A peace but no pacification, or, An answer to that new designe of the oath of pacification and accomodation lately printed a subject for all that love true peace and liberty to consider / by Iohn Saltmarsh ... Saltmarsh, John, d. 1647. This text is an enriched version of the TCP digital transcription A71059 of text R15667 in the English Short Title Catalog (Wing S494). Textual changes and metadata enrichments aim at making the text more computationally tractable, easier to read, and suitable for network-based collaborative curation by amateur and professional end users from many walks of life. The text has been tokenized and linguistically annotated with MorphAdorner. The annotation includes standard spellings that support the display of a text in a standardized format that preserves archaic forms ('loveth', 'seekest'). Textual changes aim at restoring the text the author or stationer meant to publish. This text has not been fully proofread Approx. 24 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 9 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. EarlyPrint Project Evanston,IL, Notre Dame, IN, St. Louis, MO 2017 A71059 Wing S494 ESTC R15667 12099945 ocm 12099945 54080 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A71059) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 54080) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 240:E71, no 31) A peace but no pacification, or, An answer to that new designe of the oath of pacification and accomodation lately printed a subject for all that love true peace and liberty to consider / by Iohn Saltmarsh ... Saltmarsh, John, d. 1647. [16] p. Printed by Barnard Alsop ..., London : 1643. Half title preceeding t.p. Reproduction of original in Thomason Collection, British Library. eng Parker, Henry, 1604-1652. -- Oath of pacification. Great Britain -- Politics and government -- 1642-1649. A71059 R15667 (Wing S494). civilwar no A peace, but no pacification. Or, An answer to that new designe of the oath of pacification and accommodation. Lately printed. A subject for Saltmarsh, John 1643 3856 3 0 0 0 1 0 34 C The rate of 34 defects per 10,000 words puts this text in the C category of texts with between 10 and 35 defects per 10,000 words. 2005-12 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2006-03 SPi Global Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2006-06 Jason Colman Sampled and proofread 2006-06 Jason Colman Text and markup reviewed and edited 2006-09 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion A PEACE , BVT NO Pacification . A PEACE , BUT NO PACIFICATION . OR , An Answer to that new Designe of the Oath OF PACIFICATION AND ACCOMMODATION . Lately printed . A subject for all that love true peacè and liberty , to consider . By Iohn Saltmarsh , M.M.A. LONDON , Printed by Barnard Alsop , and are to be sold at the Castle in Cornhill . 1643. A PEACE , BVT NO PACIFICATION . IT is a notion more Platonicall than reall for a private man to thinke he can arbitrate Imperiall differences , and it is rather an act of Fancie than Iudgement , a policy of Imagination , than State , for the soule of one is of no just latitude nor comprehension for a designe of that bredth , as the Pacification of a Kingdome , and when the judgement proves too narrow for the designe , the designe must needs fall short of the requisite proportions ; and further , they that would intervene in such controversies , and mysteries of high Accommodations , must be situated geometrically for both sides , and stand upon so much vantage ground , as he may have a full prospect over all particulars , whether springing or full blowne . As for instance , if you would compose the King and Parliament , you must either have a right and cleare cognizance of both , and see almost the veriest atomes in the state of both , or else you shall doe right to neither ; for the least things are of moment in States , and Politickes , and I doe beleeve it is impossible for any to be so qualified an Arbitrator for our supreme disputes , being so full of new Revolutions , and Interpositions , especially now , when an Almighty power seemes to mingle , and incorporate his owne Interests with ours , and engage us upon new Fundamentals . And though Accommodation bee such a subject as will gaine both Readers and parties , yet it is of dangerous consequence , to write unto the spirits of men , of things that may retard and stay their publick pursuits ; especially now in a time of an Irish Accommodation ; for there are few in such haste after their enemies , but they will stay a while and talke with any that can parley and discourse of Peace ; and the musick of Pacification is so sweet , as many could willingly let their engagements fall out of their hands to hearken and follow such tunes : we should be farre better Statesmen for these times , if wee first laboured to finde the true elevation of things , for when we have such intrinsecall variations in our State and Church , it cannot bee an act of commensuration to weigh designes at the beam of old Politicks and Conveniences , and they that would now place us upon old bottomes , are such in whom the old interests prevaile more than the new , and if we take hold of them to guide us , they will at length bring us backe into as bad a condition as we have forsaken ; although they may seeme to lead us about a while through some new and pleasing conceptions to entertaine us from observation . It was a smooth fallacy of the Prophet , who led his enemy so farre , as he suffered him not to see the mistake , till he had brought him into the midst of Samaria . The peace and prosperity we have had , have wrought in us such principles of ease and indulgency , as makes us industrious in projectings after Pacifications , never looking forward at inconsistencies , nor behind at consequences , nor about us , at the season , and other circumstances . For Accommodations in the latitude of the notion , are of such a contexture , and intermingled constitution , as they usually take in various and equall principles from both . Now I appeale to any whether the others Principles either Religious or Civill be consistent with ours now , and whether they be such as can dwell together , or incorporate , whether their essences and operations be not divers , and being so contrariant as we see , and having wrought out each others interests into severall independencies and stations already , how shall these be reconciled ! unlesse wee attaine hereafter to live under those heavenly and propheticall influences , where Antipathies and Contrarieties are made friends , Where the Lion and the Lambe lye downe together , and the children play with the Cockatrice . Againe , Accommodation is the putting an untimely period to our Reformation , which by that must necessarily be prevented in the period it aimed at , because it seemes to be met in the halfe way , and we bespeake it to stop , and bring with us a new designe rather of diversion , than advancement or propagation . And again , these times are such as the infuosins are stronger , and the principles too , being inabled not only by many divine influences and providences and concurrencies ; but carried on with Arguments , and reason , and treatises , which the contestations of former ages in this Kingdome never knew ; each party assuring their side with a more learned Artifice , so as men are now acted aswell by conscience as passion , as well by Iudgement as resolution , and this is one reason with me that not any such pacification can well be transacted , for both sides have been so Argumentatively and rationally informed , and have taken in their owne fundamentalls so deeply , and in so much divinity , and assurance , as it is not possible nor probable to mediate a reconciliation till you have loosened and unhinged the one ; and therefore these Maxims of Moderation & Accommodation are rather the issues , and ingenious experiments of Melancholy spirits , who please themselvs and others in these stormes , and gloomy seasons , by painting twilights and calme enterludes ; or else the subtill incantations of some that are no right wishers to the cause : and doe wee not further see how the wars and broyles of preceding ages , left alwayes a turbulent and inflaming remainder in the dispositions of men ? so as the old differences and effusions did onely forsake the broader and wider passages of Battailes , and sought out straiter , those of Emulations , Duells , and Quarrells , and men have rather fought the great Contentions over againe in the Abridgements afterwards , so as the warre was still the same in such unsound Pacifications , onely the method was new , and the bloud of those warme distempers flowed downe onely in narrower channels , and thus when civill contentions , and Nationall flames are forced backe againe by the hand of an immature Pacification , they brake out in as many particular combu●tions , as summ'd up , would make a competent destruction . And besides all these considerations , the Parliamentary party have obliged themselves by Vowes and Covenants , and so are not such masters of times and circumstances , as their enemies are ; ( having given up their owne relations and selfe policy , and involved them in more universall and sublime ends ) but their enemies ( whose interests are of a lighter and easier , and more sequacious constitution ) are ready to turne with all advantages of State , and every civill or gainfull emergency ; and though they be men of obligations , and Covenants too , yet their Covenants are rather like engines of Policy and Religion , to open and shut at pleasure , and to set down and take up their soules and affaires to the necessities , conveniences , and occasions of State : and this overthrowes the very substratum and fundamentall of this new Oath ; for when there hath beene such private landing places and secret Posternes in their owne Covenants , to goe out and come in at , it is most likely that if they finde not the like liberty againe in another , they will force it ; it being now made by wicked Counsellors one branch of the Prerogative to be transcenden● to Obligation , and Protestation , and Covenant , and to make the supremest violations and evasions lawfull , but the woe will not fall so directly upon the Covenanter , as upon those that have mistaught him , and drawn out his good intentions into the labyrinths of their owne art , these are the ministers of seducement , & by such are the best carried on , ( having made some virtue their friend for a time , or some peculiar disposition of their master at their first insinuation . ) And though the Author of the Pacificating Oath would perswade us of the terrours , and judgements , such Oathes would cast upon the violators , as if the violation brought with it ( like a boding Comet ) the sparklings of an heavenly indignation ; yet wee must know that Princes as they are exalted into the divine notion of Gods , so their Favourites make them beleeve that their politicall deitie can secure them ; and then there are ever some State Casuist at hand too who can heale their distempers with many a blandishment and evasion , so as I know not whether to admire more the glory , or infelicity of a Crowne , for there is a Divinity which is calculated meerly for the Meridian of Princes , and will fit no lower condition ; and there is an order of Prerogative Divines , who onely study the disinteressings and disobligings of their Prince : now I would gladly know what remedy he hath reserved for us in case of violation ( it being too apparant how the supremest may be misinstructed and abused , ) all I can find out , is an heavenly indignation & revenge ; and he must know , this is not an immediate judgment which treades alwayes on the heeles of a transgression , but may be powred upon the next succeeding Throne , or at least in the evening of the offendour ; for there are certaine graduall effluxes of the Divine Wrath , and many stayes and periods which his Infinite Wisedome makes , and is not accountable to our Tribunals ; and what shall a State doe then in this space and intervall to judgement ? for being then made passive againe , it becomes a subject to as much , if not more Tyrannie , than before : and usually the revolt of Prerogatives , and the Relapses are more dangerous than the first excesse : as the wrath of Pharaoh and Saul after some particular violations grew more implacable and violent : and as we see in civill Stories of our owne : and the reason why a relapsing power becomes more vindicative , because there is a capacity of revenging recovered , and there seemes to lye nothing in their way to breake the stroake . Nor let the Author of the new Oath thinke he can be more ingenious in contriving , than some Ministers of State in eluding , nor so exquisite in the forme , as they in their suggestions and infusions for violation : and whatsoever he tels us of the ancient transaction in such cases , I must answer him , that if hee can revive the (a) ancient reverence and simplicity and faith of those ages with the ancient transaction , then I shall allow more to his president : but he knowes that the (b) Machiavillisme of later times have made a Maxime in the science of Politickes , how to overwit their owne obligations , and have made it one part of the perfection of a Statist , (c) to be too wise for engagements : and though the wisedome of the first coalition in this State made it their surest designe to seale the Inauguration by an Oath , yet we see there is no infallibility in such counsels and acts ; no protection from the violence of evill counsell : and such hath beene the declination of States of late , that Oathes were but in the reputation of Politicke formes with many , unlesse it be with those who drive on a holier designe , as that of Reformation , and with such , Covenants and Oathes have their just reputation , as it appeares in the late transactions of Scotland , and other Reformed Kingdomes , and of England now ; and this appeares to be the opinion of this Authour too , for in his sixt page , he urges much the stately and sanctimonious forme or solemnity , as of necessity amongst Plebeians , so as by that very notion , he pleads the Pompe and Ceremony of an oath so as if he would have it by that accesse of some glorious lustre , to dart the people into an obligation , as well as the Prince ; when as there are many safer , and more naturall meanes to becalme the jealousies of Subjects , even a reall application to their affections , in the motions of Iustice , and Peace , and Religion ; and that people shall never take umbrages , where the goings of the Prince are cleare and discerneable , and not shaded by the crowde of Privadoes and bad Ministers ; but in a word , when the first and Primitive oath which is the highest and most supreame rise of an obligation , is not inviolable , nor includible , what strength and assurance , can be in derivatives and supplementals of the same nature ? Nor do I think it a designe of that happy and wholsome constitution as some take it , I mean an oath of Pacification , for satisfaction of jealousies , for there is an art to take away all jealousies , and in the roome bring delusions of assurance , and so thicken and incrassate the satisfactions , that people shall in time forfeite their liberties in a mist , and scarce believe they are oppressed , till they be oppressed almost beyond a remedy ; and this nation hath been ever easily carried on into such an incredulity and misbeliefe , and have often served many yeeres apprentiship both of ignorance and bondage . Nor will any wise man suppose that to bee a good condition for any State , especially for a government so mixt as ours , which ought ever to be looking to the just Interests of one another , especially after a season of encroachment and exorbitation : for to take in such a remedy as shall leave no Iealousie behinde it , is to take in such a quantity of Opium as will rather bring a Lethargy than a kindly rest , and rather make a Kingdome stupid than peaceable ; surely those remedies are best , which keepe States waken and sensible , and the eyes of the Kingdome open . And as there is a jealousie in some which is but a virtuous luxuriancy of love and affection , and tends onely to the preservation of honor and propriety in the suspected party , so there is in the best States : & sure there is no such way to keep things in their owne rights and priviledges , but such a sollicitous and carefull vigilancy , and wise suspition . That which I now conceive to be the only Interest of our Reformation , is not a Pacification but a Peace . For a Pacification is a more proper and safe notion for forraigne States than our owne , for a Pacification is but the accommodating of a difference , and a meeting of severall principles , and a resolving to agree with one another , without any further incorporation , but this cannot be intrinsecall nor naturall enough for us of the same kingdom , this is no such indistant complication as we should now aim at , and as our new & holy fundamentals cal for : our purest & soundest peace would be from a succumbency & invalidity , when on the worse part the opposition is spent & exhaled , then there is no feare , that there will breake forth any fresh and mutuall Contendings , and there must needs be more security in that peace where all possibility of resistance is taken away , than where there lives two natures of proportionall abilities and passions , which would prove like the two men in the Fable , who being weary with beating one another , tooke truce for an houres refreshment , and fell fresh to their blowes againe . A Peace then and not a Pacification is our assertion , and I hope all who value a Reformation according to their Covenant , will pursue those things which make for that , and suffer themselves not to be taken off their holy and famous resolutions for Peace , by any faire or specious argument for Pacification , Pacification being but the halfe way to Peace , and this I conceive is the Peace which will make both England and Scotland happy , not so much by inventing any new engines to binde our Kings in chaines , and our Princes in fetters of iron , but by endeavouring such an extirpation of Popery , Prelacie , and malignity , as our Peace may be rather secured by a disability of contending , than by any new Oath or possibility of resisting . For any further Criticisme upon the Author I have none ; I confesse he reasons well upon many particulars , and makes his inke rise high , and dash handsomly upon those that stand about the Throne , and had he reached further with his pen even to a Peace , and writ but beyond a Pacification , he had writ well . A Review . I Shall gather his designe into this compend. . An Oath and ceremonious forme for the King , another for the Queene , and the temeration being so dangerous , hee thinkes we are secured sufficiently : and he presumes , ( having laid downe this forme ) to lay upon it this weight , the honour of God , safety of Religion , P. 1. justice of Parliament . I confesse the Oath abstractively considered is able to beare this , and a larger superstructure ; but when concretively and pactionately taken , let all judge who knowes there is a revolution in the highest Orbes , and a changeablenesse and mutability in every thing to the very borders of immortality . In the ceremonious forme he seemes to ayme especially at the satisfaction of the people , P. 6. and he pleads for the attiring and apparelling the Oath in some glorious ceremonies : but popular satisfactions in true Christian States are more solidly obtained by just and free and regular redresses : I know very well that gusts of discontent will be blowing sometimes from the people upon the best administrations , but they will soone blow over , God having obliged himselfe not to suffer the rod of the wicked to rest upon the lot of the righteous . And for the Oath to the Queene , P. 1. I onely expose to the consideration of any , what security or assurance is there in such Fundamentals which an Absolution or Dispensation , or other Iesuiticall engine can overturne at pleasure , though I could tell him more too , for at the priviledge of this Oath he must needs let in a toleration of that which the condition of our Covenant cannot comply with . 〈◊〉 word , for any such obligationall happinesse , let the States of Holland reply , who have had too sad experience of the many effusions which the ministers of that tyrannous Philip had contrived , and especially now , in the season of the universall Apostacy , wherein Faith shall not be able to grow up to so just a stature as formerly , being a qualification ( saith that holy assertion ) scarce to be found on earth . And though this way of obligation and satisfaction hath beene made use on ( as he sayes ) by God and man , yet we must know God hath an essentiall immutability to insure his oath , and man had a fidelity then , which was not so well acquainted with the artifice of reservation , equivocation , and elusion . Conclusion . NOw consider the frailty and uncertainty in such foundations as oaths , the complexion and obligation of our late Covenants , the evasions and machinations of a reconciled enemy , the inconsistency of our principles and theirs , the fresh feuds from the remainders of an old combustion , our deep ingagements , our small purchase for the expence of so much blood and treasure , and tell me if there be any security but in some things beyond an Accommodation . To the Reader . I Have no other quarrell to the Booke than its incongruitie to our Reformation and Covenant , and civill libertie and security , though it may be this is a misfortune rather of the Authors affection than intention ; which making too much hast after Peace , fell into this error of Pacification : I could wish his excellent expressions had flowed in a better channell : nor would I be mistaken by others in what I doe , for I undertake not to write in a Politicke , out a rationall capacity . Quod si Pompeius & Caesar conjungi possint , me satis vicisse putabo . Bald. in Ep. ad Cico● . FINIS . Notes, typically marginal, from the original text Notes for div A71059e-120 Cap. 29. (a) Tanti nimirum est Rerump : firma & valida fundamenta poni , quoram non postremum hoc fuit , ut fides ac iuramentum civitatem regerent . Liv. (b) Principi nihil iniustum quod fructuosum ; Expediret autem fingere contrarium atque ita iuramentum concipere , non afficiam populum iniuriis . Lib. 5. pol. c. 9. (c) Sic Julius 11 Pontifex iactare ausus est , turpissimo hercule exemplo se foedera & societates cum Gallis Germanisque non aliter contrahere quam fallendi gratia . Quale erat Atheniensium & hodie multorum principum viro populum nullis iniuriis affectum iri , Plebs enim iuramento hoc contenta , & veluti secura de reliquis non admodum erit sollicita , etiamsi postea magnis iniuriis afficiatur .