Reflections on Mr. Varillas's history of the revolutions that have happned in Europe in matters of religion and more particularly on his ninth book that relates to England / by G. Burnet ... Burnet, Gilbert, 1643-1715. 1686 Approx. 154 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 101 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2004-03 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A30405 Wing B5852 ESTC R13985 12390080 ocm 12390080 60976 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A30405) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 60976) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 272:1) Reflections on Mr. Varillas's history of the revolutions that have happned in Europe in matters of religion and more particularly on his ninth book that relates to England / by G. Burnet ... Burnet, Gilbert, 1643-1715. 203, [1] p. Printed for P. Savouret ..., Amsterdam : 1686. Pages 168-203 photographed from British Library copy and inserted at the end. Errata: p. [1] at end of Huntington Library copy. Reproduction of original in Huntington Library. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Varillas, -- Monsieur -- (Antoine), 1624-1696. -- Histoire des revolutions arrivées dans l'Europe en matiere de religion. Reformation -- England. Europe -- Church history. Europe -- History -- 1517-1648. Great Britain -- Religion -- 17th century. 2003-10 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2003-10 Aptara Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2003-11 Mona Logarbo Sampled and proofread 2003-11 Mona Logarbo Text and markup reviewed and edited 2003-12 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion REFLECTIONS On Mr. VARILLAS's HISTORY Of the Revolutions that have happned in Europe in matters of Religion . And more particularly on his Ninth Book that relates to England . By G. BURNET , D. D. Amsterdam , Printed for P. Savouret in the Warmoes-street near the Dam. 1686. REFLECTIONS On Mr. VARILLAS's HISTORY of the Revolutions that have happned in Europe in matters of Religion , and more particularly on his 9 th Book that relates to England . MR . Varillas has within a few Years given the World so many-Books of History , and these have been so much read and so well received , that it seems he thinks he is now so far possessed of the esteem of the Age , that he may venture to impose upon it the falsest coyn that can be struck , not doubting but that the name Varillas stampt upon it will make it pass current , and this being a time in which some have thought that they might doe whatsoever they pleased against those of the Religion , he it seems thinks he may likewise say whatsoever he pleased against them , that so there may be a due proportion between the injuries that he does them with his pen , and those that others make them feel with severer tools , and perhaps he thought the severities that are now exercised upon them , are so contrary to that tenderness with which the humane Nature , not to say the Christian Religion , is apt to inspire all that are not transported with such violent Passions that they drown the Motions of our bowels towards the miserable , that nothing could divert the World from those merciful inclinations but the dressing up the first beginnings of the Reformation in such odious representations as might possess the Age with so much fury against them , that none of the miseries that they suffer , might create the least Compassion for them . It is true , Princes have their Prerogatives with which they take great liberties as their several passions are excited and dextrously managed , the desire of glory mixing with a heat of blood , at one time can produce a w●r , as terrible in its consequences , as it was injustifiable in its first beginnings , and the same ambition mixing with a superstitious disposition of mind , and working upon colder Blood , can at another time produce a violation of Edicts that have been solemnly sworn to , and often confirmed , and accompany that with a sequel of Severities , that are more easily lamented than expressed ; yet an humble regard to the sublime character of a Crown'd Head lays a restraint on those Groans , which we would rather stifle than give them their full scope , least the language of our Sorrows look like an accusing of those , whom , after all that our brethren have suffered at their hands , we would still force our selves to reverence , and therfore we choose rather to support our grief , than to vent it at their cost . But small Scriblers , who have set a price upon their pens , and sacrifice our reputation , that they may merite a pension at the hands of the chief Instruments of our Brethrens sufferings , are not to look for such respect : he that fights against the Laws of War ought to expect no quarter when he is taken . A Historian that favours his own side , is to be forgiven , thô he puts a little too much life in his colours , when he sets out the best sides of his party , and the worst of those from whom he disfers : and if he but slightly touches the failings of his Friends , and severely aggravates those of the other side , thô in this he departs from the laws of an exact Historian , yet this biass is so natural , that if it lessens the credit of the Writer , yet it does not blacken him , but if he has no regard either to truth or decency , if he gives his imagination a full scope to invent , and his pen all the liberties of foul language , he ought not to think it strange , if others take some pains to expose him to the World. And thô their Conscience and Religion obliges them to take other measures with relation to Truth , and their Breeding engages them to a strict modesty of Stile , yet if the things that are said are as severe as they are true , and as wounding as they may appear soft , it is nothing but what a Zeal for Truth , and an Indignation at so much ill-managed injustice draws from them . It is not to be denied that Mr. Varillas has an art of writing that is entertaining he pretends to discover many Secrets to give pictures of Men to the life , and to interweave the Histories that he relates with a thread of Politiques that is very agreable , only this appears to be overdone , and those who have had much practice in humane Affairs see that the conduct of the World is not so steady and so regular a thing as he loves to represent it , unlookt for Accidents , the caprices of some Tempers , the secrets of Amours and Jealousies , with other particular Passions are the true sources of almost all that is transacted in the World ; even Interest it self does not always govern Mankind , but Humour and Passion have their turns , and oft times the largest share in humane affairs . So that I ever thought that his books had too much of the air of a Romance , and seemed too fine to be true . He does indeed now and then , to maintain his Reputation in his Reader 's mind , vouch some letter or narrative , but he neither tells whither it is in Print , or in Manuscript , or where he had it , and where others may find it : so this way of Citation looked suspitious , yet I could not easily take up such hard thoughts of him as to imagine , that all this was his own Invention : but being in Paris last Summer , I had the good fortune to become acquainted with some men of great probity , and that had particularly applied themselves to examine the History of France with great exactness ; they were of the Church of Rome , and seemed to have no other dislike at Mr. Varillas , but that which was occasioned by the liberty , that he had given himself , to writ his own Imaginations for true Histories they assured me there was no regard to be had to any thing that he writ , that he had gathered together many little stories , which he knit together as he pleased , and that without any good Authority : and they told me that the greatest number of the pieces he cited were to be found now here but in his own fancy . In a word , they spoke of all his books with a sharpness of stile , and a degree of contempt , that I will not repeat , least I seem to come too near his forms of speech , which are the worst Patterns that one can follow . I found he was generally so much decried in Paris , that he has reason to say in his Preface , that when the Archbishop of Paris thought on him , all the World had abandoned him , for I did not find any Man under a more universal Contempt than he was , and the esteem in which his Works were held in Forreign Parts far beyond what was paied them in France , was imputed to his Method of Writing , that wants none of the beauties of History except that of Truth , and to the Ignorance in which Strangers live as to the Particulars of their History . It is true , at last he has found a Patron and a Pension , and now he has given us an Essay of his Merits ; but if this Work is examined severely , he will very probably soon lose his appointments ; since mercenary Pens are seldom paied longer than they can be useful . Here one finds so much occasion for censure , that whereas in other Books one must run up and down to find matter for a Critical Judgment , here it occurs so copiously that a Man must take care not to surfeit his Reader with too much of it ; and therefore must choose out the more remarkable Errours and there are even so many of these , that it is to be feared that the World will not think him not his Writings worth the time and the pains that must be bestowed on them . Mr. Maimbourg has set a Pattern to the World , that thô few wil care to imitate , yet it has taken so much with the present Age , that it is no light indication of its degeneracy , when surch books are so much read and sold , in which the Writer seems to have so broken loose from all the common measures either of honesty or shame , that one would wonder of what composition he were made , if they did not know that he has lived 50 ▪ years the in Iesuite Order : for as he has no regard to truth , or likelyhood in what he writs , so he seems to be proof against the evidentest discoveries of his prevarications that are possible ; and when they are laid open in a manner capable of making any man besides himself to blush , he neither has the conscience to confess his errours , nor the sense of honour to justify himself : but he finds out still new matter to writ on , and a new stock of Champaigne wine , as I have been told , that he has oft said , to make his blood boil till he has spoild an other piece of History ; and he thinks a scornfull period or two in a Preface is enough to carry off all the shame to which his errours ought to condemn him . He has also the Impudence to dedicate his books to the King , and the world is still willing to be cosened by him . This trade has succeeded so well with him , that it seems Mr. Varillas vies with him in it , and as he has the chaster stile , and the more natural way of misleading his Reader , so he has resolved not to be behind him in a bold quality that I love not to set down by its proper Name . But thô Mr. Varillas has the art to refine upon the pattern that Mr. Maimbourg set him , yet Mr. Maimbourg is the Author of the Invention , and therefore he deserves the better Pension . History is a sort of Trade in which false Coyn and false Weights are more criminal than in other Matters ; because the Errour may go further and run longer : thô these Authors colour their copper too slightly to make it keep its credit long . If Men think there are degrees of Lying , then certainly those that are the most loudly told , that wound the deepest , that are told with the best grace , and that are transmitted to Posterity under the deceitful colours of Truth , have the blackest Guilt ; but some Men have arrived at equal degrees in hardning their Consciences and in steeling their Forheads , and are without the reach either of inward Remorses or publick Discoveries ; so that as Augustus fancied there was a charm in the Pillour of a Roman , that died hugely indebted , since without an extraordinary saporiferous composition he could not fancy how such a Man could sleep securely ; so if humane Nature did not often produce some very irregular Individuals , a Man that feels the Authority that Truth and Modesty have ever a pure mind , can not easily imagine by what secret others can quite extinguish those Inclinations which he finds are so prevalent in himself . But I will now by Mr. Varillas's leave take the liberty to set before him some of his most conspicuous errours , and thô I do not expect much sincerity from himself , yet I hope the world will be juster than he has shewed himself to be . Mr. Varillas begins his History with a view of the progress of that which he calls Heresy , in a Prophetick stile , setting , forth what effects it was to produce , as if he were foretelling what was to fall out , and that for 11. pages ( according to the Impression of Amsterdam ) this has so little of the air of a Historian , and is so full of the figures of a Declaimer , that it looks liker the strain of a heated and angry Fryer , than of a grave and serious Writer of History , who ought to be always in cold blood , and ought not to let the heats of a vitious Rhetorick transport him . But this is so like one of the forced raptures of some Missionary , that one would think it was writ either by one of them , or for one of them . It is much a safer thing to prophecy concerning matters that are past , than concerning those that are to come , and one is less in danger of committing errours ; yet when heat enters into matters of History , and meets with so vast a deal of Ignorance as is that of Mr. Varillas , no wonder if it carries him into great errours . If Mr. Varillas had gathered the History of the last Age out of any Books or out of those Letters tha● he so often vouches , he could not have said that Edward th● 6th's Tutor or Governour was the Duke of Northumberland , since there is not any one Book writ concerning that Time , that does not shew the contrary . The Duke of Somerset was his Governour , and for the Duke of Northumberland , thô the last two Years of that Reign , in which that King was past the Age of Tutelage , he bore the chief sway of affairs , yet he had neither the Character of the King's Tutor or Governour , nor any other whatsoever , but only that of a Privy Councellour , that was much considered by him , and he at his Death professed that he had been always a Catholick in his Heart , so that his pretending to be of the Reformed Religion to serve his interests , shews that he belongs no more to our Church , than the now forced Converts belong to that of Rome . In the same page he says that Mary Queen of Scotland did by her Bastard Brother's persuasions marry a single Gentleman , and on the Margent he gives his Name Henry d' Arley ; this is a new proof how little he knows the Books of the last Age. This Henry whom he calls d' Arley was Henry Lord Darly , eldest Son to the Earl of Lenox , which was one of the chief Families of Scotland , and a Branch of the Family of the Stewarts . It is true it came off from it before the Crown came into it by Mariage , yet the Grandfather of this Henry had matched with one that was very near the Crown , and Cosen German to K. Iames the 4th's and Sister to Hamilton Earl ; of , Aran this Lord Darly's Mother was also Uterine Sister to K. Iames the 5. being the Daughter to the Queen Dowager of Scotland that was K. Henry the 8th's Sister , who by her second mariage with the Earl of Angus ( Dowglass ) had Lady Isabel Dowglass , who was bred in the Court of England , and whom K. Henry the 8. maried to the Earl of Lennox , that had by her this Lord Darly , who as he was the Queen of Scotland's Cosin German , was also the next Heir to the Crown of England after her , and might have been a dangerous Competitour to her in that Succession , having been born and bred in England , so that this mariage was so far from making her contemptible to her Subjects , that it was considered as the wisest act of her life : and Mr. Var. could not Imagine any thing more honourable to the Earl of Morny's memory , than to make him the adviser of so wise a choice . It is no wonder to see Mr. Var. make so bold with meaner persons , when he takes so much liberty wiht the Royal Family of England , as to stain their descent , for which if the consideration of the Crowns they wear , did not restrain him , yet the particular regard to the King that now reigns , ought to have taught him so much respect as not to have ventured to blot his Scutcheon so far as to call his Great Grandfather a single Gentleman and if he had payd the respect he owed to the Memory of that unfortunate Princess , he had no● enlarged so much on her Story , but I know what is due to the Memory of a crowned Head , even when it is laid in ashes , and thô he makes an easy weakness to be her prevailing Character , upon which he would discharge all her Misfortunes , this Picture is so different from the Truth that she was certainly one of the wittiest and highest spirited Women that ever lived . But it seems Mr. Varillas has pretended to some Pension from the Crown of England , and in revenge for the disappointment he has resolved to debase the Race all he can . Here he affords our Kings the honour to be descended at least from a Gentleman , thô one of the ordin ariest sort ; but upon another occasion he is not so liberal , for in his History he says that Henry the 8th had reasons to desire the mariage of his Bastard Son the Duke of Richmond with his Daughter Mary , that were too well known , for libels had been spread over all Europe , reproaching him that his Great Grandfather was not a Gentleman , but that by his credit at Court , and by the vast riches that he had acquired , he had obtained leave to marry a Daughter of the Family of the Plantaganets , that was then 16. degrees distant from the Crown , and yet by that means his Grand-child came to reign ; upon which he makes a long speculation concerning the King's Reflections on that matter , and the reasons that restrained him from writing on that subject , as if it were an ordinary thing for Princes to become their own Heralds . He also tells us how he comforted himself by the remembrance of the meanness of Arbaces K. of Persia , that was the Son of a Locksmith , whose Posterity had reigned so long , and with so much glory , and therefore he says he designed to marry his Natural Son and his Daughter together . Here is such a mixture of Impertinencies , that it is not easy to know at what one is to begin , and if there were but this one period , it is enough to let the World see , how incapable Mr. Varillas is of writing History . I shall not in this place shew the falsehood of that Imputation on Henry the 8th , that he designed this incestuous Match , for that will come in more property upon another occasion ; only if his Birth was defective on his Great Grandfathers side , it was an odd method for the correcting of it , to think of adding a new blot , and of bringing a Bastard into the 5th Succession ; so the reason is as foolish as the matter of fact is false , and the Ignorance that Mr. Var. shews here is the more remarkable , because this matter belongs to the most extraordinary transaction that is in the whole French History , in which he pretends to be so conversant . I need not say any more to prove the Tudors to be Gentlemen , but to tell that they are Welshmen , of the Race of the Ancient Britons , who do all pretend to the highest Birth of any in the English Nation , and do run up their Pedigrees to Iulius Cesar's time ; among whom is the Race of the the Ap Theodore's or the Sons of Theodore , that by a corruption of some Ages were called Tudors : but knows Mr. Varillas so little of the French History , as to have forgot that the Daughter of France , that was maried to Henry the 5th of England , in whose right both Henry the 5th , and her son Henry the sixth were crowned Kings of France in Paris , did after King Henry the 5th's death marry Owen Tudor , by whom she had 3. Sons the two eldest were made the Earls of Richmont and Pembroke , being the Kings Uterine Brothers , and the next heirs to that Title , that he claimed to the Crown of France , in the right of his Mother ( which I am far from thinking was a good one . ) This being the case , it was no extraordinary thing for a man of the Earl of Richmont's rank to marry a Lady that was then at such a distance from the Crown , thô it was only in the 6th and not the 16th degree ; but I do not insist on this , because it may be only the fault of the Printer , and I will not descend to a doubtful fault , when I have such material ones in my way . I know there are a sort of men that are much more ashamed when their Ignorance is discovered , than when their other vices are laid open , since degenerate minds are more jealous of the reputation of their understanding , than of their honour . And as Mr. Varillas is very like to be of this temper , so if a simpathy with Mr. Maimbourg has not wrought him up to the like pitch of assurance ▪ such discoveries as these ought to affect him a little ; and here a man is apt to lose his patience , when he finds such a Scribler pretend to defame the Noblest blood in the world . There is nothing else in the first Prophetick Rhapsody that relates to our matters , so I was inclined to go from hence to a more particular enquiry into our English affairs , only the Ignorance that he discovers in the next paragraph is so surprising that I will bestow a short remark on it . He says , that the Switzers were so prevailed on by this pretext , that their separating themselves from the Roman Communion was the best expedient to preserve them from falling under the Dominion of the House of Austria ( thô it is certain they were then in no sort of fear of that ) that the four chief Cantons were seduced in less than a years time ; but that the seven little Cantons continued in the belief of their Fathers , and the two midle sised Cantons tollerated equally both the Religions . One would have thought that a man that had pretended to the name of a Historian , would have at least begun his studies with some small tast of Cosmography , and would have taken some pains to know the Map ; and as the Switzers are in the neighbourhood of France , so they have been so long the Allies of that Crown , that the Ignorance of the Importance of the Cantons is a fault in one that pretends to be such an illuminated Historian , that deserves a worse correction than I think fit to give it . To reckon Basle and Shaff housen among the great Cantons , and Lucern among the small Cantons , Solohern and Fribourg being also so considerable that some reckon them with the great Cantons ; and to put Glaris and Appeuzel in a superiour order to them that are among the smallest of the least is such a Complication of errours that it is not easy to imagine how he had the luck to fetch in so many into one period . But this is not all the Ignorance that is in it ; for whereas he pretends , that the four Cantons , that received the Reformation did it in less than a year , this is so false that Zwinglius having begun to preach the Reformation in the year 1519. the whole matter was examined in a course of several years , and at last Zurich received the Reformation in the year 1525. Bern three years after in the year 1528. and Basle a year after in the year 1529. as for Schaff house I must confess my Ignorance , but there was at least 10 years interval in this matter ; and if Lucern is not so much in his favour , because it is the Residence of the Spanish Ambassadour , yet I cannot imagine what has made him degrade Solohern into the number of the small Cantons , which is the Residence of the French Ambassadour , and is reckoned by many among the greater . But it is likely that he knew nothing of all this matter , except by report , and perhaps he thought the period would run smoother to range the Cantons thus in the great , in the small , and the midle-sised Cantons , and that it would also reflect on the Reformation as a precipitated change to say that 4 Cantons turnd in one year . But thô Impertinence is a fault scarce to be named , when one has so many of a more criminal nature in his way , yet such as are more signal and more advantageously situated for the Reader 's eye deserve to be viewed in our passage , with the scorn that they deserve . Mr. Varillas begins his 3. book which opens the progress of Luther's affairs with a Preamble of 38. pages , in which he sets out the state of Europe at that time , so copiously and with so little judgement , that he bestows 14. pages on the Conquests that Selim the Turk had made , and on his defeat of the Mamelucks . This whole tedious ramble signifies nothing to Luther's matters ; but in short it was a secret to swell the Volume , and to raise the price of the book , as well as it must lessen the price of the Author , who shews , how little he understands where he ought to place his digressions . What notions does that view of every State of Europe give the world , that doe any way prepare the Readers mind ; for what was to come after , unless it be that Mr. Var. being to present a piece of as arrant Poëtry as any that ever possessed the Stage , he thought it necessary to fill it at first with many Actors , and to make a great appearance , thô none of them were to act any part in his Play ? But since he will needs be writing , thô he understands not the common-Elements , I will take the pains for once to instruct him a little how he ought to have made this introduction , since he it seems was resolved to begin with one . He ought then to have open'd the State of Europe with Relation to Religion and Learning ; he to have shewed what scandals the Popes and the Court of Rome had given , what was the State of the secular Clergy , the Ignorance , Irregularity , and vices of the Bishops , and Curates ; what were the ●isorders and dissolutions of the Monastick Orders , both of those that were endowed and of the Mendicants . He ought to have shewed in what sort of Studies they imploied their time , and with what sort of Sermons they entertained the People : and to this he ought to have added somewhat of the State of the Universities of Europe ; and of the beginnings of Learning that were then arising . He ought to have shewed the different Interests , in which the several Nations of Europe were engaged , after the times of the Councils of Constance and Basle ; and to this he might have added the State of the Courts of Europe with Relation to Religion , upon all which he might have found matter for a long , and a much more pertinent Introduction . And to conclude , he ought to have told the Dispositions , in which the Peoples minds were , as to those matters : and if he would needs make a vain shew of his faculty of telling of tales , he might have set out the State of the Eastern Churches , after the Treaty at the Council of Florence , and of its effects ; of the ruine of those Churches ; and of the Ignorance , as well as misery to which they were reduced by the rigour of the Mahometan yoke . It is true this was not a necessary preliminary to the bringing Luther on the Stage , but it had been much less impertinent , than a long recital of Sultan Selim's Conquests . But I am caried too far , and hereafter I will confine my self to that , which does more immediatly belong to me . He begins that part of his Advertisement , that relates to the affairs of England , with a sort of an Apophthegme worthy of him : he says , it is without comparison more difficult to be exactly true in matters of Religion , than in other matters ; since in those others , it is only Interest and Passion that make Men lie ; but in matters of Religion Conscience does so entirely conquer all the powers of the Soul , and reduces them to such a Slavery , that it forces a man to write , that which it dictates , without troubling himself to examine whither it is true or false . Here is such a view of his Notion of Religion , that how false soever this proposition is in it self , yet it gives us a true light of his Ideas of Religion . Good God shall that principle , which does elevate , and illuminate our natures , be considered as a more powerful depravation of them , than that which flows either from Interest or Passion ? shall that which is the Image of the God of Truth , and that reduces the Soul to a chast purity of Spirit , be made the Author of the enslaving of all our powers , and the emancipating us from all scrupulosity concerning truth or falsehood ? this perhaps is the character of Mr. Varillas's Religion , thô those that know him well assure me , that Religion makes very little impression on him ; and if that is true , then his Apophthegme fails in himself , since the Interest of a Pension , and the passion of making himself acceptable in the present time , have as entirely freed him from all regard to Truth , as ever any false Principle of Religion did an enraged Zealot . It is matter of horrour to see Religion , and Conscience set up as the violentest Corrupters of Truth : but we know out of what school this has sprung , and it seems Mr. Varillas has so devoted himself to the Order of the Jesuites , that he is resolved to speak aloud , that which they more prudently think fit to whisper in secret , and indeed if we may judge of him by this character , that he gives of Religion , we must conclude him to be entirely possessed with it , since never Man seem'd to be less solicitous , than he is , concerning the truth , or falsehood of the things , that hoavers . He accuses me of favouring my own side too much , and that if I confess some of King Henry's faults , it is only that I may have an occasion to excuse the wretched Cranmer . This is some Intimation , as if he had read my Book , but I doe not believe he has done it : for thô I have no great opinion either of his Vertue , or of his Understanding ; yet I doe not think , he is so forsaken of common-sense , and of all regard to his reputation , as to have adventured to have advanced so many notorious falsehoods , if he had seen upon what Authentical grounds I had so exposed them , that I doe not think it possible even for Mr. Maimbourg himself after all his 50 years Noviciat , to arrive at a confidence able to maintain them any longer , if he had once read my Book , and what I had writ was at least so important , that he ought to have weakned the credit of my History , by some more evident proofs , than that of saying barely , that I was extreamly partial to my own side . My book was so much read , and so favourably spoken of in France these three Years past , that in common decency he ought to have alledged somewhat , to have justified his Censure ; but this manner of writing was more easy , as well as more imperious . And if a large Volume of History supported with the most Authentick proofs , that has ever yet perhaps accompanied any Book of that sort , is to be thus shaken off , it is a vain thing to write Books for Men of Mr. Varillas's temper . This had been more pertinent , if he had voucht for it a report , which was so spread over Paris , that I had received advices of it from several hands , of a design in which , as was reported , a Clergy-man was engaged that has many excellent qualities , to which Mr. Varillas seems to be a great Stranger , for he has both great application , and much sincerity . He has searcht with great exactness that vast Collection of Mss. that relate to the last Age , which are laid up in the King's Library , and he had found so many things relating to England , that he intended to publish a Volume of Memoires relating to our Affairs : he had also said , that in some things he would enlarge himself more copiously than I had done , and that in other things he must differ from me . Matters generally grow bigger by being oft told , so this was given out as a design to write a Counter-History , which should overthrow all the credit that my Work had got . But upon my coming to Paris , I found some sincere enquirers into truth , and who by consequence are Men that have no value for Mr. Varillas , who intended to bring us together that we might in an amicable manner reason the matter be foresome of our common Friends ▪ and both of us seemed to be so well disposed to sacrifice all to truth , that two Persons of such Eminence , that they can receive no honour by the most advantageous Characters that I can give them , who were Mr. Thevenot and Mr. Auzont , did procure us a meeting in the King's Library , and in their presence . In which the Abbot as he discovered a vast memory , great exactness and much sincerity , so he confessed that he had no exceptions to the main parts of my History ; he mentioned some things of less moment , in all which I gave not only our two learned Arbiters , but even himself full satisfaction , so that I quickly perceived I had to doe with a man of honour . He insisted most on the judgment of the Sorbonne against K. Henry's Mariage , which is not in their Registers . But I was certainly informed by a Dr. of the Sorbonne that their Registers are extreamly defective , and that many of their Books are lost . He alledged a letter to K. Henry that he had seen , telling him , that it was to be feared that he might be displeased with the decision of the Sorbonne , and that it might doe him more hurt than good , which Letter bearing s after the decision that I have printed , does not seem to agree with it . To this I answered , that all the other decisions of Universities being given simply in the King's favours , and that of the Sorbonne bearing only , that the Majority had declared for him , this left ablot upon the matter , since when the opposition is inconsiderable , decisions are given in the Name of the whole Body ; but the mention of the Majority imported , that there was a great opposition made , which , thô it was not supported by a number equal to the other , yet was so considerable , as to lessen very much the credit of the Decision . To this I added , that K. Henry's printing this the Year after it was given , and none ever accusing that piece of Forgery , Card. Pool on the contrary acknowledging that he was in Paris when it was obtained , these were undeniable Evidences of its genuinness , to which he answered by a hearty acknowledgment , that he had seen another Letter , in which the detail of the whole Proceeding of the Sorbonne is set down ; and , as I remember , there were but one or two more than the Majority , that opined on the King's side ; but the rest were in different Classes . Some suspended their opinions : others , thô they condemned the Mariage , yet did not think it could be broken , since it was once made : and some were positively of the Pope's side . In end , after some hours discours , in which all the Company was fully satisfied with the Answers that I gave , he concluded , that as he had seen many more Letters relating to that matter than I had done , so if I thought fit , he would furnish me with a Volume of Authentical proofs for what I had writ , greater than that which I had already printed . And these were the Letters of the French Ambassadours , that were in King Henry the 8th's Court , that are in the King's Library ; but I did not stay long enough in Paris to procure this . Now what those Letters of Cardinal Bellays are , upon which Mr. Varillas pretends to found his Relation , I cannot imagine . For as he came not to act in this matter till the last step of it ; so his Letters cannot carry any long Series of this affair in them , and they must be far from giving those long excursions , into which Mr. Varillas always delights to wonder . And , as I remember , I was in particular told , that those Letters were in the King's Library , and so , since all that was there , agreed with my History , this must pass among those hardy Citations of Authors , that Mr. Varillas is apt to make , to give credit to his Inventions . He flourishes a little to shew some small reading , but he is as unhappy in that , as in other things . He mentions Cambden , as having writ the History of that Revolution with some more moderation , than he is pleased to allow me ; but he says , he does so constantly favour the Calvinists , in prejudice of those that he calls Catholicks , that one needs only read the first page , that turns up to him , in any part of his History , to be convinced of it . This is a very good proof that Mr. Varillas never opened any one page of Cambden ; Since he does not write of that Revolution . For he begins his History with Q. Elisabeth's Reign , and says no more of what went before her time , than what amounts to a very short hint of her Birth and Education , and a general Introduction into her Reign ; and that History is writ with so much judgment and impartiality , that as it acquired the Author the friendship and esteem of that eminent Historian Mr. du Thou ; so he after Cambden's Death published the second Volume , from the Manuscript that the Author had sent him . If the discovery of a great many Rebellions and Conspiracies against the Person of that famous Queen is that , which disgusts Mr. Varillas at that History , it is because his Religion has so enslaved his Conscience , that he is so little concerned in Truth or Falsehood , as not to be able to endure one of the gravest Writers , that this Age has produced , because he could not avoid the Recital of those many Crimes , that some of the Men of Mr. Varillas's principles as to Religion were not afraid to commit . After this he mentions another of our Historians , whom he calls Dr. Morton , and to make his Reader know that he is acquainted with the History of his Life , he tells us he was afterwards a Bishop ; but this is one of the Authors of his invention , for thô we had a Doctor Morton , that was Bishop of Durham , and that died about 30 years ago ; yet he writ no History . By the Character that Mr. Varillas gives this pretended Author , that he was more moderate than Cambden , I fancy he is mistaken in the Name , and that he would say Dr. Heylin , thô this Name and Morton have no affinity ; but Heylin was no Bishop : it is true , Dr. Heylin has writ so moderately , that some have been severe upon him for it ; but I will make no other Reflections on this , unless it be to shew the slightness of Mr. Varillas's way of writing , who it is likely had heard one talk at the same time both concerning Dr. Morton and Dr. Heylin , and he in his assuming way , pretends upon this to give a Character of that History , putting the Name Morton for Heylin ; but he never read a Word of Dr. Heylin , thô in his daring way , he pretends to give his Character ; and repents himself of the praise of Moderation that he had given in preference to Cambden , and sets it out as an artifice , since whereas Cambden blames always the pretended Catholicks without any mitigations , Morton in blaming them counterfeits some pity for them , that is to say , he had some degrees of Mr. Varillas's Character of Religion . But Dr. Heylin's History being writ only in English , and it having never been translated either into Latin or French , Mr. Varillas cannot give a Character of it from his own knowledg . From our side he goes to the Writers of the Roman side , and begins with another essay of his exactness to his principles of Religion . For he says , Sanders writ so violently , that it vvas no vvonder if the Protestants caried their revenge so far , as to force him to die of hunger , in the Mountains of the North of England , to vvhich he had retired . Here are only three capital Errours : for 1. Sanders's Book , concerning the English Schisme , vvas not published till after his Death , so that this could give no occasion for so severe a revenge . 2. Sanders did not die in the North of England , but in Ireland . 3. Sanders vvas sent over by the Pope to raise and conduct a Rebellion in Ireland , for vvhich he had immediate povvers from the Pope . He was so active , that he brought an Army together , which was defeated by the Queen's Forces : and upon that he fled into a Wood , where he was , some days after , found dead . So that having received no Wounds , it was believed he died of Hunger . This being the state of that affair , as it is related of all sides , is not Mr. Varillas a very creditable Author , who has the brow to report it as he does ? For the Character that he gives of Ribadeneira , it is so embroiled , that I do not think it worth the vvhile to examine it . It is enough to say that Ribadeneira is a Jesuite , that is to say , a Man true to Mr. Varillas his Character of Religion , and his History is nothing but Sanders drest up in another Method . I speak of that which is in Latin , for the Spanish , I have never seen it . For Lesley he is generally a grave and wise Writer , but Mr. Varillas names him , because some body had told him , that one of such a name had writ of those matters , otherwise he had never cited him with relation to English Affairs , which he scarce ever mentions , but as they happned to be intermixt with the Scotsh . In conclusion , Mr. Varillas pretends to depend upon Cardinal Bellay's Letters , and so he thinks here is enough to settle , in the spirit of his Reader , a firm beleef of all that he intends to write ; but let him tell the World where they are to be found , since the printed Volume contains nothing of the matters , that he pretends to cite from him . And since I have printed so many of the Original Letters of that Time , and have told the Reader where they are to be found , I will expect the like from him , otherwise let him cite them as long as he will , I will take the liberty to tell him that I do not believe him . And I think , that by this time I have given him sufficient reasons for excusing my Incredulity , in matters that he gives us upon his own word . Here is enough for a preliminary . But I am affraid I grow heavy to my Reader ; and that by this time he is so fully satisfied concerning the principles both of Mr. Varillas's Religion , and his morals , that he begins to lose patience , when he sees how far I am like to carry him in a more copious discovery . But there are a sort of men , that must be severely repressed : and there are some times , in which even a fool is to be answered according to his folly . Yet I will so far manage my Reader , as not to overcharge him too much : therefore as to many of those Political digressions , that Mr. Var. makes upon the Interest of England , France and Spain , I will pass them quite over , as the whipped cream that he sets before his Reader . Some of them are not unpleasant , if they were proposed as considerations , which might perhaps have had their weight : but his averring them confidently is not to be excused , they might pass in a kind of a Book of Politicks as a refining upon the actions of Princes ; but this way of writing is by no means to be allowed in History , since it is without any sort of evidence , and History ought to relate things as we find they really were designed , and transacted ; and not as we imagine they ought or might have been . I am now entring upon a subject , in which it will be much more easy for me to say too much , than too little : for Mr. Varillas commits so many Errours , that thô I am resolved to let lesser matters pass unregarded , yet I find so many in my way , which require a discovery , that I am engaged in a task as ingrateful to my self , as it must be severe upon him . 1. He begins with an assurance , that all the rest of Wiclef's Heresy were so entirely rooted out of England , that the whole Nation , without excepting one single Person , was of the same Religion during the Reign of Henry the 7th . I am not now near the Records of that time , but in my History I have shewed by the Records of K. Henry the 8th's Reign , that in the year 1511. which was but two years after Henry the 7th's Death , there remain yet in the Registers of the See of Canterbury the Processes of 41 Persons , of whom 7 were condemned for Hereticks , and delivered to the Secular Arm , and the rest had the weakness to abjure : and from this hint one must conclude , that Mr. Varillas had no knowledg of our Affairs ; but he thought the Period was rounder , and the air of writing was more assuming , when he asserted that the whole Nation , without excepting one single Person , was of the same Religion . The Opinions , objected to those Persons , shew , that the Reformation found a disposition in the Nation , to receive it by the Doctrines which were entertained by many in it : For the chief of them are , that the Sacrement of the Altar was not Christ's Body , but material Bread : That Images ought not to be worshipped : That Pilgrimages were neither necessary nor profitable : and that we ought not to address our Prayers to Saints , but only to God. But since this may be thought only a flourish of Mr. Varillas's Pen , I go to other matters , in which it cannot be denied that a greater exactness was necessary . 2. He lays down for a foundation to all that was to come after , that P. Arthur was very unhealthy , when he was married . That he was recovering out of a great Disease , of which he died 5 Months after . It is true , he does acknowledg , that three Words in the Bull , that was granted for the subsequent Marriage , seem to import , that this Marriage was consummated : yet he takes the Word of the other Historians , and repeats this of P. Arthur's ill Health so often , that he hoped , it seems , by that means to make his Reader swallow it down easily . Here he had writ a little more artificially , if he had set over against this , on the Margent some citation of a Letter , or Recital , vvhich vvould have cost him nothing , and have been full as true , as his other citations are . Many Witnesses that vvere examined upon Oath , deposed before the Legates , vvhen this matter vvas examined , that P. Arthur vvas of a good Complexion , vigorous and robust , when he vvas married ; that he bedded vvith his Princess every night : and the Decay of vvhich he died , vvas ascribed to his too early Mariage . And of this Mr. Varillas takes some notice , vvithout reflecting on the consequence , that the Reader might naturally draw from it ; for he says , K. Henry the 7th delayed the marrying of his second Son 6 years after he had obtained the Bull , and that the Death of his eldest Son made him apprehend the loss of his second Son ; if he married him so young . And thô he intervveaves a Politick reflection , according to his vvay , that is to say impertinently , and says , if this fear vvas not altogether just ; yet since K. Henry the 7th had no other Son , it vvas not altogether unreasonable . But it is obvious that this is altogether impertinent , if P. Arthur's Mariage vvent no further than a publick Ceremony . But there are other circumstances that overthrovv this , as much as a thing that is of its nature secret , is capable of being disproved . It is said by our Historians , who writ at that time , that the Spanish Ambassadour took proofs of the consummation of the Mariage . And in the Bull of dispensation , for the subsequent Mariage , this was also supposed as a thing that was perhaps done . But thô our Author set on the Margent the precise Words , in which he says that was conceived ; yet either he never read the Bull , and so took this upon trust , or he was in a fit of his Religion , which was so violent , that it made him not only take no care of what he said , whither it was true or false ; but made him advance a deliberate falsehood . For whereas in the Preamble of the Bull of Dispensation for the younger Brother , it is set forth , that P. Arthur and the Princess had been lawfully married , and had perhaps consummated their Mariage , where the matter of fact is set down in a dubious manner , he makes that the Dispensation had allowed their Mariage , even thô the former had been consummated . And as the Words that he cites are not the Words of the Bull , so they give a different notion of the matter ; since as he gives the Words , they seem only to be a clause put in , to make the Bull more unquestionable ; whereas in truth they are a part of the matter of fact represented to the Pope . And thô this doubtful way of representing this matter of fact , that is in the Bull , was all that could be decently said upon this case , yet it seems the Spaniards , who knew the Mariage was consummated , resolved to set the matter past dispute , for they either procured at that time a Breve , of the same date with the Bull , or they forged one afterwards , in which in the Preamble this matter is asserted , without any perhaps , or other limiting Word , it being positively set forth , that the Mariage was consummated . If Mr. Varillas's Religion sets him at liberty from the scrupulosity of writing truth , yet that profound Policy , to which he always pretends , should oblige him to take a little care , that the falsehoods that he advances , may not be easily discovered . 3. He says , Henry the 8th was 12. year old , when his Brother died ; and that his Father had designed him for the Ecclesiastical State. This was taken up by the Writers of the last Age , to make the Parallel between Iulian the Emperour and him seem to agree : that as Iulian had been a Reader in the Church ; so King Henry should be represented as an Abbot with a little band . But as King Henry was not 12 year old , when his Brother died , for he wanted some Months of 11 : and as at that Age young Princes , considering the respect that is payed to them in their Education , have seldome been found far advanced in Learning ; so it does not appear , that he had then any other Education different from what was given his Brother , who understood Latin , and some of the beginnings of Learning . Learning was then in great reputation , and K. Henry the 7th engaged his Children to study , either to raise their Authority the higher by that means , or perhaps to amuse them with Learning , that they might not think of pretending to the Crown during his Life , since the undoubted Title to it resting in the Person of their Mother , it had devolved upon them by her Death , thô they did not think fit to claim their Right . 4. He says , that when K. Henry the 7th intended to marry his younger Son to P. Arthur's Widdow , the Privy Council of England approuved it the more easily , because of the precaution that had been taken to hinder the consummation of the former Mariage : and to confirm this , he cites on the Margent the Petition , that the Parliament of England offered upon this matter to P. Alexander the 6th . But as the Depositions are yet extant of the Duke of Norfolk , that was then a Privy Councellour , and of two others , that there was no precaution used to hinder the consummation ; so Warham , that was at that time Archbishop of Canterbury , opposed the second Mariage , as being neither honourable , nor well-pleasing to God , as he himself did afterwards depose upon Oath . The Parliament took no cognisance of the matter , nor did it make any address to the Pope ; so that this citation is to be considered as an effect of Mr ▪ Varillas his notion of Religion . 5. He runs out , in his manner , into a long speculation concerning the different interests of England and Spain , that made the Spaniards go backwards and forwards , in the agreeing to the Match , that was proposed for P. Henry and the Princess ; whom by an extravagant affectation he calls always Duke of York : and makes the Princesse's Parents represent to K. Henry the 7th , the danger of his Son 's growing weary of the Princess , since he was 4 year younger than she was , and that in order to the procuring of a dissolution of the Mariage from the Court of Rome , he might pretend that his Father had forced him to marry her , whenever he should grow weary of her . All the other Writers of that time put K. Henry the 7th's desiring this second Mariage meerly on his covetousness , which made him equally unwilling to repay the Portion , or to send a great jointure yearly after the Princess : and the Prince of Wales was too great a Match to be so uneasily admitted by the King and Queen of Spain . He whom he calls by the Title of the Duke of York , was indeed only Duke of York , for some Months after his Brother's Death , during which time it was supposed , that the Princess might be with child by his Brother ; which proves beyond exception , that it was believed , that the first Mariage was consummated . But when there was no more reason to apprehend that , then he carried the Title , that belongs to the Heir apparent of our Crown . But it seems the King and Queen of Spain were more easily satisfied in this matter , than Mr. Varillas would make us believe they were : for two years after the Bull was granted , when P. Henry came to be of Age , he instead of entring into any engagement to marry the Princess , made a solemn protestation in the hands of the Bishop of Winchester , by which he recalled the consent that he had given during his Minority , and declared that he would never marry her . But it is very likely Mr. Varillas had never heard of this , thô the instrument of that Protestation was not only mentioned , but printed by many of the Writers of that Age : and it is confessed by Sanders himself , who , after all Mr. Varillas's flourish with his Letters , is his only Author . And for this foresight , that he thinks he may justly ascribe to the King and Queen of Spain , because they are represented by the Writers of that time , to have had an extraordinary Sagacity , the reason that he makes them give , shews it was a contrivance of his own : since a moral force , such as the Authority of a Father , was never so much as pretended to be a just ground to annul a Mariage , after it was made and consummated ; otherwise most of the Mariages that have been made , might have been dissolved . 6. He adds to this another speculation , that is worthy of him , he pretends that the King and Queen of Spain apprehended , that K. Henry the 7th had acquired the Crown of England , and by consequence had a right to dispose of it at his pleasure ; upon which the Crown of Spain was afraid , least he should have disinherited his Son , and given the Crown to the Duke of Suffolk , that was then at Brussels , and was preparing an Invasion of England , from which they did not know , but K. Henry the 7th might save himself , by declaring Suffolk his Successour , and that upon those fears they were unwilling to consent to the Match . Here is such a mixture of Follies , that it is not easy to tell which of them is the most remarkable . This Doctrine of the Crown of England's being alienable at the King's pleasure , might have passed well with those , that some years ago thought to have shut out the next Heir , and yet even these did not pretend that it could have been done by the King alone . But here is a new Theory of Politicks , for which we are sure Mr. Varillas can cite no Authorities from the Laws and Constitutions of England . K. Henry the 7th had indeed acquired the Crown , by defeating that Tyrant and Usurper Richard the 3 d : but as he pretended to be Heir of the Lancastrian Race himself , so by marrying to the Heir of the House of York , that was the right Heir , he by a conjunction of all Titles , made the matter sure . But this gave him no right to alienate the Crown at his pleasure , and to fancy , that a King might be induced to give away his Crown from his own Son , to the Person in the World that he hated most , and whom at his Death he ordered his Son never to forgive ; who , by the way , was not Duke but only Earl of Suffolk , is a Dream better becoming so slight a brain as is that of Mr. Varillas , than the consummated wisdome of the King and Queen of Spain . But thus it falls out when a Library Keeper turns Statesman ; and when from being a teller of tales , he will turn a Writer of Histories , which he composes out of his own Imaginations , he must needs fall into childish errours . When do Kings fall under those weaknesses , as to disinherit an only Son , to cover them from a remote fear : and a very remote one it was ; for the Archduke needed at that time the assistance of England against France too much , to be in a condition to raise a Civil War in England , and to support a competition to the Crown , which could have no other effect , as to him , but to give France an opportunity , during the distractions of England , to come and destroy him . In short , here is a Vision of a poor-spirited Pedant , which is too much considered , when it named and laught at . 7. He pretends to enter into the reasons that were alledged at Rome , both for and against the granting of the Bull ; but at last he concludes , that Pope Alexander the 6th would not consent to it ; that he might not give occasion to accuse him , of having broken the Discipline of the Church . But here is such a false representation of the Court of Rome at that time , and in particular of P. Alexander the 6th , that since Mr. Varillas will needs write Romances , I must put him in mind of one Rule ; that as Painters shew their Judgment and Learning , in that which is in one Word called le Costume , observing the Air , Manners , and Habits of the Ages and Scenes to which their Pieces belong ; so Poets , when they bring unknown Names into their Plays , they may clothe them with what Characters they please ; but if they represent Men , whose Histories are known , they must not confound Characters , nor represent a Nero as a grave Philosopher , or as a good natured Prince ; nor a Marcus Aurelius as a wanton Stage-player , or as a bloody Tyrant . And therefore , thô Mr. Varillas may shew his pretended discoveries , concerning Men that are less known , yet when he brings in an Alexander the 6th on the Stage , it is too bold a violation of Poetry , to lay a strictness of Conscience , or a sense of Honour to his charge : and thô there is one part of this Period true , that there had never been any dispensation of this sort formerly granted , to serve as a Precedent for it : yet that exactness , in which he represents the Enquiry , that the Divines of Rome made concerning this matter , agrees ill with the State of the Court of Rome at that time ; and a Painter may as justly represent the old Romans in Pantalaons , and with Hats in their hands . 8. He says , K. Henry the 7th was preparing all things for the Mariage of his Son , to the Princess , when he died . And a little before that he had said , that her Parents sacrificed the Interest of their Family to the satisfaction of the King of England , by consenting to it . A Match with the Heir of the Crown of England , was no very costly Sacrifice : and for his vision concerning the design of marrying her to the Duke of Calabria , and by that means of restoring the Kingdome of Naples , it does so ill agree with the Character of the King of Arragon , that since there is no proof brought of this , I must look on it as one of those Imaginations , with which Mr. Varillas loves to entertain his Readers . But for K. Henry the 7th , he was so far from making any preparations for the Mariage , that one of the Writers of that Age assures us , that at his Death he charged his Son to break it , apprehending perhaps a return of a new civil War , upon the issue of a doubtful Marriage . 9. He gives us a new tast of his unskilfulness in ordering his Scenes . He had found that when Henry the 8th's Divorce came to be started , there was some discourse of a Match between him and Francis the first 's Sister , afterwards the Queen of Navarre , and therefore he thought a proposition for her , might come in before the Mariage , as a pretty ornament to his Fable . But the silence of all the Papers of that Time , which I have seen , is a much better evidence against it , than his pretended negotiation of Mr. de Piennes is for it , to which no credit is due . It is well known that in the Archives of Venice there are Recitals laid up of all the Negotiations of their Ambassadours , and Mr. Varillas having perhaps heard of this , he fancied it would have a good grace , to cite such Recitals as to French Affairs , thô all that know the State of France , know , that this has not been the practice of that Court. But as there is no proof to shew that there was any such Proposition made at that Time , so the State of K. Lewis the 12th's Court differs extreamly from it , in which the Count of Angoulême , afterwards Francis the first , and his Sister , were not so favourable , as to give us reason to think that pains was taken to raise that Lady to the Throne of England . 10. He tells us , that King Henry the 8th calling a Parliament in the beginning of his Reign , they thought themselves bound in point of Honour , to oblige to execute his Father's Orders , relating to his Mariage ; who had not only made it the chief Article of his Testament , and charged his Son to do it upon his last Blessing ; but had laid the same charge on the Men of the greatest Credit in England , as he spoke his last Words to them : upon which the Parliament being careful to maintain this Authority , to which they pretended , over their Master , did oblige him , by repeated Remonstrances to marry the Princess . Here he goes to show how implacably he is set against the Crown of England : formerly he had debased their Birth , but he thought that was not enough ; now he will degrade them of their Dignity , and give the Parliament a Superiority over them . But it is a fatal thing for an ignorant Man to write History : for if Mr. Varillas could have so much as opened our Book of Statutes , he would have found , that the first Parliament , that K. Henry the 8th held , was assembled the 21. of Ianuary 1510. almost 8. Months after the Mariage , which was celebrated six Weeks after he came to the Crown , in which time , if Mr. Varillas had understood any thing of our Constitutions , he would have known , that it was impossible for a Parliament to have met , since there must be 40. Days between a Summonds and a Meeting of Parliament ; so that if the new King had summoned one , the Day after his Father's Death , it could not have met sooner , than the day before the Mariage . 11. He says , the Queen bore five Children , the first three , Sons , and the other two , Girls ; but the eldest Son lived only 9 Months , the other two Sons , and the eldest Girl , died immediately after they were born , only the youngest , that was born the 8 of February 1515 , was longer lived . Mr. Varillas has a peculiar talent of committing more Errours in one single Period , than any Writer of the Age : and here he has given a good essay of his art ; for the Queen bore only three Children , the first was a Son , born the 1. of Ianuary , that died the 22 of February thereafter , which was not two full Months , much less 9 Months : the second Son died not immediatly , but about a Fourtnight after he was born : and the Daughter , afterwards Q. Mary , was born the 9th of February 1516. So that thô by chance he has hit the Month right , yet he is mistaken , both as to the Year , and the Day of the Month. So unadvised a thing it is for an ignorant Writer , to deliver matters of fact so particularly : for thô this may deceive others , that are as ignorant as himself , by an appearance of exactness ; yet it lays him too open to those , that can find the leisure and the patience , to expose him : and the last is no easy matter . 12. He runs out into a very copious account of K. Henry's Disorders , and dresses up Q. Katherine's Devotions in a very sublime strain . It does not appear , that in all that time he had any other Mistress , but Elisabeth Blunt : and during all that while , he had the highest Panigyriques made him by all the Clergy of Europe , upon his Zeal for Religion and Piety ; possible so , that if we did not live in an Age , in which Flattery has broke loose from all the restraints of Decency , they would appear very extravagant Commendations ; and if the sublimities of Flattery were not rather a just prejudice against a Prince , which give a character of a swelled Ambition , and an imperious Tyranny , that must be courted by such abject methods , so that it is hard , whither we ought to think worse of the Flaterers , or the Flatered , we would be tempted to judge very advantageously of K. Henry the 8th , by the Dedications , and other fawning Addresses that were made him . As for Q. Katherine , it does appear , that she was indeed a vertuous and devout Woman ; but Mr. Varillas being more accustomed to Legends , than to true Histories , could not set out this , without a considerable addition of his own : for the half of it is not mentioned by any Author , that ever I saw , nor by any quoted by himself : but a Poët must adorn his matter , and if he has not judgment , he overdoes it . 13. He says , the King designed to marry his natural Son the Duke of Richmont , to his Daughter Mary ; upon which he makes that long digression , concerning the Names of the Race of Tudors , that was formerly considered . When a Man affirms a thing , that is so notoriously injurious to the Memory of a Prince , he ought at least to give some sort of proof of its truth : for thô in the accesses of Mr. Varillas's Religious Fits , he does not think fit to trouble himself with those inconsiderable matters of Truth and Falsehood ; yet all the World is not of his mind , and some colours of Truth are at least lookt for . It is true , a Negative is not easily proved , so a bold Affirmer fancies , he has some advantages ; but in this case it is quite otherwise , for the whole series of the Original Instructions , Messages and Letters , that passed between Rome and England , in that matter , are still extant , in all which there is not the least tittle , relating to this Proposition . And there are some things of such indecency , that nothing but a temper like Mr. Varillas's can bring them together . For when K. Henry was pretending a scruple of Conscience , at his own marrying his Brother's Wise , it is very improbable , that he would have asked a Dispensation for a Mariage in a much nearer Degree . For Sanders , that is Mr. Varillas's Author , says , that both Propositions were made at the same time . There were many Libels printed against K. Henry , about that time ; but the strongest , and the best writ , was that of Cardinal Pools , in which it is visible , that he spares nothing that he could alledg with any colour of Truth ; yet he says nothing of this matter , thô it had more weight in it to discover the King's Hypocrisy , in pretending to scruples of Conscience , than all the other things he alledges : and I never could find any other Author for this Story , before Sanders , whose Book was printed 60 years after . 14. He gives another essay of his skill in History , and that he is equally ignorant of the Histories of all Kingdomes , when he represents to us the endeavours of the King of Scotland , for the obtaining of a Mariage with the Princes Mary , in favours of his Son , upon whose Person he bestows a kind dash of his Pen , and he enters into a speculation of the danger , that King Henry apprehended from this Proposition ; and that if he had rejected it , the King and Prince of Scotland might have addressed themselves for it to the Parliament , and that the Parliament would have raised a general Rebellion , rather than have suffered King Henry to reject it . The dislike that Mr. Varillas has conceived against the Crown of England , seems deeply rooted in him ; for it returns very often . Here he represents forreign Princes complaining to Parliaments , when the Kings do not accept of Propositions for their Children ; as if our Princes were less at liberty in the disposal of their Children , than the meanest of their Subjects are : but he knows our Constitution as little as he does the History of Scotland , otherwise he could not have represented the King of Scotland , as pretending to the Mariage of the Princess Mary for his Son ; since K. Iames the fourth , that had married King Henry's Sister , was kill'd at the Battel of Floddun the 2 September 1513 , above three years before the Princess was born , he left an infant Son , between whom and the Princess a Treaty of a Mariage was once proposed , but no progress was made in it , for K. Henry neglected it . And he had always his Parliaments so subject to him , to apprehend any of those vain Schemes , with which Mr. Varillas would possess his Reader . There are many that make no great progress in History , but yet know somewhat of the Death of Kings , and that carry some small measure of Chronology in their Head. Yet since Mr. Varillas has not yet got so far , he had best buy some common Chronological Tables , and have them always before him , when he writes ; and this will at least preserve him from such childish Errours . 15. He tells us , that there were many Pretenders to the young Princess ; and to make a full Period , he tells us , that all the Souverains of Europe courted her , both the Emperour , the Kings of France , Spain and Scotland ; and so he gives us a fantastical speculation of King Henry's balancing those Propositions one against another . But since for a round Periods sake he will needs split Charles the 5th in two , and name both the Emperour and the K. of Spain as two Pretenders , he might have as well subdivided him into the King of Arragon and Castile , Sicily and Naples , and the very Titular Kingdome of Ierusalem , might have come in for its share . 16 He tells us that thô the match of Scotland was the most for the Interest of the Nation ; yet King Henry was so angry with his Nephew the King of Scotland , for taking part against him , in his last war with France , that he resolved never to give him his Daughter . Here Mr. Varillas will see again the necessity of purchasing a Chronological Table ; for thô that will cost him some money , which as I am told , goes very near his heart ; yet it will preserve him from some scurvy errours , they may spoil the sale of his books : for any one of those Tables , even the worst and cheepest , would have shewed him , that it was not his Nephew that took part with France against him ; but his Nephew's Father : for King Iames the 4th , that was King Henry's Brother-in-Law , made war on that occasion , and was killed in it , leaving an Infant Son behind him ; but it is pleasant to see the Ignorance of this Scribler , that makes in one place King Iames the 4th to court the Princess for his Son , thô he died several years before she was born , and then makes King Iames the 5th to be making war with his Uncle , during his Father's life , and while himself was an Infant . 17. He says , the Emperour came , and pretended the second to the Princess , and upon that he sets down a large negotiation , that he had with Cardinal Wolsey . But he shews here an ignorance of Charles the 5th's Life , thô he pretends to have made more than ordinary discoveries concerning his Affairs , that proves , that he has studied all History alike ill . He reckons up the series of the Propositions for the Princess quite wrong ; for she was first contracted to the Dolphin the 9 November 1518 , by a Treaty yet extant , then Charles the 5th came into England in Person , and contracted a Mariage with her at Windsor the 22 of Iune 1522 ; after that there was a Proposition made for the King of Scotland , that was soon let fall ; and last of all there was a Treaty set on foot , for the King of France then a Widdower , or for his second Son the Duke of Orleans , it being left to Francis's option to determine that : and so remarkable a passage , as Charles the 5th's coming to England in person , was unhappily unknown to Mr. Varillas ; otherwise he would have dressed up a mighty Scene of Politicks to adorn it . 18 He gives us the character and the History of Card. Wolsey , with his ordinary colours , in which truth comes very seldome in for an ingredient , he tells us how he was Bp. of Tournay , or rather Oeconome of that See , and how many journeys he made between Tournay and London ; and that he being enriched at Tournay , he got the Bishoprick of Lincoln , after that , upon the Bp. of Winchester's death , he had that See , from that he was raised to be Archbishop of York ; then he was made Chancellour of England , then Cardinal and Legat à Latere , and last of all , he was made Chief Minister of State ; and to shew our Author 's deep Judgment , this last Article seemed so doubtful a point to him , that he must needs bestow a proofe on it , and he sends us to P. Leo the 10th's Register , thô the advancements that he had already reckoned up , may well make this pass without a more particular Proof ; nor is P. Leo's Register a place likely to find it in . Here is a great deal to let his Reader see , how entirely he was possessed with the History of that time ; since he could run out so far with the Character and History of that Minister ; but for the strain , in which he sets out his Character , one must see , it is only Mr. Varillas's fancy : for how came he to know Cardinal Wolsey's air and manner of deportment , even in the smallest thing . I that have seen much more of him in his Letters , Dispatches and Instructions than Mr. Varillas can pretend to have done , dare not goe so far , because I have not arrived at Mr. Varillas his pitch of Religion ; but if his character is no truer than the History that he gives of Wolsey , I know what name is due to it . He was made Bishop of Tournay in October , and Bp. or Lincoln in the March thereafter , or rather in February , for the Temporalty was given him the 4th of March , which is always restored after the Consecration , so that here was not time enough to make such journies between Tournay and London , nor to enrich himself with the former : he had not Winchester but 15 years after that ; but he was made Archbishop of York two year after he had Lincoln ; he was also made Cardinal and Legate , before he was made Chancelour ; for Warham Archbishop of Canterbury was Chancelour while he was Legate , and had some disputes with him , touching his legative power ; upon which he obtained that Dignity , for puting an end to all disputes ; and in stead of his being last of all Minister of State , he was first of all Minister of State , while he was only the Lord Almoner , and all his other dignities came upon him , as the natural effects of that Confidence and favour into which the King had received him . 19. He cannot assent to some Historians , that imagine he was the Confident of K. Henry's Pleasures , since he thinks , if that had been true , he could not have been so cheated afterwards , as he was . Here is a Demonstration that he never read my History , into which I have put , besides other Evidences of his being on the secret of Anne Boleyn's matter , two letters , that she writ to him , which are undeniable proofs of it . But as for the long Story into with he runs out , concerning Charles the 5th's Intrigues with him , and his way of writing to him , in the stile of Son and Cousin , for which he cites on the Margent the Emperour's Letters to Wolsey , that lie in his fancy , that is the greatest Library in the World , but the hardest to be come at , all this is so loosely writ , that it is plain Mr. Varillas had no light to direct him in it , since he says not a word of the most important circumstance of it , which was the Emperour's coming in person to England , which was beleeved to have been done chiefly to gain Wolsey entirely , and in which it is certain , that he had all the success that he had wisht for . 20. He says , Wolsey being alienated from the Emperour , engaged the King of France , after he was set at liberty , to treat for a Match between the Dauphin and the Princess of England , upon which they were contracted with great Magnificency ; but that was not enough , for the Cardinal's malice . I have formerly shewed , that the proposition of a Mariage between the Dauphin and the Princess was in the year 1518 , long before Francis the first 's Imprisonment ; but the Treaty set on foot after his Liberty , was either for himself , or his second Son , and this sort of a Treaty being somewhat extraordinary , where the alternative lay between the Father and the Son for the same Lady , Mr. Varillas shews his great ignorance of the Affairs of that Time , since he says nothing of it ; for this would have given him occasion enough to have entertained his Reader with many Visions and Speculations . 21. He says , that Wolsey dealt with Longland the King's Confessour , to possess him with scruples concerning the lawfulness of his Mariage , that Longland refused to do it , but engaged Wolsey to begin , and he promised to fortify the scruples , that the Cardinal should infuse into the King's mind . Upon which the Cardinal did open the matter to the King , and the King being shaken by his proposition , laid the matter before his Confessour , who seconded the Cardinal . In this he has taken the liberty to depart from Sanders , thô he is the Author whom he generally copies ; but it is easy to pretend to tell secrets , but not so easy to prove them . The King himself did afterwards in publick not only deny this , but affirmed that Wolsey had opposed his scruples all he could , and that he himself had opened them in Confession to Longland , and the King himself said to Grineus , that he was disquieted with those scruples ever from the year 1529 , which was three years before the matter was made publick . 22. He says , the King upon that consulted the Divines of England , concerning the validity of the Mariage , and that all those that were Men of probity and disinteressed , answered in the affirmative ; but some that did aspire , or that were corrupted , thought it doubtful , others , who were very few in number , affirmed it was unlawful . This is so false , that all the Bishops of England , Fisher only excepted , declared under their Hands and Seals , that they thought the Mariage unlawful . 23. He gives a Character of Anne Boleyn , in which he takes up the common Reports of her ill shape , her yellow colour , her gag tooth , her Lump under her chin , and her hand with six fingers : but because all this agrees ill to the Mistress of a King , he , to soften that , adds a long Character of her Wit , her Air and Humour , in which he lays her charms , and here he takes all the licences of a Poët , as well as of a Painter . But as several of her Pictures , yet extant , shew the folly of those Stories , concerning her Deformity , so the other particulars of this Picture are for most part fetcht out of that Repository of false History , that lies in Mr. Varillas's Imagination . 24. He says , the English Historians , and some other Catholicks , agree to those things , and for his Vouchers he cites on the Margent , Sanders , Ribadeneira and Remond ; but they add many other particulars , thô they differ concerning them , and thô he will not affirm them to be true ; yet he thinks it worth the while to set them down . They say , that Anne Boleyn's true Father was not known : that she was born in England , while he was Ambassadour in France : that Henry the 8th , being in love with the Mother , had sent away her Husband , that so he might satisfy his Appetites more freely ; but that he soon quited the Mother for her eldest Daughter Mary : that Sr. Thomas Boleyn at his return to England , finding his Wife with Child , begun a Sute against her , but that the King forced him to be reconciled to his Wife , and to own the Child that she bore some time after , who was Anne Boleyn : that this Daughter at the Age of 15 , was dishonoured by two of her Father's Domesticks , upon which she was sent to France , where she was so common a Prostitute , that she went by the Name of the English Hackney : that she was a common subject of Raillery : that she became a Lutheran , thô she made still profession of the other Religion . He says , others make her pass for a Heroïne , that cannot be enough commended , yet he acknowledges there are not Authentical Evidences left , to discover their imposture . Here is a way of writing , that agrees well with Mr. Varillas's other Qualities : he was here in a cold fit , and so his Religion did not operate so strong , as to disengage him quite from all regard to truth , only it produces one start , that is sufficiently extravagant , for he accuses all that is said in favours of Anne Boleyn of imposture , thô at the same time he acknowledges , there are not Authentick Evidences to disprove it ; but how then came he to know , that those Commendations were Impostures ? He answers that in the beginning of this Paragraph , and cites in general the Historians of England and other Catholick Writers : and for the Historians of England he gives us Sanders alone , thô he can hardly make a plural out of him , unless he splits him into three or four subdivisions , as he had done Charles the 5th , when he reckoned up the Emperour and the King of Spain as two of the Pretenders to the Princess Mary . But thô I have in my History demonstrated the falsehood of all this Legend so evidently , that I had perhaps wearied my Reader , by prooving that too copiously , yet since I see that nature can croud so much impudence in Mr. Varillas alone , as might serve even the whole Order of the Jesuites , and that he is resolved to keep up the credit of the blackest falsehoods , as the Church of Rome preserves still in her Breviary a great many Lessons with Prayers and Anthems , relating to them , that are now by the consent of learned Men exploded as Fables , I must again lay open this matter , thô I thought I had so fully confuted those Lies , that even a Pension could not have engaged a Man to support them any more . It may seem enough to an impartial Mind , that Sanders was the first , that ever published those Stories , above 50 years after Anne Boleyn's Death : that thô Card. Pool , and the other Writers of that Time , had left nothing unsaid , that could blacken K. Henry ; yet none of them had brow enough to assert Sanders's Fictions : and that after Anne Boleyn's Tragical Fall , when her Misfortunes had made it a fashionable thing to blacken her , yet these impostures were reserved for Sanders , and for an Age , in which he and many others of his Church were setting on many Rebellions and Conspiracies against Q. Elisabeth , they were so powerfully acted by Mr. Varillas's Spirit of Religion , thô they had not the folly to own it , as he has done , as to give themselves the liberty to say the foulest things against the Mother , without giving themselves the trouble to enquire , whither they were true or false : and the things here advanced are of such a nature , that either they must be evidently true , or they are notoriously false ; for an Embassy into France of such a continuance , a Sute moved upon Sr. Tho. Boleyn's return , were publick matters , and must have lien open to a discovery . The whole Recital is impossible , as it is told ; for if she was born after Sr. Tho. Boleyn return'd from an Embassy , to which King Henry had sent him , that he might enjoy his Wife , and in which he staid two years , as Sanders says ; then since King Henry came to the Crown in the year 1509 , she must be born in the year 1511 , and then the 15th year of her Age will fall in the year 1526 , and it being certain that the King began to court her in the year 1527 , here is not time enough for her Leudness and her long stay in France . But it is certain that she was born in the year 1507 , two years before K. Henry came to the Crown , and when he was but 14 years old , and that at 7 years old she went over to France with K. Henry's Sister , when she was married to Lewis the 12th ; and thô upon that King's Death the Queen Dowager of France came soon after back into England , yet Anne Boleyn staid still in France , and was in the service of Claud Francis's the first 's Queen , and after her Death the King's Sister , the Dutchess of Alençon , took her into her service , and these two Princesses were so celebrated for their Vertue , that this alone is enough to shew , that she was then under no infamy , since she was of their Family . She was also Maid of Honour to our Queen Katherine , who , even by Mr. Varillas's Character , was of too severe a Vertue to admit a common Prostitute to that degree of Honour . So that here is more than enough to discredit all those Calumnies . 25. He says , thô there is not Evidence enough in the former Reports , yet there is a certain proof for K. Henry's disorders with the Elder of the two Sisters , Mary Boleyn , since in the demand , that K. Henry made for a permission to marry Anne , he confessed his disorders with her Sister , and offered to do Pennance for them : and to vouch for this , he cites King Henry's Petition to P. Clement the 7th . Here Mr. Varillas shews , how little he understands the advantages that he has , to maintain his Assertions , since there is an Authority for this last , that has more appearance of truth in it , than all his other Citations put together , thô his ignorance made him incapable of finding it out . For Cardinal Pool , in his Book against K. Henry , objects this to him , and this has a fair appearance : whereas the Petition , that he cites , is a Dream of his own , that was never before heard of . But thô I have said more for the honour of Cardinal Pool , than all the Panegiricks that have been given him , amount to , yet I am very well assured , that in this particular he was abused by Reports , to which he gave too easy a belief : for as all the Original Instructions and Dispatches , that were made upon that Affair , are yet extant , in which there is not one Word relating to this matter ; so it is plain , that the Affair was never so far advanced , as to demand a permission for a second Mariage , since that could never be so much as asked , till the first was dissolved , and that not being gained , there was not room made for it . If the King had given such advantages against himself , as to have put such a Confession in a Petition to the Pope , is it to be imagined , that the Popes would not have discovered this in some Authentical manner , and even have put it in the Thundering Bull , that was afterwards published against him ? for this alone proved his Hypocrisy of pretending scruples of Conscience at his Mariage beyond exception ; and if the King acted in this matter without any regard to Conscience , it is unreasonable to represent him as so strictly Conscientious , and that he would have confessed so scandalous a secret , and so to have put himself in the power of those , of whom he could not be well assured . 26. He gives us a long account of Wolsey's design , to engage the King to marry the Dutchess of Alençon . Of the Bishop of Tarke's being sent over to bring the English Princess into France , upon her being contracted to the Dauphin . And of Wolsey's prevailing with him , to let that Proposition fall , and to set on another , for a Mariage between the King of England and the Dutchess of Alençon . And that the Bp. of Tarke was cheated by Wolsey ; and being in the interests of the Dutchess of Alençon , he demanded a publick Audience of the King , in the presence of the Council , in which he imployed all his Eloquence to persuade him to divorce his Queen , and to marry the most Christian King's Sister . In all this matter Mr. Varillas is only the Copier of Sanders , yet he cannot tell another Man's Lie , without mixing some additions of his own ; for the Bp. of Tarke's being sent over , to demand the Princess , is one of the fruits of his own Religion . But thô a Pedant of a Priest , such as Sanders , had told so improbable a Story ; yet it ill became a Man , that pretends to know Courts , and the Negotiations of Ambassadours , as Mr. Varillas does , to assert such improbabilities , as that an Ambassadour sent express to demand a Princess for his Master's Son , which was the greatest advantage that France could have possibly hoped for , should be so far wrought on by the Minister of the Court , to which he was sent , as not only to let all this fall ; but to make a new Proposition for the illegitimating of the young Princess , and for offering his Master's Sister to King Henry , and all this without any Instructions from his Master , and thereby exposing the Dutchess of Alençon to the scorn of being rejected , after she was so publickly offered to the King of England ; thô every Body knows , that the first offers of Princesses are made in secret . And after all this , that the Bishop of Tarke , who not only exceeded his Instructions , but acted contrary to them in so important a matter , was neither recalled , nor disgraced ; but on the contrary , he was afterwards promoted to be a Cardinal by the recommendation of the Court of France ; and he being a Cardinal , and seeing afterwards how he was abused , if we may believe this Fable , is it to be supposed , that he , either out of his own Zeal for the Court of Rome , or by the Accusations that naturally such a Proposition , begun by him , must have brought on him , would not have told all this secret afterwards ? In short , as this Relation contains many particulars in it , that are not according to the Forms of our Court , such as his demanding an Audience in the presence of the Council ( for it seems , as Mr. Varillas set our Parliaments above our Kings , he will make the Privy Council equal to them ) so the whole is so contrary to all the Methods of Ambassadours , that this would scarce pass , if it related to the transactions of the Courts of China or Iapan ; but it is so gross an imposition on such as know the Methods of the Courts of Europe , that Mr. Varillas presumed too much on the credulity of his Readers , when he thought that this could be believed : and si non è vero , il è ben trovato , is so necessary a Character for a Man to maintain , that would have his Books sell well , which I am told is Mr. Varillas's chief Design , that he had best find out some Judge of his Pieces , that has a true Understanding , since it is plain , that he has not sence enough himself to make a right Judgment in such matters . 27. He says , when Cardinal Wolsey went over into France he caried a Commission to consult the Universities of France , touching the King's Divorce ; but that the change of Affairs in Italy , made the King to recal him ; who was strangely surprised , when he found that the King had no thoughts of marrying the Dutchess of Alençon , and that he was become so much in love with Anne Boleyn , that he was resolved to marry her on any Terms . It is an unfortunate thing for a Man , to have heard too much , and to have read too little of History : for as the one gives him much confidence , so the other exposes him to many Errours . Mr. Varillas had heard , that K. Henry had consulted many Universities ; but not knowing where to place this , he fancied , that it must be the first step in the whole Matter . But he knew not , that this was not thought on , till after a Sute of above two Years continuance , in which the King saw , how he was deluded by the Court of Rome ; and upon that , he took the other Method of consulting the Universities . All his speculations concerning Card. Wolsey , are built on the common Mistake , that supposes him ignorant of the King's intentions for Anne Boleyn , the falsehood of which I have sufficiently demonstrated . 28. He tells us , that Card. Wolsey having once several Bishops to dine with them , the King knowing of it , went to them after Dinner , and made a Writing to be read to them , that set forth the Reasons against his Mariage : the Bishops did not approve it quite ; yet they were so complying , as to say , that if those things were true , his scruples were well grounded . This was too important a thing , not be made appear probable by some of his pretended Vouchers , thô it is most certainly false ; for a Resolution , signed by all the Bishops of England , except Fisher , was produced before the Legates , to shew how well the King's scruples were grounded . 29. He says , the Privy Councel acted more steadily , and intended to give the King an undeniable proof of his Mistresses Lewdness ; for Sr. Thomas Wiat , that had obtained of her the last favours , was willing to let the King know it ; and so being of the Privy Councel , he not only owned the matter to the rest of that Board , but was content to let the King know it ; and when he found that the King would not believe it , he offered to make the King himself an Eye-witness to their Privacies ; but thô the Duke of Suffolk made this bold Proposition to the King , he was so far from hearkning to it , that Wiat was disgraced upon it , and by this means the Mistress was covered from such dangerous Discoveries for the future . Such a Story as this might have passed from a Sanders , that knew the World little ; but in earnest , it seems the fits of Mr. Varillas's Religion are strong even to Extasy , since they make him write as extravagantly of humane Affairs , as if he had passed his whole Life in a Desert . A Man that knows what humane Nature is , cannot think that Wiat would have either so far betraied Mrs. Boleyn , or exposed himself , as to have made such a Discovery ; it being more natural for a Man , that was assured of a young Lady's Favour , to contribute to her Elevation , since that must have raised himself , than to contrive her Ruin. And K. Henry , whose imperious temper gave him a particular Disposition to Jealousy , must have been of different composition from all the rest of Mankind , if he could have rejected a Discovery of this nature . And when the secrets of Jealousies are opened to Princes , it is too gross , even for a Romance , to make the Discoverer to begin with the Councel-board , and to procure a Deputation from them , to acquaint the King with them . But as Wiat does not appear to have been a Privy Councelour , till near the end of K. Henry's Reign ; so it is plain enough , he was never disgraced , but continued to be still imploied by the King in some forreign Embassies , to the end of his Life . 30. He says , Anne Boleyn endeavoured , thô in vain , to engage Sr. Thomas More to negociate her Affair ; but he being proof against all corruption , Gardiner , that was a Canonist , was made Secretary of State , and was sent to Rome with My-Lord Brian , who scandalised all Rome with his lewd behaviour ; and had the impudence to assure the Pope , that the Queen desired to be divorced , that so she might retire into a Monastery . And made other offers of great advantage to the Pope , in case he would allow the Divorce . Mr. Varillas cannot say too much in Sr. Thomas More 's commendation ; but since he was a Man of so much Sincerity , it is certain , that he approved of the Divorce : for in a Letter , that his own Family printed among his other Works , in Q. Mary's Reign , he , writing to Cromwel , owns , that he had approved of the Divorce , and that he had great hopes of the King's success in it , as long as it was prosecuted in the Court of Rome , and founded on the defects that were pretended to be in the Bull ; and after that most of the Universities and of the learned Men of Europe had given their Opinions in favours of the Divorce , four years after it was first moved , he being then Chancellour , went down to the House of Commons and made those Decisions to be read there , and upon that he desired the Members of Parliament to report in their Countries , that which they had heard and seen ; and added these very Words , and then all Men will openly perceive , that the King has not attempted this Matter for his Will and Pleasure , but only for the discharge of his Conscience . Upon Wolsey's Disgrace , he was made Chancellour , and continued in that high trust almost three years ; which is an evident sign that he did not then oppose the Divorce ; nor did he grow disgusted of the Court , till he saw that the King was upon the point of breaking with the See of Rome . So that he would have liked the Divorce , if the Pope could have been prevailed with to allow it ; but he did not approve of the King 's procuring it another way . Mr. Varillas is no happier in the other parts of this Article : for Gardiner was not sent first to Rome , to negotiate this matter . Knight that was Secretary of State , was first imploied ; and Gardiner was not made Secretary of State , till near the end of this Negotiation : nor was he ever sent to Rome with Brian : nor was Brian a Lord , but only a Knight ; and it was a year after this Sute was first begun , before Brian was imploied in it ; so that he could carry no such deluding Message to the Pope , concerning the Queen's desiring the Divorce . And for this pretension of the Queen's desiring to retire to a Monastery , it was never made use of by the English Ambassadours . It was on the contrary a notion of the Pope's , who thought , that if that could be put in her Head , it would be the easiest Method of getting out of this uneasy matter : and therefore he ordered his Legate Card. Campegio , to advise the Queen to it . And for the scandals of Brian's Life , they must have been very great , if they gave offence at Rome at that time : but as I can not answer much for Brian , so I will not trouble my self to vindicate him ; but he could not behave him more indecently at Rome , than Campegio did in England , when he came over Legate , who scandalised even the Court with his lewd behaviour . 31. He says , the Pope was sensible of his obligations to the King , and resolved to do all he could to gratify him , and so ordered Cajetan to examine the matter , who did it in his manner , after the Method of the Schools . And here he gives us an abstract of his Book . He laid this down for a Maxime , that the High-Priest under the N. Testament had no less Authority , than the High-Priest had under the Law of Moses , who had power to allow of such Mariages , to good ends and in good Circumstances ; and that the end of this Mariage was noble : that the Crowns of England and Spain being united , might send their Fleets to block up Constantinople . And that by this Mariage , as Italy was to be set at Peace , so K. Henry was diverted from marrying into Families suspect of Heresy : and that therefore the Pope could not grant a Dispensation for annulling it . And with his usual Confidence , he cites on the Margent Cajetan's Consultation . And this , he says , confirmed the Pope in his Resolution , not to grant the Dispensation for breaking the Mariage upon any Terms whatsoever . I have given such Authentick Demonstrations of the Falsehood of this Particular , that I am sure the strongest Fit of Mr. Varillas's Religion can not resist them . For the Pope , upon the first Proposition , franckly granted the Dispensation , and only consulted with some Cardinals about the Methods of doing it : and afterwards he sent one over to England , and promised , that he would do , not only all that he could grant either in Law or Justice ; but every thing else that he could grant out of that plenitude of Power , with which he was vested in the King's favour . The Pope also proposed a Method , that perhaps would have brought the matter to an easier issue , which was , that if the King was satisfied in his own Conscience concerning the Divorce , in which he did not think that there was a Doctor in the whole World , that could judg so well as himself , then he might put away his Queen , and marry another , and then the Pope would confirm all . For the crafty Pope thought , it would be easier for him to confirm it , when it was once done , than to give Authority to do it : and in short , the Pope made the King still believe , that he would do it , till by that means he brought the Emperour to grant him all he desired . And as for Cajetan's opinion , I am now in a Countrey where I cannot find his Works , so I cannot be so positive in this matter ; but as far as my Memory serves me , Cajetan writ nothing with relation to this matter : but only in the body of his School-Divinity , that he had published long before this Sute began , he had set on foot a new Opinion , touching the Prohibitions of marrying in near Degrees , which the Church by a constant Tradition had in all Times lookt on as Moral Laws ; whereas he asserted , they were only Positive Precepts , that did not bind under the Christian Religion , and by consequence , that there was no Law now against Mariages in those Degrees , but the Law of the Church , with which the Pope might dispense . In all the Books that I have seen , that were writ for the Queen's Cause , Cajetan's Authority is brought , as a thing already abroad in the World , and not as a Consultation writ upon this Occasion : and by what I remember of that Cardinal's Life , it is said , that in his reasonings with Luther he had found himself so defective in the knowledg of the Scripture , that whereas formerly he had given himself wholly to the Study of School-Divinity , he after that gave himself entirely to the Study of the Scripture , in which , making allowances for his Ignorance of the Original Tongues , he succeeded to admiration . But thô I cannot procure a Sight of his Treatise concerning the Degrees of Mariage , the Idea that I retain of his solide way of writing , makes me conclude , that he was not capable of writing in so trifling a manner , as Mr. Varillas represents the Matter . For what Man of sense could say , that the Highpriest under the Jewish Religion could dispense with a Brother's marrying his Brother's Widdow , in some cases : in case that a Brother died without Children , his Brother , or the next of Kin , might have married the Widdow , by the Dispensation that the Law gave , and not by a Dispensation of the Highpriest . And for the Ends that he pretends of those two Princes , going to block up Constantinople with their Fleets , a Man must be ignorant in History to the Degree of Mr. Varillas , to imagine this , since as the Kings of those Times had no Royal Fleets , but were forced to hire Merchant Vessels , when they had occasion for them ; so the blocking up of Constantinople was too bold a project for those Days , and does not seem to have been so much as once thought on . And for the other Ends that he mentions , thô the procuring such a Peace to Italy , as was for the Interest of the Popes , was a thing for which they would have sacrificed any thing ; yet this differs much from P. Iulius the second 's Character , who granted the Dispensation , since his whole Reign was a continued Imbroilment of Italy . Nor does it appear that K. Henry's Mariage could have any influence on the Peace of Italy , unless it were very remote . And as for the other Reason alledged for the Mariage , that it diverted K. Henry from marrying into Families suspect of Heresy , this is too great a violation of the Costume ; for it seems Mr. Varillas had the present State of Europe in his Head , when he writ it : but Cajetan could not write this , for in the year 1503 there were no Families in Europe suspect of Heresy : so that all this reasoning , that is here entitled to Cajetan , is a mass of Mr. Varillas's crude Imaginations , which doe equally discover both his Ignorance , and his want of Judgment . 32. He accuses Mr. Beaucaire , for saying a thing , that was no way probable , when he affirms , that Card. Campegio caried over to England a Bull annulling the Mariage , which he was allowed to shew both to the King and to Card. Wolsey , but that this was only an artifice to procure him the more credit for drawing out the Process into a great length . But when a Writer rejects what he finds affirmed by another , that lived in the Time concerning which he writs , he ought at least to give some reasons to justify his being of another mind ; since it is a little too bold for any Man , of a temper more modest than that of Mr. Varillas , to deny a matter of fact , meerly because he thinks it is no way probable : but it is not only probable , but evidently true , as I have made it appear beyond all possibility of contradiction : for after that Campegio had , according to his Instructions , shewed the Bull , both to the King and to Wolsey , great endeavours were used at Rome to procure an Order for his shewing it to some of the King's Ministers ; but the Pope could not be prevailed on so far : and I have printed an Original Letter of Iohn Castalis , that contains a long conference that he had with the Pope on this head ; by which it appears , that the only consideration that the Pope had before his Eyes in this whole matter , was the Emperour's Greatness , and his Fears of being ruined , if he had made any further steps in that Affair . 33. He says , that the Queen having thrown her self at the King's Feet , and made a very moving Speech , the King was so far melted with it , that he said , he was contented to refer the matter to be judged by the Pope in Person , upon which she went out instantly , that so the King might not have time to recal that , which perhaps he had said a little too suddenly : and that she always claimed this Promise , thô the King had no regard to it . Here is a new Fit of his Religion , for it seems Sanders felt not those vigorous motions , that were necessary to furnish out his Scenes : and therefore , thô Mr. Varillas adds no Discovery as to matters of fact , beyond what Sanders had made , yet he has the more copious Inventions of the two . But he does not place his contrivances judiciously , for it is much safer to dress up the secrets of the Cabinet , than publick Courts of Judicature with such garnishings : and as that was the most solemn Trial , that ever England saw , in which a King and Queen appeared as Delinquents , to be tried for Incest , so the matter is not only particularly related by those that lived in that Time , or soon after it ; but the Journals of the Court are yet in being , and by all these it appears , that as soon as the Queen made that moving Speech , she immediatly rise and went out , without staying for one Word of Answer . And in all that long Sute that followed afterwards , for obliging the King to carry on the Sute at Rome , that depended for three years , this offer of the King 's , if it had any other being but that which Mr. Varillas's Fiction gives it , would have been certainly alledged , for obliging the King to continue the Process at Rome ; but it was never so much as mentioned , so the honour of it belongs to Mr. Varillas . 34. He says , that in the Process , as the King's Advocates produced a Letter , that Card. Hadrian had writ at the time of the granting the Bull for the Mariage , that he had heard P. Iulius the second say , that he could not grant it , the Queen's Advocates produced likewise a Letter of Pope Iulius to the King of England , that assured him , that thô he had not granted the Bull as soon as it was demanded , that was not out of any intention to refuse it ; but that he had only waited for a favourable conjuncture , that so he might doe it the more deliberatly . This is of no consequence ; but some Men get into ill habits , that engage them , even when there is no advantage to tell Lies . The whole Journals of this Sute mention neither the one nor the other of these matters : there is somewhat like the second , of which some , it seems , had in discours given Mr. Varillas a dark Hint , and he resolved to garnish it up the best he could . There was a Breve of P. Iulius's produced , but not writ to the King of England , for it was addressed to the Kings of Spain , and was indeed believed to be forged in Spain . It was conceived in the very Words of the Bull for the Mariage , and was of the same date , and the only difference between it and the Bull was , that whereas the Bull mentioned the Queen's Mariage with P. Arthur , as having been perhaps consuminated , this spoke of the consummation of that Mariage less doubtfully , and without a perhaps : and the inference that was made upon this was , that the Spaniards foreseeing that the consummation of P. Arthur's Mariage would be proved , he forged this Breve , to make it appear , that the Pope was informed of that as of a thing certain , thô it was decent in the publick Bull to mention it doubtfully . But Mr. Varillas shews how dangerous a thing it is to write History upon flying Reports , helped up a little with the dull Invention of an ill Poet. 35. He runs out into a high commendation of the Zeal and Fidelity that some of the English Bishops , who were named to be the Queen's Advocates , shewed in pleading her Cause . But in this he shews , how little he understands the common forms of Law : for since the Queen declined the Court , and appealed to the Pope , there was no more occasion given to her Advocates , to speak to the merits of her Cause . And whereas he pretends , that this was done , not only by Bp. Fisher , but by the Bishops of London , Bath and Ely , that was impossible , since all the Bishops had signed a Writing , which was produced before the Legates , in which they all declared themselves against the Lawfulness of the Mariage . 36. He says , the Pope recalled the Cause , to be heard before himself , on this pretence , that the King had by Word of Mouth consented to it . This is a flight of our Author's , to colour that shameful secret : for when the Emperour had agreed to put Florence into the hands of the Medici , the Pope who had seemed to favour the King's cause till that time , did then admit of the Queen's Appeal : and thô he had signed a formal Promise , never to recal the Cause , yet he being as little a Slave to his Word , as Mr. Varillas is to Truth , broke his faith . But he never so much as once pretended this consent of the King 's . 37. He says , Wolsey being disgraced , was sent to York , where he languished some time , being reduced almost to Beggary . This comes in as a dash of his Pen , to set out K. Henry's Severity : but one of Wolsey's Domesticks , that writ his Life , tells us , in how great State he went to York , with a Train of 160 Horse , and an Equipage of 72 Carts following him with his Houshold-stuf ; for the King restored him not only his Archbishoprick of York , but also his Bishoprick of Winchester , which Mr. Varillas fancies he took from him : and it was impossible for a Man , that had those two great Benefices , to be reduced to any degrees of Want. 38. He says , Anne Boleyn raised Cranmer to the Dignity of chief Minister of State , who was one of the profligatest Men of England , that had nothing of Christianity in him , but the outward appearances , being ambitious , voluptuous , bold , turbulent and capable of all sorts of Intrigues . He had studied long in Germany , where he was infected with Lutheranisme , thô he did not outwardly profess it . He took a Concubine in Germany , whom he afterwards married by the King's permission . He had been Chaplain long in the Family of Boleyn , so when the See of Canterbury fell vacant , Anne Boleyn presented him . The Fit here is extream hot and long , and shews , how entirely Mr. Varillas was subdued by it , since it is hardly possible for a Man to spit out more Venome and Falsehood at once . Cranmer was never in the Affairs of State , much less chief Minister . And any Ignorance less than Mr ▪ Varillas's would have found , that Cromwel succeeded Wolsey in the Ministry . As for Cranmers Ambition , as he had passed the greatest part of his Life in a secret Retirement , so he was in Germany when the See of Canterbury fell vacant , and when he understood that the King intended to raise him to that Dignity , he excused himself all he could , and delaied his Return to England some Months , that so the King might have time given him to change his Mind . He was so far from being turbulent and hardy , and from being a Man of Intrigues , that his plain Simplicity made him to be despised by his Enemies , till they found that there was a wise Conduct under all that Mildness and Slowness . And it was this simplicity , and his keeping himself out of all Intrigues , that preserved him in K. Henry's esteem . He never went to study in Germany , but was sent into Italy and Germany to reason with the learned Men in the Universities concerning the King's Divorce . He married a Wife in Germany , and was so far from obtaining the King's Permission to marry her , that upon a severe Law , that was afterwards made against the Mariage of the Clergy , he sent her into Germany for some time , yet he franckly owned his Mariage to the King , when he questioned him upon it , and there was never the least imputation laid upon his Chastity , except this of his Mariage , which we think none at all . He was never Chaplain in the Boleyn Family , but lived private in Cambridg , when the King came to hear of him , and to imploy him in the Prosecution of the Divorce . And so far was he from being presented by Anne Boleyn , upon the Vacancy of Canterbury , that he was then in Germany . And now it appears what a secret Mr. Varillas has , of making as much Falsehood go into one Period , as would serve another to scatter up and down a whole Book ; but we know the Society that has this secret , and it is certain , that Mr. Varillas has learnt it to perfection . 39. He says , the King accepted Cranmer upon condition , that he would pronounce the Sentence of Divorce between their Majesties of England , in case that the Pope ratified their contested Mariage : and thus by a way so uncanonical he was made Archbishop of Canterbury . There was no occasion of demanding any such Promise of Cranmer , for he had openly declared his opinion , that the Mariage was incestuous and unlawful , so that his Judgment was already known . But Mr. Varillas shews how little he knew our matters , when he says , that Cranmer was made Archbishop in an uncanonical way ; for as he was chosen by the Chapter of Canterbury , so he had his Bull from Rome , and how little soever , this is Canonical according to the Canons of the Ancient Church , yet Mr. Varillas has no reason to except to the Uncanonicalness of it . 40. He says , he was installed by another Artifice , for being required to swear the Oath to the Pope , he had a Notary by him , who attested , that he took this Oath against his Will , and that he would not keep it to the prejudice of the King. He made no Protestation , that he took that Oath against his Will ; but he repeated a Protestation twice at the high Altar , that he intended not by that Oath to the Pope , to oblige himself to any thing , that was contrary to the Law of God , to the King's Prerogative , or to the Laws of the Land , nor to be restrained by it from proposing or consenting to any thing , that might concern the Reformation of the Christian Faith , the Government of the Church of England , or the Prerogatives of the King and Kingdome . This is a different thing from protesting , that he took the Oath against his Will , which as it had been ridiculous in it self , so was very far contrary to that native Singleness of Heart , in which he always acted . 41. He says , there was an ancient Law against the Subjects of England's acknowledging a forreign Jurisdiction , upon which the King raised a Sute against his Clergy , for owning the Pope's Jurisdiction , in that which was a mixt Court , relating both to the Temporal and the Spiritual . And he adds , that the Clergy had an easy Answer to this Charge , since that Law had no regard to the Spiritual Authority . Matters of Law are things of too delicate a nature for so slight a Man as Mr. Varillas to look into them . He represents this as one single Law , that was very old , and that related only to Temporals , whereas if he had known any thing of our Laws , he would have seen , that there was a vast number of Laws made in the Reigns of many of our Kings , such as Edward the first , Edward the third , Richard the second , Henry the 4th , and Henry the 5th , all relating to this matter , and these Laws were made in express Words against all that brought Bulls and Provisions from Rome to Ecclesiastical Benefices . 42. He says , the motions of the Clergy in their own defence , could not but be feeble , since they had two such treacherous Heads , as Cranmer Archbishop of Canterbury , and Lee Archbishop of York , so they made a submission to the King , but he would not receive it , unless they would acknowledg , that he had the same Authority over the Ecclesiastical Body , that he had over his other Subjects : and thus , without thinking on what they did , they furnished the King with a pretence of calling himself , Head of the Church of England . Cranmer was so little concerned in this matter , that it was past two years before he was Archbishop , while Warham was Archbishop of Canterbury ; for the Submission was made in March 1531 , and he was consecrated in March 1533. And Lee of York was so far from consenting to it , that he strugled long against it , after Warham and his Synode had past it . And whereas he pretends , that the King drew his pretence , to be Head of the Church of England , from a general acknowledgment that they had made of the King's Authority over Churchmen , this is so far from true , that the whole Clergy , even his admired Fisher not excepted , did in the Title of the Submission , to which they all set their hands , call the King in so many formal Words , supream Head of the Church and Clergy of England , in so far as was agreable to the Law of Christ : and this was done during More 's Ministry , who continued Chancellour 15 Months after this . 43. He says , that upon More 's laying down his Office , the King gave the Seals to another Churchman , that was no less devoted to him than Granmer , whose name was Andley , on whom he bestows a character , thô he knows nothing concerning him . Andley was no Churchman , but a common Lawyer as More was , that had been Chancellour before him , and the Gentlemen of that Robe being raised upon Merit , and not by their Birth , his low Extraction was no extraordinary matter . 44. He says , the King finding that the Pope was ofraid , that he should contract a secret Mariage with Anne Boleyn , resolved to do it , on design to do the Pope a Spite ; so the Day being set , one Polland a Priest , being appointed to do the Office , demanded the Pope's Bull for the Mariage , which he was made believe that the King had procured ; but the King swore to him , that he had it in his Closet , and that nothing made him not go immediatly to fetch it , but his unwillingness to retard that Action . This is so ill told , that Mr. Varillas ought to have imploied a little of his Religious Zeal , to make it more plausible ; for it was then so well understood , that the Pope was entirely united to the Emperour , that Polland Lee could not imagine there was any Bull granted ; and he was all his Life of too complying a Temper , to need such Artifices to oblige him to do any thing , that might serve to advance him . Mr. Varillas represents the King here too much like a private Gentleman , that keeps his Papers in his own Closet , of several Popes , the Canons of many Synodes and Councils , ●nd by the concurring Testimonies of almost all the Greek and Latin Fathers , both Ancient and Modern , and by the agreeing Doctrines both of Schoolmen , Canonists and Casuists ; and if Tradition was the true Expounder of Scripture , and the sure Conveyance of Doctrine , the Mariage was certainly incestuous ; so that according to the fundamental Doctrine of the Church of Rome , the Mariage was unlawful : and by the same Authorities it was also proved , that the Pope's Dispensation could not make void the Law of God , and that the Clergy of England were the proper Judges of what fell out in England . This being the State of that Matter , and almost all the Universities of Europe , that of Bologna it self not excepted , thô it was the Pope's own Town , having declared in the King's Favours , it was no wonder , if Cranmer , upon such Grounds , proceeded to give Sentence . 47. He dresses up a Speech for Card. Bellay , all out of his own Fancy ; but one thing is remarkable : he makes the Cardinal represent to the King , that if he went to separate himself from the Communion of the Church of Rome , either he would succeed in it , or not ; if he succeeded in it , besides that he put himself in a state of Damnation , there would be no place found that would be safe for his sacred Person , against the attempts of zealous Catholicks , who would endeavour to kill him , that they might preserve their ancient Religion ; and if he succeeded not , he might be assured , that he would lose both his Crown and his Life in a general Revolt . Mr. Varillas is now in a Fit of Religion of another sort , for as there are hot and cold Fits of Agues ▪ so if some of his Fits make him forget the obligations of speaking truth , this makes him speak out a Truth indeed , but of that nature , that if he had been long practised in the Secrets of the Court of Rome , or of the Jesuite Order , he would have known , that thô during the Minority of a King , a Cardinal Perron might speak it boldly , or during the confusions of a Civil War , the whole Sorbonne might declare in Favours of it , yet under such a Reign , and in the present Conjuncture , it was to be denied boldly . And one would not have thought , that at this time a Clement or a Ravilliae would have had no worse character , but that of zealous Catholicks . So we have now an entire notion of a zealous Catholick from Mr. Varillas : he does not trouble himself to examine what he says , whither it is true or false , nor will he stick at any Crime , if it may tend to preserve his Religion . And if a Prince goes about to change his Religion , and to depart from the Communion of the See of Rome , he must at first look for a general Revolt , which must end in his Deprivation and Death , and if that fails , there is a reserve of zealous Catholicks , who will pursue him into every corner , and never give over , till they have sacrificed him to the interest of their Religion . This is the severest thing that the greatest Ennemy to their Church could possibly object to it ▪ and yet Mr. Varillas has so little judgment , as to put it in the Mouth of a Cardinal . But it is but lately that he has got his Pension , and he has not past a long Noviciat , or perhaps he is now too old to learn the refayings , that his Pattern Mr. Maimbourg would have taught him , who in such a Reign as this is in France , must dress up their Religion as a Doctrine , all made up of Obedience and Submission . But perhaps some had told Mr. Varillas , that the late Articles of the Clergy lookt like the beginning of a Separation from the Court of Rome , so that he thought , it was fit to let the King know his Danger , if he went a step further , either in that Matter , or in a Reformation of Religion , of which there has been so much noise made lately in France , thô it is visible that this has been set on foot , meerly to deceive those , that had a mind to cosen themselves by the hopes of some Amendments , to make Shipwrack of their Faith and of a good Conscience . 48. He makes the Hopes , that the Cardinal Bellay had of succeeding in his Negotiation , to be chiefly founded on the King's being weary of Anne Boleyn , and his becoming in love with Iane Seimour ; and that therefore he concluded that time , and a little Patience might infallibly dispose him to return back again to Queen Katherine . He makes here strange Discoveries in the matters of Love , since he fancies , that the King 's falling in love with a new Mistress , might dispose him to return to his old and abandoned Queen . The thing is also so falsely timed , that it was two years and almost a half after this , before there appeared any beginnings , either of the King's Dislike of Anne Boleyn , or of his Love to Iane Seimour . But the made up of Obedience and Submission . But perhaps some had told Mr. Varillas , that the late Articles of the Clergy lookt like the beginning of a Separation from the Court of Rome , so that he thought , it was fit to let the King know his Danger , if he went a step further , either in that Matter , or in a Reformation of Religion , of which there has been so much noise made lately in France , thô it is visible that this has been set on foot , meerly to deceive those , that had a mind to cosen themselves by the hopes of some Amendments , to make Shipwrack of their Faith and of a good Conscience . 48. He makes the Hopes , that the Cardinal Bellay had of succeeding in his Negotiation , to be chiefly founded on the King's being weary of Anne Boleyn , and his becoming in love with Iane Seimour ; and that therefore he concluded that time , and a little Patience might infallibly dispose him to return back again to Queen Katherine . He makes here strange Discoveries in the matters of Love , since he fancies , that the King 's falling in love with a new Mistress , might dispose him to return to his old and abandoned Queen . The thing is also so falsely timed , that it was two years and almost a half after this , before there appeared any beginnings , either of the King's Dislike of Anne Boleyn , or of his Love to Iane Seimour . But the true Account of this last Negotiation of the Cardinal de Bellay is that at Marseilles : the Pope had promised to Francis the first , that if K. Henry would submit the matter to him , and send a Proxy to Rome , he would judg in his favours against the Queen , because he knew that his cause was just and good ; and the Cardinal was sent over to induce the King to make his Submission ; but the King would not upon verbal Promises make so great a step , yet he promised that , if Assurances were sent him , that were formal and binding , he would upon that send a Submission in full form to Rome , and when the Cardinal procured these from the Court of Rome , the King did send over the Submission . So that Mr. Varillas having supprest the true Account of this Negotiation , he thought he must make it up with somewhat of his own Invention : and as all Liquors drawn out of a musty Barrel tast of the Calk ; so there are so many characters that belong to Mr. Varillas's imagination , that it is hard for him to venture on inventing , without discovering , that he has full as little Judgment as he has Sincerity . 49. He lays the blame of the slowness of the Courier , on the care that the Emperour's Ministers had taken , to stop the passages . But this was a ridiculous observation : for there being a Day set for the Courier's Return , he hapned only to come two Days after his time , and it being in the Winter , in which the Sea was to be twice past , there is no need to run to any other speculation for a slowness of two Days in such a Voyage , and at such a Season ; but it is often observed of those , that have contracted ill habits , as lying in particular , that their naughty customes return upon them , even when there is no provocation lying on them , to tempt them to them ; so Mr. Varillas has given himself such a liberty , to interweave his own Fancies with all the Transactions that he relates , that he cannot let the flightest thing pass without bringing in a stroak of his Politicks to adorn it . 50. He says , the Pope having past Sentence against the King , the King did upon that hold a Parliament on the 24 of April , 1534 , in which he made himself to be acknowledged supream Head of the Churches of England and Ireland ; and got his former Mariage to be condemned , and his second to be confirmed , upon which Q. Katherine died of Grief . In such publick things Mr. Varillas should be wiser than to venture on the giving of Dates , for it is at least two to one that he gives them wrong . The Parliament , that past all these Laws , sate down on the 15th of Ianuary , and was prorogued on the 29th of March , and Sentence was given against the King at Rome the 23 of March : for the truth is , the King did not expect sincere dealing from the Court of Rome , and therefore he looking on this last Proposition as a Delusion , to divert him from passing the Acts , that he had projected for this Session , resolved to go on with his Design , knowing that if the Pope would grant him that which he desired , it would not be uneasy for him to get those Acts repealed . Q. Katherine lived two years after this ; so that , thô the Melancholy , which this gave her , did very likely shorten her Days , yet it was too Poetical , to make her just to die at the end of that Parliament . 51. He says , that the King upon the first informations of Anne Boleyn's Disorders , would not believe them ; but at last he found such proofs , as fully convinced him , upon which he waited , till he found a fit opportunity , to let his Jealousy break out . It agrees ill with what he had said before , that K. Henry was become weary of Anne Boleyn , to make him now so uneasy to believe ill of her ; for nothing disposes so much to Jealousy , as a Dislike already conceived , which naturally inclines one to think ill of a Person whom he does not love ; but it is certain K. Henry never pretended , that he saw any thing , that was dishonourable in her : and the ridiculous Tale of the Tilling at Greenwich was a ly too ill contrived , to be again taken up ; for the Queen 's dropping a Handkerchief , was a favour of too publick a nature , and is not at all credible , considering that she found the King's affections were straying from her . And even that was too slight a matter , to have wrought her ruin , thô it had been true . 52. He says , her own Father was one of her Judges , but thô she made a cunning Defence , yet she was condemned together with four of her Adulterers , and after that she went to meet Death , with more of fierceness , than of a true greatness of Soul , and she died as exactly in all the Maximes of the Stoical Philosophy , as if she had studied them . This assertion of her Father's being one of her Judges , has past so current , that I have no reason to charge Mr. Varillas for it , because I my self yeelded to the current of Writers ; yet having procured a sight of the Original Record of her Process , I found it was a falsehood , and in the end of my first Volume I had corrected the Errour in which I had fallen : so I must at least conclude , that Mr. Varillas never read any History . The Queen had a strange Plea , for there was not one Witness brought against her , so that she was condemned meerly upon Testimonies that were brought in writing , which is expresly contrary to our Law. As for her Behaviour at her Death , it was far from being Stoïcal , for it was rather too cheerful ; and the Lieutenant of the Tower , who knew her Behaviour better than any Person whatsoever , gives a very different representation of it , for in his Letter to Court he tells of her great Devotion , of her cheerfulness and of the protestations that she made of her innocence the Morning before she died , when she received the Sacrement , adding , that her Almoner was still with her , and had been with her ever since two a clock after Midnight . And he also says , that she had much Joy and Pleasure in her Death . And as all this is very far from the Maximes of the Stoical Philosophy , so it seems Mr. Varillas understands very little what they were , otherwise , if he had remembred what a picture he had made of Anne Boleyn , he must have known , that the amourous disposition that he had fastned on her , agreed very ill with a Stoical Unconcernedness and equality of Temper . But this he thought was a pretty conclusion of one of the Scenes of his Piece . And now being as weary of this ungrateful Imployment , as any Reader , or as even Mr. Varillas himself must needs be , I find my self at great ease , being no more obliged to turn over so very ill a Book . And since in the Survey of one of the shortest of the ten Books , of which that Work consists , I have found so many capital Errours , in most of which there is a complication of divers Mistakes in the same Period ; to how much publick shame must Mr. Varillas be exposed , if those , who are concerned , examine the other Books , as I have done this . I expect no other Justice from himself , but that he will reckon all this scorn , that such a Discovery must bring upon him , as a meritorious Suffering at the hands of Hereticks , and that he will use it as an Argument to raise his Pension . But it will be a great happiness if others can learn , thô at his cost , to write with more Truth and greater Caution . The design of all revealed Religion is , to heighten in us those Seeds of Probity , Vertue and Gentleness , that are in our Nature , and I will not stick to say , that it were better for Mankind , that there were no revealed Religion at all in being , and that humane Nature should be left to it self , than that there were such a sort of a revealed Religion received , that overthrows all the Principles of Morality , and that instead of making Men sincere , teaches them to be false , and instead of inspiring them with Love and Mercy , enflames them with Rage and Cruelty , and it is likely , that M. Varillas will easily find out , what that Society is , of which I mean. For he deserves well to be at least one of the Lay-brothers of the Order , if not to fill up Mr. Maimbourg's room , and then the Order will not lose by the change much of a quality , that has been believed to be almost an essential ingredient in its Constitution , which gave occasion to a very pleasant Passage , that , as I was told , fell out at Amiens within these 20 years . All the Companies of Tradesmen in the Church of Rome choose a Saint for their Patron , and the many new invented Trades have put some Bishops to hard shifts to give proper Saints , which has produced some very ridiculous Patronages , for the Cooks have the Assumption for their Feast , because the two first Sillables assum signifies roasted ; and when the Needle-makers at Paris asked of the Cardinal Gondy a Patron , he could not easily find out a Saint that had any relation to their Trade , but he advised them to take All-Saints , for it could not be thought , but that some one or other of the Saints had made Needles ; but the Bishop of Amiens gave Ignatius Loyola to be the Patron of the Packers , now the Word emballeur , as it signifies a Packer , it passes also for a Trepan ; so the Packers being satisfied with the Bishop's nomination , had Ignatius up on his Day in a Procession , upon which the Jesuites were offended , to see their Patron pretended to by such a Company of Mechanicks , and sued the Packers upon it , they defended themselves upon the account of their Bishop's naming him to them , and when the Bishop was asked why he had given him for their Patron , he alluding to the other signification of the Word emballeur said , that he had observed that all the emballeurs of Europe were under that Saint's Patronage . But it is not necessary to infer from hence , that Mr. Varillas has a just claim to his protection , for thô he seems to have very good inclinations , yet he wants the address that is necessary to recommend him to so refined a Society , and to a perfection in it , that cost Mr. Maimbourg a whole Jubily for a Novitiat ; for thô seven years is enough to learn an ordinary Trade , yet 50 is necessary to furnish a Man with a sufficient stock of Impudence for so hardy an Imployment . ADVERTISEMENT . I Have at last found Card. Cajetan's Works , and am now confirmed in that , which was only a conjecture , when I writ upon the 31st Article , pag. 141 ; for it is hard even to guess wrong , when it is in contradiction to Mr. Varillas : and as the Reasons that he put in Cajetan's Mouth , had such manifest Characters of his own ignorance and hardiness , that I could not so much as doubt of the Imposture , yet I was not positive , till I had taken some pains to find out Cajetan's Works , and there I saw my conjectures were well grounded . That Volume in which he delivers his opinion in the matter of the obligation of the Levitical Law concerning the degrees of Mariage , was writ long before this Dispute of K. Henry's was started ; for it is dedicated to Pope Leo the tenth . And instead of all those impertinencies , with which Mr. Varillas calumniates him , and of which none less ignorant than himself , is capable , all that Cajetan says is that , whereas Thomas Aquinas was of opinion , that those degrees were moral , and of eternal obligation , he in his Commentary declares himself of another Mind , but takes a very backward Method to prove it , yet such as was sutable enough to the blindness of the time in which he writ ; for he proves that they are not Moral , only because the Pope dispenced with them , who could not dispence with the Moral Law , and he gives for instance the Mariage of the King of Portugal , to which he adds these Words , The present Queen of England had likewise consummated her former Mariage with the late Brother of the King of England her Husband . So that Cajetan was only driven to this opinion , that he might justify the practises of the Court of Rome . And it appears by what he says concerning it , that it was considered at Rome as an undoubted Truth , that the Queen's first Mariage with Prince Arthur was consummated : and so it is sufficiently apparent , how impudent Mr. Varillas is in the abstract , that he charges on Cardinal Cajetan's Memory , it was far from his way of reasoning , to talk of Fleets blocking up Constantinople ; but Mr. Varillas , who knows little of the past Time , and fancies that matters went formerly as they go now , had perhaps the low Estate in which the Otthoman Empire is at present , or the Bombarding of Genoa in his Eye , when he thought of the sending Fleets against Constantinople above 180 year ago ; but this speculation was as much out of Cajetan's way , as it is sutable to Mr. Varillas . Page 250 he says , King Henry the eighth had opposed the Mariage of his Sister to the King of Scotland with so much violence , that it brought on him several Fits of an Ague . But that Mariage being made in August 1502 , the young Prince was not then 11 years old , and this is too early even for a Poët to make matters of State to have gone so deep into his thoughts , as that they endangered his Health . But as the Legends of Saints represent them in Extasies , before they have past their Childhood , so Mr. Varillas thought it sutable to the rest of his Poëm , to represent K. Henry even in his Infancy as transported with the violence of impetuous passions . But I am afraid I lay too much to his charge , since I do not believe that he had examined the History of his Life so Critically , as to know even his Age ; but it is a sad thing for an ignorant Man , not to have a Chronological Table always before him . FINIS . Notes, typically marginal, from the original text Notes for div A30405-e110 pag. 5. Lib. 9. Pag. 249. Pag. 6. p. 226. 228. ● 240. p. 239. Illudqu● carnali ●●●pula for● consummavi Etiamsi Matrim●nium f●rit per ●●●●nalem ●●●pulam ●●●●summa●● p. 232. Ibid. p. 235. p. 2●6 . p. 237 ▪ p. 240 , 24● ●orison . p. 244. p. 245. Ibid. p. 246. p. 248. P. 250. p. 2●1 . P. 252. Ibid. Ibid. Ibid. p. 257. p. 258. p. 259. P. 260. Ibid. P. 261. p. 263 , &c ▪ P. 266. p. 278. Ibid. ● . 269 , & ●70 . p. 272. p. 274. p. 277. Ibid. ● . 278. Ibid. p. 2●1 . Ibid. Ibid. P. 2●2 . Ibid. P ▪ 283. Ibid. p. 286. p. 287. p. 287. Ibid. P. 288. p. 289. p. 250. Notes for div A30405-e10930 2da 2dae quaest . 15 Art. 9. Moderna quoque Regina Angliae consummaverat prius matrimoniu● cum olim fratre istius Regis Angli sui marit