Dissertation concerning the antiquity of churches wherein is shewn, that the Christians in the two first centuries, had no such publick separate places for worship, as the papists generally, and some Protestants also presume, and plead for. Hill, Joseph, 1625-1707. 1698 Approx. 195 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 39 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2009-10 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A43790 Wing H1999 ESTC R19760 12442953 ocm 12442953 62137 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A43790) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 62137) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 942:10) Dissertation concerning the antiquity of churches wherein is shewn, that the Christians in the two first centuries, had no such publick separate places for worship, as the papists generally, and some Protestants also presume, and plead for. Hill, Joseph, 1625-1707. [4], 71, [1] p. Printed for Tho. Parkhurst ..., London : 1698. Reproduction of original in Union Theological Seminary Library, New York. Attributed to Joseph Hill. cf. Wing. At head of title: II. Table of contents: p. [4] Advertisement: p. [1] at end. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Church history -- Primitive and early church, ca. 30-600. 2008-10 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2008-12 SPi Global Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2009-01 John Pas Sampled and proofread 2009-01 John Pas Text and markup reviewed and edited 2009-02 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion II. DISSERTATION CONCERNING THE ANTIQUITY OF CHURCHES . Wherein is shewn , That the CHRISTIANS , In the Two First CENTURIES , Had no such Publick Separate Places for Worship , as the Papists generally , and some Protestants also Presume , and Plead for . LONDON : Printed for Tho. Parkhurst at the Bible and Three Crowns in Cheapside near Mercers-Chappel , 1698. NOBILISSIMO DOMINO , D o. ROBERTO SOUTHWEL , Equiti aurato . Summis virtutibus , perinde ac eruditione ornatissimo , Longo rerum usu , & Prudentia civili celeberrimo . Magnis merito Officiis & Honoribus decorato . Sub Carolo II. Ad Aulam Portugalliae semel atque iterum , Ad Bruxellensem quoque , & Brandeburgicam Legato . Necnon Sanctiori Concilio a Secretis . Gulielmo III. In Regno Hiberniae ab Epistolis . Itemque Regalis Societatis Praesidi . Hanc qualemcunque Dissertationem , Quam humillime D. D. C. JOSEPHUS HILL . THE CONTENTS . SECT . 1. THE Question stated . SECT . 2. The first Argument , that the Apostles , and Primitive Christians had no Publick separate Places for Worship , taken from their Persecution , vindicated and inforced . SECT . 3. A second Argument , from the defect of Proof for Churches so early . SECT . 4. Our Adversaries Proofs from Scripture Considered , and Answered . SECT . 5. What kind of Places were used for Worship . SECT . 6. Testimonies for our Opponents in the first Century answered . SECT . 7. Testimonies in second Century answered . SECT . 8. As also in the third Century . SECT . 9. Their Reasons answered , and of Churches standing and worshipping towards the East . SECT . 10. Several Considerations , for corroborating our Assertion . SECT . 11. Testimonies of the Persecution of Christians , and how continued in the first Ages . SECT . 12. Concerning the number of Martyrs . SECT . 13. Testimonies that the Christians had no Churches in the two first Centuries . SECT . 14. And that they assembled frequently in the Night , and always in the most Private Places , during their Persecution under the Heathens , DISSERTATION II. Of the Antiquity of Artificial Churches under the Gospel . SECTION I. HAVING Discoursed in a former Dissertation , Of the Antiquity of Temples in the times of the Old Testament : I proceed in this , with the Consideration , Of the Antiquity of Churches in Gospel times under the New. Wherein the common Opinion of Protestants is maintained , not only against Bellarmine and Baronius , but some Protestants also , as Fuller in his Miscellanea Sac. l. 2. c. 9. who undertakes to prove that Christians had their Churches or Temples built , even in the days of the Apostles : And more especially Mede , who hath largely handled this Subject in 's Treatise Of Appropriate Places for Christian Worship , both in , and ever since the Apostles time . Both these state and maintain the Question as they do , and light their Candles at their Torches . In this Controversie our Adversaries take the Word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ( which we render , when taken for a Religious Assembly , by the word Church ; from 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , whence the Saxon Cyric , and the German Kyrk , and we by adding a double Aspiration Chyrch , or Church ) as it was in after Ages ( not in the beginning ) taken for a Publick Place for Worship . Concerning which , here let me premise , That although we have no particular command for building of Churches , as of Old for the Tabernacle ( which was a moveable Temple ) or the Temples , which were standing Tabernacles , ( their Names being frequently interchanged ; ) nor do they recommend our Services to God , as those that were Typical of our Saviour did : Yet are Edifices very convenient for the Worshippers , and are so far necessary for the advancing Gods Service , as appears by the Light of Nature , and the use of Synagogues amongst the Jews : That by such Structures we are better defended against the injuries of Wind and Weather ; as also , the Voice of the Minister is in them more Audible than in the open Air , and that thereby we have greater conveniency of excluding such , as ought not to Communicate with us : Besides that after the spreading of the Gospel , they were more necessary for the containing a greater number of Christians , than could meet together in private Houses , or Places : which occasioned afterwards , as liberty was granted , or encouragement given by Christian Magistrates , the building of Oratories and Churches . So that tho we grant the Primitive Christians had always Places for Publick Worship ; yet we deny they built any Edifices publickly for the exercise of their Religion , or had any such appropriate places , as our Opponents call Temples or Churches ; but worshipp'd God in such numbers , as could conveniently meet together , only in private Houses , or such places as were obscure , for above 200 Years after our Blessed Saviour's Ascension . Altho in the Third Century , they had some Oratories or Conventicles , here and there , even in the Roman Empire , as well as in Persia , and other Nations , where the Gospel was spread . For Arnobius , who flourished about 285 , mentions , l. 4. the Christian Conventicles . And Lactantius his Schollar ( Justit . l. 5. c. 2. ) a Temple destroyed in Bithynia . Who being Schoolmaster to Crispus , the Son of Constantine , it 's probable , the publick Places , granted the Christians by Galienus , were then enlarged , which were before called Conventicles ; as he saith , One in Phrygia set a Conventicle on Fire , and burnt all assembled therein , cap. 11. SECT . 2. The Reasons for this our Assertion are , ( 1. ) The great Persecutions the Christians lived under for the most part , all that time . Which is so apparent from all Histories , Sacred and Civil , that I wonder Fuller should say , That Persecutions in the beginning were more rare , and for the most part private . Both which are notoriously false , as appears from the Acts. For no sooner had the Apostles begun to preach the Gospel , c. 2. & 3. but they were by the Rulers imprisoned , beaten and charged to desist , c. 4 & 5. Stephen taken and stoned , c. 6 & 7. And thereupon the Church of Jerusalem by a great Persecution , scattered , c. 8. & 11. v. 19. After we have Herods persecuting the Christians , killing James , and imprisoning Peter , with intention to put him to Death , c. 12. The Rulers persecute Paul and Barnabas at Antioch , c. 13. and at Iconium ; and at Lystra Paul is stoned , c. 14. He and Silas whip'd and imprison'd by the Roman Magistrates , c. 16. Persecuted at Thessalonica , c. 17. A Tumult against Paul , &c. c. 19. He saith , bonds and afflictions wait for him in every City , and that grievous Wolves should enter among them , not sparing the Flock , c. 20. And what Persecutions he suffered at Jerusalem , not only from the Rabble , but the Chief , both of the Jews and Romans , may be seen in the following Chapters . Most of his Epistles were written in Bonds . And it s generally said , that he suffered at Rome under Nero , as Peter , many say , did also . And St. John's Banishment into the Isle of Patmos , is certain ( as 't is said ) by the Emperour Domitian . And Hospinian hath observed , that from the Apostles time , till Bishop Sylvester and the Emperour Constantine's , for above 300 Years , not one of all those 30 Bishops of Rome , but suffer'd Martyrdom . But Fuller adds , that the same publick calamities were usually common to the Jews with the Christians ; and therefore if they kept their Synagogues , why might not these their Churches . Mede also urgeth this of the Jewish Synagogues , because the Jews Religion was no more the Empires than the Christians . Both which we deny , for the Jews were the Persecutors , and the Christians the Persecuted : they usually stirring up and incensing the Gentiles against these , as the Acts of the Apostles testifie , and St. Paul , 1 Thes . 2.14 , 15 , 16. Nor had the Christians then any Churches , as the Jews had Synagogues , tho they had in some Cities separate Meetings . Of the Jewish Synagogues we read in Scripture , but neither Scripture nor History mentions any publick Churches for 200 Years . And afterwards , when they had some Oratories , we read of courses taken for demolishing them : but not ( much less at the same time ) of the Jewish Synagogues . These having been long before , publickly tollerated in many Places to the Jews where they resided . And they having now renounced Christ , the Devil and Heathen Emperours had no cause to disquiet them , but made use of them in opposing Christianity . As Julian we know , employ'd them for building again their Temple at Jerusalem , to despite the Christians . And no Religion is more hated of a Natural Man than the True ; all others being prefer'd before this . Mr. Mede in answering the Objections against his Opinion , endeavours to enervate this of Persecution two ways . ( 1. ) By asserting , that the greatest Persecutions ( as the five last of the Ten ) fell out in the Third Century , wherein 't is granted the Christians had some Oratories , and therefore why not in the two former , seeing their Persecutions were not continual , nor of long duration . But tho we grant , in regard of the abundance of Bloud-shed , the last were the cruellest ; yet was there always such as hindred , both the erecting and appropriating Churches , and publickly assembling ( the Laws and Emperors being their Enemies ) contenting themselves to meet as they could with the most safety in secret . And tho their Persecution was not constant , yet were they constantly liable thereunto , as the Apostle tells us , Rom. 8.36 . For thy sake we are killed all the day long , we are accounted as Sheep for the Slaughter . Histories also shew us , their Sufferings were more continual , and less interrupted , in the two first , than third Century . Wherein after a sore Storm under Valerian , they enjoy'd a comfortable calm , under his Son Galienus , who restored to them their Cemeteries , and all other places of Worship ; which was such a favour or Tolleration , as we read not of in the two first Ages . ( 2. ) Mr. Mede argues from the credibility of the Christians having Oratories in the Roman Empire , as well as in the Persian . Which we deny , for 't is the Roman Empire only , that is represented under the Shape of a Red Dragon with 7 Heads and 10 Horns , making War with the Saints of God. Nor are we now dealing with a matter of Opinion , or Credibility , but matter of Fact and History ; which ascertains the Persecution under the Roman Emperors for 300 years , but mentions little or none at all , under the Persian Monarchs , during that time , tho afterwards , as Sozomen l. 2. c. 8. relates by Saporez , which was long before Isdigerdis , who was Contemporary with Theodosius . Nor doth the Churches of Persia prejudice our Opinion ; seeing they were but ( by Mr. Mede's acknowledgment ) in Constantine's time . Before which , there were some Churches in the Roman Empire . For Dioclesian his Predecessor made an Edict for the demolishing them . Having thus vindicated our Argument from several Attacks : We may further enforce it , both by the experience of former Ages , and also our own . The Israelites in Egypt , tho they dwelt together , a long time at least , yet we read not of any Temples they built there . And when they were in Captivity in Babylon , tho we read of their building Houses , Jer. 29. yet nothing of Synagogues . Pass on from the Heathenish to the Popish Persecutions , former and latter : Where at this day , in Italy , France , Spain and Portugal , are any Churches built , or Publick Meeting-Places for Protestants ? Nay even the Lutherans will not allow the publick exercise of the Reformed Religion . The Story of the German Church under Johannes a Lasco , who fled from London , to avoid the Persecution under Queen Mary , to the Lutherans , and how barbarously treated , is well known , and lamentable to consider . And the same spirit continues , so that the Dutch Church at Hamburg go to Altena , and the English are confin'd to their own House . Sweden is expelling them , and several Princes persecuting them . Nor need we go so far , the experience of these Three Kingdoms is sufficient . Where altho the Persecution of the Nonconformists , was not from the Heathens , ( as the Primitive Christians : ) Nor from Papists ( as the Waldenses of old , and all Dissenters from them generally ever since : ) Or any Protestants of a different Denomination ; nor to death ; but only Fines or Imprisonments . &c. Yet who went about to build any publick Places for Worship , or had such , till a Tolleration was granted them ? Who can imagine any so mad , as to build or buy publick Places , where their Enemies are Rulers ; and having all Civil Power in their hands , would not only shut them up , or demolish them , but also severely punish such presumption . SECT . 3. Our 2d Argument is from the defect of sufficient Testimonies from Scripture , of the Christians having any publick appropriate places in the Apostles time ; or from authentick Authors , of any such the two first Centuries . Nor let any think it sufficient to say , that Argumentum ab autoritate non valet negative ; an Argument from authority negatively , is of no force . For in Religion , Scripture so argues , not only in matter of our duty , because never commanded ; but also in matter of History , as Hebr. 7.14 . Our Lord sprang out of Juda , of which Tribe Moses spake nothing concerning Priesthood . Whence by the way , we may gather , that our Saviour never went further into the Temple , not being a Priest of the Tribe of Levi , than the Outward Court. And in matters of Fact so many Hundred Years ago , this way of arguing is generally used and received . As Baronius useth it in a like case , A. D. 48. and others also frequently . For how should we know , what was done so long since , but by History . Now in all the diligent searchers into Antiquity , as Eusebius , Hierom , Clemens Alexandrinus , and other Ancient Fathers and Authors , we find no footsteps of any publick Churches , the two first Centuries ; but many against them . For the Scriptures , whosoever reads the Apostles Acts , which contain their History about 32 Years ; will find the Church assemblies still in private Houses , as c. 12. v. 12. so c. 20. v. 8. and to the very last , c. 28. v. 29 , 30. so also in their Epistles . And the all places were indifferent to them in respect of holiness , yet not of conveniency ; so that according thereto , no doubt they were appointed ; and in the heat of Persecution , such as were most secret and secure . And will never find the Church therein taken for a Place . It being the general Opinion of Protestants , which the Learned Lutheran , Gerrard de Eccles . c. 2. relates . In S. literis significatio Ecclesiae pro loco non occurrit ; sed progressu temporis factum , ut à Scriptoribus Ecclesiasticis tandem reciperetur . Sed quilibet videt hanc appellationem esse impropriam , & 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 . In the Holy Scriptures , the Church is no where taken for a Place ; tho in process of time , it came to be so used in Ecclesiastical Writers . But every one sees , the taking of it in this sense , is improper and catachrestical . Camero likewise , a Learned Calvinist , in 's Tract . de Ecclesia , and generally all of both Professions . So that we may conclude as to the Scriptures , that however the grand Tyrant Custom prevailed in after Ages , to call the Place by the name of Church , yet from the beginning it was not so . And for human Testimonies ; for the first Ages succeeding the Apostles , we might here produce very many , to prove the Primitive Christians had no such publick Churches or Temples . But in regard we sustain the negative part , and our Opponents the affirmative , to whom the Proof most properly belongs , according to the Maxim , affirmanti incumbit probatio : And those that favour our Adversaries Opinion , will be apt to say , we do but beg the Question ; for that they have both Scripture , and good Humane Testimonies for them . We shall therefore first examine what they alledge ; and afterwards produce such Witnesses against them , as we shall willingly submit to the judgment of all impartial Men , on which side the Truth lies . For if they can either by Scripture , or approved Authors , mantain their cause , we shall yield it ; notwithstanding the improbability therof , from the Persecutions the Christians were under in the first Ages . But here we must profess , that this being matter of fact , we are not to be put off , nor shall we acquiesce with conjectures or probabilities , such as Platina , Polid. Virgil , &c. urge , from the Apostles and Primitive Christians zeal to promote Religion , ( as if there could be none , without such appropriate and consecrated Places , as they call Churches ) But there must be authentick Records , from approved Authors , that there were such in the Apostles days , and the two first Ages after our Saviour ; otherwise we can have no certainty of what was done at such a distance from us , so many Ages agone . SECT . 4. We shall therefore now enter the Lists with our Adversaries , and not decline any of their Weapons , being well secur'd by the shield of Truth . Tho we take no notice of several flourishes they make , that being needless , in regard of the several Editions of the Authors , wherein they may be seen , and especially of Mede , our principal Adversary . From Scripture , especially 1 Cor. 11.18 , 20 , 22. which Bellarmine c. 4. de cultu sanctorum , and Baronius , produce for Churches and Oratories distinct from private Houses in the Apostles days . Answered at large by Vedelius in his Exercitation upon Ignatius's Epistle to the Magnesians . Mr. Fuller likewise , who argues that from that the Apostle having said , v. 18. when you come together in the Church , forthwith expounds it by v. 20. when you come together in the same place ; shewing by the Church he denotes the Place . But here he supposeth , that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , is to come together in the same place ; which is denied . For men cannot come , or meet together , but in some place , either natural or artificial . Beza renders it in unum , others simul or conjuncti : I should ad idem . For the expression is Hellenistical , and signifies not only a Concourse in the same place , but agreement . in condition , and concurrence in the same action , tho in different places , according to the Septuagint . Even as in Acts 2.44 . and other Texts it must be understood ; for both the diversity of Tongues , and multitude of Christians , as five thousand , c. 4. v. 4. manifest it could not be in the same place . Camero in his Myrothecium , shews the Phrase is taken from the Septuagints Version of Psalm . 2.2 . where the Princes assemble together , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , not in reference to the same place , but to their conjunction in heart and counsel about the same thing . Which sence Dr. Hammond follows , on Acts 1.15 . If any object , if the Church be not the place , but the People , 't is as much as to say , when you meet together in a Meeting . But this is also denied , for 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 signifies only the general Notion of coming together , or assembling , as Acts 11.26 . but the Church , a special , viz. a holy Meeting . So that 't is not the place , but the imployment , that gives the denomination . For as it is not in every place , where the Senators or Parliament-men meet , that there is a Senate or Parliament . Nor in every place , where the Pastors of the Church meet , is there forthwith a Synod . Seeing both sorts may come together at Fasts or Feasts , or other occasions . But there and then only , where and when they meet to deliberate about affairs , Civil or Ecclesiastical . So wheresoever the Members of a Church come together , they are not for that said to come together in the Church , but only then and there , when and where they come together for the exercise of Religion . But the chief Argument all our Opponents make use of , is from v. 22. where they assert an Antithesis or Opposition , between private Houses proper to each , and the Church which is common to all . Let us therefore duly consider it . And ( 1. ) That tho the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 be used above 100 times in the New Testament ; yet this is the only place our Protestants insist on for their Opinion . Altho Bellarmine alledgeth also , 1 Cor. 14.25 . which yet clearly proves the contrary . ( 2. ) We deny , as Camero in his Answer to Fuller , ( Tract . de Eccles . c. 1. ) that the opposition here , is made between the doing of any thing in this or that place ; but in the presence of others , or not in their presence . As when one doth that in publick , which should be done at home ; we rate him saying , Hast thou not an House of thy own ? Dost thou despise the City ? understanding not the Structures or Streets , but the faces of the Citizens who are there . And that this is the Apostles meaning , appears both by the following words , and shame them that have not : that is the poor Brethren , that had neither Money to buy , nor Provisions to bring for their Feasts of Charity ( then in use at the Sacrament of the Lords Supper . ) So that 't is not despising the Place , but the Persons ; putting the poor ( who are a great part of the Church ) to blush and be ashamed . And also by a parallel Place in this Epistle , c. 14. v. 34 & 35. where the Apostle forbids their Women to speak in the Churches , And if they will learn any thing , let them ask their Husbands at home ; for it is a shame for Women to speak in the Church . Where we see a plain opposition , between the Church and their own Home ; which yet cannot be understood of the Church as a Place : The Case being clear , that it was not unlawful for Women to speak in such a Place simply , but only at such a time when the Congregation was at Divine Worship : otherwise , it would be unlawful for any Woman , before or after Publick Worship , to speak in the place . Nor was it sinful surely , for Women to speak at their Love-Feasts , tho in the Church . Besides , 't is said , your Women in the Churches , which implies , there were more than one Congregation in the Church of Corinth . I shall not stand to alledge Commentaries on 1 Cor. 11.22 . as Cajetan , who is absolutely for the Congregation , and Aquinas , and Carthusian , as also Dr. Pearson on the Creed , p. 337. say , it may as well be so understood as of the place . But further prove the Truth ( 3. ) By the Argument which the Apostle draws from the holiness of the Meeting , and not from the holiness of the Place , to take the Corinthians off from their Dissentions , v. 18. for in every Meeting , Dissentions are to be avoided ; but in a holy Meeting , ordained for Religion , they ought to be detested . And so from Intemperance , v. 20 , 21. shewing unity in the Truth of Doctrine , and unanimity in affections are necessary for the right receiving the Lords Supper , in the following Verses . And I would further argue with mine Opponents , suppose their meeting had been on some Mountain , or in some Cave , ( which was not unusual ) and the faults here mentioned had been committed ; should they not have been liable to the same censure of despising the Church of God ? But ( 4. ) Should we grant the opposition they make , between the Church and their own Houses , yet will not this serve to overthrow our Opinion , or establish their own ; except they can further prove , this Church or Place to have been publick , and not in a private House , like unto others mentioned throughout the Acts. Mr. Mede carries this 22d verse , for a reproof of the Corinthians , for using profane Banquetings and Feastings in a sacred place , to introduce his Opinion of the holiness of Churches , as Bellarmine c. 5. de cultu sanct . saith , Satis inn●it●r , tunc etiam Ecclesiam aliquo modo sacratam fuisse , hence 't is sufficiently gathered , that even then the Church was some manner of way holy ; which he saith , was for consecration . But Mede runs against the stream of Interpreters , who expound it of their Love-Feasts . Neither doth the Apostle reprove them for any such thing , but for their schismatical , unbrotherly and intemperate Carriage therein . These Love-Feasts , a Lapide , as Austin , Aquinas , Cajet an , and others , think preceeded ; and Justinian as Chrysostom and divers others , that they followed after the Communion . The Opinions of the Ancients concerning their order , are cited by these two Learned Jesuites upon the place , where they may be seen ; and the manner of them in Kerchers Roma Subterranea l. 6. c. 27. As far as my reading reaches , tho these Love-Feasts sometimes were before as in the Church of Alexandria , ( as Sozomen saith , l. 7. c. 19. ) and some others : Yet more usually they followed after the Sacrament . However , we have multiplicity of Testimonies in the Writings of the Ancients , for them at the Communion in the Primitive Church : and none I can find amongst them for Mr. Mede's Opinion , except Sedulius ; nor amongst the Modern , but Salmeroni ; and these quite contrary to the genius of the Text. But he proceeds to tell us , that as most of the Words signifying an Assembly or Company , are wont to be used also for the place ; so here 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 . Which we deny not in common Speech ; but then the expression is not proper , but figurative , continens pro contentis , the Place containing , for the Persons contained . He cites St. Austin taking the Church here for the place of Meeting . It 's true , he does so , on Leviticus , l. 3. c. 57. to which Bede on the Text refers , but only for the time wherein the Congregation met , Ecclesia dicitur locus , quo Ecclesia congregatur : And it is apparent , that the faults mentioned by the Apostle , are such only as were committed , at the time of their assembling for the Worship of God. Nor doth Austin appropriate it to a Place civil or artificial , as our Opponents do , not considering such abuses have their course in their Meetings in what place soever , natural or civil . The next Author he produceth is Basil , who pleads for the Holiness of Churches ; of which hereafter . Commentators follow . The Author of the Comments on the Epistles ( falsly ascribed to Hierom ) a Pelagian , seems to deliver the Opinion of others , rather than his own , saying , Quidam hunc locum ad illos referunt , qui Epulas in Ecclesia faciebant : facientes eam trielinium Epularum . And Sedusius ( whom the former Author seems to point at ) is of that Opinion , thinking it unlawful to keep their Feasts in the Church . Wherein he is singular , and contrary to the Apostle , who rectifies the abuse only , by admonishing them to stay one for another , and make their poor Brethren partakers with them of their Viands . Furthermore , even those that take the Church for a holy Place , and cite this ( as Sir H. Spelman and several others ) of the Corinthians making the Church trielinium Epularum , make it only a private Room , for trielinium was never taken for a House , much less a publick one . To which may be added , the practice in after Ages , in St. Austin's time , when the Christians kept their Love-Feasts in memoriis Martyrum , or in their Churches , as appears by his Answer to Faustus the Maniche , l. 10. c. 20 , 21. at large . As for Chrysostom , Theodoret , Theophilact and Cecumenius , tho they take the Church for a Place ; yet none of them as Mede , that the Corinthiaws fault was , in keeping there profane Banquetings : Nor otherwise than in reference to the very time only , of their meeting therein . And whereas Chrysostom says , the Church as well as the Poor were wronged ; he cannot , I suppose , mean it of the Place , for Time and Place cannot be said to be despised or dishonoured , but by an extrinsecal denomination , when God is dishonoured , or our Brethren , by our unchristian behaviour in the place . As here the latter member , being joyn'd thereto by a copulative , may fairly expound the former ( as usually ) viz. in shaming them that have not , you despise the Church , as Cajetan and Piscator expound it . So that tho the Grammatical opposition be between two places ; yet the Logical and Theological is between a place of many present therein , and a private place . From these Testimonies , Mede concludes there were places appointed , and set apart for Christian Worship , even in the Apostles times . But tho no Man doubts , that believes the Gospel , that the Christians had places for Worship ; yet it follows not thence , that they were set apart from all other uses , for Christian Worship . Neither doth he , or any other Opponent prove this . Places of meeting , the Ancients suppose , but separate Places they suppose not . It was 200 Years and more , e'er they had Publick Oratories . And when the Heathen objected they had no Temples , Altars nor Images , they freely confess as much . Having vindicated this Text in the Corinths , we shall briefly mention some others , alledged for separate and publick Churches : Tho some are so far-fetch'd , they deserve not mentioning . As Mr. Fuller from 1 Cor. 14.40 . That all things be done decently , and in order , inferring that publick Offices be done in publick Places , as much as may be . And what , I pray , is more publick than the open Air , Mountains and Fields where our Saviour instructed his Followers ? Likewise from Acts 19.9 . Paul separated the Disciples , disputing daily in the School of one Tyrannus : As if this School was one of the Temples of Christians , which he confesseth was but borrowed , or hired for the urgent necessity . His next place is Acts 15.21 . whence he argues , the Israelites from the beginning of their Commonwealth had Synagogues ; so the Christians from the day of Pentecost , Churches . But that is very dubious ; for tho I judge Synagogues much Ancienter than till after the Captivity ( whence many Learned Men date them ; ) yet that they were so Ancient as he makes them , cannot be proved . Nor will Ps . 74.8 . serve , admitting various Translations . The 70 , They have put down the Feasts ; Hierome , Tabernacula ; Montanus , Conventicula ; Junius , Synagogas , which denotes all kinds of Assemblies , Civil and Ecclesiastical , in their places ; as Gerhard de Eccles . c. 1. § . 4. shews at large . Nor that of Ps . 83.12 of which Sir H. Spelman hath a Discourse , at the end of his Tract de non temerandis Ecclesiis . And who sees not a vast difference ; the Israelites were a free State of themselves , and had Governours Civil and Ecclesiastical , supream and subordinate , in the Land of Canaan , of their own : Whereas the condition of Christians was quite otherwise , till Constantine's time , as all know . His last Scripture is James 2.2 . where 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Synagogue , is much more pregnant to denote a Place , than 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Church ; for of above 100 Texts where this is used , no one , except that in 1 Cor. 11.22 . is with any colour alledged for a Place ; whereas Synagogue is frequently so taken , both in the 70 , and in the New Testament , when applied to the Jews , as Acts 13.14 . & 14.1 . &c. tho sometimes for an Assembly , and most usually so when applied to Christians . As the Syriac here renders it ; and Beza , coetum : the vulgar Latine ( which some say is the Vetus Italica , and make great account of it , ( as our Bishop Andrews , &c. ) conventum ; as our last Version Assembly , and the former company ; declining the Word Synagogue , for no other reason , that I can conceive , but because they judged , that Christians had no separate Places in those days , as the Jews had ; James we know wrote to the Twelve Tribes dispersed , with whom the Word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , was in use , as Hellenistical ; so that after they became Christians , they might well call their Metting , of what condition soever it were , by that name : For the Word signifies all kinds of Assemblies , Civil and Sacred , as Dr. Hammond shews on Matth. 6.2 . from many Texts ; and here in James , Consistories for Judicature , by 5 reasons . And the Apostles having used the Word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or Church , to distinguish the Christians meetings from the Jewish , and as more proper , &c. ( which Gerhard in the Chap. above cited , notes ; ) the Name of Synagogue was soon given over among Christians , and such places called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ; but whether before they became separate places , or after ; and about what time such were built for Prayer , is the question . SECT . 5. Mr. Mede from Scripture , proceeds to enquire , what manner of Places these appropriate were , before he produceth the testimonies of Antiquity for such . Where first he acknowledges ( as Baronius had before him ) that they were not so goodly and stately , as after the Empire became Christian , and we now enjoy : But some capable and convenient room , within the Walls or Dwelling of some pious Disciple , dedicated by him to the use of the Church , usually an Upper-Room , such as that called Caenaculum Sionis , where the Apostles and Disciples after our Saviour's Ascension , usually assembled , and the Holy Ghost fell upon them , on the day of Pentecost . Concerning which place he brings a long Train of Traditions from Nicephorus ; a most fabulous Author , in the judgment of all Learned Men ; not worthy to be mentioned . Here let me observe the Difference amongst our Opponents . ( 1. ) As to the Place , Bellarmine and Baronius , as also our Fuller , conclude from that Text in the Corinths , for appropriate Houses or Churches ; but Mede only for one Room , usually an upper , in an House . ( 2. ) Bellarmine would have these Houses to be holy Temples , from the Christian Sacrifices therein , meaning the Mass , which he thinks is alone sufficient for the denomination of a Temple . For c. 4. de cultu sanctorum , he saith , Templum nihil aliud est , quam locus Altaris . A Temple is no other thing than the place of an Altar : called also , basilica , saith he , as erected at some Saints Sepulcher . Baronius and Fuller content themselves with the distinction of Oratories , which tho poor and mean amongst Christians , in comparison of the Heathens Temples , yet were those Temples , as well as these . But Mede will have his rooms , by reason of the Owners Dedication , to be Oratories and Churches : Tho Justinian distinguishes these , ( on 1 Cor. 11. ) saying , Christians had their meetings first in private Houses , afterwards in Oratories and Churches . And whereas Mr. Mede discourseth of a room and House , in the singular number ( as best suiting his Opinion of appropriate places , even in the Apostles days ) meaning without doubt , wheresoever there was a Church , as he instanceth in the coenaculum Sionis , in Jerusalem . All this is nothing better than building upon the Sand. For considering the several circumstances in Acts c. 1. & 2. its far more probable , that that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or upper Room , was in the Temple , than any private House As appears from several Authors and Arguments gathered together in Pool's Synopsis , on Acts 1 13. to which I refer , being unwilling to transcribe such Authors , as are common , and easily come at . Then what room could contain such numbers , as 3000 Acts 2.41 . which soon increased ( as some think ) to 5000 , or more probably , ( as others gather from the Text Acts 4.4 . ) were so many more . The ingenious Potter on 666. ch . 36. from the multitude of Believers in Jerusalem , computes that each of the Twelve Apostles might have about 500 under his care . Besides , the Gift of so many Tongues , implies their several meetings accordingly : for we must not fancy , as Salmasius and some others , that whoever spake in any Language , was understood by all : because this makes the Miracle to be in the Hearers , and not the Speakers ; who were inspired for preaching the Gospel abroad in the Nations , whose Languages they were ignorant of before . Consider also that hot Persecution that presently followed the year after , in the 8th of the Acts , and whether this did not necessitate them , often to change the places of their assembling , it being neither safe to meet in great multitudes , nor always in the same place . It 's probable also , from v. 3. by Saul's entring 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 into their several Houses , was either when , or where they assembled ; for into every House ( as we render it ) of so many Christians , as were in Jerusalem , seems to me improbable . I pass over the fabulous Traditions , and fictitious Glosses on Acts 10.9 . and 18.22 . especially , as unworthy the Author , and the least consideration . And can grant him that which follows , of some giving whole Houses , for sacred Assemblies , as the multitude of Believers increased ; tho this cannot be proved in the two first Centuries . As also , that at length , they built Structures in the Coemeteries of Martyrs ; which yet Platina and Polid. Virgil say , were but Sacella , Chappels , and those in secret and unknown places SECT . 6. We shall now proceed to examine their Testimonies : which Mr. Mede having most fully gathered , and regularly , of all our Opponents , ranked throughout the 3 first Centuries : We shall therefore follow his order , and paticularly consider them , as he represents them . Altho we think it not necessary to express all his words ; his Works by many Editions , being in most Scholars hands . He begins with Eusebius's relating a passage out of Philo the Jew , concerning the Essenes , whose manner of Life and Worship Philo describes ( p. 376. &c. and more fully in his following Book de vita contemplativa , p. 893. &c. of last Edition 1691. ) Which place in Eusebius l. 2. c. 17. Hist . Bellarmine before him had alledged , c. 4. de cultu sanctorum : tho they both knew Eusebius's being generally censured , for his accommodating it to the Christians . For its plain to any that peruses Philo , that he speaks of a Sect of Jews , who were Monks , and had each their proper place for Worship , called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , and one 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or common , wherein they assembled for Worship every 7th day . Whereas the Christians neither withdrew into Cells , nor observed the 7th , but the first day of the Week , from Christ's Resurrection , and the day of Pentecost , which fell on the first , and after , as appears by Scripture . And however confident Mede is , of Eusebius being of his Opinion , the contrary appears in 's Book de prepar . Evangel . l. 7. c. 6. & l. 13. c. 13. and Philo's Book of the Cherubims , shews he was not of Mede's mind . His next Argument is from the Apostles Salutations of several Persons , and the Church in his or their House . Which he understands not of Families , ( as he grants 't is commonly taken ) but the Congregation of Saints . Whence he infers , appropriate Places , and their Dedication by their Owners , to be Oratories for the Church in their several Cities . And he cites Lucian's Philopatris , for their Description . To which we reply , ( 1. ) That this proves no more , than that Christians had meetings in private Houses , which none denies : which yet were often interrupted , not only in Dioclesian's time , when they were examined if they kept their meetings in their Houses , as appears in the Acts of Martyrs , but in Tertullian's time also . ( 2. ) The Place in their Houses , was but a caenaculum , or Dining-Room , as Mede grants ; which as it was incapable of salutation , so of containing the whole Church in most of those Cities . For who can think their Houses , much less one room , so large , seeing Aquila was but a Tent-maker , banished from Rome by Claudius , after whose Death he returned , before St. Paul's Epistle to the Church there , wherein c. 16. v. 5 he salutes the Church in their House . And not only at Rome , but at Philippi , or Ephesus also , the Church that was in his House , as 1 Cor. 16.19 . And what the rest were that had Churches in their Houses , we read not . ( 3. ) The Church in their Houses is considered as distinct from themselves , that were Masters and Owners , and thus it is fairly applied to their Families : But if to the whole Congregation , the Persons whose Houses they were , being Members thereof , as well as any others , it were very improper . For so when St. Paul bids the Church of Rome , Salute the Church in Aquila and Priscilla's House , Rom. 16.5 . his meaning is , that the Romans should salute themselves . So in wishing the Colossians ( 4.15 . ) to salute the Church in Nymphas's House , he desires them to salute themselves . And so of the rest . Now to say these Masters of Houses , bestowed some part or place thereof to the Churches use , needs no proof ( for none can lawfully enter into another man's House , without his allowance ) but that they Dedicated them , doth : For if Dedication was then used ( of which hereafter ) yet surely not by a private person . And whereas some singular thing must be meant , saith Mede , he concludes , this of the whole Church in their House , must be it . Which is inconsequent . And tho it be unreasonable , to demand a reason of anothers actions , which himself conceals ; yet something may be gathered for this , from the Apostle . As for Aquila and Priscilla from Rom. 16.3 , 4. and Acts 18.26 . And as they were his helpers in Christ Jesus , that is in reference to the promoting the Gospel : so were Nymphas also , and Philemon , whom Paul calls his fellow labourer . As for Lucian , cited also by Baronius , for proof of Houses separate : Vedelius answers , ( 1. ) That the Dialogue Philopatris , is none of Lucian's , sed alterius alicujus scioli : and ( 2. ) That the place may as well be understood of a private as a publick House . His 3d proof is from Tradition , That Theophilus to whom St. Luke inscribes his Gospel and Acts , converted his House into a Church ; derived from the Traditions of Clemens . As Indens likewise mentioned , 2 Tim. 4.21 . a Roman Senator and Martyr from the Acta Pudentis . This of Theophilus mentioned by Bellarmine c. 4. de cultu sanct . from Clements Recognit . l. 10. and Baronius A. D. 58. num . 32. that had not found who he was , but in Clements Recognitions : Vedelius answers , — ( in Epist . Ign. ad Magnes . ) scriptis quae citat Baronius tantum deferendum est , quantum citanti : To the Writings cited by Baronius we are to give as much credit , as to the Citer . See the judgment of Papists concerning these Recognitions , in Coci censura Scriptorum , p. 20. of Pererius , Sixtus Senensis , Driedo , yea Baronius himself , A. D. 51. num . 53. who saith , That out of these Books , as out of a dirty Sink , are taken such prodigious Lies , and mad Dotages , as are not only to be reproved , but extreamly rejected by the Learned , &c. His last Testimony is from Clemens's Epistola ad Corinthios , who speaking of Gods Worship under the Gospel , saith , He hath determined where and by whom , &c. Whence Mede concludes , Places , as well as Times and Persons , were appropriate and distinct , in the Apostles days . Adding , that this Divine Ordinance is found in the Analogy of the Old Testament . To which I answer ( 1. ) That 't is granted this Epistle is authentick . Grotius hath in a large Epistle approved it . Salmasius de Epise . & Presbyt . and Blundel and Hammond in their Disciplinarian Controversies , own it for genuine . Junius and Dr. Fell , in their Notes vindicate it ; tho I know , a late Author , Ernestus Teutzelius a German hath largely answered them , and pronounces the Epistle spurious ; especially for the mention of the Phoenix therein . Whom I have had thoughts to refute , and animadvert on some others that have nibled at it , when I get time to publish various Observations I have upon it . For Dr. Wake in 's Introduction to his Translation , c. 2. hath only touched thereon . But ( 2. ) What needs Mr. Mede to make such a stir about Clemens's 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , when the Scripture hath determined , that God under the Gospel is to be worshipped every where , as Malachy 1.11 . From the rising of the Sun to the going down of the same . And our Saviour himself signifies as much , John 4.20 , 21 , 22 , 23. where he declares who are the true Worshippers of God under the Gospel , without any reference to place , in opposition to the worshipping him , in this or that place ; whether on the Mount where the Patriarchs worshipped him of old , or at Jerusalem where the Jews worshipped him afterwards . As Gorran observes , localitatem excludit : He excludes appropriation to any place , as necessary to Gods worship ; and adds , non determinat locum orationis alienbi , sed ubique ; determines not the place of prayer to any particular place , but enlarges it to every place . To every private House , Acts 9.11 , to the top of an House , 10.9 . to the Sea shore , 21.5 . so the Apostle , 1 Cor. 1 , 2. In every place call on the Name of Jesus Christ our Lord ; and 1 Tim. 2.8 . I will , that men pray every where . And undoubtedly Clement could not be ignorant of this , considering the persecuting times wherein he lived , when the Churches of God were driven from place to place , and constrained to meet as they could , with most safety . And Mede's saying , that Clemen's Divine Ordinance , for the place of Church Service , is to be found in the Analogy of the Old Testament ; seems very strange . For the Temple at Jerusalem was the only place God appointed for the Jewish Worship . And should the Christians by Analogy have but one Temple ? They had also many Synagogues , which our Churches more resemble ; yet where did God prescribe the place wherein they were to be built ? And as to his Principle . That as the Divine Majesty is most sacred , and incommunicable , so the things wherewith he is served , should not be common , but appropriate to that end . This proves nothing of the place , but only its qualification , that it ought to be appropriate , whereof any place is capable : nor doth Clemens mention any such separate or appropriate places ; of which we shall have occasion to speak more hereafter . As also how this Analogy hath misled him and several others , to assert the holiness of Places by Dedication , and Temples , Priests , Altars , and proper Sacrifices under the Gospel . SECT . 7. In the Second Century , Mr. Mede begins with the Testimonies of Ignatius the Martyr , A. D. 107. First with his confessed Epistle ad Magnesios ; and then with the spurious ad Antiochenos . But had he lived to have seen what is now extant , of and concerning these Epistles , by the great Luminaries of Learning in this Age , A. B. Vsher , Dally , Bp. Pearson , Larock , &c. he would never have laid such stress upon them . The manifest difference between the ancient genuine Copies , and the latter , is evident by their Translations ; particularly that of Caius College in Cambridge , which A. B. Vsher prefers to the common Greek Copies . Wherein this very place 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , &c. is quite differently rendred from Mede's ; carrying the words for an unity in Doctrine , not Devotion : and that they should all come into Christ , as into one Temple and Altar , making him both ; as alluding to 1 Pet. 2.4 . where the one Temple , into the which we are built up , coming unto him ; and one Altar Jesus Christ , and spiritual Sacrifices offered to God , in him as on an Altar , whereby they become acceptable . Not to insist upon 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or Temple , no ways agreeing to the meeting places of the Primitive Christians : as both Bellar. de Rom. Pontif. l. 3. c. 13. and Vedelius hath shewn sufficiently , from the Ancient Fathers . And that which follows in Mede , of one Bishop , and one Altar , in every Church , is not only alien to the scope of Ignatius , but the Truth also . For the Church of Ephesus had 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or Bishops , Acts 20.28 . so had the Philipians , 1.1 . and of Jerusalem , Narcissus and Alexander , who at the same time jointly governed the Church , as Eusebius relates . Gersom Bucer in 's Answer to Downam's Sermon , p. 302. proves the like in other Churches , by ten instances : and Vedelius the same , Exercit. 8. in Epist . Ignat. c. 3. And Epiphanius of old , professed that the Church of Alexandria was singular in this , of having but one Bishop . It 's true , the Inscription of the 7 Epistles , Apoc. c. 2 & 3. each , to the particular Angel of the Church , seems to imply that they had but one apiece . Which yet Mr. Mede himself sufficiently shews is inconsequent , in 's Comment on Apocal. p. 265. where he observes it the course in Scripture , to attribute that to one Angel , which is performed by the Ministry of many . What 's alledged from Justin Martyr is answered by Bucer ; and Sozomen acquaints us , ( Hist . Eccl. l. 7. c. 3. ) That even Villages had their Bishops ; and no wonder then , if one Lords Table in each might suffice to make them correlatives . Mr. Mede proceeds with another proof out of Ignatius's Epistle ad Antiochenos , ( wherein he salutes the Keepers of the holy Doors ) concluding thence holy Houses . This Epistle he endeavours to perswade us is genuine ( contrary to the judgment of all other Protestants ) from sundry probabilities . But this is a strange way of reasoning , That it 's likely such a thing should be done , and therefore it was done . And to say , because the Antiochians were his own Flock , I think rather makes it improbable ; because he had sufficiently established them in the Faith before he lest them ; which , when he went thence to Rome , to receive the Crown of Martyrdom , he endeavoured by his Epistles to do for other Churches . And surely they would have been careful above all other Churches , in keeping their own Pastor's Letter , if he had sent them one . And was not Polycarp as likely to be acquainted with this , as the rest . Besides that , if he or Eusebius had had any inkling of such an Epistle , surely they would have mentioned it , tho they could not meet with it . And how doth Mede prove any such Officers in the Primitive Churches ? that which he alledges for this from the Apostolical Constitutions , falsly father'd on Clemens , is yet stranger . For besides others , my Learned Countriman Cook , in 's censura Scriptorum , hath detected so much vanity , and many Lyes therein ( whereof he reckons Eight ) besides the censures of Athanasius , the 6 Synod in Trullo , Binius , Baronius , Bovius and Bellarmine ; that I wonder Mr. Mede , who knew all this , should once offer to produce them . I know Mr. Cook and many Learned Divines reject all Ignatius's Epistles : altho others , considering the Testimonies of the Ancients , acknowledge 7 for genuine , specified by Eusebius , Hierom and others , tho robbed of some passages mentioned by the Fathers ; and also have a number of beggarly patches added to his Purple , as A. B. Vsher saith : Of which 7 , this ad Antiochenos is none , and therefore not genuine ; for more were not found nor acknowledged by Polycarp ( who composed them together ) Euseb . Hierome , Sophronius and Ruffinus . What Mede observes besides , is the Argument of Baronius An. 109. numb . 19. and Gretser against Whitaker de S. Script . l. 4. c. 7. Which I shall not need to answer , it being done already so fully by Vedelius on Ignatius's Epistles ( whom Mede more especially undertakes in this Treatise ) in 's pref . c 3. ( wherein he refutes Martialis , Mastraeus , Baronius and Pellarmine ) and his Exercitation on this Epistle : that I need not mention , Cook , Scult●tus , Rivet , Gerhard , Erockman , &c. Mede's next Testimony , is from two Epistles of Pius the First , Bishop of Rome ; relating in the former how Euprepria , titulum domus suae pauperibus resignavit , ubt nune cum pauperibus nostris commorantes missas agimus ; resigned the Title of her house to the Poor , where now ( saith Pius ) we residing with our poor , say Mass . And in the latter of a Presbyter that erected a Titulus or Church . To this , which Baronius alledged before to the same purpose , an . 57. numb . 98 , 99 , 100. and Vedelius answered : We further say , ( 1. ) These Epistles are forged , as Causabon's Exercit . 16. shews , For if Mass was so early , how came it , saith he , that no footsteps thereof is extant in approved Authors , for above 300 Years ? And Bishop Morton in 's Book of the Mass l. ● . § . 1. not before St. Ambrose time , about A. D. 373. who uses it in another Notion than Papists do since . And Morney of the Mass , l. 1. c. 1. saith it was unknown for 400 years . Not to mention the many Authors , who have handled this Argument of the Mass , against Bellarmine , and other Papists largely . I shall only name du Moulin on the Mass in French , and more largely in Latine , c. 1. for the Pedigree of the Mass . ( 2. ) We answer , This was most likely some room in the House ( seeing they dwelt therein ) where they said Mass ; and were it the whole House , yet was it but a private one , which scarce any wise man would call a Temple . And for the name of Title , that was given at pleasure . So that were these spurious Epistles authentick , they neither prove our adversaries Opinion , nor disprove ours . Mr. Mede produceth next Theophilus Antiochenus , l. 2. ad Antolycum ; who saith , God hath given Synagogues , which we call holy Churches , &c. Which yet is confest by him to be doubtful . For ( saith he ) if it were probable Synagogue was here taken , as usually in the New Testament for a place , then Church likewise for a place . To which we say , that if Church , in a hundred places of the New Testament , be taken for a Congregation : then 't is most probable , it 's so taken here . And the sense of the words makes this evident ; for Theophilus compares Heresies to rocky Islands ; and the wholesome Doctrine of Truth and Holiness , to good and habitable Islands ; and not the places of Truth and Heresies . The last Author in this 2d Century alledged , is Clemens Alexandrinus ; who useth the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or Church , for the Place , and not the Congregation only , Stromat . l. 7. And so again in the story of the young man , who had left the Church , and betook himself to a Mountain with Robbers . That Christians had places of meetings is beyond all doubt ; but we say in private Houses and Places for 200 years and upwards . Nor doth Clemens or any other , prove they had publick Oratories . And Vedelius , p. 74. upon this passage of Clemens , shews , they did not think this appellation so proper and convenient . Therefore Salvian 200 years after , l. 3. de gub . Dei , Itaque Ecclesias vel potius Templa , &c. correcting the impropriety , in using Churches , for the places of assembling , and preferring the word Temples . And for the opposition of Church and Mountain , in the story of the young man , that became Captain to a Band of Robbers : The sense is plain , that he left the company of Christians , rather than the place of their Assembly , to associate with Robbers on the Mountains . Thus for the two first Centuries , we have heard the noise of our Adversaries Artillery , which was nothing but Powder , and vanished into Smoak , without any Shot , that might in the least wound our cause . SECT . 8. Mr. Mede goes on with the 3d Century , wherein we shall follow him at the Heels , tho not obliged thereto , by our Assertion . For I know no Protestant that in this Century denies Christian Oratories ; but only in the two first . And therefore 't is not fair to feign Adversaries , and represent us as denying that we willingly grant . We know well , the Church being considerably increased , Oratories were built ; and the fate that followed them , namely , to be demolished . For Eusebius relates , how before Dioclesian's days , there was both an enlargement of Churches formerly built ; and an addition of new , more large and stately than the former , which were also destroyed in his Reign ; and towards the end of this 3d Age the Christians not only questioned for affording their private Houses to meet in , but moreover tortur'd for it . Add hereunto , that Mede still goes on to pervert the state of the Question : as if private Houses and secret places in sore Persecutions ( which none denies ) were publick Oratories , Churches or Temples . The first Author cited by him is Tertullian in three places , whereof the first hath reference to the Assembly ; and if to the place , yet only to the time of Worship ; for which an upper room served ; as Hospinian ( de orig . Templ . c. 3. ) explains him ; and the second citation implies as much , where 't is said their House was in editis & apertis , in high and open places , as their coenacula or upper rooms were ; seeing in Temples tho never so large , people are upon the Ground . I shall not meddle with what is added of Churches anciently looking Eastward ; ( for which Bellarmine gives ●ive reasons , c. 3. de cultu sanct . ) further than by referring to such Antiquaries , as have treated thereof ; Walfridus Strabo , Hospinian and others . The 3d is in 's Book de corona militis ; several others being waved : ( all which are brought to the same purpose by Baronius , A. D. 57. num . 99. except that one out of l. de spectaculis . ) There c. 3. it s said , those that were to be baptised , first made their abrenunciation of the Devil , &c. in the Church , and after again at the Water . Upon which Mede , to serve his own Hypothesis , supposeth their Baptisteries , were not then , as now our Fonts , within , but without the Church , and often in places very remote from it . But how will he , or any other prove that there were any Baptisteries in Tertullian's time , distinct from the places of their Assemblies . Hospinian that was well versed in Ecclesiastical Antiquities , finds none before Constantine's time , de orig . baptisterii , p. 30 , 31. For as no place for Baptism was prescribed by Christ , or his Apostles , but lest indifferent , and accordingly used at first : so we find nothing certain concerning this in the Primitive Church . The History of Basilides in Euseb . l. 6. c. 5. manifests that some were baptised in Prisons , and Cyprian's Epistle to Magnus , that sick persons were baptised in their Beds . Nor doth it follow , the Church here is not the Assembly , because that was also at the Baptistery . For if there were such ( as I think there was not ) yet a part more likely was only there ; and probably the abrenunciation was not the same day . However , without all doubt , it was not made but when the Church was assembled , and respected the Assembly and not the Place . Consider but those times , and what Tertullian saith to encourage the Christians to meet , notwithstanding the danger thereof , Si Fides transferre potest montem , annon potest militem ? Can Faith remove a Mountain , and can it not remove a Soldier ? and again , If you cannot keep your Dominicals in the Day , keep them in the Night : and , then judge , if he can be thought a support to our Adversaries . His next Witness in Hyppolytus , who in 's Tract de Antichristo , saith , then 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , The Temples of God should be as common Houses : And Churches every where demolished , &c. This Author is cited by the Rhemists , to prove that Antichrist should abolish their Mass : but of small or no account with Protestants . For he makes Antichrist to be the Devil , appearing in the shape of a Man ; and that John the Evangelist is not yet dead , but shall continue with Enoch and Elias till the time of Antichrist . And lived in Cryptis , or subterraneous Vaults , as Baronius writes A. D. 259. numb . 10. where he officiated also , as Eusebius relates . So that Mede's inference , that he was well acquainted with such places , as Temples and Churches , seems less probable , ( seeing we read of none before ) than that this Tract is supposititious . Besides that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 agrees not to Christian Churches , as both Bellarmine and Vedelius have largely proved , which we mentioned before . For the same time Lampridius an Historian is cited , who reports , Quod cum Christiani quendam locum , qui publicus flier at , occupassent ; contra Popinarii dicerent , sibi cum deberi ; Alexander Mammeae Imperator rescripsit : melius esse , ut quomodo cunque Deus illic colatur , quam Popinarits dedatur . That when the Christians had possest a publick place ; which the Victualers challeng'd to belong to them ; Alexander the Emperour determined ; it was better , that God should be there any manner of way worshipped , than that the Victualers should have it . This Passage is brought by Baronius , A. D. 57. num . 101. for the same purpose ; who yet afterwards , A. D. 224. confesseth , that at that time the Christians had no Church there , but chose that place to build one in . For which he alledgeth a fabulous Miracle . But Platina in the life of Calixtus , believes not this , by reason of the frequent Persecutions in those days . Calixtus himself having suffered Martyrdom . And Baronius acknowledgeth , that Persecution was frequent in this Emperour Alexander's days , and divers suffered Martyrdom , even the Bishop of Rome himself . So that 't is doubtful , whether they built any publick Oratory , in that publick place , during his Reign ; and if they did , 't is the first we read of in any Classic Author . The next Author is Gregory of Neocaesarea , Sirnamed Thaumatourgus , who in an Epistle called canonica , describes the Discipline then in use , with the distinct and regular places for Penitents , ( who stood without the Gate of the Oratory ) Auditors , and others that stood within , as the Catechumens and Faithful in distinct places . And further in 's Life written by Gregory Nissen , 't is said , that he was a great Founder and Erecter of Churches ; whereof that built by him at Neocaesarea in Fontus ( where he was Bishop ) Gregory Nissen saith , was still standing in his time , having remained unshaken in a great Earthquake , which had thrown down all other Edifices both publick and private . Now let it be granted , That this Canonical Epistle is genuine ; tho I will not say , as Bellarmine , that without controversie 't is so ; even for that which he saith is certain . That this Gregory made a short Confession of Faith , which he learned of John the Evangelist , appearing unto him in the company of the blessed Virgin , the Mother of God : and the many monstrous Fables father'd on this devout Man , by the name of Miracles . But because Balsamon , the learned Canonist , hath commented upon it , I shall not reject it ; tho neither Christ our Lord and Lawgiver , nor his Apostles , no nor the Church of the First Age , ( wherein like occasions were given by defection ) ever made such orders , or used such distinctions of places : which any considering man will judge , more befitting peaceable than persecuting times . And ( 2. ) We further grant , as we have several times suggested , that in this Third Century the Christians had their publick Oratories , small at the first , and afterwards enlarged , as Eusebius testifies , Hist . l. 8. c. 1. tho most in secret , by reason of Persecution . So that neither this , nor the following Testimonies , prejudice our Assertion : nor prove theirs , of such publick and separate places of Worship , both in and ever since the Apostles times . But how Gregory Nissen came to believe , that the Temple Thaumaturgus built , continued till his time , I know not . For whosoever considers the many Edicts , made by Heathen Emperors between these two Gregory's days , for demolishing them all , will think this incredible . Except some Ruderaes remaining , and a Temple after built upon them , was accounted the same ; like as that which we read in the Gospel , of Solomon's Porch . Or that it was preserved by a Miracle , as Baronius thinks , and that a greater , than its preservation in the Earthquake . For the Decree of Dioclesian was very general and severe , for demolishing all Churches ; which both Theodoret and Eusebius write , was so punctually executed , that all were pulled down , not one by them excepted . And this Decree came forth from Nicomedia , a City in Bithynia , upon which Pontus bordered , wherein Neocaesarea stood , and therefore very unlikely this should be spared . But if any have so strong a Faith to believe , what is reported of this great Wonder-worker Gregory , he may possibly think that he had sufficient power to restrain Dioclesian's Agents , and defend the Church he built . For Baronius at the Year 253. num . 135 , 136 , 137. relates what power he had over Devils , to cast them out of their Temples , and drive them out of any place , whither he pleased , and restore them also at his pleasure : which he did , to shew his power , to one in writing under his hand , saith Baronius , in these words , Gregorius Satanae , ingredere ; Gregory to Satan , enter in , that was into his Temple again . And Bellarmine relates another Miracle of him upon this very Argument , c. 4. de cultu Sanct. saying , That when he would have built a Church , and wanted room , by reason of a Rock , that border'd on the place , where he would build it , he by his prayers removed it away . Mr Mede was wiser than to mention this , for Gregory's building of Churches . And indeed none can imagine , how much prejudice such fabulous Miracles and lying Legends ( decryed and detested even by many sober and Learned Papists ) hath done to Christianity . Let but any one read a Pamphlet Printed this very Year , of a Conference between a Jew and a Jesuite , at Amsterdam ; concerning Christ being the true Messiah , which this undertaking to prove by his Miracles ; was replied upon by the other , with a Number as great , out of many Popish Authors , insomuch that the Jew quite confounded the Jesuite . And wheras Mr. Mede notes , that a litle before the persecution of Decius ( which was A. D. 252. ) the Christians erected Oratories , in the Name of Christ . I desire Baronius may be consulted , and then let any one judge , how improbable it is that Christians had publick Churches , with such distinction of places , as is mentioned or built such Publick Oratories , as our Adversaries say . For Decius gave express order to forbid all Christian assemblies ; upon pain of Death , threatning accurate observing them ; ( because many Heathens were converted thereby to Christianity . ) As appears by Aemilianus his writing to Dionysius Bishop of Alexandria in Euseb . l. 7. c. 9. vel 10. and Baronius ad A. D. 260. Num. 17. who further relates , how their very Coemateria or burying places ( which were Vaults under ground , called cryptae , as Baronius shews A. D. 259 num . 16. ) usually a Mile or more from their Cities ( which were often after some time discovered ; and then how dangerous it was to meet there , he shews . A 255 ) were now strictly forbidden them in particular , as well as in the general all other places whatsoever . Cyprian contemporary with Gregory , is next alledged for Christian Oratories . ( 1 ) In his book de Opere and Eleemosynis , by the Name of Dominicum brought also by Bellarm. c. 4 de cultu Sanct. ( 2 ) In 55 Epistle , by the Title of Ecclesia . We never doubted , but Christians had from the first Oratories , or places of Meeting : And that in this Century some publick , which as the Church increased , were inlarged . But that even in Cyprian's time their assembling were in subterraneous Vaults ; both at Alexandria , as we have shewn ; and Rome , as is clear by Pope Cornelius's Letter to the Bishop of Vienna , as Baronius testifies A. 255. n. 47. and here at Carthage in Africa , A. 260. n. 37. Where the Proconsul urged Cyprian himself with the Emperors Edict , ne in aliquibus locis conciliabula fiant , nee caemeteria ingrediantur ; that the Christians should not meet in any places , nor enter into their Coemeteries . In which they usually celebrated the holy Mysteries ; which Pameltus calls the Sacrifice ; but Goulartius , the Word , Sacraments and Prayers ; performed only , when the Church assembled . Nor is the opposition mentioned , of any force , as we shew'd on 1 Cor. 11.22 . Another Contemporary cited , is Dionysius Alexandrinus in 's Epistle to Basilides , declaring his Opinion , That Women during the time of their Separation , ought not to enter into the Church , which he calls the House of God. By which we learn , saith Mede , not only the Christians had their Houses of Worship , but a religious respect also , to difference them from common places . To this we say , as formerly , That Christians had always places for meeting in , but still whether in private Houses , or in publick lies the question . And if but a Chamber in a private House , where they worshipped God , it was sufficient to denominate it the House of God , as well as a Cathedral . And that their Assemblies then were very private , appears in that they were forbidden on pain of death ( as we have shewn ) and yet where this is related by Eusebius , Dionysius testifies , that nevertheless they kept them . But surely not in the usual places , where they had easily been discovered , to the loss of their lives ; but in all likelihood often changed the places , for their security . And whether every such , was thereby so sanctified , that it was unlawful for a menstruous Woman to enter thereinto , let any one judge . Nor was this a Canon , as Mede calls it , Baronius hath made apparent against Balsamon ; and by the equity of a contrary course taken by Pope Gregory , in regard that legalia or ceremonials are now abdicated . And if it were in force , it relates not to the Place simply , but the Offices there performed , and the time thereof , which suppose the Congregation present , from which such an one was to be excluded , whether the meeting was on a Mountain , or in an House , or under Ground , in Caves and Dens of the Earth . Nor need Mr. Mede tell us , such places were known to the Gentiles , and called worshipping places . For when the Christians were grown so numerous , before this time of A D. 260. as Tertullian thinks , near to equalize the Heathens ; their Assemblies could not possibly be concealed , whether above or under the Ground ( especially when they enjoyed any tollerable freedom from Persecution ) as appears by two Rescripts of Gallienus in Euseb . Hist . l. 7. c. 12. one for restoring all places in general to the Christians , and the other their Coemiteries in particular . Nor doth Aurelian's Speech in Vopiscus evince a publick place ; nor the opposition between the Capitol and Church imply the place ; but the Congregation rather , that stands in congruous opposition to the Sibyls Oracles . For they might be Masters of the Christian Oratories when they pleased , and there consult of what they list , even of setting forth the Books of the Sibyls . But Mr. Mede thinks his cause is supported by that of Eusebius l. 7. relating how Paulus Samosatenus being deposed by the Council , Aurelian decreed , that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the House of the Church , should be taken from him , &c. This Bellarmine c. 4. de cultu sanctorum , and also our Fuller alledge to the like purpose . Yet both ours confess , that some interpret it of domum Epifcopalem , the Bishops House . Belike Christopherson , tho a Popish Bishop in Queen Maries days , and zealous for the Opinion of our Opponents . So Baronius takes it , A. D. 272. num . 18. and our Learned Antiquary Sir H. Spelman , de non temerandis Ecclesiis , p. 64. for a House belonging to the Church of Antioch . And indeed 't is not reasonable to understand it , of a publick Temple , as Fuller calls it ; for to what purpose should he keep that , which could be of no use to him , neither for an Habitation , nor for publick Worship , being deprived of his Bishoprick for Heresie , and Domnus in his place : and the Congregation could keep him out of , without troubling the Emperour . Nor is it denied , that in the time Eusebius mentions between the 9 and 10 Persecution , for about 30 Years , several old Oratories or Churches were enlarged , and new built ; like as 't is manifest they were demolished by Dioclesian 40 years after . And were the 3 places of Eusebius alledged , taken for the place ; they speak of no more than an House or Houses , which denotes them private , not publick , as Churches and Temples . Mr. Fuller lays mighty stress on Eusebius calling them 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , which he renders prisca aedificia , ancient edifices : and from thence infers , that therefore there were Oratories or Churches , even in the Apostles times . For he tells us , the Learned define saeculum , an age , to denote 100 years : and that one age is not sufficent to denominate houses prisca , or antient ; considering that monas an unity , is not to be accounted a number ; wherefore they must be of two Ages at least , or more , to be termed Ancient . But all this is very strange talk . For ( 1. ) Eusebius hath nothing answerable to saeculum an age . ( 2. ) If monas an unity be no number ; then one hundred years , or one thousand . is no number ; and so should be insufficient to denominate any thing ancient . ( 3 ) The Phrase may either import the distance of time , between their erection and amplification ; or the distance between their erection , and the time when Eusebius wrote , which was considerably longer , and more probably I think to be here meant . ( 4. ) Let it be considered , that we read of no Edifices before Decius and Valerians Persecution : and those specified only by coemiteria , places of Burial , in which they had their cryptae , Vaults under Ground ; which were forbidden them , and again restored and granted them by Gallienas . Now this Persecution by Decius and Valerian , was but about 40 years before Dioclesian's : so that if we take the Phrase for the time intervening , it imports no more than Edifices formerly built , and those not very ancient . ( 5. ) New and Old , are Terms of respect , and taken in great latitude ; so that now a Man of an hundred years , is truly accounted a very old man ; tho in the antedeluvian days , one of 200 but young , when Men lived to eight or nine hundred . And tho some of our Churches in England may be termed truly ancient , being perhaps of 6 or 700 years standing ; yet the eldest in Eusebius's time , could not be 300 ; nor hath any yet been proved to have been then an hundred years old . Such a Critick as Mr. Fuller might have observed the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is such , being both variously rendred , and applied in the New Testament . Sometimes to great Antiquity , as Mat. 11.21 . Hebr. 1.1 . and Jude 4. Sometimes to things not long before , as 2 Pet. 1.9 . He hath forgotten that he was purged from his 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , old sins ; and sometimes to that lately past , as Mark 15.44 . Pilate asked the Centurion , if Jesus had been 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , any while dead . But the Latin Version prisca aedificia , ancient Edifices , better suited his Hypothesis ; which made him adhere thereto rather than the Original Greek ; which may well be rendred priora aedificia , former edifices . Mr. Mede's last Witness , which he saith will dispatch all at once , and depose for the whole , and thinks alone sufficient to carry his Cause , is Euseb . Hist . Eccles . l. 8. c. 1. Where describing those Halcyon days , from Cyprian's Martyrdom to the Persecution of Dioclesian , the shews the vast multitude of Christians and their Meetings , cum antiquis illis aedificiis ( i. e. Oratories ) satis amplius loci non haberent , amplas spaciosasque in omnibus urbibus ex fundamentis , erexerunt ecclesias ; so that having no longer room enough in their ancient buildings , ( i. e. Oratories , as he had named them ) they erected large and spacious Churches from their foundations , in all their Cities . Here 's not only Churches in those days , but such as might then be called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , ancient Edifices , which how far it may reach , let others judge . But if this Witness will depose for the whole , there 's no thanks due to Mr. Mede ; considering that long before , this was dispatch'd ; Baronius having alledged the same , and Vedelius answered him , ( as he could not but know ) Exercit , in epist . ad Magnes . Tertio , Eusebii l. 8. c. 1. citat Baronius , & dicit eum asserere , longe ante Dioclesiani tempora fuisse Ecclesias . Sed falsum est , &c. Thirdly , Baronius cites the 8th Book of Eusebius c. 1. and saith , that he affirmeth Churches to have been long before Dioclesians time . But 't is false to say , Eusebius speaks of the time long before Dioclesians Reign . For he speaks only of that part of time , intermediating between the 9 and 10 Porsecution , ( or according to the computation of others the 8th and 9th ) as the series of the preceeding story , and the Text it self sufficiently shew . Now the Persecution preceeding Dioclesian 's began A. D. 272. under the Emperour Valerian , and ended about 10 years after . And the Persecution by Dioclesian began , as some account , A. D. 306. Whereby the ridiculousness of Baronius 's inference appears , viz. There were Churches long before the time of Dioclesian ; therefore in the very days of the Apostles there were such . As if I should say , Eusebius testifies , That for about 30 years before Dioclesian there were Churches : therefore he saith that there were Churches 300 years before Dioclesian . But this course is frequently used by Baronius , that corrupter of Chronicles . But that Mede insists on most , ( as others before him ) is that Phrase in Eusebius 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ancient Edifices . Which how far it may reach , faith he , let others judge . Belike he trusted more to his Readers forwardness , to embrace the suspicions this Phrase might raise , at first sight in their minds , than his own improvement of it ; that he turns it off with so short and slender a Remark , which in shew was his most pregnant proof . Or knowing that Fuller had done his best on the Phrase , waved the speaking further thereon . However , having spoken sufficiently , I think , to it in the former Paragraph , I need say nothing more in this . But that Eusebius mentions there , and also c. 2. and 6. is very remarkable ; and lets us see , that tho Prosperity be desired of all , yet few can use it aright : so that we may conclude , if it were best for God's People , they should enjoy it . For from Valerian's Persecution to Dioclesian's , the Church had a comfortable calm ( Aurelian's Edict made for Persecution , being never signed by him , God having terrified him with Lightning ( as Eutropius and Vopiscus affirm ) and so stopt his wicked Tyranny . ) But alas , instead of being better'd , they extreamly degenerated : So that Eusebius saith , God sent that direful storm of Persecution on them under Dioclesian , for the corruptness of their lives and manners . Maximè vero Ecclesiasticorum , in quorum vultu simulationem , in corde dolum , verbis fallaciam cernere licuit : livore , superbia , inimicitiis inter se certantes , tyrannidem potius quam sacerdotium sapere videbantur ; Christianae pietatis omnino obliti ; divina mysteria profanabant potius , quam celebrabant . Which I forbear to English . Those that please may read more in Fox's Martyrology in the 9th Primitive Persecution ? tho he misreckon it , there having been no general Persecution in Aurelian's Reign , who as he himself saith , rather intended , than moved Persecution . But for their wickedness followed the 10th . When their Churches were demolished , their Bibles burnt , their Persons punished with all kinds of cruelty ; neither Courtiers , nor Friends , not the Empress Prisca , nor Daughter Valeria spared ; his Decree was aut Deos Gentilium , aut mortem eligerent ; That the Christians should choose either the Heathen Gods or Death . Of this Tenth and greatest Persecution , Eusebius in his 8th Book of History . Lactantius de mortibus Persecutorum , from 7 to 49 Chap. with the Notes in Latin of 1693 , which are 10 times larger than the Text. And Fox in his first book of Martyrology , from Eusebius and several others , have written largely ; which I shall not transcribe , but dismiss with this short remark ; That of all the 10 general Persecutions , this last ( which was the forest , and continued above Ten Years , ) only reached England ; wherein Albanus first , and very many after , sealed their Faith in Christ with their blood ; so that Christianity was almost with the Scriptures , and Churches destroyed throughout the whole Kingdom , tho shortly after revived by the blessed Constantine . Having now examined all our Adversaries Witnesses we leave the Impartial Reader to judge of their validity ; and whether they prove the Christians to have had any publick appropriate places for Worship in the two first Centuries . Which tho undoubtedly most sit and convenient always ; yet in times of Persecution , men must do as they may , and meet as secretly as they can , and be constrained , often to change their meeting places , and when private Houses will not serve for secresie , to seek out Vaults under ground , where they may worship God. And yet not even in the most secret and retired places , without fear of their enemies , and danger of their lives : which shews our happiness in this regard , above theirs , who were much better than we . There is but one scruple , that I can imagine , remaining : and that is , tho these places were private , yet they might be , as Mede terms them , appropriate . To which I answer , that his first Argument for his Opinion , which immediatly follows , from their worshipping towards the East , implies that he takes them for Publick , and purposely built accordingly for that end . And ( 2 ) . who ever diligently peruses his Treatise , will see that he founds their appropriation ( as also their holiness , of which in the next Dissertation ) on their Consecration , ( or as he sometimes calls it Dedication . ) Now if we consider when this begun , Platina in vitis Pontif. tells us , That Telesphorus having suffer'd Martyrdom , in the first year of Antomus Pius ( which was about the year of our Lord 142. ) Hyginus an Athenian succeeded him . Who ordained these two things . First the use of those Witnesses we commonly call Godfathers and Godmothers , in the Administration of the Sacrament of Baptism . Which was then , I confess , more necessary , by reason the generallity of those amongst whom the Christians lived , were Heathens . And therefore in case the Parents , on whom it is incumbent to see thei Children educated in the Christian Religion , came to die ; they that were Sponsors , might take care to see them brought up therein . Which Institution ( as likewise Confirmation ) is now degenerated into a meer Formality : few regarding their solemn Engagements made for that end . And ( 2. ) he ordained also Templorum consecrationes ; the Consecration of Temples , that or Churches , being the usual Names , given to all places for Gods Worship , in after Ages . So that Consecration being but introduced in the second Century ; if Mede takes it in the usual sense ; his Opinion that There were appropriate Places for Christian Worship both in the Apostles days , and ever since , falls to the Ground ; except it can be proved , that some of them at least , lived so long . But if he takes it for a private House , or some room therein , where the Church met together , as he seems in the beginning , and by the expressions of the Church in their House : then whensoever any Owners thereof , gave leave for the Christians to assemble therein , their permission was a Consecration thereof , whereby they appropriated the same to the Churches use ; and so , according to his Tenets , employed them no more for their own Civil use , being appropriate to a Sacred . Or else some pious Christians , gave their Houses , as he thinks , and dedicated them to the Church for a Meeting Place , by which Dedication it was appropriated . But neither of these can be reasonably imagined . Considering ( 1. ) That we read of several that sold their Possessions , for the Maintenance of the Poor : but we read of none that gave their Houses to the Church for meeting in . ( 2. ) The multitude of Christians increasing , many Houses were requisite to contain them , as we have formerly observed . ( 3. ) How often in those bloody Persecutious , they were forced to shift their Meeting-Places , to shun the loss of their Estates , Liberties and Lives , we may easily conclude . And lastly , Had any either granted , or given any House , or certain place , for such an use , as therein constantly to assemble : they had thereby , without all doubt , been quickly discovered , certainly dispersed , and often times most severely punish'd . So that tho we are not to question the readiness of many that were able , nor their pious liberality : so we must also consider their Prudence , the times wherein they lived , and what was most conducible to their preservation , that they might not run themselves on the rocks of destruction . SECT . 9. Our Opponents besides the Authorities mentioned , produce several Arguments for their Opinion ; whereof 3 are made use of by Mede , which we shall now consider . First , It 's certain , saith he , That in their Sacred Assemblies , Christians used then to Worship and Pray towards the East . Which how it could be done , with any order and conveniency , is not easie to be conceived ; unless we suppose the places , wherein they worshipped to have been situated and accommodated accordingly , that is chosen and appointed to that end . This he had touched on before , from Tertullian in the beginning of the 3d Century ; for which no authority is vouched , but that only of the forged Apstolical Constitutions , falsly ascribed to Clemens . Here let me observe , whereas Mede saith to worship and pray , Bellarmine c. 3 de cultu sanct . rightly restrains to prayers only , and those made publickly in the Temples . For having mentioned several Authors for this , adds , Et omnes illi Veteres , qui scribunt Apostolicam esse traditionem , ut oremus conversi ad Orientem ; id praecipue servari par est , in solemnibus precibus , quae funduntur in Templis : And all those Ancients which write , that 't is an Apostolical Tradition , that we pray turned towards the East : that ought especially to be observed in the solemn Prayers , which are made in Temples . Secondly , Tho we grant this an ancient Custom ; yet is it without Command , or Example in the Scriptures ; for Christ never required it , nor was it practised from the beginning of Christianity . Where 's the Proof they then used so to Worship ? Or when this Custom first came up ? For as to the Constitutions , rightlier to be called Apocryphal than Apostolical ( as we have formerly observed ) they deserve no Credit at all . Thirdly , If this necessarily implies Edifices so situated , which I question , and he supposes , ( but hath not proved ) then those 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , upper rooms , the coenaculum Sionis , that upper room in Sion , and private Houses , which were the first Churches , he grants in the beginning of his Treatise , were all so situate , which I hardly think , he himself thought . And much less that the Coemeteries and Vaults under Ground , which so many Authors mention for their Meeting Places ( as we shall shew hereafter ) were so : or had such Light Eastward , more than from other Quarters of the Heavens . Fourthly , Bellarmine there treating of the Form of Christian Churches , saith only , Vt plurimum eas ad Orientem conversas fuisse , & quatuor latera habuisse quibus quatuor Mundi partes aspicerent . That for the most part they were turned towards the East , and had four sides , turned towards the four parts of the World. Likewise Walfridus Strabo de rebus Eccles . c. 4. saith , Majorem partem Ecclesiarum ita fabricari ; That the greater part of Churches were so made . So that by their saying , all were not so ; some might be round , as we have an ancient Church in Cambridge so built , which some say , was the usual Form of the Jewish Synagogues , such as the lesser , at Amsterdam . And some sited otherwise than Eastward , as the Church of Antioch in Syria , as Socrates l. 5. c. 21. testifies . And if they were oblong , and stood East and West , seeing they had four sides , 't is meant doubtless of the Chancel , which was Eastward . Of which distinction in Churches ; when first it began , or who was the Author thereof , is not set down by any Writers I have met with . Tho we know , in Constantine's time , when stately Churches were erected , this was used . And if we take this in the first Ages , for private places , frequently stiled Oratories and Chappels , such as were in Houses and Vaults under Ground , or above in the open Air ; to say their aspect was Eastward , is to beg the question , and cannot be proved . We may well imagine , those built , were rather according to the conveniency of the place , or pleasure of the Founders . As the Chappels of Emanuel and Sidney College in Cambridge , which stood rather North and South . Tho the former hath now a new one built in Mode and Figure ; and is no more to be derided , as formerly , by Cart-wright , an Oxford Poet : Much like the Chappel Ominous , Of ' th Colledge called God with us . Nor the other now in danger to be demolished , as Mr. Mathews , an ancient Fellow thereof , told me , was in the days of A. B. Land , threatned therewith . I confess Bellarmine brings several Authors for this situation of Churches ; but none that proves there was always such , nor that they were all such ; as also for the Ceremony of praying towards the East , for which he produces 5 reasons , ( such as they are ) I shall briefly represent them , to shew the sorry grounds of this practice , which takes away the liberty Christ hath left us , to advance a Custom of humane Constitution . 1. Because Paradise was in the East , and we being here but strangers , should labour to regain our ancient Country , which we were cast out of . Which is produced by several other Papists , as the Opinion of the Fathers , and lately by the Learned Huetius c. 3. de situ Paradisi . As if Paradise , where ever it was ( the place thereof having puzzl'd so many Learned Inquisitors ) whether in or near Mesopotamia , or elsewhere , was not as well West to the Christians beyond it , as East to us on this side . Or that we were to look after a Terrestial Paradise , more than a Coelestial , whereof that was but a Type . And as the Saints in the Old Testament lookt from all parts toward the Temple , as a Type of our blessed Saviour ; so under the New , we are directed to look towards Heaven , as the Habitation of our Heavenly Father , where Christ sits at his right hand to make Intercession for us . 2. Because the Sun rising there , 't is the most excellent part of the World. But supposing its motion , doth it not continually arise in the several Horizons , to those of the same Latitude throughout the World and there set to their Antipodes ? so that the East of Jerusalem , as Gregory explains it , must needs be West , to the further parts of the World. And how can that be most excellent to any , which is equally alike to all ? 3. Because Christ whom we Worship , is the light of the world , Vir Oriens , the Man of the East . It s true that as the blessed God , is called light , which of all creatures is the most pure : So Christ is called , the Sun of righteousness , the light of the world , and the day spring from on high &c. But this is only metaphorically , in regard of his illuminating us , and not at all to the place of East or West , North or South , all being equally alike to him for that end . 4. Because Christ was crucified with his Face Westward , so that we look Eastward to behold his countenance . And he ascended towards the East , and from thence shall come to Judgment . But where 's the proof of that posture in his Crucifiction ? Not in the Scripture sure . And how should the Christians beyond Jerusalem pray towards his Face so , who lived in Persia , and other Eastern Countries . Math. 24.27 . is meant of his Gospel Dispensation , or his speedy coming to destroy Jerusalem , as Hammond and Lightfoot think ; or by that Emblem to Judgment : the point of East in the Heavens , being no where so to all the World he is to Judge . 5. Because the Jews prayed , and pray towards the West , we towards the East ; to signifie theirs to be the killing Letter , and ours the Vivificating Spirit , and that the Veil still remains over their hearts , which we converted unto the Lord , have laide aside . That the Jews at the Temple looked Westward , was because the Mercy-Seat , in the most holy Place was at the West end thereof . But that they do so still , as Gregory also saith , I think is a mistake ; I never observed it in any of their Synagogues , tho I have seen several , and their Worship : yet I never saw any People so regardless therein as the present Generation of the Jews . But why may we not pray in the same posture with the Jews of old , which were Gods People , and had his direction ? as well as in the posture of those Gentile Idolaters that worshipped the Sun ( Ezek. 8.16 . ) as the Persians and many other Nations ? Truly if you will believe the Cardinal , because this posture signifies so much more excellent things than the Jewish , which he there mentions ; even the difference between the Gospel and Christianity , from the present Religion of the accursed Jews , the Enemies of our Lord Jesus Christ . Here recommend me to the man that hath so strong Faith , as to believe a bare posture can denote such great things , to which it hath no tendency , or likeness at all . But if any one hath list and leisure , to see a deal of dry Learning thrown away on this subject of praying towards the East ; they may peruse the 18th Chap. of Gregory's Notes on Zachary 6. v. 12. Who had written also a Treatise , he intituled Alkibla ( i. e. the place toward which men worship ) as the Publisher of his posthumous Works acquaints us : the loss whereof he laments , tho for my part , I think it not great . Before I pass to another Argument , let me set down the Opinion of Strabo in the place fore-mentioned ; ( an Author near 800 Years old , when Ceremonies and Superstition were in Vogue , and near their Altitude ) concerning the site of Churches Eastward . Et quia diversitas Idololatriae , diversis modis Templa extruxerat : non magnopere curabant illius temporis justi , quam in partem orationis loca converterent , dum tantum videretur , ubi eliminatae sunt Daemonum sordes , ibi Deum creatorem omnium , qui ubique est , coli & adorari . And because Temples were built after divers manners , according to the different ways of Idolatry : The righteous men of those days , did not much care which way the places of Prayer stood ; their consideration being only this , that look where the filth and abomination of Devils were cast out of Doors , there God the Creator of all , who is every where , might be worshipped and adored . Now that by the righteous men of those times , which cared not which way they converted their places , or selves in Prayer to God , were the times of the Conversion of the Empire from Idolatry to Christianity , is plain by what preceds , c. 3. where he saith , After the time was come , wherein the true Worshippers in Spirit and Truth , not in Jerusalem only , or in the Hill of Samaria , that is not locally but spiritually , began to worship the Father , and the Doctrine of Salvation went forth into all Nations , according to the commandment of the Lord , the Faithful began to seek loca munda , clean places ( which he interprets by that which follows ) and removed from tumults and affairs of men of carnal conversation , therein to celebrate pure Prayers , and the holy Mysteries , and the comforts of mutual edification . For tho we read in the Gospel , the Disciples were with the Believers always in the Temple , or in some upper room , praising God , and giving themselves to Fasting and Prayer ; yet after the coming down of the Holy Ghost upon them . we read Act 1. & 2d chap. that they Celebrated Prayers and the Eucharist circa domos , from house to house : and they met together not only within the City , in some house or other , but without also in secret places , as at Philippi . Acts 16.13 . But when the number of Believers was multiplied , they began to make their Houses , Churches , as we often read in the Legends of the Saints . Oftentimes also declining the rage of Persecutors , they had their meetings in Vaults under ground , and in places of Burial , and in Caves , and desert Mountains and Valleys . Then as the Miracle of Christian Religion profited more and more ; and the Devil loosing ground , as Christ gained : New Oratories were built ; nor so only , but also the Temples of their Gods and Idols , with the abominable Worship thereof , being thrown away and banished , were changed into the Churches of God. It 's true , that he dislikes not praying towards the East , but gives reasons for the congruity of it ; yet upon consideration of the Temple at Jerusalem , that the Holy of Holies was Westward , and that Solomon in 's Prayer at the Dedication thereof , turned his Face that way , he concludes , His & aliis exemplis edocti , cognoscimus , non errasse illos , vel errare , qui Templis vel noviter Deo constructis , vel ab Idolorum squalore mundatis , propter aliquam locorum opportunitatem , in diversas plagas altaria statuerunt ; quia non est locus , ubi non sit Deus . By these and other Examples , we learn that they who either in Temples nowly built for God , or purged from the filthiness of Idols , did according to the opportunity of places , set Altars towards different Coasts , did nothing erre , seeing there is no place where God is not present . And accordingly proceeds to shew , that in the Temple built by Helena at Jerusalem , upon Christ's Sepulcher ; and in the Pantheon at Rome , converted to Christian use ; as also , in St. Peter's Church there , Altars were Erected , not only towards the East , but also , other Quarters of the Heavens . And adds , Haec cum secundum voluntatem , vel necessitatem fuerint ita disposita , improbare non audemus . So that tho he approves rather , of praying towards the East ; yet professeth , he dares not blame those , who otherwise ordered the matter , and that not only in case of necessity , but of meer will and pleasure . Concluding thus , Vnusquisque in suo sensu abundet , propè est Dominus omnibus , invocantibus eum in veritate . Let every one abound in his own sense , the Lord is near to all that call upon him in Truth . I must add to all these , the Example of the Church of England , in reading the Liturgy , Ministers Prayers , and Peoples practice ; and further shew , that tho Mede joins the position of Churches and Prayers ; yet neither of these necessarily infer the other ; but I have run out too far on this Argument already . The second is drawn from the Discipline of the Church , which required distinct and regular places in their Assemblies , for Penitents , Auditors , Catechumens and the Faithful ; which argues , they had places accommodated for that purpose . We had this Argument before , in the middle of the Third Century , where we answered the same ; and therefore shall be briefer here . Where I shall not insist upon it , That distinctions might be made in private Houses or Places ; tho not so well or great as in publick Churches . Nor deny the authority of that obscure Epistle ; however called Canonical , of Gregorius Neocaesariensis , which was a little before alledged for this Discipline , and also considered . But roundly answer , that no such distinction of places can be proved in the days of the Apostles , or an hundred years after . It 's therefore a strange inference , that if there were such different places , for the several sorts of Church Members , in Gregory's time ; which was about 250 years after the Nativity of our blessed Saviour ; that there were such in the Apostles days , and ever since ; as our Adversaries would perswade us . But they must have stronger reasons than these , before they gain our assent . For who seeth not , that such distinction of places is more sit for times of Peace than Persecution ( such as were mostly the first 300 years of Christianity ) wherein men must be content to do as they may , and can , seeing they cannot do as they desire . The Third Argument is drawn from the Example of the Synagogues and Proseucha's of the Jews , whose Religion was as contrary to the Empires , as the Christians , and yet in their dispersion amongst the Gentiles , had appropriate places for the exercise thereof . Who can believe that such a Pattern should not invite the Christians to an imitation of the same , tho we should suppose there were no other reasons to induce them , but that of ordinary conveniency . This Reason supposes the Christians might do , as the Jews , who built them Synagogues in those Cities where they resided ; having a legal Tolleration for the exercise of their Religion ; whereas the Laws of the Empire were against the Christians . Which makes me wonder such Learned Men , as Fuller , Mede and others , that could not but know so much ; should produce this Plea for their Opinion . Just as if they should argue , The Jews in many Popish Countries , build and enjoy their Synagogues , whose Religion is more contrary to Popery than the Protestants ; and therefore the Protestants should follow their Example , and build themselves Churches for their publick Worship . To which the answer is easie ; that so they would if they had the like Tolleration . But to what purpose should they build up that which the Magistrates would throw down , and they should never enjoy , but instead thereof be more persecuted and punisht . Whence in several great Cities , where there are some Protestants , Ministers are sent them , which they call , sub Cruce , or under the Cross of Persecution , as the Learned Professor Hornbeck was in his younger years in Collen , ( where I have seen the Jews Synagogue ) and others I have known at Ghent , and elsewhere , incognito , or disguis'd , exercising their Office with great secresie , for their greater security . Not to mention the Persecutions the Christians were under in the first Ages of Christianity , when the Jews enjoyed the Liberty of their Religion : having spoken something thereof in the second Section , and shall more fully in the following . Nor let any one stop me , with objecting the many Thousands of Jews under Caligula and Claudius Reigns , for their Tumults and Insurrections : or the Wars in the Reigns of Nero and Vespasian , wherein eleven hundred thousand perished , Jerusalem taken and demolished , with the Temple burnt . Nor after under Aelius Adrianus , about A. D. 130. who tho he built Jerusalem , calling it Aelia by his fore-name , ( as he did Adrianople by his other ) yet made miserable Havock of the Jews and their Country . For this was not by Persecution , but by open Wars with them for 6 Years together , which they brought upon themselves . The occasion is said to be , quod mutilare genitalia vetarentur , arma corripuerant ; that being forbidden Circumcision , they took up Arms. Instead of humbly addressing for a revocation , they betake themselves to Warlike Opposition ; being also set agog by Bencochab , who gave himself out for their Messias . In which Wars this their false Messias was slain ; and more Thousands of the Jews , than the number of the Israelites that came out of Egypt , as their Rabbins report ; or as our Historians , five hundred thousand , and a thousand of their Villages burnt down to the Ground . SECT . 10. Having now Answered their Reasons , We shall proceed to lay down several Considerations for the corroborating our Assertion . Which amount not to a Demonstration , I confess , That there could be no publick Places erected , for the Exercise of the Christian Religion , in the two First Centuries ; yet compared with our Adversaries Arguments , will render our Cause much more probable , and weigh down theirs so clearly , as to satisfie all unprejudiced Readers . 1. Let 's consider the State and Condition of the World as to Religion , when our blessed Saviour , after his Resurrection , sent forth his Apostles to Preach the Gospel to all Nations . In which were two sorts of Men , Jews and Gentiles ; of whom 't is hard to say , whether were the more implacable Enemies to the Christian Religion , and the Professors thereof . As for the Jews , what Calumnies and Tumults did they raise against the Christians , not only in Judea , but wheresoever they resided ; accusing their Doctrine as Blasphemous , their Persons as Factious and Seditious , and setting up a new King instead of Caesar . And where they had no power to Persecute them , they stirred up the Magistrates in the Empire to do it , as we find frequently in the Acts of the Apostles . And as to the Gentiles , what Ignorance , Wickedness , and abominable Idolatries they lived in , Scripture hath abundantly declared . God having in times past suffered 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 all the Gentiles , rather than as we Translate it , all Nations , to walk in their own ways . Acts 14.16 . For the Jews had the way of Salvation made known to them ; but the Gentiles ways were in gross Idolatry , setting up to themselves multiplicity of Gods , whom they worshipped and served ; although some of the wiser sort of them held one Supream , whom they called Jove , contracted from Jehova , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Father both of Men and Gods. And this their Idolatrous Worship and Religion was so ancient , even from Time immemorial , and so universal in all the Nations of the Gentiles ; that none can imagine but the Gospel , which opposed and condemned this wherever it came , should have the utmost Opposition , and its Publishers and Professors Persecutions , rather than a Toleration or Permission to set up a Religion in publick , destructive of their own . 2. Consider the Power of the Roman Monarchy , which was then at the height ; having Conquered the greatest part of the Western Nations , both in Europe and Africa , and Eastward as far as Euphrates , in which especially the Gospel was to be Preached , though it was carried also into the remoter Parts elsewhere , over which the Roman Eagle never stretcht her Wings . In the City of Rome , Tacitus Reports , Hist . l. 11. there were not fewer than 6944000. and what vast Nations were then subject to its Empire , is sufficiently known ; and what numerous Armies they constantly kept up . All which Power was Unanimous for the defence of their Idols , and their Idolatrous Worship , against all Men and Means that would defame them , or tended to their Demolition . 3. Consider also , That at that time there was not only the greatest Power to oppose Christianity , but also the greatest intellectual Helps and Means , Learning being then in its full Meridian of Glory . They had subtle Philosophers for defending their Religion , and as good Arguments for its Verity , as Bellarmine , and the Papists , alledge for theirs , such as Antiquity , Universality , Extent , Succession of their Priests , Prosperity , and the like . They had Eloquent Orators to Plead their own , and Implead , Tertullus like , the Christian Religion ; besides the vast multitude of Priests , and those imployed for the training them up in their Idolatrous Worship , whereby they became prejudiced to the utmost against the Gospel of Christ , especially considering the nature and tendency thereof , either as to the Credenda or Agenda , things to be Believed or Practised , injoyned therein . For Sinners to be Saved by a Crucified Jesus , might well to the Carnal and Unbelieving Jews and Gentiles be a stumbling Block , and accounted Foolishness ; as the Resurrection of the Dead , and other Articles of our Faith , strange Doctrines : And things so contrary to Flesh and Blood , as Self-denial , Mortification , Suffering joyfully Persecution , and even Death it self for Christ's sake and the Gospel , might well be accounted hard Sayings not to be born , but rather derided and rejected , as indeed they were generally by the wise Men of the World. Nor let any here object Mahometism , for that was set up when the Empire was broken to pieces under Heraclius , by the Irruption of the Barbarous Nations ; and in Arabia , amongst an ignorant People , where few Christians were , and no Learning , but ready to embrace any Innovations , and receive any Impressions of Religion , especially such a Sensual one as the Alcoran holds forth ; when there were neither Men of Knowledge and Parts to oppose it , nor Princes of Power to persecute it , but worldly Power to set it up and support it . So that 't is less wonder that soon grew publick : Whereas it was quite otherwise with the Gospel , which was neither set up , nor carried on , by Might and Power of Arms , but by the Spirit of the Lord accompanying it all along , where it was carried , to make it Efficacious . 4. Consider how strongly Gentilism was guarded by Laws . For all Nations , though they had several Idol Gods , and Worship , yet accounted their Religion to be of a Divine Original : As the Romans from the Goddess Egeria , and others from some God or Goddess they Worshipped : and would never suffer their Gods to be dishonoured , or their Rites of Worship , how Ridiculous soever , to be defamed by any amongst them , though Foreigners they could not hinder , did , as the Romans , the Jews and Egyptians especially . I shall not abuse the Reader 's Patience , in citing Histories and Poets for these things , they are so many , and so well known ; nor how they always provided by their Laws , Security for their own , and Prohibition and Penalties against other Religions . The Romans , by the Laws of the 12 Tables , forbad Nequis alios inducat Deos , sed Patriam sive Romanam Religionem sequatur . That none should introduce other Gods , but follow the Country's , or Roman Religion , and that under severe Penalties . Of which Cicero , l. 2. de Legibus largely . By vertue of which Laws alone , many Christians were extreamly punish'd by the Praetors , and Presidents of Provinces , and put to Death , without any Edicts from the Emperors ; though where these were added to enforce their Execution , Persecution was much more fierce and cruel : And this appears plainly by Pliny's Epistle to Trajan ; who having Condemned and Executed many by the Laws of the Empire , deterr'd at length by the multitude of those that were to be punished , Consulted the Emperor what he should do in that case , the Emperors having power to Suspend Execution , though not to Abrogate the Laws , which Senatus Populusque & Principes Romani decreverant ut non sint Christiani : The Roman Senate , People and Princes had decreed , as that no Christians be tollerated . Another early Law made by the Senate , mention'd by Eusebius , 5.21 . Non debere demitti Christianos qui semel ad Tribunal venissent , nisi propositum mutent : That the Christians which once came to publick Tryal , should not be dismist , except they changed their Religion . 5. Consider the Policy of the State , which was against Tollerating any diverse Religion amongst them , and much more a contrary to their own . As the Christian , which wholly changed the Face of the World , accounted their Deities Idols , and their Devotion gross Idolatry ; which was therefore judged dangerous for raising Tumults and Commotions among the People , which might end in Civil Wars for Religion : So that they Unanimously concluded it best for the Publick Safety , to Extirpate Christianity , and the Professors thereof . Yea , so Jealous were they , that all Societies , or Conventions , were forbidden , as appears by 42. & 43. Epist . Plinij , l. 10. And much more of Christians , as Ep. 98. Acquaints Trajan , How the Christians forbore post edictum meum , quo secundum mandata tua hetaerias esse vetueram : After my Edict , whereby I forbad , according to your Command ; all Conventions of Societies . This Consideration of State-Policy , hath been the great Argument and Engine in all Ages for Persecution ; insomuch , that some Christian Writers of Politicks , upon this account , justifie the Heathens , and Popish Inquisition ; though S. James calls this Wisdom earthly , sensual , devillish , quite contrary to that from above , which is , first pure , then peaceable , gentle and easie to be intreated , full of mercy , &c. And oh ! that it had not prevail'd amongst Protestants , to the great Scandal of the Prince of Peace , and his peaceable Gospel , which they profess ! It was far more tollerable in the Gentiles , who had only the Light of Nature for their Guide ; as the Romans , who yet tollerated the Nations they Conquered , to retain their Religion , not only Gentilism , but Judaism also , both in Judea , and in their dispersion in the Roman Territories : the Jews having before submitted to the Roman Government , and become their Tributaries , when Subdued by Pompey . By reason whereof , the Christians coming from Jerusalem , and passing in the Empire , a while at the first for Jews , whose Synagogues they used then to frequent , passed undiscerned , without Persecution ; 'till afterwards that they were discovered , and then both Jews and Gentiles became their implacable Enemies , those frequently stirring up these ( as we read in the Acts ) to Persecute them . For they both accounted them setters up of a strange God and Religion , in their worshipping Christ , whom they both took for a meer Man , whom their Ancestors had Crucified ; and that the Gospel tended to overturn both their Religions , and ways of Worship ; which will yet more evidently appear , by that which in the next place follows . 6. Consider the many and grievous false Accusations brought against the Christians , which greatly incensed all sorts of People against them . They were accused of Atheism , and all manner of Impiety , as killing and eating Children , Incest , and impure Mixtures , Magick , and every Evil almost that might render them odious , which may be read in the Primitive Fathers , Greek and Latine , in their Apologies for Christianity ; summarily mentioned in Spencer's Annotations on the First Book of Origen . So that the Christians for their Impiety , were accounted the Cause of all those publick Calamities that befel the Empire . If there was a Famine , Pestilence , &c. the People cryed out Christianos ad Leones , cast the Christians to the Lions , as Tertul. Apol. c. 40. Cypr. Ep. 75. and others . So when Rome was taken by Alaricus , it was imputed to the Anger of the Gods , for the contempt of their Religion ; which occasioned S. Austin to write that excellent Book de civitate Dei , and Orosius his Orchestra , for the Refutation of their Heathenish Folly , which was so great , that they still thought to appease the Anger of their Gods , with the Blood of the Christians . Nor were they less traduced for being Enemies to the State , and such as turned the World upside down ; notwithstanding all their peaceable Demeanour under the Civil Government ; because they would not Pray to their Idols ( though they did to Almighty God ) nor offer Sacrifices to them for the Prosperity thereof . In like manner also were they Accused , for being Rebels to their Emperors ; because they refused to frequent their Solemn Feasts and Spectacles for their Victories ; nor would Swear , as others did , by their Genius ; nor give them Divine Honours , by offering Sacrifices to them , together with their Idol Gods. For as Julius Caesar , as Suetonius tells us in his Life , c. 76. Decerni sibi passus est , Templa , Aras , simulachra , juxta Deos : Suffered Temples , Altars and Images , to be Decreed for him near the Gods. So his Heathen Successors in the Empire continued the same , as may be seen in Pliny's Epistle to Trajan . Hence they were called Sacrilgi , Sacriligious , and Lawless , because this Worship of the Gods and Caesar , was by Law Established : Yea , the Enemies of Mankind , because by their Contempt of the Gods , they brought Miseries upon the World. So that being accounted by the Heathens Enemies of their Gods , and Religion , their State , Emperors , Laws , Manners , and all Mankind : No wonder if they became the object of publick Hatred , according to that of Tertul. l. Scorp . c. 11. Odio habemur ab omnibus hominibus nominis causa . We are hated of all Men for the Name of Christians , and his , and Athenagoras , and Justin , likewise in their Apologies , as our Saviour had foretold , Matth. 10.22 . So 24.9 . and Luke 21.12 . And it had been happy for after Ages , since the World turn'd Christian , if these Calumnies had not been used , to represent the best sort of Men , as Enemies to Princes and States , who could not in Conscience comply to worship the Image they set up . How have not only Papists under such Pretexts , all along Persecuted all that would not submit to their impious Impositions , but even Protestants also , frequently for small Matters , all such as refused to Dance after the Fidle of the Times . 7. Let us further consider the Temporal Interest of most , which carries all before it , with those that regard not their Spiritual and Eternal : The whole World turning continually upon the Hinge of Self-Interest . And herein the vast number of those ingaged thereby against the Christians ; some for preserving the Dignities and Revenues they had , and others for Augmenting them . Of the former sort were the several Religious Orders of Priests , or Flamines , and Augurs or Prognosticators , with the whole Rabble that depended on them . Which must needs be many , considering the multitude of Places and People , as also of Idols and Temples they were to serve , by performing their Religious Functions in Sacrifices , Lustrations and Supplications . All which had great Credit , as in all Religions such have , especially amongst an Ignorant and Superstitious People . And understood very well , that Christianity , would ruine at once all their Offices , Honours , and Profit . Knowing that thereby their Gods would be derided , their Worship neglected , their Oracles remaining contemned , and proved often false ; many of them being already silenced ; which the learned Plutarch both confest and wondred at in 's Book de defectu Oraculorum , amongst his Works , and with Camararius's Notes alone . Which Consideration stopt two of the Heathen Emperours , which had most kindness for Christ , if we may believe Lampridius in the Life of Alexander Severus , who writes thus . Christo ( Alexander ) Templum facere voluit , eumque inter Deos recipere . Quod et Adrianus cogitasse fertur , qui Templa in omnibus Civitatibus sine simulachris jusser at fieri : Quoe hodie idcirco , quia non habent numina , dicuntur Adriani , quae ille ad hoc parasse diccbatur : Sed prohibitus est ab iis , qui consulentes sacra , repererant omnes Christianos futuros , si id optata evenisset , & Templa Reliqua deserenda . Alexander Severus would have made a Temple for Christ , and receive him amongst the Gods. Which Adrian , also is said to have determined , who had commanded Temples to be made in all Cities without Images ; which therefore still , because they have no Gods , are called Adrian's ; which He was said to have prepared for this ; but was prohibited by those , who consulting the Oracles , found all would turn Christians , if that had happened well , and all other Temples would be forsaken . Of the latter Sort , that were for augmenting their Estates , were especially the Magistrates , both Supream and Subordinate . For knowing they might gain , by the Execution of the Laws : Those especially that were Superstitious , Covetous , and Cruel , were thereby induced to fly upon the Spoil , by confiscating the Estates of Christians , who indured a great fight of Afflictions ; were made a gazing Stock both by Reproaches and Afflictions ; and were Companions of them that were so used , and took joyfully the spoiling of their Goods , Heb. 10.32 , 33 , 34. and elsewhere their Sufferings are set forth , comprizing their Losses : Yea , even Felix the Governour hoped to have got Mony from poor Paul for his Freedom ; and communed with him oftner for this End , thinking belike , that his Friends would contribute thereto , Acts 24.26 . So that Temporal Interest ingaged all Officers , Sacred and Civil , to prevent and suppress Christianity , and the Professors thereof . 8. To all the former Considerations , which suggest sufficient Reasons for the Christians to keep themselves as private as possible , we may add several other Particulars . As the vast Multitude of their Enemies , whose extream prejudice against Christianity , and inveterate hatred of the Christians , stirr'd them up frequently to raise Popular Tumults against their Persons , Families , and Societies ; as we read in the Acts of the Apostles , and other Authors . And if the People were supprest by the Magistrates from exorbitant Violence , they had always Liberty to accuse them , and bring them to Tryal . And such was their Malice and Rage , that sometimes they hurried them by Violence before their Rulers ; and sometimes exhibited Multitudes in the same Libel , or Accusation . Then were they strictly examined , and put to purge themselves upon Oath . And if they denied , were commanded , for further Proof thereof , not only to Worship and Sacrifice to the Idol Gods and Emperours , but also to curse Christ . And if they confest , were certainly condemned to Punishment , which was of several kinds , most usually Death . Altho no other Crime was alledged or proved then their Christianity . Their Christian Constancy , termed inflexible obstinacy , was judged sufficient ground for their Condemnation . Of which the Primitive Fathers Apologies , and Pliny's Epistle to Trajan , inform us sufficiently . And if they were brought to a Publick Tryal , where less Tumultuousness , and more legal Proceedings were used : Yet how little Hopes they could have , of escaping the utmost Severities of the Laws against them , may be easily imagined , seeing all that Tryed them , as well as those that Accused them , were their implacable Enemies . For when an Accusation was brought in , the Pretor in Rome , and the Proconsul or Supream Governour in the Provinces , having appointed the Time of Tryal , then came and sate on the Tribunal , and the Judges chosen by Lot ( more or fewer , according to the Quality of the Cause ) sate on Benches . And all the Favour the Accused had , was to Object against those he thought good , ( as we are wont in England of the Juries ) which the Accuser had likewise Liberty to do ; and the number of those rejected being again supplied by Lot , the Cause was pleaded , and the Judges gave Sentence , by Capital Letters in Tables , A. absolvebat , absolved . C. condemnabat , condemned . N. L. non liquet , It s not manifest . As our Juries pronounce , Guilty , or Not Guilty , or Ignoramus . I know the manner of the Grecians passing Sentence was otherwise , by casting small stones into an Urne , the White and whole signifying Absolution , the Black and Holed Condemnation . But this only by the by . Having thus laid down so many Considerations , to support our Assertion ; I submit them to the Judgment of all impartial Readers , if they do not preponderate our Opponents Reasons for theirs ; and proceed in the last Place , to produce several Testimonies , for Defence of the Truth we have laid down , and undertaken to prove . SECT . 11. We come now to alledge several Testimonies to make good our Position ; which we shall take from such Authentick Authors , as are beyond all Exceptions ; and not such spurious ones , as several that have been brought against us . And for the more distinct proceeding herein ; we shall reduce them to these three General Heads . 1. Such as speak of the Persecution of the Primitive Churches ; whereby any one may judge , whether they were in a Condition suitable to the injoyment of certain appropriate Places , call them Oratories , Churches , or as some of our Opponents falsly Temples ( for that Name came not in for them , till the fourth Century ) if you please ; much less to build such publickly in the first Ages , for their constant worshipping in . 2. Such as declare , that for two hundred Years at least they had no such , as our Adversaries avouch . 3. What kind of Places they then assembled in : Which were the most Private they could find or contrive for their Security . As to the first of these , concerning the Persecution of the Primitive Church , mentioned in the Acts of the Apostles ; we have spoken something already in the second Section ; and shall therefore proceed to that part of Nero's Reign , that immediately Succeeds . For St. Paul's coming to Rome , about the fifth of that Emperour , and Imprisonment there for the space of two Years , concludes the Acts. There he found a flourishing Church , as appears by c. 1. v. 8. of that admirable Epistle he had Written to them , between two and three Years before . Whether Founded by those Strangers of Rome that were at Jerusalem in the Day of Pentecost , Acts 2.10 . Or by those mentioned in the 16. Chapter of his Epistle , or joyntly by them all , I determine not : But that it was not by Peter , who had not as yet been there , is apparent by the Series of History . During his Imprisonment , he wrote several of his excellent Epistles , as that to the Galatians ( a People inhabiting Tanium pessinunt , and Anoyra in Asia ) the Ephesians , Philippians , Colossians , Philemon , and as most think , even those that were last , as that to the Hebrews , and those to Timothy . Tho' Dr. Cave and others Judge , the first to Timothy was written in 's return to Rome , and the second in the Year following . For both , some Places of Scripture , and many Ancient Fathers testifie , that being released after two Years by Nero , he went and Preached the Gospel , in the East , Italy , France , and Spain for about four Years , and being apprehended and brought again to Rome , was there Beheaded . For Nero now inraged at the increase of the number of Christians , and the decrease of the Worshippers of the Idol Gods , made that bloody Decree , Quisquis Christianum se confitetur , tanquam generis humani convictus hostis , sine ulteriore sui defensione , capite Plectitor . Whosoever confesseth himself to be a Christian , shall as thereby a convicted Enemy of Mankind , without any further Defence of himself , loose his Head. And Orosius l. 7. c. 7. Primus ( Nero ) Romae Christianos supplicits & mortibus affecit ; ac per omnes Provincias pari Persecutione execruciari imperavit ; ipsumque nomen extirpari conatus , &c. Nero was the first at Rome , that punished the Christians , and put them to Death ; and commanded that through all the Provinces , they should be tormented with like Persecution ; and endeavoured to extirpate the very Name of Christians . Where Note , that tho' all Authors generally make him the first Persecutor of the Christians , it must either be understood , as first of the Emperors ; or the first general Persecution , after the Constitution of Churches amongst the Gentiles , which is usually reckoned from our Saviours Ascension , the Time of twenty five Years to Nero. For that both particular Persons , and the Church at Jerusalem , were persecuted before Nero's Time , is manifest in the Acts of the Blessed Apostles . There is a Passage in Tacitus Annals , l. 15. c. 44. transcribed by Sulpicius Severus , l. 2. Hist . very remarkable , for Congruity with Scripture , and clearing some Places therein . Which I shall therefore , tho' somewhat large , relate , and improve . Having set forth the burning of Rome , attributed to Nero , Abolendo rumori subdidit reos , & quaesitissimis paenis affecit , quos per flagitia invisos , vulgus Christianos appellabat . Auctor nominis ejus Christus , qui Tiberio Imperitante per Proconsulem Pontium Pilatum supplicio affectus erat . Repressaque in Praesens exitiabilis Superstitio , rursus erumpebat , non modo per Judaeam , originem ejus mali , sed per urbem etiam , quo cuncta undique atrocia aut pudenda confluunt , celebranturque . Igitur primo correpti , qui fatebantur , deinde judicio eorum multitudo ingens , haud perinde in crimine incendii , quam odio humani generis convicti sunt . Et pereuntibus addita ludibria , ut ferarum tergis contecti , leniatu canum interirent , aut crucibus affixi , aut flamandi , atque ubi defecisset dies ; in usum nocturni luminis uterentur . Hortos sui ei spectaculo Nero obtulerat . Nero to extinguish the Rumor of his burning the City , falsly accused , and exquisitely tormented those , odious for their wickedness , which the common People called Christians . The Author of that Name is Christ , who in the Reign of Tiberius , was executed by his Proconsul Pontius Pilate . And this Pestilent Superstition having been repressed for a Time , broke out again , not only in Judea , the Original of that evil , but also in the City of Rome , whither all heinous and shameful things from all parts flow together , and are had in Estimation . First therefore they were apprehended , who confessed ; then a great multitude of them being discovered were convicted in Judgment , not so much for the crime of burning the City , as the hatred of Mankind . And mockeries added to their Deaths , they were covered with the Skins of wild Beasts , that they might be torn in Pieces by Dogs , or Crucified , or Burnt , and when the Day was spent , they were used for Lights in the Night . Nero had offered his Gardens for this Spectacle . Here we have the Heathens Opinion of Christianity and Christians : An Attestation to that great Article of our Faith , Christs Suffering under Pontius Pilate : And the Sufferings of his Servants ( for which I alledge the Place especially ) These caused that Defection of many , the Historian briefly touches in saying , this Pernicious Superstition ( meaning Christianity ) was for a Time represt . That is , by those former Persecutions , we have frequently mentioned in Paul's Epistles ( and also those of James and Peter . ) Whereby some forsook the Christian Assemblies , others apostatized from the Faith of Christ , against which the Apostle warns the rest , Hebrews , 10.23 . to the end of the Chapter . Others mixt Christianity with Judaism ( which was tollerated ) lest they should suffer Persecution for the Cross of Christ , Gal. 6.12 . Altho those Sanguinary Laws and Bloody Persecutions that followed , had not as yet fallen on them , as Heb. 12.4 . shews , where the Apostle saith , Ye have not yet resisted unto Blood. For these were begun by Nero , about the seventh or eighth Year of his Reign . I suppose , before the Conflagration at Rome ( usually reckoned the tenth ) but for these , see the several Notes on c. 2. of Lactantius , de mortibus Persecutorum . Domitian about thirteen Years after Nero is made Emperor , who in Cruelty surpast him : Taking Pleasure in beholding those in Torments , nor sparing some of his nearest Relations . Confirmatissimam toto orbe Christi Ecclesiam , datis ubique crudelissimae Persecutionis Edictis , convellere ausus est universali Persecutione . Saith Orosius l. 7. c. 7. That is , He adventured to pluck up by the Roots the Church of Christ , that was most firmly settled in the whole World , by universal Persecution , Edicts for most cruel Persecutions every where being given out by him . So that how privately soever the Christians kept their Assemblies , most of their Pastors were forced to fly , according to the Verse of that Time. Vrbibus antiqui Patres fugêre relictis . The ancient Fathers leaving the Cities fled . Trajan about a Year and four Months after Domitian , follows in the Empire , under whom the Third General Persecution is reckoned . For that many Christians suffer'd under him , by his Governours executing the Laws against them is manifest . For , Suidas saith , Tyberianus the President of Syria writ him Word , Se non esse parem Christianis occidendis , eo quod ultro illi se neci offerrent . That he was not able , or sufficient for killing the Christians , because of their own Accord , they offered themselves to Death . And Pliny his Proconsul in Bithynia , after he had put many to Death , affrighted with their Multitude , consulted the Emperor what was to be done with them , in that excellent Epistle to Trajan , l. 10. Epist . 98. ( mentioned by Tertul. in Apol. Eusebius and others ) which I shall not transcribe , being in most Mens hands . Only let me observe , that so severe was the Persecution , that many for fear , denied they were Christians , tho' they had been they confest , but had forsaken it , some of them ante plures Annos many Years before ; and that after he had forbidden their Societies , according to the Emperors command , they had forborn them ; and having faithfully declared , their Manner of Worship , and Innocency of Life ; yet Trajan answers him , They should not be sought after , but Connived at , except they were Accused and Convicted , and then if they persisted , they should be punished . Conquirendi non sunt : Si deferantur , & arguantur , puniendi sunt , by which occasion , saith Eusebius , l. 3. Hist . c. 33. Plurimi ex fidelibus multiplicis Martyrii certamen subjerunt . Many of the Christian suffered manifold Martyrdom . And thus I have gone through the first Age , and the Times of all the Apostles ; St. John who out-lived all the rest , till the third Year of Trajan ( as Iraeneus and Hierom affirm ) and dyed 100. or more Years of old Age. From what 's said , let any impartial Man judge , If in the Apostles Times as well as ever since , the Christians had such Places for Worship , as our Adversaries contend for . I design not a History , and therefore shall not proceed to the General Persecutions that follows in the Second and Third Century , which together with the former , are generally counted Ten ( tho' differently reckoned ) that they may answer the Ten Plagues of Egypt , but by some Twelve in Number . In regard 't is needless ; so many having related them at large , Eusebius especially , at whose Torch most after him Light their Candles . And in our own Language , Fox in the beginning of his Martyrology . I shall only request , the considering the History of those general Persecutions in the Roman Empire ; and it will appear , that tho' they were not continual , yet the Christians in the first Ages had not any long time of Repose , tho' some lucid Intervals sometimes , when the Affairs of the Empire were disturbed and turbulent , ( as is usual we know by Modern Examples ) especially from Commodus to Severus , and from Severus to Decius . So that it was the wonderful Work of God , and Power of his Grace , that carried on the Work of the Gospel , against all Opposition ; and let the World see how vain the Attempts of Men were , against what Gods Hand and Counsel determined before should come to pass . As Tertul . in c. 5. Apolog. Cruciate , torquete , damnate , atterite nos — . Plures efficimur quoties metimur à vobis . Semen est Sanguis Christianorum , Torment , torture , condemn , break us to Pieces . The oftner we are Mowen down by you , the more we are made . The Blood of Christians , is the Seed of the Church . And because some pretend , the good Nature of some of the Emperors , and their peaceable Reigns : It is not denied , that some were far better , comparatively than others , as Nerva , Domitians Successor , who recalled those he had Banished , as John the Evangelist , with many others , and acquitted the Christians from the Rigour of the Laws . But Alas ! this was but a short Breathing Time , he having Reigned but four Months and nine Days above a Year ; so that it 's scarce accounted ; nor some that were longer , no nor any , as the effect of their Clemency , but Reason of State , and their being imbarrest in other Affairs , or imbroiled in Wars . For this we have Theodoret's evident Testimony , Hist . l. 1. c. 38. Quotquot Imperatores ante Constantinum M. regnarunt , contra Veritatis Professores insana rabie furere non desierunt . All the Emperors that Reigned before Constantine the Great , ceased not with mad Fury to Rage against the Professors of the Truth . So that we may conclude , there was no trusting to their Friendship , or Favour , further than their Temporal Interest , and their own Safety , and Security of the Government were concerned . And therefore small Opportunity or Incouragement for Christians injoying any publick Places for Worship constantly , much less for Building any such . SECT . 12. Here occurs an Objection , made against the Greatness and Cruelty of these Persecutions , by Reason of the Paucity of the Martyrs comparatively , with the common Opinion of their great Multitudes . Which is especially managed , by my old Friend , the Learned Mr. Dodwel , in 's XI . Dissertation on Cyprian . But in this he seems not only singular , but to found his Opinion upon a false Foundation ; that because we find not so many mention'd in Antiquity , therefore they were fewer , than we commonly account them . For some Presidents of Provinces prohibited the reserving the Records of the Martyrs Tryals : And most of those that were recorded , and remained to the Times of Christian Emperors ; afterwards by the Irruption of the barbarous Nations into the Empire , were lost . So that we have little more than what Eusebius had gather'd up , and Published , in 's Ecclesiastical History , and more particularly in two Books of the Martyrs ; the former a Collection of the Ancient Martyrs , which is lost . The latter of those of Palastine that had suffered in his Time. Besides , 't is observable , that great numbers were slain , both by the Magistrates and People without any formal Process of Law , and so could not be taken Notice of . Propter Confessionem torquetis . Causa non judicata supplicia infertis , saith Justin in 's Apology , Vpon our Confession you Torment us . No Judgment being given of the Cause , you punish us . And to the same Purpose , Tertul. in Apologet. c. 37. The Governours of Cities and Provinces , being stir'd up by the Priests and People ; made no great difficulty many Times , to Sacrifice them to the Popular Fury . For Things being carried often by Tumults , many were slain quasi jure Belli , as if it were in War , sometimes 10 , 20 , 30 , 60 , and sometimes 100 , Men and Women with their little ones were Massacred in a Day , as Eusebius tells us , l. 3. c. 33. and l. 4. c. 8. and l. 8. c. 9. of his History . Insomuch that the Emperors were forced to give Orders for restaining them , as Hadrian Ne quis posthac sine objectu criminis & legitima accusatione condemnaretur . Let none hereafter be condemned without setting forth the Crime , and a legal Accusation . Nor are we to reckon the Persecutions , or number of Martyrs , by the Emperors Edicts ; for 't is evident , the Roman Rulers and Governors , waited not for any such Decrees , but when any were Accused , they Tryed , Condemn'd and Executed them , according to the Laws made against them . This is evident by Pliny's Proceeding , when he was Proconsul in Pontus and Bithynia , without Trajans Order . Yea , under some of the Emperors that more favour'd the Christians , as Alexander Severus , through his Mother Mammea's Perswasions , though they emitted no Edicts for prohibiting their Persecution , many Martyrs suffered in their Reigns . But this Question relating to Matter of Fact , cannot be determined otherwise , than by having recourse to the Historians and Ancient Fathers that have written of those Times . Which whosoever peruseth , may soon see that vast Army of glorious Martyrs , which may astonish him , and sill him with Admiration of their Christian Fortitude , under such direful Sufferings as they underwent . It would be endless to recite their Sayings , for the great number of Martyrs . In the Third General Persecution there were innumerable Martyrs . The Menologia Graecorum say , Decem millia Christianorum in Monte Ararat cruci suffixa sub Trajano . That there were ten Thousand Christians Crucified under the Reign of Trajan in the Mountain of Ararat . In the Fourth under Adrian , Passim Martyrum millena , there were frequently Thousands of Martyrs . And so in the following , many thousands in the general , are reckon'd by several Authors . Chytraeus in 's Historical Kalender , reports from the fore-mention'd Menology , 28 Decembris bis decem millia Martyrum in Nicomedia ustorum , That on the 28th of December Twenty Thousand were burnt in Nicomedia . And if so many on one Day , what numbers in so many Years ? And if so many in one Place , how great must the number be in all Places ? But we must not stay upon Particulars . Euseb . l. 5. saith under the Emperor Antoninus , Innumerabiles prope Martyres per universum orbem enituisse ; That Martyrs almost innumerable , were famous throughout the World. And if in the Fifth Persecution ( as that 's usually reckon'd ) alone , were so many , what were there in all the Ten or Twelve ? Prudentius Hymno xi . l. de Coronis , saith , In●u●eros Martyres ; Rome ignoros fuisse ; That there were innumerable unknown Martyrs at Rome ; and if at Rome alone , what in the whole Empire ? And of them all Cyprian saith , l. de Exhort . ad Martyr . Non posse numerari Martyres Christianos Novi Testamenti ; That the Christian Martyrs of the New Testament cannot be numbred . And St. Augustin often in 's Sermons de Temp. mentions the millia Martyrum , Thousands of Martyrs : And Tract . 113. in Joh. innumerabiles , innumerable . I shall only further recite what Fox , l. 1. p. 44. saith from an Ancient Author , Hierom or Heliodorus , where he makes this Calculation . Nullus esset Dies , qui non ultra quinque millium numerum Martyrum , reperiri posset ascriptus , excepto die Calendarum Januarii , i. e. There is no Day in the whole Year , unto which more than the number of five Thousand Martyrs cannot be ascribed , except only the first of January . Which by Computation amounts to a Million and Eight Hundred Twenty five Thousand . To animadvert on Dodwels Dissertation , is not necessary ; in regard the Considerations laid down in the Tenth Section , with what is here added , I suppose sufficient . If any desire further Satisfaction , I must refer them to such Authors , as have industriously answered him . As Monsr . Jaquelot , in French , Dissertation , 4. c. 5. in the general . Pagius in Critica Baroniana , frequently in several Places . Mabellonius in Itinere Italico . And the Notes of several on Lactantius de mortibus Persecutorum . But especially , Theodor. Ruinartius in Praefatione ad acta Martyrum , most particularly . To conclude this Discourse of the Primitive Persecutions , I shall likewise refer the Reader to such as have more largely treated thereof , besides those formerly mention'd . Lactantius de mortibus Persecutorum cum notis variorum . Ultrajecti , 1693. 8vo . Meisnerus de Persecutionibus & Martyriis Christianorum veterum . Witteb . 1654. 4to . Gerhardi Vossii Commentarius in Epist . Plinii & edicta , Caes . R. Adversus Christianos , Amsterd . 1654. Christ . Cortholtius de Persecutionibus Ecclesiae Primirivae sub Impp. Ethnicis , deque veterum Christianorum Cruciatibus . Jenae . 1660. 8vo . A Table of whose several sorts of Torments , may also be seen in Fox's Martyrology . SECT . 13. We shall now proceed , to confirm our Opinion , by producing undeniable Testimonies , from approved Ancient Authors , such especially as writ Apologies for the Christians against the Gentiles . Wherein they plead for those of former Ages , as well as their own ; and in all places , as well as where they lived ; though especially where their Enemies endeavoured to defame their Holy Profession . 1. Minutius Felix , who flourished as Dodwel thinks about the end of M. Antoninus's Reign ; but Bellarmine , under Alex. Severus , or about A. D. 206. And Baldwin yet later . However Cecilius the Heathen Objects , Cur occultare & abscondere , quicquid illud colunt , magnopere nituntur ? Cum honesta semper publico gaudeant , scelera , secreta sint ? Cur nullas aras habent , Templa nulla , nulla nota simulachra ? Why the Christians greatly endeavour to keep secret and hide , that they Worship : Seeing honest Things may rejoice to be Publick , but wicked Things would be kept secret ? Why they have no Altars , no Temples , nor known Images ? To which Octavius the Christian replies , by way of Concession , think ye that we hide that we Worship , if we have no Temples or Altars ? What Image shall I make of God , since Man is his Image ? What Temple shall I build for him , seeing the whole World made by him cannot contain him ? Concluding it better . He be set up in our Minds and Hallowed in our Hearts . 2. Origen , who flourished by Bellarmin's account , about the Year 226. in his excellent Book against Celsus , the Epicurean Philosopher . Which he wrote at above sixty Years of Age , as Euseb . saith l. 6. c. 36. Therefore A. D. 245. having been born , 185. Wherein Celsus Objects in the end of l. 7. That the Christians 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , could not indure to see the Temples , Altars , and Statues , and l. 8. p. 389 , 390 , and 391. of the Cambridge Edition , objects the same . To which Origen replies , That the Christians had for Altars spiritual Minds , and Prayers out of a pure Conscience for Incense . For Statues , the Image of God their Maker ; and Temples agreeable to these ; Holy Bodies , and the most excellent Temple of all , the Body of Christ , John 2.19 , 22. 1 Pet. 2.5 . Isa . 54.11 , 12. Not regarding liveless and sensless Temples , which sensless Men admire : Because taught to shun those counterfeit Religions , which make all those impious , that depart from the Religion of Jesus Christ , who is the Way , the Truth and the Life . By which some might think , Origen thought it unlawful to Worship God in a Temple , as when He saith 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 . We avoid to Build liveless and dead Temples to him that is the bestower of all Life . But Origen hath no such meaning , as the Series of his Discourse shews : But that wheresoever Righteous Persons are found , that offer up Vows and Prayers to God from a pure Mind and Conscience , there God is worshipped after the best Manner , whether within a Temple , or without , elsewhere . And Lil. Giraldus in 's Hist . Deorum Syntagm . 1. Commends this as a most acute Discourse in Origen . For , whereas the Pagans thought they performed , a great piece of Service and Worship to God , by building Temples to him : This Origen opposeth , because a Temple is a sensless or a liveless Thing , and Contributes nothing to the pleasing of God in his Worship . Our Saviour and his Apostles , having by Word and Prayers , worshipped God as acceptably often in the open Air , as in the Temple of Jerusalem . So that hitherto the Christians had no Publick Places of Worship , but only in Private , may be rationally concluded . 3. Arnobius , who flourished by Bellarmin's account about A. D. 285. or as other later , brings in the Gentiles objecting against the Christians as the greatest Crime , that they had no Temples , Altars , nor Images ; and answers not by denial , but granting what they said ; and for Temples , In cujus rei necessitatem , aut dicitis esse constructa , aut esse ●ursus aedificanda censetis ? What Necessity think you doth urge Men to build them , or after they are pulled down , to repair and restore them ? See his Reasons for the Christians forbearing to build them Temples , l. 6. He shews that Temples were not necessary , though convenient for their Religion . Therefore when they had Liberty , they built them Oratories , in the Third Century , which were now demolished by Dioclesian . For the Christians in all Times , and Places of the Empire , understood very well , that it was in the Emperors Power to pull down , whatsoever they Built , whensoever they pleased . And therefore if their Religion depended on Temples or Structures ( as the Religion of the Heathens did , who as Lactant. saith l. 5. c. 19. found it all there , and left it there ) they had been in an ill Case . If they have but a Private House , or Room , as our Saviour when he instituted the Sacrament of his Body and Blood , or the Disciples met in at Troas , their Service is as acceptable to God , as if performed in a Temple as glorious as Solomons . And this is the meaning of Arnobius , when he saith , Neque aedes sacras ad venerationis Officia extruamus , They did not build Temples , to perform Off●ces of Worship . For that God is equally served , honoured , and worshipped , as well without Temples as in them : Which Clemens Alexandrinus , Eusebius , Athanasius , &c. have often asserted and proved . 4. Lactantius , Arnobius's Schollar , Condemns the Gentiles for their Temples , Altars , and Images . Quid sibi Templa , quid arae volunt ? Quid denique ipsa simulachra ? What means your Temples , Altars , and Images ? In his Instit . l. 6. c. 25. Non Templa illi congestis in altitudinem saxis extruenda sunt : In suo cuique consecrandus est pectore . Temples are not to be built to God , of Stones raised on heighth , every one ought to Consecrate him in his own Bre●st So again , Si Deus non videtur , ergo his rebus coli debet quae non videntur . If God be Invisible , He is to be Worshipped with such Things as cannot be seen . From these Ancients , it appears , the Primitive Christians held it as a Thing indifferent , as to the acceptableness of their Worship to God , whether they performed it in Temples , or without : And that Gods Worship being meerly of a spiritual Nature , the Place though never so magnificent and glorious , contributed nothing thereto : Which was directly opposite to the Opinion the Heathen had of Temples . And Secondly , The Gentiles Objections against Christians , shews that they had no Temples in the Days of Minutius Felix , and Origen . For we deny not , that there were Churches or Houses of Divine Worship in Arnobius or Lactantius's Time , who lived in the end of the Third or beginning of the Fourth Century . For they both acknowledge them , though but in some Places ( it being improbable that Christians in all Places had them ) Lactan. l. 4. mentions a Conventicle pull'd down , and l. 5. c. 21. Of one burnt in Phrygia with all the People therein . and l. 5. c. 2. Of a Temple of God demolished . For about his Time , in the F●urth Century , begun the Christians to use the Word Temple , for the Place of Christian Assemblies : Which formerly , to distinguish them from the Gentiles Temples they called , Oratories , Assemblies , Congregations , Collects or gatherings together , Churches , and sometimes also Stations ; as Bellarmin , and Vedelius , formerly mention'd ; and Bauldrus in 's Notes on Lactantius , de mortibus Persecutorum , and Spanhem have shewn . Nor say we , that Lactantius taxed the Heathens barely for their Buildings ; but for their Error , in thinking , God was better served in Temples than without : And that the more glorious they were , their Service was more grateful to God. Whereas the Christian Religion , tota in animo colentis est , is all in the mind of the Worshipper . And this appears all along in his Book , l. 2. c. 6. l. 5. c. 19. and l. 6. c. 1. and 25. Also Chrysostom , Homil. 36. on 1 Corinth . saith , That in the Apostle's Days , Houses were Churches , meaning Private Houses no doubt . And Isidore Pelusiota his Schollar is very plain and positive , l. 2. Epist . 246. That in the Time of the Apostles , when the Church abounded with the Graces of the Spirit , and Holiness of Life , there were no Temples , though ours now are adorned more than is meet . And having distinguished between 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the Church , and the Place , as 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the Sacrifice and Altar , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the Councel , and Place of their Convention ; concludes that in the Apostle's Times 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , there were no Artificial Churches . These with other of the Ancients , are followed by many of the Learned in after Ages . Gerhard the Glory of the Lutherans for Learning , c. 2. § . 9. de Ecclesia , saith , Ex Actis Apostolicis , & Seriptoribus vetustioribus constat , quod Christiani . Apostolorum tempore nondum habuerunt Publica Templa , sed in Privatis Domibus convenerunt . That 't is manifest from the Acts of the Apostles , and Ancient Writers , that the Christians had no Publick Temples in the Apostles Time , but met in Private Houses . The Learned Jesuit Justinian , in 's excellent Comments on the Epistles on 1 Cor. 11.18 . saith , The Christian Assemblies were first in Privatis Domibus in Private Houses ; afterwards in Oratoriis & Ecclesiis , in Oratories and Churches : Plainly distinguishing Oratories from Private Houses , and shews by Reason of Persecution , they met very often in Vaults , and Burying-places . Our renowned Bishop Pearson in 's Comment on the Creed , p. 337. having said Acts 11.26 . and 1 Cor. 11.18 . seem to take the Church for the Place , in the following Page saith , it s not certain the Apostle uses them in that Sense , nor that there were any Houses set apart for the Worship of God , in the Apostles Times , which then could be called by the Name of Churches . And that the Primitive Christians thus continued , without Publick Oratories or Churches , is concluded by Vedelius in Ignat. Vltra ducentissimum annum , nullum Oratoriorum Publicorum vestigium apparet : That there 's no footsteps in Antiquity of any Publick Places of Worship for above the first Two Hundred Years after Christ : And upon the same grounds Spanhemius in Hist . Saeculo 2d o. That Templa adhuc Christianis nulla , ex silentio veterum & conditione temporum liquet , &c. That the Christians had no Temples in the Second Century is apparent , from the Ancient Writers making no mention of any , and the Condition of those Times , by Reason of Persecution . So also Cuperus in 's Ep. ad P. Voet. amongst the Notes on Lactantius de mortibus Persecutorum . I shall add no more Testimonies for this , that the Christians had not any Publick Places to assemble in from the Times of the Apostles and ever after , as our Adversaries affirm ; having shewn the Opinions of Clem. Alexandrinus , Eusebius and others , concerning Temples in my first Dissertation . But proceed to the Third Thing proposed , which will further clear this Controversie : In shewing , what Time , and in what kind of Places they assembled , during their Persecution under the Heathens . SECT . 14. First , How careful the Primitive Christians were , of keeping their Assemblies for the Worship of God , as Private as possible ; appears by their holding them frequently in the Night , of which we have unquestionable Witnesses . Pliny in 's Ep. to Trajan , writes Se de sacris corum nihil aliud comperisse , quam caetus antelucanos , &c. That he found nothing concerning their Religious Worship , but that they held their Meetings , in the Night before Day-light , wherein they sung Hymns to Christ as God , &c. The same is Recorded in Tertullian's Apol. c. 2. Euseb . Hist . l. 3. c. 32. And Hiecrom in Chron. Euseb . Gerh. Vossius in 's Comment on the foremention'd Epistle saith , It was necessary for them so to assemble in the Night , because of the continual Persecution they were under , Persecutio totis sae●●lis duravit , ut passim necesse fuerit conveniri noctu . Tertullian , l. 2. ad Vxorem , disswading her from Marrying an Infidel , brings this as one Argument , that He would not willingly suffer her to leave him in Bed , to frequent the Nocturnal Assemblies of Christians , if it were needful . Quis Nocturnis Convocationibus , si ita oportuerit , à latere suo eximi libenter feret ? And the Learned Heraldus in 's Notes on Tertullian , de Corona Militis , saith , That the Christians often assembled in the Night , saepius Noctu Congregatos . And so do several others : Whence the Learned derive that Ceremony , of Burning Wax Candles before the Shrines of Saints even in the Day Time ( as is usual in all the Popish . Countries ) to retain that Custom of the Primitive Christians , who in Times of Persecution met in the Night , and usually in the Burying Places of the Deceased Christians . Secondly , Let us consider what kind of Places , the Primitive Christians held their Assemblies in , for Worship : And we shall find them the privatest possible , that they might not be discovered . So that Celsus p. 4 , and 5. in Origen , makes this his very first Objection against the Christians in general , and not of that time only , that they held their Meetings in Private and obscure Places . The which none ever doubted of or denied , that are not strangers in Ecclesiastical History or Antiquity ; wherein this is so frequently mentioned . Alexander Hales Writes of the whole Time in general , related by G. Biel on the Canon of the Mass , Lect. 13. Ab Episcopatu Petri Apostoli , usque ad Tempus Sylvestri , &c. That from Peter to Sylvester Persecution raging , the Episcopal Station of the Bishop of Rome was uncertain : But wheresoever the present Necessity constrained them to be , whether in Vaults under-ground , or the Houses of Christians , or what other places soever ; there they celebrated Mass upon an Altar of Wood , made hollow like an Ark , which was carried by the Priests to the Place , wheresoever tho Bishop of Rome lay hid . And Hierom on 40. Chap. of Ezekiel describes those Vaults , which they often made their Meeting-places , Dum essem Romae Puer , &c. When I was a Youth at Rome , and instructed in liberal Studies , it was my Custom with others of the same Age and Profession , on the Lords Days to visit the Sepulchres of the Apostles and Martyrs , and often to enter into the Vaults , which were digged deep in the Earth ; wherein were on each side as we went , the Bodies of dead Men buried . And all Places there were so Dark , that it might well be said of them , according to that of the Prophet , The Living go down into Hell. And rarely Light was let in from above , to qualifie the horror of the Darkness , through a Hole rather than a Window . And again , going on Foot by Foot , and being compassed about with dark Night , we are minded of that which Virgil saith , Horror ubique animos , simul ipsa silentia terrent . Horror on every side , and Silence therewithal affrights Mens Minds . A like Description of these Vaults where tho Christians met , we have in Prudentius his 11th Hymn , in excellent Verses , but too many to be here inserted . Not that these Burying-places were peculiar to the Martyrs ; for other Christians were also Buried there , though not in the same Graves , till under Christian Emperors , Churches were Erected in Cities , into which the Martyrs Bodies were brought from without , and Superstition prevailed to make them the Common Burying-places : Which many Learned Men both Papists and Protestants have written against , and shewn how Injurious 't is to the Health of the Living , with many other Reasons ; but the Tyrant Custom hath always conquer'd the strongest Arguments . Nor when they met in such Places , was it for their Worshipping the Reliques of the Martyrs , as the Papists thence infer : But ( besides their Privacy , being remote from their Cities , ) for the preserving their Memories fresher in their Minds , and by their Examples be excited to Constancy in the Faith , and Suffering Martyrdom . And though Onuphrius de Caemiteriis , maintains , that Structures were made for Worship in these Burial-places ; and Hospinian grants it came to that at length ; yet were they but Sacella , or Chappels under-ground ; as Platina tells us in the Life of Calixtus , who having said he did not believe that famous and large Church which Alexander the Son of Mammaea ( who began his Reign , A. D. 225. according to Baronius ) had granted the Christians , to be the same , with that which Calixtus was said to have built , on the other side of Tiber , he gives this Reason , Cun●…a tempestate , ob crebras Persecutiones , occulta essent omnia , & sacella potius , atque eadem abdita , & plerumque subterranea , quam apertis in Locis & Publicis fierent . For in those Days , by Reason of frequent Persecutions , all Things were carried secretly : And they had Chappels rather , and those hidden , and for the most part under-ground , than in open and publick Places . Which last Words are also recited by Pol. Virgil. If any desire further Satisfaction , concerning the Primitive Christians meeting in those Burial-Places : He may find it in Kercher's Roma subterranea , l. 1. c. 2. de Coemeteriis . But though these Places after some time , and Martyrdom under Nero and following Emperors , were used more especially by the Christians , as appears by the Edict of Decius , Nec usquam omnino vel vobis , vel aliis quibusque potestas erit aut celebrandi conventus , aut in ea quae coemeteria appellantur ingredi ; Thus the Christians in Alexandria , and all others were prohibited their Meetings , or entering into the Coemiteries particularly . As also by the Edict of Valerian , whereby all their Assemblies being strictly prohibited , these Places in special were forbidden them ; And as Gallienus his Son by his Rescript graciously restored the Places of Worship in general : So by another these Coemeteries in special , Euseb . Hist . l. 7. Yet as Necessity required , by Reason of Persecution , their Meetings in these Places , being found out and known by the Heathens , they met elsewhere some times in one Place , and some times in another , as in Woods , Caves , Mountains , &c. When they could not in Private Houses , that they might not be discovered . Our Learned Hooker in 's fifth Book of Eccles . Pol. § . 11. hath a short , but very comprehensive Passage for this . The Church of Christ ( saith He ) which was in Jerusalem , and hold that Profession , which had not , the publick Allowance , and countenance of Authority , could not so long use the Exercise of christian Religion , but in Private only . And as God gave Increase to his Church ; they sought out both there , and abroad for that Purpose , not the sittest ( for so the Times would not suffer them to do ) but the safest Places they could . In Process of Time , some whiles by Sufferance , some whiles by special Leave and Favour , they began to erect to themselves Oratories . Thus Hilary also in his Book against the Arrians and Auxentius , speaking of Christians in the Apostles Days , affirms that they were , Per caenacula & secreta coenutes , such as had their Meetings in Chambers , and secret Places . Afterwards most commonly in caemiteriis & cryptis , in subterraneous Vaults . And in the Time of his Banishment warns them to whom he writes , to beware of Antichrist , for you are unhappily taken with the Love of Walls , you do not well in venerating the Church of God for Structures and Edifices : Is it doubtful that Antichrist shall sit in these ? Montes mihi & sylvae , & lacus , & carceres & vordgines tutiores sunt , &c. Mountains and Woods , and Lakes , and Prisons , and Gulfs , are more safe to me . For in these , the Prophets either abiding or drowned , have Prophesied by the Spirit of God , And Walafudus Strabo to the same Purpose , whose Words we recited in Ninth Section , Page 40. So Polid. Virgil , a good Antiquary in 's Book de Inventione rerum , l. 5. c. 6. affirms that , à Christi ascensu , ad Dioclesianum & Maximianum , toto fere temporis intervallo tantum aberat , ut aliquod templum à Christianis , publicè aedificaretur ; ut etiam ommia essent occulta & sacella potius , atque etiam abdita , & plerumque subterranea quàm apertis in Locis ac Publicis fierent . That from Christs Ascension to Dioclesian and Maximianus , for that whole Interval of Time almost , the Christians were so far from building any Temple in Publick , that all Things were kept secret : And Chappels rather , and those also hidden , and for the most part under-ground , than in open and publick Places . Though He thinks it credible , where the Fury of persecuting Tyrants reached not , the Apostles might Consecrate some Temples , as Matthew in Aethiopia , Bartholomew in India , and Andrew in Scythia , and James at Jerusalem . But these are but this Conjectures ( for which he brings no Proof in founded upon the Piety of the Apostles , who always imployed their utmost Power to propogate Religion amongst all Nations . For : we no where find that any of the Apostles required the erecting of Structures for Worship , or Consecrating any for that end : Nor the least Signification , that without such , Religion could not be propogated . And the Renowned Sir H. Spelman , p. 70. De non temevandis Ecclesiis , having mentioned the Consecration of Churches in Constantines Time , adds , That the Christians being in Elder Ages in Persecution , might hardly Build or Dedicate any Churches ; but were constrained to use Private Houses , and Solitary Places for their Assemblies . The Learned Mr. Robert Cook Viccar of Leeds in 's Censura quor . Script . shews Dionysius Works to be Counterfeit , because he mentions several Things , and particularly stately Temples , after the manner of that at Jerusalem , having their Sancta Sanctorum divided from the rest , into which it was not lawful for the Monks and Lay People to enter . Whereas there were no such Things in those Days , saith Cook , but Christians met together after the Manner of the Apostles , Acts 1.13 . and 12.12 . and 20.8 . in private and secret Places , and there had their Prayers and Sermons : Publick Temples they had none by reason of Tyrants . I might bring in the like Attestations from our famous Jewel Article 3. p. 145. Willet's Synopsis Papismi , sixth General Controversie , Quest . 6. With several others : But I shall conclude all with the Testimony of a great Historian yet living ( of whose Acquaintance and Friendship I have the Honour to partake ) viz , Dr. Spanhem the Honorary Professor at Leyden , who in 's learned and useful Ecclesiastical Hist . of the New Testament saith , Loca Sacrorum Conventuum fuere saeculo secundo , partim aedes privatorum , caenacula , balnea , porticus , cryptae , loca abdita . Partim caemeteria seu Sepulchreta Martyrum ad quae Conventus indicerent , zelo accendendo , his constantiae exemplis . The Places of the Christians Meetings in the Second Century , were partly Private Houses , Dining Rooms , Baths , Galleries , Vaults , and secret Places : Partly Burial-Places or Sepulchres of the Martyre , which they appointed their Meetings , for the inflaming their Zeal , by those Examples of Constancy . And afterwards shews , the Manner of notifying their Conventions , was by their Servants from House to House : For as yet neither the beating of Wood , nor sound of Bells , or Brass , or Voice of Cryers were used for , this end , lost their Assemblies should be known to the Heathens . In the Third Century , whether the Christians had any Temples or Churches Dedicated or Consecrated by Sacred and Christian Rites is , saith He , a Controversie amongst the Learned . Pol. Virgil , Durantus , Baronius , Bellarminus , Ciaconius and Valcsius affirm it . And of ours also Wower , Fuller , Selden and others . That Churches are frequently mentioned in this Age , is out of doubt : At nec Temptorum illis aut Nomen , aut Forma , aut Splendor , aut Species quaedam . Aedes fuere Privatorum , Domus , caenacula , sed plorumque caemeteria , Cryptae spatiosissimae , quas areas Martyrum dixere ; etiam latibula , stabula , oremi , carceres , agri ex Antiquis Scripporibus , & ox Conditione Temporum , saeviente ut plurimum Persecutions . Quanquam sub . Al. Severo , & Philippis , & Gallieno , conveniendi libertas Christianis major . Hinc nulla esse Christianis Templa . Quae memorantur Templa , Tituli , Consecrationum Ritus Sacerdotales , à Baronio , Ciaconio , Fr. Bivario , aliis ; ea ex Apocryphis Decretalibus , ex Pontific . vitis , ex Flavii Dextri Chronico Supposititio , id genus fontibus lutulentis hausta . But they had neither the Name , nor Form , nor Splendor , nor Shape or Kind of Temples . They were the Dwellings of Private Persons , Houses , Dining-Rooms , and for the most part Burying-places , very spacious Vaults , which they called the Floors of the Martyrs : Also Lurking-places , Stables , Wildernesses , Prisons , Fields , as from Ancient Writers , and the Condition of those Times is manifest , Persecution then for the most Part raging . Allthough under Al. Sevetus , the Philips , and Gallienus , greater Liberty was given for Christian Assemblies . Hence we conclude , the Christians yet had no Temples . Those Temples , Titles , and Sacerdotal Rites of Consecration , mentioned by Baronius , Ciaconius , Fr. Bivarius , and others ; are all taken from the Apocryphal Decretals , the Lives of the Popes , and the Supposititious Chronicle of Flavius Dexter , and such like impure Fountains . Thus far that Learned Professor . To draw up all in a short Conclusion . We read in Eusebius of the Christians building Publick Oratories after Deeius and Valerians Days , not of any built before . These were by Publick Decrees , commanded to be pulled down by Dioclesian and Maximus , and not long after restored by Consiantine . Those formerly taken from the Christians by Decius and Valerian , were expressed to be Caemeteria Places of Burial in which they had their Cryptae or Vaults under-ground , formerly represented . So that for separate and publick Places for Worship , for Two Hundred Years and more after Christs . Nativity , we have no Records in approved History . FINIS . A Catalogue of BOOKS sold by Thomas Parkhurst , at the Bible and Three Crowns , in Cheap-side near Mercers-Ckappel . THE Fountain of Life open'd , or a Display of Christ in his Essential and Mediatorial Glory ; containing Forty Two Sermons on varions Texts . Wherein the Impetration of our Redemption by Jesus Christ is orderly unfolded , as it was begun , carried on , and finished by his Covenant Transaction , mysterious Incarnation , solemn Call and Dedication , blessed Offices , deep Abasement and Supereminent Advancement . A Treatise of the Soul of Man , wherein the Divine Original , excellent and immortal Nature of the Soul are opened ; its Love and Inclination to the Body , with the necessity of its Separation from it , consider'd and Improved . The Existence , Operations and States of separated Souls both in Heaven and Hell immediately after Death , asserted , discussed , and variously applied . Divers knotty and difficult Questions about departed Souls both Philosophical and Theological , stated and determin'd . The Method of Grace in bringing home the Eternal Redemption , contrived by the Father , and accomplished by the Son , through the Effectual Application of the Spirit unto Gods Elect being the second Part of Gospel-Redemption . The Divine Conduct or Mystery of Providence , its Being and Efficacy asserted and vindicated . All the Methods of Providence in our Course of Life open'd , with Directions how to apply and improve them . Navigation spiritualiz'd , or a new Compass for Seamen , consisting of Thirty Two Points of pleasant Observations , profitable Applications , serious Reflections , all concluded with so many spiritual Poems , &c. Two Treatises , the first of Fear , the second the Righteous Mans Refuge in the Evil Day . A Saint indeed , the great Work of a Christian . A Touchstone of Sincerity , or Signs of Grace , and Symptoms of Hypocrisie , being the second Part of the Saint indeed . A Token for Mourners , or boundaries for Sorrow for the Death of Friends . Husbandry spiritualiz'd : Or the Heavenly use of Earthly Things . All these Ten by Mr. John Flavel . A Funeral Sermon on the Death of that Pious Gentlewoman Mrs. Judith Hammond , late Wife of the Reverend Mr. George Hammond , Minister of the Gospel in London . Of Thoughtfulness for the Morrow . With an Appendix concerning the immoderate Desire of foreknowing Things to come . Of Charity in Reference to other Mens Sins . The Redeemer's Tears wept over lost Souls , in a Treatise on Luke 19.41 , 42. . With an Appendix , wherein somewhat is occasionally Discoursed concerning the Sin against the Holy Ghost , and how God is said to Will the Salvation of them that Perish . A Sermon directing what we are to do after a strict Enquiry whether or no we truly Love God. These Five by Mr. John Howe .