Friendly and seasonable advice to the Roman Catholicks of England by a charitable hand. Comber, Thomas, 1645-1699. 1677 Approx. 217 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 90 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2008-09 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A34067 Wing C5468 ESTC R1768 12410128 ocm 12410128 61513 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A34067) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 61513) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 661:4) Friendly and seasonable advice to the Roman Catholicks of England by a charitable hand. Comber, Thomas, 1645-1699. The third edition enlarg'd with an addition of the most convincing instances and authorities, and the testimony of their own authors for the same. [23], 152, [4] p. Printed for Henry Brome ..., London : 1677. Includes bibliographical references. Advertisement: p. [1]-[4] at end. Reproduction of original in Huntington Library. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Catholics -- England. 2006-08 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2006-08 Aptara Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2007-06 Robyn Anspach Sampled and proofread 2007-06 Robyn Anspach Text and markup reviewed and edited 2008-02 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion Imprimatur , G. Jane R. P. D. HEN. Episc . Lond. à Sac. Dom. March 20. 1676 / 7. Friendly and Seasonable ADVICE TO THE Roman Catholicks OF ENGLAND . The Third Edition enlarg'd : with an addition of the most convincing Instances and Authorities ; and the Testimony of their own Authors for the same . BY A Charitable Hand . LONDON , Printed for Henry Brome at the Gun at the West-end of St. Pauls , 1677. TO HIS Honoured and Worthy Friend M r. S. B. Concerning the former Edition . SIR , I Cannot answer your Inquiry , till I have not only commended but encouraged your charity to your Country men of the Roman Communion ; it being an excellent piety to endeavour to reduce them into the right way , who are so confident in the wrong . The zeal of most men expresseth it self by fury and clamour against Dissenters , whilst you shew your esteem for the rational principles of the Church of England by your diligence to propagate them , and your desires to reconcile its misinformed Adversaries to them . It is one of the great properties of Goodness to be communicative , and a copy of S. Paul's most obliging charity , Act. 26. 29. to wish that all whom you converse with , were as happy in the choice of their Faith , as you know your self to be : wherefore that I may as well quicken your generous design , as invite some others to imitate so good an example , I will propound these few considerations . 1. The relation in which the English Romanists stand to us should excite our care ; for they are all Natives of the same Country , Subjects of the same Government , and are called by the same general name of Christians : many of them our kind Neighbours , familiar Acquaintance , or near Kindred , and some of them ( where their Prejudice doth not blind them ) persons of great reason , and of so good inclinations , that they are not made vicious by the evil liberties which their principles do allow : and shall we for want of affection or courage suffer them to be kept in ignorance and imposed on at present , and to be led blindfold in such a way as will extreamly hazard the Salvation of their precious Souls hereafter ? If all the relations they bear to us do possess us with any real affection for them , we cannot but do our utmost to undeceive them . The frauds indeed of the Guides of that Church are daily more and more laid open , but for want of such a charity as yours is , they who are chiefly concerned , seldom come to the knowledge of them : I am sure those excellent pens which discover'd them , did not design we should make their delusions the subject of our mirth , but the means to convert the Souls of those who are linked to us in so many bonds , that it is a shame we should suffer them to be so deceived . 2. But we usually excuse our remisness , under the pretence that it is impossible to convert them : Had our Ancestors so esteemed it , the World had wanted the blessing of the Reformation : I grant 't is difficult , because of their rooted prejudice , and the policy of their Leaders , yet not impossible because many have undertaken it , and prevailed . So that as Seneca saith in another case , it is not because of the difficulty that we do not attempt it , but because we do not attempt it , therefore it seems difficult , Ep. 104. The Philosopher tells us where there is no difficulty , there is no opportunity to exercise either art or vertue : and if we were once willing to take some pains for so noble an end , it would much allay the trouble thereof , to consider the advantages which it may bring not only to the party which is the object of our charity , but to the Church , yea and to our own Souls also : for He that converteth a sinner from the errour of his way , shall save a Soul from death , and shall hide a multitude of sins , Jam. 5. 20. and they who turn many to righteousness shall shine as the Stars for ever and ever , Dan. 12. 3. Nay moreover if such Pious endeavours should want success on Earth , they shall not fail of a reward in Heaven . 3. And finally , if we consider the unwearied industry of our Adversaries in seducing , methinks it should awaken our diligence , in strengthning the weak , and reducing such as are out of the way . It had been very strange if the Apostles should have been unwilling to travel for the propagation of the right faith , and the winning Souls of Heaven , when the Pharisees compassed Sea and Land to reconcile a Proselyte to their particular Sect ; and yet alas 't is too often seen , that the children of this world are wiser in their generation than the children of light , S. Luk. 16. 18. The Hermit Pambo accidentally beholding a theatrick woman dance exquisitely before a loose assembly at Alexandria , is said to have wept abundantly , to consider how much more pains she took to serve evil ends , than he himself did to serve God. Had we as much tenderness as that holy man , doubtless we have as great occasion for our shame and sorrow , when we see others more active to advance the Mystery of iniquity , than we are to promote the glory of God , and the salvation of your brethrens immortal Souls . These Considerations , worthy Sir , I know have excited your charitable resolutions , and I hope will prevail with many others to endeavour the reformation of their deceived friends : wherefore that I may answer your desires , and contribute my poor assistance to so pious and generous a design ▪ I have sent you the following papers , wherein the delusions of that party are discovered as plainly , yet as modestly as may be , that they may see in a little room how much it is their interest and advantage to embrace the true Catholick Religion of the English Church . I know all these particulars have been more fully handled by better pens , but most of these writings have been by way of dispute , and intended rather to convince than perswade . So that they may be very proper to give fuller satisfaction in any particulars doubted of , when their great Prejudices are first a little removed : besides there are many through unavoidable business , company , or other divertisements , who either have no leisure or no inclination to read a larger volume , being of Callimachus's mind , that A great book is a great evil a , who yet may be prevailed with to spare one hour for so small an abstract as this . The Jewish Talmud tells us of a noble Heathen , who came to Rabbi Hillet , and offered to become a Proselyte , if he could teach him the whole Law at one lesson , Tract . Sab. fol. 31. and if you meet with any of his mind , they may perhaps be gratified with this little Abridgment , wherein the mistakes of the Roman Perswasion are put into as narrow a compass as they can well be reduced to ; so that even those who are yet resolved to be of that Church may perhaps not be unwilling to peruse it , that they may at one view see , what their Religion is charged with . And if it do not gain such persons , yet it will teach them to censure mildly , and to dissent from us with more moderation : and as the volume is small , and so may invite those to its perusal who are delighted with brevity , so the style is as mild as the matter would allow , and can give no just offence to any : the particulars are so plain , and so fully proved more at large by others , that the Author resolves not to dispute , but in pure charity to advise the Romanists not to resist apparent truth and reason , having no worse intentions towards them than to set them into the best way to Heaven ; and if any be angry at him or you for this , they are the greatest enemies to themselves , and more concerned for their present Opinions , than for their everlasting Salvation ; but it is to be hoped the sincerity of your intention to do good may oblige some kindly to accept this Manual , at least as a testimony of your love ; to whom , if you have the liberty of discourse , you shall do well to clear those exceptions which Prejudice may suggest , and at least to obtain from them a resolution , impartially to enquire into the truth of that which they so confidently do believe : and sure , it is infinite pity that persons of excellent reason should be so much enslaved , as not to dare to ask the right way to bliss of any , but those who have an absolute dominion over them , nor once to go about to judge for themselves in a case of so great Concernment . I would be loath to think so hardly of their Superiours , as to suppose they interdicted their Adherents from all converse with us ; for this were the exact parallel of the Muscovian policy , where it is death for any to travel out of their own Kingdom without especial license , for fear they should never endure their former bondage , when once they have seen the freedom of other Nations : and if once you can prevail so far , that they will impartially compare their own Opinions with ours , it is probable they may become our friends . I shall add no more but to wish this Token may be as kindly accepted as it will be charitably offered by you , and to assure you , you shall never want his prayers for your success , who is , Sir , Yours to serve you , TO His esteemed Friend M r. W. R. Concerning this present Edition . SIR , YOVR account of the speedy dispersing of this Little Tract , encourageth me to hope , it hath not only been acceptable to the World , but also blessed by God to the reducing some from the Roman Opinions , and the establishing others in the Protestant Faith ; And that it may more effectually serve to these desirable Ends , I have been content to obey your Request , in reviewing it in order to another Impression , which ( You tell me ) is now desired . In which Review , I have rectified the Method of the whole , and illustrated and strengthened every part , with the Addition of so many of the most convincing Instances and Authorities as could be put in without too much swelling the Bulk . I confess I did suppose the things to be so evident , and so plainly proved in larger Discourses , that I was not curious before , always to bring Proofs for my Assertions : But now your Letter acquaints me both that some Romanists ( who resolve boldly to deny , what they cannot otherwise evade ) have questioned the Truth of some parts of this charge ; And also that those Protestants whose Charity hath invited them to seek their Friends Conversion , have desired I should add my Authors to confirm these Allegations : Therefore for the full satisfaction of both Parties I have proved all the particulars by the Testimony of such Authors whose Evidence is unquestionable , chusing usually the plain Confessions of Popes and Cardinals , or other approved Writers of the Roman Church , that so those of that Party may believe these Matters from the mouth of those whom they esteem their best Friends , which they would suspect , if we related upon our own Credit , whom they unjustly account their Enemies ; And though their present Romish Priests should deny those things , which the most Eminent Writers of their own Church have formerly acknowledged , they are not to be doubted of upon that account , since the Confession of former Writers against their own Party is better Evidence , than the denial of the later can be for it ; for No man will lye ( saith Tertullian ) to his own disgrace , but rather for his credit : And it is more fit to believe such as confess against themselves , than such as deny for themselves a . So that none can justly doubt of these Truths thus attested : And he that once believes them , and yet retains the Religion of Rome , must be of a humor differing from the rest of Mankind , who cannot chuse a known delusion , nor delight in sitting under apparent abuses . I must expect the Admirers of that once famous Church will entertain these just and necessary Accusations thereof with some little heats of Passion ; but I hope it will calm those hasty motions when they deliberately consider , that since I say no more than Truth I do no injury to Rome , and the Charity which I have for them obliges me to say so much . And why ( saith the Philosopher ) art thou displeased at me , who have done no more than a Looking-glass doth to the deformed , having only shewed thee to thy self as thou art ? Shall the Physician be said to reproach him whose disease he discovers to him b ? They will remember I hope that I have undertaken the office of a Friendly Counsellor , whose duty ( according to the Graecian Sage ) is , Not to advise that which is most pleasing , but that which is most profitable c . And if in compliance with this Rule I shall somewhat displease them to their Advantage , I shall not only obtain a Pardon , but merit their Thanks also in the end : However , I ask no more , than that laying aside their Prejudices , they will put on so much affection to their own real interest as to weigh the Reasons and Arguments upon which my Advice is grounded , and if they be convincing and perswasive , I desire them not to resist their own Freedom , nor despise him that sincerely seeks their good ; but if they absolutely resolve the most rational and just Motives shall not perswade them to alter their Old Opinions , I shall pity and pray for them , but can use no other Methods in this case ; for it is Counsel and not Command which I give , since men should be reasoned and not forced into a right Faith , and would God the Roman Church had never obtruded her Opinions upon the world by any other means , but these gentle and rational perswasions , her Neighbours then would not have had so just cause to complain of her . And now , Sir , since I write , and you and other zealous Protestants act by these fair Methods , if our endeavours for our Countrymens Conversion be not maliciously misconstrued , they cannot be censured to tend to the harm of any , but must be confessed to aim at the present and future happiness of all that we shall address our selves to in this Matter : And I shall rejoyce if my pains herein may attain these blessed ends , and let you particularly understand how gladly I would encourage your Love to the Church of England , and comply with all your Pious desires , since I am , Sir , Your affectionate and faithful Friend . Friendly and Seasonable ADVICE TO THE Roman Catholicks OF ENGLAND . The Introduction . My Friends and Country-men , IT is observed by others , and complained of by your selves , That you lie under many inconveniences , by reason of your stiff adherence to those Opinions which Rome calls Religion : the charges you are at to maintain a forreign Jurisdiction , and your want of the Communion of those Christians among whom you live , the uneasie Rites imposed on you here , and the great hazard of your Salvation hereafter , are reckoned by others to be evils appendant to your professing the Faith of that Church . But if you your selves do not feel or not fear these things , and so account them no grievance , yet you are sensible of other pressures , and frequently complain , that your Estates are obnoxious to the penalties of the Law , and your Persons exposed to the general hatred of the People . You tell us , you want many Priviledges of other Subjects , and lie under many burthens from which others are free : You perceive , that your actions are observed , your designs suspected , and your Party accused to be the cause of all Publick evils . How far some of your own Perswasion have contributed hereunto I shall not take upon me to judge ; esteeming it a more charitable employment to offer some expedient to free you from those sad effects , which you complain of , than either to enquire after the cause of the Nations general Antipathy to your Religion , or dispute about the Occasion thereof ▪ Wherefore , whilst some accuse your practices , and others deride your worship , I have so much affection for your Persons ( as my Countrymen ) and so much charity for your Souls ( since you bear the name of Christian ) as to present you with some useful Advice . 'T is true , the common apprehension concerning you might almost discourage such an Attempt , it being generally believed , that a Roman Catholicks prejudice is like theirs in St. Augustine , who ( being descended of misbelieving Ancestors ) preferred their Extraction before the Truth : and like the resolution of Cotta in Cicero , who says , That no discourse of either learned or unlearned men , should ever remove him from the Opinion received from his Fore-fathers , concerning the worship of the Immortal gods a . But I know many of you are masters of more reason than to ground your Faith upon so uncertain a Foundation : It is not the part of wise men ( saith a learned Father ) to be enslaved to a received Opinion , nor rashly to give up themselves to their Fathers customes ; but to endeavour to find out the Truth b . And it is the advice of the great Apostle , to prove all things , and hold fast that which is good , 1 Thess . 5. 21. because it is a zeal without knowledge , and a foolish obstinacy to be confident of that which we never did examine . I can easily believe your Spiritual Guides will esteem no sin more mortal , than to enquire into those Principles which you receive from them , and they will scarce allow you the liberty to peruse a few lines presented by so charitable a hand : But their Prohibitions ( methinks ) should make you more suspicious and inquisitive , and cause you to resolve to try that Coyn which shuns the Touchstone , knowing that Truth seeks no Corners , and that which is Real fears no Test . The Church of England puts no such Restraints upon her adherents , nor is she unwilling to have her Doctrines tried by Scripture and the best Antiquity ; because she finds those are her best Sons that have enquired most narrowly . Evil needs a mask and a disguise ( said the brave Agesilaus ) but Light makes true goodness to be more illustrious and more lovely . And a greater than he saith , Every one that doth evil hateth the light , neither cometh to the light , lest his deeds should be reproved : but he that doth turth cometh to the light . S. John iii. 20. 21. If therefore you have but so much consideration as to suspect , and so much courage as to examine , I should not be without hope , that my Advice might take place , since ( as Plato notes ) Every soul is unwillingly deprived of Truth , which men cannot resist when once it appears unto them : I shall ask no more of you than to search impartially , whether the Doctrines wherein you differ from the Church of England , deserve so firm an assent as you give them ; and he that dares not do this , is not a Disciple , but a Slave . It may be those Counsellours may please the heady Bigots of your Perswasion better , who advise them to ease their mind by reproaching the Laws and the Government , or to attempt the shaking off their Grievances by more desperate courses : But I do not believe the wiser and more sober Romanists can approve such cursed motions , there are many of them too noble to admit such thoughts . It is the Stoicks character in Galen , That they would rather betray their Country , than renounce their Maxims : But I take those of your Party to be generally of a better temper , and therefore I hope you will account it to be far more Friendly and Seasonable Advice , to try these your Principles strictly , before you expose your Country or your Selves to suffer all the ill-consequences of your rigid maintaining of them , and if you once rightly understand them , I hope you will discern they do not deserve to be retained at so dear a rate : so that it is possible you may resolve to quit your mistaken Opinions and your real Sufferings together . However , though your Enquiry shall not have this effect , yet this Trial of your Principles ought not to be wholly declined ; for I would advise you to examine the Roman Doctrines , if it were but only to declare , that your Religion is not a blind and accidental choice , and to vindicate your selves from the charge of the Old Samaritans , who worshipped they knew not what . SECTION 1. Whether the Roman Opinions , which differ from the Church of England , be the Old Religion ? I doubt not , but these who have been educated in the Romish Religion , as well as those who have inconsiderately turned to it , do please themselves in fancying they are of the Old Religion ; and hence they assume and appropriate to themselves the Name of Catholicks , upon this presumption , that they do intirely , and in all things , agree with the Ancient and Universal Church : But ( my Friends ) if you have the patience to enquire , you will find there is no good ground for this perswasion ; it being evident the Roman is not the Old Religion , in any other Articles , but only in those which are found in the Apostles Creed , or founded upon the plain words of Holy Scripture ; for that is the Old Religion which God revealed at first , and which Christ and his Apostles taught . That is truest which was the first ( saith Tertullian ) and that was first , which was from the beginning c . So S. Cyprian ; We ought not to regard so much , what some others before us have thought fit , as what Christ himself , who was before all , hath done d . Now , if that be the Old Religion , which is taught in the Holy Scripture and the Creed , herein the Religion of Rome cannot pretend to be Older than the Religion of this Church , because we hold all these Articles as well as they ; yea , if the case be rightly stated , the Church of Englands Faith is the Old Religion , and not that of Rome ; for she professeth , To believe nothing as an Article of Faith , but what is read in Holy Scripture , or may be proved thereby : Artic . vi . But the Roman Church declares , They receive Traditions with the same veneration that they do the Scriptures . Concil . Trident. Sess . 4. So that we hold all the Principles of the Old Religion , and no other ; but they ( under the pretence of Traditions ) have invented and added many points to the Old Religion , which are not mentioned in the Bible , and Decreed other Articles contrary to the Old Religion recorded in Scripture , and all these are a New Religion ; and yet these are the Doctrines in which we differ . In all the Principles which are truly the Old Religion we and they generally do agree ; but if you take the Religion of the Roman Church for the Doctrines in which they differ from us , it may be justly said , they are of the New Religion , and we of the Old , since our Religion was recorded in Scripture sixteen hundred years ago ▪ ( as our Adversaries seem to confess , when they call us , Scriptuarii , Scripture-men : Prateol . ) whereas all that which is properly their Religion , is of much later Date . And that I may not be thought to invent this Charge , or to accuse the Roman ▪ Church wrongfully , I will instance in the most principal of the Doctrines wherein we differ , and bring in your own Doctors as Witnesses of this Truth . 1. That Prayers to the Saints are not mentioned by Christ nor his Apostles , is confessed by Salmeron , Lindan , and Bannes e . Etherianus saith as much of Prayers for the Dead f . Indulgences are not to be found in Scripture , nor in the Ancient Doctors , say Durandus , Major , Cajetan , and Antoninus g . Transubstantiation it self cannot be proved by Scripture , if you will take three Cardinals words for it h . And if our designed brevity would allow it , the like might be proved of all the rest . But we must proceed to shew , there are some New things in the Romish Religion , directly contrary to the Scripture . The taking the Cup from the Laity is contrary to our Saviours Institution , as that very Council of Constance confesseth which first enjoyned it ; for they say , the Sacrament shall be given in one kind only to the people , Non obstante , &c. notwithstanding our Lord did appoint it in both : Concil . Constant . Sess . 13. And your own Authentick Vulgar Translation ( as if this Innovation had been foreseen ) where the Greek only hath , We are all partakers of one bread , adds [ & de uno Calice ] and of one Cup : 1 Cor. 10. 17. The Veneration which you give to Images , seems to all impartial eyes directly contrary to the Second Commandement ; and though your Priests will not directly confess it , yet their general leaving out the Second Commandement in your Catechisms , and cutting the Tenth in Two , to keep up the number , and conceal the omission from the Vulgar , is a fair Evidence , they themselves suspected that this Commandement made against them , and feared others would apprehend it so . To these you may add , Praying in an unknown Tongue which S. Paul condemns in one whole Chapter , 1 Corinth . xiv . as some of your own Commentators on the place confess : As also the making Saints and Angels your Mediators to God , when the same Apostle positively saith , There is but one Mediator , viz. Christ Jesus : 1 Tim. ii . 5. All these therefore cannot rightly be accounted any part of the Old Religion , properly so called : But if we shall descend lower , these , and many other Points of your Religion are so far from being the Old Religion , that the Writers of the Roman Church do acknowledge , they were not known to the Primitive Fathers ; yea , they record the very time when most of them were imposed . The Doctrine of Purgatory was first built upon the Credit of those fabulous Dialogues attributed to Gregory the First ; or if they were his ( which many doubt ) this was six hundred years after Christ , and it was not generally believed in the Church five hundred years after , as we learn from an Old Historian , Otto Frising . Chronic. An. 1146. And as for the Prayers made to deliver Souls from thence ( that gainful Article of your Church ) we are told by your own Authors , that the first who caused them to be appointed by your Church , was Odilo Abbot of Clugny , An. 1000. * . The worshipping of God by Images , was not allowed by the Ancient Fathers , say your own Authors , Clemangis , Polyd. Virgil , and Peresius Aiala i . And all men know , this kind of use of Images can be derived no higher ( as to its being Decreed ) than that despicable Council k in the Eighth Century ; but both the Doctrine and the Council also was rejected for many years after by the French , English , and German Churches l . Indulgences are not Ancient , as Bishop Fisher confesses m : Nor is there any good proof in your own Authors for them before the time of Pope Alexander 3. A. 1160 , or the Council of Clermont however , An. 1096 n . And the first who made Mony of them was Boniface 9 th . An. 1390. as Platina and Polydore Virgil tell us o . And the first Jubilee ( the great Market for them ) was not an hundred years before p . The forcing all Priests to vow Single Life , and renounce their Wives , was first obtruded upon the Church by Pope Hildebrand q : Without any Precedent ( saith an Old Historian ) and ( as many thought ) of an indiscreet Zeal , contrary to the Holy Fathers Opinion r . And yet he was not obeyed here in England in this for above a hundred years after ; for our Ancient Records say , All these Decrees availed nothing , for the Priests by the Kings consent still had their Wives , as formerly s . Auricular Confession to a Priest was never imposed as necessary until the Lateran Council t : It being little above fifty years before , that we are informed by the famous Master of the Sentences , and by Gratian your great compiler of the Decrees , that it was in our choice whether we would confess to God only , or to the Priest also u ; and T. Aquinas confesseth this was the Opinion then w . Transubstantiation ( the discriminating Doctrine of your present Church ) was not held by the Fathers , as your own Doctors acknowledge x ; and one of the Infallible Heads of your Church affirms , That the Elements cease not to be of the substance and nature of Bread and Wine y . The Schoolmen confess Transubstantiation is not Ancient z : And two of the most famous of them plainly deny it a . The Administring the Sacrament in One kind , is no older than the Council of Constance ( as was noted before ) b ; the practice of the whole Church , and of Rome it self being otherwise till then c : Finally , many things were never decreed and imposed as necessary to be believed till the late Council of Trent ; such as the equalling Apocryphal books and Traditions to the undoubted Canon of Scripture , Justification by the merit of Good works , &c. Which Council of Trent was never fully owned by the Catholicks of France d : Nor was it ever received as a lawful Council by this English Nation . It would be too tedious to run over all the rest of those Points wherein the Roman differs from the English Church , or else it might be shewed , that the Appeals to Rome , and the Pope's Vniversal claim , Veneration of Relicks , Invocation of the Blessed Virgin , Pilgrimages , &c. were wholly unknown to the three first Centuries , as the ingenuous Romanists will confess , and our Writers have largely proved . By all which it appears , that the Old Religion of Rome for the first three hundred years , had no formal Invocation of Saints nor Angels ; no Purgatory , nor Prayers to be delivered thence ; no Images , no Transubstantiation , no half Communion , no Jubilees , no Indulgences ' no constrained Coelibate , no Prayers in an unknown Tongue , no customary Auricular Confession , no Apocrypha in her Canon of Scripture , nor the rest : Now if you strip your Church of these Doctrines , she retains scarce any thing , but the Protestant Articles of the Church of England ; But if you take Rome with these Additions , her Religion is not so Old by far as the Religion of this Church . Perhaps it will be pretended , Though these Decrees were made in later Ages , yet the Determinations were made by vertue of Apostolical Traditions preserved in the Roman Church from the very beginning ; and upon this Pretence your Late Writers of Controversie have generally laid aside all Arguments from Scripture and Ancient Fathers , and resolve all into Oral Tradition and the Infallibility of the Roman Church : But what is this but to confess , that the Scriptures , the Ancient Fathers , and all written Records ( which are Impartial witnesses ) do make against them ? only these unknown Traditions , which are only in their own keeping ( and may be of their own devising ) these , they say , bear witness for them , which is to make themselves Judges in their own Cause ; and may justly occasion your enquiry , whether the former Popes knew of these Traditions or no ? if not , how then came the later Popes to the knowledge of them ? If they knew of them of old , why did they let them sleep so long , and suffer the Church to erre for so many years for want of them ? Did they discharge their Vniversal Headship well in this Concealment ? But in very truth it is Evident , the first Popes knew of no such Traditions , and the later Popes have invented them to support their New designs ; which appears by the Ancient Popes declaring directly contrary to these pretended Apostolical Traditions , of which take a few Examples . Pope Gaius writes , That the Righteousness of the Saints avails nothing to our Pardon or Justification e . Pope Gelasius denies Transubstantiation , as was noted just now f . The famous Gregory the Great saith , He himself was the Emperors Servant , and owed him obedience g ; and declares , That God had given the Emperor power over Priests as well as others h . The same Pope disowns the Title of Vniversal Bishop , as unfit for him or any other i . He also determines , that it is lawful for Priests who cannot contain to marry k : And he allows Images for History and Memory only l . A later than he also in the Canon Law Decrees , that in such Diocess where there be people of Divers Languages , The Bishop shall provide fit men to celebrate Divine offices , and Minister the Sacraments of the Church according to the diversity of Rites and variety of their Languages : Decretal . Greg. l. 1. Tit. 31. cap. 14. The aforesaid Pope Gregory the First affirms , that the Book of Maccabees is not Canonical m . And as well the Ordinary Gloss , as the Old Editions of the Bibles which were allowed by the Roman Bishops , and used in that Church before the Council of Trent , do all distinguish between the Canonical Books , and those which the Protestant Church now call Apocrypha n Yet the contrary to all these hath been afterwards decreed upon pretence of being Apostolical Traditions : By which account you may see ( if your Prejudices hinder not ) that the present Roman Church ( as it differs from the Church of England ) retains neither the Old Religion of the Scriptures , nor that of the Primitive Church in general , nay , nor that of the Ancient Church of Rome ; for they have omitted some Points , added others , and altered so many , that though Rome keep the Old Name , it doth not keep the Old Faith. We may now seek Rome in the midst of Rome ( as Juvencus Vitalis said ) : Nor can it be denied ( saith Another ) but the Roman Church is not a little different from its Ancient beauty and splendor o . There is not the Faith , the Manners , nor the Worship of the Primitive Roman Church ; and therefore according to S. Ambrose , They that have not Peter ' s Faith cannot succeed to Peter ' s Inheritance p ; and as S. Hierome observes , They are not the Sons of the Saints who possess their places , but they which follow their Works : And , That only ( saith Lactantius ) is the Catholick Church which retains the true Worship of God q . You might have seen and heard in Rome of Old , a Bishop without a Triple Crown or the Title of Vniversal , Churches without Images , Priests under no Vows of Single life , Litanies without any names of Saints or Ora pro nobis , the Mass celebrated in a known Tongue , Bibles calling divers books Apocrypha , which are now reckoned Canonical Scripture ; People not enslaved by Auricular Confession , not debarred of the Cup , not frighted with Purgatory , nor impoverished with purchasing Prayers and Indulgences to save them from thence , &c. To conclude therefore , Why may you not justly desert them , who have in so many things departed from the Old Religion , taught by Christ and his Apostles , believed by the Ancient Fathers , and received by the first and best Bishops of that same Church ? If you desire to be really of the Old Religion , nay , if you would hold the Faith of the Primitive Roman Church , you may come much nearer to it , by embracing the Religion of your own Country , than by retaining the Opinions of the Modern Church of Rome , which are most of them meer Innovations : And though you have reverenced them while you supposed them Ancient and Apostolical , yet we hope you will now renounce them when they are evidently discovered to be Gibeonites disguised on purpose to deceive , and ( notwithstanding their mouldy Pretences , as if they had come from far , and were descended from Ancient Times ) their true Original is much later and nearer to this present Age. And now , Secondly , it will be easie to determine , That as the Roman is not the Old Religion , so neither ought the Professors of it to appropriate to themselves the Name of Catholick . For whether we take it in the Primary and Grammatical sense for [ Vniversal ] , or in its common acceptation for [ True Believers , ] The Romanist hath no peculiar Right to this Venerable Title : First , because their Faith in those Points wherein it differs from the Church of England is not Universal ; for as the judicious Mr. Brerewood computes , the Christians holding the Faith of Rome , are not above a fourth part of those who believe in Christ r : And the excellent Author of Europae Speculum s thus makes out the Account : The Greek Church ( saith he ) in number exceeds any other — , and the Protestants in number and circuit of Territory are very near equal to the Papal part , these are two fourth parts : to which if we add the Oriental Christians , which are not of the Roman Communion , and those under Prester John or the Abassine Christians , we have another fourth part of the Christian people ; and then the Romanists , are but one fourth part of Christians only . And it is very odd to say , that the fourth part is the whole : And surely ( my Friends ) you cannot seriously think the Roman Church to be the Vniversal ( or Catholick ) Church in this sense , when you remember that the Pope's Authority is not acknowledged by the Generality of those Christians living in England , Scotland and Ireland , with the Plantations thereunto belonging , nor by those of Denmark and Sweden , nor by those of Transylvania , Walachia and Moldavia , nor by the large Church of Russia , nor by the populous States and Provinces of the Dutch , with their many Plantations abroad , nor by at least five parts of six of the vast Country of Upper Germany , nor by two parts of three of the Switzers , nor by those of Geneva and Piedmont , nor by very many in France , Hungary , Poland , &c. How many Millions of Christians are there in the Eastern World who have no dependance on the Roman Church ? The Christians of the Greek Church ( properly so called ) under the three Patriarchs of Constantinople , Alexandria and Antioch , those of Armenia ( who are professed Enemies of Rome , and yearly Excommunicate the Pope ) . The Georgian Christians , with many other lesser Names in Asia , the Abassine Christians in Africa ; all these are not of the Communion of the Roman Church , and therefore , how can that Church pretend to the Title of Vniversal , or Catholick in this sense ? But secondly , if you say you are Catholicks , that is , true Believers in all Points ; I desire you to consider , that none say so but your Selves , and 't is suspicious their Witness is not true , who bear witness to themselves , S. John v. 31. And where so many Articles of Faith are New , it is probable some are False ; since the Oldest things in Religion are the truest and the best : So that upon the whole Enquiry , the Church of England may more justly claim the Title of Catholick , because the Principles thereof are few and clearly deduced from Scripture , believed in the Primitive Church , and universally received by all sorts of Christians , who differ in some Ceremonies ; but for the Points , which this Church accounts necessary to Salvation , the whole Christian World generally agrees in them . And since the Religion of the Church of England is the most Ancient and most Vniversal , you will be more truly of the Old Religion , and more properly styled Catholicks by embracing the Faith professed in your own Country , and disowning those who damn all Christians but them of their own Party , although it be Evident there are in the World , Christians far more in number than they , and among those many equal in Learning and superior in Piety to the best of the Roman Church , who are reprobated and sentenced to Eternal Flames by their uncharitable Anathema's . SECTION II. Whether the said Opinions were not introduced for evil Ends ? ALthough all this be matter of Fact , and acknowledged by your own Writers , yet I must expect , the venerable Esteem you have so long had for the Roman Church , will make you slow to believe this deserved Charge of Innovation ; and perhaps you will wonder how so pure , so Celebrated , and so Orthodox a Church , as Rome Primitive was , should vary so much from her first Faith , yet since the Change is so Evident , and so well attested , I hope at least your Curiosity will tempt you to Enquire : First , For what ends she should bring in these New Doctrines . Secondly , By what means they became so generally believed . Thirdly , Of what nature the things themselves are . Fourthly , Whether there be Authority sufficient in the Roman Church to Impose them on the whole Christian World. Fifthly , Whether the Catholicks of England ought to be swayed by that Authority to embrace them : And if in examining these Particulars any thing shall be spoken which sounds harshly to your ears , ( accustomed to hear nothing but Encomiums of Rome ) I shall desire you to consider , that Truth is seldom grateful to Offenders ; and I must say with one of the Writers of the Popes Lives , We relate these things because they were done , and if the Popes would not have base or evil things reported of them , they must do no such things , or if they do them , not fancy they can be so concealed , as that they shall not be known nor related to Posterity : Papyrius Masson . de Vit. Pont. For my own part , I profess , I take no delight in Accusations ; nor shall I say any thing out of malice to that Church , but out of pity to the Souls of those who without reason dote upon it : If you enquire , What ends the Roman Church could have to bring in these New Doctrines ? I Reply , The first decay of that Church began in her Manners . For after there were Christian Magistrates ( saith S. Hierome ) the Church became fuller of Riches and emptier of Vertue t . And for the Roman Bishops , they began very early to affect a Dominion beyond the bounds of Priesthood , as Socrates notes u ; which made S. Basil say thirteen hundred years ago , I hate the Pride of that Church w , and caused a Heathen Historian of that Age to say , The Roman Bishops were richly clad , carried in Litters , and profuse in their feastings x ; But the faults of that Age were small in respect of After-times , for as their wealth and power increased , their manners grew still worse and worse , as we find by the complaints of Salvian , and many others , till at length about the ninth Age your own Baronius saith , The face of the Roman Church was become most filthy , when lewd and potent Curtezans swayed all there : At whose pleasure Sees were changed , Bishops placed , and which is horrid to Pious ears , their Paramors were thrust into S. Peter ' s Chair , false Popes which only serve to fill up so great a space of Time in the Catalogue of Roman Bishops y . And a Writer who lived in those Times tells us . The World was amazed at the Manners of the Romans z . It is strange ( saith another Historian ) how far in that Age they were degenerated from the Piety of the Old Popes a . This Age ( as Another speaks ) was especially unhappy in this , that for about an hundred and fifty years , there were fifty Popes wholly fallen from the Vertue of their Predecessors , being disorderly and Apostatical rather than Apostolical b . And if our brevity would permit it , we could shew out of Platina , Onuphrius , and Others of your own Writers , that there was no Reformation in all the Ages , while these New Doctrines were in coyning : Now it is the Great Philosopher's observation , That Wickedness is destructive of good Principles c . So that it is no wonder , if in such Decays of Piety , and such a flood of Iniquity , the Roman Church did bring in many New Articles suitable to her Manners ; and I think when Pride , Luxury and Covetousness possess the Chair , we can hardly expect any other Laws , but such as shall gratifie these affections : And the Practices as well as the Decrees of Rome for divers of the latter Centuries have so apparently tended this way , that it hath been taken notice of by all those of her own Communion , whose affection hath not rob'd them of their discerning Powers ; yea , even in Catholick Countries it hath abated much of the Reverence formerly paid to that See , by reason the designs thereof are so apparently Secular , tending not to the Salvation of Souls , but the support of their own Grandeur : Which makes me admire our English Romanists should hug their Chains , and adore those who abuse their well-meaning Devotion with Articles of Faith serving rather to carry on the Designs of the Imposers , than the Salvation of their over credulous Believers : Methinks an easie apprehension might discover , that the Roman Guides govern you by Principles that have more of Machiavel in them , than of Conscience or Gospel-simplicity , and a little consideration will inform you , that those things which they teach you to call Religion , are Arts to enslave and impoverish you , and Engines to advance themselves to the highest pitch of honour and abundance : S. Bernard ( though a great friend to the Roman Church ) saw this , when he said , At Rome all regard is given to Honour , but to Holiness none at all d . Were this the fault of particular mens Evil management ( from which no Society is free ) it were more excusable , but there are Doctrines added to the Old Catholick Faith ( even most of the Tenets wherein they differ from the Church of England ) which are plain Artifices to increase the power and wealth of Rome . Doctrines for which they dispute with us upon Demetrius's Principle , because thereby they have their gain , Act. xix . 25. And many think the Guides of your Church contend for some of these Principles , not because they believe them , but because it is their Interest the people should be perswaded of them ; which makes them secretly laugh at their Credulity who will be imposed on by them , as that great Cardinal did , when he gave the People ( who flocked about him ) his Benediction in these words , Qui vult decipi decipiatur : And it is a vile suspicion of this which we may gather from that observation of Hospinian , That in Italy the name [ Christian ] is used for an Ideot or Fool e . But to be more particular , let us look over some Instances of such New Doctrines as are taught in the Roman Church for Secular ends . We begin with the Doctrine of Implicit Faith or believing as the Church believes , a Doctrine unknown in S. Cyrils time , who speaking to his young Christians , Bids them not meerly believe the things he spoke because he affirmed them , unless he did demonstrate them to be so out of the Divine Scripture f . And truly this Novel Doctrine may agree with Pythagoras's Ipse dixit , and is a good shelter for Paganism , the best Argument for which , Balbus saith , is this , That he had received it from his Fore-fathers g . The Jewish Rabbins told their Disciples , They must believe whatever they taught them , though they should say that their right hand was their left : and it was becoming enough in Apel●es the Heretick to charge his seduced Scholars , not to examine his Principles by Reason h : But it is below the Honour of true Religion to desire to be taken upon Trust ; so that this Doctrine is a policy of your Priests to secure their evil Principles from being enquired into , and a device to make you depend on them as Infallible Oracles , who can by this means lead you blind-fold whither they will , and impose any thing on you which serves their Interest , under the pretence of true Religion . 2. Auricular Confession to a Priest was voluntary of Old , and only used in case of a troubled Conscience , or a strong Temptation : But it is now made necessary at stated times , in all probability to make the Priest master of every mans Secrets , to discover the least inclination of their Proselytes to leave them , to keep the Laity in awe , and make them venerate and depend upon their Spiritual Guide , who hereby hath them at his Mercy : And their Doctors do affirm , that in some cases it is lawful to discover what is revealed to them in Confession , especially if it concern the Roman Church i . And thus they have an Intelligencer in the breast of every Great man of their Communion . The Exempting the Regular Clergy from their Lawful Bishops Jurisdiction ( which S. Bernard complains of as an unjust thing k : And the freeing Ecclesiasticks from their Natural Princes Authority is , that the Pope may have Subjects numerous and potent to give Intelligence and abet his Interest in the bowels of all Kingdoms . The Popes Supremacy , Appeals to Rome , the Collation of Benefices and other Preferments , the Creating their Maker in the Mass , with many others , do all aim at the Honour of the Church of Rome , and the making its most inferior Priests revered : But because the Honour of the Church of Rome cannot be maintained without vast riches , it is obvious to all , that many of their New Doctrines and Practices have been introduced with design to fill the Churches Treasuries : or if Ignorance and Superstition were the Mother of these gainful Devices , it is certain Covetousness hath been an officious Nurse unto them . As in the case of Purgatory , and Prayers to deliver Souls from thence , a Novel fancy , feared and suspected at first by some , but countenanced and Decreed by that Church , thereby to oblige the people to give liberally for themselves or their deceased Friends , to those who sell their Prayers so commonly that they occasioned that Proverb , No penny no Pater Noster . It is impossible to reckon the vast sums that this Opinion brings in , for so many Masses , Dirige's , Requiems , for those Trentals , Obits , and Anniversaries , which the deluded Romanists purchase , with Oblations of Houses and Lands , Plate , Vestments , Jewels , Images and Ready mony . And it is very remarkable , that the fear of losing this Income was one main Impediment to restrain the Pope from yielding to a Reformation . To these may be added the Doctrines of Images and Invocation of Saints , with the reports of Miracles done at certain places , and the Device of Canonization by the Pope ( an Honour that none of the Saints for the first five or six Centuries ever had ) but certain it is , that people being perswaded of Miracles wrought on Earth and Intercession made in Heaven by these Saints , do undertake Pilgrimages to these places and make Oblations there , or else send their Offerings if they cannot go : And this in so excessive degrees , that there have been , and are some Shrines which cu●vy the Treasuries of the greatest Princes of Europe ; we may instance in Tho. Beckets at Canterbury l , and the still famous Lady of Loretto m . The Relicks also of all other Saints , yea , such as are said to belong to Jesus himself , have been formerly carried about to collect Mony , yea , sold for great sums , and are accounted Marketable ware , and very gainful Commodities in the Roman Church . The Year of Jubilee and distribution of Indulgences are used as devices to get mony , as your own Writers complain n . The Pope's pretences to a power of Dispensing with Vows and Oaths , Leagues and Contracts , Marriages in prohibited degrees , &c. fill his Coffers with Silver and his Court with Suitors . The taking mony for Penances and granting Absolution upon it for Notorious sins , is so known an Infamy , that we have the very book in our hands , copyed out of the Original in the Apostolick Chamber , setting down the rates and sums to be paid for Absolution from the most horrid wickednesses : And to convince us that Mony is the only thing sought by the Church in these Absolutions , the said book tells us , that These acts of Grace cannot be granted to the Poor who have nothing , and therefore cannot be comforted o . And though the Priests and Fryers have these and many more ways to draw Mony from the people , yet the Pope uses them but as Spunges , to suck in wealth from others , that he may squeez it into his own Coffers afterwards : For it is scarce within the reach of Arithmetick what sums the Roman Church receives from the Inferior Clergy and Bishops for Institutions , Confirmations , Investitures , Palls , First-fruits , Tenths , &c. The very Tenths and First-fruits formerly enjoyed by the Pope , amounting in this Nation , as we now compute them , to above 20000 l. per An. And in the time of the Roman Jurisdiction here , the Clergy paid him a fifth part of their Livings , sometimes for two or three years beside ; and for the English Bishops , their subjection to Rome cost them dear , Walter le Grey Archbish . of York paying Ten thousand pound sterling for his Pall p . And it was complained in the 23 d of Henry 8 th that the Papacy had received out of England in about forty years past , for Investitures of Bishops only Threescore thousand pounds q . And the Doctrine of sorcing all Priests to renounce Marriage , is maintained by the Policy of the Roman Court , that they may not only profit by them living , but be their Heirs when they die , there being no other good Reason to be given for this rigid Imposition ; for sure they will not say it is simply unlawful for Priests to marry , since two Popes , S. Gregory the Great and Pius the Second , affirm They may be allowed to marry r ; and their great Canonist saith , There is as great reason to allow Priests marriage now , as ever there was to restrain it s . What then ! do they forbid it that Priests may be more pure ? that cannot be the Reason , because S. Paul saith , Marriage defiles not , Heb. xiii . 4. And Fornication which certainly doth defile , is tolerated , if not allowed t , and called a Venial sin u : However reputed by their Casuists a lesser sin in the Priest , than Marriage x . And how pure this Doctrine makes your Clergy let Experience and your own Writers teach you . There are many ( saith S. Bernard ) who cannot be hid for their multitude , nor do they seek to be concealed through their Impudence , who being kept from Nuptial Remedies run into all filthiness a . There are few free ( saith Another ) in these days from the crime of Fornication b . The Pope thinking it almost a Miracle some Ages since to hear a Candidate for a Bishoprick attested to be a pure Virgin c . The true Reason therefore of this Doctrine , which occasions so much wickedness , we may learn from the Canon . Law : which allows not Regular Bishops to dispose of their Estates by Will , nor others of the Clergy to be too free of their Alms in their sickness d , ( how earnestly soever they exhort the Laity thereunto : ) And thus the Church becomes their Heir , And these Spoyls of the Clergy ( as they very significantly term them ) which fall to the Church at their deaths amount to a good round sum , as a judicious Author observes e . I cannot express one half of those Arts which the Roman Church hath to drein both Clergy and Laity : But certain it is , they do draw a Mass of Treasure Annually from the Countries under their yoke , insomuch that it was complained of to the Council of Spain , that Pope Pius 5th had got fourteen Millions out of that Kingdom in a short space f . And in the time of Henry 3 d of England it was computed , that the Popes Revenue out of this Nation exceeded the Kings g . And another time complaint was made by the English , that there went Threescore thousand Marks yearly out of this Land to Rome h . I shall not mention the Frauds and Cruelties used in Collecting this Mony , only noting that Johan . Sarisburiensis , a great Bigot of the Popes ( and a hot stickler in Beckets Cause ) assures us , That the Legates of the Apostolical Seat , did Tyrannize over the Provinces , as if the Devil ( saith he ) were gone out from the presence of the Lord to scourge the Church i ; yet to oppose these Officers of the Pope , is reckoned at Rome the most mortal sin : No wonder then can it be , that Pope Sixtus 5 th , in five years time got together Five Millions of Crowns ( as Ciracella informs us ) Four Millions of which his Successor Gregory 14 th wasted in Pomp and Riot in less than Ten months time : Europ . Spec. p. 263. And indeed they spend these Sacred Treasures as badly as they get them ; the very Popes themselves of late designing only to swallow all the little neighbouring Principalities , and to make themselves Temporal Princes , to raise their Nephews and Neeces ( if not Sons and Daughters ) and advance their Families to the highest Dignities and Fortunes . So that there is little of Holiness left in them but in an empty Title , it being a little above a hundred years since one said , No man at this day looks for Holiness in the Popes , they are accounted excellent , if they be tolerably good , or less wicked than other men are : Papyr . Masson . in Vit. Julii 31 An. 1550 : and the rest of his Clergy and People are suitable ; for , It cannot be dissembled ( saith a late exact Observer ) that the whole Country is strangely overflowd with Wickedness , with filthiness of Speech , with beastliness of Actions ; both Governors and Subjects , both Priests and Fryers , each striving as it were with other in an Impudentness therein : Europ . Spec. p. 27. But I will not pursue this most ungrateful Subject , which I profess I do not relate out of any envy , or delight in telling such sad stories : but I am forced to say these unpleasing Truths to rescue your Souls from those who serve the ends of their Ambition and Covetousness out of your Devotion ; from those who perswade you to call that Religion which maintains them in the highest plenty and luxury : from those who Decree , that Good works merit Salvation ; not because they believe this Doctrine ( for if they did , they would do more Goodworks themselves ) but because this Perswasion among the people fills the Churches Treasures , and hath made the Old Pious and poor Priests and Deacons of Rome , Illustrious Cardinals , who in Magnificence , and Pomp dare vye with the greatest Estates of Christendom ; and their Great Master scorns to have Kings and Emperors thought his Equals : Wherefore , when you have duly weighed all this , and considered the Pride and insatiable Avarice of the Roman Church , and withal observed , how all the Doctrines in which they differ from us , tend meerly to advance these ends , you cannot think it unlikely , that such men with such designs should alter and add to their Old Faith , especially when you hear S. Paul say , The love of Mony is the root of all evil , which while some coveted after , they have erred from the Faith : 1 Tim. vi . 10. It is nothing that is truly Ancient or really good , that we perswade you to renounce ; but Novel Policies and Devices which minister to Secular designs , and you ought to account him your Friend who would rescue you from this abuse , and perswade you into that Church , whose Principles are Primitive , plain and honest , whose Clergy are content with the Revenues which the Laws of the Land allow them , having none of these Vnchristian Artifices of extraordinary gains , nor no design to teach you any Doctrines , but such as will make you good , and direct you in the way to Heaven . SECTION III. Whether the said Opinions were not established by evil means ? THe next Enquiry is , By what means these New Doctrines became so generally believed ? And here first we may note , your Church hath good reason to use this Proverb , Ignorance is the Mother of Devotion ; because the wretched blindness of those Ages wherein these Opinions were propagated , did hugely contribute to their Reception : for it is not to be denied , that from the time of the decay of the Western Empire , and the Irruptions of the Goths and Vandals into Europe , there began to be a great decay of Learning , and Barbarism crept in by degrees , which is evident by the different style and way of writing which the later Fathers use , in comparison of those who lived in the first four or five Centuries , and at length this Ignorance became so universal , That the study of the liberal Arts was generally laid aside ; as an Old Historian complains k : and that Age which bred many of these Errors is commonly by your own Writers called , The Obscure Age l , being wholly without any persons eminent for Wit or Learning m , the very inferior Priests being not able to translate an Epistle into Latin o ; which Aegyptian darkness continued in all the Western world till a few years before the Reformation , as your own Espencaeus confesseth o . Now this gross stupidity must needs make the World apt and easie to be abused with the most absurd and monstrous Doctrines ; for Ignorance is the Mother of all Errors ( as an Old Council affirms p , and not of true Devotion ( as you now pretend . ) This made way for the Politick Guides of Rome to impose such Opinions on the Church as might best serve their own ends ; These Tares were sowed while men slept , Matth. xiii . 25. and there were many Circumstances concurring in those unlucky Ages which contributed to the furthering the Roman designs , the withdrawing of the Emperors into the East , and first the Decay of the Western Empire ; then the destruction of the Eastern , and the desolation of all the famous Oriental Churches by the spreading Inundation of Turks and Saracens ; so that the Pope had neither Emperor nor Patriarch ( for a long time ) that could oppose him , the Miseries of all Christendom giving him opportunity to make himself the sole Governor of these Parts of the World , and none were able to contend with him , though many complain'd of his Vsurpation ; Johan . Sarisburiensis telling Adrian 4 th ( who asked him what men thought of the Roman Church ) That they esteemed it a Stepmother , not a Mother — , and the Pope of Rome himself was grievous to all , and almost intolerable q . I shall not now be so tedious to you as to relate , how this Church by force , and by taking all advantages did attempt to suppress all that did oppose her Impositions and Grandeur ; what wars the Popes raised against the German Emperors , what occasions they took to enslave the Greek Church , when they petitioned for relief against the conquering and cruel Turks ; what Persecutions they raised against the Albigenses , Bohemians and Wicklevists , and how they destroyed all that resisted their Innovations with Fire and Sword ; only desiring you to remark , That the Roman Church was the first Author of putting men to death for that which they call Heresy : A practice wholly differing from the Rules of Christianity r , from the Opinion and Practice of the Ancient Church s : It being a New and unheard of way of Preaching ( saith your S. Gregory ) to force men by stripes to believe t ; yet by Fire and Fagot the modern Church of Rome affrights the World into the Embracing these Articles , or by Inquisitions and Racks , awes them into silence , not daring to question them : Her Greatness , Riches , Interest and Severity to Opposers , hath been one means to obtrude the belief of her gainful Articles upon men ; and her Policies and Frauds have been another , for you cannot think it unlikely that they ( who have so little Piety , as to turn Religion into Policy ) should have so little honesty as to equivocate for the defence of their Politick Religion ; and verily , the Ignorance and Credulity of those blind Ages were such , that your Church never sought for solid Arguments to confirm their New Decrees , but built them usually upon Fictions , and proved them by notorious Forgeries , and accounted this way of proceeding not only lawful but Pious , so that whosoever reads those Discourses of your Jesuites in defence of these Deceits , called by them Piae fraudes , will conclude the High-Priests of Rome-Christian as well as Rome-Heathen to have been of Opinion , That it was expedient the people should be deceived in their Religion , as Scaevola the Pagan , Pontifex M. in S. Augustine saith u ; and no doubt your Church agrees with the Heathen Varro in the same Author w , where he saith , There are many Truths in Religion which it is not expedient for the people to know , and though divers things therein be false , yet the people ought to think them true : The instances of some particulars will make this more evident ; 1. Miracles were the foundation , and most authentick proofs for Invocation of Saints , Veneration of Images and Relicks , Pilgrimages , Purgatory , Monastical Vows , and most of the gainful Articles of the Roman Church ; and yet S. Chrysostome saith , that there were no footsteps of the power of Miracles left in the Church in his time x . And your S. Gregory thinks them unnecessary among Believers y , and so do many others z : Yet in the dark Ages nothing was more frequently pretended than Miracles wrought by Saints living and dead , as appears by the stories of their Lives , and the Legends of your Church , which Relations are so senseless and so ridiculous , so impossible and unlikely , so little agreeing with Chronology , History , or Geography , that the Modern Writers of the Roman Party are ashamed of them . Hence your own Canus complains , that these Authors of Saints Lives with false and counterfeit Fables have blemished the Lives of Saints a . And the same Writer saith there b , that the Author of your so famed Golden Legend was a man of an Iron forehead and a Leaden soul : Harding also affirmeth c , That there be many vain Fables in it : Simeon Metaphrastes , is another of these Miracle-Writers , and is so eminent that he is read in the Modern Roman Breviaries d , and yet Cardinal Bellarmine blames him for incredible stories , and relations not agreeing to Ancient Writers , He adds ( saith he ) many things out of his own wit , not as they were really done , but as they might have been done e . And is not this notorious forgery ? Yea , the Popes themselves in the latest sort of Breviaries have left many of these fabulous Miracles out , since they have done the work now for which they were invented ; the Doctrines supported by these lies are now generally embraced , and when the Arch is compleated , the Props on which it was raised , may be laid aside ; yet still you ought to ask , If these stories were false , how came the Infallible Church to put them into her Offices ? if they were true , why doth she now reject them ? And it is observable , that the Roman Church at present pretends but to very few Miracles , and the Doctors thereof ( in this knowing Age ) are very shy of believing any at all , as one of your own Priests proves at large f . The Reason of which must needs be , because they fear this Inquisitive and learned Generation should discover the fraud of them . For since Miracles are especially necessary to convince unbelievers , there is far more need of them since the Reformation ( when so many disbelieve the Religion of your Church ) than was before ( when all the Nations of the West were at the Devotion thereof . ) Yet then many Miracles are recorded and now few or none , an Argument sufficient to make a wary man believe , there were few real Miracles at any time since the settlement of Christianity ; only the superstitious and ignorant credulity of the former Ages was fit to be abused with such Pretences : And now , why are you so stiff in maintaining those Opinions which were believed at first upon so slight and false inducements , as these Legends and Miracles are confessed to be ? But this Argument is of late so fully handled by two excellent Pens g , that I may dismiss it , with my hearty wish you would read those Tracts without Prejudice , being not written to abuse real Religion ( as some tell you ) but to undeceive you , and unmask that hypocrisie which hath long walked in the venerable Mantle of Truth : Nor ought you to be angry at the Relators , but at the Inventors of such falshoods , who have got many fair Houses and Lands , vast sums of Mony and innumerable costly Oblations by these Fictions , to the scandal of Christianity it self . My second instance shall be of the Artifice of Forging Records for to attest their Novel Doctrines ( especially that of the Pope's Supremacy ) they put out divers spurious Tracts under illustrious names , which served to wheadle an illiterate Age into a Reverence for the Roman Church and her Opinions ; whereas now the cheat is so palpable , that your modern Doctors ( though they keep the Conclusions ) disown those feigned books that were the Premises from whence they were inferred : Of this nature are the Decretal Epistles of all the Popes from Clemens down to Pope Syricius An. 385. formerly cited as good Authorities , and transcribed some parts of them into your Canon Law , but now the most learned Romanists confess a great part of them to be meer forgeries h : Baronius styles divers of them Apocryphal i : And Cardinal Cusanus saith ; That being applied to the times of those Holy men they do betray themselves k And indeed these Epistles were never cited by any good old Author , and were first brought into France by one Riculfus Arch. B. of Ments five hundred years after those Popes were dead , as Hincmarus Arch. B. of Rhemes a Writer of that Age affirms l , and Baronius also confesseth m . Nor did the Roman See blush some Centuries ago to alledge for its Supremacy the most fabulous Donation of Constantine the Great , wherein he is pretended to make the Pope head over the whole Church , and superiour to all the four Patriarchs of the East ( naming Constantinople for one , which City was not yet built ) giving him in fee the City of Rome , and all Italy , with all the Provinces of the Western Empire ( though he gave all these to one of his Sons afterwards ) . This senseless Edict was pleaded by several of the Popes in former times to countenance their ambitious pretences n , and of Old was received without suspicion by the gravest and learnedst Doctors , saith Binius o , who yet confesseth there , it was a meer forgery devised ( he thinks ) by the Greeks , and now adaies all Romanists generally disown it , and indeed it is as ridiculous a forgery as ever the world saw . My Brevity will not allow me to enlarge upon this Subject , otherwise I could add innumerable Examples of like dealing . The absurd Council of Sinuessa , The monstrous Recognitions of Clement , The threescore new Canons father'd by Turrian and others , upon the famous General Council of Nice , The Pontifical ascribed to Pope Damasus ; with innumerable other Tracts of the same Metal , being all apparent Forgeries , and yet were long countenanced by Rome to support her unjust Supremacy and other Innovations . My third Instance shall be of Suppressing or corrupting true Records , of which take a few Examples : The Legates of Rome , within less than a hundred years after the general Council of Nice did produce two Canons ( to prove the Popes Right to receive Appeals ) in a famous Council of Carthage , An. 419. which Canons they pretended were made in the aforesaid Nicene Council ; but these Canons wholly differed from all the best Manuscripts of that Council then extant , particularly from two eminent ones , which the African Fathers sent for from Constantinople and Alexandria ; nor do they agree with those genuine Editions of the Nicene Council now extant ; and indeed the Council of Carthage received not these pretended Canons of Nice , but esteemed them to have been corrupted , as we do at this day : Not long after ( to abet the Roman Supremacy ) Pope Leo writing to Theodosius the Emperor , cites a Canon of a particular and dubious Council at Sardi●a of later Date and less Authority , affirming it to be a Canon of the general Council at Nice p : The Edition of the Councils put out by Dionysius Exiguus about An. 520. being for a long time the sole approved Copy extant in these parts of the World , doth in favour of the Popes Supremacy , leave out divers Canons even of General Councils which seem to make against it q , though the said Canons are recorded in Zonaras and Balsamon , and in this Age confessed to have been made in those Councils by the Romanists themselves ; but in the Time when the Supremacy was in hatching , it was not thought expedient those Canons should be known : It were endless to reckon up all the Additions , Diminutions , and Alterations , which all the Roman Editions of the Councils since , are guilty of ; and because an ingenious Essay hath been made that way by a late Author , I shall refer my Reader thither r , and out of infinite Examples conclude with one Evident piece of Falsification : The xxxv . Canon of the Council of Laodicea , Forbids the faithful to call on the name of Angels , which being a condemnation of the Doctrine and Practice of Rome in Praying to Angels , The Later Editions of this Council have impudently put in , Angulos [ Angles or Corners ] instead of Angelos [ Angels s ] ; though all the Greek Copies t and Fathers read 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 u , and all the old Latin Exemplars have , Angelos w . Yea , Pope Adrian himself ( before this worship of Angels came up ) read it [ Angelos ] in that Epitome of Canons which he sent to Charles the Great , An. 773. Thus they corrupt the Councils to suit them to their own Opinions , Nor have single Fathers and Ancient Authors fared better : S. Cyprian put out by Pamelius is altered in many places contrary to the Ancient Copies ; for Example where the Father saith , the Church is founded Super Petram x , Pamelius changes it into Super Petrum , upon Peter , instead of upon a Rock y . And Ludovicus Vives ( a Romanist ) assures us that there are Ten or Twelve lines positively asserting Purgatory , put into the Printed Copies of S. Aug. de Civitate Dei lib. 21. cap. 24. contrary to the Ancient Manuscripts z . Fulbertus Carnotensis quotes S. August . saying of the Sacramental bread , This then is a figure ( the Roman Editions put in ) As a Heretick will say ; when indeed S. Augustine says so , and speaks his own sense a . Aimonius speaking of the Eighth Council saith , They determined about Images otherwise than the Orthodox Fathers had Decreed : and so Baronius reads b : But the Modern Printed Copies quite contrary put in , — according as the Orthodox Fathers had Decreed c . But why do I stand upon particular Instances , This wickedness which all other men account the same Villany with suborning false Witnesses , stopping the mouths of the True , and counterfeiting Hands and Seals , is owned by the present Church of Rome : And Sixtus Senensis doth highly extol Pope Pius 5 th . for his most holy Decree , to burn all Books which were ( accounted ) Heretical , To purge and cleanse all Catholick Authors , and especially the Writings of the Fathers d . Now in what manner they effect this most holy work , the Bel●ick Inquisitors ( appointed by the Roman See ▪ ) shall tell you , We strike out ( say ) they ) many Errors , in other of the Ancients , we extenuate and excuse them , or by feigning a Commentitious gloss , either deny , or fix a commodious sense to their words e . Thus they served S. Ambrose his works , cancelling and altering whole pages together , contrary to all the Old Manuscripts , as appeared by the Original Papers which Savarius the Stationer shewed to Francis Junius , according to which the Inquisitors had ordered him to Print that Edition : Lugdun . An. 1559. f . Thus they left the story of Pope Joan out of the Copies of Anastasius Biblioth . though the Manuscripts had the said story in them as Marquar . Freherus testified , who lent them the said Manuscripts g . And I might fill a Volume with Instances of like unjust dealings ; but I will only add the memorable account which Boxhornius one of your Divinity Professors at Lovain gives of himself , viz. That he having been employed by the Inquisitors to strike out at least six hundred places of the Ancients , which seemed to make against the Roman Doctrines , was so troubled in mind upon it , that it was an occasion of his turning Protestant , and made him resolve to quit that Religion which could not defend it self without such manifest Impostures h . And I wish the consideration thereof might have the same effect upon you ; for the matter of Fact is so evident , that the Index Expurgatorius , the Book which directs these Falsifications , is now come into Protestant hands to the eternal Infamy of the Roman Church ; whose people cannot rationally trust to any Author which comes through their Priests dishonest hands ; And since false Books are invented , true and genuine Writers altered and corrupted , or else wholly prohibited , if they seem to make against them ( for which cause Clement 8 th . puts the Bible into his Index of prohibited Books ) and all Editions but their own condemned and burnt by the Roman Church ; the people must needs be deluded into a perswasion , that all these New Doctrines are Primitive Truths , when indeed this abominable Forging evidently shews , that the Pope and his Conclave think that both Scripture and Antiquity do make against these Innovations , and would discover the Imposture , if they were suffered to speak out ; to whom I may justly apply the words of Arnobius , To intercept what is written , and to design to smother published Records , is not to defend the Gods , but to fear the Testimony of the Truth i : And because Good men ( as S. Augustine saith ) will not deceive ; but neither good nor evil men would willingly be deceived k , I may suppose that the most Devoted Romanists cannot but discern how unsafe he is in believing , as those men teach him , who make no Conscience to invent , impose , and pretend things never so false , provided they may thereby advance their Churches Interest , or their own private ends : They who dare write Lies , will not be afraid to speak them , and they who corrupt the Remains of the Holy Saints deceased , are not to be trusted with the Souls of the living ; And whoever gives himself up to such Guides , unnaturally chuses his own delusion , and desperately hazards his own salvation : S. Ambrose adviseth us if we choose a Guide , to be careful he be endued with two properties , Honesty and Prudence : for his Honesty will be a security that he will not deceive us , and his Prudence will prevent our suspicion of his being deceived himself l ; which wise Counsel if you follow , you must no longer adhere to these unfaithful Leaders : Nor ought you to fear to forsake them , either because your Forefathers fathers relied on them , or because the Doctrines that they teach were once so generally received here ; since your Forefathers lived in an Age wherein there was little means to detect these Forgeries , whereas you are by Providence fallen into those times ▪ wherein all the Dishonest Arts of that Church are discovered so plainly , that if your Forefathers had seen as much as you may see , they would have forsaken Rome long since , and not have left you this Objection to make : Nor are the Doctrines ever the better for being generally received , when as they were imposed on the World by such evil means as Force and Fraud ; which being thus made evident , you can no longer wonder how these Innovations came to be so generally beleived , being propagated by as wicked means as they were invented for evil ends : So that now what the Roman Church thought would secure her Opinions ( if it could have been kept close ) must needs make them odious ( being once laid open ) and the Impostures ▪ which they designed should tye men to their Church , will ( as some of their own Doctors have prophesied ) be an Occasion to make all Discerning men turn from it ; for Religion is to be defended ( saith Lactantius ) not with wickedness but fidelity , for if you attempt to defend Religion by Evil Arts , you do not defend , but pollute and violate it m . SECTION IV. Whether the said Opinions tend to advance the Ends of true Religion ? NOw though it be altogether unlikely those Principles should be either true or good , which stand in need of such Arts to propagate and defend them , yet because you have been so long accustomed to call these things Religion , and it is not easie to lay aside our rooted Prepossessions , we will pass to the Third Enquiry , viz. Whether the things themselves be good in their own nature , and Parts of true Religion ? Now we may try this by considering what are the ends of True Religion , and whether these Principles serve to advance those ends ? True Religion therefore hath three Principal Ends : 1. To advance the honour of God. 2. To assist us in the Devout worshipping of him . 3. To teach us to imitate him by a holy life and conversation . Let us here therefore examine , whether the peculiar Articles of the Roman Church do not hinder rather than promote these Ends : For if it appear these Principles are dishonourable to God , impediments to Devotion , and hindrances to a holy life ; then those Doctrines are also Evil in their own nature , and they can be no real parts of a good or True Religion : Nor must you retain them because you have once judged them good , if upon Tryal they prove to be otherwise . We must be firm to our Principles ( saith Epictetus ) yet not to all of them , but only to those which are right ; we must begin at the right end , and first lay the foundation by considering whether our Principles be good or evil , and after build upon that by constancy and firmness of Resolution n . Wherefore let me desire you patiently and impartially to enquire . First , If there be not some of your Principles and Practices which tend not to the honour of God ; if it be a dishonour to the Divine Majesty for a mortal man to contradict his Laws by contrary Constitutions , I fear your Church will hardly be found innocent : For do they not command things which God hath forbidden in as plain words as can be spoken , as in the case of Images , Exod. xx . 4 ? and Prayer in an unknown Tongue , 1 Con. xiv . 28. Do they not forbid things which God hath allowed , as in the case of Priests Marriage ? Heb. xiii . 4. 1 Cor. vii . 2 Chap. ix . 5. 1 Tim. iii. 2. 12 ? and taking the Cup from the People ? which they have decreed with a Non obstante , that is , notwithstanding our Lord Jesus appointed the contrary . Do they not presume to dispense with the very Laws of God , in many cases of Matrimony and Divorce , of Vows , Oaths , Leagues and Contracts ? So that laying aside the Commandment of God , ye hold the Tradition of men , as our Saviour speaks , Mark vii . 8. Your Holy Father who doth all this may think himself the greatest upon Earth , but if our Lord Jesus tell us the Truth , He shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven , Matth. v. 19. Secondly , Is it not a great derogation to an Infinite and Invisible Being , to be represented by an Image , and worshipped under such Representations ? Agreeable to the worship which Heathens gave to their false gods o , and some Hereticks to our Saviour p , but contrary to the Decrees and Practice of the Primitive Christians q , and to the great scandal of Modern Jews , who call your Churches Houses of Idols , upon this account r . Thirdly , Doth not the Doctrine of Merits cast a palpable dishonour upon the glorious Redemption wrought by Jesus Christ ? Sure I am , divers of the Ancients , as well as of your later Writers , think so s . Nor can we think it to be less than Blasphemy , which Bellarmine affirmeth , viz. That a man may be said to be his own Redeemer without any injury to Christ t . Doubtless those who fancy they can redeem themselves , and satisfie for their own sins , cannot but have a mean esteem of Christ's Merits and Satisfaction . Fourthly , Your praying to Angels and Saints , especially the blessed Virgin , making them your Mediators and Patrons , and asking the greatest things of them , hath made Prayers to God by Jesus Christ to be generally neglected by the vulgar people , who say ten times as many Ave Mary's as Pater Noster's , and wickedly fancy the Blessed Virgin and Holy Saints are more compassionate than our Lord Jesus . This Doctrine ( saith a very wise man ) hath wrought that general effect in all Countreys subject to the Papacy ; that men have more affiance , and assume to themselves a greater conceit of comfort in the Patronage of the creatures and servants of God , than of God himself , the Prince and the Creator u . A fault which St. Paul lays to the Heathens charge , Rom. i. 25. How dishonourable must it needs be , to leave Jesus that one Mediator : 1 Tim. ii . 5. ( who always doth certainly hear us , and is most apt to pity us , and best able to help us ) to pray to God by those , concerning whom your own Doctors doubt whether they know any thing done here w ? and the Scripture plainly saith they do not x . Reason shews it is impossible they should hear many Prayers in divers places at once . To have the worship paid to the Master and the Servants , the same in all outward expressions , only differing in a nice School-distinction , must needs be an affront to the King of Saints . If you have any tenderness or zeal for the honour of Jesus , it cannot but be offensive to you , to observe how your Legends tell of greater miracles wrought by some of their fabulous Saints , than ever Jesus wrought . To hear one of your Church say , That Christ did nothing which S. Francis did not do , yea , that he did more than Christ himself y . What is more injurious to the honour of the Divine Majesty , than your S. Bonaventure's putting in the name of the Virgin Mary into Davids Psalms instead of the name of God ? To have her adored by the Heathenish Title of the Queen of Heaven z , and invocated by the impious name of Mother of the whole Trinity a ! These things are rather Blasphemy than Devotion , and as dishonourable to God as they are Dissonant from Antiquity . Let none ( saith Epiphanius ) adore Mary ; but why do I mention a Woman ? nay , not any Man : this Reverence is due only to God , nor are the Angels capable of such glorification b Fifthly , The supposing a necessity of superadding the Saints Merits and the daily Sacrifice of the Mass , to the Merit of that one Offering for sin which Jesus made on the Cross : Heb. ix . 28. is an evident lessening the value and sufficiency of the Death of Christ , Sixthly , The calling of the Holy Scripture a Nose of Wax , a Leaden Rule , and an Inky Gospel c . The putting in the Apocryphal books , wherein are some things wicked d , and others notoriously false e , into an equal rank with the Word of God indited by the Spirit ; own Traditions to be equal in value to it f , are palpable dishonours to God who writ the Holy Scripture . These things ( my Friends ) can hardly be reckoned matters tending to the honour of God , unless you can suppose the cancelling his Laws , disparaging his Nature , undervaluing the Merits , the Mercies and the Miracles of Jesus by cheap and odious Comparisons , the diminution of his worship , and making him sharer with his Servants therein , and the vilifying of his Divine word , be no dishonour to him you pretend to serve . Secondly , Let us examine whether these Doctrines do assist you in the Devout worshipping of God ? It is very suspicious that Church doth not teach a right way of serving God , which deceives you in the first Principle of Religion , viz. That God alone is to be worshipped : a Sentence so odious to the Roman Doctors , that the Index Expurgatorius blots it out of the indices of S. Athanasius and S. Augustines Works g , and if they could do it ▪ undiscovered , they would blot it out of the Bible also , Matth. iv . 10. But there it shall stand for ever to reprove those , who divide Religious worship between God and his Creatures , thereby diminishing that Devotion which intirely belongs to the Divine Majesty , since affections are most vigorous when placed upon one Object , and if they be dispersed among many , grow weak and trifling ; whence we may conclude , the Protestant who worships none but God , is the greater lover of him , and worships with a more united and servent Devotion . As for your Publick worship , it is attended with so many Ceremonies as must needs disturb the Devotion as well of the Priests as the People , there is such frequent bowing , crossing , prostration , sprinkling with Holy water , beating the breast , smoaking with Incense , &c. that the mind is taken off from a steady intention upon the inward and main part of the Duty , while it is entertained with such variety of outward Rites . For our mind ( saith Quintilian ) cannot sincerely intend its whole self upon many things at once , whatever new object it looks upon , it gives over the thoughts of that which it first propounded to it self : And this is most evident where the Objects are so different as sensible and intellectual things are . For where the Senses and their perceptions are vigorously employed , there the Intellectual Powers cease to act ( as a great Philosopher observes h ) . So that it is your Passions and your Fancies that are wrought upon , not your Mind nor the higher faculties of your Soul , by these numerous Ceremonies ; and therefore that which you think Devotion , I doubt is but a fantastical and false fire , not kindled by the love of God , nor warming your nobler Powers at all , and those steady , rational and spiritual desires , which flow from an undisturbed contemplation of the Divine Goodness and are the very life of Prayer , I fear you are strangers to , being so often taken off and diverted by variety of sensible Representations . Again , the making all your Publick prayers in an Vnknown Tongue , destroys all true Devotion in the People ; S. Clemens of Alex. tells us of some Heathens who thought those Prayers most effectual which were uttered in a barbarous Language i . But Christians know , that Prayer is the desiring something of God , and if the Mind be not exercised in this desire , it avails nothing ; but where the words are not understood , the mind cannot desire the things mentioned , so that none can properly pray in an Vnknown Tongue , nor so much as rationally say Amen , 1 Cor. xiv . 16. By this absurd Practice therefore you ( who are unlearned ) spend the time of the Publick offices in admiring and gazing , not in joyning with the Priest or Praying . And because the people have no employment while the Mass lasteth , they spend the whole time usually in talking and laughing privately , as those who Travel in Catholick Countries do inform us k . And it may occasion your wonder , why the Roman Church should so obstinately refuse to reform so irrational a Custom , which S. Paul hath written a whole Chapter to condemn , 1 Cor. xiv . The force of whose Arguments and Authority , hath made your wisest Doctors declare against it . By S. Paul ' s Doctrine ( saith Card. Cajetan ) it is better for the edifying of the Church , that Publick prayers were made in the Vulgar Tongue than in Latin l . To the same purpose Lyra m . And your Rhemish Annotators say , When a man prayeth in a strange Tongue which himself understandeth not , it is not so fruitful for Instruction to him , as if he knew particularly what he prayed n . Gabriel Biel also gives several Reasons why Prayers should be in a known Tongue , saying , It is better 1. For stirring up Devotion , 2. for enlightning the Mind , 3. for retaining the things in memory , 4. for keeping the thoughts from wandring o . Yet your admired Church will oppose Reason and Scripture , and deprive all the Common people that are of her Communion , of the exercise of their Devotion in her Offices , rather than so far seem to confess a fault , as to amend it ; chusing rather to let you lose the benefit of worshipping God , than to reform the most unjust Customes which she hath once espoused ; but ( if you be wise ) if that Church will not pray in such a Language as you can joyn in , you will go over to the Church of England , where you may Pray with the Spirit and with understanding also . In the next place your Private Prayers are not so good a way of worshipping God as other Christians have ; The Images and Pictures , which the Heathens first taught your Doctors to call , The books of the unlearned p , and which are placed before you in time of Prayer , are no help , but an hindrance to all true Devotion ; for while your lips are repeating your Oraisons , your mind is taken up with the beauty , colour , lineaments and workmanship of the Image : so that your own Conscience will tell you , by these diversions you often draw near to God with your lips , when your hearts are far from him , which is a vain worship : Matth. xv . 8. And the Casuists of your Church , foreseeing that Images would take off the attention , have determined most impiously , That it is not necessary to Prayer that the person praying should think of what he speaks q . A Doctrine suitable enough to that slight and formal worship which your Church appoints ; and the Ordinary people among you , think they have prayed sufficiently , when they have pattered over so many little Oraisons as agree to the number of their Beads ; A new Invention , which came not into the Church till all serious Devotion was ceased r , it being a sign he minds his Prayers but little , that needs a string of Beads to reckon them by ; yet these Beads ( saith one of your own Authors ) are now the chief Instruments of the hypocrites counterfeit Devotion s . I shall not ravel into the body of your Prayers , since the Author of the Reflections on the Romish Devotions hath sufficiently done this ; but I cannot but remark , that the repeating Ave Maria , and the name of Jesus so many times over , as in those fifteen little Prayers in the Psalter of Jesus , where the name of Jesus is thrice mentioned in each Prayer , and each Prayer is ordered to be said Ten times over ; and those numerous names of Saints repeated in your Litanies with no petition annexed but Ora pro nobis : This way of Praying is so far from agreeing with the Primitive worship of God among the Christians , that it is evidently derived from that Heathenish superstition of praying by repeating a hundred names of their Deities together , interposing nothing but O hear us t ; and in this manner Baals Priests are supposed to pray , 1 Kings xviii . 26. But to Christians Jesus saith , When ye pray use not vain repetitions as the Heathens do , for they think that they shall be heard for their much speaking : Matth. vi . 7. Wherefore though you have admired this trifling way of worship , when you knew no better , yet if you would acquaint your selves with the solid and rational way of praying prescribed in the Church of England ( wherein Great things , in an exact method , in plain and proper phrases , and in a known Language , are asked of God alone in the name of Jesus Christ ) you would easily leave off those formal , vain and superficial Devotions , which can neither be acceptable to God , nor profitable unto your selves . Thirdly , Let us pass to the last of these particulars and enquire , If the Doctrines of Rome , differing from those of England , do tend to promote our imitating God by a holy life and conversation ; without which all our worship is in vain ; For it is a folly and miserable errour ( saith S. Augustine ) to humble your self before him in adoration , to whom you chuse to be unlike in conversation , and to give him religious worship , whose Example you will not follow ; since the sum of all Religion is to imitate him you worship u . Now there are several Principles of the Roman Church which seem to hinder an holy life , as first , The custome of Confessing to a Priest weekly or monthly , together with the Absolution following of course upon this Confession , this is ( I fear ) a great hindrance to amendment of life , at which it pretends to aim , for while men relie on this remedy , they go on without fear in those sins for which they have so easie a cure at hand , like those who venture without scruple on dangerous Meats , because they have their Physicians beside them : 'T is true there is a Penance enjoyned sometimes , but it is such a one as the rich may buy off and the poor may undergo , and yet both retain the sin , because the Penance is not its proper cure ; the going in Pilgrimages , giving mony , saying or reading over such proportions of Legends or little chiming prayers , with others far more impertinent , tend not to rectifie a vicious habit , and a plaister on the Toe may as soon cure the Head-ach , as these Penances effect a Reformation , or obtain a pardon at Gods hands . And yet all men see , when the day of Confession is over , and the Penance past , that you are generally confident of a Pardon , and fancy you begin upon a new score . It is not easie to enumerate all the devices which your Church hath invented to convey pardon of Sins , Holy water , Relicks of Saints , visiting some certain Churches , saying some certain Prayers , making Oblations of mony to such and such uses , Indulgences , and other such things , so that he that hath mony need never want Pardon from Rome ; but alas , these things can never really take away the guilt of one sin , and yet they embolden men to commit many ; For the multitude of Sinners increaseth , when hope is given that sin may be bought off , and men easily fall into those sins for which Mony will purchase their pardon : as Arnobius said to the Heathens , who relied on such like fantastical means of Remission w : and we may say of the Guides of your Church , as Seneca in a like case , They sin more in such Absolutions , than the Offender doth in the Crime x . For by perswading men they can have Remission on so easie Terms , they make them secure before they are safe , because Almighty God , who only finally can Remit , never promised Pardon on these Terms , and it is only those who forsake as well as confess their sins to whom he will shew Mercy , Prov. xxviii . 13. And if either the Pope or any of his Substitutes , pretend to have power to forgive sins on any other Terms , they abuse those who are so weak to believe them , and make them forfeit their Souls ( I doubt ) for the sad price of this Credulity : S. Basil saith truly , The power of Absolving was not absolutely given , but upon condition of the Penitents Reformation y . And we tell our People more sincerely , that if a Priest Absolve them a thousand times over , and if they give ever so much mony , without amendment of life they can have no pardon , according as Scripture it self teaches z , and the Holy Fathers also ; If thou givest all that thou hast , and dost not forsake thy sins , thou art twice deceived , both in losing thy Mony and thy Pardon also a . Again , as if the Roman Church designed to make men think their own actual Holiness were never necessary , they have other devices to perswade you into a belief of coming off well at the end of your life , howsoever ill you have spent it : The Hereticks in Tertullians time said , It was a meritorious thing to be of their Party b . And you are told it is a ready way of Salvation to die in the Communion of the Roman Church , and if you can but receive the Sacraments of that Church , and be Absolved by one of their Priests , you scarce doubt of obtaining Heaven at last ; and if you have no good works of your own , they perswade you the Church can sell you the Merits of the Saints ; or if you should drop into Purgatory by the way , the pains of that ( they say ) are not endless , and if you give liberally on your Death-beds , or if any others afterwards give for you , to purchase so many Masses and other Prayers for your Soul , you will ere long be delivered from thence . All which notorious delusions do miserably deceive poor men , and most mischievously encourage them to put off their Repentance , and to resolve not to be troubled with holiness in the way , since they fancy they shall come off so easily in the end ; and alas they are as false as they are mischievous ▪ for the Ancient Fathers unanimously affirm no mans estate can be altered after this life , But as the last day of a mans life finds him , so the last day of the World finds him c . Nor will any thing help thee ( saith S. Augustine ) but what is done while thou art here d . Out of innumerable such Testimonies , that of S. Salvian may serve : Although a man should have so pious a Son who for alleviating his Fathers punishment , would desire to give all the goods he left behind him , it would do him no good , for the Piety of the Son can do nothing to procure that Rest to a man after Death , which his own Impiety and Infidelity hath denied him e . Finally , these and the like Principles make so many infamous men and women , so many Thieves and Murtherers , debauched and prophane persons to take Sanctuary in the Roman Church , because the Tenets thereof seem not to oblige them to forsake their evil ways , but reconcile wickedness and Salvation together : so that this Religion tends not to perswade men to Holiness of life , and therefore is no good Religion : I grant there are some Persons in that Church who live better than these Opinions engage them to do , and do not draw those Conclusions into their practice which naturally follow from these Principles ; but that is only an evidence of the excellent vertue of such Persons , but no proof of the goodness of these Doctrines ; and if these men be Holy in a Religion which gives such encouragement to evil , doubtless they would be more holy by far , if they were taught better things : I shall only add , that as the Roman Church is too loose in matters pertaining to Gods Laws , so she is too strict in matters pertaining to her own Constitutions , like the Old Pharisees who Tithed Mint and Annise , and neglected the weightier matters of the Law : Matth. xxiii . which is a great obstruction to real Holiness , when men place Religion in Ceremonies and slight things , for while they are curious in these matters , they neglect greater , and think by observing the Rules of the Church , they compensate for passing by the Laws of God , your own Ordinary Gloss saith , That is Superstition , when Religion is placed in observing the Ordinances of men f . And if so , then your wonderful strictness in Crossing , Bowing , using Holy Water , Abstinence on certain days , wearing Crosses , &c. in which you have placed so much Religion , are no better than Superstition . It cannot be denied , that most Roman Catholicks are more afraid to eat flesh on a Fasting-day than to curse or swear ; they will be drunk on a Holy-day which God forbids , but not work on it because the Church forbids it ; many of them dare fornicate and debauch , who dare not neglect Confession , nor read a book written by a supposed Heretick : And generally , they are punctual in crossing , sprinkling , bowing and observing all Orders of the Church , even such as live in the open breach of Gods Commandements , and yet fancy themselves more sure of Heaven than the most pious and holy Protestant : Thus this Religion is too strict where God gives us more liberty , and too remiss where his Holy Law hath bound us with Eternal and Indispensable bonds ; and it is designed to promote Obedience to the Roman Church , rather than Inward holiness towards God : The effect of all which Considerations is this , That whosoever sincerely desires to glorifie God and worship him with a rational Devotion , and whoever would imitate him by a Holy Life , ought not to chuse or retain such a Religion whose Principles tend so evidently to the dishonour of Gods Name , the hindrance of true Devotion , and to the rendring a Holy life unnecessary : And as it was proved before , that the appropriated Articles of the Roman Faith were not Ancient , nor induced for pious ends , nor propagated by honest means : so now it is evidenced , the Articles are not good in their own nature , and therefore there is no reason why you should not renounce them , unless you retain them in meer Reverence to the Authority of the Pope who doth impose them , which Matter is the Subject of our last Enquiries . SECTION V. Whether the Roman Bishop have sufficient Authority to impose the said Opinions upon all Christian Churches ? THe Last , and almost the only shelter that your Doctors flie to at this day for the defence of your Principles is , That the Bishop of Rome is the sole Vicar of Christ , the Infallible and only Judge of Controversies , and the Supream Head of the Vniversal Church ; and hereby their Adherents are awed into the retaining all his Decrees of what nature soever they be : But let me beg leave to advise you not to lay so much stress upon these Titles and Authority , till you have seriously examined by what Right the Pope laies claim to them ; for his Power had need be very great and his Proofs very good , upon the Credit whereof you receive so many new and suspicious Articles of Religion , some of which we ought not to receive though preached by an Angel : Gal. 1. 8 , 9. And first , though we stand not much upon Titles , you may note that the name of Vicar of Christ is never given to the Pope in the first Ages , and when this Title came into use , it was not appropriated to the Bishop of Rome , but other Bishops and Priests are styled Vicars of Christ also , even by a Pope of Rome g , as also by the Old French Emperours h , and by our own Saxon Law i : So that there is no reason for the Roman Bishop to challenge any propriety in this Title , or any special Priviledge by virtue thereof . Secondly , As to his being an Infallible Judge and the Supream Head of the Catholick Church throughout the World , you may remember we have proved , there are more Christians in the World who deny this Supremacy of Rome , than there are who do acknowledge it : And if the belief of this Infallible Headship be the reason why you receive other Articles of Faith , this then is the most fundamental Article of all others , and ought to be the best attested : And if our Lord Jesus had designed to make S. Peter and his Successors at Rome ( not at Antioch ) such Supream Infallible Judges , we may expect he would have set down this Article plainly in Holy Scripture , and not have left his sole visible Vice-gerent to the suspicion of bearing witness to himself . As for that place Matth. xvi . Thou art Peter , and upon this Rock will I build my Church : it is indeed by the Popes in their Forged Decretals expounded as a confirmation of their pretences to Supremacy ; but the Fathers take this Rock , not for S. Peter's Person , but for his Faith which he confessed , and for Christ himself the Object thereof : So S. Augustine k , Nazianzen l , S. Cyril m , S. Chrysostome n , S. Ambrose o , and Hilary p , expound the place ; and if so , this belongs no more to S. Peter , than to the rest of the Apostles who confessed the same Faith , and belongs no otherwise to the Pope , than as he varies not from S. Peter's Faith , and so far it belongs to all Orthodox Bishops with respect to their several Churches : And for the Keys of the kingdom of Heaven , ver . 19. they were given as much to the other Apostles as to S. Peter , Matth. xviii . 18. ( as also the aforesaid Fathers do observe ) being all equally sharers in the Power of the Keys , and all Foundations as well as S. Peter q , so that S. Cyprian plainly tells us , The rest of the Apostles were as great as Peter , endowed with an equal share of Honour and Power r ; Nor do we find that ever S. Peter pretended to any Power over the other Apostles . Peter , James and John , though preferred by Christ ( saith Eusebius ) before the rest , challenged not to themselves the glory of Primacy , but chose James the Just , Bishop of the Apostles s : And if any were greatest it was S. James , who was President in that first Council at Jerusalem , and did determine the Question there , though S. Peter was present t . Yea , Clemens Bishop of Rome in the first Decretal Epistle ( a good evidence against the Inventors thereof ) styles this very S. James , Bishop of Bishops , governing the Holy Church of the Hebrews at Jerusalem , and also all the Churches , which were every where founded by the Providence of God u . And an Ancient Council calls Jerusalem the Mother of all Churches w ; but as for the Primacy of Rome , there is no genuine Author for the first Three Centuries takes any notice of it , and Aeneas Sylvius * afterwards Pope confesseth , There was little respect paid to Rome before the Nicene Council : If Polycrates and the Asian Bishops had known of this Infallibility and Supremacy , they would not have opposed Pope Victor's Opinion , nor despised his Excommunication so boldly as they did ; neither would Irenaeus ( who calls the Bishops of Rome no more but Presbyters ) have presumed to reprove the same Victor for his arrogance and indiscretion , as we find he did x . S. Cyprian ▪ surely never heard of this Power of the Roman Bishop , who calls Cornelius Bishop of that See , no more but Brother and Colleague , and gives to Pope Stephen his Successor at Rome , the Titles of False Apostle , Schismatick , friend to Hereticks , and enemy to Christians : utterly despising his Judgment , and not regarding his Determinations y . Besides , if this Supremacy had been believed in the first Ages of the Church , the Roman Bishops sense would have been enquired of concerning all controverted places of Scripture , his Decrees cited to silence Hereticks , and all Appeals must have been made finally to him : He also should have called and presided in all eminent Councils , whereas Cardinal Cusanus affirms , That the Emperours or their Deputies were Presidents in Eight General Councils z Nor did the Fourth General Council at Chalcedon suppose that the Roman Bishop had any Supremacy given him from Christ , when that Council saith , Rome hath justly had the Priviledges given unto it by the Fathers , because it was the Seat of the Empire ; and for the same Reason ▪ they grant equal Priviledges to the Bishop of Constantinople a . Yea , S. Gregory Bishop of Rome saith , The Fathers of the Council of Chalcedon were they who offered his Predecessors the Title of Universal Bishop , which yet they accepted not b : And to convince us that this Vniversal Supremacy is a late Device , it is evident , that it was not only unknown to others in the first Age , but to the very Popes themselves , as these few Instances will shew : Liberius Bishop of Rome An. 350. sending the Confession of his Faith to Athanasius desireth his Approbation thereof , That I may know ( saith he ) whether I am of the same Judgment with you in matters of Faith , and that I may be more certain , and readily obey your commands c . And when the Bishop of Constantinople began to call himself Vniversal Bishop , Pope Gregory in his Epistle to Mauritius the Emperour saith , He admires at the Arrogance of assuming this New Title , which none of the Bishops of Rome had ever accepted of , a Title blasphemous to Christian Ears ; and with many other words he inveighs against this Title , as unfit for any Christian Bishop , as may be seen at large in his Epistles d . And in his Epistle to Eulogius Patriarch of Alexandria he is displeased that Eulogius writes to him by the proud Title of Universal Bishop , desiring him wholly to forbear that language , for ( saith he ) That is a diminution to you , which is afforded to another beyond what reason doth require : And he there tells Eulegius , That the Council of Chalcedon had offered this Title to the Old Bishops of Rome , but they would not accept it e : Of which he gives this Reason in another Epistle , — Because if one Patriarch be called Universal , the name of Patriarch is taken from the rest f . And so little did Pope Boniface think of deriving his Supremacy from Christ , that with intreaty he obtained of the intruding Emperour Phocas to decree , That the Roman Church should be Head of all Churches g , as the Ancient Historians witness h . But this Imperial Constitution will scarce justifie the Supremacy and Jurisdiction which the Pope now claimeth over all the World , and it utterly destroys the pretences of a Divine Right to it . It would be too tedious to relate at large all the steps by which the Bishops of Rome attained to their present Grandeur ; I shall therefore only note , that the first Ages began early to complain of his Encroachments and Ambition i ; and all succeeding Times frequently opposed the Pope's Pretences herein ; The Sixth Council of Carthage allowed not his claim of Appeals k . The Bishops of France complain of his sending a Legate to Dedicate a Church there , as an undue Act , contrary to the Ancient Canons and all Primitive Constitutions , For though ( saith the Historian ) the Bishop of Rome for the dignity of his Apostolical Seat , be more venerable than other Bishops , yet it is not lawful for him in any thing to transgress the Tenor of Canonical rules ; and as every Bishop of the Orthodox Church is the Spouse of his own See , and represents the person of our Saviour , so it cannot agree to any Bishop , boldly to act any thing in the Diocess of another l ; the like checks the Popes frequently received for medling in France , from the Princes of that Nation m . About that Time also the Bishops of Italy complained of the Roman Vsurpation to the Patriarch of Constantinople , as appears by Photius's Letter , in answer to that complaint , extant in Cardin. Baronius n . And there are many like Examples in the Historians of those Ages , wherein this bold Jurisdiction began first to be exercisedin this Western part of Europe o . And to this very day the Churches of France do little value the Pope's Supremacy , though in other Opinions they agree with the Roman Church , as may be seen in the French Writers p . And it is not long since the King of France was about to take away his Nations dependence from Rome , by erecting the Archbishoprick of Burges into a Patriarchate . And now , why should you be awed into the belief of Evil and inconvenient Doctrines by a pretended Supremacy , not given by Christ , not challenged by the best Popes , not acknowledged by the first Christians , not much regarded by some Catholick Countries ? Why should you be enslaved by an Authority gained by fraud and policy , confirmed by force and cruelty , enlarged by dividing Christian Princes , by the undermining the Empire and oppressing many Ecclesiastical and Temporal persons in their just Rights ? Why should you fear to renounce an Usurped Jurisdiction , since what is unjustly seized on at first , can never be legally enjoyed , nor is it confirmed by the longest prescription of Time q , as the Civil Law speaks ? I must confess I cannot see that any Christians without the Pale of his own Diocess , are obliged to own him further than by the respect due to a Bishop of an Ancient Patriarchal See , nor so far neither if he be not content with his own , and keep not close to the Primitive Faith. SECTION VI. Whether the Pope hath any Right to exercise a Jurisdiction over England . BUt since my Discourse is directed particularly to the Catholicks of England , it will be most considerable to enquire , Whether the Roman Bishop can justly claim any Authority over them ? and ( if Prejudices were laid aside ) I doubt not but to make it evident , that the Pope neither hath nor ought to have any Authority over this Nation . For first , let it be considered that Britain was the first of the Provinces which did publickly profess the Faith of Christ , saith Sabellicus r , which is also attested by other more Ancient Writers s . So that it is agreed on all hands , here was a true and perfect Church of Christ near five hundred years before they had any Communication with the Bishop of Rome , or knew one syllable of this foundation-Article of the Modern Faith of that Church , viz. of the Pope ' s Vniversal Supremacy : It is also certain the Church of Britain was not subject to Rome at the time of the First General Council at Nice ; And in the Sixth Canon of that Council it is decreed concerning the three Patriarchs Jurisdictions , That the Ancient custom should be established , that Aegypt , Lybia and Pentapolis should be subject to the Bishop of Alexandria , because the Bishop of Rome had the like Custome , and likewise so it was at Antioch , and in other Provinces the Priviledges should be preserved to their Churches , &c. t . Now the Ancient Custom and Priviledge of this Church of Britain then was to govern it self without subjection to any Forreign Patriarch , and the Pope could not usurp any Dominion here afterwards without transgressing this Canon of the most famous General Council ; especially if we consider how this Canon was expounded in Ruffinus's daies , viz. That Rome should have the Government of the Suburbicarian Churches u . And the Ancient Survey of the Imperial Provinces will tell you what the Suburbicarian Region was , viz. Three Islands , Sicily , Sardinia and Corsica , and part of Italy , from the East end to the border of Tuscany Westward : And this was all the Ancient extent of the Roman Bishops Jurisdiction , the rest of Italy being under the Metropolis of Millain , which Church of Old paid no Subjection to Rome ; much less could any be due to him from Britain . Again , in the Third General Council of Ephesus An. 431. it was decreed , That in all Dioceses and Provinces it should hereafter be observed , That no Bishop should henceforward lay hold of another Province , which had not formerly and from the beginning been under the power of their Predecessors w , which Canon the Pope must break also , before he can assume a power over the Church of Britain , which , with the Island of Cyprus and some other places , was its own head ( as those Times phrased it ) and subject to no Patriarch : So that when Augustine the Monk ( coming over to convert the Pagan Saxons ) required the British Bishops to profess Subjection to the See of Rome ; They did by virtue of these Canons refuse it , telling him , They had a Patriarch of their own , to whom alone they were subject in Spiritual things under God , and Dionothus Abbot of Bangor by divers Arguments shewed , they owed no Subjection to the Roman Bishop : as an Old Historian informs us x . And accordingly the British Bishops retained their Old Rites different from Rome , and kept their Old Priviledges , being consecrated by the Archbishop of S. Davids , and he by his own Suffragans , making no Profession of Subjection to any other Church ( saith their Historian y , which continued till the day of King Henry the First . The Saxons indeed shewed more Respect to Rome , because it had assisted in their Conversion , hence they sometimes asked Advice of the Pope , as of an Eminent neighbour Patriarch , but their Bishops never professed Subjection to Rome , nor did they own his Supremacy , or look on him as an Infallible Judge , as appears by their not obeying the Pope's Decree made in a Roman Council , about restoring Wilfrid to his Archbishoprick of York An. 680. And though the Pope had confirmed and recommended the Canons of the Second Nicene Council about Images , the English Church rejected and despised them , writing a Book to condemn Image-worship , in the name of all the Princes and Bishops of England , and sending it to Charles the Great of France , by the learned Alcuinus , as our Histories do attest z And moreover it is evident that all Ecclesiastical Laws were then made by the Saxon Kings and Bishops , . in their Provincial Councils , by their own Authority , without ever so much as acquainting the Pope therewith , or desiring his consent thereto , or confirmation thereof : The Popes indeed about the latter end of the Saxon times began to degenerate in Manners , and aim at high things in all the Western world ; but his Pride was checked here , even as ( as we shewed before ) it was in other places : for when that Insolent Pope Hildebrand ( who first presumed to depose an Emperour a ) took the boldness to require Fealty of King William the Conqueror , he answered him in this manner , Fealty I neither have acknowledged , nor will I do it , because neither did I promise it , nor do I find that my Predecessors ever did it to your Predecessors , as appears by the Conqueror's Letter still extant b . And when by Policy and evil Arts he had made some encroachments here , yet still his Power was esteemed no other than a Temporal Power , permitted by the favour of our Kings , not due by any Original Right : Hence the Historian saith , That King Henry the First having subdued all his Enemies , feared none but the Pope , and that not for his Spiritual , but his Temporal Power c . And an Old Record affirms that King Henry the Second smartly asked the Bishop of Chichester , How he durst argue for the Pope ' s Authority which was granted by Men , against his Royal Power derived from God d ? The turbulent and seditious Attempts of T. Becket and his faction about that time , to subject the English Clergy to the Pope's Vniversal Supremacy , are sufficiently known ; but if our Ancestors ( whom you call Roman Catholicks ) had been of your Opinion in this great Article of Faith , they would not have made so stout an Opposition against the Pope's Supremacy as they did : It being apparent that the whole body of the Nation then looked on it as an Encroachment and an Vsurpation ; for in the famous Statutes of Clarendon they condemn it , Decreeing ▪ among other things , That all the Clergy should bonâ fide , swear to the King ; and none should Appeal , but unto the Archbishop , or from him finally to the King , without particular License e . And to restrain his medling here , the Kings of England declared , they had a Right to forbid the Pope's Legates from entring into this Land , and often did prohibite them ( even Qu. Mary her self exercising this Power ) yea , it was adjudged in a Parliament 25 Ed. 3. To be Treason to bring in the Pope's Bulls here without the Kings consent , Stat. de Provisor . though the sending these be an Act of Spiritual Jurisdiction ; but it is plain they would not allow the Pope in those days to exercise Spiritual Jurisdiction here without the King's leave , for his very Excommunicating certain English Bishops in a Parliament 16 of Rich. 2. is declared to tend To the open disherison of the Crown , and the destruction of the King , his Law , and all his Realms , and a little after it is affirmed there , that the Popes attempts be clearly against the Kings Crown and Regality , used and approved in the time of all his Progenitors f , finally therefore they all promise to stand with the King against all such Encroachments with their very lives : And if you be well versed ( as becometh English-men ) in the Histories and Statutes of your own Country ; you must needs know that the Authority which the Pope once exercised here , was gotten by taking advantages of the necessities of our Kings , and the divisions among the People . And in those Times which are accounted most Popish , it was checked by Laws , complained of in Parliament , and thought an Oppression by the wisest and greatest Subjects , so that the most Noble Hen. de Lacy Earl of Lincoln , in his dying Speech ( to his Son in Law Thomas Earl of Lancaster ) said among other things , That the Church of England heretofore Honourable and Free , was now enslaved by Romish Oppressions : charging him , to stand up like a man for the Honour of God and the Church , and the Redemption of his Country g . And the same Author tells us , that it was debated in a Council at London An. 1408. Whether all Payments and Obedience to the Pope should not be taken away h ? Which shews , they thought it in the power of this Nation to take away his Authority here when they pleased : And they retained it , not as being necessarily or originally due to him , but only in respect of his being a Bishop of an Ancient Apostolical Seat , as is evident from those Instructions which King Henry the Fifth gave to his Embassadors , sent to Pope Martin the Fifth , bidding them ( if they perceived any delay in their affair ) to tell the Pope , That their Master the King , if he yielded not to his Demands , would use his own power in these Particulars , for he did not apply himself to Rome out of necessity , but for Respect sake i . And therefore when this permissive Authority grew uneasie to those who had endured it for some time , it was rejected much more Legally than ever it was introduced , viz. by the Regal Power with the advice and consent of the Lords and Commons in Parliament * . And this is to be noted , the Clergy and Laity of this Parliament did hold most of the Opinions of the Roman Church in other things , and yet consented to the abolishing the Pope's Vsurped Power over England , as believing it to be an unjust Encroachment : And Stephen Gardiner Bishop of Winchester ( a great Persecutor of the Protestants ) did then make a learned Oration De verâ obedientiâ , shewing that the King was by Right and by God's Law the Supream Head of this Church of England . And now , that I may not only confute a false Opinion ▪ but establish the true , let me intreat you impartially to consider , that as it appears the Pope is not Dejure supream Head of this Church of England , so it is as evident , that the King of England is the Supream Head of the Churches in his own Dominions : For indeed all Christian Princes are , or ought to be so in their own Dominions ; whence it was that Constantine the Great did retain the Title of Pontifex Maximus without any blot to his Christianity , saith Baronius k . And the highest Appeals in all Controversies Ecclesiastical , even in matters of Faith , were made to him , though he used the assistance and Counsel of his Bishops , for determining them . And it is evident that he and his Successors ( as Cusanus before confesseth ) did call and Preside in all General Councils , and ratified their Decrees , which were no Laws till they were stamped with the Imperial Authority : yea , the Imperial Code sufficiently witnesses , that the Emperour 's made Laws concerning Religion , the whole Third book of Justinian's Basilicks being nothing else but Imperial Constitutions , de Episcopis , Clericis & Sacris : They also erected Patriarchates , and gave them supream Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction over such Provinces as they pleased , as at Justinianopolis in Daeia l , and at Ravenna in Italy it self m , which had no dependence on Rome till the time of Constantinus Pogon : And all Ecclesiastical affairs depended on the Emperors , saith Socrates n , so that Pope Anastasius calls the Emperor Anastasius , The Vicar of God by the Divine command presiding over the Earth o . An Authority like this also was exercised by the Western Emperors of the French Line , being stayled , The Rulers of the True Religion , a Title given to Charles the Great and to Ludovicus by two several Councils which they had called p ; and the present French Kings do claim the Supremacy over the French Churches , as may be seen in ●●ohellus and P. Pith●us cited before , Sect. 5. One of the French Writers telling us it is the Opinion of his Nation , that Le Royiassisté de son Conseil d'estate est ●●●es Di●● Chief Terrie● de l'Eglise de son Royanme & 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Pape q . And it may be proved concerning other Christian Princes , that they allow not the Pope to impose his Decrees on their Kingdoms , nor to exercise any Jurisdiction among them but by their special License and consent , and prohibite his exercising any power over their Subjects when they please : And why may not the King of England , being a free and absolute Monarch , be allowed as great a Priviledge in his own Dominions ? Do you not tell us ; that Pope Eleutherius called King Lucius by the Title of Vicar of Christ r ; and doth not King Edgar call himself Christs Vicar s , and none taxed this Title then ? Did not the Saxon Kings preside in all National Councils , and make Laws for Religion by the advice of their own Bishops , by their own Authority ? Did they not erect new Sees for Bishops , and change them as they saw fit ? Did they not invest all Bishops by delivering the Ring and Pastoral Staff t ? And the same power was still exercised by K. William the Conqueror , for all things both Divine and Humane depended on his Order , saith an Old Historian u . And when the Pope began to encroach upon the King's Supremacy here in England , he was generally opposed as we noted before . And in the aforesaid Parliament of Richard the Second , the Nation declared , That they would not endure that the Crown of England should be submitted to the Pope , and the Laws and Statutes of this Realm by him defeated and avoided at his pleasure w : for Bracton our most famous Lawyer affirms , that The Kings of England have no Supream on earth but God : And accordingly the Kings and Parliaments of this Nation made Laws in reference to Religion as they saw expedient , and among the rest they enacted many Laws in a direct opposition to the Pope's Spiritual as well as Temporal Jurisdiction , declaring thereby , that they esteemed him no Head of this Church , but an ambitious and dangerous Encroacher upon the Rights of the Crown , as you will find by perusal of those several Statutes cited in the Margin x . By which Laws long since enacted , it is declared to be Treason to receive or harbour any Agents or Emissaries from Rome against the King's Proclamations , and without his special License : Upon all which Considerations the Judges have declared , that the Act of Parliament for Restoring the Supremacy over the Church unto the Crown , was not the introducing a New Law , but a declaration of the Old y : For it was many hundred years before , that King Henry the Second did declare , That be would account it high Treason in any man , that should affirm the Pope's Authority was above his z . And before that , Anselm was told , That it was impossible for him to keep the Faith which he owed to the King ; and to pay Obedience to the Pope contrary to his Royal Pleasure b . Which ( methinks ) may fitly admonish you who do own the Pope's Supremacy over England , and yet glory much in your Loyalty to the King ; to enquire how these two can stand together ? Our Saviour saith , No mancan serve two Masters , Matth. vi . 24. however not two Supream Lords , neither can there be two highest Powers in one Kingdom , nor can any Subjects obey both , since they will sometimes command contrary things : 'T is true , if the Roman Bishop would profess to our King , as his Predecessor Leo the Fourth did to Lotharius of France , Concerning your Capitulars or Imperial Precepts , we through the assistance of Christ promise as much as we are able , to keep and conserve the same for ever c . If he would acknowledge himself subject to our King in his Dominions , as his Predecessors were to the Emperours of Old ; if he behaved himself toward his Majesty , as S. Gregory did to Mauritius , who calls that Emperour , his Lord , and himself , his Servant ; declaring , that He was subject to the Emperours Commands , and accordingly had done his duty in publishing a Law ( which the Emperour ordered him to promulge ) though for his own part he thought it not agreeable to the Laws of God d . If the present Popes claimed no more than a Primacy of order and precedency among other Bishops , then the case might easily be determined : But you know of later times the pretences of Rome are much higher , for she challenges a Supremacy over all Christian Princes , a power to depose them , an Authority to abrogate or dispense with their Laws , and absolve their Subjects from their Allegiance , a Priviledge to be appealed unto as to the last and highest Tribunal on Earth ▪ so that Clement the Fifth is recorded in the Acts of the Council of Vienna to have said , That all the Right of Kings depended on him alone e ; and Boniface the Eighth owned himself not only Lord of France , but of all the World f , for So great was the Impudence of this Boniface ( saith the French Chronologer ) that he presumed to affirm the Kingdom of France was a Fee of the Papal Majesty g . And as to this Kingdom , Pope Innocent the Fourth saith , That the King of England was his Vassal and his Slave h , and they esteem England also a Fee of the Papacy , and so is Ireland too it seems . Whereupon the Pope hath dared to nominate a King of Ireland , and hath given away the Kingdom of England to those who attempted to conquer it ; he hath condemned our Laws , and ▪ absolved the Subjects of England from their Allegiance , upon which many of your Party have entred into Conspiracies and Rebellion : So that now it appears , the Pope claims an Absolute Supremacy over our King and his Realms , and how he can be a good Subject of the King of England , who professes Obedience to this Forreign Princely Prelate , is very hard to be understood : if you believe this claim , and own the Pope to be above the King , you must then obey him , even when his Orders contradict those of your lawful Sovereign , and so you are the Pope's Subjects , not the King 's ; nor can his Majesty have any security of your Allegiance , any longer than he pleases the Roman Bishop , so that he Reigns over you at the Pope's mercy . I know many of you English Catholicks have so Loyal an affection for the King , that your Church-men are forced to invent many plausible pretences to perswade you , that the Supremacy claimed by the Pope doth not entrench upon the King's Supremacy , telling you , that you need not obey the Pope if he commanded you to fight against your King ; wherein they put a fallacy upon you , for they know the Pope can Excommunicate and depose him ( even for a very small matter , say your Canonists i ) , and then he is no longer Your King : They pretend further this Supremacy over Kings in Temporals is not the Doctrine of your Church , but only of some Jesuites , upon whom they lay all those foul . Doctrines of Deposing and murthering Kings , so wickedly maintained by divers eminent Writers of your Church k . But this is a delusion also , for when or where did the Pope , or the Heads of the Roman Church , condemn these Opinions , or suppress these Seditious Books , nay , on the contrary , the Books are approved and the Authors preferred at Rome , even when France condemns them l : And those honest and loyal secular English Priests that have ventured to write against this usurped Power of the Popes over Kings in Temporals ( though they held his Supremacy here in Spirituals ) have been persecuted almost to death by the Roman Bishop ; they have been suspended , and their Books condemned , and their persons so odiously represented that no English Catholicks durst harbour them ; witness the learned F. Preston under the name of Roger Widrington in King James's days , with his fellow-Priests , and Peter Walsh Author of the Letter to the Catholicks , who is at this day a great Sufferer by the Pope's means , meerly for writing , that you of the Roman Church ought to be Loyal to the King in all matters of Temporal cognizance ; a clear evidence , that ( whatever your Church may pretend ) they will not endure that any of you Catholicks shall hold the King's power to be above the Pope's in any thing ; and consequently they will not allow you to be good Subjects . Now to sum up all these particulars , how grievous an abuse is it ▪ for a Forreign Prelate , whose Predecessors had no Authority here at all , to usurp such a power over you as to impose New and inexpedient Articles upon you ? Why should you enslave your selves to him that cannot have so much as a Spiritual Jurisdiction here without breaking the Canons of the most famous General Councils ? Why may ▪ you not take the same liberty to oppose his Decrees , that your Ancestors in all Ages have done ? they whom you account good Catholicks rejected his Doctrines sometimes , despised his Bulls and Excommunications frequently , and always opposed his pretended claim of a Supremacy over this Nation ; why should you call that an Article of Faith , and account it the Principal point of Religion , viz. That England ought to be subject to Rome ; which even in those you call Catholick Times was declared to be no less than Treason , and no other than an Opinion that did destroy the Prerogative of the King , the Priviledges and Liberties of this Church , the freedom and quiet of all English Subjects ? They were Romanists in other Points who condemned Appeals to Rome , and maintained , that the Crown of England was in no Earthly subjection , and that the King had no Supream but God only ; who counted all the Power which the Pope ever had here , meerly permissive , tolerated by this Nation so long as they pleased , and such as might be curbed , lessened , hindred or taken away by the Supream Authority of this Nation when ever they saw expedient : It was a King and Parliament of your Religion in most points , that restored the King to his just Supremacy , and took away the precarious or usurped and much abused Power of the Roman Bishop here ; they thought a Supremacy in Spirituals , as to this Kingdom , was more than he had any Right to , but he and his Agents expect to be allowed to over-rule the Temporal Laws also ; methinks , if you have the Nobleness and Gallantry of true English spirits , your affections for the Roman Church should not rob you of your love to your Native Country , nor suffer you to endure those pretences which dishonour the King , and despoil him of his Ancient Rights , and enslave this free Church and Nation to one that only seeks his own ends in claiming this Subjection ; for though the holding the Pope's Supremacy doth contribute to the support of his own Grandeur , yet it doth not further any mans Salvation , and it is so far from doing any good in those Nations where it is allowed him , that it might be made appear , the setting up and abetting this Supremacy hath occasioned the murther of many Princes , stirred up the complaints of all sorts of people , and filled Christendom for many Ages , with Massacres , Treasons , War and Bloodshed l ; which was so notorious in the German Empire , that it came to be a Proverb saith Guiccardine , It is the property of the Church to hate the Caesars : And the mischief it hath done in England ( by rifling the Nations wealth before the Reformation , and disturbing its Quiet since ) is so well remembred and so deeply resented , by the generality of the people , that they will never endure that heavy Yoak any more , nor can they be perswaded scarce ever to esteem them Loyal Subjects or true to their Countries Interest , who do not renounce this unjust and odious Jurisdiction . Why therefore ( O my Friends ) will you be so imprudent , to oppose the Rights and Prerogative of your Lawful Sovereign , the Priviledges of that Church wherein you were born , the Freedom and Interest of your beloved Country , the desire of your fellow-Subjects and best Friends , yea , and your own liberty also ? Why will you oppose ( I say ) all these , meerly to support an unjust and groundless Power , which no Ecclesiastick ought to have any where , much less in so remote and so free a Monarchy ? to support a Power which is inconsistent with the Security of the Crown , the Peace of the Kingdom , and the welfare of Private persons ? S. Peter never bid any to honour his Successor the Pope thus , but his Opinion was , that you must submit to the King as Supream , 1 Pet. ii . 13. and his Counsel follows thereupon , viz. that you should Fear God and Honour the King , ver . 17. S. Paul commands Every Soul to be subject to the Higher Powers , Rom. xiii . 1. Neither Bishops nor Apostles themselves are excepted , saith S. Chrysostome . And S. Bernard tells Pope Eugenius , that the Apostles were forbid to exercise Dominion , Luke xxii . 25 , 26. and therefore he adds , If you would have Apostolical and Royal Power together you lose both m . Finally therefore , it is unreasonable for the Roman Bishop to challenge such Authority here , and the Laws of God and Man forbid it , so that I may expect you shall be so far from receiving any Articles for the sake of this Authority , that you shall not scruple to renounce the Authority it self , which was so ill-gotten at first , so wretchedly abused while it did obtain , and so legally taken away at last ; and in so doing you will demonstrate your selves to be Loyal to your King , Faithful to your Country , Friends to your own Liberty , and men of an un-inslaved Understanding . SECTION VII . Advice to the English Catholicks to forsake the Opinions of Rome and embrace the Religion of the Church of England . TO Conclude , as my pity to see you so miserably imposed on , hath moved me to endeavour by these plain and Cogent Arguments to rescue you from that yoke , which neither we nor our Fathers were able to bear ; So my desire of your perfect Freedom , and my unfeigned wishes for your Temporal , Spiritual and Eternal welfare , do prompt me to advise you to comply with the Religion of the Church of England , and this Advice is not only grounded upon the foregoing considerations , but may be further pressed upon these motives : 1. If you consider the excellent method of our Reformation which was so necessary at that time , that for some Ages before , the wisest and best men of the Roman Church had not only confessed there was great need of it , but had complained for want thereof , and pressed the Pope earnestly thereunto , witness the Judicious Epistle of Rob. Grosthead that pious Bish . of Lincoln , to Pope Innocent the Fourth , yet to be seen in our Historians n ; the publick complaint of the English Church in the Council of Lyons o ; the private Writings of John Gerson , Nich. Clemangis , Aeneas Sylvius ( afterwards Pope ) and many others : And at least One Hundred Years before Luthers time a Reformation was urged for , in the Pisane Council p and that so strongly , that before the Election of a Pope , the Cardinals solemnly promised , Who ever of them should be chosen Pope , that he would before the dissolution of that Council Reform the Catholick Church as well in the Head as the Members q . And when Alexander the Fifth was chosen , He promised to take Care of a General Reformation , and that pious and Learned Men should be chosen in every Nation to treat with the Cardinals about it r : But after all , neither he nor his Successors would ever Reform either their Doctrines or Practices , being more intent upon their private advantage , than the general good , and more moved with Cardinal Scombergs Counsel , than by all the former complaints , who told the Pope , That by the Reformation it would be confessed that the things provided against , were deservedly reproved by the Lutherans , which would be a great abetting to their whole Doctrine , Hist . Counc . Trent . l. 1. p. 83. which is to resolve to Err always , rather than to be thought to have once erred ; and herein the Roman Church is of the same humour with those Gentiles to whom Arnobius speaks , What you have once done without reason , ye defend lest you should seem formerly to have been ignorant , and you account it better not to be overcome , than to yield to plain and confessed Truth s . Wherefore since Rome resolved not to Reform , England ( having first restored her King to his Ancient and just Supremacy ) resolved to reform it self , without the Popes leave or consent , knowing full well they had Authority sufficient among themselves to order the Affairs of Religion , which had been Regulated many Hundred years in this Land by the King and his own Bishops , without any dependence on the Pope at all : Thus the Kings of Judah reformed their Kingdoms of Old , Thus the King of Spain with Leander Bishop of Sevil reformed that Kingdom from Arianism without the Pope t and thus King Edgar intended to proceed in the Reformation of the English Church of Old when he told his own Clergy , I have Constantines Sword in my hands , and you have Peters in yours u That is , we need no further Authority or power to reform , Than what we have within our selves : The Kings of this Nation , with the advice and consent of their Bishops , Barons and Commons had been always wont to order Ecclesiastical affairs as they thought meet , not heeding whether the Pope were pleased or displeased thereat ; And accordingly this happy Reformation was made by the Supreme Power of this Kingdom , upon mature deliberation , in a Regular , Orderly , and Legal way ; and it was managed with so much moderation and prudence , that the Romanists of England said little against it , but Communicated with this Church ( after the Reformation ) till the Pope for his own ends forbid them so to do ; but I hope his Prohibition without any just reason , shall not outweigh the Supreme Authority of your own Nation , with you , who profess your selves to be Loyal Subjects , and for the interest of England ; and since there was such need of Reformation , such obstinacy in Rome , such Authority here , and so orderly proceedings in this Reformation , I think all Good Christians and sober men , being Natives of this Land , ought to submit unto it . II. You will be further perswaded hereunto , by considering the Doctrine of this Church , which agrees with Primitive Christianity , in that it obliges you to believe nothing as of necessity to Salvation , but what may be plainly proved our of Holy Scripture , and for this reason you must still hold the three Creeds of the Apostles , of Nice , and of Saint Athanasius , all which the Church of England intirely believes . And he only is a Heretick which follows not this Holy Rule ( say the Constitutions of Theodosius and Gratian ) but they are Catholicks that embrace it : In this Church we give as much honour to , and obey more Canons of , the first Four General Councils , than they of Rome do ; we approve of that Exposition of Scripture which hath the consent of the Fathers of the first three or four Centuries , yea we hold all that the Church of Rome it self held as necessary to Salvation for Five or Six hundred Years together , and it is very remarkable that a Romanist may turn Protestant without adding any one Article to his Faith , but a Protestant cannot turn to Rome unless he embrace many new Articles ▪ for our Doctrines are generally confessed by both sides to be true , but those of the Roman Church are rejected by our Reformers , as Novel Additions , and such as have no good foundation in Scripture , nor Genuine Antiquity ▪ And therefore the Protestant Doctrines are the surer and safer , as in which both sides agree ; For Example , we and they both hold there are two States after this life , Heaven and Hell , but they add a third which is Purgatory , and this we deny : We and they both say , that sins are to be remitted by the merits of Christs death , but they add the merits of the Saints , and their own satisfactions with the merit of their own good works , which we deny to be Expiatory , or such as can merit Remission for us : We hold there be two Sacraments Baptism and the Eucharist , these they confess are the Chief , but add Five more , to which we affirm the name of Sacraments doth not properly belong : We say that God alone is to be worshipped , they confess he is chiefly to be worshipped ; but then they say the Blessed Virgin Mary , Angels , and Saints are to be worshipped also , which Additions we deny : We say Christ is our only Mediator and Advocate , they confess he is principally so , but add , that Saints and Angels are so in an inferiour manner , which we utterly deny : We say Christ is really present in the Sacrament of the Altar , this they confess , but add , he is corporally there by the Transsubstantiation of the Bread , &c. and this we deny : We say the Scriptures are the Rule of Faith , and they will not absolutely deny it , but add their own Traditions , which we reject : We say there are XXII . Books of the Old Testament Canonical , and they confess these all to be so , but they add divers , and call them Canonical , which we affirm to be Apocryphal ; I could give more instances , but these may suffice to shew that the Protestant Doctrines look most like the Ancientest , as being received by both Parties , but the Roman Opinions are Novel Enlargements of Old Catholick Truths , so that a Protestant becoming a Romanist must take up many Articles barely upon the credit of that Church , and begin to believe many things anew , questioned by the bigger part of Christendom ; but a Romanist turning Protestant retains all the Old Essentials of his former Faith ; and doth only become a Primitive Roman Catholick . III. The Discipline and Government of the Church of England are more agreeable to Primitive patterns than those of the present Roman Church are : Our King hath the same Power that the Religious Kings of Judah had , the same which the great Constantine , and the succeeding Emperors for many years enjoyed , the same power which the Ancient Kings of this Nation exercised , viz. A power to convene his Clergy and advise with them about affairs of the Church : A power to ratifie that which the Bishops and Clergy agree upon , and give it the force of a Law : A power to chuse fit persons to Govern the Church , A power to correct all Offenders against Faith or Manners , be they Clergy , or Lay-men : And finally , A power to determine all Causes and Controversies Ecclesiastical and Civil , among his own Subjects ( by the advice of fit Counsellors ) so as there lies no Appeal from his Determination ; and this is that we mean when we call him Supreme Governour of this Church , which our King must needs be , or else he cannot keep his Kingdoms in peace ; Besides for Spiritual Jurisdiction , and sacred Administrations , we have a Patriarch of our own , The Arch-Bishop of Canterbury Primate of all England , whom Vrban the Second call'd the Pope of the other World w And his See was usually styled , The Chair of the English Patriarch x and is reckoned among the Patriarchates by a Forreign Writer y . And now his Priviledges and Liberties are restored by Law , and his Title and Authority confirmed ; so that there lies no Appeal from him but to the King ; we have also Right Reverend Bishops , together with other inferiour Priests and Deacons ( the only Primitive and proper Orders of the Clergy ) who can prove their Ordination to be as goodas any of the Romish Priests can do z , And are now . Consecrated and Ordained by a more excellent Form , and more agreeing to the eldest times , than Rome it self can shew ; and if you will Judge impartially , it must be confessed that the Clergy of England are altogether as Learned , and generally more painful and pious than in any Catholick Country whatsoever : Our Canons for Ecclesiastical Government are all founded on the Canons of Ancient Councils ( as I could shew by particular induction , if time would permit ) and for the Exercise of our Discipline it is managed with more moderation , and ease to the People than that of the Roman Church is : IIII. You may consider our Divine Service and Sacred Administrations , which ( as far as ever God made necessary to Salvation ) may be had in this Church : We have the Holy Scriptures plainly translated , Learnedly interpreted , and practically Preached ; We have daily Prayers , by a Form so Grave and so Agreable to the undoubted parts of Ancient Liturgies , that it may challenge all Christendom to produce any thing so consonant to the purest Primitive Devotions ; A Form which hath all those parts of the Roman Offices which were known and used in the first three Centuries , but wants all the Innovations and Corruptions of the present Mass ; And is used in English for the benefit of the meanest Christian in our Assemblies : We have also those two Sacraments which Christ ordained ( and many of the Elder and Later Doctors own no more a ) . As for the other five Rites falsly called Sacraments , viz. Confirmation , Matrimony , Holy Orders , visiting of the Sick , Repentance and Satisfaction for wrongs done , we retain these , but not by the name of Sacraments , keeping the Primitive and main part of them , only attended with fewer Ceremonies : We press and practice also Charity and good works , as much as the Roman Church doth , and it may be demonstrated that more and greater gifts have been given in England to pious uses , by private persons since the Reformation , than in two Centuries before : And though we dare not say we shall merit Eternal life by them ( because that is the gift of God ) yet we believe none can come to Heaven without good works : In a word , the Church of England worships God as he hath prescribed in Holy Scripture , She commands all that he enjoyns , and forbids all that he prohibits , and therefore wanteth nothing that is necessary to Salvation . V. You may look upon our Ceremonies which are few and easie , Ancient and Significant , and though we do not place so much Religion in Externals as the Church of Rome doth , yet here is prescribed all that is needful for decency and order , viz. That the Clergy always wear Grave and distinct habits , and have peculiar Garments in Divine Administrations , that Churches be adorned and neat , that the People be Reverent in Gods House , that the memory of our Saviours chief Acts , and the Festivals of the Holy Apostles be religiously observed ; That Lent , with the Vigils of great Feasts , the Ember weeks , and all the Fridays in the Year , be kept as days of Fasting or Abstinence , and if some Protestants do not observe them , yet others do , and are commended for it , and you may follow the best , not the most : you will have more liberty ( by turning to the English Church ) as to Circumstantials , and greater helps as to the Essentials of Religion : So that it is upon all accounts your wisest and safest course to embrace this so true , so Primitive , so Pious , and so rational a Religion . Let me therefore shut up my Charitable and Friendly Advice by Requesting you to consider all these things without prejudice or passion , and then I hope you will perceive how much the Religion of this Church excells that of Rome , in Antiquity , Integrity , and Usefulness , and no longer suffer your selves to be so sadly imposed on , and so miserably made to serve the ends of Avarice and Ambition : And if you have taken such prudent and pious Resolutions , you shall not only be freed from the inconveniences you complain of here , but also have better assurances of your Salvation hereafter , than the Roman Church can give you ; For there you have only the words of their Priests for it , whose interest and whose practice it hath been to deceive you ; But here you shall have all the assurances which the word of God can give you , provided you become reformed in your lives as well as in your Religion , and will leave off your old Vices , as well as your old Opinions ; For unless we can perswade you to become Proselytes of Righteousness , we shall not much value the gaining you over to our Profession ; because we know it is neither the being Papist nor Protestant will save those that live in their sins ; But this Religion is the better chiefly in this , that it is most likely to bring you to unfeigned Repentance , and the practice of real Holiness . And if you desire further information in these particulars , let me advise you to consult the late Eminent Protestant Writers , together with some of the most able and ingenuous of the English Clergy , whom you will find very willing and ready to give you more full satisfaction , and to be men that have no designs upon you , but to direct you in the best way to Heaven : And doubtless , if you would but try the difference a while , a little experience would teach you how happy and advantagious a change he makes , who forsakes the Religion of Rome , and embraces the Communion of the Church of England . FINIS . A Catalogue of some Books Printed for , and sold by H. Brome , since the dreadful Fire of London , 1666. to 1677. Divinity . DR . Hammond on the New Testament , fol. — his Practical Tracts , fol. Mr. Farindons 130 Sermons , fol. Newman's Concordance , fol. Bishop Sanderson's Sermons , fol. Dr. Heylin on the Creed , fol. Bishop Taylor 's Cases of Conscience , fol. — His Polemical Discourses , fol. Mr. Cumber's Companion to the Temple , being a Paraphrase on the Common Prayer . Bishop Wilkins Principles and Duties of Natural Religion . Bishop Cosen's Devotions . Bishop Taylor 's Holy Living and Dying . Mr. Fowler 's Design of Christianity . Dr. Patrick's Witnesses to Christianity . — His Advice to a Friend in Two Vol. — His Christian Sacrifice . — His Devout Christian . Holy Anthems of the Church . The Saints Legacies . The Reformed Monastery , or the Love of Jesus . Bona's Guide to Eternity . Sermons . Dean Lloyd's Two Sermons at Court. Dr. Sprat's Sermon at Court. Bishop Lany's Sermon at Court. Mr. Sayer's Assize Sermon . Mr. Naylor's Con. Sermon for Col. Cavendish . Mr. Standish's Sermon at Court. Dr. Dupor●'s Three Sermons on May 29th . Novemb . 5th . Jan. 30th . Dr. Du Monlin's Two Sermons on Novemb. 5 th . — His Sermon at the Funeral of Dr. Turner . Histories . The Life of the great Duke of Espernon being the History of the Civil Wars of France , beginning 1598. where D'Avila leaves off , and ending in 1642. by Charles Cotton Esq ; The Commentary of M. Elaiz de Mon●●uc the great Favourite of France , in which are contained all the Sieges , Battails , Skirmishes , in Three King's Reigns by Charles Cotton Esq ; Mr. Rycants History of Turky . The History of the Three last Grand Seigniors , their Sultana's and Chief Favourites , Englisht by John Evelin Esq ; The History of Don Quixot , fol. Bishop Wilkin's Real Character fol. Bishop Cosens against Transubstantiation . Dr. Guidots History of Bathe , and of the Hot Waters there . The Fair one of Tunis , or a New piece of Gallantry , by Charles Cotton Esq ; Domus Carthusiana , ●or the History of the most Noble Foundation of the Coarter House in London , with the Life and Death of Thomas Su ton Esq ; The History of the Sevarites , a Nation inhabiting part of the third Continent . Physick . Dr. Glissonde Ventriculo & Intestinis . De Vita Naturae . Dr. Barber's Practice , with Dr. Decker's Notes . Sir Ken. Digby's Excellent Receipts in Physick , Chirurgery and Cockery . The Anatomy of the Elder Tree , with its approved Vertue . Miscellanies . Dr. Skinner's Lexicon . History of the Irish Remonstrance . Lord Bacon's Advancement of Learning . The Planters Manual . Treatise of Human Reason . The Compleat Gamester . Toleration discuss'd by R. L' Estrange Esq ; England ' s Improvement by R. Coke Esq ; Leyburn's Arith. Recreations . Geographical Cards describing all parts of the World. School Books . S●revelius Lexicon in Quarto . Centum Fabulae , in Octavo . Nolens Volens , or you shall make Latine . Radyns Rudimenta Artis Oratoriae . Pools Parnassus . The Schollars Guide from the Accedence to the University . Erasmus Coll. English . Lipsius of Constancy , English . Controversies . Considerations touching the true way to suppress Popery , to which is added an Historical account of the Reformation here in England . Lex Talionis , being an Answer to Naked Truth . The Papists Apology answered . A Seasonable Discourse against Popery . — The Defence of it . The difference between the Church and Court of Rome . Take heed of both extreams , Popery and Presbytery , by Mr. Bolein . Dr. Du Moulin against the Lord Castlemain . — Against Papal Tyranny . Fourteen Controversial Letters against Popery . Papists no Catholicks . Popery no Christianity . Mr. Gataker against the Papists . — A Calm Answer to a Violent Discourse of M. N. for the Invocation of Saints . Origo Protestanti●m : Or an Answer to a Popish Manuscript ( of N. N's . ) by John Shaw Rector of Whalton . Law Books . Lord Cokes Reports in Four Vol. Sir James Dyer's Reports . The Clerks Guide . The Exact Constable , with large Additions . FINIS . Notes, typically marginal, from the original text Notes for div A34067-e200 a 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ▪ apud Athenaeum . Notes for div A34067-e560 a Tertul. Apol. cap. 32. b Arrian . in Epict. l. 2. c. 14. c Diog. Laert . in Vit. Solon . Notes for div A34067-e890 a Cicer. de natur . Deor. lib. 2. b Theodoret. de Curand . Graec. affect . Serm. 1. c Tertul. in Marcio● . lib. 4. d Cyprian . ad Caecilian . Ep. 63. e Salmeron in 1 Tim. cap. 2. Lindan . Panop . l. 3. c. 5. Bannes 2. 2 ae qu. 1. Art. 10. conclus . 2. f Hugo Etherian . de regressu animae . g Durand . 4. Sent. dist . 20. qu. 3. Major . 4. d. 2. qu. 2. Cajetan . Opusc . 15. cap. 1. Antonin . part . 1. sum . tit . 10. cap. 3. h Fisher de Captiv . Babyl . c. 10. De Alliaco in 4. Sent. qu. 6. art . 1. Cajetan . ap . Suarez . Tom. 3. disp . 46. * Ranul . Higden Polychron , l. 6. c. 15. Petrus Damian . Vit. Odilon . i Clemangis de nov . Celebr . II. Polydor. Virgil de Invent. rer . l. 6. Aiala de Tradit . p. 2. c. de Imag. k Concil . secundum Nicaen . An. 787. l Hoveden Annal . Par. 1 ▪ p. 405. Matth. Westmon . Anno. 793. m Fish . in 18. Artic. Luther . n Scioppius de Indulg . cap. 12. o Platin. in Vit. Polyd. Virgil. de Invent. l. 8. cap. 1. p Temp. Bonifac . 8. An. 1300. Polyd. Virg. ut supra , l. 8. c. 1. q An. 1074. Matth. Westmon . eod . An. Vincent . Spec. hist . l. 24. c. 45. Antonin . lib. 16. cap. 1. §. 21. r Sigebert . Chron. ad A. 1074. s Histor. Petroburg . Anno 1127. ap . Spelm. T. 2. p. 36. t Concil . Later . Can. 21. An. 1215. u Peter Lomb. l. 4. sentent . dist . 77. Gratian. de Poenit. dist . 1. c. 89. circ . An. 1150 w Tho. Aqu. in 4. Sent. dist . 17. x Gregor . de Valent. de Transub . lib. 2. cap. 7. Cardin. Cusan . Exercit . l. 6. y Gelasius Pap. de secundis Naturis contra Eutych . z Ap. Suarez . Tom. 1. in Euch. disp . 7. a Scotus in 4. Sent. cap. II. qu. 3. Durand . in 4. Sent. dist . 10. qu. 1. n. 13. b An. 1415. c T. Aquin. in Johan . 6. Alphons . à Castro adv . haeres . lib. 6. d Bochell . de Decr. Eccles . Gallic . l. 5. tit . 20. e Gaii Epist . Decret . ad Felicem , ap . Binium T. 1. p. 173. f Gelas . de secundis Nat. contr . Eutych . g Grego . Mag. Epist . ad Maurit . lib. 2. Ep. 62. h Idem ad Theod . lib. 2. Ep. 65. i Idem . ad Eulog . lib. 7. Epist . 30. k Respons . ad Interrog . secundam Aug. Cantuariens . l Ad Seren. lib. 7. Epist . 109. m Greg. Mag. Expos . in Job . l. 19. c. 17. n Gloss . Ordin . An. 1200. in Praefat . de libris Canon . & non Canon . Biblia Complu tens . in Praef à Card. Ximenio approb . à Leone x. An. 1502. Biblia Vulg. Edit . Basil . cum Gloss . Ord. An. 1506. Biblia S. Pagnini & Birkmanni , & Vatabli per Rob. Stephan . A. 1541. o Cassander de Officio boni Viri . p Ambros . de Poenitent . lib. 1. cap. 6. q Lactant. Instit . lib. 4. cap. ult . r Brerewoods Enquir . of Langu . and Rel. s Sir Edwyn Sands Europ . Spec. p. 268 , 269 , &c. t Hieronym . Vitâ Malach. u Socrat. hist . lib. 7. c. 11. w Basil . Epist ▪ 10. & Baronius Tom. 4. An. 327. §. 32. x Ammian . Marcellin . hist . lib. 27. y Baron . Annal. Tom. 10. An. 912. §. 8. z Gerbert . Epist . 40. ad Stephanum Rom. Eccl. Diacon . a Sabellicus , Enne ad . 9. l. 2. b Genebrard . Chronolog . lib. 4. 10. Secul . init . c Aristot . Ethic . lib. 6. d Bernard . de Consid . l. 4. c. 2. e Hosp . de orig . Monach. l. 6. c. 66. f Cyril . Cateches . 4. p. 84. g Cicero de Natur. Deorum . l. 3. h Euseb . hist . lib. 5. c. 13. i Al. Hal. Par. 4. q 28. mem . 2. art . 2. Panorm . c. Omnis de poen . & rem . n. 24. D Soto de rat . deteg . Secr. mem . 3. q 4 ▪ k Bernard . de Consid . lib. 3. c. 4. l Antiq. Canterb . fol. 247. m Lassel's Vovage to Italy . n Polydor. Virgil . de Invent. l. 8. c. 1. o Vide , Taxam Camerae Apostol . Impress . Parisiis . p Matth. Paris . pag. 274. q L. Herbert . hist . Hen. 8th . p. 230. r Gregor , Magn. Respons . ad . Interrog . August Cant. 2. Pius 2. in G●stis Concil . Basil . s Panormitan . de Clericis conjug . Can. Cum Olim. t Deoret . P. Alex . l. 3. tit . 2. c. 3. u Gloss . ad Gratian . dist . 82. c. 5. x Ibid dist . 34. Can. 7. Costerus enchirid . de Coelibat . cap. 17. a Bern. de Convers . ad Cleric . cap. 29. b Gloss . ad Gratian . dist . 82 c. 5. c Matth. Paris . hist . An. 1234. d Decretal . Gregor . lib. 3. de Testam . tit . 26. cap. 7 , 9. e Europ . Specul . pag. 197. f Europ . Specul . pag. 198. g Antiquitat . Brittan p. 178. h Matth. Paris . pag. 667. & Epist . Anglor . ad Innocent . i Sarish . Polycraticon . lib. 5. qap. 16. k Sabellic . Enne . 9. lib. 1. ● ▪ l Baron . Annal. Tom. x. An. 900. §. 1. m Genebrard . Chron. lib. 4. ( n ) Praefatio R. Aluredi ad Pastoral . Gregorii . o Claud. Espen . Com. ad 2 Tim. 3. o Claud. Espen . Com. ad 2 Tim. 3. p Concil . Toletan . 4. c. 24. A. 633. q Sarisbur . Polycraticon . lib. 6. cap. 24. r 2 Tim. ii . 24 , 25. s Tertul. ad Scap. c. 2. Concil . Toletan . 4. cap. 56. t Gregorius M. Epist . ad Episc . Constantinop . u August . de Civit. Dei. l. 4. c. 27. w Idem , ibid. cap. 31. x Chrysost . de Sacerdotio , l. 4. y Gregor . Mag. hom . 4. z Augustin . de ver . Relig. cap. 24. Ferus Commentar . in lib. Judic . a Canus , Loc. Commun . lib. II cap. 6. b Idem ibid. c Harding against Jewels Apol. d Breviar . Rom. Fest . Nicol. 6. Dec. Fest . S. Blasii , Feb. 13. Fest . S. Alexii , Julii 17. e Bellarmin . de Scriptor . Eccles . f Rog. Wid●ingt . de Jaram . Fidelitatis , c. x. p. 402. g Dr. Stillingfleet of Miracles . Author of the Reflections on the Romish Devotions . h Jo. de Turrecrem ▪ de Eccl. l. 2. c. 101. i Baron . Annal. T. 2. An. 102. §. 6 , 7. Jo. Driedo de dogm . & Scrip. Ecc. l. 1. c. 2. k Cusanus de Concord . Cathol . l. 2. c. 34. Cl. Espencaeus de contin . l. 1. c. 2. Bellarm. de Rom. Pontif. l. 2. c. 14. l Hincm . Rhem. lib. Contr. Hincm . Laudunens . m Baron . Annal. T. 9. An. 865. §. 5 , 6 , 7. n Adrian . Ep. ad Constant . & Iren. Act. Concil . Nicen. 2. An. 794. Leo. 9. Epist . ad Michael . Const . An. 1054. o Not. in Edict . Constant . Concil . Tom. 1. p. 154. p Leo. Pap. Epist . ad Theodof . Concil . Tom. 2. q Exempli gr . Tres Canon . Concil . 1. Constantinop . Omnes ▪ Can. Concil . Ephes . Oecum . 3. Canon . 28. Concil . Chalcedon . Oecum . 4. r Roman Forgeries print . Lond. 1673. s Angulos , legunt . Merlin . Tom. 1. Concil . Edit . An. 1530 Colon. Crabbe p. 226. ed. A. 1538. Colon. Carranza sum . Concil . pag. 82. Lugd. 1568. t ap . Zonar . Balsam . & Harmenopulum . u Theodor. in Colos . 3. Photius . Nomo-Canon . Tit. 12. c. 9. w Dionys . Exig . Cod. Can. n. 138. Crescon . breviar . Can. §. 90. Fulgent . Ferrand . Bre● . Can. §. 184. x Cyprian . Ep. 40. Edit . Gryphii . p. 52. Morellii 124. y Editio Pamel . Ep. 40. p. 7. z Ludov. Vives Comment . in Aug. de Civ . Dei , l. 21. c. 24. a Fulbertus Carnot . edit . An. 1608. pag. 168. b Baron . Annal . Tom. x. an . 869. c Aimonius de Gestis Franc. l. 5. c. 8. d Epistol . Nuncup . ante Bibliothecam Sixti Senens . e Censores Belg. de libro Bertrami . f Junii Prae● . ad Indicem Expurg . Cens . Belg. g Blondel Epist . ante librum de Joan. Papis c. 3. h Henr. Boxhorn . de Eucharistiâ l. 3. initio . i bArno . advers . Gent. lib. 1. k Aug. de verb. Apost . Ser. 32. l Ambros . de Offic. l. 2. c. 8. m Lactant. Instit . lib. 6. c. 19. n Arrianus in Epictet . lib. 2. cap. 15. o Lactant. Instit . lib , 2. cap. 2. p Irenaeus adv . haeres . l. 1. c. 24. q Concil . Eliber . can . 36. Origen in Cels . lib. 7. Tertul. Apol. c. 30. r Cornel. Agrip. de Vanit . Scien . cap. 57. Bern. de Annun . serm . 1. p. 123. Durand . in Sent. lib. 2. dist . 8. qu. 1. s August . de Verb. Apos , Ser. 15. Walden de Sacr. Rit . Tom. 3. Tit. 1. cap. 7. t Bellarm. de Purgat . l. 1. c. 14. u Sand. Europae Spec. pag. 5 , 6 , 7. w Gratian. caus . 13. qu. 2. c. 19. 2 Decret . Gloss . Interlin . in Isa . 63. x Job xiv . 21 , 22. Eccles . ix . 5. Isa . lxiii . 13. y Lib. Conform . fol. 1149. z Jer. vii . 18. ubi videtur esse nomen Junonis olympiae . a Missal . Polon . fol. 237. b Epiphan . adv . collyridianos Panar . haer . 79. c Pighius Hierarch . lib. 3. Canus lib. 3. c. 2. d 2 Maccab. xiv . 42. Turrian . in Sadeel , pag. 99. e Eccles . xivi . 20. 2 Esdras vi . 40. f Concil . Trident . Sess . 4. g Adorari solius Dei est : Del●atur ex Ind. operum Athanasii . Indice libr. prohib . & Expurg . p. 52. Madrit . Anno 1627. item ex Ind. Op. S. Aug. bd . p. 56. h Porphyr . de Abstin . lib. 1. §. 41. i Clem. Alex. Stromat . 1. k Europ . Spec ▪ pag. 10. l Cajet . com . in 1. Corinth . 14. 17. m Lyr. in Loc. n Rhem. Test . Annot. on 1 Cor. 14. o Gab. Biel in Can. Miss . Lect. 62. p Porphyr . ap . Euseb . Praepar . Evang . lib. 3. q Suarez . de Orat. lib. 3. cap. 14. & Salmeron . r An. Dom. 1090. s Polyd. Virgil. de invent . rer . l. 5. c. 9. t Selden de Diis Syris , pag. 52. Saubertus de Sacrific . cap. 13. pag. 296. u Aug. de Civ . Dei , lib. 8. c. 17. w Arnob. adv . Gentes , lib. 7. pag. 216. x Senec. Ep. 97. y Basil . reg . brev . qu. 15. z Mich. vi . 7. a Augustin . homil . 2. ex 50. hom . b Tertul. de Praescrip . adv . haret . c. 41. c Augustin . Epist . 80. d Idem de Verb. Apost . Ser. 21. e Salvian . ad Eccles . Cath. lib. 3. f Gloss . Ordin . ad Colos . 2. g Euseb . Pap. Decret . Ep. 3. h Capitol . Carol . & Lud. l. 5. c. 163. i Legibus Hydens . ap . Spelm. Tom. 1. pag. 440. k Aug. de verb. Dom. Serm. 13. l Nazianz. Test . de Vet. Testam . m Cyril . de Trin. lib. 4. n Chrysost . hom . 55. in Matth. o Ambros . Com. in Ephes . 2. p Hilar. de Trin. lib. 2. cap. 6. Ambros . in Esal . 38. q Aug ▪ in Johan . Tract . 118. Origen . in Matt. Tract . 1. Hilarius de Trinit . l. 6. Hieron . in Jovin ▪ lib. 1. r Cypr. de Unit . Eccles . s Euseb . Eccles . hist . l. 2. c. 1. t Acts xv . 13. u Decret . Epist . Clement . 1. in Titul . Epist . w Concil . Constant . I. Ep. ad Dam. * Aene. Sylv. Ep. 288. x Euseb . Eccles . hist . l. 5. c. 24. y Cyprian ad Pompei . Ep. 74. z Cusan . de Concor . Cath. lib. 3. c. 6. a Concil . Chal. Can. 28. An. 451. b Gregor . Epist . lib. 7. Ep. 30. c Athanas . Ep. ad Epictet . d Gregor . Epist . lib. 2. ad Maurit . Epist . 32 , 36 , 38. e Gregor . Epist . lib. 7. Ep. 30. f Idem lib. 7. Epist . 36. g Beda de 6. aetat . Mundi . h Paul. Diacon . rer . Rom. lib. 18. Histor . Longob . lib. 4. c. 11. Anastas . Bibl. Vit. Bonif. Tertii , Ado aetat . Sext. Reg. Chron. l. 1. Aimon . de gest . Franc. l. 4. c. 4. i Firmilianus ad Cypr. Ep. 75. k Concil . 6. Carthag . An. 419. l Glaber Rodulph . hist . lib. 2. c. 4. m Vita Ludov. Pii à P. Pithaeo edit . An. 863. Annal. Franc. d P. Pithaeo eod . An. n Photius Constant . Ep. Encycl . ap . Baron An. 863. §. 42. o Constit . Imper. à Godalsto Tom. 1. pag. 24 , 25. Luitprand . Ticin . histor . lib. 6. cap. 9 , & 10. p Bochellus l. 5. de Decret . Eccles . Gallic . tit . 20. Pithaeus de lib. Eccles . Gallican , c. 3. § , 3. n. 13. q LL. Basilic . l. 10. tit . 1. & Balsamon not . in Concil . Ancyran . p. 378. r Sabellic . Enn. 7. lib. 5. s Tertul. adv . Jud. c. 7. Theodoret. de Cur. Graec. aff . Ser. 9. t Can. 6. Concil . Nicaen . juxt . Dionys . Exig . u Histor . Ecclese . lib. 1. c. 6. w Concil . Ephes . Can. 8. x Ge●●● Monm . de Aug. vers . fin . y Gyrald . Camb. It in . l. 2. c. 1. z Hoved. Annal part . 1. p. 405. Matth. Westm . An. 793. a Onuphri●s in Vit. Greg. 7. b Baron . Annal . An. 1076. §. 25. c Matth. Paris . An. 1107. d Record . An. tertio Hen. 2. e Matth. Paris . An. 1164. f Stat. 16. Ric. 2 di Statute Book pag. 238. g Tho. of Walsing . An. 1312. pag. 74. num . 20. h Tho. Walsing . An. 1408. p. 420. i Vitâ Henr. Chicely , p. 56 , & 57. * An. 26. Hen. 8. k Annal. Tom. 3. An. 312. l Imperial . Const . Novel ▪ II. & Nov. 131. c. 3. m Rescript . Valent . 31 An. 432. n Socrat. hist . Prooem . ad lib. 5. o Anastas . Pap. Epist ad Anastas . Imp. ap . Binium T. 2. par . 1. p. 507. p Concil . 1. Mogun . An. 813. & Concil . II. Mogun . An. 847. ap . Bin. T. 3. p. 1. Sect. 2. q Claud. Fau●●et en les Libertes de l'Eglis . Gallican . p. 234. r Epist . Eleuth . ad R. Lucium ap . Spelm● ▪ s Leg. Hydens . cap. 8. Spelm● Tom. ● . p. 438. t Ingulph . hist. p. 902. u Eadmer . histor . p. 6. w Stat. 16 Ric. 2. c. 5. x Stat. 25 Ed. 3. de Provisor . Stat. 27 , 28 Ed. 3. cap. 1 , 2. Stat. 28 Ed. 3. cap. 3. Stat. 2 Hen. 4. cap. 3. Stat. 6 Henr. 4. cap. 1. Stat. 7 Henr. 4. cap. 6. Stat. 3 Henr. 5. cap 4. y Coke 5. Rep. Cawdry's Case , fol. 8. z Spelm. Concil . T. 2. p. 58. b Rex ad Anselm . ap Eadmerum pag. 62. c Leon. Epist . ad Lothar . & Lud. Aug. ap . Grat. dist . 10. c. 9. d Gregor . Epist . lib. 2. ad Maurit . Ep. 62. e Concil . Vienn . sub Clem. 5. f Papyr . Masson . Vit. Bonis . 8. g Tilius Episs . Meld . Chronic. de Reg. Fran. An. 1302. h Matth. Paris . ad An. 1253. i Gloss . in Decret . dist . 40. cap. 6. St ▪ Papa . Suarez . defens . Fidei , & lib. contr . Regem Magn. Brittan . k Mariana , lib. de Rege . l Answer to Philanax Anglicus , 125. l See the Answer to Philanax Angl. chap. 4. p. 72. m Bern. ad Eugen . Pap. de consid . l. 2. n Matth. Paris . An. 1253. o ap . Binium Concil . Tom. 3. p 2. sol . 729. &c. p Concil . Pisanum An. 1411. q Concil . Pisan . Sess . 16. r Et Sess . 20. ap . Binium Tom. 3. p. 2. p. 836. s Arnob. adv . gentes , l. 6. p. 197. t Concil . Tolet. 3. An. 589. u Edgar Ap. Ailred . Col. 361. w Malmsbury de Pontif. L. 1. de Anselmo . x Eadmer . Cant. pag. 113. y Duaren . de benef . lib. 1. c. 9. z Mason de Ministerio Anglicano . a Ambros . lib. de Sacram. Aug. Doctrin . Christ . l. 3. c. 9. Paschusius de Caen. Dom. Bessarion . de Sacram . Euchar.