Constantius the Apostate being a short account of his life and the sense of the primitive Christians about his succession and their behaviour toward him : wherein is shown the unlawfulness of excluding the next heir upon the account of religion, and the necessity of passive obedience, as well to the unlawfull oppressour, as the legal persecutour : being a full answer to a late pamphlet intituled Julian the Apostate, &c. Bennet, John, d. 1686. 1683 Approx. 125 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 49 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2003-01 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A27390 Wing B1884 ESTC R24199 08047613 ocm 08047613 40781 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A27390) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 40781) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 1222:5) Constantius the Apostate being a short account of his life and the sense of the primitive Christians about his succession and their behaviour toward him : wherein is shown the unlawfulness of excluding the next heir upon the account of religion, and the necessity of passive obedience, as well to the unlawfull oppressour, as the legal persecutour : being a full answer to a late pamphlet intituled Julian the Apostate, &c. Bennet, John, d. 1686. [26], 65 p. Printed for Walter Kettilby, London : 1683. Reproduction of original in the University of Illinois (Urbana-Champaign Campus). Library. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Constantius -- II, -- Emperor of Rome, 317-361. Church history -- Primitive and early church, ca. 30-600. 2000-00 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2001-11 Aptara Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2002-02 TCP Staff (Oxford) Sampled and proofread 2002-02 TCP Staff (Oxford) Text and markup reviewed and edited 2002-03 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion CONSTANTIVS THE APOSTATE : BEING A Short Account of His LIFE , and the Sense of the Primitive Christians about His Succession : AND Their Behaviour toward Him. Wherein is shown the Unlawfulness of Excluding the Next Heir upon the Account of Religion , and the Necessity of Passive Obedience , as well to the Unlawfull Oppressour , as the Legal Persecutour : BEING A full Answer to a late Pamphlet , intituled Iulian the Apostate , &c. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Sopho. Let us either deserve to have a good Prince , or patiently suffer and obey such as we deserve . 1 Hom. against Wilfull Reb. &c. LONDON , Printed for Walter Kettilby at the Bishop's Head in St. Paul's Church-yard . 1683. THE Epistle Dedicatory TO Mr. IOHNSON , Authour of IVLIAN the APOSTATE . SIR , THE kindness you have for an Apostate ( for certainly Iulian was never better treated than by you ) makes me think Constantius hath a particular title to your Protection , especially since we are sure he revolted to Arrianism , and not to Popery . Now whether these kind sentiments proceed from a diffusive Charity , or rather a Natural inclination whereby every thing favours its like , I shall not presume to determine , though the latter is ●he more probable , since , like Iulian , you took holy Orders , and like him too have , in effect at least , denied a Passive Crucified Saviour : this will be plain to any one that considerately reades your book , and is the onely thing hath induc'd me to say what I have ; for I declare I am wholly unacquainted with any thing that belongs to you , but that , your Name and your Character in the Church ; so that no personal grudge could be the occasion of these papers ; but a just sense of what I owe to my Religion , and the Civil Government under which I live ; from which I ill deserve the Protection and Liberty I enjoy , if I should not use my utmost endeavour to sustain it , when it is so evidently supplanted ( as now it is ) by your pernicious principles . And I cannot think but your Religion is as indifferent to you , as you would have the World believe that of the Rippon-Addressers is to them , since you so palpably explode the glorious end of it Obedience . I say this after a due and carefull reading of your papers ; and I was more exact in the perusal , because your prejudic'd friends gave it out , that your book ought to be the perfect measure of our conduct in relation to his R. H. and the true State of that Civil Obedience we owe to a Tyrant ; and added likewise , that the Authorities you quoted were unquestionable , your inferences and deductions necessary and pertinent , and your arguments unanswerable : but after the most diligent and impartial search , not a syllable of all this appear'd ; and indeed when I considered the Vouchers , I laught at my self for giving credit to any thing they so confidently asserted , since o● late all that have not a mind to b● impos'd upon , understand what they say , with the same precaution they believe women , or interpret dreams ; and indeed they have that quality of great Lyars to have the contrary of what they affirm generally true . I hope , Sir , you will not take this for a too severe reflexion upon your friends ; I am sure they value themselves upon these pious artifices ; and it would have been unkind in them , when you had taken so much pains in publishing so many notorious falsities to advance the cause , if they had not advanc'd the credit of your book by the same means . After these unwelcome truths I can expect little favour from you , and indeed entreat none ; all that I desire is , that you would reade this as patiently as I did yours , and then , if you please , censure as freely : but of all faults , I am confident you have no reason to accuse me of that , which is almost natural to Dedications , Flattery , and which would have been an unpardonable crime in Your Servant . THE PREFACE . SInce I intend to use the same method i● the Account of the Life of Constan●ius , as is observ'd in Julian's ; it will be necessary to take a view of the Preface to that Book , that I may clear all things as I go , leaving nothing unanswer'd , that has the least appearance of an argument . And that , what he urges may more evidently appear , I shall reduce the force of all he says , to these following Propositions , and give my answers to them distinctly . 1. The Rippon-Addressers are very solicitous , lest his Majesty should agree to the Bill of Exclusion ( pag. 4. ) and thence infers , that if they were Protestants , they were men weary of their Religion , p. 6. 2. The Primitive Christians conduct contrary to that of the Addressers . 3. If they had known Julian's Religion before Constantius's Death , he had not succeeded . p. 7. 4. Passive Obedience necessary for the first Christians , because the Laws were against them ; ( p. 7. ) but not for those under Julian , because they had the Laws on their side ; for when 't is prescrib'd without Law , and against Law , 't is Mahumetan ( p. 8. ) 5. Passive Obedience contrary to the Gospel ; this he pretends to prove from 1 Cor. 7. 21 , 22 , 23 verses , with Dr. Hammond's Paraphrase : and by the example of St. Paul , Act. 22. 25 , 26 , &c. 16. 39 , &c. p. 9. 6. Passive Obedience contrary to the Law of the Land. As to the first of these . I don't find the Addressers of Rippon are fond of a Popish , but a lawfull Successour : and if Mr. Johnson infers from their aversion to the Bill of Exclusion , that they are weary of their Religion ; certainly he doth not think them Protestants now . For what can be a greater mark of that sacred profession , than to be severely cautious to prevent an Action that would be contrary to all Laws divine and humane ? They are strangers to that way of preserving their Religion , by acting contrary to the dictates of it ; and will hardly venture to doe an unjust thing now , that they may go quietly to Church hereafter . Certainly we are not by this means to avoid Persecution ; this is nothing else , but preferring the eternal torments of the next world , before the little pressures of this , and leaping into Hell to avoid the Cross. I should have made a far different construction of this Address ; for if the Gentlemen of Rippon were sure his R. H. were a Papist ( whereof no man yet ever made a legal proof ) yet what they did was their duty ; for they knew Imperatores bonos voto expetendos , qualescunque tolerandos : And that this was the opinion of the Primitive Christians , as well as Tacitus . Which will be more fully made out in my answer to the second Position , which is , That the Conduct of the Primitive Christians , was quite contrary to that of the Addressers . It will be hard to reconcile this saying of his , not onely to truth , but sense ; for if the Primitive Christians acted quite contrary to the Addressers , then when these made it their humble Petition to his Majesty not to exclude his R. H. they supplicated to Constantius to put by Julian ; but this was not so , as he himself assures us ( p. 18. ) so that his saying the Primitive Christians acted contrary to the Gentlemen of Rippon , when he acknowledges they did nothing at all , must either be non-sense , or made out by a new definition of contraries . But I will suppose he means had the Christians known Julian's Apostacy , they would have us'd all possible means to have prevented hi● coming to the Empire . Which is the substance ● the third Position to be answered . Certainly he ought to have good grounds for this assertion , and know of some presidents of their precluding the next Heir upon the account of Heresie or Apostacy ; or at least that it is manifest , from some principles they own'd , that they would , if it had lain in their power : If he knows any thing of this nature , he would doe well to inform the world of it , and give us a second Edition of his Book , which onely such an Addition could make considerable . For in his Preface he gives no reason at all ●for what he asserts ; and in the second Chapter of his Book , where proofs of this kind would be very necessary , he onely tells as that Gregory Nazianzen [ highly before disoblig'd by Julian ] in an invective long after his death tells Constantius [ then in Heaven ] that he did ill in s●ving and making Julian King ; who was both ill sav'd , and made an ill King : and then concludes , Constantius would not have done so , if he had known Julian's Apostacy . Sure this Gentleman has had the misfortune that the Christian's Children had under Julian , to be deny'd the use of Logick and Rhetorick ; for how else could he make such an absurd inference , or understanding the nature of an Invective , undertake to deduce a concluding argument from any thing that is deliver'd in one ? I declare , ( though I have the greatest veneration for the Holy Fathers imaginable , and especially for that great Name Gregory Nazianzen ) yet I cannot think it my duty strictly to believe all they say in the height of a Panegyrick , or an Invective ; there are certain allowances to be made in our belief of Speeches , that are the effects of either kindness or anger ; and the distinction may not be improperly ad●mitted , between the Father , and the Oratour : but this will be more evident , to any impartial man , when I shall prove that many things in Gregory's Invective said in favour of Constantius , or against Julian , are not precisely true : for every one knows Constantius had faults ; for 't is acknowledg'd ( p. 29. ) that he was guilty of the Murther of his kindred and innovation in matters of Faith ( for 't is there said he repented of these things at his death ) and I shall add , of a severe Persecution ( which will be seen anon . ) Granting this to be true , how could he justly merit this Complement from Gregory ? You were led by the hand of God into every counsel and enterprize , whose wisedom was admir'd above your power , and again your power , more than your wisedom ; but your piety was valued above them both . ( Greg. Inv. ) If Mr. Johnson thinks this deservedly said of Constantius , he must either think all Histories that give us an account of that unhappy Emperour's life , fabulous , or entitle God to his Apostacy ; but I suppose he is not arriv'd to that height of folly , to believe the former , or of impiety , to admit of the latter . 'T is probable he will rather conform to the general opinion of all understanding men , that Gregory did , and might say more in an Invective , than would be allowable in a History or a Sermon . Again , that he should make the Devil steal in along with the Consult ( p. 25. ) can onely be imputed to the uncontrollable liberty of an Invective ; for St. Austin tells us , God that gave the Empire to the Christian Prince Constantine , gave it also to Julian the Apostate . Those things without doubt , that One and the True God doth govern and rule as he pleaseth , by causes , although hidden , yet not unjust . ( Aug. de Civ . D. 5. c. 21. ) Origen likewise tells us , that bad and good Princes are both the gift of God , Si mali sunt actus nostri , & operamur malignum in conspectu dei ; dantur nobis principes secundum cor nostrum . [ Orig. in lib. Iud. Hom. 4. ] Now which is in the right , St. Austin or Gregory , let any man judge . But farther , can any man believe that the Father spoke in earnest , when he tells Constantius he did ill to save Julian , ( p. 23. ) i. e. he had done well if he had Murther'd him ( for there is no difference in the Court of Conscience , between doing an injury your self , and permitting it to be done by others , if it lye in your power to prevent it , ) if by that means he had prevented his succession ; since 't is contrary , not onely to Scripture , but common prudence , to prevent a future inconvenience by a present ill , and by a sin endeavour to avert onely a possible misfortune . I can't tell how difficult it is to satisfie other people ; but for my own part , I think , I can justly conclude from these instances , that every thing in Gregory's Invective , is not to be urg'd for proof : And this doth not at all derogate from the truth and sincerity of his other works , because the nature of the thing gives him liberties now ; which , as they are not allowable in his other Writings , so neither are they usual . But certainly nothing in the world is more senseless and ridiculous , than that which Mr. Johnson urges to enhanse the credit of this Invective ( p. 27. ) where he says the things [ concerning Julian ] were not deliver'd coldly , and nakedly set down , but with an Emphasis , and the greatest vehemency : For all people know , the passion they were deliver'd with , ought to make us suspect the truth of them ; for angry men often speak what they don't think themselves ; they do not consider what ought to be said , but what makes most against their enemy ; and their fury improves every thing into a weapon to serve their revenge : For I would fain know of Mr. Johnson , which he thinks more exactly true , Tully's Offices , or his Philippicks ; and yet how nakedly and coldly one is deliver'd , and with what vehemence and pomp of words the other , is easily seen . Therefore ( with all submission ) I think Gregory's authority in this Invective , ought to have no more weight with us , than Grotius allows to the sayings of Orators [ Prol. l. 1. de Ju. Bel. & Pa. ] Nos saepe iis utimur , non tam ut inde astruamus fidem , quam ut his quae dicere volumus , ab ipsorum dictis , aliquid ornamenti accedat . I can hardly imagine that Holy Father himself , had he been at the Consult , would have encourag'd Constantius to exclude Julian , though he knew his Apostacy ; because it cannot be easily suppos'd , that he would coolly have done an Action , contrary to the Law of Nature : the reveal'd word of God : and the practice of the Primitive Christians . 1. That the Exclusion of Julian , would have been contrary to the Law of Nature , may be gather'd from what Mr. Johnson says of his Title to the Crown ( p. 19. ) viz. that it was 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , so that destroying this , must needs be a great breach of the Law of Nature , which cannot be allowable upon any Consideration ; for a Heathen will tell us , Nec derogari aliquid ex hâc [ lege naturae ] licet , neque tota abrogari potest : neque verò per Senatum , aut per populum , solvi hâc lege possumus ; nec est quaerendus interpres , aut explanator ejus alius ; nec erit alia l●x Romae , alia Athenis , alia nunc , alia posthac : sed & omnes gentes , & omni tempore , una lex & sempiterna & immortalis continebit ; unusque erit communis quasi magister , & imperator omnium , Deus ille legis hujus inventor , disceptator , lator ; cui qui non parebit ipse se fugiet , & naturam hominis aspernabitur ; atque hoc ipso luet maximas poenas , etiamsi caetera supplicia quae putantur effugerit . [ This is quoted Lact. 6. Inst. 8. out of Cic. Books de Repub. that are lost . ] If this be true ( which I am sure no man of common knowledge will deny ) what becomes of the lawfulness of Excluding Julian ? 'T would have been equally as just to have prevented his Succession hy death as any other means ; for any thing tending to this had been a breach of the Law of Nature , and would onely differ from the former , as robbing a man doth , from cutting his Throat . 2. That such an attempt is contrary to the reveal'd Law of God , may necessarily be infer'd from the exact agreement there is between the Scriptures and the Law of Nature ; This , being onely 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 legis illius architypae & aeternae quae est immensè divina ; and those , his reveal'd will : but 't is expresly set down in Scripture , that the Right of Succession is entail'd on Primogeniture ; for Gen. 49. 3. when Jacob blessed his sons , he call'd Reuben his first-born the Excellency of dignity , and the Excellency of power ; and in 2 Chron. 21. 3. 't is said , that Jehoram succeeded Jehosaphat , because he was the first-born . I might fill my Margin with quotations to this purpose , but I shall onely add that great instance of the Right of Primogeniture , Gen. 4. 7. where God tells Cain of his younger brother Abel , Unto thee shall be his desire , and thou shalt rule over him ; which are the very words which God spake Chap. 3. v. 16. when he gave the man dominion over the woman . Now that this right extends to proximity of blood , no body questions ; so that unless we have some warrant from Scripture to res●ind this title , it is the highest sacrilege imaginable to attempt it ; and I challenge all the world to shew where that warrant is . God himself , indeed , may dispose of the right that he first gave ; but I would fain know what people could ever lawfully pretend to alter the Succession , without an express warrant from God ? David , I confess , made Solomon King , but he declares 't was by God's immediate ●ppointment ; and of all my sons , for the Lord hath given me many sons , he hath chosen Solomon my son to sit upon the Throne of the kingdom of the Lord over Israel , 1 Chron. 28. 5. Now I shall readily grant the Authour of Julian's friends , Enthusiasts ; but I can hardly admit they have a particular revelation for what they would now be at ; and without this , I think the Exclusion of the Next Heir utterly unlawfull . And that this was the sense of the first Christians , will be evident from the Apology of Athenagoras to M. Aurelius , and his son Commodus : where having declar'd the Christians were of all others most piously inclin'd toward God and their Empire , he concludes with this profession : We pray for your Empire , that the Son ( as it is most fit ) may in the Kingdom succeed the Father , and that your Empire may encrease and flourish , all being made subject to you , which would be much for our good , that we leading a quiet and peaceable life , may readily obey you in all your Commands . I think nothing can be fuller than this to prove what I design'd , for that in these words he declar'd the sense of the Church , we must necessarily grant , if we consider what his Character then was , when he spake them . Athe. Legat. pro Christ. But to come nigher to the business in hand ; the Primitive Christians did know Julian's Apostacy , before Constantius died : For as soon as ever he was declar'd Emperour by the Souldiers , he laid by all pretence to Christianity ; for going through every City , he open'd the Temples , and call'd himself the High Priest ( Soz. ) So that , like Mr. Johnson , he did not lay by the name of Priest , though he turn'd Apostate . Now that the Army should be ignorant of what Julian did so publickly in the face of the Sun , is not to be imagin'd ; especially if Constantius himself knew it ; which Mr. Johnson would have us believe , from the passage he cites from Gregory Naz. that Constantius repented his declaring Julian his Successour ; which could onely be upon the account of his Apostacy , so that he must needs know it . But if we give any credit to Marcellinus ( whose authority I am sure Mr. Johnson seems much to value ) if Constantius did know that Julian was a Pagan , it was impossible he should repent of his leaving him his Successour : for he tells us ( l. 21. ) that upon his falling sick he did in his right understanding [ integro sensu ] nominate Julian his heir , and ( l. 22. ) with his last breath [ supremâ voce ] pronounc'd hi● Emperour : Now that he spoke or shew'd any signs of his repentance after his death , Mr. Johnson will hardly allow , because that looks too like a Popish Miracle . I am rather inclin'd to believe that Constantius thought the Right of Succession was so inviolable , that the highest provocation imaginable ought not to prevail with him to alter it ; for else why did he not endeavour to exclude him , when he had been guilty of the highest ingratitude , in procuring himself to be declar'd Emperour by the Army , and af●erwards in justifying his title by an open rebellion ? It had certainly been but justice to have proceeded with the greatest rigour against him for so insolent an Vsurpation . But alas ! he knew his Edicts in this case would be superseded by a greater Law , and that they would be of little force against that title from which he first deriv'd the power to make them . I hope this is a sufficient answer to the second Chapter , wherein Mr. Johnson pretends to shew the sense of the Primitive Christians about Julian's Succession , but makes one man's opinion the sense of the whole Church , and takes that opinion too of his , from his Invectives : this is so dis-ingenuous , it could never be excus'd : but that the badness of the cause he is engag'd in , can find nothing else to support it . As to the fourth Position , that Passive Obedience was necessary for the first Christians , because the Laws were against them , but not to those under Iulian , because the Laws were for them . I answer ; that this distinction is frivolous ; for since the will of their Emperour was a Law ( as Gregory acknowledges In. p. 92. ) if they were executed by his Command , they died lawfully . But I shall refer the farther proof of this to a particular Chapter of Passive Obedience . But since he urges the Authority of holy Scripture to confirm what he says in this place , we must , for method sake , take notice of it : which is the fifth thing to be answer'd , viz. That Passive Obedience is contrary to the Gospel , as may be seen 1 Cor. 7. 21 , 22 , 23 verses , with Dr. Hammond's Paraphrase . 'T is very strange , that when our Saviour so often recommends sufferings to us as our duty , and the badge of our profession , that quietly and patiently submitting to them , should be contrary to the Gospel ; certainly he has a particular Bible to himself ; for we find in ours , that suffering is particularly the business of the Gospel ; and is the great concluding beatitude , ( Mat. 5. 11. ) nay 't is evident that misery and persecution were first entail'd on Christianity ; for the Jews had the prospect of Temporal blessings : Riches and honours were the lot of their inheritance ; but we are commanded to take up the Cross , and despise the shame of it , that thereby we might imitate him , who condescended to be our great exemplar : But however , it will not be amiss to see what Reason he has for this monstrous assertion ; and because every one has not Dr. Hammond's Paraphrase at hand ( which I am confident is the reason he quoted it ) I shall give it you here with the Text. V. 21. Art thou call'd being a servant ? care not for it : but if thou mayst be made free , use it rather . Para. [ In what condition of life soever a man is , when he is converted to Christianity , let him contentedly continue in it , and not think that Christian Religion frees a man from any obligation that lay upon him before ; for that is to make Christian Religion a pretence to covetousness , or lust , or secular advantages , ( see 1 Tim. 6. ) if either being a Christian might manumit a servant , or free a husband , or a wife from former obligation . He therefore that being a bondman is converted to Christianity , must not think that it is any disparagement to his Christianity , that he continues a servant still , nor be solicitous of changing his condition . Yet this is not so to be understood , but that if by any fair regular means , he can obtain his freedom , he may then make use of them , and prefer liberty before servitude ; for so he might have done , had he never been a Christian . ] Ver. 22. For he that is call'd in the Lord , being a servant , is the Lord's freeman ; likewise he that is call'd , being free , is Christ's servant . Para. [ For he that being in the condition of a servant , is converted to Christianity , doth by his conversion become a freeman in respect of Christ ; not that he ceases to be a servant to his former master , or reaps any secular advantages thereby , but his advantages are spiritual , viz. that by being a Christian he is freed from many servitudes , that of sin , &c. that lye upon all others ; and to live in Christ's family as one of his freemen , though in respect of the world he continue as a servant . And so on the other side , he that is a freeman , and turns Christian , becomes thereby a servant of Christ's , undertaking Obedience to his Command , though he lose not his liberty in the world by that means . ( By which 't is clear , that Christ meddles not with the secular Government of this world , nor changes any man 's outward condition by his becoming Christian . ) ] Ver. 23. Ye are bought with a price , be not servants of men . Para. [ Ye that are Christians , and not formerly servants to Heathens , do not voluntarily put your selves in that condition , but chuse liberty rather . ] Certainly Mr. Johnson has a different Edition of Dr. Hammond , as well as of the Bible , from that which is in use with us ; for from these Texts above cited , nothing can be infer'd to prove what he designs , viz. that we are encourag'd by Christianity to procure more civil Liberties and Franchises ; for it is positively set down in the Paraphrase , that Christ meddles not with the secular government of this world , nor changes any man 's outward condition , by his becoming Christian. One would think , by this way of procedure , Mr. Johnson , like Julian , onely reades the Scriptures , to pervert other people by an ill application of them , and to use the Gospel against his Saviour . 2. His inference , that St. Paul was against Passive Obedience [ Act. 22. 26 , &c. ] because he told the Captain ( that was ignorant of his condition ) that he was a Roman , and consequently exempt from the punishment he was going to inflict upon him , is the most absurd reasoning imaginable . I perceive after all his bawling against Passive Obedience , he is perfectly ignorant what it is ; for to suffer torments when we can avert them by lawfull means , is not Passive Obedience , but stupidity : this is not taking up the Cross ( as a great Man observes ) but pulling it down upon us : Christianity allows us to make a defence , but we are not to resist ; we may certainly tell our story ; but if that will not be heard , we must submit with patience . And these were the Methods of the Primitive Christians , they pray'd to God , they supplicated to their Emperours , to avert a threatn'd persecution ; but if these means would not doe , they had Gregory Nazianzen's comfort left still , to dye patiently . 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 . Since Passive Obedience is not onely allow'd , but enjoin'd by the Gospel ( as is briefly shown already , and shall be more fully prov'd by and by ) that it should be contrary to the Law of the Land ( which is the sixth and last thing he lays down ) cannot be admitted , since our Laws must necessarily conform to the determinations of the Holy Scriptures ; and whatsoever is enacted contrary to them , is ipso facto void ; and I am sure whatever he says , will hardly induce any man in his right senses to think otherwise . I am sure the Case he brings ( p. 9. ) is nothing to the purpose ; for he can onely infer from that , That a man may kill an aggressour , and the Law take no hold of him . If he could prove from any instance that the Law obliges a man ( if he can ) to kill one that offers violence to him , he had said something : But there is a vast difference between what the Law permits , and what it commands ; he is not indeed obnoxious to any legal punishment here , but the verdict of a Iury will not absolve him from a guilt he has contracted by disobeying our Saviour , who has commanded us not to resist evil , [ evil not signifying a thing , but a person ] Mat. 5. 39. So that the killing of a Pursevant , though it be excus'd in the eye of the Law , it will not be so hereafter in heaven ; For if he onely design'd an arrest ( as 't is own'd he did ) a man ought not to take away his life : this is plain from Dr. Hammond [ Prac. Cat. p. 164. ] where he tells us a private man may not by the Law of Christ take away another's life , to save his own goods , or to repell any such kind of injury , because life is more than goods ; nay , ' ●twould be better to avoid taking away another's life , though to save his own ; thereby imitating his Saviour who laid down his life for his enemies . lbid . As to those arguments ( p. 15. ) from Sir Simon Ewe's Iournal to prove the lawfulness and necessity of excluding a Popish Successour . I hardly think them worth the least remark . For what can be more unreasonable , than that which they seem to enforce , that it had been just and warrantable not onely to have dis-inherited the Queen of Scots , but to have taken away her life too , for her Religion ? For what just pretence could Queen Elizabeth have to Condemn a Princess altogether as independent as her self , and one that was onely accountable to God for her actions ? they might as well have addrest against the French King or the Pope for endeavouring to pervert her Majestie 's Subjects , for the Queen had equal power over these Princes , though she had them not in possession : And though an Act of Parliament against them , would not perhaps have been of very great force , yet it would have been expedient to have shewn her good will ( as Mr. Johnson calls it . ) But we shall find the weakness of these arguments in the effect they bad on the Queen ; for she was so far from being persuaded that the fact was lawfull , that she always deny'd her being consenting , or so much as privy to it , when it was done ; and though there might be some probable reasons to believe she was innocent , yet the very suspicion of her being privy to it , has fixt an eternal blot upon her ( otherwise unspotted ) reputation . So that these arguments will seem of very little weight to his present Majesty , when all the world knows how unjustly , and unsuccessfully too , they were urg'd against his great Ancestour , to a Princess that was her mortal enemy , and one but too desirous of her destruction . There is nothing now left in the Preface that is worth taking notice of , but the Act of the 13 of Queen Elizabeth , whereby 't was enacted Treason during her life , to affirm that she , and her Parliament , could not make Laws and Statutes , of sufficient force and validity , to limit and bind the Crown of this Realm , and the Descent , Limitation , Inheritance , &c. I shall not presume to determine of the equity and justice of this Act , or whether it were in their power to doe as they did ; but the Excellent Authour of a late Pamphlet , entituled , The Great point of Succession discussed , being an Answer to the History of Succession , &c. though he was a Member of those very Parliaments that were so hot for the Bill of Exclusion , freely declares that the Crown of England is , and ought to be , inseparably annext to proximity of blood , by the Laws of God , and Nature , and this Realm ; so that consequently any Act , that pretends to alter the Succession , is utterly unlawfull , and ipso facto void : and so it ought to be adjudged when it ever comes to the Question before the Reverend Iudges , p. 35. If any one requires fuller satisfaction , I refer him to the Book it self , which will convince not onely the diffiders , but the prejudic'd too , of the truth of what is here deliver'd . As for the great Subscribers to that Act , we have a Hierarchy not at all inferiour to them , either in piety or learning , who are of the contrary opinion ; and till I know the reasons why they subscrib'd , I shall not be sway'd by their Authorities , when I think I have as great to ballance them . 'T will be time now to give some account of the ensuing Work , but any considering man will reade the design in the Title Page , or at least will find it in the Book it self , from which I shall no longer detain him . The Editions of those Authours that are Cited . AThanasius 2 Vol. Par. 1627. Lactantius Basil. 1563. Origen con . Cel. Cantab. 1658. August . Opera Bas. 1569. Gregory Naz. Par. 1609. Tertullian Par. 1616. Ambrose Bas. 1555. Athenagoras Par. 1577. Theodoret Par. 1673. Rufinus Par. 1580. Nicep . Call. Fran. 1588. Socratis and Sozome . Histor. Eccl. Par. 1668. Homilies Lon. 1623. The Editions of Dr. Hammond , Bishop Taylor , &c. of the English Divines , are not so various that I need to set down here the particular times or places when and where they were printed . Constantius THE APOSTATE . CHAP. I. A Short Account of the Life of Constantius . CONSTANTINE the Great having by his last Will divided his Empire between his three Sons , Constantine , Constantius , Constance , died in the Suburbs of Nicomedia , no one of his Sons being present at his death : But Constantius , not so far off as the other two , first came to Court ; where having paid the usual respects that are due to the memory of a deceased Parent , as if all other tyes of Nature were buried with his Father , he commanded , or at least permitted , the execution of his Uncle and Cousins , Constantius Dalmatius and his Sons . [ Atha . p. 856. ] About three months after the Brothers were proclaim'd Emperours by the Army , each took his share , though not without some dissatisfaction and disturbance ; but things being happily compos'd for the present , they retir'd to their respective Provinces . This agreement did not last long , for Constantine thought himself hardly dealt withall , and not content with his share of F●ance , Spain and Britain , would needs encroach upon his Brother Constance , who had Italy and Africk , but was slain in the prosecution : Thus the Empire of the West devolv'd to Constance , but all this new accession could not prevent his being assasinated by Magnentius an Usurping Rebel : who at length after many defeats by Constantius , was forced to that degree of despair , that he slew himself , and left his Conquerour in the quiet possession of all the Empire . I was unwilling to perplex this brief account of his coming to the entire possession of the Empire , with the relation of any of his particular actions , reserving it rather to this place where I may doe it with less interruption . Constantius had not been long upon the Throne , but by the insinuations of an Arian Priest , he was brought over to be a great favourer of that Heresie ; the account of his perversion , is at large in most Ecclesiastical Histories ; and because it may be material , I shall give it at length out of Theodoret [ l. 2. c. 3. ] Constantia , Sister to Constantine the Great , was very intimate with an Arian Priest , who , dissembling his own opinion , made it his business to defend or excuse Arius ; this man , upon her death-bed , she recommended to her Brother's care , who was signally kind to him ; and as a particular mark of his favour , entrusted his last Testament in his hands : the delivery of which to Constantius , when he came to Court , was sufficient to recommend him to his favour ; and gave him an interest , that in a short time became pernicious to the whole Christian World ; ●or he improving the opportunity he had of being nigh the Emperour , and making his advantage of an inconstant humour that was peculiar to him , easily made him out of love with the true Religion , and as zealous for the false . He perswaded the Emperour , who was but too prone to hearken to any thing that was ill , ( Ath. p. 883. ) that all the disturbances in the Church arose from introducing the word Consubstantial into the Articles of Faith , which was no-where to be found in Holy Scripture , and the blame of this was laid upon Athanasius . Thus was that unhappy Emperour perverted to a Heresie , the most dangerous that ever infested the Church , for Athanasius tells us ( who had certainly good reason to know ) they deny'd Christ. [ p. 590. ] Athanasius was the first man that suffer'd by the Emperour's Apostacy ; for his piety and learning rendring him formidable to those Hereticks , they soon traduced him to Constantius , who sent part of his Army to seize him at Alexandria , but by a miraculous escape , he prevented the danger and fled to Rome . Georgius an Arian succeeded him in his Diocess , who repeated all the Cruelties of the former Persecutions , which were ten times worse in him , than in the Heathens , since he at least profest Christianity ; he whipt the Men with rods , stript the Virgins naked , and brought them to the fire , [ Nicep . Cal. Eccl. Hist. ] and in fine , acted all those torments a busie malice could invent , or a blind fierce zeal could execute . But Alexandria was not the onely Scene of Persecution ; it spread it self in a short time as far as the Heresie that was the cause of it ; but it raged particularly in Constantinople : for Macedonius despising the known methods of cruelty as too mean for an Arian to exercise , had recourse to those that were particularly of his own invention ; he did not onely punish those that would not Communicate with him , with the ordinary punishments of Whips , Chains , Death : but by an unpresidented cruelty , would force open their mouths with Clubs , and then throw into them the sacred Elements . Women likewise and Children , though not initiated nor baptiz'd , were preposterously forced to be partakers of the Holy Sacrament , and were made , as far as it lay in his power , Hereticks before they knew what Religion was . [ Nic. Call. ib. ] This certainly was a far greater wickedness than that of Iulian ; when by adding the Images of the Heathen gods to his own , he design'd to deceive the Christians into Idolatry ; for this was down-right forcing them ( if it were possible ) into Heresie . Upon these unheard-of methods of Persecution , and other bodily torments no less strange , that are at large set down in that History , the Authour makes this severe remark : Insolitum sane id , exoticumque supplicium , ab iis , qui Christum professi sunt , inventum ; quod ea quae olim Graecorum Tyranni magno studio & ambitione excogitarunt , longè post se reliquit . ( Ni. Cal. ib. ) AEgypt and Lybia were depriv'd of all their Orthodox Bishops , whose places were supply'd by Arians . Ath. Epis. ad Soli. vi . Liberius , Hosius , Paulinus , Dionysius , Eusebius , Luciferus , were Banish'd for refusing to subscribe against Athanasius , who had been acquitted by so many Synods before . Ib. And Constantius himself at length proceeded to that degree of cruelty against the Orthodox Christians , that he made an Edict , not onely to banish them , but to put them to death . Athan. p. 8. 53. And the same Father tells us , that when Maximianus ( Constantine's Father ) persecuted the Christians , the Heathens themselves would conceal them , and were so generous often as to suffer fines and imprisonment , rather than betray those that fled to them for Protection : but the New Hereticks act just the contrary , they voluntarily take upon them the office of Searchers , and Executioners , and think that he that hides a Christian is as much their enemy as he that 's hid . And then speaking of Constantius , he says ( Atha . p. 8. 36. ) Maximianus sent the Confessours into one common place of Banishment ; so that in all their mi●fortunes , they had one comfort left ( and that no small one ) of mutual society . But Constantius industri●●●●●●●●rted those that were friends , that he might make the misery of their banishment more insupportable , and prevent the onely happiness they desir'd , not to be parted till they died . This was so great a Cruelty , that never can be excus'd , and no body but a Primitive Christian could bear it without repining . It would be an endless piece of business to recount all the sufferings of the Church , under this cruel Apostate , who was no less a Tyrant in Civil affairs , than a Persecutour in Religious ; it being an observ'd Maxim , that under him no one had escap'd Condemnation , of whom it had been but whisper'd that he was guilty ; for he seldom heard above one side , viz. the whispering Arian or Eunuch , and 't was counted as insolent for any one accus'd to pretend to make a defence as to protest against Arianism . Ammian . in 21 tells us , Si affectatae dominationis ansam quandam falsam reperiisset , aut leve● , hanc sine fine scrutando fasque eodem modo ducens ac nefas , Caligulae , Domitiani , & Commodi immanitatem facile superavit . So that if a Roman Emperour can act contrary to the Law ( as Mr. Iohnson affirms ) , certainly Constantius did : For what can be more evident , than that no man should be condemn'd without being first heard , or his Accuser appearing , was an Establisht Law of the Empire ? But yet that he acted quite contrary to this , we may plainly see in Athanasius : For how many were drag'd to death , without daring to offer at a defence ? Which would have been so far from excusing them , that it would onely have rendred them more guilty in the eye of the Judge ; who being always resolv'd to condemn , must needs res●nt any thing ill , that look't as if it design'd to prevent him . And if putting People to death upon pretence and shamms was the particular mark ( as Mr. Iohnson delivers ) of an Arbitrary lawless Tyrant , certainly Constantius put in as fair for the Title as any one ; For what could be more so , than the Actions of his Deputies in AEgypt by his Commission ? Where innocent children , and ●oolish old women were executed ; these for prescribing , those for wearing an insignificant charm against an Ague , under the pretence that they dealt in Sorcery . The first time certainly that people ever died for being fools , or that old women suffer'd for superstition , which in them is as necessary an effect of Age as grey hairs ; and they might as justly have been executed for being ugly , or having wrinckles . Neither were the Emperour's actions at home less unaccountable ; for when his Sycophants had once persuaded him , that the safety of the World did so much depend upon his , that it must cease to be with him , ( wh●ch he vain man believed ! ) he suspected all that came nigh him to have designs upon him ; a whisper or a wry look was death ; discontent at any thing was mis-interpreted disaffection to the government ; and a man must not be angry , for fear it should be thought he was displeas'd at the Emperour . These , and many o●her things of this inhumane strain , are recounted at large in the Histories of that age . Where , if any one will please to look , he will find that I have just occasion to say a great deal more than I have . If these provocations could not urge the Primitive Christians to have so much as ill thoughts of their Emperour , what can doe it ? The benefi●s of Constantine the Great , the first Patron of their Religion , and Establisher of their happiness , were still fresh in their memories , which must needs make their wounds deeper now ; for having once sound the joys of a peacefull settl'd Church , where ( as they do in heaven now ) they enjoy'd the purest Religion , and the most perfect peace ; certainly it must needs be matter of the highest discontent , to have all these comforts s●atch't from them , and by the Son of the Great Constantine that gave them : Here are the most aggravating circumstances imaginable ; but their patience was not to be conquer'd , they still made good that saying of Athanasius , That Persecution was the lot of Christianity , Atha . p. 836. But this will be more evident when we come , in the third Chapter , to shew the behaviour of the Christians toward Him. CHAP. II. The Sense of the Primitive Christians about his Succession . COnstantius came to the Crown with the profession of that Religion his Father was so eminent a defender of ; so that the Christians under Constantine ( without the gift of Prophecy ) could not well expect his Apostacy . But I am induced to believe , that if they had , there would have been no Petitions to the Emperour to exclude his Son , to secure their Religion ; but rather assurances from them , that this was not a just way to preserve it ; there would have been no Bill from the Senate with a Contradiction in the belly of it , to tell the Emperour they would by no means attempt the violation of his Prerogative , or the alteration of the fundamental Laws of the Empire ; and yet in the very next clause , offer at the Exclusion of his lawfull Heir ; the nature of the thing will not allow me to make any proof from History that it was so , but I don't question to make it more than probable it would have been so , if there had been occasion . For since the Right of the next Heir to the Crown is so strongly secur'd by the Laws of God and Nature , ( as I hope has been sufficiently prov'd in the Preface ) and that it is plain Constantius had this right , being descended from Constantine ; I can't imagine that the fears of the Christians ( though they had the assurance of Constantius being an Arian ) could authorize them to attempt his Exclusion ; for besides that it is contradictory to the Principles of their Religion , to prevent a future inconvenience , by a present ill , ( as is shown before ) if we may conclude what they would have done then , from what their forefathers did before , or they themselves afterwards , we shall find that they thought no reason great enough to put by the lawfull Heir . For when a Heathen was to succeed , there was not the least attempt to bar him ; not onely because they doubted their strength , and therefore thought their endeavours would be in vain , but because they thought the contrary their duty ; for they did not onely not make it their business to prevent his coming to the Empire , but as much as in them lay assisted it ; for as 't is above cited from Athenagoras , they declar'd they thought it most just that Commodus , as rightfull Heir , should succeed his Father M. Aurelius ; nay 't was their constant prayer to Almighty God that he might : which certainly had been the greatest madness in the world ( he being a Heathen , and consequently their mortal enemy ) if they had not thought it so necessary a duty incumbent upon them , that no consideration of their future quiet , or the unmolested enjoyment of their Religion , could exempt them from . So that if the Actions of these Christians have any Authority with us , if we have not disclaim'd their very principles as well as piety , we shall not think it so strange , as Mr. Iohnson would have the world believe we do , for Christians not to oppose the Succession of their lawfull Prince , though part of his Religion be to extirpate theirs . If it were our own case , we might lawfully pray for his conversion , and I don't question but we should doe it very heartily , for the free exercise of our Religion is the greatest happiness we can wish for on this side heaven ; but if we could have it but for an evil thought , 't were much too dear , and not to be purchased at that rate : And therefore I have often look't with horrour upon that unchristian prayer of the Protestants under Queen Mary , which was certainly ( whatever Mr. Iohnson declares to the contrary ) never heard or read , to have been us'd by any good Christian man against any Prince , though he were a Pagan or Infidel , &c. [ Pream . to the Act ] ( as shall be seen at large when I come to treat of the Christians prayers ) and it was deservedly made Treason then , for it was so long before in the eye of heaven ; for if an evil thought or wish against our neighbour , is made as much murther , by the Gospel , as actually striking him to the heart , why such a notorious profession of our hatred to our Princess , and desire of her destruction ( upon what consideration soever ) should not incurr a proportionable guilt , I cannot easily imagine . But to come nigher to the case in hand , 't will be evident to any , never so little conversant in the Ecclesiastical Writers , that most of those very people , that Mr. Iohnson represents to the world for such fierce Excluders of a Prince , that profest a contrary Religion to theirs , did not think ( or at least did not act as if they thought ) that a Prince could be barr'd of his Right of Succession , upon the score of Religion ; for not two years after Iulian's death , Valens a furious Arian , and bitter persecutour of those that dissented from him , was peacefully admitted to be Emperour , and assisted too by the Army ; whom we can't think in the least inclin'd to favour that Heresie ( for they were Iovinian's Souldiers ) but they knew their duty to their Prince . I hope these plain instances will satisfie any reasonable man , that the Primitive Christians did not think it consistent with the Principles of their Religion , to exclude a lawfull Successour upon any terms , since we see that neither being a Heathen or an Arian ( two the most dangerous enemies to Christianity ) could prevail with them to attempt it . 'T would be easie here to answer all the pretended Arguments and Authorities Mr. Iohnson brings , to prove the contrary actions of the Primitive Christians toward Iulian : but I suppose the Reader remembers what has been already said of them particularly in the Preface ; so that I shall not need to trouble him , or my self , with a repetition . But I shall hasten to give an Account of their Behaviour toward Constantius , and leave the world to judge whether it be not more agreeable to the Gospel , than that which Mr. Iohnson falsely scandalizes the Christians , under Iulian , with ; and consequently fittest for our imitation . CHAP. III. Their Behaviour towards Him in Words . 'T IS a strange account Mr. Iohnson gives us of the Christians behaviour towards their Emperour , though a Persecutour , and an Apostate ; for railing is certainly so far from being Evangelical , that it is contrary to the Principles of common breeding . But perhaps these were some of those unhappy people the Emperour had interdicted the benefit of going to School to , and now he deservedly found the effect of his cruelty . But then he ought to have told us so , and not to have laid it down in such general terms , as if it were the approv'd practice of the whole Church : This is the strangest injustice to that famous age imaginable , and onely exposing those examples , one would think , by the end of his book , he designs we should imitate ; for from the scope of his Book , I can conclude nothing but this , viz. That he intends to give us an account how the Christians in former ages behav'd themselves toward an Apostate , to inform us what we may doe on the like occasion . I must confess he has done most of his own party a considerable kindness ; for they hitherto have rail'd without president , as well as without cause : And I suppose Greek e'er long will be much in fashion with them , as a Language that will extremely accomplish them for that Christian liberty . But as for us , we shall rather fetch the methods of our Conduct from the graver Writings of the Fathers of those times ; and not imitate him , who , like our late travelling Sparks , onely observes , and treasures up the vices and follies of the places he visits , and exposes them , when he comes home , for rarities and accomplishments . None certainly but the scum and rabble of that age could be guilty of those indignities to their Emperour : but Mr. Iohnson tells us , no less a man than Theodoret commends them for their Nick-names and Reproaches , and quotes his 3 d Book and c. 22. for what he says ; I have look't with both eyes , and cannot find any thing like it : He commends indeed the Antiochians for their Zeal , but not their rudeness . As to the Example of Maris , which he brings as the second and last argument to justifie ill language given to an Emperour , if an Apostate , is of very little force ; for without all doubt , it was an indiscreet Action , and nothing but his great Zeal for Religion could make any colourable excuse for it ; For who , unless he had a mind to be a Martyr , would affront an Emperour in the height of his devotion , and upbraid his gods when he was paying his adorations to them ? Origen I am sure would have counted such an Action down-right madness ; for he tells us , when we doe nothing contrary to the law and word of God , we are not so mad or furious as to stir up , against our selves , the wrath of the King or of the Magistrate , which would bring upon us blows , torments , and divers kinds of death . And I have some reason to assert this , from the quite different Conduct of all the Fathers that liv'd under Constantius ; that were so far from doing any thing of this nature , unprovok't , that all the Cruelties that Apostate Emperour could inflict , did not extort the least mis-becoming expression from them . Athanasius tells the Emperour in his Apology ; I am not mad , O King , neither have I forgot the voice of God that saith , Curse not the King , no not in thy heart . And again , I did not oppose the Command of your Majesty , God forbid . I am not such a man as would oppose the very Treasurer of the City , much less so great an Emperour ; I was not so mad as to contradict such a Command as yours ; I neither did oppose the Command of your Majesty , nor will now attempt to enter into Alexandria , untill you , of your Goodness , will please , I shall . And in another place of the same Apology he tells Constantius , If I had been accus'd before others , I had appeal'd unto your Majesty , as the Apostle appeal'd unto Caesar — But seeing they have taken the boldness to calumniate me before Thee , to whom shall I appeal from Thee , but to the Father of him who said , I am truth , that he may incline thy heart to mercy ? St. Hilary tells him ( and in the time of Persecution too ) your mild nature ( blessed Lord ) agreeth with your gracious disposition ; and because of your great mercy , we don't doubt of easily obtaining what we desire of you ; we beg of you not onely with words , but tears , that the Catholick Church be no longer persecuted by our brethren . Hilar. ad Const. l. 2. And 20 Bishops of the West , in the conclusion of a Letter from a Synod at Ariminum , We beseech you , that you cause us not to stay from our Charges ; but that the Bishops , together with their own People , may with peace employ themselves in prayers and the service of God , making supplication for your Kingdoms safety and peace , in which the divine Majesty long preserve you . Atha . Epist. de Syn. Ari. &c. Hosius likewise ( a man of an extraordinary Zeal and Courage ) though provok't by the severest Persecutions imaginable , can't think it lawfull for him to speak so much as dis-respectfully of the Emperour : but tells him , Since he had receiv'd his Imperial Power from God , whosoever did detract any thing from that , should be look't upon as an opposer of the Ordinance of God. It would be easie to seem very learned upon this point , that is , to stuff my Margin with quotations ; but that 's a vanity I am not over-desirous to be thought guilty of . I hope the authorities I have already cited , will be sufficient to prove what I design'd , viz. That it was the judgment of the Primitive Christians , that no ill usage from their Emperour , though a Heathen or Apostate , could authorize them to affront him ; and that difference of Religion , doth not , by any means , cancell our Obedience to him . Now that the face of things should be so soon chang'd , as that it should be damnation to speak ill of the Emperour under Constantius ; and under Iulian , his immediate Successour , not onely permitted , but meritorious , to curse him ( as Mr. Iohnson acquaints us ) is very strange . I am confident if they did those Actions he lays to their charge , they had no president for them in former ages ; and the doctrine they govern'd themselves by , was perfectly new and their own : For 't is well known all the first Christians acted quite contrary ; they continually night and day pray'd for the safety of the Emperour , [ Cypr. ad Demet . ] It would be easie out of the Martyrologies of the first times , to give instances of the Christians submission , as strange , as the cruelty of their Persecutours : But this will be unnecessary , since their sufferings and patience are so well known , that Mr. Iohnson himself is forc't to own it ; but tells us withall , 't was their duty to suffer patiently , because they were persecuted according to law . This answer is of very little force , for there was no other law but the will of their Emperours against them , or their Edicts , which were onely their will manifested ; both which were as much Laws in Iulian's time , as N●ro's : Therefore why the Christians should think it their duty patiently to submit to all the inhumane cruelties of that first Persecutour , and those under Iulian rebell , or at least murmur at those lighter pressures of their Emperour , I am not able to resolve . I am inclin'd to think , that Mr. Iohnson's Christians were not so good as they should be ; for those that will onely submit quietly to Persecution upon some conditions ( for he tells u● , though they resisted Iulian , they would patiently have bore the cruelty of a Heathen persecutour ) are govern'd rather by humour than Religion ; for the Gospel I am sure makes no distinction , and 't is a receiv'd maxim , Ubi lex non distinguit nemo distinguere debet ; Where the Law makes no distinction , no man ought to doe it . But besides , it has been sufficiently prov'd , that Constantius's proceedings were altogether as illegal and arbitrary , as those of Iulian could possibly be ; they were both Apostates , and though indeed the latter was less to be excus'd ( it being something a worse defection to Paganism than Arianism ) yet in respect of the quiet and security of the Church , they were both equally dangerous . And yet we see from the Examples of so many Bishops , the prayers of all the people , that they were so far from cursing him or giving him to the Devil for his due , that they seem to be fond of his life , and make the establishment and welfare of the Empire , to be the first business of their prayers . For hence it is that we give respect to a Heathen , if put in Authority ; for though he be most unworthy of it himself , who holding God's place , gives the Devil thanks for it ; but the honour we give him , his place challengeth . [ Q. 35. exerc . Nov. Test. Tom 4. op . Av. ] CHAP. IV. ●h●ir Actions . BEfore I give an Account of the Christi●● 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 their Actions toward 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ●●ll be necessary to make 〈◊〉 R●m●●ks upon those two Actions of a Souldier and a ●ishop under Iulian , which Mr. Iohnson saith m●y manifest how the Primitive Christians despis'd him ( besides that it i● very foul pl●y to infer the general sense of the Church from that of but two members of it ) I cannot grant that the Primitive Christians would by any means allow of these Actions . As to the first , that of Valentinian , I must needs own 't was far more excusable than what old Gregory did , for his Character , and the meanness of the person that suffer'd by him , may plead something in his behalf , striking in a Souldier being more pardonable than in a Bishop , and bea●ing a Priest , more tolerable , than kicking an Emperour ; but this will not justifie the violence , for it was undoubtedly a fault , though the praises the Historian gives it , would seem to prove the contrary . For to this I answer , That the Action deserv'd to be prais'd , not for its own sake , but because it shew'd an extraordinary Zeal for Christianity ; it was the Motive , and not the Fact , that was to be commended ; and that this is not purely a 〈◊〉 , but the real truth of the matter , we may i●fe● from this plain instance . In the Primitive Church many kill'd themselves , when they could by no other means avoid sacrificing to Idols ; and they stand now upon Record for Martyrs . This Action of theirs was certainly self-mur●her , and consequently criminal ; and Dr. Hammond aff●rms , that it was a fault in them too ; but the love of God , and the fear they should be polluted by Idols , was the cause of it . And so though it might as a frailty be pardon'd by God's mercy in Christ , yet sure this killing themselves was not that which made them Martyrs ; but that great love of God , and resolving against Idolatrous worship , which testified it self in their killing themselves for that Cause : This it was that made them pass for Martyrs , and that other incident fault of theirs , was not , in that case , thought so great , as to divest them or rob them of that Honour , [ Dr. Ham. Pr. C● . ] and 〈◊〉 highly probable that this was Valentinian's Case ; 't was not his striking the Priest , but his Confession , that gave him a title to two Kingdoms , that of the Empire and Heaven . But I need not have said so much of this , for Mr. Iohnson himself allows it to be an unaccountable Action , p. 44. As to the extravagant Action of old Gregory Nazianzen ( for I can't justly give it a milder Epithet ) certainly nothing but the partiality of a Son can excuse it , and 't is a fault even in him to commend it ; for who can stretch forth his hand against the Lord's anointed ( sure the Foot is not excepted ) and be guiltless ( 1 Sam. 26. 9. ) St. Chrysostom's forbidding the Empress Eudoxia to come within the Church , was not half so insolent as this Act of Gregory's , yet he severely repented of it , and tells us , in the cooler hours of his life , he did more than he could justifie . If I were to specifie the particular Actions of the Primitive Christians under Constantius , in opposition to those under Iulian , I should be as prolix and tedious as Mr. Iohnson is in his comparison of Popery and Paganism ; I shall add in general terms , ( and I defie any one to disprove me out of the Writings of the Fathers , the Histories , and the Martyrologies of that age ) that the Souldiers , ( though of a contrary opinion ) fought for him . The Fathers ( though banish'd ) pray'd for him , as likewise did the Martyrs under persecution , till the Ex●cutioner put an end at once , both to their devotion , and their lives . CHAP. V. Of their Devotion , their Psalms and Prayers . I Don't think there is so much difference between Prayers and Psalms , as to treat of them severally in two distinct Chapters . But shall speak of them here together ( I hope ) without any great absurdity . I must confess there seems some weight in the instance Mr. Iohnson urges of the young Martyr Theodorus , who curs'd the Emperour out of the Psalms ; and when he suffer'd for it , by an extraordinary assistance from Heaven , not onely surviv'd , but enjoy'd the torture : But ( like all the rest he writes ) 't is onely gloss , and onely fit to be swallow'd by those whose use he designs his book for , the prejudic'd and ignorant : These believe , because they don't understand ; Those , because it makes for them . For this Holy Martyr repeated this with the same spirit that David first deliver'd it , by way of denouncing God's judgments , not delivering his own sentiments : And Mr. Iohnson may as well say the Priest curses the People in the solemn Service on Ash●ednesday , as Theodorus did the Emperour then ; for the Idolaters come in for their share there too . Mr. Iohnson says but little of their prayers , an● that little too he draws from Gregory's 〈◊〉 where he ●lls the People what a Champion his Father had been against Iu●● , how he had stricken him with the joint prayers of the people , &c. If he did , 't was 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 all that the Christians ●ver did before him . And then what may we judge of th●● p●●yers , but that they were as extraordinary and unjustifiable as his threat●●ing to kick the Emperour ? the supplicati●●● 〈◊〉 Predecessours were not of this 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 will tell us [ That the Scriptures enjoin us for shewing the redundancy of our Charity , to pray to God even for our enemies , and wish well unto our persecutours . ] Tertul. Apol. cap. 31 , and 32. And in another place , [ We pray for the Emperour's safety , we call upon the eternal God , the true God , the living God , whom the Emperours themselves would wish above all others should be propitious to them . Ibid. 30. ] And what is more , he tells them in the same place , [ Having our arms thus spread out unto our God , let the Hooks tear us , the Crosses hang us , the Fires lick us up , &c. the posture of a Christian praying is fitted for all kind of torments : Come ye good Governours , wrest out the soul that is supplicating for the Emperour : ] Can any thing be greater ? This is the patience of a Primitive Martyr . By this we see not onely calmly to dye for the Truth , but even to dye praying for the Persecutour , was one of the great requisits to obtain so glorious a title . But perhaps Mr. Iohnson will tell us this is but one Doctor 's opinion ; but if he will take the pains onely to look in the Indexes of the Fathers , he will be directed to many places , in each of them , to this purpose . Cyprian speaking to the Emperour , says , [ Day and night continually and instantly do we pray , propitiating and appeasing God , for your peace and safety . ] Cypr. ad Demet . Sebastian tells the Emperour Dioclesian , [ The Priests of the Temples do possess your Majesty with an unjust suspicion of us , suggesting false tales , as if we were enemies to the Commonwealth ; whereas by our prayers the Commonwealth is better'd and increas'd ; for we cease not to pray for your Empire and the Roman Army . ] But to come ●igher home , Athanasius ( a man not over tame but when it was his duty ) gives this reason for celebrating prayer in the Church of Alexandria , before it was dedicated , that the people earnestly prest him , that they might all pray for the safety of the Emperour in the Church , which he himself had builded ; being ready otherwise to go out of the City , and assemble themselves in the desarts , at the solemnity of Easter , which at that time was to be celebrated . And again , speaking to the Emperour , [ You do not forbid , but are willing that all men should pray , knowing that this is the prayer of all , that you may live in safety , and continually reign in peace● — And again ( O Emperour of God most belov'd ) many circuits of years , I pray , may you live , and accomplish the dedication of this Church ; for those prayers that are made within for your welfare , don't at all hinder the dedication of the Church . ] This will be enough to satisfie any reasonable man , that Cursing an Emperour is not so Catholick a Doctrine as Mr. Iohnson would have us to believe , and that all the Fathers were not of old Gregory's mind . I am inclin'd to believe , that if he could have found but one instance more of such a fiery Zeal , it had certainly appear'd , and been improv'd to the best advantage : For we find by his transcribing so great a part of the Book of Homilies , he is of a good Communicative nature , and keeps nothing to himself that may prove in the least beneficial to the publick . But I believe it will be a hard thing to find the least pretence for this Doctrine , in all the Orthodox Writings in former ages ; and any of the Fathers would look upon the broacher of such principles with as much detestation , and call him as many names as Gregory did Iulian the Apostate . Before I conclude this Chapter , it will not be impertinent to shew , that prayers and tears were not so much out of fashion in the Primitive Church , as to be rediculous in ours ; as for their prayers , that they were not aim'd against the Emperour , I hope has been sufficiently shew'd already , but onely intend●d for his safety . And though it may seem unmanly , yet that it was not unchristian to weep , St. Ambrose will inform us ; who speaking to his Flock at Milane , tells them , [ Willingly I will never forsake you ; being constrain'd , I know not how to make opposition ; I can sorrow , I can weep , I can sigh , against Armour , Souldiers and Goths : Tears are my weapons , for such is the Armour of a Priest , otherways I cannot , dare not , resist . ] Amb. in Ora. de Bas. non Trad. And this same Father ( who had likewise to deal with an Arian Emperour , Valentinian the younger ) did not defend himself with his hand or his weapon , but by fastings , and continual watchings , and continuing under the Altars , by his prayers he procur'd God to be a defender both of him and his Church . Ruf. Ec. H. l. 2. c. 26. And that Prayers and Tears do very well together , St. Bernard tells us , writing to ●udovicus then King of France . [ Indeed we will stand and sight even unto death , if need so requires , in our Mothers behalf , with such weapons as we may lawfully use ; not with Bucklers and Swords , but with Prayers and Tears to God. ] I suppose if he had meant against the Emperour , he would hardly have wrote him word so . Ber. in Ep. 221. ad Ludo. Re. CHAP. VI. Constantius's Death . COnstantius , after having reign'd 38 years , ( a great while for a Roman Emperour and Persecutour , and yet not too long , for Athanasius wisheth him many Circuits of years ) making War in Persia , heard the unwelcome News of Iulian's being proclaim'd Emperour by the Army : 'T is not to be imagined but he resented this treacherous Action with the highest indignation ; but we do not hear that he attempted to exclude him for it ; he knew he had declar'd Iulian's right to the Succession , by making him Caesar ; and that consequently it was not in his power to take away that right which was deriv'd from the Law of Nature , and confirm'd by his Edict , and which could onely cease with Iulian's Life . That these were his thoughts , we shall best judge by his proceedings in this affair ; for he did not put out his Edicts to take away the title of Caesar from Iulian ( which was equivalent to that of H●ir-Apparent with us ) thereby shewing his design to dis-inherit him ; but leaving the prosecution of that War he had begun in Persia , he carried his Army against Iulian , to be reveng'd of that ungratefull Usurper , and to secure himself in the Empire ; for he might kill Iulian as a Rebell , and so his right would fall of course ; but he could not dis-inherit him as such , because God , though he gave the power of life and death to the Magistrate , hath yet reserv'd the disposing of Kingdoms to himself . But to proceed in the Narrative : Constantius , whether from inward grief , or the toil of a long journey , or both ( is not material ) fell ill at Mopsuecrene , a place between Cappado●ia and Cilicia , where in a very short time he died of a very high Fever ; for Marcellinus saith , that he burnt all over like fire , so that his servants could not so much as touch his body . Socrates indeed gives us a far different account of his distemper , attributing his Death to an Apoplexy . I shall leave the reconciliation of these two Historians to those that think themselves concern'd in it ; for it is not material here of what death he died : but it is certain the News of it was miraculously convey'd to Iulian ; for after he had consulted his Gods and Priests about the event of things , and they had assur'd him of success above his hopes , yet he was dissatisfied still ; he look't upon what they said to be rather slattery than prophecy , and thought their predictions rather squar'd to his desires , than truth ; but he was quickly satisfied by an extraordinary revelation ; for at the very same time the Emperour died in Cilicia , a Souldier that lif●ed Iulian upon his horse ; he being seated , suddenly himself fell down upon the ground , and cried out in the hearing of all the company , That he who had rais'd him up so high , was fallen himself . Marcel . lib. 21. Having given this account of his Death , I hope it will not be preposterous to speak a word or two of his Repentance . Socrates is silent in this matter , and the great Athanasius positively affirms , that he continued in his damnable Heresie till the last . [ 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ] p. 907. And that dying , he desir'd to be baptiz'd , but not by a holy man , but by one Euzoius ( this is also confirm'd by Socrates ) that had been depos'd for Arianism . Ibid. If any one enquires into the credit of this great Father , I shall refer him to Gregory Nazianzen's own Speech in commendation of him , which he thus begins , [ In praising Athanasius , I praise Vertue it self , &c. ] Greg. Nazian . in Land. Athan. And to Constantius's Character of him ( who certainly might be believ'd when he commended one he hated ) in a Letter he sent to the people of Alexandria , wherein he highly commends his integrity , &c. Athan. Works . Epist. 2. ad Pop. Alex. Now which is to be believed , Athanasius or Gregory , in the account of Constantius's dying a Convert or an Apostate , I leave the Impartial Reader to judge . But the authority he useth to induce us to believe a Christian did that treacherous act , is much to be suspected ; for Amm. Marcell . lib. 24. is silent as to that , who was concern'd in the expedition , and an eye-witness of what past ; as likewise Eutropius . But Aurelius Victor affirms the quite contrary , viz. that he was kill'd by a Horse-man of the enemies , and one that was ●lying too . But Theodoret tells us positively , cap. 25. lib. 3. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ; Who it was that struck this just stroke , no man knows to this day . And that it was not probable that a Christian would be guilty of this fact , will manifestly enough appear , from the passionate resentments they shew'd at his death . See Marcell . l. 24. CHAP. VII . How they us'd his Memory . THE Primitive Christians were so far from offering any injury to the Memory of Constantius , that as if they had onely remembred he was their Emperour ; and now by his being dead , own'd a new obligation superadded to that , to speak well of Him ; they deplore his loss with all the demonstrations of a real sorrow : the eyes that were wet when he persecuted them , wept afresh at his funeral , as if they had perfectly learn't that great lesson of their Saviour , not onely to bear with , but even to love their enemies . The Souldiers you would think , by the extravagance of their grief , had forgot their Character ; and Constantine himself died not more lamented than his Son. Iulian , who had no great reason to be fond of his life , if he consulted his own safety , assisted at his Obsequies , and made a very considerable figure in that sorrowfull procession ; and if we reade Gregory Nizianzen's description of his funeral , we must needs stand amaz'd at the greatness of their Charity ; He tells us , that he was carried forth with all the solemnity the Christians us'd to honour the Corps of a Pious Hero with ; and would fain persuade the people to believe that the very Angels themselves , in reward of his unusual piety , contributed their assistance to inhance the Glories of his Funeral ; but whether this is one of that Father's flights , or really true , I shan't contend : this is certain from all the Histories of that age , that he died generally lamented ; and that those that suffer'd by his Edicts , did not presume to blaspheme the Memory of him that made them . This was the Conduct of the Primitive Christian ; and if they ever acted contrary , it was not to be imputed to their Religion , but their Passions . I shall easily grant that there are some severe reflexions upon Iulian to be met withall in Authours of very good note ; but I hope Mr. Iohnson will not infer from that , that they are warrantable . If he reades those very Fathers thorough , he will find that their Theory runs sometimes contrary to their Practice , and that they don't always act according to their own principles ; and I don't know why he should draw those passages into presidents for us , which the Authours themselves in their cooler minutes were asham'd to own . CHAP. VIII . Reflexions on the Behaviour of these Christians , wherein , of Passive Obedience . THat the Persecution under Constantius was much severer than any of the ten former , is evident to any one that considers the Cruel●ies that were daily acted by the Arian Hereticks ; who as they were much more zealous for their Opinions than the Heathens , so consequently they were more eager in prosecuting those that dissented from them : The loss of a Trade or Profession was not the punishment of their Non-conformity , but of Life too ; nay , there were penalties inflicted where death was the least part of the punishment : But all these heavy grievances did not make them question God's Providence , or remonstrate to the Decrees of the Emperour ; they did not make their pressures just , by impatiently submitting to them ; nor frustrate the reward of their sufferings , by reviling their Persecutours ; thereby by rendring their Persecution onely an unprofitable affliction : they look't upon their miseries as necessary tryals of their faith , knowing that the power of even wicked and hurtfull Kings is from God. What therefore can justifie the Primitive Christians carriage toward Iulian , if it were according to the account Mr. Iohnson gives of it , p. 66 ? That they vext every vein in his Royal heart ; said all their prayers backward ; and call'd down for vengeance upon his head , &c. And at last concludes , They seem to have broke all the measures by which all the ancient and suffering Christians have gone by in their Per●ecutions , p. 68. The reasons he brings to justifie their Actions , are these : 1. That their case was different from that of the first Christians , because Christianity was now the Establisht Religion of the Empire , and they were justly incensed at Iulian in offering to disturb them in the exercise of it . 2. Since Constantius had repeal'd all the sanguinary Edicts against them , they were persecuted contrary to Law. To the first of these I answer ; That if he takes Christianity for the true Religion Constantine profess'd and maintain'd , his assertion is utterly false ; for the Emperour's Religion , which is likewise the Religion of the Empire , as far as Edicts can make it , ( and Constantine had no other way to establish any thing ) was Arianism ; for Constantius had long maintain'd that damnable Heresie , and had supply'd all the places of the Orthodox Bishops , who were banish'd for their Confession with the most violent professours of it . So that when Iulian came to the Empire , the Church was far from enjoying that peace and tranquillity Mr. Iohnson describes , p. 68. for it was miserably rent with divisions , and hardly visible but in a few persecuted , distressed members : For granting that Constantius did at last repent , it was so late first , he had no time to settle the true Religion , but left the Empire infected with the Heresie he first introduced : which was no more Christianity then , than Mahumetism is now ; for though they acknowledged a Saviour , 't was one of their own making , and the Notions they entertain'd of Christ may perhaps onely entitle them to greater damnation , than the Heathens that never heard his name : So that the quiet enjoyment of their Religion could not make them so ●ierce against Iulian , for designing to molest them , for he could not put them into a greater confusion than they were in already : Nay , they rather found the contrary ; for whoever will take the pains to compare Iulian's Usage of the Christians with that of Constantius , he will find that the Heathen was less a Persecutour than the Arian ; and that the Church had more quiet minutes in the short Reign of Iulian , than in 30 years before ; for he ( upon what private designs matters not ) call'd home the Banish'd Bishops , and r●stor'd them to their places in the Church : And though he ridicul'd Christianity , he did not often persecute the professours of it ; he endeavour'd indeed to gain Pro●●lytes , but yet , like Arians , he did not compell people to his Altars : Nay if we will take Mr. Iohnson's word , he was rather a Tempter than a Persecutour . I hope this is enough to shew , that there is not a word true of all that gay description Mr. Iohnson gives u● , p. 68 , 69 , &c. of the flourishing condition of the Church ; and consequently the just sense of the happiness they enjoy'd , and a fear to be rob'd of it , could not animate the Christians to that degree that he tells us it did . 2. As to the second , That Constantine repeal'd all the sanguinary Edicts against the Christians , and therefore if they were persecuted , 't was contrary to Law ; it is a very ●hallow inference : For though that first Christian Emperour repeal'd all the sanguinary Edicts , yet his Successour was not in the l●ast ti●d up : One single word of his would put them all in force again . Nay if we believe Iustinian ( who certainly was a good judge in the case ) the Emperour could not act contrary to Law ; for what he did , was according to his pleasure , and his pleasure was a Law , Quod Principi placuit legis habet vigorem , [ Just. Inst. l. 1. c. 2. ] and the Edicts were altogether as Arbitrary , for they were onely the Emperour's will more publickly made known ; for Theop. defines them , Edicta sunt , cum Princeps motu proprio , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 aliquid constituit ad honestatem & utilitatem reipublicae ; for whatever the Emperour enacted , how ill soever , was suppos'd to be so ; for as his sentence was always presum'd to be just [ Principis sententia praesumitur semper justa unde ab ea non appellatur ; ] so likewise were all his actions : So that whether Iulian put the Christians to death upon sanguinary Edicts , or rather accus'd them of other Crimes ( that he might avoid the invidious name of a Persecutour ) and so destroy'd them , is not material , for ' ●is certain he commanded them to be executed ; and if he did , they dy'd lawfully , for his Command was a Law ; and that the Emperour's Command had this authority , is evident from the Protestation of the people of Alexandria , Athan. p. 858. [ If it be the Emperour's Command we should be persecuted , we are all ready to suffer Martyrdom ; but if there be no such thing , we beseech Maximus , the Governour of Egypt , and all the Magistrates , that they would entreat his Majesty that no such thing may be attempted against us . ] So that what Mr. Iohnson means , p. 72. by saying the first Christians suffer'd according to the Laws of their Country , whereas those under Iulian were persecuted contrary to Law , is hard to determine ; for every one knows the will of their Emperours was the Law of their Country , for they were as Arbitrary then as he that now Usurps their Throne ; and I hope no body will say the great Turk persecutes his Subjects contrary to Law , when he kills 5 or 6000 of them for diversion : That he acts unjustly , I grant , but the Laws ( that is , his will and pleasure ) are on his side . But to put an end to this matter , 't will be evident to any that have read the former part of this Book , that all the sanguinary Acts against Christians were not repeal'd ; for those made by Constantius , which were severe enough ( if we believe Athanasius , p. 821. ) stood still in force till Iulian his immedia●e Successour came to the Crown . But Mr. Iohnson need not have given himself all this trouble to justifie the Actions of the Primitive Christians , for they were never guilty of any that wanted an excuse ; for the Church under Iulian never own'd those principles or practices that tended to the dishonour of their Emperour , as has been shew'd at large in the 2 , 3 , 4 Chapters , &c. of this book . I shall con●ine my self no longer to the Actions of a particular people or Nation , but consider what is our duty as Christians in relation to our Governours ; and what submission is due to them when they persecute us according to Law , or destroy us by an uncontrollable Arbitrary power . As to the first of these , the case is plain , and agreed upon on all hands , that submission is necessarily requir'd to a Persecutour , that acts according to the Laws of his Country : this Mr. Iohnson allows , p. 92. in these words : [ When the Laws of God and our Country interfere , and 't is made death by the Law of the Land to be a good Christian , then we are to lay down our lives for Christ's sake . ] So that all the dispute is about our Submission to a Persecutour , that acts without the authority of the Law , and contrary to it . Mr. Iohnson denies that Submission is due to him by the Gospel , [ ibid. ] but I shall make the contrary appear from the plain authority of the Holy Scriptures , the sense of the Primitive Christians , as likewise from that too of our present Church . For , first , if we are not oblig'd to submit to a Tyrant that acts contrary to the Law , we may resist him , for there is no Medium , flying being part of our Passive Obedience that is acknowledg'd due to a Persecutour that acts according to Law : but resisting is not in any case allowable ; for besides our Saviour's own words , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , 't is forbidden , Rom. 12. 17. to return any man evil for evil . And again v. 19. Dearly beloved , avenge not your selves , but rather give place unto wrath : for it is written , Vengeance is mine , I will repay it , saith the Lord. Now if no man may pay evil to his brother that has injur'd him , but by the hand of the Supreme Power , how can it be allowable to render evil for evil to the Supreme Power it self ? It cannot be done but by a Superiour , and He onely is God. We have redress indeed against the violence of our fellow subject , by applying our selves to the Magistrate , who may punish the offender , being authorized by God so to doe [ Rom. 3. 4. ] But we don't find the People have the like Power over the Magistrate : Obedience is our business , which is inconsistent with the liberty of resisting . Grotius tells us plainly , Si , quia summum imperium habenti libet , injuria nobis inferatur , toleranda potius est quam vi resistendum ; For though by the Law of Nature we have the power of Repelling injuries , yet we have a greater obligation from the Civil Government under which we live , that wholly devests us of this right . Potest igitur Civitas jus illud resistendi promiscuum publicae pacis & ordinis causâ prohibere , cap. 4. l. 2. de Iu. Bel. & Pa. So that this patient submitting to the Arbitrary determinations of the Magistrate is not onely from the doctrine of our Saviour , but from the principl●s of Civil prudence : For the Lawyers will tell us , that a mischief is better than an inconvenience ; not that the first formally consider'd is to be preferr'd to the latter , but that an inconvenience , whose consequence would reach unto the general , should be prevented rather than a mischief , that would onely endamage particular . Hence it is that opposing the Magistrate is forbid upon any terms whatsoever , since the indulgence of it would bring a train of ill consequences , ten times worse than all the mischiefs we can possibly suffer from the cruelty of a lawless Tyrant ; For as Grotius has it in his Commentary on the 13 of the Romans , Reges constituuntur ut improbitate repressa tutiùs vivant boni , hoc autem plenissimè praestant boni reges , mali quoque aliquatenus vel sui causa , & quanquam aliquando vitii aliquid interveniat , nunquam tamen non tutiùs est esse Principes , quam non esse : Rectè ergo Tacitus , vitia erunt donec homines , sed neque haec continua & meliorum interventu pensantur . It was a Maxim the former Heathens learnt from their Philosophers , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , and that this anger was not always suppos'd to be just , a Latin saying , to the same purpose , will shew us , ames parentem si aequus est , si non , feras ; and that the same , if not much greater difference is to be paid to our common Father , is out of question . In some cases I allow it is lawfull not to obey our Parent , or our King , but in all cases 't is necessary not to resist . St. Peter Commands Servants to be subject to their Masters , with all fear ; not onely the good and gentle , but also the froward ; for this is thank-worthy , if a man for conscience-sake toward God endure grief , suffering wrongfully : and Grotius will tell us , Quod dicitur subjectionem dominis deberi etiam duris , idem ad reges quoque referendum . Nay we owe a greater submission to our Governours , than a Servant doth to his Master ; for if he complains of wrongfull usage , redress is to be had from the Magistrate ; but we can onely appeal to God. But to put this matter beyond all controversie , let 's consider what St. Paul says , Rom. 13. 2. Whosoever resists the power , resists the ordinance of God ; and they that resist , shall receive to themselves damnation . Here is a general rule laid down without the least exception ; and that it belongs to us , will be evident , if we consider who gave it St. Paul , who being the Apostle of the Gentiles , what he delivers is universal . And why should we presume to be wiser than the Law , and make distinctions where we find none ? St. Paul tells us , Whoever resists the power , shall be damn'd . Mr. Iohnson tells us , we may resist one that acts contrary to Law : This distinction might be plausible , if this wicked power were not the Ordinance of God ; but since it is ( as I shall evidently make out by and by ) the resisting this Ordinance contracts a guilt , that makes us obnoxious to eternal torments . Mr. Iohnson indeed quotes Bracton to prove , that a Magistrate can have no power from God , to act contrary to the Law , Quia potestas juris solius Dei est , potestas autem injuriae Diaboli : But I wonder what Divine ●ver consulted a common Lawyer before about a Case of Conscience ; for I believe Westminster-Hall Divinity is as bad as Pulpit-law : He may likewise , if he please , make use of Scotch Politicks , and he will find his Friend● , Knox and Buchanan , of his opinion : But St. Augustine will tell him ( Praef. in Enar. 2 Ps. 29. ) [ Every evil man hath in himself the will to hurt ; but to be able to hurt , is not in his power : In that he hath the will to hurt , he is already guilty ; but that he should have the ability , is permitted by the secret dispensation of God's Providence ; toward some for Punishment ; toward some for Tryal ; toward some for obtaining a Crown : For punishment , as the Philistins were permitted to subdue the people of Israel , because they had sinned against God : For tryal , the Devil was permitted to assault Iob ; but Iob was tryed , the Devil confounded : For winning the Crown , the Persecutours were let loose against the Martyrs ; the Martyrs were slain , the Persecutours thought they had gotten the day ; these did falsly triumph in publick , the other were truly crown'd in secret : Therefore that he is permitted to deal against any , proceedeth from the secret dispensation of God's Providence ; but that he hath a will to hurt , cometh from the man himself . ] Here we see opposing even a Persecutour , is resisting the Ordinance of God ( since he hath his power from above , ) and what the consequence of that is , no Christian can be ignorant of . Now that this was not Casually spoken by that Great Father , but his setled opinion , is plain from his constant adhering to it : For in another place he says , ( l. 5. de C. D. c. 8. ) [ From whom [ God ] are all powers , howsoever all mens wills are not from him ; ] and again ( Id. de Na. Bon. &c. ) [ The power even of hurtfull Kings is from God. ] Theod. likewise on the 13 to the Romans , Quum vult eos qui peccant castigare à malis Magistratibus regi permittit . And Isidore tells us plainly , [ Hence we see both a bad and good power is ordained by God , Bonam propitio , malam irato ; for we owe good Kings to the gift of God , but evil ones to our sins ; Reges quando boni sunt , ●uneris est De● , quando vero mali sceleris est Populi . ] But some may say the Fathers are men , and consequently may err ; to obviate this Cavil , I shall add the undoubted authority of Scripture , Rom. 13. 1. There is no power but of God , and the powers that be are ordained of God : and Iob 34. 10. God maketh a wicked man to reign for the sins of the People . Since therefore 't is plain from these many instances , that the power of wicked Princes is from God , our resistance cannot be any ways warrantable : We may as well quarrel with Providence for sending Plagues among us , or murmur at the Almighty when he visits us with his Judgments , as resist a Persecutour ; for he is sent to punish us for our sins ; he is onely the instrument , the rod in God's hand , which we ought rather to kiss than burn . I hope it has been sufficiently proved from the Scriptures , and Sense of the Fathers , that the power of wicked Princes is from God , and consequently it is our duty to submit to them , though they act never so illegally . It remains now , that I should prove , that this is likewise the Doctrine of our present Church ; and here I might refer my Reader to all the Writings of our Eminent Divines since the Reformation , whose business it has been to preach up Obedience to Governours , and have unanimously declar'd against resistance upon any terms whatsoever : I might transcribe great part of Bishop Bilson , Bishop Taylour and Dr. Hammond's Tracts upon this subject , but I shall rather chuse onely to quote the Homilies , it being agreed on all sides , that in them is contain'd the true Doctrine of our Church ; and Mr. Iohnson deservedly stiles them the next best book to the Bible . I wish he could commend them upon his own knowledge ; but I am afraid he never read any more of them than serv'd for a present purpose , and cares as little for them otherwise as the Country people do : For if he had met with the Homilies against Rebellion and Disobedience , we should never have had that assertion , p. 92. That the onely Case wherein the Gospel requires Passive Obedience , is when the Laws are against a man : For in the first Homily against Disobedience and Wilfull Rebellion , there are these words , [ We shall find in very many and almost infinite places in Holy Scripture , as well of the Old Testament as the New ; as well the Evil as the Good do reign by God's Ordinance , and we are bound to obey them . ] And again — [ It cometh not of chance and fortune ( as they term it ) nor of the ambition of mortal men and women climing up of their own accord to dominion , that there be Kings , Queens and Princes , and other Governours over men , being their Subjects ; but All Kings and Queens and other Governours are especially appointed by the Ordinance of God. ] — And again , [ What shall Subjects doe then ? shall they obey the valiant , stout , wise and good Princes , and contemn , disobey and rebell against Children , or against indiscreet and evil Governours ? God forbid , &c. ] And the reason follows — [ For a Rebell is worse than the worst Prince , and Rebellion worse than the worst Government of the worst Prince that hitherto has been . ] — And in another place , [ Shall the Subjects both by their wickedness provoke God for their deserved punishment , to give them an undiscrect or evil Prince , and also rebell against them , and also against God , who for the punishment of their sins did give them such a Prince ? ] I am weary of transcribing out of a Book that ought to be almost as well known to us as our Bibles ; but I can't forbear to insert this passage , which is so pertinent to the business in hand , and makes it plain that we ought by our repentance to avert the miseries of a wicked Prince , and not by resisting his power ; the words are these , — [ Let us take away our wickedness , that provok'd God to set such an one over us , and God will either displace him , or of an evil Prince , make him a good Prince ; so that we first change our evil into good ; for Subjects to deserve through their sins , to have an evil Prince , and to rebell against him were double and treble evil , by provoking God more to plague them : Nay , let us either deserve to have a good Prince , or let us patiently suffer and obey such as we deserve . ] Having thus secur'd the Supreme Magistrate from the violence of his Subjects , it will be necessary to take some care of his under Officers ; whose power , since it is the Ordinance of God ( for Epiphanius proves , that the many Magistrates under one King are Ordain'd of God , from the 13 to the Romans ) ought no more to be resisted than the King 's . Though this may seem something harsh in an English man's ears , who will acknowledge perhaps that the King can doe no injury , and is above the censure of the Law , yet he knows his Officers are accountable for any illegal act ; and the very Command of the Prince cannot secure them from being impeach't by the People : granting this to be very true ; yet I shall still assert , that the inferiour Magistrate , though in the execution of an illegal act is not to be repell'd by force ; for though Bracton tells us , Ei qui vult viribus uti erit viriliter resistendum ; and the law in our own defence permits us to kill our enemy , yet ( as it is sufficiently declar'd before ) we sin in so doing ; and though we escape here , judgment will overtake us hereafter . Let 's hear St. Peter's opinion in the case , 1 Pet. 2. 13 , 14 , 15. Submit your selves unto every ordinance of man for the Lord's sake , whether to the King as supreme , or unto governours , as unto them that are sent by him● — For this is the will of God , &c. — From this 't is plain that we ought to submit to inferiour Officers for the Lord's sake , as well as supreme ; this subordinate power being from God , though not immediately : This is sufficiently acknowledged in our Saviour's answer to Pilate , Thou couldst have no power over me , except it were given thee from above ; and we all know he was under the Emperour . I am not ignorant that the above-cited Text from St. Peter has been perverted to serve upon a far different occasion ; the improper proper translation of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 humane Ordinance giving occasion to some ignorant or ill-minded people to infer , that all government is of humane institution ; but to any considering man 't is plain , that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 here signifies a person , and not a thing , from the division subjoyn'd , whether it be to Kings as Supreme , or Governours , &c. and therefore the best Translation runs , Submit your selves to every humane creature . Here it may be objected , that this explication is too large , because undoubtedly we are not to submit to all men : To this I answer , that sentenc●s deliver'd in general terms are not always to be taken in their full extent ; but restrictions are allowable , provided they are had from parallel places in Scripture ; for this Command of subjecting our selves to all men , implies no more but this , We must submit our selves to all men to whom submission is due : of Haymo in Rom. 13. Subditi estote omni creaturae , i.e. omnibus hominibus nobis praepositis . But that which gives colour for the allowance of this restriction , is the like expression in the same Chapter , v. 17. where we are commanded to honour all men . Certainly the meaning of this is not that the King should honour his Subjects , or the Father his Children . But as Dr. Hammond in his Paraphrase on the place , [ Give every man the Honour and Obedience that is due to him : ] and St. Paul confirms this , Rom. 13. 7. Give all men their due , Tribute to whom tribute — Honour to whom honour . But to make this point of our submission to under O●●icers , as plain a● possible , let us consider the example of our Saviour , who when he was set upon by a great multitude with swords and staves , &c. who certainly acted very illegally , for they had no just Commission for what they did , nor could have ( for our Saviour tells them , Luke ●2 . 53. This is your hour , and the power of darkness ; which Dr. Hammond explains in his Paraphrase , [ This is the time when the Devil and you are permitted to work your wills on me . ] Yet he was so far from resisting them ( though he had ten Millions of Angels at his command ) that he severely rebuked Peter for drawing his sword in his defence , and bid him put it up , for all that take the sword , shall perish by the sword . Here we see our Saviour doth not onely encourage us by his example to submit patiently to those that wrongfully assault us , but by his Precept enjoy●s it as our duty ; he doth not leave it at our disposal , whether we will submit or no ; nor is this onely a Counsel of Perfection , which brings honour and reward to those that keep it ; but to those that doe not , no manner of danger at all ( as Mr. Iohnson speaks , p. 68. from Greg. Naz. ) for we see here a penalty threatned to the resister ; though if any case might be excepted , this ought to claim the privilege , for the sword could never be drawn in a better cause , or by a better hand : But the Precept is universal and unalterable . St. Peter himself must not resist , though to defend his Saviour . This is a hard lesson ( I know ) to flesh and blood , but we must not Consult them when we are to take up the Cross ; which is the indispensable duty of every Christian , 2 Tim. 3. 12. And again , Heb. 11. 6 , 7 , 8. For whom the Lord loveth , he chas●eneth ; and scourgeth every son whom he receiveth . I hope I have not omitted any thing in Mr. Iohnson's book that might deserve the least Consideration ; but to make the surer work , it will be necessary to make some particular remarks upon those five Propositions , p. 92. into which he tells us there he has reduced the force and strength of what was formerly delivered in his Book . 1. Christianity destroys no man's natural or civil Rights , but confirms them . Ans. Christianity doth not at all meddle with our Civil Rights [ 1 Cor. 7. 20 , 21. with Dr. Hammond's Paraphrase . ] And as for Natural Rights , some it has confirm'd , but destroy'd others ; for many things were lawfull to us as men , which are not so as Christians . Nay , there were many things allow'd under the Iewish Oeconomy , which Christ hath absolutely forbid ; and particularly in this case of private revenge , and resisting the unlawfull Oppressour . See Matth. 5. v. 38 , 39 , 40 , 41 , 42 , 43. with Dr. Hammond's Paraphrase . 2. All men have a natural and civil Right and Property in their Lives , till they have forfeited them by the Laws of their Country . Ans. We had indeed a natural Right to our Lives , and we might have defended them by force , and those weapons that nature had bestowed upon us ; but this Right is superseded not onely by the Maxims of Christianity , but Civil policy too ( as has been shewn from Grotius ) ; and we can no more defend our Lives by violence , than we can destroy them upon private discontent ; both the preserving and destroying the Subject being lodg'd in the hands of the Supreme Magistrate . 3. When the Laws of God and our Country interfere , and it is made death by the Law of the Land to be a good Christian , then we are to lay down our lives for Christ's sake . This is the onely case wherein the Gospel requires Passive Obedience , namely , when the Laws are against a man : And this was the case of the first Christians . Ans. 1. The rule of our Obedience and Submission is universal , there is no person excepted ; nay , 't is plain from Scripture that we ought not onely to submit when the Laws are against us , but when they are for us , and we are illegally opprest : For if our Saviour commands us , Matth. 5. 38 , 39 , &c. not to resist a private person that offer'd us an injury , ( which is certainly illegal , and acknowledged so all over the world , since he acts without so much as any pretended a●thority ) how much rather ought we to submit to the Magistrate , though he acts contrary to Law ; for besides the general obligation we have just now mentioned , there is another that more particularly restrains us , viz. St. Paul's Command , to submit to his power as he is a Magistrate , and cons●quently ordained by God. 2. The Laws were no more against the first Christians , than they were against those under Iulian ; for they suffered both by the same Law , viz. the uncontrollable will of their Emperour . 4. That killing a man contrary to Law is Murther . Ans. I can't grant this universally true , for sometimes 't is more than Murther , viz. Treason , sometimes less , viz. Manslaughter : but that Murther is Murther , I allow . I hope the Reader will pardon the seeming lightness of this Answer , since it is necessary to shew how hard it is for Mr. Iohnson to speak truth or sense in the most trivial concerns . 5. That every man is bound to prevent Murther as far as the Law allows , and ought not to submit to be Murthered if he can help it . Ans. How plausible soever this seems , 't is utterly false : We ought indeed to prevent Murther by all the means our Laws command , for they can command nothing contrary to the Scriptures , but not by those they barely allow ; for 't is evident from what has been delivered already , that the Law permits some means that are not warranted by the Gospel , and those we must not , cannot use ; for we ought not to damn our selves to prevent the violence of a Murtherer , though offered to our selves ; for our Saviour assures us we don't lose our lives by this patient submission to death , but gain them . 'T will not be impertinent now to take notice of some Quotations pickt up out of Bracton , to countenance Mr. Iohnson's Doctrine , p. 83. who certainly has a peculiar way of perverting the sense of Authours : For how else could he arm Bracton against his Prince ? who , good man ! little thought his authority should be made use of to countenance disobedience , or to pull down the Prerogative , of which he really was so just and vigorous a defender : But our Law-books may well be debaucht to serve the purposes of ill men , when the Bible is , and Bracton has not so much reason to complain of the injury , since he hath St. Paul for a fellow Sufferer : The substance of all he cites from Bracton is this ; Rex est sub Deo & sub Lege quia Lex facit Regem . If Mr. Iohnson would but let Bracton interpret himself , we should have none of the absurd inferences he makes , p. 83. for he tells us , ● . 3. c. 26. Rex habet superiorem Deum item Legem per quam factus est Rex , item Curiam suam , viz. Comites & Barones . Here we see there is no more power allowed to the Law , than there is to the Earls and Barons ; and that they can't civilly oblige the King to Obedience , but onely morally oblige his Conscience when he is persuaded their Counsels are just , I am sure Mr. Iohnson himself will allow : Therefore 't is evident that those words cannot relate to any coercive power , but onely directive ; for he says just before , Nec factum Regis nec Chartam potest quis judicare ita quod factum Domini Regis irritetur : And what he delivers in the following words , onely implies a Moral superiority , by reason of a directive power in the Law , and likewise in the Earls , &c. not any civil jurisdiction or coercive power ; for he declares , cap. 4. p. 17. that for all the ill the King can doe , God onely can punish him : Satis sufficit ei pro poena quod Dominum expected ultorem . This is enough to satisfie those that never did , and perhaps never may see Bracton's Books of the meaning of that great Lawyer ; as for those that understand him , they know that he of all men is not in the least guilty of any saying that may derogate from the Prerogative of the Prince , for he has evidently made it his business to justifie it in its fullest extent . I might here conclude , but that Mr. Iohnson will give us another touch of the Primitive Christians , p. 93. where he tells us we have no occasion for that admirable example of the Thebaean Legion : If he had not forgot the Service of the Church , he would know the patience of Martyrs was not onely the business of our imitation , but the subject of our prayers too : And though we have not always occasion to follow their example , yet it is our constant duty to thank God for it . And therefore in the most peacefully settled times this sad story is not impertinent from the Pulpit ; we have solemn days to Commemorate the sufferings of our blessed Saviour and the Apostles : And though the Church has not thought fit to give this glorious Action a place in the Kalendar , it ought certainly to be eternally fixt in our Memories ; for then if ill times should come ( and if we consider impartially God's justice and our own sins , we have little reason to expect otherwise ) the Example and Conduct of the Thebaean Legion will be of great use to us ; there we shall see Souldiers dye with the same Meen they used to triumph ; and Chieftains not inspiring their Souldiers with Courage , but instilling the softer Maxims of Patience : Eucherius tells the Emperour ( after a second Decemation of the Legion , and upon his Command to destroy them all ) [ Despair it self , O Emperour , which is strongest in dangers , hath not arm'd us against thee : Behold we have weapons , and yet offer not to resist , because we had rather dye than overcome , chusing rather to dye innocent , than live guilty , &c. ] No body but Mr. Iohnson would say this great Example is not universally to be imitated ; and his reason is , because they suffered according to the Laws of their Country . This shift of his has been sufficiently exposed already ; but that he may not have the least pretence to it hereafter , I shall shew that the Christians under Iulian had power to resist ( and he declares the Laws were for them , ) and yet they did not ; so that his assertion , p. 94. that they would if they could ; and consequently that we may , is utterly false . Now that the Christians were able , appears from all the Historians that speak of that age ; for not onely the greatest part of the world were Christians , but Iulian's Army was entirely so ; for when they chose Iovinian for their Emperour , he refused the Honour , telling them , That since he was a Christian , he could not Command over Heathens ; but they all , with one accord , cried out , We are Christians . ] Rusin . l. 2. c. 1. Theodoret is more full in this case ; for he makes the Army tell him , that he shall command Christians that were ever bred up to that profession [ 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ] for those that were elder , had Constantine for their Teacher , the younger Constantius ; nay , they assure him they could not be Heathens , for Iulian did not live long enough to pervert them : 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 . Th. l. 4. c. 1. This Mr. Iohnson himself knew , for all he saith , p. 94. [ What would they have a few desenceless Christians doe , when they had lost their strength , and so many of their numbers ? ] for in his Preface , p. 25. he quotes St. Aug. in Ps. 124. who there saith , [ Though Iulian was an Apostate , an Oppressour and Idolater , yet Christian Souldiers served under him . ] Now whether these were unarm'd or defenceless when they were to fight , let any reasonable man judge ; and for their Numbers , I appeal to the Historians . Thus I hope I have performed my promise , viz. 1. I have shewn the Unlawfulness of Excluding the next Heir upon the account of his Religion , and that it is a practice altogether unknown to the Primitive Christians . 2. I have proved the necessity of Passive Obedience from the Scripture , the Sense of the Primitive Fathers , and the Doctrine of our present Church . 3. I have not left any thing unanswered in Iulian , &c. that opposed the Right of the next Heir , or justified Resistance . As for the latter part of the Book , since I am not concerned in the Vindication of the Papists , I shall leave it to the censure of those that are . But I must needs say , that Mr. Iohnson had more effectually routed the Papists , if he had rather set down the Arguments with which those great Men confuted their Doctrines , than onely the Rhetorick they exposed them with ; for we , ( whether it be the civility or judgment of the age , I shan't determine ) are not much affected with the Old Elizabeth-way of railing . FINIS . ADVERTISEMENT . THere is now in the Press another Answer to Julian the Apostate , Entituled JOVIAN . An Answerto Julian the Apostate . By a Minister of London . Books Printed for Walter Kettilby , at the Bishop's Head in St. Paul's Church-yard . DR . Fowler 's Libertas Evangelica . Octavo . Mr. Kidder's Discourse of Christian Forti●ude . Oct. Mr. Allen's Discourse of Divine Assistence . Oct. — Christian Justification Stated . Oct. — against Ferguson of Justification . Oct. — Persuasive to Peace and Unity : with a large Preface against the Quakers . Oct. — Mystery of Iniquity unfolded , against the Papists . Oct. — Serious and Friendly Address to the Non-conformists . Oct. — Practical Discourse of Humility . Oct. Mr. Lamb's Stop to the Course of Separation . Oct. — Fresh Suit against Independency . Oct. Mr. Long 's History of the Donatists . Oct. — Character of a Separatist . Oct. — against Hale's of Schism : with Baxter's Arguments for Conformity . Oct. — Non-conformists Plea for Peace Impleaded , against Mr. Baxter . Oct. Dr. Grove's Vindication of the Conforming Clergy . Quarto . — Defence of the Church and Clergy of England . Qu. — Responsio ad Celeusma . Qu. — Defentio suae Responsionis ad nuperum Libellum qui inscribitur Celeusma . Qu. Remarks on the Growth and Progress of Non-conformity . Qu. Baxter's Vindication of the Church of England , in her Rights and Ceremonies , Discipline and Church-Order . Qu. Mr. Halliwell's Discourse of the Excellency of Christiani●y . Qu. — True and lively Representation of Popery : shewing that Popery is only New-modelled Paganism . Qu. — Account of Familism , against the Quakers . Oct. — Sacred Method of saving Humane Souls . Qu. — Discourse of the Kingdom of Darkness . Oct. Cleget's Reply to the Mischief of Impositions , in Answer to Dr. Stilling ●●eet's Sermon . Qu. The True English-man : Humbly proposing something to rid us of the Plot in State and Contention in the Church . Qu. A Persuasive to Reformation and Unity , as the best security against the Designs of our Popish Enemies . Qu. The Harmony of Natural and Positive Divine Laws : by Walter Charleton , M. D. Notes, typically marginal, from the original text Notes for div A27390-e4540 Orig. l. 8. contra Cel. Atha . Apol. ad Const. Ath. ibid. Notes for div A27390-e6800 R●f 17. 18.