A hind let loose, or, An historical representation of the testimonies of the Church of Scotland for the interest of Christ with the true state thereof in all its periods : together with a vindication of the present testimonie, against the Popish, prelatical, & malignant enemies of that church ... : wherein several controversies of greatest consequence are enquired into, and in some measure cleared, concerning hearing of the curats, owning of the present tyrannie, taking of ensnaring oaths & bonds, frequenting of field meetings, defensive resistence of tyrannical violence ... / by a lover of true liberty. Shields, Alexander, 1660?-1700. 1687 Approx. 1758 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 387 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2004-03 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A59963 Wing S3431 ESTC R24531 08238934 ocm 08238934 41139 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A59963) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 41139) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 1240:8) A hind let loose, or, An historical representation of the testimonies of the Church of Scotland for the interest of Christ with the true state thereof in all its periods : together with a vindication of the present testimonie, against the Popish, prelatical, & malignant enemies of that church ... : wherein several controversies of greatest consequence are enquired into, and in some measure cleared, concerning hearing of the curats, owning of the present tyrannie, taking of ensnaring oaths & bonds, frequenting of field meetings, defensive resistence of tyrannical violence ... / by a lover of true liberty. Shields, Alexander, 1660?-1700. [13], 742 p. s.n.], [Edinburgh? : Printed in the year 1687. Errata: p. 696. Reproduction of original in the Union Theological Seminary Library, New York. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Church of Scotland -- Controversial literature. Church of Scotland -- History. Covenanters. 2003-08 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2003-08 Aptara Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2003-10 Jonathan Blaney Sampled and proofread 2003-10 Jonathan Blaney Text and markup reviewed and edited 2003-12 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion Some had y r hands struck off & hanged others beheaded . Some hanged & quartered 〈◊〉 Some Tortured by bools thumbkins firematches . Some taken & instantly shot in 〈◊〉 fields . Some banished , others perished in ship-wrack . women hanged , others drowned of stakes in the sea A Hind let loose , OR An Historical Representation of the TESTIMONIES , Of the Church of Scotland , for the Interest of Christ , vvith the true State thereof in all its Periods : TOGETHER WITH A Vindication of the present Testimonie , against the Popish , Prelatical , & Malignant Enemies of that Church , as it is now stated for the Prerogatives of Christ , Priviledges of the Church , and Liberties of Mankind , and sealed by the sufferings of a Reproached Remnant of Presbyterians there , witnessing against the Corruptions of the Time. WHEREIN Several Controversies of Greatest Consequence are enquired into , and in some measure cleared ; concerning hearing of the Curats , owning of the present Tyrannie , taking of ensnaring Oaths & Bonds , frequenting of field meetings , Defensive Resistence of Tyrannical Violence , with several other Subordinate Questions useful for these times . By a Lover of true Liberty . Psal. 94. 20. Shall the Throne of iniquity have fellowship with Thee that frameth mischief by a Law ? Prov. 28. 15. As a roaring Lion & a ranging Bear so is a wicked Ruler over the poor people . Hos. 8. 4. They have set up Kings but not by me , they have made Princes and I knew it not . Revel . 12. 11. And they overcame him by the bloud of the Lamb and by the word of their Testimony and they loved not their Lives unto the Death . Printed in the Year MDCLXXXVII . The Preface to the Reader . Christian Reader , PResuming it is thy desire , to answer the holy & honourable designation I accost thee with , I shall take the Confidence to assure thee , it is my design to answer in some measure the expectation , which the Title of this Treatise would offer ; in the hope , that , wherein I come short ( as I indeed confess not only my jealous fears , but my sensible conviction of my insufficiency for such a great undertaking ) thy Christian tenderness will impute it to my weakness , and not to any want of worth in the Cause I manage ; which is truly worthy , weighty , noble , & honourable , in the esteem of all the Lovers of Christ , that have Zeal for his Honour in exercise : And therefore as it gives me all the encouragement I have , in dependance on his furniture , whose Cause it is , to make such an Essay ; So it animates my ambition , albeit I cannot manage it with any proportion to its merit , yet to move the Christian Reader to make enquiry about it , and then sure I am he will find it is Truth I plead for , though my plea be weak . All I shall further say by way of Preface is to declare the Reason of the Title and the design of the work . Though Books use not to be required to render a reason of their names , which often are arbitrarly imposed , more for the Authors fancy , and the times fashion than for the readers Instruction : yet , seing the times injuries do oblige the Author to conceal his name , the Title will not obscurely notify it to some , for whose satisfaction this is mainly intended , and signify also the Scope of the subject ; which aims at giving goodly words , not suggared with Parasitick sweetness , nor painted with affected pedantry , but fairly brought forth in unhampered freedom , for the beauty of the blessing of humane & Christian Liberty , in its due & true boundaries . This was the subject of a discourse , as some may remember , on that Text whence this Title is taken Gen. 49. 21. Naphtali is a hind let loose : In prosecuting of which , the Speaker with several others , falling at the same time into the hands of the hunters , to learn the worth of that interrupted subject from the experience of the want of it ; an occasion was given , and interpreted by the Author to be a Call , to study more the preciousness of that priviledge predicated of Naphtali , which is the right an● property of the wrestling Tribe of Israel , the persecuted witnesses of Christ now every where preyed upon : And now , providence having opened a door , for delivering himself as a roe from the hand of the hunter , he thought it his duty , and as necessary a piece of service as he could do to the Generation , to bring to light his Lucubrations thereupon : With an endeavour to discover , to all that are free born , and are not contented slaves mancipated in a stupid subjection to Tyrants absoluteness ; that , this Character of Naphtali , satisfied with favour and full with the blessing of the Lord , that he is a hind let loose from the yoke of Tyrannical slaverie , is far preferable , in the account of all that understand to be Christians or men , to that infamous Stigma of Issachar ( the sin , shame , & miserie of this age ) to be a strong Ass couching under two burdens , and he saw that rest was good , and the Land that it was pleasant , and bowed his shoulder to bear , and became a servant unto tribute . But to all that are not altogether strangers in our Israel it will appear , that this Title is not ineptly applied to the subject and design of this Treatise . The party , whose Case and Cause and Contendings are here treated of , being known to have the same situation of residence in Scotland , that Naphtali had in Israel , viz. the West and the South ( Deut. 33. 23. ) will be found , among all our Tribes , most appositely to bear the signature of Naphtali , who , in their wrestlings for the Interest of Christ and the Liberties of his Israel , have mostly jeoparded their lives in the high places of the fields ; and chiefly to deserve his Elogy , being a hind ( called wild by nick-name in the scorn of them that are at ease , but ) truly weak in their present wilderness Condition , to wrestle against the force & fraud of their Cruel & cunning hunters , who cease not ( when they have now got the rest of the Roes and hinds of the field made fast asleep , under the bondage of the Lions dens & Mountains of Leopards , by a pretence of a falsely so called Liberty of Conscience ) to seek and pursue the chase of them for a prey ; Yet , really they are let loose , and not only suffered to run loose , as a prey to the hunters by the unwatchfullness of their keepers , but made to escape loose , by the mercy of the Mighty one of Iacob , from the nets of the hunters , and snares of the foulers , and from the yoke of the bondage of these beasts of prey , to whose Authority they will not oune a willing subjection : And being such hinds , so let loose , they make it their work , to give goodly words , for the worth and honour and Royalties of their Princely Master , and for the precious Liberties wherewith he hath endoted and entrusted his Spouse and Children , and to keep the goodly words of his patience , untill he return as a Roe or a young Hart upon the Mountains of Bether . This being the party , who are represented as the Wild folk of Scotland , the design of this Treatise is to hold forth the History of their manifold Chases , the Craft , keenness , & Cruelty of their hunters , and the goodlyness of the words of their Testimony : Which , by reason of the likeness of the Testimony of former Periods with the present , and that the latter may be vindicated by the former , is resumed from the beginning of the Church of Scotlands wrestlings against the Enemies of Christ , and deduced through all the most signal steps of this long propagated and hereditary War. And lest my words should not be goodly enough , nor my notions grateful to the Criticks of this age , who cast every thing as new and nice , which is someway singular and not suited to their sentiments ; that it may appear the Cause here cleared and vindicated is not of yesterday , but older than their Grandfathers who oppose it , I dare avouch without vanity , there is nothing here but what is confirmed by Authors of greatest note & repute in our Church , both ancient & modern , namely , Buchanan , Knox , Calderwood , Acts of General Assemblies , Cawses of Wrath , Lex Rex , Apologetical Relation , Napthali , Ius Populi , History of the Indulgence , Banders disbanded , Rectius Instruendum , and some other Authors much respected : whose Authority , more alwayes repelled by rage than ever yet resisted by reason , though I value more , than all the vain oblatrations of the Opposers of this Testimony , and think it sufficient to confute all imputations of its Novelty , and to counterballance the weight that may be laid on the Contradictions of the greatest that treat on this subject : Yet I do not lay so much stress on the reason of their Authority , as on the Authority of their reason ; which is here represented with that Candor and Care , that , lest any should cavil that they are wrested or wronged , when made to speak so patly to the present Controversies , I have chosen rather to transcribe their words , than to borrow their matter dressed up in my own ; except where the prolixity & multiplicity of their Arguments , as clearly demonstrating that which I adduce them for as that for which they were primarly intended , did impose the necessity of abridging them ; which yet is mostly in their oun words , though reduced into a Syllogistical forme . But this obloquie of Novelty being anticipated , when I reflect on the helps I have collected from so many hands , I am rather afraid , the Truths here delivered be comtemned as obsolete and antiquate , than cast at for new speculations . However I am content , yea it is my ambition that nothing here be looked upon as mine , but that it may appear , this is an old Plea ; and that the party here pleaded for , who are stigmatized with many singularities , are a people , who ask the old paths and the good way , that they may walk therein ; and though their paths be not now much paved , by the frequency of passengers , and multitude of Professors walking therein ; and albeit it must indeed be confessed , the word of their Testimony is some way singular , that the same things were never the word of Christs patience , stated as heads of suffering before ; yet they are not untroden paths , but the same way of Truth , which hath been maintained by the witnesses of Christ in all the Periods of our Church , and asserted by the greatest Confessors , though never before sealed by Martyrs . As for the Arguments I bring to clear & confirm them , whether they be accounted mine or borrowed from others , I am very indifferent ; if they prove the point they are brought for , which I hope they will be sound to do : But of this ● am confident , there is nothing here can be condemned , untill some one or more of those grave Authors be confuted , and when that is done ( which will be ad Calendas Graecas , or against the 30. of February ) there is something besides here which will challenge Consideration . The design then of this work is of great importance : even no less than to essay , the discussing the difficulties of all our Conflicts with open Enemies , about the present state of the Testimony ; the vindicating of all the heads of sufferings sustained thereupon , these 27 years past ; the proposing of the right state of the Testimony for the Interest of Christ , not only of this but of all former Periods ; with an account of the propagation & prosecution of the witnessings , wrestlings , and sufferings for it from time to time ; to the end it may appear , not only how great the sufferings have been , since this fatal Catastrophe and overturning of the Covenanted Reformation , and unhappie restauration of Tyrannie and Prelacie ; but that the grounds , upon which they have been stated , are not niceties and novelties ( as they are reproached and reputed by many ) but worthie and weighty Truths of great value and validity , and of near affinity unto & Conformity with the continued series and succession of the Testimonies in all former Periods . So that in this litle Treatise must be contained , a Compendious Historie of the Church of Scotland her Testimony in all ages , a vindication of the present state of it , yea in effect a short Epitome of the substance of those famous forecited Authors , as far as we need to consult them concerning the Controversies of the present time with Adversaries : Which is much , and perhaps too much , to be undertaken in so small a volume . But considering , that many who are concerned in this Cause , yea the most part who concern themselves about it , are such who have neither access nor time nor capacity to revolve the voluminous Labours of these Learned men , for light in this Case ; I have done my best , to bring them into one body of a portable bulk , with as great brevity as could consist well with any measure of perspicuity ; Not medling with any thing , but what I thought might some way conduce to clear some part of the present Testimony . Every undertaking of this nature , cannot but be lyable to several disadvantages that are unavoidable , this hath many discouraging and difficult . One is , that it shall be exposed to the Common fate of such representations , to be stigmatized as a seditious Libel , and so may be sent to the flames to be confuted ; and to enflame the fury of these firebrands , already hell-hot , into the utmost extremity of rage against the Author , that ever Cruelty it self at its fullest freedom did exert , against Truth and reason arraigned and cast for Sedition and Treason : The only Sanctuary in such a Case is , in prospect of this , to have the greater care , that nothing be spoken , but what the Speaker may dare to affirm in the face of Cruelty it self . A Second common disadvantage is obvious from the Consideration of the humor of the Age , wherein fancy hath greater force than faith , and nothing is pleasing but what is parasitical , or attempered to the palat of the Greatest not of the best ; And naked Truth , without the fairdings of flatterie , or paintings of that pâkiness which is commonly applauded as prudence now adayes , is either bogled at or exposed to scorn & Contempt ; and reason , if roundly written , except it meet with an honest heart , is commonly read with a stammering mouth , which puts a T before it , and then it is stumbled at as Treason : This Essay does expect no Entertainment from any , but such who resolve to harbour Truth be the hazard what will , even when the world raises the Hue & Cry after it , and from such who are really groaning , either by suffering or Sympathie , under the same grievances here represented . There is a Third which makes it not a litle difficult , the quality , quantity , & intricacy of the matter , here to be confined to such a Compend . All which together considered , do infer a fourth difficulty , that hardly can it get a pass through the Press ; which is blocked up against all such books , that may offer a manifestation of the innocency of that people , and the injustice & inhumanity of their enemies ; which is their only hope of preventing the worlds knowledge & condemnation of their actings . Yea there is a fifth , that wants not its own difficulty , that though the Press were patent , yet an empty Purse , from a poor impoverished people , will as readily preclude all access to it , as if it were locked up by Law ; but both together make it hard . But there is a sixth disadvantage yet more discouraging , that the man as well as the money is wanting to manage the business : And this needs no other proof , than the necessity of my poor pen to undertake it , instead of a better . It must needs be very low with that people , that stand in need of such a pitiful patrociny as mine is . Our persecuted brethren elsewhere , have this advantage of us , that they have Champions to espouse their quarrel , which we have not ; but only such , who , as they are reputed in the world , so in their own sense , owne themselves to be very unaccomplished for such work ; and under this invincible disadvantage also , that , being forced to a wandering and unsetled life , they have no conveniency , nor can be accommodated with time nor helps to performe it ; and so circumstantiated , that either it must be done at this time , and in this manner , or not at all . In the seventh place , we are at a greater loss than any suffering people , in that among all other bitter ingredients we have this Gall also in our Cup , that they that suffer most among us have not the comfort & benefit of the Sympathie of others , that sufferers use to have from good people . The reason of this makes an Eight discouragement , besides what is said above ; that not only is the Case & Cause of that poor persecuted & wasted Witnessing Remnant obscure in it self , and not known in the world , nay not so much as in the very neighbouring Churches of England & Ireland ; but also more obscured by the malice of Enemies , traducing , calumniating , & reproaching that righteous Remnant whom they intend to ruine ; not indeed as Hereticks ( which is the case of other suffering Churches , wherein they have the advantage of us also , that thô the name be more odious , yet it makes the notion of their Cause and the nature of their enemies more notour , and is more effectual to conciliate Sympathie from all that know , that Protestants are persecuted by Papists under the notion of Hereticks ; But we are at a loss in this , that our Persecuters , at least the most part of the Executioners of the Persecution , will not as yet avouch that Protestanism is Heresie , though we want not this Nick-name likewise from the Chief of them , that are professed Papists ) but as Schismaticks , Seditious , Rebells , Traitors , Murderers , holding Principles inconsistent with Government ( to wit , their Tyranny ) and the peace of humane Society ( to wit , their Association against Religion and liberty ) and therefore to be exterminated out of the world . And this Imposture covering all their mischiefs , hath prevailed so far with the blinded world , that under this brand the Consideration of their Case & Cause is buried , without farther inquirie . This were yet more tolerable from open enemies ; if there were not another more pressing discouragement in the Ninth place , peculiar to them in Scotland ; that having to do with treacherous as well as Truculent Enemies , as they have been much destroyed by open force , so much more by fraud : while by ensnaring favours some have been flattered from the Testimony , others disdaining & suspecting , as well as deprived of and secluded from , these favours , have s●uck to it ; hence Defection brought on Division , and Division Confusion , which hath reduced the Reformation to a ruinous heap . In the next place , as the Consequent of the former , while the purer Remnant have been resolutely prosecuting the Testimony , and not only keeping themselves free of , and standing at the surthest distance from , all degrees of Complyance , but also witnessing against their Brethren involved in them , and thinking it their duty to discountenance them in these Corruptions & backslidings ; they have been therefore reproached and misrepresented very industriously , as Ignorant , imprudent , transported with blind Zeal , Extravagant , wild , Separatists , espousing new & nice notions , Rejecters of the Ministry , Imposers on the Ministry , Denyers of all Government , Usurpers of an imaginary Government of their oun , that died as fools , and as guilty of their oun blood . By which odious & invidious obloquies , they have easily prevailed with many , both at home & abroad , that are more credulous than considerate , to beleeve these things of them : Hence , with prejudicate people a contrary Representation will find difficult acceptance . However this Moreover is another great disadvantage , and renders an Essay to vindicate their sufferings very uneasie , that they are thrust at & tosted on both hands , by Enemies & professed friends : And by Enemies , that are not all Papists : but professed Protestants , ouning the same fundamentalls in opinion , though in practice not holding the same Head : And by friends , that not only are Protestants , but Presbyterians , under the bonds of the same Solemn & Sacred Covenants , the obligation whereof they still oune ; And not only so , but such , whose Piety & Godliness cannot be doubted . This is a Gravamen grievous to bear , & greatly aggravates the difficultie . Finally , the greatest of all is , that not only their Cause is rendered odious , but must be confessed truly to be odd & someway singular ; and therefore will seem strange & surprising to Strangers , to hear an account of extraordinary sufferings for & upon extraordinary Causes , which never were formerly stated as heads of suffering . For now it is the Dragons chiefest stratagem with us , like to be the most subtil , ensnaring , & successful of any , that ever he set on work since ever he began this War with the Lamb , ( which yet I hope will prove as fatal to his Interest as the former ) to bring the sufferings of Christs witnesses to such a state , that may seem to spectators litle or nothing relative to Religion , that so he may destroy both them and their Testimony unlamented , and by that Trick divert others from concerting that same necessary witness in the season thereof . And for this end he will change both matter & manner , in managing the War. He will not now persecute for the old Controverted heads of Poperie , with fire & faggot as formerly , for refusing to worship Our Lady , or the blessed Sacrament of the Altar . These weapons & Engines are so worn out of use , that they will not work now as they did before . And that old Baud of Babylon is become so ugly and out of date , that he does not believe her beauty can be so bewitching , except she put on a new busk . But her Eldest Daughter , the Prelatical Church , of the same Complexion with herself , except that she is coloured with Protestant paint , is fitter for his service , to allure our Land into fornication ; And who will not be entyced , must be forced to Communion with her , by finings , confynings , exactions , extortions , & impositions of Oaths &c. Religion must be litle concerned here : for there is Preaching enough , and of Protestant Doctrine too , and without the Monkie-Tricks , & Montebank showes , & fopperies of English-Popish Ceremonies , & Lyturgical services : What would they be at ? Is it not better to yeeld to this , than to fall into the hand of the Scotish-Spanish-Inquisition , that will rack the Purse , the Body , & Conscience , and all ? This is one Complex head of suffering , and thought a very small one by many . But now finding this would not do his business yet , it looked too like Religion still : He hath therefore invented a new Machin : He will not now Persecute , nor force the Conscience at all ( so good natur'd is the Devil and his Lievetenant grown , in their old age ) for matters of meer Religion . Nay ( if we may believe him , who when he speaketh a lie speaketh it of his own ) he hath not done it this long time , but only , in all the violent Courses exercised against these Sufferers , he hath been Magistratically chastising the disobedience & rebellion , of a few turbulent Traitors , who would not oune the Government . And thus under the notion of Rebellion , & disouning Authority , he hath had access & success to destroy almost an innumerable number of honest & innocent , faithful & fruitful , lovers of Christ ; who though indeed they have had their sufferings stated upon those points , yet I doubt not shall be found among the followers of the Lamb , and Confessors and Martyrs of Christ , who haue overcome by the blood of the Lamb & the word of their Testimony , not loving their lives unto the Death , whose blood is crying for vengeance against the shedders thereof , And He will make inquisition for it , when He comes to overturn , overturn , & take His own right , for which they have been Contending . Nevertheless this is a prejudice too prevalent with many , to misregard the Case & Cause of these Contenders , or any thing that can be said to represent them favourablie . And all these disadvantages , difficulties , & discouragements together considered , would soon cool my Courage , and at first blush make me leave off before I begin , were I not persuaded that it is the Cause of Christ these reproached people are suffering for , and that their great sufferings & reproaches are both alike unjust , from both which the Lord vvill vindicate them , & bring forth their righteousness as the light & their judgment as the noon day , ●n His oun time . In confidence of vvhich , depending on his Conduct , I shall undertake , as briefly as is possible for me , to represent their case , and clear the Cause , so far at least as concerns their Contest vvith their pesecuting Enemies , vvi●h vvhom I only deal at present ; it not being my purpose to descend particularly into their necessitated Contendings vvith Complying Brethren , partly because they vvould make the volume to excresce unto too great a bulk , & because they are to be seen elsevvhere ; yet in effect these also are not only here narratively deduced , but vvhatever is odious in them is vindicated , & vvhat is difficult in some measure enodated . But it may be expected and desiderated , that I should give a distinct deduction of all the Steps of this woful defection , against which a great part of the Testimony hath been stated : but I would have the Reader advertised , I touch only that part of the Testimony which hath been sealed by severe sufferings from enemies . It were a Task transcending my Capacity , and a Theme wherein I have no pleasure , besides that it is inconsistent with my Leasure , to inlarge upon such a sad and shameful subject : Though the world indeed is at a loss , that they that would do it cannot , and they that would & should do it will not ; And it is a greater loss , not only to Scotland , but also to the whole Christian world , that what hath been done in this kind already cannot see the light , or rather that the Church of Christ is deprived of its light , which through the injury of the times , & the disingenuous Prudence of some , who suffer themselves to be imposed upon by the Patrons of Defection , is embezilled & suppressed . I mean that excellent & faithful History of Defection , the posthumous work of famous Mr. M'ward , whose praise is in the Churches : which if they that have it in keeping , would do themselves the honour , and the world the happiness , of publishing it , there would be no more need to discover , from whence , to what , and how , that Church hath fallen & degenerate ; nor so great dissicultie in that indisputable & indispensable duty that such a day calls for , in searching & trying our wayes to the end we may turn again to the Lord ; Nor any necessity for my poor essay , to invite & incite the people of the lord to take Cognizance & Compassion of poor perishing Scotland . I wish that they who have it , may consult more their oun duty and credit , and what they owe to the memory of the dead , the Churches edification , the dayes Testimony , and the honour of Christ , than to continue robbing the world of such a Treasure ; wich I doubt not to call Treason against Christ , & Sacriledge against the Church , & stick not to tell them , if they will not publish it , the world must knovv there was such a thing done . But it not being my design now , to detect or reflect upon all the defections of that declining , & by declensions divided , & by divisions almost ( only not ) destroyed Church ; I shall medle with them no further , than what is necessary to clear the cause ; refering the knowledge and account of them , either to the Notoriety of the grossest of them , or to the more particular enarration of them , to be found in papers emitted & published by the Contenders against them : Of vvhich one is of this same years edition , entituled , The Informatory vindication of a poor , wasted , misrepresented Remnant , &c. In vvhich may be evident , that notvvithstanding of all this darkness & distress , defection & division , under vvhich the Church of Scotland hath been so long & is still labouring , there is yet a poor vvasted , vvounded , rent & almost ruined , but still vvrestling & vvitnessing Remnant , of Professors & Confessors of Christ there , vvho though they have not only had their soulls exceedingly filled vvith the scorning of those that are at ease & vvith the contempt of the proud , but their bodies also killed all day long and counted as sheep for the slaughter , have yet through grace endeavoured to overcome by the blood of the Lamb and the vvord of their Testimony , & have not loved their lives dear unto the death , & have continued to this day contending both against Professed Enemies , & also declining friends , sustaining from both the utmost of rage & reproach . And since that litle book gives an account , vvhat their Conten●ings have been against their backdravving brethren on the right & left hand , I shall spare labour to offer a discussion of them , only endeavour to make it not difficult to decide & determine , on vvhose side Truth lies , by vvhat is here hinted . I shall conclude , vvith advertising the Reader of one thing further ; that , as this Reproached people , for vvhose Testimony I am pleading , is novv the only party that is persecuted in Scotland ( some fevv excepted ; vvho are exempted from the pretended favour of the current Indemnities ) & their persecution still continues , notvvithstanding of the impudent as wel as insnaring Declarations of Universal Liberty to all Dissenters , vvhich they look upon as their honour & happiness , to be thought incapable of Tyrannical & Antichristian favours ; So their past & present oppressions & sufferings are only here in general agregated described as to their kinds , & vindicated as to their causes : the particular deduction of their number , vveight , & measure ; of their names that have been martyred & murdered , both by formality of Lavv & vvithout all formality of Lavv , by Sea & Land , City & Countrey , on Scaffolds & in the fields ; of the manner of their sufferings ; & of the forme of their Trialls & Testimonies , being intended shortly ( if the Lord vvill ) to be emitted & published in a book by it self ; vvhich vvil discover to the vvorld as rare instances of the injustice , illegality , & inhumanity of the Scotish Inquisition , & of the innocency , zeal , ingenuity , & patience of the vvitnesses of Christ , as readily can be instanced in these latter ages . Only here is a taste till more come : vvhich if the Lord shall bless for its designed end , the Glory of God , the vindication of Truth , the information & satisfaction of all Serious Sympathisers vvith Zions sorrovves , & the Conviction or Confutation of Reproachers , so far at least as to make them surcease from their invidious charges of things vvhereof the innocency is here vindicated , I have obtained all my design , & shall desire to give the Lord the praise . To fill up the vacancy of this page , it will not be unprofitable for the Reader , to cast his eye upon these Sentences of Great Authors , which relate to some heads of the following discourse . Erasm. Ut Atagen , aliás vocalis , captus obiuutescit , ita quibusdam servitus adimit vocem , qui liberi loquuntur libere . Nazianzen . Melius est pro pietate dissidium , quam concordia fucata . Bernard . Si autem de veritate sumitur scandalum , utilius est ut scandalum oriatur , quam veritas relinquatur . Bracton . Rex est qui bene regit , Tyramius qui populum opprimit . Cicero . Amittit is omne imperii jus , qui e● imperio Rempublicam oppugnat . Aristot. Qui legi paret , is Deo & legi paret ; qui Regi , homini & belluae . Sweton . Sub paena perjurii non tenentur fidem fervare Regi degeneri . Ambros. Qui non repellit a socio injuriam , si potest , tam est in vitio quam ille qui facit . Chamier . At Cives omnes jus habent insurgendi contra Tyrannos , qui vi aperta regna occupant . Barclai . Contra Monarchom . Tyrannos , ut hostes publicos , non solum ab universo populo , sed à singulis etiam , impeti caedique , jure optimo posse , tota Antiquitas censuit . AN Historical Representation OF THE TESTIMONIES OF THE Church of Scotland , With the true state of the same in all the Periods thereof . WITH A Vindication of the present Testimonie . THe Church of Christ , in the impression of all that have the least spark of the dayes Spirit , is now brought to such a doleful & dreadful Case & Crisis ; that if it may not be reckoned The killing of the Witnesses : yet all that have or desire the knowledge of the times , will judge it no impeachment to the Prophecie to say , it is either very like or near unto it . When now the Devil is come down in great wrath as knowing his time is but short , and therefore exerting all the energy of the venom & violence , Craft & Cruelty of the Dragon : And Antichrist , alias Pope , his Captain General , is now universally prevailing , and plying all his hellish Engines , to batter down , & bury under the rubbish of Everlasting Darkness , what is left to be destroyed of the work of Reformation : And the Crowned heads or horns of the Beast , the Tyrants , alias Kings , of Europe , his Council of War , are advancing their Prerogatives upon the ruines of the Nations & Churches Priviledges , to such a pitch of Absoluteness ; & improving & imploying their power , for promoving their Masters ( the Devil & Antichrists ) Interests , to whom they have gifted the Churches , mancipated their own , and sacrificed the Nations Interest ; and that with such combination of Counsels , & Countenance of providential success , that all the Powers of Hell , the Principalities of Earth , & the Providence of Heaven , overruling all things for the accomplishment or the Divine purpose , & purchase , & prediction , seem to conspire to produce that prodigious Period , and ultimus Conatus of the Churches Enemie . And the commencement is so far advanced , that , now in all the Churches of Europe , either the Witnesses of Christ are a killing , or the witness for Christ is in a great measure killed ; either the followers of the Lamb , who are cal●ed & chosen & faithful , are killed for their Testimony , or fainting in their Zeal , and falling from their first Love , they are cooled or cajoled from their Testimony . Some are indulging themselves in their ease , settleing on their Lees , & sleeping in a stupid security ; And , while the Lord is roaring from above , & His & their Enemies raging about them , & designing to raze them after they have ruined their Neighbours , they are rotting away under the destructive Distempers of detestable Neutrality , loathsom lul●warmness , declining & decaying in Corruptions , defections , divisions , distractions , confusions , & so judicially infatuated with darkness & delusions , that they forget & forgo the necessary Testimony of the day . Others again , outwearied with the length & weight of the Tryal , under the tentation of Antichrists formidable strength on the one hand , & a deceitful prospect of an insnaring Liberty on the other , are overcome either to be hectored or flattered from their Testimony . And so in these Churches , comprehending all that are free from Persecution at this time , the Witness for Christ is in a great measure killed . Other Churches , which are keeping & contending for the word of Christs patience , are so wasted . & almost worn out , with Persecutions , afflictions , & calamities , that , after they have been & are ( so much ) daylie killed for the Word of God , & the Testimony of Jesus , it may well be said , there hath been & is a great slaughter of the Witnesses . And it were hard to determine , which of them can give the largest & most lamentable account of their sufferings , or which of them have had the greatest & most grievous experiences , of the Treachery & Truculency , Violence & Villanie , of Atheistical & Papistical Enemies : whether the Reformed Church of France , howling under the paw of that devouring Lyon , the French Tyrant ; or the Protestants of Hungary , under the tearing Clawes of that ravenous Eagle the Tyrant of Austria ; or those of Piedemont , under the grassant Tyranny of that litle Ty●er of Savoy . The accounts they give in print , the reports they bring with them in their flight from their respective Countreyes , & the litle Hints we have in Gazetts & News Letters , must needs enforce a conviction , if not extort a Compassion , of the greatness of their pressures ; & that with such a parity , that it is doubtful which preponderats . I shall not make comparisons , nor aggravate nor extenuate the sufferings of any of the Churches of Christ , beyond or below their due measures : But will presume to plead , that Scotland , another Ancient & sometimes famous Reformed Church , be enrolled in the Catalogue of suffering Churches , besides these mentioned ; and crave , that she may have a share of that Charity & Sympathy , which is the demand & desire of afflicted Churches of Christ , from all the fellow members of that same body : And so much the rather is this her due ; that , whereas among all the rest of the Churches , Christs witnesses are killed in some particular respect , & each of them have their own proper complaint of it ; some upon the account of Persecution , some of defection , division &c. Of this it may be said , in all respects , both the witnesses of Christ , and a witness for Christ , are killed with a witness . This is the Case of the sometimes Renouned , famous , faithful , & fruitful , Reformed , Covenanted Church of Scotland , famous for unity , faithful for verity , fruitful in the purity of Doctrine , Worship , Discipline , & Government ; which now , for these 27 years past , under the Domination of the late Tyrant & present Usurper of Brittain , hath been so wasted with oppression , wounded with Persecution , rent with Division , ruined with defection , that now she is as much despised , as she was before admired : And her Witness & Testimony for Reformation , is now as far depressed & suppressed in obscuritie as it was formerly declared & depredicated in glory & honour . And yet , which should move the greater commiseration , her witnessings & wrestlings , Tryalls & Tentations , have not been inferiour , in manner or measure , quality or continuance , to any of the forementioned Churches , thô in extent not so great , because her precinct is not so large , whereby the number of her oppressed & murdered Children could not be so multiplyed , though her Martyrs be more , and the manner of their Murder more illegal , than can be instanced in any of them , during that time . A particular enumeration or enarration whereof , cannot be here exhibited , but is referred & reserved to a peculiar Treatise of that Subject , which ere long the world may see . Only I shall give a compendious account of the kinds & causes , grounds and Heads , of their sufferings , who have been most slighted & least sympathised with , though they have sustained the greatest severities of any ; and inend endeavour to vindicate the Merit of their Cause , in the most principal heads upon which their sufferings have been stated : Whereby it will appear to impartial men , that will not be imposed upon , there hath been , & yet is , a great & grievous , & some way uparalleled , Persecution in Scotland , at least inferiour to none : Which hath not hitherto been culy considered , with any proportion to the importance thereof . But thô this be the Scope , it is not the summe of what is intended in this Discourse . The Method I have proposed to prosecute it withall , will discover it : Which is . 1. To give a brief & summary account , of the Series & Succession , success & result , of the several Contendings of the Witnesses of Christ , against His Enemies in Scotland from time to time ; that it may appear ; whether or not the present sufferings as now stated can be condemned , if the former be approven . 2. To rehearse some of the chief means , methods , & measures , that the Popish , Prelatical , & Malignant saction , have managed , for the ruin of this witnessing Remnant , & some of the most signal steps of sufferings sustained by & from these within these 27 years ; by which it will appear , that the Persecution in Scotland hath been very remarkable ( though litle regarded ) both in respect of the injustice , illegality , & inhumanity of the Persecutors , & in respect of the innocency , Zeal , & ingenuity of the Persecuted . 3. To clear the state & vindicate the merit of the cause of their sufferings , as to the most material heads of it , that are most controverted at this time . In the first of these , I must study all compendious brevity , as may consist with the clearing of my Scope : which is not to enlarge an Historical deduction , of the rise & result , progress & prosecution , occasion & continuation , of every Controversie the Church hath had with her several Adversaries in several Periods ; But only to hint at the chief Heads of their contendings , with a design to make it appear ; that the most material Heads of sufferings that are now condemned , as new & nice notions , have been transmitted from age to age , from the beginning even to this present time , through all the Periods of this Church . PERIOD . I. Comprehending the Testimony of the Culdees . IT is not without reason reckoned among the peculiar prerogatives of the renouned Church of Scotland , that Christs conquest in the conversion of that Nation , is one of the most eminent Accomplishments of Scripture Prophecies , of the propagation of His Kingdom in the New Testament Dispensation : Not only because it was , when called out of Gentile Paganisme , among the rudest of Heathen Nations , & in the ackowledgment of all , among the uttermost parts of the Earth , which were given to Christ for His inheritance & possession ; Whereunto He had , & hath still , undoubted right , by His Fathers grant , & by His oun purchase ; and took Infeofment of it by a glorious conquest , of that Land which the Roman Armes could never subdue , & erected His victorious Trophees there , whither their Triumphs could never penetrate , obtaining & thereby accomplishing that predicted Song of praise , From the uttermost parts of the Earth have we heard Songs , even Glory to the righteous ; Which gives us groun● to expect , that however Christs Interest there be now very low , and like to be lost as a prey in the Dragons Mouth , Yet Christ , having such undoubted & manifold right to it , will not so easily quit or forego His possession : But also because , He hath so constantly continued His possession , & maintained His Title , by a long course of Contendings , by the Testimonies of His witnesses , against the Invaders thereof , through all the Periods of the Church , from the very infancy of this new Dispensation : And because , Scotlands conversion into the Christian Faith was among the first fruits of the Gentiles , of the oldest date , that any standing Church holding the head Christ this day can deduce its original from . For it is clear from Ancient Records , the Christian Faith was imbraced here , a few years after the Ascension of our Saviour , being taught by the Disciples of Iohn the Apostle ; & received afterwards great increment from the Brittons , flying to Scotland to escape the Persecution of the Emperour Domitian , & was long promoted by the ancient Culdees or Cultores Dei ; men whose memory is still fragrant , for piety & purity of faith & life , who continued some hundreds of years , under various vicissitudes of Providence , before either Prelacy or Poperie was known in Scotland . They were first universally encouraged by King Cratilinth , in the time of the last Persecution under Dioclesian , which brought many of Christs witnesses hither for Shelter , who were very helpful for the setling of Truth , & the total extirpation of the Idolatry of the Druides , the Heathen Priests ; whereby the pure Doctrine , Worship , & Government also of Christs Institution , was established & continued many years , while these Witnesses of Christ had no other emulation but of well doing & to advance Pietie . In this Period , these ancient & first Confessors & Witnesses of Christ , did wrestle strenously , according to their strength & light , for the Truths & words of Christs patience , controverted in their day , both against professed Enemies Pagan Persecutors & 〈◊〉 , & pretended friends corrupters of the Faith. Their Testimony was stated , in a peculiar manner , for the verity , value , & vertue of Christs Natures & Offices , in 〈…〉 rel●●ive to either , against the Malignants & Sectaries of their time : particularly for the concerns of His Pr●phetical Office. And though we be at a loss , that for the most art their witness is buried in oblivion , through the darkness of the times succeeding : yet the scraps & fragments that are left , do furnish us with these few Remarks . I. They maintained the verity of the Christian Doctrine , against both Pagan Persecutors , & Heretical perverters ; And the purity of His instituted worship , without the vanity of humane inventions , or conformity with , either the Druides on the one hand , or the Hereticks on the other : with which , sometime befor the end of that Period , they were in●ested : Chiefly the Pelagians , with whom the faithful would have no communion , but abstracted themselves in a Monastical life , liveing & exercising their Religion in Cells , from whence many places in the Countrey yet retain the name , as Kilmarnock , Kil-Patrick &c. that is the Cells of these eminent men among the Culdees . And their Government also , was that of the primitive order without Bishops , with litle vanity , but great simplicity & holyness . Many Authors do testity , that near about 400 years the Church of Scotland knew nothing of the Episcopal Hierarchy , untill Pa●adius brought it in , & not without great opposition . II. In these Recesses , they had the advantage , both of outward peace when others were in trouble , & of inward peace of conscience , when others were debauched with many conjurations , & abjurations , combinations & confederacies , imposed & exacted by them that prevailed for the time : whereby they might both keep themselves free of insnaring Oaths , perfidious complyances , & Associations with the wicked , & also intertain & incourage the oppressed for equity , who fled unto their sanctuary for safety . We find they refused to enter into League with malignant Enemies . One memorable passage I shall insert ( though strictly it belong not to this Period , as I distinguish it , yet falling out , within 80 years thereafter , in the time of the Culdees , it will not obscurely evidence the truth of this ) Goranus the 45 King of Scots , earnestly dissuaded Lothus , King of Picts , to entertain the League with the Saxons , not only because they were treacherous & cruel , but because they were Enemies to the Countre● & to the Religion they professed , concluding thus , Homi●i vero Christiano id longe omnium videri &c. But to a Christian nothing must seem more grievous , than to consent to such a Covenant , as will extinguish the Christian Religion , & reduce the profane Customes of the Heathen , & arme wicked Tyrants the enemies of all humanity & piety against God & His Law : whereupon Lothus was perswaded to relinquish the Saxons . Buchan . Histor. rer . Scotic . III. Though they were not for partaking in wicked unnecessary Wars , without authority or against it ; yet we have ground to conclude , they were for War , & did maintain the principle of resisting Tyrannie : since there was never more of the pactice of it , nor more happy resistances in any age , than in that . Where we find , that , as their Ancestors had frequently done before , so they also followed their footsteps , in resisting , reduceing to order . repressing , & bringing to condign punishment , Tyrant ; & Usurpers ; And thought those actions , which their Fathers did by the light of nature & dictates of reason , worthy of imitation , when they had the advantage of the light of Revelation & dictates of Faith ; the one being indeed moderate & directed but no ways contradicted by the other . Therefore we read ; that , as their Predecessors had done with Thereus the 8 th King of Scotland , whom they banished in the year before Christs Incarnation 173. With Durstus the II King , whom they slew in Battel , in the year befor Christ 107. Evenus 3. who was imprisoned & dyed there , in the year befor Christ 12. Dardanus , the 20 th King , who was taken in Battel , beheaded by his oun Subjects , his head exposed to Mockage , & his body cast into a sink , Anno Christi 72. Luctatus the 22. King , who was slain for his Leachery & Tyranny , anno 110. Mogaldus the 23. King , slain anno 113. Conarus the 24. King , a Leacherous tyrant , dyed in Prison , anno 149. Satrael the 26. King , hanged anno 159. So , after the Christian Faith was publickly professed , they pursued Athirco , the 29. King , when degenerate into Tyranny , who was forced to kill himself anno 231. They slew Nathalocus , the 30. King , & cast him into a privy anno 242. They beheaded Romachus , the 36. King , and caryed about his head for a show , anno 348. As they did with many others afterwards , as witnesseth Buchan . lib. 4. Histor. Scotic , IV. Whence it is evident , that as they attained , even in these primitive times , & maintained the purity & freedom of their Ministery , independent on Pope , Prelate , or any humane Supremacy ( that Antichristian Hierarchy , & Erastian blasphemie , not being known in those dayes ) so they contended for the order & boundaries of the Magistracy , according to Gods appointment & the fundamental constitutions of their Government ; & thought it their duty to shake off the yoke , & disoune the Authority of these Tyrants that destroyed the same . Yea we find that even for incapacity , stupidity , & folly , they disouned the Relation of a Magistrate , & disposed of the Government another way , as they did with Ethodius 2. whose authority they did oune , but Titulo tenus . See Buchan . loco Citato , PERIOD . II. Comprehending the Testimonie of the same Culdees with that of the Lollards . THe following Period was that fatal one , that brought in universal Darkness on the face of the whole Church of Christ , and on Scotland with the first of them : which , as it received very early Christianity , so it was with the first corrupted with Antichristianisme : For that Mystorie of iniquity that had been long working , till he who letted was taken out of the way , found Scotland ripe for it when it came : which , while the Dragon did persecute the woman in the wilderness , did vallantly repell his Assaults , but when the Beast did arise , to whom he gave his power , he prevailed more by his subtiltie , than his rampant Predecessor could do by his rage . Scotland could Resist the Roman Legions while heathenish , but not the Roman Locusts when Antichristian . At his very first appearance in the world under the Character of Antichrist , his harbinger Palladius brought in Prelacy to Scotland , & by that conveyance the contagion of Popery : which hath always been , as every where so especially in Scotland , both the Mother & Daughter , cause & effect , occasion & consequence , of Popery . These rose , stood , & lived together , & sometimes did also fall together : & we have ground to hope , that they shall fall again ; & their final & fatal fall is not fa● off . Whatever difficulty Authors do make , in calculating the Epocha of the 42 moneths of Antichrists duration in the world , because of the obscurity of his first rise ; yet there needs not be much perplexity in finding out that Epocha in Scotland , nor so much discouragment from the fancyed permanency of that Kingdom of wickedness . For if it be certain , as it will not be much disputed , that Popery & Prelacy came in by Palladius , sent Legate by Pope Celestine , about the year 450. then if we adde 42 Moneths or 1260 Prophetical d●yes , that is years , we may have a comfortable prospect of their Tragical conclusion . And though both clashings & combinations , oppositions & conjunctions , this day may seem to have a terrible aspect , portending a darker hour befor the Dawning ; yet all these ●eelings & revolutions , though they be Symptoms of wrath incumbent upon us for our sins , they may be looked upon , through a prospect of faith , as presages & prognosticks of Mercy impendent for His Names Sake , encouraging us , when we see these dreadful things come to pass in our day , to lift up our heads for the day of our Redemption draweth nigh . This dark Period continued ●igh about 1100 years , in which though Christs witnesses were very few , yet He had some witnessing & Prophecieing in sackcloth all the while . Their Testimony was the same with that of the Waldenses & Albingenses , slated upon the grounds of their secession or rather abstraction from that Mystery Babylon , Mot●●●r of harlots Popery & Prelacy , for their corruption in Doctrine , worship , Discipline , & Government . And did more particularly relate to the concerns of Christs Priestly Office , which was transmitted from the Culdees to the Lollards , And by them handed doun to the Instruments of Reformation , in the following Period . Their Testimony indeed was not Active , by way of forcible resistance , against the Soveraign Powers ; but passive , by way of Confession & Martyrdom , & sufferings & verbal contendings , & witnessings against the prevailing corruptions of the time . And no wonder it should be so , & in this some way different from ours , because that was a dispensation of suffering , when Antichrist was on the Ascendant , & they had no call nor capacity to oppose him any other way , and were novv spirited for this passive Testimony , in which circumstances they are an excellent pattern for imitation , but not an example for confutation of that principle of defensive resistence which they never contradicted , & had never occasion to confirm by their practice . But as in their manageing their Testimony , their manner was somevvay different from ours on this respect ; so they had far the advantage of us , that their cause was so clearly stated upon the greatest of heads of sufferings , having the clearest connexion with the fundamentals of Religion . Yet we shall find in this Period our Heads of suffering someway homologated , if we consider . I. That as they did faithfully keep & contend for the word of Christs patience under that dispensation , in asserting & maintani●g both the verity of Christs Doctrin , & the purity of His Worship , by testifieing against the corruptions , errors , Idolatries , & Superstitions of Popery ; so they did constantly bear witness against the usurpation & Tyrannical domination of the Antichristian Prelats . And as the Culdees did vigorously oppose their first introduction , and after aspiring domination , as well as the corruptions of their Doctrine , As we have the contendings of Eminent witnesses recorded from age to age ; in the fourth & fifth Age , Columbe , Libthac , Ethernan , Kintogerne or Mungo ; in the Sexth & seventh Age , Colmanus , C●emens , & Samson with others , in the Eight & ninth Age , Alcuin , Rabanus Maurus , Ioannes Scotus Acrigena , are noted in Historie ; And the Lollards , by their Examinations & Testimonies , are found to have witnessed against the exercise of their power , & sometimes against the very Nature of their power it selfe : so in their practise , they condemned Prelacy as well as Popery , in that their Ministers did in much painfullness , poverty , simplicity , Humility , & Equality , observe the Institution of our Lord. And so far as their light served , & had occasion to inquire into this point , they acknowledged no officer in the House of God superior to a preaching Minister , & according to this standart they rejected & craved Reformation of exorbitant Prelacy . And it is plain that they were frequently discovered , by discountinanceing & withdrawing from their superstitions & Idolatrous worship : for all which , when they could not escape nor repell their violence , they cheerfuly embraced & endured the flames . II. That their Adversaries did manage their cruel craft , & crafty cruelty , in murdering those Servants of God , much after the same methods that ours do ; except that they are many stages outdone by their successors , as much as perfect Artists do outstrip the rude beginings of Apprentices . But on the other hand , the Suffe●ers in our day , that would follow the example of those Worthyes under Popery , would be much condemned by this generation , even by them that commend the matter of their Testimony , though they will not allow the manner of it to be imitated in this day . The Adversaries of Christ in this & that generation , are more like then his Confe●sors & witnesses are . The Adversaries then , when constrained by diversions of the times troubles , or when their designes were not ripe , pretended more moderation & aversation from severity , but no sooner got they opportunity ( which always they sought ) but so soon they renewed the Battel against Jesus Christ ; so now : when they had seven abominations in their hearts , & many cursed designes in their heads , they always spoke fairest ; so now : when they had a mind to execute their cruelty , they would resolve befor-hand whom to pitch upon before conviction ; so now : And when so resolved , the least pretence of a fault , obnoxious to their wicked Law , would serve their design ; so now : They used then to forge Articles , & falsly misrepresent their answers , & declarations of their principles ; so now . Yet on the other hand , if now poor sufferers should glory in that they are counted worthy to suffer shame for the name of Christ , as they did then ; If now they should suffer with as great cheerfullnesse , for the smallest points as for the greatest heads , as they did then , who endured the flames as gallantly , for eating a Goose upon Friday , as others did for the Doctrin of Justification , or Purgatory , or Indulgences , or worshipping of Images & Saints ; If now they should speak for every truth in question , with all simplicity & plainness , without reserves or shifts declining a Testimony , as they did ; If they should supersede from all applications to their Enemies for savour , & not medle with either petitioning or bonding with them , as they did ; nay not accepting deliverance , that they might obtain a better resurrection : Then they might expect the severe Censure of ignorant & precise fools , as the most part who suffer now are counted . III. That they stood aloof from every appearance of a base Complyance with them ; not so much as to give them an interpretative sign of it , which in their meaning might be thought a recantation , though abstractly consideredit might be capable of a more favourable construction : As the required burning of their Bill was ; which might have been thought a condemning of their accusations : but because that was not their Adversaries sense of it , they durst not do it . Not like many now a dayes , who will not be solicitous to consult that . Neither would they take any of their Oaths , nor pay any of their Eccllesiastical Exactions , as we find in the Articles brought in against the Lollards of Kyle . Knox Hist. of Reform . These things are easily complyed with now : and such as will suffer upon such things are condemned . IV. That while the Love of God and his blessed Truth , and the precepts , promise , & presence of our Lord Jesus Christ , did enable them into all patience with joy , in a passive Testimony , being by the call of a clear 8 : necessary providence sent & sett forth to behis witnesses ; they did not indeed endeavour any resistence : yet we find they never resigned nor abandoned that first & most just priviledge of resistence ; nay , nor bringing publick beasts of prey to condigne punishment , in an extraordinary way of vindictive Justice , for the Murder of the Saints . As , upon the Murder of Mr. George Wishchard , was done with Cardinal Beaton , who was slain in the tower of St. Andrews by Iames Melvin : who perceiving his consorts in the interprise moved with passion , withdrew them & said ; this work & judgment of God , although it be secret , ought to be done with greater gravity , And , presenting the point of the sword to the Cardinal , said , Repent thee of thy former wicked life , but especially of the shedding of the blood of that notable instrument of God , Mr. George Wishchard , which albeit the flame of fire consumed before men , yet it cryes for vengeance upon the● & we from God are sent to revenge it ; for here , before my God , I protest , that neither the hatred of thy person , the love of thy riches , nor the fear of any trouble thow couldst have d●me to me in particular , moved or moveth me to strike thee , but only because thow hast been & remainest an obstinate Enemy against Christ Iesus , & His holy Gospel . Of which fact , the famous & faithful Historian Mr Knox speaks very honorably , and was so far from condemning it , that while after the slaughter they kept out the Castle , he with other Godly men went to them & stayed with them , till they were together caryed captives to Fr●nce . Yet now such a fact , committed upon such another bloody & treacherous Beast , the Cardinal Prelat of Scotland , eight years agone , is generally condemned as horrid Murther . V. However , tho in this dark Period there be no noted instances of these witnesses resisting the Superior powers , for reasons above hinted : yet in this Period , we find many instances of noble & vertuous Patriots , their not only resisting , but also revenging to the utmost of severity rigorous & raging Tyrants . As may be seen in Histories . For before the corruption of Antichrist came to its hight , we find Ferchardus I. the 52. K. was drawen to judgment against his will , great crimes were layd to his charge , & among others the Pelagian heresie , & contempt of Baptisme , for which he was cast into Prison , where he killed himself ; anno 636. Eugenius 8. the 62. King degenerating into wickednesse , & rejecting the Admonitious of his friends & especially of the Ministers , was killed in a convention of his nobles , with the consent of all , anno 765. Donaldus 7. was imprisoned , where he killed himself , anno 859. Ethus , surnamed Alipes , the 72. King was apprehended , & his wicked life layd out befor the people , & then compelled to resigne the Government , & dyed in Prison , anno 875. Afterwards when the Government was transmitted to the Stewarts , Iames the 2. the 103. King , who killed William E. of Douglas in the Castle of Sterling , most treacherously after he had pretended a civil treatment , was publickly defyed by the Earles friends ; who took the Kings publick writ & subscription made to the said Earle , & tyed it to a horse tail , dragging it through the streets , & when they came to the Mercat place they Proclaimed both King & Nobles perjured Covenant-breakers : And thereafter when E. Iames his Brother , was desired to submit , he answered , he would never put himself in their reverence , who had no regard to shame , nor to the lawes of God or man , and who had so perfidiously & treacherously killed his Brother & his Cousins . Iames 3. the 104. King for his Treachery & Tyranny was opposed & purswed by armes by his oun subjects ; who finding himself under disadvantages , sent to the rebells ( as he thought them & called them ) an offer of peace , & received this answer ; that seeing the King did nothing honestly , a certain war seemed better to them then a peace not to be trusted , that there was no other hope of agreement but one , that he should quite the Government , otherwise it was to no purpose to trouble themselves with treaties . Thereafter in a battel he was slain at Bannockburn , by Gray , Ker , & Borthwick . Iames the 4. the 105. King was also constrained , by the valour of Archibald Douglas E. of Angus called Bell the Cat ▪ to reforme the Court , and put away some wicked Sycophants from his Counsel , and give way tho against his will to the execution of judgement upon others : which was the occasion of that foresaid Agnomen to the Earle . For , he with other Nobles , in a meeting at Lawder , consulting how to reform & repress the insolency of the Court , had the Apologue of the Mice laid out before them ; that the Mice ●ell upon deliberating how to be rid of the Cat , & concluded the best way was to put a bell about her neck , but when it came to be put in execution , never a Mouse durst undertake it : The Earle quickly made application , saying , I will bell the Cat ; & forthwith went out & meeting Cochran , one of these wicked Consellours , took hold of him , & hanged him with a horse halter over the bridge of Lawder , & rushing in to the Kings presence proceeded to snatch Ramsey , another of the countreyes Enemies , out of the Kings Armes , but that he yeelded at length to the Kings earnest entreaties to spare him . However we see how generously zealous these noble Patriots were for the countries good , against Tyrannie , thô they were ignorant of Religion : Yet this all alongs was still the character of the Scots in these dayes , none more terrible to Tyrants , none more Loyal to Kings then they . PERIOD . III. Containing the Testimonie of the Reformation from Poperie . AS in the former the Testimony was mostly Passive , so in the following Period , when they were increased in number & strength that embraced the Gospel , the Lord called & spirited to an Active Testimony , for these two Twins , Religion & Liberty , that were then sought to be stifled in the birth , & are now designed more declaredly to be destroyed , after they have growen up to some maturity : Which , as it renders the cruelty of the present destroyers the more grassant & grievous , so it rubs the more indeleble Infamie , on the shamfull security & Ass-like stupidity of this generation , that have received such an excellent Testimony deposited to their trust , transmitted to them through a continued trāct of the witnessings & wrestlings of their worthy Ancestors , and now let it slip & slide through their feeble fingers ; And does the more justify , yea magnify , the poor endeavours of the present Sufferers , who at least , when they cannot react these mighty works in defending Religion & Liberty , do choose rather to die than to resign the Testimony , or quite the least Priviledge that their Progenitors possessed them of : And though they be superciliously despised , as litle insignificant nothings , in the eyes of the bulk of the big boasters of this blind age ; yet , if these valiant Heroes who did such exploits for their God , in commenceing & carying on the work of Reformation , were now to see the dull Dotages of this dreaming generation ( not only suffering & consenting to , but congratulating & applauding , the introduction & reestablishment of Idolatry & Tyranny , Popery & Slavery , upon the ruines of the work they built with so great expence . ) And were to read the pitiful Petitions , and airy & empty , flattering & fauning Addresses , to this Antichristian Tyrant , for the Toleration of that Religion & Liberty , under the odious notion of a Crime , which they had conveyed to them under the security of a fundamental Law ; They , if any , would be acknowledged as their Children , who disdain & disoune such dishonorable & dastardly yeeldings , and are therefore most despised with disdain & despight . A brief Rehearsal of their Contendings will clear the Case . While the Queen Dowager Regent reigned by the curse of God , and employed all her power & policy to suppress the Gospel in Scotland ; God so Counteracted her , that the blood of the Martyrs she caused to be murdered proved the seed of the Church ; and the endeavours of His Servants had such success , that no small part of the Barons & Gentlemen , as well as commons , began to abhor the Tyranny of the Bishops : yea men almost universally began to doubt , whether they could without sin give their bodily presence to the Masse , or offer their Children to the Papistical Baptisme ? Whether these that were in any publick trust , could with safe conscience serve the higher Powers , in maintaini●g of Idolatry , persecuting their Brethren , & suppressing Christs Truth ! or whether they might suffer their Brethren to be murdered in their presence , without any declaration that such Tyrannie displeased them ? And from the Scriptures they were resolved , that a lively Faith required a plain Confession , when Christs Truth is impugned ; And that not only they be guilty that do evil , but also they that consent to evil , and this they should do , if seeing such things openly committed , they should be silent , and so allow whatsoever was done . From doubts they came to determinations , to endeavour that Christ Iesus His glorious Gospel should be Preached , His holy Sacraments truely ministred , Superstition , Idolatry , & Tyranny should be suppressed in this Realme ; And that both as to the Worship , Discipline , & Government , the Reverend face of the first primitive & Apostolick Church should be reduced again to the eyes & knowledge of men . And in this they never fa●nted till the work was finished . To accomplis● this , famous and faithfull Mr Knox , and other Servants of the Lord , did Preach diligently in Private Meetings . And for that , when they were summoned before the Queen ; several zealous & bold men repaired to her , & plainly in the hearing of the Prelats , did charge them with the cruel device intended , & told her with a vow , they should make a day of it , because they oppressed them & their tennents , for feeding of their idle bellies , they troubled the Preachers , and would murder all ; should they suffer this any longer ? No , it should not be . Thereafter , the more effectually to prosecute the Reformation begun , they entered into Covenants , to maintain & advance that work of Reformation , And to stand to the Desence thereof ; and of one another , against all wicked Power , that might intend Tyranny or trouble against them , and to resent any injury done to any of their Brerhren , upon the account of the Common Cause , as done to all . Of which Covenants they entered into many very solemnly : one was at Edinburgh anno 1557. Another at Perth , 1559. Another at Sterling 1559. binding , that none should have any correspondence with the Queen , without notifieing it to one another , And that nothing should proceed therein , without common Consent of them all . Another at Leith , anno 1560. Another at Air , anno 1562. of the same tenor . By which Covenants , as their Conjunction was the more firme among themselves , so was it the more fearful to their Adversaries ; when according to the tenor of them they kept their Conventions , & held Counsells with such gravity & clossness , that the enemies trembled . I mention these things more particularly , because these same very things commended in our Fathers , are now condemned in a poor handful , that wo●ld aim at imitating their example , in renewing & reiterating such Covenants of the same Nature & Tenor , & binding to the same very duties , and prosecute in the same methods of keeping General Meetings for Correspondence , & consultation about common mutual Duties in common danger ; whereunto they have not only present necessity to urge them , but also preterite examples of these Worthies to encourage them , and their experience of comfort & tranquillity they reaped , by these Christian Assemblies & Godly Conferences , as ost as any danger appeared to any member or members of their body . These beginings the zealous Covenanted Reformers left no means unessayed to promote , by Protestations to the Parliament , & Petitions , & many reiterated Addresses to the Queen Dowager : From whom they received many renewed fair promises ; which she had never mind to keep , and wanted not the impudence , when challenged for breaking them , to declare , It becomes not Subjects to burthen their Princes with promises , further then it pleased them to keep the same : And at another time , that she was bound to keep no Faith to Hereticks : And again , that Princes must not be strictly bound to keep their promises ; And that her self would make litle Conscience to take from all that sort their Lives & Inheritance , if she might do it with an honest excuse . Wherein she spoke not only the venome of her oun heart , but the very soul & sense , principle & project , of all Popish Princes : Whereby we may see what security we have for Religion & Liberty this day , though the most part make such a pretence a pillow to sleep on . But after many Discoveries in this kind of the Queens Treachery , at length they would no more be bribed by promises , blinded by pretences , nor boasted by her Proclamations , ( slandering their interprise , as if it pertained nothing to Religion ) from their endeavours to prosecute the same : but finding themselves compelled to take the Sword of Just defence , against all that should persue them for the matter of Religion , they first signified unto her ; That they would notifie to the King of France ; & all Christian Princes , that her cruel unjust & most Tyrannieal murther intended against Touns & Mnltitudes , was & is the only Cause of their revolt from their accustomed obedience , which they ouned & promised to their Soveraign ; provided they might live in Peace & Liberty , and enjoy Christs Gospel , without which they firmly purpose never to be subject to mortal man ; And that better it were to expose their bodies to a thousand deaths , than to deny Christ ; which thing not only do they , who commit open Idolatry , but also all such , as , seeing their Brethren purswed for the Cause of Religion , and haveing sufficient means to comfort & assist them , do nevertheless withdraw from them their dutiful support . And thereafter , they published a Declaration to the generation of Antichrist , the pestilent Prelats , & their shavelings within Scotland . That they should not be abused , thinking to escape just punishment , after that they in their blind fury had caused the blood of many to be shed , but if they proceeded in this their malicious Cruelty , they should be dealt with all , wheresoever they should be apprehended , as Murderers , & open Enemies to God & to Mankind . And that with the same measure they had measured , & intended to measure to others , it should be measured to them — that is , they should , with all force & power they had , execute just vengeance & punishment upon them ; yea begin that same War which God commandeth Israel to execute against the Canaanites , that is , Contract of Peace should never be made , till they desist from their open Idolatry & cruel Persecution of Gods Children . I rehearse this Declaration the more expresly , because in our day Declarations of this stile & strain , and aiming at the same Scope , is hideously hissed & houted at as unheard of novelties . Finally , when by all their Letters , Warnings , Admonitions & Protestations , they could obtain no redress , but rather an increase of insupportable violence ; they proponed the Question in a General Meeting : Whether she , whose pretences threatened the bondage of the whole Commonwealth , ought to be suffered so Tyrannically to domineer over them ? Unto which the Ministers , being required to give their judgment , answered , that she ought not . And accordingly they declared her deposed , from all Government over them ; because of her persecuting the Professors of the true Religion , and oppressing the Liberties of the true Lieges , never being called nor convinced of any Crime ; because of her intrusion of Magistrats against all order of Election ; because of her bringing in strangers to suppress the Liberty of the Countrey , and placing them in greatest Offices of Credite , because of her altering and subverting the old Laws of the Realme &c. Which I mention , because hence we may see what things our Fathers judged , did dissolve the relation between the people & their Rulers : And when applyed to our Case , will justify their reasons that have renounced the present Tyranny : This was done at Edinburgh , anno 1559. And thereafter , while they vindicated themselves , & went on with the work of Reformation , throwing doun all monuments of Idolatry , & propogateing the Reformed Religion ; God so blessed their endeavours that their Confession of faith , and all Articles of the Protestant Religion , was Read & Ratified by the three Estates of Parliament , at Edinburgh Iulij 1560. And the same year the Book of Discipline , containing the forme & order of Presbyterial Government , was subscribed by a great part of the Nobility . Thus through the wisdom & power of God alone , even by the weaknesse of very mean Instr●ments , against the rage & fury of the devil , and of all the powers of Hell , was this work of Reformation advanced & effectuated ; And came to the establishment of a Law , which did not only ratifie & confirme the P●ote●●ant Religion , but abolish Antichristian Popery , and appoint punishment for the Professors & promoters thereof . Which Law , often confirmed & ratified afterwards , though it be now cassed & rescinded by the Prerogative of the present Tyrant , because it anulls & invalidates his pretence to succession in the Government ( it being expressly enacted afterwards , by a Parliament at Edinburgh 156. Confirming this , that all Princes & Kings hereafter before their Coronation shall take Oath to maintain the true Religion then professed , & suppress all things contrary to it ) yet is still in force in the hearts of all honest men , that will not prostitute Religion , Law , & Liberty to the lusts of Tyrants ; and will be accounted a better bottom to build the hope of enjoying Religion upon , than the perfidious promises of a Popish Usurper , pretending a Liberty to dissenting Protestants , by takeing away the Penal Statuts , the Legal Bulwark against Popery : All which yet , to the reproach of all Protestants , some are applauding & Congratulating in this time by their Addresses & Petitions , to this destroyer of Law & Religion . I wish they would look back to see what the building of this Bulwark cost our Fathers , before they sell it at such a rate : And compare the present Addresses , Courting & Carressing the Papists , with the Addresses of these worthy builders of what they are destroying . There is one dated Edinb . May. 27. 1561. Presented to the Council , shewing , that honesty craved them ; and conscience moved them , to make the secrets of their heart patent , which was ; That , before ever these Tyrants & dumb Dogs empire over them professing Christ Jesus within this Realme , they were fully determined , to hazard Life , and whatsoever they had received . of God in temporal things — And let these Enemies of God assure themselves , that if their Counsell put not order unto them , that they should shortly take such order , that they shall neither be able to do what they list , neither yet to live upon the sweat of the browes of such as are no Debters to them . And when the mischievous Mary , the daughter of the Degraded Queen , returning from France , set up the Mass but in her oun family ; the Godly at that time gave plain signification , that they could not abide that the Land which God by His power had purged from Idolatry , should in their eyes be polluted again . Shall that Idol ( say they ) be suffered again to take place within this Realme : It shall not . The Idolatrous Priests should die the death according to Gods Law. And a Proclamation being issued to protect the Queens Domestick Servants , that were Papists ; There was a Protestation given forth presently , That if any of her Servants shall commit Idolatry , say Mass , participate therewith , or take the defence thereof , in that case this Proclamation was not extended to them in that behalf , nor to be a Safeguard to them in that behalf , no more then if they commit murther . Seeing the one is much more abominable in the sight of God then the other . But that it may be Lawful to inflict upon them , the pains contained in Gods word , against Idolaters , wherever they may be apprehended without favour . The words of Iohn Knox upon the folowing sabbath may be added . That one Masse was more fear●ul unto him then if ten thousand armed Enemies , were Landed in any part of the realme , of purpose to suppress the whole Religion : for ( said he ) in our God there is strength to resist & confound Multitudes , if we unfeignedly depend upon Him ; but when we joine hands with Idolatry , it is no doubt , but both Gods amiable Presence & comfortable defence , will leave us and what shall then become of us ? Yea when it was voted in the General Assembly , whether they might take the Queens Mass from her ? Many frankly affirmed ; that as the Mass is abominable , so it is just & right , that it should be suppressed : And that in so doing , men did no more hurt to the Queens Majestie , than they that should by force take from her a Poisoned Cup , when she were going to drink it . Thus we have some Specimen of the Zeal of our fathers against Idolatry . But in a litle time , Court favours blunted it in many . And then had the Servants of God a double Battel , fighting or the one hand against Idolatrie , and the rest of the abominations maintained by the Court. And upon the other hand , against the unfaithfullness of false brethren , and Treachery of Sycophants , who informed the Court against the Ministers for their free & faithful Preaching and warning on all occasions ; yet they sustained the brunt of all these assaults , and came off with honour . At length to be short , in process of time , this Mary a woman of a proud & crafty wit , and an indured heart against God & His Truth , insisted in the same steps of Tyranny & Treachery ( but with greater Aggravations ) that her Mother walked in , and was served according to her desert . For after that her Darling Davie Rizio , the Italian Fidler ( whom most men then supposed , and do still suspect , to be the Father of King Iames , this mans Grandfather ; and some do think it not unlikly that his Successors have derived from this stock the Italian Complexion & Constitution , both of body & mind , Spare & Swarthy , Cruel & Crafty ) received his ●ue rewards in her presence , by the Kings consent & Counsel : she conceived such contempt of & indignation against the poor uxorious young King , Henry of Darnely ; that she never rested , till she & Bothwel contrived & executed his Murther . And then she married that Murdering Adulterer , the said Earle of Bothwel . Whereupon the Protestant Noblemen pursueing the Murther , took her & sent her Prisoner to Lochlevin ; where they made her resigne the Government to her Son Iames , then an Infant . And afterwards she was beheaded by Elizabeth Queen of England . We see now by this deduction what was the Testimony of this Period , and how in many things it confirmes the Heads of the present Sufferings , which we may particularly remark . I. The Reformation of Scotland had this common with all other Protestant Churches , that it was carried on by resisting the opposing powers : But it had this peculiar advantage above all , that at once & from the begining , both Doctrine & Worship , Discipline & Government , were Reformed : as Mr. Knox witnesseth , that there was no Realme upon the face of the Earth at that time that had Religion in greater Purity . Yea , sayes he , we must speak the Truth whomsoever we offend , there is no Realme that hath the like Purity ; for all others , how sincere soever the Doctrine be , retain in their Churches and the Ministery thereof some footsteps of Antichrist & dregs of Popery , But we ( praise to God alone ) have nothing in our Churches that ever flowed from that Man of Sin. The Doctrine was purely Reformed , according to the Rule of Christ , both as to Matter & Manner of Delivery . As to the Matter of it , what it was , the Confession of Faith ratified in Parliament anno 1560. Doth witness . In the Manner of it , they studyed not the smooth & pâkie prudence that is now so much applauded , for not observeing which , such as would fain be honest in this duty , are so much condemned ; but they cryed aloud against & did not spare the sins of the time , with application to every degree of men : as we have it published & vindicated in Mr. Knox his History . They cryed that the same God who plagued Pharaoh , repulsed Sennacherib , struck Herod with wormes , and made the bellies of dogs the Grave & Sepulcher of the Spiteful Iezabel , will not spare misled Princes , who authorise the Murtherers of Christs members in this our time : Many now a dayes will have no other Religion than the Qween ; the Queen , no other than the Cardinal ; the Cardinal , no other than the Pope ; the Pope , no other than the Devil : Let men therefore consider what danger they stand in , if their Salvation shall depend upon the Queens faith . And they used to defend such manner of free dealing , from the examples of the Prophets reproving Kings Personally : Now if the like & greater corruptions be in the World this day , who dare interprise , to put to silence the Spirit of God , whih will not be subject to the apetites of misled Princes . Mr. Knox his defence befor the Queen , when rebuked for speaking of her Mariage in the pulpit , was : The Evangel , sayth he , hath two points , Repentance & Faith ; in preaching Repentance , of necessity it is that the sins of men be noted , that they way know wherein they offend . And in his dispate with Lithingtoun , requiring where any of the Prophets did so use Kings & Rulers ; he gave the example of Elias . reproveing Achab & Iezebel , that dogs shall lick the blood of Achab and eat the flesh of Jezebel ; which was not whispered in their ears , but so as the People understood : well enough , for so witnessed Iehu after the accomplishment ; Elizeiu reproved Iehoram , saying , what have I to do with thee , if it were not for Jehoshaphat , I would not have looked toward thee ; though a subject yet he gave litle reverence to the King. These were their Arguments for faithfullness then which are now exploded with contempt . Their worship was also Reformed from all Dregs of Popery , & fopperies of humane Ceremonies , retained in many other Churches ; especially in England . To whose Bishops , in Queen Elizabeths time , the Assembly wrote ; That if Surplice ▪ Corner cap , Tippet &c. have been the badges of Idolaters in the very act of Idolatry , what have Preachers to do with the dregs of that Romish Beast ? Yea what is he that ought not to fear to take , either in his hand or fore head , the mark of that odious Beast ? — We think yow should boldly oppose your selves to all power , that will dare extoll it self against God , and against all such as do burden the Conscience of the faithful , further then God hath burdened them by His oun word . The Disclpline & Government was from the begining Presbyterial , even before the establishment ; both in practice , among the Persecuted Ministers who kept their private Meetings : And in their Doctrine , This was one of Mr Knox's Articles , he sustained at St Andrews , upon his first entry unto the Ministery , Art. S. There is no Bishop except he preach even by himself wiihout any substitute . But so soon as they attained any settlement , they assembled in their first National Synod , anno 1560. by vertue of that Intrinsick Power , granted by the Lord to His Church ; nor did they so much as petition for the Indulgence of the then Authority ; But upon Christs warrant , they kept & held their Courts in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ only , and in His sole Authority , by direction of His Word & Spirit , concluded all their Counsels , Votes , & Acts. And as they knew nothing of an Exotick Supremacy , so they put out & held out Prelacy , and kept a perfect Parity ; which was nothing infringed by the extraordinary Imployments & Commissions delegated to some Superintendents , upon the account of the particular exigence of these times . II. Next we find in the Practice of these renouned Reformers , many demonstrations of pure zeal , worthy of all imitation : which I remark the rather , because poor Sufferers that would now imitate it , are condemned as blind & ignorant zelots . But why are not the Reformers condemned for the same things ? We find in the first place , that they were so far from complying with , or conniving at , or countenancing publick sins , that they could not contain themselves from declaring their Detestation of the sight of them : yea the very boyes did abominate it , as at the Reformation of St Iohnstoun , a boy cryed with a bold voice , This is intolerable , that when God by His Word hath plainly condemned Idolatry , we shall stand & see it used in despight . Whereupon he & others throw doun all the monuments of Idolatry in the place . But if now any should enterprise such a thing , when the Idol of the Masse is set up in every City , they might expect Ierubbaals censure of the Abiezrites ; th● it is true they might have the same encouragement , because they have the same Command as he had , to wit , the perpetual precept of throwing doun Idolatrous Altars . Next they were so far from complying with the Enemies , in keeping the peace with them , that they thought it a great sin not to oppose them , when their brethren were forced to take the sword of self defence , being perswaded by these arguments : That by their fainting & abstracting their support , the Enemies would be encouraged ; And thereby they should declare themselves both Traitors to the Truth once professed , and Murderers of their Brethren , whom their presence & Concurrence might preserve ; And that if they should deny their Brethren suffering for His Names sake , they should also deny Christ , and be denyed of Him ; And that God hath often punished subjects with their Princes , for winking at and not resisting their manifest iniquity ; And therefore , as He is immutable in nature , so would He not Pardon them in that which He hath punished in others &c. Which Arguments prevailed with the noble Earle of Glencarn , in zeal to burst forth in these words — Albeit never man should accompany me , yet I will go to my Brethren , and if it were but a Pike upon my shoulder , I had rather die with that company then Live after them . But now professors cannot only sit at home in their shops & ceiled houses , when the Lords people are pursued & murdered in the fields , but also can hire their Murderers , & strengthen their hands , by paying them Cesses & Localities , and what they require for help to do their work , and maintaining them in their iniquity . Which famous Mr Knox disproveth very much in his day ; Arguing that if people thought they were innocent , because they were not the actors of such iniquity , they were utterly deceived ; for God doth not only punish the chief offenders , but the Consenters to such iniquity , And all are judged to consent , who give not Testimony against it ; As the Rulers & Bishops are Criminal of all the innocent blood , that 's shed for the Testimony of Christs Truth , so are all who assist & maintain them in their blind rage , and give no declaration that their Tyranny displeaseth them ; This doctrine is strange to the blind world , but the verity of it hath been declared in all notable punishments from the begining ; when the old world was destroyed by water , Sodom & Jerusalem were destroyed , were all alike wicked ? yet all perished ; why ? All kept silence , or did not resist , by which al● approved iniquity , and joined hands with the Tyrants , as it had been in one Battel against the Omnipotent . Which words if impartially applyed , will condemn & confute the dull Daubings of the present Complyances , in maintaining Tyrants & their Emissaries , by Emoluments which they require & exact , and that professedly , for promoting their accursed projects ; And will justify Consciencious sufferers , for refuseing to pay these impositions . And this will the more appear , if we adde some more of his pithie expressions in the same place , clearing the subject he is upon , and answering an objection , what poor people might do , when compelled to give obedience to all their Rulers demanded ? Ye may saith that Author , without sedition withhold the fruits & profits , which your false Bishops & Clergy most unjustly received of yow : Upon which he subjoins the preceeding Arguments . Yet now a dayes these have no weight , but such as refuse either to pay Oppressors exactions , or Curats stipends , are condemned for giddy fools . Again we find , that when they were challenged for duty , they would never decline a declaration of its righteousness , nor do any thing directly or indirectly which might seem a condemning of it . And therefore they wold receive no pardons for these things which they could not confess to be offences . Iohn Knox , challenged for offending the Queen , had her promise , that if he would confess an offence , his greatest punishment should be , but to go within the Castle of Edinburgh , and immediatly to return to his own house ; he refused absolutely . But now , if our Pardon-mongers & prudent men had been so circumstantiate , surely they could have helped themselves with their distinctions , they might confess & be pardoned for offending the Queen , thô not confess it to be a fault in their Conscience : But Mr Knox had not learned that then . When they were pursuing the Murder of King Henry of Darnely , the Queen finding her self not strong enough , offers to forgive & pardon that insurection : The Earle of Morton , in name of all the rest , did not only refuse a Cessation , but told her they would not ask a pardon . But now sufferers , for refusing of these base & unmanly aswell as unchristian Complyances , are much condemned . Finally , because this strictness , especially in their severity against their Enemies , may be accused of Iewish rigidity , inconsistent with a Gospel Spirit of Lenity ; which also is imputed to the much condemned sufferers of Scotland at this time , for their Testimonies against Toleration & Liberty of Conscience : Let us hear what Knox sayes ; whatsoever God required of the Civil Magistrate in Israel or Juda , concerning the observation of true Religion during the time of the Law , the same doth He require of Lawful Magistrates , professing Christ Jesus , in the time of the Gospel : And Cites a large Testimony out of Augustine to this purpose . And afterward objecting to himself the practice of the Apostles , who did not punish the Idolatrous Gentiles ; he answers , That the Gentiles , being never avowed to be Gods people before , had never received his Law , and therefore were not to be punished according to the rigor of it , to which they were never subject , being strangers from the Commonwealth of Israel ; But if any think , after the Gentiles were received in the number of Abrahams children , and so made one people with the Jewes beleeving , then ●hey were not bound to the same obedience of Israels Covenant , the same seems to make Christ inferior to Moses , and contrare to the Law of His heavenly Father ; for if the Contempt and transgression of Moses's Law was worthy of death , what judge we the contempt of Christs ordinance to be ? And if Christ be not come to dissolve , but to fulfill the Law of His Heavenly Father , shall the Liberty of His Gospel be an occasion that the special glory of His Father be troden under foot , and regarded of no man ? God forbid ; And therefore I fear not to affirme , that the Gentiles be bound by the same Covenant that God made with His people Israel , in these words ; Beware that thou make not any Covenant with the Inhabitants of the Land but thou shalt destroy their Altars &c. When therefore the Lord puteth the Sword in the hand of a people , they are no less bound to purge their Cities & Countreyes from Idolatrie , then were the Israelites , what time they received the Possession of the Land of Canaan . III. For the head of Resistence of Superior powers , we have no clearer instances in any Period then in this , where of the above mentioned hints give some account , to which in their sentiments & arguments may be here subjoined . They prised and improved this principle so much , that they put it in their Confession of faith Art. 14. To save the Life of Innocents , to repress Tyranny , to defend the oppressed , are among the good works of the Second Table , which are most pleasing & acceptable to God , as these works are commanded by Himself ; And to suffer innocent blood to be ●hed if we may withstand it , is affirmed to be sin , by which Gods hot Displeasure is kindled against the proud & unthankful world . And if there were no more to render the late . Test of Scotland detestable , that condemns all resistence of Kings upon any pretence whatsoever , this may make all Christians & all men abhor the contrivance of it ; that that same Test that confirms this Thesis , doth also impose the Antithesis upon Conscience . It obliges to this Confession in the first part of it , and to deny it in the Latter . But no wonder , that men of feared Consciences can receive any thing , thô never so contradictory to it self ; And that men who deny sense and that principle irradicated in humane nature , may also deny Conscience , & make a fool of it in sowdering Contradictories . But not only did our Reformers assert this Truth for which now their children adhering to their Testimony suffer both rage and reproach , but also gave their reasons for it . As ( 1 ) Mr Knox , in his first Conference with the Queen , argues thus : There is neither greater honour nor obedience to be given to Princes than Parents ; but so it is that the father may be stricken with a phrensie , in the which he would slay his oun children ; now if the children arise , take his weapon from him , bind his hands , do the children any wrong ? It is even so with Princes , that would murder the Children of God subject to them , their blind zeal is nothing but a very mad phrensie ; and therefore to take the sword from them , and cast them into prison till they be brought to a more sober mind , is no disobedience against Princes . ( 2 ) In his Conference with Lithingtoun , he proves the same point , from the consideration of the justice of God , punishing the people for not resisting the Prince . The Scripture of God teacheth me ( saith he ) Ierusalem & Iuda were punished for the sins of Manassoh ; If you alledge they were punished because they were wicked , and not because the King was wicked , the Scripture sayes expressly , for the sins of Manasseh ; yet will I not absolve the people , I will grant the whole people offended with their King , but how ? to affirme that all Iuda committee the acts of his impiety , hath no certainty ; who can think , that all Ierusalem should turn Idolaters immediatly after Hezekias notable Reformation ? One part therefore willingly followed him in his Idolatry , the other suffered him , & so were criminal of his sin , even as Scotland is guilty of the Queens Idolatry this day . In the same Discourse he makes it plain , that all are guilty of Innocents murder who do not oppose it , from Ieremies words in his defence before the Princes — Know ye for certain if ye put me to death ye shall surely bring innocent blood upon your selves and upon the City and upon the Inhabitants thereof ; Now if the Princes & the whole people should have been guilty of the Prophets blood , how shall others be judged innocent before God , if they suffer the blood of Innocents to be shed when they may save it ? ( 3 ) Ibid. he argues from the distinction between the person placed in Authority , and the ordinance of God , the one may be resisted the other cannot . The plain words of the Apostle makes the difference : The ordinance is of God , for preservation of mankind , punishment o●vice , which is holy & constant ; Persons commonly are profane & unjust : He that resisteth the power there , is only meant of the just power wherewith God hath armed His Magistrats , which who so resists , resists Gods or●inance ; But if men in the fear of God , oppose themselves to the fury of Princes , they then resist not God , but the Devil who abuses the sword & Authority of God : It is evident the people resisted Saul , when he had sworn Ionathan should dye , whom they delivered : The Spirit of God accuses them not of any crime , but praises them & condemns the King : This same Saul again commanded the Priests of the Lord to be slain , his guard would not obey , but Doeg put the Kings cruelty in execution ; I will not ask , whether the Kings servants not obeying resisted the ordinance of God , or whether Doeg murthering gave obedience to just Authority ? The Spirit of God condemns that fact Psal. 52. that God would not only punish the Commander , but also the merciless executer ; Therefore they who gainstood his command , resisted not the ordinance of God. ( 4 ) . Ibid. He argues from examples , not only of resisting but of punishing Tyrants : chiefly the example of Uzziah is pertinent to this purpose , 2 Chon . 26. who after his usurping the Priests Office , was put out of the Temple . When it was replyed , that they were the Priests that with stood the King , not simple people : He answered , The Priests were subjects , as Ab●athar was deposed by Solomon &c. yet they made him go out of the Temple for his Leprosie , and the people put him from the Kingdom . It is noted also that Mr Knox , in that discourse , adduces examples of those , who use to be brought in as objections against defensive Armes , even the Primitive Christians , before that Passage last cited : what precepts , sayes he , the Apostles gave , I will not affirme ; But I find two things the faithful did , the one was they assisted their Preachers even against the rulers , the other was they suppressed Idolatrie wheresoever God gave unto them force , asking no leave of the Emperour nor of his deputies : Read the Ecclesiastical Histories , and ye shall find examples sufficient . IV. In the next place we may inquire into the judgment of these Reformers , concerning that Question that is now so pusling to many ; which indeed was never started before this time as a head of suffering , but now , when it is started , we may gather from our Ancestors Actings & Determinations about it , how it ought to be answered . They were indeed in capacity , and accordingly did improve it , for disouning the Authority of both the Queens : but their capacity was not the thing that made it duty , if it had not been so before . Capacity makes a thing possible , but not lawful : It does indeed make a duty seasonable , and clears the Call to it , and regulates the timing of Affirmative duties , but the want of it can never dispense with negative Precepts : And a duty , negative especially , may become necessary , when it hath not the advantage of seasonableness or capacity ; certainly it were duty to depose ●he Pope from his usurped authority , and to disoune it even in Rome it self , but there it would not be thought very feasible or seasonable , for twenty or thirty people to avouch such a thing there , yet at all times it is a duty never to oune it . It is thought unseasonable & unfeasable to disoune the Tyrants authority , but it is made necessary , when u●ged never to oune it . And for this we have the grounds of our Ancestors , shewing who may be disouned , and must not be ouned . I shall first insert here John Knox his propositions , prosecuted in his second blast , extant at the end of Anton. Gilbies Admonition to England & Scotland . 1. It is not birth only nor propinquity of bloodh that maketh , a King lawfully to Reign over a people , professing Christ Iesus and His Eternal verity , but in his Election , the ordinance which God hath established in the election of inferior judges , must be observed . 2. No manifest Idolater , nor notorious transgressor of Gods holy precepts , ought to be promo●ed to any publick regiment , honour , or dignity , in any realme , Province , or Citie , that hath subjected themselves to Christ Iesus and His blessed Evangel . 3. Neither can Oath , or promise , bind any such people to obey & maintain Tyrants , against God and His Truth known . 4. B●t if rashly they have promoted any manifest wicked person , or yet ignorantly have chosen such an one , as after Declareth himself unworthy of regiment , above the people of God ( and such be all Idolaters & Cruel Presecuters ) most justly may the same men depose & punish him , that unadvisedly before they did nominate , appoint , & elect . Accordingly this was done in deposing both the Queens : wich is fully vindicated by the Earle of Morton , in his discourse to the Queen of England , as Buchanan Relates it , Lib. 20. Pag. 746. The deed it self , neither the Custom of our Ancestors of taking a Course with their Governour , will suffer it to be accounted new , nor the moderation of the punishment to be odious : for it were not needful to recount so many Kings punished by death , bonds , & exile by our Progenitors . For the Scotish nation , being from the begining alwise free , hath created Kings upon these conditions , that the Government entrusted to them by the peoples suffrages , might be also ( if the matter required ) removed by the same suffrages : Of which Law there are many footsteps remaining even to our day ; for both in the Isles about , and in many places of the continent , in which the old Language & institutions have any abode , this Custom is kept , in creating their Governours of Clanns : And the Ceremonies , used at the entering into Government , do yet retain the express representation of this Law. Whence it is evident , that the Government is nothing else but a mutual stipulation between Kings & people : which further appears , from the inviolated tenor of the Ancient Law , since the begining of the Scotish Government , reserved even unto our memory , without the least essay either to abrogate it , or disable , or diminish it . Yea even when our fathers have deposed , banished , & more severely punished so many Kings , yet never was any mention or motion made , of relaxing the rigor of that Law : And not without reason , seeing it was not of that kind of Constitutions , that change with the times , but of those which are engraven in the minds of men from the first original , and approved by the mutual consent of all Nations , and by natures Sanction continued inviolable and perpetual , which being subject to no other Lawes do Command & rule all . This , which in every action doth offer it self to our eyes & minds , and whether we will or not abides in our breasts , our Predecessors followed ; being alwayes armed against violence , and ready to suppress Tyrants — And now for the present , what have we done , but insisting in the footsteps of so many Kingdoms & free Nations , suppressed Tyrannical Licentiousness , extolling it self above all order of Laws , not indeed so severely as our Predicessors in like cases ; if we had imitated them , not only wold we have been far from all fear of danger , but also have escaped the trouble of Calumnies — What would our Adversaries be at ? Is it that we should arm with Authority Tyrants convicted of grievous Crimes , maintained by the spoils of the subjects , having hands embrued in royal blood , and hearts gaping for the oppression of all good men ? And shall we put them upon our head , who are infamously suspected of Parricide , both projected & perpetrated ? To which we may adde , a forreign conclusion indeed , but adduced & maintained by Mr Craig , in the Assembly anno 1564. which had been determined by Learned men in Bononia , Principes omnes , tam supremi quam inferiores , possunt & debent Reformari , vel deponi per cos per quos eriguntur , confirmantur , vel admittuntur ad officium , quoties a side praestita subditis per juramentum desiciant , quoniam relatio juramenti subditorum & principum mutua est , & utrinque aequo jure servanda & resormanda , juxta Legem & conditionem juramenti ab utraque parte sacti . That is , all Rulers be they supreme or inferior , may & ought to be reformed , or bridled ( to speak moderatly ) by them by whom they are chosen , confirmed , or admitted to their office , so oft as they break that promise made by Oath to their subjects , because that the Prince is no less bound by Oath to their subjects , then are the subjects to their Princes , And therefor ought it to be kept & reformed equally , according to Law & condition of the Oath that is made of either Party . By comparing which two Testimonyes together , we may see the reasons , why neither of the two Royal Brothers , that have ruled in our day , could be conscienciously ouned as Magistrates , in the Case they have been in for several years past : The first testimony is for the second ▪ Brother , the Latter is for he first that 's gone . But as for Mr Knox his opinion , it is evident he had written a● a book against the Government of women : which though he did not intend it particularly against Mary of Scotland , yet ▪ it did invalidate her authority as well as other womens . This book he ounes and maintains , in his first conference with her , and consequently could not oune her authority as of the Lord , though he gave her common respect , as the title of Majestie &c. yet when he was particularly urged by the Queens question , yow think , said she , that I have no just authority ; He would not answer in the affirmative , but shifted it , by telling her ; That learned men in all ages , have had their judgment free , and most commonly disagreeing from the Common judgment of the world . And tho , he sayes , he could live under her government ( so may & would the greatest disouners of Tyranny , if they be not troubled with questions about ovvneing it ) yet he affirms that with the Testimony of a good Conscience , he had communicate his judgment to the world , and that if the realme found no inconveniences in her government , he would no further disallow than within his oun breast . Certainly then in his Conscience he did not & could not oune her , as the Magistrate of God ; And that thô many things which before were holden stable , had been called in doubt , yet neither Protestant nor Papist could prove , that any such question was at any time moved in publick or private , Neither could ever such a question be moved , if the Conscience were not posed , and then when it must speak , it must of necessity be unpleasant to Tyrants . Thus we have heard both the positions & scruples of this witness , let us also hear his arguings that People may punish Princes for their Idolatry & murther &c. And therefore much more may disoune them : And therefore again much more may they forbear to oune them , when called ; for can a dead man by Law be ouned to be a Magistrate , & Custos of the Law. Idolatry ( sayth he in his conference with Lithington ) ought not only to be suppressed , but the Idolater ought to die the death : but by whom ? by the people of God , for the Commandment was given to Israel ; yea a Command , that if it be heard that Idolatry is committed in any one City , that then the whole body of the people arise and destroy that City , sparing neither man woman nor child . But shall the King also be punished ? If he be an Idolater , I find no priviledge granted unto Kings more then unto people , to offend Gods Majestie . But the people may not be Judges to their King. — God is the universal Judge ; so that what His Word commands to be punished in the one , is not to be absolved in the other ; And that the people , yea or a part of the people , may not execute Gods judgments against their King being an offender , I am sure you have no other warrant , except your own imaginations , and the opinion of such as more fear to offend their Princes than God. In the same Conference we have the instance of Iehu adduced to prove that Subjects may execute Gods judgments upon their Princes . It was objected , Iehu was a King before he executed judgment upon Ahabs house , and the fact was extraordinary , and not to be imitated . He answered , he was a meer Subject ; No doubt Iezabel both thought & said he was a Traitor , and so did many others in Israel & Samaria . And whereas it was said , that the fact was extraordinary ; I say , it had the ground of Gods ordinary judgment , which commandeth the Idolater to die the death ; and ●herefore I yet again affirme , it is to be imitated of all those that prefer the true honour of the true Worship & Glory of God to the affection of flesh & wicked Princes . We are not bound , said Lithingtoun to follow extraordinary examples , unless we have the like Comman●ment & assurance . I grant , said the other , if the example repugne to the Law , but where the example aggrees with the Law , & is as it were the execution of Gods judgment expressed within the same , I say that the example approved of God stands to us in place of a Commandment ; for as God in His Nature is Constant & Immutable , so cannot He condemne in the ages subsequent that which He hath approved in His Servants before us . Then he brings another Argument from Amaziah who fled to Lachish , but the people sent thither and flew him there . Lethingtoun doubted , whether they did well or not : ●e answered , where I find execution according to Gods Law , and God Himself not accuse the doers , I dare not doubt of the equity of their Cause : And it appears . God gave them sufficient evidence of His approving the fact , for He blessed them with peace and prosperity . But prosperity does not alwise prove that God approves the fact : yes , when the acts of men agree with the Law , and are rewarded according to the promise in that Law , then the prosperity succeeding the fact is a most infallible assurance that God hath approved it ; but so it is , that there is a promise of lengthening out prosperity to them that destroy Idolatry . And again , concluding Uzziahs example , he sayes there , The people ought to execute Gods Law , even against their Princes , when that their open Crimes by Gods Law deserve punishment , especially when they are such as may infect the rest of the multitude . V. There is another thing for which people have suffered much in our day of blasphemy rebuke & trouble , which yet we find was not so odious in our Reformers eyes as this dull & degenerate age would represent it . That in some cases it is Lawfull & laudable for private persons , touched with the zeal of God & love to their Countrey , & respect to Justice trampled upon by Tyrants , to put forth their hand to execute righteous judgment upon the Enemies of God & mankind , intollerable Traitors , Murderers , Idolaters ; when the ruine of the Countrey , Destruction of Religion & Liberty , and the wrath of God is threatened , in & for the impunity of that vermin of villains , and may be averted by their destruction , always supposed , that these whose office it is to do it decline their duty . The mind of our Reformers as to this is manifest , both in their practice & opinion . We heard before of the slaughter of Cardinal Beaton , and of the fidler Rizio : we shall find both commended by Mr Knox , giving account how these that were caryed Captives to France for this Cause from St Andrews were delivered . This ( saith he ) we write , to let the posterity to come to understand , how potently God wrought in preserving & delivering of those , that had but a small knowledge of His Truth , and for the love of the same hazarded all ; That if we in our days , or our posterity that shall follow , shall see a dispersion of such as oppose themselves to impiety , or take upon them to punish the same otherwise then Laws of men will permit , if such shall be left of men , yea as it were despised & punished of God : yet let us not damn the persons that punish vice ( and that for just cause ) nor ye● despair , but that the same God that dejects will raise up again the persons dejected , to His glory and their comfort : And to let the world understand in plain termes what we mean ; that great abuser of this Commonwealth , that Pultron & vile Knave Davio was justly punished March 9. 1565. by the Counsel & hands of Iames Douglas Earle of Mortoun , Patrick Lord Lindsay &c : who for the●r just act , and most worthy of all praise , are now unworthily left of all their Brethren . This is not only commended by the Author alone , but we find it concluded by all the Brethren at that time , when the Queen brought in the Idol of the Masse again , and the proud Papists began to avow it : then let it be marked that , The Brethren universally offended , and espying that the Queen by Proclamation did but delude them , determined to put to their own hands , and to punish for example of others ; And so some Priests in the West Land were apprehended , Intimation was made to others , as to the Abbot of Cosragnel , the Parson of Sanquhar , and such , that they should neither complain to the Queen nor Council , but should execute the punishment that God has appointed to Idolaters in His Law , by such means as they might , wherever they should be apprehended . Upon this the Queen sent for Mr Knox , and dealt with him earnestly , that he would be the instrument to perswade the people not to put hand to punish . He perceiving her craft , willed her Maj. to punish Malefactors according to Law , and he durst promise quietness , upon the part of all them that professed Christ within Scotland , but if her Maj. thought to delude the Laws , he feared some would let the Papists understand , that without punishment they should not be suffered so manifestly to offend Gods Majestie . Will ye ( quoth she ) allow they shall take my Sword in their hand ? The Sword of Justice ( said he ) Madam is Gods , and is given to Princes & Rulers for one end ; which if they transgress , sparing the wicked & oppressing the Innocents , they that in the fear of God execute judgment , where God hath commanded , offend not God , although Kings do it not : the examples are evident , for Samuel spared not to slay Agag the fat & delicate King of Amalek , whom King Saul had saved ; Neither spared Elias Iezabels false Prophets , & Baals Priests , albeit that King Ahab was present ; Phineas was no Magistrate , and yet feared he not to strike Zimri & Cozbi in the very act of filthy fornication : And so Madam your Maj. may see that others then Magistrates may Lawfully punish , & have punished the vice & crimes that God commands to be punished . He proved it also at more length in his Appellation , from Deut. 13. If thy Brother solicite thee secretly saying , let us go serve other Gods , consent not to him , let not thine eye spare him 〈…〉 him ; let thy hand be first upon him , and afterward the hand of the whole people . Of these words of Moses , two things appertaining to our purpose are to be noted : The first is , that such as solicitate only to Idolatrie ought to be punished to death , without favour or respect of person ; for He that will not suffer man to spare his son , wife , &c. will not wink at the Idolatry of others , of what state or condition soever they be : It is not unknown that the Prophets had Revelations of God , which were not common to the people ; Now if any man might have claimed any priviledge from the rigor of the Law , or might have justified his fact , it should have been the Prophet , but God commands , that the Prophet that shall so solicitate the people to serve strange Gods , shall dye the death , notwithstanding that he alleadge for himself dream , vision , or Revelation , because he teacheth Apostacy from God : hereby it may be seen , that none provoking the people to Idolatry ought to be exempted from the punishment of death . Evident it is that no state , condition , nor honour can exempt the Idolater from the hands of God , when He shall call him to an account : How shall it then excuse the people , that they , according to Gods command , punish not to death such as shall solicitate or violently draw the people to Idolatrie ? The second , is that the punishment of such Crimes , as Idolatrie , blasphemy , & others that touch the Majestie of God , doth not appertain to Kings & chief Rulers only , but also to the whole body of the people , and to every member of the same , according to the vocation of every man , and according to that possibility & occasion which God doth minister , to revenge the injury done against His Glory : And that doth Moses more plainly speak in these words of the same Chapter , If in any Citie which the Lord thy God giveth thee , thou shalt hear this bruite , there are some men sons of Belial — Plain it is that Moses speaks not nor giveth charge to Kings , Rulers , & Judges only ; but he commands the whole body of the people , yea and every member of the same , according to their possibility . And who dare be so impudent as to deny ●his to be most reasonable & just ? For seeing God had delivered the whole body from bondage , and to the whole multitude had given His Law , and to the twelve tribes had distributed the Land of Canaan ; was not the whole & every member addebted to confess the benefits of God , and to study to keep the possession received ? which they could not do , except they kept the Religion established , & put out iniquity from amongst them . To the carnal man this may seem to be a rigorous & severe judgement , that even the Infants there should be appointed to the cruel death : and as concerning the City , and spoill of the same , mans reason cannot think but that it might have been better bestowed , than to be consumed . But in such cases let all creatures stoup , and desist from reasoning , when Commandment is given to execute His Judgment . I will search no other reasons , than the Holy Ghost hath assigned ; first , that all Israel should fear to commit the like abomination ; And secondly , that the Lord might turn from the fury of His anger : Which plainly doth signifie , that by the defection & Idolatry of a few , Gods wrath is kindled against the whole , which is never quenched , till such punishment be taken upon the offenders , that whatsoever served them in their Idolatry be brought to destruction &c. I have inlarged so far upon this Period , that it may appear , there is nothing now in Controversy , between the suffering & reproached party now in Scotland , and either their Friends or Enemies , which could fall under our Reformers inquiry ; but they have declared themselves of the same sentiments , that are now so much opposed : And therefore none can condemn the present heads of suffering , except also they condemn the Reformers judgment ; and consequently the imputation of novelty must fall . PERIOD . IV. Containing the Testimony of the first Contenders against Prelacy and Supremacy , from the year 1570. to 1638. HItherto the Conflict was for the Concerns of Christs Prophetical & Priestly Office , against Paganisine & Popery . But from the year 1570. And dounward , the Testimony is stated , and gradually Prosecuted , for the Rights , Priviledges , & Prerogatives of Christs Kingly Office : which hath been the peculiar Glory of the Church of Scotland , above all the Churches in the Earth , that this hath been given to her as the word of her Testimony ; and not only Consequentially & Reductively , as all other Churches may challenge a part of this dignity , but Formally & Explicitely to contend for this very head , The Headship & Kingship of Iesus Christ , the Prince of the Kings of the Earth , and His Mediatory Supremacy over His oun Kingdom of Grace , both visible & Invisible . This is Christs supremacy , a special radiant Jewel of His Imperial Croun : which , as it hath been as explicitely incroached upon in Scotland , by His Insolent Enemies , as ever by any that entered in opposition to Him ; so it hath been more expressly witnessed and wrestled for , by His suffering Servants in that Land , than in any place of the world . This was in a particular manner the Testimony of that Period , during the reign of King Iames the Sixth ; as it hath been in a great measure in our day , since the year 1660. Which , as it is the most important Cause , of the greatest Consequence that Mortals can contend for ; So it hath this peculiar Glory in it , that it is not only for a Truth of Christ , of greater value then the standing of Heaven & Earth , but also it is the very Truth , for which Christ Himself died , considered as a Martyr ; And which concerns Him to vindicate & maintain as a Monarch . The Witnesses of that day made such an high account of it , that they encouraged one another to suffer for it , as the greatest Concern ; being a witness for Christs Glorious & free Monarchie , which as it is the end of the other two Offices , so the Testimony is more Glorious to God , more honourable to His Son , and more Comfortable to them , then the Testimony either for His Prophetical office , or for His Priesthood , because His Kingdom was specially impugned at the time ; As Mr Forbes & Mr Welsh write in a Letter to the Ministers at Court. The Corruptions & Usurpations wronging this Truth , that they contended against , were Prelacy and the Kings Supremacy in Ecclesiastical matters : which will be usefull to hint a litle , how they Prosecuted the Conflict . When Sathan ( whose Kingdom was then declining ) by several instruments & means , both by force & fraud , did endeavour to put a stop to the Reformation , by reintroducing the Antichristian Hierarchy of Prelacy , when he could not reestablish the Antichristian Doctrine of Popery ; he left no means unessayed to effectuate it . And first he began to bring the name Bishop in request , that was now growing obsolete & odious , by reason of the abuse of it ( as it ought to be still ; for though the name be found in the Scriptures , yet neither is that Catechrestical application of it to Prelats to be sound , nor was there any other reason for the translation of it after that manner , except it were to please Princes ; seeing the native signification of it is an Overseer , proper and common to all faithfull Pastors . ) And indeed his first essay reached litle further then the bare name , for they were to be subject to & tryed by Assemblies , and hardly had so much power as Superintendents before . But it was a fine Court-juggle for Noblemen , to get the Church revenues into their hands , by restoring the Ecclesiastical titles , and obtaining from the titulars either Temporal Lands , or Pensions to their dependers : so they were only Tulchan Bishops , a Calfeskin to cause the Cow give milk . Yet , though this in our day would have been thought tollerable ; The faithful Servants of Christ did zealously oppose it . Mr Knox denunced Anathema to the Giver , and Anathema to the Receiver . And the following Assembly condemned the office it self , as having no sure warrant , authority , nor ground in the Book of God , but brought in by the folly & corruption of mens invention , to the overthrow of the Church ; and ordained all that brooked the office , to dimit simpliciter , and to desist & cease from preaching , while they received de novo admission from the Generall Assembly , under the pain of excomunication . Hereby they were awakened & animated , to a more vigorous Prosecution of the establishment of the House of God , in its due Government . In pursuance whereof , the Assemblies from that time untill the year 1581. Did with much painfulness & faithfulness attend the work ; untill , by perfecting of the Second Book of Discipline , they compleated their work , in the exact Model of Presbyterial Government , in all its Courts & Officers . Which was Confirmed , & Covenanted to be kept inviolate , in the National Covenant , subscribed that year by the King , his Court , & Council ; and afterwards by all ranks of People in the Land. Whence it may be doubted , whether the impudence of the succeeding Prelats that denyed this , or their perjury in breaking of it , be greater . This was but the first brush : a brisker assault followes . Wherein , for the better establishment of Prelacy , that what it wants of Divine right , might be supplyed by the accession of humane Prerogative , and not only Diocesan but also Erastian Prelacy might be set up , to destroy Christs Kingdom & advance Sathans ; the Earle of Arran & his wicked Complices , move the King , contrary both to the Word & Oath of God , to usurp the prerogative of Jesus Christ , and assume to himself , a blasphemous Monster of Supremacy , over all Persons , & in all Causes , as well Ecclesiastical as Civil . But this also the faithful Servants of God did worthily & valiantly resist : and at the very first appearance of it , gave in a Grievance to the King , anno 1582. That he had taken upon him a spiritual Power , which properly belongs to Christ , as only King & Head of the Church ; the Ministerie & execution whereof , is only given to such as bear office in the Ecclesiastical Government in the same : so that in the Kings Person , some men press to erect a new Popedome , as though he could not be full King of this Commonwealth , unless as well the spiritual as temporal Sword be put in his hand , unless Christ be rest of His Authority , and the two Jurisdictions confounded , which God hath divided , which directly tendeth to the wrack of all true Religion . Which being presented by the Commissioners of the General Assembly ; the Earle of Arran asked , with a frouning Countenance , who dare subscribe these treasonable Articles ? Mr Andrew Melvin answered , we dare , & will subscribe , & render our Lives in the Cause . And afterward , that same Assembly presented Articles , shewing , that seeing the spiritual Jurisdiction of the Church , is granted by Christ , and given only to them , that by preaching , teaching , & overseeing , bear Office within the same , to be exercised , not by the injunctions of men , but by the only Rule of Gods Word — hereafter , no other of whatsomever degree , or under whatsomever pretence , have any colour to ascribe , or to take upon them any part thereof , either in placing or displacing of Ministers , without the Churches admission , or in stopping the mouths of Preachers , or puting them to silence , or take upon them the judgment of tryal of Doctrine &c. But in contempt & contradiction to this , and to prosecute & exert this new usurped Power , Mr Andrew Melvin was summoned before the secret Council , for a Sermon of his , applying his doctrine to the Times Corruptions : whereupon he gave in his declinature against them as incompetent Judges ; and told them , they were too bold , in a Constitute Christian Church , to pass by the Pastors , Prophets , & Doctors , and to take upon them to judge the Doctrine , and to control the Ambassadors of a Greater then was there , which they neither ought nor can do . There are ( saith he , Loosing a litle Hebrew Bible from his girdle ) my Instructions & Warrant : see if any of you can control me , that I have past my injunctions . For this he was decerned , to be warded in the Castle of Edinbrugh , but he being informed , that if he entered in ward he would not be released , unless it were for the scaffold , he conveyed himself secretly out of the Countrey . Hereafter when the Parliament 1584. had enacted this Supremacy , and submission to Prelacy , to be subscribed by all Ministers ; the faithful first directed Mr David Lindsey to the King , desiring that nothing be done in Parliament prejudicial to the Churches Liberty : who got the Prison of Blackness for his Pains . And then when they could not get access for shut doors to Protest before the Parliament ; yet , when the Acts were proclaimed at the Cross of Edinburgh , they took publick Documents , in name of the Church of Scotland ( though they were but two ) that they protested against the said Acts : and fled to England , leaving behind them reasons that moved them to do so . And Mr Iames Melvin wrote against the subscribers at that time very pertinently : Proving , first , that they had not only set up a new Pope , & so become Traitors to Christ , and condiscended to that chief error of Papistrie , whereupon all the rest depend ; but further , in so doing they had granted more to the King , than ever the Popes of Rome peaceably obtained &c. And in the end , as for those that Lamented their oun weakness & feebleness , he adviseth them , to remove the publick slander , by going boldly to the King & Lords , and shew them how they had fallen through weakness , but by Gods power are risen again ; and there by publick note & witness taken , free themselves from that subscription , and to will the same to be delete , renouncing & detesting it plainly , and thereafter publickly in their Sermons , and by their Declaration & retractation in writ , presented to the faithful , manifest the same , let them do with stipend , benefice , & Life it self what they list . This I insert , because this Counsel is now condemned , and when poor people , offended with Ministers subscriptions of Bonds & other Complyances , desire acknowledgments of the offence , they reject it as an impertinent imposition , and plead they are not obliged to manifest any retractation but to an Ecclesiastical Judicatory . To which I shall say nothing here , but this is no novelty . After this , it is known what bickerings the faithful witnesses of Christ had , in their Conflicts with this supremacy , upon the account of Mr David Blacks Declinature , which they both advised him to , & approved when he gave it in , against the King & Conncil as Judges of his Doctrine . And the Commissioners of the General Assembly ordained all , to deal mightily with the power of the word , against the Councils encroachments ; for which they were charged to depart forth of Edinburgh . After which he added a second Declinature : Declaring , there are two Jurisdictions in this realme , the one Spiritual the other Civil ; the one respecting the Conscience , the other externals ; &c. — Therefore , in so far as he was one of the spiritual office-bearers , and had discharged his spiritual Calling in some measure of grace & sincerity , should not nor could not be Lawfully judged , for preaching and applying the word , by any Civil power ; he being an Ambassadour & Messenger of the Lord Jesus , having his Commission from the King of Kings , and all his instructions set doun & limited in the book of God , that cannot be extended , abridged , or altered by any mortal wight , King or Emperour ; And seeing he was sent to all sorts , his Commission & discharge of it should not nor cannot be Lawfuly , judged , by them to whom he was sent ; they being sheep & not Pastors , to be judged by the Word and ●●t to be judges thereof in a judicial way . The Interloquutor being past against him for this ; the Brethren thought it duty , that the Doctrine of the Preachers should be directed against the said Interloquutor , as against a strong & mighty hold set up against the Lord Jesus , and the freedom of the Gospel ; and praised God for the force & unity of the Spirit , that was among themselves . And being charged to depart out of Toun , they leave a faithful Declaration at Large ; shewing , how the Liberties of the Church were invaded & robbed : But all this was nothing , in comparison of their wrestlings for the Royalties of their Princely Master , and Priviledges of His Kingdom , against that Tyrants Insolencies , after he obtained he Croun of England . For then he would not suffer the Church to indict her oun Assemblies . And when the faithful thought themselves obliged to counteract his Encroachments , and therefore conveened in an Assembly at Aberdeen , anno 1605. they were forced to dissolve : and thereafter , the most eminent of the Ministers there assembled , were transported Prisoners to Black-ness . Whence being cited befor the Council , they decline their Judicatory . And one of their Brethren , Mr Robert Youngson , who had formerly succumbed , being moved in Conscience , returned : and when the rest were standing before the Council , desired to be heard ; and acknowledged his fault , and therefore , howbeit not summoned by the Lords , was charged by the Living God , and compelled to compear that day , to justifie that Assembly , to the great astonishment of the Lords , and comfort of His brethren ; He subscribed the Declinature with the rest : And for this they were arraigned , and condemned , as guilty of Treason , and banished . Before the execution of which sentence , Mr Welsh wrote to the Lady Fleming , to this effect . What am I , that He should first have called me , and then constituted me a Minister of glad things , of the Gospel of Salvation , these fifteen years already , and now last of all to be a sufferer for His Cause & Kingdom ? To witness that good Confession , that Jesus Christ is the King of Saints , and that His Church is a most free Kingdom , yea as free as any Kingdom under Heaven , not only to convocate , hold & keep her Meetings , Conventions , & Assemblies : But also to judge of all her affairs in all her Meetings & Conventions , among His members and Subjects . These two points . ( 1 ) That Christ is the Head of His Church . ( 2 ) That she is free in her Government from all other jurisdiction except Christs , are the special Cause of our imprisonment , being now convict as Traitors , for maintaining thereof . We have now been waiting with joyfulness to give the last Testimonie of our blood in confirmation thereof . If it would please our God to be so favourable , as to honour us with that dignity . After this , the King resolving by Parliament to advance the estate of Bishops again , as in the time of Popery , without Cautions as before ; and further to establish not only that Antichristian Hierarchie , but an Erastian Supremacy : The faithful Ministers of Christ , thought themselves bound in Conscience to protest . And accordingly they offered a faithful Protestation to the Parliament Iulij — 1606. obtesting , that they would reserve into the Lords own hands , that Glory which He will communicate neither with man nor Angel , to wit , to prescribe from His holy Mountain a Lively pattern , according to which His oun Tabernacle should be formed : Remembring alwise , that there is no absolute & undoubted Anthority in this world , except the soveraigne Authority of Christ the King ; to vvhom it belongeth as properly to rule the Church , according to the good pleasure of His oun vvill , as it belongeth to Him to save His Church by the Merit of His oun Sufferings : All other anthority is so intrenched vvithin the marches of Divine Command , that the least overpassing of the bounds set by God Himself , bring men under the fearful expectation of Temporal & Eternal judgements . — If ye should authorize Bishops , ye should bring into the Church the ordinance of man , vvhich experience hath found , to have been the ground of that Antichristian Hierarchie , vvhich mounted up on the steps of Bishops preeminence , until that man of sin came forth , as the ripe fruit of mans vvisedome , vvhom God shall consume vvith the breath of His oun mouth . Let the svvord of God pierce that belly , vvhich brought forth such a monster : And let the staff of God crush that egg , vvhich hath hatched such a Cockatrice : And let not only that Roman Antichrist be thrown down from the high bench of his usurped authority , but also let all the steps whereby he mounted up to that unlawful preeminence , be cut down & utterly abolished in this Land : And beware to strive against God with an open displayed banner , by building up again the walls of Iericho , which the Lord hath not only cast down , but also hath laid them under an horrible Interdiction & execration , so that the building of them again must needs stand to greater charges to the builders , then the reedifying of Iericho , to Hiel the Bethelite in the days of Ahab . Yet notwithstanding of all opposition , Prelacy was again restored in Parliament . And to bring all to a Complyance with the same , Presbytries & Synods universally charged , under highest pains , to admit a constant Moderator without change : which many refused resolutely , as being the first step of Prelacy . Upon this followed a great Persecution of the faithful , for their Nonconformity , managed by that Mongrel & Monstrous kind of Court , made up of Clergy-men & Statesmen , called the High Commission Court , erected anno 1610. whereby many honest men were put violently from their charges & habitations ; the Generality were involved in a great & fearful Defection . But the Copestone of the wickedness of that Period , was the Ratification of the five Articles of Perth ; kneeling at the Communion , private Communion to be given to the sick , private Baptisme , and Confirmation of Children by the Bishop , and observation of festival dayes . Which were much opposed & testified against by the faithful , from their first hatching anno 1618. to the year 1621. when they were ratified in Parliament : at what time they were also witnessed against from Heaven , by extraordinary Lightenings & Tempest . And against this the Testimony of the faithful continued , till the Revolution anno 1638. Here we see how the Cause was stated in this Period ; and may gather also , wherein it aggress , and how far it differs from the present Testimony , now suffered for under all rage & reproach . I. The matter of the Testimony was one with that that we are suffering for , against Popery , Prelacy , & Supremacy ; except that it was not so far extended against Tyranny , because that Tyrant was not such an usurper , nor such a violater of the fundamental constitutions of the Civil Government , as these that we have had to do with all . But as to the managing the Testimony , they far out stripped their successors in this generation , in conduct & courage , Prudence & zeal , as is above hintend in many instances : to which we may adde some more . When several plots of Papist Lords had been discovered , conspiring with the King of Spain , And they were by the Kings Indulgence favoured , and some were also perswaded to treat with them : famous Mr Davidson opposed with great resolution ; Declaring before the Synod of Lothian , that it favoured much of defection in these dayes , that such notorious rebells to God , His Church , & the Country , should be so treated with ; we should not rashly open a door to Gods Enemies , without better proof of their manners nor were yet seen . And when a convention in Falkland was consulting to call home these conspiring Traitors : Mr Andrew Melvin went thither uncalled ; and when found fault with by the King for his boldness , he answered , Sir , I have a call to come here from Christ & His Church , who have special Interest in this Turn , and against whom this Convention is assembled directly : I charge yow , and your Estates , in the Name of Christ & His Church , that ye favour not His Enemies whom He hateth , nor go about to call home nor make Citizens of these , who have traiterously sought to betray their City & native Countrey , with the overthroiw of Chists Kingdom . And further challenged them of treason against Christ , His Church & the Countrey , in that purpose they were about . About the same time in a private Conference with the King , he called the King Gods sillie vassal ; and taking him by the sleeve , told him ; Sir , yow , and Church & Countrey is like to be wracked for not telling the Truth , and giving yow faithful Counsel ; we must discharge our duty , or else be enemies to Christ & yow : Therefore I must tell yow , there are two Kings and two Kingdoms ; There is Christ and His Kingdom , whose subject King Iames the 6th is , and of whose Kingdom he is not a King , nor a Head , nor a Lord , but a member , and they vvhom Christ hath called to vvatch over & govern his Church , have sufficient Authority , and Power from Him , which no Christian King should control but assist , othervvise they are not faithfull subjects to Christ. Sir , vvhen yovv vvere in your svvedling clouts , Christ reigned freely in this Land , in spight of all His enemies ; but novv the vvisdom of your Council , vvhich is Devilish & pernicious , is this , that yovv may be served of all sorts of men to your purpose & grandour , Iew & Gentile , Papist & Protestant , because the Ministers & Protestants in Scotland are too strong , & control the King , they must be vveakened & brought lovv , by stirring up a party against them , and the King being equal & indifferent , both shall be fain to flee to him , so shall he be well setled : But , Sir , let Gods wisedom be the only wisdom , this will prove meer & mad folly ; for His curse cannot but light upon it , so that in seeking both yow shall lose both . To the like effect , Mr Robert Bruce , in a Sermon upon Psal , 51. gives faithful warning of the danger of the times . It is not we ( sayes he ) that are Partie in this cause ; no , the quarrel is betwixt a greater Prince and them . What are we , but sillie men ? Yet it has pleased Him to set us in this Office , that we should oppone to the manifest usurpation that is made upon His Spiritual Kingdom . Is there a more forcible mean to draw down the wrath of God , than to let Barrabas that nobilitate Malefactor pass free , and to begin the war against Christ and His Ministry . It puteth on the Copestone , that so many of our brethren should not be so faithful , as their Calling & this Cause craveth . Fy upon false brethren , to see them dumb , so faint hearted , when it comes to the Chock : Not only are they ashamed to speak the thing they think , which is a shame in a Pastor , but speak directly against their former Doctrin . They will speak the Truth a while , till they be put at , but incontinent they will turn and make their gifts weapons to fight against Christ ; for there is none so malicious as an Apostate when he begins to slide back &c. The same faithful witness , because he would not preach as the King would have him , against his oun conscience , to justifie & Proclaim the Kings Innocency , in a forged conspiracy against him , was put from his Church in Edinburgh , and being requested in an insinuating manner to desist from preaching but for nine or ten dayes ; he condiscended at first , thinking the matter of no great importance : yet that night his body was cast in a fever , with the terror of his conscience , and he promised he should never obey their Commandment any more . These were faithful men , yet we find they challenge themselves in deep humiliation , for their short comings & defections , at the renovation of the National Covenant , March , 30. 1596. the greatst solemnity ever had been seen in Scotland before that time , so that the place might worthily have been called Bochim . O when shall we see such a day , when even the most faithful among us , shall mourn over our far more aggravated defections ! but if they mourned then for these first degrees of declensions , we may say , quam gravius ingemiscerent illi fortes viri , qui propter Ecclesiae Scoticanae Libertatem . olim in acie decertarunt , si nostram hanc ignaviam ( ne quid gravius dicam ) conspicerent ! I know notwithstanding of all this , that some encourage themselves in a base Complyance with the present corruptions of our Church , from the practise of these Worthies ; Alledging , they did not scruple to hear & join with Prelatical men , dispensing the ordinances . But this Objection will be easily refelled , if we consider , first , the Period wherein they were but growing up to a more perfect Reformation , and therefore might bear with many things which we cannot , after we have been reformed from them : They were then advancing and still gaining ground , we are now declining , and therefore should be more shie to lose what we have gained . They had then of a long time enjoyed their Judicatories , unto which they might recur for an orderly redress of such grievances that offended them ; and when they were deprived of them , yet they were still in hopes of recovering them , and so suspended their total secession from that corrupt Church , untill they should recover them ; in the mean time still holding their right and maintaining their cause against these Invaders . But we were at thevery first begining of this unhappy Revolution , totally deprived of our Judicatories , and denuded of all expectation of them in an ordinary way , and of all place , but what they are Masters of to contend with them that way ; therefore must keep our selves free of their ▪ Communion . But next if we consider their practise , we shall find these Worthies vvere not such Conformists , as our Complyers vvould make them . What if vve find among them Meetings , that vvere Called & Counted as Seditious & Schismatick , as Ours are novv ? vve find a field Meeting , yea a General Assembly , at Dumfermling vvithout & against the Kings vvarrant , vvhen the ●ports vvere shut against them , anno 1585. But that is not so pat to the purpose , as that vve find Private-Meetings at Edinburgh , and that in the very time of publick Service in the Churches , discharged by open Proclamation anno 1624. vvherein it is charged , that they had no respect to the ordinary Pastors , contemned & impugned their Doctrine , disobeyed & controlled their Discipline , abstained to hear the Word preached , and to Participate of the Sacraments . And long before that , vve find the sincerer sort scrupled to hear Bishop Adamson , not withstanding that he vvas absolved in the Assembly . And that aftervvards , the doubt being proponed to the Assembly , if it be a slander to a Christian , to absent himself from the Sermons of them that are suspended from all function in the Ministry . The Assembly Ansvvered , there is no slander in the Case but rather it is slanderous to resort . And why is not this ground to think it slanderous or scandalous to resort to them , who deserve to be suspended ( all of them by a Spiritual cognizance , and some of them to be suspended Corporally , for their villanie ) when there can be no access orderly to do it . And the rather , because we find in this Period , that sometimes Ministers were so faithful & zealous against the Corruptions of the Ministry , that they decerned Ministers to be suspended for far smaller faults , than many now could exempt themselves from ; viz. if they were not powerful & Spiritual , if they did not apply their Doctrine to Corruptions , if they were obscure & too Scholastick before the people , cold & wanting zeal , flatterers , dissembling at publick sins for flattery or fear &c. As we may read in the Advice of the Brethren , deputed for penning the Corruptions in the Ministery , anno 1596. I wish our silent prudent Ministers now would consider the justness of this Censure , and what ground people have to be offended at such censurableness . But not only this may answer the false imputation of Conformity on these witnesses of Christ at that time , but I shall set down a part of a Letter of one of the banished Ministers at that time , discovering his mind about hearing these men , that were then serving the times . Mr Iohn Welsh , writing to Mr Robert Bruce , — what my mind is concerning the root of these branches , the bearer will shew yow more fully . They are no more to be counted Orthodox , but Apostates ; They have fallen from their Callings by receiving an Antichristian , and bringing in of Idolatrie , to make the Kingdom culpable , and to expose it to fearful Judgments , for such an high perfidie against an Oath so sol●mnly enacted & given ; And are no more to be counted Christians , but strangers , Apostates , & Persecutors , And therefore not to be heard any more , either in publick , or in Consistories , Colledges , or Synods ; for what fellowship hath light with darkness ? We see then as to that part of the Testimony , they were not dissonant to the vvitness of the present reproached sufferers . II. As the matter & manner of their Testimony against all the invaders of the Churches priviledges , did speak forth a great deal of sincere & pure zeal ; so their practice was conform , shewing forth a great deal of strictness , and aversness from all sinfull Complyances , even with things that would be now accounted of very minute & inconsiderable consequence , and for which honest sufferers now are flouted at as fools . When that Oath was formed for acknowledging the Supremacy , there was a Clause added which might have been thought to salve the matter , according to the Word of God. I fear many now would not stand to subscribe , with such a qualification . Yet the faithful then perceived the Sophistrie , that it made it rather worse , affirming that that brat of Hell was according to the word of God : And therefore , though there were several eminent men to perswade them to it both by advice & example , yet they could not in conscience Comply ; And pleaded also from the illegality of that imposition , that they should be charged with the subscription of Laws , a thing never required before of any subject ; if they offended against the Laws , why might they not be punished according to the Laws ? When many honest faithful Patriots , for their attempt at Ruthven to deliver the Countrey from a vermine of Villains that abused the King , to the destruction of the Church & Kingdom , were charged to crave Pardon , & take remission ; they would do neither , judging it a base condemning of duty : which puts a brand upon our sneaking Supplicators , & Petitioners , & Pardon-mongers , as unworthy to be called the race of such Worthies , who scorned such baseness , and choosed rather to endure the extremity of their unjust Sentences , of Intercommuning & Banishment &c. And when the Earle of Gowrie accepted of a Remission , he afterwards condemned himself for it , and desired that his old friends would accept of his friendship , to whom he had made himself justly suspected . Mr Black , when he had the same favour offered to him , refused altogether , left so doing he should condemn himself , and approve the Courts Proceedings : And the Brethren , confering with the Councellors , craving that some penalty should be condiscended unto for satisfying his Majestie in his honour , would not condiscend to any how light soever ; lest thereby they should seem to approve the Judicatorie & their Proceeding . The Imprisoned Ministers , for declining the Council , had it in their offer , that if they would without any confession of offence only submit themselves to his Majestie , pro scandalo , accepto non dato , they should be restored to their places : But it pleased God so to strengthen them , that they stopped their Mouths , and convinced them in their Consciences , that they could not do it without betraying of the Cause of Christ. Again in another case , we have Instances of such strictness , as is much scorned now a dayes . The Ministers of Edinburgh were committed to ward , for refusing to pray for the Queen , before her execution in Forthringam Castle 1586. they refused not simply to pray for her , but for the preservation of her life , as if she had been innocent of the crimes laid to her charge , which had imported a condemnation of the proceedings against her . Afterwards in the year 1600. the Ministers of Edinburgh , would not praise God for the deliverie of the King , from a pretended Conspiracy of the Earle of Gowrie at that time , of which they had no credit nor assurance ; and would not crave Pardon for it neither . For this Mr Robert Bruce was deprived of the exercise of his Ministry , and never obtained it again in Edinburgh : But now for refusing such compelled & imposed Devotion , to pray or praise for the King , poor people are much condemned . I know it is alleadged , that these faithful sufferers in those days , were not so strict as they are now , in submitting to unjust Sentences , and obeying & keeping their Confinements . I shall grant , there was much of this , and much might be tollerate in their circumstances , when the Court procedure against them was not so illegal , their Authority was not so Tyrannical , nor so necessary to be disouned , and they were so stated , that they were afrayed to take guilt upon them , in making their escapes : whereas it is not so with us . Yet we find very faithful men broke their Confinements : As Mr Iohn Murray , confined about Dumfreis , perceiving there was no end of the Bishops malice , and that he would be in no worse case than he was , he resolved without Licence either of King or Council to transport himself : So did also Mr Robert Bruce . III. For resistence of Superior Powers , we have in this Period , first the practice of some Noblemen an Ruthven , anno 1582. who took the King , and seised on that Arrant Traitor , Enemy to the Church & Countrey , the Earle of Arran ; declaring to the world the Causes of it , the Kings Correspondence with Papists , his usurping the Supremacy over the Church , and oppressing the Ministers , all by means of his wicked Councellors , whom therefore they removed from him . The King himself emitted a Declaration allowing this deed . The General Assembly approved of it , and perswaded to a Concurrence with it , and nothing was wanting to ratifie it , as a most Lawfull & laudable action . At length the Fox escapes , & changes all , and retracts his former Declaration . The Lords again rallie , and interprise the taking of the Castle of Stirling , and gain it ; but afterward surrender it : after which the Earle of Gowrie is executed , and Ministers are commanded to retract the Approbation of Ruthven business , but they refused : and many were forced to flee to England , and the Lords were banished . But in the year 1585. they return with more success , and take the Castle of Stirling . The cowardly King does again acknowledge & justify their Enterprise , that they needed no Apology of words , Weapons had spoken well enough , and gotten them audience to clear their own Cause : but his after carriage declared him as crafty & false , as he was cowardly & fearful . Again we have the advice of the General Assembly , for resisting , when the Ministers were troubled , upon Mr Blacks bussiness , and there was an intention to pull them out of their Pulpits : They advised them to stand to the discharge of their Calling , if their flocks would save them from violence , and yet this violence was expected from the King and his Emissaries . As to that point then there can be no dispute . IV. There was litle occasion for the Question about the Kings Authority in this Period , but generally all acknowledged it : because they were not sensible of his usurpation , and his cowardice made him incapable of attempting any thing that might raise commotions in civil things . Yet we remark , that whatsoever Authority he usurped beyond his sphere , that was disouned & declined by all the Faithful , as the Supremacy . Next that they resented , & represented very harshly , any aspiring to Absoluteness ; as Mr Andrew Melvin could give it no better name , nor intertain no better notion of it , then to terme it , The bloodie Guillie , as he inveighs against it in the Assembly , 1582. And next , in this same Period , we have a very good description of that Authority , which the King himself allowes not to be ouned , which out of a Kings mouth abundantly justifies the disouning of the present Tyrannie : This same King Iames , in a speech to the Parliament in the year 1609. sayth , A King degenerateth into a Tyrant , when he leaveth to rule by 〈◊〉 , much more when he beginneth to invade his Subjects Persons , Rights , & Liberties , to set up an Arbitrary Power , impose unlawful taxes , raise forces , make War upon his Subjects , to pillage , plunder , wast , and spoil his Kingdoms . PERIOD . V. Containing the Testimony for the last Reformation from Prelacy , in all its steps , from the year 1638 , to 1660. THe following Period , from the year 1638. to 1660 , continues & advances the Testimony , to the greatest hight of Purity & Power , that either this Church or any other did ever arrive unto , with a Gradation , Succession , & Complication of wonders , of Divine Wisdom , Power , Justice & Mercy , signally & singularly ouning & sealing it , to the Confusion of His Enemies , Comfort of His People , Conviction of Indifferent Neutrals , and Consternation of All. Now after a long winter , and night of Deadness & Darkness , the sun returns with an amiable approach of Light & Life : now the winter was past , the rain was over & gone , the flowers appear on the earth , and the time of singing of birds is come , and the voice of the turtle is heard in our Land. Now the second time , the Testimony comes to be managed in an Active manner , as before it was Passive : As the one hath been alwayes observed to follow interchangably upon the other , especially in Scotland , and the Last alwayes the Greatest ; which gives ground to hope , though it be now our turn to suffer , that when the summer comes again after this winter , and the day after this night , the next Active Testimony shall be more notable than any that went before . The matter of the Testimony was the same as before , for the Concerns of Christs Kingly Prerogative , but with some more increase as to its opposites : for these grew successively in every Period , the Last alwayes including all that went before . The first Period had Gentilisme principally to deal with , the second Poperie , The third Poperie & Tyrannie , the fourth Prelacy & Supremacy , this fifth hath all together , and Sectarianisme also , to contend against . The former had alwayes the opposites on one hand , but this hath them in extremes on both hands ; both fighting against one another , and both fighting together against the Church of Scotland , and she against both , till at length one of her opposites prevailed , viz. the Secterian Party , and that prevailing brought in the other , to wit , the Malignant , which now domineers over all together . Wherefore , because this Period is in it self of so great importance , the Revolutions therein emergent so eminent , the Reformation therein prosecuted wanting litle of its perfect Complement ; the Deformation succeeding in its Deviation from the Pattern being so destructive ; to the end it may be seen from whence we have fallen , and whether or not the present reproached Sufferers have lost or left their ground , we must give a short deduction of the Rise , Progress , & End of the Contendings of that Period . In the midst of the forementioned Miseries & Mischiefs , that the pride of Prelacy and Tyrannical Supremacy had multiplied beyond measure upon this Church & Nation , and at the hight of all their haughtiness , when they were setting up their Dagon , and erecting Altars for him , imposing the Service-book , and book of Canons &c. the Lord in Mercy remembered His people , and surprised them with a sudden unexpected Deliverance , by very despicable means ; even the opposition of a few weak women , at the beginning of that Contest , which , ere it was quashed , made the Tyrant tumble headless off his throne . The zeal against the English popish Ceremonies , obtruded on Edinburgh , did first inflame some feminine hearts to witness their detestation of them ; but afterwards was followed out with more Masculine fervor , accosting King & Council with Petitions , Remonstrances , Protestations , & Testimonies against the Innovations , and resolving upon a mutual Conjunction , to defend Religion , Lives , & Liberties , against all that would innovate or invade them . To fortifie which , and conciliate the favour both of God & man in the Resolution , All the Lovers of God , and friends to the Liberty of the Nation , did solemnly Renew the National Covenant ( wherein they were signally countenanced of the Lord ) vvhich , though in it self obliging to the Condemnation of Prelatical Hierarchie , and clearly enough confirming Presbyterial Government , yet they ingaged into it vvith an inlargment , to suspend the practice of Novations already introduced , and the approbation of the Corruptions of the present Government , vvith the late places & povver of Church men , till they be tried in a free General Assembly . Which vvas obtaine● that same year , and indicted at Glasgow : and there , not vvith standing all the opposition that the Kings Commissioner could make , by Protestations & Proclamations to dissolve it , the six preceeding Assemblies establishing Prelacy vvere annulled , The Service-Book , and high Commission vvere condemned ; All the Bishops vvere deposed , and their Government declared to be abjured in that National Covenant ; though many had , through the Commissioners , persvvasions , subscribed it in another sense vvithout that application : As also the five Articles of Perth vvere there discovered , to have been inconsistent vvith that Covenant & Confession , and the Civil places & povver of Church men vvere disproved & rejected : on the other hand Presbyterial Government vvas Justified & Approved , and an Act vvas passed for their keeping yearly General Assemblies . This was a bold begining , into which they were animated with more than humane resolution , against more than humane opposition , Hell as well as the powers of the earth being set against them . But when the Lord gave the Call , they considered not their oun deadness , nor were daunted with Discouragments , nor staggered at the promise through unbelief , but gave Glory to God , out braving all difficulties . Which in the following year were much increased , by the Prelats and their Popish Partakers , rendevouzing their forces under the Kings Personal Standart , and menacing nothing but misery to the zealous Covenanters : yet when they found them prepared to resist , were forced to yeeld to a Pacification , concluding that an Assembly & Parliament should be held for healing all grievances of Church and State. In which Assembly , at Edinburgh , the Covenant is ratified & subscribed by the Earle of Traquair Commissioner , and enjoined to be subscribed by the body of the whole Land , with an explication expressly condemning the five Articles of Perth , the Government of Bishops , the Civil places & power of Church men : But the sons of Belial cannot be taken with hands , nor bound with bonds of faith , humanity , or honour ; For in the year following , King & Prelats , with their Popish Abettors , go to arms again ; but were fain to accommodate the matter by a new Pacification , whereby all Civil & Religious Liberties were ratified . And in the folowing year 1641 , by Lawes , Oaths , Promises , subscriptions of King & Parliament fully confirmed . The King , Charles the I. being present , and consenting to all ; though in the mean time he was treacherously encouraging the Irish murderers , who by his Authority made a Massacre of many thousand Innocent Protestants in Ireland . But in Scotland things vvent vvell , the Kingdom of our Lord Jesus vvas greatly advanced , the Gospel flourished , and the Glory of the Lord did shine upon us , vvith such a splendor that it avvaked England , and animated the Lords People there , then groaning under those Grievances from vvhich Scotland vvas delivered , to aspire to the like Reformation . For advice in vvhich , because though all aggreed to cast off the yoke of Prelacy , yet sundry forms of Church Government vvere projected to be set up in the room thereof , chiefly the Independent order , determining all Acts of Church Government , as Election , ordination , and deposition of officers , vvith Admission , Excommunication , & Absolution of members , to be done & decided by the voices of every Particular Congregation , vvithout any Authoritative Concurrence or interposition of any other , condemning all imperative & decisive povver of Classes &c. as a meer usurpation ; Therefore the Brethren in England vvrote to the Assembly then fitting at Edinburgh , vvho gave them ansvver That they vvere grieved , that any of the Godly should be found not aggreeing vvith other Reformed Churches in point of Government , as well as Doctrine ; and that it was to be feared , where the edge of Discipline & Government is different , the Doctrine & Worship shall not long continue the same without change ; That the Government of the Church , by Compound Presbytries & Synods , is a help & strength , and not a hinderance to particular Congregations & Elderships , in all the parts of Government ; and are not an extrinsecal Power set over Particular Churches , but the intrinsecal power where with Christ hath invested His Officers , who may not exercise it Independently , but with subordination unto Presbytries &c. Which as they are Representative of particular Churches , conjoined together in one under their Government ; so their determination , when they proceed orderly , whether in Causes common to all , or brought before them by reference in case of aberration , is to the several Congregations Authoritative , & not Consultatory only . And this subordination is not only warranted by the light of nature , but grounded upon the Word of God , and conforme to the Pattern of the Primitive & Apostolick Church , for the Preservation of verity & unity , against Schisme , Heresie , & Tyrannie , which is the fruit of this Government where soever it hath place . So from henceforth the Assembly did incessantly urge uniformity in Reformation , with their Brethren in England , as the chiefest of their Desires , Prayers , & Cares . And in the year 1643. prevailed so far , that the English Parliament did first desire that the two Nations might be strictly united for their mutual defence , against the Papists & Prelatical faction and their Adherents in both Kingdoms ; and not to lay down Armes , till these implacable Enemies should be brought in subjection : and did instantly urge for the help & assistance from Scotland . Which being sent did return with an Olive branch of Peace , and not without some beginings of a Reformation in England . And afterwards , a bloody War begining between the King & Parliament , with great success on the Kings side , whence the Papists at the time got great advantage ( witness the cessation of Armes concluded in Ireland ) Commissioners were sent from both Houses to Scotland , earnestly inviting to a nearer union of the Kingdoms , and desiring Assistance from this Nation to their Brethren in that their great distress : And this , by the good hand of God , produced the solemn League & Covenant of the three Kingdoms , first drawen up in Scotland , and approven in the Assembly at Edinburgh , and afterward embraced in England , to the terror of the Popish and Prelatical party , and to the great comfort of such as were wishing and waiting for the Reformation of Religion , and the recoveries of Just Liberties . The tenor whereof did import , their sincere & constant endeavours , in their several places & Callings , for preservation of the Uniformity in Reformation , in Doctrine , Worship , Discipline , & Government ; The extirpation of Popery , Prelacy , Error & Prof●nity ; the preservation of the Rights & Liberties of the people , and of the Magistrats Authority , in defence of the true Religion and Liberty ; the discovery & punishment of Incendaries ; the retaining of the Peace & Union of the Kingdoms ; the mutual assistance & defence of all under the bond of this Covenant ; and the performing all duties we owe to God , in the amendment of our Lives , and walking exemplarly one before another . This is that Covenant comprehending the purpose of all Prior , and the Pattern of all posterior Covenants , to which Christs witnesses did always adhere , for which the present witnesses do suffer & contend ; That Covenant , which the Representative of Church & State in the three Nations did solemnly Subscribe & Swear , for themselves & posterity , of which the obligation , either to the duty or the punishment , continues indispensibly on the Generation ; which for the moral equity o● its matter , the formality of its manner , the importance of its purpose , the holyness of its solemn Engagment , and the Glory of its Ends , no power on Earth , can Disannul , Disable , or Dispense ; That Covenant , which the Lord did Ratifie from Heaven , by the conversion of many thousands at their entering under the bond of it , securing & establishing unto them , and all the faithful , the blessings & priviledges therein expressed , and avouching Himself to be their God , as they had avouched themselves to be His people ; That Covenant , which in all the Controversies it hath occasioned , did never receive a greater confirmation than from the malice & opposition of its Adversaries ; That Covenant , which malignants do malign & deny , and Sectaries scorn & lay aside , as an Almanack out of date ; which hath been many ways traduced & reproached by enemies , and yet could never be reflected on by any Serious in this Land , without a honourable & fragrant remembrance : Especially that Retortion of Adversaries of the rigor of its imposition upon Recusants , to justifie their cruelty upon its Asserters now , is to be refelled , not with confutation of its importance , but with disdain of its impudence . For who were the Recusants : but wicked enemies to God and Church & Nation , who for their malignancy were then to be prosecuted , not for their scrupling at a Covenant , but for their contumacious Contempt of a Law ? This was no violence done to their conscience ; for as they had none , and could not pretend to any , so they were never troubled for that , but for their opposition & conspiracy against the common cause . However , it went through at that time : And that the Covenanted Reformation , in a nearer conjunction betwixt the united Churches , might be promoted , the Parliament of England called an Assembly of Divines at Westminster : and desired the Assembly of Scotland to send thither their Commissioners ; which accordingly nominated & elected , Mr Alexander Henderson , Mr Robert Dowglas , Mr Samuel Rutherford , Mr Robert Balzie , Mr George Gillespie Ministers , And Iohn Earle of Cassils , Iohn Lord Maitland , and Sir Archbald Iohnstoun of Waristoun , Ruling Elders ; to Propone , Consult , Treat , & conclude in all such things as might conduce to the extirpation of Popery , Prelacy , Heresie , Schism , Superstition , & Idolatry , and for the settling of the so much desired union of the whole Island , in one forme of Church Government , one Confession of Faith , one common Catechisme , & one Directory for the Worship of God. Forces were also sent , to assist the Parliament of England : which were favoured with great success in their Entreprizes , till that War was ended by the total overthrow of Tyranny at that time , and all its upholders . But that Popish , Prelatical , & Malignant faction being brought much under in England , attempted ( not unlike the Syrians , who thought the God of Israel was not God of the Hills & Valleyes both ) to try the fortune of War in Scotland , under the conduct of that Treacherous & truculent Traitor Montrose , gathering an Army of wicked Apostates & Irish Murderers : who prevailing for a time , did punish , in the Justice of God , the Hypocrisie & self-seeking of such in this Land whose hearts were not upright in His Covenant ; at length was defeat at Philiphaugh , in the year 1645. yet certain it is , that they had Commission & warrant from the King : as the Assembly that year , Feb. 13. remonstrates it to himself ; Warning him in the name of their Master , the Lord Jesus Christ , that the guilt which cleaved to his throne was such , as ( whatsoever flattering Preachers or unfaithful Counsellors might say to the contrary ) if not timely repented , could not but involve himself & his Posterity , under the wrath of the Everliving God , for his being guilty of the shedding of the blood of many thousands of his best Subjects , for his permitting the Masse & other Idolatry in his family & Dominions &c. At the same time also the Assembly did zealously incite the Parliament to a speedy course of Justice , against these Incendaries & Murderers , as the only mean of cleansing the Land from that deluge of blood then current , and of appeasing the wrath of God : and solemnly & seasonably warned all ranks , to applaud the Glory & Righteousness of that Judgment of the sword , in the hands of these Apostates & Murderers , and to search to understand the Language of that Dispensation ; wherein many Publick sins & breaches of Covenant are pointed at , as the Causes of that desolation ; And the Covenant it self is there very Encomiastically vindicated . We are so far from repenting of it ( say they ) that we can not mention it without great joy & thankfullness to God , as that which hath drawn many blessings after it , and unto which God hath given manifold evident Testimonies : for no sooner was the Covenant begun to be taken in England , but sensibly the condition of affairs there was changed to the better , and our forces sent into that Kingdom , in pursuance of that Covenant , have been so mercifully & manifestly assisted & blessed from Heaven , that we have what to answer the enemy that reproacheth us concerning that business , & that which may make iniquity it self to stop her mouth : but which is more unto us than all victories , the Reformation of Religion in England , & Uniformity therein between both Kingdoms ( a principal end of that Covenant ) is so far advanced , that the Government of the Church by Congregational Elderships , Classical Presbyteries , Provincial & National Assemblies , is aggreed upon by the Assembly of Divines at Westmnster , and voted & conc●uded in both houses of Parliament . After this the Malignants in England being crushed in all their Projects , the King renders himself to the Scots in New castle : by whom ( because by Covenant they were not obliged to defend him , but only in defence of Religion & Liberty , which he had been destroying and they defending ; because in this war he did directly oppose & oppugne these conditions , under which they were only to defend him , and therefore they had all alongst carried towards him as an enemy , as he to them ; And because by the same Covenant they were obliged to discover , & render to condign punishment all Malignants & Incendaries , of whom he was the chief , and to re●ain the Peace & Union of the Kingdoms , which could not be retained in maintaining their destroyer , And to assist mutually all entered into that Covenant , which he was fighting against ) he was delivered up into the English , and kept under restraint in the Isle of Wight , untill he received his just demerit , for all his oppressions , Murders , Treachery , & Tyranny ; being condemned & execute Ianuar. 30. anno 1648 / 9 Which fact , though it was protested against both before & after by the Assembly of the Church of Scotland , out of zeal against the Sectarians , the executioners of that extraordinary Act of Justice ; yet it was more sor the manner than for the matter , and more for the motives & ends of it than for the grounds of it , that they opposed themselves to it , and resented it . For they acknowledged & remonstrated to himself , the Truth of all these things upon which that sentence & execution of Justice was founded . And when a wicked Association , & Unlawful Engagment was on foot to rescue him , they opposed it with all their might : Shewing , in their Answers to the Estates that year 1648. and Declarations & Remonstrances , the sinfullness & destructiveness of that Engagment ; that it was a breach of the Commandments of God , & of all the Articles of the Covenant ; Declaring withal , they would never consent to the Kings Restitution to the exercise of his Power , without previous assurance by solemn Oath under his hand & seal , for settling of Religion according to the Covenant . By which it appears , they were not so stupidly Loyal , as some would make them . Yet indeed it cannot be past without regrate , that there was too much of this plague of the Kings-evil even among good men : which from that time forth hath so infected the heads & hearts of this Generation , that it hath almost quite extinct all Loyaltie to Christ , and all zeal for Religion & Liberty . Then it began to infuse & diffuse its Contagion , when after the death of Charles the first , in the year 1649. they began , after all that they had smarted for their trusting these treacherous Tyrants , and after that Grace had been shewed them from the Lord their God , by breaking these mens yokes from from off their necks , and puting them again into a Capacity to act for the good of Religion , their oun safety , and the peace & safety of the Kingdom , to think of joining once more with the people of these abominations , and taking into their bosoms these Serpents which had formerly stung them almost to death . Hinc il●● lachrimae , en origo & Scaturigo nostrae defectionis ! There was indeed at that time a Party faithful for God , who considering the many breaches of the Solemn League & Covenant , and Particularly by the late Engagment against England , did so travel that they procured the Covenant to be renewed , with the Solemn Acknowledgment of sins & Engagment to duties , which was Universally subscribed & sworn through all the Land ; wherein also they regrete this tampering with Malignants . And therefore the Lord did mightily save & defend them from all their Adversaries , subdued them at Stirling , and in the North. They did also give warning concerning the young King , that notwithstanding of the Lords hand against his Father , yet he hearkens unto the Counsells of these , who were Authors of these Miseries to his Father ; by which it hath come to pass , that he hath hitherto refused to grant the just & necessary desires of the Church & Kingdom , for securing of Religion & Liberty : And it is much to be feared , that these wicked Counsellers , may so far prevail upon him , as to ingage him in a war , for overturning the Work of God , and bearing doun all those in the three Kingdoms that adhere therto . Which if he shall do , cannot but bring great wrath from the Lord upon himself & throne , and must be the cause of many new & great Miseries & Calamities to these Lands . And in the same warning , by many weighty reasons , they prove , that he is not to be admitted to the exercise of his power , without security for Religion & Liberty . And when the bringing home of the King came to be voted in the Assembly , there was one faithful witness , Mr Adam Kae Minister in Galaway , protested against it ; fore shewing & fore telling , what mischeef & misery he would bring with him when he should come . These things might have had some weight , to demur the Nation from medling with that perfidious Traitor . But all this serves only to aggravate the sin & shame of that distraction , which hath procured all this destruction , under which the Land mourns to this day : That notwithstanding of all these Convictions , warnings yea and discoveries of his Malignancy , Treachery , & inclinations to Tyranny ; They sent Commissioners , and concluded at Treaty with him at Breda . During which Treaty , the Commissions which he had sent to that bloody villain Montrose , & his Cut throat Complices , to raise an Armie , & wast & invade the Countrey with fire & sword the second time ; were brought to the Committee of Estates , discovering what sort of King they were treating with . Whereupon , after serious Consulting not only together , but with the Lord : And after many debates what to do in such a doubtfull case , wherein all was in danger , the Estates concluded to break off the Treaty , and recall their Commissioners . To which intent , they sent an Express with Letters to Breda ; which by providence falling into the hands of Libberton , a true Libertine , & false betrayer of his trust & Country , was by him , without the knowledge of the other Commissioners , delivered unto the King : who consulting the Contents of the Packet with his Jesuitical & Hypocritical Cabal , found it his interest to play the fox ( being disappointed at that time to play the Tyger ) and dissemble with God & man. And so sending for the Commissioners , he made a flattering speech to them , shewing that novv after serious deliberation he vvas resolved to comply vvith all their Proposals . Where upon the poor cheated Commissioners dispatch the post back with Letters , full of praise & joy , for the satisfaction they had received . The Estates , perceiving themselves imposed upon , consulted again vvhat to do ; and in end , being oversvvayed more vvith respect to their oun credite ( vvhich they thought should be impeached , if they should retract their oun Plenipotentiary Instructions , to conclude the Treaty upon the Kings assent to their Conditions ) than to their reclamant consciences , they resolved to bring home that pest , and thereby Precipitated themselves & us into ineluctable miserie . Yet they thought to mend the Matter , by binding him vvith all Cords , and puting him to all most explicite Engagments , before he should receive the Imperial Croun . Well , upon these termes home he comes , and before he set his foot on British ground he takes the Covenant . And thereafter , because the Commission of the General Assembly , by the Act o● the West Kirk August . 13. 1650. Precluded his Admittance unto the Croun , if he should refuse the then required satifaction , before his Coronation he emits that Declaration at Dumferling ; wherein , Professing & appearing in the full perswasion & love of the Truth , he repenteth ( as having to do with & in the sight of God ) his Fathers opposition to the Covenant & work of God , & his oun reluctances against the same , hoping for Mercy through the blood of Jesus Christ , and obtesting the prayers of the faithful to God for his stedfastness ; and than protesteth his Truth & sincerity in entering into the Oath of God , resolving to prosecute the ends of the Covenant to his utmost , and to have with it the same Common friends & Enemies , exhorting all to lay doun their enmity against the cause of God , and not to prefer mans Interest to Gods , which will prove an Idol of Jealousie to provoke the Lord , and he himself accounteth to be but selfish flatterie . A declaration so full of heart Professions , & high Attestations of God , that none considering what followed can reflect thereon , without horror & trembling from the holy Jealousie of the Lord , either for the then deep dissimulation or the after unparalelled Apostacy . I know it is objected by Court parasites , that the King was then compelled to do these things . To which I shall only say : It would have cost any of them their head at that time , to have asserted that he did upon deliberation & choise mock God & man , and entered into these Engagments , only with a purpose to be thereby in better Capacity , to destroy what he swore to maintain ; only because he could not have the Croun without this way , which in the Confession of the objectors themselves was only deliberate & premeditate Perjurie . Next , if it should , be granted he was Compelled ; let it be also considered , who Compelled him ; and these will be found to be the deceitful Courtiers . For , let it be adverted , what Mr Gilespie declares of the Case , who put the pen in his hand when he subscribed that Declaration : He , perceiving there was sufficient ground to Jealouse his reality , and seeing evidently that the Courtiers prevailed with the King on a sudden to offer to subscribe the Declaration ( when they observed that the Commissioners of Churh & State were resolute , & ready to go away in a fixedness , to leave out the puting of his Interest in the state of the quarrel ) and being afrayed of the sad Consequences of it , spoke his mind plainly to the King , That if he was not satisfied in his Soul & Conscience , beyond all hesitation of the righteousness of the subscription , he was so far from overdriving him to run upon that , for which he had no light , as he obtested him , yea he charged him in his Masters name , and in the name of these who sent him , not to subscribe this Declaration , no not for the three Kingdoms . Whereupon the King answered , Mr Gillespie , Mr Gillespie I am satisfied , I am satisfied with the Declaration , and therefore will subscribe it . Upon which some of the Courtiers swore that Mr Gillespie intended simply to disswade the King from subscribing it , that so Church and State might professedly lay aside his Inetrest : which would have defeat their hopes to make up themselves , as now they have done , upon the then designed ruine of the Interest of Truth . Then at his Coronation , we have his again reiterated confirmations of that Covenant : first , he is desired in name of the people to accept the Crown , and maintain Religion according to the National & Solemn League & Covenant ; whereunto he gave his apparently Cordial consent ( the words are in the forme & order of the Coronation with the whole Action . ) Then next , a Sermon being Preached upon 2 King. 11. 12 , & 17. the action commenceth , with his most solemn renewing of the National and solemn League & Covenant , by Oath . Then , he is presented to the people , and their willingness demanded to have him for their King on these termes . At the same time , in the next place , he took the Coronation Oath . Then on these termes he accepted the Sword. And after the Crown is set upon his head , the peoples obligatory Oath is proclaimed on the termes foresaid , otherwise he is not that King to whom they swore subjection . Then being set upon the Throne , he was by the Minister put in mind of his Engagments , from 1 Chron. 29. 33. And then the Nobles of the Land came one by one kneeling , and lifting up their hands between his hands , swore the same Oath . These things done , the whole Action was closed with a most solid & severe exhortation from several instances , Neh. 5. 13. Ier. 34. 18 , 19 , 20 , &c. There after in the year 1651. followed the Ratification of all these preceeding Treaties , Transactions , & Engagments , concluded & enacted by the King , and the Parliament then fully & freely conveened ; whereby the same did pass into a Perpetual Law. And this Covenant , which from the begining was & is the most sure & indispensible Oath of God , became at length the very fundamental Law of the Kingdom , whereon all the rights or priviledges , either of King or people , are principally bottomed & secured . This might seem security sufficient , but considering the former discoveries & experiences they had of his Treachery , and the visible appearances ( in the mean time ) of his Refusalls , visible Reluctances , manifest Resilings , open Counter actings , and continued prejudices against the Covenant , and his following unprecedented avowed perjurie , every thing doth indelebly fasten upon them the weakness at least of an overweening Credulity , and upon him the wickedness of a perfidious Policy , in all these Condiscensions . After this it came to pass , that zeal for the Cause rightly stated was suddenly contracted to a few , and the flame thereof extinguished in many , and Court wild fire substitute in its place : whereby a plain defection was violently carried on by the Publick Resolutioners , who relapsing into that most sinful Conjunction with the People of these abominations , so solemnly repented for & resolved against , did notwithstanding bring in Notorious Malignants , into places of power & Trust , in Judicatories & Armies , in a more Politick than Pious way of requiring of them a constrained & dissembled Repentance , to the mocking of the God of Truth , and Scorn of all our holy Engagments . Which defection did not only cause for a long time an incurable Division ; the first of that kind , and most permanent of any that ever was in the Church of Scotland , by reason of the surcease of General Assembl●es , stoped & hindered by the yoke of the Sectarian Usurpation ; but also was the spring & source of all our defections since , all flowing from & fomented by that same spirit that fostered that : And for that , since that time , the Lord hath been contending with this Church & Nation , bringing us under the bondage of these Malignant Enemies , whom we suffered them then to encourage & introduce . And both at that time , & since that time , the Lord never countenanced an Expedition where that Malignant Interest was taken in unto the state of the quarrel . Upon this our Land was invaded by Oliver Cromwel , who defeat our Army at Dumbar , where the Anger of the Lord was evidently seen to smoke against us , for espousing that Interest . And remarkable it is , how in that very day where in the Publick Resolutions were concluded in the Assembly at St Andrews , the Lord then shed the blood of His people at Ennerkeithing ; so as that the Assembly , having in great hast hurried through this Approbation , were all made to run for it , and Adjourn themselves to Dundie , where they met and compleated that step of defection . And afterwards it s known , what a peculiar vengeance fell upon that City , where this deed was done beyond all the Cities of the Nation . Next , an Army being raised , according to these unhallowed Resolutions , and the Lord puting remarkable Discountinance upon them in their attemptings at home , as was manifest in their attemptings at Torewood &c. They march into England ; and there did the Lord continue , by His leaving our Army to the Sword , to preach that Doctrine to the world Iosh. 7. 10 , 11 , 12. [ Israel hath sinned and transgressed the Covenant — have taken the accursed thing — and dissembled also , and have put it even amongst their oun stuff , therefore the Children of Israel could not stand before their enemies , but turned their backs before their Enemies , because they were accursed : Neither will I be with yow any more , except ye destroy the accersed thing from among yow ] An army of near 30000 was totally routed at Worcester ; and the Achan , the Cause of the overthrow , was forced to hide himself in the Oak , and thence to transport himself beyond sea , where he continued a wandering fugitive in Exile , till the year 1660. In the mean time the Sectarian Army here prevailed , till , after the usurper Cromwel his death , the false Monk then General , with a Combination of Malignants and Publick Resolutioners , did machinate our misery , and effectuated it by bringing home the King to England from his banishment : Wherein he was habituate into an implacable hatred against the Work of God. Yet , though since the Kings first reception into Scotland , our declensions were still growing untill they produced this fearful Revolt from God , wherein the Nation is now involved ; there was still a faithful Remnant of Ministers & Professors , zealous for the Cause , keeping their Integrity ; who in their Remonstrances & Testimonies witnessed against both their Malignant Enemies and their backsliding Brethren the Resolutioners , and also against the Sectarians their Invaders ; whose vast Toleration & Liberty of Conscience , which they brought in to invade our Religion as they had invaded our Land , and infect it with their multifarious Errors , was particularly by the Synod of Fife , and other Brethren in the Ministery that joined themselves to them , Testified against , and demonstrated to be wicked & intollerable . Now to see how far the present Testimony is Con●irmed by the witnesses of this Period , we may resume some Reflections on it . I. They impartially carried on the Testimony against Prelacy , and the Popish Prelatical & Malignant faction on the one hand , and the Sectarians on the other , without ever waving the Testimony against either , or at the least winking at the one to weaken the other : both which Testimonies they though of so great importance , that they could not dispense with but faithfully maintain both , in their witnessings & warnings . In that seasonable & necessary Warning & Declaration concerning present & imminent dangers , given at Edinb . Iuly 27. sess 27. They say first of the S●ctaries That prevailing Party of Sectaries in England , who have broken the Covenant , and despised the Oath of God , corrupted the Truth , subverted the fundamental Government , Look upon us with an evil eye , as upon these who stand in the way of their Monstrous & new fangled devices in Religion & Government ; and though there were no Cause to fear any thing from that party , but the Gangren & infection of those many damnable & abominable errors which have taken hold on them ; yet our vicinity unto and dayly Commerce with that Nation , may justly make us afrayed , that the Lord may give up many in this Land into a spirit of delusion to beleeve Lies , because they have not received the Love of the Truth . In that same warning they say we are not so to have the one of our eyes upon the Sectaries , as not to have the other upon Malignants , they being an Enemie more numerous & more dangerous than the other ; not only because experience hath proven , that there is a greater aptitude & inclination in these of our Land to comply with Malignants , than Sectaries , in that they carry on their wicked designe , under a pretext of being for the King , but also because there be many of them in our oun bovvells . By vvhich vve may see , hovv impartially they opposed both ; and that this cannot be condemned in the Testimonies of the present Sufferers , except the Assembly be condemned . And because many novv a dayes have extenuating notions of those debates , against Prelacy & Sectarianisme , about the Government of the Church &c. and condemn these that vvould adhere to & suffer for the Punctilio's of it , as rigid nicetie : I shall , for seeing vvhat account the Assembly had of them , cite their vvords in a Letter to the Assembly of divines at Westminster , Dated Edin . Iune 18. 1646. The smallest ( say they ) of Christs Truths ( if it be Lavvfull to call any of them small ) is of greater moment than all the other businesses , that ever have been debated since the begining of the vvorld to this day : but the highest of honours and heaviest of burdens is put upon yovv ; to declare , out of the Sacred Records of Divine Truth , vvhat is the Prerogative of the Croun & extent of the Scepter of Jesus Christ ; vvhat bounds are to be set betvveen Him Ruling in His House , and povvers established by God on Earth ; hovv & by vvhom His House is to be Governed ; and by vvhat vvayes a restraint is to be put on these , vvho vvould pervert His Truth and subvert the faith of many . II. In the manner of maintaining this Testimony , these famous Fathers while faithful for God gave us a perfect pattern of purity & strictness , in opposition to all degrees of conformity & complyance with the Corruptions of the time ; and laid down such Rules & Constitutions , as might regulate us in our Contendings about present Defections , and teach us what account to make of them , and how to carry towards them : which if adverted unto , would evince how manifest & manifold the declinings of many have been from the late Reformation , that yet pretend to adhere unto it , and how Justifieable the aversation & abstraction of the present reproached suffering party is , from all these defections and the daubings of them , because so much deviating & declining from the attained Reformation . I need not repeat , how Prelacy , and all the parts & pendicles of that Antichristian Hierarchy , were abjured in the National Covenant , and condemned in the Acts of Assemblies , and reabjured in the solemn League & Covenant , and in the solemn Acknowledgment of ●ins & Engagment to duties , where also we came under Sacred & Inviolable Engagments , to endeavour the extirpation thereof : Which doth clearly file the present Countenancing & submitting to the Prelatick Curats , in receiving ordinances from them , among the grossest of defections ; being altogether inconsistent with these Acts and Constitutions & Covenant-obligations to extirpate them , as much as the countenancing of Popish Priests were inconsistent therewith , being both equally Covenanted to be extirpated . Next , though in this Period , Tyrannie being in its Retrograde Motion , Erastian Supremacy was not so much contended for , and therefore not so much questioned as formerly , being held exploded with exsecration out of doors & out of doubt ; yet the Testimony was still continued against it , in the uninterupted maintaining of the Churches Priviledges and freedom of Assemblies , against all Encroachings of Adversaries . And therefore the embracing of the late detestable Indulgences , were as Contrary to the Actings of this as to the Testimonies of the former Period , against the Supremacy from which they flow . Yea many Particulars , might be instanced , wherein the Accepters had declined from the Covenanted Reformation then prosecuted ; not only in their Confederating with Malignant Usurpers , for the pretended benefite of them ( by which , if there had been no more , they are obnoxious to the Censure of the Church , standing registred in an Act of Assembly , ordaining all persons in Ecclesiastick office , for the like or lesser degrees of Complyance , yea even for procuring protections from Malignant Enemies , to be suspended from their office & all exercise thereof At Edinb . 1646. Sess , 14 ) Nor only in their taking sinfull Instructions from them , restricting them in the exercise of their Ministry ; but in admitting themselves , by their patronage , to be by them presented to their prelimited & preimposed Congregations : which involves them in the iniquity of the Abolished Patronages , condemned by the Assembly ; for that the Ministry of such so presented , is made too much to depend upon the will & pleasure of man , and such an imposition is Destructive of the Church & peoples Liberties , obstructive of the Gospels freedom & faithful plainness , and occasion of much base flattery & partiality ; And in subjecting to , homologating , & fortifying a Sacrilegions Supremacy , overturning the Intrinsick power of the Church , contrare to the Covenant obliging to the Preservation of the Government , as well as to the Doctrine of the Church , in the first Article thereof ; And in their suffering themselves , either directly or indirectly , either by Combination , persuasion , or terror , to be divided & withdrawn from that blessed Union & Conjunction , which they were obliged to maintain & promove , according to the 6th Art. of the Solemn League & Covenant ; And in their strengthening the Erastian Usurpations of Enemies encroaching upon the Churches Liberties and Christs prerogatives , against which wer are engaged expressly in the Solemn Acknowledgment of sins and Engagment to duties , where also we have these words Art. 2. Because many have of late laboured to supplant the Liberties of the Church , we shall maintain & defend the Church of Scotland , in all her Liberties & Priviledges , against all who shall oppose or undermine the same , or encroach thereupon under any pretext whatsomever , Next , we have many Demonstrations of the zeal & strictness of these Servants of Christ , in their Synodical determinations of Censures , to be past upon many Ministerial Corruptions ; which will condemn the present course of covering & countenancing them , and commend the Contendings of a poor reproached party against them , in their consciencious abstracting from them . Of which determinations , I shal rehearse some . Among the Enormities & Corruptions of the Ministrie , in their Callings , this is one , § . 4. 5. Silenee in the publick Cause — Some accounting it a point of wisedom to speak ambiguously — whereof the remedie is § . 15. That beside all other scandals , Silence or Ambiguous speaking in the publick Cause — be seasonably Censured , Gen. Ass. at Edinb . Iunij 13. 1646. There is indeed an Act against withdrawers from Ministers : but in the self same Act , they are charged to be diligent in fulfilling their Ministrie , to be faithful in Preaching , declaring the whole Counsel of God , and as they have occasion from the Text of Scripture to reprove the sins & errors , and press the duties of the time , And in all these to observe the Rules prescribed by the Acts of Assembly , wherein if they be negligent , they are to be Censured , Gen , Ass. Edinb . Aug. 24. 1647. Sess. 19. Then there is that Act , August 3. 1648. Sess. 26. for Censuring Ministers for their silence , and not speaking to the Corruptions of the time ; Calling it , a great Scandal , through some Ministers their reserving & not declaring themselves against the prevalent sins of the times ; appointing , that all that do not apply their Doctrine to these Corruptions , which is the Pastoral Gift , and that are cold or wanting of Spiritual zeal , Dissembling of Publick sins , that all such be Censured even to deprivation ; for forbearing or passing in silence the Errors & Exorbitancies of Sectaries in England , or the defections current at home , the plots & Practises of Malignants , the Principles & Tenents of Erastianisme ; And if they be found too sparing , general , or ambiguous in their applications & reproofs , and continuing so , they are to be deposed , for being pleasers of men rather than servers of Christ , for giving themselves to a detestable indifferency or Neutrality in the Cause of God , for defrauding the souls of people , yea for being highly guilty of the blood of Souls , in not giving them warning . And in that seasonable & necessary warning of the Gen. Ass. Edinb . Iuij 27. 1649. Sess. 27. we are taught how they resented the unfaithfulness of Ministers continuing in defections , and how we are to look upon them & carry to them : where they say ; It is undenyably true , that many of the evils , wherewith this Church & Kingdom hath been afflicted in our age , have come to pass because of the negligence of some and corruptions of others of the Ministrie ; And the course of backsliding was carryed on , untill it pleased God to stir up the spirits of these few , who stood in the Gap , to oppose & resist the same , and to begin the work of Reformation in the Land ; since which time , the silence of some Ministers , & the complyance of others , hath had great influence upon the backslidings of many amongst the people , who , upon the discovery of the evil of their way , complain that they got not warning , or that if they were warned by some , others held their peace , or did justify them in the course of their backsliding : we can look upon such Ministers no otherwise , than upon these that are guilty of the blood of the Lords people , and with whom the Lord will reckon , for all the breach of Covenant & defection that hath been in the Land ; The Priests lips should preserve knowledge , and they should seek the Law at his mouth , for he is the Messenger of the Lord of Hosts , but such as are departed out of the way , and have caused many to stumble at the Law , therefore hath the Lord made them contemptible before all the people , according as they have not kept His wayes , but have been partial in His Law , because they have lost their savour , He hath cast out many of them as unsavoury salt . Further more , to evidence the Purity & power of zeal burning & blazing in these dayes , in their Contendings against Publick Enemies on all hands , I shall instance some of their Acts & Testimonies , clearly condemning the manifold Complyances of this Generation , and which may contribute somewhat to Justifie the reproached preciseness of a Remnant , standing at the furthest distance from them . There is an Act for Censuring the Complyers with the publick Enemies of this Church & Kingdom , Gen. Ass. Edinb . Iunij 17. 1646. Sess. 14. where , they judge it a great & scandalous provocation , & grievous defection from the publick cause , to comply with these Malignants ( such as Iames Graham then was ) in any degree , even to procure Protections from them , or to have invited them to their houses , or to have drunk Iames Graham his health , or to be guilty of any other such Gross degrees of Complyance ; censured to be suspended from the communions , ay & while they acknowledge their offence . And yet now , for refusing these degrees of complyance , for not having the protectior of a Pass from the wicked courts of malignant enemies , by taking a wicked oath , and for refusing to drink the Kings health , a greater Enemy then ever Iames Graham was , some poor conscientious people have not only been murdere● by Enemies , but mocked & condemned by professores . There is an Act likewise , & declaration against all new oaths or bonds in the common cause imposed without consent of the Church Gen. Ass. Edinb . Iuly 28. 1648. Sess. 18. Enjoining all the members of the Church to forbear the swearing or subscribing any new oaths or bonds , in this Cause , without Advice & concurrence of the Church , especially any negative oaths or bonds , which may any way limit or restrain them in the duties whereunto they are obliged , by National or Solemn League & Covenant . Yet now , for refusing Oaths , not only limiting in Covenanted duties , but contradicting & condemning many material Principles of the Covenanted Reformation , many have not only lost their Lives , but also have been condemned , by them that are at ease having a wider conscience to swallow such baits . It is known how pertinacious the most faithful in those dayes were , in their contendings against Associations , in any undertaking for the cause , with persons disaffected to the true state thereof . I need not give any account of this , were it not that now that Principle is quite inverted ; and poor Adherers to it , for their abstracting & substracting their concurrence with such promiscuous Associations , are much hated & flouted ; therefore I shall give some hints of their sentiments of them . In their Answer to the Committee of Estates , Iulij 25. 1648. Sess. 14. the Gen. Assembly sayes , It was represented to the Parliament , that for securing of Religion it was necessary , that the Popish , Prelatical , & Malignant party , be declared Enemies to the cause upon the one hand , as well as Sectaries upon the other , and that all Associations either in forces or counsels , with the former as well as with the latter , be avoided . And in their declaration concerning the Present dangers of Religion , especially the unlawful Engagment in War , Iulij , ult . 1648. Sess. 21. They say , suppose the ends of that Engagment be good ( as they are not ) yet the means & wayes of Prosecution are unlawful ; because there is not an equal avoiding of rocks on both hands , but a joining with Malignants to suppress Sectaries , a joining hands with a black devil to beat a white devil ; They are bad Phisicians who would so cure one disease , as to breed another as evil or worse — we find in the Scriptures condemned , all Confederacies & Associations with the Enemies of true Religion , whether Canaanites Exod. 23. 32. and 24. 12 , 15. Deut. 7. 2. or other heathens 1. King. 11. 1 , 2. More Arguments against Associations may be seen in that excellent discussion of this useful Case , Concerning Associations & Confederacies with Idolaters Infidels Hereticks or any other known enemy of Truth or Godliness , by famous Mr G. Gillespie , published at that same time : whereunto is appended his Letter to the commission of the General Assembly , having these golden words in it , words fitly spoken in that season , when he was a dying , at the begining of the Publick Resolutions Having heard of some motions & beginings of complyance , with these who have been so deeply engaged in a war destructive to Religion & the Kingdoms Liberties , I cannot but discharge my conscience , in giving a Testimony against all such complyance . I know & am perswaded , that all the faithful witnesses that gave Testimony to the Thesis , that the late Engagment was contrary & destructive to the Covenant , will also give Testimony to the Appendix , that complyance with any who have been active in that Engagment is most sinful & unlawful . I am not able to express all the evils of that complyance , they are so many — But above all , that which would highten this sin even to the Heavens is , that it were not only a horrid backsliding , but a backsliding into that very sin , vvhich vvas specially pointed at & punished by the prevailency of the Malignant party , God justly making them thorns & scourges vvho were taken in as friends . Alas ! shall we split twice upon the same rock ? yea run upon it , when God hath set a beacon on it ? yea I may say , shall we thus out face & out dare the Almighty , by protecting His & our Enemies , by making peace & friendship with them , when the anger of the Lord is burning against them . I mus● here apply to our present condition , the words of Ezrah . 9. 14 — O happy Scotland , if thow canst now improve & not abuse this Golden opportunity ? but if thou help the ungodly , & love them that hate the Lord , wrath upon wrath , and wo upon wo , shall be upon thee from the Lord. Whereunto is subjoined his dying Testimony to the same purpose ; wherein are these words , , But if there shall be a falling back , to the sin of complyance with Malignant ungodly men , then I look for the breaking out of the wrath of the Lord , till there be no remedy . This was the warning of a worthy dying Man. Notwithstanding of which & many other warnings & witnessings , a course of complyance was commenced by the pulick Resolutioners , and continued in to this day ; wherein that faithful warning of a dying servant of Christ is verified . But before I leave this purpose , I must obviate an objection that some make use of for strengthening themselves in their incorporations & joinings at least in Worship , with the corruptions of the time , and for condemning conscientious withdrawers ; That the Godly in those dayes did not separate from the men of these complyances & defections , as many do now , to wit the protesting party did not withdraw from the publick Resolutioners & Associators with Malignants . I answer , first , many & these the most Godly & tender did withdraw , even from their oun Ministers , and would have gone 40. or 50 myles to hear a faithful Minister at that time : yea Ministers themselves , in the case of intrusion of the unfaithful , would have supplyed the Paroch , as if the Church had been vacant , and when they could not get access to the pulpit , they preached in the fields , on purpose to witness against , and professedly to withdraw the people from such an unfaithful Intruder ; as might be instanced particularly for time & place , if need were . But next , The Church then , though broken by division , and under the subjection of strangers deprived of her General Assemblies , yet was in a constitut Case , enjoying the priviledge , power & order of Synods & Presbyteries , to whom the people offended with their Ministers might address themselves , for an orderly redress , and removal of these Scandals in an ordinary way ; and so they needed not assume to themselves that power to regulate their communion , that in a broken State , as now is , must be allowed to them . And besides , both the Ministers at that time who were faithful , though they might have proceeded to censure & silence the corrupt party as they were obliged , yet not only found it difficult by reason of the injury of the times ; but also thought it best to spare them , And the people to bear them , as burdens ; untill , as they were still in hopes , they should obtain a General Assembly to take order with them but now it is not so . And then the defection was but begining , and people did not know and could not expect it would go such a length , and therefore could not fall upon the rigor of that duty , which such disorders call for at first : but if they had seen where these beginings would Land them at length , I doubt not but they would have resisted those beginings , in such a way as would have precluded this imputation of novelty upon our necessitated with drawings . III. We have in this Period , not only an Illustrious Testimony for the Principle , but a continued and unintermitted putting into practice the duty of defensive Armes , in resisting the Soverain power , malversing & abusing Authority to the destruction of the ends of it ; which resistence was avowed , encouraged , & furthered by the General Assembly , both for the defence of themselves , and for the help of their Brethren in England . Take one expression in their Solemn & seasonable Warning to all ranks Feb. 12. 1645. Sess 18. Unless men will blot out of their hearts the love of Religion & cause of God , and cast off all care of their Country , Lawes , Liberties &c. ( all being in visible danger of present ruine & destruction ) they must now or never appear actively , each one stretching himself to , yea beyond his power . It is no time to dally , or to go about the business by halfs , nor be almost but altogether zealous : Cursed is he that doeth the work of the Lord negligently . If we have been forward to assist our Neighbour Kingdoms , shall we neglect to defend our oun ? Or shall the Enemies of God be more active against His cause , than His people for it ? God forbid . In another seasonable & necessary warning Iuly 27. 1649. Sess. 27. They say , But if his Maj. or any having or pretending power & commission from him , shall invade this Kingdom , upon pretext of establishing him in the exercise of his royal power ; as it will be an high provocation against God , to be accessory or assisting there to , so it will be a necessary duty to resist & oppose the same . These Fathers could well distinguish , between Authority and the person abusing it : And were not so Loyal , as now their degenerate Children are ambitious to shew themselves , stupidly stouping to the shaddow thereof , and yet will be called the only Asserters of Presbyterian principles . But we find , they put it among the Characters of Malignants , to confound the Kings honour & Authority with the abuse & pretence thereof , and with Commissions , warrants , & Letters , procured from the King by the Enemies of the cause & Covenant , as if we could not oppose the Latter , without increaching upon the former . But here , an Objection or two must be removed out of the way , before we go forward . One is , from the Third Atticle of the Covinant ; where there seems to be a great deal of Loyaltie , obliging to defend the Kings Maj. his person & Authority , in the preservation & defence of the true Religion & Liberties of the Kingdoms , that the world may bear witness with our consciences of our Loyaltie , And that we have no thoughts or intentions to diminish his Majesties just power & greatness . I Ans. There is indeed a deal of Loyaltie there , and true Loyaltie , because Lawfully limited , being qualified with & subordinate unto the preservation & defence of the true Religion & Liberties of the Kingdom ( as the makers of the Covenant do expound it , in the Assembles declaration against the unlawful Eugagment Iuly ult . 1648. Sess. 21. ) not that Reverse Loyaltie , which makes duties to God conditional & limited , and duties to thee King absolute & unlimited , as our Loyalists do now . And I wish others were free of it , who have sworn Oaths of unlimited Alledgiances , to maintain the King in any power unto which his force aspires ; and to justify this their Loyaltie , will bring in this Article of the Covenant with a distorted sense , reading it backward , that we in the preservation & defence of Religion must preserve & defend the King : As if Religion obliged to defend him , do what he will. It were better such pretended Covenanters , denyed the Covenant , than to be such a reproach to it , in wresting its genuine sense . But I have adduced the sense of the best Interpreters of it , the General Assembly . Next when they entered under the bond of this Covenant , they did it with a purpose to oppose all his invasions upon Religion & the Liberty of the people , and to vindicate these precious Interests from his usurpings , into a state of Liberty : And shall we imagine , that that very Oath of God did lay upon them or us an obligation , to defend the person who is a destroyer of all these , contrary to the very nature of the Oath , contrare to the scope of the Covenanters , and contrary to their subsequent practise ? But then it will be urged , why then was that clause cast into the Covenant ? I answer we have not the same cause to keep it , as they had some cause to put it in , with accommodation to the present possessor of the Soveraignity . The ouning of it in our circumstances would be as great a reproach to us , as the want of it was to them in theirs . They put in the words , to prevent the worlds mistake , and to remove that odium industriously heaped upon the heads of those , whose hearts were associate in the defence of Religion & Liberty , therefore they would profess they would not be disloyal while he was for God. And a defiance may be given to clamour , & calumnie it self , to give one instance of the defect of performance hereof , while he went not about to ruine those things , incomparably more precious then his person or Authority , and in ruining whereof no person can retain Authority . IV. But now two things will chiefly be desiderated , which now we oune in our Testimony , for which many have dyed , that seem not to be confirmed by or consistent with the Testimony of this Period . One is , that we not only maintain defensive resistance , but in some cases vindictive & punitive force , to be executed upon men that are bloody beasts of prey , and burdens to the earth , in cases of necessity , when there is no living for them . This principle of Reason & natural Justice , was not much inquired into in this time ; when the sun was up , whose warmth & light made these beasts creep into their dens , and when they , being brought under subjection , could not force people into such extraordinary violent courses when the ordinary & orderly course of Law was running in its right Channel . Yet from the ground of their ordinary Procedure , Military & Civil , against such Monsters , we may gather the lawfullness of an ordinary Procedure in a pinch of necessity , conforme to their grounds : I hope to make this evident , when I come ex proposito to vincicate this head . But there is another thing that we onne , which seems not to have been known in these dayes , viz. That when we are required to oune the Authority of the present Dominator , we hold sinful to oune it . Yet we find these Reverend & renouned Fathers ouned King Charles I. and did not refuse the succession of Charles II. I shall answer in order . First , as to King Charles the first , there was a great difference betuixt him and his sons that succeeded ; he never declared Parliamentarely that neither Promises , Contracts , nor Oaths should bind him , as the first of his perfidious sons did ; It might have been then presumed , if he had engaged so far for promoving the Work of God , he would have been a man of his word ( for to say a King of his word , is antiquitate in a good sense , except that it means he is as absolute in his word as in his sword , and scorns to be a slave to it ) Neither professed he himself a Papist , as the second Son hath done : Again it must be granted , that more might have been comported with in the begining , when there were some hopes of redress , than after such process of time ; whereby now we see & feel beyond all debate , that the Throne stands and is stated , not only in opposition to , but upon the ruines of the Rights & Priviledges both of Religion & Liberty . But was not the equivalent done by the Church , anno 1648. when they refused to concur with that unlawful Engagment , for restoring of the King , till security be had , by Solem Oath under his hand & Seal , that he shall for himself & Successors , give his assent to all Acts & Bills for enjoining Presbyterial Government , and never make opposition to it , nor endeavour any change thereof ? Iulij ult . 1648. Sess , 21. But it will be said , that in their renewing the Covenant that year , they did not leave out that Article . True , thereby they stopped the mouths of their Adversaries : And then they were not without hopes , but that in his straits he might have proved a Manasseh taken among the thornes . And the Covenanters at that time , not being clear that he had done that which ipso jure made him no Magistrate , chused rather while matters stood so to ingage to maintain him , than simply to disoune him ( which yet our forefathers did upon smaller grounds many times ) in the hopes of being prevailed with at last . But when they saw that this proved ineffectual , therefore at the Coronation of the new King they made the Covenanted Interest the sole Basis upon which alone Authority was conferred upon him . For the second , though they did not refuse the succession of Charles the Second ( which vvas their blame and our bane , of vvhich vve may blush this day ) yet vve find many things in that Transaction vvhich justifie our disouning of him , and condemn the ouning of the present Possessor . ( 1. ) In that seasonable & necessary warning Iulij 27. Sess. 27. vvhereas many vvould have admitted his Maj. to the exercise of his Royal povver , upon any termes vvhatsoever : The Assembly declares first ; That a boundless & illimited povver is to be acknovvledged in no King nor Magistrate ; neither is our King to be admitted to the exercise of his povver , as long as he refuses to vvalk in the administration of the same , according to this rule . Secondly , that there is a mutual stipulation & obligation betvveen the King & the people , as both of them are tyed to God , so each of them are tyed to one another , for the performance of mutual & reciprocal duties ; accordingly Kings are to take the Oath of Coronation , to abolish Popery & maintain the Protestant Religion : As long therefore as the King refuses to engage & oblige himself for security of Religion & safety of his people , it is consonant to Scripture & Reason and Lavves of the Kingdom , that he should be refused . Thirdly , in the League & Covenant the duty of defending & preserving the King , is subordinate to the duty of preserving Religion & Liberty : And therefore , he standing in opposition to the publick desires of the people for their security , it vvere a manifest breach of Covenant , and a preferring the Kings Interest to the Interest of Jesus Christ , to bring him to the exercise of his povver . Fourthly , That it vvas for restraint of Arbitrary Government , and for their Just defence against Tyranny , that the Lords people did join in Covenant , and have been at the expence of so much blood these years past ; And if he should be admitted to the Government before satisfaction , it vvere to put in his hand that Arbitrary Povver , and so to abandon their former Principles , and betray the Cause . Fifthly , That he , being admitted before satisfaction , vvould soon endeavour an overturning of the things vvhich God hath wrought , and labour to dravv publick administrations , concerning Religion & Liberty , into that course & Channel in vvhich they did run under Prelacy , and before the work of Reformation . Whence they warn that every one take heed of such a snare , that they be not accessery to any such design , as they would not bring upon themselves & their families , the guilt of all the detriment that will undoubtedly follow thereupon , of all the miseries it will bring upon the Kingdoms — And therefore who soever attempt the same , oppose themselves to the cause of God , and will at last dash against the Rock of the Lords power , which hath broken in pieces many high & lofty ones , since the begining of the work in the Kingdoms . ( 2 ) I shall here insert the Act of the West-Kirk , declaring their mind very manifestly . West Kirk . August . 13. 1650. The Commission of the General Assembly , considering that there may be just ground of stumbling , from the K. Maj. refusing to subscribe & emitt the Declaration , offered to him by the Committee of Estates and the Commission of the General Assembly , concerning his former carriage & resolutions for the future , in reference to the Cause of God and the enemies & friends thereof ; Doth therefore declare , That this Kirk & Kingdom doth not oune or espouse any Malignant Party , or Quarrel , or Interest , but that they fight meerly upon their former Grounds & Principles , and in the defence of the Cause of God and of the Kingdom , as they have done these twelve years past : And therefore , as they disclaim all the sin & guilt of the King and of his house , so they will not oune him nor his interest , otherwise than with a subordination to God , and so far as he ounes & prosecutes the Cause of God , and disclaims his & his fathers opposition to the Work of God , and to the Covenant , and likewise all the enemies thereof ; And that they will with convenient speed take unto Consideration the Papers , lately sent unto them by Oliver Cromwel , and vindicate themselves from all the falshoods contained therein ; especially in these things wherein the quarrel betwixt us & that party is Mistated , as if we ouned the late Kings proceedings , and were resolved to prosecute & maintain his present Maj. Interest , before & without acknowledgment of the sin of his house and former wayes , & satisfaction to Gods people in both Kingdoms . A. KER . Aug. 13. 1650. The Committe of Estates , having seen & considered a Declaration of the Commission of the General Assembly , anent the stating of the quarrel wherein the Army is to fight , do approve the same , and heartily concur therein . Tho : Henderson . In the ( 3 ) place : It is specified in the Causes of wrath , as one of the steps of defection , Art. 9. Step. 5. That a Treaty should have been closed with him , upon his subscribing demands , after he had given many clear evidences of his disaffection & enmity to the work & people of God : That these demands , which he was required to subscribe , did not contain a real security , a real abandoning of former Malignant courses & principles , and cleaving to the Work of God ; It was not a paper or verbal security , which we were bound to demand of him , but a real one ; and to intrust him without this , was but to mock God , and deceive the world , and to betray & destroy our selves , by giving up all precious Interests of Religion & Liberty unto the hands of one , who was in a course of enmity to them : That both before , and in the mean time of the treaty , he had given evidence of his enmity in many instances , there condiscended upon particularly ; that he authorized Iames Graham to invade this Kingdom , and incouraged him by Letters to go on in that Invasion , even whilest he was in termes of a Treaty with us , as appeared by bringing into our hands the Authentick Commission it self , and sundry Letters under his own hand . Next , in the same Causes of wrath , among the sins of the Ministrie , in relation to the publick , § . 10 , 11 , 12 , 13. That they agreed to receive the King to the Covenant , barely upon writing , without any apparent evidences of a real change of principle : That they did not use freedom , in showing what was sinful in reference to that Treaty , but went on therein when they were not satisfied in their consciences , for fear of reproach & of being mistaken : That they were silent in publick , and did not give Testimony , after a discovery of the Kings Commission to Iames Graham for invading the Kingdom : That they pressed the King to make a Declaration to the world , whilst they knew by clear evidences that he had no real conviction of the things contained therein . PERIOD . VI. Containing the Testimony through the continued Tract of the present Deformation from the year 1660. to this day . NOw comes the last Catastrophe of the Deformation of the Church of Scotland , which now renders her to all Nations as infamously despicable , as her Reformation formerly made her admired & envied ; which in a Retrograde motion hath gradually been growing these 27 years , going back through all the steps by which the Reformation ascended , till now she is returned to the very border of that Babylon , from whence she took her departure , and reduced through defection , & division , and persecutions , to a confused Chaos of almost irreparable dissolution , and unavoidable desolation . Through all which steps notwithstang , to this day , Scotland hath never wanted a witness for Christ , against all the various steps of the Enemies advancings , and of professed friends declinings : Though the Testimony hath had some singularities , some way discriminating it from that of former Periods ; in that it hath been more difficult , by reason of more desperate & dreadful assaults of more enraged enemies , more expert & experienced in the accursed art of overturning than any formerly ; In that it hath been attended with more disadvantages , by reason of the Enemies greater prevalency , and Friends deficiency , and greater want of significant Assertors , than any formerly ; In that it hath been intangled in more multifarious intricacies , of questions , and debates , and divisions among the Assertors themselves , making it more dark , and yet in the end contributing to clear it more than any formerly ; In that it hath been intended & extended to a greater measure , both as to matter & manner of contendings against the Adversaries , and stated upon nicer points ; more enixely prosecuted & tenaciously maintained , & sealed with more sufferings , than any formeriy ; In that it hath had more opposition & contradiction , and less countenance from professed friends to the Reformation , either at home or abroad , than any formerly . And yet it hath had all these several specialities together , which were peculiar to the former Testimonies , in their respective Periods : being both Active & Passive , both against Enemies & Friends ; And in cumulo stated against Atheisme , Popery , Prelacy , & Errastian Supremacy , which were the successive heads of the former Testimonies , and also now extended in a particular manner against Tyrannie . And not only against the substance & essence of these in the abstract , but against substance & circumstance , abstract & concret root & branch , head & tail of them , and all complying with them , conforming to them , or countenancing of them , or any thing conductive for them , or deduced from them , any manner of way , directly or indirectly , formally or interpretatively . This is that extensive and very comprehensive Testimony of the present Period , as it is now stated & sealed with the blood of many : Which in all its parts , points & pendicles is most directly relative , and dilucidly reducible , to a complex Witness for the Declarative Glory of Christs Kingship and Headship over all , as He is God and as He is Mediator , which is the greatest concern that Creatures have to contend for , either as Men or as Christians . The matter of this Testimony , I shall give a short manuduction to the progress & Result of its Managment . During the Exile of the Royal Brothers , it is undenyably known that they were , by their Mothers caresses and the Jesuites Allurements , seduced to abjure the Reformed Religion ( which was easie to induce persons to that never had the sense of any Religion ) and to be reconciled to the Church of Rome : And that , not only they wrote to the Pope many promisses of promoting his projects , if ever they should recover the power into their hands again , and often frequented the Mass themselves ; but also , by their example and the influence of their future hopes , prevailed with many of their dependents & attendants abroad , to do the like . Yet it is also unquestionably known , that in the mean time of his Exile , ●e renewed & confirmed , by private Letters to Presbyterians , his many reiterated Engagments to adhere to the Covenant , and declared that he was & would continue the same man , that he had declared himself to be in Scotland ( wherein doubtless , as he was an expert Artist , he equivocated , and meant in his heart he would continue as Treacherous as ever ) which helped to keep a Loyal Impression of his Interest in the hearts of too many , and an expectation of some good of him , of which they were ashamed afterwards . And immediatly before his return , it s known what promises are contained in that Declaration from Breda ( from whence he came also the second time , with greater Treachery than at the first ) to all Protestants that would live peaceably under his Government ; begining now to weigh out his perfidie , & perjurie , & breach of Covenant , in offering to tolerote that in an Indulgence , which he swore to maintain as a duty . But in all this he purposed nothing , but to ingyre & ingratiate himself into the peoples over credulous affections , that they might not obstruct his return , which a jealousie of his intended Tyrannie would have awakened them to withstand . And so having seated himself , and strengthened his power against the attemptings of any , whom his conscience might suggest an apprehension that they ought to resist him , he thought himself discharged from all obligations of Covenants , Oaths , or promises , for which his faith had been pledged . And from the first hour of his arrival , he did in a manner set himself to affront & Defy the Authority , of God , and to be revenged upon his Kingdoms for inviting him so unanimously to sway their Scepter ; in polluting & infecting the people with all debaucheries & monstrous villanies ; and commencing his incestous Whoredoms that very first night he came to his Palace , wherein he continued to his dying day outvying all for vileness . Yet he went on deluding our Church with his dissimulations , and would not discover all his wickedness hatched in his heart at first , till his designs should be riper ; but directed a Letter to the Presbyterie of Edinburgh , declaring he was resolved to protect & preserve the Government of the Church of Scotland , as it is settled by Law without violation : Wherein it was observed he altered the Stile , and spake never a word of the Covenant , our Magna Charta of Religion & Righteousness , our greatest security for all Interests intrusted to him , but only of Law ; by which , as his practice expounded it afterwards , he meant the Prelatical Church , as it was settled by the Law of his Father , since which time he reckoned there was no Law but Rebellion . This was a piece & preludie of our base defection , & degeneration into blind , blockish , & brutish stupidity ; that after he had discovered so much perfidie , we not only at first tempted him to Perjurie , in admitting him to the Crown , upon his mock-engagment in the Covenant , whereby God was mocked , His Spirit was grieved , His Covenant prostituted , the Church cheated , & the State betrayed ; but after the Lord had broken his yoke from off our necks , by sending him to exile ten years , where he was discovered to be imbibing all that venome & Tyrannical violence , which he afterward vented in revenge upon the Nations ; and after we had long smarted for our first transaction with him ; yet not withstanding of all this , we beleeved him again , and Issachar-like couched under his burdens , and were so far from withstanding , that we did not so much as witness against the readmission & restauration of the head & tail of Malignants , but let them come in peaceably to the throne , without any security to the Covenanted cause , or for our Civil or Religious Interests , and by piece meal , at their oun ease , leasure & pleasure , to overturn all the Work of God , and reintroduce the old Antichristian yoke of abjured Prelacy , and blasphemous Sacrelegious Supremacy , and Absolute Arbitrary Tyrannie with all their abominations : which he , and with him the generality of our Nobility , Gentry , Clergy , & commonality by him corrupted , without regard to faith , or fear of God or man , did promote & propogate , until the Nation was involved in the greatest revolt from , & rebellion against God , that ever could be recorded in any Age or Generation ; Nay attended with greater & grosser Aggravations , than ever any could be capable of before us , who have had the greatest Priviledges that ever any Church had ; since the National Church of the Iewes , the greatest light ; the greatest effects of matchless magnified love , the greatest Convictions of Sin , the greatest Resolutions & Solemn Engagments against it , and the greatest Reformation from it , that ever any had to abuse & affront . O Heavens be astonished at this , & horribly afraid ! for Scotland hath changed her Glory , and the Crown hath fallen from off her head , by an unparalelled Apostasie , a free & voluntary , vvilfull & deliberate Apostasie , an avoued & declared & Authorized Apostasie , Tyrannically carried on by Militarie violence & cruelty , a most universal & every vvay unprecedented Apostasie ! I must a litle change my method , in deducing the narration of this Catastrophe , and subdistinguish this unhappie Period into several steps ; shevving hovv the Enemies opposition to Christ advanced , and the Testimony of His Witnesses did gradually ascend , to the pitch it is novv arrived at . I. These Enemies of God , having once got footing again , with the favour and the fawnings of the foolish Nation , went on fervently to further and promote their wicked design : and meeting with no opposition at first , did encourage themelves to begin boldly . Wherefore , hearing of some Ministers peaceably Assembled , to draw up a Monitory Letter to the King , minding him of his Covenant Engagments & promises ( which was though weak , yet the first witness & warning against that Heaven-daring wickedness then begun ) they cruelly incarcerate them . Having hereby much daunted the Ministry from their duty in that day , for fear of the like unusual & outragious usage . The Parliament conveens Ianuar. 1. 1661. without so much as a Protestation for Religion & Liberty given in to them . And there , in the first place , they frame & take the Oath of Supremacy , Exauctorating Christ , and investing His usurping Enemy with the spoils of his robbed Prerogative , acknowledging the King only supreme Governour over all persons & in all Causes , and that his power & Iurisdiction must not be declined . Whereby under all persons & all Cause● , All Church Officers , in their most properly Ecclesiastick Affairs & Concerns of Christ , are comprehended : And if the King shall take upon him to judge their Doctrine , Worship , Discipline , or Government , he must not be declined as an incompetent Judge . Which did at once enervate all the Testimony of the 4th Period above declared , and laid the foundation for all this Babel they have built since , and of all this war that hath been waged against the Son of God , and did introduce all this Tyrannie & absolute power which hath been since carried to its Complement , and made the Kings Throne the foundation of all the succeeding perjurie & Apostasie . Yet , though then our Synods & Presbytries , were not discharged , but might have had access in some Concurrence to witness , against this horrid Invasion upon Christs Prerogative and the Churches Priviledge , no joint Testimony was given against it , except that some were found witnessing against it in their singular Capacity by themselves . As faithful Mr Iames Guthrie , for declining this usurped Authority in prejudice of the Kingdom of our Lord Jesus , suffered death , and got the Martyrs Crown upon his head : And some others , for refusing that Oath arbitrarly imposed , were Banished or Confined , when they had gained this Bulwark of Christs Kingdom ; Then they waxed more insolent , and set up their Ensigns for signs , and broke doun the carved Work of Reformation with axes & hammers . In this Parliament 1661. They past an Act Rescissorie , whereby they annulled & declared void the National Covenant , the Solemn League & Covenant , Presbytrial Government , and all Lawes made in favours of the Work of Reformation , since the year 1633. O horrid wickedness ! both in its nature so attrocious , to condemn & rescind what God did so signally seal as His oun Work , to the conviction of the world , and for which He will rescind the Rescinders , and overturn these Overturners of His Work , and make the curse of that broken Covenant bind them to the punishment , vvhom its bond could not oblige to the duty Covenanted ; And in its design & end so base & detestable , for nothing but to flatter the King in making way for Prelacy , Tyranny , & Popery , and to indulge the licenciousness of some debauched Nobles ; who could not endure the yoke of Christs Government , and to suppress Religion & Righteousness under the ruines of that Reformation . But O holy & astonishing Justice , thus to recompense our way upon our own head ! to suffer this work & cause to be ruined under our unhappy hands , who suffered this Destroyer to come in before it was so effectually secured , as it should not have been in the power of his hand ( whatever had been in his heart , swelled with enmity against Christ ) to have razed & ruined that Work as now most wickedly he did , and drew in so many into the guilt of the same deed , that almost the whole Land not only consented unto it but applauded it ; by approving & countenancing another wicked Act framed at the same time , by that same perfidious Parliament for an Anniversary Thanksgiving commemorating every 29. of May , that Blasphemy against the Spirit & Work of God , and celebrating that unhappy Restauration of the Rescinder of the Reformation ; which had not only the concurrence of the universality of the Nation , But ( alas for shame that it should be told in Gath & c ! ) even of some Ministers who afterwards accepted the Indulgence ( one of which a Pillar among them , was seen scandalously dancing about the bonefires . ) And others , who should have alarmed the whole Nation quasi pro aris & focis , to rise for Religion & Liberty , to resist such wickedness , did wink at it . O how Righteous is the Lord now in turning our Harps into mourning ! Though alas ! we will not suffer our selves to this day , to see the shining Righteousness of this Retribution : And though we be scourged with Scorpions , & brayed in a Mortar , our madness , our folly in these irreligious frolicks , is not yet acknowledged let be lamented . Yet albeit , neither in this day when the Covenant was not only broken but Cassed & declared of no obligation , nor afterward when it was burnt ( for which Turks & Pagans would have been ashamed & afraid at such a terrible sight , and for which the Lords Anger is burning against these bold burners , and against them who suffered it , and did not witness against it ) was there any publick Testimony by protestation , or Remonstrance , or an publick witness ? though the Lord had some then , and some who came out afterward with the Trumpet at their mouth , whose heart then sorrowed at the sight : And some suffered for the sense they shewed of that Anniversary abomination , for not keeping which they lost both Church & Liberty . It s true the ordinary Meetings of Presbytries & Synods were about that time discharged , to make way for the exercise of the new power conferred on the four Prelats who were at Court , reordained & Consecrated thereby renouncing their former Title to the Ministry . But this could not give a discharge from a Necessary Testimony , then called for from faithful Watchmen . However the Reformation being thus rescinded & razed , and the House of the Lord pulled doun , then they begin to build their Babel . In the Parliament anno 1662. by their first Act they restore & reestablish Prelacy , upon such a foundation as they might by the same Law bring in Poperie , which was then designed ; and so settled its Harbinger Diocesan & Erastiar Prelacy , by fuller Enlargment of the Supremacy . The very Act beginneth thus . For as much as the ordering & disposal of the external Government of the Church , doth properly belong to his Maj. as an Inherent right of the Croun , by virtue of his Royal Prerogative , & Supremacy in Causes Ecclesiastick — what ever shall be determined by his Maj. with advice of the Arch Bishops , and such of the Clergy as he shall nominate , in the external Government of the Church ( the same consisting with the standing Lawes of the Kingdom ) shall be valide & effectual . And in the same Act all Lawes are rescinded , by which the sole power & Jurisdiction within the Church doth stand in the Church Assemblies , And all which may be interpreted , to have given any Church power , Jurisdiction , or Government to the Office bearers of the Church , other than that which acknowledgeth a dependence upon , & subordination to the Soveraign power of the King as Supreme . By which , Prelats are redintegrated to all their priviledges & preheminencies , that they possessed anno 1637. And all their Church power ( robbed from the Officers of Christ ) is made to be derived from , to depend upon , and to be subordinate to , the Croun prerogative of the King : whereby the King is made the only fountain of Church power , and that exclusive even of Christ , of whom there is no mentioned exception : And his vassals the Bishops , as his Clerks in Ecclesiastiks , are accountable to him for all their administrations ; A greater usurpation upon the Kingdom of Christ , than ever the Papacy it self aspired unto . Yet , albeit here was another display of a banner of defyance against Christ , in altering the Church Government of Christs Institution into the humane Invention of Lordly Prelacy , in assuming a power by prerogative to dispose of the external Government of the Church , and in giving his Creatures patents for this effect , to be his Administrators in that usurped Government ; There was no publick , Ministerial , at least united Testimony against this neither . Therefore the Lord punished this sinful & shamful silence of Ministers , in His holy Justice , though by mens horrid wickedness ; when by another wicked Act of the Council at Glasgow , above 300 Ministers were put from their Charges ; and afterwards , for their Non-conformity in not Countenancing their Diocesan Meeting , and not keeping the Anniversary day May 29. The rest were violently thrust from their labours in the Lords vineyard , and banished from their Parishes , and adjudged unto a nice & strange Confinement , twenty miles from their oun parishes , six miles from a Cathedral Church as they called it , and three miles from a Burgh ; whereby they were reduced in to many inconveniencies . Yet in this fatal Convulsion of the Church , generally all were struck with blindness & baseness , that a Paper-Proclamation made them all run from their posts , and obey the Kings Orders for their ejection . Thus were they given up , because of their forbearing to sound an alarm , charging the people of God , in point of Loyaltie to Christ , and under the pain of the Curse of the Covenant , to a wake and acquit themselves like men , and not to suffer the enemie to rob them of that Treasure of Reformation , which they were put in possession of , by the tears , prayers , & blood of such as went before them ; instead of those prudential fumblings , & fisflings then & since so much followed . Wherefore the Lord in His holy righteousness , left that enemie ( against whom they should have cried & contended , and to whose eye they should have held the Curse of the Covenant , as having held it first to their oun , in case of unfaithful silence in not holding it to his ) to cast them out of the House of the Lord , and dissolve their Assemblies , and deprive them of their priviledges , because of their not being so valiant for the Truth , as that a ful & faithful Testimony against that Encroachment might be found upon record . Nevertheless somewere found faithful in that hour & pour of darkness , who kept the Word of the Lords patience , and who were therefore kept in & from that tentation ( which carried many away into sad & shamful defections ) though not from suffering hard things from the hands of men ; & only these who felt most of their violence , found grace helping them to acquit themselves suitably to that dayes Testimony , being thereby prevented from an Active yeelding to their impositions , when they were made passively to suffer force . However that season of a publick Testimony was lost , and as to the most part never recovered to this day . The Prelats being settled , & readmitted to voice in Parliament , they procure an Act , Dogmatically condemning several Material parts & points of our Covenanted Reformation , to wit , these positions That it was lawful for Subjects , for Reformation or necessary self defence , to enter into leagues , or take up Armes , against the King : And particularly declaring that the national Covenant , as explained in the year 1638. and the Solemn league & Covenant , were & are i● themselves unlawful Oaths , and were taken by & imposed upon the subjects of this Kingdom against the fundamental Lawes & Liberties thereof , That all such gatherings & petitions , that were used in the begining of the late troubles , were unlawful & seditious : And whereas then People were led unto these things , by having disseminated among them such principles as these , That it was lawful to come with petitions & Representations of grievances to the King , That it was lawful for people to restrict their Allegiance under such & such limitations , and suspend it untill he should give security for Religion &c. It was therefore enacted , that all such positions & practices founded thereupon , were treasonable — And furder did enact ▪ that no person , by writing , praying , preaching , or malicious or advised speaking , express or publish any words or sentences , to stir up the people to the dislike of the Kings prerogative & Supremacy , or of the Government of the Church by Bishops , or justifie any of the deeds , actings , or things declared against by that Act. Yet not withstanding of all this subversion of Religion & Liberty , and restraint of asserting these Truths here trampled upon either before men by Testimony , or before God in mourning over these Indignities done unto Him , in everting these & all the parts of Reformation , even when it came to Daniels case of confession , preaching & praying Truths interdicted by Lavv ; fevv had their eyes open ( let be their vvindovvs in an open avouching them ) to see the duty of the day calling for a Testimony . Though aftervvards , the Lord Spirited some to assert & demonstrate the Glory of these Truths & duties to the vvorld . As that Judicious Author of the Apologetical Relation , vvhose Labours need no Elagium to commend them . But this is not all : for these men , having novv as they thought subverted the Work of God , they provided also against the fears of its revival : making Acts , declaring , that if the outed Ministers dare to continue to preach , and presume to exercise their Ministrie , they should be punished as seditious persons ; requiring of all a due acknowledgment of , & hearty complyance with , the Kings Government Ecclesiastical & Civil ; And that who soever shall ordinarly & wilfully withdraw & absent from the ordinary Meetings for Divine Worship in their ou● Churches on the Lords day , shall incur the Penalties there insert . Thus the sometimes Chast Virgin , whose name was Beulah to the Lord , the Reformed Church of Scotland , did now suffer a violent & villanous rape ; from a vermine of vile Schismatical Apostates , obtruded & imposed upon her , instead of her able , painful , faithful & succeseful Pastors , that the Lord had set over her , and now by their faintness & the Enemies force robbed from her ; And none now allowed by Law to administer the Ordinances , but either Apostate Curats , who by their Perjurie & Apostacy forfaulted their Ministry , or other Hirelings & Prelat● Journey-men , who run without a Mission except from them who had none to give according to Christs Institution , the seal of whose Ministry could never yet be shown in the Conversion of any sinner to Christ : but if the tree may be known by its fruit● , we may know whose Ministers they are ; ut ex ungue Leonem , by their Conversions of Reformation into Deformation , of the Work & Cause of God into the similitude of the Roman beast , of Ministers into Hirelings , of their Proselytes into ten times worse children of the Devil then they were before , of the power of Godlyness into formality , of Preaching Christ into Orations of Morality , of the purity of Christs Ordinances into the vanity of mens Inventions , of the beautiful Government of the House of God for Edification , to a Lordly preheminence & Domination over consciences , in a word of Church & State Constitutions for Religion & Liberty all up side doun into wickedness & slavery : These are the Conversions of Prelacy . But now this astonishing blow to the Gospel of the Kingdom , introducing such a Swarm of Locusts into the Church , And in forcing a Complyance of the people with this defection , and that so violently & rigorously , as even simple withdrawing was so severely punished by severe Edicts of fyning , & other arbitrary punishments at first ; what did it produce ? did it awaken all Christs Ambassadours , now to appear for Christ , in this clear & clamant case of Confessing Him , and the freedom & Purity of His Ordinances ? Alas ! the backwardness & bentness to backsliding , in a Superseding from the duties of that day , did make it evident , that now the Lord had in a great measure forsaken them , because they had forsaken Him. The standart of the Gospel was then fallen , and few to take it up . The Generality of Ministers & Professors both went & Conformed so far as to hear the Curats , contrary to many points of the Reformation formerly attained , contrare to their Covenant Engagments , and contrare to their oun principles & practice at that same time ; scrupling and refusing to keep the Bishops visitations , and to Countenance their Discipline & power of Iurisdiction , because it was required as a Testification of their acknowledgment of , & Complyance with the present Government , And yet not scrupling to Countenance their Doctrine & usurped power of Order required also by the same Law , as the same Test of the same Compliance & submission . It s strange that some yet doe plead for persisting in that same Complyance , after all the bitter Consequents of it . Other Ministers Lay altogether by in their retired recesses , waiting to see what things would turn to : Others were hopeless , turned Farmers & Doctors : others more wyllie , staid at home , & Preached quietly in Ladies Chambe●● But the faithful thought that this Tyrannical ejection did 〈◊〉 or could not unminister them , so as they might not Prea●●● Gospel where ever they were , as Ambassadours of 〈◊〉 ; but rather found themselves under an indispensible necessity to Preach the Gospel and witness for the freedom of their Ministry , and make full proof of it , in preaching in season & out of season : and thereupon as occasion offered preached to all such as were willing to hear ; but at first only in private houses , and that for the most part at such times , when Sermons in publick surceased ( a superplus of Caution . ) But afterwards , finding so great difficulties and Persecutions for their house Meetings , where they were so easily attrapped , were constrained at last to keep their Meetings in the fields , without shelter from cold , wind , snow , or rain . Where testifieing both practically & particularly against these Usurpations on their Masters Prerogatives , and witnessing for their Ministerial freedom , contrary to all Law-Interdictions , without any Licences or Indulgences from the Usurper , but holding their Ministry from Jesus Christ alone , both as to the Office & exercise thereof ; they had so much of their Masters Countenance , & success in their labours , that they valued neither hazards nor hardships , neither the contempt of pretended Friends , nor the Laws nor threatnings of Enemies , adjudging the penalty of death it self to Preachers at Field Conventicles as they called them . Now having thus overturned the Church Government , by introducing Prelacy , to advance an absolute Supremacy ; the effects whereof were either the Corruption , or Persecution of all the Ministrie , Encouragment of profanity & wickedness , the enerease & advancment of Popery , Superstition , & Error , cruel impositions on the Conscience , and oppressions for Conscience sake , by the practices of cruel Supra-Spanish Inquisitions , and all manner of outcryes of outragious violence & villany : The King proceeds in his design , to pervert & evert the wel modelled & moderated Constitution of the State Government also , by introducing & advancing an Arbitrary Tyranny ; the effects whereof were , an absolute Mancipation of Lives & Liberties and estates unto his lust & pleasure , the utter subversion of Lawes , and absolute impoverishin●● the people . For effectuating which , he first proc●● lasting Imposition of intollerable Subsidies & Taxati●● , to impoverish that he might the more easily enslave the Nation ; Next a further recognizance of his Prerogative , in a subjection of persons , fortunes , & whole strength of the Kingdom to his absolute arbitrement , in a Levy of Militia of 20000 footmen , & 2000 horsemen sufficiently armed , with 40 dayes provision , to be ready upon the Kings call to march to any part of his Dominions , for opposing whatsoever invasion , or insurrection , or for any other service . The first sproutings of Tyrannie were cherished , by the cheerfull & stupid submission generally yeelded to these exorbitances ; under which they who suffered most were inwardly Malecontents , but there was no opposition to them by word or Action , but on the contrary , generally people did not so much as scruple sending out or going out as Militia-men : never adverting unto what this Concurrence was designed , & demanded , and given for ; Nor what an accession it was , in the nature & influence of the mean it self , and in the sense & intention of the Requirers , unto a Confederacy for a Complyance with , and a Confirmation & strengthening of Arbitrary Tyrannie . After the fundamental constitutions of both Church & State are thus razed & rooted up , to confirm this Absolute Power , he contrived to frame all inferior Magistrats according to his mould : And for this end appointed , that all persons in any publick Trust or Office whatsoever should subscribe a Declaration , renouncing & abjuring the Covenants ; whereby Perjurie was made the chief & indispensible qualification , and Conditio sine qua non , of all that were capable of exercing any power or place in Church or State. But finding this not yet sufficient security for this unsettled settlement ; because he wel understood , the people stood no ways obliged to acknowledge him but only according to the solemn Covenants , being the fundamental Conditions whereupon their Allegiance was founded ( as amongst all people , the Articles mutually consented betwixt them and these whom they set over them , are the constituent fundamentalls of Government ) and wel knowing , that he & his Associats , by violating these Conditions , had loosed the people from all subjection , to him , or any deriving power from him , whereby the people might justly plead , that since he had kept no Condition they were not now obliged to him , he therefore contrived a new Oath of Allegiance to be imposed upon all in publick trust both in Church & State ; wherein they are made to oblige themselves to that Boundless breaker of all Bonds Sacred & Civil , and his Successors also , without any reciprocal obligation from him to them , or any reserved restriction , limitation , or qualification , as all humane Authority by Gods Ordinance must be bounded . Whereby the Swearers have by Oath homologated the overturning of the very Basis of the Government , making free people Slaves to the subverters thereof , betraying their native Brethren & posterity to the lust of Tyrannie , and have in effect as really as if in plain termes affirmed , that whatsoever Tyrannie shall command or do , either as to the overturning of the work of God , subverting of Religion , destroying of Liberty , or persecuting all the Godly to the utmost extremity , they shall not only stupidly endure it , but actively concur with it , and assist in all this Tyrannie . Alas there was no publick Testimony against this Trick , to bring people under the yoke of Tyrannie ; except by some who suffered for Consciencious refusing it , while many others did take it , thinking to salve the matter by their pitiful quibleng senses , of giving Cesar his due . Where as this Cesar , for whom these Loyal Alleg●ers plead , is not an ordinary Cesar , but such a Cesar , Nero , or Caligula , that if he got his due , it would be in another kind . Strange ! can Presbyterians swear that Allegiance , which is substitute in the place of the broken & burnt Covenant ? Or could they swear it to such a person , who having broken & buryed the Covenant , that he who had sworn it might have another right and another Allegiance than that of the Covenant , had then remitted to us all Allegiance founded upon the Covenant ? However , having now prepared & furnished himself with Tools so qualified for his purpose , in Church & State , he prosecutes his Persecution with such fervour & fury , rage & revenge , impositions & oppressions , and with armed formed force , against the faithful following their duty in a peaceable manner , without the least shadow of Contempt even of his abused Authority , that at length in the year 1666 , a small party were compelled to go to defensive armes . Which , whatever was the desire of the Court ( as it is known how desirous they have been of an Insurrection , when they thought themselves sure to suppress it , that they might have a vent for their Cruelty ; and how one of the Brothers hath been heard say , that if he might have his wish , he would have them all turn Rebells and go to armes . ) Yet it wa● no predetermined design of that poor Handful . For Sir Iames Turner , pursuing his cruel orders in Galoway , sent some Souldiers to apprehend a poor old man ; whom his neighbours compassionating , intreated the Souldiers to loose him as he lay bound , but were answered with drawen Swords and necessitated to their own defence : In which they relieve the man , and disarm the Souldiers , and further attacqued some others oppressing that Countrey , disarming 10 or 12 more , and killing one that made resistence . Whereupon , the Countrey being alarmed , and fearing from sad experience Sir Iames would certainly avenge this affront upon the whole Country , without distinction of free & unfree , they gather about 54 horsemen , march to Drumfreis , take Sir Iames Turner Prisoner , and disarm the Souldiers , without any more violence . Being thus by Providence engaged without any hope of retreat , and getting some Concurrence of their Brethren in the same Condition , they come to Lanerk , where they renew the Covenant ; and thence to Pentland hills : where , by the holy Disposal of God , they were routed , many killed , and 130 taken Prisoners , who were treated so treacherously & truculently , as Turks would have blushed to have seen the like . Hence now on the one hand , we may see the Righteousness of God , in leaving that Enemy to Him , whom we embraced , to make such avowed Discoveries of himself , without a blush to the world , and to scourge us with Scorpions that we nourished and put in his hands : And also , how justly at that time He left us into such a damp , that like Asses we couched under all burdens , and few came out to the help of the Lord against the Mighty , drawing on them Meroz's Curse , and the blood of their butchered Brethren ; after we had sitten , & seen , and suffered all things Civil & Sacred to be destroyed in our sight without resentment . And though the Lord , who called out these worthy Patriots who fell at Pentland to such an appearance for His Interests , did take a Testimony of their hands with acceptance by sufferings , and singularly Countenanced them in sealing it with their blood ; yet He would not give success nor His presence to the Enterprise , but left them in a sort of infatuation , without Counsel & Conduct , to be a prey to devourers , that by a sad inadvertency they took in the Tyrants Interest into the State of the Quarrel . Which should have warned His people for the future , to have stated the Quarrel otherwise . II. By this time ; and much more after , the King gave as many proofs & demonstrations of his being true to Antichrist , in minding all the promises & treaties with him , as he had of his being false to Christ , in all his Covenant Engagments with His People . For in this same year 1666. he , with his dear & Royal Brother the Duke of York , contrived , countenanced , & abetted , the burning of London , evident by their employing their Guards to hinder the People from saving their oun , and to dismiss the Incendiaries the Papists , that were taken in the fact . The Committee , appointed to cognosce upon that business , traced it fo far , that they durst go no further , unless they would arraign the Duke , & charge the King , and yet before this it was enacted as Criminal for any to say the King was a Papist . But having gained so much of his design in Scotland ; where he had established Prelacy , advanced Tyranny to the hight of Absoluteness , and his Supremacy almost beyond the reach of any additional supply , yea above the Popes oun Claim , and had now brought his only opposites , the few faithful Witnesses of Christ , to a Low pass ; he went on by Craft as wel as Cruelty , to advance his oun in promoting Antichrists Interest . And therefore , having gotten the Supremacy devolved upon him by Law ( for which also he had the Popes dispensation , to take it to himself for the time , under promise to restore & surrender it to him , as soon as he could attain his end by it , as the other Brother succeeding hath now done ) he would now exert that usurped power , and work by infnaring policy to effectuate the end which he could not do by other means . Therefore , seeing he was not able to suppress the Meetings of the Lords people for Gospel Ordinances , in house & fields , but that the more he laboured by violent courses the greater & more frequent they grew ; he fell upon a more Craftie device , not only to overthrow the Gospel and suppress the Meetings , but to break the faithful , and to divide , between the Mad-cap & the Moderate Fanaticks ( as they phrased it ) that he might the more easily destroy both ; to confirm the usurpation , and to settle people in a sinful silence & stupid submission to all the Incroachments made on Christs Prerogatives , and more effectually to overturn what remained of the Work of God. And , knowing that nothing could more fortifie the Supremacy than Ministers their homologating & acknowledging it ; Therefore he offerd the first Indulgence , Anno 1669. Signifying in a Letter , dated that year Iune 7. His gracious pleasure was , to appoint so many of the outed Ministers , as have lived peaceably & orderly , to return to preach & exercise other functions of the Ministrie , in the Paroch Churches where they formerly served ( provided they be vacant ) and to allow Patrons to present to other vacant Churches , such others of them as the Council should approve : That all who are so Indulged , be enjoyned to keep Presbytries , and the Refusers to be confined within the bounds of their paroches : And that they be enjoined not to admitt any of their neighbour Paroches unto their Communions , nor Baptize their Children , nor marry any of them , without the allowance of the Minister of the Paroch , and if they Countenance the people deserting their oun Paroches , they are to be silenced for shorter or longer time , or altogether turned out , as the Council shall see cause : And upon Complaint made & verified , of any Seditious discourse or expressions in the Pulpit , uttered by any of the Ministers , they are immediatly to be turned out , and further punished according to Law : And seeing by these orders , all Pretences for Conventickles were taken away , if any should be found hereafter to Preach without Authority , or keep Conventickles , his Pleasure is , to proceed with all severity against them , as Seditious persons & Contemners of Authority . To salve this in point of Law ( because it was against former Lawes of their oun ) and to make the Kings Letter the supreme Law afterwards , and a valid ground in Law , where upon the Council might proceed , & enact , and execute what the King pleased in Matters Ecclesiastick ; he therefore caused frame a formal Statutory Act of Supremacy , of this Tenor. That his Maj. hath the supreme Authority & Supremacy over all Persons and in all Causes Ecclesiastick , within his dominions , and that by virtue thereof , the ordering & disposal of the external Government of the Church , doth properly belong to him & his successors , as an Inherent right to the Croun : And that he may settle , enact , & emitt such Constitutions , Acts , & Orders , concerning the Administrating therof , and Persons employed in the same , and concerning all Ecclesiastical Meetings & Matters , to be proposed & determined therein ; as he in his Royal wisdom shall think fit : which Acts , Orders , & Constitutions , are to be observed & obeyed by all his Maj. Subjects , any Law , act , or custom to the contrary notwithstanding . Where upon , accordingly the Council , in their Act Iuli● . 27. 1669. do nominate several Ministers , and appoint them to Preach , and exercise the other functions of the Ministrie , at their respective Churches there specified , with Consent of the Patrons . The same day also they conclude & enact the forementioned Restrictions , conform to the Kings Letter above rehearsed , And ordain them to be intimat to every person , who is by Authority foresaid allowed the exercise of the Ministrie . These Indulged Ministers , having that Indulgence given only upon these termes , that they should accept these Injunctions , and having received it upon these termes also ( as an essential part of the bargain & Condition , on which the Indulgence was granted & accepted , as many following Proclamations did expressly declare ) do Appoint Mr Hutcheson , one of the number , to declare so much ; In Acknowledging his Maj. favour & Clemency , in granting that Liberty , after so long a restraint ; And however they had received their Ministrie from Jesus Christ , with full Prescriptions from Him for regulating them therein , yet nothing could be more refreshing on earth to them , than to have free Liberty for the exercise of their Ministrie , under the Protection of Lawful Authority : And so they purposed to be have themselves , in the discharge of the Ministrie , with that wisdom that became faithful Ministers , and to demean themselves towards Lawful Authority , notwithstanding of their known judgment in Church affairs , as wel becometh Loyal subjects ; And their prayer to God should be , that the Lord should bless his Maj. in his person & Government , and the Council in the publick administration , and especially in the Pursuance of his Maj. mind in his Letter , wherein his singular moderation eminently appears . — Afterwards they issued out Proclamations , reinforcing the punctual observation of the forementioned Injunctions , and delivered them into the Indulged . In the mean time , though Cruel Acts & Edicts were made against the Meetings of the Lords people , in houses & the fields , after all these Midianitish wyles to suppress them ; such was the presence of the Lord in these Meetings , and so powerful was His Countenance & Concurrence with the Labours of a few , who laid out themselves to hold up the Standart of Christ ; that the number of Converts multiplyed dayly , to the praise of free Grace , and to the great encouragment of the few hands that wrestled in that Work , through all humane discouragment . Therefore King & Council was put to a new shift , which they supposed would prove more effectual : To wit , because there was a great number of Non-conformed Ministers not yet Indulged , who either did or might hereafter hold Conventickles , therefore , to remeed or prevent this in time coming , they appoint & ordain them to such places where Indulged Ministers were settled , there to be confined with allowance to Preach as the Indulged should employ them ; thinking by this means to incapacitate many to hold Meetings there or elswere : And to these also they give injunctions & restrictions to regulate them in the exercise of their Ministrie . And to the end that all the outed Ministers might be brought under restraint , and the Word of God be kept under bonds , by another Act of Council they Command , that all other Ministers ( not Disposed of as is said ) were either to repair to the Paroch Churches where they were , or to some other Paroches where they may be ordinary hearers , and to declare & condiscend upon the Paroches where they intend to have their Residence . After this they assumed a Power , to Dispose of these their Curats as they pleased , and transport them from place to place ; whereof the only ground was a simple Act of Council , the Instructions alwayes going along with them , as the constant Companion of the Indulgence ▪ By all which it is apparent ; what ever these Ministers alledge , in vindication of it to cover its deformity , in their Balmes to take away its Stink , and in their Surveyes to gather Plaisters to scurf over its Scurveyness , viz. that it was but the removal of the Civil restraint , And that they entered into their places by the Call of the People ( a meer mock pretence for a Prelimited imposition , whereby that Ordinance of Christ was basely prostituted & abused ) And that their Testimony & Protestation was a Salvo for their conscience ( a meer Outopian fancy ▪ that the Indulgers with whom they bargained never heard of , otherwise , as they did with some who were faithful in testifying against their Encroachments , they would soon have given them a Bill of Ease ) It cannot be denyed , that that doleful Indulge●●e , both in its Rise , Contrivance ; Conveyance , Grant , & Acceptance , End & Effects , was a Grievous Encroachment upon the Princely Prerogative of Jesus Christ the only Head of the Church ; whereby the usurpers Supremacy was Homologated ; bowed to ▪ complyed with , strengthened & established ▪ the Cause & Kingdom of Christ betrayed , His Churches Priviledges surrendered , His Enemies hardened , His Friends stumbled , and the Remnant rent & ruined ; in that it was granted & deduced from the Kings Supremacy , and conveyed by the Council ; in that , according to his pleasure , he gave and they received a Licence & warrant , to such as he nominated & Elected and judged fit & qualified for it , and fixed them in what particular Paroch he pleased to assign , under the notion of a Confinment , in that he imposed and they submitted to restrictions in the exercise of their Ministry , in these particular Paroches , inhibiting to Preach elswhere in the Church ; And with these restrictions , he gave and they received instructions to regulate & direct them in their functions : All which was done without Advice or Consent of the Church : And thereupon they have frequentlie been called & coveened before the Counci● , to give ac●ount of their Ministerial exercise , and some of them sentenced , silenced , & deposed for alledged disobedience . This was a manifest Treason against Christ , which involved many in the actual guilt of it that day , and many others who gaped after it & could not obtain it , and for more at that time & since in the guilt of Misprision of Treason , in passing this also without a witness . Thus , in holy judgement , because of our Indulging & Conniving at the usurper of Christs Throne , He left a great part of the Ministers to take that wretched Indulgence ; and another part , instead of remonstrating the wickedness of that deed , have been left to palliate , & plaister , & Patronize it , in keeping up the Credit of the King & Councils Curats , wherein they have shewed more zeal , than ever against that wicked Indulgence . Yet the Lord had some Witnesses , who prettie early did give significations of their resentment of this dishonour done to Christ , as Mr William Weer , who having got the Legal Call of the People , and discharging his duty honestly , was turned out ; And Mr Iohn Burnet , who wrote a Testimony directed to the Council , shewing why he could not submit to that Indulgence , inserted at large in the History of the Indulgence ; Where also we have the Testimony of other ten Ministers , who drew up their Reasons of Non-Complyance with such a snare ; And Mr Alexander Blair , who , upon occasion of a Citation before the Council for not observing the 29 of Maij , having with others made his appearance , and got new Copies of Instructions presented to them , being moved with zeal and remembering whose Ambassadour he was , told the Council plainly , that he could receive no Instructions from them in the exercise of his Ministry , otherwise he should not be Christs Ambassadour but theirs , and herewith lets their Instructions drop out of his hand , knowing of no other Salv● or manner of Testifying for the Truth in the Case؛ for which he was imprisoned , & died under Confinement . But afterwards , the Lord raised up some more explicite Witnesses against that defection . All this Trouble was before the year 1673. About which time , finding this device of Indulgences proved so steadable for his Service in Scotland , he was induced to try it also in England ; which he did almost with the same or like success , & producing the same effects of defection , security , & unfaithfulness . The Occasion was upon his wars with the Dutch : Which gave another demonstrative discovery of his Treacherie & Popish perfidie , in breaking League with them , and entering into one with the French , to destroy Religion & Liberty in Britain : Wherein the King of France assures him an Absolute Authority over his Parliaments , and to reestablish the Catholick Religion in his Kingdoms of England Scotland & Ireland ; to Compass which it was necessary first to abate the pride & power of the Dutch , and to reduce them to the sole Province of Holland , by which means the King of England should have Zeland for a retreat in case of need , and that the rest of the Low Countries should remain to the King of France , if he could render himself Master of it . But to return to Scotland . While by the forementioned Device , he thought he had utterly suppressed the Gospel in house & field Meetings , he was so far disappointed , that these very means & Machins by which he thought to bury it , did chiefly contribute to its revival . For , when by Persecution many Ministers had been chased away by illegal Law-Sentences , many had been banished away , and by their ensnaring Indulgences many had been drawen away from their duty , and others were now sentenced with Confinements & Restraints , if they should not choose & fix their residence where they could not keep their Quiet & Conscience both ; they were forced to wander and disperse through the Country , and the People being tired of the cold & dead Curats , and wanting long the Ministrie of their old Pastors , so longed & hungered after the Word , that they behoved to have it at any rate cost what it would ; which made them entertain the dispersed Ministers more earnestly , and encouraged them more to their duty . By whose Endeavours , through the mighty power & presence of God , and the Light of His Countenance now shining through the Cloud , after so fatal & fearful a darkness that had over-clouded the Land for a while , with such a resplendent brightness , that it darkened the Prelatick Locusts , and made them hisse and gnash their tongues for pain , and dazeled the eyes of all Onlookers ; the Word of God grew exceedingly , and went through at least the Southern borders of the Kingdom like lightning , or like the Sun in its Meridian beauty ; discovering so the Wonders of Gods Law , the Mysteries of His Gospel , and the Secrets of His Covenant , and the Sins & Duties of that day , that a numerous issue was begotten to Christ , and His Conquest was Glorious , Captivating poor slaves of Satan , and bringing them from his power unto God , and from darkness to Light. O! who can remember the Glory of that Day , without a melting heart , in reflecting upon what we have lost , and let go , and sinned away , by our Misimprovements ? O that in that our day we had hearkened to His voice , and had known the things that belonged to our peace ! A day of such power , that it made the People , even the bulk & body of the People , willing to come out and venture , upon the greatest of hardships and the greatest of hazards , in pursuing after the Gospel , through Mosses & Moors , & inaccessible Mountains , Summer & Winter , through excess of heat & extremity of cold , many dayes & night-journeyes ; even when they could not have a probable expectation of escaping the Sword of the wilderness , and the barbarous fury of bloody Burrio's raging for their prey , sent out with orders to take & kill them , it being now made Criminal by Law , especially to the preachers & Convocaters of those Meetings . But this was a day of such power , that nothing could daunt them from their duty , that had tasted once the sweetness of the Lords presence at these persecuted Meetings . Then had we such Humiliation-dayes for personal & publick Defections , such Communion-dayes even in the open fields , and such Sabbath-Solemnities , that the places where they were kept might have been called Bethel , or Peniel , or Bochim , and all of them Iehovah-Shammah ; wherein many were truly Converted , more Convinced , and generally all Reformed from their former immoralities : That even Robbers , Thieves , and Profane Men , were some of them brought to a saving subjection to Christ , and generally under such restraint , that all the severities of heading & hanging &c. in a great many years , could not make such a Civil Reformation , as a few dayes of the Gospel , in these formerly the Devils Teritories , now Christs Quarters , where His Kingly Standart was displayed . I have not Language to lay out the inexpressible Glory of that day : But I will make bold to say two things of it , first , I doubt if ever there was Greater dayes of the Son of Man upon the Earth since the Apostolick times , than we enjoyed for the space of Seven years at that time : And next , I doubt , if upon the back of such a lightsome day there was ever a blacker night of darkness , defection , division , & confusion , and a more universal impudent Apostasie , than we have seen since . The world is at a great loss , that a more exact & complete account demonstrating both these , is not published , which I am sure would be a fertile Theme to any faithful pen. But this not being my scope at present , but only to deduce the steps of the Contendings of Christs Friends & His Enemies , I must follow the threed of my Narration . Now when Christ is gaining Ground by the preached Gospel in plenty , in purity , & power , the Usurpers Supremacy was like to stagger , and Prelacy came under universal Contempt , in so much that several Country Curats would have had but scarce half a dozen of hearers , and some none at all . And this was a General Observe that never failed , that no sooner did any poor Soul come to get a serious sense of Religion , and was brought under any real Exercise of Spirit about their Souls Concerns , but as soon they did fall out with Prelacy and left the Curats . Hence to secure what he had possessed himself of by Law , and to prevent a dangerous Paraxisme which he thought would ensue upon these Commotions , the King returned to exerce his innate Tyranny , and to emit terrible Orders , and more terrible Executioners , & bloody Emissaries , against all Field Meetings : which , after long patience ▪ the people at length could not endure ; but being first chased to the Fields , where they would have been content to have the Gospel with all the inconveniences of it , and also expelled from the Fields , being resolute to maintain the Gospel , they resolved to defend it & themselves by Armes . To which , unavoidable necessity in unsupportable extremity did constrain them , as the only remaining remedy . It is known , for several years they met without any Armes , where frequently they were disturbed & dispersed with Souldiers some killed others wounded , which they patiently endured without Resistence : At length the Ministers that were most in hazard , having a Price set upon their heads to be brought in dead or alive , with some attending them in their wanderings , understanding they were thus appointed for death , judged it their duty to provide for the necessary defence of their lives from the violence of their Armed Assaulters . And as Meetings increased , diverse others came under the same hazard , which enforced them to endeavour the same remedy , without the least intention of prejudice to any . Thus the number of Sufferers increasing , as they joyned in the Ordinances at these persecuted Meetings , found themselves in some probable Capacity to defend themselves and these much endeared & precious Gospel Priviledges , & to preserve the Memory of the Lords great Work in the Land , which to transmit to posterity was their great design . And they had no small encouragment to endeavour it , by the satisfying sweetness & comfort they found in these Ordinances , being perswaded of the justness of their Cause , and of the groundlessness of their Adversaries quarrel against them : And hereunto also they were incited & prompted , by the palpableness of the Enemies purposes to destroy the Remainder of the Gospel , by extirpating the Remnant that professed it . Wherefore in these circumstances , being redacted to that strait , either to be deprived of the Gospel or to defend themselves in their Meetings for it ; And thinking their turning their backs upon it for hazard , was a cowardly deserting duty , and palpable breach of Covenant-Engagments , abandoning their greatest Interest , They thought it expedient , yea necessary , to carry defensive Armes with them . And as for that discouragment from the difficulty & danger of it , because of their fewness & meanness , it did not deter or daunt them from the endeavour of their duty ; when they considered , the Lord in former times was wont to oune a very small party of their Ancestors , who in extremity jeoparded their lives in defence of Reformation against very potent & powerful Enemies : These now ouning the same Cause , judged themselves obliged to run the same hazard , in the same circumstances , and to follow the same method , & durst not leave it unessayed , leaving the event to God : considering also , that not only the Law of Nature & Nations doth allow self defence from unjust violence , but also the indissoluble obligation of their Covenants , to maintain & defend the true Religion & one another in promoving the same , made it indispensible to use that endeavour , the defect of which through their former supineness gave no small encouragment to the Enemies : They considered also what would be the consequence of that War , declared against all the Faithful of t●e Land with a displayed banner , prosecuted with fire & ●word , and all acts of horrid hostility , published in printed Proclamations , & written in Characters of blood by barbarous souldiers , so that none could enjoy Gospel Ordinances dispensed in Purity , but upon the hazard of their lives : And therefore , to prevent & frustrate these effects , they endeavoured to put themselves in a posture . And hereunto they were encouraged , by the constant experience of the Lords countenancing their endeavours in that posture , which alwayes proved successful for several years , their enemies either turning their backs without disturbance , when they observed them resolve defence , or in their assaultings repulsed : So that there was never a Meeting which stood to their defence , got any considerable harme thereby . Thus the Lord was with us while we were with Him , but when we forsook Him then He forsook us , and left us in the hands of our enemies . However , while Meetings for Gospel Ordinances did continue , the wicked Rulers did not cease from time to time to encrease their numerous ●ands of Barbarous Souldiers , for suppressing the Gospel in these field-Meetings . And for their Maintinance , they imposed new wicked & arbitrary Cesses & Taxations , professedly required for suppressing Religion & Liberty , banishing the Gospel out of the Land , and preserving & promoting his Absoluteness over all Matters & Persons Sacred & Civil : Which , under that tentation of great suffering threatened to Refusers , and under the disadvantage of the silence & unfaithfulness of many Ministers , who either did not condemn it or pleaded for the peaceable payment of it , many did comply with it then , and far more since . Yet at that time there were far more Recusants , in some places , ( especially in the Western Shires ) than Complyers : And there were many of the Ministers that did faithfully declare to the people the sin of it ; Not only from the illegality of its imposition , by a convention of overawed and prelimited States ; but from the nature of that imposed Complyance , that it was a sinful transaction with Christs declared Enemies , a strengthening the hands of the wicked , an Obedience to a wicked Law , a Consenting to Christs Expulsion out of the Land , and not only that , but ( far worse than the sin , of the Gadarens ) a formal Concurrence to assist His Expellers , by maintaining their force , a hiring our Oppressours to destroy Religion & Liberty ; And from the fountain of it , an Arbitrary power domineering over us , and oppressing & overpressing the Kingdoms with intollerable exactions That to pay it , it was to entail slaverie on the posterity ; And from the declared end of it , expressed in the very Narrative of the Act , viz : to levy & maintain forces for suppressing & dispersing Meetings of the Lords people , and to shew unanimous affection for maintaining the Kings Supremacy as now established by Law ; which designs he resolved , and would be capacitate by the Granters to effectuate by such a Grant , which in effect , to all tender Consciences , had an evident tendency to the exauctorating the Lord Christ , to maintain Souldiers to suppress His Work , & murder His Followers , yet all this time Ministers & Professors were unite , and with one soul & shoulder followed the Work of the Lord , till the Indulged ▪ being dissatisfied with the Meetings in the fields , whose Glory was like to overcloud & obscure their beds of ease , and especially being offended at the freedom & faithfulness of some , who set the Trumpet to their mouth , and shewed Iacob his sins & Israel his transgressions impartially without a clock or cover , they began to make a faction among the Ministers , and to devise how to quench the fervour of their zeal who were faithful for God. But the more they sought to extinguish it , the more it brake out and blazed into a flame . For Several of Christs Ambassadours , touched & affected with the affronts done to their Princely Master by the Supremacy and the Indulgence its Bastard brood & brat , began after long silence to discover its iniquity , and to acquaint the people how the Usurper had invaded the Mediators Chair , in taking upon him to depose ; suspend , silence , plant & transplant His Ministers , where & when & how he pleased , and to give forth warrants & Licences for admitting them , with Canons & Instructions for regulating them in the exercise of their Ministrie , and to arraign & censure them at his Courts for delinquencies in their Ministry ; pursuing all to the death who are faithful to Christ , and maintain their Loyaltie to His Lawes , and will not prostitute their Consciences to his lusts , and bow doun to the Idol of his Supremacy , but will oune the Kingly Authority of Christ. Yet others , and the greater number of dissenting Ministers , were not only deficient herein , but defended them , joyned with them , and ( pretending prudence & prevention of Schisme ) in effect homologated that deed and the practice of these Priests Ezek. 22. 26. teaching & advising the people to hear them , both by precept , and going along with them in that Erastian Course : And not only so , but condemned & censured such who preached against the sinfulness thereof , especially in the first place , Worthy Mr Walwood , who was among the first Witnesses against that defection , and Mr Kid , Mr King , Mr Cameron , Mr Donald Cargil &c. who sealed their Testimony afterwards with their blood ; yet then even by their Brethren were loaden with the reproachful Nicknames of Schismaticks , blind Zea●ots , I●suits &c. But it was alwayes observed , as long as Ministers were faithful in following the Lord in the way of their duty , Professors were fervent , And un-under all their Conflicts with Persecuters ▪ the courage & zeal of the lovers of Christ was blazing , and never out-braved by all the enemies boastings to undertake brisk Exploits : which from time to time they were now and then essaying , till defection destroyed , and division diverted their zeal against the Enemis of God , who before were alwayes the object against which they whetted the edge of their just Indignation . Especially the insulting insolency & insolent villanie of that publick Incendiarie , the Arch-Prelate Sharp , was judged intollerable by ingenuous Spirits ; because he had treacherously betrayed the Church & Nation , and being imployed as their delegate to oppose the threatened introduction of Prelacy , he had like a perjured Apostate and perfidious Traitor advanced himself into the place of Primate of Scotland , and being a member of Council he became a chief Instrument of all the Persecution , and main Instigator to all the bloody violence & cruelty that was exerced against the people of God ; by whose means , the letter sent doun to stop the shedding of more blood after Pentland was kept● up , until several of these Martyrs were Murdered . Therefore in Iulij 1668. Mr Iames Mitchel thought in his duty to save himself , deliver his Brethren , and free the Land of the violence of that beast of prey , and attempted to cut him off : which failing , he then escaped , but afterwards was apprehended ; and being moved by the Councils Oath , and Act of Assurance promising his life , he made Confession of the fact : Yet afterwards for the same he was arraigned before the Justiciary , and the Confession he made was brought in against him , and witnessed by the perjured Chancellour Rothes , and other Lords , contrare to their Oath & Act produced in open Court , to their indeleble infamy : whereupon he was tortured , condemned , & executed . But Justice would not suffer this Murder to pass long unrevenged , nor that Truculunt Traitor , Iamos Sharp the Arch-Prelat , who was the occasion & cause of it , and of many more both before & after , to escape remarkable punishment ; the severity whereof did sufficiently compense its delay , after ten years respite , wherein he ceased not more and more to pursue , persecute , & make havock of the Righteous for their duty , until at length he received the just demerit of his perfidie , perjury , apostasie , sorceries , villanies , and murders , Sharp arrowes of the Mighty & coals of Iuniper . For upon the 3. of May 1679. several worthy Gentlmen , with some other men of Courage & zeal for the cause of God and the good of the Country , executed righteous Judgement upon him in Magu● Moor near St Andrews . And that same moneth , on the Anniversary day May 29. the Testimony at Rutherglen was Published , against that abomination of celebrating an Anniversary day , kept every year for giving thanks for the setting up an usurped power , destroying the Interest of Christ in the Land — And angainst all sinful & unlawful Acts , emitted & executed , published & prosecuted against our Covenanted Reformation . Where also they burnt the Act of Supremacy , the Declaration , the Act Recissory &c. in way of retaliation for the burning of the Covenants . On the Sabbath following Iun. 1. A field Meeting for the Worship of God near to Loudoun-hil was assaulted by Graham of Claverhouse , and with him three troups of horse & Dragoons , who had that morning taken an honest Minister and about 14 Country-men out of their beds and carried them along with them as Prisoners to the Meeting in a Barbarous manner . But by the good hand of God upon the Defendents , they were repulsed at Drumclogg and put to flight , the Prisoners relieved , about 30. of the Souldiers killed on the place , and 3. of the Meeting , and several wounded on both sides . Thereafter the people retreating from the pursuit , consulted what was expedient in that juncture , whether to disperse themselves as formerly , or to keep together for their necessary defence . The result was , that considering the craft & cruelty of those they had to deal with , the sad consequents of falling into their hands now more incensed than ever , the evil effects that likely would ensue upon their separation , which would give them access to make havock of all ; they judged it most safe in that extremity for some time not to separate . Which Resolution , coming abroad to the ears of others of their Brethren ; determined them incontinently to come to their Assistence , considering their necessity , and their oun lyableness to the same common danger , upon the account of their endeavours of that nature elsewhere to defend themselves , being of the same judgement for maintaining of the same Cause , to which the were bound by the same Covenants , and groaning under the same burdens ; they judged therefore that if they now with held their assistence in such a strait , they could not be innocent of their Brethrens blood , nor found faithful in their Covenant : To which they were encouraged with the Countenance & success the Lord had given to that Meeting , in that defensive Resistence . This was the Rise & Occasion of that Appearance at Bothwel-bridge , which the Lord did in His Holy Soveraignty confound , for former Defections by the means of Division , which broke that litle Army among themselves , before they were broken by the Enemy . They continued together in amiable & amicable peace for the space of 8 or 9 dayes , while they endeavoured to put out & keep out every wicked thing from amongst them , and adhered to the Rutherglen-Testimony , and that short Declaration at Glasgow confirming it ; Representing their present purposes & endeavours , where only in vindication & defence of the Reformed Religion — as they stood obliged thereto by the National & Solemn League & Covenant , and the Solemn Acknowledgment of Sins & Engagment to duties ; Declaring against Popery , Prelacy , Erastianisme , and all things depending thereupon . Intending hereby to comprehend the defection of the Indulgence , to witness against which all unanimously aggreed : Until the Army encreasing , the Defenders & Daubers of that defection , some Ministers and others , came in who broke all , and upon whom the blood of that Appearance may be charged . The occasion of the breach was , first , When in the sense of the obligation of that Command , when the host goeth forth against thine enemies , keep thee from every wicked thing , an overture was offered to set times apart for humiliation for the publick sins of the Land , according to the practice of the Godly in all ages before engaging their enemies , and the laudable precedents of our Ancestors ; that so the Causes of Gods wrath against the Nation might be enquired into & confessed , and the Lords Blessing , Counsel , & Conduct to & upon present Endeavours , might be implored . And accordingly the Complying with abjured Erastianisme , by the acceptance of the ensnaring Indulgence , offered by & received from the Usurping Rulers , was condescended upon among the rest of the grounds of fasting & humiliation , so seasonably & necessarely called for at that time . The Sticklers for the Indulgence refused the overture , upon politick considerations , for fear of offending the Indulged Ministers & Gentlemen , and provoking them to withdraw their Assistence . This was the great Cause of the division , that produced such unhappy & destructive effects . And next , whereas the Cause was stated before according to the Covenants , in the Rutherglen-Testimony & Glasglow-Declaration , wherein the Kings Interest was waved ; These Dividers drew up another large paper ( called the Hamiltoun-Declaration ) wherein they assert the Kings Interest , according to the third Article of the Solemn League & Covenant . Against which the best affected contended , & protested they could not in Conscience put in his Interest in the State of the Quarrel , being now in stated opposition to Christs Interests , and inconsistent with the meaning of the Covenant , and the practices of the Covenanters , and their own Testimonies ; while now he could not be declared for as being in the defence of Religion & Liberty , when he had so palpably overturned & ruined the Work of Reformation , and oppressed such as adhered thereunto , and had burnt the Covenant &c. Whereby he had loosed the people from all obligation to him from it . Yet that contrary faction prevailed , so far as to get it published in the name of all : whereby the Cause was perverted & betrayed , and the former Testimonies rendered irrite , and the Interest of the publick Enemy epsoused . Finally , the same day that the Enemy approached in sight , And a considerable advantage was offered to do execution against them , these Loyal Gentlemen hindered & retarded all Action , till a Parly was beat , and an Address dispatched to the Duke of Monmouth , who then commanded his Fathers Army . By which nothing was gained , but free Liberty given to the Enemies to plant their Canon , and advance without interruption . After which , in the Holy All-over-ruling Providence of God , that poor handful was signally discountenanced of God , deprived of all Conduct , divested of all Protection , and laid open to the raging Sword , the just punishment of all such tamperings with the Enemies of God , and espousing their Interest , and omitting humiliation for their own and the Lands sins . About 300 were killed in the Fields , and 1000. and upwards were taken Prisoners , stripped , and carried to Edinburgh , where they were kept for a long time in the Gray Friers Church-yard , without shelter from cold or rain . And at length had the tentation of an insnaring bond of peace : Wherein they were to acknowledge that Insurrection to be Rebellion ▪ and oblige themselves never to rise in Armes against the King , nor any commissionate by him , and to live peaceably &c. Which , through fear of threatened death , and the unfaithfulness of some , and the impudence of other Ministers that perswaded them to take it , prevailed with many : Yet others resolutely resisted , judging it to imply a condemning of their duty , an abandoning of their Covenant-Engagments , wherein they were obliged to duties inconsistent with such bonds , and a voluntary binding up their hands from all oppositions to the declared War against Christ , which is the native sense of the peace they require , which can never be entertained long with men so treacherous . And therefore upon Principles of Reason & Conscience they refused that pretended Indemnity , offered in these termes . Nevertheless the most part took it : and yet were sentenced with banishment ; and sent away for America as well as they who refused it ; And by the way , ( a few excepted , ) perished in Shipwrack : whose blood yet cries both against the Imposers , and the Perswaders to that bond . III. This fearful & fatal stroke at Bothuel , not only was in its immediate effects so deadly , but in its consequents so destructive , that the decaying Church of Scotland , which before was begining to revive , was then cast into such a swoon that she is never like to recover to this day . And the Universality of her Children , which before espoused her Testimony , was after that partly drawn by Craft , and partly drawn by Cruelty , from a Conjunction with their Brethren in prosecuting the same , either into an open defection to the Contrary side , or into a detestable indifferency & neutrality in the Cause of God. For first of all the Duke of Monmouth , whose nature more averse from Cruelty than the rest of that Progeny made him pliable to all suggestions of wicked policy , that seemed to have a shew or smoothness & lenity , procured the emission of a pretended Indemnity , attended with the foresaid Band of p●ace for its Companion . Which were dreadful snares , catching many with flatteries , and fair pretences of favours , fairded over with curious words and cozening names of living peaceably &c. while in the mean time a most deadly & destructive thrust ( as it were under the fifth rib ) because most secret , was intended against all that was left remaining of the Work of God undestroyed , and a bar put upon all essayes to revive or recover it by their oun consent , who should endeavour it . This Course of Defection carried away many at that time : And from that time , since the taking of that bond of peaceable living , there hath been an universal preferring of peace to Truth , and of ease to duty . And the generality have been left to swallow all baits , tho the hook was never so discernible , all those ensnaring Oaths & Bonds imposed since , which both then & since People were left to their oun determination to chuse or refuse ; many Ministers refusing to give their Advice when required & requested thereunto , and some not being ashamed or afraid to perswad the People to take them . The Ministrie then also were generally insnared with that banded Indulgence , the pretended benefit of that Indemnity , which as it was designed so it produced the woful effect of propagating the defection , and promoting the division , and laying them by from their duty & Testimony of that day , which to this day they have not yet taken upon their former ground . For when a Proclamation was emitted , inveighing bitterly against field Meetings , and absolutely interdicting all such for the future under highest pain , but granting Liberty to Preach in houses upon the termes of a Cautionary bond given for their living peaceably : yet excluding all these Ministers who were suspected to have been at the late Rebellion ; and all these who shall afterward be admitted by Non-Conforme Ministers : And certifying , that if ever they shall be at any field Conventickle , the said Indemnity shall not be useful to such Transgressours any manner of way : And requiring security , that none under the colour of this favour continue to preach Rebellion . Though there seems to be enough in the Proclamation it self to have scarred them from this scandalous snare , yet a Meeting of Ministers at Edinburg made up of Indulged , avowed Applauders of the Indulgence , or underhand Approvers and favourers of the same , and some of them old Publick Resolutioners , assuming to themselves the name of a General Assembly , yea of the Representative of the Church of Scotland , voted for the Acceptance of it . And so formally transacted & bargained upon base , dishonest , & dishonourable termes with the Usurper , by consenting & compacting with the People to give that bond , Wherein the People upon an humble Petition to the Council , obtaining their Indulged-Minister do bind & oblige — that the said — shall live peaceably . And in order thereto to present him before his Maj. Privie Council , when they shall be called so to do ; And in case of failzie in not presenting him , to be Lyable to the summe of 6000 Merks . Whereby they condemned themselves of former unpeaceableness , and engaged to a sinful Peace with the enemies of God , and became bound and fettered under these bonds to a forbearance of a Testimony , and made answerable to their Courts , and the People were bound to present them for their duty . The sinfulness , scandalousness , & inconveniences of which transactions , are abundantly demonstrated by a Treatise thereupon , intituled , The Banders disbanded . Nevertheless many embraced this new bastard Indulgence , that had not the benefit of the former brat , of the same Mother the Supremacy , and far more consented to it without a witness , and most of all did some way homologate it , in preaching under the sconce of it : Declining the many reiterated & urgent Calls of the ●ealous Lovers of Christ , to come out and maintain the Testimony of the Gospel in the open fields , for the honour of their Master and the freedom of their Ministrie . Whereupon , as many poor People were stumbled and jumbled into many confusions , so that they were so bewildered & bemisted in doubts & debates , that they knew not what to do , and were tempted to question the Cause formerly so servently contended for against all opposition , then so simply abandoned , by these that seemed sometimes valiant for it , when they saw them consulting more their oun ease than the Concerns of their Masters Glory , or the necessity of the poor people hungering for the Gospel , and standing in need of Counsel in time of such abounding snares , whereby many became a prey to all tentations : So the more zealous & faithful , after several Addresses , Calls , & Invitations to Ministers , finding themselves deserted by them , judged themselves under a necessity to discountenance many of them , whom formerly they followed with pleasure ; and to resolve upon a pursuit & prosecution of the duty of the day without them , and to provide themselves with faithful Ministers , who would not shun for all hazards to declare the whole Counsel of God. And accordingly through the tender Mercy of God , compassionating the exigence of the People , the Lord sent them first Mr Richard Cameron , with whom after his serious solicitation his Brethren denied their concurrence , and then Mr Donald Cargil ; who , with a zeal & boldness becoming Christs Ambassadours , maintained & prosecuted the Testimony , against all the Indignities done to their Master and wrongs to the Cause , both by the encroachments of Adversaries and defections of their declining Brethren . Wherein they were signally countenanced of their Master ; And the Lords Inheritance was again revived with the showres of the Gospels blessings , wherewith they had been before refreshed ; and enlightened with a Glance & Glimpse of resplendent brightness , immediatly before the obscurity of this fearful night of darkness that hath succeeded . But as Christ was then displaying His beauty , to His poor despised & persecuted People ; so Antichrist began to blaze his bravery , in the solemn & shameful reception of his harbinger , that Pimp of the Romish whore , the Duke of York . Who had now pulled off the Mask , under which he had long covered his Antichristian Bigotrie , through a trick of his brother , constrained by the Papists importunity , and the necessity of their favour , & recruit of their Coyn , either to declare himself Papist , or to make his brother do it : whereby all the locusts were engaged to his Interest , with whom he entered into a Conspiracy and Popish Plot , as was discovered by many infallible evidences , and confessed by Coleman his Secretary , to Sir Edmund-Bury Godfrey ; for which , lest he should witness against him , when Coleman was apprehended , that Gentleman was cruelly murdered by the Duke of Yorks contrivance & command . Yet for all the demonstrations of his being a Bigot Papist , that he had long given unto the world , it is known what some suffered for saying , that the Duke of York was a Papist and being forced to leave England he was come to Scotland to promots Poperie & Arbitrary Government . However , thô the Parliament of England , for his Poperie & Villanie , and his ploting & pursuing the destruction of the Nation , did vote his Exclusion ; yet degenerate Scotland did receive him in great pompe & pride . Against which , the forementioned faithful witnesses of Christ did find themselves obliged to testify their just resentment , and to protest against his succeeding to the Croun , in their Declaration published at Sanquhair , Iune 22. 1680. Wherein also they Disoune Charles Stewart , as having any Right , Title , or Interest in the Croun of Scotland or Government thereof , as being fore●aulted several years since , by his perjurie & breach of Covenant , Usurpation on Christs Prerogatives , and by his Tyranny & breaches in the very Leges regnandi in matters Civil — And declare a war with him , and all the men of these practices — homologating the Testimony at Rutherglen , and disclaiming that declaration at Hamiltoun . This Action was generally condemned by the body of lurking Ministers , both for the matter of it , and the unseasonableness of it , and its apparent unfeasibleness , being done by a handful so inconsiderable , for number , strength , or significancy . But as they had very great & important reasons to disclaim that Tyrants Authority , hinted in the Declaration it self , and hereafter more fully vindicated : so the necessity of a Testimony against all the Tyrannical Encroachments on Religion & Liberty , then current & encreasing ; and the sin & shame of shifting & delaying it so long , when the Blasphemous Supremacy was now advanced to its summity ; the Churches Priviledges all overturned ; Religion and the Work of Reformation trampled under foot ; the Peoples Rights & Liberties destroyed , and Lawes all subverted ; and no shadow of Government left but arbitrary Absoluteness , obtruding the Tyrants will for Reason , and his Letter for the Supreme Law ( witness the Answer which one of the Council gave to another , objecting against their Proceedings as not according to Law , what devil do ye talk of Law ? have not we the Kings Letter for it ? ) And all the ends of Magistracy wholly inverted ; while innocent & honest People were grievously oppressed in their persons , Consciences , & Estates ; And Perjuries , Adulteries , Idolatries , and all impieties were not only connived at , but countenanced as badges of Loyaltie , and manifest & monstrous Robbries & Murders Authorized , Judgement turned into gall , and the fruit of Righteousness into hemlock ; do justify its Seasonableness : And the ends of the Declaration , to keep up the Standart of the Gospel , and maintain the Work of Reformation , and preserve a Remnant of faithful Adherers to it ; the nature of the Resolution declared , being only to endeavour to make good & maintain their Revolt , in opposition to all who would pursue them for it , and reinforce them to a subjection to that yoke of slaverie again ; and the extremity of danger & distress that party was in , while declared & pursued as Rebells , and intercommuned & interdicted of all supplie & solace , being put out of their oun , and by Law precluded of the harbour of all other habitations , and so both for safety & subsistence compelled by necessity to concur & keep together , may alleviate the Censure and stop the Clamour of its unfeasibleness . But thô it is not the prudence of the managment , but the justness of the Action , that I would have vindicated from obliquies ; yet it wanted nothing but success to justify both , in the conviction of many that made much outcry against it . In these dangerous in his maintainance of the true Covenanted Religion — which homage they cannot now require upon the account of the Covenant , which they have renounced & disclaimed ; and upon no other ground we are bound to them — the Croun not being an inheritance , that passeth from Father to son without the Consent of Tenants — ( 3 ) Of the hope of their returning from these Courses : Whereof there is none , seeing they have so often declared their purposes of persevering ill thein , And suppose they should dissemble a repentance — supposing also they might be pardoned , for that which is done — from whose guiltiness the Land cannot be cleansed , but by executing Gods righteous Judgements upon them — yet they cannot now be believed , after they have violated all that humane wisdom could devise to bind them . Upon these accounts they reject that King , and those associate with him in the Government — and declare them henceforth no lawful Rulers , as they had declared them to be no lawful Subjects — they having destroyed the established Religion , overturned the fundamental Lawes of the Kingdom , taken away Christs Church-Government , and changed the Civil into Tyrannie , where none are associate in partaking of the Government , but only these who will be found by Justice guilty of Criminals — And declare they shall , God giving power , set up Government & Governours according to the Word of God , and the qualifications required Exod. 18. vers . 20. — And shall not commit the Government — to any single person , or lineal succession , being not tyed as the Jewes were to one single family — and that kind being lyable to most inconveniences , & aptest to degenerate into Tyrannie — And moreover , that these men set over them shall be engaged to Govern Principally , by that Civil & Judicial Law ( not that which is any way Typical ) given by God to His people of Israel — as the best so far as it goes , being given by God — especially in matters of life & death — and other things , so far as they reach , and are consistent with Christian Liberty — exempting Divorces & Polygamie — 6. Seeing the greatest part of Ministers , not only were defective in Preaching against the Acts of the Rulers for overthrowing Religion — but hindered others also who were willing , and censured some that did it — and have voted for acceptation of that Liberty , founded upon & given by virtue of that blaspemously arrogate & Usurped power — and appeared before their Courts to accept of it , and to be enacted & authorized their Ministers — whereby they have become the Ministers of men , and bound to be answerable to them as they will — And have preached for the lawfulness of paying that Tribute , declared to be imposed for the bearing doun of the true Worship of God — And advised poor Prisoners to subscribe that Bond — which if it were universally subscribed — they should close that door , which the Lord hath made use of in all the Churches of Europe , for casting off the yoke of the whore — and stop all regress of men , when once brought under Tyrannie , to recover their Libertie again . — They declare they neither can nor will hear them &c. nor any who encouraged & strengthened their hands , and pleaded for them , and trafficqued for union with them . 7. That they are for a standing Gospel Ministrie , rightly chosen & rightly ordained — & that none shall take upon them the Preaching of the Word &c. unless called & ordained thereunto — And whereas Separation might be imputed to them , they refell both the malice , and the ignorance of that Calumnie — for if there be a Separation , it must be where the change is ; and that was not to be found in them , who were not separating from the Communion of the true Church , nor setting up a New Ministrie , but cleaving to the same Ministers & Ordinances , that formerly they followed , when others have fled to new wayes , and a new Authority , which is like the old piece in the new Garment . 8. That they shall defend themselves in their Civil , Natural , & Divine Rights & Liberties — And if any assault them , they shall look on it as a declaring a war , and take all advantages that one enemie does of another — but trouble and injure none but those that injure them — This is the Compend of that Paper which the Enemies seised and published , while it was only in a rude draught , and not polished , digested , nor consulted by the rest of the Community : yet , whether or not it was for their advantage so to blaze their oun baseness in that Paper truly represented , I leave it to the Reader to judge : or , if they did not thereby Proclaim their oun Tyrannie , and the Innocency & honesty of that people , whom thereby they were seeking to make odious ; but in effect inviting all Lovers of Religion & Liberty to Sympathise with them , in their difficulties & distresses there discovered . However that poor Partie continued together in a posture of defence , without the Concurrence or Countenance of their Covenanted Brethren , who staid at home , and left both them to be murdered and their Testimony to be trampled upon , untill the 22. of Iulij 1680. Upon the which day they were attacqued at Airsmoss , by a strong party of about 120 horse well armed , while they were but 23 horse and 40 foot at most ; and so fighting valiantly were at length routed , not without their Adversaries Testimony of their being resolute men : Several of Zions precious Mourners , and faithful Witnesses of Christ , were killed ; and among the rest , that faithful Minister of Christ , Mr Richard Cameron sealed & fulfilled his Testimony with his blood . And with others , the valiant and much honoured Gentleman , David Hackstoun of Rathillet , was after many received wounds apprehended , brought in to Edinburgh ; and there , resolutely adhering to the Testimony , and disouning the Authority of King & Council , and all their Tyrannical Judicatories , was cruelly murdered , but countenanced eminently of the Lord. Now remained Mr Donald Cargil , deprived of his faithful Collegue , destitute of his Brethrens concurrence , but not of the Lords Counsel & Conduct ; by which he was prompted & helped to prosecute the Testimony , against the Universal Apostasie of the Church & Nation , Tyranny of Enemies , Backsliding of Friends , and all the wrongs done to his Master on all hands . And considering , in the zeal of God , and sense of His holy Jealousie provoked and threatening wrath against the Land ; for the sins especially of Rulers ; who had arrived to the hight of Heaven-daring Insolence in all wickedness , in which they were still growing & going on without control ; That notwithstanding of all the Testimonies given against them , by publick Preachings , Protestations , and Declarations , remonstrating their Tyranny and disouning their Authority ; yet not only did they still persist in their sins & scandals , to make the Lords fierce Anger break forth into a flame , but were ouned also by Professors , not only as Magistrats , but as members of the Christian & Protestant Church ; And that , however both the defensive armes of men had been used against them , and the Christian armes of Prayers , and the Ministerial weapon of Preaching , yet that of Ecclesiastical Censure had not been Authoritatively exerted against them : Therefore , that no Weapon which Christ allowes His Servants under His Standart to manage against His Enemies might be wanting , thô he could not obtain the Concurrence of his Brethren to strengthen the solemnity & formality of the Action ; yet he did not judge that defect , in this broken Case of the Church , could disable his Authority nor de●ur the duty , but that he might and ought to proceed to Excommunication . And accordingly , in September — 1680. at the Torwood , he excommunicated some of the most scandalous and Principal Promoters & Abettors of this Conspiracy against Christ , as formally as the present Case could admit : After Sermon upon Ezek. 21. 25 , 26 , 27. And thou profane wicked Prince of Israel , whose day is come &c. He had a short and pertinent discourse on the nature , the subject , the causes , and the ends of Excommunication in general : And then declared , that he was not led out of any private Spirit or passion to this Action , but constrained by Conscience of duty and zeal to God to stigmatize with this brand , and wound with the Sword of the Lord , these Enemies of God that had so Apostatized , rebelled against , mocked , despised & defied Our Lord , and to declare them as they are none of His , to be none of ours . The persons excommunicated , and the Sentence against them , was given forth as followes — I being a Minister of Iesus Christ , and having Authority and Power from Him , do , in His Name & by His Spirit , excommunicat● , cast out of the true Church , and deliver up to Satan , Charles the Second , King &c. The Sentence was founded upon these grounds , declared in the pronunciation thereof ( 1 ) for his high mocking of God , in that after he had acknowledged his own sins , his fathers sins , his mothers Idolatrie — yet had gone on more avowedly in the same than all before him . ( 2 ) for his great Perjurie , in breaking & burning the Covenant . ( 3 ) for his rescinding all Lawes for establishing the Reformation , and enacting Lawes contrarie thereunto . ( 4 ) for commanding of Armies to destroy the Lords people . ( 5 ) for his being an Enemy to true Protestants , & helper of the Papists , and hindering the execution of just Lawes against them . ( 6 ) for his granting Remissions & Pardons for Murderers , which is in the power of no King to do , being expressly contrare to the Law of God. ( 7 ) for his Adulteries , and dissembling with God & man — Next by the same Authority , and in the same name , he excommunicated Iames Duke of York , for his Idolatrie , and setting it up in Scotland to defile the Land , and entycing & encouraging others to do so : Not mentioning any other sins , but what he scandalously persisted in in Scotland &c. With several other rotten Malignant Enemies , on whom the Lord hath rati●●ed that Sentence since very remarkably , whose sins & punishments both may be read more visiblie in the Providences of the time , than I can record them . But about this time , when amidst all the abounding defections & divisions of that dark & dismal hour of tentation , some in zeal for the Cause were endeavouring to keep up the Testimony of the day , in an abstraction from Complying Ministers ; Others were left ( in holy judgment , to be a stumbling block to the Generation hardening them in their defections , and to be a beacon to the most zealous to keep off from all unwarrantable excesses ) to fall into fear●ul extravagances and delirious & damnable delusions , being overdriven with ignorant & blind zeal into untroden paths , which led them into a labyrinth of darkness ; when as they were stumbled at many Ministers their unfaithfulness , so through the deceit of Sathan and the hypocrisie of his Instruments , they came to be offended at Mr Cargil his faithfulness , who spared neither left hand declensions nor right hand extremes , and left him and all the Ministers ; not only disouning all Communion with those that were not of their way , but execrating & Cursing them ; and kept themselves in desert places from all Company ; where they persisted prodigiously in fastings , and singing Psalms , pretending to wonderful raptures & Enthusiasmes : and in fine , I. Gib with 4 more of them came to that hight of Blasphemy , that they burnt the Bible & Confession of Faith. These were the sweet singers , as they were called , led away into these delusions by that Impostor & Sorcerer Iohn Gib ; who never encreased to such a number , as was then feared & reported , being within thirty & most part women : all which for the most part have been through Mercy reclaimed from that destructive way , which through Grace the Reproached Remnant , adhering to the foresaid Testimony , had alwayes an abhorrence of . Wherefore that ignorant & impudent Calumnie , of their Consortship with Gibs followers , is only the vent of viperous Envy . For they were the first that discovered them , and whose pains the Lord blessed in reclaiming them , and were alwayes so far from partaking with them , that to this day these that have come off from that way , and have offered the Confession of their scandal , do still complain of their over-rigid severity , in not admitting them to their select fellowships . To which may be added this undenyable Demonstration , that whereas the persecu●ing Courts of Inquisition did alwayes extend the utmost severity against the Ouners of this Testimony , yet they spared them : And the Duke of York , then in Scotland was so we● pleased with Gib's Blasphemies , that he favoured him extraordinarly , and freely dismissed him . This was a cloudy & dark day , but not without a burning & shining light as long as that faithful Minister of Christ , Mr Donald Cargil , was following the Work of the Lord ; who shortly after this finished his Testimony , being apprehended with other two faithful & zealous Witnesses of Christ , Mr Walter Smith , and Mr Iames Boog , who with 2 more were altogether , at Edinburgh 27. Iulij 1681. Crouned with the Glory of Martyrdom . Then came the day of the Remnants vexation , trouble , darkness & dimness of anguish , wherein who so looked unto the Land could see nothing but darkness & sorrow , & the light darkened in the Heavens thereof , wherein neither Star nor Sun appeared for many dayes , and poor People were made to grope for the wall like the blind , and to stumble in noon day as in the night . While the Persecution advanced on the one hand , a violent spait of defection carried doun the most part of Ministers & Professors before it , driving them to Courses of sinful & scandalous Conformings with the times Corruptions , Compearings before their Courts , Complyings with their Commands , paying of theis Cesses and other Exactions , Taking of their Oaths & Bonds , and countenancing their Prelatical Church-Services , which they were ashamed to do before . And thereupon on the other hand the Divisions and Confusions were augmented , and poor people that desired to cleave to the Testimony were more & more offended and stumbled at the Ministers , who either left the Land in that clamant Call of the peoples necessity , or lurked in their own retirements , and declined the duty of that day , leaving people to determine themselves in all their perplexities , as a prey to all tentations . But the tender Pastor and Shepherd of Israel , who leads the blind in the way they know not , did not forsake a Remnant in that hour of tentation who kept the Word of His Patience ; and as He helped those that fell into the hands of Enemies to Witness a good Confession , so He strengthened the zeal of the remaining Contenders , against all the Machinations of Adversaries to crush it , and all the Methods of Backsliding Professors to quench it . And the mean which most effectually preserved it in life & vigour , was the expedient they fell upon of Corresponding in General Meetings , to consult , informe , & confirme one another about common duties in common dangers , for preservation of the Remnant from the destruction & contagion of the times , and propagation of the Testimony : Laying doun this General Conclusion for a foundation of Order , to be observed among them in incident doubtful cases , & emergent Controversies , that nothing relative to the publick , and which concerns the who●e of their Community , be done by any of them , without harmonious consent sought after & rationally waited for , and sufficient deliberation about the best means & manner . In the mean time , the Duke of York , as Commissioner from his brother , held a Parliament wherein he presided , not only against all righteous Lawes that make a bloody & avowed Papist incapable or such a Trust , but against the Letter of their oun wicked Lawes , whereby none ought to be admitted but such as swear the Oaths ; yet not only was he constitute in this place , but in the whole Administration of the Government of Scotland without the taking any Oath , which then he was Courting to be entailed Successor and heir of the Croun thereof ; And for this ●n● made many pretences of flatteries , and feigned expressions of love , & of doing many acts o● kindness to that ancient Kingdom , as he hath made many dissembling protestations of it since , for carrying on his oun Popish & Tyrannical designs : But what good-will he hath born to it , not only his acts & actings written in Characters of the blood of Innocents declare , but his words do witness , which is known when and to whom he spake , when he said , It would never ●e wel til all on the southside of Forth were made a hunting field . However in that Parliament , anno 1681. he is chiefly intended , and upon the matter by a wicked Act declared legal & lineal Successor , and a detestable Blasphemous and Self-contradictory Test is framed for a Pest to Consciences , which turned out of all places of Trust any that had any remaining measure of common honesty ; And when some was speaking of a bill for securing Religion in case of a Popish Prince , the Dukes answer was notable , that whatsoever they intended or prepared against Papists should light upon others : whereby we may understand what measures we may expect , when his designs are ripe . And to all the Cruel Acts then & before made against the People of God , there was one superadded regulating the execution of all the rest , whereby at one dash all Civil & Criminal Justice was overthroun , and a foundation laid for Popish-Tyranny , that the Right of Iurisdiction both in Civil & Criminal Matters is so inherent in the Croun , that his Maj. may judge all Causes by himself , on any other he thinks fit to commissionate . Here was Law for Commissionating Souldiers to take away the lives of Innocents , as was frequently exemplified afterwards , and may serve hereafter for erecting the Spanish Inquisition to murder Protestants when he thinks fit to commissonate them . Against which wicked Encroachments on Religion & Liberty , the Faithful thought themselves obliged to emit a Testimony : And therefore published a Declaration at Lanerk , Iannary 12. 1682. Confirming the preceeding at Sanquhair , and adding reasons of their Revolt from the Government of Charles the Second . 1. For cutting off the neck at one blow of the noble Constitution of Church & State , and involving all Officers in the Kingdom in the same perjurie with himself . 2. For exalting himself into a sphere exceeding all measures Divine & humane , Tyrannically obtruding his will for a Law in his arbitrary Letters , so that we are made the reproach of Nations , who say , we have only the Law of Letters instead of the Letter of the Law. 3. For his constant adjourning & dissolving Parliaments at his pleasure . 4. For his arrogantly arrogated Supremacy in all Causes Civil & Ecclesiastick , and oppressing the Godly for Conscience & duty . 5. For his exorbitan● Taxings , Cessings , & grinding the faces of the poor , dilapidating the rights & revenues of the Croun , for no other end but to imploy them for keeping up a Borthel ▪ rather than a Court. 6. For installing a successor , such an one ( if not worse ) as himself , contrare to all Law , Reason , & Religion , and framing the Test &c. And in end offer to prove , they have done nothing in this against our Ancient Lawes , Civil or Ecclesiastick — but only endeavoured to extricate themselves from under a Tyrannous yoke , and to reduce Church & State to what they were in the year 1648 and 1649. After which Declaration , they were more condemned by them that were at ease than ever , and very untenderly dealt with ; being without any previous admonition reproached , accused , and informed against , both at home & abroad , as if they had turned to some wild & unhappy Course . For which Cause , in the next General Meeting , they resolved to delegate some of their number to forreign Churches , on purpose to vindicate themselves from these Calumnies , and to represent the justness of their Cause , and the sadness of their Case , and provoke them to some Sympathie abroad , which was denied at home : And withall to provide for a Succession of Witnesses , who might maintain the Testimony , which was then in appearance interrupted , except by Martyrdom & Sufferings . Therefore by that means having obtained access for the instruction of some young men , at an University in the United Provinces , in process of time , Mr Iames Renwick received Ordination there , and came home to take up the Standart of his Master , upon the ground where it last was left , and to carry on the Testimony against all the oppositions of that day , from open Enemies & backsliding Professors : an undertaking more desperate-like than that of Unus Athanasius contra totam orbem , and like that of a Child threshing doun a Mountain . Which yet against all the outragious rage of ravening Enemies , ranging , ravaging , hunting , chasing , pursuing after him , through all the touns , villages , cottages , woods , moors , mosses , & mountains of the Country ; and against all the scourge of tongues , contradictions , condemnations , obliquies , reproaches , & cruel mockings of incensed Professors , and generally of all the Inhabitants of the Land ; he was helped to prosecute , by many weary wanderings , travells , and traversings through the deserts , night & day , Preaching , Confering , & Catechising , mostly in the cold winter nighrs in the open fields : until , by the Blessing of God upon his labours , not only was the faithfull Witnessing Remnant that joyned in the Testimony , further cleared confirmed , and encouraged , and their number much encreased by the coming in and joyning of many others to the fellowship of their settled Societies ; but also many others , in but as soon as it grew dark , all hope lost , they dispersed , every man shifting for himself ; only a few keeping together all the nixt day , had a skirmage with a Party of the Enemies , in which they slew the Captain , and about 12 or some moe of his men , and afterwards they dispersed themselves also . The Enemies , searching the Country , gleaned up the E. of Argyle himself , Col. Rumbol an Englishman , Mr Thomas Archer Minister , Gawin Russel , an David Law , who were all condemned & execute at Edinburgh , and many others who were banished to America : and about some 20 in the Highlands , who were hanged at Inerarie . In England , the D. of Monmouths expedition , though it had more action , yet terminated in the same success , the loss of many hundred lives , many killed in Battel : And afterwas , by the mercy of the Duke of York ▪ several hunderds in the West of England were carried about and hanged before the door of their oun habitations ; and to make his Captains sport by the way , according to the number of the hours of the day , when the murdering humour came in their head , so many of the poor Captives were hanged , as a prodigious monument of monstrous Crueltie . This was the Comencement of the present Tyrants Government . In the mean time , the Wanderers in Scotland , thô they did not associate with this Expedition upon the account of the too promiscuous admittence of persons to trust in that Partie , who were then and since have discovered themselves to be Enemies to the Cause , and because they could not espouse their Declaration as the State of their Quarrel , being not concerted according to the constant Plea of the Scots Covenanters , and for other reasons given in their late Vindication : yet against this Usurpation of a bloody Papist , advancing himself to the Throne in such a manner , they published another Declaration at Sanquhair , May 28. 1685. Wherein , Approving & adhering unto all their former Declarations , And considering that Iames Duke of York , a Profest & Excommunicate Papist , was proclaimed — To testify their resentment of that deed , And to make it appear unto the world , that they were free thereof , by concurrence or connivance ; They Protest against the foresaid Proclamation of Iames Duke of York as King : In regard that it is the choosing of a Murtherer to be a Governour , who hath shed the blood of the Saints — that it is the hight of Confederacy with an Idolater , for bidden by the Law of God — contrarie to the Declaration of the Gen. Ass. of the Church , Iulij 27. 1649. And contrary to many wholesome & laudable Acts of Parliament — and inconsistent with the safety , faith , Conscience , & Christian Libertie of a Christian People , to chuse a subject of Antichrist to be their Supreme Magistrate — and to entrust an Enemy to the Work & People of God with the Interests of both : And upon many important grounds & reasons ( which there they express ) they Protest against the validity & Constitution of that Parliament , approving & ratifying the foresaid Proclamation — And against all kind of Poperie in General & Particular heads — as abjured by the National Covenant , and abrogated by Acts of Parliament — and against its entrie again into this Land , And every thing that doth or may directly or indirectly make way for the same : Disclaiming likewise all Sectarianisme , Malignancy , and any Confederacy therewith . — This was their Testimony against Poperie in the season thereof : which thô it was not so much condemned as any former Declarations , yet neither in this had they the Concurrence of any Ministers or Professors ; who as they had been silent , and omitted a seasonable Testimony against Prelacy , and the Supremacy , when these were introduced , so now also , even when this wicked Mysterie & Conspiracie of Poperie & Tyrannie , twisted together in the present designe of Antichrist , had made so great a progress , and was evidently brought above board , they were left to let ●lip this opportunity of a Testimony also , to the reproach of the declining & far degenerate Church of Scotland . Yea to their shame , the very rabble of ignorant People may be brought as a witness against the body of Presbyterian Ministers in Scotland , in that they testified their detestation of the first Erection of the Idolatrous Mass , and some of the souldierie , and such as had no Profession of Religion , suffered unto death for speaking against Poperie and the designs of the King , while the Ministers were silent . And some of the Curats , and members of the late Parliament 1686. made some stickling against the taking away of the penal Statutes against Papists ; while Presbyterians , from whom might have been expected greater opposition , were sleeping in a profound submission . I cannot without Confusion of Spirit touch these obvious & dolorous reflections , and yet in candor cannot forbear them . However the Persecution against the Wanderers went on , and more cruel Edicts were given forth against them , while a relenting abatement of severity was pretended against other Dissenters . At length what could not be obtained by Law at the late Parliament for taking off the Statutes against Papists , was effectuated by Prerogative : and to make it pass with the greater approbation , it was convoyed in a channel of pretended Clemency , offering a sort of Liberty , but really introducing a licencious Latitude , for bringing in all future snares by taking off some former , as arbitrarly as before they were imposed , in a Proclamation dated Feb. 12. 1687. Granting , by the Kings Soveraign Authority , Prerogative Royal , and absolute power , which all Subjects are to obey without reserve , a Royal Toleration , to the several Professors of the Christian Religion afternamed , with & under the several Conditions , restrictions , & limitations aftermentioned . In the first place , tolerating the Moderate Presbyterians to meet in their private houses , and there to hear all such Ministers , as either have or are willing to accept of the Indulgence allanerly , and none other : And that there be nothing said or done contrare to the wel & peace of his reign , seditious or treasonable , under the highest pains these Crimes will import , nor are they to presume to build Meeting houses , or to use out-houses or barns — In the mean time it s his Royal will & pleasure , that Field Conventicles , and such as Preach at them , or who shall any way assist or connive at them , shall be prosecute according to the utmost severity of Lawes made against them — In like manner tolerating the Quakers to meet & exercise in their forme , in any place or places appointed for their Worship — And by the same absolute power , foresaid , suspending , stoping , & disabling all Lawes or Acts of Parliament , Customs , or Constitutions against any Roman Catholick subjects — So that they shall in all things be as free in all respects as any Protestant subjects whatsoever , not only to exercise their Religion , but to enjoy all Offices , benefices , &c. which he shall think fit to bestow upon them in all time coming — And cassing , annulling , & discharging all Oaths whatsoever , and Tests , and Lawes enjoyning them . And in place of them this Oath only is to be taken — I A. B. do ackowledge , testifie , & declare that Iames the Seventh &c. is rightful King & Supreme Governour of these Realms , and over all persons therein ; And that it is unlawful for Subjects , on any Pretence or for any Cause whatsoever , to rise in Armes against him , or any Commissionated by him ; and that I shall never so rise in Armes , nor assist any who shall so do ; And that I shall never resist his power or Authority , nor ever oppose this Authority to his person — but shall to the utmost of my power assist , defend , & maintain him , his heirs & lawful successors , in the exercise of their Absolute power & Authority against all deadly — And by the same absolute power giving his ful & ample Indemnitie , to all the foresaid sorts of People , under the foresaid restrictions . Here is a Proclamation for a Prince : That Proclaims him in whose name it is emitted , to be the greatest Tyrant that ever lived in the world , and their Revolt who have disouned him to be the justest that ever was . For herein that Monster of Prerogative is not only advanced , paramount to all Lawes Divine & humane , but far surmounting all the lust , impudence , & insolence of all the Roman , Sicilian , Turkish , Tartarian , or Indian Tyrants that ever trampled upon the Liberties of Mankind ; who have indeed demanded absolute subjectio● , & surrender of their Lives , Lands , & Liberties at their pleasure , but never arrived at such a hight of arrogance as this does , to claim absolute obedience , without reserve of Conscience , Religion , Honour , or Reason ; Not only that which ignorantly is called Passive , never to resist him , not only on any Pretence , but for any Cause , even thô he should command his Popish Ianizaries to murder & massacre all Protestants , which is the tender mercy & burning fervent charity of Papists ; but also of absolute Active obedience without reserve , to assist , defend , & maintain him in every thing , whereby he shall be pleased to exercise his absolute power , thô he should command to burn the Bible as well as the Covenant ( as already he applauded Iohn Gib in doing of it ) and to burn and butcher all that will not go to Mass , which we have all grounds to expect will be the end of his Clemency at last . Herein he claims a power to command what he will , and obliging subjects to obey whatsoever he will command : A power to rescind , stop , & disable all Lawes ; which unhinges all stabilitie and unsettles all the security of humane societie , yea extinguishes all that remains of natural Liberty : Wherein , as is wel observed by the Author of the Representation of the threatening dangers impending over Protestants Pag. 53. It is very natural to observe , that he allowes the Government , under which we were born , and to which we were sworn , to be hereby subverted & changed , and that thereupon we are not only absolved & acquited from all Allegiance to him , but indispensably obliged , by the ties & engagments that are upon us , to apply our selves to the use of all means & endeavours against him , as an Enemy of the People & subverter of the legal Government . But this was so gross , and grievously gripping in its restrictions , as to persons , as to the place , as to the matter allowed the Presbyterians in Preaching , that it was disdained of all ; and therefore he behoved to busk it better , and mend the matter , in a Letter to the Council ( the Supreme Law of Scotland ) bearing date March 31. 1687. of this tenor — Whereas we did recommend to yow to take care , that any of the Presbyterians should not be allowed to Preach , but such only as should have your Allowance for the same , and that they at the receiving the Indulgence should take the Oath contained in the Proclamation — These are therefore to let you know , that thereby we meant such of them as did not solemnly take the Test ; but if nevertheless the Presbyterian Preachers do scruple to take the said Oath , or any other Oath whatsoever , and that you shall find it reasonable or fit to grant them or any of them our said Indulgence , so as they desire it upon these termes ; It is now our will & pleasure — to grant them our said Indulgence , without being obliged to take the Oath , with power unto them to enjoy the benefite of the said Indulgence ( during our pleasure only ) or so long as yow shall find they behave themselves regularly & peaceably , without giving any cause of offence to us , or any in Authority or trust under us in our Government . — Thus finding the former Proposal not adequately apportioned to his design , because of its palpable odiousness , he would pretend his meaning was mistaken ( thô it was manifest enough ) and mitigate the matter by taking away of the Oaths altogether , if any should scruple it ; whereas he could not but know , that all that had sense would abhor it : yet it is clogged with the same restrictions , limited to the same persons , characterized more plainly and peremptorly , with an addition of Cautions , not only that they shall not say or do any thing contrare to the wel & peace of his reign seditious or treasonable ; but also that they behave themselves regularly & peaceably without giving any cause of offence to him or any under him ; which comprehends lesser offences than sedition or treason , even every thing that will displease a Tyrant and a Papist , that is , all faithfulness in seasonable Duties or Testimonies . But at length lest the difformity & disparity of the Proclamation for the Toleration in Scotland , and the Declaration for Liberty of Conscience in England , should make his Pretences to Conscience suspect of disingenuity , and lest it should be said he had one Conscience for England and another for Scotland ; therefore he added a third eke to the liberty , but such as made it still an ill favoured patched project to destroy Religion & true Liberty , in another Proclamation dated at Windsor , Iune 28. 1687. wherein he sayes — Taking into our Royal Consideration , the sinistrous Interpretations , which either have or may be made of some Restrictions ( mentioned in the last ) we have thought fit by this further to declare , that we will Protect our Arch-bishops &c. And we do likewise , by our Soveraign Authority , Prerogative Royal , and Absolute power , suspend , stop , & disable , all penal & Sanguinary Lawes ; made against any for Non-conformity to the Religion established by Law in that our Ancient Kingdom — to the end , that by the Liberty thereby granted the peace & security of our Government in the practice thereof may not be endangered , we hereby straitly charge all our Loving subjects , that as we do give them leave to meet & serve God after their oun way , in private Houses , Chappels , or Places purposely hired or built for that use , so that they take care that nothing be Preached or taught , which may any way tend to alienate the hearts of our People from us & our Government , and that their Meetings be peaceably & publickly held , and all persons freely admitted to them , and that they do signify & make known to some one or more of the next Privie Councellors , Sheriffs , Stewards , Bailiffs , Justices of the Peace , or Magistrats of Burgh Royal , what place or places they set a part for these uses , with the names of the Preachers — provided alwayes that the Meetings be in houses , and not in the open fields ; for which now after this our Royal grace & favour ( which surpasses the hopes , & equalls the very wishes of the most zealously concerned ) there is not the least shadow of execuse left : Which Meetings in the fields we do hereby strictly prohibite & forbid , against all which we do leave our Lawes & Acts of Parliament in full force & vigour , notwithstanding the premises ; and do further command all our Judges , Magistrats , & Officers of forces , to prosecute such as shall be guilty of the said field Conventicles with the utmost rigour ; for we are confident , none will after these Liberties & freedoms , given to all without reserve to serve God in their oun way , presume to meet in these Assemblies , except such as make a pretence of Religion to cover their treasonable designs against our Royal person & the peace of our Government This is the Royal Charter for security of the Protestant Religion ( intended to secure it so , that it shall not go much abroad again ) in Lieu of all the Lawes , Constitutions , Oaths , & Covenants wherewith it was formerly confirmed . This is the only patent which the Royal Dâties , the Moderate Presbyterians , have now received to ensure their enjoyment of it durante beneplacito , during his pleasure whose Faith is as absolute over all ties of promises , as his power from whence it flowes is over all Lawes ; whose chiefest principle of Conscience is that no Faith is to be kept to Hereticks . Here is the Liberty which is said to surpass the hopes and equal the wishes of the most zealously concerned ; holding true indeed of too many , whose hopes & wishes & zeal are terminate upon peace rather than Truth , ease rather than duty and their own things rather than the things of Christ ; But as for the poor wild Wanderers , it some way answers their fears and corrosponds with their jealousies , who put the same interpretation upon it as on all the former Indulgences , Indemnities & Tolerations , proceeding from the same fountain & designed for the same sinistrous ends with this , which they look upon as more openly & obviously Anti-christian : and therefore , while others are rejoicing under the bramble-shadow of it , they think it a cause of weeping & matter of mourning , not because they do not share of the benefit of it , but because they are afraid to share of the Curse of it . For which cause , thô a freedom be pretended to be given , to all without reserve to serve God in their own way , they think it necessary to reserve to themselves the Liberty wherewith Christ hath made them free , and to serve Him in His Way thô interdicted by men , and to take none from Antichrist restricted with his reserves ; And do look upon it as a Seasonable Testimony for the Cause of Christ , and the Interest of the Protestant Religion , and the Lawes & Liberties of the Country , all overturned & subverted by this Toleration , to keep their Meetings as in former times , in the open fields whither their Tyranny hath driven them . And let them call these Meetings covered & treasonable designs against the Government on pretence of Religion , I trust it shall be made evident in the Conviction of all that know Religion , that their designs are to preserve it , in opposition to the Tyranny that goes about all these wayes to suppress it . Though I must suspend the Reasons of their keeping their Meetings in the fields , till I come to discuss that Case in its oun place : Here I shall only say , none that is acquainted with their Circumstances , which are as dangerously stated as ever , by reason of the Constant Persecution of Cruel enraged Enemies incessantly pursuing them without relenting , notwithstanding of all this pretence of Clemency & tenderness to Conscience , but may know they can neither have safety , secrecy , nor conveniency in houses for fear of their entrapping enemies , and none will blame them that after so many discoveries of their truculent treachery they dare not trust them : And besides , they think it sinful , scandalous , & inconvenient to seem to homologate this Toleration , the wickedness whereof they are convinced of , from these Reasons . I. Considering the Granter in his personal Capacity , as to his Morals , they look upon him as a person with whom they cannot in Prudence communicate , in any transaction of that nature . First , because being in his Principles & practice professedly treacherous , yea obliged to be both perfidious & cruel by that Religion whereunto he is addicted , he cannot be trusted in the least concerns , let be those of such momentous consequence as this , without a stupid abandoning of Conscience , Reason , & Experience . Since both that known principle , that no Faith is to be kept to Hereticks , which is espoused by all Papists , does to them justify all their lying dissimulations , equivocations , & treacheries imaginable ; and that Lateran Canon , that enjoyns Kings to destroy & exstirpate Hereticks under pain of excommunication , does oblige him to be cruel ; besides what deep engagments he is known to be under by Oaths & Promises to the Pope , both in his exile , and while a subject , and since he came to the Croun ; which make him to all Considering persons to be a person of that Character , whose deceitful dainties are not to be desired , and that when he speaketh fair is not to be beleeved , for there are seven abominations in his heart . Of which open & affronted Lies we have a sufficient swatch , both in his Proclamation for Scotland and Declaration for England ; where he speaks of his constant resolves of uniting the hearts of Subjects to God in Religion , & to their Neighbours in Christian Love , and that it never was his principle to offer violence to any mans Conscience , or use invincible necessity against any man on the account of his persuasion ; and that their Property was never in any case invaded since his coming to the Croun ; and that it hath been his constant sense & opinion , that Conscience ought not to to be constrained nor People forced in matters of meer Religion . To which , his uninterrupted endeavours to divide us from God and from on another , that he might the more easily destroy us , and his constant encroachments upon Lawes , Liberties , & Properties , and all Interests of men & Christians for Conscience sake do give the lie manifestly . And it must be great blindness not to see , and great baseness willingly to wink at that double faced equivocation , in matters of meer Religion ; by which he may elude all these flattering promises of tenderness , by excepting at the most necessary & indispensable duties , if either they be such wherein any other Interest is concerned beside meer Religion , or if their troubles sustained thereupon be not altogether invincible necessities . Hence the plain falsehood & doubleness of his Assertions as to what is past , may give ground to conclude his intended perfidie in the promises of what is future . Next , it is known what his Practices & Plots have been for the destruction of all honest & precious Interests ; what a deep hand he had in the burning of London , in the Popish plot discovered , anno 1678. in the Murder of the Earle of Essex , yea in the Parricide committed upon his oun brother . By all which it appears , nothing is so abominable & barbarous which he hath not a Conscience that will swallow & digest without a scruple ; and what he hath done of this kind must be but preparatory to what he intends , as meritorious to attone for these villanies . And in his esteem , and persuasion of Papists , nothing is thought more meritorious than to exstirpate the Protestant Religion , and destroy the Professors thereof . Therefore being such a person with whom in Reason no honest man could transact , for a tenure of the least piece of Land or house or any holding whatsoever , they dare not accept of his security or protection for so great an Interest , as the freedom & exercise of their Religion under the shadow of such a bramble . If it was the Shechemites sin & shame to strengthen a naughty Abimelech , and strengthen themselves under the shadow of his protection , much more must it be to take protection for Religion as wel as peace , from such a Monster of crueltie & treacherie . This were against their Testimony , and contrary to the Laudable Constitutions of the Church of Scotland , to take no Protections from Malignant Enemies , as was shewed above in Montroses case . See Pag. 82. above . II. Considering his Religion more particularly , they judge it unlawful so to bargain with him as this Acceptance would import . It is known he is not only a Papist , an Apostate Papist , and an Excommunicate Papist ( as is related above ) but a fiery Bigot in the Romish Religion , and zealous sworn votarie & vassal of Antichrist : who , as the Letter of the Iesuite from Liege lately published in print tells us , is resolved either to convert England to Poperie or die a Martyr , and again that he stiles himself a son of the Societie of Iesuites , and will account every injury done to them to be a wrong done against himself ; being known to be under the conduct & guidance of that furious Order , yea and enrolled as a member of that Society . Which makes it the less to be wondered , that he should require absolute obedience without reserve , seeing he himself yeelds absolute obedience as wel as implicite faith , without reserve , to the Jesuites . Such a Bigot was Mary of England ( as also his great Grandame of Scotland if she had got her will ) And his Bigotrie will make him emulous of her Crueltie , as counting it a diminution of his glory , for such a Champion as he under Antichrists banner to come short of a womans enterprizes : Nor would the late King have been so posted off the stage , if his successor were not to act more vigorously than he in this Tragical design , to which this Toleration is subservient . He is then a Servant of Antichrist , and as such under the Mediators Malediction ; yea in this respect is heir to his Grandfathers imprecation , who wished the Curse of God to fall upon such of his Posterity as should at any time turn Papists . How then can the Followers of the Lamb strike hands , be at peace , associate , confederate , or bargain with such a declared Enemy to Christ ? Certainly the Scripture-Commands of making no Covenant or League , interdicting entering into any affinity with the People of these abominations , and forbidding saying a Confederacy with them , do lay awful bonds on the Faithful to stand aloof from such . The People might have had Liberty of Conscience under the Assyrian Protection , when they were saying a Confederacy with him , but in so doing they forefaulted the benefit of the Lord being a Sanctuary to them . To bargain therefore with such an one for a Toleration of Religion , were contrary to the Scriptures , contrary to the Covenants and Principles of the Church of Scotland , against Associations & Confederacies with such Enemies . See Gillesp. Useful Case of Conscience concerning Assoc. hinted Pag. 83. and more Head. 3. Arg. 1. But to accept of this Liberty as now offered were a bargaining ; for where there is a Giving & Receiving upon certain Conditions , where there are Demands & Complyance ; Commands & Obedience , Promises & Relyance , Offers upon termes & Acquiescence in these termes , what is there wanting to a bargain , but the meer formality of Subscriptions ? At least it cannot be denied , but the Addressers have bargained for it , and in the name of all the Accepters , which must stand as their deed also ; if they do not evidence their resentment of such Presumption , which I do not see how they can , if they abide under the shadow thereof the same way as they do . I grant Liberty is very desirable , and may be taken & improven from Enemies of Religion : And so do the Wanderers now take it & improve it to the best advantage , without receiving it by acquiescing in any termes . But such a Liberty as this was never offered without a destructive design , nor ever received without a destructive effect . It is one of the filthie flatteries found in the English Addresses , particularly that from Totness , that the present Indulger is like another Cyrus who proclaimed Liberty to the People of God Ezra . 1. But who sees not the disparity in every respect ? Cyrus at his very first entry into the Government did lay out himself for the Churches good ; This man who speaks now so fair , his first work was to break our head and next to put on our hood , first to assert & corroberate his prerogative , and then by virtue of that to dispense with all Penal Lawes : It was foretold that Cyrus should deliver the Church at that time ; But was it ever promised that the Church should get Liberty to advance Antichrist ? or that Antichrist , or one of his Limbs , should be employed in the Churches deliverance , while such ? The Lord stirred up the Spirit of Cyrus ; Can it be said without blasphemy that the Lord stirred up this man , to contrive the introduction of Poperie by this Gate & Gap , except in a penal sense for judgment ? Cyrus had a Charge to build the Lord a House , but this is not a Charge but a Grant or Licence , not from nor according to Gods Authority but mans , not to build Christ a House , but a Babel for Antichrist ; and all this Liberty is but contrived as scaffolding for that Edifice , which when it is advanced then the scaffolding must be removed . 3. Considering him in his Relation as a Magistrate , it were contrary to their Testimony so often renewed & ratified , & confirmed with so many reasons , and sealed by so much blood , bonds , banishment , & other sufferings , to oune or acknowledge his Authority which is meer Usurpation & Tyrannie ; in that by the Lawes of the Land he is incapable of Government , and that he hath neither given nor can give , without an hypocritical & damning cheat , the Oath & Security indispensibly required of him before & at his entry to the Government . Yet this Liberty cannot be Complyed with , without recognoscing his Authority that he arrogates in giving it : Seeing he tenders it to all his good Subjects , and gives it by his Soveraign Authority , and to the end that by the Liberty thereby granted the peace & security of the Government in the practice thereof may not be indangered ; And in the Declaration to England , it is offered as an expedient to establish his Government on sach a foundation , as may make his Subjects happy , and unite them to him by inclination as well as duty ; to which indeed the Acceptance thereof hath a very apt subserviency : seeing it implies , not only ouning of the Government out of Duty , but an union & joyning with it and him by inclination , which is a cordial Confederacy with Gods enemie , and a cooperating to the establishment of his Tyrannie ; that the peace & security thereof may not be endangered . And in his former Proclamation , he gives them the same security for their Rights & Properties , which he gives for Religion ; And in the English Declaration , addeth that to the perfect enjoyment of their Propertie , which was never invaded &c. Which to accept , were not only to take the security of a manifest lie , but to prefer the word of a man that cannot , must not , will not keep it ( without going cross to his principles ) to the Security of Right & Law which is hereby infringed , and to acknowledge not only the Liberty of Religion , but the Right of Property to his grant : which when ever it is removed , there must remain no more Charter for it , but stupid slavery entailed upon Posterity , and pure & perfect Tyranny transmitted to them . The sin & absurdity where of may be seen demonstrated Head. 2. 4 , Considering the Fountain whence it flowes , they cannot defile themselves with it . In the English Declaration , it flowes from the Royal will & pleasur● which speaks a Domination Despotical & Arbitrary enough , but more gently expressed than in the Scots Proclamation ; where it is refounded on Soveraign Authority , Prerogative Royal , and Absolute Power : Proclaiming by sound of Trumpet à Power Paramount to all Law , Reason , & Religion , and outvying the hight of Ottoman Tyranny ▪ A Power which all are to obey without res●rve : A power to Tolerate or Restrain the Protestant Religion , according to his Royal will or pleasure : An Absolute power which can not be limited by Lawes , nor most Sacred Obligations , but only regulated by the Royal lust ; whereby indeed he may suffer the Protestant Religion , but only precariously so long as he pleases , and until his Royal pleasure shall be to command the establishment of Poperie , which then must be complyed with without control . Whereby all the tenure that Protestants have for their Religion , is only the Arbitrary word of an absolute Monarch , whose principles oblige him to break it , and his ambition to disdain to be a slave to it . Now the Acceptance of this Grant , would imply the recognizance of this power that the Granter claims in granting it ; which utterly disolves all Government , and all security for Religion & Liberty , and all the precious Interests of men & Christians : Which to acknowledge , were contrare to Scripture , contrary to Reason , and contrary to the Principles of the Church of Scotland , particularly the Declaration of the Gen. Ass. Iulij 27. 1649. See pag. 89. &c. and contrary to the Covenant . 5. Considering the Channel in which it is conveyed , they cannot Comply with it . Because it comes through such a Conveyance , as suspends , stops , & disables , all penal Lawes against Papists , and thereby everts all the Securities & legal Bulwarks that Protestants can have for the establishment of their Religion ; yea in effect leaves no Lawes in force against any that shall attempt the utter subversion of it , but rati●ies & leaves in ful vigour all wicked Lawes & Acts of Parliament , against such as would most avowedly assert it ; and stops & disables none of the most cruel & bloody Lawes against Protestants : for the most cruel are such as have been made against Field-Meetings , which are hereby left in ful force & vigour . Hence as he hath formally by absolute power suspended all Lawes made for the Protection of our Religion , so he may when he will dispense with all the Lawes made for its establishment ; and those who approve the one by such an Acceptance , cannot disallow the other , but must recognosce a power in the King to subvert all Lawes , Rights , & Liberties , which is contrare to Reason as wel as Religion , and a clear breach of the National & Solemn League & Covenants . 6. Considering the Ends of its Contrivance , they dare not have any accession to accomplish such wicked Projects , to which this Acceptance would be so natively subservient . The expressed ends of this Grant are , to unite the hearts of his Subjects to him in Loyaltie and to their Neighbours in love , as in the former Proclamation ; And that by the Liberty granted the peace & security of his Government in the practice thereof may not be endangered , as in the latter Proclamation ; And to unite the Subjects to him by inclination as well as duty which he thinks can be done by no means so effectually as by granting the free exercise of Religion , as in the English Declaration . Whence we may gather not obscurely , what is the proper tendency of it , both as to the work & worker , to wit , to incline & induce us by flatterie to a lawless Loyaltie , and a stupid contented slavery when he cannot compel us by force , and make us actively cooperate in setting & settling his Tyranny , in the peaceable possession of all his Usurpations , Robberies , & Encroachments upon our Religion , Lawes , & Liberties , and to incorporate us with Babylon , for wbo are the Neighbours he would have us unite with in love , but the Papists ? against whom all the Lovers of Christ must profess themselves irreconcileable Enemies . The English Declaration does further discover the design of this device , in one expression which will most easily be obtained to be beleeved of any in it , viz. that he heartily wishes that all the People of these Dominions were members of the Catholick Church : which clearly insinuates , that hereby he would entyce them to commit fornication with that Mother of harlots ; which entycing to Idolatrie ( if we consult the Scripture ) should meet with another sort of entertainment than such a kind & thankful Acceptance , which is not an opposing of such a wicked wish , but an encouraging & corroberating of it . And further he sayes , that all the former tract of Persecutions never obtained the end for which it was employed ; For after all the frequent & pressing endeavours that were used , to reduce this Kingdom to an exact con●ormity in Religion , it is visible the success has not answered the design , and that the difficultie is invincible . Wherein we may note his extorted acknowledgment , that all former endeavours to destroy the Work of God have been successless , which induces him to try another method , to which this Acceptance is very subservient , to wit , to destroy us and our Religion by flatteries , and by peace to overturn Truth , and by the subversion of Lawes to open a door to let in Poperie and all abominations . But what is more obscurely expressed in his words , is more visibly obvious in his works , to all that will not willingly wink at them ; discovering clearly the end of this Liberty is not for the Glory of God , nor the Advantage of Truth , or the Churches Edification , nor intended as a benefit to Protestants ; but for a pernicious design , by gratifying a few of them in a pretended favour to rob all of them of their chiefest Interests , Religion , Lawes , Rights , & Liberties , which he could not otherwise effectuate but by this arbitrary way ; for if he could have obtained his designs by Law : he would never have talked of Lenity or Liberty , but having no legal ends he behoved 〈◊〉 compass them by illegal means . They must then be very blind who do not see , his drift is , first to get in all Popish Officers in places of Publick Trust , by taking off the Penal Lawes disabling them for the same ; Then to advance his Absoluteness over all Lawes , in a way which will be best acknowledged & acquiesced in by People , till he be so strengthened in it that he fears no control ; And then to undermine & overturn the Protestant Religion , & establish Poperie & Idolatrie : which he is concerned the more violently to pursue , because he is now growing old , and therefore must make hast , lest he leave the Papists in a worse condition than he found them : which to be sure the Papists are aware of , and their conscious fears of the Nations resentments of their Villanies will prompt them , as long as they have such a Patron , to all vigilance & violence in playing their game : And withall , hereby he may intend to capacitate himself for subduing the Dutch , against whom he hath given many indications of a hostile mind of old & of late ; not only in hiring two Rascals to burn the Amsterdam-fleet heretofore , but in stirring up & protecting the Algerine Pyrats against them ; So universal a Protector is he become of late , that Papists & Protesiants , Turks & Iewes are shrouded under the shadow of his Patrociny , but with a design to destroy the best , when his time comes . Which cursed designs cannot be counteracted , but very much strengthened by this Acceptance . 7. Considering the Effects already produced thereby , they cannot but abhor it . Seeing the eyes of all that are tender may affect their hearts , observing how the Papists are hereby encouraged & encreased in numbers , the whole Nation overflow'd wlth their hellish Locusts , and all Places filled with Priests & Iesuites , yea the executive power of the Government put into the hands of the Romanists , and on the other hand how the People are endangered with their abounding & prevailing Errors ( to which the Lord may & will give up those that have not received the love of the Truth ) Truth is sallen in the streets & equity cannot enter , a Testimony against Antichrist is abandoned & laid aside as unseasonable , the edge of zeal for the Interest of Christ is blunted and its fervor extinginshed , they that should stand in the Gap and upon the watch Tower are laid aside from all opposition to the invasions of the Enemy , and lulled asleep by this bewitching Charm & intoxicating Opium , Ministers & Professors are generally settling on their lees and languishing in a fatal security , Defection is carried on , Division promoted , and Destruction is imminent . Is it not then both a part of the Witness of the Faithful , and of their wisdom to stand aloof from such a Plague , that hath such destructive effects ? 8. Considering the Nature & Name of this pretended Liberty , they cannot but disdain it as most dishonourable to the Cause of Christ. It is indeed the honour of Kings and happiness of People ; to have true humane & Christian Liberty established in the Common wealth , that is , Liberty of Persons from slaverie ; Liberty of Priviledges from Tyranny , and Liberty of Conscience from all impositions of men ; Consisting in a freedom from the Doctrines , Traditions , & Commandments of men against or beside the Word of God , in the free enjoyment of Gospel Ordinances in purity & power , and in the free observance & establishment of all His Institutions of Doctrine , Worship , Discipline , & Government , in subordination to the only Rule of Conscience , the revealed Will of its only Law-giver Jesus Christ. When this is ratified as a Right by the Sanction of approven Authority , and countenanced & encouraged as Religion , by the Confirmation of Lawes , approving whatsoever is Commanded by the God of Heaven to be done for the House of the God of Heaven ( which is the full amount of all Magistrats Authority ) Then we are obliged to accept of it with all thankful acceptation . But such a Liberty , as overturns our Rights , our Priviledges , our Lawes , our Religion , and Tolerates it only under the Notion of a Crime , and indemnifies it under the notion of a Fault to be Pardoned , and allowes the exercise thereof only in Part so & so modified , cannot be accepted by any to whom the reproach thereof is a burden , and to whom the reproaches of Christ are in esteem , in such a day when even the hoofs of Christs Interest buried in bondage are to be contended for . Whatever Liberty this may be to some Consciences , it is none to the tender according to the Rule of Conscience , It is only a Toleration which is alwayes of evil : for that which is good cannot be tolerated under the notion of good , but countenanced & encouraged as such . Therefore this reflects upon our Religion , when a Toleration is accepted which implies such a reproach : And the annexed Indemnity & Pardon tacitely condemns the Profession thereof as a fault or Crime , which no Christian can bear with , or by his acceptance homologate these reproaches , if he consider the nature of it : And much more will he be averse from it , if he consider how dishonourable it is to God ( whatever some Addressers , particucularly the Presbyterians at London , have blasphemously alledged , that God is hereby restored to His Empire over the Conscience ) Since the Granter , after he hath robbed the Mediator of His Supremacy and given it away to Antichrist , And God of His Supremacy Imperial as Universal King by a Claim of Absolute Power peculiar to Him , he hath also robbed Him of His Empire over the Conscience , in giving every man the Empire over his oun Conscience , which he reserves a power to retract whem he pleases . 9. Considering the Extent of it , they cannot class themselves amoug the number of them that are Indulged thereby . It takes in not only the Arch-Bishops & Bishops , and the Prelatical & Malignant Crue , but all Quakers , and Papists , reaching all Idolatry , Blasphemy , & Heresie , and Truth also ( which could never yet dwell together under one sconce ) Whereby the Professors of Christ come in as Partners in the same bargain with Antichrists Vassals ; And the Lords Ark hath a place with Dagon , and its Priests & Followers consent to it ; And the builders of Babel & of Ierusalem ar made to build together , under the same Protection ; and a sluce is opened to let the enemy come in like a flood , which to oppose the Accepters cannot stand in the Gap nor lift up a Standart against them . Liberty indeed should be Universally extended to all the Lords People , as Cyrus his Proclamation was General , who is there among yow of all His People ? his God be with him . But a Toleration of Idolaters , Blasphemers , & Hereticks , as Papists , &c. is odious to God , because it is contrary to Scripture , expressly Commanding Idolaters to die the death , and all Seducers & Entycers to Apostasie from God to be put to death without pity ; and Commending all righteous Magistrats that executed Judgement accordingly , as Asa , Hezekiah &c. yea even Heathen Magistrats that added their Sanction to the Lawes of God , as Artaxerxes is approven for that Statute , that whosoever will not do the Law of God and of the King , judgement should be executed speedily upon him . And in the New Testament this was never repealed but confirmed , in that the sword is given to Magistrats , not in vain , but to be a terror to , and revengers to execute wrath upon all that do evil , among whom Seducers that are evil workers & Idolaters are chiefly to be ranked , being such as do the worst of evil to mankind . Ephesus is commended because they could not bear them which are evil : and Thyatira reproved for suffering Iezebel : by which it appeareth , that our Lord Jesus is no friend to Toleration . It is true this is spoken against Church-men ; but will any think that will be approven in Civil Powers , which is so hateful in Church Officers ? Surely it will be the duty & honour of these horns spoken of Revel . 17. to eat the whores flesh & burn her with fire : And shall that be restricted only to be done against the great Antichrist , & not be duty against the lesser Antichrists , the limbs of the Great one ? It is recorded of Iulian the Apostate , that among other devices he used , to root out Christianity this was one , that he gave Toleration openly to all the different Professions that were among Christians , whereof there were many heretical in those dayes : which is exactly aped by Iames the Apostate now for the same end . It is also contrare to the Confession of faith Chap. 20. § 4. asserting that for their publishing such opinions , or maintaining of such practices , as are contrary to the light of Nature , or to the known Principles of Christianity , whether concerning Faith Worship , or Conversation , or to the power of Godliness , or such erroneous opinions or practices , as either in their oun nature , or in the manner of publishing or maintaining them , are destructive to the external Peace & . Order , which Christ hath established in the Church ; they may lawfully be called to account , and proceeded against by the Censures of the Church , and by the power of the Civil Magistrate . And therefore to accept of this Toleration is inconsistent with the Principles of the Church of Scotland , with the National & Solemn League & Covenants , & Solemn Acknowledgment of sins & Engagement to duties , in all which we are bound to extirpate Poperie , Prelacie &c. With the whole tract of Contendings in the fifth Period above related , and particularly by the Testimony of the Synod of Fife , and other Brethren in the Ministry , against Cromuels vast Toleration & Liberty of Conscience , mentioned above Pag. 76. for it is plain , if it be not to be suffered , then it is not to be accepted . 10. Considering the Termes wherein it is offered , they cannot make such a shameful bargain . In the former Proclamation it is granted expressly under several Conditions , Restrictions , & Limitations : whereof indeed some are retracted in the Latter , as the restriction of it to Moderate Presbyterians , which would seem to be taken off by extending to all without reserve to serve , God in their oun may ; but being evidently exclusive of all that would serve God in Christs way , and not after the mode prescribed , it is so modified and restricted that all that will accept of it must be Moderate Presbyterians indeed , which as it is taken in the Court sense must be an ignominy to all that have zeal against Antichrist . The Limitation also to private houses and not to out-houses , is further enlarged to Chappels or places purposely hired but still it is stinted to these , which they must bargain for with Councellors , Shiriffs &c. So that none of these Restrictions & Limitations are altogether removed , but the Condition of taking the Oath only : yet it is very near to an equivalency homologated , by the Accepters acknowledging in the Granter a Prerogative & Absolute Power over all Lawes , which is confirmed & maintained by their Acceptance . As for the rest that are not so much as said to be removed , they must be interpreted to remain , as the termes , conditions , restrictions , & limitations , upon which they are to enjoy the benefite of this Toleration . And what he sayes , that he thought fit by this Proclamation further to declare , does confirme it , that there are further explications , but no taking off of former restrictions . Hence it is yet clogged with such provisions & restrictions , as must make it very nauseous to all truly tender ( 1 ) The restriction as to the Persons still remains , that only Moderate Presbyterians , and such as are willing to accept of this Indulgence allanerly , and none other , and such only whose names must be signified to these Sheriffs , Stewards , Bailifs &c. are to have the benefit of this Indulgence : wherey all the zealous & faithful Presbyterians are excluded , ( for these they will not call them Moderate ) and all that would improve it without a formal Acceptance , and all who for their former diligence in duty are under the lash of their wicked Law , and dare not give up their names to those who are seeking their lives , must be deprived of it . ( 2 ) It is restricted to certain Places still , which must be made known to some one or more of the next privie Councellors & whereby they are tied to a dependence on their warrand , and must have their lease & licence for Preaching the Word in any place , and Field-Meetings are severely interdicted , though signally countenanced of the Lord , whereby the Word of the Lord is bound & bounded ; and by this Acceptance their bloody Lawes against Preaching in the open fields , where People can have freest access with conveniency & safety , are justified . ( 3 ) The manner of Meeting is restricted , which must be in such a way as the peace & security of the Government in the practice thereof may not be endangered , and again that their Meetings be peaceably held , which is all one upon the matter with the bond of peace , and binding to the good behaviour so much formerly contended against by Professors , and is really the same with the Condition of the Cautionary Bond in the Indulgence after Bothuel , of which see Pag. 129. And further they must be openly & publickly held , and all persons freely admitted to them ; which is for the informing trade , exposing to all the inconveniences of Iesuites , and other Spies & Flies their delations , in case any thing be spoken reflecting on the Government , a great tentation to Ministers . ( 4 ) The worst of all is upon ther matter of Preaching . which is so restricted & limited , that nothing must be said or done contrare to the well & peace of his reign , seditious or treasonable ; And in case any treasonable speeches be uttered the Law is to take place against the guilty , and none other present , providing they reveal to any of the Council the guilt so committed , as in the former Proclamation : And in the last it is further declared , that nothing must be Preached or taught , which may any way tend to alienate the hearts of the People from him or his Government . Here is the price at which they are to purchase their freedom ( a sad bargain to buy Liberty & sell Truth ) which yet hardly can be so exactly paid , but he may find a pretence for retrenching it when he pleases ; for if a Minister shall Pray for the overturning of a throne of iniquity , or for confounding all that serve graven Images , and for destruction to the Pope and all that give their power to that beast , there will be something said against the well of his Government ; Or if any shall hear this and not delate it , then the same pretence is relevant ; Or if he shall Preach against the Kings Religion as Idolatry , and the Church of Rome as Babylon , and discharge his Conscience & Duty in speaking against the Tyrannie of the times ; Or let him Preach against any publick sin faithfully , a Popish Critick or Romish Bigot shall interpret it to be an alienation of the Peoples hearts from the King & his Government . But who can be faithful , and Preach in season & out of season now , but he must think it his duty to endeavour to alienate the hearts of the People from such an Enemy to Christ , and his absolute Tyranny , so declaredly stated against God ? What Watchman must not see it his indispensable Duty , to warn all People of his Devilish designs to destroy the Church & Nation , and Preach so that People may hate the whore , and this Pimp of hers ? Sure if he Preach the whole Counsel of God , he must Preach against Poperie & Tyrannie . And if he think this Indulgence from Absolute Prerogative , granted & accepted on these termes , can supercede him from this faithfulness , then he is no more the Servant of Christ but a pleaser of men . Therefore since it is so clogged with so many restrictions , so inconsistent with duty , so contrary to Scripture , so clearly violatory of Covenant-Engagements , so cross to the constant Contendings & Constitutions of this Church , and Acts of Ass. ( See Pag. 80. &c. ) it were a great defection to Accept of it . 11. Considering the Scandal of it , they dare not so offend the generation of the Righteous by the Acceptance , and dishonour God , disgrace the Protestant Profession , wrong the Interest thereof , and betray their native Country , as thus to comply with the Design of Antichrist , and partake of this cruel tender mercy of the beast ; who hath alwayes mischief in his heart , and intends this as a Preparative for inducing or inforcing all that are hereby lulled asleep either to take on his Mark , or bear the Marks of his fiery fury afterwards . For hereby forreign Churches may think , we are in a fair way of reconciliation with Antichrist , when we so kindly accept his Harbingers favours . And it cannot but be very stumbling to see the Ministers of Scotland , whose Testimony used to be terrible to the Popish and renouned through all the Protestant Churches , purchasing a Liberty to themselves at the rate of burying & betraying the Cause into bondage & restraint , and thus to be laid by from all active & open opposition to Antichrists Designs , in such a season . The world will be tempted to think , they are not governed by Principles but their oun Interest in this juncture , seeking their oun things more than the things of Christ ; And that it was not the late Usurpation upon , & overturning of Religion & Liberty that offended them , so much as the Persecution they sustained thereby ; but if that Arbitrary Power had been exerted in their favours , tho with the same prejudice of the Cause of Christ , they would have complyed with it as they do now . Alas sad & dolorous have been the Scandals given & taken by & from the Declining Ministers of Scotland heretofore , which have rent & racked the poor Remnant , and offended many both at home & abroad , but none so stumbling as this . And therefore the tender will be shie to medle with it . 12. Considering the Addresses made thereupon , with such a stain of foulsome & blasphemous flatteries , to the dishonour of God , the reproach of the Cause , the betraying of the Church , and detriment of the Nation , and exposing themselves to the contempt of all , the poor Persecuted Partie dare not so much as seem to incorporate with them . I shall set doun the first of their Addresses , given forth in the name of all the Presbyterian Ministers , And let the Reader judge whether there be not Cause of standing aloof from every appearance of being of their number . It is dated at Edinburgh , Iulj 21. 1687. of this tenor . To the Kings most excellent Majestie . The humble Address of the Presbyterian Ministers of his Majesties Kingdom of Scotland . We your Maj. most loyal subjects , the Ministers of the Presbyterian persuasion in your Ancient Kingdom of Scotland , from the due sense we have of your Maj. gracious & surprising favour , in not only puting a stop to our long sad sufferings for Non-conformity , but granting us the Liberty of the Publick & Peaceable exercise of our Ministerial function without any hazard : As we bless the Great God who hath put this in your Royal heart , do with all find our selves bound in duty to offer our most humble & hearty thanks to your Sacred Majestie , the favour bestowed being to us and all the People of our Persuasion valuable above all our earthly comforts , especially since we have ground from your Maj. to beleeve that our Loyaltie is not to be questioned upon the account of our being Presbyterians , who as we have amidst all former tentations endeavoured , so we are firmly resolved still to preserve an intire Loyaltie in our Doctrine & Practice ( consonant to our known Principles , which according to the Holy Scriptures are contained in the Confession of faith , generally ouned by Presbyterians in all your Maj. Dominions ) and by the help of God so to demean our selves , as your Maj. may find cause rather to enlarge than to diminish your favours towards us ; throughly perswading our selves from your Maj. justice & goodness , that if we shall at any time be otherwise represented , your Maj. will not give credit to such information , until yow have due cognition thereof : and humbly beseeching , that those who promote any dsloyal Principles & practices ( as we disoune them ) may be looked upon as none of ours , whatsover name they may assume to themselves . May it please your most excellent Maj. graciously to accept of this our most hmble Address , as proceeding from the plainness & sincerity of Loyal & thankful hearts , much engaged by your Royal favour , to continue our fervent Prayers to the King of Kings , for Divine illumination & conduct , with all other blessings Spiritual & Temporal , ever to attend your Royal Person & Government , which is the greatest duty can be rendered to your Maj. by Your Maj. most humble , mast faithful , & most obedient Subjects . Subscribed in our Names , and in the name of the rest of our Brethren of our Persuasion , at their desire . Which received this Gracious return . The Kings Letter to the Presbyterians in his ancient Kingdom of Scotland . We love yow well : and we heartily thank yow for your Address : we resolve to Protect yow in your Liberty , Religion , & properties all our life : And we shall lay doun such methods , as shall not be in the power of any to alter hereafter . And in the mean tune we desire yow to Pray for our Person & Government . To which may be added that kind Complement of the Chancellors : Gentlemen , My Master hath commanded me to tell yow , that I am to serve yow in all things within the compass of my power . These Gentlemen needed not to have been sollicitous , that those who avouch an Adherance to the Covenanted Reformation , and avow an opposition to Antichristian Usurpers ( which they call promoting Dislayal principles & practices ) might not be looked upon as of their Confederacy : for all that abide in the principles & Practices of the Church of Scotland ( which they have deserted ) and that desire to be found Loyal to Christ , in opposition to His and the Churches and the Countries Declared Enemy , would count it a sin & scandal , laying them obnoxious to the Displeasure of the Holy & Jealous God , who will resent this heinous Indignity they have done unto His Majestie ( if they do not Address themselves unto Him for pardon of the iniquity of this Address , which is the desire of those whom they disoune that they may find Grace to do so ) and a shameful Reproach , exposing them to the Contempt of all of whom they expect Sympathie , to be reckoned of their Association who have thus betrayed the Cause & the Country . These mutual Complements ( so like the Caresses of the Romish whore whereby she entyces the Nations to her fornication ) between the Professed Servants of Christ and the Vassals of Antichrist , if they be cordial ; would seem to import that they are in a fair way of compounding their differences and to accommodate their oppositions at length ; which yet I hope will be irreconcileably maintained & kept up by all true Presbyterians , in whose name they have the impudence to give out their Address : But if they be only Adulatory & flattering Complements , importing only a Conjunction of tails like Samsons foxes ) with a Disjunction of heads and hearts , tending towards distinct & opposite Interests ; then , as they would suite far better the Dissmulations of Politicians , than the Simplicity of Gospel-Ministers , and do put upon them the brand of being men-pleasers rather than Servants of Christ , so for their dissemblings with Dissemblers , who know their Complements to be and take them for such , they may look to be paid home in good measure , heaped up & running over , when such methods shall be laid doun as shall not be in the power of any to alter , when such designs shall be obtained by this Liberty and these Addresses , that the after bought wit of the Addressers shall not be able to disappoint . However the Address it self is of such a dress , as makes the thing addressed for to be odious , and the Addressers to forefault the respect , & merit the indignation of all that are friends to the Protestant & Presbyterian Cause , as may appear from these obvious Reflections . 1. It was needful indeed they should have assumed the name of Presbyterians ( though it might have been more tolerable to let them pass under that name , if they had not presumed to give forth their flatteries in the name of all of that Persuasion , and to alledge it was at their desire ; which is either an illuding equivocation , or a great untruth , for though it might be the desire of the men of their oun persuasion , which is a newly start up opinion that Interest hath led them to espouse , yet nothing could be more cross to the real desires of true Presbyterians , that prefer the Truth of the Cause to the external peace of the Professors thereof ) and call it the humble Address of Presbyterian Ministers : for otherwise it could never have been known to come from men of the Presbyterian persuasion ; seeing the Contents of this Address are so clearly contrary to their known Principles . It is contrary to Presbyterian Principles , to Congratulate an Antichristian Usurper for undermining Religion , and overturning Lawes & Liberties . It is contrary to Presbyterian Principles , to justify the abrogation of the National Covenant , in giving thanks for a Liberty whereby all the Lawes are called & disabled therein confirmed . It is contray to Presbyterian Principles , to thank the King for opening a door to bring in Poperie , which they are engaged to exstirpate in the Solemn League & Covenant . It is contrary to Presbyterian Principles to allow or accept of such a vast Toleration for Idolaters & Hereticks , as is evident above from all their Contendings against it , which is also contrary to the Confession of faith , generally ouned by Presbyterians , as may be seen in the place forecited Chap. 20. Par. 4. It is contrary to Presbyterian Principles to consent to any Restrictions , Limitations , & Conditions , binding them up in the exercise of the Ministerial function , wherewith this Liberty is loaded & clogged ; whereby indeed they have the Liberty of the Publick & peaceable exercise of it , without any hazard of present Persecution , but not without great hazard of sin , and incurring the guilt of the blood of Souls , for not declaring the whole Counsel of God , which Addressers cannot declare , if they Preserve an intire Loyaltie in their Doctrine , as here they promise . 2. There is nothing here sounds like the old Presbyterian strain ; neither was there ever an Address of this stile seen before from Presbyterian hands . It would have looked far more Presbyterian like , instead of this Address , to have sent a Protestation against the now openly designed introduction of Poperie , and subversion of all Lawes & Liberties which they are Covenanted to maintain , or at least to have given an Address in the usual Language of Presbyterians , who used alwayes to speak of the Covenants , and Work of Reformation : But here never a word of these , but of Loyaltie to his excellent , to his Gracious , and to his Sacred Majestie , of Loyaltie not to be questioned , an Entire Loyaltie in Doctrine , a resolved Loyaltie in Practice , and a servent Loyaltie in Prayers : And all that they are solicitous about , is not lest the Prerogatives of their Master be encroached upon , and the Liberties of the Church be supplanted , and Religion wronged ; but lest their Loyaltie be questioned , and they be otherwise represented : And all that they beseech for is , not that the Cause of Christ be not wronged , nor Antichristian Idolatrie introduced by this Liberty ; but that these who promove any disloyal Principles & Practices may be looked upon as none of theirs , wherein all their encouragment is , that they persuade themselves from his Maj. justice & goodness , that he will not give credite to any other information until he take due cognition thereof . Here is a Lawless unrestricted Loyaltie to a Tyrant , claiming an absolute power to be obeyed without reserve , not only professed , but solicitously sought to be the Principle of Presbyterians ; whereas it is rather the Principle of Athiestical Hobbes exploded with indignation by all rational men . This is not a Christian Loyaltie , o● profession of Consciencious Subjection , to a Minister of God for good who is a terror to evil doers , but a stupid subjection & absolute Allegiance to a Minister of Antichrist , who gives Liberty to all evil men & seducers . This is not the Presbyterian Loyaltie to the King , in the defence of Christ His Evangel , Liberties of the Country , Ministration of Iustice , & punishment of iniquity , according to the National Covenant ; And in the preservation & defence of the true Religion & Liberties of the Kingdoms , according to the Solemn League & Covenant ; but an Erastian Loyaltie to a Tyrant , in his overturning Religion Lawes & Liberties , & protecting & encouraging all iniquity . This Loyaltie in Doctrine will be found Disloyaltie to Christ , in a sinful & shameful silence at the wrongs done to Him , and not declaring against the Invasions of His open Enemies . This Loyaltie in Practice is a plain betraying of Religion & Liberty , in lying by from all opposition to the open Destroyer of both . And this Loyaltie in Prayers , for all blessings ever to attend his person & Government , will be found neither consonant to Presbyterian Prayers in reference to Popish Tyrants , nor consistent with the Zeal of Christians , and the Cries of all the Elect unto God to whom vengeance belongs , against Antichrist and all his Supporters , nor any way conforme to the Saints Prayers in Scripture , nor founded upon any Scripture promises , to pray for a blessing to a Papists Tyrannie , which cannot be of Faith and therefore must be sin . It were much more suitable to pray , that the God which hath caused His Name to dwell in His Church , may destroy all Kings that shall put to their hand to alter & destroy the House of God , Ezrah . 6. 12. 3. This Address is so stuffed with sneaking flatteries , that it would become more Sycophants & Court-Parasites than Ministers of the Gospel ; and were more suitable to the Popish , Prelatical , & Malignant faction to congratulate & rejoice in their professed Patroh & Head , and fill the Gazetts with their Adulatory Addresses , which heretofore used to be deservedly inveighed against by all Dissenters ; than for Presbyterians to take a Copy from them , and espouse the practice which they had condemned before , and which was never commended in any good Government , nor never known in these British Nations , before Oliver's Usurpation & Charles his Tyranny ; flatterie being alwayes counted base among ingenuous men . But here is a Rhapsodie of flatteries , from the deep sense they have of his Maj. gracious & surprising favour — finding themselves bound in duty to offer their most humble & hearty thanks , to his Sacred Maj. the favour bestowed being to them — valuable above all earthly comforts . One would think this behoved to be a very great favour , from a very great friend , for very gracious ends : But what is it ? In not only puting a stop to their long sad sufferings ; which were some ground indeed if the way were honest : but this not only supposes an also ; what is that ? but also granting us the Liberty — which is either a needless Tautology ( for if all Sufferings were stopped , then Liberty must needs follow ) or it must respect the qualifications of the Liberty ; flowing from such a Fountain , absolute power ; through such a Conveyance , the stoping all penal Lawes against Papists ; in such a Forme as a Toleration ; for such Ends , as overturning the Reformation & introducing Poperie . This is the favour for which they offer most humble & hearty thanks , more valuable to them than all earthly comforts ; thô it be manifestly intended to deprive the Lords People , at the long run , of the Heavenly Comforts of the Preached Gospel . Sure , if they thank him for the Liberty , they must thank him for the Proclamation whereby he grants it , and justify all his Claim there to Absoluteness , being that upon which it is superstructed , and from which it emergeth , And so become a listed faction to abett & oune him in all his attemptings , engaged now to demean themselves as that he may find cause rather to enlarge than to diminish his favours , which can be no other way but in assisting him to destroy Religion & Liberty , at least in suffering him to do what he will without control . O what an indeleble reproach is this for Ministers , who pretend to be set for the defence of the Gospel , thus to be found betraying Religion , through justifying & magnifying a Tyrant , for his suspension of so many Lawes whereby is was established & supported . 4. It were more tolerable if they went no further than flatteries : but I fear they come near the border of Blasphemie , when they say , that the Great God hath put this in his Royal heart : which can bear no other Construction but this , that the holy Lord hath put it in his heart to assume to himself a blasphemous & absolute power , whereby he stops & suspends all Penal Lawes against Idolaters , and gives a Toleration for all Errors : Or if it be capable of any other sense , it must be like that as the Lord is said to have moved David to number the People , or that Rev. 17. 17. God hath put it in their hearts to fulfill His Will , and to aggree aud give their Kingdom unto the Beast . But to bless God and thank the Tyrant for this wicked Project , as deliberate & purposed by men , I say is near unto Blasphemy . And again where they say , they are firmly resolved by the help of God so to demean themselves as his Maj. may find cause rather to enlarge than to diminish his favours ; this in effect is as great Blasphemy as if they had said , they resolved by the help of God to be as unfaithful Time-serving & Silent Ministers as ever plagued the Church of God ; for no otherwise can they demean themselves so as he may find cause to enlarge his favours towards them , it being no way supposible that his enlarging his favours can consist with their faithfulness , but if they discover any measure of zeal against Antichrist , he will quickly diminish them . Thus far I have compendiously deduced the Account of the Progress , & Prosecution of the Testimony of this Church to the present State thereof , as it is Concerted & Contended for , by the Reproached Remnant now only Persecuted : which I hope this pretended Liberty shall be so far from obscuring & interrupting , that it shall contribute further to clear it , and engage them more to Constancy in it , and induce others also to Countenance it , when they shall see the sad effects of this Destructive Snare , which I leave to time to produce : And hope , that as the former Representation of their Cause will conciliate the Charity of the unbyassed , so an Account of their Sufferings thereupon will provoke them to Sympathie . To which I now proceed . PART . II. CONTAINING A BRIEF ACCOUNT Of the Persecution of the last Period , And of the great Sufferings whereby all the Parts of its Testimony were sealed . THe foregoing Deduction , being the first thing I proposed to be discussed in the Method of this Essay , hath now swelled to such a Bulk , that the Last Period of it doth in a manner swallow up what I intended to have said on the Second : Because it gives grounds to gather the Methods & Measures that our Adversaries have managed , for the ruin of this Witnessing Remnant , and also discovers some special steps of their Sufferings within these 27. years past , under the Tyranny of both the Brothers . It will now be the more easie to glean the Gradations of the Means & Machins , used by this Popish , Prelatical , & Malignant faction , to raze the Work of Reformation , and to build their Babel of Poperie & Slaverie on the ruines thereof ; And to aggregate an Account in brief of the Great Sufferings of the Faithful . Which though it be beyond my power and besides my purposes at present , to offer a Narrative of it , with any proportion to the greatness of the subject ; A more particular Relation thereof , being now projected , if Providence permit , to be Published to the world , which will discover strange & unheard of Cruelties : yet in this little heap of some hints only of the kinds of their Sufferings , I do not question but it will appear , that the Persecution of Scotland hath been very remarkable , and scarcely out-done by the most Cruel in any Place or Age , in respect of injustice , illegality , & inhumanity , though perhaps inferiour in some other Circumstances . But that none could be more unjust , illegal , or inhumane , I need not further , I cannot better , demonstrate than only to Declare the matter of fact , as it fell out in the several Steps of the Last Period . 1. In the Entry of this fatal Catastrophe , the first of their Mischievous Machinations was to remove out of the way all who were eminent Instruments in carrying on the former Work of God , or might be of influence for obstructing their Antichristian & Tyrannical designs , both in the State and in the Church . And accordingly when the Marque●s of Argyle , who had a main hand in bringing home the King , and closing the Second Treaty at Breda , went up to London to Congratulate his return from exile , he was made Prisoner in the Tower , thereafter sent doun to Scotland , indyted of high Treason , at length beheaded , and his head placed upon the Tolbooth of Edinburgh ( A watch word of warning to our Addressers , who may ere all be done meet with the same sawce ) for no other alledged Cause , but for his Complyance with the English when they had our Land in subjection ; a thing wherein the Judges that condemned him were Socii Criminis : but really for another provocation that incensed the King against him , which made him a Tyrant as infamous for villanie as for violence , to wit , for his reproving the King ( when others declined it ) for an Adulterous Rape , which he held for so piacular a Crime , that he resolved nothing should expiate it but the blood of this Nobleman . For the same Pretended Cause was the Lord Waristoun afterwards executed to death at Edinburgh , after they had missed of their design of taking him off by Clandestine ways abroad . Then they fall upon the Ministers : And because Mr Iames Guthrie was a man , who had been honoured of God to be zealous & singularly faithful in carrying on the Work of Reformation , and had asserted the Kingly Authority of Christ in opposition to the Erastian Supremacy encroaching thereupon , therefore he must Live no longer , but is condemned to die , and most basely handled as if he had been a most Notorious Thief or Malefactor ; he is hanged , & afterward his head placed upon one of the Ports of Edinburgh ; where it abideth to this day Preaching not only against the Enemies Rebellion against God , but against the defection of many Ministers since , who have Practically denied that Great Truth for which he Suffered , viz , his Testimony against the Supremacy , and for declining the Usurped Authority of him who Arrogated it . At the same time there was a Proclamation , which they caused to be read at all the Church-doors , discharging Ministers to speak against them or their Proceedings , whereby Profane & Malicious persons were encouraged to witness against their Ministers . By which means ( though many were in no hazard , thinking it commendable Prudence , commended indeed by the world , but hateful unfaithfulness before God , to be silent at such a time ) some faithful Ministers giving faithful & free warning & Protesting against the present Defection , were condemned of Treason , and banished out of the three Dominions . Others Indicta Causa without access to give in their defences , were sentenced with banishment , and could never get an Extract of their sentence : And furder were compelled to subscribe a bond , under pain of death to remove out of all the Dominions betuixt & such a day . This was the lot , and also the blot , of these famous & faithful Ministers , Mr Iohn Livingstoun , Mr Ro M● Ward , Mr Io. Broun &c. who spent the rest of their dayes in Holland , serving their Generation by their excellent Writings . Then after they had disposed of many other Ministers , whom they thrust out for not keeping the 29th of May , having now laid by the most Eminent , & whom they feared most of the Ministrie , they shortly thereafter outed & violented the rest from the exercise of their Ministrie , and straitened them with strange & severe Confinements , yea because they would not be out done 〈◊〉 suppressing Religion by any , no not by Iulian the Apostate , they proceeded to poyson all the springs & fountains of Learning ; ordaining that none be Masters in Universities , except they take the Oath of Supremacy , & oune the Government of Prelacy , and none be admitted to teach in a School without the Prelats Licence . These Courses brought many Ministers & Expectants to great Sufferings . 2. Hitherto they reached only Noblemen , Gentlemen , & Ministers , and others whom they thought might stand in their way : of advancing their Cursed Designs . The next Drift is , when they had emptied the Churches of Ministers , and filled them with the vermine of ignorant & scandalous Curats , to force the People to Conformity , and to Disoune & discountenance their oun Ministers ; first , by severe Edicts of exorbitant fining not only the persons themselves contraveening , but those that had the Superiority over them , & rigourous execution of these fines , to the Depopulation of a poor Country , by Military force . Whereby , where there was but one Church in the bounds , still enjoying a Minister whom the People could hear , the profane Souldiers would beset that Church in time of Worship , and cause all within to pay their fines , or take the garments from them that could not , and beat them to the effusion of their blood : And where the Church was planted with a Curat , the Souldiers would come and call the Names of the Parishoners , and amerciate the Absents in such fines as they pleased . In other Places they went to private houses , and by force drove them to Church , even though sick & unable . But where the Dissenters were numerous , great bands of Legal Robbers were sent to exact & extort these exorbitant fines , by plundering , quartering , beating , wounding , binding men like beasts , chasing away from houses , and harrassing whole Countrysides , in a hideous manner . And yet after all these insolencies , some of the common sort were compelled to subscribe an acknowledgment , that the Captain had used them civilly & discreetly ; though the account of others of that place manifests the violence to have been so monstrous , that it justified the greatest barbarity : shewing their exactions to have been intolerable , both for the quantity , without all proportion or pity , and for the manner of it , consuming & wasting poor Peoples provision by their very dogs , and sparing no more these who conformed than others who did not conform at all , and punishing husbands for their wives , yea doubling & tripling the same exactions after payment . Next , though at first they did not imprison any for simple absenting themselves from the Curats , yet they began to fill Prisons with such as at any time shewed more than ordinary zeal against the Curats Intrusion , and testified their dissatisfaction to his face ; for which , some were imprisoned , scourged , stigmatized , and thereafter carried to Barbadoes . Others , because they would not give the Prelats their Title of Lords , when conveened before them were also scourged : And one Minister seised for Preaching , and offending the Prelates by the same fault , was carried first to the Thieves hole , laid in irons in company with a Madman , and then banished to Shetland , the coldest & wildest of all the Scots Islands . 3. But when fining would not do , and still the People were more averse from the Curats , by getting some times occasions of hearing their oun Ministers in private : Hence were houses forced & searched , many hailed to Prisons , and several necessitate to escape at windowes with the hazard of their lives ; spies sent unto & set in suspected places , to seize & fall upon such as they found at such Meetings , or but suspected to have been there . Whence it came to pass , that many both men & women , young & old , have been dragged to Prisons , & there closs keeped as Malefactors , besides several other outragious & illegal Acts of violence & oppression committed against them , contrare to all Law , Equity , & Conscience . 4. After Pentland defeat , they ruled by rage more than either Law or Reason . There 40. Prisoners who were taken upon quarter , and solemn Parol to have their life spared , yet treacherously & bloodily were all hanged ( except 5. that were reprieved ) who had much of the Lords presence at their deaths , and assurance of His love , strengthening them to seal a Noble Testimony . One of them a much honoured young Minister , only for having a sword about him though not present at the fight , did first most patiently endure the cruel Torture of the Boots ( a Cruel Engine of Iron , whereby with wedges the Leg is tortured until the marrow come out of the bone ) and afterwards death , with great Courage & Constancy . Upon the Scaffold , at their execution , they then began that barbarity never practised in Scotland before , but frequently & al most alwayes at all the executions since , to beat Drums that they might not be heard . After this Conflict , many were forefaulted of their Estates , and intercommuned , with inhibition to all to reset , conceal , or correspond with any that had escaped , under the pain of being accounted guilty of the same Rebellion , as they called it . Souldiers are permitted to take free quarter in the Country , and Licensed to all the abuses that either Rapine or Cruelty may suggest ; to examine men by tortures , threatnening to kill or rost alive , all that would not delate all they knew was accessory to that Rising ; To strip them who did so much as resett the fugitives , & thrust them into Prisons in cold , hunger & nakedness , and croud them so with numbers , that they could scarce stand together , having the miseries of their oun excrements superadded ; yea to m●rther without process such as would not , nay could not , discover those persecuted People . But not only time but heart & tongue would fail , to relate all the Violences & Insolencies , the stobbings , woundings , stripping & impriso●ings of menspersons , violent breaking of their houses both by day & night , beatings of Wives & Children , ravishings of women , forcings of them by fire Matches & other tortures , to discover their husbands & nearest relations , although not within the compass of their knowledge , and driving away all their goods that can be carried away , without respect to guilt or innocency , and all the Cruelties ▪ that were exercised without a check by these Ruffians at that time . II. After all these tender Mercies & Clemencies or Cruelties , which his Gracious Maj. was pleased to confer or commit upon these poor Contenders for Religion & Liberty ; he and his Cabal the Council , thought it not enough to suppress them with Oppressions and force , distrusting the Authority of his Law ( that he knew the People would no more observe , than he would observe a promise or Oath ) and diffiding also the Authority of his sword , which he had above their heads ; he proposes termes of bargaining with them , whereupon he would suffer them to live , and to which he would have them bound to live according to his Prescript : Therefore , besides the old Oaths of Allegiance & Supremacy that were still going among hands , he caused coyn New Ones to keep the Peace , and to live Orderly , meaning to conforme themselves to the Disorders of the times . Whereby , after he had wrought such destruction to their Bodies & Estates , & almost nothing was left them but a bit of a Conscience , he would rob them of that too ; verifying the Constant Character of the wicked , They only consult to cast a man doun from his excellency : What is a mans excellency but a good Conscience ? But these men , having feared Consciences of their oun not capable of any impression , they presume to impose upon all others , and cannot endure so much as to hear of the Name of Conscience in the Country , except it be when it is baffled in the belchings of beastly mouths . As one , that was well acquaint with he Councils humor in this point , told a Gentleman that was going before them . To have one of these Oaths imposed upon him , who was before hand signifying his Scruples that he could not do such things in Conscience ; Conscience ( said he ) I beseech yow whatever yow do , speak nothing of Conscience before the Lords , far they cannot abide to hear that word . Therefore it is , that since this last Revolution there have been more Conscience-debauching & ensnaring Oaths invented & imposed , and some repugnant & contradictory to others , than ever was in any Nation in the World in so short a time . And hereby they have had woful success in their designes , involving the generality of the Land in the sin of Perjurie & false swearing with themselves . And it hath been observed , that scarcely have they let on year pass without imposing some Oaths or Bonds upon Presbyterians ; Such alwayes as are unlawful to take , yea & impossible to keep , sometimes more obviously gross , some times more seemingly smooth , sometimes tendered more generally through the Kingdom , sometimes imposed upon particular Shires ; And these carried on sometimes by Craft & Cunning , sometimes by Force & Cruelty . Doubtless it is not the least part of their design , hereby to make Oaths & Bonds become a trivial & common thing , & by making all men of as Capacious Consciences as themselves . 2. Further they never ceased to express their fear of another Rising ( their guilty Consciences dictating that they deserved greater opposition ) Hence , to secure themselves and incapacitate the People from further Attempts of that nature , they order all Withdrawers from Churches , all who did not joyne to suppress the Lords People , to deliver up their Armes betuixt & such a day , and not keep a horse above such a very mean price , unfit for service . 3. When force could not do the business then they try flatteries ; and hence Contrive that wicked Indulgence to divide & distroy the Ministers that remained , and to suppress Meetings . But when this bait so well busked could not catch all , but still there were Meetings for administring the Ordinances ; their flatterie turns to fury , and the Acceptance of that Indulgence by some , and despising of it by others , did both animate & instigate them unto a following forth of their design , by all the Cruel Acts & bloody executions . And hereby the residue of the Faithful of the Land were exposed unto their rage , while the Indulged became Interpretatively guilt of , & accessorie to all the Cruelties used & executed upon Ministers & Professors , for adhering unto that way . Hence it was common at private & peaceable Meetings when , without Armes of defence , they were disturbed by Souldiers , & exposed to all manner of villanous violence , some being dragged to Prisons , some banished & sold to French Captains to be transported with Rascals , many intercommuned & driven from their Dwellings & Relations , Great summes of money were proferred to any that would bring in severa● of the most eminent Ministers , either dead or alive ; yea several at several times were killed , and others cruelly handled : All which for several years they patiently endured without Resistence . But especially , when not only they were driven to the fields to keep their Meetings in all weathers , Summer & Winter , but necessitate to meet with Armes , then they raised more Troups of horse & Dragoons to pursue them with all rage , as Traitors & Rebels . Hence what pursuings , hornings , huntings , hidings , wanderings through Mountains & Moors , and all Kinds of Afflictions , the People of God then met with , because of their following that necessary & signally blessed Duty ; All the Lands Inhabitants know , the Jaylors can witness to this day , and the barbarous Souldiers , bloody Executioners of the Commands of their enraged Masters , having orders to wound & kill and apprehend all they could take at these Meetings , or on the way suspected to be going to or coming from them , having encouragment to apprehend some Ministers , and bring them dead or alive , by the promise of two thousand Merks , others valued at one thousand , and several Professors also with prices put upon their heads . Hence others that were taken of them were sent into the Bass , a Dry & Cold Rock in the Sea , where they had no fresh water , nor any provision but what they had brought many miles from the Country , and when they got it , it would not keep unspoiled . And others , both Ministers and many hundreds of Professors , were outlawed ; whereby all the Subjects were prohibited to reset , supply , intercommune with any of them , or to correspond with them by word writ , or message , or furnish them with meat , drink , house , harbour , victual , or any other thing useful under the highest pains . Hence also Prisons were filled : And the Wives & Children of the Outed Ministers , that were come to Edinburgh for shelter , were commanded to dislodge , within a short day prefixed , under the pain of being forcibly shut up or dragged out . For which and other such uses , to apprehend & seise on Meetings , a Major was appointed in Edinburgh , with command over the toun Guards , and a good Salarie for that end . Then Prisons being filled , they were emptied to make room for others in Ships , to be taken away to be sold for Slaves , in one of which were sent to Virginia above 60 men , some Ministers ; who , through the kindness & Sympathie of some English Godly People , were relieved at London . A greater Barbarity not to be fonnd , in the Reigns of Caligul● or Nero. 4. But all this is nothing to what followed : when , thinking these blood-hounds were too favourable , they brought doun from the Wild Highlands a host of Savages upon the western Shires , more terrible than Turks or Turtars , men who feared not God nor regarded man ; And being also poor pitiful Skybalds , they thought they had come to a brave world , to waste & destroy a plentiful Country , which they resolved before they left it to make as bare as their oun . This hellish Crue was adduced to work a Reformation , Like the French Conversions , to press a Band of Conformity , wherein every Subscriber was bound for himself & all under him , wife , Children , Servants , Tenants , to frequent their Paroch-Churches , and never to go to these Meetings , nor reset nor intertain any that went , but to informe against , pursue , & deliver up all vagrant Preachers as they called them , to t●yal & Judgement . Which they prosecuted with that rigor & restless boundless rage , that the Children then unborn and their pitiful Mothers do lament the memory , of that day , for the loss of their fathers & husbands . Many ho●ses & families then were left desolate in a winter flight , many lost their Cattel & Horses , and some in seeking to recover them lost their lives , by the Sword of these Burrio's . So that it was too evident , both by what orders was given , the severitie of prosecuting , and the expressions of some great ones since , that nothing less than the utter ruin and desolation of these Shires was consulted and concluded , and that expedition at that time calculated for that end ; for what else can be imagined could induce to the raising 10 , or 11000 barbarous Savages the joyning them to the standing forces , and with such cruel orders the directing them all to the West ; where there was not one person moving the finger against them ; neither could they pretend any quarrel , If it was not the faithfulness of the People there in their Covenanted Religion , and their hoplessness of complying to their Popish and Tyrannical designs , and therefore no course so feasible as to destroy them ; So for dispatching thereof , order is given forth that whosoever refuseth to subscribe that Hell-hatched bond , must instantly have 10 , 20 , 30 , 40 , moe or fewer according to his condition as he is poorer or richer , of these new Reformers sent to him , to ly not only upon free Quarters to eat up and destroy what they pleased , but also ( for the more speedy expedition ) ordered to take a six pence for each common Souldier a day , and the Officers more , according to their degrees , and so to remain till either the bond was subscribed , or all destroyed ; Nor was these Trusties deficient to further their purposes in prosecuting their orders , Who coming to their Quarters used ordinarly to produce a Billgate for near to as many more as came , and for these absents they must have double money , because their Landlord was not burthened with their maintenance , and where that was refused would take the readiest goods , and if any thing remained not destroyed and plundered at their removeing , which was not transportible , rather then the owner should get any good of it , they would in some places set fire to it , as they did with the Corn-stacks . It would require several great volumes to record the many instances of horrid Barbarities , Bloods , and Villanies of that wicked expedition , so that what by free Quarterings , Exactions , Robberies , Thifts , Plunderings and other acts of Violence & Crueltie , many places was ruined almost to desolation , all which the faithful choosed rather to suffer , than to sin in complying : and albeit their oppression was exceeding lamentable , and their loss great , yet that of the complyers was greater and sader who lossed a good Conscience in yielding to them , and compounding with them . 5 Then the Country behoved to pay the Souldiers for all this Service , and hire them to do more , by paying the imposed Cess ; whereby they were sharpened into a greater keenness in Cruel executions of their Orders , returning to those places of the Country whether they had chased the Persecuted People , who still kept their Meetings where-ever they were , though they could not attend them but upon the hazard of being killed , either in the place ( where some had their blood mingled with their sacrifice ) or fleeing , or be exposed to their dreadful Cruelties more bitter than death . For then it was counted a greater Crime , and punished with greater severity , for Persons to hear a faithful Minister Preach , than to commit Murder , Incest , Adulterie , or to be guiltie of Witchcraft , or Idolatrie , or the grossest abominations : for these have past unpunished , when some for their simple presence at a Meeting , have been executed unto the death . Then also , when some were forced to flee into the English border for shelter , there also were Parties ordered to pursue those poor hunted Partridges , who could not find a hole to hide their head in . There we lost a valiant Champion for Truth , and truly zealous Contender for the Interest of Christ , that universally accomplished Gentleman & Christian , Tho. Ker of Heyhope , who was cruelly murthered in a rancounter with a Party of the English side . Thereafter followed that Lamentable stroke at Bothuel , where about 300 were killed on the field , and about 10. or 1100 taken Prisoners , and stript , & brought into Edinburgh in a merciless manner . After which , first two faithful & painful Ministers & Witnesses of Christ , Mr Iohn Kid & Mr Iohn King , received the Croun of Martyrdom , sealling that Testimony with their blood , and many others after them for the same Cause . Then the Enemy , after the manner used before , first to wound our head and then put on a hood upon it ( as they have done alwayes after a Mischief , and intending a greater ) offered their Bond of peace , on termes that clearly condemned the Cause , never to rise in armes against the King &c. by which bond , many of the Prisoners , after they had lyen several weeks in a Church-yard , without the shadow of a house to cover them night & day , were Liberate : And many of the rest , by the persuasion of some Ministers , at whose door their blood lied as well as at the Enemies , took that bond ; and yet were sent away with others that did not take it , in a Ship bound for America between , 2. and 300. in all , who were all murdered in the Ship , being shut up under the hatches , when it split upon a rock in the North of Scotland , except about 50 persons ; whereof many to this day are Living Witnesses of such a Cruelty . III. Hitherto only the Common Rules & Rudiments of the Art of Persecution were put in practice , exactly quadrating with the Rules of Adam 〈◊〉 the 〈◊〉 for introducing of Poperie , in his Polit. Lib. 2. Cap. ●8 . which are , ( 1 ) To proceed as Musicians do , in tuning the●● Instruments gradually . ( 2 ) To press the examples of some eminent men to draw on the rest . ( 3 ) To banish all Arch Hereticks at once ( that is the most zealous Witnesses of Christ ) or at least with all expedition by degrees . ( 4 ) To put them out of all power & trust , and put in friends to the Catholick Interest . ( 5 ) To load the Protestant Opinions , as are most obnoxious , with all odious Constructions . ( 6 ) To discharge all Private Conventieles ▪ ( 7 ) To 〈◊〉 & execute rigorous Lawes against the most dangerous . ( 8 ) To foment all quarrels among Prote●●●●ts , and strengthen the Party that is ready to comply . 〈…〉 , and many other of a deeper Projection & greater ●erfection , were fallen upon afterwards , equalling● the most mischievous Machins of Spanish Inquisition ; 〈◊〉 the Methods that effectuated the desolation of the Church of 〈◊〉 , that were exactly followed , as they are related in Clarks Martyrology . Especially the last of Cantzens Rules was industriously observed , in the Device of the Indulgences both before & after Bothwel ; which contributed more to the rending & ruining the Remnant , 〈◊〉 expose the Faithful to rage & cruelty , than any thing for when by these ensnaring favours many were drawn away from their duty , the rest that maintained it , and kept 〈◊〉 the Testimony ; were both the more easily preyed upon ; and more cruelly insulted over . Hence the few Field-Meetings that were kept , were more fiercely pursued after Bothwel than the many before , and more cruel Lawes were made against them , and more bloody executions , than I can find words to express in short . But in a word , no Party of T●rtars invading the Land , or Crue of Cutthroats destroying the Inhabitants , or the most Capital Malefactors , could have been more violently opposed , or more vigorously sought to be suppressed , than these poor Meeters were . But I must make some more special hints . 1. They not only raised more forces to exhaust the strength & substance of the already wasted Country , and laid on & continued from one terme to another that wicked exaction & cruel oppression of the Cess , for the same declared ends of suppressing & banishing what remained of the Gospel , and imposed Localities for maintaining the Souldiers imployed in those designs ; for refusing which many families were pillaged , plundered , & quite impoverished , besides the heating & abusing them : But also they went on unweariedly with their Courts of Inquisition , pressing the Bonds of peace , and dragging them like dogs to Prisons that would not subscribe them , And for taking up in their Porteous Rolls the names of all that were suspect to have been at 〈◊〉 In●urection ; which they gathered by the Informations of ●●●cophants , and reputed them convict if being 〈◊〉 they did not appear , and forced others to swear 〈◊〉 , and delate upon Oath whom they did either ●ee or heard that they were in armes , or went to Meetings . And such as refused suffered bonds or banishment . Yea , having made it Criminal to reset , harbour , corrospond or converse with these whom they declared Rebels , they thereupon imprisoned , fined , & ruined vast numbers , 〈◊〉 having seen or spoken with some of them , or because they did not discover or apprehend them when they 〈◊〉 they might , and even when they were not obliged and could not know whether they were ob●o●ious persons or not : for which many Gentlemen & others were Indy●ed & imprisoned , and so●e arraigned & condemned to death . For these Causes , the Country 〈◊〉 harrassed & destroyed by four extraordinary Circuit 〈◊〉 successively going about with their numerous train●● whereby many were grievously oppressed , and with their oppressions tempted with many Impositions of Conscience debauching Oaths , & Bonds to compear when called , and to keep the Church , and to refrain from going to Meetings &c. and by these tentations involved in Complyances and Defections . 2. To enrich themselves by these means with the spoyl of the Country did not satisfie these Destroyers ; but they must glut themselves with the blood of the Saints , upon every pretext that they could catch , under any colour of Law. As upon the account of Bothwel Insurrection , many were cruelly executed to the death , some Gentlemen , and some Common Country men , without any Legal Conviction , by packing bloody Juries & Assises most partially for their Murdering ends , besides more than can be reckoned that were kept to perish in their imprisonments . And not only for being actually in armes , or any overt act of transgressing their wicked Lawes , but even for their extorted opinion of things , or because they could not condemn these necessitated Risings in armes to be Rebellion and a sin against God , which they were forced to declare by terrible menacings of death & torture , they have been condemned to death ; making their arbitrary Lawes to reach the heart , thoughts , & inward sentiments of the mind , as well as outward actions . Whereupon this became a Criminal question robbing many of their Lives , Was the rising at Bothwel-bridge Rebellion and a sin against God ? And this another , Was the killing of the Bishop of St Andrewes horrid Murther ? which if any answered negatively , or did not answer affirmatively , they were cruelly condemned to death : for which first five innocent Christians were execute upon the spot , where that Murtherer fell . Tho they declared , and it was known , they were as free as the Child unborn , and that some of them had never seen a Bishop that they knew from another man , and were never in that place of the Country where he was killed . And afterwards this was the constant question that all brought before them were troubled with , which some avouching to be duty were dismembered alive , their hands struck off , and then hanged , and their heads cut off when dead . 3. After Sanquhair Declaration , they observed the Jesuites rules more exactly , especially that mentioned above to load the Opinions as are most obnoxious with all odious Constructions , and to make it both Criminal to declare them , and also Criminal to conceal & wave their intrapping questions thereupon . For after Mr Hal● was killed at the Queensferrie , and Mr Cameron with several worthies were slain at Airsmoss , and after Mr Hackstoun for declining the Authority of his Murderers , head and tail , and for being accessory to executing Judgement upon the Arch-traitor or Arch-Bishop of St Andrewes ( thô he laid not his hands on him himself , nor was present at the action , but at a distance when it was done ) was tortured alive , with the cuting off of his hands , and then hanged , and before he was dead ripped up , his heart taken out , carried about on the point of a knife and throun into a fire , and afterwards his body quartered . Then , not only such as were with that litle handful at Airsmoss were cruelly murdered , but others against whom they could charge no matter of fact , were questioned if they ouned the Kings Authority ? which if any did not Answer affirmatively & positively , he was to look for nothing but exquisite torments by terrible kinds of tortures , & death besides . And if any declared their judgement , that they could not in Conscience oune such Authority as was then exercised ; or if they declined to give their thoughts of it , as judging thoughts to be under no humane jurisdiction ; or if they answered with such innocent specifications as these , that they ouned all Authority in the Lord , or for the Lord , or according to the Word of God , or all just & Lawful Authority , these under-went & suffered the Capital punishment of Treason . And yet both for declining & declaring their extorted Answers about this , they were condemned as unsufferable Maintainers of Principles inconsistent with Government . 4. But here , as in Egypt , the more they were afflicted the more they grew , the more that the Enem●es rage was increased the more were the People inflamed to inquire about the Grounds of their Suffering , seeing rational men and Religious Christians die so resolutely upon them ; And the more they insisted in this Inquisition , the more did the number of Witnesses multiply , with a growing increase undauntedness , so that the then shed blood of the Martyrs became the seed of the Church , and as by hearing & seeing them so signally countenanced of the Lord many were reclaimed from their Courses of Complyance , so others were daylie more & more , confirmed in the wayes of the Lord , and so strengthened by His Grace that they choose rather to endure all Torture , and embrace death in its most terrible aspect , than to give the Tyrant & his Complices any acknowledgment : yea not so much as to say , God save the King , which was offered as the price of their life , and Test of their acknowledgment , but they would not accept Deliverance on these termes , that they might obtain a better Resurrection . Which so enraged the Tygrish Truculency of these Persecuters , that they spared neither age , sexe , nor Profession : the tenderness of youth did not move them to any relenting , in murdering very boyes upon this head , nor the gray hairs of the aged ; neither were women spared , but some were hanged , some drouned , tied to Stakes within the Sea-mark , to be devoured gradually with the growing waves , and some of them of a very young , some of an old age . Especially after the murder of the never to be forgotten Martyr , Mr Cargil , the multitude of merciless Sufferings upon this account cannot be enumerated ; which encreased far beyond all the former steps , after the Lanerk Declaration , which was burnt with great Solemnity by the Magistrats of Edinburgh in their robes , together with the Solemn League & Covenant , which had been burnt before , but then they would more declaredly give new demonstrastrations of their rage against it , because they confessed and were convinced of its being conforme unto & founded upon that Covenant . And because the Incorporation of Lanerk did not , because they could not , hinder the publishing of it , therefore they were threatened with the loss of their Priviledges and forced to pay 6000 Merks . Upon the back of which , the Sufferings of poor People that ouned the Testimony were sadder & sharper , and further extended than ever : Some being banished for Souldiers to Flanders , &c. some to be sold as Slaves in Carolina , and other Places in America , to empty the filled Prisons and make room for more ● which were daylie brought in from all quarters , and either kept languishing in their ●asty Prisons , or Thiefes holes , in bolts & irons to make them weary of their life , or dispatched as Sacrifices and led as dumb Sheep to the slaughter , without suffering them to speak their dying words , for beating of Drums , or disposed of to Masters of Ships to be transported in Slaverie . 5. Had they satisfied themselves with murdering them out of hand , it would have been more tolerable , and reckoned some degree of mercy , in comparison of their malice ; which , after all their endeavours to murder their Souls , by ensnaring Offers , enslaving Bonds , blasphemous & contradictory Oaths , and multiplying captious Questions to catch the Conscience , or at least vexe the Spirits of the Righteous , whom they could not prevail with to put forth their hands into iniquity , did proceed to invent all exquisite torments more terrible than death . Some at their first apprehending were tortured with Fire-matches , burning and for ever thereafter disabling their hands : Then laid fast & locked up in great Irons upon their legs , where they lay many Moneths in the cold of winter , without any relaxation . Some were tortured with the Boots , squeezing out the marrow of their legs : Others with Thumbkins , piercing & bruising the bones of their thumbs : And some tormented with both one after another , and besides kept waking nine nights together by watchful Souldiers . who were sworn not to let the afflicted person sleep all that time . 6. All this Tyranny had been the more tolerable , if they had kept within any bounds of colourable or pretended shadow of legality , or in any consonancy to their oun wicked Lawes , or exemplars of any former Persecutions . But in an ambition to outdo all the Nero's , Domitians , Dioclesians , Duke d' Alva's , or Lewis de Grands , they scorned all formes as wel as Justice of Law , and set up monstrous Monuments of unprecedented illegalitie & inhumanitie . For when , after all their hornings , harrass●ngs , huntings , searchings , chasings , catchings , imprisonments , torturings , banishments , and effusions of blood , yet they could not get the Meetings crushed , either in publick or private , nor the zeal of the poor Wanderers quenched , with whom they had interdicted all harbour , supply , comfort , refreshment , converse or corrospondence , and whom they had driven out of their oun & all other habitations , in Touns , Villages , or Cottages , to the Deserts , Mountains , Moors , & Mosses , in whose hags & holes they were forced to make Dens & Caves to hide themselves , but that they would still meet for the Worship of God , either in Publick ( though mostly in the cold winter nights ) or in their Private fellowships for Prayer & Conference ; and to rescue their Brethren , and prevent their Murder in these extremities , would surprize and take advantages of the Souldiers now & then : They then raged beyond all bounds , and not only apprehending many innocent persons ( against whom they had nothing to accuse them of , but because they could not satisfie them in their Answers ) sentenced , and executed them , all in one day , and made an Act to do so with all ; but allowed the bloody Souldiers to murder them , without either Tryal or Sentence . Especially after the Apologetical Declaration , affixed on the Church-doors , they acted with an unheard of Arbitrariness . For not only did they frame an Oath of Abjuration , renouncing the same ; but pressed it universally upon pain of death , upon all men & women in City & Country , and went from house to house forcing young & old to give their judgement of that Declaration , and of the Kings Authority &c. to ridicule and reproach and make a Ludibrum of all Government : yea impowered Souldiers , & common Varlets , to impannel Juries , condemn & cause to be put to death innocent Recusants , and having stopt all Travel & Commerce without a Pass , signifying they had taken that Oath , they gave power to all Hostlers & Inn-keepers to impose Oaths , upon all Passengers , Travellers , Gentlemen or Countrymen , who were to swear that their Pass was not forged . And Prisoners that would not take the Oath , were according to the foresaid Act condemned , sentenced , & execute , all in one day , and early in the morning , that the People might not be affected with the Spectacles of their bloody Severities . Yea Spectators also , that gathered to see the execution , were imposed upon , and commanded to give their judgement , whether these men were justly put to death or not . And not only so , but after that , they gave Orders & Commands to to the Souldiers to pursue the chase after these Wanderers more violently , and shoot or other wise put them to death wherever they could apprehend them : Whereby many were taken & instantly most inhumanely murdered . IV. In the begining of this killing time , as the Country calls it ; the first Author & Authorizer of all these Mischiefs , Charles II. was removed by death . Then one would have thought , the Severity would have stopped : And the Duke of York succeding , in his late Proclamation would make the world beleeve , that it never was his principle , nor will he ever suffer violence to be offered to any mans Conscience , nor use force or invincible necessity against any man on the account of his persuasion ; Smooth words , to cover the mischiefs of his former Destructions , and the wickedness of his future designs . To which , his former celebrated saying , that it would never be well till all the south-syd of Forth were made a hunting-field , and his acts & actings designed to ve●ify it , since his unhappy succession , do give the lie . For immediatly upon his mounting the Throne , the executions and Acts prosecuting the Persecution of the poor Wanderers , were more Cruel than ever . 1. There were more butchered & slaughtered in the fields , without all shadow of Law , or Trial , or Sentence , than in all the former Tyrants reign ; who were murdered without time given to deliberate upon death , or space to conclude their Prayers , but either in the instant when they were Praying shooting them to death , or surprizing them in their Caves , and murdering them there , without any grant of Prayer at all ; Yea many of them murdered without taking notice of any thing to be laid against them , according to the worst of their oun Lawes , but slain & cut off without any pity , when they were found at their labour in the field , or travelling upon the road . And such as were Prisoners were condemned for ●e●using to take the Oath of Abjuration , and to oune the Authority , and surprized with their execution , not knowing certainly the time when it should be , yea leff in suspense whether it should be or not , as if it had been on design to destroy both their Souls & Bodies . Yea Queens●errie had the impudence to express his desire of it , when some went to sollicite him , being then Commissioner , for a Reprieval in favours of some of them , he told them , they should not have time to prepare for Heaven , hell was too good for them . 2. There have been more banished to forreign Plantations in this mans time , than in the others . Within these two years , several shipfulls of honest & Consciencious Sufferers have been sent to Iamacia ( to which before they were sent , some had their ears cutt ) New Ieresey , & Barbadoes , in such Crouds & Numbers , that many have died in transportation ; as many also died before in their pinching Prisons , so thronged that they had neither room to lye nor sit . Particularly the Barbarous usage of a great multitude of them that were sent to Denotter Castle , when there was no room for them in Edinburgh , is never to be forgotten ; which the wildest & rudest of Savages would have thought shame of . They were all that long way made to travel on foot , men & women , and some of both sexes , very infirme & decrepite through age , and several sick , guarded by bonds of Souldiers , And then put in to an old ruinous & rusty house , and shut up under vauts above 80 in a room , men & women , without air , without ease , without place , either to lie , or walk , & without any Comfort save what they had from Heaven , & so straitened for want of refreshment which they could not have but at exorbitant prices inconsistent with their poor empty purses , and so suffocated with the smell of the place , and of their oun excrements , that as several of them died , so it was a wonder of Mercy that any of them could outlive that Miserie : Yet there they remained some moneths , at a distance from all their friends , being sent thither to that Northern Corner out of the South & West borders of the Country ; and some out of London . Whose transportation hither , if it were not a part of this Tragical Story , would seem a merry & ridiculous passage to Strangers discovering the ridiculous folly as well as the outragious fury of their Persecuters . For at a Private Meeting in London , among others some Scotchmen , of very mean figure , some Taylors , a Shoemaker , a Chap man &c. were taken , & being found to be Scotchmen , were not only examined at the Common Courts there but by Sir Andrew Foster , by express Commission from the late King a litle before his death ; who threatened them under a strange sort of Certification ( considering what fell out immediately thereafter ) that assuredly they should be sent to Scotland very shortly , if there were not a Revolution of the Government . But this Revolution following within a few dayes retarded it a litle : yet not long thereafter they were sent in a Yacht , with a Guard of Souldiers , and a Charge of high Treason . But when brought before the Council of Scotland , the amount of all that ●ussle with them was , a Question posed to them under pain of death , whether the King should be King or no ? that is , wheither they ouned his Authority or not . Yet thô some of the poor men did oune it , they were sent to Denotter Castle : And thence among the rest banished & transported to New Iersey ; in which passage , by reason of their Croud & bad provision , the most part in the ship were cast into a fever , and upwards of 60 died yea even since the former Proclamation for this pretended Liberty , there are 21. men and 5. women sent to Barbadoes against whom nothing could be a●ledged but matters of meer Religion & Conscience : which , as it Proclaims the Notoriousness of these impudent lies wherewith the Proclamations for this Liberty are stuffed ; So it puts an indeleble brand of infamy upon some L●ndon Merchants , that are said to pretend to some profession of Religion , who sent the ship to transport them , thereby to make gain of the merchandise of the Lords Captives . 3. There have been more Cruel Acts of Parliament enacted in this Tyrants time , than the former made all his reign . For in his first Parliament held by Queensberrie Commissioner , not only was there an Act for making it Treason to refuse the Oath of Abjuration , confirming all the illegalities of their Procedure hereupon before ; but an Act making it Criminal to oune the Covenant , and another Act making it Criminal for any to be present at a Field Meeting , which was only so to Preachers before . Yet neither these Acts , and all the executions following upon them , have daunted , nor I hope shall drive them , nor the Indemnity and Toleration ( so generally now applauded ) draw them from the Duty of ouning both these , that are so much the more Publickly to be avouched , that they are so openly interdicted by wicked & blasphemous Tranny , though for the same they expect from the Scotish Inquisition all the murdering violence , that hell & Rome and Malignant rage can exert . But to conclude this Tragical Deduction : As these hints we have heaped together of the Kinds & several sorts ( the Particulars being impossible to be reckoned ) of barbarities and arbitrary Methods , used in carrying on this Persecution , demonstrating the reign or rather rage of these two Dominators , under which we have houled these 27 , years , to be a Complete & habitual Tyranny , do discover the inhumanity & illegality of their Proceedings , having no other Precedent save that of the French Conversions , or Spanish Inquisition , out done by many stages in respect of Illegality by the Scotish Inquisition , and the Practices of the Council of Scotland , and Iusticiary Court ; So I shall shut up all in a summarie Relation , of the Common Practicks & formes of Procedure in these Courts : which will be useful to understand a litle more distinctly , to the end the Innocency of Sufferers may more clearly appear . 1. They can accuse whom they will , of what they please ; And if by summar Citation , he will not , may be because he cannot , compear , if once his Name be in their Porteous rolls , that is sufficient to render him convict . 2. They used also to seize some , and shut them up in Prison year & day , without any signification of the cause of their imprisonment . 3. They can pick any man off the Street , and if he do not answer their Captious Questions , proceed against him to the utmost of severity ; as they have taken some among the Croud at Executions , & imposed upon them the Questions . 4. They can also go through all the houses of the City , as well as the Prisons , and examine all families upon the Questions of the Councils Catechisme , upon the hazard of their life ; if they do not answer to their satisfaction , as hath been done in Edinburgh . 5. When any are brought in by Seisure , sometimes ( as is said before ) they let them lie long without any hearing , if they expect they cannot reach them : But if they think they can win at them any way , then they hurry them in such hast , that they have no time to deliberate upon , and oftentimes have no knowledg● or conjecture of , the matter of their Prosecution . Yea if they be never so insignificant , they will take Diversion from their weightiest affairs , to examine & take Cognizance of poor Things , if they understand they dare vent or avow any respect to the Cause of Christ : And the silliest body will not escape their Catechization , about affairs of State , what they think of the Authority &c. 6. If they be kept in Prison any space , they take all wayes to pump and discover what can be brought in against them : Yea sometimes they have exactly observed that Device of the Spanish Inquisition , in suborning & sending Flies among them , under the disguise & shew of Prisoners , to search & find out their minds , who will outstrip all in an Hypocritical zeal , thereby to extort & draw forth words from the most wary , which may be brought in judgement against them the next day . 7. When Prisoners are brought in before them , they have neither Lybel nor Accuser , but must answer super inquirendis , to all Questions they are pleased to ask . 8. If at any time they forme a sort of Lybel , they will not restrict themselves to the Charges thereof , but examine the person about other things altogether extraneous to the Lybel . 9. They have frequently suborned Witnesses ; and have sustained them as Witnesses , who either were sent out by themselves as Spies & Inte●ligencers , or who palpably were known to delate those against whom they witnessed out of a pick & prejudice , and yet would not su●●er them to be cast for partial Counsel . 10. If they suppose a man to be wary & circumspect , and more prudent than forward in the Testimony ; then they multiply questions , and at first many impertinent Interrogations , having no Connexion with the Cause , to try his humour & freedom , that they may know how to deal with him ; And renew & reiterate several Criminal examinations , that they may know whereof , and find matter wherein , to indyte him by endeavouring to confound , or intrap , or involve him in Confessions , or Contradictions , by wresting his words . 11. They will admit no time for advice , nor any Lawful defence for a delay , but will have them to answer presently , except they have some hopes of their Complyance , and find them begining to stagger & succumb in the Testimony ; in that case , when a man seeks time to advise , they are animated to a keenness to impose , and encouraged to an expectation of Catching by their snares , which then they contrive & prepare with greater cunning . 12. If a man should answer all their questions , and clear himself of all things they can alledge against him yet they used to impose some of the Oaths , that they concluded he would not take ; and according to the measure of the tenderness they discovered in any man , so they apportioned the Oaths to trap them , to the Stricter the smoother Oaths , to the Laxer the more odious , that all natural Consciences did scar at . 13. They will not only have their Lawes obeyed , but subscribed ; And they reckon not their Subjects obedience secured by the Law-makers sanction , but the Peoples hand-writing ; And think it not sufficient that People transgress no Lawes , but they must also oune the justice of them , and the Authority that enacts them , and swear to maintain it : And yet when some have done all this , and cleared themselves by all Complyances , they will not discharge them , but under a bond to answer again when called . 14. They will have their Lawes to reach not only actions but thoughts , and therefore they require , what People think of the Bishops death , and of Bothwel Insurection ; And whether they oune the Authority , when they can neither prove their disouning of it , nor any way offending it . 15. They will have men to declare their thoughts , and hold them convict if they do not answer Positively all their Captious questions ; And if they will not tell what they think of this or that , then they must go as guilty . 16. If they insist in waving , and will not give Categorical Answers , then they can extort all and prove what they please by torture : And when they have extorted their thoughts of things , thô they be innocent as to all actions their Law can charge them with , then they used to hang them when they had done . 17. They have wheedled men sometimes into Confession either of Practices or Principles , by promising to favour their ingenuity , and upbraiding them for dissemblers if they would not , and by mock-expostulations , why were they ashamed to give a Testimony ? And then make them sign their Confessions at the Council , to bring them in as a witness against them at the Criminal Court. 18. Yea not only extrajudicial Confession will sustain in their Law , but when they have given the Publick faith , the Kings security , the Act & Oath of Council , that their Confesion shall not militate against them , they have brought it in as witness against them , and given it upon Oath , when their former Oath & Act was produced in open Court , in demonstration of their perjurie . 19. When the matter comes to an Assize or Cognizance of a Iurie , they use to pack them for their purpose , and pick out such as are listed , who they think will not be bloody enough . 20. Sometimes when the Jurie hath brought their verdict in favours of the Pannal , they have made them sit doun , & resume the Cognition of the Case again , and threatened them with an Assize of errour if they did not ●ring him in guilty . 21. Yea most frequently the Kings Advocate used to Command them to Condemn and bring in the Pannal Guilty , under most peremptory Certification ; of punishment if they should not ; so that they needed ●o Juries but only for the fashion . 22. Sometimes they have sentenced innocent persons twice , once to have their ears cut and be banished , and after the lopping of their ears , some have been re-examined and Sentenced to death , and execute . 23. They have Sentenced some and hanged them both in one day ; Others early in the morning , both to surprize the persons that were to die , and to prevent Spectators of the sight of their Cruelty ; Others have been kept in suspense , till the very day & hour of their execution . 24. Not only have they murdered serious & zealous Followers of Christ , in taking away their Lives , but endeavoured to murder their Names , and to murder the Cause for which they suffered ; loading it with all Reproaches , as Sedition & Rebellion &c. which was their peculiar Policy , to bring the Heads of Sufferings to Points that are most obnoxious to mens Censure , and accounted most extrinsick to Religion , whereby they levelled their-designs against Religion , not directly under that notion , but obliquely in the destruction of its Professors , under the odium & reproach of enemies to Government . 25. But chiefly they labour to murder the Soul , defile the Conscience , and only consult to cast a man doun from his excellency , which is his integrity ; that is a Christians Croun , and that they would rather rob him of as any thing , either by hectoring or flattering him from the Testimony ! which they endeavour by proposing many offers , with many threatenings in subtile termes ; And pretend a great deal of tenderness , protesting they will be as tender of their blood as of their oun Soul ( which in some sense is true , for they have none at all of their oun Souls ) and purging themselves as Pilate did , and charging it upon their oun head . 26. They will be very easie in their Accommodations , where they find the poor man begining to faint , and hearken to their overtures wherein they will grant him his life , yeelding to him as cunning Anglers do with Fishes : And to persuade him to some length in complying , they will offer Conference sometimes or reasoning upon the Point , to satisfie & informe his Conscience , as they pretend , but really to catch him with their busked hook . 27. If they have any hope of prevailing they will change a mans Prison , and take him out from among the more strict & fervent in the Cause , that might sharpen & strenghen his zeal , and put him in among the more cool & remiss . 28. Sometimes they used to stage several together , whereof they knew some would Comply , to Tantalize the rest with the sight of the others Liberty , and make them byte the more eagerly at their bait to catch the Conscience . But when they had done all they could ; Christ had many Witnesses , who did retain the Croun of their Testimony in the smallest Points , till they obtained the Croun of Martyrdom , and attained to the Croun of Glory , Speaking boldly to them without fear or shame , and disdaining their flattering Proposals , but looking on them under a right notion as stated there in opposition to Christ ; whereby they found this Advantage , that hence they were restrained from all sinful tampering with them , or intertaining any discourse with them , but what was suitable to speak to Christs enemies , or doing any thing to save their life but what became Christs Witnesses , who loved not their lives unto the death . Of whom universally this was observed , that to the Admiration of all , the Conviction of many enemies , the Confirmation of many friends , the Establishment of the Cause , and the Glory of their Redeeme● , they went off the stage with so much of the Lords Coun●enance , so much Assurance of Pardon & Eternal Peace , so much hope of the Lords returning to Revive His Work and Plead His Cause again in these Lands , that never any suffered with more meekness , humility , & composure of Spirit , and with more faithfulness , stedfastness , & resolution , than these Worthies did for these despised & reproached Truths : for which their surviving Brethren are now Contending & Suffering , while others are at ease . PART . III. THE PRESENT TESTIMONY Stated and Vindicated in its Principal Heads . BY what is above premitted , the Reader may see the Series & Succession of the Testimony of Christs Witnesses in Scotland from time to time , in all the Periods of that Church ; how it hath been transmitted from one generation to another Doun to our hands ; how far it hath been extended ; and what Increments it hath received in every Period ; how it hath been opposed by a Continued Prosecution of an hereditary War against Christ , by an Atheistical , Papistical , Prelatical , and Tyrannical faction ; and how it hath been concerted , contended for , maintained , & sealed actively & passively , by an Anti-pagan , Anti-Popish , Anti-Prelatical , Anti-Erastian , Anti-Sectarian , and Anti-Tyrannical Remnant of the Followers , Professors , Confessors , & Martyrs of Christ in all Ages . Now it remains in the third & last Place to consider the Merit of the Cause as it is now Stated , to see whether it will bear the weight of those great Sufferings wherewith it hath been sealed . I hope all the Lovers of Christ , who have an estee● . ●ven of His reproaches above all the Treasures of Egypt ; will grant that if these sufferings be Stated on the least or lowest of the Truths of Christs , then they are not Misstated , no● built upon a bottom that will not bear them , or is not of that worth to sustain them . For Certainly every Truth , the least of Truths , is of greater value than any thing that we can suffer the loss of for it , yea of infinitely greater value than the whole world . So that if I prove these Heads of Suffering to be Truths , wherein Conscience is concerned , the Cause will be sufficiently vindicated from the loadings & lashings of such as prefer Peace to Truth . & ease to dutie , who to Justify their oun backwardness & detastable lukwarmness call some of them only State questions about things Civil , and not Gospel-Truths and Heads to State suffering upon : And if they be Truths & Duties , the Cause will some way be rendered more Illustrious , that it is Stated upon the smallest hoofs & hair-breadths of the Concerns of Christs Declarative Glory ; as being a greater witness of its Ouners Love & Loyalty to Christ , and of their pure & tender zeal for His honour , than if for more substantial & fundamental Truths , which a Natural Conscience may reclaim to Decline , when for the meanest Circumstantials of Christs Truths they dare & are ambitious to bestow their dearest blood . But if the Complexe of them be impartially Considered , no unprejudiced Arbiter will suffer himself to have such extenuating Impressions of the present Word of Patience , & Testimony of the suffering Remant in Scotland this day : But it will appear to be a very weighty & worthy Concern , as any that either Men or Christians can be called to Witness for ; being the Priviledge of all mankind , the Duty of all Christians , and the Dignity of all Churches , to assert , It is for the Glory & Croun Prerogatives and Imperial Regalia of the King of Kings , with reference to His visible Kingdom , of which the Government is layd upon His shoulders , against the heaven-daring Usurpations & encroachments made thereupon , both as He is Mediator & King & Head of the Church , and as He is God & Universal King of the world . As He is Mediator , it is His Peculiar Prerogative to have a Supremacy & Sole Soveraignty over His oun Kingdom , to institute His oun Government , to constitute His oun Lawes , to ordain His oun Officers , to appoint His oun Ordinances , which He will have observed without alteration , addition , or diminution untill His Second Coming : This His Prerogative hath been & is invaded by Erastian Prelacy , Sacrilegious Supremacy , and now by Antichristian Poperie , which have overturned His Government , inverted His Lawes , subverted His Officiers , & Perverted His Ordinances . As He is God & Universal King , it is His in communicable Property & Glory , not only to have Absolute & Illimited Power , but to invest his Deputed Ministers of Justice with His Authority & Ordinance of Magistracy , to be administred in subordination to Him , to be regulated by His Lawes , and to be improved for His Glory & the good of Mankind : This Glory of His hath been invaded by Tyrants & Usurpers arrogating to themselves an Absolute Power , intruding themselves without His investment into Authority , in a Rebellion against Him , in opposition to His Lawes , and abusing it to His dishonour , and the destruction of Mankind . Against both which Encroachments the Present Testimony is stated , in a Witness for Religion & Liberty , to both which these are destructive . This will appear to be the Result & Tendency of the Testimony in all its parts , opposed by the Enemies of Religion & Liberty , and the end of all their oppositions , to bring it to this Crinomenon , who shall he King ? Iesus or Cesar ? Let any seriously search into all their Proclamations & Edicts against Religion & Liberty , this will be found to be the soul & sense of them , practically & Really speaking to this purpose , especially since this man came to the Throne . J. R. JAmes the 7 / 2 by the V. of G. King of Scotland , England , France , & Ireland , Defender of the Antichristian faith : To'all & sundry our good subjects , whom these presents do or many concern , Greeting . We having taken into our Royal Considerati●n , the many & great inconveniences which have happened in that our Ancient Kingdom of Scotland , especially of late years , through the persuasions of the Christian Religion , & the great heats & animosities , betuixt the Professors therof , and our good & faithful subjects , whose faith & Religion is subject & subservient to our Royal will ( the Supreme Law , & Reason , & publick Conscience ) to the disappointment of our Projects , restraint of our pleasures , and Contempt of the Royal power , Converting● true Loyaltie & absolute subjection , into words & names ( which we care not for ) of Religion & Liberty , Conscience & the Word of God , thereby withdrawing some to the Christian faction from an absolute & implicite subjection to us & our will , as if there were a Superiour Law to which they might appeal ; And considering that these Rebellious Christians do never cease to assert & maintain strange Paradoxes , such Principles as are inconsistent with the glory & interest of our Government , as that the Authority of Kings should be hem'd in with Limits , and that their Acts & Actions are to be examined by another rule than their oun Authority to make them Lawful , that somethings in the Kingdom are not subject to the Kings Authority , That there is a Kingdom within a Kingdom not subordinate to the King , And that there is another King Superior to the Supreme whom they will rather obey than us , And that we must either take Laws from Him or otherwise we are not Magistrats ; And Considering also their Practices are Conforme to their , Principles , They will not obey our Lawes but the Lawes of Another inconsistent with ours , and will calculate their Religion according to His Lawes and not according to ours , And continually make their Addresses to and receive Ambassadours from a Prince whom we know not , whom our Predicessors of truely worthy memory did crucify , One Iesus who was dead , whom they affirm to be alive , whose Government they alledge is Supreme over all Kings Whom they acknowledge but as His Vassals ; Being now by favourable fortune , not only brought to the Imperial Croun of these Kingdoms through the greatest difficulties , but preserved upon the throne of our Royal Ancestors , which from our Great founder Nimrod of Glorious Memory , and our Illustrious Predecessors Pharaoh , Nebuchadnezzar , Herod the Great , Nero , Caligula &c. of blessed & pious Memory , hath been ever opposite to and projecting the Destruction of that Kingdom of Christ : Do , after their Laudable example , resolve to suppress that Kingdom by all the means & might we can use , because His Government is hateful to us , His yoke heavy , His sayings are hard , His Lawes are contrary to our lusts ; Therefore we will not let this man reign over us , we will break His bonds and cast away His Cords , from us ; And advance & exerce our Soveraign Authority , Prerogative Royal , & Absolute Power , which all our subjects are to obey without reserve . And as by virtue of our Supremacy , whereby we are above all , but such as we are pleased to subject our selves to , settled by Law and Lineally Derived to us as an Inherent right to the Croun , we have Power to order all matters of Church as well as State , as we in our Royal wisdom shall think fit , All Laws & Acts of Christ to the contrary notwithstanding ; And accordingly in our Royal wisdom have overturned the plat-form of that Government which Christ hath instituted , razed all Courts fenced in His Name , and severely interdicted all Meetings of His subjects , and intertainment of His Ambassadours ; many of whom , in contempt of Him that sent them , we have punished according to Law , for negotiating His Affairs in our Kingdoms without our pleasure , & requiring Allegiance & obedience to Him , after we had exauctorated Him ; we have also established our Right Trusty & Entirely beloved Clerks in Ecclesiastick affairs , and their underlings , by our Authority to have the Administration of the business of Religion , and impowered our Right Trusty & well beloved Cousins & Counsellers , to Compell all to submitt to them , by Finings , Confinings , Imprisonment , Banishment , Oaths , & Bonds , and all Legal means : So now having prosecuted this war against Christ to this length , that we have no fears of a Rally of His forces again so often beaten , we are now engaged with other Antichristian Princes to give our Power to our holy Father Antichrist , so far as may serve his purpose to oppse Christ in his way ; but we reserve so much to our seeves , as may encroach upon Him in our Capacity . And therefore we have thought fit to restore to Antichrist our Ecclesiastical Supremacy , from whom we borrowed it , and for which we have no use at present : But we resolve to maintain & prosecute our Soveraign Authority , Prerogative Royal , and Absolute Power foresaid , against Christ , and without subordation to Him , from whom as we sought none so we received no Power by His Warrant & Grant , and against whom we mind to manage it to the utter most of out power . Yet reflecting upon the Conduct of the four last Reigns , how after all the frequent & pressing endeavours that were used in each of them , to reduce our Kingdoms to Antichrist , the Subjects of Christ were so stubborn , that the success hath not answered the designe : We must now change our Methods alitle , and tollerate that Profession of Christ which we cannot yet get overturned , His Subjects being so numerous , but alwayes upon these termes , that they take aspecial care that nothing be Preached or taught among them , which may be a Testimony for Christs Prerogatives in opposition to our Usurpation , or may any way tend to alienate the hearts of our People from us or our Government , or Preach his Truths which we have condemned as Seditious & Treasonable , under the highest pains these Crimes will import . Hereby we shall establish our Government on such a foundation , on the ruine of Christs , as may make our subjects happy , and unite them to us by Inclination as well as Duty , in a belief that we will not constrain Conscience in matters of meer Religion : for which we have a Dispensation from our holy-Father , and also from our oun Absoluteness , to be slaves to this Promise no longer then consists with our Interest : And which we have power to Interpret as we please : And would have all to understand , that no Testimony for Christs Supremacy against our Encroachments thereupon , shall be Comprehended under these Matters of meer Religion ●or which the Conscience shall not be constrained : But we will have the Consciences of such Subjects of his , that dare assert it , brought to a Test & probation how they stand affected in this Competition betuixt us & this King Iesus , and see whether they will oune or decline our Authority , because not of him , nor for him , nor to him , but against him & all his Interests . Our will is therefore , that all who will Countenance any other Meetings of His Subjects than we have allowed , or connive at them , shall be prosecuted according to the utmost severity of our Lawes made against them , which we leave in full force & vigour notwithstanding of the Premises . And for this effect , we further Command all our Iudges , Magistrats , & Officers of our Forces , to prosecute all these Subjects & Followers of Christ , who shall be guilty of treating with , or paying homage to that exauctorated King of theirs , in their Assemblies with His Ambassadours in the Fields , with the utmost rigor as they would avoid our highest Displeasure : for we are confident , none will after these Liberties & freedoms we have given to all without reserve , to serve God Publickly in such a way as we by our Soveraign Authority , Prerogative Royal , & Absolute Power foresaid , have prescribed & allowed , presume to meet in these Assemblies , except such whose Loyaltie to Christ doth alienate them from us & our Government . As also under the same Certifications , by the same Soveraign Authority , Prerogative Royal & Absolute Power foresaid , We charge , impower , warrand , & Authorize , against all hazards ( Hell excepted ) all our foresaid Judges & Officers in their respective places , to Prosecute & execute our Lawes , against all that may be suspected or convicted of their Adherence to Christ , or be found guilty of ouning their Allegiance to Him as their Liege Lord by Solemn Covenant , which we have caused burn by the hand of the hangman , and declared Criminal to oune it , or shall be found guilty of declining Allegiance to us & our Absolute Authority , stated in opposition to Him & His , or of maintaining that pernicious Principle , inconsistent with our Government that their lives are their oun , which they will preserve without surrender to our Mercy : All which we Command to be executed to death , or banished as Slaves , as shall be found most conducible to our Interest . And to the end , the few that remain of that way may be totally exterminated , we straitly Command all our Souldiers , Horse & Foot , to be ready upon order , to march & make search , pursue & follow , seise & apprehend , kill & slay & cause to perish , all such whether they shall be found at Meetings , or in their wanderings , wherever they may be apprehended : And ordain all our good Subjects to be assistent to these our Forces , in prosecuting this War against Christ and his Followers , and Contribute their best help & encouragement , in giving them their required Maintinance , & duely paying the Cess & Locality imposed for that end ; And that they shall not dare to Countenance , Converse with , resett , harbour , supply , or keep any manner of Correspondence with any of these Traitors that adhere to Christ , under the pain of being found airt & part with them , and obnoxious to the same Punishments to which they are lyable ; But on the contrary to Assist our Forces , to apprehend , and raise the Hue & Cry after them wherever they shall be seen , that they may be forthwith purswed , seised , cut off , & destroyed , which we order to be instantly done upon the place , where ●●ey or any of them are apprehended , & that without any delay or mercy to age or sexe &c. On the other hand if any will take a look of the Declarations & Testimonies of the other Party , without prejudice or stumbling at some Expressions which may be offensive to Criticks , he will find the Scope & Strain of them to have this Importance . WE , a Poor Company of Persecuted , reproached , & despised Christians ; who indeed have not many wise men among us after the flesh , not many mighty , not many noble , but are a few foolish , weak , base , & despised nothings in the world ; Yet having this Ambition to be His called , chosen , & faithful Souldiers , who is King of Glory , King of Heaven , King of Saints , King of Nations , King of Kings , whose Kingdom is Everlasting & Universal ; Considering the many insolent indignities , affronts , & reproaches cast upon His Name & Glory , and the many Usurpations , Encroachments , & Invasions made upon His Croun & dignity , by a Pestilent Generation of His Atheistical , Papistical , Prelatical , & Tyrannical Enemies , who have rebelled against Him , and have renounced , corrupted , & subverted His Royal Government , both in the Church & in the world , both in His Kingdom of Grace and of Power : Do bear Witness & Testimony against these Rebels , from the Highest to the Lowest : And assert the Interest & Title of our Princely Master , and oune Allegiance & absolute obedience to Him and His Government , to which He hath all undoubted right ; An Essential right by His Eternal God head , being the Everlasting Father whose goings forth have been of old from Everlasting ; A Covenant right by Compact with the Father , to bear the Glory and rule upon His Throne , by virtue of the Council of Peace between them both ; A Donative right by the Fathers right of Delegation , by which He hath all Power given to him in Heaven & in Earth , and all Authority even because He is the Son of man ; An Institute right by the Fathers Inauguration , which hath set Him as King in Zion ; An Acquisite right by His oun Purchase , by which He hath merited & obtained not only Subjects to Govern , but the Glory of the Sole Soveraignty over them in that relation , a Name above every Name ; A Bellical right by Conquest , making the People fall under Him , and be willing in the day of His Power , and overcoming those that make war with Him ; An Hereditary right by Proximity of blood & Primogeniture , being the first born , higher then the Kings of the Earth , and the first born from the dead , that in all things He might have the Preeminence ; An Elective right by His Peoples choise & surrender , a Croun wherewith His Mother Crouned Him in the Day of His espousals . In a humble recognizance of all which Rights , we oune & avouch , that He hath that Incommunicable Prerogative of Sole Soveraignty , over his Visible Kingdom as well as Invisible , without a Copartner or Competitor , either Coordinate or subordinate ; in Prescribing Lawes , by no humane Authority to be reversed ; in appointing Ordinances , immutable without addition or diminution , for matter or manner ; instituting a Government , which no man or Angel can without Blasphemy arrogate a Power either to invert or evert , change or overturn ; And Constituting Officers , which must depend only on His Authority and His alone ; and must be cloathed only with His Commission and His alone , guided by His Instructions & His alone , Acting according to His Lawes & Prescribed Platforme and His alone , without any dependence on , subordination to , Licence warrand or Indulgence from , any Mortal . And therefore We disoune & detest every thing that hath not the stamp of His Authority , either in Doctrine , Worship , Discipline or Government : And will discountenance Prelacy , Supremacy , Popery , and all Corruption contrarie to His Institution , who is Sole & Supreme Lawgiver to the Conscience , and will submit to , or comply with nothing that may directly or indirectly signify our respect unto them . Hence we will take none of their Oaths , subscribe none of their bonds , yeeld to none of their Impositions , pay none of their Exactions : Neither will we hear or receive Ordinances from any Minister , but the faithful Authorized Ambassadours , of Christ our King , whatever either rage or reproach we suffer for it . We assert & affirm also , that our Exalted Prince is King of the whole world , by whom Kings reign & Princes Decree Justice , as His Ministers of Justice , in subordination to Him ; whom He hath appointed to rule over us , with just boundaries that they may not exceed , and true Characters by which we should know them & pay them deference . And therefore , who soever shall arrogate to themselves and extend their power beyond & above His prescripts , being neither called to , nor qualified for , nor improving the Office , for the ends He hath appointed ; We will acknowledge them no otherwise than Usurping Tyrants , & not Magistrats nor Ministers of Justice , to whom He hath given the Sword by His preceptive Will , only as Lyons , Bears , Wolves , to whom he hath given a rod by His providential Will : In that case we may be passively subject when we cannot do better , but will never oune Consciencious Allegiance to them , nor oune them as our Lawful Magistrars ▪ And therefore we will not bow to their Idols they have set up , nor prostitute either Conscience or Liberty to their Lust , But will endeavour under our Masters Banner & Conduct to preserve whatever he hath intrusted to us , Religion , Life , Liberty , Estate , And whatsoever the Lord our God hath given us to possess , As they unjustly possess what their God gives them : And will maintain a war of constant opposition to them ( against whom our Lord hath declared a war for ever ) without parly , Treaty of peace , Capitulation , Composition , Truce or any Transaction : we will neither Medle nor make with them less or more , nor seek their favour , nor embrace it when it is offered , on any termes that may imply any obligation to surcease from our duty to our King , and irreconcileable opposition to them &c. Now I shall come more Distinctly to the purpose , in offering a short vindication of the Heads & Grounds of our great sufferings : Dividing them into their principal parts , which I reduce to two , viz Negatives & Positives . The Negative Grounds ? I reckon three principally . 1. For Refusing to acknowledge a Corrupt Ministrie . 2. For Refusing to oune a Tyrannical Magistracy . 3. For Refusing to Swear & subscribe their unlawful imposed Oaths , Chiefly that of Abjuration , which was the occasion of suffering unto death . The positive Grounds are also three . 1. For frequenting field-meetings , to receive Gospel-Ordinancs from faithful Ministers . 2. For maintaining the principle & practice of Defensive Resistence of Superior powers . 3. For maintaining the priviledge & Duty of offensive revenge in executing Justice upon Murdering Enemies of Mankind in cases of extreme necessity . In prosecuting which , I shall intertexe some subordinate questions relating to their respective Heads , and endeavour to discuss them briefly . HEAD . I. Where The Sufferings of many for Refusing to acknowledge a Corrupt Ministrie are Vindicated : and the Question of Hearing Curats is cleared . THis Question though it may seem nice and of no great Moment , to Persons of Gallio's or Laodiceds temper , indifferent & Lukwarm dispositions , consulting their oun more them the things of Christ , which maks it pass without any enquiry with the most part of the world : Yet to all who are truly tender in keeping a good Conscience free of the times Contagion , to all who have the true Impression of the fear of God , who is Iealous especially in the matters of his worship , to all who have the true zeal of God eating them up , in a just indignation at the indignities done to him , in usurping the office , & corrupting the Administration of the Ministrie , to all who truly Love the Gospel and put a due value on the Ordinances of Christ , the Corruptions whereof this Question touches , it will be accounted of great importance . There are three Questions about the Duty of hearing the Word , Concerning which the Lord Jesus gives us very weighty Cautions , viz what we should hear , Mark. 4. 24. how we should hear Luk. 8. 18. and whom we should hear . The last of which , though it be not so expressly Stated as the other two , yet the Searcher of the Scriptures will find it as clearly Determined , and as many Cautions to guard from erring in it , as in any other Case , And that the Concern of Conscience in it is very weighty . And certain it is if there had been more advertency in this Point , there would not have been such inconsideration and Licenciousness in the matter & manner of hearing . Nor would that itching humor & Luxuriancy of lust , in heaping up teachers to please the fancy , have been so much encouraged , to the great detriment of the Church , disgrace of the Gospel , & destruction of many poor Souls . But through the ignorance & neglect of this Duty of trying whom we should hear , by seeking some satisfieing evidence of their being cloathed with Authority from Christ , the world hath been left louse in a Licence to hear what they pleased , and so have received the Poison of error from Monte banks , instead of the true & wholesome Potions of Christs Prescripts from them that had Power & skill to administer them . Hence the many Sects , & Schismes , & errors , that have Pestered the Church in all ages , have in a great measure proceeded from this latitude & laxness of Promiscous hearing of all whom they pleased , whom either the worlds Authority impowered , or by other means were possessed of the place of Preaching , without taking any Cognizance whether they had the Characters of Christs Ambassadours or not . If this had been observed , and People had scrupled & refused to hear these whom they might know should not have Preached ; neither the Great Antichrist , nor the many lesser Antichrists , would have had such footing in the world as they have this day . It is then of no small Consequence to have this Question cleared . Neither is it of small difficulty to solve the intricacies of it , what Characters to fix for a discovery of Christs true Ministers ; whom we should submit to & obey in the Lord , and Love & esteem them for their Works sake , and for their qualities sake , as standing in Christs stead , having the dispensation of the word of Reconciliation committed to them ; And how we may discern those Characters , what judgment is incumbent to private Christians , for the satisfaction of theiroun Consciences in the Case ; And how they ought to demean themselves in their practice , with out Scandal on either hand , or sin against their oun Conscience ; how to avoid the rocks & Extremes that inadvertency or precipitancy in this matter may rush upon ; So as to escape & sail by the Scylla of sinful Separation on the one hand , and the Charybdis of sinful union & Communion on the other , which are equally dangerous ; especially how these Cautions are to be managed in a broken and disturbed & divided Case of the Church . The Question also is the more difficult , that as it was never so much questioned before this time , and never so much sought to be obscured , by the perverse disputings of men of corrupt minds to find out evasions to cover sin & escape sufferings upon this account ; So it hath never been discussed by Divines either at home or abroad , with relation to our Case , except what hath been of late by some faithful men , who have suffered upon this head , from whom I shall gather the most of my Arguments , in as Compendious a way as I can without wronging them . The reason , I fancy , that we are at such a loss in our helps from the Learned on this head , is partly , that they have written with relation to their oun times , in a Constitute Case of the Church , when Corruptions & disorders might be orderly rectified , and people might have access to get their scruples removed in a Legal way by Church-order , in which case the Learned & Judicious Mr Durham hath written excellently in his book on Scandal , but therein neither he nor others did consult nor could have a prospect of such a case as ours is ; And partly , that forreign Divines , not having this for their exercise , could not be acquainted with our circumstantiate case , and so are not fit nor Competent Arbiters to decide this Contraversie ; hence many of them do wonder at our sufferings upon this head . Every Church is best acquainted with her oun Testimony . Yet we want not the suffrage of some of the Learnedst of them , as the Great Gisb. Voetius in his Polit Eccles. in several places comes near to favour us : where he allowes People to leave some & hear such Ministers as they profit most by , from these grounds , that people should chuse the best & most edifying gifts , and from that scripture 1 Thess. 5. 21. Prove all things &c. and answers objections to the contrare , and granteth that upon several occasions one may abstain from explicite Communion with a Corrupt Church , for these reasons , that such Communion is not absolutely necessary , Necessitate either Medii or Precepti , where the Christian shall have more peace of Conscience , and free exercise of Christian Duties elswhere , And that he may keep Communion with more Purity in other places Polit. Ecces . Quest. 17. Pag. 68. And he approves of People refusing to bring their Children to be baptized by such Corrupt Ministers , because they may wait until they have occasion of a Minister , for if the best gifts be to be Coveted why should not the best Ministers be preferred ? and why should not Christians shew by their deeds , that they honour such as fear the Lord , & contemn a vile Person ? They ought not to partake of other mens sins 1 Cor. 5. 9. 11. Eph. 5. 11. They should not strengthen the hands of the wicked and make sad the Godly ; The Authority of such Ministers should not be strengthened Voet. Polit Eccles. Pag. 637. to 640. But though it labour under all these disadvantages : yet it is not the less but so much the rather necessary , to say somwhat to clear it , with dependance upon light from the Fountain , and with the help of those faithful men who hath sufficiently cleared it up , to all that have a Conscience not blinded or bribed with some prejudices , by which more light hath accrued to the Church in this point of withdrawing from Corrupt Ministers , 〈◊〉 ever was attained in former times ; which is all the good we have got of Prelacy . In so much that I might spare labour in adding any thing , were it not that I would make the Arguments vindicating this Cause of suffering alitle more publick , and take occasion to shew , that the grounds espoused by the Present & reproached party for their withdrawings , so far as they are stretched , are no other than have been ouned by our writers on this head ; to the intent it may appear , there is no Discrepancy but great likness & harmony between the Arguments & Grounds of withdrawing , in the late Informatorie Vindication &c. and those that are found in other writings . And so much the rather I think it needful to touch this subject now , that not only this hath been the first ground of our sufferings , but many that suffered a while for it , now have fainted , and condemned all their former Contendings for this Part of the Testimony , calling in question all these reasons that formerly satisfied ' them . But to proceed with some distinctness in this thorny point : Some Concessory Assertions must first be premitted , And then Our Grounds Propounded . First , I willingly yeeld to & Cordially close with the Truth of these Assertions . I. The Unity of the Spirit in the bond of Peace , ought to be the Endeavour of all that are members of the One Body of Christ , Partakers of his One Spirit , called in One Hope , Professing One Lord , Confessing One Faith , sealed with One Baptisme Eph. 4. 3. &c. And for Brethren to dwel together in Unity , is good & pleasant , and like the precious Oyntment upon the head , that ran doun upon Aarons beard Psal. 133. 1 , 2. A fragrant Oyntment indeed , if it be composed aright of Gospel-simples , according to Divine art , and the Wisdom that is from above , which is first pure & then peacable ; and not made up of Adulterate Politicks : that Union that hath the Spirit for its Author , the Scripture for its Rule , Peace for its bond & beauty , love for its Cement , Faith for its foment , Christ for its foundation , and Truth & holiness for its constant Companions , cannot but be intensely desired , enixely endeavoured , and fervently followed , by all the Professors of the Gospel of Peace , & Subjects of the Prince of Peace : Which makes Division & Schisme not only a great Miserie , but a Grand sin . But it must be in the way of Truth & Duty , and consistent with holiness & the honour of Christ , otherwise if it be in the way of Apostasie & defection , it is but a Confederacy & Conspiracy against the Lord. And true Union can neither be attained , nor retained , nor recovered ; except the sinful Cause of Division , Defection ; and the holy overruling Cause , the Anger of the Lord be removed , in turning to & following him . II. Thô there be not perfect Union , but diversity both of judgements and practices , in several Cases there may be Communion with a Church in its Ordinances and Ministrie . As 1. We may have a Catholick Communion with all Christian Ministers & Members of the Catholick Church , considered as such ; holding the Head Christ , and the foundation sure . And so we may meet for Worship with all Devout men in every Nation under Heaven , whether they be Parthians , or Medes , or Elamites , or French or Dutch &c. thô differing in Controversies of lesser moment , not overturning that ; if they hold the Universal ▪ Testimony of the Gospel , against the Common enemies thereof , Iewes , Turks , or Pagans : for there is neither Greek nor Iew if he be a Christian , Christ is all and in all Col. 3. 11. But if they be Hereticks , we can have no Communion with them . 2. We may have a more special Communion with all Protestant Ministers & Members of the Reformed Church , considered as such , more strictly , and upon stricter conditions : providing they hold , not only the Universal of Christians , but the General Testimony of Protestants , against the Greater & lesser Antichrists ; thô differing from us in some circumstantial points , not Reformed , and not contradictory unto the Protestant Testimony , against Poperie & all Heresie ; nor declining from their oun Reformation , by Defection or Schisme . And Consequently , its Lawful to oune Communion with the Churches of the United Provinces , and take Ordination from them , thô they have some formes not allowable , from which they were never Reformed , because they are sound in the Protestant Testimony . But with the Sectarians or Schismaticks or Apostates among them , we cannot oune that special Communion . 3. We may have a more Particular Communion upon yet stricter conditions , with all our Covenanted Brethren , Ministers & Members of the Churches of Britain & Ireland , considered as such : Providing they hold , not only the Universal , not only the more Special , Protestant Testimony against the Greater & lesser Antichrists , but the Covenanted Testimony for the Reformation in Doctrine , Worship , Discipline , & Government , against Poperie , Prelacy , Superstition , Heresie , Schisme , & Profanness , according to the Covenant ; Thô differing from us in those Controversial points , never Reformed , and which were never the Word of Christs patience , and do not overturn the Covenanted Testimony . But with those that contradict & counteract that , we cannot oune that particular Communion . 4. We may have yet a nearer Organical Communion , upon stricter conditions still , with all the Ministers & Members of the National Church of Scotland , constitute & confederate under one Reformed Government , according to the Rule of Christ : providing they hold , not only all the former Testimonies under the foresaid considerations , but the Presbyterian Testimony as stated in the Ecclesiastical Constitutions , and sworn to in the National Covenants & Engagements of that Church , founded upon the Word of God , against Poperie , Prelacy , Erastianisme , Sectarianisme , Toleration , Schisme & Defection ; thô differing in some things from us , never Reformed , never considered in Ecclesiastical Judicatories , never engaged against in our Covenants , never Stated as the Word of patience and Matter of Testimony . But with those that oppose , suppress , reproach , and abandon this Testimony , we cannot oune this Organical Communion , in this broken State of the Church . We may have yet a stricter Congregational Communion , upon stricter conditions , in and with the Ordinary or extraordinary Meetings or Societies of the Lords people for Gospel Ordinances , with any Minister or Ministers , duely & truely admitted to that function , according to Christs Appointment , and the Call of the people , whether in a fixed or unfixed relation : provicing he holds the Testimony of Christ , under all the former considerations , and ounes and adheres unto the true received principles of the Church of Scotland , in Doctrine , Worship , Discipline , & Government , founded upon the written Word of God , and whatsoever Declarations or Testimonies , former or latter , particular or more General , are aggreable thereunto ; thô differing from us in some of the Integral & not Essential parts of our Testimony , against the Enemies of our Covenanted Reformation . But with such as deny or decline from it , by Schisme or Defection , or Complyance with the enemies thereof , we cannot oune this Congregational Communion , in this broken State of the Church . III. Thô there be many things in a Church , to brangle & lessen the Comfort of our Communion with it and the Ministrie thereof ; yet we may keep fellowship with a true Church , thô in many things faultie and Corrupt , as all Churches are in some measure in this Militant State. As the Church of Corinth had many corruptions in their practice , yet no separation is enjoyned from it . And the Lord did not require separation from the Churches of Perga●●● & Thyatira , though they had many corruptions & deficiencies in Discipline , in a Toleration of Hereticks ; and would lay no other burden upon them , but to hold fast what they had : as Mr Durham shewes in his Comment . on the Revel . chap. 2. Lect. 6. Pag. 148 , 149. as also Chap. 18. Lect. 1. Pag. 585. in 4 to . This must be granted especially in these cases . 1. In the infant State of the Church , when the Reformation is only begun : then many things may be tolerated , before they be gradually Reformed , which in an adult State are not to be suffered . 2. In a growing case of the Church , advancing out of corruptions : then many things may be born with , while they are ascending & wrestling up the hill , which in a Declining State ; when the Church is going backward , must not be yeelded unto . See that Objection of hearing Prelatical men in the time of former Prelacy , answered above , Peri. 4. Pag. 54. 3. In a Constitute and settled case of the Church , enjoying her Priviledges & Judicatories , corruptions may be ●oreborn , and the offended are not to withdraw , before recourse to the Judicatories for an orderly redress : But in a broken & disturbed State , when there is no access to these Courts of Christ ; then people , thô they must not usurp a power of Judicial Censuring these corruptions , yet they may claim & exercise a discretive power over their oun practice ; and by their withdrawing from such Ministers as are guilty of them , signify their sense of the moral equity of these censures that have been legally enacted against these & the equivalent corruptions , and when they should be legally inflicted . As we do upon this Ground withdraw from the Prelatick Curats , and likewise from some of our Covenanted Brethren , upon the account of their being chargable with such corruptions & defections from our Reformation , as we cannot but shew our dislike of . This the Reverend Author of Rectius instruendum justifies Confut. 3. Dial. Chap. 1. Pag. 8. where he is shewing , what separation is not sinful ; and gives this for one , if we separate in that , which a National Church hath commanded us as her Members to disoune , by her standing Acts & Authority , while those from whom we separate oune that Corruption . Which holds true of the Curats , & Indulged , and Addressers , and all that we withdraw from . However it be , certainly those are to be withdrawn from , with whom we cannot communicate without submitting to the Lawes establishing them , and taking on that Test & badge of our incorporation with them , and partaking of their sin , & in hazard of their judgment . IV. Thô in some cases , as we are warranted , so are necessitated to withdraw : yet neither do we allow it upon slight or slender grounds , nor can any tender soul be forced to discountenance the Ministers of Christ ( I do not speak here of the Prelatick Curats ) without great reluctancy and grief of heart , even when the grounds of it are solid & valid , and the necessity unavoidable . Therefore we reject these as insufficient Grounds , besides what are given already . 1. We cannot withdraw from a Minister , for his Infirmities or weaknesses , Natural , spiritual or Moral . 2. Neither for Pers●nal faults & escapes : We expect a faithful , but not a sinless Ministrie . 3. Nor for every defect in faithfulness , through Ignorance , want of courage , Misinformation , or being byassed with affection for particular persons . We do not hold , that faults in Members , or defects in Ministers , do pollute the Oordinances , and so necessitate a Separation ; but aggree with what Mr Durham sayes on Revel . chap. 2. Lect. 6. Pag. 147. in 4 to . Sincerity discovered , will cover many faults . 4. Nor for every discoverie of Hypocrisie ; thô we may have gro●nd to suspect a Mans principle & Motive be not right , yet if he be following duty unblameably , and have a Lawfull Call , What then ! notwithstanding every way , whether in Pretence or in Truth , Christ is Preached , therein me may rejoyce Philip. 1. 18. 5. Nor yet for real Scandals , not attended with obstinacy , if Ministers will take reproof & admonition , and at least by Doctrinal Confessing and practicall for saking them satisfie the offended . 6. Yea thô his Scandals be so gross , that we must discountenance him , when he persis●s in them : yet that is not a disouning of his Ministrie `or a rejecting his Commission , but a discountenancing for his disorders , until they be removed . But the Apologet. Rela● Sect. 14. Pag. 290 , 291. sayes ( 1 ) there may be Ministerial corruptions , that cut the very throat of the Office , and make one no Officer — and it is past questioning , such may be shunned , without all hazard of Separation ( 2 ) when personal faults are very gross & palpable , open & avowed , such may be shuned without any hazard of Separation ; because the mans being an Officer coram Deo is much to be questioned , and there is great probability that ipso facto he had forefaulted the same , thô such should be the corruption in a Church , that notwithstanding of all this he may be maintained . ( 3 ) Separation is 〈◊〉 thing , and not hearing such or such a man is a far other thing : there may be many just grounds of exception against a particular person , why people may refuse to countenance him , without any hazard of separation , or joining with separatists in their principles : Separation is one thing , and refusing to attend the Ministrie of such a man is another thing ; for a man may joine with Ordinances in another congregation , and so testify that he hath no prejudice at the Ministrie , but only against such a man in particular . Whence it is an ignorant as wel as malicious calumnie , to say , that our withdrawing from the Curats , and also from some Ministers , whom otherwise we respect & reverence as Godly Ministers , for their offensive defections , is a disouning al the Ministrie of Scotland . Whereas , we do profess indeed a disouning of the Curats Ministrie , but for our Reverend Presbyterian Ministers , thô we do discountenance many of them with sad hearts , for their not keeping the Word of the Lords patience in this hour of tentation , nor adhering to the principles & constitutions of the Church of Scotland : Yet this is not a disouning of their Ministrie , but a Refusing to countenance them in their present administrations , in this disturbed State , till these offences be removed . V. As to disoune the Ministrie , were hateful Sectarianisme ; so to dissolve or break off Communion with a true Church , whereof we are Members , were an unnatural Schisme , which is horrid sin . But because among all the various Sufferings , wherewith the poor tossed , & racked Remnant now Persecuted have been exercised , this hath not been the lightest ; that they have been on all hands stigmatized as Schismaticks & Separatists , not only because they have maintained a resolved withdrawing from the Curats , but also have discountenanced many Presbyterian Ministers , with whom they have been offended for their declining Courses , and Complyances with the Times Corruptions , and forsaking in a great measure the duty of this day : I shall distinguish some cases of Separation , out of the Writings of our approven Authors , which will j●●tify all their withdrawings . 1. Mr Durham distinguishes these three ; Schisme , separating from the Unity & Communion of a true Church , consisting not alway in diversity of Doctrine , but in divided Practices , according to that of Augustine , Schismaticos facit not diversa fides , sed disrupta communionis Societas : Then separation , either in whole from a Church as no Church , or in part in some things wherein they cannot communicate with that corrupt Church , which is Lawful if it exceed not its ground : Then lastly , Secession , a local removing to a better Church . The first of these cannot be imputed to the Persecuted Wanderers : for they separate from no true Church , whereof they were Members , but these from whom they separate , will be found to be the Schismaticks . 2. The second of these , to wit , separation , is either Positive & Active , or Negative & Passive . The first is , when a party not only leaves Communion with a Church , whereunto they were formerly joyned , but also gathers up new distinct Churches , different from the former , under another Government & Ministrie & Ordinances , disouning those they left . The latter is , when the faithful Remnant of a declining Church , standing still & refusing to concur with the backsliding part of the same Church , after they have become obstinate in their defections , holds clossly by , & adheres unto the Reformation attained . This Famous Mr Rutherfoord in his due Right of Presbytries pag. 253. 254. sheweth to be Lawful , and calleth it a Non-Union , as that in Augustines time , when the Faithf●l did separate from the Donatists , which is Lawful & laudable . 3. Mr Rutherfoord there proceeds to distinguish , between a separation from the Church in her worst & most part , and a separation from the best & least part : and these who separate from the worst & greatest part , do notwithstanding retain a part of , and a part in the Visible Church , because they do not separate from the Church according to the least & best part therof ; as the Godly in England who refused the Popish Ceremonies & Antichristian Bishops . Hence it will follow , that though now People should withdraw from Communion with the greatest part of the Church , which is now Corrupted , they cannot be counted Separatists because , they hold still Communion with the better thô lesser part . Moreover he saith Pag. 254. 255. That there may be Causes of Non-Union with a Church , which are not sufficient causes of separation . Lastly he tells us ibid. Pag. 258. When the Greatest part of a Church makes defection from the Truth , the lesser part remaining sound , the Greast part is the Church of separatists ; thô the manyest & greatest part in the actual exercise of Discipline be the Church , yet in the case of right Discipline the best thô fewest is the Church . For Truth is like life , that retireth from the manyest Members unto the heart , and there remaineth in its fountain in case of dangers . So that it is the major part which hath made defection , that are to be accounted Separatists , and not such who stand to their principles , thô they cannot comply or joyne with the corrupt Majoritie . Thus the Apol. Relat. rehearsed his words Sect. 14. pag. 292. 293. 4. There may be a Lawful withdrawing , where the Ordinances & Ministrie are not cast at , as the Apol , Rel. saith . ibid. 291. So then , so long as people do not cast at the Ordinances , but are willing to run many miles to enjoy them : nor cast at the Church as no Church ( thô they sadly fear , that God shall be provoked by this dreadful defection , which is carried on by these men & their favourers , to give her a Bill of divorce ) nor at the Ministrie , for they love those that stand to their Principles dearly , and are most willing to hear them either in publick or private . 5. It is granted by all that write against Separatists , that separation from a Church is Lawful , when the case so falleth out , that union cannot be kept up with her without sin , Voet. Polit. Eccles. pag. 68. quest . 17. 6. The Grave Author of Rectius Instruendum Confut. 3. Dial. Chap. pag. 7. &c. allowes , every Separation is not Schisme , even from the Church which hath essentials , yea and more than essentials : If it be from those ( thô never so many ) who are drawing back from whatever piece of duty & integrity is attained ; for this is still to be held fast , according to many Scripture Commands . So Elias , when Gods Covenant was forsaken , was as another Athanasius ( I and I only am left ) in point of tenacious integrity . 7. Next he sayes , if we separate in that which a National Church hath commanded us as her Members to disoune , by her standing Acts & Authority , while those from whom we separate oune that Corruption . 8. Likewise he there asserts , there is a Lawful forbearance of Union & Complyance with notorious Backsliders , in that which is of it self sinful , or inductive to it : which is far from Separation str●ctly taken . The Commands of abstaining from all appearance of evil , and hating the garment spotted with the flesh , do clearly include this . 9. He addes , many things will warrant Separation from such a particular Minister or Congregation ; which will not warrant Separation from the Church National ; nor infer it , by Mr Durhams acknowledgement ( on Scandal , pag. 129. ) for if Scandals become excessive , he allowes to depart to another Congregation . 10. Lastly he sayes , There is a Commanded withdrawing from Persons & Societies even in Worship , the precepts Rom. 16. 17. 2 Cor. 6. 17. Prov. 19. 27. Act. 2. 40. will clearly import this by Consequence — Surely the Ministers & Professors , adhering to the Reformat●on , must be the true Church of Scotland , thô the lesse● number : These Souldiers who keep the Generals Orders , are the true Army , not the deserters of the same . But Secondly , it being in part cleared by these Assertions , what is our mind in this Controversie , I shall lay coun from Scripture Oracles , all the Causes & Cases justifying & warranding withdrawing from any Ministers ; with application of all of them to the Curats , and accommodation of some of them to all that the Wanderers withdraw from : with Arguments endeavouring to evince the Validity of them , and evidencing they are not new Notions , but the same Grounds which approven Authors have improved in this Controversie . I shall omitt the ordinary Criticismes in stating the Question , in distinguishing betuixt hearing & joyning in Worship , and ouning them as our Ministers , and submitting to them &c. And only essay to prove this Thesis : We cannot without sin oune Church Communion in Gospel Ordinances with the Prelats or their Curats , as Our Ministers , but must Withdraw from them , and any other guilty of the like Corruptions , which we can make out against them . I shall not resume what Confirmations this Thesis is strenthened with , from the Testimonies or Church Constitutions of former Periods , which are premitted in the foregoing discourse : Nor make any repitition of the Circumstances of our present Condition , Represented above , which contributes to clear it : but shortly come to the Arguments . I. It is necessary that we must acknowledge them Ministers of Christs , and his Ambassadours cloathed with his Commission , from whom we receive the ordinances of the Gospel . For otherwise they must be looked upon as Thieves , Robbers , Usurpers , and strangers whom Christs sheep will not , nay must not hear , Iohn . 10. 1 , 5. And how shall they preach , or be heard , except they be sent , Rom. 10. 15. for such whom we know may not Lawfully preach , we cannot Lawfully hear . These from whom we may receive the Misteries of God , we must account Ministers of Christ 1 Cor. 4. 1. and Ambassadours for Christ , standing in his stead , beseeching us to be reconciled to God 2. Cor. 5. 20. Hence such as we doubt to acknowledge Ministers of Christ , cloathed with His Commission , them we cannot hear without sin : But the Prelatical Curats are such as we doubt to acknowledge Ministers of Christ , cloathed with His commission : Therefore we cannot hear them . The Minor only needs probation . These who neither have nor can have the Qualifications of a Minister of Christ , nor the Lawful call of a Minister of Christ , cannot be acknowledged with confidence to be Ministers of Christ cloathed with His commission : But the Prelatical Curats are such : Ergo. — First they neither have nor can have the qualifications of Christs Ministers : Since few of them have the personal , as Christians , far less the Ministerial as Officers , mentioned 1. Tim. 3. 2-4 . Tit. 1. 6-9 . except it be to be husbands of one wife , and if that do not make them Ministers , they have nothing else : especially four are wanting in all of them . ( 1 ) Blamelessness , and freedom from Scandal , even such as affects the office ( besides other gross disorders in their life & conversation , obvious to the view of onlookers being men who have denyed the Faith , and therefore unfit to have the priviledge of Church members in any well Go●erned Church ) being in the experience of all that know them signalized under the Characters of those that run unsent , and from whom we are commanded to withdraw : Causing the people to erre by their lies and by their lightness , not sent of God Ier. 23. making the heart of the righteous sad , and strengthening the hands of the wicked Ezek. 13. 22. See also Ezek. 34 2 , 3. Such as we are commanded to beware of Math. 7. 15 , 16. Such as we must mark & avoid , Rom. 16. 17 , 18. Phil. 3. 2. Disorderly walkers from whom we must withdraw 2 Thess. 3. 6. Covenant-breakers from whom we are commanded to turn away 2 Tim. 3. 3 , 5. They are not then Blameless : and in shewing how fitly these aggree unto the persons now spoken of , time needs not be spent , such as know them can best Judge . Hence , such as either are not fit to be Church members , or have all the Characters of such Officers from whom we are to withdraw , cannot be acknowledged capable of the qualifications of the Ministers of Christ : But such are the Curats : Ergo — ( 2 ) The qualification of Vigilancy cannot be found with them : for all that know them will acknowledge that they neither do , nor can in Preaching the word be instant in season & out of season , so as to make full proof of their Ministrie 2 Tim. 4. 1-5 . Nay they can give no proof of their Ministrie at all , further than may be competent to dumb Dogs that cannot bark , Isa. 56. 10 , 11. for they nor no man can say , that the diseased they have strenghtened , or healed that which was sick &c. Ezek. 34. 4. And it is known to all that know them , that if ever there were any that assumed to themselves the name of Levites , who departed out of the way , and caused many to stumble at the Law , and corrupted the Covenant of Levi , and therefore were deservedly contemptible & base before all the people ( Mal. 2. 8 , 9. ) they are the men . Let any man judge then , whether they have the qualifications of the Messengers of the Lord of hosts . Hence , they that can give no proof of their Ministry , but that which proves them to be such whom the Lord condemns , & such who deserve to be contemned of all , cannot be acknowledged to be qualified as the Lords Ministers : But the Prelatick Curats can give no proof of their Ministry &c. Ergo — ( 3 ) The qualification of Aptness to teach is wanting , yea incompatible with them , not only such of them as are noted for ignorance , of whom clearly that is verified , they are blind watchmen , they are all ignorant ( Isa. 56. 10. ) but even their Greatest Clerks & Rabbies may fitly be called after the name of their forefathers , whom Christ calls blind Leaders of the blind , concerning whom he gives a Command to let them alone Math. 15. 14. Either generally they are discovered to be such Masters of Israel , as know not these things Iohn . 3. 10. being men not exercised in Religion , and have not Learned the Truth as it is in Jesus : or they are such , as if they have had gifts or Grace , yet now they are palpably blasted of God , and so cannot profit the people at all , being such as do not stand in Gods Counsel , for then they should have turned the people from their evil way , and so they are not apt to teach others when they are not taught of God , but steal his words every one from their Neighbour , clearly discovering they are not sent of Him Ier. 23. 21 , 22 , 30 , 32. And because they do not stand in Gods Counsel , they cannot declare all the Counsel of God , Act. 20. 27. For they can neither be apt to teach repentance towards God , since they cannot be supposed to be sensible of these sins to be repented of , for which the Land perisheth & is burnt up like a wilderness , Ier. 9. 12. for then they would first repent themselves of their oun Conformity with Prelacy , of their breach of Covenant &c. All that they can do in such a subject is , to see vain & foolish things , and not to discover the Lands intiquity , but to see false burdens , & causes of banishment , Lam. 2. 14. Nor can they be apt to teach faith , seing in many things they teach otherwise than Christ hath taught us in his word , and consen● not to wholesome words and to the Doctrine which is according to Godlyness from such the Command is to withdraw , 1. Tim. 6. 3-5 . whose Mouths must be stopped when they teach things which they ought not , Tit. 1. 9-11 . which is undenyable to all that know what sort of stuff they Preach , contrary to the word of God , and the principles of our Covenanted Reformation . Hence if none of them be apt to teach , then none of them is fit to be heard ; But none of them is apt to teach : Ergo — It is true private Christians may not judge of the enduements & qualifications of Ministers , yet every private Christian h●th the judgment of discretion , and that way may judge such an one if he appear qualified according to the rule of the word ; And may doubt if he be a qualified Minister Coram Deo , wanting these qualifications which the word requireth , Apol. Relation Sect 15. p. 283. Secondly , They have not the Lawful Call of a Minister of Christ , So much as an External Call of his Institution : which I prove thus . They that have Presentations from Patrons , & Collations from Prelats , and no more for a Call , have no Lawfull Call at all : But the Curats have presentations from Patrons , & collations from Prelats , and no more for a Call : Ergo they have no Lawful Call at all . The Minor cannot be doubted : for in this Government , the Ministers Mission , Call , Ordination , and Relation to such a people over whom he is to officiate , flowes all from the Prelate ; the Congregational Eldership hath not the least interest in it : hence the Presbyterian way of Calling Pastors was ranversed by the Parliament , when Prelacy was set up , and the old custome of Patronages was restored , Rectius Instru . Consut . of 1 Dial. chap. 4. pag. 3. The Major proposition may be proven by parts . First , presentations from Patrons cannot give a Lawful Call : for besides what other reasons might be given against this old relict of Popish bondage of patronages ; It destroyes that priviledge & Liberty of the Church in calling their oun Pastors , and makes all Intruders , without the Churches choice ; whereas the flock are allowed a Judgment of Discretion , knowledge of , & consent to the admission of their Pastors , to whom they intrust their Souls Directions , before they be subject & obey him in the Lord , for otherwise he is a stranger that hath not come in at the door , and they must not , nor will not be imposed upon , Iohn . 10. 1-5 . They had an Interest in choosing & nominating even the Apostles , though there were other Apostles of infallible knowledge as to qualifications , present to ordain them : And they appointed two to be chosen by Lots , Act. 1. 23. and even the Deacons were looked out & chosen by the people , and appointed over their business Act. 6. 3. Much less ought Ministers , to be thrust upon such a weighty employment , to pleasure Great Men who are Patrons , since in their faithfulness the people are infinitely more concerned . Rectius Instruen . ubi Supra . Hence , if the Curates have no Call but what destroyes the Peoples Priviledge , they have no Lawful Call at all , neither ought they to be ouned or Countenanced as Called Ministers : But by the Presentation of Patrons they have no Call , but what destroyes the peoples Priviledge : Ergo — Next Collations from Prelats cannot give a lawful Call : for ( 1 ) they cannot give that to others which they have not themselves : But they have not a Lawful Call themselves , because they are not Lawful officers , as is clear , & may be proven afterwards . ( 2 ) The only way of Conveyance of an ordinary Call to this office , is by the Act of a Presbytrie , Tim. 4. 14. And by Ministers their ordaining Elders in every Church , with the Consent of that Church : But a Prelats Collation is not this Act of a Presbytrie . ( 3 ) That which only makes a man a Prelats Depute , cannot give him a Call to the Ministry of Christ : But this Collation only makes a man a Prelats Depute . Or thus , A Prelats Depute is no Minister : But a Curate is a Prelats Depute : Ergo — That a Prelats Depute is no Minister , I Prove : not only from that , that a Prelat qua talis is not a servant of Christ but an enemy , and therefore cannot confer upon another that Dignity to be Christs Servant ; but from this , that the Scripture allowes no Derivation of deputed Officers . If no Officers of Christ can have Deputes of Christs Institution ; then the Deputes that they make cannot be Christs Officers of His Institution : But no Officers of Christ can have Deputes by Christs Institution : every man that hath any piece of Stewardship in Gods family , must ever see & execute it immediatly by himself , & wait upon it Rom. 12. 7 , 8. That Curats are Prelats Deputes is clear : for they are subject to them in order & jurisdiction , and derive all their Power from them , and are accountable to them . Therefore they cannot be acknowledged with confidence of conscience to be Christs Ministers , because they have not such a visible evidence of the Call of Christ , as in reason & charity doth oblige all men to receive the person so called , as truely sent : which things are so evident in themselves , that whoever denyeth them , is obliged by the same consequence to affirm , that if Simon Magus had in his horrid wickednesse purchased the Apostleship by money , the Christian world had been bound to receive him as an Apostle , Napht. p. 105. 106. Prior Edit . That their Ministry is the Lords Ordinance he plainly denyed , Napht. pag. 109. They have nothing like a solemn ordinanation , having no imposition of hands of the Presbytrie with fasting & prayer , according to the order of the Gospel , but the sole warrand & mission of the Prelat , and therefore it cannot be Lawful to countenance such , and to look upon them as Lawful Ministers Apol. Relat. Sect. 15. pag. 283. It will be objected here . 1. That then their baptism is no baptisme , if they be no Ministers . Ans. ( 1 ) what sad consequences may follow upon the nulling of their office , let them see to it who either send such ●orth or employ them . Apol. Relat. ibid. pag. 294. the best way to avoid these inconveniences is not to countenance them . But ( 2 ) the same Answers may serve which are adduced for Popish Baptismes & ordinations : And factum sometimes valet , quod fieri non debuit . Next it will be Obj. 2. That many of the Curats were in the Ministrie before , therefore the Argument is not stringent against them . Ans. The one half of it about the qualifications does still urge them , through the want of which , and their base Treachery & betraying their trust , and perjuries in breaking Covenant , they have really forfaulted their Ministry , and loosed all from an obligation to hear them , or any other to whom these Scripture Characters may be applyed , and brings all under the guilt of partaking with them that hear them . II. It is necessary also , that all whom we may lawfully hear as Ministers & Ambassadours of Christ , should not only have had a commission from Christ , sometimes conveyed to them in his orderly appointed way , by & from approven Church officers ; but they must have it then when we hear them , at this time when we oune Communion with them . For if they have sometimes had it , and forefaulted it or changed it , by taking anew right another way , it is all one in point of ouning them as if they had none at all : and we must not medle with such changelings , in things that they & we must not come & go upon Prov. 24. 21. Now plain it is that some Curats sometimes had a commission from Christ , when they were Presbyters ; but now they have changed their holding , and taken a new right from them who are no Officers of Christ , invested with power to confirm or Convey a Ministerial Mission , and so they have forefaulted what they had Mr Durham , in a digression on this subject of hearing , shewes that Ministers may forefeit on Revel . chap. 1. pag. 55. in 4 to . In matter of hearing ( sayes he ) it is not so hard to discern , who are to be counted to speak without Gods commission ; because ordinarely such have no warrantable Call at all ( no not in the outward forme , and so cannot be counted but to run unsent ) or by palpable defection from the Truth , and Commission given them in that Call , they have forefeited their commission : And so no more are to be counted Ambassadours of Christ , or Watchmen of His flock , than a Watchmen of the City is to be accounted an observer thereof , when he hath publickly made defection to the Enemy , and taken on with him . Let the Indulged and Addressing Ministers advert to this ; And consider , whether or not the truly tender have reason to discountenance them , while they continue in their palpable defection . But undenyably this refells that Objection of the Curats Ordination before they were Curats : For they that change their holding of a right , and take a new right which is null , they forego & forefeit their old right , & all right : But the Prelatick Curats have changed their holding of their right , and taken a new one which is null : Therefore they have foregone & forefeited their old one . The minor I prove thus . They who had aright from Christ by Conveyance of His officers , and take a new grant for the exercise of it , not from Christ , but by conveyance of such as are none of His officers , they change their hold●ng and take a new one which is null : But the Prelatick Curats who had a right by conveyance of His officers , have taken a new grant for the exercise of it , not from Christ , but by conveyance of the Prelat , which is none of His officers : Ergo — The stress of all will ly in the Probation of this , that the Prelat is none of Christs officers , and therefore the conveyance of a power from him is not from Christ. Which I prove . 1. Because His office is cross to the very nature of Gospel Church-Government , and therefore he cannot be a Gospel Church Ruler . Christ discharged His officers to exercise Dominion ( or Lordship Luk. 22. 25. ) or Authority as the Gentils did , but that the Chiefest should be only a Minister Math. 22. 25 , 26. The Apostle Paul disclaims Dominion over the Church , 2 Cor. 1. ult . Peter exhorts the Elders not to be Lords over Gods Heritage 1 Pet. 5. 3. The Authority of Church officers then is not a Desp●tick power , but a Ministerial Stewardship . But the Diocesan Bishop is both a Lordly Title & Power , having all Authority in the Diocess derived from him , as being as it were the Universal Pastor , and so taking upon him a power , which is neither commanded , nor can be discharged . Hence , he that subjects his His Ministrie to the Domination of a strange Lord , inverting the Nature of Gospel Church-Government , cannot be ouned in His Ministrie : But all Curats subject their Ministry &c. Ergo — 2. Because he is an officer Distinct from & superior to a Presbyter or Pastor ; whereas the Scripture makes a Bishop and Presbyter all one . The Elders of the Church of Ephesus are called Episcopi or Overseers Act. 20. 17. 28. An ordainded Elder must be a blameless Bishop , as the steward of God , Tit. 1. 5 , 7. Again , it cannot be shown where the Scripture mentions either Name , qualification , work , Duty , or ordination of an ordinary Church officer Superior to Presbyters , and which are not likewise appropriat to them , who are called Rulers , Governours , Bishops . In all the Holy Ghost His purposed recitalls of ordinary Church Officers , there is not the least hint of a Diocesan Bishop : and yet a Deacon is described , the meanest officer , in His work & qualifications . Hence then , if this Diocesan Prelate be such an uncouth beast , that neither in name nor Nature is found in the word of God , all the power derived from him is null : But the first is true : Ergo — 3. Because every Officer in the Scripture relates to the flock ( except the extraordinary Officers , who were further extended , now ceased ) Bishops of Ephesus were overseers over the flock Act. 20. the Elders that Peter writes to were over the flock . But this Diocesan Antiscriptural Monster , pretends to be over the Shepherds : And invents new Degrees & orders of Superiority & inferiority , of officers of the same kind , beside & against the Scripture , which makes all Apostles alike , & all Evangelists , so all Teachers : though there be a Distinction & Superiority in diverse Kinds , yet not in the same . God hath set some in the Church , first Apostles , Secondarly Prophets , thirdly Teachers 1 Cor. 12. 28. but not among Teachers some above others , in a power of order & Jurisdiction . Hence , an Officer over officers of the same kind is not an Officer of Christs institution , And consequently any power conveyed from his is null : But a Prelat pretends to be an officer over Officers of the same kind : Ergo — 4. Because every officer in the Church hath equally , and in perfect parity , equall power & Authority allowed them of God in the exercise of both the keyes , both of order & Jurisdiction : All ruling Elders may rule alike , and deserve equal honour : And all Preaching Elders have the like Authority , and the like honour conferred upon them 1 Tim. 6. 17. The scripture attributes both power of Order & Jurisdiction to all Preaching Presbyters equally . They must oversee the flock ( or as the word is , do the part of a Bishop over them ) Act. 20. 28. and they must also feed the flock 1 Pet. 5. 2. Subjection & obedience is one , to them all alike : All that are over us and admonish us , we must esteem highly for their works sake 1 Thess. 5. 12. and obey & submit our selves to them that watch for our souls Heb. 13. 17. we find also excommunication belongs to all alike 2 Cor. 2. 6. and ordination 1 Tim. 4. 14. But the Diocesan Prelat takes from Presbyters to himself power of ordination , assuming only his Curats for fashions sake , and the sole decisive power in Church Judicatories , wherein he hath a Negative voice ; like a Diotrephes , the first Prelat who loved to have the preeminence 3 Iohn . 9. the only precedent for Prelacy in the Scripture . Hence , he that would take all power to himself , which is undivided & equall to all officers by Christs appointment , hath none by Christs allowance , but is to be reckoned an usurping Diotrephes : But the Diocesan Prelat would take all the power to himself , which is undivided & equall to all . By all which it appears , the prelate being no Authorized Church Officer of Christs , no Authority can be derived from him ; And so that such as betake themselves to this pretended power for warranting them in the function , can warrantably claim no deference thereupon , nor can be ouned as Ministers whatever they were before . For this were an acknowledging of the power & Authority of Prelats ( especially when the Law commands our hearing as a submitting to them . ) The reason is because these men came forth from the Prelat , having no other call or warrant but what the Prelat giveth . And so a receiving of them will be a receiving of the Prelate , as a refusing of them will be accounted a slighting of the Prelat & his power . Apol. Relat. 15. pag. 272. III. It is necessare also , that all with whom we oune Communion as Ministers , should be Christs Ambassadours , having then when we hear them , and holding still their Commission from Christ as King , and only Head of His Church ; conveyed not only from Church officers , in a way that He hath revealed as the Prophet of His Church , but in a way of Dependence upon & subordination to Christ as King , who ascending far above Principalities & Powers , appointed & gave the Gifts of the Ministry Eph. 4. 8. 11. and set them in the Church 1. Cor. 12. 28. and gave them commission to go & teach the Nations , by virtue of that all Power that was given to Him in Heaven & Earth Math. 28. 18 , 19. If then they take a new holding & close with a new Conveyance of the Ministrie , and of the Power to exercise the same , from a new Architectonick usurped Power in the Church , encroaching on Christs Royal prerogative , we dare not Homologat such an affront to Christ , as to give them the respect of His Ambassadours , when they become the servants of men , and subject even in Ministerial functions to another Head then Christ ; for then they are the Ministers of men , & by men , and not by Jesus Christ , and God the Father , who raised Him from the dead , because they do not hold the Head , Col. 2. 19. Hence those that receive & derive their Church-Power from , and are subordinate in its exercise to , another Head then Christ Jesus , should not be received and subjected to as the Ministers of Christ in His Church : But the Prelats & their curats do receive & derive their Church Power from , & are subordinate in its exercise to , another Head then Christ : Therefore they should not be received &c. The first Proposition cannot be denyed . The Second is proved thus : Those officers in the Church , Professing themselves such , that derive their Church-Power from , & are subordinate in its exercise to , a Power truly Architectonick & Supreme in the Church ( to wit the Magistrate ) beside Christ ; Do derive their Power from & are subordinate in its exercise to another Head than Christ Jesus : But so it is that Prelats & their Curats do derive &c. Ergo — The Major is evident : for whosoever hath a Supreme Architectonick Power in & over the Church , must be a Head to the same , and the fountain of all Church Power . The Minor is also clear , from the foregoing Historical Deduction , manifesting the Present Prelacy to be Gross Erastianisme : for the disposal of the Government of the Church is declared by Law to be the Croun right and an inherent perpetual Prerogative , and thereupon the Bishops are restored to the Episcopal function ; And it is expressly Declared , that there is no Church Power in the Church-office bearers , but what depends upon & is subordinate unto the Supremacy , and authorized by the Bishops , who are declared accountable to the King for the Administration . By virtue of which Ecclesiastick Supremacy , He put excomunication & spiritual Censures , & consequently the Power of the Keyes , into the hands of Persons meerly Civil , in the Act for the High Commission . Hence it is clear , that as the fountain of all Church Government , he imparts his Authority to such as he pleases , and the Bishops are nothing else but his Commissioners in the exercise of that Ecclesiastick power , which is originally in Himself , and that the Curats are only His under Clerks . All the stress will lie in proving , that this Monster of a Supremacy , from which the Prelats & their Curats have all their Authority , is a Great Encroachment on the Glory of Christ as King : which will appear if we briefly consider these Particulars . 1. It usurps upon Christs Prerogative , who only hath all undoubted right to this Architectonick & Magisterial Dominion over the Church , His oun Mediatory Kingdom : not only an Essential right by His Eternal Godhead , being the Everlasting Father , whose goings forth hath been of old from Everlasting Isa. 9. 6. Mic. 5. 2. in recognizance of which , we oune but one God the Father , and one Lord , by whom are all things & we by Him 1. Cor. 8. 6. But also a Covenant-right , by Compact with the Father , to bear the Glory & rule upon His Throne , by virtue of the Counsel of Peace between them both Zech. 6. 13. A Donative right by the Fathers Delegation , by which He hath all power given in Heaven & in Earth , Math. 28. 18. and all things given unto His hand Iohn . 3. 35. and all judgment & Authority to execute it , even because He is the Son of man , Iohn . 5. 22 , 27. and to be Head over all things to the Church Eph. 1. 22. An Institute right , by the Fathers inaugaration , who hath set Him as King in Zion , Psal. 2. 6. and appointed Him Governour , that shall rule His people Israel Math. 2. 6. An Acquisite right , by His oun purchase , by which He hath merited & obtained , not only subjects to Govern , but the Glory of the Sole Soveraignty over them in that relation , A name above every name Phil. 2. 9. which is , that He is the Head of the Church , which is as much His Peculiar Prerogative , as to be Saviour of the body Eph. 5. 23. A Bellical right by Conquest , making the people fall under Him , Psal. 45. 4. and be willing in the Day of His power , Psal. 110. 3. and overcoming those that make war with Him , Rev. 17. 14. An Hereditary right by Proximity of blood & Primogeniture , being the first born higher then the Kings of the Earth , Psal. 89. 27. and the first born from the dead , that in all things He might have the preeminence , Col. 1. 18. An Elective right , by His peoples choise & surrender , having a Croun wherewith His Mother Crouned Him , in the day of His Espousals Cant , 3. ult . By all which undoubted Titles , It is His Sole incommunicable Prerogative , without a Copartner or Competitor , Coordinate or subordinate , to be Iudge , & only Lawgiver & King in Spirituals , Isa. 33. 22. to be that one Lawgiver , Iam. 4. 12. who only can give the power of the keyes to His officers , ( which Comprehends all the power they have ) Math. 16. 19. to be that one Master over all Church officers , who are but brethren , Math. 23. 8 , 10. in whose Name only they must perform all Church Acts , and all Parts of their Ministry , and not in the Name of any Mortal , Math. 28. 18. 19. Math. 18. 20. from whom only they receive what ever they have to deliver to the Church 1. Cor. 11. 23. To be the only Instituter of His Officers , who hath set them in the Church 1. Cor. 12. 28. and gave them to the Church Eph. 4. 11. whose Ambassadours only they are 2. Cor. 5. 20. from whom they have authority for edification of the Church 2 Cor. 10. 8. 2 Cor. 13. 10. in whose Name only they are to assemble , and keep & fence their Courts , both the least , Math. 18. 20. and the Greatest Act. 15. But now all this is usurped by one who is not so much as a Church member , let be a Church Officer , as such : for the Magistrate is neither , as he is a Magistrate , otherwise all Magistrats would be Church members . Hence they that have all their power from a meer usurper on Christs Prerogative , who is neither member nor officer of the Church , have none at all to be ouned or received as His Lawful Ambassadours : But the Prelats & their Curats have all their power from a meer usurper on Christs Prerogative , who is neither Member nor officer of the Church : Ergo — 2. It confounds the Mediatory Kingdom of Christ with , & subjects it to , the Kingly Government of the world , removes the Seripture Land Marks & Limits between civil & Ecclesiastick Powers ; in making the Governours of the State to be Governours of the Church , and denying all Church Government in the hands of Church officers , Distinct from & independent upon the civil Magistrat : which clearly derogats from the Glory of Christs Mediatory Kingdom , which is altogether distinct from & not subordinate to the Government of the world , both in the Old Testament & in the New. For , they have distinct fountains whence they flow : civil Government flowes from God Creator , Church Government from Christ the Lord Redeemer , Head & King of His Church , whose Kingdom is not of this world , Iohn . 18. 36. though for this end He came into the world , that He should have a Kingdom there , vers . 37. They have distinct Objects : civil Government hath a civil object , the out ward man ; Church Government a Spiritual object , men considered as Christians : In the Old Testament , the matters of the Lord are clearly distinguished from the matters of the King 2 Chron. 19. ult . In the new Testament , there are matters of Church Cognizance which do not at all belong to the civil Magistrate ; as in the case of offence , they must tell the Church , not the civil Magistrate Math. 18. 15. 20. In the case of Excommunication , the Church is to act by virtue of the power of our Lord Jesus Christ 1 Cor. 5. 4 , 5. not by the Magistrats power ; In the case of Absolution , the Church is to Iudge what Punishment is sufficient , and what evidence of repentance is sufficient to remove it , 2 Cor. 2. 6. 7. So in the case of Tryal & ordination of Ministers &c. None of these belong to the Magistrate . They have distinct Natures : The civil is a Magisterial , the Ecclesiastick is a Minsterial Government ; the one is the power of the sword , the other of the Keyes ; The one put forth in Political Punishments , the other in Ecclesiastick Censures : In the Old Testament , the Magistrats power was Coactive , by death , banishment , Confiscation &c. Ezra . 7. 26. The Church , by puting out of the Synagogue , interdiction from Sacred things &c. In the New Testament , The Magistrats power is described Rom. 13. to be that of the sword by punishment ; the power of the Church only in binding & Loosing , Math. 16. 19. They have distinct Ends : the end of the one being the good of the Common wealth , the other the Churches Edification : In the Old Testament , the end of the civil Government was one thing , and of the Church another , to wit , to warn not to trespass against the Lord , in that forecited 2. Chron. 19. 10. In the New Testament , the end of Magistratical power is to be a terror to evil works , & a praise te the good , Rom. 13. 3. but the end of Church power is Edification 1 Cor. 5. 5. 2 Cor. 10. 8. 2. Cor. 13. 10. They have distinct Courts of officers : In the Old Testament , the distinction of the civil & Ecclesiastick Sanhedrin is known , where there were distinct causes , & Persons set over them to judge them respectively 2. Chron. 19. ult . In the New Testament , we find officers given unto the Church 1 Cor. 12. 28. with no mention of the civil Magistrate at all , And Church-Assemblies distinct from Parliaments or senats ( yea when the Magistrate was an Enemy ) determining questions that did not belong to the Magistrate at all Act. 15. we have Rulers distinct from the Rulers of the Common wealth 1 Thess. 5. 12. whom we are to obey and submit our selves as those who are accountable to Christ only , for to whom else can they give account of souls ? Heb. 13. 17. we have Rulers inferiour to Labourers in word & doctrine , not to be honoured so much as they : Sure these cannot be civil Rulers 1 Tim. 5. 17. we have Rulers commended for trying Impostors , which were not Magistrats , Rev. 2. 2. And others who are rebuked for suffering Hereticks ibid. vers . 14 , 15 , 20. which supposes they had Authority to do it ; yet distinct from & not depending on the Magistrate . Besides from this confusion of the two Governments together , and making the Supreme Magistrate to be Supreme Governour of the Church , would follow many absurdities ; as that They who are not Church members should be Church officers , even Heathen Magistrats ; yea women should be Church officers ; and none should be chosen for Magistrats , but such as have the qualifications of Church officers . Sic Apol. Relat. Sect. 12. pag. 190. Rectius Instruen . Confut. 1 Dial. chap. 6. pag. 50. Hence , they that in deriving their Authority do confound the tuo Governments , civil & Ecclesiastick , and take it all from a meer civil power , cannot be ouned as having any Authority of Christs Institution : But the Prelats & their Curats , in deriving their Authority , do confound the tuo Governments civil & Ecclesiastick and take it all from a meer civil power . This same Argument equally militates against hearing the Indulged Ministers who have taken a Licence & warrand from the Usurper of this Supremacy : because it is highly injurious to Christs Headship ; very contrary to to Presbyterian Principles ; clearly Homologatorie of the Supremacy ; plainly Prejudicial to the power of the people ; very much establishing Erastianisme ; Sadly obstructive & destructive to the good of the Church ; wronging our cause & ground of suffering ; Strengthening the Prelats hands ; contradictory to our Covenants ▪ Prejudging the Meetings of Gods people ; and heinously Scandalous & offensive : As is clear by , & unanswerably poven in the History of the Indulgence . IV. There is a necessity that any man whom we may Joine with as a Minister , must not only be a minister , and a Minister cloathed with Christs commission then when we Joins with Him , but He must also have a right to administer there where we Ioin with Him. Else we can look upon him no otherwise than a thief & a robber . whom Christs sheep should not hear Io. 10. 1-5 . Now the Prelats & Curats , though they should he accounted & acknowledged Ministers , yet they have not a right to officiate where they have intruded themselves . Hence we have several Arguments , as . 1. They who have no just Authority , nor right to officiate fixedly in this Church as the proper Pastors of it , ought not to be Received but withdrawen from : But the Prelats & their Curats have no just Authority , or right to officiate in this Church as her proper Pastors : Therefore they ought not to be received , but withdrawen from . All the debate is about the Minor , which may thus be made good . They who have entered into & do officiate fixedly in this Church , without her Authority & Consent , have no right so to do : But the Prelats & their Curats have entered into & officiate fixedly in this Church , without her Authority & Consent : Ergo — The Major is manifest : for if this Church have a just right & power of Electing & Calling of Ministers , then they who enter into & officiate fixedly in this Church , without her Authority & Consent , have no just Authority or right so to do : But this Church hath a just right & power of Electing & Calling of Ministers , as all true Churches have And , if it were not evident from what is said above , might be easily demonstrated from Scripture . The minor , to wit , that the Prelats & their Curats have entered into & officiate fixedly in this Church , without her Authority & consent , is evident , from matter of fact : for there was no Church Judicatory called or convocated , for bringing of Prelats in to this Church ; but on the contrary her Judicatories were all cashiered & discharged , and all her officers turned out to let them in ; And all was done immediatly by the King & Acts of Parliament without the Church ; A practice wanting a Precedent in this and ( for any thing we know ) in all other Churches : All that the Curats can say is , that they came in by the Bishop & Patron , who are not the Church , nor have any power from her for what they do ; all their right & power is founded upon & derived from the Supremacy , whereby the Diocesan Erastian Prelat is made the Kings Delegate & substitute , only impowered thereto by his Law. This is Mr Smiths 1 st & 6 Argum. If we suppose a particular Congregation acknowledging their oun Lawful Pastor , and a few violent Persons arise and bring in a Minister by plain force , and cast out their Lawful Pastor ; Are not the faithful in that Church obliged to relinquish the Intruder , and not only Discountenance him , but endeavour his ejection ? This is our case Napth . Pag. 106. § 5. Prior Edit . 2. If we cannot submit to these Curats , without consenting to the great Encroachments made upon the Priviledges of this Church , then we cannot submit to them without sin : But we cannot submit to them without consenting to the great Encroachments made upon the Priviledges of this Church : Therefore we cannot submit to them without sin . The Minor is all the question : but instances will make it out . As first , The robbing of the Church of the Priviledge of Election of her Pastors , and substituting the bondage of Patrons presentations , is a great Encroachment upon the Priviledge of this Church : But accepting of Curats as Ministers Lawfully called , notwithstanding that they want the Election of the people , and have nothing for their warrant but a presentation from the Patron , were a Consenting to that Robberie and wicked Substitution . It will be of no force to say , our forefathers did submit to this , and to a Ministry who had no other Call. This is answered above in the Narrative : It s a poor Consequence to say , the posterity may return backward , because their forefathers could not advance further forward . Secondly , the thrusting out of Lawfull Ministers without any Cause but their adhering to the Covenanted work of Reformation , and the thrusting in others in their rooms who denyed the same , is a great Encroachment on the Churches Priviledges ; But embracing & encouraging Curats by countenancing their pretended Ministry were a consenting to this violent extrusion & intrusion . The minor is proven thus . They who leave the extruded & countenance the Intruded , they consent to the extrusion & intrusion , and declare they confess the Intruded his right is better than his who is extruded ; But they who embrace & encourage Curats by countenancing their pretended Ministry , do leave the extruded , to wit , their old Ministers , and countenance the intruded : Ergo — To say , that people in this case should protest against these Encroachments , is frivolous ; for withdrawing is the best protestation : And if after their protestation they still countenance the Encroachment , they should undo their oun protestation . The same Argument will militate against countenancing the Indulged , or any that obtained Authority to Preach in any place by a power encroaching on the Churches Liberties . There is an objection to be removed here , from Math. 23. 2 , 3. The Scribes & Pharisees sit in Moses Chair , therefore whatever they bid yow observe , that observe & do ; therefore they who without a title usurpe the office may be heard . Ans. 1. The case is no wayes alike ; for then the Lord had no other Church in the world but that , which was confined in its Solemnities of worship to that place , where they intruded themselves : He had not yet instituted the New Testament forme of Administration , in its ordinances & Officers . Therefore the Head of the Church being present might give a Toleration , Durante beneplacito : But it is not so now . But 2. Our Lords words bears no command for the people to hear them at all , but only not to reject sound Doctrine , because it came from them : Surely he would not bid them hear such , as He calls Plants that His Father had never planted , whom He bids let alone , Math. 15. 13 , 14. and who were Thieves & Robbers whom His Sheep should not hear . V. They must not only be Ministers , & acknowledged as such then and there , when & where we joine with them ; but they must be such as we can oune Church Communion with in the Ordinances administrated by them , as to the matter of them . Otherwise if they pervert & corrupt their Ministrie , by preaching & maintaining errors , either in Doctrine , Worship , Discipline , or Government , contrare to the Scriptures , our Confessions , & principles of our Covenanted Reformation , and contradictory to our Testimony founded thereupon & aggreable thereunto , maintaining errors condemned thereby , or condemning Truths maintained thereby , we must withdraw from them . For if any seek to turn us away from the Lord our God , we most put away that evil & not consent nor hearken to them , Deut. 13. 5 , 8. We must cease to hear the instruction that causeth to erre from the words of knowledge , Prov. 19. 27. we must have a care of these Leaders that will cause us to erre lest we be destroyed with them Isa. 9. 16. we must mark these who contradict the Doctrine that we have Learned , & avoid them Rom. 16. 17. If any man teach otherwise we must withdraw our selves from such 1 Tim. 6. 3 , 5. If there come any & bring not this Doctrine , we must not receive him , nor bid him God speed , in that work of his preaching or practising against any of the Truths , we have received from the word 2 Iohn 10 , 11. Hence we most not hear false Teachers , who in preaching & prayer bring forth false Doctrine contrary to the principles of our Reformation : But the Curats are false Teachers , who in preaching & prayer bring forth salse Doctrine &c. Therefore we must not hear them . The Minor is certain , in that not only many of them are tainted with points of Poperie & Ar●inianisme ; but all of them do teach false Doctrine tending to seduce the hearers ; when in their preaching they cry up the Lawfullnesse of Prelacy , and vent bitter invectives against Presbyterian Government , condemn the work of Reformation , and enveigh against the Covenant , and so teach & encourage people to follow them in open perjurie , and condemning all our Testimony , as nothing but Treason & Sedition ; which we are perswaded is Truth , and that therefore they are Blasphemers : And in their prayers , stuffed with error & larded with Blasphemy , they reproach the work of Reformation , & the power of Godlyness , and pray for a blessing on the Prelats , and on their courses which are cursed ; besides their parasitick prayers for the King , to be blessed in his Government when stated in opposition to Christ , and severall other things that tender consciences cannot go along with them therein . And yet if they hear them they must go along and actively concur with them , as their mouth to God. If it be obj●cted here : That this doth not strike against all , nor against any at all times , because some Preaches always sound Doctrine , and all preach sometime sound Doctrine ; and the like may be said of their prayers : Therefore sometimes at least they may be heard . I ans . 1. This may be alledged for all Hereticks , who do all at sometimes preach sound Doctrine , and yet these Scriptures are stringent against them at all times , which I have adduced : for by these fr●its which they bring forth at sometimes , they shew themselves to be such as we must beware of at all times . 2. We cannot know when they will Preach sound Doctrine , seeing by their subjection to that Government , they are obliged to maintain Prelacy , and impugne our Covenanted constitution . VI. They must not only be such as we can Joine with in the Ordinances as to the Matter of them , but in the manner also they must be such Administrators , as we are obliged in charity to think the Lord will approve of them , & their Administrations , & of us in our Communion with them ; Or at least that in their manner of Dispensing ordinances , they be not such as we find are under a recorded sentance of dreadful punishment , both against them & their partakers : for if it be so , it is as sufficient a ground to withdraw from them , as for men to withdraw from a Company staying in a house , that they see will fall & smother them in its ruin ; yea it is as warrantable to separate from them , as for Israel to separate themselves from the Congregation of the Rebells who were to be consumed in a moment , Numb . 16. 21. or for the Lords people to come out of Babylon , that they receive not of her plagues Rev. 18. 4. Now we find that not only the Prophets of Baal , and Inticers to Idolatrie , and Leaders to error upon the matter are threatened , and the people for adhering to them but we find also ( as is observed by Rect. Instruend . confut . dial . chap. 1. pag. 21. ) many terrible charges & Adjurations laid upon Ministers , in reference to a faithful Diligence in their Ministerial function , and a suitable Testimony concerning the sin & duty of the time , that they are commanded to cry aloud and shew the people their sin , Isa. 58. 1. and as they would not have the blood of souls upon them , to give faithful warning touching the peoples case & hazard , sin , & duty , especially in times of great sin & judgment , when God is terribly pleading His Controversie with them , Ezek. 3. 17. therefore they must be instant in season & out of season 2 Tim. 4. 2. And for their negligence & unfaithfulness herein , we find many Scripture woes & threatenings thundered against them . When in the deceit of their oun heart they promise assured Peace , when the Lord is pleading against a Generation , they are threatened to be consumed with sword & famine , and the people to whom they Prophecie shall be cast out in the Streets , Ier. 14. 13. 15. 16. therefore we dare not admit them to Prophecie to us . When they strengthen the hands & harden the hearts of evil-doers , that none doeth return from his wickedness , the Lord threatens to feed them with wormwood , & commands not to hearken to them , Ier. 23. 14-16 . their blood shall be required at their hands Ezek. 3. 18. one builds a wall , and another daubs it with untempered morter , then ye o great hailstones shall fall , and they shall be consumed in the midst thereof Ezek. 13. 10 , 11 , 14 , 18 , 22. we dare not joine with either builders or daubers of such a work , as is carried on to the dishonour of Christ & ruining of Reformation , nor by our countenance & concurrence strengthen either builders or daubers . lest we also be consumed in the midst thereof . When there is a Conspiracy of the Prophets , and the Priests violate the Law , and profane holy things , and shew no difference between the unclean & the clean then the Lord will pour out His Indignation upon all , Ezek. 22. 25 — ad●fin . We would endeavour to keep our selves free of having any hand in that Conspiracy . These Scriptures do give the perfect pourtracture of our Curats , in the conviction of all that know them . Hence we draw a complexe Argument : Such Ministers as can do no good by their Ministrie , but a great deal of hurt to their hearers , and expose themselves & them both to the Indignation of a jealous God , are not to be heard : But the Curats are such as can do no good by their Ministrie , but a great deal of hurt to their hearers , and expose themselves and them both to the Indignation of the jealous Lord : Therefore they are not to be heard . The connexion of the Major is clear from what is said above . The Minor is also evident from the application of these Scriptures , thus : They that in the deceit of their oun heart promise Peace to , and strengthen the hands of evil doers , and give them not warning , but seduce them by daubing their wickedness , and shew no difference between the unclean & the clean &c. are such as can do no good by their Ministrie , but a great deal of hurt to hearers , and expose themselves and them both to the Indignation of God : But the Curats are such : and all others who are so unfaithful as give no warning against but Justifie the sins of the times . To be short , the Minor of both these foregoing Arguments is evident from the experience of all that go to the Curats , who wrong thereby their oun souls , mar their edification , & run to Cisterns without water . What blessing can be expected upon the labours of such , who having perjured themselves in taking on with the Prelats , are prosecuting that Course of defection , and making themselves Captains to lead the people back to Egypt , encouraging profanity & wickedness , being themselves Patterns & Patrons of the times corruptions ? And seeing a blessing cannot be expected upon their labours , but rather a curse , as daylie experience maketh good , when instead of any work of conversion or conviction among people , there is nothing seen but a fearful hardening in profanity ignorance & Atheisme ; so that many that seemed to have somewhat like Religion before , through hearing of them , are turned loose & laxe in all Duties : yea never can it be instanced these 27 years , that they have brought one soul to Christ , from darkness to light , and from the power of Satan unto God ; but many instances might be given of their murdering souls , as indeed they can not be free of it , who cannot warn nor declare the whole Counsel of God. Hence these who cannot but be soul-Murderers , may not be heard nor intertained as Soul-Phisicians : But the Curats cannot but be soul-Murderers : Again we can expect no good from them , but a great deal of hurt : Seeing their Ministrie is not the Lords Ordrnance , which He will approve , and no performances can be acceptable unto the Lord which are not , in manner as well as in matter aggreeable to His will : hence the wickedness even of the Lords Lawful Priests , not only caused the people to abhor the offerings of the Lord , but even the Lord Himself to abhor His Sanctuary , and to account their incense an abomination , so that He could not away with the Calling of their Assemblies , which yet upon the matter were duties . Should not we then hate that which the Lord hates , and withdraw from that which He hath forsaken ? But the Meetings of the Curats for Administration of Ordinances in their way , the Lord hates , and hath signally forsaken : Therefore we should hate & forsake them . This is confirmed by what Mr Durham sayes in that digression about hearing Revel . 1. pag. 55. in 4 to . seeing edification is Gods gift , can it be expected but in his way , Or can that be accounted His way which He hath not warranted . VII . As we would not partake of their Judgment in countenancing of their Administration of Ordinances , so we would keep our selves free from all participation of their sin . For we must not be partakers with any in sin , nor have fellowship with the unfruitful works of darkness , that we must reprove , and that we find the Lord reproves & condemns , Eph. 5. 7 , 11. And not only Ministers in ordaining , but people in hearing , may be in hazard of partaking of some mens sins who enter into the Ministry 1 Tim. 5. 22. we must keep at the greatest distance from sin . Hence if we cannot hear the Curats without partaking of their sin , then we must not hear them : But we cannot hear the Curats without partaking of their sin . Therefore we must not hear them . The Minor I prove . If hearing of them be a Tessera of our Incorporation with them , ● Test of our Submission to them , a badge of our comp●yance with them , and sign of our Approbation of them , then we cannot hear them without partaking of their sin : But hearing of them is such : The Major cannot be denyed , if Prelacy & conformity therewith be sin , as is in part proven above : for if these be sins , then we must not incorporate with , nor submit to them , nor comply with them , nor approve them . The Minor I prove by Parts . 1. Hearing of Curats is a Tessera of our Incorporation with them . For Communion in Sacred things doth infer an incorporation of the Communicants or Joiners in all cases , both in Lawful & unlawful Communions 1 Cor. 10. 17-20 . All partakers of the bread are one body , and they which eat of the Sacrificies are partakers of the Altar ; And also they that partake of the Sacrifice offered to Devils , though they do not offer it so themselves , yet they are incorporate and have fellowship with Devils . And 2 Cor. 6. 14-17 . where they that do not come out , and are separate from unlawful Communions , are expostulated with as making an unequally yoked fellowship , between righteousness & unrighteousness , light & darkness ; Christ & Belial , the Temple of God & Idols . Hence then , if we cannot partake of their Sacred things without partaking of their Altar , and becoming one body with them ; and making such an unequally yoked Mixture with them , then we must be separate : But the first is true from these places . This Argument concludes with equal force , against joyning with any deeply engaged in the gross defections of the time . 2. Hearing of Curats is a Test of our Submission to them , & Complyance with them : for so it is required by Law , as the Acts themselves say , that a chearful concurrence , countenance , & assistence given to such Ministers , and attending all the ordinary Meetings for divine worship , is an evidence of a due ackowledgment of & hearty complyance with his Maj. Government Ecclesiastical & civil , as now established by Law within this Kingdom , Act of Parl. Iul. 10. 1663. And themselves look on all such as obey this Act , as their friends , Hence if this be sinful to submit to them , and comply with their establishment , in obedience to a sinful Act of Parliament , then it is sinful to hear them : But the former is true , as hath been shown . Ergo — 3. Hence it followes by native consequence , that hearing of Curats is a sign of our Approbation of them : for he that gives that which is required , & accepted , & Interpreted as an evidence of a due acknowledgment , & of complyance with the Government Ecclesiastical , gives the sign of his Approbation of it : But the hearer of Curats does that in obedience to the Act , requiring , accepting , & expressly interpreting it so : Therefore &c. VIII . As we would be free of their sin , in approving of , & complying with their course ; so we must endeavour to stand at the greatest Distance from all appearance of sin in our selves , either by commission or omission , in which our Joining with them in these circumstances would involve us . For we must astain from all appearance of evil 1 Thess. 5. 22. and from every thing that circumstances may make sinful : for otherways suppose a thing might be materially Lawful & not simply sinful , yet circumstances may make it sinful , and a countenancing it so circumstantiated , doth infer a Communion in these Circumstances that make it sinful . They that eat of the sacrifice are Partakers of the Altar , and if the Altar be not of Gods Approbation , the thing offered though otherwise Lawful to be eaten , cannot justify the eaters , so circumstantiated . An Idol is nothing , and that which is offered in Sacrifices to Idols is nothing , yet they who eat of it , when they know it is so circumstantiated , have fellowship with Devils 1 Cor. 10. 18 , 19 , 20 , 21. And it is called Idolatry comp . vers . 14. which provokes the Lord to jealousie vers . 22. Especially when an action is so circumstantiated , that it would infer an omission of our Duty , and a declining from or denying of our Testimony , then it is clearly sinful . For whosoever shall deny the Lord before men , him will He deny before His Father , Math. 10. 33. And we must hold fas● the Profession of our faith without wavering , Heb. 10. 23. and keep the word of His patience , if we would be kept in the hour of tentation , and hold it fast that no man take our Croun Rev. 3. 10 , 11. All Truth must be avowed , & practically avowed , on the greatest hazard : And as this Testimony must be full , so must it be also constant . It was Demass shame , that the afflictions of the Gospel made him forsake the Apostle , after great appearances for Christ : And therefore whatever Truth or Duty is opposed , that becomes the special object of this Testimony . Rectius Instruend . Consut . 3. Dial. chap. 1. pag. 18. 19. Hence , if Hearing of the Curats would infer & involve us under the guilt both of commission of sin , and omission os Duty , then we cannot hear them without sin : But the former is true : Therefore also the Latter . I prove the Minor by Parts . First , that it would infer & involve us under the guilt of Commisssion of sin , All that is said above doth evince it : And besides , palpable breach of Covenant , hereafter to be charged & cleared : And , Idolatrie is a great sin of that na●ur : but the hearing of the Curats doth infer this . Which may be made out , thus : The breach of the sceond Commandment is Idolatrie ( for to make the sins against that Command odious , they are all commprehended under that odious name of worshipping Images ; as the sins against the seventh are called Adultrie , comprehending all unchast thoughts , words , & actions ) Hearing of Curats is a breach of the second Command : Ergo — The Minor I prove thus : Every worship not according to Christs appointment , is a breach of the second Commandment : But hearing of Curats is a worship not according to Christs appointment . Which I prove thus : A worship enjoined by and performed in obedience to a Law , establishing a humane Ordinance in the Church , besides and against the Institution of Christ , is a worship not according to Christs appointment : But the hearing of Curats is a worship enjoined by and performed in obedience to a Law establishing a humane Ordinance , to wit , Diocesan Erastian Prelacy , with the Curats their substitutes . Hence also the second doth follow by necessary consequence , that it would infer & involve us under the guilt of Omission of Duty . For first , if reductively it may involve us under the guilt of Idolatrie & breach of the second Commandment , then it will infer the guilt of omission of these necessary Duties incumbent to the Lords people with a reference to Idolatry ; to make no Covenant with them nor with their Gods , nor let them dwell in the Land lest they make us sin , Exod. 23. 32 , 33 Exod. 34. 14 , 15. to overthrow their Altars , & break their Pillars , and destroy the names of them out of the place Deut. 12. 3. Iudg ▪ 2. 2. I do not adduce these precepts , to stretch them to the full measure of the demerit of the grossest of Idolaters : for as there are degrees of breaches or the Commandment , some grosser some smaller , so there are also degrees of punishment , and as to the manner of destroying & extirpating all pieces of Idolatry : But that the Commands being founded upon a Moral ground , lest they 〈◊〉 & snares unto us , do oblige us to some endeavour 〈…〉 , extirpating & overthrowing all Pieces or 〈◊〉 according to the word and our Covenants ; And 〈…〉 true & right Zeal of God , should and would not only inspire all with an unanimous aversion against the profane intruding Curats , but animate us as one man to drive away these wolves & theives , and to eradicate these plants which our heavenly Father never planted , Napht. Prior edit . pag. 108. The least Duty that can be inferred is that of the Apostles , flee from Idolatry 1 Co , . 10. 14. which Idolatry there mentioned to be avoided , is to eat of the sacrifices offered to Idols : whence we infer that if to eat of things consecrated to Idols be Idolatrie , then also to partake of Sacred things consecrated by Idols must be Idolatry ; as the Curats dispensing of Ordinances is consecrated by , & hath all its Sanction from , an I●ol of Diocesan Erastian Prelacy : But we see the Apostle expresses the former : Therefore we may infer the Latter . Further it will also infer a declining from & denying a Necessary Testimony , in the case circumstantiated . Even the smallest matter is great , when a Testimony is concerned in it , were it but the circumstance of an open window ; Daniel durst not omitt it upon the greatest hazard . And now this is clearly come to a case of confession , when there is no other way to exoner our consciences befor God & the world , and declare our Non-conformity to this course of backsliding , no getting of wrongs redrest or corruptions in the Ministry removed but by this practice : And certainly some way we must give publick Testimony against these courses , and there is no otherway so harmless & innocent as this , though suffering follow upon it Apol. Relat. Sect. 14. 272. 273. And now there is no other way apparent , whereby the difference shall be kept up betuixt such as honestly mind the Covenanted work of Reformation , and the corrupt Prelatical & Malignant Enemies . but this Argument also will infer the expediency of withdrawing , from all Ministers with whom our circumstantiat Joyning would involve us in a participation with their defections . IX . As we would endeavour to avoid Sin in our selves ; So we must have a care to give no occasion of others sinning , by our taking Liberty in a promiscuous Joining in Church Communion , whereby we may offend & stumble the consciences of others : for to that , in this as well as in other things , we must have a special respect , and forbear things not only for our oun unclearness , but for the sake of others also . If therefore the Hearing of Curats be a Scandal , we must refuse it , be the hazard what will. For who so shall offend one of Christs little ones , it were better for him that a milstone were hanged about his neck Math. 18. 6. No man must put a stumbling block or an occasion to fall in his brothers way , Rom. 14. 13. They that sin so against the brethren , and wound their weak Conscience , they sin against Christ 1 Cor. 8. 12. we must forbear somthings for conscience sake , conscience , I say , not our oun but of others , giving none offence neither to the Iewes , nor to the Gentiles , nor to the Church of God , 1. Cor. 10. 28 , 29 , 32. and so cut off all occasion from them that desire occasion 2 Cor. 11. 12. These Commands discharge whatever Practice give occasion of our brothers sinning , of calling Truth in question , of acting with a doubting conscience , or which weakens his Plerophory or assurance ; And neither the Lawfulness nor indifferency of the thing it self , nor mens Authority commanding it , nor the weakness yea or wickedness of those in hazard to be stumbled , will warrand the doing of that out of which offence arises , Rectius Instruend . Confut. 3. Dial. chap. 1. pag. 19. Mr Durham in that forecited place saith , It carries offence along with it ; in reference to the partie who runs unsent , it proves a strengthening & confirming of him , and so a partaking of his sin ; in reference to others , either strengthens them by that example to cast themselves in that snare , which possibly may be their ruine , or it grieves them and makes them sad who are tender of such things , or gives occation to make all difference of that kind to be thought light of . Hence , If Hearing of the Curats be an offence or Scandal , both in reference to Malignants , and in reference to the Godly , and in reference to the Posterity , Then it must be avoided : But the former is true : which is evidenced by parts . First , in reference to Malignants , it hardens & encourages them in their opposition to the work of God , and all backsliders & Complyers with them in their Apostasie ; This strengthens their hands in their wicked courses , when they see how they are countenanced by all , and that there is no disrespect put upon them , nor dissatisfaction evinced against their courses , then they conclude that they are approven of all : And this hardeneth them , so that they never once think of the evil of their wayes . Next in reference to the Godly , it stumbles the truly tender , by encouraging them to do contrare to their light & conscience , even when they are not clear to hear them , then they are emboldened thereunto when they see others doing so ; and so it tends to the wounding of their Peace , and makes them halt in the wayes of the Lord. Lastly with a re●erence to Posterity , it would prejudge them very much : Though now the honest party be not in a capacity to transmit the work of Reformation unto their Posterity , in such a manner as were to be wished ; Yet they should do something for keeping fresh the memory of the good old cause , by keeping up some footsteps of a standing Controversy for Zions Interest against the common enemy : But now let all Joine with , & oune the Curats , what appearance of this shall the Posterity see ? shall not they conclude that the day is lost , & the cause is gone , when they see that this generation hath fled the fields , or rather sold & betrayed the cause , by ouning , countenancing , & complying with the enemy , and no standing Testimony against these corruptions ? whereas if there were but this much of a standing difference , betwixt the People of God & the common Enemies of God , to be seen ; Posterity shall in some measure be kept from being deceived , and shall see the Interest of Christ not killed nor buried quick , but living though in a bleeding condition , and this will occasion their engaging for Christ , and interesting themselves in the quarrel ; and it is far better to see the cause of Christ ouned though , by suffering & blood , then sold & betrayed by base flenching & complying with Persecuters . This Argument may also found & i●ter a withdrawing from the Addressing Ministers who to the Great Scandal of Presbyterians give forth their Addresses in the name of all of that perswasion . X. Our duty to themselves , yea our greatest office of Love we owe to them in order to their conviction , does oblige us to withdraw from them . This may seem a Paradox , yet it will be apparent ; if we search the Scriptures , to see what we owe to Scandalous Brethren . There we find , it is a duty to endeavour by all Lawful means to shame them out of their sin : And it is an argument of hatred , when we do not rebuke our Neighbour or when we suffer sin upon him , Lev. 19. 17. If we consider them then as neighbours & friends , we must use endeavours to take away their sin from them ; if we consider them not as such but as enemies , then we must avoid them , and not be mingled with them , as I could adduce many Scriptures for that . But I suppose all that will oppose my Thesis , would have them considered as friends . Well then , if they be scandalous Brethren , this is the way prescribed by the Apostle to deal with them , in order not to suffer sin upon them , that we should withdraw from them our Company : and if we must withdraw our Company , then also a fortiore , we must deny them our Religious Communion ; for that must either be included there , or necessarly inferred . He writes , not to keep Company if any man that is called a Brother ( mark that speciality ) be a fornicator , or covetous , or an Idolater , or a railer , or an extortioner , with such an one no not to eat 1 Cor. 5. 11. And I presume they that know them best , will grant , that it would not be hard to prove that all the Curats in Scotland were chargable with some of these , or at least Partakers with them . And that if they were all impartially impannelled , they would be rare ones whom an honest Jury would not bring in guilty of this lybel . Then we are expressly Commanded , in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ , to withdraw our selves from every brother that walketh disorderly , and not after the received Tradiction ; and if any man obey not the word , to note him and have no Company with him , that he may be ashamed 2 Thess. 3. 6. 14. Sure neither their office nor their innocency , can exempt them from these rules . For either they must be considered as our brethren , or not : If not , then we oune no Church Communion with them , for that is only among brethren that are so in Sympathie , & affection , & affinity , having one father , and one mother : If they be brethren , Then all Scandalous brethren are to be withdrawn from ; But they are Scandalous brethren : Therefore they are to be withdrawn from . The Minor will not be doubted by any but such as are strangers to them , who both in their Ministerial & Personal Capacity are so scandalous to the Conviction of all , that Profanness hath gone forth from them unto all the Land , and they as much as ever the Profane Sons of Eli , have made men to abhor the offering of the Lord 1 Sam. 2. 17. But even strangers that are unacquaint with their Personal Profligatness & ignorance &c. cannot be altogither ignorant of the Scandal of Prelacy & E●astianisme , in which they are all involved , of the Scandal of Apostasie , Perjurie , & breach of Covenant , which is their brand , and the Nations bane , that hath countenanced them . And none can doubt , but if our Church were dwely constitute and invested with the orderly power of Christ , and in capacity to exerce & improve it , they would soon be censured every Soul of them as Scandalous , as they have been also Previously sentanced as such , by the Acts of our General Abssemblies . This Argument levells also against all Complying , Indulged , Addressing Ministers , who by these Courses have incurred the Character of disorderly Brethren . XI . Our faithfulness to God , and to one another ingaged in our Covenants , doth oblige us to turn away from them who have broken it , and so classed themselves among these Truce-breaking Traitors , who make our times Perillous , from whom we must turn away 2 Tim. 3. 1-5 . It appears from the foregoing deduction , how solemnly these Nations were engaged both to keep out & put out this Generation of Prelatists , now prevailing ; The obligation of which yet lyes upon all the Inhabitants of the Land , with a binding force , both in regard of their forme , and object , and end . Hence if the Curats be Covenant breakers , and we also in ouning them , then we cannot oune them without sin ; But the Curats are Covenant breakers , and we also in ouning them . Ergo — The Minor may be manifest by an indiction of all the Articles of the Solomn League & Covenant , broken by them , and all that oune them 1. That Doctrine , worship , discipline , & Government in the 1. Ar : . sworn to be preserved & propagated , was the Presbyterian then established , which our Church was in possession of , which they have opposed , & their ouners resiled from , and have not maintained . 2. We are engaged in 2. Art. to endeavour the extirpation of Prelacy , and its dependents ; which is diametrically opposite to ouning of Curats : can we oune them whom we are bound to abhor ? and submit to them whom we are bound to extirpate ? Surely this were to rebuild what we have destroyed see Napht. p. 104. And since in relation to Poperie , Heresie , & Schisme , this Article obliges us to disoune , & not to hear Papists & Schismaticks , why not also in relation to Prelatists , who are the greatest Schismaticks ? 3. They have established & homologated an Erastian Supremacy , to the Prejudice of true Religion and the Liberties of the Church & Kingdom , and their ouners have abetted & contenanced the same , and not preserved either the Liberties of Church or Kingdom , contrary to the 3. Art. 4. They have not only concealed & Countenanced Malignant Enemies to this Church & Kingdom , but have themselves been reall Incendiaries hindering the Reformation of Religion , making factions & Parties amongst the People , contrary to this League & Covenant , And their hearers are so far from bringing them to Condign Punishment . that they have strengthened their hands in their avowed opposition to the Covenants , contrary to the 4 Art. 5. They have broken our Conjunction in firme peace & union ; and yet their hearers have not marked & avoided these Causers of Divisions , contrary to Scripture , and the 5 Art. 6. Instead of assisting & defending all these that entered into this League & Covenant &c. they have been the greatest Persecuters of all them that adhered to it ; And their ouners have suffered themselves , by combination or perswasion or terror , to be divided & withdrawn from their suffering Brethren , and have made defection to the contrary part , and given themselves to a detestable indifferency in this cause , contrary to the 6. Art. 7. Instead of humbling themselves for their sins , and going before others in the example of a real Reformation , they have obstinately defended their breach of Covenant , and have been Patrons & Patterns of all deformations ; And their ouners & hearers have not repented of that neither , when they countenance such Covenant-breakers & profane persons , nor of their not labouring for the purity & power of the Gospel , when they seek it from such impure hands : Neither do they go before others in Reformation , when they are such bad examples of defection , contrary to the conclusion of the Covenant . This Argument will also strike against hearing of such Ministers that have made themselves guiltie of the same , or equivalent breaches of Covenant . XII . Finally , for Unions sake , and to avoid Schisme in the body , we must withdraw from them . This may seem another Paradox : but it is apparent , if we consider , that there should be no Schisme in the body , but that the members should have the same care one for another , 1 Cor. 12. 25. And that for to prevent & remede this , the Apostle beseeches us to mark them which Cause Divisions , & offences contrary to the Doctrine which we have learned , & avoid them , Rom. 16. 17. Now then , if the Prelats and their Curats be Schismaticks , & Separatists , and dividers , then we must avoid & withdraw from them : But so it is that the Prelats & their Curats are Schismaticks , & Separatists , and dividers : Therefore we must avoid & withdraw from them . The Minor I prove from all the Constituents of a formed Schisme , Separation , & sinful division . 1. They that start out from under due relations to a Church , and from her Ministry , are Schismaticks , Separatists , & dividers , But the Prelats and their Curats have started out from under due relations to the Covenanted Church of Scotland , & from her Ministry , in being so unnatural rebellious Children , as have broken their Mothers beauty & bands , order & Union , & razed her Covenanted Reformation , in doctrine , worship , Discipline , & Government : 2. These who withdraw from the Communion of a true Church , and therefore are Censureable by all her standing acts , are Schismatical Separatists : But the Prelats and their Curats have withdrawn from the Communion of the true Church of Scotland , and therefore are censureable by all her standing acts , in that they have made a faction & Combination repugnant to the Communion of this Church , and all her established order : 3. Those who Separate from a Church , whose Principles & Practices are subservient to that Churches true Union & Communion and right establishment , are properly Schismaticks : But the Prelats and their Curats have Separated from this Church , whose Principles & practices are subservient to its true Union & Communion and right establishment ; for they could never yet impeach or challenge any Principle or practice , contrary to the word of God , or not subservient to true Union & order , but their Principles & practices are stated in opposition to her purity & Reformation . 4 Those who innovate the worship & Government , ouned & established in a true Church , are Schismaticks : But the Prelats and their Curats have innovated the worship & Government of the true Church of Scotland , in bringing a Doctrine new & odd , and not the voice of this Church ; and their worship , over and above the corruption adhering to it , is the worshiping of an innovating party , contrary to our Churches established order : 5. They that make a rent in the bowels of the true & genuine Church , are the Schismaticks : But the Prelats and their Curats have made a rent in the bowels of this Church , and have caused all the divisions in this Church . 6. Those that divide themselves from the fellowship of a pure Church , either in her Ministry , Lawful Courts , & Ordinances , are the Schismaticks : But the Prelats and their Curats have divided themselves from the fellowship of this pure Church , in her Ministry , Lawful Courts & Ordinances , in that they have caused the ejection of her Ministry , dissipation of her Assemblies , and subversion of her pure Ordinances . 7. Those that break union with such , to whom they were under obligations to adhere , are Schismatical dividers : But the Prelats and their Curats have broken Union with such to whom they were under obligations to adhere , both from the antecedent morally obliging duty , and from the superadded obligation of the Covenants , neither could they ever pretend any thing that might loose the obligation : 8. That party in a Reformed Church , which having overturned her Reformation , hath shut out , laid aside , & persecute away sound adherers thereunto , both Ministers & Professors , & will not admit Ministers to officiate but upon the sinful termes of complyance with their way , are Schismaticks : But the Prelats and their Curats are that party in this Reformed Church , which having overturned her Reformation , hath shut out , laid aside , and Persecute away sound adherers thereunto &c. Therefore they are the Schismaticks to be withdrawn from , and their way is the Schisme , which we are bound to extirpate in the Covenant . HEAD . II. The Sufferings of many for Refusing to oune the Tyrants Authority vindicated . THe other Grand Ordinance of God , Magistracy , which He hath in His Soveraign Wisdom , Justice , & Goodness , appointed , ordained , & consecrated , for the demonstration , illustration , & vindication of His oun Glory , and the Communication , Conservation , and Reparation of the Peace , safety , order , Liberty , and universal good of mankind , is next to that of the Ministry of Greatest Concern : wherein not only the Prudence , Policie , Propertie , & Libertie of men , but also the conscience , Duty , & Religion of Christians , have a special Interest . And therefore it is no less important , pertinent , profitable , & necessary for every one that hath any of these to care & contend for , keep or recover , to inquire into and understand somthing of the institution , constitution , nature , & boundaries of the Sacred ordinance of Magistracy , than into the holy ordinance of the Ministry ; So far at least as may consist with the sphere of every ones Capacity & Station , and may conduce to the satisfaction of every ones conscience , in the discharge of the duties of their relations . Every private man indeed hath neither capacity , concern , nor necessity , to study the Politicks , or search into the secrets , or Intrigues of Government , no more then he is to be versed in all the Administrations of Ecclesiastical Policy , and Interests of the Ministry : yet every mans Conscience is no less concerned , in distinguishing the Character of Gods Ministers of Justice , the Magistrats , to whom he owes & ounes allegiance , that they be not usurping Tyrants , everting the Ordinance of the Magistracy ; than in acknowledging the Character of Christs Ministers of the Gospel , to whom he owes & ounes obedience , that they be not usurping Prelats or Impostors , perverting the Ordinance of the Ministry . The Glory of God is much concerned , in our ouning & keeping pure & intire , according to His will & word , both these Ordinances . And our Conscience as well as Interest is concerned in the advantage or hurt , profit or prejudice , of the right or wrong , observation or prevarication , of both these ordinances ; being interested in the advantage of Magistracy , and hurt of Tyrannie in the State , as well as in the advantage of the Ministry , and hurt of Diocesan or Erastian Supremacy in the Church ; in the advantage of Ltberty , and hurt of slavery in the State , as well as in the advantage of Religion and hurt of Profaneness in the Church ; in the profit of Lawes and prejudice of Prerogative in the State , as well as in the profit of Truth and prejudice of Error in the Church ; in the profit of Peace and true Loyalty , and prejudice of oppression and Rebellion in the State , as well as in the profit of Purity & Unity , and prejudice of Defection & Division or Schisme , in the Church . So that in Conscience , we are no more free to Prostitute our Loyalty & Liberty absolutely , in ouning every Possessor of the Magistracy ; than we are free to Prostitute our Religion & faith implicitely , in ouning every Pretender to the Ministry . This may seem very Paradoxical to some , because so dissonant & dissentient from the vulgar , yea almost Universal and invetrate opinion & Practice of the world , that hitherto hath not been so precise in the matter of Magistracy . And it may seem yet more strange , that not only some should be found to assert this ; but that any should be found so strict and strait-laced , as to adventure upon suffering , and even to Death , for that which hath hitherto been seldom scrupled , by any that were forced to subjection under a yoke , which they had no force to shake off , and wherein Religion seems litle or nothing concerned ; for not ouning the authority of the present Possessors of the place of Government : which seems to be a Question not only excentrick & extrinsick to Religion , but such a State question , as for its thorny Intricacies & difficulties , is more proper for Politicians & Lawyers to dispute about ( as indeed their debates about this head of Authority , have been as manifold & multiplied as about any one thing ) than for Private Christians to search into , and suffer for , as a Part of their Testimony . But if we will cast off Prejudices , and the Tyrannie of Custom , and the bondage of being bound to the worlds Mind in our inquiries about Tyrannie , and suffer our selves to Ponder impartially the importance of this matter ; And then to state the question right ; We shall find Religion & Conscience hath no small interest in this business . They must have no snall Interest in it , if we consider the importance of this matter , either extensively , or objectively , or Subjectively . Extensively considered , it is the Interest of all mankind to know and be resolved in Conscience , whether the Government they are under be of Gods Ordination or of the Devils administration ; whether it be Magistracy or Tyrannie ; whether it gives security for Religion & Liberty , to themselves and their posterity , or whether it induces upon themselves , and entails upon the posterity , slavery as to both these invaluable Interests ; whether they have matter of praise to God for the blessings & mercies of Magistracy , or matter of Mourning for the plagues & miseries of Tyrannie , to the end they may know both the sins & snares , Duties & dangers , Case & Crisis , of the times they ●ive in . All men that ever enjoyed the mercy of a right Constitute Magistracy , have experienced , and were bound to bless God for the blessed fruits of it : And on the other hand , the world is full of the Tragical Monuments of Tyrannie , for which men were bound bath to search into the Causes , and see the effects of such plagues from the Lord , to the end they might mourn over both . And from the begining it hath been observed , that as Peoples sins have alwayes procured the Scourge of Tyrannie ; So all their miseries might be refounded upon Tyrants encroachments , Usurping upon or betraying their Trust , and overturning Religion , Lawes , & Liberties . Certainly Mankind is concerned in point of Interest & Conscience , to inquire into the cause & Cure of this Epidemick distemper , that hath so long held the world in miserie , and so habitually , that now it is become as it were Natural to lye stupidly under it ; that is , that old Ingrained Gangrene of the Kings Evil , or Complyance with Tyrannie ; that hath long afflicted the Kingdoms of the world , and affected not only their backs in bearing the burden thereof ; but thir hearts into a Lethargick stupor of insensibleness ; and their heads in infatuating & intoxicating them with Notions of the Sacredness & incontroulablness of Tyrannie ; and their hands in infeebling and fettering them from all attempts to work a Cure : Or else it hath had another effect on many that have been sensible of a touch of it ; even equivalent to that , which an ingenious Author Mr Gee in his Preface to the Divine right & Original of the Civil Magistrate ( to which Mr Durham is not absonant ) expounds to be the effect of the fourth vial , Rev. 16. 8 , 9. when in these Dog-dayes of the world , power is given to the Sun of Imperial , especially Popish , Tyannie , by their exorbitant streaches of absolute Prerogative , to scorch men with fire of furious oppressions , they then blaspheme the Name of God which hath power over these Plagues , in their Mal-content Complaints , grumblings , grudgings , and Murmurings under the miserie , but they do not repent nor give Him Glory , in mourning over the causes promeriting such a Plague , and their oun accession in exposing themselves to such a scorching sun , nakedly without a Sconce . Certainly this would be the remedy that Conscience would suggest , and Interest would incite to , an endeavour either of allaying the heat , or of subtracting from it under a shelter , by declining the oblique Malignity of its Scorching rayes . But will the world never be a wakened out of this Dream & dotage , of Dull & stupid subjection to every Monster that can Mount a Throne ? Sure at length it may be expected , either Conscience from within as Gods deputy , challenging for the palpable perversion of this His excellent Ordinance , Or Iudgments from without , making sensible of the effects of it , will convince & confute these old inveterate Prejudices . And then these Martyrs for that universal Interest of mankind , who got the fore-start and the first sight of this , will not be so flouted as fools , as now they are . And who knoweth , what Prelude or Preparative , fore-boding & presaging the doun fal of Tyranny , may be in its aspirings to this hight of arbitrary absoluteness , and in the many questions raised about it , and by them imposed upon Consciences to be resolved . If we consider the object of this question ; as Conscience can only clear it , so in nothing can it be more concerned . It is that Great Ordinance of God , most signally impressed by a very Sacred & illustrious Character of the Glorious Majestie of the Most High , who hath appointed Magistracy ; in which , considering either its fountain , or Dignity , ends , or effects , Conscience must have a very great Concern . The fountain or efficient cause of Magistracy , is high & sublime . The powers that are be of God , not only by the all disposing hand of God in His Providence , as Tyranny is , nor only by way of naked approbation , but by Divine institution ; And that not only in the general , by at least a Secondary Law of Nature , but also the special investiture of it , in Institution & Constitution , is from God ; and therefore they are said to be ordained of God , to which Ordinance we must be subject , not only for wrath but also for Conscience sake ; which is the Great Duty required in the fifth Command , the first Commandment with Promise ; that hath the Priority of Place befor all the Second table , because the other Commandments respect each some one Interest , this hath a supereminent influence upon all . But Tyrannical powers are not of God in this sense . And it were Blasphemie to assert they were of the Lords Authorization , Conscience cannot bind to a subjection to this . Again the Dignity of Magistracy , ordained for the maintenance of Truth & righteousness , the only foundations of peoples felicity , whether temporal or eternal , including the bonds & boundaries of all obedience & subjection , for which they are intended & to which they refer , is supereminent ; as that Epithet of higher added to the powers that are of God , may be rendered ; making them high & sublime in Glory , whose highest prerogative is , that being Gods Ministers , they sit in the Throne of God , anointed of the Lord , judging not for man but for the Lord , as the Scripture speaks . To this Conscience is concerned in duty to render honour as due , by the Prescript of the fifth Commandment : but for Tyranny , Conscience is bound to deny it , because not due ; no more than obedience , which Conscience dare not pay to a Throne of Iniqulty , and a Throne of the Devil , as Tyranny may be called as really as Magistracy is called the Throne of God. Next Conscience is much concerned in the ends of Magistracy , which are the Greatest , the Glory of God and the good of Mankind . And in the effects of it , the maintenance of Truth , Righteousness , Religion , Liberty , Peace , & Safety , and all choicest external blessings : But the ends & effects of Tyranny are quite Contrary , Domineering for pleasure , and destroying for profit . Can we think that Conscience is nothing Concerned here , that these great ends shall be subverted , and the effects precluded ; and to that effect , that Tyrannie not only be shrouded under a Priviledge of impunity , but by our subjection & acknowledment of it , as a Lawful power , encouraged into all enormities , and Licensed to usurpe , not only our Liberties , but Gods Throne by an uncontroulable Soveraignty ? But if we Consider the subjective Concern of Conscience , it must be very great : when it is the only thing that prompts to subjection , that regulats subjection , and is a bottom for subjection to lawful powers . If it were not out of Conscience , men that are free born are naturally such Lovers of Liberty , and under Corruption such lusters after Licenciousness , that they would never come under the Order of this Ordinance , except constrained for wraths sake : but now , understanding that they that resist the power resist the Ordinance of God , and they that resist shall receive to themselves Damnation , they must needs be subject , not only for wrath , but also for Conscience sake . If Conscience were not exercised in regulating our duty to Magistrats , we would either obey none , or else would observe all their Commands promiscously , Lawful or unlawful , and would make no difference either of the matter commanded , or the power commanding : but now , understanding that we must obey God rather then man , and that we must render to all their dues , fear to whom fear , honour to whom honour , Conscience regulats us what & whom to obey . And without conscience there is litle hope for Government to prove either beneficial or permanent : litle likelyhood of either a reall , regular , or durable subjection to it . The discernible standing of Government upon conscientious grounds , is the only thing that can bring in conscience , & a conscientious submission to it ; it being the highest & most kindly principle of , and the strongest & most lasting obligation to , any relative duty . It will not be Liberty of Conscience ( as sayeth the late Declaration for it ) but reality of conscience , and Government founded upon a bottom of conscience , that will Unite the Governed to the Governours by inclination as well as duty . And if that be , then there is needful a rule of Gods revealed preceptive will ( the only Cynosure & Empress of conscience ) touching the founding & erecting of Government , that it have the stamp of Gods Authority . It must needs then follow that conscience hath a very great concernment in this question in the General , and that before it be forced to an abandoning of its light in a matter of such moments , it will rather oblige people that are conscientious to suffer the worst that Tyrants can do ; especially when it is imposed & obtruded upon conscince , to give its suffrage & express acknowledment that the present Tyranny is the Authority of God , which is so visible in the view of all that have their eyes open , that the meanest capacity that was never conversant in Lawes & Politicks can give this verdict that the Constitution & administration of the Government of the tuo Royal Brothers , under whose burthen the earth and we have been groaning these 27 years past , hath been a compleat & Habitual Tyranny , and can no more be ouned to be Magistracy the● Robbery can be acknowledged to be a rightful possession . It is so plain , that I need not the help of Lawyers & Politicians to demonstrate it , nor lanch into the Ocean of their endless debates in handling the head of Magistracy & Tyrannie : yet I shall improve what help I find in our most approved Authors who have enlarged upon this Question ( though not as I must state it ) to dilucidate the matter in Thesi , and refer to the foregoing Deduction of the succession of Testimonies against Tyranny , to clear it in Hypothesi . Whence we may see the occasion , and clearly gather the solution of the Question , which is this . Whether a people , long oppressed with the encroachments of Tyrants & Usurpers , may disoune their pretended Authority ; & when imposed upon to acknowledge it ; may rather chiefe to suffer than to oune it ? To clear this question : I shall first premit some concessions , and then come more formally to resolve it . I. It must be granted the Question is extraordinary , and never so stated by any writer on this head ; which makes it the more difficult , and odious , because odd & singular , in the esteem of those who take up opinions rather from the number of votes than from the weight of the reasons of the asserters of them . It will also be yeelded , that this was never a case of confession for Christians to suffer upon . And the reason of both is , because , before these seven years past , this was never imposed upon private & common subjects to give an account of their thoughts & conscience about the Lawfulness of the Government they lived under . Conquerers & Usurpers sometimes have demanded an acknowledgment of their Authority ; from men of greatest note & stroke in the Countries they have seised : but they never since the Creation urged it upon common people , as a Test of Loyalty ; but thought alwayes their Lawes , & power to execute them on offenders , did secure their subjection . Or otherwise to what purpose are Lawes made , and the execution of them committed to men in power , if they be not thought a sufficient fence for the Authority that makes them ; except it also have the actual acknowledgment of the subjects to ratify it ? Men that are really invested with Authority , would think it both a disparagment to their Authority , and would disdain such a suspicion of the questionableness of it , as to put it as a queston to the subjects , whether they ouned it or not . But the Gentlemen that rule us , have fallen upon a piece of unprecedented Policy : wherein they think both to involve the Nation in the guilt of their unparalelled Rebellion against the Lord , by ouning that Authority that promotes it , and so secure their Usurpations , either by the suffrage of all that oune them , or by the exstirpation of the Consciencious that dare not , with the odium & obli●uie of being enemies to Authority ; by which Trick they think to bury the honour of their Testimony . Yet in sobriety without Prophecying it may be presumed , at the long run this project will prove very prejudicial to their Interest : and herein they may verify that Scots Proverb , ov'r fast ov'r loose , and accomplish these Divine sayings He disappointeth the devices of the Crafty , He taketh the wise in their oun Craftiness , and the Counsel of the froward is carried head long . For as they have put people upon this question , who would not otherwise have made such inquiries into it ; and now finding they must be resolved in conscience to answer it , when ever they shall be brought before them ; upon a very overly search , they see terrible Tyranny witten in legible bloody Characters almost on all administrations of the Government , and so come to be fixed in the verdict that their conscience & the word of God gives of it : So it may be thought , this question now started , for as despicable beginings it hath , yet ere it come to a ful & final Decision , will be more inquired into through the world , and at length prove as fatal to Tyranny , as ever any thing could be , and then they may know whom to thank . But however though the question be extraordinary , and the sufferings thereupon be unprecedented ; And therefore among other contradictions , that may be objected , that neither in History nor Scripture we can find instances of private people their refusing to oune the Authority they were under , nor of their suffering for that refusal : yet nevertheless it may be duty without example . Many things may be done ; though not against the Law of God , yet without a precedent of the practice of the people of God. Though we could not adduce an example for it , yet we can gather it from the Law of God , that Tyranny must not be ouned , this will be equivalent to a thousand examples . Every age in somethings must be a precedent to the following , and I think never did any age produce a more honourable precedent , than this begining to decline a yoke under which all ages have groaned . 2. It will be also granted , It is not always indispensablie necessarie , at all times . for a people to declare their disclaim of the Tyranny they are under , when they cannot shake it off ; nor , when they are staged for their duty before wicked & Tyrannical Judges , is it always necessarie to disoune their pretended Authority positively ; when either they are not urged with questions about it , then they may be silent in reference to that ; or when they are imposed upon to give their judgment of it , they are not alwayes obliged , as in a case of confession , to declare all their mind , especially when such Questions are put to them with a manifest design to entrap their lives , or intangle their Conscience . All Truth is not to be told at all times ; neither are all questions to be answered when impertinently interrogate , but may be both Cautiously & Conscienciously waved . We have Christs oun practice , & his faithful servant Pauls example , for a Pattern of such prudence & Christian caution . But yet it were cruel & unchristian rigour , to censure such as out of a pious principle of zeal to God & conscience of duty , do freely & positively declare their judgment , in an absolute disouning of their pretended Authority , when posed with such Questions , though to the manifest detriment of their lives , they Conscienciously looking upon it as a case of confession . For where the Lord hath not peremptorily astricted His Confessors to such rules of prudence , but hath both promised and usually gives His Spirits Conduct , encouraging & animating them to boldness , so as before hand they should not take thought how or what they shall speak , and in that same hour they find it given them , it were presumption for us to stint them to our rules of prudence . We may indeed find rules to know , what is a case of confession ; but hardly can it be determined , what Truth or duty we are questioned about is not , or may not be , a case of confession . And who can deny , but this may be in some circumstances a case of confession , even Positively to disoune the pretended Authority of a bloody Court or Council ? when either they go out of their Sphere , taking upon them Christs Supremacy , and the Cognizance of the concerns of His Croun , whereof they are Judges no ways Competent ; then they must freely & faithfully be declined . Or when , to the dishonour of Christ , they blaspheme His Authority , and the Sacred boundaries ▪ He hath prescribed to all humane Authority , and will assert an illimited absolute Authority , refusing & discharging all offered Legal & Scriptural restrictions to be put thereupon ( as hath been the case of the most part of these worthy though poor Martyrs , who have died upon this head ) then they must think themselves bound to disoune it . Or when they have done some cruel indignity & despight to the Spirit of God , and to Christ His prerogative & Glory , and work of Reformation , and people , in murdering them without Mercy , and imposing this ouning of their King , by whose Authority all is acted , as a condemnation of these witnesses of Christ their Testimony , and a justification of their bloody cruelties against them , which hath frequently been the case of these poor people that have been staged upon this account : In this case , and several others of this sort that might be mentioned , then they may be free & Positive in disouning this Test of wicked Loyaltie , as the mark of the Dragon of the secular beast of Tyranny . And in many such cases , when the Lord gives the Spirit , I see no reason but that Christs witnesses must follow His Pattern of zeal in the case of confession , which He witnessed before Pontius Pilate in asserting His oun Kingship , as they may in other cases follow His Pattern of Prudence . And why may we not imitate the zeal of Stephen , who called the Council before whom he was staged stiff necked resisters of the Holy Ghost , Persecuters of the Prophets , and betrayers & Murderers of Christ the Just one , as well as the Prudence of Paul ? But however it be , the present Testimony against this pretended Authority Lies in the Negative , which obliges alwayes , semper & ad semper ; that is to say , we plead , that it must never be Ouned . There is a great difference between a Positive disouning , and a not Ouning : though the first be not alwayes necessary , the Latter is the Testimony of the day , and a negative case of confession , which is allwise clearer than the Positive . Though we must not allwise confess every Truth , yet we must never deny any . 3. It is confessed , we are under this sad disadvantage besides others , that not only all our Brethren , groaning under the same yoke with us , will not take the same way of declining this pretended Authority , nor adventure when called to declare their judgment about it ( which we do not condemn , as is said , and would expect from the rules of equity & charity , they will not condemn us , when we find our selves in conscience bound to use greater freedom ) But also some when they do declare their judgment , give it in termes condemnatory of , & contradictory unto our Testimony , in that they have freedom positively to oune this Tyranny , as Authority , and the Tyrant as their Lawful Soveraign . And many of our Ministers also are of the same mind . And further as we have few expressly asserting our part of the debate , as it is now stated : so we have many famous & learned divines expressly against , us in this point , as especially we find in their Comments upon Rom. 13. among whom I cannot dissemble my sorrow to find the great Calvin , saying , saepe solent inquirere &c. men often inquire , by what right they have obtained their power who have the rule ! It should be enough to us that they do govern , for they have not ascended to this eminency by their oun power , but are imposed by the hand of the Lord. As also Pareus saying too much against us . For answer to this I refer to Mr Knox his reply to Lithingtoun , producing several Testimonies of Divines against him upon this very same head ; wherein he shewes , that the occasions of their Discourses & Circumstances wherein they were stated were very far different , from those that have to do with Tyrants & Usurpers , as indeed they that are most concerned and smart most under their scourge are in best case to speak to the purpose . I shall only say , Mens averment in a Case of Conscience is not an oracle , when we look upon it with an impartial eye , in the case wherein we are not prepossessed● it will bear no other value , than what is allayed with the imperfections of fallibility ; and moreover is contradicted by some others , whose Testimony will help us as much to confirm our persuasion , as others will hurt us to infirm it . 4. But now when Tyrants go for Magistrats ; lest my plea against ouning Tyranny , should be mistaken as if it were a pleading for Anarchy : I must assert , that I and all those I am vindicating are for Magistracy , as being of divine Original , institute for the common good of humane & Christian Societies , whereunto every soul must be subject , of whatsoever quality or Character , and not only for wrath but also for conscience sake ( though as to our soul & conscience , we are not subject ) which whosoever resisteth resisteth the ordinance of God , and against which Rebellion is a damnable sin , Whereunto ( according to the fifth Commandment , and the many reiterated exhortations of the Apostles ) we must be subject , and obey Magistrates , and submit ourselves to every Ordinance of man for the Lords sake , whether it be unto the King as Supreme &c. And we account it a hateful brand of them that walk after the flesh , to despise Government , to be presumptuous , self willed , and not afrayed to speakevil of dignities and that they are filthy dreamers who despise Dominion & speakevil of dignities , and of those things which they know not . We allow the Magistrate , in whatsoever form of Government all the power the Scripture , Lawes of Nature or Nations , or Municipal do allow him : Asserting that he is the keeper & avenger of both the Tables of the Law , having a power over the Church as well as the state suited to his Capacity , that is ; not formally Ecclesiastical but objectively for the Churches good ; an external power , of Providing for the Church , & Protecting her from outward violence , or in ward disorder ; an imperate power , of commanding all to do their respective duties ; a Civil power of Punishing all , even Church officers , for Crimes ; a Secundary power of Judicial approbation or condemnation , or discretive , in order to give his Sanction to Synodical results ; a Cumulative power , assisting & strengthening the Church in all her Priviledges , subservient though not servill , Coordinate with Church power not Subordinate ( though as a Christian he is subject ) in his oun affairs , to wit Civil , not to be declined as Judge , but to be obeyed in all things Lawful , and honoured & strengthened with all his dwes . We would give unto Cesar the things that are Cesars , and to God the things that are Gods But to Tyrants , that usurpe & pervert both the things of God & of Cesar , and of the peoples Liberties , we can render none of them , neither Gods , nor Cesars , nor our oun ; Nor can we from conscience give him any other deference , but as an enemy to all , even to God , to Cesar , & the people . And in this , though it doth not sound now with Court parasites , nor with others that are infected with Royal Indulgences & Indemnities , we bring forth but the transumpt of old Principles , according to which our fathers walked when they still contended for Religion & Liberty , against the attemptings & aggressions of Tyranny against both . 5. It must be conceded , it is not an easie thing to make a man in the place of Magistracy a Tyrant . For as every escape , error , or act of unfaithfulness , even known & continued in , whether in a Ministers entry to the Ministry , or in his Doctrine , doth not unminister him , nor give sufficient ground to withdraw from him , or reject him as a Minister of Christ : So neither does every enormity , misdemeanure , or act of Tyranny , Injustice , perfidie , or profanity in the Civil Magistrate , whether as to his way of entry to that office , or in the execution of it , or in his private or personal behaviour , denominate him a Tyrant or usurper , or give sufficient ground to divest him of Magistratical power , and reject him as the Lawful Magistrate . It is not any one or tuo Acts contrary to the Royal Covenant or office , that doth denude a man of the Royal dignity , that God & the people gave him : David committed tuo acts of Tyranny , Murder & Adultery ; yet the people were to acknowledge him as their King ( and so it may be said of some others , ouned still as Kings in Scripture ) the reason is , because though he sinned against a man or some particular persons , yet he did not sin against the State , and the Catholick good of the Kingdom , subverting Law ; for then he would have turned Tyrant , and ceased to have been Lawful King. There is a great difference between a Tyrant in act , and a Tyrant in habit , the first does not cease to be a King. But on the other hand , as every thing will not make a Magistrate to be a Tyrant : So nothing will make a Tyrant habitu , a Magistrate . And as every fault will not unminister a Minister ; So some will oblige the people to reject his Ministry , as if he turn Heretical , & Preach Atheisme , Mahumetanisme , or the like , the people , though they could not formally depose him , or through the corruption of the times could not get him deposed ; yet they might reject & disoune his Ministry : So it will be granted , that a people have more power in creating a Magistrate than in making a Minister , and Consequently they have more right and may have more light in disouning a King , as being unkinged ; than in disouning a Minister , as being un-ministerd . It will be necessary therefore , for clearing our way , to fix upon some ordinary Characters of a Tyrant , which may discriminate him from a Magistrate , and be ground of disouning him as such . I shall rehearse some , from very much approved Authors ; the application of which will be as apposite to the tuo Brothers , that we have been burthened with , as if they had intended a particular & exact description of them . Buchanan de jure regni apud Scotos Shewes that the word Tyran● was at first honourable , being attributed to them that had the full power in their hands , which power was not astricted by any bonds of Lawes , nor obnoxious to the Cognition of Judges , and that it was the usual denomination of Heroes , and thought at first so honourable that it was attribute to the Gods : But as Nero & Iudas were sometimes among the Romans & Iewes names of greatest account , but afterwards by the faults of tuo men of these names , it came to pass that the most flagitious would not have these names given to their Children ; So in process of time , Rulers made this name so infamous by their wicked deeds , that all men abhorred it as contagious & Pestilentious , and thought it a more light reproach to be called a hangman then a Tyrant . Thereafter he Condiscends upon several Characters of a Tyrant . 1. He that doth not receive a Government by the will of the people , but by force invadeth it , or intercepteth it by fraud , is a Tyrant ; and who domineers even over the unwilling ( for Rex volentibus Tyrannus invitis imperat ) and procures the Supreme rule without the peoples Consent , even though for several years they may so govern , that the people shall not think it irksome . Which very well aggrees with the present Gentleman that rules over us , who , after he was by publick vote in Parliament secluded from the Government , of which the standing Lawes of both Kingdoms made him incapable for his Murthers , Adulteries , & Idolatries , by force & fraud did intercept first an Act for His Succession in Scotland , and then the actual Succession in England , by blood & treacherie usurping & intruding himself into the Government , without any Compact with , or Consent of the people ; though now he studies to make himself like another Syracusan Hiero , or the Florentine Cosinodo Medices , in a mild Moderation of his usurped power , but the West of England , and the West of Scotland both , have felt the force of it . 2. Tyrannus non civibus sed sibi gerit imperium , neque publicae utilitatis sed suae voluptatis rationem habet &c. He does not govern for the subjects well-fare or publick ultility but for himself , having no regard to that but to his oun lust ; Acting in this like robbers , who cunningly disposing of what wickedly they have acquired , do seek the praise of Justice by injury , & of Liberality by robbery ; So he can make some shew of a Civil mind , but so much the less assurance gives he of it , that it is manifest he intends not thereby the subjects good , but the greater security of his oun lusts , and stability of empire over posterity , having some what Mitigated the peoples hatred , which when he hath done he will turn back again to his old manners , for the fruit which is to follow may easily be known both by the seed and by the sower thereof . An exact Copy of this we have seen within these tuo years , as oft before in the rule of the other Brother . After God hath been robbed of His prerogatives , the Church of her Priviledges , the State of its Lawes , the Subjects of their Libertie & property , he is now affecting the praise & captating the Applause of tenderness to conscience , and Love of Peace , by offering now Liberty after all his Cruelties ; wherein all the thinking part of men do discern he is prosecuting that hellish Project , introducing Popery & slaverie ; and overturning Religion , Law , & Liberty . 3. Regium imperium secundum Naturam est , Tyrannicum contra , Regium Liberi inter Liberos est Principatus , Tyrannus domini in servas &c. Tyranny is against Nature , and a Masterly Principality over slaves . Can he be called a father , who accounts his subjects slaves ? or a Shepherd , who does not feed but devours his flock ? or a Pilot , who doth allwise study to make shipwrack of the goods , and strikes a leak in the very ship where he sails ? what is he then that bears Command , not for the peoples advantage , but studies only himself , who leadeth his subjects into manifest snares ? he shall not verily be accounted by me either Commander . Emperour , or Governour ? King Iames the 6 th also , in a speech to the Parliament anno 1609. makes this one Character of a Tyrant , when he begins to invade his subjects rights & Liberties . And if this be true , then we have not had a King these many years : the foregoing deduction will demonstrate , what a slavery we have been under . 4. Quid qui non de virtute certet c●m bonis &c. What is he then , who doth not contend for vertue with the good , but to exceed the most flagitious in vices ? If yow see then any usurping the Royal name , and not excelling in any virtue , but striving to exceed all in baseness , not tendering his subjects good with native affection , but pressing them with proud domination , esteeming the people committed to his trust not for their safegaurd but for his oun gain ; will yow imagine this man is truly a King , albeit he vapours with a numerous Lieveguard , and makes an ostentation of gorgeous Pomp ? The learned Althusius likewise in his Politicks cap. 38. Num. 15. ( as He is cited by Ius Populi chap. 16. Pag. 347. ) makes this one Character of a Tyrant , that liveing in Luxury , whoredome , greed , & idleness , he neglecteth or is unfit for his office . How these suite our times we need not express ; what effrontry of impudence is it , for such monsters to pretend to rule by virtue of any Authority derived from God , who pollute the world with their Adulteries & Incests , and Live in open defyance of all the Lawes of the universal King ; with whom to exceed in all villanies is the way to purchase the Countenance of the Court , and to aspire to preferment ? No Heliogabulus &c. could ever come up the length in wickedness , that our Rulers have professed . 5. Omnium vim Legum in se transferre &c. He can transfer unto himself the strength of all Lawes , and abrogate them when he pleases . King Iames the 6. in that fore-cited speech saith , a King degenerateth into a Tyrant when he leaveth to rule by Law. Althusius also loc . cit . saith , there is one kind of Tyranny which consisteth in violating , changing , or removing of fundamental Lawes , specially such as concern Religion ; such , saith he , Philip the King of Spain , who , contrare to the fundamental Belgick Lawes , did erect an administration of Justice by force of armes ; and such was Charles the 9 th of France , that thought to overturn the Salicque Law. All that knoweth what hath been done in Britain these 27 years , can attest our Lawes have been subverted , the Reformation of Religion overturned , and all our best Lawes rescinded ; and now the Penal Statuts against Papists disabled & stopped , without & against Law. 6. Ad suum eum unius nutum omnia &c. He can revoke all things to his nod at his pleasure . This is also one part of King Iames the 6 his Character of a Tyrant , when he sets upon arbitrary power . And of Althusius loc . cit . when he makes use of an absolute Power , and so breaks all bonds for the good of humane Society . We allow a King an absolute power taken in a good sense , that is , he is not subaltern nor subordinate to any other Prince ; but supreme in his oun dominions : or if by absolute be meant Perfect , he is most absolute that governs best according to the word of God. But if it be to be Legibus solutus , loosed from all Lawes , we thinke it blasphemy to ascribe it to any Creature . Where was there ever such an arbitrary & absolute power arrogated by any Mortal , as hath been claimed by our Rulers these years past ? especially by the present Usurper , who , in this Liberty of conscience now granted to Scotland , assumes to himself an absolute power which all are to obey without reserve , which carries the subjects slavery many stages beyond what ever the Grand Seigneur did attempt . 7. Tyranno — ad cives opprumendos &c. For by a Tyrant strangers are imployed to oppress the subjects ; They place the establishment of ther Authority in the peoples weakness , and think that a Kingdom is not a Procuration concredited to them by God , but rather a prey fallen into their hands ; Such are not joined to us by any Civil bond , or any bond of humanity , but should be accounted the most Capital enemies of God and of all men . King Iames ub , supra sayes , he is a Tyrant that imposes un Lawful Taxes , raises forces , makes war upon his subjects , to Pillage , Plnnder , wast , & spoil his Kingdoms . Althusins ubi supra makes a Tyrant , who by immoderate exactions , and the like , exhausts the subjects , and cites Scripture Ier. 22. 13. 14. Ezek. 34. 1 King. 12. 19. Psal. 14. 4. It is a famous saying of Bracton , He is no longer King ; then dum bene regit , while he rules well , but a Tyrant when-soever he oppresseth the people that are trusted to his Care & Government . And Cicero sayes , amittitis omne exceritus & imperit jiu , qui eo imperio & exercit● Rempublicans oppugnat . He loseth all legal power in & over an Army or Empire , who by that Government & army does obstruct the wel-fare of that republick . What oppressions & exactions by armed force our Nation hath been wasted with , in part is discovered above . 8. Althusius in the place above quoted , makes this an other mark , when he keepeth not his faith & promise , but despiseth his very oath made unto the people . What shall we say of him then , who not only brake but burnt , and made it Criminal to assert the obligation of the most solemnly transacted Covenant with God and with the people , that ever was entered into , who yet upon these termes of keeping that Covenant only was admitted to the Government ? And what shall we say of his Brother succeeding , who disdains all bonds , whose professed principle is , as a Papist to keep no faith to Hereticks ? 9. In the same place he makes this on Character : a Tyrants is he , who takes away from one or moe members of the common wealth the free exercise of the Orthodox Religion , And the Grave Author of the Impartial inquiry into the administration of affairs in England , doeth assert pag. 3 , 4. whensoever a Prince becomes depraved to that degree of wickedness , as to apply & employ his power & Interest , to debauch & withdraw his subjects from their fealty & obedience to God , or sets himself to extirpate that Religion which the Lord hath revealed & appointed to be the rule of our living & the means of our happiness , he doth ipso facto depose himself , and instead of being ouned any longer for a King , ought to be treated as a Rebel & Traiter against the Supreme & Universal Soveraign . This is the perfect Protracture of our Princes ; the former of which , declared an open war against Religion & all that professed it ; and the Latter did begin to prosecute it with the same cruelty of persecution , and yet continues without relenting against us ; though to others he tolerates it under the Notion of a Crime , to be for the present dispensed with , until he accomplish his design . 10. Ibid. he tells us , that for corrupting of youth he erecteth stage plages , Whore-houses , & other Play-houses , and suffers the Colledges & other Seminaries of Learning to be corrupted . There was never more of this in any age , than in the conduct of our Court , which like another Sodom profess it to be their design to debauch mankind in to all villanies , and to poison the fountains of all learning & virtue , by intruding the basest of men into the place of teachers , both in Church & University , and precluding all access to honest men . 11. Further he sayes , he is a Tyrant who doth not defend his subjects from injuries when he may , but suffereth them to be oppressed ( and what if he oppress them himself ? ) It was one of the Lawes of Edward the Confessor , Quod si Rex desit officio , nomen Regis in eo non constabit . If the King fail in the discharge of his Trust & office , he no longer deserves nor ought to enjoy that name . What name do they deserve then , who not only fail in the duty of defending their subjects , but send out their Lictors & bloody Executioners to oppress them , neither will suffer them to defend themselves ! But Althusius makes a distinct Character of this . 12. Then in fine , he must certainly be a Tyrant , who will not suffer the people , by themselves nor by their Representatives , to maintain their oun rights , neither by Law nor force : for , sayeth my Author Forecited , he is a Tyrant who hindereth the free suffrages of members of Parliament , so that they dare not speak what they would ; And chiefly he who takes away from the people all power to resist his Tyranny , as Armes , strengths , & chief men , whom therefore though innocent he hateth , afflicteth , & persecuteth , exhausts their goods & livelyhoods , without right or reason . All know that our blades have been all alongs enemies to Parliaments ; and when their Interest forced to call them , what means were used always to pacque & prelimit them and over-aw them , and how men who have faithfully discharged their trust in them have been prosecuted with the hight of envy & fury , and many murthered thereupon ; And how all the armed force of the Kingdoms have been inhanced into their hand , and the people kept so under foot , that they have been rendered incapable either to defend their oun from intestine Usurpers , or forreign Invaders . All that is said amounts to this , that when ever men in power do evert & subvert all the ends of Government , and intrude themselves upon it , and abuse it , to the hurt of the Common wealth , and the destruction of that for which Government was appointed ; They are then Tyrants , and cease to be Magistrates . To this purpose I shall here append the words of that forecited Ingenious Author of the Impartial Enquirie Pap. 13. 14. There can be nothing more evident from the light of reason as well as Scripture , than that all Magistracy is appointed for the benefite of mankind and the common good of Societies : God never gave any one power to reign over others for their destruction ( unless by His providence where He had devoted a people for their sins to ruine ) but on whomsoever He confers Authority over Cities or Nations , it is with this Conditional Proviso & Limitation , that they are to Promote their Prosperity & good , and to study their defence & Protection : All Princes are thus far Pactional — And whosoever refuseth to perform this fundamental condition , he degrades & deposes himself , nor is it rebellion in any to resist him ; whensoever Princes ceases to be for the common good , they answer not the end they were instituted unto , and cease to be what they were chosen for . 6. It will not be denyed but when the Case is so circumstantiate , that it would require the arbitration of judgment to determine whether the King be a Tyrant or not , that then people are not to disoune him : for if it be a question , whether the people be really robbed of their rights & Liberties , and that the King might pretend as much reason to complain of the people their doing indignity to his Soveraignty , as they might of his Tyranny ; Then it were hard for them to assume so for the umpirage of their oun Cause , as to make themselves absolute judges of it , and forth with to reject his Authority upon these debateable grounds . But the Case is not so with us : no Place being left for doubt or debate , but that our fundamental rights & Liberties Civil & Religious are overturned , and an absolute Tyranny exactly Characterized as above is established on the ruines thereof . Hence we have not disouned the pretended Authority , because we judged it was Tyrannical , but because it was really so . Our discretive judgment in the case was not our rule , but it was our understanding of the rule , by which only we could be regulated and not by the understanding of another , which cannot be better nor so good of our grievances , which certainly we may be supposed to understand best our selves , and yet they are such as are understood every where . To the question then , who shall be Judge between these Usurping & Tyrannizing Rulers & us ? we answer briefly & plainly , We do not usu●p a judgment in the case , pretending no more Authority over them in our private Capacity than we allow them to have over us , that is none at all ? Nor can we admit that they should be both Judges & party ; for then they might challenge that prerogative in every case , and strengthen themselves in an incontrollable immunity & impunity to do what they pleased . But we appeal to the fundamental Lawes of the Kingdom , aggreeable to the word of God , to Judge , and to the whole world of impartial Spectators to read & pronounce the judgment . L●x Rex Quest. 24. Pag. 213. sayeth in answer to this : There is a Court of Necessity no less than a Court of Justice ; And the fundamental Lawes must then speak , and it is with the people in this extremity as if they had no ruler . And as to the doubtsomness of these Lawes he sayeth ( 1 ) As the Scriptures in all fundamentals are clear ▪ & expone themselves , & actu primo condemn Heresies : So all Lawes of men in their fundamentals , which are the Law of Nature & Nations , are clear ( 2 ) Tyranny is more visible & intelligible than Heresie , and it s soon discerned — The people have a Natural Throne of Policy in their conscience , to give warning , & materially sentence against the King as a Tyrant — where Tyranny is more obscure ; and the thread smal that it escape the eye of man , the King keepeth Possession , but I deny that Tyranny can be obscure long . 7. I shall grant that many things are yeeldable even to a Grassant Dominator , & Tyrannical Occupant of the place of Magistracy , as 1. There may be some cases , wherein its Lawful for a people to yeeld subjection to a Lawless Tyrant , when groaning under his overpouring yoke , under which they must patiently bear the in●●●nation of the Lord , because they have sinned against Him , until He arise & plead His oun Cause & execute judgment in the earth ( Mic. 7. 9. ) until which time they must kiss the rod as in the hand of God , and oune & adore the holyness & Soveraignty of that Providence that hath subjected them under such a slavery ; and are not to attempt a violent ejection or excussion , when either the thing attempted is altogether impracticable , or the means & manner of effectuating it dubious & unwarrantable , or the necessary Concomitants & consequents of the cure more hurtful or dangerous than the disease , or the like . As in many cases also a man may be subject to a robber prevailing against him : So we find the people of Israel in Egyt & Babylon &c. yeelded subjection to Tyrants . But in this case we deny two things to them ( 1 ) Allegiance or active & voluntary subjection , so as to oune them for Magistrats ( 2 ) Stupid Passive obedience , or suffering without resistence . For the first , we owe it only to Magistrats , by virtue of the Law either Ordinative of God , or Constitutive of man. And it is no Argument to infer ; as a mans subjecting himself to a Robber assaulting him , is no soild proof of his approving or acknowledging the injury & violence committed by the robber , therefore a Persons yeelding subjection to a Tyrant a Publick robber does not argue his acknowledging or approving his Tyranny & oppression . For , the subjection that a Tyrant requires , and which a Robber requires , is not of the same nature : the one is Legal of subjects , which we cannot oune to a Tyrant ; the other is forced of the subdued , which we must acknowledge to a Robber . But to make the Paralell ; If the Robber should demand , in our subjecting our selves to him , an ouning of him to be no robber but an honest man , as the Tyrant demands in our subjecting our selves to him in ouning him to be no Tyrant but a Magistrate , then we ought not to yeeld it to the one no more than to the other . For the Second , to allow them Passive obedience is in-intelligible Non-sense , & a meer Contradiction : for nothing that 's meerly passive can be obedience as relative to a Law , nor can any obedience be meerly passive , for obedience is always active . But not only is the inaccuracy of the Phrase excepted against , but also that position maintained by many , that in reference to a yoke of Tyranny there is a time which may be called the proper season of suffering , that is , when suffering ( in opposition to acting or resisting ) is a necessary & indispensible duty , and resisting is a sin : For if the one be an indispensible duty , the other must be a sin at the same time : But this cannot be admitted . For , though certainly there is such a season of suffering , wherein suffering is Lawful , laudable & necessary , and all must lay their account with suffering , and litle else can be attempted but which will encrease sufferings ; yet even then we may resist as well as we can : and these two , Resistence & Suffering at the same time , are not incompatible : David did bear most patiently the injury of his Sons usurpation , when he said , let the Lord do to me as seemeth Him good 2 Sam. 15. 26. ch . 10. 12. and betaketh himself to fervent prayers Psal. 3. and yet these were not all the weapons he used against him , Neither did he ever oune him as a Magistrate . We are to suffer all things patiently as the Servants of the Lord , and look to Him for Mercy & relief ( Psal. 123. 2. ) but we are not obliged to suffer even in that season , as the slaves of men . Again , suffering in opposition to resistence , does never fall under any moral Law of God , execept in the absolutely extraordinary Case of Christs passive obedience , which cannot fall under our deliberation or imitation ; Or in the case of a positive Law , as was given to the Iewes to submit to Nebuchadnezzar , which was express & peculiar to them , as shall be cleared . That can never be commanded as indispensible duty , which does not fall under our free will or deliberation , but the enemies will as the Lord permits them , as the Case of suffering is . That can never be indispensible duty which we may decline without sin , as we may do suffering if we have not a call to it ; yea in that case it were sin to suffer , therefore in no case it can be formally indispensibly commanded , so as we may not shift it if we can without sin . Suffering simply the evil of punishment , just or unjust , can never be a conformity to Gods preceptive Will but only to His Providential disposal , it hath not voluntas signi for its rule , but only voluntas beneplaciti . All the Commands that we have for suffering , are either to direct the manner of it , that it be Patiently & Chearfully , when forced to it wrongfully 1 Pet. 2. 19 , 20. or Comparatively to determine our choise in an unavoidable alternative , either to suffer or sin : and so we are commanded rather to suffer than to deny Christ , Math. 13. 33. and we are commanded upon these termes to follow Christ to take up His Cross , when He layes it on in His Providence Math. 16. 24. See at length this cleared Lex rex Q. 30. Pag. 317-320 . otherwise in no case subjection even Passive can be a duty ; for it is allwise to be considered under the notion of a plague , Judgment , & Curse to be complained of as a burden , never to be ouned as a duty to Magistrats . As we find the Lords , people resenting it as a servitude , under which they were servants even in their oun Land , which did yeeld increase unto the Kings whom the Lord had set over them because of their sins , Neh. 9. 36. 37. 2. In diverse cases there may be some Complyance with a meer occupant , that hath no right to reign ; as upon this account the Noble Marquis of Argyle and Lord waristoun suffered for their Complyance with the Usurper Cromuel . Such may be the warrantableness , or goodness , or necessity , or profitableness of a Complyance , when people are by Providence brought under a yoke which they cannot shake off , that they may part with some of their Priviledges for the avoidance of the loss of the rest , and for the conveniency & profit , peace & safety of themselves and their Countrey , which would be in hazard if they did not comply ; they may do whatsoever is due from them to the Publick weal , what soever is an office of their station or place , or which they have any other way a call unto , whatsoever may make for their oun honest interest , without wronging others or the Countries Liberties in their transactions with these Powers , even though such a Complyance may be occasionally to the advantage of the Usurpers : Seeing good & necessary actions are not to be declined for the ill effects that are accidental to them , and arise from the use which others make of them . But though this may be yeelded in some cases to such Usurpers , especially Conquerers , that have no right of occupying the empire , but are Capable of it by derivation from the peoples consent : yet it must not be extended to such Usurpers as are also Tyrants , that have no right of their oun , nor are capable of any , and that overturn all rights of subjects . To such we can yeeld no Complyance , as may infer either transacting with them , or ouning them as Magistrates . We find indeed the Saints enjoyed Places under these , who were not their Magistrates ; as Nehemiah , & Mordecai , and Esther was Queen to Ahaswerus . But here was no Complyance with Tyrants ( for these Heathens were not such ) only some of them were extraordinary Persons , raised up by an extraordinary spirit , for extraordinary ends , in extraordinary times , that cannot be brought to an ordinary rule , as Esthers Mariage ; and all of them in their places kept the Law of their God , served the work of their generation , defiled not themselves with their Customes , acted against no good , and engaged to no evil , but by their Complyance promoted the wellfare of their Countrey , as Argyle & waristoun did under Cromuel . Again , we find they payed Custom to them , as Neh. 9. 36. 37. and we read of Augustus his taxation universally complyed with Luk. 2. 1-5 . and Christ payd it . This shall be more fully answered afterwards . Here I shall only say ( 1 ) It can never be proven that these were Tyrants . ( 2 ) Christ Paid it with such a Caution , as Leaves the title unstated ; not for conscience ( as tribute must be paid to Magistrats Rom. 13. 5 , 6. ) but only that he might not offend them ( 3 ) Any other instances of the Saints taxations are to be judged forced acts , badges of their bondage , which if they had been exacted as tests of their allegiance , they would not have yeelded . Strangers also , that are not subjects , use to pay Custom in their trafficquing , but not as tests of their allegiance . 3. There may be also in some cases obedience allowed to their Lawful Commands , because of the Lawfulness of the thing commanded , or the coincidency of another Just & obliging Authority commanding the same . We may do many things Tyranno Iubente which he commands , and Tyranno premente which he enforces , and many things also ipso sou volente seu nolente whether he will or not But we must do nothing Tyranni jussu upon the consideration of his Command , in the acknowledgment of obedience due by virtue of Allegiance , which we oune of Conscience to a Lawful Magistrate . We must do nothing which may seem to have an accessoriness to the Tyrants unlawful occupancy , or which depends only on the warrant of his Authority to do it , or may entrench on the Divine Institution of Magistracy , or bring us into a Participation of the Usurpers sin . In these cases we can neither yeeld obedience in Lawful things , nor in unlawful : Nor can we oune absolute subjection , no more then we can oune absolute obedience ; for all subjection is enjoined in order to obedience : And to plead for a Priviledge in point of obedience , and to disclaim it in point of subjection , is only the flattery of such , as having renounced with conscience all distinction of obedience , would divest others of all priviledges , that they may exercise their Tyranny without Controll . Napthali pag. 28. prior edit . 4. There may be Addresses made , to such as are not rightful Possessors of the Government , for justice , or mercy , or redress of some intollerable grievances , without scruple of accepting that which is materially justice or mercy , or seeking them at the hand of any who may reach them out to us , though he that conveyes them to us be not interested in the umpirage of them . Thus we find Ieremiah supplicated Zedekiah for mercy , not to return to prison : and Paul appealed to Cesar for justice . But in these Addresses , we may not acknowledge the wicked Lawes that brought on these grivances , nor conceal the wickedness no more than the miserie of them which we have endured , nor may we oune the Legal power of them that we address to take them off , nor signify any thing , in the matter or manner of our Representations , that may either import a declining our Testimony for which we have suffered these grievances , or a contradiction to our declinature of their pretended Authority : Only we may remonstrate what cruelties we have endured , and how terrible it will be to them to be guilty of , or accessory to our blood in not pitying us ; which was all that Ieremiah did . And as for Pauls appeal , we find he was threatened to be murdered by his Countrey-men Act. 23. 14. from whose hands he was rescued , & brought before the judicatory of Festus the Roman deputy , not voluntarely ; thence also they sought to remand him to Ierusalem , that they might kill him Act. 25. 3. whereupon he demands in justice that he might not be delivered to his accusers & Murderers , but claims the benefite of the Heathens oun Law , by that appeal to Cesar. which was the only constrained expedient of saving his oun life Act. 28. 19. by which also he got an opportunity to witness for Christ at Rome . But as shall be cleared further afterwards ; Cesar was not an Usurper over Iudea : which not obscurely is insinuated by Paul himself , who asserts , that both his person , & his Cause Criminal of which he was accused ( it was not an Ecclesiastical Cause , & so no advantage hence for the Supremacy ) appertained to Cesars Tribunal , and that not only in fact but of right Act. 25. 10. I stand at Cesars judgment seat where I ought to be judged . We cannot say this of any tribunal , senced in the name of them that Tyrannize over us . 5. I will not stand neither upon the Names & Titles of Kings &c. to be given to Tyrants & Usurpers , in speaking to them or of them , by way of appellation or compellation : for we find even Tyrants are called by these names in Scripture , being Kings de fact● though not dejure , and indeed not impertinently Kings & Tyrants for the most part are reciprocal termes . But in no case can we give them any Names or Titles , which may signify our love to them whom the Lord hates or 〈◊〉 hate the Lord 2 Chron. 19. 2. or which may flatter them , which Elihu durst not give , for fear his Maker should take him away Iob. 32. 22. or which may be taken for honouring of them , for that is not due to the vile● of men when exalted never so high Psal. 12. ult : a vile person must be contemned in our eyes Psal. 15. 4. Nor which may any way import or infer an ouning of a Magistratical relation between them & us , or any Covenant transaction or Confederacy with them , which in no termes with them as such we will say or oune Isa. 8. 12. Hence many sufferers upon this head so bear to give them their Titles . 8. It will be yeelded very readily by us , that a Magistrate is not to be disouned meerly for his differing in Religion from us , yea though he were a Heathen . We do not disoune our pretended Rulers meerly upon that account , but chearfully do grant & subscribe to that Truth , in our Confession of faith chap. 23. § 4. That Infidelity or difference in Religion , doth not make void the Magistrates just & Legal Authority , nor free the people from their due obedience to him : On which our Adversaries have insulted , as if our Principles & Practices were therby disproved . But it is easy to answer 1. let the words be considered ; and we are confident , that no sober man will think , the acknowledgment of just & legal Authority & due obedience , a rational ground to infer , that Tyranny is thereby either allowed or priviledged , Napth . Pag. 60. Prior Edition . 2. Though Infidelity or difference of Religion does not make void Authority where it is Lawfully invested ; yet it may incapacitate a person , and Lawfully seclude him from Authority , both by the word of God , which expressly forbids to set a Stranger over us who is not our brother Deut. 17. 15. Which includes as well a stranger of a strange Religion as one of a strange Countrey , and by the Lawes of the Land , which do incapitate a Papist of all Authority , Supreme or subordinate . And so if this Iames the 7 / 2 had been King before he was a Roman Catholick , if we had no more to object , we should not have quarrelled his succession . 3. We both give & grant all that is in the Confession , viz. Dominium non fundari in gratia , that Dominion is not founded on Grace . Yet this remains evident , that a Prince who not only is of another religion , but an avowed enemy to & overturner of the Religion established by Law , and intending & endeavouring to introduce a false , heretical , blasphemous , & Idolatrous religion , can claim no just & legal Authority , but in this case the people may very Lawfully decline his pretended Authority ; Nay they are betrayers of their Countrey & Posterity , if they give not a timeous & effectual Check to his Usurpings , and make him sensible that he hath no such Authority . Can we imagine , that men in the whole of that blessed work so remarkably led of God , being convocate by a Parliament of the wisest & worthyest men that ever was in England , whom they did encourage , by writing , & preaching , & every way to stand fast in their opposition to the then King displaying a banner for his prerogative ( a court dream ) against Religion & Liberty ; should be so far left , as to drop that as a principle & part of our Religion , which would sacrifice Religion it self to the lust of a raging Tyrant ? Must we beleeve , that a Religion-destroying Tyrant is a righteous Ruler ? And must we onne him to be a Nursing father to the Church ? Shall we conclude that the common bounds & Limits , whereby the Almighty hath bounded & Limited Mankind , are removed by an Article of our confession of faith , which hereby is turned into a Court creed ? Then welcome Hobs de Cive , with all the rest of Pluto's train , who would bable us into a belief , that the world is to be governed according to the pleasure of wicked Tyrants . I would fain hope at length the world would be awakened out of such ridiculous dreams , & be ashamed any more to oune such fooleries . And it may be , our two Royal Brothers have contributed more to cure men of this Moral madness , than any who went before them . And this is the only advantage , I know , that the Nations hath reaped by their reign . 9. Though we deny that Conquest can give a just Title to a Croun ; yet we grant in some cases , though in the begining it was unjust yet by the peoples after consent it may be turned into a just Title . It is undenyable , when there is just ground of the war ; if a Prince subdue a whole Land , who have justly forfeited their Liberties , when by his grace he preserves them , he may make use of their right now forefeited , and they may resign their Liberty to the Conqueror , and consent that he be their King upon fair & Legal & not Tyrannical conditions . And even when the war is not just , but successful on the invading Conquerours side , this may be an inducement to the Conquered , if they be indeed free and uningaged to any other , to a submission , dedition , & delivery up of themselves to be the subjects of the victor , and to take him for their Soveraign : as it is like the case was with the Jewes in Cesars time , whose Government was translated by dedition to the Roman power ; in the translation when a doing there was a fault , but after it was done it ceased ; though the begining was wrong , there was a post-fact which made it right , and could not be dissolved without an unjust disturbance of publick order . Whence , besides what is said above , in answer to that much insisted Instance of Christs paying tribute , and Commanding it to be paid to Cesar , the difficulty of that instance may be clearly solved . That Tribute which he paid , Math. 17. 24. &c. and that about the payment whereof He was questioned Math. 22. 21. seem to be two different Tributes . Many think very probably they were not one & the same Tribute . It s a question , for whom & by whom that of Math. 17. was gathered ; it s most likely it was gathered by the officers of the Temple for its service : however the payment was made with such caution ( tacitely declining the strict right to exact it from him , but to avoid offence , in an act in it self unobliging ) that their claim is left as much in the dark , as if the question had never been moved . The other Math. 22. was exacted for Cesar : but to that captious question our Lord returns such an Answer , as might both solve it , and evade the snare of the proponders , giving a general Rule of giving to God & to Cesar each their oun , without defining which of them had the right to the payment in question ; whether Cesar should have it , or whether it should be payed only for the Temples use : Upon which they marvelled ; which they needed not do , if they had understood in His words an express & positive declaration of an obligation to make that payment to Cesar ; for then they would have obtained one of their ends , in making Him odious to the people , who were not satisfied with the payment of it . But however , the knot is loosed by considering , that they were now Lawfully subject to the Roman Emperours as their Governours , to whom they were obliged ( I do not say Christ was ) to pay tribute . For they had yeelded themselves unto & ouned the Roman Dominion , in Pompey , Cesar Augustus , & Tiberius , ere this question about Tribute paying was proposed to our Saviour , and therfore they who stuck at the payment of it were a seditious party dissenting from the body of the Nation : Else it is not supposable readily , that their Dominion in Iudea could have been exercised long without some consent , sufficient to legitimate it to the present Rulers , And this is the more likely , if we consider the confession of the Iewes themselves , disavowing the power of Capital punishment ; It is not Lawful for us to put any man to death , And ouning Cesar as their King , with an exclusive a brenounciation of all other , we have no King but Cesar : As Paul also acknowleeges he ought to be judged at Cesars bar , in his appeal to Cesar. It is also acknowledged by very good Authors , that this was the tribute which Iudas the Galilean stood up to free the people from , and that the sedition of those Iewes that folowed him mentioned Act. 5. 37. who mutinied upon this occasion , was according to Gamaliels speech disallowed by that Sanhedrin or Council of the Iewes . And it may be gathered out of Iosephus , that the Iewes of Hircanus his party came under the Roman power by consent & dedition ; while they of Aristobalus his party looked upon the Romans as Usurpers . Which difference continued till our Saviours time , when some part of them acknowledged the Cesarean Authority , some part looked upon it as an Usurpation , and of this generally were the Pharisees . To confirm this , Calvins Testimony may be adduced , upon Math. 22. who sayeth , the Authority of the Roman Emperours was by common use approved and received among the Iewes , whence it was manifest that the Iewes had now of their oun accord imposed on themselves a Law of paying the tribute , because they had passed over to the Romans the power of the sword . And Chamiers Panstrat Tom. 2. lib. 15. cap. 16. pag. 635. what then ? if Cesars Authority were from bad beginings , did therefore Christ untruly say it was from above ? Can no power at first unjust , afterward become just ? if that were so , then either none , or very few King●oms would be just . 10. As Tyranny is a destructive plague to all the Interests of men & Christians ; So Anarchy , the usual product of it , is no less pernicious , bringing a Community into a Paroxysme as deadly & dangerous . We must oune Government to be absolutely necessary , for the constitution & conservation of all Societies . I shall not enter into a disquisition , let be determination , of the Species or Kind of Magistracy , whether Monarchy , Aristocracy , or Democracy , be preferable . My dispute at present is not levelled against Monarchy , but the present Monarch : Not against the Institution of the Species ( though I beleeve , except we betake our selves to the Divine allowance & permission ; we shal be as pusled to find out the Divine Original of it , as Cosmographers are in their search of the Spring of Nilus or Theologues of the Father of Melchizedeck ) but the constitution of this Individual Monarchy established among us ; which in its root & branch , Spring & streams , in its Original , Nature , ends , & effects , is Diametrically opposite to Religion & Liberty ; And because its Contagion , universally perverting & corrupting all the ends & Orders of Magistracy , doth affect & infect all the subordinate officers , deriving their power from such a filthy fountain ; we must also substract & deny their demanded ackowledgments , as any way due , so long as they serve the pride & projects of such a wicked power : And do not reckon our selves obliged by Covenant , or any otherways ( though in the third Article of the Solemn League , we are bound to preserve the rights & priviledges of our Parliaments , & consequently the honour & deference that 's due to our Peers , or other Parliament men , acting according to the trust committed to them , but not when they turn Traitors ingaged in a Conspiracy with the Tyrant ) to oune or defend a Soul-less shadow of a Court Cabal , made up of persons who have sold themselves to work wickedness , in conspiring with this throne of iniquity against the Lord , which is all we have for a Parliament , whom we can in no ways oune as our Representatives , but must look upon them as perjured & perfidious Traitors to God & their Countrey , which they have betrayed into the hands of a Tyrant ; And therefore divested of that power & Authority , which they had of the people as their Representatives , which now is returned to the fountain . And therefore we must act as we can against them , and also what is necessary for securing of our selves , Religion & Liberty , without them . We would think Nobles , ennobled with virtue , a great Mercy & encouragment . And if they would concur in the Testimony for Religion & Liberty , we would be glad that they should lead the van and prove themselves to be powers appointed by God , in acting for Him & His Interest . But for the want of their Conduct , we must not surcease from that duty that they abandon , nor think that the Concurrence of Peers is so necessary to legitimate our actions , as that without that formality our resolutions to maintain the Truth of God on all hazards , in a private Capacity , were unlawful in the Court of God & Nature : But on the contrare must judge , that their relinquishing or opposing their duty , which before God they are obliged to maintain , preserve , & promove , is so far from loosing our obligation , or eximing us from our duty , that is should rather press us to prosecute it with the more vigour , without suspending it upon their precedency . For now they can pretend to no precedency , when they do not answer the end of their erection , and do not seek the publick good but their oun private advantage , they cease to be the Ministers of God & of the people , and become private persons . And reason will conclude , that when the Ephori or Trustees betray their Trust , and sell or basely give away the Liberties & Priviledges of the people , which they were entrusted with , the people cannot be brought into a remediless condition ; if a Tutor waste & destroy the pupills estate , the Law provides a remedy for the pupil Ius popu . vind . cap. 15. pag. 335. 336. The remedy in this case can only be , as every one must move in his oun sphere , while all concur in the same duty ; So if any in higher place become not only remiss , but according to the influence of their power would seduce others into their Apostasie , it is their duty to resist & endeavour their Reformation or removal : And if these more eminently entrusted shall turn directly Apostates , & obstructive & destructive to common Inte●●●● , the people of an inferior degree may step forward to occupy the places , & assert the Interests , which they forefault & desert . Neither is this a breach of good order ; for Ordor is only a mean subordinate to , & intended for the Glory of God & the peoples good , and the regulation thereof must only be admitted as it is conducible & not repugnant to these ends . A Generals command to his souldiers in battel , does not impede the necessity of succession , in case of vacancy of any charge , either through death or desertion , even of such as in quality may be far inferior to those whose places they step into , Naph . Pag. 151. Prior Edition . I do not assert this for private peoples aspiring into the Capacity of Primores or Peers ; but that they may do that which the Peers desert , and dare not or will not do , if the Lord put them in a Capacity to do it . And more plainly I assert , that if the Peers of the Land , whose duty it is principally to restrain & repress Tyranny , either connive at it or concur with it , and so abandon or betray their Trust , then the Common people may do it ; at least are obliged to renounce , reject , & disoune allegiance to the Tyrant , without the peers . For which I offer these reasons 1. Because all men have as much freedom & Liberty by nature as Peers have , being no more slaves than they ; because slavery is a penal evil contrare to nature , and a miserie consequent of sin , and every man created according to Gods image is res Sacr● a Sacred thing ; And also no more subjects to Kings &c. than they ; freedom being natural to all , ( except freedom from subjection to Parents , which is a Moral duty & most kindly & natural , and subjection of the wife to the husband &c. ) but otherwise as to Civil & Politick subjection , man by nature is born as free as beasts ; No Lyon is born King of Lyons , nor no man born King of men , nor Lord of men , nor Representative of men , nor Rulers of men , either supreme or subordinate ; because none by nature can have those things that essentially constitute Rulers , the calling of God , nor gifts and qualifications for it , nor the election of the People . 2. The original of all that power , that the 〈◊〉 or Representatives can claim , is from the people , not from themselves ; from whence derived they their being Representatives , but from the peoples Commission or Compact ? when at the first constit●tion of Parliaments or publick Conventions for affairs of State , necessity put the people , who could not so conveniently meet all , to confer that honour & burden upon the best qualified , & who had chief Interest , by Delegation . Hence if the people give such a power , they may wave it when perverted , and act without their oun impowered Servants . 3. The peoples power , is greater than the power of any delegated or constituted by them ; the Cause is more than the effect ; Parliament-men do represent the people , the people do no not represent the Parliament : They are as Tutors & Curators unto the people , and in effect their servants deputed to oversee their publick affairs , therefore if their power be less the people can act without them . 4. It were irrational to imagine , the people committing the administration of their weighty affairs unto them , did denude themselves of all their radical power ; or that they can devolve upon them , or they obtain , any other power but what is for the good & advantage of the people ; therefore they have power to act without them , in things which they never resigned to them : for they cannot be deprived of that natural aptitude , & natures birth right , given to them by God & Nature , to provide the most efficacious & prevalent means for the preservation of their Rights & Liberties . 5. As the people have had power before they made Peers , and have done much without them ; So these Primores could never do without them , therefore in acts of common Interest , the Peers depend more upon the people than the people does upon them . 6. All these primeve rights , that gave rise to Societies , are equal to both People & Peers , whereof the Liberty to repress & reject Tyranny is a chief one . The People as well as Peers have a hard in making the King , and other Judges also , as is clear from Deut. 17. 14. Iudg. 9. 6. 1 Sam. 11. 15. 2 King. 14. 21. therefore they may unmake them as well as they . To seek to preserve the ends of Government , when they are over-turned , is essentially requisite to all Societies , and therefore common & competent to all Constituents of these Societies , Superiours or inferiours . The Glory of God & Security of Religion , the end of all Christian Government , doth concern all equally . As every one equally is bound to obey God rather than man , so violence in this case , destroyes both the Commonwealth , & maketh the end & the means of Government , and the injured persons obligation thereto to cease , and this equally to every man of Private or publick Capacity . In the Concern of Religion at least , We must not think , because we are not Nobles or in Authority , that the care of it or Reformation thereof does nothing pertain to us ; Nay in that , and carrying on the work thereof , there is an equality ; As in the erection of the Old Testament Tabernacle , all the people were to contribute a like , half a shekel Exod. 30. that it might be for a rememberance before the Lord. Hence it followes , if we disoune the Supreme Ruler , and the inferior confederate with him , and cannot have the Concurrence of others ; Now through the manifest & notorious Perversion of the great ends of Societie & Government , the bond thereof being dissolved , we Liberated there-from , do relapse into our Primeve Liberty & Priviledge , and accordingly as the similitude of our Case & exigence of our Cause doth require , may upon the very same Principles again joine & associate , for our better defence & Preservation , as we did at first enter into Societies Naph . P. 150. yet , whatever we may do in this case ; We are not for presumptuous Assumptions of Authority , which maleversers have forefaulted : Neither are we for new erections of Government , but are for keeping the Societie of which we are members intire , in an endeavour to have all our fellow members united unto God & to one another , in Religion & Liberty , according to the bond of the Solemn League & Covenant . Certain it is that Greater Societies under one Government , may in some cases make a Secession , & divide into Lesser without sedition : or else , how would there be now so many distinct Common-wealths in the world ? seeing at first all was under one head : and how comes it to pass , that there are so many Kingdoms in Europe , when it can be instanced when all , or the most part , were under on Roman Emperour ? But this in our Circumstance is no way expedient , neither was it ever in Projection . But our aim is to abstract our selves inoffensively , and maintain our rights that remain unrobbed , and to adhere clossly to the fundamental Constitutions , Lawes , & Laudable Practices of our native Kingdome . 11. We oune the obligation of our Sacred Covenants , unrepealably & indispensibly binding to all the duties of Christian subjection to Magistrates . But we deny , that hereby we are bound either to maintain Monarchy , especially thus perverted ; nor to oune the Authority of either of the two Monarchs that have Monarchized or Tyrannized over us these 27 years past . For as to the first we assert , that that which is in its oun nature Mutable , cannot be simply sworn unto to be maintained & preserved , but Hypothetically it most , else it were simply sinful ; since it were to make things , in their oun nature and in the Providence of God changable , unchangable ; yea it were a doun right swearing not to comply with , but to spurn against , the various vicisitudes of Divine Providence , the great Rector of the Universe . And it is unquestionable , that when things alterable & unalterable are put in the same Oath , to make the Engagment Lawful the things must be understood , as they are in their oun nature and no otherwise : else both the Imposer & the Taker grievously transgress ; the former , in taking upon him what is in the power of no Morta , and a Contradicton to the Prerogative of the Immorta God ; and the other , in ouning that power as just . Hence when these two fall to be in the same Oath , they must be so understood as it may not be made a snare to the conscience of the Sweaer . For it may fall so out in the Providence of God , that the Preservation of both is in all respects made impossible : And an adhesion to the one , may so far interfere with the Preservation of the other , as if the Mutable and that which hath no objective obligation be stuck to , the other , which with the loss of all Interests we are to maintain , must be abandoned ; yea , that which was sworn to be maintained as a mean only , & a mutable one too , may not only cease to be a mean , but may actually destroy the main end , and then it is to be laid aside , because then it inverts the order of things . Hence also it may be questioned , if it were not more convenient , to leave out those things that are alterable in themselves , out of the same Oath with things unalterable , and put them in a distinct Oaths or Covenant by themselves ; as we see Iehojadah did 2 King. 11. 17. He made a Covenant between the Lord and the King & the people , that they should be the Lords people ; between the King also & the People . Here are two distinct Covenants ; the one made with God , about things eternally obligatory , wherein King & people engage themselves upon level ground , to serve the Lord , and Joash the King his treacherous dealing with God in that matter brought the Curse of that Covenant upon him : The other Covenant was Civil , about things alterable , relating to Points of Government & Subjection . And as he , by virtue of that prior Covenant , had obliged himself , under the pain of the Curse thereof , to carry as one Covenanted to God with the people , and so not to Tyrannize over his brethren : So the people , by virtue of that same Covenant , were to yeeld obedience , but in nothing to acknowledge him as having power or Authority to countermand Gods Command ; Neither had it been an act of disloyaltie , to have broken doun his Groves , which he had with the addition of the guilt of Perjurie set up , and to have bound his ungrateful hands from the blood of the Gracious Zechariah : A perfect parallel to our Case under the former dominator , save that it was out-done as to all dimensions of wickedness by him . To speak more plainly , the Religious part of our Covenant is of an Eternal obligation : but as to the Civil part , it is impossible it can ever be so , unless it be well & Cautiously understood , that is , unless instead of any species of Government , as Monarchy , &c. we put in Magistracy it self . For this is that power which is of God : but Monarchy &c. is only a humane Creature , about the creation whereof men take a Liberty , according to what suits them best in their present Circumstances . And as to this Species of Monarchy ; men are never left at Liberty ▪ to cloath therewith any inept or impious Person . And they are perfectly loosed from it . 1. when that Species of Government becomes opposite to the ends of Government , and is turned Tyranny , especially when a legal establishment is pretended ; then it affects with its contagion the very species it self : The house is to be pulled doun , when the Leprosie is got into the walls & foundation . 2. when as it is exercised , it is turned inept for answering the end of its erection , and prejudicial to the main thing for which Government is given , to wit , the Gospel and the coming of Christs Kingdom : hence it is promised to the Church , Isai. 49. 23. Kings shall be nursing fathers to the Church — And Isai. 52. 15. It is promised to the Me●iator , that Kings shall shute their mouths — I. e. never a word in their head , but out of reverence & respect to His absolute Soveraignty , they shall take the Law from Him , without daring to contradict , far less to take upon them to prescribe in the House of God , as they in their wisdom think fit . 3. when Providence , without any sinful hand , makes that species impossible to be kept up , without the ruine of that for which it was erected : when things come to this push & pinch , whosoever are cloathed with the power are then under an obligation to comply with that alteration of providence , for the safety of the people ; else they declare themselves unworthy of rule , and such who would sacrifice the interest of the people to their particular interest ; in which case the people may make their Publick servant sensible , he is at his highest elevation but a Servant . Hence , now when this species named in the Covenant , viz , Monarchy , is by Law so vitiate , as it is become the mean & instrument of the destruction of all the ends of that Covenant , and now by Law transmitted to all successors as a hereditary , pure , perfect , & perpetual opposition to the coming of Christs kingdom ; So that as long as there is one to wear that Croun ( but Iehavah will in righteousness execute Coniahs doom upon the race Ier. 22. ult . write this man childless — ) and enter heir to the Government as now established , he must be an enemy to Christ ; there is no other way left , but to think on a new Modell moulded according the true Pattern . As to the Second , we are far less obliged to oune & acknowledge the interest of any of the two Monarchs , that we have been Mourning under these many years , from these Sacred Covenants . For as to the first of them , Charles the 2. Those Considerations did cassate his Interest , as to any Covenant obligation to oune him . 1. In these Covenants we are not sworn absolutely to maintain the Kings Person & Authority , but only Conditionally , in the Preservation & defence of Religion & Liberties . Now when this Condition was not performed , but on the contrare professedly resolved never to be fulfilled ; And when he laid out himself to the full of his power & Authority , for the destuction of that Reformed Religion & Liberties of the Kingdom ; which he solemnly swore to defend when he received the Croun , only in the termes that he should be a Loyal subject to Christ , and a true & faithful Servant to the people , in order to which a Magistrate is chosen , and all his worth , excellency , & valuableness consists in his answering that purpose ; for the excellency of a mean , as such , is to be measured from the end , and its answerableness thereunto : We were not then obliged , to maintain such an enemy to these precious Interests . 2. Because , as the people were bound to him , so he was bound to them by the same Covenant , being only on these termes entrusted with the Government : All which Conditions he perfidiously broke , whereupon only , his Authority & our Allegiance were founded ; And thereby we were loosed , from all reciprocal obligation to him by virtue of that Covenant . 3. Though he and we stood equally engaged to the duties of that Covenant , only with this difference , that the Kings Capacity being greater , he was the more obliged to have laid out that power , in causing all to stand to their Covenant Engagments , as Iosiah did 2 Chron. 34. 31 , 32 , 33. ( But alas there was never a Iosiah in the race ) yet he rose up to the hight of rebellion against God and the people , in heaven-daring insolency , and not only brake but burnt that Covenant , and made Lawes to case & rescind it , and made a not-concurring in this Conspiracy a note of incapacity for any Trust , in Church or State. Therefore to plead for an ouning of him in this case , were only concludent of this , that the Generation had dreamed themselves into such a distraction , as may be feared will be pursued with destruction , and make such dreamers the detestation of posterity , and cause all men Proclaim the righteousness of God , in bringing ruine upon them by that very power & Authority they ouned in such circumstances . 4. It is a known maxime , Qui non implet conditionem a se promissam cadit beneficio ; & qui remittit obligationem non potest exigere . He that does not fulfill the conditions falls from the benefit of it , and whoso remitts the obligation of the party obliged upon condition , cannot exact it afterwards . So then it is evident that the subjects of Scotland , were by King Charles the 2 de his consent , yea express command , disengaged from so much of that Covenant as could be alledged in favors of himself : So that all that he did , by burning & rescinding these Covenants , and pursuing all who endeavoured to ad●ere to them , was a most explicite Liberating his subjects from , & remission of their Allegiance to him ( and in this we had been fools , if we had not taken him at his word ) yea he rescinded his very Coronation , by an act of his first Parliament after his return , which did declare null & void all Acts , Constitutions , & establishments , from the year 1633 to that present session , not excepting those for his oun Coronation , after which he was never recrouned , And therefore we could not oune that right , which himself did annul . But as for his Royal Brother , Iames the 7 / 2 we cannot indeed make use of the same reasons & arguments , to disoune him , as we have now adduced ▪ yet , as we shall prove afterwards , this Covenant does oblige to renounce him . So it is so clear , that it needs no Illustration , that there lies no obligation from the Covenant to oune him : And also that for this cause we are obliged not to oune him . 1. Because as he is an enemy to the whole of our Covenant , and especially to these terms upon which Authority is to be ouned therein : So he will not come under the bond of this Covenant , nor any other compact with the people , but intrude himself upon the Throne , ●n such a way as overturns the Basis of our Government , and destroyes all the Liberties of a free people , which by Covenant we are bound to preserve , and consequently as inconsistent therewith , to renounce his Usurpation . For , a Prince that will set himself up without any transactions with the people , or conditions giving Security for Religion & Liberty , is an Usurping Tyrant , not bounded by any Law but his oun lusts . And to say to such an one , Reign thow over us , is all one as to say , come thow and play the Tyrant over us , and let thy lust & will be a Law to us : which is both against Scripture & Natural-sense . If he be not a King upon Covenant termes , either expressly or tacitely , or general stipulations according to the word of God & Lawes of the Land , he cannot be ouned as a father , Protector , or Tutor , having any fiduciary power entrusted to him over the Commonwealth , but as a Lawless & absolute Dominator , assuming to himself a power to rule or rage as he lists : whom to oune were against our Covenants ; for there we are sworn to Maintain his Maj. just & Lawful Authority , and by consequence not to oune Usurpation & Tyranny , stated in opposition to Religion & Liberty , which there also we are engaged to maintain . Sure , this cannot be Lawful Authority which is of God , for God giveth no power against Himself ; Nor can it be of the people , who had never power granted them of God to create one over them , with a Liberty to destroy them , their Religion & Liberty , at his pleasure . 2. As he is not nor will not be our Covenanted & sworn King ( and therefore we cannot be his Covenanted & sworn subjects ) So he is not nor can not be our Crouned King , and therefore we must not be his Liege subjects , ouning fealty & obedience to him . For according to the National Covenant ; as all Lieges are to maintain the Kings Authority , consistent with the subjects Liberties ; which if they be innovated or prejudged , such Confusion would ensue , as this realme could be no more a free Monarchy — So for the Preservation of true Religion , Lawes , & Liberties of this Kingdom , it is statute by the 8 Act. Parl. 1 , repeated in the 99 Act. Parl. 7. ratified in the 23. Act. Parl. 11. and 114 Act. Parl. 12. of King Iames 6. and 4 Act of K. Charles 1. that all Kings & Princes ● at their coronation & reception of their Princely , Authority , shall make their faithful Promise by their solemn Oath , in the presence of the Eternal God ; That enduring the whole time of their lives , they shall serve the same Eternal God , to the utter-most of their power , according as He hath required in His most holy Word , contained in the Old & new Testaments , and according to the same Word , shall maintain the true Religion of Christ Jesus , the preaching of His holy Word , the due & right Ministration of the Sacraments , now received & Preached within this realme ( according to the Confession of faith immediatly preceding ) and shall abolish & gainstand all false religion , contrary to the same ; And shall rule the people committed to their charge , according to the will & Command of God , revealed in His fore-said Word , and according to the Laudable Lawes & Constitutions received in this realme , no wayes repugnant to the said Will of the Eternal God ; And shal procure , to the uttermost of their power , to the Kirk of God & whole Christian people , true & perfect peace in all time coming ; And that they shall be careful to root out of their Empire all Hereticks & Enemies to the true Worship of God , who shall be convicted by the true Kirk of God of the foresaid Crimes . Now this Coronation Oath he hath not taken , he will not , he cannot take ; and therefore cannot be our Crouned King according to Law. As there be also many other Lawes incapacitating his admission to the Croun , being a Professed Papist , and no Law for it at all , but one of his oun making by a Pacqued Cabal of his oun Complices , a Parliament , wherein himself presided as Commissioner , enacting matterially his succession , and rescinding all these Ancient Lawes : which Act of Succession ( which is all the legal right he can pretend to in Scotland ) because it cannot be justified , therefore his right cannot be ouned , which is founded upon the subversion of our Ancient Lawes . But as he cannot be our Legally Crouned King , so he is not so much as formally Crouned . And therfore before his Inauguration , whatever right to be King ( whom the Representatives may admit to the Government ) he may pretend to , by hereditary Succession ; yet he cannot formally bemade King , till the people make a Compact with him , upon termes for the safety of their dearest & nearst Liberties , even though he were not disabled by Law. He might , as they say , pretend to some jus ad rem , but he could have no jus in re . The Kings of Scotland , while uncrouned , can exerce no Royal Government ; for the Coronation in Concret , according to the substance of the Act , is no Ceremonie ( as they , who make Conscience it self but a Ceremony , call it ) nor an accidental ingredient in the Constitution of a King , but as it is distinctive , so it is Constitutive : it distinguished Saul from all Israel , and made him from no King to be a King , it is dative & not only Declarative ; it puts some honour upon him that he had not before . 3. Though the Lawes should not strike against his Coronation , And though the Representatives Legally should take the same measures with him that they took with his brother , and admit him upon the termes of the Covenant ; yet after such doleful experiences of such transactions with these Sons of Belial , who must not be taken with hands , nor by the hand , it were hard to trust , or entrust them with the Government , even though they should make the fairest Professions : Since they whose Principle is to keep no faith to Hereticks ( as they call us ) and who will be as absolute in their promises as they are in their power , have deservedly forefeited all Credit & Trust with honest men ; so that none could rationally refer the determination of a half Croun reckoning to any of them , far less oune them & their Government in the Managment of the weightiest affairs of State , since their Male-versations are written in such bloody Characters , as he that runs may read them . At least it were wisdom , & is our duty , to take our Measures from the General Assemblies Procedure with the other Brother , before his admission to the Government , to suspend our Allegiance to him until Authority be Legally devolved upon him , and founded upon & bounded by termes giving all security for Religion & Liberty . 12. As I said before ; wary Prudence , in waving such an impertinent & Ticklish Question , cannot be condemned : since what ever he may be in conscience , no man in Law can be obliged , so far to surrender the common Priviledge of all Mankind , to give an account of all his inward thoughts , which are alwise said to be free . And as in nothing they are more various , so in nothing they can be more violented , than to have our opinion & sentiments of the current Government extorted from us ; a declining of which Declaration of thoughts , where no overt Act in project or practice can be proven against it , cannot be Treason in any Law in the world : So a Cautelous Answer , in such a ticklish & entrapping imposition , cannot be censured in point of Lawfullnesse of expediency , even though much be concedded , to stop the Mouths of these bloody Butchers , gaping greedily after the blood of the Answerer ; if he do not really oune , but give them to understand he cannot approve of , this Tyranny . But as these poor faithful Witnesses , who were helped to be most free , have alwise been honoured with the most signal Countenance of the Lord in a happy issue of their Testimony : So those that used their Prudentials most , in seeking shifts to sh●n severity , and studying to satisfie these Inquisitors with their stretched Concessions , were ordinarly more exposed to snares , and found less satisfaction in their Sufferings , even though they could say much to justify , or at least extenuate their Shiftings . I knew one , who had proof of this , who afterwards was ashamed of this kind of Prudence . A short account of whose managing of Answers to this Question , because it may conduce somewhat to the explication of it , may here be hinted . The question moved after the usual forme , was , Do ye onne the Authority of King Iames the 7 ? In answer to which , he pleaded first , for the immunity of his thoughts , which he said were not subject to theirs or any Tribunal . When this could not be an evasion from their extortions , he objected the ambiguity of the termes in which the Question was conceived , being capable of diverse senses : And inquired , what they meant by Authority ? what by ouning Authority ? By Authority , whether did they mean the Administration of it , as now improved ? if so , then he was not satisfied with it : or the right as now established ? if so , then he was not clear to give his opinion of it ; as being neither significant nor necessary , and that it was fitter for Lawyers , and those that were better acquaint with the Arcana Imperii , than for him to dispute it . Again he asked , what they meant by ouning ? either it is Passive subjection ; that he did not decline : or Active acknowledgment of it ; and that he said he looked upon as all the suffrage he could give to its establishment in his station , which he must demur upon some scruple . The replies he received were very various , and some of them very rare , either for ignorance or imposture . Sometimes it was answered : To oune the Kings Authority , is to take the Oath of Allegiance ; this he refused . Some answered , it is to engage never to rise in Armes against the King upon any pretence whatsoever ; this he refused likewise . Others explained it to be , to acknowledge his right to be King : To this he answered , when the Authority is Legally devolved upon him by the Representatives of both Kingdoms , it was time enough for him to give account of his sentiments . Others defined it , to oune him to be Lawful King by succession : To this he Answered , he did not understand succession could make a man formally King , if there were not some other way of Conveyance of it ; it might put him in the nearest Capacity to be King , but could not make him King. Some did thus Paraphrase upon it , that he must oune him to be his Soveraign Lord under God , and Gods vicegerent , to be obeyed in all things Lawful : To this he answered , whom God appoints , and the People choose according to Law , he would oune . When those shifts would not do , but from time to time being urged to a Categorical Answer ; he told them , he was content to live in subjection to any Government Providence set up , but for ouning the present Constitution as of God and according to Law , he durst not acknowledge it , nor oune any Mortal as his Lawful Soveraign , but in termes consistent with the Covenant securing Religion and Liberty . This not satisfying , when he came to a more pinching Trial ; he declared , he ouned all Lawful Authority according to the Word of God , and all Authority that was the Ordinance of God by His Preceptive Will , and he could be subject to any ; but further to acknowledge it , he behooved to have more clearness , for sometimes a Nation might be charged with that , ye have set up Kings and not by me &c Further he conceded , he ouned his providential Advancement to the Throne ; he ouned as much as he thought did oblige him to subject himself with patience ; he ouned him to be as Lawful as providence possessing him of the Throne of his Ancestors , and Lineal succession , as presumed next in blood & line , could make him : But still he declined to oune him as Lawful King , and alledged that was all one , whether he was Lawful or not , he refused not subjection , distinguishing it always from Allegiance . But all these concessions did not satisfie them , & they alledged he might say all this of a Tyrant : & therefore commanded him to give it under his hand , to oune not only the Lineal but the Legal succession of King Iames the 7. to the Croun of Scotland : which he did , upon a fancy that Legal did not import Lawful , but only the formality of their Law ; withal protesting , he might not be interpreted to approve of his succession . But this was a vain Protestatio contra factum . However by this we see , what is ouning this Authority , in the sense of the Inquisitors . The result of all is , to acknowledge Allegiance to the present possessor , and to approve his pretended Authority as Lawful , Rightful , & Righteous : which indeed is the true sense of the Words , and any other that men can forge or find out is strained . For , to speak properly , if we oune his Authority in any respect , we oune it to be Lawful : for eyery Authority , that is ouned to be Authority indeed , is Lawful ; Authority alwayes importing Authorization , and consisting in a Right or Call to rule , and is formally & essentially contradistinct to Usurpation : wherever the place of power is meerly usurped , there is no Authority but verbo tenu● ; A Style without truth , a barely pretended nominal equivocal Authority , no real denomination : if we then oune this Mans Authority , we oune it to be Lawful Authority : And if we cannot oune it so , we cannot oune it at all . For it is most suitable , either to manly ingenuity , or Christian simplicity , to speak properly , and to take words always in the sense that they to whom they are speaking will understand them , without equivacating . These Preliminaries being thus put by , which do contribute to clear somewhat in this Controversie , and both furnish us with some Arguments for , and solutions in most of the objections against , my Thesis in answer to the Question above stated . I set it doun thus . A people long oppressed with the Encroachments of Tyrants & Usurpers , may disoune all Allegiance to their pretended Authority , and when imposed upon to acknowledge it , may & must ratber chuse to suffer , than to oune it . And consequently we cannot as matters now stand oune , acknowledge , or approve the pretended Authority of King Iames the 7. as Lawful King of Scotland ; as we could not as matters then stood oune the Authority of Charles the 2. This consequence is abundantly clear from the foregoing deduction , demonstrating their Tyranny & usurpation . In prosecuting of this General Thesis , which will evince the particular Hypothesis : I shall . 1. Adduce some Historical Instances , whence it may be gathered , that this is not altogether without a precedent , but that people have disouned Allegiance to Tyrants & Usurpers , before now . 2. Deduce it from the Dictates of reason . 3. Confirme it by Scripture Arguments . I. Albeit , as was shewed before , this Question as now stated , is in many respects unprecedented ; yet the practice , which in our day hath been the result of it , to wit , to disoune or not to oune Prevailing Dominators Usurping the Government or abusing it , is not so alien from the examples of History , but that by Equivalency or consequence it may be collected from , & confirmed by instances . 1. To begin at home , besides many Passages related already for confirmation , we may adde ( 1 ) That for about 1025. years , the people had in their choise whom to oune ar admit to succeed in the Government , even though the Kingdom was hereditary ; and used to elect , not such who were nearest in blood & line , but these that were judged most fit for Government , being of the same progeny of Fergus , Buchan . Rer. Scot. lib. 6. pag. 195. in vita Kennethi . 3. This continued until the dayes of Kenneth the 3. who to cover his villanous Murder of his Brothers Son Malcolm , and prevent his and secure his oun sons succession , procured this Charter for Tyranny , the settlement of the succession of the next in line from the Parliament : which , as it pretended the prevention of many inconveniences , arising from Contentions & Competions about the succession ; So it was limited by Lawes , Precluding the succession of Fools or Monsters , and preserving the peoples liberty to shake off the yoke , when Tyranny should thereby be introduced : Otherwise it would have been not only an irrational surrender of all their oune Rights , & enslaving the posterity , but an irreligious contempt of Providence , refusing & anticipating its Determination in such a case . However it is clear , before this time , that as none but the fittest were admitted to the Government ; So if any did usurpe upon it , or afterwards did degenerate into Tyranny , they took such order with him , as if he had not been admitted at all ; as is clear in the instances of the first Period , and would never oune every pretender to hereditary succession . ( 2 ) As before Kenneths dayes , it is hard to reckon the numerous Instances of Kings that were dethroned , or imprisoned , or slain , upon no other account than that of their oppression & Tyranny : So afterwards , they maintained the same power & priviledge of repressing them , when ever they began to encroach . And although no Nation hath been more patient towards bad Kings , as well as Loyal towards good ones ; yet in all former times , they understood so well their Right they had , and the duty they owed to their oun preservation , as that they seldom failed of calling the exorbitantly flagitious to an account . And albeit , in stead of condoling or avenging the death of the Tyrannous , they have often both excused & justified it , yet no Kingdom hath inflicted severer Punishments upon the Murderers of just & righteous Princes : And therefore , though they did neither enquire after , nor animadvert upon those that slew Iames the 3. a flagitious Tyrant , yet they did by most exquisite Torments put them to death who slew Iames the 1. a vertuous Monarch . Hence , because these & other instances I mind to adduce of deposing Tyrants , may be excepted against , as not pertinent to my purpose , who am not pleading for exauctoration & deposition of Tyrants , being impracticable in our case : I shall once for all remove that , and desire it may be considered . [ 1 ] That though we cannot formally exauctorate a Tyrant ; yet he may ipso jure fall from his right , and may exauctorate himself , by His Law by whom Kings reign ; and this is all we plead for as a foundation of not ouning him . [ 2 ] Though we have not the same power , yet we have the same grounds , and as great & good if not greater & better reasons to reject & disoune our Tyrant , as they whose example is here adduced had to depose some of their Tyrannizing Princes . [ 3 ] If they had power & ground to depose them , then a fortiori they had power & ground to disoune them ; for that is less & inculded in the other , and this we have . [ 4 ] Though it should be granted , that they did not disoune them before they were deposed ; yet it cannot be said that they did disoune them only because they were deposed : for it is not deposition that makes a Tyrant ; it only declares him to be justly punished , for what he was before . As the sentance of a Judge does not make a man a murderer or Thief , only declares him convict of these Crimes , & punishable for them ; it s his oun committing them that makes him Criminal : And as before the sentance , having certain knowledge of the fact , we might disoune the Mans innocency or honesty ; So a Rulers Acts of Tyranny & Usurpation make him a Tyrant & Usurper , and give ground to disoune his just & legal Authority ; which he can have no more than a Murtherer or Thief can have innocency or honesty . ( 3 ) We find also examples of their disouning Kings undeposed ; as King Baliol was disouned with his whole race , for attempting to enslave the Kingdoms Liberties to forreign power . And if this may be done for such an attempt , as the greatest Court parasites & Sycophants consent ; what then shall be done for such as attempt to subject the people to Domestick or Intestine Slaverie ? Shall we refuse to be slaves to one without , and be , & oune our selves contented Slaves to one with in the Kingdom ? It is known also that King Iames the 1. his Authority was refused by his subjects in France , so long as he was a Prisoner to the English there , though he charged them upon their Allegiance , not to fight against the party who had his person Prisoner : They answered , they ouned no Prisoner for their King , nor owed no Allegiance to a Prisoner . Hence Princes may learn , though people submit to their Government ; yet their resignation of themselves to their obedience is not so full , as that they are obliged to oune Allegiance to them , when either Morally or Physically they are incapacitate to exerce Authority over them . They that cannot rule themselves , cannot be ouned as Rulers over a people . 2. Neither hath there been any Nation , but what at one time or other hath furnished examples of this Nature . The English History gives account , how some of their Kings have been dealt with by their Subjects , for impieties against the Law & Light of Nature , and encroachments upon the Lawes of the Land. Vortigernu● was dethroned for incestously marying his oun Sister . Neither did ever Blasphemies , Adulteries , Murders , Plotting against the lives of Innocents , and taking them away by Poison or Razor , use to escape the animadversion of men , before they were Priest-ridden unto a belief that Princes persons were sacred . And if men had that generosity now , this man that now reigns might expect some such animadversion . And we find also King Edward , & Richard the 2. were deposed , for Usurpation upon Lawes & Liberties , in doing whereof the people avowed . They would not suffer the Lawes of England to be changed . Surely the people of England must now be far degenerate , who having such Lawes transmitted to them from their worthy Ancestors , and they themselves being born to the possession of them without a Change , do now suffer them to be so encroached upon , and mancipate themselves , & leave their Children vassals to Poperie , & slaves to Tyranny . 3. The Dutch also , who have the best way of guiding of Kings of any that ever had to do with them ( witness their having so many of them in Chains , now in Batavia in the East Indies ) are not wanting for their part to furnish us with examples . When the King of Spain would not condescend to govern them according to their Ancient Lawes , and rule for the good of the people , they declared him to be fallen from the Seigniorie of the Netherlands , and so erected themselves into a flourishing Common-wealth . It will not be amiss to transcribe some of the words of the Edict of the Estates General to this purpose . It is well known , ( say they ) that a Prince & Lord of a Countrey is Ordained by God to be Soveraign & Head over his subjects , to preserve & defend them from all injuries , force , & violence , and that if the Prince therefore faileth therein , and in stead of preserving his subjects , doth outrage & oppress them , depriveth them of their Priviledges & Ancient Customs , commandeth them and will be served of them as slaves ; they are no longer bound to respect him as their Soveraign Lord , but to esteem of him as a Tyrant , neither are they bound to acknowledge him as their Prince , but may abandon him &c. And with this aggrees the answer of William Prince of Orange to the Edict of Proscription , published against him by Philip. the II. There is , sayes he , a Reciprocal Bond betwixt the Lord & his vassal ; so that if the Lord break the Oath , which he hath made unto his vassal , the vassal is discharged of the Oath made unto his Lord. This was the very Argument of the poor suffering people of Scotland , whereupon they disouned the Authority of Charles the Second . 4. The Monarchy of France is very absolute ; yet there also the State hath taken order with their Tyrants ; not only have we many instances of resistances made against them , but also of disouning , disabling , & invalidating their pretended Authority & repressing their Tyranny . So was the two Childerici served : So also Sigebertus , Dagabertus , and Lodowick the II. Kings of France . 5. The great body of Germany moves very slowly , and is inured to bear great burdens : yet there also we find Ioan●a of Austria Mother of Charles the 5. was put to perpetual sonment : which example is adduced by the Earle of Mortoun , in his discourse to the Queen of England ( whereof I rehearsed a part before ) vindicating the deposing & disouning Queen Mary of Scotland . If , saith he , we compare her with Ioanna of Austria — what did that poor wretch commit , but that she could not want a litle lustful pleasure , as a remedy necessary for her age ? And yet poor Creature , she suffered that punishment , of which our Dame convicted of most grievous Crimes now complains — Buchan . Rer. Scotic . l. b. 20. pag. 748. The Duke of Saxon , the Landgrave of Hesse and the Magistrats of Magdeburgh , joined in a war against her Son Charles the 5. and drew up a conclusion by resolution of Lawyers , wherein are these words — Neither are we bound to him by any other reason , than if he keep the conditions on which he was created Emperour . By the Laws themselves it is provided , that the Superior Magistrate shall not infringe the right of the inferior , & if the Superior Magistrate exceed the Limits of his power , and command that which is wicked , not only we need not obey him , but if he offer force we may resist him . Which Opinion is confirmed by some of the greatest Lawyers , and even some who are Patrons of Tyranny , Grotius none of the greatest enemies of Tyrants , de jure belli lib. 1. cap. 4. n : 11. sayth out of Barclaius , & with him , that the King doth loss his power when he seeketh the destruction of his subjects . It was upon the account of the Tyranny of that bloody house of Austria over the Helvetians , that they shook off the rule & Government of that family , and established themselves into a Republick . And at this present time , upon the same accounts , the Tyranny & Treachery of this Imperial Majestie , the Hungarians have essayed to maintain & justify a revolt in disouning the Emperour , now for several years . 6. Polland is an Elective Kingdom , and so cannot but be fertile of many instances of casting off Tyrants . Henricus Valesius , disouned for fleeing , and Sigismuadus for violating his faith to the States , may suffice . Lex Rex Q. 24. Pag. 217. 7. In Denmark , we find Christiernus their King , was for his intollerable Cruelty put from the Kingdom , he and all his Posterity , and after twenty years did end his life in Prison . 8. In Swedland , within the Compass of one Century , the people deposed & banished the two Christierns , and dethroned & imprisoned Ericus , for their oppressions & Tyranny , and for pursuing the destruction of their Subjects . 9. The Portugieses , not many years ago , laid aside and confined Alphonsus their King , for his rapines & Murders . 10. Some Dukes of Venice have been so disouned by these Common-wealths men , that laying aside their Royal honours as private men , they have spent their dayes in Monasteries . Buchan . de jure regni apud Scotos . 11. If we will revolve the old Roman Histories , we shall find no small store of such examples , both in the time of their Kings , Consuls , & Emperours . Their seventh King Tarquinius Superbus , was removed by the people , for his evident Usurpation : Neque enim ad jus regni quicquam praeter vim habebat , ut qui neque populi jussu , neque Patribus Authoribus , regnavit , sayth Livius i.e. for he had nothing for a right to the Government , but meer force , and got the rule neither by the peoples consent & choise , nor by the Authority of the Senators . So afterwards the Empire was taken from Vitellius , Heliogabulus , Maximinus , Didius Iulianus , Lex Rex , ub , supra . 12. But it will be said . Can there be any Instances of the Primitive Christians adduced ? Did ever they , while groaning under the most insupportable Tyranny of their Persecuting Emperours , disoune their Authority , or suffer for not ouning it ? To this I answer . 1. What they did or did not of this Kind , is not of moment to inquire : seeing their practice & Example , under such disavantages , can neither be known exactly , nor what is known of it be accommodated to our case : for ( 1 ) they were never forced to give their judgement , neither was the question ever put to them , whether they ouned their Authority or not : if they transgressed the Lawes , they were lyable to the punishment , they craved no more of them . ( 2 ) They confess themselves to be strangers , that had no establishments by Law , and therefore they behoved to be passively subject , when in no capacity to resist ; there was no more required of them . Yet Lex Rex Quest. 35. pag. 371. cites Theodoret affirming , Th●n evil men reigned through the unmanlyness of the sub●ects . ( 3 ) Their examples are not imitable in all things : They were against resistence , which we doubt not to prove is Lawful against Tyrannical vio●ence : Many of them refused to flee from the fury of Persecuters : They ran to Martyrdom , when neither cited nor accused ; And to obtain the Croun thereof they willingly yeelded up their lives & Liberties also to the rage or Tyrants . We cannot be obliged to all these . 2 Yet we find some examples not altogether unapplicable to this purpose . When Barochbach , the pretended King of the Iewes , after the destruction of Ierusalem , set himself up as King in Bitter a City in Arabia ; the Christians that were in his precincts , refused to oune him as King ; which was one great cause of his persecuting them . It s true he persecuted them also for other things , as for their not denying Christ ; So are we persecuted for many other things , than for our simple disouning of the King : yet this is reckoned as a distinct cause of their suffering , by Mr Mede on the Revel . Part. 1. Pag. 43. Gees Magist. Origin . ch . 10. Sect. 7. Pag. 361. The same last cited Author shewes , that when Albinus , Niger ; & Cassius , successively usurped the Empire , having none of them any Legal investure , the Christians declined the recognition of their Claim , and would not oune them ; and that upon this Tertulian sayes , Nunquam Albiniani , nec Nigriani , vel Cassiani , inveniri potuerunt Christiani , that is , the Christians could never be found to be Albinians , or Nigrians , or Cassians , meaning they were never ouners of these men for Magistrats . And so may we say , Pudet inveniri inter Carolinianos & Iacobinianos hujus temporis . Not unlike is the passage of Ambrose , who in favors of Valentinia● the rightful Governour , contested against Maximus the Tyrant , and not only disouned him but excommunicated him , for which he was threatened with death . And yet it is observable , that when Maximus offered to interpose his power in defence of Ambrose , that he might not be banished by Iustina the Empress , he would not accept of the help of Maximus , whose power he disallowed & disouned . Whence I observe , that it is not without a Precedent for a Minister to disoune a Tyrant , to refuse favour from him , yea and to excommunicate him , yea even without the concurrence of his fainting brethren ; for all which some of our faithful Ministers have been much condemned in our day , especially Mr Donald Cargil for excommunicating Charles the Second & Iames Duke of York , as if such a thing had never been done before : Whereas we see what Ambrose did to Maximus . And this same faithful Minister Ambrosius Minister at Millain , in Italy , did also hold out of the Assembly of the Christians Theodosius the Emperour though a most vertuous Prince , for that grievous Scandal committed by him , against the innocent people at Thessalonica , in killing so many of them in a Passionate transport . But 3. since this objection of the Primitive Christians is much insisted on , both against this and the head of defensive Armes : I shall further take notice of several distinctions , that do make the difference between their case & Ours very vast . ( 1 ) There is a great difference betuixt a Prince of the common Religion of his Subjects , but distinct from some of them , whom yet he does not seek to entice to his Religion , but gives them liberty & the benefite of the Law as other Subjects : ( which was the case of many in these primitive times sometimes . ) And a Prince by all means , both foul & fair , pressing to a revolt from the true and to embrace a false Religion . In this case ( which is ours with a witness ) it must be granted we should be wary , that we neither engage with him , nor oune Allegiance to him , when he would withdraw us from our Allegiance to God. ( 2 ) There is a great difference betuixt a Prince , persecuting the true Religion , which only a few of his subjects here & there did profess , who in regard of their Paucity were never in capacity to be looked upon as the body of the people , impowering him as their publick Servant : ( which was their case ) And a Prince persecuting that Religion● which was professed by the body of the Nation , when they sett him up . In this Latter case , men of great sense have denyed he should be ouned for a Prince , because then he is stated against the Common good . This was our case under the former King , and yet under this , though all Professors be not now persecuted , the publick Religion & Ancient Reformation is persecuted in a few , whom he intends to destroy , and in their destruction to bury it . ( 3 ) There is a difference , betwixt a Prince Persecuting Religion publickly ouned & received of his subjects , yet never approved nor confirmed by Law ( as it was not in the primitive times ) And a Prince persecuting Religion ratified & established by the Laws of the Land , which is our case . It will seem clear to every soul , not benighted with Court darkness , that he then de●acto and ipso jure falleth from his right in this case , because now he is not only stated against the common good , but against the very Laws by which the Subjects must be ruled . Then he ruleth not as a Prince ▪ to whom the Law giveth his Measures & Bounds , but rageth as a Tiger & Tyrant , and ought to be carried towards as such . ( 4 ) There is a difference , betwixt a Prince suppressing that Religion established by Law , which he never professed , nor never gave his consent to these Laws ( as might be the case of some of the Arian Emperours ) though it be unlawful for any people to set up any Mortal over them , who is not in this case bound to the good behaviour ; And a Prince , opposing , & oppressing that Religion , which himself hath professed and is ratified by Laws with his oun consent : which was our case under the former King , who did give the most solemn Ratification of them that ever was given , but afterwards most perfidiously retracted it . As also this Apostate Papist , did somtime profess himself Protestant , and consented to the Laws establishing it , and the Penal Statutes against Papists , though now he is going about to raze all , and ruine that alone valuable Treasure of our Nation , Religion . ( 5 ) There is a difference , betwixt a Prince consenting to Laws establishing Religion which he now persecuteth ( which might have been the case of Iulian the Apostate ) And a Prince who not only consented to these Laws , but who did upon these very terms & no other get & receive his Croun & Scepter , that he should preserve the Religion as Reformed , and protect as a Father the Professors thereof , and maintain the Laws establishing it , which yet he perfidiously & perniciously , being once settled in the Government , Breaks , Casts , Cassats , & Overturns ( which was done by Charles ) Or , And a Prince who will neither be bounded by the Laws he consented to , nor be bound to the Observation of any Laws whatsoever ; but challenges it as his prerogative Royal , to be absolute above all Laws , and denying all Security upon terms , is free to destroy Religion & Liberty , and all the valuable Interests of the Nation , when he pleases . This is Iames his Character ( 6 ) There is a difference , betwixt a Prince breaking the main & only Article of his Covenant , in a fit of fury & rage , being transported upon some Mistakes ( which was the case of Theodosius the Emperour ) And a Prince not only violating this upon deliberation , but plainly Declaring , that neither Oath nor Declaration can or will bind him , but these being made void , he will destroy without restraint all these Covenanted priviledges ( This was the case of Charles ) Or , And a Prince , who , as he never will come under the bond of a Covenant with his people , So thô he make never so many fair promises with the greatest Solemnities , maintains a principle that he will keep no promises , but when & with whom he pleases , and can get a Dispensation to break all when he likes . ( This is Iames his Ingenuity . ) Sure in this case , Such as are so Characterized Declare themselves so far from being Princes , that they profess befor the world , they are no more men to be conversed with : for if neither their words , Writs , vowes , promises , Oaths , Declarations , nor Protestations , can bind them ; what Society can be had with them ? Are they not to be looked upon & carried towards as Common Enemies of Morality , Religion , Righteousness , Liberty , Humanity , yea even of Mankind it self ? Now then , let the world be Judge , if the people of Scotland can be judged in Conscience , Reason , Prudence , Policie , or any imaginable way , bound to oune their Authority , being so Stated , and by the Act Rescissory all humane ground rescinded , that ever it shall be otherwise . let them go seek other slaves where they can find them , for we will not sell our selves & posteritie to Tyrants as slaves , nor give up our Religion and the exercise of it to the Mouldings of the Court. II. In the Second place : It being clear from these forementioned Instances , that Tyrants & Uusurpers have been disouned ; And it being also as clear as light can make any thing , from the foregoing Account of their Government , and all the Characters of Truculency Treachery , & Tyranny conspicuously relucent therein , that these two Gentlemen whose Authority we are pressed to oune , were Tyrants & Usurpers : It remains therefore to prove from all dictates of Reason about Government , that their pretended Authority could not nor cannot be ouned . For the Argument runs thus ; The Authority of Tyrants & Uusurpers cannot be ouned : But the Authority of Charles & Iames was & is the Authority of Tyrants & Usurpers : Ergo their Authority cannot be ouned . Now it s the Major of this Syllogisim that I under take to prove . The Minor being so clear from their History , that to prove it by witnesses were actum agere . 1. All Authority to be ouned of men must be of God , and ordained of God : for so the Apostle teacheth Expressly Rom. 13. 1. &c. Which is the alone formal reason of our Subjection to them , and that which makes it a damnable sin to resist them , because it is a resisting the Ordin●nce of God. The Lord ounes Himself to be the Author of Magistrats , Prov. 8. 15. By me Kings reign and Princes decree Iustice. As He is the Author of man and hath made him a sociable Creature so He is the Author of the Order of humane Society which is necessare for the Preservation of Mankind He being the God of Order & not of Confusion . And this must hold not only of the Supreme Authority , but of subordinate Magistrates also ; for they must be included in the higher Powers to whom we must be subject Rom. 13. And they that resist them resist Gods Ordinance too . Their judgment is Gods , as well as the judgment of the Supreme Magistrate Deut. 1. 17. 2 Chron. 19. 6 , 8. They are called Gods among whom the Lord judgeth , Psal. 82. 1. He speaketh not there of a Congregation of Kings . We are to be subject to them for the Lords sake , as well as to the Supreme Magistrat 1. Pet. 2. 13. Therefore all Magistrats superior & Inferior are ordained of God in the respective Places . It s true , Peter calls every degree of Magistracy , an Ordinance of man , not that he denies it to be an Ordinance of God ( for so he would cantradict Paul Rom. 13. ) but termes it so Emphatically , to commend the worth of obedience to Magistrats though but men , when we do it for the Lords sake : Not effectively as an invention of men , but subjectively because exercised by men , & created & invested by humane suffrages considered as men in Societie , and objectively for the good of man , and for the external Peace & safety of man thereby differenced from the Ministry , an Ordinance of Christ , for the spiritual good of mens souls . Hence , Those Rulers that are not of God nor ordained of God , cannot be ouned without sin : But Tyrants & Usurpers are the Rulers , that are not of God nor ordained of God , but are set up and not by Him &c. Hos. 8. 1-4 . Therefore they cannot be ouned without sin . I refer it to any man of conscience & Reason to judge , if these Scriptures proving Magistracy to be the Ordinance of God , for which alone it is to be ouned , can be applyed to Tyrants & Usurpers : How will that Rom , 13. read of Tyrants ? let every soul be subject to Tyrants , for they are ordained of God as His Ministers of Iustice &c. and are a terror to evil works and a praise to the good , would not every man nauseate that as not the Doctrine of God ? Again , how would that sound Prov. 8. By me Tyrants reign & Usurpers decree injustice ? harsh to Christian ears . Can they be said to be Gods among whom the Lord judgeth ? If they be , they must be such as the witch of Endor saw , Gods coming out of the earth , when she raised the Devil ; in a very Catichrestical meaning , as the Devil is called the God of this world . And indeed they have no more power , nor otherwise to be ouned , than he hath : for this is a Truth , Tyranny is a work of Satan & not from God ; because sin either habitual or actual is not from God ; Tyranny is sin in habit & act : Ergo — The Magistrate as Magistrate is good in nature & end , being the Minister of God for good , A Tyrant as a Tyrant is quite contrary . Lex Rex saith well A power Ethical , Politick , or Moral , to oppress , is not from God , and is not a power but a Licentious deviation of a power , and no more from God but from sinful Nature & the old Serpent , than a licence to sin , Quest. 9. Pag. 59. Hence sin , a Licence to sin , a Licencious sinning , cannot be from God : But Tyranny , Usurpation , absolute power encroaching upon all Liberties , Laws , Divine & humane , is sin , a Licence to sin , a Licencious sinning . Ergo — But to make this clear , and to obviate what may be said against this : let it be Considered how the powers that be are of God & ordained of God. Things are said to be of God and ordained of God two wayes ; by His purpose & providence , and by His Word & Warrant . Things may be of God , either of His Hand working or bringing them about ordaining & ordering them to be to His Glory ; either by a holy overruling Providence , as Samsons desire of a wife was of God Iudg. 14. 4. and Amaziahs insolent & foolish rejection of Ioash his Peaceable overture 2 Chron. 25. 20. Or by a powerful effective providence , So Rom. 11. 36. Of Him & through Him are all things 1 Cor. 8. 6. One God of whom are all things . Or things be of God of His Word warranting & Authorizing . So we are commanded to try the spirits whether they be of God ( 1 Iohn . 4. 1. ) So in this sense , sin , tentation , lust , Corruptions of the world are not of God Iam. 1. 13. 1 Iohn . 2. 16. Again , things are ordained of God , either by the order of His Counsel or Providential will , either effectively by way of Production or Direction , or Permissively by way of non-impedition : Or they are ordained by the order of His Word & Preceptive will ▪ The former is Gods Rule , the latter is ours : The former is alwise accomplished , the latter is often contradicted : The former orders all actions even sinful , the latter only that which is good & acceptable in the sight of God ▪ By the former Israel rejected Samuel , by the latter they should have continued Samuels Government , and not sought a King : By the former , Athaliah usurped the Government , by the latter , she should have yeelded obedience & resigned the Government to the posterity of Ahaziah : By the former all have a physical subordination to God as Creatures , subject to His All-disposing will ; by the latter , Those whom He approves have a moral subordination to God , as obedient subjects to His Commanding will. Now Magistrats are of God and ordained by Him both these wayes , Tyrants but one of them . I say , Magistrats , the higher Powers , to whom we owe & must oune subjection are of God both these wayes , both by His purpose & Providence , and that not meerly eventual but effective & executive of His Word , disposing both of the Title & Right , & Possession of the power , to them whom He approves , and bringing the People under a consciencious subjection , And by His Word & warrant . So Adonijah the Usurper ( though he had the pretence of Hereditary right , and also possession by Providence ) was forced to oune King Solomon in these termes upon which only a Magistrate may be ouned : The Kingdome , sayes he , was mine , and all Israel set their faces on me that I should reign , howbeit the Kingdom is turned about and become my brothers for it was his from the Lord , 1 King. 2. 15. He had both Providence turning about the Kingdom to him , and also the Warrant of the Lords Approbative & preceptive will. But Tyrants & Usurpers are only of God and ordained of God , by His overruling purpose & permissive Providence , either for performing His holy purpose towards themselves ; as Rehoboams professing he would be a Tyrant , and refusing the Lawful desires of the people was of God 2 Chron. 10. 15. Or for a judgment & vengeance upon them that are subject to them , Zech. 11 : 6 : whereby they get a power in their hand , which is the Rod of the Lords Indignation , and a Charge & Commission against a Hypocritical Nation Isa. 10. 5. 6. This is all the power they have from God , who gives Iacob to the spoil & Israel to the Robbers , when they sin against Him Isa. 42. 24. This doth not give these Robbers any right , no more than they whose Tabernacle prosper , into whose hand God bringeth abundantly Iob. 12. 6. Thus all Robbers , and the great Legal Robbers , Tyrants , and their Authorized Murderers , may be of God , to wit , by His Providence . Hence those that are not ordained of Gods preceptive will , but meerly by His Providential will , their Authority is not to be ouned : But Tyrants & Usurpers are not ordained of Gods Preceptive , but meerly by His Providential will. The Minor needs no proof : yet will be cleared by many folowing Arguments . The Major will be afterwards more demonstrated . Here I shall only say , They that have no other ordination of God impowering them to be Rulers , than the devil hath , must not be ouned : But they that have no other than the ordination of Providence , have no other ordination of God impowering them to be Rulers than the devil hath : Ergo they that have no other than the ordination of Providence must not be ouned . 2. But let us next consider , what is comprehended in the Ordination of that Authority which is to be ouned as of God : And it may be demonstrated there are two things in it , without which no Authority can be ouned as of God , viz. Institution & Constitution : So as to give him , whom we must oune as Gods Minister , Authority both in the Abstract & Concrete , that is , that he should have Magistracy by Gods Ordination , and be a Magistrate by & according to the will of God. All acknowledge that Magistracy hath Gods Institution , for the Powers that be are ordained of God : which contains not only the Appointment of it , but the qualification & forme of it . That Government is appointed by Divine Precept all agree , but whether the Precept be Moral Natural , or Moral Positive , Whether it was appointed in the State of Innocency , or since disorder came in the world , Whether it be Primario or Secundario , from the Law of nature is not agreed upon , It may possibly be all these wayes ; Government in the General may be from the Law and light of Nature appointed in Innocency , because all its relative duties are enjoined in the fifth Command , and all Nations Naturally have an esteem of it , Without which ther could be no order , distinction , or Communion in humane Societies , But the Specification or Individuation may be by a Postnate Positive & Secundary Law , yet Natural too , for though ther be no reason in Nature why any man should be King & Lord over another , being in some sense all Naturally free but as they yeeld themselves under Jurisdiction : The exalting of David over Israel is not ascribed to Nature , but to an act of divine bounty which took him from following the Ewes and made him feeder of the People of Israel , Psal. 78. 70 , 71 : yet Nature teacheth that Israel and other People should have a Government , and that this should be subjected to . Next , not only is it appointed to be , but qualified by Institution , and the Office is defined , the End prescribed , and the measures & Boundaries thereof are limited , as we shall hear . Again the formes of it , though Politically they are not stinted , that People should have such a forme & not another : yet Morally , at least Negatively , whatever be the forme , it is limited to the Rules of equity & justice , and must be none other than what hath the Lords Mould & Sanction . But there is no Institution any of these wayes for Tyranny . Hence , that Power that hath no Institution from God , cannot be ouned as His ordinance : But the Power of Tyrants is that Power , being contrary in every respect to Gods Institution , and a meer deviation from it , & eversion of it . Ergo — To the Minor it may be replyed ; Though the Power which Tyrants may exerce & Usurpers assume , may be in Concret● contrary to Gods Institution , and so not to be ouned : yet in abstracto , it may be acknowledged of God. It s but the abuse of the Power , and that does not take away the use . We may oune the Power , though we do not oune the abuse of it . I ans . 1. I acknowledge the distinction as to Magistrats is very pertinent : for it is well said by the Congregation in a Letter to the Nobility , Knox Hist. of Scot. lib. 2. That there is a great difference betwixt the Authority which is Gods ordinance , and the persons of these who are placed in Authority ; the Authority & ordinance of God can never do wrong , for it commandeth that vice be punished & virtue maintained ; But the Corrupt Person placed in this Authority may offend — Its certain higher Powers are not to be resisted but some persons in Power may be resisted . The Powers are ordained of God , but Kings commanding unjust things are not ordained of God to do such things . But to apply this to Ty●ants , I do not understand : Magistrats in some Acts may be guilty of Tyranny , and yet retain the Power of Magistracy ; but Tyrants cannot be capable of Magistracy , nor any one of the Scripture Characters of Righteous Rulers . They cannot retain that which they have forefeited , and which they have overturned ; And Usurpers cannot retain that which they never had . They may act & enact some things materially just , but they are not formally such as can make them Magistrats , no more then some unjust actions can make a Magistrate a Tyrant . A Murderer , saying the ●ife of one & killing another , does not make him no Murderer : Once a Murderer ay a Murderer , once a Robber ay a Robber , till he restore what he hath robbed : So once a Tyrant ay a Tyrant , till he make amends for his Tyranny , and that will be hard to do . 2. The Concrete does specificate the Abstract in actuating it , as a Magistrate , in his exercising Government makes his Power to be Magistracy ; a Robber in his robbing , makes his Power to be Roberie ; an Usurper in his usurping makes his Power to be Usurpation ; So a Tyrant in his Tyrannizing can have no Power but Tyranny . As the Abstract of a Magistrate is nothing but Magistracy , So the Abstract of a Tyrant is nothing but Tyranny . It s frivolous then to distinguish between a Tyrannical power in the Concrete , & Tyranny in the Abstract ; the power & the abuse of the power : for he hath no power as a Tyrant , but what is abused . 3. They that objects thus , must either mean , that power in its general Notion is ordained of God , but this particular Power ab●sed by Tyrants , and assumed by Usurpers , is not ordained : Or they must mean , that the very Power of Tyrants & Usurpers is ordained of God , but the way of holding & using it is not of God. If the first be said , they grant all I plead for : for thô the Power in general be ordained , yet what is this to Tyrants & Usurpers ? would not this Claim be ridiculous for any man to say , God hath ordained Governments to be , therefore I will challenge it ? God hath ordained Marriage , therefore any may cohabit together as man & wife , without formal Matrimony ? If the Second be alledged , that the Power of these prevailing Dominators is ordained , but not their holding & using of it : This is Non-sense , for how can a Power be ordained and the use of it be unlawful ? For , the abuse & use of Tyrannical Power is all one and reciprocal : an Usurper cannot use his Power but by Usurpation . Again is it not plain , that the Abstract & the Concrete , the act or habit , and the subject wherein it is , cannot have a contrary Denomination ? if Drunkenness and Thieft , Lying or Murder , be of the Devil ; then the Drunkard , the Thief , the Lyar , & the Murderer , are of the Devil too : So if Tyranny and Usurpation , or the use or abuse of Tyrants & Usurpers , be of the Devil ; Then must the Tyrants & Usurpers also be of him : None can say , the one is of the Devil , and the other of God. Wherefore it is altogether impertinent to use such a Distinction , with application to Tyrants or Usurpers , as many do in their pleading for the ouning of our Oppressors : for they have no power , but what is the abuse of power . 3. As that Authority which is Gods Ordinance must have His Institution : So it must have His divine Constitution from Himself and by the people . Wherever then there is Authority to be ouned of men , there must be these tuo , Constitution from God and Constitution from the people . For the first , God hath a special Interest in the Constitution of Authority , both Immediatly & Mediatly . Immediatly , He declares such & such formes of Government to be Lawful & Eligible , and does order whom & who and how people shall erect Governours . And so , He confers Royal Graces & Enduements & Gifts for Government on them , as on Ioshua & Saul : So they become the Lords Anointed , placed & set on the Throne of the Lord , 1 Chron. 29. 23. and honoured with Majestie as His deputies & vicegerents , having their Croun set on by God Psal. 21. 3. But in regard now He doth not by any special Revelation determine , who shall be the Governours in this or that place ; Therefore He makes this Constitution by mediation of men ; giving them Rules how they shall proceed in setting them up . And seeing by the Law of Nature He hath enjoined Government to be , but hath ordered no particular in it with application to singulars , He hath committed it to the positive transaction of men , to be disposed according to certain General Rules of Justice . And it must needs be so , for 1. without this Constitution , either all or none would be Magistrats : if He hath ordained Civil Power to be , and taken no order in whom it shall be , or how it shall be conveyed , any might pretend to it ; and yet none would have a right to it , more than another . If then He ●ath affixed it to a peculiar having & holding , by virtue whereof this man is enstated & entitled to the office , and not that man , there must be a Law for Constituting him in Authority , which will discover in whom it is . 2. If it were not so , then a resisting of a particular Magistrate would not be a resisting of the ordinance of God , if a particular Magistrate were not Constitute of God , as well as Magistracy is Institute of God : for still it would be undetermined , who were the Power ; and so it would be left as free & Lawful for the resister to take the place , as for the resisted to hold it ; the institution would be satisfied if any possessed i● : therefore there must be Constitution to determine it . 3. No Common Law of Nature can be put into practice , without particular Constitution regulating it . That Wives & Children oune their superior relations , is the Law of Nature ; but there must be such a relation first fixed by humane transaction , before they can oune them ; there must be Marriage Authorized of God , there must be Children begotten , and then the Divine Ordination of these relative duties take place . So the Judges of Israel for 450 years were given of God , Act. 13. 20. not all by an immediate express designation , but a mediate Call from God by men , as Iephthah Iudg. 11. 6. 11. Inferior judges also are Magistrats appointed by God , yet they have their Deputation from men . Our Saviour speaks of all Magistrats , when he applies that of the 82. Psalm to them , I said ye are Gods ; and shewes how they were Gods , because unto them the Word of God came , Iohn . 10. 35. that is , by His Word & Warrant He Authorized them , not by immediate designation in reference to the most of them , but the Word of God comes to them , or His Constitution is past upon them , who are advanced by men according to His Word . When men therefore do act according to the Divine Rule , in the Moulding & Erecting of Government & Governours , there the Constitution is of God , though it be not immediate . And where this is not observed , whatever power ( so named or pretended ) there may be , or what-soever persons there be that take upon them to be the power , and are not thereto appointed or therein instated , and do exerce such a power as God hath not legitmated , they are not a power ordained of God. Hence , whatsoever power hath no Constitution from God , eather Immediate or Mediate , cannot be ouned : But the Authority of Tyrants & Usurpers , is a power that hath no Constitution from God , either Immediate or Mediate : Ergo it cannot be ouned . The Major is cleared above . The Minor is also undenyable : For , either they must pretend to an Immediate Constitution by revelation , that Iames Duke of York , a vassal of Antichrist , had by all his plots & pranks Merited the Crown of Britain , and therefore must be Constitute King : And this I hope they will not pretend to , except the Pope hath gotten such a Revelation from Pluto's Oracle : Or they must have recourse to the Mediate Constitution by men : And if so ; Then , either this Mediate Constitution of God is left undetermined , indefinitely & absolutely giving way to any that will assume what power they please & can : And then , I confess , Tyrants may have a Constitution ; but this confusion cannot be of God : Or else , it is fixed by a Rule , regulating the succession or Constitution of the Governours , and obliging the people to oune the Government so constituted , with exclusion & disallowance of any other . And so , if in that Constitution there be a Substantial Deviation from the Rule , as when incompetent or unallowed persons be the advancers of themselves , or others , into that place by illegal & sinistrous means , in as much as in that case there is the Divine disapprobation , it may be said there is no Ordinance of God , but a Contradiction & Contraordination to Gods Order . Gee's Magist. Origin . chap. 5. Sect. 4. subject 3. pag. 135. This will shake off this of ours , and all other Tyrants & Usurpers , that come into the Government , & hold it not according to Gods Rule . 4. It is clear also in the second place , that the Authority which we can oune out of conscience , must have Constitution by the people . The special way by which men should be called into the place of Soveraign power , may perhaps not be found so expressly defined in Scripture , as mens Call to the other Ordinance of the Ministrie is ; yet in this two things are essentially necessary to the Constitution of a Magistrate , The peoples consent & compact either formal or virtual . And without these we can oune consciencious subjection & Allegiance to no man living . That the first is necessary will be evident , from the Law of Nature & Nations , and from Scripture . First the light & Law of Nature dictates , that the Right & Interest of Constituting Magistrats is in the Elective vote or suffrage of the people . This will Appear . 1. If we consider , The Original of Government among men , especially after they were so multiplied , that there was a necessity of a reduction into diverse Communities ; which , whatever was before the flood , yet after it , behoved to be by a Coalition with consent under an Elective Government . The Scripture makes it more than probable , that the first partition of Common-wealths was in Pelegs dayes , in whose time the earth was Divided Gen. 10. 25. occasioned by the Confusion of Languages at Babel which did dissolve their union and scatter them abroad upon the face of all the eath Gen. 11. 9. Then was it that we may conceive , as Buchanan sayes de Iure Regni apud Scot. the time was , when men dwelt in cottages & caves , and as strangers did wander to & fro without Laws , and such as could converse together of the same language assembled together as their humors did lead them , or as some common Utilitie did allure them ▪ A certain instinct of Nature did oblige them to desire Converse & Societie . But this confusion of Languages , and Communion of Language , in several divided Parcels , could not incorporate these several Parties into Communities ; that behoved to be the effect of some other cause : & what should that be , but the joint will , consent & aggreement of the severally Languaged ? It could not be by Consanguinity ; for there is no direction from Nature for a confinement of that into such & such degrees , to make out the bounds of a Common-wealth , or Possibility of knowing all with in such degrees ; besides all within these degrees might not be of the same Language . Now the Scripture sayes , they were divided every one after his tongue , after their families , in their Nations Gen. 10. 5. Next it could not be by Cohabitation : for how that must go to be the boundaries of a Common-wealth , inclusively or exclusively , is not defined by nature , nor can it be otherwise determined than by humane choise . Then , it could not be by mens belonging to such a Soveraign : for after that Division & Confusion , they could not all be under one Soveraign , nor under the same that they were subject to before ; and a Soveraign cannot be before the aggregation of the Subjects whereof he is head , they must first be a Common-wealth before they can belong to it . Again it cannot be founded upon the Right of fatherhood : for in that scattering , such a Right could not be uninterruptedly preserved : And then Noah should also have been the Universal Magistrate , which he could not be in these multiplied secessions . And further if it be refounded on the Right of fatherhood ; either every Company had one Common Father over all , or every Father made a Common-wealth of his oun Children : The Latter cannot be said , for that would multiply Common-wealts in infinitum : Neither can the first be said , for if they had one Common Father , either this behoved to be the Natural Father of all the Company , which none can think was so happily ordered by Babels confusion : Or else the eldest in age , and so he might be incapable for Government , and the Law of Nature does not direct that the Government should alwise be astricted to the eldest of the Community : Or else finally he behoved to be their Political Father , by consent . For before this consent , they were uningaged as to common order of Government ; none of the Community having any legal Claim to Soveraignity more than the rest . When therfore they were forced to conclude upon Association for their Mutual Preservation , they must be thought to act rationally , and not to make their condition worse but rather better by that conclusion , and , if they found it worse , to resume their radical Right which they had conferred upon men , subject to Law not to Tyrannize over them : And in this case , certainly they had the power of choosing what Kind of Government suited most to their advantage , and would best preserve their Liberties , and how far this should be extended , and who should be assumed into this Combination ; still with a reservation of the Priviledge to their oun safety , if their Associates should not do their duty : And so they might also reserve to themselves a Liberty , to alter the forme when they found it productive of more prejudice than advantage , and never to leave their condition remedieless ; And to pitch upon this way of succession and not another , the way of free election of every successor , or of definite election limited to one line , or to the nearest in line , And e contra with a reserve still of their primeve Priviledges , to secure themselves from the inconveniences of that determination , or to change it ; And to make choise of such a family & line and not another , and whether the eldest alwise of that family or the fittest is to be chosen : And however it be , yet still by the peoples consent : And in all this to have respect to some good , great , & Necessary Ends , which if they should be disappointed of , and find these means useless or destructive to , they were to be loosed from their obligation to use or to oune them . See Ius populi vindicat . ch . 5. pag. 80. &c. 2. If we consider how Nature determines the peoples Interest in the constitution of Governours : whence comes it that this man and not that man , this race & family and not that , is invested with that Title ? It will be found there is no Title on earth now to the Crowns to families , to persons , but the peoples suffrage : for the Institution of Magistracy in general does , not make Iames Stewart a King , no more than Iohn Chamberlain : Neither do qualifications make one , otherwise there might be many better than is this day extant , for there are many men better qualified : And there is no Prophetical or immediate Callings to Kingdoms now : And as for Conquest without consent , and having no more for a Title , it is no better than Royal Latrocinie . It is certain God would not Command us to obey Kings , and leave us in the Dark that we should not know him that hath a reall call to 〈◊〉 : And if he have not the peoples Call , where shall we find another ? It remains therefore they must have it from the people , who have it to give Radically & virtually ; having a power to preserve themselves , and to put it in the hands of one or more Rulers , that they may preserve themselves by them . All men are born alike as to Civil power ( no man being born with a Croun on his head ) and yet men united in Society may give it to this man & not to that man , therefore they must have it virtually ; for they can not give what they have not . And as Cities have power to choose their Magistrats , so many Cities have power to creat an Universal Ruler over them all . The people also have power to Limit the Magistrats power , with conditions ; so that the present Ruler shall not have so much prerogative as his predecessor , as Royalists cannot deny , therefore they must have given that power which they can Limit See Lex Rex Quest. 4. pag. 10. &c. Secondly the Scripture also gives Light in this particular . 1. In giving directions & Rules about their Orderly calling their Governours ; Impowering them , to take wise men , & understanding , & known among their tribes , to be made Rulers D●ut . 1. 13. To make Judges & Officers in all their gates Deut. 16. 18. To set one among their brethren King over them and not a stranger Deut. 17. 15. To what purpose are these Rules given them , if they had no interest to choose their Magistrats ? Would God command them to set a King over them , if they had not power to do it ? And to set such a man over them and not such an one , if they had no influence in making one at all ? And accordingly that wise Statist sayes very well 2 Sam. 16. 18. Hushai to A●salem , Nay , but whom the Lard & this people and all the men of Israel choose , his will I be , and with him will I abide . Which will also hold in the Negative , whom the Lord & the people and all the men of the Kingdom do not choose , his we will not be , nor with him will we abide . 2. The Scripture expressly attributeth the making of Kings to the people . All the people of Iuda took Azariah and made him King , instead of his Father Amaziah , whom they had executed 2 King. 14. 21. They came with a perfect heart to make David King in Hebron 1 Chron. 12. 38. So they made Ioash King 2 Chron. 23. 11. 3. Even these that were particularly designed of God & chosen to be Rulers , yet were not formally invested with power , before the people conferred it upon them . Gideon was called of God to it , but was not Judge till the people said , Rule thow over us , both thow & thy Son , giving him an hereditary right for his Children , Iudg. 8. 12. Saal was appointed to be King , and therefore Samuel honoured him , because he was marked out of God to be King , 1 Sam. 9. 24. and anointed him with oyl 1 Sam. 10. 1. after which he was gifted & qualified for Government , God gave him another heart vers . 9. yet all this did not make him King , till the people met for his inauguration vers . 17. &c. and Crowned him & made him King in Gilgal 1 Sam. 11. ult . David was anointed by Samuel , and yet was a persecuted fugitive for several years , and never acknowledged formally King , till the men of Iudah came & anointed him 2 Sam. 2. 4. for if he had been King before , then there were two Kings in Israel at one time , and David failed of his Royal duty in not punishing the Murderer Saul ; whereas himself sayes , he would not touch the Lords 〈◊〉 . Therefore the people made all these Kings , and that by choise & consent , without which they were no Kings . Hence I argue , If the consent & choise of the people be so essentially necessary to the making of Kings ; then they who set up themselves against the consent of the body of the Land , and without the choise of any , must be Usurpers , not to be acknowledged for Lawful Kings : But the former is true as is proven above : Ergo — Now Plain it is that this Duke set up himself against the consent of the body , being excluded from the Government by the Representatives of England , and generally hated of all ; who disdaining to wait upon the formall choise of any , but after he had paved his passage to the Throne upon his Brothers blood , did usurpe the Title without all Law. 5. The second thing necessary for the Legal Constitution of a King by the people , is their Compact with him : which must either be Express or Tacite , Explicite or Implicite . Two things are here to be proven , that will furnish an Argument for disouning both the Brothers . First , That there must be a Conditionall reciprocally obliging Covenant between the Soveraign and the Subjects , without which there is no such relation to be ouned . Secondly That when this compact is broken in all or its chiefest conditions by the Soveraign , the peoples obligation ceases . The first . I shall set doun , in the words of a famous Author , our Renouned Country man Buchanan in his Dialogue de Iure Regni apud Scotos . Mutua igitur Regi cum Civibus est pactio &c. There is then ( or there ought to be ) a Mutual compact between the King and his subjects &c. That this is indispensibly necessary & essential to make up the Relation of Soveraign & Subjects , may be proved both from the Light of Nature , & Revelation . First it may appear from the Light of Natural reason . 1. From the Rise of Government , and the Interest people have in erecting it by consent & choise ( at is shewed above ) If a King cannot be with out the peoples making , then all the power he hath must either be by compact or gift : If by compact , then we have what we proposed : And if by gift , then if abused they may recall it or if they cannot recover it , yet they may & ought to hold their hand , and give him no more that they may retain , that is no more honour or respect , which is in the honourer before the honoured get it . Can it be imagined , that a people acting rationally would give a power absolutely without restrictions to destroy all their oun rights ? Could they suppose this boundless & Lawless Creature , left at Liberty to Tyrannize , would be a fit mean to procure the the ends of Government ? for this were to set up a rampant Tyrant to rule as he listeth , which would make their condition a great deal worse then if they had no Ruler at all , for then they might have more Liberty to see to their safety . See Ius populi ch . 6. pag. 96. 97. 2. This will be clear from the nature of that Authority , which only a Soveraign can have over his Subjects ; which whatever be the Nature of it , it cannot be absolute , that is against Scripture , Nature , & Common sense , as shall be proven at more length . That is to set up a Tyrant , one who is free from all conditions , a roaring Lyon & a ranging Bear to destroy all if he pleases . It must be granted by all , that the Soveraign Authority is only fiduciarie , entrusted by God & the people with a great Charge : A great Pledge is impauned & committed to the Care & Custody of the Magistrate , which he must take special care of , and not abuse ; or waste , or alienate or sell ( for in that case Royalists themselves grant he may be deposed ) He is by Office a Patron of the Subjects Liberties , and Keeper of the Law both of God & Man , the Keeper of both Tables . Sure he hath no power over the Lawes of God but a Ministerial power , he may not stop & disable them as he pleases ; Of the same nature is it , over all other Parts of his Charge . He is rather a Tutor , than an Inheritor & proprietor of the Common-wealth , and may not do with his pupils interest what he pleases . In a word the Nature & whole significancy of his power lyes in this , that he is the Nations publick Servant , both Objectively in that he is only for the good of the people , and Representatively in that the people hath impauned in his hand all their power to do Royal Service . The Scripture eaches this , in giving him the Titles of Service , as Watchman &c. allowing him Royal wages for his Royal work Rom. 13. he is Gods Minister attending continually on this thing , There is his work , for this cause pay yow tribute also , There is his wages & maintinance . He is called so in that transaction with Rehoboam ; The old men advised him to be a Servant unto the People , then they should be his Servants 1 King. 12. 7. There was a conditional bargain proposed : As to be a Servant , or Tutor , or Guardian upon Trust , always implies Conditions & Acconntableness to them that entrust them . 3. It must needs be so otherwise great absurdities would follow . Here would be a voluntary contracted Relation , obliging as to relative duties , to a man that ouwed none correlative to us , and yet one whom we set over us . It were strange , if there were no Condition here ; and no other voluntarly suscepted Relations can be without this , as between Man & Wife , Master & Servant &c. This would give him the disposal of us & Ours , as if both we and what we have were his oun , as a mans goods are , against which he does not sin whatever he do with them . So this would make a King that could not sin against us ; being no ways obliged to us , for he can no otherwise be obliged to us but upon Covenant conditions ; he may be obliged & bound in duty to God otherwise , but he cannot be bound to us otherwise : And if he be not bound then he may do what he will , he can do no wrong to us to whom he is no wayes bound . This also is point blank against the Law of God , which is the Second way to prove it , by the Light of Revelation or Scripture . 1. In thevery directions about making & seting up of Kings , the Lord shewes what conditions shall be required of them Deut. 17. 15. &c. and in all directions for obeying them , the qualifications they should have are rehearsed as Rom. 13. 3 , 4. Therefore none are to be set up but on these conditions , and none are to be obeyed but such as have these qualifications . 2. In His promises of the succession of Kings , He secures their continuation only Conditionally , to establish the Kingdom if they be constant to do His Commandments & Judgements 1 Chron. 28. 7. There shall not fail a man to sit upon the Trone yet so that they take heed to their way to walk in Gods Law , as David did 2 Chron. 6. 16. Now He was not otherwise to perform these promises , but by the action & suffrage of the people seting him up , ( which He had appointed to be the way of calling Kings to Thrones ) if therefore the Lords promise be conditional , the peoples actions also behoved to be suspended upon the same conditions . 3. We have many express Covenants , between Rulers & Subjects in Scripture . Iephthah was fetcht from the Land of Tob , and made the head of the Gileadites by an explicite mutual stipulation , wherein the Lord was invocated as a Witness , Iudg. 11. 6 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11. So all the Elders of Israel came to make David King , and King David made a League with them in Hebron before the Lord , and then they anointed him over Israel 2 Sam. 5. 3. he made there a Covenant with them before the Lord 1 Chron. 11 , 3. He was no King before this Covenant , and so it was a Pactional Oath between him & the Kingdom , upon termes according to the Law Deut. 17. he was only a King in fieri ; one who was to be King , but now actually inaugurate a Covenanted King upon termes that satisfied them . It s true they came to recognosce his Right from the Lord ; But so did they recognosce Rehoboams Right , and came to Shechem to make him King 1 King. 12. 1. and yet when he would not enter in Covenant terms with them , to satisfie their just demands , the people answered the King , saying , what portion have we in David , neither have we inheritance in the Son of Iesse , to your tents O Israel vers . 16. They refused to acknowledge such an Usurper , and we find no Prophets ever condemning them for it . So when Iehoash or Ioash was Crowned , Iehojada made a Covenant between the Lord and the King & the people , that they should be the Lords people , between the King also and the people 2 King. 11. 17. 2 Chron. 23. 11 , 16. From all these Reasons & Scriptures , It is clear there must be a Mutual Compact . between the Subjects and every Soveraign they oune subjection to , which if he refuse , and usurp the Sword , they are under an Anterior obligation to substract their Allegiance , and to make use of their Sword , if they be in capacity , to pull it out of his hands and use it against him . And of this we are put in mind by the Motto of our old Coronation pieces , which have these Words about the Sword. pro me , si mereor in me , that is , for me but if I deserve against me : And surely to him that hath it now in his hands , it may be said , tu meruisti & adhuc meres . We see then , the Allegiance that this Usurper alledges is his due , wants a bottom , to wit a compact with the people . Whence I argue , If there must of necessity be a compact between the King & the people when , he is advanced to the Government ; then he that advances himself , without & against this compact , is an Usurper not to be ouned : But the former is true : Ergo he that advances himself without & against this compact , is an Usurper not to be ouned . And who more Notoriously deserving such a signature , than Iames the 7 / 2 who hath made horns of his oun strength , or the Popes Biills , to push his Brother out and himself in to the Throne , upon no termes at all , or any security for Religion & Liberty . One Objection is to be removed here : Can the Customs of the Iewes be binding to all Nations ? The Kings of Iudah made such Covenants , shall therefore all Kings do so ? Ans. why not this Custom , as well as Crowing , which they used likewise ? These Rules are not Typical or Cermonial , nor only so Iudicial as to be peculiarly Iudaical , but are matters of moral equity , bearing a standing reason founded upon that Law Deut. 17. 15. &c. Limiting the Prince to stand to conditions . If we cast at Divine Laws for Rules of Government , where wil we find better Laws ? It is recorded of the first of the British Kings who was Christian , that writing to Eleutherius Bishop of Rome ( before Antichrist took that seat ) for the Roman Laws , he received this Answer ; By Divine Clemency ye have received the Law & faith of Christ , yow have the Old & New Testaments , out of them in Gods Name by Counsel of your State take Laws , & Govern your Kingdom . And of another , that he began his Laws thus , God speake all these words &c. And so repeated the Laws of God. The Second thing I undertook to prove , is that Assertion of Buchanan ubi supra , de Iure Regni . Qui prior a Conventis recidit &c. There being a paction between the King & Subjects , he who first recedes from what is Covenanted , and doth Counteract what he hath Covenanted , he looses the contract ; and the bond being loosed which did hold fast the King with the people , whatever right did belong to him by virtue of that compact , he looses it , and the people are as free as before the stipulation . Which is also asserted by the Author of Ius populi ch . 6. pag. 112. It is no less clear , that when the Soveraign doth not performe the principal main & most necessary conditions , condescended & aggreed upon , de jure he falleth from his Soveraignity : and pag. 117. when the Prince doth violate his compact , as to all its conditions , or as to its chief main & most necessary condition , the subjects are de jure free from subjection to him , and at Liberty to make choise of another . This is so clear that it needs no labour to prove it , that upon this head we were loosed from all Allegiance ro the former Tyrant , who was admitted upon terms of an explicite Covenant , the conditions whereof he did as explicitely break . There are two cases wherein Subjects are loosed from Covenanted Allegiance to their Princes . 1. When the Prince remitts the obligation of the Subjects , and refuses Allegiance upon that basis ; then he can no more demand it by virtue of that compact . He that remitts & will not have that Allegiance , that the Subjects Covenanted upon such & such conditions to him , these Subjects should not give it that they so Covenanted , for they should not prostitute it to a Refuser & Remitter : But Charles the Second remitted and would not have that Allegiance , which we Covenanted upon such & such conditions viz. upon the terms of the Covenant , which he cassed , & annulled , and made Criminal to oune : Ergo to him we should not have given it , which we so Covenanted . 2. When the Prince did enter into a Mutual Covenant with the people upon Mutual conditions , and does not only cease to performe the conditions , but simply denies all obligation to do it , and makes it a quarrel to insinuate so much , yea persecutes all who dare assert the obligation of that Covenant ; and yet demands Allegiance , not upon the obligation of that Covenant which he hath remitted , but absolutely upon the grounds of his prerogative . In this case it will be evident also , the subjects are not bound either to oune their formerly Covenanted Allegiance to him , Or that which he demands on other grounds . Grotius de Iure belli is clear as to this Lib. 1. Cap. 4. Num. 12. Si ex Clausula posita in ipsa delatione Imperii , ut si Rex hoc aut hoc faciet subditi omni obedientiae vinculo solvuntur , tunc quoque Rex in privatam personam recidit . If there be such a Clause or condition in the very devolution of the Government upon a Prince , as if he do so & so the subjects shall be loosed from all bonds of obedience , then when he does so he becomes a meer private person . Grotius there supposes the power is transferred upon a resolutive condition , that is if he transgress the condition the power shall be resolved into its first fountain : much more if it be transferred expressly also upon a suspensive condition , that he shall continue to maintain the ends of the Covenant , defend Religion & the Liberties of the Subjects , in the defence whereof we shall oune Allegiance to him , otherwise not in that case if he do not maintain these ends , plain it is our obligation ceases ; for how can it stand upon a conditional obligation , when his performance of the condition sists ? But whatever be the conditions Mutual , it flowes Natively from the Nature of a Mutual compact , that qui non praestat officium promissum cadit beneficio hac lege dato , he who doth not perform the conditions aggreed upon hath no right to the benefite granted upon condition of performance of these conditions ; especially if he performe not , or violate these conditions upon supposition whereof he would not have gotten the benefite : It were very absurd to say , in a Mutual conditional compact one party shall still be bound to perform his conditions , though the other perform none but break all . Were it the act of rational Creatures to set up a Soveraign , upon conditions he shall not play the Tyrant , and yet be bound to him thô he Tyrannize never so much ? We have the Nature of Mutual compacts in the Spies Covenant with Rahab Iosh. 2. 20. If thow utter this our business , then we will be quite of thine Oath , which thow hast made us to swear : if she should break condition , then the obligation of the Oath on their part should cease . But next all the stress will ly in proving that the Covenant , on such & such conditions between a Prince & Subjects , doth equally & mutually oblige both to each other : for if it equally oblige both , then both are equally disengaged from other by the breach on either side , and either of them may have a just claim in Law against the other for breach of the conditions . But Royalists & Court-slaves alledge , that such a Covenant obliges the King to God ; but not to the people at all ; so that he is no more accountable to them , than if he had made none at all . But the contrare is evident : For [ 1 ] If the compact be Mutual , and if it be infringed on one side , it must be so in the other also ; for in contracts , the parties are considered as equalls , whatever inequality there may be betwixt them otherwise : I speak of contracts among men . [ 2 ] If it be not so , there is no Covenant made with the people at all : And so David did no more Covenant with Israel . than with the Chaldeans : for to all with whom the Covenant is made it obliges to them . Otherwise it must be said , he only made the Covenant with God , contrary to the Text ; for he made it only before the Lord as a Witness , not with Him as a party . Ioashs Covenant with the Lord is expresly distinguished from that with the people . [ 3 ] If it be not so , it were altogether non-sense to say , there were any Covenant made with the King , on the other hand : for he is supposed to be made King on such & such terms , and yet by this after he is made King he is no more obliged unto them , than if there had been no compact with him at all . [ 4 ] If he be bound as King , and not only as a man or Christian , then he is bound with respect to the people ; for with respect to them he is only King : But he is bound as King , and not only as a man or Christian , because it is only with him as King that the people Covenant , and he must transact with them under the same consideration . Next , that which he is obliged to , is the specifical act of a King , to defend Religion & Liberty , & Rule in Righteousness ; And therefore his Covenant binds him as King. Again , if he be not bound as King , then as a King he is under no obligation of Law or Oath , which is to make him a Lawless Tyrant , yea none of Gods subjects . It would also suppose that the King as King could not sin against the people at all , but only against God : for as King he could be under no obligation of duty to the people , and where there is no obligation there is no sin ; by this he would be set above all obligations to love his neighbour as himself , for he is above all his neighbours , and all mankind , and only less than God ; and so by this doctrine he is loosed from all duties of the Second Table , or at least he is not so much obliged to them as others . But against this it is Objected : both Prince & people are obliged to performe their part to each other , and both are obliged to God , but both are not accountable to each other ; there is not mutual power in the parties to compell one another to performe the promised duty ; the King hath it indeed over the people , but not the people over the King , and there is no indifferent Judge Superior to both to compell both , but God. Ans. 1. What if all this should be granted ? yet it doth not infringe the proposition : what if the people have not power to compell him ? yet Iure he may fall from his Soveraignity , though de facto he is not deposed : he loses his right to our part , when he breaks his part . 2. There is no need of a Superior Arbiter : for as in contracting they are considered as equal , so the party keeping the contract is Superior to the other breaking it : 3. There may be Mutual Coactive Power , where there is no Mutual relation of Superiority & Inferiority : yea in some cases Inferiours may have a Coactive Power by Law , to compell their Superiours failing in their duty to them ; As a Son wronged by his Father may compel him to reparation by Law ; And independent Kingdoms , nothing inferior to each other , being in Covenant together , the wronged may have a Coactive power to force the other to duty , without any Superior Arbiter . 4. The bond of suretyship brings a man under the obligation to be accountable to the Creditor , though the surety were never so high and the Creditor never so low : Solomon sayes in General without exception of Kings , yea including them because he was a King that spake it Prov. 6. 1 , 2. My son if thow be Surety for thy friend — thow art snared with the words of thy Mouth . Now a Kings power is but fiduciary ; And therefore he cannot be unaccountable for the power concredited to him . And if the Generation had minded this , our Stewarts should have been called to an account for their Stewardship ere now . Hence I argue , If a Covenanted Prince , breaking all the Conditions of his compact , doth forfeit his right to the Subjects Allegiance , then they are no more to oune him as their Soveraign : But the former is proved , that a Covenanted Prince breaking all the conditions of his compact doth forfeit his right to the Subjects Allegiance : Ergo — And Consequently when Charles the Second , expressly bound by Covenant to defend & promote the Convenanted Reformation & Liberties of the Kingdom , to whom only we were bound in the terms of his defending & promoting the same , did violently & villainously violate & vilify these conditions , we were no more bound to them . Somewhat possibly may be Objected here . 1. If this be the sense of the Covenant , then it would seem that we were not bound to oune the King , but only when & while he were actually promoving & carrying on the ends of the Covenant . Ans. It does not follow , but that we are obliged to preserve his Person & Authority in these necessary intervalls , when he is called to see to himself as a man ; for we must preserve him as a mean , because of his aptitude & designation for such an End , albeit not alwayes formally prosecuting it : we do not say , that we are never to oune him , but when actually exercised in prosecuting these ends : but we say , we are never to oune him , when he is Tyrannically & Treacherously abusing his Authority for destroying & overturning these ends , and violating all the conditions of his compact . It may be Obj. 2. Saul was a Tyrant , and a breaker of his Royal Covenant , and persecuter of the Godly , and Murderer of the Priests of the Lord , usurper upon the Priests Office , and many other wayes guilty of breaking all conditions : And yet David and all Israel ouned him as the Anointed of the Lord. Ans. 1. Saul was indeed a Tyrant , rejected of God , and to be ejected out of his Kingdom in His oun time & way , which David a Prophet knowing would not anticipate . But he was far short , and a meer Bungler in acts of Tyranny in comparison of our Grassators : he broke his Royal Covenant in very gross particular acts , but did not cass & rescind the whole of it , did not burn it , did not make it Criminal to oune its obligation , nor did he so much as profess a breach of it , nor arrogate an Absolute prerogative , nor attempt arbitrary Government , nor to evert the fundamental Laws and overturn the Religion of Israel , & bring in Idolatry , as Ours have done : He was a Persecuter of David upon some private quarrels , not of all the Godly upon the account of their Covenanted Religion : He Murdered 85 Priests of the Lord , in a transport of fury , because of their kindness to David ; but he did not make Laws adjudging all the Ministers of the Lord to death , who should be found most faithful in their duty to God & His Church , as Ours have done against all Field Preachers : He Usurped upon the Priests Office , in one elicit act of Sacrificing ; but he did not usurp a Supremacy over them , and annex it as an inherent right of his Crown . 2. He was indeed such a Tyrant , as deserved to have been dethroned & brought to condign punishment , upon the same accounts that Amaziah & Uzziah were deposed for afterwards : And in this the people failed in their duty , and for it they were plagued remarkably ; shall their Omission be an Argument to us ? 3. As the question was never put to the people , whether they ouned his Authority as Lawful or not ? So we do not read , either of their Universal ouning him , or their positive disouning him : However , That 's no good Argument , which is drawen a non facto ad faciendum ; because they did it not , therefore it must not be done . 4. They ouned him ; but how ? as the Minister of God , not to be resisted or revolted from under pain of damnation ? ( as all Lawful Magistrats ought to be ouned Rom. 13. 2 , 4. ) This I deny : for David & his six hundred men resisted him resolutely ; And though the body of the Nation did long Lazily lye & couch as Asses under his burden , yet at length , weary of his Tyranny , many revolted from under him , and adjoined themselves to David at Ziklag , while he kept himself close because of Saul the Son of Kish 1 Chron. 12. 1. who are commended by the Spirit of God for their valour vers . 2. &c. and many out of Manasseh fell to him , when he came with the Philistims against Saul to battel vers . 19. This was a practical disouning of the Tyrant , before the Lord deposed him . 5. David did indeed pay him & his Character some deference , as having been the Anointed of the Lord ; yet perhaps his honouring him with that title , the Lords anointed 1 Sam. 24. 1 Sam. 26. and calling him so often his Lord the King cannot be altogether Justified , no more than his using that same language to Achish King of Gath. 1 Sam. 29. 8. I shew before how titles might be allowed : but this so circumstantiate , does not seem so consistent with his imprecatory prayer , for the Lords avenging him on him . 1 Sam. 24. 12. and many other imprecations against him in his Psalms ; in some of which he calls the same man , whom here he stiles the Lords anointed , a Dog ; as Saul & his Complices are called Psal. 95. 6 , 14. and the evil violent & wicked man Psal 140. 1 , 4. and the vilest of men Psal. 12. ult . However it be , there can be no Argument from hence , to oune the Authority of Tyrants & Usurpers . 6. Though this Necessary conditional compact , which must alwayes be in the constitution of Lawfu● Rulers , be not alwayes express & explicite , so that a written Authentick Copy of it cannot be always produced ; yet it is alwise to be understood implicitely at least transacted , in the Rulers admission to the Government , wherein the Law of God must regulate both parties ; and when he is made Ruler , it must natively be understood that it is upon terms to be a Father , feeder , & Protector , and not a Tyrant , Murderer , & Destroyer . All Princes are so far pactional , that they are obliged , by the high & absolute Soveraign from whom they derive their Authority , to reign for the Peace & profit of the people : this is fixed unalterably by the Laws of the Supreme Legislator , and solemnly engaged unto at the Coronation : and whosoever declines or destroyes this fundamental condition , he degrades & deposes himself . It is also not only the Universal practice , but necessary for the Constitution & Conservation of all Common-wealths , to have fundamental Laws & Provisions about Government , both for the upholding & transmitting & transfering it as occasion calls , and preventing & punishing violations thereof , that there be no invasion or intrusion upon the Government , and if there be any entrance upon it not according to the Constitution , that it be illegitimated , and the Nations Liberties always secured . This doeth infer & regulate a conditional compact with all that are advanced to the Government , albeit it should not be expressed . For it is undenyable that in the erection of all Governours , the grand Interests of the Community must be seen to by Legal Securities for Religion & Liberty , which is the end & use of fundamental Laws . Now how these have been unhinged & infringed , by the introduction & present establishment by Law of that Monster of the prerogative , enacted in Parliament Anno 1661. the Apologetick Relation doth abundantly demonstrate , Sect. 10. Concerning the Kings Civil Supremacy , enhancing all the Absoluteness that ever the Great Turk could arrogate , and yet far short of what hath been Usurped since , and impudently proclaimed to the world , especially by him who now domineers , in his Challenges of Soveraign Authority , prerogative Royal , & Absolute Power , which all are to obey without reserve , whereby the whole basis of our Constitution , and Bulwark of our Religion , Laws , & Liberties , is enervated , and we have security of no Law but the Kings lust . Hence I argue , Those Princes , that , contrary to their virtual compact ( at least ) at their coming to the Crown , have overturned all fundamental Laws , cannot be ouned : But our Princes have contrary to their virtual compact ( at least ) at their coming to the Crown overturned all fundamental Laws : Ergo they cannot be ouned . The Major is plain : for they that overturn fundamental Laws are no Magistrats ; thereby all the ends of Government being subverted , and the subverter cannot be ouned as a Father or friend , but an open enemy to the Common-wealth , nor looked upon as Magistrats doing their duty , but as Tyrants seeking themselves with the destruction of the Common-wealth . : And in this case the compact , the ground of the Constitution , being violated , they fall from their right , and the people are Liberated from their obligation , and they being no Magistrats the people are no subjects , for the relation is mutual , and so is the obligation Ius populi chap. 9. pag. 183. The Minor is manifest , both from the matter of fact , and the Mischiefs framed into Laws , by the Soveraign Authority , Prerogative Royal , & Absolute Power foresaid : whereby what remains of our fundamental Constitutions , either in Religious or Civil Settlements , unsubverted as yet , may be subverted when this Absolute Monarch pleases . Which Absolute Authority we cannot in conscience oune , for these Reasons , taken both from Reason & Scripture . First it s against Reason . 1. A power contrare to Nature cannot be ouned : Absolute power is such : for that which takes away , and makes the people to give away , their Natural power of preserving their lives & Liberties , and sets a man above all rule & Law , is contrare to Nature ; such is Absolute power , making people resign that which is not in their power to resign , an absolute power to destroy & Tyrannize . 2. A power contrare to the first rise of its Constitution cannot be ouned : Absolute power is such : for , The first rise of the Constitution is a peoples seting a Soveraign over them , giving him Authority to administer justice over them ; But it were against this , to set one over them with a power to rage at randome , and rule as he lists : It s proven before , a King hath no power but what the people gave him , but they never gave , never could give an absolute power to destroy themselves . 3. That power which is against the ends of Government cannot be ouned : Absolute power is such : for , that which will make a peoples condition worse then before the Constitution , and that mean which they intended for a blessing to turn a plague & scourage to them , and all the subjects to be formal slaves at the Princes devotion , must needs be contrare to the ends of Government : But Absolute power is such : for , against the exorbitance thereof no means would be left to prevent its obstructing all the fountains of Justice , and commanding Laws & Lawyers to speak , not justice righteousness & reason , but the lust & pleasure of one man , and turning all into Anarchy & confusion : Certainly it could never be the intention either of the work or workers , at the Constitution of Government , to set up a power to enslave the people , to be a Curse to them ; but their ends was to get comfort , safety , & Liberty , under the shadow of Government . 4. That power which invalidates , and is inconsistent with the Kings compact with the people , cannot be ouned : Absolute Power is such : for , the tenor of that is alwise to secure Laws & Liberties , to rule according to Law ; but to be Absolute invalidates & is inconsistent with that : That which were an engagment into Contradictories cannot consist with that compact ; but to engage to be absolute , and yet to rule by Law , is an engagment into Contradictories , which no people could admit for a security : It s inconsistent with this compact , to give the King Absolute Power to overturn Religion & Liberty , and to assume it which was never given , were to invalidate this compact , and to make himself no King ; but to restore unto the people the power they conferred upon him , for the defence of Religion & Liberty . 5 ▪ That power which is not from God , nor of God , cannot be ouned : But Absolute Power is not of God ; because it is a power to Tyrannize & Sin , which if it were of God He should be the Author of Sin ; for if the Moral Power be of God , so must the acts be ; but the acts of Absolute Power , being Lawless , cannot be from God : Ergo neither the Moral Power to commit these acts . 6. That Ruler who cannot be Gods Minister for the peoples good cannot be ouned : ( for that is the formal reason of our consfiencious subjection to Rulers Rom. 13. 4 , 5. ) But Absolute Soveraigns are such as cannot be Gods Ministers for the peoples good ; for if they be Gods Ministers for good , they must administer justice , preserve peace , rule by Law , take directions from their Master ; and if so , they cannot be absolute . 7. A Tyrant in actu signato & exercito cannot be ouned : But an Absolute Prince is such ; being a power that may play the Tyrant if he pleases , and jure as King : And so if Kings be actu primo Tyrants , then people are actu primo Slaves ; and so Royal Power cannot be a blessing to them : yea a Lawless breaker of all bonds , promises , & Oaths , cannot be ouned as Lawful Power : But Absolute Power is such : for , it cannot be limited by these Obligations , at least people cannot have any seurity by them . 8. A Lawless Power is not to be ouned : An Absolute Power is a Lawless power : Ergo not to be ouned . The Major is plain . Cicero sayes Lib. 2. de officio Eadem constituendarum Legum causa fuit , quae Regum The reason of making Lawes was the same , as of the creation of Kings . And Buchanan de jure Regni very excellently ; when the lust of Kings was in stead of Laws , and being vested with an infinite & immoderate power , they did not contain themselves within bounds — the insolency of Kings made Laws to be desired ; for this cause Laws were made by the people , and Kings constrained to make use , not of their Licencious wills in judgment , but of that right & priviledge which the people had conferred upon them , being taught by many experiences , that it was better that their Liberty should be concredited to Laws , than to Kings ; better to have the Law which is a dumb King , than a King who is not a speaking Law. If then Laws be necessary for the making of Kings , and more necessary than Kings , And the same cause requirs both , then a King without Laws is not to be ouned . Rex must be Lex loquens ; a King must be a speaking & living Law , reducing the Law to practice : So much then as a King hath of Law , so much he hath of a King ; and he who hath nothing of the Law , hath nothing of a King. Magna Charta of England saith , the King can do nothing but by Law , and no obedience is due to him but by Law. Buchanan rehearses the words of the most famous Emperours , Theodosius & Valentinianus to this effect , Digna vox Majestate regnantis , legibus se alligatum Principem fateri ; & revero Imperio majus ost , submittere legibus Principatum . It is , say they , a word worthy of the Majestie of a King , to confess he is a tyed Prince to the Laws , and indeed it is more to submit a Principality to the Laws , than to enjoy an Empire . But now that an absolute power must be a Lawless power , is also evident ; for that 's a Lawless power that makes all Laws void , needless & useless : but such is absolute power : for , it cannot be confined to the observance of Laws . 9. That power which is destructive to the peoples Liberties cannot be ouned : Absolute power is such : for , such a Licencious freedom as is absolute , cannot consist with the peoples Liberties ; for these he may infringe when he pleases : Now these , in their oun Nature , and in all respects , being preferable to the Kings prerogative , And it being no prerogative which is not consistent with , yea in its oun nature adapted to , the precious Interests of Religion & Liberty , when the Kings Absolute Authority is stated in contradictory terms to these , we cannot oune that Authority : for now he hath another Authority than could be given him for the preservation of these Interests , in the preservation whereof he can only have an Authority to be ouned , seeing he claimes a power to destroy them if he please . 10. If we should oune Absolute Authority ; then we should oune a Royal prerogative in the King to make & dispense with Laws : Now that cannot be ouned : for , it would infer that the King had a Masterly Dominion over his subjects , to make Lawes , & inflict Penalties without their consent . And plain it is , they that make Kings must have a Coordinate power to make Laws also ; but the people in their Representatives make Kings , as is proven . Next a prerogative to dispense with Laws , except such Laws as are in their oun nature dispensable , without prejudice to any Law of God or Liberties of men , cannot be ouned : for any power to dispense with Reason & Law , not grounded on any other reason but meer will & absolute pleasure , is a brutish power . It cannot be jus Coronae , a right annexed to the Crown , to do so : for a King as a King illud tantum potest quod jure potest can do nothing but what he may do by Law. Nay this is not only a Brutish power , but a Blasphemous power , making him a Kind of God on earth illimited , that can do what he pleases : And to dispute it further , were to dispute whether God hath made all under him slaves by their oun consent ; Or whether he may encroach on the prerogative of God , or not . By this prerogative , he arrogates a power to dispense with the Laws of God also , in pardoning Murtherers &c. which no man hath power to do : the Law of God being so peremptorly indispensable Gen. 9. 6. whoso sheddeth mans blood by man shall his blood be shed . Numb . 35. 30. 31. Who so killeth any person , the murderer shall he put to death — more over ye shall take no satisfaction for the life of a murderer , but he shall be surely put to death . These pardons are acts of blood to the Community . If the Judgment be Gods , as it is Deut. 1. 17. and not for man but for the Lord 2 Chron. 19. 6. then no King can arrogate a power to dispense with it , no more then an inferior Judge can dispense with the Kings Laws : for the King is but a Minister , bearing the Sword not in vain , but as a revenger to execute wrath upon them that do evil Rom. 13. 4. They are but bastard Kings who give out sentances out of their oun mouth , contrary to Gods mind . And if he may do acts of grace by Prerogative above Law , then may he also do acts of Justice ( so pretended ) by the same Prerogative ; and so may murder Innocents , as well as pardon Murderers , he may condemn the just as well as justify the wicked , both which are alike abomination to the Lord Pro. 17. 15. This power cannot be ouned in any man. 11. To oune Absolute power , were to recognosce the King as the proper & sole Interpreter of the Law. This Buchanan shews to be very absurd : Cum regi Legum interpretationem &c. when yow grant the interpretation of Laws to a King ; yow give him such a Licence , that the Law should not speak what the Lawgiver meaneth but what is for the Interpreters Interest ; so that he may turn it to all actions , as a Lesbian rule , for his oun advantage ; And so what he pleases the Laws shall speak , and what he will not it shall not speak . Now the Kings absolute pleasure , can no more be the sense of the Law , than it can be the Law it self : He is King by Law , but he is not King of Law : No mortal can make a sense to a Law , contrare to the Law ; for it involves a Contradiction ; the true meaning is only the Law. This also would take away the use of all Laws ; for they could not declare what were just & unjust , but as the King pleased ; their genuine sense could not be the rule . 12. If we oune the Law to be above the King , then we cannot oune the King to be absolute : But the former is true : For , he must be under it several wayes : ( 1 ) under its Directive power ; that will not be denyed . ( 2 ) under its Constitutive power : he is not a King by Nature , but by Constitution & Law : therefore the Law is above the King ; because it s only from the Law that there is a King , and that such a man and not another is King , and that the King must be so & so qualified , and they that made him a King may also unmake him by the same Law. ( 3 ) under its Limiting & Restrictive power , as a man he cannot be absolute , nor as a King by Law. ( 4 ) under its Coactive power . A Law maker , said King Iames the 6. should not be a Law breaker : but if he turn an overturner of the fundamental Laws , that Law or Covenant that made him King , doth oblige to unmake him . Whatever power he hath it is only a borrowed , fiduciary power , as the Nations Publick servant : and that which was lent him in Pledge or paun , may be reclaimed , when abused by him . Especially if he turn parricide , Kill his brother , murder his nobles , burn Cities , then he may & ought to be punished by Law. Otherwise , God should have provided better for the safety of the part , than of the whole , though that part be but a mean for the safety of the whole : for if he turn Tyrant in his absoluteness , the people must be destroyed , if they may not repress him ; thus he is secured , and the whole exposed to ruine . Yea , if he be a man as well as a King , he must be under rule of Law ; and when he transgresses , either his transgressions are punishable by men , or they are not transgressions with men , See many Arguments to this purpose in Lex Rex Quest. 14. 19. 22. 23. 24. 26. 27. But Secondly I prove it by Scripture 1. Even as King he is regulated by Law , not to multiply horses , nor wives , nor money , but to keep the words of the Law , and not lift up himself above his brethren , Deut. 17. 16 , 17 , 19 , 20. he must observe to do according to the Law , and not turn from it to the right hand or to the left Iosh. 1. 7. Ergo he must not be absolute . 2. He is certainly under that Law , Math. 7. 12. what so ever ye would that men should do to yow do ye even so to them : which is the universal fundamental Law. If then he would have us keeping in our line of subordination to him , he must keep his line , and so cannot be absolute . 3. What is Gods dwe & peculiar Prerogative , can be ouned in no Mortal : But Absolute power is Gods due & peculiar Prerogative . He alone does whatsoever pleaseth Him Psal. 115. 3. He alone worketh alle things after the Counsel of His oun will Eph. 1. 11. Acts or Commands founded upon the sole pleasure of the Agent , are proper to God. Its Gods will and not the Creatures , that can make things good or just . It s Blasphemy therefore to ascribe absolute power to any Creature . 4. That which the spirit of God condemned as a point of Tyranny in Nebuchadnezzar , that is no prerogative to be ouned : but the Spirit of God condemned this in him , proceeding from absolute power , that whom he would he slew , and whom he would he kept alive , whom he would he set up , and whom he would he put doun , And his heart was lifted up Dan. 5. 19. 20. 5. That which God condemns & threatens in Tyrants in the Word in General , cannot be ouned : but Absolute power , God condemns & thereatens in the word in general ; that they turned Iudgement into Gall , and said , have we not taken to us horns by our oun strength ? Amos. 6. 12. 13. 6. The Word of God speaks nothing of the Kings Absolute prerogative , to make Laws as he will. It is plain the Kings of Iudah had it not ; but the Sanhedrin had a great part of the Nomothetick power , and of the punitive power in a special manner : the Princes & people had it by Ieremahs acknowledgment Ier. 26. 14. And Zedekiah confesses to them ; the King is not he that can do any thing against yow Ier. 38. 5. 7. we find the King in Scripture had not an absolute power , to expone or execute the Law as he would : Saul made a Law 1 Sam. 14. 2● . Cursed be the man that eats any food until evening . But expening it , & thinking to execute it after a Tyrannical manner , he was justly resisted by the people , who would not let him kill innocent Ionathan . 8. Nor had he the sole power of Interpreting it : for inferior Judges were Interpreters , who are no less essential Judges than the King , who are set to Judge for the Lord , and not for the King 2 Cron. 19. 6. and therefore they were to expone it according to their oun conscience , and not the Kings . They were to speak righteousness & Iudge uprightly Psal. 58. 1. hence called Gods , as well as Kings Psal. 82. 1. There was no essential Difference between a King of Gods approving and a Judge ; there being but one Law to both Deut. 17. 9. he was subject to judgment as well as others : for being but a brother , even while on the throne , who was not to lift up his heart above his brethren , Deut. 17. ult . When his Cause was to be judged , his person though never so great was not to be respected ; nor were they to be afrayed of the face of man , for the judgment was Gods Deut. 1. 17. therefore the Judges were to give out sentence in judgment , as if the Lord were to give it out : There was no exception of Kings there . Yea , we find according to common Law , they judged & punished offending Kings , as shall be made appear . 10. If they were under Church Censures , then they were not absolute : but we find Kings were under Church Censures ; not only rebuked sharply to their face , of which we have many instances ; but also subjected to Church discipline , as Uzziah shut up for his Leprosie . And certainly at all times this must be extended to all : for the King is either a brother , or not : If not , then he should not be King , according to the Scripture Deut. 17. 15. then also he is not a Christian , nor can he say the Lords Prayer : If he be , then if a brother offend , he is subject to the Church Math. 18. there is no exceptions of Kings there . The Objection from Eccles , 8. 3. 4. — he doth whatsoever pleaseth him where the word of a King is there is power , and who may say unto him , what doest thow ? is of no significancy here . For. 1. This Argument will enforce absolute obedience , if the power be to be taken absolutely ▪ for it is obedience that is there commanded : and so we must not only oune the absolute Authority , but obey it without reserve , which never any yet had the impudence to plead for , until Iames the unjust claimed it in a Scots Proclaimation : but we answer , It is better to obey God than man , 2. If he may do whatsoever pleases him , then he may turn Priest , then he may kill whom he pleases , & take possession ; and yet for Saules Usurpation Samuel could say more than what doest thow ? even to tell him , he had done foolishly , and his Kingdom should not continue 1 Sam. 13. 13. 14. And for Ahabs Tyranny , El●ah could tell him , the dogs shall lick thy blood even thine 1 King. 21. 19. And Ezekiel , thow profane wicked-Prince of Israel Ezek. 21. 25. 3. The meaning is then only this ; that a righteous King , his just power may not be controlled ; he is armed with power that may not be resisted , for he beareth not the Sword in vain , and therefore we must not stand in an evil matter against them I conlude then this Argument , with the words of an Ingenious Author , upon this same subject , both in Thesi & Hypothesi : whosoever shall offer to rule Arbitrarly , does immediatly cease to be King de jure . seeing by the fundamental , Common & Statute-Laws of the Realme , we know none for Supreme Magistrate & Governour but a limited Prince , and one who stands circumscribed & bounded in his power & Prerogative . Ill effects of animosities . Pag. 17. 7. From what is said this is the result , that it is essentially necessary to a Moral power & Authority , to have a right & title , without which we can oune none , but as a Tyrant sine Titulo . For what is Authority , but a right to rule ? if then it have not a right , it is not Authority . This will be undeniable , if we consider , that as Private dominon , or Property , consists in a right to enjoy ; So Publick dominion , in a right to rule . Some things indeed are exposed to the common & arbitrary use of every man , and also at the begining , by reason of the fewness of mankind , Dominion was not reduced to distinct Property ; yet now , upon the Multiplication of Occupants , of necessity it must be stated by peculiar appropriation , from the Law of Nature , and by the Grant of the Supreme King , who hath given the earth to the Children of men Psal. 115. 16 , not to be catched up as the food of beasts , which the stronger seise , and the weaker get only what the other leave them , but divided by right as an Inheritance , by Him who separated the Sons of Adam and set the bounds of the People Deut. 32. 8. Especially Publick Dominion cannot be without a foundation for its relation to the subjected , and must be so tied up , that it may be said , this man is to command and these are to obey . I shew that Authority is from God both by Institution & Constitution ; so that the Subjects are given to understand , such an one is singled out by God to sustain this Authority , by prescribing a rule for mens entry into the Authoritative relation , whereby He communicates that power to them which is not in others , and which otherwise would not be in them . Hence it is that Orderly admittance that must give the right , and upon mens having or not having such an entrance to it depends the reality or nullity of the power they challenge . Where therefore there is no Lawful Investure , there is no Moral power to be ouned ; otherwise Iohn of Leyden his Authority might have been ouned : the unlawfulness of such a power consists in the very tenore it self , and if we take away the use or holding of it , we take away the very being of it : it is not then the abuse of a power Lawfully to be used , but the very use of it is unlawful . But in the Usurpation of this Man , or Monster rather that is now mounted the Throne , there is no Lawful investure in the way God hath appointed , as is shewed above . Ergo there is no Moral power to be ouned . To clear this alitle further , it will be necessary to remove the ordinary Prentences , pleaded for a Title to warrant the ouning of such as are in power . Which are three chiefly viz. Possession , Conquest , and Hereditary Succession . The first must be touched more particularly , because it hath been the originate error , & spring of all the stupid mistakes about Government , and is the pitiful plea of many even Malecontents , why this Mans Authority is to be ouned , asserting that a person attaining & occupying the place of power ( by whatsoever means ) is to be ouned as the Magistrate . But this can give no right : for . 1. If Providence cannot signify Gods approbative ordination , it can give no right ; for without that there can be no right : But Providence cannot signify His approbative Ordination : because that , without the warrant of His Word , cannot signify either allowance or dissallowance , it is so various , being often the same to Courses directly contrary , and oftentimes contrary to the same Course : sometimes favouring it , sometimes crossing it , whether it be good or bad : And the same Common Providence may proceed from far different Purposes , to one in Mercy , to another in Judgment ; And most frequently very disproportionable to mens wayes : Providence places sometimes wickedness in the place of Iudgment , and iniquity in the place of righteousness Eccless . 3. 16. that is not by allowance . By Providence it happens to the just according to the work of the wicked , and to the wicked according to the work of the righteous Eccless . 8. 14. No man knoweth either love or hatred by all that is before them , all things come alike to all , there is one event to the righteous and to the wicked Eccel . 9. 1. It were a great debasing of the Lords anointed to give him no other warrant then sin hath in the world , or the falling of a Sparrow . 2. Either every Providential Possession , in every ease , gives a title : Or God hath Declared it as a Law , that it shall be so in this particular matter of Authority only . The first cannot be said : for , that would justify all robbery : Nor the second , for where is that Law found ? Nay it were impious to alledge it ; for it would say , there is no unjust Possessor or Disorderly occupant , but if he were once in the Possession , he were right enough : And then Usurpation would be no sin . 3. If none of the Causes of Magistracy be required to the producing of this Possessory power , then it cannot give or have any right ; for without the true Causes it cannot be the true effect , and so can have no true right to be ouned : But none of the Causes of Magistracy are required to the production of this ; neither the Institution of God , for this might have been if Magistracy had never been instituted ; Nor the Constitution of men , for this may usurp without that . 4. That which must follow upon the right , and be Legitimated by it , cannot be ouned as the right , nor can it give the title : But the Possession of the power , or the Possessory exercise thereof , must follow upon its right , and be legitimated by it . Ergo — A man must first be in the relation of a Ruler , before he can rule ; and men must first be in the relation of subjects , before they obey . The Commands of Publick Justice , to whom are they given but to Magistrats ? They must then be Magistrats , before they can be ouned as the Ministers of Justice : he must be a Magistrate before he can have the power of the Sword , he cannot by the power of the Sword make himself Magistrate . 5. That which would make every one in the Possession of the Magistracy , a Tyrant , can not be ouned : But a Possessory occupation giving right , would make every one in Possession of the Magistracy a Tyrant , can not be ouned : But a Possessory occupation giving right , would make every one in Possession a Tyrant ; for , that which enervats & takes away that necessary Distinction between the Kings personal Capacity & his Legal Capacity , his natural & his moral power , will make every King a Tyrant ( seeing it makes every thing that he can do as a man , to be Legally done as a King ) But a Possessory occupation giving right , would enervate & take away that distinction : for how can these be distinguished in a meer Possessory power ? the mans Possession is all his legal power ; and if Possession give a right , his power will give legality . 6. What sort or size of Possession can be ouned to give a right ? Either it must be partial or plenary possession : Not partial , for then others may be equally entitled to the Government , in competition with that partial possessor , having also a part of it : Not plenary , for them every interruption or Usurpation on a part , would make a dissolution of the Government . 7. Hence would follow infinite absurdities : this would give equal warrant in case of vacancy to all men to step to , & stickle for the throne , and expose the Common wealth as a booty to all aspiring spirits ; for they needed no more to make them Soveraigns , and lay a tye of subjection upon the consciences of people , but to get into possession : And in case of Competition , it would leave people still in suspense & uncertainties whom to oune , for they behoved to be subject only to the Uppermost , which could not be known until the Controversy be decided : It would cassate & make void all preobligations , Cautions , & restrictions from God about the Government : it would Cancel and make vain all other titles of any , or Constitutions , or provisions , or Oaths of Allegiance : yea to what purpose were Laws , or pactions made about ordering the Government , if possession gave right , & laid an obligation on all to oune it ? yea then it were sinful to make any such provisions , to fence in & limit the determination of providence , if providential possession may authorize every intruesive acquisition to be ouned : Then also in case of competition of two equal pretenders to the Government , there would be no place left for arbitrations : If this were true , that he is the power that is in possession , the difference were at an end ; no man could plead for his oun right then : In this also it is inconsistent with it self , condemning all resistence against the present occupant , yet justifying every resistence that is but successful to give possession . 8. That which would oblige us to oune the Devil & the Pope , cannot be a ground to oune any man : But if this were true , that possession gave right , it would oblige us to oune the Devil & the pope . Satan we find claiming to himself the possession of the worlds Kingdoms Luk. 4. 6. which as to many of them is in some respect true , for he is called the God of this world , and the Prince of this world Iohn . 14. 30. 2 Cor. 4. 4. Are men therefore obliged to oune his authority ? or shall they deny his , and acknowledge his lievtenant , who bears his name , and by whom all his orders are execute , I mean the man that Tyranizes over the people of God ? for he is the Devil that casts some into prison Revel . 2. 10. Again the Pope , his Captain-General , layes claim to a Temporal power & Ecclesiastick both , over all the Nations , and possesses it over many ; and again , under the Conduct of his vassal the Duke of York , is attempting to recover the possession of Britain : Shall he therefore be ouned ? This Cursed Principle disposes men for Poperie , and contributes to strengthen Poperie & Tyrannie both on the stage , to the vacating of all the promises of their dispossession . 9. That which would justify a Damnable sin , and make it a ground of a duty , cannot be ouned : But this fancy of ouning every power in possession would justify a damnable sin , and make it the ground of a duty : for , Resistence to the powers ordained of God is a damnable sin Rom , 13. 2. but the Resisters having success in providence may come to the possession of the power , by expelling the just occupant ; and by this opinion that possession would be ground for the duty of subjection for Conscience sake . 10. If a self-created dignity be null and not to be ouned , then a meer possessory is not to be ouned : But the former is ttue : as Christ saith , Iohn . S. 54. If I honour myself my honor is nothing . 11. That which God hath disallowed cannot be ouned : But God hath expresly disallowed possession without right Ezek. 21. 27. I will overturn , overturn , overturn it until He come whose right it is , Hos. 8. 4. They have set up Kings & not by me . Math. 26. 52. All they that take the sword shall perish with the sword ; by this the Usurper of the Sword is differenced from the true ouner . 12. Many Scripture examples confut this ; shewing that the possession may be in one , and the power with right in another . David was the Magistrate , and yet Absalom possessed the place 2 Sam. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. chap. Shebah also made a revolt and Usurped the possession in a great part , and yet David was King 2 Sam. 20. 2. Adonijah got the start in respect of possession , exalting himself , saying , I will be King : yet the Kingdom was Solomons from the Lord. 1 King. 1. ch . The house of Ahaziah had not power to keep still the Kingdom 2 Chron. 22. 9. and Athaliah took the possession of it , yet the people set up Ioash 23. 3. Next we have many examples of such who have invaded the possessor , Witness Iehoram & Iehoshaphat their expedition against Mesba King of Moah , Elisha being in the expedition 2 King. 3. 4 , 5. Hence we see the first pretence removed . The Second is no better ; which Augustine calls Magnum Latrocinium a Great Robberie ; I mean conquest ; or a power of the Sword gotten by the Sword : which that it can give no right to be ouned , I prove . 1. That which can give no signification of Gods approving will , cannot give a Title to be ouned : But meer conquest can give no signification of Gods approving will , as is just now proven about possession : for then the Lord should have approven all the unjust conquests that have been in the world . 2. Either conquest as conquest must be ouned , as a just Title to the Crown ; and so the Ammonites , Moabites , Philistims &c. prevailing over Gods people for a time ; must have reigned by right : or as a just conquest , in this case conquest is only a mean to the conquerours seising & holding that power , which the State of the war entitled him unto , And this ingress into Authority over the conquered is not grounded on conquest but on justice , and not at all privative but Inclusive of the consent of the people ; and then it may be ouned ; but without a compact , upon conditions of securing Religion & Liberty , the posterity cannot be subjected without their consent : for , what ever just quarrel the conquerour had with the present Generation , he could haue none with the Posterity , the Father can have no power to resign the Liberty of the Children . 3. A King as King , and by virtue of his Royal Office , must be ouned to be a Father , Tutor , Protector , Shepherd , & Patron of the people : But a mere conquerour without consent cannot be ouned as such . Can he be a Father & Patron to us against our will , by the sole power of the sword ? a Father to these that are unwilling to be Sons ? an head over such as will not be members ? and a defender through violence ? 4. A King as such is a special gift of God , and blessing not a judgement : But a conquerour as such is not a blessing but a judgement , his native end being not Peace but fire & sword . 5. That which hath nothing of a King in it , can not be ouned to make a King : But conquest hath nothing of a King in it ; for it hath nothing but violence & force , nothing out what the bloodyest villain that was never a King may have , nothing of Gods approving & regulating Will , nothing of Institution or constitution ; and a plain repugnancy to the Ordination of God , for God hath said , thow shalt not kill ; conquest sayes , I will kill , and Prosper , & reign . 6. A Lawful Call to a Lawful Office may not be resisted : But a Call to conquest , which is nothing but ambition or revenge , ought to be resisted ; because not of Gods preceptive will , otherwise He should be the Author of sin . 7. That power which we must oune to be the Ordinance o● God , must not be resisted Rom. 13. 2. But conquest may be resisted in defence of our King & Country : Therefore it must no be ouned to be the Ordinance of God. 8. That which God condemns in His Word cannot be ouned : But Dominion by the sword God condemns in His Word Ezek. 33. 26. ye stand upon your sword — and shall possess the Land , Amos 6. 13. ye rejoice in a thing of naught which say , have we not taken horns to us by our oun strength . Habhak . 2. 5 , 6 — Wo to him that encreaseth that which is not his , how long &c. 9. We have many examples of invading Conquerours : as Abraham for the rescue of Lot pursued the Conquering Kings unto Dan. Gen. 14. 14. Ionathan smote a Garison of the Conqueering Philistims 1 Sam. 13. 3. The Lord ouning & authorizing them so to do . The people did often shake off the yoke of their Conquerours in the history of the Judges : But this they might not do to their Lawful Rulers . What is objected from the Lords people Conquering Canaan &c. is no Argument for conquest : for He , to whom belongs the earth and its fullness , disponed to Israel the Land of Canaan for their Inheritance , and ordained that they should get the possession thereof by conquest : It followeth not , therefore that Kings now , wanting any word of promise or divine Grant to any Lands , may ascend to the Thrones of other Kingdoms than their oun , by no better title than the bloody sword . See Lex Rex Quest 12. The Third pretence , of Hereditary Succession remaines to be removed : which may be thus disproven . 1. This clashes with the former , though commonly asserted by Royalists . For either Conquest gives a right , or it does not : If it does , then it looses all allegiance to the heirs of the Crown dispossessed thereby : If it does not give a right , then no Hereditary Succession founded upon conquest can have any right , being founded upon that which hath no right : And this will shake the most part of Hereditary Successions that are now in the world . 2. If Hereditary Succession have no right , but the peoples consent ; then of it self it can give none to a man that hath not that consent : But the former is true . For , it is demanded , how doth the Son or Brother succeed ? by what right ? It must either be by divine promise ; Or by the Fathers will ; Or it must come by propogation from the first Ruler , by a right of the Primogeniture : But none of these can be . For the first , we have no immediate Divine Constitution tying the Crown to such a race , as in Davids Covenant : It will be easily granted , they fetched not their Charter from Heaven immediatly , as David had it , a man of many peculiar prerogatives , to whose line the promise was astricted of the Coming of Messias , and Iacobs Prophesie that the Scepter should not depart from Iudah until His coming Gen. 49. 10. was restricted to his family afterwards : Wherefore he could say , The Lord God of Israel chose me befor all the house of my father to be King over Israel for ever , for He hath chosen Iudah to be the Ruler , and of the house of Iudah the house of my father , and among the sons of my father He liked me to make me ▪ King over Israel , and of all my Sons He hath chosen Solomon 1 Chron. 28. 4. 5. All Kings cannot say this ; neither could Saul say it , though immediatly called of God as well as David : yet this same Promise to David was Conditional , if His Children should keep the Lords wayes 2 Chron. 6. 16. Next it cannot be said this comes from the will of the father ; for according to the Scripture , no King can make a King , though a King may appoint & design his son for succession , as David did Solomon , but the people make him . The father is some way a Cause why his son succeedeth , but he is not the Cause of the Royaltie conferred upon him by line : for the question will recur , who made him a King ? and his father ? & grand father ? till we come up to the first father . Then , who made him a King ? not himself : therefore it must be refounded upon the peoples choise & constitution : And who appointed the lineal succession , and tyed the Crown to the line , but they ? It is then at the best , the Patrimony of the people , by the fundamental Law of the Kingdom , conferred upon the successor by consent . And generally it is granted , even where the succession is lineal , he that comes to inherit , Doth it not jure hereditario but vi legis , he does not succeed by heritage but by the force of Law ; the Son then hath not his Kingdom from his father but by Law , which the people made & stand to , as long as it may consist with the reasons of publick advantage , upon which they condiscended to establish such a family over them . Neither can it be said , It is by a right of Primogeniture propogated from the first Ruler ; for this must either be Adam the first of the world ; or Fergus v. G. the first of this Kingdom . It could not come from Adam as a Monarch & father of all : For that behoved to be , either by order of Nature , or his volun●ary assignment : It could not be transferred by order of Nature ; for besides the difficulty to find out Adams successor , in the universal Monarchy , and the absurdity of fixing it on Cain ( who was a Cursed vagabond , afraied of every man , and could not be an universal Monarch yet Adams first born ) It will be asked , how this passed from him unto others ? whether it went by father-hood to all the Sons , fathers to their Posterity ? which would multiply as many Common wealths , as there have been fathers since : Or if it went by Primogeniture only to the first born , that he alone could claim the power which would infer the necessity of an universal Monarchy , without multiplication of Common-wealths . If it was by his voluntary assignment , to whom & in what proportion he pleased ; then the universal Monarchy died with himself , and so could not be conveyed at all : for , either he behoved to give each son a share , to be conveyed dounwards to their children in that proportion ; or whole & solide to one : So also the former dilemma recurs , for if the first be said , it will make as many litle Kingdoms as there have been sons of Adam ; if the second , the world should be but still one Kingdom . But however it be , this could never be the way that God appointed , either for raising a Magistratical power where it is wanting , or deriving a right to any in being ; Considering the multiplication , division , confusion , & Extinction of families that have been . If it be from Fergus the first of this line ; then either it comes from him as a King , or as a Father : not the first , for the reason above hinted : nor as a father ; for a father may defraud his son of the heritage , a King cannot deprive his son of the Crown ; a father may divide his heritage , a King cannot divide the Kingdom among his sons ; It must then be at length refounded on the peoples Consent 3. If even where lineal succession is Constituted by Law , for eviting the inconveniences of frequent elections , people are not tied to admit every first born of that line ; then that birth righr , where there is no more , cannot make a King : But the former is true ; for they are tied only conditionally , so he be qualified , and have a head to sit at the helme , and not a fool or monster , neither are they free to admit Murderers or Idolaters by the Laws of God and of the Land : It is not birth then , but their admission being so qualified , that makes Kings . Hence . 4. That which takes away the peoples birth-right , given them of God to provide for their liberties in the fitest Government , that is not to be ouned : But to make birth alone a tile to the Crown , takes away the peoples birth-right given them of God of providing for their liberties in the fitest Government , and fetters their choise to one destructive to these . Certainly where God hath not bound the conscience , men may not bind themselves nor their posterity : But God hath never fettered men to a choise of a Government or Governing line , which contrary to the intention of the Oath may prove destructive to the ends thereof . Nor can the fathers leave in legacy by Oath , any chains to fetter the after wits of posterity to a choise destructive to Religion & liberty . Israel was bound by Covenant not to destroy the Gibeonites ; but if they had risen to cut off Isael , who can doubt but they were loosed from that obligation ? for to preserve Cut-throats was contrary to the intention of the Oath : so when either Monarchy , or the succeeding Monarch , proves destructive to the ends of Government , the Choice , Law , or Oath of our fathers , cannot bind us . 5. If we are tied to the hereditary succession , not for the right the successor hath by birth , but for our Covenanted allegiance to them whose successor he is ; then cannot his birth-right be the ground of our Allegiance , And consequently hereditary succession cannot make a King : But the former is true ; for in hereditary Crowns , the first family being chosen by the suffrages of the people , for that Cause the hereditary Prince comes to the Throne , becanse his first father , and in him the whole line , was chosen : The hereditary successor hath no priviledge or prerogative , but from him who was chosen King. Therefore the obligation to the son , being no greater than the obligation to the father , which is the ground of that , if the father then was ouned only because he was chosen & qualified for Government , the Son cannot be ouned for any other Cause , but as chosen in him , and also qualified and admitted with Consent . We cannot choose the father as qualified , and tye our selves to the Successors , be what they will. 6. If a King be not born heir of a Kingdom , then is he not King by birth ; But he is not born heir of a Kindom : for , a mean cannot be born to inherit the end , the King is but a mean for the Kingdoms preservation . If the Kingdom be his by birth as an inheritance , why may he not upon necessary occasions sell his inheritance ? but if he sell it , then all confess he is no more King. 7. If that which makes a King cannot be transmitted from father to son ; then succession by birth cannot make a King : But the former is true . The Royal faculty of Governing cannot be transmitted : Solomon asked it from God , he had it not from his father : nor can he be born to the honour of a King , because not born with either the gift or honour to be a Iudge . God maketh high & low , not birth . Nor can the Call & Constitution of a King according to the will of God be transferred from father to son , for that cannot be in Gods way without the intervening Consent of the people , that cannot make him a born King. 8. If no Dominion can come by Nature , as is proven before , then can no man be a born King : Nature & birth cannot give them a Scepter in their hand ; nor Kingly Majestie they must have that alone from God & the people , and may only expect honour from their oun good Government : Kings ( as Plutarch sayes ) must be like dogs that are best hunters , not these who are born of best dogs . 9. The peculiar Prerogative of Iesus Christ must not be ascribed to any other : But this is His peculiar Prerogative , to be a born King of whom it might be truely faid , Where is He that is born King of the Iewes ? And for this end was He born , who came out of the womb with a Crown on His Head , which no Creature can bear . 10. In Scripture we find that a King was to be so & so qualified , not a stranger , but a reader of Gods Word &c. Deut. 17. 15. &c. he was not qualified by naked birth . Hence , if all the qualifications requisite in an heir cannot make a King qualified according to the Institution of God , then his being heir cannot make him King : But the first is true ; an heir may be an heir without these qualifications . 11. We find in the Scripture , the people were to make the Kings by that Law Deut. 17. thow shalt choose him whom the Lord chooseth : yea neither Saul nor David were Kings , till the people met to make them : Therefore birth never made them Kings , even though the Kingdom was tied to Davids line . That was only a Typical designment by special Promise , because Christ was to come of that line ; it was therefore established in Davids family for Typical reasons , that cannot be now alledged . 12. We find in the disposal of Government among brethren , this birth-order was not seldom inverted ; as when Iacoh was preferred before Esaw , Iudah before all the elder sons of Iacob . Ephraim before Manasseh , Solomon before Adonijah . Hence if this Gentleman now regnant , have no better pretences than these now confuted , we cannot recognosce his right to reign : yea though this last were valid , yet he cannot plead it , it being expressly provided in our Laws against the succession of a Papist . But there is one Grand Objection against all this . The Jewes and other Nations are commanded to bring their necks under the yoke of the King of Babilon and to serve him , and yet he had no other right to these Kingdom , then the Lords Providential disposal , because the Lord had given all these Lands into his hand , Ier. 27. 6 , 7 , 12. Ans. 1. He was indeed an unjust Usurper , and had no right but the Lord providential gif● ; which sometimes makes the tabernacles of Robbers prosper into whose hand God bringeth abundantly Iob. 12. 6. and gives Iacoh sometimes for a spoil and Israel to the Robbers Isai. 42. 24. and giveth power to the Beast to continue forty & two Moneths , and to have power over all kindreds & tongues & Nations Revel . 13. 5 , 7. His Tyranny also was very great extensively , in respect of his oppressions & usurpations by Conquest : but it was not so great intensively , as our Robbers & Spoilers may be charged with ; he was never such a Perverter of all the ends of Government , nor a treachrous overturner of all Conditions , he was never a Persecuter of the Iewish Religion , he never oppressed them upon that account , nor endeavoured its extirpation , he never enacted such mischiefs by Law. The Lord only made use of him to bring about the holy ends of the Glory of His Justice & Wisdom , in which respect alone he is called His Servant , as else where His ●od & hammer , having given him a charge against an Hypocritical Nation to trample them doun in His holy Providence , and accordingly there was no resistence could prevail , they must be trampled upon , no help for it ; but no subjection was required , acknowledging his Magistratical right by divine Ordinance , but only a submissive stooping to the holy disposal of divine Providence ; no ouning was exacted either of the equity of that power , or of fealtie to the administrator . 2. This behoved to be a particular Command , by Positive Revelation given at that time , not binding to others in the like Condition ; which I refer to the judgment of the objectors : put the case , and make it run paralel , If the King of England were in league with the King of France , and breaking that league should provoke that aspiring Prince , growing potent by many Conquests , to discover his designs , make preparations , and give out threatenings for the Conquest of England & all Brittain ; were the people of England bound to surrender themselves as Servants & tributaries to him , for 70 years or for ever , under pain of destruction , if they should not ? This were one of the most ridiculous inferences , that ever was pleaded : nay it would make all refusal of subjection to invaders unlawful . 3. I will draw an Argument from this to confirm my Plea : for these Commands of subjection to Babilon , were not delivered until after the King of Iudah had surrendered to Nebuchadnezzar , and entered into Covenant with him to be subject to him 2. King. 24. chap. in keeping which Covenant the Kingdom might have stood , and after he had Rebelled against him and broken that Covenant , when lo he had given his hand ; after which he could not prosper , or escape , or be delivered , Ezek. 17. 14 , 15 , 18 , 2 Chron. 36. 13. Then the Commandment came , that they should disoune their oune King Zedekiah , now forefeiting his right by breach of Covenant , and be subject to Nebuchadnezzar . Whence I argue , If people are commanded to disoune their Covenant-breaking Rulers , and subject themselves to Conquerours ; then I have all I plead for : But the former is true , by the truth of this objection : Ergo also the Latter . There is a 2 Obj. from Rom. 13. 1. let every soul be subject to the higher powers , the powers that be are ordained of God : yet the Roman Emperour , to which they were to be subject , was an usurper . Ans. 1. It cannot be proven that the Apostle intendeth here the Roman Emperour as the higher power : There were at this time several Competitions for the Empire , about which Christians might have their oun scruples whom to oune ; the Apostle does not determine their litigations , nor interest himself in parties , but gives the General Standart of Gods Ordinance they had to go by . And the best Expositors of the place do alle●ge , the question & doubt of Christians then , was not so much in whom the Supremacy was ? as whether Christians were at all bound to obey Civil power , especially Pagan ? which the Apostle resolves , in giving general directions to Christians , to obey the ordinance of Magistracy , conforme to its original , and as it respects the end for which he had & would set it up , but no respect is there had to Tyrants . 2. It cannot be proven that the Supreme power then in being was usurpative : there being then a Supreme Senate , which was a Lawful power ; nor that Nero was then an usurper , who came in by choise & consent , and with the good liking of the people . 3. The Text means of Lawful powers , not unlawful force , that are ordained of God by His Preceptive will not meerly by His Providential disposal , and of consciencious subjection to Magistracy , not to Tyranny , describing & characterizing the powers there , by such qualifications as Tyrants & Usurpers are not capable of . But I mind to improve this Text more fully hereafter , to prove the quite contrary to what is here objected . 8. From the Right of Magistracy , flowes the Magistratical Relation ; which is necessary to have a bottom , before we can build the relative duties thereof . This brings it under the fifth Commandment , which is the Rule of all relative duties between Inferiours & Superiours , requiring honour to be given to Fathers , Masters , Husbands &c. and to rightful Magistrates , who are under such political relations , as do infer the same duties ; and prohibiting not only the omission of these duties , but also the committing of contrary sins ; which may be done , not only by contrary acts , as dishonouring & rebelling against Fathers , Magistrats &c. but also by performing them to contrary objects , as by giving the Fathers due to the Fathers opposite , and the Magistrats due to Tyrants who are their opposites . Certainly this Command prescribing honour , doth regulate to whom it should be given ; And must be understood in a consistency with that duty , and Character of one that hath a mind to be an inhabitant of the Lords holy Hill Psal. 15. 4. in whose eyes a vile person is contemned but he honoureth them that fear the Lord. So that we sin against the fifth Command , when we honour them that we are obliged to contemn by another Command . Hence I argue , If ouning or honouring of Tyrants be a breach of the fifth Command ; then we cannot oune their Authority : But the former is true : Ergo the latter . I prove the Assumption . A honouring the vile to whom no honour is due , and who stand under no relation of Fathers as Fathers , is a breach of the fifth Command : But the ouning of Tyrants Authority is a honouring the vile to whom no honour is due , and who stand under no relation of Fathers , and is yet a honouring them as Fathers : Ergo the ouning of Tyrants Authority is a breach of the fifth Command . The Major is clear : for if the honouring of these to whom no honour is due , were not a breach of the fifth Command ; that precept conld neither be kept at all , nor broken at all . It could not be kept at all : for , either it must oblige us to honour all indefinitely , as Fathers , and other relations , which cannot be : or else it must leave us still in suspence & ignorance , who shall be the object of our honour ; and then it can never be kept : or finally it must astrict our honouring to such definite relations , to whom it is due ; & then our transgression of that restriction , shall be a breach of it . Next if it were not so , it could not be broken at all : for if prostituting & abusing honour be not a sin , we cannot sin in the matter of honour at all ; for if the abuse of honour be not a sin , then dishonour also is not a sin , for that is but an abuse of the duty , which is a sin as well as the omission of it . And what should make the taking away of honour from the proper object to be sin , and the giving it to a wrong object to be no sin ? Moreover if this Command do not restrict honour to the proper object ; we shall never know who is the object : how shall we know who is our Father , or what we owe to him , if we may give another his due ? The Minor also is manifest : for if Tyrants be vile , then no honour is due to them , according to that Psal. 15. 4. And yet it is a honouring them as Fathers if they be ouned as Magistrats ; for Magistrats are in a politick sense Fathers : But certain it is that Tyrants are vile , as the Epithets & Characters they get in Scripture prove . But because , in contradiction to this , it may be said ; though Fathers be never so wicked , yet they are to be honoured because they are still Fathers , And though Masters be never so vile and froward , yet they are to be subjected unto 1 Pet. 2. 18-20 . and so of other relations , to whom honour is due by this Command , therefore though Tyrants be never so vile they are to be ouned under these relations , because they are the higher Powers in place of Eminency , to whom the Apostle Paul commands to yeeld subjection Rom. 13. and Peter to give submission & honour 1 Pet. 2. 13 , 17. Therefore it must be considered , that as the relative duty of honouring the relations to whom it is due , must not interfere with the moral duty of contemning the vile , who are not under these relations ; So this general Moral of contemning the vile , must not ca●sate the obligation of relative duties , but must be understood with a Consistency therewith , without any prejudice to the duty it self . We must contemn all the vile that are not under a relation to be honoured , and these also that are in that relation in so far as they are vile . But now Tyrants do not come under these Relations at all that are to be honoured by this Command . As for the higher Powers that Paul speaks of Rom. 13. they are not those which are higher in fo●ce , but higher in Power , not in potentia but in potestate , not in a Celsitude of prevalency but in a precellency of dignity , not in the pomp & pride of their prosperity & possession of the place , but by the virtue & value of their office , being ordained of God not to be resisted , the Ministers of God for good , terrors to evil doers , to whom honour is due , those are not Tyrants but Magistrats . Hence it is a word of the same root which is rendered Authority , or an Authorized Power 1 Tim. 2. 2. And from the same word also comes that supreme to whom Peter commands subjection & honour 1 Pet. 2. 13. Now these he speaks of have the Legal Constitution of the people , being the ordinance of man to be subjected to for the Lords sake . and who sends other inferior Magistrats for the punishment of evil doers , and for the praise of them that do well , who are to be honoured as Kings or Lawful Magistrats : this cannot be said of Tyrants . But more particularly , to evince that Tyrants & Usurpers are not to be honoured according to this Command , and that it is a breach of it so to do ; let us go through all these Relations of Superiority that come under the obligation of this Command , and we shall find Tyrants & Usurpers excluded out of all . First , they cannot come under the Parental relation : We are indeed to esteem Kings as Fathers , though not properly but by way of some Analogy , because it is their office to care for the people , and to be their Counsellers , and to defend them , as Fathers do for Children : but Roaring Lyons & Ranging Bears , as wicked Rulers are , Prov. 28. 15. cannot be Fathers . But Kings cannot properly be ouned under this Relation , far less Tyrants ( with whom the Analogy of Fathers cannot consist ) there being so many notable disparities betwixt Kings & Fathers . 1. A Father may be a Father to one Child ; but a King cannot be a King or Politick Father to one only , but his Correlate must be a Community ; a Tyrant can be a Father to none at all in a Politick sense . 2. A Father is a Father by Generation to all coming out of his loyns ; a King not so , he doth not beget them , nor doth their relation flow from that ; a Tyrant is a destroyer not a Procreator of people . 3. A Father is the cause of the Natural being of his Children ; A King only of the Politick well being of his subjects ; but Tyrants are he cause of the ill being of both . 4. A Father once a Father , as long as his Children live , retains still the relation , thô he turn mad and never so wicked ; A King turning mad may be served as Nebuchadnezzar was , at least all will grant in some cases the subjects may shake off th● King ; and if in any case , it is when he turns Tyrant . 5. A Fathers relation never ceases , whither soeuer his Children go ; but subjects may change their relation to a King , by coming under another King in another Kingdom ; a Tyrant will force all lovers of freedom to leave the Kingdom where he Domineers . 6. A Fathers relation never changes , he can neither change his children nor they change their Father ; but a King may naturalize new subjects , and subjects may also change their Soveraign , Royalists will grant a State or Common-wealth way make a King , and there is great reason sometimes that a Monarchy be turned into a Common-wealth ; but a Tyrant changes those that are under him , expells the natives , brings in forreigners , and all good Patriots do pant for a Change of him every day . 7. A Father hath no power of life & death over his Children ; a King hath it over his subjects according to Law ; a Tyrant Usurps it over the innocent against Law. 8. A Father is not a Father by consent of his Childeren ; as a King is by consent of his subjects ; a Tyrant is neither a Father with it nor without it . 9. A Father is not made by the Children ; as a King is by his subjects as was shewed ; a Tyrant is neither a Natural , nor by compact , but a self created power . 10. A Father is not chosen conditionally upon compact , as a King is by the free suffrages of the Community ; A Tyrant in this Differs from a King that he is not chosen , and in Tyranny from a Father . 11. Children wanting a Father cannot choose whom they will to be their Father ; as subjects wanting a King may choose whom they will , and what form they please ; but though they can , yet if they be rational , they will never choose a Tyrant , nor a Tyrannical form of Government . 12. Children cannot restrict their Fathers power to what degrees they please ; as subjects may limit their Kings , at their first erection ; but a Tyrant though he ought yet he will not be limited , and if he might he should be restrained . 13. Children cannot set bounds how long they will have their Fathers to continue ; Subjects may condescend upon the time , in making Laws how long such an one shall be their Soveraign , ad vitam or ad culpam , according as the fundamental Law is made at first ; Tyrants ought every day to be repressed , that they should not continue at all . Yet giving and not granting , that a King were to be ouned under the relation of a Father ; though every man be bound to oune & mantain his Fathers parental Authority , yet let the case be put , that the Father turns a Robber , murderer , an avowed enemy to God and the country , is his person & Authority in that case to be ouned , to the dishonour of God , and hurt & hazard of the country ? or ought he not rather to be delivered up even by the Son to Justice ? Much more then will it follow , that a King who turns the more dangerous because the more powerfull Robber , & Legal Murderer , and enemy to God & the country , cannot be ouned ; seeing the relation betwixt Father & Son is stronger & stricter , as having another Original , than can be betwixt King & subjects , and stands unremoved as long as he is Father , though turning such they ought to contribute ( in moral duty , to which their relative duty must cede ) that he should no more be a Father , nor no more a living man , when dead by Law. Secondly , They cannot come under the herile or Masterly relation , though Analogically also sometimes they are stiled so , and subjects are called Servants , by reason of their subjection , and because it is the Office of Kings to command & subjects to obey , in this there is some Analogy . But Kings cannot properly be ouned under this relation , as Masters over either persons or goods of subjects , far less Tyrans , yea Kings assuming a Masterly power turn Tyrants . Now that the Magistratical relation is not that of a Master , is clear from many disparities & absurdities , whether we consider the state of hired Servants or Slaves . For hired Servants , the difference is vast betwixt them & subjects . 1. The hired Servant gets reward for his service , by compact ; the subjects none , but rather gives the Royal reward of Tribute to the King for his service ; the Tyrant exacts it to maintain his Tyranny . 2. The hired Servant is maintained by his Master ; the subjects maintain the King ; the Tyrant Robbes it from them by force . 3. The hired Servant bargains only for a time , and then may leave him ; the subject cannot give up his Covenanted allegiance , at that rate and for these reasons as the servant may his service ; a Tyrant wil make nor keep no such bargain . 4. The hired Servant must have his Masters profit mainly before his eyes , and his oun only secundarly ; but the Magistrates power is primarly ordinated to the publick good of the Community ▪ and only consequentially to the good of himself . 5. The Master hath a greater power over the hired Servant , to make & give out Lawes to him , which if they be Lawful he must obey ; than the King hath over the Nation , to which he is not the sole Lawgiver , as is shewed . 6. The hired Servant his subjection is Mercenary & servile ; but the subjects subjection is civil , free , voluntary , liberal , & ●oving to a Lawful King. Again for Slaves , the difference between them & subjects is great . 1. Slavery being against Nature , rational people would never choose that life if they could help it ; but they gladly choose Government , & Governours . 2. Slavery would make their condition worse then when they had no Government , for Liberty is alwise preferable ; Neither could people have acted rationally in seting up Government , if to be free of oppression of others they had given themselves up to slavery , under a Master who may do what he pleases with them . 3. All Slaves are either taken in war , or bought with money , or born in the house where their parents were slaves , as Abraham & Solomon had of that sort ; But subjects are neither captives , nor bought , nor born slaves . 4. Slavery is not Natural , but a penal fruit of sin , and would never have been if sin had not been ; But Government is not so , but Natural & necessary . 5. Slaves are not their Masters brethren ; subjects are the Kings brethren ; over whom he must not lift up himself Deut. 17. 20. 6. Masters might purchase and sell their slaves , Abimelech took sheep & men servants & gave them unto Abraham Gen. 20. 14. Iacob had maid servants & men servants & Asses Gen. 30. 43. no otherwise than other goods , Solomon got to himself servants and maidens , & servants born in his house Eccles. 2. 7. a King cannot do so with his subjects . 7. Princes have not this power to make the people slaves , neither from God , nor from the people : From God they have none , but to feed and to lead them 2 Sam. 5. 2. to rule them so as to feed them 1 Chron. 11. 2. Psal. 78. 71 , 72. From the people they have no power to make slaves , they can give none such . 8. Slavery is a Curse : It was Canaans Curse to be a servant of servants Gen. 9. 25. but to have Magistrats is a promised blessing Ier. 17. 27. 9. To be free of Slavery is a blessing , as the redemption from Egypts bondage is every where called , and the year of redemption was a Iubile of joy , so the freedom of release every seven years a great priviledge Ier 34. 9. but to be free of Government is a judgment Isai. 3. 4 , 5. it s threatened , Israel shall abide without a King & without a Prince Hos. 3. 4. In the Next place they cannot be ouned as Masters or Proprietors over the goods of the subjects ; th● in the case of necessity , the King may make use of all goods in common , for the good of the Kingdom : For 1. The introduction of Kings cannot overturn natures foundation ; by the Law of Nature property was given to man , Kings cannot rescind that . 2. A man had goods ere ever there was a King ; a King was made only to preserve property , therefore he cannot take it away . 3. It cannot be supposed that rational people would choose a King at all , if he had power to turn a greater Robber to preserve them from lesser Robberies & oppressions : would rational men give up themselves for a prey to one , that they might be safe from becoming a prey to others ? 4. Then their case should be worse by erecting of Government , if the Prince were proprietor of their goods , for they had the property themselves before . 5. Then Government should not be a blessing but a curse , and the Magistrate could not be a Minister for good . 6. Kingdoms then should be among bona fortunae , the goods of fortune , which the King might sell & dispone as he pleased . 7. His place then should not be a function , but a possession . 8. People could not then , by their removes or otherwise , change their Soveraigns . 9. Then no man might dispose of his oun goods without the Kings consent , by buying or selling , or giving almes , nay nor pay tribute , for they cannot do these things except they have of their oun . 10. This is the very Character of a Tyrant , as described 1 Sam. 8. 11. he will take your sons &c. Zeph. 3. 3. her Princes are roaring Lyons , her Iudges are evening Wolves . 11. All the threatenings & rebukes of oppression condemn this , Isai. 3. 14. 15. Ezek. 45. 9. Mic. 3. 2 , 3. Ahab condemned , for taking Naboths vineyard . 12. Pharaoh had not all the Land of Egypt , till he bought it Gen. 42. 20. So the Land became Pharaohs not otherwise . Yet giving and not granting that he were really a Master in all these respects ; Notwithstanding if he turn to pursue me for my life , because of my fidelity to my Master & his both , & will withdraw me from the service of the Supreme Universal Master , I may Lawfully withdraw my self from his , and disoune him for one , when I cannot serve two Masters . Sure he cannot be Master of the conscience . Thirdly , They cannot come under the conjugal relation , though there may be some proportion between that and subjection to a Lawful Ruler , because of the Mutual Covenant transacted betwixt them ; but the Tyrant & Usurper cannot pretend to this , who refuse all Covenants . Yet hence it cannot be inferred , that because the wife may not put away her husband . Or renounce him , as he may do her in the case of Adultery , therefore the people cannot disoune the King in the case of the violation of the Royal Covenant . For the Kings power is not at all properly a husbands power . 1. The wife by nature is the weaker vessel ; but the Kingdom is not weaker than the King. 2. The wife is given as an help to the man ; but here the man is given as an help to the Common-wealth . 3. The wife cannot limit the husbands power ; as subjects may limit their Soveraigns . 4. The wife cannot prescribe the time of her continuing under him ; as subjects may do with their Soveraigns . 5. The wife cannot change her husband ; as a Kingdom can do their Government 6. The husband hath not power of life & death ; but the Soveraign hath it over Malefactors . Yet giving and not granting , his power were properly Marital ; if the case be put , that the man do habitually break the Marriage Covenant , or take another wife , and turn also Cruel & intollerable in compelling his oun wife to wickedness ; and put the case also , that she should not get a Legal divorce procured , who can doubt but she might disoune him , and leave him ? for this case is excepted out of that Command 1 Cor. 7. 10. let not the wife depart from her husband , meaning for mere difference in Religion , or other lesser causes ; but Adulterie doth annual the Marriage relation , See Pool Synopsis Critic . in Locum . So when a Prince breaks the Royal Covenant and turns Tyrant , or without any Covenant committs a rape upon the Common-wealth , that pretended relation may & must be disouned . Hence we see , there is no relation can bring a King or Ruler under the object of the duty of the fifth Command , except it be that of a fiduciary Patron or Trustee and Publick Servant : for we cannot oune him properly either to be a Father , or a Master , or a husband . Therefore what can remain , but that he must be a fiduciary Servant ? Wherefore if he shall either treacherously break his trust , or presumptously refuse to be entrusted , upon terms & conditions to secure & be accountable for ( before God & man ) Religion & Liberty , we cannot oune his usurped Authority . That Metaphore which the learned Buchanan uses , de Iure Regni , of a Publick & Politick Phisician , is not a relation different from this of a fiduciary Servant ; when he elegantly represents him as entrusted with the preservation & restauration of the health of the politick body , and endued with shill & experience of the Laws of his Craft . If then he be orderly called unto this charge , and qualified for it , and discharges his duty faithfully , he deserves , and we are obliged to give him the deference of an honoured Physician : But if he abuse his Calling and not observe the rules thereof , and in stead of curing go about wilfully to kill the body he is entrusted with , he is no more to be ouned for a Physician but for a Murderer . 9. If we inquire further into the nature of this Relation between a King ( whose Authority is to be ouned ) and his subjects ; we can oune it only as it is Reciprocal in respect of Superiority & Inferiority , that is , whereby in some respects the King is Superior to the people , and in some respects the people is Superior to him . The King is Superior & Supreme as he is called 1 Pet. 2. 13. in respect of formal Soveraignty , and executive Authority , and Majestick Royal dignity , resulting from the peoples devolving upon him that Power , and constituting him in that relation over themselves , whereby he is higher in place & power than they , and in respect of his Charge & conduct is worth ten thousands of the people 2 Sam. 18. 3. and there is no formally regal Tribunal higher than his ; And though he be Minor universis yet he is Major singulis , greater than any one , or all the people distributively taken ; And though he be a Royal Vassal of the Kingdom , & Princely Servant of the people ; yet he is not their deputy , because he is really their Soveraign , to whom they have made over their Power of governing & protecting themselves irrevocably , except in the case of Tyranny ; and in acts of Justice , he is not countable to any , and does not depend on the people as a deputy . But on the other hand , the people is superior to the King , in respect of their fountain power of Soveraignty , that remains radically & virtually in them , in that they make him their Royal Servant , and him rather than another and limit him to the Laws for their oun good & advantage , and though they give to him a Politick Power for their oun safety ; yet they keep a Natural Power which they cannot give away , but must resume it in case of Tyranny ; And though they cannot retract the power of Justice to govern righteously , yet it is not so irrevocably given away to him , but that when he abuseth his power to the destruction of his subjects , they may wrest a sword out of a mad mans hand , though it be his oun sword and he hath a just power to use it for good , but all fiduciary power abused may be repealed . They have not indeed Soveraignity or power of life & death formally ; yet in respect they may constitute a Magistrate with Laws , which if they violate they must be in hazard of their lives , they have this power eminently & virtually . Hence in respect that the Kings Power is and can be only fiducial , by way of trust reposed upon him , he is not so superior to the people , but he may & ought to be accountable to them in case of Tyranny ; which is evident from what is said , and now I intend to make it further appear . But first I form the Argument thus ; We can oune no King that is not accountable to the people : Ergo we cannot oune this King. To clear the Connexion of the antecedent & consequent , I adde ; Either he is accountable to the people , or he is not : If he be accountible to all then he is renouncible by a part , when the Collective body either wil not , or cannot exact an account from him , when the Community is defective as to their part , it is the interest of a part , that would but cannot do their duty , to give no account to such as they can get no account from for his Maleversations , This is all we crave : If he be not accountable , then we cannot oune him , because all Kings are accountable : for these reasons . 1. The Inferior is accountable to the Superior : the King is inferior , the people superior : Ergo the King is accountable to the people . The proposition is plain ; if the Kings superiority make the people accountable to him , in case of transgressing the Laws ; then , why should not the peoples superiority make the King accountable to them , in case of transgressing the Laws ? especially seeing the King is inferior to the Laws : because the Law restrains him , and from the Law he hath that whereby he is King ; the Law is inferior to the people , because they are as it were its parent , and way make or unmake it upon occasion : and seeing the Law is more powerful than the King , and the people more powerful than the Law , we may see before which we may call the King to answer in Judgment , Buchan Iure Regni apud Scot. That the King is inferior to the people is clear on many accounts : for these things which are institute for others sake , are inferior to those for whose sake they are required or sought ; a horse is inferior to them that use him for victory ; A King is only a mean for the peoples good ; A Captain is less then the Army , a King is but a Captain over the Lords Inheritance 1 Sam. 10. 1. He is but the Minister of God for their good Rom. 13. 4. Those who are before the King , and may be a people without him , must be superior to him who is a posteriour and cannot be a King without them : let the King be considered either Materially as a Mortal man , he is then but a part inferior to the whole ; or formally under the reduplication as a King , he is no more but a Royal Servant , obliged to spend his life for the people , to save them out of the hand of their enemies 2 Sam. 19 ▪ 9. A part is inferior to the whole , the King is but a part of the Kingdom : A Gift is inferior to them to whom it is given , a King is but a gift given of God for the peoples good : That which is Mortal & but accidental , is inferior to that which is eternal & cannot perish Politically ; a King is but mortal , and it is but accidental to Government that there be a succession of Kings ; but the people is eternal , one generation passeth away & another generation cometh Eccles. 1. 4. especially the people of God , the portion of the Lords inheritance , is superior to any King , and their ruine of greater moment than all the Kings of the world ; for if the Lord for their sake smite great Kings , & slay famous Kings , as Sihon & Og Psal. 137. 17-20 . if he give kings & famous kingdoms for their ransome Isai. 43. 3 , 4. then His people must be so much superior than kings , by how much His Justice is active to destroy the one , and His Mercy to save the other . All this proves the people to be superior in dignity , And therefore even in that respect its frivolous to say , the king cannot be accountable to them , because so much superior in Glory & Pomp ; for they are superior every way in excellency ; And though it were not so , yet Judges may be inferior in rank considered as men , but they are superior in Law over the greatest as they are Judges , to whom far greater than they are accountable . The low & mean condition of them to whom belongs the power of Judgment does not diminish its dignity : when the king then is Judged by the people , the Judgment is of as great dignity as if it were done by a superior king ; for the Judgment is the sentence of the Law , 2. They are superior in power : because every constituent cause is superior to the effect , the people is the constituent cause , the king is the effect , and hath all his Royaltie from them , by the Conveyance God hath appointed ; so that they need not fe●ch it from Heaven , God gives it by the people , by whom also his power is limited and , it need be , diminished from what they gave his Ancestors : Hence , if the people constitute & limit the power they give the King , then they may call him to an account , and judge him for the abuse of it : But the first is true as is proven above : Ergo — The Major is undenyable , for sure , they may judge their oun Creature , and call him to an account for the power they gave him , when he abuses it , though there be no Tribunal formally Regal above him , yet in the case of Tyranny and violating his Trust there is a Tribunal virtual eminently above him , in them that made him & reposed that Trust upon him , as is said . 3. The fountain power is superior to the power derived : The people , though they constitute a King above them , yet retain the fountain power , he only hath the derived power : Certainly the people must retain more power eminently , than they could give to the King , for they gave it , and he receives it , with limitations , if he turn mad or uncapable they may put Curators & Tutors over him ; if he be taken captive , they may appoint another to exercise the power , if he die then they may constitute another , with more or less power ; So then if they give a way all their power , as a slave selleth his Liberty , and retain no fountain power or radical right , they could not make use of it to produce any of these acts : They set a King above them only with an executive power for their good , but the radical power remains in the people , as in an immortal spring , which they communicate by succession to this or that Mortal man , in the manner & measure they think expedient ; for otherwise if they gave all their power away , what shall they reserve to make a new King , if this man die ? What if the Royal line surcease , there be no Prophets now sent to make Kings : And if they have power in these cases , why not in the case of Tyranny ? 4. If the King be accountable by Law , for any act of Tyranny done against one man , then much more is he accountable for many against the whole state : But the former is true ; a private man may go to Law before the ordinary Judges for wronging his inheritance , and the King is made accountable for the wrong done by him . Now shall the Laws be like Spiders webs , which hold flies , but let bigger beasts pass through ? Shall Sentence be past for petty wrongs against a man , and none for Tyrannizing over Religion , Laws , & Liberties of the Kingdom ? Shall none be past against parricide or fratricide , for killing his Brother , Murdering the Nobles , and burning Cities ? Shall pettie Thieves be hanged for stealing a Sheep , and does the Laws of God or man give impunity , for robbing a whole Country of the nearest & dearest Interests they have to Crowned heads for the fancied Character of Royalty , which thereby is forfeited ? 5. If there be Judges appointed of God independently , to give out & execute the Judgment of the Lord on all offenders , without exception of the highest ; then the King also must be subject to that Judgment : But there are Judges appointed of God independently , to give out & execute the Judgment of the Lord on all offenders , without exception of the highest . Two things must be here proved ; first , that in giving Judgment they do not depend on the King , but are the immediate vicars of God : Secondly that the King is not excepted from , but subject to , their Judgment , in case he be Criminal . First they cannot depend upon the King , because they are more necessary then the King ; and it is not left to the Kings pleasure whether there be Judges or not . There may be Judges without a King , but there can be no King without Judges , nor no Justice but Confusion ; no man can bear the peoples burden alone Numb . 11. 14 , 17 , If they depended on the King , their Power would die with the King ; the streams must dry up with the fountain : but that cannot be , for they are not Ministri regis but regni , they are not Ministers of the King but of the Kingdom , whose honour & promotion , though by the Kings external call , yet comes from God , as all honour & promotion does Psal. 75. 7 , The King cannot make Judges whom he will by his absolute Power , he must be tied to that Law Deut. 1. 13. To take wise men & understanding & known : Neither can he make them dura ite beneplacito : for if these qualifications remain , there is no allowance given for their removal . They are Gods & the Children of the Mos● High , appointed to defend the poor & fatherless , as well as he , Psal. 82. 3 , 6. They are ordained of God for the punishment of evil doers , in which they must not be resisted , as well as he Rom. 13. 1 , 2. by me ( saith the Lord ) rule ... all the Iudges of the earth Prov. 8. 16. To them we must be subject for Conscience sake , as being the Ministers of God for good ; they must be obeyed for the Lords sake , as well as the King ; though they are sent of him , yet they Judge not for man but for the Lord 2 Chron. 19. 6. hence they sit in his room , and are to act as if he were on the bench : the King cannot say , the Judgment is mine , because it is the Lords : neither can he limit their sentance ( as he might , if they were nothing but his deputies ) because the Judgment is not his : nor are their Consciences subordinate to him , but to the Lord immediatly ; otherwise if they were his deputies , depending on him ; then they could neither be admonished , nor condemned for unjust Judgment , because their sentence should neither be righteous nor unrighteous , but as the King makes it ; And all directions to them were capable of this exception , do not so or so except the King command yow , crush not the poor , oppress not the fatherless , except the King command yow : yea then they could not execute any Judgment , but with the Kings Licence , and so could not be rebuked for their not executing Judgment . Now all this is contrary to Scripture , which makes the sentence of the Judges undeclinable when just Deut. 17. 11. the Lords indignation is kindled , when He looks for Iudgment & behold oppression , for righteousness & behold a Cry Isai. 5. 7. neither will it excuse the Judges to say , the king would have it so ; for even they that are subservient , to write grievousness , to turn aside the needy from Iudgment &c. are under the wo , as well as they that prescribe it Isai. 10. 1 , 2. The Lord is displeased when Iudgment is turned away back ward , and Justice stands a far of — and when there is no Iudgment , what ever be the Cause of it Isai. 59. 14 , 15. The Lord threatens He will be avenged on the Nation , when a man is not found to execute Iudgment Ier. 5. 1 , 9. And promises if they will execute Judgment & righteousness , and deliver the spoiled out of the hand of the oppressor , He will give them righteous Magistrats Ier. 22. 3 , 4. but if they do not , He will send desolation ibid. He rebukes those that turn Judgment to wormwood and leave of righteousness in the earth Amos. 5. 7. He resents it when the Law is slacked and Judgment doth not go forth freely without overawing or overruling restraint Habb . 1. 4. Can these Scriptures consist with the Judges dependence on the kings pleasure , in the exercise & execution of their Power ? Therefore if they would avoid the Lords displeasure , they are to give Judgment , though the King should countermand it . Secondly , that the King is not excepted from their Judgment , is also evident from the General Commands Gen. 9. 6. whoso sheddeth mans blood ●y man shall his blood be shed : there is no exception of Kings or Dukes here , and we must not distinguish where the Law distinguisheth not . Numb . 35. 30 , 31. whoso killeth any person the murderer shall be put to death , by the mouth of witnesses — ye shall take no satisfaction for the life of a Murderer which is guilty of death , but he shall be surely put to death . What should hinder then Justice to be awarded upon a Murdering King ? Shall it be for want of witnesses ? It will be easy to adduce thousands : Or shall this be satisfaction for his life , that he is a Crowned King ? the Law saith there shall no satisfaction be taken . The Lord speaketh to under Judges Levit. 19. 15. Ye shall do no unrighteousness in judgment , thow shalt not respect the person of the poor , nor honour the person of the Mighty . If Kings be not among the Mighty , how shall they be classed ? Deut. 1. 17. Ye shall not respect persons in judgment , but yow shall hear the small as well as the great , yow shall not be afraid of the face of man , for the judgment is Gods : if then no mans face can outdare the Law & Judgment of God , then the Kings Majestick face must not do it , but as to the demerit of blood he must be subject as well as another . It s no Argument to say , the Sanhedrin did not punish David for his Murther & Adulterie . Ergo now it is not Lawful to punish a King for the same : a reason a non facto is not relevant . David did not punish Ioab for his Murder , but Authorized it , as also he did Bathsheba's Adulterie ; will that prove that Murders connived at , or commanded by the King , shall not be punished ? or that Whores of State are not to be called to an account ? Neither will it prove that a Murdering king should not be punished , that David was not punished : because he got both the sin pardoned , and his life granted from the Lord , saying to him , by the mouth of the Prophet Nathan , Thow shalt not die : But as for the demerit of that fact , he himself pronounced the sentence out of his oun mouth 2 Sam. 12. 15. As the Lord liveth , the man that hath done this thing shall surely die . So every king condemned by the Law , is condemned by his oun mouth ; for the Law is the voice of the king : why then do we so much weary our selves concerning a Judge ? seeing we have the kings oun Confession , that is the Law. Buchanan . de jure regni . And there needs be no other difficultie , to find a Tribunal for a Murdering king , than to find one for a Murderer ; for a Judgment must acknowledge but one name , to wit of the Crime ; if a king then be guilty of Murder , he hath no more the name of a king but of a Murderer , when brought to Judgment ; for he is not Judged for his kingship , but for his Murther ; as when a Gentleman is Judged for Robbery , he is not hanged , neither is he spared , because he is a Gentleman , but because he is a Robber . See Buchanan . ubi supra . 6. If the Peoples Representatives be superior to the king in Judgment , and may execute Judgment without him , and against his will , then they may also seek account of him , for if he hath no Power but from them , and no Power without them to act as king ( no more than the eye or hand hath Power to act without the body ) then his Power must be inferior , fiduciary , & accountable to them : But the former is true , The Peoples Representatives are superior to the king in Judgment , and may execute Judgment without him , and against his will. In Scripture we find the Power of the Elders and heads of the People was very great , and in many cases superior to the king : which the Learned Dr Owen demonstrates in his Preliminary Exercitations on the Epist. to the Heb. and proves out of the Rabbins , that the kings of the Iewes might have been called to an account , & punished for transgressing of the Law. But in the Scripture we find . ( 1 ) They had a Power of Judgment with the Supreme Magistrate , in matters of Religion , Justice & Government . Hamor & Shechem would not make a Covenant with Iacobs Sons , without the consent of the men of the Citie Gen. 34. 20. David behoved to consult with the Captains of thousands , & every Leader , if it seemed good to them to bring again the Ark of God. 1. Chron. 13. 1 , 2 , 3. So also Solomon could not do it without them 1 King. 8. 1. Ahab could not make peace with Benhadad against the consent of the People 1 King. 20. 8. The men of Ephraim complain that Iephthah ▪ the Supreme Magistrate , had gone to War against the Children of Ammon without them , and threatened to burn his house with fire , which he only excuses by the Law of necessity Iudg. 12. 1 , 2 , 3. The Seventy Elders are appointed by God , not to be the Advisers only & helpers of Moses , but to bear a part of the burden of ruling & governing the People , that Moses might be eased Numb . 11. 14 , 17. Moses upon his sole pleasure had not power to restrain them , in the exercise of Judgment given of God. They were not the Magistrats depending deputies , but in the act of Judging they were independent , and their Consciences as immediatly subjected to God as the Superior Magistrate , who was to adde his approbative suffrage to their actings , but not his directive nor imperative suffrage of absolute pleasure , but only according to the Law ; he might command them to do their duty , but he could do nothing without them . ( 2 ) They had Power , not derived from the Prince at all , even a Power of life & death . The rebellious Son was to be brought to the Elders of the Citie , who had Power to stone him Deut. 21. 18 , 24. They had Power to punish Adulterie with death Deut. 22. 21. They had Power to cognosce , whom to admit into and whom to seclude from the Cities of refuge : So that if the King had commanded to take the life of an innocent man , they were not to deliver him Iosh. 20. per tot . But besides the Elders of Cities , there were the Elders and heads of the People , who had judicial Power to cognosce on all Criminal Matters , even when Ioshua was Judge in Israel we find they assumed this Power , to judge of that matter of the two tribes & the half Iosh. 22. 30. And they had Power to make Kings , as Saul & David , as was shewed : and it must needs follow , they had Power to unmake them in case of Tyranny . ( 3 ) They had Power to conveen , even without the indiction of the Ruler , as in that Iosh. 22. they convene without him : and without advice or knowledge of Samuel , the Ruler , they conveen to ask a King 1 Sam. 8. And without any head or superior , they convene & make David King , notwithstanding of Isbosheths hereditary right . Without & against Tyrannous Athaliah her consent , they convene & make Ioash King , and cared not for her Treason , Treason 2 King. 11. But now the king alone challenges the Prerogative-power of calling & dessolving Parliaments as he pleases , and condemns all meetings of Estates without his warrant , which is purely Tyrannical : for in cases of necessity , by the very Law of nature , they may & must convene . The Power is given to the king only by a positive Law , for orders sake ; but otherwise , they have an intrinsical Power to assemble themselves . All the forecited Commands , Admonitions , & Certifications , to execute Iudgement , must necessarly involve & imply & Power to convene , without which they could not be in a Capacity for it : Not only unjust Judgement , but no I●dgement , in a time when Truth is fallen in the streets & equity cannot enter , is charged as the sin of the State ; therefore they must convene to prevent this sin , and the wrath of God for it : God hath committed the keeping of the Common-wealth , not to the king only , but also to the peoples Representatives & heads . And if the king have Power to break up all Conventions of this nature , then he hath Power to hinder Judgement to proceed , which the Lord Commands : And this would be an excuse , when God threatens vengeance for it , we could not execute Iudgement , because ehe King forbad us . Yet many of these forementioned reproofs , threatenings , & certifications were given , in the time of Tyrannous & Idolatrous kings , who no doubt would inhibite & discharge the doing of their duty ; yet we see , that was no excuse , but the Lord denounces wrath for the omission . ( 4 ) They had Power to execute Judgement , against the will of the Prince . Samuel killed Agag against Sauls will , but according to the Command of God 1 Sam. 15. 32. Against Ahabs will & mind Elijah caused kill the Priests of Baal , according to Gods express Law 1 King. 18. 40. It is true it was extraordinary , but no otherwise than it is this day , when there is no Magistrate that will execute the Judgment of the Lord ; then they who have Power to make the Magistrate may & ought to execute it , when wicked men make the Law of God of none effect . So the Princes of Iudah had power , against the kings will , to put Ieremiah to death , which the king supposes , when he directs him what to say to them Ier. 38. 25. They had really such a Power , though in Ieremiahs case it would have been wickedly perverted , See Lex Rex Q. 19. 20. ( 5 ) They had a power to execute Judgement upon the king himself : as in the case of Amaziah & Uzziah , as shall be cleared afterwards . I conclude with repeating the Argument : If the king be accountable , whensoever this Account shall be taken , we are confident our disouning him for the present will be justified , and all will be obliged to imitate it : If he be not , then we cannot oune his Authority , that so presumptously exalts himself above the People . 10. If we will further consider the nature of Magistracy ; it will appear what Authority can conscienciously be ouned , to wit , that which is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Potestas , not 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Potentia ; Authorized Power , not Might or force ; Moral Power , not merely Natural . There is a great difference betwixt these two : Natural Power is common to brutes , Moral Power is peculiar to men ; Narural Power is more in the Subjects , because they have more strength & force ; Moral Power is in the Magistrate , they can never meet adequately in the same subject ; Natural power can , Moral only may warrantably exercise rule ; Natural power is opposed to impotency & weakness , Moral to illicitness or unlawfulness ; Natural power consists in strength , Moral in righteousness ; Natural power may be in a Reut of Rogues making an uproar , Moral only in the Rulers ; they cannot be distinguished by their acts , but by the Principle from which the acts proceed ; in the one from meer force , in the other from Authority . The Principle of Natural power is its oun might & will , and the end only self ; Moral hath its rise from positive Constitution , and its end publick safety . The strength of Natural power lies in the Sword , whereby its might gives Law ; the strength of Moral power is in its Word , whereby reason gives Law , unto which the Sword is added for punishment of Contraveners : Natural power takes the Sword Math. 26. 52. Moral bears the Sword Rom. 13. 4. In Natural power the Sword is the Cause ; in Moral it is only the Consequent of Authority : In Natural power the Sword legitimates the Scepter ; in Moral the Scepter legitimates the Sword : The Sword of the Natural is only backed with Metal , the Sword of the Moral power is backed with Gods warrant : Natural power involves men in passive subjection , as a traveller is made to yeeld to a Robber ; Moral power reduces to Consciencious subordination . Hence the power that is only Natural not Moral , Potentia not Potestas , cannot be ouned : But the power of Tyrants & Usurpers is only Natural not Moral , Potentia not Potestas : Ergo it cannot be ouned . The Major cannot be denied ; for it is only the Moral Power that is ordained of God , unto which we must be subject for Conscience sake . The Minor also ; for the Power of Tyrants is not Moral , because not Authorized nor warranted nor ordained of God by His preceptive Ordinance , and therefore no Lawful Magistratical Power . For the clearer understanding of this let it be observed , there are four things required to the making of a Moral or Lawful Power ; the matter of it must be Lawful , the Person Lawful , the Title Lawful , and the Use Lawful . 1. The matter of it , about which it is exerted , or the work to be done by it , must be Lawful & warranted by God ; and if it be unlawful , it destroyes its Moral being . As the Popes power in dispensing with Divine Laws , is null & no Moral Power : And so also the Kings power , in dispensing with both Divine & humane Laws is null . Hence , that power which is in regard of matter unlawful , and never warranted by God , cannot be ouned : But absolute power , which is the power of Tyrants & Usurpers ( & particularly of this of ours ) is in regard of matter unlawful & never warranted by God : Ergo — 2. The Person holding the power must be such as not only is capable of but competent to the tenure of it , and to whom the holding of it is allowed ; and if it be prohibited , it evacuates the Morality of the power . Korah & his Company arrogated to themselves the Office of the Priesthood , this power was prohibited to them , their power then was a nullity . As therefore a person that should not be a Minister , when he usurps that office is no Minister : So a person that should not be a Magistrate , when he usurps that Office , is no Magistrate . Hence , a person that is incapable & incompetent for Government , cannot be ouned for a Governour : But the D. of Y. is such a person , not only not qualified as the Word of God requires a Magistrate to be , but by the Laws of the Land declared incapable of Rule because he is a Papist , a Murderer , an Adulterer &c. 3. There must be in Moral Power , a Lawful Title & Investure , as is shewed above ; which if it be wanting , the Power is null , and the person but a Scenical King , like Iohn . of Leyden . This is essentially necessary to the being of a Magistrate ; which only properly distinguishes him from a private man : for when a person becomes a Magistrate , what is the change that is wrought in him ? what new habit or endewment is produced in him ? he hath no more natural power than he had before , only now he hath the Moral Power , right , & Authority to Rule , Legally impowering him to Govern. Let it be Considered , what makes a subordinate Magistrate , whom we may oune as such : It must be only his Commission from a Superior Power , otherwise we reject him : If one come to us of his oun head , taking upon him the style & office of a Bailif , Sheriff , or Judge , and command our Persons , demand our purses , or exact our Oaths ; we think we may deny him , not taking our selves to owe him any subjection , not ouning any bond of conscience to him ; why ? because he hath no lawful Commission . Now if we require this qualification in the subordinate , why not in the Supreme ? Hence , that Magistrate that cannot produce his Legal Investure , cannot be ouned : But the D. of Y. cannot produce his Legal Investure , his admission to the Crown upon Oath & Compact , and with the consent of the subjects , according to the Laws of the Land , as is shewed above : Ergo — 4. There must also be the Lawful Use of the Power ; which must be not only legal for its composure , but right for its practice ; its Course & Process in Government must be just , Governing according to Law , otherwise it is meer Tyranny : for what is Government , but the subjecting of the Community to the rule of Governours , for Peace & Orders sake , and the security of all their precious Interests ? and for what end was it ordained , and continued among men , but that the stronger may not domineer over the weaker ? And what is Anarchy , but the playing the Rex of the Natural power over the Moral ? Hence , that Power which is contrary to Law , evil & Tyrannical , can tye none to subjection : But the power of the King , abused to the destruction of Laws , Religion & Liberties , giving his power & strength unto the beast , & making war with the Lamb Revel . 17. 13 , 14. is a power contrary to Law , evil & Tyrannical : Ergo it can tye none to subjection : wickedness by no imaginable reason can oblige any man. It is Objected by some from Rom. 13. 1. There is no power but of God : The Usurping power is a power : Therefore it is of God , and consequently we owe subjection to it Ans. 1. The Original reading is not Universal , but thus 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 for there is no power if not from God : which confirms what I plead for , that we are not to oune any Authority , if it be not Authorized by God. The words are only relative to higher powers , in a restricted sense , and at most are but indefinite , to be determined according to the matter ; not all power simply , but all Lawful power . 2. It is a fallacia a dicto secundum quid : There is no power but of God , that is no Moral Power , as Universal negatives use to be understood , Heb. 5. 4. no man taketh this honour unto himself , but he that is called of God ; which is clear , must not be understood for the negation of the fact , as if no man at all doth or ever did take unto himself that honour , for Korah did it &c. but , no man taketh it warrantably , with a Moral right and Gods allowance , without Gods call : So also the universal imperative , in that same Text , must not be taken absolutely without restriction ; for if every soul without exception were to be subject , there could be none left to be the higher powers ; but it is understood with restriction to the relation of a subject . So here no Power but of God , to be understood with restriction to the relation of a Lawful Magistrate . It it also to be understood indiscriminately , in reference to the diverse species , sorts , & degrees of Lawful Power , Supreme & subordinate , whether to the King as Supreme , or to Governours &c. as Peter expresses it : Or whether they be Christian or Pagan : It cannot be meant of all universally , that may pretend to power , and may attain to prevailing Potency ; for then by this Text , we must subject our selves to the Papacy now intended to be introduced ; and indeed if we subject our selves to this Papist , the next thing he will require will be that . 3. To the Minor proposition , I Answer . The usurping power is a power : It is Potentia , I grant ; that it is Potestas , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or Authority , I deny . Therefore it is of God , by His Providence , I concede ; by His Ordinance ; I deny . Consequently we owe subjection to it , I deny . We may be subject passively , I grant ; Actively , out of conscience I deny . But some will Object . 2. Though the Power be Usurped , and so not Morally Lawful , in all these respects ; yet it may do good , its Laws & administrations may be good . Ans. I grant , all is good that ends well and hath a good begining . That cannot be good which hath a bad principle , bonum ex integra causa . Some Government for constitution good , may in some acts be bad ; but a Government for constitution bad , cannot for the acts it puts forth be good . These good acts may be good for matter , but formally they are not good , as done by the Usurper : They may be comparatively good , that is better so then worse ; but they cannot be absolutely , and in a Moral sense good : for to make a Politick action good , not only the matter must be warrantable , but the Call also . It may indeed induce subjects to bear & improve to the best , what cannot be remedied ; but cannot oblige to oune a Magistratical Relation . II. The Nature of the power thus discovered , lets us see the Nature of that relative duty , which we owe & must oune as due to Magistrates , and what sort of ouning we must give them ; which to inquire a litle into , will give light to the question . All the duty & deference the Lord requires of us , towards them whom we must oune as Magistrates , is comprehended in these two expressions , honour required in the fifth Command , and subjection required in Rom. 13. 1. &c. 1 Pet. 2. 13. &c. Whomsoever then we oune as Magistrates , we must oune honour & subjection as due to them : And if so be we cannot upon a consciencious ground give them honour & subjection , we cannot oune them as Magistrates . The least deference we can pay to Magistrates is subjection , as it is required in these words ; Let every soul be subject to the higher Powers , and submit your selves to every Ordinance of man for the Lords sake . But this cannot be given to Tyrants & Usurpers : Ergo no deference can be paid to them at all , and consequently they cannot be ouned . That this subjection , which is required to the higher Powers , cannot be ouned to Tyrants , will be apparent , if we consider . 1. The Subjection required is orderly subjection to an orderly power , that we be regularly under him that is regularly above : But Usurpation & Tyranny is not an Orderly Power , orderly placed above us : Therefore we cannot be ordely under it . This is gathered from the Original Language , where the powers to be subjected to are 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , ordained of God , and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the Ordinance of God , and he that resisteth the Power is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , Counter-ordered , or contrary to his orderly duty : So the duty is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 be subject . They are all words coming from one root , which signifies to Order : So that subjection is to be placed in order under another relative to an Orderly Superiority : But to occupy the seat of dignity unauthorized , is an Ataxie , a breaking of order , and bringing the Common-wealth quite out of order . Whereby it may appear , that in relation to an Arbitrary Government , there can be properly no 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , no orderly subjection . 2. The thing it self must import that relative duty which the fifth Command requires ; not only a passive stooping endurance , or a ●eigned Counterfeit submission , but a real Active duty including obedience to Lawful Commands ; and not only so , but support & maintinance ; and that both to the acts of his administration , and to his standing & keeping his station , assisting him with all our abilities , both humane & Christian ; And not only as to the external acts of duties , but the inward motions of the heart , as consent , Love , Reverence , & Honour , and all sincere fealty & Allegiance . But can a subjection of this extent , be payed to a Tyrant or Usurper ? Can we support those we are bound to suppress ? Shall we love the ungodly , and help those that hate the Lord ? Can we consent , that we & our posterity should be slaves ? Can we honour them who are vile , and the vilest of men , how high soever they be exalted ? 3. The ground of this subjection is for conscience sake , not for wrath , that is , so far & so long as one is constrained by fear , & to avoid a greater evil , to stoop to him , but out of conscience of duty , both that of Piety to God who ordained Magistracy , and that of equity to him who is His Minister for good , and under pain of damnation if we break this orderly subjection Rom. 13. 2 , 5. But can it be imagined that all this is due to a Tyrant & Usurper ? Can it be out of conscience , because he is the Lords Minister for good ? the contrary is clear , that he is the Devils drudge serving his Interest ; Is resistance to Tyrants a damnable sin ? I hope to prove it to be a duty . 4. If subjection to Tyrants & Usurpers will inveigle us in their snares , and involve us in their sin & judgment , then it is not to be ouned to them : But the former is true : Therefore the Latter . In the foregoing head I drew an Argument , for withdrawing from & disouning the Prelatick Ministers , from the hazard of partaking in their sin , and of being obnoxious to their judgment , because people are often punished for their Pastors sins ; Aaron & his sons polluting themselves , would have brought wrath upon all the people , L●v. 10. 6. because the Teachers had transgressed against the Lord , therefore was Iacob given to the Curse & Israel to reproaches Isai ▪ 43. 27 , 28. and all these Miseries Lamented by the Church were inflicted for the sins of her Prophets and the iniquites of her Priests , Lam. 4. 13. the reason was , because they ouned them , followed them , countenanced them , complyed with them , or connived at them , or did not hinder or else disoune them . The same Argument will evince , the necessity of withdrawing our subjection from & disouning Usurping & Tyrannical Rulers , when we cannot hinder their wickedness , nor give any other Testimony against them , to avert the wrath of the Lord. If the defections of Ministers will bring on the whole Nation desolating judgments ; then much more have we reason to fear it , when both Magistrates & Ministers are involved in , and jointly carrying on , and carressing & encouraging each other in promoting , a woful Apostasie from God : when the heads of the house of Iacob , & Princes of the house of Israeel , abhor judgement & pervert all equity , the heads Judge for reward , and the Priests teach for hire , and the Prophets divine for money , and yet lean upon the Lord and say , Is not the Lord among us ? none evil can come upon us : Then we can expect nothing but that Zion for their sake shall be plowed as a field & Ierusalem become heaps and the Mountain of the house as the high places of the forest , Mich. 3. 9 , 11 , 12. Certain it is that subjects have smarted sore for the sins of their Rulers : for Sauls sin in breaking Covenant with the Gibeonites , the Land suffered three years famine 2 Sam. 21. 1. and the wrath of the Lord could not be appeased , till seven of his sons were hanged up unto the Lord. What then shall appease the wrath of God , for the unp●ralelled breach of Covenant with God in our day ? For Davids sin of numbering the people , 70000 men died by the Pestilence . 2 Sam. 24. 5. For Ieroboams sin of Idolatry , who made Israel to sin , the Lord threatens to give Israel up because of the sins of Ieroboam 1 King. 14. 16. only they escaped this Judgment , who withdrew themselves and fell into Iudah . For Ahabs sin of letting go a man whom the Lord had appointed to utter destruction , the Lord threatens him , thy life shall go for his life , and thy people for his people 1 King. 20. 42. Because Manasseh King of Iudah did many abominations , therefore the Lord threatened to bring such evil upon Ierusalem & Iudah that whosoever heard it his ears should tingle &c. 2 King. 21. 11 , 12. and not withstanding of his repentance , and the Reformation in the dayes of Iosiah , notwithstanding the Lord turned not from the fierceness of His great wrath , wherewith His anger was kindled against Iudah , because of all the provocations that Manasseh had provoked Him withall 2 King. 23. 26. which was accomplished by the hands of the Chaldeans , in Iehojakims time . Surely at the Commandment of the Lord came this upon Iudah , to remove them out of His sight , for the sins of Manasseh according to all that he did , and also for the innocent blood which he shed ... which the Lord would not pardon 2 King. 24. 3 , 4. And Ieremiah further threatens , that they should be removed into all Kingdoms of the earth , because of Manasseh for that which he did in Ierusalem Ier. 15. 4. Certainly these passages were recorded for our Learning Rom. 15. 4. and for our examples , to the intent we should not do as they did 1 Cor. 10. 6. and for our admonition vers . 11. Whence we may be admonished , that it is not enough to keep our selves free of publick sins of Rulers ; Many of those then punished , were free of all actual accession to them ; but they became accessory to and involved in the guilt of them , when they did not endeavour to hinder them , and bring them to condign punishment for them , according to the Law of God which respecteth not persons ; or at least , because they did not revolt from them , as Libnah did : There might be other provocations on the peoples part , no doubt , which the Lord did also punish by these Judgments ; ●ut when the Lord specifies the sin of Rulers , as the particular procuring Cause of the Judgment , it were presumption to make it the Occasion only of the Lords punishing them : for plain it is , if these sins of Rulers had not been committed , which was the ground of the threatening & execution , the Judgment would have been prevented ; And if people had bestirred themselves as became them , in repressing & restraining such wickedness , they had not so smarted ; And when that sin so threatened & punished was removed , then the Judgment it self was removed or deferred . It is just & necessary , that the subjects being Jointly included with their Rulers in the same bond of fidelity to God , be lyable to be punished for their Rebellion & Apostasie , when they continue under the bond of subjection to them . But how deplorable were our Condition , if we shold stand obnoxions to divine Judgments , for the Atheisme , Idolatry , Murders , & Adulteries of our Rulers , and yet be neither Authorized nor Capacitated to hinder it , nor permitted to withdraw our selves from subjection to them ? But it is not so ; for , the Lords making us responsable for their debt , is an impowering us either to repress their wickedness when He gives us Capacity , or at least to save our selves harmless from their Crimes , by disouning them ; that being the only way of standing no longer accountable for their faults . 12. It remains to Consider the Ends , for which Government was institute by God , and constitute by men : from whence I Argue , That Government that destroyes the Ends of Government , is not to be ouned : But Tyranny , and especially this under which we houl , destroyes all the Ends of Government : Ergo it is not to be ouned . The Minor I prove thus . That Government that destroyes Religion & Safety , destroyes all the Ends of Government : But this Popish & arbitrary Absolute power , destroyes Religion & Safety : Ergo — It is evident both from the Laws of Nature & Revelation , that the Ends of Government are the Glory of God , & the good of Mankind . The first is the Glory of God , the ultimate end of all Ordinances ; to which whatever is opposite , is not to be ouned by them that fear Him : whatever power then is destructive to Religion , and is applyed & imployed against the Glory of the Uuniversal King , and for withdrawing us from our fealtie & obedience to Him , is nothing but Rebellion against the Supreme Lord & Lawgiver , and a Traiterous Conspiracy against the Almighty ; and therefore not to be ouned : And they are enemies to Religion , or strangers to it , who are not sensible this hath been the design of the present Government , at least these 27 years , to overturn the Reformed Covenanted Religion , and to introduce Popery . Hence , seeing a King at his best & highest elevation is only a mean for preserving Religion , and for this end only chosen of the people to be Custos utriusque tabulae , keeper of both Tables of the Law , he is not to be regarded but wholly laid aside , when he not only moves without his sphere , but his motion infers the ruine of the ends of his erection , and when he imployes all his power for the destruction of the Cause of Christ , and advancement of Antichrists , giving his power to the beast ; he is so far from deserving the deference of the power ordained of God , that he is to be looked upon & treated as a Traitor to God , and Stated enemy to Religion & all Righteousness , The Second End of Government is the good of the people , which is the Supreme & Cardinal Law ; Salus Populi est Suprema Lex . Which cannot be denied , if it be considered . 1. For this only the Magistrate is appointed of God to be His Minister , for the peoples good Rom. 13. 4. and they have no goodness but as they conduce to this end ; for all the power they have of God is with this Proviso , to promote His peoples prosperity . ( It were blasphemy to say , they are His Authorized Ministers for their destruction ) to which if their Conduct degenerate , they degrade themselves , and so must be disouned . He is therefore ; in his institution , no more than a mean for this end ; and himself cannot be either the whole or half of the end , for then he should be both the end & the mean of Government ; and it is contrary to Gods mould to have this for his end , to multiply to himself silver & gold , or lift up himself above his brethren Deut. 17. 17 , 20. if therefore he hath any other end than the good of the people , he cannot be ouned as one of Gods moulding . 2. This only is the highest pitch of good Princes ambition , to postpone their oun safety to the peoples safety . Moses desired , rather than the people should be destroyed , that his name should be razed out of the Book of life . And David would rather the Lords hand be on him & his fathers house , than on the people that they should be plagued 1 Chron. 21. 17. but he that would seek his oun ambitious ends with the destruction of the people , hath the spirit of the Devil , and is to be carried towards as one possessed with that malignant spirit . 3. Originally their power is from the people , from whom all their dignity is derived ; with reserve of their safety , which is not the donative of Kings , nor held by concession from them , nor can it be resigned or surrendered to the disposal of Kings ; since God hath provided , in His universal Laws , that no Authority make any disposal , but for the good of the people . This cannot be forfeited by the usurpation of Monarchs , but being alwise fixed in the essential Laws of Government , they may reclaim & recover it when they please . Since then we cannot alienate our safety , we cannot oune that Authority which is inconsistent with it . 4. The attaining this end was the main ground & motive , of peoples deliberating to constitute a Goverment ; and to choose such a forme , because they thought it most conducible for their good ; and to admit such persons as fittest Instruments for compassing this end ; and to establish such a Conveyance , as they thought most contributive for this end : When therefore Princes cease to be what they could be constitute for , they cease to have an Authority to be ouned ; but ceasing to answer these ends of Government , they cease to be what they could be constitute for . 5. For no other end were Magistrates limited with Conditions , but to bound them that they might do nothing against the peoples good & safety : Whosoever then breaking through all legal limitations , shall became injurious to the Community , lists himself in the number of enemies , and is only to be looked upon as such . 6. For this end all Laws are ratified or rescinded , as they conduce to this end , which is the soul & reason of the Law : then it is but reason , that the Law establishing such a King , which proves an enemy to this , should be rescinded also . 7. Contrary to this end no Law can be of force ; if then either Law or King be prejudicial to the Realme , they are to be abolished . 8. For this end , in cases of necessity Kings are allowed sometimes to neglect the Letter of the Laws , or private Interests , for the safety of the Community ; but if they neglect the publick safety , and make Laws for their oun Interests , they are no more Trustees but Traitors . 9. If it were not for this end , it were more eligible to live in deserts than to enter into Societies : When therefore a Ruler , in direct opposition to the ends of Government , seeks the ruine not only of Religion , but also of the peoples safety , he must certainly forfeit his right to reign . And what a vast as well as innocent number , have , for Religion and their adherence to their fundamental rights , been ruined , rooted out of their families & Possessions , oppressed , persecuted , Murdered , & destroyed by this and the deceased Tyrant , all Scotland can tell and all Europe hath heard . If ever the ends of Government were perverted & subverted in any place , Britain is the stage where this Tragedy hath been acted . 13. I may argue from the Covenant , that to oune this Authority is contrary to all the Articles thereof . 1. That Authority which overturns the Reformation of Religion in Doctrine , Worship , Discipline , & Government , which we are sworn to preserve against the Common Enemies thereof , in the first Art. cannot be ouned : But the present pretended Authority overturned ( and continues more to overturn ) the Reformation of Religion &c. Ergo it cannot be ouned : for against what common enemy must we preserve it , if not against him that is the chief Enemy thereof ? and how can we oune that Authority , that is wholly employed & applied for the destruction of Religion ? 2. If we are obliged to exstirpate Poperie , without respect of persons , lest we partake in other mens sins ; then we are obliged to exstirpate Papists without respect of persons , and consequently the head of them . ( For how otherwise can Poperie be exstirpated ? or how otherwise can we cleanse the Land of their sins ? ) But in the 2d Art. we are obliged to exstirpate Poperie without respect of persons , lest we partake in other mens sins : Ergo we are obliged to exstirpate Papists without respect of Persons and consequently the Crowned Iesuite , and therefore cannot oune him ; for how can we oune him , whom we are bound to exstirpate ? 3. If we be engaged to preserve the Rights & Liberties of Parliaments , and the Liberties of the Kingdoms , and the Kings Authority only in the preservation & defence of the true Religion & Liberties of the Kingdoms ; then we cannot oune his Authority , when it is inconsistent with , opposite to , & destructive of all these precious Interests , as now it is with a witness : But in the 3. Art. we are engaged to preserve the Rights & Priviledges of Parliaments , & the Liberties of the Kingdoms , and the Kings Authority only in the preservation & defence of the true Religion & Liberties of the Kingdoms : Ergo. All allegiance that we can oune to any man , must stand perpetually thus qualified , in defence of Religion & Liberty ; that is , so far as it is not contrary to Religion & Liberty , and no further , for if it be destructive of these , it is null . If we should then oune this man , with this restricted allegiance , and apply it to his Authority ( as we must apply it to all Authority that we can oune ) it were to mock God & the world , and oune Contradictions : for can we maintain the Destroyer of Religion , in defence of Religion ? And the Destroyer of all our rights & Liberties , and all our legal securities for them , in the preservation of these rights & Liberties ? that were pure Non-sense . 4. If we be obliged to endeavour , that all Incendiaries & Malignants &c. be brought to condign punishment , then we cannot oune the Authority of the head of these Incendiaries & malignant Enemies : But in the 4. Art we are obliged to endeavour that all Incendiaries & Malignants &c. be brought to Condign Punishment : Ergo — The Connexion of the Major cannot well be doubted : for is it imaginable , that the head of that unhallowed Party , the Great malignant Enemy who is the spring & gives life unto all these Abominations , shall be exempted from punishment ? or ouned for a Sacred Majestie ? shall we be obliged to discover , and bring to Justice , the litle petty Malignants , and this implacably stated Enemy to Christ escape with a Crown on his head ? Nay , we are by this obliged , if ever we be in case , to bring these stated Enemies to God & the Country to condign punishment , from the highest to the Lowest : And this we are to do , as we would have the anger of the Lord turned away from us , which cannot be without hanging up their heads before the Lord against the sun , as was done in the matter of Peor Numb . 25. 4. For hath not he & his Complices made the Kingdom a Curse ? and we with our oun consent have made our selves obnoxious to it , if we do not procure , each in our Capacities , and pursue these Traitors & Rebells , that the Judgment of the Lord be executed upon the accursed . 5. No wilful o●poser of Peace & union between the Kingdoms is to be ouned ; but according to the 5. Art. we are obliged to ende●vour that Justice be done upon him : But this man & his brother have been wilful opposers of Peace & union between the Kingdoms , all true Peace & union , except an union in Confederacy against the Lord ; for they have taken Peace from both the Kingdoms , and destroyed & annulled that which was the bond of their union , viz. the Solemn League & Covenant . 6. If we are obliged to assist & defend all those that enter into this League & Covenant , in the maintaining & pursuing thereof , and never to suffer our selves to be divided , to make defection to the contrary part &c. According to the 6 Art. Then we must not oun the Butcher of our Covenanted Brethren , who hath imbrued ●is hands in their blood , in the maintaining & pursuing thereof , and would have us withdrawn into so detestable a defection ; for we cannot both oune him as he requires to be ouned , and as God requires every Magistrate to be ouned ( so as not to resist him under pain of damnation Rom. 13. 2 ) and assist our Brethren too in resisting his Murders ; and our ouning of him were a dividing of our selves from our Brethren that oppose him , into a defection to the Contrary part , whereof he is head & Patron . Lastly in the Conclusion , we are obliged to be humbled for the sins of these Kingdoms , and to amend in a real Reformation : Whereof this is one to be mourned for , that after the Lord had delivered us from the yoke of this Tyrannical family , we again joined in affinity with the people of these abominations , and tooke these serpents into our bosome again which hath bit us so sore , and where-with the Lord hath scourged us severely . And if it was our sin to engage with them at first , then it is our sin to continue under their subjection : And is not consistent with that Repentance , that the Lords Contendings call for , to continue ouning that Power which was our sin to oune at first . III. In the Third place , I promised to confirme my Thesis from more express Scripture Arguments . Therefore I shall endeavour to gather them as briefly as may be 1. from Scripture Inferences , nearly & natively Consequential . 2. from Scripture Assertions . 3. from Scripture Precepts . 4. from Scripture Practices . 5. from Scripture Promises . 6. from Scripture Threatenings . 7. from Scripture Prayers . First , I shall offer some Arguments deduced by way of immediate Inference , from the grounds laid before us in Scripture about Government : wherein I shall confine my self to these Particulars . 1. Let us Consider the Characters of a Magistrate , laid doun in Scripture ; and we may infer , if Tyrants & Usurpers are not Capable of these Characters , then they cannot be ouned for Magistrates . For if they be not Magistrates , they cannot be ouned as Magistrats : but if they be not capable of the Characters of Magistrates , they are not Magistrates : Ergo if they be not capable of the Characters of Magistrates , they cannot be ouned as Magistrates . To find out the Characters of Magistrats , I need seek no further than than full place Rom. 13. Which usually , is made a Magazine of Objections against this Truth ; but I trust to find store of Arguments for it from thence , not repeating many that have been already deduced therfrom . We find in this place many Characters of a Magistrate , that are all incompatible with a Tyrant or Usurper . 1. He is the higher power vers 1. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Authorities Supereminent , signifying such a Precellency as draweth towards it a recognition of honour : But this is not Competent to Tyrants & Usurpers ; for they are the vilest of men ▪ let them be never so high exalted , Psal. 12. ult . and if they be vile then they are to be contemned Psal. 15. 4. and no more to be regarded then Herod was by Christ , when he called him a Fox Luk. 13. 32. But more particularly let us consider what is the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , highness , or dignity of Magistrats , set forth in Scripture . They are stiled Gods not to be reviled Exod. 22. 28. among whom God Judgeth Psal. 82. 1. so called because the Word of God came unto them Iohn 10. 35. But Tyrants are rather Devils , as one of them is called Lucifer Isai. 14. 12. and they that persecute & imprison the People of God , because acted by the Devil , and acting for him , do bear his name Revel . 2. 10. They are Divels that cast the Lords witnesses into prison . The Magistrats Judgement is Gods Iudgement Deut. 1. 17. because it is not for man but for the Lord 2 Chron. 19. 6. and therefore Solomon is said to have sat on the Throne of the Lord 1 Chron. 29. 23. But it were blasphemy to say , that Tyrants Judgement , usurping the place without His warrant , and giving forth Judgement against His Laws & Cause & People , is the Lords Judgement , or for Him , or that they sit on the Throne of the Lord. A Throne of iniquity is not the Throne of the Lord , for He hath no fellowship with it ; The Tyrants Throne is a Throne of iniquity , Psal. 94. 20. Magistrats are truly to be subjected to & obeyed , as Principalities & Powers Tit. 3. 1. it is a sin to speak evil of them , vers . 2. for it is presumption to despise Dominion & speak evil of Dignities 2 Pet. 2. 10. Iude. 8. Bu● Tyrants are very Catechrestically & abusively Principalities & Powers , no otherwise then the Devils are so termed Eph. 6. 12. and there is no argument to oune or obey the one more than the other : for if all Principalities & Powers are to be subjected to & ouned , then also the Devil must , who get the same Title . To speak Truth of Tyrants indignities , cannot be a speaking evil of Dignities ; for Truth is no evil , nor is Tyranny a Dignity . Hence they that are not capable of the Dignity of Rulers , are not to be oune● as such : But Tyrants are not capable of the Dignity of Rulers , as these places prove : Ergo — Against this it is Objected , that Paul did apply this Character to the Tyrannical High Priest Ananias , whom , after he had objurgated for mani●est injustice , he honours with that Apologie , that he wist not that he was the high Priest , for it is written , thow shalt not speak evil of the ruler of thy people Act. 23. 5. Ans. Though all should be granted that is in this Objection ▪ yet our Argument would not be enervated : for grant we should not speak evil of Tyrants , that does not evince that we should hold them as Rulers ; for we should bless our persecuters , Rom. 10. 14. and speak evil of no man Tit. 3. 2. that does not say , we should hold every man , or our persecuters , to be Rulers . The meaning must be , he knew not that he was the high Priest , that is , he did not acknowledge him to be either high Priest or Ruler , he could acknowledge or observe nothing like one of that Character in him : for as the high Priests Office was now null & ceased , so this Ananias was only an usurper of the Office , in place of Ismael or Ioseph , who had purchased it by money : And Paul had learned from his Master Gamaliel , Iudicem , qui honoris consequendi causâ pecunias dederit , revera neque Iudicem esse , neque honorandum , sed Asini habendum Loco . Tit. Talmud . de Synedrio . That a Judge who hath given money for purchasing this honour , is neither a Judge , nor to be honoured as such , but to be held in place of an Ass. And it was common among the Jewes to say , if such be gods , they are silver gods not to be honoured , as is quoted by Pool Synopsis Criticorum &c. in locum . And that this must be the sense of it is plain ; for he could not be ignorant that he was there in place of a Judge , being called before him , and smitten by him Authoritatively , whom therefore he did threaten with the judgment of God ; it were wicked to think , that he would retract that threatening which he pronunced by the Spirit of God. And therefore this place confirms my Thesis : If a Tyrannical Judge , acting contrary to Law , is not to be known or acknowledged to be a Ruler , but upbraided as a whited wall ; Then a Tyrant is not to be known or acknowledged as such : But the former is true , from this place : Therefore also the latter . Paul knew well enough he was a Judge , and knew well enough what was his duty to a Judge , that he should not be reviled ; but he would not acknowledge this Priest to be a Judge , or retract his threatening against him . 2. He is of God & ordained of God : I proved before , Tyrants are not capable of this ; yea it were blasphemy to say , they are Authorized or Ordained of God , by His Preceptive Will. Hence take only this Argument . All Rulers that we must oune are ordained of God , do reign & are set up by God Prov. 8. 15. ( for that & this place are paralell ) But Tyrants do not reign nor are set up by God Hos. 8. 4. They are set up ( saith the Lord ) but not by me : Ergo we cannot oune them to be ordained of God. 3. Whosoever resisteth this power ordained of God resisteth the Ordinance of God , and they that resist shall receive to themselves damnation vers . 2. This cannot be ouned of a Tyrant , that it is a damnable sin to resist him , for it is duty to resist & also repress him , as is proven already , and shall be afterwards . Hence , whatsoever Authority we oune subjection to we must not resist it : But we cannot oune that we must not resist this Authority : therefore we cannot oun it at all . Again , That cannot be the power not to be resisted , which is acquired & improved by resisting the Ordinance of God : But the power of Usurpers & Tyrants is acquired & improved by resisting the ordinance of God : Ergo their power cannot be the power not to be resisted . The Major is manifest : for when the Apostle sayes , the resisting of the power bring damnation to the resister , certainly that resistance cannot purchase Dominion instead of damnation : And if he that resists in a lesser degree , be under the doom of damnation : then certainly he that does it in a greater degree , so as to complete it , in puting himself in place of that power which he resisted , cannot be free . The Minor is also undenyable ; for , if Usurpers acquire their power without resistence forcible & sensible , it is because they that defend the power invaded are wanting in their duty ; but however Morally the Tyrant or Usurper is alwayes 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or in contrary order to a Lawful Power . 4. Rulers are not a terror to good works but to the evil , and they that doe that which is good shall have praise of the same vers . 3. This is the Character & duty of righteous Magistrates , though it be not alwayes their Administration : But an Usurper & Tyrant is not capable or susceptible of this Character , but on the contrary is & must be a terror to good works and a praise to the evil : for , he must be a Terror to them that would secure their rights & Liberties in opposition to his encroachments , which is a good work ; & he must be a fautor , Patron , & Protector of such , as encourage & maintain him in his Usurpation & Tyranny , which is an evil work : And if he were a terror to the evil , then he would be a terror to himself & all his Complices , which he cannot be . Therefore , that power which is not capable of the duties of Magistrates , cannot be ouned : But the Power of Tyrants & Usurpers is such : Ergo — We find in Scripture , the best Commentare on this Character , where the duties of a Magistrate are described . They must justify the righteous & condemn the wicked Deut. 27. 1. They must , as Iob did , deliver the poor that cry and put on righteousness as a cloathing — and be eyes to the blind & feet to the lame , and a Father to the poor — and break the Jawes of the the wicked Iob 29. 12-17 . Their Throne must be established by righteousness Prov. 16. 12. a King sitting on the Throne of Judgement must scatter away all evil with his eyes — then Mercy & Truth will preserve him and his Throne is upholden by Mercy Prov. 20. 8 , 28. But Tyrants have a quite contrary Character : The Throne of iniquity frames Mischief by a Law , and condemns the innocent blood Psal. 94. 20. 21. They judge not the fatherless , neither doeth the cause of the widow come unto them Isai. 1. 23. They build their house by unrighteousness , & their chambers by wrong , and use their neighbours service without wages Ier. 22. 13. They oppress the poor & crush the needy Amos 4. 1. They turn judgement to Gall & the fruit of righteousness to hemlock , and say , have we not taken horns to as by our oun strength Amos 6. 12 , 13. These contrary Characters cannot consist together . 5. He is the Minister of God for good vers . 4. not by Providential Commission , as Nebuchadnezzar was , and Tyrants may be eventually , by the Lord making all things turn about for the good of the Church ; but he hath a Moral Commission from God , & is entrusted by the people to procure their Publick & Politick good at least . Now this , and Tyranny & Usurpation , are together inconsistible : for if Tyrants & Usurpers were Ministers for good , then they would restore the publick & personal Rights , and rectify all wrongs done by them ; but then they must surrender their Authority , and resign it , or else all rights cannot be restored , nor wrongs rectified . Hence , these that cannot be ouned as Ministers of God for good , cannot be ouned as Magistrates : But Tyrants & Usurpers , ( and in particular this Man ) are such as cannot be ouned as Ministers of God for good : Ergo — Again , If Magistracy be alwise a blessing , and Tyranny & Usurpation alwise a Curse , then they cannot be ouned to be the same thing , and the one cannot be ouned to be the other : But Magistracy or the right-ful Magistrate , is alwise a blessing ; Tyranny & Usurpation or the Tyrant & Usurper , alwise a curse : Ergo — That the former is true , these Scriptures prove it . God provides him for the benefite of His people 1 Sam. 16. 1. a just Ruler is compared to the light of the morning , when the sun riseth , even a morning without Clouds 2 Sam. 23. 4. So the Lord exalted Davids Kingdom , for His people Israels sake 2 Sam. 5. 12. because the Lord Loved Israel for ever , therefore made He Solomon King to do judgement & Justice 1 King. 10. 9. when the righteous are in Authority the people rejoice — the King by Judgement stabilisheth the Land — Prov. 29. 2 , 4. The Lord promises Magistrates as a special blessing Isai. 1. 26. Ier. 17. 25. and therefore their continuance is to be praye● for , that we may lead a quiet & peaceable life in all godlyness & honesty 1 Tim. 2. 2. And they must needs be a blessing , because to have no Ruler is a Miserie ; for when Israel had no King every man did that which was right in his oun eyes Iudg. 17. 6. and the Lord threatens it ar a Curse to take away the stay & the staff — the mighty man and the man of war , the Iudge & the Prophet &c. Isai. 3. 1 , 2 &c. and that the Children of Israel shall abide many dayes without a King , and without a Prince Hos. 2. 4. But on the other hand Tyrants & Usurpers are alwayes a Curse , and given as such : It is threatened among the Curses of the Covenant , that the stranger shall get up above Israel very high — and that they shall serve their enemies which the Lord shall send against them — and He shall put a yoke of iron upon their neck , until He hath destroyed them Deut. 28. 43 , 48. As a roaring lyon and a ranging bear so is a wicked Ruler over the poor people Prov. 28. 15. and therefore , when the wicked beareth rule the people mourn Prov. 29. 2. The Lord threatens it as a Curse , that he will give Children to be their Princes , and babes shall rule over them Isai. 3. 4. and if unqualified Rulers be a curse , much more Tyrants . They are the rod of His anger , and the staff in their hand is His indignation , His axe & saw & rod Isai. 10. 5 , 15. It is one thing to call a man Gods instrument , His rod , axe , sword , or hammer ; another thing to call him Gods Minister : there is a wide difference betwixt the instruments of Gods Providence , and the Ministers of His Ordinance ; those fulfill His Purposes only , these do His precepts . Such Kings are given in the Lords anger Hos. 13. 11. therefore they cannot be ouned to be Ministers of God for good . 6. He beareth not the sword in vain for he is the Minister of God , a revenger to execute wrath upon ●im that doeth evil vers . 4. The Apostle doth not say , he that beareth the sword is the Ruler , but he is the Ruler that beareth the sword . This is not every sword ; for there is the sword of an enemy , the sword of a robber , the sword of a common traveller , but this as a faculty of Political rule & Authoritative judgement . It is not said , he takes the sword ( as the Lord expresses the Usurpation of that power , Math. 26. 52. ) but he beareth the sword , hath it delivered him into his hand by God , by Gods warrant & allowance , not in vain ; to no end or without reason , or without a Commission , as Pareus upon the place expones it . He is a revenger to execute wrath , not by private revenge , for that is condemned Paulo ante Rom. 12. 19. not by providential recompense , for when a private person so revengeth , it is the providential repayment of God ; but as Gods M●nister , by Him Authorized , commissionated , & warranted to this work . Now this cannot agree with a Tyrant or Usurper , whose sword only legitimates his scepter , and not his scepter his sword , who takes the sword rather then bears it , & uses it without reason or warrant from God , in the execution of his lustful rage upon him that doth well , and hath no right to it from God. Hence , he that beareth the sword no other way but as it may be said of a Murderer , cannot be a Magistrate bearing the sword : But a Tyrant & Usurper beareth the sword no other way but as it may be said of a Murderer : Ergo — So much for the Characters of a Magistrate , which are every way inapplicable to Tyrants & Usurpers , and as inapplicable to this of ours as to any in the world . 2. If we consider the Scripture Resemblance● importing the duty of Magistrates , and the Contrary Comparisons holding forth the sin , vileness & villany of Tyrants & Usurpers ; we may infer , that we cannot oune the last to be the first . First , from the benefite they bring to the Common wealth , Magistrates are styled . 1. Saviours ▪ as Othniel the son of Kenaz is called Iudg. 3. 9. and Ieho●haz in his younger years 2. King. 13. 5. and all good Judges & Magistrates Neh. 9. 27. But Tyrants & Usurpers cannot be such , for they are destroyers whom the Lord promises to make go forth from His people Isa. 49. 17. The Chaldea● Tyrant is called the destroyer of the Gentiles Ier. 4. 7. and the destroyer of the Lords heritage Ier. 50. 11. wherefore they can no more be ouned to be Magistrates , than Abaddon or Apollyon can be ouned to be a Saviour . 2. From their Pater●al love to the people , they are styled fathers ▪ and therefore to be honoured according to the fifth Command . So Deborah was raised up a Mother in Israel Iudg. 5. 7. Kings are nursing fathers by office Isai. 49. 23. But that Tyrants cannot be such I have proved already ; for they can no more be accounted fathers , than he that abuseth or forceth our mother . 3. From the Protection & shelter that people find under their Conduct , they are called Shields Psal. 47. Ult. The Princes of the people , the Shields of the earth , belong unto God. But Tyrants cannot be such , because they are the subverters of the earth . 4. From the Comfort that attends them , they are resembled to the morning light & fruitful shours of rain 2 Sam. 23. 4. They waited for me as for the rain , saith Iob. 29. 23. But Tyrants cannot be resembled to these , but rather to darkness , and to the blast of the terrible ones Isai. 25. 4. as a storm against the wall , If darkness cannot be ouned to be light , then cannot Tyrants be ouned to be Magistrats . 5. From their Pastoral Care & Conduct and duty , they are feeders . The Judges of Israel are commanded to feed the Lords people 1 Chron. 17. 6. David was brought to feed Jacob His people , and Israel His Inheritance Psal. 78. 71. But Tyrants are wolves not Shepherds . 6. By office they are physicians or healers Isai. 3. 7. That Tyrants cannot be such is proven above . Secondly on the other hand , the vileness , villany , & violence of Tyrants & Usurpers , are held forth by fit resemblances , being Compared to these unclean creatures . 1. Tyrants are wicked Dogs , as they who compass about Christ Psal. 22. 16 , 20. Saul is called Dog there , and in that Golden Psalm Psal. 59. 4. Saul & his Complices , watching the house to kill David , make a noyse like a dog & go round about the City . 2. They are pushing Bulls Psal. 22. 12. and crushing Kain of Bashan , that oppress the poor Amos. 4. 1. they have need then to have their horns cut s●ort . 3. They are roaring Lyons . that are wicked Rulers over the poor People Prov. 28. 15. Zeph. 3. 3. So Paul calls Nero the Lyon , out of whose mouth he was delivered . 2 Tim. 4. 17. 4. They are ranging bears Prov. 28. 15. So the Persian Monarch is emblemized Dan. 7. 5 ▪ 5. They are Leviathan the peercing Serpent & Dragon Isai. 27. 1. and have great affinity in name & Nature with the Apocalyptick Dragon : So also Isai. 51. 9. the Egyptian Tyrant is called Dragon . And Nebuchadnezzar swallowed up the Church like a Dragon Ier. 51 , 34. See also Ezek. 29. 3. 6. They are wolves ravening the prey Ezek. 22. 27. evening wolves that gnaw not the bones till the morrow Zeph. 3. 3. 7. They are Leopards : So the Grecian Tyrants is called Dan. 7. 6. and Antichrist Revel . 13. 2. 8. They are foxes : So Christ calls Herod Luk. 13. 32. 9. They are Devils who cast the Lords people into Prison Revel . 2. 10 , 13. Now can we oune all these abommable Creatures to be Magistrates ? Can these be the fathers we are bound to honour in the fifth Commandment ? They must be esteemed sons of dogs & Devils that belive so , and oune themselves sones of such fathers . If we further take notice , how the Spirit of God describes Tyranny , as altogether Contradistinct & opposite unto the Magistracy He will have ouned ; we may infer hence Tyrants & Usurpers are not to be ouned . What the Government instituted by God among His people was , the Scripture doth both relate in matter of ●act , and describes what it ought to be de jure , viz. That according to the Institution of God , magistrates should be established by the Constitution of the people , who were to make them Iudges & Officers in all their gates , that they might Iudge the people with just Iudgment Deut. 16. 18. But foreseeing that people would affect a change of that first forme of Government , and in imitation of their neighbouring Nations would desire a King , and say , I will set a King over me like all the Nations that are about me Deut. 17. 14. The Lord , intending high & holy ends by it , chiefly the procreation of the Messias from a Kingly race , did permit the change , and gave directions how he should be moulded & bounded , that was to be ouned as the Magistrate under a Monarchial forme : To wit , that he should be chosen of God , and set up by their suffrages , that he should be a brother and not a stranger , that he should not multiply horses , nor wives , nor money ( which are Cautions all calculated for the peoples good , and the security of their Religion & Liberty , and for precluding & preventing his degeneration into Tyranny ) and that he should write a Copy of the Law in a book . according to which he should Govern vers . 15. ad ●in . cap. yet the Lord did not approve the change of the form , which that luxuriant people was long affecting , and at length obtained . For long before Saul was made King , they profered an Hereditary Monarchy to Gideon , without the boundaries Gods Law required ; Which that brave Captain , knowing how derogatory it was to the Authority of Gods Institution , not to be altered in form or frame without His order , generously refused , faying , I will not rule over yow , neither shall my son rule over yow , the Lord shall rule over yow Iud. 8. 23. But his bastard , the first Monarch & Tyrant of Israel , Abimelech , by sinstrous means being advanced to be King by the traiterous Schechemites , Iotham and other of the Godly disouned him : which , by the Spirit of God , Iotham describes Parabolically , significantly ho●ding out the Nature of that Tyrannical usurpation , under the Apologue of the trees itching after a King , and the offer being repudiate by the more generous sort , embraced by the bramble : Signifying that men of worth & virtue would never have taken upon them such an arrogant Domination , and that such a Tyrannicall Government in its Nature & tendency was nothing but an useless , worthless , sapless , aspiring , scratching , & vexing shadow of a Government , under subjection to which there could be no peace nor safety . But this was rather a Tumultuary interruption than a Change of the Government , not being universally either desired or ouned ; therefore after that the Lord restored the pristine form : Which continued until , being much perverted by Samuels sons , the people unanimously & peremptorly desired the change thereof , and whether it were reason or not would have a King ; as we were fondly set upon one , after we had been delivered from his fathers yoke : And the Lord gave them a King with a Curse , and tooke him away with a vengeance , Hos. 13. 11. as He did our Charles the Second . Yet He permited it , but with a Protestation against and conviction of the sin , that thereby they had rejected the Lord 1 Sam. 8. 7. and with a demonstration from Heaven , which extorted their oun confession , that they bad added unto all their sins this evil to ask a King 1 Sam. 12. 17 , 18 , 19. And to deter & disswad from such a Conclusion , He appoints the Prophet to shew them the manner of the King that should reign over them 1 Sam. 8. 9. to declare before hand , what sort of a Ruler he woud prove , when they got him ; to wit , a meer Tyrant , who would take their sons and appoint them for himself , for his Chariots , and for horsemen , and to run before his Chariots , and make them his sowldiers , and labourers of the ground , and Instrument-makers , and houshold servants , and he would take their fields & vineyards — the best of them , and give unto his servants , in a word to make all slaves ; and that in the end when this should come to pass , they should cry out because of their King , but the Lord would not hear them vers . 11-18 , All which , as it is palpable in it self , so we have sensibly felt in our experience to be the Natural description of Tyranny , but more tollerable than an account of ours would amount to . It is both foolishly & falsely alledged , by Royalists or Tyrannists , that here is a grant of incontroulable absoluteness to Kings to Tyrannise over the people without resistence , And that this manner of the King is in the Original Mishphat , which signifies right or Law , So that here was a permissive Law given to Kings to Tyrannise , and to oblige people to passive obedience , without any remedy but tears , And therefore it was registered & laid up before the Lord in a book 1 Sam 10. 25. But I answer . 1. If any thing be here granted to Kings , it is either by Gods Approbation , directing & instructing how they should govern ; or it is only by permission & providential Commission to them , to be a plague to the people for their sin of choosing them , to make them drink as they have brewed , as sometimes He gave a Charge to the Assyrian rod to trample them doun as the mire of the streets : If the first be said , Then a King that does not govern after that manner , and so does not make people cry out for their oppression , would came short of his duty , and all behoved to Tyrannize and make the people cry out ; then a King may take what He will from his subjects , and be approved of God : this were blasphemously absurd , for God cannot approve of the sin of oppression . If the Second be said , then it cannot be an universal Grant , or otherwise all Kings must be ordained for plagnes ; And if so , it were better we wanted such nursing fathers . 2. Though Mishphat signifies right or Law , yet it signifies also , and perhaps no less frequently , Manner , Course , or Custome : And here it cannot signify the Law of God , for all these Acts of Tyranny are contrary to the Law of God ; for to make Servants of subjects is contrary to the Law of God Deut. 17. 20. forbidding to lift up himself so far above his brethren , but this was to deal with them as a proud Pharaoh ; to take so many for Chariots & horsemen , is also contrary to the Law Deut. 17. 15. he shall not multiply horses : to take their fields & vineyards , is meer Robbery , contrary to the Moral & Judicial Law , whereof he was to have alwise a Copy vers . 18. And contrary to Ezek. 46. 18. The Prince shall not take of the peoples inheritance &c. This would justify Ahabs taking Naboths vineyard , which yet the Lord accounted Robberie , and for which Tyrants are called Companions of Thieves Isai. 1. 23. & Robbers Isai. 42. 24. into whose hands the Lord somtimes may give His people for a spoyl in Judicial providence , but never with His Approbation & grant of right : to make them cry out , ●s oppression , which the Lord abhors Isai. 5. 7 , 8. And if this be all the remedy , it is none ; for it is such a Cry , as the Lord threatens He will not hear . 3. It is false that this manner of the King was registered in that Book mentioned 1 Sam. 10. 25. for that was the Law of the Kingdom , accordingly the Copy of which the King was to have for his instruction , containing the fundamental Laws , point blank contrary to this which was the manner of the King : There is a great difference between the Manner of the Kingdom , what ought to be observed as Law , and the Manner of the King what he would have as lust . Would Samuel write in a Book the rules of Tyranny , to teach to oppress , contrary to the Law of God ? He sayes himself he would only teach both King & people the good & the right way , Sam. 12. 23 , 25. 4. Nothing can be more plain , than that this was a meer disswasive against seeking a King ; for he protests against this Course , and then layes before them what sort of King he should be , in a description of many acts of Tyranny , and yet in end its said vers . 19. Nevertheless the people refused to obey the voice of Samuel , and said , Nay but we will have a King. Now what else was the voice of Samuel , than a disswasion ? I am not here levelling this Argument against Monarchy in the abstract , that does not lie in my road . But I infer from hence . 1. If God was displeased with this people for asking & ouning a King , who was only Tyrannus in fieri , and disswades from the choise by a description of his future Tyranny ; Then Certainly He was displeased with them when they continued ouning him , when a Tyrant in facto esse , according to that description : But the former is true , Therefore also the latter . The Consequence is clear ; for Continuing in sin is sin ; but continuing in ouning that Tyrant which was their sin at first , was a continuing in sin : Ergo — The Minor is confirmed thus : Continuing in counteracting the Motives of Gods disswasion , especially when they are sensibly visible , is a Continuing in sin : But their Continuing in ouning Saul after he became a Tyrant , was a Continuing in counteracting the Motives of Gods disswasion , when they were sensibly visible . I do not say , because it was their sin to ask Soul , therefore it was not Lawful to oune him , while he ruled as a Magistrate ; And so if Charles the second had ruled righteously , it would not have been sin to oune him : but after the Lord uses disswasives from a choise of such a one , and these are signally verified , if it was sin to make the choise , then it must be sin to keep it . 2. If it was their sin to seek & set up such a one before he was Tyrant , who yet was admitted upon Covenant terms , and the manner of it registered ; Then much more is it a sin to seek & set up one , after he declared himself a Tyrant , and to admit him without any terms at all , or for any to consent or give their suffrage to such a deed : But the former is true : Therefore the latter : and Consequently , to give our consent to the erection of the D. of Y. by ouning his Authority , were our sin . 3. If it be a sin to oune the manner of the King there described , then it is a sin to oune the present pretended Authority , which is the exact transumpt of it : But it is a sin to oune the manner of the King there described , or else it would never have been used as a disswasive from seeking such a King. 4. To bring our selves under such a burden which the Lord will not remove , and involve our selves under such a miserie wherein the Lord will not hear us , is certainly a sin vers . 18. But to oune or chuse such a King , whose manner is there described , would bring our selves under such a burden & miserie , wherein the Lord would not hear us : Ergo it were our sin . 4. We may adde the necessary Qualifications of Magistrates , which the Lord requires to be in all , both Superior & Inferior : And thence it may be inserred , that such pretended Rulers who neither have nor can have these Qualifications are not to be ouned as Magistrates , no more than such are to be ouned as Ministers who have no qualifications for such a function . We find their essentially necessary qualifications particularly described . Iethros Counsel was Gods Counsel & Command ; That Rulers must be able men , such as fear God , men of Truth , hating Covetousness Exod. 18. 21. Tyrants & Usurpers have none nor can have any of these qualifications , except that they may have ability of force , which is not here meant ; but that they be Morally able for the discharge of their duty : Surely they cannot fear God ; nor be men of Truth , for then they would not be Tyrants . It is Gods direction , that the man to be advanced & assumed to Rule , must be a man in whom is the Spirit Numb . 27. 18. as is said of Ioshua : what Spirit this was , Deut. 34. 9. explains , He was full of the Spirit of Wisdom , that is , the Spirit of Government ; not the Spirit of infernal or Iesuitical Policy , which Tyrants may have , but they cannot have the true Regal Spirit , but such a Spirit as Saul had when he turned Tyrant , an evil Spirit from the Lord. Moses saith : they must be wise men & understanding and known among the tribes , Deut. 1. 13. for if they be Children or fools , they are plagues & punishments Isai. 3. 2 , 3 , 4. &c. not Magistrates , who are alwise blessings . And they must be known men of intergrity , not known to be knaves or fools , as all Tyrants are alwayes . The Law of the King is , Deut , 17. 15. he must be one of the Lords choosing . Can Tyrants & Usurpers be such ? No they are set up , but not by Him Hos. 8. 4. he must be a brother & not a stranger , that is , of the same Nation and of the same Religion : for though infidelity does not make void a Magistrates Authority , yet both by the Law of God & man , he ought not to be chosen who is an enemy to Religion & Liberty : Now it were almost treason , to call the Tyrant a brother ; and I am sure it is no reason , for he disdains it , being absolute above all . That good Kings Testament confirms this , the God of Israel said , the Rock of Israel spake , he that ruleth over men must be just , ruling in the fear of God 2 Sam. 23. 3. But Tyrants & Usurpers cannot be just ; for if they should render every one their right , they would keep none to themselves , but behoved to resign their Robberies in the first place , and then also they must give the Law its course , and that against themselves . These Scriptures indeed do not prove , that all Magistrates are in all their Administrations so qualified , nor that none ought to be ouned but such as are so qualified in all respects . But as they demonstrate what they ought to be , so they prove that they cannot be Magistrates of Gods ordaining who have none of these qualifications : But Tyrants & Usurpers have none of these qualifications . Much more do they prove that they cannot be ouned to be Magistrats , who are not capable of any of these qualifications : But Usurpers are not capable of any of these qualifications . At least they conclude , in so far as they are not so qualfied , they ought not to be ouned but disouned : But Tyrants & Usurpers are not so qualified in any thing : therefore in any thing they are not to be ouned but disouned : for in nothing they are so qualified as the Lord prescribes . Secondly , I shall offer some reasons from Scripture Assertions . 1. It is strongly Asserted in Elihu's speech to Iob , that he that hateth right should not govern . Where he is charging Iob with blasphemie , in accusing God of injustice ; of which he vindicates the Almighty , in Asserting His Soveraignity & Absolute Dominion , which is inconsistent with injustice : and shewes both that if He be Soveraign He cannot be unjust , and if He be unjust He could not be Soveraign : which were horrid Blasphemy to deny . And in the demonstration of this , he gives one Maxime in a question , which is equivalent to an universal negative Iob. 34. 17 , 18. Shall even he that hateth right govern ? and wilt thow condemn him that is most just ? Is it fit to say to a King , thow art wicked ? and to Princes , ye are ungodly ? In which Words , the Scope makes it clear , that if Iob made God a hater of right , he should then deny His Government ; and if he took upon him to condemn Him of injustice , he should blasphemously deny Him to be King of the World. For it is not fit to say to any King , that he is wicked , or so ungodly as to be a hater of right ; for that were treason , Lese-Majestie , and in effect a denying him to be King : much less is it fit to say to Him that is King of Kings . Here then it is affirmed , & supposed to hold good of all Governours , that he that hateth right should not govern , or bind , as it is in the Margent ; for ●abash signifies both to bind and to Govern , but all to one sense , for Governours only can bind subjects Authoritatively , with the bonds of Laws & Punishments . I know the following Words are alledged , to favour the incontroulableness & absoluteness of Princes , that it is not fit to say to them , they are wicked . But plain it is , the words do import treason against Lawful Kings , whom to call haters of right were to call their Kingship in question ; as the Scope shewes , in that these words are adduced to Justify the Soveraignity of God by His Justice , and to confute any indirect charging Him with injustice because that would derogate from His Kingly Glory , it being impossible He could be King & unjust too . So in some Analogy , though every act of injustice do not unking a Prince ; yet to call him wicked , that is habitually unjust , and a hater of Justice , were as much as to say , he is no King , which were intollerable treason against Lawful Kings . But this is no treason against Tyrants : for Truth & Law can be no treason ; now this is the language of Truth & Law , that wicked Kings are wicked ; And they that are wicked & ungodly ought to be called so , as Samuel called Saul , and Elijah Ahab &c. However it will hold to be a true Maxime , whether we express it by way of Negation or Interrogation . Shall even he that hateth right Govern ? But are not Tyrants & Usurpers haters of right ? shall therefore they Govern ? I think it must be answered , they should not Govern. If then they should not Govern , I infer , they should not be ouned as Governours . For if it be their sin to Govern ( right or wrong , it s all one case , for they should not Govern at all ) then it is our sin to oune them in their Government : for it is alwise a sin to oune a man in his sinning . 2. The Royal Prophet , or whoever was the Penman of that Appeal for Justice against Tyranny Psal. 94. 20. does tacitely Assert the same truth , in that Expostulation , shall the Throne of iniquity have fellowship with thee , that frameth mischief by a Law ? which is as much as if he had said , the Throne of iniquity shall not , no cannot have fellowship with God ; that is , it cannot be the Throne of God that He hath any Interest in , or Concern with , by way of approbation : He hath nothing to do with it , except it be to suffer it a while , till He take vengeance on it in the end . And shall we have fellowship with that Throne , that God hath no fellowship with , and that is not His Throne but the Devils , as it must be , if God doth not oune it ? Much may be argued from hence , but in a word : A Throne which is not of God nor ordained of God , but rather of the Devil , cannot be ouned ( for that is the reason of our subjection to any power , because it is of God and ordained of God Rom. 13. 1. And that is the great dignity of Magistracy , that its Throne is the Throne of God 1 Chron. 29. 23. ) But a Throne of Tyrannie & usurpation is a Throne which is not of God , nor ordained of God , but rather of the Devil : Ergo — the Minor is proved : A Throne of iniquity &c. is a Throne which is not of God , nor ordained of God , but rather of the Devil : But a Throne of Tyranny & usurpation is a Throne of iniquity : Ergo it is not of God & so not to be ouned . 3. The Lord charges it upon Israel as a transgression of His Covenant , & trespass against His Law , that they had set up Kings & not by Him and had made Princes and He knew it not Hos. 8. 4. and then taxes them with Idolatry , which ordinarly is the Consequent of it , as we have reason to fear will be in our case . He shewes there the Apostasie of that people , in changing both the Ordinances of the Magistracy and of the Ministry , both of the Kingdom & of the priest-hood , in which two the safety of that people was founded : So they overturned all the order of God , and openly declared they would not be governed by the hand of God , as Calvin upon the place expounds it . Whereas the Lord had commanded , if they would set up Kings they should set none up but whom He choosed Deut. 17. 15. yet they had no regard to this , nor consulted Him in their admission of Kings , but set them up and never let Him to wit of it , without His knowledge , that is , without consulting Him , and without His approbation , for it can have no other sense . I know it is alledged by several Interpreters , that here is meant the tribes secession from the house of David , and their setting up Ieroboam . I shall confess that the ten tribes did sin in that erection of Ieroboam , without respect to the Counsel or Command of God , without waiting on the vocation of God , as to the time & manner , and without Covenanting with him for security for their Religion & Liberty : But that their secession from Davids line , which by no precept or promise of God they were astricted to , but only conditionally , if his Children should walk in the wayes of God , Or that their erecting of Ieroboam was materially their sin , I must deny ; and assert , that if Ieroboam had not turned Tyrant & Apostate from God ( for which they should have rejected him afterwards and returned to the good Kings of Davids line ) he would have been as Lawful a King as any in Iudah , for he got the Kingdom from the Lord the same way , and upon the same terms that David did , as may be seen expressly in 1 King. 11. 38. It must be therefore meant , either generally of all Tyrants whom they would set up without the Lords mind , as at first they would have Kings on any terms , though they should prove Tyrants , as we have seen in Sauls case . Or particularly Omri whom they set up , but not by the Lord 1 King. 16. 16. And Abab his Son , And Shallum , Menahem , Pekah &c. who were all set up by blood & treacherie , the same way that our Popish Duke is now set up , but not by the Lord , that is by His approbation . Hence I argue , those Kings that are not ouned of God , nor set up by Him , must not be ouned by us ( for we can oune none for Kings but those that reign by Him Prov. 8. 15. and are ordained of Him Rom. 13. 1. ) But Tyrants & Usurpers are not ouned of God as Kings , nor are set up by Him : Ergo — Again if it be a sin to set up Kings and not by God , then it is a sin to oune them when set up : for , that is a partaking of & continuing in the sin of that erection , and hath as much affinity with it , as resetting hath with thieft ; for if they be the thieves , they are the ressetters who receive them & oune them . 4. The Prophet Habakkuk , in his Complaint to God of the Chaldean Tyranny , Asserts that God hath made the righteous , as the Fishes of the Sea , as the Creeping things , that have no Ruler over them , Habak . 1. 14. Now how were they said to be without a Ruler , when the Chaldean actually commanded & absolutely ruled over them ? yea how can the Fishes & Reptiles have no Ruler over them ? If Domineering be ruling , they want not that ; when the weaker are over-mastered by the stronger , and by them made either to be subject : ar to become their prey . But the meaning is , these Creatures have no Ruler over them by order of nature : And the Iewes had then no Ruler over them by order of Law , or ordination from God , or any that was properly their Magistrate by Divine Institution , or humane orderly constitution . We see then it is one thing for a people to have an arbitrary or enthra●ing Tyranny , another to have true Magistracy or Authority to be ouned over them , without which Kingdoms are but as Mountains of prey , and Seas of Confusion . Hence I argue , If the Iewes , having the Chaldean Monarch tyrannising over them , had really no Ruler over them , then is a Tyrant & Usurper not to be ouned for a Ruler : But the former is true : therefore also the Latter . 5 , Our Saviour Christ delivers this as a Commonly received & a true Maxime , Iohn . 8. 54. He that honoureth himself his honour is nothing . The Iewes had objected that He had only made himself Messias , vers . 53. To whom He answers by way of concession , if it were so indeed then His Claims were void , If I honour my self my honour is nothing : And then claims an indubitable title to His dignity , It is my Father that honoureth me . Here is a two fold honour distinguished , the one real the other suppositious & null , the one renounced the other ouned by Christ , Self-honour & honour which is from God. Hence I argue , A self created dignity is not to be ouned : the Authority of Tyrants & Usurpers is a self created dignity : Ergo — this was confirmed above . Thirdly I shall offer some other considerations confirming this truth , from those Scriptures which I class among precepts . And these I find of diverse sorts touching this subject . 1. I shew before that the greatest of men , even Kings , are not exempted from punishment and Capital punishment , if guilty of Capital Crimes : for where the Law distinguisheth not , we ought not to distinguish . There is one special & very peremptory Law , given before the Law for regulating Kings , which by that posterior Law was neither abrogated nor limited even as to Kings , Deut. 13. 6-9 . If thy Brother ( and a King must be a Brother Deut. 17. 15. ) — entice the secretly saying let us go & serve other Gods — Thow shalt not consent unto him nor hearken unto him neither shall thine eye pity him . How famous Mr Knox improved this Argument , is shewed in the third Period . That which I take notice of here is only , that Kings are not excepted from this Law , but if they be open Intycers to Idolatry , by force or fraud , Persecution or Tolleration , as this Idolater now reigning is palpably doing , they are obnoxious to a legal animadversion . As it cannot be supposed , that Secret Intycers should be lyable to punishment , and not open Avouchers of a desire & design to pervert all the Nation to Idolatry : that a private perverter of one man , though never so nearly & dearly related , should be pursued & brought to condign punishment , and a publick Subverter of whole Nations , and Introducer of a false & blasphemous Idolatrous Religion , should escape Scot-free . Let the punishment inflicted be in a Judicial way , and of what measures it pleases the Judge to determine , I shall not controvert here ; Only I plead , that Idolatrous Tyrants are not excepted from this Law : and infer , that if they ought to be punished they ought to be deposed ; And if they ought to be deposed , they cannot be ouned , when undenyably , guilty of this Capital Crime , as was urged above . To this I may adde that part of that Prophetical Kings Testament ; who being about to leave the world , under some Challenges of Mal-administration in his oun Government ( for which he took himself to the well ordered everlasting Covenant , for pardon & encouragment ) after he had shown what Rulers should be , he threatens , by Antithesis , Tyrannical●pretenders , in these severe words , which do also imply a precept , and a direction how to deal with them 2 Sam 23. 6 , 7. But they of Belial shall be all of them as thorns thrust away , because they cannot be taken with hands , but the man that shall touch them must be fenced with iron & the staff of a spear , and they shall be utterly burnt with fire in the same place . Let these words be understood as a threatening against all the wicked in general , who ars to bequenched as the fire of thorns ; or particularly of the Promoters of Antichrists Kingdom , in opposition to Christs , as some Interpreters judge ; it will not weaken but confirm my Argument , if Kings who are ringleaders of that gang be not excepted . I know some do understand this of Rebells against righteous Rulers : which though indeed it be a truth , that they that are such should be so served , and roughly handled with iron and the staff of a spear ; yet it is not so consonant to the scope & connexion of this place , shewing the Characters of righteous Rulers and of usurping Tyrants , making an opposition between Rulers that are just ruling in the fear of God , and those that are Rulers of Belial , promising blessings upon the Government of the one & contempt & Rejection to the other , and shewing how both should be carried towards : Neither does it aggree with the words themselves , where the supplement in our translation is redundant ; for it is not in the Hebrw , the sons of Belial , only They of Belial , clearly relative to the Rulers of whom he was speaking before . And indeed the word Belial , in its Etymology is not more applicable to any than to Tyrants ; for it comes from beli , non , and Hhall supra , because they will have none above them , or from beli non and Hhol jugum , because they cannot suffer a yoke , but cast away the yoke of Laws and the yoke of Christ , saying , let us burst His bands &c. Nor is it alwayes aggreeable to truth , to understand it only of Rebells against righteous Rulers , that they can never be taken with hands : For as very rarely righteous Rulers have any Rebells , to be the objects of their rigour & rage ; So when there are any , discreet & wise Rulers will find many wayes to take & touch them , and quash or quiet them . But it is alwise true of Tyrants , for they can never be taken with hands , neither in a friendly manner , taken by the hand and transacted with in any bargain as other men , for they that would do so will find them like pricking & jagging bryers , which a man cannot handle without hurt to himself ; Nor can they be any other way repressed or restrained or touched , but by hands fenced with iron , that is , with the sword of necessity , or ax of Justice . And this is insinuated as duty , so to endeavour to exstirpate & eradicate such thorns , as pester the Common-wealth : but if it cannot be done , it must be duty & wisdom both not to medle with them , nor oune them , no more than Iotham , who would not subject himself nor come under the shaddow of the bastard bramble . I confess it is commonly taken as a threatening of the Lords Judgement against these Sons of Belial : And so it is . But it teacheth also what men are called to , when they have to do with such , to wit , to take the same course with them as they would to clear the ground of thorns & bryars . And that it is restricted to the Lords immediate way of taking them off , is not credible : For , it can have no tollerable sense to say , they shall be thrust away because they cannot be taken with the Lords hands : Neither is there need , that He should be fenced with iron &c. And let iron &c. be taken tropically for the Lords sword of vengeance ; yet how can it be understood , that He must be fenced there with ? or that He will trust them away , as a man must be fenced against thorns ? What defence needs the Lord against Tyrants ? It is only then intelligible , that the Lord in His righteous Judgement will make use of men & legal means , and of those who cannot take them with hands , in His Judicial procedure against them . Hence I argue , If Tyrants are to be dealt with as thorns , that cannot be taken with hands , but to be thrust away by violence , Then , when we are not in case to thrust them away , we must let them alone , and not medle nor make with them , and so must not oune them , for we cannot oune them withount medling , and without being pricked to our hurt : But the former is true : Ergo — Of this same nature , another threatening confuting the pretence of Princes impunity , may be subjoined out of Psal. 82. 6 , 7. I have said ye are Gods , and all of yow are Children of the most High , but ye shall die like men & fall as one of the Princes . From which words , the learned Author of the History of the Douglasses , Mr David Hume of Gods craft , in his discourse upon Mr Craigs Sermon upon the words , doth strongly prove , that the Scope is to beat off all Kings , Princes , & Rulers , from the conceit of impunity for their Tyrannical Dominations ; that they must not think to Domineer and do what they list , and overturn the foundations or fundamental Laws of Kingdoms , because they are gods ; as if they were thereby incontrolable , and above all Law & punishment : no , they must know , that if they be guilty of the same transgressions of the Law , as other Capital offenders , they shall die like other men , & fall as Princes who have been formerly punished . It is not to be restricted to a threatening of Mortality ; for that is unavoidable , whether they Judge justly or unjustly , and the fear thereof usually hath litle efficacy to deter men from Crimes punishable by Law : Neither can it be understood only of the Lords immediate hand taking them away , exclusive of mens legal punishment ; for expresly they are threatened to die like Common men , and to be lyable to the like punishment with them : Now common men are not only lyabl to the Lords immediate Judgement , but also to mens punishment . Hence , if Tyrants and overturners of the foundations of the earth , must be punished as other men , then when they are such they cannot be looked upon as righteous Rulers , for righteous Rulers must not be punished : But the former is true : Ergo — According to these Scriptures , which either express or imply a precept to have no respect to Princes in Judgement when turning Criminalls , we find examples of the peoples punishing Amazia &c. which is recorded without a challenge , and likewise Athalia . 2. There is a Precept given to a humbled people , that have groaned long under the yoke of Tyranny & oppression , enjoining them , as a proof of their sincerity in humiliation , to bestir themselves in shaking off those evils they had procured by their sin . Isai. 58. 6. Is not this the fast that I have ch●sen , to loose the bands of wickedness , to undo the heavy burdens , and to let the oppressed go free , and that ye break every yoke ? which are all good works of Justice & Mercy , and more acceptable to God than high flown pretences of humiliation , under a stupid submission ; and hanging doun the head as a bulrush . We see it then a duty to relieve the oppressed , and to repress Tyranny , and break its yoke . If it be Objected ( 1 ) That these are Spiritual bonds & yokes , that are here commanded to be loosed & broken ; or if any external be meant , they are only the yokes of their exactions & usuries . For Ans. I grant , that it is the great duty of a people humbling themselves before the Lord , to break off their sins by righteousness and their iniquity by shewing mercy to the poor Dan. 4. 27. but that this is the only duty I deny ; or that this is the genuine & only sense of this place , cannot be proved , or approved by the Scope ; which is , to press them to those duties they omitted , whereby the poor oppressed people of God might be freed from the yokes of them that made them to houl , and to bring them to the conviction of those sins for which the Lord was contending with them , whereof this was one , that they exacted all their Labours , or things wherewith others were grieved ( as the Margent reads ) or suffered the poor to be oppressed . ( 2 ) If it be alledged , that this is the duty proper to Rulers to relieve the oppressed &c. I Answer , It is so ; but not peculiar to them : yet most commonly they are the oppressors themselves , and cast out the poor , which others must take in to their houses . But the duty here is pressed upon all the people , whose sins are here cryed out against ( vers . 1. ) upon all who professed the service of God , & asked the ordinances of Justice ( vers . 2 ) upon all who were fasting & humbling themselves , and complained they had no success ( vers . 3. ) the reasons whereof the Lord discovers ( vers . 4. 5. ) whereof this was one , that they did not loose those bands , nor breake these yokes , nor relieved the oppessed ; And those works of Justice ( vers . 6. ) are pressed upon the same grounds , that the works of mercy are pressed upon ( vers . 7. ) sure these are not all nor only Rulers . Hence I argue , If it be a duty to break every yoke of oppression & Tyranny , then it is a duty to come out from under their subjection : But the former is true : therefore aso the latter . 3. In answer to that grand objection of the Iewes subjection to Nebuchadnezzar , I shew what litle weight or force there is in it . And here I shall take an Argument from that same Passage . The Lord commands His people there , to desert & disoune zedekiah who was the possessor of the Government at present , and sayes , it was the way of life to fall to the Chaldeans Ier. 21. 8 , 9. which was a falling away from the present King. Either this commanded subjection to the Chaldeans is an universal precept ; or it is only particular at that time . If it be universal , obliging people to subject themselves to every Conqueror , then it is also universal obliging people to renounce & disoune every Covenant-breaking tyrant , as here they were to fall away from Zedekiah : If it be only particular , then the ouners of of Tyranny have no advantage from this passage . And I have advantage , so far as the ground of the precept is as moral , as the reason of that punishment of zedekias , which was his perfidie & perjurie . Hence , if the Lord hath commanded to disoune a King breaking Covenant , then at least it is not insolent or unprecedented to do so : But here the Lord hath commanded to disoune a King : Ergo — Fourthly we may have many Confirmations of this truth , from Scripture practices approven . 1. I was but hinting before , how that after the death of that brave Captain & Judge Gideon , when Abimelech the son of his whore , did first aspire into a Monarchy , which he perswaded the silly Schechemites to consent to , by the same Argument which Royalists make so much of , for asserting the necessity of an Hereditary Monarchy [ whether is it better for yow either that all the sons of Jerubbaa● — reign over yow or that one reign over yow . ] & by bloody cruelty did usurp a Monarchical or rather Tyrannical Throne of Domination , founded upon the blood of his seventy brethren ( as we know , whose Throne is founded upon the blood of all the brethren he had ) Jotham , who escaped , s●●rned to put his trust under the shadow of such a bramble , and they that did submit , ●ound his parable verified , a mu●●al fire reciprocally consuming both the usurping King and his traiterous subjects : Neither did all the Godly in Israel submit to him . See Pool Synops. Critic . on the place Iud. 9. Here is one express example of disouning a Tyrant & Usurper . 2. I shew before , how after the Period of that Theocracy , which the Lord had maintained & managed for some time in great mercy & Majesty in & over His people , they , itching after novelties and affecting to be neighbour-like , rejected the Lord in desiring a King ; And the Lord permiting it , gave them a King in His wrath ( the true Original & only Sanction of Tyrannical Monarchy ) when the Characters of his Tyranny , presaged by Samuel , were verified in his aspiring into a great deal of absoluteness , especially in his cruel persecuting of David ; not only the 600 men that were Davids followers stood out in open opposition to him , but in the end , being weary of his Government , many brave & valiant men , whom the Spirit of God commends & describes very honourably , fell off from Saul , even while he was actually Tyrannising , before he was dead 1 Chron. 12. 1. &c. They came to David to Ziklag while he yet kept himself closs because of Saul the son of Kish ( N. B. now he is not honoured with the name of King ) they were armed with bows and could use both the right hand & the left . And of the Gadites , there separated themselves unto David men of might fit for the battel , that could handle shield & buckler , whose ●aces were as the faces of lyons vers . 8. And the Spirit came upon Amasai chief of the Captains , saying , Thine are we David & on thy side thow son of Iesse . Here was a formed Revolt from Saul unto David before he was King , for after this he was made King in Hebron , and there could not be two Kings at once . Hence I argue , if people may separate themselves from and take part with the Resister , against a Tyrant ; then they may disoune him ( for if they oune him still to be the Minister of God , they must not resist him Rom. 13. 2. ) But here is an example that many people did separate themselves from Saul and took part with the Resister David : Ergo — Here two of the first Monarchs of Israel were disouned , Abimelech & Saul . 3. The first Hereditary Successor was likewise disouned , as was hinted above likewise . The ten tribes offer to Covenant with Rehoboam , in terms securing their Rights & Liberties . They desired nothing on the matter , but that he would engage to rule over them according to the Law of God ; To which when he answered most Tyrannically , and avowed he would Tyrannise over them , and oppress them more than any of his Predicessors , they fell away from him , and erected themselves into a new Common-wealth 1 King. 12. 16. So when Israel saw that the King hearkened not unto them , they answered , what portion have we in David ? neither have we inheritance in the son of Iesse , to your tents O Israel , now see to thine oun house David 2 Chron. 10. 16. Now , however the event of this declared Revolt proved sorrowful , when they and their new King made defection unto Idolatry , yet if they had stated & managed it right , the Cause was good , justifyable , & commendable . For ( 1 ) We find nothing in all the Text condemning this ( 2 ) On the Contrary its expressly said , the Cause was from the Lord , that He might perform His saying which He spake by Ahijah 1 King. 12. 15. 2 Chron. 10. 15. And ( 3 ) When Rehoboam was preparing to pursue his pretended right , he was reproved & discharged by Shemajah , ye shall not go up nor fight against your brethren , for this thing is from me 1 King. 12. 24. 2 Chron. 11. 4. ( 4 ) Whereas it is alledged by some , that this was of God only by His providence , and not by His Ordinance ; the contrary will appear , if we consider , how formally & Covenant-wise the Lord gave ten tribes to Ieroboam 1 King. 11. 35 , 37 , 38. I will take the Kingdom out of his sons hand , and I will give it unto thee , even ten tribes ; And I will take thee , and thow shalt reign according to all that thy soul desireth , and shall be King over Israel ; And it shall be , if thow wilt hearken unto all that I command thee , and will walk in my wayes and do that which is right in my sight , to keep my statutes & my commandments , as David my servant did , that I will be with thee & build thee a sure house , as I built for David , and will give Israel unto thee . Where we see , the Kingdom was given unto him on the same Terms & conditions , that it was given to David . He may indeed give Kingdoms to whom He wi● , by Providential grant , as unto Nebuchadnezzar and others ; but He never gave them a Kingdom upon these Conditions , and by way of Covenant , that does alwayes imply & import His Word , Warrant , & ordinance ( 5 ) If we consider the Cause of the Revolt , we will find it very just : for after the decease of the former King , they enter upon terms of a Compact with the successor , upon a suspensive condition , to engage into fealty & Allegiance to him as subjects , if he would give them security for their Liberties & Priviledges . A very Lawful , Laudable & necessary transaction , founded upon Moral equity , & upon the fundamental Constitutions of that Government , and suitable to the constant practice of their Predicessors in their Covenanting with Saul & David . As for that Word 1 King. 12. 19. So Israel Rebelled against the house of David : It is no more then in the margent , they fell away or revolted ; And no more to be condemned , then Hezekiahs Rebellion 2 King. 18. 7. The Lord was with him , and he Rebelled against the King of Assyria . That was a good Rebellion . Hence , If it be Lawful for a part of the people to shake off the King , refuse subjection to him , and set up a new King of their oun , when he resolveth to play the Tyrant , and rule them after his oun absolute power ; then it is a duty , when he actually playes the Tyrant , and by his absolute power overturns Laws & Religion , and claims by Law such a prerogative : But the former is true : Ergo — See Ius Pepuli vindic . chap. 3. Pag 52. 4. This same Ieroboam , when he turned Tyrant & Idolater , was revolted from and deserted by the Priests & the Levites , and after them out of all the tribes of Israel , by all such as set their heart to seek the Lord God of Israel ; because that King , degenerating into Tyranny & Idolatry , had put them from the exercise of their office & Religion ( as our Charles did , and ordained him Priests for the Devils & for the Calves : So they returned to Rehoboam , being induced by his administration of the Government , which for a time was better then he promised , for three years he walked in the wayes of David & Salomon 2 Chron. 11. 13-17 . Hence I argue , If Idolatrous Tyrants may be deserted , then they may be disouned ; for when they desert them , they disoune them abroad , in coming under another Government ; and if they may be disouned abroad , it is the same duty at home , though may be not the same Policy or Prudence . 5. Another example of the like nature we have in the reign of Baasha , who succeeded to Nadab Ieroboams son , whom he slew & reigned in his stead ( the same way that the Duke came to the Throne ) For he could not keep his subjects within his Kingdom , but behoved to build Ramah , that he might not suffer any to go out or come in to Asa. King of Iudah , a good Prince , 1 King 15. 17. yet that could not hinder them , but many strangers out of Ephraim & Manasseh & Simeon fell to him in abundance , when they saw that the Lord his God was with him 2 Chron. 15. 9. Hence , If people may chuse another King , when they see the Lord is with him , then they may disoune their Country King , when they see the Devil is with him . 6. When Jehoram the son of Ahab reigned over Israel , we have an express example of Elisha's disouning him 2 King. 3. 14. 15. And Elisha said unto the King of Israel , what have I to do with thee ? — As the Lord of hosts liveth , before whom I stand , surely were it not that I regard the presence of Jehoshaphat the King of Judah , I would not look toward thee nor see thee , Here he declares so much contempt of him , and so litle regard , that he disdains him a look . And if he would not regard him , nor give him honour , then he did not oune him as King ; for all Kings are to be honoured , that are ouned to be Kings really . It may be alledged by some : that Elisha was an extraordinary man , and this was an extraordinary action , and therefore not imitable . I shall grant it so far extraordinary , that it is not Usual to carry so to persons of that figure , and that indeed there are few Elisha's now , not only for his Prophetick Spirit which now is ceased , but even in respect of his Gracious Spirit of zeal , which in a great measure is now extinguished : He was indeed an extraordinary man , and this Action did demonstrate much of the Spirit of Elias , to have been abiding with him . But that this was unimitable , these reasons induce me to deny . ( 1 ) Prophets were subject to Kings as well as others , as Nathan was to David ( 1 King. 1. 32 , 33. ) every soul must be subject to the higher powers that are of God ( 2 ) All the Actions of Prophets were not extraordinary , nor did they every thing by extraordinary inspiration ; that was peculiar to Christ , that He could Prophecy & do extraordinary acts when He pleased , because He received the Spirit not by measure , and it rested upon Him. ( 3 ) this particular Action & carriage was before he called for the Minstrel , and before the hand of the Lord came upon him vers . 15. Ergo this was not by inspiration . ( 4 ) The ground of this was Moral & Ordinary , for hereby he only shewed himself to be a person fit to abide in the Lords Tabernacle , and an upright walker in whose eyes a vile person is contemned , Psal. 15. 4. and a just man , to whom the unjust is an abomination Prov. 29. 27. What further can be aledged against this instance , I see not . And I need draw no Argument by Consequence , it is so plain . 7. This same Jehoram , after many signal demonstrations of the power of God exerted in the Ministry of His Servant Elisha , which sometimes did extort his acknowledgment and made him call the Prophet his father , 2 King. 6. 21. yet when in the strait siege of Samaria he was plagued with famine for his Idolatry , in so much that the pitiful Mothers were made to eat their oun tender Children ; became so insolent a Tyrant , that being incensed into a madness of outragious malice against the Prophet Elisah , that he sware , God do so to him & more also if the head of Elisha the son of Shaphat should stand on him that day , accordingly he sent a messenger to execute it . But the Prophet , from a Principle of Nature & Reason & Law , as well as Grace , and by the Spirit of a man as well as of a Prophet , stood upon his defence , and encouraged those that were with him to keep out the house against him , saying , See ye how this son of a Murderer ( a proper style for such a Monster of a King ) hath sent to take away mine head ... 2 King. 6. 32. This is a strong Argument for self defence , but I improve it thus : If Tyrants may be opposed as sons of Murderers , & Murderers themselves , and no otherwise to be accounted then under such a vile Character , then can they not be ouned as Kings : But here is an example for the first : Ergo — 8. This mans brother in Law , of the same name , Iehoram the son of Iehoshaphat , who had the Daughter of Ahab to wife , and therefore walked in the way of the house of Ahab , gives us another instance . He turned Apostate & Tyrant , and Abimelech-like ( or if yow will Yorklike ) slew his brethren , and diverse also of the Princes of Israel ; Moreover he made high places in the Mountains of Iudah , and caused the Inhabitants of Ierusalem to commit ●ornication , and compelled Iudah thereto : For which Cause of his intollerable insolency in wickedness , Libnah one of the Cities of Priests in Iudah , Revolted from him 2 King. 8. 22. because he had forsaken the Lord God of his fathers 2 Chron. 21. 10. which was the motive & impulsive Cause of their disouning him , and is not to be detorted to that restricted Cavil of Royalists , understanding it only as the Meritorous or procuring Cause of his punishment & loss sustained thereby ; for it is not so said of the Edomites who revolted at the same time , as it is mentioned in another Paragraph ; Neither of the Philistims & Arabians & Ethiopians , whose spirit the Lord stirred up against him ; These were also a punishment to him : Nor would it found very suitably to be said , that they opposed him because he had forsaken the Lord God of his fathers : for that would insinuate some influence that his Apostasie had on them , as certainly it could not but have on the Lords Priests that dwelt in Libnah , who understood by the Law of God , what was their duty to do with Intycers or Drawers or Drivers to Idolatry : And when they were not in capacity to execute the Judgement of the Lord , this was the least they could do , to Revolt . Here then is an example of a Peoples Revolt from a Prince , and disouning Allegiance to him because of Apostasie & Tyranny . 9. In this Kingdom of Iudah , after long experience of a Succession of Hereditary Tyranny in many wicked Kings , the people after they had long smarted for their lazie Loyaltie in their stupid abandoning , forgetting , & foregoing this Priviledge of disouning Tyrants , and keeping them in order , began at length to bestir themselves in their endeavours to recover their lost Liberties , and repress Tyrants Insolencies on several occasions . Wherein , though sometimes there were extravagances , when Circumstances did mar the Justice of the Action , and some did go beyond their sphere in tumultuary precipitations ; yet upon the matter it was Justice , and in conformity to a Moral Command . One impregnable witness of this we have , in the pious Plot of Iehojada the Priest , who being but a Subject , as all Priests were ( as the deposition of Abiathar by King Solomon 1 King. 2. 27. proveth ) entered into an Association with the inferior Rulers , to choose & make a new King ; and notwithstanding that the Idolatress & She-Tyrant Athaliab , who had the Possession of the Government , cried Treason , Treason at the fact , they had her forth without the ranges , & slew her 2 King. 11. 14-16 . This was according to the Law Deut. 13. And approven by all Interpreters , even Mr Pool in his Synopsis Critic . though alias Superlatively Loyal , yet approves of this , and sayes , she was an incurable Idolatress , and therefore deserved to be deposed by the Nobles of the Kingdom : And quotes Grotius in Loc. saying [ she reigned by meer force & no right , and therefore justly repressed by force , for the Hebrewes were to have Brethren for their Kings but not Sisters , Deut. 17. 15. ] Hence if Tyrants may be forcibly repressed , then may they peaceably be disouned : But this example comfirms that : Ergo — 10. The Sacred History proceeds in the Relation , how this same Joash , the Son of Ahaziah , after he degenerated into Murdering Tyranny , was slain by Jozachar & Jehozabad 2 King. 12. 20 , 21. But that was by his oun Servants in private Assassination ; therefore they are called Murderers by Amaziah his Son 2 King. 14. 5 , 6. but upon the matter it was the Justice of God , which he deserved ( if it had been duely execute ) for the blood of the Sone of Jehojada the Priest 2 Chron. 24. 25. So Amon the Son of Manasseh , for his walking in the way of his Father in Idolatry & Tyranny , and forsaking the Lord God of his Fathers , was slain in his oun house by his Servants , who conspired against him ; But though this was Justice also upon the matter , and consonant to the Command for punishing Idolaters & Murderers , yet because defective in the manner , and done by them that tooke too much upon them , in a perfidious way of private Assassination & Conspiracy , therefore the People of the Land punished them for it 2 King. 21. 23. 24. But the repressing & punishing of Amaziah is a more unexceptionable instance . The people made a Conspiracy against him in Ierusalem , and he fled to Lachish , but they sent after him to Lachish and slew him there 2 King. 14. 19. after the time that he turned away from following the Lord 2 Chron. 25. 27. Which was according to the Command Deut. 13. which hath no exception of Kings in it . This Action was not questioned either by the people , or his Successor , as the formentioned Conspiracies were . His son Uzziah succeeding , who did right & consulted the Lord ( 2 Chron. 26. 4 , 5. ) did not resent nor revenge his Fathers death ; which certainly he would have done , by advice of Zechariah who had understanding in the visions of God , if it had been a transgression . The famous & faithful Mr Knox doth clear this passage beyond Contradiction in his conference with Lithingtoun Hence I take an Argument a fortiori . If people may conspire & concur in executing Judgement upon their King turning Idolater & Tyrant ; Then much more may they Revolt from him : But this example clears the Antecedent , Ergo. 11. The same power & priviledge of peoples punishing their Princes , was exemplified in the Successor of him last mentioned , to wit , in Uzziah the son of Amaziah , called Azariah 2 King. 15. when he degenerated into the ambition of arrogating a Supremacy , in causes Ecclesiastick & Sacred as well as Civil , his heart was lifted up to his destruction , for he transgressed against the Lord his God , and went into the Temple of the Lord to burn Incense . In which Usurpation he was resisted by Azariah the Priest , and with him fourscore Priests of the Lord that were valiant men , who withstood him , and told him it did not appertain to him to take upon him so much , and bade him go out of the Sanctuary , or else it should not be for his honour . Which indeed he stomacked at as an affront , to be controled & resisted ; but in thinking to resent it he was plagued of the Lord with leprosie ; which the Priests looking upon , they thrust him out from thence : And thereafter sequestred him from all Supremacy , both that which he had before in things Civil , and that which he was affecting in matters Sacred ; for he was made to dwell in a Several house , being a leper , ( the Law including ( & here execute upon ) the King as well as the beggar ) and to resign the Government into his son Jothams hands 2 Chron. 26. 16-21 . Where it appears he was not only excommunicated by a Ceremonial punishment , but also deposed Judicially . Whether he voluntarly dimited or not , it is to no purpose to contend : its evident , that by the Law of God , the actual exercise of his power was removed , whether with his will or against it , it is all one ; And that he was punished both by God and by men is undeniable . Yea in this , his punishment was very gentle , and far short of the Severity of the Law ; for by the Law he should have been put to death , for intermedling with these holy things , interdicted to all but to the Priests under pain of death Numb . 3. 10. Numb . 18. 7. The stranger that cometh nigh shall be put to death : All were strangers that were not Priests . Whence I argue , If a Prince , for his Usurpation beyond his line in things Sacred , may by the Priests be excommunicated , and by the people deposed ; then may a Prince , not only Usurping a Supremacy ( as Charles did ) but an absolute power of overturning all things Sacred & Civil ( as James doeth ) & oppressing his subjects in all their Liberties , be disouned , a fortiori , for that is less than deposing or dethroning : But this Example clears the Antecedent : Ergo — See Knox discourse to Lethingtoun : Lex Rex Quest. 44. § . 15. pag. 461. Ius popul . chap. 3. pag. 56. 12. What if I should adduce the Example of a Kings Rebellion against , and Revolt from a Superior King , to whom he & his Fathers both acknowledged themselves subject ? Surely our Royalists and Loyalists would not condemn this ; and yet in justifying it , they should condemn their beloved principle of uncontroled subjection to uncontrolable Soveraigns possessing the Government . Ahaz became Servant to the Assyrian Monarch 2 King. 16. 7. yet Hezekiah his son , when the Lord was with him , and he prospered — Rebelled against the King of Assyria and he served him not 2 King. 18. 7. Hezekiah was indeed a King : but he was not Sennacheribs King ; he acknowledges himself his vassal , and that he offended in disouning him vers . 14. which certainly was his sin against the Lord , to make such an acknowledgment : for if his Fathers transaction with the Assyrian was sin , then it was duty to break the yoke ; if the Lord was with him in that rebellion , then it was his sin to acknowledge it to be his offence ; And to make good this ackowledgment , it was certainly his sin to commit Sacriledge in robbing the House of God , to satisfie that Tyrant . By way of Supplement , I shall adde that instance of repressing a mad & furious Tyrant , which all will acknowledge to be Lawful . Nebuchadnezzar was both stricken of God with madness , and for that was depelled from the Kingdom , according to the heavenly Oracle , The Kingdom is departed from thee and they shall drive thee from men , Dan. 4. 31-33 . Calvin sayes upon the place , he was ejected as usually is done to Tyrants , by the Combination of the nobles & people , Pool Synopsis Critic . in Locum . Thus he was unkinged for a time , both by the just Judgement of God , and by the intermediation of the just Judgement of men ; and could not be ouned to be King at that time , when his nails were like birds Clawes , and he could not tell his oun fingers : They could not oune him to be the Governour then of so many Kingdoms , when he could not Govern himself . Hence , though this is an instance of Heathens , yet because they acted upon a rational ground , it may be argued : If Kings , because of Natural madness when they cannot govern themselves , may not be ouned ; Then also because of Moral madness , when they will not govern but to the destruction of Kingdoms , may not be ouned : But the former is true : Therefore also the Latter . The same reason against the Government of Asses , will also militate against the Government of Tygers , the first is more eligible then the last . Fifthly , This may be confirmed from Several promises in Scripture . 1. There are many Gracious & precious promises of Reformation of the Magistracy , and Restitution of good Rulers , as a great blessing from God to Mankind and to the Church Isai , 1. 26. I will restore thy Iudges as at the first , and thy Counsellors as at the begining , afterwrrd tho● shalt he called the City of righteousness . If Judges must first be restored before the City can be a City of righteousness , then they must be restored before we can oune the Government thereof : for that Government under which it cannot be a City of Righteousness , cannot be ouned : since it is no Government but a Rebellion & Combination of Thieves , see vers . 23. I do not here restrict the promise , as it is a Prophecy , to its exact fulfillment , as if no Government were to be ouned but what answers this promise , of the restitution of the primitive order of Magistrats ; but I plead , that when the Princes are rebellious & Companions of Thieves , the Government is not to be ouned , till Judges be so far restored , as to reduce righteousness in some measure , which cannot be under Tyranny . And in the general I may plead , that none is to be ouned as a Magistrate but who some way is found in a promise ; for there is no Ordinance of God , no duty , no blessing , no good thing , either to be done or enjoyed , but what is in a promise : but Tyranny , or ouning of Tyrants , or subjection to Usurpers , is not nor cannot be in a promise . We have many other promises about Magistrates , as that the Lord will be for a Spirit of Iudgement to him that sitteth in Iudgement , Isai. 28. 6. A Tyrant cannot be capable of this happiness , nor we under Tyranny , nor any while they oune them . Kings shall be the Churches nursing Fathers and their Queens her nursing Mothers Isai. 49. 23. Kings are not alwayes so , but all Kings to be ouned are such as can be so , at least they are never to be ouned when they turn destroyers of what they should nourish : But Tyrants can never be Nourishers . It is promised to the Lords people , if they will hearken diligently unto the Lord , and keep the Sabbath , then shall there enter into their gates Kings & Princes Ier. 17. 24 , 25. And if they will execute Judgement & righteousness , and deliver the spoyled out of the hand of the oppressor &c. they shall obtain the same blessing Ier. 23. 3 , 4. But it is never promised , neither doth it ever come to pass in Providence , that these duties procured Tyrants . There are many other promises to the same purpose , from whence may be concluded , the Lord will not alwayes leave His people to houl under ineluctable Tyranny , but will accomplish their deliverance in His oun time & way , though we are not to look to Miracles . Whence I argue . 1. Since all the Ordinances of God , & Rulers in a special manner , are appointed & promised as blessings , these cannot be ouned for His Ordinance , which are not Blessings but Curses . 2. That which would vacate & evacuate all the promises of Magistracy , cannot be a Doctrine of God : But this that obliges to oune Tyrants & Usurpers , as long as they are up , would vacate & evacuate all these promises of Magistracy : For except the Lord work Miracles ( which are not in the promise ) and do all without means , they cannot be accomplished . For if any means be used , they must be such as will infer disouning of Tyrants ; for Magistrates cannot be restored except Tyrants be removed , and whatever way they be removed without Miracles , by others or their oun Subjects , they must still be disouned , and that before they be removed ; for if they be to be ouned before , their removal , if they exist , cannot make them to be disouned : dispossession cannot take away their right , if they have it before . 2. There are many promises of breaking the yoke of Tyrants Isai. 10. 27. His burden shall be taken away from off thy shoulder and his yoke from off thy neck . And in that promise of the Churches deliverance & enlargment , wherein they are Prophetically urged & stirred up to some activity in cooperating with the providence , Isai. 52. 1 , 2. they are called to awake & put on strength & their beautiful garments — and to shake themselves from the dust — and to rise and loose themselves from the bands of their neck , that were captives . Here is not only a promise of deliverance , or a ground of encouragment what the Church may expect , but a promise of & direction for their being active in delivering themselves , as men , from the encroachments that were made on their humane Liberties , that they should loose themselves from these bands ; Whose bands ? from their bands that ruled over them , and made them to houl , and the Lords Name to be blasphemed ( vers . 5. ) Here 's a promise of breaking the bands of Rulers , by them who houled under their subjection . And it also includes a precept , that people should not stay any longer under these yokes , than they can shake them off or slip from under them . Hence we see we are not to lie stupidly sleeping , or sinking in the Ditch , expecting the accomplishment of the promise of Deliverance , but are to endeavour actively , in dependence upon the Lords Assistance , to deliver our selves . Hence we may argue . 1. A promise by way of Command , that a people under bands of oppressing Rulers shall rouse themselves up to loose themselves from them , implies & infers a promise & a duty of disouning those Rulers ( for otherwise they cannot be loosed from their subjection . ) But here is a promise by way of Command , that a people under bands of oppressing Rulers shall rouse themselves up to loose themselves from them : Ergo — 2. If the removal of Tyranny & Usurpation be promised as a blessing , then those can never be ouned to be the Ordinance of God ; for the removal of that can never be a blessing : But in these promises we see , the removal of those is promised as a blessing : Therefore they can never be ouned . Sixthly , To the same purpose we may cite some Threatenings , that will confirm the same Truth . 1. There are many Threatenings against Tyrants themselves . There are two mentioned Ier. 22. that seem patly to quadrate , and near of a piece , with our Misrulers ; both because of the demerit of the Threatening , and the likeness of the Judgement Threatened . The ground of it was building their house by unrighteousness and their chambers by wrong vers . 13. And severally they are Threatened : Iehojakim with the burial of an Ass unlamented vers . 18 , 19. Coniah with a life without prosperity , and a death without issue to succeed vers . 30. The first of these is verified in the Elder of our Royal Brothers , the last is like to be of both . But that which I take notice of is , first , the demerit , building their house by unrighteousness , on which Whitehall is built with a witness : and particularly it is noted of Iehojakim , as his Crimson sin ( to which his Son Iehojakim or Coniah served himself heir ) that he burnt Ieremia● Roll , or Causes of wrath ; So did our Dominators burn the Causes of wrath ( a book written by the Commission of the General Assembly ) and the Covenants . Then I note these words vers . 15. Shalt thow reign because thow closest thy self in Cedar &c. It is certainly not fit for us to say , he shall reign , of whom the Lord sayes , he shall not reign : but when we oune the Authority of those whom the Lord threatens they shall not reign , we say , they shall reign : for we say , they have a rig●t to reign , and oune our selves obliged to do all that is required in our Capacity , to perpetuate their reign . There is a terrible Threatening against Zedekiah Ezek. 20. 25-27 . Thow profane ( or as some translate it ; Thow worthy to be killed , Pool . Synops. Critic . in Locum . ) wicked Prince of Israel — Thus saith the Lord God , Remove the Diadem , take off the Crown , this shall not be the same , exalt him that is low , and abase him that is high , I will overturn , overturn , overturn it , and it shall be no more untill he come whose right it is , and I will give it him . Than which nothing can be more applicable to our Princes , who are profane , and the patterns & patrons of it , whose Diadem the Lord will remove ; and if He threaten it , ●wo to them that contribute to hold it on . We see here , a profane & wicked Prince threatened to be overturned must not be ouned , because he hath no right : But our Excommunicate Tyrant , is a profane & wicked Prince threatened to be overturned : Ergo — There is another dreadful Threatening against Tyrants Am●s 4. 1 , 2. Hear this word ye Kine of Bashan , which oppress the poor , which crush the needy — The Lord God hath sworn by His Holiness , that lo the dayes shall come upon you● , that He will take you away with hooks , and your posterity with fish hooks . Shall we oune these , against whom the Lord hath engaged His Holiness by Oath so solemnly , that He will fish them with hooks ? We may fear if there be such a tye as Allegiance between them and us , that that same hook which fishes them may also catch us ; as it is said of Pharaoh and his subjects , when he is hooked , then his fish stick unto his scales , and he & they are left in the wilderness Ezek. 29. 4 , 5. that is as Grotius expounds it , whoever are of his Community shall be consorts in his Calamity , Pool Critic . in Locum . If we then oune them we must be of their Community , and so partake of their Judgements . 2. There are many Threatenings against illimited Loyaltie , and those who had more of that than Religion : for this Ephraim was broken in Judgment , because he willingly walked after the Commandment Hos. 5. 11. And because the Statutes of Omri were kept , and the works of the house of Ahab , therefore the Lord threatens to make them a desolation Mic. 6. ult . And among other Threatenings against the men of such universal Loyaltie , that is notable Hos. 10. 3. Now ye shall say , we have no King , because we feared not the Lord , what then should a King do to us ? It is the just punishment of wicked Loyalty , that prefers the fear & favour of Kings to the fear & favour of God , that at length they are brought to that pass , that either they have no Kings at all to look to , or else they have such of whom it may be said , they are no Kings in effect , for they cannot act the part of Kings to them that trust in them . Hence . 1. If to have really no Kings be a punishment , then such Kings as are a punishment cannot be ouned to be Kings ; for to have them cannot be a punishment , if the want of them be a punishment . 2. If those that have the name of Kings , that can do no good , be no Kings ; Then Tyrants that can do no good but a great deal of hurt , must be reckoned no Kings also : But here it s threatened , people that had Kings , that had the name but could do no good , should reckon they had no Kings : Therefore much more may Tyrants be reckoned to be no Kings , who can do no good but a great deal of hurt . Seventhly , This Truth is confirmed from Scripture Prayers : Whereof there are many against Tyrants , none for them . Hence we argue , If we are not to pray for Tyrants then we are not to oune them ; for we are to pray for all that are in Authority 1 Tim 2. 2 , But we are not to pray for Tyrants : Ergo we are not to oune them . The Minor now must be proved . And this leads me to another subordinate Question , which hath also been a head of suffering to some serious Seekers of God in our Land of late . The profane Emissaries of this and the late Tyrant , sent out with bloody Commissions to hunt after the Lords hidden Ones , in order to murder all whom they might meet with , that made Conscience of adhering to every part of the present Testimony ; among other trapping Questions to discover their prey , they used to put this to them as a discriminating Shibboleth , and Tessera of ouning the present Tyranny , will yow say , God save the King ? And for refusing this , many have been cruelly murdered in the Fields ; And many before their bloody Judicatories , have for this been arraigned & condemned , & executed to the death . Wherefore to this somewhat must be said . 1. By way of Concession . 2. By way of Vindication , of Scrupling it and Suffering upon it . First , In the General , it will be necessary to premit by way of Concession . 1. It is duty to pray , supplicate , & interceed for all men 1 Tim. 2. 1. not Collectively considered , nor Distributively for every one universally without exception , but indefinitely & indiscriminately , pro generibus singulorum for all sorts & sexes , of whatsoever Nation or Religion , Iew or Gentile , Christian or Infidel , not excluding any for these distinctions : And not only so , but pro singulis generum also Conditionally , if they be among those all whom the Lord will have to be saved vers . 4. If they be among those all for whom the Mediator gave himself a ransome to be testified in due time vers . 5 , 6. If they have not sinned the sin unto death , for which we are not bidden pray 1 Iohn . 5. 16. Which , because we know not particularly who are guilty of it , Charity will oblige us to take into our Prayers many that may never be the better of them ; Yet it is necessary that we pray in Faith , for what , or whomsoever we pray ; at least , if I may so call it , we must have a negative Faith , a belief that they have not sinned that sin unto death ; which we cannot have of all , there being some whose demonstrations of desperate displayes of affronted wickedness , and hatred of Godliness , may give ground to doubt of it , as Christians had of Iulian the Apostate . 2. We are obliged to love our Enemies , to Bless them that Curse us , to do good to them that hate us , to pray for them that despitefully use & persecute us Math. 5. 44. Accordingly Our Master , who commanded this , did give us a Pattern to imitate , when He prayed , Father forgive them for they know not what they do Luk. 23. 34. And His faithful Martyr Stephen , prayed for his Murderers , Lord lay not this sin to their charge , Act. 7. ult . We are to pity them , and not to seek vengeance against them , for any injuries they can do to us . Yet , as this doth not interfere with a holy & zealous Appeal to God , for righting & resenting & requiting the wrongs done to us , that He may vindicate us & our Cause , and make them repent of their injuries done to us , to the Glory of God , and Conviction of Onlookers , and Confusion of themselves , which may well consist with Mercy to their Souls : So all we can pray for them in their opposition to us , is in order to their repentance , but never for their prosperity in that Course . And we may well imitate , even against our enemies , that prayer of Zecharia's , The Lord look upon it and require it 2 Chron. 24. 22. But we are never to pray for Christs stated Enemies , as to the bulk of them , and under that formality as His Enemies : for we must not love them that hate the Lord 2 Chron. 19. 2. but hate them , and hate them with a perfect hatred , Psâl. 139. 21 , 22. We are to pray for the Elect among them , but only to the end they may escape the vengeance , which we are obliged to pray for against them . 3. We are not to exsecrate our enemies , or use imprecations against any , out of blind zeal , or the passionate or revengefull motions of our oun hearts : Our Lord rebuked His Disciples for such preposterous zeal Luk. 9. 55. Ye know not what manner of Spirit ye are of . But against the Stated & Declared Enemies of Christ , as such & while such , we may well take a pattern from the imprecatory Prayers of the Saints recorded in Scripture ; such as do not peremptorly determine about the eternal State of particular persons : which determinations , except we be extraordinarly acted by the same Spirit , whose Dictates these are , are not to be imitated by us . We find several sorts of Imprecations in the Psalms , & other Scriptures : Some are imitable , some not : Some are Propheticall having the force of a Prophecy , as Davids Psal. 35. 4. Let them be confounded — that seek after my Soul — Let Destruction come upon him Psal. 55. 15. Let them go doun quick to hell . And Ieremiah chap. 17. 18. Let them be confounded that persecute me — destroy them with double destruction . Without this Prophetical Spirit , determining the application of these threatenings to particular persons , we may not imitate this peremptoriness . Some are Typical of Christs Mediatory devoting His Enemies to destruction ; who as He interceeds for His friends , so by virtue of the same Merits ( by them trampled upon ) He pleads for vengeance against His enemies : Which Mediatory vengeance , is the most dreadful of all vengeances ( Heb. 10. 29. ) So also Psal. 40. He whose ears were opened , and who said lo I come — vers . 6. 7. that is Christ ) does imprecate shame & Confusion & desolation vers . 14. 15. As also Psal. 109. the Psalmist personates Christ , complaining of & imprecating against His enemies , particularly Iudas the Traitor vers . 8. It must be dreadful to be under the dint of the Mediators Imprecations ; And also dreadful to clash with Him in His Intercessions , that is , to apprecate for them against whom He imprecates , or pray for them against whom He intercedes . But some Imprecatio●s against the enemies of God , are imitable such as proceed from pure zeal for God , and the Spirit of Prayer , as that Psal. 109. ult . Put them in fear O Lord that the Nations may know themselves to be but men . Psal. 83. 16. — fill their faces with shame that they may seek thy Name . This is to be imitated in general against all the enemies of God Psal 129. 5. Let them all be confounded that hate Zion ; without condescending on particular persons , except obviously & not odiously desperate , & presumptively Christs implacable Enemies . 4. Touching Magistrates it is a great duty to pray , that God would give us Magistrates , as He hath promised for the Comfort of His Church Isai. 1. 26. Isai. 49. 2. Ier. 30. 21. Promises should be motives & foments of Prayer . We ought to pray against Anarchy as a Plague , and with all earnestness beg of God , that the mercy of Magistracy may aga●n be known in Brittain , of which it hath been long deprived . 5. And when we have them , it is a necessary Duty to pray for them ; for Kings and for all that are in Authority , that we may lead a quiet & peaceable life in all Godliness & honesty 1 Tim. 2. 2. Where it is specified , what sort we should pray for , and to what end . As we are not to pray for all men absolutely ; for some , as they are declared to be out of the precincts of of Christs Mediation , so they must be out of our Prayers : So there may be some in actual Rule , that may be excepted out of the verge of the Christians Prayers , as was said of Iulian the Apostate . But he that is a Magistrate indeed , and in Authority , the subjects are to pray and to give thanks for him , not as a man meerly , but as a Magistrate . Yea though they be Heathen Magistrates , Ezra . 6. 10. We may pray for all in Authority , two wayes ; As Men , & as Kings . As Men , we may pray for their Salvation , or Conversion , or taking them out of the way , if they be enemies to Christs Kingdom , according as they are stated ; and upon Condition , if it be possible , and if they belong to the Election of Grace . Though for such as are opposites to the coming of Christs Kingdom , as it is a contradiction to the second petition of the Lords Prayer [ Thy Kingdom come ] So in the experience of the most eminent wrestlers , they have found less faith & less encouragement in praying for them , than for any other sort of men . It is rare that ever any could find their hands , in praying for the Conversion of our Rulers . And though we pray that the Lord would convince them , yea & confound them , in mercy to their souls ; yet this must never be wanting in our Prayers for Tyrants , as men , that God would bring them doun , and cause Justice overtake them , that so God may be Glorified , and the Nation eased of such a burden . But if we pray for them as Kings , then they must be such by Gods approbation , and not meer possessory Occupants , to whom we owe no such respect nor duty . For whatever the Hobbists , and the time-serving Casuists of our day , and even many good men ( though wofully laxe in this point ) homolating both Doctrinally & Practically their heathenish notions , say to the contrary ; I hope it be in some measure made out , that Tyrants are no more the Ordinance of God , nor to be ouned as His Ministers & Vicegerents , than the Devil the Prince of this World for the Lords Anointed , or Baals Priests for true Ministers . If we pray for them as Kings , we must pray for their peace , prosperity , & preservation , that their Government may be blessed with success , their designs not frustrated , nor their desires disappointed . This we cannot pray for Tyrants . 6. Albeit we may pray for the Peace of the Nation , and for the Government thereof , so far as it may conduce to our oun & the Churches Tranquility , that we may live a peaceable & Godly life under it ; yet this cannot be extended to the peace of Tyrants , for whom the best Prayer that we can bestow is , that the Lord would bridle & restrain them , that they may not m●r the Churches peace . That Command , Ier. 29. 7. Seek the Peace of the City , whither soever I have caused yow to be carried Captives , and pray unto the Lord for it , for in the peace thereof shall yow have peace , is apparent to have been but of a temporary nature , upon occasion of their Captivity there , until the 70 years should be expired , having it also declared by God , that their oun peace was bound up in that of Babylons : For after that time they are taught the contrary carriage towards that City , to depart , and pray against it , and exult & rejoice in its ruine ; O Daughter of Babylon , happy shall he be that rewardeth thee as thow hast served us , that dasheth thy litle ones against the Stones , Psal. 137. 8 , 9. The voice of them that flee out of the Land of Babylon , to declare in Zion the vengeance of the Lord , the vengeance of His Temple Ier. 50. 28. And Ier. 51. 35. The violence done to me and to my flesh be upon Babylon , shall the inhabitant of Zion say , and my blood be upon Chaldea , shall Ierusalem say . Certainly this is not the season to seek the Peace of Misticall Babylon , but to pray for the destruction thereof and all its supporters : Which we cannot do , if we pray for them that improve , imploy , & apply all their power to support it , lest we pray contradictions ; as many do , who pray against Babels brats and yet pray for the King : but the Comfort is this , that Nonsensical Prayers will do litle good , litle hurt , but to themselves that pray them . Secondly , To vindicate the Scruplers & Refusers of such Compelled & extorted Devotion , in praying for Tyrants , I shall offer these Considerations . 1. The imposed form of it ( which as it is found in the Original from whence it is taken , is only Paraphrastically expounded , God save the King ; and most Catechrestically applied to Tyrants , being in the native sense of the words of this signification , Let the King Live ; which is a very improper Wish for men of death , of whom God sayes , they shall die , and the Law sayes , they should die , for their Murders & Capital Crimes ) must be taken either as an Adulatory Complement ; or a Congratulatory honour ; or a precatory benediction . The first , as it is extorted most illegally , so it can be rendered neither Civilly , nor Sincerly , nor Christianly : but all ingenuus men would think it a base imposition , to be forced not only to subject themselves to their Tyrannical Oppressors , but to flatter them as if they were not such . Whatever they may force the mouth to speak dissemblingly , they can never compell the heart to think , such wishes are due to them ; and so they can never be Cordial , nor consistent with Candor ; and to interpose the Holy & Dreadful Name of God , in a dissembling Complement , to flatter base men , is a horrid mocking of God , and a heinous taking His Name in vain , contrary to the Third Command . If it be a Congratulation ( as alwayes it is used in Scripture , and in all cases formerly ; being never imposed on men by way of Compulsion , before this sett of Tyrants started up , that know they can get no deference of honest men , but by extortion ) It is the more abominable ; not only for the Hypocrisie that is in it , but the Blasphemie , in giving thanks for the Promoter of the Devils Interest , and the Destroyer of Christs , and the Liberties of Mankind . What have we to Congratulate him for , but for overturning our Laws & Liberties , and oppressing us in most grievous Tyranny ? Besides to give the vilest of men when exalted any Congratulatory honour , is contrary to the fifth Command , as is shewed above . And it were a forsaking of the Law , thus to praise the wicked , since they that keep the Law will contend with them Prov. 28. 4. If it be a Benediction , we cannot bestow it upon one whom our Father Curses , our Mother Curses , and all our Brethren . It is no less preposterous to bless whom the Lord declaredly Curses , than to Curse whom he blesses . The Curse of the Lord is in the house of the wicked Prov. 3. 33. we cannot then bless that house . Nor can we bless them that our Mother curses , and cries for vengeance against , as she did against Nebuchadnezzar Ier. 51. 34 , 35. Nor them against whom the blood of our dead Brethren hath a Moral Cry , How long O Lord holy & true doest thow not Iudge & avenge our blood , Revel . 6. 10. And the vexed Spirits of our Brethren , yet houling under the same yoke , are puting up before the Throne of Grace , the same continued Cry , with incessant importunity , How long how long shall the wicked triumph how long shall they break in pieces thy people ? O God to whom vengeance belongeth ? Psal. 94. 1-4 . Yea God hath said it , and we must not contradict it in our practice , against all Tyrants that wrest Judgement , and say unto the wicked thow art righteous , him shall the people , curse Nations shall abhor him , Prov. 2. 24. And this must stand registred as the everlasting Claise of all Zions haters , to which all her Lovers must say , Amen , that they shall be as the grass upon the house tops and never have the benefit of the Churches benediction Psal. 129. 8. Neither do they which go by say , the blessing of Lord be upon yow , we bless yow in the Name of the Lord. This one word may be a sufficient Supercedeas from blessing any of the enemies of God , or of the Church , while acting in a declared opposition to God for the destruction of His people & interest . 2. Either this — Save the King , as they mouth it , and demand the repetition of it , is a Prayer ; or it is not . If not , it must be a dreadful profanation of the name of God , to be commanded to speak to Him , and yet not to pray . If it be a Prayer , we would expect another way of dealing with us , if rhey really desired the benefit of our Prayers , than a threatening us with death if we did it not . And if they did desire it as Darius did , that we might offer sacrifices of sweet savours unto the God of Heaven , and pray for the life of the King and of his sons Ezra . 6. 10. we could not refuse to pray for him , so far as might consist with that Prayer of the same Darius , in that same decree vers . 12. that God may destroy all Kings & people , that shall put to their hand to alter and destroy the House of God. We can pray no Prayer inconsistent with this , And to pray that God would save this King , and yet destroy all Kings that put to their hand against His House , were to pray Contradictions . But they know they deserve no Prayers , and must force them if they get them . And all the world knows , that Compelled Prayers are no devotion ; and if they be no devotion , they must be sin : Imposed Prayers , are not the Prayers that God will hear & accept ; And if we have not the faith of acceptance in them , they must be sin , for whatever is not of faith is sin , Rom. 14. ult . All Prayers which God will hear , must proceed from the heart voluntarely and fervently , in Spirit & in Truth , with the whole heart . But imposed & compelled Prayers cannot be such ; especially when they are not only by them imposed , but prescribed as to the form of them . Which sets and formes prescribed by men , and such men as usurp a Supremacy over the Church , cannot be subjected to , according to the Word of God , and the Principles of our Reformation . 3. That infallible Proposition of the Apostle , Whatsoever is not of faith is sin , must be urged yet a litle further : And that with a reference , both to the Person required to be prayed for , and to the matter of the duty more generally . First if we cannot pray for this man , neither as a Christian , nor as a King , then we cannot satisfie this imposed demand ; for it will not satisfie to pray for him as a Heathen : But we cannot in faith pray for him , either as a Christian , or as a King ▪ Not as a Christian ; for besides that he is an excommunicate Apostate ( by a sentance which we beleeve stands yet rate in Heaven , Pronounced by a faithful Servant of Christ ) and a Papist , which as such can no more be prayed for than the Pope as Pope ; ; for whom , and all the limbs of Antichrist ; the only prayer that Protestants can pray , is , that the Lord would consume him with the Spirit of His Mouth and destroy with the brightness of His coming 2 Thess. 2. 8. ( we cannot reconcile the prayers of some , that pray against the Pope and his supporters , and upholders of his tottering Kingdom , and yet for this his Antichristian vassal ) His rage & resolution in prosecuting a war against Christ and His followers , is such , that if we may make Comparisons , our faith will have litle more ground to pray for Iames , than Christians of old could find for Iulian , the the Apostate . Nor as a King , for that we cannot do , because he is none with Gods approbation , and may not do , for a very heathen could teach us to pray , that God would destroy all Kings that put to their hand to alter & destroy the House of God , Ezra . 6. 12. And besides , in the Second place , with respect to the matter of the duty in general : That cannot be in faith which wants a warrant in the Word , either by precept , promise , or practice : But to pray for wicked Tyrants & Enemies of God , wants a Warrant in the Word , either by precept , promise , or practice . There is no precept for it , either General on particular , neither express , nor any to which this is reducible . And who dare adde without a precept in the Worship of God , either for matter , or manner , or end , what He hath not commanded ? for such presumption ; Nadab & Abihu were destroyed Levit. 10. 1 , 2. because they did that which the Lord had not commanded . What Command can there be for praying for that , which is against the preceptive Will of God ? But it is against the preceptive Will of God , that there should be Tyrants : Therefore to pray that these may be preserved in the World , cannot fall under a Command of God. There is no promise for it , which is the foment & foundation of Prayer : We can pray for nothing that we have not a promise for , either General or Particular : But we have none , nor can have any , for the preservation of a plague to us , as Tyrants are . There is no Practice for it in Scripture , to pray for Kings that put to their hand to destroy the House of God. Samuel did indeed mourn for Saul ▪ but the Lord reproved him for it , How long wilt thow mourn for Saul , seeing I have rejected him from being King over Isrrel ? 1 Sam. 16. 1. belike this reproof was for his praying for Sauls preservation as King , for otherwise we may mourn for wicked wretches , for their sin & Miserie both . But hence , if the Lord reprove His Servant for mourning for a King whom He disoun●d , then we may not pray for such a King whom the Lord disounes , as He disounes all Tyrants , for they are set up & not by Him ! But the Antecedent is true in that example of Samuel : Therefore also the Consequent , that we may not pray for them as Kings , whom the Lord disounes . 4. Moreover to confirm this yet further : That Prayer is not of Faith , and so sin , which is contrary to the Precepts of God , and his promises , and the practices of the Saints : But praying for wicked Kings their preservation , is contrary to these precepts , promises , & practices &c. Ergo — It is contrary to some Divine precepts , both Affirmative , & Negative . There is an Affirmative precept , prescribing what Prayer should be used under the Domination of Tyrants , that they should weep and say , Spare thy people O Lord , give not they Heritage to reproach , that the heathen should rule over them , wherefore should they say among the people where is their God Ioel. 3. 17. If it be a reproach to be under Heathen Rulers , and if we should pray that they may not Rule , but that Our God may shew Himself where He is , and who He is , in delivering His people from their Domination ; Then it is contrary to this , to pray for the preservation of Tyrants , that do rule over them to their destruction & reproach : For it is contradictory to pray , that they may not Rule , and that they may be preserved in Ruling . There is a negative precept , prohibiting the salutation of Hereticks and Enemies of the Gospel , which will condemn this salutation of Heretical Kings : for in the Original God save the King is no more than a solemn salutation , or apprecatory Wish that he may prosper . 2 Epist. Iohn . vers . 10 , 11. If there come any — and bring not this Doctrine — neither bid him God speed , for he that biddeth him , God speed , is partaker of his evil deeds . God speed , in the Greek , is the same with God save , in the Hebrew . If then we must not say , God save a Heretick , neither must we say God save an Hertical King , or a Popish Tyrant , a sworn enemy to the Gospel of Christ , and the coming of His Kingdom . This is also inconsistent with that Rule & Directory of our prayers , commonly called The Lords prayer , not only because it cannot be reduced to any of its petitions ( which are comprehensive of all that we are warranted to pray for ) but because it is contradictory to the Second which is , Thy Kingdom come . The Coming of Christs Kingdom in our Land cannot consist with the preservation of the Tyrants reign , which is Satans rule : for Antichrists ● Satans Kingdom , and Christs , cannot be promoted both at once . It may be also demonstrated , that it is inconsistent with all the petitions of that perfect form of prayer . With the first , Hallowed be thy Name ; for when they who rule over His people make them to houl , then His Name continually every day is Blasphemed Isai , 52. 5. yea much profaned in the frequent repeating that imposition . With the Second , Thy Kingdom come for when He takes unto Him His great power & Reigns , then is the time He , will destroy them that destroy the earth , Revel . 11. 17 , 18. It is against the third , Thy will be done — for it is against His preceptive will that there should be a Throne of iniquity , it shall not have fellowship with Him ; as it would have , if according to His will. And therefore Habbakkuk pleads from the Lords Holiness & Righteousness against Tyrants , Habbak . 1. 13 , 14. It is against the fourth , Give us this day our daily bread , to pray for them that rob us of it , whom the Lord hath set over us for a plague , to domineer over our bodies , and all the means of life Neh. 9. 37. The Saints there make a Complaint of Kings , and pray to remove them , not to save them : The Church also prayes agains● base Rulers on this account , because under them they get their bread with the peril of their lives Lam. ● . 8 , 9. It is against the fifth , Forgive us our debts or sins ; for if we pray for taking away the guilt of sin , we must also pray for removing the punishment ; whereof this is one , to be under Tyrants : And if it be sin which brings on such a judgment , then it is sin to pray for the keeping of it on & continuing thereof : And though we should forgive their sin against us , yet we ought to complain against their sins against God , and the Church , in defiling it , & shedding the blood of the Saints Psal. 79. 1-7 . It is against the sixth , Lead us not into Temptation and deliver us from evil : for their Government is a continued tract of Temptation , they being a snare on Mizpah & a net spread upon Tabor Hos. 5. 1. And if we pray to be delivered from all evil , then we must pray to be delivered from Tyranny , which is a great evil . It is against the Conclusion also for thine is the Kingdom — & Glory : Tyrants being stated in opposition to the Glory of God. Again , in the next place , it is against many promises of giving good Rulers , and of breaking the yoke of Tyrants ( as I cited several above ) Neiether of which can consist with the preservation of Tyrants , if such a Prayer should be answered according to the idol of the heart of the supplicants : for if God should save this man as long as we may pray for him as a King , then all the promises of a Change & Revolution are precluded . Lastly , it is contrary to the constant tenor of the Saints prayers against theé Enemies of God. Deborah prayed upon the destruction of a Tyrant , So let all thine enemies perish O Lord Iudg. 5. ult . Iotham prayed against that bastard King , let fire come out from Abimelech & devour the men of Shechem , and — let fire come out from the men of Shechem & devour Abimelech , Iudg. 9. 20. David prayes against Saul , whom he calls Cush the Benjamite in the title of Psal. 7. alluding to Kish his Father , or because he was no better than an Ethiopian a Cushite Amos 9. 7. and could no more change his manners than an Ethiopian can change his skin Ier. 13. 23. See Pool Synops. Critic . in Locum . Where it is proven that this was Saul ; against him he prayes that the Lord would awake to Iudgement Psal. 7. 6. and that He would break the arm of the wicked and the evil man Psal. 10. 15. that He would not slay them ( to wit suddenly or in a common way ) lest the people forget , but scatter and bring them doun and consume them in wrath , that they may not be , that it may be known God ruleth in Iacob to the ends of the earth Psal. 59. 11 , 13. This is a Psalm against Dogs vers . 6. what Dogs ? Saul and his men watching David , See the Title . As also it is against Saul that he prayes , that the Lord would not grant his desires nor further his devices , and as for the head of them that compassed him about ( which was Saul ) let the mischief of their oun lips cover them Psal. 140. 8 , 9. There is also a prayer that the Saints may execute vengeance & the judgement written upon Tyrants , and bind them with chains Psal. 149. 7 , 8 , 9. The Church is brought in praying for vengeance against the Babylonian Tyrant , Nebuchadnezzar the King of Babylon hath devoured me — the violence done to me and my flesh be upon Babylon shall the Inhabitant of Zion say Ier. 51. 34 , 35. Paul imprecates any man that does not love the Lord Jesus , let him be Anathema Maranatha 1 Cor. 16. 22. and sure no Tyrant , persecuter & subverter of Christs Kingdom , can be a Lover of Christ. The Martyrs under the fifth seal slain for the Word of God , and the Testimony which they held , are brought in crying against the Tyrants that murdered them , How long ! O Lord , Holy & True , dost thow not judge & aveange our blood , Revel . 6. 9 , 10. Which though it be to be understood of a Moral Cry of blood , as Abels blood cried against Cain ; yet ought to be a pattern of our prayers against such Bloody Enemies , imbrewing their hands in the blood of our Brethren , for which we ought to pray that the Lord would haste to make inquisition . Durham Observes from this place , that Gods people in a holy way may pray for vengeance upon persecuters . 5. Let us consider the person & matter , for whom and for what this prayer is extorted . Either it is for the personal salvation of Iames the Papist : or the Royal preservation of Iames the Tyrant . It will not satisfie to pray , that if it be possible , and if it were the Lords will , he might be taken to Heaven , that so we might be quit of him . Neither were it Lawful to pray that , except we prayed first , that he might repent of this his wickedness , if perhaps it might be forgiven him , as Peter directed Simon M●gus to pray for himself Act. 8. 22. for it is unlawful to pray for the salvation of a Papist , except upon supposition of his repentance & relinquishing Poperie . We must pray nothing but according to the Wil of God ; and it is not the Wil of God , that they that have & keep & will not part with the Mark of the beast , should be saved , for he is adjudged of God to drink of the wine of His wrath Revel . 14. 9 , 10. So we cannot pray for him as a Christian , which he is not ; Nor as a Papist , except that he may get repentance . Nor can we pray for him as a King , which he is not ; nor as a Tyrant , except that he may repent of & relinquish his Tyranny & Usurpation : for Tyrants as such cannot be saved , no more than Papists as such ; for Tophet is ordained of old yea for the King it is prepared — Isai. 30. 33. We cannot then pray for his salvation , except we pray for his repentance , and relinquishing all his sins , and so we must pray for his relinquishing his Kingship , and that he may cease to be King ; for that is his sin , that he hath made himself King without God , and against the Laws of the Land. And now whil● he continues such , we must complain in prayer , not for his Misgovernment only , but for that he Governs , and desire to be delivered from him . See Gees Magistrates Original pag. 258. But now considering what a Man , and what a King he hath been , guilty of Murder , Adulterie , Idolatrie , under sentence of the Law both of God & Man ; We can pray no otherwise for him , than for a Murderer , Adulterer , or an Idolater . We cannot pray for him as Cloathed with Authority , or that the Lord may bless his Government for that is his sin & our Miserie that he is a Governour : And his Throne is a Throne of iniquity , which we dare not pray may have fellowship with God. Can we pray that God would bless him on a Throne of iniquity ? Could we pray , that the Lord would bless a Drunkard in his drunkenness , abusing his enjoyments ? Or a Thief in Stealing his , though he used his purchase never so soberly ? What if prevailing Robbers by Land , or pyrats by sea , preying upon all passengers , should require this as the sign of subjection to them , and only condition whereupon such as they apprehended & overcame should be suffered to live , that they should pray for preservation & prosperity to them ? Would not this be wickedness thus to pray for Thieves & Robbers ? And are not Tyrants the greatest of Thieves , that rob & destroy twenty for one of private Robbers ? And do they not require this as such a sign on such a Condition ? 6. Lastly , then the plea will be reduced to this , that it is exacted as a Badge of Loyaltie , and Sign , Tessera , & Sbibboleth of ouning the Authority . Which I have at this length endeavoured to prove , cannot be conscienciously Ouned by us , in these circumstances . And even by this Argument : That Authority which we cannot pray for we cannot oune : But we cannot pray for this Tyrannical Authority : Ergo — The Minor I trust is in some measure made manifest , by what is said above . And so I conclude this Head , with that forme of prayer , that I use for the King. O Lord God to whom vengeance belongeth , shew thy self ; lift up thy self thow Iudge of the Earth , render a reward to the proud . Lord how long shall the wicked ? how long shall the wicked Triumph ? Shall the Throne of iniquity have fellowship with thee , that Frameth Mischief by a Law ? The Mighty & Terrible God , destroy all Kings & people , that put to their hand to alter & destroy the House of God. Overturn , Overturn , Overturn this Throne of Tyra●ny , and let it be no more , until he come whose right it is . HEAD III. The Refusing to Swear & Subscribe the many unlawful imposed Oaths , for which many have suffered great Cruelties ; Chiefly that of Abjuration which was the Cause of Several their Suffering to Death , Vindicated . ANother Great Head of Grievous Sufferings in this fatal Period , hath been , that during this Stated War between Christ and His Enemies in Scotland , He hath no wanted Witnesses , who in their Wrestlings for the Word of God and the Testimony which they held , thought it their duty to refuse all illegally imposed & wickedly required Transactions with His Declared Enemies , and tampering any manner of way with them , in taking or subscribing any of their conscience-conzening Impositions of deceitful & destructive Bonds & Oaths , obtruded by men who have cast off all sense of a Deity or regard to Humanity , upon the Consciences of poor people , to debauch them and cast them doun from the only excellency , or integrity , that was left them : Whereby ( though they have missed of their design as to some , who through grace have escaped the snares of these fowlers , and in resisting have overcome through the blood of the Lamb ) they have prevailed to inveigle the Generality , even of the Professors of this Generation , into such a degree of defection & wretched Complyance with all their snares , that as it Prognosticates universal desolation ineluctable ( if it be not prevented by Repentance , as universal as the Complyance hath been ) So it proclaims the infamy of the Complyers perjurie , as indeleble as their perfidie with whom they have complyed . The Consideration of which woful Apostacie , in its various steps by which it hath been propogated & promoted , ought to deter & demur all the fearers of God , that would not partake of its threatened punishment , from venturing any more to come near the brink , or border of such precipices , and paths of the destroyer , when so many have stumbled , & fallen , & been hooked , & snared , & taken ; yea not so much as to look near them , lest they be left to follow their look , but to stand aloof from every appearance of Transacting with these Man-Catchers , yea Conscience-Catchers , who are so cunning to ensnare & destroy ; as their predicessors , to whose sins & Judgments also they serve themselves heirs , are described by the Holy Ghost Ier. 5. 26. — 29. They lay wait as he that setteth snares , they sct a trap , they catch men — their houses are full of deceit , therefore they are become great & waxen rich — shall I not visite for these things saith the Lord ? Many and manifold have been the snares , traps & gins , laid in the way of Professors of this Generation & Nation , by these Mischief-hatchers , these keen & cunning persecuters , the party now regnant or rather raging , in madness & malice against Christ and all that are Loyal & zealous for His Interest against their Encroachings thereon ; Where by they have caught & cozened many out of their Conscience , & have broken the neck of some , the Peace of others , & the heart of not a few . Yea no Nation can be instanced , wherein so many Oaths & Bonds , have been imposed on peoples Consciences , so nawseating for naughtyness & number as well as noxious in their nature , in an Age , as have been in Scotland within these 27 years past ; on design to wast all remainder of Conscience , or sense of Religion among people , that so having worn out the awful impression of it , they might introduce what they would , upon a people involved in the same Apostasie with themselves : And either to incorporate all with themselves in the same Combination against the Lord , or to exstirpate all Dissenters , who should discover any tenderness of Conscience , in not going along with them in the same excess of riot . And to the end they might have the greater concurrence & countenance , with the help of hells Policy , they contrived them in such terms , as might engage many to take them , and load the Recusants with odious obliquies , either as silly Scruplers , or seditious Schismaticks , or Rebells . For this hath been all alongs their grand project , to Level their designs against Religion , not directly & formally under that notion , but obliquely to the destruction of the Lovers & Professors of it , under the Nick-name of fanatical Enemies to Government . Of these ensnaring Engines levelled to these ends , some have been more patent & open , others more laten● & hidden ; both have made a prey of people , the last chiefly . For a snare , the more latent & hidden it be , and the more varnished over with the vermilion of pretended honesty & innocence , it is the more dangerous ; and will be ●o accounted by all the Circumspect & Cautious , as in its design more destructive , and in its effects when discovered more dolorous , than that which is more open & manifest . A hook , the bra●er that it is busked ; and the better that it is baited , the surer and more successful it is to catch the simple fish ; if it want its busking , they will not so readily bite at it . In vain is a net spread in the sight of any bird : yet , though this is a Truth , such silly birds have the bulk of us been , such silly doves without a heart , and so senslessly stupified , as to suffer our selves to be blind-folded & hood-winked into snares , of such a manifest baseness , as none could be readily supposed might fall into , who did not brutishly abandon all common sense of Reason , besides Religion : As the Test , and Oaths of arbitrary Allegiance , Bands of Conformity & irregular Regulation &c. Some again , and these Alas ! too many , have been insnared with snares of a more smooth , soft , & subtile Complexion , and poysoned with gilded arrowes , coloured over with the specious pretexts of the enemies relenting Condescendency & tenderness , stooping now to universal & general terms , obviously thought capable of a very good Construction , and daubed over with the untempered morter of the frequency of the almost universally unscroupled subscription of very good & Consciencious men , and the rarity of Recusants lying under the reproach of some few , wild , fantastical fools . These well busked hooks have caught many ; of which sort have been many banded Indemnities , and easily swallowed Oaths thereunto appended . Though the present indeed is contrived without gins of this sort , and now all these snares of Oaths and Bands are as illegally taken away as they were before imposed ; upon the same design , to catch silly fish by other methods ; not with hooks as before , but with a large spread net , to hale the whole School to Antichrists shore ; And to put to proof & practice the vastness of that Leviathan Prerogative of Absolute power , to dispense with all Oaths ; especially because , in all of them even the most monstrous , people might think there was some tye Obliging them to maintain the Protestant Religion , therefore to obliterate that , & bury it in oblivion , all now are taken away ; But the guilt of them still remains upon the Land , and the grievous Cry of sufferings for refusing them still continues ; And therefore the iniquity of them must be looked unto & lamented , and that with an eye to the account & reckoning must be rendered for thém , to a Greater Judgment than that of Creatures . But among all these destructive & diabolical devices , there have been none more charming & cheating , than that Cunningly Contrived Oath of Abjuration , as it is called , enjoined to be taken by all within the Kingdom , by a Proclamation about it Representing a late Declaration , emitted by that party whose sufferings I am vindicating ( as a Manifesto of their Grievances , and necessities to fall upon severe Resolutions towards their Enemies ) under ▪ the most odious Character , that the malice of men helped with hells hatred could devise ; And requiring all to Abjure it in the most peremptory manner , and under the severest penalty , that ever was heard . This Oath , I say , was contrived with such cunning , and followed with such keenness , that it hath involved moe under its obligation , and engaged more to subscribe it , than any other that went before it : because it hath been painted over with such pretexts , as never any before was capable of . The pressing of it hath been so impartial , upon all travelling in the Countrey &c. And their acceptance of the Pass annexed to it thought so necessary , as without it no business could be gone about . It s subscription so universally unscrupled , even by the Generality of great Professors & Ministers too ; the thing abjured represented so odious , as no honest man could refuse to renounce ; And the matter renounced , under its best aspect & Construction , esteemed only a paper Declaration , of a party very despicable , wherein the Principles , profession , or Confession of the Church seems no way concerned ; and if any way concerned , yet the Concern appearing so small , as few or none durst state their Sufferings upon that head . Yet I beleeve , if either such as have taken it , or others that may have the tentation of the like hereafter , will impartia●ly ponder it ; so much iniquity may be discovered in it , as may oblige the one to mourn in the sense of its sinfullness , and the other to beware of its danger . And so much the rather would I offer this to Consideration , that I know one who was wofully wheedled into it , that found the bitter effects of this poysoned pill in his wounded Conscience , after reflections on the deed , in such a measure that he despaired of ever recovering Peace . And this man had as much , and more to say , to justify his deed , than any that ever took it ; having it with all the advantages that ever it could be tendered with : for , being urged thereunto before the Iusticiary , he expressly refused to disoun that Declaration , and the Principles whereupon it was founded , and told them that it was misrépresented in the Proclamation : And when they yeelded to an abstract disouning of it in so far as the Proclamation represents it , or if so be it might be so represented , he gave in a sense in writ , wherein he would take it ; shewing that upon supposition the Declaration did assert such things as was represented , he would disoune it : And after the sense was accepted as satisfactorie , he refused to swear after the ordinary manner , following the Clerks blind manuduction , but behoved to have it written doun : And when it was written , with express specification of that Apologetical Declaration , he refused to swear it , till it was altered and corrected , And the Word pretended put in the stead of it : which done , before he subscribed it , he protested it might be constructed in no other sense , than the genuine meaning of the words he delivered in , and that it might not be reckoned a Complyance for fear of his life : yet not withstanding of all this , he lost the Jewel of inward peace , and knew the terror of the Lord for many dayes . Therefore I shall chiefly insist on discovering the iniquities of this last Oath , called the Abjuration Oath , both because it is the smoothest , and more generally taken than any other , and approven by many that condemns the rest , and the refusing it hath been punished by death , and most illegally pressed upon all , under the penalty thereof , as none of the rest was ; And because as all other Oaths successively imposed , were so contrived that the last did alwise imply & involve the substance of the former , So it will appear that the iniquity of none of the preceding Oaths was altogether wanting in this . But to the end , both the Complication of the iniquities of this Oath may be evidenced , and the Continued strain of all the Oaths ( which have also been heads of suffering , though not to this degree ) may be discovered ; I shall touch somewhat of all the sorts of them , And shew that their iniquity cleaves to this last Oath : And then come to canvass this Oath it self , After I have premitted some General Concessions . First , In a few Words some General Concessory propositions may be premitted . 1. That Oaths both Assertory and promissory are Lawful , will not be denyed but by Quakers &c. It is clear , Swearing is a Moral duty , and so material , that oftentimes it is used for the whole Worship of God Deut. 6. 13. Thow shalt fear the Lord thy God , and shall serve Him , and Swear by His Name Deut. 10. 20. — To Him shalt thow cleave & Swear by His Name . The reason is , because by whomsoever we swear , Him we profess to be our God , and invocate Him as witness of our hearts uprightness , & honest meaning in the thing sworn , according as it is understood by both parties , and as aveanger if we prove false . Hence every Oath which doth not bind us faster to serve & cleave to Him , is but a breach of the Third Command . Again it is not only Commanded as a duty , but qualified how it should be performed Ier. 4. 1 , 2. Where it is required of a people returning to the Lord , to Swear in Truth , in Iudgement , and in Righteousness . Hence every Oath which is not so qualified , and does not consist with a penitent frame , is sin . It is likewise promised in the Covenant , that Beleevers shall speak the language of Canaan , & swear to the Lord Isai 19. 18. every Oath then that is not in the language of Canaan , is unsuitable to Beleevers , that is to say , Consentaneous to the Word of God , and Confession of our faith . Again , He that sweareth in the earth shall swear by the God of Truth Isai. 65. 16. and therefore that Oath which is not according to Truth , is dishonourable to the God of Truth . If all the Oaths imposed upon Scotland these many years , were examined by these Touch-stones , they would be found all naught . So giving Bands for security , which for obligation are equivalent to promissory Oaths , are also Lawful materially : but with the same qualifications , otherwise they are sinful . 2. This duty when suitably discharged , truely , judiciously , righteously , in the fear of God , according to His. Will , is in many cases very necessary . Not onely in vowes , in which God is the party , in matters morally necessary , to keep the righteous Iudgements of God , Psal. 119. 106. Nor only in National Covenants for Reformation , and promoting the Interest of Christ , whereof we find many Instances in Scripture , in Moses , Ioshua , Asa , Hezekiah , Iosiah , Ezra , Nehemiah , their making & renewing such Covenants by Oath , coming under the dreadful Curse of it if they should break it . And this may make our hearts meditate Terror , for the universal unparalelled Breach of Solemn Covenants with God , that exposes the Nation to the Curse of it . But also in humane Transactions , whereunto God is invocated as a Witness ; as in National Transactions , at choosing & inaugurating their Magistrates , for security of Religion & Liberties , as we have many examples in Scripture . Seldome indeed do such bonds hold Tyrants , but it is this Generations indeleble brand & bane , that without this they have come under the yoke of ineluctable slavery , and have entailed it upon posterity . As likewise in Contracts & mutuàl Compacts of Friendship or stricter Association , when Edification or other Sa●faction or security Calls for it , as Iacob sware to Laban , David to Ionathan &c. In which the matter must be clear , & mutually understood , & honestly meant , without ( equivocation & mental Reservation , and all ambiguity , as also possible & likely to continue so : for otherwise , it were but a mocking of God & man , to swear a thing we either cannot or will not perform , according to the meaning of him in whose favours the Oath is given . But withall we ought to be sparing in such things , except where the matter of the Oath or Band is weighty & necessary , & not multiply them needlessly upon formality or Custom : for if there were suitable Confidence in one another , there would not be need for so many of these securities . And specially in Relative stipulations betwixt man & wife &c. Where an indissolvable relation is entered into . And in a particular manner , even in things Civil , when we are called thereunto by a Lawful maigstrate , for deciding of Contraversies , or our oun vindication , or to Confirm our Obligation to some duty , An Oath for Confirmation is an end of all strif● Heb. 6. 16. But alwise in this the matter must be Lawful , according to the will of God , and true , & certainly known , and also necessary , weighty , useful , worthy of such Confirmation , for the Glory of God , and the good of our Neighbour , that His Holy Name be not ●aken in vain ; for otherwise if the matter be false , God is made Witness of a lie ; if uncertain , Conscience Conde●ns us that we know not , nor care not , what we call God Witness to ; if unlawful , then God is called to approve what He hath comdemned , and so to contradict Himself which is horrid Blasphemy . With all which Cases , if we compare & examine all these Delusory Oaths , & hell-devised Impositions on Consciences in these dayes , obtruded to debauch & insnare them ; Not one of them , levelling all at one design , how smoothly soever conceived , can be taken without a wound & wramp to the Conscience . 3. Of all these Cases , only two are applicable to our imposed Transactions with our wicked Rulers , to wit , in the matter of friendly Contracts , or in the matter of Judicial Appearances before them , and Swearing and Banding before them , and to them . In both which , there must be a sort of Confederation with them . In Contracts with them it will not be doubted : And in Judicial submitting to their Authoritative Impositions of such Securities , it is evident , there must be also a Confederation with them , not only in acknowledging their Authority , but in coming under mutual exacted stipulations ; wherein , by taking these Oaths & Bands , we give them security of orderly ●ubjection , as members of the Community whereof they are Judges , and get their security of acquittance , and that we shall not be molested nor prosecuted among the Recusan●s . Now concerning this Confederation , I shall concede in two cases it may be ouned , and Consequentially Oaths & Bands may be given to men of their stamp . 1. A Confederation which is more Discretive or Discriminative may be allowed to them ; that is , such bargains wherein they and we are kept still divided as two parties , and not under one Incorporation , as in Contracts of Conhabitation , liveing under them as Tenants , buying & selling , and the like . But we cannot enter into a Confederation unitive with them , which may make us one body or party . 2. A Confederation which is necessary & unavoidable ; when either an unavoidable strife or contention doth arise between them & us , whereupon we are compelled to answer in Law , and can no otherwise be decided but by our Oath of Confirmation , which is an end of all strife ; or when we are falsly accused of some odious & heinous Crime , as of Murder or Adultery : It is then Lawful & necessary to vindicate our selves , by giving all these Legal Confirmations that we are free of these things ; for otherwise to lye under the imputation of such enormities , were shamefully scandalous to Religion . But we cannot allow any Transactions of this sort , which are elective & voluntary , to make or pursue either peace or pleas with them , when our oun Interest or benefit draweth us thereunto , but ere we go to Law or give Oaths & Bonds to and before the unjust and perfidious , and such also as we cannot oune as Magistrates , we would rather take wrong & suffer our selves to be defrauded , as the Apostle adviseth 1 Cor. 6. 1 , 7. It was not unlawful , as Expositors shew from that place , for the Corinthians to answer in Law for their oun vindication , being pursued by a Heathen , but it was utterly a fault to go voluntarly one with another . And if to pursue a brother was a fault , then much more to go to Law with an Apostate , with whom there should be less medling . And if to go before the unjust Magistrates , as these Heathen Judges were at Corinth who yet were Magistrats , was utterly a fault , then much more to go before such as have neither rightful nor righteous Authority at all : Which yet must be acknowledged , if we take Oaths & Bands before them ; for none can exact these but acknowledged Magistrates . Hence it is apparent , it would be an Elective Confederation with these wicked Usurping Judges , when brought before them to take their tendered Oaths and Bands , not as parties pursued before them , but as transacting with them , with whom as well as before whom we must give these Confirming Securities : And so not only must we acknowledge them to be Gods , among whom the Lord ●itteth , whose Holy Name is interposed in such Solem Transactions , but also we must swear & enter in bands to them as they require . This indeed is necessar when called before them against our will , and accused of horrid Crimes ; as was alwayes in the imposition of the Oath of Abjuration audaciously imputed to the Refusers , that they asserted Murdering Principles , and ounéd it Lawful to kill all that served the King ; In such a Case , to declare with the most solemn Asseverations , for vindication of Truth , that we disoune not only all such Assertions , but all such thoughts as that it is Lawful to kill all that serve the King , or any that serve him because they serve him , or because they have injured us any manner of way , & to declare our abhorrence of all Murder & Assassinations . But to swear such things to them , when we are altogether innocent , would be a granting that we were legally suspect , by offering a legall purgation . And so all the Subjects of Scotland should take upon them to purge themselves from a suspicion of Murder , which were odious . And to abjure a Declaration as asserting such things , when it asserts no such thing , is a Swearing to a lie . 4. All Solemn Securities of Oaths , or Bonds that are Sacred Promises , are stricti juris of most strict & indispensible obligation , as Mr Durham on the Third Command shewes in many cases : No mans loss or private prejucice can make it void ( though we swear to our oun hurt we must not change Psal. 15. 4. ) Nor indifferency in the matter , if once engaged in ( for then our Souls are bound Numb . 30. 2. ) Nor deceit of others , if the deceit be circumstantial only , as in the Gibeonites case : Nor the exstortion of it by fear or violence , if the matter be Lawful : Nor rashness and sin in the manner , if Lawful in the matter , as with the Gibeonites : Nor another meaning afterwards devised , not according to the Imposers mind , nor our oun at first who took it ( that 's but a swearing deceitfully Psal. 24. 4. ) Nor any good meaning or design in reversing the Oath ( Saul was punished for breaking his Oath with the Gibeonites , out of zeal 2 Sam. 21. 2. ) Nor though the Oath be conceived by Creatures , ( as by the Altar or Temple &c. Math. 23. 20-22 . Nor when the thing becomes impossible , if that possibility could have been foreseen or prevented : Nor any other secret meaning , by equivocation or mental reservarion , which are abominable : Nor any Dispensation from Pope Or King : Nor any other posterior Oath . None of these things can make an Oath void , but if we have bound our selves God will require it ; for who so despises an Oath , by breaking the Covenant , when lo he hath given his hand be shall not escape , God will recompense it Ezek. 17. 18 , 19. They are null indeed & of no force , when they become bonds of iniquity tying to things unlawful or impossible ; or when the thing sworn is not in our oun power Numb . 30. 5. Or when there is deceit in it , not in Circumstantialls only , but in Essentialls ; Or when it hinders a greater good ; when the case Materially altereth ; or when the party sworn to relaxeth us . All these do condemn the horrid breach of the Sacred & Solemn League & Covenant , and Confutes the perverting & wresting the words of it in the third Article , as if it did oblige to Allegiance to Tyrants ; for in that case the obligation is unlawful , and there is a deceit in essentialls , and the case materially altereth ( for in the Covenant we are bound to the King , not to a Tyrant ) and the party sworn to hath relaxed us long ago , by annulling the Covenant yet all these things prove , that the Covenant is still in force : And that all the Oaths & bonds contradictory to it , are sinful : and yet , thô it be sinful to take them , and sinful to keep them , it is nevertheless perjury to break them , especially to them whose erroneous conscience is bound by them , under a Notion of their Lawfulness . And in a special manner , it is here conspicuous , how deceitful a jugle that sinful shift of many hath been , that they could subscribe an unlawful bond under a penalty ; As for example , to answer to their Courts , or to go to Church , or separate from the persecuted Meetings of the Lords people , under such a penalty , which they thought to pay the penalty would clear them of , as if it were only an Alternative band . The iniquity of this Juggle will appear , if we consider , such Bonds cannot be Alternative : for Alternatives are alwayes disjunctive , binding equally either to this or that ; and the one Alternative is no more determinately enjoyned by the Imposer , than the other . And so , if these Bonds were Alternative , it should be in the binders choise , whether to Answer the Court , go to Church , to separate Meetings ; Or pay so much money . But it is not so , for the Stipulation & promise is determinate to the obligation , for which the bond is required , and the penalty is annexed , as a punishment of the breach of that obligation . And that fancy of cluding the bond by paying the penalty , would quite enervate all security among men , in their mutual compacts of that nature ; and under that pretence , they might give a satisfactory Complyance to the most wicked imposed obligation imaginable● to subscribe the Turks Alcoran , with a reserved intention only to pay the imposed penalty . Which Reservation is so far from being suitable to that Christian Simplicity the Gospel requires , that it does not answer that Moral honesty that our concern in the good of humane Societie calls for . It s incumbent on all that expect to Dwell in Gods Holy hill , to have this requisite qualification for one , though they swear to their oun hurt they will not change it , and they must be far from swearing deceitfully : And Consequently , if they bind themselves by a promise , which a Christian should be no less tender of than of his Oath , they must keep it . And besides , to condescend that that penalty or fine should be paid , by our selves or friends in our behalf , were to condescend that these Enemies should be enriched by our oun or the spoil of our friends , upon the account of the forfeiture of our promise ; which seems such a dishonest & dishonourable thing , that an honest heart would disdain it . And though this should be flouted as foolish preciseness , to choose rather to lye still & suffer in such a case ; yet it may be considered that Christs Cross , even with reproaches , is alwise a better Choise , than the works Ease , purchased at any price which is a hire for Christs enemies . 5. All Divines and Casuists do grant , that an Oath must be taken in his sense & meaning who tenders it , and in whose favours it is conceived : because Oaths and Bonds are for security , and therefore whosoever would deal honestly & Christianly in taking an Oath , must take in the sense that it is understood by such as impose it : Otherwise the Holy Name of God should be taken in vain , and the swearers & promisers shall deal deceitfully , in frustrating the end of the Oath or bond , and the design of the tenderers thereof . And therefore , as Reason & Religion requires , that all Oaths or Bonds be so conceived and enunciated , that all concerned may understand them , and if there be any doubt how far they bind , the Imposers should explain the same , as Abraham did to his servant : So Conscience requires , that they be alwayes taken in the Imposers sense , and as they discover their sense & sentiments of them , and not according to the meaning that we may think the words Capable of ; Nor yet according to the wheedling explications that they may give or allow , which are as deceitful & insnaring as the things themselves . Nor is it to be looked upon as a favour to get a Liberty to put a sense upon them , contrary to their known meaning ; for that is but a Liberty to mock God , to mock others , and our selves too , and nothing but a snare to the Conscience . And to put a Gloss upon printed Oaths or Bonds , which in strict Construction they will not bear , and then to subscribe them inte●ninis as offered , is not only an intangling our selves into the bond of sinful Oaths & Bonds , but to stumble the Godly , and harden the wicked in the present , and to mock posterity in future ages ; who shall see the Oaths in terminis subscribed , but not the sense they were taken in , See Apolog. Relat. Sect. 14. It is known by manifold experiences that it is dangerous to hearken to their overtures who study to ensnare us , but far more hurtful & hateful to propound overtures to them . For they interpret it a Ceding and giving ground , and when they see a man begining to yeeld , then they will seem to be very condescending , even to accept of litle at first that they may draw him on to more : like cuning Anglers , sometimes recoyling & drawing back the well baited & busked hook , to invite the poor unwary fish to pursue , and sometimes leting it run away with the hook , when it begins to bite kindly : So when thy find a man offering & ready to accept of Accommodations , they will be very yeelding and easie , but with a design to hook him . But Conscience can find no safety at present , nor satisfaction afterwards in accommodations with them . For it is plain to all that are not blinded with Ignorance , or partiality , or a Judicial stroak , that our Imposers are such sons of Belial as cannot be taken with hands , or by the hand ; And if we reflect upon the matters upon which these Accommodations are to be offered or accepted , they are not things upon which we may come & go , upon our discretion , as we do with our oun particulars , or with Problems to be disputed , or ambiguous propositions capable of different senses ; but matters so & so circumstantiate , as do require the positive determinate Judgement of the Conscience , Concerns of Truth & falshood , duty & sin , which cannot admit of Accommodation , or dispensation , or Reservation , or any other sense than the Imposers and they that state their Inquisition about such things do oune , and are observably known to have & maintain about them . Otherwise , all other forged Accommodations are but tampering tricks , jugling with juglers , deceiving the deceivers , in such a way as does not well consist with the simplicity of the Gospel , or the doves innocency : for what is that but a swearing or promising deceitfully ! Psal. 24. 4. a conceiving & uttering from the heart words of falshood Isai. 59. 13. a false Oath Zech. 8. 17. which are hateful to God , who will be a swift Witness against 〈◊〉 swearers Mal. 3. 5. Neither will they be so easily deceived , for they will readily yeeld to accommodations , or any tolerable sense that we can put upon their snares ; for they reckon that a yeelding in part , and are glead to find us so far justifying their acts & impositions , as by our offer practically to declare they bear a good sense , and they will come many wayes to our hand to get us kooked so . Secondly , These things being premitted , I shall offer Reasons why it was necessary in point of Conscience , to Refuse all the Oaths hitherto tendered , and Consequently Consciencious Sufferers upon this Account will be vindicated . And first some General Reasons against all of them together , and Then a Word to each sort of them . 1. There is one General Argument , that will Condemn coming in any terms of Oaths or Bonds with that party , that have broken the Covenant , overturned the Reformation , and destroyed the people of the Lord : Because such Transactions with them ( as is hinted above ) are a sort of Confederacy with the known Enemies of Truth & Godliness , importing a voluntary subjection to them , Complyance & Incorporation with them , as members of the same Community , whereof they are acknowledged to be head . Now all such sort of Confederacy with such malignant Enemies of God and of the Church , is unlawful , as Mr. Gillespie demonstrates in his Useful Case of Conscience , concerning Associations & Confederacies with Idolaters , or any known Enemies of Truth & Godliness . Though Civil Compacts for common Commerce may be allowed , as Abram was confederate with Aner , Eshcol , & Mamre Gen. 14. 13. Iacob Covenanted with Laban by way of Lawborrowes Gen. 31. 44. But Sacred Confederations of this sort , are unlawful from these Arguments . 1. The Law of God condemns them Exod. 23. 32. Thow shalt make no Covenant with them , nor with their gods , they shall not dwell in thy Land , lest they make thee sin against me — Where not only Religious Covenants are discharged in a tolleration of their Idolatry , but familiar Conversation also , they shall not dwell in thy Land. If then we must not suffer them , if in Capacity , sure we must far less be imposed upon by them ; if we are not to be familiar with heathens , far less with Apostates , that calls themselves Christians : for the Apostle layes much more restraint from communion with them , than with Pagans 1 Cor. 5. 10 , 11. The reason of the Law , lest they make thee sin , as long therefore as there is that hazard of sinning , the Law obliges to that caution . So Exod. 34. 12-16 . Take heed to thy self lest thow make a Covenant with the inhabitants of the Land — lest it be a snare — but ye shall destroy their Altars — lest thow make a Covenant with them — and they go a whoring after their gods and thow take of their daughters unto thy sons — Here again , all Sacred Transactions are discharged , upon a Moral & perpetually binding ground , and all Toleration is prohibited , and Conjugal Affinity . Such complyance brought on the first desolating Judgment , the flood on the old world ( Gen. 6. 1 , 2 , 3. ) when the Godly conformed & incorporated themselves , and joined in affinity with that ungodly crew , from whom they should have separated themselves . Likewise Deut. 7. 2 , 3 , 4 , 5. — Thow shalt make no Covenant with them , nor shew mercy unto them , neither shalt thow make marriages with them — for they will turn away thy son from following Me — so shall the anger of the Lord be kindled against yow — but thus shall ye deal with them , ye shall destroy their Altars . Where all Transactions with a people devoted to destruction are discharged , even that of tolleration of Malignant enemies ; according to which precept , David resolveth to destroy early all the wicked of the Land , and cut off all wicked doers from the City of the Lord Psal. 101. 8. Mark this All , of what degree or quality so ever , without respect of persons . And lest it should be thought this is meant only of these seven Nations there enumerate , the Law is interpreted by the Spirit of God of many other Nations ; where Solomon is condemned for joining in affinity with other wicked people , besides these 1 King. 11. 1 , 2. So that it is to be understood generally : against Confederacies with all , to whom the Moral ground is applicable , & the danger of insnaring the people of God. It is clear likewise , we must have nothing to do with the wicked , but to treat them & with them as enemies Psal. 139. 21 , 22. with whom as such there can be no Confederation ; for that supposes alwayes the enmity is laid aside , but that can never be between the Professors of Religion and the professed Enemies thereof : but that must alwayes be the language of their Practice , Depart from me ye workers of iniquity , for the Lord hath heard me Psal. 6. 8. The command is peremptory & perpetual , for sake the foolish , Prov. 9. 6. make no friendship with them , Prov. 22. 24. Say not a Confederacy to them Isai. 8. 12. Where it is clear from the opposition in that Text , betwixt Confederating with the wicked and the fear of God , that the one is not consistent with the other . There is an express discharge to yoke or have any fellowship with them 2 Cor. 6. 14. to the end — for what fellowship hath righteousness with unrighteousness ? — what Concord hath Christ with Belial ? — wherefore come out from among them and be separate — 2. Many fad & sharp reproofs for such Transactions & Confederations , do conclude the same thing Iud. 2. 1 , 2 , 3. — Isaid — ye shall make no league with the Inhabitants of this Land , yow shall throw doun their Altars , but yow have not obeyed my voice , why have yow done this ? Wherefore — I will not drive them out from before yow — It cannot be expected , the Lord will drive out these enemies , if we swear subjection & Allegiance , & come under Confederations with them ; for thereby we contribute actively to their settlement & establishment , and bring our selves not only under the miserie , but the guilt of strengthening the hands of evil doers . So Ier. 2. the people of God are reproved , for making themselves home born slaves ; how ? by out-Landish Confederacies vers . 18. Now what hast thow to do in the way of Egypt , to drink the waters of Sihor ? or what hast thow to do in the way of Assyria ? — The Chaldee Paraphrase hath it , Nunc ergo quid vobis contrahendo Societatem cum Pharaone rege Egyptiorum ? — & quid vobis percutiendo faedus cum Assyria . — What have yow to do Associate with Pharaoh King of Egypt ? and what have yow to do to make a Covenant with the Assyrian ? So may we say , what have we to do to take their Oaths & Bonds , that are as great enemies as they were . Ephraim is reproved for mixing himself among the people Hos. 7. 8. by making Confederacies with them ; what followes ? he is a Cake not turned , hot in the neither side , zealous for earthly things , but cold & raw in the upperside , remiss in the things of Christ. And this we have seen in our experience to be the fruit of such bargains , or bonds , or Oaths , that they that were ingaged in them , have alwise in some measure fallen from their former fervor for Christ. Nay we shall find , that such Transactions are seldom or never recorded in the Book of God without a reproof , or some greater Mark of Gods displeasure put upon them ; which doubtless ●s set purposely as beacons , that we may beware of them . And therefore . 3. We may take notice of many disallowed & condemned examples , on which the Lord sets marks of wrath , as Ahabs Covenant with Benhadad , 1 King. 20. 32. to the end : Asa's Covenant with Benhadad , which the Prophet calls a foolish deed 2 Chron. 16. from begin . to vers . 10. proceeding from an evil heart of unbelief ; as all such Transactions are over-awed Complyances . Iehosaphats with Abab hath the same Censure , though he kept himself free of Ahabs Idolatrie , and Ahab seemed to have been penitent before he joined with him , and his relation to him was very near , the enemy of both was an Infidel , the cause was good to recover a city of refuge , the manner of his proceeding was Pious consulting the Prophets , and his end good ; yet all this did not justify that wickedness , related 2 Chron. 18. and reproved 2 Chron. 19. 2. Iehu the Prophet is sent to him , Should thow love them that hate the Lord ? therefore is wrath upon thee from before the Lord. After this , when he joined himself with Ahaziah , who did very wickedly , the Lord brake his works 2 Chron. 20. 35. to the end : which made him afterwards mend his fault , for he would not again joine with him , when he sought the like Association 1 King. 22. 49. So Amaziah's bargain with the Israelites , when the Lord was not with them , is condemned by the Prophet , admonishing him to disjoyne himself from them 2 Chron. 25. 7-10 . And Ahaz his bargain with Tiglath-Pilnasser the Assyrian 2 Chron. 28. 16. &c. is plainly disallowed . 4. The complaints , Confessions , & Lamentations of the Lords people , mourning over this sin , demonstrate the evil of it Ezra , 9. 14. Should we again break thy Commandments , & join in affinity with the people of these abominations ? wouldst not thow be angry with us , till thow hadst consumed us , so that there should be no remnant nor escaping ? Psal. 106. 35. They were mingled among the heathen and learned their works . All these commands , Reproofs , Examples , & complaints , are written for our learning ; and being seriously laid to heart , will sufficiently scare all the fearers of God , to Join but stand aloof from all complyances , conjurations , or confederacies with the enemies of God , directly or indirectly , formally or interpretatively , for fear of partaking of their sins and receiving of their plagues . I insist the more largely on this Argument , both because it will conclude that for which these proofs are adduced , to condemn all bonding or bargaining with Malignant Enemies ; And because it will vindicate the aversion of this poor persecuted Remnant , from associating in expeditions of war , with promiscuous subverters & perverters of the cause , on which it were not so proper to my purpose to dilate any discourse in a distinct head , while I must confine my self only to the heads of Sufferings . Only because it may be Objected , and it will be profitable to consider it , that these Scriptures disprove only voluntary & elective confederations with the wicked , but cannot condemn necessitated subscriptions of Lawful Obligations , when the matter is not sinful ; Nor come they home to the case of Prisoners , who are constrained to transact & treat , and have to do with the men in power : Otherwise , if all bonds were unlawful , then Prisoners might not procure Liberty for longer or shorter time , upon bond & bail to answer again when called ; Which yet is generally approven , and practised without scruple , and seems not to want a precedent in Scripture , in that Iason gave such security Act. 17. 9. I shall therefore subjoin here some considerations , by way of Answer to this . 1. These Scriptures disprove all Covenants Exod. 23. 32. All confederacies Isai. 8. 12. all concord or aggreement with the men of Belial 2 Cor , 6. 15. and , without distinction of voluntary or over-awed Transactions , all Unitive aggreements of whatsoever sort are discharged , and can no more be restricted to the particulars there specified , as if any other Covenant , confederacy , or concord might be Lawful that were not a joining in Marriage , an assotiating in war , or communion in Worship with them , than the Moral grounds of these Prohibitions can be so restricted : for the hazard of sin & snares , the hurt of faithless fears , from whence they flow , and the hatefulness of such unequal Conjunctions , which are the grounds & reasons of these Laws , as may be seen in these forecited places , cannot be restricted to the particulars specified . But now all the tendered Oaths & Bonds of our Adversaries , when subscribed as they require , yea even those Transactions of Prisoners for procuring their Liberty , on terms of engaging to re-enter themselves according to aggreement with their persecuters , are Unitive Covenants or Conditional aggreements , giving solemn securities for their respective obligations , upon terms wherein both parties accord : for these bonds are given to them , and not only before them , as was said . They are confederacies of the Subjected , seeking the peace & favours of their superiours , which when over-awed are sinful to be made with wicked Enemies of Religion , as well as when unconstrained , for Ahaz his transaction with the Assyrian , was forced out of fear , and yet it is called a sinful confederacy , not to be homologated by any of the fearers of the Lord Isai. 8. 12. They are concords and aggreements with the unrighteous sons of Belial , and not about common matters , but matters wherein Religion & Righteousness are nearly concerned : Can any think that these Commands are given with exception of Prisoners ? And that if any Isralite was Prisoner to these Nations , he might make a Covenant with them for his Liberty , upon an engagment to render himself Prisoner to them again ? Then he might give bond to Gods devoted enemies , to bind up his hands from prosecuting the war with them , which all Israel was obliged to do : for if they might Covenant subjection to them , then it would have been their sin to rebel , as it was Zedekiahs sin to rebel against Nebuchadnezzar , because it was breach of Covenant : And so there might be a case , wherein the Israelites , notwithstanding of all these Prohibitions , would bee obliged not to destroy , nor break doun their Altars , to wit , if they made such a bargain with them for their Liberty , to surrender themselves as their subjects . Now we read , many times they were brought under subjection , and that as a punishment of their leaguing with them , and yet they broke the yoke , when they cried unto the Lord , and never submitted any longer than they were able to deliver themselves . Whence it is plain , that they never bound themselves to such subjection by Oath , bond , or promise , for that would have been no mercy which was purchased by Treachery . 2. It is a voluntary compact with the men in power , to procure Liberty upon bond to answer again , and cannot be called necessitated ; or if it be , it is but a necessitated sin . It must be voluntary , because it is an act of the will , and the will cannot be forced ; It s the Consent of the will , and the Consent cannot but be voluntary , in so far as it is a Consent ; and by this , whereas before their so procured Liberty they were prisoners by Constraint , now when they must return to prison , they are prisoners by Consent : It s the prisoners Choise , whether he will come out upon these terms or not , and every Choise in so far as it is a Choise , is elective & voluntary : It s put to the mans choise whether he wil continue under the Cross , and continue his Testimony for the cause , or surcease from it for a time , the Latter in the case is chosen . It s the prisoners desire and petition , to transact with them in these terms for Liberty without which no benefit of any such bond can be procured , and every desire is voluntary . Yea it is a formal Compact & Capitulation with them , binding & obliging these bonders by their oun word & writ , at least to be at their Call & Command , not by Compulsion & force now , but by the Moral obligation of their oun compact : Now every such compact is voluntary . And therefore , if all voluntary Covenants , Confederacies , & Aggreements be discharged in Scripture , then this bond of Compearance also must be discharged . The Judgement of famous Mr Rutherfoord , of a draught of a petition to have been presented to the Committee of Estates , by those Ministers who were prisoners in the Castle of Edinburgh , will confirm what is said : we find it in the Third part of his Letters Numb . 63. where are these words , I am straitned as another suffering man , but dare not petition this Committee . 1. Because it drawes us to Capitulate with such as have the advantage of the mount , the Lord of disposing for the present , and to bring the matters of Christ to yea and no ( yow being prisoners , and they the powers , is a hazard . 3. This Aggreement with the Enemies for Liberty , upon these terms , is sinful . For it is not only an acknowledgment of a wicked power , in ouning & transacting with them as Judges , who can free them and bind them as prisoners by Law , which is disproved above : But it is a binding themselves over to a pacqued , perverse , & Law-perverting Judicatory , not as prisoners by forcible constraint , but a willing consent , ackowledging the Legality of their imprisonment , and obliging themselves to observe it when demanded : yea it is a Covenanted & bonded obedience to a wicked Law ; for it is a wicked Law , to exact from a Sufferer for Truth , his re-entrie to prison , for no crime but his duty . As also it is a justifying of a wicked sentence , for it is a wicked sentence , that an innocent man shall return to prison when they please ; which is justified when they bind themselves to obey it . This is nowise like a mans going to the Gibbet on his oun feet ; for the man does not bind himself to do that , neither is it exacted of him as an obedience to a Law , nor is it given forth as a part of his sentence , Only he chooseth it for his oun ease : But if all these did concur , it were unlawful for a Martyr for Righteousness to obey such a Law , or voluntarly to submit to such a wicked sentence . Neither is it of any pertinency to urge , that it is Lawful for a man to submit so far to a Robber , as to bind himself to return to him against such a day with another purse to him : For this is a necessitated bargain , to give what a man hath and promise more to save his life , and is like a mans casting his goods out at sea to save the ship ; The other is not so but elective : This is only a Choise of the least of two evils of suffering , but the other is a choise of one of two evils which is sin , which cannot come under a Christians election at all : This is a compact with the Robber , which is still discretive , and nowise unitive of the Robber & him , in any bargain of concord or consederacy or acknowledged subjection , only a passive surrender to his greater force as an enemy ; But the other is unitive , as between Rulers & Ruled : This is not any obedience to a Law , nor is the mans purse required to be given or promised under that notion , as the other is , I shall here also subjoin some more of that foresaid Letter of Mr Rutherfoords , In the 2 place , sayes he , A speaking to them in writ , and passing in silence the sworn Covenant & the cause of God , which is the very present Controversie , is contrary to the practice of Christ and the Apostles , who being accused or not accused avouched Christ to be the Son of God , and the Messias , and that the dead must rise again , even when the Adversarie mistated the question ; Now plain it is , that neither in the bonds nor petitions , is there any word of the cause or Testimony suffered for . 4. As it is sinful , so it is very scandalous in several respects ; in that at least it hath the appearance of evil , which Christians should abstain from 1 Thes. 5. 22. and seems to be a voluntary subjecting themselves to their Impositions ( at least of that to return to prison again ) a willing acknowledgment of their unjust Usurpations ; a spontaneous consenting to their Mischiefs framed into a Law , & exacted under the Notion of a Law ; A gratifying of the enemies of Religion , and pleasing them more than any thing a prisoner can do , except he should wholly deny the cause ; and therefore chiefly always this overture is most acceptable from those that durst give any Testimony , because they look upon it as some indication of their fainting or falling from it , or of their wearying of the Cross of Christ , of which they are very glad ; And an offending and making sad the hearts & condemning the practice , of some truly tender & zealous Confessors of Christ , who have had strong tentations to make such transactions , and durst not yeeld so far for a world ; yea it is certainly an Argument of faithless fear , & impatient wearying of the Cross because of the fury of the Oppressor , which the Lord taxeth , when the Captive hasteneth that he may be loosed , and that he should not die in the pit , nor that his bread should fail , which is a dishonour to Him who hath promised to bear their charges , and hath given them many encouragments to trust , that He will open a door in His oun time & way , see Isai. 51. 13 , 14. Of this Rutherfoord addeth in that forecited Letter , Silence of the cause of God which Adversaries persecute , seems a tacite deserting of the cause , when the state of of the Question is known to beholders , and I know the Brethren intend not to leave the cause . And a litle after , sayes he , The draught of that petition which yow sent me , speaks not one word of the Covenant of God , for the adhering to which yow now suffer , and which is the Object of mens hatred , and the destruction whereof is the great work of the times ; and your silence in this nick of time ) appears to be a not confessing of Christ before men , and yow want nothing to begen an uncleanly deliverance , but the profession of silence : which is professed by all , that petition for such a bond , when their address & transaction speaks no more in favours of the cause , than if they denied it . It is plainly a coming out of prison without a Testimony , which cannot consist with faithful & zealous suffering for Christ , and is far from the choise of Christs Witnesses , who overcame by the blood of the Lamb and the Word of their Testimony , recorded Heb. 11. 35. — who were tortured not accepting de●iverance , that they might obtain a better resurection . 5. As it is Scandalous , so it is very inconvenient & unsuitable for the Confessors of Christ. In that not only they may be ignorant , and much troubled to know , what underhand ●ealings their friends may use sometimes to procure that Liberty without acquainting them , and how odiously their Act of deliverance may be worded & registred to the prejudice of the cause , which they dare not testify against afterwards when they do know it , for fear of many inconveniencies . But also it cannot be vindicated from being a dishonourable shifting , and puting off , or casting off the Call of a Testimony ; and confessing either an inconstancy , or impatience or unreadiness , or want of resolution , to confess or profess the Testimony for Christ , without some respyte to gather new defences for it : Whereas Christs Witnesses should be ready always to give an Answer , to every man that asketh them , a reason of the hope that is in them 1 Pet. 3. 15. And besides they involve themselves into the incumbrances of a doubtful suspence about the event , whereas if they keep their first resolution & condition with cheerfullness , aloof from such bargains , they know the utmost they have to fear or hope from men . But now , as it is Hard for them to come off without some sinful engagment , and to continue any measure of faithfulness when they are out , for fear of being soon called again ; so they bring themselves into many sad difficulties , how to behave , and cast themselves into many tentations unadvoidably . However except of late , a precedent of this practice can hardly be instanced among the Sufferers of Christ in former times , but on the contrary many have refused such offers . I shall only name one ; In the persecution of Qeen Mary of England , Dr Sands Prisoner at London , had the offer of Liberty , upon the terms of such a bond , finding bail to appear when he should be called , but refused it absolutely ; and when a Gentleman without his knowledge , having procured it by giving a thowsand pound Bond for him , brought him forth and required his consent and observance of the obligation , he would not consent to give any security , and denied his resolution to observe it in the least ; whereupon the Gentleman very courteously told him , he would stand to his hazard . This was far more like the innocency of the dove , but this new prudence resembles more the wisdom of the serpent . Finally as for Iasons business , which is so much harped upon by these Bonders . ( 1 ) These were Rulers that he had to deal with all , and not raging Tyrants ( 2 ) They were indifferent Arbiters between Iason and the Lewd fellowes that troubled him , and not both Judge & party ; he gave no security to his persecuters , as these Bonders do , but to the true Judges of the cause , who impartially took cognizance of it , from whom Iason might & did expect right ( 3 ) This was before he was Prisoner , being as free as his accusers , and having the Law as free for him as it was for them ; whereby he could vindicate himself and abide the Law , and be absolved by it : which does not answer the case of Prisoners , actually ingaged in & called to a Testimony for Christ , when there is no Law but what is established in opposition to Christ. ( 4 ) In the Original it is , when they got satisfaction from him , that is , when he so cleared himself , that they could not fasten any transgression upon him , then they absolved him . 2. All these Oaths & solemn Securities that have been imposed in these times , are dreadful & heinous breaches of the Third Command , by taking His Name in vain in the worst sort , whereby the takers cannot be holden guiltless . For it is impossible such Oaths & Bonds ; however they be constructed , can ever be taken with these requisite qualifications necessary to be observed in all Oaths ( and consequently in all Solemn promises or Bonds ) that are mentioned once for all Ier. 4. 2. where one that sweareth must do it , in Truth , in Iudgement , & in Righteousness . 1. They cannot be taken in Truth , which is a necessary qualification in all Oaths ; according to the definition of a true Oath ; Which is , a Solemn Invocation of God , for Confirmation of some true . Lawful , grave , and weighty , Useful , & worthy business , wherein He is attested & appealed unto , that He , as the only Searcher of hearts , may give His Testimony to the Truth of the thing , and punish the Swearer if he swear not in Truth . And this Swearing in Truth does import & require , both Sincerity of the heart , filled with Reverence and the awful apprehension of a present God ; And Simplicity of the mind , well informed of the genuine meaning of the Oath , that we have clear uptaking of it , and take it not implicitely but with our oun understanding ; And also singleness & honesty of the intention , that it be not to deceive , by puting any other sense than the imposer hath , or will allow when he understands it : So the meaning must be clear , and such as may be obviously gathered from the Words , and according as they are supposed to be understood by others , especially them that exact the Oath ; for if they mean one thing and we another , Gods Name is profaned , and the end of the Oath frustrate , and so all equivocations & mental reservations are condemned ; As all Divine treating on Oaths teach , and worthy Mr Durham particularly ▪ on the Third Command , who Asserts , that though we could devise some other meaning , that might seem to make for us ; yet if that was not meant at first tendering , but otherwise understood by him that did take it , it will not absolve from the guilt of perjurie ; for an Oath is stricti juris ▪ and will not admit on any respct or account of interpretations , prejudicial to the Native Truth of it , lest it should be found to be ( according to Psal. 24. 4. ) a swearing deceitfully . And afterwards he sayes , Much less will it exempt a man from guilt , that in swearing he had a meaning of the words , contrary to what in common sense they bear , and in the construction of all indifferent persons sine juramento or extra , but it should be plain , single , & clear . And Pareus saith in Catech Urs. Part. 2. quest . 102. Sancitum est Iuramentum , ut sit vinculum veritatis inter homines , & Testimonium quod Deus sit Author & Desensor veritatis . An Oath hath the Divine Sanction , that it might be a bond of verity among men , and a Testimony that God is the Author & defender of Truth , Now none of these Oaths & Bonds can be taken in Truth ; for if they may be safely taken in any sense : it must be such as the Oath in the design of the Imposers cannot bear , and which the Imposers never intended , nor would they ever have allowed , if they had understood it ; which industriously the Takers have a care they should not understand , and so they must take it in that sense cum animo fallendi which cannot be in Truth , but most derogatory both to the Truth & simplicity of the Gospel . And they are all unclear & ambiguous , which cannot be taken in Truth , because they have no Truth in them , as Dr. Sanderson saith De Iur. Promiss . Oblig . Prael . 6. §. 10. a Proposition of an ambiguous & indefinite sense , before the matter be distinguished , is not a true proposition ; yea nor a proposition at all : for a proposition , as its definition cleareth , should signify either a truth or a falshood , without any ambiguity : And therefore , sayes he , such Oaths should be supected , that there is some deceit lurking , and every pious & prudent man should refuse them , offered under such terms , cited by Apol. Relat Sect. 10. Pag. 118. & Sect. 14. Pag. 267. In fine , None of them can be taken in Truth : since they are all a denying the Truth , as will be evident by the induction of all of them ; Which how it can consist with the fear of God , or sincerity of the heart , cannot be imagined , and if conscience be called in to Judgement it will condemn the taking them . 2. They cannot be taken in Iudgement , that is , with knowledge & deliberation ; minding & understanding what it is we swear or subscribe , as Mr Durham explains it in the place above cited . For first , they cannot be taken in Judgement , because they are all ambiguous , the terms of them being capable of diverse senses , not explained by the Imposers● And if they were explained in their sense , then they could not be taken in Righteousness ; And so at best they are uncertain : And that is dreadful , to invock the Majestie of God to be a Witness to uncertainties , for that is to swear with an evil conscience & contempt of God , to dare to call Him in as a Witness of that which is in suspense , whether it be Truth or a lie ; And such a swearer must make it a matter indifferent , whether he make God a Witness of a Truth or of a lie in the case . Vide Pareum Loc. supra citat . Pag. 654 Sect. 4. Dr Sanderson ubi supra , gives these reasons further against all ambiguous Oaths : because of him who tendereth the Oath : for the proper end of an Oath is , that he in whose favours it is taken should have some certainity of that whereof he doubted before , but there can be no certainity out of words which have no certain sense : Next , because of him who sweareth , who if he take such an Oath in these terms , either stumbleth his neighbour , or spreadeth a net for his oun feet ; for to what else should such collusion tend , but either that by our example others may be induced to take it , whereby they are stumbled ; Or that afterwards , by virtue of that Oath , some thing may be required of us , which is either unlawful or hurtful , and this is to lay a snare for our selves ! Therefore let every prudent man beware of suffering himself to be deceived by these wiles , and of thinking so much either of the favour or of the ill will of any other , as to swallow the bait under which he is sure there is a hook : It is expedient , that in the matter of Oaths all things be done aright , and that the sense be clear to all , and that is jurare Liquido to swear with a clear conscience Apol. Relat. Pag. 267. But next , they cannot be taken in Judgement ; because they are all imposed and extorted under a sever penalty , and some of them of death , and so must be taken out of fear . Such Oaths are by many famous Divines judged unlawful , especially Publick Oaths imposed by Authority , and under colour of Law ; these are worse than a mans private Oath given to a Robber , ●for fear of Death , if the matter be unlawful : for , whether the matter be Lawful or unlawful , such Oaths coacted , exacted , & imposed by Law , cannot be taken in Judgement ; for if they be taken out of respect to the Law , then it is the persons suffrage to the equitie of that Law , and an approbation of the imposition ; Which in the present case cannot be done , by any man of conscience , for whether the Oaths be Lawful or not , the Authority imposing them is naught , and the Law wicked and can never be approven ; And if they be extorted out of fear , then they cannot be taken with deliberation , or voluntary & unviolented choise , unconstrained light or liberty , which are all the ingredients of Judgement . 3. They cannot be taken in Righteousness , that is according to the Law of equity as well as piety , neither wronging God nor others by our Oaths . Lawful Oaths should be in themselves vincula aequitatis , as well as veritatis . And Pareus saith loco supra citato , Iuramenta licita tantum ea sunt — quae suscipiuntur de rebus veris , certo cognitis , licitis ; possibilibus , gravibus , necessariis , utilibus , dignis . Lawful Oaths are only these which are ingaged into about things true , certainly known , lawful , possible , weighty , necessary , useful & worthy . And if that be true , then are all the Oaths & Bonds taken these many years , but fetterings into bonds of iniquity ; which when the consciences of the Takers will reflect on them , will become Galls of bitterness , and found to have none of these qualifications , but on the contrary to be about matters false , uncertain , unlawful , impossible , frivolous , fruitless , useless , & unworthy , to the worst degree of baseness ; and which is worst of all , dreadfully sinful , and horrid to be thought on to interpose the Name of God upon , making Him the Approver of what His Soul hates , and a Witness of that which He will be an Avanger of , as will appear by the particular consideration af all of them . 3. Let it be considered , that though ( as the pleaders for these transactions do impertinently alledge ) the same words in other cases might be subscribed in a more abstract sense , as being capable of a good construction : yet Complexly considered in the form & frame of all the Oaths & Bonds we have been troubled with , they cannot be subscribed in any sense ; and if in any , that must be the Impoposers sense , which in them all is alwayes pernicious . 1. They cannot be taken in any sense though never so good , if we consider the absolute illegality of their arbitrary imposition . It will be confessed that Oaths should be very tenderly imposed upon consciences , not only lest the Name of God be prostitute to profanation , in matters light & trivial , or dubious & uncertain ; but lest a Tyrannical Jurisdiction be exercised over the Souls of men , which are not subject to any power that Mortals can claim . So it cannot be denied , but that the Constitution of our Government requires , and Reason as well as Religion sayes it is necessary , that no Ruler hath right to enjoin an Oath which is not first enacted into a Law ; And it was alwayes accounted a good plea for refusing Oaths , when there was no Law for them ; And some have been charged with Treason , for exacting Oaths without a Statute ordaining them : Which might be brought in as a Charge against all the Imposers of Our Oaths , the most part of which have been exacted & extorted without any colour of Law ; some of them being never ordained by any Act of Parliament , and others of them before they could obtain such a Mischief framed into an Act for them , and all of them neither ever legally administred nor righteously enacted , by such who had power to make Acts ; for as for the pacqued Parliaments that made them , no consciencious Man could ever oune such a Company of perjured Traitors , to be their Parliamentary Representatives . Yet abstracting from that , I say , the Oaths that have been imposed without and against Law could never be taken in any sense , without consenting to their treasonable breach of Law , for which they have forfeited their lives to Justice , when ever there shall be a Judicatory to revise their administrations : And these that have been imposed by a pretended Law , could never be taken without justifying of that Law that ordained them , which hath been nothing but a mischief framed into a Law by a Throne of iniquity . 2. They cannot be taken in a good sense , with a safe conscience ; considering either what is plain in them , or what is more ambiguous . What is plain and capable but of one sense , that is alwayes either constraining to a clear Sin , to renounce some part of the Covenanted Reformation , in profession or practice ; Or Restraining from a clear duty , that we should not do that which we may or ought to do . There is nothing in all of them plain but what obliges to one of these two . Again what is ambiguous in them , as it ought to be refused for its ambiguity ; so when it is explained according to the Imposers mind & meaning , the sense will be found alwayes pernicious , though the words may be plausible . As when they require an obligation to Allegiance , or Loyaltie , or peaceableness , or Orderlyness , and other smooth words signifying excellent things in an abstract Notion , these will be found to carry quite another sense , if we inquire into the Imposers meaning , in which only Oaths & Bonds must be taken . The only way to find out their meaning , is to consider either their Acts or Actings , or their designs & intentions , as they are discoverable by any man of Prudence or consideration . If we consult their Acts or Actings , practically & only legally explaining them , for a commentary ; then by Allegiance , we can understand nothing else but an ouning of their Absolute Tyranny ; by Loyaltie , nothing but an absolute & implicite Obedience of their absolute Commands , without reserve ( as the late Proclamation for the Tolleration expounds it ) by peaceableness , nothing but a stupid subjection to them , leting them do what they please without resistence or control ; and by Orderlyness , nothing but a disorderly Complyance & Conformity with them , in going along with the Corruptions & Defections of the time , for their Acts & Actings expound them so . If we consider their designs & intentions , according to which they are all uniformly calculate and equally levelled ; He is blind who hath not seen , they have been driving all this time at these designs ( to which all these Oaths & Bonds have been adapted & successfully subservient , and by which they have been promoted to the present pass ) to overturn gradually all the degrees of our Covenanted Reformation , to establish Tyranny and advance it unto greater degrees of Absoluteness , and to introduce Poperie & slavery ; So that by Allegiance & Loyaltie , can be meant nothing else but an obligation to oune & obey , and never to oppose the design of advancing Tyranny ; And by Peaceableness & Orderlyness , nothing else can be intended , than an obligation never to oppose either the present Settlement , or future establishment of Poperie & arbitrary power , upon the ruines of the Reformation and our Civil & Religious Rights & Liberties . Whence , they that can take these Oaths & Bonds in any other sense , and plead for the inoffensiveness of the terms , in a more abstract notion , and sense alledged more legal , without regard to that of the Imposers practically explained by their administrations , and so looking more to the briberies of their blinded reason and wordly Interest , than to the Dictates of conscience , please themselves with such notions & quibling evasions , do but Mock God , deceive the world , illude the enemies , and delude themselves . And all these debatings for Accommodations & Expositions in another sense , are but foull fairdings of conscience-beguiling Compoundings in , and pitiful priggings for , a base Complyance . But it is usual for a guilty Son of Adam to sow fig-leaves . 4. Let it be considered , that all these Oaths & Bonds that the Land hath been debauched with these 27 years , are all condemned by and contradictory to anterior binding Orders , the Acts of the General Assembles , requiring no Oaths in the common cause to be taken without the Churches consent , as was cleared in the Historical part , upon the fifth Period pag. 82. And that especially they are condemned as being contradictory to , & violatory of prior Oaths of continuing indispensible Obligation ; being designed , pressed , & imposed on purpose to delete the same out of the minds & memories of the present Generation : I mean the National and Solemn League & Covenants , and other former Nationally binding Publick Engagments . Which , because they are not only broken & burnt , but declared Criminal to be ouned , and because the ouning of their obligation is ordinarly inserted in the Indytments of our Martyrs , I must touch upon them more particularly . It was cleared above Head. 1. Arg. 11. from the Form , the Object , and from the Ends of the Covenant , which are all Moral and of indispensible obligation , that it is of perpetual and unalterably binding force , obliging the present and all future Generations , as well as that which did first come under the bond of it . And to confirm this , I shall adde more particularly these many consideration . 1. The National Engagments are National promises , plighting & pledging the Nations publick faith , for the preservation & propagation of Religion & Liberty , to succeding posterity ; which if succeeding Generations may reverse , then the faith of men , and the faith of Nations , can be of no force above a century of years ; nay nor after the decease of them that personally made the promise : And so every new Ruler , every new Parliament , yea every person coming up to succeed the Father in any Capacity , might be free not to stand to it , which were very absurd . Certainly that promise of the Iewish Nobles & Rulers , not to exact Usury of their Brethren , but to restore & not require it of them , did not only oblige themselves , but would bring their posterity under the curse , if they should exact the same debt there remitted Neh. 5. 12 , 31. And does not a National promise of preserving the Reformation , bind as much to the curse of the breach of it ? 2. They are National vowes , avowing & avouching and devoting themselves & their posterity to be the Lords people , and to keep His Statutes & promove His Interests ; which do bind the posterity . Iacobs vow at Bethel , that the Lord should be his God Gen. 28. 21. did oblige all his posterity , virtually comprehended in him ; He found Him in Bethel and there He speake with Us , saith the Prophet many hundered years after H●s . 12. 4. The Israelites vow , to destroy the Canaanites , did oblige all their posterity Numb . 21. 2. Not only by virtue of the Lords Command , but by virtue of their vow ; as we are obliged to preserve the Reformation , not only by virtue of the Lords Command , but by virtue of our Covenants . Vowes are bonds to the Soul , which must stand Numb . 20. 2 , 4. And whereas it is said , that as a womans father or husband might disanull her vow , and so the Magistrate might abrogate the Covenant : Besides the impertinency of this Comparison , as might be easie to demonstrate , it may be refelled by giving & not granting that he might do so ; yet if the father & husband shall hold their peace , then all her vowes shall stand , and her bonds wherewith she bound her soul shall stand vers . 4 , 7. but so it was , that the Supreme Magistrate did give his Consent to the National Covenant , and the Successor did swear the Solemn League & Covenant , and received the Crown on the terms thereof , to preserve & promote Religion & Liberty ; and therefore her vowes must stand , they cannot be made void afterwards ; for it is a snare to devour that which is holy , and after vowes to make enquiry Prov. 20. 25. So we find the Rechabites were obliged to observe the vow of their forefather Ionadab Ier. 35. 6 , 14. And if the fathers vow obliges the Children ▪ shall not the Nations vow oblige the posterity ? 3. They are National Oaths which do oblige posterity : Esaws Oath to Iacob , resigning his birth-right , did oblige his posterity never to recover it Gen. 25. 33. Ioseph took an Oath of the Children of Israel , to carry up his bones into Canaan , Gen. 50. 25. which the posterity going forth of Egypt in after ages , found themselves straitly sworn to observe Exod. 13. 19. and accordingly buryed them in Shechem , Ioshua . 24. 32. The Spies swore to preserve Rahab alive and her house , Ioshua . 2. 12 , &c. which was without the Consent of the Magistrate , and yet Ioshua found himself obliged to observe it Ioshua . 6. 22. Moses swore unto Caleb to ensure him an inheritance Ioshua . 14. 9. and upon this ground he deman●s it as his right vers . 12. which he could not do , if Successors might reverse their Predicessors Lawful Oaths . The Lord will in a special manner resent & revenge the posterities breach of the Oath of their fathers Covenant Ezek. 16. 59. Thus saith the Lord God , I will even deal with thee as thow hast done , which hast despised the Oath in breaking the Covenant , which was the Covenant of their fathers . 4. They are National Covenants , wherein King , Parliament , & people do Covenant with each other , for the performance of the respective Duties of their several stations , either as to the work of Reformation , or as to the preservation of each others mutual Rights & Priviledges : So that they are National Covenants made by men with men ; and these we find do oblige the posterity . Israels Covenant with the Gibeonites did oblige the posterity Iosh. 9. 15 , 19. and for the breach of it many ages after the posterity was plagued 2 Sam. 21. 1. Zedekiah was bound by his Predecessors Covenant , though it was such as made the Kingdom base , yet in keeping it it was only to stand , Shall he break the Covenant & be delivered ? Thus saith the Lord , as I live ▪ surely mine Oath that he hath despised , and my Covenant that he hath broken , even it will I recompense upon his oun h●ad Ezek. 17. 12 , 14 , 15 , 19. The Apostle sayes even of humane Covenants , Though it be but a Mans Covenant yet if it be confirmed no man disanulleth or addeth thereunto Gal. 3. 15. that is , cannot do so Lawfully , much less can one man disanull a Nations Covenant . 5. They are National Attestations of God as a Witness , for the perpetuity as well as fidelity of these Sacred Engagments . All such Covenants , wherein the Holy Name of God is invocated as Witness , are ouned of God as His ( hence the Covenant betwixt David . & Ionathan is called the Covenant of the Lord 1 Sam. 20. 8. and Zedekiahs fault was the breach of the Lords Covenant Ezek. 17. forecited . So likewise that Covenant mentioned Ier. 34. 8 , 9 , 10. wherein the Princes & People did swear to let their Hebrew Servants go free , is called Gods , Covenant . 〈◊〉 . 18. and upon this account sorer ▪ Judgements are threatened vers . 19 , 20. And I will give the men that have transgressed my Covenant , which have not performed the Words of the Covenant which th●y had made before me — into the hands of their enemies . Certainly this did oblige the posterity , at least not to recall these Servants , and it was alwayes Morally obliging . So our National Covenant , sworn with hands lifted up to the Most high God , being materially also binding , cannot be abrogated by the posterity , except the Lord renounce His Interest in them ; as long as the Witness liveth then , who claims them as His , they cannot be made void . Especially considering . 6. They are National Covenants made with God , as the other party Contracting , in the matters of God , which none can dispense with , or grant Remissions in ; and therefore they must perpetually bind , until He loose them . And if even the posterity break them , the Lord will make them that hate them to reign over them , and He will bring a Swosd upon them to aveange the quarrel of His Covenant , Levit. 26. 15 , 17 , 25. Such were all the National Covenants of the Lords people renewed by Ioshua , Asa , Iehoshaphat , Hezekiah , Iosiah , Ezra , Nehemiah , for the breaches of which the Lord plagued the posterity . It was for breach of their fathers Covenant with God , that the ten tribes were carried away Captive 2 King. 17. 15. &c. We have already experienced the threatened Judgments for Covenant-breaking , and may look for more . 7. They are for their matter National Covenants about things Moral objectively , obliging to joine our selves to the Lord in a perpetual Covenant that shall not be forgotten . Ier. 50. 5. I might easily demonstrate all the Articles of the Covenant to be Morally obliging , but they are demonstrate sufficiently above Head. 1. Arg. 11. Therefore they are perpetually binding . 8. They are for their Ends National Covenants inviolably obliging : which cannot be made void , though they should be broken , because the ends of them are alwayes to be pursued as is proved above Head. 1. Therefore they are perpetual . 9. They are for their formality National Covenants , most Solemnly Sworn & subscribed by all ranks , with uplifted hands , with bended knees , with solemn invocating the Name of God , with solemn preaching , prayer , & praise , rendering themselves and the posterity obnoxious to the Curse if they should break it . Now the Solemnities of the Oath do aggravate the heinousness of the breach of it , as is clear from Ier. 34. 19. Ezek. 17. 18. quoted above : the reason is , because of their greater deliberation in the action , and because of the greater scandal accompanying the violation thereof . Hence as they are National Oaths & Covenants so solemnized , they are National Adiurations under the pain of a National Curse , not to break them Nationally ; Which do make the posterity obnoxious to it : as Ioshua adjuring Israel , saying , Cursed be the man that riseth up and buildeth this City Iericho Iosh. 6. 26. Which was fulfilled many generations after , in the dayes of Ahab , upon Hiel the Bethelite 1 King. 16. Ult. So the Curse of introducing abjured Prelacy , and Popery , if it be let in , will be impendent on the Nation . All National Covenants have a Curse annexed , in case of a breach when ever it shall be : So in Nehemiahs Covenant , they clave to their Brethren , & entered into a Curse , and into an Oath , to walk in Gods Law , which was given by Moses the Servant of God , and to observe & do all the Commandments of th● Lord our Lord , and His Judgements & Statutes , particularly not to enter into affinity with their Malignant enemies Neh. 10. 29 , 30. Which certainly did oblige the posterity , because the thing was Moral , So in our Covenants we are bound to the same things , and nothing but these : And therefore the posterity is lyable to the Curse of perjurie for the breach thereof . 10. They are for their Legality , National Laws , being Solemnly Ratified by the Parliament and by the King , and made the foundation of their Compact with him at his Inauguration ; whereby they became the fundamental Laws of the Government , and among the very Leges & regulae regnandi : which , though they be rescinded by a wicked Law , yet make the Rescinders chargable not only of Perjurie , in breaking a Covenant , but of Treason & Tyranny in breaking and altering the Constitution of the Government ; and render them lyable to the Curse thereof : for they cannot rescind that , nor escape its vengeance : whereof we have a speaking pledge already , in that the Rescinder of these Covenants was so terribly rescinded , and cut off by the hands of unnatural violence ; God thereby fulfilling that threatend Judgment of Covenant breakers , that he that hath broken His Covenant shall be brought to destruction , and bloody & deceitful men shall not live out half their dayes Psal. 55. 20. ult . So Charles the Second got not leave to live out half the dayes , that he projected to himself . 11. They are National Engagments of an Hereditary Nature , like that of Israel Deut. 29. 14 , 15. which did oblige not only the present , but the absent , not only them that stood there that day before the Lord their God , but the● that were not there that day . Grotius de jur . ●el . Lib. 2. cap. 6. gives these Marks of Hereditary Covenants ( 1 ) When the subject is of a permanent Nature , and as long as manet idem Corpus : therefore as long as Scotland is Scotland , whose people in their personal Capacity , whose Parliaments in their Parliamentary Capacity , whose King in his princely Capacity , did all solemnly & Sacredly engage in the Covenant , it must be real & perpetually obliging . ( 2 ) when there is such a Clause in the Covenant as that it should be perpetual : There are many Clauses in the Solemn league to this purpose , in Art. 1. are these words , that we & our posterity after us may as brethren live in faith & l●ve a●d the Lord may delight to dwell in the midst of us : in the 5. Art , we shall each one of us according to our place & interest endeavour that the Kingdoms may remain conjoined in a firme peace & union to all posterity . ( 3 ) when it is such as is made for the good of th● Kingdom : The Covenant expresses its end for the perpetual good of the Kingdom , having before our eyes the Glory of God , the advancement of the Kingdom of — Christ , the honour & happiness of the King & his posterity , and the true publick Liberty , Safety , & Peace of the Kingdoms ; wherein every ones private condition is included : and again it is added , for preservation of our selves & our Religion from utter ruine & destruction . All this is a publick National good . ( 4 ) The matter is Moral , about materially binding duties , and therefore it must be hereditary and of perpetual obligation . 12. Lastly , They are National obligations , taking on publick duties , by way of virtual Representation of the posterity . And they that think it irrational , that the father should represent & involve the family , must resolve us how the Religious & Civil Covenants of Israel & Iud●h made in Moses , Ioshua's , Davids , Asa's , Ioash's , Hezekiahs , Iosiahs , & 〈◊〉 dayes , did comprehend & bird as well the absent as the pre●ent , & their posterity , yet unborn ; as also , how the Laws & Contracts continually passed by some do take in others , not personally consenting ; yea how comes it to pass , that every succeeding generation is ●ound to the Laws , and must be obedient to the Kings , that they did not make themselves ; no reason can be given , but because they are virtually represented by & included in their fathers . Now if these Arguments prove our National Covenants to be perpetually binding and cannot be dispensed with , the● must these posterior Oaths that are made in a diametrical opposition to the Covenants , and are condemned by the Covenants , be false & unlawful Oaths : But the first is proved : Therefore these Oaths so opposite to & condemned by the Covenants are false & unlawful . That they are opposite to the Covenant , will appear in the induction of all of them . And that , what ever they be imposed by this party , they are condemned by the Covenants , wherein we are obliged to make no such Transactions with them , will appear if we consider these and the like expressions , that we shall neither directly nor indirectly , suffer our selves to be divided , by whatsoever suggestion , allurement , or terror , from this blessed Conjunction , nor shall cast in any let or impediment that may stop or hinder any such resolution , as shall be found to conduce for so good ends . Which are the Words of the National Covenant , clearly condemning Oaths & Bonds given to Malignants , which are divisive of them that adhere to , and Unitive with them that oppose the Covenant , and impeditive of resolutions to prosecute the ends thereof . So in the Solemn League & Covenant Art. 4. We are obliged to oppose all such as make any faction or parties amongst the people , contrary to this League & Covenant : but by these Oaths & Bonds such factions are made &c. And by Art. 6. we are obliged to assist & defend all those that enter into this Covenant ( contradicted by all the later Oaths & Bonds ) and not to suffer our selves directly or indirectly by whatsoever combination — to be divided — from this blessed union — whether to make defection to the contrary part , or to give our selves to a detestable indifferency &c. Which we do , when we divide our selves from these that refuse these Oaths , and makes defection unto the party that impose them . And in the Solemn Acknowledgment of sins & Engagment to duties , We are sworn § . 6. to be so far from conniving at , complying with , or countenancing of Malignancy , Injustice &c. that we shall not only avoid & discountenance these things &c. but take an effectual course to punish & suppress these evils . All which we counteract & contradict , when we take any of these Oaths or Bonds . In the Second place , by a Particular induction of the several kinds of these Oaths & Bonds , the iniquity of each of them will appear ; and the Complex iniquity of the smoothest of them , the Oath of Abjuration compared with every one of them , will be manifest . And consequently the honesty & innocency of Sufferers for Refusing them , will be discovered . I. The first in order , which was a Copy to all the rest , was the Declaration , ordained to be subscribed by all in publick Charge , office or Trust within the Kingdom : Wherein they do affirme & declare , they judge it unlawful to Subjects , upon pretence of Reformation or any other pretence whatsoever , to enter into Leagues & Covenants , or take up armes against the King — and that all these Gatherings — petitions , protestations — that were used — for carrying on of the late troubles , were unlawful & seditious ; And particularly that these Oaths — the National Covenant — and the Salemn League & Covenant , were and are in themselves unlawful Oaths . Here is a Confederacy required against the Lord , at which the Heavens might stand astonished ; an unparalelled breach of the Third Command . Which could no more be taken in Truth & Righteousness , than an Oath renouncing the Bible : but it hath this advantage of the rest ; that it is some what plain , And the iniquity legible on its front . 1. That it is a renouncing of Solemn & Sacred Covenants , perpetually binding to Moral & indispensable duties , the wickedness whereof is evident from what is said above . 2. It makes perjurie of the deepest dye , the necessary sine qua non qualification of all in publick Office : who cannot be presumed capable of administrating Justice , when they have avowed themselves perjured & perfidious , and not to be admitted among heathens let be Christians , nor trusted in a matter of ten shillings money , according to the Laws of Scotland . 3. It renounces the whole Work of Reformation , and the way of Carrying it on , as a Pretence and trouble unlawful & seditious : Which if it be a Trouble , then the Peace they have taken in renouncing it , must be such a Peace as is the plague of God upon the heart , filling it with senslessness & stupidity in His just Judgement , because of the palpable breach of Covenant ; or such a Peace , as is very consistent with the Curse & vengeance of God , pursuing the quarrel of a broken Covenant . 4. It condemns the taking up armes against the King , which shall be proven to be duty Head 5. Besides , that hereby the most innocent means of seeking the redress of Grievances , that Religion , Risings , Law , & practice of all Nations allowes , is condemned . Yet in effect , for as monstrous as this Oath is , the Complexe of its iniquity is couched in the Oath of Abjuration ; in which many of these Methods of Combinations , Risings & Declarations of war against the King , and Protestations against his Tyranny , which were used in the late Troubles for carrying on the Reformation , are abjured ; in that a Declaration is renounced in so far as it Declares war against the King , and asserts it Lawful to kill them that serve him : Which yet , in many cases in the Covenanted Reformation here renounced , were acknowledged & practised as Lawful , besides that it hath many other breaches of Covenant in it , as will be shewed . II. The next Net they contrived to catch Consciences , was the Oath of Allegiance & Supremacy : Wherein they that took it , for testification of their faithful obedience to their most gracious & redoubted Soveraign , Charles King of Great Britain — do affirme , testifie , & Declare — that they acknowledg their said Soveraign , only supreme Governour of this Kingdom , over all persons , & in all Causes ; And that no forreign Prince — hath any jurisdiction , power , or superiority over the same ; and therefore do utterly renounce all forreign power — and shall at their utmost power defend , assist , & maintain his Majs . jurisdiction foresaid — and never decline his power — The iniquity of this Oath is very vast and various . 1. It is a Covenant of Allegiance with a King , turned Tyrant and enemy to Religion , Subverter of the Reformation , and overturner of our Laws & Liberties ; and therefore demonstrate to be sinful both from the first General Argument against Oaths , and from Head. 2. 2. It cannot be taken in . Truth , Righteousness , or Iudgement : beause the words are general & very comprehensive , and ambiguous , capable of diverse senses : when he is affirmed to be supreme over all Persons and in all Causes , and to be assistest , & maintained , in that jurisdiction . Who can be sure in swearing such an Oath , but that he may thereby wrong others , wrong Parliaments in their Priviledges , wrong the Church in her Liberties , and which is worse , wrong the Lord Jesus Christ who is Supreme alone in some Causes ? Can an Oath be taken in Truth & Righteousness , to assist him in all encroachments , upon Causes , that are not subordinate to him ? and in invading all those Priviledges of Subjects , which are Natural , Civil , Moral , & Religious ? for if he be supreme in all Causes , then all these depend upon him & be subordinate to him . And can it be taken in Iudgement , and with a clear mind , when it may be debated & doubted ( as it is by some ) whether the obligation of it is to be considered , as circumstantiate & specificate to the present Object of it , supposing him a Tyrant ? or in a more abstract notion , as it might be tendered in the sense of its first Authors , as it was taken in King Iames the 6. his dayes , And as they plead for taking the English Oath of Allegiance , as it was accepted by the Puritans in Queen Elizabeths dayes● whether it obliges to a King in Idea , and in a more general consideration , as one who is said never to die ? Or with reference to such an one as we have , a morta● man , and an immortal enemy to all those precious Interests , for preservation of which he only received his Kingship ? Whether it must be taken in that of the Imposers , practically explained by their administrations ? or in any other sense , alledged more Legal ? These would be clear , before it can be taken with the due qualifications of an Oath . 3. As for the Civil part of it or Ecclesiastical , no other explanation needeth to be inquired after , than what they give forth in their Acts on record : The Act of Supremacy ( to be seen in the Historical Representation of the Sixth & last Period pag. 111. senses the Ecclesiastical part of it : And the Act for acknowledgment of his Majesties prerogative does sufficiently sense , explain , & expound the Civil part ; Declaring , That it is inherent in the Crown , and an undoubted part of the Royal prerogative — to have the sole choise & appointment of all Officers of State — the power of calling , holding , & dissolving Parliaments , and all Conventions & Meetings of Estates — the power of Armies , making of peace & war , treaties & leagues with forreign Princes or States , or at home by the subjects among themselves — and that it is high treason in the subjects — upon whatsoever ground , to rise — in Armes — or make any treaties or leagues — among themselves , without his Maj. Authority first interponed thereto ; That it is unlawful to the subjects , of whatsoever quality or function , to convocate — themselves , for holding of Councils to treat , consult , or determine in any matters Civil or Ecclesiastick ( except in the ordinary Judgements ) or make leagues or bonds upon whatsoever colour or pretence , without his Maj. special consent — That the league & Covenant , and all treaties following thereupon , and acts or deeds that do or may relate thereunto , are not obligatory — and that none — should presume , upon any pretext of any Authority whatsoever , to require the renewing or swearing of the said league & Covenant &c. Whereby it appears , that all this screwing up the prerogative to such a pitch , is by the Oath of Allegiance to defend all this jurisdiction justified ; and so , these palpable encroachments on the priviledges of the Scots Parliaments , that , by the fundamental Constitutions of the Government , alwayes had a share in making Laws , and Peace & War ; These robberies of our Natural priviledges of defending our selves by Armes , in case of the Kings Tyranny & oppression , and of Convocating for Consultations about the best means thereof ; And these Invasions upon our Ecclesiastical priviledges , in keeping General Assemblies for the affairs of Religion Prorenata , alwayes strenously contended for as a part of the Testimony ; yea all these rescindings , repealings , and condemnings of the Way & Manner , Methods & Measures , of promoting the Covenanted Reformation , are by this Oath explained & by this Act acknowledged to be parts of that supremacy & Jurisdiction to be defended & maintained : As like wise , by many wicked Acts since promulgated , which promote the Supremacy to a vast degree of Absoluteness , which all do interpret what that Supremacy is which is sworn to be maintained , to wit , pure Tyranny established by Law. See the many grievous Consequences of this laid out at large , in Apol. Relat. Sect. 10. 4. Here is absolute Allegiance sworn to an Absolute power , Paramount to all Law , engaging to faithful obedience to their Soveraign , as Supreme over all Persons and in all causes — and to defend , assist , & maintain his said jurisdiction , and never to decline his power ; there is no restriction here on obedience , nor Limitation on the power , nor definition of the Causes , nor circumscription of the cases , in which that assistance &c. is to be given , whether they be Lawful or not . Now absolute allegiance to an absolute power cannot be sworn by any man of Conscience , nor ouned by any man of reason , as is proven Head. 2. Arg. 6. It cannot be Lawful in any sense , to swear such an Oath to any Mortal , nay not to a David nor Hezekiah : because to swear unrestricted & unlimited Allegiance to any man , were a manifest mancipating of Mankind , not only to an Ass-like subjection , but to a servile obligation to maintain & uphold the Persons & Government of mutable men , be what they will , turn to what they will ; it is known the best of men may degenerate : And by this no remedy is left to redress our selves , b●t our heads , hearts , and hands all tied up under an engagment to defend , assist , & maintain whosoever doth hold the Government , manage it as he pleases . This reason will also conclude against the English Oath of Allegiance , though it be a great deal more smoothly worded , and seems only to require a rejection of the Pope and legal subjection to the King ; yet that comprehensive Clause makes it border upon absoluteness , I will bear faith & true allegiance to his Maj. heirs & successors , and him and them will defend to the uttermost of my power , against all Conspiracies & attempts whatsoever . There are no Conditions here at all , limiting the Allegiance , or qualifying the Object ; but an arbitrary imposition of true Allegiance and defence , in all cases , against all attempts ( even that of repressing their Tyranny not excepted ) not only of their persons but of their Dignities , if this be not an illimited Allegiance to an absolute power , I know not what it is . 5. Here is an acknowledgment of the Ecclesiastical Supremacy resident in the King : which is the most blasphemous Usurpation on the prerogatives of Christ and priviledges of His Church , that ever the greatest Monster among men durst arrogate : yea the Roman beast never claimed more ; And in effect , it is nothing else but one of his Names of Blasphemie twisted out of the Popes hands by K. Henry the Eight , and handed doun to Q. Elizabeth , and wafted over to & Iames the 6 th . for that was the Original & conveyance of it . The iniquity whereof is discovered above Head. 1. Arg. 3. But further may be aggravated in these particulars ( 1 ) It is only a change of the Pope but not of the Poped●m ; and nothing else but a shaking off the Ecclesiastical Pope , and submitting to a Civil Pope , by whom Christs Head-ship is as much wronged as by the other : And hereby a door is opened for bringing in Poperie ( as indeed by this Strategem it is brought now to our very doors ) for by the Act of Supremacy he hath power to settle all things concerning Doctrine , Worship , discipline , or Government , by his Clerks the Bishops , having all the Architectonick power of disposing , ordering , & ordaining these , as he in his Royal wisdom thinks fit . ( 2 ) By this , Church & State are confounded ( whereof the Distinction is demonstrate above ) making the Magistrate a proper & Competent Judge in Church matters , not to be declined ; wherby also he hath power to erect new Courts , Mongrel-Judicatories , half Civil half Ecclesiastick , which have no Warrand in the Word . ( 3 ) By this , many palpable & intollerable encroachments made upon the Liberties & priviledges of the Church of Christ are yeelded unto ; as that there must be no Church Judicatories or Assemblies , without the Magistrates consent , but that the power of convocating & indicting Assemblies do belong only to him , and the power of delegating & constituting the members thereof , that he may dissolve them when he pleases ; that his presence or his Commissioners is necessary unto each Nationall Assembly ; that Ministers have no proper decisive suffrage in Synods , but only of advice ; that the Church Judicatories be prelimited , and nothing mus● be treated there which may be interpreted grating upon the prerogative , nor any thing whatsoever but what he shall allow & approve , without which it can have no force nor validity ; yea by this a door should be opened unto the utter destruction & overthrow of all Church Judicatories , seeing he is made the fountain of all Church power . ( 4 ) By this , the Magistrate is made a Church member as he is a Magistrate , and so all Magistrats as such are Church members , even heathens . And yet ( 5 ) By this he is exempted from subjection to the Ministry , because they are made accountable to him in their administrations , and in the discharge of their function are under him as Supreme . Yea ( 6 ) By this the Magistrate is made a Church Officer , having the disposal of the Churches Government . And not only so , but ( 7 ) By this he is made a Church Officer of the highest degree , being supreme in all Causes , to whom Ministers in the discharge of their Ministrie are subordinate . And so ( 8 ) By this the Church of the new Testament is made imperfect , so long as she wanted a Christian Magistrate , wanting hereby a Chief Officer ; yea and the Apostles did amiss in robbing the Magistrate of his power ( 9 ) By this the Magistrate might exerce all Acts of jurisdiction , immediately by himself ; seeing he can do it as supreme by his Commissioners in Ecclesiastick affairs . ( 10 ) Finally By this Oath the King is made the head of the Church , being supreme over all persons & in all Causes , unto whom all Appeals & references must ultimately be reduced , even from Church Judicatories . Those things are only here touched they are more apodeictically confirmed above , and may be seen made out at large in Apol. Relat. Sect. 12. But I proceed . 6. It is contrary unto the Solemn League & Covenant ; into whose place after it was broken , burnt , buryed , & rescinded , since they have remitted the subjects allegiance by annulling the Bond of it , they substitute & surrogate this in its place : And therefore none can comply with the surrogation of the second , except he consent to the abrogation of the first Oath . All the Allegiance we can oune according to the Covenant , stands perpetually & expressly thus qualified , viz. in defence of Religon & Liberty , according to our first & second Covenants , and in its oun nature must be indispensably thus restricted : Therefore to renew the same , or take an Oath of Allegiance simply , purposely omitting the former restriction , when the powers are in manifest Rebellion against the Lord , is in effect a disouning of that limitation , and of the Soveraign prerogative of the Great God , which is thereby reserved ; and as much as to say , whatever Authority command us to do , we shall not only stupidly endure it , but actively concur with & assist in all this Tyranny . See Naph . Prior edit . Pag. 177. 178. Vindicated at length by Ius Populi . chap. 11. By all this the iniquity of the Scots Oath of Allegiance & Supremacy may appear , and also that of the English Oath of Allegiance , even abstract from the Supremacy , is in some measure discovered ; though it is not my purpose particularly to speak to that : yet this I will say , that they that plead for its precision from the Supremacy annexed , seem not to consider the full import of its terms ; for under the dignities , superiorities , & Authorities , there engaged to be upheld , the Ecclesiastical Supremacy must be included ; for that is declared to be one of the dignities of the Crown there , as well as here ; and hither it was brought from thence . And therefore those Scots men that took that Oath there , and plead that though the Oath of Allegiance in Scotland be a sin , yet it is duty to take the Oath in England , seem to me to be in a great deceit ; for the object is the same , the subject is the same , the duty expected , required , & engaged into is the same , and every thing equal in both . Yet all this iniquity here Couched , is some way Comprehended in & implyed by the Oath of Abjuration : for the Civil part is imported , in abjuring a Declaration , for its declaring war against the King ; Where it is clear , he is ouned as King , and all part with them that declare war against him being renounced , it is evident the Abjurers must take part with him in that war , and so assist & defend him ; for being subjects , they must not be neutral , therefore if they be not against him they must be for him , and so under the bond of allegiance to him : The Ecclesiastical Supremacy is inferred from that expression of it , where some are said to serve him in Church as well as in State , which implies an Ecclesiastical subordination to him as Supreme over the Church . III. The Tenor of some other Bonds was more smooth & subtil , as that of the Bond of Peace ; several times renewed & imposed , and under several forms ; but alwayes after one strain : engaging to Live Peaceably , Whereby many were caught & cheated with the seeming sai●ness of these general terms : but others discerning their fa●laciousness , refused and suffered for it . This in the General is capable of a good sense : for no Christian will refuse ●o Live Peaceably , but will endeavour , if it be possible , as much as lieth in them , to Live Peaceably with all men Rom. 12. 18. that is , so far to follow Peace with all men , as may consist with the pursuit of holiness 〈◊〉 . 12. 14. But if we more narrowly consider such Bonds , we shall find them Bonds of iniquity . for . 1. They are Covenants of Peace , or Confederacies with Gods enemies , whom we should count our enemies , and hate them because they hate Him Psal. 139. 21. It is more suitable to answer , as Iehu did to Ioram 2 King. 9. 22. — What Peace , so long as the whoredomes of thy Mother Iezebel , and her witchcrafts are so many ? than to engage to be at Peace with those , who are carrying on Babylons Interest , the Mother of harlots & witchcrafts . 2. This cannot be taken in Truth , Iudgement , & Righteousness , because of the fallacy & ambiguity of the terms : for there are diverse sorts of Peace & Peaceableness ; some kind is duty , some never . It must then be rightly qualified , for we can profess & pursue no Peace of Confederacy with the enemies of God , not consistent with the fear of the Lord , otherwise we cannot expect to have the Lord for a Sanctuary , but for a stone of stumbling Isai. 8. 8. 12-14 — No Peace obstructing the Gospel or Testimony , or abstracting from the duty of the day ; No Peace tending to sinful security Ier. 8. 11. No Peace leading to slavish stupidity ; No Peace prompting to preposterous prudence , in palliating sin , or daubing defections with untempered morter ; No Peace inconsistent with Truth ▪ they must go together Zech. 1. 19. No Peace that may not be followed with Holiness Heb. 12. 14. But it must be so qualified , that it be in the Lord , in Truth , in duty , contributing for the good of the Church Psal. 122. 8 , 9. and the fruit of that Wisdom , which is first Pure and then Peaceable Iam. 3. 17. Now all that know the Imposers of these Bonds , will acknowledge that is not the Peace they are seeking . 3. If we further enquire into their meaning of Living Peaceably , and seek a determinate sense of it from their Acts & Actings , It is plain they mean such a Peaceable Living , as gives obedience to their wicked Laws , and is a Complyance to their established Courses : And it must be such a Peaceable living , as is opposite to their sense of Sedition , Rebellion , Schisme , &c. Which they interpret every seasonable duty to be : And it must be such a Peaceable living , as they were presumed not to have been observant of before : and what ever it be , must be opposite to that with which they were charged as turbulent , and so contrary to all the duties of our Covenanted profession , as going to meetings , withdrawing from the Curats &c. Which they interpret not to be Peacable living . 4. This is contrary to our Covenants , which oblige us to a constant contending with and opposition to them . Yet all this is engaged into in the Oath of Abjuration , which abjures all war against the King , and all doing injury to them that serve him , and consequently to Peace & living Peaceably with them . IV. Of Affinity to this were many other Bonds of Regularity , frequently renewed & generally imposed , and that with unparalelled illegality & rigour ; Sometimes by hosts of Savage Highlanders ; Sometimes by Circuit-Courts , and by Heretors upon their Tenants , and with such unheard of involvements , that the Master or Heretor was obliged for himself , his Wife , Children , Servants , Tenants , and all under him , to live Orderly : Which in some was more bluntly expressed , in others more flatly explained , that they should keep the Publick Ordinances , that is , hear the Curats , and not go to any Seditious Conventicles ( so they called the Persecuted Meetings of the Lords people for the Worship of God ) and in others yet more impudently exacted , that they should not harbour , intertain , or correspond with any that went to these Meetings , but discover and assist to the apprehending of them . There were several forms of them from time to time , some longer some shorter ; but all of them , first & last , were to the same sense & scope . And the most favourably worded had much wickedness in them : for . 1. They are Covenants of Order , and coming under the same Rule with themselves , which is nothing but their lusts & Mischiefs framed into Law , not according to the Rule of the Word of God , but the iniquious Laws of men . 2. They could not be taken in Truth , Judgement , & Righteousness : for either they were ambiguous , or their plain sense obliged to manifest iniquities , to conforme with all their enacted corruptions . 3. They are clear breaches of Covenant , which obliges to another Kind of Orderlyness , and to follow other Rules , and take none from them in the Matters of God. 4. They are impossible , and absurd ; obliging Masters to bind for all under them , that could neither lye in their power , nor in their duty , to restrain their Liberty in these Lawful things , and to constrain & compell their consciences to sin . 5. They are unnatural & cruel , obliging the Takers to partake with them in their persecution of the Godly . 6. They were engagments to hear Curats , which is proved to be sin Head 1. throughout . 7. They were engagments to withdraw from the Meetings of the Lords people , proved to be duty . Head 4. Yet the Oath of Abjuration is some way equivalent to this , in that it obliges the Abjurers to renounce Disorderlyness in their sense , and to do no harm to the timeserving Orderly Clergy or Laity , serving & prosecuting their wicked Orders . V. Some other Bonds of that nature , and Oaths frequently put to Suffering people when taken Prisoners , did require peaceableness & Orderlyness , in this Style , that they should either tacitely or expressly condemn Some Risings in Armes , as at Pentland , Bothwel &c. to be Rebellion against the King , and a sin against God , & engage never to rise in Armes against the King , or any commissionate by him , upon any pretence whatsoever . The iniquity whereof is manifest : for 1. This is a Covenant equivalent to a league Offensive & Defensive with them , obliging never to offend or oppose them , not to defend nor rescue our Brethren against & from their murdering violence . 2. This could not be taken in Truth , Judgement , & Righteousness : for , who can tell how far that may extend , upon any pretence whatsoever ? this may oblige us to make a stupid surrender of our lives , when the King turns so Tyrannical as to send his Cut-throats to demand them , or Authorizes his bloody Papists to Massacre us , them we must not resist upon this pretence . 3. It is contrary to our Covenants , that allow Resistance in some cases , and oblige to assist & defend all that enter under the bond thereof . 5. This infers an ouning of the present Authority , as the irresistible Ordinance of God , and an obligation of living peaceably in subjection under it ; disproved above : To which I shall adde a part of that forecited Letter of Mr Rutherfoords the 63. in number of the third part of his printed Letters , which are a clear vindication of the principles & practice of our consciencious Sufferers on this point [ There is a promise & real purpose ( saith he ) to live peaceably under the Kings Authority ; But ( 1 ) yow do not so answer candidly & imgenuously the mind of the Rulers , who to your knowledge mean a far other thing by Authority than yow do ; for yow mean his just Authority , his Authority in the Lord — in the maintenance of true Religion , as in the Covenant , & confession of faith — is expressed from the Word of God ; they mean his supreme Authority & absolute prerogative above Laws , as their Acts clear and as their practice is , for they refused to such as were unwilling to subscribe their bond , to adde , Authority in the Lord , or just & Lawful Authority , or Authority as it is expressed in the Covenant ; but this draught of a petition yeelds the sense & meaning to them , which they crave . ( 2 ) That Authority for which they contend , is exclusive of the sworn Covenant ; So that except ye had said , ye shall be subject to the Kings Authority in the Lord , or according to the sworn Covenant , yow say nothing to the point in hand , & that sure is not your meaning ( 3 ) whoever promises so much of peaceable living under his Maj. Authority , leaveing out the exposition of the 5. Command — may upon the very same ground subscribe the bond refused by the Godly , and so yow pass from the Covenant , and make all these bypast Actings of this Kirk & State these years by-past to be horrid Rebellion , and how deep this guilt drawes consider . 5. This would infer , though the King should send and kill us , we must not resist , nor defend our oun lives : yet being an Oath against the Sixth Command , which enjoineth Natural self preservation , it should be intrinsecally sinful ; and it s all one to swear to non-preservation of self , as to swear to self Murder . 6. I hope to make it appear in the 5. Head , that this is against the practice of Nations , the Law of Nature , and the Word of God. Yet all this Complex iniquity is clearly comprehended in the Oath of Abjuration , in terminis ab●uring all war against the King. VI. There were some other Oaths , frequently obtruded upon people , for refusing which they have suffered great cruelties , that can hardly be described by any name , Nor can their imposition have a paralel in any age or place , for illegaltty , inhumanity , arbitrariness , & odiousness . These were the Oaths of Inquisition or Super inquirendis : Whereby people were pressed to answer the Inquisitors , according to all their knowledge of things , they were interrogate upon , and delate & discover Intercommuned persons in their Wanderings , or such whose names were in their Porteous Rolls &c. And power was given to single Souldiers , to press these Oaths upon whom they pleased . The iniquity of which is monstrous : for . 1. This was the worst Kind of Combination with these blood-hound , to abett & assist , them in their pursuing after the Lords people : Which is worse than to be bare consenters to such wickedness , or to be onlookers to their affliction in the day of their Calamity , but like that sin charged upon Edom , that they delivered up those of His that did remain in the day of distress Obad. vers . 13. 14. for these that took Oaths , obliged themselves to do all they could to deliver up the Remnant that escaped ; and if they did not , no thanks to them , if they could not , their sin was in their willingness : if they would not , and yet swore would contribute their help towards it , by telling of all they knew , that was horrid perjury & false swearing . 2. This could be no wayes capable of the qualifications of an Oath ; not only because the matter is wicked & unnatural , to discover may be the husband or Children or nearest relations , to please men or save their oun life , which was a great tentation , and therefore in it there could be no delibaration in swearing : but also for the doubtful perplexity confounding the mind , that they either could not or durst not tell of all they knew , and yet sware to do it . 3. It is against the Covenant , which obliges to discover Malignant enemies , and assist our Covenanting Brethren , and not to discover them , and assist Malignant enemies : which is a perfect inverting the fourth & sixth Articles of the Covenant . 4. It is contrary to clear precepts in Scripture , to assist & defend our Brethren , to make our shaddow as the night in the midst of the noon day , and hide the Outcast , and bewray not him that wandereth Isai. 16. 3. 5. The illegality of this imposition makes it very absurd , that every pitiful Officer or Souldier should be impowered to impose & exact Oaths , and impannel & examine Witnesses , about alledged Criminals . Yet the monstrousness of this Oath serves to aggravate the Oath of Abjuration ; in that the Abjurers do renounce their part of & disoune the Declarers of that abjured Declaration , and so do as much as from them is required , to give them up for a prey to their hunters ; yea they declare them Murderers in that they abjure their Declaration as asserting Murder , And consequently they must be obliged to discover them to their acknowledged Judges . VII . The Abominable Test comes next : which needs no other refutation , than to rehearse it : the substance whereof was , a Solemn Swearing , that they Ouned & sincerely professed the true Protestant Religion , contained in the confession of faith , recorded in the first Parl. of K. Iaemes the 6 — and that they would adhere thereunto all the dayes of their life — and never consent to any change or alteration contrary thereto — but renounce all Doctrines , principles , practices , whether Popish or Fanatical , contrary thereto — And they swear that the King is the only Supreme Governour of this Realme , over all persons in all causes , as well Ecclesiastical as Civil , — and promise to bear faith & true allegiance to the Kings Maj. his heirs & Lawful successors , and to their power shall assist & defend all rights , jurisdictions , prerogatives — belonging to them — And affirme — it — unlawful for subjects upon pretence of Reformation , or any other pretence whatsoever , to enter into Covenants — or to convocate , conveen , or assemble — to treat , consult , or determine in any matter of State , Civil or Ecclesiastick , without his Maj. special command — or to take up Armes against the King , or these Commissionate by him — And that there lies no obligation on them , from the National Covenant , or Solemn League & Covenant — to endeavour any change or alteration in the Government , either in Church or State , as it is now established by the Laws of the Kingdom — and they shall never decline his Maj. power & jurisdiction — And finally they swear , that this Oath is given in the plain genuine sense & meaning of the words , without any equivocation , mental reservation , or any manner of evasion whatsoever — This is the Complement of a wicked Conspiracy , couching in its Capicious bosome the Complication of all their Mischiefs , comprehending all & explaining all the former : which indeed cannot be taken with any equivocating evasion , that can escape either the Stigma of nonsense & self contradiction , or the censure of Atheisme & irreligion , or the sentence of Divine vengeance against such baffling the Name of God. The best sense that can be put upon it , is that which a poor Sot expressed , when it was tendered to him , prefacing thus before he took it , Lord have mercy upon my Soul. For. 1. It is not consistent with itself : there being such contradictions between that confession of faith and the following part , that no man can reconcile : Some whereof may be instanced as followes . ( 1 ) In the 11. Art. of that confession , entituled , of Christs Ascension it is said , that Christ is the only Head of the Church & Just Lawgiver , in which Honours & Offices if man or Angels presume to intrude themselves , we utterly detest & abhore them as blasphemous to our Soveraign & Supreme Governour Christ Jesus ; and a litle before in that same Article , it is said , this Glory Honour & prerogative He alone among the Brethren shall possess : And in the 16. Art. of the Kirk , Christ is the only Head of the same Kirk . And yet in the Test the King is affirmed to be the only supreme in all causes Ecclesiastical . ( 2 ) In the 14. Art. among good works are reckoned these , to obey Superior powers and their charges ( not repugning to the Commandment of God ) to save the lives of Innocents , to repress Tyranny , to defend the oppressed ; And among evil works these are qualified , to resist any that God hath placed in Authority [ while they pass not over the bounds of their Office ] And Art. 24. it is confessed , that such as resist the supreme power , doing that which pertains to his charge , do resist Gods Ordinance — while the Princes & Rulers vigilantly travel in the execution of their Office. And yet in the Test , true Allegiance is engaged into without any such limitations ; And it is affirmed to be unlawful , upon any pretence whatsoever , to convocate &c. or to take up Armes against the King. ( 3 ) In the 14. Art. Evil works are affirmed to be , not only those that expressly are done against Gods Commandment , but those also that , in matters of Religion & Worshipping of God , have no other assurance but the invention & opinion of men : And Art. 18. among the Notes of the true Church , Ecclesiastical Discipline uprightly ministred , as Gods Word prescribes , whereby vice is repressed , and virtue nourished , is one : In Art. 20. the voice of God and constitution of men are opposed . And yet in the Test , they swear never to endeavour any change or alteration in the Government of the Church — as it is now established ; whereof many things must be altered , yea the whole forme & frame of it , if these propositions be true , as they are . ( 4 ) In the Test , they swear never to consent to any change or alteration , contrary to that confession , and that all principles & practices contrary thereto are Popish & fanatical ( for so they divide them into one of these disjunctively ) then must all the following principles in their Test be renounced as such ; seeing they are contrary to that confession in some propositions or Articles ; And that the Government established by that confession was Presbyterian , and this established by the Test is Episcopal . 2. It comprehends all the former Oaths & Bonds , which are cleared above to be sinful . Yet for as wicked as it is , it must be some way homologated by the Oath of Abjuration , excepting the contradiction that is in it : Seeing all these oppositions against the King , sworn aginst in the Test , are abjured & renounced in that Oath of Abjuration , in renouncing all Declarations of war against the King ; for if any war can be undertaken against him , all these Kinds of opposition must be allowed , that are in the Test sworn against . VIII . In the last place , I shall come to consider more particularly the Oath of Abjuration it self ; for refusing of which the sufferings were more severe ( being extended even to death or banishment ) though the words be more smooth than in any of the former , which are these I — do abjure , renounce , & disoune a late pretended Declaration , affixed on several Mer●at Crosses &c. in so far as it declares War against the King , and assert it Lawful to kill any that serve his Maj. in Church , State , Army , or Country . That the taking of this Oath is a step of Complyance , dishonourable to God , derogatory to the dayes Testimony , contradictory to the many reiterated Confessions of Christs Worthy ( though poor & despised ) Witnesses , sealed by their blood , bonds , & banishments , encouraging & gratifying to the Enemies of God , hardening to backsliding Brethren , offensive to the Generation of the Righteous , stumbling to all , leaving a stain & sting upon the Conscience of the Subscriber , I shall endeavour to make out by these Considerations . 1. Considering the party who imposed it ; it must be looked upon as a Confederacy with them , being tendered upon all the Subjects , as a Test of their incorporating themselves with and declaring themselves for their head , and syding with them & him , in this their Contest & Contention with a poor Remnant of the Lords people , persecuted & murdered by them for Truth & Conscience sake , who issued forth that Declaration against them , here abjured . Therefore let the party be considered , imposing the Oath with such rigour , and prosecuting the Refusers with ravenous rage , murdering & torturing all who did not comply with them , declaring a Ware more formally & explicitely against Christ as King , and all that will dare to assert their Allegiance to Him , under an open displayed banner of defyance of Him & His , than ever Mortals durst espouse & avouch : The head of that Treacherous & Truculent faction , both he who was first declared against in that Declaration , and he who hath by bloody & treacherous Usurpation succeeded to him , being such a Monster for Murder & Mischief , Tyranny , Oppression & Perfidy , that among all the Nimrods & Nero's that past ages can recount , we cannot find a paralel , by all Law Divine & humane incapable of Government , or any Trust , or so much as Protection , or any Priviledge , but to be pursued by all as a Common enemy to mankind : And his Underlings , Agents & Complices , devoted to his lust , & serving his wicked designs , in their respective offices & places of trust under him , which by his nomination & sole appointment they have been erected to , & established in , with the stain & indelible Character of perjurie , the only qualification of their being capable of any advancement , occupying by usurpation intrusion & violence the publick places of judicatories , and carrying all so insolently & arbitrarly , and with an effrontry of wickedness & despight of all Reason , Religion , or Justice , that they cannot but be looked upon as the most pestilent & pestiferous Plague that ever pestered a People : The taking then of this Oath , by them projected as a Pest to infect Consciences with , and pervert them to wicked Truth-deserting & Law-perverting Loyaltie , and imposed as a Test of Complyance with them , and coming off from that litle flock whom they design to devour & destinate to destruction ; must be in their oun esteem , as well as of the Generation of the Righteous , to their satisfaction and the others sorrow , a real incorporating with them , an ouning of their usurped power as Judges to administer Oaths , giving them all obedience they required for the time to their Authority , and all the security they demanded for the Subscribers Loyaltie , an approving of all their Proceedings in that matter , and transacting , tampering , & bargaining with these Sons of Belial , out of fear : whereby a right is purchased to that common badge of their ouned & professed friends , who ( upon taking that Oath ) had from them a priviledge & allowance to travel & traffique ( where and how they will ) through the Country , denyed to all other that wanted that Badge ; I mean the Pass or Testificate they got from them thereupon , which was the Mark of that secular beast of Tyrannie , no less pernicious to the world than Poperie hath been to the Church ; and which was given to all the Takers of that Oath , as a Mark of Tessera that they were no enemies to the Government , as they call it . O base and unworthy Liverie , for the suffering Sons of Zion to put on the Signature of the Society of her devourers . Hence , if Covenants & Confederacies , declaring we are on their side , cannot be made with the Enemies of Religion , then this Oath could not be taken Lawfully : But the former is proved above : Ergo the latter followes . This will yet more appear . 2. If we consider the Party that set forth that Declaration , whom the Proclamation against it represent so odiously & invidiously whom the Oath imposed obliges us to condemn ; being so represented , as if they were maintainers of Murdering Principles , and perpetators of Assassinating villanies , inconsistent with Peace or any good Government , and therefore to be exterminated & destroyed out of the Land , whom therefore they prosecute & persecute so cruelly to the effusion of their blood , under colour of Law. 1. The takers of this Oath must have formally , under their unhappy hand , disouned & renounced them , and all part or interest in them , or Society or Sympathie with them ; who yet are known to be the Suffering people of God , more earnestly contending , witnessing , wrestling for the faith & Word of Christs patience , and have suffered more for their adherance to the Covenanted Reformation of the Church of Scotland , and for their opposition to all its deformations & defections , than any Party within the Land : yet them have they rejected as their Companions , though with some of them sometimes they have had sweet Company & Communion in the House of God , by abjuring & condemning their deed which duty & necessity drave them to . 2. Hereby they have presumptuously taken upon them , to pass a Judgement upon the deed of their Brethren , before their Murdering Enemies ; And that not a private discretive Judgement , but a publick definitive sentence ( in their Capacity ) by the most solemn way of Declaring it , that can be , by Oath & subscription under their hand ; whereby they have condemned all the Sufferings of their Brethren , who sealed their Testimony in opposition to this Complyance with their blood , and finished it with honour & joy , as foolish & frivolous profusion of their oun blood , Nay as just & legally inflicted & executed upon them , as being Rebells , of Murdering Principles & practices : For this cannot be vindicated from a more than indirect justifying of all the Murdering Severity executed upon them . 3. And hereby they have unkindly and unchristianly listed themselves on the other side against them , and taken part rather with their enemies than with them ; for thus they used to plead for t it , when they pressed this Oath upon them that scrupled it ; When any War is declared against the King , any of his Maj. Souldiers may question any man whom he is for , and if he be not for the King , he may act against him as an enemy , and if they will not declare for the King and disoune the Rebells , they are to be reputed by all as enemies . Which , whatever weakness be in the arguing , plainly discovers , that they take the abjuring of that Declaration in that juncture , to be a mans Declaring of what side he is for , and that he is not for the Emitters of that Declaration , but for the King and his party : which in the present state of affairs , is a most dreadful ouning of Christs Enemy , and disouning of His Friends . Hence , a disouning of the Lords persecuted people , and condemning their practice , and an ouning of their Persecuters and espousing their side of it , is a sinful Confederacy : But the taking of this Oath is such , as is evident by what is said : Ergo it is a sinful Confederacy . 3. Considering the Nature , Conditions , & Qualifications of so solemn & serious a peice of Gods Worship , and way of invocating His Holy Name , as an Oath is : It will appear , that the taking of this imposed Oath of Abjuration , was a dreadful & heinous breach of the Third Command , by taking His Name in vain , in the worst sort , and so cannot be holden guiltless . I prove it thus : An Oath which cannot be taken in Truth , Judgement , & Righteousness , is a breach of the Third Command : But this is an Oath which cannot be taken in Truth , Judgement , & Righteousness : Which is evident ; for . 1. It cannot be taken by any Consciencious man in Truth , in sincerity of the heart , simplicity 〈…〉 mind , singleness & honesty in the intention , not puting any other sense than the imposer hath , and which is the clear sense of it sine juramento and extra . For , if he take it according to their meaning , then he should swear it unlawful ever to declare War against the King , and consequently never to rise in Armes against him upon any pretence whatsoever : for , if we may rise in Armes for our oun defence , we mak & must declare a defensive War. And indeed , in themselves as well as in their sense & meaning who imposed them , these two Oaths , never to rise in Armes against the King , and this of Abjuration , are one and the same . Then also should he swear it unlawful , at any time , upon any occasion , or for any Cause , to kill any such as serve the King in Church , State , Army , or Country , either in Peace or War : for that is their thought , and sensus vel juramenti ipsius vel extra juramentum : And in part , for their exemption & immunity from all condign punishment , this Oath was contrived . But in fine , how can this Oath be taken in Truth ; when it is not apparent , either that the declaring of a War against the King , or killing some for some causes ( which shall afterwards be made appear to be Lawful ) that serve him , are to be abjured & disouned ? or that the Declaration does assert any such thing ? And indeed it will be found to be a denying the Truth , and a subscribing to a manifest falsehood , invoking God to be Witness thereto . 2. This Oath cannot be taken in Iudgement , that is , with knowledge & deliberation &c. All the terms of it have much obscure ambiguity , Declaring a war , and killing any who serve the King , may be constructed in several senses , good & bad , but here they are indefinitely expressed , and universally condemned . Particularly that [ in so far as ] hath several faces , and can never be sworn in Judgement ; For , if it denote a Causality , and signify as much as quia or quatenus , then all Declarations of war against any that have the name of King whatsoever , upon whatsoever grounds , and all killing of any serving him , though in our oun defence , must be universally condemned , for a quatenus ad omne valet Consequentia : If it import a restriction , excluding other things in the Declaration , but obliging to abjure only that ; then it implies also an affirmation , that these two things are contained in it , which will not appear to the Judgement of them that will seriously ponder the Declaration it self : If again it be a Supposition or Condition , and to be interpreted for if so be , then all that the Judgement can make of it is that it is uncertain , and so the Conscience dare not invoke God as a Witness of that which is uncertain whether it be a Truth or a lie . 3. This Oath could not be taken in Righteousness : for the matter is not true , certainly known , Lawful , possible , weighty , necessary , useful , & worthy : It is not true , that the Declaration imports so far as as it is represented in the Oath of Abjuration : Neither is it certainly known , but by collating these two together the Contrary will appear : Neither is it Lawful ( if it were true that such assertions were in it ) to abjure all Declarations of war against the King , and to swear it unlawful ever to kill any if he be once in the Kings service , in Church , State ; Army , or Country : Nor is it possible to reduce this Assertory Oath into a promissory one Lawfully , as most part of such Oaths may & do necessarely imply ; for when I swear such a thing unlawful , it implies my promise , by virtue of the same Oath , never to practise it ; But it is not possible ( as the case stands ) for a man to bind up himself in every case from all declared war against the King , or from killing some imployed in his service ; what if there be a necessary call to joine in armes with the Lords people , for the defence of their Religion , lives , & Liberties , against him ? what if he command a Massacre ? shall not a man defend himself ? Nor endeavour to kill none of that murdering Crew , because they are in his service ? Was ever a fool so fettered ? Nor is it of such weight , as to be the occasion of involving the whole Country in perjury or persecution , as by that Oath was done : Nor was it necessary , in this mans time , to make all abjure a Declaration out of date , when the object of it Charles the Second was dead , and no visible party actually in armes to prosecute it ; Nor was it ever of any use or worth , except it were implicitely to gratify their greedy lusting after the blood of Innocents , or the blood of silly Souls cheated by their snares , by involving them in the same sin of perjury & Conscience-debauching false-swearing , whereof they themselves are so heinously guilty . But let them , and such as have taken that Oath , and not fled to Christ for a Sanctuary , lay to heart the doom of false swearrers , the flying roll of the Curse of God shall enter into their house Zech. 5. 4. Love no false Oath for all these are things that I hate saith the Lord Zech. 8. 17. The Lord will be a swift Witness against false swearers Mal. 3. 5. And let them sist their Conscience before the Word , and set the Word to the Conscience , and these Considerations will have some weight . 4. If we consider this Particular Oath it self , aud the words of it more narrowlie , we shall find a Complication of iniquities in it , by examining the sense of them as the Imposers expound them . 1. Not only that Declaration , but all such in so far as they declare & assert such things , are here renounced ; and hereby many honest & faithful Declarations are disouned , that declare the same things . It is indeed pleaded by some , that profess to be presbyterians , as it was also pretended by some of the pressers of the Oath themselves , but in order to pervert & cheat the Conscience ; that here is not required a disouning of the Apologetical Declaration simpliciter , but only secundum quid , or rather of a pretended one of their supposing , in so far as it imports such things : But this is frivolous , for that pretended one is intended by the Imposers to be the Real Apologetical Declaration , which they will have to be disouned , and cannot be distinguished from it : And though all these Assertions cannot be fastened upon that Apologetical Declaration , but it is evident that it is invidiously misr●presented ; yet that same is the pretended one which they require to be abjured in so far as it asserts such things , which it does not : And if it be secundum quid to be disouned , then that must either be secundum that Assertion of killing any &c. Which is not to be found in it , and so it is not to be disouned at all ; or it must be secundum the Declaration of war against the King ; And so that quid or formal reason of disouning it , will oblige to disoune all Declarations of war against the King , which cannot be disouned . Others again Object , that it is not required to be disouned formally , but only conditionally , taking & confounding in so far for if so be : But to any thinking man it is plain , this cannot be a supposition , nor yet a simple restriction ( as they would give it out ) but an assertion that such things are indeed imported in it ; for so the Imposers think & say : And if it might pass current under that notion , as a supposition , being equivalent to if so be , then under that sophistical pretext , I might renounce the Covenant , or the most indisputed Confession or Declaration that ever was , in so far as it contained such things ; And so this equivocation might elude all Testimonies whatsoever , and justify all prevarications . 2. This must condemn all defensive wai of subjects against their oppressing Rulers , in that a Declaration is abjured in so far as it declares war against the King : to press & perswade people to which , it was usually urged by the Imposers , that when a war is declared by Rebells against the King , then all the subjects are obliged to disoune the Rebells , or else be repute for such themselves : And , when it was alledged the war was ceased , because the Object declared against was ceased , Charles the Second being dead , otherwise if a man be obliged to give his opinion about a war declared against a King deceased & gone , then by the same parity of reason he must be obliged to give his opinion of that war of the Lords of the Congregation ( as they were called ) against Queen Mary in the begining of the Reformation ; It was still replyed by them , that the Rebellion continued , and all were guilty of it that did not abjure that Declaration : Whence it is evident , they mean that every thing which they call Rebellion must be disouned , and consequently all Resistence of Superiors upon any pretence whatsoever , as many of their Acts explain it : yea and it was plainly told by some of them , to some that scrupled to rake the Oath because they said they did not understand it , that the meaning was to swear never to rise in armes against the King. Against this it hath been objected by several , that this was alwayes denied by Presbyterians , that ever they declared war against the King , but only for defence of their lives & Liberties , never agai●st the King expressy , purposedly , & designedly , but only against him per accidens when he happened to be the adverse party : But this distinction will not be a Salvo to the Conscience ; For the object declared against , is either a King or not ; if he be not , then a Declaration of war against him is not to be abjured ; if he be King , then he is either declared against as King qua Rex & perse , or as an oppressor , or an Abuser of his power ; the first indeed is to be disouned , for a King as King or Lawful Magistrate must not be resisted Rom. 13. 2. But the second , to declare war against a King as an oppressor and abuser of his power and subverter of the Laws , hath been ouned by our Church & State many a time , and they have opposed & declared war as purposedly against him as he did against them , and as really & formally as he was an oppres●or : sure he cannot be an oppressor only per accidens , nor does he declare war against the subjects only pes accidens : However this hath been ouned alwayes by Presbyterians , that war may be declared against him who is called King. And therefore to abjure a Declaration in so far as it declares war against the King , will condemn not only that Declaration upon the heads wherein its honesty & faithfulness chiefly consists , but all other most honest & honourable Declarations , that have been made & emitted by our worthy & renouned Ancestors , and by our Worthies in our oun time , who have formally , avowedly , & explicitely , or expressly , purposedly , & designedly declared their opposition to Tyranny & Tyrants , and their Lawful & laudable designs to repress , depress , & suppress them , by all the wayes & means , that God , & Nature , and the Laws of Nations allow , when they did ipso jure depose & exauctorate themselves from all Rule , or priviledge , or prerogative of Rulers , and became no more Gods ministers but Beelzebubs vicegerents , and Monsters to be exterminated out of the Society of Mankind . The honestest of all our Declarations of defensive war , have alwayes run in this strain ; And others , insinuating more preposterous Loayltie , have been justly taxed for asserting the Interest of the Tyrant , the greatest enemy of the declarers , and principal object of the declared war ; which disingenuous jugling & foysting in such flattering & falsifying distinctions in the State of the Quarrel , hath rationally been thought one of the procuring Causes or Occasions of the discomfiture of our former Appearances , for the Work of God & Liberties of our Country , 3. This must infer an ouning of his Authority as Lawful King ; when the Declaration disouning him is abjured in so far as it declares war against his Majestie , for in this Oath he is styled and asserted to be King , and to have the Majestie of a Lawful King , and therefore must be ouned as such by all that take it : which yet I have proved to be sinful above Head. 2. Against this it hath been quibbled by some , that that Declaration does not declare war against the King expresly as King , but only against Charles Stewart , by them declared to be no King who set forth the Declaration . But this will not salve the matter ; for then ( 1 ) It is a subscribing to a lie , in abjuring a Declaration in so far as it did declare a thing , which it did not , if that hold . ( 2 ) The enemies impose the abjuring & disouning of it , in so far as it declares war against their King , who had none other but Charles Stewart at that time , who was the King in their sense ; and an Oath cannot be taken in any other sense , contradictory to the Imposers , even though by them allowed , without an unjustifiable equivocation . ( 3 ) Though he had been King , and had not committed such acts of Tyranny as might actually denominate him a Tyrant , & forefeit his Kingship ; yet to repress his illegal arbitrariness & intollerable enormities , and to repel his unjust violence , and reduce him to good order , Subjects , at least for their oun defence , may declare a war expresly , purposedly & designedly against their oun acknowledged King : This ought not in so far to be disouned ; For then all our Declarations emitted , during the whole time of prosecuting the Reformation , in opposition to our King : would be disouned : And so with one dash unhappily the whole Work of Reformation , and the way of carrying it on , is hereby tacitely & consequentially reflected upon & reproached , if not disouned . 4. It must infer an ouning of the Ecclesiastical Supremacy , when it asserts that some do serve the King in Church as well as in State : there is no Distinction here , but they are said to serve him the same way in both . And it is certain they mean so , and have expressed so much in their Acts , that Church men are as subordinate , and the same way subject to the Kings Supremacy , as Statsmen are . The absurdity & blasphemy of which , is discovered above . 5. This condemns all killing of any that serve the King , in Church , State , Army , or Country : for a Declaration is abjured in so far as it asserts it Lawful to kill any such ; And so by this Oath , there is an impunity secured for his Idolatrous priests , and Murdering varlets , that serve him in the Church ; for his bloody Councellors , and Gouned Murderers , that serve his Tyrannical designs in the State ; for his bloody Lictors & Executioners , the Sword men , that serve him in the Army , whom he may send when he pleases to murder us ; and for his bloody Iust-asses , Informers , & Intelligencing Sycophants , the Ziphites , that serve him in the Country : All these must escape bringing to con●ign punishment , contrary to the 4. Art. of the Solemn League & Covenant , and shall be confuted Head. 6. Against this it is excepted by the Pleaders for this Oath , that it is only a declared abhoring of Murdering principles , which no Christian dare refuse ; And it may be taken in this sense safly , that it is to be abjured in so far as it asserts it Lawful to kill all that are to be imployed by his Maj. or any because so imployed , in Church , State , Army , or Country ; Which never any did assert was Law-ful : But though Murdering principles are indeed alwayes to be declaredly abhorred , and all Refusers of that Oath did both declare so much , and abhorred the thoughts of them ; yet this evasion is naught , for ( 1 ) The Declaration asserts no such thing , neither for that cause nor for any other , but expressly makes a distinction , between persons under the Epithet of bloody cruel Murderers , and these only whom it threateneth to animadvert upon . ( 2 ) The only reason of their declared intent of prosecuting these , whom they threaten to bring to conding punishment , was because they were so imployed by the Tyrant in such service , as shedding the blood of Innocents , Murdering people where they met them ; And so that 's the very reason for which they deserve to be killed , and therefore foolish , impertinent , and very absurd to be alledged , as a qualification of the sense of that impious Oath . 5. If we consider the Proclamation enjoining this Oath , and narrating and explaining the Occasions & causes of it , all these reasons against it will be confirmed ; and it will further appear , that the Proclamation it self is indirectly approved . For though it might be sustained : in the abstract , that we may & must renounce such Declarations founded on Principles inconsistent with Government , and bearing such inferences as are specified in that Proclamation : yet complexly considering what they mean by Government , and what sort of Societie that is , the Security whereof is said to be infringed by that Declaration , And what is the Scope of that Narrative ; A renouncing of a paper contradictory thereto , must be in so far a tacite approbation of that Proclamation . For that Oath which renounceth what is contrary to such a Proclamation , does justify the Proclamation : But this Oath renounces what is contrary to the Proclamation , and that only : Ergo it justifies the Proclamation . It is entituled , as it was really designed , for discovering such as oune or will not disoune the foresaid Declaration , by them falsely nicknamed , a late treasonable Declaration of war against his Majestie , and the horrid principle of Assassination . And the body of it discovers such hell-bred hatred of & malice against that poor party , destinated in their design to final & total destruction , and layes doun such Contrivances for their discovery and ruin , that the heads & hearts of the Inventors & Authors may seem to be possessed & inspired with the Devils immediatly assisting Counsell , and the Clerks pen that drew it up to have been dipt in the Stygian lake and the Gall & venome of hell : Representing the Emitters & Abetters & Spreaders of that Declaration , and all who have been joined in any of their Societies , and all who either will oune or scruple to disoune the said Declaration , in the manner by them tendered & imposed , ( which are the Generality of the most tender & consciencious Christians in the Land ) under all the vilest & most abominable & odious terms , their malice could invent ; as if they were Insolent & desperate Rebells , associated under a pretended forme of Government , who had formerly endeavoured to disguise their bloody & execrable principles , but now had pulled off the mask , and who think it a duty to kill & Murder all who do any manner of way serve the present Rulers , or bear charge under them ; who maintain principles inconsistent with all Government & Society , and tending to the destruction of the lives of their Loyal & honest subjects ; Treacherous & assassinating principles &c. who now have declared their hellish intentions , and for the better performance of their mischievons designs , do lurk in secret , and are never discerned but in the acts of their horrid assassinations , and passing up & doun among the Kings Loyal subjects , take opportunity to murder & assassinate , like execrable Rebells ; And Calling that Declaration , an execrable & damnable Paper &c. All which are execrable & damnable lies , and forgeries of the father of them , and a Charge which all their Sophistrie can never make out in any particular : Yet by them amplified to a swelling hight of heinousness ; And among other circumstances , aggravated from their frequent refusing the reiterated Offers of their Clemency , by which they understand their contempt of their presumptuous , Christ-defying , and Church-destroying Indulgences , and their not submitting to their insnaring & base Indemnities , or their conscience-cheating Bonds & Oaths by them so finely busked . From these impudently pretended premises , in their falsly forged viperous Narative , they lay doun their bloody Methods & Measurs for prosecuting that poor people , with all rigour of Savage Severity ; Ordaining , that whosoever shall oune that Declaration , and the principles therein specified ( which is a lager Dilatation of their meaning , than their pretended restriction [ in so far as &c. ] and gives a further discovery of the intent of the Oath , that gives a Covert stroke to all the principles of our Reformation which are reductively specified in that Declaration ) or whosoever shall refuse to disoune the same — shall be execute to the death ; And commanding all subjects to concur , and do their utmost endeavour , to seek , search , delate , & apprehend all such , under the severest penalties of the Laws ; And to difference the good from the bad ( meaning their oun Associates & friends , from Christs followers ) by discriminating signs , Declaring it their pleasure , and requiring all past the age of sixteen years , not to presume to travel without Testificates of , their Loyaltie & good principles , by taking the Oath of Abjuration ; whereupon they are to have a Testificate which is to serve for a free Pass , with certification to all that shall adventure to travel without such a Testificate , shall be holden & used as Concurrers with the said Rebells ; Commanding all Heretors &c. to give up the lists of the names of all under them , before the Curate ; Declaring , if any shall refuse to concur in such service , shall be holden as guilty of the foresaid crimes & punished accordingly ; And strictly prohibiting , all to harbour , lodge , or intertain any , unless they have such certificates under the same pain ; And for encouragment to any that shall discover or apprehend any to be found guilty as above said , ensuring to them the sum of 500 Merks Scots for each of them . This is that hell-hatcht Proclamation , so grievous for its effects , so dreadful for its designs , so monstrous for its absurdities , that the like hath not been seen : Whereby not only the countries Interest & Trade hath been prejudged , by compelling all to have a pass in time of peace , and these to be procured at exorbitant rates , oppressing poor people ; Not only common Hostlers & Inn-keepers are made Judges , impowered to impose Oaths upon Passengers for their passes , that they be not forged ; but many consciences coozened , cheated , wounded , & insnared , and the whole Land involved in sin . But they that took this Oath have approved & justified this detestable , execrable , bloody Proclamation , the supurious spawn of the Devills venome against Christ followers : For , they gave all the Obedience to it that was required of them in their Capacity , And obedience justifies the Law enjoining it : They have done all was required , or could be done by them , to answer the design of it in their circumstances ; And consequently by doing the thing prescribed , they have justified the grounds upon which the prescript was founded , and the methods by which it was prosecuted , which hath a dreadful Medley of iniquitie in it . Hence ( 1 ) They have subscribed to all these Odious Characters wherewith they branded that poor persecuted party , and have condemned them as Insolent , desperate Rebells , Murderers , bloody Assassins &c. ( 2 ) In disouning that Declaration , they have disouned the principles therein specified , and consequently all the Testimonie against this Usurping faction of Overturners of the Work of Reformation , Active & passive , that have been given & sealed by the eminent Servants of God , since this Catastrophe , the principle of Defensive Armes , and our Covenants , and several others which are therein specified . ( 3 ) They have given their consent to all the concurrence there required , for seeking , searching , delating , & apprehending of these people , and to all the cruel villanies committed against them . ( 4 ) They have taken on their prescribed discriminating Sign of Loyaltie , and of being repute by them men of good principles , that is , their friends , men for the times : Which is so sinful & scandalous , that it is shameful to hint at them , and yet shameful to hide them . 6. If we consider the Apologetical Declaration it self , which is so bespattered , and so odiously represented , and so rigorously enjoined to be abjured ; who will more narrowly look into it , and ponder & perpend the purpose & Scope of it , will see nothing that can be abjured conscienciously in it , but the whole of it , laying aside prejudice & invidious Critical Censoriousness , capable of a fair & acceptable Construction . The Motives leading them to set it forth , being only their desires and just endeavoures to prosecute , and secure themselves in the prosecution of , Holy Commanded Duties , and to keep a standing Testimony , against the Insolencie of those that are given up of God , to lay out themselves in promoving a Course of profanity & persecution , notwithstanding of all their viperous threatenings . Their Measures being none other , than the commendable precedents & Examples of zealous & tender hearted Christians , who have done the like , and our National and Solemn Covenants , lying with their binding force indispensable upon all of us , and obliging us to endeavour all that 's there declared , as being bound for ever to have common friends & foes with our Covenanted Reformation , to all which they declare & avouch their resolved adherence , And their oun former Declarations , Disouning their Allegiance to , & Authority of a Man who had ipso jure forfeited all Authority , by his intollerable Tyrannie , Perjurie , & perfidious breach of Trust , reposed & devolved upon him by Covenant , and by his overturning all the fundamental constitutions of the Government , perverting , inverting , & everting all Laws , all Liberties all Priviledges of Church & State , all establishments of our Covenanted Work of Reformation , all Securities of our life and enjoyments whatsoever , Usurping to himself an absolute Tyrannical Civil Supremacy , inconsistent with the safety or freedom of the people , and a monstrous blasphemous Ecclesiastical Supremacy ; Upon which considerations , to endeavour to make good their freedom & emancipation from that yoke which they had cast off , they behoved to resolve upon defensive resistence , against him and his bloody emissaries ; Which war being declared before , they only in this Declaration testified their unanimous approbation of ▪ adherence to , and resolutions for prosecuting the same , against him & his accomplices , such as lay out themselves to promove his wicked & hellish designs : By which war they do not mean a formed stated & declared Insurection with hostile force , to break the Peace of the Nation , and involve all in blood , but a resolved avowed constant Opposition to the Murdering violence , injustice , oppression , & persecution of this wicked faction , now raging rather than reigning , who have declared & still prosecute a declared war against Christ , bearing doun His Work & Interest in the Land ; And a constant endeavour , in opposition to them , to pursue the ends of our Covenants , in standing to the defence of the Glorious Work of Reformation , and their oun lives ; And in the defence thereof , to maintain the cause & Interest of Christ against His enemies , and to hold up the Standard of our Lord Jesus Christ , ( meaning the Gospel & the Word of our Testimony , ) whereunto they looked upon themselves as bound & obliged by their holy Covenants , being therein dedicated to the Lord in their persons , lives , Liberties , & fortunes , for defending & promoving this Glorious Work of Reformation , notwithstanding of all opposition , that is or may be made thereunto , and sworn against all neutrality & indifferency in the Lords Matters : Whereunto they beseech , invite , & obtest , all them who wish well to Zion to a concurrence & concerting the same cause & Quarrel . In maintaining of which opposition against such wicked Enemies , because by them they were restlessly pursued and hunted , and Murdered wherever they were found , neither could find any harbour or hiding place in any Corner of the country , for Searchers , Informers , & Justigators , who still stirred up the country to raise the hue & Crye after them , and caused them to be delivered up , and del●ted them to the Courts of their Murdering enemies , whereby much innocent blood was shed ; Therefore , to stop their Career of violence , and deter them from such Courses , they found it necessary to threaten them with more active & vigorous opposition , and that they might expect to be treated as they deserved . Wherein they are far from ouning assassinating principles , or practising assassinations ; for they give only open & plain warning , and advertisement to the world , of their necessitated endeavours to defend themselves , and prevent the Murder of their Brethren : And can no way be charged , with asserting it Lawful , to kill all employed in the Kings service in Church , State , Army , or Country , as the Proclamation in viperous invective Calumny misrepresents the Declaration , but on the contrary do jointly & unanimously declare , they detest & abhor that hellish principle of killing such as differ in judgement from them , and they are firmly & really purposed , not to injure or offend any whomsoever , but such as are directly guilty of , or accessory to the Murder of their Brethren : whom yet they mind not to assassinate or kill tumultuarly , but to prosecute them with all the legal formalities , that Justice in their Capacity , and the times disorder & distracted condition , will allow ; Expressly declaring , that they abhor , condemn , & discharge all personall attempts upon any pretext whatsomever , without previous deliberations , common consent , certain probation of sufficient witnesses , or the guilty persons confession . Neither could it ever be supposed , that they threaten all imployed in the Kings service with this sort of handling , but some select & expressly distinguished Kind of Notorious villains , men of death & blood , openly avowing & vaunting of their Murders : and these they distinguished into several Classes , according to the respective aggravations of their wickedness : In the first , they place those that Murder by Command , under pretext of an usurped Authority , as Councellours , Justiciary , & Officers of their forces , or bands of Robbers & not all nor any of these neither but the cruel & bloody . In the second Class , they threaten such as are actually in armes against them of an inferior rank ; And such Gentlemen , and Bishops , & Curats , as do professedly & willingly serve them to accomplish & effectuate their Murders , by obeying their commands , making searth for these poor men , delivering them up , instigating , informing , and witnessing against & hunting after them : & not all these neither , but such as cruelly prosecute that service , to the effussion of their blood . Neither do they threaten all equally , nor any of them peremptorly , but that continuing after the publication of this their Declaration obstinately & habitually in these courses ( Plainly declaring they intended no hurt to them if they would hold up their hands ) they would repute them as enemies to God & the Reformation , and punish them as such , according to their power , and the degree of their offence ; Withall leaving room for Civil & Ecclesiastical satisfaction , before Lawful & settled Judicatories , for the offences of such persons , as their power may not reach &c. And as unwilling to be necessitated to such severe Courses , and earnestly desirous they be prevented , they admonish them with sorrow & seriousness , of the sin & hazard of their wicked Courses ; and protest , that only Necessity of self preservation , and zeal to Religion , lest it should be totally rooted out by their insolency , did drive them to this threatening Declaration , and not because they ▪ were acted by any sinful spirit of revange . This is all that is contained in that Declaration . And if here be any thing there so odious & execrable , to be so solemnly abjured , renounced , & abhorred in the persence of God , for the pleasure of and in obedience to the will of His & our enemies , let all unbyassed Considerers impartially weigh , or any awakened Conscience speak , and I doubt not but the swearing & subscribing this Oath will be cast & condemned . I shall say nothing of the necessity , or conveniency , or expediency , or formality of this Declaration : but the Lawfulness of the matter complexely taken is so undeniable , that it cannot be renounced without condemning many very Material Principles of our Reformation : Only Success & Incapacity is wanting to justify the manner , whole proceedure , formality , and all the Circumstances of the business ; If either the Declarers themselves , or any other i● powered with strength and countenanced with success to make good the undertaking , had issued out such a Declaration in the same terms , and had prevailed & prospered in the Project , many that have now abjured it would approve & applaud it . But passing these things that are extrinsick to the consideration in hand , it is the matter that they required to be abjured & condemned , it is that the enemies quarrelled at , and not the inexpediency or informalities of it : And it must be taken as they propound it , and abjured & renounced by Oath as they represent it : And therefore the iniquity of this subscription will appear to be great , in two respects : First in denying the Truth : Secondly in subscribing to , & swearing a Lie. 1. They that have taken that Oath have denied & renounced the matter of that Declaration ; which is Truth & duty , and a Testimony to the Cause of Christ , as it is this day Stated & Circumstantiate in the Nation , founded upon former ( among us uncontroverted ) precedents & Principles of Defensive Wars , disouning Tyranny , & repressing the insolency of Tyrants & their Accomplices ; the whole matter being reducible to these two Points , Declaring a resolved endeavour of breaking the Tyrants yoke from off our neck , thereby asserting our oun & the posterities Liberty & freedom from his insupportable & entailed slavery ; And a just Threatening to curb & restrain the insolency of Murderers , or to bring them to condign punishment : Whereof as the first is no wayes repugnant , but very consonant to the Third Article ; So the Second is the very duty obliged unto in the Fourth Article of our Solemn League & Covenant . But all this they have denied by taking that Oath . 2. By taking that Oath , they have sworn & subscribed to a Lie , taking it as they represent it , abjuring it in so far as it declares &c. & asserts it is Lawful to kill all imployed in the service of the King , in Church , State , Army , or Country : which is a manifest Lie , for it asserts no such thing . Neither will any other sense put upon the words in so far as salve the matter ; for as thereby the Takers of the Oath shall deal deceitfully , in frustrating the end of the Oath , and the design of the Tenderers thereof ; And to take an Oath quatenus , eatenus , in so far , will not satisfie as Voetius Judgeth de Pol. Eccl. P. 213. So let them be taken which way they can , either for in quantum , or quatenus , or si modo , it is either a denying the Truth , or subscribing a Lie : And Consequently , these poor people suffered for Righteousness that Refused it . HEAD . IV. The Sufferings of people for frequenting Field Meetings Vindicated . HItherto the Negative Heads of Sufferings have been vindicated : now follow the Positive , founded upon Positive duties , for doing , and not denying , and not promising & engaging to relinquish which , many have suffered severely . The first both in order of nature and of time , that which was first and last , and most frequently , most constantly , most universally , and most signally sealed by Sufferings , was that which is the clearest of all , being in some respect the Testimony of all Ages , and which clears all the rest , being the Rise & Root , Cause & Occasion of all the rest ; to wit , the Necessary duty of hearing the Gospel , & following the pure & powerful faithfully dispensed Ordinances of Christ , banished out of the Churches to private houses , and persecuted out of houses to the Open Fields , and there pursued & opposed , and sought to be suppressed , by all the fury & force , rigour & rage , Cruelty & Craft , policy & power , that ever wicked men , madded into a Monstrous Malice against the Mediator Christ and the Coming of His Kingdom , could contrive or exert : yet still followed & frequented , ouned & adhered to , by the Lovers of Christ & serious seekers of God , even when for the same they were killed all day long , and counted as sheep for the slaughter , and continually oppressed , harrassed , hunted , and cruelly handled , dragged to Prisons , banished & sold for slaves , tortured , & Murdered . And after , by their fraudulent favours of ensnaring Indulgences & Indemnities , and a Continued tract of Impositions & Exactions , and many Oaths & Bonds , they had prevailed with many , and even the most part both of Ministers & Professors , to abandon that necessary duty ; And even when it was declared Criminal by Act of Parliament , and interdicted under pain of death , to be found at any Field Meetings ; they nevertheless persisted in an undaunted endeavour , to keep up the Standart of Christ , in following the Word of the Lord wherever they could have it faithfully preached , though at the greatest of hazards : And so much the more , that it was prosecuted by the rage of enemies , and the reproach & oblequies of pretended friends , that had turned their back on the Testimony , and preferred their oun ease & Interests to the cause of Christ ; and with the greater fervor , that the Labourers in that Work were few , and like to faint under so many difficulties . What the first Occasion was that constrained them to go to the fields , is declared at length in the Historical Deduction of the Testimony of the Sixt Period ; to wit , finding themselves bound in duty , to Testifie their Adherence to & Continuance in their Covenanted profession , their Abhorrence of Abjured Prelacy , and their Love & Zeal to keep Christ & His Gospel in the Land ; after they had undergone & endured many hazards & hardships , oppressions & persecutions , for Meeting in the houses , where they were so easily attrapped , and with such difficulty could escape the hands of these Cruel Men ; they were forced to take the Fields , though with the unavoidable inconveniences of all Weathers without a shelter : yet proposing the advantages , both of Conveniency for Meeting in greater Numbers , and of Secrecie in the remote recesses of Wild Moors & Mountains , and of Safety in betaking themselves to inaccessible Natural Strengths , safest either for flight or resistence , And withal having occasion there to give a Testimony for the Reformation with greater freedom . And to this very day , though many have a pretended Liberty to meet in houses , under the security of a Mans promise whose principle is to keep no faith to Hereeicks , and under the shelter & shadow of an Antichristian Toleration ; yet there is a poor people that are out of the Compass of this favour , whom all these forementioned reasons do yet oblige to keep the fields , that is both for Conveniency , Secrecy , and Safety ; they dare not trust those who are still thirsting insatiably after their blood , nor give them such advantages as they are seeking to prey upon them , by shuting themselves within houses ; And morover they take themselves to be called indispensably , in the present Circumstances , to be as publick , or more than ever , in their Testimony for the Preached Gospel , even in the open Fields . Now this would be a litle cleared : And to essay the same , I would offer first , Some Concessions . Secondly some Postulata or Supposed Grounds . Thirdly some more Special Considerations which will conduce to clear the case . First , That we may more distinctly understand what is the duty here pleaded for , and what is that which these people Suffer for , here Vindicated ; let these Concessions be premised . 1. Now under the Evangelical Dispensation , there is no place more Sacred than another , to which the Worship of God is astricted , and which He hath chosen for His House & Habitation , whither He will have His people to resort and attend , as under the Legal & Typical Dispensation was ordered : there was a place where the Lord caused His Name to dwel Deut. 12. 5 , 11. But now , neither in the Mountain nor at Ierusalem the Father will be Worshipped , but every where and any where in Spirit & in Truth Iohn . 4. 21 , 23 , 24. And the Apostle wills that men pray every where , lifting up holy hands , without wrath & doubting 1 Tim. 2. 8. We abhor therefore the English & Popish Superstition of Consecrated places , and assert that all are alike in this respect , houses or fields . 2. In the Constitute case of the Church , or when ever it can be obtained , Order , Decency & Conveniency doth require that there be appointed places , sequestrate & appropriate for the Meetings of the Lords people , according to that General Rule , Let all things be done decently & in order 1 Cot. 14. ult . And in that case private Conventicles , set up in a Schismatical Competition with Publick Churches , are not to be allowed . But even then , Private Meetings for prayer & conference , are necessary , Lawful , & Laudable . But now the Church is broken by a Crew of Schismatical Intruders , who have occupied the places of Publick Assemblies , and thrust out the Lods Ministers : It is these we scare at , and not the place . 3. Suppose a Magistrate should interdict & Discharge the publik place of Worship , and restrain from the Churches , but leave all other places free to meet in ; or if he should prohibite the houses , but leave freedom for the fields ; or discharge the fields , and give Liberty in houses ; in that case we would not contend for the place out of contempt : though it were duty then to witness against such a Sacrilegious Injury done to the Church , in taking away their Meeting places ; yet it were inexpedient to stickle & strive for one Spot , if we might have another : then when only excluded out of a place , and not included or concluded and restricted to other places , nor otherwise robbed of the Churches priviledges , we might go to houses when shut out of Churches , and go to fields when shut out of houses , and back again to houses when discharged thence . But this is not our case , for we are either interdicted of all places ; or if allowed any , it is under such confinements as are inconsistent with the freedom of the Gospel ; and besides , we have to do with one from whom we can take no orders to determine our Meetings ; nor can we acknowledge our Liberty to depend on his Authority , or favour , which we cannot oune nor trust , nor accept of any Protection from him . Neither is it the place of fields or houses , that we contend for ; Nor is it that which he mainly opposes : but it is the freedom of the Gospel faithfully preached , that we are seeking to promove & improve , and he is seeking to suppress . The contest betwixt him & us is the Service of God in the Gospel of His Son , that we profess without ouning him for the Liberty of its exercise : And therefore as an Enemy to the Matter & Object of these Religious Exercises , which are the eye-sore of Antichrist , he prosecutes with such rage the manner & Circumstances thereof . 4. Even in this case , when we are persecuted in one place we flee unto another , as the Lord allowes & directs Math. 10. 23. And if occasionally we find a house , either publick , or a Church , or a private dwelling house that may be safe or convenient , or capacious of the numbers gathered , we think it indifferent to meet there or in the Fields : But in the present circumstances , it is more for the conveniency of the people , and more Congruous for the dayes Testimony , to keep the Fields in their Meetings , even though it irritate the incensed Enemies . Which that it may appear . Secondly , I shall offer some Postulata or Hypotheses to be considered , or endeavour to make them good , and infer from them the necessity & expediency of Field Meetings at this time in these circumstances : which consequently vindicate the Sufferings that have been thereupon Stated formerly , and are still continued . 1. It is necessary at all times that Christians should meet together , whether they have Ministers or not , and whether the Magistrate allow it or not . The Authority of God , their necessity , duty , & Interest , makes it indispensable in all cases . It is necessary for their Mutual help , two are better than one for if they fall the one will lift up his fellow , Eccles. 4. 9 , 10. It is necessary for their Mutual encouragment in an evil day , to speak often one to another , which the Lord hath promised to take special notice of Mal. 3. 16 , It is necessary for cherishing Mutual Love , which is the New Commandment , and the badge of all Christs Disciples Iohn . 13. 34 , 35. a principle which they are all thaught of God. 1 Thess. 4. 9. It is necessary for nurissing Union to communicate together , in order to their being of one mind & of one mouth , and that they receive one another Rom. 15. 5 , 6 , 7. 1 Cor. 1. 10. standing fast in one Spirit , striving together for the faith of the Gospel Phil. 1. 27. It is necessary for serving one another in Love Gal. 5. 13. bearing one anothers burdens , & so fulfilling the Law of Christ Gal. 6. 2. submitting to one another Ehphs. 5. 21. 1 Pet , 5. 5. teaching & admonishing one another Col. 3. 16. comforting one another 1 Thess. 4. ult . edifying one another 1 Thess. 5. 11. exhorting one another Heb. 3. 13. It is necessary for considering one another , & provoking unto love & to good works ; And for this end , they must not forsake the assembling of themselves together , as the manner of some is , for that were to sin wilfully Heb. 10. 24 , 25 , 26. Must these things depend on the Magistrats Allowance ? or can they be done without meeting together in private or publick ? The same reasons do alike conclude , for the necessity of both . If then there must be Meetings for these ends necessary at all times , then when they cannot do it within door , they must do it without . 2. There is a necessity for Meeting for preaching & h●aring the Gospel ; the enjoyment whereof hath alwayes been the greatest design & desire of Saints , who could not live without it ; therefore they loved the place where the Lords Honour dwelt Psal. 26. 8. This was the one thing they desired of the Lord , and that they would seek after , to behold the beauty of the Lord Psal. 27. 4. for this they panted , and their Soul thirsted Psal. 42. 1 , 2. without which every Land is but a thirsty Land , where there is no water , where they cannot see the power & the Glory of God as they have seen it in the Sanctuary Psal. 63. 1 , 2. O how amiable are His Tabernacles ? one day in His Courts is better than a thousand else where Psal. 84. 1 , 10. No gladness to them like that of going to the House of the Lord Psal. 122. 1. A Christian can not possibly live without Gospel Ordinances , no more than Children can want the breasts , or the poor & needy want water when their tongue faileth for thirst ; they are promised it in high places , and in the wilderness , when they can get it no where else Isai. 41. 17 , 18. There is an innate desire in the Saints after it , as new born habes they desire the sincere milk of the Word 1 Pet. 2. 2. So that any that is offended with them for this , must be offended with them for being Christians , for as such they must have the Gospel cost what is will. It is the greatest desire of the Spouse of Christ , to know where He feeds and where to find the Shepherds tents , where they may rest at noon Cant. 1. 7 , 8. And not only in their esteem is it necessary ; but in it self , the Church cannot bear the want of it , for where there is no vision the people perish Prov. 29. 18. and when there is no open vision , the Word of the Lord is then very precious 1 Sam. 3. 1. No wonder then that the Lords people make such adoe for it , in a famine of it , that they go from sea to sea , to seek it Amos 8. 11 , 12. and that they are content to have it at any rate , though with the peril of their lives because of the sword of the Wilderness Lam. 5. 9. Seeing they cannot live without it . Would men be hindered by Law , from seeking their natural food ? nay they would fight for it before they wanted it , against any that opposed them . If then they cannot get it with peace , they must have it with trouble : And if they cannot get it in houses , they must have it wherever it is to be found , with freedom , & the favour of God. 3. It is necessary that the Meetings be as publik , as they can be with Conveniencie & Prudence ; yea simple hazard should no more hinder their Publickness & Solemnity , than their being at all . Especially in an evil time , when wickedness is encouraged & established , and conformity thereto pressed , Truth banished , and a Witness for Christ suppressed , Corruption in Doctrine , Worship , Discipline , & Government connived at , countenanced , and advanced , the Word of God is become a reproach , and men have no delight in it , Apostacy is become universal , and both Magistrats & Ministers generally turned promoters of it , which is the true Discription of our times : Then the Meetings of the Lords people , that endeavour to keep clean Garments , should be more frequent , publick , & avowed . The reasons are . 1. Then the Call of God , by His Word & Works , is more clamant , for publick & solemn humiliation . in order to avert publick imminent judgments and impendent stroks from God. It is not enough to reforme our selvs privately & personally , and to keep our selves pure from such Courses by an abstraction & withdrawing from them as is proved Head. 1. ( where this is improved as an argument against hearing the Curats ) Nor is it enough to admonish , exhort , reprove , & testify against such as are involved in these Courses : But it is necessary , for them that would be approven , to adhere to the Truth , and serve God after the right manner , and to mourn , sigh and cry for all the abominations of the time , so as to get the Mark of Mourners on their foreheads Ezek. 9. 4. and they that do so , wil be found on the Mountains like doves in the valleyes all of them mourning every one for his iniquity Ezek. 7. 16. and not only to by humbled every family apart , but there must be a great Mourning as the Mourning of Hadadrimmon in the valley of Megiddon Zech. 12. 11. to the end . That is a Solemn publick Mourning there promised . There must be a gathering themselves together , though a Nation not desired , before the decree bring forth , before the day pass as the chaff , and the fierce anger of the Lord come upon them , if they would have any possibility of their hiding Zeph. 2. 1 , 2 , 3. The Trumpet then must be blown in Zion , to sanctify a fast , to call a solemn Assembly , Gather the people , Sanctify the Congregation , Assemble the Elders , Gather the Children — Ioel. 2. 15 , 16. As was exemplified in Ezra's time , when there were great Congregations of people assembled publickly , weeping very sore , then there was hope in Israel Ezra . 10. 1 , 2. and when that Messenger of the Lord came up from Gilgal to the people of Israel , and reproved them for their Defections & Compliance with the Canaanites , they had such a solemn day of humilation , that the place of their Meeting got a name from it , they called the name of that place Bochim , that is , Weepers Iudg. 2. 4 , 5. And when the Ark was at Kirjath-jearim all the house of Israel lamented after the Lord — and they gathered together to Mizpeh and drew water & poured it out before the Lord 2 Sam. 7. 2 , 6. I shew before , that there is reason to fear that the sins of a few , especially of Magistrats & Ministers , will bring wrath upon the whole body of the people , as is plain from these Scriptures Levit. 10. 6. Isai. 43. 27 , 28. Lam. 4 , 13. Mic. 3. 11 , 21. shewing the sins of Ministers may procure universal Destruction . And 2 Sam. 24. 25. 2 King. 21. 11. Ier. 15 , 4. proving the sins of Magistrats may procure it : And Num. 3. 14 , 15. Iosh. 22. 17 , 18. Demonstrating that the sins of a party of the people , may draw wrath upon the whole . Now the only way the Scripture points out to evite & avert such publick judgments , is to make our resentment of these indignities done to our God , our Mourning over them , and our witness against them , as publick as the sins are , at least as publick as we can get them , by a publick pleading for Truth Isai. 59. 4. for the defect whereof He hides His face , and wonders that there is no man , no Intercessor vers . 16. that is none to plead with God , in behalf of His born doun Truths : There must be in order to this , a publick seeking of Truth , which if there be any found making conscience of , the Lord makes a gracious overture to pardon the City Ier. 5. 1. we cannot think there were no mourners in secret there , but there was no publick Meeting for it , and publick ouning the duty of that day : There must be valour for the Truth upon the earth Ier. 9. 3. a publick & resolute ouning of Truth : There must be a making up the hedge & standing in the Gap for the Land , that the Lord should not destroy it Ezek. 22. 30. a publick Testimony in opposition to defection : There must be a pleading with our Mother Hos. 2. 2. which is spoken to private persons in the plural number Commanding all that would consult their oun safety , publickly to condemn the sins of the whole Nation , that they may escape the publick punishment thereof , as it is expounded in Pool Synops. Critic . in locum . By this means we must endeavour to avert the wrath & anger of God , which must certainly be expected to go out against the Land , which hath all the procuring causes , all the Symptoms , Prognosticks , & Evidences of a Land devoted to destruction , that ever a Land had . If then there must be such Publick Mourning , and such Solemn Gathering for it , such public pleading for Truth , Seeking of Truth , valour for Truth , making up the hedge , and pleading with our Mother , there must of Necessity be publick Meetings for it : for these things cannot be done in private , but must be done by way of Testimony . Which I make a 2. Reason . The Nature & End of Meeting for Gospel Ordinances is for a publick Testimony for Christ and His Truths & Interest , against Sin and all dishonours done to the Son of God. So that the only end , is not only to bring to Christ & build up Souls in Christ , but it is to Testify also for the Glory of Christ , whether Souls be brought in & built up or not . The Preached Gospel is not only the Testimony of Christ 1 Cor , 1. 6. but a Testimony for Christ ; in which sense , The Testimony of Iesus is said to be the Spirit of Prophesie Revel . 19. 10. so called , Durham expounds it , for its bearing Witness to Christ , in which respect Ministers are often called Witnesses . It is also the Testimony of Israel ( not only given to Israel , but given by Israel ) unto which the tribes go up , the tribes of the Lord Ps. 122. 4. Whensoever therefore or howsoever the Testimony of the Church is contradicted , that 's not a Lawful Meeting of the tribes of the Lord. It is also the Testimony of the Preachers for Christ , against them that will not receive them , Mark. 6. 11. And a Witness unto all Nations to whom they preach . Math. 24. 14. And of all the Witnesses that hold it & suffer for it Rev. 6. 9. And the same which is the Word of Christs Testimony , is the Word of theirs Rev , 12. 11. by which they overcome , & for which they love not their lives . Wherever then the Gospel is preached , it must be a Testimony : But it cannot be a Testimony , except it be Publick , at least as publick as it can be , as we find all Christs Witnesses were in the Old & New Testaments . 3. The Motive or principle prompting the Lords people to a frequenting of Gospel Ordinances , is a publick Spirit stirring up to a publick Generation Work , whereof this is the Scope , to promote the Kingdom of Christ , and not only to obey the Lords Command enjoining the duty , to enjoy the Lord the end thereof , or to edify their oun Souls ; But to partake in & promote this Great Work of the Day , for the Glory of God and the Churches good . For the Gospel is not only a Banner of Love over His Friends , but Christs Standart of war against His Enemies Isai. 59. 19. under which , all that countenance it , are called to list themselves as His Souldiers called , & chosen , & faithful : And it is required of His Souldiers , that they be valiant for the Truth upon the earth , Discovering a Gallant greatness & generosity of a Publick Spirit , having their designs & desires not limited to their oun interests , even Spiritual , but aiming at no less than Christs Publick Glory , the Churches publick good , the Saints publick Comfort , having a publick Concern for all Christs Interests , Publik Sympathie for all Christs Friends , and a publick declared Opposition to all Christs Enemies : This is a Publick Spirit , the true Spirit of all Christs zealous Lovers & Votaries : Which , when He is a missing , will prompt them to go about the City , in the streets , and in the broad wayes , to seek Him whom their Soul loveth Cant. 3. 2. and not only in their beds , or secret corners , but they must go to the streets , and to the fields , and avow their seeking of Christ , even though the Watchmen should smite them , & the keepers of the walls take their vails from them Cant. 5. Which obliges them not only to take Him in to their oun Cottages , and intertain Him in their hearts , and give Him a Throne there , but also to endeavour to enlarge His dwelling , and propagate His Courtly residence through the World , that the Kingdoms of the earth may becom the Kingdoms of the Lord ; and if they cannot get that done , yet that He may have the Throne in ●her Mothers house , and take up His abode in the Church , or Nation they belong to , that there His Ordinances be established in purity , peace , plenty , & power , according to His oun Order ; And if that cannot be , but that their Mother play the harlot , and He be provoked to give up house with her , and by her Childrens treacherie the Usurping Enemy be invited in to His place & Habitation , and take violent possession of it , and enact His extrusion & expulsion by Law ; yet they will endeavour to secure a place for Him among the Remnant , that He may get a lodging among the afflicted & poor people that trust in the Name of the Lord — that they may feed & Lie doun & none make them afraid Zeph. 3. 12 , 13. that the poor of the flock that wait on Him may know that it is the Word of the Lord , Zech. 11. 11. they will lay out themselves to strengthen their hands . This is the Work of the publick spirited Lovers of the Gospel , which hath been and yet is the great work of this our day , to carry the Gospel , and follow it , and keep it up through the Land , as the Standart of Christ , against all opposition , from mountain to hill , when now Zion hath been Labouring to bring forth as a woman in travel , and made to go forth out of the City , and to dwell in the field Mic. 4. 10. Therefore seeing it is the publick Work of the day , and all its followers must have such a publick spirit , it followes that the Meetings to promote it must be as publick as is possible . 4. The Interest & priviledge of the Gospel , to have it in freedom , purty , power , & plenty , is the publick Concern of all the Lords people , preferable to all other Interests , and therefore more publickly , peremptorly and zealously to be contended for , than any other Interest whatsoever . It is the Glory of the Land 1 Sam. 4. 21. without which , Ichabod may be the name of every thing ; and every Land , though never so pleasant , will be but a dry & parched Land , where no water is , in the esteem of them that have seen the Lords Glory & power in the Sanctuary Psal. 63. 1. Where as its name is Hephzibah & Beulah Isai. 62. 4. and Iehovah-Shammah Ezek. 48. ult . where God is enjoyed in His Gospel Ordinances ; And the want & reproach of the Solemn Assemblies , is a matter of the saddest mourning to the Lords people Zeph. 3. 18. Therefore while the Ark abode in Kerjath-jearim the time was thought very Long , and all the house of Israel Lamented after the Lord 1 Sam. 7. 2. then they heard of it at Ephratah and found it in the fields of the Wood Psal. 132. 6. But it hath been longer than twenty years in our fields of the Woods , and therefore we should be Lamenting after it with greater concernedness ; especially remembering , how we were priviledged with the Gospel , which was somtimes publickly embraced & countenanced by Authority , and ensured to us by Laws , Statutes , Declarations , Proclamations , Oaths , Vowes , & Covenant-engagments , whereby the Land was dedicated & devoted unto the Son of God , whose Conquest it was . And now are not all the people of God obliged to do what they can , to hinder the recalling of this dedication , and the giving up of the Land as an offering unto Satan & Antichrist ? And how shall this be , but by a publick Contending for this priviledge , and a resolving they shall sooner bereave us of our hearts blood , than of the Gospel in its freedom & purity ? But this we cannot contend for publickly , if our Meetings be not publick . 5. The nature & business of the Gospel Ministrie is such , that it obliges them that exercise it to endeavour all publickness , without which they cannot discharge the extent of their Instructions : their very names & titles do insinuate so much . They are Witnesses for Christ , and therefore their Testimony should be publick , though their Lot oftentimes be to Witness in Sackcloth : They are Heraulds , and therefore they should Proclaim their Masters Will , though their Lot be often to be a voice crying in the Wilderness , as Iohn the Baptist was in his field Preachings : They are Ambassadours , and therefore they should maintain their Masters Majestie , in the Publick port of His Ambassadours , and be wholly taken up about their Soveraigns business : They are Watchmen , and therefore they should keep & maintain their post their Masters hath placed them at : Nay they are Lights & Candles , and therefore cannot be hid Math. 5. 14 , 15. The Commands & Instructions given them , infer the nec●ssity of this : They must cry aloud , and not spare , and left up their voice like a Trumpet , and shew the Lords People their transgressions & sins Isai. 58. 1. They are Watchmen upon Ierusalems walls , which must not hold their peace , day nor night , nor keep silence , nor give the Lord rest , till He establish and till He make Ierusalem a praise in the earth Isai. 62. 6 , 7. They are Watchmen , that must command all to hearken to the sound of the Trumpet Ier. 6. 17. They must be valiant for the Truth upon the earth Ier. 9. 3. They must say , thus saith the Lord even to a rebellious Nation , whether they will hear or forbear , and not be afraid of them Ezek. 2. 5 , 6. They must cause the people to know their abominations Ezek. 16. 2. and the abominations of their Fathers Ezek. 20. 4. And what their Master tells them in darkness , that they must speak in the Light , and what they hear in the ear , that they must Preach upon the house tops Math , 10. 27. These things cannot be done in a Clandestine way . And therefore now when there is so much necessity , it is the duty of all faithful Ministers , to be laying out themselves to the utmost in their Pastoral function , for the suppreffing of all the evils of the time , not withstanding of any prohibition to the contrary , in the most publick manner , according to the examples of all the faithful servants of the Lord , both in the Old & New Testaments ; Though it be most impiously & Tyrannically interdicted , yet the Laws of God stand unrepealed , and therefore all who have a Trumpet & a Mouth should set the Trumpet to their Mouth , and sound a certain sound ; not in secret for that will not alarme the people , but in in the most publick manner they can have access to . And it is the duty of all to come & hear & obey their Warnings & Witnessings , command who will the contrary . It was for mocking , despising His Words , & misusing His Prophets , that the wrath of the Lord arose against His people , the Iewes , until there was no remedy 2 Chron. 36 , 16. Therefore from all that is said , it must be Concluded , that Meetings for Gospel Ordinances must be as publick as can be : And if so , then that they should be in houses , safety will not permit to us ; to go to the streets or Mercat places , neither safety nor prudence will admit : Therefore we must go to the fields with it , cost what it will. 4. Seeing then there must be Meettngs , & publick Meetings , And seeing we cannot and dare not in Conscience countenance the Curats Meetings ; we must hear , oune , embrace , & follow such faithful Ministers as are cloathed with Christ Commission , Righteousness , & salvation , and do keep the Words of the Lords patience , and the Testimony of the Church of Scotland in particular . This I think will not , or dare not be denyed , by any that oune the Authority of Christ ( which none can deny or instruct the contrary , but our Ministers that ventured their lives in preaching in the fields have had a certain seal to their Ministry , & is sealed sensibly in the conviction of many , & confession of moe ) That Christs Ministers & Witnesses , employed about the Great Gospel Message , cloathed with His Authority , & under the obligation of His Commands lying upon them , must preach , & the people must hear them , not withstanding of all Laws to the contrary . Divines grant that the Magistrate can no more suspend from the exercise , than he can depose from the Office of the Ministry ; for the one is a degree unto the other . See Apollon . de jure Majest . circa Sacra . Part. 1. Pag. 334. &c. Rutherf . Due right of Presb. Pag. 430. &c. For whether it be right in the sight of God , to hearken unto men more than unto God , the Consciences of the greatest enemies may be appealed unto Act. 4. 19. They must not cease , wherever they have a Call & Occasion , to Teach & Preach Iesus Christ Act. 5. ult . Necessity is laid upon them , yea wo unto them if they Preach not the Gospel 1 Cor. 9. 16. In all things they must approve themselves , as the Ministers of God , in much patience , in afflictions , in necessities , &c. by honour & dishonour , by evil report & good report , as deceivers and yet true , as unknown & yet well known — 2 Cor. 6. 4 , 8 , 9. They must preach the Word , be instant in season , & out of season , reprove , rebuke , exhort , with all long suffering & doctrine 2 Tim. 4. 2. Dare any say then , that a Magistrats or Tyrants Laws can exauctorate a Minister ? or silence him by his oun proper elicite acts , as King or Tyrant , or formally & immediately ? Will Mischiefs framed into a Law , warrant such iniquity ? or an act of a King of Clay rescind the Mandats of the King of Kings ? or exempt people from obedience due thereunto ? Or will the Bishops Canons , who have no power from Christ , or the Censures of them , that stand condemned themselves by the Constitutions of the Church & Acts of the General Assemblies , have any weight in the case ? And yet these are all that can be alledged , except odious & invidious Calumnies , the ordinary Lot of the most faithful , against the present preachers in the fields , which are sufficiently confuted in their late Informatory Vindication , and need not here be touched . Seeing therefore they have given up themselves unto Christ as His servants , they must resolve to be employed for Him to the outmost of their power , and must not think of laying up their Talent in a Napkin ; especially now when there is so great necessity , when Defection is yet growing , covered , countenanced more & more , Division nothing abated , but new oyl cast daylie into the flames of devouring Contentions ; the people generally drouned in the deluge of the times snares & sins , and like to be over whelmed in the inundation of black Poperie , now coming in at the opened sluce of this wicked Toleration , with the Congratulations of Addressing Ministers ; when now the Harvest is great and the Labourers are few : Great then is the necessity , and double must the woe be that abideth such Ministers , as are silent at such a time : And great & inexcusable is the sin of the people , if they do not come out , and countenance faithful Ministers , the Messengers of the Lord of hosts , from whom they should seek the Law Mal. 2. 7. especially when there are so many , that have palpably betrayed their Trust ; and so few that are faithful in the necessary Testimony of the day . Seeing then faithful Ministers must preach , & people must hear , where can they meet with conveniency , & safety , & freedom , except either under the shelter of this wicked Toleration , which they dare not do , or else go to the fields ? 5. It must be obtained also , that the Ministers have a right to Preach , in this unfixed manner , whereever they have a Call ; their relation now , in this disturbed state of the Church , being to be considered more extensively , than in its settled condition . For understanding which , we must distinguish a three or four-fold relation , that a Minister of the Gospel stands into . First , He is a Minister of Christ , and Steward of the Mysteries of God 1 Cor. 4. 1. having his Commission from Christ as his Master : And this relation he hath universally , wherever he is . Secondly , he is a Minister of the Catholick Church , though not a Catholick Minister of it ; which is his primary relation ; for that is the Church , in which Ministers are set 1 Cor. 12. 28. and to which they are given Eph. 4. 11 , 12. Thirdly , He is a Minister of the particular Church whereof he is a Member ; and so in Scotland a Minister is a Minister of the Church of Scotland , and is obliged to lay out himself for the good of that Church . Fourthly ; he is a Minister of the particular Congregation , whereunto he hath a fixed relation in a constitute case of the Church : This last is not essential to a Minister of Christ , but is subservient to the former relations : but when separated from such a relation , or when it is impossible to be held , he is still a Minister of Christ , and His Call to preach the Gospel stands & binds . See M r Durhams Degression on this particular on Revel . chap. 2. pag. 89. &c. in quarto . For thô he be not a Catholick Officer , having an equal relation to all Churches , as the Apostles were ; Nevertheless he may exerce Ministerial Acts Authoritatively , upon occasions warrantably calling for the same , in other Churches , as Heraulds of one King , having Authority to charge in His Name wherever it be ; especially in a broken state of the Church , when all the restriction his Ministerial relation is capable of , is only a tye & call to officiate in the service of that Church whereof he is a Member ; and so he hath right to preach every where , as he is called , for the edification of that Church . The reasons are . 1. He hath power from Christ the Master of the whole Church ; and therefore , wherever the Masters Authority is acknowledged , the Servants Ministerial Authority cannot be denied ; at least in relation to that Church whereof he is a Member as well as a Minister . 2. He hath Commission from Christ , principally for the edification of Christs body , as far as his Ministrie can reach , according to the Second relation . 3. His relation to the whole Church is principal , that which is fixed to a part is only subordinate , because it is a part of the whole . 4. His Commission is indefinite to preach the Gospel , which will s●it as well in one place as in another . 5. The same great ends of the Churches greater good & edification , which warrands fixing of a Minister to a particular charge in the Churches peaceable state , will warrand his officiating more largely in her disturbed state , 6. Else it would follow that a faithful Minister , standing in that relation to a disturbed & destroyed Church , and all his gifts & graces were useless in that case , which notwithstanding are given for the good of the Church . 7. Yea by this , when his fixed relation cannot be kept , it would follow , that he ceased to be a Minister , and his Commission expired ; so that he should stand in no other relation to Christ , than any private person so qualified , which were absurd : for by Commission he is absolutely set apart for the work of the Ministrie , so long as Christ hath work for him , if he continue faithful . 8. This hath been the practice of all the Propogators of the Gospel from the begining , and of our Reformers in particular ; without which they could never have propogated it so far : And it was never accounted the Characteristick of Apostles , to preach unfixedly ; because in times of persecution , Pastors & Doctors also might have Preached wherever they came , as the Officers of the Church of Ierusalem did , when scattered upon the persecution of Stephen Act. 8. 1. did go every where preaching the Word ver . 4. Since therefore they may & must Preach in this unfixed manner , they must in this broken State look upon all the Godly in the Nation , that will oune & hear them , to be their Congregation , and embrace them all , and consult their conveniency & universal advantage , in such a way as all equally may be admitted , and none excluded from the benefit of their Ministrie . And therefore they must go to the fields with it . 6. The Lord hath so signally ouned , successfully countenanced , and singularly sealed Field-Preaching in these unfixed exercises , that both Ministers & people have been much encouraged against all opposition to prosecute them , as having experienced much of the Lords power & presence in them , and of the breathings of the enlivening , enlarging , enlightening , and strengthening Influences of the Spirit of God upon them . The people are hereby called , in this case of defection , to seek after those waters that they have been so often refreshed by : For in this case of defection , God being pleased to seal with a palpable Blessing on their Souls , the Word from Ministers adhering to their principles , they may safely look on this as a Call from God to hear them , and follow after them so ouned of the Lord. And it being beyond all doubt , that the Assemblies of the Lords people to partake of pure Ordinances , with full freedom of Conscience in the fields , hath been signally ouned & blessed of the Lord , and hath proven a mean to spread the knowledge of God beyond any thing that appeared in our best times ; And in despight of this ●ignal Appearance of God , and envy at the good done in these Meetings , all endeavours being used by wicked men to suppress utterly all these Rendevouzes of the Lords Militia , both by open force & cunning Midianitish wiles ; Ministers cannot but look upon it as their duty , and that the Lord hath been preaching from Heaven , to all who would hear & understand it , that this way of preaching , even this way , was that wherein His Soul took pleasure , and to which He hath been & is calling all who would be co-workers with Him this day , to help forward the Interest of His Crown & Kingdom . Many hundreds of persecuted people can witness this , and all the Martyrs have sealed it with their blood , and remembered it particularly on the Scaffolds , that they found the Lord there , and that He did lead them thither , where He made them to ride upon the high places of the earth , and to eat the increase of the fields , and to suck honey out of the rock , and that in their experience , under the Spirits pouring out from on high , they found the wilderness to be a fruitful field , and in their esteem , their feet were beautiful upon the Mountains that brought good tidings , that published peace , that brought good tidings of good , that published salvation , that said unto Zion , thy God reigneth . And all the Ministers that followed this way , while they were faithful , and had but litle strength , and kept His Word , and did not deny His Name , found that verified in their experience , which is said of Philadelphia Revel . 3. 8. that they had an open door which no man could shut . The Characters whereof , as they are expounded by Mr Durham , were all verified in these Meetings : where 1. The Ministers had a door of utterance upon the one side opened to them ; and the peoples ears were opened to welcome the same , in love to edification , simplicity , & diligence , on the other . 2. This had real changes following , many being made humble , serious , tender , fruitful &c. 3. The Devil raged & set himself to oppose , traduce , & some way to blast the Ministrie of the most faithful more than any others ; just as when Paul had a greater door & effectual opened to him , there were many adversaries 1 Cor. 16. 9. 4. Yet the Lord hath been observably defeating the Devil & Profanity in every place , where the Gospel came , and made him fall like lightening from Heaven , by the preaching of the Word . 5. And the most experimental proof of all was , that hereby ground was gained upon the Kingdom of the Devil , and many Prisoners brought off to Jesus Christ. And therefore seeing it is so , this mnst certainly be a Call to them who are yet labouring in that Work , which others have left off , to endeavour to keep this door open with all diligence , and reap the corn when it is ripe , and when the Sun shines make hay , and with all watchfulness , lest the wicked one sow his tares , if they should fall remiss . 7. As for the Circumstance of the place , of this unfixed manner of celebrating the Solemn Ordinances of the Worship of God , in a time of persecution : This cannot be quarrelled at by any , but such as will quarrel at any thing . But even that is better warranted , than to be weakened with their quarrels . For before the Law , Mountain-Worship was the first Worship of the World , as Abrams Iehovah-jireh Gen. 22. 14. Iac●bs Bethel ( or House of God in the open fields ) Gen. 28. 17 , 19. his Peniel Gen. 32. 30. his El-Elohe-Israel Gen. 33. ult . do witness : Under the Law , they heard of it at Ephratah they found it in the fields of the Wood Psal. 132. 6. After the Law , field-preaching was the first that we read of in the New Testament , both in Iohn his preaching in the wilderness of Iudea , being the voice of one crying in the wilderness , and the Master Usher of Christ Math. 3. 1 , 3. and in His Ambassadours afterwasds , who on the Sabbath sometimes , went out to a river side were prayer was wont to be made , As Lydia was converted at Pauls field preaching Act. 16. 13 , 14. And chiefly the Prince of Preachers , Christ Himself , preached many a time by the syds of the Mountains , and the the sea side : That Preaching Math. 5. was on a Mountain vers . 1. And this is the more to be considered , that our Lord had Liberty of the Synagog●es to Preach in , yet he frequently left them , and preached either in private houses , or in the fields ; because of the opposition of His Doctrine by the Iewish Teachers , who had appointed that any who ouned Him should be excommunicate : And therefore in the like case , at it is now , His Servants may imitate their Master : for though all Christs Actions are not imitable ; such as these of His Divine Power , and the Actions of His Divine Prerogative ( as His taking of the ass without the ouners liberty ) and the Actings o● His Mediatory Prerogative , which He did as Mediator ; but all His Gracious Actions , and Moral upon Moral grounds , and Relative upon the grounds of Relative Duties , are not only imitable , but the perfect Pattern of imitation . Therefore that superstitious & ridiculous Cavil , that such Meetings in fields or houses are Conventickles , gathering separate Congregations , is not worth the taking notice of : for this would reflect upon Christs and His Apostles w●y of preaching , and the constant method of propogating the Gospel in times of persecution , in all ages ●ince , which hath alwayes been by that way which they call keeping of Conventickles . It s absurd to say , it is a gathering of separate Congregations , it is only a searching or seeking after the Lords sheep , that are made to wander through all the Mountains , and upon every 〈…〉 , and 〈…〉 which is scattered by corrupt Sheeph●●● ▪ and the cruelty of the beasts of the field Ezek. 34. 5 , 6. and preaching to all who will come & hear the Word of Truth , in such places where they may get it done most safely , and may be most free from distraction & trouble of their enemies , who are waiting to find them out , that they may hail them to Prisons or kill them . 8. As for the Circumstance of the Time , that is specially alledged to be unseasonable , especially when there is a litle breathing , and some relaxation from the heat of Persecution , to break the peace , and awaken sleeping Dogs by such irritating Courses , is thought not consistent with Christian prudence . This is the old pretence of them that were at ease , and preferred that to duty . But as we know no peace at this time , but a peace of Confederacy with the enemies of God , which we desire not to partake of , and know of no relaxation of Persecution against such as continue to witness against them : So let what hath been said above in the 3. Hypothesis ▪ of the necess●ty of publickness in our Meetings at such a time as this is , be considered ; And let the Scripture be consulted , and it will appear , not only that in preaching the Gospel there must be a Witness & Testimony kept up ( as is proved above ) and not only that Ministers must preach the Word , and be instant in season & out of season 2 Tim. 4. 2. But that such a time as this , is the very Season of a Testimony . For in the Scripture we find , that Testimonies are to be given in these Seasons especially . 1. When the enemies of God , beginning to relent from their stiffness & severity , would compound with His Witnesses , and give them some Liberty , but not total ; as Pharaoh would let the Children of Israel go , but stay their flocks : And now our Pharaoh will give some Liberty to serve God , but with a Reservation of that part of the matter of it , that nothing be said to alienate the hearts of the Subjects from his arbitrary Government . But Moses thought it then a season to testifie ( though the bondage of the people should be thereby continued ) that there should not a hoof be left behind ; for sayes he , we know not with what we must serve the Lord , until we c●me 〈◊〉 Exod. 10. 24 , 25 , 26. So must we Testify for eve●● closly ▪ the Interest of Christ this day . 2. When there ▪ to ●l●ration of Idolatry , and Confederacy with Idolaters , and suspending the execution of penal Lawes against them , or pardoning of those that should be punished : In such a season as this , that Messenger that came from Gilgal gave his Testimony at Bochim against their toleration of Idolatrous Altars , and Confederacy with the Canaanites Iudg. 2. 1 , 2. He is called an Angel indeed , but he was only such an one as Ministers are , who are called so Rev. 2. 1. for Heavenly Spirits have brought a Heavenly Message to particular persons , but never to the whole people , the Lord hath committed such a treasure to earthen Vessels 2 Cor. 4. 7. and this came from Gilgal not from Heaven . So the Man of God testified against E●i , for his toleration of wicked Priests , thô they were his oun Sons 1 Sam. 2. 2● . &c. So Samuel witnessed against Saul , for his toleration & indemnity granted to Agag 1 Sam. 15. 23. So the Prophet against Ahab , for sparing Benhadad 1 King. 20. 42. The Angel of Ephesus is commended for this ; and he of pergamus and he of Thyatira is condemned , for omitting this Testimony , and allowing a toleration of the Nicolaitans & Iezebel Revel . 2. 2 , 14 , 20. In such a Case of universal Complyance with these things , and the peoples indulging themselves under the shadow of the protection of such a Confederacy , the Servants of the Lord that fear Him must not say a Confederacy , tho they should be accounted for signs & wonders in Israel Isai. 8. 12 , 13 , 18. But now Idolatrous Mass-Altars are set up , none thrown doun , penal Statutes against Papists are stopt & disabled , and the Generality of Ministers are Congratulating , & saying a Confederacy in their Addresses for the same . 3. When the Universal Apostacy is come to such a hight , that error is prevailing , and few syding themselves in an avowed opposition against it ; as Elijah chose that time , when the people were halting between two opinions 1 King. 18. 21. And generally all the Prophets & Servants of Christ , consulted alwayes the peoples necessity for the timing of their Testimonies : And was there ever greater necessity than now , when Poperie is coming in like a flood ? 4. 〈…〉 men are chief in power ; as when Haman was 〈◊〉 Mordecai would not give him one bowe though all 〈◊〉 people of God should be endangered by such a provocation Esther . 3. 2. And when Tyrants & Usurpers are set up without the Lords approbation , then they that have the Lords Trumpet should set it to their mouth Hos. 8. 1 , 4. Is not this the case now ? 5. When upon the account of this their Testimony , the Lords people are in greatest danger , and enemies design to Massacre them , then if they altogither hold their peace at such a time , there shall enlargment & deliverance arise another way , but they and their fathers house shall be destroyed , who are silent then , as Mordecai said to Esther Est : 4. 14. And who knowes not the cruel designs of the Papists now ? 6. When iniquity is Universally abounding , and hypocrisie among Professors , then the Servants of the Lord must cry aloud & not spare Isai. 58. 1. as the ●ase is this day . 7. When the Concern of Truth , a 〈…〉 Glory of God , is not so illustriously vindicated as He gives us to expect it shall be ; then the Watchmen must not hold their peace , and they that make mention of the Name of the Lord , must not keep silence Isai. 62. 6 , 7. especially when His Name & Glory is blasphemed , baffled , and afronted , as at this day with a Witness . 8. When Ministers generally are involved in a course of defection , and do not give faithful warning , but daub over the peoples and their oun defections ; then the Prophets must Prophesie against the Prophets Ezek. 13. 2 , 10. &c. As alas this day there is a necessity for it . 9. When publick Worship is interdicted by Law , as it was by that Edict prohibiting publick Prayer for thirty dayes in Daniels time : They could not interdict all Prayer to God ; for they could forbid nothing by that Law , but that which they might hinder & punish for contraveening ; but mental Prayer at least could not be so restrained , And certain it is , they intended only such Prayer should be discharged , as might discover Daniel : But might not the wisdom of Daniel have eluded this interdiction , by praying only secretly or mentally ? No : whatever Carnal wisdom might ▪ Mee●te , his honesty did oblige him in that case of Conf●●re par●hen he knew the writing was signed , to go into hie clossly . ●d to open his windowes , and to kneel upon his kn● , to cleatimes a day — as he did aforetime Dan. 6. 10. Nowny agaireason can be given for his opening his windowes ? Was it only to let in the air ? or was it to see Ierusalem out at these windowes ? The Temple he could look toward , as well when they were shut . No other reason can be assigned , but that it was necessary then to avouch the Testimony , for that indispensable Duty then interdicted . And is not publick preaching indispensable Duty too ? which is declared Criminal , except it be confined to the mode their wicked Law tolerates ; which we can no more homologate , than omitt the duty . 10. When it is an evil time , the evil of sin is incumbent , and the evil of wrath is impendent over a Land ; then the Lyon hath roared who will not fear ? the Lord God hath spoken , who can but Prophesie ? Amos. 3. 8. There is no contradiction here to that word , whi●e hath been miserably perverted in our day , to palli●use or ●il silence of time-servers Amos. 5. 13. The prudent shall keep● silence in that time for it is an evil time : Whereby we cannot understand a wylie withdrawing our witness against the times evils : for there they are commanded to bestir themselves actively , in seeking good , hating the evil , loving the go●d , and establishing Iudgement in the gate vers . 14 , 15. but we understand by it a submissive silence to God , without fretting ( according to that Word Ier. 8. 14. for the Lord our God hath put us to silence — and Mic. 7. 9. ) Calvin upon the place expounds it , The prudent shall be affirighted at the terrible vengeance of God ; Or they shall be compelled to silence , not willingly ( for that were unworthy of men of courage to be silent at such wickedness ) but by the force of Tyrants giving them no leave to speak . Sure then this is such a time , wherein it is prudence to be silent to God , but not to be silent for God , but to g●ve publick witness against the evils of sin abounding , and publick warning of the evils of punishment imminent . 11. Then is the 〈◊〉 of it , when worldly wisdom thinks it unseasonable ▪ 〈◊〉 men cannot endure ●ound Doctrine , but after 〈…〉 lusts they heap to themselves teachers , ha●in● 〈…〉 ; and turn away their ea●s from the Truth● 〈…〉 ●each the Word , and be instant is indeed in it 〈…〉 , because profitable & necessary ; but it is out of season as to the Preachers or Hearers external interest , and in the esteem of Worldly Wiselings 2 Tim. 4. 2 , 3 , 4. See Pool Synops. Critic . in Locum . So in our day ; men cannot endure free & faithful dealing against the sins of the times , but would have smooth things & deceits spoken unto them ▪ like those Isai. 30. 10. And nothing can be more 〈…〉 to speak plainly ( so as to give every thing its 〈…〉 ) either of the sins of the times , or of the snares of the times , or of the miseries & evils of the times , or of the duties of the times or of the dangers , and the present Crisis of the times : Which no faithful Minister can forbear . Therefore so much the more is it seasonable , that it is generally thought unseasonable . 12. In a word , whenever 〈…〉 Testimony of the Church , or any part of it , is 〈…〉 ; then is the season to keep it , and contend for it , and to hold it fast , as our Crown Revel . 3. 10 , 11. It must be then a word spoken in due season , and good & necessary ( Prov. 15. 23. ) at this time , to give a publick Testimony against all wrongs done to our blessed Lord Jesus , all the encroachments upon His prerogatives , all the invasions of the Churches priviledges , all the overturnings of our Covenanted Reformation , and this openly designed introduction of Poperie & Slaverie . But now how shall this Testimony be given by us conveniently ? or how can it be given at all , at this time , in our Circumstances , so as both ●he matter and manner of it may be a most significant Witness-bearing to the merit of it , except we go to the fields ? Who can witness significantly against Poperie & Tyrannie : and all the evils to be spoken against this day , under the protection of a Papist & Tyrant , as house-Meetings under the Covert o● this Tol●eration are stated ? for if these Meetings be private & secret , then the Testimony is not known ; if they be publick , then they are exposed to a Prey . Now by all these general Hypoth●s●s , it is already in some measure evident , that Field-Meetings are very expedient . But I shall adde some more particular Considerations , to inculcate the same more clossly . In the Third Place , besides what is said , to clear the Lawfulness & necessity of a publick Testimony against the evils of the present time , Some Considerations may be added to prove the Expediency of this way & manner of giving a Testimony , by maintaining Field-Meetings in our present Circumstances . 1. The keeping of Field-Meetings now , is not only most convenient for Testifying , but a very significant Testimony in it self , against this Popish Toleration ; the wickedness of whose Spring & Original , and of its Nature and Terms , Channel & Conveyance , End & design , is shewed in the Historical Narrative thereof , and cannot be denyed by any Presbyterian , whose constant principle is that there should be no Toleration of Poperie , Idolatrie , or Heresie , in this Reformed & Covenanted Church . Reason & Religion both will conclude , that this is to be witnessed against , by all that will adhere to the Cause or Reformation overturned hereby , and resolve to stand in the Gap against Poperie to be introduced hereby , and that will approve themselves as honest Patriots in defending the Laws & Libertys of the Country subverted hereby ▪ And besides , if it be considered with respect to the Granter ; it is palpable his design is to introduce Poperie , and advance Tyrannie , which can be hid from none that accept it , the effectuating whereof hath a n●cessary & inseparable connexion with the acceptance of the Liberty ; and is so far from being avertible by the Accepters , that it is chiefly promoted by their acceptance , and the design of it is to lay them by from all opposition thereto . If it be considered with relation to the Accepters , it is plain it must be taken as it is given , and received as it is conveyed , from its fountain of Absolute power , through a channel of an Arbitrary Law-disabling & Religion-dishonouring Toleration , which is semper mali ; and with consent to the sinful ●mpositions , with which it is tendered ; concerning & affecting the Doctrine of Ministers , that they shall Preach nothing which may alienate the subjects from the Government ; Against all which there is no access for a Protestation , consistent with the improvement of the Liberty , for it is granted & accepted on these very terms ; that there shall be no Protestation ; for if there be , that will be found an alienating of the hearts of the subjects from the Government , which by that Protestation will be reflected upon . If it be considered with respect to the Addressers for it , who formally say a Confederacy with , and Congratulate the Tolerator for his Toleration , and all the Mischiefs he is machinatinating & effectuating thereby ; then seeing they have Presumptuously taken upon them to send it in the name of all Presbyterians , it concerns all honest men , zealous Christians , and faithful Ministers of that perswasion & denomination , in honour & Conscience , to declare to the world by some publick Testimony , that they are not Consenters to that sinful , shameful , & scandalous Conspiracy , nor of the Corporation of these flattering Addressers who have betrayed the Cause , with which all will be interpreted Consenters , that are not Contradicters . Further this Tolleration is sinful as is cleared above Peri● 6. And to accept of it is contrary to our Solemn Covenants & Engagments , where we are bound to exstirpate Poperie , preserve the Reformation , defend our Liberties , and never to accept of a Toleration eversive of all these precious Interests we are sworn to maintain . And it is heinously scandalous , being in effect a succumbing at length and yeelding up the Cause , which hath been so long controverted & so long contended for , at least an appearance of ceding & lying by from contending for the Interests of Christ , of condemning our former Wrestlings for the same , of purchasing a Liberty to our selves at the rate of burying the Testimony in bondage & oblivion , of hardening & confirming open Adversaries in their wicked invasions on our Religion , Laws , & Liberties , of being weary of the Cross of Christ , that we would fain have ease upon any terms , and of weakening the hands yea condemning the Practice & peremptoriness of these that are exampted from the benefit or rather the snare of it , and suffer when others are at ease . It is also attended with many Inconveniences ; for either such as Preach under the Covert of it , must forbear declaring some part of the Counsel of God , and give no Testimony seasonable this day ; or else if they do , they will soon be discovered and made a prey . Hence seeing there must be a Testimony against this Toleration , it is certainly most expedient to give it there , where the Meeting is without the reach & bounds of it , and interdicted by the same Proclamation that tenders it , and where the very gathering in such places is a Testimony against it : for to Preach in houses constantly & leave the fields , would now be interpreted an Homologating the Toleration that commands Preaching to be so restricted ; especially when an Address is made in name of all that accept the benefit of it , from which Odium we could not vindicate our selves , if we should so make use of it . 2. The keeping of Field Meetings now is a Testimony against that wicked Law that discharges them , and interdicts them as Criminal ; yea in some respect a Case of Confession : for if Daniels case , when publick prayer was discharged under pain of death , was a Case of Confession , as all grant ; then must also our case be , when publick Preaching is discharged under the some penalty : for it is equivalent to an Universal discharge of all publick Preaching , when the manner of it is discharged , which we can only have with freedom & safety in way of publick Testimony , which can be none other in our Circumstances but in the fields , Again if the Law be wicked that discharges them , as certainly it is , and is demonstrated from what is said already , then it must be sin to obey it ; but it were an obeying of it to quite the fields . 3. The ●eeping of Field-Meetings now is a Testimony against Tyranny & Usurpation , encroaching upon our Religion , Laws , & Liberties , and presuming to restrict & bound the exercise of the Ministerial function , and discharge it altogether except it be modified according to the Circumstances prescibed by a wicked Law , which cannot be allowed a● competent to any man whose Authority is not acknowledged , for reasons given in Head. 2. Therefore though there were no more , this is sufficient to call all Ministers to give Testimony against such an Usurpation , by resfusing to obey any such Act. and Preaching where God giveth a Call. For otherwise , to submit to it , would be an acknowledging of his Magist●atical power to discharge these Meetings , and to give forth sentences against faithful Ministers . 4. The keeping of Field-Meetings now is a Testimony for the Honour , Headship & Princely Prerogative of Jesus Christ , which hath been the Great Word of His Patience in Scotland , and by an Unparalelled , insolence encroached upon by Usurpers in our day , and in effect ●enied by such as took a new holding for the exercise of their Ministrie from their Usurped power . Now in these Meetings , there is a Practical Declaration of their holding their Ministrie and the exercise thereof from Christ alone , without any dependence upon , 〈◊〉 to , or licence & warrand from His Usurping Enemies ; and that they may & will Preach in publick without Authority from them . If then it be Lawful & expedient to maintain the Interests of a King of Clay , against an Usurper ; then much more must it be Lawful & expedient , to maintain the quarrel of the King of Kings , when wicked men would banish Him and His Interests out of the Kingdom by their Tyrannical cruelty , and cruel mercy of a destructive Toleration . 5. The keeping of Field-Meetings now is a Testimony for the Gospel and the Ministrie thereof ; which is alwayes the dearest & nearest priviledge of Christians , and in the present Circumstances , when our Lives and our all are embarked in the same bottom with it , and sought to be destroyed together with it , by a party conspiring against Christ , it is necessary duty to defend both by resisting their unjust violence ; especially when Religion and the Gospel is one and the chief of our fundamental Land-rights , and the Cardinal Condition of the established Policy , upon which we can only oune men for Magistrats by the Law of the Land : And this Testimony by defence of the Gospel and of our oun lives , cannot be given expediently any where but in the Fields . It is also a Testimony for the freedom & Authority of the Gospel-Ministrie , and for their holding their unremovable Relation to the Church of Scotland , which is infringed by these Tyrannical Acts , and maintained by these exercises : which is a priviledge to be contended for , above & beyond all other that can be contended for or defended , especially to be maintained against those that have no power or Authority to take it away . There will no man quite any of his goods upon a sentence coming from an incompetent Judge ; And shall Ministers or people be hectored or fooled from such a priviledge by them that have no such power ? 6. The keeping of Field-Meetings now is a Testimony for our Covenants , the ouning whereof is declared Criminal by that same Law that discharges these Meetings ; in which we are sworn to preserve the Reformation in Doctrine , Worship , Discipline , & Government , and to defend all the Churches Liberties , and to oppose all their Opposites , and endeavour their exstirpation : And in the Solemn Acknowledgment of sins & Engagment to duties , we are sworn , because many have of late laboured to supplant the Liberties of the Kirk , to maintain & defend the Kirk of Scotland , in all her Liberties & Priviledges , against all who shall oppose & undermine the same , or encroach thereupon under any pretext whatsoever . Since then the ouning of these Meetings and the Covenants are both discharged together , and the ouning of the Covenant does oblige to a publick opposition against the dischargers , and an avowed Maintinance of the Churches priviledges , whereof this is in a manner the only & chief Liberty now left to be maintained , to keep Meetings where we may testify against them , without dependence on their Toleration ; it must follow , that these Meetings are to be maintained , which only can be in the fields ▪ with conveniency . 7. To give over these Field-Meetings now , would be an hardening & encouraging of these Enemies in their wicked design of banishing all these Meetings out of the Land ; which manifestly would be defeat , by a resolute refusal of all to submit to their discharging of them ; and they that do submit , and give them over , do evidently contribute to the effectuating that wicked design , which is certain does not nor will not terminate upon a simple suppression of that sort , but further is intended to exstirpate all Meetings for Gospel Ordinances , in which there is any Testimony against them . To Comply therefore with such a forbearance of them at this time , would lay a stone of stumbling before them , to encourage them in these their designs ; when they should see their Contrivance so universally complyed with , wherein they might boast that at length they had prevailed , to put quite away that eye-sore of theirs Field-Meetings . 8. To give over these Field-Meetings now , were a stumbling to the poor ignorant people ; who might think that now it appears that Work was but of men , and so hath come to naught , and would look upon it as an evidence of fainting , & succumbing at last in the matter of the Testimony , as being quite overcome ; and that indeed all have embraced & accepted this present Toleration , and were all alike sleeping under the shade , and eating the fruits of such a bramble . 9. Finally , To give over these Field-Meetings now , would be very scandalous to the posterity , and to Strangers , who shall read the History of our Church , to find that as Prelacy came in without a joint Witness , and the monstrous , Blasphemous , & Sacrilegious Supremacy was erected without a Testimony in its season ; So black Poperie it self and Tyranny was introduced by a Toleration , which laid them all by from a Testimony against these ; who formerly had valiantly , resolutely , & faithfully contended against all lesser Corruptions , but at last , when that came , and stricter prohibitions of all publick Meetings but under the Covert thereof were emitted , then all were perswaded to comply with that Course . How astonishing would it be to read , that all these Contendings , sealed with so much precious blood , should come to such a pitiful Period ! But I hasten to the Next , which is the Second Positive Ground of Suffering . HEAD . V. The Principle of & Testimony for Defensive Armes Vindicated . THis Truth is of that sort , that can hardly be illustrated by demonstration ; not for the darkness thereof , but for its self evidencing clearness , being scarcely capable of any further elucidation , than what is offered to the rational understanding by its simple proposition . As first Principles can hardly be proven , because they need no probation , and cannot be made clearer than they are , and such as cannot consent to them , are incapable of conceiving any probation of them : So this Truth of Self-preservation being Lawful , because it is congenite with and irradicated in every nature , that hath a Self which it can preserve , can scarcely be more illustrated that it may do so , than that it can do so . And therefore to all who have a true respect to their oun , as well as a due concern in the Interest of Mankind , and zeal for the Interest of Christ , it might seem superfluous to make a doubt or debate of this : Were it not that a Generation of men is now prevailing , that are as great Monsters in Nature , as they are Malignant in Religion , and as great perverters of the Law of Nature , as they are Subverters of Municipal Laws , and Everters of the Laws of God : Who for ouning this principle , as well as using the practice , of Defensive Resistence for self preservation against Tyrannical violence , have set up such Monuments of rage & cruelty , in the Murder of many innocent people , as was never read nor heard of before . It hath been indeed the practice of all Nations in the World , and the greatest of men have maintained this principle in all ages : But the bare ▪ Asserting the principle , when extorted by severe Inquisitions , was never a Cause of taking the lives of any , before this was imposed on the poor Suf●erers in Scotland , to give their judgement , Whether or not such Appearances for Defence ( as the Tyranny of Rulers had forced people to ) were Reb●llion and a Sin against God ; Which they could not in Conscience assert ; and therefore , thô many that have suffered upon this head , have been as free of the practice of such Res●stence as any , yet because they would not condemn the principle they have been Criminally processed , Arraigned , & Condemned to the death . And against this Truth they have been observed to have a special kind of indignation , either because the light of it , which cannot be ●id , hath some heat with it to se●rch them ; or because they fear the impression of this in the hearts of people more than others , knowing that they deserve the practical expression of it by the hands of all . But the reason they give why they are so offended at it is , that they look upon it as the Spring of all the errors of Presbyterians , and a Notion that destroyes them : Which indeed will be found to have a necessary connexion with many of the Truths that they contend for this day , as it hath been the necessary methode of de●ending them . What practices of this kind hath been , and what were the occasions inducing or rather enforcing to these Defensive Resistences here to be vindicated as to the principle of them , is manifested in the Historical Representation : Shewing , that after the whole body of the Land was engaged under the bond of a Solemn Covenant , several times renewed , to defend Religion & Liberty ; and in special manner the Magistrats of all ranks , the Supreme whereof was formally admitted to the Government upon these terms ; he with his Associates , conspiring with the Nobles to involve the whole Land in perjury & Apostasie , overturned the whole Covenanted Work of Reformation ; and thereby not only encroached upon the Interest of Christ and the Churches Priviledges , but subverted the fundamental Constitution of the Kingdoms Government , and pressed all to a submission unto and complyance with that Tyranny & Apostasie , erected upon the ruines thereof : Yet the Godly & Faithful in the Land , sensible of the indispensable obligation of these Covenants , resolved to adhere thereunto , and suffered long patiently for adherence unto the same , until being quite out wearyed by a continued tract of Tyrannical oppressions , arbitrarly enacted by wicked Laws , and illegally executed against their oun Laws , and cruelly prosecuted even without all colour of Law , in many unheard of barbarities ; when there could be no access for or success in complaining or getting redress by Law , all Petitions & Remonstrances of Grievances being declared seditious & treasonable , and interdicted as such ; they were forced to betake themselves to this last remedy of Defensive Resistence , intending only the preservation of their Lives , Religion , & Liberties ; which many times hath been blessed with success , and therefore zealously contended for , as an inamissible Priviledge ; by all well affected to the Cause of Christ and Interest of their Country , because they found it alwayes Countenanced of the Lord ; until the cause was betrayed by the Treachery and abandoned by the Cowardice of such , as were more Loyal for the Kings Interests than zealous for Christs and the Countries ; for which the Lord in His holy Jealousie discountenanced many repeated endeavours of this nature , Cuting us off and puting us to shame and would not go forth with our Armies . But because the duty is not to be measured by , and hath a more fixed Rule to be founded upon , than providence ; therefore the Godly did not only maintain the principle in their confessions & Testimonies , but prosecute the practice in carrying armes , & making use of them in the defence of the Gospel and of themselves , at Field-Meetings ; which were alwayes successfully prosperous , by the power & presence of God. This Question is sufficiently discussed , by our famous & learned invincible Patrons & Champions for this excellent priviledge of Mankind , the unanswerable Authors of Lex Rex , the Apologetical Relation , Napthali , & Ius populi Vindicatum . But because facile est inventis addere , I shall subjoine my mite . And their Arguments being various and volumniously prosecute , and scattered at large through their books , I shall endeavour to collect a Compend of them in some order . The two first speak of a Defensive war , managed in a Parliamentary way : And the two last , of Resistence against the abuse of a Lawful power , when there is no access to maintain Religion & Liberty any other way ; which does not come up so closs to our case , nor is it an adequate Antithesis to the Assertions of our Adversaries , who say , that it is no wayes Lawful , in any case or upon any pretence whatsoever , to Resist the Soveraign power of a Nation , in whomsoever it be resident , or which way soever it be erected . I shall consider it more complexely & extensively , and plead both for Resistence against the abuse of a Lawful power , and against the Use & Usurpation of a Tyrannical power , And infer not only the Lawfulness of Resisting Kings , when they abuse their power ( as is demonstrate unanswerably by these Authors ) but the expediency & necessity of the duty of Resisting this Tyrannical power , whensoever we are in a Capacity , if we would not be found treatherous Covenant-breakers , & betrayers of the Interest of God , and the Liberties of the Nation , and of our Brethren together with the posterity , into the hands of this Popish & Implacable Enemie , and so bring on us the Curse of Meroz , and the Curse of our Brethrens blood , crying for vengeance on the heads of the shedders thereof , and upon all who being in case came not to their rescue , and the Curse of posterity , for not transmitting that Reformation & Liberty , whereof we were by the valour of our fore-fathers put & left in possession . I shall not therefore restrict my self to the State of the Question , as propounded ordinarly viz. Whether or not , when a Covenanted King doth really injure , oppress & invade his Subjects Civil & Religious Rights , or unavoidably threatens to deprive them of their dearest & nearest Liberties , and sends out his Emissaries with armed violence against them , and when all redress to be had , or hope by any Address or petition is rendered void or inaccessible , yea addressing interdicted under severe penalties as treasonable ; Then & in that case , may a Communitie of these Subjects defend themselves , & their Religion & Liberties , by armes in resisting his bloody Emissaries ? But to bring it home to our present case , and answer the Laxness of the Adversaries position of the uncontrollableness of every one that wears a Crown , I shall State it thus : Whether or not is it necessary duty , for a Community ( whether they have the Concurrence of the primores or Nobles , or not ) to endeavour , in the Defence of their Lives , Religion , Laws , & Liberties , to Resist & Repress the Usurpation & Tyranny of Prevailing Dominators , using or abusing their power for subverting Religion , invading the Liberties , and overturning the foundamental Laws of their Country ? I hold the Affirmative , and shall essay to prove it , by the same Arguments that conclude this Question , as usually stated . Which will more than evince the Justifyableness of the Sufferings upon this Head. In prosecuting of this Subject , I shall first premit some Concessory Considerations to clear it . And Secondly bring Reasons to prove it . First for clearing of this Truth , and taking off Mistakes , these Concessions may be considered . 1. The Ordinance of Magistracy which is of God is not to be Resisted , no not so much as by disobedience or non-obedience , nay not so much as mentally by cursing in the heart Eccles. 10. 20. but a person cloathed therewith , abusing his power , may be in so far Resisted . But Tyrants , or Magistrates turning Tyrants , are not Gods Ordinance ; and there is no hazard of damnation for refusing to obey their unjust commands , but rather the hazard of that is in walking willingly after the Commandment , when the Statutes of Omri are kept . So that what is objected from Eccles. 8. 2-4 . I counsell thee to keep the Kings Commandment &c. is answered on Head. 2. And is to be unsterstood only of the Lawful commands of Lawful Kings . 2. Rebellion is a damnable sin : except where the word is taken in a laxe sense , as Israel is said to have Rebelled against Rehoboam , and Hezekias against Sennacherib ; which was a good Rebellion , and clear duty , being taken there for Resistence & Revolt . In that sense indeed some of our Risings in Armes might be called Rebellions , for it is Lawful to Rebel against Tyrants . But because the word is usually taken in an evil sense , therefore would have been offensive to acknowledge that before the Inquisitors , except it had been explained . But Rebellion against Lawful Magistrats is a damnable sin , exemplarly punished in Korah and his Compan● , who rebelled against Moses ; and in Shebah and Absalom who rebelled against David ; for to punish the Just is not good nor to strike Princes for equity Prov. 17. 26. And they that resist shall receive to themselves damnation Rom. 13. 2. So that this Objection brought from this place , as if the Apostle were commanding there subjection without Resistence to Nero , and such Tyrants , as it is very impertinent , It is fully answered above Head. 2. Here it will be sufficient to reply . 1. He is hereby vindicating Christianity from that reproach , of casting off or refusing subjection to all Magistrats , as if Christian Liberty had destroyed that Relation , or that they were not to be subject to Heathen Magistrats . Whereupon he binds this duty of subjection to Magistrats for conscience sake in general . And it is very considerable , what Buchanan sayes in his book de jure regni , that Paul did not write to the Kings themselves , because they were not Christians , and therefore the more might be born with from them , tho they should not understand the duty of Magistrats : But imagine , that there had been some Christian King , who had turned Tyrant and Apostate , to the Scandal of Religion ; what would he have written then ? Sure if he had been like himself , he would have denyed that he should be ouned for a King , and would have interdicted all Christians Communion with him , and that they should account him no King , but such as they were to have no fellowship with , according to the Law of the Gospel . 2. He speaks of Lawful Rulers here , not Tyrants , but of all such as are defined & qualified here , being powers ordained of God , terrours to evil works , Ministers of God for good . Yea but says Prelats , and their Malignant Adherents , these are only Motives of subjection to all powers , not qualifications of the powers : I answer , they are indeed Motives , but such as can be extended to none but to these powers that are so qualified . 3. He speaks of Lawful powers indefinitely in the plural number , not specifying any Kind or degree of them , as if only Kings & Emperours were here meant . It cannot be proven that the power of the sword is only in them . Neither was there a plurality of Kings or Emperours at Rome to be subject to : if he meant the Roman Emperour , he would have designed him in the singular number . All the reasons of the Text aggree to inferiour Judges also , for they are Ordained of God , they are called Rulers in Scripture , and Gods Ministers , revengers by Office , who judge not for man but for the Lord ; And inferiour Magistrats also are not to be resisted , when doing their duty 1 Pet. 2. 13. yet all will grant , when they go beyond their bounds and turns litle Tyrants , they may be with-stood . 4. He does not speak of Nero , concerning whom it cannot be proven , that at this time he had the Soveraign power , as the learned Mr Prin shewes : Or if he had , that he was a Tyrant at this time : and if he meant him at all , it was only as he was obliged to be de jure , not as he was de facto . All men know , and none condemns the fact of the Senate , that resisted Nero at length , without transgressing this precept . Yea I should rather think , the Senate is the power that the Apostle applies this Text to , if he applied it to any in particular . 5. The subjection here required , is the same with the honour in the fifth Command , whereof this is an exposition ; and is opposite to the Contraordinatness here condemned : Now subjection takes in all the duties we owe to Magistrates , and Resistence all the contraries forbidden ; but unlimited obedience is not here required , so neither unlimited subjection . 3. We may allow Passive subjection in some cases , even to Tyrants ; when the Lord layes on that yoke , and in effect sayes , He will have us to lie under it a while , as He Commanded the Jewes to be subject to Nebuchadnezzar : of which passage , adduced to prove subjection to Tyrants Universally , Buchanan ubi supra infers , that if all Tyrants be to be subjected to , because God by His Prephet Commanded His people to be subject to one Tyrant ; Then it must be likewise concluded , that all Tyrants ought to be killed , because Ahabs house was Commanded to be destroyed by Iehu . But passive subjection , when people are not in capacity to resist , is necessary . I do not say Passive obedience , which is a meer Chimaera , invented in the brains of such Sycophants , as would make the world slaves to Tyrants . Whosoever suffereth if he can shun it , is an enemy to his oun being : for every natural thing must strive to preserve it self against what annoyeth it ; and also he sins against the order of God , Who in vain hath ordained so many Lawful means for preservation of our being , if we must suffer it to be destroyed , having power to help it . 4. We abhor all war of subjects , professedly declared against a Lawful King , as such ; all war against Lawful Authority , founded upon or designed for maintaining Principles inconsistent with Government , or against Policy & Piety ; Yea all war without Authority . Yes , when all Authority of Magistrates supreme & subordinate is perverted and abused , contrary to the ends thereof , to the oppressing of the people , and overturning of their Laws & Liberties , people must not suspend their Resistence upon the Concurrence of men of Authority , and forbear the Duty in case of necessity , because they have no● the peers or Primores to lead them : for if the ground be Lawful , the call clear , the necessity cogent , the capacity probable , they that have the Law of Nature , the Law of God , and the fundamental Laws of the Land on their side , cannot want Authority , though they may want Par●iaments to espouse their quarrel . This is cleared above Head. 2. Yet here I shall adde . 1. The people have this priviledge of nature , to defend themselves and their Rights & Liberties as well as Peers , and had it before they erected and constituted Peers or Primores . There is no distinction of quality in interests of Nature , though ther be in Civil order : but self defence is not an act of Civil order . In such Interests , people must not depend upon the priority of their superiours , nor suspend the duties they owe to themselves and their neighbours , upon the manuduction of other mens greatness . The Law of Nature allowing self defence , or the defence of our Brethren , against unjust violence , addeth no such restriction , that it must only be done by the conduct or concurrence of the Primores or Parliaments . 2. The people have as great Interest to defend their Religion as the Peers , and more , because they have more souls to care for than they , who are far fewer . And to be violented in their Consciences , which are as free to them as to the Peers , is as unsupportable to them : yea both are equally concerned to maintain Truth , and rescue their Brethren suffering for it , which are the chief grounds of war ; and if the ground of the defensive war be the same , with them and without them , what reason can be given making their Resistence in the one case Lawful , and not in the other ? Both are alike obliged to concur , and both are equally obnoxious to Gods threatened Judgments for suffering Religion to be ruined , and not relieving & rescuing Innocents . It will be but a poor excuse for people to plead , they had no Peers to head them . What if both King & Nobles turn enemies to Religion ? ( as they are at this day ) shall people do nothing for the defence of it then ? Many times the Lord hath begun a Work of Reformation by foolish things , and hath made the least of the flock to draw them out Ier. 49. 2. and 50. 45. and did not think fit to begin with Nobles , but began it when powers & Peers were in opposition to it : and when He blessed it so at length , as to engage the publick Representatives to oune it , what was done by private persons before , they never condenmed . 3. The people are injured without the Nobles ; therefore they may resist without them , if they be able : for there can be no Argument adduced to make it unlawful to resist without them , which will not equally make it unlawful to do it with them . 4. It s true the Primores are obliged beyond others , and have Authority more than others to concur ; but Separately they cannot act as Representatives judicially : They have a Magistratical power , but limited to their particular Precincts where they have Interest , and cannot extend it beyond these bounds ; And so , if they should concur , they are still in the capacity of subjects , for out of a Parliamentary Capacity they are not Representatives . 5. All the power they can have is Cumulative not Privative , for deterior conditio Domini per Procurationem fieri non debet . Why then shall the Representatives betraying their Trust , wrong the Cause of the people , whose Trustees they are ? Nay , if it were not Lawful for people to defend their Religion , Lives , & Liberties without the concurrence of Parliaments , then their case should be worse with them than without them ; for they have done it before they had them , and so they had better be without them still . 6. People may defend themselves against the Tyranny of a Parliament , or Primores , or Nobles : Ergo they may do it without them ; for if it be Lawful to resist them , its . Lawful to wave them , when they are in a Conspiracy with the King against them . 5. We disallow all war without real indeclinable Necessity , and great & grievous wrongs sustained : and do not maintain it is to be declared or undertaken , upon supposed Grounds , or pretended Causes : And so the Question is impertinently stated by our Adversaries , Whether or not it be Lawful for Subjects , or a party of them , when they think themselves injured , or to be in a capacity , to Resist or Oppose the Supreme power of a Nation . For the Question is not , if when they think themselves injured they may Resist ? but when the injuries are real : Neither is it every realitie of injuries will justify their Resistence , but when their dearest & nearest Liberties are invaded , especially when such an invasion is made , as threatens in●luctable subversion of them . Next we do not say , that a parties esteeming themselves in a Capacity , or their being really in a Capacity , doth make Resistence a duty ; except caeteris Paribus they have a Call as well as a Capacity , which requires real Necessity , and a right to the action , and the things contended for to be real & legal Rights , really & illegally encroached upon : their Capacity gives them only a Conveniency to go about the duty , that is previously Lawful upon a Moral ground . No man needs to say , who shall be Judge ? the Magistrate or people ? For. 1. All who have eyes in their head may judge whether the sun shine or not ; and all who have common sense may judge in this case . For when it comes to a Necessity of Resistence , it is to be supposed , that the Grievances complained of , and sought to be redressed by armes , are not hid but manifest ; it cannot be so with any party only pretending their suffering wrong . 2. There is no need of the formality of a Judge , in things evident to Natures eye , as Grassant Tyranny undermining & overturning Religion & Liberty must be . Nature , in the acts of necessitated Resistence in such a case , is Judge , party , Accuser , Witness , & all . Neither is it an act of Judgement , for people to defend their oun : Defence is no act of jurisdiction , but a priviledge of Nature . Hence these common sayings , vim vi repellere omnia jura permittunt ; And defendere se est juris Naturae : Defensio vitae necessaria est , & a jure Naturali profluit . 3. Be Judge who will , the Tyrant cannot be Judge in the case : for in these Tyrannical Acts , that force the people to that Resistence , he cannot be acknowledged as King , and therefore no Judge : for it s supposed , the Judge is absent , when he is the party that does the wrong . And he that does the wrong , as such , is inferior to the innocent . 4. Let God be Judge , and all the World , taking cognizance of the evidence of their respective Manifesto's of the State of their Cause . 6. We condemn Resing to revenge private injuries ; whereby the Land may be involved in blood , for some petty wrongs done to some persons , great or small : And abhor revengful Usurping of the Magistrats sword , to avenge our selves for personal injuries . As Davids killing of Saul would have been 1 Sam. 24. 10 , 12 , 13. 1 Sam. 26. 9 , 10. To Object which in this case , were very impertinent : for it would have been an act of offence in a remote defence , if Saul had been immediatly asaulting him , it could not be denied to be Lawful : and it would have been an act of private revenge , for a personal injurie , and a sinful preventing of Gods promise of Davids succession , by a scandalous Assassination . But it is clear , then David was Resisting him , and that is enough for us ; and he supposes he might descend into battel & perish 1 Sam. 26. 10. not excluding , but that he might perish in battel against himself resisting him . We are commanded indeed not to resist evil , but whosoever shall smite us on the one check , to turn to him the other also , Math. 5. 39. and to recompense to no man evil for evil Rom. 12. 17. But this doth not condemn self defence , or Resisting Tyrants violently , endangering our Lives , Laws , Religion , & Liberties , but only resistence by way of private revenge & retaliation , and enjoins patience , when the clear call & dispensation do inevitably call into suffering ; but not to give way to all violence & Sacriledge , to the subverting of Religion & Righteousness . These Texts do no more condemn private persons retaliating the Magistrate , than Magistrats retaliating private persons , unless Magistrats be exempted from this precept , and consequently be not among Christs followers : Yea they do no more forbid private persons to resist the unjust violence of Magistrats , than to resist the unjust violence of private persons . That Objection from our Lords reproving Peter Math. 26. 52. Put up thy sword for all they that take the sword shall perish by the sword , hath no weight here : for this condemns only making use of the sword , either by way of private revenge , or usurping the use of it without Authority ( and so condemns all Tyrants ) which private subjects do not want to defend themselves , their Religion & Liberty ; or using it without necessity , which was not in Peters case , tum quia valebat Christus se ipsum defendere , tum quia volebat se ipsum tradere , Pool Synops. Critic . in Locum . Christ could easily have defended himself , but he would not ; and therefore there was no necessity for Peters rashness ; it condemns also a rash precipitating and preventing the Call of God to acts of Resistence : But otherwise it is plain , it was not Peters fault to defend his Master , but a necessary duty . The reason our Lord gives for that inhibition at that time , was two fold ; one expressed Math. 26. 52. for they that take the sword &c. Which do not belong to Peter , as if Peter were hereby threatened ; but to those that were coming to take Christ , they usurped the sword of Tyrannical violence , and therefore are threatened with destruction by the sword of the Romans : so is that commination to be understood of Antichrist , and the Tyrants that serve him Rev. 13. 10. he that killeth with the sword must be killed with the sword , which is a terrible word against persecuters . The other reason is Iohn . 18. 11. — The Cup which my Father hath given me shall I not drink ? Which clearly resells that Objection of Christs non-resistence . To which it is answered , that suffering was the end of His voluntary suscepted humiliation , and His errand to the World , appointed by the Father , and undertaken by Himself ; which is not the Rule of our practice : Thô it be true , that even in His Sufferings He left us an ensample that we should follow His steps 1 Pet. 2. 21. In many things , as He was a Martyr , His Sufferings were the purest Rule & Example for us to follow , both for the matter , and frame of Spirit , submission , patience , constancy , meekness &c. but not as He was our Sponsor , and after the same manner , for then it were unlawful for us to flee , as well as to resist , because He would not flee at that time . 7. As we are not for Rising in Armes for triffles of our oun things , or small injuries done to our selves , but in a case of necessity for the preservation of our Lives , Religion , Laws , & Liberties , when all that are dear to us as men and as Christians are in hazard : So we are not for Rising up in Armes , to force the Magistrate to be of our Religion , but to defend our Religion against his force . We do not think it the way that Christ hath appointed , to propogate Religion by Armes : Let Persecuters & Limbs of Antichrist take that to them ; but we think it a Priviledge which Christ hath allowed us , to defend & preserve our Religion by Armes : especially when it hath been established by the Laws of the Land , and become a Land-right , and the dearest and most precious Right & Interest we have to contend for . It is true Christ saith , Iohn . 18. 36. My Kingdom is not of this world ; if my Kingdom were of this world , then would my Servants fight that I should not be delivered to the Iewes . But this Objection will not conclude , that Christs Kingdom is not to be defended & preserved even by Resistence , of all that would impiously & sacrilegiously spoil us of it in this world , because it is not of this world : for then all were obliged to suffer it to be run doun , by slaves of Hell and Satan , and Antichrists vassals , Papists & Malignants : Yea Magistrats were not to fight for it , for they are among His Servants , if they be Christians . But the good Confession He Witnesses here before Pilat , is that He hath a Kingdom , which as it is not in opposition to any Cesarean Majestie ; So it must not be usurped upon by any King of Clay , but is specifically distinct from all the Kingdoms of the world , and subordinate to no earthly power , being of a Spiritual Nature ; whereof this is a demonstration , and sufficient security for earthly Kingdoms , that His Servants as such , that is , as Christians , and as Ministers , were not appointed by Him to propogate it by Armes , nor to deliver Him their King at that time , because He would not suffer His Glorious design of Redemption to be any longer retarded : but this doth not say , but thô they are not to propogate it as Christians , and as Ministers , by carnal weapons ; yet they may preserve it with such weapons as men . Hence that old saying may be vindicated , preces & lachrimae sunt arma Ecclesiae , Prayers and tears are the Armes of the Church . I grant they are so , the only best prevailing Armes , and without which all others would be ineffectual , and that they ( together with Preaching & Church Discipline &c. ) are the only Ecclesiastical or Spiritual Armes , of a Church as a Church , but the Members thereof are also Men , and as men they may use the same weapons that others do , And ye my flock the flock of my Pasture are men saith the Lord Ezek. 33. 31. Yea from this I shall take an Argument : It it be Lawful for private Subjects , without the concurrence of Parliaments , to resist a Tyrant by Prayers and tears ; Then it is Lawful also to resist him by violence ; But the former is true , as our Adversaries grant by this Objection , and I have proved it to be duty to pray against Tyrants Head 2. Ergo — The Connexion is founded upon these reasons . 1. This personal Resistence by violence , is as consistent with that Command Rom. 13. 1 , 2. Let every soul be subject unto the higher Powers — whosoever therefore resisteth the Power resisteth the Ordinance of God ; as Resistence by Prayer is with that 1 Tim. 2. 1 , 2. I exhort — that — Supplications — be made — for Kings and for all that are in Authority . If the Prince be good , the one as is unlawful as the other ; and a sinful resistence of the Ordinance of God ( to pray against him ) no less than the other ( to fight against him ) Therefore when he becomes a Tyrant & destroyer of the Lords Inheritance , and an Apostate , as I may not pray for him except conditionally , but against him as an Enemy of Christ ; so I may also fight against him as such . 2. As Adversaries themselves will grant , that Resistence by Prayers & tears is more powerful & effectual than the other ; So the Laws of the Land make the one treasonable as well as the other ; and that deservedly , when the Prince is doing his duty , but when he turneth Tyrant , neither can justly be condemned . These things being premitted , I shall come shortly to the purpose , and endeavour to prove this Truth , , That it is a necessary duty for a Community ( whether they have the Concurrence of the Primores , Nobles & Representatives or not ) to endeavour , in the defence of their Religion , Lives , Laws , & Liberties , to Resist & Repress the Usurpation & Tyranny of prevailing Dominators , using or abusing their Power , for subverting Religion , invading the Liberties , and overturning the foundamental Laws of their Country . Wherein I shall be but short , because this Truth is sufficiently confirmed by all the Arguments of the Second Head. Yet I may only hint at many other ; And prosecute them in this Order . First I shall produce some Arguments from the Law of Nature & Nations . Secondly from the Common practice of all Christian people . Thirdly from express Scriptures . I. The Arguments of the first Class are very multifarious : I shall reduce them to a few , as Compendiously as may be , and only give the strength of them in a Syllogistical forme , without expatiating save where the matters requires . 1. The greatest Antagonists of this Truth , through the clearness thereof are forced to assert & grant such particulars , as will by Consequence justify this plea. 1. Barclay contra Monarchum . is cited by the Apol. Relat. and Ius Populi asserting , that if a King will alienate & subject his Kingdom , without his Subjects consent , or be carried with a hostile mind to the destruction of his people , his Kingdom is actually lost , and the people may not only Lawfully resist , but also depose him . Grotius de jure belli lib. 1. cap. 4. asserts the same , and adds , if he but attempt to do so he may be resisted . The Surveyer of Nap●tali grants the same pag. 23 , 24. Yea this hath been granted in open Court , by the Council of Scotland , that in case of the Kings alienating his Kingdoms , he may be Resisted . Hence ( 1 If vendition or alienation of Kingdoms , or attempts of it , do annull a Kings Authority ; Then an alienation of them from Christ , to whom they are devoted by Covenant , and selling them to Antichrist , as is attempted by this King , gives the people a right to Resist him : But the former is here conceded : Ergo — ( 2 ) We need say no more to apply the other , that carrying a hostile mind to the destruction of the people does forfeit his Kingdom , and gives the people right to Resist , than that a Papist is alwise known to carry a hostile mind to the destruction of Protestants , and all the designs declared these 27 years have been demonstrative efforts of it . 2. Dr Ferne acknowledgeth , that personal defence is Lawful against the sudden , illegal , & inevitable assaults of the Kings Messengers , or of himself in so far as to ward off his blowes , or hold his hands . As also he alloweth private persons Libertie , to deny subsidies & tribute to the Prince , when he imployeth it to the destruction of the Commonwealth . Hence ( 1 ) If one man may defend himself against the sudden , illegal , & inevitable assaults of the King or his Messengers ; Then may many men , in defence of their Lives & Liberties , defend themselves against the surprising Massacres , the sudden assaults , and much more the devised & deliberate assaults of a Tyrants bloody Emissaries , which are illegal & inevitable , as all their furious & bloody on-sets have been : But the former is here acknowledged : Ergo — ( 2 ) If people may deny subsidies to a King when he employeth it , to the destruction of the Commonwealth ; Then ( as this justifies the denyal of the Cess , imposed for destruction of the Church & banishing of the Gospel , So ) this gives them right to Resist him ( for if he be the power ordained of God not to be resisted , then for this Cause tribute must be paid , for they are Gods Ministers Rom. 13. 6. and if tribute must not be paid then he is not the power ordained of God , and so may be resisted ) But the former is here allowed ; Ergo — 3. Bodin de Repub. lib. 2. cap. 5. granteth , if a King turn Tyrant , he may Lawfully , at his subjects request , be invaded , resisted , condemned , or slain by a foraign Prince . Hence , if foraign Princes may Lawfully help a people oppressed by their oun Soveraign ; then people may Resist themselves , if they be able and hold in their pains : But the former is here granted : Ergo — The Consequence cannot be denyed , for foraigners have no more Power or Authority over another Soveraign , then the people have themselves . 4. Arnisaeus de Author Princip . c. 2. n. 10 . granteth , that if the Prince proceed extrajudicially , without order of Law , by violence , every private man hath power to resist . So the Surveyer of Naphtali ubi supra grants so much of a womans violent resisting attempts , against the honour of her chastitie , and tending to ensnare her in sin , whereof her non-resistence makes her guilty . Hence ( 1 ) If every extrajudicial violence of a Prince may be Resisted ; Then also all Contrajudicial violence against Law or reason must be opposed , for that is more grievous , and all their violences wherein they do not act as Judges must be resisted , and that is all together , for in none of them they can act as Judges : But the former is here granted : Ergo — ( 2 ) If a woman may defend her Chastity against the K. lest her non-resistence make her guilty ( Oh if all women had been of this mind , the Country would not have been pestered so with the Kings bastards ) Then may a Nation , or any part of it , Resist a Tyrants attempts upon the honour of their Religion , entycing them to fornication with the Mother of harlots , lest their non-resistence make them guilty : But the former is here yeelded : Ergo — 5. That same Arnisaeus cap. 4. saith , Of the former ( to wit , he who is called a Tyrant in title ) it is determined by all without any difficultie , that he may be Lawfully repulsed , or if by force he be gotten into the Throne , he may warrantably be thence removed , because he hath not any Jot of power which is not illegitimate , and unto which resistence is forbidden for the fear of God and for conscience sake , and therefore he is no further to be looked at than as an enemy . This is so pat & pertinent to the present possessor of the Government , that no words can more particularly apply it . 6. Grotius de jure belli Lib. 1. c. 4. granteth , the Law of not resisting does not bind when the danger is most weighty & certain . And we do not plead for it in any other case . And further he sayes , The Law of non-resistence seemeth to have flowed from them , who first combined together into societie , and from whom such as did command did derive their power : Now if it had been asked of such , whether they would chuse to die , rather than in any case to resist the Superior with Armes ? I know not if they would have yeelded thereto , unless with this addition , if they could not be resisted but with the greatest perturbation of the Common-wealth & destruction of many Innocents . And afterwards he hath these words , Attamen indiscriminatim dam●are aut singulos , aut partem minorem , quae ultimo necessitatis praesidio sic utatur , ut interim & communis boni respectum non deseruit , vix ausim . From which we need make no inference , the Concession is so large , that it answers our case . 7. The Surveyer of Naphtali , in the place above cited , grants Legal self defence against the Soveraign , by way of plea in Court , for safety of a mans person or estate — as also in the case of most habited , notour , & Complete Tyranny against Law , to the destruction of the body of a people , and of all known Legal Liberties , and the being of Religion according to Law — And in case of his not being in his natural & right wits — Hence ( 1 ) If it be Lawful to resist the King by a Plea in Law , for an Estate ( yea the Law will allow , by actual force , if he come to take possession of it illegally ) Then it must be Lawful for their lives & estates , Liberties & Religion , to resist him by force , when the Legal resistence is not admitted : But the former , is yeelded here : Ergo — The reason of the Connexion is : The Municipal Law permits the one , and the Law of Nature & Nations ( which no Municipal Law can infringe ) will warrand the other : He hath no more right to be both Judge & Party in this case , more than in the other : And he can no more act as Soveraign in this case , than in the other . ( 2 ) If it be Lawful to resist habited , notour , & Complete Tyranny against Law , to the destruction of the body of a people , and of all known legal Liberties , and the being of Religion , according to Law ; Then we desire no more to conclude the duty of resisting this Tyranny exerced this 27 years habitually , which the desolation of many hindered families , the banishment of many hundreds to slavery , the rivers of blood &c. have made Notour to all Scotland at least , and the perversion of all the fundamental Laws , and all Civil & Religious Liberties , yea the subversion of every remaining Model of Our Religion , as Reformed & Covenanted to be preserved , in Doctrine , Worship , Discipline , & Government , and designs to introduce Popery & establish Arbitrary Government , have made Complete : But the former is here granted , Ergo — ( 3 ) If in the case of his being out of his wits , he should run upon an innocent man to kill him , or attempt to cut his oun throat , it were then Lawful to resist him ▪ yea a sin not to do it ; Then when in a rage , o● deliberately , he is seeking to destroy many hundreds of the people of God , he may be resisted : But the former is clear : Ergo — 8. King Iames the Sixth , in his Remonstrance for the right of Kings , against the Oration of Cardinal Perron , hath these words , The publick Laws makes it Lawful , and free for any private person , to enterprize against an Usurper of the Kingdom . Then shall it not be duty , to enterprize against a man , who by the Laws of the Land is not capable of a right to reign , who hath got into the Throne by the means of Murder , and can pretend no right but that of Succession , which I proved to be none , Head. 2. However we see by these Concessions of Adversaries , that the Absolute subjection they talk of will not hold , nor the prerogative be so incontrollable in every case , as they would pretend , and that in many cases , Salus populi hath the Supremacy above it , And that also in these cases the people must be Judges , whether they may resist or not . 2. From the Law of Nature I may argue . 1. If God , the fountain of all power and Author of all Right , hath given unto man both the power and the right of , and reason to manage self defence , and hath no wayes interdicted it in His Word to be put forth against Tyrants ; Then it is duty to use it against them upon occasion : But the former is true : Ergo — 2. If this power & right were restrained in man against the unjust violence of any , it would either be by Policy , or Grace , or some express prohibition in the Word of God : But none of these can be said : Ergo — Policy cannot destroy nature , but is rather cumulative to it ; A man entering into a Politick Incorporation , does not lose the priviledge of nature : If one particular nature may defend it self against destroying violence out of Societie , then must many of these Natures combined in Societie have the same right , and so much the more that their relative duties superadde an obligation of mutual assistence . Grace does not restrain the right of sinless nature , though it restrains corruption : but self defence is no corruption : Grace makes a man more a man than he was . And nothing can be more dishonourable to the Gospel , than that by the Law of Nature it is Lawful to resist Tyrants , but we are bound by Religion from withstanding their Cruelty : The Laws of God do not interf●●e ●ne with another . 3. That Law which alloweth comparative re-offending , so as to kill rather than be killed , teacheth Resistence : But so the Law of Nature alloweth , except we be guilty or Murder in the culpable omission of self defence . The reason is , because the love of self is nearer and greater , as to temporal life , than the love of our Neighbour ; that being the measure of this : Therefore it obliges rather to kill than be killed , the exigence of necessity so requiring . 4. If nature put no difference between the violence of a Tyrant than of another man ; then it teaches to Resist both alike : But it putteth no difference , but rather aggravates that of a Tyrant ; being the violence of a man , the injustice of a member of the Common-wealth , & the cruelty of a Tyrant . And it were absurd to say , we might defend our selves from the lesser violence , & not from the greater . 5. If particular Nature must yeeld to the good of Universal nature ; then must one man , though in greatest power , be Resisted , rather than the Universal Common-wealth suffer hurt : But the former is true ; for that dictates the necessity of the distracted father to be bound by his oun sons , lest all the family be hurt : Ergo the greatest of men or Kings , when destructive to the Common-wealth , must be Resisted ; for he is but one man , & so but particular nature . 6. That which is irrational , and reflects upon Providence , as puting men in a worse condition then Brutes , is absurd and contrary to the Law of Nature : But to say , that the Brutes have power to defend themselves by resisting what annoyes them , and deny this power to men , is irrational and reflects upon Providence , as puting men in a worse condition than Brutes : Therefore it is absurd , & contrary to the Law of Nature . 3. From the Institution of Government I may argue thus : That power and Government which is not of God may be Resisted : The Tyrants power & Government , in overturning Laws , subverting Religion , bringing in Idolatry , oppressing Subjects , is not of God : Ergo it may be Resisted : The Major is clear , because that is only the reason why he is not to be resisted , because the Ordinance of God is not to be resisted Rom. 13. 2. But they that resist a man destroying all the Interests of mankind , overturning Laws , subverting Religion &c. do not resist the Ordinance of God. And if it were not so , this would tend irremedilessly to overthrow all Policies , and open a gap to all disorder , injustice , & cruelty , and would give as great encouragment to Tyrants to do what they lift , as thieves would be encouraged , if they knew no body would resist them or bring them to punishment . 4. From the Original Constitution of Government by men , It may be argued thus : If people at the first erection of Government acted rationally , and did not put themselves in a worse case than before , wherein it was Lawful to defend themselves against all injuries , but devolved their rights upon the fiduuciary Tutory of such , as should remain still in the rank of men , that can do wrong , who had no power but by their gift , consent , & choice , with whom they associated not to their detriment but for their advantage , and determined the form of their Government , and time of its continuance , and in what cases they might recur to their primeve Liberty , and settled a succession to have Course not jure hereditario but jure & vi legis , for good ends ; Then they did not give away their birth-right of self defence , and power of resistence , which they had before to withstand the violence , injuries , & oppressions of the men they set over them , when they pervert the form and convert it to Tyranny , but did retain a power & priviledge to resist and revolt from them , and repell their violence when they should do violence to the Constitution , and pervert the ends thereof : But the former is true . Ergo — The Minor is cleared Head. 2. And the Connexion is confirmed from this ; if the Estates of a Kingdom give the power to a King , it is their oun power in the fountain , and if they give it for their oun good , they have power to judge when it is used against themselves , and for their evil ; and so power to limit & resist the power that they gave . 5. From the way & manner of erecting Governours by Compact , the necessity whereof is proven Head. 2. Many arguments might be deduced ; I shall reduce them to this form : If people must propose Conditions unto Princes , to be by them acquiesced in & submitted unto at their Admission to the Government , which thereupon becomes the fundamental Laws of the Government , and Securities for the peoples rights & Liberties , giving a Law Claim to the people to pursue the Prince , in case of fai●ing in the main & principal thing Covenanted , as their oun Covenanted Mandatarius who hath no Ius or Authority of his oun , but what he hath from them , and no more power but what is contained in the Conditions , upon which he undertaketh the Government ; Then when either an Usurper will come under no such conditions , or a Tyrant doth break all these conditions , which he once accepted , and so become stricto jure no Prince , and the people be stricto jure Liberated from subjection to him , they may & must Defend themselves and their fundamental Rights & Priviledges , Religion & Laws , and Resist the Tyanny overturning them : But the former is true Ergo — The Connexion is clear : And the Minor is proved Head. 2. And at length demonstrated and applied to the Government of Charles the Second by Ius Populi . cap. 6. See Arg. 4. & 5. Head. 2. 6. From the Nature of Magistracy it may be argued thus . That power which is properly neither Parental , nor Marital , nor Masterly , & Despotick , over the Subjects Persons & goods , but only fiduciary and by way of trust , is more to be Resisted than that which is properly so : But that power which is properly so , that is Parental power , and Marital , and Masterly , may be Resisted in many cases : Ergo that power which is not so properly , but only fiduciary is more to be Resisted . That a Kings power over his subjects is neither Parental , nor Marital , &c. is proven Head. 2. And the Major needs no Probation . The Minor is clear by Instances . 1. If Children may in case of necessity resist the fury of their father , seeking to destroy them ; then must private subjects Resist the rage & Tyranny of Princes , seeking to destroy them , and what is dearest to them ; for there is no stricter obligation Moral between King & people , than between Parents & Children , nor so strict ; and between Tyrants & people there is none at all : But the former cannot be denyed : Ergo — 2. If Wives may Lawfully defend themselves against the unjust violence of enraged Husbands ; then must private subjects have power to Resist the furious assaults of enraged Tyrants , for there is not so great a tye betwixt them and people , as between man & wife ; yea there is none at all : But the former is true : Ergo — 3. If Servants may defend themselves against their Masters ; then must private subjects defend themselves against a Tyrant or his Emissaries : But the former is true : Ergo — 4. If the Kings power be only fiduciary , and by way of Paun , which he hath got to keep ; then when that power is manifestly abused , to the hurt of them that entrusted him with it , he ought to be Resisted by all whom he undertook to protect : But the former is true : Ergo the latter . 7. From in the Limited power of Princes it may be thus argued : If Princes be limited by Laws & Contracts , and may be resisted by Plea's in Law , and have no absolute power to do & command what they will , but must be limited both by the Laws of God and man , and cannot make what Laws they will in prejudice of the peoples Rights , nor execute the Laws made according to their pleasure , nor conser on others a Lawless licence to oppress whom they please ; Then when they turn Tyrants , and arrogate a Lawless Absoluteness , and cross the Rules & transgress the Bounds prescribed by Gods Law & mans Law , and make their oun lust a Law , and execute the same arbitrarly , They must be Resisted by force , when a legal resistence cannot be had , in defence of Religion and Liberty : But all Princes are limited &c. Ergo — The Minor is proved Head. 2. And the Connexion may be thus confirmed in short : That power which is not the Ordinance of God may be resisted : But an absolute illimited power , crossing the Rules and transgressing the bounds prescribed by Gods Law and mans , is not the Ordinance of God : Ergo it may be Resisted . 8. Further from the Rule of Government it may be argued several wayes . 1. That power which is contrary to Law , evil & Tyrannical , can tye none to subjection , but if it oblige to anything , it tyes to Resistence : But the power of a King against Law , Religion , and the Interests of the subjects , is a power contrary to Law , evil & Tyrannical : Ergo — The Major is plain , for Wickedness can tye no man but to resist it : That power which is contrary to Law evil & Tyrannical is Wickedness . 2. That power and those Acts , which neither King can exerce nor command , nor others execute , nor any obey , must certainly be Resisted : But such is the power and Acts that oppress the subjects , and overturn Religion & Liberty : Ergo — The Minor is evident from Scriptures condemning oppression & violence , both in them that command , and in them that execute the same , and also them that obey such wicked commands . The Major is clear from Reason : both because such power & such Acts as cannot be commanded , cannot be executed , cannot be obeyed Lawfully , are sinful & wicked ; and because it cannot be a Magistratical power , for that may alwayes be exerced & executed Lawfully . And what a man cannot command , the resisting of that he cannot punish : But acts of oppression against Law , Religion , & Liberty , a man cannot command . Ergo the Resisting of these he cannot punish . 3. That Government or Administration , which is not subordinate to the Law & Will of God , who hath appointed it , must be Resisted ; But that Government or Administration , which undermines or overturnes Religion & Liberty , is not subordinate to the Law & Will of God : Ergo — The Major is clear : for nothing but what is the Ordinance of God , subordinate to His Law & Will , is irresistible Rom. 13. 2. The Assumption is undenyable . 9. From the Ends of Government , which must be acknowledged by all to be , the Glory of God , and the Good of Mankind : yea all that have been either wise or honest , have alwayes held that Salus Populi est Suprema Lex , The Arguments may run thus , in short . 1. That Doctrine which makes the Holy one to cross His oun ends in giving Governours , must be absurd & Unchristian , as well as irrational : But such is the Doctrine that makes all Kings & Tyrants irresistible upon any pretence whatsoever . Ergo — The minor I prove : That Doctrine which makes God intending His oun Glory & the peoples good , to give Governours both as Fathers to preserve and as Murderers to destroy them , must make the Holy one to cross His oun ends ; for these are Contradictory : But the Doctrine that makes all Kings & Tyrants irresistible &c. is such : For by Office they are Fathers to preserve , and by Office also they must be Murderers , vested with such a power from God actu primo , if they be irresistible when they do so ; seeing every power that is irresistible is the Ordinance of God. Hence also when a Blessing turns a Curse it is no more the Ordinance of God , but to be resisted : But when a King turns a Tyrant , overturning Religion & Liberty , then a Blessing turns a Curse : Ergo — 2. Means are to be Resisted , when they are not useful for but destructive to the ends they were appointed for : But Governours overturning Religion & Liberty , are Means not useful for , but destructive to the ends for which they were appointed , Seeing then they are neither for the Glory of God , nor the good of Mankind . Ergo — 3. If all powers & Prerogatives of men , are only means appointed for and should vaile unto the Supreme Law of the peoples Safety , and all Laws be subordinate to and corroborative of this Law , and when cross to it are eatenus null & no Laws , and all Law-formalities in Competition with it are to be laid aside , and all Parliamentary priviledges must yeeld to this , and King & Parliament both conspiring have no power against it , and no Soveraign power by virtue of any resignation from the people can comprize any Authority to act against it ; Then it is duty to obey this Supreme Law , in Resisting all powers & Prerogatives , all Laws & Law-formalities , and all conspiracies whatsoever against this Supreme Law , the Safety of the people : But the former is true , as was proven Head. 2. Ergo — 4. That power which is obliged & appointed to command & rule , Justly & Religiously , for the good of the people , and is only set over them on these conditions , and for that end , cannot tye them to subjection without Resistence , when the power is abused to destruction of Laws : Religion , and people : But all power is so obliged & appointed : Therefore whensoever it is so abused it cannot tye people to subjection , but rather oblige them to Rejection of it . 10. From the Obedience required to Government , It may be argued thus . 1. If we may flee from Tyrants , then we may Resist them : But we may flee from Tyrants : Ergo we may Resist them . The Connexion I prove ( 1 ) If all grounds of Justice will warrand the one as well as the other , then if the one be duty so is the other : But the former is true : For the same justice & equity that warrands declining a Tyrants unjust violence by flight , will warrand Resistence when flight will not do it ; The same Principle of self defence , that makes flight duty when Resistence is not possible , will aso make Resistence duty when flight is not possible ; The same Principle of Charity to Wives & Children , that makes flight Lawful when by Resistence they cannot avoid Tyranny , will make Resistence duty when by flight they cannot evite it ; The same Principle of Conscience to keep Religion free , that prompts to flight when Resistence will not save it , will also prompt to Resist when flight is not practicable . ( 2 ) If to flee from a just power , when in Justice we are obnoxious to its sword , be to resist the Ordinance of God and so sin ; then to flee from an unjust power must be also a Resisting of the abusing of it , and so duty , for the one is Resistence as the other , but the difference of the power resisted makes the one Lawful the other not : Again , if Royal power may be resisted by interposing seas and miles , why not also by interposing walls & armes ? both is resistence , for against a Lawful Magistrate that would be resistence . ( 3 ) If a Tyrant hath irresistible power to kill and destroy the people , he hath also irresistible power to cite & summond them before him ; and if it be unlawful to resist his murders , it must be as unlawful to resist his summonds . ( 4 ) For a Church or Community of Christians persecuted for Religion , to flee with Wives & Children , strong & weak , old & yong , to escape Tyrannical violence , and leave the Land , were more unlawful than to Resist : For what is not possible as a Natural means of preservation , is not a Lawful mean ; but this were not a possible mean : Neither is it warranted in Natures Law , or Gods Word , for a Communitie or Society of Christians , that have Gods Right and mans Law to the Land and the Covenanted Priviledges thereof , to leave the Country and Cause of Christ , and all in the hands of a Tyrant & Papist , to set up Idolatry upon the ruines of Reformation there . A private man may flee , but flight is not warranted of them as of a private single man. 2. If it be duty to disobey , its duty to Resist Tyrants , in defence of Religion & Liberty : But it is duty to disobey them . Ergo — The Connexion only will be stuck at which is thus strengthened : If subjection be no more pressed in Scripture than obedience , then if non-obedience be duty , non-subjection must be so also , and consequently Resistence : But subjection is no more pressed in Scripture than obedience : For all Commands of subjection to the Higher powers as Gods Ministers , under pain of damnation , do only respect Lawful Magistrats , and in Lawful things and do include obedience ; and non-obedience to the power so qualified is a resisting of the Ordinance of God , as well as non-subjection : If then obedience to Magistrats be duty , and non-obedience sin , and obedience to Tyrants sin and non-obedience duty ; Then by Parity of reason , subjection to Magistrats is duty and non-subjection is sin , and also subjection to Tyrants is sin and non-subjection duty . 11. From the Resistence allowed in all Governments , it may be argued thus : If it be duty to defend our Religion , Lives , & Liberties , against an invading army of Cut-throat Papists , Turks , or Tartars , without or against the Magistrats warrand ; Then it must be duty to defend the same against invading home-bred Tyrants , except we would subscribe our selves home-born slaves : But the former is true : Ergo — The Minor cannot be doubted ; because the Magistrats power cannot be privative & destructive to defence of our Religion , Lives , & Liberties ; nor can it take away Natures birth-right to defend these ; or make it fare the worse than if we had no Magistrats at all , now if we had no Magistrats at all we might defend these against Invaders , and whether we have Magistrats or not we are under Moral obligations of the Law of God to endeavour the defence of these : But this needs not be insisted on . The Connexion of the Proposition is clear : If Princes be more Tyrannical in invading Religion & Liberties themselves , than in suffering others to do it , or hindering them to be opposed ; And if their invasion be more Tyrannical , hurtful , & dangerous than the invasion of Strangers ; Then if it be duty to resist Strangers invading these Interests , it is more duty to Resist home-bred Tyrants invading the same : But the former is true : Therefore the latter . Resisting in the one case is no more Resisting the Ordinance of God than in the other . 12. From the Motives of Resistence we may draw this Argument , which might be branched out into several , but I shall reduce it to this Complexe one : If when we are in a Capacity , we cannot acquit our selves in the duties that we owe to our Covenanted Religion , and our Covenanted Brethren , and Posterity , and our selves , nor absolve & exoner our selves from the sin & Judgment of Tyrants , who overturn Religion , oppress our Brethren , impose slavery on our selves , and entail it upon Posterity , by a Passive subjection , submission to , and not opposing these mischiefs ; Then Resistence is necessary : But the former is true : Ergo — The Connexion is clear : for there cannot be a Medium ; if we cannot discharge these duties by subjection , submission , and not opposing ; then we must do them by non-subjection , non-submission , and opposing ; since they must be done some way . The Assumption is thus confirmed . 1. The duties we owe to Religion , when it is corrupted , declined from , & overturned , are not only to Reforme our oun hearts & wayes , and keep our selves Pure from the Corruptions established , and to rebuke and witness against the Complyers with the same , and so by work , doing & suffering , keep & contend for the Word of our Testimony ; But further , when by the Constitution of the Kingdom Religion is become a fundamental Law , and consequently the Magistrate overturning it , is violating & everting the main grounds & ends of the Government , and turning grassant & ingrained Tyrant , especially when it is not only so Authorized & Confirmed by Law , but Corroberated by solemn vowes & Covenants made & sworn unto God by all ranks of people , to maintain & defend this Religion with their lives & fortunes — and resist all contrary errors & corruptions according to their vocation ; and the uttermost of that power that God puts in their hands , all the dayes of their lives , As also mutually to defend & assist one another . ( as in the National Covenant ) And sincerely , really , & constantly endeavour — the Preservation of the Reformed Religion in Doctrine , Worship , Discipline , & Government , the extirpation of Poperie , Prelacie &c — and to assist & defend all those that enter into the same bond in the maintaining thereof — ( as in the Solemn League ) Then to defend & maintain that Religion and themselves Professing it ; when it is sought to be razed ; This must be an Interest as necessary to be defended , as that of our bodies which is far inferiour , and as necessary a duty , as to defend our Natural & Civil Liberties from perpetual slaverie , and as preferrable thereunto , as Christ Interest is to mans , and as the end of all self preservation is to the means of it , the preservation of Religion being the end of all self preservation : But this duty cannot be discharged without Resistence , in a meer Passive subjection & submission ; Otherwise the same might be discharged in our universal submission to Turks coming to destroy our Religion . Certainly this Passive way cannot answer the duty of Pleading for Truth Isai. 59. 4. seeking the Truth Ier. 5. 1. being valiant for it Ier. 9. 3. making up the hedge , standing in the Gap &c. Ezek. 22. 30. which yet are necessary incumbent duties according to our Capacity ; Therefore we cannot answer the duties we owe to Religion in a meer Passive way . 2. The duty we owe to our Covenanted Brethren , is to assist & defend them , and releive them when oppressed , as we are bound by our Covenants , and antecedently by the Royal Law of Christ , the foundation of all Righteousness among men toward each other , Math. 7. 12. All things whatsoever ye would that men should do to yow , do ye even so to them — We would have them helping us when we are oppressed , so should we do to them when it is in the power of our hands to do it , and not forbear to deliver them for fear the Lord require their blood at our hand , Prov. 24. 11 , 12. But this cannot be done by meer subjection with out Resistence . 3. There is no way to free our selves of the sin & judgment of Tyrants by meer Passive subjection : We find in the Scriptures , people have been so involved and punished for the sins of Tyrants ; As the people of Iudah for Manasseh 2 King. 21. 11. &c. Ier. 15. 4. whose sins if they had not been committed , the judgments for them had been prevented , and if the people had hindered them they had not smarted ; But being joyntly included with their Rulers in the same bond of fidelity to God , and made accountable as joynt Principals with their Kings for that debt , by their Mutual as well as Several engagments to walk in His Wayes , they were lyable to be punished for their Rebellion & Apostasie , because they did not hinder it . Hence some-what must be done to free our selves of their sin and to escape their Judgments : But this can be nothing else but opposition to them by Resistence ; or else if we make any other opposition , it will make us more a prey to their fury . II. Secondly this Truth is Confirmed from the Common Practice of the people of God , even under Persecution . Whence I shall draw an Argument ab Exemplis , which to condemn were impious , and to deny were most impudent . And for formes sake , it may run thus : What the people of God under both Testaments have frequently done , in time of Persecution , for defending , vindicating , or recovering their Religion & Liberties , may & ought to be done again in the like Circumstances , when these are in the like hazard : But under both Testaments , the people of God frequently in times of Persecution have defended , vindicated , or Recovered their Religion & Liberties by defensive Armes , Resisting the Soveraign powers that sought to dostroy them : Ergo this may & ought to be done again when these Religious Civil & natural priviledges , are in the like hazard to be destroyed by the violent encroachments of the Soveraign powers . The Proposition cannot be denyed , except by them that do profess themselves enemies to the people of God , and condemn their most frequently reiterated practices most solemnly & signally ouned of God , to the confusion of their enemies , to the conviction of the World , that the Cause for which they contended was of God , and to the encouragment of all the Patrons of such a Cause , to hope that when it is at the lowest it shall have a Revival & Glorious Issue . It is true somtimes they did not Resist , when either they were not in a Capacity , or did not see a Call to such an Action , but were extraordinarly Spirited of the Lord for Passive Testimonies under a suffering dispensation : But 't is as true , that many times they did Resist , when the Lord capacitated , called , & Spirited them for Active Testimonies . And therefore , if their Suffering under these Circumstances may be imitated by a people so stated ; Then also their Actions under these other Circumstances may be imitated , by a people in the like case . And by an impartial Scrutiny it will be found , that the examples of their endeavoured Resistence will be litle inferiour , if not superiour in number or importance , to the examples of their submissive Sufferings in all ages : Which will appear in the Probation of the Assumption , by adduction of many Instances , which I shall only cursorly glean out of that plentiful harvest that Histories afford . 1. I need only to glance at that known & famous History of the Maccabees , of undoubted verity , though not of Cannonical Authority . In which , according to Scripture Predictions , we have a notable account of Heroick Interprizes , Atchievments , & Exploits , performed by them that knew their God , and tendered His Glory and their Religion & Countries Liberties , above the Common Catechrestick notions of incontrollable irresistible Royaltie , and absolute implicite Loyaltie , that have abused the world in all ages . We have there an account of the noble & successful Resistence of a party of a few Godly & zealous Patriots , without the concurrence of Civil Authority , or countenance of the Ephori or Primores regni , against a King universally acknowledged & subjected unto , that came in Peaceably , and obtained the Kingdom by fl●tt●ries , with whom the greatest part and those of the greatest note took part , and did wickedly against the Covenant and Nations Interest , and were corrupt by flatteries : Yet a few Priests , with the concurrence of some common Country-men , did go to armes against him and them ; And the Lord did wonderfully assist them for a considerable time , as was foretold by Daniel . 11. This fell out under the persecution of Antiochus Epiphanes , and was happily begun by Mathias a Godly Priest , and his five Sons , who being commanded under severe Certifications to Worship according to the then Law and the Kings wicked lust , did valiantly resist that abomination , and went to defensive armes : which while living he Patronized , and when adying did encourage his sons to it by a notable Oration , shewing what case his Country was in , and what a duty & dignity it was to redeem & deliver it . This was vigorously prosecuted by Iudas Maccabeus , expressly for the quarrel of Religion & Liberty , against that mighty Tyrant & all his Emissaries . 2. To come to the History of the Gospel Dispensation : It is true , in that time of the Primitive Persecutions under Heathen Emperours , this Priviledge of Self Defence was not much improved or contended for by Christians , who studied more to play the Martyrs than to play the Men , because in these Circumstances the Lord was pleased to Spirit for and call them unto , and accept off their hands , passive Testimonies ; while they were incorporate under a Civil relation with the Heathens , in subjection to Governours who did not by open Tyrannie overturn their Civil Liberties , only did endeavour to eradicate Religion , which at that time had never become their Right by Law ; while they were scattered and out of Capacity , and never could come to a separate formed Community by joynt Concurrence & Correspondence , to undertake a Declared Resistence ; while Religion was only a propagating through the Nations , and the Lord Providentially did preclude the least appearance that might be of propagating it by any formed force , being the Gospel of Peace designed to save and not to destroy : Yet even then , Instances are not wanting of Christians Resisting their Enemies , and of Rescuing their Ministers &c. As these are found on record . 1. How some inhabiting Mareots , with force rescued Dyonisi●● of Alexandria , out of the hands of such as were carrying him away , about the year 235. 2. How about the year 310. the Armenians waged war against Maximus , who was come against them with an Army , because of their Religion . 3. How about the year 342. the Citizens of Alexandria defended Athanasius their Minister , against Gregorius the intruded Curate , and Syrianus the Emperours Captain , who came with great force to put him in . 4. How about the year 356. the people of Constantinople did in like manner stand to the defence of Paulus , against Constantius the Emperour , and killed his Captain Hermogenes : And afterwards in great Multitudes they opposed the intrusion of the Heretick Macedonius . 5. How , when a wicked Edict was sent forth to pull doun the Churches of such as were for the Clause of one Substance , the Christians that maintained that Testimony resisted the bands of Souldiers , that were procured at the Emperours Command by Macedonius , to force the Mantinians to embrace the Arrian Heresie : But the Christians at Mantinium , kindled with an earnest zeal towards Christian Religion , went against the Souldiers with Cheerful minds & valiant Courage , and made a great slaughter of them . 6. How about the year 387. the people of Cesarea did defend Basil their Minister . 7. How for fear of the people , the Lievtenant of the Emperour Valens , durst not execute those 80 Priests who had came to supplicate the Emperour , and were commanded to be killed by him . 8. How the Inhabitants of Mount Nitria espoused Cyril●s quarrel , and assaulted the Lievtenant and forced his Guards to flee . 9. How about the year 404. when the Emperour had banished Chrysostome , the people flocked together , so that the Emperour was necessitated to call him back again from his Exile . 10. How the people resisted also the transportation of Ambrose by the command of Valentinian the Emperour ; And chused rather to lose their lives , than to suffer their pastor to be taken away by the Souldiers . 11. How the Christians , oppressed by Baratanes King of Persia , did flee to the Romans to seek their help . And Theodosius , the Emperour , is much praised for the war which he commenced against Chosroes King of Persia , upon this inducement , that that King sought to ruine & exstirpate those Christians in his Dominions , that would not renounce the Gospel . 3. But when Religion was once imbraced in imbodyed Corporations , and established by Law , and became a peoples common Interest & Liberty , in a Capacity to defend it with their lives & other Liberties , and when it was propagated through the Nations : Then the Lord did call for other more Active Testimonies , in the preservation & defence of it : Of which we have many Instances in Histories . About the year 894. The Bohemian Christians Resisted Drahomica their Queen , who thought to have destroyed them & reintroduced Paganisme . About the year 1420. they maintained a long defensive war against the Government , and the Popes Legats , under the managment of their brave Captain Zizca ; which was further prosecuted after him by the remaining Thaborites . And again in this Century , anno 1618. They maintained a Defensive war against the Emperour Ferdinand the Second , electing and erecting a new King in opposition to him , Frederick Palatine of the Rhine , in which Cause many received the Crown of Martyrdom : and this was also espoused by King Iames the 6. who sent to aid his Son in Law against the Emperour . 4. If we look to the Histories of the Waldenses , these constant Opposers of Antichrist , we will find many Instances of their Resistence . About the year 1194. very early , while Waldo ( from whom they had their name ) was alive , they began to defend themselves by Armes , after the bloody Edict of Aldephonsus King of Arragon ; an Edict so like to many of ours emitted this day , that as it would seem our Enemies have taken the Copy of it , so it were very seemly for the people grieved with such Edicts to imitate the Copy of the Waldenses their practice , in opposition to them . Anno 1488. they resist by Armes Albert de Capitaneis sent by Pope Innocent the 8. in Pragola & Frassaniere , and through out Piedmont ; where for the most part the off-spring of the old Waldenses had their residence , where very evidently , through many successions of ages , they shewed themselves to be the true Successors of their Worthy Progenitors , valiant for the Truth . That 's a famous Instance of their Resistence , in opposing vigorously the Lord of Trinity , in that same Piedmont , at which time they so solemnly asked their Ministers , Whether it were not Lawful to defend themselves against his violence ? Who answered affirmatively . And accordingly they did it with wonderful success at that time , and many times thereafter . Especially it is notour ; in the memory of this present age , how anno 1655. a vigorous defensive war was prosecuted against the D. Savoy , by their Captains Gianavel , Iahier &c. which was espoused by many Protestant Princes . And no further gone than the very last year , it is known how they resisted the Armes of the Tyger , and the French that helped him , and that their Simplicity in trusting Popish promises was their ruine . 5. If we look over the Histories of the Albigenses , we find many Instances of their Defensive Resisting their Oppressing Superiours . About anno 1200. They defended themselves at Beziers and Carcasson , against the Popes Legat and his Crossed Souldiers , under the Conduct , first of the Earle of Beziers , and then of the Earle of Foix , and Earle Remand of Thoulouse , and were helped by the English who then possessed Guienne bordering upon Thoulouse : which resistence continued several years . Afterwards anno 1226. they maintained a Resistence against the King of France . 6. In Spain , we find the people of Arragon contesting with Alphonso 3 d. and associating themselves together against him . And they tell Pedro 3 d. their King , that if he would not contain himself within the limits of the Laws , they would pursue him by Armes , about anno 1283. As also other Spaniards , who rose in Armes several times against Pedro the 1 King of Castile . 7. It was this which brought the Cantons of Helvetia into this State of freedom , wherein they have continued many years . For about the year 1260. they levied war against their oppressing nobles . And anno 1308. they joined in Covenant to defend themselves against the house of Austria : and anno 1315. they renewed it at Brunna , in which at length the rest of the Cantons joined , and formed themselves into a Common-wealth . 8. If we take a glance of the Germans , we will find at the very Commencement of the Reformation , as soon as they got the name of Protestants , they Resisted the Emperour Charles the fifth . The Duke of Saxon , the Land Grave of Hesse , and the City of Magd●burgh , with Advice of Lawyers , concluded That the Laws of the Empire permitted Resistence of the Emperour in some cases , that the times were then so dangerous , that the very force of Conscience did lead them to Armes , and to make a League to defend themselves , though Caesar or any in his name should make war against them — for since he attempteth to root out Religion , and subvert our Liberties , he giveth us cause enough to resist him with a good conscience : The matter standing as it doth , we may ( say they ) Resist , as may be shewed both by Sacred & Profane Histories — And so they undertooke and stated the war upon the account of Religion & Liberty . 9. If we but cast an eye over to the Hollanders , we will find how much they stand obliged to this practice of Defensive Armes ; having thereby recovered both Religion & Liberty , and established themselves into a fiourishing State. We find even in the time of D. de Alva's Persecution , they began to defend Haerlem and Valenciennes in Henault , and went on till under the conduct of William of Nassaw Prince of Orange , they declared the King of Spain to have fallen from the Government of those Countries : and so effectually shook off the yoke of Spanish Tyrannie . 10. If we go to the French Hugenots , we will find many Instances among them , and many brave Heroes raised up , to maintain the principle and prosecute the practice thereof , of older & later date . The History of the Civil wars of France is stored with their Trophees ; and the Memories of Condie & Coligni will ever be fragrant . There were many Resistences there , both before & since the Parisian Massacre . It is sad , that the present Protestants there are so far degenerate from the Spirit of their Ancestors . 11. The many practices of the Hungarians , Resisting the encroachments of the house of Austria , prove the same . And when Mathias denyed the free exercise of Religion unto the Protestants of Austria , they took up Armes in their oun defence , and sent a Protestation unto the Estates of Hungarie , requiring their Assistence , conforme to their League . And now this present war there founded upon this plea. 12. The Polonians have often times levied war against their Kings : and we are furnished by Clark in his Martyrol . with a late Instance of their Resistence against the Soveraign Powers , at Lesita in Poland anno 1655. 13. The Danes & Swedes have not been wanting for their parts in taking course with their Christierns , Kings of that name , whom they resisted & punished . And generally , wherever the Reformation was received , we find this principle espoused and the practice of it prosecuted . Nay there hath been no Nation in the world , but it will be found , they have either resisted or killed Tyrants . 14. The most Deserving & Celebrated Monarchs in the world , have espoused the quarrel of oppressed Subjects . Not only such as Tamerlanc , whose observable Saying is noted , when he advanced against Bajazet , I go ( sayes he ) to chastise his Tyrannie and to deliver the afflicted people . And Philip & Lewis of France , who assisted the Barons of England against King Iohn . And Charles the Great , who upon this ground undertook a war against the Lombards in Italie . But even Constantine the Great , hath it recorded for his honour , that he employed his power & force against L●cinius , upon no other Motive but because he banished , tortur'd , & destroyed those Christians in his Dominions , that would not abandon their Religion . And Q. Elizabeth is commended , for assisting the Dutch to maintain their Religion by force , when they could not enjoy it by favour . And King Iames the 6. gave publick aid to the Protestants in Germany & Bohemia against the Emperour . Against whom also Gustavus Adolphus marched , that he might deliver the oppressed Cities from the bondage that Ferdinand had brought them into . Yea King Charles the first , this mans Father , pretended at least to help the Protestants in France at Ree and Rochel : And though he himself was avowedly Resisted by the Parliaments of both Ringdoms , yet he was forced to Declare in his Acts of Oblivion & Pacification , The Scots late taking up Armes against him , in defence of their Religion , Laws , & Priviledges , to be no Treason nor Rebellion — See Apol. Relat. Sect. 11. pag. 149. And thô the late Charles the Second condemned all the Risings of the people of Scotland for defence of Religion & Liberty , and their lives & priviledges , which his oun Tyrannie forced them into ; yet he justified the present Revolt of Heathens & Mahumetan Subjects from the young King of Bantam in Iava Major in the East Indies , who , when he got the Government in his hands by his Fathers Resignation , killed his subjects , and caused them to be killed without any cause , which was the reason of their revolt ftom him , and defending the Father against the son : This defensive war of these Subjects was justied by the said Charles , in his sending Amunition &c. for their relief . These , and many moe Instances that might be adduced , are sufficient evidences of the Righteousness and Reason of such Resistences , when the Greatest of Princes have undertakent he Patrocinie of them . III. From Scripture-Proofs , I shall but briefly gather some of the many that might be pressed , which being put together to me seem impregnable . I shall reduce them to these heads . 1. I shall aduce some practices of the Lords people , frequently reiterated , never condemned , alwayes approven , confirming this Point . 2. Some severe Reprehensions for their omission of this duty , in the season thereof . 3. Some promises both of Spiriting for the duty , and of Countenancing it , when undertaken . 4. Some precepts commanding such Atchievments . 5. Some prayers supplicating for them . All which put together will make a strong Argument . First , For practices of this kind , there is nothing more common in Scripture Historie . 1. I shall begin at the first war that is recorded in the World : wherein some loss fell to the Godly at first , but afterwards by the virtue & valour of their Brethren they were vindicated , and the victory recovered with honour . Lot & his family living in Sodom was taken Prisoner , by Chedarlaomer and his Confederates Gen. 14. 12. but Abraham hearing of it , armed his trained servants , and pursued them to Dan , and rescued him vers . 14-16 . thereby justifying that Rebellion of the Cities of the plain , by taking part & vindicating the Rebells . Hence , he that may rescue subjects from the violence of any Tyrannizing Domination by armes , may also rise with these subjects to oppose that violence : But here is an example of that in Abraham — Ergo — 2. After the Lords people were possessed of Canaan , and forgetting the Lord did enter into affinity with these interdicted Nations , some of them were left to prove Israel , that the Generations of the Children of Israel might know to teach them war. Iudg. 3. 1 , 2. And when they did evil in the sight of the Lord , He sold them into the hand of Chushan-rishathaim King of Mesopotamia , whom they served and were subject to eight years ver . 8. but when they cried unto the Lord , their Rebellion , shaking off that yoke , was successful under the Conduct of Othniel ver . 10. And after a relapse unto the like defection , they became subject to Eglon King of Moab , whom they served eighteen years vers , 14. but attempting the same remedy by armes , under the Conduct of Ehud , they recovered their Liberty . And after his death , falling into that sin again which procured the like Miserie , they became subject to Iabin King of Canaan , who twenty years mightily oppressed them Iudg. 4. 1-3 . but by the Lords Commandment , under the Conduct of Deborah & Barak , they Rebelled & prevailed . Whence , If the Lords people , serving a Soveraign Domineering power , may shake off the yoke of their subjection ; then it is duty to defend themselves and Resist them , for there is no other way of shaking it off : But these examples prove the former : Ergo — Object . If any Cavil that these were not their oun Kings , to whom they owed Allegiance , but only invading Conquerours , whom they might resist . 1 Ans. ( 1 ) Yet they were the Soveraign powers for the time : And therefore , if Royalists & Loyalists grounds hold good , they ought upon no pretence whatsoever to have been Resisted : And thô possibly they might not be by Compact their oun Kings , yet by Conquest they were , as much as that would make them , and by their oun Consent , when they paid them Kings due , viz , tribute . ( 2 ) No more are they our oun Kings , who either intrude themselves into an Arbitrary Domination over us ( without any terms of a Compact , upon a pretence of hereditary succession ) or being our Covenanted Kings overturn all the Conditions of their Compact , & degenerate into Tyrants : To such we owe no Allegiance , more than Israel did to these Dominators . ( 3 ) I retort that old recocta Crambe , who should be Judge , whether they were their oun Lawful Kings or not ? For they acted as Kings , and thought themselves their absolute Lords , and gave themselves out to be such ; And yet we find an approved Rebellion against them . Mr Gee in his Magistrats Original chap. 8. Sect. 4. Pag. 268. improves these Instances to the same purpose , And addes Neither ( as far as my observation goes ) can any immediate or extraordinary Command or Word for what they so did be pretended to , or pleaded from the Text , for many of them , or for any save Barak or Gideon . 3. Yet Gideons example , thô he had an extraordinary Call , cannot be pretended as unimitable on the matter ; for that was ordinary , thô the Call & Manner was extraordinary . He , with the Concurrence of a very few men , did break the yoke of subjection , to Midian Iudg. 6. & 7. Ch : And having called his Brethren out of all mount Ephraim , into a conjunction with him in the pursuit of his victory ; When he demanded supply of the Princes of Succoth , and of the men of Penuel , and they denied it , he served them as Enemies . Whence , If a small party may with Gods Approbation deliver themselves , and the whole of their Community , from the bondage of their oppressing Dominators whom they had served several years , and may punish their Princes that do not come out to their help , in a Concurrence with them and encouragement of them in that attempt ; Then must it be duty to defend themselves against their Oppressours that rule over them , and all ought to concur in it ; or else there would not be justice in punishing them that were defective in this work : But we see the former from this Example Ergo — Object . If it be said , Gideon , and the rest of the extraordinary raised Judges , were Magistrats , therefore they might defend & deliver their Country , which a private people that are only subjects may not do . I ans . ( 1 ) They were subject to these Tyrants that oppressed them , who were then the Soveraign powers of that time , and yet they shook off their yoke by defensive armes . ( 2 ) They were not the● Magistrats , when they first appeared for their Countries defence & deliverance , neither in that did they act as such , but only as Captains of Rebells , in the esteem of them that had power over them . It is clear Gideon was not Ruler , till that Authority was conferred upon him after the deliverance . See Iudg. S. 22. &c. Yet he did all this before . 4. When his bastard Abimelech Usurped the Government , and was made King by the men of Schechem ; At length God sending an Evil Spirit between him and his Complices that set him up , not only was he Resisted by the treacherous Shechemites ( which was their brand & bane , in the righteous Judgement of God , for their aiding him at first in killing his Brethren ) Iudg. 9. 23 ; 24. &c. but also he was opposed by others of the men of Israel , as at Thebez , where he was slain by a woman vers . 50. ad fin . Whence , If an Usurping Tyrant , acknowledged as King by the Generality , may be disouned by the Godly , and threatened with Gods vengeance to consume both him & h●s Complices that comply with him ; and if he may be opposed & Resisted not only by those that set him up , but also by others that were in subjection to him , and at length be killed by them without resentment of the rest of the Nation ; Then must it be duty for a people , who had no hand in the erection of such a Dominator , to defend themselves against his force : But the former is true by this Example : Ergo — 5. When Israel fell under the Tyranny of Ammon , oppressing them eighteen years , they did by Resisting these Supreme powers shake off their yoke , under the Conduct of Iephthah . And being challenged sharply by the men of Ephraim , who it seems claimed the Prerogative of making war , and therefore came to revenge & reduce Iephthah & his Company to order , Casting herein belike a Copy to our regular Loyalists , who are very tenacious of this Plea of the Ephraimites , that at least without the Primores Regni no war is to be made ; yet we find Iephthah did not much regard it , but stoutly defended himself , & slew of them 42000 men known by their Shibboleth Iudg. 12. If people then when questioned for defending themselves , by them that claim a Superiority over them & should deliver them , may defend themselves both without them & against them ; then it is a peoples duty & priviledge : But the former is true by this Example . 6. They were then made subject to the Philistims 40 years , whom the men of Iudah acknowledged for their Rulers : yet Samson , that rackle-handed Saint , never ceased from pelting them upon all Occasions ; and when challenged for it by the men of Iudah , saying , knowest thow not that the Philistims are Rulers over us ? what is that that thow hast done ? Samson objects nothing against their being Rulers ; but notwithstanding prosecutes his purpose of vindicating himself , in defence of his Country , As they did unto me , sayes he , so have I done unto them Iudg. 15. 11. Hence , If Saints may avenge themselves upon them whom the Country calls Rulers , and when enabled by God may do to them as they did to them ; then must it be duty for them to defend themselves against them : But the Antecedent is true by this Example . 7. When Saul , in the pursuit of the Philistims , had charged the people with a foolish Oath ( like unto many of the ensnaring Oaths that Monarchs use to impose upon people ) not to eat any food until the evening , Ionathan his son tasted but a litle honey and lo he must die ; Which Saul confirmed with another peremptory Oath , God do so to him and more also if he should not die ? Whereupon the people , as resolute on the other hand to save him , Resisted the rage of that Ruler , and swore as peremptorly that not one hair of his head should fall to the ground : So the people rescued Ionathan that he died not 1 Sam. 14. 44 , 45. Hence , If people may Covenant by Oath to Resist the Commands , and Rescue a man from a Tyrants Cruelty ; then it is duty to defend themselves against him : The Antecedent is true here . 8. Afterwards when the manner of the King , presaged by Samuel was verified in Sauls degeneration into many abuses of Government ; this priviledge of Resistence was not wholly mancipated , but maintained by Davids defensive Appearance with his litle Army He took Goliahs sword not for ornament , or only to fright Saul , but to defend himself with it , and was Captain first to four hundred men 1 Sam. 22. 2. had a mind to keep out ●eilah against him with 600 men 1 Sam. 23. 13. and afterwards a great host came to him to Ziklag , while he kept himself closs because of Saul the son of Kish 1 Chron. 12. 1. throughout ▪ where they left Saul , and came & helped David against him . This is proved at length by Lex Rex quest 32. Pag. 340. 9. The City Abel , whither Shebah the Traitor had fled , did well to Resist Ioab the Kings General , coming to destroy a whole Citie for a Traitors sake , and not offering peace to it ( according to the Law Deut. 20. 10. ) and defended themselves by Gates & Walls , not withstanding he had a Commission from the King 2 Sam. 20. And after the Capitulating , they are never challenged for Rebellion . 10. The ten tribes revolted from the House of David , when Rehoboam claimed an Absolute power , and would not acquiesce to the peoples just conditions 1 King. 12. 2 Chron. 10. Which is before justified Head. 2. Hence , if it be Lawful for a part of the people to shake off the King , refuse subjection to him , & set up a new one , when he but resolves to play the Tyrant ; then it must be duty to resist his violence , when he is Tyrannizing : But the Antecedent is clear from this Example . This is vindicated at more length by Ius Pop. Ch. 3. Pag. 52. 11. The Example of Elisha the Prophet is considerable 2 King. 6. 32. Elisha sat in his house , and the Elders with him ; And the King sent a man before him , but ere the Messengers came to him , he said to the Elders , see how the son of a Murderer hath sent to take away mine head ; look when the Messenger cometh , shut the door , and hold him fast at the door ; is not the sound of his Masters feet behind him ? Here was violent Resistence resolved against both the man & the Master , thô the King of the Land for the time . And this calling him the son of a Murderer ; and resisting him , is no more extraordinary ( thô it was an extraordinary mans Act ) than it is for a plaintiff to lybel a true crime against a wicked person , and for an oppressed man to close the door upon a Murderer , Lex Rex Quest. 32. Pag. 346. Hence , if a King or his Messenger coming to use unjust violence against an innocent Subject , be no more to be regarded than a Murderers Emissarie , but may be resisted by that innocent Subject ; Then must a Community of such innocent Subjects defend themselves against a Tyrant or his Emissaries , coming against them on such a wicked errand : The Antecedent is here clear . 12. The City Libnah revolted from under Iehorams Tyrannie 2 Chron. 21. 10. P. Martyr on the place saith , they revolted because he endeavoured to compell them to Idolatrie . This is justified above Head. 2. Hence , if it be Lawful for a part of the people to revolt from a Tyrannical Prince , making defection from the true Religion ; then it is duty to defend themselves against his force : The Antecedent is here plain . 13. When Athaliah usurped the Monarchy , Iehojada the priest strenghtened himself , and made a Covenant with the Captains &c. to put her doun , and set up Ioash 2 King. 11. 2. Chron. 23. and when she came & cried , Treason , Treason , they regarded it not , but commanded to kill her and all that help her . Whence , if those that are not Kings may Lawfully kill an Usurpress , and all her helpers , then may a people resist them : But Iehojada though no Magistrate did it . 14. The repressing & punishing Amaziah the son of Ioash is an undenyable Instance , vindicated by Mr Knox ; see above Per. 3. Pag. 38. After the time that he turned away from following the Lord , the people made a Conspiracy against him in Ierusalem , and he fled to Lachish , but they sent & slew him there 2 King. 14. 19. 2 Chron , 25. 27. Hence , a fortiori , If people may conspire & concur in executing Judgment upon their King turning Idolater & Tyrant , then much more must they defend themselves against his violence . 15. The same power of peoples Resisting Princes , was exemplified in Uzziah or Azariah , when he would needs be supreme in things Sacred as well as Civil 2 King. 15. 2 Chron. 26. fourscore priests , that were valiant men , withstood him , and thrust him out of the Temple , deturbarunt eum , saith Vatablus , expulerunt eum saith Ar. Mont. vid. Pool Synopss . in Loc. See this vindicated by Mr Knox. Per. 3. Pag. 33. above . Hence , If private Subjects may by force resist and hinder the King from transgressing the Law , then must they resist him when forcing them to transgress the Law of God. 16. After the Return from the Babylonish Captivity when the Iewes were setting about the Work of building the Temple , which they would do by themselves , and not admit of any Association with Malignants ( upon their sinister misinformation , & Sycophantick Accusation , that they were building the rebellious & bad City , and would refuse to pay the King toll , tribute , & custome ) they were straitlie discharged by Artaxerxes to proceed in their Work , and the inhibition was execute by force & power Ezrah . 4. But by the encouragement of the Prophets , Haggai & Zechariah , countermanding the Kings decree ▪ they would not be hindered , the eye of their God being upon them , thô Tatnai the Governour of those parts , Shetharboznai , and their Companions , would have boasted them from it , with the Usual Arguments of Malignants , who hath commanded yow to do so & so ? Ezrah . 5. 3-5 . And yet this was before the decree of Darius was obtained in their favours , Ezrah . 6. Hence , if people may prosecute a duty without & against a Kings command , and before an allowance by Law can be obtained ; Then may a people resist their Commands and force Used to execute them : But here the Antecedent is manifest . 17. When Nehemiah came to Ierusalem , and invited the Iewes to build up the Walls of the City , they strengthened their hands for that good work against very much opposition : And when challenged by San●allat the Horonite , Tobiah the Servant the Ammonite , and Gesh●m the Arabian . Great Kings-men all of them , who despise & ●oasted them , what is this that ye do ? will ye rebeli against the King ? say they . He would not plead Authority , thô in the general he had the Kings warrant for it : Yet he would not give them any other satisfaction , than to intimate , whether they had that or not , having the Call of God to the Work , they would go on in the duty , and God would prosper them against their opposition , Nehem. 2. 19 , 20. And accordingly , not withstanding of all Scoffs & Plots & Conspiracies to hinder the building , yet they went on , and were encouraged to remember the Lord , & fight for their Brethren &c. and to build with weapons in their hands , N●h . 4. and brought it to an end , notwithstanding of all their Practices to fright them from it , chap. 6. Hence , If neither Challenges of Rebellion , nor Practices of Malignant Enemies who pretend Authority , nor any discouragements whatsoever , should deter people from a duty which they have a Call & Capacity from God to prosecute , and if they may promove it against all opposition by defensive armes ; Then , when a people are oppressed & treated as Rebells , for a necessary duty , they may & must defend themselves , and maintain their duty , notwithstanding of all Pretences of Authority against them . 18. I shall adde one Instance more , which is vindicated by jus populi , from the Historie of Esther . Because Mordecai refused to do homage to a Hangman ( Haman I should say ) a cruel Edict was procured from Ahasuerus , to destroy all the Jewes , written & sealled with the Kings ring , according to the Laws of the Medes & Persians , becoming a Law irrevocable & irreversible Esther . 3. 12 , 13. Yet the Lords Providence , always propitious to His People , brought it about so , that Haman being hanged , & Mordecai advanced , the Jewes were Called & Capacitated , as well as Necessitated , to resist that armed Authority that decreed to Massacre them , and that by the Kings oun Allowance , Esther . 9. When his former decree drew near to be put in execution , in the day that the Enemies of the Jewes hoped to have power over them , it was turned to the Contrary that no man could withstand them . Here they had the allowance of Authority to resist Authority : And this was not a Gift of a new right by that Grant , which they had not before ; only it was corroborative of their radical right to defend themselves , which is not the Donative of Princes , And which they had power to exerce & use without this , thô may be not the same Capacity : for the Kings warrand could not make it Lawful in point of Conscience , if it had not been so before . Hence , If people may have the Allowance of well advised Authority , to resist the decree & force of unlawful Authority ; then may a people maintain right Authority , in defending themselves against the injuries of pretended Authority : But by this Instance we see , the Jewes had Ahasuerus his Allowance to resist the decree & force of his oun ill-advised Authority , thô irreversible . And hence we see , that Distinction , in this Point , is not groundless , between resisting the Authority of Supreme powers , and the abuses of the same . Secundly , We have in the Scripture both tacite & express Reproofs , for lying by from this duty in the season thereof . 1. In Jacobs Swan-Song or Prophetical Testament , wherein he foretells , what should be the fate & future condition of each of the Tribes , and what should be remarked in their carriage influencing their after Lot in their generations , for which they should be commended or discommended , approved or reproved ; Coming to Issachar , he Prophetically exprobates his future Ass-like stupiditie , that indulging himself in his lazie ease and lukewarm security , he should mancipate himself & his Interests into a servile subjection unto his Oppressors Impos●itions , even when he should be in a Capacity to shake them off , and free himself by Resistence , Gen. 49. 14 , 15. Issachar is a strong Ass couching doun between two burdens . This is set doun by the Holy Ghost , as the brand & bane , not of the person of Issachar Jacobs Son , but of the Tribe , to be inured upon them , when they should be in such a concition by their oun silliness : Hence I argue , If the Holy Ghost exprobrate a people for their stupid subjection to prevailing Tyranny , when they do not improve their Ability , Capacity , & Right to maintain & defend their Liberties & Priviledges ; Then this implies a Commanded duty to defend them , according to their Capacity , from all unjust invasion : But the former is true here : Therefore also the later . 2. In Deborahs Song after their victorious Resistence , the people are severely upbraided for not concurring in that Expedition Iudg. 5. 16 , 17 , 23. and Meroz is particularly cursed for not coming to the help of the Lord , to the help of the Lord against the Mighty . This is Recorded as a resting Reproof , against all that will withdraw their helping hand from the Lords people , when necessitate to appear in defensive Armes for the preservation of their lives & Liberties . On the other hand , Zebulon & Naphtali are commended for jeoparding their lives in the high places of the fields , and are approved in that practice of fighting against the Kings of Canaan , that then ruled over them vers . 18 , 19. Hence , if people be Reproved & Cursed for staying at home to look to their oun Interests , when others jeopard their lives for their Countries defence & freedom from Tyrannie & Oppression ; Then this implies its a duty to concur in so venturing : But here , Rubeen , Dan , Asher , & Meroz , are Reproved & Cursed for staying at home , when Zebulon & Naphtali jeoparded their lives &c. Ergo. Thirdly , we have in the Scriptures many promises of the Lords approving & countenancing the duty of Defensive Armes even against their Oppressing Rulers . 1. In that forecited Testament of the Patriarch Iacob , in that part of it which concerns Gad , he Prophecies that Tribe should have a lot in the world answering his name , and be engaged in many Conflicts with Oppressing Dominators , who at first should prevail over him , but at length God should so bless his endeavours to free himself from their oppressions , that he should overcome . There is an excellent Elegancy in the Original , answering to the Etymology of the name Gad which signifies a Troop , reading thus in the Hebrew , Gad a Troop shall overtroup him , but he shall ouertroup them at the last Gen. 49. 19. And Moses homologating the same Testimony , in his blessing the Tribes before his death , shewes that he should make a very forcible & successful Resistence , and should execute the Justice of the Lord over his Oppressors Deut. 33. 20. 21. Wherein is implied a promise of Resistence to be made against Oppressing Conquerours , who should acquire the supreme rule over them for a time : And the success of that Resistence for overcoming , necessarly supposes Resistence . Hence , where there is a promise of success at last to a peoples Conflicts against prevailing Tyrannie , there is implied an Approbation of the duty , and also a promise of its performance wrapped up in that promise : But here is a promise &c. Ergo — 2. In that Threatening against Tyrants , shewing how they shall be thrust away & burnt up with fire , there is couched a promise , and also an implyed Precept of Resisting them 2 Sam 23. 6. The Sons of Belial shall be all of them as thorns thrust away — with hands fenced with iron &c. which clearly implies Resistence , and more than that . Rejection & Repression . Hence , If it be threatened as a Curse against Rulers of Belial . and promised as a Blessing , that they shall be so roughly handled ; then this implies a duty to resist them , who cannot be otherwayes taken : But here this is threatened &c. 3. When the Lord shall have mercy on Iacob & choose Israel , It is promised Isai. 14. 2 , 3. that they shall take them Captives whose Captives they were , And they shall rule over their Oppressors — This necessarly implies & infers a Promise of Resistence against these Oppressing Rulers , in the time off their Domineering , as well as revenge after their yoke should be broken ; And some thing of mens action as wel as Gods Judgement in breaking that yoke : for they could not take them Captives , nor Rule over them , except first they had resisted them whose Captives they were : There is Resisting of the Supreme Power , subjection whereunto was the bondage wherein they were made to serve . Hence ; If it be promised , that a Captivated & subjugated people shall break the yoke & free themselves of the bondage of them that had them in subjection ; then it is promised in that case , they must resist the Supreme Powers ; for such were they whose Captives they were : The Antecedent is here express . 4. There are promises that the Lords people , when those that rule over them are incensed against the Holy Covenant , and when many of their Brethren that should concur with them shall be frighted from their duty by fear , o r corrupted with flatterie , shall be made strong to do exploits , thô in such Enterprizes they may want success for some time , and fall by the sword & flame and by captivity & spoyl many dayes Dan. 11. 30-34 . Which is very near Paralel , to the case of the Covenanted people of Scotland their appearing in Defensive exploits against their Covenant-breaking Rulers these many years bygone . This was very eminently fulfilled , in the Historie of the Maccabees , before r●hearsed . Hence , If it be promised that a people shall be strong to do exploits , in Resisting the Armes of their Rulers , opposing their Covenant , and overturning their Religion & Liberties ; Then it must be approven that such a Resistence is Lawful , even thô it want success : But this is here promised . To the same purpose it is promised , that after the Lords people have been long kept as Prisoners under the bondage of Oppressing Rulers , they shall by a vigorous Resistence be saved from their Tyrannie Zech. 9. 13-17 . when the Lord shall bend Iudah for him and raise up Zions Sons against the Sons of Greece — So it was in their Resistences & victories , against the Successors of Alexander , who had the rule over them for a time . And so it may be again , when the Lord shall so bend His people for Him. Hence , If the Lord promises to fit & Spirit His people for Action against their Oppressing Rulers , and to Crown their Atchievements when so fited & Spirited with Glorious success ; Then it is their duty , and also their honour , to Resist them : But here that is plainly promised . 5. There are promises of the Lords making use of His people , and strengthening them to break in pieces the power of His & their Enemies , and His defending & maintaining them against all their power & projects , when they think most to prevail over them . As is promised , in the threatened Catastrophe of the Babylonian Usurpation Ier. 51. 20-24 — Thow art ( sayes He to Israel , of whom He speaks as the rod of His Inheritance in the preceeding verse ) my battle ax & weapons of war , and with thee will I break in pieces &c. Whensoever this hath been or shall be accomplished ( as it may relate to the vengeance to be execute upon the New Testament Babylon ) it clearly implies their breaking in pieces Powers that were Supreme over them . Hence , If the Lord will make use of His peoples vindictive Armes against Babylon ruling over them , then He will Justifie their Defensive Armes against Babylon Oppressing them : Here it is promised &c. So Mic. 4 ▪ 11. to the end , Many Nations shall be gathered to defile & look upon Zion , and then the Lord shall give Allowance & Commission to His people to arise & thresh &c. What time the accomplishment of this is referred to , is not my concern to inquire : It seems to look to the New Testament times , wherein the Lords people shall be first in great straits , and then enlarged : But to restrict it to the Spiritual Conquest over the Nations by the Ministrie of the Word ( thô I will not deny but that may be included ) seems too great a straitening of the Scope , and not so apposite to the Expressions , which certainly seem to import some forcible action of men , and more than the Peaceable Propagation of the Gospel . It is usually referred to the latter dayes of that Dispensation , when both the Iewish & Gentile Zion shall be totally & finally delivered from Babylon or Antichristian Tyrannie , before or about which Period , the Enemies of Christ and of His people shall attempt their Ultimus Conatus to destroy the Church groaning under their bondage ; but when they are all well mustered in a General Randezvous , the Lords people shall have a gallant game at the chase . But whensoever the time be of fulfilling the promise , it ensures to the people of God the success of their Defensive Armes against them , that pretended a Domination over them . And it looks to a time , when they should have no Rulers of their oun , but them under whose subjection they had been long groaning , and now brought to a very low pass : yet here they should not only resist but thresh them . Hence , If in the latter dayes the people of God are to be honoured , and acted forth with such a Spirit & Capacity to thresh & beat doun these powers under which they have been long groaning ; Then when the Lord puts them in such Capacity to attempt it , they should be ambitious of such a honour : But here it is promised &c. The same may be inferred from the Prophets vision Zech. 1. 19 , 20. He sees four Carpenters Resisting the four hornes : the hornes scattered Iudah , so that no man did lift up his head ; but the Carpenters came to fray them , to cast out the hornes of the Gentiles , which lifted up their horn over the Land of Iudah . These hornes had the Supreme power over Iudah for a time , while they were in no Capacity to resist them ; But as soon as the Lord furnishes them with Capacity & Instruments impowered to resist them , they do it effectually . The Carpenters are certainly the Lords people themselves ; for here they are opposite to the Gentiles , which all were except the Lords people . Hence , If the Lord promises , when reconciled to His people , to furnish them with Instruments to fray & scatter the power of Tyrants , who have long born doun their head ; Then when they are so furnished , they may resist them : But the Lord here promises that &c. This is more plainly promised also Zech. 10. 5. &c. Then they shall be as mighty men which shall tread doun their Enemies — And the pride of Assyria shall be brought doun — Hence , If the Lord , when He shall have Mercy on His people , will bless their Resistence so , as to bring doun the pride & Scepter of them that had the Supreme power over them ; Then , in hope of such a blessing , they may attempt such a duty , when the Call is clear . Fourthly , we have also Precepts , from whence we may consequentially conclude the Approven duty of Defensive Armes against Oppressing Rulers . 1. The Children of Israel are Commanded to vexe the Midianites & sinite them , for saith the Lord , they vexe yow with their Wyles Numb . 25. 17 , 18. And to avenge themselves Numb . 31. 2. Which did not only oblige the people , when they had Moses for their Magistrate to lead them forth ; but in the dayes of Gideon , when they were under their rule whom they were to avenge themselves upon . Hence , If people must vexe their Enemies , & avenge themselves of them , by a war offensive , when ensnared by their Craftiness ; much more may they resist them by a war Defensive , when invaded by their Cruelty . 2. There is a Command to pu●ish every City or party , making Apostasie into Idolatry Deut. 13. 12-15 . Upon this Moral Ground was Israels war against Benjamin Iudg. 20. And their bringing Amaziah into Condign punishment , which is vindicated by Mr Knox. See above Per. 3. pag. 41 , 42. Hence , If people are to bring to condign punishment Idolatrous Apostates seeking to Intyce them ; Then much more ought they to resist such Tyrants seeking to Inforce them to such Apostasie . 3. There is a precept , not only to defend , but also to rescue & deliver our Brethren when in hazard Prov. 30. 11 , 12. We must not for bear to deliver them when drawen to death : which will at least infer the duty of assisting them when forced to defend themselves ; for , If it be a duty to to rescue them from any prevailing power that would take their lives unjustly , much more is it duty to defend them and our selves both against their Murdering violence : But it is duty to rescue them &c. 4. All that would learn to do well , are commanded Isai. 1. 17. to relieve the Oppressed : which is not spoken to Magistrates only , many of whom were the Oppressors , the Princes were rebellious & Companions of thieves vers . 23. So also Isai. 58. 6. It is required of a people that would be accepted of God in their humiliations , to let the Oppressed go free , and to break every yoke . Hence , If it be duty to relieve the Oppressed by breaking the yoke of them that Oppress them ; Then it is duty to defend them and our selves both against them that would oppress us more : But the former is here commanded : Therefore &c , 5. There is a Command for a spoyled Oppressed people , when the Lord is reconciled to them and Sympathises with them , to deliver themselves from their Rulers servitude Zech. 2. 7. Deliver thy self O Zion which dwellest with the daughter of Babylon . Which comprehends all the ordinary Active means of peoples delivering themselves , from oppressing powers that rule over them : And consequently Defensive Resistence ; for it cannot only be restricted to flight included ( vers . 6. ) the promise annexed ( vers . 9. ) imports more , when they that spoyled them shall be a spoyl to their servants : Whereby it is insinuated , they were so to deliver themselves , as not only to free themselves from their servitude , but to bring their Masters under subjection . Hence , If the Lords people , being subject to Tyrants ruling over them for the time , may deliver themselves from their Oppressing Masters , then may they resist them & Defend themselves : The Antecedent is express here in the Command . 6. There is a Command given by Christ to His Disciples , to provide themselves with Defensive weapens , necessary for their Defence against them that would pursue after their lives ; as well as with other things necessary for their sustenance Luk. 22. 36 — Now he that hath a purse let him take it and likewise his scrip , and he that hath no sword let him sell his garment & buy one . Before , when he had sent them out upon an extraordinary Commission , as it were to serve their Apprentship in the Work of the Gospel , He did not allow them such sollicitous care to provide themselves , because He would give them a proof of His sufficiency to sustain & protect them , without the ordinary means of their oun Diligence . But now , when He was about to withdraw His bodily presence from them , and would warn them of the Discouragements they were to expect in the Prosecution of their more continued Work , which they had a Commission for not to be retracted , He would not have them to expect Provision & Protection by a Course of Miracles , but to provide themselves with means for their sustenance , and also for their Defence against the violence of men ; which chiefly was to be expected from their Rulers , who would persecute them under the notion of Transgressors of the Laws of their Kingdoms & Countries . He was not indeed to make much use of them , at that time , for Himself ; Who was then to finish the Work of Redemption by Suffering : Only , that what was written might be accomplished in Him , He would make so much use of them , as voluntarely to be involved under the censure & reproach of Rebellion , being taken among men in Armes , that He might be reckoned among Transgressours vers . 37. Therefore when they told him , they had two swords , He said , It is enough vers . 38. I need not stand upon that Impertinency of a Conceit , that these were Spiritual swords : Which deserves no Confutation , being fitter to be put among Quakers delirious distractions , than to be numbered among the notions of men of understanding : for then the Purse and the Scrip must be Spiritual too ; And these Spritual things must be bought by sellings of Garments ; And yet they would be such Spiritual tools , as would have a sharp edge for cutting off of Carnal ears , and such as would be both visible & sensible ; And two of them would be enough . They were then ordinary Material swords , which the Lord Commands His Followers to provide themselves with , for their defence as Men , in cases of necessity , and , when they should be in a Capacity , to improve them against their Murdering Persecuters , against whom He gives His Royal Grant of Resistence ; that the world may know , His Subjects , thô they have more Priviledges Spiritual , yet they have no less humane Priviledges than other men : Albeit at that Period of His determined Suffering , He would not allow the present use of them . Hence , If the Lords people should provide themselves with Armes of defence , thô they should be reputed Transgressors for so doing ; Then may they use these Armes of Defence , against them that Persecute them under that Notion : But the Antecedent is clear : Therefore &c. Fifthly , We may infer the same Truth from some of the Prayers of the Saints , wherein they glory in the confident expectation of the Lords strengthening them , & favouring & approving their helpers , & in the experience of the Lord Assisting them , while in the mean time constitute in a formed Appearance of Resistence . I shall only hint these . 1. In that prayer Psal. 44. 5. They glory in hope that through the Lord they will push doun their enemies &c. yet now they were under the power of Tyrannizing Dominators which they were Resisting : for vers . 9. they complain they were put to shame , because the Lord went not forth with their Armies , & they which hated them spoyled them — And for His Sake were killed all day long : Hence they plead , that the Lord would awake — and not forget their affliction & oppression . Whereby it is evident , they were under the yoke of Tyrannizing powers , and Resisting according to their might . Which , by whomsoever or upon what occasion soever the Psalm was compiled , shewes , that no want of Success in Resisting Tyrants , can mar the Saints faith in pleading for the Lords Assistence & Approbation of the Duty . Hence , they that in faith may pray for & boast of their treading doun their Tyrannizing powers . that rise up against them , may also in faith attempt the Resisting of them in their oun defence : But here the Lords people did the former . 2. We find David under Sauls persecution , while he had a party of 600. men to defend himself against his rage , in the Psalmes which he composed upon that occasion , not only complaining of Oppressors , but encouraging himself in the faith that God would be with them that assisted him , in his essay of defending himself , and imprecating destruction to Saul & his Complices ; that the Lord would cut them off in His Truth , and let him see his desire upon them Psal. 54. 4 , 5. ult . And Psal. 57. 4. And Psal , 57. throughout , And Psal. 140. 7 , 9. He imprecates against the head of them that compassed him about , and consequently against Saul . Whence I argue . 1. If the Lords people , conflicting with & encompassed with Oppressing Rulers as so many Lyons & Dogs , may pray & praise for the help of those that assist them , in their endeavours of Self-preservation from them ; then may they make use of their help for their Defence , for which they pray & praise : But here we see the Lords people did the former : Therefore they may do the latter . 2. If we may pray against Kings , and for preservation from them ; Then may we Defend our selves against them , and endeavour the means of that preservation for which we pray . The Connexion is before cleared : yet here I adde ; That which will give a Dispensation from our duty of praying for them , will also dispense from the duty of being passively subject to their will ; And consequently will allow defending our selves from their violence : But here we see Tyrannie & Treacherie , and designed Mischief will give a Dispensation from our duty of praying for them , thô that be duty as indispensable as subjection . Again , if any thing demur us from Resisting of Princes , it must be respect to their Majestie , and the Character of the Lords anointing upon them : But we see , no respect to that will demur a Believer from praying in faith against them : Therefore no such respect will hinder , but that he may defend himself against his violence . And indeed , if we consider it right , if the impression of any Majestie God hath put upon Princes should bind up our hands from any Resistence , it will restrain from prayer-resistence : for , if that impression have any force at any time , it must be when a man is most solemnly stated before God , and speaking to God as a Christian , rather than when he is acting as a man with a man like himself : And as prayer-resistence is the more formidable & forcible Resistence than any other ( as this Saul , and many other Kings , have found by their woful experience ) so it is more restricted than other Resistence ; for , we may defend our selves against many whom we must not pray against , to wit , our private enemies , for whom we are commanded to pray ; yet no body will deny but we may resist their violence : And likewise , we are commanded to pray for Kings , when invested with Gods Authority : But when their degeneration looses us from that obligation to pray for them , and allowes us to pray against them when they turn Enemies to God ( as we see in the prayers of the Psalmist ) Then also we may more warrantably resist them by Defensive Armes . 3. Among the Halle-luyahs , in the end of Psalmes , there is one Calcula●e for the prevailing time of the Church , when the Lord shall take pleasure in His people . In that time of the Saints being joyful in Glory , when they may glory in the rest & security the Lord will vouchafe upon them , they are Prophetically & very Pathetically excited to praise prayer-wise Psal. 149. 6. to the end . Let the high praises of God be in their mouth , and a two edged sword in their hand — to bind their Kings with chains — to execute upon them the Iudgement written ; this h●nour have all the Saints , Halle-lujah . This was their praise & honour , when they were brought in to execute vengeance upon the Kings & Nobles of 〈◊〉 . This also in Davids time was the ambition and also the attainment of the Saints , in their Triumphant victories over many of their Oppressors round about them . But it looks to a further & more famous execution of vengeance upon the Tyrants of the earth , when they shall have long kept under the Church of God , & at length the Lord shall give His people a Capacity to break their yoke : which , when ever it shall be , shall be their honour . Hence , If it be the honour of the Saints , when the Lord puts them in Capacity , to execute vengeance upon their Enemies , thô they be Kings that Oppress them ; Then it may be their ambition to seek it , at least they may resist them . Thus from several Scripture Practices , Reproofs , Promises , Precepts , & prayers , this Truth may be proven : from which Scriptures , though other precious Truths are more Natively deduced , yet this Truth by unstrained & unconstrained Consequence may be also clearly inferred . HEAD . VI. The Sufferings of Some , upon the account of Extraordinary executing of Iudgement upon Notorious Incendiaries & Murdering publick Enemies by private persons in the circumstances wherein they were stated , vindicated . SUrely ( saith Solomon ) Oppression maketh a wise man mad , as on the other hand , a gift destroyeth the heart . Which , whensover there is a Concurrence & verification of both together , makes it very incident , and no wayes to be admired , that either some Actions of the Oppressed be Censurable ; Or that there be found many to Censure them , either out of ignorance , or prejudice , at a far off glance , which a nearer & narrower inspection of circumstances , through a Prospect of Charity , would not so readily condemn . When the Oppression of Tyrants comes to such a hight & pinch of Extremity , that it not only threatens a Community with desolation , but induces a necessity of unavoidable dissolution , and reduces a people to such a paroxisme of Desperation & consternation ( in respect of humane deliberation bringing them to their wits end ) that either they must succumb as slaves , and mancipate consciences , persons , Liberties , properties , and all they are or have , to the lust of raging Tyrants and their revening Emissaries ; or surrender themselves , and their posterity , and which is dearer the Interest of Religion , to be destroyed : Then it is no wonder , that they be sometimes necessitated in such an extremity ; extremis malis extrema adhibere remedia , and forced to fall upon such expedients to prevent their utter extermination , as at other times common Order , and ordinary Justice would make extravagant . Yea it is no marvel , thô they fall into several real Extravagances , which are not to be justified nor extenuated ; but rather it is to be acknowledged , as a Miracle of the Lords Mercy , that in such a case they are restrained from more scandalous Excesses of that nature . Yet even then , such as live at ease , free of oppression , who are blinded with prejudice at the Oppressed , and bribed with the Indulgence & Lenity of the Oppressours towards themselves , will look upon these Actions as transports of madness , and effects of extravagant zeal , while they weigh them only in the scales of Ordinary Justice , and do not ponderate them in the ballance of Necessitated Virtue ; nor perpend the circums●ances which made those extraordinary Acts of Judgement , which materially are Lawful at all times to be executed by some , to be then necessary Acts of Justice to be inflicted by them in such a case . But if either the Oppressours themselves ; Or such who are blinded & bribed with their gifts and killed with their kindness , not only into an omission of concurring , but into a condemning of such extraordinary Attempts of taking off those Destroyers ; Or if On-lookers at a Distance , would seriously consider , and ingenuously declare their opinion in a particular application of the case to themselves , what they would do in such circumstances : I doubt not , but as Charity should oblige them to be sparing of their Censures , in a case whereof they have no experience ; So Justice , in resolving this point for themselves , would constrain them to justify such extraordinary necessitated Practices for self preservation , in preventing perishing by destroying their Destroyers , and move them rather to admire their Patience , who have suffered so much and so long those beasts of prey to devour them , than to censure their precipitancies , in being constrained to endeavour to deliver themselves at last from , and put an end to their Cruelty who did most annoy them . Yea ( as Naphtali sayes very well ) It were impossible that rational men , after the feeling of so sore grievances , and the teaching of so many & sad experiences , should still couch under the burden , and submit themselves to the yoke of such vile Apostate Upstarts and bloody Villains , and not rather acquit themselves like men , by pulling off these vizards , under which they mask their Villanies and clock their violence ; and plucking them out of that Sanctuary of Loyaltie , and Refuge of Authority , which they do not more pretend than profane by all their horrid Rebellion against God , and cruel Murders executed upon the Lords people , to the effect that in the righteous & deserved punishment of these wicked men , both the sin of the Land might be sisted , and the fierce Anger of the Lord averted , Naph . Prior edit . Pag. 134. Nevertheless such Lawful , and ( as one would think ) laudable Attempts , for cutting off such Monsters of Nature , beasts of prey , burdens to the earth , as well as Enemies to the Common-wealth , are not only condemned as Murders & horrid Assassinations , but Criminally & Capitally punished as such . And upon this account , the Sufferings of s●ch , as have left a Conviction upon the consciences of all that knew them , of their honesty , integrity , soundness , in the principles , and seriousness in the practice of Religion , have been several , singular , and signally severe ; and ouned of the Lord to the admiration of all Spectators : Some being cruelly tortured & executed to the death , for essaying such execution of Judgement , as Mr Mitchel ; others for accomplishing it , as Mr Hackstoun of Rathillet , and others , who avowed their accession to the cutting of that Arch-Traitor Sharp , Prelat of St Andrewes ; And others for not condemning that and the like Acts of Justice , thô they were as innocent of the facts as the Child unborn . The foregoing Historical Representation of the matters of fact , doth clear the Circumstances of the Actions : which , if ever any of that nature performed by private men without publick Authority , could be justified , will at least demur the condemning of them . For , the men , or rather monsters , thus removed , had not only been perjured Apostates from , and conjured Enemies against God , in a Conspiracy with the Devil to destroy the Reformation and the Remnant that professed it , affronted Blasphemers , perfidious Betrayers of the Country , and Enemies to the Commonweath , Malignant Incendiaries , and habitual Murderers of many of the Lords people , who for many notorious Crimes had forfeited their lives to Justice ; But were insolently prosecuting their Murdering designs , informing the Council , and instigating them against innocent people to destroy them utterly , procuring from them bloody Orders to spare none but cut off all who might fall into their hands , and vigorously & vigilantly with all violence pursuing their Murdering Mandats , both in their oun persons , and by villains whom they hounded out as Intelligencers to get & to give notice where any of those people might be detected , whom they vowed ( and avowed a design ) to destroy , when in the heat & hight of their rage they were cut off . The Actors were no wayes subject to them , nor any other way related than declared & Independent Enemies are to one another , having renounced all relation to them and their Masters as Magistrats or their superiours ; and were in no terms of peace with them , but maintaning an hostile opposition , and carrying without cessation , armes to resist them ; and when they got that advantage over them , that these Enemies were seeking against them , they declared solemnly to them , and dyed declaring it to the world , that they were not moved out of private revenge for personal injuries they had done against themselves , but being touched with the zeal of God , love to their Country , respect to Justice trampled upon by Tyrants , and for saving themselves , rescuing their Brethren , and preventing their Murthering them , because there were none that would or could execute Justice upon them legally , therefore they were forced to put forth their hands against them as enemies , with whose preservation their oun could not consist . Their Circumstances were such , that they were redacted to the greatest of Extremities , precluding all other humane possibility of preserving themselves and their Brethren from the destruction intended , and declaredly resolved , and restlessly sought & prosecuted , by these Murderers : being persecuted to the death by them , daylie chased , hunted , way-laid , turned out of their oun habitations , intercommuned , discharged & denyed all harbour in any house , under the hazard of the same pains that themselves were lyable to , which was death by the present Law , and so forced to hide in Caves & Dens ; out of which they durst not come forth , if it were but to seek bread for themselves , without eminent danger of their lives ; the Country raising the hue & cry after them , whensoever they were seen , whereby many were killed as soon as they were apprehended : Hence they could neither escape in the Land , nor by flight out of the Land , all passages by sea & Land being stopt , and none suffered to go any where , without strict examination what they were , which was impossible for them to elude : And many other specialities of miserie & danger were ingredients in their Circumstances , that no words can represent to them that are altogether strangers to them . Wherefore in such a strait & pinch of Perplexity , when they could not otherwise escape the fury of these firebrands , nor demur & deter the rest of them from an uncontrolled pursuit after the lives of Innocents , nor otherwise avert the wrath of God against the Land for the impunity of such vermine ; And seeing there was no access to address themselves to Magistrats , who by Office are obliged to bring such villains to condign punishment , And none were found in publick Authority but such as patronized & Authorized them , whom in Conscience they could not acknowledge , and in prudence durst not make application to them for fear of their lives ; What could they do ? what was left them to deliberate , but to fall upon this Extraordinary Course ; wherein if they have stumbled into some extravagancies , as to the manner , who can think it strange , considering the Case ? But as that is not the debate ; so as for such Acts of vengeance as are peccant in the matter , and were not circumstantiate as above rehearsed , being disouned in their publick Declarations , and the Actors excluded from their Communion for whom I plead ; it were iniquous to impute the scandal of them to that Suffering people . It is only the so Circumstantiate , necessitated , extraordinary execution of Judgement , upon notoriously gross & grassant Incendiaries , Tyrants , and terrible Murdering Enemies , when there is no living for them , that I vindicate . And thô the handling of this tender & quick-sented subject may seem odious to some , and my Discourse upon it as pregnant with an oblique design ; to obivate such unmerited surmises , I must say , it is only the wiping off of such Reproaches as reflect on Religion , the vindication of preterite extraordinary practices of this nature , the investigation of present duty with respect to future Emergencies , and the restraining all Extravagancies incident in this Head , that I intend . However this may be exploded by this generation as odious & un-couth Doctrine , yet in former Periods of this Church it hath been maintained with Courage , & asserted with Confidence . How the Ancient Scots , even after they received the Christian faith , served their Tyrants and Oppressours , how in the begining of the Reformation the killing of the Cardinal , and of David Rizio , were and are generally to this day justifed , and what was the Judgement & pleading of our Reformers for practising this principle against Idolaters &c. needs not be here repeated : Mr Knox's Judgement in particular is before declared , and will be further discovered , if we consider how he resented his slackness , in puting people to execute Judgement in these words , insert in Second Part of the Cloud of Witnesses Pag. 60. For God ( said he ) had not only given me knowledge , and a tougne to make known the impiety of the Idol , but had given me Credit with many , who would have put in execution Gods Judgements , if I would only have consented thereto : but so careful was I of the common Tranquility , and loath was I to offend some , that in secret conference with zealous men , I travelled rather to slacken that fervency God had kindled in them , than to animate & encourage them to put their hands to Gods Work ; wherein I acknowledge my self to have done most wickedly , and from the bottom of my heart I do ask God pardon , that I did not what in me lay to have suppressed that Idol in the begining . But the preceeding Historical Representation doth abundantly demonstrate this is no Noveltie , to assert , That when the ruine of the Countrie , suppression of Religion , destruction of the Remnant professing & suffering for it , and the Wrath of God is threatened in & for the impunity of Idolaters & Murderers , that by the Law of God & Man should die the death , and supposing alwayes such as are in publick Office not only decline their duty , but encourage those destroyers , yea Authorize them themselves ; we may not only maintain defensive Resistence according to our Capacity , but endeavour also vindictive & Punitive force in executing Judgment upon them in cases of necessity , as before Circumstantiate . And ● am the more confident to assert it , that what I say cannot be condemned , till first what our Reformers have proven be confuted . However to endeavour to make it some what clear , I shall first premit some Assertions , to clear the State of the Question : And then give some Reasons for it when clearly Stated . First , It will be needful for clearing our way , to shew what length we may warrantably go in this matter of executing Judgment , in our private Capacity , in extraordinary Cases of necessity , by setting doun some propositions negative & positive : Signifying what we disoune , and what we oune in this point . I. What we disoune , may appear in these Assertions . 1. No necessity not Circumstance supposible whatsoever , can justify the Murder of the Righteous or Innocent , or vindicate the unlawful taking away of their life directly or indirectly , immediately or mediately , which in thought as well as deed we must abhor , as a horrid breach of the Sixth Command . The Guilt whereof may be incurred several ways ; As by killing them Immediately , as Cain did his brother Abel ; or Commanding them to be killed , as Saul commanded Doeg to kill the Lords Priests ; or Contriving their Murder , as David did Uriahs , and Iezebel Naboths ; or Counselling thereunto , as the people advised the Princes to the murder of Ieremiah , and all that cryed Crucifie Iesus were Murderers of Christ ; Or by procuring it , as Haman was guilty of the intended murder of the Iewes ; Or Concurring therein , as Ioab was guilty of Uriahs death as well as David , and Iudas of Christs by betraying him ; Or by the Patrocinie thereof , defending & sparing the Murderers ; when called by Office to punish them , as David was guilty in not punishing Ioab , Ahab in patronizing the Murder of Naboth ; Or by Consenting thereunto , as Saul consented to the death of Stephen ; or by knowing & permitting , & conniving at it , as is condemned Prov. 24. 11 , 12. Whether this be done under colour of Law , as Pilate Murdered our Lord , Herod killed Iames ; or without all colour , by Absolute power , as Herod the Ascalonite murdered the Infants ; or whether it be done by purpose , as Ioab murdered Abner & Amasa ; or without previous purpose , yet with knowledge of the Action in the perpetrating of it , as men may do in passion when provoked beside their purpose , or in a Tumult without intending it before hand , yet that is Murder , Barabas committed Murder in the Insurection . For , as for Casual killing contrary to intention without knowledge , that 's no breach of the Command . And , whatever may be said of necessitated delivering up the Innocent , pursued by a potent Enemy , to deliver the City from his fury ; or of prefering our oun life to our innocent neighbour , in a case when both cannot be preserved , and by preserving the one Lawfully the other happens to lose his life ; I do not medle with these Cases . But since this is taken for granted by Casuists , I infer , if it be Lawful that an innocent man die in case of necessity , that others may be preserved ; Then much more is it Lawful , that the nocent wo are guilty of murdering the Righteous all these wayes above specified , and actually prosecuting their murdering designs by these methods , should rather be made to die than the Righteous be destroyed . But of this sort of Murder , taking away the life of the Righteous , none hath the impudence to accuse that Reproached people . 2. Thô a man kill an innocent unwittingly & unwillingly , besides his knowledge and against his will ; yet he may be guilty of sinful homicide , if he was obliged to know that he was in hazard of it , and neglected to consider , lest a man might be killed by what he was doing : as if a man should shoot at random , when he doth not know but some may be killed thereby ; or if one were hewing with an axe , which he either knew or might have known to be loose , and the head not well fastened to the helve , did not advertise those about him of it , if by flying off it happened to kill any person , he were not innocent , but if he knew not without any inadvertency , then he were guiltless , Deut. 19. 5. See Durham on 6. Com. So if a man built a house without battlements , he should bring blood upon his house , if any man fell from thence Deut. 22. 8. But of this the question is not . 3. Thô a person be not altogether innocent , nor to be reckoned among the Rigtheous ; but suppose him wicked & profane , and engaged in an evil Course , dishonourable to God , prejudicial to the Church & Kingdom , and very injurious to us : Yet it may be Murder to kill him , if he be not guilty of Crimes that deserve death by the Law of God : for the life of man is not subjected to the arbitrement of any , but His who is the Author of life & death : It s necessary to all to obey the Law , Thow shalt not kill , without exception , but such killing as is approven by the Author of the Law , as saith Ames●de Consciencia cap , 31. quest . 2 , Hence , this people so much reproached with extravagant Actions , do abundantly clear themselves of that imputation of being of the mind to kill all that differ from them , which was the impudent forgerie of the father of lies , in their Informatory Vindication Head. 2. Pag. 54. We positively disoune ( say they ) as horrid Murder , the killing of any because of a different perswasion or opinion from us , albeit some have invidiously cast this odious Calumny upon us . And it is as clear , they that took the Oath of Abjuration swore a lie , when they abjured the Apologetical Declaration , in so far as it asserted it was Lawful to kill all imployed in the Kings service , when it asserted no such thing , as is shewed above Head. 3. To think so much , let be to declare it , far more to practise such a thing against all that served the King , or any meerly because they served him , or because they are in a wicked Course , or because they have oppressed us , were abominable : for these things simply do not make men guilty of death , to be punished Capitally by men according to the Law of God. But when they are stated in such opposition to us , and serve the Tyrants Murdering Mandats by all those wayes above specified ; then we may by the Law of God and Nature and Nations destroy , slay , and cause to perish , and avenge our selves on them that would assault us and are seeking our destruction , as it was Lawful for the Iewes to do with Hamans Emissaries Esther . 8. 11 , 13. & 9. 1 , 2 , 5. This Charge then cannot reach the Case . 4. Thô Murderers , and such as are guilty of death by the Law of God , must be punished by death , for he that sheddeth mans blood by man must his blood be shed : Yet it may be Murder for a man to kill another , because he thought him so Criminal , and because he thought it his duty , being moved by a pretended Enthusiastical Impulse , in imitation of the extraordinary Actions of such as were really moved by the Spirit of God. As when Iames & Iohn would have commanded fire to come doun to consume the Samaritans , the Lord rebuked them , saying , ye know not what manner of Spirit ye are of , for the Son of man is not come to destroy mens lives but to save them Luk. 9. 54-56 . Such impulses had need to be well examined , for ordinarly they will be found not consistent with a Gospel Spirit , which is alwayes averse from act of Cruelty . Blind zeal sometimes may incite men to fearful work : yea the persecuters have often most of that Spirit , as our Lord foretells , the time cometh that whosoever killeth yow shall think that ●e doth God service Iohn . 16. 2. Paul in his Pharisaical zeal breathed out slaughter against the disciples . And Satan can drive men under several colours , to act such things , as he did the Bours in Germany , and Iohn of Leyden and his followers , whose practices are deservedly detested by all that have any spark of Christianity or humanity : for if this were espoused as a Principle , there would be no security for mens lives . But hence it cannot be concluded , that God may not animate some to some rare Enterprises , for the cutting off of Tyrants and their bloody Emissaries , Incendiaries , Destroyers of innocent people , and puting an end to and stoping the Career of their Murders , in a time of real extreame necessity , the matter of the action being unquestionably Lawful , their ends & intentions really good & commendable , there being also a deficiency of others to do the work , and themselves in some probable Capacity for it . See Ius Popul . Cap. 20. Pag. 410. Neither can it be denyed , but true zeal may sometimes incite people to such exploits , for the preservation of Religion & Liberty , their oun lives and Brethren , all like to be destroyed by the impunity of beasts of prey . This will be found very consistent with a Gospel Spirit : And though this Principle be asserted , and also put in practice , all persons notwithstanding thereof would have sufficient securitie for their life , except such as hath really forefeited their lives by all Law of God & man. Those that are led by Impulses , may pretend the imitation of extraordinary examples and abuse them ; yet hence it will not follow , that in no case these extraordinary Examples may be imitated . Shall the examples of good Magistrats , executing Justice on Idolaters & Murderers , be altogether unimitable , because Tyrants abuse them in persecuting the innocent ? If this arguing were good , it would make all vertuous Actions in the world unimitable ; for these may be abused by pretenders . See Ius Popul ▪ ubi supra Pag. 412. But it cannot be charged upon the Sufferers upon this head , that they had nothing to give as the reasons of their Actions but pretexts of Enthusiasmes . 5. Thô a man be really so Criminal , as tha● he deserves death by the Law of God & man ; yet it may be murder to kill him , if we do not certainly know it , and can prove it , and convict him of it upon Tryal : for no man must be killed indictâ or incognitâ causâ . Thus even Magistrats may Murder Murderers , when they proceed against them without probation or cognition according to Law , far more private persons . Thus the Abiezrites would have murdered Gideon , not only unjustly for his duty of throwing doun the Altar of Baal , but illegally , because they would had him brought out that he might die without any further Tryal Iudg. 6. 29 , 30. So likewise the Iewes that banded & bound themselves under a curse to kill Paul before he was tried , would have Murdered him , not only unjustly for his duty , but illegally before he was tried Act. 23. 12. But this doth not condemn the Actions of those Sufferers , in maintaining the necessary execution of Judgement , upon persons who are Notorious Murderers , yea professing a trade and prosecuting habitually a tract of continued Murdering the people of the Lord. 6. Thô it should be certainly known , and sufficiently proven , that a man is a Murderer &c. Yet it were Murder for an inferiour , under a relation of subjection to him , to kill him , as long as that subjection were acknowledged : for whensoever the common & mutual right or relation , either Natural , Moral , Civil , or Religious , to the prejudice or scandal of the Church or State or particular persons , is broken by killing any person , that is Murder ; thô the person killed deserve to die . As if a Subject should kill an acknowled King , a Son by Nature or in Law should kill his Natural or legal father , a Servant should kill his Master , breaking these relations , while their right & tye were acknowledged ( as some of them must still be acknowledged as long as the Correlates continue in being , to wit , that of a father is not broken by his becoming a Murderer ) and to the danger , detriment , & scandal of the Church & State ; That were properly Assassination : for Assassines are they , who being subject to others , either out of their oun head for their oun ends , or by command of their Superiours , kill their Superiours , or such as they command them to kill , as Alstedius describes them Theolog. Cas. cap. 18. de homicid . reg . 55. Therefore David would not kill Saul , because he acknowledged him to be the Lords Anointed , to whom he was under a relation of subjection ; and because he was his Master and Father in Law ; And because it would have tended to the hurt of the Kingdom , and involved it in Combustions & Contentions about the succession , and prejudged his oun right , as well as to the scandal of the people of God , thô Saul deserved otherwise to be capitally punished . So Ishbosheth was killed by Baanah & Rehab 2 Sam. 4. 7. So Iozachar & Iehozabad who killed Ioash 2 King. 12. 21. were punished as Murderers chap. 14. 6. because they were his servants , and did assassinate him to whom they were subject . So the servants of Amon were punished by the people , as Conspirators against their King & Master 2 King. 21. 23 , 24. though Amon deserved to have been punished as well as Amaziah was . Hence generally it is observed by some , that thô right be given to equals or Superiours to bring their nearest relations to condign punishment , when they turn entycers to Idolatry Deut. 13. 6. Yet no right or jus , upon any cause or occasion whatsoever , is given to inferiours , as Children &c. to punish their fathers . See Pool . Synop. Critie . in Locum . However it be , this cannot condemn the taking off of Notorious Murderers , by the hand of such as were no way subject nor related to them , but as enemies , who in extreame necessity executed righteous Judgement upon them , without prejudice of the true necessary & chief good of the Church & Commonwealth , or of any particular persons just right & security , as Napthali qualifies it Pag. 22. 23. Prior edit . 7. Thô the matter of the Action were just , and the Murderer such a person as we might punish , without any breach of relative obligations or duties ; Yet the manner may aggravate it to some degree of Murder ; if it be done Secretly , when it may be execute publickly ; or suddenly & precipitantly , when it may be done deliberately , without rushing upon such an Action , or hurrying the Murderer to eternity , as this also might have had some weight with David not to murder Saul secretly & suddenly in the Cave , or when he was sleeping , So Ishbosheth and Io●sh and Amoa were murdered ; Or if it be done subtilly , when it may be performed in more plain & fair dealing ; or teacherously , under colour of friendship ; or cruelly without regard to humanity ; and especially when the Actors are at peace with the person , whose blood they shed , as Ioab shed the blood of war in peace 1 King. 2. 5. in killing Abner & Amasa so craftily & cruelly ; and Absalom made his servants Assassinate Amnon 2 Sam 13. 28 , 29. But this cannot be charged upon them , who executed righteous Judgement , as publickly , deliberately , and calmely , as the extraordinary exigence of pressing necessity , in extremity of danger , could allow , upon notorious Murderers , with whom they were in open and avowed terms of hostility . 8. Thô the manner also be inculpable ; yet if the principle and motive of killing , even those that deserve to die be out of malice , hatred , rage , or revenge , for private or personal injuries , it is Murder . For the affection & intention doth make one and the same action of taking away the life , homicide or no homicide , as Lex Rex saith Quest. 31. Pag. 338. If a man out of hatred deliberately take away another mans life , he is a Murtherer eatenus ; but if that same man had taken away the others life , by the flying off of his axe head , he neither hating him before nor intending to hurt him , he is no Murtherer by Gods express Law , allowing Cities of refuge for the one , and not for the other Deut. 4. 42. Deut. 19. 4. &c. private revenge is indignity to God , whose it is to take vengeance Deut. 32. 35. Rom. 12. 19. Dearly beloved avenge not your selves , for vengeance is the Lords . For which cause Iacob curses Simeon & Levi their Murder of the Schechemites , for in their anger they slew a man Gen. 49. 6 , 7. So David would not put forth his hand against Saul , for his oun private & personal quarrel . So Ioab killed Abner , and Absalom Amnon . But this doth not make the execution or Judgement , out of zeal for God , respect to Righteousness , love to the Nations Interest , and care to preserve the persecuted people of God from imminent destruction , upon publick Enemies Incendiaries , that are trampling upon all these precious Interests , and threatening the utter ruine of them , and in a particular manner their destruction who thus prevent them . 9. Thô the motive or cause were upon a publick account , yet it may be Murder to have a wrong End in it : as either to intend simply the destruction of the person on whom they execute Judgement , as the end to which all their Action is directed , or to make their oun advantage or honour the end of the Action . Thus David would not kill Saul , because it might have been thought he did it to obtain the Kingdom , of which he was rightfull successor : And deservedly he punished the Amalekite , that brought newes of his killing Saul ; and Baanah & Rechab , for their killing Ishbosheth , thinking thereby to advance themselves at Davids Court. So also Ioab murdered Amasa to secure himself in the Generals place . And Iehu , though upon the matter he executed righteous Judgement , his end was only himself , it is condemned as murder . But when the execution of righteous Judgement is both formally intended by the Actors , and natively & really doth conduce to the Glory of God , the preservation of the Remnant threatened to be destroyed by these Murderers , the suppressing of impiety , doing of Justice , turning away wrath , and removing of present and preventing of future judgments , then it may be duty Naph . Pag. 23. Prior edit . 10. Thô the end also were not culpable ; yet it may be Murder to kill Criminals by transgressing the sphere of our vocation , and usurping upon the Magistrats sword : for he by Office is a Revenger , to execute wrath upon him that doth evil Rom. 13. 4. none must make use of the sword of vindictive Justice , but he to whom the Lord giveth it , therefore they that came to take Christ are condemned & threatened for this Math. 26. 52. all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword . The God of Order hath assigned to every man his station & calling , within the bounds whereof he should keep , without transgressing by defect or excess , let every man abide in the same calling wherein he was called 1 Cor. 7. 20. and study to be quiet and do his oun business 1 Thess. 4. 11. Therefore David would not kill Saul , because he would have done it beside his calling . And therefore the killing of Ioash and Amon was murder , because the Assassines did transgress their vocation . But when Notorious Incendiaries do not only transgress their vocation , but the Limits of humane societie , and turn open enemies to God & man , destroying the innocent , making havock of the Lords heritage , and vaunting of their villanies and boasting of their wickedness , and thereby bringing wrath upon the Land if such effrontries of insolence should pass unpunished , and when there is no Magistrate to do that work of Justice , but all in that p●ace are airt & part with them , patrons & defenders of them , yea no Magistrate that can be acknowledged as a Minister of God to be applied unto ; in that case , it is no a transgression of our vocation , nor an Usurpation upon the Magistrats , where there is none , to endeavour to avert wrath , by executing righteous Judgement . Otherwise if for fear , or suspicion of the accidental hazard of private mens Usurping the Office or doing of the duty of Publick persons , every vertuous Action which may be abused shall be utterly neglected , Impiety shall quickly gain Universal Empire , to the extermination of all goodness Naph . Pag. 24. Prior edit . To clear this , it must be considered , that a mans calling is two fold ; his particular calling , whereunto in the ordinary course of things he is regularly confined ; and his general calling , not circumscribed by particular rules , which from the common obligation of the end for which all callings are institute , in the clear exigence of an extraordinary emergent , according to the general rules of righteousness , bind to an aggreeable practice : Therefore circumstances may sometimes so diversitie Actions , that what in the ordinary & undisturbed state of things would be accounted an excess of our particular calling , & an Usurpation , in an extraordinary occurrence may become a necessary duty of our general calling . 11. Thô it were no Usurpation beyond our calling ; yet it may be murder , to kill any without the Call of God in a case of necessity , either in tute●â vitae proximâ , or though it be remotâ when the hazard is unavoidable . Every thing must have Gods Call in its season to make it duty , so also the time of killing Eccles. 3. 3. For want of this , David would not kill Saul . Lex Rex saith excellently to this Quest. 31. pag. 329 , 330. David might have killed Saul when he was sleeping , and when he cut of the lap of his garment , but it was unlawful for him to kill the Lords anointed , as it is unlawful to kill a man because he is the image of God Gen. 9. 6. except in case of necessity — David having Saul in his hand , was in a remote posture of defence , the unjust invasion then was not actual , nor unavoidable , nor a necessary mean in humane prudence for self preservation ; for King Saul was not in an actual pursuit of the whole Princes , Elders , Community of Israel ; Saul did but seek the life of one man David , and that not for Religion , or a National pretended offence , and therefore he could not in conscience put hands on the Lords Anointed , but if Saul had actually invaded David for his life , David might in that case make use of Goliahs sword ( for he took not that weapon as a Cypher to boast Saul ) and rather kill then be killed : Thus he . By a Call here we do not mean an express or immediate Call from God , such as the Prophets might have to their extraordinary executions of Judgement , as Samuel & Elijah had to kill Agag and Baals Prophets : but either the allowance of man , then there is no question about it ; Or if that cannot be had , as in the case circumstantiate it cannot , Then the Providential & Morall Call of extream necessity , for preservation of our lives , and preventing the murder of our Brethren , may warrant an extraordinary executing of righteous Judgement upon the Murderers . Men may have a Call to a necessary duty , neither every way mediate nor immediate , as the Call of runing together to quench a fire in a City , when Magistrats through wickedness or negligence will not or do not call people forth unto that work ; they have not mans call , nor an immediate call from Heaven , yet they have a Lawful Call from God : So they do not intrud upon the Magistrats Office , nor want they a call to this execution of Judgement , who do materially that work for that exigent which Magistrats by Office were bound to do , being called thereto by God , by Nature , and the call of inevitable Necessity , which knoweth no h●mane Law , and to which some Divine positive Laws will cede . Ius populi cap. 20. pag. 423. 12. Thô this be a principle of reason & natural Justice , when all the forementioned circumstances are clear , that it is Lawful for private persons to execute righteous Judgement , upon notorious Incendiaries and Murdering publick Enemies , in cases of necessity : yet it might be a sinful breach of the Sixth Command , to draw extraordinary examples of it to an ordinary practice in killing all who might be found Criminal , and would deserve death by the Law , as all that have served under a banner of Tyrannie & violence , displayed against God & His people , to the ruine of the Reformation , wasting of the Country , oppression of many honest families , and destruction of many innocent people , are and would be found guilty of Murder ; as the Chief Captain would have truly alledged Paul to have been a Murderer , if he had been the Egyptian which made an uproar , and led out four thousand men that were Murderers Act. 21. 38. As for the vulgar & ordinary sort of those Vermine of Varlets , it is of no advantage for oppressed people to foul their fingers upon them , when their slaughter would not put a stop to , but rather encrease , the destruction of the people of God ; and were unlawful to prevent & anticipate the due & Legal execution of Justice , where there is any prospect or expectation of its runing in its right channel . But for the chief & principal Ring-leaders , and common publick & habitual Incendiaries , and Masters of the ●rade of Murdering the Lords people , when there is no other way of being rid of their rage , and preserving our selves and preventing the destruction of our Brethren , we may in that case of necessity make publick examples of them , in an extraordinary Procedure against them , that may be most answerable to the Rules of the ordinary Procedure of Justice , and in imitation of the Heroick Actions recorded and justified in the Word of God , in the like extraordinary cases ; which are imitable , when the matter of their Actions is ordinary , that is , neither preternatural nor Supernatural thô the occasion was singular , just and necessary , both by Divine precept , and as a mean to good & necessary ends , and when there is no other to do the work , nor any prospect of access to Justice in its ordinary & orderly course , nor possibility of suspending it till that can be obtained . We need not then any other call than a Spirit of holy zeal for God , and for our oun & our Brethrens preservation , in that pinch of extremity . We do not hold these extraordinary Actions for regular & ordinary Precedents , for all times & persons universally : which if people should fancy , and heed more the glory & fame of the Action , than the sound & solid Rule of the Scriptures , they may be tempted & carried to fearful extravagances . But they may be Warrants , for private persons in their doing of these things , in an extreame necessity , to which at other times they are not called . And when the Lord , with Whom is the residue of the Spirit , doth breath upon His people moe or fewer , to the exciting of more than ordinary zeal , for the execution of Justice upon such Adversaries , we should rather ascribe Glory & Praise to Him , Whose hand is not shortened , but many times chooseth the weak & foolish things of the world to confound the mighty & the wise , than condemn His Instruments for doing such things Naph . pag. 24 , 25. Prior Edit . All these cases , which are all I can think on at present , comprehending all that may any way infer the guilt of murder , I have collected ; to the end I may conclude this one Argument , and leave it to be considered : If this extraordinary executing of Judgement , upon Notorious Incendiaries and Murdering publick Enemies , by private persons , in the circumstances above declared , cannot be reduced to any case that can infer the guilt of murder ; Then it cannot be condemned but justified : But this extraordinary executing of Judgement &c. cannot be reduced to any case that can infer the guilt of murder ( as will appear by the induction of all of them ) Ergo this extraordinary executing of Judgement &c. cannot be condemned but justified . II. In the Next place , What we oune may be done warrantably in taking away the life of men without breach of the Sixth Command , will appear by these propositions & Assertions , which will bring the matter to the present Circumstantiate Case . 1. It is certain , thô the Command be indefinitely expressed , it doth not prohibite all killing , but only that which is condemned in other explicatorie Commands . Our Lord Jesus repeating this Command , explains it by expressing it thus , Math. 19. 18. — Thow shalt not Murder . And if any be Lawful , it is granted by all , that is , which is unavoidable by the invincible necessity of Providence , when a man following his duty doth that which beside & contrary his intention and without any previous neglect or oversight in him , proveth the hurt & death of another , in which case he was allowed to flee to the City of refuge by the Law of God. Whence if that Physical necessity did justify that kind of killing , shall not a Moral necessity every way invincibly unavoidable ( except we suffer our selves and our Brethren to be destroyed by beasts of prey ) vindicate this kind , in an extraordinary extremity , when the Murderers are protected under the sconce of pretended Authority ? In which case the Law of God would allow deliberate Murderers should be pursued by the Avenger of blood , and not to have Liberty to flee to these subterfuges and pretexts of Authority ( meer Tyranny ) but to be taken from the horns of such altars , and be put to death , as Mr Mitchel sayes in vindicating his oun Action , in a Letter dated Feb. 1674. 2. It is Lawful to take the life of known & convicted Murderers by publick Justice : Yea it is indispensably necessary by the Law of God , and no mercy nor pardon of the Magistrate may interpose to spare them ; for , Whoso killeth any person the Murderer shall be put to death by the mouth of Witnesses — ye shall take no satisfaction for the life of a Murderer — but he shall surely be put to death , He was not to be admitted to the benefit of any refuge : And the reason is , blood defiles the Land , and the Land cannot be cleansed of the blood that is shed therein , but by the blood of him that shed it Numb . 35. 30 , 31 , 32 , 33. Hence if it be so necessary to cleanse the Land , then when the Magistrate is not only negligent in his duty , but turns a Patron & Protector of such Murderers , and imployes them as his Emissaries to murder & destroy , it cannot be expected he should cleanse the Land , for then he should free it of the burden of himself , and begin with himself : Therefore then there must be more incumbent upon private persons , touched with the zeal of God , than at another time . And as Mr Knox in his Conference with Queen Mary , sayes They that in the fear of God execute Judgement where God hath commanded , offend not God thô Kings do it not : and adduces the examples of Samuel killing Agag , Elias killing the Prophets of Baal , and of Phineas killing Zimri & Cozbi . 3. It is Lawful for private persons to kill , in Moderamine inculpatae tutulae , their unjust Assaulters , in defending themselves against their violence , and that both in Tutela vitae proxima , in the immediate defence of our life against an immediate assault , in the instant of the assault , and also in tutela remotâ in a remote defence of our selves , when that is as necessary as the first , and there is no other way of escaping the destruction intented by Murtherers , either by flight or resistence ; then it is Lawful to preserve our selves by taking advantages to cut them off . 4. It is Lawful in a just war to kill the enemie ; yea in the defensive war of private subjects , or a part of the Commonwealth , against their oppressing Tyrants , as is proven Head. 5. Where several of the Arguments used to evince that Truth will confirm this : as namely those Arguments taken from the peoples power in Reformation , and those taken from the hazard of partaking of others sin & Judgment . For if all the Magistrats , Supreme & subordinate , turn principal patrons and patterns of all abominations , and persecuters and destroyes of the people for not complying with them , then the people are not only under an obligation to resist them ; but seeing otherwise they would by lyable to their sin , in suffering them thus to trample on Religion and the Interests of God as well as their oun , in order to turn away the wrath of God , it is incumbent upon them to vindicate Religion , and Reform the Land from these Corruptions , in an endeavour to bring those Malignant Enemies of God and Destroyers of the people to condign punishment , that the heads of the people being hanged up before the Lord against the sun , the fierce anger of the Lord may be turned away from the Land Numb . 25. 4. In this case , as Buchannan sayes of a Tyrant , de jure regni , A Lawful war being once undertaken with such an enemy as a Tyrant is , every one out of the whole multitude of mankind may assault with all the calamities of war a Tyrant , who is a publick Enemy , with whom all good men have a perpetual warfare . And thô the war ●e not alwayes actually prosecute in a hostile manner , yet as long as peace is not concluded and the war ceased , they that have the just side of the quarrel may take advantages in removing & taking off ( not every single souldier of the Contrary side , for that would contribute nothing to their prevailing in the end ) but the principal Instruments & promoters of the war , by whose fall the offending side would suffer great loss , and the defending would be great Gainers . So Iael killing Sisera Iabins Captain-General , is greatly commended . Now this was the Case of the Sufferers upon this head , as Mr Mitchel one of them represents it , in his fore-cited letter I being ( sayes he ) a Souldier , not having laid doun my armes , but still upon my oun defence , having no other end nor quarrel at any man — besides the prosecution of the ends of the Covenant , Particularly the overthrow of Prelats & Prelacy ; And I being a declared enemy to him ( that is Sharp ) on that account , and he to me in like manner , I never found my self obliged — to set a sentinel at his door for his safety , but as he was alwayes to take his advantage , as it appeareth , so I of him to take any opportunity offered ; Moreover we being in no terms of Capitulation , but on the contrary , I by his instigation being excluded from all grace & favour , thought it my duty to pursue him at all occasions . 5. It is Lawful to kill enemies in the rescue of our Brethren , when they are keeping them in bondage , and reserving them for a sacrifice to the fury of Tyrants , or leading them forth to the slaughter , or in the time of acting their Murdering violence upon them , Then , to break Prisons , beat up Garrisons , surprise the Murderers , and kill them in the rescue of our innocent Brethren , is very Lawful , according to that Command Prov. 24. 11 , 12. and the practice of Moses , who seeing one of his Brethren suffering wrong , he defended him , and avenged him that was oppressed , and slew the Egyptian Act. 7. 24. For that is a certain Truth , which Grotius saith in locum , jus naturae dat innocenti & innocentem tutanti jus in nocentem . Hence it cannot but be Lawful also , in a case of necessity , when both our selves and our Brethren are pursued incessantly by destroying Murderers , to avenge our selves on them , and slay them , when there is no other way to be rid of their violence . 6. It is Lawful to prevent the Murder of our selves or our Brethren , when no other way is left , by killing the Murderers before they accomplish their wicked design , if they be habitually prosecuting it , and have many times accomplished it before . This followeth upon the other : And upon this account it had been duty for Gedaliab to have suffered I●banan to slay Ishmael , and so prevent the Governours murder , if it had been certainly known that Ishmael was sent by the King of Ammon to assassinate him Ier. 40. 14 , 15. for nothing is there objected against the Lawfulness of the thing , but only it was alledged that he spoke falsly . Alstedius asserts this Theol. Cas. de h●micidio reg . 6. pag. 331. Licitum est praevenire eum qui vult invadere , & praeveniendo occidere antequam invadat , si necessarium est praevenire , quia aliter vita propria defendi non potest nisi preveniendo . It is Lawful to prevent him that would assault us , and by preventing to kill him before his invasion , if it be so necessary , to prevent him , that our life cannot be otherwise defended but by preventing . And hence he justifies that saying , licitum est occidere insidiantem , It is Lawful to kill him that lyeth in wait to murder , ibid. This is all the length that the reproached Sufferers , whom I am vindicating , go in asserting this principle , as may be seen in their Informatory Vindication Head 2. pag. 55. where they say , We maintain it as both righteous & rational , in defence of our lives , Liberties , & Religion , after an orderly & Christian manner , to endeavour by all means Lawful & possible , to defend our selves , rescue our Brethren , and prevent their murder , in a martial opposition against wicked Persecuters , who are seeking to destroy them & us , and imbrue their hands in our blood , according to the true import of the Apologetical Declaration . Which is very rational . Especially considering . 7. These Murderers , who are thus to be prevented , are such whom the Law of God commands to be put to death , and no where allowes to be spared being publick Enemies to God and good men , Open Blasphemers , avowed Idolaters , affronted Adulterers , Notorious Murderers , habitual Tyrants , suppressing Religion , oppressing the Innocent , and professing a trade of destroying the Lords people . Surely if God hath expressly in His Laws provided , that Blasphemers , Idolaters , Murderers &c. should not be suffered to live , He never intended men dayly guilty , yea making profession of these Crimes , should be allowed impunity , either by virtue of their Office , or because there is none in Office to execute Judgement upon them ; but in a case of extreame necessity these Laws will not only allow but oblige people , dayly Murthered by them , for their oun preservation , for vindication of Religion , for purging the Land of such wickedness , for turning away the wrath of God , to prevent their prosecuting their Murdering designs any further , and put a stop to their persecution by puting an end to their wicked lives . Seeing , as Buchannan sayes de jure Regni , It is expressly commanded to cut off wickedness & wicked men , without any exception of rank or degree , and yet in no place of Sacred Scripture are Tyrants more spared than private persons . Much less their bloody Emissaries . Now seeing all these Cases of Killing I have collected , are justifyable in Scripture , and none of the Sufferers upon this Head whom I am vindicating , have exceeded in principle or practice the amount of these Assertions , What is said already may have some weight to demur a censorious condemnation of them . But as the True Non-Conformist well observes , in answer to Dial. 7. pag. 391. Seeing the consideration resulting from the Concurrence of all circumstances , whereupon the right dignoscing of such deeds when actually existent doth mostly depend , doth more contribute to the clearing & passing a judgement on a case of this nature , when the whole contexture is exposed to certain examination , than to set doun general rules directive of such practices ( which yet will all justify this in question ) Therefore to clear the case further , all may be resolved into this State of the Question . Whether or not private persons , incessantly pursued unto death , and threatened with ineluctable destruction by Tyrants and their Emissaries , May , to save themselves from their violence in case of extreame Necessity , put forth their hand to execute righteous Judgement upon the Chief & principal Ringleaders , Instruments , & Promoters of all these destructive Mischiefs & Miseries , Who are open & avowed Enemies to God , Apostates , Blasphemers , Idolaters , Tyrants , Traitors , Notorious Incendiaries , Atrocious Murderers , and known and convict to be publick Enemies , prosecuting their Murdering Designs notourly & habitually , and therefore guilty of death by all Laws of God & man ; And in such an extraordinary case , put them to death who have de jure forefeited their lives to Justice , when there is no access to publick Justice , nor prospect of obtaining it in an orderly way , nor any probability of escaping their intended destruction , either by flight or resistence , if they be past longer unpunished ; And so deliver themselves from their Murdering Tyranny , while they are under no acknowledged subjection to them , nor at peace with them , but maintaining a defensive resistence against them ; And in this extraordinary execution of Justice , being not chargable with ignorance of matters of fact so manifest , nor mistake of circumstances so palpable , nor with malice rage or revenge against their persons for private & particular injuries , nor with Enthusiastick Impulses pretended as their Rule , nor with deceit or Treacherie in the manner , nor with any breach of relation or obligation , nor Usurpation upon or prejudice to any Lawful Right whatsoever in the matter , nor with any selfish or sinistrous ends in the design ; But forced to performe this Work of Judgement , when there is none other to do it , out of zeal for the Glory of God , Care of the Countries good , love to their Brethren , sense of their oun Danger , & Respect to Justice ; to the end , that by the removal of these wicked Destroyers , their war against the prevailing faction of their Malignant Enemies may be more successfully maintained , their Religion , Lives , Laws , & Liberties more securely defended , their Brethren rescued , their Murder prevented , Impietie suppressed , the Land cleansed from blood , and the wrath of God averted ; That this is the true State of the Question , the preceeding Assertions all comprehended here do make it evident . To which I answer in the Affirmative . And shall come to give my Reasons . Secondly , Then I shall offer some Reasons for this , first from some grounds & Hypotheses of Reason : Then more expressly from Scripture proofs . I. There may be some Arguments offered from the Dictates of natural reason . Which I shall but only glance at . 1. I premit the Consideration of the Practice of all Nations , even such from whom Patterns have been taken for Government , and who have had the most polite & purest Policy , and have been the severest Animadverters upon all Extravagants & Transgressers of their vocation : Yet even among them , for private persons to destroy and rid the Common-wealth of such burdens , and vile vermine so pernicious to it , was thought a virtue meriting rather Commendation , than a thing to be Condemned . I shall not here instance the laudable practices recorded in Scripture : These may be seen in their oun place . Neither do I speak of ruder Nations , among whom this is a rel●ct of reason , not of ruderness : as the Oriental Indians have a Custome , whenever any person runs a muck , that is , in a revengeful fury takes such a quantity of Opium , as distracts them into such a rage of mad animosity , that they fear not to assault ( which is the common operation of that potion there ) and go through destroying whom they can find in their way : Then every man Armes against him : and is ambitious of the honour of first killing him : which is very rational , for otherwise no man could be safe ; and it seems to be as rational , to take the same Course with our mad Malignant mucks , who are drunk with hellish fury , and are runing in a rage to destroy the people of God whom they can meet with . But all the Nations where the best Policy was established , have been of this mind . In Greece publick rewards were enacted to be given , and honours appointed by several Cities , to those that should kill Tyrants , from the mightiest of them to the meanest ; with whom they thought there was no bond of humanity to be kept . Hence Thebe is usually commended for killing her husband , Timoleon for killing his Brother , because they were pernicious & destructive to the Common-wealth : which , thô it seem not justifyable , because of the breach of relation of natural subjection , yet it shewes what sentiments the most politick Nations have had of this practice . As also among the Romans , Cassius is commended for killing his son , and Fulvius for killing his oun son going to Catiline , and Brutus for killing his kinsmen having understood they had conspired to introduce Tyranny again . Servilius Ahalas is commended for killing even in the Court Sp. Melius , turning his back and refusing to compear in judgement , and for this was never judged guilty of bloodshed , but thought nobilitate by the slaughter of a Tyrant , and all posterity did affirme the same . Cicero , speaking of the slaughter of Cesar , stiles it a famous & divine fact , & positum ad imitandum . Sulpitius Asper , being asked , why he had combined with others against Nero , and thought to have killed him ? made this bold reply , that he knew not any other way to put a stop to his villanies , and redeem the world from the infection of his example , and the evils which it groaned under by reason of his crimes . On the contrary , Domitius Corbulo is reprehended by all , for neglecting the safety of mankind , in not puting an end to Nero's Cruelty , when he might very easily have done it : And not only was he by the Romans reprehended but by Tyridates the Persian King , being not at all afrayed lest it should afterward befall an example unto himself . When the Ministers of Cajus Caligula , a most cruel Tyrant , were with the like crueltie tumultuating for the slaughter of their Master , requiring them that killed him to be punished , Valerius Asiaticus the Senator cried out aloud , I wish I had killed him , and thereby both composed their clamour & stopt their rage . For there is so great force in an honest deed ( saith Buchannan de jure Regni , relating this passage ) that the very lightest shew thereof , being presented to the minds of men , the most furious assaults are allyed , and fury will languish , and madness it self mu●t acknowledge the soveraignity of reason . The Senate of Rome did often approve the fact , thô done without their order oftentimes by private hands : As upon the slaughter of Commodus , in stead of revenging it , they decreed that his Carcass should be exposed and torn in pieces . Sometimes they ordered before hand to have it done ; As when they condemned Didimus Iulianus , they sent a Tribune to slay him in the Palace : Nay they have gone so far , as in some cases to appoint reward for such as should kill those Tyrants that trampled upon their Laws , and murdered virtuous & innocent people ; As that sentence of the Senate against the two Maximim doth witness , qui cos occiderit proe●ium merebitur . Buchannan ubi supra , rehearsing many instances of this nature , gives reasons of their approvableness . And these I find here and there scattered , in his book de jure Regni . 1. They that make a prey of the Common-wealth , are not joined to us by any civil bond or tye of humanity , but should be accounted the most Capital enemies of God and of all men . 2. They are not to be counted as within humane societie , but transgressors of the limits thereof ; Which who so will not enter into , and contain himself within , should be taken & treated as wolve● , or other kinds of noysome beasts , which whosoever spares he preserves them to his oun destruction , and of others , and whosoever killeth doth not only good to himself , but to all others , and therefore doth merit rather reward than to be condemned for it . For if any man , divested of humanity , should degenerate into such Crueltie , as he would not meet with other men but for their destruction ) as the Monsters I am speaking of could meet with none of the party here treated on , but to this effect ) he is not to be called a man , no more than Satyres , Apes , or Bears . 3. It is expressly Commanded to cut off , wickedness & wicked men , without any exception of rank or degree : And if Kings would abandon the Counsells of wicked men , and measure their greatness rather by duties of virtue , than by the impunity of evil deeds ; they would not be grived for the punishment of Tyrants , nor think that Royal Majestie is lessened by their destruction , but rather be glad that it is purged from such a stain of wickedness . 4. What is here to be reprehended ? is it the cause of their punishment ? that is palpable : Is it the Law which adjudges them to punishment ? All Laws were desired as necessary for repressing Tyrants ; whosoever doth condemn this must likewise condemn all the Laws of Nations : Is it the person executing the Laws ? where will any other be found to doe it , in such circumstances . 5. A Lawful war being once undertaken with an enemy for a just cause , it is Lawful not only for the whole people to kill that enemy , But for every one of them : every one therefore may kill a Tyrant , who is a publick enemy , with whom all good men have a perpetual war-fare . Meaning , if he be habitually Tyrannical , and destructive to the people , so that there is no living for good people for him : Otherwise , thô a man by force or fraud acquire Soveraignity , no such violence is to be done to him , providing he use a moderate way in his Government , such as Vespasian among the Romans ; Hiero in Syracuse . 6. Treason cannot be committed against one who destroyes all Laws and Liberties of the people , and is a pernicious plague to the Common-wealth . 2. Such is the force of this Truth in the case circumstantiate ; that it extorts the acknowledgment of the Greatest Authors , Ancient & Modern , Domestick & Forreign , and even of all rational Royalists , ( as Mr Mitchel sayes in his Post-script to the forecited letter ) that it is Lawful for any private person to kill a Tyrant sine titulo and to kill Tories or open Murderers as devouring beasts , because the good of his Action doth not only redound to the person himself , but to the whole Common-wealth , and the person acting incurs the danger himself alone . Tertulltan , though a man loyal to excess , sayes , Every man is a souldier enrolled to bear Armes against all Traitors & publick Enemies . The Ancient Ecclesiastical Historian , Sozomene , relating the death of Iulian , and intimating that he was supposed to have been slain by a Christian souldier , addes , Let none be so rash as to condemn the person that did it , considering he was ●us couragious in behalf of God & Religion . Sozom. Hist. Lib. 6. cap. 2. Barcla●us , a great Royalist , saith , Tyrannos ut hostes publ●s , non solum ab universo populo , sed a singulis etiam , impeti caedique jure optimo posse , tota Antiquitas ceasuit . That Tyrants as publick Enemies may be attacqued , and Lawfully slain , not only by all the people but every one of them , all Antiquity judged . Grotiue de jure be●i Lib. 1. cap. 4. saith , 〈◊〉 & cui juris gentium requisita non adsint , imperium arripuerit , ●●que pactio u●a sequuta sit , aut fides illi data , sed sola vi re●●●tur possessio , videtur manere bellis jus ; ac proinde 〈◊〉 eum 〈◊〉 quod in hostem licet , qui a quolibet , etiam pri●ato jure , po●est interfici . Yea King Iames the 6. in his R●m●●strancs for the right of Kings , sayes , The publick Laws makes it Lawful and free for any private person to enterprize against an Usurper . Divines say the same . Chamier Tom. 2. Lib. 15. cap. 12. Sect. 19. Cives omnes jus habent insurgendi contra Tyrannos . Aisted . Theolog. Gas. cap. 17. reg . 9. pag. 321. Tyrannum absque Titulo , qui est invasor , quilibet pr. vatus potest & debet ● medio tollere , quia patriam hostiliter invadit . And cap. 18. reg . 14. pag. 332. Licitum est privato cuivis occidere Tyrannum , qui injuste invadit Dominium . But Dr Ames . de Cons●tentia Lib. 5. cap. 31. de homicidio quest . 4. asserts all that is here pleaded for in terminis Quest. 4. An aliquando licet occidere hominem Authoritate privata ? Resp. Aliquando licet occidere nulla publica Cognitione precedente , sed tum solum , quando causa evidenter postulat ut hoc siat , & Authoritas publica non potest implorari : In isthoc enim casu , privatus publice Minister constituitur , tam n●●tu Dei , quam omnium hominum consensu . He propones the question : If sometimes it be Lawful to kill a man by private Authority ? He answers , It is sometimes Lawful to kill another without publick Cognition , proceeding , but then only when the cause doth evidently require it that it be done , and publick Authority cannot be implored ; for in that case any private man is constitute in stead of a publick Minister of Justice , both by Gods allowance , and by the consent of all men . These propositions carry such evidence in them , that the Authors thought it superfluous to confirme them , and sufficient to affirme them . And from any reason that can be adduced to prove any of these Assertions , it will be as evident that this Truth I plead for is thereby confirmed , as that it self is thereby strengthened . For it will follow natively , if Tyrants and Tyrants sine titulo , be to be thus dealt with ; then the Monsters of whom the question is , those Notorious Incendiaries and Murdering publick Enemies , are also to be so served : For either these Authors assert the Lawfulness of so treating Tyrants sine titulo , because they are Tyrants , or because they want a title : If the first be said ; Then all Tyrants are to be so served ; and reason would say , and Royalists will subscribe , if Tyrants that call themselves Kings may be so animadverted upon , because of their perniciousness to the Common-wealth by their Usurped Authority , then the subordinate firebrands that are tho immediate instruments of that destruction , the inferior emissaries that act it and actually accomplish it in Murdering innocent people , may be so treated ; for their persons are not more sacred than the other , nor more impunible : If the second be said , it is Lawful to kill them because they want a title ; Then it is either because they want a pretended title , or because they want a real & Lawful one : The Latter is as good as none , and it is proved Head. 2. Arg. 7. that no Tyrants can have any : The former can not be said , for all Tyrants will pretend some , at least before they be killed . 3. But thô some of these Great Authors neither give their reasons for what they assert , nor do they extend it to all Tyrants that Tyrannise by virtue of their pretended Authority , yet it will not be difficult to prove , that all great & small that murder , destroy , and Tyrannise over poor people , are to be punished , though they pretend Authority for what they do . And hence , If all Tyrants , Murderers , & Destroyers of mankind ought to be punished ; then when it cannot be done by publick Authority , it may be done by private : But all Tyrants , Murderers , & Destroyers of mankind , ought to be punished : Ergo — The Minor is manifest from the General Commands of shedding the blood of every man that sheds● it Gen. 9. 6. of puting to death whosoever killeth any person Numb . 35. 30 , 31. of respecting no mans person in Iudgement Deut. 1. 17. and universally all penal Laws are general without exception of any , for under that reduplication of criminal transgressing those Laws , under that general Sanction , they are to be judged ; which admits of no partial respect : for if the greatest of men be Murderers , they are not to be considered as great , but as Murderers ; just as the meanest are not to be considered as mean or poor , but as Murderers . But I need not insist on this , being sufficiently proved Head. 2. Arg. 9. And through out that Head , proving that Tyrants can have no Authority . And , if they have no Authority , then Authority ( which they have not ) cannot exempt them from punishment . The Connexion of the Major Proposition may be thus urged : When this Judgement cannot be executed by publick Authority , either it must be done by private Authority in case of extreame necessity , or not at all : for there is no Medium but either to do it by publick Authority , or private : If not at all , Then the Land must remain still defiled with blood , and cannot be cleansed Numb . 35. 33. Then the fierce anger of the Lord cannot be averted Numb . 25. 4. for without this executing of Judgement , He will not turn it away Ier. 5. 1. Then must Murderers be encouraged by their impunity to make havock of all according to their Lust , besides that poor Handful who cannot eschape being their prey , as their Case is circumstantiate . Besides , this is point blank contrary to these General Commands , which say peremptorely , The Murderer shall be put to death , but this supposed Case when publick Authority will not or cannot put them to death , sayes , they shall not be put to death . In this Case then I demand , whether their impunity is necessary , because they must not be put to death ? or because they cannot be put to death ? To say the Latter , were an untruth : for private persons can do it , when they get access , which is possible : If the former , then it is clearly contradictory to the Commands , which say , they must be put to death , excepting no Case , but when they cannot be put to death . If it be said , they must not be put to death , because the Law obliges only publick Authority to execute Judgement . To this I reply . 1. I trust to make the Contrary appear from Scripture and by . 2. If the Law obliges none but those in publick Authority to execute Judgement , then when there is no Judgement execute , it must be the sin of non but those in publick Authority : And if it be only their sin , now comes others to be threatened & punished for this , that Judgement is not executed ? if they must only stand by and be spectators of their omissions unconcerned , What shall they do to evite this wrath ? Shall they exhort them ? or witness against them , But that more than all this is required is proved before several times , where this Argument of peoples being punished for the sin of their Rulers hath been touched . 3. Then when there is no Authority , it must be no sin at all that Judgement is not executed , because it is the sin of none : it can not be sin , except it be the sin of some . 4. What if those in publick Authority be the Murderers ? who shall put them do death ? By what Authority shall Judgement be execute upon them ? Whither publick or private ? publick it cannot be : for there is no formal publick Authority above the Supreame , who are supposed the party to be punished : If it be by the radical Authority of the people , which is the thing we plead for , then it is but private , as that of one party against another : The people are the party grieved , and so cannot be Judges : At best then this will be extrajudicial executing of Judgement . And if the people may do it upon the Greatest of Tyrants , then a part of them who are in greatest hazard may save themselves from those of Lesser Note , by puting them to death : for if all the people have right to punish Universal Tyrants , because they are destroyers of all ; then a part hath right to punish particular Tyrants , because they are destroyers of them , when they cannot have access to publick Authority , nor the concurrence of the whole body . 4. Let these Murderers & Incendiaries be considered , either as a part of the Community with them whom they murder & destroy , or not : If they be a part , and do belong to the same Community ( which is not granted in this case , yet let it be given ) Then when the safety of the whole or better part , cannot consist with the sparing or preserving of a single man , especially such an one as prejudges all and destroyes that better part ; he is rather to be cut off , than the whole or the better part be endangered : for the cutting off of a Contagious Member that destroyes the rest of the body , is well warranted by Nature , because the safety of the whole is to be preferred to the safety of a part , especially a destructive part : But now who shall cut it off ? since it must be cut off , otherwise a greater part of the body will be presently consumed , and the whole endangered . It is sure the Phisicians duty : but what if he will not ? or can not ? or there be no Phisician ? then any that can may & must : yea one member may in that case cut off another . So when either the Magistrate will not , or dare not , or does not , or there is none to do this necessary work of Justice , for the preservation of the Community ; any member of it may rather prevent the destruction of the whole , or a greater part , by destroying the Murdering & destructive Member , than suffer himself & others to be unavoidably destroyed by his being spared . If they be not within , or belonging to that Societie , then they may be dealt with & carried towards as publick Enemies & Strangers , and all advantages may be taken of them in cases of necessity , as men would do if invaded by Turks or Tartars . 5. Let it be considered , what men might have done in such a case before Government was erected , if there had been some publick & notour Murderers still preying upon some sort of men . Certainly then private persons ( as all are in that case ) might kill them to prevent further destruction . Hence if this was Lawful before Government was established , it cannot be unlawful when people cannot have the benefit of the Government ; when the Government that is , instead of giving redress to the grieved & oppressed , does allow & impower them to destroy them : otherwise people might be better without Government than with it , for then they might prevent their Murderers by cutting them off . But so it is that this was Lawful before Government was established . For let it be adverted , that the Scripture seems to insinuate such a Case before the flood . Cain , after he Murdered his brother , feared that every man that found him should slay him Gen. 4. 14. If he had reason to fear this , as certainly he had , if the Lord had not removed that by proroguing the execution of vengeance upon him , for his greater punishment and the worlds more Lasting instruction , and by seting a mark upon him , and inhibiting under a severe threatening any to touch him ; Then either every man that should have killed him was the Magistrate ( which were ridiculous ) or every man was every & any private person universally , which might have killed him if this inhibition had not past upon it . Anisworth upon the place sayes , that among the ancient Romans every one might kill without a challenge , any man that was Cursed for some publick Crime , and cites Dyonis . Halicarnas . L. 2. And so Cain spoke this from a dictate of Nature and a guilty Conscience . 6. At the Erection of Government , thô the people resign the formal power of life & death and punishing Criminals over to the Governour , Constitute by them ; yet as they retain the radical power & right virtually , So when either the Magistrats neglects their duty of vindicating the innocent and punishing their destroyers , or impowers Murderers to prey upon them ; In that case they may resume the exercise of it to destroy their destroyers , when there is no other way of preventing or escaping their destructions : because extremis morbis extrema remedia . In an extraordinary exigent , when Ahab & Iezebel did undo the Church of God , Elias with the peoples help killed all Baals Priests against and without the Kings will , in this case its evident the people resumed their power , as Lex Rex saith Quest. 9 , Pag. 63. There must be a Court of Necessity , no less than a Court of Justice , when it is in this extremity as if they had no Ruler , as that same Learned Author sayeth Quest. 24. Pag. 213. If then the people may resume that power in cases of necessity which they resigned to the Magistrate ; then a part may resume it , when a part only is in that necessity , and all may claim an interest in the Resumption , that had an interest in the Resignation . 7. Especially upon the dissolution of a Government , when people are under a necessity to revolt from it , and so are reduced to their primeve Liberty , they may then resume all that power they had before the resignation , and exert it in extraordinary exigents of necessity . If then a people that have no Magistrats at all may take order with their destroyers , then must they have the same power under a Lawful revolt . As the ten tribes , if they had not exceeded in severity against Adoram R●h●boams Collector , had just cause to take order with that Usurpers Emissarie , if he came to oppress them : But if he had come to Murder them , then certainly it was duty to put him to death , and could not be censured at all , as it is not , in the Historie 1 King. 12. 18. But so it is that the people pursued by these Murderers , some of which in their extreame exigences they put to death ; have for these several years maintained a declared Revolt from the present Government , and have denyed all subjection to it upon the grounds vindicated Head. 2. And therefore they must be considered as reduced to their primeve Liberty , and their pursuers as their publick Enemies , to whom they are no otherwise related than if they were Turks , whom none will deny it Lawful to kill , if they invade the Land to destroy the inhabitants . 8. Hence , seeing they are no other than publick Enemies , unjustly invading , pursuing , and seeking them to destroy them ; what Arguments will prove the Lawfulness of Resistance , and the necessity of self Defence , in tutelâ vitae proximà , will also prove the Lawfulness of taking all advantages upon them , in tutelâ remotà ▪ for if it be Lawful to kill an enemy in his immediat assault , to prevent his killing of them when there is no other way of preserving themselves from his fury ; Then it must be Lawful also , in his remote but still incessant pursuit , to prevent his Murdering them by killing him , when the●e is no other way to escape in a case of extreame necessity . But that this was the Case of that poor people , Witnesses can best prove it ; And I dare appeal to two sorts of them that know it best , that is , all the pursuers , and all the pursued . 9. This is founded , and followes upon the 4 Art. of the Solemn League & Covenant : Where we are bound with all faithfulness to endeavour , the discovery of all such as have been or shall be Incendiaries , Malignants , or evil Instruments — that they may be brought to publick trial & receive condign punishment . Now as this obliges to the orderly & ordinary way of prosecuting them , when there is access to publick Judicatories : so when there is none , Either this Article obliges to no endeavour at all ( which cannot be , for it is Moral duty to endeavour the punishment of such ) or else it must oblige to this extraordinary Action & execution of Judgement , if to any at all . Especially considering , how in the sense of the short comings of this duty , it is renewed in the Solemn Acknowledgment of sins & Engagement to duties That we shall be so far from conniving at Malignity , injustice , &c. that we shall — take a more effectual Course , than heretofore , in our respective Places & Callings , for punishing & suppressing these evils — Certainly we were called to one way of prosecuting this obligation then , when it was first engaged into , and to another now , when our Capacity & Circumstances are so materially & formally altered : if the effectual Course then , was by publick Authority ; then now when that is wanting , there must be some obligation to take some effectual Course still , that may suit our Places & Callings , which will certainly comprehend this extraordinary way of suppressing those-evils , by preventing their growth in curbing the Instruments & executing Judgement upon them , in a case of extreame Necessity , which will suit with all Places & all Callings . II. From the Scriptures , these Arguments are offered . First , Some approven Examples , and imitable in the like Circumstances , will clear & confirm the Lawfulness of this extraordinary Work of Judgement executed by private persons , upon notorious Incendiaries , firebrands , & Murderers , guilty of death by the Law of God. 1. Moses spyed an Egyptian smiting an Hebrew one of his Brethren , and he looked this way and that way , and when he saw that there was no man , he slew the Egyptian and hid him in the sand . Exod. 2. 11 , 12. Here 's an uncondemned Example : whereof the Actor who was the Relator did not condemn himself , thô he condems himself for faults that seem less odious ; yea in effect he is rather commended by Stephen the Martyr Act. 7. And thô it be extraordinary , in that it was done by private Authority , not by a Judge , as it was objected to him the second day : yet it was not unimitable ; Because that Action , thô Heroical , whereof the ground was ordinary , the Rule Moral , the Circumstances commonly incident , the managment directed by humane prudence , cannot be unimitable : But such was this Action , thô Heroical . The ground was ordinary , spying his Brother in hazard , whose Murder he would have prevented . The Rule was Moral , being according to that Moral precept of rescuing our Brother in hazard Prov. 24. 11 , 12. The Circumstances were incident in a case of extreame necessity , which he managed very prudently , looking this way & that way , and hiding him in the sand . Therefore it may be imitated in the like Case . It signifies nothing to say that he was moved by the Spirit of God thereto : for unto every righteous performance , the motion of the Spirit of God is requisite . This Impulse that Moses had and others aftermentioned , was nothing but a greater measure of that assisting Grace , which the extraordinariness of the case and the difficulties therein occurring did call for ; but the intervening of such motions , do not alter the Rule , so as to make the action unimitable . Impulses are not the Rule of duty , either under an ordinary or extraordinary exigence ; but when they are subsequent & subservient both to the Rule of duty ▪ and to a mans call in his present circumstances , they clearly determine to the species of an Heroick Enterprise ; in so much that it is not only the particular deed that we are to heed for our imitation , but we are to emulate the Grace & Principle of zeal which produced it , and is thereby so conspicuously relucent for our upstirring to acts in like manner , as God may give opportunity As is observed by the True Non-conformist Dial. 7. Pag. 392. &c. 2. When Israel Joyned himself unto Baal-Peor , the Lord said unto Moses , take all the heads of the people , and hang them up before the Lord against the Sun , that the fierce Anger of the Lord may be turned away from Israel . And Moses said unto the Judges , slay every one his men that were joyned unto Baal-Peor . And when Zimri brought the Medianitish Cozbi , in the sight of Moses , and in the sight of all the Congregat●on , who were weeping before the door of the Tabernacle ; And when Phinehas . saw it , he rose up — and took a javelin in his hand , and he went after the man of Israel , into the Tent , and thrust both of them through — So the Plague was stayed — And the Lord spake unto Moses , saying , Phinehas hath turned my wrath away from the Children of Israel , while he was zealous for my sake among them — I give unto him my Covenant of Peace — because he was zealous for his God , and made an atonement for the Children of Israel Numb . 25. 3 — 13. This Action is here much commended , and recorded to his commendation Psal. 106. 30 , 31. Then stood up Phinehas & executed Iudgement and so the Plague was stayed and that was counted unto him for righteousness unto all generations that is — in justitiam facti coram hominibus , qui alios potuissent hoc factum pessime interpretari , tanquam temerarium , intempesti●um , a privato contra Magistratum patratum , crudele nimis ab negatum poenitentiae spatium , Deus tamen aestimavit tanquam insigniter justum . Pool Synops. Critic . in Locum . It is certain , this Action was some way extraordinary ; because Phinehas was not a Magistrate , nor one of the Judges whom Moses commanded to slay every one his men vers 5. Otherwise , if this had been only an ordinary execution of Judgement by the Authority of Moses , Phinehas his Action would not have been so much taken notice of , nor so signally rewarded ; but here it is noted as a singular act of zeal , which it could not have been , if it was only an ordinary execution of the Magistrats command : yet thô this action was signally Heroical , proceeding from a Principle of pure zeal for God , and prompted by a powerful motion of the Spirit of God to that extraordinary execution of Judgement : It is notwithstanding imitable in the like Circumstances . For , the matter is ordinary , being neither preternatural nor supernatural , but just & necessary . The end was ordinary , to turn away the wrath of God , which all were obliged to endeavour . The principle was ordinary , ( thô at the time he had an extraordinary measure of it ) being zealous for the Lord , as all were obliged to be . The rule was ordinary , to wit , the Command of slaying every man that was joined to Baal-Peor vers . 5. only this was extraordinary , that the zeal of God called him to this Heroical Action , thô he was not a magistrate , in this extraordinary exigent , to avert the wrath of God ; which was neither by Moses his command , no● by the Judges their obedience , turned away , onely by Phinehas's act of another nature , and his zeal appearing therein & prompting him thereto , the Lord was appease● & the plague stayed . In which fervour of zeal , transporting him to the omission off the ordinary solemnities of Judgement , the Spirit of the Lord places the righteousness & praise of the Action . Yet the same Call & Motion of zeal might have impowered others to do the like : the Text speaks of no other Call he had , but that of zeal vers . 11 , 12 , 13. ye● another was obliged to do the same , upon the ground of that Moral Command Deut. 13. 6 — 9. having the ground of Gods ordinary Judgement , which commandeth the Idolater to die the death , and therefore to be imitate of all that prefer the true honour & Glory of God to the affection of flesh & wicked Princes , as Mr Knox affirmeth in his conference with Lithingtoun , rehearsed before Per. 3. Further , let it be inquired , what makes it unimitable ? Certainly it was not so , because he had the motion & direction of Gods Spirit ; for men have that to all duties . It was not , because he was raised & stired up of God to do it , for God may raise up Spirits to imitable actions . It was not , because he had an extraordinary Call , for men have an extraordinary Call to imitable actions , as the Apostles had to Preach . We grant these Actions are extraordinary & unimitable ; which , first , do deviate from the rule of com ; mon virtue , and transcend all rules of common reason & Divine Word ; but this was not such , but an heroick Act of zeal & fortitude : Next these Actions , which are contrary to a Moral ordinary Command are unimitable , as the Israelites robbing the Egyptians , borrowing & not paying again , Abrahams offering his son Isaac ; but this was not such : Next those Actions , which are done upon some special Mandate of God , and are not within the compass of ordinary obedience to the ordinary rule ; are unimitable ; but this is not such : As also Miraculous Actions , and such as are done by the extraordinary inspiration of the Spirit of God , as Elias his killing the Captains with their fifties by fire from Heaven ; but none can reckon this among these . See Ius populi at length discussing this point , and pleading for the imitableness of this Action cap. 20. If therefore the Lord did not only raise up this Phinehas to that particular act of Justice , but also warrant & accept him therein & reward him therefore , upon the account of his zeal , when there was a Godly & zealous Magistrate , able , and whom we cannot without breach of charity presume , but also willing to execute Justice , how much more may it be pleaded , that the Lord , who is the same yesterday , to day & for ever , will not only pour out of that same Spirit upon others , but also when He gives it , both allow them , thô they be but private persons , & also call them , being otherwise in a Physical & Probable Capacity , to do these things in an extreamely necessi●ous and otherwise irrecoverable state of the Church , to which in a more intire condition He doth not call them ? And particularly , when there is not only the like or worse provocations , the like necessity of execution of Justice & of Reformation , for the turning away of wrath & removing of Judgments , that was in Phinehas's case ; but also , when the Supreme Civil Magistrate , the Primores regni & other inferiour Rulers , are not only unwilling to do their duty , but so far corrupted & perverted , that they are become the Authors & Patronizers of these abominations Naph . Prior Edit . Pag. 23. 3. When the Children of Israel served Eglon the King of Moab , and they cried unto the Lord , He raised them up a Deliverer , Ehud the son of Gera , who made a dagger , & brought a present unto Eglon , and put forth his left hand , and took the dagger from his right thigh , and thrust it into his belly Iudg. 3. 21. That this Action was approven will not be doubted , since the Lord raised him up as a Deliverer , who by this Heroical Action commented it , and since it was a Message from God. And that it was extraordinary were ridiculous to deny , for sure this was not the judicial Action of a Magistrate : Neither was Ehud a Magistrate at this time , but only the Messenger of the people sent with a present . Yet it is imitable in the like case , as from hence many grave Authors concluded the Lawfulness of killing a Tyrant without a Title . 4. When the Lord discomfi●ed the host of Iabin , and Sisera his Captain fled into the house of Heber the Kenite , Iael Hebers wife took a nail of the tent , and went softly ●nto him , and smote the nail into his temples Iudg. 4. 21. Of which the Prophetess Deborah sayes , chap. 5. 24. blessed above wemen shall Iael the wife of Heber the Kenite be , blessed shall she be above women in the tent . Yet not only was Iael no Magistrate , but in subjection to & at peace with Iabin , thô she killed his Captain . But , nulla hic erat in●ustitia , cum declaratus esset hostis publicu● , justum erat Bellum , Oppressor erat Populi Dei ; debebat Iael , quasi membrum reipublicae ; communem hostem prodere & perdere . Itaque peccasset Iahel si eum non occidisset . Martyr & al●i cirati in Pool . Synops. Critic . in Locum , Albeit that Author himself , in his English Annotations , does cut the knot in stead of loosing it , in denying Deborahs Song to be Divinely inspired in its first composure , but only recorded as a History by Divine inspiration , as other Historical Passages not approven , only because this Heroick fact of Iael is there commended ; which is too bold an attempt upon this part of the holy Canon of the Scripture : Whence we see , what inconveniences they are driven to , that deny this principle of natural Justice the Lawfulness of cutting off publick Enemies to procure the Deliverance of the Lords people . Hence , if it be Lawful for private persons , under subjection to and at peace with the publick Enemies of the Lords people , to take all advantages to break their yoke , and deliver the oppressed from their bondage , by killing their Oppressors ; it must be much more Lawful , for such as acknowledge no such subjection nor aggreement , to attempt the same in extreame necessity : But the former is true : Therefor the later . 5. When Samson married the Timnite , and obliged himself by compact , to give them thirty sheets and thirty change of garmentts , upon their solving his riddle : The Spirit of the Lord came upon him , and he went doun to A●hkelon , and slew thirty men of them and took their Spoyl Iud. 14. 19. And afterwards , when he lost his wife by the crueltie & treacherie of those Philistines , he said unto them , Though yow have done this , yet will I be avenged of yow , and after that I will cease , and he smote them hip & thigh with a great slaughter chap. 15. 7 , 8. And wen the Iewes , who acknowledged the Philistims for Rulers , 〈◊〉 to Et●m to expostulate with him , all the satisfaction he gave them was to avouch , that as they did unto him so he had done unto them● and to kill a thousand more of them vers . 11. &c. These were extraordinary Heroick facts , not only because they flowed from an extraordinary power wherewith he was endued , and from an extraordinary Motion & Call , but because of his avenging his oun private injuries for the publick good , in a way both of fortitude & prudence , without a declared war , provoking the enemies against himself , and diverting from the people and converting against himself all their fury , in which also he acted as a Type of Christ ; and also because he acted not as a Magistrate at this time , for by whom was he called or counted a Magistrate ? not by the Philistines , nor by the men of Iudah , for they tell him that the Philistines , were their Lords , and they bound him and delivered him up to them : Yet in his private Capacity , in that extraordinary exigence , he avenged himself and his Country against his publick enemies , by a Clandestine war : which is imitable in the like case , when a prevailing faction of Murdering enemies domineer over & destroy the people of God , and there is no other way to be delivered from them : for his ground was Moral , because they were publick enemis to whom he might do as they did to him . Hence , If Saints sometimes in cases of necessity may do unto their publick enemies as they have done unto them , in prosecuting a war not declared against them ; then much more may they do so in cases of necessity , to deliver themselves from their Murdering violence , when a war is declared : But here is an example of the former : Ergo — 6. When these same Philistims again invaded and overran the Land in the time of Saul , Ionathan his son and his Armour-bearer fell upon the Garrison of these uncircumcised , and killed them 1 Sam. 14. 6 , 13. This was an Heroick Action , without publick Authority , for he told not his father vers 1. And singular indeed , in respect of the effect , and were a tempting of the Lord for so few to assault such a multitude , as it were to imitate Sams●n in his Exploits : but in this respect , these Actions are only unimitable in consideration of prudence , not of Conscience , or as to the Lawfulness of the thing : their ground was Moral , to cut off publick enemies . Hence , If it be Lawful to fall upon a Garrison of publick enemies , oppressing the Country , then it must be Lawful to fall upon one or two , that are the Ring-leaders of publick Enemies , and main promoters of their destruction , that are as pernicious , and have no more right or power , than the Philistims : But such is the Case of those about whom the question is . 7. When David dwelt in the Country of the Philistims , he and his men went up & invaded the Gesharites and the Gezrites and the Amalekites : And David smote the Land , and left neither man nor woman alive 1 Sam. 27. 8 , 9. This was without publick Authority , having none from Saul , none from Achish in whose Country he dwelt , and none of his oun , being no Magistrate . We deny not the Divine motion , but plead that it is imitable from its Moral ground , which was that Command to cut off the Amalekites Exod. 17. and the Amorites whose relicts these Nations were ; the same Ground that Saul the Magistrate had to destroy them . Whence it is Lawful sometimes for others than Magistrates to do that which is incumbent to Magistrates , when they neglect their duty . All I plead for from it , is , If it be Lawful for private persons , upon the Call of God , to cut off their publick enemies , when they are obliged by the Command of God to destroy them , thô they be living quietly & peacably in the Country ; then may it be Lawful , in cases of necessity , for private persons , to cut off their publick enemies , whom they are obliged by the Covenant of God to bring to condign punishment , and to exstirpate them ( as the Covenant obliges in reference to Malignant Incendiaries ) when they are ravening like Lyons for their prey . 8. In the dayes of Ahab & Iezebels Tyranny , whereby the Idolatrous Prophets of Baal were not punished according to the Law , Elijah said unto the people , take the Prophets of . Baal , let none of them escape ; and they took them to the brook Kishon & slew them there 1 King. 18. 40. How Mr Knox improved this passage we heard before , in the Historical Representation Per. 3. And Ius Pop : vindicates it , that in some cases private persons may execute Judgement on Malefactors , after the example of Elias here . Which fact Peter , Martyr in Loc. defendeth thus [ I say it was done by the Law of God : for Deut. 18. 20. God decerned that the false Prophet should die , and chap. 17. the same is said of private men & women , who would worship Idols : But chap. 13. not only is death threatened against a seducing Prophet , but a Command is added that no man should spare his Brethren — thirdly it is Commanded , that the whole City when it becometh Idolatrous , should be cut off by fire , & sword : And Levit. 24 , 14 — 16. it is Statute , that the Blasphemer should not live , to which we may adde the Law or equity of Taliation ; for these Prophets of Baal caused Iezebel & Ahab kill the Servants of the Lord. See Ius Pop. cap. 20. Pag. 425. Upon this also Mr Mitchel defends his fact ubi supra — Also Elijah by virtue of that precept ( Deut. 13 ) gave commandment to the people to destroy Baals priests , contrary to the command of the seducing Magistrate , who was not only remiss & negligent in executing Justice , but became a Protector & defender of the Seducers , then & in that case I suppose the Christians duty not to be very dark : 9. This Idolatrous & Tyrannical house was afterwards condignly punished by I●hu 2 King. 9. And 10 chapt . who destroyed all the Idolaters , who were before encouraged & protected by that Court chap. 10. 25. This extraordinary fact was not justified by his Magistratical Authority : for that was as extraordinary as the fact it self ; and conferred as a mean to accomplish the fact . He had no Authority by the peoples suffrages , nor was he acknowledged as such by the Court or body of the people , only the Lord gave it extraordinarly . But it is not the imitation of his assumption of Authority that is here pleaded for , but the imitation of his fact in extraordinary cases , when not only Tyrants & Idolaters pass unpunished , but their insolency in Murdering the Innocent is intolerable . Mr Knox vindicates this at length ubi supra , and shewes that it had the ground of Gods ordinary Judgement , which commands the Idolater to die the death ; And that thô we must not indeed follow extraordinary examples , if the example repugn to the Law , but where it agrees with and is the execution of the Law , an example uncondemned stands for a Command , for God is , constant and will not condemn in ages subsequent what He hath approved in His Servants before . See the Testim . of Period . 3. above , and Ius pop . cap. 20. pag. 418. 10. When Athaliah , the Mother of Ahaziah , had Tyrannized six years , at length Iehojada with others made a Conspiracie against her , to depose her and make Ioash King : which when it was discovered , she cried Treason , Treason , as indeed it would have been so if she had been the Lawful Magistrate ; for it was an attempt of Subjects against her that had the possession of the Soveraign power . But I●●●●da commanded the Captains to have her forth without the ranges , and him that followeth her kill with the sword : And they laid hands on her , and she was slain 2 King. 11. 14 — 16. That this is imitable in the punishment of Tyrants , is cleared above . If therefore it be Lawful for Subjects to kill Usurping Tyrants , and such as follow them to help them , under , whom nevertheless people might have a life ; then it must be Lawful for private persons to put forth their hand against their Cut-throat Em●ssaries , in a case of necessity , when there is no living for them . 11. When Amaziah turned Idolater & Tyrant , after the time that he turned away from following the Lord , they made a Conspiracy against him in Ierusalem , and he fled to Lachish , but they sent to Lachish after him , & slew him there 2 Chron. 25 ▪ 27. This fact is before vindicated by Mr Knox Period 3. afterward Head 2. and Head 5. 12. When Esther made suite to reverse Hamans Letters , the King granted the Iewes in every City , not only to gather themselves together and to stand for their life , but also to destroy , to slay , and to cause to perish , all the power of the people and Province , that would assault them , both litle Ones & Women — and to avenge themselves on their Enemies : And accordingly in the day that their enemies hoped to have power over them , the Iewes gathered themselves to lay hand on such as sought their hurt , and smote all their enemies with the stroke of the sword , Esther 8. 11 , 13. chap. 9. 1 — 5. &c. They had indeed that Law of Nature fortified by the Kings accessory Authority , as Valentin●●● by his Edict granted the like Liberty , to resist any unjust invader to depopulate the Lands of his Subjects , ut digno ilico supplicio subjugetur ac mortem quam ininabatur accipiat — And the like of Arcadius is extant in Codice Iustinaneo , titulo , Quomodo liceat unicuique sine judice se vindicare vel publicam devotionem . But that doth not exclude the Lawfulness of such Resistences in case of necessity , without publick Authority : So here , it was not the Kings commandment that made the Iewes avenging themselves Lawful , if it had not been Lawful before & without it ; it gave them only Liberty to improve that priviledge , which they had from God and Nature . Surely their power of Resisting did not depend on the Kings Commandment , as is proven Head 5. Ergo neither their power of avenging themselves , to prevent their Murder by their enemies : Which they could and were obliged to do , if there had been no such Authority : Ergo it was not only suspended upon the Kings Authority . And as for Hamans sons and adherents , being Agagites , they were obliged by a Prior Command to avenge themselves on them , on all occasions , by that Command to destroy Amalek : Therefore it must be Lawful , even without publick Authority , in some cases of necessity , to prevent the Murder of publick Enemies , by laying hands on them that seek the hurt of all the people of God. Secundly , There are some Precepts from which the same may be concluded . 1. There is a Command , and the first Penal Statute against Murderers , we read Gen. 9. 6. Whoso sheddeth mans blood by man shall his blood be shed . Here the Command is given in general to punish Capitally all Murderers : but there may be some that no Magistrate can punish , who are not here exempted , to wit , they that are in Supreme Authority and turn Murderers , as was said above . Again the Command is given in general to Man , involving all the Community ( where the Murderer is ) in guilt if his blood be not shed : as we find in the Scripture , all the people were threatened & punished because Judgement was not executed , and when it was executed even by these that were no Magistrates , the Wrath of God was turned away , Whereof there are many examples above . Further , if the Command to shed the blood of Murderers be given before the Institution of Magistracy , then in case of necessity to stop the Course of Murderers , it may be obeyed . When there is no Magistrate to execute it : But here it is given before the Institution of Magistracy , when now there was no Government in the world , but family-Government , as Grotius on the place saith , Cum enim lex haec ●ata est , non dum constituta sunt judicia , itaque naturale justaliatus hic indicatur ; quod , aucto humano genere & in gentes distributo , merito solis judicibus permissum fuit , extra casus quosdam exceptos , in quibus mansit jus illud 〈◊〉 . When this Law was given publick Judgement was not yet constitute , Therefore the natural right & Law of Taliation is here held forth , which when mankind was increased and divided into several Nations , was justly permitted only to Judges , some cases excepted in which that primaeve right did remain . And if in any , then in this case in question . Hence Lex Rex answereth the P. Prelate essaying to prove that a Magi●●racy is established in the Text , denyes that Ba Adam , by man , must signify a Magistrate , for than there was but family Government , and cites 〈◊〉 of the same mind , that the Magistrate is not spoken of here . Though this Command afterwards was given to the Magistrate Numb . 35. 30. yet in a ease of necessity , we must recur to the Original Command . 2. This same Command of punishing Murdering Enemies , is even after the Institution of Magistrates , in several cases not astricted to them , but permitted to the people , yea enjoyned to them : As ( 1 ) Not only Magistrates , but the people , are Commanded to avenge themselves on their publick Enemies , as the Israelites , after their being insnared in the matter of Peor ; are Commanded to vexe the Midianites & smite them , because they beguiled them , and brought a Plague upon them Numb 25. 17 , 18 and Numb . 31. 2. to avenge themselves on them , and for this end to arme themselves , and go against them , and avenge the Lord of Midian : Which they executed with the slaughter of all the males . So likewise are they Commanded to destroy Amalek . It is true these Commands are given primarly & principally to Magistrates , as there to Moses , and afterwards to Saul : yet afterwards we find , other than Magistrates upon this Moral Ground , having the Call of God , did execute Judgement upon them , as Gidion & David , before they were Magistrates , did avenge themselves and the Lord upon them , as is before cleared . It is also true , that there was some holy severity then to be extended against particular Nations as such , peculiar to that Dispensation , which is not pleaded as imitable : but the ground was Moral , and the right of a peoples saving themselves by the destruction of their enemies ; when there is no other way for it , is Natural . And this is all we plead for here . If people may vexe their enemies , and avenge themselves against them , even without publick Authority , when ensnared by their Craftiness ; Much more may they put a stop to their insolency , by cutting off their principal & most pernicious Instruments , in case of necessity , when invaded by their Cruelty : But here a people is Commanded to vexe their enemies , and avenge themselves on them , and accordingly Gideon & David did so , without publick Authority , and that upon a ground which is Moral & Natural : Ergo — ( 2 ) The execution of the punishment of Murderers is committed to the people : The revenger of blood himself shall slay the Murderer , what he meeteth him he shall slay him , Numb . 35. 19 , 21. So that if he met him before he got into any Refuge , he might Lawfully slay him , and if he did flee to any , he was to be rendered up to the Avengers hands Deut. 19. 12. that the guilt of innocent blood may be put away from Isra●l vers . 23. This revenger of blood was not the Magistrate : for he was the party pursuing Numb . 35. 24. between whom and the Murderer the Congregation was to judge : He was only the next in blood or kindred . In the Original he is called Goel , the redeemer , or he to whom the right of redemption belongs , and very properly so called , both because he seeks redemption and compensation for the blood of his Brother , and because he redeems the Land from blood guiltiness , in which other-wise it would be involved . I do not plead that this is alwayes to be imitated , as neither it was alwayes practiced in Israel : but If a private man , in a hot pursuit of his Brothers Murderer , might be his avenger , before he could be brought to Judgement , then much more may this power be assumed , in a case of necessity , when there is no Judgement to be expected by Law , and when not only our Brethren have been murdered by them that profess a trade of it , but others also and our selves are dayly in hazard of it , which may be prevented in cutting them off . I do not see what is here meerly Iudicial , so as to be rejected as Iudaical : for sure Murderers must be slain now as well as then , and there is the same hazard of their escaping now as then , Murder involves the Land in guilt now as well as then , and in this case of necessity especially , that Law that gives a man right to preserve himself gives him also right to be his oun avenger , if he cannot otherwise defend himself . ( 3 ) Not only the execution , the decision of matters of life & death , is committed to them ; as in the case of Blasphemie & Cursing , all that heard were to lay their hands upon his head , and all the Congregation was to stone him Levit. 24. 14 , 16. The man-slayer was to stand before the Congregation in Judgement , Then the Congregation shall judge between the slayer and the avenger of blood Numb . 35. 12 , 24. The people claimed the power of life & death , in seeking to execute Judgement upon those that had spoken Treason against Saul , bring the men ( say they ) that we may put them to death 1 Sam. 11. 12. Especially in the case of punishing Tyrants , as they did with Amaziah . Certainly this is not so Judicial or Judaical , as that in no case it may be imitated : for , That can never be abrogated altogether which in many cases is absolutely necessary ; but that the people , without publick Authority , should take the power of life & death , & of puting a stop to the insolency of Destroyers by puting them to death , is in many cases absolutely necessary ; for without this they cannot preserye themselves against Grassant Tyrants , nor the fury of publick enemies or fire-brands within themselves , in case they have no publick Authority , or none but such as are on their Destroyers side . ( 4 ) Not only the power of purging the Land , by Divine precept is incumbent on the people , that it may not lye under blood guiltiness ; but also the power of Reforming the Courts of Kings , by taking Course with their wicked Abetters and evil Instruments , is committed to them , with a promise that if this be done , it shall tend to the establishment of their Throne : which is not only a supposition in case it be done , but a supposed Precept to do it , with an insinuation of the necessity & expediency of it , that it is as suitable as the taking away of the dross from silver , in order to the production of a vessel Prov. 25. 4 , 5. Take away the wicked from before the King , and his throne shall be established in Righteousness : Which is not only there given to Kings , for then it would be in the second person spoken to them , but to the people to do it before them ; as the people did with Baals Prophets from before Ahab . And Our Progenitors many times have done with wicked Counsellors , as may be seen in the foregoing Representation , and more fully in the Historie of the Dowglasses , and in Knox & Calderwoods Histories . Hence If it be duty to Reforme the Court , and to take away a Kings wicked Sycophants Counsellors , Agents & Instigators to Tyrannie ; Then it must be Lawful , in some cases of necessity , to restrain their Insolency , & repress their Tyrannie , in executing Judgement upon such of them , as are most unsupportable , who are made drunk with the blood of Innocents : But the former is true : Therefore — ( 5 ) For the Omission of the executing of this Judgement on Oppressors & Muderers , involving the whole Land in blood guiltiness , which cannot be expiated but by the blood of them that are so Criminal ; Not only Magistrates , but the whole people have been plagued : As for Sauls murdering the Gibeonites , the whole Land was plagued , until the man that consumed them , and devised against them to destroy them , seven of his sons were delivered unto them , to be hanged up before the Lord 2 Sam. 21. 5 , 6. So also for the sins of Manasseh . The reason was , because if the Magistrate would not execute Judgement , the people should have done it : for not only to the King , but also to his Servants , and to the people that entered in by the gates , the Command is , Execute yee Iudgement , and deliver the spoyled out of the hand of the Oppressor Jer. 22. 2 , 3. thô it be true , this is to be done by every one in their station , salvâ justitia , salvo ordine , & pro modulo vocationis , and it chiefly belongs to Judges & Magistrates : Yet this is no wrong to Justice , nor breach of Order , nor sinful transgression of peoples vocation , not only to hinder the shedding of innocent blood , to prevent Gods executing of what He there threatens , but also to execute Judgement on the Shedders , to prevent their progress in Murdering Villanie ; when Inferiour as well as Superiour Magistrates are oppressing & Tyrannizing : Therefore this seeking & doing & executing judgement is so often required of the people , in such a Case , when Princes are rebellious & Companions of Thieves , and in the City where Judgement used to be , now Murderers bear sway Isai. 1. 17 , 21. the Lord is displeased where there is none Isai. 59. 15 , 16. Jer. 5. 1. See this vindicated in Lex Rex quest . 34. pag. 367. and in jus popul . cap. 10. pag. 237. 3. That Command concluds the same against Idolaters , Apostates , and Entycers thereunto Deut. 13. 6. &c. If thy brother — or thy friend , which is as thi● oun soul , entyce the secretly , saying , let us go & serve other gods — thow shalt not spare nor conceal him , but thow shalt surely kill him — because the hath sought to thrust thee away from the Lord thy God — And all Israel shall hear & fear and do no more any such wickedness . And vers . 13. &c. If thow shalt hear say in one of thy Cities — saying , Certain men , the Children of Belial , are gone out — and have withdrawn the Inhabitants of their City , saying , let us go to serve other gods — Then shalt thow enquire — and behold if it be truth , and the thing certain — thow shalt surely smite the Inhabitants of that City with the edge of the sword , destroying it utterly — This Cause of the Open Entycers to Idolatry , was not brought to the Judges , as common Idolaters , and such who were entyced to serve other gods & worship them , were to be brought to the gates , and to be stoned first by the hands of the Witnesses , and afterwards by all the people Deut. 17. 3 , 5 , 7. But this is another Law : Of which the Iewish Antiquaries , and particularly Grotius out of Philo and the Rabb . in Loc saith , Cum in alijs criminibus soleret reus servari &c. i. e. Whereas in other crimes the guilty used to be kept after the sentence a night & a day , that if he could say any more for himself he might , these were excepted from this benefit ; And not only so , but it was permitted to any to execute Judgement upon them ( viz. Entycers to Idolatry ) without waiting for a Judge : The like was used against the Sacrilegious Robbers of the Temple , and priests who sacrificed when they were polluted , and those who cursed God by the Name of an Idol , and those who lay with an Idolatress , chiefly those who denyed the divine Authority of the Law : And this behoved to be before the people , at least ten , which in Hebrew they called Hheda — Neither is this to be admired in so grievous a Crime , when even the manslayer without the place of refuge might have been killed by the Kins-man of the defunct , And upon Numb . 15. 30. the punishment of presumptuous Blasphemers , he sayes , Caeteram hic intelligenda hoc modo &c. i. e. But here these are to be understood thus , that the guilty shall not be brought to the Judges , but be killed by them that deprehended them in the Crime , as Phin. has did to Zimri : and proves it out of Mamonides Pool . Synops. Critic . in Loc. And it must be so : for in this case no mention is made either of Judges , or Witnesses , or further Judgement about it , than that he that was tempted by the Entycer should fall upon him , and let the people know it , that they might lay hands on him also ; otherwise evil men might pretend such a thing when it was not true . But in case of a Cities Apostasie , and hearkening to Entycers , the thing was only to be sollicitously enquired unto , and then thô it was chiefly incumbent upon the Magistrate to punish it , yet it was not astricted to him , but that the people might do it without him . As upon this Moral Ground , was Israels war stated against Benjamin Judg. 20. 13. when there was no King nor Judge , and also when there were Kings that turned Idolaters & Tyrants , they served them so , as here is Commanded : Witness Amaziah , as is shewed above . Hence not only Moses , upon the peoples defection into Idolatrie in the Wilderness , commanded all on the Lords side , every man to put his sword by his side — and s●ay every man his brother and every man his Companion and every man his neighbour , whereby three thousand fell at that time by the sword of the Levites Exod. 32. 27 , 28. But also Joash , Gideons father , upon the same Moral Ground , thô he was no Magistrate , could say to the Abiezrites , Will ye plead for Baal — he that will plead for him , let him be put to death while it is yet morning — Judg. 6. 31. Moreover ( as Mr Mitchel adduces the example very pertinently , we see that the people of Israel destroyed Idolatry , not only in Judah wherein the King concurred , but in Ephraim and in Manass●h , where the King himself was an Idolater ; and albeit they were but private persons , without publick Authority : for what all the people was bound to do by the Law of God , every one was bound to do it to the uttermost of his power & Capacity . Mr Mitchel offers this place to vindicate his fact of shooting at the prelate . Deut. 13. 9. Wherein ( sayes he ) it is manifest , that the Idolater or intycer to Worship a false god , is to be put to death by the hand of those whom he seeks to turn away from the Lord : Which precept I humbly take to be Moral , and not meerly Iudicial , and that it is not at all Ceremonial or Levitical . And as every Moral precept is Universal , as to the extent of place , so also as to the extent of Time , & persons . The chief thing Objected here is , that this is a Judicial precept , peculiarly suited to the Old Dispensation ; which to plead for as a Rule under the New Testament , would favour of Jewish rigidity inconsistent with a Gospel Spirit . Ans. How Mr Knox refells this , and clears that the Command here is given to all the people , needs not be here repeated ; but it were sufficient to read it in the foregoing Representation Period . 3. Pag. 30. as it is also cited by Ius Pop. Pag. 212. &c. But these General Truths may be added , concerning the Iudicial Laws . 1. None can say that none of the Judicial Laws , concerning political Constitutions , is to be observed in the New Testament : for then many special Rules of Natural & Necessary equity would be rejected , which are contained in the Judicial Laws of God : Yea all the Laws of equity in the World would be so cast ; for none can be instanced , which may not be reduced to some of the Judicial Laws : And if any of them are to be observed , certainly these Penal Statutes , so necessary for the preservation of Policies , must be binding . 2. If we take not our measures from the Judicial Laws of God , we shall have no Laws for punishment of any Malefactors by death , juris Divini , in the New Testament . And so all Capital punishments must be only humane Constitutions ; and consequently they must be all Murders : for to take away the life of man , except for such Causes as the Lord of our life ( to whose Arbitriment it is only subject ) hath not approven , is Murder , as Dr Ames saith de homocidio Conscience . Lib. 5. cap. 31. quest . 2. For in the New Testament , thô in the general the power of punishing is given to the Magistrate , yet it is no where determined , neither what , nor how Crimes are to be punished . If therefore Penal Laws must be taken from the Old Testament ; the Subject of executing them , as well as the Object , must be thence deduced , that is , what is there astricted to the Magistrate must be so still , and what is permitted to the people must remain in like manner their Priviledge ; since it is certain , the New Testament-Liberty is not more restricted as to Penal Laws than the Old. 3. Those Judicial Laws , which had either somewhat Typical , or Paedagogical , or peculiar to the then Iudacial State , are indeed not binding to us under that formality ; thô even these Doctrinally are very useful , in so far as in their general nature , of equity of proportion , they exhibite to us some Documents of Duty : But those Penal Judgements , which in the matter of them are appended to the Moral Law , and are in effect but accurate determinations & accommodations of the Law of Nature , which may suit our Circumstances as well as the Jewes , do oblige us as well as them . And such are these Penal Statutes I adduce ; for , that Blasphemy , Murder , & Idolatry , are heinous Crimes , and that they are to be punished , the Law of Nature dictates ; and how , and by whom , in several cases , they are to be punished , the Law judicial determines . Concerning the Moral equity even of the strictest of them , Amesius de Conscienc . lib. 5. de Mosaicis appendicibus praeceptorum , doth very learnedly assert their binding force . 4. Those Judicial Laws , which are but Positive in their forme , yet if their special internal & proper Reason & Ground be Moral , which pertains to all Nations , which is necessary & useful to Mankind , which is rooted in and may be fortified by humane reason , and as to the substance of them approven by the more intelligent Heathens ; those are Moral , and oblige all Christians as well as Jewes : And such are these Laws of punishing Idolaters &c. founded upon Moral grounds , pertaining to all Nations necessary & useful to Mankind , rooted in & fortified by humane Reason , to wit , that the Wrath of God may be averted , and that all may hear & fear and do no more so wickedly ; especially if this Reason be superadded , when the case is such , that innocent & honest people cannot be preserved , if such wicked persons be not taken order with . 5. Those Judicial Laws , which being given by the Lords immediate Authority , thô not so solemnly as the Moral Decalogue , are neither as to their end Mortuae , dead , nor as to their use Mortiferae , deadly , nor as to their nature , Indifferent , nor in any peculiar respect restringible only to the Jewes , but the transgressions whereof both by omission & commission are still sins , and were never abolished neither Formally nor Consequentially in the New Testament , must be Moral : But such as these Penal Laws I am speaking of , They cannot be reputed among the Ceremonial Laws , dead as to their end , and deadly as to their use , or indifferent in their nature : for sure , to punish the Innocent upon the account of these Crimes , were still sin , now as well as under the Old Testament ; and not to punish the Guilty , were likewise sin now as well as then . If then the matter be Moral and not abolished , the execution of it by private persons , in some cases when there is no access to publick Authority , must be Lawful also . Or if it be Indifferent , that which is in its oun nature Indifferent , cannot be in a case of extreame necessity unlawful , when otherwise the destruction of our selves & Brethren is in all humane consideration inevitable . That which God hath once Commanded , and never expressly Forbidden , cannot be unlawful in extraordinary cases , but such are these precepts we speak of : Therefore they cannot be in every case unlawful . Concerning this case of the obligation of Judicial Laws , Ames . de Conscienc . lib. 5. cap. 1. quest . 9. 6. Those Laws which are predicted to be observed & executed in the New Testament times , cannot be Judicial or Judaical , restricted to the Old : But such is this . In the day , that a fountain shall be opened for th● house of David for sin & for uncleaness ; which clearly points at Gospel-times , It is said , the Lord will cause the Proph●ts and the unclean Spirits to pass out of the Land : And it shall come to pass . that when any shall yet Prophesie , then his father & his mother that begat him shall say unto him , thow shalt not live — and shall thrust him through when he Prophesieth Zech. 13. 3. Which cannot be meant of a Spiritual penetration of the heart : for it is said , he shall not live ; and the wounds of such as might escape , by resistence or flight , are visible in his hands vers 6. It is therefore to be understood of Corporal killing Intycers to Idolatrie , according to the Law Deut. 13. 9. either by delivering them up to the Judges , as Piscator on the place sayes ; Or as Grotius saith , transfodient ut Phineas Zimri Numb . 25. hoc intellige de Pseudo-propheta populum volente abducere ad cultum falsorum deorum ; nam in tales quemvis Iudaeum Lex armabat , Deut. 13. quae Lex expresse addit , in tali crimine nec filio parcendum . From all which I conclude , If people are to bring to condign punishment Idolatrous Apostates , seeking to intyce them ; Then may oppressed people , dayly in hazard of the death of their Souls by Complyance ; or of their bodys by their Constancy in Duty , put forth their hand to execute Judgement , in case of necessity , upon Idolatrous Apostates & Incendiaries , and the principal Murdering Emissaries of Tyrants , that seek to destroy people , or enforce them to the same Apostasie : But the former is true : Therefore &c. 4. The same may be inferred from that Command of Rescuing & Delivering our Brother , when in hazard of his life ; for omitting which duty . no pretence even of ignorance will excuse us Prov. 24. 11 , 12. If thow forbear to deliver them that are drawen unto death , and those that are ready to be slain , if thow sayest , behold we knew it not ; doth not He that pondereth the heart consider it ? and He that keepeth thy Soul doth not He know it , and shall not He render to every man according to his works ? eripe h. e. ex manu invasoris , latronis , injusti Magistratus &c. idque vel manu , vel lingua defendente , vel quovis alio modo licito : Solent homines multas excusationes nectere , se nescire illius vel periculum , vel innocentiam , non tanta authoritate valere ut eum liberent , rerum suarum satagere , alienis nolle se ingerere &c. hic unam excusationem reliquas omnes complectentem exempli causâ proponit , & refellit : as Commentators say , Pool Synops. Critic . in locum . This precept is indefinitely given to all : Principally indeed belonging to righteous Magistrates ; But in case of their omission , And if instead of detending them they be the persons that draw or send out their destroying Emissaries to draw them to death , then the precept is no more to be restricted to them , than that vers 2. not to be envious against evil men , or that vers 10. If thow faint in the day of Adversity thy strength is small , can be said to be spoken only to Magistrates . Hence , If it be a Duty to Rescue our Brethren from any prevailing power that would take their lives unjustly , and no pretence even of ignorance will excuse the forbearance of it ; Then it must be Lawful , in some extraordinary cases , to prevent the Murdering violence of publick Incendiaries , by killing them rather than to suffer our selves or our Brethren to be killed , when there is no other way in probability either of saving our selves or Rescuing them : But here the former is Commanded as a duty : Therefore the Later also must be justified , when the duty cannot otherwise be discharged . Now having thus at some length endeavoured to discuss this some way odd & esteemed odious Head : to which Task I have been as unwillingly drawn , as the Actors here pleaded for were driven to the occasion thereof ; whom only the necessity of danger did force to such Atchievements to preserve their oun and Brethrens lives , in prosecuting the Cause ; and nothing but the necessity of duty , did force me to this Undertaking , to defend their Name from Reproach , and the Cause from Calumnies . I shall Conclude with a humble Protestation , that what I have said be not stretched further than my obvious & declared Design doth aim at : which is not to press a practice from these precedents , but to vindicate a Scripture Truth from invidious or ignorant Obloquies ; and not to specify what may or must be done in such Cases hereafter , but to justify what hath been done in such Circumstances before . Wherein I acknowledge , that thô the Truth be certain , such things may be done , yet the duty is most difficult to be done with Approbation . Such is the fury of corrupt passion , far more fierce in all than the pure zeal of God is to be found fervent in any , that too much Caution , Tenderness , & Fear , can scarce be adhibite , in a Subject wherein even the most warrantable provocation of holy zeal is ordinarly attended with such a concurrence of Self-interest and other carnal Tentations , as it is impossible without the signal Assistance of special Grace to have its exercise in any notable Measure or Manner , without the Mixture of sinful allay , as the True Non-conformist doth truly observe ubi supra Pag. 391. Yet this Doctrine , thô in its defined and uncautioned Latitude be obnoxious to accidental abuses ( as all Doctrines may be abused by mens corruption , or ignorance ; misapplying the same ) is nevertheless built upon such Foundations , that Religion will oune to be firme , and Reason will ratify their force . And I hope it is here so circumscribed with Scripture-boundaries , and restricted in the narrow Circumstantiation of the Case , that as the Ungodly cannot captate advantage from it , to encourage themselves in their Murdering villanies , seeing they never were , never can be so Circumstantiate , as the Exigence here defined requires ; So as for the Godly , I may presume upon their tenderness , and the Conduct of that Spirit that is promised to lead them , and the zeal they have for the honour of Holiness , with which all real Cruelty is inconsistent , to promise in their Name , that if their Enemies will repent of their wickedness , and so far at least Reforme themselves as to surcease from their cruel Murdering violence , in persecuting them to the death , and devouring them as a prey ; then they shall not need to fear from them the danger of this Doctrine , but as saith the proverb of the Ancients , Wickedness proceedeth from the Wicked but their hand shall not be upon them . But if they shall still proceed to Murder the Innocent , they must understand , they that hold this Truth in Theorie , will also reduce it to practice . And bloody Papists must know , that Christians now are more Men , than either stupidly to surrender their throats to their Murdering swords , or supinely to suffer their villanie to pass unpunished ; and thô their favours have flattered many , and their sury hath forced others , into a faint succumbing & superceding from all Action against them ; Yet all are not asleep : and I hope there are some , who will never enter in any terms of peace with them , against whom the Mediator hath declared and will prosecute a war for ever , but will still oune & aim at this , as the highest pitch of their ambition , to be found among His chosen , called , & faithful ones , who maintain a constant opposition against them . However , thô the Lord seems in His providence , to put a bar upon all publick Appearances under a display of open war against them ; and it is not the design of what is said here on this and the foregoing Head , to incite or invite to any : Yet Certainly , even at this present , all that have the zeal of God and love to His righteous Cause rightly stated in their hearts , will find themselves called not to supercede altogether from all Actions , of avowed and even violent opposition against them , whom we are all bound both by the Morality of the duty , and the Formality of Solemn & Sacred Covenants , to hold out from a violent intrusion into and peaceable possession of this Land devoted to God , and to put them out when they are got in either by their fraud or force ; And this plea , now brought to an end , will oblige all the Loyal Lovers of Christ , to an Endeavour of these . 1. To take Alarms , and to be fore-warned and fore-armed , resolute & ready to withstand the invasion of Poperie ; that it be neither established by Law , through the supineness of such , who should stand in the Gap , and resolve rather to be sacrificed in the spot , by a valiant resisting , than see such an Abomination set up again ; Nor introduced by this Liberty , through the wyles of such , whose chiefest principle of policy is perfidie , who design by this wide Gate , and in the womb of the wooden horse of this Toleration , to bring it in peaceably ; Nor intruded by force & fury , fire & sword , if they shall fall upon their old game of Murders & Massacres . It concerns all to be upon their Guard , and not only to come out of Babylon , but to be making ready to go against it , when the Lord shall give the Call. 2. To resist the beginings of their Invasions , before they be past remeady : And for this effect , to oppose their gradual erections of their Idolatrous Monuments , and not suffer them to set up the Idol of the Mass , in City or Country ; without attempting , if they have any force , to overthrow the same . 3. In the mean time , to defend themselves and the Gospel , against all their Assaults , and to Rescue any out of their hands upon all occasions , that for the Cause of Christ they have caught as a prey , & to oppose & prevent their oun & the Nations ruine & slaverie . But to Conclude : As it will be now expected , in Justice & Charity , that all the Vassals & Votaries ; Subjects and Servants , of the One Common Lord & King , Christ Jesus , every where through out His Dominions , who may see this Representation of the case and Vindication of the cause of a poor wasted & wounded , persecuted & reproached , Remnant of the now declining , sometimes Renouned , Church of Scotland , will be so far from standing Esaw-like on the other side ; either as Enemies , rejoicing to look on their Affliction in the day of their Calamity ; or as Neutral , unconcerned with their distressed Condition ; or as Strangers , without the knowledge or sense of their Sorrowes & Difficulties ; Or as Gallio's caring for none of these things , or thinking their case not worthy of Compassion , or their cause of Consideration , or possibly condemning their Sufferings , as at best but Stated upon slender , subtile , & nice Points , that are odd & odious , and invidiously represented : It is now expected , I say , that Christians , not possessed with Prejudice ( which is very improper for any that bear that Holy & honourable Signature ) and not willing to be imposed upon by Misinformations , will be so far from that Unchristian temper towards them , as to be easily byassed with all Reports & Reproaches to their disadvantage , that if they weigh what is in this Treatise offered , and truly I may say candidely Represented , without any design of prevarication , or painting , or daubing , to make the Matter either better or worse than it will seem to any impartial Observer ; they will admit & intertain a more charitable Construction of them , and not deny them Brotherly Sympathie and Christian Compassion , nor be wanting in the duty of Prayer & Suppltcation for them , that at length the Lord would turn His hand upon the litle Ones , and bring at least a thrid Part , a Remnant of Mourners , through the fire . So to that litle Flock , the poor of the Flock , that wait upon the Lord , and desire to keep His way ; I shall only say , Though I judged Necessity was laid upon me , in stead of a better , to essay this Vindication of your cause : as stated betwixt yow and your , and your Lords Enemies , the men that now ride over your heads , that say to your Soul , bow doun that we may go over yow , I desire not that yow should , yea I obtest that yow may not , lay any Stress on the strength of what I have said ; but let its weight lie where it must be laid , on that firm Foundation , that will bear yow and it both , that Stone , that tried Stone , that Precious Corner Stone , that sure Foundation , Christ Jesus : And search the Scriptures of Truth , to see whether these things be so or not : And I doubt not , but by that Touchstone if these Precious Truths be tried , they will be found neither hay nor stubble , that cannot abide the fire , but as silver tried in a furnace of earth purified seven times . Do not offend , that they are contemned as small , and contradicted as odious , but look to the importance of His Glory , whose Truths & Concerns they are , and from Whom they are seeking to draw or drive yow , who oppose and oppugu these Truths . Stand fast therefore in the Liberty where with Christ hath made yow free , and hold fast every Word of His patience , that yow may be kept in this hour of tentation . Let no man take your Crown , or pull yow doun from your excellency , which is alwayes the design of your wicked Enemies , in all their several shapes & shewes , both of force & fraud , craft & cruelty . Beware of their snares , and of their tender Mercies , for they are cruel ; and when they speak fair beleeve them not , for there are seven abominations in their hearts . Say ye not a Confederacy , to all them to whom this people shall say a Confederacy , neither fear ye their fear , nor be afraied ; Sanctify the Lord of Hosts Himself , and let Him be your fear , and let Him be your dread , And He shall be for a Sanctuary , but for a stone of stumbling and for a rock of offence , to both the houses of Israel , for a gin & for a snare to the Inhabitants of Ierusalem . Wait upon the Lord , who hideth His face from the House of Iacob , and look for Him , among His Children , though now yow be reputed for signs & wonders in Israel , from the Lord of Hosts Which dwelleth in Mount Zion . Who knowes , but therefore will the Lord wait , that He may be Gracious unto yow , and therefore will He be exalted that He may have Mercy upon yow , for the Lord is a God of Judgement , Blessed are all they that wait for Him. To Whom be all the Glory . AMEN . FINIS . ERRATA . Pag : Lin : 26 6 for way read may . 34 14 f. bloodh r. blood . ibid. ult . r. Governours . 36 35 f. he r. the. 52 5 r. hinted . 70 38 f. at r. a. 75 32 r. accursed . 76 27 r. thought . 94 33 next Christians r. this being . 103 30 r. Elogium . 147 29 r. ruines . 169 31 f. may r. way . 174 17 r. humble . ibid. 25 f. mast r. most . ibid. ult . f. tune r. time . 203 8 r. Tyranny . 209 27 r. Christ. 220 7 f. them r. then . 267 18 f. them r. then . 284 23 f. servas r. servos . 286 3 f. upon d. up an . ibid. 20 r. subjects . ibid. 35 f. amittitis r. amittit is . 343 27 f. at r. as . 345 4 f. as r. us . 374 15 r. Israel . 381 36 f. he r. the. 385 7 f. 27. r. 25. 389 23 f. way r. may . 390 16 f. 137. r. 136. 397 19 f. & r. an . ibid. 31. f. ehe r. the. 432 1 f. ar r. or . 433 ult . f. ars r. are . 435 17 f. trust r. thrust . 451 36 r. Jehojachin . 456 28 f. not odiously r. notoriously . 467 25 f. stealing his r. his stealing , 494 43 f. divine r. divines . 542 24 r. if there be any thing here . 551 8 f. by r. be . 563 28 r. afterwards . 598 6 dele . in . 612 35 r. Kingdoms . 641 4. wo r. who . 662 35 f. proceeding r. preceeding . Besyds these , in some places for Incendaries read Incendiaries , also there are some other escapes as an s for an f , an e for an c , an u for an n , or the like , and some others in the pointing which will not mar the sense , and it s hoped the discreet Reader will readiely excuse . Having come to a conclusion of the six heads proposed to be treated of ; I Judged it conduceing by way of postscript to subjoin a Seventh , in vindication of these consciencious and truely tender sufferers , who in the dread and aw of the holy , Soveraigne & Supreme Law-giver , who commandeth his subjects and followers to abstain from all appearance of evill , did in obedience to him and his Royall Law , choose rather to suffer the rage , robberies & violence of Crwel and bloody enemies , togither with Censurs , reproaches , obloquies & contempt of appostatiseing professors , than to give any aid or encowragement to the avowed and declared enemies of Christ , that might contribute to the promoveing their Sacrilegious Tyrannicall and hellish projects & practices , calculat & prosecut against the Gospel and Kingdome of Christ , the Covenanted reformed Religion of the Church , the Rights , Laws and Liberties of the people , and to the Introduceing of Antichristian Idolatrie , Tyrannie & Slaverie , by paying any of their wicked & wickedly imposed exactions , raised for furthering their hellish designes , of which , none who payes them can be Innocent . HEAD . VII . The Sufferings of many , for Refusing to pay the wicked Exactions of the Cess , Locality , Fynes &c. Vindicated . IT will possibly seem impertinent , or at least preposterous at such a time , when the pressure of these ●urdens is not more pinching to the Generality of professing people , and in such a retrograde order , as after the discussion of the foregoing Heads , to subjoyne any disquisition of these Questions , which are now out of date and doors with many . But considering that the Impositions of these Burdens are still pressing to some and the difficulties of doubts & disputes about them still pusling , the sin & scandal of complying with them still lying upon the Land , not confessed nor forsaken , the leaven of such Doctrine as daubs & defends the like complyance still intertained , the Sufferings of the Faithful for refusing them , still contemned & condemned , and the fears & expectations of more snares of that nature , after this fair weather is over , still encreasing , if I may be so happy as to escape impertinencies in the manner of managing this disquisition , I fear not the Censure of the impertinency or needlessness of this Essay . As to the order of it , it was intended to have been put in its proper place among the Negative Heads of Sufferings : But knowing of how litle worth or weight any thing that I can say is with the prejudged , and having a Paper writ by two famous Witnesses of Christ against the Defections of their day , Mr. McWard & Mr. Broun , more fully & largely detecting the iniquity of the Cess ( from which the wickedness of other exactions also may be clearly deduced ) thô at such distance at the writing of the foregoing Heads , that it could not be had in readiness to take its due place , and time would not allow the suspending other things until this should come to hand ; I thought it needful , rather than to omit it altogether , to insert it here . However , thô neither the form of it , being by way of Letter , nor the method adapted to the design of a moving disswasion , nor the length & prolixitie thereof , will suffer it to be here transcribed as it is ; yet to discover what were their sentiments of these things , and what was the Doctrine Preached and Homologated by the most faithful both Ministers and Professors of Scotland , eight or nine years since , how closely continued in by the Contendings of this Reproached Remnant , still persecuted for these things , and how clearly abandoned & resiled from , by their Complying Brethren now at Ease , I shall give a short Transumpt & Compend of their Reasonings ; in a method subservient to my Scope and with Additions necessary for applying their Arguments against the other Exactions here adduced in this Head , and bringing them also under the dint of them , thô not touched by them expressly . I must put altogether , because it would dilate the Treatise already excressed into a bigness , far beyond the boundaries I designed for it , to handle them distinctly ; and their affinity , both as to their fountain , nature , & ends , is such , that what will condemn one of them will condemn all . What and how many & manifold have been the exorbitant Exactions , as the fruits & soments of this crwel Tyranny , that the Godly in our Land , have been groaning under these 27 years , and upon what occasions they have been at diverse times , and in diverse manners & measurs imposed , I need not here relate , the first part of the Treatise doth represent it . The first of these Tyrannical Exactions , were the Fynes for not hearing the Curats , and other parts of Non-conformity ; which , together with paying the Curats stipends , were too universally at first complyed with : But afterwards upon more mature consideration and after clearer discoveries of the Imposers projects & practices , they were scrupled & refused by the more tender . And their Sufferings , upon the account of that Recusancy , have been very great & grievous , to the utter impoverishment & depopulation of many Families , besides the personal Sufferings of many in long Imprisonments , which some chose rather to sustain with patience , than pay the least of those Exactions . Yea , some when ordered to be legally liberate , and set forth out of Prison , choosed rather to be detained still in bondage , than to pay the Iaylour-fees , their Keepers demanded of them . Many other wicked Impositions have been pressed & prosecuted , with great rigor & rage , as Malitia-money , and Locality , for furnishing Souldiers , listed under a banner displayed against Religion & Liberty , with necessary provision , in and for their wicked service ; which of late years have been contended against by the Sufferings of many , and daylie growing a Tryal to moe . But the most impudently insolent of all these Impositions , and that which plainly paraphrases , openly expresses & explains all the rest , calculate for the same ends , was by that wicked Act of Covention , enacted Anno 1678. Declaring very plainly its ends , to levy & maintain forces for suppressing Meetings , and to shew unanimous affection for maintaining the Kings Supremacy established by Law. Or as they represent it in their Act , for continuation of it , Act. 3. Parl. 3. Char. 2. August 20. 1681. Seeing the Convention of Estates holden at Edinburgh in the moneth of Iuly 1678 upon weighty Considerations therein specified , and particularly the great danger the Kingdom was under , by seditious & rebellious Conventicles , and the necessity which then appeared , to encrease the forces , for securing the Government , and suppressing these rebellious Commotions , which were fomented by seditious principles & practices , did therefore humbly & dutifully offer a chearful & unanimous Supplie of 800000 pound Scots — in the space of five years — And the Estates of Parliament now conveened , having taken to consideration , how the dangers from the forsaids Causes do much encrease , in so far as such as are seditiously & rebelliously enclined , do still propogate their pernicious principles , and go on from one degree of rebellion to another , till now at last the horrid villanies of murther , assassination , & avowed rebellion , are ouned , not only as things Lawful , but as obligations from their Religion — Do therefore , in a due sense of their duty of God , to their Sacred Soveraign , and the preservation of themselves and their posterity , of new make an humble , unanimous , chearful , & heartly offer , for themselves , and in name of , and as representing this his Maj. ancient Kingdom , of a continuation of the foresaid Supply , granted by the Convention of Estates ; And that for the space of five years or ten terms successive , begining the first Terms payment at Martin-mas 1683. which yet is to be continued until Martin-mas 1688. Here is a Sample of their wicked Demands , shewing the nature , quality , & tendency of all of them : Wherein we may note . 1. That they continue it upon the same Considerations , upon which it was first granted . 2. That these were , & yet remain to be , the danger of the Meetings of the Lords people for Gospel Ordinances , by them forced into the Fields , which they call Rebellious Conventicles ; and the necessity of securing their Usurpation upon the Prerogatives os Christ , Liberties of His Church , and Priviledges of Mankind ( which they call their Government ) and suppressing the Testimonies for the Interest of Christ ( called by them Rebellious Commotions . ) 3. That their motive of continuing it , was their Considerations of some weak Remainders of former zeal for God , in prosecuting the Testimony for the Interests of Christ , and Principles of the Covenanted Reformatton ( which they call propogating pernicious Principles ) and some weak attempts to oppose & resist their Rebellion against God , and vindicate the Work , & defend the people of God , from the destruction they intended against them , and their Lawful & obliged endeavours to bring the Destroyers & Murderers to condign punishment ( which they call horrid vil●anies of Murder , Assassination , & av●wed Rebellion . ) Here all the Active Appearances of the Lords people , vindicated in the foregoing Heads , are industriously Represented , under these odious & invidious Names , as motives to contribute this Supplie of means to suppress them , and to involve all the Contributers in the guilt of condemning them . 4. That as a Test of their Allegiance unto , & Con●ede●acy with that Execrable Tyrant ( which they call their duty to their Sacred Soveraign ) they enact this as Representatives of the Kingdom , and must be ouned as such by all the payers . 5. That it is the same Cess , that was granted by the Convention of Estates , and the Terme of its continuation is not yet expired . And hence it is manifest , that that Act of Convention , thô its first date be expired , and thereupon many plead for the Lawfulness of paying it now , that formerly scrupled at and witnessed against it , yet is only renewed , revived , & corroberated , and the Exaction continued upon no other basis or bottom but the first State Constitution . Which was , & remains to be a Consumating & Crimson wickedness , the cry whereof reaches Heaven : Since upon the matter it was the setting of a day , betwixt & which ( exceeding the Gadarens wickedness , & short of their Civility ) they did not beseech Christ & His Gospel to be gone out of Scotland , but with armed violence declared , they would with the strong hand drive Him out of His possession ; in order to which their Legions are levied , with a professed Declaration , that having exauctorate the Lords Anointed by Law , and cloathed the Usurper with the spoils of His Honour , they will by force maintain what they have done , and having taken to themselves the House of God in possession , they will sacrifice the Lives , Liberties , & fortunes of all in the Nation , to secure themselves in the peaceable possession of what they have robbed God ; And that there shall not be a Soul left in the Nation , who shall not be slain , shut up , or sold as slaves , who will oune Christ and His Interest . All which they could not , nor cannot accomplish , without the subsidiary Contribution of the peoples help . This is the plain sense of the Act for the Cess ; and , thô not expressed , the tacite & uniforme intention of all the rest . Yet for as monstrous and manifest the wickedness of these designs are , so judicially were the bulk of our Seers plagued with blindness , that many of them were left to plead for the payment of these Impositions ; others , thô they durst not for a world do it themselves , to be silent , and by their silence to encourage & embolden many to such a Complyance ; presuming with themselves , and without furrher enquirie , that the zeal of God , and love to His Glory , and the Souls of their Brethren , would constrain them to speak in so clamant a case , if they did observe any sin in it . Whereby the Universality was involved in the guilt of these things , especially deceived by the patrociny & pleadings of such of late , who formerly witnessed against it . O that it might be given to us to remember Lots wife , turned into a Pillar of Salt , to season us lest the stink of our Destruction , and what may follow upon it , be all that the posterity get for a warning not to tread our paths . As for the few that have suffered upon this Head , they have been so discruciated with perplexities , in their Conflicts with the rage of Enemies , and reproach of Friends , and fear of these snares attending every lot or occupation they could put themselves in , that they have been made to desire death , as their best refuge , and only retreat wherein they may find rest from all these rackings : For in no place could they escape the reach of some of these Impositions , nor the noise of their clamarous Contendings of Arguments that pleaded for it . But some have had more Love to Christ and His Interests , than language to plead for Him , and more resolution to suffer than learning to dispute for His Cause ; And where pure zeal for Christ , and love to His bleeding Interests , in a time when He is crucified afresh , and put to open shame , and the Concurrence of all is required to help forward the War against Him , is in integrity & vigor , it will burn with its flame those knots that it cannot in hast loose ; And chuse rather to lie under the imputation of being zealous without knowledge , than lose or let go such an opportunity of witnessing a good Confession ; yea when it could do no more , expire with an Ichabod in its mouth . But shortly to come to the point . I shall 1. Permit some Concessions . 2. Propose some paralel Questions . 3. Offer some Reasons to clear it . 1. I shall willingly grant in the General , concerning paying of Exactions , Impositions , or Emoluments . 1. They are to be paid to these to whom they are due : As Tribute & Custom is to be paid to the Powers ordained of God , and for this Cause that they are Gods Ministers attending continually upon this very thing Rom. 13. 6 , 7. So Stipends and all outward Encouragments are due to Ministers of the Gospel , who sow Spiritual things and should reap these carnal things 1 Cor. 9. 11 , 12. Fynes also , and all legal Amercements for Delinquencies against just Laws , must be payed , Deut. 22. 19. And whatsoever is due by Law to Officers , appointed by Law for keeping Delinquents in Custody : As all Debts whatsoever . But Tyrants Exactions , enacted & exacted for promoving their wicked designs against Religion & Liberty ; Hirelings Salaries , for encouraging them in their intrusions upon the Church of God ; Arbitrary Impositions of pecuniary punishments for clear Duties ; And extorted hirings , of the subordinate instruments of Persecuters oppressions , are no wise due and cannot be debt , and therefore no equity to pay them . 2. It s Lawful to pay them , when due and debt either by Law or Contract , even thô they should be afterward abused and misimproven to pernicious ends . But these payments for such wicked ends , either particularly specified & expressed in the very Act appointing them , or openly avouched by the Exactors are of another nature , than Impositions fundamentally appointed for the publick good ; and the after misapplication thereof , made by such as are entrusted therewith , is no more imputable unto the Land or Payers , than is the theft of a Collector stealing or running away with the same without making Count or reckoning to Superiours . It is then a foolish thing to say , that former Impositions were peacably payed , thô we saw and were convinced that their use was perverted , and they were used against the good of the Land and Gods people . For no such thing was laid doun as the ground , or declared as the end , of these exactions ; but what fell out was by the personal abuse and perversion of those in power ; which was rheir oun personal fault , and posteriour to the legal engagment and submission to the payment thereof by the Land in their Representatives . 3. It s Lawful to pay them sometimes , even when fundamentally and Originally from the first Constitution of them they were not due , but Illegally or Usurpatively challenged & exacted , if afterwards they were by dedition or voluntary engagment legally submitted unto by the true Representatives . But not so , when they were never either Lawfully enacted , or legally exacted , or voluntarly engaged by the Representatives , except such as represented the enslavement of the Nation , and betrayed the Country , Religion , Liberty , Property , and all precious Interests , and declaredly imposed to further the destruction of all . Nor can any with reason say , that this Case is but like the Case of the people of Israel under the feet of Enemies , paying to them of the fruits of their Ground , as was regrated & lamented by Nehemiah Chap. 9. 36 , 37. For so they must say , the Exactions now in debate are their Redemption-money , and by these they purchase their Liberty of Life & Lands , and oune themselues to be a people under Conquest . And yet they cannot deny , but they are both exacted & payed as Tests of their Allegiance as Subjects , and Badges of their Loyaltie & Obedience . But this is answered before Head 2. Conces . 7. § . 2. Pag. If any should object the practice of Christ , thô otherwise free , yet paying Custom lest He should offend : It is fully solved ibid. Head 2. Conces . 9. Pag. Here it s sufficient to hint ( 1 ) That which made ●hem marvel at His wise Answer was , that He left the Title unstated , and the Claim unresolved , whether it belonged to Cesar or not , and taught them in the general to give nothing to Cesar with prejudice to what was Gods ; which condemns all the Payments we speak of , which are all for carrying on the War against God. ( 2 ) Cesar was no Tyrant nor Usurper at this time , because they had legally submitted themselves unto several Cesars successively before . ( 3 ) It was , lest He should offend : But here it will be evident , that the offence & scandal lyeth upon the other hand , of paying the Exaction : And it is against all Religion to say , that both the doing and refusing to do the same Act , can give offence . But ( 4 ) make the Case like ours , and I doubt not to call it Blasphemy to say , that Christ would have payed , or permitted to pay a Taxation , professedly imposed for levying a War against Him , or banishing Him and His Disciples out of the Land ; Or to fill the mouths of the greedy Pharisees , devouring widowes houses , for their pretence of long Prayers ; Or that He would have payed , or suffered to pay their Extortions , if any had been exacted of Him , or His Disciples , for His Preaching , or working Miracles ; Or if help or hire had been demanded , for encouraging those that rose to stone Him for His good deeds . 4. It is Lawful to pay a part to preserve the whole , when it is extorted only by force & threatenings , and not exacted by Law ; when it is a yeelding only to a lesser suffering , and not a consenting to a Sin to shift suffering . The Objection of a man being seised by a Robber , transacting with him to give him the one half or more to save the rest and his life , commonly made use of to justify the paying of these Impositions , while under the power and at the reverence of such publick Robbers , cannot satisfie in this Case . It is thus far satisfying , that there is a manifest Concession in it , that instead of righteous Rulers , we are under the power , and fallen into the hand of Robbers , from whom we are not able to rise up . But there is no paritie . For to bring it home without halting , and make it speak sense , we must suppose that the Robber , not only requires a part for himself , and a part for his underling Shavers , horse-rubbers &c. but a part upon this declared Account , that he may by that supplie be enabled & furnished with all things necessary , for murdering my Father , Mother , Wife , Children , Kinsmen , & Friends ( all whom he hath now in his power ) yea , and for doing that besides , which is worse than all these put together : Whether then shall I , by giving the Robber that part which he seeks , enable him to do all these mischiefs ? Or by refusing , expose my self to the hazard of being robbed or slain ? Let the Conscience of any man answer this ( for nothing can be here alledged against the paritie as now propounded ) and then I fear not but the Objection shall be found a blaze of empty words , blown away by any breath . But Alas ! will this Tattle of a Robber be found relevant in that day , when the publick Robbers shall be proceeded against by the just Judge ? Let them who think so , think also , they see the Court fenced , and the Judge set , and hear these words sounding in their ears , ye are cursed with a Curse , for ye have robbed Me. even this whole Nation ; And then they are like to lay as litle weight on the Objection , for fear of falling under the weight of the Curse , as I do . 5. It is Lawful Passively by forcible constraint to submit to the execution of such wicked Sentences , as impose these burdens , if it be not by way of Obedience to them : This is suffering and not sinning . Hence it is easie to refell that Objection : If it be Lawful ( which hitherto was never questioned ) for a man , who is sentenced to die , to go to the place of execution , then a man being under the Moral force of a Law , which is equivalent , may pay Cesses , Localities , Fines &c. Ans. 1. Might it not be doubted , whether a mans going upon his oun feet to be execute , had as manifest , and ex natura rei , a tendency , yea & proper Causuality to advance the design of the enemy , and his refusing to go had as clear a Testimony against the Clamant wickedness of their Course , as his refusing to pay their Impositions ; Whether , I say in this case a man might no● , yea ought not to refuse to go to the place of execution . But 2. Whosoever would conclude any thing from it , to give it either life or legs , must make it run thus : Let the order run in this forme ( else there is no paralel , and so no inference ) we appoint all the Opposers of our Course ( that is all the lovers of our Lord Jesus ) whom we have for their Rebellious Randevouzing at Conventicles sentenced as Enemies & Traitors to die , to come and be hanged by virtue of our sentence ; Otherw●se besides the Moral force of the Law , adjudging them to die , we shall use force , and drag them like Dogs to the place of execution ; And in puting us to this Trouble , they shall fall under the reproach , that being sentenced to die , they scrupled forsooth , yea refused to go on their oun legs to the Gibbet . Let this I say be made the Case , which to me is the exact paralel , and their every Child will know what to Answer , or to hiss the Objection as pure ridicule . 3. I suppose the Objection speaks of a righteous & innocent person , who for Righteousness is brought , as a Sheep to the slaughter ( for a Malefactor , who hath lost all right to his life , is not to be understood ) Then to make the Case paralel , it must be taken for granted ( 1 ) There is a publick Law with the penaltie of death statute for the violation thereof . ( 2 ) That the person to be executed , hath not only transgressed that Law , but his disobedience to the Law is notour . ( 3 ) That he is processed and convict of the transgression thereof : Whereupon followes ( 4 ) The Sentence , and then the Execution . Now the Law being wicked , and the man from the fear of God being constrained to disobey the Law , he can in nothing be justly construed Active , but in that disobedience or renitence : But in the whole of what befalls him for this , he being a captive Prisoner , is to be looked upon as passive . Yea the very Act of going to the place of execution in the present Case , howbeit as to its Physical entitie , it is of the same kind with the Executioners Motion that goes along with him , yet in its Moral & Religious being , whence it hath its specification , it s wholly the Suffering of a Captive , Well then , ere any thing can be pleaded from the pretended paritie ; seeing there are Laws , made for paying such Exactions , Cesses , Salaries , & Fynes , for the declared ends of ruining the people & Interests of Christ. It s necessary , in order to a just paralel , that the Law must be ●irst disobeyed . ( 2 ) The disobedience must be notour . ( 3 ) The delinquent must be processed & pursued , as guilty of the transgression , and convicted thereof , whereupon Sentence passeth against him for the breach of the Law. Here I grant all with advantage to the Cause : As in the first Case , so in this , he who is judged guilty of the breach of this wicked Law , and who is sentenced for that violation , ought to suffer patiently the spoiling of his goods , and not to decline suffering , if it were unto blood , striving against this sin . 6. It s Lawful of two evils of Sufferings to chuse the least : where both come in the election , as in the Cases forementioned , and in a mans throwing of his goods over board in a storm : These and the like are deeds in the present exigent voluntary & rational , being upon deliberation & choise , where the least evil is chosen under the notion of good , yea of the best that can be in the present case , and accordingly the will is determined , and meets & closes with its proper object : Or one of them only be proposed to be submitted to , but another lesser evil of suffering is in a mans power to chuse & propose , for purchasing his immunity from a greater ; which is not imposed nor exacted of him , either by a wicked Law , or for wicked ends declared , but voluntarely offered ; As in the Case of parting with some money to a Robber or Murderer to save the life , when he is seeking only the life ; As the ten men that were going to the House of the Lord said unto Ishmael , slay us not for we have treasures in the field , for which he forebare and slew them not Ier. 41. 8. In this a man does nothing , which under such circumstances is not only Lawful ( one of the main ends for which goods are given to him , to wit the preservation of his life , being thereby attained ) but it were a grievous sin , and would conclude him guilty of self-murder , not to make use of such a mean for preservation of his life , which God hath put in his power , and is in the case called for by His Precept . But however force may warrant one to do that , which may be done for shunning a greater evil of loss ; yet it is never sufficient to make one do that which is a greater evil , than all the evil that can be said to be shunned : For the evil shunned is suffering , but the evil done to shun this , is real and active Concurrence , in manner , measure , & method , enjoyned by Law , in strengthening the hands of those who have displayed a banner against all the Lovers of our Lord Jesus Christ ; A manifest chusing of sin to shun suffering , and a saving of life with the prejudice of that in the preservation whereof he should be ready to lay doun all , and be at a point to endure the worst this wicked world can make him suffer , ere he be found guiltie in the matter of a Complyance of that nature . And thô the rod of the wicked should seem to rest on his lot , for his refusal , and he be the object of their rage & revenge , for holding his integritie ; yet he shall be honoured as a faithful Witness , helped to endure as seeing Him who is invisible , and amidst all his sufferings & sorrowes , made to rejoice , in the hope that when God shall lead forth these Workers of iniquity , he shall not be found amongst the Company of these who have turned aside with them into their crooked Courses , and for that shall be overturned & crushed with them , under the Curse that is hovering over their heads , . It s true a man should not cast himself and his family ( which if he provide not for , he is worse than an Infidel ) upon sufferings , either needlessly or doubtfully , when he is not perswaded it is Trurh & Duty he suffers for , and of value sufficient to countervail the loss he may sustain for it . But on the other hand , in the present and all like cases it is highly of the concernment of all men to be careful & circumspectly Cautions , when the Case comes to be stated upon suffering or not suffering , in examining well whether the Course whereby a man shuns suffering● be of God , and not to take Plausibilities for Demonstrations ; seeing the flesh is not only ready to inculcate that Doctrine , spare thy self , but is both witty of invention to plead for what will affourd ease , and as unwilling to listen to what would , if attended unto , expose us to the malice & rage of rigorous enemies : It being alwise more becoming the Professors of the Gospel , and the Followers of our Lord Jesus , who must walk to Heaven bearing His Cross , to abstain at all hazards when the case is doubtful , than to rush forward upon an uncertainty , when it is not evident they have Gods approbation for what they do . Yea suppose a person erred to his oun hurt in the first case , through weakness , yet it will argue much more sincerity & uprightness towards God , and is done with less danger than in the other . And as many as walk according to this Rule , are like to have the Peace of the Israel of God , to compense whatever of trouble or loss they may meet with in the world , when others shall not have this bird of Paradise to sing in their bosome . II. But shunning prolixity , to come neare● the point , because perhaps some may alledge such Cases are not determined in the Scriptures , nor can any Case be found paralel to these under Consideration , from which we may gather the determination thereof ; Which I think indeed hard to find , because in the wickedness of former ages such monstrous Exactions had never a Precedent , for such declared ends , so declaredly impudent . I shall make some Suppositions , and propose some Questions , all of a piece , and some way paralel to this under debate , and leave any Conscience touched with the fear of God to answer . 1. Suppose , when our Lord Iesus and His Disciples were tossed upon the waves by the storm at sea . and he was sleeping , that then Herod or Pilate , or the Chief Rulers had sent peremptory orders to all men , to supply and furnish with such things as he had , the men they imployed , to capacitate them once for all and for ever to sink that floating bottom out of sight ; and that somewhat should be given to the Souldiers engaged in that Enterprise , somewhat to the Pharisees fot perswading them to it , and fynes to be exacted from the Recusants , and Rewards to be given to such as should keep them in Custody that should fall in their hands , either of them that refused to pay the Moyety prescribed , or of such of them as should escape drouning . In this Case would , or durst any of the Lovers of Iesus comply with any of these demands ? and not rather chuse to perish with Him , or in opposition to such wicked attempts ? Now hath not the Lord Jesus , and all the Interest He hath in the Nation , been imbarqued as it were in one bottom , and floating like a wrack in the sea ? And have not these called Rulers in this Land , in their rage against the Lords Anointed , and the handful who adhere to Him , sent their peremptory orders to pay a Cess for sinking His floating Interests ; and to pay the Curats for perswading to it ; and fynes for not concurring in it ; And rewards to Iaylors & others that are appointed to oppress the Recusants ? Who durst concur then in this Complyance , who had love to Christ in exercise , and who had his friends in the same bottom imbarqued ? And besides seeing the Great God had the man of whom this is required , bound with his oun consent , under a Sacred & Solemn Oath , and under the penaltie of never seeing His face , if he do not venture life & fortune to preserve that precious Interest , and all who are embarqued with it from perishing . Shall he notwithstanding of this , give what these enemies to Christ , call for as His Concurrence , to enable them to execute their wicked Contrivance ? Does any man think or dream that the pitiful Plea , of what they call a Moral force , will clear and acquit him before God from the guilt of a Concurrence in this Conspiracie , while in the mean time he furnished whatsoever these Enemies demanded of him with this express Declaro that it was for this Cause exacted , and for this end imposed ? Or can he think to be saved , when they shall be sentenced who with so much deliberation & despight have done this thing ? O let us consider the after reckoning ! And let us not with pretences distinguish our selves into a Defection , or distract our selves into the oblivion of this , that God is righteous to whom the reckoning must be made . 2. Let it be supposed , under Sauls Tyranny , when the Ziphims informed him of Davids hiding himself with them , Or when Doeg informed him of Abimelechs resetting him , That an order had been given forth to all Israel , with this Narrative : Whereas that Rebel David had now openly despised Authority , had been intertained by the Priest , received Goliabs sword from him , and gathered a Company of armed men together , therefore to the end he and his Complices , may be brought to Justice , We ordain all from Dan to Beersheba , to concur either personally in this Expedition against him , or to pay Cess to our standing forces to maintain them in this expedition , or so much to gratify the Ziphims for their kindness , or to furnish Doeg with a sword , to murder the Priests of the Lord. Would any that favoured Davids righteous Cause , have dared to do any of these ? Would these that durst not concur themselves , contribute any encouragment to the Concurers ? Would Sauls Servants that would not fall upon the Priests of the Lord themselves , have given Doeg one of their swords to do it , or money to buy one , if it had been demanded ? To the same purpose , suppose a party comes to a Dissenter , with an express order , and this Narrative , Whereas there is such a Minister , meet with some people , at an execrable Conventicle as they call it ( but in it self the pure Worship of God ) therefore to the end the Minister may be taken & murdered , and the Servants of the Lord for the Countenance they gave him may be brought to the same punishment , they ordain him , for the accomplishing of their design , to furnish that partie with all necessares , or to pay such a summ of money for not concuring with them : Now should he in this case not only forbear to lay doun his life for his brethren , and forbear to deliver them , that are thus drawn unto death on such an account , ( into which forbearance the Great God will make so accurate an inquirie Prov. 24. 11 , 12. as may make us tremble , whether we look backward or forward ) but also furnish according to the tenor of this Order , that partie of the Dragons Legions , in their War against the Prince Michael & His Angels , with supplies , and think to put off the matter and plead innocent with this , that he was under the Moral force of a Law , accompanied with such military force , as if he had refused , they would have taken away all he had & c. ? For this Plea in its full strength , is to do evil that some good may come of it ( no true good ) which brings just damnation Rom. 3. 8. or to chuse sin rather than affliction . 3. What if Manasseh , or other Idolatrous Princes , that sacrificed to Devils , and made Children pass through the fire to Molech , had enacted a Cess , or under severe Impositions of Fynes had commanded all to concur to a solemn Sacrifice of that nature , charging every man against a certain day , to bring in his proportion in order to celebrate the Sacrifice with all its statute solemnities ; Or should have taken a child from every father , and then made a Law that each of these should contribute such a summ , for furnishing with all necessaries , and maintaining these Murderers , whom they had conduced to shed the blood of their innocent Children or sacrifice them to Molech : Could it be expected that any of the Godly would have payed such Exactions , and then have wyped his mouth with the notion of a moral force ? This comes home enough to our Case : For no sacrifice they can offer to the Devil , can be more real or so acceptable , as what they declare they intend to do ; being so direct , not only an opposition to the coming of the Kingdom of Christ , but the deletion of His precious Interests , and exstirpation of His faithful Remnant , and the giving Satan such an absolute Dominion in the Nation , as that they who have made the decree , and all who put it in execution , practically declare thereby they have mancipate themselves to his slavery , and sold themselves to work wickedness , in the sight of the Lord : So likewise , that all the rest of the Nation , may with themselves become his vassals , and in evidence of their opposition to Christ , and in recognition of Satans Soveraignity & their subjection , they are appointed to pay these black Meales . 4. Let it be supposed , that after Nebuchadnezzar had made the decree , for all to fall doun & worship his Image , and the three Children were apprehended for refusing it , he had made another , that all the Jewes especially should contribute , every one a Faggot , or money to buy it , to heat the furnace , or a rope to lead them to it : Can any man suppose , that Daniel , or the rest of the faithful , would have payed it ? Even so , let it be supposed , that any one of these faithful Ambassadours of Christ , or all these zealous Workers together with God , who have laboured among the people in the Preached Gospel , should fall into the hands of these Hunters ; And then they should make a Law , and appoint every man in the Nation , to send but one threed , to make a Towe , to hang that Minister , or to hang the whole Company of Christs Ambassadours , and a farthing to pay the Executioner : Can any man , without horrour think of complying so far as to contribute what is commanded ? Or would not a Gracious man frighted into an abhorrence at the attrociousness of the wickedness , or fired into a flame of zeal for God , say without demur , as not daunted , with fear of what flesh could do unto him , I will rather venture my All to keep them alive , or be hanged with them , than by doing what is demanded be brought forth & classed in the cursed & cruel Company of those who shall be dragged before the Tribunal of Christ , with their fingers dyed & dropping with the blood of those who are peculiarly dear to Him ? I know it will be said that in all these cases it would be a clear case of Confession . Well , that 's all I would have granted : For that which doth over ballance to a Testimony , in all the cases mentioned , is so far from being wanting in the cases now under consideration , that they have all to enforce the duty , that all of them put together do include ; As will be clear to any who consider ( 1 ) The preciousness of the things & Interests to be destroyed ( 2 ) The Concurrence called for from every one , that this desperate design may be accomplished . ( 3 ) The great , manifold , & indispensible obligations all are under , not only to abstain from the required Concurrence , but to preserve also & maintain these things in opposition to all , whom Satan sets on work to serve him in this Expedition against the Son of God , and to do it or endeavour it with the loss of life , and all things dearest to men , to the end that these things which are Satans eyesore , as only obstructive of His Kingdom , may be preserved among the poor Remnant , and propogate in their power & purity to the posteritie . Happy he who shall be found so doing now , when the Dragon and his Angels are drawn into the fields , and have proclaimed the War , and published to the world the Causes thereof ; So that now this General having laid aside all his old disguises , doeth in his true shape march upon the head of his black Legions , who wear his badge & colours , and fight under his banner & standart . III. In the last place , with all possible brevity , I shall offer some Reasons against Complyance with these Exactions in Cumulo . 1. To pay these Impositions , upon such declared Accounts , for such declared Causes , and for such declared ends , would condemn the Contendings & Sufferings of many eminently Godly , especially in our day who have refused them . Of these Questions & Sufferings thereupon among the Godly in former times , we cannot instruct much , for such insolent Impositions , as to all the dimensions of their heinousness , were never heard before . But we want not Examples of the Saints refusing to give their money and other such things to wicked men , either to comply with their wicked demands , obey their wicked Laws , encourage their wicked courses , or furtheir their wicked designs . In Scripture we find Paul would not give Felix money that he might be loosed , thô he sent for him often for that end Act. 24. 26. Mr Durham in his exposition of the Revelation . Chap. 6. vers 9. Lect. 6. Pag. gives an account , that when in the persecution of Dioclesian the Persecutors sought but the Bibles , poors coats , money , or Cups ( wherewith they served ) to be given them , as some Evidence of their ceding ; But they refused to accept deliverance upon these terms : yea when the Souldiers , partly wearieing to be so bloody , partly desirous of seeming victory over Christians , did profess themselves content to take any old paper or clout in place of the Bible , they refused to give any Ecvola ( as it was called from the Greek 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ) or cast-away clout ; yea when Souldiers would violently pluck such things from them against their wills , they would follow them , professing their Adherence unto the Truth , and that they had not any way willingly delivered these things , as it is to be seen in Baronius . An. 303. pag. 748. It is reported of one Marcus Arethusius , who was put to torment under Iulian , because he would not build the Idol Temple which he had formerly demolished , when they were content to accept some part of the Expenses from him , and to spare his life , he refused to give obolum or one half penny , Sozom. Lib. 5. 9. Cent. Mag. Cent. 4. pag. 797. and 833. By which and many other instances we may see , how resolutly the primitive Saints held fast their Testimonies : from which especially they were called Martyrs or witnesses ; and by which often , not only many weak ones were strengthened , but also many Persecuters convinced and made to cry out , Certainly great is the God of the Christians ; while as they saw that no Allurments on the one side , nor Terrors on the other , could make them loose their grips , but still Truth and Christ were born witness unto , and well spoken of by them . It will not be unnecessary here to consider some of Mr. Durhams observations in the fourth Lecture , for clearing thereof , he adduced these matters of fact . Such as Obs. 7. That the giving of a Testimony by outward Confession of the Truth when called for , is necessary , and commendable , as well as soundness of faith ; yea it is oftentimes the outward testifieing of the Truth before men , more than the faith of it before God , that bringeth on suffering : And there was nothing more abhorred in the primitive Christians than dissembling of a Testimony , to evite suffering , as appeareth in Augustins writings de mendacio & contra mendacium , and the writings of others to that purpose . Obs. 8. That every Truth of the word may be a ground of suffering warrantably : For the least thing that hath a Truth in it , as well as the more concerning fundamental Truths , is the word of God , and so can not be dispensed with by His people . Obs. 9. Every Truth in the word hath an outward Testimony joined to it , and sometimes may be called for upon very great hazards . Obs. 10. When it is called for , this Testimony or confession to any Truth befor men , is no less necessary , and ought as peremptorily to be held and st●ck to as the former : Therefor it is called ( Rom. 10. ) Confession unto Salvation . And called for by a peremptorie certification . Matt. 10. 32. 33. Obs. 11. That these who are sound in the Faith of the word , will be also exceeding tonacious of their Testimony , in Scripture , and in primitive times , we will find the Saints sticking at , and hazarding themselves on things which appear of very small moment , yet were to them of great concernment ▪ because of the Testimony , which was involved in them , which they would not let go . Such was Mordecai , Ester 3. Daniel 6. his not shutting of his windowes . Yea further in his lately printed Sermons on Matth. 16. 24. Serm. 7. pag. 155. the same Author saith . There is not in some respect a more and a less in the matter of duty and in the matter of Truth or in respect of Suffering . And a little after . § . 5. he sayes , We would not limit sufferings for Christ to things simply Lawful or unlawful , for it may be sometimes for things indifferent in their oun nature , which yet being so & so circumstantiated to us may draw on suffering ; a thing may be indifferent & Lawful to some , which to others stated under such & such circumstances may be counted a receding from some part of a just Testimony ; even thô the matter be not such in it self and in its oun nature , yet it may be so circumstantiate to some persons as it may be lyable to that Construction if they shall recede from or forbear it ; as in the Example of Daniel , who suffered for opening his windowes , which was a thing indifferent in it self and not essential to his worshiping of God , but — he finds himself bound in conscience , and that on very just ground , to do as he was wont to do before , and that on the manifest hazard of his life , left his malicious enemies should have it to say , that he receded from his duty , & that he thought more shame now , or was more afraid now , than before to worship the true God. How worthy Mr Knox argueth for withholding Emoluments from the false Bishops and Clergy may be seen before , part . 1. per. 3. pag. 28 , 29. The general Assembly in their Declaration dated Jullij ult : 1648. concerning the then unlawful engadgement in a War against England , plainly & positively Dehorteth all members of the Kirke of Scotland from contributing any assistence thereunto , expressed as followeth ; That they do not concur in , nor any way assist this present engadgement , as they would not partake in other mens sins , and so receive of their plagues but that by the grace & assistence of Christ , they stedfastly resolve to suffer the rod of the wicked , and the utmost which wicked mens malice can afflict them with , rather than to put forth their hands to iniquitie . In which Declaration may be seen at large , that candor , faithfullness & freedom which becometh the Ministers of the Gospel , & dignitie of Watchmen , in their seasonable warning & disswading all from assisting any way to that unlawful engadgement , perceiving the sin and snare thereof , So obviously tending to the involveing the Land in guilt , & exposeing to wrath ; yea and that notwithstanding of the fair and plausible pretexts of the engadgers and joyners therein , who pretended & professed their undertaking to be for the furthering reformation , establishing and securing the Covenanted Religion from the plotings & endeavours of the Popish , Prelatick & Malignant enemies thereof , and prosecuting the ends of the Covenants ; Pretences which no doubt our silent & time-serveing Ministers ( if they had any such now to plead ) would streniously improve , in vindication of their prudent silence , sinfull & shamfull Complyances . Alas how sad & lamentable is the condition of the Church & Nation now ! that even when the case is so far altered that not only all such pretences are laid aside , Reformation deserted & disdained , the established Religion razed & ruined , the Covenant broken & burned , and the owning the obligation thereof declared Treason , but also an absolute Power pleaded & exercised to the suspending , stoping & disabling all penal Laws against Poperie & Prelacy , a gap opened by an Antichristian toleration to the leting in all the Heresies , Idolatries & blasphemies of the mother of Harlots , and the Land openly defiled therewith , unjust & wicked Taxations arbitrarily imposed and levied , for the most dreadful , Sacrilegious and hellish ends that ever was publ●shed to the world , far exceeding in wickedness these testified against by the Assembly 1648 , or any formerly . While the Watchmen have so far abandoned their duty of seting the trumpet to their mouth and giveing due warning of the sin and danger of those dreadfull and Judgement-procuring courses , that they are caught in the snare & found complementing & encouraging , the principall Instrument of all these evills , by their scandalous flattering Adresses . How faithfull & tender some have been even in our day their sufferings and losses in a measur above others makes manifest , amongst whom the worthy Laird of Kersland is not to be forgotten , whose Estate heritable & moveable was declared forfeited , and seased , for his appearing in Arms to joyn with that faithfull party who by horrid oppression were forced to betake themselves to defensive resistence anno 1666 ; who considering the equitie of the cause he appeared for , the indispensibleness of the obligations binding him to that duty , and how much a good Conscience is to be prefered to an Estate , durst not part with the sweet comforts of the one for the uncertain profits of the other ; And as he was earnest with God by frequent & fervent Prayer for light & stedfastness in the matters of his suffering & Testimony , So it pleased the Lord , so to determine his heart therein , as that all the endeavours & perswasions used both by friends & foes to move him to a composition with the enemies for his Estate proved unsuccessfull , yea it is well known how that severals , both of his near relations & others , who used the most forcible & perswasive Arguments , as the consideration of the ancient & honourable Familie he was descended from ; The miserable case that he , his Lady and Children should be in , without his Estate ; The Counsel & Judgement of grave & Godly Ministers ; The freedom & practice of other learned and knowing men ; Togither also with the imputation of vain scrupulocity , simple & unwarrantable nicitie & precisness &c , that yet even some of those who dealt most with him , were by his defences & reasonings convinced of the equitie of his cause , and brought to commend his upright resolution , and to applaud his tenderness and faithfullness ; and in particular his own father , who pleaded much that he would only consent , that he with others of his friends might compone in favours of his Familie , and that he himself should be no wayes concerned in it further than to assent that the thing be done , but could not prevail , who afterwards blessed God that he did not , declaring that he had much more satisfaction , & comfort in his sons honestie , & stedfastness than many such Estats could ever have affourded him . I shall here mention some considerations which prevailed with him to decline all composition directly or indirectly with the enemies in that matter . ( 1 ) That he could never attain to freedom to use any such manifest dissimulation , as deliberatly to assent to any thing that might import his acknowledgeing that to be a sin & fault ( yea such a sin & fault as Rebellion ) which he was convinced in his conscience to be unquestionable duty both before God & man , nor therby dissemblingly to insinuat his undoubted right to his Estate , to be in the person or at the ●isposeing of any other . ( 2 ) Considering that there can be no new right procured upon a composition , and granted to any , but such as shall carry in the narative thereof that he had forfeited that Estate by Rebellion , with a long preamble condemning the cause of God , and dutyfull endeavours of his people for Reformation , and in defence of Religion & Libertie , all as Sedition , Rebellion & Treason ; whereupon he resolved rather to part with his Estate , than be any way instrumental & occasional to the indignifieing that holy & honourable Cause with such disdainfull , reproachful & blasphemous Epithets . And albeit such tenderness in principle & practice of this Worthy Gentleman , and of many others of the faithfull sufferers in our day , be censured & condemned by the luke-warm & worldly-wise Professors in this age , as an unprecedented noveltie , or precise & unwarrantable notion , yet we find it the same with the faithfull sufferers in former ages , and exactly agreeing with the Doctrine & Principles of the most orthodox and famous Divines , for the Reverend and learned Calvin● haveing the same case of conscience proposed to him by the Godly , persecuted in his age , to which his solid and faithfull Answer is extant in his 375 Epistle , Article third , thus proposed and Answered . An a principe peti possit confiscatio bonorum , illorum nomine & gratia , quibus persecutio intenditur ? Resp : certum est illud fieri non posse sine peccato , rescriptum enim sive indultum principis , complectitur omnino blasphemias apertas , contra Dei gloriam , quia fiet illic mentio , errorum & crimìnum , & laesoe majestatis divinae , à damnatis ; quod rescriptum erit deinde in jure exhibendum illi qui eo uti cogitabit , atque illud est approbationis genus quoddam , nullo modo ferendum , quare non video ut viro pio & recte justituto in Evangelio , ejusmodi fictionibus sese liceat involvere . i. e. Whither the confiscation of goods can be sought back again from a Prince , in the name and behalf of these who are forfaulted for Religion ? to which he Answers , that it is certain it cannot be done without sin ; for the new right , or the de novo damus , ( as we call it ) granted by the Prince , doeth really contain , open blasphemies against the glory of God ; because therein mention is made of errors , crims , & divine lese-Majestie , whereof the condemned are found guilty ; which new right most in Law be exhibited by him who intendeth to use the same ; and that is a certain kind of approbation no ways to be tolerat . Wherfore I see not that it is Lawfull for a Godly man rightly instructed in the Gospel , to involve himself into such fictions . 2. From the Fountain & Conveyance , whence they proceed ; the iniquity of these payments might be concluded ; which is nothing else than that Arbitrary Power domineering over us , and oppressing & overpressing the Kingdoms with intolerable Exactions ; which to pay is all the consent & Concurrence required of us to entail slaverie on the posterity . I mean to pay it , out of submission only to the Moral force of its Imposition , which is all the justification required of that absolute Tyranny imposing it . For we have the Testimony of a King for it ( K. Iames Speech to the Parliament anno 1609. ) that a King degenerateth into a Tyrant , when he leaveth to rule by Law , much more when he begins — to set up an Arbitrary Power , impose unlawful Taxes &c. It can be denyed by none , that know either Religion or Liberty , and are not enemies to both , that these Impositions under consideration , upon such accounts , for such ends , are as unlawful Taxes , and as illegally and arbitrarily imposed , as ever could demonstrate the most Despotical Absoluteness , Paramount to all Law , or precedent , but that of Benhadad , of a very Tyrannical strain , Thus saith Benhadad , thy silver & thy gold is mine — yet I will send my Servants , and they shall search thine house , and it shall be that whatsoever is pleasant in thine eyes , they shall put in their hand , & take it away , 1 King. 20. 3 , 6. which even an Ahab and his Elders would not hearken to nor consent . But from an Exotick Dominator this were not so intollerable , as from such as pretend an hereditary right to Govern , who should remove violence & spoyl , and take away their Exactions from the Lords people , as the Lord saith , Ezek. 45. 9. but instead of that , that they may do evil with both hands earnestly , the Prince asketh and the Iudge asketh for a reward , and the great man uttereth his mischievous desire , so they wrap it up , Mic. 7. 3. The easie Complyance with which , makes Zion as the grape gleanings of the vintage . If those Exactions be wicked , then Complyance with them must be iniquity : For it justifies the Court that enacts & exacts them , a pa●qued Iunct● of a prevalent faction made up of perjured Traitors , in a Course of enmity against God , and the Country , who to prosecute the War against the Almighty , and root out all His people out of the Land , condescend upon these Cesses , Fynes &c. as a fit & adapted Medium thereunto . Wherefore , of necessity all that would not oune that Conclusion , as their oun deed , in these Representatives , and oune them as their Representatives in that deed , must bear witness against the same , by a Refusal , to oune the debt , or pay the same . But I shall conclude this , with observing ( 1 ) The holy & remarkable righteousness of the Lord , that we , who would not contend earnestly for the Liberty of the Gospel , who would not acquit our selves like men , in witnessing our Loyaltie to Christ , were not fixed in our Engagements , nor stedfast in holding the Liberties , wherewith Christ hath made us free , did not reclaim nor reluctate when we saw our Royal Masters Prerogative invaded ; should be trode upon in all Civills , and treated as Slaves , even by these , whom we had gratified with a base & sinful forbearance to plead for God , and preserve from their violence these things , these precious & invaluable things , which we should have kept more tenderly than the apple of our eye . O the relucency of this Righteousness , in making the Gods whom we have served smite us , and in making them , whose interest we minded with a misregard & Perjury-involving neglect of the Interest of Christ , thus to destroy our poor pitiful Interests ! And thus having taught them to be Captains over us , we must now sit in the house of bondage in our Land. ( 2 ) Who will not adore & admire the Righteousness of the Lord , particularly in leaving some of these to be designedly trode upon , who not only were involved in the common guilt of not with-standing these Encroachments , but first went a great way in concuring to the making of these wicked Laws ; And now have been made to lye under the load , laid upon their loyns , by the hands of such , to whom they gave the hand in overturning the Work of God ? Why should not they be spoyled ? Why should not the young Lyons roar upon them , and make their Land wast ? Why should not men of the same mettal & soul with the Children of Noph & Tahapanes , break the Crown of their head ( or feed upon their Crown ) who have sold & set the Crown of Christ upon anothers head , and concured to crush His faithful Remnant ? O let us learn to read & revere ! Let us not be wheedled with we know not what , out of our good old Principles into the espousing the Interest , or embarquing into the same bottom with men of such Principles & Practices . And whoso is wise , and will observe these things , even they shall understand the loving kindness of the Lord : Great loving kindness , that He hath shewed to his poor Remnant , in delivering us from deliverances by such Deliverers , whereby the work had been more really and more shamefully ruined , and the hope of the posterity more certainly razed . 3. From the declared Ends of all of them , declared either verbally or virtually , and indisputably & universally known : To wit , that by such Exactions they might be enabled to maintain & prosecute the National Rebellion against Christ , and root out His Gospel , and all the faithful Preachers & Professors thereof . These designs being notour , and the Impositions demanded being the best expedients , and most adapted means to attain them , it cannot but be manifest , that whosoever complyes with the means do cooperate with the ends : Which , if any thing , will involve the Complyers in the Contrivers sin , and make the Payers obnoxious to the Enacters judgments . If they that take rewards to slay Innocents , be lyable to a Curse Deut. 27. 25. they cannot be free who give them : They cannot say Amen to it , who so cooperate to the effectuating the slaughter . If any thing make Zion lyable to be plowed as a field , when the heads thereof judge for reward , Mic. 3. 11 , 11. it must be , when they demand such rewards , and the demands are complyed with . But some may pretend , and under that pretence think to shut the shour of suffering , and command the serenity & sun-shine of a good Conseience too , and to shelter their soul under that shadow ; That these Exactions may be necessary for other ends : Can any State be without Exactions ? Is it not necessary that forces be maintained and such as are in publick office in the Kingdom ? Wherewithall shall the Nation be guarded against forreign invasion ? Alas ! the pretence is so false & frivolous as he could not escape the Censure of foolish , who in answering it appeared serious , save in a just indignation at its empty vanitie . What are these forces and publick Officiers for ? What are they employed about , but to promote the Dragons designs , and serve his drudgerie ? Shall these guard the Nation , who together with Religion tread upon the poor remaining shadow of Liberty ? Do they indeed fear a forreign invasion ? No , it doth not hold us here : These called Rulers hide not their designs , but hold them to our eye that we may not pretend ignorance . They will do the greatest hast first : Christ and His Interest is their great eyesore . This one Iesus who calls Himself a King ( yea and He will be so to their cost ) and His Subjects as the most dangerous partie , are to be discussed in the first place : And thereafter , when they are liberate from that fear of His returning to His Throne , whom they have exauctorate ( for if ever He do , they are ruined , make hast O Lord● ) and have eaten the flesh and drunk the blood of His people , then they will be in a better case to defend the Land , by shewing the Enemy those Teeth & Tusks , wherewith they have torn the people of the Lord. But will men put out their oun eyes , that they may be taken with the more tameness to grind in their Mill , and make them merry at our madness ? Have we lost our senses , that we may with confidence jeopard our Souls ? Have they not invaded the Mediators Kingdom , and taken to themselves His House in possession ? And because Reavers may not be Rewers , they will destroy all in the Land , who seem faithful to Christ , and resolute to follow the Captain of the host of Israel . But is it not enough that they menace Heaven ? Will they mock us into the same Rebellion with themselves ? He will not be mocked , but turn their jest into earnest . I cannot here shift the transcribing some of the very words of that Author , whose Reasonings I am but gleaning on this subject . Oh Brittain ! O Scotland ! bent into , & bold in backsliding , the wrath of God , and thy wo seems to be upon the wing . And alas ! I am afraid , that by this Crowning & Crimson wickedness , the Lord God Almighty is making a way to His Anger , and preparing the Nation for a Sacrifice , to expiate in the sight of the world our Perjurie , defection & Heaven-daring Provocations . Alas ! I am afraid that the sword of the Lord , which shall avenge the quarrel of His Covenant , is near to be drawn — that the Contributers , as well as the stated partie of contrivers , decreers and cruel Executioners of these decrees , may fall under the blow of the forbished sword of the Lord God : And that the Land of such abominations , may be swept of its Inhabitants with the besome of destruction , and soaked with the blood of those , who instead of contending for Christ , have by this payment associate with His stated , His declared , and implacable Enemies , whose rage is come up before Him , and will bring Him doun to take revenge . Alas ! My fears , My fears are multiplied upon me , that the war shall not only at last Land in Britain : But that He hath been all this while training up a Militia abroad , breeding them in blood , and teaching them how to be skillful to destroy , against the time He give them order to march , and put the flaming sword in their hand , to be bathed in the blood of backsliding Brittain ! Oh if our turning unto Him , that He might turn away from the fierceness of His Anger , might prevent this woful day ! But since instead of any turning unto Him , we surpass the deeds of the heathen , and out do in wickedness all that went before us , and proceed with a petulancy reaching Heaven from evil to worse ; I am afraid that all the bloodshed since the sword was drawn in the Nations about , all the sacked Cities all the burnt dorps & villages , all the wasted Countries , all the slain of the Lord by sea or Land , all the pillagings , rapes , Murders outrages ( which rage it self , could hardly outdo ) all the horrid & inhumane Cruelties , that have been committed during this bloody war ( wherein the sea hath been dyed , and the Land as it were drouned with the blood of the slain ) all the truculent & treacherous Murthers of that Monster Alva in the Low Countries , all the incredible Cruelties of the Guises , and the bloodshed in the Massacres of France , all the Tortures that the people of the Lord have been put to in the valleys of Piedmont , by that Litle fierce Tyger the Duke of Savoy , all the savage and barbarous butcheries of the Irish Massacre ; shall be forgotten , or seem things not to be mentioned in one day ; when what shall be done in Brittain comes to be reinembered . O Brittain ô Brittain : of all Nations under the Cope of Heaven , most ripe for the sickle of vengeance ! shall this Throne of iniquity , which hath framed so many mischiefs into Laws , and all that are Complices in this wicked Conspiracie , who now are gathering themselves against the soul of the Righteous , & condemning the innocent blood , be able to save its subjects , when He comes to make inquisition for that blood ? or shall the subjects calling in all from 60 to 16 , be able to support the Throne ? Alas ! in vain shall they offer to draw up , and draw the sword & defend , when the Lord God of hosts drawes His sword , to accomplish upon them the vengeance written , & wrapt up in these words , He shall bring upon them their oun iniquity ▪ and shall cut them off in their oun wickedness , yea the Lord our God shall cut them off . And if it come to this , then in that day escape who will , Professing Gentlemen , and others who in this have complyed with the Rulers , shall not escape : Then shall they be payed for this Payment . The storme of His displeasure ( even thô they get their souls for a prey , yea so much the more as He will not suffer them to perish eternally ) shall be observed to fall particularly upon their houses , Interests , & Estates . Who can think upon the wickedness of Brittain , with its just aggravations , and imagine the righteous Lord will proportion His Judgments , to the heinousness of our guilt , and His revenges to the rage , whereby He , and His Christ hath been , and is opposed , and take other measures ? 4. From the Nature of these Payments , it is not our they are sinful Complyances & Transactions with Christs declared Enemies , and do partake of Unitive Confederacies with them ; which are demonstrated to be sinful , Head 3. Arg. 1. in gen . Pag. Certainly such bargains cannot be discretive , exacted and complied with by Persons no wayes incorporate together , being only overcome by meer force : since they are not only demanded and granted Acknowledgements of that Power that imposes them , as legally Lording over them , but obediential submissions to these wicked Laws that enacts them ; which is a formal justifying of these Laws : For Laws cannot be obeyed except they be justified , seeing Laws unjust and unjustifyable cannot be obeyed . Therefore , seeing the Payment of the Cess , Locality , Fynes stipends , fees &c. is an obediential Complyance with the Laws that enjoyn them , that obedience can no more be justified , than the Laws enacting such Payments : which none can justify but he that is an enemy to those things for opposing which they are exacted . If then Complyances with the wicked Impositions & exactions of Arbitrary Dominators , enemies to the Work & People of God , be in Scripture condemned , then such Payments cannot be justified : But such Complyances are condemned , and cannot be approven . This was Issachars brand , that being a strong Ass , he couched between burdens , and bowed his shoulder to bear and became a servant to Tribute Gen. 49. 14. This was Asa's folly , that he so far Complyed with Benhadad , as to give money to take his help 1 King. 15. 18. Condemned by the Prophet Hanani 2 Chron. 16. 7. &c. much more if he had given it to help him . It s one of the instances of the Evil that Menahem did in the sight of the Lord , 2 King. 15. 18 — 2c . that when Pul the King of Assyria came against the Land he gave him a thousand talents of silver , that his hand might be with him , which he exacted of Israel : This was certainly evil in the sight of the Lord , for if the Confederacy was evil , then this price to procure it was evil also : And if Menahems exaction was evil , then Israels Complyance was evil also ; for thus Ephraim was oppressed & broken in judgement , because he willingly walked after the Commandment , Hos. 5. 11. It was also a part & proof of Ahaz's Confederacy with Tiglith-Pileser King of Assyria , that he sent money to him 2 King. 16. 8. Which to all the fearers of the Lord is condemned & discharged Isai. 8. 12 , 13. Which if it was evil , then also Hezekiahs Complyance with Sennacherib , giving him money , and offering to bear that which was put on him , 2 King. 18. 14 , 15. was evil : And also Iehojakims taxing the Land , to give the money according to the commandment of Pharoh 2 King. 23. 35. was sinful to the Exacter , and likewise to the Complyers . These were all sinful Complyances and Confederacies with the wicked , making their peace with them to whom they payed them : Therefore all Peace-making payments , by way of Unitive aggreement with the wicked , must be sinful . And accordingly in the time of Montrose , the Gen. Ass. made an Act for Censuring the Complyers with the Publick Enemies of this Church & Kingdom , Iun. 17. 1646. Sess. 14. See Part. 1. Per. 5. Pag. 82. 5. Where these Exactions are extorted only as badges of bondage , without Consent unto the Law imposing them , it s a Case more suitable for lamentation then Censure , that she that was Princess among the Provinces should become tributary Lam. 1. 1. But when they are Acknowledgemens of the Lawgivers , and an exact obedience to the Law , and voluntary agreement & bargain with them , strengthening them to the prosecution of their Mischiefs , they cannot be free of the Imposers sin . It was the sin of the men of Shechem , and a proof of their hearts inclination to follow Abimelech , that they gave him threescore and ten pieces of silver , enabling him to kill threescore & ten persons and to hire vain & light persons to follow him , which they payed as an acknowledgement of his usurped Power , Iudg. 9. 3 — 5. for which afterwards fire came out of the house of Abimelech & devoured them . Certainly a voluntary consent into a Mischief is a partaking with the sin of it , a consent unto Theft is a partaking with it Psal. 50. 18. But if there be any consent unto a Mischief , it must be when the person agrees it be done against himself , and voluntarily subjects himself to the force of the Law imposing it , and not only does not oppose or witness against the doing of it against others , but yeelds to its reaching himself , and gives what is demanded to strengthen the Robbers to exercise their Robberie over all . As the Payer of the Cess , Fynes , & Fees , &c. gives all the consent required of him , to these Mischiefs framed into Law , not only to rob himself , but the Church & Nation of its dearest Treasure the Gospel , for the punishment of ouning which , and as means to remove it , these Payments are exacted . But the Plea of the payers is , that they are constrained to it , and they do it against their will. Ans. 1 He who sayes he understands this , that the Payer of these Exactions can purge himself of the guilt of them , is like to buy an after wit at a dear rate . Can it be thought by any man of knowledge & conscience , that so remote a force makes the deed unvoluntary , whereby the payer is purged from the guilt of accession to the Imposers deed , whom hereby in this very Imposition he ounes as his Representatives ! 2. The payment cannot be involuntary ; for the Law enjoyning it , being the publick & declared will of the Nation , requires no other voluntareness but obedience , and judgeth no other thing involuntareness but disobedience . So that the Law being fatisfied , it absolves the Satisfier from all transgression , and looks npon all who yeeld obedience as equally willing , and equally out of the reach of its appended penaltie , in case of disobedience . Neither are we to please our selves with other fancies & fictitious unwillingness , when real obedience is yeelded , whereby the Law is satisfied , and the Law-maker capacitated thereby to act all his intended Mischiefs . For to be unwilling to part with money in the Case , as it is no vertue in it self , so I suppose there are few who will be sollicitous to purge themselves of this . And to be unwilling from some struglings of light & conscience , is such an unwillingness as aggravates the guilt of the Giver , and makes it more heinous in the sight of God , and hateful in the eyes of all tender men : The Law enjoyning such payments takes no notice of such reluctancies , only requireth obedience , and when that is yeelded , the Law is satisfied , as to the voluntareness of the Action , and must construe the Agent a willing walker after the Command , and a voluntary Complyer with the publick will of the Nation . 3. It must be simply , really , & truly a voluntary deed , when there is Deliberation and Election . The Law requiring these payments being promulgate , every man must be supposed to put the question to himself , what shall I do in the case ? Shall I obey and be free ? Or disobey and suffer ? Here is Election & choice upon mature deliberation : And so the deed becomes truly voluntary . This will be confirmed , if we consider the Law of God , Deut. 22. 25. concerning Rapes . Where , to make the unvoluntareness of the betrothed Virgin , she must not only be supposed to strugle & resist the attempt made upon her chastitie & honour by the villain , but she must cry for assistence in that resistence , without which she is held in Law willingly to consent to the committing of that wickedness . And moreover if we consider the Law vers . 13. it will be manifest , in order to her escaping of death , that when violented and the villain hath committed this villany , she is to carry as Tamar ( when defiled of that beast , thô of the blood Royal ) did 2 Sam. 13. 19. that is , to complain & cry , and crave Justice against him , and be wanting in nothing , that may bring him to condign punishment . This doth aptly correspond to our Case . Scotland is the betrothed Virgin : We were espoused to Jesus Christ , and joyned to Him , by a Marriage Covenant , never to be forgotten ; But the Rulers , and with them the body of the Land have treacherously broken it : yet there is a Remnant that adhere to Him as Head & Husband ; because of which , these called Rulers incensed against Him will violently commit a Rape upon them , and have them prostitute their bodies , their fortunes , yea their Souls & Consciences to their lusts , and thus they will needs ravish the Queen in the Kings presence . And so , while with displayed banner they declare they will drive our Covenanted Husband out of the Nation , and destroy all who will oune Him as such , they call for our Assistence & Complyance , to enable them to accomplish this wickedness . Now either must we make all the Resistence that is in our power ; or the Law judgeth us willingly to consent ; and because of that we fall in the hands of the righteous Judge , and have neither the evidence of our Resisting , nor Crying , nor pursuing the wicked for this violent Rape , to produce and plead upon , why Sentence should not pass , and the Laws just severity be execute upon us . What ? Alas ! do they declare they will stone our Husband ? ( Ah! for which of His good deeds is this done ) And shall they make a Law whereby we shall be obliged to furnish them with stones to do it ? And shall they be obeyed ? Is this our strugling ? Is this our Crying ? Is this our endeavour that the wicked may be brought to condign punishment ? Oh! let us meditate terror , lest we be brought forth as willing Consenters ! For whatever vengeance the jealous & just God shall execute upon them , who have committed the Rapt , shall equally , in its crushing & everlastingly confounding weight , fall upon them who do not by their-Refusing , & their Resisting make their unwillingness manifest ; which in the present Case is their strugling their Crying , and calling God and man , to witness , they are not Consenters , but continue constant & loyal in their love to their betrothed Husband . 6. A formal Consent to the wickedness of these Impositions were the less matter , if the payment of them were not also a Concurrence to assist them , and a strengthening their hands in it . But this is so manifest , that the paying of the Cess , Locality , Fynes , Fees , &c. is a Concurrence with and a Contributing towards the promoving the wicked designs for which they are imposed , that he must have a conscience of brass , and in a great measure seared who will run upon such a formal Engagement against the Lord and His anointed King in Zion . If it was Aarons sin which made the people naked , and which brought so great a sin upon them , to take , and the peoples sin & shame to give , that Contribution of Golden ear-rings for making a Calf , Exod. 32. 3. &c. And if it was Gideons sin to take , and Israels to give , that Contribution of the ear-rings of their prey , to make an Ephod Iudg. 8. 25. Then , as it is our oppressors sin to take , so it must be our sin & shame to give , their demanded Exaction to help them in erecting such Idols of Jealousie , as they have set up , and are commanding al● to bow to , to provoke the Lord to Jealousie , especially when they affrontedly require such Contributions to be payed , both as punishments for not assisting , and as means to assist in their establishment . Should we thus help the ungodly , and love them that hate the Lord ? And will not this bring doun wrath upon us from the Lord ? 2 Chron. 19. 2. Alas ! instead of Arguing , it were more fitt to fall a weeping , when it s come to be a question amongst us , whether , in stead of coming to the help of the Lord , against the Mighty , we shall really help the Mighty against the Lord , and that while they call for our assistence formally upon this declared account . As the very inscription of their Acts does carry it in their front , requiring a supply to his Majestie &c. If this be not a Casting in a Lot among them , who can tell what it is ? Sure it is a preparing a table for that troup , and a furnishing a drink-offering unto that number , Isai. 65. 31. Seeing it is a supplying them with necessaries , to solemnize their Idolatrous fest vities , who forsake the Lord , and not only forget but lay waste His Holy Mountain , for which all that have any accession to it , are threatned to be numbered to the sword . If any thing be a strengthening the hands of evil doers , Ier. 23. 14. certainly this is . For as they cannot accomplish their cursed ends without these Exactions , so the payment of them , is all the present , personal , & publick Concurrence in wageing this war with Heaven , that is required of the Nation , to wit , such a summ to furnish them with all necessaries , and maintain the Executioners of their hell-hatched and Heaven-daring Decrees & Orders : And the Law requiring no more but contributing what is appointed , looks equally upon all the Givers , as followers of the Command , and active Concurrers in complying with its end , and carrying on & promoving its design , and so assoils them from all the statute serverities , in case of Deficiencie . 7. If it were only a Concurrence in their wickedness to pay those their Exacted supplies , it were more easily comported with : But I fear it shall be found a hire & reward for their wicked service . At first they were only enacted & exacted as Helps to capacitate this Popish Prelatical & Malignant faction to prosecute the war they had undertaken & declared against Christ : But now , having thereby been enabled to carry it through this length that they have almost got all visible Appearances for Christ , in ouning His Gospel , and propagating His Testimony , quite suppressed by means of these Impositions , and having got the fields cleared of those that formerly opposed their Course & Career , and all obstacles removed that might stand in the way of the Reception , they have prepared for their Mistris , the Babylonish lady , the Mother of Harlots ; they now demand these payments , as their wages and Hire for their labour : Which to pay now is more than a justifying , seeing it is a rewarding them for their work . And to pay these Pimps , and to purchase their peace thereby , is worse than to bring the hire of a whore into the House of the Lord ( Deut. 23. 18. ) since it is a hyring them to bring the whore into the House of the Lord. O how hath Scotland plaid the Harlot with many Lovers ! Is this the zeal we should have had to our Covenanted husband , and the honour of His House , that we have not only suffered His Enemies , to come in and take Possession of it , but Consented to their invasion , and not only Consented , but Invited them to come in , and not only Invited them , but Prostitute our Estates & Consciences also to their Arbitrary Lusts , and not only plaid the harlot with them , but hyred them also when they had done ! And for this the Lord may say to Scotland , as He said to His People of old , They give gifts to all whores , but thow givest thy gifts to all thy Lovers , and hirest them that they may come unto thee on every side , for thy whoredome ; And the Contrary is in thee from other women in thy whoredoms — in that thow givest a reward , and no reward is given unto thee , therefore thow art contrary , Ezek. 16. 33 , 34. There Israel is taxed for hyring the Assyrians : But let it be considered and enquired into in the History , how this was : What evidence can be given of this in their Transactions with them ? Was only that they were entysed , or did entyse them into a Communion with their Idolatry ? It is true , Ahaz may be an instance of that , in his sending the pattern of the Altar he saw at Damascus , 2 King. 16. 10. And it cannot be denyed but in several respects they did partake with the Assyrians in their Idolatrie , which was their Adulterie . But what could be their hire they gave them for it , if it was not their Taxations they payed , and money they sent unto them ? as Ahaz did vers . 8. and Hezekiah also , thô a good man , 2 King. 18. 14 , 15. Which can no more be justified , than Asa's paying to Benhadad . It was then their Confederacies , and the hire of them the Lord calls the hire they gave unto their lovers . With this also Ephraim is charged , that he hyred lovers , Hos. 8. 9 , 10. of this we have instances in Menahems giving to Pul a thousand Talents of silver , and exacting it of the People , 2 King. 15. 19. 20. And in Hoshea his becoming servant to Shalmanesar King of Assyria , and giving him presents , 2 King. 17. 3. If then hyring wicked men in Confederacies to help the Lords People , be a hyring of lovers so much condemned in Scripture , what must a hiring of them to hurt them , and rewarding them after they have done , and when they formally seek it for such work be ? but a giving the reward they seek to slay the Innocent ( Deut. 27. 25. ) and a voluntary yeelding that which they take ( Ezek. 22. 12. ) Which if it be sin in the Takers , cannot be justified in the Givers , but will render both obnoxious to the Indignation of a provoked God , in the day when He shall begin to Contend for the wrongs He hath got , both by the Work and the wages . Now let all the Acts for the Cess and Continuation thereof , and other Acts & Edicts for fines & forfeitures , be considered in their just import , according to the trwe meaning of the Enacters , and the Causes for which they exact them , and will have them Complyed with , It will be found they were both declared , intended , & improved , and accordingly approved by the Complyers ▪ Not only as Helps but as Hyres for our Oppressours and Destroyers , and for such as have been , and are more destructive and explicitely declared Enemies to Christs Interests & People in Scotland , than ever the Assyrians were to the Church in the old Testament . The Cess was not only a help but a hire to the Tyrant & His Complices , for suppressing Meetings for Gospel Ordinances ; Especially the Continuation of it , from time to time was humbly , unanimously , chearfully & heartily offered , for themselves and in name of , and as representing this Kingd●m , as a hire for the doing of it , and an encouragment to suppress what remained of these Conventicles . The Localitie was intended as a help to the Souldiers in their quarterings upon this account , But afterwards , being expressly discharged to be furnished without payment according to the current rates of the Countrie , Act. 3. Parl. 3. K. Char. 2. Aug. 20. 1681. The Contribution of it gratis must be interpreted for a reward of their service , Fines are appointed , not only for a punishment of Contraveeners of their wicked Laws , but for a hire to their most violent Executers . Stipends for a hire to their Hireling Curats . And fees as a hire to Iaylors to keep the Lords People in bondage . By which hyres these destroyers have been rewarded , by them whom they have destroyed , and for which the righteous Lord will reward both . 8. Let it be considered , how far these submissions are short of , and how clearly these Complyances are inconsistent with , that duty which lies upon us with reference to them . Our obligation to God and our Brethren doth indispensibly bird us to a Contrary carriage . If it bind us in our Station & Capacity to an Active renitency , It doth much more bind us up from such Complyances . Neither is it imaginable , how Moral force can ever justify our doing that deed , we are obliged by all imaginable bonds , yea if in any probable Capacity , by the utmost of real force , to counteract . Can we give them that which they require , and by which they are enabled to murder our Brethren , which we are so indispensibly obliged to rescue our Brethren , Prov. 24. 11 , 12. to relieve the oppressed Isai. 1. 27. to loose the bonds of wickedness , to undo the heavy burdens , to let the oppressed go free , and to break ever● yoke Isai. 58. 6. What do we owe to these Enemies , but seeing they have constitute themselves by these Acts implacable Enemies to Christ , His People & Interests in habitu , not only plainly & importunately to pray that He would overturn them , but to oppose their Course , to the uttermost of our power , and to concur to wrest that power out of their hands ? And since they will needs make the whole Nation a Curse , they are so far from being to be complyed with , that for these Exactings & Exactions they are to be looked upon , and carried unto , not only as these who have sold themselves to work wickedness , but endeavour also to engage with themselves all in the same guilt , and expose them to the same Curse . And therefore that the Anger of the Lord may be turned away from His people , every one in his station is obliged to endeavour to bring these Achans to condign punishment . 9. As it must be taken for granted , that these wicked Oppressions by Law are Perjurie avouched in the sight of God , yea in a peculiar manner , our Covenanted subjection unto Him is turned into an open War against Him : So we cannot but beleeve , that for this hight of wickedness the Curse of God ( to which in the Covenant the Nation in case of breach , is liable by their oun consent ) and the Mediators Malediction shall follow , pursue , overtake , and fall upon the head of these , who have made the Decrees , and upon all who concur in the execution , and carry on this Course : Oh! its impossible to keep them company , and not fall with them into the hands of the living God. Well then , seeing every one from whom these Exactions are required , is under an anterior obligation to God and the Brethren , to preserve these precious Interests , which the Imposers have been long essaying to root out & ruine , and His people whom they have been destroying , with the loss of all he hath , life not excepted . ( For I suppose none , who acknowledgeth his Soul is still under the bond of the Covenant ( and it s like to cost him his soul who denies it ) but he will oune this to be duty ; Nay none who hath any sense of Religion , but abstracting from the subjective obligation of a sworn Covenant , he will oune an objective obligation from the Law of the great superior , that doth immediately bind the Conscience to witness against this course , and to lay doun , if it should come to that , his life for his Brethren ) Then for a man to give his goods to destroy these things & persons , which he is obliged to defend & preserve with the loss of all , is so clear a making himself a Tyransgressor , in paying his proportion , and being at the expense of destroying what he built , and building what he destroyed , that it seems inexplicable how he can dream to be innocent ; especially when more lies upon it than the souls of the Complyers are worth , even the Interest of Christ in the Land. And to close this I would put home the question , and pose the Conscience of any that took that Covenant ; If in that day the question had been asked at him whether he would have judged the paying of a Cess for the ends narrated , to suppress a Testimony for that Covenanted Reformation , the paying of fines & fees ( for ouning it ) to the overturners , Breakers & Burners of it , to be a plain Perjurie & palpable counteracting of the ends thereof ? And let him speak his soul , and it s beyond debate with me , he will not dare to say he took it in a sense which can subsist with these Complyances . Nay I doubt not , if to any Morally serious , it had been then said , yow will pay money &c. for destroying this Covenant and its ends , and deleting the Remnant that shall be found to adhere to it , he would have given Hazaels answer . It concerns every man , that would be free of the Curse of it , to consider how he is brought to make enquirie after vowes ; or to dream of Consistencies betwixt the performing those Engagements , and the plainest concurring in a Counteracting thereof . 10. If then these Impositions be so wicked , and for such wicked Ends & Causes ; Then , in order to my being free of this heinous guilt there is a necessity of my giving a Testimony , and such an one , which when brought to the Touchstone , will get Gods approbation , and be my Acquittance from a Concurrence . Now it is not imaginable that my Testimony , can be the exact obedience to the Law , against the wickedness whereof it is witnessed : But on the Contrary , it must be at least a plain & positive Refusing to yeeld obedience to that Law , when I am in no other case to counteract these Commands , for I must either obey and be guilty , or refuse and be innocent . I shall not here plunge into the Labyrinth of these debates & difficulties , wherewith this matter of Testimonies hath been perplexed , and mostly by those who have had no great mind to the thing . I shall only propound these few Queries ( 1 ) Wether any thing less than a Testimony can free me of this guilt , whereby the Nation involved in it , is made a Curse ? ( 2 ) Wether we beleeve that the Testimony of every one shall be called for , in the day when God shall seek out this wickedness ? ( 3 ) Whether , if ever it be necessary , it be not then when Christ is openly opposed , and every one is called either to concur or to testifie ? ( 4 ) Whether a Testimony against a wicked Law must not be notour ? for my Testimony must make it evident that the Law is not obeyed by me , else it is no Testimony . ( 5 ) Whether it be not necessary also , that it be with that plainness & boldness , as it may keep some proportion with the prodigiousness of that wickedness testified against ? ( 6 ) Whether to the making it a Testimony indeed , it is not only required , that an opposition be made at first , out that this be so persisted in , as by no subsequent deed , it be weakened ? ( 7 ) Whether we do not take it for granted , that according as a man hath Testified , the sentence of the righteous Judge shall pass ? For he who hath not purged himself thereby from the guilt of this Conspiracy , shall be led forth & punished with these Workers of iniquity . It s a saying which should sink in the soul of every one who would be saved , especially in such a day , Whosoever therefore shall Confess me before men , him will I Confess also before my Father which is in Heaven , but whosoever shall deny me before men him will I also deny &c. Oh that men would now judge of things & Courses , as in that hour they desire to be judged and then there would be litle difficulty , what to determine in the Case . 11. From what is said it appears , that there is no other way of Testifying against it , or shunning the sin of this wickedness , imposing & enjoyning these Complyances , but by Refusing them : Which as it is clear duty , so it hath many Advantages to countervail all the supposed loss that can be sustained thereby . It is a shameful subterfuge to say , I strengthen them more by doing thus which will make them take all , and so put themselves in better case to do the Mischief decreed . For as it is then my suffering not my sin , so it is simply false that I do hereby strengthen their hands ; for hereby I do more certainly weaken their hands , and wound their Cause by my Counteracting , Testifying & Suffering . For. 1. I do really to the uttermost of the sphere of my activity Counteract their design , And hence besides my oun upmaking Peace of Conscience ( which is my hundredfold in this Life ) I glorify God in the day of visitation , behaving as the Subject & Souldier of the Prince Michael : And thô I losse my life in the Conflict , yet the victory over the Dragon , and his Lievtennant & Trustees , and their Lictors is thereby gained , and they are foiled , while I fight & overcome by my not loving my life in the present case unto the death . 2. I do by my example encourage my Brethren to stand fast , and withstand in this evil day . 3. I hereby transmitt to Posterity a Pattern for imitation , and so propogate an opposition to this Course to succeeding generations . 4. I hereby ( so to speak ) engage God to arise & appear to plead His oun Cause and His Peoples . For when we out of love to Him and zeal for His Interests , take our lives in our hands , or expose our substance as a prey in witnessing for Him , then He is engaged to oune us , and to plead His Cause taking the quarrel then to be against Himself . Hence it is that when He puts on the Garments of vengeance for cloathing , and goes forth to meet them who in their risings up against His People run upon the bosses of His Buckler , His Arm is said to bring salvation to Himself , Isai. 59. 16 , 17. and Isai. 63. 5. This keeps a man in case to Pray against such a Partie ; Whereas a Complyance with them in the least degree , will wound a mans faith , and weaken His Confidence , so that he cannot wrestle with God to prevail : For that wherein his strength lay , a good Conscience being sinned away , in vain doeth he essay , when he hath cut his oun hair , to shake himself as at other times . Alas ! If by keeping a due distance from his enemies , we were in case to play the Samsons or Iacobs on our knees , this Enemy who think it their stability to stand upon the ruines of Christs Interest , should not stand long upon their feet . He who would have his prayer heard , Thy Kingdom come , should make his Practice in a conformity thereto speak this plain language , If I perish I perish , but Comply I will not : For it s not necessary that I live , or have an estate , but its necessary I should witness a good Confession against the wrongs done to Christ. 6. This keeps a man in case , either to Act for God with advantage , if an opportunity be put in his hand , or to Suffer , as under His supportings , and the shinings of His face , whereby even while dieing he becomes an Ornament to his Profession , gives a dash to the Enemy , and so becomes more than a Conquerer . 12. Let us consider the matter of Scandal in the present case , and remember whose words these are , Wo to the World because of offences , and Wo to him by whom offences ●ome : And it will appear the payers of these Exactions become highly guilty before God. 1. In stumbling & hardening this Partie of Enemies . For , thô there was never a Partie before them in the Nation ( and I much doubt if ever a Partie can come after them to outdo them ) who had so many evidences of Plagues poured upon their hearts , that He may pour furth His wrath , & cause His fury to rest upon them ; And that , in His spotless Justice He will rain snares upon them , that thereafter He may rain fire & brimstone , & a horrible tempest as the portion of their Cup , when He shall come to plead His oun Cause : yet we would beware lest we do any thing that may embolden them , or make them bless themselves in this their stated opposition to Christs . And because we know not but some of the Elect , may for a time be carried doun with the Current of this impetuous opposition to Him , and may concur actively for a season in promoving this Course , we ought even upon this supposition so to witness , and so to keep a distance from all apparent or interpretative Complyance with what they contrive & carry on , as they may by beholding our stedfastness be provoked to consider their oun Course ; that considering at last how their feet go doun to death , and their steps take hold on hell , they may hasten their escape from the Company of His Enemies , lest they be consumed with the fire of His Indignation , if found congregate with the men of these God-provoking practices . 2. By paying what is required , I stumble also & offend my weak Brethren , while by my example they are encouraged to rush into the same Complyance . O let every man , whose Practice may be pleaded as a Pattern , remember that Word , and who spoke it , It were better that a Mistone were hanged about his neck , and he cast into the midst of the sea , than offend any of these litle ones . 3. Sufferers for refusing this payment are offended , when the payer doth not only encourage the Persecuters to proceed with rigor & rage against him as a peevish & froward Malecontent , but does what in him lies to wound the heart & weaken the hands of such a faithful Witness : Whereas , if the poor Sufferer saw himself by a Joynt Testimony ouned by his Brethren , he would be comforted , strengthened , & become more confident in the Conflict . 4. In paying these things , the Complyers either by their Example lay a snare for the posterity , to whose knowledge their Carriage may come ; and so in stead of leaving them a Pattern of contending earnestly for the faith , they spread a net for their feet , yea pave them a way to defection & Apostasie : Or else they engage the Great God , out of zeal to His oun Glory , and tenderness to His People who shall succeed , for preventing of their following of such Progenitors , wherein they have not been followers of Him fully , to give such a Testimony against their untenderness , and set such marks of displeasure upon their Course , that the thoughts of turning aside with them , and following their steps shall be terrible to all that hear of it , le●t for such a Complyance they fall as they did , for falling from their oun stedfastness into the hands of the living God. But Alas ! for the Posterity , under whose Curse we are like to go off the stage , because of our not having done what we ought , yea what we might , both for transmitting pure Ordinances unto them , and for not transcribing in our Pactice the noble Example of our zealous & Heroick Ancestors , who valiantly resisted vvhen violently attacqued , and by their valour wrestled us into a State of Liberty ? Well , if we leave those that shall succeed us such an Example as this , He is like to make us such an Example as will fright the following Generations , and force them to serve themselves heirs to them who have gone before us , who did acquit themselves as the good Souldiers of Jesus Christ , and not to us , the debt of whose declensions & defections cannot be payed , without the destruction of those who shall serve themselves heirs to us . But Alas ! who does think on what he owes to the poor Posterity ! Or who doth make Conscience to preserve for them that precious Treasure put in our Custodie , and judges it more necessary than to live , to leave the Tract of a way of Contending zealously for God , and the Preservation of His Interests , and the Propogation of His oun pure Ordinances to the Posteritie , shining so clearly by suffering & blood , as the way-faring man , and they who shall come after , though fools need not erre therein . Our only Comfort is , that the Lord who shall see His seed , and must prolong His dayes , will make His pleasure prosper , and preserve some to be Witnesses of it to His Praise . FINIS .