VBP 31504 475 40 concerned concern VBN 31504 475 41 . . . 31504 476 1 However however RB 31504 476 2 prevalent prevalent VB 31504 476 3 the the DT 31504 476 4 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 476 5 that that WDT 31504 476 6 more more JJR 31504 476 7 than than IN 31504 476 8 equality equality NN 31504 476 9 of of IN 31504 476 10 right right NN 31504 476 11 to to TO 31504 476 12 use use VB 31504 476 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 476 14 opportunities opportunity NNS 31504 476 15 is be VBZ 31504 476 16 due due JJ 31504 476 17 to to IN 31504 476 18 any any DT 31504 476 19 one one NN 31504 476 20 , , , 31504 476 21 it -PRON- PRP 31504 476 22 is be VBZ 31504 476 23 not not RB 31504 476 24 an an DT 31504 476 25 instinctive instinctive JJ 31504 476 26 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 476 27 . . . 31504 477 1 The the DT 31504 477 2 contrary contrary NN 31504 477 3 is be VBZ 31504 477 4 the the DT 31504 477 5 fact fact NN 31504 477 6 . . . 31504 478 1 Unless unless IN 31504 478 2 we -PRON- PRP 31504 478 3 are be VBP 31504 478 4 dominated dominate VBN 31504 478 5 by by IN 31504 478 6 some some DT 31504 478 7 other other JJ 31504 478 8 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 478 9 than than IN 31504 478 10 justice justice NN 31504 478 11 , , , 31504 478 12 we -PRON- PRP 31504 478 13 instinctively instinctively RB 31504 478 14 yield yield VBP 31504 478 15 assent assent NN 31504 478 16 to to IN 31504 478 17 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 31504 478 18 's 's POS 31504 478 19 proposition proposition NN 31504 478 20 that that IN 31504 478 21 the the DT 31504 478 22 prize prize NN 31504 478 23 flute flute NN 31504 478 24 should should MD 31504 478 25 be be VB 31504 478 26 awarded award VBN 31504 478 27 to to IN 31504 478 28 the the DT 31504 478 29 best good JJS 31504 478 30 flute flute NN 31504 478 31 player player NN 31504 478 32 whether whether IN 31504 478 33 opulent opulent JJ 31504 478 34 or or CC 31504 478 35 indigent indigent JJ 31504 478 36 , , , 31504 478 37 literate literate JJ 31504 478 38 or or CC 31504 478 39 illiterate illiterate JJ 31504 478 40 , , , 31504 478 41 citizen citizen NN 31504 478 42 or or CC 31504 478 43 slave slave NN 31504 478 44 . . . 31504 479 1 A a DT 31504 479 2 group group NN 31504 479 3 of of IN 31504 479 4 small small JJ 31504 479 5 children child NNS 31504 479 6 exploring explore VBG 31504 479 7 the the DT 31504 479 8 fields field NNS 31504 479 9 and and CC 31504 479 10 woods wood NNS 31504 479 11 for for IN 31504 479 12 wild wild JJ 31504 479 13 flowers flower NNS 31504 479 14 will will MD 31504 479 15 concede concede VB 31504 479 16 to to IN 31504 479 17 each each DT 31504 479 18 what what WDT 31504 479 19 flowers flower NNS 31504 479 20 he -PRON- PRP 31504 479 21 finds find VBZ 31504 479 22 whether whether IN 31504 479 23 by by IN 31504 479 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 479 25 better well JJR 31504 479 26 eyes eye NNS 31504 479 27 or or CC 31504 479 28 better well JJR 31504 479 29 luck luck NN 31504 479 30 . . . 31504 480 1 So so RB 31504 480 2 with with IN 31504 480 3 groups group NNS 31504 480 4 of of IN 31504 480 5 small small JJ 31504 480 6 boys boy NNS 31504 480 7 fishing fish VBG 31504 480 8 in in IN 31504 480 9 the the DT 31504 480 10 streams streams NNPS 31504 480 11 and and CC 31504 480 12 brooks brooks NNP 31504 480 13 . . . 31504 481 1 In in IN 31504 481 2 games game NNS 31504 481 3 of of IN 31504 481 4 cards card NNS 31504 481 5 for for IN 31504 481 6 stakes stake NNS 31504 481 7 , , , 31504 481 8 the the DT 31504 481 9 players player NNS 31504 481 10 do do VBP 31504 481 11 not not RB 31504 481 12 expect expect VB 31504 481 13 to to TO 31504 481 14 hold hold VB 31504 481 15 cards card NNS 31504 481 16 of of IN 31504 481 17 equal equal JJ 31504 481 18 value value NN 31504 481 19 and and CC 31504 481 20 they -PRON- PRP 31504 481 21 concede concede VBP 31504 481 22 the the DT 31504 481 23 stakes stake NNS 31504 481 24 to to IN 31504 481 25 the the DT 31504 481 26 winner winner NN 31504 481 27 , , , 31504 481 28 whether whether IN 31504 481 29 won win VBN 31504 481 30 by by IN 31504 481 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 481 32 greater great JJR 31504 481 33 skill skill NN 31504 481 34 or or CC 31504 481 35 superior superior JJ 31504 481 36 cards card NNS 31504 481 37 . . . 31504 482 1 Also also RB 31504 482 2 there there EX 31504 482 3 is be VBZ 31504 482 4 an an DT 31504 482 5 instinctive instinctive JJ 31504 482 6 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 482 7 that that WDT 31504 482 8 the the DT 31504 482 9 evil evil JJ 31504 482 10 results result NNS 31504 482 11 of of IN 31504 482 12 one one PRP 31504 482 13 's 's POS 31504 482 14 own own JJ 31504 482 15 conduct conduct NN 31504 482 16 should should MD 31504 482 17 be be VB 31504 482 18 borne bear VBN 31504 482 19 by by IN 31504 482 20 him -PRON- PRP 31504 482 21 alone alone RB 31504 482 22 . . . 31504 483 1 If if IN 31504 483 2 one one CD 31504 483 3 suffers suffer VBZ 31504 483 4 loss loss VBP 31504 483 5 through through IN 31504 483 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 483 7 own own JJ 31504 483 8 misjudgment misjudgment NN 31504 483 9 , , , 31504 483 10 incapacity incapacity NN 31504 483 11 , , , 31504 483 12 or or CC 31504 483 13 want want NN 31504 483 14 of of IN 31504 483 15 care care NN 31504 483 16 , , , 31504 483 17 then then RB 31504 483 18 , , , 31504 483 19 whatever whatever WDT 31504 483 20 the the DT 31504 483 21 precepts precept NNS 31504 483 22 of of IN 31504 483 23 other other JJ 31504 483 24 virtues virtue NNS 31504 483 25 may may MD 31504 483 26 require require VB 31504 483 27 , , , 31504 483 28 we -PRON- PRP 31504 483 29 do do VBP 31504 483 30 not not RB 31504 483 31 feel feel VB 31504 483 32 that that IN 31504 483 33 justice justice NN 31504 483 34 requires require VBZ 31504 483 35 us -PRON- PRP 31504 483 36 to to TO 31504 483 37 bear bear VB 31504 483 38 any any DT 31504 483 39 part part NN 31504 483 40 of of IN 31504 483 41 that that DT 31504 483 42 loss loss NN 31504 483 43 . . . 31504 484 1 On on IN 31504 484 2 the the DT 31504 484 3 contrary contrary NN 31504 484 4 , , , 31504 484 5 we -PRON- PRP 31504 484 6 feel feel VBP 31504 484 7 instinctively instinctively RB 31504 484 8 that that IN 31504 484 9 he -PRON- PRP 31504 484 10 should should MD 31504 484 11 bear bear VB 31504 484 12 the the DT 31504 484 13 loss loss NN 31504 484 14 alone alone RB 31504 484 15 , , , 31504 484 16 that that IN 31504 484 17 it -PRON- PRP 31504 484 18 is be VBZ 31504 484 19 the the DT 31504 484 20 natural natural JJ 31504 484 21 penalty penalty NN 31504 484 22 for for IN 31504 484 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 484 24 lack lack NN 31504 484 25 of of IN 31504 484 26 judgment judgment NN 31504 484 27 , , , 31504 484 28 capacity capacity NN 31504 484 29 , , , 31504 484 30 or or CC 31504 484 31 care care NN 31504 484 32 . . . 31504 485 1 If if IN 31504 485 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 31504 485 3 neighbor neighbor NN 31504 485 4 neglects neglect VBZ 31504 485 5 to to TO 31504 485 6 insure insure VB 31504 485 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 485 8 house house NN 31504 485 9 and and CC 31504 485 10 loses lose VBZ 31504 485 11 it -PRON- PRP 31504 485 12 by by IN 31504 485 13 fire fire NN 31504 485 14 , , , 31504 485 15 I -PRON- PRP 31504 485 16 see see VBP 31504 485 17 no no DT 31504 485 18 reason reason NN 31504 485 19 why why WRB 31504 485 20 he -PRON- PRP 31504 485 21 should should MD 31504 485 22 not not RB 31504 485 23 bear bear VB 31504 485 24 the the DT 31504 485 25 loss loss NN 31504 485 26 alone alone RB 31504 485 27 . . . 31504 486 1 In in IN 31504 486 2 this this DT 31504 486 3 connection connection NN 31504 486 4 , , , 31504 486 5 perhaps perhaps RB 31504 486 6 I -PRON- PRP 31504 486 7 should should MD 31504 486 8 not not RB 31504 486 9 omit omit VB 31504 486 10 to to TO 31504 486 11 notice notice VB 31504 486 12 references reference NNS 31504 486 13 often often RB 31504 486 14 made make VBN 31504 486 15 to to IN 31504 486 16 the the DT 31504 486 17 rights right NNS 31504 486 18 of of IN 31504 486 19 labor labor NN 31504 486 20 , , , 31504 486 21 the the DT 31504 486 22 rights right NNS 31504 486 23 of of IN 31504 486 24 capital capital NN 31504 486 25 , , , 31504 486 26 property property NN 31504 486 27 rights right NNS 31504 486 28 , , , 31504 486 29 and and CC 31504 486 30 personal personal JJ 31504 486 31 rights right NNS 31504 486 32 , , , 31504 486 33 as as IN 31504 486 34 if if IN 31504 486 35 they -PRON- PRP 31504 486 36 were be VBD 31504 486 37 different different JJ 31504 486 38 in in IN 31504 486 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 486 40 nature nature NN 31504 486 41 and and CC 31504 486 42 importance importance NN 31504 486 43 . . . 31504 487 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 487 2 do do VBP 31504 487 3 not not RB 31504 487 4 as as RB 31504 487 5 yet yet RB 31504 487 6 see see VB 31504 487 7 such such JJ 31504 487 8 difference difference NN 31504 487 9 . . . 31504 488 1 All all DT 31504 488 2 rights right NNS 31504 488 3 are be VBP 31504 488 4 personal personal JJ 31504 488 5 rights right NNS 31504 488 6 , , , 31504 488 7 and and CC 31504 488 8 the the DT 31504 488 9 right right NN 31504 488 10 of of IN 31504 488 11 each each DT 31504 488 12 to to TO 31504 488 13 control control VB 31504 488 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 488 15 labor labor NN 31504 488 16 , , , 31504 488 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 488 18 savings saving NNS 31504 488 19 , , , 31504 488 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 488 21 person person NN 31504 488 22 , , , 31504 488 23 and and CC 31504 488 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 488 25 property property NN 31504 488 26 is be VBZ 31504 488 27 the the DT 31504 488 28 same same JJ 31504 488 29 . . . 31504 489 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 489 2 am be VBP 31504 489 3 not not RB 31504 489 4 yet yet RB 31504 489 5 convinced convince VBN 31504 489 6 that that IN 31504 489 7 the the DT 31504 489 8 right right NN 31504 489 9 of of IN 31504 489 10 the the DT 31504 489 11 laborer laborer NN 31504 489 12 to to TO 31504 489 13 make make VB 31504 489 14 use use NN 31504 489 15 of of IN 31504 489 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 489 17 labor labor NN 31504 489 18 is be VBZ 31504 489 19 superior superior JJ 31504 489 20 to to IN 31504 489 21 that that DT 31504 489 22 of of IN 31504 489 23 the the DT 31504 489 24 capitalist capitalist NN 31504 489 25 to to TO 31504 489 26 make make VB 31504 489 27 use use NN 31504 489 28 of of IN 31504 489 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 489 30 capital capital NN 31504 489 31 ; ; : 31504 489 32 that that IN 31504 489 33 , , , 31504 489 34 whatever whatever WDT 31504 489 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 489 36 greater great JJR 31504 489 37 need need NN 31504 489 38 , , , 31504 489 39 the the DT 31504 489 40 right right NN 31504 489 41 of of IN 31504 489 42 one one CD 31504 489 43 without without IN 31504 489 44 property property NN 31504 489 45 is be VBZ 31504 489 46 superior superior JJ 31504 489 47 to to IN 31504 489 48 that that DT 31504 489 49 of of IN 31504 489 50 one one NN 31504 489 51 who who WP 31504 489 52 has have VBZ 31504 489 53 property property NN 31504 489 54 ; ; : 31504 489 55 that that IN 31504 489 56 the the DT 31504 489 57 right right NN 31504 489 58 to to TO 31504 489 59 get get VB 31504 489 60 is be VBZ 31504 489 61 superior superior JJ 31504 489 62 to to IN 31504 489 63 the the DT 31504 489 64 right right NN 31504 489 65 to to TO 31504 489 66 save save VB 31504 489 67 . . . 31504 490 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 490 2 is be VBZ 31504 490 3 also also RB 31504 490 4 loudly loudly RB 31504 490 5 proclaimed proclaim VBN 31504 490 6 that that IN 31504 490 7 " " `` 31504 490 8 property property NN 31504 490 9 rights right NNS 31504 490 10 " " '' 31504 490 11 are be VBP 31504 490 12 of of IN 31504 490 13 little little JJ 31504 490 14 importance importance NN 31504 490 15 compared compare VBN 31504 490 16 with with IN 31504 490 17 " " `` 31504 490 18 human human JJ 31504 490 19 rights right NNS 31504 490 20 , , , 31504 490 21 " " '' 31504 490 22 unmindful unmindful JJ 31504 490 23 of of IN 31504 490 24 the the DT 31504 490 25 truth truth NN 31504 490 26 that that WDT 31504 490 27 the the DT 31504 490 28 right right JJ 31504 490 29 " " '' 31504 490 30 of of IN 31504 490 31 acquiring acquire VBG 31504 490 32 , , , 31504 490 33 possessing possess VBG 31504 490 34 and and CC 31504 490 35 defending defend VBG 31504 490 36 property property NN 31504 490 37 " " '' 31504 490 38 is be VBZ 31504 490 39 , , , 31504 490 40 as as RB 31504 490 41 much much RB 31504 490 42 as as IN 31504 490 43 any any DT 31504 490 44 other other JJ 31504 490 45 , , , 31504 490 46 a a DT 31504 490 47 human human JJ 31504 490 48 right right NN 31504 490 49 and and CC 31504 490 50 , , , 31504 490 51 as as IN 31504 490 52 such such JJ 31504 490 53 , , , 31504 490 54 necessary necessary JJ 31504 490 55 to to TO 31504 490 56 be be VB 31504 490 57 maintained maintain VBN 31504 490 58 if if IN 31504 490 59 the the DT 31504 490 60 race race NN 31504 490 61 is be VBZ 31504 490 62 to to TO 31504 490 63 rise rise VB 31504 490 64 above above IN 31504 490 65 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 490 66 primitive primitive JJ 31504 490 67 condition condition NN 31504 490 68 of of IN 31504 490 69 poverty poverty NN 31504 490 70 . . . 31504 491 1 However however RB 31504 491 2 , , , 31504 491 3 I -PRON- PRP 31504 491 4 do do VBP 31504 491 5 not not RB 31504 491 6 see see VB 31504 491 7 that that IN 31504 491 8 the the DT 31504 491 9 differences difference NNS 31504 491 10 , , , 31504 491 11 if if IN 31504 491 12 any any DT 31504 491 13 , , , 31504 491 14 affect affect VB 31504 491 15 the the DT 31504 491 16 general general JJ 31504 491 17 question question NN 31504 491 18 of of IN 31504 491 19 individual individual JJ 31504 491 20 rights right NNS 31504 491 21 . . . 31504 492 1 The the DT 31504 492 2 conclusion conclusion NN 31504 492 3 I -PRON- PRP 31504 492 4 arrive arrive VBP 31504 492 5 at at IN 31504 492 6 is be VBZ 31504 492 7 this this DT 31504 492 8 : : : 31504 492 9 Society society NN 31504 492 10 , , , 31504 492 11 and and CC 31504 492 12 with with IN 31504 492 13 it -PRON- PRP 31504 492 14 the the DT 31504 492 15 race race NN 31504 492 16 , , , 31504 492 17 can can MD 31504 492 18 not not RB 31504 492 19 survive survive VB 31504 492 20 unless unless IN 31504 492 21 it -PRON- PRP 31504 492 22 restrains restrain VBZ 31504 492 23 to to IN 31504 492 24 some some DT 31504 492 25 extent extent NN 31504 492 26 individual individual JJ 31504 492 27 freedom freedom NN 31504 492 28 of of IN 31504 492 29 action action NN 31504 492 30 , , , 31504 492 31 nor nor CC 31504 492 32 can can MD 31504 492 33 any any DT 31504 492 34 particular particular JJ 31504 492 35 society society NN 31504 492 36 long long RB 31504 492 37 survive survive VBP 31504 492 38 if if IN 31504 492 39 it -PRON- PRP 31504 492 40 carry carry VBP 31504 492 41 that that DT 31504 492 42 restraint restraint NN 31504 492 43 too too RB 31504 492 44 far far RB 31504 492 45 . . . 31504 493 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 493 2 should should MD 31504 493 3 , , , 31504 493 4 therefore therefore RB 31504 493 5 , , , 31504 493 6 ascertain ascertain NN 31504 493 7 and and CC 31504 493 8 maintain maintain VB 31504 493 9 the the DT 31504 493 10 line line NN 31504 493 11 , , , 31504 493 12 the the DT 31504 493 13 equilibrium equilibrium NN 31504 493 14 , , , 31504 493 15 between between IN 31504 493 16 necessary necessary JJ 31504 493 17 freedom freedom NN 31504 493 18 and and CC 31504 493 19 necessary necessary JJ 31504 493 20 restraint restraint NN 31504 493 21 . . . 31504 494 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 494 2 is be VBZ 31504 494 3 only only RB 31504 494 4 by by IN 31504 494 5 such such JJ 31504 494 6 action action NN 31504 494 7 of of IN 31504 494 8 society society NN 31504 494 9 that that WDT 31504 494 10 justice justice NN 31504 494 11 can can MD 31504 494 12 be be VB 31504 494 13 established establish VBN 31504 494 14 and and CC 31504 494 15 the the DT 31504 494 16 welfare welfare NN 31504 494 17 of of IN 31504 494 18 the the DT 31504 494 19 race race NN 31504 494 20 be be VB 31504 494 21 advanced advance VBN 31504 494 22 . . . 31504 495 1 This this DT 31504 495 2 brings bring VBZ 31504 495 3 us -PRON- PRP 31504 495 4 to to IN 31504 495 5 the the DT 31504 495 6 question question NN 31504 495 7 of of IN 31504 495 8 how how WRB 31504 495 9 and and CC 31504 495 10 by by IN 31504 495 11 what what WDT 31504 495 12 instrumentalities instrumentality NNS 31504 495 13 society society NN 31504 495 14 can can MD 31504 495 15 best best RB 31504 495 16 perform perform VB 31504 495 17 this this DT 31504 495 18 momentous momentous JJ 31504 495 19 task task NN 31504 495 20 , , , 31504 495 21 the the DT 31504 495 22 securing securing NN 31504 495 23 of of IN 31504 495 24 justice justice NN 31504 495 25 . . . 31504 496 1 This this DT 31504 496 2 will will MD 31504 496 3 be be VB 31504 496 4 considered consider VBN 31504 496 5 in in IN 31504 496 6 the the DT 31504 496 7 next next JJ 31504 496 8 chapter chapter NN 31504 496 9 . . . 31504 497 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31504 497 2 V V NNP 31504 497 3 JUSTICE justice NN 31504 497 4 CAN CAN MD 31504 497 5 BE be VB 31504 497 6 SECURED secured JJ 31504 497 7 ONLY only RB 31504 497 8 THROUGH through IN 31504 497 9 GOVERNMENTAL GOVERNMENTAL NNP 31504 497 10 ACTION action NN 31504 497 11 . . . 31504 498 1 THE the DT 31504 498 2 BEST best NN 31504 498 3 FORM form NN 31504 498 4 OF of IN 31504 498 5 GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT NNP 31504 498 6 In in IN 31504 498 7 the the DT 31504 498 8 present present JJ 31504 498 9 state state NN 31504 498 10 of of IN 31504 498 11 civilization civilization NN 31504 498 12 society society NN 31504 498 13 can can MD 31504 498 14 not not RB 31504 498 15 act act VB 31504 498 16 effectively effectively RB 31504 498 17 for for IN 31504 498 18 determining determine VBG 31504 498 19 and and CC 31504 498 20 maintaining maintain VBG 31504 498 21 the the DT 31504 498 22 line line NN 31504 498 23 , , , 31504 498 24 the the DT 31504 498 25 equilibrium equilibrium NN 31504 498 26 , , , 31504 498 27 between between IN 31504 498 28 necessary necessary JJ 31504 498 29 freedom freedom NN 31504 498 30 and and CC 31504 498 31 necessary necessary JJ 31504 498 32 restraint restraint NN 31504 498 33 , , , 31504 498 34 or or CC 31504 498 35 in in IN 31504 498 36 short short JJ 31504 498 37 , , , 31504 498 38 justice justice NN 31504 498 39 , , , 31504 498 40 except except IN 31504 498 41 through through IN 31504 498 42 some some DT 31504 498 43 governmental governmental JJ 31504 498 44 organization organization NN 31504 498 45 with with IN 31504 498 46 power power NN 31504 498 47 to to TO 31504 498 48 define define VB 31504 498 49 and and CC 31504 498 50 enforce enforce VB 31504 498 51 . . . 31504 499 1 Appeals appeal NNS 31504 499 2 to to IN 31504 499 3 altruistic altruistic JJ 31504 499 4 sentiments sentiment NNS 31504 499 5 will will MD 31504 499 6 not not RB 31504 499 7 suffice suffice VB 31504 499 8 . . . 31504 500 1 This this DT 31504 500 2 truth truth NN 31504 500 3 was be VBD 31504 500 4 recognized recognize VBN 31504 500 5 by by IN 31504 500 6 the the DT 31504 500 7 framers framer NNS 31504 500 8 of of IN 31504 500 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 500 10 federal federal JJ 31504 500 11 and and CC 31504 500 12 many many JJ 31504 500 13 state state NN 31504 500 14 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 500 15 , , , 31504 500 16 in in IN 31504 500 17 naming name VBG 31504 500 18 first first RB 31504 500 19 among among IN 31504 500 20 the the DT 31504 500 21 purposes purpose NNS 31504 500 22 of of IN 31504 500 23 government government NN 31504 500 24 the the DT 31504 500 25 establishment establishment NN 31504 500 26 of of IN 31504 500 27 justice justice NN 31504 500 28 . . . 31504 501 1 Any any DT 31504 501 2 government government NN 31504 501 3 , , , 31504 501 4 however however RB 31504 501 5 , , , 31504 501 6 or or CC 31504 501 7 rather rather RB 31504 501 8 those those DT 31504 501 9 entrusted entrust VBN 31504 501 10 with with IN 31504 501 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 501 12 administration administration NN 31504 501 13 , , , 31504 501 14 may may MD 31504 501 15 through through IN 31504 501 16 mistake mistake NN 31504 501 17 or or CC 31504 501 18 wilfulness wilfulness NN 31504 501 19 do do VBP 31504 501 20 injustice injustice NN 31504 501 21 to to IN 31504 501 22 some some DT 31504 501 23 of of IN 31504 501 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 501 25 subjects subject NNS 31504 501 26 . . . 31504 502 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 502 2 has have VBZ 31504 502 3 often often RB 31504 502 4 done do VBN 31504 502 5 so so RB 31504 502 6 in in IN 31504 502 7 the the DT 31504 502 8 past past NN 31504 502 9 and and CC 31504 502 10 the the DT 31504 502 11 future future NN 31504 502 12 is be VBZ 31504 502 13 not not RB 31504 502 14 free free JJ 31504 502 15 from from IN 31504 502 16 the the DT 31504 502 17 danger danger NN 31504 502 18 . . . 31504 503 1 The the DT 31504 503 2 very very JJ 31504 503 3 possession possession NN 31504 503 4 of of IN 31504 503 5 power power NN 31504 503 6 excites excite NNS 31504 503 7 a a DT 31504 503 8 desire desire NN 31504 503 9 to to TO 31504 503 10 use use VB 31504 503 11 it -PRON- PRP 31504 503 12 , , , 31504 503 13 and and CC 31504 503 14 it -PRON- PRP 31504 503 15 is be VBZ 31504 503 16 an an DT 31504 503 17 admitted admit VBN 31504 503 18 characteristic characteristic NN 31504 503 19 of of IN 31504 503 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 503 21 human human JJ 31504 503 22 nature nature NN 31504 503 23 that that WDT 31504 503 24 those those DT 31504 503 25 vested vest VBN 31504 503 26 with with IN 31504 503 27 power power NN 31504 503 28 , , , 31504 503 29 political political JJ 31504 503 30 or or CC 31504 503 31 other other JJ 31504 503 32 , , , 31504 503 33 are be VBP 31504 503 34 prone prone JJ 31504 503 35 to to TO 31504 503 36 exercise exercise VB 31504 503 37 it -PRON- PRP 31504 503 38 unduly unduly RB 31504 503 39 , , , 31504 503 40 to to TO 31504 503 41 abuse abuse VB 31504 503 42 it -PRON- PRP 31504 503 43 . . . 31504 504 1 Men men NN 31504 504 2 in in IN 31504 504 3 authority authority NN 31504 504 4 are be VBP 31504 504 5 often often RB 31504 504 6 said say VBN 31504 504 7 to to TO 31504 504 8 be be VB 31504 504 9 " " `` 31504 504 10 drunk drunk JJ 31504 504 11 with with IN 31504 504 12 power power NN 31504 504 13 . . . 31504 504 14 " " '' 31504 505 1 Hence hence RB 31504 505 2 to to TO 31504 505 3 ensure ensure VB 31504 505 4 justice justice NN 31504 505 5 the the DT 31504 505 6 governmental governmental JJ 31504 505 7 organization organization NN 31504 505 8 should should MD 31504 505 9 be be VB 31504 505 10 such such JJ 31504 505 11 that that IN 31504 505 12 the the DT 31504 505 13 limits limit NNS 31504 505 14 of of IN 31504 505 15 the the DT 31504 505 16 various various JJ 31504 505 17 powers power NNS 31504 505 18 of of IN 31504 505 19 the the DT 31504 505 20 government government NN 31504 505 21 be be VB 31504 505 22 carefully carefully RB 31504 505 23 defined define VBN 31504 505 24 and and CC 31504 505 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 505 26 administrators administrator NNS 31504 505 27 be be VB 31504 505 28 kept keep VBN 31504 505 29 within within IN 31504 505 30 those those DT 31504 505 31 limits limit NNS 31504 505 32 . . . 31504 506 1 Some some DT 31504 506 2 years year NNS 31504 506 3 ago ago RB 31504 506 4 I -PRON- PRP 31504 506 5 might may MD 31504 506 6 have have VB 31504 506 7 pointed point VBN 31504 506 8 to to IN 31504 506 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 506 10 own own JJ 31504 506 11 federal federal JJ 31504 506 12 and and CC 31504 506 13 state state NN 31504 506 14 governments government NNS 31504 506 15 as as IN 31504 506 16 the the DT 31504 506 17 best good JJS 31504 506 18 in in IN 31504 506 19 form form NN 31504 506 20 and and CC 31504 506 21 character character NN 31504 506 22 for for IN 31504 506 23 establishing establish VBG 31504 506 24 justice justice NN 31504 506 25 and and CC 31504 506 26 rested rest VBD 31504 506 27 there there RB 31504 506 28 . . . 31504 507 1 In in IN 31504 507 2 later later JJ 31504 507 3 years year NNS 31504 507 4 , , , 31504 507 5 however however RB 31504 507 6 , , , 31504 507 7 the the DT 31504 507 8 superiority superiority NN 31504 507 9 of of IN 31504 507 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 507 11 system system NN 31504 507 12 is be VBZ 31504 507 13 questioned question VBN 31504 507 14 , , , 31504 507 15 and and CC 31504 507 16 radical radical JJ 31504 507 17 changes change NNS 31504 507 18 are be VBP 31504 507 19 urged urge VBN 31504 507 20 , , , 31504 507 21 and and CC 31504 507 22 indeed indeed RB 31504 507 23 some some DT 31504 507 24 have have VBP 31504 507 25 been be VBN 31504 507 26 made make VBN 31504 507 27 , , , 31504 507 28 in in IN 31504 507 29 the the DT 31504 507 30 federal federal JJ 31504 507 31 system system NN 31504 507 32 and and CC 31504 507 33 in in IN 31504 507 34 that that DT 31504 507 35 of of IN 31504 507 36 some some DT 31504 507 37 of of IN 31504 507 38 the the DT 31504 507 39 states state NNS 31504 507 40 . . . 31504 508 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 508 2 feel feel VBP 31504 508 3 , , , 31504 508 4 therefore therefore RB 31504 508 5 , , , 31504 508 6 that that IN 31504 508 7 I -PRON- PRP 31504 508 8 should should MD 31504 508 9 make make VB 31504 508 10 some some DT 31504 508 11 defense defense NN 31504 508 12 of of IN 31504 508 13 the the DT 31504 508 14 system system NN 31504 508 15 , , , 31504 508 16 believing believe VBG 31504 508 17 as as IN 31504 508 18 I -PRON- PRP 31504 508 19 do do VBP 31504 508 20 that that DT 31504 508 21 in in IN 31504 508 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 508 23 general general JJ 31504 508 24 form form NN 31504 508 25 and and CC 31504 508 26 character character NN 31504 508 27 it -PRON- PRP 31504 508 28 is be VBZ 31504 508 29 best well RBS 31504 508 30 adapted adapt VBN 31504 508 31 to to TO 31504 508 32 secure secure VB 31504 508 33 firmly firmly RB 31504 508 34 as as RB 31504 508 35 much much JJ 31504 508 36 individual individual JJ 31504 508 37 liberty liberty NN 31504 508 38 of of IN 31504 508 39 action action NN 31504 508 40 and and CC 31504 508 41 equality equality NN 31504 508 42 of of IN 31504 508 43 right right NN 31504 508 44 as as IN 31504 508 45 is be VBZ 31504 508 46 consistent consistent JJ 31504 508 47 with with IN 31504 508 48 the the DT 31504 508 49 welfare welfare NN 31504 508 50 of of IN 31504 508 51 the the DT 31504 508 52 whole whole JJ 31504 508 53 number number NN 31504 508 54 , , , 31504 508 55 or or CC 31504 508 56 , , , 31504 508 57 in in IN 31504 508 58 other other JJ 31504 508 59 words word NNS 31504 508 60 , , , 31504 508 61 best best RB 31504 508 62 adapted adapt VBN 31504 508 63 to to TO 31504 508 64 secure secure VB 31504 508 65 justice justice NN 31504 508 66 . . . 31504 509 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 509 2 has have VBZ 31504 509 3 become become VBN 31504 509 4 a a DT 31504 509 5 familiar familiar JJ 31504 509 6 maxim maxim NN 31504 509 7 that that IN 31504 509 8 the the DT 31504 509 9 functions function NNS 31504 509 10 and and CC 31504 509 11 powers power NNS 31504 509 12 of of IN 31504 509 13 government government NN 31504 509 14 may may MD 31504 509 15 all all DT 31504 509 16 be be VB 31504 509 17 grouped group VBN 31504 509 18 in in IN 31504 509 19 three three CD 31504 509 20 classes class NNS 31504 509 21 or or CC 31504 509 22 departments department NNS 31504 509 23 , , , 31504 509 24 corresponding correspond VBG 31504 509 25 to to IN 31504 509 26 the the DT 31504 509 27 duties duty NNS 31504 509 28 already already RB 31504 509 29 named name VBN 31504 509 30 : : : 31504 509 31 ( ( -LRB- 31504 509 32 1 1 LS 31504 509 33 ) ) -RRB- 31504 509 34 that that IN 31504 509 35 of of IN 31504 509 36 determining determine VBG 31504 509 37 what what WP 31504 509 38 rules rule NNS 31504 509 39 and and CC 31504 509 40 regulations regulation NNS 31504 509 41 should should MD 31504 509 42 be be VB 31504 509 43 observed observe VBN 31504 509 44 , , , 31504 509 45 what what WDT 31504 509 46 restraints restraint NNS 31504 509 47 and and CC 31504 509 48 duties duty NNS 31504 509 49 should should MD 31504 509 50 be be VB 31504 509 51 imposed impose VBN 31504 509 52 upon upon IN 31504 509 53 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 509 54 subjects subject NNS 31504 509 55 ; ; : 31504 509 56 ( ( -LRB- 31504 509 57 2 2 LS 31504 509 58 ) ) -RRB- 31504 509 59 that that IN 31504 509 60 of of IN 31504 509 61 determining determine VBG 31504 509 62 whether whether IN 31504 509 63 in in IN 31504 509 64 a a DT 31504 509 65 given give VBN 31504 509 66 case case NN 31504 509 67 any any DT 31504 509 68 of of IN 31504 509 69 these these DT 31504 509 70 rules rule NNS 31504 509 71 , , , 31504 509 72 etc etc FW 31504 509 73 . . . 31504 509 74 , , , 31504 509 75 have have VBP 31504 509 76 been be VBN 31504 509 77 violated violate VBN 31504 509 78 ; ; : 31504 509 79 and and CC 31504 509 80 ( ( -LRB- 31504 509 81 3 3 LS 31504 509 82 ) ) -RRB- 31504 509 83 that that DT 31504 509 84 of of IN 31504 509 85 punishing punish VBG 31504 509 86 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 509 87 violation violation NN 31504 509 88 and and CC 31504 509 89 otherwise otherwise RB 31504 509 90 enforcing enforce VBG 31504 509 91 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 509 92 observance observance NN 31504 509 93 . . . 31504 510 1 These these DT 31504 510 2 three three CD 31504 510 3 groups group NNS 31504 510 4 have have VBP 31504 510 5 come come VBN 31504 510 6 to to TO 31504 510 7 be be VB 31504 510 8 called call VBN 31504 510 9 the the DT 31504 510 10 three three CD 31504 510 11 powers power NNS 31504 510 12 of of IN 31504 510 13 government government NN 31504 510 14 and and CC 31504 510 15 to to TO 31504 510 16 be be VB 31504 510 17 designated designate VBN 31504 510 18 as as IN 31504 510 19 the the DT 31504 510 20 legislative legislative JJ 31504 510 21 , , , 31504 510 22 judicial judicial JJ 31504 510 23 , , , 31504 510 24 and and CC 31504 510 25 executive executive NN 31504 510 26 , , , 31504 510 27 though though IN 31504 510 28 they -PRON- PRP 31504 510 29 are be VBP 31504 510 30 usually usually RB 31504 510 31 named name VBN 31504 510 32 in in IN 31504 510 33 another another DT 31504 510 34 order order NN 31504 510 35 as as IN 31504 510 36 the the DT 31504 510 37 executive executive JJ 31504 510 38 , , , 31504 510 39 legislative legislative JJ 31504 510 40 , , , 31504 510 41 and and CC 31504 510 42 judicial judicial JJ 31504 510 43 . . . 31504 511 1 The the DT 31504 511 2 most most RBS 31504 511 3 efficient efficient JJ 31504 511 4 form form NN 31504 511 5 of of IN 31504 511 6 government government NN 31504 511 7 for for IN 31504 511 8 good good JJ 31504 511 9 or or CC 31504 511 10 evil evil NN 31504 511 11 , , , 31504 511 12 and and CC 31504 511 13 the the DT 31504 511 14 quickest quick JJS 31504 511 15 to to TO 31504 511 16 act act VB 31504 511 17 , , , 31504 511 18 is be VBZ 31504 511 19 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 31504 511 20 that that IN 31504 511 21 in in IN 31504 511 22 which which WDT 31504 511 23 all all DT 31504 511 24 of of IN 31504 511 25 these these DT 31504 511 26 powers power NNS 31504 511 27 are be VBP 31504 511 28 united united JJ 31504 511 29 in in IN 31504 511 30 a a DT 31504 511 31 single single JJ 31504 511 32 individual individual NN 31504 511 33 . . . 31504 512 1 If if IN 31504 512 2 that that DT 31504 512 3 individual individual NN 31504 512 4 were be VBD 31504 512 5 always always RB 31504 512 6 strong strong JJ 31504 512 7 , , , 31504 512 8 yet yet CC 31504 512 9 peace peace NN 31504 512 10 - - HYPH 31504 512 11 loving loving NN 31504 512 12 , , , 31504 512 13 self self NN 31504 512 14 - - HYPH 31504 512 15 controlled control VBN 31504 512 16 , , , 31504 512 17 sagacious sagacious JJ 31504 512 18 and and CC 31504 512 19 exclusively exclusively RB 31504 512 20 devoted devoted JJ 31504 512 21 to to IN 31504 512 22 the the DT 31504 512 23 welfare welfare NN 31504 512 24 of of IN 31504 512 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 512 26 subjects subject NNS 31504 512 27 , , , 31504 512 28 that that DT 31504 512 29 form form NN 31504 512 30 of of IN 31504 512 31 government government NN 31504 512 32 would would MD 31504 512 33 perhaps perhaps RB 31504 512 34 secure secure VB 31504 512 35 them -PRON- PRP 31504 512 36 justice justice NN 31504 512 37 most most RBS 31504 512 38 surely surely RB 31504 512 39 and and CC 31504 512 40 speedily speedily RB 31504 512 41 . . . 31504 513 1 Such such JJ 31504 513 2 men man NNS 31504 513 3 , , , 31504 513 4 however however RB 31504 513 5 , , , 31504 513 6 are be VBP 31504 513 7 rare rare JJ 31504 513 8 and and CC 31504 513 9 such such JJ 31504 513 10 governments government NNS 31504 513 11 have have VBP 31504 513 12 been be VBN 31504 513 13 found find VBN 31504 513 14 to to TO 31504 513 15 be be VB 31504 513 16 invariably invariably RB 31504 513 17 and and CC 31504 513 18 almost almost RB 31504 513 19 inevitably inevitably RB 31504 513 20 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 31504 513 21 in in IN 31504 513 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 513 23 dealings dealing NNS 31504 513 24 with with IN 31504 513 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 513 26 subjects subject NNS 31504 513 27 , , , 31504 513 28 and and CC 31504 513 29 in in IN 31504 513 30 the the DT 31504 513 31 plenitude plenitude NN 31504 513 32 of of IN 31504 513 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 513 34 power power NN 31504 513 35 to to TO 31504 513 36 become become VB 31504 513 37 oppressive oppressive JJ 31504 513 38 . . . 31504 514 1 While while IN 31504 514 2 they -PRON- PRP 31504 514 3 may may MD 31504 514 4 effectually effectually RB 31504 514 5 protect protect VB 31504 514 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 514 7 subjects subject NNS 31504 514 8 from from IN 31504 514 9 foreign foreign JJ 31504 514 10 aggression aggression NN 31504 514 11 and and CC 31504 514 12 domestic domestic JJ 31504 514 13 anarchy anarchy NN 31504 514 14 , , , 31504 514 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 514 16 tendency tendency NN 31504 514 17 is be VBZ 31504 514 18 to to TO 31504 514 19 impose impose VB 31504 514 20 burdens burden NNS 31504 514 21 and and CC 31504 514 22 restrict restrict VB 31504 514 23 individual individual JJ 31504 514 24 liberty liberty NN 31504 514 25 more more JJR 31504 514 26 than than IN 31504 514 27 necessary necessary JJ 31504 514 28 , , , 31504 514 29 and and CC 31504 514 30 to to TO 31504 514 31 disregard disregard VB 31504 514 32 the the DT 31504 514 33 innate innate JJ 31504 514 34 desire desire NN 31504 514 35 of of IN 31504 514 36 men man NNS 31504 514 37 for for IN 31504 514 38 liberty liberty NN 31504 514 39 or or CC 31504 514 40 at at IN 31504 514 41 least least JJS 31504 514 42 for for IN 31504 514 43 equality equality NN 31504 514 44 of of IN 31504 514 45 restraint restraint NN 31504 514 46 . . . 31504 515 1 This this DT 31504 515 2 form form NN 31504 515 3 of of IN 31504 515 4 government government NN 31504 515 5 has have VBZ 31504 515 6 already already RB 31504 515 7 largely largely RB 31504 515 8 disappeared disappear VBN 31504 515 9 and and CC 31504 515 10 is be VBZ 31504 515 11 further further RB 31504 515 12 disappearing disappear VBG 31504 515 13 , , , 31504 515 14 though though IN 31504 515 15 it -PRON- PRP 31504 515 16 may may MD 31504 515 17 again again RB 31504 515 18 be be VB 31504 515 19 resorted resort VBN 31504 515 20 to to IN 31504 515 21 for for IN 31504 515 22 the the DT 31504 515 23 restoration restoration NN 31504 515 24 of of IN 31504 515 25 order order NN 31504 515 26 , , , 31504 515 27 should should MD 31504 515 28 the the DT 31504 515 29 present present JJ 31504 515 30 forms form NNS 31504 515 31 of of IN 31504 515 32 government government NN 31504 515 33 fail fail VBP 31504 515 34 to to TO 31504 515 35 prevent prevent VB 31504 515 36 violence violence NN 31504 515 37 and and CC 31504 515 38 preserve preserve VB 31504 515 39 the the DT 31504 515 40 peace peace NN 31504 515 41 . . . 31504 516 1 But but CC 31504 516 2 other other JJ 31504 516 3 forms form NNS 31504 516 4 of of IN 31504 516 5 government government NN 31504 516 6 have have VBP 31504 516 7 not not RB 31504 516 8 been be VBN 31504 516 9 and and CC 31504 516 10 are be VBP 31504 516 11 not not RB 31504 516 12 yet yet RB 31504 516 13 wholly wholly RB 31504 516 14 free free JJ 31504 516 15 from from IN 31504 516 16 the the DT 31504 516 17 same same JJ 31504 516 18 objectionable objectionable JJ 31504 516 19 tendency tendency NN 31504 516 20 . . . 31504 517 1 The the DT 31504 517 2 vesting vesting NN 31504 517 3 of of IN 31504 517 4 all all PDT 31504 517 5 these these DT 31504 517 6 governmental governmental JJ 31504 517 7 powers power NNS 31504 517 8 in in IN 31504 517 9 a a DT 31504 517 10 group group NN 31504 517 11 or or CC 31504 517 12 class class NN 31504 517 13 of of IN 31504 517 14 persons person NNS 31504 517 15 instead instead RB 31504 517 16 of of IN 31504 517 17 one one CD 31504 517 18 person person NN 31504 517 19 has have VBZ 31504 517 20 been be VBN 31504 517 21 followed follow VBN 31504 517 22 by by IN 31504 517 23 the the DT 31504 517 24 same same JJ 31504 517 25 results result NNS 31504 517 26 . . . 31504 518 1 Aristocracies aristocracy NNS 31504 518 2 or or CC 31504 518 3 oligarchies oligarchy NNS 31504 518 4 have have VBP 31504 518 5 the the DT 31504 518 6 same same JJ 31504 518 7 tendency tendency NN 31504 518 8 and and CC 31504 518 9 even even RB 31504 518 10 in in IN 31504 518 11 a a DT 31504 518 12 greater great JJR 31504 518 13 degree degree NN 31504 518 14 . . . 31504 519 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 519 2 have have VBP 31504 519 3 proved prove VBN 31504 519 4 even even RB 31504 519 5 more more RBR 31504 519 6 selfish selfish JJ 31504 519 7 and and CC 31504 519 8 tyrannical tyrannical JJ 31504 519 9 than than IN 31504 519 10 the the DT 31504 519 11 single single JJ 31504 519 12 ruler ruler NN 31504 519 13 . . . 31504 520 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 520 2 , , , 31504 520 3 like like IN 31504 520 4 all all DT 31504 520 5 crowds crowd NNS 31504 520 6 , , , 31504 520 7 are be VBP 31504 520 8 less less RBR 31504 520 9 sensitive sensitive JJ 31504 520 10 in in IN 31504 520 11 conscience conscience NN 31504 520 12 , , , 31504 520 13 less less RBR 31504 520 14 moved move VBN 31504 520 15 by by IN 31504 520 16 appeals appeal NNS 31504 520 17 to to IN 31504 520 18 reason reason NN 31504 520 19 , , , 31504 520 20 than than IN 31504 520 21 is be VBZ 31504 520 22 the the DT 31504 520 23 single single JJ 31504 520 24 individual individual NN 31504 520 25 . . . 31504 521 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 521 2 offend offend VBP 31504 521 3 more more JJR 31504 521 4 the the DT 31504 521 5 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 521 6 of of IN 31504 521 7 equality equality NN 31504 521 8 . . . 31504 522 1 The the DT 31504 522 2 French French NNP 31504 522 3 Revolution Revolution NNP 31504 522 4 was be VBD 31504 522 5 not not RB 31504 522 6 so so RB 31504 522 7 much much JJ 31504 522 8 against against IN 31504 522 9 the the DT 31504 522 10 king king NN 31504 522 11 as as IN 31504 522 12 against against IN 31504 522 13 the the DT 31504 522 14 nobility nobility NN 31504 522 15 , , , 31504 522 16 who who WP 31504 522 17 with with IN 31504 522 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 522 19 oppressive oppressive JJ 31504 522 20 feudal feudal JJ 31504 522 21 exemptions exemption NNS 31504 522 22 had have VBD 31504 522 23 excited excite VBN 31504 522 24 the the DT 31504 522 25 resentment resentment NN 31504 522 26 of of IN 31504 522 27 the the DT 31504 522 28 people people NNS 31504 522 29 at at IN 31504 522 30 large large JJ 31504 522 31 . . . 31504 523 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 523 2 was be VBD 31504 523 3 not not RB 31504 523 4 till till IN 31504 523 5 after after IN 31504 523 6 he -PRON- PRP 31504 523 7 had have VBD 31504 523 8 cast cast VBN 31504 523 9 in in IN 31504 523 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 523 11 lot lot NN 31504 523 12 with with IN 31504 523 13 the the DT 31504 523 14 emigrés emigré NNS 31504 523 15 that that WDT 31504 523 16 the the DT 31504 523 17 king king NN 31504 523 18 was be VBD 31504 523 19 deposed depose VBN 31504 523 20 and and CC 31504 523 21 guillotined guillotine VBN 31504 523 22 . . . 31504 524 1 Nor nor CC 31504 524 2 have have VB 31504 524 3 pure pure JJ 31504 524 4 democracies democracy NNS 31504 524 5 , , , 31504 524 6 in in IN 31504 524 7 the the DT 31504 524 8 few few JJ 31504 524 9 instances instance NNS 31504 524 10 where where WRB 31504 524 11 they -PRON- PRP 31504 524 12 have have VBP 31504 524 13 undertaken undertake VBN 31504 524 14 to to TO 31504 524 15 exercise exercise VB 31504 524 16 directly directly RB 31504 524 17 all all PDT 31504 524 18 the the DT 31504 524 19 powers power NNS 31504 524 20 of of IN 31504 524 21 government government NN 31504 524 22 , , , 31504 524 23 showed show VBD 31504 524 24 less less JJR 31504 524 25 tendency tendency NN 31504 524 26 to to TO 31504 524 27 be be VB 31504 524 28 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 31504 524 29 and and CC 31504 524 30 inconsiderate inconsiderate JJ 31504 524 31 of of IN 31504 524 32 individual individual JJ 31504 524 33 freedom freedom NN 31504 524 34 and and CC 31504 524 35 desires desire NNS 31504 524 36 . . . 31504 525 1 The the DT 31504 525 2 nearest near JJS 31504 525 3 approach approach NN 31504 525 4 to to IN 31504 525 5 such such PDT 31504 525 6 a a DT 31504 525 7 government government NN 31504 525 8 was be VBD 31504 525 9 that that DT 31504 525 10 of of IN 31504 525 11 ancient ancient JJ 31504 525 12 Athens Athens NNP 31504 525 13 where where WRB 31504 525 14 the the DT 31504 525 15 populace populace NN 31504 525 16 sent send VBD 31504 525 17 into into IN 31504 525 18 exile exile NN 31504 525 19 , , , 31504 525 20 practically practically RB 31504 525 21 without without IN 31504 525 22 trial trial NN 31504 525 23 , , , 31504 525 24 Aristides Aristides NNP 31504 525 25 , , , 31504 525 26 called call VBN 31504 525 27 the the DT 31504 525 28 Just Just NNP 31504 525 29 , , , 31504 525 30 Miltiades Miltiades NNP 31504 525 31 , , , 31504 525 32 the the DT 31504 525 33 victor victor NN 31504 525 34 of of IN 31504 525 35 Marathon Marathon NNP 31504 525 36 , , , 31504 525 37 and and CC 31504 525 38 Themistocles Themistocles NNP 31504 525 39 , , , 31504 525 40 the the DT 31504 525 41 victor victor NN 31504 525 42 of of IN 31504 525 43 Salamis Salamis NNP 31504 525 44 . . . 31504 526 1 The the DT 31504 526 2 excesses excess NNS 31504 526 3 of of IN 31504 526 4 the the DT 31504 526 5 Paris Paris NNP 31504 526 6 Commune Commune NNP 31504 526 7 of of IN 31504 526 8 1870 1870 CD 31504 526 9 during during IN 31504 526 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 526 11 reign reign NN 31504 526 12 , , , 31504 526 13 the the DT 31504 526 14 lynchings lynching NNS 31504 526 15 of of IN 31504 526 16 today today NN 31504 526 17 by by IN 31504 526 18 mobs mob NNS 31504 526 19 of of IN 31504 526 20 so so RB 31504 526 21 - - HYPH 31504 526 22 called call VBN 31504 526 23 " " `` 31504 526 24 respectable respectable JJ 31504 526 25 citizens citizen NNS 31504 526 26 " " '' 31504 526 27 who who WP 31504 526 28 assume assume VBP 31504 526 29 the the DT 31504 526 30 power power NN 31504 526 31 to to TO 31504 526 32 accuse accuse VB 31504 526 33 , , , 31504 526 34 judge judge VB 31504 526 35 and and CC 31504 526 36 execute execute VB 31504 526 37 all all DT 31504 526 38 at at IN 31504 526 39 once once RB 31504 526 40 , , , 31504 526 41 indicate indicate VB 31504 526 42 how how WRB 31504 526 43 much much JJ 31504 526 44 regard regard NN 31504 526 45 unrestrained unrestrained JJ 31504 526 46 democracies democracy NNS 31504 526 47 would would MD 31504 526 48 have have VB 31504 526 49 for for IN 31504 526 50 the the DT 31504 526 51 rights right NNS 31504 526 52 of of IN 31504 526 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 526 54 individual individual JJ 31504 526 55 members member NNS 31504 526 56 . . . 31504 527 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 31504 527 2 , , , 31504 527 3 despite despite IN 31504 527 4 the the DT 31504 527 5 danger danger NN 31504 527 6 of of IN 31504 527 7 more more JJR 31504 527 8 or or CC 31504 527 9 less less JJR 31504 527 10 arbitrariness arbitrariness NN 31504 527 11 , , , 31504 527 12 of of IN 31504 527 13 more more RBR 31504 527 14 or or CC 31504 527 15 less less JJR 31504 527 16 oppression oppression NN 31504 527 17 of of IN 31504 527 18 the the DT 31504 527 19 individual individual NN 31504 527 20 , , , 31504 527 21 any any DT 31504 527 22 government government NN 31504 527 23 must must MD 31504 527 24 be be VB 31504 527 25 made make VBN 31504 527 26 strong strong JJ 31504 527 27 enough enough RB 31504 527 28 perfectly perfectly RB 31504 527 29 to to TO 31504 527 30 maintain maintain VB 31504 527 31 order order NN 31504 527 32 and and CC 31504 527 33 peace peace NN 31504 527 34 among among IN 31504 527 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 527 36 subjects subject NNS 31504 527 37 . . . 31504 528 1 Order order NN 31504 528 2 is be VBZ 31504 528 3 earth earth NN 31504 528 4 's be VBZ 31504 528 5 as as RB 31504 528 6 well well RB 31504 528 7 as as IN 31504 528 8 heaven heaven NNP 31504 528 9 's 's POS 31504 528 10 first first JJ 31504 528 11 law law NN 31504 528 12 . . . 31504 529 1 The the DT 31504 529 2 goddess goddess NN 31504 529 3 Themis Themis NNP 31504 529 4 in in IN 31504 529 5 the the DT 31504 529 6 early early JJ 31504 529 7 Greek greek JJ 31504 529 8 mythology mythology NN 31504 529 9 was be VBD 31504 529 10 the the DT 31504 529 11 goddess goddess NN 31504 529 12 of of IN 31504 529 13 order order NN 31504 529 14 as as RB 31504 529 15 well well RB 31504 529 16 as as IN 31504 529 17 the the DT 31504 529 18 supplier supplier NN 31504 529 19 of of IN 31504 529 20 _ _ NNP 31504 529 21 themistes themiste VBZ 31504 529 22 _ _ NNP 31504 529 23 or or CC 31504 529 24 decisions decision NNS 31504 529 25 . . . 31504 530 1 She -PRON- PRP 31504 530 2 was be VBD 31504 530 3 present present JJ 31504 530 4 as as IN 31504 530 5 the the DT 31504 530 6 spirit spirit NN 31504 530 7 of of IN 31504 530 8 order order NN 31504 530 9 in in IN 31504 530 10 the the DT 31504 530 11 councils council NNS 31504 530 12 of of IN 31504 530 13 gods god NNS 31504 530 14 and and CC 31504 530 15 men man NNS 31504 530 16 . . . 31504 531 1 The the DT 31504 531 2 government government NN 31504 531 3 that that WDT 31504 531 4 can can MD 31504 531 5 not not RB 31504 531 6 or or CC 31504 531 7 will will MD 31504 531 8 not not RB 31504 531 9 maintain maintain VB 31504 531 10 order order NN 31504 531 11 and and CC 31504 531 12 peace peace NN 31504 531 13 , , , 31504 531 14 prevent prevent VB 31504 531 15 violence violence NN 31504 531 16 and and CC 31504 531 17 fraud fraud NN 31504 531 18 , , , 31504 531 19 enforce enforce VB 31504 531 20 individual individual JJ 31504 531 21 rights right NNS 31504 531 22 and and CC 31504 531 23 redress redress VB 31504 531 24 individual individual JJ 31504 531 25 wrongs wrong NNS 31504 531 26 completely completely RB 31504 531 27 and and CC 31504 531 28 promptly promptly RB 31504 531 29 , , , 31504 531 30 is be VBZ 31504 531 31 so so RB 31504 531 32 far far RB 31504 531 33 a a DT 31504 531 34 failure failure NN 31504 531 35 and and CC 31504 531 36 whatever whatever WDT 31504 531 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 531 38 form form NN 31504 531 39 should should MD 31504 531 40 be be VB 31504 531 41 reformed reform VBN 31504 531 42 or or CC 31504 531 43 overthrown overthrow VBN 31504 531 44 . . . 31504 532 1 Even even RB 31504 532 2 military military JJ 31504 532 3 despotism despotism NN 31504 532 4 is be VBZ 31504 532 5 better well JJR 31504 532 6 than than IN 31504 532 7 disorder disorder NN 31504 532 8 . . . 31504 533 1 On on IN 31504 533 2 the the DT 31504 533 3 other other JJ 31504 533 4 hand hand NN 31504 533 5 , , , 31504 533 6 there there EX 31504 533 7 must must MD 31504 533 8 be be VB 31504 533 9 taken take VBN 31504 533 10 into into IN 31504 533 11 account account NN 31504 533 12 the the DT 31504 533 13 tendency tendency NN 31504 533 14 , , , 31504 533 15 already already RB 31504 533 16 mentioned mention VBN 31504 533 17 , , , 31504 533 18 of of IN 31504 533 19 the the DT 31504 533 20 possessor possessor NN 31504 533 21 of of IN 31504 533 22 unlimited unlimited JJ 31504 533 23 power power NN 31504 533 24 over over IN 31504 533 25 others other NNS 31504 533 26 to to TO 31504 533 27 use use VB 31504 533 28 it -PRON- PRP 31504 533 29 for for IN 31504 533 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 533 31 own own JJ 31504 533 32 benefit benefit NN 31504 533 33 or or CC 31504 533 34 pleasure pleasure NN 31504 533 35 at at IN 31504 533 36 the the DT 31504 533 37 expense expense NN 31504 533 38 of of IN 31504 533 39 those those DT 31504 533 40 subject subject JJ 31504 533 41 to to IN 31504 533 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 533 43 control control NN 31504 533 44 , , , 31504 533 45 where where WRB 31504 533 46 not not RB 31504 533 47 restrained restrain VBN 31504 533 48 by by IN 31504 533 49 affection affection NN 31504 533 50 or or CC 31504 533 51 like like IN 31504 533 52 virtues virtue NNS 31504 533 53 . . . 31504 534 1 Under under IN 31504 534 2 all all DT 31504 534 3 governments government NNS 31504 534 4 there there EX 31504 534 5 has have VBZ 31504 534 6 been be VBN 31504 534 7 more more RBR 31504 534 8 or or CC 31504 534 9 less less JJR 31504 534 10 friction friction NN 31504 534 11 between between IN 31504 534 12 the the DT 31504 534 13 persons person NNS 31504 534 14 governing govern VBG 31504 534 15 and and CC 31504 534 16 those those DT 31504 534 17 governed govern VBN 31504 534 18 ; ; : 31504 534 19 more more RBR 31504 534 20 or or CC 31504 534 21 less less JJR 31504 534 22 strife strife NN 31504 534 23 , , , 31504 534 24 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 534 25 culminating culminate VBG 31504 534 26 in in IN 31504 534 27 rebellion rebellion NN 31504 534 28 and and CC 31504 534 29 even even RB 31504 534 30 revolution revolution NN 31504 534 31 . . . 31504 535 1 If if IN 31504 535 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 535 3 be be VB 31504 535 4 said say VBN 31504 535 5 that that IN 31504 535 6 under under IN 31504 535 7 a a DT 31504 535 8 government government NN 31504 535 9 by by IN 31504 535 10 the the DT 31504 535 11 people people NNS 31504 535 12 directly directly RB 31504 535 13 , , , 31504 535 14 a a DT 31504 535 15 pure pure JJ 31504 535 16 democracy democracy NN 31504 535 17 , , , 31504 535 18 such such JJ 31504 535 19 as as IN 31504 535 20 seems seem VBZ 31504 535 21 to to TO 31504 535 22 be be VB 31504 535 23 advocated advocate VBN 31504 535 24 at at IN 31504 535 25 this this DT 31504 535 26 day day NN 31504 535 27 , , , 31504 535 28 there there EX 31504 535 29 would would MD 31504 535 30 be be VB 31504 535 31 no no DT 31504 535 32 distinction distinction NN 31504 535 33 between between IN 31504 535 34 governors governor NNS 31504 535 35 and and CC 31504 535 36 governed govern VBN 31504 535 37 , , , 31504 535 38 that that IN 31504 535 39 all all DT 31504 535 40 would would MD 31504 535 41 be be VB 31504 535 42 governors governor NNS 31504 535 43 and and CC 31504 535 44 governed govern VBN 31504 535 45 alike alike RB 31504 535 46 , , , 31504 535 47 the the DT 31504 535 48 answer answer NN 31504 535 49 is be VBZ 31504 535 50 that that IN 31504 535 51 in in IN 31504 535 52 a a DT 31504 535 53 pure pure JJ 31504 535 54 democracy democracy NN 31504 535 55 the the DT 31504 535 56 governing govern VBG 31504 535 57 power power NN 31504 535 58 is be VBZ 31504 535 59 and and CC 31504 535 60 can can MD 31504 535 61 be be VB 31504 535 62 exercised exercise VBN 31504 535 63 by by IN 31504 535 64 only only RB 31504 535 65 a a DT 31504 535 66 part part NN 31504 535 67 of of IN 31504 535 68 the the DT 31504 535 69 people people NNS 31504 535 70 , , , 31504 535 71 a a DT 31504 535 72 majority majority NN 31504 535 73 it -PRON- PRP 31504 535 74 may may MD 31504 535 75 be be VB 31504 535 76 , , , 31504 535 77 but but CC 31504 535 78 still still RB 31504 535 79 only only RB 31504 535 80 a a DT 31504 535 81 part part NN 31504 535 82 . . . 31504 536 1 This this DT 31504 536 2 part part NN 31504 536 3 are be VBP 31504 536 4 the the DT 31504 536 5 governors governor NNS 31504 536 6 . . . 31504 537 1 The the DT 31504 537 2 other other JJ 31504 537 3 part part NN 31504 537 4 , , , 31504 537 5 perhaps perhaps RB 31504 537 6 nearly nearly RB 31504 537 7 as as RB 31504 537 8 numerous numerous JJ 31504 537 9 , , , 31504 537 10 are be VBP 31504 537 11 governed govern VBN 31504 537 12 . . . 31504 538 1 Friction friction NN 31504 538 2 and and CC 31504 538 3 even even RB 31504 538 4 factious factious JJ 31504 538 5 strife strife NN 31504 538 6 would would MD 31504 538 7 still still RB 31504 538 8 exist exist VB 31504 538 9 . . . 31504 539 1 Indeed indeed RB 31504 539 2 , , , 31504 539 3 a a DT 31504 539 4 government government NN 31504 539 5 by by IN 31504 539 6 a a DT 31504 539 7 pure pure JJ 31504 539 8 democracy democracy NN 31504 539 9 ruling rule VBG 31504 539 10 directly directly RB 31504 539 11 would would MD 31504 539 12 probably probably RB 31504 539 13 be be VB 31504 539 14 more more RBR 31504 539 15 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 31504 539 16 than than IN 31504 539 17 any any DT 31504 539 18 other other JJ 31504 539 19 , , , 31504 539 20 as as IN 31504 539 21 was be VBD 31504 539 22 the the DT 31504 539 23 case case NN 31504 539 24 in in IN 31504 539 25 Athens Athens NNP 31504 539 26 . . . 31504 540 1 The the DT 31504 540 2 government government NN 31504 540 3 by by IN 31504 540 4 one one CD 31504 540 5 , , , 31504 540 6 or or CC 31504 540 7 that that IN 31504 540 8 by by IN 31504 540 9 a a DT 31504 540 10 few few JJ 31504 540 11 , , , 31504 540 12 would would MD 31504 540 13 be be VB 31504 540 14 restrained restrain VBN 31504 540 15 to to IN 31504 540 16 some some DT 31504 540 17 extent extent NN 31504 540 18 by by IN 31504 540 19 public public JJ 31504 540 20 opinion opinion NN 31504 540 21 , , , 31504 540 22 would would MD 31504 540 23 refrain refrain VB 31504 540 24 from from IN 31504 540 25 extreme extreme JJ 31504 540 26 measures measure NNS 31504 540 27 lest lest IN 31504 540 28 they -PRON- PRP 31504 540 29 excite excite VBP 31504 540 30 effectual effectual JJ 31504 540 31 resistance resistance NN 31504 540 32 , , , 31504 540 33 but but CC 31504 540 34 a a DT 31504 540 35 majority majority NN 31504 540 36 would would MD 31504 540 37 feel feel VB 31504 540 38 no no DT 31504 540 39 such such JJ 31504 540 40 restraint restraint NN 31504 540 41 . . . 31504 541 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 541 2 would would MD 31504 541 3 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 541 4 constitute constitute VB 31504 541 5 public public JJ 31504 541 6 opinion opinion NN 31504 541 7 and and CC 31504 541 8 it -PRON- PRP 31504 541 9 would would MD 31504 541 10 be be VB 31504 541 11 less less RBR 31504 541 12 likely likely JJ 31504 541 13 to to TO 31504 541 14 fear fear VB 31504 541 15 resistance resistance NN 31504 541 16 . . . 31504 542 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 542 2 is be VBZ 31504 542 3 evident evident JJ 31504 542 4 , , , 31504 542 5 therefore therefore RB 31504 542 6 , , , 31504 542 7 that that IN 31504 542 8 the the DT 31504 542 9 frame frame NN 31504 542 10 of of IN 31504 542 11 government government NN 31504 542 12 should should MD 31504 542 13 be be VB 31504 542 14 such such JJ 31504 542 15 as as IN 31504 542 16 to to TO 31504 542 17 secure secure VB 31504 542 18 uniformity uniformity NN 31504 542 19 in in IN 31504 542 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 542 21 action action NN 31504 542 22 so so IN 31504 542 23 that that IN 31504 542 24 it -PRON- PRP 31504 542 25 shall shall MD 31504 542 26 not not RB 31504 542 27 act act VB 31504 542 28 arbitrarily arbitrarily RB 31504 542 29 and and CC 31504 542 30 unequally unequally RB 31504 542 31 on on IN 31504 542 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 542 33 subjects subject NNS 31504 542 34 . . . 31504 543 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 543 2 assume assume VBP 31504 543 3 that that IN 31504 543 4 no no DT 31504 543 5 sane sane JJ 31504 543 6 man man NN 31504 543 7 would would MD 31504 543 8 desire desire VB 31504 543 9 to to TO 31504 543 10 live live VB 31504 543 11 under under IN 31504 543 12 any any DT 31504 543 13 government government NN 31504 543 14 where where WRB 31504 543 15 the the DT 31504 543 16 wielders wielder NNS 31504 543 17 of of IN 31504 543 18 the the DT 31504 543 19 governmental governmental JJ 31504 543 20 power power NN 31504 543 21 , , , 31504 543 22 one one CD 31504 543 23 or or CC 31504 543 24 many many JJ 31504 543 25 , , , 31504 543 26 are be VBP 31504 543 27 entirely entirely RB 31504 543 28 without without IN 31504 543 29 legal legal JJ 31504 543 30 restraint restraint NN 31504 543 31 . . . 31504 544 1 We -PRON- PRP 31504 544 2 all all DT 31504 544 3 desire desire VBP 31504 544 4 normally normally RB 31504 544 5 , , , 31504 544 6 not not RB 31504 544 7 only only RB 31504 544 8 order order NN 31504 544 9 and and CC 31504 544 10 peace peace NN 31504 544 11 , , , 31504 544 12 but but CC 31504 544 13 also also RB 31504 544 14 personal personal JJ 31504 544 15 liberty liberty NN 31504 544 16 and and CC 31504 544 17 equality equality NN 31504 544 18 of of IN 31504 544 19 rights right NNS 31504 544 20 . . . 31504 545 1 The the DT 31504 545 2 problem problem NN 31504 545 3 , , , 31504 545 4 then then RB 31504 545 5 , , , 31504 545 6 is be VBZ 31504 545 7 how how WRB 31504 545 8 to to TO 31504 545 9 order order VB 31504 545 10 the the DT 31504 545 11 frame frame NN 31504 545 12 of of IN 31504 545 13 government government NN 31504 545 14 so so IN 31504 545 15 that that IN 31504 545 16 it -PRON- PRP 31504 545 17 shall shall MD 31504 545 18 be be VB 31504 545 19 strong strong JJ 31504 545 20 enough enough RB 31504 545 21 to to TO 31504 545 22 protect protect VB 31504 545 23 us -PRON- PRP 31504 545 24 individually individually RB 31504 545 25 as as RB 31504 545 26 well well RB 31504 545 27 as as IN 31504 545 28 collectively collectively RB 31504 545 29 , , , 31504 545 30 but but CC 31504 545 31 not not RB 31504 545 32 left leave VBD 31504 545 33 able able JJ 31504 545 34 to to TO 31504 545 35 oppress oppress VB 31504 545 36 us -PRON- PRP 31504 545 37 or or CC 31504 545 38 any any DT 31504 545 39 of of IN 31504 545 40 us -PRON- PRP 31504 545 41 . . . 31504 546 1 As as IN 31504 546 2 said say VBN 31504 546 3 by by IN 31504 546 4 Alexander Alexander NNP 31504 546 5 Hamilton Hamilton NNP 31504 546 6 , , , 31504 546 7 we -PRON- PRP 31504 546 8 " " `` 31504 546 9 must must MD 31504 546 10 first first RB 31504 546 11 enable enable VB 31504 546 12 the the DT 31504 546 13 government government NN 31504 546 14 to to TO 31504 546 15 control control VB 31504 546 16 the the DT 31504 546 17 governed governed JJ 31504 546 18 , , , 31504 546 19 and and CC 31504 546 20 in in IN 31504 546 21 the the DT 31504 546 22 next next JJ 31504 546 23 place place NN 31504 546 24 oblige oblige NN 31504 546 25 it -PRON- PRP 31504 546 26 to to TO 31504 546 27 control control VB 31504 546 28 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 546 29 . . . 31504 546 30 " " '' 31504 547 1 One one CD 31504 547 2 great great JJ 31504 547 3 step step NN 31504 547 4 toward toward IN 31504 547 5 such such PDT 31504 547 6 a a DT 31504 547 7 form form NN 31504 547 8 of of IN 31504 547 9 government government NN 31504 547 10 was be VBD 31504 547 11 made make VBN 31504 547 12 in in IN 31504 547 13 the the DT 31504 547 14 establishment establishment NN 31504 547 15 of of IN 31504 547 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 547 17 federal federal JJ 31504 547 18 and and CC 31504 547 19 state state NN 31504 547 20 governments government NNS 31504 547 21 by by IN 31504 547 22 giving give VBG 31504 547 23 effect effect NN 31504 547 24 to to IN 31504 547 25 the the DT 31504 547 26 theory theory NN 31504 547 27 of of IN 31504 547 28 the the DT 31504 547 29 tripartite tripartite JJ 31504 547 30 nature nature NN 31504 547 31 of of IN 31504 547 32 governmental governmental JJ 31504 547 33 powers power NNS 31504 547 34 , , , 31504 547 35 entrusting entrust VBG 31504 547 36 each each DT 31504 547 37 of of IN 31504 547 38 the the DT 31504 547 39 three three CD 31504 547 40 to to IN 31504 547 41 a a DT 31504 547 42 different different JJ 31504 547 43 person person NN 31504 547 44 or or CC 31504 547 45 group group NN 31504 547 46 of of IN 31504 547 47 persons person NNS 31504 547 48 , , , 31504 547 49 or or CC 31504 547 50 , , , 31504 547 51 in in IN 31504 547 52 other other JJ 31504 547 53 words word NNS 31504 547 54 , , , 31504 547 55 to to IN 31504 547 56 a a DT 31504 547 57 different different JJ 31504 547 58 department department NN 31504 547 59 , , , 31504 547 60 each each DT 31504 547 61 restraining restrain VBG 31504 547 62 the the DT 31504 547 63 other other JJ 31504 547 64 departments department NNS 31504 547 65 from from IN 31504 547 66 exceeding exceed VBG 31504 547 67 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 547 68 defined define VBN 31504 547 69 powers power NNS 31504 547 70 , , , 31504 547 71 so so IN 31504 547 72 that that IN 31504 547 73 the the DT 31504 547 74 government government NN 31504 547 75 , , , 31504 547 76 however however RB 31504 547 77 democratic democratic JJ 31504 547 78 , , , 31504 547 79 shall shall MD 31504 547 80 not not RB 31504 547 81 run run VB 31504 547 82 wild wild JJ 31504 547 83 . . . 31504 548 1 At at IN 31504 548 2 this this DT 31504 548 3 day day NN 31504 548 4 , , , 31504 548 5 however however RB 31504 548 6 , , , 31504 548 7 even even RB 31504 548 8 this this DT 31504 548 9 feature feature NN 31504 548 10 of of IN 31504 548 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 548 12 form form NN 31504 548 13 of of IN 31504 548 14 government government NN 31504 548 15 is be VBZ 31504 548 16 assailed assail VBN 31504 548 17 as as IN 31504 548 18 hampering hamper VBG 31504 548 19 the the DT 31504 548 20 people people NNS 31504 548 21 and and CC 31504 548 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 548 23 government government NN 31504 548 24 and and CC 31504 548 25 greatly greatly RB 31504 548 26 delaying delay VBG 31504 548 27 desired desire VBN 31504 548 28 reforms reform NNS 31504 548 29 . . . 31504 549 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 549 2 may may MD 31504 549 3 be be VB 31504 549 4 admitted admit VBN 31504 549 5 that that IN 31504 549 6 a a DT 31504 549 7 government government NN 31504 549 8 with with IN 31504 549 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 549 10 powers power NNS 31504 549 11 thus thus RB 31504 549 12 separated separate VBD 31504 549 13 in in IN 31504 549 14 different different JJ 31504 549 15 departments department NNS 31504 549 16 is be VBZ 31504 549 17 not not RB 31504 549 18 able able JJ 31504 549 19 to to TO 31504 549 20 act act VB 31504 549 21 as as RB 31504 549 22 quickly quickly RB 31504 549 23 as as IN 31504 549 24 desired desire VBN 31504 549 25 by by IN 31504 549 26 zealous zealous JJ 31504 549 27 persons person NNS 31504 549 28 confident confident JJ 31504 549 29 of of IN 31504 549 30 the the DT 31504 549 31 excellence excellence NN 31504 549 32 of of IN 31504 549 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 549 34 schemes scheme NNS 31504 549 35 and and CC 31504 549 36 impatient impatient VB 31504 549 37 for for IN 31504 549 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 549 39 realization realization NN 31504 549 40 , , , 31504 549 41 but but CC 31504 549 42 , , , 31504 549 43 on on IN 31504 549 44 the the DT 31504 549 45 other other JJ 31504 549 46 hand hand NN 31504 549 47 , , , 31504 549 48 it -PRON- PRP 31504 549 49 is be VBZ 31504 549 50 less less RBR 31504 549 51 liable liable JJ 31504 549 52 to to TO 31504 549 53 act act VB 31504 549 54 too too RB 31504 549 55 hastily hastily RB 31504 549 56 , , , 31504 549 57 less less RBR 31504 549 58 liable liable JJ 31504 549 59 to to TO 31504 549 60 act act VB 31504 549 61 arbitrarily arbitrarily RB 31504 549 62 , , , 31504 549 63 or or CC 31504 549 64 to to TO 31504 549 65 disregard disregard VB 31504 549 66 individual individual JJ 31504 549 67 rights right NNS 31504 549 68 and and CC 31504 549 69 interests interest NNS 31504 549 70 . . . 31504 550 1 The the DT 31504 550 2 idea idea NN 31504 550 3 of of IN 31504 550 4 a a DT 31504 550 5 division division NN 31504 550 6 of of IN 31504 550 7 governmental governmental JJ 31504 550 8 powers power NNS 31504 550 9 is be VBZ 31504 550 10 not not RB 31504 550 11 of of IN 31504 550 12 recent recent JJ 31504 550 13 origin origin NN 31504 550 14 . . . 31504 551 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 31504 551 2 argued argue VBD 31504 551 3 that that IN 31504 551 4 the the DT 31504 551 5 judges judge NNS 31504 551 6 should should MD 31504 551 7 have have VB 31504 551 8 no no DT 31504 551 9 other other JJ 31504 551 10 political political JJ 31504 551 11 power power NN 31504 551 12 , , , 31504 551 13 should should MD 31504 551 14 not not RB 31504 551 15 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 551 16 enforce enforce VB 31504 551 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 551 18 decisions decision NNS 31504 551 19 . . . 31504 552 1 In in IN 31504 552 2 Rome Rome NNP 31504 552 3 under under IN 31504 552 4 the the DT 31504 552 5 Republic Republic NNP 31504 552 6 there there EX 31504 552 7 was be VBD 31504 552 8 divided divide VBN 31504 552 9 between between IN 31504 552 10 the the DT 31504 552 11 pretor pretor NN 31504 552 12 and and CC 31504 552 13 the the DT 31504 552 14 judex judex NN 31504 552 15 the the DT 31504 552 16 power power NN 31504 552 17 to to TO 31504 552 18 decide decide VB 31504 552 19 controversies controversy NNS 31504 552 20 . . . 31504 553 1 The the DT 31504 553 2 pretor pretor NN 31504 553 3 had have VBD 31504 553 4 other other JJ 31504 553 5 duties duty NNS 31504 553 6 , , , 31504 553 7 but but CC 31504 553 8 the the DT 31504 553 9 judex judex NN 31504 553 10 was be VBD 31504 553 11 confined confine VBN 31504 553 12 to to IN 31504 553 13 the the DT 31504 553 14 single single JJ 31504 553 15 duty duty NN 31504 553 16 to to TO 31504 553 17 hear hear VB 31504 553 18 and and CC 31504 553 19 determine determine VB 31504 553 20 . . . 31504 554 1 The the DT 31504 554 2 framers framer NNS 31504 554 3 of of IN 31504 554 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 554 5 Federal Federal NNP 31504 554 6 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 554 7 and and CC 31504 554 8 of of IN 31504 554 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 554 10 early early JJ 31504 554 11 state state NN 31504 554 12 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 554 13 did do VBD 31504 554 14 not not RB 31504 554 15 act act VB 31504 554 16 hastily hastily RB 31504 554 17 nor nor CC 31504 554 18 unadvisedly unadvisedly RB 31504 554 19 . . . 31504 555 1 As as IN 31504 555 2 heretofore heretofore RB 31504 555 3 stated state VBN 31504 555 4 , , , 31504 555 5 the the DT 31504 555 6 long long JJ 31504 555 7 controversy controversy NN 31504 555 8 with with IN 31504 555 9 Great Great NNP 31504 555 10 Britain Britain NNP 31504 555 11 over over IN 31504 555 12 the the DT 31504 555 13 relations relation NNS 31504 555 14 between between IN 31504 555 15 that that DT 31504 555 16 country country NN 31504 555 17 and and CC 31504 555 18 her -PRON- PRP$ 31504 555 19 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 555 20 , , , 31504 555 21 the the DT 31504 555 22 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 31504 555 23 acts act NNS 31504 555 24 of of IN 31504 555 25 the the DT 31504 555 26 British british JJ 31504 555 27 King King NNP 31504 555 28 and and CC 31504 555 29 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 555 30 , , , 31504 555 31 caused cause VBN 31504 555 32 in in IN 31504 555 33 the the DT 31504 555 34 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 555 35 a a DT 31504 555 36 profound profound JJ 31504 555 37 study study NN 31504 555 38 of of IN 31504 555 39 the the DT 31504 555 40 nature nature NN 31504 555 41 of of IN 31504 555 42 government government NN 31504 555 43 : : : 31504 555 44 what what WP 31504 555 45 should should MD 31504 555 46 be be VB 31504 555 47 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 555 48 purposes purpose NNS 31504 555 49 and and CC 31504 555 50 how how WRB 31504 555 51 best well RBS 31504 555 52 to to TO 31504 555 53 effect effect VB 31504 555 54 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 555 55 purposes purpose NNS 31504 555 56 and and CC 31504 555 57 avoid avoid VB 31504 555 58 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 555 59 abuses abuse NNS 31504 555 60 . . . 31504 556 1 The the DT 31504 556 2 principal principal JJ 31504 556 3 men man NNS 31504 556 4 among among IN 31504 556 5 them -PRON- PRP 31504 556 6 in in IN 31504 556 7 each each DT 31504 556 8 Colony Colony NNP 31504 556 9 were be VBD 31504 556 10 familiar familiar JJ 31504 556 11 with with IN 31504 556 12 the the DT 31504 556 13 history history NN 31504 556 14 of of IN 31504 556 15 governments government NNS 31504 556 16 and and CC 31504 556 17 with with IN 31504 556 18 the the DT 31504 556 19 theories theory NNS 31504 556 20 of of IN 31504 556 21 government government NN 31504 556 22 advanced advance VBN 31504 556 23 by by IN 31504 556 24 European european JJ 31504 556 25 lawyers lawyer NNS 31504 556 26 and and CC 31504 556 27 political political JJ 31504 556 28 philosophers philosopher NNS 31504 556 29 . . . 31504 557 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 557 2 were be VBD 31504 557 3 acquainted acquaint VBN 31504 557 4 with with IN 31504 557 5 the the DT 31504 557 6 arguments argument NNS 31504 557 7 of of IN 31504 557 8 Montesquieu Montesquieu NNP 31504 557 9 and and CC 31504 557 10 others other NNS 31504 557 11 that that IN 31504 557 12 a a DT 31504 557 13 separation separation NN 31504 557 14 of of IN 31504 557 15 the the DT 31504 557 16 powers power NNS 31504 557 17 of of IN 31504 557 18 government government NN 31504 557 19 and and CC 31504 557 20 the the DT 31504 557 21 vesting vesting NN 31504 557 22 of of IN 31504 557 23 each each DT 31504 557 24 , , , 31504 557 25 the the DT 31504 557 26 executive executive JJ 31504 557 27 , , , 31504 557 28 legislative legislative JJ 31504 557 29 , , , 31504 557 30 and and CC 31504 557 31 judicial judicial JJ 31504 557 32 , , , 31504 557 33 in in IN 31504 557 34 different different JJ 31504 557 35 hands hand NNS 31504 557 36 was be VBD 31504 557 37 essential essential JJ 31504 557 38 to to IN 31504 557 39 liberty liberty NN 31504 557 40 . . . 31504 558 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 558 2 did do VBD 31504 558 3 not not RB 31504 558 4 merely merely RB 31504 558 5 theorize theorize VB 31504 558 6 , , , 31504 558 7 however however RB 31504 558 8 . . . 31504 559 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 559 2 had have VBD 31504 559 3 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 559 4 lived live VBN 31504 559 5 and and CC 31504 559 6 labored labor VBN 31504 559 7 under under IN 31504 559 8 governments government NNS 31504 559 9 not not RB 31504 559 10 thus thus RB 31504 559 11 divided divide VBN 31504 559 12 in in IN 31504 559 13 functions function NNS 31504 559 14 or or CC 31504 559 15 only only RB 31504 559 16 partially partially RB 31504 559 17 so so RB 31504 559 18 . . . 31504 560 1 Colonial colonial JJ 31504 560 2 governors governor NNS 31504 560 3 had have VBD 31504 560 4 assumed assume VBN 31504 560 5 legislative legislative JJ 31504 560 6 functions function NNS 31504 560 7 in in IN 31504 560 8 the the DT 31504 560 9 promulgation promulgation NN 31504 560 10 of of IN 31504 560 11 ordinances ordinance NNS 31504 560 12 , , , 31504 560 13 and and CC 31504 560 14 also also RB 31504 560 15 judicial judicial JJ 31504 560 16 functions function NNS 31504 560 17 as as IN 31504 560 18 judges judge NNS 31504 560 19 of of IN 31504 560 20 probate probate NN 31504 560 21 and and CC 31504 560 22 in in IN 31504 560 23 other other JJ 31504 560 24 ways way NNS 31504 560 25 . . . 31504 561 1 The the DT 31504 561 2 colonial colonial JJ 31504 561 3 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 561 4 did do VBD 31504 561 5 not not RB 31504 561 6 hesitate hesitate VB 31504 561 7 to to TO 31504 561 8 dictate dictate VB 31504 561 9 to to IN 31504 561 10 the the DT 31504 561 11 courts court NNS 31504 561 12 in in IN 31504 561 13 particular particular JJ 31504 561 14 cases case NNS 31504 561 15 and and CC 31504 561 16 often often RB 31504 561 17 acted act VBD 31504 561 18 as as IN 31504 561 19 a a DT 31504 561 20 court court NN 31504 561 21 of of IN 31504 561 22 appeal appeal NN 31504 561 23 . . . 31504 562 1 In in IN 31504 562 2 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 562 3 Bay Bay NNP 31504 562 4 the the DT 31504 562 5 legislature legislature NN 31504 562 6 came come VBD 31504 562 7 to to TO 31504 562 8 be be VB 31504 562 9 known know VBN 31504 562 10 as as IN 31504 562 11 the the DT 31504 562 12 General General NNP 31504 562 13 Court Court NNP 31504 562 14 and and CC 31504 562 15 exercised exercise VBD 31504 562 16 judicial judicial JJ 31504 562 17 power power NN 31504 562 18 freely freely RB 31504 562 19 , , , 31504 562 20 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 562 21 calling call VBG 31504 562 22 in in RP 31504 562 23 the the DT 31504 562 24 judges judge NNS 31504 562 25 to to TO 31504 562 26 sit sit VB 31504 562 27 with with IN 31504 562 28 them -PRON- PRP 31504 562 29 . . . 31504 563 1 The the DT 31504 563 2 same same JJ 31504 563 3 individual individual NN 31504 563 4 could could MD 31504 563 5 at at IN 31504 563 6 one one CD 31504 563 7 and and CC 31504 563 8 the the DT 31504 563 9 same same JJ 31504 563 10 time time NN 31504 563 11 fill fill VB 31504 563 12 an an DT 31504 563 13 executive executive NN 31504 563 14 and and CC 31504 563 15 a a DT 31504 563 16 legislative legislative JJ 31504 563 17 or or CC 31504 563 18 judicial judicial JJ 31504 563 19 office office NN 31504 563 20 . . . 31504 564 1 In in IN 31504 564 2 colonial colonial JJ 31504 564 3 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 564 4 William William NNP 31504 564 5 Stoughton Stoughton NNP 31504 564 6 held hold VBD 31504 564 7 the the DT 31504 564 8 offices office NNS 31504 564 9 of of IN 31504 564 10 military military JJ 31504 564 11 commander commander NN 31504 564 12 , , , 31504 564 13 lieutenant lieutenant NN 31504 564 14 governor governor NN 31504 564 15 , , , 31504 564 16 and and CC 31504 564 17 chief chief JJ 31504 564 18 justice justice NN 31504 564 19 at at IN 31504 564 20 the the DT 31504 564 21 same same JJ 31504 564 22 time time NN 31504 564 23 . . . 31504 565 1 Because because IN 31504 565 2 of of IN 31504 565 3 the the DT 31504 565 4 frequent frequent JJ 31504 565 5 and and CC 31504 565 6 prolonged prolonged JJ 31504 565 7 absences absence NNS 31504 565 8 of of IN 31504 565 9 the the DT 31504 565 10 titular titular JJ 31504 565 11 governor governor NN 31504 565 12 he -PRON- PRP 31504 565 13 was be VBD 31504 565 14 often often RB 31504 565 15 the the DT 31504 565 16 acting act VBG 31504 565 17 governor governor NN 31504 565 18 . . . 31504 566 1 As as IN 31504 566 2 an an DT 31504 566 3 inevitable inevitable JJ 31504 566 4 consequence consequence NN 31504 566 5 , , , 31504 566 6 when when WRB 31504 566 7 sitting sit VBG 31504 566 8 as as IN 31504 566 9 a a DT 31504 566 10 judge judge NN 31504 566 11 he -PRON- PRP 31504 566 12 was be VBD 31504 566 13 more more RBR 31504 566 14 a a DT 31504 566 15 zealous zealous JJ 31504 566 16 prosecutor prosecutor NN 31504 566 17 than than IN 31504 566 18 an an DT 31504 566 19 impartial impartial JJ 31504 566 20 judge judge NN 31504 566 21 . . . 31504 567 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 31504 567 2 conduct conduct NN 31504 567 3 in in IN 31504 567 4 the the DT 31504 567 5 witchcraft witchcraft NN 31504 567 6 trials trial NNS 31504 567 7 was be VBD 31504 567 8 comparable comparable JJ 31504 567 9 to to IN 31504 567 10 that that DT 31504 567 11 of of IN 31504 567 12 Jeffreys Jeffreys NNP 31504 567 13 in in IN 31504 567 14 the the DT 31504 567 15 infamous infamous JJ 31504 567 16 " " `` 31504 567 17 Bloody Bloody NNP 31504 567 18 Assizes Assizes NNP 31504 567 19 . . . 31504 567 20 " " '' 31504 568 1 Hutchinson Hutchinson NNP 31504 568 2 was be VBD 31504 568 3 also also RB 31504 568 4 often often RB 31504 568 5 acting act VBG 31504 568 6 governor governor NN 31504 568 7 while while IN 31504 568 8 holding hold VBG 31504 568 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 568 10 commission commission NN 31504 568 11 as as IN 31504 568 12 chief chief JJ 31504 568 13 justice justice NN 31504 568 14 . . . 31504 569 1 In in IN 31504 569 2 view view NN 31504 569 3 of of IN 31504 569 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 569 5 experience experience NN 31504 569 6 and and CC 31504 569 7 deep deep JJ 31504 569 8 study study NN 31504 569 9 , , , 31504 569 10 the the DT 31504 569 11 opinions opinion NNS 31504 569 12 formed form VBN 31504 569 13 by by IN 31504 569 14 the the DT 31504 569 15 framers framer NNS 31504 569 16 of of IN 31504 569 17 the the DT 31504 569 18 early early JJ 31504 569 19 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 569 20 of of IN 31504 569 21 this this DT 31504 569 22 country country NN 31504 569 23 should should MD 31504 569 24 be be VB 31504 569 25 of of IN 31504 569 26 great great JJ 31504 569 27 weight weight NN 31504 569 28 in in IN 31504 569 29 forming form VBG 31504 569 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 569 31 own own JJ 31504 569 32 . . . 31504 570 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 570 2 is be VBZ 31504 570 3 worth worth JJ 31504 570 4 while while IN 31504 570 5 to to TO 31504 570 6 cite cite VB 31504 570 7 the the DT 31504 570 8 opinions opinion NNS 31504 570 9 of of IN 31504 570 10 some some DT 31504 570 11 . . . 31504 571 1 Thomas Thomas NNP 31504 571 2 Jefferson Jefferson NNP 31504 571 3 was be VBD 31504 571 4 not not RB 31504 571 5 in in IN 31504 571 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 571 7 day day NN 31504 571 8 , , , 31504 571 9 nor nor CC 31504 571 10 has have VBZ 31504 571 11 he -PRON- PRP 31504 571 12 been be VBN 31504 571 13 since since RB 31504 571 14 , , , 31504 571 15 regarded regard VBN 31504 571 16 as as IN 31504 571 17 opposed oppose VBN 31504 571 18 to to IN 31504 571 19 popular popular JJ 31504 571 20 government government NN 31504 571 21 . . . 31504 572 1 Virginia Virginia NNP 31504 572 2 had have VBD 31504 572 3 as as RB 31504 572 4 early early RB 31504 572 5 as as IN 31504 572 6 1776 1776 CD 31504 572 7 declared declare VBD 31504 572 8 in in IN 31504 572 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 572 10 first first JJ 31504 572 11 constitution constitution NN 31504 572 12 that that IN 31504 572 13 the the DT 31504 572 14 three three CD 31504 572 15 great great JJ 31504 572 16 departments department NNS 31504 572 17 should should MD 31504 572 18 be be VB 31504 572 19 kept keep VBN 31504 572 20 separate separate JJ 31504 572 21 . . . 31504 573 1 Jefferson Jefferson NNP 31504 573 2 , , , 31504 573 3 who who WP 31504 573 4 besides besides IN 31504 573 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 573 6 other other JJ 31504 573 7 opportunities opportunity NNS 31504 573 8 of of IN 31504 573 9 observing observe VBG 31504 573 10 the the DT 31504 573 11 operation operation NN 31504 573 12 of of IN 31504 573 13 government government NN 31504 573 14 was be VBD 31504 573 15 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 573 16 chief chief JJ 31504 573 17 magistrate magistrate NN 31504 573 18 of of IN 31504 573 19 the the DT 31504 573 20 state state NN 31504 573 21 , , , 31504 573 22 criticized criticize VBD 31504 573 23 that that DT 31504 573 24 constitution constitution NN 31504 573 25 as as IN 31504 573 26 not not RB 31504 573 27 making make VBG 31504 573 28 such such JJ 31504 573 29 separation separation NN 31504 573 30 effectual effectual JJ 31504 573 31 . . . 31504 574 1 In in IN 31504 574 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 574 3 " " `` 31504 574 4 Notes Notes NNP 31504 574 5 on on IN 31504 574 6 Virginia Virginia NNP 31504 574 7 " " '' 31504 574 8 he -PRON- PRP 31504 574 9 wrote write VBD 31504 574 10 of of IN 31504 574 11 it -PRON- PRP 31504 574 12 : : : 31504 574 13 " " `` 31504 574 14 All all PDT 31504 574 15 the the DT 31504 574 16 powers power NNS 31504 574 17 of of IN 31504 574 18 government government NN 31504 574 19 , , , 31504 574 20 legislative legislative JJ 31504 574 21 , , , 31504 574 22 executive executive JJ 31504 574 23 and and CC 31504 574 24 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 574 25 , , , 31504 574 26 result result VB 31504 574 27 to to IN 31504 574 28 the the DT 31504 574 29 legislative legislative JJ 31504 574 30 body body NN 31504 574 31 . . . 31504 575 1 The the DT 31504 575 2 concentrating concentrating NN 31504 575 3 these these DT 31504 575 4 in in IN 31504 575 5 the the DT 31504 575 6 same same JJ 31504 575 7 hands hand NNS 31504 575 8 is be VBZ 31504 575 9 precisely precisely RB 31504 575 10 the the DT 31504 575 11 definition definition NN 31504 575 12 of of IN 31504 575 13 despotic despotic JJ 31504 575 14 government government NN 31504 575 15 . . . 31504 576 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 576 2 will will MD 31504 576 3 be be VB 31504 576 4 no no DT 31504 576 5 alleviation alleviation NN 31504 576 6 that that IN 31504 576 7 these these DT 31504 576 8 powers power NNS 31504 576 9 will will MD 31504 576 10 be be VB 31504 576 11 exercised exercise VBN 31504 576 12 by by IN 31504 576 13 a a DT 31504 576 14 plurality plurality NN 31504 576 15 of of IN 31504 576 16 hands hand NNS 31504 576 17 and and CC 31504 576 18 not not RB 31504 576 19 by by IN 31504 576 20 a a DT 31504 576 21 single single JJ 31504 576 22 one one NN 31504 576 23 . . . 31504 577 1 One one CD 31504 577 2 hundred hundred CD 31504 577 3 and and CC 31504 577 4 seventy seventy CD 31504 577 5 - - HYPH 31504 577 6 three three CD 31504 577 7 despots despot NNS 31504 577 8 would would MD 31504 577 9 surely surely RB 31504 577 10 be be VB 31504 577 11 as as RB 31504 577 12 oppressive oppressive JJ 31504 577 13 as as IN 31504 577 14 one one CD 31504 577 15 . . . 31504 578 1 Let let VB 31504 578 2 those those DT 31504 578 3 who who WP 31504 578 4 doubt doubt VBP 31504 578 5 it -PRON- PRP 31504 578 6 turn turn VBP 31504 578 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 578 8 eyes eye NNS 31504 578 9 on on IN 31504 578 10 the the DT 31504 578 11 republic republic NN 31504 578 12 of of IN 31504 578 13 Venice Venice NNP 31504 578 14 . . . 31504 579 1 As as IN 31504 579 2 little little JJ 31504 579 3 will will MD 31504 579 4 it -PRON- PRP 31504 579 5 avail avail VB 31504 579 6 us -PRON- PRP 31504 579 7 that that IN 31504 579 8 they -PRON- PRP 31504 579 9 are be VBP 31504 579 10 chosen choose VBN 31504 579 11 by by IN 31504 579 12 ourselves -PRON- PRP 31504 579 13 . . . 31504 580 1 An an DT 31504 580 2 elective elective JJ 31504 580 3 despotism despotism NN 31504 580 4 was be VBD 31504 580 5 not not RB 31504 580 6 the the DT 31504 580 7 government government NN 31504 580 8 we -PRON- PRP 31504 580 9 fought fight VBD 31504 580 10 for for IN 31504 580 11 , , , 31504 580 12 but but CC 31504 580 13 one one CD 31504 580 14 which which WDT 31504 580 15 should should MD 31504 580 16 not not RB 31504 580 17 only only RB 31504 580 18 be be VB 31504 580 19 founded found VBN 31504 580 20 on on IN 31504 580 21 free free JJ 31504 580 22 principles principle NNS 31504 580 23 , , , 31504 580 24 but but CC 31504 580 25 in in IN 31504 580 26 which which WDT 31504 580 27 the the DT 31504 580 28 powers power NNS 31504 580 29 of of IN 31504 580 30 government government NN 31504 580 31 should should MD 31504 580 32 be be VB 31504 580 33 so so RB 31504 580 34 divided divided JJ 31504 580 35 and and CC 31504 580 36 balanced balance VBN 31504 580 37 among among IN 31504 580 38 several several JJ 31504 580 39 bodies body NNS 31504 580 40 of of IN 31504 580 41 magistracy magistracy NN 31504 580 42 as as IN 31504 580 43 that that DT 31504 580 44 no no DT 31504 580 45 one one PRP 31504 580 46 could could MD 31504 580 47 transcend transcend VB 31504 580 48 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 580 49 legal legal JJ 31504 580 50 limits limit NNS 31504 580 51 without without IN 31504 580 52 being be VBG 31504 580 53 effectually effectually RB 31504 580 54 checked check VBN 31504 580 55 and and CC 31504 580 56 restrained restrain VBN 31504 580 57 by by IN 31504 580 58 the the DT 31504 580 59 others other NNS 31504 580 60 . . . 31504 581 1 For for IN 31504 581 2 this this DT 31504 581 3 reason reason NN 31504 581 4 the the DT 31504 581 5 convention convention NN 31504 581 6 which which WDT 31504 581 7 passed pass VBD 31504 581 8 the the DT 31504 581 9 ordinance ordinance NN 31504 581 10 of of IN 31504 581 11 government government NN 31504 581 12 laid lay VBD 31504 581 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 581 14 foundation foundation NN 31504 581 15 on on IN 31504 581 16 this this DT 31504 581 17 basis basis NN 31504 581 18 , , , 31504 581 19 that that IN 31504 581 20 the the DT 31504 581 21 legislative legislative JJ 31504 581 22 , , , 31504 581 23 executive executive JJ 31504 581 24 and and CC 31504 581 25 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 581 26 departments department NNS 31504 581 27 should should MD 31504 581 28 be be VB 31504 581 29 separate separate JJ 31504 581 30 and and CC 31504 581 31 distinct distinct JJ 31504 581 32 , , , 31504 581 33 so so IN 31504 581 34 that that IN 31504 581 35 no no DT 31504 581 36 person person NN 31504 581 37 should should MD 31504 581 38 exercise exercise VB 31504 581 39 more more JJR 31504 581 40 than than IN 31504 581 41 one one CD 31504 581 42 of of IN 31504 581 43 them -PRON- PRP 31504 581 44 at at IN 31504 581 45 the the DT 31504 581 46 same same JJ 31504 581 47 time time NN 31504 581 48 . . . 31504 582 1 But but CC 31504 582 2 no no DT 31504 582 3 barrier barrier NN 31504 582 4 was be VBD 31504 582 5 provided provide VBN 31504 582 6 between between IN 31504 582 7 these these DT 31504 582 8 several several JJ 31504 582 9 powers power NNS 31504 582 10 . . . 31504 582 11 " " '' 31504 583 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 583 2 was be VBD 31504 583 3 this this DT 31504 583 4 defect defect NN 31504 583 5 , , , 31504 583 6 this this DT 31504 583 7 lack lack NN 31504 583 8 of of IN 31504 583 9 barriers barrier NNS 31504 583 10 , , , 31504 583 11 that that WDT 31504 583 12 Jefferson Jefferson NNP 31504 583 13 lamented lament VBD 31504 583 14 . . . 31504 584 1 When when WRB 31504 584 2 the the DT 31504 584 3 draft draft NN 31504 584 4 of of IN 31504 584 5 the the DT 31504 584 6 Federal Federal NNP 31504 584 7 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 584 8 of of IN 31504 584 9 1787 1787 CD 31504 584 10 was be VBD 31504 584 11 submitted submit VBN 31504 584 12 to to IN 31504 584 13 the the DT 31504 584 14 states state NNS 31504 584 15 , , , 31504 584 16 one one CD 31504 584 17 of of IN 31504 584 18 the the DT 31504 584 19 principal principal JJ 31504 584 20 objections objection NNS 31504 584 21 urged urge VBD 31504 584 22 against against IN 31504 584 23 it -PRON- PRP 31504 584 24 was be VBD 31504 584 25 that that IN 31504 584 26 in in IN 31504 584 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 584 28 structure structure NN 31504 584 29 sufficient sufficient JJ 31504 584 30 regard regard NN 31504 584 31 was be VBD 31504 584 32 not not RB 31504 584 33 paid pay VBN 31504 584 34 to to IN 31504 584 35 keeping keep VBG 31504 584 36 the the DT 31504 584 37 three three CD 31504 584 38 departments department NNS 31504 584 39 of of IN 31504 584 40 government government NN 31504 584 41 separate separate JJ 31504 584 42 and and CC 31504 584 43 distinct distinct JJ 31504 584 44 . . . 31504 585 1 In in IN 31504 585 2 reference reference NN 31504 585 3 to to IN 31504 585 4 this this DT 31504 585 5 objection objection NN 31504 585 6 Madison Madison NNP 31504 585 7 wrote write VBD 31504 585 8 in in IN 31504 585 9 the the DT 31504 585 10 " " `` 31504 585 11 Federalist Federalist NNP 31504 585 12 " " '' 31504 585 13 : : : 31504 585 14 " " `` 31504 585 15 No no DT 31504 585 16 political political JJ 31504 585 17 truth truth NN 31504 585 18 is be VBZ 31504 585 19 certainly certainly RB 31504 585 20 of of IN 31504 585 21 greater great JJR 31504 585 22 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 31504 585 23 value value NN 31504 585 24 or or CC 31504 585 25 is be VBZ 31504 585 26 stamped stamp VBN 31504 585 27 with with IN 31504 585 28 the the DT 31504 585 29 authority authority NN 31504 585 30 of of IN 31504 585 31 more more RBR 31504 585 32 enlightened enlightened JJ 31504 585 33 patrons patron NNS 31504 585 34 of of IN 31504 585 35 liberty liberty NN 31504 585 36 than than IN 31504 585 37 that that DT 31504 585 38 on on IN 31504 585 39 which which WDT 31504 585 40 this this DT 31504 585 41 objection objection NN 31504 585 42 is be VBZ 31504 585 43 founded found VBN 31504 585 44 . . . 31504 586 1 The the DT 31504 586 2 accumulation accumulation NN 31504 586 3 of of IN 31504 586 4 all all DT 31504 586 5 powers power NNS 31504 586 6 , , , 31504 586 7 legislative legislative JJ 31504 586 8 , , , 31504 586 9 executive executive JJ 31504 586 10 , , , 31504 586 11 and and CC 31504 586 12 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 586 13 , , , 31504 586 14 in in IN 31504 586 15 the the DT 31504 586 16 same same JJ 31504 586 17 hands hand NNS 31504 586 18 , , , 31504 586 19 whether whether IN 31504 586 20 of of IN 31504 586 21 one one CD 31504 586 22 , , , 31504 586 23 few few JJ 31504 586 24 , , , 31504 586 25 or or CC 31504 586 26 many many JJ 31504 586 27 , , , 31504 586 28 and and CC 31504 586 29 whether whether IN 31504 586 30 hereditary hereditary JJ 31504 586 31 , , , 31504 586 32 self self NN 31504 586 33 - - HYPH 31504 586 34 appointed appoint VBN 31504 586 35 , , , 31504 586 36 or or CC 31504 586 37 elective elective JJ 31504 586 38 , , , 31504 586 39 may may MD 31504 586 40 justly justly RB 31504 586 41 be be VB 31504 586 42 pronounced pronounce VBN 31504 586 43 the the DT 31504 586 44 very very JJ 31504 586 45 definition definition NN 31504 586 46 of of IN 31504 586 47 tyranny tyranny NN 31504 586 48 . . . 31504 587 1 Were be VBD 31504 587 2 the the DT 31504 587 3 Federal Federal NNP 31504 587 4 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 587 5 therefore therefore RB 31504 587 6 really really RB 31504 587 7 chargeable chargeable JJ 31504 587 8 with with IN 31504 587 9 this this DT 31504 587 10 accumulation accumulation NN 31504 587 11 of of IN 31504 587 12 powers power NNS 31504 587 13 , , , 31504 587 14 or or CC 31504 587 15 with with IN 31504 587 16 a a DT 31504 587 17 mixture mixture NN 31504 587 18 of of IN 31504 587 19 powers power NNS 31504 587 20 having have VBG 31504 587 21 a a DT 31504 587 22 dangerous dangerous JJ 31504 587 23 tendency tendency NN 31504 587 24 to to IN 31504 587 25 such such PDT 31504 587 26 an an DT 31504 587 27 accumulation accumulation NN 31504 587 28 , , , 31504 587 29 no no DT 31504 587 30 further further JJ 31504 587 31 argument argument NN 31504 587 32 would would MD 31504 587 33 be be VB 31504 587 34 necessary necessary JJ 31504 587 35 to to TO 31504 587 36 inspire inspire VB 31504 587 37 a a DT 31504 587 38 universal universal JJ 31504 587 39 reprobation reprobation NN 31504 587 40 of of IN 31504 587 41 the the DT 31504 587 42 system system NN 31504 587 43 . . . 31504 587 44 " " '' 31504 588 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 588 2 elsewhere elsewhere RB 31504 588 3 declared declare VBD 31504 588 4 the the DT 31504 588 5 maxim maxim NN 31504 588 6 to to TO 31504 588 7 be be VB 31504 588 8 a a DT 31504 588 9 " " `` 31504 588 10 fundamental fundamental JJ 31504 588 11 article article NN 31504 588 12 of of IN 31504 588 13 liberty liberty NN 31504 588 14 . . . 31504 588 15 " " '' 31504 589 1 Hamilton Hamilton NNP 31504 589 2 was be VBD 31504 589 3 apprehensive apprehensive JJ 31504 589 4 of of IN 31504 589 5 danger danger NN 31504 589 6 to to IN 31504 589 7 liberty liberty NN 31504 589 8 from from IN 31504 589 9 the the DT 31504 589 10 legislative legislative JJ 31504 589 11 department department NN 31504 589 12 and and CC 31504 589 13 favored favor VBD 31504 589 14 a a DT 31504 589 15 strong strong JJ 31504 589 16 executive executive NN 31504 589 17 to to TO 31504 589 18 guard guard VB 31504 589 19 against against IN 31504 589 20 it -PRON- PRP 31504 589 21 . . . 31504 590 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 590 2 declared declare VBD 31504 590 3 in in IN 31504 590 4 the the DT 31504 590 5 " " `` 31504 590 6 Federalist Federalist NNP 31504 590 7 " " '' 31504 590 8 that that IN 31504 590 9 the the DT 31504 590 10 legislative legislative JJ 31504 590 11 department department NN 31504 590 12 was be VBD 31504 590 13 " " `` 31504 590 14 everywhere everywhere RB 31504 590 15 extending extend VBG 31504 590 16 the the DT 31504 590 17 sphere sphere NN 31504 590 18 of of IN 31504 590 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 590 20 activity activity NN 31504 590 21 and and CC 31504 590 22 drawing draw VBG 31504 590 23 all all DT 31504 590 24 power power NN 31504 590 25 into into IN 31504 590 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 590 27 impetuous impetuous JJ 31504 590 28 vortex,"--that vortex,"--that IN 31504 590 29 the the DT 31504 590 30 people people NNS 31504 590 31 " " `` 31504 590 32 never never RB 31504 590 33 seem seem VBP 31504 590 34 to to TO 31504 590 35 have have VB 31504 590 36 recollected recollect VBN 31504 590 37 the the DT 31504 590 38 danger danger NN 31504 590 39 from from IN 31504 590 40 legislative legislative JJ 31504 590 41 usurpation usurpation NN 31504 590 42 which which WDT 31504 590 43 by by IN 31504 590 44 assembling assemble VBG 31504 590 45 all all DT 31504 590 46 power power NN 31504 590 47 in in IN 31504 590 48 the the DT 31504 590 49 same same JJ 31504 590 50 hands hand NNS 31504 590 51 must must MD 31504 590 52 lead lead VB 31504 590 53 to to IN 31504 590 54 the the DT 31504 590 55 same same JJ 31504 590 56 tyranny tyranny NN 31504 590 57 as as IN 31504 590 58 is be VBZ 31504 590 59 threatened threaten VBN 31504 590 60 by by IN 31504 590 61 executive executive JJ 31504 590 62 usurpation usurpation NN 31504 590 63 . . . 31504 590 64 " " '' 31504 591 1 Washington Washington NNP 31504 591 2 in in IN 31504 591 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 591 4 Farewell Farewell NNP 31504 591 5 Address Address NNP 31504 591 6 , , , 31504 591 7 after after IN 31504 591 8 much much JJ 31504 591 9 experience experience NN 31504 591 10 with with IN 31504 591 11 , , , 31504 591 12 and and CC 31504 591 13 observation observation NN 31504 591 14 of of IN 31504 591 15 , , , 31504 591 16 legislative legislative JJ 31504 591 17 action action NN 31504 591 18 , , , 31504 591 19 said say VBD 31504 591 20 : : : 31504 591 21 " " `` 31504 591 22 The the DT 31504 591 23 necessity necessity NN 31504 591 24 of of IN 31504 591 25 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 31504 591 26 checks check NNS 31504 591 27 in in IN 31504 591 28 the the DT 31504 591 29 exercise exercise NN 31504 591 30 of of IN 31504 591 31 political political JJ 31504 591 32 power power NN 31504 591 33 by by IN 31504 591 34 dividing divide VBG 31504 591 35 and and CC 31504 591 36 distributing distribute VBG 31504 591 37 it -PRON- PRP 31504 591 38 in in IN 31504 591 39 different different JJ 31504 591 40 depositaries depositary NNS 31504 591 41 and and CC 31504 591 42 constituting constitute VBG 31504 591 43 each each DT 31504 591 44 the the DT 31504 591 45 guardian guardian NN 31504 591 46 of of IN 31504 591 47 the the DT 31504 591 48 public public JJ 31504 591 49 weal weal NN 31504 591 50 against against IN 31504 591 51 invasions invasion NNS 31504 591 52 by by IN 31504 591 53 the the DT 31504 591 54 others other NNS 31504 591 55 has have VBZ 31504 591 56 been be VBN 31504 591 57 evinced evince VBN 31504 591 58 by by IN 31504 591 59 experiments experiment NNS 31504 591 60 ancient ancient JJ 31504 591 61 and and CC 31504 591 62 modern modern JJ 31504 591 63 , , , 31504 591 64 some some DT 31504 591 65 of of IN 31504 591 66 them -PRON- PRP 31504 591 67 in in IN 31504 591 68 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 591 69 own own JJ 31504 591 70 country country NN 31504 591 71 and and CC 31504 591 72 under under IN 31504 591 73 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 591 74 own own JJ 31504 591 75 eyes eye NNS 31504 591 76 . . . 31504 592 1 To to TO 31504 592 2 preserve preserve VB 31504 592 3 them -PRON- PRP 31504 592 4 must must MD 31504 592 5 be be VB 31504 592 6 as as RB 31504 592 7 necessary necessary JJ 31504 592 8 as as IN 31504 592 9 to to TO 31504 592 10 institute institute VB 31504 592 11 them -PRON- PRP 31504 592 12 . . . 31504 592 13 " " '' 31504 593 1 After after IN 31504 593 2 having have VBG 31504 593 3 lived live VBN 31504 593 4 for for IN 31504 593 5 generations generation NNS 31504 593 6 under under IN 31504 593 7 governments government NNS 31504 593 8 in in IN 31504 593 9 which which WDT 31504 593 10 there there EX 31504 593 11 was be VBD 31504 593 12 no no DT 31504 593 13 effective effective JJ 31504 593 14 division division NN 31504 593 15 of of IN 31504 593 16 powers power NNS 31504 593 17 , , , 31504 593 18 the the DT 31504 593 19 people people NNS 31504 593 20 of of IN 31504 593 21 the the DT 31504 593 22 various various JJ 31504 593 23 colonies colony NNS 31504 593 24 in in IN 31504 593 25 setting set VBG 31504 593 26 up up RP 31504 593 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 593 28 own own JJ 31504 593 29 governments government NNS 31504 593 30 at at IN 31504 593 31 the the DT 31504 593 32 time time NN 31504 593 33 of of IN 31504 593 34 the the DT 31504 593 35 Revolution Revolution NNP 31504 593 36 very very RB 31504 593 37 generally generally RB 31504 593 38 declared declare VBN 31504 593 39 for for IN 31504 593 40 such such JJ 31504 593 41 division division NN 31504 593 42 , , , 31504 593 43 in in IN 31504 593 44 more more RBR 31504 593 45 or or CC 31504 593 46 less less JJR 31504 593 47 explicit explicit JJ 31504 593 48 terms term NNS 31504 593 49 . . . 31504 594 1 Even even RB 31504 594 2 in in IN 31504 594 3 the the DT 31504 594 4 few few JJ 31504 594 5 cases case NNS 31504 594 6 where where WRB 31504 594 7 the the DT 31504 594 8 division division NN 31504 594 9 was be VBD 31504 594 10 not not RB 31504 594 11 expressly expressly RB 31504 594 12 made make VBN 31504 594 13 , , , 31504 594 14 it -PRON- PRP 31504 594 15 was be VBD 31504 594 16 implied imply VBN 31504 594 17 in in IN 31504 594 18 the the DT 31504 594 19 constitution constitution NN 31504 594 20 . . . 31504 595 1 The the DT 31504 595 2 provision provision NN 31504 595 3 in in IN 31504 595 4 the the DT 31504 595 5 constitution constitution NN 31504 595 6 of of IN 31504 595 7 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 595 8 adopted adopt VBN 31504 595 9 in in IN 31504 595 10 1780 1780 CD 31504 595 11 may may MD 31504 595 12 be be VB 31504 595 13 cited cite VBN 31504 595 14 as as IN 31504 595 15 an an DT 31504 595 16 example example NN 31504 595 17 of of IN 31504 595 18 the the DT 31504 595 19 strength strength NN 31504 595 20 of of IN 31504 595 21 the the DT 31504 595 22 conviction conviction NN 31504 595 23 . . . 31504 596 1 " " `` 31504 596 2 In in IN 31504 596 3 the the DT 31504 596 4 government government NN 31504 596 5 of of IN 31504 596 6 this this DT 31504 596 7 Commonwealth Commonwealth NNP 31504 596 8 the the DT 31504 596 9 legislative legislative JJ 31504 596 10 department department NN 31504 596 11 shall shall MD 31504 596 12 never never RB 31504 596 13 exercise exercise VB 31504 596 14 the the DT 31504 596 15 executive executive JJ 31504 596 16 and and CC 31504 596 17 judicial judicial JJ 31504 596 18 powers power NNS 31504 596 19 or or CC 31504 596 20 either either DT 31504 596 21 of of IN 31504 596 22 them -PRON- PRP 31504 596 23 ; ; : 31504 596 24 the the DT 31504 596 25 executive executive NN 31504 596 26 shall shall MD 31504 596 27 never never RB 31504 596 28 exercise exercise VB 31504 596 29 the the DT 31504 596 30 legislative legislative JJ 31504 596 31 and and CC 31504 596 32 judicial judicial JJ 31504 596 33 powers power NNS 31504 596 34 or or CC 31504 596 35 either either DT 31504 596 36 of of IN 31504 596 37 them -PRON- PRP 31504 596 38 ; ; : 31504 596 39 the the DT 31504 596 40 judicial judicial JJ 31504 596 41 shall shall MD 31504 596 42 never never RB 31504 596 43 exercise exercise VB 31504 596 44 the the DT 31504 596 45 legislative legislative JJ 31504 596 46 and and CC 31504 596 47 executive executive JJ 31504 596 48 powers power NNS 31504 596 49 or or CC 31504 596 50 either either DT 31504 596 51 of of IN 31504 596 52 them -PRON- PRP 31504 596 53 . . . 31504 596 54 " " '' 31504 597 1 To to IN 31504 597 2 this this DT 31504 597 3 provision provision NN 31504 597 4 were be VBD 31504 597 5 appended append VBN 31504 597 6 , , , 31504 597 7 as as IN 31504 597 8 the the DT 31504 597 9 reason reason NN 31504 597 10 for for IN 31504 597 11 it -PRON- PRP 31504 597 12 , , , 31504 597 13 the the DT 31504 597 14 memorable memorable JJ 31504 597 15 words word NNS 31504 597 16 , , , 31504 597 17 " " `` 31504 597 18 To to IN 31504 597 19 the the DT 31504 597 20 end end NN 31504 597 21 that that WDT 31504 597 22 it -PRON- PRP 31504 597 23 may may MD 31504 597 24 be be VB 31504 597 25 a a DT 31504 597 26 government government NN 31504 597 27 of of IN 31504 597 28 laws law NNS 31504 597 29 and and CC 31504 597 30 not not RB 31504 597 31 of of IN 31504 597 32 men man NNS 31504 597 33 . . . 31504 597 34 " " '' 31504 598 1 From from IN 31504 598 2 1776 1776 CD 31504 598 3 to to IN 31504 598 4 the the DT 31504 598 5 present present JJ 31504 598 6 century century NN 31504 598 7 as as IN 31504 598 8 new new JJ 31504 598 9 states state NNS 31504 598 10 were be VBD 31504 598 11 formed form VBN 31504 598 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 598 13 people people NNS 31504 598 14 in in IN 31504 598 15 most most JJS 31504 598 16 instances instance NNS 31504 598 17 have have VBP 31504 598 18 adopted adopt VBN 31504 598 19 similar similar JJ 31504 598 20 provisions provision NNS 31504 598 21 . . . 31504 599 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 31504 599 2 the the DT 31504 599 3 people people NNS 31504 599 4 of of IN 31504 599 5 Maine Maine NNP 31504 599 6 when when WRB 31504 599 7 they -PRON- PRP 31504 599 8 separated separate VBD 31504 599 9 from from IN 31504 599 10 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 599 11 in in IN 31504 599 12 1820 1820 CD 31504 599 13 adopted adopt VBD 31504 599 14 the the DT 31504 599 15 most most RBS 31504 599 16 stringent stringent JJ 31504 599 17 provision provision NN 31504 599 18 by by IN 31504 599 19 prohibiting prohibit VBG 31504 599 20 not not RB 31504 599 21 only only RB 31504 599 22 the the DT 31504 599 23 departments department NNS 31504 599 24 but but CC 31504 599 25 all all PDT 31504 599 26 the the DT 31504 599 27 persons person NNS 31504 599 28 in in IN 31504 599 29 either either DT 31504 599 30 department department NN 31504 599 31 from from IN 31504 599 32 exercising exercise VBG 31504 599 33 any any DT 31504 599 34 of of IN 31504 599 35 the the DT 31504 599 36 powers power NNS 31504 599 37 properly properly RB 31504 599 38 belonging belong VBG 31504 599 39 to to IN 31504 599 40 either either DT 31504 599 41 of of IN 31504 599 42 the the DT 31504 599 43 other other JJ 31504 599 44 departments department NNS 31504 599 45 . . . 31504 600 1 Of of RB 31504 600 2 course course RB 31504 600 3 some some DT 31504 600 4 exceptions exception NNS 31504 600 5 to to IN 31504 600 6 the the DT 31504 600 7 rule rule NN 31504 600 8 are be VBP 31504 600 9 necessary necessary JJ 31504 600 10 and and CC 31504 600 11 these these DT 31504 600 12 are be VBP 31504 600 13 usually usually RB 31504 600 14 named name VBN 31504 600 15 in in IN 31504 600 16 the the DT 31504 600 17 constitution constitution NN 31504 600 18 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 600 19 . . . 31504 601 1 Again again RB 31504 601 2 the the DT 31504 601 3 dividing divide VBG 31504 601 4 line line NN 31504 601 5 between between IN 31504 601 6 the the DT 31504 601 7 powers power NNS 31504 601 8 can can MD 31504 601 9 not not RB 31504 601 10 always always RB 31504 601 11 be be VB 31504 601 12 precisely precisely RB 31504 601 13 defined define VBN 31504 601 14 and and CC 31504 601 15 , , , 31504 601 16 further far RBR 31504 601 17 , , , 31504 601 18 each each DT 31504 601 19 department department NN 31504 601 20 in in IN 31504 601 21 the the DT 31504 601 22 performance performance NN 31504 601 23 of of IN 31504 601 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 601 25 own own JJ 31504 601 26 proper proper JJ 31504 601 27 functions function NNS 31504 601 28 may may MD 31504 601 29 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 601 30 be be VB 31504 601 31 obliged oblige VBN 31504 601 32 to to TO 31504 601 33 exercise exercise VB 31504 601 34 a a DT 31504 601 35 power power NN 31504 601 36 strictly strictly RB 31504 601 37 pertaining pertain VBG 31504 601 38 to to IN 31504 601 39 another another DT 31504 601 40 department department NN 31504 601 41 . . . 31504 602 1 All all DT 31504 602 2 that that WDT 31504 602 3 the the DT 31504 602 4 maxim maxim NN 31504 602 5 requires require VBZ 31504 602 6 is be VBZ 31504 602 7 that that IN 31504 602 8 the the DT 31504 602 9 three three CD 31504 602 10 powers power NNS 31504 602 11 should should MD 31504 602 12 be be VB 31504 602 13 kept keep VBN 31504 602 14 as as RB 31504 602 15 distinct distinct JJ 31504 602 16 and and CC 31504 602 17 separate separate JJ 31504 602 18 as as IN 31504 602 19 possible possible JJ 31504 602 20 and and CC 31504 602 21 have have VB 31504 602 22 the the DT 31504 602 23 government government NN 31504 602 24 still still RB 31504 602 25 go go VB 31504 602 26 on on RP 31504 602 27 . . . 31504 603 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 603 2 is be VBZ 31504 603 3 true true JJ 31504 603 4 we -PRON- PRP 31504 603 5 should should MD 31504 603 6 not not RB 31504 603 7 fear fear VB 31504 603 8 to to TO 31504 603 9 question question VB 31504 603 10 the the DT 31504 603 11 wisdom wisdom NN 31504 603 12 of of IN 31504 603 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 603 14 fathers father NNS 31504 603 15 , , , 31504 603 16 but but CC 31504 603 17 conclusions conclusion NNS 31504 603 18 they -PRON- PRP 31504 603 19 have have VBP 31504 603 20 arrived arrive VBN 31504 603 21 at at IN 31504 603 22 in in IN 31504 603 23 matters matter NNS 31504 603 24 of of IN 31504 603 25 government government NN 31504 603 26 after after IN 31504 603 27 long long JJ 31504 603 28 study study NN 31504 603 29 , , , 31504 603 30 observation observation NN 31504 603 31 , , , 31504 603 32 and and CC 31504 603 33 actual actual JJ 31504 603 34 experience experience NN 31504 603 35 should should MD 31504 603 36 not not RB 31504 603 37 be be VB 31504 603 38 disregarded disregard VBN 31504 603 39 unless unless IN 31504 603 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 603 41 error error NN 31504 603 42 can can MD 31504 603 43 be be VB 31504 603 44 clearly clearly RB 31504 603 45 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 31504 603 46 . . . 31504 604 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 31504 604 2 VI VI NNP 31504 604 3 THE the DT 31504 604 4 NECESSITY NECESSITY NNP 31504 604 5 OF of IN 31504 604 6 CONSTITUTIONAL constitutional JJ 31504 604 7 LIMITATIONS limitation NNS 31504 604 8 UPON upon IN 31504 604 9 THE the DT 31504 604 10 POWERS power NNS 31504 604 11 OF of IN 31504 604 12 THE the DT 31504 604 13 GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT NNP 31504 604 14 . . . 31504 605 1 BILLS bill NNS 31504 605 2 OF of IN 31504 605 3 RIGHTS right NNS 31504 605 4 It -PRON- PRP 31504 605 5 should should MD 31504 605 6 be be VB 31504 605 7 evident evident JJ 31504 605 8 that that IN 31504 605 9 the the DT 31504 605 10 division division NN 31504 605 11 and and CC 31504 605 12 distribution distribution NN 31504 605 13 of of IN 31504 605 14 governmental governmental JJ 31504 605 15 powers power NNS 31504 605 16 among among IN 31504 605 17 different different JJ 31504 605 18 depositaries depositary NNS 31504 605 19 will will MD 31504 605 20 not not RB 31504 605 21 alone alone RB 31504 605 22 prevent prevent VB 31504 605 23 encroachments encroachment NNS 31504 605 24 by by IN 31504 605 25 the the DT 31504 605 26 governing govern VBG 31504 605 27 power power NN 31504 605 28 upon upon IN 31504 605 29 the the DT 31504 605 30 liberty liberty NN 31504 605 31 of of IN 31504 605 32 the the DT 31504 605 33 subject subject NN 31504 605 34 . . . 31504 606 1 The the DT 31504 606 2 executive executive JJ 31504 606 3 department department NN 31504 606 4 in in IN 31504 606 5 performing perform VBG 31504 606 6 only only JJ 31504 606 7 executive executive JJ 31504 606 8 functions function NNS 31504 606 9 can can MD 31504 606 10 , , , 31504 606 11 in in IN 31504 606 12 the the DT 31504 606 13 absence absence NN 31504 606 14 of of IN 31504 606 15 other other JJ 31504 606 16 checks check NNS 31504 606 17 , , , 31504 606 18 act act VB 31504 606 19 oppressively oppressively RB 31504 606 20 . . . 31504 607 1 The the DT 31504 607 2 legislative legislative JJ 31504 607 3 department department NN 31504 607 4 , , , 31504 607 5 especially especially RB 31504 607 6 , , , 31504 607 7 without without IN 31504 607 8 exceeding exceed VBG 31504 607 9 the the DT 31504 607 10 legislative legislative JJ 31504 607 11 function function NN 31504 607 12 , , , 31504 607 13 can can MD 31504 607 14 in in IN 31504 607 15 many many JJ 31504 607 16 ways way NNS 31504 607 17 and and CC 31504 607 18 in in IN 31504 607 19 excessive excessive JJ 31504 607 20 degrees degree NNS 31504 607 21 oppress oppress VBP 31504 607 22 the the DT 31504 607 23 individual individual NN 31504 607 24 by by IN 31504 607 25 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 31504 607 26 restrictions restriction NNS 31504 607 27 of of IN 31504 607 28 personal personal JJ 31504 607 29 liberty liberty NN 31504 607 30 , , , 31504 607 31 by by IN 31504 607 32 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 31504 607 33 exactions exaction NNS 31504 607 34 , , , 31504 607 35 by by IN 31504 607 36 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 31504 607 37 discriminations discrimination NNS 31504 607 38 . . . 31504 608 1 The the DT 31504 608 2 theory theory NN 31504 608 3 of of IN 31504 608 4 representative representative JJ 31504 608 5 government government NN 31504 608 6 is be VBZ 31504 608 7 that that IN 31504 608 8 the the DT 31504 608 9 legislature legislature NN 31504 608 10 will will MD 31504 608 11 be be VB 31504 608 12 a a DT 31504 608 13 body body NN 31504 608 14 of of IN 31504 608 15 men man NNS 31504 608 16 who who WP 31504 608 17 will will MD 31504 608 18 regard regard VB 31504 608 19 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 608 20 as as IN 31504 608 21 entrusted entrust VBN 31504 608 22 with with IN 31504 608 23 important important JJ 31504 608 24 powers power NNS 31504 608 25 to to TO 31504 608 26 be be VB 31504 608 27 exercised exercise VBN 31504 608 28 deliberately deliberately RB 31504 608 29 and and CC 31504 608 30 wisely wisely RB 31504 608 31 for for IN 31504 608 32 the the DT 31504 608 33 welfare welfare NN 31504 608 34 of of IN 31504 608 35 the the DT 31504 608 36 whole whole JJ 31504 608 37 commonwealth commonwealth NN 31504 608 38 and and CC 31504 608 39 not not RB 31504 608 40 for for IN 31504 608 41 any any DT 31504 608 42 one one CD 31504 608 43 or or CC 31504 608 44 more more JJR 31504 608 45 classes class NNS 31504 608 46 or or CC 31504 608 47 interests,--who interests,--who WP 31504 608 48 will will MD 31504 608 49 regard regard VB 31504 608 50 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 608 51 not not RB 31504 608 52 as as IN 31504 608 53 mere mere JJ 31504 608 54 delegates delegate NNS 31504 608 55 or or CC 31504 608 56 proxies proxy NNS 31504 608 57 , , , 31504 608 58 but but CC 31504 608 59 as as IN 31504 608 60 representatives representative NNS 31504 608 61 , , , 31504 608 62 like like IN 31504 608 63 the the DT 31504 608 64 directors director NNS 31504 608 65 of of IN 31504 608 66 a a DT 31504 608 67 corporation corporation NN 31504 608 68 , , , 31504 608 69 to to TO 31504 608 70 form form VB 31504 608 71 and and CC 31504 608 72 act act VB 31504 608 73 upon upon IN 31504 608 74 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 608 75 own own JJ 31504 608 76 judgment judgment NN 31504 608 77 after after IN 31504 608 78 investigation investigation NN 31504 608 79 and and CC 31504 608 80 reflection reflection NN 31504 608 81 . . . 31504 609 1 Experience experience NN 31504 609 2 has have VBZ 31504 609 3 shown show VBN 31504 609 4 , , , 31504 609 5 however however RB 31504 609 6 , , , 31504 609 7 that that IN 31504 609 8 members member NNS 31504 609 9 of of IN 31504 609 10 the the DT 31504 609 11 legislature legislature NN 31504 609 12 do do VBP 31504 609 13 not not RB 31504 609 14 always always RB 31504 609 15 nor nor CC 31504 609 16 generally generally RB 31504 609 17 act act VB 31504 609 18 upon upon IN 31504 609 19 that that DT 31504 609 20 theory theory NN 31504 609 21 . . . 31504 610 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 610 2 seem seem VBP 31504 610 3 to to TO 31504 610 4 be be VB 31504 610 5 inoculated inoculate VBN 31504 610 6 with with IN 31504 610 7 the the DT 31504 610 8 bacillus bacillus NN 31504 610 9 of of IN 31504 610 10 irrepressible irrepressible JJ 31504 610 11 activity activity NN 31504 610 12 , , , 31504 610 13 the the DT 31504 610 14 desire desire NN 31504 610 15 continually continually RB 31504 610 16 to to TO 31504 610 17 be be VB 31504 610 18 proposing propose VBG 31504 610 19 new new JJ 31504 610 20 laws law NNS 31504 610 21 , , , 31504 610 22 new new JJ 31504 610 23 restrictions restriction NNS 31504 610 24 , , , 31504 610 25 new new JJ 31504 610 26 exactions exaction NNS 31504 610 27 . . . 31504 611 1 If if IN 31504 611 2 the the DT 31504 611 3 laws law NNS 31504 611 4 enacted enact VBN 31504 611 5 prove prove VBP 31504 611 6 difficult difficult JJ 31504 611 7 of of IN 31504 611 8 enforcement enforcement NN 31504 611 9 by by IN 31504 611 10 reason reason NN 31504 611 11 of of IN 31504 611 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 611 13 interference interference NN 31504 611 14 with with IN 31504 611 15 what what WP 31504 611 16 individuals individual NNS 31504 611 17 feel feel VBP 31504 611 18 to to TO 31504 611 19 be be VB 31504 611 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 611 21 rights right NNS 31504 611 22 , , , 31504 611 23 then then RB 31504 611 24 new new JJ 31504 611 25 and and CC 31504 611 26 oppressive oppressive JJ 31504 611 27 methods method NNS 31504 611 28 of of IN 31504 611 29 enforcement enforcement NN 31504 611 30 are be VBP 31504 611 31 devised devise VBN 31504 611 32 , , , 31504 611 33 still still RB 31504 611 34 further further RB 31504 611 35 restricting restrict VBG 31504 611 36 liberty liberty NN 31504 611 37 and and CC 31504 611 38 equality equality NN 31504 611 39 . . . 31504 612 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 612 2 have have VBP 31504 612 3 seen see VBN 31504 612 4 it -PRON- PRP 31504 612 5 stated state VBN 31504 612 6 that that IN 31504 612 7 in in IN 31504 612 8 the the DT 31504 612 9 first first JJ 31504 612 10 ten ten CD 31504 612 11 days day NNS 31504 612 12 of of IN 31504 612 13 the the DT 31504 612 14 session session NN 31504 612 15 of of IN 31504 612 16 the the DT 31504 612 17 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 612 18 legislature legislature NN 31504 612 19 this this DT 31504 612 20 present present JJ 31504 612 21 year year NN 31504 612 22 over over IN 31504 612 23 a a DT 31504 612 24 thousand thousand CD 31504 612 25 laws law NNS 31504 612 26 were be VBD 31504 612 27 proposed propose VBN 31504 612 28 . . . 31504 613 1 Further further RB 31504 613 2 , , , 31504 613 3 the the DT 31504 613 4 members member NNS 31504 613 5 of of IN 31504 613 6 the the DT 31504 613 7 legislature legislature NN 31504 613 8 are be VBP 31504 613 9 beset beset VBN 31504 613 10 by by IN 31504 613 11 constituents constituent NNS 31504 613 12 and and CC 31504 613 13 others other NNS 31504 613 14 to to TO 31504 613 15 favor favor VB 31504 613 16 legislative legislative JJ 31504 613 17 measures measure NNS 31504 613 18 for for IN 31504 613 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 613 20 own own JJ 31504 613 21 special special JJ 31504 613 22 benefit benefit NN 31504 613 23 , , , 31504 613 24 or or CC 31504 613 25 that that DT 31504 613 26 of of IN 31504 613 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 613 28 association association NN 31504 613 29 , , , 31504 613 30 or or CC 31504 613 31 of of IN 31504 613 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 613 33 locality locality NN 31504 613 34 . . . 31504 614 1 One one CD 31504 614 2 result result NN 31504 614 3 is be VBZ 31504 614 4 that that IN 31504 614 5 during during IN 31504 614 6 every every DT 31504 614 7 legislative legislative JJ 31504 614 8 session session NN 31504 614 9 the the DT 31504 614 10 ordinary ordinary JJ 31504 614 11 citizen citizen NN 31504 614 12 is be VBZ 31504 614 13 dreading dread VBG 31504 614 14 oppressive oppressive JJ 31504 614 15 legislation legislation NN 31504 614 16 and and CC 31504 614 17 feels feel VBZ 31504 614 18 relieved relieve VBN 31504 614 19 when when WRB 31504 614 20 the the DT 31504 614 21 session session NN 31504 614 22 is be VBZ 31504 614 23 over over RB 31504 614 24 . . . 31504 615 1 When when WRB 31504 615 2 we -PRON- PRP 31504 615 3 consider consider VBP 31504 615 4 the the DT 31504 615 5 wide wide JJ 31504 615 6 , , , 31504 615 7 almost almost RB 31504 615 8 unlimited unlimited JJ 31504 615 9 range range NN 31504 615 10 of of IN 31504 615 11 the the DT 31504 615 12 legislative legislative JJ 31504 615 13 function function NN 31504 615 14 , , , 31504 615 15 and and CC 31504 615 16 the the DT 31504 615 17 power power NN 31504 615 18 and and CC 31504 615 19 tendency tendency NN 31504 615 20 of of IN 31504 615 21 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 615 22 to to TO 31504 615 23 push push VB 31504 615 24 that that DT 31504 615 25 function function NN 31504 615 26 to to IN 31504 615 27 the the DT 31504 615 28 extreme extreme NN 31504 615 29 , , , 31504 615 30 it -PRON- PRP 31504 615 31 would would MD 31504 615 32 seem seem VB 31504 615 33 that that IN 31504 615 34 some some DT 31504 615 35 check check NN 31504 615 36 should should MD 31504 615 37 be be VB 31504 615 38 put put VBN 31504 615 39 upon upon IN 31504 615 40 the the DT 31504 615 41 legislature legislature NN 31504 615 42 to to TO 31504 615 43 prevent prevent VB 31504 615 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 615 45 enacting enact VBG 31504 615 46 discriminatory discriminatory JJ 31504 615 47 laws law NNS 31504 615 48 or or CC 31504 615 49 otherwise otherwise RB 31504 615 50 depriving deprive VBG 31504 615 51 the the DT 31504 615 52 individual individual NN 31504 615 53 of of IN 31504 615 54 some some DT 31504 615 55 accustomed accustomed JJ 31504 615 56 and and CC 31504 615 57 cherished cherish VBN 31504 615 58 freedom freedom NN 31504 615 59 of of IN 31504 615 60 action action NN 31504 615 61 . . . 31504 616 1 If if IN 31504 616 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 616 3 be be VB 31504 616 4 said say VBN 31504 616 5 that that IN 31504 616 6 public public JJ 31504 616 7 opinion opinion NN 31504 616 8 is be VBZ 31504 616 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 31504 616 10 restraint restraint NN 31504 616 11 , , , 31504 616 12 the the DT 31504 616 13 answer answer NN 31504 616 14 is be VBZ 31504 616 15 that that IN 31504 616 16 in in IN 31504 616 17 a a DT 31504 616 18 democracy democracy NN 31504 616 19 , , , 31504 616 20 or or CC 31504 616 21 in in IN 31504 616 22 a a DT 31504 616 23 republic republic NN 31504 616 24 with with IN 31504 616 25 universal universal JJ 31504 616 26 suffrage suffrage NN 31504 616 27 , , , 31504 616 28 the the DT 31504 616 29 efficient efficient JJ 31504 616 30 public public JJ 31504 616 31 opinion opinion NN 31504 616 32 is be VBZ 31504 616 33 practically practically RB 31504 616 34 that that DT 31504 616 35 of of IN 31504 616 36 the the DT 31504 616 37 majority majority NN 31504 616 38 of of IN 31504 616 39 the the DT 31504 616 40 electorate electorate NN 31504 616 41 , , , 31504 616 42 and and CC 31504 616 43 it -PRON- PRP 31504 616 44 is be VBZ 31504 616 45 an an DT 31504 616 46 acknowledged acknowledged JJ 31504 616 47 truism truism NN 31504 616 48 that that WDT 31504 616 49 the the DT 31504 616 50 unrestrained unrestrained JJ 31504 616 51 majority majority NN 31504 616 52 is be VBZ 31504 616 53 even even RB 31504 616 54 more more RBR 31504 616 55 likely likely JJ 31504 616 56 than than IN 31504 616 57 the the DT 31504 616 58 few few JJ 31504 616 59 to to TO 31504 616 60 be be VB 31504 616 61 oppressive oppressive JJ 31504 616 62 of of IN 31504 616 63 the the DT 31504 616 64 individual individual NN 31504 616 65 . . . 31504 617 1 The the DT 31504 617 2 opinion opinion NN 31504 617 3 of of IN 31504 617 4 the the DT 31504 617 5 many many JJ 31504 617 6 is be VBZ 31504 617 7 more more RBR 31504 617 8 variable variable JJ 31504 617 9 than than IN 31504 617 10 that that DT 31504 617 11 of of IN 31504 617 12 the the DT 31504 617 13 few few JJ 31504 617 14 , , , 31504 617 15 more more RBR 31504 617 16 likely likely JJ 31504 617 17 to to TO 31504 617 18 be be VB 31504 617 19 swayed sway VBN 31504 617 20 by by IN 31504 617 21 sympathy sympathy NN 31504 617 22 , , , 31504 617 23 prejudice prejudice NN 31504 617 24 , , , 31504 617 25 and and CC 31504 617 26 other other JJ 31504 617 27 emotions emotion NNS 31504 617 28 . . . 31504 618 1 Indeed indeed RB 31504 618 2 , , , 31504 618 3 public public JJ 31504 618 4 opinion opinion NN 31504 618 5 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 618 6 induces induce VBZ 31504 618 7 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 618 8 to to TO 31504 618 9 enact enact VB 31504 618 10 laws law NNS 31504 618 11 which which WDT 31504 618 12 they -PRON- PRP 31504 618 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 618 14 feel feel VBP 31504 618 15 to to TO 31504 618 16 be be VB 31504 618 17 unwise unwise JJ 31504 618 18 and and CC 31504 618 19 tyrannical tyrannical JJ 31504 618 20 . . . 31504 619 1 If if IN 31504 619 2 history history NN 31504 619 3 and and CC 31504 619 4 reason reason NN 31504 619 5 show show VBP 31504 619 6 that that IN 31504 619 7 the the DT 31504 619 8 happiness happiness NN 31504 619 9 of of IN 31504 619 10 the the DT 31504 619 11 people people NNS 31504 619 12 as as IN 31504 619 13 a a DT 31504 619 14 whole whole NN 31504 619 15 requires require VBZ 31504 619 16 certain certain JJ 31504 619 17 individual individual JJ 31504 619 18 liberties liberty NNS 31504 619 19 and and CC 31504 619 20 rights right NNS 31504 619 21 to to TO 31504 619 22 be be VB 31504 619 23 left leave VBN 31504 619 24 undisturbed undisturbed JJ 31504 619 25 and and CC 31504 619 26 that that IN 31504 619 27 the the DT 31504 619 28 safety safety NN 31504 619 29 of of IN 31504 619 30 the the DT 31504 619 31 people people NNS 31504 619 32 as as IN 31504 619 33 a a DT 31504 619 34 whole whole NN 31504 619 35 does do VBZ 31504 619 36 not not RB 31504 619 37 require require VB 31504 619 38 the the DT 31504 619 39 contrary contrary NN 31504 619 40 , , , 31504 619 41 then then RB 31504 619 42 in in IN 31504 619 43 order order NN 31504 619 44 to to TO 31504 619 45 secure secure VB 31504 619 46 justice justice NN 31504 619 47 those those DT 31504 619 48 possessing possess VBG 31504 619 49 the the DT 31504 619 50 powers power NNS 31504 619 51 of of IN 31504 619 52 government government NN 31504 619 53 should should MD 31504 619 54 be be VB 31504 619 55 restrained restrain VBN 31504 619 56 from from IN 31504 619 57 any any DT 31504 619 58 acts act NNS 31504 619 59 infringing infringe VBG 31504 619 60 those those DT 31504 619 61 liberties liberty NNS 31504 619 62 and and CC 31504 619 63 rights right NNS 31504 619 64 ; ; : 31504 619 65 for for IN 31504 619 66 , , , 31504 619 67 as as RB 31504 619 68 already already RB 31504 619 69 stated state VBN 31504 619 70 , , , 31504 619 71 justice justice NN 31504 619 72 consists consist VBZ 31504 619 73 in in IN 31504 619 74 the the DT 31504 619 75 equilibrium equilibrium NN 31504 619 76 between between IN 31504 619 77 restrictions restriction NNS 31504 619 78 necessary necessary JJ 31504 619 79 for for IN 31504 619 80 the the DT 31504 619 81 welfare welfare NN 31504 619 82 of of IN 31504 619 83 the the DT 31504 619 84 whole whole JJ 31504 619 85 people people NNS 31504 619 86 without without IN 31504 619 87 discrimination discrimination NN 31504 619 88 , , , 31504 619 89 and and CC 31504 619 90 the the DT 31504 619 91 freedom freedom NN 31504 619 92 of of IN 31504 619 93 the the DT 31504 619 94 individual individual NN 31504 619 95 to to TO 31504 619 96 serve serve VB 31504 619 97 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 619 98 own own JJ 31504 619 99 welfare welfare NN 31504 619 100 . . . 31504 620 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 620 2 think think VBP 31504 620 3 there there EX 31504 620 4 are be VBP 31504 620 5 such such JJ 31504 620 6 liberties liberty NNS 31504 620 7 and and CC 31504 620 8 rights right NNS 31504 620 9 . . . 31504 621 1 The the DT 31504 621 2 subjects subject NNS 31504 621 3 of of IN 31504 621 4 King King NNP 31504 621 5 John John NNP 31504 621 6 in in IN 31504 621 7 the the DT 31504 621 8 13th 13th JJ 31504 621 9 century century NN 31504 621 10 thought think VBD 31504 621 11 so so RB 31504 621 12 and and CC 31504 621 13 compelled compel VBD 31504 621 14 the the DT 31504 621 15 king king NN 31504 621 16 to to TO 31504 621 17 guarantee guarantee VB 31504 621 18 by by IN 31504 621 19 the the DT 31504 621 20 Magna Magna NNPS 31504 621 21 Charta Charta NNP 31504 621 22 that that IN 31504 621 23 certain certain JJ 31504 621 24 specified specify VBN 31504 621 25 rights right NNS 31504 621 26 and and CC 31504 621 27 liberties liberty NNS 31504 621 28 should should MD 31504 621 29 not not RB 31504 621 30 be be VB 31504 621 31 infringed infringe VBN 31504 621 32 . . . 31504 622 1 Again again RB 31504 622 2 , , , 31504 622 3 the the DT 31504 622 4 subjects subject NNS 31504 622 5 of of IN 31504 622 6 Charles Charles NNP 31504 622 7 I -PRON- PRP 31504 622 8 in in IN 31504 622 9 the the DT 31504 622 10 17th 17th JJ 31504 622 11 century century NN 31504 622 12 had have VBD 31504 622 13 a a DT 31504 622 14 similar similar JJ 31504 622 15 conviction conviction NN 31504 622 16 and and CC 31504 622 17 expressed express VBD 31504 622 18 it -PRON- PRP 31504 622 19 in in IN 31504 622 20 the the DT 31504 622 21 Petition Petition NNP 31504 622 22 of of IN 31504 622 23 Right Right NNP 31504 622 24 , , , 31504 622 25 which which WDT 31504 622 26 named name VBD 31504 622 27 some some DT 31504 622 28 liberties liberty NNS 31504 622 29 and and CC 31504 622 30 rights right NNS 31504 622 31 not not RB 31504 622 32 to to TO 31504 622 33 be be VB 31504 622 34 infringed infringe VBN 31504 622 35 . . . 31504 623 1 The the DT 31504 623 2 king king NN 31504 623 3 assented assent VBD 31504 623 4 to to IN 31504 623 5 that that DT 31504 623 6 much much JJ 31504 623 7 limitation limitation NN 31504 623 8 of of IN 31504 623 9 the the DT 31504 623 10 royal royal JJ 31504 623 11 power power NN 31504 623 12 . . . 31504 624 1 In in IN 31504 624 2 the the DT 31504 624 3 same same JJ 31504 624 4 century century NN 31504 624 5 , , , 31504 624 6 upon upon IN 31504 624 7 the the DT 31504 624 8 accession accession NN 31504 624 9 of of IN 31504 624 10 William William NNP 31504 624 11 and and CC 31504 624 12 Mary Mary NNP 31504 624 13 , , , 31504 624 14 a a DT 31504 624 15 Bill Bill NNP 31504 624 16 of of IN 31504 624 17 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 624 18 was be VBD 31504 624 19 framed frame VBN 31504 624 20 and and CC 31504 624 21 enacted enact VBN 31504 624 22 into into IN 31504 624 23 law law NN 31504 624 24 by by IN 31504 624 25 King King NNP 31504 624 26 and and CC 31504 624 27 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 624 28 , , , 31504 624 29 naming name VBG 31504 624 30 liberties liberty NNS 31504 624 31 and and CC 31504 624 32 rights right NNS 31504 624 33 of of IN 31504 624 34 the the DT 31504 624 35 subject subject NN 31504 624 36 which which WDT 31504 624 37 ought ought MD 31504 624 38 not not RB 31504 624 39 to to TO 31504 624 40 be be VB 31504 624 41 abridged abridge VBN 31504 624 42 . . . 31504 625 1 Succeeding succeed VBG 31504 625 2 Kings king NNS 31504 625 3 and and CC 31504 625 4 Parliaments parliament NNS 31504 625 5 seem seem VBP 31504 625 6 to to TO 31504 625 7 have have VB 31504 625 8 respected respect VBN 31504 625 9 the the DT 31504 625 10 provisions provision NNS 31504 625 11 of of IN 31504 625 12 this this DT 31504 625 13 Bill Bill NNP 31504 625 14 of of IN 31504 625 15 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 625 16 in in IN 31504 625 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 625 18 legislation legislation NN 31504 625 19 for for IN 31504 625 20 British british JJ 31504 625 21 subjects subject NNS 31504 625 22 . . . 31504 626 1 Had have VBD 31504 626 2 they -PRON- PRP 31504 626 3 conceded concede VBN 31504 626 4 the the DT 31504 626 5 claim claim NN 31504 626 6 of of IN 31504 626 7 the the DT 31504 626 8 people people NNS 31504 626 9 of of IN 31504 626 10 the the DT 31504 626 11 American American NNP 31504 626 12 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 626 13 that that IN 31504 626 14 they -PRON- PRP 31504 626 15 also also RB 31504 626 16 were be VBD 31504 626 17 protected protect VBN 31504 626 18 by by IN 31504 626 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 626 20 provisions provision NNS 31504 626 21 , , , 31504 626 22 the the DT 31504 626 23 course course NN 31504 626 24 of of IN 31504 626 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 626 26 political political JJ 31504 626 27 history history NN 31504 626 28 might may MD 31504 626 29 have have VB 31504 626 30 been be VBN 31504 626 31 different different JJ 31504 626 32 . . . 31504 627 1 As as IN 31504 627 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 627 3 was be VBD 31504 627 4 , , , 31504 627 5 however however RB 31504 627 6 , , , 31504 627 7 the the DT 31504 627 8 British british JJ 31504 627 9 government government NN 31504 627 10 practically practically RB 31504 627 11 held hold VBD 31504 627 12 that that IN 31504 627 13 neither neither DT 31504 627 14 Magna Magna NNP 31504 627 15 Charta Charta NNP 31504 627 16 , , , 31504 627 17 the the DT 31504 627 18 Petition Petition NNP 31504 627 19 of of IN 31504 627 20 Right Right NNP 31504 627 21 , , , 31504 627 22 nor nor CC 31504 627 23 the the DT 31504 627 24 Bill Bill NNP 31504 627 25 of of IN 31504 627 26 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 627 27 restrained restrain VBD 31504 627 28 it -PRON- PRP 31504 627 29 in in IN 31504 627 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 627 31 dealings dealing NNS 31504 627 32 with with IN 31504 627 33 the the DT 31504 627 34 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 627 35 , , , 31504 627 36 and and CC 31504 627 37 this this DT 31504 627 38 in in IN 31504 627 39 despite despite IN 31504 627 40 of of IN 31504 627 41 the the DT 31504 627 42 protests protest NNS 31504 627 43 of of IN 31504 627 44 some some DT 31504 627 45 of of IN 31504 627 46 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 627 47 most most RBS 31504 627 48 eminent eminent JJ 31504 627 49 statesmen statesman NNS 31504 627 50 . . . 31504 628 1 The the DT 31504 628 2 resolutions resolution NNS 31504 628 3 of of IN 31504 628 4 the the DT 31504 628 5 various various JJ 31504 628 6 Colonial colonial JJ 31504 628 7 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 628 8 and and CC 31504 628 9 the the DT 31504 628 10 formal formal JJ 31504 628 11 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 628 12 of of IN 31504 628 13 Independence Independence NNP 31504 628 14 recite recite VB 31504 628 15 many many JJ 31504 628 16 grievous grievous JJ 31504 628 17 instances instance NNS 31504 628 18 of of IN 31504 628 19 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 31504 628 20 action action NN 31504 628 21 by by IN 31504 628 22 the the DT 31504 628 23 government government NN 31504 628 24 in in IN 31504 628 25 disregard disregard NN 31504 628 26 of of IN 31504 628 27 the the DT 31504 628 28 doctrines doctrine NNS 31504 628 29 of of IN 31504 628 30 those those DT 31504 628 31 charters charter NNS 31504 628 32 . . . 31504 629 1 So so RB 31504 629 2 bitter bitter JJ 31504 629 3 was be VBD 31504 629 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 629 5 experience experience NN 31504 629 6 that that IN 31504 629 7 , , , 31504 629 8 when when WRB 31504 629 9 the the DT 31504 629 10 people people NNS 31504 629 11 of of IN 31504 629 12 the the DT 31504 629 13 various various JJ 31504 629 14 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 629 15 came come VBD 31504 629 16 to to IN 31504 629 17 frame frame NN 31504 629 18 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 629 19 for for IN 31504 629 20 " " `` 31504 629 21 a a DT 31504 629 22 government government NN 31504 629 23 of of IN 31504 629 24 the the DT 31504 629 25 people people NNS 31504 629 26 , , , 31504 629 27 by by IN 31504 629 28 the the DT 31504 629 29 people people NNS 31504 629 30 , , , 31504 629 31 and and CC 31504 629 32 for for IN 31504 629 33 the the DT 31504 629 34 people people NNS 31504 629 35 " " `` 31504 629 36 independent independent JJ 31504 629 37 of of IN 31504 629 38 the the DT 31504 629 39 British british JJ 31504 629 40 crown crown NN 31504 629 41 and and CC 31504 629 42 all all DT 31504 629 43 other other JJ 31504 629 44 external external JJ 31504 629 45 authority authority NN 31504 629 46 , , , 31504 629 47 they -PRON- PRP 31504 629 48 very very RB 31504 629 49 generally generally RB 31504 629 50 insisted insist VBD 31504 629 51 that that IN 31504 629 52 even even RB 31504 629 53 such such PDT 31504 629 54 a a DT 31504 629 55 government government NN 31504 629 56 should should MD 31504 629 57 have have VB 31504 629 58 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 629 59 powers power NNS 31504 629 60 defined define VBN 31504 629 61 and and CC 31504 629 62 limited limit VBD 31504 629 63 , , , 31504 629 64 that that IN 31504 629 65 some some DT 31504 629 66 rights right NNS 31504 629 67 of of IN 31504 629 68 the the DT 31504 629 69 individual individual NN 31504 629 70 should should MD 31504 629 71 be be VB 31504 629 72 specified specify VBN 31504 629 73 which which WDT 31504 629 74 the the DT 31504 629 75 government government NN 31504 629 76 should should MD 31504 629 77 not not RB 31504 629 78 infringe infringe VB 31504 629 79 nor nor CC 31504 629 80 have have VB 31504 629 81 the the DT 31504 629 82 lawful lawful JJ 31504 629 83 power power NN 31504 629 84 to to TO 31504 629 85 infringe infringe VB 31504 629 86 . . . 31504 630 1 From from IN 31504 630 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 630 3 own own JJ 31504 630 4 experience experience NN 31504 630 5 the the DT 31504 630 6 people people NNS 31504 630 7 were be VBD 31504 630 8 convinced convince VBN 31504 630 9 that that IN 31504 630 10 such such JJ 31504 630 11 definitions definition NNS 31504 630 12 and and CC 31504 630 13 limitations limitation NNS 31504 630 14 were be VBD 31504 630 15 necessary necessary JJ 31504 630 16 for for IN 31504 630 17 the the DT 31504 630 18 security security NN 31504 630 19 of of IN 31504 630 20 the the DT 31504 630 21 individual individual NN 31504 630 22 even even RB 31504 630 23 under under IN 31504 630 24 a a DT 31504 630 25 popular popular JJ 31504 630 26 government government NN 31504 630 27 . . . 31504 631 1 The the DT 31504 631 2 first first JJ 31504 631 3 step step NN 31504 631 4 of of IN 31504 631 5 the the DT 31504 631 6 representatives representative NNS 31504 631 7 of of IN 31504 631 8 the the DT 31504 631 9 people people NNS 31504 631 10 of of IN 31504 631 11 Virginia Virginia NNP 31504 631 12 toward toward IN 31504 631 13 a a DT 31504 631 14 declaration declaration NN 31504 631 15 of of IN 31504 631 16 independence independence NN 31504 631 17 of of IN 31504 631 18 the the DT 31504 631 19 British british JJ 31504 631 20 crown crown NN 31504 631 21 , , , 31504 631 22 and and CC 31504 631 23 the the DT 31504 631 24 setting setting NN 31504 631 25 up up RP 31504 631 26 an an DT 31504 631 27 independent independent JJ 31504 631 28 government government NN 31504 631 29 , , , 31504 631 30 was be VBD 31504 631 31 the the DT 31504 631 32 adoption adoption NN 31504 631 33 of of IN 31504 631 34 a a DT 31504 631 35 declaration declaration NN 31504 631 36 of of IN 31504 631 37 rights right NNS 31504 631 38 in in IN 31504 631 39 the the DT 31504 631 40 individual individual NN 31504 631 41 which which WDT 31504 631 42 no no DT 31504 631 43 government government NN 31504 631 44 should should MD 31504 631 45 infringe infringe VB 31504 631 46 . . . 31504 632 1 This this DT 31504 632 2 was be VBD 31504 632 3 adopted adopt VBN 31504 632 4 and and CC 31504 632 5 promulgated promulgate VBN 31504 632 6 sometime sometime RB 31504 632 7 before before IN 31504 632 8 the the DT 31504 632 9 constitution constitution NN 31504 632 10 proper proper JJ 31504 632 11 was be VBD 31504 632 12 framed frame VBN 31504 632 13 . . . 31504 633 1 The the DT 31504 633 2 statement statement NN 31504 633 3 was be VBD 31504 633 4 declared declare VBN 31504 633 5 to to TO 31504 633 6 be be VB 31504 633 7 necessary necessary JJ 31504 633 8 in in IN 31504 633 9 order order NN 31504 633 10 that that IN 31504 633 11 the the DT 31504 633 12 government government NN 31504 633 13 might may MD 31504 633 14 be be VB 31504 633 15 " " `` 31504 633 16 effectually effectually RB 31504 633 17 secured secure VBN 31504 633 18 against against IN 31504 633 19 maladministration maladministration NN 31504 633 20 . . . 31504 633 21 " " '' 31504 634 1 Similar similar JJ 31504 634 2 limitations limitation NNS 31504 634 3 upon upon IN 31504 634 4 the the DT 31504 634 5 powers power NNS 31504 634 6 of of IN 31504 634 7 the the DT 31504 634 8 government government NN 31504 634 9 were be VBD 31504 634 10 imposed impose VBN 31504 634 11 in in IN 31504 634 12 the the DT 31504 634 13 early early JJ 31504 634 14 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 634 15 of of IN 31504 634 16 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 634 17 , , , 31504 634 18 New New NNP 31504 634 19 Hampshire Hampshire NNP 31504 634 20 , , , 31504 634 21 New New NNP 31504 634 22 Jersey Jersey NNP 31504 634 23 , , , 31504 634 24 Delaware Delaware NNP 31504 634 25 , , , 31504 634 26 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP 31504 634 27 , , , 31504 634 28 Maryland Maryland NNP 31504 634 29 , , , 31504 634 30 North North NNP 31504 634 31 Carolina Carolina NNP 31504 634 32 , , , 31504 634 33 and and CC 31504 634 34 South South NNP 31504 634 35 Carolina Carolina NNP 31504 634 36 ; ; : 31504 634 37 also also RB 31504 634 38 in in IN 31504 634 39 the the DT 31504 634 40 first first JJ 31504 634 41 constitution constitution NN 31504 634 42 of of IN 31504 634 43 Connecticut Connecticut NNP 31504 634 44 in in IN 31504 634 45 1818 1818 CD 31504 634 46 , , , 31504 634 47 and and CC 31504 634 48 in in IN 31504 634 49 the the DT 31504 634 50 first first JJ 31504 634 51 constitution constitution NN 31504 634 52 of of IN 31504 634 53 Rhode Rhode NNP 31504 634 54 Island Island NNP 31504 634 55 in in IN 31504 634 56 1842 1842 CD 31504 634 57 . . . 31504 635 1 The the DT 31504 635 2 people people NNS 31504 635 3 of of IN 31504 635 4 New New NNP 31504 635 5 Jersey Jersey NNP 31504 635 6 in in IN 31504 635 7 1844 1844 CD 31504 635 8 made make VBD 31504 635 9 the the DT 31504 635 10 limitations limitation NNS 31504 635 11 more more RBR 31504 635 12 definite definite JJ 31504 635 13 , , , 31504 635 14 and and CC 31504 635 15 the the DT 31504 635 16 people people NNS 31504 635 17 of of IN 31504 635 18 Maryland Maryland NNP 31504 635 19 imposed impose VBD 31504 635 20 additional additional JJ 31504 635 21 limitations limitation NNS 31504 635 22 in in IN 31504 635 23 1864 1864 CD 31504 635 24 . . . 31504 636 1 The the DT 31504 636 2 people people NNS 31504 636 3 of of IN 31504 636 4 New New NNP 31504 636 5 York York NNP 31504 636 6 did do VBD 31504 636 7 not not RB 31504 636 8 in in IN 31504 636 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 636 10 first first JJ 31504 636 11 constitution constitution NN 31504 636 12 of of IN 31504 636 13 1777 1777 CD 31504 636 14 expressly expressly RB 31504 636 15 in in IN 31504 636 16 terms term NNS 31504 636 17 guarantee guarantee VBP 31504 636 18 individual individual JJ 31504 636 19 rights right NNS 31504 636 20 , , , 31504 636 21 but but CC 31504 636 22 they -PRON- PRP 31504 636 23 impliedly impliedly RB 31504 636 24 did do VBD 31504 636 25 so so RB 31504 636 26 by by IN 31504 636 27 making make VBG 31504 636 28 the the DT 31504 636 29 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 636 30 of of IN 31504 636 31 Independence Independence NNP 31504 636 32 the the DT 31504 636 33 preamble preamble NN 31504 636 34 , , , 31504 636 35 and and CC 31504 636 36 in in IN 31504 636 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 636 38 constitution constitution NN 31504 636 39 of of IN 31504 636 40 1821 1821 CD 31504 636 41 they -PRON- PRP 31504 636 42 incorporated incorporate VBD 31504 636 43 an an DT 31504 636 44 explicit explicit JJ 31504 636 45 statement statement NN 31504 636 46 of of IN 31504 636 47 individual individual JJ 31504 636 48 rights right NNS 31504 636 49 not not RB 31504 636 50 to to TO 31504 636 51 be be VB 31504 636 52 infringed infringe VBN 31504 636 53 . . . 31504 637 1 The the DT 31504 637 2 example example NN 31504 637 3 of of IN 31504 637 4 the the DT 31504 637 5 original original JJ 31504 637 6 states state NNS 31504 637 7 in in IN 31504 637 8 this this DT 31504 637 9 respect respect NN 31504 637 10 has have VBZ 31504 637 11 been be VBN 31504 637 12 followed follow VBN 31504 637 13 by by IN 31504 637 14 most most JJS 31504 637 15 of of IN 31504 637 16 the the DT 31504 637 17 subsequent subsequent JJ 31504 637 18 states state NNS 31504 637 19 of of IN 31504 637 20 the the DT 31504 637 21 Union Union NNP 31504 637 22 . . . 31504 638 1 In in IN 31504 638 2 1778 1778 CD 31504 638 3 a a DT 31504 638 4 convention convention NN 31504 638 5 chosen choose VBN 31504 638 6 to to TO 31504 638 7 draft draft VB 31504 638 8 a a DT 31504 638 9 constitution constitution NN 31504 638 10 for for IN 31504 638 11 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 638 12 submitted submit VBD 31504 638 13 a a DT 31504 638 14 draft draft NN 31504 638 15 to to IN 31504 638 16 the the DT 31504 638 17 people people NNS 31504 638 18 , , , 31504 638 19 who who WP 31504 638 20 rejected reject VBD 31504 638 21 it -PRON- PRP 31504 638 22 by by IN 31504 638 23 a a DT 31504 638 24 large large JJ 31504 638 25 majority majority NN 31504 638 26 mainly mainly RB 31504 638 27 because because IN 31504 638 28 it -PRON- PRP 31504 638 29 did do VBD 31504 638 30 not not RB 31504 638 31 contain contain VB 31504 638 32 a a DT 31504 638 33 " " `` 31504 638 34 Bill Bill NNP 31504 638 35 of of IN 31504 638 36 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 638 37 . . . 31504 638 38 " " '' 31504 639 1 To to TO 31504 639 2 quote quote VB 31504 639 3 from from IN 31504 639 4 Harry Harry NNP 31504 639 5 A. A. NNP 31504 639 6 Cushing Cushing NNP 31504 639 7 , , , 31504 639 8 a a DT 31504 639 9 writer writer NN 31504 639 10 on on IN 31504 639 11 the the DT 31504 639 12 History history NN 31504 639 13 of of IN 31504 639 14 Commonwealth Commonwealth NNP 31504 639 15 Government Government NNP 31504 639 16 in in IN 31504 639 17 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 639 18 , , , 31504 639 19 " " `` 31504 639 20 No no DT 31504 639 21 demand demand NN 31504 639 22 was be VBD 31504 639 23 more more RBR 31504 639 24 general general JJ 31504 639 25 than than IN 31504 639 26 that that DT 31504 639 27 for for IN 31504 639 28 a a DT 31504 639 29 Bill Bill NNP 31504 639 30 of of IN 31504 639 31 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 639 32 which which WDT 31504 639 33 should should MD 31504 639 34 embody embody VB 31504 639 35 the the DT 31504 639 36 best good JJS 31504 639 37 results result NNS 31504 639 38 of of IN 31504 639 39 experience experience NN 31504 639 40 . . . 31504 639 41 " " '' 31504 640 1 In in IN 31504 640 2 1780 1780 CD 31504 640 3 a a DT 31504 640 4 second second JJ 31504 640 5 convention convention NN 31504 640 6 submitted submit VBD 31504 640 7 another another DT 31504 640 8 draft draft NN 31504 640 9 of of IN 31504 640 10 a a DT 31504 640 11 constitution constitution NN 31504 640 12 containing contain VBG 31504 640 13 the the DT 31504 640 14 famous famous JJ 31504 640 15 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 640 16 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 640 17 of of IN 31504 640 18 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 640 19 , , , 31504 640 20 and and CC 31504 640 21 this this DT 31504 640 22 the the DT 31504 640 23 people people NNS 31504 640 24 adopted adopt VBN 31504 640 25 by by IN 31504 640 26 a a DT 31504 640 27 majority majority NN 31504 640 28 of of IN 31504 640 29 more more JJR 31504 640 30 than than IN 31504 640 31 two two CD 31504 640 32 to to IN 31504 640 33 one one CD 31504 640 34 . . . 31504 641 1 The the DT 31504 641 2 only only JJ 31504 641 3 objection objection NN 31504 641 4 urged urge VBD 31504 641 5 against against IN 31504 641 6 the the DT 31504 641 7 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 641 8 of of IN 31504 641 9 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 641 10 was be VBD 31504 641 11 that that IN 31504 641 12 it -PRON- PRP 31504 641 13 did do VBD 31504 641 14 not not RB 31504 641 15 go go VB 31504 641 16 far far RB 31504 641 17 enough enough RB 31504 641 18 . . . 31504 642 1 In in IN 31504 642 2 the the DT 31504 642 3 convention convention NN 31504 642 4 that that WDT 31504 642 5 drafted draft VBD 31504 642 6 the the DT 31504 642 7 Federal Federal NNP 31504 642 8 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 642 9 it -PRON- PRP 31504 642 10 was be VBD 31504 642 11 strongly strongly RB 31504 642 12 urged urge VBN 31504 642 13 that that IN 31504 642 14 a a DT 31504 642 15 Bill Bill NNP 31504 642 16 of of IN 31504 642 17 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 642 18 should should MD 31504 642 19 be be VB 31504 642 20 incorporated incorporate VBN 31504 642 21 in in IN 31504 642 22 the the DT 31504 642 23 draft draft NN 31504 642 24 , , , 31504 642 25 but but CC 31504 642 26 it -PRON- PRP 31504 642 27 was be VBD 31504 642 28 deemed deem VBN 31504 642 29 , , , 31504 642 30 by by IN 31504 642 31 the the DT 31504 642 32 majority majority NN 31504 642 33 at at IN 31504 642 34 least least JJS 31504 642 35 , , , 31504 642 36 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 31504 642 37 and and CC 31504 642 38 even even RB 31504 642 39 dangerous dangerous JJ 31504 642 40 to to TO 31504 642 41 make make VB 31504 642 42 a a DT 31504 642 43 specific specific JJ 31504 642 44 declaration declaration NN 31504 642 45 of of IN 31504 642 46 individual individual JJ 31504 642 47 rights right NNS 31504 642 48 , , , 31504 642 49 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 31504 642 50 as as IN 31504 642 51 the the DT 31504 642 52 federal federal JJ 31504 642 53 government government NN 31504 642 54 contemplated contemplate VBD 31504 642 55 was be VBD 31504 642 56 in in IN 31504 642 57 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 642 58 very very JJ 31504 642 59 nature nature NN 31504 642 60 limited limit VBN 31504 642 61 to to IN 31504 642 62 such such JJ 31504 642 63 powers power NNS 31504 642 64 as as IN 31504 642 65 were be VBD 31504 642 66 expressly expressly RB 31504 642 67 , , , 31504 642 68 or or CC 31504 642 69 by by IN 31504 642 70 necessary necessary JJ 31504 642 71 implication implication NN 31504 642 72 , , , 31504 642 73 conferred confer VBN 31504 642 74 by by IN 31504 642 75 the the DT 31504 642 76 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 642 77 , , , 31504 642 78 and and CC 31504 642 79 hence hence RB 31504 642 80 to to TO 31504 642 81 specify specify VB 31504 642 82 certain certain JJ 31504 642 83 things thing NNS 31504 642 84 the the DT 31504 642 85 government government NN 31504 642 86 should should MD 31504 642 87 not not RB 31504 642 88 do do VB 31504 642 89 might may MD 31504 642 90 be be VB 31504 642 91 construed construe VBN 31504 642 92 as as IN 31504 642 93 permitting permit VBG 31504 642 94 it -PRON- PRP 31504 642 95 to to TO 31504 642 96 do do VB 31504 642 97 anything anything NN 31504 642 98 not not RB 31504 642 99 so so RB 31504 642 100 specified specified JJ 31504 642 101 . . . 31504 643 1 This this DT 31504 643 2 argument argument NN 31504 643 3 prevailed prevail VBD 31504 643 4 and and CC 31504 643 5 the the DT 31504 643 6 draft draft NN 31504 643 7 submitted submit VBN 31504 643 8 to to IN 31504 643 9 the the DT 31504 643 10 states state NNS 31504 643 11 contained contain VBD 31504 643 12 no no DT 31504 643 13 Bill Bill NNP 31504 643 14 of of IN 31504 643 15 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 643 16 . . . 31504 644 1 Immediately immediately RB 31504 644 2 , , , 31504 644 3 however however RB 31504 644 4 , , , 31504 644 5 a a DT 31504 644 6 storm storm NN 31504 644 7 of of IN 31504 644 8 objections objection NNS 31504 644 9 was be VBD 31504 644 10 raised raise VBN 31504 644 11 against against IN 31504 644 12 it -PRON- PRP 31504 644 13 because because IN 31504 644 14 of of IN 31504 644 15 the the DT 31504 644 16 omission omission NN 31504 644 17 . . . 31504 645 1 Despite despite IN 31504 645 2 the the DT 31504 645 3 arguments argument NNS 31504 645 4 of of IN 31504 645 5 Hamilton Hamilton NNP 31504 645 6 and and CC 31504 645 7 Madison Madison NNP 31504 645 8 that that IN 31504 645 9 a a DT 31504 645 10 Bill Bill NNP 31504 645 11 of of IN 31504 645 12 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 645 13 was be VBD 31504 645 14 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 31504 645 15 , , , 31504 645 16 ratification ratification NN 31504 645 17 was be VBD 31504 645 18 finally finally RB 31504 645 19 obtained obtain VBN 31504 645 20 only only RB 31504 645 21 by by IN 31504 645 22 a a DT 31504 645 23 general general JJ 31504 645 24 assurance assurance NN 31504 645 25 and and CC 31504 645 26 understanding understanding NN 31504 645 27 that that IN 31504 645 28 a a DT 31504 645 29 sufficient sufficient JJ 31504 645 30 Bill Bill NNP 31504 645 31 of of IN 31504 645 32 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 645 33 should should MD 31504 645 34 be be VB 31504 645 35 added add VBN 31504 645 36 immediately immediately RB 31504 645 37 upon upon IN 31504 645 38 the the DT 31504 645 39 organization organization NN 31504 645 40 of of IN 31504 645 41 the the DT 31504 645 42 new new JJ 31504 645 43 government government NN 31504 645 44 . . . 31504 646 1 The the DT 31504 646 2 necessary necessary JJ 31504 646 3 amendments amendment NNS 31504 646 4 , , , 31504 646 5 therefore therefore RB 31504 646 6 , , , 31504 646 7 were be VBD 31504 646 8 submitted submit VBN 31504 646 9 at at IN 31504 646 10 the the DT 31504 646 11 first first JJ 31504 646 12 session session NN 31504 646 13 of of IN 31504 646 14 the the DT 31504 646 15 new new JJ 31504 646 16 Congress Congress NNP 31504 646 17 and and CC 31504 646 18 were be VBD 31504 646 19 unanimously unanimously RB 31504 646 20 adopted adopt VBN 31504 646 21 by by IN 31504 646 22 the the DT 31504 646 23 states state NNS 31504 646 24 . . . 31504 647 1 Other other JJ 31504 647 2 limitations limitation NNS 31504 647 3 have have VBP 31504 647 4 since since IN 31504 647 5 been be VBN 31504 647 6 imposed impose VBN 31504 647 7 , , , 31504 647 8 notably notably RB 31504 647 9 those those DT 31504 647 10 in in IN 31504 647 11 the the DT 31504 647 12 XIVth XIVth NNP 31504 647 13 amendment amendment NN 31504 647 14 , , , 31504 647 15 assuring assure VBG 31504 647 16 to to IN 31504 647 17 every every DT 31504 647 18 citizen citizen NN 31504 647 19 equal equal JJ 31504 647 20 consideration consideration NN 31504 647 21 in in IN 31504 647 22 legislation legislation NN 31504 647 23 by by IN 31504 647 24 the the DT 31504 647 25 states state NNS 31504 647 26 . . . 31504 648 1 By by IN 31504 648 2 the the DT 31504 648 3 Federal Federal NNP 31504 648 4 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 648 5 as as IN 31504 648 6 it -PRON- PRP 31504 648 7 now now RB 31504 648 8 stands stand VBZ 31504 648 9 the the DT 31504 648 10 citizen citizen NN 31504 648 11 , , , 31504 648 12 in in IN 31504 648 13 time time NN 31504 648 14 of of IN 31504 648 15 peace peace NN 31504 648 16 at at IN 31504 648 17 least least JJS 31504 648 18 , , , 31504 648 19 is be VBZ 31504 648 20 guaranteed guarantee VBN 31504 648 21 , , , 31504 648 22 among among IN 31504 648 23 other other JJ 31504 648 24 matters matter NNS 31504 648 25 , , , 31504 648 26 the the DT 31504 648 27 protection protection NN 31504 648 28 of of IN 31504 648 29 the the DT 31504 648 30 writ writ NNP 31504 648 31 of of IN 31504 648 32 habeas habeas NNP 31504 648 33 corpus corpus NNP 31504 648 34 ; ; , 31504 648 35 freedom freedom NN 31504 648 36 from from IN 31504 648 37 bills bill NNS 31504 648 38 of of IN 31504 648 39 attainder attainder NN 31504 648 40 and and CC 31504 648 41 ex ex FW 31504 648 42 post post FW 31504 648 43 facto facto FW 31504 648 44 legislation legislation NN 31504 648 45 ; ; : 31504 648 46 freedom freedom NN 31504 648 47 of of IN 31504 648 48 religious religious JJ 31504 648 49 belief belief NN 31504 648 50 and and CC 31504 648 51 worship worship NN 31504 648 52 ; ; : 31504 648 53 freedom freedom NN 31504 648 54 of of IN 31504 648 55 thought thought NN 31504 648 56 and and CC 31504 648 57 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 648 58 expression expression NN 31504 648 59 ; ; , 31504 648 60 freedom freedom NN 31504 648 61 peacefully peacefully RB 31504 648 62 to to TO 31504 648 63 assemble assemble VB 31504 648 64 with with IN 31504 648 65 others other NNS 31504 648 66 and and CC 31504 648 67 petition petition NN 31504 648 68 for for IN 31504 648 69 redress redress NN 31504 648 70 of of IN 31504 648 71 grievances grievance NNS 31504 648 72 ; ; , 31504 648 73 freedom freedom NN 31504 648 74 from from IN 31504 648 75 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 31504 648 76 searches search NNS 31504 648 77 and and CC 31504 648 78 seizure seizure NN 31504 648 79 ; ; : 31504 648 80 the the DT 31504 648 81 right right NN 31504 648 82 not not RB 31504 648 83 to to TO 31504 648 84 be be VB 31504 648 85 prosecuted prosecute VBN 31504 648 86 for for IN 31504 648 87 infamous infamous JJ 31504 648 88 crimes crime NNS 31504 648 89 except except IN 31504 648 90 first first RB 31504 648 91 accused accuse VBN 31504 648 92 by by IN 31504 648 93 a a DT 31504 648 94 grand grand JJ 31504 648 95 jury jury NN 31504 648 96 ; ; : 31504 648 97 the the DT 31504 648 98 right right NN 31504 648 99 in in IN 31504 648 100 all all DT 31504 648 101 criminal criminal JJ 31504 648 102 prosecutions prosecution NNS 31504 648 103 to to IN 31504 648 104 a a DT 31504 648 105 speedy speedy JJ 31504 648 106 and and CC 31504 648 107 public public JJ 31504 648 108 trial trial NN 31504 648 109 by by IN 31504 648 110 an an DT 31504 648 111 impartial impartial JJ 31504 648 112 jury jury NN 31504 648 113 , , , 31504 648 114 to to TO 31504 648 115 be be VB 31504 648 116 confronted confront VBN 31504 648 117 with with IN 31504 648 118 the the DT 31504 648 119 witnesses witness NNS 31504 648 120 against against IN 31504 648 121 him -PRON- PRP 31504 648 122 and and CC 31504 648 123 to to TO 31504 648 124 have have VB 31504 648 125 assistance assistance NN 31504 648 126 of of IN 31504 648 127 counsel counsel NN 31504 648 128 ; ; : 31504 648 129 that that IN 31504 648 130 he -PRON- PRP 31504 648 131 shall shall MD 31504 648 132 not not RB 31504 648 133 be be VB 31504 648 134 deprived deprive VBN 31504 648 135 of of IN 31504 648 136 life life NN 31504 648 137 , , , 31504 648 138 liberty liberty NN 31504 648 139 , , , 31504 648 140 or or CC 31504 648 141 property property NN 31504 648 142 without without IN 31504 648 143 due due JJ 31504 648 144 process process NN 31504 648 145 of of IN 31504 648 146 law law NN 31504 648 147 ; ; : 31504 648 148 that that IN 31504 648 149 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 648 150 private private JJ 31504 648 151 property property NN 31504 648 152 shall shall MD 31504 648 153 not not RB 31504 648 154 be be VB 31504 648 155 taken take VBN 31504 648 156 from from IN 31504 648 157 him -PRON- PRP 31504 648 158 even even RB 31504 648 159 for for IN 31504 648 160 public public JJ 31504 648 161 use use NN 31504 648 162 without without IN 31504 648 163 just just RB 31504 648 164 compensation compensation NN 31504 648 165 ; ; : 31504 648 166 that that IN 31504 648 167 the the DT 31504 648 168 obligations obligation NNS 31504 648 169 accruing accrue VBG 31504 648 170 to to IN 31504 648 171 him -PRON- PRP 31504 648 172 under under IN 31504 648 173 lawful lawful JJ 31504 648 174 contracts contract NNS 31504 648 175 shall shall MD 31504 648 176 not not RB 31504 648 177 be be VB 31504 648 178 impaired impair VBN 31504 648 179 ; ; : 31504 648 180 that that IN 31504 648 181 he -PRON- PRP 31504 648 182 shall shall MD 31504 648 183 not not RB 31504 648 184 be be VB 31504 648 185 denied deny VBN 31504 648 186 the the DT 31504 648 187 equal equal JJ 31504 648 188 protection protection NN 31504 648 189 of of IN 31504 648 190 the the DT 31504 648 191 laws law NNS 31504 648 192 . . . 31504 649 1 The the DT 31504 649 2 guarantees guarantee NNS 31504 649 3 in in IN 31504 649 4 the the DT 31504 649 5 state state NN 31504 649 6 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 649 7 are be VBP 31504 649 8 generally generally RB 31504 649 9 of of IN 31504 649 10 the the DT 31504 649 11 same same JJ 31504 649 12 nature nature NN 31504 649 13 . . . 31504 650 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 650 2 is be VBZ 31504 650 3 difficult difficult JJ 31504 650 4 to to TO 31504 650 5 see see VB 31504 650 6 how how WRB 31504 650 7 any any DT 31504 650 8 of of IN 31504 650 9 these these DT 31504 650 10 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 650 11 , , , 31504 650 12 or or CC 31504 650 13 such such JJ 31504 650 14 other other JJ 31504 650 15 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 650 16 as as IN 31504 650 17 may may MD 31504 650 18 be be VB 31504 650 19 contained contain VBN 31504 650 20 in in IN 31504 650 21 the the DT 31504 650 22 federal federal JJ 31504 650 23 and and CC 31504 650 24 state state NN 31504 650 25 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 650 26 , , , 31504 650 27 prevent prevent VB 31504 650 28 legislative legislative JJ 31504 650 29 or or CC 31504 650 30 executive executive JJ 31504 650 31 action action NN 31504 650 32 necessary necessary JJ 31504 650 33 for for IN 31504 650 34 the the DT 31504 650 35 welfare welfare NN 31504 650 36 of of IN 31504 650 37 the the DT 31504 650 38 people people NNS 31504 650 39 generally generally RB 31504 650 40 . . . 31504 651 1 There there EX 31504 651 2 is be VBZ 31504 651 3 certainly certainly RB 31504 651 4 an an DT 31504 651 5 ample ample JJ 31504 651 6 field field NN 31504 651 7 for for IN 31504 651 8 such such JJ 31504 651 9 action action NN 31504 651 10 without without IN 31504 651 11 overstepping overstep VBG 31504 651 12 these these DT 31504 651 13 boundaries boundary NNS 31504 651 14 . . . 31504 652 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 31504 652 2 , , , 31504 652 3 it -PRON- PRP 31504 652 4 is be VBZ 31504 652 5 today today NN 31504 652 6 urged urge VBN 31504 652 7 by by IN 31504 652 8 some some DT 31504 652 9 impulsive impulsive JJ 31504 652 10 persons person NNS 31504 652 11 , , , 31504 652 12 eager eager JJ 31504 652 13 to to TO 31504 652 14 impose impose VB 31504 652 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 652 16 theories theory NNS 31504 652 17 on on IN 31504 652 18 the the DT 31504 652 19 people people NNS 31504 652 20 at at IN 31504 652 21 once once RB 31504 652 22 , , , 31504 652 23 that that IN 31504 652 24 all all DT 31504 652 25 or or CC 31504 652 26 many many JJ 31504 652 27 of of IN 31504 652 28 these these DT 31504 652 29 limitations limitation NNS 31504 652 30 upon upon IN 31504 652 31 the the DT 31504 652 32 powers power NNS 31504 652 33 of of IN 31504 652 34 government government NN 31504 652 35 should should MD 31504 652 36 be be VB 31504 652 37 removed remove VBN 31504 652 38 or or CC 31504 652 39 disregarded disregard VBN 31504 652 40 and and CC 31504 652 41 the the DT 31504 652 42 majority majority NN 31504 652 43 of of IN 31504 652 44 the the DT 31504 652 45 people people NNS 31504 652 46 allowed allow VBD 31504 652 47 unrestricted unrestricted JJ 31504 652 48 sway sway NN 31504 652 49 in in IN 31504 652 50 all all DT 31504 652 51 matters matter NNS 31504 652 52 of of IN 31504 652 53 governmental governmental JJ 31504 652 54 action action NN 31504 652 55 . . . 31504 653 1 Others other NNS 31504 653 2 who who WP 31504 653 3 do do VBP 31504 653 4 not not RB 31504 653 5 go go VB 31504 653 6 so so RB 31504 653 7 far far RB 31504 653 8 , , , 31504 653 9 yet yet CC 31504 653 10 urge urge VB 31504 653 11 that that IN 31504 653 12 the the DT 31504 653 13 majority majority NN 31504 653 14 should should MD 31504 653 15 be be VB 31504 653 16 free free JJ 31504 653 17 to to TO 31504 653 18 suspend suspend VB 31504 653 19 these these DT 31504 653 20 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 653 21 temporarily temporarily RB 31504 653 22 or or CC 31504 653 23 in in IN 31504 653 24 some some DT 31504 653 25 particular particular JJ 31504 653 26 classes class NNS 31504 653 27 of of IN 31504 653 28 cases case NNS 31504 653 29 . . . 31504 654 1 Against against IN 31504 654 2 this this DT 31504 654 3 opinion opinion NN 31504 654 4 I -PRON- PRP 31504 654 5 submit submit VBP 31504 654 6 that that IN 31504 654 7 after after IN 31504 654 8 so so RB 31504 654 9 many many JJ 31504 654 10 centuries century NNS 31504 654 11 of of IN 31504 654 12 experience experience NN 31504 654 13 of of IN 31504 654 14 the the DT 31504 654 15 tendency tendency NN 31504 654 16 of of IN 31504 654 17 all all DT 31504 654 18 governments government NNS 31504 654 19 to to TO 31504 654 20 enlarge enlarge VB 31504 654 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 654 22 powers power NNS 31504 654 23 over over IN 31504 654 24 the the DT 31504 654 25 subject subject NN 31504 654 26 , , , 31504 654 27 and and CC 31504 654 28 of of IN 31504 654 29 struggles struggle NNS 31504 654 30 to to TO 31504 654 31 limit limit VB 31504 654 32 the the DT 31504 654 33 powers power NNS 31504 654 34 of of IN 31504 654 35 government government NN 31504 654 36 over over IN 31504 654 37 private private JJ 31504 654 38 rights right NNS 31504 654 39 and and CC 31504 654 40 to to TO 31504 654 41 protect protect VB 31504 654 42 the the DT 31504 654 43 individual individual NN 31504 654 44 from from IN 31504 654 45 governmental governmental JJ 31504 654 46 oppression oppression NN 31504 654 47 , , , 31504 654 48 the the DT 31504 654 49 burden burden NN 31504 654 50 of of IN 31504 654 51 evidence evidence NN 31504 654 52 and and CC 31504 654 53 of of IN 31504 654 54 argument argument NN 31504 654 55 is be VBZ 31504 654 56 heavily heavily RB 31504 654 57 on on IN 31504 654 58 those those DT 31504 654 59 who who WP 31504 654 60 would would MD 31504 654 61 now now RB 31504 654 62 advocate advocate VB 31504 654 63 unlimited unlimited JJ 31504 654 64 powers power NNS 31504 654 65 even even RB 31504 654 66 for for IN 31504 654 67 the the DT 31504 654 68 most most RBS 31504 654 69 democratic democratic JJ 31504 654 70 government government NN 31504 654 71 . . . 31504 655 1 A a DT 31504 655 2 government government NN 31504 655 3 directly directly RB 31504 655 4 by by IN 31504 655 5 the the DT 31504 655 6 people people NNS 31504 655 7 is be VBZ 31504 655 8 of of IN 31504 655 9 course course NN 31504 655 10 in in IN 31504 655 11 practice practice NN 31504 655 12 a a DT 31504 655 13 government government NN 31504 655 14 by by IN 31504 655 15 a a DT 31504 655 16 shifting shifting NN 31504 655 17 and and CC 31504 655 18 often often RB 31504 655 19 narrow narrow JJ 31504 655 20 majority majority NN 31504 655 21 of of IN 31504 655 22 the the DT 31504 655 23 people people NNS 31504 655 24 . . . 31504 656 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 656 2 is be VBZ 31504 656 3 not not RB 31504 656 4 yet yet RB 31504 656 5 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 31504 656 6 by by IN 31504 656 7 experience experience NN 31504 656 8 or or CC 31504 656 9 reason reason NN 31504 656 10 that that IN 31504 656 11 such such PDT 31504 656 12 a a DT 31504 656 13 government government NN 31504 656 14 , , , 31504 656 15 unlimited unlimited JJ 31504 656 16 , , , 31504 656 17 would would MD 31504 656 18 be be VB 31504 656 19 as as RB 31504 656 20 regardful regardful JJ 31504 656 21 of of IN 31504 656 22 individual individual JJ 31504 656 23 rights right NNS 31504 656 24 or or CC 31504 656 25 welfare welfare NN 31504 656 26 as as IN 31504 656 27 a a DT 31504 656 28 republican republican JJ 31504 656 29 form form NN 31504 656 30 of of IN 31504 656 31 government government NN 31504 656 32 with with IN 31504 656 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 656 34 checks check NNS 31504 656 35 and and CC 31504 656 36 balances balance NNS 31504 656 37 and and CC 31504 656 38 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 656 39 restrictions restriction NNS 31504 656 40 . . . 31504 657 1 The the DT 31504 657 2 excesses excess NNS 31504 657 3 of of IN 31504 657 4 the the DT 31504 657 5 unlimited unlimited JJ 31504 657 6 democracies democracy NNS 31504 657 7 of of IN 31504 657 8 ancient ancient JJ 31504 657 9 Greece Greece NNP 31504 657 10 and and CC 31504 657 11 of of IN 31504 657 12 the the DT 31504 657 13 unrestrained unrestrained JJ 31504 657 14 democracy democracy NN 31504 657 15 of of IN 31504 657 16 France France NNP 31504 657 17 during during IN 31504 657 18 and and CC 31504 657 19 after after IN 31504 657 20 the the DT 31504 657 21 revolution revolution NN 31504 657 22 of of IN 31504 657 23 1789 1789 CD 31504 657 24 and and CC 31504 657 25 the the DT 31504 657 26 lynchings lynching NNS 31504 657 27 in in IN 31504 657 28 this this DT 31504 657 29 country country NN 31504 657 30 do do VBP 31504 657 31 not not RB 31504 657 32 contribute contribute VB 31504 657 33 to to IN 31504 657 34 such such JJ 31504 657 35 demonstration demonstration NN 31504 657 36 . . . 31504 658 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 658 2 is be VBZ 31504 658 3 not not RB 31504 658 4 those those DT 31504 658 5 who who WP 31504 658 6 defend defend VBP 31504 658 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 658 8 present present JJ 31504 658 9 form form NN 31504 658 10 of of IN 31504 658 11 government government NN 31504 658 12 with with IN 31504 658 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 658 14 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 658 15 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 658 16 , , , 31504 658 17 who who WP 31504 658 18 resist resist VBP 31504 658 19 political political JJ 31504 658 20 action action NN 31504 658 21 tending tend VBG 31504 658 22 to to TO 31504 658 23 weaken weaken VB 31504 658 24 them -PRON- PRP 31504 658 25 , , , 31504 658 26 that that DT 31504 658 27 should should MD 31504 658 28 be be VB 31504 658 29 called call VBN 31504 658 30 unprogressive unprogressive JJ 31504 658 31 , , , 31504 658 32 undemocratic undemocratic JJ 31504 658 33 , , , 31504 658 34 or or CC 31504 658 35 wanting want VBG 31504 658 36 in in IN 31504 658 37 love love NN 31504 658 38 of of IN 31504 658 39 country country NN 31504 658 40 . . . 31504 659 1 Those those DT 31504 659 2 of of IN 31504 659 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 659 4 ancestors ancestor NNS 31504 659 5 , , , 31504 659 6 English English NNP 31504 659 7 and and CC 31504 659 8 American American NNP 31504 659 9 , , , 31504 659 10 who who WP 31504 659 11 fought fight VBD 31504 659 12 for for IN 31504 659 13 these these DT 31504 659 14 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 659 15 , , , 31504 659 16 who who WP 31504 659 17 obtained obtain VBD 31504 659 18 them -PRON- PRP 31504 659 19 only only RB 31504 659 20 after after IN 31504 659 21 years year NNS 31504 659 22 of of IN 31504 659 23 strife strife NN 31504 659 24 , , , 31504 659 25 who who WP 31504 659 26 incorporated incorporate VBD 31504 659 27 them -PRON- PRP 31504 659 28 in in IN 31504 659 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 659 30 federal federal JJ 31504 659 31 and and CC 31504 659 32 state state NN 31504 659 33 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 659 34 and and CC 31504 659 35 safeguarded safeguard VBD 31504 659 36 them -PRON- PRP 31504 659 37 against against IN 31504 659 38 the the DT 31504 659 39 varying vary VBG 31504 659 40 impulses impulse NNS 31504 659 41 of of IN 31504 659 42 the the DT 31504 659 43 populace populace NN 31504 659 44 , , , 31504 659 45 were be VBD 31504 659 46 not not RB 31504 659 47 unpatriotic unpatriotic JJ 31504 659 48 nor nor CC 31504 659 49 unmindful unmindful JJ 31504 659 50 of of IN 31504 659 51 the the DT 31504 659 52 welfare welfare NN 31504 659 53 of of IN 31504 659 54 the the DT 31504 659 55 people,--were people,--were NNP 31504 659 56 not not RB 31504 659 57 indifferent indifferent JJ 31504 659 58 to to IN 31504 659 59 human human JJ 31504 659 60 liberties liberty NNS 31504 659 61 or or CC 31504 659 62 human human JJ 31504 659 63 rights right NNS 31504 659 64 . . . 31504 660 1 Neither neither CC 31504 660 2 are be VBP 31504 660 3 they -PRON- PRP 31504 660 4 such such JJ 31504 660 5 who who WP 31504 660 6 today today NN 31504 660 7 strive strive VBP 31504 660 8 to to TO 31504 660 9 preserve preserve VB 31504 660 10 those those DT 31504 660 11 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 660 12 won win VBD 31504 660 13 at at IN 31504 660 14 such such JJ 31504 660 15 expense expense NN 31504 660 16 of of IN 31504 660 17 blood blood NN 31504 660 18 and and CC 31504 660 19 treasure treasure NN 31504 660 20 . . . 31504 661 1 On on IN 31504 661 2 the the DT 31504 661 3 contrary contrary NN 31504 661 4 , , , 31504 661 5 it -PRON- PRP 31504 661 6 is be VBZ 31504 661 7 those those DT 31504 661 8 who who WP 31504 661 9 would would MD 31504 661 10 override override VB 31504 661 11 these these DT 31504 661 12 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 661 13 and and CC 31504 661 14 revert revert VB 31504 661 15 to to IN 31504 661 16 the the DT 31504 661 17 old old JJ 31504 661 18 days day NNS 31504 661 19 of of IN 31504 661 20 unlimited unlimited JJ 31504 661 21 governmental governmental JJ 31504 661 22 power power NN 31504 661 23 , , , 31504 661 24 that that WDT 31504 661 25 are be VBP 31504 661 26 the the DT 31504 661 27 reactionaries reactionary NNS 31504 661 28 . . . 31504 662 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 662 2 may may MD 31504 662 3 be be VB 31504 662 4 admitted admit VBN 31504 662 5 that that IN 31504 662 6 some some DT 31504 662 7 of of IN 31504 662 8 these these DT 31504 662 9 limitations limitation NNS 31504 662 10 if if IN 31504 662 11 enforced enforce VBN 31504 662 12 do do VBP 31504 662 13 now now RB 31504 662 14 and and CC 31504 662 15 then then RB 31504 662 16 impede impede VB 31504 662 17 and and CC 31504 662 18 even even RB 31504 662 19 prevent prevent VB 31504 662 20 some some DT 31504 662 21 governmental governmental JJ 31504 662 22 action action NN 31504 662 23 desired desire VBN 31504 662 24 by by IN 31504 662 25 some some DT 31504 662 26 group group NN 31504 662 27 or or CC 31504 662 28 section section NN 31504 662 29 of of IN 31504 662 30 the the DT 31504 662 31 people people NNS 31504 662 32 , , , 31504 662 33 but but CC 31504 662 34 while while IN 31504 662 35 action action NN 31504 662 36 in in IN 31504 662 37 violation violation NN 31504 662 38 of of IN 31504 662 39 these these DT 31504 662 40 limitations limitation NNS 31504 662 41 might may MD 31504 662 42 benefit benefit VB 31504 662 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 662 44 sponsors sponsor NNS 31504 662 45 it -PRON- PRP 31504 662 46 would would MD 31504 662 47 necessarily necessarily RB 31504 662 48 be be VB 31504 662 49 at at IN 31504 662 50 the the DT 31504 662 51 expense expense NN 31504 662 52 of of IN 31504 662 53 others other NNS 31504 662 54 . . . 31504 663 1 Those those DT 31504 663 2 who who WP 31504 663 3 seek seek VBP 31504 663 4 such such JJ 31504 663 5 legislation legislation NN 31504 663 6 against against IN 31504 663 7 others other NNS 31504 663 8 would would MD 31504 663 9 quickly quickly RB 31504 663 10 appeal appeal VB 31504 663 11 to to IN 31504 663 12 these these DT 31504 663 13 limitations limitation NNS 31504 663 14 if if IN 31504 663 15 legislation legislation NN 31504 663 16 were be VBD 31504 663 17 directed direct VBN 31504 663 18 against against IN 31504 663 19 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 663 20 . . . 31504 664 1 The the DT 31504 664 2 noisiest noisy JJS 31504 664 3 declaimers declaimer NNS 31504 664 4 against against IN 31504 664 5 these these DT 31504 664 6 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 664 7 fall fall VBP 31504 664 8 back back RB 31504 664 9 for for IN 31504 664 10 protection protection NN 31504 664 11 upon upon IN 31504 664 12 the the DT 31504 664 13 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 664 14 guaranty guaranty NN 31504 664 15 of of IN 31504 664 16 freedom freedom NN 31504 664 17 of of IN 31504 664 18 speech speech NN 31504 664 19 . . . 31504 665 1 So so RB 31504 665 2 long long RB 31504 665 3 as as IN 31504 665 4 these these DT 31504 665 5 barriers barrier NNS 31504 665 6 are be VBP 31504 665 7 maintained maintain VBN 31504 665 8 every every DT 31504 665 9 individual individual NN 31504 665 10 , , , 31504 665 11 no no RB 31504 665 12 matter matter RB 31504 665 13 how how WRB 31504 665 14 poor poor JJ 31504 665 15 and and CC 31504 665 16 feeble feeble JJ 31504 665 17 , , , 31504 665 18 will will MD 31504 665 19 be be VB 31504 665 20 , , , 31504 665 21 theoretically theoretically RB 31504 665 22 at at IN 31504 665 23 least least JJS 31504 665 24 , , , 31504 665 25 secure secure JJ 31504 665 26 in in IN 31504 665 27 some some DT 31504 665 28 rights right NNS 31504 665 29 against against IN 31504 665 30 the the DT 31504 665 31 attacks attack NNS 31504 665 32 of of IN 31504 665 33 the the DT 31504 665 34 many many JJ 31504 665 35 . . . 31504 666 1 Without without IN 31504 666 2 such such JJ 31504 666 3 barriers barrier NNS 31504 666 4 every every DT 31504 666 5 individual individual NN 31504 666 6 is be VBZ 31504 666 7 at at IN 31504 666 8 the the DT 31504 666 9 mercy mercy NN 31504 666 10 of of IN 31504 666 11 an an DT 31504 666 12 inconstant inconstant JJ 31504 666 13 majority majority NN 31504 666 14 . . . 31504 667 1 Without without IN 31504 667 2 such such JJ 31504 667 3 barriers barrier NNS 31504 667 4 justice justice NN 31504 667 5 can can MD 31504 667 6 not not RB 31504 667 7 be be VB 31504 667 8 said say VBN 31504 667 9 to to TO 31504 667 10 be be VB 31504 667 11 secured secure VBN 31504 667 12 . . . 31504 668 1 Lord Lord NNP 31504 668 2 Treasurer Treasurer NNP 31504 668 3 Burleigh Burleigh NNP 31504 668 4 of of IN 31504 668 5 Queen Queen NNP 31504 668 6 Elizabeth Elizabeth NNP 31504 668 7 's 's POS 31504 668 8 time time NN 31504 668 9 declared declare VBD 31504 668 10 that that IN 31504 668 11 England England NNP 31504 668 12 could could MD 31504 668 13 never never RB 31504 668 14 be be VB 31504 668 15 ruined ruin VBN 31504 668 16 by by IN 31504 668 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 668 18 kings king NNS 31504 668 19 , , , 31504 668 20 but but CC 31504 668 21 only only RB 31504 668 22 by by IN 31504 668 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 668 24 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 668 25 . . . 31504 669 1 If if IN 31504 669 2 the the DT 31504 669 3 safeguards safeguard NNS 31504 669 4 of of IN 31504 669 5 the the DT 31504 669 6 federal federal JJ 31504 669 7 and and CC 31504 669 8 state state NN 31504 669 9 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 669 10 are be VBP 31504 669 11 maintained maintain VBN 31504 669 12 , , , 31504 669 13 neither neither CC 31504 669 14 Congress Congress NNP 31504 669 15 nor nor CC 31504 669 16 the the DT 31504 669 17 state state NN 31504 669 18 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 669 19 can can MD 31504 669 20 ruin ruin VB 31504 669 21 America America NNP 31504 669 22 . . . 31504 670 1 If if IN 31504 670 2 the the DT 31504 670 3 American american JJ 31504 670 4 people people NNS 31504 670 5 should should MD 31504 670 6 ever ever RB 31504 670 7 consent consent VB 31504 670 8 to to IN 31504 670 9 the the DT 31504 670 10 removal removal NN 31504 670 11 of of IN 31504 670 12 these these DT 31504 670 13 safeguards safeguard NNS 31504 670 14 they -PRON- PRP 31504 670 15 would would MD 31504 670 16 give give VB 31504 670 17 evidence evidence NN 31504 670 18 of of IN 31504 670 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 670 20 want want NN 31504 670 21 of of IN 31504 670 22 self self NN 31504 670 23 - - HYPH 31504 670 24 restraint restraint NN 31504 670 25 , , , 31504 670 26 of of IN 31504 670 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 670 28 unwillingness unwillingness JJ 31504 670 29 and and CC 31504 670 30 even even RB 31504 670 31 incapacity incapacity NN 31504 670 32 to to TO 31504 670 33 govern govern VB 31504 670 34 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 670 35 , , , 31504 670 36 and and CC 31504 670 37 would would MD 31504 670 38 pave pave VB 31504 670 39 the the DT 31504 670 40 way way NN 31504 670 41 for for IN 31504 670 42 the the DT 31504 670 43 man man NN 31504 670 44 on on IN 31504 670 45 horseback horseback NN 31504 670 46 as as IN 31504 670 47 the the DT 31504 670 48 French French NNP 31504 670 49 Revolution Revolution NNP 31504 670 50 paved pave VBD 31504 670 51 the the DT 31504 670 52 way way NN 31504 670 53 for for IN 31504 670 54 Napoleon Napoleon NNP 31504 670 55 . . . 31504 671 1 To to TO 31504 671 2 deprive deprive VB 31504 671 3 a a DT 31504 671 4 single single JJ 31504 671 5 one one CD 31504 671 6 of of IN 31504 671 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 671 8 rightful rightful JJ 31504 671 9 liberty liberty NN 31504 671 10 is be VBZ 31504 671 11 to to TO 31504 671 12 endanger endanger VB 31504 671 13 the the DT 31504 671 14 liberties liberty NNS 31504 671 15 of of IN 31504 671 16 all all DT 31504 671 17 . . . 31504 672 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31504 672 2 VII VII NNP 31504 672 3 THE the DT 31504 672 4 INTERPRETATION interpretation NN 31504 672 5 AND and CC 31504 672 6 ENFORCEMENT enforcement NN 31504 672 7 OF of IN 31504 672 8 CONSTITUTIONAL constitutional JJ 31504 672 9 LIMITATIONS limitation NNS 31504 672 10 NECESSARILY necessarily NN 31504 672 11 A a DT 31504 672 12 FUNCTION function NN 31504 672 13 OF of IN 31504 672 14 THE the DT 31504 672 15 JUDICIARY judiciary NN 31504 672 16 Under under IN 31504 672 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 672 18 federal federal JJ 31504 672 19 and and CC 31504 672 20 state state NN 31504 672 21 form form NN 31504 672 22 of of IN 31504 672 23 government government NN 31504 672 24 the the DT 31504 672 25 question question NN 31504 672 26 naturally naturally RB 31504 672 27 arises arise VBZ 31504 672 28 where where WRB 31504 672 29 should should MD 31504 672 30 be be VB 31504 672 31 lodged lodge VBN 31504 672 32 the the DT 31504 672 33 power power NN 31504 672 34 to to TO 31504 672 35 determine determine VB 31504 672 36 whether whether IN 31504 672 37 in in IN 31504 672 38 a a DT 31504 672 39 given give VBN 31504 672 40 instance instance NN 31504 672 41 either either CC 31504 672 42 department department NN 31504 672 43 has have VBZ 31504 672 44 encroached encroach VBN 31504 672 45 on on IN 31504 672 46 the the DT 31504 672 47 proper proper JJ 31504 672 48 field field NN 31504 672 49 of of IN 31504 672 50 any any DT 31504 672 51 other other JJ 31504 672 52 department department NN 31504 672 53 , , , 31504 672 54 and and CC 31504 672 55 whether whether IN 31504 672 56 either either DT 31504 672 57 department department NN 31504 672 58 has have VBZ 31504 672 59 encroached encroach VBN 31504 672 60 on on IN 31504 672 61 the the DT 31504 672 62 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 672 63 rights right NNS 31504 672 64 of of IN 31504 672 65 the the DT 31504 672 66 individual individual JJ 31504 672 67 citizen citizen NN 31504 672 68 . . . 31504 673 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 673 2 should should MD 31504 673 3 be be VB 31504 673 4 evident evident JJ 31504 673 5 that that IN 31504 673 6 neither neither CC 31504 673 7 the the DT 31504 673 8 executive executive NN 31504 673 9 nor nor CC 31504 673 10 the the DT 31504 673 11 legislative legislative JJ 31504 673 12 department department NN 31504 673 13 is be VBZ 31504 673 14 a a DT 31504 673 15 fit fit JJ 31504 673 16 depositary depositary NN 31504 673 17 of of IN 31504 673 18 such such JJ 31504 673 19 power power NN 31504 673 20 . . . 31504 674 1 Both both DT 31504 674 2 these these DT 31504 674 3 , , , 31504 674 4 from from IN 31504 674 5 the the DT 31504 674 6 nature nature NN 31504 674 7 of of IN 31504 674 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 674 9 powers power NNS 31504 674 10 , , , 31504 674 11 are be VBP 31504 674 12 aggressive aggressive JJ 31504 674 13 . . . 31504 675 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 675 2 act act VBP 31504 675 3 of of IN 31504 675 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 675 5 own own JJ 31504 675 6 volition volition NN 31504 675 7 . . . 31504 676 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 676 2 initiate initiate VBP 31504 676 3 proceedings proceeding NNS 31504 676 4 and and CC 31504 676 5 measures measure NNS 31504 676 6 to to TO 31504 676 7 carry carry VB 31504 676 8 out out RP 31504 676 9 policies policy NNS 31504 676 10 . . . 31504 677 1 In in IN 31504 677 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 677 3 activities activity NNS 31504 677 4 they -PRON- PRP 31504 677 5 are be VBP 31504 677 6 apt apt JJ 31504 677 7 , , , 31504 677 8 consciously consciously RB 31504 677 9 or or CC 31504 677 10 unconsciously unconsciously RB 31504 677 11 , , , 31504 677 12 to to TO 31504 677 13 overstep overstep VB 31504 677 14 the the DT 31504 677 15 boundary boundary JJ 31504 677 16 lines line NNS 31504 677 17 between between IN 31504 677 18 the the DT 31504 677 19 departments department NNS 31504 677 20 and and CC 31504 677 21 also also RB 31504 677 22 the the DT 31504 677 23 limits limit NNS 31504 677 24 set set VBN 31504 677 25 for for IN 31504 677 26 the the DT 31504 677 27 protection protection NN 31504 677 28 of of IN 31504 677 29 the the DT 31504 677 30 citizen citizen NN 31504 677 31 against against IN 31504 677 32 such such JJ 31504 677 33 activities activity NNS 31504 677 34 . . . 31504 678 1 Again again RB 31504 678 2 , , , 31504 678 3 questions question NNS 31504 678 4 may may MD 31504 678 5 and and CC 31504 678 6 often often RB 31504 678 7 do do VBP 31504 678 8 arise arise VB 31504 678 9 between between IN 31504 678 10 the the DT 31504 678 11 government government NN 31504 678 12 and and CC 31504 678 13 the the DT 31504 678 14 individual individual JJ 31504 678 15 citizen citizen NN 31504 678 16 that that WDT 31504 678 17 are be VBP 31504 678 18 not not RB 31504 678 19 political political JJ 31504 678 20 questions question NNS 31504 678 21 , , , 31504 678 22 but but CC 31504 678 23 are be VBP 31504 678 24 questions question NNS 31504 678 25 of of IN 31504 678 26 private private JJ 31504 678 27 right right NN 31504 678 28 , , , 31504 678 29 the the DT 31504 678 30 right right NN 31504 678 31 of of IN 31504 678 32 the the DT 31504 678 33 individual individual NN 31504 678 34 against against IN 31504 678 35 the the DT 31504 678 36 government government NN 31504 678 37 . . . 31504 679 1 The the DT 31504 679 2 disputants disputant NNS 31504 679 3 are be VBP 31504 679 4 the the DT 31504 679 5 individual individual JJ 31504 679 6 citizen citizen NN 31504 679 7 or or CC 31504 679 8 group group NN 31504 679 9 of of IN 31504 679 10 citizens citizen NNS 31504 679 11 on on IN 31504 679 12 the the DT 31504 679 13 one one CD 31504 679 14 hand hand NN 31504 679 15 , , , 31504 679 16 and and CC 31504 679 17 the the DT 31504 679 18 government government NN 31504 679 19 on on IN 31504 679 20 the the DT 31504 679 21 other other JJ 31504 679 22 whether whether IN 31504 679 23 that that DT 31504 679 24 government government NN 31504 679 25 be be VB 31504 679 26 a a DT 31504 679 27 monarchy monarchy NN 31504 679 28 , , , 31504 679 29 a a DT 31504 679 30 republican republican JJ 31504 679 31 or or CC 31504 679 32 representative representative JJ 31504 679 33 government government NN 31504 679 34 , , , 31504 679 35 or or CC 31504 679 36 a a DT 31504 679 37 pure pure JJ 31504 679 38 democracy democracy NN 31504 679 39 . . . 31504 680 1 In in IN 31504 680 2 such such JJ 31504 680 3 case case NN 31504 680 4 it -PRON- PRP 31504 680 5 would would MD 31504 680 6 seem seem VB 31504 680 7 clear clear JJ 31504 680 8 that that IN 31504 680 9 one one CD 31504 680 10 party party NN 31504 680 11 should should MD 31504 680 12 not not RB 31504 680 13 have have VB 31504 680 14 the the DT 31504 680 15 power power NN 31504 680 16 to to TO 31504 680 17 decide decide VB 31504 680 18 the the DT 31504 680 19 question question NN 31504 680 20 . . . 31504 681 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 681 2 is be VBZ 31504 681 3 an an DT 31504 681 4 axiom axiom NN 31504 681 5 that that IN 31504 681 6 neither neither CC 31504 681 7 party party NN 31504 681 8 to to IN 31504 681 9 a a DT 31504 681 10 controversy controversy NN 31504 681 11 should should MD 31504 681 12 be be VB 31504 681 13 the the DT 31504 681 14 judge judge NN 31504 681 15 in in IN 31504 681 16 the the DT 31504 681 17 matter matter NN 31504 681 18 . . . 31504 682 1 The the DT 31504 682 2 legislature legislature NN 31504 682 3 that that WDT 31504 682 4 enacts enact VBZ 31504 682 5 a a DT 31504 682 6 statute statute NN 31504 682 7 claimed claim VBN 31504 682 8 by by IN 31504 682 9 a a DT 31504 682 10 citizen citizen NN 31504 682 11 to to TO 31504 682 12 be be VB 31504 682 13 beyond beyond IN 31504 682 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 682 15 powers power NNS 31504 682 16 and and CC 31504 682 17 to to TO 31504 682 18 deprive deprive VB 31504 682 19 him -PRON- PRP 31504 682 20 of of IN 31504 682 21 some some DT 31504 682 22 right right RB 31504 682 23 guaranteed guarantee VBN 31504 682 24 to to IN 31504 682 25 him -PRON- PRP 31504 682 26 by by IN 31504 682 27 the the DT 31504 682 28 constitution constitution NN 31504 682 29 , , , 31504 682 30 should should MD 31504 682 31 not not RB 31504 682 32 be be VB 31504 682 33 the the DT 31504 682 34 judge judge NN 31504 682 35 of of IN 31504 682 36 the the DT 31504 682 37 question question NN 31504 682 38 any any DT 31504 682 39 more more RBR 31504 682 40 than than IN 31504 682 41 should should MD 31504 682 42 the the DT 31504 682 43 complaining complaining NN 31504 682 44 citizen citizen NN 31504 682 45 . . . 31504 683 1 So so RB 31504 683 2 the the DT 31504 683 3 executive executive NN 31504 683 4 should should MD 31504 683 5 not not RB 31504 683 6 be be VB 31504 683 7 the the DT 31504 683 8 judge judge NN 31504 683 9 where where WRB 31504 683 10 a a DT 31504 683 11 citizen citizen NN 31504 683 12 claims claim VBZ 31504 683 13 it -PRON- PRP 31504 683 14 has have VBZ 31504 683 15 exceeded exceed VBN 31504 683 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 683 17 powers power NNS 31504 683 18 to to IN 31504 683 19 the the DT 31504 683 20 detriment detriment NN 31504 683 21 of of IN 31504 683 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 683 23 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 683 24 or or CC 31504 683 25 statutory statutory JJ 31504 683 26 rights right NNS 31504 683 27 . . . 31504 684 1 Even even RB 31504 684 2 if if IN 31504 684 3 a a DT 31504 684 4 statute statute NN 31504 684 5 be be VB 31504 684 6 enacted enact VBN 31504 684 7 or or CC 31504 684 8 ratified ratify VBN 31504 684 9 by by IN 31504 684 10 the the DT 31504 684 11 people people NNS 31504 684 12 directly directly RB 31504 684 13 , , , 31504 684 14 under under IN 31504 684 15 the the DT 31504 684 16 modern modern JJ 31504 684 17 initiative initiative NN 31504 684 18 and and CC 31504 684 19 referendum referendum NN 31504 684 20 , , , 31504 684 21 and and CC 31504 684 22 a a DT 31504 684 23 citizen citizen NN 31504 684 24 claims claim VBZ 31504 684 25 that that IN 31504 684 26 the the DT 31504 684 27 statute statute NN 31504 684 28 deprives deprive VBZ 31504 684 29 him -PRON- PRP 31504 684 30 of of IN 31504 684 31 some some DT 31504 684 32 right right JJ 31504 684 33 guaranteed guarantee VBN 31504 684 34 by by IN 31504 684 35 the the DT 31504 684 36 constitution constitution NN 31504 684 37 , , , 31504 684 38 the the DT 31504 684 39 people people NNS 31504 684 40 should should MD 31504 684 41 not not RB 31504 684 42 be be VB 31504 684 43 the the DT 31504 684 44 judge judge NN 31504 684 45 ; ; : 31504 684 46 much much RB 31504 684 47 less less JJR 31504 684 48 should should MD 31504 684 49 a a DT 31504 684 50 majority majority NN 31504 684 51 . . . 31504 685 1 If if IN 31504 685 2 the the DT 31504 685 3 individual individual NN 31504 685 4 is be VBZ 31504 685 5 left leave VBN 31504 685 6 to to TO 31504 685 7 be be VB 31504 685 8 the the DT 31504 685 9 judge judge NN 31504 685 10 of of IN 31504 685 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 685 12 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 685 13 or or CC 31504 685 14 legal legal JJ 31504 685 15 right right NN 31504 685 16 as as IN 31504 685 17 against against IN 31504 685 18 the the DT 31504 685 19 government government NN 31504 685 20 , , , 31504 685 21 the the DT 31504 685 22 result result NN 31504 685 23 would would MD 31504 685 24 be be VB 31504 685 25 anarchy anarchy JJ 31504 685 26 . . . 31504 686 1 If if IN 31504 686 2 the the DT 31504 686 3 government government NN 31504 686 4 , , , 31504 686 5 even even RB 31504 686 6 the the DT 31504 686 7 most most RBS 31504 686 8 popular popular JJ 31504 686 9 government government NN 31504 686 10 , , , 31504 686 11 is be VBZ 31504 686 12 to to TO 31504 686 13 be be VB 31504 686 14 the the DT 31504 686 15 judge judge NN 31504 686 16 , , , 31504 686 17 the the DT 31504 686 18 result result NN 31504 686 19 would would MD 31504 686 20 often often RB 31504 686 21 be be VB 31504 686 22 tyranny tyranny JJ 31504 686 23 . . . 31504 687 1 There there EX 31504 687 2 would would MD 31504 687 3 be be VB 31504 687 4 occasions occasion NNS 31504 687 5 , , , 31504 687 6 as as IN 31504 687 7 there there EX 31504 687 8 have have VBP 31504 687 9 been be VBN 31504 687 10 , , , 31504 687 11 when when WRB 31504 687 12 an an DT 31504 687 13 excited excited JJ 31504 687 14 people people NNS 31504 687 15 or or CC 31504 687 16 majority majority NN 31504 687 17 would would MD 31504 687 18 tyrannize tyrannize VB 31504 687 19 over over IN 31504 687 20 the the DT 31504 687 21 individual individual NN 31504 687 22 , , , 31504 687 23 indeed indeed RB 31504 687 24 over over IN 31504 687 25 the the DT 31504 687 26 minority minority NN 31504 687 27 . . . 31504 688 1 To to TO 31504 688 2 secure secure VB 31504 688 3 alike alike RB 31504 688 4 the the DT 31504 688 5 people people NNS 31504 688 6 against against IN 31504 688 7 anarchy anarchy NN 31504 688 8 and and CC 31504 688 9 the the DT 31504 688 10 individual individual NN 31504 688 11 against against IN 31504 688 12 tyranny tyranny NN 31504 688 13 , , , 31504 688 14 power power NN 31504 688 15 must must MD 31504 688 16 be be VB 31504 688 17 vested vest VBN 31504 688 18 in in IN 31504 688 19 some some DT 31504 688 20 impartial impartial JJ 31504 688 21 , , , 31504 688 22 independent independent JJ 31504 688 23 arbiter arbiter NN 31504 688 24 to to TO 31504 688 25 determine determine VB 31504 688 26 authoritatively authoritatively RB 31504 688 27 and and CC 31504 688 28 finally finally RB 31504 688 29 the the DT 31504 688 30 relative relative JJ 31504 688 31 rights right NNS 31504 688 32 and and CC 31504 688 33 duties duty NNS 31504 688 34 of of IN 31504 688 35 each each DT 31504 688 36 under under IN 31504 688 37 the the DT 31504 688 38 constitution constitution NN 31504 688 39 . . . 31504 689 1 The the DT 31504 689 2 proper proper JJ 31504 689 3 department department NN 31504 689 4 to to TO 31504 689 5 be be VB 31504 689 6 made make VBN 31504 689 7 the the DT 31504 689 8 depositary depositary NN 31504 689 9 of of IN 31504 689 10 this this DT 31504 689 11 important important JJ 31504 689 12 power power NN 31504 689 13 would would MD 31504 689 14 seem seem VB 31504 689 15 to to TO 31504 689 16 be be VB 31504 689 17 the the DT 31504 689 18 judicial judicial JJ 31504 689 19 . . . 31504 690 1 That that DT 31504 690 2 department department NN 31504 690 3 does do VBZ 31504 690 4 not not RB 31504 690 5 initiate initiate VB 31504 690 6 , , , 31504 690 7 has have VBZ 31504 690 8 no no DT 31504 690 9 policies policy NNS 31504 690 10 , , , 31504 690 11 does do VBZ 31504 690 12 not not RB 31504 690 13 act act VB 31504 690 14 of of IN 31504 690 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 690 16 own own JJ 31504 690 17 volition volition NN 31504 690 18 , , , 31504 690 19 but but CC 31504 690 20 acts act VBZ 31504 690 21 only only RB 31504 690 22 when when WRB 31504 690 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 690 24 action action NN 31504 690 25 is be VBZ 31504 690 26 regularly regularly RB 31504 690 27 invoked invoke VBN 31504 690 28 in in IN 31504 690 29 some some DT 31504 690 30 controversy controversy NN 31504 690 31 and and CC 31504 690 32 then then RB 31504 690 33 only only RB 31504 690 34 to to TO 31504 690 35 end end VB 31504 690 36 that that DT 31504 690 37 controversy controversy NN 31504 690 38 . . . 31504 691 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 691 2 may may MD 31504 691 3 seem seem VB 31504 691 4 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 31504 691 5 even even RB 31504 691 6 to to IN 31504 691 7 state state NN 31504 691 8 , , , 31504 691 9 much much RB 31504 691 10 less less JJR 31504 691 11 defend defend NN 31504 691 12 , , , 31504 691 13 the the DT 31504 691 14 proposition proposition NN 31504 691 15 , , , 31504 691 16 but but CC 31504 691 17 as as IN 31504 691 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 691 19 logical logical JJ 31504 691 20 result result NN 31504 691 21 is be VBZ 31504 691 22 that that IN 31504 691 23 the the DT 31504 691 24 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 691 25 when when WRB 31504 691 26 invoked invoke VBN 31504 691 27 by by IN 31504 691 28 the the DT 31504 691 29 individual individual NN 31504 691 30 must must MD 31504 691 31 refuse refuse VB 31504 691 32 effect effect NN 31504 691 33 , , , 31504 691 34 so so RB 31504 691 35 far far RB 31504 691 36 as as IN 31504 691 37 he -PRON- PRP 31504 691 38 is be VBZ 31504 691 39 concerned concern VBN 31504 691 40 , , , 31504 691 41 to to IN 31504 691 42 a a DT 31504 691 43 legislative legislative JJ 31504 691 44 act act NN 31504 691 45 which which WDT 31504 691 46 deprives deprive VBZ 31504 691 47 him -PRON- PRP 31504 691 48 of of IN 31504 691 49 some some DT 31504 691 50 right right JJ 31504 691 51 guaranteed guarantee VBN 31504 691 52 by by IN 31504 691 53 the the DT 31504 691 54 constitution constitution NN 31504 691 55 , , , 31504 691 56 and and CC 31504 691 57 must must MD 31504 691 58 thus thus RB 31504 691 59 disappoint disappoint VB 31504 691 60 those those DT 31504 691 61 who who WP 31504 691 62 procured procure VBD 31504 691 63 the the DT 31504 691 64 passage passage NN 31504 691 65 of of IN 31504 691 66 the the DT 31504 691 67 act act NN 31504 691 68 , , , 31504 691 69 the the DT 31504 691 70 proposition proposition NN 31504 691 71 has have VBZ 31504 691 72 been be VBN 31504 691 73 , , , 31504 691 74 is be VBZ 31504 691 75 still still RB 31504 691 76 being be VBG 31504 691 77 , , , 31504 691 78 denied deny VBN 31504 691 79 . . . 31504 692 1 The the DT 31504 692 2 action action NN 31504 692 3 of of IN 31504 692 4 the the DT 31504 692 5 courts court NNS 31504 692 6 in in IN 31504 692 7 exercising exercise VBG 31504 692 8 that that DT 31504 692 9 power power NN 31504 692 10 has have VBZ 31504 692 11 been be VBN 31504 692 12 and and CC 31504 692 13 is be VBZ 31504 692 14 even even RB 31504 692 15 now now RB 31504 692 16 denounced denounce VBN 31504 692 17 as as IN 31504 692 18 usurpation usurpation NN 31504 692 19 . . . 31504 693 1 Though though IN 31504 693 2 the the DT 31504 693 3 proposition proposition NN 31504 693 4 is be VBZ 31504 693 5 now now RB 31504 693 6 long long RB 31504 693 7 established establish VBN 31504 693 8 , , , 31504 693 9 these these DT 31504 693 10 attacks attack NNS 31504 693 11 justify justify VBP 31504 693 12 some some DT 31504 693 13 repetition repetition NN 31504 693 14 of of IN 31504 693 15 the the DT 31504 693 16 argument argument NN 31504 693 17 in in IN 31504 693 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 693 19 support support NN 31504 693 20 . . . 31504 694 1 The the DT 31504 694 2 logic logic NN 31504 694 3 of of IN 31504 694 4 Chief Chief NNP 31504 694 5 Justice Justice NNP 31504 694 6 Marshall Marshall NNP 31504 694 7 in in IN 31504 694 8 _ _ NNP 31504 694 9 Marbury Marbury NNP 31504 694 10 _ _ NNP 31504 694 11 v. v. IN 31504 694 12 _ _ NNP 31504 694 13 Madison Madison NNP 31504 694 14 _ _ NNP 31504 694 15 , , , 31504 694 16 1 1 CD 31504 694 17 _ _ NNP 31504 694 18 Cranch Cranch NNP 31504 694 19 _ _ NNP 31504 694 20 137 137 CD 31504 694 21 _ _ NNP 31504 694 22 at at IN 31504 694 23 p. p. NN 31504 694 24 176 176 CD 31504 694 25 _ _ NNP 31504 694 26 , , , 31504 694 27 seems seem VBZ 31504 694 28 to to IN 31504 694 29 me -PRON- PRP 31504 694 30 irresistible irresistible JJ 31504 694 31 and and CC 31504 694 32 worthy worthy JJ 31504 694 33 of of IN 31504 694 34 frequent frequent JJ 31504 694 35 quotation quotation NN 31504 694 36 despite despite IN 31504 694 37 the the DT 31504 694 38 attacks attack NNS 31504 694 39 upon upon IN 31504 694 40 it -PRON- PRP 31504 694 41 . . . 31504 695 1 The the DT 31504 695 2 Chief Chief NNP 31504 695 3 Justice Justice NNP 31504 695 4 said say VBD 31504 695 5 : : : 31504 695 6 " " `` 31504 695 7 This this DT 31504 695 8 original original JJ 31504 695 9 and and CC 31504 695 10 supreme supreme NNP 31504 695 11 will will MD 31504 695 12 ( ( -LRB- 31504 695 13 of of IN 31504 695 14 a a DT 31504 695 15 people people NNS 31504 695 16 ) ) -RRB- 31504 695 17 organizes organize VBZ 31504 695 18 the the DT 31504 695 19 government government NN 31504 695 20 and and CC 31504 695 21 assigns assign NNS 31504 695 22 to to IN 31504 695 23 different different JJ 31504 695 24 departments department NNS 31504 695 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 695 26 respective respective JJ 31504 695 27 powers power NNS 31504 695 28 . . . 31504 696 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 696 2 may may MD 31504 696 3 either either CC 31504 696 4 stop stop VB 31504 696 5 here here RB 31504 696 6 , , , 31504 696 7 or or CC 31504 696 8 establish establish VB 31504 696 9 certain certain JJ 31504 696 10 limits limit NNS 31504 696 11 not not RB 31504 696 12 to to TO 31504 696 13 be be VB 31504 696 14 transcended transcend VBN 31504 696 15 by by IN 31504 696 16 those those DT 31504 696 17 departments department NNS 31504 696 18 .... .... . 31504 697 1 The the DT 31504 697 2 government government NN 31504 697 3 of of IN 31504 697 4 the the DT 31504 697 5 United United NNP 31504 697 6 States States NNP 31504 697 7 is be VBZ 31504 697 8 of of IN 31504 697 9 the the DT 31504 697 10 latter latter JJ 31504 697 11 description description NN 31504 697 12 . . . 31504 698 1 The the DT 31504 698 2 powers power NNS 31504 698 3 of of IN 31504 698 4 the the DT 31504 698 5 legislature legislature NN 31504 698 6 are be VBP 31504 698 7 defined define VBN 31504 698 8 and and CC 31504 698 9 limited limited JJ 31504 698 10 ; ; : 31504 698 11 and and CC 31504 698 12 that that IN 31504 698 13 those those DT 31504 698 14 limits limit NNS 31504 698 15 may may MD 31504 698 16 not not RB 31504 698 17 be be VB 31504 698 18 mistaken mistaken JJ 31504 698 19 or or CC 31504 698 20 forgotten forget VBN 31504 698 21 , , , 31504 698 22 the the DT 31504 698 23 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 698 24 is be VBZ 31504 698 25 written write VBN 31504 698 26 . . . 31504 699 1 To to IN 31504 699 2 what what WDT 31504 699 3 purpose purpose NN 31504 699 4 are be VBP 31504 699 5 powers power NNS 31504 699 6 limited limit VBN 31504 699 7 and and CC 31504 699 8 to to IN 31504 699 9 what what WDT 31504 699 10 purpose purpose NN 31504 699 11 is be VBZ 31504 699 12 that that IN 31504 699 13 limitation limitation NN 31504 699 14 committed commit VBN 31504 699 15 to to IN 31504 699 16 writing write VBG 31504 699 17 if if IN 31504 699 18 these these DT 31504 699 19 limits limit NNS 31504 699 20 may may MD 31504 699 21 at at IN 31504 699 22 any any DT 31504 699 23 time time NN 31504 699 24 be be VB 31504 699 25 passed pass VBN 31504 699 26 by by IN 31504 699 27 those those DT 31504 699 28 intended intend VBN 31504 699 29 to to TO 31504 699 30 be be VB 31504 699 31 restrained restrain VBN 31504 699 32 ? ? . 31504 700 1 The the DT 31504 700 2 distinction distinction NN 31504 700 3 between between IN 31504 700 4 a a DT 31504 700 5 government government NN 31504 700 6 with with IN 31504 700 7 limited limited JJ 31504 700 8 and and CC 31504 700 9 unlimited unlimited JJ 31504 700 10 powers power NNS 31504 700 11 is be VBZ 31504 700 12 abolished abolish VBN 31504 700 13 if if IN 31504 700 14 those those DT 31504 700 15 limits limit NNS 31504 700 16 do do VBP 31504 700 17 not not RB 31504 700 18 confine confine VB 31504 700 19 the the DT 31504 700 20 persons person NNS 31504 700 21 on on IN 31504 700 22 whom whom WP 31504 700 23 they -PRON- PRP 31504 700 24 are be VBP 31504 700 25 imposed impose VBN 31504 700 26 , , , 31504 700 27 and and CC 31504 700 28 if if IN 31504 700 29 acts act NNS 31504 700 30 prohibited prohibit VBN 31504 700 31 and and CC 31504 700 32 acts act NNS 31504 700 33 allowed allow VBN 31504 700 34 are be VBP 31504 700 35 of of IN 31504 700 36 equal equal JJ 31504 700 37 obligation obligation NN 31504 700 38 . . . 31504 701 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 701 2 is be VBZ 31504 701 3 a a DT 31504 701 4 proposition proposition NN 31504 701 5 too too RB 31504 701 6 plain plain JJ 31504 701 7 to to TO 31504 701 8 be be VB 31504 701 9 contested contest VBN 31504 701 10 , , , 31504 701 11 either either CC 31504 701 12 that that IN 31504 701 13 the the DT 31504 701 14 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 701 15 controls control VBZ 31504 701 16 any any DT 31504 701 17 legislative legislative JJ 31504 701 18 act act NN 31504 701 19 repugnant repugnant JJ 31504 701 20 to to IN 31504 701 21 it -PRON- PRP 31504 701 22 , , , 31504 701 23 or or CC 31504 701 24 that that IN 31504 701 25 the the DT 31504 701 26 legislature legislature NN 31504 701 27 may may MD 31504 701 28 alter alter VB 31504 701 29 the the DT 31504 701 30 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 701 31 by by IN 31504 701 32 an an DT 31504 701 33 ordinary ordinary JJ 31504 701 34 act act NN 31504 701 35 . . . 31504 702 1 Between between IN 31504 702 2 these these DT 31504 702 3 alternatives alternative NNS 31504 702 4 there there EX 31504 702 5 is be VBZ 31504 702 6 no no DT 31504 702 7 middle middle JJ 31504 702 8 ground ground NN 31504 702 9 . . . 31504 703 1 The the DT 31504 703 2 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 703 3 is be VBZ 31504 703 4 either either CC 31504 703 5 a a DT 31504 703 6 superior superior JJ 31504 703 7 , , , 31504 703 8 paramount paramount JJ 31504 703 9 law law NN 31504 703 10 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 31504 703 11 by by IN 31504 703 12 ordinary ordinary JJ 31504 703 13 means mean NNS 31504 703 14 , , , 31504 703 15 or or CC 31504 703 16 it -PRON- PRP 31504 703 17 is be VBZ 31504 703 18 on on IN 31504 703 19 a a DT 31504 703 20 level level NN 31504 703 21 with with IN 31504 703 22 ordinary ordinary JJ 31504 703 23 legislative legislative JJ 31504 703 24 acts act NNS 31504 703 25 , , , 31504 703 26 and and CC 31504 703 27 , , , 31504 703 28 like like IN 31504 703 29 other other JJ 31504 703 30 acts act NNS 31504 703 31 , , , 31504 703 32 is be VBZ 31504 703 33 alterable alterable JJ 31504 703 34 when when WRB 31504 703 35 the the DT 31504 703 36 legislature legislature NN 31504 703 37 shall shall MD 31504 703 38 please please VB 31504 703 39 to to TO 31504 703 40 alter alter VB 31504 703 41 it -PRON- PRP 31504 703 42 .... .... . 31504 704 1 Certainly certainly RB 31504 704 2 all all PDT 31504 704 3 those those DT 31504 704 4 who who WP 31504 704 5 have have VBP 31504 704 6 framed frame VBN 31504 704 7 written write VBN 31504 704 8 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 704 9 contemplate contemplate VBP 31504 704 10 them -PRON- PRP 31504 704 11 as as IN 31504 704 12 forming form VBG 31504 704 13 the the DT 31504 704 14 fundamental fundamental JJ 31504 704 15 and and CC 31504 704 16 paramount paramount JJ 31504 704 17 law law NN 31504 704 18 of of IN 31504 704 19 the the DT 31504 704 20 nation nation NN 31504 704 21 , , , 31504 704 22 and and CC 31504 704 23 consequently consequently RB 31504 704 24 the the DT 31504 704 25 theory theory NN 31504 704 26 of of IN 31504 704 27 every every DT 31504 704 28 such such JJ 31504 704 29 government government NN 31504 704 30 must must MD 31504 704 31 be be VB 31504 704 32 that that IN 31504 704 33 an an DT 31504 704 34 act act NN 31504 704 35 of of IN 31504 704 36 the the DT 31504 704 37 legislature legislature NN 31504 704 38 repugnant repugnant JJ 31504 704 39 to to IN 31504 704 40 the the DT 31504 704 41 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 704 42 is be VBZ 31504 704 43 void void JJ 31504 704 44 . . . 31504 704 45 " " '' 31504 705 1 In in IN 31504 705 2 1825 1825 CD 31504 705 3 that that IN 31504 705 4 eminent eminent JJ 31504 705 5 jurist jurist NN 31504 705 6 , , , 31504 705 7 Chief Chief NNP 31504 705 8 Justice Justice NNP 31504 705 9 Gibson Gibson NNP 31504 705 10 of of IN 31504 705 11 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP 31504 705 12 , , , 31504 705 13 in in IN 31504 705 14 a a DT 31504 705 15 dissenting dissent VBG 31504 705 16 opinion opinion NN 31504 705 17 in in IN 31504 705 18 _ _ NNP 31504 705 19 Eakin Eakin NNP 31504 705 20 _ _ NNP 31504 705 21 v. v. IN 31504 705 22 _ _ NNP 31504 705 23 Raub Raub NNP 31504 705 24 _ _ NNP 31504 705 25 , , , 31504 705 26 12 12 CD 31504 705 27 _ _ NNP 31504 705 28 S. S. NNP 31504 706 1 & & CC 31504 706 2 R. R. NNP 31504 706 3 _ _ NNP 31504 706 4 330 330 CD 31504 706 5 , , , 31504 706 6 insisted insist VBD 31504 706 7 in in IN 31504 706 8 an an DT 31504 706 9 able able JJ 31504 706 10 , , , 31504 706 11 elaborate elaborate JJ 31504 706 12 , , , 31504 706 13 and and CC 31504 706 14 exhaustive exhaustive JJ 31504 706 15 argument argument NN 31504 706 16 that that IN 31504 706 17 while while IN 31504 706 18 the the DT 31504 706 19 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 706 20 was be VBD 31504 706 21 bound bind VBN 31504 706 22 to to TO 31504 706 23 refuse refuse VB 31504 706 24 effect effect NN 31504 706 25 to to IN 31504 706 26 a a DT 31504 706 27 state state NN 31504 706 28 statute statute NN 31504 706 29 in in IN 31504 706 30 conflict conflict NN 31504 706 31 with with IN 31504 706 32 the the DT 31504 706 33 Federal Federal NNP 31504 706 34 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 706 35 , , , 31504 706 36 it -PRON- PRP 31504 706 37 was be VBD 31504 706 38 bound bind VBN 31504 706 39 to to TO 31504 706 40 give give VB 31504 706 41 it -PRON- PRP 31504 706 42 effect effect NN 31504 706 43 if if IN 31504 706 44 repugnant repugnant NN 31504 706 45 only only RB 31504 706 46 to to IN 31504 706 47 the the DT 31504 706 48 state state NN 31504 706 49 constitution constitution NN 31504 706 50 . . . 31504 707 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 707 2 frankly frankly RB 31504 707 3 admitted admit VBD 31504 707 4 the the DT 31504 707 5 logical logical JJ 31504 707 6 conclusion conclusion NN 31504 707 7 that that IN 31504 707 8 in in IN 31504 707 9 such such JJ 31504 707 10 case case NN 31504 707 11 the the DT 31504 707 12 only only JJ 31504 707 13 remedy remedy NN 31504 707 14 the the DT 31504 707 15 citizen citizen NN 31504 707 16 had have VBD 31504 707 17 to to TO 31504 707 18 enforce enforce VB 31504 707 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 707 20 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 707 21 rights right NNS 31504 707 22 was be VBD 31504 707 23 that that DT 31504 707 24 of of IN 31504 707 25 revolution revolution NN 31504 707 26 . . . 31504 708 1 When when WRB 31504 708 2 , , , 31504 708 3 however however RB 31504 708 4 , , , 31504 708 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 708 6 opinion opinion NN 31504 708 7 in in IN 31504 708 8 _ _ NNP 31504 708 9 Eakin Eakin NNP 31504 708 10 _ _ NNP 31504 708 11 v. v. IN 31504 708 12 _ _ NNP 31504 708 13 Raub Raub NNP 31504 708 14 _ _ NNP 31504 708 15 was be VBD 31504 708 16 cited cite VBN 31504 708 17 in in IN 31504 708 18 1845 1845 CD 31504 708 19 in in IN 31504 708 20 argument argument NN 31504 708 21 in in IN 31504 708 22 _ _ NNP 31504 708 23 Norris Norris NNP 31504 708 24 _ _ NNP 31504 708 25 v. v. IN 31504 708 26 _ _ NNP 31504 708 27 Clymer Clymer NNP 31504 708 28 _ _ NNP 31504 708 29 , , , 31504 708 30 2 2 CD 31504 708 31 _ _ NNP 31504 708 32 Pa. Pennsylvania NNP 31504 709 1 St. St. NNP 31504 709 2 _ _ NNP 31504 709 3 277 277 CD 31504 709 4 , , , 31504 709 5 he -PRON- PRP 31504 709 6 said say VBD 31504 709 7 he -PRON- PRP 31504 709 8 had have VBD 31504 709 9 changed change VBN 31504 709 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 709 11 opinion opinion NN 31504 709 12 on on IN 31504 709 13 that that DT 31504 709 14 question question NN 31504 709 15 , , , 31504 709 16 partly partly RB 31504 709 17 " " `` 31504 709 18 from from IN 31504 709 19 experience experience NN 31504 709 20 of of IN 31504 709 21 the the DT 31504 709 22 necessity necessity NN 31504 709 23 of of IN 31504 709 24 the the DT 31504 709 25 case case NN 31504 709 26 . . . 31504 709 27 " " '' 31504 710 1 In in IN 31504 710 2 the the DT 31504 710 3 later later JJ 31504 710 4 case case NN 31504 710 5 , , , 31504 710 6 _ _ NNP 31504 710 7 De De NNP 31504 710 8 Chastellux Chastellux NNP 31504 710 9 _ _ NNP 31504 710 10 v. v. IN 31504 710 11 _ _ NNP 31504 710 12 Fairchild Fairchild NNP 31504 710 13 _ _ NNP 31504 710 14 , , , 31504 710 15 15 15 CD 31504 710 16 _ _ NNP 31504 710 17 Pa. Pennsylvania NNP 31504 711 1 St. St. NNP 31504 711 2 _ _ NNP 31504 711 3 18 18 CD 31504 711 4 , , , 31504 711 5 he -PRON- PRP 31504 711 6 was be VBD 31504 711 7 emphatic emphatic JJ 31504 711 8 in in IN 31504 711 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 711 10 declaration declaration NN 31504 711 11 of of IN 31504 711 12 the the DT 31504 711 13 power power NN 31504 711 14 and and CC 31504 711 15 duty duty NN 31504 711 16 of of IN 31504 711 17 the the DT 31504 711 18 court court NN 31504 711 19 to to TO 31504 711 20 refuse refuse VB 31504 711 21 effect effect NN 31504 711 22 to to IN 31504 711 23 a a DT 31504 711 24 state state NN 31504 711 25 statute statute NN 31504 711 26 in in IN 31504 711 27 conflict conflict NN 31504 711 28 with with IN 31504 711 29 the the DT 31504 711 30 state state NN 31504 711 31 constitution constitution NN 31504 711 32 . . . 31504 712 1 In in IN 31504 712 2 delivering deliver VBG 31504 712 3 the the DT 31504 712 4 opinion opinion NN 31504 712 5 of of IN 31504 712 6 the the DT 31504 712 7 court court NN 31504 712 8 he -PRON- PRP 31504 712 9 used use VBD 31504 712 10 this this DT 31504 712 11 vigorous vigorous JJ 31504 712 12 language language NN 31504 712 13 : : : 31504 712 14 " " `` 31504 712 15 It -PRON- PRP 31504 712 16 is be VBZ 31504 712 17 idle idle JJ 31504 712 18 to to TO 31504 712 19 say say VB 31504 712 20 the the DT 31504 712 21 authority authority NN 31504 712 22 of of IN 31504 712 23 each each DT 31504 712 24 branch branch NN 31504 712 25 ( ( -LRB- 31504 712 26 of of IN 31504 712 27 the the DT 31504 712 28 government government NN 31504 712 29 ) ) -RRB- 31504 712 30 is be VBZ 31504 712 31 defined define VBN 31504 712 32 and and CC 31504 712 33 limited limit VBN 31504 712 34 in in IN 31504 712 35 the the DT 31504 712 36 constitution constitution NN 31504 712 37 , , , 31504 712 38 if if IN 31504 712 39 there there EX 31504 712 40 be be VBP 31504 712 41 not not RB 31504 712 42 an an DT 31504 712 43 independent independent JJ 31504 712 44 power power NN 31504 712 45 able able JJ 31504 712 46 and and CC 31504 712 47 willing willing JJ 31504 712 48 to to TO 31504 712 49 enforce enforce VB 31504 712 50 the the DT 31504 712 51 limitations limitation NNS 31504 712 52 .... .... . 31504 712 53 From from IN 31504 712 54 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 712 55 very very JJ 31504 712 56 position position NN 31504 712 57 it -PRON- PRP 31504 712 58 is be VBZ 31504 712 59 apparent apparent JJ 31504 712 60 that that IN 31504 712 61 the the DT 31504 712 62 conservative conservative JJ 31504 712 63 power power NN 31504 712 64 is be VBZ 31504 712 65 lodged lodge VBN 31504 712 66 with with IN 31504 712 67 the the DT 31504 712 68 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 712 69 , , , 31504 712 70 which which WDT 31504 712 71 in in IN 31504 712 72 the the DT 31504 712 73 exercise exercise NN 31504 712 74 of of IN 31504 712 75 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 712 76 undoubted undoubted JJ 31504 712 77 right right NN 31504 712 78 is be VBZ 31504 712 79 bound bind VBN 31504 712 80 to to TO 31504 712 81 meet meet VB 31504 712 82 every every DT 31504 712 83 emergency emergency NN 31504 712 84 . . . 31504 712 85 " " '' 31504 713 1 The the DT 31504 713 2 results result NNS 31504 713 3 of of IN 31504 713 4 the the DT 31504 713 5 contrary contrary JJ 31504 713 6 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 713 7 are be VBP 31504 713 8 well well RB 31504 713 9 stated state VBN 31504 713 10 by by IN 31504 713 11 the the DT 31504 713 12 same same JJ 31504 713 13 court court NN 31504 713 14 in in IN 31504 713 15 _ _ NNP 31504 713 16 Perkins Perkins NNP 31504 713 17 _ _ NNP 31504 713 18 v. v. IN 31504 713 19 _ _ NNP 31504 713 20 Philadelphia Philadelphia NNP 31504 713 21 _ _ NNP 31504 713 22 , , , 31504 713 23 156 156 CD 31504 713 24 _ _ NNP 31504 713 25 Pa. Pennsylvania NNP 31504 714 1 St. St. NNP 31504 714 2 _ _ NNP 31504 714 3 554 554 CD 31504 714 4 . . . 31504 715 1 " " `` 31504 715 2 If if IN 31504 715 3 laws law NNS 31504 715 4 in in IN 31504 715 5 conflict conflict NN 31504 715 6 with with IN 31504 715 7 the the DT 31504 715 8 constitution constitution NN 31504 715 9 be be VB 31504 715 10 passed pass VBN 31504 715 11 by by IN 31504 715 12 the the DT 31504 715 13 legislature legislature NN 31504 715 14 , , , 31504 715 15 approved approve VBN 31504 715 16 by by IN 31504 715 17 the the DT 31504 715 18 governor governor NN 31504 715 19 and and CC 31504 715 20 sustained sustain VBN 31504 715 21 by by IN 31504 715 22 the the DT 31504 715 23 court court NN 31504 715 24 , , , 31504 715 25 that that DT 31504 715 26 is be VBZ 31504 715 27 revolution revolution NN 31504 715 28 . . . 31504 716 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 716 2 is be VBZ 31504 716 3 no no DT 31504 716 4 less less JJR 31504 716 5 revolution revolution NN 31504 716 6 because because IN 31504 716 7 accomplished accomplish VBN 31504 716 8 without without IN 31504 716 9 great great JJ 31504 716 10 violence violence NN 31504 716 11 . . . 31504 717 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 717 2 matters matter VBZ 31504 717 3 little little JJ 31504 717 4 to to IN 31504 717 5 the the DT 31504 717 6 house house NN 31504 717 7 owner owner NN 31504 717 8 whether whether IN 31504 717 9 the the DT 31504 717 10 structure structure NN 31504 717 11 built build VBN 31504 717 12 to to TO 31504 717 13 shelter shelter VB 31504 717 14 him -PRON- PRP 31504 717 15 be be VB 31504 717 16 blown blow VBN 31504 717 17 up up RP 31504 717 18 by by IN 31504 717 19 dynamite dynamite NN 31504 717 20 , , , 31504 717 21 or or CC 31504 717 22 the the DT 31504 717 23 foundation foundation NN 31504 717 24 be be VB 31504 717 25 pried pry VBN 31504 717 26 out out RP 31504 717 27 stone stone NN 31504 717 28 by by IN 31504 717 29 stone stone NN 31504 717 30 with with IN 31504 717 31 a a DT 31504 717 32 crowbar crowbar NN 31504 717 33 . . . 31504 718 1 In in IN 31504 718 2 either either DT 31504 718 3 case case NN 31504 718 4 he -PRON- PRP 31504 718 5 is be VBZ 31504 718 6 houseless houseless JJ 31504 718 7 . . . 31504 718 8 " " '' 31504 719 1 One one CD 31504 719 2 desirable desirable JJ 31504 719 3 result result NN 31504 719 4 of of IN 31504 719 5 this this DT 31504 719 6 doctrine doctrine NN 31504 719 7 that that IN 31504 719 8 the the DT 31504 719 9 courts court NNS 31504 719 10 when when WRB 31504 719 11 regularly regularly RB 31504 719 12 invoked invoke VBD 31504 719 13 can can NN 31504 719 14 and and CC 31504 719 15 should should MD 31504 719 16 refuse refuse VB 31504 719 17 effect effect NN 31504 719 18 to to IN 31504 719 19 an an DT 31504 719 20 unconstitutional unconstitutional JJ 31504 719 21 statute statute NN 31504 719 22 is be VBZ 31504 719 23 that that IN 31504 719 24 it -PRON- PRP 31504 719 25 ensures ensure VBZ 31504 719 26 to to IN 31504 719 27 every every DT 31504 719 28 person person NN 31504 719 29 , , , 31504 719 30 not not RB 31504 719 31 in in IN 31504 719 32 the the DT 31504 719 33 military military JJ 31504 719 34 or or CC 31504 719 35 naval naval JJ 31504 719 36 service service NN 31504 719 37 , , , 31504 719 38 the the DT 31504 719 39 right right NN 31504 719 40 to to TO 31504 719 41 test test VB 31504 719 42 in in IN 31504 719 43 the the DT 31504 719 44 judicial judicial JJ 31504 719 45 courts court NNS 31504 719 46 the the DT 31504 719 47 authority authority NN 31504 719 48 of of IN 31504 719 49 any any DT 31504 719 50 official official NN 31504 719 51 to to TO 31504 719 52 interfere interfere VB 31504 719 53 with with IN 31504 719 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 719 55 person person NN 31504 719 56 , , , 31504 719 57 liberty liberty NN 31504 719 58 , , , 31504 719 59 or or CC 31504 719 60 property property NN 31504 719 61 , , , 31504 719 62 whatever whatever WDT 31504 719 63 authority authority NN 31504 719 64 , , , 31504 719 65 executive executive JJ 31504 719 66 or or CC 31504 719 67 legislative legislative JJ 31504 719 68 , , , 31504 719 69 the the DT 31504 719 70 official official NN 31504 719 71 may may MD 31504 719 72 plead plead VB 31504 719 73 . . . 31504 720 1 In in IN 31504 720 2 France France NNP 31504 720 3 and and CC 31504 720 4 other other JJ 31504 720 5 countries country NNS 31504 720 6 of of IN 31504 720 7 continental continental JJ 31504 720 8 Europe Europe NNP 31504 720 9 questions question NNS 31504 720 10 of of IN 31504 720 11 the the DT 31504 720 12 existence existence NN 31504 720 13 and and CC 31504 720 14 extent extent NN 31504 720 15 of of IN 31504 720 16 the the DT 31504 720 17 authority authority NN 31504 720 18 of of IN 31504 720 19 an an DT 31504 720 20 official official NN 31504 720 21 in in IN 31504 720 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 720 23 action action NN 31504 720 24 against against IN 31504 720 25 individuals individual NNS 31504 720 26 are be VBP 31504 720 27 triable triable JJ 31504 720 28 , , , 31504 720 29 at at IN 31504 720 30 least least JJS 31504 720 31 at at IN 31504 720 32 the the DT 31504 720 33 pleasure pleasure NN 31504 720 34 of of IN 31504 720 35 the the DT 31504 720 36 executive executive NN 31504 720 37 , , , 31504 720 38 only only RB 31504 720 39 in in IN 31504 720 40 administrative administrative JJ 31504 720 41 tribunals tribunal NNS 31504 720 42 , , , 31504 720 43 that that RB 31504 720 44 is is RB 31504 720 45 , , , 31504 720 46 courts court NNS 31504 720 47 pertaining pertain VBG 31504 720 48 to to IN 31504 720 49 the the DT 31504 720 50 executive executive JJ 31504 720 51 department department NN 31504 720 52 and and CC 31504 720 53 instituted institute VBN 31504 720 54 to to TO 31504 720 55 assist assist VB 31504 720 56 that that DT 31504 720 57 department department NN 31504 720 58 in in IN 31504 720 59 the the DT 31504 720 60 performance performance NN 31504 720 61 of of IN 31504 720 62 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 720 63 functions function NNS 31504 720 64 . . . 31504 721 1 The the DT 31504 721 2 aggrieved aggrieved JJ 31504 721 3 individual individual NN 31504 721 4 can can MD 31504 721 5 only only RB 31504 721 6 apply apply VB 31504 721 7 to to IN 31504 721 8 the the DT 31504 721 9 superiors superior NNS 31504 721 10 of of IN 31504 721 11 the the DT 31504 721 12 official official NN 31504 721 13 complained complain VBD 31504 721 14 of of IN 31504 721 15 . . . 31504 722 1 Such such JJ 31504 722 2 tribunals tribunal NNS 31504 722 3 naturally naturally RB 31504 722 4 incline incline VBP 31504 722 5 to to TO 31504 722 6 uphold uphold VB 31504 722 7 the the DT 31504 722 8 authority authority NN 31504 722 9 claimed claim VBD 31504 722 10 , , , 31504 722 11 and and CC 31504 722 12 indeed indeed RB 31504 722 13 can can MD 31504 722 14 lawfully lawfully RB 31504 722 15 allow allow VB 31504 722 16 the the DT 31504 722 17 plea plea NN 31504 722 18 that that WDT 31504 722 19 the the DT 31504 722 20 act act NN 31504 722 21 complained complain VBD 31504 722 22 of of IN 31504 722 23 was be VBD 31504 722 24 ordered order VBN 31504 722 25 in in IN 31504 722 26 pursuance pursuance NN 31504 722 27 of of IN 31504 722 28 some some DT 31504 722 29 executive executive JJ 31504 722 30 policy policy NN 31504 722 31 . . . 31504 723 1 A a DT 31504 723 2 recent recent JJ 31504 723 3 instance instance NN 31504 723 4 is be VBZ 31504 723 5 that that DT 31504 723 6 unhappy unhappy JJ 31504 723 7 affair affair NN 31504 723 8 at at IN 31504 723 9 Zabern Zabern NNP 31504 723 10 in in IN 31504 723 11 Alsace Alsace NNP 31504 723 12 where where WRB 31504 723 13 an an DT 31504 723 14 army army NN 31504 723 15 officer officer NN 31504 723 16 in in IN 31504 723 17 time time NN 31504 723 18 of of IN 31504 723 19 peace peace NN 31504 723 20 wantonly wantonly RB 31504 723 21 struck strike VBD 31504 723 22 and and CC 31504 723 23 wounded wound VBD 31504 723 24 a a DT 31504 723 25 peaceful peaceful JJ 31504 723 26 crippled crippled JJ 31504 723 27 citizen citizen NN 31504 723 28 with with IN 31504 723 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 723 30 sabre sabre NNP 31504 723 31 . . . 31504 724 1 The the DT 31504 724 2 victim victim NN 31504 724 3 could could MD 31504 724 4 only only RB 31504 724 5 appeal appeal VB 31504 724 6 to to IN 31504 724 7 the the DT 31504 724 8 officer officer NN 31504 724 9 's 's POS 31504 724 10 military military JJ 31504 724 11 superiors superior NNS 31504 724 12 , , , 31504 724 13 who who WP 31504 724 14 acquitted acquit VBD 31504 724 15 the the DT 31504 724 16 offender offender NN 31504 724 17 on on IN 31504 724 18 the the DT 31504 724 19 ground ground NN 31504 724 20 that that IN 31504 724 21 the the DT 31504 724 22 dignity dignity NN 31504 724 23 of of IN 31504 724 24 the the DT 31504 724 25 military military NN 31504 724 26 must must MD 31504 724 27 be be VB 31504 724 28 protected protect VBN 31504 724 29 . . . 31504 725 1 In in IN 31504 725 2 the the DT 31504 725 3 United United NNP 31504 725 4 Kingdom Kingdom NNP 31504 725 5 , , , 31504 725 6 while while IN 31504 725 7 at at IN 31504 725 8 present present NN 31504 725 9 , , , 31504 725 10 as as IN 31504 725 11 for for IN 31504 725 12 centuries century NNS 31504 725 13 , , , 31504 725 14 the the DT 31504 725 15 individual individual NN 31504 725 16 can can MD 31504 725 17 appeal appeal VB 31504 725 18 to to IN 31504 725 19 the the DT 31504 725 20 judicial judicial JJ 31504 725 21 courts court NNS 31504 725 22 against against IN 31504 725 23 officials official NNS 31504 725 24 acting act VBG 31504 725 25 under under IN 31504 725 26 any any DT 31504 725 27 executive executive JJ 31504 725 28 or or CC 31504 725 29 legislative legislative JJ 31504 725 30 orders order NNS 31504 725 31 , , , 31504 725 32 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 725 33 , , , 31504 725 34 and and CC 31504 725 35 even even RB 31504 725 36 a a DT 31504 725 37 majority majority NN 31504 725 38 of of IN 31504 725 39 the the DT 31504 725 40 House House NNP 31504 725 41 of of IN 31504 725 42 Commons Commons NNPS 31504 725 43 , , , 31504 725 44 can can MD 31504 725 45 at at IN 31504 725 46 any any DT 31504 725 47 time time NN 31504 725 48 deprive deprive VB 31504 725 49 him -PRON- PRP 31504 725 50 of of IN 31504 725 51 that that DT 31504 725 52 right right NN 31504 725 53 . . . 31504 726 1 In in IN 31504 726 2 this this DT 31504 726 3 country country NN 31504 726 4 the the DT 31504 726 5 executive executive JJ 31504 726 6 and and CC 31504 726 7 legislative legislative JJ 31504 726 8 departments department NNS 31504 726 9 combined combine VBN 31504 726 10 have have VBP 31504 726 11 no no DT 31504 726 12 such such JJ 31504 726 13 power power NN 31504 726 14 . . . 31504 727 1 So so RB 31504 727 2 long long RB 31504 727 3 as as IN 31504 727 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 727 5 present present JJ 31504 727 6 system system NN 31504 727 7 is be VBZ 31504 727 8 maintained maintain VBN 31504 727 9 , , , 31504 727 10 questions question NNS 31504 727 11 between between IN 31504 727 12 government government NN 31504 727 13 officials official NNS 31504 727 14 and and CC 31504 727 15 individuals individual NNS 31504 727 16 must must MD 31504 727 17 remain remain VB 31504 727 18 cognizable cognizable JJ 31504 727 19 by by IN 31504 727 20 the the DT 31504 727 21 judicial judicial JJ 31504 727 22 courts court NNS 31504 727 23 where where WRB 31504 727 24 the the DT 31504 727 25 private private JJ 31504 727 26 citizen citizen NN 31504 727 27 is be VBZ 31504 727 28 on on IN 31504 727 29 a a DT 31504 727 30 par par NN 31504 727 31 with with IN 31504 727 32 the the DT 31504 727 33 highest high JJS 31504 727 34 official official NN 31504 727 35 , , , 31504 727 36 and and CC 31504 727 37 the the DT 31504 727 38 single single JJ 31504 727 39 individual individual NN 31504 727 40 is be VBZ 31504 727 41 on on IN 31504 727 42 a a DT 31504 727 43 par par NN 31504 727 44 with with IN 31504 727 45 the the DT 31504 727 46 government government NN 31504 727 47 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 727 48 . . . 31504 728 1 In in IN 31504 728 2 contrast contrast NN 31504 728 3 to to IN 31504 728 4 the the DT 31504 728 5 Zabern zabern JJ 31504 728 6 affair affair NN 31504 728 7 we -PRON- PRP 31504 728 8 may may MD 31504 728 9 note note VB 31504 728 10 that that IN 31504 728 11 the the DT 31504 728 12 striking strike VBG 31504 728 13 copper copper NN 31504 728 14 miners miner NNS 31504 728 15 of of IN 31504 728 16 Michigan Michigan NNP 31504 728 17 were be VBD 31504 728 18 not not RB 31504 728 19 obliged oblige VBN 31504 728 20 to to TO 31504 728 21 apply apply VB 31504 728 22 to to IN 31504 728 23 higher high JJR 31504 728 24 military military JJ 31504 728 25 officials official NNS 31504 728 26 for for IN 31504 728 27 redress redress NN 31504 728 28 of of IN 31504 728 29 wrongs wrong NNS 31504 728 30 claimed claim VBD 31504 728 31 to to TO 31504 728 32 have have VB 31504 728 33 been be VBN 31504 728 34 inflicted inflict VBN 31504 728 35 upon upon IN 31504 728 36 them -PRON- PRP 31504 728 37 by by IN 31504 728 38 the the DT 31504 728 39 military military NN 31504 728 40 . . . 31504 729 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 729 2 were be VBD 31504 729 3 free free JJ 31504 729 4 to to TO 31504 729 5 apply apply VB 31504 729 6 , , , 31504 729 7 and and CC 31504 729 8 did do VBD 31504 729 9 apply apply VB 31504 729 10 , , , 31504 729 11 to to IN 31504 729 12 tribunals tribunal NNS 31504 729 13 outside outside RB 31504 729 14 of of IN 31504 729 15 and and CC 31504 729 16 independent independent JJ 31504 729 17 of of IN 31504 729 18 the the DT 31504 729 19 executive executive NN 31504 729 20 . . . 31504 730 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 730 2 and and CC 31504 730 3 such such JJ 31504 730 4 as as IN 31504 730 5 they -PRON- PRP 31504 730 6 should should MD 31504 730 7 be be VB 31504 730 8 the the DT 31504 730 9 most most RBS 31504 730 10 unwilling unwilling JJ 31504 730 11 to to TO 31504 730 12 degrade degrade VB 31504 730 13 the the DT 31504 730 14 courts court NNS 31504 730 15 or or CC 31504 730 16 lessen lessen VB 31504 730 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 730 18 power power NN 31504 730 19 . . . 31504 731 1 A a DT 31504 731 2 similar similar JJ 31504 731 3 instance instance NN 31504 731 4 is be VBZ 31504 731 5 that that DT 31504 731 6 of of IN 31504 731 7 the the DT 31504 731 8 striking strike VBG 31504 731 9 miners miner NNS 31504 731 10 in in IN 31504 731 11 Colorado Colorado NNP 31504 731 12 who who WP 31504 731 13 so so RB 31504 731 14 loudly loudly RB 31504 731 15 complained complain VBD 31504 731 16 of of IN 31504 731 17 the the DT 31504 731 18 acts act NNS 31504 731 19 of of IN 31504 731 20 the the DT 31504 731 21 militia militia NN 31504 731 22 . . . 31504 732 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 732 2 were be VBD 31504 732 3 not not RB 31504 732 4 obliged oblige VBN 31504 732 5 to to TO 31504 732 6 appeal appeal VB 31504 732 7 to to IN 31504 732 8 military military JJ 31504 732 9 or or CC 31504 732 10 executive executive JJ 31504 732 11 officers officer NNS 31504 732 12 for for IN 31504 732 13 redress redress NN 31504 732 14 . . . 31504 733 1 The the DT 31504 733 2 Judicial Judicial NNP 31504 733 3 Courts Courts NNPS 31504 733 4 were be VBD 31504 733 5 as as RB 31504 733 6 open open JJ 31504 733 7 to to IN 31504 733 8 them -PRON- PRP 31504 733 9 as as IN 31504 733 10 to to IN 31504 733 11 any any DT 31504 733 12 others other NNS 31504 733 13 and and CC 31504 733 14 there there RB 31504 733 15 they -PRON- PRP 31504 733 16 would would MD 31504 733 17 be be VB 31504 733 18 upon upon IN 31504 733 19 an an DT 31504 733 20 equality equality NN 31504 733 21 with with IN 31504 733 22 the the DT 31504 733 23 officials official NNS 31504 733 24 . . . 31504 734 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 31504 734 2 VIII viii VBP 31504 734 3 AN an DT 31504 734 4 INDEPENDENT INDEPENDENT NNP 31504 734 5 AND and CC 31504 734 6 IMPARTIAL IMPARTIAL NNP 31504 734 7 JUDICIARY judiciary NN 31504 734 8 ESSENTIAL essential NN 31504 734 9 FOR for IN 31504 734 10 JUSTICE justice NN 31504 734 11 For for IN 31504 734 12 the the DT 31504 734 13 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 734 14 to to TO 31504 734 15 be be VB 31504 734 16 in in IN 31504 734 17 fact fact NN 31504 734 18 , , , 31504 734 19 as as RB 31504 734 20 well well RB 31504 734 21 as as IN 31504 734 22 in in IN 31504 734 23 theory theory NN 31504 734 24 , , , 31504 734 25 the the DT 31504 734 26 protector protector NN 31504 734 27 of of IN 31504 734 28 the the DT 31504 734 29 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 734 30 rights right NNS 31504 734 31 of of IN 31504 734 32 the the DT 31504 734 33 individual individual NN 31504 734 34 against against IN 31504 734 35 the the DT 31504 734 36 government government NN 31504 734 37 , , , 31504 734 38 and and CC 31504 734 39 of of IN 31504 734 40 the the DT 31504 734 41 legal legal JJ 31504 734 42 rights right NNS 31504 734 43 of of IN 31504 734 44 the the DT 31504 734 45 individual individual NN 31504 734 46 against against IN 31504 734 47 the the DT 31504 734 48 aggressions aggression NNS 31504 734 49 of of IN 31504 734 50 others other NNS 31504 734 51 , , , 31504 734 52 it -PRON- PRP 31504 734 53 should should MD 31504 734 54 be be VB 31504 734 55 made make VBN 31504 734 56 so so RB 31504 734 57 far far RB 31504 734 58 as as IN 31504 734 59 possible possible JJ 31504 734 60 free free JJ 31504 734 61 , , , 31504 734 62 impartial impartial JJ 31504 734 63 and and CC 31504 734 64 independent independent JJ 31504 734 65 . . . 31504 735 1 The the DT 31504 735 2 judges judge NNS 31504 735 3 should should MD 31504 735 4 have have VB 31504 735 5 such such JJ 31504 735 6 security security NN 31504 735 7 of of IN 31504 735 8 tenure tenure NN 31504 735 9 , , , 31504 735 10 and and CC 31504 735 11 such such JJ 31504 735 12 security security NN 31504 735 13 and and CC 31504 735 14 liberality liberality NN 31504 735 15 of of IN 31504 735 16 maintenance maintenance NN 31504 735 17 , , , 31504 735 18 that that IN 31504 735 19 they -PRON- PRP 31504 735 20 will will MD 31504 735 21 have have VB 31504 735 22 no no DT 31504 735 23 occasion occasion NN 31504 735 24 nor nor CC 31504 735 25 disposition disposition NN 31504 735 26 to to TO 31504 735 27 court court VB 31504 735 28 the the DT 31504 735 29 favor favor NN 31504 735 30 , , , 31504 735 31 or or CC 31504 735 32 fear fear VB 31504 735 33 the the DT 31504 735 34 disfavor disfavor NN 31504 735 35 , , , 31504 735 36 of of IN 31504 735 37 any any DT 31504 735 38 individual individual JJ 31504 735 39 or or CC 31504 735 40 class class NN 31504 735 41 however however RB 31504 735 42 powerful powerful JJ 31504 735 43 or or CC 31504 735 44 numerous numerous JJ 31504 735 45 , , , 31504 735 46 not not RB 31504 735 47 even even RB 31504 735 48 the the DT 31504 735 49 government government NN 31504 735 50 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 735 51 . . . 31504 736 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 736 2 should should MD 31504 736 3 be be VB 31504 736 4 made make VBN 31504 736 5 free free JJ 31504 736 6 to to TO 31504 736 7 consider consider VB 31504 736 8 only only RB 31504 736 9 what what WP 31504 736 10 is be VBZ 31504 736 11 the the DT 31504 736 12 truth truth NN 31504 736 13 as as IN 31504 736 14 to to IN 31504 736 15 the the DT 31504 736 16 existing exist VBG 31504 736 17 law law NN 31504 736 18 or or CC 31504 736 19 fact fact NN 31504 736 20 in in IN 31504 736 21 question question NN 31504 736 22 , , , 31504 736 23 uninfluenced uninfluence VBN 31504 736 24 by by IN 31504 736 25 any any DT 31504 736 26 suggestions suggestion NNS 31504 736 27 of of IN 31504 736 28 what what WP 31504 736 29 is be VBZ 31504 736 30 demanded demand VBN 31504 736 31 by by IN 31504 736 32 prince prince NNP 31504 736 33 , , , 31504 736 34 people people NNS 31504 736 35 , , , 31504 736 36 or or CC 31504 736 37 individual individual NN 31504 736 38 , , , 31504 736 39 or or CC 31504 736 40 by by IN 31504 736 41 any any DT 31504 736 42 suggestion suggestion NN 31504 736 43 of of IN 31504 736 44 consequent consequent JJ 31504 736 45 good good JJ 31504 736 46 or or CC 31504 736 47 evil evil NN 31504 736 48 to to IN 31504 736 49 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 736 50 . . . 31504 737 1 This this DT 31504 737 2 proposition proposition NN 31504 737 3 to to IN 31504 737 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 31504 737 5 mind mind NN 31504 737 6 is be VBZ 31504 737 7 so so RB 31504 737 8 self self NN 31504 737 9 - - HYPH 31504 737 10 evident evident JJ 31504 737 11 that that IN 31504 737 12 quotations quotation NNS 31504 737 13 from from IN 31504 737 14 eminent eminent JJ 31504 737 15 philosophers philosopher NNS 31504 737 16 can can MD 31504 737 17 not not RB 31504 737 18 strengthen strengthen VB 31504 737 19 it -PRON- PRP 31504 737 20 . . . 31504 738 1 The the DT 31504 738 2 necessity necessity NN 31504 738 3 of of IN 31504 738 4 some some DT 31504 738 5 independent independent JJ 31504 738 6 tribunal tribunal NN 31504 738 7 between between IN 31504 738 8 the the DT 31504 738 9 governors governor NNS 31504 738 10 and and CC 31504 738 11 the the DT 31504 738 12 governed govern VBN 31504 738 13 was be VBD 31504 738 14 recognized recognize VBN 31504 738 15 in in IN 31504 738 16 republican republican JJ 31504 738 17 Rome Rome NNP 31504 738 18 , , , 31504 738 19 where where WRB 31504 738 20 it -PRON- PRP 31504 738 21 was be VBD 31504 738 22 provided provide VBN 31504 738 23 that that IN 31504 738 24 the the DT 31504 738 25 persons person NNS 31504 738 26 of of IN 31504 738 27 the the DT 31504 738 28 tribunes tribune NNS 31504 738 29 should should MD 31504 738 30 be be VB 31504 738 31 inviolate inviolate JJ 31504 738 32 , , , 31504 738 33 an an DT 31504 738 34 immunity immunity NN 31504 738 35 not not RB 31504 738 36 granted grant VBN 31504 738 37 to to IN 31504 738 38 any any DT 31504 738 39 other other JJ 31504 738 40 officials official NNS 31504 738 41 . . . 31504 739 1 The the DT 31504 739 2 medieval medieval JJ 31504 739 3 cities city NNS 31504 739 4 of of IN 31504 739 5 Italy Italy NNP 31504 739 6 frequently frequently RB 31504 739 7 selected select VBD 31504 739 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 739 9 judges judge NNS 31504 739 10 from from IN 31504 739 11 some some DT 31504 739 12 other other JJ 31504 739 13 city city NN 31504 739 14 that that WDT 31504 739 15 they -PRON- PRP 31504 739 16 might may MD 31504 739 17 be be VB 31504 739 18 free free JJ 31504 739 19 from from IN 31504 739 20 any any DT 31504 739 21 connection connection NN 31504 739 22 with with IN 31504 739 23 different different JJ 31504 739 24 local local JJ 31504 739 25 factions faction NNS 31504 739 26 or or CC 31504 739 27 interests interest NNS 31504 739 28 . . . 31504 740 1 When when WRB 31504 740 2 , , , 31504 740 3 however however RB 31504 740 4 , , , 31504 740 5 the the DT 31504 740 6 empire empire NN 31504 740 7 supplanted supplant VBD 31504 740 8 the the DT 31504 740 9 republic republic NN 31504 740 10 in in IN 31504 740 11 Rome Rome NNP 31504 740 12 , , , 31504 740 13 and and CC 31504 740 14 the the DT 31504 740 15 free free JJ 31504 740 16 cities city NNS 31504 740 17 of of IN 31504 740 18 Italy Italy NNP 31504 740 19 were be VBD 31504 740 20 made make VBN 31504 740 21 subject subject JJ 31504 740 22 to to IN 31504 740 23 despotic despotic JJ 31504 740 24 domination domination NN 31504 740 25 , , , 31504 740 26 the the DT 31504 740 27 independence independence NN 31504 740 28 of of IN 31504 740 29 these these DT 31504 740 30 tribunals tribunal NNS 31504 740 31 was be VBD 31504 740 32 lost lose VBN 31504 740 33 . . . 31504 741 1 History history NN 31504 741 2 shows show VBZ 31504 741 3 that that IN 31504 741 4 those those DT 31504 741 5 possessing possess VBG 31504 741 6 the the DT 31504 741 7 governmental governmental JJ 31504 741 8 power power NN 31504 741 9 have have VBP 31504 741 10 always always RB 31504 741 11 been be VBN 31504 741 12 unwilling unwilling JJ 31504 741 13 to to TO 31504 741 14 maintain maintain VB 31504 741 15 an an DT 31504 741 16 independent independent JJ 31504 741 17 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 741 18 . . . 31504 742 1 The the DT 31504 742 2 only only JJ 31504 742 3 countries country NNS 31504 742 4 today today NN 31504 742 5 possessing possess VBG 31504 742 6 a a DT 31504 742 7 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 742 8 with with IN 31504 742 9 any any DT 31504 742 10 considerable considerable JJ 31504 742 11 degree degree NN 31504 742 12 of of IN 31504 742 13 independence independence NN 31504 742 14 are be VBP 31504 742 15 the the DT 31504 742 16 United United NNP 31504 742 17 Kingdom Kingdom NNP 31504 742 18 and and CC 31504 742 19 some some DT 31504 742 20 of of IN 31504 742 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 742 22 " " `` 31504 742 23 Dominions dominion NNS 31504 742 24 beyond beyond IN 31504 742 25 the the DT 31504 742 26 seas sea NNS 31504 742 27 " " '' 31504 742 28 and and CC 31504 742 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 742 30 own own JJ 31504 742 31 country country NN 31504 742 32 . . . 31504 743 1 The the DT 31504 743 2 need need NN 31504 743 3 of of IN 31504 743 4 it -PRON- PRP 31504 743 5 was be VBD 31504 743 6 seen see VBN 31504 743 7 in in IN 31504 743 8 the the DT 31504 743 9 experience experience NN 31504 743 10 of of IN 31504 743 11 the the DT 31504 743 12 people people NNS 31504 743 13 of of IN 31504 743 14 England England NNP 31504 743 15 and and CC 31504 743 16 of of IN 31504 743 17 the the DT 31504 743 18 English English NNP 31504 743 19 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 743 20 in in IN 31504 743 21 America America NNP 31504 743 22 under under IN 31504 743 23 a a DT 31504 743 24 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 743 25 liable liable JJ 31504 743 26 to to TO 31504 743 27 be be VB 31504 743 28 deprived deprive VBN 31504 743 29 of of IN 31504 743 30 office office NN 31504 743 31 or or CC 31504 743 32 salary salary NN 31504 743 33 if if IN 31504 743 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 743 35 opinions opinion NNS 31504 743 36 were be VBD 31504 743 37 displeasing displease VBG 31504 743 38 to to IN 31504 743 39 the the DT 31504 743 40 crown crown NN 31504 743 41 . . . 31504 744 1 Charles Charles NNP 31504 744 2 I -PRON- PRP 31504 744 3 assented assent VBD 31504 744 4 to to IN 31504 744 5 the the DT 31504 744 6 Petition Petition NNP 31504 744 7 of of IN 31504 744 8 Right Right NNP 31504 744 9 and and CC 31504 744 10 promised promise VBD 31504 744 11 to to TO 31504 744 12 observe observe VB 31504 744 13 it -PRON- PRP 31504 744 14 , , , 31504 744 15 but but CC 31504 744 16 no no DT 31504 744 17 provision provision NN 31504 744 18 was be VBD 31504 744 19 made make VBN 31504 744 20 for for IN 31504 744 21 any any DT 31504 744 22 tribunal tribunal JJ 31504 744 23 independent independent JJ 31504 744 24 of of IN 31504 744 25 the the DT 31504 744 26 king king NN 31504 744 27 to to TO 31504 744 28 determine determine VB 31504 744 29 whether whether IN 31504 744 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 744 31 acts act NNS 31504 744 32 were be VBD 31504 744 33 in in IN 31504 744 34 violation violation NN 31504 744 35 of of IN 31504 744 36 any any DT 31504 744 37 article article NN 31504 744 38 of of IN 31504 744 39 the the DT 31504 744 40 Petition Petition NNP 31504 744 41 . . . 31504 745 1 Consequently consequently RB 31504 745 2 , , , 31504 745 3 when when WRB 31504 745 4 afterward afterward RB 31504 745 5 in in IN 31504 745 6 the the DT 31504 745 7 matter matter NN 31504 745 8 of of IN 31504 745 9 the the DT 31504 745 10 tonnage tonnage NN 31504 745 11 and and CC 31504 745 12 poundage poundage NN 31504 745 13 tax tax NN 31504 745 14 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 745 15 remonstrated remonstrate VBD 31504 745 16 against against IN 31504 745 17 the the DT 31504 745 18 imposition imposition NN 31504 745 19 of of IN 31504 745 20 the the DT 31504 745 21 tax tax NN 31504 745 22 as as IN 31504 745 23 a a DT 31504 745 24 violation violation NN 31504 745 25 of of IN 31504 745 26 the the DT 31504 745 27 royal royal JJ 31504 745 28 promise promise NN 31504 745 29 in in IN 31504 745 30 assenting assent VBG 31504 745 31 to to IN 31504 745 32 the the DT 31504 745 33 Petition Petition NNP 31504 745 34 of of IN 31504 745 35 Right Right NNP 31504 745 36 , , , 31504 745 37 the the DT 31504 745 38 king king NN 31504 745 39 abruptly abruptly RB 31504 745 40 ended end VBD 31504 745 41 the the DT 31504 745 42 session session NN 31504 745 43 and and CC 31504 745 44 in in IN 31504 745 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 745 46 speech speech NN 31504 745 47 of of IN 31504 745 48 prorogation prorogation NN 31504 745 49 denied deny VBD 31504 745 50 the the DT 31504 745 51 right right NN 31504 745 52 of of IN 31504 745 53 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 745 54 to to TO 31504 745 55 interpret interpret VB 31504 745 56 the the DT 31504 745 57 Petition Petition NNP 31504 745 58 and and CC 31504 745 59 asserted assert VBD 31504 745 60 that that IN 31504 745 61 it -PRON- PRP 31504 745 62 was be VBD 31504 745 63 for for IN 31504 745 64 him -PRON- PRP 31504 745 65 alone alone JJ 31504 745 66 to to TO 31504 745 67 determine determine VB 31504 745 68 " " `` 31504 745 69 the the DT 31504 745 70 true true JJ 31504 745 71 intent intent NN 31504 745 72 thereof thereof RB 31504 745 73 . . . 31504 745 74 " " '' 31504 746 1 Again again RB 31504 746 2 , , , 31504 746 3 the the DT 31504 746 4 legality legality NN 31504 746 5 of of IN 31504 746 6 the the DT 31504 746 7 imposition imposition NN 31504 746 8 by by IN 31504 746 9 the the DT 31504 746 10 king king NN 31504 746 11 of of IN 31504 746 12 the the DT 31504 746 13 " " `` 31504 746 14 ship ship NN 31504 746 15 money money NN 31504 746 16 " " '' 31504 746 17 tax tax NN 31504 746 18 without without IN 31504 746 19 the the DT 31504 746 20 consent consent NN 31504 746 21 of of IN 31504 746 22 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 746 23 was be VBD 31504 746 24 hopelessly hopelessly RB 31504 746 25 questioned question VBN 31504 746 26 . . . 31504 747 1 The the DT 31504 747 2 king king NN 31504 747 3 procured procure VBD 31504 747 4 from from IN 31504 747 5 the the DT 31504 747 6 judges judge NNS 31504 747 7 an an DT 31504 747 8 opinion opinion NN 31504 747 9 that that IN 31504 747 10 he -PRON- PRP 31504 747 11 could could MD 31504 747 12 lawfully lawfully RB 31504 747 13 impose impose VB 31504 747 14 such such PDT 31504 747 15 a a DT 31504 747 16 tax tax NN 31504 747 17 without without IN 31504 747 18 awaiting await VBG 31504 747 19 the the DT 31504 747 20 assent assent NN 31504 747 21 of of IN 31504 747 22 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 747 23 , , , 31504 747 24 when when WRB 31504 747 25 necessary necessary JJ 31504 747 26 for for IN 31504 747 27 the the DT 31504 747 28 defense defense NN 31504 747 29 of of IN 31504 747 30 the the DT 31504 747 31 kingdom kingdom NN 31504 747 32 , , , 31504 747 33 and and CC 31504 747 34 that that IN 31504 747 35 he -PRON- PRP 31504 747 36 was be VBD 31504 747 37 the the DT 31504 747 38 judge judge NN 31504 747 39 of of IN 31504 747 40 the the DT 31504 747 41 necessity necessity NN 31504 747 42 and and CC 31504 747 43 proper proper JJ 31504 747 44 amount amount NN 31504 747 45 of of IN 31504 747 46 the the DT 31504 747 47 tax tax NN 31504 747 48 . . . 31504 748 1 But but CC 31504 748 2 this this DT 31504 748 3 was be VBD 31504 748 4 not not RB 31504 748 5 the the DT 31504 748 6 opinion opinion NN 31504 748 7 of of IN 31504 748 8 an an DT 31504 748 9 independent independent JJ 31504 748 10 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 748 11 . . . 31504 749 1 The the DT 31504 749 2 judges judge NNS 31504 749 3 at at IN 31504 749 4 that that DT 31504 749 5 time time NN 31504 749 6 could could MD 31504 749 7 be be VB 31504 749 8 promoted promote VBN 31504 749 9 , , , 31504 749 10 removed remove VBN 31504 749 11 , , , 31504 749 12 or or CC 31504 749 13 " " `` 31504 749 14 recalled recall VBN 31504 749 15 " " '' 31504 749 16 at at IN 31504 749 17 any any DT 31504 749 18 time time NN 31504 749 19 at at IN 31504 749 20 the the DT 31504 749 21 king king NN 31504 749 22 's 's POS 31504 749 23 sole sole JJ 31504 749 24 pleasure pleasure NN 31504 749 25 , , , 31504 749 26 and and CC 31504 749 27 they -PRON- PRP 31504 749 28 well well RB 31504 749 29 knew know VBD 31504 749 30 the the DT 31504 749 31 king king NN 31504 749 32 's 's POS 31504 749 33 obstinate obstinate NN 31504 749 34 insistence insistence NN 31504 749 35 in in IN 31504 749 36 the the DT 31504 749 37 matter matter NN 31504 749 38 . . . 31504 750 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 750 2 opinion opinion NN 31504 750 3 simply simply RB 31504 750 4 gave give VBD 31504 750 5 expression expression NN 31504 750 6 to to IN 31504 750 7 the the DT 31504 750 8 king king NN 31504 750 9 's 's POS 31504 750 10 will will NN 31504 750 11 , , , 31504 750 12 and and CC 31504 750 13 hence hence RB 31504 750 14 inspired inspire VBD 31504 750 15 no no DT 31504 750 16 respect respect NN 31504 750 17 . . . 31504 751 1 Finally finally RB 31504 751 2 , , , 31504 751 3 for for IN 31504 751 4 want want NN 31504 751 5 of of IN 31504 751 6 an an DT 31504 751 7 independent independent JJ 31504 751 8 tribunal tribunal NN 31504 751 9 empowered empower VBN 31504 751 10 to to TO 31504 751 11 determine determine VB 31504 751 12 authoritatively authoritatively RB 31504 751 13 between between IN 31504 751 14 king king NN 31504 751 15 and and CC 31504 751 16 subject subject VB 31504 751 17 " " `` 31504 751 18 the the DT 31504 751 19 true true JJ 31504 751 20 intent intent NN 31504 751 21 " " '' 31504 751 22 of of IN 31504 751 23 the the DT 31504 751 24 Petition Petition NNP 31504 751 25 of of IN 31504 751 26 Right Right NNP 31504 751 27 , , , 31504 751 28 the the DT 31504 751 29 legal legal JJ 31504 751 30 extent extent NN 31504 751 31 and and CC 31504 751 32 limitation limitation NN 31504 751 33 of of IN 31504 751 34 the the DT 31504 751 35 royal royal JJ 31504 751 36 power power NN 31504 751 37 , , , 31504 751 38 the the DT 31504 751 39 lawfulness lawfulness NN 31504 751 40 of of IN 31504 751 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 751 42 exercise exercise NN 31504 751 43 upon upon IN 31504 751 44 the the DT 31504 751 45 subject subject NN 31504 751 46 in in IN 31504 751 47 a a DT 31504 751 48 given give VBN 31504 751 49 case case NN 31504 751 50 , , , 31504 751 51 the the DT 31504 751 52 issues issue NNS 31504 751 53 between between IN 31504 751 54 them -PRON- PRP 31504 751 55 had have VBD 31504 751 56 to to TO 31504 751 57 be be VB 31504 751 58 submitted submit VBN 31504 751 59 to to IN 31504 751 60 the the DT 31504 751 61 arbitrament arbitrament NN 31504 751 62 of of IN 31504 751 63 civil civil JJ 31504 751 64 war war NN 31504 751 65 , , , 31504 751 66 with with IN 31504 751 67 the the DT 31504 751 68 result result NN 31504 751 69 that that IN 31504 751 70 the the DT 31504 751 71 monarchical monarchical JJ 31504 751 72 system system NN 31504 751 73 of of IN 31504 751 74 government government NN 31504 751 75 was be VBD 31504 751 76 overthrown overthrow VBN 31504 751 77 . . . 31504 752 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 752 2 successor successor NN 31504 752 3 , , , 31504 752 4 an an DT 31504 752 5 unchecked unchecked JJ 31504 752 6 parliament parliament NN 31504 752 7 , , , 31504 752 8 was be VBD 31504 752 9 no no DT 31504 752 10 less less RBR 31504 752 11 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 31504 752 12 in in IN 31504 752 13 many many JJ 31504 752 14 of of IN 31504 752 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 752 16 acts act NNS 31504 752 17 , , , 31504 752 18 and and CC 31504 752 19 was be VBD 31504 752 20 in in IN 31504 752 21 turn turn NN 31504 752 22 overthrown overthrow VBN 31504 752 23 and and CC 31504 752 24 the the DT 31504 752 25 monarchy monarchy NN 31504 752 26 restored restore VBD 31504 752 27 . . . 31504 753 1 The the DT 31504 753 2 restored restore VBN 31504 753 3 dynasty dynasty NN 31504 753 4 , , , 31504 753 5 however however RB 31504 753 6 , , , 31504 753 7 obeying obey VBG 31504 753 8 the the DT 31504 753 9 impulse impulse NN 31504 753 10 of of IN 31504 753 11 all all DT 31504 753 12 possessors possessor NNS 31504 753 13 of of IN 31504 753 14 governmental governmental JJ 31504 753 15 powers power NNS 31504 753 16 , , , 31504 753 17 soon soon RB 31504 753 18 began begin VBD 31504 753 19 again again RB 31504 753 20 to to TO 31504 753 21 claim claim VB 31504 753 22 and and CC 31504 753 23 exercise exercise VB 31504 753 24 autocratic autocratic JJ 31504 753 25 power power NN 31504 753 26 , , , 31504 753 27 to to TO 31504 753 28 encroach encroach VB 31504 753 29 upon upon IN 31504 753 30 the the DT 31504 753 31 rights right NNS 31504 753 32 and and CC 31504 753 33 liberties liberty NNS 31504 753 34 thought think VBD 31504 753 35 to to TO 31504 753 36 have have VB 31504 753 37 been be VBN 31504 753 38 secured secure VBN 31504 753 39 to to IN 31504 753 40 the the DT 31504 753 41 subject subject NN 31504 753 42 by by IN 31504 753 43 the the DT 31504 753 44 royal royal JJ 31504 753 45 assent assent NN 31504 753 46 to to IN 31504 753 47 the the DT 31504 753 48 Petition Petition NNP 31504 753 49 of of IN 31504 753 50 Right Right NNP 31504 753 51 and and CC 31504 753 52 vindicated vindicate VBN 31504 753 53 by by IN 31504 753 54 successful successful JJ 31504 753 55 resistance resistance NN 31504 753 56 , , , 31504 753 57 and and CC 31504 753 58 also also RB 31504 753 59 to to TO 31504 753 60 suspend suspend VB 31504 753 61 the the DT 31504 753 62 operation operation NN 31504 753 63 of of IN 31504 753 64 the the DT 31504 753 65 laws law NNS 31504 753 66 at at IN 31504 753 67 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 753 68 pleasure pleasure NN 31504 753 69 . . . 31504 754 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 31504 754 2 again again RB 31504 754 3 there there EX 31504 754 4 was be VBD 31504 754 5 as as RB 31504 754 6 yet yet RB 31504 754 7 no no DT 31504 754 8 impartial impartial JJ 31504 754 9 , , , 31504 754 10 independent independent JJ 31504 754 11 tribunal tribunal NN 31504 754 12 in in IN 31504 754 13 England England NNP 31504 754 14 to to TO 31504 754 15 determine determine VB 31504 754 16 authoritatively authoritatively RB 31504 754 17 the the DT 31504 754 18 line line NN 31504 754 19 between between IN 31504 754 20 the the DT 31504 754 21 royal royal JJ 31504 754 22 power power NN 31504 754 23 and and CC 31504 754 24 the the DT 31504 754 25 specified specify VBN 31504 754 26 rights right NNS 31504 754 27 of of IN 31504 754 28 the the DT 31504 754 29 subject subject NN 31504 754 30 . . . 31504 755 1 The the DT 31504 755 2 judges judge NNS 31504 755 3 were be VBD 31504 755 4 still still RB 31504 755 5 removable removable JJ 31504 755 6 at at IN 31504 755 7 the the DT 31504 755 8 king king NN 31504 755 9 's 's POS 31504 755 10 sole sole JJ 31504 755 11 pleasure pleasure NN 31504 755 12 . . . 31504 756 1 James James NNP 31504 756 2 II II NNP 31504 756 3 did do VBD 31504 756 4 not not RB 31504 756 5 hesitate hesitate VB 31504 756 6 to to TO 31504 756 7 use use VB 31504 756 8 this this DT 31504 756 9 power power NN 31504 756 10 to to TO 31504 756 11 obtain obtain VB 31504 756 12 such such JJ 31504 756 13 opinions opinion NNS 31504 756 14 and and CC 31504 756 15 decisions decision NNS 31504 756 16 as as IN 31504 756 17 he -PRON- PRP 31504 756 18 desired desire VBD 31504 756 19 . . . 31504 757 1 Preparatory preparatory JJ 31504 757 2 to to IN 31504 757 3 the the DT 31504 757 4 trial trial NN 31504 757 5 of of IN 31504 757 6 the the DT 31504 757 7 Quo Quo NNP 31504 757 8 Warranto Warranto NNP 31504 757 9 case case NN 31504 757 10 against against IN 31504 757 11 the the DT 31504 757 12 City City NNP 31504 757 13 of of IN 31504 757 14 London London NNP 31504 757 15 to to TO 31504 757 16 procure procure VB 31504 757 17 the the DT 31504 757 18 forfeiture forfeiture NN 31504 757 19 of of IN 31504 757 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 757 21 charter charter NN 31504 757 22 , , , 31504 757 23 the the DT 31504 757 24 king king NN 31504 757 25 removed remove VBD 31504 757 26 Chief Chief NNP 31504 757 27 Justice Justice NNP 31504 757 28 Pemberton Pemberton NNP 31504 757 29 and and CC 31504 757 30 appointed appoint VBD 31504 757 31 in in IN 31504 757 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 757 33 place place NN 31504 757 34 the the DT 31504 757 35 servile servile JJ 31504 757 36 Saunders saunder NNS 31504 757 37 who who WP 31504 757 38 had have VBD 31504 757 39 drawn draw VBN 31504 757 40 the the DT 31504 757 41 writ writ NNP 31504 757 42 in in IN 31504 757 43 the the DT 31504 757 44 case case NN 31504 757 45 and and CC 31504 757 46 had have VBD 31504 757 47 conducted conduct VBN 31504 757 48 all all PDT 31504 757 49 the the DT 31504 757 50 proceedings proceeding NNS 31504 757 51 in in IN 31504 757 52 behalf behalf NN 31504 757 53 of of IN 31504 757 54 the the DT 31504 757 55 crown crown NN 31504 757 56 as as IN 31504 757 57 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 757 58 counsel counsel NN 31504 757 59 to to IN 31504 757 60 the the DT 31504 757 61 stage stage NN 31504 757 62 where where WRB 31504 757 63 the the DT 31504 757 64 case case NN 31504 757 65 was be VBD 31504 757 66 ready ready JJ 31504 757 67 for for IN 31504 757 68 argument argument NN 31504 757 69 in in IN 31504 757 70 the the DT 31504 757 71 Court Court NNP 31504 757 72 of of IN 31504 757 73 King King NNP 31504 757 74 's 's POS 31504 757 75 Bench Bench NNP 31504 757 76 . . . 31504 758 1 The the DT 31504 758 2 case case NN 31504 758 3 of of IN 31504 758 4 the the DT 31504 758 5 city city NN 31504 758 6 was be VBD 31504 758 7 thereby thereby RB 31504 758 8 made make VBN 31504 758 9 hopeless hopeless JJ 31504 758 10 and and CC 31504 758 11 the the DT 31504 758 12 city city NN 31504 758 13 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 758 14 helpless helpless JJ 31504 758 15 . . . 31504 759 1 In in IN 31504 759 2 the the DT 31504 759 3 case case NN 31504 759 4 of of IN 31504 759 5 the the DT 31504 759 6 " " `` 31504 759 7 Seven Seven NNP 31504 759 8 Bishops Bishops NNPS 31504 759 9 , , , 31504 759 10 " " '' 31504 759 11 prosecuted prosecute VBN 31504 759 12 for for IN 31504 759 13 libel libel NN 31504 759 14 in in IN 31504 759 15 presenting present VBG 31504 759 16 to to IN 31504 759 17 the the DT 31504 759 18 king king NN 31504 759 19 a a DT 31504 759 20 petition petition NN 31504 759 21 for for IN 31504 759 22 him -PRON- PRP 31504 759 23 to to TO 31504 759 24 recall recall VB 31504 759 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 759 26 order order NN 31504 759 27 for for IN 31504 759 28 the the DT 31504 759 29 reading reading NN 31504 759 30 in in IN 31504 759 31 the the DT 31504 759 32 churches church NNS 31504 759 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 759 34 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 759 35 of of IN 31504 759 36 Indulgence Indulgence NNP 31504 759 37 , , , 31504 759 38 he -PRON- PRP 31504 759 39 seems seem VBZ 31504 759 40 to to TO 31504 759 41 have have VB 31504 759 42 felt feel VBN 31504 759 43 tolerably tolerably RB 31504 759 44 sure sure JJ 31504 759 45 of of IN 31504 759 46 the the DT 31504 759 47 court court NN 31504 759 48 as as IN 31504 759 49 it -PRON- PRP 31504 759 50 was be VBD 31504 759 51 already already RB 31504 759 52 constituted constitute VBN 31504 759 53 . . . 31504 760 1 Two two CD 31504 760 2 able able JJ 31504 760 3 and and CC 31504 760 4 learned learn VBD 31504 760 5 justices justice NNS 31504 760 6 , , , 31504 760 7 however however RB 31504 760 8 , , , 31504 760 9 Holloway Holloway NNP 31504 760 10 and and CC 31504 760 11 Powell Powell NNP 31504 760 12 , , , 31504 760 13 ventured venture VBD 31504 760 14 the the DT 31504 760 15 opinion opinion NN 31504 760 16 that that IN 31504 760 17 the the DT 31504 760 18 petition petition NN 31504 760 19 was be VBD 31504 760 20 not not RB 31504 760 21 libelous libelous JJ 31504 760 22 . . . 31504 761 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 761 2 were be VBD 31504 761 3 both both DT 31504 761 4 promptly promptly RB 31504 761 5 " " '' 31504 761 6 recalled recall VBN 31504 761 7 . . . 31504 761 8 " " '' 31504 762 1 Again again RB 31504 762 2 force force NN 31504 762 3 had have VBD 31504 762 4 to to TO 31504 762 5 be be VB 31504 762 6 used use VBN 31504 762 7 to to TO 31504 762 8 free free VB 31504 762 9 the the DT 31504 762 10 subject subject NN 31504 762 11 and and CC 31504 762 12 maintain maintain VB 31504 762 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 762 14 " " `` 31504 762 15 rights right NNS 31504 762 16 and and CC 31504 762 17 liberties liberty NNS 31504 762 18 " " '' 31504 762 19 against against IN 31504 762 20 the the DT 31504 762 21 sovereign sovereign NN 31504 762 22 . . . 31504 763 1 James James NNP 31504 763 2 II II NNP 31504 763 3 was be VBD 31504 763 4 driven drive VBN 31504 763 5 from from IN 31504 763 6 the the DT 31504 763 7 country country NN 31504 763 8 and and CC 31504 763 9 William William NNP 31504 763 10 of of IN 31504 763 11 Orange Orange NNP 31504 763 12 called call VBD 31504 763 13 to to IN 31504 763 14 the the DT 31504 763 15 throne throne NN 31504 763 16 . . . 31504 764 1 This this DT 31504 764 2 time time NN 31504 764 3 the the DT 31504 764 4 people people NNS 31504 764 5 in in IN 31504 764 6 settling settle VBG 31504 764 7 the the DT 31504 764 8 new new JJ 31504 764 9 government government NN 31504 764 10 through through IN 31504 764 11 parliamentary parliamentary JJ 31504 764 12 action action NN 31504 764 13 went go VBD 31504 764 14 farther far RBR 31504 764 15 than than IN 31504 764 16 before before RB 31504 764 17 in in IN 31504 764 18 the the DT 31504 764 19 way way NN 31504 764 20 of of IN 31504 764 21 restraint restraint NN 31504 764 22 upon upon IN 31504 764 23 the the DT 31504 764 24 government government NN 31504 764 25 and and CC 31504 764 26 took take VBD 31504 764 27 the the DT 31504 764 28 necessary necessary JJ 31504 764 29 step step NN 31504 764 30 to to TO 31504 764 31 secure secure VB 31504 764 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 764 33 rights right NNS 31504 764 34 and and CC 31504 764 35 liberties liberty NNS 31504 764 36 . . . 31504 765 1 In in IN 31504 765 2 a a DT 31504 765 3 new new JJ 31504 765 4 instrument instrument NN 31504 765 5 , , , 31504 765 6 this this DT 31504 765 7 time time NN 31504 765 8 called call VBD 31504 765 9 a a DT 31504 765 10 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 765 11 instead instead RB 31504 765 12 of of IN 31504 765 13 a a DT 31504 765 14 Petition Petition NNP 31504 765 15 , , , 31504 765 16 they -PRON- PRP 31504 765 17 reiterated reiterate VBD 31504 765 18 the the DT 31504 765 19 rights right NNS 31504 765 20 of of IN 31504 765 21 the the DT 31504 765 22 subject subject NN 31504 765 23 as as RB 31504 765 24 twice twice RB 31504 765 25 before before IN 31504 765 26 they -PRON- PRP 31504 765 27 had have VBD 31504 765 28 been be VBN 31504 765 29 formally formally RB 31504 765 30 asserted assert VBN 31504 765 31 in in IN 31504 765 32 the the DT 31504 765 33 Magna Magna NNPS 31504 765 34 Charta Charta NNP 31504 765 35 and and CC 31504 765 36 the the DT 31504 765 37 Petition Petition NNP 31504 765 38 of of IN 31504 765 39 Right right UH 31504 765 40 . . . 31504 766 1 This this DT 31504 766 2 instrument instrument NN 31504 766 3 , , , 31504 766 4 known know VBN 31504 766 5 as as IN 31504 766 6 the the DT 31504 766 7 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 766 8 of of IN 31504 766 9 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 766 10 of of IN 31504 766 11 1688 1688 CD 31504 766 12 , , , 31504 766 13 was be VBD 31504 766 14 presented present VBN 31504 766 15 to to IN 31504 766 16 William William NNP 31504 766 17 and and CC 31504 766 18 Mary Mary NNP 31504 766 19 , , , 31504 766 20 who who WP 31504 766 21 solemnly solemnly RB 31504 766 22 engaged engage VBD 31504 766 23 to to TO 31504 766 24 observe observe VB 31504 766 25 and and CC 31504 766 26 maintain maintain VB 31504 766 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 766 28 provisions provision NNS 31504 766 29 . . . 31504 767 1 Further further RB 31504 767 2 still still RB 31504 767 3 ( ( -LRB- 31504 767 4 and and CC 31504 767 5 this this DT 31504 767 6 was be VBD 31504 767 7 the the DT 31504 767 8 new new JJ 31504 767 9 and and CC 31504 767 10 effective effective JJ 31504 767 11 guaranty guaranty NN 31504 767 12 of of IN 31504 767 13 the the DT 31504 767 14 subject subject NN 31504 767 15 's 's POS 31504 767 16 rights right NNS 31504 767 17 ) ) -RRB- 31504 767 18 , , , 31504 767 19 in in IN 31504 767 20 the the DT 31504 767 21 Act Act NNP 31504 767 22 for for IN 31504 767 23 the the DT 31504 767 24 settlement settlement NN 31504 767 25 of of IN 31504 767 26 the the DT 31504 767 27 crown crown NN 31504 767 28 it -PRON- PRP 31504 767 29 was be VBD 31504 767 30 enacted enact VBN 31504 767 31 by by IN 31504 767 32 king king NN 31504 767 33 , , , 31504 767 34 lords lord NNS 31504 767 35 , , , 31504 767 36 and and CC 31504 767 37 commons common NNS 31504 767 38 that that WDT 31504 767 39 thereafter thereafter RB 31504 767 40 the the DT 31504 767 41 judicial judicial JJ 31504 767 42 tenure tenure NN 31504 767 43 of of IN 31504 767 44 the the DT 31504 767 45 judges judge NNS 31504 767 46 of of IN 31504 767 47 the the DT 31504 767 48 courts court NNS 31504 767 49 should should MD 31504 767 50 be be VB 31504 767 51 during during IN 31504 767 52 good good JJ 31504 767 53 behavior behavior NN 31504 767 54 . . . 31504 768 1 Since since IN 31504 768 2 that that DT 31504 768 3 time time NN 31504 768 4 for for IN 31504 768 5 more more JJR 31504 768 6 than than IN 31504 768 7 two two CD 31504 768 8 centuries century NNS 31504 768 9 " " `` 31504 768 10 the the DT 31504 768 11 true true JJ 31504 768 12 intent intent NN 31504 768 13 " " '' 31504 768 14 of of IN 31504 768 15 the the DT 31504 768 16 laws law NNS 31504 768 17 has have VBZ 31504 768 18 been be VBN 31504 768 19 determined determine VBN 31504 768 20 , , , 31504 768 21 not not RB 31504 768 22 by by IN 31504 768 23 king king NN 31504 768 24 or or CC 31504 768 25 parliament parliament NN 31504 768 26 or or CC 31504 768 27 people people NNS 31504 768 28 , , , 31504 768 29 but but CC 31504 768 30 by by IN 31504 768 31 a a DT 31504 768 32 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 768 33 made make VBD 31504 768 34 strong strong JJ 31504 768 35 and and CC 31504 768 36 independent independent JJ 31504 768 37 . . . 31504 769 1 There there EX 31504 769 2 has have VBZ 31504 769 3 been be VBN 31504 769 4 no no DT 31504 769 5 need need NN 31504 769 6 to to TO 31504 769 7 resort resort VB 31504 769 8 to to IN 31504 769 9 force force NN 31504 769 10 to to TO 31504 769 11 defend defend VB 31504 769 12 the the DT 31504 769 13 legal legal JJ 31504 769 14 rights right NNS 31504 769 15 of of IN 31504 769 16 the the DT 31504 769 17 subject subject NN 31504 769 18 . . . 31504 770 1 But but CC 31504 770 2 this this DT 31504 770 3 security security NN 31504 770 4 for for IN 31504 770 5 individual individual JJ 31504 770 6 rights right NNS 31504 770 7 and and CC 31504 770 8 liberties liberty NNS 31504 770 9 was be VBD 31504 770 10 not not RB 31504 770 11 extended extend VBN 31504 770 12 to to IN 31504 770 13 British british JJ 31504 770 14 subjects subject NNS 31504 770 15 in in IN 31504 770 16 America America NNP 31504 770 17 . . . 31504 771 1 After after IN 31504 771 2 the the DT 31504 771 3 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 771 4 had have VBD 31504 771 5 so so RB 31504 771 6 increased increase VBN 31504 771 7 in in IN 31504 771 8 population population NN 31504 771 9 and and CC 31504 771 10 wealth wealth NN 31504 771 11 that that IN 31504 771 12 they -PRON- PRP 31504 771 13 were be VBD 31504 771 14 deemed deem VBN 31504 771 15 worth worth JJ 31504 771 16 exploitation exploitation NN 31504 771 17 , , , 31504 771 18 the the DT 31504 771 19 government government NN 31504 771 20 , , , 31504 771 21 among among IN 31504 771 22 other other JJ 31504 771 23 means mean NNS 31504 771 24 of of IN 31504 771 25 controlling control VBG 31504 771 26 them -PRON- PRP 31504 771 27 , , , 31504 771 28 took take VBD 31504 771 29 over over RP 31504 771 30 the the DT 31504 771 31 appointment appointment NN 31504 771 32 of of IN 31504 771 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 771 34 judges judge NNS 31504 771 35 , , , 31504 771 36 in in IN 31504 771 37 many many JJ 31504 771 38 instances instance NNS 31504 771 39 with with IN 31504 771 40 a a DT 31504 771 41 tenure tenure NN 31504 771 42 during during IN 31504 771 43 the the DT 31504 771 44 government government NN 31504 771 45 's 's POS 31504 771 46 pleasure pleasure NN 31504 771 47 only only RB 31504 771 48 . . . 31504 772 1 In in IN 31504 772 2 the the DT 31504 772 3 circular circular JJ 31504 772 4 letter letter NN 31504 772 5 of of IN 31504 772 6 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 772 7 Bay Bay NNP 31504 772 8 Colony Colony NNP 31504 772 9 to to IN 31504 772 10 the the DT 31504 772 11 other other JJ 31504 772 12 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 772 13 in in IN 31504 772 14 1768 1768 CD 31504 772 15 they -PRON- PRP 31504 772 16 are be VBP 31504 772 17 asked ask VBN 31504 772 18 to to TO 31504 772 19 consider consider VB 31504 772 20 whether whether IN 31504 772 21 for for IN 31504 772 22 the the DT 31504 772 23 judges judge NNS 31504 772 24 of of IN 31504 772 25 the the DT 31504 772 26 land land NN 31504 772 27 not not RB 31504 772 28 to to TO 31504 772 29 hold hold VB 31504 772 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 772 31 commissions commission NNS 31504 772 32 during during IN 31504 772 33 good good JJ 31504 772 34 behavior behavior NN 31504 772 35 and and CC 31504 772 36 to to TO 31504 772 37 have have VB 31504 772 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 772 39 salaries salary NNS 31504 772 40 appointed appoint VBN 31504 772 41 for for IN 31504 772 42 them -PRON- PRP 31504 772 43 by by IN 31504 772 44 the the DT 31504 772 45 crown crown NN 31504 772 46 did do VBD 31504 772 47 not not RB 31504 772 48 have have VB 31504 772 49 a a DT 31504 772 50 tendency tendency NN 31504 772 51 to to TO 31504 772 52 " " `` 31504 772 53 endanger endanger VB 31504 772 54 the the DT 31504 772 55 happiness happiness NN 31504 772 56 and and CC 31504 772 57 security security NN 31504 772 58 of of IN 31504 772 59 the the DT 31504 772 60 subjects subject NNS 31504 772 61 . . . 31504 772 62 " " '' 31504 773 1 One one CD 31504 773 2 of of IN 31504 773 3 the the DT 31504 773 4 counts count NNS 31504 773 5 in in IN 31504 773 6 the the DT 31504 773 7 indictment indictment NN 31504 773 8 of of IN 31504 773 9 July July NNP 31504 773 10 4 4 CD 31504 773 11 , , , 31504 773 12 1776 1776 CD 31504 773 13 , , , 31504 773 14 against against IN 31504 773 15 the the DT 31504 773 16 king king NN 31504 773 17 's 's POS 31504 773 18 government government NN 31504 773 19 was be VBD 31504 773 20 that that IN 31504 773 21 it -PRON- PRP 31504 773 22 had have VBD 31504 773 23 made make VBN 31504 773 24 the the DT 31504 773 25 colonial colonial JJ 31504 773 26 judges judge NNS 31504 773 27 dependent dependent JJ 31504 773 28 on on IN 31504 773 29 the the DT 31504 773 30 king king NN 31504 773 31 's 's POS 31504 773 32 will will MD 31504 773 33 alone alone JJ 31504 773 34 for for IN 31504 773 35 the the DT 31504 773 36 tenure tenure NN 31504 773 37 of of IN 31504 773 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 773 39 offices office NNS 31504 773 40 and and CC 31504 773 41 the the DT 31504 773 42 amount amount NN 31504 773 43 and and CC 31504 773 44 payment payment NN 31504 773 45 of of IN 31504 773 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 773 47 salaries salary NNS 31504 773 48 . . . 31504 774 1 As as IN 31504 774 2 a a DT 31504 774 3 consequence consequence NN 31504 774 4 of of IN 31504 774 5 this this DT 31504 774 6 experience experience NN 31504 774 7 with with IN 31504 774 8 a a DT 31504 774 9 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 774 10 dependent dependent JJ 31504 774 11 on on IN 31504 774 12 the the DT 31504 774 13 governing govern VBG 31504 774 14 power power NN 31504 774 15 for for IN 31504 774 16 the the DT 31504 774 17 tenure tenure NN 31504 774 18 and and CC 31504 774 19 maintenance maintenance NN 31504 774 20 of of IN 31504 774 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 774 22 judges judge NNS 31504 774 23 , , , 31504 774 24 the the DT 31504 774 25 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 774 26 when when WRB 31504 774 27 they -PRON- PRP 31504 774 28 set set VBP 31504 774 29 up up RP 31504 774 30 independent independent JJ 31504 774 31 governments government NNS 31504 774 32 of of IN 31504 774 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 774 34 own own JJ 31504 774 35 provided provide VBN 31504 774 36 a a DT 31504 774 37 fixed fix VBN 31504 774 38 tenure tenure NN 31504 774 39 for for IN 31504 774 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 774 41 judges judge NNS 31504 774 42 in in IN 31504 774 43 every every DT 31504 774 44 instance instance NN 31504 774 45 but but CC 31504 774 46 one one CD 31504 774 47 . . . 31504 775 1 Connecticut Connecticut NNP 31504 775 2 in in IN 31504 775 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 775 4 first first JJ 31504 775 5 constitution constitution NN 31504 775 6 made make VBD 31504 775 7 the the DT 31504 775 8 tenure tenure NN 31504 775 9 during during IN 31504 775 10 good good JJ 31504 775 11 behavior behavior NN 31504 775 12 , , , 31504 775 13 as as IN 31504 775 14 did do VBD 31504 775 15 Delaware Delaware NNP 31504 775 16 , , , 31504 775 17 Maryland Maryland NNP 31504 775 18 , , , 31504 775 19 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 775 20 , , , 31504 775 21 New New NNP 31504 775 22 Hampshire Hampshire NNP 31504 775 23 , , , 31504 775 24 North North NNP 31504 775 25 Carolina Carolina NNP 31504 775 26 , , , 31504 775 27 South South NNP 31504 775 28 Carolina Carolina NNP 31504 775 29 , , , 31504 775 30 and and CC 31504 775 31 Virginia Virginia NNP 31504 775 32 . . . 31504 776 1 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP 31504 776 2 at at IN 31504 776 3 first first RB 31504 776 4 fixed fix VBD 31504 776 5 the the DT 31504 776 6 tenure tenure NN 31504 776 7 at at IN 31504 776 8 seven seven CD 31504 776 9 years year NNS 31504 776 10 , , , 31504 776 11 but but CC 31504 776 12 in in IN 31504 776 13 1790 1790 CD 31504 776 14 changed change VBD 31504 776 15 it -PRON- PRP 31504 776 16 to to IN 31504 776 17 good good JJ 31504 776 18 behavior behavior NN 31504 776 19 . . . 31504 777 1 The the DT 31504 777 2 same same JJ 31504 777 3 tenure tenure NN 31504 777 4 was be VBD 31504 777 5 fixed fix VBN 31504 777 6 for for IN 31504 777 7 the the DT 31504 777 8 federal federal JJ 31504 777 9 judges judge NNS 31504 777 10 in in IN 31504 777 11 the the DT 31504 777 12 Federal Federal NNP 31504 777 13 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 777 14 . . . 31504 778 1 In in IN 31504 778 2 some some DT 31504 778 3 instances instance NNS 31504 778 4 also also RB 31504 778 5 , , , 31504 778 6 further further JJ 31504 778 7 provision provision NN 31504 778 8 was be VBD 31504 778 9 made make VBN 31504 778 10 for for IN 31504 778 11 the the DT 31504 778 12 independence independence NN 31504 778 13 of of IN 31504 778 14 the the DT 31504 778 15 judges judge NNS 31504 778 16 by by IN 31504 778 17 forbidding forbid VBG 31504 778 18 the the DT 31504 778 19 diminishing diminishing NN 31504 778 20 of of IN 31504 778 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 778 22 salaries salary NNS 31504 778 23 during during IN 31504 778 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 778 25 term term NN 31504 778 26 of of IN 31504 778 27 office office NN 31504 778 28 . . . 31504 779 1 The the DT 31504 779 2 people people NNS 31504 779 3 of of IN 31504 779 4 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 779 5 , , , 31504 779 6 which which WDT 31504 779 7 had have VBD 31504 779 8 been be VBN 31504 779 9 the the DT 31504 779 10 most most RBS 31504 779 11 harried harried JJ 31504 779 12 of of IN 31504 779 13 the the DT 31504 779 14 Colonies Colonies NNPS 31504 779 15 , , , 31504 779 16 declared declare VBD 31504 779 17 emphatically emphatically RB 31504 779 18 the the DT 31504 779 19 necessity necessity NN 31504 779 20 for for IN 31504 779 21 an an DT 31504 779 22 independent independent JJ 31504 779 23 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 779 24 . . . 31504 780 1 Article article NN 31504 780 2 XXIX xxix NN 31504 780 3 of of IN 31504 780 4 the the DT 31504 780 5 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 780 6 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 780 7 of of IN 31504 780 8 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 780 9 adopted adopt VBN 31504 780 10 in in IN 31504 780 11 1780 1780 CD 31504 780 12 is be VBZ 31504 780 13 as as IN 31504 780 14 follows follow VBZ 31504 780 15 : : : 31504 780 16 " " `` 31504 780 17 It -PRON- PRP 31504 780 18 is be VBZ 31504 780 19 essential essential JJ 31504 780 20 to to IN 31504 780 21 the the DT 31504 780 22 preservation preservation NN 31504 780 23 of of IN 31504 780 24 every every DT 31504 780 25 individual individual NN 31504 780 26 , , , 31504 780 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 780 28 life life NN 31504 780 29 , , , 31504 780 30 liberty liberty NN 31504 780 31 and and CC 31504 780 32 property property NN 31504 780 33 and and CC 31504 780 34 character character NN 31504 780 35 that that IN 31504 780 36 there there EX 31504 780 37 be be VB 31504 780 38 an an DT 31504 780 39 impartial impartial JJ 31504 780 40 interpretation interpretation NN 31504 780 41 of of IN 31504 780 42 the the DT 31504 780 43 laws law NNS 31504 780 44 , , , 31504 780 45 and and CC 31504 780 46 administration administration NN 31504 780 47 of of IN 31504 780 48 justice justice NN 31504 780 49 . . . 31504 781 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 781 2 is be VBZ 31504 781 3 the the DT 31504 781 4 right right NN 31504 781 5 of of IN 31504 781 6 every every DT 31504 781 7 citizen citizen NN 31504 781 8 to to TO 31504 781 9 be be VB 31504 781 10 tried try VBN 31504 781 11 by by IN 31504 781 12 judges judge NNS 31504 781 13 as as IN 31504 781 14 free free JJ 31504 781 15 , , , 31504 781 16 impartial impartial JJ 31504 781 17 and and CC 31504 781 18 independent independent JJ 31504 781 19 as as IN 31504 781 20 the the DT 31504 781 21 lot lot NN 31504 781 22 of of IN 31504 781 23 humanity humanity NN 31504 781 24 will will MD 31504 781 25 admit admit VB 31504 781 26 . . . 31504 782 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 782 2 is be VBZ 31504 782 3 , , , 31504 782 4 therefore therefore RB 31504 782 5 , , , 31504 782 6 not not RB 31504 782 7 only only RB 31504 782 8 the the DT 31504 782 9 best good JJS 31504 782 10 policy policy NN 31504 782 11 but but CC 31504 782 12 for for IN 31504 782 13 the the DT 31504 782 14 security security NN 31504 782 15 of of IN 31504 782 16 the the DT 31504 782 17 rights right NNS 31504 782 18 of of IN 31504 782 19 the the DT 31504 782 20 people people NNS 31504 782 21 and and CC 31504 782 22 of of IN 31504 782 23 every every DT 31504 782 24 citizen citizen NN 31504 782 25 that that WDT 31504 782 26 the the DT 31504 782 27 judges judge NNS 31504 782 28 of of IN 31504 782 29 the the DT 31504 782 30 supreme supreme NNP 31504 782 31 judicial judicial NNP 31504 782 32 court court NN 31504 782 33 should should MD 31504 782 34 hold hold VB 31504 782 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 782 36 offices office NNS 31504 782 37 so so RB 31504 782 38 long long RB 31504 782 39 as as IN 31504 782 40 they -PRON- PRP 31504 782 41 behave behave VBP 31504 782 42 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 782 43 well well RB 31504 782 44 ; ; : 31504 782 45 and and CC 31504 782 46 that that IN 31504 782 47 they -PRON- PRP 31504 782 48 should should MD 31504 782 49 have have VB 31504 782 50 honorable honorable JJ 31504 782 51 salaries salary NNS 31504 782 52 ascertained ascertain VBN 31504 782 53 and and CC 31504 782 54 established establish VBN 31504 782 55 by by IN 31504 782 56 standing stand VBG 31504 782 57 laws law NNS 31504 782 58 . . . 31504 782 59 " " '' 31504 783 1 New New NNP 31504 783 2 Hampshire Hampshire NNP 31504 783 3 , , , 31504 783 4 with with IN 31504 783 5 a a DT 31504 783 6 similar similar JJ 31504 783 7 experience experience NN 31504 783 8 , , , 31504 783 9 adopted adopt VBD 31504 783 10 the the DT 31504 783 11 same same JJ 31504 783 12 language language NN 31504 783 13 in in IN 31504 783 14 Art art NN 31504 783 15 . . . 31504 784 1 XXXV XXXV NNP 31504 784 2 of of IN 31504 784 3 her -PRON- PRP$ 31504 784 4 Bill Bill NNP 31504 784 5 of of IN 31504 784 6 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 784 7 . . . 31504 785 1 The the DT 31504 785 2 Maryland Maryland NNP 31504 785 3 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 785 4 of of IN 31504 785 5 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 785 6 of of IN 31504 785 7 1776 1776 CD 31504 785 8 contains contain VBZ 31504 785 9 this this DT 31504 785 10 article article NN 31504 785 11 : : : 31504 785 12 " " `` 31504 785 13 Art art NN 31504 785 14 . . . 31504 786 1 XXX XXX NNP 31504 786 2 . . . 31504 787 1 That that IN 31504 787 2 the the DT 31504 787 3 independency independency NN 31504 787 4 and and CC 31504 787 5 uprightness uprightness JJ 31504 787 6 of of IN 31504 787 7 the the DT 31504 787 8 judges judge NNS 31504 787 9 are be VBP 31504 787 10 essential essential JJ 31504 787 11 to to IN 31504 787 12 the the DT 31504 787 13 impartial impartial JJ 31504 787 14 administration administration NN 31504 787 15 of of IN 31504 787 16 justice justice NNP 31504 787 17 and and CC 31504 787 18 a a DT 31504 787 19 great great JJ 31504 787 20 security security NN 31504 787 21 to to IN 31504 787 22 the the DT 31504 787 23 rights right NNS 31504 787 24 and and CC 31504 787 25 liberties liberty NNS 31504 787 26 of of IN 31504 787 27 the the DT 31504 787 28 people people NNS 31504 787 29 ; ; : 31504 787 30 wherefore wherefore VBD 31504 787 31 the the DT 31504 787 32 chancellor chancellor NNP 31504 787 33 and and CC 31504 787 34 judges judge NNS 31504 787 35 ought ought MD 31504 787 36 to to TO 31504 787 37 hold hold VB 31504 787 38 commissions commission NNS 31504 787 39 during during IN 31504 787 40 good good JJ 31504 787 41 behavior behavior NN 31504 787 42 . . . 31504 787 43 " " '' 31504 788 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 788 2 is be VBZ 31504 788 3 true true JJ 31504 788 4 that that IN 31504 788 5 in in IN 31504 788 6 most most JJS 31504 788 7 of of IN 31504 788 8 the the DT 31504 788 9 states state NNS 31504 788 10 the the DT 31504 788 11 official official JJ 31504 788 12 tenure tenure NN 31504 788 13 of of IN 31504 788 14 the the DT 31504 788 15 judges judge NNS 31504 788 16 has have VBZ 31504 788 17 since since RB 31504 788 18 been be VBN 31504 788 19 reduced reduce VBN 31504 788 20 to to IN 31504 788 21 a a DT 31504 788 22 more more RBR 31504 788 23 or or CC 31504 788 24 less less JJR 31504 788 25 brief brief JJ 31504 788 26 term term NN 31504 788 27 of of IN 31504 788 28 years year NNS 31504 788 29 . . . 31504 789 1 This this DT 31504 789 2 fact fact NN 31504 789 3 is be VBZ 31504 789 4 only only RB 31504 789 5 another another DT 31504 789 6 instance instance NN 31504 789 7 of of IN 31504 789 8 the the DT 31504 789 9 tendency tendency NN 31504 789 10 of of IN 31504 789 11 the the DT 31504 789 12 governing govern VBG 31504 789 13 power power NN 31504 789 14 to to TO 31504 789 15 lower lower VB 31504 789 16 if if IN 31504 789 17 not not RB 31504 789 18 remove remove VB 31504 789 19 all all DT 31504 789 20 barriers barrier NNS 31504 789 21 set set VBN 31504 789 22 up up RP 31504 789 23 against against IN 31504 789 24 it -PRON- PRP 31504 789 25 for for IN 31504 789 26 the the DT 31504 789 27 protection protection NN 31504 789 28 of of IN 31504 789 29 the the DT 31504 789 30 individual individual NN 31504 789 31 . . . 31504 790 1 Majorities majority NNS 31504 790 2 as as RB 31504 790 3 well well RB 31504 790 4 as as IN 31504 790 5 absolute absolute JJ 31504 790 6 kings king NNS 31504 790 7 like like IN 31504 790 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 790 9 own own JJ 31504 790 10 way way NN 31504 790 11 . . . 31504 791 1 The the DT 31504 791 2 change change NN 31504 791 3 where where WRB 31504 791 4 made make VBN 31504 791 5 may may MD 31504 791 6 have have VB 31504 791 7 given give VBN 31504 791 8 majorities majority NNS 31504 791 9 greater great JJR 31504 791 10 freedom freedom NN 31504 791 11 to to TO 31504 791 12 enforce enforce VB 31504 791 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 791 14 will will NN 31504 791 15 upon upon IN 31504 791 16 individuals individual NNS 31504 791 17 , , , 31504 791 18 but but CC 31504 791 19 it -PRON- PRP 31504 791 20 has have VBZ 31504 791 21 not not RB 31504 791 22 increased increase VBN 31504 791 23 confidence confidence NN 31504 791 24 in in IN 31504 791 25 the the DT 31504 791 26 integrity integrity NN 31504 791 27 of of IN 31504 791 28 the the DT 31504 791 29 judges judge NNS 31504 791 30 nor nor CC 31504 791 31 made make VBD 31504 791 32 them -PRON- PRP 31504 791 33 more more JJR 31504 791 34 firm firm JJ 31504 791 35 to to IN 31504 791 36 ascertain ascertain VB 31504 791 37 and and CC 31504 791 38 declare declare VB 31504 791 39 only only RB 31504 791 40 the the DT 31504 791 41 truth truth NN 31504 791 42 . . . 31504 792 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 792 2 is be VBZ 31504 792 3 true true JJ 31504 792 4 also also RB 31504 792 5 that that IN 31504 792 6 in in IN 31504 792 7 most most JJS 31504 792 8 states state NNS 31504 792 9 now now RB 31504 792 10 the the DT 31504 792 11 people people NNS 31504 792 12 have have VBP 31504 792 13 taken take VBN 31504 792 14 to to IN 31504 792 15 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 792 16 directly directly RB 31504 792 17 the the DT 31504 792 18 task task NN 31504 792 19 of of IN 31504 792 20 selecting select VBG 31504 792 21 men man NNS 31504 792 22 suitable suitable JJ 31504 792 23 for for IN 31504 792 24 judges judge NNS 31504 792 25 instead instead RB 31504 792 26 of of IN 31504 792 27 entrusting entrust VBG 31504 792 28 that that IN 31504 792 29 important important JJ 31504 792 30 duty duty NN 31504 792 31 to to IN 31504 792 32 the the DT 31504 792 33 governor governor NN 31504 792 34 or or CC 31504 792 35 legislature legislature NN 31504 792 36 , , , 31504 792 37 as as IN 31504 792 38 was be VBD 31504 792 39 the the DT 31504 792 40 practice practice NN 31504 792 41 in in IN 31504 792 42 the the DT 31504 792 43 early early JJ 31504 792 44 days day NNS 31504 792 45 of of IN 31504 792 46 the the DT 31504 792 47 republic republic NN 31504 792 48 . . . 31504 793 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 793 2 can can MD 31504 793 3 not not RB 31504 793 4 think think VB 31504 793 5 this this DT 31504 793 6 has have VBZ 31504 793 7 tended tend VBN 31504 793 8 to to TO 31504 793 9 secure secure VB 31504 793 10 better well JJR 31504 793 11 judges judge NNS 31504 793 12 , , , 31504 793 13 though though IN 31504 793 14 it -PRON- PRP 31504 793 15 may may MD 31504 793 16 have have VB 31504 793 17 secured secure VBN 31504 793 18 judges judge NNS 31504 793 19 more more RBR 31504 793 20 subservient subservient NN 31504 793 21 to to IN 31504 793 22 majorities majority NNS 31504 793 23 . . . 31504 794 1 Effectually effectually RB 31504 794 2 to to TO 31504 794 3 guard guard VB 31504 794 4 the the DT 31504 794 5 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 794 6 and and CC 31504 794 7 legal legal JJ 31504 794 8 rights right NNS 31504 794 9 of of IN 31504 794 10 all all DT 31504 794 11 alike alike RB 31504 794 12 , , , 31504 794 13 the the DT 31504 794 14 judges judge NNS 31504 794 15 should should MD 31504 794 16 possess possess VB 31504 794 17 what what WP 31504 794 18 is be VBZ 31504 794 19 called call VBN 31504 794 20 the the DT 31504 794 21 legal legal JJ 31504 794 22 mind mind NN 31504 794 23 and and CC 31504 794 24 the the DT 31504 794 25 judicial judicial JJ 31504 794 26 temperament temperament NN 31504 794 27 . . . 31504 795 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 795 2 should should MD 31504 795 3 be be VB 31504 795 4 able able JJ 31504 795 5 and and CC 31504 795 6 learned learn VBD 31504 795 7 that that IN 31504 795 8 they -PRON- PRP 31504 795 9 may may MD 31504 795 10 appreciate appreciate VB 31504 795 11 the the DT 31504 795 12 real real JJ 31504 795 13 meaning meaning NN 31504 795 14 , , , 31504 795 15 purpose purpose NN 31504 795 16 , , , 31504 795 17 and and CC 31504 795 18 scope scope NN 31504 795 19 of of IN 31504 795 20 the the DT 31504 795 21 constitution constitution NN 31504 795 22 and and CC 31504 795 23 statutes statute NNS 31504 795 24 ; ; , 31504 795 25 calm calm JJ 31504 795 26 and and CC 31504 795 27 equable equable JJ 31504 795 28 in in IN 31504 795 29 temperament temperament NN 31504 795 30 that that IN 31504 795 31 they -PRON- PRP 31504 795 32 may may MD 31504 795 33 not not RB 31504 795 34 be be VB 31504 795 35 influenced influence VBN 31504 795 36 by by IN 31504 795 37 sympathy sympathy NN 31504 795 38 , , , 31504 795 39 prejudice prejudice NN 31504 795 40 , , , 31504 795 41 or or CC 31504 795 42 other other JJ 31504 795 43 emotions emotion NNS 31504 795 44 ; ; , 31504 795 45 strong strong JJ 31504 795 46 and and CC 31504 795 47 courageous courageous JJ 31504 795 48 in in IN 31504 795 49 character character NN 31504 795 50 that that IN 31504 795 51 they -PRON- PRP 31504 795 52 may may MD 31504 795 53 resist resist VB 31504 795 54 all all DT 31504 795 55 pressure pressure NN 31504 795 56 other other JJ 31504 795 57 than than IN 31504 795 58 fair fair JJ 31504 795 59 argument argument NN 31504 795 60 . . . 31504 796 1 To to TO 31504 796 2 find find VB 31504 796 3 the the DT 31504 796 4 men man NNS 31504 796 5 possessing possess VBG 31504 796 6 these these DT 31504 796 7 qualities quality NNS 31504 796 8 requires require VBZ 31504 796 9 extensive extensive JJ 31504 796 10 and and CC 31504 796 11 protracted protracted JJ 31504 796 12 inquiry inquiry NN 31504 796 13 and and CC 31504 796 14 patient patient JJ 31504 796 15 consideration consideration NN 31504 796 16 , , , 31504 796 17 such such JJ 31504 796 18 as as IN 31504 796 19 are be VBP 31504 796 20 not not RB 31504 796 21 and and CC 31504 796 22 can can MD 31504 796 23 not not RB 31504 796 24 be be VB 31504 796 25 exercised exercise VBN 31504 796 26 by by IN 31504 796 27 the the DT 31504 796 28 people people NNS 31504 796 29 directly directly RB 31504 796 30 . . . 31504 797 1 The the DT 31504 797 2 task task NN 31504 797 3 should should MD 31504 797 4 be be VB 31504 797 5 deputed depute VBN 31504 797 6 in in IN 31504 797 7 the the DT 31504 797 8 first first JJ 31504 797 9 instance instance NN 31504 797 10 to to IN 31504 797 11 the the DT 31504 797 12 head head NN 31504 797 13 of of IN 31504 797 14 the the DT 31504 797 15 state state NN 31504 797 16 , , , 31504 797 17 the the DT 31504 797 18 chief chief JJ 31504 797 19 executive executive NN 31504 797 20 . . . 31504 798 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 798 2 has have VBZ 31504 798 3 the the DT 31504 798 4 best good JJS 31504 798 5 means mean NNS 31504 798 6 of of IN 31504 798 7 ascertaining ascertaining NN 31504 798 8 who who WP 31504 798 9 possesses possess VBZ 31504 798 10 the the DT 31504 798 11 requisite requisite JJ 31504 798 12 qualifications qualification NNS 31504 798 13 in in IN 31504 798 14 the the DT 31504 798 15 greatest great JJS 31504 798 16 degree degree NN 31504 798 17 . . . 31504 799 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 799 2 would would MD 31504 799 3 feel feel VB 31504 799 4 that that IN 31504 799 5 he -PRON- PRP 31504 799 6 alone alone RB 31504 799 7 was be VBD 31504 799 8 responsible responsible JJ 31504 799 9 for for IN 31504 799 10 a a DT 31504 799 11 proper proper JJ 31504 799 12 selection selection NN 31504 799 13 , , , 31504 799 14 and and CC 31504 799 15 that that IN 31504 799 16 feeling feeling NN 31504 799 17 of of IN 31504 799 18 responsibility responsibility NN 31504 799 19 would would MD 31504 799 20 tend tend VB 31504 799 21 to to TO 31504 799 22 make make VB 31504 799 23 him -PRON- PRP 31504 799 24 deliberate deliberate JJ 31504 799 25 and and CC 31504 799 26 painstaking painstaking JJ 31504 799 27 in in IN 31504 799 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 799 29 choice choice NN 31504 799 30 . . . 31504 800 1 On on IN 31504 800 2 the the DT 31504 800 3 other other JJ 31504 800 4 hand hand NN 31504 800 5 , , , 31504 800 6 if if IN 31504 800 7 the the DT 31504 800 8 original original JJ 31504 800 9 selection selection NN 31504 800 10 be be VB 31504 800 11 entrusted entrust VBN 31504 800 12 to to IN 31504 800 13 the the DT 31504 800 14 legislature legislature NN 31504 800 15 or or CC 31504 800 16 left leave VBD 31504 800 17 with with IN 31504 800 18 the the DT 31504 800 19 people people NNS 31504 800 20 acting act VBG 31504 800 21 directly directly RB 31504 800 22 , , , 31504 800 23 individual individual JJ 31504 800 24 members member NNS 31504 800 25 would would MD 31504 800 26 have have VB 31504 800 27 a a DT 31504 800 28 much much RB 31504 800 29 lower low JJR 31504 800 30 sense sense NN 31504 800 31 of of IN 31504 800 32 personal personal JJ 31504 800 33 responsibility responsibility NN 31504 800 34 and and CC 31504 800 35 the the DT 31504 800 36 individual individual JJ 31504 800 37 members member NNS 31504 800 38 of of IN 31504 800 39 the the DT 31504 800 40 electorate electorate NN 31504 800 41 scarcely scarcely RB 31504 800 42 any any DT 31504 800 43 at at RB 31504 800 44 all all RB 31504 800 45 . . . 31504 801 1 True true JJ 31504 801 2 , , , 31504 801 3 in in IN 31504 801 4 those those DT 31504 801 5 states state NNS 31504 801 6 where where WRB 31504 801 7 the the DT 31504 801 8 judges judge NNS 31504 801 9 are be VBP 31504 801 10 elected elect VBN 31504 801 11 by by IN 31504 801 12 the the DT 31504 801 13 people people NNS 31504 801 14 directly directly RB 31504 801 15 , , , 31504 801 16 excellent excellent JJ 31504 801 17 judges judge NNS 31504 801 18 are be VBP 31504 801 19 often often RB 31504 801 20 and and CC 31504 801 21 perhaps perhaps RB 31504 801 22 ordinarily ordinarily RB 31504 801 23 chosen choose VBN 31504 801 24 , , , 31504 801 25 but but CC 31504 801 26 I -PRON- PRP 31504 801 27 think think VBP 31504 801 28 I -PRON- PRP 31504 801 29 state state VBP 31504 801 30 a a DT 31504 801 31 truth truth NN 31504 801 32 in in IN 31504 801 33 stating state VBG 31504 801 34 that that IN 31504 801 35 upon upon IN 31504 801 36 the the DT 31504 801 37 whole whole JJ 31504 801 38 those those DT 31504 801 39 courts court NNS 31504 801 40 composed compose VBN 31504 801 41 of of IN 31504 801 42 judges judge NNS 31504 801 43 with with IN 31504 801 44 a a DT 31504 801 45 long long JJ 31504 801 46 tenure tenure NN 31504 801 47 and and CC 31504 801 48 appointed appoint VBN 31504 801 49 by by IN 31504 801 50 the the DT 31504 801 51 executive executive JJ 31504 801 52 stand stand NN 31504 801 53 higher high JJR 31504 801 54 in in IN 31504 801 55 public public JJ 31504 801 56 estimation estimation NN 31504 801 57 and and CC 31504 801 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 801 59 opinions opinion NNS 31504 801 60 have have VBP 31504 801 61 greater great JJR 31504 801 62 weight weight NN 31504 801 63 . . . 31504 802 1 Such such JJ 31504 802 2 courts court NNS 31504 802 3 are be VBP 31504 802 4 certainly certainly RB 31504 802 5 a a DT 31504 802 6 greater great JJR 31504 802 7 protection protection NN 31504 802 8 to to IN 31504 802 9 those those DT 31504 802 10 guilty guilty JJ 31504 802 11 of of IN 31504 802 12 no no DT 31504 802 13 wrong wrong NN 31504 802 14 , , , 31504 802 15 but but CC 31504 802 16 who who WP 31504 802 17 have have VBP 31504 802 18 been be VBN 31504 802 19 so so RB 31504 802 20 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 31504 802 21 as as IN 31504 802 22 to to TO 31504 802 23 incur incur VB 31504 802 24 the the DT 31504 802 25 displeasure displeasure NN 31504 802 26 of of IN 31504 802 27 an an DT 31504 802 28 excited excited JJ 31504 802 29 community community NN 31504 802 30 . . . 31504 803 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 31504 803 2 , , , 31504 803 3 despite despite IN 31504 803 4 the the DT 31504 803 5 lessons lesson NNS 31504 803 6 of of IN 31504 803 7 history history NN 31504 803 8 and and CC 31504 803 9 the the DT 31504 803 10 reasons reason NNS 31504 803 11 contra contra NNP 31504 803 12 , , , 31504 803 13 it -PRON- PRP 31504 803 14 is be VBZ 31504 803 15 proposed propose VBN 31504 803 16 in in IN 31504 803 17 this this DT 31504 803 18 twentieth twentieth JJ 31504 803 19 century century NN 31504 803 20 that that WDT 31504 803 21 the the DT 31504 803 22 tenure tenure NN 31504 803 23 of of IN 31504 803 24 the the DT 31504 803 25 judges judge NNS 31504 803 26 shall shall MD 31504 803 27 again again RB 31504 803 28 be be VB 31504 803 29 during during IN 31504 803 30 pleasure pleasure NN 31504 803 31 only,--this only,--this NNP 31504 803 32 time time NN 31504 803 33 during during IN 31504 803 34 the the DT 31504 803 35 pleasure pleasure NN 31504 803 36 of of IN 31504 803 37 the the DT 31504 803 38 majority majority NN 31504 803 39 of of IN 31504 803 40 the the DT 31504 803 41 electorate electorate NN 31504 803 42 . . . 31504 804 1 The the DT 31504 804 2 proposition proposition NN 31504 804 3 is be VBZ 31504 804 4 not not RB 31504 804 5 stated state VBN 31504 804 6 so so RB 31504 804 7 baldly baldly RB 31504 804 8 by by IN 31504 804 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 804 10 proposers proposer NNS 31504 804 11 . . . 31504 805 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 805 2 phrase phrase VBP 31504 805 3 it -PRON- PRP 31504 805 4 as as IN 31504 805 5 the the DT 31504 805 6 right right NN 31504 805 7 of of IN 31504 805 8 the the DT 31504 805 9 people people NNS 31504 805 10 to to TO 31504 805 11 remove remove VB 31504 805 12 or or CC 31504 805 13 recall recall VB 31504 805 14 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 31504 805 15 public public JJ 31504 805 16 servants servant NNS 31504 805 17 , , , 31504 805 18 whether whether IN 31504 805 19 judges judge NNS 31504 805 20 , , , 31504 805 21 or or CC 31504 805 22 governors governor NNS 31504 805 23 , , , 31504 805 24 or or CC 31504 805 25 other other JJ 31504 805 26 officials official NNS 31504 805 27 . . . 31504 806 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 806 2 propose propose VBP 31504 806 3 that that IN 31504 806 4 at at IN 31504 806 5 the the DT 31504 806 6 request request NN 31504 806 7 of of IN 31504 806 8 a a DT 31504 806 9 certain certain JJ 31504 806 10 small small JJ 31504 806 11 percentage percentage NN 31504 806 12 of of IN 31504 806 13 the the DT 31504 806 14 electorate electorate NN 31504 806 15 , , , 31504 806 16 setting set VBG 31504 806 17 forth forth RP 31504 806 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 806 19 dissatisfaction dissatisfaction NN 31504 806 20 with with IN 31504 806 21 a a DT 31504 806 22 judge judge NN 31504 806 23 , , , 31504 806 24 he -PRON- PRP 31504 806 25 may may MD 31504 806 26 be be VB 31504 806 27 removed remove VBN 31504 806 28 by by IN 31504 806 29 a a DT 31504 806 30 majority majority NN 31504 806 31 of of IN 31504 806 32 the the DT 31504 806 33 voters voter NNS 31504 806 34 . . . 31504 807 1 As as IN 31504 807 2 precedents precedent NNS 31504 807 3 for for IN 31504 807 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 807 5 proposal proposal NN 31504 807 6 they -PRON- PRP 31504 807 7 point point VBP 31504 807 8 triumphantly triumphantly RB 31504 807 9 to to IN 31504 807 10 the the DT 31504 807 11 provision provision NN 31504 807 12 of of IN 31504 807 13 the the DT 31504 807 14 British British NNP 31504 807 15 Act Act NNP 31504 807 16 of of IN 31504 807 17 Settlement Settlement NNP 31504 807 18 that that WDT 31504 807 19 judges judge NNS 31504 807 20 should should MD 31504 807 21 be be VB 31504 807 22 removable removable JJ 31504 807 23 by by IN 31504 807 24 the the DT 31504 807 25 crown crown NN 31504 807 26 upon upon IN 31504 807 27 the the DT 31504 807 28 request request NN 31504 807 29 of of IN 31504 807 30 both both DT 31504 807 31 Houses Houses NNPS 31504 807 32 of of IN 31504 807 33 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 807 34 , , , 31504 807 35 and and CC 31504 807 36 to to IN 31504 807 37 similar similar JJ 31504 807 38 provisions provision NNS 31504 807 39 in in IN 31504 807 40 many many JJ 31504 807 41 of of IN 31504 807 42 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 807 43 state state NN 31504 807 44 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 807 45 . . . 31504 808 1 Of of RB 31504 808 2 course course RB 31504 808 3 , , , 31504 808 4 there there EX 31504 808 5 should should MD 31504 808 6 be be VB 31504 808 7 lodged lodge VBN 31504 808 8 somewhere somewhere RB 31504 808 9 the the DT 31504 808 10 power power NN 31504 808 11 to to TO 31504 808 12 remove remove VB 31504 808 13 judges judge NNS 31504 808 14 proven prove VBN 31504 808 15 to to TO 31504 808 16 be be VB 31504 808 17 unworthy unworthy JJ 31504 808 18 of of IN 31504 808 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 808 20 high high JJ 31504 808 21 office office NN 31504 808 22 , , , 31504 808 23 or or CC 31504 808 24 incapable incapable JJ 31504 808 25 of of IN 31504 808 26 performing perform VBG 31504 808 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 808 28 high high JJ 31504 808 29 duties duty NNS 31504 808 30 , , , 31504 808 31 but but CC 31504 808 32 it -PRON- PRP 31504 808 33 should should MD 31504 808 34 be be VB 31504 808 35 lodged lodge VBN 31504 808 36 in in IN 31504 808 37 a a DT 31504 808 38 body body NN 31504 808 39 of of IN 31504 808 40 men man NNS 31504 808 41 before before IN 31504 808 42 whom whom WP 31504 808 43 the the DT 31504 808 44 accused accuse VBN 31504 808 45 judge judge NN 31504 808 46 can can MD 31504 808 47 appear appear VB 31504 808 48 in in IN 31504 808 49 person person NN 31504 808 50 or or CC 31504 808 51 by by IN 31504 808 52 counsel counsel NN 31504 808 53 , , , 31504 808 54 hear hear VBP 31504 808 55 the the DT 31504 808 56 complaints complaint NNS 31504 808 57 and and CC 31504 808 58 face face VB 31504 808 59 the the DT 31504 808 60 witnesses witness NNS 31504 808 61 against against IN 31504 808 62 him -PRON- PRP 31504 808 63 , , , 31504 808 64 and and CC 31504 808 65 adduce adduce VB 31504 808 66 evidence evidence NN 31504 808 67 and and CC 31504 808 68 argument argument NN 31504 808 69 in in IN 31504 808 70 reply,--and reply,--and NNS 31504 808 71 who who WP 31504 808 72 can can MD 31504 808 73 on on IN 31504 808 74 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 808 75 part part NN 31504 808 76 see see VB 31504 808 77 the the DT 31504 808 78 witnesses witness NNS 31504 808 79 and and CC 31504 808 80 hear hear VB 31504 808 81 the the DT 31504 808 82 arguments argument NNS 31504 808 83 before before IN 31504 808 84 deciding decide VBG 31504 808 85 . . . 31504 809 1 That that DT 31504 809 2 was be VBD 31504 809 3 the the DT 31504 809 4 opinion opinion NN 31504 809 5 of of IN 31504 809 6 the the DT 31504 809 7 British British NNP 31504 809 8 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 809 9 in in IN 31504 809 10 the the DT 31504 809 11 few few JJ 31504 809 12 cases case NNS 31504 809 13 presented present VBN 31504 809 14 to to IN 31504 809 15 them -PRON- PRP 31504 809 16 , , , 31504 809 17 and and CC 31504 809 18 the the DT 31504 809 19 state state NN 31504 809 20 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 809 21 in in IN 31504 809 22 this this DT 31504 809 23 country country NN 31504 809 24 have have VBP 31504 809 25 generally generally RB 31504 809 26 entertained entertain VBN 31504 809 27 the the DT 31504 809 28 same same JJ 31504 809 29 opinion opinion NN 31504 809 30 . . . 31504 810 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 810 2 was be VBD 31504 810 3 also also RB 31504 810 4 held hold VBN 31504 810 5 by by IN 31504 810 6 Parliament Parliament NNP 31504 810 7 that that IN 31504 810 8 the the DT 31504 810 9 address address NN 31504 810 10 for for IN 31504 810 11 removal removal NN 31504 810 12 should should MD 31504 810 13 state state VB 31504 810 14 the the DT 31504 810 15 reasons reason NNS 31504 810 16 therefor therefor IN 31504 810 17 . . . 31504 811 1 In in IN 31504 811 2 1855 1855 CD 31504 811 3 Governor Governor NNP 31504 811 4 Gardner Gardner NNP 31504 811 5 of of IN 31504 811 6 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 811 7 declined decline VBD 31504 811 8 to to TO 31504 811 9 remove remove VB 31504 811 10 a a DT 31504 811 11 judge judge NN 31504 811 12 of of IN 31504 811 13 probate probate NN 31504 811 14 on on IN 31504 811 15 address address NN 31504 811 16 by by IN 31504 811 17 the the DT 31504 811 18 legislature legislature NN 31504 811 19 because because IN 31504 811 20 no no DT 31504 811 21 sufficient sufficient JJ 31504 811 22 grounds ground NNS 31504 811 23 were be VBD 31504 811 24 stated state VBN 31504 811 25 in in IN 31504 811 26 the the DT 31504 811 27 address address NN 31504 811 28 . . . 31504 812 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 812 2 said say VBD 31504 812 3 that that IN 31504 812 4 in in IN 31504 812 5 every every DT 31504 812 6 instance instance NN 31504 812 7 then then RB 31504 812 8 on on IN 31504 812 9 record record NN 31504 812 10 full full JJ 31504 812 11 reasons reason NNS 31504 812 12 for for IN 31504 812 13 removal removal NN 31504 812 14 had have VBD 31504 812 15 accompanied accompany VBN 31504 812 16 the the DT 31504 812 17 address address NN 31504 812 18 . . . 31504 813 1 The the DT 31504 813 2 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 813 3 provision provision NN 31504 813 4 for for IN 31504 813 5 removal removal NN 31504 813 6 by by IN 31504 813 7 address address NN 31504 813 8 evidently evidently RB 31504 813 9 was be VBD 31504 813 10 not not RB 31504 813 11 designed design VBN 31504 813 12 to to TO 31504 813 13 lessen lessen VB 31504 813 14 the the DT 31504 813 15 impartiality impartiality NN 31504 813 16 and and CC 31504 813 17 independence independence NN 31504 813 18 of of IN 31504 813 19 the the DT 31504 813 20 judge judge NN 31504 813 21 by by IN 31504 813 22 subjecting subject VBG 31504 813 23 him -PRON- PRP 31504 813 24 to to IN 31504 813 25 removal removal NN 31504 813 26 at at IN 31504 813 27 the the DT 31504 813 28 mere mere JJ 31504 813 29 will will NN 31504 813 30 of of IN 31504 813 31 the the DT 31504 813 32 executive executive NN 31504 813 33 and and CC 31504 813 34 legislature legislature NN 31504 813 35 , , , 31504 813 36 but but CC 31504 813 37 that that IN 31504 813 38 he -PRON- PRP 31504 813 39 might may MD 31504 813 40 be be VB 31504 813 41 removed remove VBN 31504 813 42 for for IN 31504 813 43 corruption corruption NN 31504 813 44 , , , 31504 813 45 neglect neglect NN 31504 813 46 of of IN 31504 813 47 duty duty NN 31504 813 48 , , , 31504 813 49 incapacity incapacity NN 31504 813 50 , , , 31504 813 51 immorality immorality NN 31504 813 52 , , , 31504 813 53 or or CC 31504 813 54 other other JJ 31504 813 55 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 31504 813 56 conduct conduct NN 31504 813 57 , , , 31504 813 58 after after IN 31504 813 59 notice notice NN 31504 813 60 , , , 31504 813 61 hearing hearing NN 31504 813 62 , , , 31504 813 63 and and CC 31504 813 64 deliberation deliberation NN 31504 813 65 . . . 31504 814 1 For for IN 31504 814 2 the the DT 31504 814 3 executive executive NN 31504 814 4 and and CC 31504 814 5 legislature legislature NN 31504 814 6 , , , 31504 814 7 or or CC 31504 814 8 even even RB 31504 814 9 the the DT 31504 814 10 majority majority NN 31504 814 11 of of IN 31504 814 12 the the DT 31504 814 13 people people NNS 31504 814 14 , , , 31504 814 15 to to TO 31504 814 16 remove remove VB 31504 814 17 a a DT 31504 814 18 judge judge NN 31504 814 19 because because IN 31504 814 20 they -PRON- PRP 31504 814 21 do do VBP 31504 814 22 not not RB 31504 814 23 like like VB 31504 814 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 814 25 opinions opinion NNS 31504 814 26 as as IN 31504 814 27 to to IN 31504 814 28 what what WP 31504 814 29 the the DT 31504 814 30 constitution constitution NN 31504 814 31 requires require VBZ 31504 814 32 or or CC 31504 814 33 forbids forbid VBZ 31504 814 34 them -PRON- PRP 31504 814 35 to to TO 31504 814 36 do do VB 31504 814 37 , , , 31504 814 38 would would MD 31504 814 39 destroy destroy VB 31504 814 40 the the DT 31504 814 41 independence independence NN 31504 814 42 of of IN 31504 814 43 the the DT 31504 814 44 judges judge NNS 31504 814 45 and and CC 31504 814 46 thus thus RB 31504 814 47 deprive deprive VB 31504 814 48 the the DT 31504 814 49 citizen citizen NN 31504 814 50 of of IN 31504 814 51 all all DT 31504 814 52 security security NN 31504 814 53 for for IN 31504 814 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 814 55 rights right NNS 31504 814 56 and and CC 31504 814 57 liberties liberty NNS 31504 814 58 under under IN 31504 814 59 the the DT 31504 814 60 constitution,--would constitution,--would MD 31504 814 61 be be VB 31504 814 62 despotism despotism NN 31504 814 63 . . . 31504 815 1 The the DT 31504 815 2 principal principal JJ 31504 815 3 argument argument NN 31504 815 4 for for IN 31504 815 5 lessening lessen VBG 31504 815 6 the the DT 31504 815 7 independence independence NN 31504 815 8 of of IN 31504 815 9 the the DT 31504 815 10 judges judge NNS 31504 815 11 and and CC 31504 815 12 making make VBG 31504 815 13 them -PRON- PRP 31504 815 14 more more JJR 31504 815 15 subservient subservient NN 31504 815 16 to to IN 31504 815 17 the the DT 31504 815 18 inconstant inconstant JJ 31504 815 19 majority majority NN 31504 815 20 seems seem VBZ 31504 815 21 to to TO 31504 815 22 be be VB 31504 815 23 that that IN 31504 815 24 otherwise otherwise RB 31504 815 25 the the DT 31504 815 26 judges judge NNS 31504 815 27 will will MD 31504 815 28 misuse misuse VB 31504 815 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 815 30 power power NN 31504 815 31 and and CC 31504 815 32 impede impede VB 31504 815 33 the the DT 31504 815 34 operation operation NN 31504 815 35 of of IN 31504 815 36 statutes statute NNS 31504 815 37 they -PRON- PRP 31504 815 38 do do VBP 31504 815 39 not not RB 31504 815 40 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 815 41 approve approve VB 31504 815 42 of of IN 31504 815 43 . . . 31504 816 1 The the DT 31504 816 2 argument argument NN 31504 816 3 has have VBZ 31504 816 4 little little JJ 31504 816 5 or or CC 31504 816 6 no no DT 31504 816 7 foundation foundation NN 31504 816 8 in in IN 31504 816 9 fact fact NN 31504 816 10 . . . 31504 817 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 31504 817 2 among among IN 31504 817 3 the the DT 31504 817 4 hundreds hundred NNS 31504 817 5 , , , 31504 817 6 if if IN 31504 817 7 not not RB 31504 817 8 thousands thousand NNS 31504 817 9 , , , 31504 817 10 of of IN 31504 817 11 cases case NNS 31504 817 12 of of IN 31504 817 13 holding hold VBG 31504 817 14 a a DT 31504 817 15 statute statute NN 31504 817 16 unconstitutional unconstitutional JJ 31504 817 17 a a DT 31504 817 18 few few JJ 31504 817 19 may may MD 31504 817 20 seem seem VB 31504 817 21 to to TO 31504 817 22 have have VB 31504 817 23 been be VBN 31504 817 24 so so RB 31504 817 25 decided decide VBN 31504 817 26 because because IN 31504 817 27 the the DT 31504 817 28 judges judge NNS 31504 817 29 thought think VBD 31504 817 30 them -PRON- PRP 31504 817 31 unwise unwise JJ 31504 817 32 and and CC 31504 817 33 oppressive oppressive JJ 31504 817 34 . . . 31504 818 1 Some some DT 31504 818 2 expressions expression NNS 31504 818 3 in in IN 31504 818 4 judicial judicial JJ 31504 818 5 opinions opinion NNS 31504 818 6 have have VBP 31504 818 7 been be VBN 31504 818 8 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 31504 818 9 in in IN 31504 818 10 that that DT 31504 818 11 respect respect NN 31504 818 12 , , , 31504 818 13 but but CC 31504 818 14 the the DT 31504 818 15 courts court NNS 31504 818 16 everywhere everywhere RB 31504 818 17 in in IN 31504 818 18 this this DT 31504 818 19 country country NN 31504 818 20 , , , 31504 818 21 now now RB 31504 818 22 if if IN 31504 818 23 not not RB 31504 818 24 at at IN 31504 818 25 first first RB 31504 818 26 , , , 31504 818 27 disclaim disclaim VB 31504 818 28 any any DT 31504 818 29 such such JJ 31504 818 30 power power NN 31504 818 31 . . . 31504 819 1 The the DT 31504 819 2 same same JJ 31504 819 3 Chief Chief NNP 31504 819 4 Justice Justice NNP 31504 819 5 Marshall Marshall NNP 31504 819 6 , , , 31504 819 7 who who WP 31504 819 8 had have VBD 31504 819 9 so so RB 31504 819 10 convincingly convincingly RB 31504 819 11 stated state VBN 31504 819 12 the the DT 31504 819 13 duty duty NN 31504 819 14 of of IN 31504 819 15 the the DT 31504 819 16 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 819 17 to to TO 31504 819 18 refuse refuse VB 31504 819 19 effect effect NN 31504 819 20 to to IN 31504 819 21 unconstitutional unconstitutional JJ 31504 819 22 statutes statute NNS 31504 819 23 , , , 31504 819 24 later later RB 31504 819 25 in in IN 31504 819 26 _ _ NNP 31504 819 27 McCulloch McCulloch NNP 31504 819 28 _ _ NNP 31504 819 29 v. v. IN 31504 819 30 _ _ NNP 31504 819 31 Maryland Maryland NNP 31504 819 32 _ _ NNP 31504 819 33 , , , 31504 819 34 4 4 CD 31504 819 35 _ _ NNP 31504 819 36 Wheat Wheat NNP 31504 819 37 . . . 31504 819 38 _ _ NNP 31504 819 39 316 316 CD 31504 819 40 , , , 31504 819 41 disclaimed disclaim VBN 31504 819 42 for for IN 31504 819 43 the the DT 31504 819 44 courts court NNS 31504 819 45 all all DT 31504 819 46 pretensions pretension NNS 31504 819 47 to to IN 31504 819 48 any any DT 31504 819 49 power power NN 31504 819 50 to to TO 31504 819 51 inquire inquire VB 31504 819 52 into into IN 31504 819 53 the the DT 31504 819 54 necessity necessity NN 31504 819 55 of of IN 31504 819 56 any any DT 31504 819 57 statute statute NN 31504 819 58 , , , 31504 819 59 or or CC 31504 819 60 in in IN 31504 819 61 any any DT 31504 819 62 way way NN 31504 819 63 to to TO 31504 819 64 interfere interfere VB 31504 819 65 with with IN 31504 819 66 the the DT 31504 819 67 discretion discretion NN 31504 819 68 of of IN 31504 819 69 the the DT 31504 819 70 legislature legislature NN 31504 819 71 . . . 31504 820 1 In in IN 31504 820 2 strong strong JJ 31504 820 3 and and CC 31504 820 4 explicit explicit JJ 31504 820 5 language language NN 31504 820 6 other other JJ 31504 820 7 courts court NNS 31504 820 8 have have VBP 31504 820 9 disclaimed disclaim VBN 31504 820 10 such such JJ 31504 820 11 pretensions pretension NNS 31504 820 12 . . . 31504 821 1 The the DT 31504 821 2 Minnesota Minnesota NNP 31504 821 3 court court NN 31504 821 4 in in IN 31504 821 5 _ _ NNP 31504 821 6 State State NNP 31504 821 7 _ _ NNP 31504 821 8 v. v. IN 31504 821 9 _ _ NNP 31504 821 10 Corbett Corbett NNP 31504 821 11 _ _ NNP 31504 821 12 , , , 31504 821 13 57 57 CD 31504 821 14 _ _ NNP 31504 821 15 Minn. Minnesota NNP 31504 821 16 _ _ NNP 31504 821 17 345 345 CD 31504 821 18 , , , 31504 821 19 held hold VBD 31504 821 20 that that IN 31504 821 21 courts court NNS 31504 821 22 were be VBD 31504 821 23 not not RB 31504 821 24 at at IN 31504 821 25 liberty liberty NN 31504 821 26 to to TO 31504 821 27 declare declare VB 31504 821 28 a a DT 31504 821 29 statute statute NN 31504 821 30 unconstitutional unconstitutional JJ 31504 821 31 because because IN 31504 821 32 it -PRON- PRP 31504 821 33 is be VBZ 31504 821 34 thought think VBN 31504 821 35 by by IN 31504 821 36 them -PRON- PRP 31504 821 37 to to TO 31504 821 38 be be VB 31504 821 39 unjust unjust JJ 31504 821 40 or or CC 31504 821 41 oppressive oppressive JJ 31504 821 42 , , , 31504 821 43 or or CC 31504 821 44 to to TO 31504 821 45 violate violate VB 31504 821 46 some some DT 31504 821 47 natural natural JJ 31504 821 48 , , , 31504 821 49 social social JJ 31504 821 50 , , , 31504 821 51 or or CC 31504 821 52 political political JJ 31504 821 53 right right NN 31504 821 54 of of IN 31504 821 55 the the DT 31504 821 56 citizen citizen NN 31504 821 57 , , , 31504 821 58 unless unless IN 31504 821 59 it -PRON- PRP 31504 821 60 can can MD 31504 821 61 be be VB 31504 821 62 shown show VBN 31504 821 63 that that IN 31504 821 64 such such JJ 31504 821 65 injustice injustice NN 31504 821 66 is be VBZ 31504 821 67 prohibited prohibit VBN 31504 821 68 , , , 31504 821 69 or or CC 31504 821 70 such such JJ 31504 821 71 rights right NNS 31504 821 72 protected protect VBN 31504 821 73 , , , 31504 821 74 by by IN 31504 821 75 the the DT 31504 821 76 constitution constitution NN 31504 821 77 . . . 31504 822 1 The the DT 31504 822 2 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP 31504 822 3 court court NN 31504 822 4 in in IN 31504 822 5 _ _ NNP 31504 822 6 Com Com NNP 31504 822 7 . . . 31504 822 8 _ _ NNP 31504 822 9 v. v. IN 31504 822 10 _ _ NNP 31504 822 11 Moir Moir NNP 31504 822 12 _ _ NNP 31504 822 13 , , , 31504 822 14 199 199 CD 31504 822 15 _ _ NNP 31504 822 16 Pa. Pennsylvania NNP 31504 823 1 St. St. NNP 31504 823 2 _ _ NNP 31504 823 3 534 534 CD 31504 823 4 , , , 31504 823 5 used use VBD 31504 823 6 this this DT 31504 823 7 language language NN 31504 823 8 : : : 31504 823 9 " " `` 31504 823 10 Much much JJ 31504 823 11 of of IN 31504 823 12 the the DT 31504 823 13 argument argument NN 31504 823 14 and and CC 31504 823 15 nearly nearly RB 31504 823 16 all all PDT 31504 823 17 the the DT 31504 823 18 specific specific JJ 31504 823 19 objections objection NNS 31504 823 20 advanced advance VBN 31504 823 21 are be VBP 31504 823 22 to to IN 31504 823 23 the the DT 31504 823 24 wisdom wisdom NN 31504 823 25 and and CC 31504 823 26 propriety propriety NN 31504 823 27 and and CC 31504 823 28 to to IN 31504 823 29 the the DT 31504 823 30 justice justice NN 31504 823 31 of of IN 31504 823 32 the the DT 31504 823 33 statute statute NN 31504 823 34 and and CC 31504 823 35 the the DT 31504 823 36 motives motive NNS 31504 823 37 supposed suppose VBD 31504 823 38 to to TO 31504 823 39 have have VB 31504 823 40 inspired inspire VBN 31504 823 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 823 42 passage passage NN 31504 823 43 . . . 31504 824 1 With with IN 31504 824 2 these these DT 31504 824 3 we -PRON- PRP 31504 824 4 have have VBP 31504 824 5 nothing nothing NN 31504 824 6 to to TO 31504 824 7 do do VB 31504 824 8 . . . 31504 825 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 825 2 are be VBP 31504 825 3 beyond beyond IN 31504 825 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 825 5 province province NN 31504 825 6 and and CC 31504 825 7 are be VBP 31504 825 8 considerations consideration NNS 31504 825 9 to to TO 31504 825 10 be be VB 31504 825 11 adduced adduce VBN 31504 825 12 solely solely RB 31504 825 13 to to IN 31504 825 14 the the DT 31504 825 15 legislature legislature NN 31504 825 16 . . . 31504 825 17 " " '' 31504 826 1 The the DT 31504 826 2 court court NN 31504 826 3 of of IN 31504 826 4 West West NNP 31504 826 5 Virginia Virginia NNP 31504 826 6 in in IN 31504 826 7 _ _ NNP 31504 826 8 Slack Slack NNP 31504 826 9 _ _ NNP 31504 826 10 v. v. IN 31504 826 11 _ _ NNP 31504 826 12 Jacob Jacob NNP 31504 826 13 _ _ NNP 31504 826 14 , , , 31504 826 15 8 8 CD 31504 826 16 _ _ NNP 31504 826 17 W. W. NNP 31504 827 1 Va. Virginia NNP 31504 827 2 _ _ NNP 31504 827 3 612 612 CD 31504 827 4 , , , 31504 827 5 said say VBD 31504 827 6 : : : 31504 827 7 " " `` 31504 827 8 That that IN 31504 827 9 the the DT 31504 827 10 judges judge NNS 31504 827 11 are be VBP 31504 827 12 convinced convince VBN 31504 827 13 that that IN 31504 827 14 a a DT 31504 827 15 statute statute NN 31504 827 16 is be VBZ 31504 827 17 contrary contrary JJ 31504 827 18 to to IN 31504 827 19 natural natural JJ 31504 827 20 right right NN 31504 827 21 , , , 31504 827 22 absolute absolute JJ 31504 827 23 justice justice NN 31504 827 24 , , , 31504 827 25 or or CC 31504 827 26 sound sound JJ 31504 827 27 morality morality NN 31504 827 28 does do VBZ 31504 827 29 not not RB 31504 827 30 authorize authorize VB 31504 827 31 them -PRON- PRP 31504 827 32 to to TO 31504 827 33 refuse refuse VB 31504 827 34 it -PRON- PRP 31504 827 35 effect effect VB 31504 827 36 . . . 31504 827 37 " " '' 31504 828 1 The the DT 31504 828 2 court court NN 31504 828 3 of of IN 31504 828 4 Washington Washington NNP 31504 828 5 in in IN 31504 828 6 _ _ NNP 31504 828 7 Fishing Fishing NNP 31504 828 8 Co. Co. NNP 31504 828 9 _ _ NNP 31504 828 10 v. v. IN 31504 828 11 _ _ NNP 31504 828 12 George George NNP 31504 828 13 _ _ NNP 31504 828 14 , , , 31504 828 15 28 28 CD 31504 828 16 _ _ NNP 31504 828 17 Wash. Washington NNP 31504 828 18 _ _ NNP 31504 828 19 200 200 CD 31504 828 20 , , , 31504 828 21 held hold VBD 31504 828 22 that that IN 31504 828 23 " " `` 31504 828 24 a a DT 31504 828 25 statute statute NN 31504 828 26 can can MD 31504 828 27 not not RB 31504 828 28 be be VB 31504 828 29 ignored ignore VBN 31504 828 30 by by IN 31504 828 31 the the DT 31504 828 32 courts court NNS 31504 828 33 because because IN 31504 828 34 leading lead VBG 31504 828 35 in in IN 31504 828 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 828 37 application application NN 31504 828 38 to to TO 31504 828 39 absurd absurd JJ 31504 828 40 , , , 31504 828 41 incongruous incongruous JJ 31504 828 42 , , , 31504 828 43 or or CC 31504 828 44 mischievous mischievous JJ 31504 828 45 results result NNS 31504 828 46 . . . 31504 828 47 " " '' 31504 829 1 A a DT 31504 829 2 few few JJ 31504 829 3 cases case NNS 31504 829 4 may may MD 31504 829 5 also also RB 31504 829 6 be be VB 31504 829 7 cited cite VBN 31504 829 8 showing show VBG 31504 829 9 how how WRB 31504 829 10 relentlessly relentlessly RB 31504 829 11 this this DT 31504 829 12 disclaimer disclaimer NN 31504 829 13 is be VBZ 31504 829 14 applied apply VBN 31504 829 15 . . . 31504 830 1 The the DT 31504 830 2 court court NN 31504 830 3 of of IN 31504 830 4 New New NNP 31504 830 5 York York NNP 31504 830 6 in in IN 31504 830 7 _ _ NNP 31504 830 8 Kittinger Kittinger NNP 31504 830 9 _ _ NNP 31504 830 10 v. v. IN 31504 830 11 _ _ NNP 31504 830 12 Buffalo Buffalo NNP 31504 830 13 Traction Traction NNP 31504 830 14 Co. Co. NNP 31504 830 15 _ _ NNP 31504 830 16 , , , 31504 830 17 160 160 CD 31504 830 18 _ _ NNP 31504 830 19 N. N. NNP 31504 831 1 Y. Y. NNP 31504 831 2 _ _ NNP 31504 831 3 377 377 CD 31504 831 4 , , , 31504 831 5 held hold VBD 31504 831 6 that that IN 31504 831 7 the the DT 31504 831 8 courts court NNS 31504 831 9 had have VBD 31504 831 10 no no DT 31504 831 11 power power NN 31504 831 12 to to TO 31504 831 13 inquire inquire VB 31504 831 14 into into IN 31504 831 15 the the DT 31504 831 16 motives motive NNS 31504 831 17 inducing induce VBG 31504 831 18 legislation legislation NN 31504 831 19 and and CC 31504 831 20 could could MD 31504 831 21 not not RB 31504 831 22 impute impute VB 31504 831 23 to to IN 31504 831 24 the the DT 31504 831 25 legislature legislature NN 31504 831 26 any any DT 31504 831 27 other other JJ 31504 831 28 than than IN 31504 831 29 public public JJ 31504 831 30 motives motive NNS 31504 831 31 . . . 31504 832 1 The the DT 31504 832 2 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP 31504 832 3 court court NN 31504 832 4 in in IN 31504 832 5 _ _ NNP 31504 832 6 Sunbury Sunbury NNP 31504 832 7 R.R. R.R. NNP 31504 833 1 Co. Co. NNP 31504 833 2 _ _ NNP 31504 833 3 v. v. IN 31504 833 4 _ _ NNP 31504 833 5 People People NNP 31504 833 6 _ _ NNP 31504 833 7 , , , 31504 833 8 33 33 CD 31504 833 9 _ _ NNP 31504 833 10 Pa. Pennsylvania NNP 31504 834 1 St. St. NNP 31504 834 2 _ _ NNP 31504 834 3 278 278 CD 31504 834 4 , , , 31504 834 5 had have VBD 31504 834 6 urged urge VBN 31504 834 7 upon upon IN 31504 834 8 it -PRON- PRP 31504 834 9 the the DT 31504 834 10 argument argument NN 31504 834 11 that that IN 31504 834 12 the the DT 31504 834 13 statute statute NN 31504 834 14 in in IN 31504 834 15 question question NN 31504 834 16 had have VBD 31504 834 17 been be VBN 31504 834 18 " " `` 31504 834 19 passed pass VBN 31504 834 20 in in IN 31504 834 21 fraud fraud NN 31504 834 22 of of IN 31504 834 23 the the DT 31504 834 24 rights right NNS 31504 834 25 of of IN 31504 834 26 the the DT 31504 834 27 people people NNS 31504 834 28 . . . 31504 834 29 " " '' 31504 835 1 The the DT 31504 835 2 court court NN 31504 835 3 held hold VBD 31504 835 4 that that IN 31504 835 5 , , , 31504 835 6 if if IN 31504 835 7 true true JJ 31504 835 8 , , , 31504 835 9 that that DT 31504 835 10 fact fact NN 31504 835 11 would would MD 31504 835 12 not not RB 31504 835 13 authorize authorize VB 31504 835 14 it -PRON- PRP 31504 835 15 to to TO 31504 835 16 refuse refuse VB 31504 835 17 it -PRON- PRP 31504 835 18 effect effect VB 31504 835 19 . . . 31504 836 1 The the DT 31504 836 2 Tennessee Tennessee NNP 31504 836 3 court court NN 31504 836 4 in in IN 31504 836 5 _ _ NNP 31504 836 6 Lynn Lynn NNP 31504 836 7 _ _ NNP 31504 836 8 v. v. IN 31504 836 9 _ _ NNP 31504 836 10 Polk Polk NNP 31504 836 11 _ _ NNP 31504 836 12 , , , 31504 836 13 76 76 CD 31504 836 14 _ _ NNP 31504 836 15 Tenn. Tennessee NNP 31504 837 1 St. St. NNP 31504 837 2 _ _ NNP 31504 837 3 121 121 CD 31504 837 4 , , , 31504 837 5 was be VBD 31504 837 6 asked ask VBN 31504 837 7 to to TO 31504 837 8 declare declare VB 31504 837 9 a a DT 31504 837 10 statute statute NN 31504 837 11 ineffective ineffective JJ 31504 837 12 because because IN 31504 837 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 837 14 enactment enactment NN 31504 837 15 was be VBD 31504 837 16 procured procure VBN 31504 837 17 by by IN 31504 837 18 bribing bribe VBG 31504 837 19 members member NNS 31504 837 20 of of IN 31504 837 21 the the DT 31504 837 22 legislature legislature NN 31504 837 23 . . . 31504 838 1 The the DT 31504 838 2 court court NN 31504 838 3 held hold VBD 31504 838 4 it -PRON- PRP 31504 838 5 could could MD 31504 838 6 not not RB 31504 838 7 do do VB 31504 838 8 so so RB 31504 838 9 . . . 31504 839 1 The the DT 31504 839 2 Missouri Missouri NNP 31504 839 3 court court NN 31504 839 4 in in IN 31504 839 5 _ _ NNP 31504 839 6 Slate Slate NNP 31504 839 7 _ _ NNP 31504 839 8 v. v. IN 31504 839 9 _ _ NNP 31504 839 10 Clarke Clarke NNP 31504 839 11 _ _ NNP 31504 839 12 , , , 31504 839 13 54 54 CD 31504 839 14 _ _ NNP 31504 839 15 Mo. Mo. NNP 31504 839 16 _ _ NNP 31504 839 17 17 17 CD 31504 839 18 , , , 31504 839 19 had have VBD 31504 839 20 before before IN 31504 839 21 it -PRON- PRP 31504 839 22 a a DT 31504 839 23 statute statute NN 31504 839 24 authorizing authorize VBG 31504 839 25 the the DT 31504 839 26 licensing licensing NN 31504 839 27 of of IN 31504 839 28 bawdy bawdy JJ 31504 839 29 houses house NNS 31504 839 30 and and CC 31504 839 31 was be VBD 31504 839 32 urged urge VBN 31504 839 33 to to TO 31504 839 34 declare declare VB 31504 839 35 it -PRON- PRP 31504 839 36 unconstitutional unconstitutional JJ 31504 839 37 because because IN 31504 839 38 against against IN 31504 839 39 public public JJ 31504 839 40 policy policy NN 31504 839 41 and and CC 31504 839 42 destructive destructive JJ 31504 839 43 of of IN 31504 839 44 good good JJ 31504 839 45 morals moral NNS 31504 839 46 . . . 31504 840 1 The the DT 31504 840 2 court court NN 31504 840 3 held hold VBD 31504 840 4 it -PRON- PRP 31504 840 5 had have VBD 31504 840 6 no no DT 31504 840 7 such such JJ 31504 840 8 power power NN 31504 840 9 . . . 31504 841 1 The the DT 31504 841 2 Justices Justices NNPS 31504 841 3 of of IN 31504 841 4 the the DT 31504 841 5 Maine Maine NNP 31504 841 6 Supreme Supreme NNP 31504 841 7 Court Court NNP 31504 841 8 in in IN 31504 841 9 an an DT 31504 841 10 opinion opinion NN 31504 841 11 reported report VBN 31504 841 12 in in IN 31504 841 13 103 103 CD 31504 841 14 _ _ NNP 31504 841 15 Maine Maine NNP 31504 841 16 _ _ NNP 31504 841 17 508 508 CD 31504 841 18 stated state VBD 31504 841 19 the the DT 31504 841 20 principle principle NN 31504 841 21 as as IN 31504 841 22 follows follow VBZ 31504 841 23 : : : 31504 841 24 " " `` 31504 841 25 It -PRON- PRP 31504 841 26 is be VBZ 31504 841 27 for for IN 31504 841 28 the the DT 31504 841 29 legislature legislature NN 31504 841 30 to to TO 31504 841 31 determine determine VB 31504 841 32 from from IN 31504 841 33 time time NN 31504 841 34 to to IN 31504 841 35 time time NN 31504 841 36 the the DT 31504 841 37 occasion occasion NN 31504 841 38 and and CC 31504 841 39 what what WDT 31504 841 40 laws law NNS 31504 841 41 are be VBP 31504 841 42 necessary necessary JJ 31504 841 43 or or CC 31504 841 44 expedient expedient JJ 31504 841 45 for for IN 31504 841 46 the the DT 31504 841 47 defense defense NN 31504 841 48 and and CC 31504 841 49 benefit benefit NN 31504 841 50 of of IN 31504 841 51 the the DT 31504 841 52 people people NNS 31504 841 53 ; ; : 31504 841 54 and and CC 31504 841 55 however however RB 31504 841 56 inconvenienced inconvenienced JJ 31504 841 57 , , , 31504 841 58 restricted restrict VBN 31504 841 59 , , , 31504 841 60 or or CC 31504 841 61 even even RB 31504 841 62 damaged damage VBN 31504 841 63 particular particular JJ 31504 841 64 persons person NNS 31504 841 65 and and CC 31504 841 66 corporations corporation NNS 31504 841 67 may may MD 31504 841 68 be be VB 31504 841 69 , , , 31504 841 70 such such JJ 31504 841 71 general general JJ 31504 841 72 laws law NNS 31504 841 73 are be VBP 31504 841 74 to to TO 31504 841 75 be be VB 31504 841 76 held hold VBN 31504 841 77 valid valid JJ 31504 841 78 unless unless IN 31504 841 79 there there EX 31504 841 80 can can MD 31504 841 81 be be VB 31504 841 82 pointed point VBN 31504 841 83 out out RP 31504 841 84 some some DT 31504 841 85 provision provision NN 31504 841 86 in in IN 31504 841 87 the the DT 31504 841 88 State State NNP 31504 841 89 or or CC 31504 841 90 United United NNP 31504 841 91 States States NNP 31504 841 92 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 841 93 which which WDT 31504 841 94 clearly clearly RB 31504 841 95 prohibits prohibit VBZ 31504 841 96 them -PRON- PRP 31504 841 97 . . . 31504 841 98 " " '' 31504 842 1 Further further RB 31504 842 2 , , , 31504 842 3 it -PRON- PRP 31504 842 4 is be VBZ 31504 842 5 a a DT 31504 842 6 maxim maxim NN 31504 842 7 of of IN 31504 842 8 the the DT 31504 842 9 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 842 10 , , , 31504 842 11 from from IN 31504 842 12 the the DT 31504 842 13 beginning beginning NN 31504 842 14 and and CC 31504 842 15 now now RB 31504 842 16 , , , 31504 842 17 that that IN 31504 842 18 no no DT 31504 842 19 statute statute NN 31504 842 20 should should MD 31504 842 21 be be VB 31504 842 22 refused refuse VBN 31504 842 23 effect effect NN 31504 842 24 unless unless IN 31504 842 25 clearly clearly RB 31504 842 26 contrary contrary JJ 31504 842 27 to to IN 31504 842 28 some some DT 31504 842 29 provision provision NN 31504 842 30 of of IN 31504 842 31 the the DT 31504 842 32 constitution,--unless constitution,--unless NNP 31504 842 33 the the DT 31504 842 34 conflict conflict NN 31504 842 35 is be VBZ 31504 842 36 evident evident JJ 31504 842 37 beyond beyond IN 31504 842 38 a a DT 31504 842 39 reasonable reasonable JJ 31504 842 40 doubt doubt NN 31504 842 41 . . . 31504 843 1 This this DT 31504 843 2 is be VBZ 31504 843 3 a a DT 31504 843 4 maxim maxim NN 31504 843 5 , , , 31504 843 6 a a DT 31504 843 7 canon canon NN 31504 843 8 of of IN 31504 843 9 interpretation interpretation NN 31504 843 10 , , , 31504 843 11 that that IN 31504 843 12 courts court NNS 31504 843 13 always always RB 31504 843 14 have have VBP 31504 843 15 in in IN 31504 843 16 mind mind NN 31504 843 17 and and CC 31504 843 18 apply apply VB 31504 843 19 in in IN 31504 843 20 considering consider VBG 31504 843 21 the the DT 31504 843 22 question question NN 31504 843 23 of of IN 31504 843 24 the the DT 31504 843 25 constitutionality constitutionality NN 31504 843 26 of of IN 31504 843 27 a a DT 31504 843 28 statute statute NN 31504 843 29 . . . 31504 844 1 Thus thus RB 31504 844 2 scrupulous scrupulous JJ 31504 844 3 are be VBP 31504 844 4 the the DT 31504 844 5 courts court NNS 31504 844 6 to to TO 31504 844 7 keep keep VB 31504 844 8 within within IN 31504 844 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 844 10 proper proper JJ 31504 844 11 sphere sphere NN 31504 844 12 , , , 31504 844 13 to to TO 31504 844 14 respect respect VB 31504 844 15 the the DT 31504 844 16 limits limit NNS 31504 844 17 of of IN 31504 844 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 844 19 powers power NNS 31504 844 20 . . . 31504 845 1 If if IN 31504 845 2 the the DT 31504 845 3 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 845 4 would would MD 31504 845 5 be be VB 31504 845 6 equally equally RB 31504 845 7 scrupulous scrupulous JJ 31504 845 8 , , , 31504 845 9 would would MD 31504 845 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 845 11 refrain refrain VB 31504 845 12 from from IN 31504 845 13 infringing infringe VBG 31504 845 14 on on IN 31504 845 15 those those DT 31504 845 16 rights right NNS 31504 845 17 and and CC 31504 845 18 liberties liberty NNS 31504 845 19 of of IN 31504 845 20 the the DT 31504 845 21 citizen citizen NN 31504 845 22 guaranteed guarantee VBN 31504 845 23 by by IN 31504 845 24 the the DT 31504 845 25 constitution constitution NN 31504 845 26 , , , 31504 845 27 there there EX 31504 845 28 would would MD 31504 845 29 be be VB 31504 845 30 less less JJR 31504 845 31 restriction restriction NN 31504 845 32 , , , 31504 845 33 less less JJR 31504 845 34 friction friction NN 31504 845 35 , , , 31504 845 36 less less JJR 31504 845 37 turmoil turmoil NN 31504 845 38 , , , 31504 845 39 less less JJR 31504 845 40 need need NN 31504 845 41 of of IN 31504 845 42 the the DT 31504 845 43 judicial judicial JJ 31504 845 44 check check NN 31504 845 45 , , , 31504 845 46 less less JJR 31504 845 47 injustice injustice NN 31504 845 48 . . . 31504 846 1 But but CC 31504 846 2 the the DT 31504 846 3 complaints complaint NNS 31504 846 4 against against IN 31504 846 5 the the DT 31504 846 6 courts court NNS 31504 846 7 are be VBP 31504 846 8 not not RB 31504 846 9 all all RB 31504 846 10 because because IN 31504 846 11 of of IN 31504 846 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 846 13 holding holding NN 31504 846 14 statutes statute NNS 31504 846 15 unconstitutional unconstitutional JJ 31504 846 16 . . . 31504 847 1 Many many JJ 31504 847 2 have have VBP 31504 847 3 felt feel VBN 31504 847 4 that that IN 31504 847 5 courts court NNS 31504 847 6 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 847 7 erred err VBD 31504 847 8 in in IN 31504 847 9 having have VBG 31504 847 10 too too RB 31504 847 11 much much JJ 31504 847 12 respect respect NN 31504 847 13 for for IN 31504 847 14 the the DT 31504 847 15 legislative legislative JJ 31504 847 16 power power NN 31504 847 17 and and CC 31504 847 18 because because IN 31504 847 19 of of IN 31504 847 20 that that DT 31504 847 21 respect respect NN 31504 847 22 have have VBP 31504 847 23 allowed allow VBN 31504 847 24 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 847 25 rights right NNS 31504 847 26 and and CC 31504 847 27 liberties liberty NNS 31504 847 28 to to TO 31504 847 29 be be VB 31504 847 30 sacrificed sacrifice VBN 31504 847 31 at at IN 31504 847 32 the the DT 31504 847 33 behest behest NN 31504 847 34 of of IN 31504 847 35 majorities majority NNS 31504 847 36 and and CC 31504 847 37 often often RB 31504 847 38 at at IN 31504 847 39 the the DT 31504 847 40 behest behest NN 31504 847 41 of of IN 31504 847 42 active active JJ 31504 847 43 , , , 31504 847 44 interested interested JJ 31504 847 45 minorities minority NNS 31504 847 46 more more RBR 31504 847 47 insistent insistent JJ 31504 847 48 than than IN 31504 847 49 the the DT 31504 847 50 inert inert JJ 31504 847 51 majority majority NN 31504 847 52 . . . 31504 848 1 The the DT 31504 848 2 decision decision NN 31504 848 3 of of IN 31504 848 4 the the DT 31504 848 5 United United NNP 31504 848 6 States States NNP 31504 848 7 Supreme Supreme NNP 31504 848 8 Court Court NNP 31504 848 9 in in IN 31504 848 10 the the DT 31504 848 11 _ _ NNP 31504 848 12 Charles Charles NNP 31504 848 13 River River NNP 31504 848 14 Bridge Bridge NNP 31504 848 15 _ _ NNP 31504 848 16 case case NN 31504 848 17 , , , 31504 848 18 11 11 CD 31504 848 19 _ _ NNP 31504 848 20 Peters Peters NNP 31504 848 21 _ _ NNP 31504 848 22 420 420 CD 31504 848 23 , , , 31504 848 24 was be VBD 31504 848 25 mourned mourn VBN 31504 848 26 by by IN 31504 848 27 such such JJ 31504 848 28 men man NNS 31504 848 29 as as IN 31504 848 30 Webster Webster NNP 31504 848 31 , , , 31504 848 32 Kent Kent NNP 31504 848 33 , , , 31504 848 34 Story Story NNP 31504 848 35 , , , 31504 848 36 and and CC 31504 848 37 others other NNS 31504 848 38 as as IN 31504 848 39 breaking break VBG 31504 848 40 down down RP 31504 848 41 the the DT 31504 848 42 safeguards safeguard NNS 31504 848 43 of of IN 31504 848 44 the the DT 31504 848 45 constitution constitution NN 31504 848 46 . . . 31504 849 1 The the DT 31504 849 2 decision decision NN 31504 849 3 in in IN 31504 849 4 the the DT 31504 849 5 _ _ NNP 31504 849 6 Slaughter Slaughter NNP 31504 849 7 House House NNP 31504 849 8 _ _ NNP 31504 849 9 cases case NNS 31504 849 10 was be VBD 31504 849 11 regarded regard VBN 31504 849 12 by by IN 31504 849 13 many many JJ 31504 849 14 able able JJ 31504 849 15 jurists jurist NNS 31504 849 16 as as IN 31504 849 17 ignoring ignore VBG 31504 849 18 that that IN 31504 849 19 provision provision NN 31504 849 20 of of IN 31504 849 21 the the DT 31504 849 22 XIVth XIVth NNP 31504 849 23 amendment amendment NN 31504 849 24 to to IN 31504 849 25 the the DT 31504 849 26 Federal Federal NNP 31504 849 27 Constitution Constitution NNP 31504 849 28 forbidding forbid VBG 31504 849 29 any any DT 31504 849 30 denial denial NN 31504 849 31 to to IN 31504 849 32 any any DT 31504 849 33 one one CD 31504 849 34 of of IN 31504 849 35 the the DT 31504 849 36 equal equal JJ 31504 849 37 protection protection NN 31504 849 38 of of IN 31504 849 39 the the DT 31504 849 40 laws law NNS 31504 849 41 . . . 31504 850 1 The the DT 31504 850 2 _ _ NNP 31504 850 3 Elevator Elevator NNP 31504 850 4 _ _ NNP 31504 850 5 cases case NNS 31504 850 6 , , , 31504 850 7 holding hold VBG 31504 850 8 that that IN 31504 850 9 elevators elevator NNS 31504 850 10 were be VBD 31504 850 11 public public JJ 31504 850 12 utilities utility NNS 31504 850 13 and and CC 31504 850 14 therefore therefore RB 31504 850 15 subject subject JJ 31504 850 16 to to IN 31504 850 17 public public JJ 31504 850 18 control control NN 31504 850 19 as as IN 31504 850 20 to to IN 31504 850 21 charges charge NNS 31504 850 22 for for IN 31504 850 23 service service NN 31504 850 24 , , , 31504 850 25 though though IN 31504 850 26 the the DT 31504 850 27 owners owner NNS 31504 850 28 had have VBD 31504 850 29 no no DT 31504 850 30 special special JJ 31504 850 31 franchise franchise NN 31504 850 32 , , , 31504 850 33 no no DT 31504 850 34 part part NN 31504 850 35 of of IN 31504 850 36 public public JJ 31504 850 37 power power NN 31504 850 38 , , , 31504 850 39 are be VBP 31504 850 40 even even RB 31504 850 41 now now RB 31504 850 42 thought think VBN 31504 850 43 to to TO 31504 850 44 have have VB 31504 850 45 made make VBN 31504 850 46 a a DT 31504 850 47 wide wide JJ 31504 850 48 breach breach NN 31504 850 49 in in IN 31504 850 50 the the DT 31504 850 51 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 850 52 barriers barrier NNS 31504 850 53 against against IN 31504 850 54 the the DT 31504 850 55 invasion invasion NN 31504 850 56 of of IN 31504 850 57 private private JJ 31504 850 58 rights right NNS 31504 850 59 . . . 31504 851 1 The the DT 31504 851 2 decision decision NN 31504 851 3 in in IN 31504 851 4 the the DT 31504 851 5 _ _ NNP 31504 851 6 Chinese Chinese NNP 31504 851 7 Deportation Deportation NNP 31504 851 8 _ _ NNP 31504 851 9 cases case NNS 31504 851 10 , , , 31504 851 11 149 149 CD 31504 851 12 U. U. NNP 31504 851 13 S. S. NNP 31504 851 14 698 698 CD 31504 851 15 , , , 31504 851 16 shocked shock VBD 31504 851 17 the the DT 31504 851 18 sense sense NN 31504 851 19 of of IN 31504 851 20 justice justice NN 31504 851 21 of of IN 31504 851 22 many many JJ 31504 851 23 . . . 31504 852 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 852 2 was be VBD 31504 852 3 to to IN 31504 852 4 the the DT 31504 852 5 effect effect NN 31504 852 6 that that WDT 31504 852 7 Congress Congress NNP 31504 852 8 could could MD 31504 852 9 empower empower VB 31504 852 10 the the DT 31504 852 11 executive executive NN 31504 852 12 to to TO 31504 852 13 arrest arrest VB 31504 852 14 upon upon IN 31504 852 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 852 16 own own JJ 31504 852 17 warrant warrant NN 31504 852 18 any any DT 31504 852 19 person person NN 31504 852 20 it -PRON- PRP 31504 852 21 claimed claim VBD 31504 852 22 to to TO 31504 852 23 be be VB 31504 852 24 an an DT 31504 852 25 alien alien NN 31504 852 26 unlawfully unlawfully RB 31504 852 27 residing reside VBG 31504 852 28 in in IN 31504 852 29 the the DT 31504 852 30 United United NNP 31504 852 31 States States NNP 31504 852 32 and and CC 31504 852 33 to to TO 31504 852 34 deport deport VB 31504 852 35 him -PRON- PRP 31504 852 36 without without IN 31504 852 37 trial trial NN 31504 852 38 , , , 31504 852 39 unless unless IN 31504 852 40 he -PRON- PRP 31504 852 41 could could MD 31504 852 42 affirmatively affirmatively RB 31504 852 43 prove prove VB 31504 852 44 to to IN 31504 852 45 the the DT 31504 852 46 satisfaction satisfaction NN 31504 852 47 of of IN 31504 852 48 a a DT 31504 852 49 single single JJ 31504 852 50 judge judge NN 31504 852 51 ( ( -LRB- 31504 852 52 to to TO 31504 852 53 be be VB 31504 852 54 selected select VBN 31504 852 55 by by IN 31504 852 56 the the DT 31504 852 57 executive executive NN 31504 852 58 ) ) -RRB- 31504 852 59 , , , 31504 852 60 and and CC 31504 852 61 by by IN 31504 852 62 a a DT 31504 852 63 specified specify VBN 31504 852 64 kind kind NN 31504 852 65 of of IN 31504 852 66 evidence evidence NN 31504 852 67 only only RB 31504 852 68 , , , 31504 852 69 that that IN 31504 852 70 he -PRON- PRP 31504 852 71 was be VBD 31504 852 72 not not RB 31504 852 73 guilty guilty JJ 31504 852 74 , , , 31504 852 75 however however RB 31504 852 76 ample ample JJ 31504 852 77 and and CC 31504 852 78 probative probative JJ 31504 852 79 other other JJ 31504 852 80 evidence evidence NN 31504 852 81 might may MD 31504 852 82 be be VB 31504 852 83 adduced adduce VBN 31504 852 84 and and CC 31504 852 85 however however RB 31504 852 86 impossible impossible JJ 31504 852 87 to to TO 31504 852 88 produce produce VB 31504 852 89 the the DT 31504 852 90 specified specify VBN 31504 852 91 evidence evidence NN 31504 852 92 . . . 31504 853 1 Justices Justices NNPS 31504 853 2 Fuller Fuller NNP 31504 853 3 , , , 31504 853 4 Field Field NNP 31504 853 5 , , , 31504 853 6 and and CC 31504 853 7 Brewer Brewer NNP 31504 853 8 vigorously vigorously RB 31504 853 9 dissented dissent VBD 31504 853 10 on on IN 31504 853 11 the the DT 31504 853 12 ground ground NN 31504 853 13 that that IN 31504 853 14 such such JJ 31504 853 15 action action NN 31504 853 16 by by IN 31504 853 17 the the DT 31504 853 18 executive executive NN 31504 853 19 , , , 31504 853 20 though though IN 31504 853 21 under under IN 31504 853 22 the the DT 31504 853 23 authority authority NN 31504 853 24 of of IN 31504 853 25 Congress Congress NNP 31504 853 26 , , , 31504 853 27 was be VBD 31504 853 28 in in IN 31504 853 29 violation violation NN 31504 853 30 of of IN 31504 853 31 the the DT 31504 853 32 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 853 33 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 853 34 against against IN 31504 853 35 arrest arrest NN 31504 853 36 without without IN 31504 853 37 judicial judicial JJ 31504 853 38 warrant warrant NN 31504 853 39 , , , 31504 853 40 against against IN 31504 853 41 deprivation deprivation NN 31504 853 42 of of IN 31504 853 43 liberty liberty NN 31504 853 44 without without IN 31504 853 45 trial trial NN 31504 853 46 by by IN 31504 853 47 jury jury NN 31504 853 48 and and CC 31504 853 49 due due JJ 31504 853 50 process process NN 31504 853 51 of of IN 31504 853 52 law law NN 31504 853 53 . . . 31504 854 1 Justice Justice NNP 31504 854 2 Brewer Brewer NNP 31504 854 3 after after IN 31504 854 4 quoting quote VBG 31504 854 5 Madison Madison NNP 31504 854 6 , , , 31504 854 7 that that DT 31504 854 8 banishment banishment NN 31504 854 9 is be VBZ 31504 854 10 among among IN 31504 854 11 the the DT 31504 854 12 severest severest NN 31504 854 13 of of IN 31504 854 14 punishments punishment NNS 31504 854 15 , , , 31504 854 16 went go VBD 31504 854 17 on on RP 31504 854 18 to to TO 31504 854 19 say say VB 31504 854 20 : : : 31504 854 21 " " `` 31504 854 22 But but CC 31504 854 23 punishment punishment NN 31504 854 24 implies imply VBZ 31504 854 25 a a DT 31504 854 26 trial trial NN 31504 854 27 . . . 31504 855 1 ' ' `` 31504 855 2 No no DT 31504 855 3 person person NN 31504 855 4 shall shall MD 31504 855 5 be be VB 31504 855 6 deprived deprive VBN 31504 855 7 of of IN 31504 855 8 life life NN 31504 855 9 , , , 31504 855 10 liberty liberty NN 31504 855 11 or or CC 31504 855 12 property property NN 31504 855 13 without without IN 31504 855 14 due due JJ 31504 855 15 process process NN 31504 855 16 of of IN 31504 855 17 law law NN 31504 855 18 . . . 31504 855 19 ' ' '' 31504 856 1 Due due IN 31504 856 2 process process NN 31504 856 3 of of IN 31504 856 4 law law NN 31504 856 5 requires require VBZ 31504 856 6 that that IN 31504 856 7 a a DT 31504 856 8 man man NN 31504 856 9 be be VB 31504 856 10 heard hear VBN 31504 856 11 before before IN 31504 856 12 he -PRON- PRP 31504 856 13 is be VBZ 31504 856 14 condemned condemn VBN 31504 856 15 , , , 31504 856 16 and and CC 31504 856 17 both both DT 31504 856 18 heard hear VBD 31504 856 19 and and CC 31504 856 20 condemned condemn VBD 31504 856 21 in in IN 31504 856 22 the the DT 31504 856 23 due due JJ 31504 856 24 and and CC 31504 856 25 orderly orderly JJ 31504 856 26 procedure procedure NN 31504 856 27 as as IN 31504 856 28 recognized recognize VBN 31504 856 29 by by IN 31504 856 30 the the DT 31504 856 31 common common JJ 31504 856 32 law law NN 31504 856 33 from from IN 31504 856 34 time time NN 31504 856 35 immemorial immemorial JJ 31504 856 36 . . . 31504 856 37 " " '' 31504 857 1 In in IN 31504 857 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 31504 857 3 research research NN 31504 857 4 I -PRON- PRP 31504 857 5 have have VBP 31504 857 6 found find VBN 31504 857 7 more more JJR 31504 857 8 cases case NNS 31504 857 9 where where WRB 31504 857 10 it -PRON- PRP 31504 857 11 has have VBZ 31504 857 12 seemed seem VBN 31504 857 13 to to IN 31504 857 14 me -PRON- PRP 31504 857 15 the the DT 31504 857 16 courts court NNS 31504 857 17 have have VBP 31504 857 18 construed construe VBN 31504 857 19 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 857 20 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 857 21 too too RB 31504 857 22 strictly strictly RB 31504 857 23 , , , 31504 857 24 than than IN 31504 857 25 where where WRB 31504 857 26 they -PRON- PRP 31504 857 27 have have VBP 31504 857 28 construed construe VBN 31504 857 29 them -PRON- PRP 31504 857 30 too too RB 31504 857 31 liberally liberally RB 31504 857 32 . . . 31504 858 1 The the DT 31504 858 2 tendency tendency NN 31504 858 3 has have VBZ 31504 858 4 been be VBN 31504 858 5 rather rather RB 31504 858 6 away away RB 31504 858 7 from from IN 31504 858 8 the the DT 31504 858 9 enforcement enforcement NN 31504 858 10 of of IN 31504 858 11 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 858 12 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 858 13 and and CC 31504 858 14 to to TO 31504 858 15 allow allow VB 31504 858 16 legislative legislative JJ 31504 858 17 encroachments encroachment NNS 31504 858 18 upon upon IN 31504 858 19 them -PRON- PRP 31504 858 20 . . . 31504 859 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 859 2 regard regard VBP 31504 859 3 this this DT 31504 859 4 as as IN 31504 859 5 a a DT 31504 859 6 very very RB 31504 859 7 dangerous dangerous JJ 31504 859 8 tendency tendency NN 31504 859 9 . . . 31504 860 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 31504 860 2 the the DT 31504 860 3 encroachments encroachment NNS 31504 860 4 have have VBP 31504 860 5 not not RB 31504 860 6 been be VBN 31504 860 7 at at IN 31504 860 8 first first RB 31504 860 9 perceived perceive VBN 31504 860 10 , , , 31504 860 11 but but CC 31504 860 12 I -PRON- PRP 31504 860 13 think think VBP 31504 860 14 courts court NNS 31504 860 15 should should MD 31504 860 16 be be VB 31504 860 17 vigilantly vigilantly RB 31504 860 18 on on IN 31504 860 19 the the DT 31504 860 20 watch watch NN 31504 860 21 for for IN 31504 860 22 them -PRON- PRP 31504 860 23 , , , 31504 860 24 otherwise otherwise RB 31504 860 25 individual individual JJ 31504 860 26 rights right NNS 31504 860 27 guaranteed guarantee VBN 31504 860 28 to to IN 31504 860 29 the the DT 31504 860 30 people people NNS 31504 860 31 by by IN 31504 860 32 the the DT 31504 860 33 constitution constitution NN 31504 860 34 may may MD 31504 860 35 be be VB 31504 860 36 gradually gradually RB 31504 860 37 weakened weaken VBN 31504 860 38 and and CC 31504 860 39 finally finally RB 31504 860 40 destroyed destroy VBN 31504 860 41 . . . 31504 861 1 This this DT 31504 861 2 duty duty NN 31504 861 3 of of IN 31504 861 4 the the DT 31504 861 5 courts court NNS 31504 861 6 was be VBD 31504 861 7 declared declare VBN 31504 861 8 in in IN 31504 861 9 the the DT 31504 861 10 case case NN 31504 861 11 of of IN 31504 861 12 _ _ NNP 31504 861 13 Boyd Boyd NNP 31504 861 14 _ _ NNP 31504 861 15 v. v. IN 31504 861 16 _ _ NNP 31504 861 17 United United NNP 31504 861 18 States States NNP 31504 861 19 _ _ NNP 31504 861 20 , , , 31504 861 21 116 116 CD 31504 861 22 _ _ NNP 31504 861 23 U. U. NNP 31504 862 1 S. S. NNP 31504 862 2 _ _ NNP 31504 862 3 616 616 CD 31504 862 4 at at IN 31504 862 5 page page NN 31504 862 6 641 641 CD 31504 862 7 - - HYPH 31504 862 8 -where -where NN 31504 862 9 in in IN 31504 862 10 refusing refuse VBG 31504 862 11 effect effect NN 31504 862 12 to to IN 31504 862 13 a a DT 31504 862 14 statute statute NN 31504 862 15 requiring require VBG 31504 862 16 the the DT 31504 862 17 production production NN 31504 862 18 of of IN 31504 862 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 862 20 books book NNS 31504 862 21 and and CC 31504 862 22 papers paper NNS 31504 862 23 by by IN 31504 862 24 a a DT 31504 862 25 defendant defendant NN 31504 862 26 in in IN 31504 862 27 proceedings proceeding NNS 31504 862 28 for for IN 31504 862 29 forfeiture forfeiture NN 31504 862 30 , , , 31504 862 31 the the DT 31504 862 32 court court NN 31504 862 33 said say VBD 31504 862 34 : : : 31504 862 35 " " `` 31504 862 36 Though though IN 31504 862 37 the the DT 31504 862 38 proceeding proceeding NN 31504 862 39 in in IN 31504 862 40 question question NN 31504 862 41 is be VBZ 31504 862 42 devested deveste VBN 31504 862 43 of of IN 31504 862 44 the the DT 31504 862 45 aggravating aggravate VBG 31504 862 46 effects effect NNS 31504 862 47 of of IN 31504 862 48 actual actual JJ 31504 862 49 search search NN 31504 862 50 and and CC 31504 862 51 seizure seizure NN 31504 862 52 , , , 31504 862 53 yet yet CC 31504 862 54 it -PRON- PRP 31504 862 55 contains contain VBZ 31504 862 56 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 862 57 substance substance NN 31504 862 58 and and CC 31504 862 59 essence essence NN 31504 862 60 , , , 31504 862 61 and and CC 31504 862 62 effects effect VBZ 31504 862 63 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 862 64 substantial substantial JJ 31504 862 65 purpose purpose NN 31504 862 66 . . . 31504 863 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 863 2 may may MD 31504 863 3 be be VB 31504 863 4 that that IN 31504 863 5 it -PRON- PRP 31504 863 6 is be VBZ 31504 863 7 the the DT 31504 863 8 obnoxious obnoxious JJ 31504 863 9 thing thing NN 31504 863 10 in in IN 31504 863 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 863 12 mildest mild JJS 31504 863 13 and and CC 31504 863 14 least least JJS 31504 863 15 repulsive repulsive JJ 31504 863 16 form form NN 31504 863 17 ; ; : 31504 863 18 but but CC 31504 863 19 illegitimate illegitimate JJ 31504 863 20 and and CC 31504 863 21 unconstitutional unconstitutional JJ 31504 863 22 practices practice NNS 31504 863 23 get get VBP 31504 863 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 863 25 first first JJ 31504 863 26 footing footing NN 31504 863 27 in in IN 31504 863 28 that that DT 31504 863 29 way way NN 31504 863 30 , , , 31504 863 31 namely namely RB 31504 863 32 , , , 31504 863 33 by by IN 31504 863 34 silent silent JJ 31504 863 35 approaches approach NNS 31504 863 36 and and CC 31504 863 37 slight slight JJ 31504 863 38 deviations deviation NNS 31504 863 39 from from IN 31504 863 40 legal legal JJ 31504 863 41 modes mode NNS 31504 863 42 of of IN 31504 863 43 procedure procedure NN 31504 863 44 . . . 31504 864 1 This this DT 31504 864 2 can can MD 31504 864 3 only only RB 31504 864 4 be be VB 31504 864 5 obviated obviate VBN 31504 864 6 by by IN 31504 864 7 adhering adhere VBG 31504 864 8 to to IN 31504 864 9 the the DT 31504 864 10 rule rule NN 31504 864 11 that that IN 31504 864 12 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 864 13 provisions provision NNS 31504 864 14 for for IN 31504 864 15 the the DT 31504 864 16 security security NN 31504 864 17 of of IN 31504 864 18 person person NN 31504 864 19 and and CC 31504 864 20 property property NN 31504 864 21 should should MD 31504 864 22 be be VB 31504 864 23 liberally liberally RB 31504 864 24 construed construe VBN 31504 864 25 . . . 31504 865 1 A a DT 31504 865 2 close close JJ 31504 865 3 and and CC 31504 865 4 literal literal JJ 31504 865 5 construction construction NN 31504 865 6 deprives deprive VBZ 31504 865 7 them -PRON- PRP 31504 865 8 of of IN 31504 865 9 half half PDT 31504 865 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 865 11 efficacy efficacy NN 31504 865 12 and and CC 31504 865 13 leads lead VBZ 31504 865 14 to to IN 31504 865 15 gradual gradual JJ 31504 865 16 depreciation depreciation NN 31504 865 17 of of IN 31504 865 18 the the DT 31504 865 19 right right NN 31504 865 20 as as IN 31504 865 21 if if IN 31504 865 22 it -PRON- PRP 31504 865 23 consisted consist VBD 31504 865 24 more more RBR 31504 865 25 in in IN 31504 865 26 sound sound NN 31504 865 27 than than IN 31504 865 28 in in IN 31504 865 29 substance substance NN 31504 865 30 . . . 31504 866 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 866 2 is be VBZ 31504 866 3 the the DT 31504 866 4 duty duty NN 31504 866 5 of of IN 31504 866 6 courts court NNS 31504 866 7 to to TO 31504 866 8 be be VB 31504 866 9 watchful watchful JJ 31504 866 10 for for IN 31504 866 11 the the DT 31504 866 12 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 866 13 rights right NNS 31504 866 14 of of IN 31504 866 15 the the DT 31504 866 16 citizen citizen NN 31504 866 17 and and CC 31504 866 18 against against IN 31504 866 19 any any DT 31504 866 20 stealthy stealthy JJ 31504 866 21 encroachments encroachment NNS 31504 866 22 thereon thereon NN 31504 866 23 . . . 31504 867 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 867 2 motto motto NN 31504 867 3 should should MD 31504 867 4 be be VB 31504 867 5 _ _ NNP 31504 867 6 obsta obsta NNP 31504 867 7 principiis principiis NNP 31504 867 8 _ _ NNP 31504 867 9 . . . 31504 867 10 " " '' 31504 868 1 A a DT 31504 868 2 review review NN 31504 868 3 of of IN 31504 868 4 the the DT 31504 868 5 cases case NNS 31504 868 6 in in IN 31504 868 7 which which WDT 31504 868 8 the the DT 31504 868 9 courts court NNS 31504 868 10 have have VBP 31504 868 11 been be VBN 31504 868 12 called call VBN 31504 868 13 upon upon IN 31504 868 14 to to TO 31504 868 15 decide decide VB 31504 868 16 whether whether IN 31504 868 17 a a DT 31504 868 18 statute statute NN 31504 868 19 breaks break VBZ 31504 868 20 over over IN 31504 868 21 the the DT 31504 868 22 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 868 23 limitation limitation NN 31504 868 24 will will MD 31504 868 25 demonstrate demonstrate VB 31504 868 26 to to IN 31504 868 27 any any DT 31504 868 28 dispassionate dispassionate JJ 31504 868 29 person person NN 31504 868 30 that that IN 31504 868 31 upon upon IN 31504 868 32 questions question NNS 31504 868 33 of of IN 31504 868 34 expediency expediency NN 31504 868 35 , , , 31504 868 36 of of IN 31504 868 37 the the DT 31504 868 38 general general JJ 31504 868 39 welfare welfare NN 31504 868 40 , , , 31504 868 41 or or CC 31504 868 42 even even RB 31504 868 43 of of IN 31504 868 44 justice justice NN 31504 868 45 , , , 31504 868 46 the the DT 31504 868 47 judges judge NNS 31504 868 48 rarely rarely RB 31504 868 49 if if IN 31504 868 50 ever ever RB 31504 868 51 oppose oppose VBP 31504 868 52 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 868 53 opinion opinion NN 31504 868 54 to to IN 31504 868 55 that that DT 31504 868 56 of of IN 31504 868 57 the the DT 31504 868 58 legislators legislator NNS 31504 868 59 . . . 31504 869 1 The the DT 31504 869 2 courts court NNS 31504 869 3 do do VBP 31504 869 4 not not RB 31504 869 5 obstruct obstruct VB 31504 869 6 the the DT 31504 869 7 current current NN 31504 869 8 of of IN 31504 869 9 progress progress NN 31504 869 10 ; ; : 31504 869 11 they -PRON- PRP 31504 869 12 only only RB 31504 869 13 keep keep VBP 31504 869 14 it -PRON- PRP 31504 869 15 from from IN 31504 869 16 overflowing overflow VBG 31504 869 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 869 18 banks bank NNS 31504 869 19 to to IN 31504 869 20 the the DT 31504 869 21 devastation devastation NN 31504 869 22 of of IN 31504 869 23 the the DT 31504 869 24 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 869 25 rights right NNS 31504 869 26 of of IN 31504 869 27 the the DT 31504 869 28 people people NNS 31504 869 29 . . . 31504 870 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31504 870 2 IX IX NNP 31504 870 3 THE the DT 31504 870 4 NECESSITY NECESSITY NNP 31504 870 5 OF of IN 31504 870 6 MAINTAINING maintain VBG 31504 870 7 UNDIMINISHED UNDIMINISHED NNS 31504 870 8 THE the DT 31504 870 9 CONSTITUTIONAL constitutional JJ 31504 870 10 LIMITATIONS limitations NN 31504 870 11 AND and CC 31504 870 12 THE the DT 31504 870 13 POWER power NN 31504 870 14 OF of IN 31504 870 15 THE the DT 31504 870 16 COURTS court NNS 31504 870 17 TO to IN 31504 870 18 ENFORCE ENFORCE NNP 31504 870 19 THEM.--CONCLUSION them.--conclusion NN 31504 870 20 Despite despite IN 31504 870 21 the the DT 31504 870 22 lessons lesson NNS 31504 870 23 of of IN 31504 870 24 history history NN 31504 870 25 showing show VBG 31504 870 26 the the DT 31504 870 27 need need NN 31504 870 28 of of IN 31504 870 29 specified specified JJ 31504 870 30 limitations limitation NNS 31504 870 31 upon upon IN 31504 870 32 the the DT 31504 870 33 legislative legislative JJ 31504 870 34 power power NN 31504 870 35 to to TO 31504 870 36 ensure ensure VB 31504 870 37 personal personal JJ 31504 870 38 liberty liberty NN 31504 870 39 and and CC 31504 870 40 justice justice NN 31504 870 41 , , , 31504 870 42 it -PRON- PRP 31504 870 43 is be VBZ 31504 870 44 still still RB 31504 870 45 urged urge VBN 31504 870 46 by by IN 31504 870 47 the the DT 31504 870 48 impatient impatient NN 31504 870 49 that that IN 31504 870 50 this this DT 31504 870 51 check check NN 31504 870 52 upon upon IN 31504 870 53 legislative legislative JJ 31504 870 54 action action NN 31504 870 55 should should MD 31504 870 56 be be VB 31504 870 57 removed remove VBN 31504 870 58 , , , 31504 870 59 or or CC 31504 870 60 at at IN 31504 870 61 least least JJS 31504 870 62 that that IN 31504 870 63 the the DT 31504 870 64 legislature legislature NN 31504 870 65 should should MD 31504 870 66 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 870 67 be be VB 31504 870 68 the the DT 31504 870 69 judge judge NN 31504 870 70 of of IN 31504 870 71 the the DT 31504 870 72 constitutionality constitutionality NN 31504 870 73 of of IN 31504 870 74 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 870 75 acts act NNS 31504 870 76 , , , 31504 870 77 and and CC 31504 870 78 that that IN 31504 870 79 the the DT 31504 870 80 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 870 81 as as IN 31504 870 82 the the DT 31504 870 83 representatives representative NNS 31504 870 84 of of IN 31504 870 85 the the DT 31504 870 86 people people NNS 31504 870 87 may may MD 31504 870 88 be be VB 31504 870 89 trusted trust VBN 31504 870 90 to to TO 31504 870 91 observe observe VB 31504 870 92 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 870 93 requirements requirement NNS 31504 870 94 and and CC 31504 870 95 limitations limitation NNS 31504 870 96 . . . 31504 871 1 From from IN 31504 871 2 the the DT 31504 871 3 beginning beginning NN 31504 871 4 , , , 31504 871 5 however however RB 31504 871 6 , , , 31504 871 7 the the DT 31504 871 8 people people NNS 31504 871 9 of of IN 31504 871 10 this this DT 31504 871 11 country country NN 31504 871 12 have have VBP 31504 871 13 not not RB 31504 871 14 fully fully RB 31504 871 15 trusted trust VBN 31504 871 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 871 17 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 871 18 . . . 31504 872 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 872 2 have have VBP 31504 872 3 not not RB 31504 872 4 only only RB 31504 872 5 set set VBN 31504 872 6 bounds bound NNS 31504 872 7 to to IN 31504 872 8 legislative legislative JJ 31504 872 9 power power NN 31504 872 10 , , , 31504 872 11 but but CC 31504 872 12 within within IN 31504 872 13 those those DT 31504 872 14 bounds bound NNS 31504 872 15 they -PRON- PRP 31504 872 16 have have VBP 31504 872 17 imposed impose VBN 31504 872 18 in in IN 31504 872 19 most most JJS 31504 872 20 instances instance NNS 31504 872 21 the the DT 31504 872 22 check check NN 31504 872 23 of of IN 31504 872 24 an an DT 31504 872 25 executive executive JJ 31504 872 26 veto veto NN 31504 872 27 . . . 31504 873 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 873 2 have have VBP 31504 873 3 also also RB 31504 873 4 complained complain VBN 31504 873 5 of of IN 31504 873 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 873 7 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 873 8 far far RB 31504 873 9 more more RBR 31504 873 10 loudly loudly RB 31504 873 11 than than IN 31504 873 12 they -PRON- PRP 31504 873 13 have have VBP 31504 873 14 of of IN 31504 873 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 873 16 courts court NNS 31504 873 17 , , , 31504 873 18 and and CC 31504 873 19 latterly latterly RB 31504 873 20 have have VBP 31504 873 21 subjected subject VBN 31504 873 22 them -PRON- PRP 31504 873 23 to to IN 31504 873 24 the the DT 31504 873 25 initiative initiative NN 31504 873 26 and and CC 31504 873 27 referendum referendum NN 31504 873 28 and and CC 31504 873 29 in in IN 31504 873 30 some some DT 31504 873 31 instances instance NNS 31504 873 32 to to IN 31504 873 33 the the DT 31504 873 34 recall recall NN 31504 873 35 . . . 31504 874 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 31504 874 2 the the DT 31504 874 3 judgment judgment NN 31504 874 4 of of IN 31504 874 5 those those DT 31504 874 6 urging urge VBG 31504 874 7 that that IN 31504 874 8 the the DT 31504 874 9 legislature legislature NN 31504 874 10 should should MD 31504 874 11 be be VB 31504 874 12 trusted trust VBN 31504 874 13 not not RB 31504 874 14 to to TO 31504 874 15 trespass trespass VB 31504 874 16 on on IN 31504 874 17 the the DT 31504 874 18 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 874 19 rights right NNS 31504 874 20 of of IN 31504 874 21 the the DT 31504 874 22 people people NNS 31504 874 23 may may MD 31504 874 24 be be VB 31504 874 25 enlightened enlighten VBN 31504 874 26 by by IN 31504 874 27 recalling recall VBG 31504 874 28 some some DT 31504 874 29 instances instance NNS 31504 874 30 of of IN 31504 874 31 legislative legislative JJ 31504 874 32 action action NN 31504 874 33 upon upon IN 31504 874 34 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 874 35 questions question NNS 31504 874 36 left leave VBN 31504 874 37 to to IN 31504 874 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 874 39 decision decision NN 31504 874 40 by by IN 31504 874 41 the the DT 31504 874 42 constitution constitution NN 31504 874 43 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 874 44 . . . 31504 875 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 875 2 is be VBZ 31504 875 3 hardly hardly RB 31504 875 4 necessary necessary JJ 31504 875 5 to to TO 31504 875 6 cite cite VB 31504 875 7 instances instance NNS 31504 875 8 of of IN 31504 875 9 the the DT 31504 875 10 abuse abuse NN 31504 875 11 of of IN 31504 875 12 this this DT 31504 875 13 power power NN 31504 875 14 in in IN 31504 875 15 the the DT 31504 875 16 matter matter NN 31504 875 17 of of IN 31504 875 18 determining determine VBG 31504 875 19 who who WP 31504 875 20 are be VBP 31504 875 21 entitled entitle VBN 31504 875 22 to to IN 31504 875 23 seats seat NNS 31504 875 24 in in IN 31504 875 25 the the DT 31504 875 26 legislature legislature NN 31504 875 27 . . . 31504 876 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 876 2 is be VBZ 31504 876 3 common common JJ 31504 876 4 knowledge knowledge NN 31504 876 5 that that WDT 31504 876 6 , , , 31504 876 7 in in IN 31504 876 8 the the DT 31504 876 9 past past NN 31504 876 10 at at IN 31504 876 11 least least RBS 31504 876 12 , , , 31504 876 13 both both DT 31504 876 14 law law NN 31504 876 15 and and CC 31504 876 16 fact fact NN 31504 876 17 have have VBP 31504 876 18 often often RB 31504 876 19 been be VBN 31504 876 20 over over RB 31504 876 21 - - HYPH 31504 876 22 ridden ridden JJ 31504 876 23 for for IN 31504 876 24 partisan partisan JJ 31504 876 25 advantage advantage NN 31504 876 26 . . . 31504 877 1 As as IN 31504 877 2 an an DT 31504 877 3 illustration illustration NN 31504 877 4 of of IN 31504 877 5 how how WRB 31504 877 6 far far RB 31504 877 7 a a DT 31504 877 8 legislature legislature NN 31504 877 9 will will MD 31504 877 10 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 877 11 go go VB 31504 877 12 in in IN 31504 877 13 this this DT 31504 877 14 direction direction NN 31504 877 15 I -PRON- PRP 31504 877 16 may may MD 31504 877 17 cite cite VB 31504 877 18 a a DT 31504 877 19 recent recent JJ 31504 877 20 instance instance NN 31504 877 21 in in IN 31504 877 22 Maine Maine NNP 31504 877 23 . . . 31504 878 1 The the DT 31504 878 2 constitution constitution NN 31504 878 3 of of IN 31504 878 4 that that DT 31504 878 5 state state NN 31504 878 6 provides provide VBZ 31504 878 7 ( ( -LRB- 31504 878 8 Art art NN 31504 878 9 . . . 31504 879 1 IV IV NNP 31504 879 2 , , , 31504 879 3 Pt Pt NNP 31504 879 4 . . . 31504 880 1 3 3 LS 31504 880 2 , , , 31504 880 3 Sec Sec NNP 31504 880 4 . . . 31504 881 1 11 11 LS 31504 881 2 ) ) -RRB- 31504 881 3 that that IN 31504 881 4 " " `` 31504 881 5 no no DT 31504 881 6 person person NN 31504 881 7 holding hold VBG 31504 881 8 any any DT 31504 881 9 office office NN 31504 881 10 under under IN 31504 881 11 the the DT 31504 881 12 United United NNP 31504 881 13 States States NNP 31504 881 14 ( ( -LRB- 31504 881 15 post post NN 31504 881 16 officers officer NNS 31504 881 17 excepted except VBN 31504 881 18 ) ) -RRB- 31504 881 19 shall shall MD 31504 881 20 have have VB 31504 881 21 a a DT 31504 881 22 seat seat NN 31504 881 23 in in IN 31504 881 24 either either DT 31504 881 25 house house NN 31504 881 26 of of IN 31504 881 27 the the DT 31504 881 28 legislature legislature NN 31504 881 29 during during IN 31504 881 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 881 31 continuing continue VBG 31504 881 32 in in IN 31504 881 33 such such JJ 31504 881 34 office office NN 31504 881 35 . . . 31504 881 36 " " '' 31504 882 1 This this DT 31504 882 2 provision provision NN 31504 882 3 was be VBD 31504 882 4 in in IN 31504 882 5 the the DT 31504 882 6 original original JJ 31504 882 7 constitution constitution NN 31504 882 8 of of IN 31504 882 9 1821 1821 CD 31504 882 10 , , , 31504 882 11 and and CC 31504 882 12 until until IN 31504 882 13 the the DT 31504 882 14 legislative legislative JJ 31504 882 15 session session NN 31504 882 16 of of IN 31504 882 17 1913 1913 CD 31504 882 18 the the DT 31504 882 19 exception exception NN 31504 882 20 of of IN 31504 882 21 " " `` 31504 882 22 post post NN 31504 882 23 officers officer NNS 31504 882 24 " " '' 31504 882 25 was be VBD 31504 882 26 understood understand VBN 31504 882 27 to to TO 31504 882 28 refer refer VB 31504 882 29 to to IN 31504 882 30 officers officer NNS 31504 882 31 in in IN 31504 882 32 the the DT 31504 882 33 postal postal JJ 31504 882 34 service service NN 31504 882 35 and and CC 31504 882 36 such such JJ 31504 882 37 officers officer NNS 31504 882 38 often often RB 31504 882 39 held hold VBD 31504 882 40 seats seat NNS 31504 882 41 in in IN 31504 882 42 the the DT 31504 882 43 legislature legislature NN 31504 882 44 without without IN 31504 882 45 question question NN 31504 882 46 . . . 31504 883 1 In in IN 31504 883 2 1913 1913 CD 31504 883 3 , , , 31504 883 4 however however RB 31504 883 5 , , , 31504 883 6 the the DT 31504 883 7 House House NNP 31504 883 8 of of IN 31504 883 9 Representatives Representatives NNPS 31504 883 10 held hold VBN 31504 883 11 for for IN 31504 883 12 awhile awhile JJ 31504 883 13 that that IN 31504 883 14 the the DT 31504 883 15 exception exception NN 31504 883 16 referred refer VBD 31504 883 17 only only RB 31504 883 18 to to IN 31504 883 19 military military JJ 31504 883 20 officers officer NNS 31504 883 21 of of IN 31504 883 22 the the DT 31504 883 23 United United NNP 31504 883 24 States States NNP 31504 883 25 stationed station VBN 31504 883 26 at at IN 31504 883 27 military military JJ 31504 883 28 posts post NNS 31504 883 29 within within IN 31504 883 30 the the DT 31504 883 31 state state NN 31504 883 32 , , , 31504 883 33 though though IN 31504 883 34 no no DT 31504 883 35 such such JJ 31504 883 36 officer officer NN 31504 883 37 had have VBD 31504 883 38 ever ever RB 31504 883 39 held hold VBN 31504 883 40 a a DT 31504 883 41 seat seat NN 31504 883 42 in in IN 31504 883 43 the the DT 31504 883 44 legislature legislature NN 31504 883 45 . . . 31504 884 1 That that IN 31504 884 2 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 884 3 are be VBP 31504 884 4 prone prone JJ 31504 884 5 to to TO 31504 884 6 disregard disregard VB 31504 884 7 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 884 8 provisions provision NNS 31504 884 9 is be VBZ 31504 884 10 also also RB 31504 884 11 manifest manif JJS 31504 884 12 in in IN 31504 884 13 the the DT 31504 884 14 vast vast JJ 31504 884 15 amount amount NN 31504 884 16 of of IN 31504 884 17 special special JJ 31504 884 18 legislation legislation NN 31504 884 19 enacted enact VBN 31504 884 20 despite despite IN 31504 884 21 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 884 22 prohibitions prohibition NNS 31504 884 23 of of IN 31504 884 24 such such JJ 31504 884 25 legislation legislation NN 31504 884 26 . . . 31504 885 1 There there EX 31504 885 2 are be VBP 31504 885 3 also also RB 31504 885 4 numerous numerous JJ 31504 885 5 instances instance NNS 31504 885 6 where where WRB 31504 885 7 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 885 8 while while IN 31504 885 9 perfunctorily perfunctorily RB 31504 885 10 heeding heed VBG 31504 885 11 the the DT 31504 885 12 letter letter NN 31504 885 13 of of IN 31504 885 14 the the DT 31504 885 15 constitution constitution NN 31504 885 16 consciously consciously RB 31504 885 17 violate violate VB 31504 885 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 885 19 spirit spirit NN 31504 885 20 and and CC 31504 885 21 evade evade VB 31504 885 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 885 23 requirements requirement NNS 31504 885 24 . . . 31504 886 1 In in IN 31504 886 2 many many JJ 31504 886 3 states state NNS 31504 886 4 there there EX 31504 886 5 is be VBZ 31504 886 6 a a DT 31504 886 7 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 886 8 provision provision NN 31504 886 9 that that IN 31504 886 10 no no DT 31504 886 11 legislative legislative JJ 31504 886 12 act act NN 31504 886 13 shall shall MD 31504 886 14 become become VB 31504 886 15 effective effective JJ 31504 886 16 until until IN 31504 886 17 after after IN 31504 886 18 a a DT 31504 886 19 specified specify VBN 31504 886 20 time time NN 31504 886 21 has have VBZ 31504 886 22 elapsed elapse VBN 31504 886 23 from from IN 31504 886 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 886 25 enactment enactment NN 31504 886 26 " " '' 31504 886 27 except except IN 31504 886 28 in in IN 31504 886 29 cases case NNS 31504 886 30 of of IN 31504 886 31 emergency emergency NN 31504 886 32 , , , 31504 886 33 " " '' 31504 886 34 which which WDT 31504 886 35 emergency emergency NN 31504 886 36 , , , 31504 886 37 however however RB 31504 886 38 , , , 31504 886 39 is be VBZ 31504 886 40 to to TO 31504 886 41 be be VB 31504 886 42 declared declare VBN 31504 886 43 in in IN 31504 886 44 the the DT 31504 886 45 act act NN 31504 886 46 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 886 47 . . . 31504 887 1 This this DT 31504 887 2 provision provision NN 31504 887 3 , , , 31504 887 4 of of IN 31504 887 5 course course NN 31504 887 6 , , , 31504 887 7 is be VBZ 31504 887 8 to to TO 31504 887 9 give give VB 31504 887 10 the the DT 31504 887 11 people people NNS 31504 887 12 time time NN 31504 887 13 to to TO 31504 887 14 understand understand VB 31504 887 15 the the DT 31504 887 16 statute statute NN 31504 887 17 and and CC 31504 887 18 prepare prepare VB 31504 887 19 to to TO 31504 887 20 obey obey VB 31504 887 21 it -PRON- PRP 31504 887 22 . . . 31504 888 1 The the DT 31504 888 2 word word NN 31504 888 3 " " `` 31504 888 4 emergency emergency NN 31504 888 5 " " '' 31504 888 6 in in IN 31504 888 7 the the DT 31504 888 8 exception exception NN 31504 888 9 implies imply VBZ 31504 888 10 a a DT 31504 888 11 sudden sudden JJ 31504 888 12 , , , 31504 888 13 unexpected unexpected JJ 31504 888 14 happening happening NN 31504 888 15 . . . 31504 889 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 889 2 is be VBZ 31504 889 3 defined define VBN 31504 889 4 in in IN 31504 889 5 Webster Webster NNP 31504 889 6 as as IN 31504 889 7 a a DT 31504 889 8 " " `` 31504 889 9 pressing press VBG 31504 889 10 necessity necessity NN 31504 889 11 ; ; : 31504 889 12 an an DT 31504 889 13 unforeseen unforeseen JJ 31504 889 14 occurrence occurrence NN 31504 889 15 or or CC 31504 889 16 combination combination NN 31504 889 17 of of IN 31504 889 18 circumstances circumstance NNS 31504 889 19 which which WDT 31504 889 20 calls call VBZ 31504 889 21 for for IN 31504 889 22 immediate immediate JJ 31504 889 23 action action NN 31504 889 24 or or CC 31504 889 25 remedy remedy NN 31504 889 26 . . . 31504 889 27 " " '' 31504 890 1 In in IN 31504 890 2 Indiana Indiana NNP 31504 890 3 in in IN 31504 890 4 one one CD 31504 890 5 legislative legislative JJ 31504 890 6 session session NN 31504 890 7 , , , 31504 890 8 out out IN 31504 890 9 of of IN 31504 890 10 200 200 CD 31504 890 11 acts act NNS 31504 890 12 , , , 31504 890 13 155 155 CD 31504 890 14 were be VBD 31504 890 15 made make VBN 31504 890 16 to to TO 31504 890 17 take take VB 31504 890 18 effect effect NN 31504 890 19 at at IN 31504 890 20 once once RB 31504 890 21 by by IN 31504 890 22 a a DT 31504 890 23 recital recital NN 31504 890 24 that that WDT 31504 890 25 an an DT 31504 890 26 emergency emergency NN 31504 890 27 existed exist VBD 31504 890 28 therefor therefor RB 31504 890 29 . . . 31504 891 1 In in IN 31504 891 2 Illinois Illinois NNP 31504 891 3 a a DT 31504 891 4 two two CD 31504 891 5 - - HYPH 31504 891 6 thirds third NNS 31504 891 7 vote vote NN 31504 891 8 of of IN 31504 891 9 all all PDT 31504 891 10 the the DT 31504 891 11 members member NNS 31504 891 12 elected elect VBD 31504 891 13 to to IN 31504 891 14 each each DT 31504 891 15 house house NN 31504 891 16 is be VBZ 31504 891 17 required require VBN 31504 891 18 for for IN 31504 891 19 the the DT 31504 891 20 adoption adoption NN 31504 891 21 of of IN 31504 891 22 the the DT 31504 891 23 emergency emergency NN 31504 891 24 clause clause NN 31504 891 25 . . . 31504 892 1 Among among IN 31504 892 2 the the DT 31504 892 3 acts act NNS 31504 892 4 of of IN 31504 892 5 the the DT 31504 892 6 last last JJ 31504 892 7 session session NN 31504 892 8 containing contain VBG 31504 892 9 the the DT 31504 892 10 emergency emergency NN 31504 892 11 clause clause NN 31504 892 12 was be VBD 31504 892 13 one one CD 31504 892 14 appropriating appropriate VBG 31504 892 15 $ $ $ 31504 892 16 600 600 CD 31504 892 17 for for IN 31504 892 18 printing print VBG 31504 892 19 the the DT 31504 892 20 report report NN 31504 892 21 of of IN 31504 892 22 a a DT 31504 892 23 monument monument NN 31504 892 24 association association NN 31504 892 25 . . . 31504 893 1 In in IN 31504 893 2 Tennessee Tennessee NNP 31504 893 3 the the DT 31504 893 4 exception exception NN 31504 893 5 was be VBD 31504 893 6 of of IN 31504 893 7 cases case NNS 31504 893 8 where where WRB 31504 893 9 " " `` 31504 893 10 the the DT 31504 893 11 public public JJ 31504 893 12 welfare welfare NN 31504 893 13 " " `` 31504 893 14 required require VBD 31504 893 15 an an DT 31504 893 16 earlier early JJR 31504 893 17 date date NN 31504 893 18 . . . 31504 894 1 Out out IN 31504 894 2 of of IN 31504 894 3 265 265 CD 31504 894 4 laws law NNS 31504 894 5 passed pass VBN 31504 894 6 at at IN 31504 894 7 one one CD 31504 894 8 session session NN 31504 894 9 230 230 CD 31504 894 10 contained contain VBD 31504 894 11 the the DT 31504 894 12 declaration declaration NN 31504 894 13 that that IN 31504 894 14 the the DT 31504 894 15 public public JJ 31504 894 16 welfare welfare NN 31504 894 17 required require VBD 31504 894 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 894 19 going go VBG 31504 894 20 into into IN 31504 894 21 effect effect NN 31504 894 22 immediately immediately RB 31504 894 23 . . . 31504 895 1 In in IN 31504 895 2 Texas Texas NNP 31504 895 3 the the DT 31504 895 4 constitution constitution NN 31504 895 5 provides provide VBZ 31504 895 6 that that IN 31504 895 7 no no DT 31504 895 8 bill bill NN 31504 895 9 shall shall MD 31504 895 10 be be VB 31504 895 11 passed pass VBN 31504 895 12 until until IN 31504 895 13 it -PRON- PRP 31504 895 14 has have VBZ 31504 895 15 been be VBN 31504 895 16 read read VBN 31504 895 17 on on IN 31504 895 18 three three CD 31504 895 19 several several JJ 31504 895 20 days day NNS 31504 895 21 in in IN 31504 895 22 each each DT 31504 895 23 house house NN 31504 895 24 and and CC 31504 895 25 free free JJ 31504 895 26 discussion discussion NN 31504 895 27 allowed allow VBD 31504 895 28 thereon thereon NN 31504 895 29 , , , 31504 895 30 but but CC 31504 895 31 that that IN 31504 895 32 " " `` 31504 895 33 in in IN 31504 895 34 cases case NNS 31504 895 35 of of IN 31504 895 36 imperative imperative JJ 31504 895 37 public public JJ 31504 895 38 necessity necessity NN 31504 895 39 four four CD 31504 895 40 - - HYPH 31504 895 41 fifths fifth NNS 31504 895 42 of of IN 31504 895 43 the the DT 31504 895 44 house house NN 31504 895 45 may may MD 31504 895 46 suspend suspend VB 31504 895 47 the the DT 31504 895 48 rule rule NN 31504 895 49 . . . 31504 895 50 " " '' 31504 896 1 Out out IN 31504 896 2 of of IN 31504 896 3 118 118 CD 31504 896 4 laws law NNS 31504 896 5 passed pass VBN 31504 896 6 at at IN 31504 896 7 one one CD 31504 896 8 session session NN 31504 896 9 all all DT 31504 896 10 but but IN 31504 896 11 five five CD 31504 896 12 contained contain VBD 31504 896 13 the the DT 31504 896 14 statement statement NN 31504 896 15 that that IN 31504 896 16 " " `` 31504 896 17 imperative imperative JJ 31504 896 18 public public JJ 31504 896 19 necessity necessity NN 31504 896 20 " " '' 31504 896 21 required require VBN 31504 896 22 suspension suspension NN 31504 896 23 of of IN 31504 896 24 the the DT 31504 896 25 rule rule NN 31504 896 26 . . . 31504 897 1 Legislatures legislature NNS 31504 897 2 also also RB 31504 897 3 seem seem VBP 31504 897 4 prone prone JJ 31504 897 5 to to TO 31504 897 6 disregard disregard VB 31504 897 7 the the DT 31504 897 8 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 897 9 provision provision NN 31504 897 10 for for IN 31504 897 11 the the DT 31504 897 12 referendum referendum NN 31504 897 13 despite despite IN 31504 897 14 the the DT 31504 897 15 strong strong JJ 31504 897 16 , , , 31504 897 17 explicit explicit JJ 31504 897 18 language language NN 31504 897 19 of of IN 31504 897 20 that that DT 31504 897 21 provision provision NN 31504 897 22 . . . 31504 898 1 In in IN 31504 898 2 California California NNP 31504 898 3 the the DT 31504 898 4 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 898 5 provision provision NN 31504 898 6 is be VBZ 31504 898 7 as as IN 31504 898 8 follows follow VBZ 31504 898 9 : : : 31504 898 10 " " `` 31504 898 11 No no DT 31504 898 12 act act NN 31504 898 13 shall shall MD 31504 898 14 go go VB 31504 898 15 into into IN 31504 898 16 effect effect NN 31504 898 17 until until IN 31504 898 18 ninety ninety CD 31504 898 19 days day NNS 31504 898 20 after after IN 31504 898 21 the the DT 31504 898 22 adjournment adjournment NN 31504 898 23 of of IN 31504 898 24 the the DT 31504 898 25 legislature legislature NN 31504 898 26 which which WDT 31504 898 27 passed pass VBD 31504 898 28 such such JJ 31504 898 29 act act NN 31504 898 30 ... ... NFP 31504 898 31 except except IN 31504 898 32 urgency urgency NN 31504 898 33 measures measure NNS 31504 898 34 necessary necessary JJ 31504 898 35 for for IN 31504 898 36 the the DT 31504 898 37 immediate immediate JJ 31504 898 38 preservation preservation NN 31504 898 39 of of IN 31504 898 40 the the DT 31504 898 41 public public JJ 31504 898 42 peace peace NN 31504 898 43 , , , 31504 898 44 health health NN 31504 898 45 or or CC 31504 898 46 safety safety NN 31504 898 47 , , , 31504 898 48 passed pass VBN 31504 898 49 by by IN 31504 898 50 a a DT 31504 898 51 two two CD 31504 898 52 - - HYPH 31504 898 53 thirds third NNS 31504 898 54 vote vote NN 31504 898 55 of of IN 31504 898 56 all all PDT 31504 898 57 the the DT 31504 898 58 members member NNS 31504 898 59 elected elect VBD 31504 898 60 to to IN 31504 898 61 each each DT 31504 898 62 house house NN 31504 898 63 . . . 31504 898 64 " " '' 31504 899 1 Surely surely RB 31504 899 2 the the DT 31504 899 3 language language NN 31504 899 4 of of IN 31504 899 5 the the DT 31504 899 6 exception exception NN 31504 899 7 is be VBZ 31504 899 8 strong strong JJ 31504 899 9 and and CC 31504 899 10 forceful forceful JJ 31504 899 11 . . . 31504 900 1 Two two CD 31504 900 2 - - HYPH 31504 900 3 thirds third NNS 31504 900 4 of of IN 31504 900 5 all all PDT 31504 900 6 the the DT 31504 900 7 members member NNS 31504 900 8 elected elect VBD 31504 900 9 to to IN 31504 900 10 each each DT 31504 900 11 house house NN 31504 900 12 must must MD 31504 900 13 hold hold VB 31504 900 14 that that IN 31504 900 15 the the DT 31504 900 16 measure measure NN 31504 900 17 is be VBZ 31504 900 18 urgent urgent JJ 31504 900 19 , , , 31504 900 20 not not RB 31504 900 21 admitting admit VBG 31504 900 22 of of IN 31504 900 23 delay delay NN 31504 900 24 , , , 31504 900 25 that that IN 31504 900 26 the the DT 31504 900 27 public public JJ 31504 900 28 peace peace NN 31504 900 29 , , , 31504 900 30 health health NN 31504 900 31 or or CC 31504 900 32 safety safety NN 31504 900 33 , , , 31504 900 34 not not RB 31504 900 35 the the DT 31504 900 36 mere mere JJ 31504 900 37 interests interest NNS 31504 900 38 or or CC 31504 900 39 convenience convenience NN 31504 900 40 of of IN 31504 900 41 individuals individual NNS 31504 900 42 or or CC 31504 900 43 localities locality NNS 31504 900 44 , , , 31504 900 45 is be VBZ 31504 900 46 threatened threaten VBN 31504 900 47 and and CC 31504 900 48 that that IN 31504 900 49 the the DT 31504 900 50 danger danger NN 31504 900 51 is be VBZ 31504 900 52 imminent imminent JJ 31504 900 53 , , , 31504 900 54 requiring require VBG 31504 900 55 immediate immediate JJ 31504 900 56 action action NN 31504 900 57 . . . 31504 901 1 Among among IN 31504 901 2 other other JJ 31504 901 3 instances instance NNS 31504 901 4 , , , 31504 901 5 the the DT 31504 901 6 legislature legislature NN 31504 901 7 of of IN 31504 901 8 California California NNP 31504 901 9 at at IN 31504 901 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 901 11 special special JJ 31504 901 12 session session NN 31504 901 13 of of IN 31504 901 14 1911 1911 CD 31504 901 15 adjudged adjudge VBD 31504 901 16 an an DT 31504 901 17 act act NN 31504 901 18 to to TO 31504 901 19 validate validate VB 31504 901 20 certain certain JJ 31504 901 21 defective defective JJ 31504 901 22 registrations registration NNS 31504 901 23 of of IN 31504 901 24 voters voter NNS 31504 901 25 in in IN 31504 901 26 some some DT 31504 901 27 municipalities municipality NNS 31504 901 28 to to TO 31504 901 29 be be VB 31504 901 30 an an DT 31504 901 31 urgency urgency NN 31504 901 32 measure measure NN 31504 901 33 within within IN 31504 901 34 the the DT 31504 901 35 language language NN 31504 901 36 of of IN 31504 901 37 the the DT 31504 901 38 exception exception NN 31504 901 39 ; ; : 31504 901 40 also also RB 31504 901 41 an an DT 31504 901 42 act act NN 31504 901 43 to to TO 31504 901 44 change change VB 31504 901 45 the the DT 31504 901 46 boundaries boundary NNS 31504 901 47 in in IN 31504 901 48 a a DT 31504 901 49 Reclamation Reclamation NNP 31504 901 50 District District NNP 31504 901 51 . . . 31504 902 1 Oregon Oregon NNP 31504 902 2 has have VBZ 31504 902 3 a a DT 31504 902 4 similar similar JJ 31504 902 5 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 902 6 requirement requirement NN 31504 902 7 and and CC 31504 902 8 exception exception NN 31504 902 9 which which WDT 31504 902 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 902 11 legislature legislature NN 31504 902 12 does do VBZ 31504 902 13 not not RB 31504 902 14 always always RB 31504 902 15 observe observe VB 31504 902 16 . . . 31504 903 1 At at IN 31504 903 2 the the DT 31504 903 3 session session NN 31504 903 4 of of IN 31504 903 5 1911 1911 CD 31504 903 6 , , , 31504 903 7 among among IN 31504 903 8 other other JJ 31504 903 9 cases case NNS 31504 903 10 the the DT 31504 903 11 legislature legislature NN 31504 903 12 adjudged adjudge VBD 31504 903 13 an an DT 31504 903 14 act act NN 31504 903 15 authorizing authorize VBG 31504 903 16 a a DT 31504 903 17 county county NN 31504 903 18 to to TO 31504 903 19 levy levy VB 31504 903 20 a a DT 31504 903 21 tax tax NN 31504 903 22 for for IN 31504 903 23 advertising advertise VBG 31504 903 24 the the DT 31504 903 25 county county NN 31504 903 26 's 's POS 31504 903 27 resources resource NNS 31504 903 28 to to TO 31504 903 29 be be VB 31504 903 30 within within IN 31504 903 31 the the DT 31504 903 32 exception exception NN 31504 903 33 ; ; : 31504 903 34 also also RB 31504 903 35 an an DT 31504 903 36 act act NN 31504 903 37 dividing divide VBG 31504 903 38 a a DT 31504 903 39 road road NN 31504 903 40 district district NN 31504 903 41 ; ; : 31504 903 42 but but CC 31504 903 43 an an DT 31504 903 44 act act NN 31504 903 45 appropriating appropriate VBG 31504 903 46 money money NN 31504 903 47 to to TO 31504 903 48 guard guard VB 31504 903 49 against against IN 31504 903 50 the the DT 31504 903 51 bubonic bubonic JJ 31504 903 52 plague plague NN 31504 903 53 was be VBD 31504 903 54 not not RB 31504 903 55 declared declare VBN 31504 903 56 to to TO 31504 903 57 be be VB 31504 903 58 within within IN 31504 903 59 the the DT 31504 903 60 exception exception NN 31504 903 61 . . . 31504 904 1 In in IN 31504 904 2 Oklahoma Oklahoma NNP 31504 904 3 with with IN 31504 904 4 a a DT 31504 904 5 similar similar JJ 31504 904 6 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 904 7 provision provision NN 31504 904 8 and and CC 31504 904 9 exception exception NN 31504 904 10 , , , 31504 904 11 the the DT 31504 904 12 legislature legislature NN 31504 904 13 seems seem VBZ 31504 904 14 to to TO 31504 904 15 have have VB 31504 904 16 run run VBN 31504 904 17 riot riot RB 31504 904 18 . . . 31504 905 1 At at IN 31504 905 2 the the DT 31504 905 3 session session NN 31504 905 4 of of IN 31504 905 5 1910 1910 CD 31504 905 6 a a DT 31504 905 7 very very RB 31504 905 8 large large JJ 31504 905 9 proportion proportion NN 31504 905 10 , , , 31504 905 11 if if IN 31504 905 12 not not RB 31504 905 13 a a DT 31504 905 14 majority majority NN 31504 905 15 , , , 31504 905 16 of of IN 31504 905 17 the the DT 31504 905 18 statutes statute NNS 31504 905 19 were be VBD 31504 905 20 adjudged adjudge VBN 31504 905 21 to to TO 31504 905 22 be be VB 31504 905 23 within within IN 31504 905 24 the the DT 31504 905 25 exception exception NN 31504 905 26 . . . 31504 906 1 Among among IN 31504 906 2 them -PRON- PRP 31504 906 3 was be VBD 31504 906 4 an an DT 31504 906 5 act act NN 31504 906 6 to to TO 31504 906 7 pay pay VB 31504 906 8 the the DT 31504 906 9 mileage mileage NN 31504 906 10 and and CC 31504 906 11 per per IN 31504 906 12 diem diem NN 31504 906 13 of of IN 31504 906 14 the the DT 31504 906 15 members member NNS 31504 906 16 ; ; : 31504 906 17 an an DT 31504 906 18 act act NN 31504 906 19 providing provide VBG 31504 906 20 stenographers stenographer NNS 31504 906 21 for for IN 31504 906 22 the the DT 31504 906 23 Supreme Supreme NNP 31504 906 24 Court Court NNP 31504 906 25 ; ; : 31504 906 26 an an DT 31504 906 27 act act NN 31504 906 28 authorizing authorize VBG 31504 906 29 the the DT 31504 906 30 sale sale NN 31504 906 31 of of IN 31504 906 32 four four CD 31504 906 33 tracts tract NNS 31504 906 34 of of IN 31504 906 35 land land NN 31504 906 36 at at IN 31504 906 37 public public JJ 31504 906 38 sale sale NN 31504 906 39 ; ; : 31504 906 40 an an DT 31504 906 41 act act NN 31504 906 42 to to TO 31504 906 43 pay pay VB 31504 906 44 J. J. NNP 31504 906 45 J. J. NNP 31504 906 46 O'Rourke O'Rourke NNP 31504 906 47 $ $ $ 31504 906 48 238.10 238.10 CD 31504 906 49 for for IN 31504 906 50 room room NN 31504 906 51 rent rent NN 31504 906 52 . . . 31504 907 1 On on IN 31504 907 2 the the DT 31504 907 3 other other JJ 31504 907 4 hand hand NN 31504 907 5 , , , 31504 907 6 an an DT 31504 907 7 act act NN 31504 907 8 to to TO 31504 907 9 reimburse reimburse VB 31504 907 10 the the DT 31504 907 11 Governor Governor NNP 31504 907 12 $ $ $ 31504 907 13 5000 5000 CD 31504 907 14 expended expend VBN 31504 907 15 by by IN 31504 907 16 him -PRON- PRP 31504 907 17 for for IN 31504 907 18 state state NN 31504 907 19 purposes purpose NNS 31504 907 20 , , , 31504 907 21 and and CC 31504 907 22 an an DT 31504 907 23 act act NN 31504 907 24 to to TO 31504 907 25 reimburse reimburse VB 31504 907 26 a a DT 31504 907 27 sheriff sheriff NN 31504 907 28 $ $ $ 31504 907 29 4000 4000 CD 31504 907 30 expended expend VBN 31504 907 31 by by IN 31504 907 32 him -PRON- PRP 31504 907 33 in in IN 31504 907 34 the the DT 31504 907 35 support support NN 31504 907 36 of of IN 31504 907 37 state state NN 31504 907 38 prisoners prisoner NNS 31504 907 39 were be VBD 31504 907 40 not not RB 31504 907 41 so so RB 31504 907 42 considered consider VBN 31504 907 43 . . . 31504 908 1 True true JJ 31504 908 2 , , , 31504 908 3 Oklahoma Oklahoma NNP 31504 908 4 is be VBZ 31504 908 5 a a DT 31504 908 6 new new JJ 31504 908 7 and and CC 31504 908 8 radical radical JJ 31504 908 9 state state NN 31504 908 10 , , , 31504 908 11 but but CC 31504 908 12 let let VB 31504 908 13 us -PRON- PRP 31504 908 14 turn turn VB 31504 908 15 to to IN 31504 908 16 the the DT 31504 908 17 extreme extreme NNP 31504 908 18 east east NNP 31504 908 19 , , , 31504 908 20 to to IN 31504 908 21 Maine Maine NNP 31504 908 22 with with IN 31504 908 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 908 24 heritage heritage NN 31504 908 25 of of IN 31504 908 26 law law NN 31504 908 27 - - HYPH 31504 908 28 abiding abide VBG 31504 908 29 traditions tradition NNS 31504 908 30 from from IN 31504 908 31 the the DT 31504 908 32 parent parent NN 31504 908 33 state state NN 31504 908 34 of of IN 31504 908 35 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 908 36 . . . 31504 909 1 Maine Maine NNP 31504 909 2 has have VBZ 31504 909 3 also also RB 31504 909 4 adopted adopt VBN 31504 909 5 the the DT 31504 909 6 referendum referendum NN 31504 909 7 in in IN 31504 909 8 language language NN 31504 909 9 similar similar JJ 31504 909 10 to to IN 31504 909 11 that that DT 31504 909 12 in in IN 31504 909 13 the the DT 31504 909 14 California California NNP 31504 909 15 constitution constitution NN 31504 909 16 , , , 31504 909 17 including include VBG 31504 909 18 the the DT 31504 909 19 exception exception NN 31504 909 20 . . . 31504 910 1 The the DT 31504 910 2 state state NN 31504 910 3 had have VBD 31504 910 4 got get VBN 31504 910 5 along along RB 31504 910 6 quite quite RB 31504 910 7 comfortably comfortably RB 31504 910 8 without without IN 31504 910 9 making make VBG 31504 910 10 Lincoln Lincoln NNP 31504 910 11 's 's POS 31504 910 12 birthday birthday NN 31504 910 13 a a DT 31504 910 14 legal legal JJ 31504 910 15 holiday holiday NN 31504 910 16 , , , 31504 910 17 but but CC 31504 910 18 in in IN 31504 910 19 1909 1909 CD 31504 910 20 the the DT 31504 910 21 legislature legislature NN 31504 910 22 awoke awake VBD 31504 910 23 to to IN 31504 910 24 the the DT 31504 910 25 imminent imminent JJ 31504 910 26 danger danger NN 31504 910 27 to to IN 31504 910 28 the the DT 31504 910 29 public public JJ 31504 910 30 peace peace NN 31504 910 31 , , , 31504 910 32 health health NN 31504 910 33 or or CC 31504 910 34 safety safety NN 31504 910 35 of of IN 31504 910 36 the the DT 31504 910 37 state state NN 31504 910 38 in in IN 31504 910 39 longer long JJR 31504 910 40 delay delay NN 31504 910 41 and and CC 31504 910 42 so so RB 31504 910 43 established establish VBD 31504 910 44 such such PDT 31504 910 45 a a DT 31504 910 46 holiday holiday NN 31504 910 47 at at IN 31504 910 48 once once RB 31504 910 49 without without IN 31504 910 50 according accord VBG 31504 910 51 to to IN 31504 910 52 the the DT 31504 910 53 people people NNS 31504 910 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 910 55 right right NN 31504 910 56 of of IN 31504 910 57 review review NN 31504 910 58 . . . 31504 911 1 The the DT 31504 911 2 town town NN 31504 911 3 of of IN 31504 911 4 Eden Eden NNP 31504 911 5 , , , 31504 911 6 in in IN 31504 911 7 which which WDT 31504 911 8 is be VBZ 31504 911 9 situated situate VBN 31504 911 10 Bar Bar NNP 31504 911 11 Harbor Harbor NNP 31504 911 12 , , , 31504 911 13 a a DT 31504 911 14 summer summer NN 31504 911 15 resort resort NN 31504 911 16 , , , 31504 911 17 had have VBD 31504 911 18 by by IN 31504 911 19 vote vote NN 31504 911 20 for for IN 31504 911 21 sometime sometime RB 31504 911 22 excluded exclude VBN 31504 911 23 automobiles automobile NNS 31504 911 24 without without IN 31504 911 25 any any DT 31504 911 26 apparent apparent JJ 31504 911 27 danger danger NN 31504 911 28 to to IN 31504 911 29 the the DT 31504 911 30 public public JJ 31504 911 31 peace peace NN 31504 911 32 , , , 31504 911 33 health health NN 31504 911 34 or or CC 31504 911 35 safety safety NN 31504 911 36 , , , 31504 911 37 but but CC 31504 911 38 at at IN 31504 911 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 911 40 last last JJ 31504 911 41 session session NN 31504 911 42 in in IN 31504 911 43 1913 1913 CD 31504 911 44 the the DT 31504 911 45 legislature legislature NN 31504 911 46 by by IN 31504 911 47 a a DT 31504 911 48 two two CD 31504 911 49 - - HYPH 31504 911 50 thirds third NNS 31504 911 51 vote vote NN 31504 911 52 of of IN 31504 911 53 all all PDT 31504 911 54 the the DT 31504 911 55 members member NNS 31504 911 56 elected elect VBD 31504 911 57 to to IN 31504 911 58 each each DT 31504 911 59 house house NN 31504 911 60 adjudged adjudge VBD 31504 911 61 that that IN 31504 911 62 the the DT 31504 911 63 public public JJ 31504 911 64 peace peace NN 31504 911 65 , , , 31504 911 66 health health NN 31504 911 67 or or CC 31504 911 68 safety safety NN 31504 911 69 would would MD 31504 911 70 be be VB 31504 911 71 imperiled imperil VBN 31504 911 72 by by IN 31504 911 73 postponing postpone VBG 31504 911 74 for for IN 31504 911 75 ninety ninety CD 31504 911 76 days day NNS 31504 911 77 the the DT 31504 911 78 operation operation NN 31504 911 79 of of IN 31504 911 80 an an DT 31504 911 81 act act NN 31504 911 82 authorizing authorize VBG 31504 911 83 a a DT 31504 911 84 repeal repeal NN 31504 911 85 of of IN 31504 911 86 the the DT 31504 911 87 vote vote NN 31504 911 88 . . . 31504 912 1 In in IN 31504 912 2 all all PDT 31504 912 3 the the DT 31504 912 4 instances instance NNS 31504 912 5 cited cite VBN 31504 912 6 , , , 31504 912 7 which which WDT 31504 912 8 are be VBP 31504 912 9 but but CC 31504 912 10 few few JJ 31504 912 11 out out IN 31504 912 12 of of IN 31504 912 13 many many JJ 31504 912 14 , , , 31504 912 15 it -PRON- PRP 31504 912 16 is be VBZ 31504 912 17 difficult difficult JJ 31504 912 18 to to TO 31504 912 19 see see VB 31504 912 20 how how WRB 31504 912 21 the the DT 31504 912 22 ninety ninety CD 31504 912 23 days day NNS 31504 912 24 ' ' POS 31504 912 25 postponement postponement NN 31504 912 26 of of IN 31504 912 27 the the DT 31504 912 28 operation operation NN 31504 912 29 of of IN 31504 912 30 the the DT 31504 912 31 acts act NNS 31504 912 32 cited cite VBN 31504 912 33 could could MD 31504 912 34 imperil imperil VB 31504 912 35 the the DT 31504 912 36 peace peace NN 31504 912 37 , , , 31504 912 38 health health NN 31504 912 39 or or CC 31504 912 40 safety safety NN 31504 912 41 of of IN 31504 912 42 the the DT 31504 912 43 public public NN 31504 912 44 , , , 31504 912 45 however however RB 31504 912 46 much much JJ 31504 912 47 it -PRON- PRP 31504 912 48 might may MD 31504 912 49 inconvenience inconvenience VB 31504 912 50 or or CC 31504 912 51 annoy annoy VB 31504 912 52 individuals individual NNS 31504 912 53 or or CC 31504 912 54 localities locality NNS 31504 912 55 . . . 31504 913 1 These these DT 31504 913 2 instances instance NNS 31504 913 3 should should MD 31504 913 4 , , , 31504 913 5 however however RB 31504 913 6 , , , 31504 913 7 throw throw VB 31504 913 8 considerable considerable JJ 31504 913 9 doubt doubt NN 31504 913 10 upon upon IN 31504 913 11 the the DT 31504 913 12 proposition proposition NN 31504 913 13 that that IN 31504 913 14 the the DT 31504 913 15 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 913 16 rights right NNS 31504 913 17 of of IN 31504 913 18 the the DT 31504 913 19 people people NNS 31504 913 20 are be VBP 31504 913 21 safe safe JJ 31504 913 22 in in IN 31504 913 23 the the DT 31504 913 24 hands hand NNS 31504 913 25 of of IN 31504 913 26 the the DT 31504 913 27 legislative legislative JJ 31504 913 28 department department NN 31504 913 29 without without IN 31504 913 30 the the DT 31504 913 31 check check NN 31504 913 32 of of IN 31504 913 33 the the DT 31504 913 34 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 913 35 . . . 31504 914 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 914 2 have have VBP 31504 914 3 somewhere somewhere RB 31504 914 4 seen see VBN 31504 914 5 the the DT 31504 914 6 statement statement NN 31504 914 7 that that IN 31504 914 8 during during IN 31504 914 9 recent recent JJ 31504 914 10 years year NNS 31504 914 11 upwards upwards JJ 31504 914 12 of of IN 31504 914 13 500 500 CD 31504 914 14 acts act NNS 31504 914 15 of of IN 31504 914 16 federal federal JJ 31504 914 17 and and CC 31504 914 18 state state NN 31504 914 19 legislation legislation NN 31504 914 20 have have VBP 31504 914 21 been be VBN 31504 914 22 held hold VBN 31504 914 23 by by IN 31504 914 24 the the DT 31504 914 25 courts court NNS 31504 914 26 to to TO 31504 914 27 be be VB 31504 914 28 in in IN 31504 914 29 violation violation NN 31504 914 30 of of IN 31504 914 31 some some DT 31504 914 32 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 914 33 provision provision NN 31504 914 34 , , , 31504 914 35 and and CC 31504 914 36 that that IN 31504 914 37 this this DT 31504 914 38 fact fact NN 31504 914 39 should should MD 31504 914 40 arouse arouse VB 31504 914 41 the the DT 31504 914 42 people people NNS 31504 914 43 to to TO 31504 914 44 put put VB 31504 914 45 some some DT 31504 914 46 check check NN 31504 914 47 on on IN 31504 914 48 such such JJ 31504 914 49 exercise exercise NN 31504 914 50 of of IN 31504 914 51 the the DT 31504 914 52 judicial judicial JJ 31504 914 53 power power NN 31504 914 54 . . . 31504 915 1 On on IN 31504 915 2 the the DT 31504 915 3 contrary contrary NN 31504 915 4 , , , 31504 915 5 it -PRON- PRP 31504 915 6 should should MD 31504 915 7 arouse arouse VB 31504 915 8 the the DT 31504 915 9 people people NNS 31504 915 10 to to TO 31504 915 11 insist insist VB 31504 915 12 on on IN 31504 915 13 the the DT 31504 915 14 retention retention NN 31504 915 15 of of IN 31504 915 16 that that DT 31504 915 17 power power NN 31504 915 18 , , , 31504 915 19 and and CC 31504 915 20 to to TO 31504 915 21 elect elect VB 31504 915 22 wiser wise JJR 31504 915 23 legislators legislator NNS 31504 915 24 who who WP 31504 915 25 will will MD 31504 915 26 more more RBR 31504 915 27 faithfully faithfully RB 31504 915 28 respect respect VB 31504 915 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 915 30 oaths oath NNS 31504 915 31 to to TO 31504 915 32 observe observe VB 31504 915 33 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 915 34 limitations limitation NNS 31504 915 35 . . . 31504 916 1 But but CC 31504 916 2 another another DT 31504 916 3 and and CC 31504 916 4 different different JJ 31504 916 5 proposition proposition NN 31504 916 6 is be VBZ 31504 916 7 urged urge VBN 31504 916 8 upon upon IN 31504 916 9 us -PRON- PRP 31504 916 10 . . . 31504 917 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 917 2 is be VBZ 31504 917 3 not not RB 31504 917 4 to to TO 31504 917 5 leave leave VB 31504 917 6 the the DT 31504 917 7 legislature legislature NN 31504 917 8 without without IN 31504 917 9 check check NN 31504 917 10 upon upon IN 31504 917 11 the the DT 31504 917 12 tendency tendency NN 31504 917 13 to to TO 31504 917 14 disregard disregard VB 31504 917 15 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 917 16 limitations limitation NNS 31504 917 17 upon upon IN 31504 917 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 917 19 power power NN 31504 917 20 , , , 31504 917 21 but but CC 31504 917 22 to to TO 31504 917 23 subject subject VB 31504 917 24 the the DT 31504 917 25 judicial judicial JJ 31504 917 26 check check NN 31504 917 27 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 917 28 to to TO 31504 917 29 reversal reversal VB 31504 917 30 by by IN 31504 917 31 a a DT 31504 917 32 majority majority NN 31504 917 33 of of IN 31504 917 34 that that DT 31504 917 35 part part NN 31504 917 36 of of IN 31504 917 37 the the DT 31504 917 38 electorate electorate NN 31504 917 39 choosing choose VBG 31504 917 40 to to TO 31504 917 41 act act VB 31504 917 42 on on IN 31504 917 43 the the DT 31504 917 44 matter matter NN 31504 917 45 . . . 31504 918 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 918 2 is be VBZ 31504 918 3 proposed propose VBN 31504 918 4 that that IN 31504 918 5 whenever whenever WRB 31504 918 6 a a DT 31504 918 7 court court NN 31504 918 8 of of IN 31504 918 9 last last JJ 31504 918 10 resort resort NN 31504 918 11 shall shall MD 31504 918 12 adjudge adjudge VB 31504 918 13 that that IN 31504 918 14 a a DT 31504 918 15 statute statute NN 31504 918 16 trespasses trespass NNS 31504 918 17 upon upon IN 31504 918 18 the the DT 31504 918 19 reserved reserved JJ 31504 918 20 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 918 21 rights right NNS 31504 918 22 of of IN 31504 918 23 the the DT 31504 918 24 individual individual NN 31504 918 25 , , , 31504 918 26 an an DT 31504 918 27 appeal appeal NN 31504 918 28 may may MD 31504 918 29 be be VB 31504 918 30 taken take VBN 31504 918 31 direct direct RB 31504 918 32 to to IN 31504 918 33 the the DT 31504 918 34 electorate electorate NN 31504 918 35 , , , 31504 918 36 and and CC 31504 918 37 that that IN 31504 918 38 if if IN 31504 918 39 a a DT 31504 918 40 majority majority NN 31504 918 41 of of IN 31504 918 42 those those DT 31504 918 43 choosing choose VBG 31504 918 44 to to TO 31504 918 45 vote vote VB 31504 918 46 on on IN 31504 918 47 the the DT 31504 918 48 question question NN 31504 918 49 desire desire NN 31504 918 50 the the DT 31504 918 51 statute statute NN 31504 918 52 to to TO 31504 918 53 stand stand VB 31504 918 54 , , , 31504 918 55 the the DT 31504 918 56 constitution constitution NN 31504 918 57 shall shall MD 31504 918 58 thereafter thereafter RB 31504 918 59 be be VB 31504 918 60 held hold VBN 31504 918 61 to to TO 31504 918 62 be be VB 31504 918 63 amended amend VBN 31504 918 64 to to IN 31504 918 65 that that DT 31504 918 66 extent extent NN 31504 918 67 . . . 31504 919 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 919 2 is be VBZ 31504 919 3 submitted submit VBN 31504 919 4 that that IN 31504 919 5 such such PDT 31504 919 6 a a DT 31504 919 7 procedure procedure NN 31504 919 8 would would MD 31504 919 9 destroy destroy VB 31504 919 10 all all DT 31504 919 11 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 919 12 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 919 13 , , , 31504 919 14 no no RB 31504 919 15 matter matter RB 31504 919 16 what what WDT 31504 919 17 safeguards safeguard NNS 31504 919 18 are be VBP 31504 919 19 attempted attempt VBN 31504 919 20 . . . 31504 920 1 Is be VBZ 31504 920 2 there there EX 31504 920 3 any any DT 31504 920 4 assurance assurance NN 31504 920 5 that that IN 31504 920 6 such such PDT 31504 920 7 a a DT 31504 920 8 majority majority NN 31504 920 9 would would MD 31504 920 10 be be VB 31504 920 11 more more RBR 31504 920 12 considerate considerate JJ 31504 920 13 of of IN 31504 920 14 the the DT 31504 920 15 individual individual NN 31504 920 16 's 's POS 31504 920 17 right right NN 31504 920 18 to to IN 31504 920 19 life life NN 31504 920 20 , , , 31504 920 21 liberty liberty NN 31504 920 22 , , , 31504 920 23 and and CC 31504 920 24 property property NN 31504 920 25 than than IN 31504 920 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 920 27 representatives representative NNS 31504 920 28 whom whom WP 31504 920 29 they -PRON- PRP 31504 920 30 have have VBP 31504 920 31 selected select VBN 31504 920 32 or or CC 31504 920 33 should should MD 31504 920 34 have have VB 31504 920 35 selected select VBN 31504 920 36 for for IN 31504 920 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 920 38 virtue virtue NN 31504 920 39 and and CC 31504 920 40 wisdom wisdom NN 31504 920 41 , , , 31504 920 42 and and CC 31504 920 43 who who WP 31504 920 44 are be VBP 31504 920 45 sworn swear VBN 31504 920 46 , , , 31504 920 47 as as RB 31504 920 48 well well RB 31504 920 49 as as IN 31504 920 50 the the DT 31504 920 51 judges judge NNS 31504 920 52 , , , 31504 920 53 to to TO 31504 920 54 respect respect VB 31504 920 55 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 920 56 guaranties guaranty NNS 31504 920 57 ? ? . 31504 921 1 Under under IN 31504 921 2 the the DT 31504 921 3 present present JJ 31504 921 4 procedure procedure NN 31504 921 5 for for IN 31504 921 6 amendment amendment NN 31504 921 7 to to IN 31504 921 8 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 921 9 , , , 31504 921 10 propositions proposition NNS 31504 921 11 for for IN 31504 921 12 amendment amendment NN 31504 921 13 are be VBP 31504 921 14 first first RB 31504 921 15 considered consider VBN 31504 921 16 and and CC 31504 921 17 debated debate VBN 31504 921 18 face face NN 31504 921 19 to to IN 31504 921 20 face face NN 31504 921 21 in in IN 31504 921 22 a a DT 31504 921 23 legislature legislature NN 31504 921 24 or or CC 31504 921 25 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 921 26 convention convention NN 31504 921 27 by by IN 31504 921 28 representatives representative NNS 31504 921 29 of of IN 31504 921 30 the the DT 31504 921 31 people people NNS 31504 921 32 , , , 31504 921 33 and and CC 31504 921 34 can can MD 31504 921 35 not not RB 31504 921 36 be be VB 31504 921 37 submitted submit VBN 31504 921 38 to to IN 31504 921 39 the the DT 31504 921 40 people people NNS 31504 921 41 until until IN 31504 921 42 after after IN 31504 921 43 opportunity opportunity NN 31504 921 44 for for IN 31504 921 45 full full JJ 31504 921 46 and and CC 31504 921 47 free free JJ 31504 921 48 discussion discussion NN 31504 921 49 by by IN 31504 921 50 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 921 51 representatives representative NNS 31504 921 52 , , , 31504 921 53 and and CC 31504 921 54 the the DT 31504 921 55 people people NNS 31504 921 56 themselves -PRON- PRP 31504 921 57 have have VBP 31504 921 58 thereby thereby RB 31504 921 59 been be VBN 31504 921 60 more more RBR 31504 921 61 or or CC 31504 921 62 less less RBR 31504 921 63 prepared prepared JJ 31504 921 64 for for IN 31504 921 65 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 921 66 consideration consideration NN 31504 921 67 . . . 31504 922 1 Even even RB 31504 922 2 under under IN 31504 922 3 this this DT 31504 922 4 procedure procedure NN 31504 922 5 , , , 31504 922 6 amendments amendment NNS 31504 922 7 have have VBP 31504 922 8 been be VBN 31504 922 9 adopted adopt VBN 31504 922 10 that that IN 31504 922 11 the the DT 31504 922 12 people people NNS 31504 922 13 have have VBP 31504 922 14 afterward afterward RB 31504 922 15 regretted regret VBN 31504 922 16 . . . 31504 923 1 There there EX 31504 923 2 is be VBZ 31504 923 3 now now RB 31504 923 4 much much JJ 31504 923 5 agitation agitation NN 31504 923 6 for for IN 31504 923 7 the the DT 31504 923 8 " " `` 31504 923 9 short short JJ 31504 923 10 ballot ballot NN 31504 923 11 , , , 31504 923 12 " " '' 31504 923 13 for for IN 31504 923 14 restoring restore VBG 31504 923 15 to to IN 31504 923 16 the the DT 31504 923 17 chief chief JJ 31504 923 18 executive executive NN 31504 923 19 the the DT 31504 923 20 power power NN 31504 923 21 of of IN 31504 923 22 appointment appointment NN 31504 923 23 of of IN 31504 923 24 important important JJ 31504 923 25 officials official NNS 31504 923 26 , , , 31504 923 27 a a DT 31504 923 28 power power NN 31504 923 29 at at IN 31504 923 30 first first RB 31504 923 31 possessed possess VBN 31504 923 32 by by IN 31504 923 33 him -PRON- PRP 31504 923 34 , , , 31504 923 35 but but CC 31504 923 36 taken take VBN 31504 923 37 away away RB 31504 923 38 by by IN 31504 923 39 later later JJ 31504 923 40 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 923 41 amendments amendment NNS 31504 923 42 . . . 31504 924 1 The the DT 31504 924 2 adoption adoption NN 31504 924 3 of of IN 31504 924 4 the the DT 31504 924 5 " " `` 31504 924 6 initiative initiative NN 31504 924 7 and and CC 31504 924 8 referendum referendum NN 31504 924 9 " " '' 31504 924 10 has have VBZ 31504 924 11 not not RB 31504 924 12 produced produce VBN 31504 924 13 the the DT 31504 924 14 beneficial beneficial JJ 31504 924 15 results result NNS 31504 924 16 expected expect VBN 31504 924 17 . . . 31504 925 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 925 2 is be VBZ 31504 925 3 found find VBN 31504 925 4 that that IN 31504 925 5 the the DT 31504 925 6 initiative initiative NN 31504 925 7 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 925 8 produces produce VBZ 31504 925 9 defective defective JJ 31504 925 10 , , , 31504 925 11 unworkable unworkable JJ 31504 925 12 statutes statute NNS 31504 925 13 , , , 31504 925 14 and and CC 31504 925 15 that that IN 31504 925 16 the the DT 31504 925 17 referendum referendum NN 31504 925 18 can can MD 31504 925 19 be be VB 31504 925 20 used use VBN 31504 925 21 to to TO 31504 925 22 delay delay VB 31504 925 23 and and CC 31504 925 24 even even RB 31504 925 25 veto veto VB 31504 925 26 expedient expedient NN 31504 925 27 legislation legislation NN 31504 925 28 . . . 31504 926 1 Under under IN 31504 926 2 the the DT 31504 926 3 proposed propose VBN 31504 926 4 procedure procedure NN 31504 926 5 the the DT 31504 926 6 questions question NNS 31504 926 7 whether whether IN 31504 926 8 the the DT 31504 926 9 constitution constitution NN 31504 926 10 should should MD 31504 926 11 be be VB 31504 926 12 amended amend VBN 31504 926 13 and and CC 31504 926 14 as as IN 31504 926 15 to to IN 31504 926 16 the the DT 31504 926 17 nature nature NN 31504 926 18 of of IN 31504 926 19 the the DT 31504 926 20 amendment amendment NN 31504 926 21 are be VBP 31504 926 22 sprung spring VBN 31504 926 23 upon upon IN 31504 926 24 the the DT 31504 926 25 people people NNS 31504 926 26 without without IN 31504 926 27 this this DT 31504 926 28 preliminary preliminary JJ 31504 926 29 examination examination NN 31504 926 30 , , , 31504 926 31 debate debate NN 31504 926 32 and and CC 31504 926 33 approval approval NN 31504 926 34 by by IN 31504 926 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 926 36 chosen choose VBN 31504 926 37 representatives representative NNS 31504 926 38 , , , 31504 926 39 and and CC 31504 926 40 this this DT 31504 926 41 often often RB 31504 926 42 , , , 31504 926 43 if if IN 31504 926 44 not not RB 31504 926 45 always always RB 31504 926 46 , , , 31504 926 47 in in IN 31504 926 48 times time NNS 31504 926 49 of of IN 31504 926 50 popular popular JJ 31504 926 51 excitement excitement NN 31504 926 52 . . . 31504 927 1 With with IN 31504 927 2 such such PDT 31504 927 3 a a DT 31504 927 4 procedure procedure NN 31504 927 5 I -PRON- PRP 31504 927 6 can can MD 31504 927 7 see see VB 31504 927 8 no no DT 31504 927 9 more more JJR 31504 927 10 stability stability NN 31504 927 11 of of IN 31504 927 12 right right NN 31504 927 13 , , , 31504 927 14 no no DT 31504 927 15 more more JJR 31504 927 16 security security NN 31504 927 17 for for IN 31504 927 18 justice justice NN 31504 927 19 , , , 31504 927 20 than than IN 31504 927 21 under under IN 31504 927 22 any any DT 31504 927 23 unlimited unlimited JJ 31504 927 24 , , , 31504 927 25 absolute absolute JJ 31504 927 26 government government NN 31504 927 27 . . . 31504 928 1 How how WRB 31504 928 2 unstable unstable JJ 31504 928 3 popular popular JJ 31504 928 4 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 928 5 may may MD 31504 928 6 be be VB 31504 928 7 at at IN 31504 928 8 times time NNS 31504 928 9 may may MD 31504 928 10 be be VB 31504 928 11 seen see VBN 31504 928 12 in in IN 31504 928 13 the the DT 31504 928 14 classic classic JJ 31504 928 15 example example NN 31504 928 16 of of IN 31504 928 17 the the DT 31504 928 18 citizens citizen NNS 31504 928 19 of of IN 31504 928 20 Rome Rome NNP 31504 928 21 applauding applaud VBG 31504 928 22 Marius Marius NNP 31504 928 23 and and CC 31504 928 24 Sulla Sulla NNP 31504 928 25 in in IN 31504 928 26 turn turn NN 31504 928 27 with with IN 31504 928 28 equal equal JJ 31504 928 29 fervor fervor NN 31504 928 30 , , , 31504 928 31 and and CC 31504 928 32 in in IN 31504 928 33 the the DT 31504 928 34 lesser less JJR 31504 928 35 and and CC 31504 928 36 very very RB 31504 928 37 recent recent JJ 31504 928 38 example example NN 31504 928 39 of of IN 31504 928 40 the the DT 31504 928 41 voters voter NNS 31504 928 42 of of IN 31504 928 43 the the DT 31504 928 44 city city NN 31504 928 45 of of IN 31504 928 46 Seattle Seattle NNP 31504 928 47 , , , 31504 928 48 who who WP 31504 928 49 elected elect VBD 31504 928 50 a a DT 31504 928 51 mayor mayor NN 31504 928 52 , , , 31504 928 53 then then RB 31504 928 54 soon soon RB 31504 928 55 recalled recall VBD 31504 928 56 him -PRON- PRP 31504 928 57 , , , 31504 928 58 and and CC 31504 928 59 but but CC 31504 928 60 little little JJ 31504 928 61 later later RB 31504 928 62 re re VB 31504 928 63 - - JJ 31504 928 64 elected elect VBD 31504 928 65 him -PRON- PRP 31504 928 66 by by IN 31504 928 67 a a DT 31504 928 68 larger large JJR 31504 928 69 majority majority NN 31504 928 70 than than IN 31504 928 71 before before RB 31504 928 72 . . . 31504 929 1 Constitutions constitution NNS 31504 929 2 to to TO 31504 929 3 be be VB 31504 929 4 of of IN 31504 929 5 any any DT 31504 929 6 value value NN 31504 929 7 as as IN 31504 929 8 bulwarks bulwark NNS 31504 929 9 of of IN 31504 929 10 liberty liberty NN 31504 929 11 should should MD 31504 929 12 not not RB 31504 929 13 be be VB 31504 929 14 immediately immediately RB 31504 929 15 changeable changeable JJ 31504 929 16 with with IN 31504 929 17 the the DT 31504 929 18 popular popular JJ 31504 929 19 sentiment sentiment NN 31504 929 20 of of IN 31504 929 21 the the DT 31504 929 22 day day NN 31504 929 23 , , , 31504 929 24 but but CC 31504 929 25 slowly slowly RB 31504 929 26 and and CC 31504 929 27 only only RB 31504 929 28 after after IN 31504 929 29 long long JJ 31504 929 30 reflection reflection NN 31504 929 31 and and CC 31504 929 32 discussion discussion NN 31504 929 33 . . . 31504 930 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 930 2 should should MD 31504 930 3 contain contain VB 31504 930 4 only only RB 31504 930 5 the the DT 31504 930 6 results result NNS 31504 930 7 of of IN 31504 930 8 long long JJ 31504 930 9 thought thought NN 31504 930 10 and and CC 31504 930 11 long long JJ 31504 930 12 experience experience NN 31504 930 13 . . . 31504 931 1 Legislation legislation NN 31504 931 2 is be VBZ 31504 931 3 ever ever RB 31504 931 4 active active JJ 31504 931 5 , , , 31504 931 6 ever ever RB 31504 931 7 moving move VBG 31504 931 8 this this DT 31504 931 9 way way NN 31504 931 10 and and CC 31504 931 11 that that DT 31504 931 12 way way NN 31504 931 13 , , , 31504 931 14 ever ever RB 31504 931 15 experimenting experiment VBG 31504 931 16 , , , 31504 931 17 enacting enact VBG 31504 931 18 new new JJ 31504 931 19 statutes statute NNS 31504 931 20 and and CC 31504 931 21 amending amend VBG 31504 931 22 and and CC 31504 931 23 repealing repeal VBG 31504 931 24 old old JJ 31504 931 25 ones one NNS 31504 931 26 , , , 31504 931 27 now now RB 31504 931 28 imposing impose VBG 31504 931 29 fetters fetter NNS 31504 931 30 on on IN 31504 931 31 individual individual JJ 31504 931 32 liberty liberty NN 31504 931 33 , , , 31504 931 34 now now RB 31504 931 35 striking strike VBG 31504 931 36 them -PRON- PRP 31504 931 37 off off RP 31504 931 38 and and CC 31504 931 39 perhaps perhaps RB 31504 931 40 imposing impose VBG 31504 931 41 others other NNS 31504 931 42 . . . 31504 932 1 Even even RB 31504 932 2 in in IN 31504 932 3 England England NNP 31504 932 4 and and CC 31504 932 5 America America NNP 31504 932 6 , , , 31504 932 7 where where WRB 31504 932 8 personal personal JJ 31504 932 9 liberty liberty NN 31504 932 10 of of IN 31504 932 11 action action NN 31504 932 12 is be VBZ 31504 932 13 most most RBS 31504 932 14 prized prize VBN 31504 932 15 , , , 31504 932 16 time time NN 31504 932 17 was be VBD 31504 932 18 when when WRB 31504 932 19 statutes statute NNS 31504 932 20 were be VBD 31504 932 21 enacted enact VBN 31504 932 22 almost almost RB 31504 932 23 putting put VBG 31504 932 24 people people NNS 31504 932 25 and and CC 31504 932 26 business business NN 31504 932 27 in in IN 31504 932 28 strait strait NNP 31504 932 29 - - HYPH 31504 932 30 jackets jacket NNS 31504 932 31 . . . 31504 933 1 In in IN 31504 933 2 English English NNP 31504 933 3 Norfolk Norfolk NNP 31504 933 4 as as RB 31504 933 5 late late RB 31504 933 6 as as IN 31504 933 7 Henry Henry NNP 31504 933 8 VIII VIII NNP 31504 933 9 's 's POS 31504 933 10 time time NN 31504 933 11 no no DT 31504 933 12 one one NN 31504 933 13 was be VBD 31504 933 14 to to TO 31504 933 15 " " `` 31504 933 16 dye dye NN 31504 933 17 , , , 31504 933 18 shear shear NN 31504 933 19 or or CC 31504 933 20 calender calender NN 31504 933 21 " " '' 31504 933 22 cloth cloth NN 31504 933 23 except except IN 31504 933 24 in in IN 31504 933 25 the the DT 31504 933 26 town town NN 31504 933 27 of of IN 31504 933 28 Norwich Norwich NNP 31504 933 29 ; ; : 31504 933 30 and and CC 31504 933 31 no no DT 31504 933 32 one one NN 31504 933 33 in in IN 31504 933 34 the the DT 31504 933 35 northern northern JJ 31504 933 36 counties county NNS 31504 933 37 was be VBD 31504 933 38 to to TO 31504 933 39 make make VB 31504 933 40 " " `` 31504 933 41 worsted worst VBN 31504 933 42 coverlets coverlet NNS 31504 933 43 " " '' 31504 933 44 except except IN 31504 933 45 in in IN 31504 933 46 the the DT 31504 933 47 city city NN 31504 933 48 of of IN 31504 933 49 York York NNP 31504 933 50 . . . 31504 934 1 In in IN 31504 934 2 the the DT 31504 934 3 reign reign NN 31504 934 4 of of IN 31504 934 5 Elizabeth Elizabeth NNP 31504 934 6 a a DT 31504 934 7 statute statute NN 31504 934 8 was be VBD 31504 934 9 passed pass VBN 31504 934 10 forbidding forbid VBG 31504 934 11 the the DT 31504 934 12 eating eating NN 31504 934 13 of of IN 31504 934 14 meat meat NN 31504 934 15 on on IN 31504 934 16 Wednesday Wednesday NNP 31504 934 17 and and CC 31504 934 18 Saturdays Saturdays NNP 31504 934 19 and and CC 31504 934 20 this this DT 31504 934 21 not not RB 31504 934 22 on on IN 31504 934 23 the the DT 31504 934 24 score score NN 31504 934 25 of of IN 31504 934 26 health health NN 31504 934 27 or or CC 31504 934 28 religion religion NN 31504 934 29 but but CC 31504 934 30 avowedly avowedly RB 31504 934 31 to to TO 31504 934 32 increase increase VB 31504 934 33 the the DT 31504 934 34 price price NN 31504 934 35 of of IN 31504 934 36 fish fish NN 31504 934 37 . . . 31504 935 1 Statutes statute NNS 31504 935 2 fixing fix VBG 31504 935 3 the the DT 31504 935 4 weight weight NN 31504 935 5 and and CC 31504 935 6 price price NN 31504 935 7 of of IN 31504 935 8 loaves loaf NNS 31504 935 9 of of IN 31504 935 10 bread bread NN 31504 935 11 and and CC 31504 935 12 the the DT 31504 935 13 size size NN 31504 935 14 and and CC 31504 935 15 price price NN 31504 935 16 of of IN 31504 935 17 a a DT 31504 935 18 glass glass NN 31504 935 19 of of IN 31504 935 20 ale ale NN 31504 935 21 were be VBD 31504 935 22 not not RB 31504 935 23 formally formally RB 31504 935 24 repealed repeal VBN 31504 935 25 till till IN 31504 935 26 1824 1824 CD 31504 935 27 . . . 31504 936 1 The the DT 31504 936 2 famous famous JJ 31504 936 3 Statute Statute NNP 31504 936 4 of of IN 31504 936 5 Laborers Laborers NNPS 31504 936 6 forbade forbid VBD 31504 936 7 laboring labor VBG 31504 936 8 men man NNS 31504 936 9 to to TO 31504 936 10 ask ask VB 31504 936 11 or or CC 31504 936 12 receive receive VB 31504 936 13 more more JJR 31504 936 14 than than IN 31504 936 15 a a DT 31504 936 16 prescribed prescribed JJ 31504 936 17 low low JJ 31504 936 18 sum sum NN 31504 936 19 for for IN 31504 936 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 936 21 labor labor NN 31504 936 22 and and CC 31504 936 23 also also RB 31504 936 24 forbade forbid VBD 31504 936 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 936 26 moving move VBG 31504 936 27 about about IN 31504 936 28 seeking seek VBG 31504 936 29 employment employment NN 31504 936 30 . . . 31504 937 1 The the DT 31504 937 2 statutes statute NNS 31504 937 3 against against IN 31504 937 4 forestalling forestalling NN 31504 937 5 , , , 31504 937 6 regrating regrate VBG 31504 937 7 , , , 31504 937 8 and and CC 31504 937 9 engrossing engrossing NN 31504 937 10 were be VBD 31504 937 11 not not RB 31504 937 12 formally formally RB 31504 937 13 repealed repeal VBN 31504 937 14 until until IN 31504 937 15 1844 1844 CD 31504 937 16 . . . 31504 938 1 In in IN 31504 938 2 early early JJ 31504 938 3 times time NNS 31504 938 4 in in IN 31504 938 5 New New NNP 31504 938 6 England England NNP 31504 938 7 also also RB 31504 938 8 , , , 31504 938 9 statutory statutory JJ 31504 938 10 attempts attempt NNS 31504 938 11 were be VBD 31504 938 12 made make VBN 31504 938 13 to to TO 31504 938 14 fix fix VB 31504 938 15 the the DT 31504 938 16 price price NN 31504 938 17 of of IN 31504 938 18 various various JJ 31504 938 19 commodities commodity NNS 31504 938 20 and and CC 31504 938 21 the the DT 31504 938 22 wages wage NNS 31504 938 23 of of IN 31504 938 24 various various JJ 31504 938 25 kinds kind NNS 31504 938 26 of of IN 31504 938 27 workmen workman NNS 31504 938 28 . . . 31504 939 1 Men man NNS 31504 939 2 were be VBD 31504 939 3 fined fine VBN 31504 939 4 for for IN 31504 939 5 accepting accept VBG 31504 939 6 higher high JJR 31504 939 7 than than IN 31504 939 8 the the DT 31504 939 9 prescribed prescribed JJ 31504 939 10 wages wage NNS 31504 939 11 . . . 31504 940 1 The the DT 31504 940 2 Sunday Sunday NNP 31504 940 3 laws law NNS 31504 940 4 in in IN 31504 940 5 some some DT 31504 940 6 places place NNS 31504 940 7 forbade forbid VBD 31504 940 8 walking walk VBG 31504 940 9 about about IN 31504 940 10 on on IN 31504 940 11 Sunday Sunday NNP 31504 940 12 except except IN 31504 940 13 " " `` 31504 940 14 reverently reverently RB 31504 940 15 to to TO 31504 940 16 go go VB 31504 940 17 to to IN 31504 940 18 and and CC 31504 940 19 return return VB 31504 940 20 from from IN 31504 940 21 meeting meeting NN 31504 940 22 . . . 31504 940 23 " " '' 31504 941 1 Everywhere everywhere RB 31504 941 2 was be VBD 31504 941 3 the the DT 31504 941 4 ever ever RB 31504 941 5 present present JJ 31504 941 6 tendency tendency NN 31504 941 7 of of IN 31504 941 8 the the DT 31504 941 9 legislative legislative JJ 31504 941 10 power power NN 31504 941 11 to to TO 31504 941 12 invade invade VB 31504 941 13 and and CC 31504 941 14 direct direct VB 31504 941 15 every every DT 31504 941 16 function function NN 31504 941 17 of of IN 31504 941 18 society,--social society,--social NNP 31504 941 19 , , , 31504 941 20 religious religious JJ 31504 941 21 , , , 31504 941 22 political political JJ 31504 941 23 , , , 31504 941 24 and and CC 31504 941 25 economical economical JJ 31504 941 26 . . . 31504 942 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 942 2 should should MD 31504 942 3 be be VB 31504 942 4 noted note VBN 31504 942 5 that that IN 31504 942 6 all all PDT 31504 942 7 these these DT 31504 942 8 and and CC 31504 942 9 similar similar JJ 31504 942 10 statutes statute NNS 31504 942 11 were be VBD 31504 942 12 under under IN 31504 942 13 governments government NNS 31504 942 14 unrestrained unrestraine VBN 31504 942 15 by by IN 31504 942 16 written write VBN 31504 942 17 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 942 18 and and CC 31504 942 19 bills bill NNS 31504 942 20 of of IN 31504 942 21 right right RB 31504 942 22 enforced enforce VBN 31504 942 23 by by IN 31504 942 24 an an DT 31504 942 25 independent independent JJ 31504 942 26 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 942 27 . . . 31504 943 1 Though though IN 31504 943 2 from from IN 31504 943 3 time time NN 31504 943 4 to to IN 31504 943 5 time time NN 31504 943 6 many many JJ 31504 943 7 restrictive restrictive JJ 31504 943 8 statutes statute NNS 31504 943 9 have have VBP 31504 943 10 been be VBN 31504 943 11 modified modify VBN 31504 943 12 and and CC 31504 943 13 many many JJ 31504 943 14 repealed repealed JJ 31504 943 15 , , , 31504 943 16 other other JJ 31504 943 17 restrictive restrictive JJ 31504 943 18 statutes statute NNS 31504 943 19 have have VBP 31504 943 20 been be VBN 31504 943 21 enacted enact VBN 31504 943 22 . . . 31504 944 1 Today today NN 31504 944 2 the the DT 31504 944 3 same same JJ 31504 944 4 process process NN 31504 944 5 is be VBZ 31504 944 6 going go VBG 31504 944 7 on on RP 31504 944 8 . . . 31504 945 1 While while IN 31504 945 2 now now RB 31504 945 3 and and CC 31504 945 4 then then RB 31504 945 5 restrictions restriction NNS 31504 945 6 and and CC 31504 945 7 embargoes embargo NNS 31504 945 8 of of IN 31504 945 9 longer long JJR 31504 945 10 or or CC 31504 945 11 shorter short JJR 31504 945 12 standing standing NN 31504 945 13 are be VBP 31504 945 14 removed remove VBN 31504 945 15 , , , 31504 945 16 there there EX 31504 945 17 is be VBZ 31504 945 18 still still RB 31504 945 19 the the DT 31504 945 20 same same JJ 31504 945 21 tendency tendency NN 31504 945 22 to to TO 31504 945 23 enact enact VB 31504 945 24 other other JJ 31504 945 25 restrictions restriction NNS 31504 945 26 and and CC 31504 945 27 prohibitions prohibition NNS 31504 945 28 . . . 31504 946 1 At at IN 31504 946 2 every every DT 31504 946 3 session session NN 31504 946 4 of of IN 31504 946 5 Congress Congress NNP 31504 946 6 and and CC 31504 946 7 of of IN 31504 946 8 the the DT 31504 946 9 state state NN 31504 946 10 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 946 11 measures measure NNS 31504 946 12 are be VBP 31504 946 13 constantly constantly RB 31504 946 14 proposed propose VBN 31504 946 15 hampering hampering NN 31504 946 16 in in IN 31504 946 17 some some DT 31504 946 18 way way NN 31504 946 19 the the DT 31504 946 20 freedom freedom NN 31504 946 21 of of IN 31504 946 22 the the DT 31504 946 23 citizen citizen NN 31504 946 24 in in IN 31504 946 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 946 26 occupation occupation NN 31504 946 27 , , , 31504 946 28 in in IN 31504 946 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 946 30 pursuit pursuit NN 31504 946 31 of of IN 31504 946 32 happiness happiness NN 31504 946 33 . . . 31504 947 1 Demands demand NNS 31504 947 2 are be VBP 31504 947 3 being be VBG 31504 947 4 made make VBN 31504 947 5 upon upon IN 31504 947 6 the the DT 31504 947 7 legislative legislative JJ 31504 947 8 department department NN 31504 947 9 by by IN 31504 947 10 one one CD 31504 947 11 class class NN 31504 947 12 or or CC 31504 947 13 interest interest NN 31504 947 14 for for IN 31504 947 15 legislation legislation NN 31504 947 16 to to TO 31504 947 17 restrain restrain VB 31504 947 18 other other JJ 31504 947 19 classes class NNS 31504 947 20 or or CC 31504 947 21 interests interest NNS 31504 947 22 , , , 31504 947 23 but but CC 31504 947 24 for for IN 31504 947 25 exemption exemption NN 31504 947 26 for for IN 31504 947 27 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 947 28 . . . 31504 948 1 In in IN 31504 948 2 earlier early JJR 31504 948 3 times time NNS 31504 948 4 there there EX 31504 948 5 were be VBD 31504 948 6 statutes statute NNS 31504 948 7 fixing fix VBG 31504 948 8 a a DT 31504 948 9 maximum maximum JJ 31504 948 10 wage wage NN 31504 948 11 for for IN 31504 948 12 labor labor NN 31504 948 13 , , , 31504 948 14 and and CC 31504 948 15 though though IN 31504 948 16 these these DT 31504 948 17 proved prove VBD 31504 948 18 ineffectual ineffectual JJ 31504 948 19 it -PRON- PRP 31504 948 20 is be VBZ 31504 948 21 now now RB 31504 948 22 proposed propose VBN 31504 948 23 to to TO 31504 948 24 fix fix VB 31504 948 25 a a DT 31504 948 26 minimum minimum JJ 31504 948 27 wage wage NN 31504 948 28 , , , 31504 948 29 even even RB 31504 948 30 though though IN 31504 948 31 it -PRON- PRP 31504 948 32 should should MD 31504 948 33 prove prove VB 31504 948 34 to to TO 31504 948 35 be be VB 31504 948 36 much much RB 31504 948 37 more more JJR 31504 948 38 than than IN 31504 948 39 the the DT 31504 948 40 labor labor NN 31504 948 41 is be VBZ 31504 948 42 worth worth JJ 31504 948 43 . . . 31504 949 1 There there EX 31504 949 2 are be VBP 31504 949 3 also also RB 31504 949 4 proposed propose VBN 31504 949 5 , , , 31504 949 6 and and CC 31504 949 7 in in IN 31504 949 8 many many JJ 31504 949 9 instances instance NNS 31504 949 10 enacted enact VBN 31504 949 11 , , , 31504 949 12 statutes statute NNS 31504 949 13 restricting restrict VBG 31504 949 14 the the DT 31504 949 15 freedom freedom NN 31504 949 16 of of IN 31504 949 17 the the DT 31504 949 18 workman workman NN 31504 949 19 as as IN 31504 949 20 to to IN 31504 949 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 949 22 output output NN 31504 949 23 , , , 31504 949 24 of of IN 31504 949 25 the the DT 31504 949 26 employer employer NN 31504 949 27 as as IN 31504 949 28 to to IN 31504 949 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 949 30 direction direction NN 31504 949 31 of of IN 31504 949 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 949 33 business business NN 31504 949 34 . . . 31504 950 1 The the DT 31504 950 2 natural natural JJ 31504 950 3 activities activity NNS 31504 950 4 of of IN 31504 950 5 men man NNS 31504 950 6 are be VBP 31504 950 7 sought seek VBN 31504 950 8 to to TO 31504 950 9 be be VB 31504 950 10 hampered hamper VBN 31504 950 11 and and CC 31504 950 12 handicapped handicap VBN 31504 950 13 in in IN 31504 950 14 vexatious vexatious JJ 31504 950 15 ways way NNS 31504 950 16 . . . 31504 951 1 In in IN 31504 951 2 illustration illustration NN 31504 951 3 , , , 31504 951 4 I -PRON- PRP 31504 951 5 quote quote VBP 31504 951 6 the the DT 31504 951 7 following following NN 31504 951 8 from from IN 31504 951 9 the the DT 31504 951 10 " " `` 31504 951 11 Boston Boston NNP 31504 951 12 Herald Herald NNP 31504 951 13 " " '' 31504 951 14 of of IN 31504 951 15 June June NNP 31504 951 16 5 5 CD 31504 951 17 , , , 31504 951 18 1914 1914 CD 31504 951 19 : : : 31504 951 20 " " `` 31504 951 21 Twenty twenty CD 31504 951 22 - - HYPH 31504 951 23 five five CD 31504 951 24 states state NNS 31504 951 25 and and CC 31504 951 26 the the DT 31504 951 27 United United NNP 31504 951 28 States States NNP 31504 951 29 itself -PRON- PRP 31504 951 30 forbid forbid VB 31504 951 31 any any DT 31504 951 32 discrimination discrimination NN 31504 951 33 by by IN 31504 951 34 an an DT 31504 951 35 employer employer NN 31504 951 36 against against IN 31504 951 37 union union NN 31504 951 38 men man NNS 31504 951 39 . . . 31504 952 1 Utah Utah NNP 31504 952 2 alone alone RB 31504 952 3 has have VBZ 31504 952 4 a a DT 31504 952 5 law law NN 31504 952 6 to to TO 31504 952 7 protect protect VB 31504 952 8 the the DT 31504 952 9 non non JJ 31504 952 10 - - JJ 31504 952 11 union union JJ 31504 952 12 men man NNS 31504 952 13 from from IN 31504 952 14 organized organized JJ 31504 952 15 discrimination discrimination NN 31504 952 16 of of IN 31504 952 17 union union NN 31504 952 18 labor labor NN 31504 952 19 to to TO 31504 952 20 drive drive VB 31504 952 21 him -PRON- PRP 31504 952 22 from from IN 31504 952 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 952 24 trade trade NN 31504 952 25 . . . 31504 953 1 Several several JJ 31504 953 2 of of IN 31504 953 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 953 4 states state NNS 31504 953 5 require require VBP 31504 953 6 that that IN 31504 953 7 all all DT 31504 953 8 public public JJ 31504 953 9 printing printing NN 31504 953 10 shall shall MD 31504 953 11 bear bear VB 31504 953 12 the the DT 31504 953 13 union union NN 31504 953 14 label label NN 31504 953 15 . . . 31504 954 1 One one CD 31504 954 2 extends extend VBZ 31504 954 3 that that WDT 31504 954 4 rule rule VBP 31504 954 5 to to IN 31504 954 6 all all DT 31504 954 7 stationery stationery NN 31504 954 8 . . . 31504 955 1 Twelve twelve CD 31504 955 2 states state NNS 31504 955 3 require require VBP 31504 955 4 employers employer NNS 31504 955 5 advertising advertise VBG 31504 955 6 for for IN 31504 955 7 help help NN 31504 955 8 to to TO 31504 955 9 mention mention VB 31504 955 10 in in IN 31504 955 11 the the DT 31504 955 12 advertisement advertisement NN 31504 955 13 the the DT 31504 955 14 existence existence NN 31504 955 15 of of IN 31504 955 16 a a DT 31504 955 17 strike strike NN 31504 955 18 . . . 31504 956 1 The the DT 31504 956 2 Minnesota Minnesota NNP 31504 956 3 statute statute NN 31504 956 4 provides provide VBZ 31504 956 5 that that IN 31504 956 6 , , , 31504 956 7 per per IN 31504 956 8 contra contra NNP 31504 956 9 , , , 31504 956 10 no no DT 31504 956 11 employer employer NN 31504 956 12 shall shall MD 31504 956 13 require require VB 31504 956 14 any any DT 31504 956 15 statement statement NN 31504 956 16 from from IN 31504 956 17 a a DT 31504 956 18 person person NN 31504 956 19 seeking seek VBG 31504 956 20 employment employment NN 31504 956 21 as as IN 31504 956 22 to to IN 31504 956 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 956 24 participation participation NN 31504 956 25 in in IN 31504 956 26 a a DT 31504 956 27 strike strike NN 31504 956 28 . . . 31504 957 1 Eight eight CD 31504 957 2 states state NNS 31504 957 3 have have VBP 31504 957 4 enacted enact VBN 31504 957 5 statutes statute NNS 31504 957 6 exempting exempt VBG 31504 957 7 labor labor NN 31504 957 8 organizations organization NNS 31504 957 9 from from IN 31504 957 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 957 11 respective respective JJ 31504 957 12 anti anti JJ 31504 957 13 - - JJ 31504 957 14 trust trust JJ 31504 957 15 laws law NNS 31504 957 16 . . . 31504 958 1 The the DT 31504 958 2 unscrupulous unscrupulous JJ 31504 958 3 employer employer NN 31504 958 4 may may MD 31504 958 5 yet yet RB 31504 958 6 find find VB 31504 958 7 the the DT 31504 958 8 labor labor NN 31504 958 9 union union NN 31504 958 10 the the DT 31504 958 11 best good JJS 31504 958 12 means mean NNS 31504 958 13 of of IN 31504 958 14 throttling throttle VBG 31504 958 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 958 16 competitors competitor NNS 31504 958 17 and and CC 31504 958 18 securing secure VBG 31504 958 19 a a DT 31504 958 20 monopoly monopoly NN 31504 958 21 . . . 31504 958 22 " " '' 31504 959 1 There there EX 31504 959 2 seems seem VBZ 31504 959 3 at at IN 31504 959 4 times time NNS 31504 959 5 to to TO 31504 959 6 be be VB 31504 959 7 a a DT 31504 959 8 frenzy frenzy NN 31504 959 9 for for IN 31504 959 10 such such JJ 31504 959 11 legislation legislation NN 31504 959 12 . . . 31504 960 1 Only only RB 31504 960 2 a a DT 31504 960 3 vivid vivid JJ 31504 960 4 imagination imagination NN 31504 960 5 can can MD 31504 960 6 adequately adequately RB 31504 960 7 picture picture VB 31504 960 8 what what WP 31504 960 9 might may MD 31504 960 10 result result VB 31504 960 11 if if IN 31504 960 12 Congress Congress NNP 31504 960 13 and and CC 31504 960 14 the the DT 31504 960 15 state state NN 31504 960 16 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 960 17 , , , 31504 960 18 or or CC 31504 960 19 the the DT 31504 960 20 inconstant inconstant JJ 31504 960 21 majority majority NN 31504 960 22 of of IN 31504 960 23 the the DT 31504 960 24 electorate electorate NN 31504 960 25 , , , 31504 960 26 were be VBD 31504 960 27 freed free VBN 31504 960 28 from from IN 31504 960 29 all all DT 31504 960 30 constitutional constitutional JJ 31504 960 31 limitations limitation NNS 31504 960 32 or or CC 31504 960 33 from from IN 31504 960 34 the the DT 31504 960 35 check check NN 31504 960 36 of of IN 31504 960 37 an an DT 31504 960 38 independent independent JJ 31504 960 39 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 960 40 . . . 31504 961 1 Though though IN 31504 961 2 Great Great NNP 31504 961 3 Britain Britain NNP 31504 961 4 , , , 31504 961 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 961 6 mother mother NN 31504 961 7 country country NN 31504 961 8 , , , 31504 961 9 has have VBZ 31504 961 10 no no DT 31504 961 11 written write VBN 31504 961 12 constitution constitution NN 31504 961 13 and and CC 31504 961 14 no no DT 31504 961 15 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 961 16 empowered empower VBN 31504 961 17 to to TO 31504 961 18 enforce enforce VB 31504 961 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 961 20 limitations limitation NNS 31504 961 21 , , , 31504 961 22 it -PRON- PRP 31504 961 23 is be VBZ 31504 961 24 the the DT 31504 961 25 happy happy JJ 31504 961 26 possessor possessor NN 31504 961 27 of of IN 31504 961 28 a a DT 31504 961 29 practically practically RB 31504 961 30 homogeneous homogeneous JJ 31504 961 31 people people NNS 31504 961 32 of of IN 31504 961 33 the the DT 31504 961 34 Anglo Anglo NNP 31504 961 35 - - HYPH 31504 961 36 Saxon Saxon NNP 31504 961 37 race race NN 31504 961 38 , , , 31504 961 39 little little JJ 31504 961 40 affected affect VBN 31504 961 41 by by IN 31504 961 42 immigration immigration NN 31504 961 43 , , , 31504 961 44 and and CC 31504 961 45 imbued imbue VBN 31504 961 46 for for IN 31504 961 47 centuries century NNS 31504 961 48 with with IN 31504 961 49 a a DT 31504 961 50 deep deep JJ 31504 961 51 regard regard NN 31504 961 52 for for IN 31504 961 53 personal personal JJ 31504 961 54 liberty liberty NN 31504 961 55 and and CC 31504 961 56 private private JJ 31504 961 57 rights right NNS 31504 961 58 . . . 31504 962 1 Yet yet RB 31504 962 2 , , , 31504 962 3 even even RB 31504 962 4 there there RB 31504 962 5 today today NN 31504 962 6 , , , 31504 962 7 statutes statute NNS 31504 962 8 are be VBP 31504 962 9 demanded demand VBN 31504 962 10 and and CC 31504 962 11 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 962 12 enacted enact VBN 31504 962 13 in in IN 31504 962 14 derogation derogation NN 31504 962 15 of of IN 31504 962 16 them -PRON- PRP 31504 962 17 . . . 31504 963 1 In in IN 31504 963 2 this this DT 31504 963 3 country country NN 31504 963 4 the the DT 31504 963 5 population population NN 31504 963 6 as as IN 31504 963 7 the the DT 31504 963 8 result result NN 31504 963 9 of of IN 31504 963 10 great great JJ 31504 963 11 immigration immigration NN 31504 963 12 is be VBZ 31504 963 13 more more RBR 31504 963 14 heterogeneous heterogeneous JJ 31504 963 15 . . . 31504 964 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 964 2 comprises comprise VBZ 31504 964 3 races race NNS 31504 964 4 and and CC 31504 964 5 peoples people NNS 31504 964 6 of of IN 31504 964 7 diverse diverse JJ 31504 964 8 temperaments temperament NNS 31504 964 9 , , , 31504 964 10 of of IN 31504 964 11 diverse diverse JJ 31504 964 12 experiences experience NNS 31504 964 13 , , , 31504 964 14 of of IN 31504 964 15 diverse diverse JJ 31504 964 16 traditions tradition NNS 31504 964 17 , , , 31504 964 18 many many JJ 31504 964 19 unschooled unschooled JJ 31504 964 20 in in IN 31504 964 21 self self NN 31504 964 22 - - HYPH 31504 964 23 government government NN 31504 964 24 and and CC 31504 964 25 lacking lack VBG 31504 964 26 in in IN 31504 964 27 that that DT 31504 964 28 traditional traditional JJ 31504 964 29 reverence reverence NN 31504 964 30 for for IN 31504 964 31 liberty liberty NN 31504 964 32 and and CC 31504 964 33 order order NN 31504 964 34 so so RB 31504 964 35 characteristic characteristic JJ 31504 964 36 of of IN 31504 964 37 the the DT 31504 964 38 Teutonic teutonic JJ 31504 964 39 races race NNS 31504 964 40 . . . 31504 965 1 We -PRON- PRP 31504 965 2 even even RB 31504 965 3 find find VBP 31504 965 4 some some DT 31504 965 5 classes class NNS 31504 965 6 openly openly RB 31504 965 7 declaring declare VBG 31504 965 8 that that IN 31504 965 9 if if IN 31504 965 10 they -PRON- PRP 31504 965 11 can can MD 31504 965 12 get get VB 31504 965 13 possession possession NN 31504 965 14 of of IN 31504 965 15 the the DT 31504 965 16 government government NN 31504 965 17 they -PRON- PRP 31504 965 18 will will MD 31504 965 19 exploit exploit VB 31504 965 20 the the DT 31504 965 21 rest rest NN 31504 965 22 of of IN 31504 965 23 the the DT 31504 965 24 people people NNS 31504 965 25 for for IN 31504 965 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 965 27 own own JJ 31504 965 28 benefit benefit NN 31504 965 29 . . . 31504 966 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 966 2 essay essay VBP 31504 966 3 also also RB 31504 966 4 to to TO 31504 966 5 bargain bargain VB 31504 966 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 966 7 votes vote NNS 31504 966 8 for for IN 31504 966 9 special special JJ 31504 966 10 legislation legislation NN 31504 966 11 in in IN 31504 966 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 966 13 favor favor NN 31504 966 14 at at IN 31504 966 15 the the DT 31504 966 16 expense expense NN 31504 966 17 of of IN 31504 966 18 the the DT 31504 966 19 people people NNS 31504 966 20 at at IN 31504 966 21 large large JJ 31504 966 22 and and CC 31504 966 23 without without IN 31504 966 24 regard regard NN 31504 966 25 to to IN 31504 966 26 the the DT 31504 966 27 principles principle NNS 31504 966 28 of of IN 31504 966 29 equality equality NN 31504 966 30 of of IN 31504 966 31 right right NN 31504 966 32 . . . 31504 967 1 With with IN 31504 967 2 such such PDT 31504 967 3 a a DT 31504 967 4 population population NN 31504 967 5 with with IN 31504 967 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 967 7 universal universal JJ 31504 967 8 suffrage suffrage NN 31504 967 9 , , , 31504 967 10 were be VBD 31504 967 11 it -PRON- PRP 31504 967 12 not not RB 31504 967 13 for for IN 31504 967 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 967 15 written write VBN 31504 967 16 constitutions constitution NNS 31504 967 17 with with IN 31504 967 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 967 19 Bills bill NNS 31504 967 20 of of IN 31504 967 21 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 967 22 and and CC 31504 967 23 with with IN 31504 967 24 an an DT 31504 967 25 independent independent JJ 31504 967 26 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 967 27 to to TO 31504 967 28 guard guard VB 31504 967 29 them -PRON- PRP 31504 967 30 , , , 31504 967 31 there there EX 31504 967 32 would would MD 31504 967 33 be be VB 31504 967 34 no no DT 31504 967 35 security security NN 31504 967 36 here here RB 31504 967 37 for for IN 31504 967 38 personal personal JJ 31504 967 39 liberty liberty NN 31504 967 40 and and CC 31504 967 41 rights right NNS 31504 967 42 . . . 31504 968 1 We -PRON- PRP 31504 968 2 should should MD 31504 968 3 be be VB 31504 968 4 in in IN 31504 968 5 the the DT 31504 968 6 condition condition NN 31504 968 7 of of IN 31504 968 8 the the DT 31504 968 9 people people NNS 31504 968 10 of of IN 31504 968 11 France France NNP 31504 968 12 as as IN 31504 968 13 depicted depict VBN 31504 968 14 by by IN 31504 968 15 Wm Wm NNP 31504 968 16 . . . 31504 969 1 S. S. NNP 31504 969 2 Lilly Lilly NNP 31504 969 3 in in IN 31504 969 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 969 5 recent recent JJ 31504 969 6 book book NN 31504 969 7 , , , 31504 969 8 " " `` 31504 969 9 The the DT 31504 969 10 New New NNP 31504 969 11 France France NNP 31504 969 12 . . . 31504 969 13 " " '' 31504 970 1 He -PRON- PRP 31504 970 2 wrote write VBD 31504 970 3 : : : 31504 970 4 " " `` 31504 970 5 It -PRON- PRP 31504 970 6 is be VBZ 31504 970 7 now now RB 31504 970 8 more more JJR 31504 970 9 than than IN 31504 970 10 a a DT 31504 970 11 century century NN 31504 970 12 since since IN 31504 970 13 the the DT 31504 970 14 principles principle NNS 31504 970 15 of of IN 31504 970 16 1789 1789 CD 31504 970 17 were be VBD 31504 970 18 formulated formulate VBN 31504 970 19 there there RB 31504 970 20 . . . 31504 971 1 But but CC 31504 971 2 in in IN 31504 971 3 no no DT 31504 971 4 country country NN 31504 971 5 , , , 31504 971 6 not not RB 31504 971 7 even even RB 31504 971 8 in in IN 31504 971 9 Russia Russia NNP 31504 971 10 , , , 31504 971 11 is be VBZ 31504 971 12 individual individual JJ 31504 971 13 freedom freedom NN 31504 971 14 less less JJR 31504 971 15 . . . 31504 972 1 The the DT 31504 972 2 state state NN 31504 972 3 is be VBZ 31504 972 4 as as RB 31504 972 5 ubiquitous ubiquitous JJ 31504 972 6 and and CC 31504 972 7 as as RB 31504 972 8 autocratic autocratic JJ 31504 972 9 as as IN 31504 972 10 under under IN 31504 972 11 the the DT 31504 972 12 worst bad JJS 31504 972 13 Bourbon Bourbon NNP 31504 972 14 or or CC 31504 972 15 Oriental oriental JJ 31504 972 16 despots despot NNS 31504 972 17 . . . 31504 973 1 Nowhere nowhere RB 31504 973 2 is be VBZ 31504 973 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 973 4 hand hand NN 31504 973 5 so so RB 31504 973 6 heavy heavy JJ 31504 973 7 upon upon IN 31504 973 8 the the DT 31504 973 9 subject subject NN 31504 973 10 in in IN 31504 973 11 every every DT 31504 973 12 department department NN 31504 973 13 of of IN 31504 973 14 human human JJ 31504 973 15 life life NN 31504 973 16 . . . 31504 974 1 Nowhere nowhere RB 31504 974 2 is be VBZ 31504 974 3 the the DT 31504 974 4 negation negation NN 31504 974 5 of of IN 31504 974 6 the the DT 31504 974 7 value value NN 31504 974 8 and and CC 31504 974 9 of of IN 31504 974 10 the the DT 31504 974 11 rights right NNS 31504 974 12 of of IN 31504 974 13 personal personal JJ 31504 974 14 independence independence NN 31504 974 15 more more RBR 31504 974 16 absolute absolute JJ 31504 974 17 , , , 31504 974 18 more more RBR 31504 974 19 complete complete JJ 31504 974 20 , , , 31504 974 21 and and CC 31504 974 22 more more RBR 31504 974 23 effective effective JJ 31504 974 24 . . . 31504 974 25 " " '' 31504 975 1 Yet yet CC 31504 975 2 France France NNP 31504 975 3 is be VBZ 31504 975 4 a a DT 31504 975 5 republic republic NN 31504 975 6 with with IN 31504 975 7 manhood manhood NN 31504 975 8 suffrage suffrage JJ 31504 975 9 and and CC 31504 975 10 with with IN 31504 975 11 an an DT 31504 975 12 elective elective JJ 31504 975 13 legislature legislature NN 31504 975 14 . . . 31504 976 1 But but CC 31504 976 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 976 3 courts court NNS 31504 976 4 are be VBP 31504 976 5 not not RB 31504 976 6 vested vest VBN 31504 976 7 with with IN 31504 976 8 any any DT 31504 976 9 power power NN 31504 976 10 to to TO 31504 976 11 conserve conserve VB 31504 976 12 any any DT 31504 976 13 rights right NNS 31504 976 14 of of IN 31504 976 15 the the DT 31504 976 16 people people NNS 31504 976 17 against against IN 31504 976 18 legislative legislative JJ 31504 976 19 caprice caprice NN 31504 976 20 . . . 31504 977 1 CONCLUSION conclusion VB 31504 977 2 The the DT 31504 977 3 thesis thesis NN 31504 977 4 I -PRON- PRP 31504 977 5 have have VBP 31504 977 6 endeavored endeavor VBN 31504 977 7 to to TO 31504 977 8 support support VB 31504 977 9 in in IN 31504 977 10 these these DT 31504 977 11 lectures lecture NNS 31504 977 12 , , , 31504 977 13 so so RB 31504 977 14 far far RB 31504 977 15 as as IN 31504 977 16 I -PRON- PRP 31504 977 17 have have VBP 31504 977 18 a a DT 31504 977 19 thesis thesis NN 31504 977 20 , , , 31504 977 21 is be VBZ 31504 977 22 this this DT 31504 977 23 : : : 31504 977 24 ( ( -LRB- 31504 977 25 1 1 LS 31504 977 26 ) ) -RRB- 31504 977 27 that that IN 31504 977 28 , , , 31504 977 29 after after RB 31504 977 30 all all RB 31504 977 31 , , , 31504 977 32 human human JJ 31504 977 33 justice justice NN 31504 977 34 consists consist VBZ 31504 977 35 in in IN 31504 977 36 securing secure VBG 31504 977 37 to to IN 31504 977 38 each each DT 31504 977 39 individual individual JJ 31504 977 40 as as RB 31504 977 41 much much JJ 31504 977 42 liberty liberty NN 31504 977 43 of of IN 31504 977 44 action action NN 31504 977 45 in in IN 31504 977 46 the the DT 31504 977 47 exercise exercise NN 31504 977 48 of of IN 31504 977 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 977 50 physical physical JJ 31504 977 51 and and CC 31504 977 52 mental mental JJ 31504 977 53 powers power NNS 31504 977 54 and and CC 31504 977 55 as as IN 31504 977 56 much much JJ 31504 977 57 liberty liberty NN 31504 977 58 to to TO 31504 977 59 enjoy enjoy VB 31504 977 60 the the DT 31504 977 61 fruits fruit NNS 31504 977 62 of of IN 31504 977 63 such such JJ 31504 977 64 action action NN 31504 977 65 as as IN 31504 977 66 is be VBZ 31504 977 67 consistent consistent JJ 31504 977 68 with with IN 31504 977 69 like like UH 31504 977 70 liberty liberty NN 31504 977 71 for for IN 31504 977 72 other other JJ 31504 977 73 individuals individual NNS 31504 977 74 , , , 31504 977 75 and and CC 31504 977 76 with with IN 31504 977 77 such such JJ 31504 977 78 restrictions restriction NNS 31504 977 79 only only RB 31504 977 80 as as IN 31504 977 81 are be VBP 31504 977 82 necessary necessary JJ 31504 977 83 for for IN 31504 977 84 the the DT 31504 977 85 welfare welfare NN 31504 977 86 of of IN 31504 977 87 society society NN 31504 977 88 as as IN 31504 977 89 a a DT 31504 977 90 whole whole NN 31504 977 91 without without IN 31504 977 92 discrimination discrimination NN 31504 977 93 for for IN 31504 977 94 or or CC 31504 977 95 against against IN 31504 977 96 any any DT 31504 977 97 individual individual NN 31504 977 98 ; ; : 31504 977 99 and and CC 31504 977 100 ( ( -LRB- 31504 977 101 2 2 LS 31504 977 102 ) ) -RRB- 31504 977 103 that that IN 31504 977 104 that that DT 31504 977 105 justice justice NN 31504 977 106 is be VBZ 31504 977 107 more more RBR 31504 977 108 firmly firmly RB 31504 977 109 secured secure VBN 31504 977 110 by by IN 31504 977 111 a a DT 31504 977 112 government government NN 31504 977 113 with with IN 31504 977 114 a a DT 31504 977 115 division division NN 31504 977 116 of of IN 31504 977 117 powers power NNS 31504 977 118 , , , 31504 977 119 with with IN 31504 977 120 a a DT 31504 977 121 written write VBN 31504 977 122 constitution constitution NN 31504 977 123 excluding exclude VBG 31504 977 124 from from IN 31504 977 125 governmental governmental JJ 31504 977 126 interference interference NN 31504 977 127 such such JJ 31504 977 128 personal personal JJ 31504 977 129 rights right NNS 31504 977 130 as as IN 31504 977 131 long long JJ 31504 977 132 experience experience NN 31504 977 133 has have VBZ 31504 977 134 shown show VBN 31504 977 135 to to TO 31504 977 136 be be VB 31504 977 137 necessary necessary JJ 31504 977 138 both both DT 31504 977 139 for for IN 31504 977 140 the the DT 31504 977 141 happiness happiness NN 31504 977 142 and and CC 31504 977 143 efficiency efficiency NN 31504 977 144 of of IN 31504 977 145 the the DT 31504 977 146 individual individual JJ 31504 977 147 subject subject NN 31504 977 148 and and CC 31504 977 149 for for IN 31504 977 150 the the DT 31504 977 151 welfare welfare NN 31504 977 152 and and CC 31504 977 153 efficiency efficiency NN 31504 977 154 of of IN 31504 977 155 all all DT 31504 977 156 ; ; : 31504 977 157 and and CC 31504 977 158 ( ( -LRB- 31504 977 159 3 3 LS 31504 977 160 ) ) -RRB- 31504 977 161 finally finally RB 31504 977 162 with with IN 31504 977 163 an an DT 31504 977 164 independent independent JJ 31504 977 165 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 977 166 to to TO 31504 977 167 defend defend VB 31504 977 168 those those DT 31504 977 169 rights right NNS 31504 977 170 when when WRB 31504 977 171 assailed assail VBN 31504 977 172 , , , 31504 977 173 as as IN 31504 977 174 they -PRON- PRP 31504 977 175 often often RB 31504 977 176 have have VBP 31504 977 177 been be VBN 31504 977 178 , , , 31504 977 179 and and CC 31504 977 180 will will MD 31504 977 181 be be VB 31504 977 182 , , , 31504 977 183 by by IN 31504 977 184 impatient impatient JJ 31504 977 185 and and CC 31504 977 186 changeable changeable JJ 31504 977 187 majorities majority NNS 31504 977 188 . . . 31504 978 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 978 2 may may MD 31504 978 3 be be VB 31504 978 4 admitted admit VBN 31504 978 5 that that IN 31504 978 6 the the DT 31504 978 7 courts court NNS 31504 978 8 sometimes sometimes RB 31504 978 9 err err VBP 31504 978 10 in in IN 31504 978 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 978 12 interpretation interpretation NN 31504 978 13 of of IN 31504 978 14 the the DT 31504 978 15 constitution constitution NN 31504 978 16 and and CC 31504 978 17 the the DT 31504 978 18 laws law NNS 31504 978 19 , , , 31504 978 20 since since IN 31504 978 21 judges judge NNS 31504 978 22 , , , 31504 978 23 however however RB 31504 978 24 carefully carefully RB 31504 978 25 selected select VBN 31504 978 26 , , , 31504 978 27 are be VBP 31504 978 28 but but CC 31504 978 29 men man NNS 31504 978 30 ; ; : 31504 978 31 but but CC 31504 978 32 there there EX 31504 978 33 must must MD 31504 978 34 be be VB 31504 978 35 somewhere somewhere RB 31504 978 36 in in IN 31504 978 37 the the DT 31504 978 38 body body NN 31504 978 39 politic politic NN 31504 978 40 of of IN 31504 978 41 a a DT 31504 978 42 free free JJ 31504 978 43 state state NN 31504 978 44 some some DT 31504 978 45 body body NN 31504 978 46 of of IN 31504 978 47 men man NNS 31504 978 48 with with IN 31504 978 49 the the DT 31504 978 50 power power NN 31504 978 51 of of IN 31504 978 52 authoritative authoritative JJ 31504 978 53 interpretation interpretation NN 31504 978 54 of of IN 31504 978 55 the the DT 31504 978 56 fundamental fundamental JJ 31504 978 57 law law NN 31504 978 58 as as RB 31504 978 59 well well RB 31504 978 60 as as IN 31504 978 61 other other JJ 31504 978 62 laws law NNS 31504 978 63 . . . 31504 979 1 Does do VBZ 31504 979 2 earlier early JJR 31504 979 3 history history NN 31504 979 4 or or CC 31504 979 5 later later RB 31504 979 6 experience experience NN 31504 979 7 point point NN 31504 979 8 to to IN 31504 979 9 any any DT 31504 979 10 better well RBR 31504 979 11 equipped equip VBN 31504 979 12 , , , 31504 979 13 more more RBR 31504 979 14 stable stable JJ 31504 979 15 , , , 31504 979 16 more more RBR 31504 979 17 safe safe JJ 31504 979 18 tribunal tribunal NN 31504 979 19 ? ? . 31504 980 1 Should Should MD 31504 980 2 not not RB 31504 980 3 the the DT 31504 980 4 people people NNS 31504 980 5 endeavor endeavor VBP 31504 980 6 to to TO 31504 980 7 raise raise VB 31504 980 8 rather rather RB 31504 980 9 than than IN 31504 980 10 lower lower VB 31504 980 11 the the DT 31504 980 12 position position NN 31504 980 13 of of IN 31504 980 14 the the DT 31504 980 15 courts court NNS 31504 980 16 ; ; : 31504 980 17 to to TO 31504 980 18 conserve conserve VB 31504 980 19 rather rather RB 31504 980 20 than than IN 31504 980 21 impair impair VB 31504 980 22 that that DT 31504 980 23 freedom freedom NN 31504 980 24 , , , 31504 980 25 impartiality impartiality NN 31504 980 26 , , , 31504 980 27 and and CC 31504 980 28 independence independence NN 31504 980 29 of of IN 31504 980 30 the the DT 31504 980 31 judges judge NNS 31504 980 32 declared declare VBN 31504 980 33 by by IN 31504 980 34 the the DT 31504 980 35 people people NNS 31504 980 36 of of IN 31504 980 37 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP 31504 980 38 in in IN 31504 980 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 980 40 Declaration Declaration NNP 31504 980 41 of of IN 31504 980 42 Rights Rights NNPS 31504 980 43 , , , 31504 980 44 after after IN 31504 980 45 years year NNS 31504 980 46 of of IN 31504 980 47 galling gall VBG 31504 980 48 experience experience NN 31504 980 49 of of IN 31504 980 50 the the DT 31504 980 51 contrary contrary NN 31504 980 52 , , , 31504 980 53 to to TO 31504 980 54 be be VB 31504 980 55 " " `` 31504 980 56 essential essential JJ 31504 980 57 to to IN 31504 980 58 the the DT 31504 980 59 preservation preservation NN 31504 980 60 of of IN 31504 980 61 every every DT 31504 980 62 individual individual NN 31504 980 63 , , , 31504 980 64 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 980 65 life life NN 31504 980 66 , , , 31504 980 67 liberty liberty NN 31504 980 68 , , , 31504 980 69 property property NN 31504 980 70 and and CC 31504 980 71 character character NN 31504 980 72 " " '' 31504 980 73 ? ? . 31504 981 1 Are be VBP 31504 981 2 not not RB 31504 981 3 they -PRON- PRP 31504 981 4 the the DT 31504 981 5 reactionaries reactionary NNS 31504 981 6 who who WP 31504 981 7 , , , 31504 981 8 despite despite IN 31504 981 9 the the DT 31504 981 10 lessons lesson NNS 31504 981 11 of of IN 31504 981 12 history history NN 31504 981 13 , , , 31504 981 14 would would MD 31504 981 15 revert revert VB 31504 981 16 to to IN 31504 981 17 the the DT 31504 981 18 days day NNS 31504 981 19 of of IN 31504 981 20 a a DT 31504 981 21 dependent dependent JJ 31504 981 22 , , , 31504 981 23 recallable recallable JJ 31504 981 24 , , , 31504 981 25 and and CC 31504 981 26 hence hence RB 31504 981 27 timid timid JJ 31504 981 28 judiciary judiciary NN 31504 981 29 ? ? . 31504 982 1 But but CC 31504 982 2 justice justice NN 31504 982 3 is be VBZ 31504 982 4 not not RB 31504 982 5 fully fully RB 31504 982 6 and and CC 31504 982 7 certainly certainly RB 31504 982 8 secured secure VBN 31504 982 9 by by IN 31504 982 10 the the DT 31504 982 11 maintenance maintenance NN 31504 982 12 of of IN 31504 982 13 particular particular JJ 31504 982 14 political political JJ 31504 982 15 institutions institution NNS 31504 982 16 , , , 31504 982 17 however however RB 31504 982 18 excellent excellent JJ 31504 982 19 . . . 31504 983 1 Political political JJ 31504 983 2 institutions institution NNS 31504 983 3 are be VBP 31504 983 4 not not RB 31504 983 5 self self NN 31504 983 6 - - HYPH 31504 983 7 acting act VBG 31504 983 8 . . . 31504 984 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 984 2 are be VBP 31504 984 3 only only RB 31504 984 4 instrumentalities instrumentality NNS 31504 984 5 for for IN 31504 984 6 the the DT 31504 984 7 action action NN 31504 984 8 of of IN 31504 984 9 society society NN 31504 984 10 . . . 31504 985 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 985 2 are be VBP 31504 985 3 not not RB 31504 985 4 only only RB 31504 985 5 to to TO 31504 985 6 be be VB 31504 985 7 established establish VBN 31504 985 8 and and CC 31504 985 9 maintained maintain VBN 31504 985 10 ; ; : 31504 985 11 they -PRON- PRP 31504 985 12 are be VBP 31504 985 13 to to TO 31504 985 14 be be VB 31504 985 15 administered administer VBN 31504 985 16 , , , 31504 985 17 and and CC 31504 985 18 the the DT 31504 985 19 best good JJS 31504 985 20 institutions institution NNS 31504 985 21 may may MD 31504 985 22 be be VB 31504 985 23 maladministered maladministere VBN 31504 985 24 . . . 31504 986 1 Even even RB 31504 986 2 under under IN 31504 986 3 such such PDT 31504 986 4 a a DT 31504 986 5 system system NN 31504 986 6 of of IN 31504 986 7 government government NN 31504 986 8 as as IN 31504 986 9 I -PRON- PRP 31504 986 10 have have VBP 31504 986 11 endeavored endeavor VBN 31504 986 12 to to TO 31504 986 13 show show VB 31504 986 14 to to TO 31504 986 15 be be VB 31504 986 16 the the DT 31504 986 17 best good JJS 31504 986 18 yet yet RB 31504 986 19 devised devise VBN 31504 986 20 to to TO 31504 986 21 secure secure VB 31504 986 22 justice justice NN 31504 986 23 , , , 31504 986 24 injustice injustice NN 31504 986 25 is be VBZ 31504 986 26 still still RB 31504 986 27 often often RB 31504 986 28 suffered suffer VBN 31504 986 29 by by IN 31504 986 30 the the DT 31504 986 31 individual individual NN 31504 986 32 or or CC 31504 986 33 by by IN 31504 986 34 society society NN 31504 986 35 . . . 31504 987 1 Oppressive oppressive JJ 31504 987 2 statutes statute NNS 31504 987 3 within within IN 31504 987 4 the the DT 31504 987 5 legislative legislative JJ 31504 987 6 power power NN 31504 987 7 are be VBP 31504 987 8 too too RB 31504 987 9 readily readily RB 31504 987 10 enacted enact VBN 31504 987 11 . . . 31504 988 1 Abuses abuse NNS 31504 988 2 in in IN 31504 988 3 administration administration NN 31504 988 4 are be VBP 31504 988 5 too too RB 31504 988 6 long long RB 31504 988 7 permitted permit VBN 31504 988 8 to to TO 31504 988 9 exist exist VB 31504 988 10 . . . 31504 989 1 The the DT 31504 989 2 only only JJ 31504 989 3 remedy remedy NN 31504 989 4 for for IN 31504 989 5 these these DT 31504 989 6 is be VBZ 31504 989 7 a a DT 31504 989 8 more more RBR 31504 989 9 enlightened enlighten VBN 31504 989 10 public public JJ 31504 989 11 opinion opinion NN 31504 989 12 , , , 31504 989 13 a a DT 31504 989 14 wider wide JJR 31504 989 15 diffusion diffusion NN 31504 989 16 of of IN 31504 989 17 the the DT 31504 989 18 spirit spirit NN 31504 989 19 of of IN 31504 989 20 impartiality impartiality NN 31504 989 21 , , , 31504 989 22 a a DT 31504 989 23 greater great JJR 31504 989 24 realization realization NN 31504 989 25 of of IN 31504 989 26 the the DT 31504 989 27 right right NN 31504 989 28 and and CC 31504 989 29 need need NN 31504 989 30 of of IN 31504 989 31 every every DT 31504 989 32 person person NN 31504 989 33 to to IN 31504 989 34 life life NN 31504 989 35 , , , 31504 989 36 liberty liberty NN 31504 989 37 , , , 31504 989 38 and and CC 31504 989 39 the the DT 31504 989 40 results result NNS 31504 989 41 of of IN 31504 989 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 31504 989 43 industry industry NN 31504 989 44 and and CC 31504 989 45 economy economy NN 31504 989 46 . . . 31504 990 1 Nor nor CC 31504 990 2 are be VBP 31504 990 3 the the DT 31504 990 4 judgments judgment NNS 31504 990 5 of of IN 31504 990 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 990 7 courts court NNS 31504 990 8 always always RB 31504 990 9 righteous righteous JJ 31504 990 10 . . . 31504 991 1 Some some DT 31504 991 2 of of IN 31504 991 3 the the DT 31504 991 4 instances instance NNS 31504 991 5 of of IN 31504 991 6 unrighteous unrighteous JJ 31504 991 7 judgments judgment NNS 31504 991 8 result result VBP 31504 991 9 from from IN 31504 991 10 failure failure NN 31504 991 11 to to IN 31504 991 12 ascertain ascertain NN 31504 991 13 and and CC 31504 991 14 apply apply VB 31504 991 15 the the DT 31504 991 16 truth truth NN 31504 991 17 as as IN 31504 991 18 to to IN 31504 991 19 the the DT 31504 991 20 facts fact NNS 31504 991 21 of of IN 31504 991 22 the the DT 31504 991 23 case case NN 31504 991 24 ; ; : 31504 991 25 some some DT 31504 991 26 from from IN 31504 991 27 errors error NNS 31504 991 28 in in IN 31504 991 29 judgment judgment NN 31504 991 30 ; ; : 31504 991 31 some some DT 31504 991 32 from from IN 31504 991 33 lack lack NN 31504 991 34 of of IN 31504 991 35 firmness firmness NN 31504 991 36 in in IN 31504 991 37 judges judge NNS 31504 991 38 in in IN 31504 991 39 enforcing enforce VBG 31504 991 40 the the DT 31504 991 41 known know VBN 31504 991 42 rights right NNS 31504 991 43 of of IN 31504 991 44 the the DT 31504 991 45 individual individual NN 31504 991 46 on on IN 31504 991 47 the the DT 31504 991 48 one one CD 31504 991 49 hand hand NN 31504 991 50 , , , 31504 991 51 or or CC 31504 991 52 those those DT 31504 991 53 of of IN 31504 991 54 society society NN 31504 991 55 on on IN 31504 991 56 the the DT 31504 991 57 other other JJ 31504 991 58 ; ; : 31504 991 59 and and CC 31504 991 60 perhaps perhaps RB 31504 991 61 a a DT 31504 991 62 very very RB 31504 991 63 few few JJ 31504 991 64 from from IN 31504 991 65 incompetency incompetency NN 31504 991 66 or or CC 31504 991 67 corruption corruption NN 31504 991 68 . . . 31504 992 1 These these DT 31504 992 2 causes cause NNS 31504 992 3 can can MD 31504 992 4 be be VB 31504 992 5 removed remove VBN 31504 992 6 to to IN 31504 992 7 a a DT 31504 992 8 large large JJ 31504 992 9 extent extent NN 31504 992 10 , , , 31504 992 11 by by IN 31504 992 12 a a DT 31504 992 13 more more RBR 31504 992 14 rigid rigid JJ 31504 992 15 insistence insistence NN 31504 992 16 on on IN 31504 992 17 skill skill NN 31504 992 18 , , , 31504 992 19 ability ability NN 31504 992 20 , , , 31504 992 21 industry industry NN 31504 992 22 , , , 31504 992 23 learning learning NN 31504 992 24 , , , 31504 992 25 and and CC 31504 992 26 courage courage NN 31504 992 27 on on IN 31504 992 28 the the DT 31504 992 29 part part NN 31504 992 30 of of IN 31504 992 31 those those DT 31504 992 32 assuming assume VBG 31504 992 33 to to TO 31504 992 34 administer administer VB 31504 992 35 justice justice NN 31504 992 36 as as IN 31504 992 37 attorneys attorney NNS 31504 992 38 and and CC 31504 992 39 counselors counselor NNS 31504 992 40 . . . 31504 993 1 The the DT 31504 993 2 same same JJ 31504 993 3 insistence insistence NN 31504 993 4 in in IN 31504 993 5 the the DT 31504 993 6 selection selection NN 31504 993 7 of of IN 31504 993 8 judges judge NNS 31504 993 9 will will MD 31504 993 10 lessen lessen VB 31504 993 11 the the DT 31504 993 12 injustice injustice NN 31504 993 13 resulting result VBG 31504 993 14 from from IN 31504 993 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 993 16 errors error NNS 31504 993 17 in in IN 31504 993 18 judgment judgment NN 31504 993 19 and and CC 31504 993 20 from from IN 31504 993 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 993 22 lack lack NN 31504 993 23 of of IN 31504 993 24 firmness firmness NN 31504 993 25 . . . 31504 994 1 There there EX 31504 994 2 is be VBZ 31504 994 3 yet yet RB 31504 994 4 another another DT 31504 994 5 cause cause NN 31504 994 6 of of IN 31504 994 7 injustice injustice NN 31504 994 8 , , , 31504 994 9 the the DT 31504 994 10 delay delay NN 31504 994 11 and and CC 31504 994 12 expense expense NN 31504 994 13 in in IN 31504 994 14 obtaining obtain VBG 31504 994 15 even even RB 31504 994 16 righteous righteous JJ 31504 994 17 judgments judgment NNS 31504 994 18 . . . 31504 995 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 995 2 is be VBZ 31504 995 3 an an DT 31504 995 4 axiom axiom NN 31504 995 5 , , , 31504 995 6 that that IN 31504 995 7 justice justice NN 31504 995 8 delayed delay VBN 31504 995 9 is be VBZ 31504 995 10 justice justice NN 31504 995 11 denied deny VBN 31504 995 12 . . . 31504 996 1 This this DT 31504 996 2 delay delay NN 31504 996 3 and and CC 31504 996 4 expense expense NN 31504 996 5 are be VBP 31504 996 6 often often RB 31504 996 7 charged charge VBN 31504 996 8 against against IN 31504 996 9 the the DT 31504 996 10 courts court NNS 31504 996 11 and and CC 31504 996 12 judges judge NNS 31504 996 13 , , , 31504 996 14 as as IN 31504 996 15 if if IN 31504 996 16 they -PRON- PRP 31504 996 17 had have VBD 31504 996 18 full full JJ 31504 996 19 control control NN 31504 996 20 over over IN 31504 996 21 judicial judicial JJ 31504 996 22 procedure procedure NN 31504 996 23 . . . 31504 997 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 997 2 is be VBZ 31504 997 3 not not RB 31504 997 4 the the DT 31504 997 5 judges judge NNS 31504 997 6 but but CC 31504 997 7 the the DT 31504 997 8 legislature legislature NN 31504 997 9 that that WDT 31504 997 10 shapes shape VBZ 31504 997 11 the the DT 31504 997 12 judicial judicial JJ 31504 997 13 system system NN 31504 997 14 and and CC 31504 997 15 prescribes prescribe VBZ 31504 997 16 the the DT 31504 997 17 judicial judicial JJ 31504 997 18 procedure procedure NN 31504 997 19 , , , 31504 997 20 so so RB 31504 997 21 far far RB 31504 997 22 as as IN 31504 997 23 they -PRON- PRP 31504 997 24 are be VBP 31504 997 25 not not RB 31504 997 26 fixed fix VBN 31504 997 27 by by IN 31504 997 28 the the DT 31504 997 29 constitution constitution NN 31504 997 30 . . . 31504 998 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 998 2 is be VBZ 31504 998 3 not not RB 31504 998 4 the the DT 31504 998 5 courts court NNS 31504 998 6 but but CC 31504 998 7 the the DT 31504 998 8 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 998 9 that that WDT 31504 998 10 provide provide VBP 31504 998 11 for for IN 31504 998 12 so so RB 31504 998 13 many many JJ 31504 998 14 appeals appeal NNS 31504 998 15 and and CC 31504 998 16 allow allow VBP 31504 998 17 so so RB 31504 998 18 many many JJ 31504 998 19 stays stay NNS 31504 998 20 and and CC 31504 998 21 consequent consequent NN 31504 998 22 delays delay NNS 31504 998 23 . . . 31504 999 1 Judges judge NNS 31504 999 2 and and CC 31504 999 3 lawyers lawyer NNS 31504 999 4 the the DT 31504 999 5 country country NN 31504 999 6 over over RB 31504 999 7 are be VBP 31504 999 8 urging urge VBG 31504 999 9 a a DT 31504 999 10 more more RBR 31504 999 11 simplified simplified JJ 31504 999 12 , , , 31504 999 13 a a DT 31504 999 14 more more RBR 31504 999 15 speedy speedy JJ 31504 999 16 , , , 31504 999 17 and and CC 31504 999 18 less less RBR 31504 999 19 expensive expensive JJ 31504 999 20 procedure procedure NN 31504 999 21 . . . 31504 1000 1 They -PRON- PRP 31504 1000 2 are be VBP 31504 1000 3 also also RB 31504 1000 4 urging urge VBG 31504 1000 5 the the DT 31504 1000 6 establishment establishment NN 31504 1000 7 of of IN 31504 1000 8 more more JJR 31504 1000 9 courts court NNS 31504 1000 10 with with IN 31504 1000 11 more more JJR 31504 1000 12 judges judge NNS 31504 1000 13 to to TO 31504 1000 14 cope cope VB 31504 1000 15 with with IN 31504 1000 16 the the DT 31504 1000 17 constantly constantly RB 31504 1000 18 increasing increase VBG 31504 1000 19 litigation litigation NN 31504 1000 20 , , , 31504 1000 21 in in IN 31504 1000 22 order order NN 31504 1000 23 that that IN 31504 1000 24 the the DT 31504 1000 25 wrongs wrong NNS 31504 1000 26 against against IN 31504 1000 27 the the DT 31504 1000 28 individual individual NN 31504 1000 29 and and CC 31504 1000 30 the the DT 31504 1000 31 wrongs wrong NNS 31504 1000 32 against against IN 31504 1000 33 society society NN 31504 1000 34 may may MD 31504 1000 35 be be VB 31504 1000 36 redressed redress VBN 31504 1000 37 with with IN 31504 1000 38 a a DT 31504 1000 39 minimum minimum NN 31504 1000 40 of of IN 31504 1000 41 delay delay NN 31504 1000 42 and and CC 31504 1000 43 cost cost NN 31504 1000 44 . . . 31504 1001 1 It -PRON- PRP 31504 1001 2 is be VBZ 31504 1001 3 the the DT 31504 1001 4 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 1001 5 that that WDT 31504 1001 6 hesitate hesitate VBP 31504 1001 7 and and CC 31504 1001 8 often often RB 31504 1001 9 it -PRON- PRP 31504 1001 10 is be VBZ 31504 1001 11 the the DT 31504 1001 12 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 1001 13 that that WDT 31504 1001 14 tie tie VBP 31504 1001 15 the the DT 31504 1001 16 hands hand NNS 31504 1001 17 of of IN 31504 1001 18 the the DT 31504 1001 19 judges judge NNS 31504 1001 20 . . . 31504 1002 1 In in IN 31504 1002 2 some some DT 31504 1002 3 states state NNS 31504 1002 4 it -PRON- PRP 31504 1002 5 is be VBZ 31504 1002 6 sought seek VBN 31504 1002 7 to to TO 31504 1002 8 deprive deprive VB 31504 1002 9 the the DT 31504 1002 10 judges judge NNS 31504 1002 11 of of IN 31504 1002 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 31504 1002 13 proper proper JJ 31504 1002 14 influence influence NN 31504 1002 15 in in IN 31504 1002 16 jury jury NN 31504 1002 17 trials trial NNS 31504 1002 18 . . . 31504 1003 1 In in IN 31504 1003 2 some some DT 31504 1003 3 states state NNS 31504 1003 4 it -PRON- PRP 31504 1003 5 is be VBZ 31504 1003 6 even even RB 31504 1003 7 sought seek VBN 31504 1003 8 to to TO 31504 1003 9 prevent prevent VB 31504 1003 10 them -PRON- PRP 31504 1003 11 from from IN 31504 1003 12 saying say VBG 31504 1003 13 more more JJR 31504 1003 14 than than IN 31504 1003 15 yes yes UH 31504 1003 16 or or CC 31504 1003 17 no no DT 31504 1003 18 to to TO 31504 1003 19 proposed propose VBN 31504 1003 20 instructions instruction NNS 31504 1003 21 to to IN 31504 1003 22 a a DT 31504 1003 23 jury jury NN 31504 1003 24 . . . 31504 1004 1 In in IN 31504 1004 2 many many JJ 31504 1004 3 states state NNS 31504 1004 4 nearly nearly RB 31504 1004 5 the the DT 31504 1004 6 whole whole JJ 31504 1004 7 matter matter NN 31504 1004 8 of of IN 31504 1004 9 procedure procedure NN 31504 1004 10 , , , 31504 1004 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 1004 12 various various JJ 31504 1004 13 steps step NNS 31504 1004 14 , , , 31504 1004 15 are be VBP 31504 1004 16 fixed fix VBN 31504 1004 17 by by IN 31504 1004 18 statute statute NN 31504 1004 19 and and CC 31504 1004 20 become become VB 31504 1004 21 difficult difficult JJ 31504 1004 22 of of IN 31504 1004 23 improvement improvement NN 31504 1004 24 . . . 31504 1005 1 If if IN 31504 1005 2 courts court NNS 31504 1005 3 could could MD 31504 1005 4 have have VB 31504 1005 5 more more JJR 31504 1005 6 power power NN 31504 1005 7 and and CC 31504 1005 8 the the DT 31504 1005 9 legislatures legislature NNS 31504 1005 10 would would MD 31504 1005 11 interfere interfere VB 31504 1005 12 less less RBR 31504 1005 13 in in IN 31504 1005 14 matters matter NNS 31504 1005 15 of of IN 31504 1005 16 procedure procedure NN 31504 1005 17 , , , 31504 1005 18 I -PRON- PRP 31504 1005 19 am be VBP 31504 1005 20 sure sure JJ 31504 1005 21 the the DT 31504 1005 22 cause cause NN 31504 1005 23 of of IN 31504 1005 24 justice justice NN 31504 1005 25 would would MD 31504 1005 26 be be VB 31504 1005 27 better well RBR 31504 1005 28 served serve VBN 31504 1005 29 . . . 31504 1006 1 In in IN 31504 1006 2 conclusion conclusion NN 31504 1006 3 , , , 31504 1006 4 perfect perfect JJ 31504 1006 5 justice justice NN 31504 1006 6 may may MD 31504 1006 7 not not RB 31504 1006 8 be be VB 31504 1006 9 attainable attainable JJ 31504 1006 10 by by IN 31504 1006 11 us -PRON- PRP 31504 1006 12 imperfect imperfect JJ 31504 1006 13 men man NNS 31504 1006 14 . . . 31504 1007 1 As as IN 31504 1007 2 said say VBN 31504 1007 3 by by IN 31504 1007 4 Addison Addison NNP 31504 1007 5 , , , 31504 1007 6 " " '' 31504 1007 7 omniscience omniscience NN 31504 1007 8 and and CC 31504 1007 9 omnipotence omnipotence NN 31504 1007 10 are be VBP 31504 1007 11 requisite requisite JJ 31504 1007 12 for for IN 31504 1007 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 1007 14 full full JJ 31504 1007 15 attainment attainment NN 31504 1007 16 . . . 31504 1007 17 " " '' 31504 1008 1 Yet yet CC 31504 1008 2 it -PRON- PRP 31504 1008 3 is be VBZ 31504 1008 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 1008 5 duty duty NN 31504 1008 6 and and CC 31504 1008 7 especially especially RB 31504 1008 8 the the DT 31504 1008 9 duty duty NN 31504 1008 10 of of IN 31504 1008 11 those those DT 31504 1008 12 of of IN 31504 1008 13 the the DT 31504 1008 14 legal legal JJ 31504 1008 15 profession profession NN 31504 1008 16 to to TO 31504 1008 17 attain attain VB 31504 1008 18 to to IN 31504 1008 19 such such JJ 31504 1008 20 approximation approximation NN 31504 1008 21 as as IN 31504 1008 22 may may MD 31504 1008 23 be be VB 31504 1008 24 possible possible JJ 31504 1008 25 . . . 31504 1009 1 No no DT 31504 1009 2 more more RBR 31504 1009 3 noble noble JJ 31504 1009 4 work work NN 31504 1009 5 can can MD 31504 1009 6 engage engage VB 31504 1009 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 31504 1009 8 powers power NNS 31504 1009 9 ; ; : 31504 1009 10 no no DT 31504 1009 11 greater great JJR 31504 1009 12 service service NN 31504 1009 13 can can MD 31504 1009 14 be be VB 31504 1009 15 rendered render VBN 31504 1009 16 mankind mankind NN 31504 1009 17 . . . 31504 1010 1 I -PRON- PRP 31504 1010 2 do do VBP 31504 1010 3 not not RB 31504 1010 4 except except IN 31504 1010 5 the the DT 31504 1010 6 endowment endowment NN 31504 1010 7 of of IN 31504 1010 8 schools school NNS 31504 1010 9 , , , 31504 1010 10 colleges college NNS 31504 1010 11 , , , 31504 1010 12 libraries library NNS 31504 1010 13 , , , 31504 1010 14 and and CC 31504 1010 15 the the DT 31504 1010 16 like like JJ 31504 1010 17 , , , 31504 1010 18 nor nor CC 31504 1010 19 the the DT 31504 1010 20 endowment endowment NN 31504 1010 21 of of IN 31504 1010 22 hospitals hospital NNS 31504 1010 23 and and CC 31504 1010 24 other other JJ 31504 1010 25 charitable charitable JJ 31504 1010 26 institutions institution NNS 31504 1010 27 . . . 31504 1011 1 Great great JJ 31504 1011 2 as as IN 31504 1011 3 are be VBP 31504 1011 4 the the DT 31504 1011 5 virtues virtue NNS 31504 1011 6 of of IN 31504 1011 7 charity charity NN 31504 1011 8 , , , 31504 1011 9 benevolence benevolence NN 31504 1011 10 , , , 31504 1011 11 philanthropy philanthropy NN 31504 1011 12 , , , 31504 1011 13 piety piety NN 31504 1011 14 and and CC 31504 1011 15 the the DT 31504 1011 16 like like JJ 31504 1011 17 , , , 31504 1011 18 justice justice NN 31504 1011 19 is be VBZ 31504 1011 20 a a DT 31504 1011 21 yet yet RB 31504 1011 22 greater great JJR 31504 1011 23 virtue virtue NN 31504 1011 24 . . . 31504 1012 1 To to TO 31504 1012 2 quote quote VB 31504 1012 3 Addison Addison NNP 31504 1012 4 again again RB 31504 1012 5 , , , 31504 1012 6 " " `` 31504 1012 7 There there EX 31504 1012 8 is be VBZ 31504 1012 9 no no DT 31504 1012 10 virtue virtue NN 31504 1012 11 so so RB 31504 1012 12 truly truly RB 31504 1012 13 great great JJ 31504 1012 14 and and CC 31504 1012 15 godlike godlike VBP 31504 1012 16 as as IN 31504 1012 17 justice justice NN 31504 1012 18 " " '' 31504 1012 19 ; ; , 31504 1012 20 and and CC 31504 1012 21 in in IN 31504 1012 22 the the DT 31504 1012 23 words word NNS 31504 1012 24 of of IN 31504 1012 25 Daniel Daniel NNP 31504 1012 26 Webster Webster NNP 31504 1012 27 's 's POS 31504 1012 28 eulogy eulogy NN 31504 1012 29 : : : 31504 1012 30 " " `` 31504 1012 31 Whoever whoever WP 31504 1012 32 labors labor VBZ 31504 1012 33 on on IN 31504 1012 34 this this DT 31504 1012 35 edifice edifice NN 31504 1012 36 of of IN 31504 1012 37 justice justice NN 31504 1012 38 , , , 31504 1012 39 clears clear VBZ 31504 1012 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 1012 41 foundations foundation NNS 31504 1012 42 , , , 31504 1012 43 strengthens strengthen VBZ 31504 1012 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 1012 45 pillars pillar NNS 31504 1012 46 , , , 31504 1012 47 adorns adorn VBZ 31504 1012 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 1012 49 entablatures entablature NNS 31504 1012 50 , , , 31504 1012 51 or or CC 31504 1012 52 contributes contribute VBZ 31504 1012 53 to to TO 31504 1012 54 raise raise VB 31504 1012 55 its -PRON- PRP$ 31504 1012 56 august august JJ 31504 1012 57 dome dome NN 31504 1012 58 still still RB 31504 1012 59 higher high JJR 31504 1012 60 in in IN 31504 1012 61 the the DT 31504 1012 62 skies sky NNS 31504 1012 63 , , , 31504 1012 64 connects connect VBZ 31504 1012 65 himself -PRON- PRP 31504 1012 66 in in IN 31504 1012 67 name name NN 31504 1012 68 , , , 31504 1012 69 fame fame NN 31504 1012 70 , , , 31504 1012 71 and and CC 31504 1012 72 character character NN 31504 1012 73 with with IN 31504 1012 74 that that DT 31504 1012 75 which which WDT 31504 1012 76 is be VBZ 31504 1012 77 , , , 31504 1012 78 and and CC 31504 1012 79 must must MD 31504 1012 80 be be VB 31504 1012 81 , , , 31504 1012 82 as as RB 31504 1012 83 durable durable JJ 31504 1012 84 as as IN 31504 1012 85 the the DT 31504 1012 86 frame frame NN 31504 1012 87 of of IN 31504 1012 88 human human JJ 31504 1012 89 society society NN 31504 1012 90 . . . 31504 1012 91 " " '' 31504 1013 1 PUBLISHED PUBLISHED NNS 31504 1013 2 ON on IN 31504 1013 3 THE the DT 31504 1013 4 FOUNDATION foundation NN 31504 1013 5 ESTABLISHED ESTABLISHED NNS 31504 1013 6 IN in IN 31504 1013 7 MEMORY memory NN 31504 1013 8 OF of IN 31504 1013 9 HENRY HENRY NNP 31504 1013 10 WELDON WELDON NNP 31504 1013 11 BARNES barne NNS 31504 1013 12 OF of IN 31504 1013 13 THE the DT 31504 1013 14 CLASS CLASS NNP 31504 1013 15 OF of IN 31504 1013 16 1882 1882 CD 31504 1013 17 , , , 31504 1013 18 YALE YALE NNP 31504 1013 19 COLLEGE COLLEGE NNP 31504 1013 20 STORRS STORRS NNP 31504 1013 21 LECTURES lectures NN 31504 1013 22 Published publish VBN 31504 1013 23 by by IN 31504 1013 24 Yale Yale NNP 31504 1013 25 University University NNP 31504 1013 26 Press Press NNP 31504 1013 27 THE the DT 31504 1013 28 REFORM reform NN 31504 1013 29 OF of IN 31504 1013 30 LEGAL LEGAL NNP 31504 1013 31 PROCEDURE PROCEDURE NNP 31504 1013 32 . . . 31504 1014 1 By by IN 31504 1014 2 MOORFIELD MOORFIELD NNP 31504 1014 3 STOREY STOREY NNP 31504 1014 4 . . . 31504 1015 1 Price price NN 31504 1015 2 $ $ $ 31504 1015 3 1.35 1.35 CD 31504 1015 4 net net NN 31504 1015 5 delivered deliver VBN 31504 1015 6 . . . 31504 1016 1 THE the DT 31504 1016 2 JUDICIARY judiciary NN 31504 1016 3 AND and CC 31504 1016 4 THE the DT 31504 1016 5 PEOPLE PEOPLE NNS 31504 1016 6 . . . 31504 1017 1 By by IN 31504 1017 2 FREDERICK FREDERICK NNP 31504 1017 3 N. N. NNP 31504 1017 4 JUDSON JUDSON NNP 31504 1017 5 . . . 31504 1018 1 Price price NN 31504 1018 2 $ $ $ 31504 1018 3 1.35 1.35 CD 31504 1018 4 net net NN 31504 1018 5 delivered deliver VBN 31504 1018 6 . . . 31504 1019 1 CONCERNING CONCERNING NNP 31504 1019 2 JUSTICE JUSTICE NNP 31504 1019 3 . . . 31504 1020 1 By by IN 31504 1020 2 LUCILIUS LUCILIUS NNP 31504 1020 3 A. a. NN 31504 1020 4 EMERY EMERY NNP 31504 1020 5 . . . 31504 1021 1 Price price NN 31504 1021 2 $ $ $ 31504 1021 3 1.15 1.15 CD 31504 1021 4 net net NN 31504 1021 5 delivered deliver VBN 31504 1021 6 . . . 31504 1022 1 _ _ NNP 31504 1022 2 Uniform Uniform NNP 31504 1022 3 in in IN 31504 1022 4 style style NN 31504 1022 5 with with IN 31504 1022 6 the the DT 31504 1022 7 Storrs Storrs NNP 31504 1022 8 Lectures Lectures NNPS 31504 1022 9 _ _ NNP 31504 1022 10 INTERNATIONAL INTERNATIONAL NNP 31504 1022 11 ARBITRATION ARBITRATION NNP 31504 1022 12 AND and CC 31504 1022 13 PROCEDURE PROCEDURE NNP 31504 1022 14 . . . 31504 1023 1 By by IN 31504 1023 2 ROBERT ROBERT NNP 31504 1023 3 C. C. NNP 31504 1023 4 MORRIS MORRIS NNP 31504 1023 5 , , , 31504 1023 6 with with IN 31504 1023 7 a a DT 31504 1023 8 foreword foreword NN 31504 1023 9 by by IN 31504 1023 10 PRESIDENT PRESIDENT NNP 31504 1023 11 TAFT TAFT NNP 31504 1023 12 . . . 31504 1024 1 Price price NN 31504 1024 2 $ $ $ 31504 1024 3 1.35 1.35 CD 31504 1024 4 net net NN 31504 1024 5 delivered deliver VBN 31504 1024 6 . . .